History of the Rise and Influence of Rationalism in Europe (W. E. H. Lecky, 1865) ========================================================== The great Whig history of reason against magic, witchcraft, and persecution. Public domain. Internet Archive full text (historyofriseinf02leck). V. t BL 2750 .L4 1872 v. 2 Lecky, William Edward Hartpole, 1838-1903. History of the rise and EATIOI^ALISM II^T EUROPE. VOL. 11. HISTORY EISE A]^D INFLUEI^OE OF THE SPIRIT OP 1 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. W. E. II. LECKY, M.A, REVISED EDITION. IN TWO VOLUMES. VOL. II. l^EW YOPJv: D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 549 & 551 BROADWAY. 1872. OOI^TEI^TS THE SECOND VOLUME, CHAPTER lY.— Continued. PAET II. THE HISTORY OP PEESECUTIOif. Men who believe the Doctrine of Salvation in the Church alone will always persecute— Success of Persecution shown in the Cases of the Japanese Christians, the Albigenses, the Spanish Protestants, the Massacre of St. Bartholomew, and the Laws of Eliza- beth—Weakness of the Objection derived from the History of Ireland— And from that of the English Dissenters— True Causes of Opinions— Influence of the. Levitical Laws on Persecution — Opinions of the Fathers determined chiefly by their Circum- stances—Uncompromising Tolerance of Lactantius— Constantine persecutes the Jews — And the Heretics — And the Pagans — PLCView of their Condition before Theo- dosius— Destruction of the Temples in the Country Districts— Libanius— Even in the Days of Persecution Cypri.an regarded the Levitical System as the foundation of dealings with Heretics — Theology of Persecution systematised by Augustine — His Character and Influence— Aversion to tho Effusion of Blood— St. Martin and Am- brose—Opinion that Ecclesiastics should under no circumstances cause the Death of Men — Increase of the Corporate Action of the Church stimulates Persecution — The first Monks— Euin of Paganism— The Church was then for several Centuries an al- most unmixed Blessing— Decomposition of the Mediteval Society renews Heresies— "Which are encountered by Persecution — Innocent III. — Unparalleled Magnitude and Atrocity of the Persecution perpetrated by Catholicism — Protestants persecuted not so atrociously, but quite as generally, as Catholics— Examples in Germany, England, Ireland, Scotland, France, Sweden, America, and Holland — Persecution advocated or practised by Luther, Calvin, Beza, Jurieu, Knox, Cranmer, Eidley, Melanchthon, elc. — Socinus and Zuinglins tolerant— Castellio, his Life and "Writings— Answereil ij 0 CONTENTS OF Calrin and Beza — Persecution by Protestants peculiarly inexcusaLle — Comparative liberality of Erasmus, Hopital, and More— Position assigned by Bossuet to Socinians and Anabaptists — Persecution a positive Dogma among Protestants — Toleration fa- voured by the Mingling of Eeligions produced by the Eeformation — ^And by the Marriage of the Clergj'— And by the greater flexibility of Protestantism— Proof of this is in a comparison of Tolerance in France and England — French Tolerance based on three forms of Scepticism — Montaigne, the Sceptical Man of the "World — Descartes, the Sceptical Philosopher — Bayle, the Sceptical Scholar — The ' Compelle inirare ' — Political circumstances favourable to Toleration — Comparison of the Eegency and the Kestoration— Influence of Vice on Historic Development— Voltaire— Intolerance of Rousseau — Pevolution removes all Civil Disabilities from Jews and Protestants — Catholicism incapable of adopting Eoligious Liberty — Bull of Gregory SVI. — In Protestant Countries, Tolerance the result and measure of the advance of Eationalism — Writings of the great Divines of the seventeenth century lead to it — First Move- ment during the P>ebellion — Policy of Cfomivell — Contrast between the Independ- ents and Presbyteriaus— Harrington— Milton— Jeremy Taylor— Eepeal of the writ ' De Hxretico combureudo '—Intolerance of Ilobbes— Attitude of the Clergy during the revolution — Toleration Act — Abrogation of the Censorship — Establishment of the Scottish Kirk— Complete Tolerance of Protestantism- Eevicw of the iufluenco of Eationalism on the Method of Enquiry ..... Pago 11 CHAPTER V. ON THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. The Secularisation of Politics consists of two parts: the elimination of Theological In- terests from the Motives of Policy, and the substitution of a Secular for a Theologi- cal Principle as the Basis of Authority- Eeligion and Patriotism the chief Moral Principles of Society— The First the Moral Principle of Antiquity— Type of Charac- ter it formed— Patriotism the Moral Principle of Judaism— Correspoi\ds to the Spirit of Sect in Eeligion — Christianity in the Eoman Empire triumphed on the condition of transforming itself under the influence of the Spiritof Sect— Complete ascendency of Theology— The Crusades— The Church replaced the Civil Government when the latter proved inefficient- The Truce of God— Contest between the Eegal and Eccle- siastical Power- A Comparison of the Crusades and the Eeligious Wars shows the declining influence of Theology— Alliances of Francis I. and Eichelieu— Close of Ee- ligious Wars— The Inquisiticm separates Eeligious Questions from Politics— Sketch of its Constitution and Progress— The Doctrine of the Incapacity of the Magistrate to decide Eeligious Questions, which is the Basis of Modern Tolerance, first advo- cated in favour of the Inquisition — Collisions with the Civil Power— Difficulty of De- fining Ecclesiastical Offences-Unpopularity attaching to the Inquisition— Decline of Persecution — Suppression of Heretical Books still continued — Its prevalence in the Early Church— Eeuchlin— System of Eeligious Disabilities nest abolished— Change in France eflfectod in 1S30 — That in England accelerated by Irish Policy — The Irisb THE SECOND VOLUME, 7 ParliameDt— The Clergy disappear from OflQces of Power— Eevicw of tbe steps of Secularisation— Decline of the Temporal Power of the Pope— Political Life acts pow erfully on the Theological Habits— It diminishes the sense of the Importance ot Theology— It leads to a neglect of General Principles— Diflerence between the Politi- cal and Philosophical Standing Point — Injurious effects now resulting from the as- cendency of Political Modes of Thought— Important influence of Political Life in promoting a True Method of Enquiry— Three phases of the Conflict between the Sec- tarian and the Judicial Spirit in Politics— The Secul«risation of the Basis of Author- ity— Passive Obedience — According to the Fathers all Eebellion sinful — Considering the Anarchy and Worship of Force that was then general, this Teaching was favour- able to Liberty— The Election of Bishops by Universal Sufl'rage— Conflict between the Pope and Kings favourable to Liberty— Power of Deposition— Moral Authority necessarily with the Pope — Public Penance — Power of Dispensation — Scholasticism favourable to liberty— St. Thomas Aquinas— Doctrine of the Mediate Character of the Divine Eight of Kings— The Eeformation produces a Variety of Interests, and there fore of Political Opinions — The Papal Party insists on the Eight of Deposition- Works of Bellarmine and Suarez burnt at Paris — The Jesuits proclaim the Social Contract— Suarez de Fide — Mariana de Eege — Tyrannicide fascinates an Early Civili- sation—Its Importance in the History of Liberal Opinions— First maintained unequiv- ocally by Jean Petit— Advocated by Grtivin, Toletus, Sa, Molina, Ayala, and Kelle- rus— Murder of Henry III. eulogised in the League and by the Pope — Political Assas- sination approved among Protestants — But the Jesuits were its Special Advocates — Great Services of the Jesuits to Liberalism— Galilean Church represented Despotic Interests — Eeasons of this — Circumstances that made Patriotism in France antago- nistic to Liberty— Slight Suctuation produced by the Attitude of the Protestants in 1615— Eesolutions of 1665 and 16S2—Bossuet— Protestantism being a Eebellion was favourable to Democracy — The two compensatory parts of Primitive Church Govern- ment revived but dissevered — Different Political Tendencies of Episccpalianism and Presbyterianism- Different Political Tendencies resulting from the Eelative Positions assigned to the Old and New Testaments — Opinions of Huss and Wycliffc and of the Leaders of the Eeformation— The Scotch lead the ran of Protestant Liberalism— Knox — Buchanan — The Scotch Deputation to Elizabeth — English Dissenters assimi- lated with the Scotch— Debt England owes to the Non-Episcopal Churches— Extreme servility of Anglicanism — The Homilies — Taylor — Anglicanism supported every Ee- aciion — Exceptional Position of Hooker — Two Schools of Despotism in England — Barclay, Filmer, Hobbes— Sidney, Locke— Parallel between the History of Eoligious and of Political Liberty In England — Greatest English Freethinkers inimical to Lib- erty— Hobbes, Bolingbroke, Hume — Diflerence between the Growth of English and French Liberty analogous to that between English and French tolerance — French Protestants — Circumstances that diminished their Influence — Sectarianism incom- patible with Patriotism— Two currents of Opinion among the French Protestants — The Liberal Opinion dominated — The 'Franco-G.iUia' of Hotmau — The 'Vindicioe contra Tyraunos' — Montaigne notices tlie Subordination of Opinions to Interests in « COKTEJSTTS OF France— Revival of Classical "Writings acted on Liberty— In the first place, by tbo renewed Study of Roman Law— Opinions of Bodin, Gronovius, Noodt, etc.— Phases of Jurisprudence— Principal effect of the Classics in altering the Type of Heroism- Different Types resulting from the Sense of Dignity and the Sense of Sin — La Boetie — Circumstances that prepared the Democracy of the Eighteenth Century : First, the Increase of Capital ; Second, the Increase of Knowledge— Servitude and Superstition the necessary lot of all great bodies of men before Printing— Third, Change in the Relative Position of the Cavalry and Infantry in War— The English Archers— Rise of the Flemish Infantry— The Italian Condottieri — The Invention of Gunpowder and of the Bayonet— Fourth, Influence of Political Economy on Democracy— The French Revolution inevitable ; Importance of the Question into whose guidance it would fall— Reasons why Catholicism was incompetent for the Task— Early Freethinkers not favourable to Political Liberty— Opinions of Socinus, Montaigne, Charron, and Bayle— Change in their Attitude in the Eighteenth Century— Wide Influence of the Revolution— Rousseau— His Power over French Society— Dress, Theatre, Gardens — The Stream of Self-Sacrifice passing from Theology to Politics — The Democratic Ideal consists of Two Parts— The Doctrine of Nationalities— Theories of Interna tional Arrangements, of Hildcbrand, Dante, Grotius, and Diplomacy— Causes that rendered it possible in the Nineteenth Century— Synthesis of the Moral Principles of Christianity and Paganism — Democracy an Aspect of the Christian Spirit, Page 100 CHAPTER VI. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. The Industrial System of Antiquity rested upon Slavery- Effects of this Institution oa National Character— Decline of Industry in Rome— Comparison between Ancient and Modern Slavery— Atrocious Excesses to which the Empire arrived— Christianity undertook the Abolition of Slavery — Fh-st Movement in favour of the Slaves due to Seneca and his followers— Invasion of Barbarians favourable to Slaves— But Chris- tianity the most efiBcient opponent of the evil— Review of the Measures for abolish- ing Slavery — And for alleviating the condition of those who still continued enslaved — Anglo-Saxon measures— Services of the Fathers and the Benedictines in making La- bour honourable— The Ferocity of Manners corrected by the Creation of Charity- Long period that elapsed before the preeminent services of Christianity were in this respect appreciated — Great Development of Self-sacrifice — Deficiency of the Indus- trial Theory of the Church — Long continuance of Serfdom — Emancipation of the Towns begins Modern Industrial History — Effects of the Crusades on Industry — The System of Corporations politically useful though economically bad— Points of Con- tact of Industrial and Theological Enterprises — First ground of collision was Usury — The Principles that regulate Interest altogether unknown to the Ancients — Position of Money-lenders in Greece and Gaul — And in the Roman Empire — The Early and Mediaeval Church condemned all Interest — On the twofold ground of the Law of Na- ture and of Autl ority — Money-lending first monopolised by Jews — Rise of the Id- THE SECOND VOLUME. 9 dustrial Eepublics of Italy, makes it popular among Christians— Council of the Lat- eran — Eeformation shakes the Old Superstition — Saumaise — Change in the moaning of the word Usury in the Sixteenth Century— Casuistry of the Jesuits— Decree of Benedict 5IV. — Laws upon Usury based on Theological grounds, disappear — The Economical Question discussed by Locke, Adam Smith, Hume, Turgot, and Bentham— The Eussian Easkol the last Eepresentative of the Ancient Doctrine— Importance of this Controversy in producing an Antagonism between Industry and Theology— Com- merce produces a New Principle of Federation— Foundation of Consulships— Organi- sation of Diplomacy- Commerce leads to Intercourse -with Men of different Religions, and therefore to Tolerance — First class who benefited by this Tolerance, the Jews — Sketch of the different Persecutions of which they were the Object — Their Services to Literature— And to Commerce— Tolerated at Leghorn, Venice, Pisa, and Genoa- Industrial Habits of Thought make Men estimate lowly the Influence of Dogma- Injury Persecution has done to Industry — Spain, France, Bruges, and Amsterdam- Decline of the Ideal of Poverty produced by the Industrial Civilisation— Luxury of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries— Sumptuary Laws— Influence of the Black Death — Economical effects of Luxury — It is substituted for Monasticisci r.s ti Check upon Population— Its Influence on Intellectual Development— Decadence of Monastic Spirit — Alliance of the Clergy with the Aristocracy — Increase of Commerce— The Navigation Laws — First Mercantile Societies in England — "Wealth of Belgium — P>apid growth of Diplomacy— The Hanseatic League represses Piracy— The Venetians found Political Economy, and the Medici give an Intellectual Ascendency to Industry — Manner In which all this combined with the Eevival of Classic Learning- And with the Influence of Moorish Civilisation — Change of Tastes resulting from Increased Wealth revives the Theatre— Importance of this Amusement as an Intellectual In- fluence—And as an Index of the Condition of Civilisation— Its great Corruption in Pagan Eome — Denounced by the Fathers — The Last Eefuge of Paganism — Not en- couraged by Julian— Disappeared with the Dissolution of the Eoman Civilisation- New Types of Amusement— The ' Histriones ' of St. Thomas Aquinas— Else of the Eeligious Plays— Hroswltha— The Eellgious Plays pass from the Churches to the Theatres— Their Immorality— Position assigned to Satan— EflTect in bringing the Church into Contempt— Faint Signs of Secular Plays— Impromptus— Pantomimes, etc— The Farces — The higher Drama reappears in Italy— First Plays— Examples of its encouragement by Ecclesiastics— Contrast between the Italian and French Drama in their Eelation to the Church— The Secularisation of Music, its successive stages- Influence of Gothic Architecture upon the Stage— The Eeligious Struggle produces a Eevulsion in the Sentiments with which the Theatre was regarded- Fierce Opposition in France— Sacraments denied to Actors— Mollere, Eacine, Lully, Hucrne de la Mdcbo— Advance of Theatre in France, Spain, and Italy— Voltaii-e-Tho Eevolution removes Disqualifications from Actors— Triumph of the Theatre at Eome— Impor- tant effects of this Contest— The Creation of the Theatre the last Service of the In- dustrial Civilisation of Italy— The Eeformation— Importance of ths Question to which Eeligion the Sceptre of Industry would fall— It seemed at first in the grasp of 10 cojn'te:nts of the secojs^d volume Spain— Magnificent Position of Spain under Charles V.— The Economical En'or that Gold alone is Wealth — The Italians in a great measure escaped this — First conse- quence of this error in Spain, was that Manufactures were neglected, and all the na- tional energies were concentrated upon the Gold Mines— Second consequence, that the Colonies were ruined by Eestrietivo Laws — Third consequence, a Convulsion of Prices resulting indeed frjm the Excessive Supply of Gold, but aggravated by Lawa prohibiting its Export — These Economical Causes aggravated by the vast Develop- ment of the Monastic System — Its Incompatibility with Industry — And by the Eevi- val of Slavery— Las Casas— And by four great acts of Eeligious Intolerance — The Downfall of Spain an almost unmingled Benefit to Mankind— Introduction of Hot Drinks into Europe, their Moral and Social EiTects- On the Downfall of Spain tho Sceptre of Industry passes to Protestantism, but the Influence of the two Eeligions ceased to be involved in the Contest— Antagonism of Intellectual Tendency between Town and Country— Changes that have been effected in their Eclative Importance — Mediaeval preference for Agriculture— Schoo. of Sully— Superseded by the Mercan- tile Theory which was more favourable to Manufactm-es — Colbert — The School of Quesnay which followed was theoretically extremely unfavourable to Manufactures, but practically favourable to it— Modification of this School by Eaynal— Adam Smith proves Manufactures to be a Som'ce of Wealth — But maintains the superior Produc- tivity of Agriculture— Eefuted on this last point by Eicardo — Movement in favour of Manufactures stimulated by the Invention of Credit— And by the Development of Machinery — Economical effects of Machines — Special Force of their Influence in England— The Intellectual Expression of an Industrial Civilisation is Political Econ- omy—Its Pacific Influence— Theological Agencies not pacific- xind Philosophical ones inefficient — Effects of Political Economy in uniting different Countries — And different Classes— Effects of the Principle of Interest upon the AfFections— The Phi- losophy of Mortification and the Philosophy of Development represented respectively by Asceticism and Industrialism— Asceticism supreme till the Fourteenth Century— The History of Monasteries shows its steady Decline — Position assigned by Industrial- ism to Wealth— the Destruction of Asceticism among the Ancient Greeks due to Art ; among the Moderns, to Industry — Intellectual Influences favourable to Industrialism — Utilitarianism the Philosophical Expression of Industrialism — Evils resulting from this Philosophy — Decline of the Spirit of Self-Sacriflce — Tendency to Material- ism— Conclusion, ........ Page 223 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. CHAPTER lY. {continued^). ON PERSECUTION. Part II. THE mSTORY OF PERSECUTION. The considerations I have adduced in the first 2>art of this chapter will be sufficient to show how injurious hare been the eflects of the doctrine of exclusive salvation. We have still, however, one consequence to examine, before which all others fade into insignificance. I mean, of course, re- ligious persecution. This, which is perhaps the most fearful of all the evils that men have inflicted upon their fellows, is the direct practical result of the principles we have hitherto considered in their speculative aspect. If men believe with an intense and realising faith that their own view of a dis- [juted question is true beyond all possibility of mistake, if they further believe that those who adopt other views will be doomed by the Almighty to an eternity of misery which, with the same moral disposition but with a difierent belief, they Avould have escaped, these men will, sooner or later, 12 RATIONALISM DT EUROPE. persecute to the full extent of their power. If you speak to thera of the physical and mental suffering which persecution produces, or of the sincerity and unselfish heroism of its victims, they will reply that such arguments rest altogether on the inadequacy of your realisation of the doctrine they believe. What suffering that man can inflict can be compar- able to the eternal misery of all Avho embrace the doctrine ot the heretic ? What claim can human virtues have to our for- bearance, if the Almighty punishes the mere profession of error as a crime of the deepest turpitude ? If you encoun- tered a lunatic who, in his frenzy, w^as inflicting on multi- tudes around him a death of the most prolonged and ex- cruciating agony, would you not feel justified in arresting his cai-eer by every means in your power — by taking his life if you could not otherwise attain your object ? But if you knew that this man was inflicting not temporal but eternal death, if he was not a guiltless though dangerous madman, but one whose conduct you believed to involve the most heinous criminality, would you not act with still less com- punction or hesitation?^ Arguments from expediency, though they may induce men under some sjtecial circum- stances to refrain from persecuting, will never make them adopt the principle of toleration. In the first i^lace, those who believe that the religious service of the heretic is an act positively offensive to the Deity, will always feel disposed to put down that act if it is in their power, even though they cannot change the mental disposition from which it springs. In the next place, they will soon perceive that the interven- ' As St. Thomas Aquinas says, ' Si falsarii pecuniaj vel alii malefactores statim per seculares principes juste morti traduntur, multo magis h^retici statim, ex quo de haeresi eonvincuntur, possunt non solum excommunicari sed o', juste occidi.' (Summa, pars ii. qu. si. art. iii.) ON PERSECUTIOX, 13 tion ol the ci\il ruler can exercise almost as much influence upon belief as upon profession. For although there is indeed a certain order and sequence in the history of opinions, as in the phases of civilisation it reflects, which cannot be alto- gether destroyed, it is not the less true that man can greatly accelerate, retard, or modify its course. The opinions of ninety-nine persons out of every hundred aie formed mainly by education, and a Government can decide in whose hands the national education is to be placed, what subjects it is to comprise, and what principles it is to convey. The opinions of the great majoi'ity of those who emancipate themselves from the prejudices of their education are the re- sults in a great measure of reading and of discussion, and a Government can prohibit all books and can expel all teachers that are adverse to the doctrines it holds. Indeed, the sim- ple fact of annexing certain penalties to the profession of par- ticular opinions, and rewards to the profession of opposite opinions, while it will undoubtedly make many hypocrites, "will also make many converts. For any one who attentive- ly observes the process that is pursued in the formation of opinions must be aware that, even when a train of argument has preceded their adoption, they are usually much less the result of pare reasoning than of the action of innumerable distorting influences which are continually deflecting our judgments. Among these one of the most powerful is self- interest. When a man desires very earnestly to embrace a certain class of doctrines, either in order to join a particular profession, or to please his friends, or to acquire peace of mind, or to rise in the world, or to gratify his j)assions, or to gain that intellectual reputation which is sometimes con- nected with the profession of certain opinions, he will usual- ly attain his desire. He may pursue his enquiry in tlie most 14 HATIOJ^ALISM m EUKOPE. conscientious spirit. He may be firmly resolved to make any sacrifice rather than profess what lie does not believe, yet still his aifections will endow their objects Avith a magnetism of which he is perhaps entirely unconscious. He will reason not to ascertain what is true, but to ascertain whether ho can conscientiously affirm certain opinions to be true. He will insensibly withdraw his attention from the objections on one side, and will concentrate it with disproportionate energy upon the other. He will preface every conclusion by an ar- gument, but the nature of that argument will be determined by the secret bias of his Avill. If, then, a Government can act upon the wishes of a people, it can exercise a considerable influence upon their reason. Such are some of the arguments by which the persecutor in the earlier stages of Christian history might have defend- ed his acts. And surely the experience of later times has fully corroborated his view by showing that, in the great conflicts between argument and persecution, the latter has been continually triumphant. Persecution extirpated Chris- tianity from Japan ; it crushed the fair promise of the Albi- genses ; it rooted out every vestige of Protestantism from Spain. France is still ostensibly, and was long in truth, the leading champion of Catholicity, but the essential Catholicity of France was mainly due to the massacre of St. Bartholomew and the revocation of the Edict of Nantes. England is just- ly esteemed the chief pillar of Protestantism, yet the English l^eople remained long poised indecisively between the tAvo creeds till the skilful jjolicy and the coercive laws of Eliza- beth determined its vacillations. At the Reformation al- most every Government prohibited one or other religion; and whereas the members of the State religion formed at first but a doubtful and wavering majority, and sometime? ON PEKSECUTION. 15 not even a majority, a few generations produced substantial unanimity ; and since the policy of coercion has been general- ly abandoned, and the freest scope been given for discussion, the relative position of Protestants and Catholics has not been perceptibly changed. Before such broad and patent facts as these, the few ex- ceptions that may be adduced can have no great weight; and even those exceptions, when carefully examined, will often be found far less real than is supposed. Thus, for example, the case of Ireland is continually cited. The Irish Catholics, we are told, Avere subject at first to a system of open plunder, and then to a long detailed legal persecution * which was de- signed to make them abandon their faith. All the paths of honour and Avealth were monopolised by Protestants, while shackles of every description hampered the Catholics in all the relations of life. Yet these only clung the closer to their faith on account of the storms that assailed it. That very acute observer, Arthur Young, declared at the close of the penal laws, that the relative proportion of Catholics to Prot- estants had not been at all reduced — if anything rather the reverse — and that those who denied this admitted that, at the j)ast rate of conversions, 4,000 years would be required to make Ireland Protestant. In the Irish Parliament it was stated that Vl years of the penal system had only produced 4,055 converts. This statement may at first sight appear to furnish an extremely strong argument, but it completely omits the most important element of Irish ecclesiastical history. In Ireland the old faith marked the division between two * For their details see Parnell, Penal Laws. lu common parlance, the * penal laws ' date from the treaty of Limerick, but the legislative assaults on Irish Catholicism be^an with Elizabeth. 16 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. races, it Avas the symbol of the national spirit, it was upheld by all the passions of a great patriotic struggle, and its con- tinuance simply attests Ihe vitality of a political sentiment. When every other northern nation abandoned Catholicism, the Irish still retained it out of antipathy to their oppressors, and in every great insurrection the actuating spirit was mainly political. Of all the outbreaks against the English power, that of 1640 was probably the most passionate and most vindicti\-c. In tliat rebellion one Englishman of dis- tinction was exempt from the hostility that attached to his race. He was treated Avith the most resj^ectful and even af- fectionate deference, and when he died, he was borne to the grave with all the honours the rebel army could afford. That Englishman was Bishop Bedell, the counsellor of Sarpi and of De Dominis, and the founder of proselytism in Ire- land.' Sucli was the spirit that was displayed by the Irish Catho- lics in the lujdst of one of their most ferocious outbreaks ; and surely no one who is acquainted with the history of Ire- land since the Union will imagine that the repeal of the per- secuting code has in any degree mitigated their zeal. While their influence in the State has been immeasurably augmented, while their number has inci'eased with a rapidity that was only broken by the frightful famine and emigration that more than decimated their ranks, the sectarian spmt that actuates them has become continually more conspicuous. It ' The very curious life of Bedell, by his son-in-law, Alexander Clogy, whicli was written in 1641-2, and which formed the basis of the Barrative of Burnet, was printed from the IISS. in the British Museum in ISC'2. Wo have au amus- ing instance of the uncompromising Protestantism of Bedell in the foct that when the insurgents who retained him prisoner gave him permission to perform the Anglican service freely with his friends, he availed himself of that permissios to celebrate the thanksgiving for the 5th of November. ON PERSECUTION. 17 may indeed he truly said that Ireland is now the only civilised country where public opinion is governed, not occasionally hut habitually, by theological considerations, where the most momentous secular interests are continually subordinated to the conflicts of rival clergy, and where there is scarcely a chord of purely patriotic feeling that vibrates in the national breast. The causes of this deplorable condition I have not now to investigate.' It is sufficient to say that it exists in spite of the abi'Ogation of the persecuting laws. If there was one secular question which the Irish Catholics pursued with an intense and genuine ardour, it was the struggle for the repeal of the Union. For a long series of years they maintained that struggle with a combination of enthusiasm, of perseverance, and of self-sacrifice, such as has been seldom evinced in a political contest ; and they invaria- bly based their claim on the broad principle that the form of government in any country should be determined by the majority of its inhabitants. But no sooner had that princi- ple come into collision with the Church, no sooner had its triumph menaced the security of the Vatican, and wrested two provinces from the Pope, than all this Avas changed. The teaching of Davis and of O'Connell was at once for- gotten. The bond that had so long connected the Irish Catholics with liberalism was broken, and the whole party pressed forward, with an alacrity that would be ludicrous if it were not pitiable, to unite themselves with the most retro- gressive politicians in Europe, and to discard and trample on the principles they had so long and so enthusiastically maintained. These considerations show that the intense energy of Irish * I have endeavoured to trace them in a book called The Leaders of Pub- lic Opinion in Ireland. VOL. n.— 28 18 KATIONALISM IN EUEOT'E. Catholicism cannot be altogether attributed to religious perse- cution. Much the same qualification may be applied to the case of the English dissenters. The Anglican Church, it is some- times said, persecuted with great cruelty those who separated from her ecclesiastical government; yet, nevertheless, the dissenters became so powerful that they shattered both the Church and the Crown, and brought the king and the Arch- bishop of Canterbury to the scaffold. But this is a palpable misrepresentation. The extreme servility which the English Church manifested to the most tyrannical of sovereigns, and the bitter persecution it dii-ected against all adverse com- munions, had together made Puritanism the i-epresentative and the symbol of democracy. The rebellion was simply the outburst of political liberalism, intensified, indeed, but by no means created, by the exasj)eration of the dissenters. It represented the hatred of political tyranny much more than the hatred of episcopacy. After two or three fluctuations, a period arrived when the Church of England was greatly depressed, and the Toleration Act was passed, which, though very defective in theory, accorded a large measure of jDracti- cal liberty to all classes of dissenters. Those who maintain that persecution can only strengthen the system against which it is directed, might have expected that this act would have produced a diminution of dissent, or, at least, a relaxa- tion of its jjrinciples. But the result was precisely opposite. About the time when the act was passed, the dissenters were estimated at rather more than one twenty-third of the popu- lation of England ; less than a century after they Avere esti- mated at one-fourth.* In zeal the Methodists will bear com- parison with the Puritans, and if the animosity between Anglicans and dissenters is mitigated, this has not been * See a note iu Buckle, History of CiviHsadon, vol. i. p. 38o ON PEESECUTION. 19 because dissent has been attracted to the Church, but because the Church has been penetrated by the doctrines of dissent. The foregoing arguments appear to me to prove, not, indeed, that persecution is a good thing, or even that it can invariably eifect the object for which it is employed, but that it has, as a matter of fact, exercised an enormous influence over the belief of mankind. The two main causes of theological changes seem to be the appearance from time to time of great religious teachers, and the succession of the phases of civili- sation. The first cast abroad the seeds of religious truth ; the second provide the different atmospheres by which those seeds are in turn developed. But, while this law is producing a continual modification of opinions, whicb is more or less felt through the entire community, it leaves free scope for the operation of many minor influ.ences, which cause in the same period a considerable diversity of realised belief, and a still greater diversity of profession. Of these influences, the intervention of government is probably tlie most powerful. It is certainly far more powerful than any direct polemical discussion. Millions of devoted Catholics and millions of devoted Protestants would, at the present hour, repudiate indignantly their present belief but for the coercive enact- ments of former rulers ; and there is scarcely a country in which the prevailing faith is not in some degree due to bygone legislation. But whether or not this be true is, in reality, immaterial to my argument ; for, however strongly the reader may deny the efficacy of persecution upon belief, it is certain that until lately it was deemed indisputable. It is also certain that, in ages when the doctrine of exclusive salvation is fully realised, the spirit of faith will be so exalted that the ruler will never question for a moment the justice MO EATIOFALISM IN EUKOPE. of his belief. Now, when men are firmly convinced that the highest of all possible objects is to promote the interests of their faith, and that by the employment of force they can most fully attain that object, their j^ersecution will be measured by their power and their zeal.' These are the general logical antecedents of persecution, and they are quite sufficient to account for all its atrocities, without imputing any sordid motives to the persecutor. There is, however, one other consideration that exercised a very important influence in the same direction — ^I mean the example of the Jewish legislators. When we now read of such scenes as the massacres of Canaan, the slaughter of the priests of Baal, or the forcible reforms of Josiah, they can scarcely be said to pi-esent themselves to the mind as having any very definite application to the present. Those who do not regard them as the natural products of an imperfect civ- ilisation, regard them at least as belonging to a disj)ensation so entirely excej)tional as to be removed altogether from the ordinary conditions of society. But in the early Church, and in the sixteenth century, they were looked upon in a very different light. The relations of an established religion to the State were mainly derived from the Old Testament. The Jewish w^as deemed a type of the Christian Church, and the policy that was commended in the one was regarded as at least not blamable in the other. Now the Levitical code was the first code of religious persecution that had ever appeared among mankind. It pronounced idolatry to be not • This was the opinion expressed by Charles James Fox. 'The only foundation for toleration,' he said, 'is a degree of scepticism, and without it there can be none. For if a man believes in the saving of souls, he must soon think about the means ; and if by cutting off one generation he can save many future ones from hell fire, it is his duty to do it.' (Rogers, Ileollcdions, D. 49.) ON PERSECUTION. 21 simply an error, but a crime, and a crime that must be expiated with blood. ^ The opinions of the Fathers on the subject were divided. Those who wrote when a pagan or heretical power was su- preme were the champions of toleration. Those who wrot^- when the Church was in the ascendency usually inclined to persecution. Tertullian during the pagan,^ and Hilary of Poitiers during the Arian' persecution, were the most con- spicuous advocates of the duty of absolute and complete tol- eration ; and several passages tending, though less strongly, in the same direction, emanated from other Fathers during seasons of adversity.* It should, however, be mentioned that Lactantius, in the reign of Constantino, asserted the iniquity of persecution quite as strongly as any previous writer,* and ^ On the influence of this command on Christian persecution, see Bayle, Contrains-les d^enlrer, pt. ii. ch. iv., and some striking remarks in Kenan, Vie de Jesus, pp. 412, 413 ; to which I may add as an illustration the following passage of Simancas : — ' Hajretici pertinaces publice in conspectu populi com- burendi sunt ; et id fieri solet extra portas civitatis : quemadmodum olim, in Deut. cap. xvii., idolatra educebatur ad portas civitatis, et lapidibus obrue- batur.' {De Catliol. Instil, p. 3Y5.) Tayloi", in noticing this argument, finely says that Christ, by refusing to permit his apostles to call down fire like Elias on the misbeliver, clearly indicated his separation from the intolerance of Judaism. {Liberty of Prophesying, sec. 22.) " Apol. cap. xxlv. ' Ad Aiixentium. ■• The reader may find a full statement of the passages from the Fathers fiivourable to toleration in Whitby, On Laws against Heretics (1723, published anonymously) ; Taylor, Liberty of Prophesying ; Bayle, Contrains-lcs d'entrer; and many other books. The other side of the question has been developed, among other writers, by Palmer, On the Church ; Muzzarelli, Simancas, Para- mo, and all the other old writers on the Inquisition. There is, I think, an im- partial view of the whole subject in Milman, History of Christianity. Sec, too, Blackstone's Commentaries, b. iv. ch. iv. * Jnst. lib. V. c. XX. Lactantius embraced Christianity during tlie persecu- tion of Diocletian, but it appears almost certain that his ListitiUions were mainly written, or at least published, at Treves during the reign of Constan- tine, and he never abandoned the tolerant maxims he proclaimed. This was 22. EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. also that the later Fathers, while defending the milder forms of coercion, seldom or never wished death to be the penalty of heresy. In this resjDect the orthodox seem to have been for a time honourably distinguished from the Arians. On one occasion in the reign of the Arian emperor Valens, no less than eighty Catholic ecclesiastics were imprisoned in a ship at sea and treacherously burnt.' Still, from the very moment the Church obtained civil power under Constantine, the general principle of coercion was admitted and acted on both against the Jews, the here- tics, and the pagans. The first had at this time become es- pecially obnoxious, on account of a strong Judaising move- ment which had produced one or two heresies and many aj)ostasies, and they were also accused of assailing ' with stones and other manifestations of rage' those who aban- doned their faith. Constantine provided against these evils by a law, in which he condemned to the flames any Jew who especially creditable to him, as he was tutor to the son of Constantine, and consequently singularly tempted to avail himself of the arm of power. Un- fortunately, this very eloquent writer, who was certainly one of the ablest in the early Church, possessed comparatively little influence on account of his passion for paradox. He maintained that no Christian might engage in war- fare, or execute a capital sentence ; he was one of the strongest assertors of the opinion that God the Father had a figure (a controversy raised by Origen), and he was accused of denying the personaUty of the Holy Ghost. ' Lactan- tius,' said Jerome, 'quasi quidam fluvius eloqucntioe TuUiancB, utinam tarn nostra confirmare potuisset, quam facile aliena destruxit ! ' {Epist lib. ii. epist. 14). The works of Lactantius were condemned by a council presided over liy Pope Gelasius in the 5th century. See Alexandri, Hist. Ecclesiastica (Paris, 1699), tom. iv. pp. 100-103 ; Ampere, Hiit. Littiraire de la France, tom. i. pp. 218-223. Some of the peculiar notions of Lactantius appeared at a later period among the Waldenses. ^ Socrates, hb. iv. c. xvi. The Donatists were also fierce persecutors, and Nestorius showed his sentiments clearly enough when he said to the Emperor, ' Give me the earth purged from heretics, and I will give you heaven.' The Spanish Arians seem to have originated the intense intolerance that has been perpetuated from generation to generation in Spain. ON PERSECUTION. 23 threw stones at a Christian convert, and at the same time ren- dered it penal for any Christian to become a Jew/ Against the Arian and Donatist heretics his measures were more en- ergetic. Their churches were destroyed, their assemblies were forbidden, their bishops banished, their writings burnt, and all who concealed those writings threatened with death. Some of the Donatists were actually condemned to death, but the sentence was remitted, and any blood that was at this time shed seems to have been due to the excessive turbulence of the Circumcelliones, a sect of Donatists whose princij)les and acts appear to have been perfectly incompatible with the tranquillity of the State." The policy of Constantine towards the pagans is involved in considerable obscurity, and I have already in a former chapter sketched its princij)al features. During the first years of his reign, while the ascendency of Christianity was very doubtful, and while the pagan Licinius was still his colleague in the empire, he showed marked tolerance towards the ad- herents of the old superstitions ; and when his law against private or magical sacrifices had created a considerable panic among them, he endeavoured to remove the impression by a ' Cod. Theod. lib. xvi. tit. 8. The apostate 'sustinebit meritas pcenas,' Constantius afterwards made the penalty confiscation of goods. A Jew who married a Christian incurred the penalty of death. See, on this department of legislation, Bedarride, Hist, des Juifs, pp. 16-20. ^ Milman, History of Christianity, vol. ii. pp. 372-375. See also the re- view of these measures in Palmer, On the Church, vol. ii. p. 250. The Arians had to pay ten times the taxes of the orthodox. The first law that has come down to us, in which the penalty of death is annexed to the simple profession of a heresy, is law 9 De Hceretids in the Theodosian Code. It was made by Iheodosius the Great, and was applicable only to some sects of Manichseans. It is worthy of notice that this is also the first law in which we meet the title of ' Inquisitors of the Faith.' Optatus in the reign of Constantine advocated the massacre of the Donatists on the ground of the Old Testament precedents (see Milman). 24 RATIONALISM EST EUROPE. proclamatioa in which he authorised in the most express terms the worship in the temples.^ Besides this, he still re- tained the old imperial title of Pontifex Maximus," and does not appear to have altogether discarded the functions it im- plied. As, however, his position became more strong, and especially after the defeat of Licinius in 324, he gradually changed his policy. By forbidding the prefects and govern- ors to pay any respect to the idols, he jilaced the govern- ment of the provinces in Christian hands.' About 330, he went still further, and if we believe the unanimous testimony of the ecclesiastical historians, he prohibited the temple wor- ship. This enactment has not come down to us, but the pro- hibition is expressly and unequivocally asserted by both Eu- sebius, Sozomen, and Theodoret,* and Libanius tells us that the penalty of holdmg converse with the old gods was death.^ Eusebius notices some temples that were at this time closed, and speaks of similar measures as being very common ; but, at the same time, we have decisive evidence that the pagan '■ ' Addite aras publicas atque delubra, et consuetudinis vestras celebrate solemnia : nee enim prohibemus preterita) usurpationis ofScia libera luce trac- tari.'— CoJ. Th. lib. ix. tit. 16, cc. i. ii. - The first emperor who refused it was Gratian (Zosimus, book iv.). ^ Eusebius, Vita Const, lib. ii. c. xliv. xlv. * See Eusebius, Vita Const, lib. ii. c. xliv. xlv., lib. iv. c. xxiii. ; Theodoret, lib. vi. c. xxi. ; Sozomen, lib. iii. c. xvii. Eusebius repeats this assertion over and over again ; see Milman, History of Christianity, vol. ii. pp. 460-464 (ed. 1840). * Speaking of his youtli, Libanius says : ' Plus apud Deos quam apuQ homines in terra convresabatur, tametsi lex prohiberet, quam audenti violare capitis poena fuit. Verumtamen cum illis ipsis vitam agens et iuiquam legem et impium logislatorem derideba*.' {De Vita sua, Libanii Opera [ed. 1627], vol. ii. p. 11.) However in his oration Pro I'emplis, Libanius says distinctly that Constantine did not disturb the worship of the temples. It is hard to re- concile these two passages and the last with the statements of Eusebius, but I suppose the '"act is that the law was made, but was generally suffered to be liiopcrative. ON PEESECUTIOX. 25 worship was connived at in many and probably most parts of the empire, that temples were dedicated, and the ceremo- nies performed without molestation or concealment/ It is only by taking into account the extreme laxity of the admin- istration of law at this period of Roman history, that we can estimate aright the position of the pagans. The govern- ment was strongly hostile to their faith, but was as yet re- strained by their numbers; the habitual policy was therefore gradually to destroy their jDolitical importance, and by laws dii-ected ostensibly against magic to suppress those portions of worship which were not indeed the essentials, but formed what may be called the religious luxui'ies of paganism. Other and more stringent laws were made, but they were generally in abeyance, or at least their execution depended upon political circumstances, or upon the disposition of the governors. Constantius made laws distinctly prohibiting every form of pagan worship,' but yet there is no fact more certain than that this worship continued till the period of Theodosius.' ^ See a great deal of evidenc3 of this ia Beugaot, Decadence du Poly- fheisme. But it is absurd to speak of Constantine, as M. Beugnot does, as an apostle of tolerance. ' Connivance,' as Burke once said, ' is the relaxation of tyranny, and not the definition of liberty.' One of Constantine's proclama- tions of tolerance seems to have been posterior to the prohibition of public sacrifices. ' Cod. Th. xvi. 10, 2-4. The terms of one of these laws seem to imply that Constantine had made a similar enactment : ' Cesset superstitio : sacrifi- ciorum aboleatur insania. Nam quicunque contra legem divi Principis Paren- tis nostrl, et hanc nostris mansuetudinis jussionem, ausus fuerit sacrificia celebrare, competens in eum vindicta et pr^sens sententia exeratur.' For a full discussion of this very perplexing subject see Milman, Hist, of Christian- tfi/, and Gibbon, ch. xxi. " Thus, for example, the pagan Zosimus tells us expressly that in the begin- ning of the reign of Theodosius his coreligionists were still at liberty to wor- hip in the temples. The history is in a great measure a repetition of that of the persecution which the Christians had themselves endured. Generally they iiQ KATIONALISM IN EUROPE, It is not necessary to follow in detail the persecuting laws of tlie first century of the Church's power, and indeed Buch a task Avould be intolerably tedious on account of the activity that was displayed in this department of legislation. The Theodosian Code, which was compiled under Theodo- sius the younger, contains no less than sixty-six enactments against heretics, besides many others against pagans, Jews, apostates, and magicians. It is sufficient to say that at first the Arian measures seem to have been rather more severe than the Catholic ones, but that the scope of the latter was steadily enlarged, and their severity increased, till they reached a point that has seldom been surpassed. First the pagans were deprived of offices in the State ; then their secret sacri- fices were prohibited; then every kind of divination Avas for- bidden; then the public sacrifices were suppressed; and finally tlie temples were destroyed, their images broken, and the entire worship condemned.^ The enforcement of these measures in the country districts was the last, the most diffi- cult, and the most melancholy scene of the drama. For in those days, when means of communication were very few and ignorance very general, it was quite possible for a re- ligious movement to gain a comj^lete ascendency in the towns while the peasants Avere scarcely aware of its existence. In their calm retreats the paroxysms of change were seldom felt. They still continued with unfaltering confidence to worship the old gods when a new faith had attracted the educated to its Banner, or when scepticism was withering the beliefs of the past. Multitudes had probably scarcely bad been allowed freely to celebrate their worship, but from that time, either through popular indignation or imperial suspicions, there were sudden out- bursts of fearful persecution. ' See the laws De Templis. ON PEESECUTION. 27 realised the existence of Christianity when the edict arrived which doomed their temples to destruction. Libanius, who, as the minister of Julian, had exhibited a spirit of tolerance even more remarkable than that of his master, pleaded the peasants' cause with coui'age, dignity, and pathos. The tem- ple, he said, was to them the very eye of nature, the symbol and manifestation of a present Deity, the solace of all their troubles, the holiest of all their joys. If it was overthrown, their dearest associations would be annihilated. The tie that linked them to the dead would be severed. The poetry of life, the consolation of labour, the source of faith would be destroyed.' • But these pl-eas were unavailing. Under Theodosius the Great all the temples were razed to the ground, and all forms of pagan and heretical Avorship abso- lutely prohibited.'' Such was the persecuting spirit displayed by the Chris- tians of the fourth and fifth centuries. It is both interesting and important to observe how far it was the consequence of a theological development, and what were the stages of that development. The noble protests against persecution which the persecuted prelates had uttered form indeed a striking contrast to the measures I have related ; but, unfortunately, new circumstances j)roduce new opinions, and when the bias of the will is altered, a change will soon be manifested in the judgment. Still, in justice to the persecutors, it must be admitted that they were but the logical exponents of princi- ples that had before existed in the Church. These principles ' Fro Tcmplis. ' It is said, however, that, notwithstanding these laws, tlie Novatians (prob- ably on account of the extremely slight difference that separated them from the orthodox) were allowed to celebrate their worship till a.d. 525, when the Bishop of Rome succeeded in procuring their suppression. (Taylor, Liberty of Prophenyinc;, epistle dedicatory.) 28 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. were the doctrine of" exclusive salvation, and the conceptions of the guilt of error and of ecclesiastical authority. It is very remarkable, too, that even before Constantius some theolo- gians had begun to deduce their rule of conduct towards heretics from the penal enactments of the Levitical law. To excommunicate the heretic was, they said, to consign him to eternal damnation ; and they were justified in inflicting this frightful punishment upon those "who rebelled against their authority, because the ancient idolater had been punished W'ith death.' From such a doctrine there was but a step to persecution. The premises were already formed ; it only re- mained to draw the obvious conclusion. There cannot, I think, be much doubt that the minds of the leaders of the Church were so prepared by these modes of thought, that the eulogies which Eusebius unceasingly lavishes upon the j)ersecuting edicts of Constantine were a faithful expression of their sentiments. But the writer who was destined to consolidate the whole system of persecution, to furnish the arguments of all its later defenders, and to give to it the sanction of a name that long silenced every ' ' Neither let those who refuse to obey their bishops and priests think ■within themselves that they are in the way of life and of salvation, for the Lord God says in Deuteronomy, " Whoever will act presumptuously, and will not hear the priest or the judge, whoever he may be in those days, he shall die, and the people will hear and fear, and do no more presumptuously." God commanded those to be slain who would not obey the priests or the judges set over them for a time. Then, indeed, they were slain with the sword while the carnal circumcision still remained ; but now, since the spiritual circumcision has begun amid the servants of God, the proud and contumacious are killed when they are cast out of the Church. For they cannot Uve without it ; for the house of God is one, and there can be salvation for no one except in the Church.' (Cypriaui Epist, lib. i. ep. 11.) That excommunication is a severer penalty than death, and that the Church, having the power of inflicting the first, may also inflict the second, was one of the arguments of Bellarmiuo in favour of persecution, and was answered by Taylor, Liberty of rrophcsying, sec. 14. ON PEESECIJTIO^J. 29 pleading of mercy, and became the glory and the watchword of every persecutor, was viuqiiestionably Augustine, on whom more than any other theologian — more perhaps even than on Dominic and Innocent — rests the resj)onsibility of this fear- ful curse. A sensualist and a Manicha?an, a philosopher and a theologian, a saint of the most tender and exquisite piety, and a siipporter of atrocious persecution, the life of this Father exhibits a strange instance of the combination of the most discordant agencies to the development of a single mind, and of the influence of that mind over the most conflicting inter- ests. Neither the unbridled passions of his youth, nor the extravagances of the heresy he so long maintained, could cloud the splendour of his majestic intellect, which was even then sweeping over the whole field of knowledge, and ac- quiring in the most unpropitious spheres new elements of strength. In the arms of the frail beauties of Carthage, he learned to touch the chords of passion with consummate skill ; and the subtleties of Persian metaphysics, the awful problems of the origin of evil and of the essence of the soul which he vainly sought to fathom, gave him a sense of the darkness around us that coloured every j)ortion of his teach- ing. The weight and compass of his genius, his knowledge both of men and of books, a certain aroma of sanctity that imparted an inexpressible charm to all his later writings, and a certain impetuosity of character that overbore every ob- stacle, soon made him the master intellect of the Church. Others may have had a larger share in the construction of her formularies — no one since the days of the apostles in- fused into her a larger measure of his spirit. He made it his mission to map out her theology with inflexible precision, to develop its principles to their full consequences, and to coordinate its various parts into one authoritative and sym- 30 KATIONALISM IN EUROPE. metrical whole. Impatient of doubt, he shrank from no con- clusion, however unpalatable ; he seemed to exult in tram- pling human instincts in the dust, and in accustoming men to accept submissively the most revolting tenets. He was the most staunch and enthusiastic defender of all those do'ctrines that grow out of the habits of mind that lead to persecution. No one else had developed so fully the material character of the torments of hell, no one else had plunged so deeply into the speculations of predestinarianisra, very few had dwelt so emphatically on the damnation of the unbaptised. For a time he shrank from, and even condemned, persecution ; but he soon perceived in it the necessary consequence of his princi- j)les. He recanted his condemnation; he flung his whole genius into the cause ; he recurred to it again and again ; and he became the framer and the representative of the theology of intolerance.* Strange indeed has been the destiny of this man ! The most illustrious of his contemporaries, in a few centuries, lost their ascendency. Their names, indeed, still continued in honour, their works Avei'e read by monkish scholars, but changing modes of thought and feeling soon isolated them from the sympathies of mankind. Alone by the power of his genius, Augustine traversed the lapse of ages with un- fading influence ; but he survived to be the watchword of the most opposing doctrines, the promoter alike of the best and worst sentiments of our nature. From his teaching con- cerning imputed righteousness, predestinarianism, and good works, the Protestants drew their most powerful weapons. In the intolerant rigidity of his doctrines, in his exaltation ^ See his Retract, lib. ii. c. v. ; E^nst. xciii. (in some editions xlviii.) cxxvii. clxxxY. ; Contra Gaudentium, c. xxv. ; Contra Epiid. Farmeniani, c. vii. There are many other passages on the subject scattered through his writings. ON PEESECUTION-. 31 of authority, and in the imperious character of his genius, CathoHcism recognised her most faithful type. Both sects found in his writings the purest expressions of their religious sentiments, and both sheltered their intolerance beneath his name. The arguments by which Augustine suj)ported persecution were, for the most part, those which I have already stated. Some of them were drawn from the doctrine of exclusive sal- vation, and others from the precedents of the Old Testament. It was merciful, he contended, to punish heretics, even by death, if this could save them or others from the eternal suffering that awaited the unconverted. Heresy was de- scribed in Scripture as a kind of adultery; it was the worst species of murder, being the murder of souls ; it was also a form of plaaphemy ; and on all these grounds might justly be punished. If the New Testament contained no examples of the apostles employing force, this was simply because in their time no priest had embraced Christianity. But had not Elijah slaughtered with his own hand the prophets of Baal? Did not Hezekiah, and Josiah, and the king of Nineveh, and Nebuchadnezzar after his conversion, destroy by foi'ce idolatry within their dominions, and were they not expressly commended for their piety ? St. Augustine also seems to have originated the application of the w^ords, ' Compel them to enter in,' to religious persecution.' It is, however, worthy of remark, that although Augustine defended the measures that had been taken against the Donatists, and although he maintained that heresy was the worst of crimes, and that it should be punished according to its enormity, he still, with an amiable inconsistency, exerted himself much to prevent the penalty from being capital. He Epist, 1. Bonifacio 32 RATIONALISM LST EUEOPE. exhorted, he even commanded as a hishop, those in authority to restrict it to banishment; he threatened, if they refused to do so, that the bishops would cease to inform against heretics ; and he laboured not unsuccessfully to save the lives of some who were condemned.^ In this respect the manner in which heretics and pagans were treated presents a re- markable contrast. In a passage which occurs in one of his letters to the Donatists, St. Augustine informs us of two striking facts. The iirst is, that, in his time, the sentence of death was incurred by any one who celebrated the rites of the religion which had a few centui'ies before been universal in the empire. The second is, that this sentence was unan- imously apj)lauded in the Christian Church.^ y The reluctance of the clergy to sanction the deatli of heretics for a long time coexisted with the most earnest desire to suj^press their worship by force, and to banish their teach- ers from the emj)ire. The first execution of heretics in which ecclesiastics took any part seems to have been in a.d. 385, ' See especially Ep'isi. c. clvili. elix. clx. On the other hand, Augustine bases the right of punishing heresy on the enormity of the crime, which he considered greater than any other. (^Contra Gaudentium, lib. i. c. xix.) He assimilates heresy to blasphemy, and says that blasphemy is justly punished by death. {Epist. cv., otherwise clxvi.) He adduces as applicable precedents all the worst Old Testament persecutions, and he defends the condemnation of some Donatists to death by Constantine, on the ground of justice, though he applauds on the ground of mercy the remission of the sentence. (^Contra Parmcniamim, lib. i. c. viii.) His general view seems to have been that here- tics might justly be punished by death, but that the orthodox should not exact strict justice. However, he vacillated a good deal, and both moderate and exti-eme persecutors find much in their defence in his writings. Eehgious hb- erty he emphatically cursed. ' Quid est enim pejor mors animEe quam libertas erroris ? ' {Bjnst. clxvi.) ^ ' Quis enim nostrxun, quis vestrum non laudat leges ab imperatoribus datas contra sacrificia paganorum ? Et certe longe ibi poena severior consti- tuta est; illius quippe impietatis capitale supplicium est.' {Epist. xciii., in some editions xcviii.) See Gibbon, ch. xxviii. ON PEKSECUTION. 33 when some Priscillianists were put to death at the instigation of two ohscure hishops named TJrsatius and Ithacus. St. Ambrose, thongh one of the most active in procuring the suppression of the Jewish and jiagan worship, protested strongly against this act; and St, Martin of Tours de- nounced it with almost passionate vehemence as an atrocious crime, and refused to hold any communion with the offend- ing hishops.' The indignation that was excited on this occasion resulted, perhaps, hardly so much from the fact that heretics had been put to death, as from the part the bishops had taken in the transaction; for from an early period there was an opinion dilFused through the Church, of which Tertullian and Lactantius were the principal expo- nents, that a Christian should under no circumstances slay his fellow-men, either by biinging a capital charge, or by acting as a judge, a soldier, or an executioner. When the triumph of Christianity had been attained, it was of course necessary that this rule — which, indeed, had never been gen- erally adopted in its full stringency — should be relaxed as regards laymen, but it still continued in the case of priests. All ecclesiastics who delivered up a culprit to the civil power, without supplicating the judges that he should not be punished by death or mutilation, were regarded as guilty of a gross irregularity, and were in consequence liable to ecclesiastical censures. At first this rule was the ex^^ression of a pure philanthropy, and was intended to save the life of the accused, but it at last degenerated into an act of the ' Ampere, Hist. Litteraire de la France, torn. i. pp. 319, 320 ; Milman, vol. jii. p. 60 ; Taylor, Liberty of Prophesying, sec. 14. Sft. Martin, however, was one of the most active in destroying the pagan temples, and used in that em- ployment to range over his diocese at the head of a perfect army of monks. (See Gibbon.) VOL. II.— 29 34 KATIOXALISM IN EUROPE, most odious hypocrisy. Boniface VIII. decided that a bishop might safely deliver up a culprit, though he was certain his intercession would not he attended to; and the same form of supplication continued to be employed by the Inquisitors, though they had themselves condemned the heretic to death, and though Innocent VIII. had excommunicated any magis- trate who either altered their sentence, or delayed more than six days in carrying it into execution.^ During the latter half of the fourth century there were two causes which contributed especially to the increased severity of the persecution. The first was the great devel- opment of the corporate action of the clergy, as evinced by the multitude of councils. A large proportion of these, and among others those of Ephesus and Constantinople, which were esteemed oecumenical, called upon the civil power to banish or otherwise punish the heretics,' and their decrees had a considerable influence upon the government. The second cause was the establishment and rapid growth of the monastic system, which called into existence a body of men who, in self-denial, in singleness of purpose, in heroic courage, and at the same time in merciless fanaticism, have seldom been surpassed. Abandoning every tie of home and friend- ship, discarding all the luxuries and most of what are deemed the necessaries of life, scourging and macerating their bodies, ^ The liistoi-y of this has been written in a very striking book called La IhUrance EccUsiaatique et Civile, by Thaddeus de Trautsmandorff. The author was a canon of Olmutz, and afterwards Bishop of Konigsgratz in Bohemia. The work appeared in Latin, at Pavia, in 1783, and was translated into French in 1796. It is one of the most remarkable books in favour of tolerance pro- duced by any priest in the 18th century. See, too, on the form of intercession employed by the Inquisitors, Limborch, Ilisforla Inquisitionis (Amsterdam, 1692), pp. 365-367, 372. ^ On the influence of the Councils see Palmer, vol. ii. p. 333 ; Muzai-elli^ Sur V Inquisition. ON PEESECUTION. 35 iving in filth and loneliness and desolation, wandering half- starved and half-naked through the deserts with the wild beasts for their only companions, the early monks almost extinguished every natural sentiment, and emancipated them- selves as far as is possible from the conditions of humanity.' Ambition, and wealth, and ease, and all the motives that tell most powerfully upon mankind, were to them unmeaning words. No reward could bribe them, no danger could appal them, no affection could move them. They had learned to embrace misery with a passionate love. They enjoyed a ghastly pleasure in multiplying forms of loathsome penance, and in trampling upon every natural desire. Their imagina- tions, distempered by self-inflicted sufferings, peopled the solitude with congenial spirits, and transported them at will beyond the horizon of the grave. To promote the interests of their Church was the only passion that remained, and to gratify it there was no suffering that they were not ready to endure or to inflict. The pagan historians have given us a graphic description of the zeal they' manifested in destroying the temples. Sometimes a bishop led the enterprise from which the civil authorities recoiled, and one prelate, named Marcellus, perished in a conflict with the peasants who were defending with despairing courage the altars of their gods. A few years of such zeal sufliced, and paganism as a distinct system perished in the empire. After the suppression of paganism in the Roman empire, a period of many centuries occurred during which religious persecution was very rare. The principle was indeed fully admitted, and whenever the occasion called for it it was applied ; but heresies scarcely ever appeared, and the few that arose were exceedingly insignificant. A few heretics * Vide St. Jerome, passim. 36 EATIONALISM IK ErEOPE. ■whose doctrines vreve merged in the charge of magic, two or three who were burnt by Alexius Comnenus, some more wlio were burnt in France in the beginning of the eleventh century, and some Cathari and sectaries w^ith kindred views who were burnt at Cologne ' or in Italy, seem to have been all or nearly all who perished for heresy dui'ing several centuries before the Albigenses. Catholicism was then per- fectly in accordance with the intellectual wants of Europe. It was not a tyranny, for the intellectual latitude it permitted was fully commensurate with tlie wants of the people. It was not a sect or an isolated influence acting in the midst of Europe and forming one weight in the balance of poAver, but rather an all-pervasive energy animating and vivifying the whole social system. A certain unity of type was then manifested, which has never been restored. The corpora- tions, the guilds, the feudal system, the monarchy, the social habits of the people, their laws, tlieir studies, their very amusements, all grcAV out of ecclesiastical teaching, embodied ecclesiastical modes of thought, exhibited the same general tendencies, and presented countless points of contact or of ^ Natalis Alexandei-, Historia Ecclesiastica, torn. v. p. 337. The following are all the cases Simaucas could collect : ' Antiquissima est poena ignis adver- n, p. 335.) Castellio notices in his time the bitter complaints of some zealous theologians ' si quern videant stran- gulari, ac non vivum lenta flamma, torreri.' (Cluten, J)e Hceretkis pcrsequcndis [1610] : Preface of Martin BcUius.) See for a very horrible instance (pro- duced, however, by aggravated ciscumstances), Sessa, De Judceis (Turin, 1*71 7), p. 96. I may mention here that Eymericus was an Inquisitor in Aragon about 1368. His Diredorium was printed at Barcelona as early as 1503 ; it passed through a great many editions, and with the Commentaries of Pegna was long the standing guide of the Inquisition. The admiring biographer of Eymericus sums up his claims upon posterity in one happy sentence ; ' Ha;c magna est et postrema viri laus, eum acri odio htereticos omnes habuisse.' ludepeudently of its value as throwing light upon the Inquisition in its earlier stages, this book is remarkable as giving a singularly clear view of the heresies of the time. I have not met anywhere else with so satisfactory a review of the opin- ions of Averroes. In addition to the brief sketch prefixed to the Diredorium, there is a full history of the life of Eymericus (which was rather remarkable) in Touron, Hist, dcs Hommcs lllustres deVOrdre de St. Dominique. ^ The tortures of the Inquisition I have noticed in the last chapter ; but I may add that this mode of examination was expressly enjoined by Pope In- nocent IV. in a bull beginning : ' Teneatur pineterea potestas seu rector omnes hsereticos quos captas habuerit cogere citra membri diminutionera et mortis periculum tanquara vere latrones et homicidas animarum, et fures Sacramen- torum Dei et fidei Christianas, errores suos expresse foteri et accusare alios htereticos.' Clement IV. issued a bull nearly in the same terms (Eymericus, Appendix, p. 9). It was decided by the Inquisitors that even a heretic who confessed his guilt might be tortured to discover his accomphces (Carcna, De Inquisitione [Lugduni, 1649], pp. 69-73). The rule was that the tortures were not to be repeated, but it was decided that they might be continued through three days : ' Si qutestionatus decenter nolucrit fatcri veritatem . . . poterit ad terrorem, vel etiam ad veritatem, secunda dies vel tertia assignari ad continuan- dum tormenta, non ad iterandum, quia iterari non dcbent, nisi novis super- venientibus indiciis contra eum, quia tunc possunt ; sed contmuari non prohi- bentur.' (Eymericus, p. 314.) Paramo, a Sicilian Inquisitor, assures us that the Inqu'sition was like the good Samaritan, pouring into its wounded country the wine of * wholesome severity mingled with the oil of mercy. lie was also ON PERSECUTION. 43 who dared to exercise their reason in the pursuit of truth ; but what language can describe, and what imagination can conceive, the mental suffering that accompanied it? For in those days the family was divided against itself The ray of conviction often fell upon a single member, leaving all others untouched. The victims who died for heresy were not, like those who died for witchcraft, solitary and doting women, but were usually men in the midst of active life, and often in the first flush of youthful enthusiasm, and those who loved them best were firmly convinced that their agonies upon eai'tli were but the prelude of eternal agonies hereafter/ This was especially the case with weak women, who feel most acutely the sufferings of others, and around whose minds the clergy had most successfully wound their toils. It is horrible, it is appalling to reflect what the mother, the wife, the sister, the daughter of the heretic must have suf- fered from this teaching. She saw the body of him who was dearer to her than life, dislocated and writhing and quiver- ing with pain ; she watched the slow fire creeping from limb to limb till it had swathed him in a sheet of agony ; and when at last the scream of anguish had died away, and the tor- tured body was at rest, she was told that all this was ac- ceptable to the God she served, and was but a faint image of the sufferings He would inflict through eteraity upon the dead. Nothing was wanting to give emphasis to the doc- trine. It rang from every pulpit. It was painted over Df opinion that it resembled the Jewish tabernacle, in which the rod of Aaron and the manna (of mercy) lay side by side. {De Origin. Inq. p. 153.) * The following is part of the sentence pronounced upon the relapsed here- tic : ' Tu in reprobum sensum datus, maligno spiritu ductus pariter et seductus, prseeligisti torqueri diris et perpetuis cruciatibus in infernum, et hie temporali- bus ignibus corporaliter consumari, quam adha3rcndo consilio saniori ab errori bus damnabilibus ac pestiferis resilire.' (Eymericus, p. 33Y.) i4 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. every altar. The Spanish heretic was led to the flames in a dress covered with representations of devils and of frightful tortures, to remind the spectators to the very last of the doom that awaited him. All this is very horrible, but it is only a small part of the misery which the persecuting spirit of Rome has produced. For, judging by the ordinary measure of human courage, for every man who dared to avow his principles at the stake, there must have been multitudes who believed that by such an avowal alone they could save their souls, but who were nevertheless scared either by the prospect of their own suf- ferings or of the destitution of their children,' who passed ' It was the invariable rule to confiscate the entu-e property of the impen- itent heretic, a rule which Paramo justifies on the ground that the crime of the heretic is so great that something of his impurity falls upon all related to him, and that the Almighty (whom he blasphemously terms the First Inquisitor) deprived both Adam and his descendants of the Garden of Eden. The chil- dren of the heretic were thus left absolutely destitute, and with a stigma upon them that in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries was sufficient to shut them out from all sympathy, from all charity, and from all hope. The thought that those who were most dear to him would probably be abandoned either to star- vation or to the life of the prostitute, was doubtless one of most acute pangs of the martyr, and the hope of preventing such a catastrophe one of the most powerful inducements to recant. In this rule we have also an explanation of those trials of dead men for heresy which the Catholic clergy so frequently instituted. Protestants sometimes regard these simply as displays of impotent malice. Nothing, however, can be more false. They had the very inteUigible object of robbing the children of the dead. 'Juste enim proceditur contra defunctos hoereticos. Primo, ut memoria ejus damnatur. Secundo, ut bona ilhus per fiscum ab hajredibus defuucti seu a quibuslibet aUis possessoribus auferantur.' (Paramo, De Or'ig. et Progressu Sancii Inquisitloms [Madrid, 1598], p. 588.) The confiscation of the goods of the heretic was authorised by a bull of Innocent III. (on the ground that children are in the Divine judgments often punished for the offences of their fathers), and again by Alexander IV. (Eymericus, pp. 58, 59, 64.) The following passage from an old ecclesiastical lawyer gives a vivid picture of the ferocity displayed towards the children of heretics : ' Ipsi filii hcereticorum adeo sunt efiecti a jure incapaces et inhabiles ad succedendum patri, quod illi etiam in uno nummo succedere non possunt : immo semper debent iu miseria et egestate sordescere sicut filii reorum criminia ON rEKSECUTION. 45 their lives in one long series of liypoci-itical observances and studied falsehoods, and. at last, with minds degraded, bj habitual deception, sank hopeless and terror-stricken into the grave.^ And besides all these things, Ave have to remember that the spirit which was manifested in acts of detailed per- secution had often swept over a far wider sphere, and pro- duced sufferings not perhaps so excruciating, but far more ex- tensive. We have to recollect those frightful massacres, per- haps the most fearful the world has ever seen : the massacre of the Albigenses which a pope had instigated, or the massacre of St. Bartholomew for which a pope returned solemn thanks to Heaven. We have to recollect those religious wars which reproduced themselves century after century with scarcely diminished fury, which turned Syria into an Aceldama, which inundated with blood the fairest lands of Europe, which blasted the prosperity and paralysed the intellect of many a noble nation, and which planted animosities in Europe that two hundred years have been imable altogether to destroy. Nor should we forget the hardening effects that must have been produced on the minds of the spectators who at every royal marriage in Spain Avere regaled by the pixblic execu- tion of heretics, or who were summoned to the great square of Toulouse to contemplate the struggles of four hundred IcCSffi raajestatis humanae, adeo quod nihil aliud eis sit rclinquendum, nisi sola vita quae ex misericordia largitur, et tales esse debent in hoc mundo ut eis vita sit supplicium et mors solatium.' (Farinacius, Be Delictis et Foenis, p. 205 ; Venice, 1619.) However, it was provided that children who betrayed their parents preserved their inheritance. On the laws resulting from these notions, see Prescott, Ferdinand and Isabella, vol. i. pp. 262, 263. ^ Before operating in any district, the Inquisitors always made a proclama- tion offering pardon under certain conditions to those who confessed and re- tracted their heresies within thirty or forty days. Mariana says that when this proclamation was made, on the first establishment of the Inquisition in Anda- lusia, 17,000 recantations followed. {Be Rebus Hispanicis, lib. xxiv. c. 17.) 46 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. witches iu the flames. When we add together all these various forms of suffering, and estimate all their aggrava- tions ; when we think that the victims of these persecutions were usually men who were not only entirely guiltless, but who proved themselves by their very deaths to be endowed with most transcendent and heroic virtues ;, and when we still further consider that all this was but part of one vast con- spiracy to check the development of the human mind, and to destroy that spirit of impartial- and unrestricted enquiry which all modern researches prove to be the very first con- dition of progress as of truth ; when we consider all these things, it can surely be no exaggeration to say that the Church of Rome has inflicted a greater amount of unmerited suffering than any other religion that has ever existed among mankind. To complete the picture, it is only necessary to add that these things were done in the name of the Teacher who said: 'By this shall all men know that ye are my disci- ples, that ye love one another.' But while the preeminent atrocity of the persecutions of the Church of Rome is fully admitted, nothing can be more grossly disingenuous or untrue than to represent persecution as her peculiar taint. She persecuted to the full extent of the power of her clergy, and that power was very great. The persecution of which every Protestant Church Avas guilty, was measured by the same rule, but clerical influence in Protestant countries was comparatively weak. The Protes- tant persecutions were never so sanguinary as those of the Catholi(!S, but the principle was affirmed quite as strongly, was acted on quite as constantly, and was defended quite as pertinaciously by the clei-gy. In Gei*many, at the time of the protestation of Spires, when the name of Protestant was assumed, the Lutheran princes absolutely proliibitcd tlie cele- ON PERSECUTION. 4:7 bration of mass within tlicir dominions. In England a simi- lar measure was passed as early as Edward VI.' On the accession of Elizabeth, and before the Catholics had given any signs of discontent, a law was made prohibiting any re- ligious service other than the Prayer Book, the penalty for the third offence being imprisonment for life ; while another law imposed a line on any one who abstained from the Angli- can service. The Presbyterians through a long succession of reigns were imprisoned, branded, mutilated, scourged, and exposed in the pillory. Many Catholics under false pretences were tortured and hung. Anabaptists and Arians were burnt alive." In Ireland, the religion of the immense majori- ' Ilallam, Const. Hist. * Ibid. And then in 1562 it was enacted, that all who had ever graduated at the universities or received holy orders, all lawyers, all magistrates, must take the oath of supremacy when tendered to them, under pain of forfeiture or imprisonment during the royal pleasure ; and if after three months they refused to take the oath when again tendered to them, they were guilty of high treason and condemned to death. Xow the discontent of the Catholics might be a very good reason for makmg them take the oath of allegiance, which is simply a test of loyalty. It might even be a reason for making the oath of supi-emacy obligatory on those who for the future aspired to offices of impor- tance— in other words, for excluding the Catholics from such offices ; but to pass a retrospective law which made almost every educated Roman Catholic, if he refused to take an oath which was absolutely and confessedly irreconcil- able with the doctrines of his Church, liable to be punished with death, was as sweeping a measure of persecution as any that history records. And this was done many j-ears before the bull which deposed Elizabeth. The misconceptions which ignorance, and worse than ignorance, accumulated around this subject have been so completely dispelled by Hallam and Macaulay that I will only add one remark. The principal apology which was published for the policy of Elizabeth towards the Catholics, was Bishop Bilson's Christian Subjection, in 1585. In that work the coercive laws were openly justified on the ground of the absolute sinfulness of toleration (pp. 16-29). Nor was it merely the public profession of error which was rightly prohibited. This distinction the Bishop indignantly repudiates. 'No corner is so secret,' he says, addressing the Catho- lics, ' no prison so close, but your impiety there suffered doth oft'end God, infect others, and confirm your own frowardness. If your religion be good, why should it lack churches? If it be naught, why should it have chambere? 48 EATIOXALISM IN EUEOPE. ty of the people was Ibannecl and 23roscnbed. ; and when iu 1626 the Government manifested some slight wish to grant it partial relief, nearly all the Irish Protestant bishops, under the presidency of Usher, assembled to protest in a solemn resolution against the indulgence. ' The religion of Papists,' they said, 'is superstitious, their faith and doctrine erroneous and heretical ; their Church in respect of both apostatical. To give them therefore a toleration, or to consent that they may freely exercise their religion, and profess their faith and doctrine, is a grievous sin.' ' In Scotland, during almost thp whole j)eriod that the Stuarts were on the throne of England, a persecution rivalling in atrocity almost any on record was directed by the English Go\ernment, at the instigation of the Scotch bishops, and with tlie approbation of the English Church, against all who repudiated episcojjacy. If a.conven- ticle was held in a house, the preacher was liable to be put to death. If it was held in the open air, both minister and people incurred the same fate. The Presbyterians were hunted like criminals over the mountains. Their cars were torn from the roots. They were branded with hot irons. Their fingers were wrenched asunder by the thumbkins. The bones of their legs were shattered in the boots. Women were scourged publicly through the streets. Multi- tudes were transported to Barbadoes. An infuriated soldiery was let loose upon them, and encouraged to exercise all their ingeniiity in torturing them.' ^N'or was it only the British (l Christian prince may not pardon or wink at your falsehood' (p. 26). See also on the duty of intolerance, pp. 10-29. Milner, iu his Letters to a Prehea- dary^ has collected much evidence on the subject. / There is much truth as well as bitter eloquence in the taunt of an old persecuted Puritan, when he denounced Anglicanism as ' the Church that is planted iu the blood of her mother.' ' Elrington, Life of Usher, vol. i. p. '73. " For the circumstances of the persecution in Scotland, see Wodrow's His- ON PERSECUTIOISr. 49 Government, or tlie zealous advocates of episcopacy, who manifested this spirit. When the Reformation triumplied in Scothand, one of its first fruits was a law prohibiting any priest fi'om celebrating, or any worshipper from hearing mass, under j^ain of the confiscation of his goods for the first of- fence, of exile for the second, and of death for the third.' That the Queen of Scotland should be permitted to hear mass in her own private chapel, was publicly denounced as an intolerable evil. ' One mass,' exclaimed Knox, ' is more fearful to me than if 10,000 armed enemies were landed in any part of the realm.' ^ In France, when the government of certain towns was conceded to the' Protestants, they im- mediately employed their power to suppress absolutely the Catholic worship, to prohibit any Protestant from attend- ing a marriage or a funeral that was celebrated by a priest, to put down all mixed marriages, and to persecute to the full extent of their power those who had abandoned their creed.' In Sweden, all who dissented from any article of the Confession of Augsburg were at once banished.* In Protestant Switzerland numerous Anabaptists perished by drowning ; the freethinker Gentilis by the axe ; Servetus, and a convert to Judaism, by the flames. In America, the colonists who were driven from their own land by persecu- tion, not only proscribed the Catholics, but also persecuted the Quakers — the most inoffensive of all sects — Avith atrocious severity.^ If Holland was somewhat more toler- tory ; and for a summary of the laws against Nonconformists in England, Neal's History of the Puritans, vol. ii. pp. 695, 696. ^ Buckle, Hist, vol. ii. p. 231 ; McKenzie, Laws of Scotland. "" McCrie, Life of Knox (ed. 1840), p. 246. ' Much evidence of this is collected in Buckle, vol. i. pp. 509-523. * Macaulay, Essays, vol. ii. p. 140 ; Laing, Sweden, ' See the history, in Bancroft. VOL. II. — 30 50 EATIONALISM lis EUHOPE. ant, it was early remarked, that while the liberty alloAved there Avas unusually great, the power accorded to the clergy was unusually small/ As late as 1690 a synod Avas held at Amsterdam, consisting partly of Dutch and partly of French and English ministers Avho were driven to Holland by perse- cution, and in that synod the doctrine that the magistrate lias no right to crush heresy and idolatry by the civil power, was unanimously pronounced to be 'false, scandalous, and pernicious,' ^ "When Descartes went to Holland, the reformed clergy directed against him all the force of their animosity, and the accusation by w^hich they endeavoured to stir up the civil power against the author of the most sublime of all modern proofs of the existence of the Deity, was atheism.' The right of the civil magistrate to punish heresy Avas main- tained by the Helvetic, Scottish, Belgic, and Saxon Confes- sions.* Luther, in reply to Pliilip of Hesse, distinctly assert- ed it ; ^ Calvin, Beza, and Jurieu, all wrote books on the lawfulness of persecution. Knox, appealing to the Old Tes tament, declared that those who were guilty of idolary might justly be put to death," Cranmer and Ridley, as well as four ' Temple, On the United Provinces. " Bayle, art, Axtgustine, note H. See, too, on the general intolerance of the Dutch clergy, Hallam, Hist, of Lit.^ vol. iii. p. 289. ' Biog. Univ., art, Descartes ; Voltaire, Lettres Fhilosojihiques, xiv. Considering the writings of Descartes, this is perhaps the most preposterous accusation ever brought against a philosopher, if we except one of which Lin- nseus was the victim. Some good people in Sweden desired, it is said, to have his system of botany suppressed, because it was based upon the discovery of the sexes of the plants, and was therefore calculated to inflame the minds of youth. (Gioja, Filonofia della Sladstica, tom. ii. p. 389.) * Palmer, On the Church, vol. i. p. 380. * And also in reply to the Wittenberg theologians. At an earlier period, when his translation of the New Testament was proscribed, he had advocated toleration. For a full view of his sentiments, see Henry's Life of Calvin, vol ii. pp. 232-242. * McCrle's /'■/'■; of Knox, p. 24G. It is in his Jpnellation that this great ON PEKSECUTION". 51 otlier bishops, formed the commission in the reign of Edward VI, for trying Anabaptists ; and, if we may believe Fox, it was only by the long and earnest solicitation of Cranmer that Edward consented to sign the warrant that consigned Joan Boclier to the flames/ ' The only two exceptions to this spirit among the leaders of the Reformation, seem to have been Zuinglius and Socinus. The first was always averse t;- persecution.'' The second was so distinctively the apostle c " toleration, that this was long regarded as one of the peculiar doctrines of his sect.' With these exceptions, all the leading apostle of murder most fully expounded his views: 'None provoking the people to idolatrie oglit to be exempted from the punishment of death. . . . The whole tribes did in verie dede execute that sharp judgement against the tribe of Benjamin for a lesse offense than for idolatrie. And the same oght to be done wheresoever Christ Jesus and his Evangill is so receaved in any rcalme province or citie that the magistrates and people have solemnly avowed and promised to defend the same, as under King Edward of late days was done in England. In such places, I say, it is not only lawful to punish to the death such as labour to subvert the true religion, but the magistrates and people are bound to do so onless they wil provoke the wrath of God against themselves. . . . And therefore, my Lordes, to return to you, seing that God hath armed your handes with the sworde of justice, seing that His law most streatly commaudeth idolaters and fals prophetes to be punished with death, and that you be placed above your subjects to reigne as fathers over their children, and further seing that not only I, but with me manie thousand famous, godUe, and learned persons, accuse your Byshoppes and the whole rabble of the Papistical clergie of idolatrie, of murther, and of blasphemie against God committed : it appertameth to your Honours to be vigilant and carefull in so weightie a mat- ter. The question is not of earthly substance, but of the glorie of God, and of the salvation of yourselves.' (Knox's Works, Laing's edition, vol. iv. pp. 500-515.) In' a debate in the House of Lords, July 15, 1864, Lord Houghton stated, on the authority of Mr. Froude, that that gentleman in the course of his researches had discovered addresses from both houses of Convocation to Queen EUzabeth, requesting her to put Mary Queen of Scots to death aa quickly as possible, which she might justly do, Mary ' being an idolater.' ' 'Nea.Vsffislori/ of the Puritans (ed. 1*754), vol. i. pp. 40, 41. * This is noticed by Hallam and other writers. ^ Thus, for example, Jurieu, the great antagonist of Bossuet, the most eminent French minister in Holland (he was pastor of Rotterdam), and cer- tainly one of the most distinguished Protestants of his day, calls universal 53 RATIONALISM IN ECEOPE. Reformers seem to have advocated persecution, and in nearly every country where their boasted Reformation triumphed, tliG result is to be mainly attributed to coercion.* "When Calvin burnt Servetns for his opinions on the Trinity, this, Avhich, in the words of a great modern historian, ' had per- Iiaps as many circumstances of aggravation as any execution for heresy that ever took place,' ' was almost unanimously ap- plauded by all sections of Protestants.' Melanchthon, Bul- linger, and Farel wrote to express their warm approbation of the crime. Beza defended it in an elaborate treatise. toleration, ' ce dogme Socinien, le plu3 dangereus de tous ceux de la secto Socinionne, puisqu'il va h ruiner le Christianisrae et k etablir I'mdifference des religions.' {Droits des deux Soitverains en Matiere de Religion, la Conscience et V Experience [Rotterdam, 1687], p. 14.) This work is anonymous, but there is, I believe, no doubt about its authorship. It was written in reply to the Contrains-les d'entrer of Bayle, with the rather unnecessary object of showing that the French Protestants repudiated the tolerant maxims of that great writer. ' I commend the following passage to the special attention of my readers : Teut-on nier que le paganisme est tombe dans le monde par I'autorite dea empereurs Romains ? On peut assurer sans temcrite que le paganisme seroifc encore debout, et que les trois quarts de I'Europe seroient encore payens si Constantin et ses successeurs n'avoient emploie leur autorite pour I'abolir. Mais, je vous prie, de quelles voies Dieu s'est-il servi dans ces derniers slides pour retablir la veritable religion dans I'Occident ? Les rois de Suede, ceux de Danemarck, ceux d'Angleterre, les magistrates souverains de Suisse, des Pais- Bas, des villes libres d'AUemagnc, les princes electeurs, et autres princes souverains de I'empire, n'ont-ils pas emploie leur autorite pour abbatre le Papisme ? ... En verite il faut etre bien temeraire pour condamner des voies dont la Providence s'est constamment servi pour etablir la veritable re- ligion ; excepte le premier etablissement du Christianisme, et sa conservation, dans laquelle Dieu a voulu qu'il y cut un miracle sensible ; c'est pourquoi il n'a pas voulu que Tautorite s'en raeliit ; excepte, dis-je, cet endroit de I'his- toire de TEglise, on voit constamment partout que Dieu fait entrcr I'autorite pour etablir la veritable religion et pour ruiner les fausses.' {Droit des deux Souverains, pp. 280-282.) " Hallam, Hist, of Literature, vol. i. p. 554. ^ See the collection of approbations quoted by Beza, Dc Ilwrcficis; McKen- zie. Life of Calvin, pp. 79-89 ; and the remarks in Coleridge, Xotcs on Enc^ lish Divines, vol. i. p. 49. o:n- PEESECUTioisr. 