On the Instrumental Discrepancies in Lyman-alpha Observations of Solar Flares

Harry J. Greatorex, Ryan O. Milligan, Ingolf E. Dammasch · 2024

Read On the Instrumental Discrepancies in Lyman-alpha Observations of Solar Flares by Harry J. Greatorex, Ryan O. Milligan, Ingolf E. Dammasch (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-00736.txt.

Description

A 2024 arXiv research paper by Harry J. Greatorex, Ryan O. Milligan, Ingolf E. Dammasch. Despite the energetic significance of Lyman-alpha (Ly α \rm\alpha ; 1216Å) emission from solar flares, regular observations of flare related Ly α \rm\alpha have been relatively scarce until recently. Advances in instrumental capabilities and a shift in focus over previous Solar Cycles mean it is now routinely possible to take regular co-observations of Ly α \rm\alpha emission in solar flares.

Catalog record

CREATORHarry J. Greatorex, Ryan O. Milligan, Ingolf E. Dammasch
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-00736

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Instrumental Discrepancies in Lyman-alpha Observations of Solar Flares Harry J. Greatorex, Ryan O. Milligan, Ingolf E. Dammasch Abstract Despite the energetic significance of Lyman-alpha (Ly α \rm\alpha ; 1216Å) emission from solar flares, regular observations of flare related Ly α \rm\alpha have been relatively scarce until recently. Advances in instrumental capabilities and a shift in focus over previous Solar Cycles mean it is now routinely possible to take regular co-observations of Ly α \rm\alpha emission in solar flares. Thus, it is valuable to examine how the instruments selected for flare observations may influence the conclusions drawn from the analysis of their unique measurements. Here, we examine three M-class flares each observed in Ly α \rm\alpha by GOES-14/EUVS-E, GOES-15/EUVS-E, or GOES-16/EXIS-EUVS-B, and at least one other instrument from PROBA2/LYRA, MAVEN/EUVM, ASO-S/LST-SDI, and SDO/EVE-MEGS-P. For each flare, the relative and excess flux, contrast, total energy, and timings of the Ly α \rm\alpha emission were compared between instruments. It was found that while the discrepancies in measurements of the relative flux between instruments may be considered minimal, the calculated contrasts, excess fluxes, and energetics may differ significantly - in some cases up to a factor of five. This may have a notable impact on multi-instrument investigations of the variable Ly α \rm\alpha emission in solar flares and estimates of the contribution of Ly α \rm\alpha to the radiated energy budget of the chromosphere. The findings presented in this study will act as a guide for the interpretation of observations of flare-related Ly α \rm\alpha from upcoming instruments during future Solar Cycles and inform conclusions drawn from multi-instrument studies. 1 Introduction The Lyman-alpha line of neutral hydrogen (Ly \rm\alpha ; 1216Å) is the most intense emission line in the quiescent solar spectrum ( Curdt et al., 2001 ) . In spite of this, observations of flare-related Ly \rm\alpha emission have historically been relatively scarce. Among the earliest measurements of flare-related Ly \rm\alpha emission were the spectroscopic observations of Skumanich et al. (1978) using the Laboratoire de Physique Stellaire et Planetaire (LPSP; Bonnet et al. 1978 ) onboard Eighth Orbiting Solar Observatory (OSO-8), and of Canfield and van Hoosier (1980) using the NRL Spectrograph ( Bartoe et al., 1977 ) within the Apollo Telescope Mount onboard Skylab . However, due to the individual instrumental capabilities required to observe such an energetic emission line on flare timescales, it has only been possible in the last decade to conduct statistical studies using calibrated photometric measurements of flare-related Ly \rm\alpha . Milligan et al. (2020) conducted a large-scale statistical study of Ly \rm\alpha flares observed by the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites (GOES) during Solar Cycle 24. From their analysis of > 500 M- and X-class flares, it was found that both the energy and contrast in flare-related Ly \rm\alpha emission tend to scale with Soft X-Ray (SXR) magnitude. Furthermore, it was found that 95% of the flares sampled had an associated Ly \rm\alpha contrast of < 10%. However, unique cases could reach contrasts of up to \sim 30%. Comparatively, observations of flare-related