The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia, Vol. 3 Hosted text — Tower of Babel library. Source: Internet Archive . Public domain. Cornell University The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924095207126 CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY NT 924 095 207 126 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA _ JAMES ORR, M.A., D.D., Generat Eprror JOHN L. NUELSEN, D.D., LL.D. EDGAR Y. MULLINS, D.D., LL.D. ASSISTANT EDITORS MORRIS O. EVANS, D.D., Pu.D., Manacine Eprror VOLUME III HERESY— NAARAH CHICAGO THE HOWARD-SEVERANCE COMPANY 1915 Hermon Herod On the other hand there is no evidence that there ever was a time when “all they which are in Asia” (AV) turned away from obedience 3. Unlike- to Paul. Whatever may have been lihood of It the disloyalty and disobedience of Being in individuals—and this certainly existed; Ephesus see, e.g., Acts 20 29f—yet, certainly the NT does not show that all that were in Asia, the Christian community as a whole, in Ephesus and Miletus and Laodicea and Hiera- polis and Colossae and other places, repudiated his apostolic authority. If the words 4, Proba- ‘all they which are in Asia” refer to bility of It all the Christians from the procon- Being in sular province of Asia, who happened Rome to be in Rome at the time of Paul’s second imprisonment there, it can easily be understood that they should turn away from him at that testing time. It is impossible to say exactly what form their desertion of the apostle assumed. Their turning away would likely be caused by fear, lest if it were known that they were friends of the prisoner in the Mamertine, they would be involved in the same imprisonment as had over- taken him, and probably also in the same death penalty. : It is altogether in favor of a reference to Rome, that what is said about Phygellus and Hermogenes and their turning away from Paul is immediately followed by a reference to Onesiphorus, and to the great kindness which he showed, when he sought the apostle out very diligently in Rome. On the whole, therefore, a reference to Rome and to the manner in which these persons, named and un- named, from Asia, had deserted Paul, seems most probable. See Poycettus. Joun Ruruerrurp HERMON, hir’mon (JT4°, hermon; B, ‘Aep- pov, Haermén): The name of the majestic moun- tain in which the Anti-Lebanon range 1. Descrip- terminates to the 8. (Dt 3 8, etc). tion It reaches a height of 9,200 ft. above the sea, and extends some 16 to 20 miles from N. to §. It was called Sirion by the Sidonians (Dt 3 9; cf Ps 29 6), and Senir by the Amorites (Dt 3 9). It is also identified with Sion (Dt 4 48). See Srrton; Senter; Sion. Some- times it is called “Mt. Hermon” (Dt 3 8; Josh 11 17; 1 Ch 5 23, etc); at other times 2. The simply “Hermon” (Josh 11 3; Ps Hermons 89 12, etc). . Once it is called ‘“Her- mons’ (0°72, herménim). AV mistakenly renders this “the Hermonites” (Ps 42 6). It must be a reference to the triple summits of the mountain. There are three distinct heads, rising near the middle of the mass, the two higher being toward the E. The eastern declivities are steep and bare; the western slopes are more grad- ual; and while the upper reaches are barren, the lower are well wooded; and as one descends he passes through fruitful vineyards and orchards, finally entering the rich fields below, in Wady et- Teim. The Aleppo pine, the oak, and the poplar are plentiful. The wolf and the leopard are still to be found on the mountain; and it is the last resort of the brown, or Syrian, bear. Snow lies long on the summits and shoulders of the mountain; and in some of the deeper hollows, esp. to the N., it may be seen through most of the year. Mt. Hermon is the source of many blessings to the land over which it so proudly lifts its splendid form. Refreshing breezes blow from its cold heights. Its snows are carried to Damascus and to the towns on the seaboard, where, mingled with the shardb, “drink,” they mitigate the heat of the Syrian summer. Great reservoirs in the depths of the mountain, fed by the melting snows, find outlet THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1378 in the magnificent springs at Hasbetyeh, Tell el- Kady, and Banids, while the dew-clouds of Hermon bring a benediction wherever they are carried (Ps 133 3). rs marked the northern limit of Joshua’s victorious campaigns (Josh 12 1, etc). It was part of the dominion of Og (ver 5), and with the fall of that monarch, it would naturally come under Israelitish influ- ence. Its remote and solitary heights must have attracted worshippers from the earliest times; and we cannot doubt that it was a famous sanctuary in far antiquity. Under the highest peak are the ruins of Kasr ‘Antar, which may have been an ancient sanctuary of Baal. Onom speaks of a temple on the summit much frequented by the surrounding peoples; and the remains of many temples of the Rom period have been found on the sides and at the base of the mountain. The sacred- ness of Hermon may be inferred from the allusion in Ps 89 12 (cf En 6 6; and see also Baan HER- MON). sae have thought that the scene of the Trans- figuration should be sought here; see, however, TRANSFIGURATION, Mount oF. The modern name of Hermon is Jebel eth-Thilj, “mount of snow,” or Jebel esh-sheikh, ‘mount of the elder,” or “of the chief.” ; Little Hermon, the name now often applied to the hill between Tabor and Gilboa, possibly the Hill of Moreh, on which is the sanctuary of Neby Dahy, has no Bib. authority, and dates only from the Middle Ages. W. Ewina HERMONITES, hir’mon-its: In Ps 42 6 AV, where RV reads ‘‘Hermons.” See Hermon. 3. Sanctu- aries HEROD, her’ud: The name Herod (Hp#éys, Hérédés) is a. familiar one in the history of the Jews and of the early Christian church. The name itself signifies “‘heroic,’’ a name not wholly applicable to the family, which was characterized by craft and knavery rather than by heroism. The for- tunes of the Herodian family are inseparably con- nected with the last flickerings of the flame of Judaism, as a national power, before it was forever extinguished in the great Jewish war of rebellion, 70 AD. The history of the Herodian family is not lacking in elements of greatness, but whatever these elements were and in whomsoever found, they were in every case dimmed by the insufferable egotism which disfigured the family, root and branch. Some of the Herodian princes were undeniably talented; but these talents, wrongly used, left né marks for the good of the people of Israel. Of nearly all the kings of the house of Herod it may truly be said that at their death “they went without being de- sired,” unmissed, unmourned. The entire family history is one of incessant brawls, suspicion, in- trigue and shocking immorality. In the baleful and waning light of the rule of the Herodians, Christ lived and died, and under it the foundations of the Christian church were laid. The Herodians were not of Jewish stock. Herod the Great encouraged the circulation of the legend of the family descent from an illus- i. The trious Bab Jew (Ant, XIV, i, 3), but Family it has no historic basis. It is true the Descent Idumaeans were at that time nominal _ Jews, since they were subdued by John Hyrcanus in 125 BC, and embodied in the Asmionein kingdom through an enforced circumcision, but the old national antagonism remained (Gen 27 41). The Herodian family sprang from Antipas (d. 78 BC), who was appointed governor of Idumaca by Alexander Jannaeus. His son Antipater, who suc- 1379 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hermon Herod ceeded him, possessed all the cunning, resourceful- ness and unbridled ambition of his son Herod the Great. He had an open eye for two things—the un- conquerable strength of the Rom power and the _ Pitiable weakness of the decadent Asmonean house, and on these two factors he built the house of his hopes. He craftily chose the side of Hyrcanus II in his internecine war with Aristobulus his brother (69 BC), and induced him to seek the aid of the Romans. Together they supported the claims of Pompey and, after the latter’s defeat, they availed themselves of the magnanimity of Caesar to submit to him, after the crushing defeat of Pompey at Pharsalus (48 BC). Asa reward, Antipater re- ceived the procuratorship of Judaea (47 BC), while his innocent dupe Hyrcanus had to satisfy himsclf with the high-priesthood. Antipater died by the hand of an assassin (43 BC) and left four sons, Phasael, Herod the Great, Joseph, Pheroras, and a daughter Salome. The second of these sons raised the family to its highest pinnacle of power and in raising the always welcome tribute-money for the Rom government, gained for him additional power at court. His advance became rapid. Antony appointed him “‘tetrarch” of Judaea in 41 BC, and although he was forced by circumstances temporarily to leave his domain in the hands of the Parthians and of Antigonus, this, in the end, proved a, blessing in disguise. In this final spasm of the dying Asmoncan house, Antigonus took Jerus by storm, and Phasael, Herod’s oldest brother, fell into his hands. The latter was governor of the city, and foreseeing his fate, he committed suicide by dashing out his brains against the walls of his prison. Antigonus incapacitated his brother Hyr- canus, who was captured at the same time, from ever holding the holy office again by cropping off his ears (Ant, XIV, xiii, 10). Meanwhile, Herod was at Rome, and through the favor of Antony and Augustus he obtained the crown of Judaca in 37 BC. The fond ambition of his heart was now at- tained, although he had literally to carve out his THE HERODIAN FAMILY TREE { By Doris {Herod Agrippa (king of Calchis) d. 100 AD ( Herod (king of Cal- chis) d. 48 AD Antipater (exec. 4 BO) By Mariamne Aristobulus Herod Agrippa ’ (murdered 7 BC) (king of Judaeca) Alexander d. 44 AD (murdered 7 BC) Drusilla Herodias U (MK 6) { By Mariamne Phasael daughter of Simou Herod Philip Herod the Great (Mk 6 17) (king of Judaea 37 BC-4 AD) By Malihace Antipas Autipas, d. 39 AD d. 78 BC (tetr. of Gal.) Antipater Joseph Archelaus (Proc. Judaea (ethn. of Judaea 47-43 BC) 4 BC-6 AD) Pheroras By Cleopatra Herod Philip (tetr. Salome of E. Jord. terri- tory 4 BC-34 AD) Bernice (Acts 25 23) Ll (Acts 24 24) Herod had, besides, five other wives (Ani, XVII,i, 3; BJ, I, xviii, 4) and seven other children, who died early, or at least do not figure in history. glory. Pheroras was nominally his co-regent and, possessed of his father’s cunning, maintained him- self to the end, surviving his cruel brother, but he’ cuts a smallfigurein the family history. He, as well as his sister Salome, proved an endless source of trouble to Herod by the endless family brawls which they occasioned. With a different environment and with a differ- ent character, Herod the Great might have been worthy of the surname which he now 2. Herod bears only asa tribute of inane flattery. the Great What we know of him, we owe, in the main, to the exhaustive treatment of the subject by Jos in his Antiquities and Jewish War, and from Strabo and Dio Cassius among the classics. We may subsume our little sketch of Herod’s life under the heads of (1) political activity, (2) evidences of talent, and (3) character and domestic life. (1) Political activity—Antipater bad great am- bitions for his son. Herod was only a young man when he began his career as governor of Galilee. Jos’ statement, however, that he was only “fifteen years old” (Ani, XIV, ix, 2) is evidently the mistake of some trauscriber, because we are told ( XVII, viii, 1) that “he continued his life till a very old age.” That was 42 years later,so that Herod at this time must have been at least 25 years old. His activity and success in ridding his dominion of dangerous bands of freebooters, and his still greater success own empire with the sword. He made quick work of the task, cut his way back into Judaea and took Jerus by storm in 37 BC. The first act of his reign was the extermination of the Asmonean house, to which Herod himself was related through his marriage with Mariamne, the grandchild of Hyrcanus. Antigonus was slain and with him 45 of his chief adherents. Hyrcanus was recalled from Babylon, to which he had been banished by Antigonus, but the high-priesthood was bestowed on Aristobulus, Herod’s brother-in-law, who, however, soon fell a victim to the suspicion and fear of the king (Ant, XV, iii, 3). These out- rages against the purest blood in Judaea turned the love of Mariamne, once cherished for Herod, into a bitter hatred. The Jews, loyal to the dynasty of the Maccabees, accused Herod before the Rom court, but he was summarily acquitted by Antony. Hyrcanus, mutilated and helpless as he was, soon followed Aristobulus in the way of death, 31 BC (Ant, XV, vi, 1). When Antony, who had ever befriended Herod, was conquered by Augustus at Actium (31 BC), Herod quickly turned to the powers that were, and, by subtle flattery and timely support, won the imperial favor. The boundaries of his kingdom were now extended by Rome. And Herod proved equal to the greater task. By a decisive victory over the Arabians, he showed, as he had done in his earlier Galilean government, what manner of man he was, when aroused to action. Herod THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1380 The Arabians were wholly crushed, and submitted themselves unconditionally under the power of Herod (Ant, XV, v, 5). Afraid to leave a rem- nant of the Asmonean power alive, he sacrificed Mariamne his wife, the only human being he ever seems to have loved (28 BC), his mother-in-law Alexandra (Ant, XV, vii, 8), and ultimately, shortly before his death, even his own sons by Mariamne, Alexander and Aristobulus 7 BC (Ant, XVI, xi, 7). In his emulation of the habits and views of life of the Romans, he continually offended and defied his Jewish subjects, by the introduction of Rom sports and heathen temples in his dominion. His influence on the younger Jews in this regard was baneful, and slowly a distinct party arose, partly political, partly religious, which called itself the Herodian party, Jews in outward religious forms but Gentiles in their dress and in their whole view of life. They were a bitter offence to the rest of the nation, but were associated with the Pharisees and Sadducees in their opposition to Christ (Mt 22.16; Mk 36; 12 13). In vain Herod tried to win over the Jews, by roya) charity in time of famine, and by yielding, wherever possible, to their bitter prejudices. They saw in him only a usurper of the throne of David, maintained by the strong arm of the hated Rom oppressor. Innumerable plots were made against his life, but, with almost superhuman cunning, Herod defeated them all (Ant, XV, viii). He robbed his own people that he might give munificent gifts to the Romans; he did not even spare the grave of King David, which was held in almost idolatrous reverence by the people, but. robbed it of its treasures (Ant, XVI, vii, 1). The last days of Herod were embittered by endless court intrigues and conspiracies, by an almost in- sane suspicion on the part of the aged king, and by increasing indications of the restlessness of the nation. Like Augustus himself, Herod was the victim of an incurable and loathsome disease. His temper became more irritable, as the malady made progress, and he made both himself and his court unutterably miserable. The picture drawn by Jos (Ant, XVII) is lifelike and tragic in its vivid- ness. In his last will and testament, he remained true to his life-long fawning upon the Rom power (Ant, XVII, vi, 1). So great became his suffering toward the last that he made a fruitless attempt at suicide. But, true to his character, one of the last acts of his life was an order to execute his son Anti- pater, who had instigated the murder of his half- brothers, Alexander and Aristobulus, and another order to slay, after his death, a number of nobles, who were guilty of a small outbreak at Jerus and who were confined in the hippodrome (Ant, XVI, vi, 5). He died in the 37th year of his reign, 34 years after he had captured Jerns and slain Antigonus. Jos writes this epitaph: ‘‘A man he was of great barbarity toward all men equally, and a slave to his passions, but above the consideration of what was right. Yet was he favored by fortune as much as any man ever was, for from a private man he became a king, and though he were encompassed by ten thousand dangers, he got clear of them all and con- tinued his life to a very old age” (Ant, XVII, viii, 1). (2) Evidences of talent—The life of Herod the Great was not a fortuitous chain of favorable acci- dents. He was unquestionably a man of talent. In a family like that of Antipas and Antipater, talent must necessarily be hereditary, and Herod inherited it more largely than any of his brothers. His whole life exhibits in no small degree statecraft, power of organization, shrewdness. He knew men and he knew how to use them. He won the warmest friendship of Rom emperors, and had a faculty of convincing the Romans of the righteousness of his cause, in every contingency. In his own dominions he was like Ishmael, his hand against all, and the hands of all against him, and yet he maintained himself in the government for a whole generation. His Galilean governorship showed what manner of man he was, a man with iron determination and | great generalship. His Judaean conquest proved the same thing, as did his Arabian war. Herod was a born leader of men. Under a different environ- ment he might have developed into a truly great man, and had his character been coérdinate with his gifts, he might have done great things for the Jewish people. But by far the greatest talent of Herod was his singular architectural taste and ability. Here he reminds one of the. old Egyp Pharaohs. Against the laws of Judaism, which he pretended to obey, he built at Jerus a magnificent theater and an amphitheater, of which the ruins remain. The one was within the city, the other outside the walls. Thus he introduced into the ascetic sphere of the Jewish life the frivolous spirit of the Greeks and the Romans. To offset this cruel infraction of all the maxims of orthodox Juda- ism, he tried to placate the nation by rebuilding the temple of Zerubbabel and making it more magnifi- cent than even Solomon’s temple had been. This work was accomplished somewhere between 19 BC and 11 or 9 BC, although the entire work was not finished till the procuratorship of Albinus, 62-64 AD (Ant, XV, xi, 5, 6; XX, ix, 7; Jn 2 20). It was so transcendently beautiful that it ranked among the world’s wonders, and Jos does not tire of describing its glories (BJ, V, v). Even Titus sought to spare the building im the final attack on the city (BJ, VI, iv, 3). Besides this, Herod rebuilt and beautified Strato’s Tower, which he called after the emperor, Caesarea. He spent 12 years in this gigantic work, building a theater and amphitheater, and above allin achieving the apparently impossible by creating a harbor where there was none before. This was accomplished by constructing a gigantic mole far out into the sea, and so enduring was the work that the remains of it are seen today. The Romans were so appreciative of the work done by Herod that they made Caesarea the capital of the new régime, after the passing away of the Herodian power. Besides this, Herod rebuilt Samaria, to the Ruins of One of Herod's Temples in Samaria. utter disgust of the Jews, calling it Sebaste. In Jerus itself he built the three great towers, Antonia, Phasaelus and Mariamne, which survived even the catastrophe of the year 70 AD. All over Herod’s dominion were found the evidences of this con- structive passion. Antipatris was built by him, on the site of the ancient Kapharsaba, as well as the stronghold Phasaelus near Jericho, where he was destined to see so much suffering arid ultimately to die. He even reached beyond his own domain to satisfy this building mania at Ascalon, Damascus, Tyre and Sidon, Tripoli, Ptolemais, nay even at Athens and Lacedaemon. But the universal char- acter of these operations itself occasioned the bitter- 1381 est hatred against him on the part of the narrow- minded Jews. (3) Characteristics and domestic life-—The per- sonality of Herod was impressive, and he was pos- sessed of great physical strength. His intellectual powers were far beyond the ordinary; his will was indomitable; he was possessed of great tact, when he saw fit to employ it; in the great crises of his life he was never at a loss what to do; and no one has ever accused Herod the Great of cowardice. There were in him two distinct individualities, as was the case with Nero. Two powers struggled in him for the mastery, and the lower one at last gained complete control. During the first part of his reign there were evidences of large-heartedness, of great possibilities in the man. But the bitter experiences of his life, the endless whisperings and warnings of his court, the irreconcilable spirit of the Jews, as well as the consciousness of his own wrongdoing, changed him into a Jewish Nero: a tyrant, who bathed his own house and his own people in blood. The demons of Herod's life were Jealousy of power, and suspicion, its necessary companion. He was the incarnation of brute lust, which in turn became the burden of the lives of his children. History tells of few more immoral families than the house of Herod, which by intermarriage of its mem- bers so entangled the genealogical tree as to make it a veritable puzzle. As these marriages were nearly all within the line of forbidden consanguinity, under the Jewish law, they still further embittered the people of Israel against the Herodian family. When Herod came to the throne of Judaea, Phasael was dead. Joseph his younger brother had fallen in battle (Ant, XIV, xv, 10), and only Pheroras and Salome survived. The first, as we have seen, nomi- nally shared the government with Herod, but was of little consequence and only proved a thorn in the king’s flesh by his endless interference and plotting. To -him were allotted the revenues of the East Jordanic territory. Salome, his sister, was ever neck-deep in the intrigues of the Herodian family, but had the cunning of a fox and succeeded in making Herod believe in her unchangeable loyalty, although the king had killed her own son-in-law and her nephew, Aristobulus, his own son. The will of Herod, made shortly before his death, is a convincing proof of his regard for his sister (Ant, XVII, vin, 1). ‘ His domestic relations were very unhappy. Of his marriage with Doris and of her son, Antipater, he reaped only misery, the son, as stated above, ultimately falling a victim to his father’s wrath, when the crown, for which he plotted, was prac- tically within his grasp. Herod appears to have been deeply in love with Mariamne, the grandchild of Hyrecanus, in so far as he was capable of such a feeling, but his attitude to the entire Asmonean family and his fixed determination to make an end of it changed whatever love Mariamne had for him into hatred. Ultimately she, as well as her two sons, fell victims to Herod’s insane jealousy of power. Like Nero, however, in a similar situation, Herod felt the keenest remorse after her death. As his sons grew up, the family tragedy thickened, and the court of Herod became a veritable hotbed of mutual recriminations, intrigues and catastro- phes. The trials and executions of his own con- spiring sons were conducted with the acquiescence of the Rom power, for Herod was shrewd enough not to make a move without it. Yetso thoroughly was the condition of the Jewish court understood at Rome, that Augustus, after the death of Mariamne’s sons (7 BC), is said to have exclaimed: “I would rather be Herod’s hog than his son.”’ At the time -of his death, the remaining sons were these: Herod, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Herod son of Mariamne, Simon’s daughter; Archelaus and Antipas, sons of Malthace, and Herod Philip, son of Cleopatra of Jerus. Alexander and Aristo- bulus were killed, through the persistent intrigues of Antipater, the oldest son and heir presumptive to the crown, and he himself fell into the grave he had dug for his brothers. By the final testament of Herod, as ratified by Rome, the kingdom was divided as follows: Arche- laus received one-half of the kingdom, with the title of king, really “ethnarch,”’ governing Judaea, Samaria and Idumaea; Antipas was appointed “tetrarch”’ of Galilee and Peraea; Philip; “tetrarch”’ of Trachonitis, Gaulonitis and Paneas. To Sa- lome, his intriguing sister, he bequeathed Jamnia, Ashdod and Phasaeclus, together with 500,000 drachmas of coined silver. All his kindred were liberally provided for in his will, ‘‘so as to leave them all in a wealthy condition” (Ant, XVII, viii, 1). In his death he had been better to his family than in his life. He died unmourned and unbeloved by his own people, to pass into history as a name soiled by violence and blood. As the waters of Callirhoe were unable to cleanse his cor- rupting body, those of time were unable to wash away the stains of atyrant’s name. The only time he is mentioned in the NT is in Mt 2 and Lk 1. In Mt he is associated with the wise men of the East, who came to investigate the birth of the “king of the Jews.’’ Learning their secret, Herod found out from the ‘priests and scribes of the people” where the Christ was to be born and ordered the “massacre of the innocents,’ with which his name is perhaps more generally associated than with any other act of his life. As Herod died in 4 BC and some time elapsed between the massacre and his death (Mt 2 19), we have here a clue to the ap- proximate fixing of the true date of Christ’s birth. Another, in this same connection, is an eclipse of the moon, the only one mentioned by Jos (Ani, XVII, vi, 4; text and note), which was seen shortly before Herod’s death. This eclipse occurred on March 13, in the year of the Julian Period, 4710, therefore 4 BC. Herod Antipas was the son of Herod the Great and Malthace, a Samaritan woman. Half Idu- maean, half Samaritan, he had there- fore not a drop of Jewish blood in his veins, and “Galilee of the Gentiles” seemed a fit dominion for such a prince. He ruled as “‘tetrarch”’ of Galilee and Peraea (Lk 3 1) from 4 BC till 89 AD. The gospel picture we have of him is far from prepossessing. He is super- stitious (Mt 14 1f), foxlike in his cunning (Lk 13 31f) and wholly immoral. John the Baptist was brought into his life through an open rebuke of his gross immorality and defiance of the laws of Moses (Lev 18 16), and paid for his courage with his life (Mt 14 10; Ant, XVIII, v, 2). On the death of his father, although he was younger than his brother Archelaus (Ant, XVII, ix, 4f; BJ, II, ii, 3), he contested the will of Herod, who had given to the other the major part of the dominion. Rome, however, sustained the will and assigned to him the ‘“‘tetrarchy”’ of Galilee and Peraea, as it had been set apart for him by Herod (Ant, XVII, xi, 4). Educated at Rome with Archelaus and Philip, his half-brother, son of Mariamne, daughter of Simon, he imbibed many of the tastes and graces and far more of the vices of the Romans. His first wife was a daughter of Aretas, king of Arabia. But he sent her back to her father at Petra, for the sake of Herodias, the wife of his brother Philip, whom he had met and seduced at Rome. Since the latter was the daughter of Aristobulus, his half-brother, and therefore his niece, and at the same time the 3. Herod Antipas Herod Herodias THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1382 wife of another half-brother, the union between her and Antipas was doubly sinful. Aretas repaid this insult to his daughter by a destructive war (Ant, XVIII, v, 1). Herodias had a baneful influ- ence over him and wholly dominated his life (Mt 14 3-10). He emulated the example of his father in a mania for erecting buildings and beautifying cities. Thus he built the wall of Sepphoris and made the place his capital. He elevated Bethsaida to the rank of a city and gave it the name “Julia,” after the daughter of Tiberius. Another example of this inherited or cultivated building-mania was the work he did at Betharamphtha, which he called “Julias’” (Ant, XVIII, ii, 1). His influence on his subjects was morally bad (Mk 8 15). [If his life was less marked by enormities than his father’s, it was only so by reason of its inevitable restrictions. The last glimpse the Gospels afford of him shows him to us in the final tragedy of the life of Christ. He is then at Jerus. Pilate in his perplexity had sent the Saviour bound to Herod, and the utter inefficiency and flippancy of the man is revealed in the account the Gospels give us of the incident (Lk 23 7-12; Acts 4 27). It served, however, to bridge the chasm of the enmity between Herod and Pilate (Lk 23 12), both of whom were to be stripped of their power and to die in shameful exile. When Caius Caligula had become emperor and when his scheming favorite Herod Agrippa I, the bitter enemy of Antipas, had been made king in 87 AD, Herodias prevailed on Herod Antipas to accompany her to Rome to demand a similar favor. The machinations of Agrippa and the ac- cusation of high treason preferred against him, however, proved his undoing, and he was banished to Lyons in Gaul, where he died in great misery (Ant, XVIII, vii, 2; BJ, UI, ix, 6). Herod Philip was the son of Herod the Great and Cleopatra of Jerus. At the death of his father he inherited Gaulonitis, Trachonitis and 4. Herod Paneas (Ant, XVII, viii, 1). He was Philip apparently utterly unlike the rest of the Herodian family, retiring, digni- fied, moderate and just. He was also wholly free from the intriguing spirit of his brothers, and it is but fair to suppose that he inherited this totally un-Herodian character and disposition from his mother. He died in the year 34 AD, and his territory was given three years later to Agrippa I, his nephew and the son of Aristobulus, together with the tetrarchy of Lysanias (Ant, XVIII, iv, 6; XIX, v, 1). Herod Archelaus was the oldest son of Herod the Great by Malthace, the Samaritan. He was a man of violent temper, reminding one a great 6. Herod deal of his father. Educated like all Archelaus the Herodian princes at Rome, he was fully familiar with the life and arbi- trariness of the Rom court. In the last days of his father’s life, Antipater, who evidently aimed at the extermination of all the heirs to the throne, accused him and Philip, his half-brother, of treason. Both were acquitted (Ani, XVI, iv, 4; XVII, vii, 1). By the will of his father, the greater part of the Herodian kingdom fell to his share, with the title of “ethnarch.” The will was contested by his brother Antipas before the Rom court. While the matter was in abeyance, Archelaus incurred the hatred of the Jews by the forcible repression of a rebellion, in which some 3,000 people were slain. They therefore opposed his claims at Rome, but Archelaus, in the face of all this opposition, received the Rom support (Ani, XVII, xi, 4). It is very ingeniously suggested that this episode may be the foundation of the parable of Christ, found in Lk 19 12-27. Archelaus, once invested with the government of Judaea, ruled with a hard hand, so that Judaea and Samaria were both soon in a chronic state of unrest. The two nations, bitterly as they hated each other, became friends in this common crisis, and sent an embassy to Rome to complain of the conduct of Archelaus, and this time they were successful. Archelaus was warned by a dream of the coming disaster, whereupon he went at once to Rome to defend himself, but wholly in vain. His government was taken from him, his possessions were all confiscated by the Rom power and he him- self was banished to Viennain Gaul (Ant, XVII, xii, 2,3). He, too, displayed some of his father’s taste for architecture, in the building of a royal palace at Jericho and of a village, named after himself, Archelais. He was married first to Mariamne, and after his divorce from her to Glaphyra, who had been the wife of his half-brother Alexander (Ant, XVI, xiii). The only mention made of him in the Gospels is found in Mt 2 22. ’ Of Herod, son of Herod the Great and Mariamne, Simon’s daughter, we know nothing except that he married Herodias, the daughter of his dead half- brother Aristobulus. He is called Philip in the NT (Mt 14 3), and it was from him that Antipas lured Herodias away. His later history is wholly un- known, as well as that of Herod, the brother of Philip the tetrarch, and the oldest son of Herod the Great and Cleopatra of Jerus. Two members of the Herodian family are named Agrippa. They are of the line of Aristobulus, who through Mariamne,_ granddaughter 6. Herod of Hyrcanus, carried down the line of AgrippaI the Asmoneanblood. Anditis worthy of note that in this line, nearly extin- guished by Herod through his mad jealousy and fear of the Maccabean power, the kingdom of Herod came to its greatest glory again. Herod Agrippa I, called Agrippa by Jos, was the son of Aristobulus and Bernice and the grandson of Herod the Great and Mariamne. Educated at Rome with Claudius (Ant, XVIII, vi, 1, 4), he was possessed of great shrewdness and tact. Returning to Judaea for a little while, he came back to Rome in 37 AD. He hated his uncle Antipas and left no stone unturned to hurt his cause. His mind was far-seeing, and he cultivated, as his grandfather had done, every means that might lead to his own promotion. He, therefore, made fast friends with Caius Caligula, heir presumptive to the Rom throne, and his rather outspoken advocacy of the latter’s claims led to his imprisonment by Tiberius. This proved the making of his fortune, for Caligula did not forget him, but immediately on his accession to the throne, liberated Agrippa and bestowed on him, who up to that time had been merely a private citizen, the ‘“tetrarchies” of Philip, his uncle, and of Lysanias, with the title of king, although he ‘did not come into the possession of the latter till two more years had gone by (Ant, XVIII, vi, 10). The foolish ambition of Herod Antipas Jed to his undoing, and the emperor, who had heeded the accusation of Agrippa against his uncle, bestowed on him the additional territory of Galilee and Peraea in 39 AD. Agrippa kept in close touch with the imperial government, and when, on the assassina- tion of Caligula, the imperial crown was offered to the indifferent Claudius, it fell to the lot of Agrippa to lead the latter to accept the proffered honor. This led to further imperial favors and further ex- tension of his territory, Judaea and Samaria being added to his domain, 40 AD. The fondest dreams of Agrippa had now been realized, his father’s fate was avenged and the old Herodian power had been restored to its original extent. He ruled with great munificence and was very tactful in his contact with the Jews. With this end in view, several years before, he had moved Caligula to recall the 1383 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Herod Herodias command of erecting an imperial statue in the city of Jerus; and when he was forced to take sides in the struggle between Judaism and the nascent Christian sect, he did not hesitate a moment, but assumed the réle of its bitter persecutor, slaying Jamesthe apostle with the sword and harrying the church whenever possible (Acts 12). He died, in the full flush of his power, of a death, which, in its harrowing details reminds us of the fate of his grandfather (Acts 12 20-23; Ant, XIX, viii,2). Of the four children he left (BJ, II, xi, 6), three are known to history— Herod Agrippa II, king of Calchis, Bernice of im- moral celebrity, who consorted with her own brother in defiance of human and Divine law, and became a byword even among the heathen (Juv. Sat, vi.156-60), and Drusilla, the wife of the Rom governor Felix (Acts 24 24). According to tradi- tion the latter perished in the eruption of Vesuvius in 79 AD, together with her son Agrippa. With Herod Agrippa I, the Herodian power had virtu- ally run its course. Herod Agrippa II was the son of Herod Agrippa I and Cypros. When his father died in 44 AD he was a youth of only 17 years and con- sidered too young to assume the gov- ernment of Judaea. Claudius there- fore placed the country under the care of a procurator. Agrippa had received a royal education in the palace of the emperor himself (Ant, XIX, ix, 2). But be had not wholly for- gotten his people, as is proven by his intercession in behalf of the Jews, when they asked to be per- mitted to have the custody of the official high- priestly robes, till then in the hands of the Romans and to be used only on stated occasions (Ant, XX, i, 1). On the death of his uncle, Herod of Calchis, Claudius made Agrippa II “tetrarch”’ of the terri- tory, 48 AD (BJ, II, xii, 1; XIV, iv; Ant, XX, v, 2). As Jos tells us, he espoused the cause of the Jews whenever he could (Ant, XX, vi, 3). Four years later (52 AD), Claudius extended the do- minion of Agrippa by giving him the old “‘tetrar- chies” of Philip and Lysanias. Even at Calchis they had called him king; now it became his official title (Ant, XX, vii, 1). Still later (65 AD), Nero added some Galilean and Peraean cities to his domain. His whole career indicates the predominating influ- ence of the Asmonean blood, which had shown itself in his father’s eareer also. If the Herodian taste for architecture reveals itself here and there (Ant, XX, viii, 11; [X, iv), there is a total absence of the cold disdain wherewith the Herods in general treated their subjects. The Agrippas are Jews. — Herod Agrippa II figures in the NT in Acts 25 13; 26 32. Paul there calls him “king” and ap- peals to him as to one knowing the Scriptures. As the brother-in-law of Felix he was a favored guest on this occasion. His relation to Bernice his sister was a scandal among Jews and Gentiles alike (Ant, XX, vii, 3). In the fall of the Jewish nation, Herod Agrippa’s kingdom went down. Knowing the futility of resistance, Agrippa warned the Jews not to rebel against Rome, but in vain (BJ, I, xvi, 2- 5; XVII, iv; XVIII, ix; XIX, iii). When the war began he boldly sided with Rome and fought under its banners, getting wounded by a sling-stone in the siege of Gamala (BJ, IV, i, 3). The oration by which he sought to persuade the Jews against the rebellion is a masterpiece of its kind and became historical (BJ, II, xvi). When the in- evitable came and when with the Jewish nation also the kingdom of Herod Agrippa II had been destroyed, the Romans remembered his loyalty. With Bernice his sister he removed to Rome, where he became a praetor and died in the year 100 AD, at the age of 70 years, in the beginning of Trajan’s reign. 7. Herod Agrippa II Lirsraturs.