53 Only- one man of eminence ventured openly to oppose it, and tliat man, who may be regarded as the first avowed champion of complete religious liberty, was also one of the most emineni of the precursors of rationalism. He wrote under the name of Martin Bellius, but his real name w^as Chatillon, or, as it was generally latinised, Castellio/ Castellio was a Frenchman, a scholar of remarkable ac- quirements, and a critic of still more remarkable boldness. He had been at one time a friend of Calvin, and had filled a professorsliip at Geneva, but the daring sj^irit which he 3arried into every sphere soon scandalised the leaders of the Reformation. Having devoted himself early to Biblical criticism, he had translated the Bible into Latin, and in tlie course of his labours he came to the conclusion that the Song of Solomon was simply a Jewish love song, and that the allegory that was supposed to underlie it was purely imagi- nary.' A still graver offence in the eyes of the Geneva thco- ' His name was originally Chatillon or Chateillon, which, after the fashion of the age, he latinised into Castellio ; but at the beginning of his career, some one having called him by mistake Castalio, he was so charmed by the name, which, by reminding him of the Castalian fount, seemed a good augury for his literary career, that he adopted it. See, for a full account of his life, Bayle, art. Castalio, and Henry, Life of Calvin ; and, for a short notice, Hal- lam, Hist, of Literature, vol. i. p. 557. Besides the works I have noticed in the text, Castalio translated the dialogues of the famous Socinian Ochino, and an anonymous German work of the mystical school of Tauler, edited the Sibyl- line verses (his preface is given to the recent edition by Alexander [Paris, 1846]), wrote a defence of his translation of the Bible (which translation seems to have been an indifferent performance), and published some minor essays or dialogues. ^ From which he somewhat rashly concluded that it ought not to be re- tained in the Bible. ' For my part,' said Niebuhr, when a young German pas- tor expressed his scruples about reading -^hat he believed to be simply a love Bong, ' I should deem the Bible itself imperfegt if it did not include an expres- sion of the deepest and strongest passion of humanity.' The history of the in- terpretations of the Song of Solomon would be long and curious — from the Jewish Cabalists, who, regarding heaven as the union of man with the Deity bj 'J^ RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. logians was his emphatic repudiation of the Calvinistic cloc- triHe of predestination. He assailed it not so much by any train of arguments, or hy an appeal to authority, as on the liroad grounds of its repugnance to our sense of right, and he 'leveloj)ed its moral atrocity in a manner that elicited from licza a torrent of almost frantic invective. Driven from (reneva, he at last obtained a professorship at Basle, where lie denounced the murder of Servetus, and preached for the iirst time in Christendom the duty of absolute toleration, based upon the rationalistic doctrine of the innocence of error. The object of doctrines, he said, is to make men better, and *hose which do not contribute to this end are absolutely un- important. The history of dogmas should be looked upon as a series of developments, contributing to the moral perfection of mankind. First of all, polytheism was supreme. Christ came and effected the ascendency of monotheism, in which -lews, Turks, and Christians all agree. Christianity again iiitroduced a specific type of character, of which universal charity and beneficence were the leading features. Questions concerning the Trinity, or predestination, or the sacraments, are involved in great and perhaps impenetrable obscurity, and have no moral influence, and ought in consequence not to be insisted upon. ' To discuss the difference between the Law and the Gospel, gratuitous remission of sins or imputed righteousness, is as if a man were to discuss whether a jirince was to come on horseback, or in a chariot, or dressed in white or in red.' * To persecute for such questions -is absurd, love, and death as the ' kiss of God,' esteemed the Song of Solomon the highest expression of this transcendental uniftn, to the somewhat fantastic ci'iticisms of M. Renan. ' On which Beza comments :* ' Hac impietate quid tandem magis impium aut diabolicum IpsiB imquam inferiorum portas exhalarunt.' {De Hcereticis a Civili Magistratu puniendis : Lihellus aclversris Martini BelJii farraginem ft. Novorum Academicorum sedam [1554"^, f. 58.) ON PEESECUTION. Da and not only absurd but atrocious. For if the end of Chris- tianity be the diffusion of a spirit of beneficence, persecution must be its extreme antithesis ; and if persecution be an essen- tial element of a religion, that religion must be a curse to mankind/ Such new and startling sentiments as these, coming from a "writer of considerable eminence, attracted much attention, and aroused great indignation. Both Calvin and Beza rejilied in a strain of the fiercest invective. Calvin especially, from the time when Castellio left Geneva, pursued him with untiring hatred, laboured hard to procure his expulsion from Basle, denounced him in the preface to an edition of the New Testament' as ' one who had been chosen by Satan to deceive the thoughtless and indifferent,' and attempted to blast his character by the grossest calumnies. In the friendshijj of ' ' Quis non putet Christum aliquera esse Molochura aut ejus generis aliquem Deum si sibi vivos homiues immolari, comburique velit? Quis velit servirc Christo ea conditione, ut si in aliqua re inter tot controversias ab iis dissideat, qui habent in alios potestatem, vivus comburatur ipsius Christi jussu crudelius quam in tauro Plialaridis, etiamsi in mediis flammis Christum magna voce eoncelebret, et se in eum pleno ore credere vociferetur ? ' (Preface of Martin Bellius in Joachim Gluten's De Hcereticis persequendis, cd. 1610.) This veork consists of a collection of passages from different authors (two of them by Cas- tellio) in favour of toleration. ^ See Bayle and Henry. Castellio, when publishing his edition of the Bible, made the preface the vehicle of a warm appeal for toleration (which is given in Gluten). Calvin, among other things, accused him of stealing wood for his fire — an accusation which was solemnly refuted. Boyle has collected much evi- dence to show that CasteUio was a man of spotless character, singularly loved by those about him, intensely amiable, keenly sensible of the attacks of which he was the object. Castellio has himself made a collection of the epithets Cal- vin in one short work heaped upon him : ' Vocas me subiude in GaUico libello : blasphemum, calumniatorem, malignum, canem latrantem, plenum ignorantire et bestialitatis, sacrarum literarura impurum corruptorem, Dei prorsus deriso- *em, omnis religionis contemptorem, impudcntem, impurum cancm, impium, obscoenum, torti perversique ingenii, vagum, balatronem, nebulonem vero ap- pellas octies ; et hsec omnia longe copiosius quam a me rccensentur facis in li- bello duorum foliorum et quidein perparvorum.' 56 EATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. Socinus, Castellio found some comi-jeusation for the general hatred of which he was the object, and he appears to have inclmed gi'catly to the doctrines of his friend. Separated alike froni the Protestants and the Catholics, his prospects in life were blighted, he sank into a condition of absolute desti- tution, and is said to have been almost reduced to literal starvation, when death relieved him of his sufferings. A few kindly sentences of Montaigne,^ who pronounced his closing scene to have been a disgrace to mankind, have in some degree rescued this first apostle of tolei'ation from oblivion. Some years after the murder of Servetus, Beza, in relating its circumstances, declared that CastelHo and Socinus were the only men who had opposed it ; ^ and although this state- ment is not strictly true,^ it but very little exaggerates the ' Essais, liv. i. c. 34. " Beza, Vita Calvini. ^ It is sufficiently refuted by Beza himself in his answer to Castellio, when he speaks of those who objected to the burning of Servetus (he calls them ' emissaries of Satan ') as amounting to a sect. He also specifies two or three writers, of whom the principal seems to have been Clebergius. I have never been able to meet with the work of this author, but Beza represents him as objecting absolutely to all forms of persecution, and basing this objection on the absolute innocence of honest error ; which doctrine again he rested on the impossibility of ascertaining certainly religious truths, as demonstrated by the continuance of controversy. The following passages quoted by Beza are ex- tremely remarkable for the age : ' De controvei-siis nondum certo constat ; si enim constaret disputari defuisset.' ' Nonne Dcus eos amabit qui id quod verum esse putant defenderint bonA fide ? Etiam si forte erraverint, nonne eis veniam dabit ? ' (Beza, pp. 65, 93.) Hallam has also exhumed three or four books or pamphlets that were written at the same time in favour of toleration. Acontius (Acanacio) seems to have been one of the most distinguished of these authors. Hallam says {Hist, of Literature) his book is, ' perhaps, the first wherein the limitation of fundamental articles of Christianity to a small number is laid down at considerable length. He instances among doctrines which he does not reckon fundamental, those of the Real Presence and of the Trinity.' Acontius was born at Trent. He adopted sceptical or indifierent opinions, verging on Socinianism ; he took refuge in England, and received a pension from Elizabeth. There is a full notice of him in an anonymous French historv of Socinianism of ON PEESECUTION. 57 ananimity that was displayed. Vf lien we recollect the great notoriety of this execiitiou, and also its aggravated character, 60 general an approbation seems to show clearly not only that the spirit of early Protestantism was as undoubtedly intolerant as the spirit of Catholicism, which is an unques- tionable fact, but also that it flinched as little from the extreme consequences to which intolerance leads. It seems to show that the comparative mildness of Protestant persecu- tions results much more from the circumstances under which they took place, than from any sense of the atrocity of burn- ing the heretic. And, indeed, while the Romish persecutions were undoubtedly unrivalled in magnitude, it must be admitted that there are some aspects under which they con- trast not unfavourably with the Protestant ones. Catholi- cism was an ancient Church. She had gained a great part of her influence by vast services to mankind. She rested avow- edly upon the principle of authority. She was defending herself against aggression and innovation. That a Church so circumstanced should endeavour to stifle in blood every aspiration towards a j)urer system, was indeed a fearful crime, but it was a crime which was not altogether unnatural. She might point to the priceless blessings she had bestowed upon humanity, to the slavery she had' destroyed, to the civilisation she had founded, to the many generations she had led with honour to the grave. She might show how completely her doctrines were interwoven with the whole social system, hoAV fearful would be the convulsion if they very great research (1723), ascribed to Guichard or to Lamy (pp. 261-2G4). The hand of Socinus was suspected in some of these works. That of Bcllius was by some ascribed to him. So, too, was a work now attributed to an author named Minos Celso, concerning whom scarcely anything is known, except that, like Socinus, he was born at Sienna. (See Blocf. Univ., arts. Servetus and Celso.) 58 NATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. were destroyed, and how absolutely incompatible they were with the acknowledgment of private judgment. These con- siderations would not make her blameless, but they "would at least palliate her guilt. But what shall we say of a Church that was but a thing of yesterday, a Church that had as yet no services to show, no claims upon the gratitude of mankind, a Church that was by ^^rofession the creature of pri- vate judgment, and was in reality generated by the intrigues of a corrupt court, which, nevertheless, suppressed by force a worship that multitudes deemed necessary to their salvation, and by all her organs, and with all her energies, persecuted those who clung to the religion of their fathers ? What shall we say of a religion which comprised at most but a fourth l)art of the Christian world, and which the first explosion of private judgment had shivered into countless sects, which was, nevertheless, so pervaded by the sj^irit of dogmatism that each of these sects asserted its distinctive doctrines with the same confidence, and persecuted with the same unhes- itating virulence, as a Churcli that Avas venerable with the homage of more than twelve centuries ? What shall we say of men who, in the name of religious liberty, deluged their land with blood, trampled on the very first principles of patriotism, calling in strangei'S to their assistance, and openly rejoicing in the disasters of their cou.ntry, and who, when they at last attained their object, immediately established a religious tyranny as absolute as that which they had sub- verted ? These Avere the attitudes wliich for more than a century Protestantism uniformly presented ; and so strong and so general was its intolerance that for some time it may, I believe, be truly said that there were more instances of [)artial toleration being advocated by Roman Catholics than by orthodox Protestants. Although nothing can be moj-e ON PEESECUTIOM. 59 cgregiously absurd than to represent the Inquisition as some- thing unconnected with the Church, although it was created by a pope, and introduced into the chief countries of Europe by the sovereigns who were most devoted to the Church, and composed of ecclesiastics, and directed to the punish- ment of ecclesiastical offences, and developed in each country according to the intensity of Catholic feeling, and long regarded as the chief bulwark of Catholicity — although all the atrocities it perpetrated do undoubtedly fall upon the blood-stained Church that created it — it is nevertheless true that one or two popes endeavoured to moderate its severities, and reproved the excesses of Torquemada in language that is not Avithout something of evangelical mildness. Erasmus, too, at all times endeavoured to assuage the persecution, and Erasmus lived and died in communion with the Church. Sir Thomas More, though he was himself a persecutor, at least admitted the abstract excellence of toleration, and extolled it in his Utopia. Hopital, and Lord Baltimore, the Catholic founder of Maryland, were tlie two first legislators who uniformly upheld religious liberty when in power ; and Maryland continued the solitary refuge for the oppressed of every Christian sect, till the Puritans succeeded in subvert- ing tlie Catholic rule, when they basely enacted the whole penal code against those who had so nobly and so generously received them. But among the Protestants it may, I believe, be safely affirmed, that there was no example of the consistent advocacy or practice of toleration in the sixteenth century that was not virulently and generally denounced by all sections of the clergy,^ and scarcely any till the middle of the seven- * If this language should appear startliug to any reader, I commend to his attention the following passage from an historian who was accustomed to weigh well his expressions: 'At the end of the sixteenth century the simple 60 EATIONALISM DJ EUROPE. teentli century. Indeed, even at the close of the seventeenth century, Bossuet vras able to maintain that the right of the civil magistrate to punish religious error was one of the points on which both churches agreed ; and he added that he only knew two bodies of Christians who denied it. They were the Socinians and the Anabaptists.^ It is often said that Protestantism in its earlier days persecuted, because it had inherited something of the princi- ples of Rome ; but that persecution was entirely uncongenial with its character, and was therefore in course of time aban- doned. In a certain sense, this is undoubtedly true. Prot- proposition, that men for holdii;g or declaring heterodox opinions in rehgion should not be burned alive or otherwise put to death, was itself little else than a sort of heterodoxy ; and though many privately must have been persuaded of its truth, the Protestant churches were as far from acknowledging it as that of Rome. No one had yet pretended to assert the general right of religious worship, which, in fact, was rarely or never conceded to the Komanists in a Protestant country, though the Huguenots shed oceans of blood to secure the same privilege for themselves.' (Hallam, Hist, of Literature, vol. i. p. 559.) The same judicious historian elsewhere says : ' Persecution is the deadly orig- inal sin of the Reformed churches, that which cools every honest man's zeal for their cause in proportion as his reading becomes more extensive.' ( Const. Hist. vol. i, ch. 2.) ' ' La discipline de nos Reformes permet aussi le recours au bras seculier en certains cas, et on trouve parmi les articles de la discipline de I'Eglise de Geneve que les ministres doivent deferer au magistrat les incorrigibles qui raeprisent les peines spirituelles, et en particulier ceux qui enscignent de nou- veaux dogmes sans distinction. Et encore aujourd'hui celui de tons les auteurs Calvinistes qui reproche le plus aigremeut a I'Eglise Romaine la cruaute de f;a doctrine, en demeure d'accord dans le fond, puisqu'il permet I'exercice de la puissance du glaive dans les matieres de la religion et de la conscience (Juriou, Syst. ii. ch. 22, 23, &c.) ; chose aussi qui ne peut etre revoquee en doute sans cnerver et comme estropier la puissance publique ; de sorte qu'il n'y a point d'illusion plus dangereuse que de donner la souffrance pour un caractere de la vraie Eglise, et je ne connois parmi les Chretiens que les Sociniens etles Ana- baptistes qui s'opposent a cette doctrine.' ( Variations Protcstantes, liv. x. c. 56.) The Anabaptists, however, were not always so tolerant, and one of the earhest rxllymg cries of the insurgents of Miinster was : ' Que tons non re- oaptisez f>issent mis a inort comme payens et meschans.' (Sleidan, liv. x.") 0:X PEESECUTION. 61 estantism received tlie doctrine of persecution from Rome, just as it i-eceived the Athanasian Creed or any other por- tion of its dogmatic teaching. The doctrine of private judg- ment is inconsistent with persecution, just as it is inconsistent with the doctrine of exclusive salvation, and with the univer- sal practice of all sections of early Protestants in their deal- ings with error. If man is bound to form his opinions by his private judgment, if the exercise of private judgment is both a duty and a right, it is absurd to prescribe beforehand the conclusion to which he must arrive, to brand honest error as criminal, and to denounce the spirit of impartiality and of scepticism as offensive to the Deity. This is what almost all the Protestant leaders did in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and what a very large proportion of them still do, and it was out of this conception of the guilt of error that persecution arose. Nothing can be more erroneous than to represent it as merely a weapon which was employed in a moment of conflict, or as the outburst of a natural indigna- tion, or as the unreasoning observance of an old tradition. Persecution among the early Protestants was a distinct and definite doctrine, digested into elaborate treatises, indissolu- bly connected with a large portion of the received theology, developed by the most enlightened and far-seeing theologians, and enforced against the most inoffensive as against the most formidable sects. It was the doctrine of the palmiest days of Protestantism. It was taught by those who are justly esteemed the greatest of its leaders. It was manifested most clearly in those classes which were most deeply imbued wit1i its dogmatic teaching. The Ej^iscoi^alians generally justified it by appealing to St. Augustine, and Calvin and the Scotch Puritans by appealing to the Old Testament ; but in both cases the dominating and controlling cause was the belief in 62 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. exclusive salvation and in tlie guilt of error ; and in all coun- tries the first dawning of tolerance represents the rise of that rationalistic spirit which regards doctrines simply as the vehicles of moral sentiments, and which, while it greatly diminishes their value, simplifies their character and lessens their number. The evidence I have accumulated will be sufficient to show how little religious liberty is due to Protestantism considered as a dogmatic system. It might appear also to show that tlie influence of the Reformation upon its development was but small. Such a conclusion would, however, be altogether '■rroneous; for although that influence was entirely indirect, it was not the less powerful. To the Reformation is chiefly due the appearance of that rationalistic spirit which at last destroyed persecution. By the events that followed the Ref- ormation, the adherents of different religious creeds became so mingled, that it was the interest of a large proportion of the members of every Church to advocate toleration. At the Reformation, too, the doctrine of the celibacy of the clergy was assailed, and the ministers of the new churches, being drawn into more intimate communion with society, were placed in circumstances far more fitted to develop the kind- ly affections than the circumstances of the Catholic priests ; while in England, at least, the accomplishments of a scholar and the refinement of a gentleman, blending with the pure and noble qualities of a religious teacher, have produced a class type which is scarcely sullied by fanaticism, and is prob- ably, on the whole, the highest as it is the most winning that has ever been attained. Besides this, the Reformation produced a number of churches, which possessed such an amount of flexibility that they have been able to adapt them- selves to the requirements of the age, while Catholicism con- ON PERSECUTION. 63 tinues to the present day the hitter enemy of toleration. The influence of the first three facts is, I think, sufficiently obvious. A short sketch of the history of toleration in France and England will clearly establish the fourth. In order to understand the history of religious liberty, tliere ai-e two distinct series of facts to be considered. There is a succession of intellectual changes which destroyed the conceptions on Avhich persecution rests, and a succession of political events which are in part the consequence of those changes, but which also react i^owerfully upon their cause. The intellectual basis of French toleration is to be found in that great sceptical movement which originated tOAvards the close of the sixteenth century, and which at last triumphed in the Revolution. In no other country had that movement been so powerful, not only on account of the great ability with which it was conducted, but also from the curious fact that its first three leaders represented three entirely diflerent casts of mind, and acted in consequence upon three difierent sections of society. The scepticism of Montaigne was that of a man of the world ; the scepticism of Descartes was that of a philosopher ; the scepticism of Bayle was that of a scholar. Montaigne, looking with an impartial eye on the immense variety of opinions that were maintained with equal confidence by men of equal ability, and judging all subjects by a keen, worldly, and somewhat superficial common sense, arrived at the conclusion that it was hopeless seeking to ascertain what is true ; that such a task transcended the limits of human powers ; and that it was the part of a wise man to remain poised with an indifferent mind between opposing sects. As a consequence of this, he taught for the first time, or almost for the first time, in France, the innocence of error and the evil of persecution, Descartes had a far greater confidence in 64 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. liuman faculties, but he bad also a far greater distrust of the ordinary judgments of expex'ience. He taught men that the beginning of all wisdom is absolute, universal scepticism; that all the impressions of childhood, all the conclusions of the senses, all of what are deemed the axioms of life, must be discarded, and from the simple fact of consciousness the en- tire scheme of knowledge must be evolved. Like many of the greatest philosophers, Descartes did not pause to apply his principles to practical life, but their influence was not the less great. The scepticism which he made the beginning of wisdom, and the purely rational process by which that scep- ticism was at last dispelled,- were alike inconsistent with a system wliich esteemed doubt a sin, and which enforced con- viction by the brand. The intellect of Bayle was very different from those of his predecessors, and was indeed in some respects almost unique. There have been many greater men, but there never perhaps was one who was so admirably fitted by his acquirements and his abilities, and even by the very defects of his charac- ter, to be a perfect critic. "With the most profound and varied knowledge he combined to an almost unrivalled extent that rare faculty of assuming the standing-point of the system he was discussing, and of developing its arguments as they would have been developed by its most skilful advocate. But while he possessed to the highest degree that knowledge and that philosophical perception which lay bare the hidden springs of past beliefs, he appeared to be almost absolutely destitute of the creative power, and aliuost absolutely indif- ferent to the results of controversy. He denied nothing. He inculcated nothing. He scarcely exhibited any serious pref- erence. It was his delight to bring together the arguments of many discordant teachers, to dissect and analyse them Avith ON PERSECUTION. 65 tlie most exquisite skill, and then to develop them till they mutually destroyed one another. His genius was never so conspicuous as when lighting up the wrecks of opposing sys- tems, exhuming the shattered monuments of human genius to reveal their nothingness and tlieir vanity. In that vast re- pertory of obscure leai-ning from which Voltaire and every succeeding scholar have drawn their choicest weapons, the most importaDt and the most insignificant facts, the most sublime speculations to which man can soar, and the most trivial anecdotes of literary biography, lie massed together in all the irony of juxtaposition, developed with the same cold but curious interest, and discussed with the same withering sardonic smile, Never perhaps was there a book that evinced more clearly the vanity of human systems, or the disintegrating power of an exhaustive enquiry. To such a writer nothing could be more revolting than an exclusive worship of one class of opinions, or a forcible suppression of any of the ele- ments of knowledge. Intellectual liberty was the single sub- ject which kindled his cold nature into something resembling enthusiasm. In all he wrote he was its earnest and uuAvaver- ing ad\ ocate, and he diffused his own passion among the scholars and antiquarians of whom he was the chief. He had also the merit of doing more than any previous writer to break the spell which St. Augustine had so long cast over theology. The bitter article on the life of that saint was well adapted as a prelude to an attack upon his opinions. But while the immense learning and the extraordinary ability of the I>lotionary of Bayle render it one of the most important pioneers of religious liberty, there was another work in which the same author applied himself more direct- ly to the advocacy of toleration. I mean that treatise on the text ' Compel them to enter in,' in which, abandoning for VOL. II. 31 GQ RATIONALISM IN ETTEOPE. once the negative and destructive criticisni in which he de- lighted, he undertook to ehicidate the hases of a rational be- lief. This book may, I believe, without exaggeration, be regarded as one of the most \aluable contributions to theol- ogy during the seventeenth century, and as forming more than any other work the foundation of modern rationalism.^ While the famous argument of Tillotson against transubstantiation is stated as forcibly as by Tillotson, and the famous argument of Chilling-worth on the necessity of private judgment as the basis even of an infallible Church as forcibly as by Chilling- worth, the main principles of Kant's great work on the rela- tions of the Bible to the moral faculty are fully anticipated, and are developed in a style that is as remarkable for its clearness, as that of tlie German philosopher is for its ob- scurity. At the beginning of this work Bayle disclaims any intention of entering into a critical examination of the pas- sage that he had taken as his motto. His refutation of the persecutor's interpretation rests not on any detailed criticism, but on a broad and general principle. There are certain in- tellectual and moral truths which are universal among man- kind, and which, being our earliest and njost vivid intuitions, cannot be questioned without universal scepticism.^ Thus, for example, the axiom that the whole is greater than a part, represents the highest kind of certainty to which we can pos- sibly attain, and no message purporting to be a revelation can be received in contradiction to it. For the reality of such a revelation, and the justice of such an interpretation must necessarily be established by a process of reasoning, and ' Tayle, who was a great coward about bis books, published this under the title ' Contraim-les d'cntrer, traduit de VAnglois du Sieiir Jean Fox de Bruggs, par M. J. F. : k Cantorberry, ehez Thomas Litwel.' * See, for a full development of tV is, ch. i. ON PERSECUTION. 67 no process of reasoning can be so evident as the axiom. In the same Avay, the fundamental differences between riglit and wrong are so stamped upon the mind, that they may be taken as the ultimate tests of all ethical teaching. No posi- tive enactments can supersede them. ISTo interpretation of a Divine revelation that violates them can be acknowledged as correct.' The intuition by which we know what is right and what is wrong, is clearer than any chain of historic reason- ing ; and, admitting the reality of a revelation, if the action of the moral faculty were suspended, we should have no means of deciding from what source that revelation had emanated. In judging therefore a moral precept, we should dissociate it as far as possible from all special circumstances that are connected with our passions and our prejudices, and, having I'educed it to its simplest and most abstract form, should re- ject it without hesitation if repugnant to our moral faculty. We should do this even if we can discover no second mean- ing. But, if tested by this rule, it will appear grossly im- moral to compel nien to profess a religion they do not be- lieve, and therefore such a course cannot be enjoined by the Deity. iSTor is it less irrational than immoral. For one of the first and most obvious consequences of persecution, is to prevent that comparison of tlie opinions of many classes which is absolutely essential for the discovery of truth. We believe perhaps that our neighbours are immersed in damna- ble error, but they believe the same thing of us. We may be firmly persuaded of the truth of the opinions we have been • ' Sans exception il faut souniettre toutes les lois morales a cette idee naturelle d'equite qui, aussi bien que la lumi^re metaphysique, illumine tout homme venant au monde.' And therefore he concludes ' que tout dogme pai-- ticulier, soit qu'on I'avance comme contenu dans I'Ecriture, soit qu'on le pro- pose autremcnt, est foux lorsqu'il est refute par les notions claires et distinctea dc la lumiere naturelle, principalement a I'egard de la morale.' (ch. i.) CS RATIONALISM LST EUKOPE. taught, but we know that each new research encroaches upon the domain of prejudice, and that the more the horizon of our minds extends, the more necessary we find it to revise both our principles and our arguments. And indeed, when we consider the feebleness of our faculties, the extent to which our conceptions are coloured by the atmosphere in which we live, and above all, the infinite nature of the Being to whom we aspire, it is impossible to avoid suspecting that all our conceptions on this subject must be jDartial and distorted ; that our attempts to classify religious opinions into absolute truth and falsehood are almost necessarily futile ; that different men according to the measure of their faculties obtain some faint glimpses of different aspects of the Divine nature ; and that no one has a right to arrogate to himself the possession of such an amount of perfect truth as to render it unnecessary for him to correct and enlarge his views by comparing them with those even of the most ignorant of mankind.^ It is not necessary for my purpose to pursue in detail the arguments by which Bayle developed these princij)lcs, or to notice the many important consequences he deduced from them. What I have written will be sufficient to show the general character of his defence of toleration. It will show ' ' Tout liomme aiant eprouve qu'il est sujet h, I'erreur, et qu'il voit ou croit voir en vieillissant la faussete de plusieurs cboses qu'il avoit cm veritables, doit ctre toujours dispose h ecouter ceux qui lui offrent des instructions en matifere meme de religion. Je n'en excepte pas les Chretiens ; ct je suis per- suade que s'il nous venoit une flotte de la terre Australe ou il y eut des gens qui fissent connoltre qu'ils • souhaitoient de conferer avcc nous sur la nature de Dieu et sur le culte que I'homme lui doit, aiant appris que nous avons sur cela des erreurs damnables, nous ne ferions pas mal de les ecouter, non seulement parceque ce seroit le moien de les desabuser des erreurs ou nous croirions qu'ils seroient, mais aussi parceque nous pourrions profitcr de leurs lumieres, et que nous devons nous faire de Dieu une idee si vaste et si infinie que nous pouvons soup9onner qu'il augmeutera nos conuoissances h I'iufiui, et par de5 ei des manieres dont la varietc sera iufiuie.' (Part i. c. 5.) ON PERSECUTION. 69 that Bayle, like Montaigne and Descartes, was tolerant be- cause he was rationalistic, and was rationalistic because he was sceptical. Keenly sensible of the weakness of our fac- ulties, and of the imperfection of all dogmatic systems, he resolved to subordinate those systems to the teachings of natural religion, and he therefore protested against a practice Avhich presupposes a degree of certainty that does not exist, and which is repugnant to the dictates of conscience. The intellectual movement of which these three writers were the representatives, and in a great degree the cause, was clearly reflected in the policy of the two wisest, if not greatest rulers France has ever possessed. By the Edict of Nantes, Henry lY., whose theological zeal was notoriously languid, solemnly established the principle of toleration. By entering into a war in which his allies were chiefly Protes- tants, and his enemies Catholics, Richelieu gave a new direc- tion to the sympathies of the people, instituted lines of de- marcation which were incompatible witli the old spirit of sect, and prepared the way for the general secularisation of politics. The reaction which took place under Louis XIV., although it caused intolerable suffering, and, indeed, partly in consequence of that suffering, had eventually the effect ot accelerating the movement. The dragonnades, and the re- vocation of the Edict of Nantes, formed the most conspicuous events of a period which was preeminently disastrous to France, and the effects of those measures upon French pros- perity were so rapid and so fatal that popular indignation was roused to the highest point. The ruin of the French army, the taxation that ground the people to the dust, the paralysis of industry, the intellectual tyranny, and the almost monastic austerity of the court, had all combined to increase the discontent, and, as is often the case, the whole weight ot 70 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. tilis unpopularity Avas directed against each separate element of tyranny. The recoil was manifested in the wild excesses of the Regency, a period which presents, in many resjjects, a very striking resemblance to the reign of Charles II. in Eng- land. In both cases the reaction against an enforced austeri- ty produced the most unbridled immorality ; in both cases this was increased by the decay of those theological notions on which morality was at that time universally based; in both cases the court led the movement ; and in both cases that movement eventuated in a revolution which in the order of religion produced toleration, and in the order of politics produced an organic change. That vifce has often proved an emancipator of the mind, is one of the most humiliating, but, at the same time, one of the most unquestionable facts in his- tory. It is the special evil of intolerance that it entwines itself around the holiest j^arts of our nature, and becomes at last so blended with the sense of duty that, as has been finely said, ' Conscience, which restrains every other vice, becomes the prompter here.' ^ Two or three times in the histoiy of mankind, its destruction has involved a complete dissolution of the moral principles by which society coheres, and the cra- dle of religious liberty has been rocked by the worst passions of humanity. When the moral chaos that followed the death of Louis XIV. was almost universal, when all past beliefs were cor- roded and vitiated, and had degenerated into empty names or idle superstitions, a great intellectual movement arose, under the guidance of Voltaire and Rousseau, which was designed to reconstruct the edifice of morality, and which, after a brief but fierce struggle with the civil power, obtained a com- plete ascendency on the Continent. The object of these ' Grattan. ox PEKSECUTION. Tl writers was not to erect a new system of positive religion, but rather to remove those systems which then existed, and to prove the adequacy of natural religion to the moral wants of mankind. The first of these tasks was undertaken especially by Voltaire. The second was more congenial to the mind of Rousseau. Both writers exercised a great influ- ence upon the history of toleration ; but that influence, if not directly opposed, was at least very difierent. Voltaire was at all times the unflinching opponent of persecution. No matter how powerful was the persecutor, no matter how in- significant was the victim, the same scathing eloquence was launched against the crime, and the indignation of Europe was soon concentrated upon the oppressor. The fearful storm of sarcasm and invective that avenged the murder of Galas, the magnificent dream in the Philosophical JDictlonary reviewing the history of persecution from the slaughtered Canaanites to the latest victims who had perished at the stake, the indelible stigma branded upon the persecutors of every age and of every creed, all attested the intense and passionate earnestness with which Voltaire addressed himself to bis task. On other subjects a jest or a capi'ice could often turn him aside. When attacking intolerance, he employed, indeed, every weapon, but he employed them all Avith the concentrated energy of a profound conviction. His success was equal to his zeal. The spirit of intolerance sank blasted beneath his genius. Wherever his influence passed, the arm of the Inquisitor was palsied, the chain of the captive riven, the prison door flung, open. Beneath his withering irony persecution appeared not only criminal but loathsome, and since his time it has ever shrunk from observation, and masked its features under other names. He died, leaving a reputation tbat is indeed far from spotless, but having done more to de- 72 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. Btroy the greatest of human curses than any other of the sons of men. Rousseau had probably quite as strong a sense of the evil of religious persecution as Voltaire, but by a remarkable pro- cess of reasoning he justified its worst excesses. He saw very plainly that the intolerance of the past was not due to any accidental circumstances or to any interested motives, but was the normal product of the doctrine of exclusive sal- vation. He maintained that reciprocity was the condition of toleration ; that is to say, that a dominant party is only justi- fied in according toleration where there is some reasonable probability that it will continue when the relative position of the parties is changed. From these two. principles he in- ferred the necessity of the widest intolerance. He told the believers in the doctrine of exclusive salvation that it was their manifest duty to persecute all who differed from them. He told the philosophers that it was necessary to banisli all who held the doctrine of exclusive salvation, because that principle was incompatible with the tranquillity of society.' This opinion was very natural at a time when the experiment of absolute toleration had scarcely ever been tried, and in the writings of one who was essentially a theorist. We now know that religious liberty has an admirable influence in reducing opinions to their proper level ; that it invariably acts upon and modifies doctrines which seem subversive to society; ^ ' Ceux qui distinguent rintolerance civile et rintolerance theologique, se trompent h mon avis. Ces deux intolerances sont inseparables. II est impos- sible de vivre en paix avec des gens qu'on croit damnes ; les aimer seroit hair Dieu qui lespuoit: il faut absolument qu'on les ramfene ou qu'on les tour- mcnte. ... On doit tolerer tous les religions qui tolerent les autres, autant que leur dogmes n'ont rien de contraire aux devoirs du citoyen ; mkis quiconque ose dire hors de I'Eglise point de salut, doit etre chasse de I'etat, h nioins que I'etat ne soit I'Eglise, et que le prince ne soit le pontife.' {Contrai Social, liv. iv. c. 8.) ON PEESECUTIOX. \T3 and that while it leaves the professions of men iin^ihanged, it profoundly alters their realisations. This Kousseau did not pei-ceive, and his blindness was shared by many of his con- temporaries. In the French Kerolution especially we find the two tendencies — an intense love of religious liberty and a strong bias towards intolerance — continually manifested. In that noble enactment ^vhich removed at a single stroke all civil disabilities from Protestants and Jews, we have a splendid instance of the first. In the exile, the spoliation, and, too often, the murder, of Catholic priests, we have a melancholy example of the second. Still it must be admitted in palliation of these excesses that they took place in a paroxysm of the wildest popular excitement, when the minds of men Avere exasperated to the highest degree by an atrocious and long-continued tyranny, when the very exist- ence of the State was menaced by foreign invaders, and when the bulk of the priesthood were openly conspiring against the liberties of their countr3^ It should also be remembered that the priests had to the very last declared themselves the implacable enemies of religious liberty. At all events, the spirit of tolerance soon regained the ascendency, and when the elements of revolution had been at last consolidated into ar regular government, France found herself possessed of a degree of religious liberty which had never been paralleled in any other Roman Catholic country, and which has been barely equalled in the most advanced Protestant ones. As this liberty grew out of the social and intellectual condition which was attained at the Revolution, it was not dependent upon any political combination, and the long series of politi- cal changes which have taken place during the last half-cen- tury have only fortified and developed it. The inference to be drawn from this sketch is, that the iT EATIOXALISK XN EUEOPE. growth of religious liberty in France was at all times directly opposed to the Church, and that its triumph was a measure of her depression. Once, however, in the present century, an attempt was made, under the leadership of Lamennais, to associate Catholicity with the movement of modern civilisa- tion, and it was supported by all the advantages of great genius and great piety, combined with circumstances that were in some respects singularly propitious. The issue of that attempt is profoundly instructive. It is shown in the abandonment of Catholicity by the greatest of its modern cliampions. It is shown still more strikingly in the solemn and authoritative condemnation of religious liberty by a pope, who justly attributed it to the increasing spirit of rationalism. ' We arrive now,' wrote Gregory XVI., ' at another most fruitful cause of evils, with which we lament that the Church is at j^resent afflicted ; namely, indiiferentism, or that pernicious opinion which is disseminated everyAvhere by the artifice of wicked men, according to which eternal sal- vation may be obtained by the profession of any faith, if only practice be directed by the rule of right and uprightness. . . . From this noxious fountain of indifferentisra flows that absurd and erroneous opinion, or rather that form of madness, which declares that liberty of conscience should be asserted and maintained for every one. For wliich most pestilential error, that full and. immoderate liberty of opin ions leaves the Avay which, to the injury of sacred and civil government, is now spread far and wide, and which some with the utmost impudence have extolled as beneficial to re- ligion. But " what," said Augustine, " is more deadly to the soul than the liberty of error ? " . . . From this cause, too, arises that never sufiiciently to be execrated and ♦■-o be detested liberty of publication of all books which the ON rEESECUTION. 75 populace relisb, which some are most ardently extending and promoting. , . . And yet, alas ! there are those who are so carried away hy impudence that they audaciously assert that the deluge of errors flowing from this source is amply counterhalanced by an occasional hook which, amid the transport of iniquity, defends religion and truth. . . . What sane man would permit poison to he publicly scattered ahout, sold, and even drunk, because there is a remedy by which its effects may possibly be counteracted ? ' ^ If we compare the history of English toleration with the history I have just sketched, we shall find some striking points of resemblance ; but also some differences which illus- trate very happily the nature of the superiority of Protestant- ism over Catholicism, Among Protestants, as among Catho- lics, the advance of the si^irit of rationalism was, as I have said, the necessary antecedent of the victory of toleration. As long as men believed that those who rejected certain ojsinions were excluded from salvation, they continued to per- secute. When the number of what were deemed fundamental doctrines was very great, the persecution was very severe. When the progress of latitudinarianism diminished the num- ber, the circle of toleration was proportionately enlarged ; when the government feU into the hands of classes who did not believe or did not realise the doctrine of exclusive salva- tion, the persecution entirely ceased. Other influences, such as the conflict of interests, the progress of political liberty, the softening of manners, or the benevolent feelings of individ- ual divines, did no doubt affect the movement; but their agency was so subsidiary that, speaking generally, it may be safely asserted, that as the doctrine of exclusive salvation was ' Bull delivered at St. Maria Maggiore on the Feast of the Assumption, 1832. The whole bull is given by Lamennais, Affaires dc Rome, pp. 318-357. it> RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. the source of that fearful mass of suffering Avhicli we have reviewed, so the spirit of ratioualisua which deBtroyed that doctrine was the measure of religious liberty. It is also true that in Protestant countries as well as in Catholic ones the great majority of the clergy were the bitter enemies of the movement, that they defended entrenchment after entrench- ment with a desperate tenacity, and that some of the noblest triumphs of toleration are the memorials of their depression. But at this point the history of the religions divides, and two very important distinctions attest the superiority of Protes- tantism. Its flexibility is so great, that it has been able cor dially to coalesce with a tendency which it long resisted, >\hereas the Church of Rome is even now exhausting its ;>Lrength by vain efforts to arrest a spirit with which it is un- able to assimilate. Besides this, as I have already noticed, toleration, however incompatible with some of the tenets which Protestants have asserted, is essentially a normal result of Protestantism, for it is the direct, logical, and inevitable consequence of the due exercise of private judgment. When men have appreciated the countless differences which the ex- ercise of that judgment must necessarily produce, when they have estimated the intrinsic fallibility of their reason, and the degree in which it is distorted by the will, when, above all, they have acquired that love of truth which a constant ap- peal to private judgment at last produces, they will never dream that guilt can be associated with an honest conclusion, or that one class of arguments should be stifled by authority. In the seventeenth century, when the controversies with Catholicism had brought the central j)rinciple of Protestant- ism into clear relief, and when the highest genius of Europe still flowed in the channels of divinity, this love of truth Avas manifested in the greatest works of English theology to a de- ON PEESECUTION. 77 gree which no other department of literature has ever equal- led. Hooker, unfolding with his majestic eloquence the im- mutable principles of eternal law; Berkeley, the greatest modern master of the Socratic dialogue, asserting the claims of free thought against those who vainly hoasted that they monojDolised it, and pursuing with the same keen and pierc- ing logic the soj)hisms that lurked in the commonplaces of fashion and in the obscurest recesses of metaphysics ; Chil- lingworth, drawing with a bold and unfaltering hand the line between certainties and probabilities, eliminating from theol- ogy the old concej)tion of faith considered as an uni-easoning acquiescence, and teaching that belief should always be strict- ly ' proportionable to the credibility of its motives ; ' — these and sucli as these, even when they were themselves opposed to religious liberty, were its real founders. Their noble con- fidence in the power of truth, their ceaseless struggle against the empire of prejudice, their comprehensive views of the laws and limits of the reason, their fervent passionate love of knowledge, and the majesty and dignity of their sentiments, all produced in England a tone of thought that was essentially opposed to persecution, and made their writ- ings the perennial source by which even now the most heroic natures are invigorated. A nation was not far fi-om a just estimate of religious controversies when it had learnt to hold with Milton that ' opinion in good men is but knowledge in the making ; ' and that ' if a man believes things only because his pastor says so, or the assembly so determines, without knowing other reason, though his belief be true, yet the very iruth he holds becomes his heresy.' ^ It was not far from re- ligious liberty when it could receive the noble language of Chillingworth : ' K men do their best endeavours to free them ' Areopagitica. i^ EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. selves from all errors, and yet tail of it through liuman frailty, so well I am pei-suaded of the goodness of God, that if in me alone should meet a confluence of all such errors of all the Protestants in the woiid that were thus qualified, I should not be so much afraid of them all, as I should be to ask par- don for them.' ' There does not appear to have been any general move- ment in England in favour of religious liberty till the time of the Great Rebellion. The tyranny of Laud had then disgust- ed most men with the system he pursued ; the rapid vicissi- tudes of politics had made all parties endure the bittex'ness of persecution, and the destruction of the old government had raised some of the ablest Englishmen to power. It would have been strange, indeed, if this great question liad been un- touched at a period when Cromwell was guiding tlie admin, istration, and Milton the intellect, of England, and when the enthusiasm of liberty had thrilled through every quarter of the land. The Catholics, indeed, were ruthlessly proscribed, and Drogheda and Wexfoi'd tell but too plainly the light in which they were regarded. The Church of England, or, as it was then termed, ' prelacy,' was also legally suppressed, though Cromwell very frequently connived at its worship; but Avith these exceptions the toleration was very large. There was a division on the subject between the Independents and the Presbyterians. The former, vrith Cromwell himself, desired the widest liberty of conscience to be extended to all Christians, short of the toleration of 'PojDcry and Prelacy;' and in 1653 they succeeded in inducing the Parliament to pass a bill to that effect. Supported by the Independents, Crom- well went still further, and gave the Jews once more a legal footing in England, permitted them to celebi-ate their wor- ' Religion of Protestants, p. 44 (eJ. 1742). ON PEESECUTION. Y9 ship, and protected their pei-sons from injury. The Presby- terians, on the other hand, constantly laboured to thwart the measures of the Protector. They desired that those only should be tolerated who accepted the ' fundamentals ' of Christianity, and they drew up a list of these 'fundamentals,' which formed as elaborate and exclusive a test as the articles of the Church they had defeated.* i45axter, however, although he pronounced universal toleration to be ' soul-murde]*,' ^ and struggled vigorously against the policy of the Independents, was, on the whole, somewhat more liberal than his coreligion- ists ; and it should be recorded to his special honour that he applauded the relief that was granted to the Jews, when most of the Presbyterians, under the leadership of Prynne, were denouncing it. The three principal writers who at this time represented ^ A full description of them is given in Neal's History of the Puritans, n In 1648 the Presbyterians tried to induce the Parliament to pass a law by which any cue who persistently taught anything contrary to the main proposi- tions comprised in the doctrines of the Trinity and the Incarnation should be punished with death, and all who taught Popish, Arminian, Antinomian, Baptist, or Quaker doctrines, should be imprisoned for life, unless they could find sureties that they would teach them no more. (Neal, vol. ii. pp. 338- . 340.) The Scotch were unwearied in their efforts to suppress liberty of con- science, and in 1645 their Parliament addressed the English Parliament: ' The Parliament of this kingdom is persuaded that the piety and wisdom of the honourable houses will never admit toleration of any sects or schisms contrary to our solemn league and covenant ; ' and at the same time published a solemn ' declaration against toleration of sectaries and liberty of conscience.' {Ibid. I)p. 211-222.) Among the notions started by the Anabaptists was that of a sleep of the soul between death and judgment, against which Calvin wrote a book with the bai-barous title of Psychopannychia. This very harmless notion was one of those which, when obstinately persisted in, the Presbyterians of 1 G48 wished to punish with an indefinite period of imprisonment. (Neal, vol. ii. p. 339.) ^ ' Popery, Mahometauism, infidelity, and heathenism are the way to dam- nation ; but liberty to preach up and to practise them is the means to make men Papists, Mahometans, Infidels, and Heathens ; therefore this liberty is the way to men's damnation.' {Holy Commonwealth, 2d Preface.) so EATIONALISM IX EUROPE, the movement of toleration, -were ITarrington, Milton, and Taylor — the first of whom dealt mainly with its i^olitical, and the other Iavo with its theological aspect. Of the three, it must he acknowledged that the politician took by far the most comprehensive view. He perceived very clearly that political liberty cannot subsist where there is not absolute religious liberty, and that religious liberty does not consist sinij)ly of toleration, but implies a total abolition of religious disqualifi- cations. In these respects he alone among his contempo- raries anticipated the doctrines of the nineteenth century. ' Where civil liberty is entire,' he wrote, ' it includes liberty of conscience. Where liberty of conscience is entire, it in- cludes civil liberty.' * ' Liberty of conscience entire, or in the Avhole, is Avhere a man, according to the dictates of his own conscience, may have the free exercise of his religion, without impediment to his preferment or employment in the State.' ^ But if Harrington took the widest view of the rights of conscience, Milton was certainly the advocate who w^as most likely to have advanced the cause, both on account of his high position in the Commonwealth, and because his opinions on the subject were, for the most part, embodied in a tract, which probably represents the very highest point that English elov|uence has attained. The Paradise Lost is, indeed, scarce- ly a more glorious monument of the genius of Milton than the Areopagitica. If, even at the present day, when the cause ^ Political Aphorisms, 23, 24. ^ A System of Politics, ch. vi. Passages very similar occur in the Oceana, and, indeed, all through the writings of Harrington. The following is, I think, a very remarkable instance of political prescience: 'If it be said that ia France there is hberty of conscience in part, it is also plain that while the hierarchy is standing this liberty is foiling, and that if ever it comes to pull down the hierarchy, it pulls down that monarchy also. Wherefore the mon- archy and hierarchy will be beforehand with it, if they see then- true interest.' {System of Politics, ch. vi.) ON PEKSECUTION. 81 for whicli it was written has long since triumphed, it is im- possible to read it without emotion, we can hardly doubt that when it first appeared it exercised a mighty influence over the awakening movement of liberty. Milton advocated toler- ance on several distinct grounds. In defence of truth he deemed persecution wholly unnecessary, ' For truth is strong next to the Almighty. She needs no policies or stratagems or licensings to make her victorious. These are the shifts and the defences that error uses against her power.' ^ But if per- secution is unnecessary in the defence of truth, it has a fearful eflScacy in preventing men from discovering it ; and when it is so employed, as infallibility does not exist among mankind, no man can assuredly decide. For truth is scattered far and wide in small portions among mankind, mingled in every sys- tem with the dross of error, grasped perfectly by no one, and only in some degree discovered by the careful compai'ison and collation of opposing systems.^ To crush some of these systems, to stifle the voice of argument, to ban and pro- scribe the press, or to compel it only to utter the sentiments of a single sect, is to destroy the only means we possess of arriving at truth ; and as the difficiilty of avoiding error is under the most favourable circumstances very great, it may be presumed that the doctrines which it is necessary to hold ' Arcopagitica. - ' Truth, indeed, came once into the world with her Divine Master, and was a perfect shape most glorious to look on ; but when He ascended, and his Apostles after Him were laid asleep, then straight arose a wicked race of de- ceivers, who, as the story goes of the Egyptian Typhon with his conspirators, how they dealt with the good Osyris, took the virgin Truth, hewed her lovely form into a thousand pieces, and scattered them to the four winds. From that time ever since the sad friends of Truth, such as durst appear, imitating the careful search that Isis made for the mangled body of Osyris, went up and down gathering up limb and limb, still as they could find them. We have not yet found them all. Lords and Commons, nor ever shall do till her Master's second coming.' (Areopaffiiica.) VOL. II. — -32 82 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. are but fe^\', and -where the error is not fundamental it should not be sui^pressed by law. All the differences that divide Protestants are upon matters not bearing on salvation, and therefore all classes — Socinians, Arians, and Anabaptists, as well as others — should be tolerated.' The Catholics, however, Milton rigidly excludes from the smallest measure of toler- ance, and the reason he gives is very remarkable. The in- triguing policy of its priesthood might at that time, at least, furnish a plausible ground, but Milton, though evidently be- lieving it to be so, expressly refuses to base his decision upon it. His exclusion of Catholics rests upon a distinct religious principle. The worship of the Catholics is idolatrous, and the Old Testament forbids the toleration of idolatry.'' The last name I have mentioned is Taylor, whose Liberty of Prophesying is, if we except Tlie Religion of Protestants , unquestionably the most important contribution of the Angli- can Church towards toleration.' It is scarcely possible to read it without arrivinix at an invincible conviction that it ' See his tract, Of true Religion, Hercsi/, ScJiistn, Toleration, published in IG'ZS. He does not, however, seem to have understood the Socinian heresy exactly as it is now understood. * 'As for tolerating the exercise of their (the Catholics') religion, supposing their State activities not to be dangerous, I answer that toleration is either public or private, and the exercise of their religion as far as it is idolatrous can be tolerated neither way: not publicly, without grievous and unsufferable gcandal given to all conscientious beholders ; not privately, without great offence to God, declared against all kind of idolatry though secret. Ezech. viii. 7, 8, and verse 12, &c. ; and it appears by the whole chapter, that God was no less offended with those secret idolatries than with those in public, and no less provoked than to bring on and hasten his judgments on the whole land for them also.' {Ibid.) It is of course open to supposition, and not very improbable, that this passage, being written after the Restoration, when Cathol- icism had become a serious menace to the liberty of England, emanated rather from the politician than from the theologian. ^ Chillingworth published The Jteligion of Protestants in 1637, one year before he took orders — which last step he had many scruples about. ON' PEESECUTION. 83 expressed the gemaine sentiments of its anthor. Its argu- ment is based upon latitudinarian principles, which appear more or less in all his writings, and its singularly indulgent tone towards the Catholics, its earnest advocacy of their claims to toleration,^ which would hardly have been expected from so uncompromising a Protestant as the author of The Dissuasive from Popery^ was certainly not intended to pro- pitiate the Puritans. Besides this, the whole book is ani- mated with a warmth and tenderness of charity, a catholicity of temper biassing the judgment in favour of mercy, which could scarcely have been counterfeited. This was indeed at all times the most amiable characteristic of Taylor, His very style — like the murmur of a deep sea, batlied in the sun — so richly coloured by an imagination that was ne^-er disunited from the affections, and at the same time so sweetly cadenced, so full of gentle and varied melodies, reflects his character ; and not the less so because of a certain want of nervousness and consistency, a certain vagueness and almost feebleness which it occasionally displays. The arguments on which he based his cause are very simple. He believed that the great majority of theological j)ropositions cannot be clearly deduced from Scripture, and that it is therefore not necessary to hold them. The Apostles' Creed he regarded as containing the doctrines which can certainly be established, and, therefore, as comprising all that are fundamental. All errors on ques- tions beyond these do not affect salvation, and ought, in conse- quence, to be tolerated. As far, therefore, as he was a scep- tic, Taylor was a rationalist, and as far as he was a rational- ist he was an advocate of toleration. Unfortunately for his ■ Sec. 22. He desires that they should be absolutely tolerated, unless, indeed, they openly preach such doctrines as the non-obserrance of faith with heretics, or that a pope can absolve subjects from the oath of allegiance, or that an heretical prince may be slain by his people. 84: EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. reputation, he wrote The Liberty of Prophesying in exile, and, to a certain extent, aLanclonecl its princij^les when liis Church regained her ascendency.* All through the period of the Restoration the movement of toleration continued. The vast amount of scepticism ex- isting in the country caused the governing class to look with comparative indifference upon doctrinal differences ; and the general adoption of the princij^les of Bacon and of Descartes, by the ablest writers, accelerated the movement, which began to aj)pear in the most unexpected quarters.^ The expression of that movement in the Anglican Church is to be found in the latitudinarian school, which followed closely in the steps of Chillingworth. Like the Independents and Presbyterians of the Commonwealth, like the greater number of the oppo- nents of the execution of Servetus, the members of this school usually based their advocacy of tolerance on the ground of the distinction between fundamentals and non-fundamentals, and the degree in which they restricted or expanded the first depended mainly on their scepticism. Glanvil, who was, perhaps, the most uncompromising of these writers, having in his treatise On the Yanity of Dogmatising preached al- ' On which Coleridge remarks, I think, a little too severely : ' If Jeremy Taylor had not in effect I'etracted after the Eestoration, if he had not, as soon as the Church had gained power, most basely disclaimed and disavowed the principle of toleration, and apologised for the pubhcation by declaring it to have been a ruse de guerre, currying pardon for his past liberalism by charg- ing, and most probably slandering, himself with the guilt of falsehood, treach- ery, and hypocrisy, his character as a man would have been almost stainless ' (Notes on English Divines, vol. i. p. 209.) ^ E. g. in Quakerism — that strange form of distorted rationalism, which, while proclaiming doctrines absolutely subversive of national independence, and indulging in extravagances almost worthy of Bedlam, maintained in the most unequivocal language the absolute inefficiency of mere religious cere- monies, the possibility of salvation in any Church, and the injustice of every form of persecution. ON PERSECUTION. 8d most universal "scepticism, proceeded in consequence to ad- vocate almost universal toleration. He di-ew up a catalogue of necessary articles of belief, which was of such a nature that scarcely any one was excluded, and he contended that no one should be punished for errors that are not fundamen- tal. The eflccts of the tendency Avere soon manifested in the laws, and in 1677 the power of putting heretics to death was withdrawn from the bishops. It appears, then, that the first stage of tolei'ation in Eng- land was due to the spirit of scepticism encroaching upon the doctrine of exclusive salvation. But what is especially worthy of remark is, that the most illustrious of the advo- cates of toleration were men who were earnestly attached to positive religion, and that the writings in which they em- bodied their arguments are even now among the classics of the Church. Tlie Ileliyion of Protestants and Tlie Liberty of Prophesying are justly regarded as among the greatest glories of Anglicanism, and Glanvil, Owen, and Hales are still honoured names in theology. This is well worthy of notice when we consider the unmixed scepticism of those who occupied a corresponding position in France ; but there is another circumstance which greatly heightens the contrast. At the very period when the principle of toleration was first established in England by the union of the spirit of scepti- cism with the spirit of Christianity, the greatest living anti- christian writer was Hobbes, who vras perhaps the most un- flinching of all the supporters of persecution. It was his leading doctrine that the civil power, and the civil power alone, has an absolute right to determine the religion of the nation, and that, therefore, any refusal to acquiesce in that religion is essentially an act of rebellion. But while the rationalistic spirit had thus found a firm Ob RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. footing witliiu the Chiircli, it -u'as strongly oj^posed and generally oyerborne by the dogmo.tic sjiirit which was rep- resented by the great majority of the clergy, and which radiated with especial energy from Oxford. Taylor, as we have seen, recoiled before the prevailing intolerance. Glan- vil sank into considerable disci*edit, from which, however, he in some degree emerged by his defence of witchcraft. Here- tics were no longer liable to be burnt, but all through the reign of Charles II. and during the greater part of the reign of James, the Dissenters endured every minor form of per- secution. At last, James, irritated by the penal laws that oppressed his co-religionists, determined to proclaim tolera- tion with a high hand. That he did this solely with a view to the welfare of his own Church, and not at all from any love of toleration, may be inferred with considerable cer- tainty from the fact that he had himself been one of the most relentless of persecutors ; but it is not impossible, and, I think, not .altogether improbable, that he would have ac- cepted a measure of toleration which relieved the Roman Catholics, without embarking in the very hazardous enter- prise of establishing Catholic ascendency. The sequel is too well known to require repetition. Every educated English- man knows how the great majority of the clergy, in spite of the doctrine of passive obedience they had taught, and of the well-known decision of Taylor that even an illegal ordi- nance should be accepted, refused to read the declaration ; how their attitude endeared them to the people, and accel- erated the triumph of the Revolution ; how they soon im- prudently withdrew from and opposed the movement they had produced ; how upon the achievement of the Revolu- tion they sank into a condition of almost unequalled political depression ; and how the consequence of that depression Ol'f PEESECUTION. 87 was the Toleration Act, which, though very imperfect ac- cording to our present notions, is justly regarded as the Magna Charta of religious liberty. Those who defended it were of the same class as the previous advocates of tolera- tion. Somers and the other leading Whigs were members of the Anglican Church. Locke was in religion the avowed disciple of Chillingworth, and in politics the highest repre- sentative of the principles of Harrington ; and it was on the double ground of the sanctity of an honest conviction, and of the danger of enlarging the province of the civil magis- trate, that he defended toleration against the theologians of Oxford.' While the Toleration Act and the establishment of the Scotch Kirk gave virtual freedom of w^orship to all Protestants, the abrogation of the censorship established freedom of discussion. The battle was thus won. Intoler- ance became an exception and an anomaly, and it was simply a question of time how soon it should be expelled from its last entrenchments. We have seen that the spirit of intolerance was at first equally strong in the Church of Rome and in the reformed churches, and that its extinction both in Catholic and Prot- estant countries was due to the spirit of rationalism. We have seen that in both cases tlie clergy were the untiring enemies of this the noblest of all the conquests of civilisa- tion, and that it was only by a long series of anti-ecclesiasti- cal revolutions that the' sword was at last wrung from their grasp. We have seen, too, that while the Church of Kome was so constituted, that an aijti-ecclesiastical movement where she ruled invariably became antichristian, the flexi- bility of Protestantism was so great, that rationalism found ' His opponent was Archdeacon Proast, ■whose pamphlets were printed in the University. 88 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. free scope for action within its jiale. Discarding more and more tlieir dogmatic character, and transforming themselves according to the. exigencies of the age, the churches of the Reformation have in many cases allied themselves with the most daring speculations, and have in most cases cordially- coalesced with the spirit of toleration. When a country which is nominally Roman Catholic is very tolerant, it may he inferred with almost absolute certainty that the social and intellectual influence of the CluTrch is comparatively smjill ; hut England and America conclusively prove that a nation may be very tolerant, and at the same time profoundly Prot- estant. When in a Roman Catholic country the human in- tellect on the highest of subjects pui-sues its course with unshackled energy, the freethinker is immediately severed from the traditions, the worship, the moralising influences of his Church ; but Germany has already shown, and England is beginning to shoAV, that the boldest speculations may be Avedded to a Protestant worship, and may find elements of assimilation in a Protestant creed. It is this fact winch is the most propitious omen of the future of Pi'otestantism. For there is no such thing as a theological antiseptic. Every profound intellectual change the human race has yet under- gone, has produced at least some modification of all depart- ments of speculative belief. Much that is adapted to one phase of civilisation becomes useless or pernicious in another. The moral element of a religion ajDpe'als to forms of emotion which are substantially unchanged by time, but the intel- lectual conceptions that arp associated with it assume their tone and colour from the intellectual atmosphere of the age. Protestantism as a dogmatic system makes no converts, but it has shown itself capable of blending with and consecrat- ing the prevailing rationalism. Compare the series of doc- ON PEESECUTION". ■ 89 trines I have reviewed in the present chapter with the habit- ual teaching of modern divines, and the change is sufficiently apparent. All those notions concerning the damnation of unbaptised infants, or of the heathen, or- of the heretic, which once acted so great a ]^aYt in the history of Christen- dom, are becoming rapidly unrealised and inoperative, Avhere they ai"e not already openly denied. Nor has it been other- wise with persecution. For centuries the Protestant clergy preached it as a duty ; when driven from this position, tliey almost invariably defended its less atrocious forms, disguis- ing it under other names. At last this passed away. Only a few years ago, six ladies Avcre exiled from Sweden because they had embraced the Koman Catholic faith ; ^ but a strik- ing example soon proved how uncongenial were such meas- ures with the Protestantism of the nineteenth century. An address drawn up by some of the most eminent English op- ponents of Catholicism, and signed by the Archbishop of Canterbury,- protested against the act as an outrage to the first principles of Protestantism. The history which I have traced in the present chapter naturally leads to some reflections on the ultimate con- sequences of the rationalistic method of investigation as distinguished from the system of coercion. The question. What is truth ? has certainly no prospect of obtaining a speedy answer ; but the question, What is the spirit of truth? may be discussed with much greater prospect of agreement. By the spirit of truth, I mean that frame of mind in which ' Annualre des Deux Mondcs, 1858, p. 463. In the previous year an attempt bad been made by the Government to moderate the fierce intolerance of the Swedish law ; but the bill, though adopted by the Houses of the Middle Class and of the Peasants, was rejected by those of the Nobles and of the Clergy. A slight — unfortunately very slight — modification was effected iu 1860. 90 EATIONALISM IX EUKOPE. men who acknowledge their own fallibility, and who desire above all things to discover what is true, should adjudicate between conflicting arguments. As soon as they have dis- tinctly perceived that reason, and reason alone, should deter- mine their opinions, that they never can be legitimately certain of the truth of Avhat they have been taught till they have both examined its evidence and heard what can be said against it, and that any influence that introduces a bias of the will is necessarily an impediment to enquiry, tlie whole theory of j^ersecution f\ills at . once to the ground. For the object of the persecutor is to suppress one portion of the elements of discussion ; it is to determine the judgment by an influence other than reason ; it is to pi-event that free- dom of enquiry which is the sole method we possess of arriving at truth. The persecutor never can be certain that he is not persecuting truth I'ather than error, but he may be quite certain that he is suppressing the spirit of truth. And indeed it is no exaggeration to say that the doctrines I have reviewed represent the most skilful, and at the same time most successful, conspiracy against that spirit that has ever existed among mankind. Until the seventeenth century, every mental disposition which philosophy pronou.nces to be essential to a legitimate research was almost uniformly branded as a sin, and a large proportion of the most deadly intellectual vices were deliberately inculcated as virtues. It was a sin to doubt the opinions that had been instilled in childhood before they had been examined ; it was a Aartue to hold them with unAvavering, unreasoning credulity. It was a sin to notice and develop to its full consequences every objection to those opinions ; it Avas a virtue to stifle CA'^ery objection as a suggestion of the devil. It was sinful to study with equal attention and with an indifferent mind ON PEKSECUTION-. 91 the -writings on both sides, sinful to resolyc to follow the light of evidence wherever it might lead, sinful to remain poised in donbt between conflicting opinions, sinful to give only a qualified assent to indecisive arguments, sinful even to recognise the moral or intellectual excellence of opponents. In a word, there is scarcely a disposition that marks the love of abstract truth, and scarcely a rule which reason teaches as essential for its attainment, that theologians did not for centuries stigmatise as oflensive to the Almighty. By de- stroying every book that could generate discussion, by dif- fusing through every field of knowledge a spirit of bound- less credulity, and, above all, by pei'secuting with atrocious cruelty those who difiered from their opinions, they suc- ceeded for a long period in almost arresting the action of the European mind, and in persuading men that a critical, impartial, and enquiring spirit was the worst form of vice. From this frightful condition Europe was at last rescued by the intellectual influences that produced the Reformation, by the teaching of those great philosophers who clearly laid down the conditions of enquiry, and by those bold innovators who, with the stake of Bruno and Vanini before their eyes, dared to challenge directly the doctrines of the past. By these means the spirit of philosophy or of truth became prominent, and the spirit of dogmatism, with all its conse- quences, was proportionately weakened. As long as the latter spirit possessed an indisputable ascendency, persecu- tion was ruthless, universal, and unquestioned. When the former spirit became more powerful, the language of anath- ema grew less peremptory. Exceptions and qualifications were introduced; the full meaning of the words was no longer realised; persecution became languid ; it changed its character ; it exhibited itself rather in a general tendency 92 KATIONALISM IN EUROPE. than in overt acts ; it grew aj^ologetioal, timid, and evasive. In one age the persecutor burnt the heretic ; in another, he crushed him with penal laws ; in a third, he withheld from him places of emolument and dignity ; in a fourth, he sub- jected him to the excommunication of society. Each stage of advancing toleration marks a stage of the decline of the spirit of dogmatism and of tlie increase of the spirit of truth. Now, if I have at all succeeded in carrying the reader with me in the foregoing arguments, it -will appear plain that the doctrine of exclusive salvation represents a point from which two entirely different systems diverge. In other words, those who reject the doctrine cannot pause there. They will inevitably be carried on to a series of doctrines, to a general conception of religion, that is radically and funda- mentally different from the conception of the adherent of the doctrine. I speak of course of those who hold one or other opinion with realising earnestness. Of these it may, I believe, be truly said, that according to their relation to this doctrine they will be divided into different classes, with dif- ferent types of character, different standards of excellence, difierent, conceptions of the whole spirit of theology. The man who with realising earnestness believes the doctrine of exclusive salvation, will habitually place the dogmatic above the moral element of religion ; he will justify, or at least very slightly condemn, pious frauds or other immoral acts that support his doctrines ; he will judge men mainly accord- ing to their opinions, and not according to their acts; he will lay greater stress on those duties that grow out of an eccle- siastical system, than on those which grow out of the moral nature of mankind; he wUl obtain, the cei'taiuty that is neces- sary to his peace by excluding every argument that is adverse to his belief; and he will above all manifest a con- ON PEKSECUTIO:!?'. 93 stant tendency to persecution. On the other hand, men who have been deeply imbued with the sj^irit of earnest and impartial enquiry, will invariably come to value such a dis- position more than any particular doctrines to which it may lead them ; they will deny the necessity of correct opinions ; they will place the moral far above the dogmatic side of their faith; they will give free scope to every criticism that restricts their belief; and they will value men according to their acts, and not at all according to their opinions. The first of these tendencies is essentially Roman Catholic. The second is essentially rationalistic. It is impossible I think to doubt that, since Descartes, the higher thought of Europe has been tending steadily in this second direction, and that sooner or later the spirit of truth will be regarded in Christendom, as it was regarded by the philosophers of ancient Greece, as the loftiest form of virtue. We are indeed still far from that point. A love of truth that seriously resolves to spare no prejudice and accord no favour, that prides itself on basing every conclusion on rea- son or conscience, and on rejecting every illegitimate influ- ence, is not common in one sex, is almost unknown in the other, and is very far indeed from being the actuating spirit of all who boast most loudly of their freedom from prejudice. Still it is to this that we ai'e steadily approximating ; and there probably never before was a period since the triumph of Christianity, when men were judged so little according to their belief, and when history, and even ecclesiastical history, was written with such earnest, such scrupulous impartiality. In the political sphere the victory has almost been achieved. In the social sphere, although the amalgamation of different reUgious communities is still very imperfect, and although a change of religion by one member of a family not unfrequently 94 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE produces a rupture uucT causes a vast amount of the more petty forms of persecution, the improvement has been rapid and profound. The fierce invectives Avhich Protestant and Catholic once interchanged, are now for the most part con- fined to a small and select circle of the more ardent disciples of either creed ; arid it is commonly admitted among edu- cated men, that those wlio under the sense of duty, and at the cost of great mental sufiering, have changed their re- ligion, ought not to be pronounced the most culpable of man- kind, even though they have rejected the opinions of their censor. This is at least a vast improvement since the time when the ' miscreant ' was deemed a synonyme for the misbe- liever, and when apostasy was universally regarded as the worst of crimes. Already, under the same influences, edu- cation at the Universities has in a great measure lost its old exclusive character ; and members of different creeds having been admitted within their pale, men are brought in contact with representatives of more than one class of opinions at a time when they are finally deciding what class of opinions they will embrace. There cannot, I think, be much doubt that the same movement must eventually modify profoundly the earlier stages of education. If our private judgment is the sole rule by which Ave should form our opinions, it is ob- viously the duty of the educator to render that judgment as powerful, and at the same time to preserve it as unbiassed, as possible. To impose an elaborate system of prejudices on the yet undeveloped mind, and to entwine those prejudices with all the most hallowed associations of childhood, is most certainly contrary to the spirit of the doctrine of private judgment. A pi-ejudice may be true or false; but if private judgment is to decide between opinions, it is, as far as that judgment is concerned, necesarily an evil, and especially ON PERSECUTION^. 95 when it appeals strongly to the affections. The sole ohject of man is not to search for truth ; and it may be, and un- doubtedly often is, necessary for other purposes to instil into the mind of the child certain opinions, which he will have hereafter to reconsider. Yet still it is manifest that those who appreciate this doctrine of private judgment as I have described it, will desire that those opinions should be few, that they should rest as lightly as possible upon the mind, and should be separated as far as possible from the eternal princi^iles of morality. Such seem the general outlines of the movement around us. Unhappily it is impossible to contemplate it without feeling that the Protestantism of Chilling Avorth is much less a reality to be grasped than an ideal to which, at least in our age, we can most impet'fectly approximate. The overwhelm- ing majority of the human race necessarily accept their opinions from authority. "Whether they do so avowedly, like the Catholics, or unconsciously, like most Protestants, is immaterial. They have neither time nor opportunity to ex- amine for themselves. They are taught certain docrines on disputed qiiestions as if they were unquestionable truths, when they are incapable of judging, and every influence is employed to deepen the impression. This is the true origin of their belief Not until long years of mental conflict have passed can they obtain the inestimable boon of an assured and untrammelled mind. The fable of the ancient ^ is still true. The woman even now sits at the portal of life, pre- senting a cup to all who eiiter in which diffuses through every vein a poison that will cling to them for ever. The judgment may pierce tlie clouds of prejudice ; in the mo- ments of her strength she may even rejoice and triumph in * Cebes. DO KATIUNALISM I^ EUKOPE. her liberty ; yet the concej^tions of childhood will long remain latent in the mind, to reappear in every hour of weakness, when the tension of the reason is relaxed, and when the power of old associations is supreme.' It is not surprising * This very painful recurrence, ■which occupies such an important place iu all religious biographies, seems to be attached to an extremely i-emarkable and obscure department of mental phenomena, which has only been investigated with earnestness within the last few years, and which is termed by psycholo- gists ' latent consciousness,' and by physiologists ' unconscious cerebration ' or the ' reflex action of the brain.' That certain facts remain so hidden in the mind, that it is only by a strong act of volition they can be recalled to recollec- tion, is a fact of daily experience ; but it is now fully established that a multi- tude of events which are so competely forgotten that no effort of will can re- vive them, and that their statement calls up no reminiscence, may nevertheless be, so to speak, imbedded in the memory, and may be reproduced with intense vividness under certain physical conditions. This is especially the result of some diseases. Thus, e. g., there is a case on record of an ignorant woman repeating, in a delirium, certain words which were recogTiiscd as Hebrew and Chaldaic. When she returned to consciousness she knew nothing of these words, she had no notion of their meaning ; and being told that they were Hebrew and Chaldaic, she could recollect no possible way m which she coidd Iiave acquired them. A searching investigation into her antecedents was in- stituted ; and it was found that when a girl she had been servant to a clergy- man who was accustomed to walk up and down his passage reading those languages. The words were hidden in the mind, were reproduced by disease, and were forgotten when the disease had passed. (Carpenter, Human Phys- iology, p. 808.) It is said that a momentary review of numbers of long-for- gotten incidents of life is the last phenomenon of consciousness before the insensibility that precedes drowning. But not only are facts retained in the memory of which we are unconscious, the mind itself is also perpetually act- ing— pursuing trains of thought automatically, of which we have no conscious- ness. Thus it has been often observed, that a subject which at night appears tangled and confused, acquires a perfect clearness and arrangement during sleep. Thus the schoolboy knows that verses learnt by heart just before sleep are retained with much greater facility than those which are learnt at any other time. Thus, in th3 course of recollection, two facts will often rise in succession which appear to have no connection whatever ; but a careful investigation will prove that there is some forgotten link of association which the mind had pur- sued, but of which we were entirely unconscious. It is irt connection with these facts that we should view that reappearance of opinions, modes of thought, and emotions belonging to a former stage of our intellectual history, that is often the result of the automatical action of the mind when volition is ON- PEESECUTION'. 97 that very few" should i^ossess the courage and the perseverance to encounter the mental struggle. The immense majority either never examine the opinions they have inherited, or ex- amine them so completely under the dominating influence of the prejudice of education, that whatever may have been the doctrines they have been taught, they conclude that they are so unquestionably true that nothing but a judicial blind- ness can cause their rejection. Of the few who have obtained a glimpse of higher things, a large proportion cannot endure a conflict to which old associations, and, above all, the old doctrine of the guilt of error, lend such a peculiar bitterness ; they stifle the voice of reason, they turn away from the path altogether suspended. It is especially common (or, at least, especially mani- fest) in languor, in disease, and, above all, in sleep. M. Maury, who has in- vestigated the subject with his usual great ability, has shown that in sleep hyperesthesia of the memory is very common ; that not only facts, but pro- cesses of thought that belong altogether to the past, are reproduced ; and that a frequent dreamer will often be brought under the influence of vices in which he had once indulged, but by which in his waking hours he is rarely or never overcome. There can be little doubt that when we are actively reasoning this automatic action of the mind still continues, but the ideas and trains of thought that arc thus produced are so combined and transformed by the rea- son, that we are unconscious of their existence. They exist nevertheless, and form (or greatly contribute to) our mental bias. It is impossible to review this most suggestive subject without suspecting that the saying, ' habit is a second nature,' represents more than a metaphor ; that the reason is much more closely connected with the will than is generally imagined ; and that the origin of most of those opinions we attribute to pure reasoning, is more composite than we suppose. This important subject was first incidentally pointed out by Leibnitz. After his time it seems, except in as far as it was connected with the animism of Stahl, to have been almost unnoticed till very recently. Sir W. Hamilton (in his Essays) has treated it from a psychological, and Drs. Laj-- cock {The Bm'm and the Mind) and Carpenter {Human Fhi/sioloffi/, pp. 799- 819) from a medical, point of view. Mr. Morell, following in the steps of Stahl, has availed himself of it {Mental Philosophy) to explain the laws of generation, ascribing the formation of the foetus to the unconscious action of the sou) ; and M. Maury {Le Sommeil et Ics Revcs) has shown its connection with the phenomena of sleep. See, too, Tissot, Sur la Vie ; and Saissct. L'Ame et la Vie. VOL. II. — 33 98 NATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. of knowledge, tliey purchase peace at the expense of truth. This is, indeed, in our day, the most fatal of all the obstacles to enquiry. It was not till the old world had heen reduced to chaos that the divine voice said, ' Let there be light ; ' and in the order of knowledge, as in the order of nature, dissolution must commonly precede formation. There is a period in the history of the enquirer when old opinions have been shaken or destroyed, and new opinions have not yet been formed ; a period of doubt, of terror, and of darkness, when the voice of the dogmatist has not lost its power, and the phantoms of the past still hover over the mind ; a period when every land- mark is lost to sight, and every star is veiled, and the soul seems drifting helpless and rudderless before the destroying- blast. It is in this season of transition that the temptations to stifle reason possess a fearful power. It is when contrast- ing the tranquillity of past assurance with the feverish par- oxysms that accompany enquiry, that the mind is most likely to abandon the path of truth. It is so much easier to assume than to prove ; it is so much less painful to believe than to doubt; there is such a charm in the repose of prejudice, when no discordant voice jars upon the harmony of belief; there is such a thrilling pang when cherished dreams are scattered, and old creeds abandoned, that it is not surprising that men should close their eyes to the unwelcome light. Hence the tenacity exhibited by systems that have long since been dis- proved. Hence the oscillation and timidity that charac- terise the research of most, and the indilFerence to truth and the worship of expediency that cloud the fair promise of not a few. In our age these struggles are diffused over a very wide circle, and are felt by men of many grades of intellect. This fuct, however, while it accounts for the perturbation and ON PEKSECUTION. 99 instaLility that cliaracterise a large portion of contemjiorary literature, should materially lighten the burden of each individual enquirer. The great majority of the ablest intel- lects of the century have preceded him, and their genius irradiates the path. The hands of many sympathisers are extended to assist him. The disintegration around him will facilitate his course. He who, believing that the search for truth can never be offensive to the God of truth, pursues his way with an unswerving energy, may not unreasonably hope that he may assist others in their struggle towards the light, and may in some small degree contribute to that consumma- tion when the professed belief shall have been adjusted to the requirements of the age, when the old tyi'anny shall have been broken, and the anarchy of transition shall have passed away. CHAPTER y. THE SECULAEISATIOK OF POLITICS. The evidence I have collected in the preceding chapters will he sufficient to exhibit the nature of the rationalistic movement, and also the process by which it has been devel- oped. To establish the first, I have revieAved a long series of theological conceptions which the movement has weakened or transformed. To establish the second, I have shoAvn that the most important changes were much less the results of direct controversy than of the attraction of the prevailing modes of thought, which themselves represented the conver- gence of a great variety of theological influences. In the remainder of this work, I proj)ose to trace more fully than I have yet had occasion to do, the relations of the rationalistic movement to the political and economical history of Europe ; or, in other words, to show on the one hand how the theo- logical development has modified political and economical theories ; and, on the other hand, how the tendencies pro- duced by these have reacted upon theology. But, before entering upon this field, it will perhaps not be altogether unnecessary to remind the reader once more of the main princij^le upon which the relevance of this sj^ecies of narrative depends. It is that the S2:)eculative oi^inions which are embraced by any large body of men are accepted not ou THE SECULAEISATTON OF POLITICS. 101 account of the arguments upon which they rest, but on account of a predisposition to receive them. This predispo- sition depends Avith many persons entirely upon the circum- stances of their position, that is to say, upon the associations of cliildhood, friendship, or interest, and is of such a nature as altogether to dispense with arguments. "With others, it depends chiefly upon the character of theu- minds, which induces them to embrace one class of arguments rather than another. This intellectual character, again, results partly from natural and innate peculiarities, and partly from the totality of influences that act upon the mind. For the mind of man is no inert receptacle of knowledge, but absorbs and incorporates into its own constitution the ideas which it receives. In a healthy condition, increased knowledge implies an increased mental capacity, and each peculiar dej^artment of study not merely comprises a peculiar kind of information, but also produces a j^eculiar ply and tendency of judgment. All minds are more or less governed by what chemists term the laws of elective affinity. Like naturally tends to like. The predominating passion of every man colours tlie whole train of his reasoning, and in every subject he examines, he instinctively turns to that aspect which is most congruous to his favourite pursuit. If this be so, we should naturally expect that politics, which occupy so large a place in the minds of men, should at all times have exercised a considerable influence on the tone of thought from which theological opinions arise, and that a general tendency to restrict the province of theology should have resulted in a secularisation of politics. In the present chapter, I shall examine the stages of that secularisation and the minor changes that are connected with it. The subject will naturally divide itself into two parts. We shall first see 102 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. how theological interests gradually ceased to be a maiu object of political combinations ; and afterwards, .how, by the repudiation of the divine right of kings and the assertion of the social contract, the basis of authority was secularised. If we take a broad view of the course of history, and ex- amine the relations of great bodies of men, we find that ro ligion and patriotism are the chief moral influences to which they have been subject, and that the separate modifications and mutual interaction of those two agents may almost be said to constitute the moral history of mankind. For some centuries before the introduction of Christianity, patriotism was in most countries the presiding moral principle, and re- ligion occupied an entirely subordinate position. Almost all those examples of heroic self-sacrifice, of passionate devotion to an unselfish aim, which antiquity afibrds, were produced by the spirit of patriotism. Decius and Regulus, Leonidas and Harmodius, are the j^agan parallels to Christian martyrs.* Nor was it only in the great crises of national history that this spirit was evoked. The pride of patriotism, the sense of dignity which it inspires, the close bond of sympathy pro- duced by a common aim, the energy and elasticity of charac- ter which are the parents of great enterprises, Avere manifest- ed habitually in the leading nations of antiquity. The spirit of patriotism pervaded all classes. It formed a distinct type of character, and was the origin both of many virtues and of many vices. If we attempt to estimate the moral condition of such a phase of society, we must in some respects place it extremely ^ It is worthy of notice, that the first development of sculpture, which in almost all other nations was religious, in Kome appears to have been patriotic — the objects of representation being not the gods, but the true national ideals, the heroes of Rome. (See 0. Miiller, Manuel crArchcoloffie, vol. i pp. 251. 