The psychology of prizes: Loss aversion and optimal tournament rewards
Dmitry Ryvkin, Qin Wu · 2024
Read The psychology of prizes: Loss aversion and optimal tournament rewards by Dmitry Ryvkin, Qin Wu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01068.txt.
Description
Abstract We study the optimal allocation of prizes in rank-order tournaments with loss averse agents. Prize sharing becomes increasingly optimal with loss aversion because more equitable prizes reduce the marginal psychological cost of anticipated losses. Furthermore, loss aversion can boost effort if prizes are sufficiently equitable, but otherwise effort declines with loss aversion.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dmitry Ryvkin, Qin Wu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01068
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The psychology of prizes: Loss aversion and optimal tournament rewards Dmitry Ryvkin, Qin Wu Abstract We study the optimal allocation of prizes in rank-order tournaments with loss averse agents. Prize sharing becomes increasingly optimal with loss aversion because more equitable prizes reduce the marginal psychological cost of anticipated losses. Furthermore, loss aversion can boost effort if prizes are sufficiently equitable, but otherwise effort declines with loss aversion. Overall, these results give credence to more equitable allocations of competitive rewards. A win-win scenario is where optimal prizes are equitable even under loss neutrality, in which case the principal benefits from agents’ loss aversion. K eywords: tournament, loss aversion, optimal prizes J EL codes: C72, D72, D82 1 Introduction In this paper, we study the optimal allocation of competitive prizes, such as rank-based bonuses, in a setting where agents are loss averse . That is, in addition to standard monetary payoffs, agents derive psychological utility from anticipated gains and losses relative to an expectations-based reference point ( Kőszegi and Rabin 2006 ) , where the marginal impact of losses is stronger relative to gains. We use a rank-order tournament model similar to Lazear and Rosen 1981 , with stochastic performance affected by costly effort as well as idiosyncratic additive noise, where a principal allocates a fixed budget to rank-dependent prizes. We study the impact of loss aversion on the agents’ effort and on the optimal (effort-maximizing) prize schedule. Rank-based rewards are common in organizations and other settings. For example, end-of-year bonuses or salary raises are typically based on performance rankings, with managers allocating a fixed budget to these incentives. Therefore, one of the central questions organizations face is that of optimal prize allocation : How should these rank-based rewards be structured to maximize workers’ performance? This question has been addressed in the literature using various models of rank-based rewards, referred to as contests or tournaments, where agents have standard preferences. It is well-known, however, that most individuals’ preferences exhibit reference dependence and loss aversion ( Kahneman and Tversky 1979 ) , whereby outcomes are evaluated as gains or losses relative to a reference point, and the marginal disutility of a loss exceeds the marginal utility of a gain by a factor \lambda>1 referred to as the loss aversion coefficient . According to a recent meta-analysis by Brown et al. 2024 , the average value of \lambda across more than a hundred experimental studies is close to 2, indicating substantial loss aversion in the population. The impact of loss aversion on performance has been studied in various domains. In sports, loss aversion forces individuals and team managers to use safer, and ultimately suboptimal, strategies when they are ahead ( Pope and Schweitzer 2011 ; Pedace and Smith 2013 ) . Similarly, in education, loss-averse students tend to perform worse on multiple-choice exams where unanswered questions receive partial credit, as they avoid guessing to secure guaranteed points ( Karle, Engelmann and Peitz 2022 ) . Managerial loss aversion has been linked to inferior investment decisions ( Odean 1998 ; Fellner and Sutter 2009 ) , suboptimal operational decisions ( Schweitzer and Cachon 2000 ; Wang, Webster and Suresh 2009 ) , and even an increased incidence of illegal behavior ( Mishina et al. 2010 ) . Thus, it is generally believed that loss aversion is detrimental to performance, and individuals need to be “debiased,” i.e., trained to be less loss averse, to realize their full potential ( Hueber and Schwaiger 2022 ) . At the same time, it has been demonstrated how loss aversion can be harnessed to generate extra incentives for effort provision. In a field experiment with factory workers, Hossain and List 2012 find that framing compensation as a punishment leads to higher effort than when it is framed as a reward. Fryer et al. 2012 report similar results for the impact of teacher bonuses on student achievement; and Abeler et al. 2011 show that by manipulating reference points (expectations of earnings) it is possible to make individuals work longer. These findings suggest that the impact of loss aversion depends on the incentive scheme, and performance can be improved, or at least the negative impact of loss aversion reduced, if incentives are properly adjusted. For example, Marchegiani, Reggiani and Rizzolli 2016 show that it helps for managers to be lenient when workers are loss averse; and Dodonova and Khoroshilov 2006 show that compensation packages with a large share of stock options are optimal for loss averse managers. In this paper, we further contribute to understanding how loss aversion interacts with incentives, and how it can be harnessed to improve performance. In a tournament setting, agents exert effort, and outcomes are realized in the form of prizes. Following Kőszegi and Rabin 2006 ; Kőszegi and Rabin 2007 , we posit that any given prize is evaluated relative to a stochastic reference point represented by all alternative outcomes, i.e., all other possible prizes the agent could receive. This reference point is endogenous, in the sense that the probabilities of alternative prizes are influenced by the agent’s effort decision as well as the efforts of other agents. We adopt the choice-acclimating personal equilibrium solution concept, whereby agents correctly anticipate how their efforts will affect those probabilities. We have two major results. First, the equilibrium effort can decrease or increase with loss aversion, depending on the allocation of prizes. Specifically, for any distribution of noise, effort decreases with loss aversion when fewer than half of all agents receive a positive prize; and increases with loss aversion when more than half of all agents receive the same top prize. For more general prize allocations, the results are more nuanced and depend also on the details of the noise distribution. Second, for any distribution of noise, the optimal allocation of prizes becomes (weakly) more equitable as loss aversion rises. We know from the existing literature that the exact configuration of optimal prizes in rank-order tournaments (without loss aversion) is determined by the distribution of noise. Specifically, optimal prizes tend to be more equitable for noise distributions with heavier tails ( Drugov and Ryvkin 2020 ) . While those forces continue to operate also in the presence of loss aversion, the latter provides an additional mechanism for the optimality of prize sharing. Combining the two results, we find that for distributions of noise such that relatively unequal prizes are optimal for loss neutral agents, the equilibrium effort can be nonmonotone (specifically, U-shaped) in loss aversion if prizes are adjusted optimally. The reason is that for relatively low loss aversion the optimal number of positive prizes is small and effort declines, whereas for sufficiently high loss aversion the optimal number of equal prizes at the top becomes large enough and effort then rises. For intuition, recall that each prize is evaluated relative to all other prizes which can be received with the corresponding probabilities; therefore, the contribution of each prize v_{r} awarded for rank r to the gain-loss utility is a linear combination of differences v_{r}-v_{s} , for all s\neq r , with weights equal to the product of probabilities of receiving v_{r} and v_{s} . In the symmetric equilibrium, all these probabilities are equal, but, due to loss aversion,