—Jos, Ani and BJ; Strabo; Dio Cassius. Among all modern works on the subject, Schtirer, The Jewish People in the Time of Jesus Christ (5 vols) is per- haps still the best. Hewry E. Doskxer HERODIANS, hé-ro’di-anz (Hpwktavol, Héra- dianot): A party twice mentioned in the Gospels (Mi 22 16||Mk 12 13; 3 6) as acting with the Pharisees in opposition to Jesus. They were not a religious sect, but, as the name implies, a court or police party, supporters of the dynasty of Herod. othing is known of them beyond what the Gospels state. Whatever their political aims, they early perceived that Christ’s pure and spiritual teaching on the kingdom of God was irreconcilable with these, and that Christ’s influence with the people was antagonistic to their interests. Hence, in Galilee, on the occasion of the healing of the man with the withered hand, they readily joined with the more powerful party of the Pharisees in plots to crush Jesus (Mk 3 6); and again, in Jerus, in the last week of Christ’s life, they renewed this alliance in the attempt to entrap Jesus on the question of the tribute money (Mt 22 16). The warning of Jesus to His disciples to “beware of the leaven of Herod” (Mk 8 15) may have had reference to the insidious spirit of this party. JAMES ORR _ HERODIAS, hé-ro’di-as (Hpedids or “Hpwitds, Hérédids): The woman who compassed the death of John the Baptist at Machaerus (Mt 14 1-12; Mk 6 14-29; ef also Lk 3 19.20; 9 7-9). Accord- ing to the Gospel records, Herodias had previously been married to Philip, but had deserted him for his brother Herod the tetrarch. For this Herod was reproved by John (cf Lev 18 16; 20 21), and Herod, therefore, to please Herodias, bound him and cast him into prison. According to Mt 14 5 he would even then have put John to death, but ‘feared the multitude,’’ which regarded John as a prophet. But Mk 6 19f relates it was Herodias who esp. desired the death of John, but that she was withstood by Herod whose conscience was not altogether dead. This latter explanation is more in harmony with the sequel. At Herod’s birthday feast, Herodias induced her daughter Salome, whose dancing had so charmed the tetrarch, to ask as her reward the head of John the Baptist on a charger. This was given her and she then brought it to her mother. Herodias was daughter of Aristobulus, son of Herod the Great, by Mariamne, daughter of Hyr- ecanus. Her second husband (cf above) was Herod Antipas, tetrarch of Galilee and Peraea (c 4-39 AD), son of Herod the Great by Malthace. Herod Anti- pas was thus the step-brother of Aristobulus, father of Herodias. Regarding the first husband of Hero- dias, to whom she bore Salome, some hold that the Gospel accounts are at variance with that of Jos. In Mt 14 8; Mk 6 17; Lk 3 19, heis called Philip the brother of Herod (Antipas). But in Mt 143 and Lk 3 19 the name Philip is omitted by certain important MSS. According to Jos, he was Herod, son of Herod the Great by Mariamne daughter of Simon the high priest, and was thus a step-brother of Herod Antipas (cf Jos, Ant, XVIII, v, 4). It is suggested in explanation of the discrepancy (1) that Herod, son of Mariamne, bore a second name Philip, or (2) that there is confusion in the Gospels with Herod-Philip, tetrarch of Trachonitis, who was the son of Herod the Great and Cleopatra, and who was in reality the husband of Salome, daughter of Herodias (cf also A. B. Bruce, Expos Gr Test., IL, 381; A. C. Headlam, art. “Herod” in HDB, II, 359, 860). According to Jos (Ant, VIII, vii, 2; XVIII, vii, 1) the ambition of Herodias proved the ruin of Herod Antipas. Being jealous of the power of Agrippa her brother, she induced Herod to de- Herodion Hezekiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1384 mand of Caligula the title of king. This was refused through the machinations of Agrippa, and Herod was banished. But the pride of Herodias kept her still faithful to her husband in his misfortune. C. M. Kerr HERODION, hé-rd’di-on (HpwStwv, Héradion; WH ‘HpgSiwv): A Rom Christian to whom Paul sent greetings (Rom 16 11). The name seems to imply that he was a freedman of the Herods, or a member of the household of Aristobulus, the grand- son of Herod the Great (ver 10). Paul calls him “my kinsman,” i.e. “a Jew” (see Juntas, 1). HERON, her'un (MQIN, ’dnaphah; xapaSprés, charadriés; Lat Ardea cinerea): Herons are men- tioned only in the abomination lists of Lev 11 19 (m ‘‘ibis”) and Dt 14 18. They are near relatives Heron (Ardea cinerea). of crane, stork, ibis and bittern. These birds, blue, white or brown, swarmed in Europe and wintered around Merom, along the Jordan, at the head- waters of the Jabbok and along its marshy bed in the dry season. Herons of Southern Africa that summered in the Holy Land loved to nest on the banks of Merom, and raise their young among the bulrushes, papyrus, reeds and water grasses, although it is their usual habit to build in large trees. The white herons were small, the blue, larger, and the brown, close to the same size. The blue were 33 ft. in length, and had a 5-ft. sweep. The beak, neck and legs constituted two-thirds of the length of the body, which is small, lean and bony, taking its appearance of size from its long loose feathers. Moses no doubt forbade these birds as an article of diet, because they ate fish and in older specimens would be tough, dark and evil smelling. The very poor of our western and southeastern coast states eat them. GENE STRATTON-PoRTER HESED, hé’sed, SON OF. Sce BEN-HESEn. HESHBON, hesh’bon (DWT, heshban; ‘EoeBav, Hesebén):, The royal city of Sihon king of the Amor- ites, taken and occupied by the Israelites under Moses (Nu 21 25f, etc). It lay on the southern border of Gad (Josh 13 26), and was one of the cities fortified by Reuben (Nu 82 87). It is reck- oned among the cities of Gad given to the Merarite Levites (Josh 21 39). In later lit. (Isa 15 4; 16 Sf; Jer 48 2.34.45; 49 3) it is referred to as a city of Moab. It passed again into Jewish hands, and is mentioned by Jos (Ant, XIII, xv, 4) as among their possessions in the country of Moab under Alexander Jannaeus. The city with its district called Hesebonitis, was also under the juris- diction of Herod the Great (Ant, XV, vii, 5, where it is described as lying in the Peraea). Onom places it 20 Rom miles from the Jordan. It is rep- resented by the modern Hesban, a ruined site in the mountains over against Jericho, about 16 miles E. of the Jordan. It stands on the edge of Wddy Hesban in a position of great strength, about 600 ft. above ‘Ain Hesban. "The ruins, dating mainly from Rom times, spread over two hills, respectively 2,930 ft. and 2,954 ft. in height. There are remains of a temple overlooked from the W. by those of a castle. There is also a large ruined reservoir; while the spring in the valley forms a succession of pools (Cant 7 4). Thecity is approached from the valley by a steep path passing through a cutting in_the rock, which may have been closed by a gate (Con- der, Heth and Moab, 142). On a hill to the W., el-Kurmiyeh, is a collection of dolmens and stone circles (Musil, Arabia Petraea, I, 383 ff). b aes W. Ewine HESHMON, hesh’mon (j1207, heshmén): An unidentified place on the border of Judah toward Edom (Josh 15 27). This may have been the original home of the Hasmoneans. : HETH, hath (m): The eighth letter of the Heb alphabet; transhterated in this Encyclopaedia as Ah (guttural hk). It came also to be used for the number 8. For name, etc, see ALPHABET. HETH, heth (7, héth): In Gen 23 10 the an- cestor of the Hittites. As the various peoples who occupied Canaan were thought to belong to one stock, Gen 10 15 (1 Ch 1 13) makes Heth the (2d) son of Canaan. In Gen 23 the ‘“‘sons of Heth”’ occupy Hebron, but they were known to have come there from the north. A reference to this seems to be preserved in the order of the names in Gen 10 15.16, where Heth is placed between Sidon and the Jebusites. See Hirritss. HETHLON, heth’lon (j5MM, hethlan; Pesh hethrén}: Name of a place associated with Zedad on the ideal northern boundary of Israel, as given in Ezk 47 15 and 48 1, but not named in Nu 34 8, while the LX-X evidently tr? the text it had. In accordance with the opinion they hold as to the boundary line of Northern Israel, van Kasteren and Buhl seek to identify Hethlon with ’Adlun on the river Qasmiyeh. Much more in harmony with the line of the other border towns given is its identifi- cation with Heitala to the N.E. of Tripoli. The ‘way of Hethlon” would then coincide with the Eleutherus valley, between Homs and the Mediter- ranean, through which the railway now runs, and to this identification the LXX seems to give testi- mony, indicating some path of ‘‘descent” from the Biga’a. : W. M. Curisrre HEWER, hi’ér (1077, hotébh): Applies esp. to a wood-worker or wood-gatherer (cf Arab. hattab, ‘a woodman”) (Josh 9 21.23.27; 2 Ch 2 10; Jer 46 22). Gathering wood, like drawing water, was a menial task. Special servants were assigned to the work (Dt 29 11). Joshua set the Gibeonites to hewing wood and drawing water as a punishment for their trickery, whereas were it not for the oath which the Israelites had sworn, the Gibeonites would probably have been killed. See DRawEr or WATER 1385 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Herodion Hezekiah Am, haécabh, from the root “to cut’? or “to carve,’’ applies to hewers of stone in 1 K 6 15; 2K 12 12; 1 Ch 22 15; 2 Ch 2 18. Jamgs A. Parco HEXATEUCH, hek’sa-ttik: This word, formed on the analogy of Pentateuch, Heptateuch, etc, is used by modern writers to denote the 1. Evidence first six books of the Bible (i.e. the for Law and Josh) collectively. Many critics hold that these six books were composed out of the sources JEP, etc (on which see PENTATEUCH), and only separated very much later into different works. The main grounds for this belief are: (1) the obvious fact that Josh pro- vides the sequel to the Pent, narrating the conquest and settlement in Canaan to which the latter work looks forward, and (2) certain material and stylistic resemblances. The composition of the respective works is considered in the arts. PentaTeuce and JOSHUA. Here we must glance at the evidence against the theory of a Hexateuch. It is admitted that there is no trace of- any such work as the 2. Evidence Hexateuch anywhere in _ tradition. against The Jewish Canon places the Pent in a separate category from Josh. The Samaritans went farther and adopted the Pent alone. The orthography of the two works differs in certain important particulars (see E. Kénig, Hinleitung, 1511, 250). Hence a different literary history has to be postulated for the two works, even by those who adopt the theory of a Hexateuch. But that theory is open to objection on other grounds. There are grave differences of opinion among its supporters as to whether all the supposed Pentateucha] documents are present in Josh, and in any case it is held that they are quite differently worked up, the redactors having proceeded on one system in the Pent and on quite another in Josh. Arguments are given in the art. PENTATEUCH to show the presence of Mosaic and pre-Mosaic ele- ments in the Pent and the unsoundness of the docu- mentary theory in that work, and if these be correct the theory of a Hexateuch necessarily falls to the ground. ; For Bibliography see Pentatrucu; JosHUA. Harotp M. Wiener HEZEK], he2’/é-ki (PI, hizki). See Hizx1. HEZEKIAH, hez-é-ki’a (PPI, hizkiyah): (1) King of Judah. See special art. (2) A son of Neariah, of the royal family of ‘Ju- dah (1 Ch 3 23, RV “Hizkiah’’). (8) An ancestor of Zephaniah (Zeph 11, AV “Hizkiah’’). (4) One of the returned exiles from Babylon (Ezr 2 16; Neh 7 21). HEZEKIAH ("p11 hizkiyah, “Jeh has strength- ened”; also written WPT, hizkiyaha, “Jeh has strengthened him’; “Efextas, Hezekias): One of the greatest of the kings of Judah; reigned (according to the most self-consistent chronology) from c 715 to ec 690 BC. ; On the OT standard of loyalty to Jeh he is eulo- gized by Jesus Sirach as one of the three kings who alone did not “commit trespass” (Sir 49 4), the other two being David and Josiah. The Chronicler represents him (2 Ch 82 31) as lapsing from the wis- dom of piety only by his vainglory in revealing the resources of his realm to the envoys of Merodach-baladan. In 2 K.18 5, the earliest es- timate, his special distinction, beyond all other Judaean kings, before or after, was that he “trusted in Jeh, the God of Israel.” It is as the OT Esti- mate king who “clave to Jeh” (2 IX 18 6) that the Heb mind sums up his royal and personal character. I. Sources for His Life and Times.—The his- torical accounts in 2 K 18-20 and 2 Ch 29-32 are derived in the main from the same 1. Scripture state annals, though the latter seems Annals also to have had the Temple archives to draw upon. For “the rest of his acts,’’ 2 K refers to a source then still in existence but now lost, “the book of the chronicles of the kings of Judah” (2 K 20 20), and 2 Ch to “the vision of Isaiah the prophet the son of Amoz, in the book of the kings of Judah and Israel” (2 Ch 32 32). In this last-named source (if this is the origi- nal of our Book of Isa), besides the warnings and directions called out by the course of the history, there is a narrative section (Isa 36-39) recounting the Sennacherib crisis much as do the other his- tories, but incorporating also a passage of Isaianic prophecy (87 22-32) and a “writing of Hezekiah king of Judah” (88 10-20). Lastly, in Sir 48 17- 25, there is a summary of the good and wise deeds of Hezekiah, drawn from the accounts that we already have. Of these sources the account in 2 K is most purely annalistic, originating at a time when religious and political values, in the Heb mind, were 2. View- inseparable. In 2 Ch the religious point and coloring, esp. in its later developed Coloring ritual and legal aspects, has the de- cided predominance. Sirach, with the mind of a man of letters, is concerned mainly with eulogizing H. in his “praise of famous men” (ef Sir 44-50), of course from the devout Heb point of view. In the vision of Isaiah (Isa 1-39), we have the reflection of the moral and spiritual situation in Jerus, as realized in the fervid prophetic consciousness; and in the prophecy of his younger contemporary Micah, the state of things in the out- lying country districts nearest the path of invasion, where both the iniquities of the ruling classes and the horrors of war were felt most keenly. Doubt- less also many devotional echoes of these times of stress are deducible from the Pss, so far as we can fairly identify them. It is in Hezekiah’s times esp. that the Assyr in- scriptions become illuminating for the history of Israel; for one important thing they 3. Side- furnish certain fixed dates to which the Lights chronology of the times can be ad- justed. Of Sennacherib’s campaign of 701, for instance, no fewer than six accounts are at present known (see G. A. Smith, Jerus, II, 154, n.), the most detailed being the ‘“Taylor Cylinder,” now in the British Museum, which in the main agrees, or at least isnot inconsistent, with the Scripture history. I. Events of His Reign.—From his weak and unprincipled father Ahaz (cf 2 Ch 28 16-25), Hezekiah inherited not only a dis- 1. His organized realm but a grievous burden Heritage of Assyr dominance and tribute, and the constant peril and-suspense of greater encroachments from that arrogant and arbi- trary power: the state of things foretold in Isa 7 20; 8 7f. The situation was aggravated by the fact that not only the nation’s weakness but its spiritual propensities had incurred it: the domi- nant classes were aping the sentiments, fashions and cultus of the East (cf Isa 2 6-8), while the neg- lected common people were exposed to the corrup- tions of the still surviving heathenism of the land. The realm, in short, was at the spiritual nadir-point from which prophets like Isaiah and Micah were laboring to bring about the birth of a true Heb con- science and faith. Their task was a hard one: with a nation smear-eyed, dull-eared, fat-hearted (Isa 6 10), whose religion was a precept of men learned by Hezekiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1386 rote (Isa 29 13). Clearly, from this point of view, a most difficult career was before him. The sense of this unspiritual state of things fur- nishes the best keynote of Hezekiah’s reforms in religion, which according to the Chroni- 2. Religious cler he set. about as soon as he came Reform to the throne (2 Ch 29 3). It is the Chronicler who gives the fullest ac- count of these reforms (2 Ch 29-31); naturally, from his priestly point of view and access to eccle- siastical archives. Hezekiah began with the most pressing constructive need, the opening and cleans- ing of the Temple, which his father Ahaz had left closed and desecrated (2 Ch 28 24), and went on to the reorganization of its liturgical and choral service. In connection with this work he appointed a Passover observance, which, on a scale and spirit unknown since Solomon (2 Ch 80 26), he designed as a religious reunion of the devout-minded in all Israel, open not only to Jerus and Judah, but to all who would accept his invitation from Samaria, Galilee, and beyond the Jordan (2 Ch 30 5-12.18). The immediate result of the enthusiasm engendered by this Old Home Week was a vigorous popular movement of iconoclasm against the idolatrous high places of theland. That this wasno weak fanatical impulse to break something, but a touch of real spiritual quickening, seems evidenced by one inci- dent of it: the breaking up of Moses’ old brazen serpent and calling it what it had come to mean, mhushtan, “a piece of brass’ (2 K 18 4); the movement seems in fact to have had in it the sense, however crude, that old religious forms had become hurtful and effete superstitions, hindering spirit- uality. Nor could the movement stop with the old fetich. With it went the demolition of the high places themselves and the breaking down of the pillars (maccébhéth) and felling of the sacred groves (dshérah), main symbols these of a debasing nature~ cult. This reform, on account of later reactions (see under MawassEH), has been deemed ineffective; rather, its effects were inward and germinal; nor were they less outwardly than could reasonably be expected, before its meanings were more deepened and centralized. : All this, on the king’s part, was his response to the spiritual influence of Isaiah, with whose mind his own was sincerely at one. As a 3. Internal devout disciple in the school of pro- Improve- _phetic ideas, he earnestly desired to ments maintain the prophet’s insistent atti- tude of “quietness and confidence” (cf Isa 30 15), that is, of stedfast trust in Jeh alone, and of abstinence from revolt and entangling alliances with foreign powers. This, however, in the stress and suspense of the times, did not pre- clude a quiet preparation for emergencies; and doubtless the early years of his reign were notable, not only for mild and just administration through- out his realm, but for measures looking to the forti- fying and defence of the capital. His work of repairing and extending the walls and of strength- ening the citadel (Millo), as mentioned in 2 Ch 32 5,had probably been in progress long before the Assyr crisis was imminent. Nor was he backward in coming to an understanding with other nations, as to the outlook for revolt against Assyria. He could not learn his lesson of faith all at once, esp. with a factious court pulling the other way. He did not escape the suspicion of Sargon (d. 705), who for his Egyp leanings counted him among the “‘plot- ters of sedition” (cf COT, 100); while the increas- ing prosperity and strength of his realm marked him for a leading réle in an eventual uprising. He weathercd at least one chance of rebellion, however, in 711, probably through the strenuous exertions of Isaiah (see Isa 20 1 ff). Hezekiah’s opportunity to rise against Assyr domination seems to have been taken about 704. How so pious a king came to do it in 4. The spite of Isaiah’s strenuous warnings, Assyrian both against opposition to Assyria and Crisis alliance with other powers, is not very clear. The present writer ventures to suggest the view that the beginning was forced or perhaps sprung upon him by his princes and nobles. In the year before, Sargon, dying, had left his throne to Sennacherib, and, as at all ancient changes of sovereignty, this was the signal for a general effort for independence on the part of sub- ject provinces. That was also the year of Heze- Pool of Hezekiah. kiah’s deadly illness (2 K 20; Isa 38), when for a, time we know not how long he would be incapaci- tated for active administration of affairs. Not un- likely on his recovery he found his realm committed beyond withdrawal to an alliance with Egypt and perhaps the leadership of a coalition with Philistia; in which case personally he could only make the best of the situation. There was nothing for it but to confirm this coalition by force, which he did in his Phili campaign mentioned in 2 K 18 8. Mean- while, in the same general uprising, the Chaldaean Merodach-baladan, who had already been expelled from Babylon after an ll-year reign (721-710), again seized that throne; and in due time envoys from him appeared in Jerus, ostensibly to con- gratulate the king on his recovery from his illness, but really to secure his aid and alliance against Assyria (2 K 20 12-15; Isa 89 1-4). Hezekiah, flattered by such distinguished attention from so distant and powerful a source, by revealing his resources committed what the Chronicler calls the one impious indiscretion of his life (2 Ch $2 31), incurring also Isaiah’s reproof and adverse predic- tion (2 K 20 17f; Isa 89 6f). The conflict with Sennacherib was now inevitable; and Hezekiah, by turning the water supply of Jerus from the Gihon spring to a pool within the walls and closing it from without, put the capital in readiness to stand a siege. The faith evoked by this wise work, con- firmed by the subsequent deliverance, is reflected in Ps 46. That this incurring of a hazardous war, however, with its turmoils and treacheries, and the presence of uncouth Arab mercenaries, was little to the king’s desire or disposition, seems indicated in Ps 120, which with the other Songs of Degrees (Pss 120-34) may well reflect the religious faith of this period of Hezekiah’s life, : The critical moment came in 701, when Sen- nacherib, who the year before had reconquered _ Babylon and = expelled Merodach- 5. Invasion baladan (perhaps Isa 21 1-9 refers to and De- this), was free to invade his rebellioug liverance provinces in the W. It was a vig- : _ oreus and sweeping campaign; in which, beginning with Sidon and advancing down 1387 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hezekiah through the coast lands, he speedily subdued the Phili cities, defeating them and their southern allies (whether these were from Egypt proper or from its extension across the Sinai peninsula and Northern Arabia, Mugri, is not quite clear) at Eltekeh; in which campaign, according to his inscription, he took 46 walled towns belonging to Judah with their spoil and deported over 200,000 of their inhabitants. This, which left Jerus a blockaded town (in fact he says of Hezekiah: ‘Himself I shut up like a bird in a cage in Jerus his royal city’’), seems referred to in Isa 1 7-9 and predicted in Isa 6 11f. Its immediate effect was to bring Hezekiah to terms and extort an enormous tribute (2 K 18 14-16). When ‘later, however, he was treacherous enough to disregard the compact thus implied (perhaps Isa ch 33 refers to this), and demanded the surrender of the city (2 K 18 17—19 7; Isa 86 2—37 7), Heze- kiah besought the counsel of Isaiah, who bade him refuse the demand, and predicted that Sennacherib would “hear tidings’? and return to his own land; which prediction actually came to pass, and sudden- ly Hezekiah found himself free. A deliverance so great, and so signally vindicating the forthputting of faith, could not but produce a momentous revul- sion in the nation’s mind, like a new spiritual birth in which the faith of the ‘“remnant’’ became a vital power in Israel; its immediate effect seems por- trayed in Ps 124 and perhaps Ps 126, and its deep significance as the birth of a nation in a day seems summarized long afterward in Isa 66 7-9; ef 87 3; 2K 19 8. A second summons to surrender, sent from Libnah by letter (2 K 19 1ff; Isa 37 8 ff), is treated by the Scripture historians as a later 6. The feature of the same campaign; but Second recent researches seem to make it Summons possible, nay probable, that this be- longed to another campaign of Sen- nacherib, when Taharka of Ethiopia (Tirhakah, 2 K 19 9; Isa 37 9) came to power in Egypt, in 691. If this was so, there is room in Hezeckiah’s latter years for a decade of peace and prosperity (ef Ch 32 22.23.27-30), and in Isaiah’s old age for a collection and revision of his so wonderfully vindicated prophecies. The historians’ evident union of two stories in one makes the new attitude with which this crisis was met, obscure; but the tone of confirmed confidence and courage seems decidedly higher. The discomfiture of Sennachcrib in this -case was brought about, not by a rumor of rebellions at home, but by an outbreak of plague (2 K 19 35f; Isa 37 36f), which event the Scripture writers interpreted as a miracle. The prophetic sign of deliverance (2 K 19 29; Isa 37 30) may be referred to the recovery of the devastated lands from the ravage inflicted by Sennacherib in his first campaign (cf also Ps 126 5f). ; I. His Character.—Our estimate of Hezekiah’s character is most consistently made by regarding him as a disciple of Isaiah, who was earnestly minded to carry out his prophetic ideas. As however, these were to begin with only the initial ideas of a spiritual “remnant,” the king’s sym- pathies must needs be identified at heart, not with his imperious nobles and princes, but with a minor- ity of the common people, whose religious faith did not become a recognizable influence in the state until after 701. In the meantime his zeal for purer wor- ship and juster domestic administration, which made him virtually king of the remnant, made him a wise and sagacious prince over the whole realm. Isaiah’s glowing prophecy (32 1-8) seems to be a Messianic projection of the saner and clearer-seeing era that his domestic policy adumbrated—a time when king and nobles rule in righteousness, when man can lean on man, when things good and evil are seen as they are and called by their right names. When it came to dealing with the foreign situation, however, esp. according to the Isaianic program, his task was exceedingly difficult, as it were a pioneer venture in faith. His effort to maintain an attitude of stedfast trust in Jeh, with the devout quietism which, though really its consistency and strength looked like a supine passivity, would lead his rest- lessly scheming nobles to regard him as a pious weakling; and not improbably they came to deem him almost a negligible quantity, and forced his hand into diplomacies and coalitions that were not to his mind. Some such insolent attitude of theirs seems to be portrayed in Isa 28 14-22. This was rendered all the more feasible, perhaps, by the eriod of incapacitation that must have attended is illness, in the very midst of the nation’s critical affairs. Isaiah’s words (83 17 ff) may be an allu- sion at once to his essential kingliness, to the abey- ance of its manifestation duc to his disease, and to the constricted condition into which, meanwhile, the realm had fallen. This exceedingly critical episode of Hezekiah’s career does not seem to have had its rights with students of the era. Considering the trials that his patient faith must have had, always at cross-purposes with his nobles (cf Ps 120 61); that now by reason of his sickness they had the whip hand; that his disease cut him off not only from hope of life, but from association with men and access to the sanctuary (cf Isa 38 10.11.12); that, as his son Manasseh was not born till three years within the fifteen now graciously added to his life (cf 2 K 21 1), his illness seemed to endanger the very perpetuity of the Davidic dynasty, we have reason for regarding him as well-nigh a martyr to the new spiritual uprise of faith which Isaiah was laboring to bring about. In the Messianic ideal which, in Isaiah’s sublime conception, was rising into personal form, it fell to his lot to adumbrate the first kingly stage, the stage of committal to Jeh’s word and will and abiding the event. It was a cardinal element in that composite ideal which the Second Isaiah pushes to its ultimate in his por- trayal of the servant of Jeh; another element, the element of sacrifice, has yet to be added. Mean- while, as with the king so with his remnant-realm, the venture of faith is like a precipitation of spirit- ual vitality, or, as the prophet puts it, a new birth (cf Isa 26 17{; 37 3; 66 7{, for the stages of it). The event of deliverance, not by men’s policies but by Jeh’s miraculous hand, was the speedy vindi- cation of such trust; and the revulsion of the next decade witnessed a confirming and solidifying of spiritual integrity in the remnant which made it a factor to be reckoned with in the trying times that succeeded (see under Manassen). The date of Hezekiah’s death (probably not long after 690) is not certainly known; nor of the death of his mentor Isaiah (tradition puts this by martyrdom under Manasseh); but if our view of his closing years is correct, the king’s death crowned a consistent char- acter of strength and spiritual stedfastness; while the popperoachable greatness of Isaiah speaks for itself. IV. Reflection of His Age in Literature.—The sublime and mature utterances of Isaiah alone, fall- ing in this time, are sufficient evidence 1. Compila- that in Hezekiah’s age, Israel reached tion and its golden literary prime. Among the Revival idealists and thinkers throughout the nation a new spiritual vigor and insight were awake, Of their fellowship was the king him- self, who emulated the activity of his predecessor Solomon as patron of piety and letters. The com- pilation of the later Solomonic section of the Prov- erbs (Prov 25-29), attributed to the “men of Hezekiah,” indicates the value attached to the Hezekiah High Day THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1388 accumulations of the so-called Wisdom literature; and it is fair to assume that these men of Hezekiah did not stop with compiling, but stamped upon the body of Proverbs as a whole that sense of it as a philosophy of life which it henceforth bears, and perhaps added the introductory section, Prov 1-9. Nor would a king so zealous for the organization and enrichment of the temple-worship (cf Isa 38 20) be indifferent to its body of sacred song. It seems certain that his was, in all the nation’s history, the greatest single agency in compiling and adapting the older Davidie Pss, and in the composition of new ones. Perhaps this union of collecting and creative work in psalmody is referred to in the men- tion of ‘‘the words of David, and of Asaph the seer’’ (2 Ch 29 30). To Hezekiah himself is attributed one ‘‘writing”’ which is virtually a psalm, Isa 38 20. The custom through all the history of hymnology (in our own day also) of adapting older composi- tions to new liturgical uses makes uncertain the identification of psalms belonging specifically to this period; still, many psalms of books ii and iii, and esp. those ascribed to Asaph and the sons of Korah, seem a close reflection of the spirit of the times. An interesting theory recently advanced (see Thirtle, OT Problems) that the fifteen Songs of the Steps (‘‘Degrees”’ or ‘‘Ascents,”’ Pss 120-34) are a memorial of Hezekiah’s fiftcen added years, when as a sign the shadow went backward on the steps of Ahaz (2 K 20 8-11), seems to reveal many remarkable echoes of that eventful time. Nor does it seem unlikely that with this first ex- tensive collection of psalms the titles began to be added. This literary activity of Hezekiah’s time, though concerned largely with collecting and reviving the treasures of older literature, was pur- 2. Of More sued not in the cold scribal spirit, but Creative in a fervid creative way. This may be Strain realized in two of the psalms which the present writer ascribes to this period. Ps 49, a psalm of the sons of Korah, is concerned to make an essential tenet of Wisdom viable in song (cf vs 3.4), as if one of the “men of Hezekiah” who is busy with the Solomonic counsels would popularize the spirit of his findings. Ps 78 in like manner, a Maschil of Asaph, is concerned to make the noble histories of old viable in song (ver 2), esp. the wilder- ness history when Israel received the law and beheld Jeh’s wonders, and down to the time when Ephraim was rejected and Judah, in the person of David, was chosen to the leadership in Israel. Such a didactic poem would not stand solitary in a period so instructed. As in Wisdom and psalmody, so in the domain of law and its attendant history, theliterary activity was vigorous. This age of Hezekiah seems the likeliest time for puting into literary idiom that ‘‘ book of the law’ found later in the Temple (2 K 22); which book Josiah's reforms, carried out according to its com- mands, prove to have been our Book of Dt. This is not the place to discuss the Deuteronomic problem (see under Josian); itis fair to note here, however, that as compared with the austere statement of the Mosaic statutes elsewhere, this book has a literary art and color- ing which seem to stamp its style as that of a later age than Moses’, though its substance is Mosaic; and this age of Hezekiah seems the likeliest time to put its re- writing and adaptation. Nor did the new spirit_of literary creation feed itself entirely on the past. The king's chastening experience of illness and trial, with the stedfast faith that upbore and survived it, must have been fruitful of new ideas, esp. of that tremendous con- ception, now just entering into thought, of the ministry of suffering. Time, of course, must be allowed for the ripening of an idea so full of involvement; and it is long before its sacrificial and atoning values come to light in such utterances as Isa §3. But such psalms as 49 and 73,not to mention Hezekiah's own psahn (Isa 38), show that the problem was a living one; it was working, moreover, in connection with the growing Wisdom phi- losophy, toward the composition of the Book of Job, which in a masterly way both subjects the current Wis- dom motives to a searching test and vindicates the intrinsic integrity of the patriarch in a discipline of ex- tremest trial. The life of a king whose experience had. some share in clarifying the ideas of such a book was not lived in vain. Joun FraNKLIN GENUNG HEZEKIAW’S SICKNESS. See Drat or Awaz. HEZEKIAH, THE MEN OF: A body of men of letters to whom is ascribed the compilation of a sup- plementary collection of Solomonic proverbs (Prov 25 1). See Proverss, Boox or, II, 5; Hazexran, IV, 2. HEZION, hé’zi-on (JPIM, hezydn; LXX B, *Atelv, Azein, A, ’AtafA, Azaél): An ancestor of Ben-hadad, king of Syria (1 K 16 18). HEZIR, hé’zér: 7 (1) (WT, béeir; LXX B, Xnfelv, Chézein, A, Ietelp, Iezeir): A Levite in the time of David (1 Ch 24 15). (2) (LXX ‘Htelp, Hézeir): A chief of the people in the time of Nehemiah (Neh 10 20). HEZRO, hez’rd, HEZRAI, hez’ra-i, hea‘ri (TTT, heerd, 2S 23 35; 1 Ch 11 37, but the Keré of 28 23 35is “I hezray. The ancient VSS almost unanimously support the form Hezrai): A Carmel- ite, ie. an inhabitant of Carmel. See CarmMEniTe. One of David's thirty “mighty men.” HEZRON, hez’ron (FEN, hegrén, and jI7Z, hegrin; LXX ’Acpav, Asrén): (1) Ason of Reuben (Gen 46 9; Ex 6 14), and head of the family of the Hezronites (Nu 26 6). (2) Ason of Perez, and grandson of Judah (Gen 46 12; Nu 26 21; 1 Ch 2 5.9.18.21.24.25; 4 1), a direct ancestor of David (Ruth 4 18f). He appears also in the genealogy of Our Lord ('Eepdu, Esrém) (Mt 1 3; Lk 3 33). HEZRON (j1730, hecrén, “inclosure’’): On the S. boundary of Judah between ‘“Kadesh-barnea’’ and ‘“Addar’ (Josh 15 3); in the || passage (Nu 34 4) “Hazar-addar.”” The two places may have been near together. Conder suggests that the name survives in Jebel Hadhireh, a mountain N.W. of Petra in the Tth. HEZRONITES, hez/ronits QO} and IEG , ha-hegroni; LXX 6 ’Acpwvel, ho Asrénet): The name of the descendants of Hezron the son of Reuben (Nu 26 6), and of the descendants of Hez- ron the son of Perez (26 21). HIDDAI, hid’é-i, hi-da’i CU, hidday; Alex. ‘A0Gal, Haththat): One of David’s thirty “mighty men” (2 § 23 30), described as “of the brooks of Gaash.”? In the || list in 1 Ch 11 32 the form of the name is “Hurai” (Y10, haray). HIDDEKEL, hid’é-kel OPI, hiddekel): One of the rivers of Eprn (q.v.) (Gen 2 14, RVm “that is, Tigris”; so L Tiyps, Tigris), said to flow E. to Assyria, usually identified with the Tigris, which rises in Armenia near Lake Van and, after flowing 8.E. through 8 degrees of latitude, joins the Eu- phrates in Babylonia to form the Shatt el-’Arab, which runs for 100 miles through a delta which has been formed since the time of Abraham, and now enters the Pers Gulf through 2 branches. About one-third of the distance below its source, and soon after it emerges from the mountains of Kurdistan, the Tigris passes by Mosul, the site of ancicnt Nineveh, and, lower down at Bagdad, ap- proaches within a few miles of the Euphrates. ere and for many miles below, since the level is lower 1389 than that of the Euphrates, numerous canals are conducted to it, irrigating the most fertile portions of Babylonia. Grorce FREDERICK WRIGHT HIDDEN, hid’’n: The tr of taman, “to hide,” ‘to bury” (Job 8 16); of ¢aphan “to conceal,” “store up’? (15 20, “The number of years is hidden to the oppressor,’’ RV “even the number of years that are laid up for the oppressor,’? m “and years that are numbered are laid up’; Job 24 1, ‘Why, seeing times are not hidden from the Almighty,” RV “Why are times not laid up by the Almighty?” m as AV with “Why is it?” prefixed; Ps 83 3, “They consulted [RV “‘consult’’] against thy hidden ones’); of magptunim (from ¢dphan), “hidden things or places’ (Ob ver 6, ‘How are his hidden things sought up!” RV “treasures,” ARV “sought out’); of pala’, “to be wonderful,” “difficult” (Dt 30 11, “This commandment . . . . isnot hidden from thee,” RV ‘‘too hard for thee,’ m “or wonderful’); of haphas, Hithpael, “‘to hide one’s self” (Prov 28 12, RV ‘‘When the wicked rise, men hide themselves,”’ m ‘Heb must be searched for’); of kruptés, “hidden,” ‘‘secret’’ (1 Pet 3 4, ‘the hidden man of the heart’; 1 Cor 4 5, krupton, “‘the hidden things of darkness’; 2 Cor 4 2, “the hidden things of dishonesty,” RV “‘of shame’); of apokrip- td, “‘to hide away,” trop., not to reveal or make known (1 Cor 2 7, “But we speak God’s wisdom in a mystery, even the wisdom that hath been hidden”; cf Eph 3 9; Col 1 26). Among the occurrences of ‘‘hidden’’ in Apoc we have (2 Esd 16 62), ‘'The Spirit of Almighty God.... searcheth out all hidden things in the secrets of the earth,’ RV ‘‘He who made all things and searcheth out hidden things in hidden places’'; Ecclus 42 19, ‘‘reveal- ing the steps [RV ‘‘traces”] of hidden things,"’ apékru- hos; ver 20, ‘‘ Neither any word is hidden from him,"’ V ‘‘hid,” ekrdbé). W. L. Walker HIEL, hi’el OSM, Ai’al; ’AxuAA, Achiél): A Bethelite who according to 1 K 16 34 rebuilt Jericho, and in fulfilment of a curse pronounced by Joshua (Josh 6 26) sacrificed his two sons. This seems to have been a custom prevalent among primitive peoples, the purpose being to ward off ill luck from the inhabitants, esp. in a case where the destroyer had invoked a curse on him who pre- sumed torebuild. Numerous instances are brought to light in the excavations of Gezer (Macalister, Bible Side-Lights from the Mound of Gezer, ch x). At first the very best was claimed as a gift to the deity, e.g. one’s own sons; then some less valuable member of the community. When civilization prevented human sacrifice, animals were offered instead. The story of Abraham offering Isaac may be a trace of this old custom, the tenor of the story implying that at the time of the writing of the record, the custom was coming to be in disrepute. A similar instance is the offering of his eldest son by the king of Edom to appease the deity and win suc- cess in battle (2 K 3 27; ef Mic 6 7). Various conjectures have been made as to the identity of this king. Ewald regarded him as a man of wealth and enterprise (unternehmender reicher Mann); Cheyne following Niebuhr makes it Jehu in dis- guise, putting 1 K 16 34after2 K 10 33; Winck- ler explains as folklore. W. N. Stearns HIERAPOLIS, hé-ér-ap’é-lis (“Iepdwodts, Hier- dpolis, “sacred city’): As the name implies, Hierap- olis was a holy city. It was situated 6 miles from Laodicea and twice that distance from Colossae, on the road from Sardis to Apamea. Though its history is not well known, it seems to have been of Lydian origin, and once bore the name of Kydrara. The Phrygian god Sabazios was worshipped there under the name Echidma, and represented by the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hezekiah High Day symbol of the serpent. Other local deities were Leto and her son Lairbenos. Though called the holy city, Hierapolis was peculiarly regarded as the stronghold of Satan, for there was a Plutonium, or a hole reaching far down into the earth, from which there issued a vapor, even poisoning the birds flying above. It is supposed that upon a stool, deep in the Plutonium, a priest or priestess sat, and, when under the influence of the vapor, uttered prophecies valuable to those who sought them. Though a stronghold of Satan, Hierapolis early became a Christian city, for, according to Col 4 13, the only place where it is mentioned in the NT, a church was founded there through the influence of Paul while he was at Ephesus. Tradition claims that Philip was the first evangelist to preach there, and it also claims that he and his two unmarried daughters were buried there; a third who was married, was buried at Ephesus. Several of the early Christians suffered martyrdom at Hierapolis, yet Christianity flourished, other churches were built, and during the 4th cent. the Christians filled the Plutonium with stones, thus giving evi- dence that the paganism had been entirely sup- planted by the church. During the Rom period, Justinian made the city a metropolis, and it con- tinued to exist into the Middle Ages. In the year 1190 Frederick Barbarossa fought with the Byzan- tines there. The modern town is called Pambuk Kalessi, or cotton castle, not because cotton is raised in the vicinity, but because of the white deposit from the water of the calcareous springs. The springs were famous in ancient times because they were supposed to possess Divine powers. The water is tepid, impregnated with alum, but pleasant to the taste. It was used by the ancients for dyeing and medicinal Punoeye: The deposit of pure white brought up y the water from the springs has heaped itself over the surrounding buildings, nearly burying them, and stalactite formations, resembling icicles, hang from the ruins. The ruins, which are exten- sive, stand on a terrace, commanding an extensive view, and though they are partly covered by the deposit, one may still trace the city walls, the temple, several churches, the triumphal arch, the gymnasium and baths, and the most perfect theater in Asia Minor. Outside the walls are many tombs. E. J. Banks HIEREEL, hi-er’é-el (‘IepefA, Hiereél): 1 Esd 9 21. In Ezr 8 9 the name is Jehiel. HIERIELUS, hi-er-i-é’lus (’Iefp{ydos, Tezriélos). See JezRiELUS. HIEREMOTH, hi-er’é-moth (‘Tepeya0, Iereméth): (1) 1 Esd 9 27=Jeremoth (Ezr 10 26). (2) 1 Esd 9 30=Jeremoth (Ezr 10 29, m ‘‘and Ramoth’’). HIERMAS, hi-dr’mas (‘Ieppds, Hiermds): 1 Esd 9 26, corresponding to Ramiah in Ezr 10 25. HIGGAION, hi-ga’yon, hi-gion (JT3G, hig- gayon): The meaning of this word is uncertain. Two interpretations are possible; the one based on an allied Arab. root gives ‘a deep vibrating sound,” the other derived from the Gr VSS of Ps 9 16, where we read higgdydn Selah, takes it to mean an instrumental interlude. See Psaums. HIGH DAY: Is found in Gen 29 7 as a render- ing of the Heb 2173 D1, yam gadhdl, lit. “great day.’’ The Heb means the day at its height, broad daylight, as contrasted with the time for getting the cattle to their sheds for the night (cf Fr. grand jour). In Jn 19 31, “highday” renders peydAq Highest High Things THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1390 tysépa, megdlé héméra, lit. ‘great day,’’ and refers to the Passover Sabbath—and therefore a Sabbath of special sanctity. HIGHEST, hi’est (JDP, ‘elyon; tweros, hi- psistos): The tr of ‘elyon, used frequently of God and commonly tr “Most High’ (Ps 18 13, “The Highest gave his voice,’’ RV “Most High’; 87 5, “the highest himself,” RV “Most High”; Ezk 41 7, ‘the lowest [chamber] to the highest’’); of gam- mereth, the foliage of a tree (as if the wool or hair of trees), “the highest branch” (Ezk 17 3.22, RV “top,” “lofty top”); of ra’sh, “head,’’ ‘‘top’’ (Prov 8 26, “the highest part of the dust of the world,” AVm “the chief part,’’ RV “the beginning of,’’ m “sum’’); gappé marém, “‘on the ridges of the heights” (Prov 9 3, “the highest places of the city’); ghabhéth méal gabhorh, lit. “one high [powerful] who is above the high [oppressor],”’ is tré “he that is higher than the highest’? (Eccl 5 8), RV “one higher than the high [regardeth].” In the NT, hupsistos (like ‘ely6n) is used of God (Lk 1 32, “the Son of the Highest,” ver 35, “the power of the Highest,” ver 76, “the prophet of the High- est’; 6 35, “‘the children of the Highest,” in these places RV has ‘Most High’’); we have also ‘‘Ho- ganna in the highest’? (Mt 21 9; Mk 11 10; see Hosanna), “Glory to God in the highest” (Lk 2 14), “Glory in the highest’ (Lk 19 38); prdtoklista, “the first reclining-place”’ (at table), the chief place at meals, the middle place in each couch of the triclinium (Robinson), is rendered (Lk 14 8), “‘the highest room,’”’ RV “chief seat’’; “room’’ was intro- duced by Tindale; Wiclif had ‘‘the first place” : protokathedria (prétos, “‘first,” kdthedra, “seat’’), ‘the first or chief seat,’’ is rendered (Lk 20 46) “‘the highest seats,’ RV “chief seats,’ Wiclif “the first chairs.’” “The Highest”’ as a term for God appears (2 Esd 4 11.34, RV “Most High’; Wisd 6 3, hupsistos; Ecclus 28 7, RV ‘Most High’’). See also Gon, NaMEs OF. W. L. WaLKER HIGHMINDED, hi’mind-ed: In modern usage denotes elevation of mind in a good sense, but formerly it was used to denote_upliftedness in a bad sense, pride, arrogance. It is the tr of hupsélophroné6, “to be highminded,” | “proud,” ‘haughty’ (Rom 11 20, “Be not highminded, but fear’; 1 Tim 6 17, ‘Charge them that are rich .... that they be not highminded”’); of tuphéa “to wrap in mist or smoke,’’ trop., to wrap in con- ceit, to make proud, ete (2 Tim 3 4, “Traitors, heady, highminded,” RV “puffed up”; ef 1 Tim 36; 6 4). “No one can be highminded without thinking better of himself, and worse of others, than he ought to think” (Crabb, English Synonymes). W. L. WaLkER HIGH, MOST. See Gop, Namus or. HIGH PLACE: (1) ‘High place’ is the normal tr of TAB, bamah, a word that means simply “‘ele- vation” (Jer 26 18; Ezk 36 2, ete; 1. General cf the use in Job 9 8 of the waves of the sea. For the pl. as a proper noun see Bamotu). In AV_ of Bak 16 24.25.31.39, “high places” is the tr of 27, rdmah (RV “lofty places”), a common word (see Raman) of exactly the same meaning, indistinguishable from bamdah in ver 16. In three of these vs of Ezk (24.31.39) raméh is paralleled by 24, gabh, which again has recisely the same sense (“eminent place” in AV, RV), and the ‘vaulted place” of ARV (ERVm) is in disregard of Heb parallelism. In particular, the high places are places of worship, specifically of idolatrous worship. So the title was transferred from the elevation to the sanctuary on the elevation (1 K 117; 14 23; ef the burning of the “high place” in 2 K 23 15), aud so came to be used of any idolatrous shrine, whether constructed on _an ele- vation or not (note how in 2 K 16 4; 2 Ch. 28 4 the “high places” are distinguished from the ‘‘hills’’). So the “high places” in the cities (2 K 17 9; 2 Ch 21 11 [LXX]) could have stood anywhere, while in Ezk 16 16 a portable structure seems to be in point. (2) The use of elevations for purposes of worship is so widespread as to be almost universal, a ad Tell Taanach (a Typical Canaanite High Place). and rests, probably, on motives so primitive as to evade formal analysis. If any reason is to be as- signed, the best seems to be that to dwellers in hilly country the heaven appears to rest on the ridges and the sun to go forth from them—but such reasons are certainly insufficient to explain everything. Certain it is that Israel, no less than her neighbors, found special sanctity in the hills. Not only was Sinai the ‘‘Mount of God,” but a long list can be drawn up of peaks that have a special relation to Jeh (see Mount, Mountain; and for the NT, ef Mk 9 2; He 12 18-24, ete). And the choice of a hilltop for the Temple was based on considerations other than convenience and visibility. (But bémah is not used of the Temple Mount.) Archaeological research, particularly at Petra and Gezer, aided by the OT notices, enables us to reconstruct these sanctuaries with 2. Descrip- tolerable fulness. The cult was not tion limited to the summit of the hill but took place also on the slopes, and the objects of the cult might be scattered over a con- siderable area. The most sacred objects were the upright stone pillars (mag¢ébhah), which seem to have been indispensable. (Probably the simplest “high places’? were only a single upright stone.) They were regarded as the habitation of the deity, but, none the less, were usually many in number (a fact that in no way need implicate a plurality of deities). At one time they were the only altars, and even at a.later period, when the altar proper was used, libations were sometimes poured on the pillars directly. The altars were of various shapes, according to their purpose (incense, whole burnt offerings, etc), but were always accompanied by one or more pillars. Saucer-shaped depressions, into which sacrifices could be poured, are a remnant of very primitive rites (to this day in Samaria the paschal lamb is cooked in a pit). The trees of the high place, esp. the “‘terebinths’’ (oaks?), were sacred, and their number could be supplemented or their absence supplied by an artificial tree or pole (dshérah, the “grove” of AV). (Of course the original meaning of the pillar and asherah was not always known to the worshipper.) An amusing feature of the discoveries is that these objects were often of minute size, so that the gods could be grati- fied at a minimum of expense to the worshipper. Images (ephods?; the t*ra@phim were household objects, normally) are certain, but in Pal no rem- nants exist (the little Bes and Astarte figures were ROCK ALTARS AT TELL EL-MUTASELLIM—MEGIDDO 1391 not idols used in worship). Other necessary fea- tures of a high place of the larger size were ample provision of water for lustral purposes, kitchens where the sacrifices could be cooked (normally by boiling), and tables for the sacrificial feasts. Kon mally, also, the service went on in the open air, but slight shelters were provided frequently for some of the objects. If a regular priest was attached to the high place (not always the case), his dwelling , Rts: Pos) eee Pillars and Hollow Stone of the High Place at Gezer. [Bible Side-Lights from the Mound of Gezer.] must have been a feature, unless he lived in some nearby village. Huts for those practising incuba- tion (sleeping in the sanctuary to obtain revelations through dreams) seem not to have been uncommon. But formal temples were very rare and “houses of the high places” in 1 K 12 31; 13 32; 2 K 17 29.32; 23 19 may refer only to the slighter structures just mentioned (see the comm.). In any case, however, the boundaries of the sanctuary were marked out, generally by a low stone wall, and ablutions and removal of the sandals were necessary before the worshipper could enter. For the ritual, of course, there was no uniform rule. The gods of the different localities were different, and in Pal a more or less thorough rededi- cation of the high places to Jeh had taken place. So the service might be anything from the orderly worship of Jeh under so thoroughly an accredited leader as Samuel (1 S 9 11-24) to the wildest orgiastic rites. That the worship at many high places was intensely licentious is certain (but it must be emphasized against the statements of many writers that there is no evidence for a specific phallic cult, and that the explorations have revealed no un- mistakable phallic emblems). The gruesome ceme- tery for newly born infants at Gezer is only one of the proofs of the prevalence of child-sacrifice, and the evidence for human sacrifice in other forms is unfortunately only too clear. See Gezzr, and illustration on p. 1224. (1) The opposition to the high places had many motives. When used for the worship of other gods their objectionable character is ob- 3. History vious, but even the worship of Jeh in the high places was intermixed with heathen practices (Hos 4 14, etc). In Am 6 21- 24, etc, sacrifice in the high places is denounced because it ig regarded as a substitute for righteous- ness in exactly the same way that sacrifice in the Temple is denounced in Jer 7 21-24. Or, sacri- fice in the high places may be denounced under the best of conditions, because in violation of the law of the one sanctuary (2 Ch 33 17, etc). (2) In 1 8, sacrifice outside of Jerus is treated as an entirely normal thing, and Samuel presides in one such case (1 S 9 11-24). In1 K the prac- tice of using high places is treated as legitimate before the construction of the Temple (1 K 3 2-4), but after that it is condemned unequivocally. The primal sin of Northern Israel was the establishment THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Highest High Things of high places (1 K 12 31-33; 13 2.33 f), and their continuance was a chief cause of the evils that came to pass (2 K 17 10f), while worship.in them was a characteristic of the mongrel throng that repopu- lated Samaria (2 K 17 32). So Judah sinned in building high places (1 K 14 23), but the editor of K notes with obvious regret that even the pious kings (Asa, 1K 16 14; Jehoshaphat, 22 43; Jehoash, 2K 123; Amaziah, 14 4; Azariah, 15 4; Jotham, 16 Be) did not put them away; i.e. the editor of K has about the point of view of Dt 12 8-11, according to which sacrifice was not to be restricted to Jerus until the country should -be at peace, but afterward the restriction should be absolute. The practice had been of such long standing that Hezekiah’s destruction of the high places (2 K 18 4) could be cited by. Rabshakeh as an act of apostasy from Jeh (2 K 18 22; 2 Ch 82 12; Isa 36 7). Under Manasseh they were ‘rebuilt, in connection with other idolatrous prac- tices (2 K 21 3-9), This act determined the final punishment of the nation (vs 10-15), and the root- and-branch reformation of Josiah (ch 23) came too late. The attitude of the editor of Ch is still more condemnatory. He explains the sacrifice at Gibeon as justified by the presence of the Tabernacle (1 Ch 16 39; 2129; 2 Ch 1 3.18), states that God- fearing northerners avoided the high places (2 Ch 11 16; cf 1 K 19 10.14), and (against K) credits Asa (2 Ch 14 3.5) and Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 17 6) with their removal. (This last notice is also in con- tradiction with 2 Ch 20 33, but 16 17a is probably meant to refer to the Northern Kingdom, despite 17b.) On the other hand, the construction of high places is added to the sins of Jehoram (2 Ch 21 11) and of Ahaz (2 Ch 28 4.5). (8) Among the prophets, Elijah felt the destruc- tion of the many altars of God as a terrible grief (1 K 19 10.14). Amos and Hosea each mention the high places by name only once (Am 7 9; Hos 10 8), but hoth prophets have only denunciation for the sacrificial practices of the Northern Kingdom. That, however, these sacrifices were offered in the wrong place is not said. Isa has nothing to say about the high places, except in 36 7, while Mic 1 5 equates the sins of Jerus with those of the high places (if the text is right), but promises the exaltation of Jerus (4 1f). In the references in Jer 7 31; 19 5; 32 85; Ezk 6 3.6; 16 16; 20 29; 48 7, idolatry or abominable practices are in point (so probably in Jer 17 3, while Jer 48 35 and Isa 16 12 refer to non-Israelites). (4) The interpretation of the above data and their historical import depend on the critical position taken as to the general history of Israel’s religion. See Reticion oF JsraEL; Criticism; DrEuTer- ONOMY, etc. LireRraTuRE.