α \alpha -TCVAE: On the relationship between Disentanglement and Diversity
Cristian Meo *, Louis Mahon, Anirudh Goyal, Justin Dauwels · 2024
Read α \alpha -TCVAE: On the relationship between Disentanglement and Diversity by Cristian Meo *, Louis Mahon, Anirudh Goyal, Justin Dauwels (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-00588.txt.
Description
Abstract Understanding and developing optimal representations has long been foundational in machine learning (ML). While disentangled representations have shown promise in generative modeling and representation learning, their downstream usefulness remains debated. Recent studies re-defined disentanglement through a formal connection to symmetries, emphasizing the ability to reduce latent domains (i.e., ML problem spaces) and consequently enhance data efficiency and generative capabilities.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cristian Meo *, Louis Mahon, Anirudh Goyal, Justin Dauwels |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-00588
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
α \alpha -TCVAE: On the relationship between Disentanglement and Diversity Cristian Meo *, Louis Mahon, Anirudh Goyal, Justin Dauwels Abstract Understanding and developing optimal representations has long been foundational in machine learning (ML). While disentangled representations have shown promise in generative modeling and representation learning, their downstream usefulness remains debated. Recent studies re-defined disentanglement through a formal connection to symmetries, emphasizing the ability to reduce latent domains (i.e., ML problem spaces) and consequently enhance data efficiency and generative capabilities. However, from an information theory viewpoint, assigning a complex attribute (i.e., features) to a specific latent variable may be infeasible, limiting the applicability of disentangled representations to simple datasets. In this work, we introduce α \alpha -TCVAE, a variational autoencoder optimized using a novel total correlation (TC) lower bound that maximizes disentanglement and latent variables informativeness. The proposed TC bound is grounded in information theory constructs, generalizes the β \beta -VAE lower bound, and can be reduced to a convex combination of the known variational information bottleneck (VIB) and conditional entropy bottleneck (CEB) terms. Moreover, we present quantitative analyses and correlation studies that support the idea that smaller latent domains (i.e., disentangled representations) lead to better generative capabilities and diversity. Additionally, we perform downstream task experiments from both representation and RL domains to assess our questions from a broader ML perspective. Our results demonstrate that α \alpha -TCVAE consistently learns more disentangled representations than baselines and generates more diverse observations without sacrificing visual fidelity. Notably, α \alpha -TCVAE exhibits marked improvements on MPI3D-Real, the most realistic disentangled dataset in our study, confirming its ability to represent complex datasets when maximizing the informativeness of individual variables. Finally, testing the proposed model off-the-shelf on a state-of-the-art model-based RL agent, Director, significantly shows α \alpha -TCVAE downstream usefulness on the loconav Ant Maze task. † † ∗ Work done while doing a research internship at Mila, Quebec AI Institute. 1 Introduction The efficacy of machine learning (ML) algorithms is intrinsically tied to the quality of data representation ( Bengio et al., 2013 ) . Such representations are useful not only for standard downstream tasks such as supervised learning ( Alemi et al., 2017 ) and reinforcement learning (RL) ( Li, 2017 ) , but also for tasks such as transfer learning ( Zhuang et al., 2020 ) and zero-shot learning ( Sun et al., 2021 ) . Unsupervised representation learning aims to identify semantically meaningful representations of data without supervision, by capturing the generative factors of variations that describe the structure of the data ( Radford et al., 2016 ; Locatello et al., 2019b ) . According to Bengio et al. (2013) , disentanglement learning holds the key to understanding the world from observations, generalizing knowledge across different tasks and domains while learning and generating compositional representations ( Higgins et al., 2016 ; Kim & Mnih, 2018 ) . Problem Formulation. The goal of disentanglement learning is to identify a set of independent generative factors \bm{z} that give rise to the observations \bm{x} via p(\bm{x}|\bm{z}) . However, from an information theory perspective, the amount of