Advancing Crime Linkage Analysis with Machine Learning: A Comprehensive Review and Framework for Data-Driven Approaches

Vinicius Lima, Umit Karabiyik · 2024

Read Advancing Crime Linkage Analysis with Machine Learning: A Comprehensive Review and Framework for Data-Driven Approaches by Vinicius Lima, Umit Karabiyik (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-00864.txt.

Description

Abstract Crime linkage is the process of analyzing criminal behavior data to determine whether a pair or group of crime cases are connected or belong to a series of offenses. This domain has been extensively studied by researchers in sociology, psychology, and statistics. More recently, it has drawn interest from computer scientists, especially with advances in artificial intelligence.

Catalog record

CREATORVinicius Lima, Umit Karabiyik
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-00864

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Advancing Crime Linkage Analysis with Machine Learning: A Comprehensive Review and Framework for Data-Driven Approaches Vinicius Lima, Umit Karabiyik Abstract Crime linkage is the process of analyzing criminal behavior data to determine whether a pair or group of crime cases are connected or belong to a series of offenses. This domain has been extensively studied by researchers in sociology, psychology, and statistics. More recently, it has drawn interest from computer scientists, especially with advances in artificial intelligence. Despite this, the literature indicates that work in this latter discipline is still in its early stages. This study aims to understand the challenges faced by machine learning approaches in crime linkage and to support foundational knowledge for future data-driven methods. To achieve this goal, we conducted a comprehensive survey of the main literature on the topic and developed a general framework for crime linkage processes, thoroughly describing each step. Our goal was to unify insights from diverse fields into a shared terminology to enhance the research landscape for those intrigued by this subject. K eywords Crime Linkage \cdot Criminalistics \cdot Criminal Behavior \cdot Crime Patterns \cdot Artificial Intelligence \cdot Machine Learning 1 Introduction Crime Linkage (CL) [ 1 ] is a multidisciplinary field that has garnered significant attention from sociologists, psychologists, statisticians, and computer scientists [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . In essence, they aim to connect pairs of crimes by creating crime link associations [ 3 ] . The CL analysis is typically based on Modus Operandi (MO) or criminal behavior, which can be inferred from evidence found at crime scenes or other source of police data [ 8 ] . These MOs/behaviors are systematically compared to assess the similarities between different crimes [ 9 ] . High similarity scores often indicate potential connections, providing valuable insight into shared offender characteristics or underlying patterns within these criminal acts. The literature on crime linkage encompasses a wide array of methods and evaluation metrics, alongside various data sets used to establish connections between criminal incidents. Numerous studies have showcased CL outcomes, particularly in cases involving property crimes and sexual offenses [ 5 ] . The CL is in essence a classification problem, where the goal is to either assess if a pair of crimes is linked or not, or to associate a case to a series of offenses, based on pattern characteristics. There are many methodologies for modeling and evaluating crime linkage. Data-driven approaches in CL have been explored using statistical methods, fuzzy logic, and machine learning techniques. Although recent years have seen a surge in artificial intelligence (AI) research, studies applying machine learning to crime linkage are still in the early stages. We sought to understand the reasons behind this. To gain insight, we surveyed key data-driven work, including both statistical and machine learning approaches, and analyzed the challenges - whether implicit or explicit - associated with handling large amounts of data. Previous literature surveys have not included machine learning approaches [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] , thus, our aim is to provide an extension of research assessment on the theme. When analyzing the studies collected, we observed a general framework in the CL process, which will be also discussed in this paper. In summary, the contributions of this study is two fold: • (1) A comprehensive survey of the main literature on data-drive crime linkage and outline of a general framework of the linkage process to support further research in the topic. • (2) Analyze the main challenges faced by crime linkage, especially when dealing with machine learning and bigger datasets, and thus support future work. The structure of this paper unfolds as follows. First, we will discuss the main literature on crime linkage, outlining the concepts and definitions involved. Then, in Section 3, we will describe the general framework usually used to work on CL, as a discussion of each step and the techniques involved. Section 4 is dedicated to elaborate on the challenges faced by the topic, as potential solutions when applicable. Finally, we will wrap up with the main conclusions of this work. The Appendix (Section 6 ) will show all the papers surveyed and details on each study. 2 Related Work Crime Linkage, a.k.a. Case Linkage or Behavioral Crime Linking, has been a subject of extensive study, particularly within domains such as Criminology and Psychology. Its origins trace back to the 1970s [ 1 ] , with a notable surge in practical research observed in the 2000s [ 4 ] . Although related to criminal profiling [ 5 ] , crime linkage specifically refers to “the process of linking two or more crimes together on the basis of the crime scene behavior exhibited by an offender” [ 10 ] . In other words, this discipline is interested in understanding pattern characteristics in criminal behavior that might suffice connections between which seem to be unrelated crimes, often in the context of serial offenders. Crime Linkage is underpinned by two assumptions in criminal behavior: consistency and distinctiveness. The latter posits that serial criminals exhibit patterned actions akin to a signature behavior [ 11 ] , while the former suggests that this signature is unique enough to differentiate their criminal activity from others [ 10 ] . However, in terms of data-driven CL, Bennell et al. [ 12 ] introduced three other assumptions that challenge research in this area: the reliability of coded data within systems, the accuracy of the data, and analysts’ ability to accurately link crimes using this data. Basically, the reliability and suitability of the data to draw conclusions on the link between crime remain the subject of debate [ 13 ] . The primary focus of this topic lies in identifying pairs or series of crimes committed by the same perpetrator. This field is of significant importance, and CL has already been used as evidence in court proceedings to implicate suspects [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] . In particular, Keppel documented the first case in Canada where crime linkage was used as evidence, which a decision later corroborated the result through DNA analysis [ 17 ] . However, the authors have debated whether and how pattern behavior can be used as evidence in court. Labuschagne [ 18 ] points out that a linkage decision should not be based only on computerized approaches, while Canter et al. [ 19 ] do not recommend exclusively experience-based decisions. In 1993, the U.S. Supreme Court established guidelines for the incorporation of scientific evidence into legal proceedings, now enshrined in Rule 702, commonly known as the Daubert standard [ 20 ] . This landmark decision provided a framework to bolster the credibility of forensic science evidence. The standards outlined for admissible scientific evidence include factors such as reliability, peer review and publication, error rates, general acceptance within the scientific community, the existence of known standards, and applicability to the specific case at hand. In the context of Data-Driven Crime Linkage and its conformity with the Daubert standard, Pakkanen et al. [ 20 ] proposed an evaluation framework centered on three key aspects: • Consistent Behavior: This pertains to assessing the probability of consistency in linking one crime to another

Read the complete text