252.) THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 103 high. Patriotism has always proved the best cordial of Lx- inanity, and all the sterner and more robust virtues were de- veloped to the highest degree by its power. ISTo other influ- ence diffuses abroad so much of that steady fortitude which is equally removed from languor and timidity on the one liand, and from feverish and morbid excitement upon the other. In nations that have been long pervaded by a strong and continuous political life, the pulse beats high and steadi- ly ; habits of self-reliance are formed which enable men to confront danger with a calm intrepidity, and to retain a cer- tain sobriety of temperament amidst the most trying vicissi- tudes. A capacity for united action, for self-sacrifice, for long and persevering exertion, becomes general. A high, though sometimes rather capricious, standard of honour is formed, and a stei-n simplicity of habits encouraged. It is probable that in the best days of the old classic republics the passions of m.en were as habitually under control, national tastes as simple and chastened, and acts of heroism as fre- quent and as grand, as in the noblest periods of subsequent history. Never did men pass through life with a more ma- jestic dignity, or meet death with a more unfaltering calm. The full sublimity of the old classic type has never been re- produced in its perfection, but the spirit that formed it has often breathed over the feverish struggles of modern life, and has infused into society a heroism and a fortitude that have proved the invariable precursors of regeneration. All this was produced among nations that were notorious- ly deficient in religious feeling, and had, indeed, degraded their religion into a mere function of the State. The disin- terested cnthusiam of patriotism had pervaded and animated tliem, and had called into habitual action many of the noblest moral capacities of mankind. 104 EATIONALISM EST EUROPE. To this picture there is, however, a melancholy revei-se If the ancient civilisations exhibited to a very high degree the sterner virtues, they were preeminently deficient in the gentler ones. The pathos of life was habitually repressed. Sufiering and weakness met with no sympathy and no assist- ance. The slave, the captive, the sick, the helpless, were treat- ed with cold indifference, or with merciless ferocity. The hospital and the refuge for the afflicted were unknown. The spectacle of suffering and of death was the luxury of all classes. An almost absolute destruction of the finer sensi- bilities was the consequence of the universal worship of force. The sentiment of reverence was almost extinguished. The existence of the gods was, indeed, recognised, but the ideals of excellence were not sought on the heig^hts of Olympus, but ill the annals of Roman jH'owess. There was no sense of the supei-human, no conception of sin, no desire to rise above the things of earth ; pride was deemed the greatest of virtues, and humility the most contemptible of weaknesses. The welfare of the State being the highest object of unselfish de- votion, virtue and vice were often measured by that standard, and the individual was habitually sacrificed to the community. But perhaps the greatest vice of the old form of patriot- ism was the narrowness of sympathy which it produced. Outside the circle of their own nation all men were regarded with contempt and indifference, if not with absolute hostility. Conquest was the one recognised form of national progress, and the interests of nations were, thei-efore, regarded as di- rectly opposed. The intensity with which a man loved his country was a measure of the hatred which he bore to those who were without it. The enthusiasm which produced the noblest virtue in a narrow circle was the direct and powerful cause of the strongest international antipathies. THE SECULARISATION OF TOLITICS. 105 In Juflffia the religious system occupied a more prominent position than among the Greeks or Romans, but it had been indissohibly connected with national interests, and the at- tachment to it was in reality only a form and aspect oi patriotism. Whatever opinion may be held as to whether a future life was intended to be among the elements of the Le- vitical i-evelation, there can be no question that the primary incentives which that revelation offered were of a patriotic order. The devotion of the people to their religious system was to be the measure of their national prosperity. When their faith burnt with a strong and unsullied flame, every enemy succumbed beneath their arms; but whenever idol- atry had corrupted their devotions, a hostile array encircled Mount Moriah. All the traditions of their religion wei-e identified with splendid national triumphs. The rescue from Egypt, the conquest of Canaan and the massacre of its in- habitants, the long series of inspired warriors Avho had broken the chains of a foreign master, the destruction of the hosts of the Assyrian, the numerous vicissitudes of national fortune, had all contributed to interweave in the Jewish mind the association of the Church and of the State. The spirit of sect, or an attachment not to abstract principles but to a definite and organised ecclesiastical institution, is a spirit essentially similar to patriotism, but is directed to a different object, and is therefore in most cases hostile to it. In Judsea the spirit of patriotism and the spirit of sect were united ; each intensified the other, and the exclusive intol- erance which is tlie result of each existed with double vir- ulence. Such was the condition of the Pagan and Jewish world when the sublime doctrine of universal brotherhood, was preacbed to mankind. After eighteen hundred years men 106 EATIONALISM IN ErEOPE. are only beginning to realise it, and at the time when it was first proclaimed it was diametrically ojDposed to the most cherished prejudices of the age. In Judsea the spirit of an exclusive patriotism not oxAy pervaded the national mind, but was also at this period an intensely active moral princijDle. In the Roman Empire patriotism was little more than an intellectual conception ; society was in a condition of moral dissolution, and a disin- terested enthusiasm was unknown. The fortunes of the in- fant Church were, probably, in no slight measure determined by these circumstances. In Judsea it was rejected with in- dignant scorn. In the Roman Empire it obtained a marvel- lous triumph, but it triumphed only by transforming itself under the influence of the spirit of sect. The passion for the visible and material which in that age it was impossible to es- cape— which incrusted the teachings of the Church with an elaborated and superstitious ritualism, designed to appeal to and enthral the senses, and converted its simple moral prin- ciples into a complicated creed — acted with equal force upon its government, and transformed it into a highly centralised monarchy, pervaded by a spirit of exclusiveness very similar to that which had animated the old Roman republic. The spirit of sect was, indeed, far stronger and more virulent than the most envenomed spirit of nationality. The ancient patriot regarded nations that were beyond his border with indifference, or with a spirit of rivalry; but the priest de- clared every one who rejected his opinions to be a criminal. From this period for many centuries Catholicism, consid- ered as an ecclesiastical organisation, was the undisputed mistress of Europe ; national feelings scarcely ever came into collision with its interests, and the whole current of affairs was directed by theology. When, however, the first breath- THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 107 ings of the spirit of Kationalism were felt in Europe, when, under the influence of that spirit, dogmatic interests Legau to wane, and their paramount importance to be questioned, a now tendency was manifested. The interests of the Church were subordinated to those of the State. Theology was ban- ished from department after department of politics, until the whole system of government was secularised. The period in which political affairs were most completely governed by theological considerations was unquestionably the age of the Crusades. It was no political anxiety about the balance of power, but an intense religious enthusiasm, that impelled the inhabitants of Christendom towards the city wliich was at once the cradle and the symbol of their faith. All interests were then absorbed, all classes Avero governed, all passions subdued or coloured by religious fervour. National animosities that had raged for centuries were pacified by its power. The intrigues of statesmen and the jealousies of kings disappeared beneath its influence. Nearly two millions of lives are said to have been sacrificed in the cause. Neglected governments, exhausted finances, depopidated countries, were cheerfully accepted as the price of success. No wars the world had ever before seen were so popular as these, which were at the same time the most dis- astrous and the most unselfish. Long before the Reformation such wars as the Crusades had become impossible, and the relative prominence of secu- lar policy had materially increased. This was in part the result of the better organisation of the civil government, which rendered unnecessary some of the services the Church had previously rendered to the community. Thus, when the general tolerance of private wars had produced a condition of anarchy that rendered all the relations of life insecure, the 108 EATIONALISM EST EUROPE. Churcli interiDOsed and proclaimed in tlie ekventh century the ' Truce of God,' wliicli Avas the first eifective barrier to the hiwlessness of the Tbarons. Her bishops became the arbi- trators of every quarrel, and succeeded in a great measure in calming the ferocity of the age. But when this object was in part attained, and when the regal power was consolidated, the Truce of God, in spite of many attemj)ts to revive it,* fell rapidly into desuetude, and the preservation of tranquillity passed from the ecclesiastical to the civil government. This is but a single example of a process that was continually going on during the latter half of the middle ages. The Church had formerly exercised nearly every function of the civil government, on account of the inefficiency of the lay governors; and every development of secular administration, while it relieved the ecclesiastics of a duty, deprived them of a source of poAver. But, besides the diminution of influence that resulted from this cause, the Church for many centuries found a strenuous antagonist in the regal power. The famous history of the investitures, and the equally remarkable, though less famous, ordinance by which in 1319 all bisho^DS were expelled from the Parliament of Paris, are striking examples of the energy with which the conflict was sustained. Its issue depended mainly on the superstition of the people. In a profoundly superstitious age neither skill nor resolution could resist the effects of an excommunication or an interdict, and the most illustrious monarchs of the middle ages succumbed beneath their power. But some time before the Reformation their terror was in a great measure destroyed. The rapid growth ' It was coafirmed as part of the general law of the Church by Alexander III. in 11*79. See Ducellier, Hlsf. dcs Classes Lahorieuses en France, pp. 87- 89, 12'7, 128. THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS. 109 of the industrial classes, "vvliicli were at all times sei^arated from theological tendencies, the revival of a spirit of bold and unshackled enquiry, and the discredit that had fallen upon the Church on account of the rival poj)es,* and of the corruj^tion of the monasteries, were the chief causes of the emancipation. The Reformation was only possible when the old superstitions had been enfeebled by the spirit of doubt, and diluted by the admixture of secular interests. Kings then availed themselves gladly of the opportunity of throw- ing off the restraints of the Papacy. Patriots rebelled against the supremacy of a foreign power. The lay classes wel- comed a change by which the pressure of the clergy was lightened. A comparison of the religious wars produced by the Re- formation with the Crusades shows clearly the great change that had passed over the spirit of Europe. Tlie Crusades had been purely religious. They represented solely the en- thusiasm of the people for dogmatic interests, and they were maintained for more than two centuries by an effort of unex- ampled self-sacrifice. In the religious wars, on the other hand, the secular and the ecclesiastical elements were very evenly balanced. The object sought was political power, but difference of religious belief formed the lines of demarca- tion separating the hostile coalitions, and created the enthusi- asm by which the struggle was maintained. The spirit of the theologian was sufficiently powerful to inundate Europe with blood, but only when united with the ambition of the politician. Yet dogmatic agreement still formed the prin- ciple of alliance, and all cooperation with heretics was deemed a sin. This i^hase of opinions continued for more than a century ' Mably, Observations sur Vllistoire dc Frarice, liv. iv. c. v. no KATIONALISM IN EUROPE. after the Reformation. It passed away under the pressxire of advancing civilisation, but not before the ministry of Riche- lieu ; for although Francis I. had made an alliance -witli the Turks, and a few otlier sovereigns had exhibited a similar indifference to the prevailing distinctions, tlieir policy was rarely successful. Even at the last, the change was only effected with considerable difficulty, and Italy, Spain, Ger- many, and the Netherlands swarmed with writings denounc- ing the alliance of the French with the Swedes as little short of an apostasy from Christianity. A book entitled '■liars Gallicus^ and published in 1635, under the pseudonyme of Alexander Patricius Ai-macanus, was especially singled out as the most conclusive demonstration of the sinfulness of al- liances with heretics, and it marks the first dawn of the repu- tation of one who was destined to exercise a deep and lasting influence over the fortunes of the Church. It was written by Jansenius, who owed to it his promotion to the bishopric of Ypres.^ But the genius of Richelieu, seconded by the intellec- tual influences of the age, prevailed over every difficulty ; and the Peace of "Westphalia is justly regarded as closing tlie era of religious wars. The invasion of Holland by Louis XIV. was near becoming one, and religious fanaticism has more than once lent its aid to other modern struggles ; ^ but wars like those which once distracted Europe have become almost im- possible. Among all the elements of affinity and repulsion that regulate the combinations of nations, dogmatic interests, which were once supreme, can scarcely be said to exist. Among all the possible dangers that cloud the horizon, none ' Avis aux Refugiez, p. 56 (ed. 1692). ' E. g. the recent invasion of Morocco by the Spaniards. On the religioua character Louis XIV. tried to give the invasion of Holland, see Michelet, Jjouis XIV. THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. Ill appears more improbable than a coalition formed upon the principle of a common belief, and designed to extend the sphere of its influence. Such coalitions were once the most serious occupations of statesmen. They now exist only in the speculations of the expounders of prophecy. It was in tins way that, in the course of a few centuries, the foreign policy of all civilised nations was completely and finally secularised. Wars that were once regarded as simple duties became absolutely impossible. Alliances that were once deemed atrocious sins became habitual and unchallenged. That which had long been the centre around which all other interests revolved, receded and disappeared, and a profound change in the actions of mankind indicated a profound change in their belief I have already noticed the decline of that religious perse- cution which was long the chief sign and measure of ecclesi- astical influence over the internal policy of nations. There is, however, one aspect of the Inquisition which I have not referred to, for it belongs to the subject of the present chapter — I mean its frequent hostility to the civil power. Before the thirteenth century, the cognisance of heresy was divided between the bishop and the civil magistrate. The Church proclaimed that it was a crime more deadly than any civil ofience, and that it should be punished according to its enormity; the bishop accused the heretic, and the magistrate tried and condemned him. During the earlier part of the middle ages, this arrangement, which had been that of the Theodosian Code, was accej)ted without difficulty. The civil government was then very submissive, and heretics almost unknown, the few cases that appeared being usually resolved into magic. When, however, at the close of the twelfth century, a spirit of rebellion against the Church liad 112 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. been widely diffused, the Popes perceived that some more energetic system was required, and among the measures that were devised the principal was the Inquisition, which was in- tended not merely to suppress heresy, but also to enlarge the circle of ecclesiastical jurisdiction. This new tribunal * was placed in the hands of the two religious orders of St. Dominick and St. Francis, and its first object was to monopolise the trials of cases of heresy. The bishop of the diocese had a certain position in the local tribu- nal, hut it was generally little more than Iionorary, and was entirely subordinate to that of the chief Inquisitor. The civil government was only represented by an 'Assessor,' and by some minor officers appointed by the Inquisitor himself, and its function was merely to execute those Avhom the ecclesias- tics had condemned. A third of the confiscated goods was bestowed uj)on the district w^here the trial took place, which in its turn Avas to bear the expenses of the confinement of the prisoners. To crown all, the society was centralised by the appointment of an Inquisitor-General at Rome, with whom all the branches of the tribunal were to be in constant com- munication. It is obvious that this organization, in addition to its re- ligious importance, had a very great political importance. It transferred to ecclesiastics a branch of jurisdiction which had always been regarded as belonging to the civil power, and it introduced into every country where it was acknowledged, a corporation of extraordinary powers entirely dependent on a foreign potentate. The Inquisitors early found a powerful, though somewhat encroaching, friend in the Emperor Fred- ' The relations of the Inquisition and the civil power have been admirably Bketched by Sarpi in a short work called Discorso delV Oricfine deW TJffiziush every jDrinciple which he believes to be true to its legit- imate consequences, regardless of the results which may follow. l!^othing can be more fatal in politics than a pre- ponderance of the philosophical, or in philosophy than a preponderance of the political sj)irit. In the first case, the ruler will find himself totally incapable of adapting his measures to the exigencies of exceptional circumstances ; he will become involved in inextricable difiiculties by the com- plexity of the phenomena he endeavours to reduce to order; and he will be in perpetual collision with public opinion. In the second case, the thinker will be continually harassed by considerations of expediency which introduce the bias of the will into what should be a purely intellectual process, and impart a timidity and a disingenuousness to the whole tone of his thoughts. There can, I think, be little doubt that this latter influence is at present acting most unfavourably upon THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 133 speculative opinions in conntries wliere political life is very powerful. A disinterested love of truth can hardly coexist with a strong political spirit. In all countries where the hahits of thought have been mainly formed by political life, wo may discover a disposition to make expediency the test of trutli, to close the eyes and turn away the mind from any ai'guments that tend towards a radical change, and above all to make utilitarianism a kind of mental perspective accord- ing to which the different parts of belief are magnified or diminished. All that has a direct influence upon the well- being of society is brought into clear relief; all that has only an intellectual importance becomes unrealised and in- operative. It is probable that the capacity for pursuing ab- stract truth for its own sake, which has given German think- ers so great an ascendency in Europe, is in no slight degree to be attributed to the political languor of their nation. This predisposition acts in different ways upon the pro- gress of Rationalism. It is hostile to it on account of the intense conservatism it produces, and also on account of ita opposition to that purely lihilosophical spirit to which Ra- tionalism seeks to subordinate all departments of speculative belief. It is favourable to it, inasmuch as it withdraws the minds of men from the doctrinal aspect of their faith to con- centrate them upon the moral aspect, which in the eyes of the politician as of the rationalist is infinitely the most im- portant. But probably the most important, and certainly the most beneficial, effect of political life is to habituate men to a true method of enquiry. Government in a constitutional country is carried on by debate, all the arguments on both sides aie brought forward with unrestricted freedom, and every news- paper reports in full what has been said against the princi 134 EATIONALISM IN EUEDPE. pies it advocates by the ablest men in the country. Men may study the debates of Parliament under the influence of a strong party bias, they may even pay more attention to the statements of one party than to those of the other, but Lhey never imagine that they can form an opinion by an ex- clusive study of -what has been -written on one side. The two views of every question are placed in juxtaposition, and every one who is interested in the subject examines both. When a charge is brought against any politician, men natu- rally turn to his reply before foinning an opinion, and they feel that any other course would be not only extremely fool- ish, but also extremely dishonest. This is the spirit of truth as opposed to the spirit of falsehood and imposture, which in all ages and in all departments of thought has discouraged men from studying opposing systems, lamented the circula- tion of adverse arguments, and denounced as criminal those who listen to them. Among the higher order of intellects, the first spirit is chiefly cultivated by those philosophical studies which discipline and strengthen the mind for re- search. But what philosophy does for a very few, political life does, less perfectly, indeed, but still in a great degree, for the many. It diflTuses abroad not only habits of acute reason- ing, but also, what is far more important, habits of impartial- ity and intellectual fairness, wliicli will at last be carried into all forms of discussion, and will destroy every system that refuses to accept them. Tear after year, as political life extends, we find each new attempt to stifle the expression of opinion received with an increased indignation, the sym- pathies of the people immediately enlisted on behalf of the oppressed teacher, and the work vrhich is the object of con- demnation elevated in public esteem often to a degree that is flxr greater than it deserves. Year after year the convio THE SECULArJSATIOi^ OF POLITICS. 135 tion becomes more general, that a provisional abnegation of the opinions of the past and a resolute and unflinching im- partiality are among the highest duties of the enquirer, and that he who shrinks from such a research is at least mor- ally bound to abstain from condemning the opinions of his neighbour. If we may generalise the experience of modern constitu- tional governments, it Avould appear that this process must pass through three phases. When political life is introduced into a nation that is strongly imbued with sectarianism, tliis latter spirit will at first dominate over political interests, and the whole scope and tendency of government will be direct- ed by theology. After a time the movement I have traced in the present chapter will appear. The secular element will emerge into light. It will at length obtain an absolute ascendency, and, expelling theology successively from all its political strongholds, will thus weaken its influence over tlie human mind. Yet in one remarkable way the spirit of sec- tarianism will still survive : it will change its name and object transmigrate into political discussion, and assume the form of an intense party-spirit. The increasing tendency, how- ever, of political life seems to be to weaken or eftace this spirit, and in the more advanced stages of free government it almost disappears. A judicial spirit is fostered which leads men both in politics and theology to eclecticism, to judge all questions exclusively on the ground of their intrinsic merits, and not at all according to their position in theologi- cal or political systems. To increase the range and intensity of political interests is to strengthen this tendency; and every extension of the suffrage thus difluses over a wider circle a habit of thought that must eventually modify theo- logical belief If the suffrage should ever be o-ranted to i'36 EATIO]SrALISM EST EUEOPE. women, it would probably, after two or three generations, effect a complete revolution in their habits of thought, which by acting upon the first period of education would influence the whole course of opinion. Such then have been some of the leading tendencies pro- duced by that purely secular political spirit which is itself a result of the declining influence of theology. It now remains for us to examine the second branch of our subject — the sec- ularisation of the basis or principle of authority upon which all political structures rest. In the course of the last few years a great many insurrec- tions of nations against their sovereigns have taken place, which have been regarded with warm approval by the pub- lic opinion of the most advanced nations in Europe. Some countries have cast off their rulers in order by coalescing to form one powerful State, others because those rulers were tyrannical or incapable, others because the system of their government had grown antiquated, and others in order to realise some historical nationality. In many cases the de- posed rulers had been bound to their people by no distinct stipulations, had violated no law, and had been guilty of no extraordinary harshness. The simple ground upon which these changes were justified was that the great majority of the nation desired them, and that ground has generally been acquiesced in as sufficient. To exhibit in the plainest form the change that has come over public opinion, it may be suf- ficient to say that for many centuries all such insurrections would have been regarded by theologians as mortal sins, and all who jDarticipated in them as in danger of perdition. The teaching of the early Fathers on the subject is per- fectly unanin^.ous and unequivocal. Without a single excep- tion, all who touched upon the subject pronounced active re THE SECULAEISATIOSr OF POLITICS. 13T sistance to the established authorities to be under all circum- stances sinful. If the law enjoined wliat was wrong, it should be disobeyed, but no vice and no tyranny could justi- fy revolt.* This doctrine was taught in the most emphatic terms, not as a counsel of expediency applicable to special circumstances, but as a moral principle universally binding upon the conscience. It was taught in the midst of the most horrible persecutions. It was taught when the Christians were already extremely numerous, and their forbearance, notwithstanding their numbers, was constantly claimed as a merit.' So harmonious and so emphatic are the Patristic testimonies upon the subject, that the later theologians who adopted other views have been utterly unable to adduce any passages in their support, and have been reduced to the mel- ancholy expedient of virtually accusing the early Christians of hypocrisy, by maintaining that, notwithstanding the high moral tone they assumed on the subject, the real cause of their submission was their impotence,' or to the ludicrous expedient of basing a system of liberal politics on the in- vectives of Cyril and Gregory Nazianzen against the memory of Julian.* * See Gi'otius, De Jure Belli et Facts, lib. i. cap. 4 ; Taylor, Dudor Dubi- tantium, lib. iii. cap, 3, and also the list of authorities cited by Gregory XVI. in his bull to the Bishops of Poland, ' concerning the maxims of the Catholic Church on submission to the civil power ' ; Lameunais, Affaires de Rome, pp. 308-317. But perhaps the fullest exposition of the Patristic sentiments on the subject is in a very able book called Sacro-Sancta Regum Majestas, pub- lished at Oxford at the beginning of the Great Rebellion. "^ Striking instances of this are given hy Grotius, Be Jure, lib. i. c. iv. § Y. ' This has been maintained among others by Milton and Gronovius among the Protestants, and by Bellarmine and (in more modern times) by Bianchi among the Catholics. See Bianchi, Traits de la Puissance EccUsiastique (trad. Peltier, Paris, 1857), torn. i. pp. 639-642. •* This appears to have been a favourite argument of the French Prot- estants : Avis anx litfugiez sur ''ear procha'm Retoicr en France, p. 43. To 138 EATIOXALISM EST EUEOPE. It is manifest that such a doctrine is absolutely iucorapat' ible with political liberty. 'A limited monarcli,' as even the Tory Plume admitted, ' who is not to be resisted when he exceeds his limitations, is a contradiction in terms.' Besides, in almost every case, the transition from an absolute to a limited monarchy has been the result of the resistance of the people ; and the whole course of history abundantly proves that power, when once enjoyed, is scarcely ever voluntarily relinquished. From these considerations Grotius and many other writers have concluded that a Christian people, when oppressed by tyi'ants, is bound to sacrifice its hopes of libei*- ty to its faith, while Shaftesbury and his followers have de- nounced Christianity as incompatible with freedom. But to those who regard the history of the Church not as one homo- geneous whole, but as a series of distinct phases, the attitude of its early leaders will appear very different. For the first condition of liberty is the establishment of some higher principle of action than fear. A government that rests on material force alone must always be a tyranny, whatever may be the form it assumes ; and at the time Christianity be- came supreme the Koman Empire was rapidly degenerating into that fi-ightful condition. Increasing corruption had de- stroyed both the tie of religion and the tie of patriotism, and the army was the sole arbiter of the destinies of the State. After a time the invasion of the barbarians still further ag- these the Galilean Catholics replied that Julian was dead when the invectives v/ere delivered. Ililary, however, inveighed vehemently against the Arian Emperor Constantius, in the lifetime of the latter ; and Bianchi, m a very in- genious fashion, argues from this that Constantius must have been virtually deposed on account of his heresy, for respect to lawful sovereigns is among the plainest duties ; and as St. Hilary called Constantius ' a precursor of Anti- christ,' ' a rascal,' and ' an object of malediction,' &c., &c., it may be inferred that he did not regard him as his lawful sovereign. {Puissance EccL, torn. L pp. 651, 652.) THE SECDLAKISATION OF POLITICS. 139 gravated the situation. Hordes of savages, fresh from a life of unbounded freedom, half-frenzied by the sudden acquisi- tion of immense wealth, and belonging to many different tribes, were struggling fiercely for the mastery. Society was almost resolved into its primitive elements; force had become the one measure of dignity. Alone amid these dis- cordant interests the Christians taught by their precepts and their examj^le the obligation of a moral law, and habituated men to that respect for authority and that exercise of self- restraint Avhich form the basis of every lasting political struc- ture. Had they followed the examj)le of others, they might probably have more than once saved themselves from fright- ful persecutions, and Avould have certainly become a formi- dable power in the State long before the accession of Constan- tine. But, guided by a far nobler instinct, they chose in- stead to constitute themselves the champions of legality, they irradiated submission with a purer heroism than has ever glowed around the conqueror's path, and they kept alive the sacred flame at a time when it had almost vanished from the earth. We may say that they exaggerated their principle, but such exaggeration was absolutely essential to its efficacy. The temjDtations to anarchy and insubordina- tion were so great, that had the doctrine of submission been stated with any qualifications, had it been stated in any but the mosi emphatic language, it would have proved inopera- tive. Indeed, what cause for resistance could possibly have been more just than the joersecutions of a Nero or a Diocle- tian ? Yet it was in the reign of Nero that St. Paul incul- cated in unequivocal language the doctrine of passive obe- dience; and it was the boast of Tertullian and other of the Fathers, that at a time Avhen Rome was swarming with Christians, the most horrible persecutions were endured liO EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. without a murmur or a struggle. Sucli conduct, if adopted as a binding precedent, would arrest the whole development of society ; but, considered in its own place in history, it is impossible to overvalue it. 15esides this, it should be remembered that the early Church had adopted a system of government that was based upon the most democratic princij)les. It can be no exagger- ation to say, that if the practice of electing bishops by uni- versal suffrage had continued, the habits of freedom would have been so diffused among the people, that the changes our own age has witnessed might have been anticij)ated by many centuries, and might have been effected under the direct patronage of Catholicism. This, however, Avas not to be. The system of episcopal election was far in advance of the age, and the disorders it produced were so great that it was soon found necessary to abolish it. At the same time many circumstances pointed out the Roman See as the natu- ral centre of a new form of organisation. The position Rome occupied in the world, the increasing authority of the bishop resulting from the transfer of the civil ruler to Constantino- ple, the admirable administrative and organising genius the Roman ecclesiastics had inherited from the Emj)u-e, their sustained ambition, the splendour cast upon the see by the genius and virtues of St. Gregory and St. Leo, the conversion of the barbarians, the destruction of the rival sees of Jerusa- lem, Antioch, and Alexandria, and the Greek schism — all tended to revive in another form the empire Rome had so long exercised over the destinies of mankind. "When the Papal power was fully organised, and during the whole of the period that elapsed between that time and the Reformation, the rights of nations against their sover- eigns may be said to have bppn almost unnoticed. The THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. lil great question concerning the principle of authority lay in the conflicting claims of temporal sovereigns and of popes. Although the power the latter claimed and often exercised over the former has produced some of the most fearful calam- ities, although we owe to it in a great degree the Crusades and religious persecution, and many of the w^orst features of the semi-religious struggles that convulsed Italy during the middle ages, there can be no question that it was on the whole favourable to liberty. The simple fact that nations acknowledged two different masters was itself a barrier to despotism, and the Church had always to appeal to the sub- jects of a sovereign to enforce its decisions against him. There was therefore a certain bias among ecclesiastics in favour of the people, and it must be added that the medieval popes almost always belonged to a far higher grade of civil- isation than their opponents. Whatever may have been their faults, they represented the cause of moral restraint, of intelligence, and of humanity, in an age of j)hysical force, ignorance, and barbarity. It is not necessary to follow in detail the history of the encroachments of the spiritual upon the civil power, or to enter into the interminable controversies about the power of deposition. Such topics are only connected indirectly with the subject of the present chapter, and they have been treated with great ability by several well-known writers.' There ^ A clear secular view of the subject is given by Mr. Hallam, in the chapter on the ' Increase of Ecclesiastical Authority,' in his Hist, of (lie Middle Ages. It has also been examined very fully by Bossuet, from a Galilean point of view, in his Defence of the Articles of the Gcdlican Church, and from an Ultramon- tane point of view by Bianchi, On Ecclesiastical Power. This last book, which is a work of exceedingly extensive learning, but of imdisguised and indeed dishonest partiality, was pubhshed originally in Italian in 1745, and directed especially against the opmions of Giannone. The French translation was made in 1857, and consists of two (in every sense of the word) most 142 EATIOJVALISM IN EUEOPE. are, however, two points connected with them to which it may be advisahle to refer. In the first place, in judging the question as to the right of the Pope to depose sovereigns, it is evident that the advantage must have always remained with the former, in an age in which he was himself regarded as the final arbiter of moral questions. Every conclusion was then arrived at not by way of reasoning but by way of authority, and, with the very doubtful exception of general councils, there was no higher authority than tlie Pope. General councils too were rare occurrences ; they could only be convened by the Pope, and in the majority of cases they were the creatures of his will. When a bull of excommuni- cation had been launched, the sovereign against whom it was directed might indeed assemble a council of the bishops of his own people, and they might condemn the excommunica- tion ; but, however strong might be their arguments, their authority was necessarily inferior to that which was opposed to them. They might appeal to the declarations of the Fathers, but the right of interpreting those declarations rest- ed with the Church, of which the Pope was, in fact, the au- thoritative representative, Nor had he any difficulty in this respect. If it was said that the early bishops enjoined abso- lute submission to the pagan persecutors, it was answered that this was an irrelevant argument, for the Church only claimed the power of deposing those who by baptisiu were placed under her dominion. If it was rejoined that the same submission was shown under Constantius or Yalens or Julian, the reply was that the weakness of the Christians was the cause of their resignation, and that the fact of the Church possessing the power of excommunication did not ponderoas volumes. It is now the great standard work of the Ultramontane party. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 143 at all imply that she was bound on every legitimate occasion to exercise it. If, in fine, the passages in which the Fathers dilated upon the sinfulness of all rebellion against the sover- eign were adduced, it Avas answered that the Po^De exhorted no one to such rebellion, for by the sentence of deposition the sovereign had been deprived of his sovereignty.' In this way the Patristic utterances were easily evaded, and the ec- clesiastical authority of the Pope made it almost a heresy to question his claims. In the next place, it should be observed that this doctrine of deposition was not so much an isolated assumption on the part of the Popes as a logical and necessary inference from other parts of the teaching of the Church. The point on which the controversies between Catholics on this subject have chiefly turned is the right of the Popes to condemn any notorious criminal to public penance, a sentence which in- volved the deprivation of all civil functions, and therefore in the case of a sovereign amounted to deposition.* But wdie- ther or not this right was always acknowledged in the Church, there can be little doubt that the power which was generally conceded to the ecclesiastical authorities of relax- ing or annulling the obligation of an oath necessarily led to their political ascendency, for it is not easy to see how those who acknowledged the existence of this power could make an exception in favour of the oath of allegiance. When the rise of the scholastic philosophy had intro- duced into Christendom a general passion for minute defini- ' As one of the leading supporters of the Papal party put it with amusing coolness : ' Certe licet Paulas dixerit " oranis anima potestatibus sublimioribua eubdita sit " nunquam addidit, etiam potestatibus excommunicatis vel depri- vatis a papa.' (Suarez, Be Fide, Ub. vi. cap. 4.) * Bianchi, Puissance EccUsiastique, torn. i. pp. SSO-S'Jl. Louis le Debon. naire seems to have been deposed in this way. 144 EATIOJ^ALISM IN EU.ROPE. tioDS, and for the organisation and elaboration of all depart- ments of theology, the attitude of hostility the Church had for some time exhibited towards the civil power was more or less reflected in the writings that were produced. St. Thomas Aquinas, indeed, the ablest of all these theologians, distinctly asserts the right of subjects to withhold their obedience from rulers who were usurpers or unjust ; ^ but this opinion, which was probably in advance of the age, does not appear to have been generally adopted, or at least generally promulgated. The right of popes to depose princes who had fallen into heresy was, however, at this time constantly asserted.^ To the schoolmen too Ave chiefly owe the definition of the doc- trine of the mediate character of the Divine Right of Kings, which is very remarkable in the history of opinions as the embryo of the jwinciples of Locke and Rousseau. It was universally admitted that both popes and kings derived their authority from the Deity, and from this fact the royal advo- cates inferred that a pope had no more power to depose a king than a king to depose a pope. But, according to some of the schoolmen, there was this distinction between the cases : a pope was directly and immediately the representa- tive of the Almighty, but a king derived his power directly from the people. Authority, considered in the abstract, is ' ' PriDciijibus sa;cularibus in tantum homo obedire tenetur in quantum ordo justitiffi requirit. Et ideo si non habeant justum principatum sed usurpatum, vel si injusta prajcipiant, non tenentur eis subditi obedire, nisi forte per aecidens propter vitandum saandalum vel periculum.' {Summa, Pars II. Quasst. civ. art. 6.) - Bossuet simply remarks that for some centuries after St. Thomas the schoolmen seem to have been nearly unanimous on this point, but that it is manifest that they were mistaken! (See Bianchi, tom. i. pp. 135, 136.) The writer among the schoolmen who was most favourable to liberty was the Eng- lishman William of Ockham. (Milman, Hist, of Latin Chrutianity, vol. vi. pp. 470-4'7-±.) THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 145 of Divine origin; and when the people had raised a particu- lar family to the throne, the sanction of the Deity rested upon its members, but still the direct and immediate source of regal power was the nation/ Although this doctrine was not asserted in the popular but in the Papal interest, and al- though it was generally held that the people, having trans- ferred their original autliority to the sovereign, were incapa- ble of recalling it, except perhaps in such extreme cases as when a sovereign had sought to betray to a foreign power the country he ruled, it is not the less certain that we have here the first link of a chain of principles that terminated in the French Revolution. After all, however, it is rather a matter of curiosity than of importance to trace among the vast mass of speculations bequeathed to us by the schoolmen the faint outlines of a growing liberalism. Whatever may have been the opinions of a few monkish speculators, however splendid may have been the achievements of a few industrial half-sceptical re- publics,^ it was not till the Reformation tliat the rights of na- ^ Suarez, De Fide, lib. iii. cap. 2 ; Bianchi, ch. i. These theologians of course endeavour to trace back their distinction to the origin of Christianity, but its formal definition and systematic euforceraeut are due mainly to the schoolmen. * The political influence of the Italian republics upon English public opin- ion was very powerful in the seventeenth century, when the habit of travelling became general among the upper class of Englishmen, and when a large pro- portion of the highest intellects acquired in Italy a knowledge of the Italian writers on government, and an admiration for the Itahan constitutions, and especially for that of Venice. The highest representative of this action of tha Italian upon the English intellect was Harrington. His Oceana, though pub- lished under the Commonwealth and dedicated to Cromwell, was altogether uninfluenced by the inspiration of Puritanism ; and it was only by the inter- cession of Cromwell's favourite daughter, Lady Claypole, that its pubUcatiou was permitted. (Toland, Life of Harrington.) It is remarkable that while Harrington's writings were avowedly based in a very great degree upon those of Italians, they also represent more faithfully than any others of the seveu- AOL. 11. — 36 146 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. tionalities became a great question in Europe. The spirit ol insuljordination created by the struggle, and tlie numeroug important questions which Protestantism submitted to the adjudication of the multitude, predisposed the people to en- large the limits of their power; while the countless sects that Avere appealing to popular favour, and the frequent op- position of belief between the governors and the governed, ensured a full discussion of the subject. The result of this was the creation of a great variety of opinions, the views of each sect being determined mainly by its circumstances, or, in other words, by the predisposition resulting from its interests. If vv'e begin our review with the Ultramontane party in the Church of Rome, which especially represented the opinions of the Popes, we find that it was confronted with two great facts. In the first place, a multitude of soA'ereigns had embraced Protestantism simply to emancipate them- selves from Papal control ; and in the next place, the Cath- olic popiilation in several countries w^as sufficiently numerous to resist with some chance of success their Protestant rulers. The points, therefore, which were most accentuated in the teaching of the writers of this school, w-ere the power of the teenth century what are regarded as the distinctive merits of English liberty. That a good government is an organism, not a mechanism — in other words, that it must grow naturally out of the condition of society, and cannot be unposed by theorists — that representative assembhes with full powers are the sole effi- cient guardians of liberty — that liberty of conscience must be allied with polit- ical hberty — that a certain balance should be preserved between the different powers of the State, and that property produces empire, are among the main propositions on which Harrington insists ; and most of them arfe even now the main points of difference between English liberty and that which emanates from a French source. Harrington was also a warm advocate of the ballot. He was answered by Feme, Bishop of Chester, in a book called Pian-Fiano; by Matthew Wren, sou of the Bishop of Ely ; and in the Holy Commonwealth of Baxter. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. liY Pope to depose sovereigns, especially for heresy, and the riglit of the people to resist an heretical ruler. The vigour with which these propositions Vv'cre maintained is sufficiently illustrated by the dealings of the Popes with the English Govei-nment ; and the arguments in their support were em- bodied by Cardinal Bellarmine in his treatise ' On the Su- premacy of the Sovereign Pontiff over Temporal Affairs,' and by the famous Jesuit Suarez in his ' Defence of the Faith.' The Parliament of Paris ordered the first of these works to be burnt in 1610, and the second in 1614. The most ardent and by far the most able champions of Ultramontanism were the Jesuits, who, however, went so far beyond the other theologians in their principles that they may be justly regarded as a separate class. The marvellous flex- ibility of intellect and the profound knowledge of the world tliat then at least characterised their order, soon convinced them that the exigencies of the conflict Avere not to be met by following the old precedents of the Fathers, and that it was necessary to restrict in every way the overgrown power of the sovereigns. They saw, what no others in the Catholic Church seem to have perceived, that a great future was in store for the people, and they laboured with a zeal that will secure them everlasting honour to hasten and direct the emancipation. By a system of the boldest casuistry, by a fearless use of their private judgment in all matters which the Church had not strictly defined, and above all by a skil- ful employment and expansion of some of the maxims of the schoolmen, they succeeded in disentangling themselves from the traditions of the past, and in giving an impulse to liber- alism wherever their influence extended. Suarez, in the book to which I have just referred, devoted himself especially to the question of the mediate or immediate nature of the Divine 148 SATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. Right of Kings.' It -was a question, he acknowledged, that could not be decided either Iby Scrij^ture or the Fathers ; but the schoolmen were on the whole favourable to the latter view, and the Popes had often asserted their own authority over sovereigns, which, according to Ultramontane princi- ples, was almost decisive of the question. He elaborated the doctrine of the ' social contract' with such skill and em- phasis as to place the sovereign altogether upon a lower level than the nation, while the Pope towered over all. Accord- ing to these principles, the interests of the sovereign should be subordinated to those of the people. The king derived all his power immediately from the State ; and in a case of extreme misgovernment, when the j)reservation of the State required it, the nation might depose its sovereign,^ aud might, if necessary, depute any person to kill him.' The case of an heretical prince was still plainer ; for heresy being a revolt against that Divine authority to which the sovereign ulti- mately owed his power, it in a certain sense annulled his title to the throne. Still, as the Pope was the arbiter of these * Suarez, De Fide, lib. iii. cap. 2. This book of Suarez was written in reply to one by James I. of England. ^ He says that ' Potestatem banc deponendi regem esse posse vel in ipsa republica vel in Summo Pontifice, diverse tamen modo. Nam in republica solum per modum defensionis necessarise ad conservationem suam, . . . turn ex vi juris naturalis quo licet vim vi repellere, turn quia semper hie casus ad propriam reipublicse conservationem necessarius, intelligitur exceptus in primo illo foedere quo respublica potestatem suam in regem transtulit. . . . At vero in Summo Pontifice est hfec potestas tanquam in superiori habcnte jurisdictionem ad corripicndum reges.' {De Fide, lib. vi. cap. iv.) ' 'Ergo quando respublica juste potest regem deponere, recte faciunt minis- tri ejus regem cogendo vel interficiendo si sit necesse.' (Jbid.) Suarez adds, however, that before pronouncmg a sentence of deposition against the sov- ereign, it is at least advisable and becoming (though not absolutely necessary) for the nation to apply to the Pope for his sanction. This notion has been developed at length by De Maistre, Le Pape. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 149 questious, a sentence of deposition shonkT precede rebellion ' The Pope had the power of issuing this sentence on two grounds — because he was the superior of the temporal ruler, and also because heresy was a crime which fell under his cognisance, and which was worthy of temporal penalties. To deny that the Pope could inflict such penalties on heretics, no matter what may be their rank, is to fall under the suspicion of heresy;* to deny that death is a natural punishment for heresy was to assail the whole system of persecution which the Church had organised. In defending this doctrine against the charges brought against it on the ground of its dangerous consequences, Suarez maintained that the deposed king could only be killed by those whom the Pope had ex- pressly authorised ; ^ but there can be little doubt that the Jesuits looked with a very indulgent eye on all attempts at assassination tliat were directed against a deposed sovereign who was in opposition to the Church. It would, however, be a mistake to suppose that the Je- suits advocated liberal principles only with a view to theo- logical advantages, or in Protestant countries, or under the shelter of ecclesiastical authorities. More than once they maintained even theii' most extreme forms in the midst of Catholic nations, and, strange as the assertion may appear, it is in this order that we find some of the most rationalistic in- tellects of the age. Two of the leading characteristics of a ^ ' Statim per hteresim rex ipso facto privatur aliquo modo dominio et pro- piietate sui regni, quia vel confiscatum manet vel ad legitimum successorem Catholicum ipso jure transit, et nihilominus non potest statitn regno privari, Bed juste illud possidet et administrat donee per sententiam saltern declara- toriam crimiuis condemnetur.' (Lib. vi. cap. iv.) ^ Bianchi has collected a striking chain of passages in defence of this pro- position (torn, i. pp. 145-14'7). ^ ' Si Papa regcm deponat, ab illis tautum poterit expelli vel iuterfici qmbus ipse id commiserit.' {De Fide, hb. vi. c. iv.) 150 EATIONALISM UJ EUKOPE. rationalistic mind, as we have already seen, are a love of ap pealing to the general principles of natural religion rather than to dogmatic tenets, and a disposition to wrest the latter into conformity with the former ; and of these two tendencies Avc find among the Jesuits some striking examples. The fa- mous work of Mariana ' Concerning the King and the Regal Institution ' will furnish us with an illustration of these truths. This extremely remarkable hook was published at Toledo in 1599, and it bears at its commencement the apiH'obation of the leaders of the Jesuits.* It was dedicated to Philip III., for whose benefit it was written ; and it must be acknowl- edged that, among the countless works that have been dedi- cated to sovereigns, it would be impossible to find one more free from the taint of adulation. Its ostensible object was to collect a series of moral precepts for the benefit of sover- eigns, but the really important part, and that with which we are alone concerned, is the examination of the rights of na- tions against their sovereigns. The cardinal point upon which this examination turns is a distinction which some of the schoolmen had derived from Aristotle, and which became very prominent in the beginning of the seventeenth century, between a king and a tyrant, as two things almost generi- cally different. A ruler who belonged to the latter class had no right to the name of king, nor could he claim the privi- leges or the reverence attached to it ; and to be a tyrant, as Mariana exj)lained, it was not necessary to be a usurj)er.' Every ruler, however legitimate, belongs to this category if the main principle of his government is selfishness, and if he habitually sacrifices the interests of his people to his lusts or » It is signed by Stephanus Hojecla, Visitor of the Jesuits in the province. of Toledo. ' Be Rege et Regis Itistihdione, pp. 55-65. (1st ed.) THE SECULAEISATIOISr OF POLITICS. 151 to bis pride. Such rulers are the worst of evils, the enemies of tlie huma-n race. They had been figured by the ancients in the fables of AntcTSus, the Iljdra, and the Chimera, and thfc greatest achievements of the heroes of antiquity had been their destruction.' This being the case, the important question arose, whether it is no'sv lawful to kill a tyrant ? * That there should be no equivocation as to the nature of the inquiry, Mariana takes for his text the recent assassination of Henry III. of France by Clement. He relates, in a tone of evident admiration, how this young Dominican, impelled by a religious enthu- siasm, and having fortified his courage by the services of the Church, had contrived to obtain an interview with the king, had stabbed him to death with a poisoned knife, and had himself fallen beneath the swords of the attendants. ' Thus,' he says, ' did Clement perish as many deem the eternal honour of France — a youth but four-and-twenty years of age, simple in mind and weak in body; but a higher might confirmed both his courage and his strength.' ' In examining the moral character of this act, there was a great division of opinion. Very many extolled it as worthy of immortality ; others, however, whose learning and sagacity were not to be despised, severely condemned it. They said that it was not lawful for a single unauthorised individual to condemn and slaiighter the consecrated ruler of a nation ; that David did not dare to slay his bitterest enemy because that enemy was the Lord's Anointed; that amid all the per- eecutions tlie early Church underwent, no Christian hand * Be Rege et Regis Instltutione, p. 62. ■■' Ibid. lib. i. ch. vi. ' An tyrannum opprimcre fas sit ? ' * P. 69. Mr. Hallam observes tliat tlie words 'seternum Gallise decus* were omitted in the later editions, which, however, in other respects scarcelj differed from the first. (//,'«/. of Lit.) 152 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. was ever raised against the monsters who filled the throne j that political assassinations have, in the great majority of cases, injured the cause they were meant to serve, and that if their legitimacy were admitted, all resj^ect for sovereigns would vanish and universal anarchy would ensue. ' Such,' added Mariana, ' are the arguments of those wdio espouse the cause of the tyrant, but the champions of the people can urge others that are not less numerous or less powerful.' ' He then proceeds, in a strain that leaves no doubt as to his own opinion, to enumerate the arguments for tyrannicide. The people had conceded a certain measure of their power to their sovereign, but not in such a manner that they did not themselves retain a greater authority, and might not at any time recall what they had given if it was misused.' The common voice of mankind had enrolled the great tyranni- cides of the past among the noblest of their race. Who ever censured the acts or fliiled to admire the heroism of Harmo- dius or Aristogeiton or Brutus, or of those who freed their land from the tyranny of a Domitian, a Caracalla, or a He- liogabalus ? And what was this common sentiment but the voice of nature that is within us, teaching us to distinguish what is right from what is Avrong ? ' If some ferocious beast had been let loose upon the land, and was devastating all around him, Avho would hesitate to applaud the man who, at ' P. 12. ^ ' Certe a republica unde ortum habet rcgia potestas, rebus exigentibua Regem ia jus vocari posse et si sanitatem respuat principatu spoliari. Xeque ita in principem jura potestatis transtulit ut non sibi majorem resei-vaiit potes- tatem. . . . Populis volentibus tributa nova imperantur, leges coustitu- untur ; et quod est amplius populi Sacramento jura imperandi quamvis hieredi- taria successori conflrmantur ' (pp. 72, IZ). Very remarkable words to bave been written by a Spaniard and a priest nearly a century before Locke. ' 'Et est communis sensus quasi quaedam naturae vox mentibus nostril indita, auribus insonans lex, qua a turpi houestum secernimus.' (p. '74.) THE SECULARISATION" OF POLITICS 153 the risk of his life, had ventured to slay it ? Or what words would be deemed too strong to brand the coward who re- mained a passive si:)ectator while his mother or the wife of his soul was torn and crushed ? Yet the most savage animal is but an inadequate image of a tyrant, and neither wife nor mothei' has so high a claim upon our affections as our country.^ These wei-e the chief arguments on either side, and it remained to draw the conclusion. The task, Mariana assures us, is not difficult, but it is necessary to distinguish between different cases. In the first place, the tyrant may be a con- queror who by force of arms, and without any appeal to the people, had obtained possession of the sovereign power. In this case there was no obscarity : the examj^le of Ehud Avas a guide, and the tyrant might be justly slain by any of the people. '^ The next case was that of a sovereign elected by the nation, or who had obtained his throne by hereditary right, but who sacrificed his people to his lusts, infringed the laws, deSj)ised true religion, and preyed upon the fortunes of his subjects. If there existed in the nation any authoritative assembly of the j)eople, or if such an assembly could be con- voked, it should warn the sovereign of the consequences of his acts, declare war against him if he continued obdurate, and, if no other resource remained, pronounce him to be a public enemy and authorise any individual to slay him.^ If ' Pp. 72-V4. ^ ' la eo consentire turn philosophos turn tbeologos video earn principem tpii vi et ai-mis remiiublicam occupavit nuUo prseterea jure, nullo publico civium consensu, perimi a quocumque, vita et principatu spoliari posse.' (pp. 74, 75.) A few lines lower comes the eulogy of Ehud. The ' consenting theologians ' are not cited — and, indeed, Mariana scarcely ever quotes an ecclesiastical authority — but the reader may find a great many given in Suarez {De Fide, lib. vi. cap. iv.). St. Thomas justified Ehud on this general ground, and in this point seems to have differed little or not at all from Mariana. ^ ' Si medieinam respuat prineeps, neque spes ulla sanitatis rcUuquatur, 154 RATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. in the last place the king who had degenerated into a tyiant had supressed the right of assemhly, no steps should he taken unless the tyranny -was flagrant, unquestionable, and intoler- ahle ; but if this "were so, the iudiTidual who, interpreting the wishes of the people, slew the sovereign should be applauded.* Nor was this doctrine likely to lead to as many tragedies as was supposed. ' Happy indeed would it be for mankind were there many of such imflinching resolution as to sacrifice life and happiness for the liberty, of their country ; but the desire of safety withholds most men from great deeds, and this is why of the great multitude of tyrants so few have perished by the sword.' ' It is, however, a salutary thought for princes to dwell upon, that if they oppress their i^eople and make themselves intolerable by their vices, to slay them is not only without guilt, but is an act of the highest merit.'" There was, however, one aspect of the question of tyran- nicide which presented to the mind of our author consider- able difficidty, and to which he devoted a separate chapter. That to slay a tyrant with a dagger was a meritorious act he was perfectly convinced, but to mingle poison with his food was a somewhat different matter. This distinction, Mariana tells us incidentally, was first suggested to him, many years before the publication of the book, by one of his scholars, when, as a public instructor, he was impressing his doctrines sententia pronunciata licebit rcipublicffi ejus impeiium detrcctare primum, et quoniam bellum necessario concitabitur ejus defendendi consilia explicare. . . . Et si res feret neque aliter se respublica tueri possit, eodem defensionis jure ac vcro potiore auctoritate et propria, principem publicum hostem declaratum ferro pcrimere. Eademque facultas esto cuicumque private, qui spe impunita- tis abjecta, ncglecta salute, ia eonatum juvandi rempublicam iiigredi voluerit.' (p. V6.) ' 'Qui TOtis publicis favens cum pcrimere tentarit, haudquaquam iniq'.ie eum fecisse existimabo.' (p. 11.) « Pp. 11, 18. THE SECULAKISATI02f OF POLITICS. 155 upon the youth of Sicily.' The way in which he resolves it IS very remarkable, as exhibiting the modes of thought or reasoning from which these speculations sprang. He in the first place shows very clearly that nearly every argument that justifies the one mode of slaughter may be also urged in favour of the other ; but notwithstanding this he concludes that poison should be prohibited, because he says it is pro- hibited by that common sentiment of mankind which is the voice of nature and the test of right.^ The docti'ine of tyrannicide, of which Mariana may be regarded as the chief apostle, is one that is eminently fitted to fascinate men who are just emerging out of a protracted servitude, and who have not yet learned to calculate the ulterior consequences of political acts. To slay a royal crim- inal, who, for the gratification of his own insatiable vanity, is causing the deaths of thousands of the innocent, and blast- ing the prosperity of his nation, is an act that seems at first sight both laudable and useful, especially if that sovereign had violated the obligations by which he had bound himself. A man who has committed an act of treason, which the law would punish by death, has incurred a penalty and retained ' P. 83. ^ ' Nos tamen non quid facturi sint homines sed quid per naturae leges con- cessum sit despicimus. . . . Et est naturae vox communis hominum sen- sns vituperantium si quis in alios quantumvis hostes veneno grassetur,' (pp. 83-83.) It is said that Mariana, in his History, has treated kings with consid- erable deference ; but his anti-monarchical opinions appear very strongly in a short work called ' Discourse on the Defects of the Government of the Jesuits,' which contains — what is extremely rare in the writings of the members of the order — a bitter attack on the general, and a fierce denunciation of the despotic principles on which the society is constituted. The following (which I quote from a French translation of 1625) is very characteristic : — 'Selon mon opinion la monarchic nous met par terre, non pour estre monarchic ains pour n'estre bien temperee. C'est un furieux sanglier qui ravage tout par oii il passe, ct si on ne I'arreste tout court, nous ne devons espcrer de repos.' (ch. x.) 156 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. a privilege. The penalty is that he should be put to death ; the privilege is that he should only be put to death by the constituted, authorities and in the legal way. But if in addi- tion to his original crime he has paralysed the law that should avenge it, it may plausibly be argued that he has forfeited his privilege : he has placed, himself above the law, and has therefore placed himself out of the law and become an outlaw. Besides this, the exceedingly prominent place tyrannicide occupies in the history both of the Greeks, the Romans, and the Jews, tells powerfully upon the imagination, and it is quite certain that none of these nations looked upon the act with the feelings of modern Englishmen. But to those who take a wider view of the field of politics, the immense danger of encouraging individuals to make them- selves the arbiters of the destinies of a nation will be far more than sufficient to counterbalance these arguments. The de- gree of favour that public opinion shows to political assassi- nations, though by no means the sole, is perhaps the princi- pal regulator of their number ; for although the conspirator may be prepared, to encounter universal obloquy, the direc- tion his enthusiasm has taken is, in the first instance, deter- mined by the mental atmosphere he breathes. And. if it be true, as Mariana asserts, that the number of those who possess sufficient resolution to engage in such enterprises is under all cases small, it is also true that tfiose few would usually be men preemin:;ntly unfit to adjudicate upon the policy of nations. For the amount of heroism it evokes is no test or measure of the excellence of a cause. Indeed, nothing can be more certain than that the highest displays of courage, self-sacrifice, and enthusiasm are usually elicited not by those motives of general philanthropy which all men must applaud, but by attachment to some particular class of THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 157 disputed questions or to the interests of some particulai party. The excitement of controversy, the very fact that the opinions in question have but few adherents, the impossi- bility of triumphing by normal means, and the concentration of every thought upon a single aspect of a single subject, all stimulate fanaticism. The great majority of men will do far more for a cause they have espoused in spite of the opposi- tion of those around them, than for one that is unquestion- ably good. We accordingly find that among the many at- tempts that "were made upon the lives of rulers in the six- teenth century, nearly all were produced by attachment to certain religious opinions which the conspirator desired to see predominate, and from which an immense projsortion of the people dissented. Never was there a spiiit of more complete and courageous self-sacrifice than instigated Ravail- lac to slay perhaps the very best sovereign in modern Europe. And have we not, in our own day, seen the repre- sentatives of a sect of revolutionists whose principles are re- jected by the great majority of educated men attempting, again and again, to fvirther their views by the assassination of a monarch of a difierent nation from their own, whose throne is based upon uuivei'sal suffrage, and. who, in the judgment of at least a very large proportion of his contem- poraries, has proved himself the chief pillar of order in Europe ? These considerations, which the old Jesuit writers com- pletely omitted, serve to show that even in the best case — even in those instances in which the conspirator is seeking only what he firmly believes to be good — the practice of tyrannicide is almost always an evil. But we have to add to this the assassinations from corrupt motives that in socie- ties favourable to tyrannicide have always been frequent; we 158 NATIONALISM IN EUROPE. have to add also the danger to the State resultiug from that large class of men so prominent in all criminal records who verge upon the border of insanity, who, pai'tly from an ex- cess of vanity and partly from natural weakness of volition, and partly under the influence of a kind of monomania, are drawn by an irresistible fascination to the perpetration ol any crime surrounded with circumstances of notoriety ; and when we still further consider the perpetual insecurity and the distrust between sovereign and people that must neces- sarily exist w^hen these conspiracies are frequent, we shall have little hesitation in pronouncing ujion the question. Po- litical assassination is denounced, in general terms, as an atrocious crime, simply because in the great majority of in- stances it is so ; and even in the extremely few cases that are generally recognised as exccjitions, we have to deduct from the immediate advantages that were obtained the evil of an example that has been misused. It is arguments of this kind, drawn from exj)ediency, that are now regarded as most decisive on this as on many other questions of political ethics ; but they could have little weight in the early stages of political life, when the minds of men were still moulded by theological discussions, and were consequently pi-edisposed to deduce all conclusions with an inflexible logic from general principles. Tyrannicide ac- cordingly occupied an extremely prominent place in the revival of liberalism in Europe. The first instance in which it was formally supported by a theologian aj^pears to have been in 1408, shortly after the Duke of Orleans had been murdered at the instigation of the Duke of Burgundy, when a priest, and, as is generally said, a Franciscan,' named John ' He is called so in, I think, every history of the occurrence I have met with ; but a writer in the Journal dcs Scavans of 1*748 maintains (pp. 994- THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS, 159 Petit, who was tbeu professor of theology in the University of Paris, justified the act, and delivered a public oration in defence of the thesis, ' That it is lawful, according to natural and divine law, for every subject to slay or cause to be slain a traitor and disloyal tyrant.' This doctrine was afterwards energetically denounced by Gerson and condemned by the Council of Constance.' After the Reformation, however, it was very widely diffused. Grevin, one of the immediate suc- cessors of Jodelle, and therefore one of the founders of the French Drama, brought it upon tlie stage in a play upon 'The Death of Csesar,' which was first acted in 1560, and was reprinted with an anti-monarchical preface at the time of Ravaillac.^ A few years before the publication of the work of Mariana, no less than thi-ee Jesuits — Franciscus To- letus, Emmanuel Sa, and the famous Molina — had defended it.' The first, who was made a cardinal in 1583, justified it chiefly in the case of tyrants who had usurped dominion ; * 996) that there is some doubt upon the point. It is worthy of remark that the duke who instigated the murder, and probably inspired the apology, died liimself by the hand of an assassin. (Van Bruyssel, Jlist du Commerce Bdge, tom. ii. pp. 48, 49.) ^ Mariana rejects this decree without hesitation, on Ultramontane prin- ciples, as not having been confirmed by the Pope (De Rcge^ p. 79). Suarez seems to think it binding, but argues (De Fide, lib. vi. c. 4) that it applies only to tyrants h% reghnine, because the Council condemns the opinion that ' sub- jects ' may slay a tyrant, and a tyrant in tltulo has, properly speaking, no ' sub- jects.' ^ There is a full notice of this play in Charles, La Comedie en France an Seizieme Siecle. ^ Sa was a Portuguese — the other two were Spaniards. The prominence ihis doctrine acquired in Spain in the reign of Philip II. is probably in part due to the contest of Spain with Elizabeth, who was regarded as a tyrant both in tltulo and in regimine, and consequently naturally marked out for assassina- tion. Mariana's book was probably written under Philip II., for the royal pi-ivilege to print it was granted only three months after the death of that king. * ' Adverte duplicem esse tyrannum unum potestate et dominio qui non habet titulura verum, sed tyrannice occupat rempublicam : et huuc licet occi 160 RATIONALISM LN EUEOPE. but intimated also, that the nation might depose a lawful sovereign, that it might condemn him to death, and that then any individual might slay him. Sa ^ and Molina " expi-essed the same opinion with still greater emphasis, and Balthazar Ayala, the most illustrious Spanish lawyer of the age, in his celebrated work on the ' Rights of "War,' which was pub- lished in 1582, though utterly repudiating their doctrine con- cerning tyrants with a lawful title, cordially embraced it in the case of usurpers.' The French Jesuits, it is true, appalled by the outcry that was raised against them on account of the Avork of Mariana, repudiated its principles; but, in 1611, Mariana found a defender in another Jesuit named Kellerus,* who only made a single reservation — that a formal sentence Avas always necessary before tyrannicide was justifiable. dere, dum aliter non potest liberari respublica et dum spes est libertatis proba- bilis ; aliter non licet privato cuilibet occidere. Alteram administrationi qui habet quidem verum titulum sed tyrannice tractat subditos, et hunc non licet absque publica auctoritate occidere.' [Summa Casmim Conscieniiee, lib. v. c. vi. p. 653.) * ' Tyrannice guberuans juste acquisitum dominium non potest spoliari sine publico judicio ; lata vero sententia potest quisque fieri executor : potest autem deponi a populo etiam qui juravit ei obcdientiam perpetuam si monitus non vult corrigi. At occupantem tyrannice potestatera quisque de populo potest occidere si aliud non sit remedium est enim publicus liostis.' {Ajjhorism. Con fessariorum, verb. Tyrannus.) ^ ' TjTannum primo modo nefas est privatis interficere ; possit tamen res- publica quoad capita conveuire, eique resistere, lataque sententia deponere ab administratione atque ilium depositvun punirg. Secundo modo tyrannum quivia de republica potest licite cum interficere.' (^Comment. Pars IV. tract, iii. disp. 6.) ' ' Tyi'annum qui per vim et illegitime principatum occupavit, si tyrannis aliter tolli non possit, occidere cuilibet licitum sit.' {De Jure et Officns helllcis, lib. i.) * In a book called Ti/rannicidlum, sen Scilum Catholicormn de Tyranni Tnternecione. This book (which was written in reply to a Calvinistic attack) contains a great deal of information about the early literature of tyrannicide. It bears the approbation of Busa?us, the head of the Jesuits in Northern Ger- many. THE SECULAKISATIOISr OF POLITICS. 161 When Henry III. was assassinated bj Clement, the Catholics of the League received the news with a burst of undisguised exultation, and in many churches the image of the murderer was placed for reverence upon tlie altar of God. The Pope publicly pronounced the act to be worthy of ranking with that of Judith ; he said that it could only have been accom- plished by the special assistance of Providence, and he blas- iDhemously compared it to the Incarnation and to the Resur- rection.' On the other hand, it would be unfair to forget the murder of the Duke of Guise in France and of Cardinal Beaton in Scotland, the justification of these instances of political assassination by the most eminent Protestants, and the many seditious works at least verging upon an approval of tyrannicide that issued from the Protestant press. Still the main champions of tyrannicide were unquestion- ably the Jesuits, and it is not difficult to discover the reason. It has been said that the despotic character of their govern- ment has in these later times proved inimical to the growth of individuality among them, and that while the institution considered as a whole has flourished, it has failed remarkably to produce originality either in intellect or in character.' But however this may be now, it is certain that it was not so in the early days of the society, when a few isolated Jesuits were scattered through a community of heretics Avag- ing a continued war against overwhelming numbers. All the resources of their minds were then taxed to the utmost, and they had every motive to encourage an opinion that en- abled a single individual, by an act of self-devotion, to sway the destinies of a nation. ' De Thou, liv. xcvL The Pope was Sixtus V. ^ Lamennais, Affaires de Rome. Since the days of Lamennais the names of Eavignan and Felix have done much to rescue the order from the reproach. VOL. II. — 37 162 RATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. It may be said that the work of Mariana is an extreme in- Btance of Jesuitical principles, and in a certain sense this is undoubtedly true. Mariana stands almost alone among his brethren in the dii'ectuess and absence of qualifications that characterise his teaching, and he is still more remarkably distinguished for the emphasis with which he dwells upon purely political rights. In his book the interests of the Church, though never forgotten, never eclipse or exclude the interests of the peoj)le, and all the barriers that are raised against heresy are equally raised against tyranny. But his doctrine of tyrannicide, extreme, exaggerated, and dangerous as it is, was but a rash conclusion from certain pi'inciples which were common to almost all the theologians of his order, and which are of the most vital importance in the history both of civil liberty and of Rationalism. In nearly every writing that issued from this school we find the same desire to restrict the power of the sovereign and to augment the power of the people, the same determination to base the po- litical system on a doctrine derived from reason rather than from authority, the same tendency to enunciate principles tlie application of which would — whether their authors de- sired it or not — inevitably extend beyond the domain of the- ology. All or nearly all these writers urged in the interests of the Church that doctrine of a ' social contract ' Avhich was destined at a later period to become the cornerstone of the liberties of Europe. Nearly all drew a broad distinction be- tween kings and tyi-ants ; nearly all divided the latter into those who were tyrants, as it was said, in regimine (that is to say, legitimate rulers who misgoverned), and tyrants in titulo (that is to say, rulei-s with no original authority) ; and nearly all admitted that the Papal deposition, by annulling the title-deeds of regal power, transferred the sovereign from THE SECULAEISATIOK OF POLITICS. 163 the former class to the latter. These Avere the really impor- tant pomts of their teaching, for they were those which deep- ly and permanently influenced the habits of political thought, and on these points the Jesuits were almost unanimous. In the application of them they differed. Usually tyrannicide, at least in the case of a tyrant in regimine, Avas condemned, though, as we have seen, there were not wanting those who maintained that the nation as well as the Pope might depose a sovereign, might condemn him to death and depute any in- dividual to slay him. In the case of a tyrant in titulo the more violent opinion seems to have predominated. If he was a conqueror or a usurper, St. Thomas Aquinas had dis- tinctly said that he might be slain.^ If he was a monarch deposed for heresy, it was remembered that heresy itself might justly be punished Avith death, and that CA^ery act of the deposed sovereign against Catholicity Avas a crime of the deepest die perpetrated by one who had no legitimate au- thority in the State. The cloud of subtle distinctions that were sometimes raised around these questions might give scope for the ingenuity of controversialists, but they could have but little influence OA^er the passions of fanatics.'^ If we now turn from the Jesuits to the Galilean section of the Catholic Church, the contrast is very remarkable. We find ourselves in presence of a new order of interests, and consequently of new principles. The great power of the ' See Suarez, De Fide, lib. vi. cap. iv. ' Ou the inevitable tendency of the doctrine of deposition to tyrannicide, there are some good remarks in Bossuet, Defensio, lib. i. c. 3. The doctrine of tyrannicide among the Jesuits seems to have died away after Suarez : the political condition of Europe no longer made it of great service to the Church, and the controversies of Jansenism diverted the energy of the Jesuits into new channels. Pascal, in his Provincial Letters, barely touches this aspect of the Jesuit teaching. 164 KATIONALISM IN EUROPE. French Church and of the monarchy with which it was con- nected had early induced its bishops to assume a tone of in- dependence in their dealings with the Papal See that was elsewhere unknown, and a close alliance hetAveen Church and State was the manifest interest of both. But in order that such an alliance should be effectual, it was necessary that the Pope should be reduced as much as possible to the level of an ordinary bisliop, while the sovereign was exalted as tlie immediate rej)resentative of the Deity. In this way the bishops were freed from the pressure of Papal ascendency, and the sovereign from the worst consequences of excommu- nication. The advocates of Galilean principles have been able to prove decisively that in nearly all attempts to pre- vent the encroachments of the Pope upon secular dominion, French theologians have been prominent, while their oppo- nents have rejoined with equal truth that the Galilean author- ities were by no means unanimous in their sentiments, and that the negation of the Papal claims was not usually thrown into a very dogmatic form." The case of an heretical j)riuce before the Reformation was hardly discussed,"'' and in other cases the rivalry between the two sections of the Church was rather implied in acts than expressed in formal statements. On the one side there was a steady tendency to exalt the spiritual power of the Popes above that of the Councils, and their temporal power above that of kings ; on the other side there was a corresponding tendency in the opposite direction. ' See on tlie one side Bianclii, Puissance Soiiveraine, and on the other the Defensio of Bossuet. ^ According to Bianchi, the first Catholic who maintained that the Pope had no power over the temporal possessions of princes who fell into heresy was an Englishman of the time of James I. — William Barclay, the father of the author of the Arc/cnis. W. Barclay wrote against and was answered bj Tellarmine. (Bianchi, tom. ii. pp. 768, 769.) THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 165 As the power of deposition was in the middle ages the centre of the more liberal system of politics, and as everything that was taken from the popes was given to the kings, the Galilean system was always inimical to freedom. At the same time, as the interference of an Italian priest with French politics offended the national pride, it was eminently popular ; and thus, as in many subsequent periods of French history, pa- triotism proved destructive to liberty. It appeared for a short time as if the Reformation were about to give rise to new combinations. The invectives of the Protestants against the Papal Power produced a mo- mentary reaction in its favour, which was remarkably shown in the States General assembled at Paris in 1615. The Third Estate, either because Protestant principles were diffused among its members or because it represented especially the secular feelings of the middle classes, then projaosed, among Dther articles, one declaring that the Pope j^ossessed no power of deposing sovereigns, or under any circumstances releasing subjects from the oath of allegiance; but the nobles and the clergy refused to ratify it, and Cardinal Perron, probably as the representative of the clergy, asserted the Ultramontane principles with the strongest emphasis.^ Very soon, however, a complete change passed over the minds of the French clergy. The Huguenots, in several of their synods, had dwelt with great emphasis upon their denial of the existence of a mediate power between the Deity and a king, and there was some danger that if they possessed the monopoly of this opinion the civil power might be attracted to their side. Besides this, the French Protestants made war against their rulers for the purpose of obtaining liberty of conscience, and the French Catholics naturally ' Bianchi, torn. i. pp. 96-104. 166 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. pronounced these wars to be sinful. In 1668 the Soibonne asserted the absolute independence of the civil power, and the same thing was again declared in the famous Articles of 1682, which are the recognised bases of Gallicanism. In his defence of these articles Bossuet soon afterwards systematised the whole theology of the school. The general result, as far as it regards civil liberty, may be briefly told. The king occupied his throne by the direct and immediate authority of the Deity, and is consequently, in his temporal capacity, alto- gether independent both of the Pope and of the wishes of the people. Every pope who had exercised or claimed a power of deposition had exceeded his functions and been guilty of usurpation ; every subject who had raised his hand against the sovereign or his agents had committed a mortal sin. The sole duty of the nation is to obey, and from this obligation no tyranny and no injustice can release it. If the rulers of the people are as wolves, it is for the Christians to show themselves as sheep.' Such was the teaching of the different sections of tne Catholic Church. If w^e now turn to Protestanism, we find a diversity at least equally striking and not less manifestly due to the diversity of interests. At the same time, although the opinions advocated by any particular section at a particular time were mainly the result of the special circumstances under which it was placed, there were some general consid- erations that complicated the movement. In the first place, the foct that the Reformation was essentially an act of spiritual rebellion — an appeal from those in authority to the judgments of the people — gave an imj)ulse to the spirit of insubordination which was still further strengthened by the ' Dcfeiisio, lib. i. c. 15, IG. Avcrtisscments stir les Leftres de M. Jurieu, THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS. 167 republican form that many of the new organisations assumed. In the Early Church the ecclesiastical government had com- bined in a very remarkable manner the jn-inciple of authority and the principle of liberty, by magnifying to the highest point the episcopal authority, while the bishops were them- selves elected by universal suffrage. But a process of gradual centralisation soon destroyed this balance, and transformed the ecclesiastical organisation from a republic into a mon- archy ; and although the primitive elements were revived in Protestantism, they were revived in such a way that their original character was essentially falsified. For the system of popular election and the supreme and divine authority of the episcopacy, which in the Early Church formed the two compensatory parts of a single scheme, at the Reformation were violently dissevered and thrown into tlie strongest antagonism — the Calvinistic chiirches constituting themselves the leading champions of the one, while Anglicanism was the representative of the other. Now it has often been observed, and is in itself sufficient- ly obvious, that when men have formed an ecclesiastical organisation which is intensely democratic, they will have a certain predisposition in favour of a political organisation of a kindred nature. If in Church government they are accus- tomed to restrict very jealously the influence of the ruler, to diffuse as much as possible the supreme power, and to regard the will of the majority as the basis of authority, they will scarcely submit without a murmur to a political system in which all power is centralised in a single man, and from which all popular influence has been carefully eliminated. Puritanism has therefore a natural bias towards democracy, and Ejjiscopalianism, which dwells chiefly on the princij^le of authority, towards despotism. Special circumstances have 168 EATIONALISM EST EUROPE. occasionally modified but seldom or never altogether reversed these tendencies. Both forms have sometimes coalesced cordially with constitutional monarchy ; but even in these cases it will usually be found that the Puritans have gravi- tated towards that party which verges most upon repub- licanism, and the Episcopalians to that which is most akin to despotism. Another general tendency which has been much less fre- quently noticed than the preceding one results from the pro- portionate value attached by different Churches to the Old and New Testaments. To ascertain the true meaning of passages of Scripture is the business not of the historian but of the theologian, but it is at least an historical fact that in the great majority of instances the early Protestant defenders of civil liberty derived their political j)rinciples chiefly from the Old Testament, and the defenders of despotism from the New. The rebellions that were so frequent in Jewish history formed the favourite toj)ic of the one — the unreserved sub- mission inculcated by St. Paul, of the other. When, there- fore, all the principles of right and wrong were derived from theology, and when by the rejection of tradition and eccle- siastical authority Scripture became the sole arbiter of theo- logical difficulties, it was a matter of manifest importance in ascertaining the political tendencies of any sect to discover which Testament was most congenial to the tone and com- plexion of its theology.^ The favourable influence Protestantism was destined to exercise upon liberty was early shown. Among the accusa- tions the Catholics brought against Huss and Wycliflfe, none was more common than that they had proclaimed that mortal sin invalidated the title of the sovereign to his thi'one; and ' Ilallam, Hist, of Lit THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 169 the last of these Reformers was also honourably distmguishecl for his strong assertion of the unchristian character of slavery.* At the Reformation the different attitudes assumed by different sovereigns towards the new faith and the constant vicissitudes of the religious wars exercised their natural influence upon the opinions of the leaders ; hut on the whole, liberal views strongly predominated, although they were not often thrown into formal statements. Luther and Calvin both fluctuated a good deal upon the subject, and passages have been cited from each by the adherents of both views. It is j)robable, however, that Calvin ultimately inclined rather to the repub- lican, and Luther — who had been greatly agitated by the war of the peasants — to the despotic theory. Zuinglius, without reasoning much on the subject,'' accepted the liberal principles of his countrymen, and he died bravely upon the battle-field. TJlrich von Hutten appears to have adopted the Reformed tenets mainly as a principle of liberty, emancipat- ing men both from intellectual and from political tyranny. ' From truth to liberty and from liberty to truth ' was the programme he proclaimed. The country, however, in which Protestantism assumed the most emphatically liberal charac- ter was unquestionably Scotland, and the man who most clearly represented its tendency was Knox. A great writer, whose untimely death has been one of the most serious misfortunes that have ever befallen English literature, and whose splendid genius, matured by the most varied and extensive scholarship, has cast a flood of light upon many of the subjects I am endeavouring to elucidate — has lately traced with a master-hand the antecedents of the * Barrington On the Statutes, p. 280. ■•' See, however, some rather strong passages quoted by Kcllerus, Tyranni- cidium, pp. 73, 74. 170 RATIONALISM EN' EUEOPE. Scotcli Reformation.' He has shown that for a long period before it was accomplished there had been a fierce contest between the aristocracy on the one hand, and. the sovereigns and Catholic clergy of Scotland upon the other; that this struggle at last terminated in the triumph of the aristocracy and the subversion of the Catholic establishment ; that the new clergy, called into existence by a movement that was in- tensely hostile to the sovereign, were from the first the main promoters of sedition ; and that being hated, by the Crown, and having speedily quarrelled with the nobles, they cast themselves for support upon the people, and became the most courageous and energetic of the champions of democracy. The utter contempt for ecclesiastical traditions that charac- terised the Puritanical sects enabled them without much dif- ficulty to mould their theology into conformity with their wishes ; for Scripture was the only guide they acknowledged, and it has been most abundantly proved that from Scripture honest and able men have derived and do derive arguments in support of the most opposite opinions. In all the conflicts with the civil authorities Knox threw himself into the fore- ground, and constantly asserted, with the most emphatic clearness, that it was the right and even the duty of a nation to resist a persecuting sovereign. ■ Speaking of the persecu- tions that Mary had directed against the English Protestants, he declared that when they began it was the duty of the English people not merely to have deposed their queen, but also to have put her to death; and he added, with character- istic ferocity, that they should have included in the same slaughter all her councillors and the whole body of the Catholic clergy." ' Sae Buckle's H'lst. of Scottish CivUisaiion. ' ' And therfor I fear not to affirm that it had bene the dutie of the nol.il THE SECULAEISATIOI^r OF POLITICS. lYJ The opinions which Knox embodied chiefly in fierce de- clamations, and which he advocated mainly with a view to religions interests, were soon after systematised and at the same time secularised by Buchanan in a short dialogue en- titled ' De Jure Regni apud Scotos,' which was published in 1579, and which bears in many respects a striking resem- blance to some of the writings that afterwards issued from the Jesuits. In Buchanan, however, we find none of those countless subtleties and qualifications to which the Catholic theologians commonly resorted in order to evade the deci- sions of the Fathers or the schoolmen, nor do we find any- thing about the dej)osing power of the Pope. The principles that were enunciated were perfectly clear and decisive : they were derived exclusively from reason, and they were dii-ected equally against every form of tyranny. The argument is based upon ' the social contract.' Men were naturally form- ed for society : in order to arrest the intestine discord that sprang up among tliem, they created kings ; in order to re- strain the poAver of their kings, they enacted laws. The na- tion being the source of regal power is greater than and may therefore judge the king ; the laws being intended to restrain the king in case of collision, it is for the people and not for the ruler to interpret them. It is the duty of the king to identify himself with the law,' and to govern exclusively ac- cording to its decisions. A king is one who governs by law, and according to the interests of the people ; a tyrant is one itie, judges, rulers, and people of England, not only to have resisted and again- standed Marie, that Jesabel whome they call their queen, but also to have punished her to the death, with all the sort of her idolatrous preestes, together with all such as should have assisted her what tyme that shee and they openly began to suppresse Christes Evangil, to shed the blood of the saincts of God, and to erect that most devillish idolatrie, the Papistical abominations.' (Knox, Appellation.) ^ As Buchanan tersely puts it, ' Rex, lex loquens ; lex, rex mutus.' 