—See, esp., IpoLatry, and also ALTARS; AsueRaH, etc. For the archaeological lit., see Pauzs- TINE. Burton Scotr Easton HIGH PRIEST. Sce Prizst, Hicu. HIGH THINGS: The tr of hupsélés, “high,” “lofty,”’ “elevated” (Rom 12 16, “Mind not high things, but condescend to men of low estate,”” AVm “be contented with mean things,” RV ‘Set not your mind on high things, but condescend to [m “Gr be carried away with’’] things [m ‘‘them”’] that are lowly’); high things are proud things, things re- garded by the world as high. High thing is hipsdma, “a high place,” “eleva- tion,” ete (2 Cor 10 5, “casting down every high thing that is exalted against the knowledge of God,” ‘Vike a lofty tower or fortress built up proudly by the enemy’”’). In Jth 10 8; 13 4, hupsdma is ren- dered ‘‘exaltation.”’ W. L. WaLker Highway Hinnom THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1302 HIGHWAY, hi’'wa. See Roan; Way. HILEN, hi’len qen , hilén): A city in the hill country of Judah, probably W. or S.W. of Hebron, assigned with its suburbs to the Levites (1 Ch 6 58 [Heb 48]). The form of the name in Josh 15 51; 21 15 is Hoton (q.v.). HILKIAH, hil-ki’a (m>por, hilkiyah, ‘“Jeh is my portion”’ or ‘‘Jeh’s portion’): The name of 8 individuals in the OT or 7, if the person mentioned in Neh 12 7.21 was the same who stood with Ezra at the reading of the Law (Neh 8 4). The latter appears as Ezecias (AV) in 1 Esd 9 43. Five of this name are clearly associated with the priest- hood, and the others are presumably so. The ety- mology suggests this. Either interpretation of the name expresses the person’s claim on Jeh or the parents’ recognition of Jeh’s claim on him. (1) The person mentioned above (Neh 8 4, etc). (2) A Levite of the sons of Merari (1 Ch 6 45). (8) Another Levite of Merari, son of Hosah (1 Ch 26 11). Is he the “‘porter,’’ i.e. “doorkeeper” of 1 Ch 16 38? (4) Father of the Gemariah whom Zedekiah of Judah sent to Nebuchadnezzar (Jer 29 3). (5) The man in 2 K 18 18 ff who is evidently more famous as the father of Eliakim, the major- domo of Hezekiah’s palace (Isa 22 20 ff; 36 3 ff). Probably the father’s name is given in this and similar cases to distinguish between two persons of otherwise identical name. (6) A priest of Anathoth, father of Jeremiah (Jer 1 1). (7) The son of Shallum, and the best known of the name (1 Ch 6 13). He is great-grandfather of Ezra through his son Azariah (1 Esd 8 1; cf 1 Ch 911; Neh 11 11). He discovered the lost Book of the Law during the repairing of the Temple (2 K 22 4.8 ff); became chief leader in the ensuing reformation in 621 BC (2 K 23 4; 2 Ch 34 Off; 35 8). He showed the recovered book to Shaphan the scribe, who, in turn, brought it to the notice of the king. At Josiah’s request he led a deputation to Huldah the prophetess to ‘enquire of the Lord”’ concerning the new situation created by the dis- covery. The book discovered is nsnally identified with the Book of Dt. See DEuTERONomY. Henry WALLACE HILL, HILL COUNTRY, hil’ kun-tri: The com- mon tr of three Heb words: (1) MPRA, gibh‘ah, from root meaning ‘to be curved,” is almost always tr’ “hill”; it is a pecul- ia-ly appropriate designation for the very rounded hills of Pal; it is never used for a range of mountains. Several times it occurs as a place-name, “‘Gibeah of Judah” (Josh 15 20.57); ‘“Gibeah of Benjamin” or “Saul” (Jgs 19 12-16, etc); “Gibeah of Phine- has” (Josh 24 33m), ete (see GrszaH). Many such hills were used for idolatrous rites (1 K 14 23; 2K 17 10; Jer 2 20, etc). ; : (2) WO, har, frequently tr4 in AV “hill,” is in RV usually tr? “mountain” (cf Gen 7 19; Josh 15 9; 18 15f, and many other references), or ‘‘hill- country.” Thus we have the “hill-country of the Amorites” (Dt 1 7.19.20); the “hill-country of Gilead” (Dt 3 12); the “hill-country of Ephraim” (Josh 17 15.16.18; 19 50; 20 7, etc); the “‘hill- country of Judah”? (Josh 11 21; 20 7; 21 11; 2 Ch 27/4, etc; and (4 épew#, hé oreiné] Lk 1 39.65); the “hill-country of Naphtali” (Josh 20 7). For geographical descriptions scc PALESTINE, Country; pura; JupAg, ete. (3) DBY, ‘ophel, is tr? by “hill” in 2 K 6 24; Isa 32 14; Mic 4 8, but may possibly mean “tower” or “fort.” In other passages the word occurs with the art. as a place-name. See OPHEL. . W. G. MastermMan HILL, MOUNT, MOUNTAIN: (1) The commonest word is WW, har (also “1, hardr, and VW, herer), which is rendered “hill,” “mount,” or “mountain.” It occurs several hundreds of times. In a numher of places RV changes “‘hill’’ to “*moun- tain," eg. Gen 7°19, mountains covered by flood; Ex 24 4, Horeb; Josh 18 14, mountain hefore Beth-horon: Jgs 16 3, mountain before Hebron; Ps 95 4, ‘The heights of the mountains are his also"; 121 i, “I will lift up mine eyes unto the mountains.’ ‘ Hill’ remains in Dt 11 11, “land of hilis and valleys"; 1 K 20 23, “god of the hills’: Ps 2 6, ‘‘my holy hill of Zion”; 98 8, ‘hills sing for joy.’ ‘‘Mount’ is changed to “hill-country" in Dt 1 7, “hill-country of the Amor- ites"; Jgs 12 15, ‘“‘hill-country of the Amalekites’’; Dt 3 12, “hill-country of- Gilead"; but Gen 31 21, ‘mountain of Gilead'’; and Jgs 7 3, ‘‘ Mount Gilead." “Hill” or “hills” is changed to ‘hill-country”’ in Dt 17; Josh 9 1; 10 40; 11 16; 17 16; 2111. In Dtl 41.43, ARV changes “hill” to '‘hill-country,”’ while ERV has ‘‘mountain."’ The reasons for these differences of treatment are not in all cases apparent. (2) The Gr 8pos, dros, is perhaps etymologically akin to “Wi, har. Tt occurs often in the NT, and is usually tr? “mount” or “mountain.” In three places (Mt 6 14; Lk 4 29; 9 37) AV has hill, which RV retains, except in Lk 9 37, “when they were come down from the mountain”’ (of the trans- figuration). The derivative épevés, oreinds, “hill country,” occurs in Lk 1 39.65. (3) The common Heb word for “hill” is “933, gibh‘ah=Gibeah (Jgs 19.12); cf Geba, 923, gebha‘ (1 $ 18 8); Gibeon, JIRA, gib‘én (Josh 9 3); from root 334, gabha', ‘to be high’; cf Arab. Bae) 4 kubbeh, ‘‘dome”’; Lat caput; xepady}, kephalé. (4)In 18911, AV has “hill” for M23, ma‘dleh, root mby , ?alah, “to ascend”; cf Arab. Pad Ue, ‘ala’, “to be high,” and As, “ali, “high.” Here and elsewhere RV has “‘ascent.”’ (5) EV has “hill” in Isa 6 1 for TIP, keren, = 1. Names a “horn”; ef Arab. wy karn, “horn,” which is also used for a mountain peak. (6) 0, fdr, is trd “mountain” in Dnl 2 35.45, 3 but RVm “rock” in Dni 2 35. The Arab. yr. tar, “mountain,” is esp. used with Sinai, Aves meen ) lo, jebel tar sind’. (7) S82, mugcdbh (Isa 29 3), is tré in AV “mount,” in ERV “fort,” in ARV ‘“‘posted troops”; cf AB, magcabh, “garrison” (1 S 14 1, etc), from root AX} =—T? “to set.” (8) b$D, sollah, from 590, salal, “‘to raise,” isin AV and ERV “mount,” AVm “engine of shot,” ARV ‘‘mound” (Jer 32 24; 33 4; Ezk 42; 17 17; 21 22; 26 8; Dnl 11 15). The mountains and hills of Pal are the features of the country, and were much in the thoughts of ; the Bib. writers. Their general aspect 2. Figura- is that of vast expanses of rock. As tive and compared with better-watered regions Descriptive of the earth, the verdure is sparse and incidental. Snow remains through- out the year on Hermon and the two highest peaks of Lebanon, although in the summer it is in great isolated drifts which are not usually visible from below. In Pal proper, there are no snow moun- nacabh, ‘‘to set’’; cf Arab. es , nagab, 1393 tains. Most of the valleys are dry wadies, aud the roads often follow these wadies, which are to the traveler veritable ovens. It is when he reaches a commanding height and sees the peaks and ridges stretching away one after the other, with perhaps, through some opening to the W., a gleam of the sea like molten metal, that he thinks of the vastness and enduring strength of the mountains. At sun- set the rosy lights are succeeded by the cool purple shadows that gradually fade into cold gray, and the traveler is glad of the shelter of his tent. The stars come out, and there is no sound outside the camp except perhaps the cries of jackals or the barking of some goat-herd’s dog. These mountains are apt to repel the casual traveler by their bareness. They have no great forests on their slopes. Steep and rugged peaks like those of the Alps are entirely absent. There are no snow peaks or glaciers. There are, it is true, cliffs and crags, but the general outlines are not striking. Nevertheless, these mountains and hills have a great charm for those who have come to know them. To the Bib. writers they are symbols of eternity (Gen 49 26; Dt 33 15; Job 16 7; Hab 3 6). They are strong and stedfast, but they too are the creation of God, and they manifest. His power (Ps 18 7; 97.5; Isa 40 12; 4115; 5410; Jer 4 24; Nah 15; Hab 3 6). The hills were places of heathen sacrifice (Dt 122; 1K 117; 2K 164; 17 10; Ezk 6 13; Hos 4 13), and also of sacrifice to Jeh (Gen 22 2; 31 54; Josh 8 30). Zion is the hill of the Lord (Ps 2 6; 185 21; Isa 8 18; Joel 3 21; Mic 4 2). Many proper names are associated with the moun- tains and hills: as Abarim, Amalekites, Ammah, Amorites, Ararat, Baalah, Baal-hermon, Bashan, 8. Par- Beth-el, Bether, Carmel, Chesalon, Ebal, ticular Ephraim, Ephron, Esau, Gaash, Gareb, CAE: Geba, Gerizim, Gibeah, Gibeon, Gilboa, Mountains Gilead, Hachilah, Halak, Hebron, Heres, Hermon, Hor, Horeb, Jearim, Judah, Lebanon, Mizar, Moreh, Moriah, Naphtali, Neho, Olives, Olivet, Paran, Perazim, Pisgah, Samaria, Seir, Senir, Sephar, Shepher, Sinai. Sion, Sirion, Tahor, Zalmon, Zemaraim, Zion. See also ‘mountain of the east’ (Gen 0 30); ‘‘mountains of the leopards” (Cant 4 8); “rocks ild goats" (1 S 24 2); ‘hill of the foreskins"’ (Gibeah-haaraloth) (Josh 5 3); ‘‘mountains of brass (Zee 6 1); ‘hill of God" (Gibeah of God) (1.8 10 5); “hill of Jeh'’ (Ps 24 3); ‘‘mount of congre enone ste 14 13); see also Mt 4 8; 5 1; 14 23; 15 29; 17 1; 28 16; Lk 8 32; Gal 4 25. ALFRED Ety Day HILLEL, hil’el (O57, hillal, “he greatly praised”; LXX '’EAAAA, Ellél): An inhabitant of Pirathon in the hill country of Ephraim, and father of Abdon, one of the judges of Israel (Jgs 12 13.15). HIN, hin (7°, Ain): A liquid measure containing 12 logs, equal to about 8 quarts. See WurcuTs AND MEASURES. _HIND, hind. See Due. HIND OF THE MORNING, THE: The tr of Aijeleth hash-Shahar (‘ayyeleth ha-shahar) in the title of Ps 22, probably the name of some well- known song to which the ps was intended to be sung, which possibly had reference to the early habits of the deer tribe in search of water and food, or to the flight of the hind from the hunters in early dawn; or “morning” may symbolize the deliverance from persecution and sorrow. “The first rays of the morning sun, by which it an- nounces its appearance before being itself visible, are compared to the fork-like antlers of a stag; and this appearance is called, Ps 22 title, ‘The hind of the morn- ing,’ because those antler rays preceded the red of dawn, which again forms the transition to sunrise" (Delitzsch, Iris, 107). According to Hengstenberg, the words indicate the subject-matter of the poem, the character, sufferings, and triumph of the person who is set THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Highway Hinnom before us. Sec Psatms. For an interesting Mes- sianic interpretation see Hood, Christmas Evans, the Preacher of Wild Waies, 92 ff. M.O. Evans HINGE, hinj (M5, pdth): Hinges of Jewish sacred buildings in Scripture are mentioned only in connection with Solomon’s temple. Here those for the doors, both of the oracle and of the outer temple, are said to have been of gold (I K 7 50). By this is probably to be under- stood that the pivots upon which the doors swung, and which turned in the sockets of the threshold and the lintel, were cased in gold. The proverb, ‘As the door turneth upon its hinges, so doth the sluggard upon his bed” (Prov 26 14), describes the ancient mode of ingress and egress into important edifices. In the British Museum are many exam- ples of stone sockets taken from Bab and Assyr pal- aces and temples, engraved with the name and titles of the royal builder; while in the Hauran doors of a single slab of stone with stone pivots are still found in situ. Hinges, as we understand the word, were unknown in the ancient world. See Houss II, 1. Ancient Egyptian Hinges. 1, 2, 4. Bronze pivot hinges; 3. Ba- salt pivot for hinges.—Brit. Mus. W. SHaw Ca.pecorr HINNOM, hin’om, VALLEY OF (0379 73, gé hinném, Josh 16 8; 18 16; “valley of the son of Hinnom”’ [037 ja 74, gé bhen hinndm), Josh 16 8; 18 16; 2 Ch 283; 336; Jer 7 31f; 19 2.6; 32 35; “valley of the children [sons] of Hinnom”’ [OSM "2A "A, gé bheng hinndm], 2 K 23 10; or simply “the valley,” lit. the “hollow” or “ravine” [N°30, ha-gay’], 2 Ch 26 9; Neh 2 13.15; 3 18; Jer 31 40 and, perhaps also, Jer 2 23 [the above refer- ences are in the Heb text; there are some variations in the LXX]): The meaning of ‘‘Hinnom”’ is un- known; the expressions ben Hinnom and bené Hinnom would suggest that it is a proper name; in Jer 7 32; 19 6 it is altered by the prophet to ‘valley of slaughter,’’ and therefore some have thought the original name must have had a pleasing meaning. It was near the walls of Jerus, “by the entry of the gate Harsith’’ (Jer 19 2); the Valley Gate opened into it (Neh 213; 313). The 1. Bible boundary between Judah and Benja- References min ran along it (Josh 15 8; 18 16). and History It was the scene of idolatrous practices in the days of Ahaz (2 Ch 28 3) andof Manasseh, who “made his children to pass through the fire in the valley of the son of Hinnom”’ (2 Ch 33 6), but Josiah in the course of his reforms ‘“de- filed Topheth, which is in the valley of the children [m “son’’] of Hinnom, that no man might make his son or his daughter to pass through the fire to Mo- lech” (2 K 23 10). It was on account of these evil practices that Jeremiah (7 32; 19 6) announced the change of name. Into this valley dead bodies were probably cast to be consumed by the dogs, as is done in the Wddy er-Rabdabi today, and fires were here kept burning to consume the rubbish of the city. Such associations led to the Ge-Hinnom (NT “‘Gehenna’’) becoming the “type of Hell” (Milton, Paradise Lost, i, 405). See GEHENNA. The Valley of Hinnom has been located by differ- ent writcrs in each of the three great valleys of Jerus. In favor of the eastern or Kidron valley Hinnom Hittites THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1304 we have the facts that, Eusebius and Jerome (Onom) place “Gehennom’ under the eastern wall : of Jerus and the Moslem geographical 2. Situation writers, Mukaddasi and NAsir-i-khus- tan, call the Kidron valley Wddy Jahamum. The Jewish writer Kimchi also identifies the Valley of Jehoshaphat (i.e. the Kidron) with Hinnom. These ideas are probably due to the Z. 2 “ Sa Gehenna and Akeldama. identification of the eastern valley, on account of its propinquity to the Temple, as the scene of the last judgment—the “Valley of Jehoshaphat?’ of Joel 3 2—and the consequent transference there of the scene of the punishment of the wicked, Gehenna, after the ancient geographical position of the Valley of Hinnom, had long been lost. In selecting sacred sites, from the 4th Christian cent. onward, no critical topographical acumen has been displayed until quite modern times. There are three amply sufficient arguments against this view: (1) the Kidron valley is always called a nahal and not a gay’ (see Kivron); (2) the “Gate of the Gai” clearly did not lie to the E. of the city; (3) En-rogel, which lay at the beginning of the Valley of Hinnom and to its E. (Josh 15 8; 18 16) cannot be the ‘Virgin’s fount,’ the ancient Gihon (2 S 17 17). See GIHON. Several distinguished modern writers have sought to identify the Tyropceon Valley (el Wad) with Hinnom, but as the Tyropceon was incorporated within the city walls before the days of Manasseh (see JERUSALEM), it is practically impossible that it could have been the scene of the sacrifice of children—a ritual which must have occurred be- yond the city’s limits (2 K 23 10, ete). The clearest geographical fact is found in Josh 15 8; 18 16, where we find that the boundary of Judah and Benjamin passed from 3. WAdy er- En-rogel ‘‘by the valley of the son of Rababi Hinnom’’; if the modern Bir Eyydb is En-rogel, as is certainly most probable, then the Wddy er-Rabébi, known traditionally as Hinnom, is correctly so called. It is possible that, the name extended to the wide open land formed by the junction of the three valleys; indeed, some would place Tophet at this spot, but there is no need to extend the name beyond the actual gorge. The Wédy er-Rababi commences in a shallow, open valley due W. of the Jaffa Gate, in the center of which lies the Birkeé Mamilla; near the Jaffa Gate it turns S. for about 3 of a mile, its course being dammed here to form a large pool, the Birket es Sulian. Below this it gradually curves to the E. and rapidly descends between sides of bare rocky scarps, much steeper in ancient _times. A little before the valley joins the wide Kidron valley lies the traditional site of AKELDAMA (q.v.). E. W. G. Masrerman HIP (pw, shdk, “leg,” “limb,” “hip,” ‘‘shoul- der’): Samson smote the Philis “hip and thigh” (Heb “leg upon thigh’”’), which was indicative of ‘“‘a great slaughter” (Jgs 15 8), the bodies being hewed, in pieces with such violence that they lay in bloody confusion, their limbs piled up on one another in great heaps. See also SINEW. HIPPOPOTAMDS, hip-d-pot’a-mus (Job 41 1m). See BEHEMOTH. HIRAH, hi'ra (1, hirah; LXX Elpds, Hirds): A native of Adullam, and a “friend” of Judah (Gen 38 1.12). The LXX and the Vulg both describe him as Judah’s “shepherd.” HIRAM, hiram (7%, hiram; LXX Xipdp, Chirdm, but Xapép, Cheirdm, in 2S 6 11; 1 Ch 14 1): There is some confusion regarding the form of this name. In the books of S and K the pre- vailing form is ‘Hiram’ (O°, hirém); but in 1K 5 10.18m (Heb 24.32); 740m ‘“Hirom” (OT, hirém) is found. In Ch the form of the word is uniformly ‘“Huram’”’ (O77, haradm). (1) A king of Tyre who lived on most friendly terms with both David and Solomon. After David had taken the stronghold of Zion, Hiram sent messengers and workmen and materials to build a palace for him at Jerus (2 8 6 11; 1 Ch 14 1). Solomon, on his accession to the throne, made a league with Hiram, in consequence of which Hiram furnished the new king of Israel with skilled work- men and with cedar trees and fir trees and algum trees from Lebanon for the building of the Temple. In return Solomon gave annually to Hiram large quantities of wheat and oil (1 K 6 1 [Heb 15] ff; 2 Ch 2 3 [Heb 2] ff). “At the end of twenty years, wherein Solomon had built the two houses, the house of Jeh and the king’s house,” Solomon made a present to Hiram of twenty cities in the land of Galilee. Hiram was not at all pleased with these cities and contemptuously called them ‘‘Cabul.” His displeasure, however, with this gift, does not seem to- have disturbed the amicable relations that had hitherto existed between the two kings, for subsequently Hiram sent to the king of Israel 120 talents of gold (1 K 9 10-14). Hiram and Solo- mon maintained merchant vessels on the Medi- terranean and shared mutually in a profitable trade with foreign ports (1 K 10 22). Hiram’s servants, “shipmen that had knowledge of the sea,’”’ taught the sailors of Solomon the route from Ezion-geber and Eloth to Ophir, whence large stores of gold were brought to King Solomon (1 K 9 26; 2 Ch 8 171). Jos (CAp, I, 17, 18) informs us, on the authority of the historians Dius and Menander, that Hiram was the son of Abibal, that he had a prosperous reign of 34 years, and died at the age of 53. He’ tells us on the same authority that Hiram and Solomon sent problems to each other to solve; that Hiram could not solve those sent him by Solomon, whereupon he paid to Solomon a large sum of money, as had at first been agreed upon. Finally, Abde- mon, a man of Tyre, did solve the problems, and proposed others which Solomon was unable to ex- lain; consequently Solomon was obliged to pay ack to Hiram a vast sum of money. Jos further states (Ant, VIII, ii, 8) that the correspondence carried on between Solomon and Hiram in regard to the building of the Temple was preserved, not only in the records of the Jews, but also in the publie records of Tyre. It is also related by Phoenician historians that Hiram gave his daughter to Solomon in marriage. (2) The name of a skilful worker in brass and other substances, whom Solomon secured from 1395 Hiram king of Tyre to do work on the Temple. His father was a brass-worker of Tyre, and his mother was a woman of the tribe of Naphtali (1 K 7 14), “a woman of the daughters of Dan’’ (2 Ch 2 14 [Heb 13]; 1 K 7 13 ff; 2 Ch 2 13f [Heb 12.13)). Jesse L. Corron HIRCANUS, hér-ka’nuz. See Hrrcanus. HIRE, hir: Two entirely different words are tré “hire” in the OT: . (1) The most frequent one is "2W, sakhdr, vb. “20 , sdkhar, and verbal adj. W2W, sakhir. (a) As a vb. it means “to hire’’ for a wage, either money or something else; in this sense it is used with regard to ordinary laborers (1S 2 5; 2 Ch 24 12), or mercenary soldiers (25 10 6; 2K 76; 1 Ch 19 6; 2 Ch 26 6), or a goldsmith (Isa 46 6), or a band of loose followers (Jgs 9 4), or a false priest (Jgs 18 4), or Balaam (Dt 23 4; Neh 13 2), or hostile counsellors (Ezr 4 5), or false prophets (Neh 6 12f), As a verbal adj. it refers to things (Ex 22 15; Isa 7 20) or men (Lev 19 13; Jer 46 21). (b) As anoun it denotes the wage in money, or some- thing else, paid to workmen for their services (Gen 30 32f; 318; Dt 24 15; 1K 5 6; Zec 8 10), or the rent or hire paid for a thing (Ex 22 15), or a work-beast (Zec 8 10). In Gen 80 16 Leah hires from Rachel the privilege of having Jacob with her again, and her conception and the subsequent birth of a son, she calls her Aire or wage from the Lord for the gift of her slave girl to Jacob as a concubine (Gen 30 18). (2) The other word tr‘ hire is 72N, ’ethnan, once J2mIN , ’ethnan. It is rather a gift (from root D2, ndthan, “to give’) than a wage earned by labor, and is used uniformly in a bad sense. It is the gift made to a harlot (Dt 23 18), or, reversing the usual custom, made by the harlot nation (Kzk 16 31.41). It was also used metaphorically of the gifts made by Israelites to idols, since this was regarded as spiritual harlotry (Isa 23 17f; Mic 1 7; cf also Hos 8 9 f). In the Eng. NT the word occurs once as a vb. and 3 t as a noun as the tr of muodds, misthés, and its verbal form. In Mt 20 1.8 and Jas 6 4 it refers to the hiring of ordinary field laborers for a daily wage. In Lk 10 7 it signifies the stipend which is due the laborer in the spiritual work of the kingdom of God. It is a wage, earned by toil, as that of other laborers. The word is very significant here and absolutely negatives the idea, all too prevalent, that money received by the spiritual toiler isa gift. Itisrather a wage, the reward of real toil. Wiiiam Joszpa McGLotauin HIRELING, hir'ling (W>2W, sakhir): Occurs only 6 t in the OT, and uniformly means a laborer for a wage. In Job 7 1f there is reference to the hireling’s anxiety for the close of the day. In Isa 16 14 and 21 16 the length of the years of a hireling is referred to, probably because of the accuracy with which they were determined by the employer and the employee. Malachi (3 5) speaks of the oppression of the hireling in his wages, probably by the smallness of the wage or by in some way de- frauding him of part of it. In the NT the word “hireling”’ (uo Owrds, misthotds) occurs only in Jn 10 12f, where his neglect of the sheep is contrasted unfavorably with the care and courage of the shepherd who owns the sheep, who leads them to pasture and lays down his life for their protection from danger and death. Wiutam Joserpa McGuortauin HIS, hiz: Used often in AV with reference to a neuter or inanimate thing, or to a lower animal THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hinnom Hittites (Gen 1 11, “after his kind’; Lev 1 16, “pluck away his crop’”’ } Acts 12 10, “of his own accord’’; 1 Cor 15 38, “his own body’’), etc. RV substi- tutes “its.” HISS, his (PW, sharak): “To hiss’’ has two appli- cations: (1) to call, (2) to express contempt or scorn. (1) Itis the tr of sharak, a mimetic word meaning to hiss or whistle, to call (bees, etc), (a) Isa 5 26, “T will hiss unto them from the ends of the earth,” RV “hiss for them [m “him’’] from the end of the earth’; 7 18, “Jeh will hiss for the fly that is in the uttermost part of the rivers of Egypt, and for the bee that is in the land of Assyria’; viz. Egyptians whose land was noted for flies (18 1) and Assyrians whose country was preéminently one of bees. Danger- ous enemies are compared to bees in Dt 1 44; Ps 118 12 (Skinner’s Isaiah): Zec 10 8, “I will hiss for them, and gather them’’ (His own people, who will come at His call). (2) More often, to hiss is to express contempt or derision (1 K 9 8; Job 27 23; Jer 19 8, etc). In this sense we have also frequently a hissing (2 Ch 29 8; Jer 19 8; 26 9.18; 29 18; 51 37; Mic 6 16, sh*rékah); Jer 18 16, sh*rikdth or sh*rikoth; Ecclus 22 1, ‘Every one will hiss him [the slothful man] out in his disgrace’’ (eksurissd, ‘“‘to hiss out’); Wisd 17 9, “hissing of serpents’’ (surigmdés). W. L. WaLKER HITHERTO, hith’ér-to6 (to this): Used of both place and time. It is the tr of various words and phrases: (1) Of place, ‘adh hdélam (2 § 7 18, “Thou hast brought me hitherto,’ RV “thus far’; 1 Ch 17 16; perhaps 1 S 7 12, ‘adh hénnah, “Hitherto hath Jeh helped us” [in connection with the setting up of the stone Ebenezer]) belongs to this head; hénnah is properly an adv. of place; it might always be ren- dered ‘thus far.” (2) Of time, ‘adh koh, “unto this” (Ex 7 16, “Hitherto thou hast not hearkened”; Josh 17 14, “Hitherto Jeh hath blessed me’); méaz, “from then” (28 16 34, RV “in time past’); hal’ah, “beyond,” etc (Isa 18 7, “terrible from their be- ginning hitherto,’’ RV ‘‘onward’’); ‘adh kah, Aram. (Dnl 7 28, RV “here,’’ m “hitherto’’); ‘adh hén- nah, “unto here” (Jgs 16 138; 181 16; Ps 71 17, etc); dchri tou detro (Rom 1 13, ‘was let [RV “hindered’’] hitherto’’); héds drti, “until now’ (Jn 6 17, “My Father worketh hitherto, and I work,” RV “even until now,” that is, “on the Sabbath as well as on other days, and I do as He does”’; 16 24, “Hitherto have ye asked nothing in my name: ask, and ye'shall receive,” that is “up till now’; “now ask in my name and ye shall receive’); mipé, “not yet”’ (1 Cor 3 2, “Hitherto ye were not able to bear it,” RV ‘not yet’). W. L. Waker HITTITES, hit’its (0 WA, DUAN, bend beth, hittim; Xerrato., Chetiatoi): One of the seven nations conquered by Israel in Pal. I. OT Notices I. Enumeration of Races 2. Individuais 3. Later Mention II. History Sources . Chronology. : Egyptian Invasions: XVIIIth Dynasty “The Great King” Egyptian Invasions: XIXth Dynasty . Declension of Power: Aryan Invasion Second Aryan Invasion . Assyrian Invasions . Invasion by Assur-nasir-pal 10. Invasions by Shalmaneser II and Rimmon- nirari ITI 11. Revolts and Invasions 12. Break-up of Hittite Power 13. Mongols in Syrla OWNER GOW p+ Hittites THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1396 WII. Lanevacs - Mongol Race . Hittite and Egyptian Monuments . Hair and Beard . Hittite Dress : . Hittite Names . Vocabulary of Pterium Epistles - Tell el-Amarna Tablet IV. Reuicion 1. Polytheism: Names of Deities 2. Religious Symbolism V. Script 1. Cuneiform and Hieroglyphic 2. Description of Signs 3. Interpretation of Monuments LITERATURE I. OT Notices.—The “sons of Heth’’ are noticed 12 t and the Hittites 48 t in the OT. In 21 cases the name occurs in the enumeration 1. Enumer- of races, in Syria and Canaan, which are ation of said (Gen 10 6f) to have been akin Races to the early inhabitants of Chaldaea : and Babylon. From at least 2000 BC this population is known, from monumental records, to have been partly Sem and partly Mon- golic; and the same mixed race is represented by the Hittite records recently discovered in Cappadocia and Pontus. Thus while the Canaanites (“lowlanders’’), Amorites (probably “highlanders’’), Hivites (‘‘tribes- men”’) and Perizzites (“‘rusties’’) bear Sem titles, the Hittites, Jebusites and Girgashites appear to have non-Sem names. Ezekiel (16 3.45) speaks of the Jebusites as a mixed Hittite-Amorite people. The names of Hittites noticed in the OT include several that are Sem (Ahimelech, Judith, Bashe- _,. math, etc), but others like Uriah and 2. Individ- Beeri (Gen 26 34) which are probably uals non-Sem. Uriah appears to have mar- _ ., Ned a Heb wife (Bathsheba), and Esau in like manner married Hittite women (Gen 26 34; 36 2). In the time of Abraham we read of Hittites as far S. as Hebron (Gen 23 3 ff; 27 46), but there is no historic improbability in this at a time when the same race appears (see Zon) to have ruled in the Nile Delta (but see Gray in Expos, May, 1898, 340). NOR ONE In later times the “land of the Hittites’? (Josh 1 4; Jgs 1 26) was in Syria and near the Euphrates (see TAHTIM-HopsHI); though Uriah (2 11) lived in Jerus, and Ahimelech (1 8 26 6) followed David. In the time of Solomon (I K 10 29), the “kings of the Hittites’ are mentioned with the “kings of Syria,’ and were still powerful a century later (2 K 7 6). Solomon himself married Hittite wives (1 K 11 1), and a few Hittites seem still to have been left in the S. (2 Ch 8 7), even in his time, if not after the captivity (Ezr 9 1; Neh 9 8). IL History.—The Hittites were known to the Assyrians as Hatli, and to the Egyptians as Kheta, and their history has been very fully 1. Sources recovered from the records of the XVIIIth and XIXth Egyp Dynasties, from the Am Tab, from Assyr annals and, quite 3. Later Mention recently, from copies of letters addressed to Bab rulers by the Hittite kings, discovered by Dr. H. Winckler in the ruins of Boghaz-keui (‘the town of the pass’), the ancient Pterium in Pontus, E. of the river Halys. The earliest known notice (King, Egypt and W. Asia, 250) is in the reign of Saamsu-ditana, the last king of the first Bab Dy- nasty, about 2000 BC, when the Hittites marched on the “land of Akkad,” or “highlands” N. of Meso- potamia. The chronology of the Hittites has been made clear by the notices of contemporary rulers in Baby- lonia, Matiene, Syria and Egypt, 2. Chronol- found by Winckler in the Hittite ogy correspondence above noticed, and is of great importance to Bible history, because, taken in conjunction with the Am Tab, with the Kassite monuments of Nippur, with the Bab chronicles and contemporary chronicles of Babylon and Assyria, it serves to fix the dates of the Egyp kings of the XVIJIth and XIXth Dynasties which were previously uncertain by nearly a century, but which may now be regarded as settled within a few years. From the Am Tab it is known that Thothmes IV was contemporary with the father of Adad-nirari of. Assyria (Berlin no. 30), and Amenophis IV with Buma-burias of Babylon (Brit. Mus. no. 2); while a letter from Hattu-sil, the Hittite contemporary of Rameses I], was addressed to Kadashman-lurgu of Babylon on the occasion of his accession. These notices serve to show that the approximate dates given by Brugsch for the Pharaohs are more correct than those pro- posed by Mahler; and the following table will be useful for the understanding of the history—Thoth- mes III being known to have reigned 54 years, Amenophis ITI at least 36 years, and Rameses II, 66 yearsor more. The approximate dates appear to be thus fixed. The Hyksos race having been expelled from the Delta by Aahmes, the founder of the XVIIIth (Theban) Dynasty, after 1700 BC, 3. Egyptian the great trade route through Pal and Invasions: Syria waslater conquered by Thothmes XVIIIth I, who set up a monument on the W. Dynasty bank ofthe Euphrates. The conquests of Aahmes were maintained by his suc- cessors Amenophis I and Thothmes I and II; but when Thothmes III attained his majority (about 1580 BC), a great league of Syrian tribes and of Canaanites, from Sharuhen near Gaza and “from the water of Egypt, as far as the land of Naharain” (Aram-naharaim), opposed this Pharaoh in his 22d ‘aay being led by the king of Kadesh—probably adesh on the Orontes (now Kedes, N. of Riblah)— but they were defeated near Megiddo in Central Pal; and in successive campaigns down to his 31st year, Thothmes III reconquered the Pal plains, and all Syria to Carchemish on the Euphrates. In his 29th year, after the conquest of Tuneb (now Tennib, W.of Arpad), he mentions the tribute of the Hit- tites including ‘304 Ibs in 8 rings of silver, a great piece of white precious stone, and zagu wood.” ‘They were, however, still powerful, and further wars in Syria were waged by Amenophis II, while Thoth- mes IV also speaks of his first “campaign against the land of the Khbeta.’’ Adad-nirari I wrote to Egypt to say that Thothmes IV had established his father (Bel-tiglat-Assur) as ruler of the land of Marhasse (probably Mer’ash in the extreme N. of Syria), and to ask aid against the “king of the land of the Hittites.’ Against the increasing power of this race Thothmes IV and his son Amenophis III strengthened themselves by marriage alliances with the Kassite kings of Babylon, and with the cognate rulers of Matiene, E. of the Hittite lands of Syria, and Cappadocia. Dusratta of Matiene, whose sister 1397 _THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hittites Gilukhepa was married by Amenophis III in his 10th year, wrote subsequently to this Pharaoh to announce his own accession (Am Tab, Brit. Mus. no. 9) and his defeat of the Hittites, sending a two- horse chariot and a young man and young woman as “spoils of the land of the Hittites.’ About this time (1480 BC) arose a great Hittite ruler bearing the strange name Subbiliuliuma, similar to that of Sapalulmi, chief of 4, “The the Hattinai, in North Syria, men- Great King” tioned by Shalmaneser II in the 9th cent. BC. He seems to have ruled at Pterium, and calls himself ‘the great king, the noble king of the Hatti.”’ He allied himself against Dusratta with Artatama, king of the Harri or North Syrians. The Syrian Hittites in Marhassi, N. of the land of the Amorites, were led shortly after by Edugamma of Kinza (probably Kittiz, N. of Arpad) in alliance with Aziru the Amorite, on a great raid into Phoenicia and to Bashan, S. of Damascus. Thus it appears that the Amorites had only reached this region shortly before the Heb conquest of The XVIIIth Dynasty was succeeded, about 1400 BC, or a little later, by the XIXth, and Rameses I appears to have been the 5. Egyptian Pharaoh who made the treaty which Invasions: Mursilis, brother of Arandas, con- XIXth tracted with Egypt. But on the Dynasty accession of Seti I, son of Rameses I, the Syrian tribes prepared to “make a stand in the country of the Harri’ against the Egyp resolution to recover the suzerainty ofs their country. Seti I claims to have conquered ‘‘Kadesh (on the Orontes) in the Land of the Amorites,’’ and it is known that Mutallis, the eldest son of Mur- silis, fought against Egypt. According to his younger brother Hattusil, he was a tyrant, who was finally driven out by his subjects and died before the accession of Kadashman-Turgu (about 1355 BC) in Babylon. Hattusil, the contemporary of Rameses II, then seized the throne as ‘‘great king of the Hittites’ and “king of Kus’ (“Cush,”’ Gen 2 13), a term which in the Akkadian language meant, “the West.” In his 2d year Rameses II advanced, CONTEMPORARIES OF THE HITTITE KINGS Babylon Assyria Egypt 1529 BC, Ussi ce 1520 BC, Bel-tiglat-Assur e 1520 BC, Thothmes IV 1521 ‘‘ Adumetas ©1510 ‘* Tazzigurumas e 1500 ‘* Agukakrime ¢ 1500 Rimmon-nirari I ¢ 1490 ‘* Kadashman-Aku ec 1490 Amenophis IIT ec 1480 ‘* Kadashman-indas ec 1480 “ Assur-Bel-nisisu © 1475 ** Kuri-galzul e 1454 ‘' Amenophis IV ec 1440 ‘* Burna-burias ec 1450 ‘* Buzur-Assur ce 1480 ‘* Horus ec 1400 ‘* Kadashman-urutas c 1430 ‘ Assur-uballidh e 1400 ‘* Rameses I e€ 13895 ‘* Kuri-galzu IT ec 1390 ‘* Bel-nirari I ¢ 1355 ‘' Nazimarutas ce 1360 ‘ Arik-dén-ilu ec 1360 ‘ Setil e 1335 ‘* Kadashman-Turgu e 1340 ‘* Adad-nirari II ¢ 1337 ‘* Rameses II ec 1320 Kadashman-burias e 1320 ‘* Shalmaneser I c 1300 Kadashman-Enlil ©1300 ‘“ Tukulti-Ninip e© 1285 ‘ Sagarakti-burias e 1270 ‘* Rimmon-nadin-akhi e© 1265 ‘* Bél-kudur-usur ec 1270 ‘* Merenptah e 1240 ‘* Rimmon-sum-nasir ©1235 ‘* Adar-bal-asar e 12385 “ Seti IT e 1210 Zagaga-sum-edin c 1200 ‘ Assur-dan 1176 Marduk-bal-edin ©1175 “* Mutakkil-Nusku ec 1200 ‘** Rameses III Bashan. Amenophis III repelled them in Phoeni- | after the capture of Ashkelon, as far as Beirft, and cia, and Subbiliuliuma descended on Kinza, having made a treaty with Egypt, and captured Edugamma and his father Suttatarra. He also conquered the land of Ikata which apparently lay E. of the Eu- hrates and S. of Carchemish. Some 30 years ater in the reign of Amenophis IV, Dusratta of Matiene was murdered, and _ his kingdom was attacked by the Assyrians; but Subbiliuliuma, though not a friend of Dusratta with whom he disputed the suzerainty of North Syria, sent aid to Dusratta’s son Mattipiza, whom he set on his throne, giving him his own daughter as a wife. A little later (about 1440 BC) Aziru the Amorite, who had been subject to Amenophis III, submitted to this same great Hittite ruler, and was soon able to conquer the whole of Phoenicia down to Tyre. All the Egyp conquests were thus lost in the latter part of the reign of Amenophis III, and in that of Ameno- phis IV. Only Gaza seems to have been retained, and Burna-burias of Babylon, writing to Amenophis IV, speaks of the Canaanite rebellion as beginning in the time of his father Kuri-galzu I (Am Tab, Brit. Mus. no. 2), and of subsequent risings in his own time (Berlin ne. 7) which interrupted communi- cation with Egypt. Assur-yuballidh of Assyria (Berlin no. 9), writing to the same Pharach, states also that the relations with Assyria, which dated back even to the time of Assur-nadin-akhi (about 1550 BC), had ceased. About this earlier period Thothmes III records that he received presents from Assyria. The ruin of Egypt thus left the Hittites independent, in North Syria, about the time when —according to OT chronology—Pal was conquered by Joshua. They probably acknowledged Arandas, the successor of Subbiliuliuma, as their suzerain. in his 5th year he advanced on Kadesh where he was opposed by a league of the natives of ‘the land of the Kheta, the land of Naharain, and of all the Kati’ (or inhabitants of Cilicia), among which con- federates the “prince of Aleppo’ is specially noticed. The famous poem of Pentaur gives an exaggerated account of the victory won by Rameses II at Kadesh, over the allies, who included the people of Carchemish and of many other unknown places; for it admits that the Egyp advance was not con- tinued, and that peace was concluded. A second war occurred later (when the sons of Rameses I[ were old enough to take part), and a battle was then fought at Tuneb (Tennib) far N. of Kadesh, robably about 13816 BC. The celebrated treaty Beuween Rameses IT and Hattusil was then made, in the 21st year of the first named. It was engraved on a silver tablet having on the back the image of Set (or Sutekh), the Hittite god of heaven, and was brought to Egypt by Tar-Tessubas, the Hittite envoy. The two “great kings” treated together as equals, and formed a defensive and offensive alliance, with extradition clauses which show the advanced civilization of the age. In the 34th year of his reign, Rameses II (who was then over 50 years of age) married a daughter of Hattusil, who wrote to a son of Kadashman-Turgu (probably Kadashman-burias) to inform this Kassite ruler of Babylon of the event. He states in another letter that he was allied by marriage to the father of Kadashman-Turgu, but the relations between the Kassite rulers and the Hittites were not very cordial, and complaints were made on both sides. Hattusil died before Rameses II, who ruled to extreme old age; for the latter (and his queen) wrote letters to Hittites THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1398 Pudukhipa, the widow of this successful Hittite overlord. He was succeeded by Duchalia, who calls himself “the great king’ ‘and the “son of Pudukhipa the great queen, queen of the land of the city of the Hatti.” Hittite King and Daughter. _ The Hittite power began now, however, to decline, in consequence of attacks from the W. by hostile Aryan invaders. In the 5th year of 6. Declen- Seti Merenptah II, son of Rameses II, sion of these fair ‘“‘peoples of the North” raided Power: the Syrian coasts, and advanced even Aryan In- to Belbeis and Heliopolis in Egypt, vasion in alliance with the Libyans W. of the Delta. They were defeated, and Merenptah appears to have pursued them even to Pa-Kan’ana near Tyre. A text of his 5th year (found by Dr. Flinders Petrie in 1896) speaks of this campaign, and says that while ‘‘Israel is spoiled” the ‘‘Hittites are quieted’: for Merenptah appears to have been on good terms with them, and allowed corn to be sent in ships ‘‘to preserve the life of this people of the Hatti.”’ Dudhalia was succeeded by his son “Arnuanta the great king,” of whom a bilingual seal has been found by Dr. Winckler, in Hittite and cuneiform characters; but the con- federacy of Hittite tribes which had so long resisted Egypt seems to have been broken up by these disasters and by the increasing power of Assyria. A second invasion by the Aryans occurred in the reign of Rameses III (about 1200 BC) when “agi- tation seized the peoples of the North,”’ 7. Second and “no people stood before their Aryan In- arms, beginning with the people of the vasion Hatti, of the Kati, of Carchemish and Aradus.” The invaders, including Da- nai (or early Greeks), came by land and sea to Egypt, but were again defeated, and Rameses ITI— the last of the great Pharaohs—pursued them far north, and is even supposed by Brugsch to have conquered Cyprus. Among the cities which he took he names Carchemish, and among his captives were ‘the miserable king of the Hatti, a living prisoner,” and the ‘‘miserable king of the Amorites.”’ : Half a century later (1150 BC) the Assyrians began to invade Syria, and Assur-ris-ist reached Beirit; for even as early as about 1270 BC Tukulti- Ninip of Assyria had conquered the Kassites, and had set a Sem prince on their throne in Babylon. Early in his reign (about 1130 BC) Tiglath-pileser I claims to have subdued 42 kings, marching “‘to the fords of the Euphrates, the land of the Hatti, and the upper sea of the setting sun’’—or 8. Assyrian Mediterranean. Soldiers of the Hatti Invasions had seized the cities of Sumasti (prob- ably Samosata), but the Assyr conqueror made his soldiers swim the Euphrates on skin bags, and so attacked “‘Carchemish of the land of the Hittites.” The Moschians in Cappadocia were ap- parently of Hittite race, and were ruled by 5 kings: for 50 years they had exacted tribute in Comma-~ gene (Northeastern Syria), and they were defeated, though placing 20,000 men in the field against Tiglath-pileser I. He advanced to Kumani (prob- ably Comana in Cappadocia), and to Arini which was apparently the Hittite capital called Arinas (now Iranes), W. of Caesarea in the same region. The power of the Hittites was thus broken by Assyria, yet they continued the struggle for more than 4 centuries afterward. After the 9. Invasion defeat of Tiglath-pileser I by Marduk- by Assur- nadin-akhi of Babylon (1128-1111 nasir-pal BC), there is a gap in Assyr records, and we next hear of the Hittites in the reign of Assur-nasir-pal (883-858 BC); he entered Commagene, and took tribute from ‘‘the son of Bahian of the land of the Hatti,’”’ and from ‘‘San- gara of Carchemish in the land of the Hatti,’’ so that it appears that the Hittites no longer acknowl- edged a single “great king.’”’ They were, however, still rich, judging from the spoil taken at Carche- mish, which included 20 talents of silver, beads, chains, and sword scabbards of gold, 100 talents of copper, 250 talents of iron, and bronze objects from the palace representing sacred bulls, bowls, cups and censers, couches, seats, thrones, dishes, instruments of ivory and 200 slave girls, besides embroidered robes of linen and of black and purple stuffs, gems, elephants’ tusks, chariots and horses. The Assyr advance continued to ‘Azz4z in North Syria, and to the Afrin river, in the country of the Hattinai who were no doubt Hittites, where similar spoils are noticed, with 1,000 oxen and 10,000 sheep: the pagutu, or “maces” which the Syrian kings used as scepters, and which are often represented on Hittite monuments, are specially mentioned in this record. Assur-nasir-pal reached the Mediterranean at Arvad, and received tribute from “kings of the sea coast’’ including those of Gebal, Sidon and Tyre. He reaped the corn of the Hittites, and from Mt. Amanus in North Syria he took logs of cedar, pine, box and cypress. His son Shalmaneser II (858-823 BC) also in- vaded Syria in his Ist year, and again mentions Sangara of Carchemish, with Sapalulmi 10. Inva- of the Hattinai. In Commagene the sions by chief of the Gamgums bore the old Shalma- Hittite name Mutallis. In 856 BC neserJIand Shalmaneser II attacked Mer’ash and immon- advanced by Dabigu (now Toipuk) nirari III to ‘Azziz. He took from the Hat- tinai 3 talents of gold, 100 of silver, 300 of copper, 1,000 bronze vases and 1,000 em- broidered robes. He also accepted as wives a daughter of Mutallis and another Syrian princess. Two years later 120,000 Assyrians raided the same region, but the southward advance was barred by the great Syrian league which came to the aid of Irhuléna, king of Hamath, who was not sub- dued till about 840 BC. In 836 BC the people of Tubal, and the Kati of Cappadocia and Cilicia, were again attacked. In 831 BC Qubarna, the vassal king of the Hattinai in Syria, was murdered by his subjects, and an Assyr tartanu or general was sent to restore order. The rebels under Sapalulmi had been confederated with Sangara of Carchemish. Adad-nirari III, grandson of Shalmaneser II, was 1399 the next Assyr conqueror: in 805 BC he attacked ‘Azziz and Arpad, but the resistance of the Syrians was feeble, and presents were sent from Tyre, Sidon, Damascus and Edom. This conqueror states that he subdued “the land of the Hittites, the land of the Amorites, to the limits of the land of Sidon,” as well as Damascus, Edom and Philistia. But the Hittites were not as yet thoroughly sub- dued, and often revolted. In 738 BC Tiglath- pileser I1 mentions among his tribu- 11. Revolts taries a chief of the Gamgums bearing and In- the Hittite name Tarku-lara, with vasions Pisiris of Carchemish. In 702 BC Sennacherib passed peacefully through the “land of the Hatti’” on his way to Sidon: for in 717 BC Sargon had destroyed Carchemish, and had taken many of the Hittites prisoners, sending them away far east and replacing them by Baby- lonians. Two years later he in the same way took the Hamathites as captives to Assyria. Some of the Hittites may have fled to the S., for in 709 BC Sargon states that the king of Ashdod was deposed by “people of the Hatti plotting rebellion who des- pised his rule,’’ and who set up Azuri instead. The power of the Hittites was thus entirely broken before Sennacherib’s time, but they were not entirely exterminated, for, in 673 BC, Esar- 12. Break- haddon speaks of “twenty-two kings up of Hit- of the Hattiandnearthesea.’”’ Hittite tite Power names occur in 712 BC (Tarhu-nazi of Meletene) and in 711 BC (Mutallis of Commagene), but after this they disappear. Yet, even in a recently found text of Nebuchad- nezzar (after 600 BC), we read that ‘‘chiefs of the land of the Hattim, bordering on the Euphrates to the W., where by command of Nergal my lord I had destroyed their rule, were made to bring strong beams from the mountain of Lebanon to my city Babylon.” A Hittite population seems to have survived even in Rom times in Cilicia and Cappadocia, for (as Dr. Mordtman observed) a king and his son in this region both bore the name Tarkon-dimotos in the time of Augustus, according to Dio Cassius and Tacitus; and this name recalls that of Tarku-timme, the king of Erine in Cappa- docia, occurring on a monument which shows him as brought captive before an Assyr king, while the same name also occurs on the bilingual silver boss which was the head of his scepter, inscribed in Hittite and cuneiform characters. The power of the Mongolic race decayed gradu- ally as that of the Sem Assyrians increased; but even now in Syria the two races remain 13. Mon- mingled, and Turkoman nomads still gols in camp even as far §. as the site of Syria Kadesh on the Orontes, while a few tribes of the same stock (which entered Syria in the Middle Ages) still inhabit the plains of Sharon and Esdraelon, just as the southern Hit- tites dwelt, among the Amorites at Jerus and Hebron in the days of Abraham, before they were driven north by Thothmes III. ; If, Language.—The gucstions of race and lan- guage in early times, before the early stocks were mixed or decayed, cannot be dissoci- 1. Mongol ated, and we have abundant evidence Race of the racial type and characteristic dress of the Hittites. The late Dr. Birch of the British Museum pointed out the Mon- gol character of the Hittite type, and his opinion has been very generally adopted. In 1888 Dr. Sayce (The Hittites, 15, 101) calls them ‘“Mongoloid,”’ and says, “They had in fact, according to craniolo- gists, the characteristics of a Mongoloid race.” This was also the opinion of Sir W. Flower; and, if the Hittites were Mongols, it would appear prob- able that they spoke a Mongol dialect. It is also THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hittites apparent that, in this case, they would be related to the old Mongol population of Chaldaea (the people of Akkad and Sumir or “of the highlands and river valley”) from whom the Sem Babylonians derived their earliest civilization. Passage-Frieze, Iasili-kaia. The Hittite type is represented, not only on their own monuments, but on those of the XVIIIth and XIXth Egyp Dynasties, including a 2. Hittite colored picture of the time of Rame- on Egyp- ses III. The type represented has a tian Monu- short head and receding forehead, ments a prominent and sometimes rather curved nose, a strong jaw and a hair- less face. The complexion is yellow, the eyes slightly slanting, the hair of the head black, and gathered into a long pigtail behind. The physiog- nomy is like that of the Sumerians represented on a bas-relief at Tel-loh (Zirgul) in Chaldaea, and very like that of some of the Kirghiz Mongols of the present time, and of some of the more purely Mon- golic Turks. The head of Gudea at Zirgul in like manner shows (about 2800 BC) the broad cheek bones and hairless face of the Turkish type; and the language of his texts, in both grammar and vocabu- lary, is closely similar to pure Turkish speech. Gz Le “ofo . AES REGS Priest-King and God of Cultivation. ie Hs" Among Mongolic peoples the beard grows only late in life, and among the Akkadians it is rarely represented—-excepting in the case of 8. Hair and gods and ancient kings. The great Beard bas-relief found by Koldewey at : Babylon, and representing a Hittite thunder-god with a lone pigtail and (at the back) a Hittite inscription, is bearded, but the pigtailed heads on other Hittite monuments are usually hair- Hittites less. At Iasili-Kaia—the rock shrine near Pterium —only the supreme god is bearded, and all the other male figures are beardless. At Ibreez, in Lycaonia, the gigantic god who holds corn and grapes in his hands is bearded, and the worshipper who approaches him also has a beard, and his hair is arranged in the distinctive fashion of the Sem Babylonians and Assyrians. This type may represent Sem mixture, for M. Chantre discovered at Kara-eyak, in Cappa- docia, tablets in Sem Bab representing traders’ letters perhaps as old as 2000 BC. The type of the Ibreez figures has been said to resemble that of the Armenian peasantry of today; but, although the Armenians are Aryans of the old Phrygian stock, and their language almost purely Aryan, they have mixed with the Turkish and Sem races, and have been said even to resemble the Jews. Little re- liance can be placed, therefore, on comparison with modern mixed types. The Hittite pigtail is very distinctive of a Mongolic race. It was imposed on the Chinese by the Manchus in the 17th cent., but it is unknown among Aryan or Sem peoples, though it seems to be represented on some Akkadian seals, and on a bas-relief picturing the Mongolic Susians in the 7th cent. BC. The costume of the Hittites on monuments seems also to indicate Mongolic origin. Kings and riests wear long robes, but warriors (and the gods at Ibreez and Babylon) wear short jerkins, and the Turkish shoe or slipper with a curled-up toe, which, however, is also worn by the Heb tribute bearers from Jehu on the ‘‘black obelisk” (about 840 BC) of Shalmaneser II. Hittite gods and warriors are shown as wearing a high, conical head- dress, just like that which (with addition of the Moslem turban) characterized the Turks at least as late as the 18th cent. The short jerkin also appears on Akkadian seals and bas-reliefs, and, 4. Hittite Dress Hittite Warrior (from Senjirli). generally speaking, the Hittites (who were enemies of the Lycians, Danai and other Aryans to their west) may be held to be very clearly Mongolic in physical type and costume, while the art of their monuments is closely similar to that of the most archaic Akkadian and Bab sculptures of Meso- potamia. It is natural to suppose that they were a branch of the same remarkable race which civilized THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1400 Chaldaea, but which seems to have had its earliest home in Akkad, or the “highlands” near Ararat and Media, long before the appearance of Aryan tribes either in this region or in Ionia. The con- clusion also agrees with the OT statement that the Hittites were akin to the descendants of Ham in Babylonia, and not to the “fair” tribes (Japheth), incliding Medes, Ionians and other Aryan peoples. As early as 1866 Chabas remarked that the Hittite names (of which so many have been men- tioned above) were clearly not Sem, and this has been generally allowed. Those of the Amorites, on the other hand, are Sem, and the type repre- sented, with brown skin, dark eyes and hair, aqui- line features and beards, agrees (as is generally allowed) in indicating a Sem race. There are now some 60 of these Hittite names known, and they do not suggest any Aryan etymology. They are quite unlike those of the Aryan Medes (such as Baga-datta, etc) mentioned by the Assyrians, or those of the Vannic kings whose language (as shown by recently published bilinguals in Vannic and Assyrian) seems very clearly to have been TIranian—or similar to Pers and Sanskrit—but which only occurs in the later Assyr age. Comparisons with Armenian and Georgian (derived from the Phrygian and Scythian) also fail to show any similarity of vocabulary or of syntax, while on the other hand comparisons with the Akkadian, the Kassite and modern Turkish at once suggest a linguistic connection which fully agrees with what has been said above of the racial type. The common element Tarku, or Tarkhan, m Hittite names suggests the Mongol dargo and the Turkish tarkhan, meaning a “tribal chief.’ Sz again is an Akkadian word for a “ruler,” and nazi is an element in both Hittite and Kassite names. It has also been remarked that the vocabulary of the Hittite letters discovered by Chantre at Pterium recalls that of the letter writ- ten by Dusratta of Matiene to Amen- ophis III (Am Tab no. 27, Berlin), and that Dusratta adored the Hittite god Tessupas. A careful study of the language of this letter shows that, in syntax and vocabulary alike, it must be regarded as Mongolic and as a dialect of the Akkadian group. The cases of the noun, for instance, are the same as in Akkadian and in modern Turkish. No less than 50 words and terminations are common to the language of this letter and of those discovered by M. Chantre and attributed to the Hittites whose territory immediately adjoined that of Matiene. The majority of these words occur also in Akkadian. But in addition to these indications we have a letter in the Am Tab (Berlin no. 10) written by a Hittite prince, in his own tongue and 5. Hittite Names 6. Vocabu- lary of Pterium Epistles 7. Tellel- in the cuneiform script. It is from Amarna (and not to, as has been wrongly sup- Tablet posed by Knudtzon) a chief named _ -Yarhun-dara, and is addressed to Amenophis III, whose name stands first. In all the other letters the name of the sender always follows that of the recipient. The general meaning of this letter is clear from the known meanings of the “ideograms” used for many words; and it is also clear that the language is “agglutinative”’ like the Akkadian. The suffixed possessive pro- nouns follow the pl. termination of the noun as in Akkadian, and prepositions are not used as they are in Sem and Aryan speech; the precative form of the vb. has also been recognized to be the same as used in Akkadian. The pronouns mi, “my,” and iz, “thy,” are to be found in many living Mon- golic dialects (e.g. the Zyrianian me and te); in Akkadian also they occur as mi and zt. The letter 1401 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hittites opens with the usual salutation: “Letter to Ameno- phis III the great king, king of the land of Egypt [Mizzari-na], from Tarhun-dara [Tarhundara-dal, king of the land of Arzapi [or Arzaa], thus. To me is prosperity. To my ‘ nobles, my hosts, my ca- valry, to all that is mine in all my lands, may there be prosperity; [moreover?] may there Be prosperity: to thy house, thy wives, thy sons, thy nobles, thy hosts, thy cavalry, to all that is thine in thy lands may there be prosper- ity.” The letter continues to speak of a daughter of the Pharaoh, and of a sum of gold which is being sent in charge of an envoy named Irsappa. It con- cludes (as in many other instances) with a list of presets, these being sent y “the Hittite prince [Nu Hattu] from the land Igait’”? (perhaps the same as Ikata), and including, besides the gold, various robes, and ten chairs of ebony inlaid with ivory. As far as it can at present be understood, the language of this letter, which bears no indications of either Sem or Aryan speech, whether in vocabu- lary or in syntax, strongly favors the conclusion that the native Hittite language was a dialeet of that spoken by the Akkadians, the Kassites and the Min- yans of Matiene, in the same age. IV. Religion.—The Hittites like their neighbors adored many gods. Besides Set (or Sutekh), the “great ruler of heaven,” and Storm-God Tessupas. 1. Poly- Istar (Ashtoreth), we also find men- theism: tioned (in Hattusil’s treaty) gods and Names of goddesses of ‘“‘the hills and rivers of the Deities land of the Hatti,” ‘the great sea, the winds and the clouds.” Tessupas was known to the Babylonians as a name of Rimmon the god of thunder and rain. On a bilingual seal (in Hittite and cuneiform characters), now in the Ashmolean Museum, we find noticed the goddess Ishara, whose name, among the Kassites, was equivalent to Istar. The Hittite gods are repre- sented—like those of the Assyrians—standing erect on lions. One of them (at Samala in Syria) is lion-headed like Nergal. They also believed in demons, like the Akkadians and others. Their pantheon was thus also Mongolic, and the suggestion (by Dr. Winckler) that they adored Indian gods (Indra, Varuna), and the 2. Religious Pers Mithra, not only seems improb- Symbolism able, but is also hardly supported by the quotations from Sem texts on which this idea is based. The sphinx is found as a Hittite emblem at Eyuk, N. of Pterium, with the double-headed eagle which again, at Iasili-kaia, supports a pair of deities. It also occurs at Tel- loh as an Akkadian emblem, and was adopted by the Seljuk Turks about 1000 AD. At Eyuk we have a representation of a procession bringing goats and rams to an altar. At Imflatun-bunar the winged sun is an emblem as in Babylonia. At Mer’ash, in Syria, the mother goddess carries her child, while an eagle perches on a harp beside her. At Carchemish the naked Istar is represented with wings. The religious symbolism, like the names of deities, thus suggests a close connection with the em- blems and beliefs of the Kassites and Akkadians. V. Script.—In the 16th cent. BC, and down to the 18th cent., the Hittites used the cuneiform characters and the Bab language 1. Cunei- for correspondence abroad. On seals .form and and mace-heads they used their own Hiero- hieroglyphics, together with the cunei- glyphic form, These emblems, which occur on archaic monuments at Hamath, Carchemish and Aleppo in Syria, as well as very frequently in Cappadocia and Pontus, and less fre- quently as far W. as Ionia, and on the E. at Baby- lon, are now proved to be of Hittite origin, since the discovery of the seal of Arnuanta already noticed. The suggestion that they were Hittite was first made by the late Dr. W. Wright (British and Foreign Evangelical Review, 1874). About 100 such monu- ments are now known, including seals from Nineveh and Cappadocia, and Hittite gold ornaments in the Ashmolean Museum; and there can be little doubt that, in cases where the texts accompany figures of the gods, they are of a votive character. The script is quite distinctive, though many of the emblems are similar to those used by the 1 adians. There are some 170 signs 2. Descrip- in all, arranged one below another in tion of the lme—as among Akkadians. The Signs lines read alternately from right to left and from left to right, the profile em- blems always facing the beginning of each line. The interpretation of these texts is still a contro- versial question, but the most valuable suggestion toward their understanding is that made by the late Canon Isaac Taylor (see The Alphabet, 1883). A syllabary which was afterward used by the Inscription and Mutiiated Figure from Jerabis. Greeks in Cyprus, and which is found extensively spread in Asia Minor, Egypt, Pal, Crete, and even on later coins in Spain, was recognized by Dr. Taylor as being derived irom the Hittite signs. It Hivite Holiness THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1402 was deciphered by George Smith from a Cypriote- Phoenician bilingual, and appears to give the sounds applying to some 60 signs. These 3. Interpre- sounds are confirmed by the short bi- tation of linguals as yet known, and they appear Monuments in some cases at least to be very clearly : _ the monosyllabic words which apply in Akkadian to similar emblems. We have thus the bases of a comparative study, by aid of a known language and script—a method similar to that which enabled Sir H. Rawlinson to recover scientifically the lost cuneiform, or Champollion to decipher Egyp hieroglyphics. See also ARcHaE- oLocy oF Asta Minor; Recent EXxpiorarion. Litzprature.—The Egyp notices will be found in Brugsch’s A History of Egypt under the Pharaohs, 1879, and the Assyr in Schrader’s Cuneiform Inseriptions and the OT, ET, 1885. The discoveries of Chantre_ are published in his Mission en Cappadoce, 1898, and those of Dr. H. Winckler in the Mitteilungen der deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft, no. 35, December, 1907. The re- searches of Humann and Puchstein, Reisen in Klein- asien und Nordsyrien, 1890, are also valuable for this | question; as is also Dr. Robert Koldewey's discovery of a Hittite mouument at Babylon (Die hetiische Inschrift, 1900). The recent discovery of sculpture at a site N. of Samala by Professor Garstang is published in the Annals of Archaeology, I, no. 4, 1908, by the University of Liver- ool. These sculptures are supposed to date about 800 C, but no accompanying inscriptions have as yet been found. The views of the present writer are detailed in his Teil Amarna Tablets, 2d ed, 1894, andin The Hittites and Their Languages, 1898. Dr. Sayce has given an account of his researches in a small volume, The Hittites 1888, but many discoveries by Sir C. Wilson, Mr. D. G Hogarth, Sir W. Ramsay, and other explorers have since been published, and are scattered in various periodicals not easily accessible. The suggestions of Drs. Jensen, Hommel, and Peiser, in Germany, of comparison with Armenian, Georgian and Turkish, have not as yet pro- duced any agreement; nor have those of Dr. Sayce, who looks to Vannic or to Gr; and further light on Hittite decipberment is still awaited. See, further, Professor Garstang’s Land of the Hittites, 1910. C. R. Conpur HIVITE, hi’vit (10, hiwwt; Etatos, Heuatos): A son of Canaan (Gen 10 17), i.e. an inhabitant of the land of Canaan along with the Canaanite and other tribes (Ex 3 17, ; etc). In the list of Canaanite peoples given in Gen 16 19-21, the Hivites are omitted in the Heb text, though inserted in LXX and 8. Gesenius suggests that the name is descriptive, meaning “villagers.’’ The difficulty of explaining it is increased by the fact that it has been confused with ‘“Horite” in some passages of the Heb text. In Josh 9 7 the LXX reads “‘Horite’ as also does Cod. Ain Gen 34 2, and in Gen 36 2 a comparison with vs 24.25 shows that ‘“Horite’’ must be substi- tuted for ‘‘Hivite.’’ In Jgs 3 3 the Hittites are described as dwelling “in Mount Lebanon, from Mount Baal-hermon unto the entrance of Hamath,’’ andin accord- 1, Name 2, Geo- ance with this the Hivite is described graphical in Josh 11 3 as being “under Hermon Situation in the land of Mizpeh,” and in 2 8 24 7 they are mentioned immediately after “the stronghold of Tyre.’”’ Hence the LXX (Cod. A) reading must be right in Gen 34 2 and Josh 9 7, which makes the inhabitants of Shechem and Gibeon Horites instead of Hivites; indeed, in Gen 48 22 the people of Shechem are called Amorite, though this was a general name for the population of Canaan in the patriarchal period. No name resembling Hivite has yet been found in the Egyp or Bab inscriptions. A. H. Sayce HIZKI, hiz’ki Opt, hizki; LXX ’Atoxl, Azaki; AV Hezeki): A son of Elpaal, a descendant of Benjamin (1 Ch 8 17). HIZKIAH, hizki’a (A3PIM, hizkiyah; LXX ‘Etexta, Ezekia, “strength of Jeh’’): (1) A son of Neariah, a descendant of David (1 Ch 3 23, AV ‘“‘Hezekiah’’). (2) An ancestor of the prophet Zephaaiah (Zeph 11). In RV this word is here tr? ‘‘Hezekiah.” This name again appears in Neh 10 17 [Heb 18] in the form of “Hizkijah” in AV, but as “Hezekiah” in RV. See Hezexrau. HOAR, hor, HOARY, hor’i. See Cotor (8); Ha:r. ; HOAR-FROST, hér’frost, HOARY. See Frost. HOBAB, hi’bab (3M , habhabh, “beloved”; LXX *OB4B, Obdb): This name occurs only twice (Nu 10 29; Jgs 4.11). It is not certain whether it denotes the father-in-law or the brother-in-law of Moses. The direct statement of Nu 10 29 is that Hobab was “the son of Reuel” (AV ‘‘Raguel”). This is probably the correct view and finds support in Ex 18 27, which tells us that some time before the departure of the Israelites from Sinai, Jethro had departed and returned to his own land. The state- ment of Jgs 4 11 is ambiguous, and therefore does not help us out of the difficulty, but is rather itself to be interpreted in the light of the earlier statement in Nu 10 29. Mohammedan traditions favor the view that Hobab was only another name for Jethro. But this has little weight against the statements of Scripture. However, whether father-in-law or brother-in-law to Moses, the service he rendered to the leader of the hosts of Israel was most valuable and beautiful. Hobab was an experienced sheikh of the desert whose counsel and companionship Moses desired in the unfamiliar regions through which he was to journey. His knowledge of the wilderness and of its possible dangers would enable him to be to the Israelites “instead of eyes.”’ The facts recorded of this man are too meager to enable us to answer all the questions that arise con- cerning him, A difficulty that remains unsolved is the fact that in Jgs 1 16 and 4 11 he is described as a Kenite, while in Ex 3 1 and 18 1, the father-in- law of Moses is spoken of as “‘the priest of Midian.’’ ‘ Jesse L. Cotton HOBAH, hio’ba (1310, hobhah): A place ‘‘on the left hand,” i.e. to the N. of ‘“Damascus,” to which Abraham pursued the defeated army of Chedor- laomer (Gen 14 15). It is probably identical with the modern Hoba, about 60 miles N.W. of Damascus. HOBAIAH, hi-ba’ya (M730, hobhayah, “whom Jeh hides,” i.e. ‘‘protects’’): The head of a priestly family that returned from Babylon with Zerubbabel. Because they could not trace their genealogy, they were not permitted to serve in the priestly office (Neh 7 63 f). In the K’ré of this passage and in the | list of Ezr 2 61, this name appears in the form “Habaiah” (M3, hdbhayyah). “Obdia’’ is the form of the word in 1 Esd 5 38. HOCK ("Pp%, ‘akar, “to root out’’): To hamstring, i.e. to render useless by cutting the tendons of the hock (in AV and ERV “hough”). ‘In their self- will they hocked an ox” (Gen 49 6, AV “digged down a wall’), in their destructiveness maiming those which they could not carry off. See also Josh 11 6.9; 25 8 4. HOD, hod (351, hadh, “majesty,” “splendor”; LXX A, “05, Héd; B, ’N4, 04): One of the sons of Zophah, a descendant of Asher (1 Ch 7 37). HODAIAH, hi-da’ya. See Honavian, 1403 HODAVIAH, hod-a-vi'a (TITIAN, hodhawyah, or JVM, hadhawyaha; A, ‘O8ovla, Ha- douta): (1) One of the heads of the half-tribe of Manasseh on the E. of the Jordan (1 Ch 6 24). : (2) A Benjamite, the son of Hassenuah (1 Ch 9 (8) A Levite, who seems to have been the head of an important family in that tribe (Ezr 2 40). In Neh 7 48 the name is Hodevah (MTN, hédh- wah; Kers MYT, hodhyah). Cf Ear 8 9. (4) Ason of Elioenai, and a descendant of David (1 Ch 3 24; APT, hadhaywaha; Keren, hodhawyadhu, AV ‘‘Hodaiah’’). HODESG, ho’desh (7h, hadhesh, “new moon”): He of the wives of Shaharaim, a Benjamite (1 Ch HODEVAH, hé-de'va, ho’dé-va (ITN, hadh- wah, TITW, haodhtyah, “splendor of Jeh”’): A Levite and founder of a Levite family, seventy-four of whom returned from exile with Zerubbabel, 538 BC (Neh 7 43). ARVm gives as another reading “Hodeiah.”? In Ezr 2 40 he is called Hodaviah, of which Hodevah and Hodeiah are slight textual corruptions, and in Ezr 3 9 Judah, a name prac- tically synonymous. HODIAH, hé-di’a, HODIJAH, hé-di’ja (PTW, hodhiyah, “splendor of Jeh’’): (1) A brother-in-law of Naham (1 Ch 4 19), and possibly for that reason reckoned a member of the tribe of Judah. AV tr “‘his wife” is wrong. (2) One of the Levites who explained to the people the Law as read by Ezra (Neh 8 7) and led | their prayers (Neh 9 5). He is doubtless one of the two Levites of this name who sealed the cove- nant of Nehemiah (Neh 10 10.18). (3) One of the chiefs of the people who sealed the covenant of Nehemiah (Neh 10 18). J. Gray McA.usTEer HOGLAH, hog’la (1237), hoghlah, “partridge”): The third of five daughters of Zelophehad of the tribe of Manasseh (Nu 26 33). Z. leaving no male heir, it was made a statute that the inheritance in such eases should pass to the daughters, if such there were, as joint heirs, on condition, however, of marriage within the tribe (Nu 27 1-11; 36 1-12; Josh 17 3 f). HOHAM, hio’ham (O71, hdham, “whom Jeh impels[?]’ Ges.): An Amorite king of Hebron and one of the five kings of the Amorites who leagued for war on Gibeon because of its treaty of peace with Joshua. The five were defeated in the decisive battle of Beth-horon, shut up in the cave at Mak- kedah in which they had taken refuge, and after the battle were slain, hanged and cast into the cave (Josh 10 1-27). HOISE, hoiz: The older form of “hoist” (OH hoise), to raise, to lift, and is the tr of epaird, “to lift up’: “they ... . hoised up the mainsail to the wind” (Acts 27 40). RV “and hoisting up the foresail to the wind”; Wiclif has “‘lefte up,” Tindale “‘hoysed up.” HOLD, hold: In ARV frequently “stronghold” (Jes 9 49; 18224; 24 22; 286 17; 23 14; 1 Ch 11 16; 12 16). See Fortirication. In Rev 18 2 for AV “cage” (phulaké) RV substitutes, as in first clause, “hold,” and in m “prison.” HOLDING, hdl’ding: Occurs with various shades of meaning: (1) as the tr of tamakh, “to THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hivite Holiness acquire,’’ it has the sense of taking, obtaining (Isa 33 15, RV ‘that shaketh his hands from taking a bribe,’’ ERV, as AV, “holding’’); (2) of kal, “to hold,” “contain,” having the sense of containing or restraining (Jer 6 11, “I am weary with holding in’); (8) of kratéd, ‘to receive,” “observe,” “main- tain” (Mk 7 3, “holding the tradition of the elders’; 1 Tim 1 19, échd, “holding faith and a good conscience’; 3 9, “holding the mystery of the faith in a pure conscience’); (4) holding fast, cleav- ing to, krafed (Col 2 19, ‘not holding the head,” RV “holding fast’; cf Acts3 11; Rev 7 1, “holding the four winds of the earth, that no wind should blow’’); antéchomat, ‘to hold over against one’s self,” “to hold fast’ (Tit 1 9, RV “holding to the faithful word’’); (5) holding forth, epécho, “to hold upon, to hold out toward” (Phil 2 16, “holding forth the word of life,’ so RV); Lightfoot has “holding out” (as offering); others, however, render “holding fast,”’ persevering in the Christian faith and life—connecting with being ‘‘blameless and harmless’”’ in ver 15. WALKER HOLINESS, hi'li-nes (OTR, kadhosh, “holy,” WIP, kadhesh, “holiness”; dyros, hdgios, ‘“‘holy’’): I. In rep OT Muanino ofr THE TERM 1. The Holiness of God @ Absoluteness and Majesty 2) Ethical Holiness 2 oliness of Place, Time and Object 3. Holiness of Men 3 Ceremonial 2) Ethical and Spiritual Ii. In toe NT: Tae Curistian ConcEprion 1. Applied to God 2. To Christ 3. To Things 4. To Christians 1) As Separate from the World £3 As Bound to the Pursuit of an Ethical Ideal I. Inthe OT Meaning of the Term.—There has been much discussion as to the original meaning of the Sem root KDSH, by which the notion of holiness is expressed in the OT. Some would con- nect it with an Assyr word denoting purity, clear- ness; most modern scholars incline to the view that the primary idea is that of cutting off or separa- tion. Etymology gives no sure verdict on the point, but the idea of separation lends itself best to the various senses in which the word “‘holiness” is em- ployed. In primitive Sem usage “holiness” seems to have expressed nothing more than that ceremonial separation of an object from common use which the modern study of savage religions has rendered famil- iar under the name of taboo (W. R. Smith, Religion of the Semites, Lect iv). But within the Bib. sphere, with which alone we are immediately concerned, holiness attaches itself first of all, not to visible objects, but to the invisible Jeh, and to places, sea- sons, things and human beings only in so far as they are associated with Him. And while the idea of ceremonial holiness runs through the OT, the ethi- cal significance which Christianity attributes to the term is never wholly absent, and gradually rises in the course of the revelation into more emphatic prominence. ; : . As applied to God the notion of holiness is used in the OT in two distinct senses: (1) First in the more general sense of separation from 1. The all that is human and earthly, It thus Holiness denotes the absoluteness, majesty, and of God awfulness of the Creator in His dis- tinction from the creature. In this use of the word, “holiness” is little more than an equivalent general term for “Godhead,” and the adj. “holy” is almost synonymous with ‘‘Divine”’ (ef Dnl 4 8.9.18; 6 11). Jeh’s “holy arm’ (Isa 52 10; Ps 98 1) is His Divine arm, and His “holy name” (Lev 20 3, etc) is His Divine name. When Hannah sings “There is none holy as Jeh” (1 8 2 2), Holiness Holy Place THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1404 the rest of the verse suggests that she is referring, not to His ethical holiness, but simply to His supreme Divinity. _ (2) But, in the next place, holiness of character in the distinct ethical scnse is ascribed to God. The injunction, “Be ye holy; for I am holy’’ (Lev 11 44; 19 2), plainly implies an ethical concep- tion. Men cannot resemble God in His incom- municable attributes. They can reflect His like- ness only along the lines of those moral qualities of righteousness and love in which true holiness con- sists. In the Psalmists and Prophets the Divine holiness becomes, above all, an ethical reality con- victing men of sin (Isa 6 3.5) and demanding of those who would stand in His presence clean hands and a pure heart (Ps 24 3 f). From the holiness of God is derived that cere- monial holiness of things which is characteristic of the OT religion. Whatever is con~ 2, Holiness nected with the worship of the holy of Place, Jeh is itself holy. Nothing is holy in Time and itself, but anything becomes holy by Object its consecration to Him. A _ place where He manifests His presence is holy ground (Ex 3 5). The tabernacle or temple in which His glory is revealed is a holy building (Ex 28 29; 2 Ch 36 5); and all its sacrifices (Ex 29 33), ceremonial materials (30 25; Nu 6 17) and utensils (1 K 8 4) are also holy. The Sab- bath is holy because it is the Sabbath of the Lord (Ex 20 8-11). “Holiness, in short, expresses a relation, which consists negatively in separation from common use, and positively in dedication to the service of Jeh” (Skinner in HDB, II, 395). The holiness of men is of two kinds: (1) A cere- monia! holiness, corresponding to that of impersonal objects and depending upon their rela- 3. Holiness tion to the outward service of Jeh. of Men Priests and Levites are holy because they have been “hallowed” or “‘sancti- fied’? by acts of consecration (Ex 29 1; Lev 8 12. 30). The Nazirite is holy because he has separated himself unto the Lord (Nu 6 5). Above all, Israel, notwithstanding allits sins and shortcomings, is holy, as a nation separated from other nations for Divine purposes and uses (Ex 19 6, etc; ef Lev 20 24). (2) But out of this merely ceremonial holiness there emerges a higher holiness that is spirit- ual andethical. For unlike other creatures man wag made in the image of God and capable of reflecting the Divine likeness. And as God reveals Himself as ethically holy, He calls man to a holiness resem- bling His own (Lev 19 2). In theso-called “Law of Holiness’? (Lev 17-26), God’s demand for moral holiness is made clear; and yet the moral contents of the Law are still intermingled with ceremonial elements (17 10 ff; 19 19; 21 1 ff). In psalm and prophecy, bowever, a purely ethical conception comes into view—the conception of a human holi- ness which rests upon righteousness and truth (Ps 15 1f) and the possession of a contrite and humble spirit ({[sa 57 15). This corresponds to the knowledge of a God who, being Himself ethically holy, esteems justice, mercy and lowly piety more highly than sacrifice (Hos 6 6; Mic 6 6-8). il. In the NT: The Christian Conception.— The idea of holiness is expressed here chiefly by the word hagios and its derivatives, which corre- spond very closely to the words of the KDSH group in Heb, and are employed to render them in the LXX. The distinctive feature of the NT idea of holiness is that the external aspect of it has almost entirely disappeared, and the ethical meaning has become supreme. ‘The ceremonial idea, still exists in contemporary Judaism, and is typically repre- sented by the Pharisees (Mk 7 1-13; Lk 18 11 f). But Jesus proclaimed a new view of religion and morality according to which men are cleansed or defiled, not by anything outward, but by the thoughts of their hearts (Mt 15 17-20), and God is to be worshipped neither in Samaria nor Jerus, but wherever men seek Him in spirit and in truth (Jn 4, 21-24). i In the NT the term “holy” is seldom applied to God, and except in quotations from the OT (Lk 1 49; 1 Pet 1 15f), only in the 1. Applied Johannine writings (Jn 1711; Rev to God 48; 610). Butitis constantly used of the Spirit of God (Mt 1 18; Acts 12; Rom 5 5, etc), who now, in contrast with OT usage, becomes specifically the Holy Spirit or Holy Ghost. : In several passages the term is 2. Applied applied to Christ (Mk 1 24; Acts 8 to Christ 14; 4 30, etc), as being the very type of ethical perfection (cf He 7 26). In keeping with the fact that things are holy in a derivative sense through their relationship to God, the word is used of Jerus (Mt 4 5), 3. Applied the OT covenant (Lk 1 72), the to Things Scriptures (Rom 1 2), the Law (7 12), the Mount of Transfiguration (2 Pet 1 18), ete. But it is esp. in its application to Christians that the idea of holiness meets us in the NT in a sense that is characteristic and distinctive. 4. Applied to Christ’s people are regularly called Christians ‘‘saints’’ or holy persons, and holinessin the high ethical and spiritual meaning of the word is used to denote the appropriate quality of their life and conduct. (1) No doubt, as applied to believers, ‘‘saints’’ conveys in the first place the notion of a separation from the world and a con- secration to God. Just as Israel under the old covenant was a chosen race, so the Christian church in succeeding, to Israel’s privileges becomes a holy nation (1 Pet 2 9), and the Christian individual, as one of the elect people, becomes a holy man or woman (Col 3 12). In Paul’s usage all baptized persons are “saints,’’ however far they may still be from the saintly character (cf 1 Cor 1 2.14 with 6 1ff). (2) But though the use of the name does not imply high ethical character as a realized fact, it_always assumes it as an ideal and an obliga- tion. It is taken for granted that the Holy Spirit has taken up His abode in the heart of every regenerate person, and that a work of positive sanctification is going on there. The NT leaves no room for the thought of a holiness divorced from those moral qualities which the holy God demands of those whom He has called to be His people. See SANCTIFICATION. LitERatuRE.—Robertson Smith, Religion of the Sem- ites, Lects lii, iv; A. B. Davidson, Theology of the OT, 145 ff; Schultz, Theology of the OT, II, 167 ff; Orr, Sin as a Problem of To-day, ch iii; Sanday-Headlam, Romans, 12 ff; arts. ‘‘ Holiness’’ in HDB and ‘' Heiligkeit Gottes im AT” in RE. S i J.C. Lampert HOLLOW, hol’d (93, kaph, 323, nabhabh): “Hollow” is the tr of kaph, “hollow’’ (Gen 32 25.32, “the hollow of his thigh,” the hip-pan or socket, over the sciatic nerve); of ndbhabh, ‘‘to be hollow” (Ex 27 8; 38 7; Jer 62 21); of shd‘al, “hollow” (Isa 40 12, “Who hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand?” [in handfuls; ef 1 K 20 10; Ezk 13 19]); of makhtésh, “a mor- tar,” “socket of a tooth” (from its shape) (Jgs 15 19, “God clave an [RV “the’’] hollow place that is in Lehi’); of sh*ka‘drdrath, prob. from ké‘ar, “to sink” (Lev 14 37, “the walls of the house with hollow strakes,” so ERV, ARV “hollow streaks,” depressions); of kotlétés (Wisd 17 19, “the hollow mountains,” RV “hollows of the mountains’’); of koiloma (2 Mace 1 19, “hollow place of a pit,” RV 1405 “hollow of a well’); of antrédés (2 5, “a hollow cave,” RV ‘“‘a chamber in the rock,” m “Gr a caver- nous chamber’’). W. L. WaLKER HOLM-TREE, him’tré: (1) TIM, treah (Isa 44 14, AV “cypress’’): The name, from the root meaning (ef Arab. taraza) “to be hard,’’ implies some very hard wood. Vulg has tlex, which is Lat for holm oak, so named from its holly-like leaves (hollen in OF =“‘holly’’); this tr has now been adopted, but it is doubtful. (2) mptvos, prinos, Sus ver 58. This is the ilex or holm oak. There is a play on the words prinos and prisai (lit. “‘saw’’) in vs 58 and 59 (seeSusanna). The evergreen or holm oak is represented by two | species in Pal, Quercus tlex and Q. coccifera. The leaf of both species is somewhat like a small holly leaf, is glossy green and usually spiny. The Q. lex is insignificant, but Q. coccifera is a magnificent tree growing to a height of 40 ft. or more, and often found in Pal flourishing near sacred tombs, and itself not infrequently the object of superstitious venera- tion. E. W. G. MasterMan HOLOFERNES, hol-é-far’néz (‘Ododépvns, Olo- phérnés): According to the Book of Jth, chief cap- tain of Nebuchadnezzar, king of the Assyrians (Gth 2 4), who was commissioned to make war upon the West country and to receive from the inhabitants the usual tokens of complete sub- mission, earth and water. The object of the expedition of H., who thus became the typical persecutor of the Jews, was to compel men every- where to worship Nebuchadnezzar. He was slain by Judith, the heroine of the book of that name, during the siege of Bethulia. There is no notice of H. except in the Book of Jth. The termination of the word would seem to indicate a Pers origin for the name. The H. of Shakespeare and Rabelais is in no way connected with the deeds of the H. of the Apoc. J. Hourcuison HOLON, holon (72M or FSH, halan): (1) One of the towns in the hill country of Judah (Josh 15 51) assigned to the Levites (21 15). In 1 Ch 6 58 (Heb 48), it is HiLEN (which see). The site may be the important ruins of Beit ‘Alam (see PEF, III, 313, 321, Sh XX1). (2) Probably once an important town in the “plain,” i.e. plateau, of Moab (Jer 48 21); the site is unknown. HOLYDAY, ho’li-da: This word occurs twice in AV, viz. Ps 42 4, “a multitude that kept [RV “keeping’”’] holyday,’”’ and Col 2 16. In the latter case it ig a rendering of the Gr word ¢opr#, heorté, the ordinary term for a religious festival. RV trs “feast day.’ In the former instance “‘keeping holyday” renders 3219 , hghégh. The vb. means to “make a pilgrimage,” or “keep a religious festival.”’ Occasionally the idea of merrymaking prevails, as inl 8 30 16—“eating and drinking,’’ and enjoying themselves merrily. The Psalmist (who was per- haps an exiled priest) remembers with poignant regret how he used to lead religious processions on festival occasions. T. Lewis HOLY GHOST, h3’li gost. HOLY GHOST (SPIRIT), SIN AGAINST THE. See BLaspuHemy; Hoty Spirit, III, 1, (4). HOLY OF HOLIES, ho’liz (QWIPA wip, ko- dhesh ha-kédhashim, Ex 26 33, “2"t, d°*bhar, 1 K 6 16, etc; in the NT, d&yva dylwv, hdgia hagién, He 9 3): The name given to the innermost shrine, or adytum of the sanctuary of Jeh. See Hoty Sprnrit. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holiness Holy Place The most holy place of the tabernacle in the wilderness (Ex 26 31-33) was a small cube of 10 cubits (15 ft.) every way. It was 1. Inthe — divided from the holy place by a veil Tabernacle which was lifted when entrance was made (see VrIL). Ceiled by curtains which bore cherubic figures embroidered in blue and pune and scarlet (26 1), it contained no furniture ut the Ark of the Covenant, covered by a slab of gold called the Mrrcy-Snat (q.v.), and having within it only the two stone tables of the Law (see TABERNACLE; ARK OF CovENANT). Only the high priest, and he but once a year, on the great Day or ATONEMENT (q.V.), was permitted to enter within the veil, clothed in penitential garments, amid a cloud of incense, and with blood of sacrifice (Lev 16; cf He 9 7). The proportions of the most holy place in the first temple were the same as in the tabernacle, but the dimensions were doubled. 2. Inthe The sacred chamber was enlarged to 20 Temple of cubits (80 ft.) each way. We now Solomon meet with the word d*bhir, ‘oracle’ (1 K 6 16, ete), which with the exception of Ps 28 2, belonging perhaps to the same age, is met with in Scripture only in the period of Solomon’s reign. This sanctum, like its pred- ecessor, contained but one piece of furniture—the Ark of the Covenant. It had, however, one new conspicuous feature in the two large figures of cheru- bim of clive wood, covered with gold, with wings stretching from wall to wall, beneath which the ark was now placed (1 K 6 23-28; 2 Ch 3 10-13; see TEMPLE). In Ezekiel’s temple plans, which in many things may have been those of the temple of Zerubbabel, the prophet gives 20 cubits as the 3. In Later length and breadth of the most holy Times place, showing that these figures were regarded as too sacred to undergo change (Ezk 41 4). There was then no Ark of the Covenant, but Jewish tradition relates that the blood of the great Day of Atonement was sprinkled on an unhewn stone that stood in its place. In Herod’s temple, the dimensions of the two holy chambers remained the same—at least in length and breadth (see Tempity, Heron’s). The holiest place continued empty. In the spoils of the temple depicted on the Arch of Titus there is no representa- tion of the Ark of the Covenant; only of the furni- ture of the outer chamber or holy place. In the Ep. to the He we are taught that the true holy of holies is the heaven into which Jesus has now entered to appear in virtue of His own sacrifice in the presence of God for us (He 9 11 ff). Restriction is now removed, and the way into the holiest is made open for all His people (10 19.20). W. Suaw CaLnecotr HOLY ONE. See Gop, Namzs oF. HOLY PLACE (WPT, ha-kédhesh, Ex 26 33, Sar, ha-hékhal, 1 K 6 17, ete; | wpdry oxnva, hé prété skené, He 9 6f): The taber- nacle consisted of two divisions to which a graduated scale of holiness ig attached: ‘The veilshall separate unto you between the holy place and the most holy” (Ex 26 33). This distinction was never abrogated. In the Ep. to the He these divisions are called the “first?? and “‘second’”’ tabernacles (He 9 6f). The term “holy place’’ is not indeed confined to the outer chamber of the sanctuary; in Lev 6 16, it is applied to “the court of the tent of meeting.’’ But the other is its technical use. In Solomon’s temple we have a different usage. The word hékhal, 4, Figura- tive 1. The Terms Holy Spirit THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1406 “temple,” is not at first applied, as after, to the whole building, but is the designation specifically of the holy place, in distinction from the d¢bhir, or “oracle” (cf 1 K 6 3.5.16.17.33, etc; so in Ezk 41 1.2.4, etc). The wider usage is later (cf 2 K 11 1011.18, ete). The size of the holy place differed at different times. The holy place of the tabernacle was 20 cubits long by 10 broad and 10 high 2. Size of (30X15X15 ft.); that of Solomon’s the Holy temple was twice this in length and Place breadth—40 by 20 cubits; but it is ; : contended by many (Bahr, etc) that in ‘height it was the full internal height of the building—30 cubits; the Herodian temple has the same dimensions of length and breadth, but Jos and Middoth give largely increased, though differing, numbers for the height (see Tempra, Herop’s). The contents of the holy place were from the beginning ordered to be these (Ex 25 23 ff; 30 1-10): the altar of incense, a golden 3. Contents candlestick (i Solomon’s temple in- of Holy creased to ten, 1 K 7 49), and a table Place of showbread (likewise increased to ; ten,2 Ch 4 8). For the construction, position, history and uses of these objects, see TABERNACLE; ‘TEMPLE, and arts. under the several headings. This, as shown by Jos and by the sculp- tures on the Arch of Titus, continued to be the furniture of the holy place till the end. As the outer division of the sanctuary, into which, as yet, not the people, but only their representa- tives in the priesthood, were admitted 4. Symbol- while yet the symbols of the people’s ism consecrated life (prayer, light, thanks- giving) were found in it, the holy place may be said to represent the people’s relation to God in the earthly life, as the holy of holies repre- sented God’s relation to the people in a perfected communion. In the Ep. to the He, the holy place is not largely dwelt on as compared with the court in which the perfect sacrifice was offered, and the holiest of all into which Christ has now entered (Christ passes “through” the tabernacle into the holiest, 9 11). It pertains, however, evidently to the earthly sphere of Christ’s manifestation, even as carth is the present scene of the church’s fellow- ship. Through earth, by the way which Christ has opened up, the believer, already in spirit, finally in fact, passes with Him into the holiest (He 10 19; cf 9 8; see Westcott, Hebrews, 233 ff). _ W. Saw CaLnEcotr HOLY SPIRIT, ho’li spir’it: I. OT TeacuHinos ss To THE Spirit . Meaning of the Word . The Spirit in Relation to the Godhead . In External Nature In Man Imparting Powers for Service 1) Judges and Warriors 2) Wisdom for Various Purposes 3) In Prophecy Imparting Moral Character In the Messiah Predictions of Future Outpouring of the Spirit HE Non-CanonicaL LITERATURE . The Spirit in Josephus . In the Pseudepigrapha . In the Wisdom of Solomon . In_Philo He Hoty Spiniv in THE NT . In Relation to the Person and Work of Christ o) Birth of Jesus 2) Baptism 3) Temptation a Public Ministry : 5) Death and Resurrection and Pentecostal Cob whe IT. Legler ara ey POD III. ale Gift 2. The Holy Spirit in the Kingdom of God (1) Synoptic Teachings (2) In the Writings of John oy In Acts aa 4) In Paul's Writings (a) The Spirit and Jesus 2 a (o) In Bestowing Charismatic Gifts fe c) In the Beginnings of the Christian Life 3 In the Religious and Moral Life (e) In the Church 1 (f) In the Resurrection of Believers (5) The Holy Spirit in Other NT Writings LITERATURE The expression Spirit, or Spirit of God, or Holy Spirit, is found in the great majority of the books of the Bible. In the OT the Heb word uniformly employed for the Spirit as referring to God’s Spirit is 117, ré%h, meaning “breath,” “wind” or ‘‘breeze. The vb. form of the word is 14, rah, or 17, ri*h, used only in the Hiphil and meaning ‘‘to breathe,” “to blow.’ A kindred vb. is M7], r@wah, meaning “to breathe,” “having breathing room,” “to be spacious,” etc. The word always used in the NT for the Spirit is the Gr neuter noun rvedxa, pnetima, with or without the article, and for Holy Spirit, rvebua dywv, pneima hdgion, or 7d wveiua 7d ayo, 16 pnetima t6 hdgion. In the NT we find also the expressions, “the Spirit of God,” “the Spirit of the Lord,” “the Spirit of the Father,” “the Spirit of Jesus,” “of Christ.” The word for Spirit in the Gr is from the vb. rvéw, pnéd, “to breathe,’”’ “to blow.” The corresponding word in the Lat is spiritus, meaning “spirit.” I. The Teachings as to the Spirit in the OT.— At the outset we note the significance of the term itself. From the primary meaning 1. Meaning of the word which is “wind,” as refer- of the ring to Nature, arises the idea of breath Word in man and thence the breath, wind or Spirit of God. We have no way of tracing exactly how the minds of the Bib. writers connected the earlier literal meaning of the word with the Divine Spirit. Nearly all shades of meaning from the lowest to the highest appear in the OT, and itis not difficult to conceive how the original narrower meaning was gradually expanded into the larger and wider. The following are some of the shades of OT usage. From the notion of wind or breath, ruth came to signify: (1) the principle of life itself; spirit in this sense indicated the degree of vitality: ‘My spirit is consumed, my days are extinct’? (Job 17 1; also Jgs 16 19; 1 S 30 12); (2) human feelings of various kinds, as anger (Jgs 8 3; Prov 29 11), desire (Isa 26 9), courage (Josh 211); (8) intelligence (Ex 28 3; Isa 29 24); (4) general disposition (Ps 34 18; 5117; Prov 14 29; 16 18; 29 23). No doubt the Bib. writers thought of man as made in the image of God (Gen 1 27 f), and it was easy for them to think of God as being likeman. It is remarkable that their anthropomorphism did not go farther. They preserve, however, a highly spiritual conception of God as compared with that of surrounding nations. But as the human breath was an invisible part of man, and as it represented his vitality, his life and energy, it was easy to trans- fer the conception to God in the effort to represent His energetic and transitive action upon man and Nature. The Spirit of God, therefore, as based upon the idea of the ruéh or breath of man, originally stood for the energy or power of God (Isa 31 3; cf A. B. Davidson, Theology of the OT, 117-18), as contrasted with the weakness of the flesh. We consider next the Spirit of God in relation to God Himself in the OT. Here there are several points to be noted. The first is that 2. The there is no indication of a belief that Spirit in the Spirit of God was a material par- Relation to ticle or emanation from God. The the God- _ point of view of Bib. writers is nearly head always practical rather than specula- tive. They did not philosophize about the Divine nature. is 3 Nevertheless, they retained a 1407 very clear distinction between spirit and flesh or other material forms. Again we observe in the OT both an identification of God and the Spirit of God, and also a clear distinction between them. The identification is seen in Ps 139 7 where the omni- presence of the Spirit is declared, and in Isa 63 10; Jer 31 38; Ezk 36 27. In a great number of passages, however, God and the Spirit of God are not thought of as identical, as in Gen 1 2; 6 3; Neh 9 20; Ps 5111; 104 29f. Of course this does not mean that God and the Spirit of God were two distinct beings in the thought of OT writers, but only that the Spirit had functions of His own in distinction from God. The Spirit was God in action, particularly when the action was specific, with a view to accomplishing some particular end or purpose of God. The Spirit came upon indi- viduals for special purposes. The Spirit was thus God immanent in man and in the world. As the angel of the Lord, or angel of the Covenant in certain passages, represents both Jeh Himself and one sent by Jeh, so in like manner the Spirit of Jeh was both Jeh within or upon man, and at the same time one sent by Jeh to man. Do the OT teachings indicate that in the view of the writers the Spirit of Jeh was a distinct person in the Divine nature? The passage in Gen 1 26 is scarcely conclusive. The idea and importance of personality were but slowly developed in Israelit- ish thought. Not until some of the later prophets did it receive great emphasis, and even then scarcely in the fully developed form. The statement in Gen 1 26 may be taken as the pl. of majesty or as referring to the Divine council, and on this account is not conclusive for the Trinitarian view. Indeed, there are no OT passages which compel us to under- stand the complete NT doctrine of the Trinity and the distinct personality of the Spirit in the NT sense. There are, however, numerous OT passages which are in harmony with the Trinitarian con- ception and prepare the way for it, such as Ps 139 7; Isa 638 10; 4816; Hag 2 5; Zec 46. The Spirit is grieved, vexed, etc, and in other ways is conceived of personally, but as He is God in action, God exerting power, this was the natural way for the OT writers to think of the Spirit. : The question has been raised as to how the Bib. writers were able to hold the conception of the Spirit of God without violence to their monotheism. A suggested reply is that the idea of the Spirit came gradually and indirectly from the conception of subordinate gods which prevailed among some of the surrounding nations (I. F. Wood, The Spirit of God in Bub. Literature, 30). But the best Israelitish thought developed in opposition to, rather than in analogy with, polytheism. A more natural explanation seems to be that their simple anthropomorphism led them to conceive the Spirit of God as the breath of God parallel with the con- ception of man’s breath as being part of man and yet going forth from him. We consider next the Spirit of God in external Nature. “And the Spirit of God moved [was brooding or hovering] upon the face 3. The of the waters” (Gen 1 2). The figure Spirit in is that of a brooding or hovering bird External (cf Dt 32 11). Here the Spirit brings Nature order and beauty out of the primeval chaos and conducts the cosmic forces toward the goal of an ordered universe. Again in Ps 104 28-30, God sends forth His Spirit, and visible things are called into being: ‘Thou sendest forth thy Spirit, they are created; and thou renewest the face of the ground.” In Job 26 13 the beauty of the heavens is ascribed to the Spirit: “By his Spirit the heavens are garnished.” In Isa 32 15 the wilderness becomes a fruitful field as the result THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holy Spirit of the outpouring of the Spirit. The Bib. writers scarcely took into their thinking the idea of second causes, certainly not in the modern scientific sense. They regarded the phenomena of Nature as the result of God’s direct action through His Spirit. At every point their conception of the Spirit saved them from pantheism on the one hand and poly- theism on the other. The Spirit may next be considered in imparting natural powers both physical and intellectual. In Gen 2 7 God originates man’s person- 4. The al and intellectual life by breathing Spirit of into his nostrils “the breath of life.” God in ManIn Nu 16 22 God is “the God of the spirits of all flesh.” In Ex 28 3; 31 3; 36 31, wisdom for all kinds of workmanship is declared to be the gift of God. So also physical life is due to the presence of the Spirit of God (Job 27 3); and Elihu declares (Job 33 4) that the Spirit of God made him. See also Ezk 37 14 and 39 29. Thus man is regarded by the OT writers, in all the parts of his being, body, mind and spirit, as the direct result of the action of the Spirit of God. In Gen 6 3 the Spirit of God “strives” with or “rules’’ in or is “humbled” in man in the antedilu- vian world. Here reference is not made to the Spirit’s activity over and above, but within the moral nature of man. The greater part of the OT passages which refer to the Spirit of God deal with the subject from the oint of view of the covenant relations 5. In Im- etween Jeh and Israel. And the parting greater portion of these, in turn, have Powers for to do with gifts and powers conferred Service by the Spirit for service in the ongoing of the kingdom of God. We fail to grasp the full meaning of very many statements of the OT unless we keep constantly in mind the fundamental assumption of all the OT, viz. the covenant relations between God and Israel. Extra- ordinary powers exhibited by Israelites of what- ever kind were usually attributed to the Spirit. These are so numerous that our limits of space forbid an exhaustive presentation. The chief points we may notice. (1) Powers conferred upon judges and warriors.— The children of Israel cried unto Jeh and He raised up a savior for them, Othniel, the son of Kenaz: “And the Spirit of Jeh came upon him, and he judged Israel” (Jgs 3 10). So also Gideon (Jgs 6 34): “The Spirit of Jeh came upon [lit. clothed itself with] Gideon.”’ In Jgs 11 29 “the spirit of Jeh came upon Jephthah”’; and in 13 25 ‘“‘the Spirit of Jeh began to move” Samson. In 14 6 “the Spirit of Jeh came mightily upon him.” In 18 16 14 we read “the Spirit of Jeh departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from Jeh troubled him.” In all this class of passages, the Spirit imparts special endowments of power without necessary reference to the moral character of the recipient. The end in view is not personal, merely to the agent, but concerns the theocratic kingdom and implies the covenant between God and Israel. In some cases the Spirit exerts physical energy in a more direct way (2 K 2 16; Ezk 2 1f; 3 12). (2) Wisdom and skill bestowed for various purposes. —Bezalel is filled with the Spirit of God in wisdom and in understanding to work in gold, and silver and brass, etc, in the building of the tabernacle (Ex 31 2-4; 35 31); and the Spirit of wisdom is given to others in making Aaron’s garments (Ex 28 3). So also of one of the builders of Solomon’s temple (1 K 7 14; 2 Ch 2 14). In these cases there seems to be a combination of the thought of natural talents and skill to which is superadded a special endowment of theSpirit. Pharach refers to Joseph as one in whom the Spirit of God is, as fitting Holy Spirit THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1408 him for administration and government (Gen 41 88). Joshua is qualified for leadership hy the Spirit (Nu 27 18). In this and in Dt 34 9, Joshua is represented as possessing the Spirit through the laying on of the hands of Moses. This is an inter- esting OT parallel to the hestowment of the Spirit by laying on of hands in the NT (Acts 8 17; 19 6). Daniel is represented as having wisdom to interpret dreams through the Spirit, and afterward because of the Spirit he is exalted to a position of authority and power (Dnl 4 8; 5 11-14; 6 3). The Spirit qualifies Zerubbahel to rebuild the temple (Zec 4 6). The Spirit was given to the people for instruc- tion and strengthening during the wilderness wanderings (Neh 9 20), and to the elders along with Moses (Nu 11 17.25). It thus appears how very widespread were the activities of the redemp- tive Spirit, or the Spirit in the covenant. All these forms of the Spirit’s action bore in some way upon the national life of the people, and were eet in one way or another toward theocratic ends. (3) The Spirit in OT rophecy.—The most distinctive and important manifestation of the Spirit’s activity in the OT was in the sphere of prophecy. In the earlier period the prophet was called seer (TN, ré’eh), and later he was called prophet (N°22, na@bhi’). The word “prophet” (rpodyrns, prophétés) means one who speaks for God. The prophets were very early differentiated from the masses of the people into a prophetic class or order, although Ahraham himself was called a prophet, as were Moses and other leaders (Gen 20 7; Dt 18 15). The prophet was esp. distinguished from others as the man who possessed the Spirit of God (Hos 9 7). The prophets ordinarily began their messages with the phrase, “thus saith Jeh,” or its equivalent. But they ascribed their mes- sages directly also to the Spirit of God (Eizk 2 2; 8 3; 11 1.24; 18 3). The case of Balaam pre- sents some difficulties (Nu 24 2). He does not seem to have been a genuine prophet, but rather a diviner, although it is declared that the Spirit of God came upon him. Balaam serves, however, to illustrate the OT peint of view. The chief in- terest was the national or theocratic or covenant ideal, not that of the individual. The Spirit was hestowed at times upon unworthy men for the achievement of these ends. Saul presents a similar example. The prophet was God’s messenger speak- ing God’s message by the Spirit. His message was not his own. It came directly from God, and at times overpowered the prophet with its urgency, as in the case of Jeremiah (1 4 ff). There arc quite perceptible stages in the develop- ment of the OT prophecy. In the earlier period the prophet was sometimes moved, not so much to intelligible speech, as hy a sort of enthusiasm or prophetic ecstasy. In 1 § 10 we have an example of this earlier form of prophecy, where a company with musical instruments prophesied together. To what extent this form of prophetic enthusiasm was attended by warnings and exhortations, if so attended at all, we do not know. There was more in it than in the excitement of the diviners and devotees of the surrounding nations. For the Spirit of Jeh was its source. In the later period we have prophecy in its highest forms in the OT. The differences hctween earlier and later prophecy are probably due in part to the conditions. The early period required action, the later required teaching. The judges on whom the Spirit came were deliverers in a turbulent age. There was not need for, nor could the people have borne, the higher ethical and spiritual truths which came in later revelations through the prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah and others. See 2 8 93 2; Ezk 22: 83: 11 24; 13 3; Mic 3 8; Hos 9 7. A difficulty arises from statements such as the following: A lying spirit was sometimes present in the prophet (1 K 22 21f); Jeh puts a spirit in the king of Assyria and turns him back to his destruc- tion (Isa 87 7); because of sin, a lying prophet should serve the people (Mic 2 11); in Micaiah’s vision Jeh sends a Pana Ae? one seer lyi rophets (1 ; an evil spirit from deneaiees ca Saul (1 S$ 16 14; 18 10; 19 9). The following considerations may be of value in explaining these passages. Jeh was the source of things generally in OT thought. Its pronounced monotheism appears in this as in so many other ways. Besides this, OT writers usually spoke phenomenally. Prophecy was a particular form of manifestation with certain outward marks and signs. Whatever presented these outward marks was called prophecy, whether the message conveyed was true or false. The standard of discrimination here was not the outward signs of the prophet, but the truth or right of the message as shown by the event. As to the evil spirit from Jeh, it may he explained in either of two ways. First, it may have referred +o the evil disposition of the man upon whom God’s Spirit was acting, in which case he would resist the Spirit and his own spirit would be the evil spirit. Or the “evil spirit from Jeh” may have referred, in the prophet’s mind, to an actual spirit of evil which Jeh sent or permitted to enter the man. The latter is the more probable explana- tion, in accordance with which the prophet would conceive that Jeh’s higher will was accomplished, even through the action of the evil spirit upon man’s spirit. Jeh’s judicial anger against transgression would, to the prophet’s mind, justify the sending of an evil spirit by Jeh. The activity of the Spirit in the OT is not limited to gifts for service. Moral and spiritual character is traced to the Spirit’s operations as 6. The well. “Thy holy Spirit’? (Ps 61 11); SpiritIm- “his holy Spirit’? Usa 63 10); “thy parting good Spirit’’ (Neh 9 20); “Thy Spirit Moral and is good” (Ps 143 10) are expressions Spiritual pointing to the ethical quality of the Character Spirit’s action. ‘“Holy’’ is from the vb. form (WIP, kadhash), whose root meaning is doubtful, but which probably meant “to be separated,’’ from which it comes to mean to be exalted, and this led to the conception to be Divine. And as Jeh is morally good, the concep- tion of “the holy [= Divine] one’’ came to signify the holy one in the moral sense. Thence the word was applied to the Spirit of Jeh. Jeh gives His good Spirit for instruction (Neh 9 20); the Spirit is called good because it teaches to do God’s will (Ps 148 10); the Spirit gives the fear of the Lord (isa 11 2-5); Judgment and righteousness (Isa 32 15 ff); devotion to the Lord (Isa 44 3-5); hearty obedience and a new heart (Ezk 36 26 f); penitence and prayer (Zcc 12 10). In Ps 51 11 thereis an in- tense sense of guilt and sin coupled with the prayer, “Take not thy holy Spirit from me.” us we see that the OT in numerous ways recognizes the Holy Spirit as the source of inward moral purity, although the thought is not so developed asin the NT. In hoth the first and the second sections of Isa, there are distinct references to the Spirit in con- nection with the Messiah, although 7. The the Messiah is conceived as the ideal Spirit in the King who springs from the root of Messiah David in some instances, and in others : as the Suffering Servant of Jeh. This is not the place to discuss the Messianic import of the latter group of passages which has given rise to 1409 Holy Spirit THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA much difference of opinion. As in the case of the ideal Davidic King which, in the prophet’s mind, passes from the lower to the higher and Messianic conception, so, under the form of the Suffering Ser- vant, the “remnant” of Israel becomes the basis for an ideal which transcends in the Messianic sense the original nucleus of the conception derived from the historic events in the history of Israel. The prophet rises in the employment of both conceptions to the thought of the Messiah who is the “anointed” of Jeh as endued esp. with the power and wisdom of the Spirit. In Isa 11 1-5 a glowing picture is given of the “shoot out of the stock of Jesse.” The Spirit imparts “wisdom and understanding” and endows him with manifold gifts through the exercise of which he shall bring in the kingdom of righteousness and peace. In Isa 42 1ff, the “servant” is in like manner endowed most richly with the gifts of the Spirit by virtue of which he shall bring forth “justice to the Gentiles.’ InIsa 61 1 ff occur the notable words cited by Jesus in Lk 4 18f, beginning, ‘The Spirit of the Lord is upon me,” etc. In these passages the prophet describes elab- orately and minutely the Messiah’s endowment with a wide range of powers, all of which are traced to the action of God’s Spirit. In the later history of Israel, when the sufferings of the exile pressed heavily, there arose a tendency : to idcalize a past age as the era of the 8. Predic- special blessing of the Spirit, coupled tions of Fu- with a very marked optimism as to a | ture Out- future outpouring of the Spirit. In pouring of Hag 2 5 reference is made to the Mo- the Spirit saic period as the age of the Spirit, “when ye came out of Egypt, and my Spirit abode among you.” In Isa 44 3 the Spirit is to be poured out on Jacob and his seed; and in Isa 59 20 a Redeemer is to come to Zion under the cove- nant of Jeh, and the Spirit is to abide upon the people. The passage, however, which esp. indicates the transition from OT to NT times is that in Joel 2 28.32 which is cited by Peter in Acts 2 17-21. In this prophecy the bestowal of the Spirit is extended to all classes, is attended by marvelous signs and is accompanied by the gift of salvation. Looking back from the later to the earlier period of OT history, we observe a twofold tendency of teach- ing in relation to the Spirit. The first is from the outward gift of the Spirit for various uses toward a deepening sense of inner need of the Spirit for moral purity, and consequent emphasis upon the ethical energy of the Spirit. The second tendency is toward a sense of the futility of the merely human or theocratic national organization in and of itself to achieve the ends of Jeh, along with a sense of the need for the Spirit of God upon the people generally, and a prediction of the universal diffusion of the Spirit. Hl, The Spirit in Nan-Canonical Jewish Litera- ture.—In the Palestinian and Alexandrian literature of the Jews there are comparatively few references to the Spirit of God. The two books in which the teachings as to the Spirit are most explicit and most fully developed are of Alexandrian origin, viz. The Wisdom of Solomon and the writings of Philo. In the OT Apocrypha and in Jos the references to the Spirit are nearly always merely echoes of a_long-past age when the Spirit was active among men. In no par- ticular is the contrast between the canonical and non- canonical literature more striking than in the teaching as to the Spirit of God. Jos has a number of references to the Holy Spirit, but nearly always they have to do with the long-past history of Israel. He refers to 22 books of the OT 1. The which are of the utmost reliahility. There Spirit i are other books, but none ‘of like author- pirit in ity,” because there has ‘‘not heen an Josephus — exact_ succession of prophets” (CA , 1, .. Samuel is described as having a faree place in the affairs of the kingdom because he is a prophet (Ant, VI, v, 6). God appears to Solomon in sleep and teaches hlm wisdom (ib, VITI, li); Balaam propnesios through the Spirit’s power (1b, IV, v, 6); and Moses was such a prophet that his words were God’s words (lh, IV, vili, 49). In Jos we have then simply a testimony to the inspiration and power of the prophets and the books written by them, in so far as we have in him teach- ings regarding the Spirit of God. Even here the action of the Spirit is usually implied rather than expressed. In the pseudeplgraphic writings the Spirit of God ls usually referred to as acting in the long-past history of Israel or In the future Messianic age. In 2. The the apocalyptic books, the past age of ae eraT powers when the Spirit wrought mightlly, Spirit in ecomes the ground of the hopes of the the Pseude- future. The past is glorified, and out of It iorapha arises the hope of a future kingdom of pigrap and power. Enoch says to Methuse- lory ati: “The word calls me and the Spirit 4s poured ont upon me’’ (En 91 1). In 49 1-4 the Messiah has the Spirit of wisdom, understanding and might. Enoch is represented as describing his own translation. ‘'He was carried aloft in the chariots of the Spirlt’’ (En 70 2). In Jub 81 16 Isaac Is represented as prophesying, and in 25 13 it is said of Rehekah that the “ Holy Spirit descended into her mouth.’”’ Sometimes the actlon of the Spirit Is closely connected with the moral life, although this is rare. ‘The pul of God rests’’ on the man of pure and loving heart (XII P, Benj. . In Simeon 4 it is declared that Joseph was a good man and that the Spirit of God rested on him. There appears at times a lament for the departed age of proph- ecy (1 Macc 9 27; 14 41). The future is depicted in glowing colors: The Spirit is to come in a future judg- ment (XII P, Levi 18); and the spirit of holiness shall rest upon the redeemed in Paradise (Levi 18); and in Levi 2 the spirit of insight is given, and the vision of the sinful world and its salvation follows. Generally speak- ing, this literature is far below that of the OT, both in moral tone and religious insight. Much of it seems childish, although at times we encounter noble passages. There is lacking in it the prevailing OT mood which is hest described as prophetic, in which the writer feels constrained by the power of God’s Spirit to speak or write. The OT literature thus possesses a vitality and power which accounts for the strength of its appeal to our religious consciousness. We note in the next place a few teachings as to the Spirit of God in Wied. Here the ethical ele- ment in character is a condition of the 3. The Spirit’s indwelling. ‘Into a malicious Spirit in the soul wisdom shall not enter: nor dwell Wisdom of in the body that is subject unto sin. Solomon For the holy spirit of discipline will flee deceit, and will not abide when unrighteousness cometh in” (Wisd 1 4f). This “holy spirit of discipline’ is evidently God’s Holy Spirit, for in ver 7 the writer proceeds to assert, “For the Spirit of the Lord filleth the world,” and in vs 8.9 there is a return to the conception of un- righteousness as a hindrance to right speaking. In Wisd 7 7 the Spirit of Wisdom comes in response to prayer. In 7 22-30 is an elaborate and very beautiful description of wisdom: ‘In her is an under- standing spirit, holy, one only, manifold, subtil, lively, clear, undefiled, plain, not subject to hurt, loving the thing that 13 good, quick, which cannot be letted, ready to do good, kind to man, stedfast, sure,’ etc. ‘She is the brightness of the ever- lasting light, the unspotted mirror of the power of God, and the image of his goodness,”’ etc. No one can know God’s counsel except by the Holy Spirit (9 17). The writer of Wisd was deeply possessed of the sense of the omnipresence of the Spirit of God, asseeninl 7andin12 1. Inthe latter passage we read: ‘For thine incorruptible spirit is in all things.” In Philo we have what is almost wholly wanting in other Jewish literature, viz. analytic and reflective thought upon the work of the Spirit of 4, The God. The interest in Philo is primari- Spirit in ly philosophic, and his teachings on Philo the Spirit possess special interest on this account in contrast with Bib. and other extra-Bib. literature. In his Questions and Solutions, 27, 28, he explains the expression in Gen 8 1: “Te brought a breath over the earth and the wind ceased.” He argues that water is not diminished by wind, but only agitated and dis- Holy Spirit THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1410 turbed. Hence there must be a reference to God’s Spirit or breath by which the whole universe obtains security. He has a similar discussion of the point why the word “Spirit” is not. used instead of ‘‘breath”’ in Gen in the account of man’s creation, and concludes that ‘to breathe into” here means to ‘Gnspire,” and that God by His Spirit imparted to man mental and moral life and capacity for Divine things (Allegories, xiii). In several passages Philo discusses prophecy and the prophetic office. One of the most interesting relates to the prophetic office of Moses (Life of Moses, xxiiiff), He also describes a false prophet who claims to be ‘inspired and possessed by the Holy Spirit’? (On Those Who Offer Sacrifice, xi). In a very notable passage, Philo describes in detail his own subjective experi- ences under the influence of the Holy Spirit, and his language is that of the intellectual mystic. He says that at times he found himself devoid of impulse or capacity for mental activity, when suddenly by the coming of the Spirit of God, his intellect was rendered very fruitful: ‘and sometimes when J have come to my work empty I have suddenly become full, ideas being, in an invisible manner, showered upon me and implanted in me from on high; so that through the influence of Divine inspiration I have become greatly excited and have known neither the place in which I was, nor those who were present, nor myself, nor what I was saying, nor what I was writing,” etc (Migrations of Abraham, vii). In Philo, as in the non-canonical literature gener- ally, we find little metaphysical teaching as to the Spirit and His relations to the Godhead. On this point there is no material advance over the OT teaching. The agency of the Holy Spirit in shaping and maintaining the physical universe and as the source of man’s capacities and powers is clearly recognized in Philo. In Philo, as in Jos, the con- ception of inspiration as the complete occupation and domination of the prophet’s mind by the Spirit of God, even to the extent of suspending the operation of the natural powers, comes clearly into view. This is rather in contrast with, than in conformity to, the OT and NT conception of inspiration, in which the personality of the prophet remains intensely active while under the influence of the Spirit, except possibly in cases of vision and trance. Ill. The Holy Spirit in the NT.—In the NT there js unusual symmetry and completeness of teaching as to the work of the Spirit of God in relation to the Messiah Himself, and to the founding of the Mes- sianic kingdom. The simplest mode of presenta- tion will be to trace the course of the progressive activities of the Spirit, or teachings regarding these activities, as these are presented to us in the NT literature as we now have it, so far as the nature of the subject will permit. This will, of course, dis- turb to some extent the chronological order in which the NT books were written, since in some cases, as jn John’s Gospel, a very late book contains early teachings as to the Spirit. (1) The birth of Jesus—In Mt 118 Mary is found with child “of the Holy Spirit” (é« rvedparos aylov, ek pneimatos hagiou); an angel 1. The tells Joseph that that “which is con- Spirit in ceived in her is of the Holy Spirit’ Relation to (1 20), all of which is declared to be in the Person fulfilment of the prophecy that a virgin and Work _ shall bring forth a son whose name of Christ shall be called Immanuel (Isa 7 14). In Lk 1 35 the angel says to Mary that the Holy Spirit (pneuma hagion) shall come upon her, and the power of the Most High (dvvayus ‘Yyicrov, diunamis Hupsisiou) shall overshadow her. Here “Holy Spirit’’ and “power of the Most High” are || expressions meaning the same thing; in the one case emphasizing the Divine source and in the other the holiness of “the holy thing which is begotten” (1 35). In connection with the pres- entation of the babe in the temple, Simeon is described as one upon whom the Holy Spirit rested, to whom revelation was made through the Spirit and who came into the temple in the Spirit (Lk 2 25-28). So also Anna the prophetess speaks con- cerning the babe, evidently in Luke’s thought, under the influence of the Holy Spirit (Lk 2 36 ff). : It is clear from the foregoing that the passages in Mt and Lk mean to set forth, first, the super- natural origin, and secondly, the sinlessness of the babe born of Mary. The act of the Holy Spirit is regarded as creative, although the words employed signify “begotten” or “born” (yevyndév, gennéthén, Mt 1 20; and yerrduevor, genndmenon, Lk 1 385). There is no hint in the stories of the nativity con- cerning the pretemporal existence of Christ. This doctrine was developed later. Nor is there any suggestion of the immaculate conception or sinless- ness of Mary, the mother of Our Lord. Dr. C. A. Briggs has set forth a theory of the sinlessness of Mary somewhat different from the Roman Catholic view, to the effect that the OT prophecies foretell the purification of the Davidic line, and that Mary was the culminating point in the purifying process, who thereby became sinless (Incarnation of the Lord, 230-34). This, however, is speculative and without substantial Bib. warrant. The sinlessness of Jesus was not due to the sinlessness of His mother, but to the Divine origin of His human nature, the Spirit of God. In He 10 5 ff the writer makes reference to the sinless body of Christ as affording a perfect offering for sins. No direct reference is made to the birth of Jesus, but the origin of His body is ascribed to ae (He 10 5), though not specifically to the Holy irit. FO) The baptism of Jesus—The NT records give: us very little information regarding the growth of Jesus to manhood. In Lk 2 40ff a picture is given of the boyhood, exceedingly brief, but full of signifi- cance. The “child grew, and waxed strong, filled with wisdom [m “becoming full of wisdom’’]: and the grace of God was upon him.”’ Then follows the account of the visit to the temple. Evidently in all these experiences, the boy is under the influence and guidance of the Spirit. This alone would supply an adequate explanation, although Luke does not expressly name the Spirit as the source of these particular experiences. The Spirit’s action is rather assumed. Great emphasis, however, is given to the descent of the Spirit upon Jesus at His baptism. Mt 3 16 declares that after His baptism ‘the heavens were opened unto him, and he saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, aud coming upon him.” Mk 1 10 repeats the statement in substantially equivalent terms. Lk 8 22 declares that the Spirit descended in “bodily form, as a dove” (cwyartk@ elder as mepicrepdy, somatikd eidei hos peristerdn). In Jn 1 32.33 the Baptist testifies that he saw the Spirit descending upon Jesus as a dove out of heaven, and that it abode upon Him, and, further, that this descent of the Spirit was the mark by which he was to recognize Jesus as “he that baptizeth in the Holy Spirit.” We gather from these passages that at the baptism there was a new communication of the Spirit to Jesus in great fulness, as a special anointing for His Messianic vocation. The account declares that the dovelike appearance was seen by Jesus as well as John, which is scarcely compatible with a subjec- tive experience merely. Of course, the dove here is to be taken as a symbol, and not as an assertion that God’s Spirit assumed the form of a dove actually. 1411 Various meanings have been assigned to the symbol. One connects it with the creative power, according to a gentile usage; others with the speculative philosophy of Alexandrian Judaism, according to which the dove symbolized the Divine wisdom or reason. But the most natural explanation con- nects the symbolism of the dove with the brooding or hovering of the Spirit in Gen 1 3. In this new spiritual creation of humanity, asin the first physical creation, the Spirit of God is the energy through which the work is carried on. Possibly the dove, as a living organism, complete in itself, may sug- gest the totality and fulness of the gift of the Spirit to Jesus. At Pentecost, on the contrary, the Spirit is bestowed distributively and partially at least to individuals as such, as suggested by the cloven tongues as of fire which ‘‘sat upon each one of them’ (Acts 2 3). Jn 3 34 emphasizes the fulness of the bestowal upon Jesus: “For he whom God hath sent speaketh the words of God: for he giveth not the Spirit by measure.’”’ In the wit- ness of the Baptist the permanence of the anoint- ing of Jesus is declared: “Upon whomsoever thou shalt see the Spirit descending, and abiding’’ (1 33). It is probable that the connection of the bestowal of the Spirit with water baptism, as seen later in the Book of Acts, is traceable to the reception of the Spirit by Jesus at His own baptism. Baptism in the Spirit did not supersede water baptism. The gift of the Spirit in fulness to Jesus at His baptism was no doubt His formal and public anoint- ing for His Messianic work (Acts 10 38). The baptism of Jesus could not have the same signifi- cance with that of sinful men. For the symbolic cleansing from sin had no meaning for the sinless one. Yet as an act of formal public consecration it was appropriate to the Messiah. It brought to a close His private life and introduced Him to His public Messianic career. The conception of an anointing for public service was a familiar one in the OT writings and applied to the priest (Ex 28 41; 40 18; Lev 4 3.5.16; 6 20.22); to kings (1 8 9 16; 10 1; 15 1; 16 3.13); sometimes to prophets (1 K 19 16; cf Isa G1 1; Ps 22; 206). These anointings were with oil, and the oil came to be regarded as a symbol of the Spirit of God. The anointing of Jesus with the Holy Spirit qualified Him in two particulars for His Messianic office. (a) It was the source of His own endow- ments of power for the endurance of temptation, for teaching, for casting out demons, and healing the sick, for His sufferings and death, for His resurrection and ascension. The question is often raised, why Jesus, the Divine one, should have needed the Holy Spirit for His Messianic vocation. The reply is that, His human nature, which was real, required tHe Spirit’s presence. Man, made in God’s image, is constituted in dependence upon the Spirit of God. Apart from God’s Spirit man fails of his true destiny, simply because our nature is constituted as dependent upon the indwelling Spirit of God for the performance of our true functions. Jesus as human, therefore, required the presence of God’s Spirit, notwithstanding His Divine-human consciousness. (b) The Holy Spirit’s coming upon Jesus in fulness also qualified Him to bestow the Holy Spirit upon His disciples. John the Baptist esp. predicts that it is He who shall baptize in the Holy Spirit (Mt 3 11; Mk 18; Lk 3 16; see also Jn 20 22; Acts 15). It was esp. true of the king that He was anointed for His office, and the term Messiah (7°W2, mashieh, equivalent to the Gr 6 Xpiorés, ho Chrisiés), meaning the Anointed One, points to this fact. (3) The temptation of Jesus —The facts as to the temptation are as follows: In Mt 4 1 we are told THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holy Spirit that Jesus was led by the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil. Mk 1 12 declares in his graphic way that after the baptism “straight- way the Spirit driveth [é«Bdéd\e, ekbdllei] him forth into the wilderness.’ Lk 41 more fully declares that Jesus was “full of the Holy Spirit,” and that He was “led in the Spirit in the wilderness during 40 days.” The impression which the nar- ratives of the temptation give is of energetic spiritual conflict. As the Messiah confronted His life task He was subject to the ordinary conditions of other men in an evil world. Not by sheer divinity and acting from without as God, but as human also and a part of the world, He must overcome, so that while He was sinless, it was nevertheless true that the righteousness of Jesus was also an achieved righteousness. The temptations were no doubt such as were peculiar to His Messianic vocation, the misuse of power, the presumption of faith and the appeal of temporal splendor. To these He opposes the restraint of power, the poise of faith and the conception of a kingdom wholly spiritual in its origin, means and ends. Jesus is hurled, as it were, by the Spirit into this terrific conflict with the powers of evil, and His conquest, like the temptations themselves, was not final, but typical and representative. It is a mistake to suppose that the temptations of Jesus ended at the close of the forty days. Later in His ministry, He refers to the disciples as those who had been with Him in His temptations (Lk 22 28). The temptations con- tinued throughout His life, though, of course, the wilderness temptations were the severest test of all, and the victory there contained in principle and by anticipation later victories. Comment has been made upon the absence of reference to the Holy Spirit’s influence upon Jesus in certain remarkable experiences, which in the case of others would ordi- narily have been traced directly to the Spirit, as in Lk 11 14 ff, ete (cf art. by James Denney in DCG, 1, 732, 734). Is it not true, however, that the point of view of the writers of the Gospels is that Jesus is always under the power of the Spirit? At His baptism, in the temptation, and at the beginning of His public ministry (Lk 4 14) very special stress is placed upon the fact. Thence- forward the Spirit’s presence and action are assumed. From time to time, reference is made to the Spirit for special reasons, but the action of the Spirit in and through Jesus is always assumed. (4) The public ministry of Jesus—Here we can select only a few points to illustrate a much larger truth. The writers of the Gospels, and esp. Luke, conceived of the entire ministry of Jesus as under the power of the Holy Spirit. After declaring that Jesus was “full of the Holy Spirit” and that He was led about by the Spirit in the wilderness forty days in 4 1, he declares, in 4 14, that Jesus “returned in the power of the Spirit into Galilee.” This is followed in the next verse by a general summary of His activities: “And he taught in their synagogues, being glorified of all.’ Then, as if to complete his teaching as to the relation of the Spirit to Jesus, he narrates the visit to Nazareth and the citation by Jesus in the synagogue there 6f Isaiah’s words beginning, ‘“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me,” with the detailed description of His Messianic activity, viz. preaching to the poor, announcement of release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, and to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord (Isa 61 1f). Jesus proclaims the fulfilment of this prophecy in Himself (Lk 4 21). In Mt 12 18 ff a citation from Isa 42 1-3 is given in connection with the miraculous healing work of Jesus. It is a passage of exquisite beauty and describes the Messiah as a quiet and unobtrusive and tender minister to human needs, possessed of Holy Spirit THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1412 irresistible power and infinite patience. Thus the highest OT ideals as to the operations of the Spirit of God come to realization, esp. in the public minis- try of Jesus. The comprehensive terms of the description make it incontestably clear that the NT writers thought of the entire public life of Jesus as directed by the Spirit of God. We need only to read the evangelic records in order to fill in the details. The miracles of Jesus were wrought through the power of the Holy Spirit. Occasionally He is selzed as it were by a sense of the urgency of His work in some such way as to impress beholders with the presence of a strange power working in Him. In one case men think He is beside Himself (Mk 3 21); in another they are impressed with the authoritativeness of His teaching (Mk 1 22); in another His intense devotion to His task makes Him forget bodily needs (Jn 4 31); again men think He has a demon (Jn 8 48); at one time He is seized with a rapturous joy when the 70 return from their successful evangelistic tour, and Luke declares that at that hour Jesus rejoiced in the Holy Spirit (Lk 10 21; cf Mt 11 25). This whole passage is a remarkable one, containing elements which point to the Johannine conception of Jesus, on which account Harnack is disposed to discredit it at certain points (Sayings of Jesus, 302). One of the most impressive aspects of this activity of Jesus in the Spirit is its suppressed intensity. Nowhere is there lack of self-control. Nowhere is there evidence of a coldly didactic attitude, on the one hand, or of a loose rein upon the will, on the other. Jesus is always an intensely human Master wrapped in Divine power. The miracles contrast strikingly with the miracles of the apocryphal gospels. In the latter all sorts of capricious deeds of power are ascribed to Jesus as a boy. In our Gospels, on the contrary, no miracle is wrought until after His anointing with the Spirit at baptism. A topic of especial interest is that of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. Jesus cast out demons by the power of God’s Spirit. In Mt 12 31; Mk 3 28f; Lk 12 10, we have the declaration that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is an unpardon- able sin. Mark particularizes the offence of the accusers of Jesus by saying that they said of Jesus, “He hath an unclean spirit.’ The blasphemy against the Spirit seems to have been not merely rejection of Jesus and His words, which might be due to various causes. It was rather the sin of ascribing works of Divine mercy and power— works which had all the marks of their origin in the goodness of God—to a diabolic source. The charge was that He cast out devils by Beelzebub the prince of devils. We are not to suppose that the unpardonable nature of the sin against the Holy Spirit was due to anything arbitrary in God’s arrangements regarding sin. The moral and spiritual attitude involved in the charge against Jesus was simply a hopeless one. It presupposed a warping or wrenching of the moral nature from the truth in such degree, a deep-seated malignity and insusceptibility to Divine influences so complete, that no moral nucleus remained on which the forgiving love of God might work. See Buas- PHEMY. (5) Death, resurrection and Pentecostal gift— It is not possible to give here a complete outline of the activities of Jesus in the Holy Spirit. We observe one or two additional points as to the relations of the Holy Spirit to Him. In He 9 14 it is declared that Christ “through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish unto God,” and in Rom 1 4, Paul says He was ‘declared to be the Son of God with power, according to the spirit of holiness, by the resurrection from the dead’ (cf also Rom 8 11). . As already noted, John the Baptist gave as a particular designation of Jesus that it was He who should baptize with the Holy Spirit, in contrast with his own baptism in water. In Jn 20 22, after the resurrection and before the ascension, Jesus breathed on the disciples and said ‘Receive ye the Holy Spirit”’ There was probably a real com- munication of the Spirit in this act of Jesus in anticipation of the outpouring in fulness on the day of Pentecost. In Acts 1 2 it is declared that He gave commandment through the Holy Spirit, and in 1 5 it is predicted by Him that the disciples should “be baptized in the Holy Spirit not man: days hence’; and in 1 8 it is declared, “Ye shall receive power, when the Holy Spirit is come upon. you.’ It is clear from the preceding that in the thought of the NT writers Jesus is completely endued with the power of the Holy Spirit. It is in large measure the OT view of the Spirit; that is to say, the opera- tion of the Spirit in and through Jesus is chiefly with a view to His official Messianic work, the charismatic Spirit imparting power rather than the Spirit for holy living merely. Yet there is a differ- ence between the OT and NT representations here. In the OT the agency of the Spirit is made very prominent when mighty works are performed by His power. In the Gospels the view is concen- trated less upon the Spirit than upon Jesus Him- self, though it is always assumed that He is acting in the power of the Spirit. In the case of Jesus also, the moral quality of His words and deeds is always assumed. Our next topic in setting forth the NT teaching is the Holy Spirit in relation to the kingdom of God. Quite in harmony with the plenary 2. The enduement of Jesus, the founder Spirit in the of the kingdom, with the power of the Kingdom Spirit, is the communication of the of God Spirit to the agents employed by Providence in the conduct of the affairs of the kingdom. We need, at all points, in considering the subject in the NT to keep in view the OT background. The covenant relations between God and Israel were the presupposition of all the blessings of the OT. In the NT there is not an identical but an analogous point of view. God is continuing His work among men. Indeed in a real sense He has begun a new work, but this new work is the fulfilment of the old. The new differs from the old in some very important respects, chiefly indeed in this, that now the national and theocratic life is wholly out of sight. Prophecy no longer deals with political questions. The power of the Spirit no longer anoints kings and judges for their duties. The action of the Spirit upon the cosmos now ceases to receive attention. In short, the kingdom of God is intensely spiritualized, and the relation of the Spirit to the individual or the church is nearly always that which is dealt with. (1) Synoptic teachings.—We consider briefly the synoptic teachings as to the Holy Spirit in relation to the kingdom of God. The forerunner of Jesus goes before His face in the Spirit and power of Elijah (Lk 1.17). Of Him it had been predicted that He should be filled with the Holy Spirit from His mother’s womb (Lk 115). The Master expressly predicts that the Holy Spirit will give the needed wisdom when the disciples are delivered up. “It is not ye that speak, but the Holy Spirit” (Mk 13 11). In Lk 12 12 it is also declared that “The Holy Spirit shall teach you in that very hour what ye ought to say.”’ Likewise in Mt 10 20, “It is not ye that speak, but the Spirit of your Father that speaketh in you.’ In Lk 11 13 is 1413 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holy Spirit a beautiful saying: If we who are evil give good gifts to our children, how much more shall the “heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to them that ask him.” This is a variation from the || passage in Mt (7 11), and illustrates Luke’s marked emphasis upon the operations of the Spirit. In Mt 28 19, the disciples are commanded to baptize in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. This passage has been called in question, but there is not sufficient ground for its rejection. Hitherto there has been almost no hint directly of the personality of the Spirit or the Trinitarian im- plcaiigas in the teaching as to the Spirit. Here, owever, we have a very suggestive hint toward a doctrine-of the Spirit which attains more complete development later. (2) In the Gospel of John there is a more elaborate presentation of the office and work of the Holy Spirit, particularly in chs 14-17. Several earlier passages, however, must be noticed. The passage on the new birth in Jn 3 5ff we notice first. The expression, “‘except one be born of water and the Spirit,’’ seems to contain a reference to baptism along with the action of the Spirit of God directly on the soul. In the light of other NT teachings, however, we are not warranted in ascribing saving efficacy to baptism here. The “birth,” in so far as it relates to baptism, is symbolic simply, not actual. The outward act is the fitting symbolic accompaniment of the spiritual regeneration by the Spirit. Symbolism and spiritual fact move on_|| lines. The entrance into the kingdom is symboli- cally effected by means of baptism, just as the “new birth” takes place symbolically by the same means. In Jn 6 51 ff we have the very difficult words attributed to Jesus concerning the eating of His flesh and the drinking of His blood. The disciples were greatly distressed by these words, and in 6 63 Jesus insists that “it is the spirit that giveth life; the flesh profiteth nothing.’’ One’s view of the meaning of this much-discussed passage will turn largely on his point of view in interpreting it. If he adopts the view that John is reading back into the record much that came later in the history, the inference will probably follow that Jesus is here referring to the Lord’s Supper. If on the other hand it is held that John is seeking to reproduce substantially what was said, and to convey an impression of the actual situation, the reference to the Supper will not be inferred.. Certainly the language fits the later teaching in the establish- ment of the Supper, although John omits a detailed account of the Supper. But Jesus was meeting a very real situation in the carnal spirit of the multi- tude which followed Him for the loaves and fishes. His deeply mystical words seem to have been intended to accomplish the result which followed, viz. the separation of the true from the false dis- ciples. There is no necessary reference to the Lord’s Supper specifically, therefore, in His words. Spiritual meat and drink, not carnal, are the true food of man. He Himself was that food, but only the spiritually susceptible would grasp His meaning. It is difficult to assign any sufficient reason why Jesus should have here referred to the Supper, or why John should have desired to introduce such reference into the story at this stage. In Ju 7 37ff we have a saying of Jesus and its interpretation by John which accords with the synoptic reference to a future baptism in the Holy Spirit to be bestowed by Jesus: ‘He that believeth on me, as the scripture hath said, from within him shall flow rivers of living water.’’ John adds: “But this spake he of the Spirit, which they that believed on him were to receive: for the Spirit was not yet given; because Jesus was not yet glorified.’’ No doubt John’s Gospel is largely a reproduction of the facts and teachings of Jesus in the evangel- ist’s own words. This passage indicates, however, that John discriminated between his own con- structions of Christ’s teachings and the teachings themselves, and warns us against the custom of many exegetes who broadly assume that John pup eyed his material with slight regard for careful and correct statement, passing it through his own consciousness in such manner as to leave us his own subjective Gospel, rather than a truly historical record. The ethical implications of such a process on John’s part would scarcely harmonize with his general tone and esp. the teachings of his Epp. No doubt John’s Gospel contains much meaning which he could not have put into it prior to the coming of the Spirit. But what John seeks to give ie the teaching of Jesus and not his own theory of esus. We give next an outline of the teachings in the great chapters from 14 to 17, the farewell discourse of Jesus. In 14 16 Jesus says, “I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter’ (mapdxdyros, pardklétos; see PaRacLeTE). Next Jesus describes this Comforter as one whom the world cannot receive. Disciples know Him because He abides in them. The truth of Christianity is spiritually discerned, i.e. it is discerned by the power and indwelling of the Holy Spirit. In the name of ‘reality,’ science sometimes repudiates these inner experiences as ‘‘mystical.”’ But Chris- tians cling to them as most real, data of experience as true and reliable as any other forms of human experience. To repudiate them would be for them to repudiate reality itself. The Father and Son shall make their abode in Christians (14 23). This is probably another form of assertion of the Spirit’s presence, and not a distinct line of mystical teaching. (Cf Woods, The Spirit of God in Bib. Literature, 243.) For in ver 26 the promise of the Spirit is repeated. The Father is to send the Spirit in the name of Christ, and He is to teach the disciples all things, quickening also their memories. In the NT generally, and esp. in John’s and Paul’s writings, there is no sense of conflict between Father, Son and Spirit in their work in the Chris- tian. All proceeds from the Father, through the Son, and is accomplished in the Christian by the Holy Spirit. As will appear, Christ in the believer is represented as being practically all that the Spirit does without identifying Christ with the Spirit. So far there are several notes suggesting the personality of the Holy Spirit. The designa- tion “another Comforter,” taken in connection with the description of his work, is one. The fact that He is sent or given is another. And another is seen in the specific work which the Spirit is to do. Another is the masculine pronoun employed here (éxetvos, ekeinos). In ver 26 the function of the Spirit is indicated. He is to bring to “remembrance all that I said unto you.” In 15 26 this is made even more comprehensive: ‘He shall bear witness of me,’’ and yet more emphatically in 16 14, “He shall glorify me: for he shall take of mine, and shall declare it unto you.’ The sphere of the Spirit’s activity is the heart of the individual believer and of the ehurch. His chief function is to illumine the teaching and glorify the person of Jesus. Jn 15 26 is the passage which has been used in support of the doctrine of the procession of the Spirit. Jesus says, “I will send” (réuyw, pémpsd), future tense, referring to the “Spirit of truth which proceedeth from the Father’ (éxropeveras, ekporetietai), present tense. The present tense here suggests timeless action and has been taken to indicate an essential relation of the Spirit to God the Father (cf Godet, Comm. on John, in loc.). The hazard of such an interpretation lies chiefly in the absence of other Holy Spirit confirmatory Scriptures and in the possibility of another and simpler meaning of the word. How- ever, the language is unusual, and the change of tense in the course of the sentence is suggestive. Perhaps it is one of the many instances where we must admit we do not know the precise import of the language of Scripture. In 16 7-15 we have a very important passage. Jesus declares to the anxious disciples that it is expedient for Him to go away, because otherwise the Spirit will not come. ‘He, when he is come, will convict the world in respect of sin, and of righteousness, and of judgment’? (16 8). The term tr? “convict”? (édéyée, elégkset) involves a cognitive along with a moral process. The Spirit who deals in truth, and makes His appeal through the trnth, shall convict, shall bring the mind on which He is working into a sense of self-condemna- tion on account of sm. The word means more than reprove, or refute, or convince. It signifies up to a certain point a moral conquest of the mind: “of sin, because they believe not on me” (16 9). belief is the root sin. The revelation of God in Christ is, broadly speaking, His condemnation of all sin. The Spirit may convict of particular sins, but they will all be shown to consist essentially in the rejection of God’s love and righteousness in Christ, ie. in unbelief. “Of righteousness, because I go to the Father, and ye behold me no more” (16 10). What does this mean? Does Jesus mean that His going to the Father will be the proof of His right- eonsness to those who put Him to death, or that this going to the Father will be the consummating or crowning act of His righteousness which the Spirit is to carry home to the hearts of men? Or does He mean that because He goes away the Spirit will take His place in convicting men of righteousness? The latter meaning seems implied in the words, “and ye behold me no more.” _ Probably, however, the mean- ings are not mutually exclusive. “Of judgment because the prince of this world hath been judged” (16 11). In His incarnation and death the prince of this world, the usurper, is conquered and cast ont. We may sum up the teachings as to the Spirit in these four chapters as follows: He is the Spirit of truth; He guides into all truth; He brings to memory Christ’s teachings; He shows things to come; He glorifies Christ; He speaks not of Him- self but of Christ; He, like believers, bears witness to Christ; He enables Christians to do greater works than those of Christ; He convicts the world of sin, of righteousness, and of judgment; He comes because Christ goes away; He is “another Com- forter’; He is to abide with disciples forever. These teachings cover a very wide range of needs. The Holy Spirit is the subject of the entire discourse. In a sense it is the counterpart of the Sermon on the Mount. There the laws of the kingdom are expounded. Here the means of realization of all the ends of that kingdom are presented. The king- dom now becomes the kingdom of the Spirit. The historical revelation of truth in the life, death, resur- rection and glorification of Jesus being completed, the Spirit of truth comes in fulness. The gospel as history is now to become the gospel as experience. The Messiah as a fact is now to become the Messiah as a life through the Spirit’s action. All the ele- ments of the Spirit’s action are embraced: the charismatic for mighty works; the intellectual for guidance into truth; the moral and spiritual for producing holy lives. This discourse transfers the kingdom, so to speak, from the shoulders of the Master to those of the disciples, but the latter are empowered for their tasks by the might of the indwelling and abiding Spirit. The method of the kingdom’s growth and advance is clearly indicated as spiritual, conviction of sin, righteousness and THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1414 judgment, and obedient and holy lives of Christ’s disciples. ; é Before passing to the next topic, one remark should be made as to the Trinitarian suggestions of these chapters in Jn. The personality of the Spirit is clearly implied in much of the language here. It is true we have no formal teaching on the metaphysical side, no ontology in the strict sense of the word. This fact is made much of by writers who are slow to recognize the personality of the Holy Spirit in the light of the teachings of John and Paul. These writers have no difficulty, however, in asserting that the NT writers hold that God is a personal being (see I. F. Woods, The Spirit of God in Bib. Literature, 256, 268). It must be insisted, however, that in the N’‘T, as in the OT, there is little metaphysics, little ontological teaching as to God. His personality is deduced from the same kind of sayings as those relating to the Spirit. From the ontological point of view, therefore, we should also have to reject the per- sonality of God on the basis of the Bib. teach- ings. The Trinitarian formulations may not be correct at all points, but the NT warrants the Trinitarian doctrine, Just_as it warrants belief in the personality of God. We are not insisting on finding metaphysics in Scripture where it is absent, but we do insist upon consistency in construing the popular and practical language of Scripture as to the second and third as well as the first Person of the Trinity. We add a few lines as to John’s teachings in the Epp. and Revelation. In general they are in close harmony with the teachings in his Gospel and do not require extended treatment. The Spirit imparts assurance (1 Jn 3 24); incites to confession of Christ (4 2); bears witness to Christ (6 6ff). In Rev 14 the “seven Spirits’ is an expression for the completeness of the Spirit. The Spirit speaks to the churches (2 7.11; 3 6). The seer is “in the Spirit’? (4 2). The Spirit joins the church in the invitation of the gospel (22 17). (3) The Holy Spirit in the Book of Acts—The Book of Acts contains the record of the beginning of the Dispensation of the Holy Spirit. There is at the outset the closest connection with the recorded predictions of the Holy Spirit in the Gospels. Particularly does Luke make clear the continuity of his own thought regarding the Spirit in his earlier and later writing. Jesus in the first chapter of Acts gives commandment through the Holy Spirit and predicts the reception of power as the. result of the baptism in the Holy Spirit which the disciples are soon to receive. The form of the Spirit’s activities in Acts is chiefly charismatic, that is, the miraculous endow- ment of disciples with power or wisdom for their work in extending the Messianic kingdom. As yet the work of the Spirit within disciples as the chief sanctifying agency is not fully developed, and is later described with great fulness in Paul’s writings. Some recent writers have overemphasized the con- trast between the earlier and the more developed view of the Spirit with regard to the moral life. In Acts the ethical import of the Spirit’s action appears at several points (see Acts 5 3.9; 7 51; 8 18f; 189; 15 28). The chief interest in Acts is naturally the Spirit’s agency in founding the Messianic kingdom, since here is recorded the early history of the expansion of that kingdom. The phenomenal rather than the inner moral aspects of that great movement naturally come chiefly into view. But everywhere the ethical implications are present. Gunkel is no doubt correct in the state- ment that Paul’s conception of the Spirit as inward and moral and acting in the daily life of the Chris- tian opens the way for the activity of the Spirit as 1415 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holy Spirit a historical principle in subsequent ages. After all, this is the fundamental and universal import of the Spirit (see Gunkel, Die Wirkungen des heiligen Geistes, etc, 76; ef Pfleiderer, Paulinismus, 200). We now proceed to give a brief summary of the Holy Spirit’s activities as recorded in Acts, and follow this with a discussion of one or two special points. The great event is of course the outpouring or baptism of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost followed by the completion of the baptism in the Holy Spirit by the baptism of the household of Cornelius (2 1ff; 10 17-48). Speaking with tongues, and other striking manifestations attended this baptism, as also witnessing to the gospel with power by the apostles, See Baptism oF rHe Hoty Spirzit. This outpouring is declared to be in fulfilment of OT prophecy, and the assertion is also made that it is the gift of the exalted Lord Jesus Christ (2 17.33). Following this baptism of the Holy Spirit the dis- ciples are endued with miraculous power for their work. Miracles are wrought (Acts 2 43 ff), and all necessary gifts of wisdom and Divine guidance are bestowed. A frequent form of expression describ- ing the actors in the history is, “filled with the Holy Spirit.’? It is applied to Peter (4 8); to disciples (4 31); to the seven deacons (6 3); to Stephen (6 5; 7 55); to Saul who becomes Paul (13 9). The presence of the Spirit and His immediate and direct superintendence of affairs are seen in the fact that Ananias and Sapphira are represented as lying to the Holy Spirit (5 3.9); the Jews are charged by Stephen with resisting the Holy Spirit (7 51); and Simon Magus is rebuked for attempt- ing to purchase the Spirit with money (8 18 f). The Holy Spirit is connected with the act of baptism, but there does not seem to be any fixed order as between the two. In Acts 9 17 the Spirit comes before baptism; and after baptism in 8 17 and 19 6. In these cases the coming of the Spirit was in connection with the laying on of hands also. But in 10 44 the Holy Spirit falls upon the hearers while Peter is speaking prior to baptism and with no laying on of hands. These instances in which the order of baptism, the laying on of hands and the gift of the Spirit seem to be a matter of indifference, are a striking indication of the non-sacramentarian character of the teaching of the Book of Acts, and indeed in the NT generally. Certainly no par- ticular efficacy seems to be attached to the laying on of hands or baptism except as symbolic representa- tions of spiritual facts. Gunkel, m his excellent work on the Holy Spirit, claims Acts 2 38 as an ‘instance when the Spirit is bestowed during bap- tism (Die Wirkungen des heiligen Geisies, etc, 7). The words of Peter, however, may refer to a recep- tion of the Spirit subsequent to baptism, although evidently in immediate connection with it. The baptiam of the Holy Spirit clearly then was not meant tosupplant water baptism. Moreover, inthe strict sense the baptism of the Holy Spirit was a historical event or events completed at the outset when the extension of the kingdom of God, begin- ning at Pentecost, began to reach out to the gentile world. See Baprism or THE Hoxy Srrair. In Acts the entire historical movement is repre- sented by Luke as being under the direction of the Spirit. He guides Philip to the Ethiopian and then “catches away” Philip (8 29.39). He guides Peter at Joppa through the vision and then leads him to Cornelius at Caesarea (10 19f; 1112f). The Spirit commands the church at Antioch to separate Saul and Barnabas for missionary work (13 2 ff). He guides the church at Jerus (15 28). He forbids the apostle to go to Asia (16 6f). The Spirit enables Agabus to prophesy that Paul will be bound by the Jews at Jerus (21 11; cf also 20 23). The Spirit appointed the elders at Ephesus (20 28). One or two points require notice before passing from Acts. The impression we get of the Spirit’s action here very strongly suggests a Divine purpose moving on the stage of history in a large and com- prehensive way. In Jesus that purpose was individualized. Here the supplementary thought of a vast historic movement is powerfully suggested. Gunkel asserts that usually the Spirit’s action is not conceived by the subjects of it in terms of means (Mittel) and end (Zweck), but rather as cause (Ursache) and activity (Wirkung) (see Die Wirkungen des heiligen Getstes, etc, 20). There is an element of truth in this, but the idea of purpose is by no means confined to the historian who later recorded the Spirit’s action. The actors in the spiritual drama were everywhere conscious of the great movement of which they as individuals were a part. In some passages the existence of purpose in the Spirit’s action is clearly recognized, as in His restraining of Paul at certain points and in the appointment of Saul and Barnabas as mission- aries. Divine purpose is indeed implied at all points, and while the particular end in view was not always clear in a given instance, the subjects of the Spirit’s working were scarcely so naive in their apprehension of the matter as to think of their expe- riences merely as so many extraordinary phe- nomena caused in a particular way. We note next the glossolalia, or speaking with tongues, recorded in Acts 2, as well as in later chapters and in Paul’s Epp. The prevailing view at present is that “speaking with tongues” does not mean speaking actual intelligible words in a foreign language, but rather the utterance of meaningless sounds, as was customary among the heathen and as is sometimes witnessed today where religious life becomes highly emotional in its manifestation. To support this view the account in Acts 2 is questioned, and Paul’s instructions in 1 Cor 14 are cited. Of course a man’s world-view will be likely to influence his interpretation in this as in other matters. Philosophically an antisupernatural world-view makes it easy to question the glossolalia of the NT. Candid exegesis, however, rather requires the recognition of the presence in the apostolic church of a speaking in foreign tongues, even if alongside of it there existed (which is open to serious doubt) the other phenomenon mentioned above. Acts 2 3ff is absolutely conclusive taken by itself, and no valid critical grounds have been found for rejecting the passage. 1 Cor 14 con- firms this view when its most natural meaning is sought. Paul is here insisting upon the orderly conduct of worship and upon edification as the important thing. To this end he insists that they who speak with tongues pray that they may also interpret (1 Cor 14 5; ch 13). It is difficult to conceive what he means by “interpret” if the speaking with tongues was a meaningless jargon of sounds uttered under emotional excitement, and nothing more. Paul’s whole exposition in this chapter implies that “tongues” may be used for edification. He ranks it below prophecy simply because without an interpreter ‘‘tongues’’ would not edify the hearer. Paul himself spoke with tongues more than they all (14 18). It seems scarcely in keeping with Paul’s character to suppose that he refers ‘lets to a merely emotional volubility in meaningless and disconnected sounds. See Tonauzs, GIFT oF. (4) The Holy Spirit in Paul’s writings —The teachings of Paul on the Holy Spirit are so rich and abundant that space forbids an exhaustive presenta~- tion. In his writings the Bib. representations reach their climax. Mr. Wood says correctly that Paul grasped the idea of the unity of the Christian life. All the parts exist in a living whole and the Holy Holy Spirit = - THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1416 Spirit constitutes and maintains it (Wood, The | aspects as well as in its charismatic forms. It isa Spirit of God in Bib. Literature, 268). In fact a careful study of Paul’s teachings discloses three || lines, one relating to faith, another to Christ, and the third to the Holy Spirit. That is to say, his teachings coalesce, as it were, point by point, in reference to these three subjects. Faith is the human side of the Divine activity carried on by the Holy Spirit. Faith is therefore implied in the Spirit’s action and is the result of or response to it in its various forms. But faith is primarily and essentially faith in Jesus Christ. Hence we find in Paul that Christ is represented as doing sub- stantially everything that the Spirit does. Now we are not to see in this any conflicting conceptions as to Christ and the Spirit, but rather Paul’s intense feeling of the unity of the work of Christ and the Spirit. The “law’’ of the Spirit’s action is the revelation and glorification of Christ. In his Gos- pel, which came later, John, as we have seen, defined the Spirit’s function in precisely these terms. Whether or not John was influenced by Paul in the matter we need not here consider. (a) We begin with a brief reference to the con- nection in Paul’s thought between the Spirit and Jesus. The Holy Spirit is described as the Spirit of God’s Son (Rom 8 14 ff; Gal 4 6), as the Spirit of Christ (Rom 8 9). He who confesses Jesus does so by the Holy Spirit, and no one can say that Jesus is anathema in the Holy Spirit (1 Cor 12 3). Christ is called a life-giving Spirit (16 45); and in 2 Cor 317 the statement appears, “Now the Lord is the Spirit.” All of this shows how com- pletely one Paul regarded the work of Christ and the Spirit, not because they were identical in the sense in which Beyschlag has contended, but because their task and aim being identical, there was no sense of discord in Paul’s mind in explaining their activities in similar terms. (6) The Spirit appears in Paul as in Acts impart- ing all kinds of charismatic gifts for the ends of the Messianic kingdom. He enumerates a long list of spiritual gifts which cannot receive separate treatment here, such as prophecy (1 Thess 5 19f); tongues (1 Cor 12-14); wisdom (2 6 ff); knowl- edge (12 8); power to work miracles (12 9f); discerning of spirits (12 10); interpretation of tongues (12 10); faith (12 9); boldness in Chris- tian testimony (2 Cor 3 17f); charismata gen- erally (1 Thess 1 5; 48, etc). See SprriruaL Grrts. In addition to the above list, Paul esp. emphasizes the Spirit’s action in revealing to himself and to Christians the mind of God (1 Cor 2 10-12; Eph 3 5). He speaks in words taught by the Spirit (1 Cor 2 13). He preaches in demonstra- tion of the Spirit and of power (1 Cor 2 4; 1 Thess 1 5). 4 the above manifestations of the Spirit, as enumerated in Paul’s writings, we have presented in very large measure what we have already seen in Acts, but with some additions. In 1 Cor 14 and elsewhere Paul gives a new view as to the charis- matic gifts which was greatly needed in view of the tendency to extravagant and intemperate indul- gence in emotional excitement, due to the mighty action of God’s Spirit in the Corinthian church. He insists that all things be done unto edification, that spiritual growth is the true aim of all spiritual endowments. This may be regarded as the con- necting link between the earlier and later NT teaching as to the Holy Spirit, between the charis- matic and moral-religious significance of the Spirit. To the latter we now direct attention. (c) We note the Spirit in the beginnings of the Christian life. From beginning to end the Chris- tian life is regarded by Paul as under the power of the Holy Spirit, in its inner mora! and religious singular fact that Paul does not anywhere expressly declare that the Holy Spirit originates the Chris- tian life. Gunkel is correct in this so far as specific and direct teaching is concerned. But Wood who asserts the contrary is also right, if regard is had to clear implications and legitimate inferences from Paul’s statements (op. cit., 202). Rom 8 2 does not perhaps refer to the act of regeneration, and yet it is hard to conceive of the Christian life as thus constituted by the “law of the Spirit of life” apart from its origin through the Spirit. There are other passages which seem to imply very clearly, if they do not directly assert, that the Christian life 1s originated by the Holy Spirit (1 Thess 1 6; Rom 6 5; 89; 1 Cor 2 4; 611; Tit 3 5). aoe The Holy Spirit in the beginnings of the Christian life itself is set forth in many forms of statement. They who have the Spirit belong to Christ (Rom 8 9). We received not the Spirit of bondage but of adoption, “whereby we cry, Abba, Father” (Rom 815). “The Spirit himself beareth witness with our spirit, that we are children of God” (Rom 8 16). The Spirit is received by the hearing of faith (Gal 3 2). See also Rom 5 5; 8 2; 1 Cor 16 11; Gal 3 3.14; Eph 2 18. There are two or three expressions employed by Paul which express some particular aspect of the Spirit’s work in be- lievers. One of these is “first-fruits’’ (Rom 8 23, drapx%, aparché), which means that the present possession of the Spirit by the believer is the guarantee of the full redemption which is to come, as the first-fruits were the guarantee of the full harvest. Another of these words is “earnest” (2 Cor 1 22; & 5, éppa8dv, arrabin), which also means a pledge or guarantee. Paul also speaks of the “sealing” of the Christians with the Holy Spirit of promise, as in Eph 1 13 (éc¢payloOnre, esphragis- théte, ‘“‘ye were sealed”). This refers to the seal by which a king stamped his mark of authorization or ownership upon a document. (d) Paul gives a great variety of expressions indi- cating the presence and activity of the Holy Spirit in the religious and moral life of the Christian. In fact at every point that lifeis under the guidance and sustaining energy of the Spirit. If we live after the flesh, we die; if after the Spirit, we live (Rom 8 6). The Spirit helps the Christian to pray (Rom 8 26f). The kingdom of God is righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit (Rom 14 17). Christians are to abound in hope through the Holy Spirit (Rom 16 13). “The fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, meekness, self-control’ (Gal 6 22). Christians are warned to grieve not the Holy Spirit (Eph 4 30), and are urged to take the sword of the Spirit (6 17). The flesh is contrasted with the Spirit at a number of points in Paul’s writings (e.g. Rom 8 5f; Gal 6 17 ff). The Spirit in these passages probably means either the Spirit of God or man’s spirit as under the influence of the Spirit of God. Flesh is a difficult word to define, as it seems to be used in several somewhat different senses. When the flesh is represented as lusting against the Spirit, however, it seems equivalent to the “carnal mind,” i.e. the mind of the sinful natural man as distinct from the mind of the spiritual man. This carnal or fleshly mind is thus described because the flesh is thought of as the sphere in which the sinful impulses in large part, though not altogether (Gal 6 19ff), take their rise. Paul contrasts the Spirit with the letter (2 Cor 3 6) and puts strong emphasis on the Spirit as the source of Christian liberty. As Gunkel points out, spirit ahd freedom with Paul are correlatives, like spirit and life. Freedom must needs come of the Spirit’s presence because He is superior to all other 1417 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Holy Spirit Home authorities and powers (Die Wirkungen des heiligen Geistes, etc, 95). See also an excellent passage on the freedom of the Christian from statutory religious requirements in DCG, art. ‘Holy Spirit” by Dr. James Denney, I, 739. (e) The Holy Spirit inthe church. Toward the end of his ministry and in his later group of epp., Paul devoted much thought to the subject of the church, and one of his favorite figures was of the church as the body of Christ. The Holy Spirit is represented as animating this body, as communicating to it life, and directing all its affairs. As in the case of the individual believer, so also in the body of believers the Spirit is the sovereign energy which rules com- pletely. By one Spirit all are baptized into one ody and made to drink of one Spirit (1 Cor 12 13). All the gifts of the church, charismatic and otherwise, are from the Spirit (12 4.8-11). All spiritual gifts in the church are for edification (14 12). Prayer is to be in the Spirit (14 15). The church is to preserve the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace (Eph 4 3). Love (Col 1 8); fellow- ship (Phil 2 1); worship (3 3) are in the Spirit. The church is the habitation of the Spirit (Eph 2 22). The church is an epistle of Christ written by the Spirit (2 Cor 3 3). Thus the whole life of the church falls under the operation of the Holy Spirit. (f) The Spirit also carries on His work in believers in raising the body from the dead. In Rom 8 11 Paul asserts that the present indwelling in believers of the Spirit that raised up Jesus from the dead is the guarantee of the quickening of their_mortal bodies by the power of the same Spirit. See also 1 Cor 15 44f; Gal 6 5. We have thus exhibited Paul’s teachings as to the Holy Spirit in some detail in order to make clear their scope and comprehensiveness. And we have not exhausted the material supplied by his writings. I+ will be observed that Paul nowhere elaborates a doctrine of the Spirit, as he does in a number of instances his doctrine of the person of Christ. The references to the Spirit are in con- nection with other subjects usually. This, however, only serves to indicate how very fundamental the work of the Spirit wasin Paul’s assumptions as to the Christian life. The Spirit is the Christian life, just as Christ is that life. The personality of the Spirit appears in Paul as in John. The benediction in 2 Cor 13 14 distin- guishes clearly Father, Son and Spirit (cf also Eph 4 4), In many connections the Spirit is distim- guished from the Son and Father, and the work of the Spirit is set forth in personal terms. It is true references are often made to the Holy Spirit by Paul as if the Spirit were an impersonal influence, or at least without clearly personal attributes. This dis- tinguishes his usage as to the Spirit from that as to Christ and God, who are always personal. It is a natural explanation of this fact if we hold that in the case of the impersonal references we have a survival of the current OT conception of the Spirit, while in those which are personal we have the developed conception as found in both Paul and John. Personal attributes are ascribed to the Spirit in so many instances, it would seem unwar- ranted in us to make the earlier and lower con- ception determinative of the later and higher. In Paul’s writings we have the crowning factor in the Bib. doctrine of the Holy Spirit. He gathers up most of the preceding elements, and adds to them his own distinctive teaching or emphasis. Some of the earlier OT elements are lacking, but all those which came earlier in the NT are found in Paul. The three points which Paul esp. brought into full expression were first, the law of edification in the use of spiritual gifts, second, the Holy Spirit in the moral life of the believer, and third, the Holy Spirit in the church. Thus Paul enables us to make an important distinction as to the work of the Spirit in founding the kingdom of God, viz. the distinction between means and ends. Charis- matic gifts of the Spirit were, after all, means to ethical ends. God’s kingdom is moral in its pur- ose, ‘righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy pirit.” Christianity is, according to Paul, inher- ently and essentially supernatural. But its per- manent and abiding significance is to be found, not in extraordinary phenomena in the form of “mighty works,’’ “wonders,” “tongues”? and other miracles in the ordinary sense, but in the creation of a new moral order in time and eternity. The super- natural is to become normal and “natural” in human history, therefore, in the building up of this ethical kingdom on the basis of a redemption that is in and through Jesus Christ, and wrought out im all its details by the power of the Holy Spirit. (5) The Holy Spirit in other NT writings.