Fabry–Pérot open resonant cavities for measuring the dielectric parameters of mm-wave optical materials
Brodi D. Elwood, Paul K. Grimes, John Kovac, Miranda Eiben, Grant Meiners · 2024
Read Fabry–Pérot open resonant cavities for measuring the dielectric parameters of mm-wave optical materials by Brodi D. Elwood, Paul K. Grimes, John Kovac, Miranda Eiben, Grant Meiners (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01058.txt.
Description
Abstract As millimeter-wave cosmology experiments refine their optical chains, precisely characterizing their optical materials under cryogenic conditions becomes increasingly important. For instance, as the aperture sizes and bandwidths of millimeter-wave receivers increase, the design of antireflection coatings becomes progressively more constrained by an accurate measure of material optical properties in order to achieve forecasted performance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Brodi D. Elwood, Paul K. Grimes, John Kovac, Miranda Eiben, Grant Meiners |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01058
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fabry–Pérot open resonant cavities for measuring the dielectric parameters of mm-wave optical materials Brodi D. Elwood, Paul K. Grimes, John Kovac, Miranda Eiben, Grant Meiners Abstract As millimeter-wave cosmology experiments refine their optical chains, precisely characterizing their optical materials under cryogenic conditions becomes increasingly important. For instance, as the aperture sizes and bandwidths of millimeter-wave receivers increase, the design of antireflection coatings becomes progressively more constrained by an accurate measure of material optical properties in order to achieve forecasted performance. Likewise, understanding dielectric and scattering losses is relevant to photon noise modeling in presently-deploying receivers such as BICEP Array and especially to future experiments such as CMB-S4. Additionally, the design of refractive elements such as lenses necessitates an accurate measure of the refractive index. High quality factor Fabry–Pérot open resonant cavities provide an elegant means for measuring these optical properties. Employing a hemispherical resonator that is compatible with a quick-turnaround 4 Kelvin cryostat, we can measure the dielectric and scattering losses of low-loss materials at both ambient and cryogenic temperatures. We review the design, characterization, and metrological applications of quasioptical cavities commissioned for measuring the dielectric materials in the BICEP3 (95 GHz) and BICEP Array mid-frequency (150 GHz) optics. We also discuss the efforts to improve the finesse of said cavities, for better resolution of degenerate higher order modes, which can provide stronger constraints on cavity parameters and sample material thickness. a]Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA b]Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA keywords Resonant cavity, Dielectric losses, Quasioptical, Fabry–Pérot, Optical materials, Sub-millimeter instrumentation, Complex permittivity † † authorinfo: Send correspondence to B. D. Elwood: [email protected] 1 INTRODUCTION The astrophysical observations carried out in the millimeter and sub-millimeter wavelength regime provide key insights into many of the open questions in physics today. Experiments using millimeter light image black holes, map high-redshift regions of the Universe, and observe the Cosmic Microwave Background, to name a few [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . These experiments aim to expand our understanding of the influence of black holes on cosmic evolution, explore the growth of structure in the cosmos, and provide insights into the earliest epochs of the Universe. Optics used in experiments within the mm/sub-mm regime often incorporate polymers like polyethylene, polytetrafluoroethylene, and nylon; ceramics such as alumina; or monocrystalline silicon. Plastics are frequently used for filters, lenses, vacuum windows, or laminate antireflection coatings, while alumina and silicon are common filter and lens materials [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . An experimenter’s choice of a material for a given optic hinges on its complex permittivity (namely index of refraction and dielectric losses) at the desired temperature, which is often cryogenic [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . As mm-wave experiments often employ cryogenically cooled optics in order to reduce optical loading, we seek a robust method of empirically measuring complex permittivity as a function of temperature, as its behavior can be nontrivial [ 10 ] . In the context of current and future CMB experiments, such as BICEP/Keck or CMB-S4, we are motivated to seek high precision measurements of refractive index as we require an accuracy of \pm.005 in index measurements for designing optics. Additionally, we desire to understand material loss in order to better model instrument photon noise and systematics, such as forebaffle coupling and far-sidelobe response. Numerous well-established techniques exist for measuring the the index and loss of materials in the mm-wave regime. Many of those techniques utilize closed resonant cavities, typically waveguides [ 11 ] . The accuracy of index and loss measurements from waveguide cavity (so-called Nicholson-Ross-Weir) methods relies on the quality of sample machining; gaps between the material under test and waveguide walls result in significant errors, which are exacerbated at high frequencies. When one wishes to measure complex permittivity at cryogenic temperatures, in the case of a closed resonator, one has to take care to account for differential coefficients of thermal expansion between the metallic waveguide and the dielectric sample. Additionally, due to the frequency scaling of the quality factor with the resonant frequency, and since the accuracy of loss measurements deteriorates for losses below the reciprocal of the quality factor, NRW methods become impracticable at high frequencies, typically above 75\text{\,}\mathrm{G}\mathrm{H}\mathrm{z} . Furthermore, for low loss materials of thicknesses that are integer multiples of wavelength, measurements using NRW methods become unstable [ 12 ] . Similarly, measurement techniques employing Fourier transform spectrometers suffer from increased systematic uncertainty in the limit of low loss materials or samples thin compared to a wavelength [ 13 , 14 ] . The use of an open resonator comes with the advantage that the standing modes of optical resonators, in particular simple two-mirror topologies such as Fabry–Pérot hemispherical open resonators, are well-studied and have readily recordable observables that depend strongly on cavity electrical length and round-trip loss [ 15 ] . Compared to closed resonator techniques, the mode spectrum of cavities enables quasi-broadband measurements. Due to the build-up of the electromagnetic field in the cavity, we can naturally integrate over many transits through the inserted optical material of interest. High quality factor Fabry–Pérot open cavities provide a means for measuring the optical properties of low-loss dielectric materials which only relies on one length dimension of the material under test. By taking high signal-to-noise measurements of the resonant modes of an empty and dielectric-loaded open resonator, we can infer the index and loss of an inserted dielectric sample. Measurement apparatuses can be readily designed for operation down to cryogenic temperatures. In this work, we first establish the basic working theory of quasioptical open resonant cavities, employing the full vector theory as established in the literature [ 16 ] . We discuss a quasioptical cavity fabricated for this work and detail a measurement procedure for inferring index and loss from measurements of its fundamental modes, before reporting the results for several polyethylene samples. Finally, we conclude with a brief discussion of future improvements to open resonator techniques for measuring complex permittivity, including ongoing efforts to extend these methods to cryogenic temperatures. 2 (Quasi)-optical cavities Given the challenges associated with traditional methods for measuring complex permittivity in the mm-wave regime, open resonant cavities offer a promising alternative due to their high-quality factors and ability to integrate over multiple transits of the optical material. To fully leverage these advantages, careful consideration must be given to the design of the cavity, particularly in minimizing power losses and ensuring effective coupling. In the end, we construct cavity quality factor such that we can measure low-loss materials while retaining enough transmitted power to stay above the transmission background of the cavity. To construct a cavity with a given quality factor, we must account for the sources of power loss intrinsic to the cavity: coupling losses from the apertures, conductive losses on the mirror surfaces, and diffractive losses off the edges of the mirror and apertures. The coupling constant \beta —the ratio of cavity incident power to intrinsic power lost—parametrizes the power coupled into the cavity. For the cavity used in this work, we selected an aperture coupling of \beta=$0.3$ . Ansys HFSS calculations were carried out to show apertures of 1\text{\,}\mathrm{mm} diameter and 1.05\text{\,}\mathrm{mm} depth provide