172 RATIONALISM LN" EUKOPE. wbo governs by his own will, and contrary to tlie interests of the people. An opinion had been spread abroad "by some that a king being trammelled by recognised constitutional ties might be resisted if he A'iolated them, but that a tyrant who reigns where no constitution exists must be always obeyed ; but this opinion was altogether false. The people may make war against a tyrant, and may pursue that war until he is slain. Though Buchanan does not expressly defend the slaughter of a tyi'ant by a pri^-ate individual, he recalls in language of unqualified praise the memories of the tyranni- cides of antiquity. This little tract, being in conformity with the spirit of the time, and esi:)ecially with the Sf)irit of the Scotch people, had a very great influence. Its main principles, as we have seen, differ but little from those of St. Thomas Aquinas and the schoolmen; but by disengaging them from the crowd of theological considerations that had previously rendered them almost inoperative except when religious interests were con- cerned, Buchanan opened a new stage in the history of liber- ty. The doctrines, however, which he for the first time sys- tematised had been at a still earlier j)eriod diffused among his fellow-countrymen. When Queen Elizabeth, in 1571, put some questions to a Scotch deputation concerning the reasons that had induced the Scots to depose their queen, slie was immediately favoured in reply with a long dissertation on the manifest superiority of nations to their sovereigns ; which, as Camden assures us, and as we can readily believe, she re- ceived with extreme indignation.^ The same principles were no less general among the English Dissenters, and were ex- hibited alike in their writings and in their policy: Milton ' Camden, Annul., pars ii. (ad ann. 1571). THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. ITo only translated into eloqncnt prose the no less eloquent acts of Cromwell. It is difficult indeed to overrate the deht of gratitude that England owes both to her own Nonepiscopal Churches and to those of Scotland. In good report and in evil, amid per- secution and ingratitude and horrible wrongs, in ages when all virtue seemed corroded and when ajDOstasy had ceased to be a stain, they clung fearlessly and faithfully to the banner of her freedom. If the Great Rebellion was in England for the most part secular in its causes, it is no less true that its success was in a great measure due to the assistance of the Scotch, who were actuated mainly by religion, to the heroic courage infused into the troops by the English ministers, and to the spirit of enthusiasm created by the noble writings that were inspired by Puritanism. Xeither the persecutions of Charles nor the promised toleration of James ever caused them to swerve. Without their assistance English liberty would no doubt have been attained, but no one can say how long its triumph would have been retarded, or what catas- trophes would have resulted from the strife. For it is to Puritanism that we mainly owe the fact that in England re- ligion and liberty were not dissevered : amid all the fluctua- tions of its fortune,^ it represented the alliance of these two principles, which the predominating Church invariably pro- nounced to be incompatible. ^ The attitude of this latter Church forms indeed a strange contrast to that of Puritanism. Created in the first instance by a court intrigue, pervaded in all its parts by a spirit of the most intense Erastianism, and aspiring at the same time * It is worthy of remark, as showing their persistence, that probably the ablest modern advocate of what may be termed the Biblical aspect of liberty was Robert Hall. 174 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. to a spiritual authority scarcely less absolute than that of the Church which it had superseded, Anglicanism was from the beginning at once the most servile and the most efficient agent of tyranny. Endeavouring by the assistance of tem- poral authority and by the display of worldly pomp to real- ise in England the same position as Catholicism had occu- pied in Europe, she naturally flung herself on every occasion into the arms of the civil power. No other Church so uni- formly betrayed and trampled on the liberties of her coun- try.^ In all those fiery trials through which English liberty has passed since the Reformation, she invariably cast her influence into the scale of tyranny, supported and eulogised every attempt to violate the Constitution, and wrote the fearful sentence of eternal condemnation upon the tombs of the martyrs of freedom." That no tyranny however gross, that no violation of the constitution hoAvever flagrant, can justify resistance ; that all those principles concerning the rights of nations on which constitutional government is ' As Macaulay very truly and very eloquently wrote, ' The Church of Eng- land conthiued to be for more than 150 years the servile handmaid of mon- archy, the steady enemy of public liberty. The divine right of kings and the duty of passively obeying all their commands were her favourite tenets. She held those tenets firmly through times of oppression, persecution, and licen- tiousness, while law was trampled down, while judgment was perverted, while the people were eaten as though they were bread. Once, and but once — for a moment, and but for a moment — when her own dignity and property were touched, she forgot to practise the submission she had taught.' {Essays, vol. i. p. 60, ed. 1861.) Hallam, however, has disinterred a curious book called A Sliort Treatise of Politique Power, published by Poynet, Protestant Bishop of Winchester, in 1558, advocating the most seditious doctrines, and among others tyrannicide. But the explanation is simple : PojTiet wrote during the .^persecution of Mary. {Hist, of Lit., vol. ii. pp. 3*7-40.) - ' Eternal damnation is prepared for all impenitent rebels in hell with Satan the first founder of rebellion.' ' Heaven is the place of good obedient subjects, and hell the prison and dungeon of rebels against God and their prince.' (Homily on Wilful RchelUon.) THE SECTJLAKTSATION OF POLITICS. 175 based are false, and all those efforts of resistance by which constitutional government is achieved are deadly sins, was her emphatic and continual teaching. 'A rebel,' she declared, 'is worse than the worst prince, and rebellion worse than the worst government of the worst prince hath hitherto been.' ' God placeth as well evil princes as good,' and therefore 'for subjects to deserve through their sins to have an evil prince and then to rebel against him were double and treble evil by provoking God more to plague them.' St. Paul counselled passive obedience under Caligula, Claudius, and Nero, ' who Avere not only no Christians but jjagans, and also either foolish rulers or cruel tyrants ;' nay the Jews owed it. even to Nebuchadnezzar, when ' he had slain their king, nobles, parents, children, and kinsfolk, burned their country cities, yea Jerusalem itself, and the holy temple, and had carried the residue into captivity.' Even the Blessed Virgin, ' being of the royal blood of the ancient natural kings of Jewry, did not disdain to obey the commandment of an hea- then and foreign prince;' much more therefore should we ' obey princes, though strangers, wicked, and wrongful, when God for our sins shall place such over us,' unless, indeed, they enjoin anything contrary to the Divine command ; but even 'in that case we may not in anywise withstand violently or rebel against rulers, or make any insurrection, sedition, or tumults, either by force of arms or otherwise, against the anointed of the Lord or any of his officers, but we must in Buch case patiently suifer all wrongs.' ^ ' If I should determine no cases,' wrote Jeremy Taylor, ' Homilies on Wilful Eehcllion and on Obedience. The same doctrines were laid down in the Canons of Convocation in 1606, and by the University of Oxford in 1G22, when censnring a preacher named Knight, who had said that subjects oppressed on account of rehgion might sometimes resist. (Hal- lam, Const. Hist,, vol. i. p. 415.) 176 KATIONALISM IX EUROPE. when treating the question of resistance in the greatest work on Moral Philosophy that Anglicanism has produced, ' but upon such mighty terms as can he afforded in this question, and are given and yet prevail not, I must never hope to do any service to any interest of wisdom or peace, of justice or religion ; and therefore I am clearly of opinion that no man who can think it lawful to fight against the supreme power of his nation can he fit to read cases of conscience, for noth- ing can satisfy him whose conscience is armour of proof against the plain and easy demonstration of this question. . . . The matter of Scripture being so plain that it needs no interpretation, the practice and doctrine of the Church, which is usually the best commentary, is now bxit of little use in a case so plain ; yet this also is as plain in itself, and without any variety, dissent, or interruption universally agreed upon, universally practised and taught, that, let the powers set over us be what they will, we must sufier it and never right ourselves.' ' The teaching of which these extracts are examples was constantly maintained by the overwhelming majority of the Anglican clergy for the space of more than 150 years, and during the most critical periods of the history of the English Constitution. When 'Charles I. attempted to convert the monarchy into a despotism, the English Church gave him its constant and enthusiastic support. When, in the gloomy period of vice and of reaction that followed the Restoration, the current of opinion set in against all liberal opinions, and the maxims of despotism w^ere embodied even in the Oath of ' Dudor JDuhitaniium, lib, iii. cap. iii. Ussher, who was perhaps still more competent than Taylor to express the sentiments of the Fathers, was at least equally emphatic. See Elrington's Idfe of Ussher, vol. i. p. 239. Berke- ley made an ingenious attempt to show that passive obedience was ordained by the law of nature : see his Discourse on Passive Obedience. THE SEOUL AKISATION OF POLITICS. 17T Allegiance/ the Church of England directed the stream, allied herself in the closest union with a court whose vices were the scandal of Christendom, and exhausted her anathe- mas not upon the hideous corruption that surrounded her, but upon the princii^les of Hampden and of Milton. All through the long series of encroachments of the Stuarts she exhibited the same spirit. The very year when Kussell died was selected by the University of Oxford to condemn the writings 'of Buchanan, Baxter, and Milton, and to proclaim the duty of passive obedience in a decree which the House of Lords soon afterwards committed to the flames.'' It was not till James had menaced her supremacy that the Church was aroused to resistance. Then indeed, for a brief but memora- ble period, she placed herself in opposition to the Crown, and contributed largely to one of the most glorious events in Enghsh history. But no sooner had William mounted the throne than her policy was reversed, her whole energies were directed to the subversion of the constitutional liberty that was then firmly established, and it is recorded by the great historian of the Revolution that at least nine-tenths of the clergy were opposed to the emancipator of England. All through the reaction under Queen Anne, all through the still worse reaction under George III., the same spirit was dis- played. In the first period the clergy, in their hatred of liberty, foUoAved cordially the leadership of the infidel Boling- broke ; in the second they were the most ardent supporters " In the clause that it was not lawful ' on any pretence whatever to take up arms against the king.' This clause was expunged At the Revolution (Allen's Hist, of Royal Prerogative in England, p. 89). Magna Charta had declared that kings who violated it might be resisted. " This decree is given in full in Wodrow's Hist, of Church of Scotland, vol. iii. p. 506. See on this whole subject, Hallam, Const. Hist., vol ii. pp. 459-465 (ed. 1854). VOL. II. — 38 178 KATIONALISM m EUEOPE. of the wars against America and against the French Revolu- tion, which have Ijeen the most disastrous in which England has ever engaged. From first to last their conduct was the same, and eveiy triumph of liberty was their defeat. There are contrasts that meet us in the history of Ration- alism which it is impossible to realise without positive amaze- ment. When we remember for how long a pei'iod the Church of England maintained that resistance to the regal power was in all cases a deadly sin, and that such men as a Wash- ington or a Garibaldi were doomed ' to burn together in hell with Satan the first founder of rebellion,' it is hard to say whether the present condition of English public opinion shows most clearly the impotence of the theologians who were unable to prevent so absolute a rejection of their prin- ciples, or the elasticity of the Church that has survived it. Although, however, the general current of Anglican ecclesiastical opinion was on this subject extremely steady, there was one divine who forms a marked exception, and that divine was probably the ablest that Protestantism has ever jproduced. Hooker — not indeed the gi-eatest but perhaps the most majestic of English writers — was not more distinguished for his splendid eloquence than for his tendency to elevate the principles of natural right, and for his desire to make the Church independent of the State. In his discussions of the nature of the civil power both of these characteristics ai-e strikingly shown. In examining the true origin and func- tions of government he scarcely ever appeals to the decisions of the Fathers, and not often to the teachings of Scripture, but elaborates his theory from his own reason, aided by the great philosophers of antiquity. His doctrine in its essential parts differs little from tliat of Buchanan. Individuals join- ing together in societies created kings to govern them. The THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS. 1Y9 regal power was at fii-st absolute, but soon ' men saw that to live by one man's will became the cause of all men's misery, and this constrained tliem to come into laws wherein all men might see their duty.' ' Although the king received his au- thority fi-om the people in the first instance, it was not on that account the less sacred, for ' on whom the same is be- stowed even at men's discretion they likewise do hold it of Divine right.' At the same time the kmg was subject to the law, and as the power of enacting laws resides with tlie whole people, any attempt upon his part to enact laws con- trary to the will of the people is a tyranny. Such laws are, in fact, a nullity.' From these principles we should naturally have supposed that Hooker would have drawn the conclusion of Buchanan, and would have maintained that the will of the people is a sufficient reason for changing the government. It is, how- ever, an extremely remarkable fact as showing the spirit of the class to which he belonged that this great writer, who had exhibited so clearly the fundamental propositions of mod- ern liberalism, who had emancipated himself to so great a degree from the prejudices of his profession, and who wrote with the strongest and most manifest bias in favour of free- dom, shrank to the last from this conclusion. He desired to see the power of the government greatly restricted ; he eulo- gised constitutional government as immeasurably superior to » Uccl Pol, lib. i. sec. 10. ^ ' The lawful power of making laws to commaud whole political societies jf men belonging so properly unto the same entire societies, that for any prince or potentate, of what kind soever, upon earth to exercise the same of himself and not by express commission immediately and personally received from God, or else from authority derived at the first from their consent upon whose persons they impose laws, it is no better than mere tyranny. Laws they are not therefore which public approbation hath not made so.' {Eccl Pol, hb. i. sec. 10.) 180 RATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. despotism ; lie even thought that the vioLation of a constitu- tional tie was a just cause for resistance, but when he came to the last great question he dismissed it with these melan- choly words : — ' May then a hody-j^olitick at all times with- draw, in whole or in part, that influence of dominion which passeth from it if inconvenience doth grow thereby? It must be presumed that supreme governors will not in such cases oppose themselves and be stiff in detaining that the use whereof is with public detriment, but siirely without their consent I see not how the body should be able by any fresh means to help itself, saving when dominion doth escheat.' * It is scarcely necessary, I think, to review in detail the other works which appeared in England upon this subject. A large proportion of them at least are well known : their arguments are little more than a rei^etition of those which I have described, and after all they were not the real causes of the development. A spirit of freedom, fostered in England by the long enjoyment of political and social institutions far superior to those of other nations, had produced both a capa- city and an ambition for freedom which must inevitably have triumphed, and it is a matter of comparative insignificance what particular arguments were selected as the pretext. On the other hand, the genius and the circumstances of the Anglican Church predisposed its leaders towards despotism, and they naturally grasped at every argument in its support. I may observe, however, that there was a slight difference of oj)inion among the English supporters of despotic principles." The earliest school, which was represented chiefly by Barclay and Blackwood, appears to have acknowledged that men ' Eccl. Pol., b. viii. ch. ii. At a later period Burnet threw himself into the liberal movement as cordially as Locke, but he was almost isolated in the Church. - This change is clearly shown in Sidney. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 181 were born free, and to have admitted some possible circum- Btauces under which resistance was lawful. The later school, which was led by Filmer, Heylin, Main waring, and Hobbes, entirely denied this original freedom. The ' Patriarcha ' of Filmer, which was the principal exposition of the doctrines of the last class, rested, like some of the writings of the Gal- ilean school, upon the supposition that the political govern- ment is derived from and is of the same nature as paternal government,^ and it concluded that resistance was in all cases sinful. This book was in the first instance answered by Sidney, who opposed to it ' the social compact,' but rested a considerable portion of his argument on the Old Testament. At the Revolution, however, the clergy having revived the principles of Filmer,' Locke thought it necessary to publish another answer, and accordingly wrote his famous treatise of ' Government,' which differs from that of Sidney in being ' Bossuet maintained this, remarking that 'Abimelech,' which was a name originally common to all the kings of Palestine, signifies, ' My father king.' {Befensio, lib. i. c. 3.) In England the patriarchal theory of govern- ment seems to have become especially popular under James I. (see Hallam's Hist, of Lit, vol. iii. p. 439, ed. 1854), but there are many traces of it at an earlier period. Thus in the Institution of a Christian Man (ISS'J), and in Tlie Necessary Doctrine and Erudition for any Christian Man (1543), passive obedience is unequivocally enforced as a deduction from the Fifth Command- ment. 'I die,' said Lord Capel on the scaffold, in 1649, 'for keeping the Fifth Commandment, given by God himself, and written with His own finger. It commands obedience to parents ; and all divines, differ as they will on other points, agree in this, and acknowledge that it includes the magistrate ' (Marsden, History of the Later Puritans, from 1642 to 1662, p. 320). Milton, on the other hand, said : ' Pater et res diversissima sunt. Pater nos genuit ; at non rex nos sed nos regem creavimus. Patrem natura dedit populo, regem ipse populus dedit sibi ; non ergo propter regem populus, sed propter popu- lum rex est.' {Defensio Pop. Aiig., cap. i.) ' As Locke says, ' I should not speak so plainly of a gentleman long fince past answering (Sir R. Filmer), had not the pulpit of late years pub- licly owned his doctrine, and made it the current divinity of the times.' (Preface to Treatise on Government.) 182 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. almost entirely based upon secular considerations, althougb a considerable space is devoted to the refutation of the theo- logical arguments of his opponent. Locke adojjts almost en- tirely the principles of Hooker, for whom he entertained feel- ings of deep and well-merited admiration, but he altogether discards the qualifications by which Hooker had sometimes neutralised his teaching. All government, he maintains, is the gift of the people for the people's advantage, and there- fore no legislation is legitimate which is contrary to the peo- ple's interests, and no change of government wrong which is in accordance with them.* Prerogative is that measure of power which the nation concedes to its ruler, and the nation may either extend or restrict it." To impose taxes on a peo- ple without their consent is simply robbery.' Those who are appointed by the people to legislate have no power to trans- fer their authority to others,* nor may they govern excej)t by established laws.^ And as the sovereignty in the first instance emanates from the people, so the people may reclaim it at will. The ability with which these views were urged, and the favourable circumstances under which they appeared, gave them an easy triumph, and the Revolution made them the bases of the Constitution. ' ' The end of government being the good of the community, whatever alterations are made in it tending to that end cannot be an encroachment upon anybody, since nobody in government can have any right tending to any other end.' (On Government, c. xiv.) ^ Ibid., c. xviii, ' ' If any one shall claim a power to lay or levy taxes on the people with- out their consent, he thereby invades the fundamental law of property, and subverts the end of government.' (Ibid., ch. si.) * ' The legislature cannot transfer the power of making laws, for, it being but a delegated power from the people, they who have it cannot pass it over to others.' (Ibid.) This doctrine was very justly regarded by Grattan and Plunket as decisive against the constitutional character of the Act of Union between England and Ireland. ° !bid. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 183 It is well worthy of remark that the triumph of toleration and the triumph of civil liberty should both have been defin- itively effected in England at the same time, and should both have found their chief champion in the same man. Both were achieved by laymen in direct opposition to the Church and in the moment of her extreme depression. Both too represented a movement of secularisation: for by the first theological questions were withdrawn from the sphere of politics, and by the second the principle of authority was re- moved from a theological to a secular basis. But what espe- cially characterises the development of English liberty is that, although it Avas effected contrary to the Church and contrary to the clergy, it was not effected contrary to religion. This — which, when we consider the mournful history of Continental liberty, may perhaps be regarded as the happiest fact in English history — was no doubt due in a great measure to the success with which the Dissenters had associated religion and liberty ; to the essential imperfection of the Anglican theory, which left undefined the question when allegiance may be transferred to a triumj^hant rebel,* ' The passages from Scripture which the Anglican divines cited as their poUtical rules would seem to imply that allegiance should always be rendered to the sovereign de facto. This doctrine, however, was at the Revolution generally and indignantly repudiated by the clergy, who maintained that while King James held his court at St. Germains he alone was entitled to their allegiance. However, after the Revolution, Bancroft published a work called JBishop Overall's Convocation BooJc^ which had been approved by botli Houses of Convocation at the beginning of the reign of James I. This work (which had not before been published) asserted in the strongest terms the doctrine of passive obedience, based it on the patriarchal theory of govern- ment, and declared that in case of a change of government being effected by unrighteous means, allegiance should be transferred to the new power when it was ' thoroughly settled.' Thereupon Sherlock declared that he considered himself bound by the voice of the Church to take the oaths of allegiance to the government of William (which, to the world at large, seemed very far indeed from ' thoroughly settled '), and he accordingly accepted the deanery 184 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. and also to the admirable modeAtion of Somers and Locke : but it was still more due to the genius of the Reformation. Never did Protestantism exhibit more clearly its admirable flexibility of doctrine, its capacity for modifying and recast- ing its principles to meet the wants of succeeding ages, than •when, without any serious religious convulsion, the political system of England was based upon the direct negation of the unanimous teaching of the Early Church and of the almost unanimous teaching of the National one. And the contrast the history of English liberty bears to that of Continental liber- ty becomes still more remarkable when we remember the atti- tude exhibited by the avowed opponents of Christianity. In England, with the exception of Shaftesbuiy, the most emi- nent of these were either indifferent or opposed to the move- ment. Under the government of the Stuarts, Hobbes not only maintained the most extreme views of Taylor and Us- sher, but carried them to a point from which even those divines would have recoiled : for the result of his philosophy was nothing less than to make the civil ruler the supreme arbiter of the moral law. During the reaction under Queen Anne the clerical party owed its chief strength to the genius of Bolingbroke, who consolidated its broken forces, and elaborated with an almost dazzling eloquence his ideal of ' A Patriot King ' to counterbalance the ideal of liberty. And at a still later period, while Bishop Horsley was proclaiming that 'subjects had nothing to say to the laws except to obey them,' Hume was employing all his skill in investing with of St. Paul's. The explosion that followed is admirably described by Macaulay (eh, xvii.). It is evident that the doubt hanging over this part of the theory of the Anglican divines, was favourable to liberty — in the first place by weakening the logical force of that theory, and in the second place by giving those who shrunk from absolutely rejecting it a pretext for joining the new eovernment. THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS. 185 the most seductive colours the policy cf the Stuarts, in ren- dering the great supporters of liberty in the seventeenth century either odious or ridiculous, and in throwing into the most plausible aspects the maxims of their- opponents.* It is remarkable that while England and France have been the two nations which have xmdoubtedly done most for the political emancipation of mankind, they have also been those in which tlie National Churches were most bitterly opposed to freedom. We have seen the manner in which the double movement of secularisation and of liberty was effected in the Protestant country; it remains to trace the corresponding development in the Catholic one. It was upon the French Protestants that the office whicli in England was filled by the Puritans naturally devolved. The fact that they were a minority, and often a persecuted minority, gave them a bias in favour of liberty, while at the same time their numbers were sufficiently great to communi- cate a considerable impulse to public opinion. Unfortunate- ly, however, the extreme arrogance and the persecixting spirit they manifested whenever they rose to power rendered them peculiarly unfit to be the champions of liberty ; while at the same time their position as a minority of the nation, govern- * Among the less eminent freethinkers there were, indeed, some excep- tions to this tendency. Thus Tindal wrote a tract against Passive Obedience in 1694, a defence of Toleration in 1697, and a defence of a Free Press in 1698. Toland too wrote, in 1*702, a somewhat remarkable book called Anfflica Libera, in which he advocated very eloquently the political prin- ciples of Locke, denounced strongly the doctrine of Hobbes that a sovereign has a right to dictate the rehgion of his subjects, and mamtained that ' the success of the Protestant religion, poUtically speaking, depends on the lib- erty of the several States of Europe' (p. 185). Toland also edited the Oceana, and wrote the Lives of Harrington and Milton. But the most eminent avowed English freethinkers of the seventeenth and eighteenth cen- turies are those mentioned in the text, with the exception of Gibbon, who sat in Parliament as a Tory. 186 NATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. eel mainly by religious principles in an era of religious wars, rendered their prevailing spirit profoundly anti-national. Wherever sectarian feeling is keenly felt, it proves stronger than patriotism. The repulsion separating men as members of different religious becomes more powerful than the attrac- tion uniting them as children of the same soil, and the maxim that a man's true country is not that in which ho was born but that of his co-religionists being professed, or at least act- ed on, treason is easily justified. In the present day, when the fever of theology has happily subsided, Ireland forms an almost solitary example of a nation in which national inter- ests and even national pride are habitually sacrificed to sec- tarianism ; but in the sixteenth century such a sacrifice was general, and although in France at least it was made quite as much by the majority as by the minority, it naturally ap- peared in the latter case more conspicuous and repulsive. The atrocious persecutions the majority directed against the minority rendered the alienation of the latter from the na- tional sympathies both natural and excusable, but it did not appear so to the persecutors. The majority have therefore usually been able to enlist the j)atriotic feelings of the multi- tude against the minority, and this has weakened the political influence of the latter. In the political teaching of the French Protestants it is easy to detect two distinct currents. Whenever the Pope or the Ultramontane theologians jiut forward a claim to the power of deposition, the Protestants constituted themselves the champions of loyalty, and endeavoured in this manner to win the favour of the rulers. Thus we find their synods condemning with great solemnity the treatise of Suarez, pro- testing in the most emphatic language against the disloyalty of the Catholics, and assuring the sovereign in their petitions THE SECULAKISATION- OF POLITICS. 187 that they at least recognised no mediate power hetwecn the king and the Almighty.* If we were to judge their opinions by the language of some of their petitions, we might imagine that they were no less favourable to despotism than the An- glicans. But such a judgment would do them great injustice. No body of men ever exhibited a greater alacrity in resisting persecution by force, and, with a few exceptions, the general tone of their theology as of their policy was eminently favour- able to liberty. Opinions on these subjects have so com- pletely changed since the seventeenth century, that the defence of the French Protestants is chiefly to be found in the writings of their adversaries ; and, according to modern notions, it would be difficult to find a nobler eulogy than is implied in the accusation of one of the ablest of these, who declared that the general tendency of the Protestant writings was always to the effect that ' kings and subjects were recip- rocally bound by contract to the performance of certain things, in such a manner that if the sovereign failed to per- form his promise the subjects were freed from their oath of allegiance, and might engage themselves to new masters.' ' The opinions of the French Protestants on these points may be more easily ascertained from their actions than from tlieir writings ; and the right of resisting religious persecu- tion was naturally more considered than the right of resisting * Many instances of this are collected by Bianchi (torn. i. pp. 46-84), but the fullest account I have met with is in a very clever anonymous bock (written from a strong Catholic point of view, and ascribed by some to an author named Pellison, and by others to Bayle), called Avis mix Refitgiez sur leur prochain retour en France, par M. C. L. A. A. P. D. P. The condemna- tion of the book of Suarez was by a Synod of Tonneins, in 1014. On the other hand, on the extremely liberal views of Jurieu, who preceded both Sidney and Locke, see Michelet, Hist, de Louis XIV., pp. 43^1-436. The book in which Jurieu especially expressed them is his Sovpirs de la Franct Esclave. * Avis mix Refugiez, pp. 04, 65 (ed. 1692) 188 EATIONALISM IN" EUEOPE. political tyranny. Jurieu strenuously asserted the first right ; and although Saurin is said to have taken the opiDOsite view/ the numerous rebellions of the Protestants leave no doubt as to their general sentiments. The two most remarkable works bearing upon the secular aspect of the question that issued from this quarter were the 'Franco-Gallia' of Hotman, and the'Vindicise contra Tyrannos' of Junius Brutus. The first of these was published in 1573. Its author (who had escaped from France to Geneva at the time of the mas- sacre of St. Bartholomew) was one of the most learned law- yers of the day, and the chief advocate of the Protestant view of some of the legal questions that arose about the suc- cession of the crown." The 'Franco-Gallia' is an elaborate attempt to j^rove that the Crown of France is, by right, not hereditary but elective. The arguments are drawn in part from general considerations about the origin of government, Avhich Hotman attributed to the will of the people,' but chiefly from facts in French history. The writer also at- tempts to show, in an argument that was evidently directed against Catharine de' Medici, that the exclusion of women from the French throne implied, or at least strongly recom- mended, their exclusion from the regency, and that on every occasion in which they had exercised the supreme power disastrous consequences had ensued.* ' Michelet, Hist, de Louis XIV. (1860), p. 432. ^ The works of Hotman were collected in three large volumes, in 1600. After the Franco- Gallia the best known are the Brutv.m Fulnmi, which was written on the occasion of the excommunication of the King of Navarre ; and the Anlilribonius, which was written in opposition to the revival of Ro- man legislation. Joseph Scaliger said he helped in the composition of the Franco-Gallia {Scalifferana, art. Hoitomanmts). =* Franco-Gallia^ lib. i. c. 9. ^ Lib. i. c. 24. So Knox : ' To promote a woman to beare rule is repug- nant to nature, coutumelie to God, a thing most contrarious to his reveled THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 189 A much more remarkable book was the ' Vindicise contra Tyrannos,' which was published about the same time as the ' Franco-Gallia,' and translated into French in 1581, and which, being written with much ability, exercised a very considerable influence. Some have ascribed it, but appar- ently without reason, to Hotman—others to Linguet or to Parquet. The autlior, whoever he may be, holds, like Hooker, that the regal authority is, in the first instance, derived from the people, but that notwithstanding this it is held by Divine right. From this consideration he argues that a king is bound by two pacts, on the observance of which his legitimacy depends — a pact to God that he will govern according to the Divine law, and a pact to the people that he will govern according to their interests.' A nation may resist by arms a sovereign who has violated the Divine law, because the first of these j)acts is then broken, and also because it is part of the Providential system that subjects should be punished for the crimes of their ruler, which im- plies that they are bound to prevent them.* This last propo- sition the author maintains at length from the Old Testament. Whenever the king violated the Divine command, some fear- ful chastisement was inflicted upon the nation, and the chief oflice of the prophets was to signalise these violations, and to urge the people to resistance. Every page of Jewish history bears witness to this, and at the present day the Jews are dispersed because their ancestors did not snatch Christ from the hands of Pilate. But it is impossible to go so far with- out advancing a step further; for if the Jewish precedent is ivill and approved ordinance ; and finallie it is the subversion of good order of all equitie and justice.' {Momtrous Regiment of Women.) ' QucesL ii. ' Vindlcioe contra Tyrannos, p. 45 (ed. 1610). 190 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. to be apiilied, it is manifest the Divine law is violated not merely by the persecution of truth, but also by the toleration of error. Xo crime was more constantly denounced or more fiercely punished under the old Dispensation than religious tolerance. No fact is more legibly stamped upon the Jewish writings than that, in the opinion of their authors, a Jewish sovereign who permitted his people to practise unmolested the rites of an idolatry which they preferred was committing a sin. Nor does the author of the book we are considering shrink from the consequence. He quotes, as an applicable precedent, the conduct of the people who at the instigation of Elijah massacred the whole priesthood of Baal, and he maintains that the toleration of an ' impious sacred rite ' is a justifiable cause of rebellion.^ The question then arose in what manner this resistance was to be organised. And here the writer separates himself clearly from the school of Mariana, for he strongly denies the right of an individual to take the life of a persecutor by way of assassination, however favourable the people might be to the act. Resistance can only be authorised by a council rep- resenting the people. In all well-regulated countries a par- liament or assembly of some kind exists which may be re- garded as representative; and although each individual member is less than the king, the council, as a whole, is his superior, and the vote of the majority may depose him.' When such a council does not exist it may be extemiDorised, but the elements should, if possible, be drawn from the aris- tocracy and the magistrates. Nor is it simply a nation that may thus withdraw its allegiance. The author, evidently with a view to the position of the French Protestants, adds that particular districts or cities, if the inhabitants desire it ' Vindklce, pp. 38-39, 60. * P. 45. THE SECULAKISATION OF POLITICS. 191 and if their magistrates consent, may likewise withdraw themselves from their allegiance, and may insist upon the maintenance among them of the worship they believe to be right, and the suppression of that which they believe to be wrong/ The principles which were thus urged in favour of rebellion on religious grounds apply, with very little change, to rebellions that are purely political. A king who ruled in opposition to the will of his people had broken the pact that bound him, and had consequently become a tyrant. In the case of a tyrant who had occupied the throne by force against the manifest will of the people, but in this case alone, tyran- nicide is lawful, and the examples of Harmodius and Aristo- geiton, of Brutus and Cassius, are to be commended. In other cases, however, resistance must first be authorised by a council representing the nation, and consisting of its leading men. Like Hotman, the author contends that all monarchy was originally elective, and he adds that it still so retains its character, that the people may at any time reject the family they have raised to the throne, and that the heir apparent is no more than a candidate for office." There is one other question treated in this remarkable book to which I may advert for a moment, because, although not connected with the right of resistance, it throAVS some light upon the condition of feeling sectarian animosities had produced. This question is whether, when the majority of a nation is persecuting the minority, a foreign potentate may interpose by arms to succour his co-religionists. The reply is that it is his imperative duty to do so. If he does not, he is guilty of the blood of the martyrs : he is even worse than the perseciutors ; for they at least imagine that they are slay- ' Vindicice, p. 60. "^ P. 79. 192 EATIONALISM D^ EUROPE. ing the wicked, "while he permits the slaughter of those whom he knows to he the just. It is not probahle that many of the French Protestants would have sanctioned all the propositions of this book, but the principles of which it may be regarded as the concentra- tion were very widely diffused among the members of both creeds, and had no inconsiderable influence in preparing the way for the Revolution. The chief political importance, however, of the religious wars was not so much in the doc- trines they produced as in the circumstances under which those doctrines were advocated. Few things contributed more powerfully to the secularisation of politics than the anarchy of opinions, the manifest subordination of principles to interests, that was exhibited on all sides among theolo- gians. A single battle, a new alliance, a change in the policy of the rulers, a prospect of some future triumph, was sufii- cient to alter the whole tone and complexion of the teachings of a Church. Doctrines concerning the sinfulness of rebel- lion, which were urged with the most dogmatic certainty and supported by the most terrific threats, swayed to and fro with each vicissitude of fortime, were adopted or aban- doned with the same celerity, curtailed or modified or ex- panded to meet the passing interests of the hour. They be- came, as Bayle said, like birds of passage, migrating with every change of climate. In no country and in no Church do we find anything resembling the conduct of those an- cient Christians who never advocated passive obedience more strongly than when all their interests were against it. The apostasies were so flagrant, the fluctuations were so rapid, that it was impossible to overlook them, and they continued till the ascendency of theology over politics Avas destroyed. The keen eye of the great sceptic of the age THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 193 soon marked the change, and foresaw the issue to which it was leading,' It will probably have struck the reader in perusing the foregoing pages, and it Avill certainly have struck those who have examined the books that have been referred to, that, in addition to theological interests and traditions, there was a purely secular influence derived from the writings of pagan- ism acting strongly in the direction of liberty. The names that recur most frequently in these writings are those of the great heroes of antiquity; and whether we examine the works of Mariana or Hooker, or of the author of the ' Vindi- ciae,' we are transported into discussions concerning the origin of power that are drawn mainly from the pagan phi- losophers.^ This influence was, I think, of two kinds — the first being chiefly logical, and the second chiefly moral. At the close of the twelfth or the beginning of the thirteenth century, two professors of the University of Bologna, named Irnerius and Accursius, devoted themselves to exploring manuscripts of some of the Laws of Justinian, which had for centuries ' ' Voycz rhorrible impudence de quoi nous pelotons les raisons divines, et combien irreligieusement nous les avons rejettees et reprises selon que la fortune nous a changez de place en ces orages publics. Cette proposition si solennelle, s'il est permis au sujet de se rcbeller et armer contre son prince pour la defense de la religion, souvienne-vous en quelles bouches cette annee passee raffirmative d'icelle etoit I'arcboutant d'un parti, la negative de quel autre parti c' etoit I'arcboutant, et oyez a present de quelle quartier vient la vols et instruction de I'une et de I'autre si les armes bruyent moins pour cette cause que pour celle-la.' — Montaigne, Ussais, liv. ii. c. 12. * This tendency of the classical writings elicited a burst of extreme indignation from Hobbes : 'Inter rebellionis causas maximas numerari potest librorum poUticorum et historicorum quos scripserunt veteres Grseci et Eo- inani lectio. . . . Mihi ergo monarchiis nihil videtur esse damnosiua posse, quam permittere ut hujusmodi libri publico doceantur, nisi simul a magistris sapientibus quibus venenum corrigi possit remedia applicentur. Morbum hunc comparari libet cum hydrophobia,' &c. {Leviaihan, cap. xxix.) VOL. II.— 39 194 RATIONALISM EST EUKOPE. been buried in the great library of Ravenna ; and they not only revived the knowledge of a legislation that was sup- posed to have perished, but also formed a school of commen- tators who did good service in elucidating its character. For * a very long period the laboiirs that were thus instituted had but little influence outside the domain of jurisprudence; but at last, in the sixteenth century, a succession of great lawyers arose — of Avhom Bodin, Cujas, and Alciat were the most remarkable — who applied to the Roman law intellects of a far higher order, and, among other points, paid great atten- tion to its historic development, Tlie balance between the popular and the aiistocratic rights and the gradual encroach- ment of the imperial ];)ower upon the liberties of Rome became for about a century favourite subjects of discussion, and naturally prodiiced similar enquiries concerning modern States, From a philosophical investigation of these ques- tions the lawyers passed by an inevitable transition to an examination of the origin of government, a subject which they pursued, from their own point of view, as energetically as the theologians, Bodin, who was probably the ablest of those who devo'ted themselves to these studies, cannot indeed be regarded as a representative of the democratic tendency ; for he strenuously repudiated the notion of a social contract, maintaining the origin of monarchy to be usurpation; he denied that the ruler should be regarded simply as a chief magistrate, and he combated with great force the distinction whicb Aristotle and the schoolmen had drawn between a king and a tyrant,^ Hotman, however, in France, and, about a century later, Gronovius and Noodt, who were two ' He tried, however, to establish a distinction of his own — that a king was one who governed according to the law of nature, and a tyrant one who outraged it. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 195 of the most eminent Dutch advocates of liberty, based their teaching ahiiost entirely upon these legal researches/ But the priucijDal influence which the pagan writings exercised upon liberty is to be found in the direction they gave to the enthusiasm of Europe. It has no doubt fallen to the lot of many who have come in contact with the great masterpieces of the Greek chisel to experience the sensation of a new perception of beauty which it is the prerogative of the highest works of genius to evoke. A statue we may have often seen with disappointment or indifference, or with a languid and critical admiration, assumes one day a new aspect in our eyes. It is not that Ave have discovered in it some features that had before escaped our notice ; it is not that we have associated with it any definite ideas that can be expressed by words or defended by argument : it is rather a silent revelation of a beauty that had been hidden, the dawn of a new conception of grandeur, almost the creation of another sense. The judgment is raised to the level of the object it contemplates ; it is moulded into its image ; it is thrilled and penetrated by its power. Something of this kind took place in Europe as a conse- quence of the revival of learning. In the middle ages the ascendency of the Church had been so absolute that the whole measure of moral grandeur had been derived from the ecclesiastical annals. The heroism, the self-sacrifice, the ' See Noodt Or« the Power of Sovereigns, and Gronovius On tlie Royal Law, both of which were translated into French by Barbeyrac — the first in I'ZOT, and the second in 1714. They were both in the form of lectures delivered near the end of the seventeenth century before the University of Leyden, and are both, I think, rather dismal performances. Noodt was a strenuous advocate of hberty of conscience, and also one of the principal assailants of the theological superstitions about usury. Gronovius is best remembered for his Annotations of Grotius, in which he strongly repudiated the servile political maxims of that writer. 196 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. humility, the labours of the saints formed the ideal of perfec tioD, and a greatness of a different order could scarcely be imagined. The names of the heroes of antiquity were indeed familial-, their principal achievements were related, and the original writings in which they were recorded were some- times read, but they fell coldly and lifelessly upon the mind. The chasm that divided the two periods arose not -so much from the fact that the heroes of antiquity were pagans, and therefore, according to the orthodox doctrine, doomed to eternal reprobation, or even from the different direction their heroism had taken, as from thS type of character they dis- played. The sense of human dignity and the sense of sin, as we have already noticed, are the two oj^posing sentiments one or other of which may be traced in almost every great moral movement mankind has undergone, and each, when very powerful, produces a moral type altogether dif- ferent from that which is produced by the other. The first is a proud aspiring tendency, intolerant of every chain, eager in asserting its rights, resenting promptly the slightest wrong, self-confident, disdainful, and ambitious. The. second produces a submissive and somewhat cowering tone ; it looks habitually downwards, grasps fondly and eagerly at any support which is offered by authority, and in its deep self-distrust seeks, with a passionate earnestness, for some dogmatic system under which it may shelter its naked- ness. The first is the almost invariable antecedent and one of the chief efficient causes of political liberty, and the second of theological change. It is true that as theological or j)oliti- cal movements advance they often lose their first character, coalesce with other movements, and become the representa- tives of other tendencies ; but in the first instance one or other of these two sentiments mav almost alwavs be detected. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 197 It was the sense of sin that taught the old Catholic saints to sound the lowest depths of mortification, of self-sacrifice, and of humiliation ; that convulsed the mind of Luther in the monastery of Wittenberg, and persuaded him that neither his own good works nor the indulgences of the Pope could avert the anger of the Almighty ; that impelled Wesley and Whitfield to revolt against the frigid moral teaching of their time, and raise once more the banner of Justification by Faith ; that urged the first leaders of Tractarianism towards a Church which by authoritative teaching and multiplied absolutions could allay the paroxysms of a troubled con- science.' On the other hand, almost every great political revolution that has been successfully achieved has been preceded by a tone of marked self-confidence and pride, manifested alike in philosophy, in general literature, and in religion. When a theological movement has coalesced with a struggle for liberty, it has usually been impregnated with the same spirit. The sense of privilege was much more prominent in the Puritanism of the seventeenth century than the sense of sin, and a fierce rebellion against superstition than humility.^ iSTow the sense of human dignity was the chief moral agent of antiquity, and the sense of sin of medievalism; and ' See some striking remarks on this in Froude's Nemesis of Faith, pp. IGO, 161. ' What, for esami^le, could be more opposed to the spirit of the moderu Evangelical party, which is supposed by some to represent the Puritanism of the 1 7th century, than those noble lines of the great poet of the latter ? — ' Mortals ! who would follow me. Love virtue, she alone is free : She can teach ye how to climb Higher than the sphery chime ! Or, if virtue feeble were, Heaven itself would stoop to her.' — Comus. 198 EATIONALISM IN ErEOPE, although it is i)robable that the most splendid actions have been performed by men who were exclusively nnder the in- fluence of one or other of these sentiments, the concurrence of both is obviously essential to the well-being of society, for the first is the especial source of the heroic, and the second of the religious, virtues. ' The first produces the qualities of a patriot, and the second the qualities of a saint. In the mid- dle ages, the saintly type being the standard of perfection, the heroic type was almost entirely unappreciated. The nearest approach to it was exhibited by the Crusader, whose valour was nevertheless all subordinated to superstition, and whose whole career was of the nature of a penance. The want of sympathy between the two periods was so great that for the space of many centuries, during which Latin was the habitual language of literature, the great classical works scarcely exercised any appreciable influence. Sometimes men attempted to mould them into the image of the mediseval conceptions, and by the wildest and most fantastic allegories to impart to them an interest they did not otherwise possess. Thus Troy, according to one monkish commentator, signified Hell, Helen the human soul, Paris the Devil, Ulysses Christ, and Achilles the Holy Ghost. Actreon torn by his own dogs was an emblem of the sufferings of Christ ; the Kubi- con was an image of Baptism.^ It was not till the revival of learning had been considerably advanced that a percep- tion of the nobility of the heroic character dawned upon meia's minds. Then for the first time the ecclesiastical type v\'as obscured, a new standard and aspiration was manifested; * Cibrario, Econorma Politica del Medio Evo, vol. ii. p. 247 (2d ed.). This tendency was turned to ridicule by Ulrich von Hutten in a very witty but very profane adaptation of the Fables of Ovid to the Christian history [Epistolm Obscurorum Virorum [London, 1689], pp. 103-10'7), and also bv Rabelais. THE SECULARISATION OF POLITICS. 199 and i^opular enthusiasm, taking a new direction, acliieved that political liberty which once created intensified the ten- dency that produced it. We cannot have a better example of this passionate aspi- ration towards political liberty than is furnished by the trea- tise ' On Voluntary Servitude,' oi', as it was afterwards called, the ' Coutre-un,' ' of La Boetie. This writer, who was one of the most industrious labourers in the classical field, never pauses to examine the origin of government, or to adjudicate between conflicting theologians ; but he assumes at once, as a fact that is patent to the conscience, that the subordination of the interests of a nation to the caprices of a man is an abuse, and that the great heroes of antiquity are deserving of imitation. The ' Contre-un ' is throughout one fiery appeal — so fiery indeed that Montaigne, who published all the other works of La Boetie, refused to publish this — to the people to cast off their oppressors. It reads like the de- clamations of the revolutionists of the eighteenth century. ' Wretched and insensate people,' writes the author, ' enam- oured of your misery and blind to your interests, you suffer your property to be pillaged, your fields devastated, your houses stripped of their goods, and all this by one whom you have yourselves raised to power, and whose dignity you maintain with your lives ! He who crushes you has but two eyes, but two liands, but one body. All that he has more than you comes from you. Yours are the many eyes that fcpy your acts, the many hands that strike you, the many feet that trample you in the diist : all the power with which he * The name was given during the Ufe of Montaigne, who praised it. {Essais, liv. i. c. 27.) La Boetie, unfortunately, died when only in his thirty- second year, and nearly all his works appear to have been posthumous They have all been republished at Paris, by Leon Fougere, in 1846. 200 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE, injures you is your own. From indignities that the beasts themselves would not endure you can free yourselves by sim- ply willing it. Resolve to serve no more, and you are free. WithdraAV your support from the Colossus tlmt crushes you, and it will crumble in the dust Think of the bat- tles of Miltiades, of Leonidas, and of Themistoclcs, which, after two thousand years, are as freshin the minds of men as though they were of yesterday ; for they were the triumphs not so mucli of Greece as of liberty All other goods men will labour to obtain, but to, liberty alone they are indifferent, though Avhere it is not every evil follows, and every blessing loses its charm Yet w^e were all moulded in the same die, all born in freedom as brothers, born too with a love of liberty which nothing but our vices has effaced.' During the last century language of this kind has by con stant repetition lost so much of its force that w^e can scarcely realise the emotions it kindled wdaen it possessed the fresh- ness of novelty, and in a nation convulsed by the pai'oxysms of civil war. The French Protestants in 1578 adopted the ' Contre-un ' as one of the most effectual means of arousing the people to resistance,' and as late as 1836Lamennais made its republication the first measure of his democratic crusade. In the history of literatui'c it will always occupy a 2:)rominent place on account of the singularbeauty of its language, while in the history of Rationalism it is remarkable as one of the clearest illustrations of the tendency of the classical writ- ings to foster and at the same time secularise the spirit of liberty. * It appeared for the first time, together with the Franco- Gallia, in a seditious book called Memoires de Vestat de France sous Charles IX. ?ee Les Hisioridtcs de Tallemant des Rmux (ed. 1834), tcm. i. p. 395. THE SECULAEISATIOJSr OF POLITICS. 201 Owing to the influences I Iiave endeavoured to trace, the ascendency theology had so long exercised over politics was during the religious wars materially weakened, while at the same time the aspiration towards liberty was greatly strengthened. During the comparative torpor that followed the Peace of Westphalia, and still more after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes, the struggle was for a time sus- l^ended ; and it was not till near the close of the eighteenth century that the question of the rights of nations reappeared prominently in France — this time, however, not under the auspices of the theologians, but of the freethinkers. But, be- fore reviewing the principles that were then urged, it is necessary to notice for a moment the chief causes that were preparing the people for liberty, and without which no argu- ments and no heroism could have triumphed. The fii'st of these was the increase of wealth. Whatever may be the case with small communities and under special circumstances, it is certain that, as a general rule, large masses of peoj)le can only enjoy political liberty when the riches of the country have considerably increased. In the early periods of civilisation, when capital is very scanty, and when, owing to the absence of machines and of commerce, the results of labour are extremely small, slavery in one form or another is the inevitable condition of the masses. The abject poverty in which they live casts them helplessly upon the few who are wealthy ; wages sink to a j^oint that is bai-ely sufficient for the sustenance of life, and social progress becomes impossible. ' If the hammer and the shuttle could, move themselves,' said Aristotle, ' slavery would be unneces- sary; ' and machinery having virtually fulfilled the condition, the predicted result has followed.^ The worst and most de- ' See some very good remarks on this in Chevalier, Leitres sur VOryani- sadon de Travail (1848), p. 17. 202 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. grading forms of labour being performed by machinery, pro- duction, and. consequently capital, liaAC been immensely in- creased, and, progress becoming possible, a middle class has been formed. Commerce not only gives an additional devel- opment to this class, but also forms a bond, of union con- necting the diffet-ent parts of the country. The roads that are formed, for the circulation of wealth become the channels of the circulation of ideas, and render possible that simul- taneous action upon which all liberty depends. The next great cause of liberty was the increase of knowl- edge. And here again we may discern the evidence of that inexorable fatality which for so many centuries doomed man- kind alike to superstition and to slavery, until the great in- ventions of the human intellect broke the chain. When we hear men dilating vipon the degrading superstitions of Ca- tholicism, marvelling how a creed that is so full of gross and material conceptions could win belief, and denouncing it as an apostasy and an error, it is sufBcient to say that for 1,500 years after the establishment of the Christian religion it was intellectually and morally impossible that any religion that was not material and superstitious could have reigned over Europe. Protestantism could not possibly have existed without a general diffusion of the Bible, and that diffusion was impossible until after the two inventions of paper and of printing. As long as the material of books was so expen- sive that it was deemed necessary to sacrifice thousands of the ancient manuscripts in order to cover the parchment with new writing, as long as the only way of covering those parchments was by the slow and laborious process of tran- scription, books, and therefore the knowledge of reading, were necessarily confined to an infinitesimal fraction of tlie community. Pictures and other material images, which a THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 203 Council of Arras well called the ' Book of the Ignorant,' were then the chief means of religious instruction, not simply because oral instruction Avithout the assistance of books was manifestly insufficient, but also because, in a period when the intellectual discipline of reading is nnknown, the mind is in- capable of grasping conceptions that are not clothed in a pictorial form. To those who will observe, on the one hand, how invariably the media3val intellect materialised every de- partment of knowledge it touched, and on the other hand how manifestly the peculiar tenets of Catholicism are formed either by the process of materialising the intellectual and moral conceptions of Christianity or else by legitimate de- ductions from those tenets when materialised — to those Avho still further observe how every great theological movement, either of progress or of retrogression, has been preceded by a corresponding change in the intellectual condition of society, it will appear evident that nothing short of a continned mir- acle could have produced a lasting triumph of Christian ideas except under some such form as Catholicism presents. It was no doubt possible that small communities like the Wal- denses, shut out from the general movement of the age, in- spired by very strong enthusiasm, and under the constant suj)ervision of zealous pastors, might in some small degree rise above the prevailing materialism; but when we remem- ber how readily nations, considered as wholes, always yield to the spirit of the time, and how extremely little the gen- erality of men strive against the natural bias of their minds, it will easily be conceived that the great mass of men must have inevitably gravitated to materialism. When iinder such circumstances a spiritual faith exists, it exists only as the appanage of the few, and can exercise no influence or control over the people. 204: RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. But while superstition is thus the inevitable, and there- fore the legitimate condition of an early civilisation, the same causes that make it necessary render imj^ossible the growth of political liberty. Neither the love of freedom nor the capacity of self-government can exist in a great nation that is plunged in ignorance. Political liberty was in an- cient times almost restricted to cities like Athens and Rome, where public life, and art, and all the intellectual influences that were concentrated in a great metropolis, could raise the Dcople to an exceptional elevation. In the middle ages, servitude was mitigated by numerous admirable institutions, most of which emanated from the Church ; but the elements of self-government could only subsist in countries that were so small that the proceedings of the central government came under the immediate cognisance of the whole people. Else- where the chief idea that Avas attached to liberty was free- dom from a foreign yoke. It was only by the slow and diffi- cult penetration of knowledge to the masses that a movement like that of the eighteenth century became possible ; and we may distinctly trace the steps of its evolution through a long series of preceding centuries. The almost simultaneous in- troduction into Europe from the East of cotton-paper by the Greeks and by the Moors, the invention of rag-paper at the end of the tenth century, the extension of the area of instruc- tion by the substitution of universities for monasteries as the centres of education, the gradual formation of modern lan- guages, the invention of printing in the middle of the fif- teenth century, the stimulus given to education by the numerous controversies the Reformation forced upon the at- tention of all classes, the additional inducement to learn to read arising among Protestants from the position assigned to the Bible, and in a less decree amone Catholics from the THE SEOUL AEI8ATI0N OF POLITICS. 205 cxtraorclinaiy popularity of the "Imitation" of Thomas a Kempis, the steady reduction in the price of books as the new art was perfected, the abandonment of a dead language as the vehicle of instruction, the simplification of style and arguments which brought knowledge down to the masses, tlie sceptical movement which diverted that knowledge from tlieological to political channels, were all among the antece- dents of the Revolution. When knowledge becomes so gen- eral that a large proportion of the people take a lively and constant interest in the management of the State, the time is at hand when the bounds of the Constitution will be enlarged. A third great revolution favourable to liberty is to be found in the history of the art of war. In the early stages of civilisation military achievements are, next to religion, the chief source of dignity, and the class which is most distin- guished in battle is almost necessarily the object of the most profound respect. Before the invention of gunpowder, a horseman in armour being beyond all comparison superior to a foot-soldier, the whole stress of battle fell upon the cav- alry, who belonged exclusively to the upper classes — in the first instance because the great expense of the equipment could only be met by the rich, and in the next place because express laws excluded plebeians from its ranks. It is, hoAV- ever, well worthy of notice that in this respect the position of the English was exceptional. Although St. George, who was the object of extreme reverence throughout the middle ages as the patron saint of cavalry, was also the patron saint of England, the skill of the English archers was so great that they rapidly rose to European fame, and obtained a position which in other countries belonged exclusively to the horse- men. In all the old battles the chivalry of France and the 206 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. yeomen of England, were the most jDrominent figures; find this distinction, trivial as it may now appear, had. probably a considerable influence over the history of opinions. With this exception, the ascendency of the cavalry in the middle ages was unquestionable, but it was not altogether imdisputed; and it is curious to trace from a very distant period the slow rise of the infantry accompanying the pro- gress of democracy. The Flemish burghers brought this force to considerable perfection, and in the battle of Courtray their infantry defeated the cavalry opposed to them. A similar achievement was performed by the Swiss infantry in the battle of Morgarten. The French had always treated their own foot-soldiers with extreme contempt; but Crecy and Poitiers having been mainly won by the English archei'S, a slight revulsion of feeling took place, and great though not very successful efforts were made to raise a rival corps. For some time after the battle of Poitiers all games except arch- ery were prohibited in France. More than once, too, in their combats with the English, the French cavalry were compelled to dismount and endure what they conceived the degradation of fighting on foot, and the same practice was frequent among the free-lances of Italy under the leadership of Sir John Ilawkwood and of Carmagnola. The invention of gunpowder, as soon as firearms had ac- quired some degree of excellence, seriously shook the ascen- dency of the cavalry. The mounted soldier was no longer almost invulnerable by the foot-soldier, or his prowess deci- sive in battle. Yet, notwithstanding this change, the social distinction between the two branches of the army which chivalry * had instituted continued ; the cavalry still repre- sented the upper and the infantry the lower classes, and in ' Chivalry (cheval). THE SECULAEISATIOJST OF TOLITICS. 207 France the nobles alone had. a right to enter the former. The comparative depression of the military importance of the cavalry had therefore the effect of transferring in a measure the military prestige from the noLles to the jjeople. For some time the balance trembled very evenly between the two forces, until the invention of the bayonet by Yauban gave the infantry a decided superiority, revolutionised the art of war. and thereby influenced the direction of enthusiasm.' The last general tendency I shall mention was produced by the discoveries of political economy. Liberty cannot be attained without a jealous restriction of the province of gov- ernment, and indeed may be said in a great measure to con- sist of such a restriction. The process since the Eeformation has passed through two distinct stages. The first, which was effected mainly by the diffusion of Rationalism, was the triumph of tolerance, by which the vast field of speculative opinions was withdrawn from the jurisdiction of the civil power. The second, which was eflected by political econ- omy, was free-trade, by which the evil of the interference of government with commercial transactions was proved. This last ijroposition, which was one of the most important, was also one of the earliest of the achievements of political econ- ' On tlie earlier part of the history of the comparative importance of cavalry and infantry, see the very clear account in a work of the present French Emperor, Du Passe ct de VAvenir de VAriillerie ; and on the later part, and especially on the influence of Vauban, the brilliant sketch of the revolutions in the art of war in the last volume of Thiers' Hist, de V Empire. M. Thiers has made some striking remarks on the effects of the sceptical movement of the eighteenth century upon war — disturbing the old traditions of the art, and culminating in the innovations of Napoleon. The democratic importance of the ascendency of infantry has been noticed by Condorcet, Tableau de V Esprit humain, p. 144. Condorcet, however, has ascribed that ascendency exclusively to gimpowder. See, too, Cibrario, Economia Publica del Medio Evo, torn, i, pp. 334, 335. 208 EATIONALISM Df EUROPE. omists, for it was ardently professed by the French school nearly twenty years before the pnblication of the ' Wealth of Nations ; ' and as the catastrophe of Law and the minis- terial position of Turgot directed public opinion in France very earnestly towards economical qxiestions, it exercised an extensive influence. Many Avho were cotnparatiyely imper- vious to the more generous entlnisiasm of liberty became by these enquiries keenly sensible of the evil of an all-directing government, and anxious to abridge its power. ^ There Avere of course innumerable sj)ecial circumstances, growing out of the policy of the French rulers, which accel- erated or retarded the advance or influenced the character of the Revolution. The foregoing pages have no pretension to be a complete summary of its antecedents, but they may serve to show that a revolutionary movement of some kind was the normal result of the tendencies of the age, that its chief causes are to be sought entirely outside the discussions of political philosophers, and that the rise of great republican writejs, the princiiDles they enunciated, and the triumph of their arguments were all much more the consequences than the causes of the democratic spirit. In other words, these men were rather representative than creative. But for the preceding movement they would never have appeared, or, at least, would never have triumphed, although when they ap- peared they undoubtedly modified and in a measure directed the movement that produced them. The change must neces- sarily have taken place, but it was a question of great impor- tance into whose hands its guidance was to fall. If we take a broad view of the history of liberty since the establishment of Christianity, we find that the ground of ' This has been noticed by many political economists, but by no one more ably than by Mr. Buckle. THE SECULAEISATION OF TOLITICS. 200 conflict was nt first personal and at a later period political liberty, and that in the earlier stage the Catholic Churcli was the special representative of progress. In the transition from slavery to serfdom, and in the transition from serfdom to lib- erty, she was the most zealons, the most nnwearied, and the most efficient agent. The same thing may be said of the earliest jDeriod of the political evolution. As long as the condition of society was such that an enlarged political lib- erty was impossible, as long as the object was not so mucli to produce freedom as to mitigate servitude, the Church was still the champion of the people. The balance of power pro- duced by the numerous corporations she created or sanc- tioned, the reverence for tradition resulting from her teach- ing, which perpetuated a network of unwritten customs with the force of public law, the dependence of the civil upon the ecclesiastical power, and the rights of excommunication and deposition, had all contributed to lighten the pressure of despotism. After a time, however, the intellectual progress of society destroyed the means which the Church possessed for mitigating servitude, and at the same time raised the popular demand for liberty to a point that was perfectly in- compatible with her original teaching. The power of the Papal censure was so weakened that it could scarcely be reckoned upon as a political influence, and all the compli- cated checks and counter-checks of mediteval society were swept away. On the other hand, the struggle for political liberty in its widest sense — the desire to make the will of the people the basis of the government — the conviction that a nation has a right to alter a government that opposes its sentiments — has become the great characteristic of modern politics. Experience has shown that wherever intellectual life is active and unimpeded a political fermentation will en- VOL. II. — 40 210 -RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. sue, and will issue in a movement having for its object the repudiation of the Divine right of kings, and the recognition of the will of the people as the basis of the government. The cui-rent has been flowing in this direction since the Re« formation, but has advanced with peculiar celerity since tlie Peace of Westphalia, for since that event the desire of secur- ing a political ascendency for any religious sect has never been a preponderating motive with politicians. With this new spirit the Catholic Church cannot possibly harmonise. It is contrary to her genius, to her traditions, and to her teaching. Besting upon the princi])le of authority, she in- stinctively assimilates with those forms of government that most foster the habits of mind she inculcates. Intensely dogmatic in her teaching, she naturally endcavcars to arrest by the hand of power the circulation of what she believes to be error, and she therefore allies herself with the political system under which alone such suppression is possible. Asserting as the very basis of her teaching the binding authority of the past, she cannot assent to political doctrines which are, in fact, a direct negation of the uniform teaching of the ancient Church.' In the midst of the fierce struggle of the sixteenth century isolated theologians might be per- mitted without censure to propound doctrines of a seditious nature, but it was impossible ultimately to overlook the fact that the modern secularisation of the basis of authority and the modern latitude given to a discontented people are di- rectly contrary to the teaching of the Fathers, and extend ' As a distinguished Anglican divine of our own day has put it, ' It is idle, and worse than idle, to attempt to restrict and explain away this positive command (" Kesist not evil "), and the Christian Church has always upheld it in its full extent. With one uniform unhesitating voice it has proclaimed tht dutij of passive obedience.'' (Sewell, Christian Politics, ch. x.) THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 211 far beyond the teacliing of the medueval theologians/ The fact that modern oj^nions have been in a measure evolved from the sjDeculations of the schoolmen, or that the school- men were the liberals of their time, though important in the judgment of the rationalist, is of no weight in the eyes of those who assert the finality of the teaching of the past. Tlie natural incaj^acity of Catholicism to guide the demo- cratic movement had in the eighteenth century been aggra- vated by the extremely low ebb to which it had fallen, both intellectually and morally. Nearly all the greatest French intellects of the seventeenth century were warmly attached to Catholicism ; all those of the eighteenth century were op- posed to it. The Church, therefore, like every retrogressive institution in a progressive age, cast herself with more than common zeal into the arms of power, and on every occasion showed herself the implacable enemy of toleration. In 1780, but a few years before the explosion that shattered the eccle- siastical system of France, the assembly of the French clergy thought it necessary solemnly to deplore and condemn the partial tolerance that had been accorded to the French Prot- estants, and to petition the king that no further privileges might be granted them. Such a Church was manifestly '■ I have already referred to the bull of Gregory XVI. attesting this con- tradiction. I may add the following admission of a writer who may be re- garded as one of the principal representatives of the Ultramontane party, which has always been the most liberal in politics : — ' Quoique nous tombions d'accord que la source ou I'origiiie de la puissance publique reside dans la multitude, nous nions cependant que la puissance publique etant une fois transferee au prince, le peuple conserve toujours sur lui un droit de sou- verainete. Nous disons, au contraire, qu'il ne lui reste plus des lors que le devoir d'obeir, et qu'il n'existe qu'un cas ou il puisse se soustraire k cette obeissanee, comme en conviennent les plus ardents defenseurs de la puissance royale, savoir, celui ou le prince deviendrait I'ennemi public et declar6 de tout son peuple, et ou il chercherait h detruire la societe civile.' (Bianchi, tom. i. p. 84.) 212 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. identified with despotism, and having repeatedly asserted the evil of toleration she had no right to complain Avhcn the Revolutionists treated her according to her principles/ Catholicism having thus become the representative of desj^otism, and French Protestantism having sunk into insig- nificance, the guidance of the democratic movement neces- sarily passed into the hands of the freethinkers. In the earlier stages of the movement, when liberty was evolved from the religious wars, they had usually stood aloof. Thus Faustus Socinus had predicted that the seditious doctrines by which the Protestants supported their cause would lead to the dissolution of society, and in denouncing them he es- pecially singled out for condemnation the noble struggle of the Dutch against Spain.* Montaigne, though Buchanan had been his tiitor andLaBoetie one of his most intimate friends, always leaned strongly towards political conservatism. His disciple Charron went still further, and distinctly asserted the doctrine of passive obedience.* Bayle, too, exerted all his influence in discouraging the revolutionary tenets of Jurieu.* Nor was there anything extraordinary in this, for ' See, for some striking evidence of these sentiments, the Discours 2)cir iin Ministrc Patriot stir le projd d^accorder Vitat civil auz Protestants, by the Abbe de L'Enfert (Paris, IVS"?). " Bayle, Did., art, Faustus Socinus, Eemarque c. ^ La Sax/esse, p. iii, * Many have ascribed the Avis aux Eefugiez to Eayle. The charge, how- ever, seems (as far as I know) destitute of external evidence, and, consider- ing the great zeal with which Bayle threw himself into the defence of the Calvinists when they were attacked by Maimbourg, is rather improbable. Arguments of style are very untrustworthy, because a great writer always produces many imitators, and Bayle's style was by no means difficult to imitate. However, Bayle's aversion to democratic theories pervades all his works, and Hallam says the presumption is strongly in favour of his having written the Avis, while Gibbon and Mackintosh speak of it as certainly his. Voltaire, as is well known, has a far deeper stain upon his memory — a dark damning stain which all his splendid services can never eiiace : he applauded the partition of Poland. THE SECULAEISATION OF POLITICS. 213 the aspect Europe presented iu their thne might well have appalled any spectator who was exempt from the prevailing fimaticism. All the honds of cohesion upon which the po- litical organisation depended were weakened or destroyed. The spirit of private judgment had descended to those who by ignorance or long servitude were totally incapable of self-government, and it had lashed their passions to the wild- est fury. Patriotism seemed to have almost vanished from Christendom. Neither Catholics nor Protestants deemed it the least disgraceful to call down a foreign invasion upon their land, to trample its interests in the dust, and to avow the warmest sympathy for its enemies. Religion, which had so long formed the basis of order, inspired the combatants with the fiercest hatred, and transformed every vice into a virtue. While a pope was causing medals to be struck in honour of the massacre of St. Bartholomew, and enjoining Yasari to paint the scene upon the walls of the Vatican ; while the murderer of Henry III. was extolled as a martyr, and writings defending his act were scattered broadcast among the people; while the conflagration spreading from land to land absorbed or eclipsed all other causes of dissen- sion, blasted the material prosperity of Europe, and threat- ened a complete dissolution of almost all political structures, it was not surprising that the freethinkers, who stood apart from the conflict, should have sought at any risk to consoli- date the few remaining elements of order. But in the eighteenth century their position and the circumstances that surrounded them were both changed ; and the writings of Rousseau and of his disciples proved the trumpet-blast of that great revolution which shattered the political system of France, and the influence of which is even now vibrating to the farthest limits of civilisation. i3l4: RATIONALISM IX EUEOPE. It has been said' that while the Revohition of England bore in its womb the liberty of England, the Revolution of France bore, that of the world ; and those who have traced the long series of political changes already effected will scarcely deem the boast an hyperbole. All around us the spirit of that Revolution is permeating the masses of the people with its regenerating power. Many ancient desjpotisms have already crumbled beneath its touch; others are even now convulsed by the agonies of transformation, or by the last paroxysms of a despairing resistance. Every form of government in which the nation does not actively participate is recognised as transitory, and every sagacious despot keeps the pi'ospect of future liberty continually before his j)eople. The resurrection of nations is the miracle of our age. All the power of standing armies and of protecting laws, all the treaties of diplomatists and the untiring vigilance of strong- willed despots, have been unable to arrest it. The treaties have been torn, the armies have been scattered, the spirit of liberty has survived. The doctrine of nationalities, by the confession of its keenest adversaries, has now ' almost ac- quired the force of public law ; ' Mt has annulled the most solemn international obligations, and there is every reason to believe that before the century has closed it will be the recognised basis of politics. Assuredly no part of this great change is due to any original discoveries of Rousseau, though his personal influence was very great, and his genius peculiarly fitted for the posi- tion he occupied. He was one of those writers who are eminently destitute of the judgment that enables men with- Thiers. "^ This was, if I remember right, the expression of Cardinal AntonelU in oue of his THE SECULAEISATION OF TOLITICS. 215 out exaggeration to discriminate between trutli and flilse- hood, and yet eminently endowed with that logical faculty which enables them to defend the opinions they have em- braced. ISTo one plunged more recklessly into paradox, or supported those paradoxes with more consummate skill. At the same time the firmness Avith which he grasped and developed general principles, and that wonderful fusion of passion and argument which constitutes the preeminent beauty of his style, gave his eloquence a transcendent power in a revolutionary age. Nothing is more curious than to observe how the revolt against tlie empire of conventionali- ties of which he was the apostle penetrated into all parts of French society, revolutionising even those which seemed most remote from his influence. It was shown in fashionable assemblies in a disregard for social distinctions, for decora- tions, and for attire, that had for centuries been unknown in France. It was shown in the theatre, where Talma, at the instigation of the great revolutionary painter David, banished from the French stage the custom of representing the heroes of Greece and Rome with powdered wigs and in the garb of the courtiers of Versailles, and founded a school of acting which made an accurate imitation of nature the first condi- tion of excellence.^ It was shown even in the coiintry houses, where the mathematical figures, the long formal alleys arranged with architectural symmetry, and the trees dwarfed and trimmed into fiintastic shapes, which Le Notre had ^ The first step, according to Madame Fusil {Souvenirs (Tune Adrice, pp. 2*7-54), in this direction was taken by an actress named Madame Saiat- Hubcrt, who discarded powder and took the ancient sculptures as her model ; but it was the genius of Talma, warmly seconded by the autiqnarians, by the revolutionists, and especially by the Girondins, that finally vanquished tlie prevailing prejudice. The incongruity of the old costume has, I think, been exaggerated : it was well suited to the Greeks — of Racine. 216 RATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. made the essential elements of a Frencli garden, "u'ere sud- denly discarded and replaced by tlie wild and irregular beauties that Kent had made popular in England.* But though the character and the original genius of Rousseau Avere stamped upon every feature of his time, the doctrines of the ' Social Contract ' are in all essentials borrowed from Locke and from Sidney, and where they diverge from their models they fall speedily into absurdity.^ The true causes of their mighty influence are to be found in the condition of society. Formerly they had been advocated with a view to special political exigencies, or to a single country, or to a sin- gle section of society. For the first time, in the eighteenth century, they peneti'atcd to the masses of the people, stirred them to their lowest depths, and produced an upheaving that was scarcely less general than that of the Reformation. The history of the movement was like that of the enchanted well in the Irish legend, which lay for centuries shrouded in dark- ness in the midst of a gorgeous city, till some careless hand left open the door that had enclosed it, and the morning sun- light flashed upon its waters. Immediately it arose respon- sive to the beam ; it burst the barriers that had confined it ; it submerged the city that had surrounded it ; and its resist- less waves, chanting wild music to heaven, rolled over the temples and over the palaces of the past. There is no fact more remarkable in this movement tlian the manner in which it has in many countries risen to the position of a religion — that is to say, of an unselfish enthu- ' See a singularly curious essay on the history of Gardens in Vitct, pMdes sur VJIistoire de VArt. Le Notre laid out the gardens of Versailles for Louis XIV. " As, for example, when it is contended that a people with representa- tive government are slaves, except during the period of the elections. (Cori. irnt Social, liv. iii. ch. xv.) THE SECULARISATION OF TOLmCS. 217 siasin uniting vast bodies of men in aspiration towards an ideal, and proving the source of heroic virtues. It is always extremely important to trace the direction in which the spirit of self sacrifice is moving, for npon the intensity of that spirit depends the moral elevation of an age, and npon its course the religious future of the world. It once impelled the war- riors of Euroj)e to carry ruin and desolation to the walls of Jerusalem, to inundate the plains of Palestine wath the blood of slaughtered thousands, and to purchase by unparalleled calamities some relics for the devotion of the pilgrim. It once convulsed Europe with religious w^ars, suspended all pacific operations, and paralysed all secular interests in order to secure the ascendency of a church or of a creed. It once drove tens of thousands into the retirement of the monas- teries ; induced them to macerate their bodies, and to mortify their affections; to live in sackcloth and ashes, in cold and poverty and privations, that by such means they might attain their reward. These things have now passed away. The crusader's sword has long been shattered, and his achieve- ments have been idealised by the poet and the novelist. The last wave of the religious wars that swept over so many lands has subsided into a calm that is broken only by the noisy recriminations of a few angry jjolemics. The monastic system and the conceptions from which it grew are fading rapidly before the increasing day. Celibacy, voluntary poverty, and voluntary subjection, were the three subjects which Giotto painted over the high altar of Assisi as the distinctive characteristics of the saint — the efforts of self- sacrifice that lead to the beatitude of heaven. All of them have now lost their power. Even that type of heroic gran- deur which the ancient missionary exhibited, though eulo- gised and revered, is scarcely reproduced. The spirit of self 218 KATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. sacrifice still exists, but it is to be sought in other fields — in a boundless philanthropy growing out of affections that are common to all religions, and above all in the sphere of politics. Liberty and not theology is the enthusiasm of the nineteenth century. The very men who would once hayc been conspicuous saints are now conspicuous revolutionists, for while their lieroism and their disinterestedness are their own, the direction these qualities take is determined by the pressure of their age. If we analyse the democratic ideal which is exercising so wide an influence, we find that it consists of two parts — a re- arrangement of the map of Europe on the principle of the rights of nationalities, and a strong infusion of the democratic element into the government of each State. The recogni- tion of some universal principle of political right powerful enough to form a bond of lasting concord has always been a favourite dream with statesmen and philosophers. Hilde- braud sought it in the supremacy of the spiritual power, and in the consequent ascendency of the moral laAv; Dante in the fusion of all European States into one great empire, presided over in temporal matters by the Cresars and in spiritual by the Popes ; Grotius and Henry TV. of France, in a tribunal like the Amphictyonic assembly of ancient Greece, deciding with supi-eme authority international differences ; dij)lomacy in artificial combinations, and especially in the system of the balance of power. The modern doctrine of the rights of na- tionalities could not possibly have attained any great imj)or- tance till the present century — in the first place because it is only after the wide diffusion of education that the national sentiment acquires the necessary strength, concentration, and intelligence, and in the next place because the influence of the selfish side of human nature was hostile to it. The con- THE SECULAETSATION OF POLITICS. 219 cei^tions that the interests of adjoining nations are diametri- cally opposed, that wealth can only he gained by displace- ment, and that conquest is therefore the chief path to pro- gress, were long universal ; hut during the last century po- litical economy has been steadily subverting them, and has already effected so much that it scarcely seems unreasonable to conclude that the time will come when a policy of terri- torial aggrandisement will be impossible. At the same time the extension of free-trade has undoubtedly a tendency to effect the disintegration of great heterogeneous empires by destroying the peculiar advantages of colonies and of con- quered territory; while railways and inci'easing knowledge weaken national antipathies and facilitate the political agglo- meration of communities with a common race, language, and geographical position. The result of all this is that motives of self-interest do not 02:)pose themselves as powerfully as of old to the recognition of territorial limits defined by the wishes of the people. And this is peculiarly important, be- cause not only does interest, as distinguished from passion, gain a greater empire with advancing civilisation, but pas- sion itself is mainly guided by its power. If, indeed, we ex- amine only the proximate causes of European wars, they present the aspect of a perfect chaos, and the immense major- ity might be ascribed to isolated causes or to passing ebulli- tions of national jealousy. But if we examine more closely, we find that a deepseated aversion produced by general causes had long preceded and prepared the explosion. The great majority of wars during the last 1,000 years may be classified under three heads — wars produced by opposition of religious belief, wars resulting from erroneous economical notions either concerning the balance of trade or the material advantages of conquest, and wars resulting from the collision 220 rationalism: in eueope. of the two liostile doctrines of the Divine right of kings and the rights of nations. In the first instance knowledge has gained a decisive, and in the second ahnost a decisive, vic- tory. Whether it will ever render equally impossible ijoliti- cal combinations that outrage national sentiment is one of the gi-eat problems of the future. This much at least is cer- tain, that the progress of the movement has profoundly and irrevocably impaired the force of treaties and of diplomatic arrangements as the regulating principles of Europe. But whatever may be thought on these subjects, it is at least certain that the movement we have traced has become a great moral influence in Europe, and, like many others, ex- hibits a striking synthesis of the distinctive elements of two different civilisations. The spirit of patriotism has under its influence assumed a position scarcely less prominent than in antiquity, while at the same time, by a transformation to vfhich almost all the influences of modern society have con- curred, it has lost its old exclusiveness without altogether losing its identity, and has assimilated with a sentiment of universal fraternity. The sympathy between great bodies of men was never so strong, the stream of enthusiasm never flowed in so bi'oad a current as at present; and in the demo- cratic imion of nations we find the last and highest expres- sion of the Christian ideal of the brotherhood of mankind. Nor is it simply in the international aspect of democracy that we trace this influence ; it is found no less clearly in the changes tliat have been introduced into internal legislation and social life. The political merits of democracy I do not now discuss, but no one at least can question the extent to which legislation has of late years been modified in favour of the lower classes, the sympathy and even deference that has been shown to their wants, the rapid obliteration of the THE SEOUL AEISATION OF POLITICS. 