Is bouncing easier with a negative effective dark fluid density ?

Stéphane Fay · 2024

Read Is bouncing easier with a negative effective dark fluid density ? by Stéphane Fay (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01524.txt.

Description

A 2024 arXiv research paper by Stéphane Fay. Assuming that a cosmological model can describe the whole Universe history, we look for the conditions of a cosmological bounce that thus have to be in agreement with late time observations. Our approach involves casting such a theory into General Relativity with curvature ( Ω κ \Omega_{\kappa} ), matter ( Ω m \Omega_{m} ), radiation ( Ω r \Omega_{r} ) and an effective dark fluid ( Ω d \Omega_{d} ) and formulating the corresponding field equations as a 2D dynamical system, wherein

Catalog record

CREATORStéphane Fay
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01524

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Is bouncing easier with a negative effective dark fluid density ? Stéphane Fay Abstract Assuming that a cosmological model can describe the whole Universe history, we look for the conditions of a cosmological bounce that thus have to be in agreement with late time observations. Our approach involves casting such a theory into General Relativity with curvature ( Ω κ \Omega_{\kappa} ), matter ( Ω m \Omega_{m} ), radiation ( Ω r \Omega_{r} ) and an effective dark fluid ( Ω d \Omega_{d} ) and formulating the corresponding field equations as a 2D dynamical system, wherein phase space points corresponding to extrema of the metric function are constrained by observational data on the aforementioned parameters densities. We show that if this effective dark fluid density is positive at the bounce, these observational constraints imply its occurrence in the future at a redshift z < − 0.81 z<-0.81 whatever the cosmological model (dark energy, brane, f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) , etc.) corresponding to this effective dark fluid and even in the presence of positive curvature. Hence, the effective dark fluid density must be negative at the bounce such as it arises for z > − 0.81 z>-0.81 and thus possibly in the past. Observations also impose that the dark fluid effective density can change sign only within the redshift range 0.54 < z < 0.61 0.54<z<0.61 . We then proceed by examining three distinct cosmological models: a non linear dark fluid model, a Randall Sundrum brane model and a f ⁡ ( R ) = R + m ​ R n + Λ f(R)=R+mR^{n}+\Lambda model. For each of them, we examine the conditions for (1) a bounce at early time (when radiation dominates over matter), (2) with a negative effective dark fluid energy density, (3) this having to change sign within the above specified redshift interval (to be positive at present time). We find that none of the three models under consideration satisfy all three constraints. We therefore conclude that while a negative effective dark fluid energy density required by observational constraints on Ω m \Omega_{m} , Ω r \Omega_{r} and Ω k \Omega_{k} for a bounce at early times facilitates this bounce, the requirement for Ω d \Omega_{d} to change sign and become positive within the above specified narrow redshift interval proves exceedingly challenging to satisfy these same constraints. pacs 95.30.Sf, 98.80.Jk, 95.36.+x I Introduction In this paper, we investigate how a classical cosmological bounce can be constrained by late time observations and how it is difficult for it to satisfy them. A cosmological bounce is a way to circumvent a singularity. With an ekpyrotic scenario, it can also produce effects similar to inflation [ 1 , 2 ] such as smoothing out the cosmological background [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Two types of bounce can be distinguished: a quantum one [ 8 , 9 ] or a classical one [ 10 ] . Loop Quantum Cosmology [ 11 , 12 ] is the most successful quantum bounce in which the singularity is resolved in a generic way [ 13 ] . It predicts a quantum bridge between contracting and expanding Universe. In the classical scenario, after contracting to a finite size larger than the Planck length, the Universe undergoes a bounce and begins expanding. This is generally challenging since such bounce has to violate the null energy condition, leading to instability and ghost that can nerveless be avoided [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] . In this paper, we focus on a classical bounce and consider a cosmological model that includes matter, radiation, (effective or not) dark fluid and curvature, encompassing the whole Universe history from early to late times [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] . We show then how late time observations imply that the effective dark fluid density must be negative during the bounce and change sign within a narrow redshift interval. By examining several cosmological models (a non linear dark fluid model, a Randall Sundrum brane model and a f(R)=R+mR^{n}+\Lambda model) for which we calculate the corresponding effective dark fluid equation of state w , we show how it is challenging to achieve such a bounce consistent with current observations of parameters density. Let us note that curvature is often neglected whereas it provides insights into various early Universe scenarios: emergence from a false vacuum [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , multiverse [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] or initial conditions [ 26 ] . Methods for detecting curvature have been developed [ 27 , 28 ] but observational evidence is still pending [ 29 , 30 , 31 ] while some theories suggest that it should be either flat or closed [ 32 , 33 ] . Studying a bouncing Universe benefits from employing mathematical tools that provide insight into the general properties of an equation system, such as extrema of the metric function, without necessarily solving it. Dynamical system analysis [ 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 ] serves as an effective approach for this purpose. By reformulating the field equations into a dynamical system represented by trajectories in a phase space, we transform the task of studying a system of differential equations into one of investigating the geometric properties of this phase space. However, each gravitation theory needs some specific variables to be rewritten as a dynamical system whereas they can generally be cast into General Relativity with an effective dark fluid by rearranging the terms in the field equations (i.e. without a conformal transformation of the metric) leaving unchanged the scale factor evolution and thus the existence of a bounce. Hence, as a mathematical tool, we will define a phase space for General Relativity with matter, radiation, an effective dark fluid and curvature. Then we will use this tool to study bouncing cosmology for any theories, from General Relativity to f(R) theories, defining their corresponding effective dark fluid. Finding some variables describing such a phase space in presence of curvature is a difficult task (see [ 36 , 40 , 41 ] for instance). We manage to use only two normalised variables related to the matter and radiation densities. The dynamical system thus consists in a set of only two differential equations, whereby the trajectories in phase space depend on the effective dark fluid equation of state w and a constant p From this phase space we get the following results. First, observations [ 42 ] constrain 0<p<0.27\times 10^{-4} . This inequality determines the phase space points where extrema of the metric function occur and thus a bounce when also specifying w . Furthermore, it also allows to derive that a positive effective dark fluid density at the bounce invariably entails its occurrence in the future at a redshift z<-0.81 , whatever the cosmological model describing the whole Universe history. Hence, a negative effective dark fluid density is necessary for a bounce in the past that agrees with the present day observations, even in the presence of a positively curved Universe. Moreover, observations pinpoint the redshift range within which the effective dark fluid density undergoes a sign change, namely 0.54<z<0.81 , this

Read the complete text