Detection of LUAD-Associated Genes Using Wasserstein Distance in Multi-Omics Feature Selection
Shaofei Zhao, Siming Huang, Kexuan Li, Weiyu Zhou, Lingli Yang, Shige Wang · 2024
Read Detection of LUAD-Associated Genes Using Wasserstein Distance in Multi-Omics Feature Selection by Shaofei Zhao, Siming Huang, Kexuan Li, Weiyu Zhou, Lingli Yang, Shige Wang (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01773.txt.
Description
Abstract Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) is characterized by substantial genetic heterogeneity, posing challenges in identifying reliable biomarkers for improved diagnosis and treatment. Tumor Mutational Burden (TMB) has traditionally been regarded as a predictive biomarker, given its association with immune response and treatment efficacy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shaofei Zhao, Siming Huang, Kexuan Li, Weiyu Zhou, Lingli Yang, Shige Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01773
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Detection of LUAD-Associated Genes Using Wasserstein Distance in Multi-Omics Feature Selection Shaofei Zhao, Siming Huang, Kexuan Li, Weiyu Zhou, Lingli Yang, Shige Wang Abstract Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) is characterized by substantial genetic heterogeneity, posing challenges in identifying reliable biomarkers for improved diagnosis and treatment. Tumor Mutational Burden (TMB) has traditionally been regarded as a predictive biomarker, given its association with immune response and treatment efficacy. In this study, we treated TMB as a response variable to identify genes highly correlated with it, aiming to understand its genetic drivers. We conducted a thorough investigation of recent feature selection methods through extensive simulations, selecting PC-Screen, DC-SIS, and WD-Screen as top performers. These methods handle multi-omics structures effectively, and can accommodate both categorical and continuous data types at the same time for each gene. Using data from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) via cBioPortal, we combined copy number alteration (CNA), mRNA expression and DNA methylation data as multi-omics predictors and applied these methods, selecting genes consistently identified across all three methods. 13 common genes were identified, including HSD17B4, PCBD2 , which show strong associations with TMB. Our multi-omics strategy and robust feature selection approach provide insights into the genetic determinants of TMB, with implications for targeted LUAD therapies. Introduction Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD), a predominant subtype of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), accounts for nearly 40% of all lung cancer cases worldwide, making it a critical focus in oncology research. According to the Global Cancer Observatory (GLOBOCAN), lung cancer remains the leading cause of cancer-related deaths, with over 2 million new cases and approximately 1.8 million deaths reported annually [ 6 ] , and LUAD comprises the majority of these cases. The prognosis for LUAD patients remains poor, with a five-year survival rate below 20%, particularly due to late-stage diagnoses when treatment options are limited. Recent advancements in multi-omics technologies have provided a deeper understanding of the molecular landscape of LUAD, and several studies have focused on multi-omics approaches and machine learning techniques to extract highly related genes. For example, using feature selection frameworks with mutual information and random forest, the researchers found a consensus set of twelve genes with significant diagnostic potential, which could differentiate LUAD from normal samples with high accuracy [ 1 ] .However, despite these advancements, high genetic and molecular heterogeneity in LUAD continues to limit the applicability of existing biomarkers for early and personalized diagnostics. The analysis of multi-omics data presents significant challenges due to its high dimensionality, with tens of thousands of genes but only a few hundred subjects, and the integration of multiple data platforms. This structure introduces a high degree of noise, and creates an array-like predictor structure, where for n subjects, the predictors not only has the regular high dimensionality p but also additional dimension d associated with d different platforms. This complexity makes traditional analysis methods ineffective and sometimes even incapable of handling predictors with such multi-layer structure. As a result, effective feature selection is crucial for detecting signals in this noisy environment. Feature selection, or feature screening has long been a hot