221 linos of class divisions, and the ever increasing tendency to amalgamation based upon political equality and upon en- larged sympathy. It is thus that amid the transformation or dissolution of intellectual dogmas the great moral principles of Christianity continually reappear, acquiring new power in the lapse of ages, and influencing the type of each pacceeding civilisation. CHAPTER VI. THE IN'DUSTKIAL HISTORY OF RATION'AIISM. The history of labour is only second iu importance to the history of knowledge. The estimate in which industry is held, the principles by which it is regulated, and the channels in which it is directed, not merely determine the material prosperity of nations, but also invariably contribute to the formation of a type of character, and in consequence to a modification of opinions. In the course of the present work I have more than once had occasion to refer to the influence of the industrial spirit upon Rationalism, but I have thought it advisable to reserve its full discussion for a separate chap- ter, in which the relation between the two evolutions will be clearly manifested, and the importance of commerce both as a disintegrating and constructive agent will be established. If we examine from an industrial point of view the old civilisation, which was sinking rapidly into dissolution when Christianity arose, we shall at once perceive that slavery was the central fact upon which it rested. "Whenever, in a highly-organised society, this institution is prominent, it will impart a special cast to the national character, and will in Bome i-espects invert the normal conditions of development. For labour, being identified with ignominy, will become dis- tasteful to all classes., and wealth will be speedily accumu THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOKY OF RATIONALISM. 223 lated in the hands of a few. Where slavery exists there is no middle class, little or no manufacturing or commercial enterprise. The slaveowner possesses the means of rapidly amassing wealth, while the freeman who is not a slaveowner, being shut out from nearly every jiath of industry, and being convinced that labour is a degradation, will be both demoral- ised and impoverished. At the same time a strong military spirit will usually be encouraged, both because the energies of men find no other sphere of action, and because in such a condition of society conquest is the chief path to wealth. In some respects the consequences of all this will appear very fascinating. A high military enthusiasm being engendered, the nation which cherishes sla^'ery will usually prove vic- torious in its conflicts with the commercial communities around it. It will produce many great warriors, many splen- did examples of military devotion. A combination of the high mettle of the soldier and of a chivalrous contempt for trade and the trading spirit will impart an aristocratic and refined tone to the national manners, while the national in- tellect will be diverted from utilitarian inventions and pur- suits, and will be concentrated on sublime speculations and works of beauty. But as soon as the first energy of the con- quering spirit has passed away, the hollo wness of such a civ- ilisation becomes apparent. The increase of wealth, which in a free nation stx-engthens the middle classes and gives a new impulse to commercial enterprise, in a slave nation pro- duces only luxury and vice; and the habit of regarding mul- titudes as totally destitute of rights, combined with the military spirit that is general, gives that vice a character of the most odious ferocity.^ ' TLe effects of slavery upon character have lately been treated with 224 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. It is of course possible that the intervention of other in flnences may modify this type of character, and may retard and in some degree prevent the downfall it produces ; but in as far as slavery is predominant, in so far will these tenden- cies be displayed. In the ancient civilisation they were de- veloped to the full extent. From a very early j^eriod the existence of slavery had produced, both in Greece and. Rome, a strong contempt for commerce and for manual labour, which was openly professed by the ablest men, and which harmonised well with their disdain for the more utilitarian aspects of science. Among the Boeotians those who had de- iiled themselves with commerce were excluded for ten years from all offices in the State. Plato pronounced the trade of a shopkeeper to be a degradation to a freeman, and he wished it to be punished as a crime. Aristotle, who asserted so strongly the political claims of the middle classes, declared, nevertheless, that in a perfect State no citizen should exer- cise any mechanical art. Xenophon and Cicero were both of the same opinion. Augustus condemned a senator to death because he had debased his rank by taking part in a manufacture. The single form of labour that was held in honour was agriculture ; and in the earlier and simpler pe- riods of the national history, while slaves were still few and luxury was unknoAvn, this pursuit proved a sufficient vent for the pacific energies of the people. But when the number and Avealth of the population had been multiplied, when along series of victories had greatly increased the multitude of slaves, and when the political privileges of a Roman citizen had been widely extended, all classes flocked within the walls, the surrounding country fell entirely into the hands of the very remarkable ability in Cairncs' Slave Power. See also Storch, Eeo7i. Politique, torn, v., and Ch. Comte, Traite de Legislation, lib. v. THE INDUSTEIAL IIISTOKT OF EATIOXALISM. 225 aristocracy, and either remained uncultivated or was culti- vated only by slaves,^ and the task of supplying the over- grown city with corn devolved chiefly xipon the colonies. Within the city a vast half-military population, sufliciently powerful to control the government, and intent only upon enjoyment, paralysed the energies of the empire, and de- stroyed every trace of its ancient purity. ' Bread and the games of the circus ' was the constant demand ; every other consideration w' as sacrificed to grant it ; and industry, in all its departments, was relinquished to the slaves. If we compare the condition of the ancient with that of the modern slaves, we shall find that they were in some re- spects profoundly different. The modern slave-trade was an atrocity unknown to the ancients, nor was there then the difference of race and colour that now prevents a fvision of the free and the enslaved classes. Aristotle, the greatest of all the advocates of slavery, recommended masters to hold out the prospect of future emancipation to their slaves ; and we know that in the latter days of the Roman Empire the manumission of old slaves was very general, and of those who were not old, by no means rare. Besides this, the great development of commerce enabling the modern slaveowners to command every description of luxury in exchange for the produce of unskilled slave-labour, they have usually, in order to guard against rebellion, adopted the policy of brutalising their slaves by enforced ignorance — to such an extent that it is actually penal, in the majority of the Slave States of America, to teach a slave to read. In the ancient civilisa- * See on this subject Plutarch, Lives of the Gracchi ; Dionysius, Halicar- iiassus, lib. ii. cap. 28 ; Columella, De Re Bustled. This whole subject has been very ably treated by M. Comte, Traile de Legislation. See also Blanqui, Histoire iCEconomie Politique ; Bureau de la Malle, Economie Politique des Romains. VOL. II. — 41 226 EATIONAI.ISM IX EUKOPE. tions, on the otlier hand, the slave produced all the articles of refinement and luxury, conducted the most difficult forms of labour, and often exercised the most important professions. His mind was therefore very frequently cultivated to the highest point, and his value was proportioned to his intelli- gence. Terence, Epictetus, Publius Syrus, and many other writers were slaves, as were also some of the leading physi- cians, and many of the most distinguished sculptors. It should be remembered, too, that while modern slavery was from the beginning an evil, slavery among the ancients was at first an unmingled blessing — an important conquest of the spirit of humanity. "When men were altogether barbarous they killed their prisoners ; when they became more merci ful they preserved them as slaves.' Still, in the latter days of the republic, and during the emiDire, the sufferings of the slaves were such that it is im- possible to read them without a shudder. The full ferocity of the national character Avas directed against them. They were exposed to wild beasts, or compelled to fight as gladia- tors ; they were often mutilated with atrocious cruelty ; they were tortured on the slightest suspicion, they were crucified for the most trivial ofiences. If a master was murdered all his slaA^es were tortured ; if the perpetrator remained undis- covered all were put to death, and Tacitus relates a case in which no less than 400 suflered for a single undiscovered criminal. We read of one slave who was crucified for hav- ing stolen a quail, and of another who was condemned to be thrown to the fish for having broken a crystal vase. Juvenal describes a lady of fashion gratifying a momentary caprice by ordering a slave to be crucified." ' The distinctions have been fully developed by Cairnes and De Tocque- ville. - See much horrible evidence of the atrocities practised on Roman slaves THE i:n^dustkial history of eationalism. 227 It was in this mannei' that the old civilisation, which rested on conquest and on slavery, had passed into complete dissolution, the free classes heing altogether demoralised, and the slave classes exposed to the most horrible . cruelties. At last the spirit of Christianity moved over this chaotic so- ciety, and not merely alleviated the evils that convulsed it, but also reorganised it on a new basis. It did this in three ways ; it abolished slavery, it created charity, it inculcated self-sacrifice. In the first of these tasks Christianity was powerfully as- sisted by two other agents. It is never possible for the moral sense to be entirely extinguished ; and, by a lav/ which is constantly manifested iu history, we find that those who have emancipated themselves from the tendencies of an evil age often attain a degree of moral excellence that had not been attained in ages that were comparatively pure. The latter days of pagan Eome exhibit a constant decay of relig- ious reverence and of common morality ; but they also ex- hibit a feverish aspiration towards a new religion, and a finer sense of the requirements of a high morality than had been displayed in the best days of the republic. We have a strik- ing instance of the first of these tendencies in that sudden diffusion of the worship of Mithra, which Avas one of the most remarkable of the antecedents of Christianity. About seventy years before the Christian era this worship was in- troduced into Italy, as Plutarch tells us, by some Cilician pirates; and at a time when universal scepticism seemed the dominant characteristic of the Roman intellect, it took such in Loiseleur, Etude sur les Crimes et lea Pciiies dans V Antl quite ct les Temps Modernes (Paris, 1863), pp. 83-98 ; and in Comte, Traite de Legislcdion, liv. V. There is an extremely good essay on the condition of the ancient slaves —one of the best ever written on the subject — in Bodin's EeinbUc, lib. i. c. 5. 22S KATIOKALISM m EUEOPE. firm root that for 200 years it continued to flourish, to excite the warmest enthusiasm, and ^o jjroduce a religious revival in the centre of a population that appeared entirely de- praved. In the same way, aboiit the time when Nero as- cended the throne, and when the humanity of the masses had sunk to the lowest ebb, there appeared in the centre of pa- ganism a powerful reaction in favour of the suffering classes, of which Seneca was the principal exponent, but which was more or less reflected in the whole of the literature of the time. Seneca recurred to the subject again and again, and for the first time in Rome he very clearly and emphatically enforced the duties of masters to their slaves, and the exist- ence of a bond of fraternity that no accidental difference of position could cancel. Nor was the movement confined to the writings of moralists. A long series of enactments by Nero, Claudius, Antonine, and Adrian gave the servile class a legal position, took the power of life and death out of the hands of the masters, prevented the exposure of slaves when old and infirm on an island of the Tiber (where they had often been left to die), forbade their mutilation or their employ- ment as gladiators, and appointed special magistrates to re- ceive their complaints. What was done was, no doubt, very imperfect and inadequate, but it represented a tendency of which Christianity was the continuation.^ A second influence favourable to the slaves came into action at a later period : I mean the invasion of the barba- rians, who have been justly described as the representatives of the principle of personal liberty in Europe.'^ Slavery was not, indeed, absolutely unknown among them, but it was alto- gether exceptional and entirely uncongenial with their habits. ' This movement has been -vrell noticed by Grotius, Dc Jure, lib. iii. c. 14. * Giiizot. THE lA'DrSTKIAL HISTOKT OF EATIONALISM. 229 Pi'isoners of war, criminals, or men who had gambled away their liberty, were the only slaves, and there is no reason to believe that servitude was hereditary. Whenever, therefore, these tribes obtained an ascendency, they contributed to the destruction of slavery. But when the fullest allowance has been made for these influences, it will remain an undoubted fact that the recon- struction of society was mainly the woi'k of Christianity. Other influences could produce the manumission of many slaves, but Christianity alone could efiect the profound change of character that rendered possible the abolition of slavery. There are few subjects more striking, and at the same time more instructive, than the history of that great transition. The Christians did not preach a revolutionary doctrine. They did not proclaim slavery altogether unlaw- ful, or, at least, not until the bull of Alexander III. in the twelfth century ; but they steadily sapped it at its basis, by opposing to it the doctrine of universal brotherhood, and by infusing a spirit of humanity into all the relations of society. Under Constantino, the old laws for the protection of slaves were reenacted with additional provisions, and the separa- tion of the family of the slave was forbidden. At the same time the servile punishment of crucifixion was abolished; but not so much from motives of humanity as on account of the sacred character it had acquired. Very soon a disposition was manifested on all sides to emancipate slaves, and that emancipation was invariably associated with religion. Sun- day was esjjecially recommended as the most ajiproi^riate day for the emancij)ation, and the ceremony almost invaria- bly took place in the church. Gregory the Great set the ex- ample of freeing a number of liis slaves as an act of devo- tion ; and it soon became customary for sovereigns to do thy 230 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE, same thing at seasons of great j^ublic rejoicing. Under Jus- tinian tlie restrictions that had been placed upon emancipa- tion by testament were removed. For a short time the mere resolution to enter a monastery gave liberty to the slave; and the monks, being for the most part recruited from the servile caste, were always ready to facilitate the deliverance of their brethren. Even in religious persecutions this object was remembered. The Jews were early noted as slave-deal- ers, and among the first and most frequent measures directed against them was the manumission of their Christian slaves. In all the rites of religion the difference between bond and free was studiously ignored, and the clergy invariably pro- claimed the act of enfranchisement to be meritorious.^ By these means an impulse favourable to liberty was im- parted to all who were within the influence of the Chiirch. SlaA'ery began rapidly to disappear, or to fade into serfdom. At the same time the Church exerted her powers, with no less effect, to alleviate the sufferings of those who still contin- ued in bondage. In England, especially, all the civil laws ' Cod. Tlieod. lib. ii. tit. 8, lex 1, and iv. V, 1. For the history of the action of Christianity upon slavery, see A. Comte, Phihsoplde Positive, torn, vi. pp. 43-47; Storch, Economie Politique, torn. v. pp. 806-810; Troplong, Influence du Christianisme sur le Droit Civil. The measures against Jew slave-owners have been noticed by Bedarride, Du Lac, and many other writ- ers. It must be acknowledged, however, that the Christian Emperor Gratian made one law which may rank with the most atrocious of Paganism. It pro- vides that if a slave accused his master of any crime except high treason, the justice of the charge was not to be examined, but the slave was to be committed to the flames : ' Cum accusatores servi dominis intonent, nemo judiciorum expectet even turn, nihil quecri, nihil discuti placet, sed cum ipsis delationum libelhs, cum omni scripturarum et meditati criminis apparatu, nefandarum accusationum* crementur auctores : excepto tamen adpetitss majestatis crimine, in quo etiam servis honesta proditio est. Nam et hoc facinus tendit in dominos.' — Cod. Theod. ix. 6, 2. Honorius accorded slaves the liberty of accusing their masters in cases of heresy, and Theodosius in cases of paganism. THE INDUSTEIAL niSTOET OF EATIOXALISil. 231 for tlie protection of the theows, or Saxon slaves, appear to have been preceded by, and based upon, the canon law. When, as ftir as can be ascertained, the power of the master was by law unlimited, we find the Church assuming a juris- diction on the subject, and directing sjDCcial penances 'against masters who took from their theows the money they had law- fully earned; against those who slew their theows Avithout judgment or good cause ; against mistresses who beat their female theows so that they die within three days; and against freemen who, by order of the lord, kill a theow.' Above all, the whole machinery of ecclesiastical discipline was put in motion to shelter the otherwise unprotected chas- tity of the female slave.* That Church which often seemed so haughty and so overbearing in its dealings with kings and nobles, never failed to listen to the poor and to the oppressed, and for many centuries their protection was the foremost of all the objects of its policy. Yet as long as the old antipathy to labour continued, nothing of any lasting value had been effected. But here, again, the influence of the Church was exerted with unwa- vering beneficence and success. The Fathers employed all their eloquence in favour of labour ; ^ but it is to the monks, and especially to the Benedictine monks, that the change is preeminently due. At a time when religious enthusiasm was all directed towards the monastic life as towards the ideal of perfection, they made labour an essential part of their discipline. Wherever they went, they revived the tra- ditions of old Roman agriculture, and large tracts of France and Belgium were drained and planted by their hands. And ' Wright, Letter on the Political Condition of the English Peasantry dur- \ng the Middle Ages. London, 1843. * Champagny, La Charite Chreticnnc, pp. 2*75-289. 232 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. though agriculture and gardenmg were the forms of labour in which they especially excelled, they indirectly became the authors of every other. For when a monastery was j)lanted, it soon became the nucleus around which the inhabitants of the neighbourhood clustered. A town was thus gradually formed, civilised by Christian teaching, stimulated to indus- try by the example of the monks, and protected by the rev- erence that attached to them. At the same time the orna- mentation of the church gave the first impulse to art. The monks of the order of St. Basil devoted themselves especial- ly to painting, and all the medisBval architects whose names have come down to us are said to have been ecclesiastics, till the rise of those great lay companies who designed or built the cathedrals of the twelfth century. A great number of the towns of Belgium trace their origin in this manner to the monks.' For a long time the most eminent prelates did not disdain manual labour; and it is related of no less a per- sonage than Becket that he was in the habit of labouring during harvest time in the fields with the monks at the mon- asteries which he visited." By these means the contempt for labour which had been produced by slavery was corrected, and the path was opened for the rise of the industrial classes which followed the Cru- sades. The ferocity of character that had preceded Chris- tianity was combated with equal zeal, though not quite equal success, by the oi'ganisation of Christian charity. There is certainly no other feature of the old civilisation so repulsive as the indifference to suffering that it displayed. It is indeed true that in this respect there Avas a considerable ' See on this subject Perm, Tm Ricliesse dans les Societes Chretiennes, torn. 1. pp. 345-361 ; Van Bruyssel, Hist, du Commerce Beige, torn. i. pp. 58, 59. * Eden, HMory of iJic Lahourinrj Classes in England, vol. i. p. 50. THE INDUSTETAL HISTOKY OF EATIOKALISM. 233 difference between the Greeks and the Romans. In their armaments, in their wars, above all, in the extreme solicitude to guard the interests of orphans and minors that character- ised their legislation,* the former displayed a si')irit of hu- manity for ■which we look in vain among the latter. Besides this, the political systems of Greece and, in its latter days, of Rome, were so framed that the state in a great measure supplied the material wants of the people, and a poor law of the heaviest kind was, to a certain extent, a substitute for private beneficence. Still there, as elsewhere, purely chari- table institutions were absolutely unknown. Except as far as the law interposed, there was no public refuge for the sick or for the destitute. The mfant Avas entirely unprotected ; and infanticide having been — at least in the case of deformed children — expressly authorised by both Plato and Aristotle, was seldom regarded as a crime.'' The practice of bring- ing up orphans avowedly for prostitution was equally com- mon. The constant association of human suffering with popular entei'tainments rendered the popular mind continu- ally more callous. Very different was the aspect presented by the early Church. Long before the era of persecution had closed, the hospital and the Xenodochion, or refuge for strangers, was known among the Christians. The epitaphs in the catacombs abundantly prove the multitude of foundlings that were sustained by their charity ; and when Christianity became the ^ Grote, Hist, of Greece, vol. ii. p. 123. ^ Hume has very ingeniously suggested, and Malthus has adopted the Euggestion, that the ancient permission of infanticide had on the whole a tendency to multiply rather than to diminish population ; for, by removing the fear of a numerous family, it induced the poor to marry recklessly ; while, once the children were born, natural affection would struggle to the last to sustam them. 23-1 RATIONALISM IN ErKOPE. dominant religion, the protection of infants was one of the first changes that was manifested in the laws.' The frequent fam- ines and the frightful distress caused hy the invasion of the barbarians, and by the transition from slavery to freedom, were met by the most boundless, the most lavish benevolence. The Fathers were ceaselessly exliorting to charity, and in lan- cjuage so emj^hatic that it seemed sometimes almost to ignore the rights of property, and to verge upon absolute commun- ism. = Tlie gladiatorial games were ceaselessly denounced ; but the affection with which they were regarded by the people long resisted the efforts of pliilanthropists, till, iu the midst of the spectacle, the monk Telemachus rushed between the combatants, and his blood was the last that stained the arena, * It is worthy of notice that deserted children in the early Church ap- pear to have been supported mainly by private charity, and those foundling hospitals, to which poUtical economists so strongly object, were xmknown. In the time of Justinian, however, we find notices of Brephotrophia, or asylums for children; and foundations, intended especially for foundlings, are said to have existed in the seventh and eighth centuries (Labourt, Recher- clies sn7- les Enfants trouvis, Paris, 1848, pp. 32, 33). A foundling hospital was estabhshed by Innocent III. at Rome. The objections to these institu- tions, on account of their encouragement of vice, as well as the frightful mortality prevaiUng among them, are well known. M'Culloch states that between 1*792 and 1*797 the admissions into foundhng hospitals in Dublin were 12,786, and the deaths 12,561 {Pol Econ. part i. ch. viii.). Magdalen asylums, which M. Ch. Comte and other economists have vehemently de- nounced, were also unknown in the early Church. The first erected in France was early in the thirteenth century ; the famous institution of the Bon Pasteur was founded by a Dutch lady converted to CathoUcism in 1698. A full history of these institutions is given in Parent-Duchatelet's singularly interesting work on Frostitution in the City of Farts. The admirable socie- ties for the succour of indigent mothers, which complete the measures for the protection of infancy, were chiefly the work of the French freethinkers of the last century. Beaumarchais dedicated part of the profits of the Mariage de Figaro to that of Lyons (DucelUer, Hist, dcs Classes Lahoricuse.% en France, p. 296). ^ See some very striking instances of this in Champagny's Charite Chreficnne THE INDUSTRIAL IIISTOIiY OF EATIONALISM. 235 But perhaps the noblest testimony to the extent and tlie catholicity of Christian charity was furnished by an adver- sary. Julian exerted all his energies to produce a charitable movement among the Pagans; 'for it is a scandal,' he said, ' that the Galileans should support the destitute, not only of their religion, but of ours.' In reading the history of that noble efflorescence of charity ■which marked the first ages of Christianity, it is impossible to avoid reflecting upon the strange destiny that has con- signed almost all its authors to obscurity, while the names of those who took any conspicuous part in sectarian history have become household words among mankind. We hear much of martyrs, who sealed their testimony with blood ; of courageous missionaries, who planted the standard of the Cross among savage nations and in pestilential climes ; but we hear little of that heroism of charity, which, with no pre- cedent to guide it, and with every early habit to oppose it, confronted the most loathsome forms of suffering, and, for the first time in the history of humanity, made iDflin and hideous disease the objects of a reverential affection. In the intel- lectual condition of bygone centui'ies, it was impossible that these things should be appreciated as they deserved. Charity was practised, indeed, nobly and constantly, but it did not strike the imagination, it did not elicit the homage of man- kind. It was regarded by the masses as an entirely subordi- nate department of virtue ; and the noblest efforts of philan- thropy excited far less admiration than the macerations of an anchorite or the proselytising zeal of a sectarian. Fabiola, that Roman lady who seems to have done more than any other single individual in the erection of the first hospitals ; St. Landry, the great apostle of charity in France; even Telemachus himself, are all obscure . names in history. The 23G KATioNALisjr m eueope. men who organised tliat vast network of hospitals that over- s2)reacT Europe after the Crusades have passed altogether from recollection. It was not till the seventeenth century, wdien modern habits of thought were widely diffused, that St. Vincent de Paul arose and fui'nished an example of a saint who is profoundly and universally revered, and who owes that reverence to the splendour of his charity. But although it is ti-ue that during many centuries the philanthroj^ist was placed upon a far lower level than at present, it is not the less true that charity was one of the earliest, as it was one of the nohlest, creations of Christianity ; and that, independent- ly of the incalculable mass of suffering it has assuaged, the influence it has exercised in softening and purifying the char- acter, in restraining the passions, and enlarging the sympa- thies of mankind, has made it one of the most important elements of our civilisation. The precepts and examples of the Gospel struck a chord of pathos which the noblest phi- losophies of antiquity had never reached. For the first time the aureole of sanctity encircled the brow of sorrow and invested it wdth a mysterious charm. / It is related of an old Catholic saint that, at the evening of a laborious and well- spent life, Christ appeared to him as a man of sorroAvs, and, commending his past exertions, asked him what reward he would desire. Fame, and wealth, and earthly pleasures had no attraction to one who had long been weaned from the things of sense ; yet the prospect of other and spiritual bless- ings for a moment thrilled the saint with joy; but when he looked upon that sacred brow, still shadowed as with the anguish of Gethsemane, every selfish wish was forgotten, and, with a voice of ineffable love, he answered, ' Lord, that I might suffer most ! ' ^ ' This is, I believe, related of St. John of the Cross. There is a some THE IXDUSTEIAT^ IIISTOET OF RATIONALISM. 237 The third principle that Christianity employed to correct the evils of a decayed society was the principle of self-sacri- fice. We have already seen some of the evils that resulted from the monastic system; but, considered in its proper place, it is not difficult to perceive its use. For the manner hi which society attains that moderate and tempered excel- lence which is most congenial to its welfare is by imperfectly aspiring towards an heroic ideal. In an age, therefore, when the government of force had produced universal anarchy, theologians taught the doctrine of passive obedience. In an age Avhen unbridled luxury had produced an unbridled cor- ruption, they elevated voluntary poverty as a virtue. In an age when the facility of divorce had almost legalised polyg- amy, they proclaimed, with St. Jerome^ that ' marriage peo- ples earth, but virginity heaven.' The earlier portion of the middle ages presents the almost unique spectacle of a society that was in all its parts moulded and coloured by theological ideas, and it was natural that when the progress of knowledge destroyed the ascendency of those ideas a universal modification should ensue. But besides this, it is not, I think, difficult to perceive that the industrial condition of Europe at this time contained ele- ments of dissolution. The true incitements to industry must ever be found in its own rewards. The desire of wealth, the multiplied wants and aims of an elaborated civilisation, the rivalry and the ambition of commerce, are the chief causes of its progress. Labour performed as a duty, associated with the worship of voluntary poverty, and with the condcmna- lion of luxury, was altogether abnormal. It was only by what similar legend of a Spanish saint of the thirteenth century named Ramon Monat, The Virgin appeared to him and ofifered him a crown of roses, which he refused, and Christ then save him His own crown of thorns. L!C)S RATIONALISM m EUROPE. the emancipation and develojiment of some of tlie towns of Italy and Belgium that the industrial spirit became entirely secular, and, assuming a new prominence and energy, intro- duced an order of tendencies into Europe which gradually encroached upon the domain of theology, and contributed largely towards the Reformation, and towards the rationalism that followed it. But before examining the nature of those tendencies it may be necessary to say a few words concern- ing the circumstances that gave them birth. Although the old Roman slavery received its death-blow under the influences I have noticed, some lingering remains of it continued till the twelfth or thirteenth century ; ' and the serfdom that followed not only continued much later, but even for a long time absorbed great numbers of the free peasants. The rapacity of the nobles, and the famines that were so frequent during the middle ages, induced the poor to exchange their liberty for protection and for bread ; and the custom of punishing all crimes by fines, Avitli the alternative of sei'vitude in case of non-jDayment, still further increased the evil. At the same time the mildness of the ecclesiastical rule, and also the desire to obtain the advantage of the prayers of the monks, induced many to attach themselves as * In 1102 a Council of Westminster found it necessary to prohibit tlie sale of slaves in England (Eden, Hist, of Labouring Classes, vol. i. p. 10) ; and still later the English were accustomed to sell slaves to the Irish, and Giraldus Cambrensis tells us that the emancipation of their slaves as an act of devotion was enjoined by the Irish bishops on the occasion of Strong- bow's invasion. Bodin has noticed some passages from the bulls of the Popes relative to slaves in Italy as late as the thirteenth century [Ecpubliqiie, p. 43). Religion, which so powerfully contributed to the emancipation, in some cases had an opposite influence, for Christians enslaved without scruple Jews and Mohammedans, who naturally retaliated. The number of Christian slaves bought up by the Jews had been one of the complaints of Agobard In the ninth century. THE ESTDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF EATIOXALISM. 239 serfs to tlie raonfisteries.* ' Although it woukl be unfjiir to accuse the Church of ahandoning the cause of emancipation, it is probable that this last fact in some degree lessened her zeal.' The bulk of the population of Europe was emanci- pated between the twelfth and fifteenth centuries ; but the remains of serfdom have even now scarcely disappeared/ In the towns, however, j)ersonal and political liberty was at- tained much earlier. Something of the old Roman munici- jDal government had lingered faintly in the south of France during the whole of the middle ages ; but the complete emancipation was chiefly due to the necessities of sovereigns, who, in their conflicts with the nobles or with other nations, gladly purchased by privileges the assistance of the towns. It is probable that the fact of many of the English kings be- ing usurpers contributed in this way to the emanci2:)ation of the English citizens ; * and the struggle between the king ' See on all these causes Hallam's Middle Ages, vol. i. pp. SlV, 218. "^ ' The clergy, and especially several Popes, enforced manumission as a duty upon laymen, and inveighed against the scandal of keeping Christians in bondage ; but they were not, it is said, as ready in performing their own parts. The villeins upon the Church lands were among the last who were emancipated.' — Hallam, Middle Ages, vol. i. p. 221. ^ The decline of serfdom has been treated by Hallam, Hist, of Middle Ages, vol. i. pp. 222, 223. As late as 1775, coUiers in Scotland were bound to perpetual service in the works to which they belonged. Upon the sale of those works the purchasers had a right to their services, nor could they be elsewhere received into service except by permission of the owner of the col- liei'ies. See a note by M'CuUoch, in his edition of the Wealth of Ncdions, vol. ii. p. 186. * ' It wants not probability, though it manifestly appears not, that Wil- liam Rufus, Henry I., and King Stephen, being all usurpers, granted large immunities to burghs to secure them to their party, and by the time that Glanvil wrote, which was in the reign of Henry II., burghs had so great privileges as that, if a bondsman or servant remained in a burgh as a burgess or member of it a year and a day, he was by that very residence made free ; and so it was in Scotland : he was always free, and enjoyed the liberty of the burgh if he were able to buy a burgage, and his lord claimed him not within a year and a day.' — Brady, Historical Treatise on Cities (1690), p. 18. 210 KATIONALISM EST EUROPE. and nobles in France, and between the Popes and the em- perors in Italy, had a similar effect. WheneA^er a town was emancipated an impulse was given to industry. The Cru- sades at last gave the municipal and industrial element an extraordinary prominence. The great sums for which kings and nobles became indebted to the middle classes, the rapid development of navigation, the inventions that were iraj)ort- ed into Europe from the East, and, above all, the happy for- tune that made the Italian towns the centre of the stream of wealth, had all, in different ways, increased the influence of the towns. In the course of the twelfth century, nearly all which carried on commercial intercourse with Italy had ob- tained municipal government, and some of those of Belgium, and along the shores of the Baltic, almost equalled the Italian ones in commercial activity.* At the same time the creation of guilds and corporations of different trades consolidated the advantages that had been gained. For although it is un- doubtedly true that in a normal condition of society the sys- tem of protection and monopoly, of which the corporations were the very ideal, is extremely unfavourable to production, in the anarchy of the middle ages it was of great use in giv- ing the trading classes a union which protected them from plunder, and enabled them to incline legislation in their favour. Commerce, under their influence, became a great power. A new and secular civilisation was called into being, which grad- ually encroached upon the ascendency of theological ideas, and inti'oduced a new i)hase in the development of Europe. It may be observed, however, that the opposition that at last arose between the theological and the commercial spirits ^ Thierry, Hkt. du Tiers Etat, pp. 24, 25. It is scarcely necessary to refer to the admirable sketch of the history of towns in the Wealth of Nations. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY OF EATIONALISM. 241 IS not exactly what we might at first sight liave expected ;■ for in the earlier stages of society they have striking points of afiinity. Missionary enterprises and commercial entei-- l^rises are the two main agents for the diffusion of civilisa- tion; they commonly advance together, and eacli lias very frequently proved the pioneer of the other. Besides this, the Crusades, which were the chief expi'ession of the religious sentiments of the middle ages, owed their partial success in a great measure to the commercial communities. It was the merchants of Amalfi Avho, by their traffic, first opened the path for Christians to Jerusalem, and, in conjunction with the other Italian republics, suj)plied the chief wants of the Crusaders. The spirit that made the Venetian merchants of the thirteenth century stamp the image of Christ upon their coins, and the merchants of Florence impose a tax upon their rich woollen manufactures, in order, with the produce, to erect that noble cathedral which is even now among the wonders of the world, seemed to augur well for their alliance with the Church. Yet the event shows that these expecta- tions were unfounded, and that wherever the type of civilisa- tion was formed mainly by commercial enterprise, there firose a conflict with the theologians. The first point in which the commercial civilisation came into collision with the Church was the lawfulness of lending money at interest, or, as it was then called, of practising usury. In the present day, when political economy has been raised to a science, nothing can appear more simple than the positicm that interest occupies in pecuniary arrangements. We know that, in a society in which great works of indus- try or public utility are carried on, immense sums will neces- sarily be borrowed at interest, and that such transactions are vol: ii: — 42 242 NATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. usually advantageous both to the lender and the borrower The first lends his nioney for the purpose of increasmg hia wealth by the interest he receives ; the second obtains the advantage of disposing of a sum which is sufficient to set in motion a lucrative business, and this advantage more than compensates him for the interest he pays. We know, too, that this interest is not capricious in its amount, but is gov- erned by fixed laws. It usually consists of two distinct ele- ments— the interest which is the price of money, and what has been termed ' the ' interest of assurance.' The price of money, like the price of most other commodities, is deter- mined by the law of supply and demand." It depends ujjou the proportion between the amount of money that is to be lent and the demands of the borrowers, which proportion is itself influenced by many considerations, but is chiefly regu- lated in a normal state of society by the amount of wealth and the amount of enterprise. The second kind of interest arises in those cases in which there is some danger that the creditor may lose what he has lent, or in which some penalty, * By J. B. Say, in his Traite cVEconomie Politique, where the subject of usury is admirably discussed. The term, ' interest of assurance,' however, is defective, because it does not comprise the opprobrium cast upon the lender, which is one great cause of the extraordinary rise of interest. ^ As this is not a treatise of Pohtical Economy, the reader will, I trust, pardon my adoptmg this old and simple formulary, without entering at length into the controversy created by the new formulary of Ricardo — that price is regulated by the cost of production. In the vast majority of cases these two formularies lead to exactly the same result, and the principal advantage of that of Ricardo seems to be, first, that in some cases it gives greater pre- cision than the other, and secondly, that it supplements the other, meeting a few cases to which the old formulary will not apply. In determining the value of the precious metals as measured by other things — that is to say, as reflected in prices — the rule of Ricardo seems most satisfactory : in deter- mining the normal rate of interest, the old rule is, I think, perfectly ade- quate. There are some good remarks on this in Chevallier, Ucon. Polit. sec. V. c. 1. THE lifDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISlSr, 243 inflicted by la^y or by public opinion, attaches to the loan. For it is manifest that men will not divert their capital from secure to insecure enterprises unless there is a possibility that they may obtain a larger gain in the latter than in the former, and it is equally manifest that no one will voluntarily take a course that exposes him to legal penalties or to public reproach unless he has some pressing motive for doing so. If, then, when the law of supply and demand has regu- lated the rate of interest, the government of the country in- terposes, and cither prohibits all interest or endeavours to fix it at a lower rate; if public opinion stigmatises the lender at interest as infamous, and if religion brands his act as a crime, it is easy from the foregoing princii^les to perceive what must be the consequence. As long as there are persons who urgently desire to borrow, and persons who possess cap- ital, it is quite certain that the relation of debtor and creditor will continue ; but the former will find that the terms have greatly altei-ed to his disadvantage. For the capitalist will certainly not lend without exacting interest, and such inter- est as is at least equivalent to the profits he would derive if he employed his money in other ways. If the law forbids this, he must either not lend, or lenrl in a manner that ex- poses him to legal penalties, A great number, overcome by their scruples or their fears, will adopt the former course, and consequently the amount of money in the community which is to be lent, and Avhich is one of the great regulators of the price of money, will be diminished; while those who venture to incur the risk of infringing human, and, as they believe. Di- vine laws, and of incurring the infamy attached by public opinion to the act, must be bribed by additional interest. At the same time the furtive character given to the transaction is eminently favourable to imposition. The more thei'efore 244 KATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. law, public oijiuion, and religion endeavour to lower the cur- rent rate of interest, the more that rate Avill be raised. But these principles, simple as they may now appear, were entirely unknown to the ancients, and from an extreme- ly early j^eriod the exaction of interest was looked upon with disfavour. The origin of this prejudice is probably to be found in the utter ignorance of all uncivilised men about the laws that regulate the increase of wealth, and also in that early and universal sentiment which exalts prodigality above parsimony. At all times and in all nations this preference has been shown, and there is no literature in Avhich it has not been reflected. From the time of Thespis downwards, as Bentham reminds us, there is scarcely an instance in which a lender and a borrower have appeared upon the stage without the sympathies of the audience being claimed for the latter. • The more ignorant the people, the more strong will be this prejudice ; and it is therefore not surj^rising that those who were the preeminent representatives of parsimony, who were constantly increasing their wealth in a way that was so dif- ferent from the ordinary forms of industry, and who often appeared in the odious light of oppressors of the poor, should have been from the earliest times regarded with dislike. Aristotle and many other of the Greek philosophers cordially adopted the poj)ular view; but at the same time money- lending among the Greeks was a common though a despised profession, and was little or not at all molested by authority. Among the Gauls it was placed under the special patronage of Mercury. In Rome also it was authorised by law, though the legislators constantly sought to regulate its terms, and though both the philosophers and the people at large branded the money-lenders as the main cause of the decline of the empire. The immense advantages that capital possesses in a THE INDUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 245 slave-countiy, and the craving foi' luxury that was univer- sal, combined with the insecurity produced by general mal- administration and corruption, and by frequent tumults created with the express object of freeing the plebeians from iheir debts, had raised the ordinary rate of interest to an enormous extent ; and this, which was in truth a symptom of the diseased condition of society, was usually regarded as the cause. At the same time the extreme severity with which Roman legislation treated insolvent debtors exasper- ated the people to the highest point against the exacting creditor, while, for the reasons I have already stated, the popular hatred of the usurers and the interference of legisla- tors with their trade still further aggravated the evil. Be- sides this, it should be observed that when public opinion stigmatises money-lending as criminal, great industrial enter- prises that rest upon it will be unknown. Those who borrow Avill therefore for the most part borrow on account of some urgent necessity, and the fact that interest is wealth made from the poverty of others will increase the j^rejudice against it. When the subject came under the notice of the Fathers and of the mediaeval writers, it was treated with unhesitating emphasis. All the pagan notions of the iniquity of money- lending were mianimously adopted, strengthened by the hostility to wealth which early Christianity constantly incul- cated, and enforced with such a degree of authority and of persistence that they soon passed into nearly every legisla- tive code. Turgot and some other writers of the eighteenth century have endeavoured to establish a distinction between more or less rigorous theologians on this subject. In fact, however, as any one who glances over the authorities that have been collected by the old controversialists on the sub- 246 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. ject may couvince himself, there was a perfect imanimity oii the general prmci2:)les connected with usury till the casuists of the seventeenth century, although there were many con- troversies about their special applications/ A radical mis- conception of the nature of interest ran through all the writings of the Fathers, of the mediseval tlieologiaus, and of the theologians of the time of the Reformation, and produced a code of commercial morality that appears with equal clear- ness in the Patristic invectives, in the decrees of the Councils, and in nearly every book that has ever been written on the Canon Law. The difference between theologians was not in what they taught, but in the degree of emphasis with which they taught it. There were no doubt times in which the doctrine of the Church fell into comparative desuetude : there were times when usury was very generally practised, and not very generally condemned. There are even a few examples of Councils which, without in any degree justifying usury, contented themselves with expressly censuring priests who had practised it.'' But at the same time there is a long All the old Catholic works on the Canon Law and on Moral Philosophy show this, but I may especially indicate Concina, Adversus Usuram (Romse, 1746); Concina, Usura Contractus trini (Romse, 1748); Leotardus, De Usuris (Lugduni, 1649); Lamet et Fromageau, Didionnaire des Cas de Con- science (a collection of the decisions of the doctors of the Sorbonne), art. Usure (Paris, 1733); and Conferences EccUsiastiques de Paris sur VUsure (Paris, 1748). This last work was published under the direction or, at all events, patronage of Cardinal de Noailles, and contains a very large amount of information on the subject. It went through several editions : the first was published in 1697. See too Liegeois, Essai sur VHistoire et la Legislor Hon de V Usure. - This appears to have been the case in England, where the laxity on the subject was considerable, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries (see Ander- son, Hist, of Commerce, vol. i. pp. 79-113). Only a month before the Coun- cil of Nice, Constantine had confirmed the old Roman law which legalised an interest of 12 per cent. ; and it was probably the desire to avoid collision with the civil power that dictated the language of a curious decree of the THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 247 unbroken chain of tineqnivocal condemnations, extending from the period of the Fathers to the period of the Eeforma- tion The doctrine of the Church has been involved in some little obscurity on account of the total change that has taken place during the last three centuries in the meaning of the word usury, and also on account of the many subtle- ties with which the casuists surrounded it ; but if the reader will fiardon a somewhat pedantic array of definitions, it will be easy in a few words to disentangle it from all ambiguity. Usury, then, according to the unanimous teaching of the old theologians, consisted of any interest that was exacted by the lender from the borrower solely as the price of the loan.' Its nature Avas, therefore, entirely independent of the amount that was asked, and of the civil laws upon the sub- Council, in which usury is condemned only when practised by clergymen, but at the same time is condemned on grounds that are equally appUcable to lay- men : ' Quoniam raulti sub regula constituti avaritiam et turpia lucra sectan- tur, oblitique divinse Scripturae dicentis, " Qui pecuniam suam non dedit ad usuram," mutuum dantcs centesimas exigunt ; juste censuit sancta et magna synodus ut si quis inventus fuerit post banc definitionem usuras accipiens . dejiciatur.a clero et alienus existat a regula.' (See Troplong, Memoire sur le Prct d Vlrderet, read before the Institute in 1844.) But the Council of Eliberis, in the beginning of the fourth century, and the Third and Fourth Councils of Carthage, expressly condemned usux-y in laymen. * The following were the principal definitions of usury employed by the writers on Canon Law : — 1. Usui-a est pretium usus pecunicC mutuatse. 2. Lucrum immediate ex mutuo provenions. 3. Usura est cum quis plus exigat in pecimia aut in aliqua, re quam dederit. 4. Ultra sortem lucrum aliquod ipsius ratioue mutui exactum. — This last is the definition of Benedict XIV. Melanchthon defined usury nearly in the same way : ' Usura est lucrum supra sortem exactum tantum propter ofHcium mutuationis.' To this I may add the description given by St. Augustine of the sin : ' Si foeneraveris homini, id est mutuam pecuniam dederis, a quo aliquid plus quam dedisti expectas accipere, non pecuniam solam sed aliquid plus quam dedisti, sive illud triti- cum sit, sive vinum, sive oleum, sive quodlibet aliud, si plus quam dedisti expectas accipere foenerator es et in hoc improbandus non laudandus ' (Ser- mon iii. on Psalm xxxvi.). — See Concina, Advrrsus Usuram, pp. 32, 33. 2-18 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. ject. Those who lent money at three per cent, -were cora- mitting usury quite as really as those who lent it at foi-ty per cent.,' and those who lent money at interest in a country where there was no law upon the subject as those who lent it in defiance of the most stringent prohibitions.'' It is not, however, to be inferred from this that everything of the nature of interest was forbidden. In the first place, there was the case of permanent alienation of capital. A man might deprive himself for ever of a certain sum, and receive instead an annual revenue; for in this case he was not re- ceiving the price of a loan, as a loan implies the ultimate restitution of that which had been lent. There is some reason to believe that this modification was introduced at a late period, when the rise of industrial enterprises had begun to show the ruinous character of the doctrine of usury ; but at all events the distinction was generally adoj^ted, and be- came the cornerstone of a large amount of legislation.' In ^ In 1677, when much casuistry had been already applied to the subject, some one submitted this point to the doctors of the Sorbonne. Their decision was : ' Que Titius ne seroit pas exempt d'usure en ne prenant que trois pour cent d'interet, parceque tout profit et tout gain tire du pret, si petit qu'il puisse 6tre, fait I'usure. L'Ezechiel au ch. xviii. ne fait point de distinction du plus ou du moins.' — Lamet et Fromageau, Diet des Cos de Conscience (Art. Tlsure). ^ Thus Innocent XI. condemned the proposition, 'Fsura non est dum ultra sortem aliquid exigitur tauquam ex benevolentia et gratitudine debitura, sed solum si exigatur tanquam ex justitia debitum.' — See Conferences sur VUsure, torn. i. p. 100. ' ' Tandis que le eri des peuples centre le pret a interet le faisait pros- crire, I'impossibilite de I'abolir eutierement fit imaginer la subtilite de I'alie- nation du capital ; et c'est ce systeme qui etant devenu presque general parmi les theologieus a ete adopte aussi par les jurisconsultes, h. raison de I'influ- euce beaucoup trop grande qu'ont cue sur notre jurisprudence et notre legis- lation les principes du droit canon.' (Turgot, Mem. sur les Frets d'' Argent, § 29.) Some seem to have tried to justify usury on the condition of the lender obliging himself not to demand his money till a certain period, for we find Alexander VII. condemning the proposition, ' Quod sit licitum mutuant! THE IKDUSTKIAL HISTOKT OF EATION^LISM. 2-19 tlie next place, there were certain cases in whicli a lender might claim interest from his debtor — not as the price of the loan, not as a rent exacted for the nse of money — but on other grounds which were defined by theologians, and which were, or were at least believed to be, entirely distinct/ Such were the cases known among the schoolmen under the titles of ' damnum emergens ' and ' lucrum cessans.' If a man was so situated that, by withdrawing a portion of his capital from the business in which he was engaged, he would suffer a palpable and unquestionable loss, and if for the pur- pose of assisting his neighbour he consented to withdraw a certain sum, he might stipulate a compensation for the loss he thus incurred. He was not lending money for the pui- pose of gaining money by the transaction, and the interest he exacted was solely a compensation for a loss he had actually sustained. In the same way, if a man was able to apply money to a purpose that Avould bring a certain gain, and if he consented to divert a certain sum from this channel in order to lend it to a friend, it was generally (but by no means always^) believed that he might receive an exact equivalent for the sacrifice he had unquestionably made. The question, too, of insurances was early raised, and created a cloud of the most subtle distinctions : so, too, did those great lending societies, which were founded in Italy by Ber- nardin de Feltre, under the title of ' Monti di Pietii,' for the purpose of counteracting the usury of the Jews. Their ob- aliquid ultra sortem exigere, modo se obliget ad non repctendum sortem usque ad certum terapus.' {Confh-ences sur V ITsure, torn. i. p. 100.) ^ These cases, of which I have only noticed the principal, and which were many of them very complicated, were discussed with much detail by the doc- tors of the Sorbonne. See Lamet et Fromageau ; see also the Mcmoire of Troplong. ' St. Thomas Aquinas was believed to be hostile to this indulgence. 250 EATIOiS^ALISM IN EmOPE. ject was to lend money to the poor without interest, but veiy soon a small sum was exacted in return, in addition to what had been lent. This was very naturally stigmatised as usury, because, as we have seen, usury was entirely irre- spective of the amount that was asked ; but some theolo- gians maintained, and Leo X. at last decided by a bull, that this exaction was not usurious, because it was simply a fee for the payment of the officials connected with the establish- ments, and not .the price of the loan.^ These examples will serve to show the general character that controversies on usury assumed. Above all the compli- cations and subtleties with which the subject was surround- ed, one plain intelligible principle remained — the loan of money was an illicit way of acquiring wealth. In other words, any one who engaged in any speculation in which the increase of his capital by interest was the object had com- mitted usury, and was therefore condemned by the Church. It is said that after the twelfth century the lawfulness of usury was a popular tenet among the Greeks ; ^ but before this time the teaching of theologians on the subject seems to have been perfectly unanimous, and with this exception it continued to be so till the Keformation. Usury was not only regarded as an. ecclesiastical crime, but Avas also, as far as the Church could influence the legislators, a civil one, and it was especially singled out as one that should be investigated with torture.' * Besides Lamet and Fromageau, there is a discussion as to ' Monti di Tieth. ' in Escobar's Moral Philosopluj. - Conferences sur V Usure, torn. i. p. 23. Salelles, De Materiis Tribuiia- Hum Inquisitionis (Romaj, 1651), torn. ii. p. 156. According to Cibrario {Economia Folitka dd Medio Uvo, vol. ii.p. 52), a heretic named Bech, vrho was burnt in Piedmont in 13S8, was accused among other things of havii/i? maintained that ' incest and usury are not sins.' ^ Chartario, Praxis Irderrocfandarum Rerum (Roma?, 1618), p. 201. THE INDTJSTEIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 251 Such then was the doctrine of theologians. It remains to examine for a moment the arguments on Avhich it was based. The first of these in the present day appears very startling. It was said that usury, however moderate, is one of those crimes, like murder or rohbery, that are pal- pably contrary to the law of nature. This was shown by the general consent of all nations against it, and also by a con- sideration of the nature of money; for 'all money is sterile by nature,' ^ and therefore to expect profit from it is absurd. The essence of every equitable loan is, that precisely that which was lent should be returned; and therefore, as Lac- tantius maintained, and as the mediaeval moralists unani- mously repeated, to exact interest is a species of robbery. It is true that it might naturally occur to the minds even of mediaeval theologians that houses or horses were sometimes lent at a fixed rent, which was paid notwithstanding their restitution. But this difficulty was answered by a very subtle distinction, which if it was not originated was at least ^ This is an absurdity of Aristotle, and the number of centuries during which it was incessantly asserted without being (as far as we know) once questioned is a curious illustration of the longevity of a sophism when ex- pressed in a terse form and sheltered by a great name. It is enough to make one ashamed of one's species to think that Bentham was the first to bring into notice the simple consideration that if the borrower employs the bor- rowed money in buying bulls and cows, and if these produce calves to ten times the value of the interest, the money oorrowed can scarcely be said to be sterile or the borrower a loser. The Greek word for interest {t6koq, from rihiTO), I beget) was probably connected with this delusion. Besides a host of theologians, the notion that usury was contrary to the law of nature was mahitained by Domat, one of the greatest names in French jurisprudence. Leo X. condemned usury on the following grounds : ' Dominus noster, Luca attestante, aperte nos prEecepto adstrinxit ne ex dato mutuo quidquam ultra Eortem speraremus ; est enim propria usurarum interpretatio quando vide- licet ex usura rei quae non germinat de nullo labore, nuUo sumptu, nullo peri- culo, lucrum foenusque couquiri studetur.' [Confercyices sw V Usurc, torn, L p. 100.) 252 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. chiefly developed by St. Thomas Aquinas. The use of a horse may he distinguished, at least hy the intellect, from the horse itself. Men borrow a horse and afterwards restore it, hut the usage of the horse lias been a distinct advantage, for which they may lawfully pay ; but in the case of money, which is consumed in the usage, the thing itself has no value distinct from its usage. When therefore a man restores the exact sum he has borrowed, he has done all that can be re- quired of him, because to make him pay for the usage of this money is to make him pay for a thing that does not exist, or, perhaps more correctly, to make him pay twice for tlie same thing, and is therefore, said St. Thomas, dishonest.' This was one branch of the argument ; the other was de- rived from authority. The political economy of the Fathers was received with imj^licit faith, and a long series of passages of Scripture Avere cited which were universally regarded as condemnatory of usury.* As it is quite certain that commer- cial and industrial enterprise cannot be carried on on a large scale without borrowing, and as it is equally certain that these loans can only be effected by paying for them in the ' The views of St. Thomas (who was one of the chief authorities on the subject) are in the Summa, Pars ii. Quast, TS. At the end of the eighteenth century they were drawn up with great elaboration by a writer named Pothier, and torn to pieces by Turgot [Mem, sur les Frets d''Arffent, § 26, 27). The argument as I have stated it is, I know, very obscure, but I venture to tl ink that is chiefly the fault of St. Thomas. The chief passages cited were — Lev. xxv. 36, Deut xxiii. 19, Ps. xv. 5, JHzsh xviii., and (from the New Testament) Luke vi. 85. As Turgot notices, the popular interpretation of this last passage was peculiarly inexcusable in Catholics, who always interpret the injunctions that surround it as ' counsela of perfection,' not obligatory on every man. Yet Bossuet was able to say, ' La tradition constaute des conciles, a. commencer par les plus anciens, celle des Papes, des peres, des interpretes et de TEglise Romaine, est d'interpreter ce versct, " Mutuum date nihil inde sperantes," comme prohibitif du profit qu'on tire du pret ; " inde " c'est a dire de I'usure.' (2nde Pastcrale, contrt la Version de Richard Simon.) THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 253 shape of interest, it is no exaggeration to say that the Church had cursed the material development of civilisation. As long as her doctiiue of usury was helieved and acted on, the arm of industry was paralysed, the expansion of commerce was arrested, and all the countless blessings that have flowed from them were withheld.' As, however, it is impossible for a society that is even moderately civilised to continue with- out usury, Ave find, from a very early period, a certain antag- onism existing on this subject between the civil law and the Church. The denunciations of the Fathers were soon succeeded by a long series of Councils which unanimously condemned usurers, and the canonical law is crowded with enactments against them ; but at the same time kings found it constantly necessary to borrow for the equipment of their armies, and they very naturally shrank from suppressing a class to which they had recourse. Edward the Confessor in- deed in England, St. Lewis in France,* and a few other sov- ^ Montesquieu, speaking of the scholastic writings on usury, says, with a little exaggeration, ' Ainsi nous devons aux speculations des Scholastiques touts les malheurs qui ont accompagne la destruction du commerce ' {Esprit des Lois, lib. xxi. c. 20) ; and Turgot, ' L' observation rigoureuse de ces lois serait destructive de tout commerce ; aussi ne sont-elles pas observees rigou- reusement. Elles interdisent toute stipulation d'interct sans alienation du capital. . . . Et c'est una chose notoire qu'il n'y a pas sur la terre une place de commerce ou la plus grande partie du commerce ne roule sur I'argent emprunte sans alienation du capital ' ( Hem. sur les Frets cF Argent, § xiv.). M. Sismondi has justly observed {ISFouvcaux Principes d' Economic Politique) that the prohibition of usury in Catholic countries has also done very much to promote a passion for luxury, and to discourage economy — the rich who were not engaged m business finding no easy way of emi^loying their savings productively. ^ Confirming in this respect a French law of the eighth and ninth century which provided that 'Usuram non solum clerici, sed nee laici Christiani, ex- igci-c debent.' Some think Justinian proliibitcd usury, but there is a good deal of dispute about this. Richard I. of England 'Christianum foenera- torem fieri prohibuit aut quacunque conventionis occasione aliquid recipere ultra id quod mutuo concessit' {Bromton CJironicon). Some governors made 254 RATIONALISM IIT EUEOPE, ereigiis of remarkable piety, took this extreme step; but gen- erally usury, though not altogether recognised, was in some degree connived at. Besides, to lend Avas esteemed much more sinful than to borrow,' and in the earlier part of the middle ages the usurers were almost exclusively Jews, who had no scruples on the subject, and who had adopted this profession partly because of the great profits they could de- rive from it, and partly because it was almost the only one open to them. It was not till the close of the eleventh cen- tury that Christian money-lenders became numerous, and the rise of this class was the immediate consequence of the com- mercial development of the Italian republics. The Lom- bards soon became the rivals of the Jews ; ^ the merchants of Florence carried on usury to a still greater extent,^ and for the first time this was done oijeuly, with the full sanction both of law and public opinion. From Italy usury passed to France and England ; * and the Third Council of the Lateran,* which was convened by Alexander III., in 1179, complained that it had so increased that it was almost everywhere prac- tised. The same Council endeavoured to arrest it by decree- ing that no notorious and impenitent usurer should be admit- ted to the altar should be absolved at the hour of death, or it a law that the property of those who had been usurers might be confis- cated by the crown after their death (Cibrario, Economia Politica del Medio Evo, vol. iii. p. 319). This arrangement had a double advantage : the gov- ernment might borrow money from the usurer while he was living, and rob his children when he was dead. ' According to the doctors of the Sorbonne, it was sinful to borrow at usury except under extreme necessity, but the whole stress of the denuncia- tions was directed against the lenders. " Bedarride, Hist, des Juifs, pp. 186-189. ^ Muratori, Antiq. Italicce, dissert, xvi. — a good history of the rise of Christian usurers. * Ibid. * Ihid. Tliis Council is reckoned a general one bv the Cathohcs. THE IXDrSTEIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 255 Bhoulcl receive Christian burial,' All this, however, was in vain : the expansion of commercial enterprise became every year more marked, and the increase of usury was its neces- sary consequence. In this manner the rise of an industrial civilisation pro- duced a distinct opposition between the practice of Christen- dom and the teaching of the Church. On the one hand, to lend money at interest became a constant and recognised transaction, and the more the laws of wealth were under- stood, the more evident it became that it was both necessary and innocent. On the other hand, there was no subject in the whole compass of Catholic theology on which the teach- ing of the Church was more unequivocal.* Usury had always been defined as any sum that was exacted as the price of a loan, and it had been condemned with unqualified severity by the Fathers, by a iDng series of Popes and Councils, by the most eminent of the medieval theologians, and by the unanimous voice of the Church. The result of this conflict evidently depended on the comparative prevalence of dog- matic and rationalistic modes of thought. As long as men derived their notions of duty from authority and tradition, they would adopt one conclusion ; when they began to inter- rogate their own sense of right, they would soon arrive at another. The sequel of the history of usury is soon told. The Ref- ' Ibid. The Council of Vienne, presided over by Clement Y., pro- nounced it to be heretical to justify usury : ' Sane si quis in istum errorem inciderit, ut pertinaciter affirmare prtesumat exercere usuras non esse pecca- tum, decernimus eum velut hasreticum puniendum.' ( Conferences sur V Usure, torn. i. p. 93.) ^ According to Concina, usury has been condemned by twenty-eight Coun- cils (six of them regarded by the Church of Rome as general), and by seven- teen popes {Adversm Usuram, pp. 112, 113). 256 EATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. ormatioii, which Avas in a, great measure effected by the trading classes, speedily dispelled the illusions on the subject, although the opinions of the Reformers were at first somewhat divided. Melanchthon, Brentius, and (perhaps) Bucer adojpted the old Catholic view;^ but Calvin maintamed that usury was only wrong when it was exacted in an oppressive manner from the poor,^ and, with admirable good sense, he refused to listen to those who exhorted him to check it by law. In England money-lending was first formally permitted under Henry VIII.' Somewhat later Grotius discussed it in a lib- eral though rather hesitating tone, maintaining strongly that it was at least not contrary to the law of nature." Two or three other Protestant writers, who are now almost forgot- ten, appear to have gone still further; but the author to whom the first unequivocal assertion of the modern doctrine of interest is due seems to be Saumaise,^ who, between 1638 and 1640, published three books in its defence. His vicAv was speedily but almost silently adopted by most Protest- ants, and the change produced no difficulty or hostility to Christianity. Among the Catholics, on the other hand, the difficulty of discarding the past was very considerable. At the begin- ning of the sixteenth century the modern distinction between ' See the passages in Concina, JJmra trini Contractus, pp. 250, 251. ^ Concina, Adversus ZTsuram, p. 2. This view was also adopted by Molinasus : ' Carolus Molinseus contendit acerrime usuram, nisi fraus adsit aut debitor nimium opprimatur, licitam esse. Doctores omnes a sescentis annis contrarium docuerunt' (Lcotardus, De Usv.ris, p. 15). Calvin was one of the very first who exposed the folly of the old notion about the sterility of money : see a remarkable passage in one of bis letters quoted by M'Cul- loch, Fol. Econ., pt. iii. ch. viii. ' Anderson, Hid. of Commerce, vol. i. p. 304. * Be Jure Belli et Pack, lib. ii. cap. 12. » Better known as Salmasius, the aTithor of the Defensio Regis to which Milton replied. THE INDUSTRIAL IIISTORT OF RATIONALISM. 257 usury and interest had been introduced among laymen, tc the great indignation of theologians,' ia order to evade the censure of the canonical law. The casuistry of the Jesuits was soon applied to the subject, and two or three circuitous ways of obtaining interest became popular, which gave rise 10 long and virulent controversies.^ Early in the eighteenth century three professors of the University of Ingolstadt, named Pichler, Tanner, and Hannold, took a further step, and contended that some forms of undoubted usury might be safely practised if the civil law j)ermitted them ; ' and in 1743 a writer named Broedersen Avrote a book which seems to have embodied and combined nearly all the leading senti- ments of the different schools of laxer theologians. The sub- ject had by this time excited so much agitation that Bene- ' Le Fevre, who was tutor to Louis XIII., mentions that in his time the term interest had been substituted for usury, and he added : ' C'est 1^ pro- prement ce qu'on peut appeler I'art de chicaner avec Dieu.' Marot also, who wrote in the first half of the sixteenth century, made this change the object of a sarcasm : — ' On ne prete plus k I'usure, Mais tant qu'on veut a I'interet.' (See Conferences sur V Usure, torn. i. p. 25.) According to Concina, the first, or nearly the first (fere primus), Catholic theologian who cavilled at the old definitions of usury was Le Coreur, who wrote a treatise in 1682, in which he maintained that moderate interest might be exacted on commercial loans, but not on those which had their origin in the necessities of poverty {Advcrsus Usuram, p. 3). The Catholic writers at this period nearly always spoke of the modern doctrine as a Protestant heresy — the heresy of Calvin, Molinseus, and Salmasius, - One of these was elaborately discussed by Concina in a treatise called T>c Usura trim Contractus (Romaj, 1748). Others, which arose especially in the commercial communities of Belgium, are noticed in Lamct and Froma- geau, and also by Troplong. ^ Pichler was a Jesuit, and his views on usury — a perfect cloud of sub- tleties— are contained in his Jus Canonicum (Venetiis, 1730), lib. iii. tit, 19, Tanner was also a Jesuit. Of Hannold I know nothing except from the brief notice of his opinions in Concina, Be Usura trini Gontrcctus, pp, 152-155. VOL. II. — 43 258 RATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. diet XIV. deemed it necessary to interpose. He accordingly, as the head of the Catholic Church, issued an encyclical letter in which he acknowledged that there were occasions when a lender, on special grounds, might claim a sum additional to what he had lent, but refused to j^ronounce in detail on the merits of the controversies that had been raised concerning particular kinds of loans, and contented himself with laying down authoritatively the doctrine of the Church. That doctrine was that usury is always a sin ; that it consists of any sum that is exacted beyond what had been lent, solely on account of the loan ; ^ and that the fact of this interest being moderrue, or being exacted only from a rich man, or in order to further a commercial undertaking, in no degree alters its character.' This appears to have been the last official utterance of the Church upon the subject, and al- though isolated theologians for some time attempted to stem the tide, their voices soon died away before the advancing spirit of Rationalism. Year by year what the old theolo- gians had termed usury became more general. The creation of national debts made it the very pillar of the jjolitical system. Every great enterprise that was undertaken re- ceived its' impulse from it, and the immense majority of the wealthy were concerned in it. Yet though it had long been ' ' Peccati genus illud quod usura vocatur, quodque in contractu mutui propriam suam sedem ct locum liabet, in co est repositum quod quis ex ipso- met mutuo, quod suapte natura tantundem duntaxat reddi postulat quantum receptum est, plus sibi reddi velit quam est receptum.' — Epistola Bcned. XIV., in Concina, Adver&us Usuram, p. 14. - 'Neque vero ad istara labem purgandam ullum arcessiri subsidium poterit, vel ex eo quod id lucrum non excedens et nimium sed moderatum, uon magnum sed exiguum sit ; vel ex eo quod is a quo id lucrum solius causA mutui deposcitur non pauper sed dives existat ; nee datam sibi mutuo sum- mam relicturus otiosam, sed ad fortunas suas amplificandas vel novis coemen- dis prsediis vel qusestuosis agitandis negotiis, utilissime sit impensurus.' — Ibid. THE mDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 259 branded as a mortal sin, and though mortal sin implied eternal separation from the Deity and the endurance of eter- nal and excruciating sufferings, the voice of the Church was silent. The decrees of the Councils remained indeed un- changed ; the passages from Scripture and from -the Fathers that had so long heen triumphantlj adduced continued precisely the same; but the old superstition faded steadily and almost silently away, till exevj vestige of it had dis- appeared. Laws, indeed, against usury still continued upon the statute book, but they were intended not to prohibit interest, but only to regulate its rate ; and as the principles of political economy were elucidated, this too began to pass away. At the close of the seventeenth century, Locke j^ro- tested strongly against the attempt to reduce interest by law ; ^ but the full investigation of the subject was reserved for the following century. It was remarked that Catharine of Russia having endeavoured to lower the general rate of interest from six to five per cent., her enactment had the effect of raising it to seven; and that Louis XY., in the same manner, raised it from five to six when intending to reduce it to four.'' Li England both Adam Smith and Hume threw a flood of light upon the subject, though neither of them fully perceived the evil of the laws, which the first, indeed. ' See liis Considerations on the Lowering of Interest, \i\ih\\s\\Q([ va. \QiS)\ — a tract which is, unfortunately, deeply tinged with the errors of the raercan tile theory, but is full of shrewd guesses on the laws of money. Locke per- ceived that interest depended upon supply and demand, and that all attempts to reduce it below the natural level were pernicious or abortive. He thought, however, that the maximum should be fixed by law to prevent imposition, but that that maximum should be fixed above the natural rate. At a still earlier period Harrington saw the necessity of usury, but involved himself in great obscurity, and almost absurdity, when discussing it ; see his Preroga^ ttve of Fopular Government, c. 3. " Storch, Economic Politique, tom. iii. p. 187. 260 EATIONALISM IN. EUKOPE. expressly applauded.^ In France, nine years before tlie 'Wealth of Nations,' Turgot had disclosed most of those evils ; and he appears to have clearly seen that interest is not capricious, btit bears a fixed relation to the general condition of society.' At last Bentham, in his famous 'Letters on Usury,' gave what will probably jjrove a deathblow to a legislative folly that has been in existence for 3,000 years. It has been observed by a Russian political economist that the Starovertsis, and some other dissenters from the Russian Church, still maintain that it is sinful to lend money 'at interest " — perhaps the last representatives of what was for many centuries the unanimous teaching of the Christian Church. The importance of this episode depends not so much on the question that was immediately at issue — though that question, as we have seen, was far from being insignilicant — ' Adam Smith ■nislied the legal interest to be fixed a very little above the current rate of interest, as a check upon prodigality and rash specula- tion. This is still done in many countries, but Bentham showed decisively (Letter xiii.. On Uswy) that such a law is extremely detrimental to industrial progress, as each new enterprise is almost necessarily more hazardous than old-established ones, and therefore capitalists will only direct their capital to the former if the interest to be obtained from them is considerably higher than could be obtained from the latter. To which it may be added that any attempt to dictate by law the terms on which a man may lend his money is an infringement of the rights of property, and that the borrower is much more likely to know at what rate he may profitably borrow than the legis- lator. ^ Besides the Ilemolre, Turgot noticed the subject in a very striking manner in his Reflexions sur la Formation des Jiichcsses. Like nearly every one in his time, he fell into the error of believing that the abundance of the precious metals told upon the rate of interest ; but this did not affect his main argument, and on the whole there is not much in Bentham that was not anticipated by Turgot. In Italy Genovesi, who was a contemporary of Turgot, advocated the abolition of usury laws. (Pecchio, Storia delJa Econo- mia Fubblica in Italia, p. 114.) * Storch, Economie Politique, torn. iii. p. 173. THE LXDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISJI. 2G1 as upon its influence in breaking the authority of the Church. A second way in which the rise of the industrial classes that followed the Crusades tended towards the same object was by uniting nations of different religions in commercial rela- tions. Before this time the intervention of the Pope had been the most effectual agent in regulating national differ- ences, and General Councils formed the highest, and indeed almost the solitary, expression of a European federation. The benign influence of Catholicism was continually exer- cised in correcting the egotism of a restricted patriotism ; and although this benefit was purchased by the creation of an intense animosity towards those who were without, and also by an excessive predominance of ecclesiastical influ- ence, it would be unfair to forget its inestimable value. After the Crusades, however, a new bond of cohesion was called into existence, and nations were grouped upon a new princi pie. The appointment of consuls in the Syrian towns, to sii- perintend tlie commercial interests of the Western nations, gave the first great impulse to international diplomacy ' — an influence which for many centuries occupied an extremely ^ I use tins expression because that obscure subject which Papebrochius and Mabillon have investigated, and which tliey have called Diplomacy, is much more what we should now term the History of Charters. The rise and influence of consulships has been traced in English by Warden, in French by Eorel, and in Latin by Steck. The subject has been also well noticed by Van Bruyssel, Hist, du Commerce Beige, torn. i. p. 140 ; and the iufluence of diplomacy as superseding General Councils, by Littre, Revolution, Conserva- tion ct Fositivisme, one of the ablest books the Positive School has ever pro- duced. The distinction between the old and new sense of diplomacy is ex- pressed respectively in the woi'ds ' la diplomatique ' and ' la diplomatic,' the last of which is less than a century old. (See De Plassan, Hist, de la Diplo- matie Fran^aise, Introd.) - I may add that one of the first systems of navi- gation law depended upon an institution called the ' Consulship of tJie Sea,' which consisted of a tribunal of leading merchants authorised to determine disputes. 262 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. important place in civilisation, but appears now to be steadi< ly waning before the doctrine of the rights of nationalities and before the increasing publicity of politics. The social and intellectual consequences of commercial intercourse were still greater. For while an intense sectarian spirit is com- patible with the most transcendent abilities and with the most profound learning, provided those abilities and that learning are directed in a single channel, it can very rarely survive close contact with members of different creeds. When men have once realised the truth that no single sect possesses a monopoly either of virtue or of abilities — when they have watched the supporters of the most various opinions dogmatising with the same profound conviction, defending their belief with the same energy, and irradiating it with the same spotless purity — when they have learnt in some-degree to assume the standing-point of different sects, to perceive the aspect from which what they had once deem- ed incongruous and absurd seems harmonious and coherent, and to observe how all the features of the intellectual laud- scape take their colour from the prejudice of education, and shift and vary according to the point of view from which they are regarded — when, above all, they have begun to re- vere and love for their moral qualities those from whom they are separated by their creed, their sense both of the certainty and the importance of their distinctive tenets will usually be impaired, and their intolerance towards others pro- portionately diminished. The spectacle of the contradictions around them, of the manifest attraction which different class- es of opinions possess to different minds, will make them sus- pect that their own opinions may possibly be false, and even that no one system of belief can be adajDted to the require- ments of all men : while, at the same time, their growing THE INDrSTEIAL IIISTOKY OF KATIONALISM, 263 sense of the moral excellence that may be associated with the mo?t sui^erstitious creed will withdraw their minds from dogmatic considerations. For human nature is so consti- tuted, that, although men may persuade themselves iiitellec- tually that error is a damnable crime, the voice of conscience protests so strongly against this doctrine, that it can only be silenced by the j)ersuasion that the personal character of tlie heretic is as repulsive as his creed. Calumny is the homage which dogmatism has ever paid to conscience. Even in the periods when the guilt of heresy was universally believed, the spirit of intolerance was only sustained by the diffusion of countless libels against the misbeliever, and by the sys- tematic concealment of his virtues. How sedulously theolo- gians at that time laboured in this task, how unscrupulously they maligned and blackened every leading opponent of their views, how eagerly they fanned the flame of sectarian animosity, how uniformly they j^rohibited those whom they could influence from studying the writings or frequenting the society of men of different opinions from their own, is well known to all who are acquainted with ecclesiastical his- tory. The first great blow to this policy was given by the rise of the commercial classes that followed the Crusades. Orthodox Catholics came into close and amicable connection both with Greeks and with Mohammedans, while their new pursuit made them, for the first time, look with favour upon the Jews. It was these last who in the middle ages were the special objects of persecution, and it was also towards them that the tolerant character of commerce was first manifested. The persecution of the Jewish race dates from the very earliest period in which Christianity obtained the direction of the civil power;' and, although it varied greatly in its ' As their latest historian says, ' Le Cliristianismc ne jjrit une veritable 264 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. character and its intensity, it can scarcely be said to have definitively ceased till the French Revolution. Alexander II., indeed, and three or four other Popes,' made noble efforts to arrest it, and more than once interposed with great cour- age, as well as great humanity, to censure the massacres; but the priests were usually unwearied in inciting the pas- sions of the people, and hatred of the Jew was for many cen- turies a faithful index of the jjiety of the Christians. Mas- sacred by thousands during the enthusiasm of the Crusades and of the War of the Shej)herds, the Jews found every ec- clesiastical revival, and the accession of every sovereign of more than usual devotion, occasions for fresh legislative re- strictions. Theodosius, St. Lewis, and Isabella the Catholic — Avho were probably the three most devout sovereigns before the Reformation — the Council of the Laterau, which led the religious revival of the thirteenth century, Paul lY,, who led that of the sixteenth century, and above all the religious orders, were among their most ardent persecutors. Every- thing was done to separate them from their fellow-men, to mark them out as the objects of undying hatred, and to stifle all compassion for their sufierings. They were compelled to wear a peculiar dress, and to live in a separate quarter. A Christian might not enter into any partnership with them ; consistance que sous la regno de Constantin ; et c'est k dater de cette cpoque que commence, k proprement parler, pour les Juifs I'ere des persecutions re- ligieuses.' {Bedamde,' Hkt. des Juifs, p. 16.) In this, however, as in other persecutions, the Arians were quite as bad as the orthodox. Constantius persecuted at least as much as Constantine, and the Spanish Visigoths more than either. ' On the liberality of several Popes to the Jews, see Bedarride, p. 260, on Alexander II., pp. 114-123. St. Bernard also laboured to assuage the persecution. Alexander VI. was especially generous to the Jews, and made great efforts to alleviate their sufferings — a fact that should be remembered in favour of a Pope for whom there is not much else to be said. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. ^ 2G5 he might not eat with them; he might not use the same bath; het might not employ them as physicians; he might not even purchase their drugs.* Intermarriage witli them was deemed a horrible pollution, and in the time of St. Lewis any Christian who had chosen a Jewess for his mistress was burnt alive. '^ Ev^n in their executions they were separated from other criminals, and, till the fourteenth centur}', they were hung between tAvo dogs, and Avith the head down- wards.^ According to St. Thomas Aquinas, all they possess- ed, being derived from the practice of usury, might be justly * For a long list of these prohibitions see a curious book, Be Judccis (Turin, 1Y17), by Joseph Scssa (one of the judges appointed in Piedmont to regulate the afifairs of the Jews), p. 10. As early as the reign of Constan- tine a Council of Elvira forbade Christians holding any communication with Jews. The Council of the Lateran compelled Jews to wear a separate dress ; and this very simple provision, by bringing them prominently before the people in an intensely fanatical age, contributed greatly to rouse the passions of the CathoHcs, and to facilitate the massacres that ensued (see Eios, I^txidcs sur hs Jtiifs d'' Espafjiie [trad. Majmabel], p. 109). St. Vincent Ferrier persuaded the Spanish Government to enforce this decree against both Jews and Moors. (Paramo, De Oric/. Inq. p. 164.) ^ CEuvres de St. Foix, tom. iv. pp. S8, 89. A similar enactment was made in Spain (Rios, pp. 88, 89). It was also a popular belief that the blood of Jews was black and putrid, and the bad smell for which they were unhappily notorious innate. There is a long discussion on this in Sessa. But perhaps the most curious instance of this order of superstitions is a statute of Queen Joanna I., in 1347, regulating the houses of ill-fame at Avignon, in which, after providing with great detail for the accommodation of the Christians, it is enacted that no Jew shall be admitted imder severe penalties (Sabatier, Ilisf. de la Legislation mr ics Famncs Fitlliqtie/i, p. 103). The authenticity of this statute has been questioned, but M. Sabatier seems to have succeeded in defending it, and he has shown that in 1408 a Jew was actually flogged at Avignon for the offence in question (pp. 105, 106). This extreme horror of Jews furnished Ulrich von Hutten with the subject of one of the happiest pieces of irony he ever wrote — the exquisite description of the mental agonies of 'a student of Frankfort, who, mistaking a Jew for a magistrate of the city, took off his hat to him, and on discovering-his error was unable to decide whether he had committed a mortal or only a venial sin. {Epixioi Olscuro- rum Virorum, ep. 2.) ^ Michelet, Origincs de Droit, p. 368 266 EATIONALISM IN EUPtOPE. confiscated,' and if they were ever permitted to pursue that practice immolested, it Avas only because they wei:e already BO hopelessly damned, that no crime could aggravate their condition.'' Insulted, plundered, hated, and despised by all Christian nations, banished from England by Edward I., and from France by Charles VI., they found in the Spanish Moors rulers who, in addition to that measuie of tolerance which is ■ ' The Duchess of Brabant, having some scruples of conscience about tolerating the Jews, submitted the case to St. Thomas. He replied, among other things, that the Jews -were doomed to perpetual servitude, and that all their property being derived from usury may be lawfully taken from them, to be restored to those who paid the usury, or, if this is impossible, to be ap- plied to some pious purpose. (See this curious letter, given at length in Van Bruyssel, Hist, du Commerce Beige, tom. i. pp. 239, 240.) On the general doctrine that property derived from usury may be confiscated by the civil power, see Paramo, Be Orig. Inquisit. p. 16*7. ^ There was a good deal of controversy in the middle ages about whether the Jews should be permitted to practise usury. The liberty seems to have been first openly granted in the commercial towns of Italy, but it gradually spread, and was admitted by some Popes. Sessa gives the reasons that were avowed by theologians : ' Usurae Judaicas tolerantur qtiidem ex permissione Prin- cipum et sumoiorum Pontificum in Hebra;is ut de gente deperditfi, et quorum salus est desperata, et ad eum finem ne Christiani foenoris exercitio strangu- lentur a Christianis ' (De Judceis, p. 9). The permission was granted in Pied- mont in 1603. St. Lewis refused to permit the Jews to exercise usury (Trop- long), and the Spanish rulers seem to have vacillated on the subject (Bedar- ride, pp. 192-194). There can be no doubt the monopoly of usury which the Jews possessed did more to enrich than all their persecutions to impov- erish them. For although, as Adam Smith observes, the current rate of interest should represent approximately the average of profits, this is only when it is free, and the exertions of divines and legislators in the middle ages had raised it far above the high rate it would then naturally have borne. It seems to have usually ranged between 25 and 40 per cent. In 1430 we find the Florentines, in order to reduce the current rate, admitting the Jews into their city, whence they had previously been excluded, on the condition of their lending money as low as 20 per cent. (Cibrario, vol. iii. p. 318). It is curious to observe how, while persecution prevented the Jews from ever amalgamating Tfiih other nations, the system of usury prevented them. IVom ever perishing or sinking into insignificance. THE IKDUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 267 ahvaj'S produced hj a higli intellectual culture, were prob- ably not without a special sympathy for a race whose pure monotheism formed a marked contrast to the scarcely dis- guised polytlieism of the Spanish Catholics; and Jewish learning and Jewish genius contributed very largely to that bright but transient civilisation which radiated from Toledo and Cordova, and exercised so salutary an influence upon the belief of Europe. But when, in an ill-omened hour, the Cross supplanted the Crescent on the heights of the Alhambra, this solitary refuge was destroyed, the last gleam of tolerance vanished from Spain, and the expulsion of the Jews was determined. This edict was immediately due to the exertions of Tor- quemada, who, if he did not suggest it, at least by a singular act of audacity overcame the irresolution of the Queen ; ' but its ultimate cause is to be found in that steadily increasing poi^ular fanaticism which made it impossible for the two races to exist together. In 1390, about a hundred years before the conquest of Granada, the Catholics of Seville, being excited by the eloquence of a great j)reacher, named Hernando Mar- tinez, had attacked the Jews' quarter, and murdered 4,000 Jews,^ Martinez himself jjresiding over the massacre. About a year later, and partly through the influence of the same eminent divine, similar scenes took place at Valentia, Cordo- va, Burgos, Toledo, and Barcelona.^ St. Vincent Ferrier, ' Tlie Jews oifered 30,000 ducats to remain. The Queeu, it is said, for a time hesitated, but Torquemada, confronting her on the threshold of the palace with a crucifix in his hand, exclaimed, ' Judas sold his God for thirty pieces of silver — you are about to sell him for thirty thousand ' (Bedarrlde and Prescott). The anecdote is related by Paramo, p. 144, only he does not specify the sum. ^ Rios, Etudes sur les Juifs d'Espaync, p. V/. Rios says that the con- temporary writers are unanimous about the number. * Ibid. pp. '79-82. Llorente, Hist de V Inquisition, torn. i. p. 1-11. 268 EATIONALISM IN ECKOrE. who was then stirring all Spain w^ith his preaching, devoted himself especially to the Jews ; and as the people zealously seconded the reasoning of the saint by massacring those who hesitated, many thousands were converted,' and if tliey relapsed into Judaism were imprisoned or burned. Scenes of this kind took place more than once during the fifteenth century, and they naturally intensified the traditional hatred, which was still further aggravated by the fact that most of the tax-gatherers were Jews. At last the Moorish war, which had always been regarded as a crusade, was drawing to a close, the religious fervour of the Spanish rose to the highest point, and the Inquisition was established as its ex- pression. N"umbers of converted Jews were massacred; others, w^ho had been baptised during past explosions of popular fury, fled to the Moors, in order to practise their rites, and at last, after a desperate resistance, were captured and burnt alive.^ The clergy exerted all their energies to ' Eios gives a delightful Spanish complexion to all this : ' L'apparition de Saint Vincent Ferrier devant le peuple Juif avait ete un fait veritablement prodigieux. 