— There is little to add to the NT teaching as to the Holy Spirit. Paul and John practically cover all the aspects of His work which are presented. There are a few passages, however, we may note in con- cluding our general survey. In He the Holy Spirit is referred to a number of times as inspiring the OT Scriptures {He 3 7; 9 8; 10 15). We have already referred to the remarkable statement in He 9 14 to the effect that the blood of Christ was offered through the eternal Spirit. In 10 29 doing ‘‘despite unto the Spirit of grace’ seems to be closely akin to the sin against the Holy Spirit in the Gospels. In He 4 12 there is a very remarkable description of the “word of God” in personal terms, as having all the energy and activity of an actual personal presence of the Spirit, and recalls Paul’s language in Eph 6 17. In 1 Pet we need only refer to 1 11 in which Peter declares that the “Spirit of Christ’? was in the OT prophets, pointing forward to the sufferings and glories of Christ. Lireratore.—t. F. Wood, The Spirit of God in Bib. Literature; art. ‘‘ Spiritual Gifts’’ in HB; Gunkel, Die Wirkungen des heiligen Getstes; Gloel, Der hetlige Geist in der Hetlsverkiindigung des Paulus; Wendt, Die Be- griffe Fleisch und Geist tm btblischen Sprachgebrauch; Weinel, Die Wirkungen des Geistes und der Geister; Dick- son, St. Paul's Use of the Terms Flesh and Spirit; Smea- ton, Doctrine of the Holy Spirit; Walker, The Spirit and the Incarnation; Denio, The Supreme Leader; Moberly, Administration of the Holy Spirit in the Body of Christ; Hutchings, Person and Work of the Holy Spirit; Owen, Pneumatologia; Webb, Person and Office of the Holy Spirit; Hare, The Mission of the Comforter; Candlish, The Work of the Holy Spirit; Wirgman, The Sevenfold - Gifts; Heber, Personality and Offices of the Holy Spvrit; Swete, The Hol Johnson, The Work of the Holy Spirit; Spirit in the NT; Moule, Vent Creator; oly Spirit Then and Now; Kuyper, The Bib. Theologies of Schultz, Davidson, Weiss, Beyschlag, Stevens; list appended to art. on ae in HDB and DCG; extensive bibliography in Denio’s The Supreme Leader, 239 ff. . . Y. MuLuiins HOMAM, hi’mam (DIN, homam, “destruc- tion’): A Horite descendant of Esau (1 Ch 1 39). The name appears in Gen 36 22 as ‘““Heman.” HOME, him (73, bayith, “house,” Bip’, makom, “place,” DON, ’ohel, “tent” [Jgs 19 9], 37D, shabh, “to cause to turn back,” JIM, tawekh, iM, tdkh, “middle,” “midst? [Dt 21 12]; otkos, otkos, “house,” “household,” ev8ypéo, endéméd, “to be among one’s people,” ofkos idios, ‘one’s own proper [house]”): This term in Scripture does not stand for a single specific word of the original, but for a variety of phrases. Most commonly it is a tr of the Heb bayith, Gr oles, “house,’’ which means either the building or the persons occupying it. In Gen 43 26 “home” and “into the house”’ represent the same phrase, “to the house” (ha-bay*thah). In Ruth 1 21, “hath brought me home again” means “has caused me to return.” In 2 Ch 25 10 Home-born Hope THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1418 “home again” means “to their place.” In Eccl 12 5 “long home,” RV “everlasting home,” means “eternal house.” In Jn 19 27 “unto his own home’’ means “unto his own things” (so Jn 1 11). In 2 Cor 5 6 (and RV vs 8.9) “be at home” is a tr of endémeé, “to be among one’s own people,” as opposed to ekdéméé, ‘‘to be or live abroad.” BenJsaMin Reno DowNER HOME-BORN, him’bérn (TTR, ezrah): A native-born Heb, as contrasted with a foreigner of different blood. The same Heb word is found in Lev 16 29; 18 26 and elsewhere, but is tr? differ- ently. Home-born in Jer 2 14 is a tr of the phrase ma Tet, ylidh bayith, where it means a person free-born as contrasted with a slave. HOMER, hi’mér (WAM, homer): A dry measure containing about 11 bushels. It was equal to 10 ephas. See WricuTs anD MEAsuREs. HOMICIDE, hom’‘i-sid (3X4, rd¢éh): Heb has no word for killing or murder; rd¢éh is the word for manslayer. The Gr for murder is ¢6v0s, phénos. Homicide was every conscious violent action against a human being with the immediate result of death. It was always to be punished by death, being considered a crime against the image of God. Killing is definitely forbidden in the sixth commandment (Gen 9 5f; Ex 20 13; 21 12; Lev 24 17.21; Nu 35 16-21; Dt 19 11-13). The penalty of death was not inflicted when the killing was unintentional or unpremeditated (Ex 21 13; Nu 35 22-25; Josh 20 3-5; cf Mish, Makkaith, xi. 5). Cities of Refuge were founded to which the manslayer could escape from the “avenger of blood.’ There he had to abide till after the death of the officiating high priest. If he left the city hefore that event, the avenger who should kill him was free from punishment (Ex 21 13; Nu 36 10-15. 25-28.32; Dt 19 1-138; Josh 20 2 ff). See Crrms oF Rerucs. Killing a thief who broke in during the night was not accounted murder (Ex 22 2). Unintentional killing of the pregnant woman in a fray was punished according to the lex talionis, i.e. the husband of the woman killed could kill the wife of the man who committed the offence without being punished (Ex 21 227). This was not usually carried out, but it gave the judge a standard by which to fine the offender. If a man failed to build a battlement to his house, and anyone fell over and was killed, blood-guiltiness came upon that man’s house (Dt 22 8). He who killed a thief in the daytime was guilty in the same way (Ex 22 3; cf AV). Where a body was found, but the murderer was unknown, the elders of the city nearest to the place where it was found were ordered by a pre- scribed ceremony to declare that they were not guilty of neglecting their duties, and were therefore innocent of the man’s blood (Dt 21 1-9). Two witnesses were necessary for a conviction of murder (Nu 35 30). If a slave died under chastisement, the master was to be punished according to the principle that “he that smiteth a man, so that he dieth, shall surely be put to death” (Ex 21 20; cf Ex 21 12). According to the rabbis the master was to be killed by the sword. Since in this pas- sage the phrase “he shall die’ is not used, some have supposed that punishment by death is not indicated. If the slave punished by the master died after one or two days, the master was not liable to punishment (Ex 21 21). Because of the words, ‘for he is his money,” the rabbis held that non-Israelitish slaves were meant. In ancient times the avenger of blood was himself to be the executioner of the murderer (Nu 35 19.21). Ac- cording to Sanhedhrin 9 1 the murderer was to be beheaded. Nothing is said in the law about suicide. Paut LEVERTOFF HONEST, on’est, HONESTY, on’es-ti: The word “honest’’ in the NT in AV generally represents the adj. «adds, kalés, “good,’’ “excellent,” ‘“‘hon- orable,”’ and, with the exception of Lk 8 15, “honest and good heart,” is changed in RV into the more correct “honorable’ (Rom 12 17; 2 Cor 8 21; 18 7; Phil 4 8); inl Pet 2 12, into “seem- ly.” In ARV “honestly” in He 13 18 is rendered “honorably,” and in 1 Thess 4 12 (here eusché- ménés) is rendered “becomingly.” The noun “honesty”? occurs but once in AV as the tr of oeu- vorys, semnotés (1 Tim 2 2), and in RV is more appropriately rendered “gravity.” James ORR HONEY, hun’i (W2, debhash; pA, méli): One familiar with life in Pal will recognize in d*bhash the Arab. dibs, which is the usual term for a sweet syrup made by boiling down the juice of grapes, raisins, carob beans, or dates. Dibs is seldom, if ever, used as a name for honey (cf Arab. ’asal), whereas in the OT d‘bhash probably had only that meaning. The honey referred to was in most cases wild honey (Dt 32 18; Jgs 148.9; 18 14 25. 26.29.43), although the offering of honey with the first-fruits would seem to indicate that the bees were also domesticated (2 Ch 31 5). The bees constructed their honeycomb and deposited their honey in holes in the ground (1 8 14 25); under rocks or in crevices between the rocks (Dt 32 13; Ps 81 16). They do the same today. When do- mesticated they are kept in cylindrical basket hives which are plastered on the outside with mud. The Syrian bee is an esp. hardy type and a good honey producer. It is carried to Europe and America for breeding purposes. In OT times, as at. present, honey was rare enough to be considered a luxury (Gen 43 11; 1 K 14 8). Honey was used in baking sweets (Ex 16 31). It was forbidden to be offered with the meal offering (Lev 211), perhaps because it was fermentable, but was presented with the fruit offering (2 Ch 31 5). Honey was offered to David’s army (2 8S 17 29). It was sometimes stored in the fields (Jer 41 8). It was also exchanged as merchandise (Ezk 27.17). In NT times wild honey was an article of food among the lowly (Mt 3 4; Mk 1 6). Figurative: “A land flowing with milk and honey” suggested a land filled with abundance of good things (Ex 3 8.17; Lev 20 24; Nu 183 27; Dt 6 3; Josh 6 6; Jer 11 5; Ezk 206.15). « land of olive trees and honey” had the same mean- ing (Dt 8 8; 2 K 18 32), and similarly “streams of honey and butter” (Job 20 17). Honey was a standard of sweetness (Cant 4 11; Ezk 3 3; Rev 10 9.10). It typified sumptuous fare (Cant 5 1; Isa 7 15.22; Ezk 16 13.19). The ordinances of Jeh were ‘‘sweeter than honey and the droppings of the honeycomb” (Ps 19 10; 119 103). “Thou didst eat... . honey” (Ezk 16 138) expressed Jeh’s goodness to Jerusalem. James A. Patcu HONORABLE, on’ér-a-b’l (333, kabhédh; ed- oxhpov, euschémén): In the OT “honorable” is for the most part the tr of ka@bhédh, properly, “to be heavy,” “weighty” (Gen 34 19, RV “honored”; Nu 22 15; 1896; Isa 35, etc); kabhadh, “weight,” “heaviness,” etc, occurs in Isa 6 13; hodh, “beauty,” “majesty,’’ “honor” (Ps 111 3, RV “honor’’); ’ddhar, ‘to make honorable,” “illus- trious” (Isa 42 21, “magnify the law, and make it honorable,” RVm “make the teaching great and glorious’); yakar, “precious” (Ps 45 9); nasa’ panim, “lifted up of face’ (2 K 5 1; Isa 8 3; 9 15); nse phanim (Job 22 8, RVm “he whose 1419 person is accepted”); euschémén, lit. “well fash- ioned,” is tr! Mk 15 48, AV “honorable,” RV “of honorable estate”; ef Acts 13 50; 17 12; éndozos, “in glory,” occurs 1 Cor 4 10, RV “glory”; timios, “weighty” (He 13 4, RV “had in honor”); déimos, “without weight or honor’ (1 Cor 12 23, “ess honorable’); éntimos, “in honor’ (Lk 14 8), “more honorable.” RV gives for ‘honorable’ (1 § 9 6), “held in honor”; for "Yet shall I be glorious’’ (Isa 49 5), ‘‘I am honor- able’’; ‘“‘honorable”’ for ‘‘honest’’ (Rom 12 17; 2 Cor 13 7; Phil 4 8, m ‘'reverend’’); for ‘‘honestly'’ (He 13_18) ARV has “honorably."’ : In Apoc we have endézés tr4‘‘ honorable" (Tob 12 7, RV ‘‘gloriously’’); endoros (Jth 16 21), timios (Wisd 4 8), dordz6 (Ecclus 24 12, RV ‘‘glorified’’), déza (29 27, RV ‘‘honor"’), etc. : W_ L. Waker HOOD, hééd (MDT, zentphoth): The ladies’ “hoods” of Isa 3 23 AV appear as “turbans’’ RV; and “mitre” of Zee 3 5 is “turban, or diadem’ ERVm. The word is from the vb. zdnaph, “to wrap round.” Jt connotes a head-covering, not a per- manent article of dress. See Drauss, 5; Har. HOOF, hoof. See Cozw; Cioven. HOOK, hook: (1) M30, hakkah, is rendered “Fishhook” in Job 41 1 RV (AV “hook”). RV is correct here and should have used the same tr for the same word in Jsa 19 8; Hab 1 15, instead of retaining AV’s “angle.” Similarly in Am 4 2, May, cinnah, and M17 NINO, stroth daghah, appear to be synonyms for “fishhook,” although the former may mean the barb of a fisher’s spear. In the NT “fishhook”’ occurs in Mt 17 27 (dyxtorpor, dgkis- tron). (2) The “flesh-hook” aera, mazlégh, mT, mizlaghah) of Ex 27 3, etc, was probably a small pitchfork, with two or three tines. (3) The “pruning-hook” (VAT, mazmérah), used in the culture of the vine (Isa 18 5), was a sickle-shaped knife, small enough to be made from the metal of a spear-point (Isa 2 4; Joel 3 10; Mic 4 3). (4) ‘}, waw, is the name given the supports of certain hangings of the tabernacle (Ex 26 32, etc). Their form is entirely obscure. (5) M1, hah, is rendered “hook”? in 2 K 19 28=Isa 37 29; Ezk 29 4; 38 4, and Ezk 19 4.9 RV (AV “chain’”). se) U Fig. 3.—Plan of House. the doorposts. To the present day the post retains its function as commanded in Dt 6 9; 11 20, and in it is fitted a small case containing a parchment on which is written the exhortation to obedience. (5) Hinge (IB, podth, 1K 7 50; WX, gir, Prov 26 14).—Specimens of sill and head sockets of stone have been discovered which suggest the Mune a Wade S —— = Fig. 4.—Elevation of House from Court. use of the pivot hinge, the elongated swinging stile of the door being let into the sockets at top and bottom. A more advanced form of construction was necessary to this type of door than in the pre- vious instance, and some little skill was required to brace it so that it would hold together. The con- struction of doors and windows is an interesting question, as it is in these two details that the joinery THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1436 craft first claimed development. cation, however, of anything of the nature of ad- vancement, and it seems probable that there was r Al none. (6) Lock and key Za (“lock,”? man‘al, Neh 3 3ff; Cant 5 5; “key,” maphiéh, Jgs 3 25; fig. Isa 22 22; Kiels, kleis, Mt 16 19, etc).—In later Hellenic times a sort of primitive lock and key appeared, similar to the Arab. type. See Excava- tions of Gezer, I, 197, and illustration in art. Kuy. ; (7) Threshold (AO , saph, 1 K 14 17; Ezk 40 6ff; {OD’, miphian, 1 8 6 4.5; Ezk 9 3, etc).—Next to the corner-stone, the threshold was specially sacred, and in many instances foundation-sacrifices have been found buried under the threshold. In later times, when the Hebrews became weaned of this unholy practice, the rite remained with the substitution of a lamp inclosed between two bowls as a symbol of the life. See Guzzr. (8) Hearth (MN, ’ah, Jer 36 22.23, RV “brazier’’; “2, kiyyor)—The references in the OT and the frequent discovery of hearths make it clear that so much provision for heating had been made. It is un- likely, however, that chimneys were provided. The smoke from the wood or charcoal fuel was allowed to find its way through the door and windows and the many interstices occurring in workmanship of the worst possible description. The “chimney” referred to (Hos 13 3) is a doubtful tr. The “fire in the brazier’’ (Jer 36 22 RV) which burned before the king of Judah in his ‘winter house” was prob- ably of charcoal. The modern natives, during the cold season, huddle around and warm their hands at a tiny glow in much the same way as their an- cient predecessors. The use of cow and camel dung for baking-oven (annir) fires appears to have continued from the earliest time to the present day (Ezk 4 15). See also Hearra. Pag ey Si Fig. 5.—Window. ss nt Vie a ee Fig. 6.—Living-Room of House. (9) Window (8vpls, thuris, Acts 209; 2 Cor 11 33).—It would appear that windows were often simple openings in the wall which were furnished with some method of closing, such as is suggested . 14387 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA House in Fig. 5, which, it may be conjectured, was some- what the same as the primitive door previously mentioned. The window of the ark (hallan, Gen 8 6), the references in Gen 26 8; Josh 2 15, and the window from which Jezebel looked (2 K 9 30), were presumably of the casement class. Ahaziah fell through a lattice (s°bhakhah) in the same palace, and the same word is used for the “networks” (1 K 7 41) “covering the bowls of the capitals,” and in Cant 2 9, “through the lattice” (hdrakktm). It would appear, therefore, that some variety of treat- ment existed, and that the simple window opening with casement and the opening filled in with a lattice or grill were distinct. Windows were small, and, according to the Mish, were kept not less than the country; see Excavations of Gezer, I, 190; PEFS, Warren’s letters, 46. ‘They let him down through the tiles [«épapos, kéramos] with his couch into the midst before Jesus” (Lk 5 19) refers to the breaking through of a roof similar to this. The roof (“housetop,” gagh; Saye, dima) was an important part of every house and was subjected tomany uses. It was used for worship (2 K 23 12; Jer 19 13; 32 29; Zeph 15; Acts 10 9). Ah- salom spread his tent on the “top of the house” (2 8 16 22). In the Feast of the Tabernacles temporary. booths (sukkah) were erected on the housetops. The people, as is their habit today, . gathered together on the roof as a common meeting- place on high days and holidays (Jgs 16 27). The Mopern ARAB VILLAOE. 6 ft. from floor to sill. The lattice was open, with- out glass filling, and in this connection there is the interesting figurative reference in Isa 54 12 AV, “windows of agates,” tr? in RV “pinnacles of rubies.” Heaven is spoken of as having “‘windows” Cdrubbah) for rain (Gen 7 11; 8 2; 2 K 7 2, etc). (10) Roofs (43, gagh; oréyn, siég2)—These were flat, and their construction is illustrated in Figs. 2 and 6. Cf ‘The beams of our house are cedars, and our rafters are firs’ (Cant 117). To get over the difficulty of the larger spans, a common practice was to introduce a main beam (kurdh) carried on the walls and strengthened by one or more interme- diate posts let into stone sockets laid on the floor. Smaller timbers as joists (“rafters,” rdadhit) were spaced out and covered in turn with brushwood; the final covering, being of mud mixed with chopped straw, was beaten and rolled. A tiny stone roller is found on every modern native roof, and is used to roll the mud into greater solidity every year on the advent of the first rains. Similar rollers have been found among the ancient remains throughout wild wranglings which can be heard in any modern native village, resulting in vile accusations and ex- posure of family secrets hurled from the housetops of the conflicting parties, illustrate the passage, “And what ye have spoken in the ear in the inner chambers shall be proclaimed upon the housetops” (Lk 12 3). (1) Upper chambers and stairs. —It is certain that there were upper chambers (‘dliyah; twepdov, huperbon, Acts 9 37, etc) to some of 2. Houses the houses. Ahaziah was fatally in- of More jured by falling from the window of than One his palace, and a somewhat similar fate befell his mother, Jezebel (2 K 1 2; 9 33). The escape of the spies from the house on the wall at Jericho (Josh 2 15) and that of Paul from Damascus (2 Cor 11 38) give sub- stantial evidence of window openings at a consider- able height. Elijah carried the son of the widow of Zarephath “up into the chamber.”’ The Last Supper was held in an upper chamber (Mk 14 15). Some sort of stairs (ma‘dlah) of stone or wood must have Story Hei THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1438 existed, and the lack of the remains of stone steps | according to its attitude (Mt 10 13). A divided suggests that they were wood steps, probably in the form of ladders. (2) Palaces and castles Carmén, birah, hékhal; athy, aulé, mwapepBodh, parembolé)-—These were part of every city and were more elaborate in plan, raised in all probability to some considerable height. The Can. castle discovered by Macalister at Gezer shows a building of enormously thick walls and smallrooms. Reisner has unearthed Ahab’s palace at Samaria, revealing a plan of considerable area. Solomon’s palace is detailed in 1 K 7 (see TemMPLE). In this class may also be included the megalithic fortified residences with the beehive guard towers of an earlier date, described by Dr. Mackenzie (PE F, I). Walls were plastered (Lev 14 43.48), and small fragments of painted (Jer 22 14) plaster discovered from time to time show that some at- 3. Internal tempt at mural decoration was made, Appear- usually in the form of crudely painted ance line ornament. Walls were recessed here and there into various forms of cupboards (q.v.) at various levels. The smaller cuttings in the wall were probably for lamps, and in the larger and deeper recesses bedmats may have been kept and garments stored. Fig. 6 shows the living-room of an ordinary house, as previously described. fl. Other Meanings.—The word has often the sense of “household,” and this term is frequently substituted in RV for “house” of AV (e.g. Ex 12 3; 2K711; 105; 15 5; Isa 363; 1 Corl 11; 1 Tim 5 14); in certain cases for phrases with ‘house’ RV has “at home’ (Acts 2 46; 5 42). See Houss or Gop; HovusrHo.p. Lireraturs.—Macalister, Excavations at Gezer; PEFS; Sellin, Excavations at Taanach; Schumacher, Excavations at Tell Mutesellim; Bliss, Mound of Many Cities; arts. in Dictionaries and Encyclopaedias. Arcu. C. Dickiz HOUSE, FATHER’S. See Faruer’s House. HOUSE, GARDEN. See Garpren Hovss. HOUSE OF GOD: In Gen 28 17.22=BerTHen (q.v.).. In Jgs, 1 and 2 Ch, Ezr, Neh, Ps, ete (béth ha-élohim), a designation of the sanctuary = “house of Jeh”’ (of the tabernacle, Jgs 18 31; 20 18.26 AV; of the temple, 1 Ch 9 11; 24 5AV; 2 Ch 5 14; Ps 42 4; Isa 2 3, ete; of the 2d temple, Ezr 6 8.15; Neh 6 10; 13 11; cf Mt 12 4). Spiritually, in the NT, the “house of God’ (otkos theots) is the church .or community of believers (1 Tim 3 15; He 10 21; 1 Pet 417; ef 1 Cor 3 9.16.17; 1 Pet 2 5). HOUSEHOLD, hous’héld: Three words are usually found in the Bible where the family is indi- cated. These three are the Heb word bayiih and the Gr words otkia and otkos. The unit of the na- tional life of Israel, from the very beginning, was found in the family. In the old patriarchal days each family was complete within itself, the oldest living sire being the unquestioned head of the whole, possessed of almost arbitrary powers. The house and the household are practically synonymous. God had ealled Abraham “that he might command his children and household after him’’ (Gen 18 19). The Passover-lamb was to be eaten by the “‘house- hold”? (Ex 12 3). The “households” of the rebels in the camp of Israel shared their doom (Nu 16 31- 33; Dt 11 6). David’s household shares his humil- iation (2 8 15 16); the children everywhere in the OT are the bearers of the sins of the fathers. Hu- man life is not a conglomerate of individuals; the family is its center and unit. Nor is it different in the NT. The curse and the blessing of the apostles are to abide on a house, house falls (Mk 3 25). The household believes with the head thereof (Jn 4 53; Acts 16 15.34). Thus the households became the nuclei for the early life of the church, e.g. the house of Prisca and Aquila at Rome (Rom 16 5), of Stephanas (1 Cor 16 15), of Onesiphorus (2 Tim 1 16), etc. No wonder that the early church made so much of the family life. And in the midst of all our modern, rampant individualism, the family is still the throb- bing heart of the church as well as of the nation. Henry E. Doskxer HOUSEHOLD, CAESAR’S. See Cazsar’s HovusEHOoLp. HOUSEHOLDER, hous’hél-dér (olxoSeonérys, otkodespétés): The word occurs in Mt 13 27.52; 20 1; 21 33, for the master or owner of*a_“house- hold,” i.e. of servants (dowiloi). The Gr word emphasizes the authority of the master. HOUSETOP, hous’top. See House. HOW: Represents various Heb and Gr words, interrogative, interjectional and relative. Its dif- ferent uses refer to (1) the manner or way, e.g. Gen 44 34, “How shall I go up to my father?” (ékh); Mt 6 28, “how they grow” (pés); 1 Cor 15 35, “How are the dead raised?’’; (2) degree, extent, frequently, “how great” (Dnl 4 3, mah; Mk 5 19, hésos, “how much”); “how many” .(Mt 27 13, pésos); “how much” (Acts 9 13, hesos); “how much more” (Mt 7 11, posos; 1S 14 30, ’aph kt); “how oft’’ (Ps 78 40, kammah; Mt 18 21, posdkis); “how long’’ (Job 7:19, kammah; Mt 17 17, héds péte), etc; (8) the reason, wherefore, etc (Mt 18 12; Lk 2 49, tis); (4) means—by what means? (Jn 3 4.9, pds); (5) cause (Jn 12 34; Acts 2 8; 4 21, pds); (6) condition, in what state, ete (Lk 23 55, hds; Acts 15 36, pos; Eph 6 21, tis); “how” is sometimes used to empha- size a statement or exclamation (2 S 1 19.25.27, “How are the mighty fallen!’’); “how” is also used for ‘‘that’’ (Gen 30 29, ’éh 'dsher, frequently “how that”; Ex 9 29, ki most frequently, in the NT, ee 12 5; 16 12.21; Acts 7 25; Rom 7 1, ete, in : V has ‘‘wherefore" for ‘‘how'’ (Gen 38 29, m se i 12 6; Joh 22 what" Gg 26), O1 13_5); has ‘‘how that" QS 2 22); ‘that’’ (1 Ch 18 9; Lk 1 58; Gal 4 13: Jas 2 22; Rey’2 2); has “that even’ for “how that’t (He 12 17) "What is this?" for ‘‘How is it that?” (Lk 16 2); omits ‘‘ Howisit?"’ (Mk 2 16, different text): 215! why 9 28; ‘‘when"’ (Joh 37 _ “How” in compounds gives us Howbeit (how be it). It is the tr of ’alam, “but,” “truly,” “yet” (Jgs 18 29); of ’akh, “certainly,” “only” (1°S 8 9); of ’ephes, “‘moreover,’’ ete (28 12 14); of ken, “so,” “thus” (2 Ch 32 31); of rak, “only,” “surely,” “nevertheless” (1K 11 13); of alld “but,” ete (In 7 27; Acts 7 48; 1 Cor 8 7, etc): of dé, “but,” ete Jn 6 23); of méntoi (In 7 13 AV); many other instances. go Ce een but” (2 K 12 13, 19), (Joh 30 24), ‘now’ (J; 1 us Hy “nay, did” (He 3 1a Uy ed ee GE Oor ta 2h), 1439 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Bouse, Father's ber eae eee to ee for aise" qlev 29 21-80) 22 HUMAN SACRIFICE. See Sacririce, Human. 28; 1K 2243; Mk 14 36: “ nevertheless” (Nu 13 : Handing’ Gosh 29 19; Li, 10 20 ERY, “noverthelose™ ARV; Phil 414) for “nay” (Rom 77). Howsoever (in what manner soever, although, however) is the tr of kG? ’dsher, ‘‘all that which,” etc (Zeph 3 7, “howsoever I punished them,” RV “ac- cording to all that J have appointed concerning her,” m “howsoever I have punished her’; ERV omits “have’”); of rak, “only,” “surely,” “never- theless” (Jgs 19 20); of yhi-mah, “et be what” (28°18 22.28, RV “but come what may”); in 2 S 24 3 “how” and “soever” are separated (kahém), “how many soever they may be,’’ lit. “as they and as they.” W. L. WaLxer HOZATI, ho’za-i TN, hézay, or as it stands at the close of the verse in question, 2,Ch 33 19, "TiN, hézdy; LXX rév dépdvrev, tén hordntén; Vulg “Hozai”’ j AV the seers; AVm ‘Hosai’; ARV “Hozai,”” ARVm “the seers.’ LXX not improb- ably reads O° , ha-hdzim, as in ver 18; an easy error, since there we find D°FAT WAT), we-dhibheré ha-hdzim, ‘the words of the seers,’ and here “1 “Tn, dibheré hozay, ‘the words of Hozai.” Kittel, following Budde, conjectures as the original read- ing VT, hdzayw, “his [Manasseh’s] seers”): A his- toriographer of Manasseh, king of Judah. Thought by many of the Jews, incorrectly, to be the prophet Isaiah, who, as we learn from 2 Ch 26 22, was his- toriographer of a preceding king, Uzziah. This “History of Hozai” fee not come down to us. The prayer of Manasseh, mentioned in 33 121.18 f and included in this history, suggested the apocryphal book, ‘The Prayer of Manasses,” written, probably, in the 1st cent. BC. See ApocrypHa. J. Gray McALLIsteR HUCKSTER, huk’stér: A retailer of small wares, provisions, or the like; a peddler. “A huckster shall not be acquitted of sin’’ (Sir 26 29). Neither a merchant nor a huckster is without sin. HUKKOK, huk’ok (Ppl, hukkdk): A town on the border of Naphtali named with Aznoth-tabor (Josh 19 34). It is _ usuall identified with the village of yakuk, which stands on the W. of Wady el--Amid, to the N.W. of Gennesaret, about 4 miles from the sea. This would fall on the boundary of Zebulun and Naphtali, between Tabor and Han- nathon (Josh 19 14). The identification may be correct; but it seems too far from Tabor. HUKOK, hi’kok. See HaixaTs. HUL, hul oan, hil): The name of one of the “sons of Aram” in the list of nations descended from Noah, but a people of uncertain identity and location (Gen 10 23; 1 Ch 1 17). HULDAH, hul’da (ator , huldah, “weasel”; "Oba, Hélda): A prophetess who lived in Jerus during the reign of Josiah. She was the wife of Shallum, keeper of the wardrobe, and resided in the “Mishneh” or second part or quarter of Jerus (lo- cation unknown). Cheyne says it should read, “She was sitting in the upper part of the gate of the Old City,” i.e. in a public central place ready to receive any who wished to inquire of Jeh. He gives no reason for such a change of text. The standing and reputation of Huldah in the city are attested by the fact that she was consulted when the Book of the Law was discovered. The king, high priest, counsellors, etc, appealed to her rather than to Jeremiah, and her word was accepted by all as the word of Jeh (2 K 22 14-20; 2 Ch 34 22-29). J. J. REEVE HUMILIATION, hi-mil-i-a’shun, OF CHRIST (Acts 8 33; Phil 2 8). See Kunosrs; Person or Curist. HUMILITY, hi-mil’i-ti (1939, ‘dndwah; tare- vodpocivn, iapeinophrosiing): (1) The noun occurs in the OT only In Prov 15 33; 18 12; 22 4, but the adj. '‘humble" appears frequentl. as the tr of ‘dnt, ‘dnaw, shaphal, meaning also ‘‘ poor,” ‘afflicted’; the vb., as the tr of ‘dnah, ‘to afflict,”’ ‘‘to humble," and of kana‘, ‘‘to be or become humbled"; cana’, ‘‘to belowly,”’ occurs in Mic 6 8. For ‘‘humble”’ & 912; 10 12) RV bas ‘‘poor’; Ps 10 17; 34 2; 32, ‘‘meek"’; for ‘‘humbled" (Ps 35 13), ‘“aficted"! Usa 2 11; 10 33), “brought low''; for ‘‘He humbleth himself” ce 29) “is brought low,’’ m “bumbleth himself’; Ps 10 10, “‘boweth down"; tapeinophrosune is trd “humility ’’ (Col 2 18.23; 1 Pet § 5); in several other places it is tr4‘‘lowlIness"’ and ‘‘lowliness of mind''; tapeinés is trd ‘‘bumble” (Jas 4 6; 1 Pet 6 5; else- where “lowly,’’ otc; 1 Pet 3 8, tapeinédphrén), RV “bumble-minded""; tapeindé, ‘to humble,"’ occurs fre- quently (Mt 18 4; 23 12, etc); tapetnésis is ‘‘ bumil- iation™ (Acts 8 33); for ‘‘vile body” (Phil 3 21) RV gives ‘‘body of our humiliation.” _ (2) @) Inthe OT as well as in the NT; humility is an essential characteristic of true piety, or of the man who is right with God. God humbles men in order to bring them to Himself (Dt 8 2.3, etc), and it is when men humble themselves before Him that they are accepted (1 K 21 29, 2 Ch 7 14, etc); to “walk humbly with thy God” completes the Di- vine requirements (Mic 6 8). In Ps 18 35 (28 22 36) the quality is ascribed to God Himself, “Thy gentleness [or condescension] hath made me great.’ Of “him that hath his seat on high” it is gaid, ‘“‘[He] humbleth [shaphél] himself to behold the things that are in heaven and in the earth” (Ps 113 6). It is in the humble heart that “the high and lofty One, .. . . whose name is Holy” dwells (Isa 67 15; cf 66 2). (b) The word tapeinophrosuné_is not found in classical Gr (Lightfoot); in the NT (with the ex- ception of 1 Pet 5 5) it is Pauline. In Gr pre- Christian writers tapeines is, with a few exceptions in Plato and Platonic writers, used in a bad or inferior sense—as denoting something evil or un- worthy. The prominence it gained in Christian thought indicates the new conception of man in relation to God, to himself, and to his fellows, which is due to Christianity. It by no means implies slavishness or servility; nor is it inconsistent with a right estimate of oneself, one’s gifts and calling of God, or with proper self-assertion when called for. But the habitual frame of mind of a child of God is that of one who feels not only that he owes all his natural gifts, etc, to God, but that he has been the object of undeserved redeeming love, and who regards himself as being not his own, but God’s in Christ. He cannoé exalt himself, for he knows that he has nothing of himself. The humble mind is thus at the root of all other graces and virtues. Self-exaltation spoils everything. There can be no real love without humility. ‘Love,’ said Paul, “Vaunteth not itself, is not puffed up” (1 Cor 13 4). As Augustine said, humility is first, second and third in Christianity. : (c) Jesus not only strongly impressed His disci- ples with the need of humility, but was in Himself its: supreme example. He described Himself as ‘meek and lowly [tapeines] in heart” (Mt 11 29). The first of the Beatitudes was to “the poor in spirit”? (Mt 5 3), and it was “the meek’? who should “inherit the earth.’ Humility is the way to true greatness: he who should “humble himself as this little child” should be “the greatest in the kingdom of heaven”; “Whosoever shall exalt him- self shall be humbled; and whosoever shall humble himself shall be exalted” (Mt 18 4; 23 12; Lk Humps Hur THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1440 14 11; 18 14). To the humble mind truth is re- vealed (Mt II 25; Lk 10 21). Jesus set a touch- ing example of humility in His washing His disci- ples’ feet (Jn 13 1-17). (d) St. Paul, therefore, makes an earnest appeal to Christians (Phil 2 1-11) that they should cherish and manifest the Spirit of their Lord’s humility— ‘én lowliness of mind each counting other better than himself,” and adduces the supreme example of the self-emptying (kéndsis) of Christ: “Have this mind in you, which was also in Christ Jesus,’’ ete. The rendering of heautén ekéndsen (Phil 2 7 AV) by “he humbled himself’? has given rise to the desig- nation of the Incarnation as ‘‘the Humiliation of Christ.” (e) There is a false humility which Paul warns against, a self-sought, “voluntary humility” (Col 2 18.23). This still exists in many forms, and has to be guarded against. It is not genuine humility when we humble ourselves with the feeling that we are greater than others, but only when we do not think of self at all. It is not alone the sense of sin that should create the humble spirit: Jesus had no sin. It belongs not merely to the creature, but even to a son in relation to God. There may be much self-satisfaction where sinfulness is confessed. We may be proud of our humility. It is necessary also always to beware of ‘‘the pride that apes humility.” W. L. WaLkER HUMPS, humps: Appears in Isa 30 6.in ARV for “bunches” in AV. HUMTAH, hum’ta (TON, humtdh): An un- identified place mentioned between Aphekah and Hebron in the mountain of Judah (Josh 15 54). HUNDRED, hun’dred (TN, mé’ah; tardy, hekatén). See NumpBer. HUNGER, hun’gér (A99, ra‘abh; Aupds, limds (subs.), wewwdw, peindd (vb.): (1) The desire for food, a physiological sensation associated with emptiness of the stomach, and dependent on some state of the mucous membrane; (2) starvation as the effect of want of food, as Ex 16 3; Isa 49 10; (3) to feel the craving for food as Dt 8 3; when used to indicate the condition duc to general scarcity of food as Jer 38 9; Ezk 34 29 it is replaced in RV by “famine.” The word is used to express the poverty which follows idleness and sloth (Prov 19 15). The absence of this condition is given as one of the charactcristics of the future state of happi- ness (Isa 49 10; Ezk 34 29; Rev 7 16). Meta- phorically the passionate striving for moral and spiritual rectitude is called hungering and thirsting after righteousness (Mt 5 6); and the satisfaction of the soul which receives Christ is described as a state in which ‘he shall not hunger” (Jn 6 35). On two occasions it is said of Our Lord that He hungered (Mt 21 18; Lk 4 2); 9 t the old Eng. expression ‘‘an hungred”’ is used, the ‘‘an’”’ being a prefix which indicates that the condition is being continued (Mt 12 1.3; 26 35.37.42.44; Mk 2 25; Lk 6 3 AV). In Mt 42 AV, “an hungred’’ has been changed to “hungered” in RV. “Hard be- stead and hungry” in Isa 8 21 means bested (that is, placed) in a condition of hardship, “sore distressed,’”” ARV. The word occurs in Spenser, “Thus ill bestedd and fearful more of shame’’ (I, i, 24). The reference of the aggravation of the sensation of hunger when one who is starving awakes from a dream of food (Isa 29 8) is graphi- cally illustrated by the expcrience of the antarctic voyager (Shackleton, Heart of the Antarctic, II, 9). ALEX. MAcauisTER HUNTING, hunt’ing (YX, cayidh): The hunting of wild animals for sport, or for the defence of men and flocks, or for food, was common in Western Asia and Egypt, esp. in early times. Some of the Egyp and Assyr kings were great hunters in the first sense, for example Amenhotep III (1411-1375 BC), “a lion-hunting and bull-baiting Pharaoh,” who boasted of having slain 76 bulls in the course of one expedition, and of having killed at one time or other 102 lions; and the Assyrian conqueror, Tiglath-pileser I (¢c 1100 BC), who claimed 4 wil bulls, 14 elephants and 920 lions as the trophies of his skill and courage. The Bib. prototype of these heroes of war and the chase is Nimrod, ‘a mighty hunter before Jeh”’ (Gen 10 9), that is perhaps “a hunter 1, Nimrod who had no equal,” a figure not yet and His clearly identifiable with any historical Like or mythical character in the Assyro- Bab monuments, but possibly the Gilgamesh of the great epic, who may be the hero represented on seals and reliefs as victorious over the lion (Skinner, “Gen,” JCC, 208). We are re- minded also of Samson’s exploit at Timnah (Jgs 14 5 f), but this, like David’s encounter with the lion and the bear (1 S 17 34f) and Benaiah’s struggle with a lion in a pit on a snowy day (2 8 23 20), was an occasional incident and scarcely comes under the category of hunting. There is no evi- dence that hunting for sport was ever practised by the kings of Judah and Israel. Not until the time of Herod the Great, who had a hunting establish- ment and was a great hunter of boars, stags, and wild asses (Jos, BJ, I, xxi, 13), mastering as many as 40 beasts in one day, do we find a ruler of Pal indulging in this pastime. Hunting, however, for the two other purposes mentioned above was probably as frequent among the Israelites, even after they had 2. Hunting ceased to be nomads, as among their in the OT neighbors. We know indeed of only two personal examples, both in the patriarchal period and both outside the direct line of Israelitish descent: Esau (Gen 25 27 ff) and Ishmael (Gen 21 20); but there are several refer- ences and many figurative allusions to the pursuit and its methods and instruments. Hunting (inclu- sive of fowling) is mentioned in the Pent in the regu- lation about pouring out the blood and covering it with dust (Lev 17 13); and there is a general reference in the proverb (Prov 12 27): “The sloth- ful man roasteth not that which he took in hunting.” The hunting of the lion is assumed in Ezekiel’s allegory of the lioness and her two whelps (Ezk 19 1-9; cf Job 10 16); of the antelope or oryx (Dt 14 5; Isa 51 20); of the roe (Prov 6 5); of the pees in the mountains (1 8 26 20), and of irds in general in many passages. Hunting is probably implied in the statement about the pro- vision of harts, gazelles and rocbucks for Solomon’s kitchen (1 K 4 23), and to some extent in the refer- ence to the den of lions in Babylon (Dnl 6 7 ff). The weapons most frequently employed by hunt- ers seem to have been bows and arrows. Isaac (Gen 27 3) commands Esau to take 3. Methods his bow and quiver and procure him of Hunters venison or game (ef also Isa 7 24; Job 41 28). This method is amply illus- trated by the monuments. Ashur-nazir-pal ITI (885- 860 BC) and Darius (¢ 500 BC), for example, are depicted shooting at lions from the chariot. Use was also made of the sword, the spear, the dart or javelin, the sling and the club (Job 41 26.28 , where the application of these weapons to hunting is im- plied). The larger animals were sometimes caught in a pit. The classical reference is in Ezekiel’s allegory, ‘He was taken in their pit’”’ (shahath, Ezk 19 4.8; cf also Isa 24 17f; Jer 48 43f; Ps 36 7, etc). Thedetails of this mode of capture as practised 1441 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Humps Hur at the present day, and probably in ancient times, are described by Tristram in his Natural History of the Bible (118 f). A more elaborate method is de- scribed by Maspero in Lectures historiques (285). Assyrian Lion Hunt. To make the pit-capture more effective, nets werc also employed: “They spread their net over him” (Ezk 19 8; cf Ps 35 7). When caught, the lion was sometimes placed in a large wooden cage (Ezk 19 9, siighar, the Assyr shigdru; for the word and the thing cf SBOT, “zk,” Eng., 132; Heb, 71). The lion (or any other large animal) was led about by a ring or hook (h4&h) inserted in the jaws or nose (2 K 19 28=Isa 37 29; Ezk 19 4.9; 29 4; 38 4). From wild animals the hrutal Assyrians transferred the custom to their human captives, as the Israel- ites were well aware (2 Ch 33 11 RVm, Heb ha; for monumental illustrations ef SBOT, ‘“Ezk,”’ Eng., 132f). Nets were also used for other animals such as the oryx or antelope (Isa 51 20). The Egyp and Assyr monuments show that dogs were employed in hunting in the ancient East, and it is not improbable that they were put to this service by the Hebrews also, but there is no clear Bib. evidence, as “greyhound” in Prov 30 31 is a ques- tionable rendering. Jos indeed (Ani, IV, viu, 9) mentions the hunting dog in a law ascribed to Moses, but the value of the allusion is uncertain. The hunting of birds or fowling is so often referred or alluded to that it must have been very widely practised ef Ps 913; 1247; Prov 1 17; 5; ceel 9 12; Am 8 5, etc). The only bird specifically mentioned is the partridge, said to be hunted on the mountains (1 S 26 20). The method of hunting is sup- posed by Tristram (NHB, 225) to he that still prevalent—continual pursuit until the creature is struck down by sticks thrown along the ground—but the interpretation is uncertain. Birds were generally caught by snares or traps. Two passages are peculiarly instructive on this point: Job 18 8-10, where six words are used for such contrivances, represented respectively by ‘‘net,” ‘‘toils,” ‘‘gin,”’ ‘‘snare,’’ ‘‘noose,’” 4. Fowlers and Their Snares Hunting Deer in an Enclosed Field. “trap’’; and Am 3 5, which is important enough to be cited in full: ‘Can a bird fall in a snare upon the earth, where no gin is set for him? shall a snare spring up from the ground, and have taken nothing at all? The word for ‘‘snare’’ in this passage (pak) probably describes a net laid on the ground, perhaps a circular net like the Egyp bird-trap. represented in the Cam- bridge Bible, ‘‘ Amos,”’ 157. ‘he word for ‘gin,’ usually trd in RV “snare” (makésh, lit. ‘‘fowling instrument’) is supposed to refer either to the bait (ib, 158) or to the catch connected with it which causes the net to collapse (Slegfried). For a full account of Egyp modes of fowl- ing which probably illustrate ancient Palestinian methods, ef Wilkinson, Popular Account, TI, 178-83. The two words (mékésh and pah) mentioned above are used fig- uratively in many OT Passee es the former repeatedly of the deadly influence of Canaanitish idolatry on Israel, as in Ex 23 33, ‘‘For if thou serve their gods, it will surely be a snare unto thee” (cf Ex 34 12; Dt 7 16; Josh 23 13). The use of the hawk in fowllng, which is at- tested for Northern Syria hy a bas-relief found in 1908 at Sakje-Geuzi, is not mentioned in the OT, but there may perhaps he an allusion in Apoc (Bar 3 17, ‘‘they that had their pastime with the fowls of the air’). A reference to the use of decoys has heen found in Jer § 27, ‘‘a cage... . full of birds,’ hut that is a doubtful interpretation, and in the Gr of Sir 11 30, '‘As a decoy partridge in a cage, so is the heart of a proud man,’’ but the Heb text of the latter is less explicit. See Fow er. The NT has a few figurative allusions to hunting. The words for “catch” in Mk 12 13 and Lk 11 54 ; (agreio and théreid) mean lit. “hunt.” 5. Allusions The vb. “ensnare’”’ (pagideiid) occurs in the NT once in the Gospels (Mt 22 15), and d the noun ‘‘snare”’ (pagis) is met with in 5 passages (Lk 21 34; Rom 11 9; 1 Tim 3 73 69; 2 Tim 2 26). Another word_for “snare’ (bréchos), which means lit. “noose’’ (RVm), is used in 1 Cor 7 35. The words for “things that cause stumbling” and “stumble” (skdndalon and skanda- liz6) may possibly conceal in some passages an allu- sion to a hunter's trap or snare, Skandalon is closely allied to skanddléthron, “the stick in_a trap on which the bait is placed,” and is used in LXX for mokésh. The abundant use of imagery taken from hunting in the Bible is remarkable, in view of the comparative rarity of literal references. Lrrerature.