information retained by every latent variable may be insufficient to represent realistic generative factors ( Kirsch et al., 2021 ; Do & Tran, 2020 ) , limiting the applicability of disentangled representations to simple problems. What is more, Friedman & Dieng (2022) recently introduced the Vendi score, a new metric for gauging generative diversity, showing that entangled generative models, such as the Very Deep VAE ( Child, 2020 ) , consistently produce samples with less diversity compared to ground truth. This is indicative of their limited representational and generative prowess. In contrast, Higgins et al. (2019) ; Higgins et al. (2022) re-defined disentangled representations through the lens of symmetries, linking disentanglement to computational problem spaces (e.g., disentangled representations inherently reduce the problem space ( Arora & Barak, 2009 ) ), suggesting that disentangled models should be able to explore and traverse the latent space more efficiently, leading to enhanced generative diversity. Previous Work. Most existing disentangled models optimize lower bounds that only impose an information bottleneck on the latent variables, and while this can result in factorized representations ( Higgins et al., 2016 ) , it does not directly optimize latent variable informativeness ( Do & Tran, 2020 ) . As a result, while several approaches have been proposed to learn disentangled representations by optimizing different bounds ( Chen et al., 2018 ; Kim & Mnih, 2018 ) , imposing sparsity priors ( Mathieu et al., 2019 ) , or isolating source of variance ( Rolinek et al., 2019 ) , none of the proposed models successfully learned disentangled representations of realistic datasets. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, no systematic and quantitative analyses have been proposed to assess to what extent disentanglement and generative diversity ( Friedman & Dieng, 2022 ) are correlated. Proposed method. In this work, we propose \alpha -TCVAE, a VAE optimized using a novel convex lower bound of the joint total correlation (TC) between the learned latent representation and the input data. The proposed bound, through a convex combination of the variational information bottleneck (VIB) Alemi et al. (2017) and the conditional entropy bottleneck (CEB) Fischer & Alemi (2020) , maximizes the average latent variable informativeness, improving both representational and generative capabilities. The effectiveness of \alpha -TCVAE is especially prominent in the MPI3D-Real Dataset ( Gondal et al., 2019 ) , the most realistic dataset in our study that is compositionally built upon distinct generative factors. Figure 1 illustrates a comparison of the latent traversals between \alpha -TCVAE, Factor-VAE and \beta -VAE, showing that \alpha -TCVAE leads to the best visual fidelity and generative diversity (i.e., higher Vendi Score). Interestingly, the proposed TC bound is grounded in information theory constructs, generalizes the \beta -VAE ( Higgins et al., 2016 ) lower bound, and can be reduced to a convex combination of the known variational information bottleneck (VIB) ( Alemi et al., 2017 ) and conditional entropy bottleneck (CEB) ( Fischer & Alemi, 2020 ) terms. Figure 1: Ground truth (first row), reconstructions (second row) and latent traversals comparison of \alpha -TCVAE, Factor-VAE, and \beta -VAE on the MPI3D-Real Dataset. Notably, \alpha -TCVAE showcases superior visual fidelity and generative diversity, as indicated by a higher Vendi Score. Experimental Evaluation In order to determine the effectiveness of \alpha -TCVAE and the downstream usefulness of the learned representations, we measure the diversity and quality of generated images and disentanglement of its latent representations. Then, we perform a correlation study between the considered downstream scores across all models, analyzing how generative diversity and disentanglement are related across different datasets. This analysis substantiates our claim that disentanglement leads to improved diversity. Finally, we conduct experiments to assess the downstream usefulness of the proposed method from a broader ML perspective. Notably, the proposed method consistently outperforms the related baselines, showing a significant improvement in the RL Ant Maze task when applied off-the-shelf in Director, a hierarchical model-based RL agent ( Hafner et al., 2022 ) . 2 Related Work Generative Modelling and Disentanglement Recently Locatello et al. (2019b) demonstrated that unsupervised disentangled representation learning is theoretically impossible, nonetheless disentangled VAEs, acting as both representational and generative models, Kingma &