11 avait apparu a leurs yeux comme un ange sauveur, et cette circonstance ne pouvait qu'etre favorable k sa haute mission evangelique. Le 8 juin 1391, les rues de Valence se remplissaient du sang des Juifs, les bou- tiques etaient brulees, les maisons de la Juivcrie saccagees par une multitude cffrcnec, les malheureux Juifs couraicnt aux egliscs demandant le bapteme, et ils etaient repousses de toutcs parts et ne rencontraient que la mort, quand au milieu de la populace St. Vincent Ferrier se prcsentc et elevant sa voix inspiree, il met un terme h. cette horrible carnage. La multitude se tait. Les Juifs appeles par ce nouveau apCtre, qui se donna plus tard h lui-meme le nom d'ange de I'Apocalypse, ecoutent la parole divine et se couvertisseut. . . . Tout cela contribua puissamment au merveilleux resultats de sa pre- dication' (pp. 89, 90). St. Vincent was a Domiuicfn, a very great preacher, and so very good that he always undressed in the dark lest he should see himself naked. For his miracles, his virtues, and the multitudes he converted, see his life in Spanish by Vincent Justiniano (Vnlcntia, 15*75). Paramo sava that the Inquisitors discovered that no less than 17,000 of the converts 'f St. Vincent returned to Judaism {Be Oi-ig. Inq. p. IGT). "^ Twelve, however, who were captured at Malaga during the siege in 11 86 were impaled by Ferdinand. THE INDUSTKIAL niSTOKY OF EATIOXALISM. 2G9 produce the expulsion of the entire race, and to effect this object all the old calumnies Avere revived, and two or three miracles invented,' When we take into consideration all these circumstances, and the condition of public feeling they evince, we can per- haps hardly blame Isabella for issuing the decree of banish- ment against the Jews ; but at the same time it must be ac- knowledged, that history relates very few measures that pro- duced so vast an amount of calamity — calamities so frightful, that an old historian has scarcely exaggerated them when he describes the sufferings of the Sj)anish Jews as equal to those of their ancestors after the destruction of Jerusalem,' In three short months, all unconverted Jews were obliged, un- der pain of death, to abandon the Spanish soil.' Although they were permitted to dispose of their goods, they were for- bidden to carry either gold or silver from Spain, and this measure made them almost hel23less before the rapacity of their persecutors. Multitudes, falling into the hands of the pirates who swarmed around the coast, were plundered, of all they possessed, and reduced to slavery ; multitudes died of famine or of plague, or were murdered or tortured with hor- rible cruelty by the African savages, or were cast back by tempests on the Spanish coast. Weak women, driven from luxurious homes among the orange groves of Seville or Granada, children fresh from their mothers' arms, the aged, the sick, and the infirm, jierished by thousands. About ' They are detailed by Paramo. ^ Picus Mirandola. ^ It seems impossible to ascertain tlie number of the exiles with accuracy, for the Spanish historians vary greatly, from Cardoso who estimates it at 120,000, to Mariana who states it at 800,000. Paramo says some place it at more than 170,000, and others at more than 400,000 (p. 167). Justiniano says 420,000. Great numbers of the Jews avoided banishment by baptism. 270 EATIOJTALISM IN EUROPE. 80,000 took refuge in Portugal, relying on the promise of the king; but even there the hatred of the Spaniards pursued them. A mission was organised. Spanish priests lashed the Portuguese into fury, and the king was jjersuaded to issue an edict which threw even that of Isabella into the shade. All the adult Jews were banished from Portugal ; but first of all their children below the age of fourteen were taken from them to be educated as Christians. Then, indeed, the cup of bitterness was filled to the brim. The serene fortitude with Avhich the exiled people had borne so many and such grievous calamities gave Avay, and was replaced by the wildest parox- ysms of despair. Piercing shrieks of anguish filled the land. Women Avere known to fling their children into deep wells, or to tear them limb from limb, rather than resign them to the Christians. When at last, childless and broken-hearted, they sought to leave the land, they found that the ships had been purposely detained, and the allotted time having ex- pired, they were reduced to slavery, and baptised by force. By the merciful intervention of Rome most of thei^ at last regained their liberty, but their children were separated from them forever. A great peal of rejoicing filled the Peninsula, and proclaimed that the tiiumph of the Spanish priests was complete.' Certainly the heroism of the defenders of every other creed fades into insignificance before this martyr people, who for thirteen centuries confronted all the evils that the fiercest fanaticism could devise, enduring obloquy and spoliation and the violation of the dearest ties, and the infliction of the most hideous sufierings, rather than abandon their faith. For these were no ascetic monks, dead to all the hopes and pas- > Bedarride, pp. 291-301 ; Paramo, 235. Paramo says the Portuguese decree of banishment was simply changed for one of compulsory baptism. THE INDUSTRIAL niSTOKY OF KATIOXALISM. 271 sions of life, but were men wlio appreciated intensely the worldly advantages they relinquished, and whose affections had become all the more lively on account of the narrow circle in which they were confined. Enthusiasm and the strange phenomena of ecstasy, which have exercised so large an influence in the history of persecution, which have nerved so many martyrs with sui^erhuraan courage, and have dead- ened or destroyed the anguish of so many fearful tortures, were here almost unknown. Persecution came to the Jewish nation in its most horrible forms, yet surrounded by every circumstance of petty annoyance that could destroy its grandeur, and it continued for centuries their abiding por- tion. But above all this the genius of that wonderful people rose supresiie. While tliose around them were grovelling in the darkne-ss of besotted ignorance ; while juggling miracles and lying relics were the themes on which almost all Europe v/as expatiating ; while the intellect of Christendom, en- thralled by countless superstitions, had sunk into a deadly torpor, in which all love of enquiry and all search for truth were abandoned, the Jews wei-e still pursuing the path of knowledge, amassing learning, and stimulating progress Avitli the same unflinching constancy that they manifested in their faith. They were the most skilful physicians, the ablest financiers, and among the most profound philosophers ; while they were only second to the Moors in the cultivation of natural science. They were also the chief interpreters to Western Europe of Arabian learning.' But their most ini- ' The very extensive Jewish literature of the middle ages is fully reviewed by Bedarride and Rios. Maimonides is of course the greatest name. M. Renan, in his essay on Averroes, has shown that nearly all the first translations into Latin of the works of Averroes were by Jews (chiefly by those of Mont- pellier, who were especially famous for their learning), and that Averrois.n took deep root in Jewish teaching. Maimonides wrote a letter on the vanit.y 272 EATIONALISM LIST EUEOPE. portant service, and that with which we are now most es- pecially concerned, was in sustaining commercial activity. For centuries they were almost its only representatives. By travelling from land to land till they had become intimately acquainted hoth with the wants and the productions of each, by practising money-lending on a large scale and with con- summate skill, by keeping up a constant and secret corre- spondence and organising a system of exchange that was then unparalleled in Europe,' the Jews succeeded in making themselves absolutely indispensable to the Christian com- munity, and in accumulating immense wealth and acquiring immense influence in the midst of their sufferings. When the Italian republics rose to power, they soon became the centres to which the Jews flocked ; and under the merchant governments of Leghorn, Venice, Pisa, and Genoa, a degree of toleration was accorded that Avas indeed far from perfect, but Avas at least immeasurably greater than elsewhere. The Jews were protected from injury, and permitted to practise of astrology, which two popes applauded (Bedarridc, p. 151). lie was also distiuguished for his liberal views about inspiration (Lee, On Inspiration, pp. 454-459). The controversial literature of the Jews directed against Chris- tianity was extremely voluminous. A catalogue of these works, and a de- scription of many of them, is given in a little book, called Bibliothcca Judaica Antichristiana, by John Bernard de Rossi (Parmje, 1800). ' A very old and general tradition ascribes the invention of the letter of exchange to Jews who, havmg been banished from France, had taken refuge in Lombardy. Nor does there seem to be anything of much weight to op- pose to it, though some have contended that the Italians were the real invent- ors. At all events, the Jews appear to have been among the first to employ it. The earliest notice of letters of exchange is said to be in a statute oi Avignon of 1243. In 1272 there was a Venetian law 'De Litteris Cambii.' Compare on this subject Villeneuve-Bargemont, Hist. d'Economie Politique, tom. i. pp. 2'7'7-279; Blanqui, Jlist. d'Econ.Pol., tom. i. p. 183; Montes- quieu, Esprit dcs Lois, liv. xxi. c. 20 ; and the tractate of Jules Thieurry, La Lettre de Change (Paris, 1862). THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 273 medicine and money-lending unmolested, and public opinion, as well as the law, looked upon them with tolerance.' The tolerant spirit the commercial classes manifested to- wards the Jews before the Reformation was displayed with equal clearness towards both Catholics and Protestants in the convulsions that followed it. In addition to the reasons I have already given, there were two causes actively sustaining the predisposition. In the first place, tlie industrial character is eminently practical. The habit of mind that distinguishes it leads men to care very little about principles, and very much about results ; and this habit has at least a tendency to act upon theological judgments. In the second place, religious w^ars and persecutions have always proved extremely detrimental to industry. The expulsions of the Jews and Moors from Spain, and of the Huguenots from France, were j^erhaps the most severe blows ever directed against the industry of either country ; while the nations which on these or similar occasions w^ere wise enough to receive the fugitives, reaped an immediate and an enormous advantage. The commercial genius of the Jewish exiles was one of the elements in the development of Leg- horn, Pisa, stnd Ancona. Amsterdam owes a very large part of its prosperity to tbe concourse of heretics who had been driven from Bruges and from the surrounding country. The linen maiaufacture in Ireland, as well as many branches of English industry, were greatly stimulated by the skill and caj)ital of the French refugees. French commerce received a powerful and long-sustained impulse from the good relatio}is ' Bedarride, pp. 258, 259. The magnificent synagogue at Leghorn (prob- ably the finest in existence) was erected by the Spanish Jews who took refuge In that city VOL. II. — 41 274 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. Francis I. liacl establislied with the Turks. It was not there- fore surprising that Amsterdam, and in a less degree the other centres of commercial enterprise, should have been from an early period conspicuous for their tolerance, or that the diffusion of the industrial spirit should have everywhere prepared the way for the establishment of religious liberty. Another consequence of the rise of the industrial spirit was the decay of the theological ideal of voluntary poverty which had created the monastic system. Immediately after the Crusades we find nearly all Europe rushing with extreme and long-sustained violence into habits of luxury. The return of peace, the contact with the luxurious civihsations of the East, the sudden increase of wealth that followed the first impetus of commerce, had all contributed to the move- ment. An extraordinary richness of dress was one of its first signs, and was encountered by a long succession of sump- tuary laws. At the end of the thirteenth century we find Philip the Fair regulating with the most severe minuteness the number and quality of the dresses of the different classes of his subjects.* About the middle of the fourteenth century a parliament of Edward III. passed no less than eight laws against French fashions." Even in Florence, among the * See tbis ordinance (wbich was issued in 1294) in Blanqui, Hist, d' Ecorvo- mie Politique^ torn. i. pp. 225, 226. It provided, among other things, that dukes, counts, and barons, who have 6,000 livres rent, may have four robes a year, and their wives as many. Knights with 3,000 Uvres rent may have three. No member of the middle class may wear any ornament of gold or precious stones, or any dress that was green or gray. As M. Blanqui observes, articles of luxury would have been imported necessarily from foreign countries into France, which would necessitate an export of French gold — according to the current notions the greatest evil that could beflill the country. - Anderson, Hist, of Commerce, vol. i. p. 193. See, too, p. 179. More than a century after the passion for dress reached Scotland, when the alarmed and indignant legislators enacted (in MS*?) that the wives and daughters of merchants should 'be abuilzied ['dressed,' from 'habiller'] gangand and cor> THE INDtJSTKIAL HIS'TORY OF KATIONALISM. 275 officers of the reiDublic, in the beginnhig of the fourteenth century, was one especially appointed ' to repress the luxury of women.' ' Bruges, which had then risen to great wealth, became very famous in this respect ; and the French king and queen having visited it early in the fourteenth century, it is related that the latter was unable to restrain her tears ; for, as she complained, she ' found herself in presence of 600 ladies more queenly than herself '' The fearful depopulation that was produced by the black death greatly strengthened the tendency. The wages, and consequently the prosperity, of the working classes rose to an unexampled height, which the legislators vainly tried to repress by fixing the maximum of wages by law ; ' while the immense fortunes resulting from the innumerable inheritances, and also that frenzy of enjoyment which is the natural reaction after a great catastrophe, impelled the uj)per classes to unprece- dented excesses of luxury. This new passion was but part of a great change in the social habits of Europe, which was everywhere destroying the old rude simplicity, rendering the interiors of houses more richly and elaborately furnished, creating indoor life, increasing the difference between dif- ferent ranks, producing a violent thirst for wealth, and making its display one of the principal signs of dignity. There are few things more difficult to judge than those great outbursts of luxury that meet us from time to time in history, and Avhich, whenever they have appeared, have respondent for their estate, that is to say, on their heads short curches [a kind of cap] with little hudes as are used in Flanders, England, and other coun- tries, . . . and that na -women weare tailes unfit in length, nor furred under but on the hailie dale.' {Ibid. vol. iii. pp. 280, 281.) * Blanqui, torn. i. p. 250. ^ Anderson, vol. i. p. 144. ^ Wade, Ilislory of the Middle and Worldng Classes. 276 KATIOJfALISM IN ETJEOPE. proved the precursors of intellectual or political change. A sober appreciation of their effects will probably be equally removed from those Spartan, Stoical, or monastic declamations which found their last great representative in Rousseau, and from the iniqualified eulogy of luxury in which Yoltaire and some of his contemporaries indulged. Political economy, by establishing clearly the distinction between productive and un- pi'oductive expenditure, and by its doctrine of the accumula- tion of capital, has dis2:)elled forever the old illusion that the rich man who lavishes his income in feasts or pageants is contributing involuntarily to the Avealth of the community ; and history unrolls a long catalogue of nations that have been emasculated or corrupted by increasing riches. But, on the other hand, if luxury be regarded as including all those comforts which are not necessary to the support of life, its introduction is the very sign and measure of civilisation ; and even if we regard it in its more common but less definite sense, its increase has frequently marked the transition from a lower to a higher stage. It represents the substitution of new, intellectual, domestic, and pacific tastes for the rude warlike habits of semi-barbarism. It is the parent of art, the pledge of peace, the creator of those refined tastes and delicate susceptibilities that have done so much to soften the friction of life. Besides this, what in one sense is a luxury, soon becomes in another sense a necessary. Society, in a highly civilised condition, is broken np into numerous sec- tions, and each rank, except the very lowest, maintains its position chiefly by the display of a certain amount of luxury. To rise to a higher level in the social scale, or at least to avoid the discomfort and degradation of falling below his original rank, becomes the ambition of every man; and these motives, by producing abstinence from marriage, form one of THE INDUSTEIAL HISTOEY OF EATIONALISM. 277 the principal checks ujjon population. However exaggerated may have been the apprehensions of Malthus, the controversy which he raised has at least abundantly joroved that, when the multiplication of the species is checked by no stronger motive than the natural disinclination of some men to mar- riage, when the habitual condition of a large proportion of the inhabitants of a country that is already thickly inhabited is so low that they marry fearlessly, under the belief that their children can fare no worse than themselves, when poor- laws have provided a refuge for the destitute, and when no strong religious motive elevates celibacy into a virtue, the most fearful calamities must ensue/ Looking at things upon a large scale, there seem to be two, and but two adequate, checks to the excessive multiplication of tlie species : the first consists of physical and moral evils, such as wars, famines, pestilence, and vice, and those early deaths which are so fre- quent among the poor; the second is abstinence from mar- riage. In the middle ages, the monastic system, by dooming many thousands to perpetual celibacy, produced this absti- nence, and consequently contributed greatly to avert the impending evil.* It is true that the remedy by itself was very inadequate. It is also true that, considered in its economical aspect, it was one of the worst that could be con- ceived; for it greatly diminished the productive energies of society, by consigning immense numbers to idleness, and by diffusing a respect for idleness tln-ough the whole community. But still the monastic system was in some measure a remedy ; ' Besides the great work of Malthus, there is an admirable exposition of this doctrine in Senior's Political Economy. Perhaps the most enthusiastic champion of luxury is Filangieri. ^ This has been noticed in a very forcible, but, of course, one-sided manner, by De Maistre, who recurs to the subject again and agam in his works ; also by Villeneuve-Bargemont, Economic Politique Chrelienne. 278 RATIONALISM 1^ EUROPE. and, as it appears to me, the increased elaboration of social life, rendering the passion for wealth more absorbing, was one of the necessary j)reliminaries of its safe abolition. That elaboration was effected after the Crusades, and the change it has produced is very remarkable. The repressive influence upon population that was once exercised by a religious system resting on the glorification of voluntary poverty, and designed to mortify the natural tendencies of mankind, is now exercised by that increased love of wealth which grows out of the multiplication of secular aims, or, in other words, out of the normal development of society. But, putting aside the incidental effects of luxury iipon population, there can be no doubt that its effects in stimulat- ing the energies of mankind, by investing material advan- tages with a new attraction, have sometimes been very great and very beneficial. For the love of wealth and the love of knowledge are the two main agents of human progress; and, although the former is a far less noble passion than the latter, although, in addition to the innumerable crimes it has produced, it exercises, when carried to excess, a more than common influence in contracting and indurating the charac- ter, it may well be doubted whether it is not, on the whole, the more beneficial of the two. It has produced all trade, all industry, and all the material luxuries of civilisation, and has at the same time j^roved the most powerful incentive to intellectual pursuits. Whoever will soberly examine the history of inventions, of art, or of the learned professions, may soon convince himself of this. At all events, the two pursuits will usually rise together. The great majority of mankind always desire material prosperity, and a small mi- nority always desire knowledge ; but in nations that are un- developed, or are declining, these desires are unable to over- THE INDirSTEIAL niSTOEY OF RATIONALISM. 279 come the listlessness that is general. There is then no buoy- ancy in the national character. All lively curiosity, all the fire and energy of enterprise, are unknown. Men may love ■wealth, and even sacrifice moral principles to attain it, but tliey are unable to emancipate themselves from the em- pire of routine, and their languid minds recoil with the same antipathy from novelty, whether it comes to them in the form of industrial enterprise, or of intellectual innovation. This is even now very much the condition of Spain and of some other nations, and during the greater part of the middle ages it was the general condition of Christendom. In such a state of society, the creation of a spirit of enterj>rise is the very first condition of mental as of material progress ; and when it is called into existence in one department, it will soon be communicated to all. The ardent passion for luxury that followed the Crusades — the new tastes, new ideas, and new fields of enterprise that were suddenly made popular — produced it in Euroise ; and the impulse that began in indus- try was soon felt in knowledge. In the Roman empire, which rested on slavery, luxury produced idleness. In the fourteenth century it stimulated industry, and aroused a strong feeling of opposition to that monastic system, which, by its enormous development, was a serious imjDediment to progress. This opposition, which was at first created by the increas- ed energy of laymen, was intensified by the deterioration of the monks. At one time, as I have already observed, they liad been the great directors of labour. But when their numbers and their wealth had immensely increased, their first enthusiasm passed away, and multitudes thronged the monasteries simj^ly to escape the bm-dens of life. Besides this, the priesthood had become intimately allied Avith the 280 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. nobles, who are always opposed to the industrial classes. The alliance Vv^as in part the result of special circumstances, for the Crusades were directed conjointly by priests and nobles ; and it was during the Crusades that the aristocracy obtained its distinct and complete organisation. It was also in part the consequence of a certain harmony which exists between the theological and the aristocratic spirit. Both, raising the past far above the present, regard innovation with extreme dislike, and both measure excellence by a dif- ferent rule from personal merit. If I have been fortunate enough to carry the reader with me through the foregoing arguments, the importance of in- dustry in influencing theological developement Avill have be- come apparent. We have seen that a great religious change is effected not by direct arguments, but by a predisposition to receive them, or, in other words, by a change of sympa- thies and bias. Y\^e have also seen that the industrial spirit which became prominent early in the fourteenth century pro- duced such a change. It did so in three ways. It arose in a society in which the laity Avere crouching in abject submis- sion to the priesthood, and it developed and raised to honour the practice of money-lending, which the priesthood had in- variably anathematised. It arose in a society in which the duty of religious intolerance was regarded as an axiom, and it produced a tendency towards toleration by uniting men of different creeds in amicable intercourse, by elevating to hon- our on account of their commercial merits the people who were most persecuted on account of their creed, by making men concentrate their attention mainly on practice rather than on theory, and by calling into existence an order of in- terests which persecution seriously endangered. It, in the last place, made men look with aversion upon the monastic THE USTDUSTEIAL HISTOEY OF EATIONALISM. 281 ideal which was the very centre of the i/revailiiig theology. In all these ways it proved the precursor of the Reformation, ani in all these ways it harmonised with the spirit of Ration- alism. Commercial enterprise, bearing in its ti'ain these intellec- tual consequences, spread rapidly over Europe. The acci- dental discovery at Amalfi of a manuscript of Roman laws is said to have produced the navigation laws ; ^ the invention of the compass rendered long voyages comparatively secure; and every shore, from the Baltic to the Mediterranean, was soon fringed with harbours. In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries we find the first mercantile companies established in England.^ At a still earlier period Belgium had entered into relations with more than thirty kingdoms or states.' The consular system, which emanated from the commercial republics, and which was designed for the special protection of merchants, advanced rapidly in importance.* As early as the thirteenth century the consuls of Italy, Spain, and France had in most countries acquired an extended and recognised authority. England, in the fourteenth century, followed the example,^ and about the same time the jurisdiction which had formerly been confined to seaports was extended to the toAvns in the interior. From these consulships, or perhaps from the papal legations which were already known, arose at last the institution of resident ambassadors, which completed ' Pecchio, Sioria della Economia Puhhlica in Italia (Lugano, 1849), p. 11. - Andersou, Hist, of Comraerce, vol. i. p. 11 '7. The first English commer- cial companies were ' the Merchants of the Staple ' and ' the Merchants of St. Thomas £l Becket.' ^ Yan Bruyssel, Hist, du Commerce Be'c/e, torn. i. p. 234. * See the stages of its development in Warden, On Consular Establish- ments. ^ The earliest notice Macpherson has been able to find of an English con- sul is in 1346 {Aimals of Commerce, vol. i. p. 536). 2S2 KATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. the organisation of dij^lomacy, though its influence was not fully acquired till much later, in tlie coalitions resulting from the rivalry of Francis and Charles V/ The Hanseatic League repressed piracy, associated commerce -with the first efflorescence of political liberty, and by the treaty of Stral- snnd, in 13 70, made commercial interests preeminent in the North; while in the South the Venetians, anticipating in some measure the doctrines of later economists, sketched the first faint outlines of the laws that govern them.° At last the Medici appeared, and surrounded industry with the aure- oles of genius and of art. For the first time the intellectual capital of Italy was displaced, and Rome itself paled before that new Athens which had arisen upon the banks of the Arno. An aristocracy, formed exclusively from the trading and mercantile classes,' furnished the most munificent and discerning patrons art had ever found ; almost every great ' Before this time ambassadoi'S were sent culy on occasions of emergency. The first instance of a resident ambassador seems to have been in 1455, when Francis Sforza, Duke of Milan, established one at Genoa, and towards the close of the century the institution became somewhat common in Italy (Cibra- rio, Economia Politka del Medio Evo [Torino, 1842], vol. i. p. 319). It was also about this time that the use of cipher in diplomacy became usual. {Ibid De Plassan, Hist, de la Diplomatie Erangaise, Introd.) " M. Blanqui has collected some extremely remarkable evidence of this {Historic d''Economie Politique, tom. i. pp. 244-2'i'O). The Lombards also occasionally manifested extremely enlightened views on these subjects (see Eossi, Economic Politique, tom. 1. p. 260), and Milan, perhaps longer than any other great town in Europe, was exempt from the medieval system of corporations. However, the first Italian winter of considerable merit on Political Economy was probably Serra, who was a Neapolitan, and it was at Naples that the first Professorship of Political Economy in Europe was established in 1754 by the munificence of the Florentine Intieri. ' As early as 1282, a magistracy had been constituted at Florence exclu- sively of merchants ; and the example was soon followed by Sienna, and in a great measure by Venice and Genoa. (See Blanqui, tom. i. p. 245 ; Rossi, tom. i. p. 266.) THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 283 intellectual movement was coloured by its influence, and its glory was reflected upon the class from -vvliicli it sprang. It may here be advisable to rise for a moment above the industrial movement with which we have hitherto been oc- cupied, and to endeavour to obtain a general concejition of the difierent streams of thought which were at this time shooting across Europe, Such a review, which will be in part a summary of conclusions I have established in previous chapters, will help to show how admirably the industrial movement liarmonised with the other tendencies of the age, and also how completely the Reformation was the normal consequence of the new condition of society. While, then, the development of industry was producing an innovating, tolerant, and anti-monastic spirit, two great revivals of learning were vivifying the intellectual energies of Christendom. The first consisted of that resuscitation of the classical writings which began about the twelfth century and culmi- nated in the labours of Erasmus and the Scaligers. This re- vival broke the intellectual unity which had characterised the middle ages. It introduced a new standard of judgment, a new ideal of perfection, a new order of sympathies. Men began to expatiate in an atmosphere of thought where relig- ious fanaticism had never entered, and where the threaten- ings of the dogmatist were iinknown. Tlie spell that had bound their intellects was broken, and the old type of char- acter gradually destroyed. The influence of the movement passed from speculative philosoj)hy to art, which was then the chief organ of religious sentiments, and, under the pat- ronage of the Medici, a profound change took place in both painting and architecture, which intensified the tendency that produced it. 28-i EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. The second revival was protlucecl by the action of Moorish civilisation. It was shown chiefly in an increased passion for natural science, Avhich gradually substituted the concep- tion of harmonious and unchanging law for the conception of a universe governed by perpetual miracles. "With this passion for science, astrology rose into extraordinary repute, and it necessarily involved a system of fatalism, which, in its turn, led the way to a philosophy of history. From the same quarter arose many of those pantheistic speculations about the all-j^ervasive soul of the universe, to which the writers of the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries were so passionately addicted.' In all these ways, Moorish influence contributed to shake the old faith, to produce new predispositions, and thus to prepare the way for the coming change. Roger Bacon, who was probably the greatest natu- ral j)hilosopher of the middle ages, was profoundly versed in Arabian learning, and derived from it many of the germs of his philosophy." The fatalism of the astrologers and the pantheism of Averroes tinged some of the most eminent Christian writings long after the dawn of the Reformation. In one I'espect, Mahometan influence had somewhat antici- pated the classical revival. The IMahometan i^hilosophers were intense admirers of Aristotle ; and it was chiefly through translations made by the Jews from the Arabic versions, that the knowledge of that philoso];)her penetrated to Europe. There was another influence, growing partly out of the industrial development, and partly out of the revival of clas- sical learning, at this time acting upon Europe, which I have * Many of these views were almost identical with those of Mesmer and his followers. (See Bertrand, Hist, du Magnetisme Animal en France, pp IS-IY.) - Sharon Turner's llisi. of En(jland, vol. \v. pp. 39, 40. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIOi^ALISM. 285 not yet bad occasion to mention, which many readers will deem far too trivial for notice, but which, nevertheless, aj)- pears to me so extremely important, both as a symptom and a cause, that I shall venture, at the risk of being accused of unpardonable digression, to trace some of the leading stages of its i^rogress. I mean that change in the character of pub- lic amusements, produced chiefly by the habits of luxury, wdiich took place about the fifteenth century, and which produced the revival of the theatre. No one can question the immense importance in the in- tellectual history of mankind of an institution which elicited the dramas of Euripides, Sophocles, ^schylus, Calderon, Lope de Vega, Corneille, Moliere, Racine, Voltaire, Goethe, Schiller, Shakspeare, and Ben Jonson, and which has invari- ably appeared as one of the most conspicuous signs and causes of a lising civilisation. Combining the three great influences of eloquence, of poetry, and of jiainting, it has probably done more than any other single agent to produce that craving after the ideal, that passionate enthusiasm of intellect, out of which all great works of imagination have sprung. It has been the seed-plot of poetry and romance, and it has exercised a considei'able though less direct in- fluence over eloquence. The age of Demosthenes and JEs- chines was also the age in which the theatre of Athens was the object of such a passionate devotion, that no politician was permitted even to propose the abolition of its subsidy.' The golden age of Roman eloquence was also the golden age of the Roman theatre, and the connection between acting and eloquence was one of the favourite subjects of the discus- sions of the time.' In modern days, Burke declared, in an • See the Ohjnthiacs. ' Roseins even wrote a book on this subject, but it has unfortunately not 286 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. assembly in no degree inferior to any of Greece or of Rome, that there was probably no orator among those be addressed, who did not owe something of his skill to the acting of Gar- rick,' And this amusement, which has ever proved one of the chief delights, and one of the most powerful incentives of genius, had, at the same time, the rare privilege of acting with equal power upon the opposite extreme of intellect, and is even now almost the only link connecting thousands with intellectual pursuits. But the aspect in which the history of the theatre is most remarkable, is perhaps to be found in its influence upon na- tional tastes. Every one who considers the world as it really exists, and, not as it aj)pears in the writings of ascetics or sentimentalists, must have convinced himself that in great towns, where multitudes of men of all classes and charac- ters are massed together, and where there are innumerable strangers separated from all domestic ties and occupations, public amusements of an exciting order are absolutely neces- sary ; and that, while they are often the vehicle and the occa- sion of evil, to suppress them, as was done by the Puritans of the Commonwealth, is simply to plunge an immense por- tion of the population into the lowest depths of vice. Na- tional tastes, however, vary with the different stages of civ- ilisation, and national amusements undergo a corresponding modification ; combats of men and animals being, for the most part, the favourite type in the earlier stages, and dra- matic representations in the later ones. The history of come down to us. He kept a school of declamation, which was attended by the ablest orators of his time. The passion for the theatre is said to have come to Rome from Egypt, and Batyllus, the greatest actor of the Augustan period, was from Alexandria. See on this subject a curious dissertation, ' De Lusu Romanorum,' in Graevius, Thesaurus Antiq. Rom., torn. viii. ' Murphy's Life of Garricl: THE ESTDTTSTEIAL HISTOKY OF EATIONALISM. 287 amusements is thus important, as a reflection of the history of civilisation, and it becomes still more so when we remem- ber that institutions which are called into existence Ly a cer- tain intellectual tendency, usually react upon and intensify their cause. In this, as in most other respects, we find a strong con- trast existing between the two leading nations of antiquity. The Athenians, who for a long period repelled gladiatorial spectacles with disgust, were passionately devoted to the drama, which they carried to the very highest point of per- fection, and from which they deiived no small amount of their intellectual culture. The Romans, on the other hand, who regarded every subject from a military point of view had long prohibited theatrical representations, except those which formed part of the worship of the gods. The first public theatre was ei'ected by Pompey, and he only evaded the censure of the severe moralists of his time by maki-ng it a single story of a building that was ostensibly a temple of Venus. The Stoics, and the representatives of the old re- publican spirit, denounced the new amusement as calculated to enervate the national character. Public opinion branded actors as infamous, and, as a necessary consequence, they speedily became so. The civilisation of the Empire made the theatre at last extremely popular ; but that civilisation was the most corrupt the world had ever seen, and the drama partook of the full measure of its corruption. A few rays of genius from the pens of Seneca, Plautus, or Terence flashed across the gloom ; but Pome never produced any dramatists compai'able to those of Greece, or any audience at all resembling that which made the theatre ring with in- dignation because Euripides had inserted an apology for mental reservation into his ' Hippolytus,' or had placed a too 1500 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. ardent panegyric of wealth in the mouth of Bellerophon. After a time the position of an actor became so degraded, that it was made a form of perpetual servitude/ and no one who had embraced that profession was permitted at any future time to abandon it. The undisguised sensuality reach- ed a point which we can scarcely conceive. Women were sometimes brought naked upon the stage.'' Occasionally an attempt was made to amalgamate theatrical amusements with those bloody spectacles to Avhich the people wei^e so passionately devoted, and the tragedy was closed by the burning of a criminal, who Avas compelled to personate Her- cules.' At the same time, by a cui-ious association of ideas, the theatre was still intimately connected witli religious ob- servances ; the temple was often the scene of its orgies, and the achievements of the gods the subject of representation. It is certainly not surprising that the early writers of Chrigtianity should have directed all their eloquence against ' Nero, however, made energetic efforts to relieve the actors from the stigma attached to them (as he did also to alleviate the sufferings of the slaves), and Gibbon has noticed the great honour in which he held the Jewish actor Aliturus, and the repeated and successful efforts of that actor to obtain a relaxation of the persecutions of the Jews. Under Nero, too, lived and died (when only fourteen) a lovely and gifted actress named Eucharis — the first who appeared on the Greek stage, which Nero had instituted — who seems to have won more affection and left a deeper impression than almost any other who died so young. Her charms are recorded in perhaps the most touching of all the epitaphs that have descended to us from antiquity, and her Deautiful features formed one of the last ideals of expiring art. (Visconti, Iconograpliie Ancienne, 287.) ■■^ See the evidence of this collected by Sabaticr, Hist, de la Legislation mr les Femmcs Puhliqucs, pp. 45-47 ; Maguin, Origincs du TMutre, torn. i. pp. 284-287 ; and Lcbrun, Discours sur le Theatre, pp. 79-82. This last author tries as much as possible to attenuate the facts he admits, in order that the invectives of the Fathers might fall with their full force on the modern theatre. The Floral games were in this respect the worst. ^ Tertullian, Ad Nationcs, lib. i. c. 10. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 28 9 such an institution as this. They inveighed against it as the school of profligacy", and a centre of idolatry; and they dwelt, in language which it is impossible to read without emotion, upon the duty of those who might be called, at any moment, to endure for their faith the most horrible forms of torture and of death, abstaining from whatever could ener- vate their courage or damp their zeal. Mingled with these noble exhortations we find no small amount of that monastic spirit wliich regards pleasure as essentially evil, and also two or thi-ee arguments which perhaps represent the extreme limits of human puerility. Tertullian, having enumerated with great force and eloquence many of the most horrible vices of the theatre, adds that at least the Almighty can never pardon an actor who, in defiance of the evangelical as- sertion, endeavours, by high-heeled boots, to add a cubit to his stature, and who habitually falsifies his face.' The position of public amusements in the early histoi-y of Christianity is extremely important. On the one hand, the austerity with which the Christians condemned them was probably one of the chief causes of the hatred and conse- quent persecution of which the early Church was the victim, and which contrasts so remarkably Avith the usually tolerant character of polytheism. On the other hand, when Chris- tianity had attained its triumph, when the intellectual and moral basis of paganism was completely sapped, and when the victorious Church had begun to exhibit something of the spirit from which it had sufiered, the theatre and the circus b<;came the last strongholds of the dying faith. Partly be- cause they had actually emanated from the j^agan worship, and partly because the Christian Councils and Fathers de- nounced them with an absolute and unqualified severity, * De Speciaculis, cap. xxiii. VOL. II. — i5 290 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. they were soon regarded as the chief expression of j^agan- ism ; and the people, who endured with scarcely a mnrmui the destruction of their temples and the suppression of their sacrifices, flew to arms whenever their amusements were menaced. The servitude, indeed, hy which the actor was enchained for life to the theatre, was soon abrogated in the case of those who desired to become Christians ; ' and the bishops refused to baptise any actor who persisted in his j)rofession, and excommunicated any Christian who adopted it ; ^ but the theatres were still thronged with eager specta- tors. Indeed, one curious enactment of the Theodosian Code provides that some of the temples should be saved from the general destruction, because they were associated with pub- lic games.^ When the bishops were manifestly unable to suj)press the public games, they directed all their energies to restricting them to days that were not sacred. St. Am- brose succeeded in obtaining the abolition of Sunday repre- sentations at Milan, and a similar rule was at last raised to a general law of the empire.* • It is remarkable, however, when considering the relations of Christianity and Paganism to the theatre, tliat Julian, who ^ Cod. Theod., lib. xv. tit. 7, 1. 8. If the emancipated actress turned out badly, she was to be dragged back to the stage and kept there till she was ' a ridiculous old woman ' (ridicula anus). ^ Neander, Churcli History, vol. ii. p. SYO. An old Council forbade Chris- tian women marrying actors. The actors, however, at a later period claimed one saint as their patron. This was St. Genetus, who was an actor in the reign of Diocletian. According to the legend, he was acting the part of a Christian in a piece which was designed to turn the new religion to ridicule, when, between the acts, he saw a vision, which converted-him, and he accord- ingly proclaimed his allegiance to Christ upon the stage. The emperor and the audience at first loudly applauded, imagining that this was part of the play; but when they discovered the truth, the actor was put to death. » Cod. Theod., xvi. 10. 3. * Lebrun, pp. 117, 118 ; Cod. Tlieod., xv. 5. 5 THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 291 was by far the most distinguished champion of the latter, formed in this respect a complete exception to his co-religion- ists. His character was formed after the antique model, and his antipathy to public amusements was almost worthy of a bishop. Libanius, it is true, has left a long disquisition in praise of pantomimic dances, which, he maintained, were of a far higher artistic merit than sculpture, as no sculptor could rival the grace and beauty of the dancers ; but on this subject he received no encouragement from his master. It has been ingeniously, and, I think, justly remarked, that this austerity of Julian, by placing him in direct opposition to that portion of the population which was opposed to Chris- tianity, was one of the causes of the failure of his attempts to rally the broken forces of paganism. After a time the Roman theatre languished and passed away. The decline was partly the result of the ceaseless opposition of the clergy, who during the middle ages were too powerful for any institution to resist their anathema, but still more, I think, of the invasion of the barbarians, which dissolved the old civilisation, and therefore destroyed the old tastes. The theatre soon lost its attraction ; it lingered, indeed, faintly for many centuries, but its importance had passed away, and about the end of the thirteenth century most antiquaries seem to think the last public theatres were destroyed. The amusements of men were of an entirely dif- ferent, and, for the most part, of a warlike character. Battle and the imitations of battle, boisterous revels, the chase, and, after the Crusades, the gaming-table, became the delight of the upper classes ; while the poor found congenial recreation m bear-baiting, bull-fighting, and countless similar amuse> ments — in fjiirs, dances, perambulant musicians, sham fights, 292 EATIONALISM m EUROPE. and rude games.^ Besides these, there were numerous mountebanks, who were accustomed to exhibit feats of min- gled agility and buffoonery, which were probably the origin of the modern pantomime, and in which, as it has been shown by a high authoritj^,^ there is reason to believe a dress very similar to that of our harlequins was employed. It is prob- ably to these mountebanks, or possibly to the troubadours or wandering minstrels, who had then become common, that St. Thomas Aquinas referred in a passage w^hich excited a fierce controversy in the seventeenth century. In discussing the subject of amusement, the saint suggested the question whether the profession of an 'actor' was essentially sinful; and, having enumerated some special circumstances that might make it so, he answers the question in the negative,' ^ Sti'utt's Sj)orts and Pastimes of the Enr/lish People. Muratori, Antiq. Ital. Dissert., 29. In Italy the pham fights were carried on on a vast scale and with wooden swords, and were the cause of many deaths. Amusements somewhat similar to those which were once popular in Italy are said to con- tinue in Russia. Storch, PJcon. PoUi., torn. iii. p. 403. ^ Riccoboni, Hist, du Theatre Italien depuis Van 1500 jusqu'd Van 16G0, torn. i. pp. 4-6. The author of this remarkable book (who was known pro- fessionally under the name of Lelio) was one of the greatest Italian actors of his time. He travelled much from theatre to theatre, and in the different cities lie visited i-ansacked the public libraries for works bearing upon his history. His book was originally written in French, and is dedicated to Queen Caroline of England. ^ He says distinctly, 'OfEcium histrionum, quod ordinatur ad solatium hominibus exhibendum, non est secundum se illicitum.' It appears certain that when this was written there were no public theatres or dramatic repre- sentations, except the religious ones. At the same time, it is impossible to draw a clear line between the public recitation of verses or the exhibitions of mountebanks on the one hand, and the simplest forms of the drama upon the other. Bossuet has cited a passage from St. Thomas's work De Senten- tiis, in which he speaks of the exhibitions that had ' formerly taken place in the theatres.' At all events, the saint was not very favourable to these ' his- triones,' for he speaks of gains that have been acquired ' de turpi causa, sicut de meretricio et histrionaiu.'' See on this subject Concina, De SpcC' iaculis, -pp. Z6-il ; Lebrun, Discours sur le Theatre, p^y. 189-194; Bossuet, Rtjlcxions sur la Comklie, g§ 22-25. THE INDUSTRIAL IIISTOET OF KATIONALISIL 293 'because,' as he says, 'recreation is necessary to mankind,' and also because ' it had been revealed to the blessed Paph- nutius that a clown ^ was to be his companion in heaven.' Such, then, was the character of public amusements before the revival of learning. The time, however, was at hand when a profound change, fraught with momentous conse- quences to the Church, was manifested ; and it is worthy of notice, that while that change was ultimately caused by the advance of civilisation, the Church itself was its pioneer. The first revival of the theatre is undoubtedly to be found in the religious plays. From the earliest times men seem to have been accustomed to throw into dramatic forms the ob- jects of their belief; and the j)agan mysteries, which were essentially dramatic,^ retained their authority over the popu- lar mind long after every other portion of the ancient wor- ship was despised. The first biblical play on record is on Moses, and is the composition of a Jew named Ezekiel, who lived in the second century. The second is a Greek tragedy on the Passion, by St. Gregory Nazianzen. Tlie religious ceremonies, and especially those for Christmas, Epiphany, and Holy Week, became continually more dramatic, and the monks and nuns after a time began to relieve the monotony of the cloister by private representations. The earliest known instance of this is of the tenth century, when a German ab- ' ' Joculator,' Bossuet, however, says that the Ads of St. Paphnutius show that this was simply a perambulant flute-player. After all, Bossuet is obliged to make the following admission : ' Apres avoir purge la doctrine de Saint Thomas des exces dont on la chargeoit, il faut avouer avec le respect qui est du k un si grand homme, qu'il semble s'ctre un peu eloigne, je ne dirai pas des scntimens dans le fond, mais plutut des expressions des anciens Peres sur le sujet des divertissemens.' {Reflexions sur la Comedie, § 31.) ' Mackay's Rclic/ious Development of the Greeks and Hchreivs, vol. ii. pp. 286-297. Besides the drama, it is probable that the gladiatorial spectacles (which are of Etruscan origin) were originally religious. They seem at firs< to have been celebrated at the graves, and in honour of the dead. ■294 EATIONALISM EN' EURfiPE. bess aiamed Hvoswitha composed two or three dramas, with a religious object, but imitated, it is said, in part from Ter- ence, which were acted by the nuns. The subject of one of them is curious. A hermit had brought up in the ways of piety a beautiful girl, but she rebelled against his authority, neglected his counsels, and fled to a house of ill fame. The hermit, having discovered the place of her resort, assumed the dress and the manners of a soldier, penetrated to her re- treat, supported his character so skilfully that he deceived its inmates, and at last found an ojiportunity of reclaiming his Avard/ In the extreme weariness of the conventual life, amuse- ments of this kind were welcomed with delight, and, though often and severely censured, they continued in some monas- teries till far into the eighteenth century." The form, how- ever, which they generally assumed was not that of secular di-amas with a religious tendency, but of mysteries or direct representations of scenes from Scripture or from the lives of the saints. "Until the latter part of the thirteenth century they were exclusively Latin, and were usually acted by priests in the churches ; but after this time they assumed a popular form, their religious character speedily declined, and they became at last one of the most powerful agents in bringing the Church, and indeed all religion, into disrepute.' The evidence of this is not to be found in the representations * See Villemain, Moyen Age ; Martonne, Piete du Moyen Age ; Leroy, Ftudes tur les Clyster es, p. 41. "^ Concina, who published his work, De Spectaailis, in lYSS, at the re< quest of Benedict XIY., mentions that the custom still continued in some monasteries ; and he devoted a dissertation to proving that monks who laid aside their ecclesiastical dress to personate laymen were guilty of mortal sin. ' See the collections of these by Hone, Jubinal, Jacob, &c. ; and the works of Leroy, Suard, and Collier upon their history. THE LN'DUSTEIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 295 of the Almighty that Avere so frequent upon the stage ; ^ for these, though inexpressibly shocking ia our eyes, were per- fectly in harmony with the intellectual condition of the time ; hut rather in the gross indecency whicli the worst days of the lloman theatre had scarcely surpassed,^ and perhaps still more in the strange position that was assigned to Satan. At first the mysteries had probably contributed much to the re- ligious terrorism. The glare and smoke of the fire of hell wei'e constantly exhibited, and j)iercing shrieks of agony broke upon the ear. Very soon, however, Satan was made to act the part of a clown. His appearance was greeted with shouts of laughter. He became at once the most prom- inent and most poj)ular character of the piece, and was eman- cipated by virtue of his character from all restraints of deco- rum. One of the most impressive doctrines of the Church was thus indissolubly associated in the popular mind with the ridiculous, and a spirit of mockery and of satire began to play around the whole teaching of authority. It is difficult, indeed, to say how far these rude dramatic representations contributed to that disruption of old religious ties that preceded and prepared the Reformation. At a ^ On which see Malone, Hist, of the English Stage, pp. 12, 13, Some curious examples of it have been collected by Hone ; and also in Strutt's History of the Manners of the People of England, vol. iii. pp. 137-140. - Some striking instances of this indecency, which indeed is sufficiently manifest in most of the mysteries, are given by Jacob in his Introduction to his collection of Farces. Wherever the seventh commandment was to be broken, the actors disappeared behind a curtain which was hung across a part of the stage ; and this is the origin of the Frsnch proverbial expression about things that are done ' derriere le rideau.' More than once the Govern- ment suppressed the sacred plays in France on account of their evil effects upon morals. In England matters seem to have been if possible worse ; and Warton has shown that on at least one occasion in the fifteenth century, Adam and Eve were brought upon the stage strictly in their state of innocence. In the next scene the fig-leaves were introduced. (Malone's History of the Eng- lish Stage, pp. 15, 16.) 296 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. very early period those strange festivals, the Feast of Fools and the Feast of Asses,' had introduced into the churches in- decent dances, caricatures of the priesthood, and even a paro- dy of the Mass; and the mysteries of the fourteenth and fif- teenth centuries carried the same spirit far and wide. But •what I desire especially to notice is, that their popularity was mainly due to that material prosperity wdiich was it- self a consequence of the industrial develoj)ment we are considering. This growing passion for an order of amuse- ments in some degree intellectual, this keen relish for specta- cles that addressed themselves especially to the imagination, was the beginning of that inevitable transition from the rude, simple, warlike, unartistic, nnimaginative tastes of barbarism, to the luxurious, refined, and meditative tastes of civilisation. Coarse and corrupt as they were, these early plays reflected the condition of a society that was struggling feebly into a new phaseof civilisation, and vfhich at the same time, though still deriving its conceptions from the Church, was tending surely and rapidly towards secularisation. The change was first efiected in Italy and France. In those countries, which were then the centres of material prosperity, the dramatic tastes had naturally been most developed, and the mysteries had attained an extraordinary popularity. A modern Italian bibliographer has been able even now to collect more than one hundred difierent pieces of this kind, which were represented in Italy in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries.'' About the middle of the fifteenth ' The Feast of Fools and the Feast of Asses are said to have originated (though probably under other names) in the Greek Church about 990. (Ma- lonc's Hist, of English Stage, p. 9.) La Mere Sotte, in France, originated, or at least became popular, during the quarrel between the King of France and the Pope, at the beginning of the tenth century. (Monteil, Hist, des Fran- 7ais des Diverses Etats, torn. iii. p. 342, ed. 1853.) ^ Biblionrajia delle Aniiche Bapprcsentazioni Italiane Sacrf. e Profam THE EvDUSTKIAL HISTOET OF EATIOXALISM. 297 century the exhibitious of the mountebanks began to be thrown into a systematic form. A complete story t\ as ex- hibited, and the harlequin rose to great prominence as chief actor,' We find, too, a few representations of Pagan fables, and also some plays that were termed impromptus, in which the outline of a plot was sketched by the author, but the dialogue left to the ingenuity of the actor. Besides these, dialogues, or discussions of the nature of farces,^ became com- mon ; and having passed from Italy to France, they there assumed the dimensions of regular dramas, sometimes of very considerable merit. One of them, the famous farce of 'Patelin,' which was probably composed about 14G8 by Peter Blanchet, an advocate of Poitiers, still holds its posi- tion upon the French stage.' The directors of the religious plays attempted to meet these new rivals by tlie invention of semi-religious ' moralities,' which were properly repre- sentations of allegorical figures of virtues and vices,* and were stampate nei Secoli XV. e XVI. ^ dal Colomh de Bathics (Firenze, 1852). One of these mysteries, the S. Giovanni e Paolo, was writen by Lorenzo de' Medici himself (Roscoe, Lorenzo de' Medici, eh. v.). ^ Riccoboni, torn. i. p. 89. One of the most famous of the early harie- quins was Cecchino, who is also celebrated for having published at Venice, in 1621, perhaps the first defence of the theatre. He was ennobled by the Emperor of Germany. ^ These farces, in the earliest and simplest forms, were called ' contrasti ' in ItaUan, or ' debats ' iu French. De Batines has made a list of several which were translated from Italian into French ; e. g. the discussions between wine and water, between life and death, between man and woman, &c. Italian actors sometimes migrated to France, and in ISYY we find a regular Italian company, called I Gelosi, there. ^ As a comic opera, and also, I believe, as a play. The popularity of the farce of Faidin produced Le Nouveau Patelin and Le Testament d(, Patelin, both of which have been reprinted by Jacob. Hallam says {Hist, of Lit., vol. i. p. 216) that the farce of Patelin was first printed in 1490. There ia extreme uncertainty resting upon the early chronology of the drama ; scarcely any two authorities agree upon the subject. * The term ' morality,' however, was very loosely used. Jacob has r& 298 KATIO:s"ALISM IN EUROPE. intended to act the j^artof a compromise ; but the farces isoon became the dominating form, and all other performances sank into secondary importance.' Latin plays were also some- times acted by the scholars in the colleges, a practice which was afterwards made very popular by the Jesuits. This was the first stage of the movement. The second was the creation of secular plays of a higher order of merit, wliich completely superseded and destroyed the mysteries." Like the former, this advance emanated chiefly from the com- mercial civilisation of Florence, but it is extremely remark- able that the leaders of the Church in Italy were among its most ardent supporters. Tlie first regular Italian comedj^ appears to have been the ' Calandra,' and its author was the Cardinal Bibbiena, who had long been secretary to Lorenzo priuted an old play, called La Moralit'a de VAvcu-jle d du Boiteux, which is nothing more than a farce. From the religious plays the personifications passed to the ballets, in which they still sometimes appear. An old French poem describes in rapturous terms the performance of a certain Madarae do Brancas, in the character of Geometry, in a ballet on the seven liberal arts, danced before Louis XIV. in 1663. ' Farces appear also to have been the chief form of dramatic literature in Spain in the fifteenth century. See Bouterwek's Hist, of Spanish Lilemiure. They were followed by eclogues. '^ Some remains, however, of the mysteries continue to the present day, especially in the villages of the Tyrol. There is still, too, a great ' passion jjlay,' as it is termed, celebrated every tenth year at the little village of Oberam- mergau, in Bavaria, near the frontiers of the Tyrol, which, though it is not more than 300 years old, and though it is almost entirely devoid of grotesque scenes, may l^e on the whole looked upon as a representative of the meditcval plays. It consists of scenes from the Passion (beginning at the triumphal entry into Jerusalem, and ending with the appearance to the Magdalene after the Kesurrection), between which pictures from the Old Testament (partly wax-work and partly tableaux vivants), typical of the Passion, are displayed. A chorus, like those of the Greek plays, sings hymns concerning the connec- tion between the type and the antitype. When J saw it in 1860, the pl.ij lasted for TJ hours, and commanded the attention of an immense audiencp t.: the close. THE INDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF EATIONx^LISM. 299 do' Medici/ The play Avas probably written in the last few years of the fifteenth century, when the author was still young, but it at all events did not impede his advancement in the Church. The two first Italian tragedies were the ' Sophonisba ' of Trissino, which was imitated from Eurij)ides, and the ' Rosimunda ' of Ruccellai, which was imitated from Seneca. The ' Sophonisba ' was acted for the first time at Vicenza, about 1514, and was soon afterwards represented at Rome under the special patronage of Leo X., who appointed its author ambassador at the court of the Emperor Maximil- ian. The ' Rosimunda ' was first acted, in the presence of the same Pope, at Florence, in 1515.* The earliest instance of a secular musical drama is the ' Orplieus ' of Politiano, which was composed for the amusement and acted in the presence of the Cardinal Gonzaga of Mantua.* A few years later we find Clement VII. present with the Emperor Charles v., at Bologna, at the rei^resentation of the comedy of 'The Three Tyrants,' by Ricci." As a natural consequence of this patronage, the Italian theatre at its commencement does not appear to have been very hostile to the Church, and in this respect forms a marked contrast to the theatre of France. The 'Eugenie' of Jodelle, which was the first regular comedy * Kiccoboni, torn. i. pp. 32, 33. The Calandra is now nearly forgotten, but its author will always be remembered as the subject of two of the noblest of the portraits of Raphael, — one at Florence, and the other at Madrid. ^ Compare Riccoboni, torn. ii. pp. 9, 10 ; and Sismondi, Hist, cle la Lit- teratnre du Midi, tom. ii. pp. 188-199. The two pieces seenk to have been acted nearly at the same time ; but the SophonMa was not printed for some years afterwards. Ruccellai also wrote a play called Orestes, which, how- ever, was not brought at this time on the stage. ' Roscoe's Lorenzo de" Medici, ch. v. ; Hogarth's Memoirs of the Opera, pp. 6-8. Of course, as Hallam has observed, recitative not being yet in- vented, the music was confined to choruses and songs scattered throughout the piece. * Riccoboni, tom. i. p. 183. 300 EATIONAI.ISM IM EUUOPE, acted on the French stage, was throughout what many of the older farces had been, a bitter satire upon the clergy.^ One of the most important consequences of this revival of the theatre was the partial secularisation of music. This ai't, to which the old Greeks had ascribed so great a power over both mind and body, and which some of their states had even made an essential element of the civil polity,'^ had for many centuries been entirely in the hands of the Chvirch. Almost all the music that really deserved the name was ec- clesiastical, and all the great names in musical history had been ecclesiastics. St. Ignatius having, according to tlie legend, heard the angels singing psalms in alternate strains before the throne of God, introduced the practice of an- tiphons. St, Ambrose regulated the church music for the diocese of Milan, and St. Gregory the Great for the re- mainder of Christendom. St. Wilfrid and St. Dunstan were the apostles of music in England. In the eleventh century, the monk Guido of Arezzo invented the present system of musical notation. Nearly at the same time, the practice of singing in parts, and combining several distinct notes in a single strain,^ which is the basis of modern harmonies, * See Charles, La Comklie en France au Seizihne Steele (1862). Eicco- boni, however, asserts that Moliere took the character, and even some of the incidents and speeches, of his Tariuffe from an old Italian play called Doctor Bachctone (torn. i. p. 13Y). " Among the Arcadians, for example, music was compulsory, and the one district in which this custom fell into desuetude was said to have sunk far below the surrounding civilisation. There is a singularly curious chapter on the effects ascribed to music among the Greeks, in Bumey's History of Music, vol. i. pp. 173-194. The legends of Orpheus charming hell, Arion appeasing the waves, and Amphion moving the stones by music, as well as ' the music of the spheres ' of Pythagoras, will occur to evei-y one. ^ Called originally ' discantus.' The exact date of its invention is a mat- ter of great controTcr?y. It is said to have been suggested by the variec tones of the organ. THE INDUSTEIAL IIISTOKY OF EA.TIONALISM, 301 first appeared in the services of the Church. From a very early period music had been employed to enhance the effect of the sacred plays, and as it continued to occupy the same position when the drama had heen secularised, St. Philip Neri, in 1540, in order to counteract the new attraction, originated at Rome the oratorio. About twenty years later, Palcstrina, a chaplain of the Vatican, reformed the whole system of Church music. These exertions would perhaps have retained for it somethmg at least of its ancient ascend- ency, but for the invention in 1600 of recitative, which, by rendering possible complete musical dramas, immediately created the opera, withdrew the scejttre of music from the Church, and profoundly altered the prevailing taste. From this time the star of St. Cecilia began to wane, and that of Apollo to shine anew. Those 'Lydian and Ionic strains' which Plato so jealously excluded from his rej^ublic, and which Milton so keenly appreciated, were heard again, and all Italy thrilled with passion benea^i their power. Venice especially found in them the most faithful expression of her character, and no less than three hundred and fifty different operas were represented there between 1637 and 1680. In France the opera was introduced at the desire of Cardinal Mazarin ; and it is remarkable that Perrin, who wrote the first French operas, was a priest; that Cambert, who assisted him in composing the music, was a churCh organist ; and that nearly all the first actors had been choristers in the ca- thedials. From this time the best singers began to desert •the churches for the theatre. In England the musical dramas known under the name of masques elicited some of the jioblest poetry of Ben Jon son and of Milton.' * See Burney's Hht. of Music ; Castil-Blaze, ChapeUe Musique des Bois dt France ; Hogarth's Bl&t. of the Opera ; Monteil, Hist, des Fran^ais {XVII. 302 EATIOI^ALISM IN EUROl'E. ADOtlier way in wLicli the Cluirch exercised, I think, an indirect influence upon the stage, is not quite so obvious as the preceding one. Whatever opinion may be held on the general question of the comparative merits of the classical and the Gothic architecture, it is at least certain that the latter was immeasurably superior in suggesting the effects of immense distances — in acting, not simj)ly on the taste, but also on the emotions, by a skilful employment of all the means of illusion which an admirable sense of the laws of perspective can furnish. The Greek temple might satisfy the taste, but it never struck any chord of deeper emotion, or created any illusion, or suggested any conception of the Infinite. The eye and the mind soon grasped its proportions, and realised the full measure of its grandeur. Very different is the sentiinent produced by the Gothic cathedral, with its almost endless vistas of receding arches, with its high altar rising conspicuous by a hundred lights amid the gloom of the j)ainted windows, while farther and farther back the eye loses itself in the undefined distance amid the tracery of the gorgeous chancel, or the dim columns of Our Lady's chapel. The visible there leads the imagination to the invisible. The sense of finiteness is vanquished. An illusion of vastness and awe presses irresistibly on the mind. And this illusion, which the architecture and the obscurity of the temple produce, has always been skilfully sustained in Catholicism by ceremonies which are preeminently calculated to act upon the emotions through the eye. Now it is surely a remarkable coincidence, that while Christian architecture is thus indisputably superior to pagan architecture in creating the illusion of distance, the modern Slccle) ; the notice of Palestrina iu Hallam's Hist, of Literahire ; and the Essays on Musical Notation, by Titet and Coussemaker. THE rnDL'STELAL IIISTOKY OF KATIONALISM. 303 theatre should Tbe distinguished by precisely the same supe- riority from the ancient one. A fundamental rule of the modern theatre is, that the stage should he at least twice as deep as it is broad. In the theatres of antiquity, tlie stage M^as five or six times as broad as it was deep.^ It resembled tlie jjortion which is now exhibited wlien the curtain is down. The wall that closed it in, instead of being concealed, was brought 2:)rominently before the sjjectator by rich sculptures, and illusion was neither sought nor obtained. In the modern theatre, our present system of decoration only advanced by slow degrees from the rude representations of heaven and hell, that were exhibited in the mysteries, to the elaborate scenery of our own day; but still the constant j)rogress in this direction exhibits a conception of the nature of the spec- tacle, wdiich is essentially different from that of the Greeks, and is probably in a great measure due to the influence of ecclesiastical ceremonies upon the taste. It is not difficult to perceive the cause of the favour which Leo and his contemporaries manifested to the theatre. They belonged to a generation of ecclesiastics who were far removed from the austere traditions of the Church, who had thrown themselves cordially into all the new tastes that lux- ury and revived learning had jDroduced, and who shrank with an undisguised aversion from all religious enthusiasm, from all intolerance of the beautiful. Their lives were one long dream of art and poetry. Their imaginations, matured and disciplined by constant study of the noblest works of Grecian genius, cast a new colouring upon their profession, and * The stage of Orange, which is probably the most perfect Eoman theatre in existence, is 66 yards broad and 12 deep. (See Vitet's Essay on the Anti- quities of Orange, in his Eludes siir VHistoire cCArt.) The length of the stage of Herculaneum is greater than that of San Carle at Naples, but its depth is only a few feet. 304 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. adorned, with a pagan beauty every creation of the Cliurch. Such men as these were but little likely to repress the intel- lectual passion that arose almost simultaneously iu Italy, France, and Spain,' and created the modern theatre. ''Isut when the teaching of Luther had thrilled through Europe, a new spirit was infused into the Vatican. The intellectualist and the art critic were replaced by men of saintly lives but of persecuting zeal, and a fierce contest between the Church and the theatre began, which continued till near the close of the eighteenth century, and ended in the complete victory of the latter. The doctrine of tlie Church on this subject was clear and decisive. The theatre was unequivocally condemned, and all professional actors were pronounced to be in a condition of mortal sin, and were, therefore, doomed, if they died in their profession, to eternal perdition.* This frightful propo- sition was enunciated with the most emphatic clearness by countless bishops and theologians, and was even embodied in the canon law and the rituals of many dioceses.^ The Ritual of Paris, witli several others, distinctly pronounced ' The Spanish theatre very early rose to perfection, and, after IGOO, Spanish tragi-comedies soon became dominant, even in Italy. (See Eiccoboni's history of the movement ; and Bouterwek's Hist, of Spanish Literature.) In this review I have not entered into an examination of the English theatre, for two reasons : first, because its growth was almost entirely isolated, while the dramatic literatures of Italy, Spain, and France were closely con- nected ; and, secondly, because my present object is to trace the relations of Catliolicism and the drama. ^ The following was the decision of the doctors of the Sorbonne in 1694 : ' Les comediens, par leur profession comme elle s'exercise, sont en etat de peche mortel.' — Did. dcs Cas de Conscience, de Lamet et Fromageau, torn. i. p. 803. ^ See an immense mass of evidence of this collected in Desprez de Boissy, Lettres sur Ics Spectacles (1*780) ; Lebrun, Biscours stir la Comklie Ooncina, De Spectaculis. THE ES^DUSTKIAL HISTOEY OF RATIONALISM. 305 that actors were by their very employment necessarily ex- communicated.' This "was the sentence of the Church upon those whose lives were spent in adding to the sum of human enjoyments, in scattering the clouds of despondency, and charming away the weariness of the jaded mind. None can tell how many hearts it has wrung with anguisli, or hoA\- many noble natures it has plunged into the depths of vice. As a necessary consequence of this teaching, the sacraments were denied to actors Avho refused to repudiate their profes- sion, and, in France at least, their burial was as the burial of a dog.^ Among those who were thus refused a place in con- secrated ground was the beautiful and gifted Le Couvreur, who had been perhaps the brightest ornament of the French stage. She died without having abjured the profession she had adorned, and she was buried in a field for cattle upon the banks of the Seine. An ode by Yoltaire, burning with the deep fire of an indignant j)athos, has at once avenged and consecrated her memory. ^ ' Arcendi [a sacra communione] sunt publice indigni, quales sunt excom- municati, interdicti, manifeste infames ut meretrices, concubinarii, comcedi.' (Quoted by Concina, Be Spcctaculis, p. 42. See also Lebrun, Discours, p. 34.) Some theologians, in order to reconcile their sentiments with the pas- sage from St. Thomas that I have quoted, said that it was actors of immoral pieces that were excommunicated, but they added that the condition of the theatre was such that all actors fell under the censure. Moliere was regarded as peculiarly and preeminently bad. Eacine was far from innocuous ; and Bossuet distinctly maintained that any piece was immoral which contained a representation of love, however legitimate its character. (See his Reflexions sur la Comidie.) 2 'L'Eglise condamne les comediens, et croit par-U defendre assez la comedia ; la decision en est precise dans les Rituels {Hit de Paris, pp. 108- 1 14), la pratique en est constante. On prive des sacremens et a la vie et h, »a mort ceux qui jouent la comedie s'ils ne renoneent k leur art ; on les passe h, la sainte table comme des pecheurs publics ; on les exclut des ordres sacres comme des personnes inf&mes ; par une suite infaillible, la sepulture ecclesi- astique leur est deniee.' — Bossuet, E(flezions sur la Comedie, § xi. VOL. II. — 46 30(1 NATIONALISM IN EUROPE. It is hard for tliose who are acquainted with the habits of modern Roman Catholic countries to realise the intense bitterness which theologians of the seventeenth and eigh- teenth centuries manifested towards the theatre. Moliere, whose plays were continually cited as among the most signal instances of its depravity, was the object of especial denun- ciation, and when he died it was only with extreme difficulty that permission could be obtained to bury hitn in consecrated ground/ The religious mind of Racine recoiled before the censure. He ceased to write for the stage when in the zenith of his 'powers^ and an extraordinary epitaph, while recording his virtues, acknowledges that there was one stain upon his memory — he had been a dramatic poet.^ In 1696, and again in 1701, on the occasion of the jubilee, the actors entreated the pope to relieve them from the censures of the canon law, but their request was unavailing; and when, upon the recov- ery of Louis XIV. from a serious illness, every other corpora- tion at Paris offered up a Te Deum, they were especially ex- cluded.^ At least one archbishop distinctly prohibited his clergy from marrying them ; * and when a lawyer, named * Lebrun relates this with much exultation. Speaking of Moliere hs says : ' Ce qui est constant, c'est que sa mort est une morale terrible pour tons ses confreres, et pour tous ceux qui ne cherchent qu'i rire — un peu de terre obtenu par priere, c'est tout ce qu'il a de I'Eglise, et encore fallut-il bien protester qu'il avoit donne des marques de repentir. Eosimond ctant mort subitement en 1691, fut enterre sans clerge, sans lumiere, et sans aucune priere, dans un endroit du cimetiere de St. Sulpice ou Ton met les enfans morts sans bapteme.' {Diseotirs sur la Comedie, ed. I'Zol, p. 259.) ■ This marvellous production is given in full by Desprez de Boissy, torn . pp. 510-512. Its author was named Tronchon. = Ibid. p. 124. * The Archbishop of Paris. This refusal was of course comprised in the general rule, that actors as excommunicated persons should be excluded from the sacraments (Desprez de Boissy, torn. i. p. 447). And yet these priests had the audacity to reproach actors with their immorality ! The THE IXDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 307 Hvierne de la Mothe, A-eutured, in 1761, to denounce this act as a scandal, and to defend the profession of an actor, his work was burned by the hand of the executioner, and his name erased from the list of advocates/ Lulii, the first great musical composer of France, could only obtain absolution by burning an opera he had just composed." Yet in spite of all this the theatre steadily advanced, aud as the opposition was absolute and unequivocal its progress was a measure of the defeat of the Church. In France, al- though the law pronounced actors infamous, and consequent- ly excluded them from every form of public honour and em- ployment, and although till far into the eighteenth century custom prohibited those who occupied any magisterial ap- pointment from attending the theatre, the drama retained an undiminished popularity. In Spain it appears to have se- cured a certain measure of toleration by throwing itself into the arms of the Church. Calderon infused into it the very spirit of the Inquisition. The sacred plays continued after they had been abolished in almost every other country ; and although Mariana and some other leading theologians de- noiniced all dramatic entertainmeijts, they were unable to procure their final suppression.' The opera, it is true, was Council of Illiberis, one of the oldest on record, prohibited any Christian woman from marrying an actor. (Lebrun, Discours, p. 157.) ^ See the curious Arret du Parlement, in Desprez de Boissy, torn. i. pp. 473-481. ^ Hogarth, Memoirs of the Opera, p, 28. ' Philip II., however, and Philip IV. banished all actors from Spain (Boissy, Lettrcs sur Ics Spectacles, torn. i. pp. 483, 484) ; and the venerable and miracle-working Father Posadas, at a later period, caused the destruc- tion of the theatre of Cordova (Concina, JDe Sped. p. 178). On the extent to which actors laboured to wm the favour of the Church by religious plays and by singing at the Church festivals, see the indignant remarks of Mariana. i>ei2f^e, pp. 406-419. 308 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. somewhat severely treated, for some divines having ascribed to it a period of pestilence and of drought, it was for a time abolished; * but it at last secured its position in Spain. The Italians at all times thronged the theatre with delight. Even the Romans exhibited such a marked passion for this form of amusement, that the popes Avere obliged to yield. At first dramatic entertainments were only permitted at Rome during the carnival, and Benedict XIV., while according this per- mission, addressed a pastoral to the bishops of his kingdom to assure them that he did it with extreme reluctance to avoid greater evils, and that this permission was not to be construed as an approval." Gradually, however, these amusements were extended to other seasons of the year; and even the opera, in obedience to the wishes of the people, was introduced. At last, in 1671, a public opera-house was built at Rome; but female performers were long strictly prohibit- ed, and their places supplied by eunuchs— an unfortunate race, which came in consequence into great request in the Holy City.' The man who did moi-e than any other to remove the ^ Buckle, Hist., vol. i. p. 347, note. In the same way, Lebrun ascribes the earthquakes that desolated ancient Antioch to the passion of the inhab- itants for the theatre {Biscows, pp. 132, 133). The English bishops, in 1563, attributed the plague to the theatres (Fronde's Hist., vol. vii. p. 519). '^ See an energetic extract which Concina has prefixed to his book. Some of the cardinals, however, were less severe, and in the first half of the seven- teenth century the musical parties of the Cardinal Barberini were very fa- mous. It was probably there, and certainly at Eome, that Milton met Leonora Baroni, who was one of the first of the long line of great Italian opera- singers, and to whom he, with a very unpuritanical gallantry, addressed three Latin poems (Hogarth, Ifemoirs of the Opera, pp. 17, 18). These carnival dramas excited the great indignation of the Calvinist Dalteus (Concina, pp. 302, 303). The Itahans do not seem to have been so violent against the theatre, as the French priests, though De Boissy has collected a rathei long ist of condemnations. ^ Desprez de Boissy, torn. ii. pp. 234-236. THE INDUSTKIAL HISTOKY OF EATIONALISM. 309 Stigma that rested upon actors, was unquestiouably Voltaire. There is, indeed, something singularly noble in the untiring zeal with which he directed poetry and eloquence, the keen- est wit and the closest reasoning, to the defence of those wlio had so long been friendless and despised. He cast over them the aegis of his own mighty name, and the result of his advocacy was sliown in the enactment by which the French Revolutionists, at a single stroke, removed all the disquali- fications under which they laboured. The position actors have since conquered in almost every country, and the extent to which the theatre has become a recognised institution, must be manifest to every one. Among the many illustra- tions of the impotence of modern ecclesiastical efforts to arrest the natural current of society, there are few more curious than is furnished on the opening night of the Roman theatre, when the cardinal-governor of Rome appears, as the representative of the pope, to sanction the entertainment by his presence, to listen to the sweet songs of the opera sving by female singers, and to watch the wreathings of the dance. I trust the reader will pardon the great length to which this disquisition on the drama has extended. It is not alto- gether of the nature of a digression, because, although an institution like the theatre cannot be regarded as entirely the creation of any one nation, it certainly owes its first impulse and some of its leading cliaracteristics to that union of an industrial and intellectual civilisation which attained its culmination under the Medici. Xor is it without an impor- tant bearing on the subject of my work, because the succes- sive transformatioiis I have reviewed furnish one of the most striking examples of that process of gradual secularisation which, under the influence of the rationalistic spirit, is dis- played, in turn in each department of thought and action. 310 EATIONALISjI in EUROPE. Besides this, there are fe^y more powerfully clestnictive agents thau customs or institutions, no matter how little aggressive, which a Church claiming supreme authority en- deavours to suppress, and which have nevertheless secured their position in the world. By the simple fact of their existence, they at first divide the allegiance of mankind, and at last render obsolete a certain portion of ecclesiastical teaching, and thereby im])art a character of mobility and flexibility to the Avhole. In this respect Protestantism has been far less affected by the change than her rival, for Prot- estantism docs not claim the same coercive authority, and can, therefore, in a measure assimilate with the developments of society, and piirify and temper when it cannot altogether control. It must be acknowledged also, that while the Calviuistic section of the Reformed Churches has ever dis- played a bigotry on the subject of amusements, which is at least equal to that of the Church of Rome,* Anglicanism has always been singularly free from the taint of fanaticism;* nor is it, I believe, too much to add, that her forbearance has received its reward, and that, if we except the period of depravity that elapsed between the Restoration and the publication of the work of Jeremy Collier in 1698, and which ' On the decrees of the French Protestants agamst the theatre, see Lebrun, p. 255. Calvin at Geneva was equally severe, and his policy long after found an enthusiastic defender in Rousseau. In England, one of the most atrocious acts of tyranny of which Charles I. was guilty, was elicited oy a book called the Histriomastiz, of Prynne, and one of the first effects of ;he triumph of the Puritans was the suppression of the theatre. ^ I have mentioned the way in which Moliere, Lulli, and Le Couvreur were treated in France. As a single illustration of the different spirits of Catholicism and Anglicanism, I may mention the fate of their English paral- cls — Shakespeare, Lawes, and Mrs. Oldfield. No murmur of controversy ever disturbed the grave of Shakespeare, and the great poet of Puritanism sang his requiem. Lawes and Mrs. Oldfield both rest in Westminster Abbey, to which the latter was borne with almost regal pomp. THE INDUSTKIAL IIISTOEY OF EATIOXALISM. 311 may be justly ascribed in a great measure to the reaction against Puritanism, the English theatre has been that in which the moralist can find least to condemn. The creation of the secular theatre was one of the last results of the industrial supremacy of Italy. A succession of causes, into which it is not now necessary to enter, had cor- roded that 2)olitical system, to which the world is so deej)lT indebted ; and the discoyery of the passage round the Cape of Good Hoj)e by Gama, and of America by Columbus, to- g^her with some other causes, directed the stream of com- merce in new channels. By the time when the effects of these discoveries began first to be felt, the Reformation had divided Christendom into two opj)Osing sections, and the important question arose, to which of these sections the sceptre of industry would fall. It must, I think, be acknowledged, that to a spectator of the sixteenth century no proposition could seem more clear than that the commercial supremacy of Europe was destined to be exercised by Catholicism. The two great discoveries I have mentioned had both fallen to the lot of the intensely Catholic nations of the Spanish peninsula. Sj)ain especiallv exhibited a combination of advantages which it would be very difficult to parallel in history. Her magnificent colonies opened out a boundless prospect of wealth, and she seemed to possess all those qualities and capacities that were requi- site for their development. The nation was in the zenith of its power. The glories of Granada still rested upon it. Charles V. had united the imperial sceptre with that of Spain, had organised a vast navy, had constituted himself the recognised head of the Catholic interests, had humbled that French power which alone could imperil his ascendency, and had acquired the reputation of the most consummate 312 EATIONALISM EST EUEOPE. politician of the age. If we add to this, that the passion foi wealth had never been more strongly exhibited than by the Spaniards, it would seem as though no element of commer- cial gi-eatness was wanting, Reasoniug d priori, it would appear natural to conclude that Spain was about to embark in a long and glorious career of commerce, that she would incline the balance of material prosperity decisively to the .side of the religion of which she was the champion, but that the commercial spirit would at last act upon and modify her religious fanaticism. None of these results followed. Although for a few years the Spanish Catholics were the arbiters and the directors of commerce, and although the cifects of their ascendency have not even yet jaassed away, the j)rosperity of Spain was speedily eclipsed. At a time when she seemed on the high- way to an almost boundless wealth, she sank into the most abject poverty. Her glory was withered, her power was shattered, her fanaticism alone remained. There are several considerations that explain this apparent anomaly. The fii'st is, I think, to be found in the erroneous economical doctrine which became the mainspring of Spanish legislation. Although it would undoubtedly be a gross exaggeration to regard the Italian republics as having arrived at the knowledge of the true laws that govern wealth, there can be no question that their policy was far more in conformity with the principles of political economy than that of any of their successors till after the time of Quesnay and Smith. The exquisite practical skill they possessed, and also the pe- culiarity of their position, which made most of them entirely dependent upon commerce, and consequently the natural ene- mies of i->rotective privileges, saved them from the worst THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY OF RATIONALISM. 313 legislative errors of the age ; and, indeed, it Las been the just boast of Italian economists, that, if we except Serra, Geno- vesi, and perhaps one or two others, even their speculative writers have always been singularly free from the errors of that 'mercantile system' which in other countries was so long su- preme. It was not until Spain had risen to power, and the sti-eam of American gold had begun to inundate Europe, that the doctrine upon which that fatal system rests became the centre of commercial legislation. To state this doctrine in the simplest form, it was believed that all wealth consisted of the precious metals, and that therefore a country was necessarily impoverished by every transaction which diminished its metallic riches, no matter how much it may have added to its other possessions. If, therefore, two nations exchanged their commodities Avith a view of increasing their wealth, the single object of each was to regulate the transaction in such a manner that it might obtain a larger amount of money than it before pos- sessed, or, in other Avords, that the value of its non-metallic exports should be greater than of its imj)orts. But as the excess of exports over imports on one side implied a cor- responding excess of imports over exports on the other, it followed that the interests of the two nations were diametri- cally opposed, that the loss of one was the condition and measure of the gain of the other, and that to the nation which was unable to incline what was termed the ' balance of commerce' in its favour, the entire transaction was an evil. It followed also that the importance of native produc- tions was altogether subordinate to that of the export or im- poi't of gold. From these principles three important practical conse- quences were drawn which contributed greatly to the down- 314 PvATIONALISM IN ETJEOPE. fall of Spain. In the first place, the whole energy both of the government and people was concentrated npon the gold mines, and manufactures and almost all forms of industry- sank into neglect. In the next place, the colonies were speedily ruined by an elaborate system of commercial re- strictions and monopolies, devised with the vain hope of en- riching the mother-country, and some of them were at length goaded into successful rebellion. In the last place, an undue amount of gold was introduced into Spain, which had the very natural, but, to the Spaniards, the very aston- ishing effect of convulsing the whole financial system of the countiyJ For the value of gold, like the value of other com- modities, is governed by the law" of supply and demand ; and the fact that this metal has been selected as the general instrument of exchange, while it makes any sudden alteration in its value peculiarly dangerous, does not in any degree re- move it from the law. When it suddenly becomes too com- mon, its value — that is to say, its purchasing power — is de- preciated ; or, in other words, the price of all other articles is raised. After a time things adjust themselves to the new standard, and many political economists, considering the sudden stimulus that is given to industry, the particular class of enterprises the change in the value of money specially favours, and still more its effect in lightening the pressure of national debts, have regarded it as ultimately a benefit ; but, at all events, the confusion, insecurity, and uncertainty of the transition constitute a grave danger to the community, and the loss inflicted on certain classes ' is extremely serious. In our own day, although the influx of Australian and Califor- nian gold has told very sensibly upon prices, the immense area of enterprise over which it has been diftused, the conn- ^ Those who directly or indh'ectly depend upon used incomes. THE mDUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 315 teracting influence of machinery in cheapening commodoties, and also a few exceptional causes of demand,' have mate- rially deadened the shock. But the stream of gold that was directed to Spain after the discovery of America produced nearly the fall measure of evil, while the economical error of the age deprived the Spaniards of nearly all the good that might have been expected. The temporary evil of a violent change in prices could only have been abated, and the permanent evil of the decay of national industry could only have been in some degree compensated, by the free employment of American gold to purchase the industry of foreign nations ; but this would involve the export of the precious metal, Avhich the government under the severest penalties prohibited. It is true that, as no prohibition can finally arrest the natural flow of affliirs, the gold did issue forth,* but it was in the manner that was least advantageous to Spain. Charles V. and Philip II. employed it in their wars ; but wars are almost always detrimental to industry ; many of these were disastrous in their conclusions, and those of Charles were undertaken much more in the interests of the empire than of Spain, while Philip sacrificed every other consideration to the advantage of the Church. The only other mode of egress was by infringing the law. After a ^ According to Chevallier (whose book on this subject has been translated and endorsed by Mr. Cobden), the adoption of a gold standard by France is the principal. '-' The famous sermon of Bishop Latimer, describing the revolution of prices in England, was preached as early as 1548, only twenty-seven years after the conquest of Mexico, and at a time when the great mines of Potosi (which were only discovered in 1545) could scarcely have had any effect upon Europe. The most striking evidence of the perturbation of prices in Eng- land in the sixteenth century is given in 'A Compendious or Briefe Examina- tion of Ccrtayne Ordinary Complaints of divers of our Countrymen, by W. S.' [probably William Stafford], 1581. The greater part of this curious pamphlet has been reprinted in the fifth volume of the Pamplihtccr (1815). 