The role of intermediate Δ Δ \Delta\Delta states in nucleon-nucleon scattering in the large- N c N_{c} and unitary limits, and Δ Δ \Delta\Delta and Ω Ω \Omega\Omega scattering
Thomas R. Richardson, Matthias R. Schindler, Roxanne P. Springer · 2024
Read The role of intermediate Δ Δ \Delta\Delta states in nucleon-nucleon scattering in the large- N c N_{c} and unitary limits, and Δ Δ \Delta\Delta and Ω Ω \Omega\Omega scattering by Thomas R. Richardson, Matthias R. Schindler, Roxanne P. Springer (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01715.txt.
Description
Abstract We explore potential explanations for why using large- N c N_{c} ( N c N_{c} is the number of colors) scaling to determine the relative size of few-nucleon low-energy operators agrees with experiment even when dynamical Δ \Delta ’s are not explicitly included.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas R. Richardson, Matthias R. Schindler, Roxanne P. Springer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01715
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The role of intermediate Δ Δ \Delta\Delta states in nucleon-nucleon scattering in the large- N c N_{c} and unitary limits, and Δ Δ \Delta\Delta and Ω Ω \Omega\Omega scattering Thomas R. Richardson, Matthias R. Schindler, Roxanne P. Springer Abstract We explore potential explanations for why using large- N c N_{c} ( N c N_{c} is the number of colors) scaling to determine the relative size of few-nucleon low-energy operators agrees with experiment even when dynamical Δ \Delta ’s are not explicitly included. Given that the large- N c N_{c} analysis is predicated on the nucleons and Δ \Delta ’s being degenerate, this is a curious result. We show that for purely S S -wave interactions the relationships dictated by large- N c N_{c} scaling are unaffected whether the Δ \Delta is included or not. In the case of higher partial waves that do not mix with S S -waves, the impact of the Δ \Delta is perturbative, which makes the agreement with naive ( Δ \Delta -less) large- N c N_{c} ordering unsurprising. For higher partial waves that mix with S S -waves, the nucleon and Δ \Delta would need to decouple to get agreement with naive large- N c N_{c} ordering. We find all N N N\!N , Δ N \Delta N , and Δ Δ \Delta\Delta low energy coefficients for leading-order baryon-baryon scattering in Δ \Delta -full pionless effective field theory in terms of the two independent parameters dictated by the SU( 2 F 2F ) spin-flavor symmetry that arises in the N c N_{c} → ∞ \rightarrow\infty limit. Because of recent lattice QCD results and experimental interest, we extend our analysis to the three-flavor case to study Ω Ω \Omega\Omega scattering. We show that in the unitary limit (where scattering lengths become infinite) one of the two SU( 2 F 2F ) parameters is driven to zero, resulting in enhanced symmetries, which agree with those found in spin-1/2 entanglement studies. I Introduction One way to connect interactions between nucleons to the underlying theory of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) is to use effective field theories (EFTs). The EFTs are often cast as expansions in small quantities, such as low momenta and, if pions are included as degrees of freedom, the light quark masses, divided by the breakdown scale of the EFT. The utility of the EFTs can be augmented by considering the consequences of the limiting cases of approximate symmetries of nature. Such an approximate symmetry emerges for the baryon spectrum in the large- N_{c} limit of QCD [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , providing another approach to capture additional nonperturbative aspects of the strong interactions. When combined with EFTs, the large- N_{c} analysis can establish relationships among the low-energy coefficients (LECs) of the EFT. For example, the large- N_{c} expansion has been applied to the meson and single-baryon sectors of chiral perturbation theory (see, e.g., Refs. [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] ). Baryon-baryon scattering in the large- N_{c} limit was first considered in Ref. [ 16 ] , in which the momentum was assumed to scale linearly with N_{c} . The leading-in- N_{c} interaction is O(N_{c}) , and with the momentum scaling of Ref. [ 16 ] the kinetic and potential energies are of the same order in the large- N_{c} expansion. In the following we focus on low-momentum scattering, and we assume that momenta are independent of N_{c} . This scaling follows that chosen by Refs. [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] . In particular, Refs. [ 17 , 18 ] argue that despite the lack of a smooth large- N_{c} limit for the scattering amplitude, the SU(4) symmetry emerging in the baryon sector with this momentum scaling provides relevant constraints on the relative sizes of different spin-isospin contributions to the nucleon-nucleon ( N\!N ) interactions. The analysis is performed by considering two-nucleon matrix elements of the Hamiltonian, which in the large- N_{c} limit can be expressed in terms of bilinears of quark fields that encode the spin and isospin content [ 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . The resulting 1/ N_{c} hierarchy of the different spin, isospin, and momentum structures is mapped onto phenomenological models or effective field theories (EFTs) of the N\!N interactions, indicating the relative sizes of the model/EFT parameters that are to be fit to data [ 18 ] . The LECs are typically subtraction point dependent; they are not observables. Nevertheless, at specific subtraction points, LECs can be extracted from data where available. N\!N scattering serves as an important test case of establishing the usefulness of the large- N_{c} limit for understanding baryon-baryon interactions. However, the main utility of the large- N_{c} analysis lies with those cases for which not enough data is available to sufficiently constrain LECs, e.g., symmetry-violating interactions or the coupling to external fields. For a recent review see Ref. [ 24 ] . The delta resonances ( \Delta ’s) might be expected to play a critical role when considering how nucleons ( N ’s) behave in the large- N_{c} limit of QCD. In particular, the inclusion of the \Delta ’s is crucial to obtaining a consistent picture of pion-nucleon scattering [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . As N_{c} \rightarrow\infty , the baryon spectrum not only exhibits an SU(2 F ) spin-flavor symmetry, where F is the number of flavors, but deviations from this symmetry can be calculated systematically in a perturbative 1/ N_{c} expansion [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 25 , 26 , 20 , 21 ] . Restricting the discussion to two flavors, the N ’s and \Delta ’s transform in the same SU(4) multiplet and have degenerate masses, together with a whole tower of states with higher spin and isospin that do not have equivalents in the physical world where N_{c}=3 . This SU(4) symmetry in the baryon sector has been used to derive the large- N_{c} scaling of matrix elements of single-nucleon states; see, e.g., Refs. [ 16 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] for reviews. The scalings of these matrix elements also form the basis of the large- N_{c} analysis in the N\!N sector. However, while the large- N_{c} analysis (happening at the quark level) implicitly includes the \Delta , many of the phenomenological models and EFTs do not include \Delta ’s as active/explicit degrees of freedom; instead their effects are subsumed into the parameters of the model or EFT. That this mismatch of active degrees of freedom might be problematic has been pointed out in Ref. [ 18 ] . Further, Ref. [ 19 ] analyzed the N\!N potential in a meson-exchange picture and showed that again the \Delta degrees of freedom are important for a consistent analysis within this framework. It is therefore possibly surprising that no disagreement between the large- N_{c} expectations and the relative sizes of the model/EFT parameters dictated by data has been found in the two-nucleon sector. If the \Delta is important for theoretical consistency, why do the large- N_{c} expectations appear to hold in two-nucleon