topic in statistical and machine learning research, particularly due to its critical role in managing high-dimensional and complex data. Fan and Lv’s introduction of Sure Independent Screening (SIS) was a pivotal development, demonstrating that SIS could reliably identify all true predictors in sufficiently large samples, hence the term "sure" screening [ 4 ] . Their work inspired further advancements in sure screening, with methods like Distance Correlation based Sure Independence Screening (DC-SIS) [ 9 ] , Projection based Sure Independence Screening (PC-Screen) [ 10 ] , Stable Correlation Screening (SC-SIS) [ 5 ] , and Multivariate Rank Distance Correlation based Sure Independence Screening (MrDc-SIS) [ 13 ] . For a comprehensive review and comparison of these robust screening techniques, Zhao and Fu [ 13 ] offers detailed insights. Recently, Zhao et al. [ 14 ] utilized a model-free and distribution-free screening method, MrDcGene, on the TCGA-LUAD dataset. This method effectively confirmed known biomarkers and identified new gene candidates associated with LUAD, showcasing the potential of advanced sure screening methods in handling the intrinsic complexity of multi-omics data. Building on recent advancements in dependence measures, we noted a new approach using the Wasserstein distance as a dependence metric, as introduced in the work by Mordant and Segers [ 11 ] . The Wasserstein distance offers several advantages. First, it remains stable under transformations like rotation and monotonic changes, making it robust in noisy, high-dimensional data. Second, unlike some traditional measures, it does not rely on assumptions about linearity or Gaussian distributions, which allows it to work effectively in model-free, distribution-free settings, making it a versatile choice for complex, mulit-omics data. Finally, Wasserstein distance measures dependence by minimizing the “transport cost” between distributions, grounded in optimal transport theory, providing a reliable and theoretically sound way to measure associations. These properties make the Wasserstein distance particularly well-suited for high-dimensional, multi-omics datasets like the TCGA-LUAD, where both complexity and noise are prevalent. In this paper, we aim to thoroughly test and compare the performance of the Wasserstein distance against other feature selection methods through extensive simulation studies. Following these simulations, we will apply the Wasserstein distance-based approach to the real TCGA-LUAD dataset, which we downloaded through cBioPortal [ 3 ] , to evaluate its effectiveness in identifying meaningful gene associations for LUAD. Results Up to three levels of subheading are permitted. Subheadings should not be numbered. Comparative Analysis of Feature Selection Methods: Simulation Studies In our comparison, we evaluate ten popular feature selection methods, including our Wasserstein distance-based screening (WD-Screen). The other methods are as follows, for details, please refer to Zhao and Fu [ 13 ] • Sure Independence Screening (SIS) [ 4 ] – uses Pearson correlation as the dependence measure between each predictor and response variable. • Sure Independence Ranking and Screening (SIRS) [ 16 ] – uses Pearson correlation between each predictor and the rank of response variable. • Robust Rank Correlation Screening (RRCS) [ 7 ] – uses Kendall’s \tau as the dependence measure between each predictor and the response variable. • Distance Correlation based Sure Independence Screening (DC-SIS) [ 9 ] – uses distance correlation as the dependence measure between each predictor and the response variable. • Robust Distance Correlation Screening (DC-RoSIS) [ 15 ] – uses distance correlation between each predictor and the rank of response variable. • Multivariate Rank based Distance Correlation Screening (MrDc-SIS) [ 13 ] – uses distance correlation between the multivariate rank of predictors and response variables. • Stable Correlation based Screening (SC-SIS) [ 5 ] – uses a different weight function in the distance correlation as the dependence measure between each predictor and response variable. • Projection Correlation based Screening (PC-Screen) [ 10 ] – uses projection correlation as the dependence measure between each predictor and response variable. • Ball correlation based Screening (BCor-SIS) [ 12 ] – uses ball correlation as the dependence measure between each predictor and response variable. Study 1: Benchmarking and Validation of Feature Selection Methods To establish a benchmark, allow comparison with prior studies, and verify the correctness of our implementation for each method, we replicate a similar simulation setup as used in previous papers [ 4 ,