316 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. few years, the full effects of this policy * v,'ere manifested. Manufactures had languished. Prices were immensely raised. Confusion and insecurity characterised every financial under- taking. The Spaniards, to adopt the image of a great po- litical economist, realising the curse of Midas, found all the necessaries of life transmuted into gold, while, to crown all, the government prohibited its export under pain of death. These economical causes will help to show why it was that the material prosperity of the great Catholic power was so transient, and also why no strong industrial spu-it was evoked to counteract the prevailing fanaticism. This last fact -will be still further elucidated, if we consider the social and religious institutions which Spanish Catholicity encouraged. The monasteries, in numbers and wealth, had reached a point that had scarcely ever been equalled ; and besides subtracting many thousand men and a vast amount of wealth from the productive resources of the country, they produced habits of mind that are altogether incompatible with industry. The spirit that makes men devote themselves in vast numbers to a monotonous life of asceticism and pov- erty is so essentially opposed to the spirit that creates the energy and enthusiasm of industry, that their continued co- existence may be regarded as impossible. Besides this, that aristocratic system which harmonises so well with a theo- logical society revived. A warlike and idle nobility took * Aggravated to a certain extent by the dishonest tampering with the coinage, in which Charles V., like most of the sovereigns of the time, in- dulged. The chief results of this are, first, that the good coins are driven out of circulation, as men naturally prefer giving the smallest value possible for what they purchase ; secondly, nominal prices are raised as the intrinsic value of coins is depreciated ; thirdly, all the evils of uncertainty, panic, and suffering inflicted upon creditors and persons with fixed incomes are pro- duced. THE TODUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 317 the place of the old merchant nobles of Italy, and a stigma was in consequence attached to lahour,* which was still fur- tber increased by the revival of slavery. The resurrection of this last institution is usually ascribed to Las Casas, the only really eminent philanthropist Spain ever produced. In this statement there is, however, some exaggeration. Las Casas only landed in America in 1513, and he does not appear to have taken any step on the sub- ject of slavery till some years later ; but negroes had been employed as slaves by the Portuguese in their colonies in the very beginning of the century,^ and a certain number were introduced into the Spanish colonies as early as 1511. They do not, however, appear to have been fully recognised by the government, and further imports were discouraged till 1516, when the monks of St. Jerome, who then adminis- tered affairs in the West Indies, recommended their employ- ment. In the following year. Las Casas pronounced ener- getically in the same sense. Strange as it may now appear, there can be no doubt that in doing so he was actuated by the purest benevolence. Perceiving that the wretched In- dians, to whose service he had devoted his life, perished by thousands beneath the hard labour of the mines, w-hile the negroes employed by the Portuguese bore the fatigue with- out the slightest injury, he imagined that by introducing the latter he was performing an act of undoiibted philanthroj^y; and thus it came to pass, that one Avhose character presents ' See Blanqui, Hist. cfEconomie Politique, torn. i. pp. 271-284, -where the whole subject of the political economy of Chai-les V. is admirably treated. ^ The beginning of the trade dates from 1440, in which year some Portu guese merchants, having kidnapped some Moors on the coast of Africa, only consented to ransom them on receiving negroes in exchange. (M'Pherson'a Annals of Commerce, vol. i. p. 661.) 318 EATIONALISM IN EUKOPE. an almost ideal type of beneficence became a leading pro- moter of negro slavery/ / The traffic once organised, and encouraged by the govern- ment, spread rapidly. Its monopoly was granted to the Belgians, who sold it to the Genoese; but merchants of Venice, Barcelona, and England had all an early share in the adventure. The first Englishman wl o took part in it was a certain John Hawkins, who made au expedition to the African coast in 1562.* Scarcely any one seems to have regarded the trade as wrong. Theologians had so success- fully laboured to produce a sense of the amazing, I might almost say generical, difierence between those who were Christians and those who were not, that to apply to the latter the principles that were applied to the formei", would have been deemed a glaring paradox. If the condition of the negroes in this world was altered for the worse, it was ' The first writer who undertook the defence of Las Casas was Gregoire, Bishop of Blois, in a paper read before the French Institute in 1804, and the subject was afterwards treated, though in a rather different point of view, in a letter by a Mexican priest named Don Gregorio Funes, and in an essay by Llorente. They are reprinted, together with translations of all the rele- vant passages from Herrera (the original authointy on the subject), in Llorente's edition of the works of Las Casas (1822). The first of these writers attempted to impugn the authority of Herrera, but for this there seems no sufficient reason ; nor does it appear that Herrera, or indeed any one else at the time, considered the conduct of Las Casas wrong. The monks of St. Jerome are much more responsible for the introduction of negroes than Las Casas. It is impossible to read the evidence Llorente has collected without feeling that, as a general rule (with a few striking excep- tions), the Spanish clergy laboured earnestly to alleviate the condition of the captive Indians, that this was one of their chief reasons in advocating the import of negroes, and that ihey never contemplated the hon-ors that soon grew out of the trade. It should be added that the Spanish Dominican Soto was perhaps the first man who unequivocally condemned that trade. ^ M'Pherson's Annals of Commerce, vol. ii. p. 638. At a much later period, in 1689, the English made a convention with Spain to supply the West Indies with slaves from Jamaica. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 319 felt that their prospects in the next were greatly improved. Besides, it was remembered that, shortly after the deluge, Ham had behaved disrespectfully to his drunken father, and it vfas believed by many that the Almighty had, in con- sequence, ordained negro slavery. / The Spanish were not in general bad masters. On the contrary, when the gold fever had begun to subside, they were in this respect distinguished for their humanity ; ' and their laws on the subject still present, in some points, a favourable contrast to those of America ; but the eftect of slavery upon the national character was not the less great. Besides these considerations, we must take into account the great acts of religious intolerance of which Spain was guilty, and which recoiled with fatal effect upon her indus- trial system. Never did a people verify more fully tlie great truth, that industry and fanaticism are deadly foes. Four times the Spanish nation directed all its energies in the cause of the Church, and four times its prosperity received a wound from which it has never recovered. By the expulsion of the Jews, Spain was deprived of all her greatest financiers, and of almost all her most enterprising merchants. By the expul- sion of the Moors, she lost her best agriculturists; vast plains were left uninhabited, except by banditti, and some of the most important trades were paralysed forever. By the expe- dition of the Armada, that naval supremacy which, since the discoveries of the Cape passage and of America had made commerce exclusively maritime, implied commercial suprem- acy, passed from her hands, and was soon divided between the Protestant nations of England and Holland. By her persecutions in the Netherlands, she produced a spirit of ' This was noticed by Bodin in his time. See La liejniblique, p. 41 (1511). 820 EATIONALISM IN" EUKOPE. resistance that baffled Ler armies, destroyed her prestige, and resulted in the establishment of another State, distinguished alike for its commercial genius, its bravery, and its Prot- estantism. There were, of course, other circumstances which acceler- ated or aggravated the downfall of Sjjain ; but the really dominating causes are all, I think, to be found under the economical or theological heads I have noticed. It is well worthy of attention how they conspired, acting and reacting upon one another, to destroy that political stntcture which was once so powerful, and which appeared to possess so many elements of stability. Nor can we question that that destruction Avas an almost unmingled benefit to mankind. Blind folly, ignoble selfishness, crushing tyranny, and hideous cruelty, mark every page of the history of the domination of Spain, whether we turn to the New World or to the Nether- lands, or to those glorious Italian cities which she blasted by her rule. During the period of her ascendency, and espe- cially during the reigns of Charles Y. and Philip II., who were the most faithful representatives of her spirit, she Avas guilty of an amount of persecution before Avhich all the enormities of Eomau emperors fade into insignificance. She reorganised the accursed institution of slavery on a gigantic scale, and in a form that was in some respects worse than any that had before existed ; she was the true author of the mer- cantile theory and of the colonial policy which have been the sources of disastrous wars to every European nation ; she replaced municipal independence by a centralised despotism, and the aristocracy of industry by the aristocracy of war ; ' and she uniformly exerted the whole stress of her authority to check on all subjects and in all forms the progress of * Blanqui, Hist, de VEcon. Pol., torn. i. p. 277. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOKY OF RATIONALISM. 321 enquiry and of knowledge. Had she long continued to exorcise the assimilating, absorbing, and controlling influence of a great Power, the advancement of Europe might have been indefinitely retarded. Happily, however, Providence, in the laws of history as in the laAvs of matter, tends ever to perfection, and, annexing fatal penalties to the resistance of those laws, destroys every obstacle, confounds those who seek to arrest the progress, and, by the concurrence of many agencies, effects the objects it designs. Before leaving the subject of Spanish industry, I may no- tice one article that was at this time brought into Europe, not because it was itself very important, but because it was the beginning of a great social change that was fully accom- plished about a century afterwards — I mean the introduction of hot drinks. Towards the middle of the sixteenth century, the Spaniards imported cliocolate from Mexico. Rather more than half a century later, tea was introduced from Chiiia and Japan. It had been noticed by Marco Polo as early as the thirteenth century, but it was j)robably first brought to Eu- rope by the Jesuit missionaries in the first years of the seven- teenth century, and it was soon after largely imported by the Dutch. In 1636 we find it in usage in France, and enthusi- astically patronised by the Chancellor Seguier. The earliest notice of it in England is in an Act of Parliament of 1660. The discovery of the circulation of blood, which produced an ex- aggerated estimate of the medical value of bleeding and of hot drinks, and the writings of two physicians named Tuli)ius and Bontekoe, gave a great impulse to its popularity. In a letter written in 1680, Madame de Sevigne observes that the Marchioness de la Sabliere had just introduced the custom of drinking it with milk. About the middle of the same century, coftee began to pour in from Turkey. The proper- VOL. II. — i1 322 EATIONALISM m EUEOPE. ties of this berry had been noticed in 1591 by the Venetian physician Alpinus, and soon afterwards by Bacon in his 'Natural History,' and the drink was introduced into Eng- land in 1652 by an English Turkey merchant named Ed- wards. In France the first coffee-house was established at Marseilles in 1664. A few years later, Soliman Aga, the ambassador of Mahomet IV., made the new beverage very fashionable in Paris ; and in 1672 an Armenian named Pascal established a coffee-house in that city. He had soon count- less imitators ; and it was observed that this new taste gave a serious and almost instantaneoiis clieck to drunkenness, which had been very prevalent in France. Coffee-houses were the true precursors of the clubs of the eighteenth cen- tury. They became the most important centres of society, and they gave a new tone to the national manners. In Eng- land, though they were once even more popular than in France, and though they are indissolubly associated with one of the most brilliant periods of literary history, the}^ have not taken root ; but the effect of hot drinks upon do- mestic life has 2>i"obably been even greater than on the Con- tinent. Checking the boisterous revels that had once been universal, and raising woman to a new position in the do- mestic circle, they have contributed very largely to refine manners, to introduce a new order of tastes, and to soften and improve the character of men. They are therefore, I think, not unworthy of a passing notice in a sketch of the moral and intellectual consequences of commerce.' * The fullest history of hot drinks I have met with is in a curious and learned book, D'Aussj, Hist, de la Vie Privee des Frangais (Paris, 1815), torn. iii. pp. 116-129, which I have followed closely. See, too, Pierre La- eroix, Hktoire des Ancicnnes Corporations, p. 7fi ; Pelletier, Le Tlie et It Cafe ; Cabanis, Rapports du Physique et du Moral, 8me Memoire ; and, for the English part of the history, M'Pherson's Annals of Commerce, vol. il pp. 447-489. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 323 When the Spanish supremacy was destroyed, what may be termed the commercial antagonism of the two religions ceased. England and Holland were long the leaders of com- merce ; and if Catholic nations have since distinguished them- selves in that course, it has heen when their zeal had grown languid and their system of policy been secularised. The general superiority in industry of Protestant countries has been constantly noticed and often explained. The suppres- sion of monasteries, the discouragement of mendicity, and the construction of churches that were in no degree formed upon the ascetic principle, contributed to the progress ; but perhaps the principal cause was the intellectual impulse com- municated by the Reformation, which was felt in every field both of speculation and of action.' Eut while the relative interests of Protestantism and Catholicism have not been very seriously involved in the history of industry since the seventeenth century, there is another form of antagonism which long after made that his- tory a faithful mirror of theological progress. I mean the conflict between town and country, between the manufoc- turing and the agricultural intei-ests. The question which of these two spheres of existence is most conducive to the happiness and the morality of mankind will, no doubt, al- ways be contested ; but the fact that they produce entirely different intellectual tendencies, both in religion and politics, will scarcely be disputed. The country is always the repre- ^ I do not include among these causes the diminution of Church holidays, for although in some few countries they may have degenerated into an abuse, the number that are compulsory has been grossly exaggerated ; and more- over, their good effects in procuring some additional recreation for the work- ing classes appear to me to have much moi-e than counterbalanced any slight injury they may have done to labour. There is some correspondence be- tween Dr. Doyle and Lord Cloncurry on this subject, which is well worthy of attention, in Fitzpatrick's Life of Doyle. 324 EATIONALISM IN ErEOPE. sentative of stability, immobility, and reaction. The towns are the representatives of progress, innov^ation, and revolu- tion. The inhabitants of the country may be veiy vicious ; biit even in the midst of their vice they will be extremely superstitious, extremely tenacious of the customs of religions that have elsewhere passed away, and especially addicted to that aspect of those religions which is most opposed to the spirit of Rationalism. All the old superstitions concerning witches, fairies, hereditary curses, prophetical dreams, magi- cal virtues, lucky or unlucky days, places, or events, still linger among the poor ; Avhile even the educated are distin- guished for the retrospective character of their minds, and for their extreme antipathy to innovation. Tlie general character of great towns, and especially of manufacturing towns, is entirely different.' It is indeed true that the great subdivision of labour, while it is eminently favourable to the increase of wealth, is for a time unfavourable to the intel- lectual development of the labourer; for tlie mind that is concentrated exclusively upon the manufacture of a single portion of a single object is far less happily circumstanced than if it were occupied with a complex subject which de- mands the exercise of all its faculties. But this disadvan- tage is more than compensated by the intellectual stimulus of association, and by the increased opportunities which greater rewards and steady progress produce. Certain it is that neither the virtues nor vices of great towns take the form of reaction in politics, or of superstition in religion. The past rests lightly, often too lig-htly, upon them. Nov ' The difference between town and countrj' in this respect has been fully noticed by Mr. Buckle {Hist, of Civ., vol. i. pp. 844-34'7), who ascribes it chiefly to the fact that agriculturists are dependent for their success upon atmospheric changes, which man can neither predict nor control. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY Of RATIONALISM. 325 elty is welcomed, progi-ess is eagerly pursued. Vague tra- ditions are keenly criticised, old doctrines are disintegrated and moulded afresh by the individual judgment. Besides this, the manufacturing is also the commercial interest ; and the great intellectual importance of commerce we have al- ready seen. Such, then, being the opposite predispositions evoked by agricultural and manufacturing occupations, it becomes a matter of considerable interest and importance to trace the history of their comparative development ; and in order to do so it will be necessary to give a brief outline of the progress of economical opinion on the subject. Before the dawn of a correct political economy in the eighteenth century, Europe was for the most part divided between two doctrines on the subject of commerce. Both schools regarded money as the single form of wealth; but, according to one of them, commerce should be altogether discouraged, as at best a dangerous and a gambling specula- tion ; while, according to the other, it should be pursued as the chief method of acquiring wealth, but only on the con- dition of the exports exceeding the imports. The first of these schools usually discouraged manufactures, and concen- trated its attention upon agriculture ; the other was eminent- ly favourable to manufactures. Before the sixteenth centui'y, the notions of the first school, without being systematised or formally stated, were very generally diftused ; politicians la- boured to make each nation entirely self-subsisting ; and there was an antipathy, or at least a disinclination, to any specula- tion that involved an export of gold, even with the eventual object of obtaining a larger supply in return.' Besides this, the rude simplicity of manners which made the demand for * See M'CulIoch's Political Economy, and his Introduction to the Wealth of Nations. 326 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. manufactured goods very small, the superstitions about usury wliicli fell with crushing weight on industrial enterprise, the imperfection of the means of communication, the zeal with which the monks pursued agriculture, the especial adaptation of that pursuit, on account of its comparative facility, to an early stage of civilisation, and the recollection of the peculiar honour in which it had been held by the ancients, — all tend- ed in the same direction. With the exception of the Italian republics and the cities of the Hanseatic League, which had little or no land to cultivate, and were almost forced by their circumstances into commerce, agriculture was every- where the dominant form of labour, and the habits of mind it created contributed much to colour, intensify, and perpetu- ate the mediaeval superstitions. When, however, the great discoveries of gold in America created in all nations an eager desire to obtain it, industry began to assume a new form and more gigantic proportions ; and although, owing to causes which I have already traced, it languished in Spain, it Avas rapidly developed in other countries, and the opinions of statesmen on the subject were steadily modified. Sully was probably the last minister of very considerable abilities who systematically opposed manu- factures as an evil. The opposite opinion, which regarded them as the most efficient magnet of foreign gold, found its greatest representative in Colbert ; ' and although the ruinous ' See Blanqui. In England the mercantile system began under the influ- ence of the East India Company, which, in 1600, obtained permission to export the precious metals to the amount of £80,000 per aimum, on the con- dition that within six months of every expedition (except the first) the Com- pauy should import an equal sum. Under Henry VIII., and more than once at an earlier period, all exportation of the precious metals had been forbid- den. The restrictive laws on this subject were repealed in 1663 (M'CuUoch'a Introd. Discourse). The two most eminent English defenders of the mercan- tile system — Thomas Mun, whose Treasure hy Foreign Trade was published THE IKDUSTEIAL IIISTOEY OF EATIONALISM. 327 wars of Louis XIV., and still more the revocation of the Edict of Nantes, in a great measure counteracted his efforts ; although, too, the ultimate effects of the jDrotective system have been extremely detrimental to industry ; there can he little doubt that this minister did more than any preceding statesman to make manufactures a prominent form of Euro- pean industry. He removed many of the impositions under which they suffered, protected their interests -uhenever they were menaced, and did all that lay in his power to encourage their development. Indeed, at first sight, the school which followed that of Colbert, though in reality an immense step in advance, might appear less favourable to the mamifacturing interests. The economists — as Quesnay, and those very able writers and statesmen who adopted his opinions, were termed — were not simply the precursors of political economy; they were the actual fou,nders of many parts of it ; and though their system, as a whole, has perished, and their fame been eclipsed by the great thinker of Scotland, they will always form one of the most important links in the history of the science. Perhaps their principal achievement was the repudiation of the old doctrine that all wealth consisted of gold — a doctrine which, having lighted np the labours of the alchemists, and inspired all the Eldorado dreams of the middle ages, had become the cardinal principle of commercial legislation.* Almost at the same time, and about twenty-five years before tlie publication in 1664, and Sir Josiah Cliild, whose New Discourse of Trade was published In 1668 — both wrote in the interests of the East India Company. ' The earliest writer who very clearly expounded the true nature of money was probably Bishop Bei'keley, whose Querist, considei-ing that it was written in 1735, is one of the most remarkable instances of political sagacity of the age ; far superior in this respect, I think, to the economical writings of Locke. Berkeley very nearly broke loose from the system of ' the balance 328 eationalism in eueope. of ' The Wealth of Nations,' this doctrine was assailed, and the possibility of the increase of Avealth being in inverse proportion to the increase of gold was asserted, by Hume in England, and by Quesnay in France. But while the French economists perceived very clearly the mistake of their prede- cessors, when they came to establish their own doctrine they fell into an error which is a striking illustration of the dif- ficulty with which, in one stage of progress, even the most acute minds rise to truths which in another stage appear per- fectly self-evident. Nothing, according to their view, can really add to the national wealth which does not call new matter into existence, or at least introduce it to the service of men. Mines, fisheries, and agriculture fulfil these con- ditions, and consequently add to the national wealth. Manu- fiictures, simply giving matter a new form, though they are extremely useful to the community, and though they may enable an individual to augment his portion of the national wealth, can never increase the great total. Practically, there- fore, for the great majority of nations, agriculture is the sin- gle source of wealth ; all manufactures are ultimately salaried of commerce.' The following queries are a curious example of the struggles of an acute reason against this universal error : — ' Whether that trade should not be accounted most pernicious, wherein the balance is most against us ? and whether this be not the trade of France ? ' ' Whether the annual trade between Italy and Lyons be not about four mil- lions in favour of the former, and yet whether Lyons be not a gainer by this trade ? ' ' Whether the general rule of determining the profit of a commerce by its balance doth not, like other rules, admit of exceptions ? ' ' Whether it would not be a monstrous folly to import nothing but gold and silver, sup- posing we might do it, from every foreign part to which we trade ? ' ' Whether he must not be a wrong-headed patriot or politician whose ultimate view was drawing money into a country and keeping it there?' (Querist, 61, 555, 556, 55*7, 559.) Berkeley is an example of, perhaps, the rarest form of genius — that which is equally adapted for political speculation, and for the most subtle and super- sensuous regions of metapliysics. THE INDUSTEIAL, HISTOKY OF EATIONALISM. 329 by it, and its encouragement should be the main object of judicious policy, Raynal, it is true, in this matter separated from the rest of the school. He saw that manufactures in- vested the raw material with new qualities, and making it the object of new demand increased its value; but at this point lie stoppecl^l Agriculture and industry he regarded as both sources of national wealth, but not so commerce. For- getting that an article may be fiir more valuable in a country into which it is imported than in that in Avhich it is indige- nous, and that when the costs incident upon transport have been deducted from this excess, the remainder is a pure gain, he maintained that commerce, being simply displacement, could not increase the general wealth. These doctrines were undoubtedly in some respects very unfavourable to manufactures, yet their consequences were not as evil as might have been expected. In the first place, the economists were unwittingly guilty of a grievous injus- tice to their favourite pursuit. All taxation, they believed, Bhould be levied upon the net gains of the country ; and as those gains were exclusively due to agriculture, they con- cluded, as Locke on somewhat different grounds had con- cluded in the preceding century, that the proprietors of the soil should bear the entire burden. Besides this, the econo- mists, as the first great opponents of the mercantile theory, were on all occasions the advocates of free trade, the sub- verters of every form of monopoly, the reformers of all the neans of communication. By the ministry of Turgot, and by the legislation of the revolutionary parliaments, such countless abuses of detail were swept away, and so many useful measures recommended, that it may be truly said that manufactures owe more to them than to any preceding legis- lators. ' Say, Traite d^Economie Politique, liv. i. ch. 2. 330 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. At last Adam Smith appeared ; and wliile he effectually destroyed all that part of the doctrme of the economista which was hostile to manufactures, he established upon the firm basis of demonstration, and developed and irradiated with matchless skill, all that was most favourable to their progress. Proving that labour was the basis of value, that money is but a single form of merchandise which has been selected as the instrument of exchange, and that the goods of foreign countries are eventually pui'chased by native pro- ductions— unravelling by a chain of the clearest but most sub- tle reasoning the functions of capital, the manner in which it is created by the combination of parsimony with industry, and the special facilities which manufactures and the division of la- bour of which they admit offer for its increase — giving, too, a fatal blow to the system of restrictions by which statesmen had long imagined that they could promote the interests of wealth, — Adam Smith performed the double service of dis- pelling the notion that manufactures are useless or perni- cious, and unfolding the true laws that regulate their pros- perity. Generation after generation, and almost year by year, his principles have penetrated more deeply into the policy of Europe ; and generation after generation, manufac- tures, freed from their old shackles, acquire a greater expan- sion, and the habits of thought which they produce a corre- sponding importance. It is, however, an extremely remarkable fact, as showing the tenacity with which the doctrines of the ' economists ' clung to the mind, that even Adam Smith thought it neces- sary, in classifying the sources of wealth, to reserve for agri- culture a position of special prominence, as the most abun- dant 3f these sources.' He arrived at this conclusion, not ^ Wealth of Nations, book ii. cb. 5. THE ESTDUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALISM. 33] from any observation of what had actually taken place, but from two general considerations. In manufactures, he con- tended, wealth is produced by the unaided toil of man, whereas in agriculture nature cooperates with human exer- tions. Besides this, agriculture, unlike other pursiiits, in ad- dition to wages and profit, can furnish a rent. The first of these statements, as has often been observed, is j)alpably in- accurate, for nature is in many instances extremely service- able to the manufacturer; as, for example, when steam or water puts his machinery in motion. The second argument lost its force when Ricardo discovered the true cause of rent, proving that it is a sign of the limited productivity of the soil, and not of its superiority to other sources of wealth.' But while this steady modification of economical opinions in favour of manufactures is one great cause of the progress of the latter, it would probably have been insufficient, but for the cooperation of two other influences. The first of these was the system of credit. This remarkable agency, which has long proved one of the great moralising influences of society, by the immense importance it has bestowed upon ' As long as the good land to be cultivated is practically unlimited rela- tively t: the population, no rent is paid. When, however, the best land no longer sufficiently supplies the wants of an increased population, it will still continue to be cultivated ; but it will be necessary also to cultivate land of an inferior quality. The cost of the production of a given quantity of the best corn will necessarily be greater when derived from the latter than when derived from the former ; but wlien brought to the market, all corn of the same quality will bear the same price, and that price will be regulated by the cost of production which is greatest (for no one would cultivate the bad land if the sale of its produce did not compensate for his outlay), so that in the sale of com of the same quality at the same price, the profits of the posses- sors of the good, will be greater than the profits of the possessors of the bad land. This difference is the origin of rent, which is, therefore, not a primal dement of agriculture, and which has not, as Adam Smith supposed, an; influence on price. cJJiJ EATIONALISM IN EUROPE. :.Viaracter, and one of the great pledges of peace, by the union it has established between different nations, and, at the same time, the most powerful of all the engines of warfare, is chiefly due to the industrial genius of Holland ; for though some traces of it may be found among the Jews and the Ital- ian republics of the middle ages, the system was not dul}'- organised till the establishment of the bank of Amsterdam in 1G09. The immediate object was to increase the amount of money in circulation, and thus give a new impetus to indus- try; and within certain limits, and subject to certain dan- gers, which we have not now to consider, it has fully an- swered its end. Tlie second influence is the rapid development of mechani- cal contrivances. Strictly speaking, machinery dates from the rudest instrument by which men tilled the soil ; but its higher and more elaborate achievements are always the prod- uct of civilisation, upon which, in turn, they powerfully react. The most important machine invented, or at least introduced into Europe, in the middle ages, was probably the windmill,^ which was an agent in the agricidtural interests. In the fifteenth century, a machine for printing transformed the intellectual condition of Europe. In the nineteenth century, the machines of Watt, Arkwright, and Stephenson, and the many minor inventions that are subsid- iary to them, have given an imj^ulse both to commerce and manufactures which is altogether unparalleled in the history of mankind. In addition to the necessary difficulties con- ' The earliest European notice of windmills is, I believe, to be found ia a charter of William, Count of Mortain (grandson of William the Conqueror), dated 1105, which has been pubUshed by Mabillon. They are supposed to have been brought from Asia Minor. (D'Aussy, La Vi" ^'^ivee des Fran^ais. tom. i. pp. 62, 63.) THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 533 uected with the mtroduction of a new form of industry, every step of the progress of machines Avas met by a fierce opposition, directed at one time by the ablest statesmen/ and hng afterwards sustained by the lower classes, who very naturally regarded these inventions as prejudicial to their interests. And, certainly, the first result of machinery, by economising the labour of production, is to throw a vast number of the poor out of employment, and to reduce, by increased concurrence, the wages of the remainder. The second is to diminish the price of the article of manufacture, to the benefit of the consumer; and in most cases this depre- ciation leads to an immense extension of demand, which necessitates a multij^lication of machines, and usually con- tinues till the nimiber of jiersons employed is immeasurably greater than before the machinery had been introduced. At the same time, this increased facility of production and this increased demand produce an accumulation of capital far more rapid than had previously taken place ; which, as the rate of wages depends entirely upon the jDroportion national capital bears to the labouring classes, among whom it is to be divided, is a main condition of the material prosperity of the latter. Even in those instances in which, from the nature of the case, the demand for the manufactured article cannot be so extended as to compensate for the loss of employment which the introduction of machinery occasions, although the passing evils are very great, the change is usually an advantage ; for economical production implies increasing wealth, and the capital gained in one department finds its outlet in others. There are, no doubt, other effects of machinery which are serious drawbacks to these advantages — some of tliem ' Amongst others, Colbert. 334 EATIONALISM EST EUROPE. lulterent in this mode of production, but many of them part- ly or altogether due to the process of transition. Such ar« the great increase of the inequalities of fortune which results from the absorption of all production by colossal manufac- tures, the unnatural multiplication and agglomeration of population they occasion, the sudden and disastrous fluctua- tions to which manufacturing industry is peculiarly liable, the evil efiects it fi-equently exercises upon health, and the temptation to employ young children in its service. All these points have given rise to much animated discussion, which it does not fall within the province of the present work to review ; but at all events it is unquestionable that, for good or for evil, the invariable efiect of modern machinery has been to increase the prominence of manufactures, to multiply the number of those engaged in them, and, there- fore, in the opposition of tendencies that exists betw^een the agricultural and manufacturing classes, to incline the balance in favour of the latter. Beyond all other nations, England has been in this respect distinguished. Both in the intellectual and in the mechani- cal influences I have reviewed, she stands without a rival; for with, I think, the exception of Say, France has not pro- duced any political economist of gi-eat original powers since Turgot ; and America, notwithstanding her rare mechanical genius, is as yet unable to boast of a "Watt or a Stephenson. It is not surprising that a land which has attained this dou- ble supremacy, and which possesses at the same time un- limited coal-mines, an unrivalled naA^y, and a government that can never long resist the natural tendency of afflxirs, should be preeminently the land of manufactures. In no other country are the intellectual influences connected with them so powerful ; and the constant increase of the manu- THE INDUSTKIAL IlISTOET OF EATIO^'ALISM. 335 facturing population is rapidly verifying, in a sense that should not be restricted to politics, the prediction of Mr. Cobden, that eventuallj' ' the towns must govern England.' ' In the preceding examination cf the ways ia which the successive evolutions of European industry have reflected or influenced the history of belief, I have often had occasion to refer to the dift'erent branches of political economy in their relation to different aspects of industrial progress. It remains for me now to consider in a more general point of view the theological consequences of this great science, which has probably done more than any other to reveal the true phys- iology of society. For although political economists, and especially those of England, have often endeavoured to isolate the phenomena of wealth, all such attempts have proved entirely futile. Even Adam Smith lighted up an im- mense series of moral and social interests by his science. Malthus, opening out the great question of population, im- mensely increased its range ; and it is now impossible to be imbued with the leading writings on the subject without forming certain criteria of excellence, certain general concep- tions of the aim and laws of human progress, that cannot be restricted to material interests. I shall endeavour, without entering into any minute details, to sketch the general out- lines of these conceptions, and to show in what respects they harmonise or clash with theological notions. The first important consequence of political economy I iiave in some degree anticipated in the last chapter. It is to There are some striking, though now rather ancient, statistics on this point in Babbage On Machines, eh. i. In 1830, the non-cultivators were in Italy as 31 to 100; in France, as 50 to 100; in England, as 200 to 100. During the first thirty years of the century, the population of England in- creased about fifty-one per cent. ; that of the great towns, 123 per cent. 336 KATIONALISM IN EUROPE. contribute largely towards the realisation of the great Chris- tian conception of universal peace. Tlie history of the fortunes of that conception in the hands of theologians is profoundly melancholy. Though peace upon earth was at first proclaimed as a main object of Christianity, and though for about three centuries the Christian discij)les displayed unwearied zeal and amazing heroism in advocating it, the sublime conception of a moral unity gradually faded away before the conception of a unity of ecclesiastical organisa- tion ; and for many centuries theologians were so far from contributing to the suppression of war, that they may be justly regarded as its chief fomenters. Certain it is, that the i:)criod when the Catholic Church exercised a supreme ascendency, was also the period in which Europe was most distracted by wars ; and that the very few instances in which the clergy exerted their gigantic influence to suppress them, are more than counterbalanced by those in which they were the direct causes of the bloodshed. Indeed, they almost consecrated war by teaching that its issue was not the result of natural agencies, but of supernatural interposi- tion. As the special sphere of Providential action, it as- sumed a holy character, and success became a proof, or at least a strong presumption, of right. Hence arose that union between the sacerdotal and the military spirit whicb meets us in every page of history ; the countless religious rites that were intei-woven with military jiroceedings ; the legends of visible miracles deciding the battle ; the trial by combat, which the clergy often wished to suppress, but which never- theless continued for centuries, because all classes regarded the issue as the judicial decision of the Deity. When these superstitions in some measure decayed, the religious wars began. The bond of Catholic unity, which was entirely THE mDUSTKIAL HISTORY OF ■RATIONALISltf. 337 insuiBcient to prevent wars between Catholic nations, proved povrerful enough to cause frightful convulsions when it w^as assailed ; and one of the most faithful measures of the decay of theological influences has been the gradual cessation of the wars they produced. The inadequacy of theological systems as a basis of European tranquillity having been clearly proved by the experience of many centuries, there arose in the eighteenth century a school which attempted to establish this tranquil- lity by a purely intellectual process — by giving intellectual pursuits and political principles a decisive predommance over the military spirit. I allude to the French philosophers, who in this as in many other respects were simply endeav- ouring to realise in their own way one of the great ideal conceptions of Christianity. They arose at a period well suited to the enterprise. France was wearied, exhausted, and almost ruined by the long wars of Louis XIV. The prestige that Conde and Turenne had cast upon the French arms had perished beneath the still greater genius of Marl- borough. An intense intellectual life had arisen, accom- panied by all the sanguine dreams of youth. Voltaire, after coquetting for a short time with the military spirit, threw himself cordially into the cause of peace. He employed all his amazing abilities and all his unrivalled influence to dis- credit war, and, with the assistance of his followers, suc- ceeded in establishing the closest union between the intel- lects of France and England, and in replacing the old theo- logical and military antipathy by the sympathy of common aspirations. But a few years passed away, and all this was changed. The iniquitous war against the French Revolution into which Pitt suffered his country to plunge, and the pernicious genius TOL.II. — 48 338 EATIONALISM IN EUROPE, of Napoleon, evoked all the reactionary influences in Europe, revived the military spirit in its full intensity, and plunged the greater part of the civilised world into the agonies of a deadly struggle. There can, I think, he little doubt that there is a ten- dency in civilisation to approximate towards the ideal of the French philosophers. It can hardly be questioned that the advance of intellectual cultvirc produces a decline of the military spirit, and that the cohesion resulting from a com- munity of principles and intellectual tendencies is rapidly superseding artificial political combinations. But at the same time it is no less certain that the bond of intellectual sympatliy alone is far too weak to restrain the action of col- liding passions, and it was reserved for political economy to supply a stronger and more permanent principle of unity. Tliis principle is an enlightened self-interest. Formerly, as I have said, the interests of nations were supposed to be diametrically ojsposed. The wealth that was added to one was necessarily taken from another ; and all commerce was a kind of balance, in which a gain on one side implied a cor- responding loss on the opposite one. Every blow that was struck to the prosperity of one nation was of advantage to the rest, for it diminished the number of those among whom the wealth of the world was to be divided. Religion might indeed interpose and tell men that they ought not to rejoice in the misfortunes of others, and that they should subordi- nate their interests to higher considerations; but still each people, as far as it followed its selfish interests, was hostile to its neighbour ; ^ and even in the best ages the guiding ^ Even Voltaire said, ' Telle est la condition humaine, que souhaiter la grandeur de son pays c'est souhaiter du mal a ses voisins. . . . II est clair qu'un pays ne pent gagner sans qu'un autre perd.' {Diet. Phil., art. Patrie.) THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 339 principles of large bodies of men are almost always selfish. Independently of the many wars that were directly occa- sioned by a desire to alter commercial relations, there was a constant smouldering ill-feeling created by the sense of habitual antagonism, which the slightest difference kindled into a flame. For this great evil political economy is the only correc- tive. It teaches, in the first place, that the notion that a commercial nation can only pi-osper by the loss of its neigh- bour, is essentially false. It teaches still further that each nation has a direct interest in the prosperity of that with which it trades, just as a shopman has an interest in the wealth of his customers. It teaches too that the difierent markets of the world are so closely connected, that it is quite impossible for a serious derangement to take place in any one of them without its evil efiects vibrating through all ; and that, in the present condition of Europe, commer- cial ties are so numerous, and the interests of nations so closely interw^oven, that war is usually an evil even to the victor. Each successive development of political economy has brought these truths into clearer relief, and in propor- tion to their diflusion must be the antipathy to war; the desire to restrict it, when it does break out, as far as possible to those who are actually engaged ; and the hostility to all who have provoked it. Every fresh commercial enterprise is therefore an additional guarantee of peace. I know that, in the present day, when Europe is suffering to an almost unexampled extent from the disquietude result- ing from the conflict between opposing principles and un- equal civilisations, speculations of this kind must appear to many unreal and Utopian. Most assuredly, as long as na- tions tolerate monarchs who, resting upon the traditions of 340 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. an effete theocracy, regard their authority as of divine right, and esteem it their main duty to arrest by force the political develoj^ments of civilisation, so long must standing armies and wars of opinion continue. Nor would the most sanguine political economist ventiire to predict a time in which the sword would be altogether unknown. The explosions of passion are not always restrained by the most evident ties of interest ; exceptional circumstances countei'act general tendencies ; and commerce, which links civilised communi- ties in a bond of unity, has ever forced her way among bar- barians by bloodshed and by tyranny. But in order to jus- tify the prospect of a great and profound change in the rela- tions of European nations, it is only necessary to make two postulates. The first is, that the industrial element, which, in sj^ite of legislative restrictions and military perturbations, is advancing every year with accelei-ated rapidity, is destined one day to become the dominant influence in politics. The second is, that those principles of political economy which are now acknowledged to be true by every one who has stud- ied them, will one day be realised as axioms by the masses. Amid the complications and elaborations of civilisation, the deranging influence of passion, whether for good or for evil, becomes continually less, and interest becomes more and more the guiding influence, not perhaps of individuals, but of communities. In proportion to the commercial and indus- trial advancement of a nation, its interests become favourable to peace, and the love of war is in consequence diminished. When therefore the different states of Europe are closely interwoven by commercial interests, when the classes who represent those interests have become the guiding power of the state, and when they are fully penetrated with the truth that war in any quarter is detrimental to their prosperity, a THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY OF RATIONALISM. 341 guarantee for the j^eace of Euroi^e "will have Leen attained, if not perfect, at least far stronger than any which either re- ligion or philanthropy has yet realised. In such a condition of commercial activity, and in such a condition of public knowledge, a political transformation would necessarily en- sue, and. the principal causes of present perturbations would be eliminated. At the same time two kindred movements which I have already noticed — the i;ecognition of the princi- ple of the rights of nationalities as the basis of political mo- rality, and. the growing ascendency of intellectual pursuits diminishing the admiration of military glory — would, consoli- date the interests of peace. Many years must undoubtedly elapse before such a condition of society can be attained; torrents of blood must yet be shed before the political obsta- cles shall have been removed, before the nationalities which are still writhing beneath a foreign yoke shall have been re- lieved, and before advancing knowledge shall have finally destroyed those theological doctrines concerning the rela- tions between sovereigns and nations which are the basis of all the worst tyrannies that are cursing mankind; but as surely as civilisation advances, so surely must the triumph come. Liberty, industry, and peace are in modern societies indissolubly connected, and their idtimate ascendency de- pends upon a movement which may be retarded, but cannot possibly be arrested. It should be observed, too, that while the nations which are most devoted to industrial enterprise are the most wealthy and the most pacific, they are also, as a general ndc, those which are most likely to wield the greatest power in war. This, as Adam Smith has acutely observed, is one of the most important differences between ancient and modern societies. Formerly, when war depended almost entirely 3i2 EATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. upon unaided valoiir, the military position of a ricii nation was usually unfavourable ; for while its wealth enervated its character and attracted the cupidity of its neighbours, it did not in the hour of strife furnish it with advantages at all commensurate with these evils. Hence the ruin of Carthage, Corinth, and Tyre, the great centres of commercial activity among the ancients. Since, however, the invention of gun- powder and the elaboration of military machinery, war has become in a great measure dependent upon mechanical genius, and above all upon financial prosperity, and the ten- dency of the balance of power is therefore to incline steadily to the nations that are most interested in the preservation of peace. The influence political economy exercises in uniting dif- ferent communities by the bond of a common interest, is also felt in the relations between the different classes of the same community. It is indeed no exaggeration to say, that a w^ide diffusion of the principles of the science is absolutely essen- tial, if democracy is to be other than a fearful evil. For when the masses of the poor emerge from the torpor of igno- rance, and begin keenly to examine their position in the gra- dations of society, property is almost certain to strike them as an anomaly and an injustice. From the notion that all men are born free and equal, they will very speedily jiass to the conviction that all men are born with the same title to the goods that are in the world. .Paley may have been wrong in regarding general utility as the ultimate basis of the'rights of property, but most assuredly no other will ob- tain the respect of those who, themselves struggling with poverty, have obtained a supreme authority in the state. The long series of measures directly or indirectly infringing on the rights of property that have disgraced the democracy THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY OF EA.TIONALISM, 343 of France/ and the notion of the natural hostility of capital and labour which is so general among the labouring classes on the Continent, are sufficient to cause a profound disqui- etude to those who have convinced themselves that democ- racy is the ultimate form of political development. Political economy, and political economy alone, can remedy the evil. It does not indeed teach the optimism or the fatalism that some have imagined, and there can be little question that its ascendency must give in many respects new directions to the channel of wealth, repi'essing forms of exjjenditure which have long been regarded as peculiarly honourable, and which will be regarded in a very different light when they are uni- versally acknowledged to be useless or detrimental to so- ciety.'' Nor does it teach that the interests of rich and poor ' There is a full description of these in Chevallier's Lettres mr V Organisa- tion du Travail — a very able, and, considering that it was written in 1848, a very courageous book. ^ The main interest of the poor is that as large a proportion as possible of the national wealth should be converted into capital, or, in other words, diverted from unproductive to productive channels. Wealth in the form of diamonds or gold ornaments, retained only for ostentation, has no effect upon wages. Wealth expended in feasts or pageants does undoubtedly directly benefit those who furnish them, but is of no ultimate good to the community, because the jDurchased article perishes unproductively by the use. Were the sums expended in these ways devoted to productive sources, they would, after each such employment, be reproduced, and become again available for the purposes of society ; and those who now gain their living in supplying what is useless to mankind would betake themselves to the enlarged field of pro- ductive enterprise. But this train of reasoning should be corrected by the following considerations : 1st. Wealth is a mean, and not an end, its end being happiness ; and therefore mere accumulation, with no further object, is plainly irrational. Some modes of expenditure (such as public amusements), which rank very low indeed when judged by one test, rank very high when judged by the other. The intensity, and the wide diffusion of enjoyment they pro- duce, compensate for their transience. 2d. There is such a thing as imma- terial production. Expenditure in the domain of art or science, which adds nothing to the material wealth of the community, may not only produce enjoyment, but may become the source of enjoyment and improvement foi 344 NATIONALISM EST ErEOPE. are identical in such a sense that the -wages of the workman and the profits of his employer must rise and fall together, the fact being rather the reverse. Nor, again, that a gov- ernment is altogether impotent in regulating the distribution of vrealth, for the laws of succession and the direction given to taxation have in this respect a gigantic influence. What, however, it does j)rove is, that the wages of the labourer de- pend so necessarily upon the proportion between the sum that is provided for the payment of labour, and the number of those among Avhomi it is divided, that all direct eftbrts of the government to cause the permanent elevation of wages are, in the end, prejudicial to the very class they' are intend- ed to benefit. It proves that the material prosperity of the working classes depends upon the increase of cajjital being more rapid than that of population, and that this can only be ensured, on the one hand, by the continence of the labourer guarding against excessive multiplication, and, on the other hand, by the fullest encouragement of production, which im- plies the i^erfect protection of caj^italists ; for he who has no assurance that he may retain what he has accumulated, will cither never accumulate, or will conceal his property unpro- ductively. In other words, political economy demonstrates, beyond the possibility of doubt, that if the property of the rich were confiscated and divided among the poor, the meas- all future time. 3d. The great incentive to production is the desire to rise to the higher ranks, and the great attraction of those ranks to the majority of men is the ostentation that accompanies them; so that that expenditure which directly is unproductive may indirectly be highly productive. Besides this, we should consider the effects of sudden outbursts of luxury at different periods of history and its different influences upon morals. So stated, the question of the most advantageous expenditure is extremely complicated, and varies much with different circumstances. As a general rule, however, politi cal economy tends to repress the luxury of ostentation. THE ENDUSTEIAL niSTORT OF RATIONALISM, 345 ure would in the end be the most fearful catastrophe that could befall the latter. This great truth, that, in a financial point of view, with a very few exceptions, each nation, trade, or profession is in- terested in the prosperity of every other, has been growing clearer and clearer with each new develoiDinent of political economy,^ and cannot fail to exercise a vast moral influence upon society. For though concurrence of action based solely upon community of interests, considered in itself, has no moral value, its effect in destroying some of the principal causes of dissension is extremely important. And, indeed, human nature is so constituted, that it is impossible for bodies of men to work together under the sense of a com- mon interest Avithout a warm feeling of amity arising be- tween them. Common aims and hopes knit them together by a bond of sympathy. Each man becomes accustomed to act with a view to the welfare of others, and a union of af- fections usually replaces or consecrates the union of interests. The sentiment thus evoked is undoubtedly a moral senti- ment ; and if it is not so powerful as that whicb is elicited by agencies apiDealing directly to enthusiasm, it is more gen- eral, more uniform, and perhaps, on the whole, not less bene- ficial to mankind. It would be easy to show that political economy, by re- vealing the true causes of national prosperity, has effected, or is effecting, a considerable alteration in many of our moral judgments. Such, for example, is the change in the relative * At least till Say, whose TMorie des DihoucMs (directed against the notion of a ' universal glut,' which was maintained in Tranche by Sismondi and in England by Malthus) may be regarded as the highest demonstration of the truth. The first writer who intimated the identity of the interests of nations engaged in commerce was probably Dudley Forth, in his famous work on commerce, published in 1691. 346 RATIONALISM IN EUEOPE. position in the moral scale of prodigality and avarice, of youttful indiscretions, and of imprudent marriages ; and such too are the important modifications introduced into the conception of charity by the Avritings of Defoe, of Ricci, and of Malthus. It will, however, he sufficient for my present purpose, to indicate the predominating hias which these speculations produce, in order to ascertain the class of opinions and the tone of philosophy they are most likely to flivour. On this point there can be little doubt. It has been again and again recognised that political economy represents the extreme negation of asceticism. What may be termed the ascetic and the industrial phi- losophies have at all times formed two of the most important divisions of human opinions ; and as each brings with it a vast train of moral and intellectual consequences, their his- tory touches almost every branch of intellectual progress. The watchword of the first philosophy is mortification ; the watchword of the second is development. The first seeks to diminish, and the second to multiply, desires ; the first, ac- knowledging happiness as a condition of the mind, endeavours to attain it by acting directly on the mind, the second by act- ing on surrounding circumstances. The first, giving a great- er intensity to the emotions, j^roduces the most devoted men ; the second, regulating the combined action of society, produces the highest social levch The first has proved most congenial to the Asiatic and Egyptian civilisations, and the second to the civilisations of Europe. From the beginning of the fourth century, when the mo- nastic system was first introduced from Egypt into Christen- dom,^ until near the Reformation, the ascetic theory was ' The Therapeutes mentioned by Pliilo {De VitA ContanplativA) were probably pagans ; and, indeed, in Asia and Africa the monastic type haa THE ESfDUSTEIxVL HISTORY CF EATIONALISM. 347 everywhere predominant. The movement that was provoked by the examples of St. Anthony and St. Pachomius, and hy the writings of St. Jerome and St. Basil, received its full or- ganisation about two centuries later from St. Benedict. The Crusades and St. Bernard produced the military orders ; the teaching of St. Bruno, the Carthusians ; the religious struggle of the thirteenth century, the Franciscans, Dominicans, and Cai'melites ; ^ tlie conflict of the Reformation, the Theatines and the Jesuits. With the exception of the last century, during which some opposition had arisen to the monks, this long space of time represents the continuous elevation of the ascetic principle as the sui^reme type with which all forms of heroism naturally assimilated or coalesced. If we compare this period with the last three centuries, the contrast is very evident. Formerly, asceticism represent- ed the highest point of moral dignity, and in exact proportion as a society was stimulated towards its conception of excel- lence the monasteries were multiplied. At present, the abo- lition of monasteries is an invariable concomitant of an ad- vancing civilisation, the immediate consequence of every im- portant movement of national progress. Protestantism was the first great protest against asceticism ; but the process of confiscation which it initiated in the sixteenth century, and which was then regarded as the most liorrible sacrilege, has always existed, and has assumed forms very similar to that among Christians. The horrible macerations of the Buddhists rival those of any Christian sect, and the antipathy to the fair sex is nearly as great among the pagan as among the Christian anchorites. Some pagan religionists of Siam made it a rule never to keep hens, because those animals are of the female sex. (Bayle, Kouvelhs Leitres, lettre xxi.) Some Christians of Syria, with equal wisdom, resolved never to eat the flesh of any female animal. (IbUI.) ' The Carmelites had existed before upon Mount Carmel, and had even traced their origin to the prophet Elijah ; but they were transferred to Europe, • reorganised, and greatly multiplied in the thirteenth century. 348 RATIONALISM IX EUROPE. since been imitated by almost every Catliolic government in Europe. Not only France, at a time when she had repu- diated Catholicism, but even Austria and Spain have pursued this course. No less than 184 monasteries were suppressed, and ecclesiastical property to the value of more than two millions of florins confiscated, by Joseph II. of Austria: 3,000 monasteries are said to liave been suppressed in Eu- rope between 1830 and 1835 ; 187 in Poland, in 1841.' And these acts, as well as those which have recently taken place in Italy, have been, for the most part, elicited by no scandals on the part of the monks, but were simply the expression of a public opinion whicli regarded the monastic life as essen- tially contemptible and disgraceful. Of this industrial civilisation, political economy is the in- tellectual expression ; and it is not too much to say, that it furnishes a complete theory of human progress directly op- posed to the theory of asceticism. According to its point of view, the basis of all intellectual and social development is wealth ; for as long as men are so situated that all are obliged to labour for their sustenance, progress is impossible. An accumulation of capital is therefore the first step of civ- ilisation, and this accumulation depends mainly on the mul- tiplication of wants. /When the inhabitants of any country are contented with what is barely sufficient for the support of life, they will only perform the minimum of labour ; they will make no steady and sustained efforts to ameliorate their condition, and, as they will j)lace little or no restraint upon multiplication, their numbers increasing more rapidly than the means of sustenance, the most frightful suffering must ensue. To raise that people from its barbarism, the first es- sential is to make it discontented with its condition, As ' iTontalembert, Moines cP Occident^ Introd. pp. 199, 200. THE INDUSTRIAL HISTOEY OF EATIONALISM. 349 Boon as the standard of its necessities is raised, as soon as men come to regard as necessaries a certain measure of tlie comforts of life, habits of parsimony and self-restraint will be formed, and material progress will begin. But it is im- possible for men by these means to satisfy their wants. The horizon of their ambition continually recedes. Each desire that is accomplished produces many others, and thus new ex- ertions are elicited, and the constant development of society secured./ In the atmosphere of luxury that increased wealth produces, refined tastes, perceptions of beauty, intellectual aspirations appear. Faculties that were before dormant are evoked, new directions are given to human energies, and, under the impulse of the desire for wealth, men arise to sup- ply each new want that wealth has produced. Hence, for the most part, arise art, and literature, and science, and all the refinements and elaborations of civilisation, and all the inventions that have alleviated the sufferings or multiplied the enjoyments of mankind. And the same principle that creates civilisation creates liberty, and regulates and sustains .morals. The poorer classes, as wealth, and consequently the demand for their labour, have increased, cease to be the help- less tools of their masters. Slavery, condemned by political economy, gradually disappears. The stigma that attached to labour is removed. War is repressed as a folly, and des- potism as an invasion of the rights of property. The sense of common interests unites the dififerent sections of mankind, and the conviction that each nation should direct its energies to tliat form of produce for which it is naturally most suited, efl'ects a division of labour which renders each dciieudent upon the others. Under the influence of industrial occu- pations,, passions are repressed, the old warlike habits are destroyed, a respect for law, a consideration for the interests 350 EATIONAI.ISM IN EUEOPE, of otliers, a sobriety and perseverance of character are incul- cated. Integrity acquires a new value, and dissipation a new danger. The taste is formed to appreciate the less intense but more equable enjoyments, and the standard of excel- lence being rectified by the measure of utility, a crowd of imaginary virtues and vices which ignorance had engendered pass silently away. This, or something like this, is the scheme of progress which political economy reveals. It differs essentially from the schemes of most moralists in the fact that its success de- pends not upon any radical change in the nature of mankind, not upon any of those movements of enthusiasm which are always transient in their duration and restricted in their sphere, but simply ujDon the diffusion of knowledge. Taking human nature with all its defects, the influence of an enlight- ened self-interest, first of all upon the actions and afterwards upon the character of mankind, is shown to be sufficient to construct the whole edifice of civilisation ; and if that prin- ciple were withdrawn, all would crumble in the dust. The emulations, the jealousies, the conflicting sentiments, the insatiable desires of mankind, have all their place in the economy of life, and each successive development of human . progress is evolved from their play and from their collision. When therefore the ascetic, proclaiming the utter depravity of mankind, seeks to extirpate his most natural passions, to crush the expansion of his faculties, to destroy the versatility of his tastes, and to arrest the flow and impulse of his nature, he is striking at the very force and energy of civilisation. Hence the dreary, sterile torpor that characterised those ages in which the ascetic principle has been supreme, while the 3ivilisations which have attained the highest perfection have THE INDUSTEIAL HISTORY OF EATIONALIS^r. 351 been those of ancient Greece and modern Europe, Avhich were most opposed to it. It is curious to observe by what very different processes the antipathy to asceticism was arrived at in these two periods. In the first it is to be ascribed mainly to the sense of the harmony of complete development, and above all to the passionate admiration of physical beauty which art con- tributed largely to sustain. The statues of tlie most lovely were then placed among the statues of the goddesses, and the athletic games made the symmetry and beauty of the manly frame the highest type of perfection. ' A perfect mind in a perfect body ' was the ideal of the philosopher, and the latter was considered almost a condition of the former. Harmo- nious sustained manhood, without disproportion, or anomaly, or eccentricity — that godlike type. in which the same divine energy seems to thrill with equal force through every faculty of mind and body, the majesty of a single power never de- ranging the balance or impairing the symmetry of the whole, was probably more keenly appreciated and more frequently exhibited in ancient Greece than in any succeeding civilisa- tion. Among the moderns, on the other hand, the law of development has been much more social than individual, and depends, as we have seen, on the growth of the industrial element. If we examine the history of the last few cen- turies, since the Italian republics revived commerce on a large scale, or since the Portuguese for the first time founded a great colonial empire in the interests of industrial enter- prise,' we find that these interests have been steadily beconi- ' Among the ancients, the Phoenician colonies, and a few others of less importance, were no doubt commercial ; but the immense majority were due either to tlie love of migration natural to a barbarous people, or to an excess 352 PvATIONALISM IN EUROPE. ing supreme in all war, legislation, and diplomacy, and that ihe pliilosophy of utility, which is the most faithful expres- sion of the industrial spirit, has attained a corresponding place in the sphere of thought. It is supported by the as- cendency of the inductive philosophy, which has always con- centrated its efforts chiefly on material advantages. It is sup- ported by the rapid diffusion through all classes of habits of thought derived from political life, which is the consequence of the extension of political liberty. It is supported too by the investigations of those great moralists who since Cum- berland have been mainly emjoloyed in proving that virtue is a condition of happiness, from which men have illogically, but not unnatui-ally, inferred, that that which has no utility can have no moral value.' The immense importance of utilitarianism in correcting the evils of fanaticism, in calling into action the fliculties which asceticism had petrified, and in furnishing a simple, universal principle of life, has been clearly shown. Its capa- bility of coalescing with received theological doctrines can hardly be doubtful to those who remember that Paley made it tlie corner-stone of his moral philosophy, maintaining that a hope of future reward was the natural jirinciple of virtue. Indeed, one of the few political economists who have endeav- of population, or to a desire when vanquished to escape servitude, or to a fear of invasion, or to the spirit of conquest. The substitution of the industrial for the military colonial system is one of the important changes in history, and on the whole, perhaps, it cannot be better dated than from the Portu- guese colonial empire, which Yasco da Gama founded, and Albuquerque con- solidated. ^ A great political economist, in a work which has now become very rare, says, ' Toute vertu qui n'a pas I'utilite pour objet immediat me parait futile, ridicule, pareille h cette perfection de Talapoin qui consiste a se tenir sur un seul pied plusieurs annees de suite, ou dans quelque autre mortification nuisi- ble h lui-meme, inutile aux autres, et que son Dieu meme doit regarder en pitie.' (J. B. Say, Olbie, p. 81.) THE IXDUSTKIAL HISTOEY CF EATIONALISM. 353 oured to give their science a theological complexion, has argued that the laws of economical and of religious progress are identical, being self-denial for an end/ At the same time, the defects of such a system are sufficiently manifest, and they are in a great measure also the defects of rational- ism. Utility is, perhaps, the highest motive to which reason can attain. The sacrifice of enjoyments and the endurance of sufferings become rational only when some compensating advantage can be expected. The conduct of that Turkisli atheist,^ who, beliving that death was an eternal sleep, re- fused at the stake to utter the recantation which wonld save his life, replying to every remonstrance, 'Althongh there is no recompense to be looked for, yet the love of trutli con- straineth me to die in its defence,' in the eye of reason is an inexplicable folly ; and it is only by appealing to a far higher faculty that it appears in its true light as one of the loftiest forms of virtue. It is from the moral or religious faculty alone that we obtain tlie conception of the purely disinter- ested. This is, indeed, the noblest thing we possess, the celestial spark that is within us, the impress of the divine image, the principle of every heroism. Where it is not developed, the civilisation, however high may be its general average, is maimed and mutilated. In the long series of transformations we have reviewed, there are two which have been eminently favourable to this, the lieroic side of human nature. The substitution of the philosophical conception of truth, for its own sake, for the theological conception of the guilt of error, has been in this respect a clear gain ; and the political movement which has resulted chiefly from the introduction of the spirit of rational- ' Perin, La Ulc/iesse dans !es Sociefes Chretienncs. 2 Mahomet Effendi. See Bayle, Pcmees Divases, % 182. VOL. II. — 49 354 RATIONALISM IN EUROPE. ism into politics, has produced, and is producing, some of the most splendid instances of self-sacrifice. On the whole, how- ever, it can hardly be douhtcd, that the general tendency of these influences is unfavourable to enthusiasm, and that both in actions and in speculations this tendency is i^ainfully visi- ble. With a far higher level of average excellence than in former times, our age exhibits a marked decline in the spirit of self-sacrifice, in the appreciation of the more poetical or religious aspect of our nature. The history of self-sacrifice during the last 1800 years, has been mainly the history of the action of Christianity upon the world. Ignorance and error have, no doubt, often directed the heroic spirit into wrong channels, and have sometimes even made it a cause of great evil to mankind ; but it is the moral type and beauty, the enlarged conceptions and persuasive power of the Christian faith, that have chiefly called it into being, and it is by their influence alone that it can be permanently sustained. The power of Christianity in tliis respect can only cease wnth the annihilation of the moral nature of mankind ; but there are periods in which it is comparatively low. The decay of the old spirit of loyalty, the destruction of asceticism, and the restriction of the sphere of charity, which has necessarily resulted from the increased elaboration of material civilisa- tion, represent successive encroachments on the field of self- sacrifice which have been very imperfectly compensated, and have given our age a mercenary, venal, and unheroic charac- ter, that is deeply to be deplored. A healthy civilisation implies a double action — the action of great bodies of men moving Avith the broad stream of their age, and eventually governing their leaders ; and the action of men of genius or heroism upon the masses, raising them to a higher level, sup- plying them with nobler motives or more comprehensive THE INDUSTRIAL HISTORY OF RATIONALISM. 355 principles, and modifying, though not altogether directing, the general current. The first of these forms of action is now exhibited in great perfection. The second has but little influence in practice, and is almost ignored in speculation. The gradual evolution of societies, the organised action of great communities under the impulse of utilitarian mctives, is admirably manifested; but great individualities act seldom and feebly upon the world. At the same time, the history of speculative philosophy exhibits a corresponding tone. There has always been an intimate connection between utilitarianism and those systems of metaphysics which great- ly restrict and curtail the original powers of our nature, regarding the liuman mind as capable only of receiving, arranging, and transforming ideas that come to it from with- out. Those who hold that all our ideas are derived from sensation, will always, if they are consistent, make utility the ultimate principle of virtue, because by their system they can never rise to the conception of the disinterested;^ and, on the other hand, it will be usually found that the sensual school and the materialism which it has produced, have arisen in periods when the standard of motives w^as low, and when heroism and pure enthusiasna had but little influence. In our present absolute ignorance of the immediate causes of life, and of the nature and limits of mind and matter, this consideration furnishes perhaps the most satisfactory argu- ments in favour of spiritualism ; and it is as an index of the moral condition of the age that the prevalence of either spiiitualism or materialism is especially important. At pres ' As Madame de Stael said, ' La morale fondee sur I'interet, si fortement prechee par les ccrivains fran9ais du dernier siecle, est dans une connexion intime avec la metaphysique qui attribue toutes nos idees a des sensations' [L" Allemciffne). I believe all who are conversant with the history of philoso- phy will acknowledge this to be profoundly true. 356 KxVTIONALISM IN EUROPE. ent, the tendency towards the latter is too manifest to escape the notice of any attentive observer. That great reaction against the materialism of the last centnry, which was represented by the ascendency of German and Scotch philosoj^hies in England, and by the revival of Cartesianisni in France, which i:)roduced in art a renewed admiration for Gothic architecture ; in literature, the substitution of a school of poetry appealing powerfully to the passions and the imagination, for the frigid intellectualisra of Pope or of Voltaire ; and in religion, tlie deep sense of sin, displayed in different forms both by the early Evangelicals and by the early Tractarians, is everywhere disappearing. In England, the philosophy of experience, j^tished to the extremes of Hume, and represented by the ablest living philosopher in Europe, has been rising with startling rapidity to authority and has now almost acquired an ascendency in speculation. In France, the reaction against spiritualism and the tendency towards avowed materialism, as represented by the writings of Comte,^ of Renan, and of Taine, are scarcely less powerful than at the close of the last century; while, under the guid- ance of Schoppenhauer and of Buchner, even Germany itself. ' It is indeed true, that a first principle of the Positive school is the asser- tion that the limit of human faculties is the study of the successions of phe- nomena, and that we are therefore incapable of ascertaining their causes ; and M. Littre, in his j^reface to the recent edition of Gomte's works, has adduced this principle to show that Positivism is unaffected by arguments against materialism. As a matter of fact, however, the leading Positivists have been avowed materialists ; the negation of the existence of metaphysics as a science distinct from physiology, which is one of their cardinal doctrines, implies, or all but implies, materialism ; and the tendency of their school has, I think, of late years been steadily to substitute direct negations for scepticism. There are some good remarks on this in a very clear and able little book, called Le Matcrialisme Contemporaine^ by Paul Janet, a writer on whom (since Saisset died) the defence of Spiritualism in France seems to have mainly devolved. THE INDUSTRIAL IIISTOKY OF RATIONALISM. 357 SO long the chosen seat of metaphysics, is advancing with no faltering steps in the same career. This is the shadow resting npon the otherwise brilliant picture the history of Rationalism presents. The destruction of the belief in witchcraft and of religious persecution, the decay of those ghastly notions concerning future punish- ments, which for centuries diseased the imaginations and embittered tlie character of mankind, the emancipation of suffering nationalities, the abolition of the belief in the guilt of error, which paralysed the intellectual, and of the asceti- cism which paralysed the material, progress of mankind, may be justly regarded as among the greatest triumphs of civili- sation ; but when we look back to the cheerful alacrity with Avhich, in some former ages, men sacrificed all their material and intellectual interests to what they believed to be right, and w^hen we realise the unclouded assurance that was their reward, it is impossible to deny that we have lost something in our progress. ^ IE"© E X ABELARD, standard of impartial ii phy planted by, i. 71 Aberdeen, In.iunction of the synod of, re- specting -witches, i. 145 Abgarus, l^ina; of Edessa, portrait and letter of Christ to, i. 229 Abimelech, Bossuet on the name, ii. ISl note Abyssians, their superstitions respecting potters and blacksmiths, i. 9S note Acontius (Acanacio), his life and writings, ii. 57 note Actors, stigma attached to them in ancient times, Ii. 288, 290, 806. Attempts of Ne- ro to relieve them, 288 note. The actor Aliturus and the actress Encharis, 288 note. St. Genetus, the patron saint of actors, 290 note. Actors, how regarded by the Ohurch, 804. The sacraments de- nied to them, 306, 307. The stigma upon actors removed in a great degree by Vol- taire, 309. Removal of their disqualifica- tions by the French Revolution, ii. 809 Adam, the sin of, according to the Cabalists, i. 67 note Adonis, Greek statues of, i. 243 Adrian VI., Pope, his bull against witch- craft, i. 82 jEons, origin of the central doctrine of the, of the Gnostics, i. 46 7iote Aerolites probably worshipped in ancient Greece, i. 243 Agobard, St., archbishop of Lyons, opposes the popular belief in sorcery, i. 65, 66. His fcll'orts in dispelling superstition, 231. His work denouncing the idolatry of im- ago worship, 232 Asricultiu-al interests, their conflict with manufacturing interests, ii. 328. Mediae- val preference for agriculture, 824. The superior productivity of agriculture as- serted hv Adam Smith, but refuted by l£icardo,"830, 381 Agvippa, Cornelius, regarded as a sorcerer, i. 109. Notice of his career, 110 note AKf>6\i6oi, the ancient Greek wooden statues with marble heads so called, i. 242 note Albigenses, massacre of the, in the twelfth century, i. 71. Success of persecution shown in the case of the, ii. 14. Period of the massacre, 80. The crime instigated by a pope, 45 Alcazar of Seville, architectural beauties of the, i. 286 Alexander II., Pope, his liberality to the Jews, ii. 264 Alexander III., Pope, confirms the 'Truce of God ' as a general law of the Church, ii. 108 7iote Alexander IV., Pope, his bull confiscating the goods of heretics, ii. 44 note Alexander VI., Pope, his liberality to the Jews, ii. 264 note Alexander VII., Pope, on money-lending, ii. 248 note Alexandria, the introduction of pictures forbidden by some Christians of, into their churches, i. 233 Alexandrian or Neo-Platonic school, its theories, i. 46. Its influence over early Christianity, 46 note Alhambra, character of the ornamentation of the, i. 280 note Aliturus, the Jewish actor, ii. 2SS note Allegiance, Oath of, despotic maxims em- bodied in the. ii. 177. Abolition of this clause, 177 note Ambassadors, probable origin of resident, ii. 2S1 Ambrose, St., miracle related of, i. 95. His protest against the execution of some heretics, ii. 38 America, cases of witchcraft in, in the sev- enteenth century, i. 137. Protestant per- secutions of the Catholics and Quakers in, ii. 49. Slavery in, compared with that of the Greeks and Romans, 225 Amsterdam, one great cause of its pros- perity, ii. 273 Amulets, value attributed by fetishism to, i. 206 Amnio, archbishop of Lyons, his view of Gotteschalk's opinions 'as to double pre- destination, i. 385 note Amusements^ public, influence of wealth and luxviry upon the character of, ii. 285 Anabaptists, persecution of, in England, un- der Queen Elizabeth, ii. 47. " And in Switzei-land, 49. Position assigned to them by Bossuet, 60. Their notion of the sleep of the soul between death and liids-ment, 79 note. Calvin's book against 'it, 79 note 3G0 Anresthcsia, a sj'mptom of some of the forms of madness, i. 124 Ancyra, Council of, condemns the belief in lycanthropy, 1. 96 Angel, St. Ailgustine on the meaning of the word, i. 47 note. Pagan genii identified with guardian angels, 215. One assigned by the Talmud to every star and every element, 289. This notion represented in old Christian painting and sculpture, 289 note. Gradual decline of this belief, 289. Angels univer.sally believed to have co- habited with the daughters of the ante- diluvians, 843 Jnsclico, Fra, his character and that of his works, i. 246 Anglicanism, the old Puritan's description of, ii. 47 note. Servility and enmity of, to public libcrtv, 174. Lord Macaulay on the siil'i-rt (|iio)rd, 114: note. 'Homilies on A^ilfiil lolHlli.m' quoted, 174. Every renctinii siipiinited hy it. 177. Excep- tional position of Hooker, 178. Predispo- sition of Anglicanism towards despotism, ISO. Anglican notions on allegiance to the sovereign de facto, 1S3 note. Its treatment of the theatre, 811 Anglo-Saxons, their measures for alleviating the condition of slaves, ii. 231 Animals, belief in the connection between evil spirits and, i. 95. Use made of ani- mals in Christian symbolism, 95 note. Ascription of intelligence to animals in the middle ages, 96 note. Mystic ani- mals among the Celts, 96 note. Innkeep- ers who -were said to have turned their guests into animals. 97 note. The higher forms of animal beauty appreciated by the Greek sculptors, 239 note. Descartes' doctrine of animals, i. 346 note. Stahl founds the psychology of animals, 346 note Antony, St., miracles related of. i. 156, 157 Anthropomorphism, the second stage of re- ligious belief, i. 207. The government of the universe then ascribed by men to be- ings like themselves, 207. IJut, unable to concentrate their attention on the Invisi- bls, they fall into idolatry, 208. Progress of anthropomorphism, 217. Conclusion of the anthropomorphic impulse shown hy St. Peter's at Rome, 267 Antiphons, legendary origin of, ii. 800 Antipodes, controversy in the early Church as to the existence of the, i. 275. Correct doctrine stumbled upon by the Manichffi- ans, 275. Existence of the Antipodes de- nied by the Fathers, 275, 276. And by Cosmas in his 'Topographia Christiana",' 276. Their existence asserted by St. Vir- gilius, 280 Apelles, painted Lais, i. 254 Apocalyptic subjects in Christian art, 1. 249 Apollo, in Greek statues, the tvpe of male beauty, i. 243 Apparitions, the belief ':n, one of the corner- stones of the pisychology of the Fathers, i. 341. Predisposition of the Greeks to see ghosts, 341 note. Apparitions seen by the ancients, 342 Apples, the supposed especial power of the ■Jovil over. i. GO note Aquatic deity, pagan representation of an, adopted by Christian art, i. 214 Aquinas, St. Thomas, his belief in the power of the devil, i. 88. On the connection be- tween spirits and animals, 97 note. On infant baptism. 361 note. His notion of the locality of hell, 346 note. His re- marks in favour of ]KT^:ecution, ii. 12. His assertic'U 2. His remarks on the Jews, 265. His -Hislriones' quoted, 292 ami note , Arabs, influence pf their workn on the intel- lectual energies of Christendom, ii. 284 Arcadius, the emperor, suppresses the works of Eunomius, ii. 118 Archers, English, their skill, ii. 205 Architecture, the only form of art open to the Mahometans, i. 286. The Alhambra and Alcazar of Seville, 286. The works of Greek architects at Eavenna, Yenice, &c., 246. Introduction of the form of the cross in the ground plan of churches, 250 note. Transition which took place in ai-chitec- ture, 262. Period of the origin of Gothic architecture, 262. Fitness of Gothic as Christian architecture, 263. Hutchinson on the causes of the ancient preference of Gothic to Eoman architecture, 264 note. Style altered by Brunelleschi, 265. Su- periority of Gothic architecture for dis- tances, and its influence on the stage, ii. 802 Arians, ascendency of the, in the East, in the reign of Valens, i. 57. Their persecu- tions, ii. 22. Intolerance cf the Spanish Arians, 22 note. Persecuted by Constan- tine. 23. Persecutions of, under Elizabeth, ii. 51 Aristocratical system, its influence in con- solidating the doctrine of hereditary mer- it, i. 358 Aristotle, his position in the Church in the middle ages owing to the early heretics, i. 380 note. His views respecting the exer- cise of mechanical arts, ii. 224. And re- specting slavery, 225. On the sterility of money, 251 Arras, trials at, in 1459, 1. 28 note Art, the most faithful expression of religious realisation, during the continuance of idolatry, i. 209. Influence of the national religions on the art of the ancients, 209. The art of the Catacombs, and its freedom from idolatry, 211. Efleet of Pagan tradi- tions upon Christian art, 210. Its freedom from terrorism in early times, 212. Its great love of S3Tnbolism, 213. Symbol of the peacock. 213. And of Orpheus, 214. Examples of the introductien of pagan gods into Christian art, 214 note. Masks of the sun and moon as emblems of the resurrection, 214. The Pagan genii of the seasons as guardian angels, 215. The symbol of the fish (^x^vs), 215. And of the stag. 215. Other subjects taken from Old Testament symbols, 216. Causes of the growing tendency to represent di- rectlv the object of worship, 216. Por- traits of God' the Father, 217. Materiali- sation of every- spiritual conception from the sixth to tlie twelfth centuries, 217, 361 Influence of Gnosticism over Christian art, 217. Progress of the representation of the Creator in ai-t, 219. Influence of the Apocryphal Gospels, 222. Probable Gnostic origin of the conventional cast of features ascribed to Christ, 222. Influence of painting and sculpture in strengthening Mariolatry, 225. Architecture the only- form of ai't open to the Mahometans, 236. Character of Christian art in the middle ages, 2.37. Gold and silver carving, and ivory diptychs, 237 note. Illumination of manuscripts, 237. Influence of medi.-?- val modes of thought upon art, 288 note. Period in which the ascetic ideal of ugli- ness was most supreme, 241 note. The Abbe Pascal on medieval art, 241 note. The work of Bishop Durandus, 241 note. Greek idolatry fading into art, 241. Its four stages, 242. A corresponding transi- tion in Christendom, 244. Greek influ- ence on Christian art, 244. In Italy, 244 note. Effects on art of the tradition of the personal def(>rmity of Christ, 245. The Byzantine style broken by a study of ancient Grwk sculpture, 246. Christian school of Giotto and Fra Angelico, 246. A general efflorescence of the beautiful pro- duced bv the revival of learning in Eu- rop>\ '2'T. AT-'v-ilvptie subioots, 249. Prn-v. - . <■ ^ r- !i-,ii 1,1 iirt, ^No. Itelig- ioii-- ! ', ' _ , _:n'^lc'l siiii|,h- :is studies oi\\\'- i'-:ii!ii,iil. _.".-'. C'aiiM'.s cii' this secu- larisation of ;u-t. -Ib-l. Influence upon art of sensuality, 254. And of oriental robes, 255 note, influence of the discovery of many great works of pagan sculpture, 25G. History of Greek art after the rise of Christianity, 257. The types of Chris- tian replaced by tho^e of Pagan art, 259. Reaction in favour of spiritualism led by Savonarola, 260.. Eapidity of the secular- isation of art after the death of Savonarola, 261. Never afterwards assumed a com- manding influence over the minds of men, 262. Transition which took place in arch- itecture, 262. Intellectual importance of the history of art, 26T Ascetism. ^^'e Monasticism A sscs, feast of, ii. 295. Origin of the, 296 note Astrologers, called Matheinatici, i. 65 note Astrology, revival of the passion for, in the middle ages, i. 70. M. Comte's remarks on, as a science, 2S4. Peter of Apono's at- tempt to construct a system of religions by the aid of, 284 note. Cardan and Van- iiii's horoscope of Christ, 2S4 note. Bodin on the influence of the stars over the de- velopment of societies, 284 Astronomony displaces the ancient notion of man's position in the universe, i. 283. Beauty of the suggestion of Dr. Chalmers respecting insignificance of the earth, 285 note. Views of the ancient astronomers as to the motion of the celestial bodies, 285 note. Cause of the growth of the science of astronomy, 288. Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, and Tycho Brahe, 288. Des- cartes' theory of vortices, 289. Comets, 290. Halley's prediction of their revolu- tion, 291. Laplace on the argument of design derived from the motions of the planetary bodies, 297 note Atheism, Glanpii's character of, in his time, i. 134 note. Loose senses in which the word atheism has been used. 134 note Atmospheric disturbances attributed to the power of the devil, and of witches, i. 91 Augury, bow punished by the Emperor ConstantiuE, i. 53 Augustine, St., on the meaning of the word angel, i. 47 note. Eegarded lycanthropy as a fable, 96, 97 note. On the miracles worked by the relics of St. Stephen, ITS note. His defence of the Genesis against the Maniehaeans, 273. Ilis opinion of the incorporeity of the soul, 812 7iote. His j-emarks on the existence of mice, 345 note. His view of infant baptism, 862. His views as to the condemnation of all external to the Church. 376. The theory of predei-tlnation siibslantfally held bv St. Augu>tine, i. :>:! The theology of persecution systcrnatised by him, ii. 29. Notice of bis ebaractc-r and" influence, 29, 80. His aversion to the efl^usion cf blood, 31. Condemns religious liberty, 82 note Authorit}-, examination of the basis or prin- ciple of, on which all political structures rest, ii. 136 Averroes, influence of, over the whole intel- lect of Europe, i. 71. Kenan's essay on, 71 note. Orgagna's picture of, at Pisa, 71 note. Impulse given to psychology by the school of, 843 Avitus, St., his verse on infant baptism quoted, i. 863 note Ayala, Balthazar, his defence of tyrannicide "under some circumstances, ii. 160 BACCHUS, in Greek statues, a type of disgraceful efleminncy, i. 248 Bacon, Lord, his view of witchcraft, i. 124. Influence of his philosophy on its decline, 128. On the cause of the paralysis of the human faculties in the middle' ages, 2S3. Enlightenment of bis age, 292 note. His inability to grasp the discoveries of the astronomers of his time, 292 note. Causes of his influence, 400, 401. Carpings of the Tractarian party at the inductive philoEO- phy of Bacon, 4"08-«o/e Bacon, Roger, his persecution, i. 282. In- fluence of Arabian learning over him, ii. 284 Bagpipes, praised by Julian in one of his e])igrams, i. 2G3 note Ballot, the, advocated by Harrington in the seventeenth centuiy. ii. 145 note Baltimore, Lord, upholds religious libcrtv, ii. 59 Bamberg, great number of \v itches burnt at, i. 29 Baptism, fetish notions in the early Church respecting the water of, i. 204. L^nanim- ity of the Fathers concerning the non- salvability of unbaptised infants, SCO. Opinion as to a special place assigned to unbaptised infants, 361. The ' baptism of blood,' and the 'baptism of perfect Icvc,' 860 note. Opinions of Pelagius, St. Au- gustine, Origen, and St Fulgentius, 862. Superstitious rites devised as substitutes for regular baptism, 864 note. Doctrijie of the Church ot Home as enunciated b.v bG2 the Council of Trent, 866. Conflicting tendencies on the subject produced by the Eeformation, 365. Effects of the Anabap- tist movement, 865. Cases of baptism by sand and wine, 366 note. Doctrines of the Lutherans and Calvinists, 36T. The doctrine of original sin rejected by Soci- nus, 372. By Zuinglius, 373. And by Chillingworth and Jeremy Taylor, 874 note Barbarians, conversion of the, causes Idol- atry to become general, i. 230 Barberini, Cardinal, his musical parties, il 803 note Barclay, "William, first denied the power of the Pope over tiie temporal possessions of princes, ii. 164 note. On lawful resistance to tyranny, ISl Baroni, Leonora, her singing, ii. 303 ftnte. Milton's Latin poems addressed to her, 30S vote Bartholomew, St., success of persecution shown in the case of the massacre of, ii. 14. Heaven thanked by a Pope for the massacre of, 45 Bartholomeo, Tra, influence oi Savonarola over him, i. 261 Basil, St., (ievotion of the monks of, to painting, ii. 232 Baxter, liichard, his defence of the persecu- tion of witches, i. 33, 126. His account of the death of Lowes, 126 note. His vain endeavours to revive the belief in witch- craft by accounts of witch trials in Ameri- ca, 138. His work answered by Hutchin- son, 139. His view of religious liberty, ii. 70 Bayle, his view of witchcraft, i. 116. His attempt to overcome the popular supersti- tions respecting comets, 291. His works, and those which best show his genius, 291 iiote. His remarks on the tendency of theologians to condemn error more se- verely than immorality, 815 note. His denunciation of torture, 833 -noie. The character of Bayle regarded as the scepti- cal scholar, ii. 64. His influence on relig- ious liberty in France, 64. His 'Con- trains-les d'entrer,' 64. Arguments by which his principles- were developed, 67, 63. His advocacy of the doctrine of pas- sive obedience, 212. The 'Avis aux Ec- fnaiez' ascribed to him, 212 noie Bayonet, importance of the invention of the, to democracy, 11. 