Ly \rm\alpha from the Project for On-Board Autonomy (PROBA2; Santandrea et al. 2013 ) have consistently found contrasts of \rm<1\% ( Kretzschmar et al. 2013 ; Raulin et al. 2013 ). One explanation for these notably low contrasts may be significant detector degradation and the presence of contaminants in the PROBA2 signal. Currently, the extent to which these discrepancies may exist in co-observations between individual instruments is not well documented. Ly \rm\alpha emission is optically thick and therefore observations in Ly \rm\alpha are subject to effects of Centre-to-Limb Variation (CLV), whereby the position of a flare on the solar disk (and the subsequent column depth along the observing line of sight) can impact the measured Ly \rm\alpha irradiance (for further discussion see Woods et al. 1995 ; Woods et al. 2006 ; Milligan 2021 ). The extent to which CLV may impact Ly \rm\alpha observations was examined by Milligan et al. (2020) using combined stereoscopic observations of an X1.1 flare from GOES-15 and the Mars Atmosphere and Volatile Evolution (MAVEN; Eparvier et al. 2015 ) in orbit around Mars. For MAVEN, the flare was located close to disk-centre, whereas for GOES the flare appeared at the solar limb. Subsequently, a \sim 45% increase in flare-related Ly \rm\alpha excess was observed at Mars relative to Earth, thus demonstrating the magnitude of CLV on observations of optically-thick emission. Temporally, flare-related Ly \rm\alpha emission tends to peak in conjunction with nonthermal Hard X-Ray (HXR) emission and therefore the derivative of the SXRs in alignment with the Neupert Effect ( Neupert, 1968 ) ; examples of the nonthermal origin of Ly \rm\alpha emission are demonstrated in Nusinov et al. (2006) , da Costa et al. (2009) , Milligan et al. (2017) , Dominique et al. (2018) , Li et al. (2022) , Tian et al. (2023) , and Greatorex et al. (2023) . In some instances, secondary Ly \rm\alpha emission peaks occur during the decay-phase, which is speculated to originate from cooling loop plasma rather than the flare footpoint regions ( Kretzschmar et al., 2013 ) , or from filament eruptions ( Wauters et al., 2022 ) . However, systematic effects have also been shown to account for apparent violations of expected Neupertian behaviour. Milligan and Chamberlin (2016) found flare-related Ly \rm\alpha emission observed by the Extreme-ultraviolet Variability Experiment (EVE; Woods et al. 2012 ) onboard SDO to peak within the gradual phase co-temporally with the associated Soft X-ray (SXR) emission. This was later attributed to issues with the Kalman filters used during data processing (D. Woodraska - Private Communication) Recent instrumental advancements mean that it is now possible to image solar flares in Ly \rm\alpha on sufficient timescales to observe the dynamic spatial development of flare footpoints, loops, and ribbons. Li et al. (2022) studied a C1.4 flare using observations from the Ly \rm\alpha channel of High Resolution Imager within the Extreme Ultraviolet Imager onboard Solar Orbiter (SO/EUI-HRI Lyα ; Müller et al. 2020 ; Rochus et al. 2020 1 1 1 SO was omitted from this study due to difficulty in obtaining sufficient calibration data. ). In their study, the authors found a co-spatial relationship between Ly \rm\alpha emission and nonthermal HXR sources, similarity in spatiotemporal behaviour between Ly \rm\alpha and He ii (304Å) emission observed by the Extreme Ultraviolet Imager (EUVI; Howard et al. 2008 ) onboard the Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory Ahead (STEREO-A; Kaiser et al. 2008 ) and the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly onboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO/AIA; Pesnell et al. 2012 ; Boerner et al. 2012 ), and Ly \rm\alpha brightenings in both the rise and decay phase of the flare. Furthermore, the Solar Disk Imager within the Lyman-alpha Solar Telescope onboard the recently launched Advanced Space-based Solar Observatory (ASO-S/SDI-LST; Li et al. 2019 ; Feng et al. 2019 ; Gan et al. 2023 ; Chen et al. 2024 ) has been used to examine the presence of long-period QPPs in an X6.4 solar flare, co-temporal with the associated HXR emission ( Li et al., 2024 ) . Similar behaviour was presented by Milligan et al. (2017) in a multi-instrument study using observations from GOES, SDO, and the Reuven Ramaty High Energy

Read the complete text