207 Bear-baiting, iaot formerly regarded as in- human, i."307, 308 Bears, dancing, their connection with the devil, i. 96 note Beainnarchais, his charity, ii. 284 note Beauty, Greek worship of every order of, i. 239. Beauty of some of the higher forms of animal life, displayed in Greek sculp- ture, 239 7io/e. Departure of inodiseval nrt from the beautiful, 241. A general ef- florescence of the beautiful the" result of the revival of learning in Europe, 247. Influence of voluptuous beauty upon art, 256 note. The feeling of rever- ence gradually encroached upon and ab- sorbed by that of beauty, 268 Bccearia, his oopositioE to to-ture in Italv, 1. 3f 4 Becket, St. Thomas a, hymn on the Yirgiu ascribed to, quoted, i. 224 note Bedell, Bishop, respect with which he waa treated by the rebel Catholics, ii. 16. His life, by Alexander Clogy, 16 noie Beelzebub, regarded as the god of flies, i. 96 note Begards, sect of the, i. 344 Belgium, monkish origin of many of the towns of, ii. 232. First mercantile estab- lishments in, 281 Belief, religious, fetishism probably the first stage of, i. 204. Anthropomorphism the next stage, 207 Bcllarmine, Cardinal, one of his arguments in favour of persecution, ii. 28 note. His support of the Pope's right to depose sov- ereigns, 147. His work burnt in Paris, 147 Bells, church, supposed invention of, by Paulinus, i. 262 Benedict XIV., Pope, his definition of usury, ii. 247 note. His decree against it, 257 Benedictines, their services in making la- bour honourable, ii. 232 Bentham, Jeremy, his part in the movement for the mitigation of the severity of the penal code, i. 351. On usury, ii. 2.51 note. Gives the death-blow to the usury laws, 260 Berkeley, Bishop, helps by his writings the cause of toleration, ii. 77. His proposal to admit Catholics into a Protestant Uni- versity, 124 note. His sentiments on pas- sive obedience, 176 noie Bernard, St., his rejection of the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception, i. 225 7ioie Beronice, the name given by early Christian tradition to the woman healed of an issue of blood, i. 221 note. This woman one of the principal types among the Gnostics, 221 note Beza, on predestination, i. 387. Advocates the lawfulness of persecution, ii. 50. His answer to Castellio, 56 Biauchi, his work ' On Ecclesiasticil Power,' ii. 141 7ioie Bit)biena, Cardinal, his play of the 'Calan- dra,' ii. 299. Portraits of, by Pvaphael, 299 noie Biblical interpretation and criticism. See Scriptural Interpretation Bilson Bishop, his Apology for the policy of Queen Elizabeth towards the Catliolics, ii. 48 note. Maintains the sinfulness of toleration, 48 noie Binsfeldius, his opposition to the belief in Ivcanthropy, i. 98 noie Bishops, election of. in the early Church, ii. 140 Black death, a cause of the tendency tow- ards luxury, ii. 275 Blacksmiths, Abyssinian superstition re- specting, i. 98 note Blackwood, on lawful resistance to tyranny, ii. 180 Blanchot, Peter, his farce of ' Patelin,' '.I 297, £98 noie Bodin, John, his defence of the belief in witchcraft, i. 88. Testimonies to his mer- its as an historian, 107 noie. His ' Demon- omanie des 8i)rciers,' lOS. His indigna- tion at Wier's' sceptical, v.-ork 109, l!i; 3Go reference for the Old Testament, 151 note. His notion of the iniluence of the stars over the development of societies, 283 note. His study of the Eoman law, ii. 194. His view of the regal power, 194 Dody, the human, contrast between the pagan and Christian estimate of, i. 240 Boeotians, their dislike of commerce, ii. 224 Bog>iet, president of the tribunal of St. Claude, his executions for lycanthropy, i. 117 Bolingbroke, Lord, causes of the oblivion into which his works have passed, i. 190. Inimical to liberty, ii. 206 Bollandist, collection of Lives of the Saints, i. 15S note Bonaventura, St., his Psalter, in use at Eome, i. 227 note Boniface, St., bis attack on St. Yirgiiius, i. 290 Boots with pointed toes supposed to have been inoffensive to God, i. 73 Bossuet, attacks Zuinglius' notion of origi nal sin, i. 373 note. Asserts the doctrine of salvation only in the Church, 382. Position assisned'by him to Socinians and Anabaptists, ii. 60 Botticelli, the painter, influenced by Savon- arola, i. 261 Bourdeaux, De Lancre's suggestion as to the cause of witchcraft about, i. 30 note Brancas, Madame de, her performance of the character of Geometry, ii. 298 note Brephotrophia, or asylums for children, in the time of Justinian, ii. 233 Breccia, Inquisition riots in, ii. 117 Bridles, witches', or iron collars used for extorting confession, i. 146 note Broedersen, his work on usury, ii. 257 Browne, Sir Thomas, his belief in the exist- ence of witchcraft, i. 124 note, 129 Bruges, luxury of, in the fourteenth cen- tury, ii. 275 Erunelleschi, his influence on Italian arch- itecture, i. 265 Bruno, his philosophical speculations, i. 401. Burnt alive, 401 Bruyere, La, his opinions and influence on the subject of witchcraft, i. 116 Buchanan, George, his Protestant liberal- ism, ii. 171. His praise of the tyranni- cides of antiquity, 171, 172. Influence of his tract 'De Jure Kegni apud Scotos,' 17-2 Buckle, on the disbelief in witchcraft in England, i. 138. On the Scotch lieforma- tion, ii. 170 Bull-bating, not formerly regarded as in- human, i. 307. Its 'silent extinction amongst the upper classes. 309. De- fended by Canning and "Windham, 307 note. The unsuccessful warfare waged by the Popes against Spanish bull-fights, 308 note. Opposition of the Jesuit Mari.ana, 803 note. The great bull-fight of 1338 at Eome, 308 note Bullinger, his approval of the murder of Servetus, ii. 52 Burghers, privileges of, in the middle ages, 11.^239 note Burgos, miracle of the crucifix at. i. 157. Burnet. Bishcp, his liberalism, ii. 180 note Burt, Captain, on old women turning them- selves into cats, i. 148, note. His account of the belief in wtchcraft in Scotland in his time, 151 Butler, on eternal punishments, i. 838 CABALA, the Hebrew, 1. 67 note Cabalis, views of the, respecting de- mons, i. 49 note. Doctrines and beliefs of the, 66. The mystic union of Cabalis- tic philosophers and sylphs, 67 Cagliostro, the prophecies of, attributed to supernatural agency, i. 119 Cainits, their reverence for the opponents of the Jewish religion, i. 220 note Calahorra, witches put to death at, i. 37 note Calvin, John, his notions on witchcraft, i. 33 note. His view of inlant baptism, 367 note. His part in the Eucharistic contro- versy, 8T3. His view of the doctrine of salvation only for those in the Cliurch, 381. Advocates the lawfiiliios ot' ijcrsc- cution, ii. 50. Applauded tur iMirniiis; Servetus, 52. His ansAvci- to Cjstillio-s denunciation of predostiiiariaiiisni, .'",5. His book against the Anabaptists' notion of the sleep of the soul between death and judgment, 79 note. His inclination to the republican theory of government, 169. His views of money-lending, 256. His severity against the theatre. 310 note Canning, George, his defence of bull-baiting, i. mtnote Capel, Lord, his dying words on passive obedience, ii. 181 note Capital, the increase of, one of the circum- stances that prepared the demccracj' of the eighteenth century, ii. 201. Im])ort- ance to the poor of converting wealth into capital, 343 note Capital punishment, opposition of Bishop Berkeley to, i. 350. Beccaria advocated its abolition, 850 Cardan, his horoscope of Christ, 1. 284 note Carmagnola and the Italian condotlicri, ii. 206 Carmelites, their history, ii. 349 note Carthage, Council of, pronounces the dam- nation of the heathen, i. 377. Third and Fourth Councils of, condemn usury, ii. 247 note Carving on gold and silver, how preserved in the middle ages, i. 237 note. Carved ivory diptychs, 237 note Casaubon, Meric, his defence of the belief in the existence of withcraft, i. 136 Cassino, Monte, EchO(d of Greek mosaic artists established at, i. 237 Castanaga, a Spanish monk, questions the justice of executions for witchcraft, i. 37 note Castillio, his life and writings, ii. 53. His repudiation of predestinarianism, 53. De- nounces the murder of Servetus, 54. Answered by Calvin and Beza, 55. Epi- thets heaped upon him by Calvin, 55 note. His end, 56 Catacombs, tombs of the exorcists in the, i. 50 note. The art of the catacombs alto- gether removed from idolatry, 211. Only one or two representations of martyr- doms, 211. Svstematic exclusion of all 364 images of sorrow, suffering, and venge- ance, 212. Great love of symbolism evinced by the art of the catacombs. 213 Cathari, a sect of Gnostics, their efforts to subdue the propensities of the body, i. 240 Catholicism, Roman, traces of the com- promise between Christianity and Pagafi- ism in. i. 60. Identification of startling natural phenomena by the priests with acts of rebellion against themselves, 63. The continuance of miraculous power still maintained by the Church of liome, 155. But the sense of the miraculous on the decline among the great body of educated Catholics, 159, 162. nationalis- tic tendencies in Eoman Catholic coun- tries, 184. Eeflections on St. Peter's at Kome as a memorial of the decay of Ca- tholicism, 265. Torture employed by Catholics during the reign of Mary, 883 note. Doctrine of the Church of Kome respecting infant baptism as enunciated by the Council of Trent, 366. Early Ca- tholicism perfectly in accordance with the intellectual wants of Europe, ii. 86. Pe- riod when it became the principle of ret- rogression, 3S. And when coei-cion was matured, 88. Establishment of the In- quisition, massacre of the Albigenses, and injunction of the Fourth Council of the Latcran, 38. Atrocity of the persecution perpetrated by Catholicism, 40. A greater amount of unmerited suffering inflicted by the Church of Rome than by any oth- er religion that has ever existed, 46. Persecution of Catholics imder Elizabeth, 4T. Catholic and Protestant persecutions compared, 57. Growth of religious lib- erty in France always opposed by the Church, 74 Attempts of Lamennais to associate Catholicity with the movement of modern civilisation, 74. Catholicism proscribed by the English Common- wealth, 78. Milton's reasons for exclud- ing Catholics from toleration, 82. Period of the undisputed ascendency of Catholi- cism in Europe, 107. Catholic emancipa- tion, 123. Endowment of the college of Maynooth, 123. Proposal of Bishop Berkeley to admit Catholics into a Prot- estant lini versify, 123 note. Review of the Ultramontano party, 146. The works of Bcllarmlne and Suarcz burnt at Paris, 147. Teaehiug of French Catholicism as to the independence of the civil power, 166. In its earlier stage the Catholic Church the representative of progress, 203. Natural incapacity of Catholicism to guide the democratic movement in the eighteenth century, 211. Her im- placable enmity to toleration, 212. Effect of the prohibition of usury in Catholic countries, 253 note, Cato, his remai-k on celibacy, i. 99 Cats, old women turning themselves into, L 148 note, Causes, ultimate, failure of the mind of man in discovering, i. 297. Cavalry : change in the relative position of cavalry and i jfantry in war, ii. 205 Cecchino, the harlequin, notice of, ii. £97 noti Celibacy regarded as the highest form of virtue, i. 93. The old writers respecting women, 99. Influence of the celibacy of the monks in strengthening Mariolatry, 224 Cellini, Benvenuto, his combination of im- morality and piety, i. 391 Celso, Minos, his work attributed to Bolliu?, ii. 57 note Celts, their ascription of ihtelligence to animals, i. 96 note Censorship, abrogation of the, in England, ii. 87. A literary censorship directed against heretical writings after the aboli- tfon of punishment for heresy, IIS. Dio- cletian, Julian, Constantino, and Arcadius, 118. Beginning of licenses. 119. Convo- cation and the Star Chamber, 119 Cerebration, unconscious, instances of, ii 95, 96 note Ceres, in Greek statues, a type of summer and of maternal love, i. 243. Chalmers, Dr., his suggestion respecting the earth, i. 287 note Chance, games of, why prohibited, i. 287. Old opinions on the sub.iect of lots, 287 note. Gataker's work on the natural laws of lot, 287 note Charity of the early Christians, ii. 233. Long period that elapsed before it was ajipreciated, 235 Charlemagne, his stringent laws against sorcerers, i. 65. His contemptuous disre- gard of the decrees of the Second Coun- cil of Nice, 280 Charles V., Emperor, number of Dutch heretics put to death during his reign, ii. 41. Magnificent position of Spain under his government, 311. His employment of gold in his wars, 815. His dishonest tarripering with the coinage, 316 note Charles IX., of France, alleged cause of his early death, i. 110 Charms, reverence of, fetishism, i. 207 Charron, his famous treatise on ' Wisdom,' i. 115, 388 note. His denunciation of tor- ture in France, 338. His advocacy of the doctrine of passive obedience, ii. 212 Chemistry, its separation from alchemy, i. 292 Child, Sir Josiah, his defence of the mercan- tile system, ii. 327 note Chillingworth, William, causes of his join- ing the Church of Rome, i. ISO. Rejects original sin, 874 note. Helps by his writ- ing's the cause of toleration, ii. 77, 78 Chocolate, importation of, into Europe, ii, Christ, as represented in Christian art before and after the twelfth century, 1. 71. Early symbols of, 215. Probable Gnostic origin of the conventional cast of features ascrib- ed to Christ, 222. No authentic portrait of Christ in the time of St. Augustine, 223 note. The first notice in writing of the resemblance of Christ to his mother, 224 note. The image at Panceas, 229. Mosaic portrait preserved in the church of St. Praxede, at Kome, 237 note. The tradition of his deformity, 245. The forg- ed letter of Lentulus to the Roman Senate on his appearance. 245 note. Car- dan's horoscope of him, 2.'-4 note ;g5 Uhristianity: the early Christians in the Ivoman empire, i. 44. Paganism, how re- garded by them, 45. Influence of the Alexandrian or Neo-Platonic school over them, 46 note. Exorcists among thom, 49, 156 note. Terror which the doctrine of demons mnst have spread among them, 50. The title 'enemies of the human race' transferred from the Christians to the magicians. 54. Magical character at- tributed to Christian rites, 55. The mir- acle of St. Hilarion, 55, 56. Policy of the early Christians towai'ds the magicians, 59. Compromise between Christianity .ind Paganism, 60. Change in the twelfth century in the popular teaching, 73. In- fluence of rationalism on Christianity, 199. Examples of fetish notions in the early Church, 204. Singularly touching and sublime character of the early Church, 212. Its symbolism as evinced in early Christian art, 213. Triumph of Christian- ity by absorbing and transforming old systems rather than annihilating them, • 223. Distinctive type and tone of Chris- tianity banished from art, and replaced by types of paganism, 259. Originality of the moral type of Christianity, 811. Peal character and test of the Christian religion, 329. Boundless philanthropy of modern Christianity, 348. The sense of sin ap- pealed to most strongly by Christianity, 356. First congelation of the moral sen- timents of Christianity into an elaborate theology, 856. Belief "of the early Church that all external to Cliristinnity wore doomed to damnation, 30o. Triuiiiph of Christianity in the Poman empire ou the cohdition of transforming itself under the influence of the spirit of sect, ii. Ifit!. Passive obedience of the e.-a-ly Christians, 137, 140. Synthesis of the moral prin- ciples of Christianity and Paganism, 220. Christianity the most effective opponent of the evil of slavery, 229. The ferocity of manners corrected by the creation of Christian charity, 232. Long period that elapsed before the preeminent services of Christian charity were appreciated, 285. Great developm'ent of self-sacrifice by Christianity, 237. Position of public amusements in the early history of Chris- tianity, 2S9 Chrysostom, St., on women, i. 99 Church and State theory, the, in England and France, ii. 121 Church, Dr. Thomas, his answer to Middle- ton's attack on the veracity of the Fa- thers, i. 173 Cicero, his idea of the soul, i. 840 Cimabue, ioy of the Florentines at one of his pictures of the Virgin, i. 268 Cimento, Aocademia del, establishment of the, in Tuscany, i. 292 (/ivcumcelliouos, their turbulence, and per- 5c-eutii)U by Constantine. ii. 28 C'vilisation, effect of, in destroying the be- lief in the miraculous, i. 102. Its power on contemporary as compared with his- torical miracles, 162 Classical writings, action of the revival of the, on liberty, ii. 193. In altering the type of heroism, 195. Attempts to mould them into the imago of the medi.-e- val conceptions, 198. This tendency ridiculed by Ulrieh von Hutten and Eabe- lii-. in . ,',.'/,. i;il._M;t of the revival of ' : -'' I i ; nil;- i]| lun'ope, 285 <' 1 .I'll iiu to all forms of per- -■'■Mii-ii. ii. .m; not,'. Passages from his 'wi-itings (luoted, 57 note Clemens Alexandrinus, on ladies using looking-glasses, i. 236 note. Admits t!ie possibility of the salvation of pagans, 877 note Clement, the Dominican friar, his murder of Henri III. of France, ii. 151. Ap- plauded for his act, 161 Clement V., Pope, removes all prohibitions against bull-flghting in Spain, i. 308 note Clement, St., miracle related of, i. 95 Clergy, opinion that they should not, under any circumstances, cause the death of men, ii. 38. Toleration denounced by all sections of the clergy, 59. Eeligious' lib- ei'ty favoured by the marriage of the Prot- estant clergy, 62. Attitude of the clergy of England respecting religious liberty during the Eevolution, 86, 87. Contest between the regal and ecclesiastical povi-er, 108. Blow struck at the power of the clergy by the suppression of the monas- teries, 123. Disappearance of the clergy from public offices, 226. Cruelty of the Spanish clergy to the Jews, 268 Clogy, Alexander, his life of Bedell, ii. 16 note Cluten, Joachim, ' De Hsereticis pcrsequen- dis,' ii. 53 note Coftee, introduction of, into Europe, ii. 822 Coinage, results of tampering with the, ii. 310 note Colbert, his suppression of executions for witchcraft, i. 117. And of accusations for sorcerv, 118. His services to manufac- tures, "ii. 826, 327 Collier, Jeremy, his work on the stage, ii. 810 Cologne, university of, its condemnation of a rationalistic spirit in some priests of the diocese, i. 104. Attempt of the In- quisition at, to destro.y the whole litera- ture of the Jews except the Bible, ii. 119 Colonies, substitution of industrial for mil- itary, ii. 851 note Comets, effect of, on the superstitions of the dark ages, i. 64. Work of Fromundus and Fieni on, i. 280 note. Superstitions respecting them, 290. Eaxo's statement of the prophetic character of comets, 290 note. Attempts to explain them in a rationalistic manner, 290. And of Para- celsus and Bayle to upset the superstitions respecting them, 291. Comets removed into the domain of law by Halley, 291. The tail of a comet considered by Whis- ton to be the locality of hell, 846 note Commerce and trade, how regarded by the ancients, ii. 224. Its interests give rise to consulships, ii. 262. Its influence in lead- ing men to tolerance, 262. Commercial activity of the Jews, 272. Eapid increabe of commerce in Europe, 281 Commonwealth, great numbers of execu- tions for witchcraft in England during the, i. 125. noG INDEX. Como, number of sorcerers put to death at, in one year, i. 31 Conception, the Imiaaculate, first appear- ance of the doctrine of, i. 2^5. St. Augus- tine on, quoted, 224 note. Adopted bj^ the Maliometans, 225 note. Eejectcd by St. Bernard as novel, 225 7ioie Concina on the history of usury, ii. 25G note, 257 note Confessions of -witches, how extorted in Scotland, i. 146 note Constance, great numbers of witches burnt at, i. 81 Constance, Council of, its denunciation of the right to slay tyrants, ii. 159 Constantine, the Emperor, his severe law against secret magic, i. 52. His destruc- tion of pagan statues, 258 note. His per- secutions of Jews and heretics, ii. 22, 23. His policy towards the pagans, 24. De- stroys the books of the Arians. 118. Le- galises interest at 12 per cent, 246 note Constantius, the Emperor, embraces the Arian heresy, i. 52. His penalties for every kind of magic, 52. St. Hilary's de- nunciations of him, ii. 187 note Constibstantiation, almost silent evanescence of the doctrine of, i. 268 ' Consulship of the Sea,' the institution so called, ii. 261 iwie Coi)isulsliii>i^. foumlation of, ii. 261. 281. The tir.st i-(ueifix, miracle of the, at Burgos, i. 157. And in Christ's Church, Dublin, 164 Crucifixion, passion for representations of the, i. 241. Abolition of, as a servile pun- ishment, ii. 229 Crusades, their iiitluenoc in sti-engthening Mariolatry, i. '.'■.'.'.. Inflni'iice of the Cru- sades on the tli.(il(i-ic.il irovernmcnt of political allaiis, ii. l(iT. Compared with the religious wars of the lieformation, 109, Influence of the Crusades on industry, 240 Cudworth, Ealph, his defence of the belief in the existence of witchcraft, i. 186 Cybele, the mother of the gods, day on which her feast was celebrated, i. 224 Cyprian commands the devil to assail a re- ligious maiden, i. 62. His view of the condemnation of all external to the Church, 876. The Levitical laws regarded by him as the foundation for the punishment of heretics, ii. 28 Cyprus stated by Nider to have been peo- pled by the childi-en of incubi, i. 49 note DiEDALUS, his sculpture, i. 242 DalL-eus, his indignation at the Carni- val dramas at Rome, ii. 80S note Dances of the ancients, some of them recon- structed by Naude, i. 115 note. The dancing mania of Flanders and Gei-many, origin of the, 77. Exorcism of the dancers, 77 note Daniel in the lion's den, early Christian symbol of, i. 216 Dante, influence of his poem over the con- ceptions of theology, i. 248. His theory of international arrangements, ii. 218 Death, doctrine of the penal nature of, re- futed by geology, i. 285. Jubinal's com- parison of the heathen and medieval rep- resentations of death, 878 note. Calmness with which it was contemplated by the heathen, 878. Uhe death of Socrates, 378. Luther's saying on the subject, 878 note Death, the black, i. 76. Causes to which it was attributed by the superstitious, 7T. Annual festival at Treves in commemora- tion of it, 77 7iot6 Death, Dance of, origin of the pictures of the, i. 78 note Decemvirs, their law against magicians, i. 42 De Maistre, on the science of the ancients, quoted, i. 288 note. His remarks on Locke's philosophy, 403 note. And ou Bacon's, 403 note Democracy : Protestantism, why favourable to, ii. 167. Circumstances that prepared the democracy of the eighteenth century, 201-207. Analysis of the democratic ideiil, 218. Doctrine of the rights of national- ities, 218. Theories of International ar- rangements, 218. Democracy an aspect of the Christian spirit, 220 Demoniacs of the Bible regarded as lunatics by Webster and Hobbes, i. 137, and note Demons, the, of the Alexandrian or Neo- Platonic school, i. 46. The doctrine of demons in its relation to heathen wor- ship, 46 note. Oiigin of the word demon as signifying devil, 47. Tertullinn on de- mons, 47. All the pagan gods and god- desses regarded by the early Christians as 367 demons, 48. Male and female devils, 49 note. Exorcists among the early Chris- tians, 49. The pliilosophical system of rsellus i. OS Do Moiitfort, liis commencement of the massacre of the Albi^enses, ii. 33 Dionysius the Areopagite, his writiuss the IMlile of Mysticism, i. 344. In part trans- lated by Scotus Krigona, 844 Uoscartes, influence of his ^v^itings in de- stroying the material notions associated with spirits, i. IIG. His Theory of Vor- tices, 2S9. His influence on the decline of the mediaival notions of hell, 339, 345, u46. His doctrine of animals, 346 note. His account of the opinion of his contem- poraries on the doctrine of a material fire, 346 note. Causes of his influence, 400. Animosity of the reformed clergy of Hol- land aaainst him, ii. 50. The character of Descartes regarded as.the sceptical philos- opher, 63. His influence on religious lib- erty, 63, 64 Despotism, predisposition of the Anglican Church towards, ii. 180 'Deuce,' origin of the word, t 49 note Devil, his supposed especial power over apples, i. 30 note. Appearances of him, in various forms, in the dark ages, 61. Tal- ismans for bafiling his devices, 63. Bas- reliefs on cathedrals of men devoting themselves to the devil, 78 note. Scepti- cism at the i)resent day on all subjects connected with the devil, 87. St. Thomas Aquinas on Satan's power, 88. Tempests and diseases said to be produced by him, 90, 92. His power of assuming the form of any animal, 95. The ' phenomena of love' under the especial influence of the devil, 99. Kirlc's account of evil spirits among the Highlanders, 148 note. Posi- tion assigned to him in the religious plays, ii. 295 Diabolus, Sprenger's derivation of the word, i. 87 note Diana, in Greek statues, a type of chastity, 1. 24;3 Digby, Sir Kenelm, his remark on the be- lief in witchcraft in his time, i. 142 Diocletian, destroys the books of the Chris- tians, ii. lis Diplomacy, international, first great impulse given to, ii. 262. Tirst use of the cipher in, 282 note Diptychs, carved ivory, 1. 236 Diseases said to have been produced by the power of the devil, i. 92 Dissenters, English, causes of their power in the seventeenth century, ii. 18. Want of success of persecution shown in their case, 18. Dissenters at the time of the Toleration Act, IS. Assimilated to the Scotch, 173 Dodwell, Dr. William, bis answer to Dr. Middloton's attack on the veracity of the Father.', i. 172 Dog, a, • moved by the spirit of Pytho,' i. 96 note Domat, his notion of the impropriety of money-lending, ii. 251 iiote Dorainick, St., legend of his mother's dream, ii. 124 The cihief reviver of persecution, 114 nUe Donatists, their fierce persecutions, ii. 23 note. Persecuted by Constantino, 23 Douay, number of sorcerers put to death at, in one vear, i. 29. Executions for witch- craft at, 117 Douglas on miracles, i. 173 Dress, richness of, after the Crusades, ii. 274 . Drinks, hot, importation of, into Europe, ii. 321. Their moral and social eff"ects. 322 Dryads, notions of the early Christians re- specting them, i. 47 Dublin, the miraculous crucifix in Christ Church at, i. 164 Durham Cathedral, Smollett's remarks en, i. 264 note Dusii, the, of the pagans, regarded by the early Christians as devils, i. 48. The ori- gin of om- ■ deuce,' 48 note EAKTH, the centre of the. regarded by St. Thomas as hell, i. 347 note. Earth- quakes, remarks of Oosmas Indicopleustes on, quoted, i. 288 note East India Company begins the mercantile system in England, ii. 326 note Echelles, Trois, the sorcerer, pardoned by Charles IX., i. 110 Eclipses, eff'ects of, on the superstitions of the dark ages, i. 64. Said to have caused the death of a French king, (v4 'Edinburgh Eeview,' its influence in Eng- land, ii. 125 Edwards, Jonathan, bis views respecting in- fant baptism, i. 368. On ' Original Sin,' 368 note. On predestination, os7 note Egyptians, influence of the national religion on the art of the ancients, i. 209 Eliberis, Council of, condemns usury, ii. 247 note Elizabeth, Queen, her laws respecting witch- craft, i. 121. Success of persecution as shown in the laws of, ii. 14. Persecutions during her reign, 46. Bishop Bilson s apology f'lr her pulic.v towards the Catho- lics, 44 ni'1(. Answer she received from a Scotch (lepulMiiiiii, 172 EncyelopuMlists, their denunciation of tor- ture, i. 333 England, first law in, against witchcraft, i. 119. Scepticism in England at the end of the seventeenth and beginning of the eighteenth centuries, 138. The unexam- pled severity of the penal code in England in the middle ages, 349. Number of an- nual executions in England in the middle of the eighteenth century, 350. Severity of the penal code during the reign of George III., 350. Sketch of the history of toleration in England, ii. 75-124. Dis- appearance of the clergy from otBces of power in England, 125, 126. Political in- fluence of the Italian republics on public opinion in England, 145 note. Debt Eng- land owes to her non- episcopal churches, 173. The two schools of despotism in England, ISO. Parallel between the his- tory of political and religious liberty in England, 183. The greatest English free- thinkers inimical to liberty, 184. Ditter- ence between the growth of Enslish and French liberty analogous to English and 368 French tolerance, 185. Sale of English slaves to the Irish in the middle ages, 233 note. Introcluotion of usury into Eng- lnn7. Character of the biblical :riticism of 305. Persecution of the roL. II.— 53 Catholics in Gcrm.any, ii. 40. I'rob.ablo cause of the ascendency of German think- ers in Europe. 183 Gerson, cbniiecllnr of the University ot Paris, his iK-U-urf ,,r the belief in witch- craft, i. .bs. Jiis r. marks oil persons who denied the existom-.' of (Icnuins, quoted, 104. Denounci-.^ i\ i:niiiiciilc, ii. ir . - . ii. 110 Januarii;>. - : . : i. ■ ■ I. :it Na]iles, i. ITO Japan, sill '1 ~ ' 1 | . i . . ulion .'-bov. n in llm ■ caseof tlie CliriMiiins in, ii. 14 Jesuits, tvrannici(!e- deleiided by the. ii. iCI. Their services to lileralifm, 102. Casuis- try of the Jesuits applied to the subject ol usury, 257. Their jiroclamation of tlic 'social contract,' ii. 148. Suarez, 'L)c Fide,' 147, 148, Mariana 'De Kcge,' 150 Jewel. Bishop, on the increase of witchcraft in England, i. 121. His ' Apology,' 170 Jews, the black death ascribed to them, i 373 fT. Their religion regarded by some of the Gnostics as the work of the principle of evil, 221 note. Constantino's ptrsecu- tion of the, ii. 22. Influence of their laws on persecution, 22. Partiality of the Spaniards tor the burning of Jews, 116. The whole literature of the .Tews, rxcept the Bible, proposed to be il.stiny.l, 111). Jewish emancipation in j;iii:l:iihl. Vl'i. The Jews early noted as ^lavc-dcakrs, 230. Jewish slaves in the middle ages, 239 note. Usury almost monopolised by the Jews, 2o4. The Jews the first class benefited by the tolerance caused by commerce, 203. Persecutions of the Jews, 26:3. Superstitions concerning them, 265 note. Controversy in the middle ages as to whether they should be permitted to practise usuiy, 266 note. Their services to literature, 267, 272. Expelled from Spain, 267. Massacre in Seville and other places in Spain, 267, 268. Barbarity of the Portuguese towards them, 270. Their commercial activity, 272. Tolerated in the Italian republics, 272. Said to havo invented letters of exchange, 272 note Joan of Ai'C, her execution for witchcraft, 1. 120 John, Filar, his success In promoting the Inquisition in Italy, il. 117 note John, St., legend of the portrait of, found in the house of a Christian, i. 235 note Jonah rescued from the fish's mouth, sym- bol of, i. 216 Jovian, the Emperor, his tolerance of pagan magic, i. 57 Juanes, the Spanish painter, 1. 247 note Judaism, patriotism the moral principle of, ii. 104. IIM! Julian, liis attempt to consolidate Neo-Pla- tiiiiism, i. 40 note. His love of magic, 56, 57. His testimony to the charity of the Cliristians, ii. 235. His antipathy to pub- lic amusements, 290 Julius II., Pope, his bull against sorcery, L 32. His munifleence to artists, 259 Jupiter, Greek busts of, i. 239 note. Their character, 244 Jurieu advocates the lawfulness of persecu- tion, ii. 50. His political teaching, 187 nfite, 188 Jurisprudence, phases of, ii. 194 Justin Martyr, his assertion of the continu- ance of :niracles in his time, i. 16S. Ad- mits the possibility of the salvation of pagans, 377 note Justinian, the Emperor, his law respecting usury, 11. 253 note KANT, his principles of biblical criticism, i.305 Kellerus, the Jesuit, his defence of tyranni- cide, ii. 160 Kings, the power of the Pope for deposing, ii. 142, 147. Doctrine of the mediate char- acter of the divine right of kings, 147. The doctrine of the ' social contract,' 148. Mariana's ' De Eege,' 150. Tyrannicide. 151 (t ceq. William Barclay's denial of the Pope's power of depositlofi, 164 note. Doctrine of passive obedience to, 175. 177. Hooker's doctrine of the regal power, 178 Kirk, the Scotch, Buckle's description of the, i. 144 iiote Kirk, Eobert. minister of Aberfoil, his ac count of evil spirits among the Highland- ers, i. 148 note Knowledge, the increase of, one of the great causes of liberty, ii. 202 Knox, John, his denunciation of the Queen hearing mass, ii. 49. Advocates the law- fulness of persecution, 50, 51. His politi- cal liberalism, 163 LABOUE, services of the Fathers and tho Benedictines in making it honourable, ii. 231 La Boetie, his treatise on 'Voluntary Servi- tude,' ii. 199. His revolutionary declama- tions, quoted, 199, 200. His work adopted by the French Protestants in 1578, and recently by Lamennais, 2€0 Lactantius, his strong assertion of the in- iquity of persecution, ii. 21. His peculiar notions, 22 note. His opinion that eccle- siastics should never cause the death of men, 33. His view of money-lending, 251 Lady-day, feast of Cybele fonnerly cele- brated on, j. 224 Lamb, the symbol of Christ, condemned by a council ' In Trullo,' i. 247 La Mere Sotte, origin of, ii. 296 note Lamennais, M. de Montalemberfs remarks on, as an heresiarch, i. 187 note. His at- tempt to associate Catholicity with the movement of modern civilisation, ii. 74 Landry, St., the apostle of charity in France, ii. 235 La Peyrere, his work on rationalistic bibli- cal interpretation, i. 3U0. Analysis of his argument, 301 iiote. His denial of the Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch, 302 Laplace, on the argument for design in the motions of the planets, i. 297 note. His review of Craig's theory of probabilities, 398 note Las Casas advocated slavery, ii. 317. De- fended by Gri-goire, Bishop of Blois, itc,., 317 note Lateran, Third Council of, its endeavours to arrest the progress of usury, ii. 254 Lateran, Fourth Council of, its denuncia- tion of heretics, ii. 39 Latimer, Bishop, his sermon describing the revolution of prices in England, ii. 316 note Law in nature, gradual substitution of the conception of, for that of supernatural ;u- tervention, i. 286 Lawes, the composer, interred in Westmin- ster Abbey, il. 810 note League, exultation of the, at the murder of Henry III., ii. 161 Leannain Sith, or familiar spirits, common among the Highlanders, i. 148 note Learning, aisthetic effect of the revival c f. i. 247 Le Coreur, on usury, ii. 257 note Le Couvrcur, the actress, ii. 305. Voltaiie's ode to her memory, 305 Leibnitz's notions of eternal punishment, i. Leith. nine women burnt for wilchcMl't at in 1664, i. 148 374 Lemia, the sorceress, put to death, i. 42 Lentulus, proconsul of Juda>a, forged letter of, on the personal appearance of Christ, i. 245 note Leo I., Pope, burns the books of the Mani- choeans, ii. 119 Leo X., his munitieence to arnsts, i. 259. Grounds upon which he condemned usury, ii. 251 note Levitical laws, influence of, on Christian persecution, ii. 22. Regarded by Cyprian as the foundation of dealings with here- tics, 28 Lessing, his principles of biblical criticism, i. 805 Libanius, his pleadings against the destruc- tion of the temples in the country dis- tricts, ii. 27. His praise of pantomimic dances, 291 Liberty, religious, cursed by St. Augustine, ii. 32 note Liberty, political, the teaching of the Fa- thers respecting rebellion favourable to liberty, ii. 1-39. As also the conflicts be- tween the Pope and kings, 140 Life, insoluble problem of, i. 298 Lilith, the tirst wife of Adam, the queen of the succubi, i. 49 note Lily, superstitious uvtion concerning, 1. 225 Limbo, origin of pictures of the descent into, i. 222 note. Unbaptised children in, 860, 367 Limoges, goldsmiths' work of, i. 237 note Linnaeus, preposterous charge brought against his system, ii. 50 note Llorente, his 'History of the Inquisition,' ii. 40 note Locke, John, on the patristic miracles, i. 164, 166. On the belief in propositions contrary to reason, 172 note. Causes of his influence. 400. Carpings of the Tractarian p:iit\- at liis ]is\chology, 403 note. Hjs dd. lir, (,i' i-rli-i.Wis liberty, ii. 87. His answer to lilinn-'s doctrino of passive obedience, Isl, la2. On interest, ii. 259 Lombards, their trade in money, ii. 251. Their political economy, 282 note Looking-glasses, ladies using, said by Cle- mens Alexandrinus to break the secund commandment, i. 285 note Lot. See Chance Lower, a Sutfolk clergyman, put to death for witchcraft, i. 126" Loyola, Ignatius, sets a day apart for the meditation of eternal damnation, i. 326 Lucretius adopted the theory of spontaneous generation, i. 844 Luke, St., probable author of the portraits of, i. 312 note ' Lullaby,' supposed origin of the word, i. 49 note Lulli, the musical composer, ii. 807 Luther, Martin, his superstitious credulity, i. 83. His sense of sin, 82. His belief in Avitchcraft, 8;3. His part in the Eucharis- tic controversy, 878. On salvation iu the Church alone, 3S1. His declaration of wredestinarianism, 385, 386 note. Asserts ihe right of the civil magistrate to punish heresy, ii. 50. His inclination to the des- potic theory of government, 169 Lutheranism." almost silent evanescence of the distinctive mark of, i. 270. Coales cence of Lutherans and Calviaists ir Prussia and other parts of Gcrmanj^ 27t note Luxembourg, Marslial of, his trial for sor- cery, i. 118 Luxury, habits of, in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, ii. 274. Sumptuary laws, 274 and note. Influence of the black death, 275. Economical elfects of luxury 276. Substitution of luxury for monas- ticism as a check upon population, 277. Influence of luxury on intellectual de- velopment, 278. And upon the character of public amusements, 2S5 Lycanthropy, belief in, i. 96, 97. Condemn- ed by a canon of the Council of Ancyra, 96. Executions in France for lycanthropy in the first half of the seventeenth centu- ry, 117 MACATTLAT, Lord, his reason why the Puritans objected to bull-baiting, i. 308 note. On the servility of the Augli'iau Church, quoted, ii. 174 note Machinery, movements in favour of manu- factures stimulated by the invention of, ii. 832. Drawbacks to its advantages, 333 Magdalen hospitals unknown to the early Church, ii. 234 note Magic, laws of the Romans against, i. 43. Character of, among the more civilised pagans, 43, 51. Its extraordinary impor- tance in the patristic teaching, 51. The Emperor Constantine's severe Taw against . secret magic, 52. The title ' enemies of the human race' transferred from the Christians to the magicians, 58. Laws of Constantius, 53. Scepticism the only true corrective for the evil, 54. The laws against magic suspended under Julian and Jovian, but afterwards renewed, 5(1. Causes of the worst outbreaks of tljese persecutions, 58. Pomponazzi's attempt to explain the phenomena of magic by the influence of the stars, 283 note. Tran- sition of the old pagan worship from the sphere of religion into that of magic, ii. 43. Existence cf prohibited pagan magi- cal rites long after the suppression of pa- ganism, 44 Magnet, the discoveries of Gilbert respect- ing the, treated with contempt by Lord Bacon, i. 292 note Mahometans, their raid against books on logic and philosophy, i. 73 note. Concep- tion some centuries "before the appearance of the doctrine in Christianity, 225 note Mahometanism the sole example of a great religion restraining semi-barbariaus from idolatry, i. 234. The deadly enemy of art, 286. The assthetic genius exliibited in Mahometan architecture, 236. Ma- hometan slaves, ii. 238 note Malebranche, his account of the decadence in the belief in witchcraft in his time, i. 116 Maleflciendo, Sprcngers derivation of the ' word, i. 87 note 'Malleus Maleficarum,' the works of in quisitors so called, i. 89 note Malthus, his theory and its consequences,!! Man : tlie ancient notion of man's position in the universe displaced bv astronomy, i. 283, 2S4. Effects of man's sin on the veg- etable world, 288 note Manichseism, outburst of, in flie twelfth century, i. 71. Cardinal tenet of, 240. The Mosaic cosmogony assailed by the Mani- chseans, 272. St. Augustine's treatise in answer, 273. Their doctrine respecting the Antipodes, 27.5. Their strange notion of the purifiratinn of the souls of the deai], ;;i',) iKil,. Their books burnt by Pojir ],,',, i., ii. lis Maniur-;. (lie inciitv of, corrected by Chris- tian (■hai-ily, ii. 'l.)l Mantua. liKi'iiisiliDu riots in, ii. 117 Mannsrripts. Iicaiitv of the illuminations of, from the. fifth tn the tenth centuries, i. 237 note. Decline of the art from this period till the revival of painting, 237 note Mar, earl o'', bled to death for having con- sulted witches how to shorten the life of James XL, i. 148 note Marcellus, his death, ii. 35 Mariana, the Jesuit, his opposition to bull- f.chtinc- in Spain, i. 308 vote. Account of liis work ■ De Eege.' ii. 150 Marii)lati-v. See Vi''gin Wai'tiii, ^^(., of Tours, his denunciation of the execution of some heretics, ii. .33. His destruction of pagan temples, 83 note Martyrdoms, only one or two representa- tions of, in the catacombs, i. 212 Mary, Queen of Scotr<, her execution for idolatry advocated by Convocation, ii. 50 note Maryland, religious liberty established in, by Lord Baltimore, ii. 59 Masques, English, ii. 301 Massachusetts, executions for witchcraft in, i. 83 Massalians, a sect of heretics, regard spit- ting as a reli;;ious exercise, i. 4S^ Massius, Bishop Gilbert, his portrait, i. 227 note Materialism of the middle ages, i. 343 Two schools of, 343. Causes of the tendency towards, at the present day, 300; ii. -356 Mathematicus, a name given to astrologers, i. 65 note Mather, Cotton, creates a panic respecting witchcraft in America, i. 137. 1-38 Matilda, Ctmnless. iiitlueiice of liur tomb on the works of Nicolas of I'isa. i. :.'58 Matter, the eSM'iilial evil of. the cardinal tenet of »',nosti^•i^nl and Manieha^ism, i. 240. V/hy matter attracts matter, an in- soluble problem, 298. Relation of mind to matter, 298 Mayence, gi-eat numbers of Jews put to death in, i. 77 Mayence, a begsar put to death for sorcery at, in 1807, i. 80 note Maynooth, college of, endowment of the, ii. 123 Mazarin, Cardinal, his letter to the bishop of Evreux on the execution of witches, i. 117 Mazarine library, Naudo the first librarian of the, i. Wo note Medici, their archaeological colleclicns. i. 258 Medici, the, give an intellectual ascendency to industry, ii. 283 Medisevaiism, the sense of sin the chief moral agent of, ii. 190 Melanchthon, Philip, notions on withcraft, i 83 note. His remarks on the question of the cause of the difference ot sex, i. 345. His predestinarian views, 386 note. His approval of the murder of Servetus, ii. 52. His detinition of usury, 247 note Melito, St., bishop of Surdis, his 'Clavis,' i. Memory, cases of hyperajsthosia of the, ii. 97 7ioie Mesmer, the cures of, attributed to super- natur.al agency, i. 119 Mice, Van Helmont's receipt for producing, i. 345 note. St. Augustine on the exist- ence of, 845 note Michael Angelo, his admiration for the torso Belvedere, i. 259. His Moses and David, 259 note. The secularisation of art repre- sented to the highest degree by Michael Angelo, 201 Middleton, Dr. Conyers, his ' Free Inquiry into the Miraculous Powers,' &c., 166, 169. Discussion of his principles by Church, Dodwell, &c., 17-2 Milan Cathedral, ridicule with which it was regarded in the last century, i. 204 note. Inquisition riots in Milan, ii. 110 Milton, .Tolin, liis advocacy of the right"} of con^^eii iiri-. ii. ^o note, 81. His 'Ar'.-opa- gilica.' -1 ti,'f.. His intolerance of Cath- olics. ^-' anil iidip. On regal power, 181 Minerva, in Greek statues, a type of female modesty and self-control, i. 243 Miniature painting conimou long before the time of Cimabue, i. 237 note Minos, character of the Greek representa- tions of, i. 244 Minutius Feli.x, his remarks on eternal pun- ishments, quoted, i. 317 note. His opin- ion of the dccmon of Socrates, 377 note Miracles of the Church, i. 15.5. Views of lioman Catholics and Protestants respit- ing miracles, 155, 156. Miracles raJated by the Fathers and iiioil'a'^al writers as undoubted and ordinary occuirciices, IStf et seq. Pvapid growth of scipliii.sm on the subject since the Kelormalion, 159. General tone adopted by Koman Catholics respecting miracles, 100. Causes of the decline of the sense of the miraculous, 101. Disbelief in the miraculous in di- rect proportion to the progress of civilisa- tion and diffusion of knowledge, 162. Ef- fect of civilisation on contemporary as compared with historical miracles, 162. Persecution rcfrarded by some I^nglish divines as a substitute ior miracles, 164. Middleton's attack upon the veracity of the patristic miracle-,, 169. Epitome of the common arguments in favour of the cessation of miracles, 175. St. Augus- tine's belief in the miracles wrought by the relics of St. Stephen, 178 7iote. Aver- sion to the miraculous a distinctive mark of Rationalism, 188. Origin and decline of the evidential school in England, 189. Tendency among the evidential school to meet the nationalists half way, 192. Sum- mary of the stages of E.ationalism in its relation to the niiraculous, 193 Molicre, dcnouuced by the Church, ii. 30C 376 Moliaa, fiis defense of tyrannicide, li. ICO Molinajus, Carolus, his remarks ou money- lending, quoted, ii. 256 note Monastioism, its inlluence in stimulating persecution, ii. 34, 35. Entiiusiasm of the Hrst monks, 35. Substitution of luxury for monasticism as a check uj>on popuhi- tion, 2T7. Causes of the decadence of thri;4i-n, Viis school of allegorical Scriptural interpretation, i. 272. His disbelief in eternal punishments, 316. His notion of the soul, 342. Associates the doctrine of infant t)aptism with that of preexistence, 3(i-'. His views of the condemnation of all external to the Ciuu-eli,376 Orleans, duke of. jnstifi.ation of the murder of, liy Jean Petit, ii. 158 Orpheus, regarded as a symbol of the at- tractive power of Christianity, i. 214 Oxford, University of, its opjiosition to al- most every step made by English intellect in connection with theology, i. 173. In- stances of this opposition in the eases of the Test Act and Catholic Emancipation, and in fli ■ .rn nt- ri-irtionary movement begun in 1 '. I : '. ! " '. < ippositicm of the Uuiversil\ ; ' .: I \-> religious liberty, ii. 86. 1>.>: ui'H .ii p I- -i\-e obedience laid down by the. ITo nole. Its decree on this subject" burnt by the House of Lords, 177 PAGANISM, how regarded by the early Christians, i. 45. The immediate ob- jects of the devotions of the pagan world according to the Neo-Platonic school, 46. Laws of "Constantine and Constantius, 52. Compromise between Christianity and paganism, 59. Continuance of the pagan rites in the form of magic, 60. Exorcists among the pagans, 156 note. Effect of pagan traditions upon early Christiaii art, ilL Sentiments of tho Fathers on the damnation of the heathen, 377. Policy of Constantine towards the pagans, ii. 23. Position of the pagans and of the govern- ment towards them at this period, 25. Eeview of their condition before the time of Th'eodosius, 26. Destruction of their temples in the country districts, 26. Pro- hibitions of Theodosius the Great, 27. Destruction of temples by St Martin of Tours, 33 note. Kuin of paganism, 85. The pagan parallels to the Christian mar- tyrs, 1(52. Type of character formed by pajan patriotism, 102. Synthesis of tho moral principles of Christianity and pa- ganism, 220. The theatre the last refuge of paganism, 289 Painting, a faithful mirror of the popular mind, before the invention of printing, i. 74 note. Its influence in strengthening tbe worship of the Virgin, 224. Peculiar characteristics, and chief causes of artistic perfection of later Italian works, 253. Sen- suality favourable to painting, 253. Influ- ence of Venetian ser.su.ilii;,-, 2r>4. Dis- covery of oil colours, 'J.Vi mitf. 'J'heir in- troduction into Italy, 2."ir.. ( 'oni]ik'te sec- ularisation of the art ;illi_r the death of Savonarola, 261. Devotion of the monks of St. Basil to painting, ii. 232 Palestrma, his Church music, ii. 301 Palmer, Mr., his collection of evidence on tlie views of the Fathers as to original sin, i. 877 note Pan, Greek statues of. i. 229 note Paneas in Phcenicia, the miraculous image of Christ at, 1. 229 Pantomimic dances, Libanius' praise of, ii. 291. Origin of pantomime in Italy, 297 Paracelsus, his belief in the existence of sylphs, &c., i. 67 note. His attempt to overcome the popular superstitions re- specting comets. 291 Paramo, an Inquisitor, his remark on tho Inquisition, ii. 42 note Paris, great numbers of witches put to death in, i. 30 Paris, Abbe, miracles at the tomb of, i. 180 Parma, Inquisition riots in, ii. 116 Pasca !^f';:;. ■:".:; pr..,,,:..,.. Patriotism, out necessity of infant '■. On the utter vanity note. His doctrine of j(l to religious systems, f the chief moral princi- ples of society, ii. 102. Type of character it formed, 103. Greatest' vice of ancient patriotism, 104. Patriotism the moral principle of Judaism, 104, 106. In the Eoman Empire, 106. Correspondence of patriotism to the spirit of sect in religion, 100. Incompatibility of sectarianism with patriotism, 186 Paul II., Pope, his persecution of artists at Home, i. 259 Paul IV., Pope, originates the ' Index Ex- purgatorius,' ii. 119 Paul the Hermit, miracles related of, i. 156 Paulinus, bishop of Nola, said to have in vented church bells, i. 262 Pavia, fresco in the monastery of, i. 825 Peacock, the symbol of immortality among pagans and the early Christians, 1. 213 Wny so regarded, 213, 214 note Pelaffius, his view of infant baptism, i. 861 Penal Code, relations between the prevail- ing sense of the enorniitv of sin and the severity of the. i. 836. Tendency of aV. 378 penal systems under the inflaenoe of tbe. clergy, '336 note. Constant tendency in the advance of civilisation to midgate the severity of penal codes, 336. J'art taken by theologians in mitigating tlie penal code, 349. Influence of Beccaria, 350 Penance, public, question of the right of the Pope to condemn criminals to, ii. 143 Pentateuch, the Mosaic authorship of the, denied by La Peyrere, i. 802 Perez, Antonio, famous prosecution of, ii. 113 Periander, tyrant of Corinth, story of He- rodotus of, i. 820 note, Perron, Cardinal, his assertion of Ultramon- tane piinciples, ii. 165 "ersecutlon, religious, revival of, at the be- ginning of the thirteenth century, i. 74. Uegarded by some English divines as a substitute for miracles, 156. The emo- tional antecedent of persecution, 831. Per- secution the result of tlie principles pro- fessed by the persecutors, 350. The his- tory of persecution, ii. 11 et eeq. Injury done to industry by persecution, 273 Persians, influence of the national religion on the art of the ancient, i. 209, 210 tioie Perugino, his scepticism, i. 261 Pestilences, eflVcts of, on the superstitions of the dark ages, i. 63. Said to have been produced by the power of the devil, 92 Peter of Apouo, denied the existence of de- mons and miracles, 1. 103 note. Accused of magic, 103 note Peter, St., with the wand of power, early Christian symbol of, i. 216 Petit, Jean, justifies the murder of the Duke of Orleans, ii. 159. His justification de- nounced by Gerson and the Council of Constaoce, 159 Petrarch gives an impulse to archsological collections, i. 258 Phidias, his colossal statue of Jupiter Olym- pus, i. 258 Philanthropy, boundless, of modern Chris- tianity, i. 349 Philip II. of Spain, Dutch heretics put to death during his reign, ii, 41 Philip Neri, St., originates the oratorio, ii. 301 Philosophers charged by the Abbe Fiard with being the representatives of the old . sorcerers, i. 119 Philosophy, moral, its progress one of the causes of the decline of the mediaeval no- tions of hell, i. 338. The sense of virtue appealed to most strongly by the philoso- phies of Greece and Kome, 356. Revival of the sense of truth due to the secular l)hilosophers of the seventeenth century, 399. The superiority of the inductive method asserted by Leonardo da Vinci, 400. Kamus and Bruno, 401. The decline of theological belief a necessarv antece- dent of the success of thL- in.lu<-rivc meth- od,-^02, 403. l>r Mai-tn'r-niiunks, 11 Locke an-. Bacon's I.llilo~,.|,ll^ . 4'i:; /-,./, . Aver- sion of the Inictariau party l^ lioth. 403 note Phryne, the mistress of Praxiteles, i. 256 note 7ichler, his views on usury, ii. 257 Pictures, stages of the veneration for, i. 22S. Decree of the Council of Illiberis against pictures in churches, 229. Admitted by the Greeks into their churches, 280. The introduction of pictures into their churchi'S forbidden by the Christians of Alexandria, 233 Pinel, the philosophy of madness mainlv due to, i. 86 Piracy, suppression of, by the Hanseatic League, ii. 282 Pius v.. Pope, his prohibition of bull-fight- ing, i. 308 note Plague, the, attributed to the theatres, ii. 308 note Plato, inUiience of his philosophy in favour- ini.' a bf lief in evil spirits, i. 43. His no- tion of lull, S19. Hts denunciation of Platonists, their idea of (he soul, i. 340, 841 note Plays, religious, rise of the. ii. 293. Account of them, 293. Their immorality, 295. '1 he great 'passion play' of Oberammergau, 299 note Plotinus, a Keo - Platonic philosopher, ashamed of possessing a body, i. 240 Plunket, the Act of Union, ii. 182 note Pluto, Greek representations of, i. 244 Political economy, influence of, on democra- cv, ii. 207. Free-trade notions in France before the ' Wealth of Nations,' 208. En- lightened views of the Venetians, 2S2 ; of the Lombards, 282 note. The first pro- fessorship founded at Naples, 288 note Schools of Sully and Colbert, 826, 327 That of Qnesnaj', 827. Berkeley's expo- sition of the true nature of money, 32S note. Enor of the Freneli economists. 828. Adam Smith on manufactures ard agriculture, 328. Eaynal's views, 329. liicardo, 331. Invention of credit. £82 Political economy an expression of an in. dustrial civilisation, 335. Its pacific in- fluence, 885, 840. Scheme of progress re- vealed by political economy, 848, '350 Politics, secularisation of, ii. 09 et teq. Polo, Marco, his notice of tea in the thir- teenth century, ii. 322 Polycarp, St., m"iracle of, i. KS Polycles, the sculptor, introduces the her- maphrodite into art, i. 256 note Pomponatius, his speculations, i. 870 Pope, decline of the temporal power of the. ii. 130. Causes of its decline, 130. Origin of his power in Eome, 140. The Pope's power of deposing sovereigns, 142, 146. Jloral authority necessarily with the Pope, 142, 148. His right to condemn criminals to public penance, 143. His power over the temporal possessions of princes denied by "William Barclay, 164. Attitude of the Protestants of France in 1615 on this question, 165 Population, doctrine of Malthus on, ii. 277. Substitution of luxury for monasticism as a check upon, ii. 277 Positivism, first principles of, ii. 856 notf. Character of the leading positivists, 356 note Possada, Father, his opposition to the thea- tre, ij. 80S note Potters, Abyssinian superstition respecting i. 67 note 379 Povertv, cause of the decline of the ideal of, ii. '274 I'oynct, Bishop of Winchester, his advocacy of sedition and tyrannicide, ii. 1T4 note Praxiteles, Titian compared with, i. 256. Said to have definitively given the char- acter of sensuality to Venus, 2.56 note, Predestinarianism, influence of the doctrine of exclusive salvation on, i. 883. C!alvin's theory of, substantially held by St. Au- gustine, 3S3. Luther's declaration and Erasmus's opposition, 3S5. The doctrine of double predestination held in the ninth conturv. 3S5 note. Views of Melanch- thon, 3S6 note. Calvin and Beza, 387 note. The doctrine assailed, ii. 54 Pi-esbyterianism, persecuted in Scotland, ii. 4S. Intolerance of the Presbyterians in En.illand in the seventeenth century, 79. Elforts of the Scotch to suppress liberty of CDnscience, SO note. Its tendency com- pared with that of Episcopalianism, 163 Prickers of witches, i)rofession of, in Scot- land, i. 146 Printinpr, servitude and superstition abol- ishedliy, ii. 21(3, 204 Proast. Arc!iiK-ni Protf.slaiils.'ilicii- clistrust and aversion for contcuipurary miracles, i. 155, 156, 16a. Their views respecting historicalluiracles, 163 Protestantism : causes of the extraordinary strides made by Kationalism in most Protestant countries, i. 1-^1. 'Hie cldicnia- tic forms of Protestantism of the sixteenth and seventeenth centiiric-s suiiiTSedcil by Protestant nationalism, 184. Dogmatic character of early Protestantism, 1. oCi'.'. The representatives of Ilatioualif m in tlie tirst period of Protestantism : Socinusand Zuinglius, .36it. Success of persecution in extirpating Protestantism from Spain and France, ii. 14. Protestant persecutions comijared with that of Catholicism, 57 et seq. In Protestant countries, tolerance the result and measure of the advance of nationalism, 75. Attitude of the Protes- tants in France in 1615 respectins- tlie Papal power, 165. Democrarv tavom-eil by Protestantism, 167. Plarr ,,i' l>i,,i,^- tantism in the development ol i;nuli
  • upon hi;-t.il-\-, 'j;)."'. liilluenceS ot phv.Mi'ul scu'iice ovt-r .-iieciilativc opin- ions, 290. Illegitiuiate ellects of science, 299. Effects of science upon belief, 800 And on Biblical interpretation, 300 Sciences, Academy of, at I'arir-, establish inenl of iho, i. i92 mDEX, JSl Botland, extreme atrocity of the perseeu- tions for witchcraft iu, i. 142-150. Perse- cution of Presbyterians in, ii. 48. And of Catholics, 48, 49. Efforts of the Scotch to suppress liberty of conscience, 79 noie. Establishment of the Scottish Kirk. 87. Political liberalism of Scotland, 1G9. Knox, ITO. Buchanan, 171. Answer of the Scotch ■k'putation to Queen Elizabeth, 17'2. Eng- lish Dissenters assimilated to the Scotch, 173. E.\istecce of serfdom in Scotland as late as 1775, 239. Sumptuary laws in the fourteenth century, 275 note Scott, Kecrinald, his 'Discovery of Witch- craft,' i. 122 Scotus Erigena, John, his disbelief in the doctrine of hell-tire, i. 320. Translates iiio writings of Denvs the Areopagite, 844. Opposes Gotteschalk's doctrinis of double piedrt-tiiiatiiin, o>"j note Scriptural interpretation : Swedenborg's 'Doctrine of Corresiiondences,' i. 272. .Allegorical school of Origen, 272. The 'Clavis' of St. Melito, 'I'd vote. Objec- tions of the Manichieans to the literal in- terprctr.tion of Genesis. 272. Answered bv St. Augustine, 273. The literal school, 274. The^'Topographia Christiana,' L'Tli. Influence of science upon Biblical int'-r- pretation, 800. The earliest example of ra- tionalistic biblical interpretation, 300. Dis- intcLTating and destructive criticism, 305. Lessing and Kant's principles, 305 Sculpture, the most ancient kinds of, i. 242. Alleged decadence of Greek sculpture ft-om Phidias to Praxiteles, 253 note. Parallel of Titian and Praxiteles, 254 note. History of Greek statues after the rise of Christianity, 257, 258. Nicholas of Pisa and his v.-orks, 258. First develop- ment of sculpture in Eome, ii. 102 note Sectari:inism iu Ireland, ii. 186. Its incom- patibility witii ]i:itriotisin, 186 Seguirr. till' < !innci_llor, his enthusiastic pa- troii;i^\- of lea in the seventeenth century. ii. 322 Selden on witchcraft, 1. 125 Self-sacrifice, ereat development of, by ':'hristianitv,"'ii. 237. Decline of the spirit of, 354 Seneca on the dutirs of masters towards their slaves, ii. 223 Sensuality, influence of, upon art, i. 255 Serfdom which followed slavery, ii. 238, 239. Manumission enforced as a duty upon lay- men, 239 note. Serfdom in Scotland in 1775, 239 Serpent, the, worshipped by the Ophites, i. 220 note. Adopted as the'emblem ,)f heal- ing, 220 note. The old Egyptian symbol of a serpent with a hawk's head, 220 note Sorra on political economy, ii. 283 note Servetus, his death, ii. 49. Calvin applaud- ed for the crime. 52. Denounced by Cas- tellio, 54. But justified by Beza, 50 Eessa on the Jews, ii. 265 note Bforza, Francis, Duke of Milan, the first to establish a resident ambassador, ii. 282 note Shaftesbury, Lord, neglect into which his writiuss have fallen, i. 190. His denunci- ation of Christianity as incompatible with freedom, ii. 138 Shakspeare, his notices of witchcraft, i. 124 Sherlock, Dr.. his disregard of the dcctrins of passive obedience, ii. 183 note Silvanus, St., bishop of Nazareth, calumni- ated by the devil, i. 100 note Simancas, Bishop, on torture, i. 834 not-. . On faith with heretics. 394 note. On the influence of the Levitical laws on Chris- tian persecution, ii. 22 note Simon Magus, his introduction of the wo- man Helena as the incarnation of the Di- vine Thought, i. 220 Sin, the sense of, appealed most strongly to, by Christianity, i. 356. The conception of hereditary guilt, 857. Original, the doctrine of, rejected by Socinns, 372. And by Zuinglius, 373. Views of Chilling- worth and Jeremy Taylor, 374 note. The scope of the doctrine of the condemna- tion of all men extends to adults, 876. Views of the Fathers on the subject, 877. Effects of this doctrine, 380 et neq. The sense of sin the chief moral agent of the middle ages, ii. 197 Sinclair, professor of moral philosophy at Glasgow, his belief in witchcraft, i. 148 note Sixtus V. applauds the assassin Clement for his murder of Henri III., ii. 161 Slavery, the unchristian character of. strong- ly asserted by Wyclifr, ii. 168. Slavery the basis of the industrial system of anti- quity, 223. Effects of this institution on national character, 228. Comparison be- tween ancient and modern slavery, 225. lis abolition undertaken by Christianity, 227. First movement in favour of the slaves due to Seneca and his followers, 223. The invasion of the Barbarians in Italy favourable to the slaves, 228. But Christianity the most efficient opponent of the evil, 228. Review of the measures for abolishing slavery, 2'>9. Jewish slave- dealers, 230. The Emperor Gratian's bar- barous slave law, 230 note. Slavery grad- u.ally fades into serfdom, 230. xVnglo- Saxon measures for alleviating the condi- tion of slaves, 231. Sale of English slaves to the Irish, 238 note. Slaves in Italy in the thirteenth century. 239 note. Chris- tian, Jewish, and Mohammedan slaves, 239 note. Eflect of slavery upon the Spanish character. 317. Negro slaves in- troduced into the West Indies and Amer- ica, 817, 818. John Hawkins and the slave trade, 318. The slave trade first un- equivocally condemned by the Spanish Dominican Soto, ii. 818 note Sleep, connection of latent consciousnesa with, ii. 97 note Smith, Adam, on usury, ii. 250. On manu- factures and ain-iiiilliiiv, ."■.'^330 Smollett, Tobias, bis i.niniks on York Min- ster and Durlinin Callicln;!, i. 204 no/i' 'Soci.al contract,' the doeliiiie of the, as elab- orated by the Jesuits, ii. 148 Socinianism : position assigned to Socinians by Bossuet, ii. 60 Socinus, Faustus, unfavourable to political liberty, ii. 212. His career compared with that o'f Zuinglius, i. 372. Kejects origiu.t) sin, 372. Distinctively the npostle of toleration, ii. 51 Socrates, his idea of the soul, i. S40 382 INDEX. ' Solomon, Song of,' regarded by Castellio as | simply a love song,ll. 53. Niebuhr's re- mark on it, 53 note, Somers, Lord, bis defence of religious liber- ty, iL ST Somnambulism : the belief that somnambu- lists had been baptised by drunken priests, i. 864 note Soothsayers, laws of the later Romans against, i. 43 Sophia, the, of the Gnostics, i. 221 note Sorbonne, its declarations of the independ- ence of the civil power, ii. 166. Its deci- sion upon usury, ii. 24S note Sorcery. See Witchcraft Sortes and sortilegi, origin of the -svoids, 1. 287 note Soto, the Spanish Dominican, the first who unequivocally condemned the slave trade, ii. 318 note Soubervies, the, put a woman to death for witchcraft, i. 80 7iote Soul, the development of a purely spiritual conception of the, one of the causes of the decline of the mediaeval notions of hell, i. 339. Idea of the Platonists of a soul, 339. Opinions of the Fathers as to the form of the soul, 341 note Spain, numbers of sorcerers put to death in, i. 30. Abolition of torture in, 333. In- troduction and progress of the Inquisition in. ii. 113 et aeq. The Spanish Moors, 206. The plays of Oalderon and the drama in Spain, 807. The sceptre of industry al- most in the grasp of Spain, 811. Magnifi- cent position of that country under Charles v., 311. Speedy eclipse of her prosperity, 812. Causes of the downfall of Spain, 314 Sphin.x, the, believ«d by some of the early Christians to be connected with their faith, i. 214 note Spina on the opposition ofl"ered to the execu- tions in Italy for witchcraft, i. 105 Spitting, a religious exercise, i. 48 note Spratt, Thomas, bishop of Roch;'Ster, en- deavours to bring theology into harmony with the Baconian philosophy, i. 131. On the miraculous, 101 note Sprenger, the inquisitor, ascribes "William Teir's shot to the assistance of the devil, i. 31. Commissioned by Tope Innocent VIII., 32. Sprenger's book on sorcery, 82. His etymological blunders, 87 Stag, the, a symbol of Christ, i. 224. Pagan and middle-age legends respecting the, 224 note ' Stahl, his psychology, i. 846 note Star Chamber, its suppression of heretical books, ii. 119 Starovertsis, in Russia, their views of the sinfulness of usury, ii. 260 Statues, wooden, of Spain, i. 238 Strauss, his remjjiks on miracles quoted, i. 183 note Suarez, the Jesuit,- his work 'De Fide' burnt in Paris, i. 147. Origin of the work, 148 note. Condemnation of his book by a synod of Tonneins, 186, 187 Succubi, or feinalc di'vils, accordins to the early Chrisliaiis. i. 4S note. Lilith, the first wife of Adam, \\w quc-en of, 49 note. Succubi, culled ijcauuain Sith, common »raong Highlanders, 14S note SufTciring, tendency of the constant con- templation of, to blunt the alfcctions, i. 824 Sullv, his opposition to manufactures, il. 326 Sumptuary laws of the thirteenth and four teenth centuries, ii. 274 Supernatural, influences of the, uoon sav- ages, i. 41, 42 Superstition, pagan, existence of, from tho sixth to the twelfth century, i. 61 Supremacy, the oath of, compulsory under pain of death, ii. 47 note Sweden, sorcei-crs put to death in, in 1670, i. 31. Combination of devotion and immo- rality in, 391. Protestant persecutions in, ii. 49. Intolerance of, at the present time, 89 Swedenborg, Emanuol. his 'Doctrine of Correspondences,' i. 272 Swindon contends that the l;)cality of hell is in the sun, i. 847 note Swiss, their morality and irrcligion, i. 392 note Switzerland, gre.it numbers of witches put to death in,"i. 31. Protestant persecutions in, ii. 49 Sylphs, intercourse of philosophers with, i. 49 note. Belief of the Cabalists in the ex- istence of, 66 Sylvans, the, of the pagans, regarded, by the early Christians as devils, i. 49 Sylvester II., regarded as a magician, i. 282. Account of him and of his works, 283 note Symbolism, great love of. evinced by the art of the Catacombs, i. 213. The peacock the symbol of immortality, 213. And Orpheus, of the attractive power of Chris- tianity, 214. Mercury, Hercules, and the Sphinx, 214 note. The masks of the sun and moon, 214. The genii of the seasons and guardian angels, '.'l-l. T;io tish an emblem of Christ, 215. 'I'in- ^t:l- . ni]iloyed for the same purpose, '21. '.. lainiiiionof symbolical subjects from the Bible, 21e». St. Melito's catalogue of birds, beasts, plants, &c., which are to be regarded as Christian symbols, 273 note Syria, massacres in, ii. 45 TALISMANS for baffling the devices of the devil, i. 63 Talma, his improvements in stage represen- tations, ii. 215 Tanner, his views on usury, ii. 257 ■Tartuffe,' Molieres, origin of some of the incidents and speeches of, ii. 300 note Tan, why reverenced by the early Chris- tians, i. 205 note Taylor, Isaac, on patristic writings, i. 173 note Taylor, Jeremy, rejects the doctrine of original sin, i. 374 note. His remarks on the" separation of Christ from the intoler- ance of Judaism, ii. 21 note. His advo- cacy of religious liberty, 82. His 'Liberty of Prophesying,' 82. Arguments on which he based Lis claims for toleration, 83. Coleridge's remarks on him, 84 note. Or passiveobedience, 176 Tra, importation of, into Europe, ii. 321 Telemaehus, the monk, ii. 234 388 Toll, "William, his successful shot ascribed ] by Sprenger to the devil, i. 31 note Tempests, power of producing, attributed to the devil and to witches, i. 91 Templars, the, accused of sorcery, i. 31 note Terror everywhere the beginning of relig- ion, i. 40. Causes which produced in the twelfth century a spirit of rebellion which was encountered by terrorism, i. 73. Historv of religious terrorism. 315 ei seq. See Hell Tertuliian on the demons supposed to exist in his time, i. 47. His treatise 'De Co- rona,'50. Against pictures, 235 ?io^(?. Ef- fect of tlie dwtrine of eternal punishment on liis rlKirartei-. -^21, S'>d note. His denial of the cxistcnc*' in ni:iQ of any incorpo- r.Ml (.'IciiK'nt. -'A-i. His dcnnn'ciation of tin- i>a-in pni.'ticr of (lor-tr.-vinir the f.Hus in the v.-uiiih, ::(;i •»-,/,■. \\\< a.lvora.-v ,,r a1>s, His npiuiou that ecclesiastics sboulil never cause the death of men. 33. His denun- ciation of the theatre, 2S0 Thales regards water as the origin of all things, \. 206 note Theatre, revolutions in the. In France, ii. 21.5. Its influence upon national tastes, 2Sfi. Contrast between the theatres of til ■ <^\: <■':= ;i;h1 i;um.i-i=. e-?T. ^M-:ii i at- ism. 'JMl. Ilise <>•< ' '■ .:'>■•. Faint signs of Seen' i- > ,■ .,: r .■ ; u-, pantomimes, vte., of a higher order. ■::■■. Ii-iini uraiiKis, 293. French, 2!i;». liitluenee of music, 299. And of Gothic architecture, 300. Shape of the stasre in ancient and modern times, 303. Catises of a revulsion in the sentiments with wliieli tl;e theatre was regarded, 304. Fieiv,. ,,i,]H,.,iti,.;i ,,f the Church in France, ■'.oc,. The theatre in S].ain and Italy. oUT, ^08. Iniportaut ell'ects ot the ei.nt.-st lietweeu the church and the The ills. I he ]hn])eror, his prohibition of every i)ortiou of the i)agan worship, i. 59. Commands monks to betake themselves to desert places, 249 note. Annexes the penalty of death to the profession of a heresy, ii. 23 note. Prohibits all forms of heretical and pagan worship, 27. And the works of Nestorius and Eutyches, 118 Theology, influence of Dante over the con- ceptions of, i. 243. Distinction between theology and science unfelt in the time of Cosmas, 279. Dawn of the distinction between them, 279 note. Influence of theology on, and obstacles cast in the way of, science, 281. Relations of theology to morals, 310. Their complete separation in antifinity. All. The decline of theo- lo!,'ical In i;- I I lee- -^ary antecedent of the sueci . i, 1 1, ;.: i-.o"phers of the sev- enteenth ..iiu;r». ii. Theological in- terests ;;i;eliialiy ceiist; to be a main ob- ject of political combinations, ii. 102, The declining' iutlucnce of theology shown by the relitrions wars of the Preformation, 10'.'. Action of political life on the theo- logical habits of thought, 130. The stream of self-sacrlflce passing from theology to politics, 217. Points of contact of indus- trial and theolvjgical enterprises, 241. In- fluence of industry upon theological judg- ments, 273. Theological agencies not pa- cific, 336 Therapcutcs, the, mentioned by Philo, ii. 346 note Theta, why regarded as the unlucky letter, i. 205 note Timanthes, his Eacrifice of Iphigenia, i. 239 note Tindal, bis works in defence of liberty, ii. 1S4 note Titian, compared with Praxiteles, i. 256 Toland, his 'Anjlica Libera,' ii. 185 note. His other works. 1^5 not,' Toledo, sujiiiosed to be ;he head-quarters of sorcei-eis in Spain, i. 30 note Tohiation, assertion of, by Zuinglius and Soeiiiiis, ii. 51. Toleration favoured by the mingling of religions produced by the Eeformation, 62. And by the marriage of the clersv, 62. And by the greater flex- ibility of "Protestantism, 62. Sketch of the history of toleration in France, 6-3-74. The absolute unlawfulness of toleration maintained bv ISishop P.ilson, 47 note. The duty of absolute toleration preached for the first time in Christendom, 54. Toleration extolled and uplieid by Eras- mus, Sir T. More, Hopital, and Lord Bal- tnnore, 59. Sketch of the history of tol- eration in Kngland, 75--S6. Intolerance in Sweden at the iiresent day, 89. The basis of iiKHhrii toler:mce advocated in favour of the luiiuh-ition, 11,5. Literary censor- ship exercised auainst heretical writiuirs, lis. Kemoval uf reli-ious ilisaliilities in England and Inlaii.l, l-Jl-i-.'.\ Inlhience of commerce in leading men to loleiancc, '-'(;■_'. F.tfeel ot' reli-ious intolerauceon the downfall of S|,aiii.:-!19 T.ilei-atlon Act. passing of the, ii. 86, 87 Tolettis, Franciscus, his justification of ty- rannicide, ii. 159 Tonneins, synod of, its condemnation of tl^e work of Suarez, ii. 1S6, 187 note Torquemada, his attempts to extirpate witchcraft in Spain, i. 30 Procures an edict expelling the Jews from Spain, ii. 267 Torture, illegality of, in England, i. 122. A horrible case of, presided over by James 1 , 123 note. Tortures to compel confes- sion of witches in Scotland, 147. In Greece and Kome, 332. Extent to which it was carried by me.lia'val Christendom, 332 note. Maisilius' invention of a tor- ture depriving the prisoner of all sleep, S'i'i note. Illegality of torture in Eng- land, 333. Extent to which it was em- ployed by Catholics under Mary. 333 note. And by Protestants, 833 note. Abolished in France, Spain, Italy, Knssia, Prussia, and Tuscany, 334. .St. AuL'ustine's state- ment of the case .against toitine, 335 note. Causes which produced the feeling against torture, 835. Torture of heretics enjoined by Pope Innocent IV., ii. 42 note. Tor- ture applied to the investigation of charges of usury, 250 Toulouse, number of sorcerers put to death 584 at, in one time, i. 29. Four hundred witches burnt in the square ol" ii. 46 Towns, modern industrial history begun by the emancipation of the, ii. 240. Privi- leges of burghers in the middle ages, 289 note.. Importance of corporations and guilds in the middle ages, 240. The con- liict between the towns and the countr_y, ii. 324. Changes cflected in their relative importance, 325 Tractarian movement, i. 173, 180, 181 Trent, Council of, on infant baptism, i. 306 Tri'vcs, vast number of witches burnt at, i. 29 Trinitj\ first Person of the, Roman Catholic representations of, all comparatively mod- ern, i. 210 'Truce of God,' the, proclaimed, ii. 108. Confirmed by Pope Alexander III. as a general law of the Church, 108 note Truth, injuriou.s effect of the doctrine of exclusive salvation on the senoe of, i. 393. ' Pious frauds,' 393 and note 394. Total destruction of the sense of truth in the middle ages resulting from the influence- of theology, 394. Credulity proclain>ed a virtue by the classes most addicted to falsehood, 395. Revival of the sense of truth due to the secular philosophers of the seventeenth century, 399 Turgot on money-lending, quoted, ii. 248 note. His remarks on the scholastic writings on usury, ii. 253 note, 260 Tuscany, abolition of torture in, i. 334 Tyrannicide in immature civilisations, ii. 150, 156. Case of Henry HI., 150, 151. Chief arguments on either side, 151-]58. Its impoitancc in the history of liberal opinions, 158. Justified by Jean Petit, 158. But denounced by Gerson and the Council of Constance, 159. Grevin's play of ' The Death of Cajsar,' 159. Advocated by Toletus, Sa, Molina, Ayala, and Kel- leius, 159, 160. The murder of Henry III. justified by the League and by Pope Six- tus v., 161. Political assassination ap- proved Liy Protestants, 161 ITLTRAMONTANE party in the Church iJ of Kome, review of the. ii. 140 Universe, the morphological theory of the, i. 294. Influence of this theory on history, 295 Usher, Archbishop, heads a protest against Catholic relief, ii, 48. His scntimenls on passive obedience, 1T6 note Usury, a ground of collision between indus- try and the Church, ii. 242. Principlos which regulate the price of money, 242 and note. Ignorance of the ancients of the principles regulating interest, 244. Money-lending among the Greeks and Gauls, 244. Interest condomuod by the early and mediaval Church, 245. Usury in England in the middle ages, 246 7iote. Twelve per cent, legalised by Constan- tino, 246 « 0^1?. Decrees of the Councils of Nice and lUiberis on the subject, 247 note. Definitions of usury ^ployed by the wiiters on Canon Law, 247 note. Change the word usury has undergone dui'ing the last throe centuries. 247. De- cision of the Sorbonne, 248 note. The 'Monti di Pieta' of Italy, 249. Argu- ments upon which the doctrines of thu theologians against usury were based, 250. Passages of Scripture cited against usury, 252. Effect of the prohibition of usury in Catholic countries on the habits of the people, 253 note. Usurers almost always Jews, 254. French law of the eighth cen- tury, 253 note. Law of Justinian, 253 note. Christian money-lenders at the close of the eleventh century, 254. Usury made popular by the rise of the Italian Republics, 254. Decree of the Third Council of Lateran, 254. And of the Council of Vienne, 255 7iot6. The old su- peistition respeetins usury shaken bv the Reformation, 255, 2o6. Views of Calvin, 256. Money-lending formally permitted by Henry VIIL in England, 256. Books of Saumaise in defence of interest, 256. Change in the meaning of the word usury in the sixteenth century, 257. Casuistry of the Jesuits, 257. Gradual disappear- ance of the laws upon usury based upon theological grounds, 259. Discussion of the economical question by Locke, Smith, Hume, Turgot, and Bentham, 259 et seq. Importance of this controversy in pro- ducing an antagonism between industry and theology, 260, 261. Controversy in the middle ages as to the propriety of per- mitting Jews to practise usury, 266 note Utilitarianism, the philosophical expression of industrialism, ii. 352. Evils resulting from this philosophy, 353 VALENS, the Emperor, his persecution ol pagan magic in the East, i. 57 Yalentiiiian, the Emperor, renews the per- secution against pagan magic, i. 57 Valery, witches burnt at, i. 31 Vanini, his view of the influence of the stars over the fortunes of Clu-istianity, i. 284 note Vavassor, 'De Forma Christi,' i. 245 note Venice, licentiousness of, i. 255. Influence of its sensuality upon art, 255. The dyers of, in the middle ages, 255 note. Period of the introduction bf the inquisition into Venice, ii. 113. Commerce of the Vene- tians, 282 Ventriloquism, attributed to supernatural agency, i. 119 Venus, the Greek statues of, a type of sen- sual beauty, i. 243. The character of sen- suality said to have been given by Praxi- teles to, 257 note Verona, execution of heretics in, ii. 117 note Vesta, supposed by the Cabalists to have been the wife of Noah, i. 67 note Vice, influence of, on historic development, ii. 70 Vicuna, Council of, its endeavours to arrest the progress of usury, ii. 254 Vincent Ferrier, St., preaches against the Jews, ii. 267. Account of him, 268 -note Vincentius, his opinions on intant baptism, i. 861 ' Vindieia; contra Tyrannos,' the. ii. 1«S, 1S9 Virgilius, St.. asserts his belief in tlie ex- istence of the Antipodes i. 2S() 385 Virstin, causes of the gro-ivin^ worsliip of the, i. 220. strengthened by Gnosticism. 222, 223. Conceptions culled from the dif- ferent beliefs of paganism more or less connected with the ideal of this worship, 223. Mariolatry strengthened by dogmat- ic definitions, 224 Instances in the mid- dle ages of a desire to give a palpable form to the mystery of the incarnation, 224 not(. The worship of the Virgin strengthened by painting, fay celibacy, and by tlie crusades, 225. No authentic por- trait of her in the time of St. Augustine, 224 note. Generally represented in the early church with the Infant Child, 224 vote. The tnrst notice of the resemblance of Christ to her, 224 note. Appearance of the doctrine of the immaculate concep- tion, 225. Salutary influence exercised by the mediitval conception of the Virgin, 226. The Virgin regarded as an omnipres- ent deity, 22(x The Psalms adapted by St. Bona'ventura to her worship, 2*27 Virtue, pursuit of, for its own sake, i. SOT. The substitution of the sense of right for the fear of punishment as the main motive of virtue, 315 et seq. The sense of, ap- pealed most strongly to by the philoso- jihers of ancient Greece and Bome, 356 ViVes, Luis, his protest against torture in Spain, i. 334 note. His opinions de- nounced by Bishop Simancas, 334 note. Of spontaneous generation, 344 note Voltaire, on the decadence in the belief in witchcraft, 117 and note. Effect of his ridicule, IIS. His denunciation of torture, 833 note. Impulse given by him to the amelioration of the penal code, 850. His influence on the spirit of toleration in France, ii. 71, 72. His approval of the partition of Poland, 213 note. His ode to the memory nf Le Couvreur the actress, 305. His removal of the stigma that rest- ed upon actors, 309. His efforts iu favour jf Deace, 337 WAGSTAFFE, an Oxford scholar, his op- I osition to the belief in the existence of witchcraft, i. 137. Notice of him from Wood, 137 vote 'Waking' witches, i. 145 War, clianges in the art of, favourable to liberty, ii. 205. Change in the relative position of the cavalry and infantry, 205. The English archers, 205. Kise of the Flemish infantry, 206. The Italian con- dottieri, 206. The invention of gunpow- der and of the bayonet, 206, 2077 Three heads under which the causes of the wars during the last 1.000 years may be classed, 219. Close of religious wars, 110 ^Varbu^ton, Bishop, helps to usher in a new phase in the history of miracles, i. 173. His notion of the origin of Gothic archi- tecture, 264 note. His argument in favour of the divine origin of Judaism, 318 7l0t6 Water, baptismal, fetish notions in the early Church respecting the, i. 205. Notion cf the sanctity of, i. 206 note. Why witches were plunged into, 206 note. Regarded by Thales as the origin of all things, 206 VOL. II.— 51 I note. Ovid on the expiatory power of, 206«o^e Wealth, posltii. Stroud, 11. D. With a Letter on the Subject by Sir James Y. Simpson, Bart., M. D. 1 vol., 12mo. Cloth. Price, $2.00. Dr. William Stroud's treatise on " The Physical Cause of tlio Death of Dni'^t. and its Eelation to the Pi-inci_ples and Practice of Christianitj%" altliouijii ii..w fiist iv].rintea in this country, has maintained, for the last quarter o'f a century, n iiiiat n ]iutatiiin in England. It is, in its own place, a masterpiece. "It could lime lucn eiiiii]H)seil," s.ays Dr. Stroud's biographer, '■ only by a man characterized by a comliination of superior en- dowments. It requu-ed, on the one hand, a profound acquaintance \\-ith medical sub- jects and medical literature. It required, on the other, an equally profound acquaint- ance with the Bible, and with theology in general." The object of the treatise is to demonstrate an Important phy sical fact connected with the death of Christ — namely, that it was caused by rupture of the heart — and to point out its relation to the princi- ples and practice of Christianity. WESTWARD BY RAIL: THE 'NEW ROUTE TO THE EAST. By W. F. Rae. 1 vol., 12mo. Cloth. 390 pages. Price, $2.00. The author of this work, one of the editors of the London Daili/ Neirs, was a stanch defender of the Union, and his work is one of the most just and appreciative books on America yet published by an Englishman. " There is a quiet and subtle charm, as well as a deep and true romantic interest, in the story of the railway journey." — Westminster lieview. '■■ He" has given us a verv pleasant and instructive book, which we heartily commend to the attention of all thoughtful and inquiring readers."— G'/f/.ssroM) 3Iail. " Ho has written a most readable, interesting, and attractive account of a journey which is long enough to be worth the complete description he has given it"—Ol>se>'i-er. THE REyELATIO:N" OF JOHT^, with ^""otes, Criti- cal, Explanatory, and Practical. Designed for both Pastors and People. By Rev. Hknry Cowles, D. D. 1 vol., 12nio, cloth. Price, $1.50. D. Appleton & Co. also publish by the same Author : " Minor Proph- ets." 12mo, cloth. Price, $2.00; " Ezekiel and Daniel." r2mo, cloth. $2.25; "Isaiah." With Notes, $2.25; "Jeremiah." 1 vol., 12mo. $2.00; "Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Songs of Solomon." $2.00. 549 & 551 Broad'wat, New Yokk. D. APPLETON & CO;S NEW WOPJvS. A TREATISE ON DISEASES OF THE NEE- VOUS SYSTEM. By William A. Hammond, M. D., Professor of Diseases of the Mind and Nervous System, and of Clinical Medicine, in the Bellevue Hospital Medical College ; Physician-in-chief to the New- York State Hospital for Diseases of the Nervous System, etc. With Forty-five Illustrations. 1 vol., 8vo, 750 pages. Price, 85.00. "In the following work I have endeavored to present a "Treatise on Diseases of the Nervous S3'stem,' which, without being superficial, would be concise and explicit, and which, while making no claim to being exhaustive, would nevertheless be sufficiently complete for the instruction and guidance of those who might be disposed to seek in- formation from its pages. How far I have been successful will soon be determined by the judgment of those more competent than myself to form an unbiassed opinion. '• One feature I may, however, with justice claim for this work, and that is, that it rests, to a great extent, on my own observation and experience, and is, therefore, no mere compilation. The reader will readily perceive that I have views of my own on every disease considered, and that I have not hesitated to express thorn.— Ea^tract from the Preface. Over fifty diseases of the nervous system, including insanity, are considered iu this treatise. OK THE PHYSIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF SE- VERE AND PROTRACTED MUSCULAR EXERCISE, with Spe- cial Reference to its Influence upon the Excretion of JSltrogen. By Austin Flint, Jr., M. D., Professor of Physiology in the Bellevue Hospital Medical College, New York. 1 vol., 8vo. Cloth. Price, §1.25. APPLETOXS' HAND-BOOK OF AMEPJCAjST 'travel. Northern and Eastern Tour. New edition, revised for the Summer of 1871. Including New York, New Jersey, Pennsylva- nia, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, A''ermont, and the British Dominion, being a Guide to Niagara, the White Mountains, the Alleghanies, the Catskills, the Adirondacks, the Berkshire Hills, the St. Lawrence, Lake Champlain, Lake George, Lake Jlemphremagog, Saratoga, Newport, Cape May, the Hudson, and other Famous Localities ; with full Descriptive Sketches of the Cities, Towns, Rivers, Lakes, Waterfalls, Mountains, Hunting and Fishing Grounds, Watering-places, Sea-side Resorts, and all scenes and objects of importance and interest within the district named. With Maps and various Skeleton Tours, arranged as suggestions and guides to the Traveller. One vol., 12mo. Flexible cloth. Price, $2.00. JAMES GORDON'S WIFE. A Novel. 8vo. Paper. Price, 50 cents. "An interesting novel, pleasantly written, refined in tone, and easy in style." — London Globe. " This novel is conceived and executed in the purest spirit. The illustrations of society in its various phases are cleverly and spiritedly done." — London Post. 549 & 551 Broadwat, New York. D. APPLETON & CO;S NEW WOPvKS. THE PRINCIPLES OF PSYCHOLOGY. By Herbert SPEXCEn. 1 vol., 8vo. Cloth. Price, $2.50. This work is thouglit by many aljle judges to be the most original and vahiable con- tribution to the science of mind that has aiiiicai-ed in tlu- inx'seiit centurv. Juliii Stuart Mill says it is -'one of the finest examples w.' [mism:- of the i»y.li..l..-ie;Ll nieihod in its full'iiower." Dr. MeCosh says '-his beld -ein ra!i/ations are ah\:iys Miij^i stive, and some may in the end be established in the prdl'mnuUst laws uf the ]k is high in tone and excellent in style. GOOD FOR NOTHING. A Novel. By AYhyte Melville. Author of " Digby Grand," " The Interpreter," etc. 1 vol., 8vo, 210 pages. Price, 60 cents. " The interest of the reader in the stoiy, which for the most part is laid in England, IS enthrailmg from the beginning to the end. The moral tone Is altogether imexception- ab\e:'—T/ie'Chro7iide. A HAND-BOOK OF LAW, for Business Men ; con- taining an Epitome of the Law of Contracts, Bills and Notes, inter- est. Guaranty and Suretyship, Assignments for Creditors, Agents, Factors, and Brokers, Sales, Mortgages, and Liens, Patents and Copyrights, Trade-Marks, the Good-Will of a Business, Carriers, In- surance. Shipping, Arbitrations, Statutes of Limitation, Partnership, with an Appendix, containing Forms of Instruments used in the Transaction of Business. By'WiLLiAM Tracy, LL. D. 1 vol., Svo, 679 pages. Half basil, $5. 5(); library leather, $6.50. This work is an epitome of those brandies of law which affect the ordinary transactions of BUSINESS MEN. It Is iiot ]iroj,ose.l hij it to mal-c every man a lawyer, but to give a man of business a convenient and reliable book of reference, to assist hun in the sohi- tion of questions relating to his rights and duties, which are constantly aiislng, and to guide him in conducting his negotiations. In preparing It, the aim has been to set forth, in plain language, the rules which constitute the doctrines of law which are examined, and to ilhintrate the mme hy decisiom of the Courts in which they are reoognUed, with marginal eefeh- ENCES TO TUE V0LU.ME3 WHEKE TUE CASES MAY BE FOUND. NEW YORK ILLUSTRATED ; with Fifty-nine Il- lustrations. A Descriptive Text and a Map of the City. An entirely new edition, brought down to date, with new Illustrations. Price, 50 cents. ' There has never been published so beautiful a guide-book to New Tork as this is. A suitable letter-press accompanies the woodcuts, the whole forming a picture of New York such as no other book affords.''— -Ve^o York World. 549 & 551 Broadway, New York. D. APPLETON & CO.'S NEW AVORKS, THE NOVELS AND NOYELISTS OF THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY. In Illustration of the Manners and Morals of the Age. By William Forsyth, M. A., Q. C. 1 vol., I'imo. Cloth. Price, $1.50. Mr. Forsyth, in his instructive and entertaining volume, has succeeded in showing t'aat much real information concerniag the morals as well as the manners of our ances- tors may be gathered from the novelists of the last century. With judicial impartiality he examines and cross-examines the witnesses, laying all the evidence before the reader. Essayists as well as novelists are called up. The Spectator, The Tatler, The "World, The Connoisseur, add coaflrmition strong to the testimony of Parson Adams, TruUiber, Trunnion, Squire Western, the "Fool of Quality," '-Betsey Thoughtless," and the Uke. A chapter on dress is suggestive of cjmparisoa. Costume is a subject on which novel- ists, like careful artists, are studiously precise. EEMIXISCEXCES OF FIFTY YEAES. BjMakk Boyd. 1 vol., 12mo, 390 pp. Price, $l.1o. Mr. Boyd h;i^ s- ■:[ iir.i -h nt' lit'- at home and abroad. He has enjoyed the acquaint- ance or frienilship ..f nrniv illii-iiio'is rntrn, and he has the additional advantage of re- membering a iiuuili :■ oi :iii ■ l,.:. , loM by his father, who possessed a retentive memory and a wide cux-le of distinL^Liis'ajd friends. The book, as the writer acknowledges, is a perfect olla podridu. Tliarj is caasider.vble variety in the anecdotes. Some relate to great generals, like the Duke of Wellington and Lord 'Clyde ; some to artists and men of lertters, and these include th? nimos of Campbell, Rogers, Thacketay, and David Roherts ; some to statesmen, and, among others, to Pitt, who was a friend of Mr. Boyd's father, to Lords Palmerston, Brougham, and Derby ; some to discoverers, like Sir John Franklin and Sir John Ross: and others— .\'jiDag which may be reckoned, perhaps, the most amusing in the volume — io persons wholly unknown to fame, or to manners and customs now hijipily obsjleta. FEAGMENTS OF SCIENCE FOE UNSCIEN- TIFIC PEOPLE. A Series of Detached Essays, Lectures, and Re- views. By John Tyndall, LL. D., F. R. S. 1 vol., 12mo. Cloth. 422 pages. Price, $2.00. Prof. Tyndall is tiis Po2t o? Modern Science. This is a book of genius — one of those r.ire productions that come but once in a generation. Prof Tyndall is not only a bold, broad, and original thinker, but one of the most eloquent and attractive of writers. In this volume he goes over a large range of scientific questions, giving us the latest views in the most lucid and graphic language, so that the subtlest order of invisible changes stand out with all the vividness of stereo- scopic perspective. Though a disciplined scientific thinker. Prof. T^mdall is also a poet, alive to all beauty, and kindles into a glow of enthusiasm at the harmonies and wonders of Nature which he sees on every side. To him science is no mere dry inventory of prosaic facts, but a disclosure of the Divine order of the world, and fitted to stir the highest feelings of our nature. GABEIELLE ANDEE. An Historical Novel. By S. Baring-Gould, author of " Myths of the Middle Ages." 1 vol., 8vo. Paper covers. Price, 60 cents. Those who take an interest in comparing the effects of the present French Revolu- tion on the Church with that of 1739 will find in this work a great deal of information illustrating the feeling in the State and Church of France at that period. The Literary Churchman says: "The book is a remarkably able one, full of vigorous and often ex- tr3-_n^ly beautiful writing and description." 549 & 551 Broadway, New York. D. APPLETON & CO.'S NEW WORKS. MUSINGS OVER THE CHRISTIAN YEAR AND LYRA INNOCENTIUM. By Charlotte Mary Yonge, together with a few Gleanmgs of liecollection, gathered by Several Friends. 1 vol. Thick 12mo, 431 pages. Price, $2.00. Miss Yonge has here produced a vohime which will possess great interest in tlic eyes of Churchmen, who have for so many years enjoyed the privilege of reading the exquisite poetry of the " Christian Year" by Eev. John Keble. Miss Yonge gives her own experience of the uninterrupted intercom'se of thirty years ; then there are the " EecoUeetions,'' by Francis M. Wilbraham ; a few words of '■ Personal Description," by Eev. T. Simpson Kvans ; then foUow the '■ Musings," one each of the poems illustrative of the "Christian Year and Lyra Innocentium." THE HEIR OF REDCLYFFE. By Ciiaelotte M. Yonge. A Xew Illustrated Edition. 2 vols., 12mo. Cloth. Price, S2.00. To be followed by HEARTSEASE. " The first of her writings which made a sensation here was the ' Heir, and what a sensation it was ! Eeferrlng to the remains of the tear-washed covers of the copy afore- said, we tind it belonged to the ' eighth thousand.' How many thousands have been issued since by the publishers, to supply the demand for new, and the places of drowned, dissolved, or swept away old copies, we do not attempt to conjecture. Not individuals merely, but households — consisting in great part of tender-hearted young damsels — ^were plunged into mourning. With a tolerable acquamtance vvith fictitious heroes (not to speak of real ones), from Pir Charles Grandlson down to the nursery idol, Carlton, we have little hesitation in pionouiicing Sir Guy Morville, or Eedclyflfe, Baronet, the most adminiMe one Ave ever nirt with, in story or out. The glorious, joyous boy, the brilliant, nrdent child of genius and of fortune, crowned with the beauty of his early hoUness, and Dvershadowed with the darkness of his hereditary gloom, and the soft and touching sad- ness of his early death— what a caution is there ! What a vision ! " — Extract from a re- view of " The Ileir of Eedcljrffe," and '• Heartsease," in the North American Revieit for April, A COMPREHENSIVE DICTIONARY OF THE BIBLE ; mainly abridged from Dr. William Smith's " Dictionary of the Bible," but comprising important Additions and Improvements from the Works of Robinson, Gesenius, Furst, Pape, Pott, Winer, Keil, Lange, Kitto, Fairbairn, Alexander, Barnes, Bush, Thomson, Stanley, Porter, Tristram, King, Ayre, and many other eminent scholars, commentators, travellers, and authors in various depart- ments. Designed to be a Complete Guide in regard to the Pronun- ciation and Signification of Scriptural Names ; the Solution of Dif- ficulties respecting the Interpretation, Authority, and Harmony of the Old and New Testaments ; the History and Description of Bib- lical Customs, Events, Places, Persons, Animals, Plants, Minerals, and other things concerning which information is needed for an in- telligent and thorough study of the Holy Scriptures, and of the Books of the Apocrypha. Illustrated with Five Hundred Maps and Engravings. Edited by Rev. Samuel W. Baknum. Complete in one large royal octavo volume of 1,234 pages. Price, in cloth bind- ing, $5.00 ; in library sheep, $6.00 ; in half .norocco, $7.50. 549 & 551 Beoadwat, New York. D. APPLETON Sl CO.'S NEW WORKS. LIGHT AND ELECTRICITY. Notes of Two Courses of Lectures before the Royal Institution of Great Britain. By John Tyndall, LL. D., F. R. S. 1 vol., 12mo. Cloth. Price, 81.25. " For the benefit of those who attended his Lectures on Light and Electricity at the Eoyal Institution, Prof. Tyndall prepared with much care a series of notes, summing up briefly and clearly the leading facts and pi-incip!es of these sciences. The notes proved so serviceable to those for whom they were designed that they were widely sought by students and teachers, and Prof. Tyndall had them reprinted in two small books. Under the conviction that they will be equally appreciated by instructors and learners in this country, they are here combined and republished in a single volumQ:'—£xtract from Freface. THE DESCENT OF MAN AND SELECTION IX RELATION TO SEX. By Charles Darwin, M. A. With Illustrations. 2 vols., 12mo. Cloth. Price, $4.00. "We can find no fault -with Mr. Dai-win's facts, or the application of them." — Utica Herald. " The theory is now indorsed by many eminent scientists, who at first combated it, including Su' Charles Lyell, probably the most learned of hving geologists.''" — Ecening Bulletin. ON THE GENESIS OF SPECIES. Bj St. George Mivart, F. R. S. 1 vol., 12mo. Cloth, with Illustrations. Price, $l.'7o. " Mr. Mivart has succeeded in producing a work which will clear the ideas of biolo ■ gists and theologians, and which treats the most delicate questions in a manner which throws light upon most of them, and tears away the barriers of intolerance on each side." — British Medical Journal. MARQUIS AND MERCHANT. A Novel. By Mortimer Collins. 1 vol., 8vo. Paper covers. Price, 50 cents. " TVe will not compare Mr. ColUns, as a novelist, with Mr. Disraeli, but, nevertheless, the qualities which have made Mr. Disraeli's fictions so widely popular are to be found in no small degree in the pages of the author of ' Marquis and Merchant.' " — Times. HEARTSEASE. A Novel. By the author of the " Heir of RedclyfFe." An Illustrated Edition. 2 vols., 12rao. Price, $2.00. This is the second of the series of Miss Yonge's novels, now being issued in a new and beautiful style wiih illustrations. Since this novel was first published anew genera- tion of readers have appeared. Nothing in the English language can equal the delinea- tion of character which she so beautifully portrays. WHAT TO READ, AND HOW TO READ, being Classified Lists of Choice Reading, with appropriate hints and remarks, adapted to the general reader, to subscribers, to li- braries, and to persons intending to form collections of books. Brought down to September, 1870. By Charles H. Moore, M. D. 1 vol., 12mo. Paper Covers, 50 cents. Cloth. Price, 75 cents. Date Due ■'■^. , - — — • ' " ■ i~ I r iiri II r ■*^ • "^ f)