—tIn addition to the works cited in the course of the art., the art. “‘Hunting’’ in DB?, HDB large and small, EB, Jew Enc; and ‘‘Jagd"’ in German Bible Dicts. of Guthe, Riehm?, and Wiener, and in RE. Winuam Tayitor Smita HUPHAM, hi’fam (ODN, huphdm, ‘‘coast- inhabitant’): One of Benjamin’s sons and head of the Huphamite family (Nu 26 39). See Huprim. HUPPAH, hup’a ("2M , huppah, “protection”): - The priest in charge of the 13th course as prescribed under David (1 Ch 24 138). HUPPIM, hup’im (O"50, huppim, “coast- people’): Probably a variant form of HupHam (q.v.). From the only mention made of him (Gen 46 21; 1 Ch 7 12.15), his direct descent is difficult to establish. HOUR, hir (0, har): (1) A prominent official in Israel. With Aaron he held up Moses’ hands during the battle against the Amalekites (Ex 17 10.12) and assisted him as judicial head of the people during Moses’ stay in the mount (Ex 24 14). : (2) Grandfather of Bezalel, the head_artificer in the construction of the Tabernacle (Ex 31 2; 35 30; 38 22; 2 Ch15). He is here assigned to the tribe of Judah, and in I Ch is connected with the same by descent through Caleb (2 19.20.50; 4 1.4). - Jos (Ané, III, ii, 4; vi, 1) makes him identi- cal with (1) and the hushand of Miriam. (3) One of the five kings of Midian slain along with Balaam when Israel avenged the “matter of Peor” upon this people (Nu 31 8; cf vs 1.2.16). In Josh 13 21 these kings are spoken of as ‘chiefs [nesv’tm] of Midian” and “princes [n*sikhim] of Sihon,” king of the Amorites. (4) According to I K 4 8 AV, the father of one of Solomon’s twelve officers who provided food for the king’s household, and_ whose district, was the hill country of Ephraim. Here RV has “Ben-hur,” taking the Heh ben, “son of,’’ as part of the proper name; and the same is true in reference to the Hyena THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1442 names of four others of these officers (ef vs 9.10. | own domain his rule was well-nigh absolute. The 11.13). (5) Father of Rephaiah, who was one of the build- ers of the wall under Nehemiah, and ruler of half the district of Jerus (Neh 3 9). Benyamin RENo DowNER HURAI, hori, ho'rai, harat (HN, haray, “Jinen-weaver’): One of David’s “mighty men” mentioned in 1 Ch 11 82 as of the brooks of Gaash, i.e. from Mt. Gaash. In the || 2 S 23 30, the orthography is Hiddai. HURAM, hi’ram (OV, haram, “noble-born”): (1) Grandson of Benjamin (1 Ch 8 5). (2) King of Tyre in alliance with David and Solo- mon. So named in 2 Ch 2 3.11.12; 8 2; 9 10.21, but elsewhere written Hiram (q.v.). (3) The Tyrian artisan who is so named in 2 Ch 2 13; 4 11.16, but elsewhere called “Hiram.” HORI, hi’ri (OM, hart, “linen weaver’): One | of the immediate descendants of Gad, and father of Abihail, a chief man of his family (1 Ch 6 14). HURT, hart: The term (noun and vb.) represents a large number of Heb words, of which the chief are I, ra‘ (vb. IPD, ra‘a‘), “evil” (Gen 26 29; 1S 24.9; Ps 36 4, etc), and TQ or W2W, shébher or shebher (from 20 , shabhar), ‘‘a fracture’ or “‘break~- ing” (Jer 6 14; 8 11.21; 10 19; cf Ex 22 10.14). In Gr a principal vb. is dduéw, adikéd, “to do in- justice’ (Lk 10 19; Rev 2 11; 6 6, etc); once the word “hurt” is used in AV (Acts 27 10, story of Paul’s shipwreck) for #@p:s, hubris, “injury” (thus RV). In RV “hurt” sometimes takes the place of other words in AV, as “sick” (Prov 28 35), “breach” (Isa 30 26), “brnise’ (Jer 80 12; Nah 3 19); sometimes, on the other hand, the word in AV is exchanged in RV for “evil’’ (Josh 24 20), “harm’’ (Acts 18 10), or, as above, “injury” (Acts 27 10). These references sufficiently show the meaning of the word—harm, bruise, breaking, etc. In Jer (ut supra) the word is used figuratively for moral disease or corruption. James ORR HUSBAND, huz’band (W°S, ish; dv4p, anér): In the Heb household the husband and father was the chief personage of an institution which was re- garded as more than a social organism, inasmuch as the family in primitive Sem society had a distinctively religious character and_ significance. It was through it that the cult of the household and tribal deities was practised and perpetuated. The house-father, by virtue of being the family head, was priest of the household, and as such, responsible for the religious life of the family and the maintenance of the family altar. As priest he offered sacrifices to the family gods, as at first, before the centralization of worship, he did to Jeh as the tribal or national Deity. We see this re- flected in the stories of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and in the Book of Job. This goes far to explain such records as we have in Gen $1 53; 82 9, and the exceptional reverence that was paid the paternal sepulchers (1 § 20 6). Abraham was regarded as being the father of a nation. It was customary, it would seem, to assign a “father” to every known tribe and nation (Gen 10). So the family came to play an important and constructive part in Heb thought and life, forming the base upon which the social structure was built, merging gradually into the wider organism of the clan or tribe, and vitally affecting at last the political and religious life of the nation itself. The husband from the first had supreme author- ity over his wife, or wives, and children. In his wife, or wives, looked up to him as their lord (Gen 18 12). He was chief (cf Arab. shétk), and to dis- honor him was a crime to be punished by death (Ex 21 15.17). He was permitted to divorce his wife with little reason, and divorces were all too common (Dt 22 13.19.28.29; Isa 50 1; Jer 3 8; 5 8; Mal 2 16, etc). The wife seems to have had no redress if wronged by him. Absolute faithful- ness, though required of the wife, was apparently not expected or exacted of the husband, so long as he did not violate the rights of. another husband. In general among Eastern people women were lightly esteemed, as in the Japhetic nations they came to be. Plato counted a state “disorganized” “where slaves are disobedient to their masters, and wives are on equality with their husbands.” “Is there a human being,” asks Socrates, “with whom you talk less than with your wife?” But from the first, among the Hebrews the ideal husband trained his household in the way they should go religiously, as well as instructed them in the traditions of the family, the tribe, and the nation (Gen 18 19; Ex 12 26; 13 8; Dt 6 7, etc). It was due to this, in part at least, that, in spite of the discords and evils incident to polygamy, the Heb household was a nursery of virtue and piety to an unusual degree, and became a genuine anticipation of the ideal real- ized later in the Christian home (1 Cor 7 2 ff; Eph 5 25; 1 Pet 3 7). Used figuratively of the relation (1) between Jeh and His people (Isa 54 5; Jer 3 14; Hos 2 19f); (2) between Christ and His church (Mt 9 15; 2 Cor 11 2; Eph 6 25; Rev 19 7; 21 2). Gro. B. Eacer HUSBANDMAN, huz’band-man, HUSBANDRY, huz’band-ri: Husbandman, originally a “house- holder” or ‘‘master of the house,” is now limited in its meaning to “farmer” or “tiller of the soil.” In this sense it is the correct tr of the various Bib. words: MDTN WN, 'tsh ’ddhamah, lit. “man of the soil” (Gen 9 20); "2N, ‘ikkar, lit. “digger,” “a farmer” (2 Ch 26 10; Jer 31 24; 51 23; Am 6 16; Joel 111); D4, gabh, “to dig” (2 K 26 12); 332, ydghabh, “to dig’ (Jer 52 16); yewpyés, georgés, “cultivator” (Mt 21 33 ff; Jn 15 1; Jas 5 7). See AcricuLTuRE. It is a common practice in Pal and Syria today for a rich man to own lands in many different parts of the country. He sets farmers over these differ- ent tracts who, with the helpers, do the plowing, planting, reaping, etc; or he lets out his lands to farmers who pay him an annual rental or return to him a certain percentage of the crop. Much of the plain of Esdraelon, for example, was until recently owned by Beirut proprietors and farmed in this way. The writer while riding on the plain near ancient Dan, was surprised to overtake an acquaint- ance from Beirut (3 days’ journey away), who had just dismounted at one of his farms to inspect it and to receive the annual account of his farmer. The pride with which the husbandman pointed out the abundant harvest will not be forgotten. All the difficulties of the owner with his husbandmen described by Jesus are often repeated today. Figurative: Jesus said “I am the true vine, and my father is the husbandman” (Jn 15 1). Hesows, cultivates, prunes and expects fruits from His church. In the parable of the Householder (Mt 21 33 ff), the wicked husbandmen were the Jews. The church is referred to as “God’s husbandry” in 1 Cor 3 9 (m ‘tilled land’). James A. Patou HUSBAND’S BROTHER (02°, yabham, “brother-in-law”; érvyapBpedw, epigambretis; Late Lat levir): He was required (Dt 25 5-10; Mt 22 1443 24) ‘to perform the duty of a husband’s brother” (yubb°mah); that is, if his brother, living with him on the paternal estate, died without male issue, he should take the widow to wife, and “Taise up seed unto his brother,’’ the firstborn of the new marriage inheriting the deceased brother’s estate. Refusal of the duty was possible, but entailed public ceremo- nial disgrace and lasting reproach. This provision for a specific case modified the general law which forbade the marriage of a sister-in-law (Lev 18 16. 18). It was a patriarchal custom (Gen 38; Judah and Tamar), and 1s alluded to in Ruth 1 11-13. A related custom is found in Ruth 4 1, Boaz playing, however, the part, not of levir (‘‘brother-in-law’’), but of ga‘él (“redeemer’’). It was at least theoreti- cally in force in Our Lord’s time (Mt 22 23-28; the question of the Sadducees concerning the resurrec- tion). For the origin and object of this custom see FaMILy; MarriaGE. Pure, WENDELL CRANNELL HUSHAH, hi’sha (WIN, hishadh, “haste”’): Mentioned in 1 Ch 4 4 as probably an individual, a Judahite, or afamily name; but may possibly be a place. : HUSHAI, hi’shi, hi’shéi CUNT, hushay, Xovoel, Chousei; Jos, Chousi): An Archite, native of Archi or Erech(?), W. of Bethel on the northern border of Benjamin and southern border of Joseph (Josh 16 2). Hushai was one of David’s most faithful and wise counsellors. When David was fleeing from Jerus and Absalom, Hushai met him, having his coat rent and earth on his head. The king persuaded him to return to Jerus, feign submission to Absalom, and try to defeat the counsel of Ahithophel (2 8 15 32f). Whatever Absalom decided on, Hushai was to send word to David through two young men, sons of the priests Zadok and Abiathar (15 34-36). Hushai obeyed, and suc- ceeded in persuading Absalom to adopt his counsel rather than that of Ahithophel (2 8 16 16—17 14). He sent word to David of the nature of Ahithophel’s counsel, and the king made good his escape that night across the Jordan. The result was the suicide of Ahithophel and the ultimate defeat and death of Absalom. J. J. REEVE HUSHAM, hi’sham (DWM, husham, Gen 36 34; DWM, hdusham, 1 Ch 1 45-46, “alert’’): Accord- ing to the former reference, Husham was one of the kings of Edom, and according to the latter he was “of the land of the Temanites” and (1 Ch 1 35 f) descended from Esau. HUSHATHITE, hi'shath-it OMWIN, hishathi, “a dweller in Hushah’’?): The patronymic given in two forms, but probably of the same man, Sib- beccai, one of David’s thirty heroes (2 8 21 18; 1 Ch 11 29; 20 4; 27 11), or Mebunnai as named in the || passage (2 S 23 2’). HUSHIM, hi’shim (OU, DUST, OMAN, hasham, “hasters’’): ; (1) Family name of the children of Dan (Gen 46 23), but of form ‘“Shuham” in Nu 26 42. a (2) The sons of Aher, of the lineage of Benjamin (1 Ch 7 12). ; : : (3) One of the wives of Shaharaim, of the family of Benjamin (1 Ch 8 8.11). HUSHSHATHITE, hush’shath-it (NWN, hush- shatht). Same as Huswarmre (q.v.), except in reduplicated form (1 Ch 27 11; cf 11 29, Heb pronunciation). HUSKS, husks (kepérva, kerdtia, ie. “little homs,” Lk 15 16): These are the pods of the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Hurai Hyena carob tree (RVm), also called the locust tree (Cera- tonia siliqua). This tree flourishes all over Pal, esp. on the western mountain slopes toward the sea; It is dioecious, by the Arabs it is called kharrab. has dense, dark, evergreen foliage, glossy leaves and long, curved pods, like small horns (hence the name). These pods which are from 4 to 9 in. in length, have a leathery case containing a pulpy substance in which the beans are imbedded; this pulp is of a pleasant, sweetish flavor and has a characteristic odor, and is much loved by children. The pods are sold in the markets, both as cattle food and for the poor, who extract by boiling them a sweetish substance like molasses. The tra- dition that the “locusts” of Mt 3 4; Mk 1 6 were carob pods is preserved in the name given to them, “St. John’s bread,” but it has little to be said for it. : E. W. G. MasterMan HUZ, huz (Gen 22 21 AV). See Uz. HUZZAB, huz’ab (AE, huggabh, only in Nah 2 7 AV and RVm): Its meaning isdoubtful. Accord- ing to Gesenius, it is a vb., Hoph. of 332, cabhabh, “flow,” hence to be rendered with preceding ver, “The palace is dissolved and made to flow down.” Wordsworth made it Pual of 222, ndgabh, ‘“fix’’: “The palace is dissolved, though established.” LXX renders with the next word, hé hupdstasis apokaliphth2, ‘‘The foundation [or treasure] is un- covered.” AV, RVm and ARV text make it Hoph. of ndgabh, “fix,” hence ‘It is decreed.”’ Perhaps more probably, with AV and RV text and ARVm, it is a name, or noun with the article (or the cor- ruption of such a word), referring either to the Assyr queen, or personifying Nineveh. No such queen is now known, but Assyriology may throw light. The ‘name’ interpretation accords best with the general trend of the passage, which de- scribes the discomfiture of a royal personage. BDB calls it “perhaps textual error.” The Massoretic vocalization may be at fault. Puitie WENDELL CRANNELL HYACINTH, hi’a-sinth (tékiw80s, hudkinthos): RV uses this word in Rev 9 17 for AV “‘jacinth,” with reference, not to stone, but to dark-purple color. In Rev 21 20, where stone is meant, RV tr# “sapphire.” HYADES, hi’a-déz. HYDASPES, hi-das’péz (Y8dorns, Huddéspés): A river mentioned in Jth 1 6 in connection with the Euphrates and Tigris, but otherwise unknown. It is possible there may be a confusion with the Hydaspes of India. Some have conjectured an identity with the Choaspes. HYENA, hi-é’na (VISR, cabhat* [Jer 12 9}; LXX talvyn, huainé [Jer 129; Ecclus 13 18}; ef Arab. we or A 4, dab‘ or dabu', “hyaena”; ef myx, ¢bho'tm, Zeboim [1 S 13 18; Neh 11 34]; also cf JIWA, gibh‘on, Zibeon [Gen 36 2.14.20; 1 Ch 1 38]; but not OMAR, gebhdyim, Zeboiim [Gen 10 19; 14 2, ete]): EV does not contain the word “hyena,” except in Ecclus 13 18, “What peace is there between the hyena and the dog? and Carob Tree (Ceratonia siliqua). See Astroxoey, II, 4. Hymenaeus Hyssop THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1444 what peace between the rich man and the poor?” In Jer 12 9, where the Heb has ha-‘ayit cabhu' (RV “a speckled bird of prey”), LXX has om#hacov valyys, spélaion huainégs, ‘‘a byena’s den,” as if from a Heb original having m*‘drah, “cave,” instead of ha-‘ayit, “bird.” The root cabha‘ may mean “to selze as prey” (cf Arab. seb‘, “lion” or “rapacious animal’’), or ‘to dip” or “to dye” (cf Arab. sabagh, “to dye’), hence the two tr® of cabhu** as “hyena” and as “‘speckled” (Vulg versicolor). The hyena of Pal is the striped hyena (Hyaena striata) which ranges from India +o North Africa. The striped, the spotted, and the brown hyenas constitute a distinct family of the order of Car- nivora, having certain peculiarities of dentition and having four toes on each foot, instead of four behind and five in front, as in most of the order. The hyena is a nocturnal animal, rarely seen though fairly abundant, powerful but cowardly, a feeder on earrion and addicted to grave-robbing. The last habit in particular has won it the abhorrence of the natives of the countries which it inhabits. In the passage cited in Ecclus, it is to be noted that itis to the hyena that the rich man is compared. The jaws and teeth of the hyena are exceedingly strong and fitted for crushing bones which have resisted the efforts of dogs and jackals. Its dens are in desolate places and are littered with frag- ments of skeletons. “Is my heritage unto me as a speckled bird of prey?” (Jer 12 9) becomes a more striking passage if the LXX is followed, “Is my heritage unto me as a hyena’s den?” Shakk-ud-Dibé‘, “Cleft of the byenas,’”’ is the name of a valley north of Wédi-ul-Keli, and Wédi- Abu-Dibé‘ (of similar meaning) is the name of an affluent of Wédi-ul-Kelt. Either of these, or possi- bly Wédi-ul-K elt itself, may be the valley of Zeboim (valley of hyenas) of 1 S 13 18. The name of Zibeon the Horite (Gen 36 2, etc) is more doubtiully connected with “hyena.” ALFRED Ey Day HYMENAEUS, hi-men-d’us (Ypévacos, Humén- aios, so named from Hymen, the god of marriage, 1 Tim 1 20; 2 Tim 2 17): A heretical teacher in Ephesus, an opponent of the apostle Paul, who in the former reference associates him with Alex- ander (see ALEXANDER), and in the latter, with Philetus (see PHILETUS). It is worthy of notice that in both passages where these persons are mentioned, the name of Hymen- aeus occurs first, showing, perhaps, that 1. His he was the leader. In the passage in Career 1 Tim Hymenaeus is mcluded in the “some’’ who had put away faith and a good conscience and who had made shipwreck concerning faith. The apostle adds that he had delivered Hymenaeus and Alexander unto Satan, that they might learn not to blaspheme. In the passage in 2 Tim, Hymenaeus and Philetus are included among persons whose profane and vain babblings will increase unto more un- 2. His godliness, and whose word “‘will eat Denial of as doth a gangrene.” The apostle the Resur- declares that Hymenaeus and Philetus rection are of the number of such people as those just described, and he adds that those two persons “concerning the truth have erred, saying that the resurrection is past already, and overthrow the faith of some.” Then, for the guidance of Timothy, he goes on to say the seal upon the foundation of God is, “The Lord knoweth them that are his: and, Let every one that nameth the name of the Lord depart from unrighteousness.” The inference intended is, that though Hymenaeus and Philetus had named the name of Christ, they did not depart from iniquity. There is no doubt in regard to the identity of this Hymenaeus with the person of the same name in 1 Tim. Accordingly, the facts mentioned in the two epistles must be placed together, viz. that though he had made a Christian profession by naming the name of Christ, yet he had not departed from iniquity, but by his profane teaching he proceeded unto more ungodli- ness, and that he had put away faith and a good conscience and had made shipwreck of faith. The error, therefore, of Hymenaeus and his two companions would amount to this: They taught that “the resurrection is past already,” that there shall be no bodily resurrection at all, but that all that resurrection means is that the soul awakes from sin. This awakening from sin had already taken place with themselves, so they held, and therefore there could be no day in the future when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God and shall come forth from the grave (Jn 6 28). This teaching of Hymenaeus had been so far success- ful: it had ‘‘overthrown the faith of some’’ (2 Tim 2 18). It is impossible to define exactly 3. Incipient the full nature of this heresy, but’ what . ve Paul says regarding it makes it evident Gnosticism that it was a form of incipient Gnosticism. This spiritualizing of the resurrection sprang from the idea of the necessarily evil nature of all material substance. This idea immediately led to the conclusion of the essentially evil nature of the human body, and that if man is to rise to his true nature, he must rid himself of the thraldom, not of sin, but of the body. This contempt for the body led to the denial of the resurrection in its literal sense; and all that Christ had taught on the subject was explained only, in an al- legorical sense, of the resurrection of the soul from sin. Teaching of this kind is described by Paul as having effects similar to the ‘‘eating’’ caused by a gangrene. It is deadly; it overthrows Christian faith. 4. Over- It not destroyed, it would corrupt the throws community, for if there is no literal resur- _ rection of the dead, then, as Paul shows Faith in 1 Cor 15, Christ is not_raised; and if 4 the literal resurrection of Christ is denied, Christian believers are yet in their sins, and the Christian religion is false. The way in which the apostle dealt with these teachers, Hymenaeus and his companions, was not merely in the renewed assertion of 5. Deliv- the truth which they denied, but also ered unto by passing sentence upon these teach- Satan ers—“whom I delivered unto Satan, that they might be taught not to blaspheme.’”’ In regard to the meaning of this sentence much difficulty of interpretation exists. Some understand it to mean simple excommunica- tion from the church. But this seems quite inade- quate to exhaust the meaning of the words employed by Paul. Others take it to signify the infliction of some bodily suffering or disease. This also is quite insufficient as an explanation. It seems that a person who was delivered unto Satan was cut off from all Christian privileges, he was “put away’’ from the body of Christian believers, and handed over to “the Satan,” the Evil One in his most distinct personality (1 Cor 6 2.5.13). Cf the cases of Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 5), and of Elymas (Acts 13 11). It is important that the purpose of this terrible sentence should not be overlooked. The intention of the punishment was distinctly remedial. Both in the case of Hymenaeus and Alexander, and in that of the person dealt with in 1 Cor 5, the intention was the attaining of an ultimate good. In 1 Cor it is “for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.” Similarly, Hymenaeus and Alexander are delivered unto Satan, not for their final perdition, but that they may be taught, through this terrible discipline—for such is the signification of the word which is tr’ “taught’”’—not to blaspheme. The purpose of this discipline, that they might learn not to blaspheme, shows the dreadful length of 1445 Hymenaeus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA impiety and of railing at Christian truth to which Hymenaeus had gone. In the history of Hymenaeus and his companions, and in their bold and anti-Christian teaching which had over- thrown the faith of some, we cannot fail 6. Th to see the fulfilment of what Paul had said “ € - many years previously, in his farewell ad- Perverse dress to the elders of the church in Ephe- Things” at sus: “T know that after my departing Ephesus grievous wolves shall enter in among you, p not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away the disciples after them” (Acts 20 29f). It was in the Ephesian church that Hymenaeus and Alexander and Philetus had arisen. The gangrene-like nature of their teaching has already been. described. JoHN RUTHERFURD HYMN, him (ipvos, hiimnos): In Col 3 16; Eph 5 19 St. Paul bids his readers sing ‘psalms and hymns and spiritual songs.’ Gregory of Nyssa (4th cent.) distinguishes these as follows: the Pss were accompanied by instruments, the hymns were mainly vocal, and the song, ode, was a general term comprehending both. This distinction might suggest that the psalm belonged especially to the public worship of the church, while the hymn was the production, more or less spontaneous, of the individual member. The inference is, however, inconsistent with 1 Cor 14 26, and it is probable that in the apostolic age, at least, the terms were used indiscriminately. Of Christian psalms or hymns we have examples in the NT. Lk 1 and 2 contain such hymns in the songs of Mary, Zacha- rias and Simeon. The Apocalypse is studded with hymns or odes, many of them quite general in character, and probably borrowed or adapted from Jewish books ok: praise. In the Epp. of Paul, esp. the later ones, fragments of hymns seem to be quoted. Lightfoot detects one in Eph 6 14, and others readily suggest themselves. It is probable that the hymn mentioned as having heen sung by Jesus and the disciples after the Passover (Mt 26 30; Mk 14 26) was the second part of the Hallel, i.e. Pss 115-18, and the hymns of Paul and Silas were most likely also taken from the Psalter. But the practice of interpolating and altering Jewish non-canonical books, like the Psalter of Solomon and the recently discovered Odes of Solomon, shows that the early Christians adopted for devotional purposes the rich store of sacred poetry possessed by their nation. For the music to which these psalms, etc, were sung, see Music; Sona. James MILLAR HYPOCRISY, hi-pok’ri-si, HYPOCRITE, hip’é- krit (3M, héneph, 239, hanéph; vwénpiots, hupd- krisis, broxpirfs, hupokrités) : ; (1) “Hypocrisy” occurs only once in the OT as the tr of héneph (Isa 32 6, RV “‘profaneness’’); hanéph, from which it is derived, means properly “to cover,” ‘to hide,” or “becloud,”’ hence to pol- lute, to be polluted or defiled, to make profane, to seduce; as a subst. it is trd “hypocrite” (Job 813; 18 16; 16 34; 17 8; 20 5; 27 8; 34 30; 36 13, in all which’ instances RV has “godless man,” “godless men,” “godless”; Prov 11 9, RV “the godless man”; Isa 917, RV “profane”; Isa 83 14, RV “the godless ones’’); it is rendered “hypocritical,” in’ Ps 35 16; Isa 10 6, RV “pro- fane.” ; : (2) “Hypocrisy,” “hypocrite” are frequent in the NT; chiefly in Christ’s discourses in the Gos- pels. The word hupokrisis (primarily, “an answer,” ‘response’’) meant generally, in classical Gr, stage- playing, acting, the histrionic art; hence it came to mean acting a part in life, ete. We find hupokrisis in this sense in 2 Mace 6 25, RV “dissimulation,”’ and hupokrinomai, ‘‘to pretend,” “to feign,” etc. Ecclus 1 29; 32 15; 38 2, tr4 “hypocrite”; 2 Mace Hyssop 5 25, “pretending peace,” RV “playing the man of peace’; 6 21, RV “to make as if.” Hupokrités (lit. “an actor”) is the LXX for hanéph (Job 34 30; 36 13), equivalent to bad, wicked, godless, which is perhaps included in some of Our Lord’s uses of the words, e.g. Mt 23 27f, “full of hypoc- risy and iniquity” (cf vs 29f; 24 51); but, in general, the meaning is acting a part, false, de- ceptive and deceived, formally and outwardly religious and good, but inwardly insincere and unrighteous; the hypocrite may come to deceive himself as well as others, but ‘‘the hypocrite’s hope shall perish” (Job 8 13 AV). On no class did Our Lord pronounce such severe condemnation as on the hypocrites of His day. “Fypocrisy’’ (hupokrisis) occurs in Mt 23 28; Mk 12 15; Lk 12 1; 1 Tim 4 2; 1 Pet 2 1 (in Gal 2 13 it is rendered ‘'dissimulation"’); krités), Mt 6 2.5.16; 75; 15 7; 22 2511.29; 24 51, Mk 7.6; Lk 12 56; 3.17, anupékritos is ‘‘ without hypocrisy,’’ so RV, Rom 129 (‘unfeigned,” 2 Cor 6 6; 1 Tim 15; 2 Tim 1 5; 1 Pet 1 22). W. L. Waker HYRCANUS, hér-ka’nus (Ypkavés, Hurkanés): ‘Son of Tobias, a man of great dignity,’’ who had a large sum of money deposited in the Temple of Jerus when Heliodorus was sent to confiscate it in 187 BC (2 Mace 3 11 ff). Opinions differ as to the identity of this H. with the grandson of Tobias whose birth and history are related at considerable length by Jos (Ant, XII, iv, 6 ff), or with another of the same name mentioned in Ant, XIII, viii, 4. See AsMONEANS; MaccaBagts. HYSSOP, his’up (AMIR, ’@0bh; tooomos, his- sGpos, Ex 12 22; Lev 14 4.6.49ff; Nu 19 6.18; 1K 4 33; Ps 517; Jn 1929; He 919): A plant used fom,ritual cleansing purposes; a humble plant springia® out of the wall (1 K 4 38), the extreme conmt#st to the cedar. ‘hypocrite’ Caper (Capparis spinosa). The common hyssop (Hyssopus officinalis) of the N.O. Labiatae, an aromatic plant with stomatic properties, cannot be the hyssop of the Bible as it is unknown in Pal, but allied aromatic plants of the same N.O. have by Maimonides (Neg. xiv.6) and other Jewish writers been identified with it. Prob- ably hyssop is identical with the Arab. zat‘ar, a name applied to a group of aromatic plants of the genus marjoram and thyme. They would any of them furnish a bunch suitable for sprinkling, and they have the important recommendation that they I,I Am Idolatry 1446 grow everywhere, being found even in the desert. Post thinks of all varieties the Origanum maru, a special variety of marjoram which favors terrace walls and rocks, is the most probable. The proposal (Royle, Jour. Royal Asiatic Soc., VII, 193-213) to identify the caper (Capparis spinosa) with hyssop, which has been popularized by the works of Tristram, has not much to recom- mend it. It is true that the caper is very com- monly seen growing out of walls all over Pal (1 K 4 33), but in no other respect is it suitable to the requirements of the Bib. references. The supposed similarity between the Arab. ’asaf (‘‘caper’’) and the Heb ’éz0bh is fanciful; the caper with its stiff, prickly stems and smooth, flat leaves would not furnish a bunch for sprinkling as serviceable as I, 1 AM, 1 AM THAT IAM. See Gon, Names OF. I WILL BE. Sce Gop, NaMEs oF. IACIMUS, i-as’i-mus. IACUBUS, i-ak’fi-bus (IaxotBos, Jakotibos; 1 Esd ' 9 48): “Akkub” in Neh 8 7. IADINUS, i-ad’i-nus (Ié8evos, Iddeinos; 1 Esd 9 48, AV Adinus): Same as Jamin of Neh 8 7. IBHAR, ib’har (2°, yibhhar, “He [God] chooses’; in S, B, "EBedp, Ebedr, in Ch, B, Badp, Badr, A, "IeBaép, Jebadr): Oue of David’s sons, born at Jerus; son of a wife and not of a concubine (4 Ch 8 6; 28S 5 15); otherwise unknown. His name in all three lists follows Solomon’s. In Peshitta’, ‘“Juchabar.” IBIS, i’bis. In Isa 34 11, yanshdph, which is rendered “‘owl,’? apparently indicates the sacred ibis (bis religiosa). The LXX gives efbis and Vulg ibis; RVm “bittern.”? See Ow1. IBLEAM, ib’lé-am (D993, yibhi‘am); A town in the territory of Issachar which was assigned to Manasseh (Josh 17 11). This tribe, however, failed to expel the inhabitants, so the Canaanites continued to dwell in that land (Jgs 1 27). It was on the route by which Ahaziah fled from Jehu. He was overtaken and mortally wounded ‘“‘at the ascent of Gur, which is by Ibleam’”’ (2 K 9 27). The name appears as Bileam in 1 Ch 6 70; and it probably corresponds to Belmen of Jth.. It is now represented by the ruin of Bel‘ameh on the W. of the valley through which the road to the south runs, about half a mile from Jenin. In 2 K 15 10, where it is said that Zechariah the son of Jero- boam was slain by Shallum “before the people,” this last phrase, which is awkward in the Heb, should be amended to read “in Bileam.” Possibly “Gath-rimmon” in Josh 21 25 is a clerical error for ‘Tbleam.”’ W. Ewine IBNEIAH, ib-né'ya (T2227, yibhneyah, “Jeh buildeth up”): A Benjamite, son of Jeroham (1 Ch 9 8). IBNIJAG, ib-ni'ja (ID, yibhniyah, or 124, yibhntyah, ‘“Jeh buildeth up’): A Benjamite, father of Reuel (1 Ch 9 8). IBRI, ib’ri (IAD, ‘ibhri, ‘a Hebrew’): A Merarite Levite, son of Jaaziah (1 Ch 24 27). See ALCIMUS. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA many species of zat‘dr. It has been specially urged that the byssop suits the conditions of Jn 19 29, it being maintained that a stem of caper would make a good object on which to raise the “sponge full of vinegar” to the Saviour’s face, the equivalent of the “reed” of Mt 27 48; Mk 16 36. For such a purpose the flexible, prickly stems of the hyssop would be most unsuitable; indeed, it would be no easy matter to find one of sufficient length. It is necessary to suppose either that a bunch of hyssop accompanied the sponge with the vinegar upon the reed, or, as has been proposed by several writers (for references see art. “Hyssop,” HB), that hussépé is a corruption of hussé, “javelin,” and that the passage should read “They put a sponge full of vinegar upon a javelin.” E. W. G. MasTeRMAN IBSAM, ib’sam (Pa, yibhsam, “fragrant,” AV Jibsam): Descendant of Issachar, family of Tolah (1 Ch 7 2). IBZAN, ib’zau (j¥3N, ’ibhcdn): The 10th judge of Israel. His city is given as Bethlehem (whether of Judah or Zebulun is not stated). He judged Israel 7 years, and when he died he was buried in his native place. The only personal details given about him in the Bib. narrative are that he had 30 sons and a like number of daughters. He sent all of his sons ‘“‘abroad’’ for wives and brought hus- bands from “abroad” for all his daughters. The exact meaning of ha-hig¢, “abroad,” is mere matter of speculation, but the great social importance of the man and, possibly, alliances among tribes, are suggested in the brief uarrative (Jgs 12 8-10). Jewish tradition identifies Ibzan with Boaz of Bethlehem-Judah (Talm, Babha’, Bathra’, 91a). Exza Davis Isaacs ICE, is (22, kerah): Ice is almost unknown in Pal and Syria except on the highest mountains. At moderate heights of less than 4,000 ft. a little ice may form during the night in winter, but the warm rays of the sun melt it the next day. A great quan- tity of snow is packed away iu caves in the moun- tains during the winter, and is thus preserved for use in the summer months. The word is fouud in the Bible in three places where it describes God’s power. ‘Out of whose womb came the ice? Aud the... . frost” (Job 38 29); ‘By the breath of God ice is given” (37 10); ‘He casteth forth his ice like morsels” (Ps 147 17). Figurative: Untrue friends are compared to streams ‘‘which are black by reason of the ice” (Job 6 16). ALFRED H. Joy ICHABOD, ik’a-bod, i’ka-bod (TI3D7°N, '7-kha- bhédh, “inglorious”; B, otal BapyaBde, ouai bar- chabéth, A, otal xaBs0, ouat chabsth, “Aripos, Atimos): Son of Phinehas, Eli’s son, slain at the battle of Aphek when the ark was takeu. Ichabod was born after his father’s death. His mother gave him this name on her death-bed to iudicate that the ‘glory [had] departed from Israel’ (1 8 4 19 ff). He was thus important as a symbol, though little is recorded of him as an individual. His nephew Ahijah was one of those who tarried with Saul and the six hundred at Gibeah just before Jonathan’s brave attack upon the Philis (1 S 14 2f). Henry WaLLAcE ICONIUM, i-k6’ni-um (‘Ikévev, Ikénion, also El«éviov, Eikénion, on inscriptions): Iconium was visited by St. Paul on his first and on his second missionary Journey (Acts 13 51 ff; 16 2ff), and 1447 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA I,T Am Idolatry if the “South Galatian theory” be correct, probably also on his third journey. His sufferings there are referred to in 2 Tim 3 11. The topographical position of Iconium is elearly ‘indicated in Acts, and the evidence of Acts has been confirmed by reeent research. Was 1. Topo- Iconium in Phrygia or in Lycaonia, graphical and in what sense can it be said to have Position belonged to one ethnical division or the other? The majority of our ancient authorities (e.g. Cicero, Strabo, Pliny), writing from the point of view of Rom provincial adminis- tration, give lconium to Lycaonia, of which geog- raphy makes it the natural capital. But Xenophon, who marehed with Cyrus’ expedition through Phry- gia into Lycaonia, calls Iconium the last city of Phrygia. The writer of Acts 14 6 makes the same statement when he represents St. Paul and St. Barnabas as fleeing from Iconium to the eities of Lycaonia—implying that the border of Phrygia and Lycaonia passed between Iconium and Lystra, 18 miles to the 8. Other ancient authorities who knew the loeal eonditions well speak of Iconium as Phrygian until far into the Rom imperial period. At the neighboring city of Lystra (Acts 14 11), the natives used:the “speech of Lyeaonia.’”’ Two in- seriptions in the Phrygian language found at Ieonium in 1910 prove that the Phrygian language was in use there for 2 centuries after St. Paul’s visits, and afford confirmation of the interesting topographical detail in Aets (see Jour. Hell. Stud., 1911, 189). In the apostolic period, Iconium was one of the chief cities in the southern part of the Rom province Galatia, and it probably belonged to 2. In Apos- the “Phrygian region’? mentioned in tolic Acts 16 6. The emperor Claudius Period conferred on it the title Claudiconium, which appears on coins of the city and on inseriptions, and was formerly taken as a proof that Claudius raised the city to the rank of a Rom colonia. It was Hadrian who raised the city to eolonial rank; this is proved by its new title, Co- lonia Aelia Hadriana Iconiensitum, and by a re- eently discovered inscription, whieh belongs to the reign of Hadrian, and which mentions the first duumvir who was appointed in the new colonia. Ieonium was still a Hellenic city, but with a stron pro-Rom bias (as proved by its title ‘“Claudian” when St. Paul visited it. About 295 AD, an enlarged province, Pisidia, was formed, with Antioch as capital, and Ieonium as a “sort of secondary metropolis.” The Byzantine arrangement, familiar to us in the Notitiae Episcopatuum, under which Iconium was the capital of a province Lycaonia, dates from about 372 AD. Iconium, the modern Konia, has always been the main trading center of the Lycaonian Plain. Trade attracted Jews to the ancient Phrygio-Hellenie city (Acts 14 1), as it attracts Greeks and Armenians to the modern Turkish town. St. Paul’s experiences at Iconium 4. St. form part of the theme of the semi- Thekla historical legend of St. Thekla, on which see Professor Ramsay’s Church in the Roman Empire, 380 ff. LiteratuRe.—Ramsay, Hist. Comm. on Paul's Ep, to the Gal, 214 ff; Cities of St. Paul, 317 ff. To the lit. referred to in the notes to the iatter book (pp. 448 ff) add Ath, Mitth., 1905, 324 ff; Revue de Philologie, 1912, 48 ff; Jour. Hellenic Studies, 1911, 188 ff. W. M. Caper IDALAH, id’a-la, i-da‘la ENT, yidh'dlah): A town in the territory of Zebulun, named with Shimron and Beth-lehem (Josh 19 15). The Talm identifies it with Huryzh (Talm Jerus on M¢gh., I, 1). This, Conder thinks, may be represented by the modern Khirbet el-Huwara to the S.of Beit Lahm. 3. Later History IDBASH, id’bash (W2", yidhbash, “honey- sweet”’[?]): A man of Judah, one of the sons of the father of Etam (1 Ch 4 3; LXX “sons of Etam”). IDDO, id’é: (1) (VAR, “ddd [? TTS , ’adhadh, “to be strong”), “hap,” “happy” [?], Ezr 817): The ‘chief at the place Casiphia,” who provided Ezra with Levites and Nethinim, the head of the Levitical body or school, said to be one of the Nethinim or temple slaves, but perhaps an “and’”’ has slipped out, and it should read: “his brethren and the Nethinim.” 1 Esd 8 4546 has ‘Loddeus [AV “Saddeus”], the captain who was in the place of the treasury,’’ kegeph meaning silver. LXX has ‘fn the place of the silver [év dpyuply rob rérov, en argurt6 tot, tépou] . . . . to his brethren and to the treasurers.” (2) (1, yiddd, “beloved,” or “loving,” 1 Ch 27 21): Son of Zechariah, and captain of the half- tribe of Manasseh in Gilead, under David. (3) (1, yiddo, “beloved,” or “loving,” Ezr 10 43): One of those who had taken foreign wives. Another reading is Jaddai, AV “Jadan.”’ In 1 Esd 9 35 ‘“Edos” (AV “Tdes”’). (4) (NY, ‘idda’, ‘timely,’ 1 K 4 14): Father of Abinadab, Solomon’s commissary in Mahanaim in Gilead. (5) (1, yidds, “beloved,” or “loving,” 1 Ch 6 21): A Gershomite Levite, son of Joah, ealled Adaiah in ver 41; aneestor of Asaph. . (6) (VIZ), ye'dd [Kethibh 197, ye'di], or 9, ‘iddd, “deeked,”’ ‘“adorned’’): Seer (hdzeh) and prophet (ndbht), the Chronicler’s ‘“‘source” for the reign of Solomon (2 Ch 9 29): ‘The visions of Iddo the seer concerning Jeroboam the son of Ne- bat’’; and for the reign of Rehoboam (2 Ch 12 15); “The histories of Iddo [T59 , ‘tdd6] the seer, after the manner of for, ‘in reckoning’’] genealogies”; and for the reign of Abijah (2 Ch 13 22): ‘The commen- tary [midhrash] of the prophet Iddo” (179, ‘iddé). He may have been the prophet who denounced Jeroboam (1 K 13), who is called by Jos and Jerome Jadon, or Jaddo. Jerome makes Iddo and Oded the same. (7) (VIF, ‘iddd, “timely,” Zee 11): Grand- father (father, aceording to Ezra) of the prophet. Zechariah. See also Zec 1 7; Ezr 61; 6 14 (NVIY, dda’). In 1 Esd 6 1, “Addo.” (8) (RITY, ‘idds', “decked,” “adorned,” Neh 12 4.16): A priest who went up with Zerubbabel (ver 4); one of the priestly clans which went up (ver 16); perhaps same as (7) Partie WENDELL CRANNELL IDLE, i’d’l, IDLENESS, i’d’l-nes: Both words, adj. and noun, render different Heb words (from SBD, ‘acél, “to be lazy,” M27, raphah, “to relax,” and UpwW, shakat, “to be quiet’). According to the Yahwistic narrative Pharaoh’s retort to the com- plaints of the Israelites was a charge of indolence (Ex 6 8.17). It was a favorite thought of Heb wisdom—practical philosophy of life—that indo- lence inevitably led to poverty and want (Prov 19 15; Eccl 10 18). The “virtuous woman” was one who would not eat the “bread of idleness’ (Prov $1 27). In Ezk 16 49 for AV “abundance of idleness’? RV has “prosperous ease.” In the NT “idle” generally renders the Gr word dpyés, argés, \it. “inactive,” “useless” (Mt 20 3.6). In Lk 24 11 “idle talk” corresponds to one Gr word which means “empty gossip” or “‘nonsensical talk.” eae T. Lewis IDOLATRY, i-dol’a-tri (D2, teraphim, “house- hold idols,” ‘idolatry’; ¢l8wAcdarpela, eiddlola- Idolatry Tiyricum THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1448 treia): There is ever in the human mind a craving for visible forms to express religious conceptions, and this tendency does not disappear with the acceptance, or even with the constant recognition, of pure spiritual truths (see Imaczs). Idolatry originally meant the worship of idols, or the wor- ship of false gods by means of idols, but came to mean among the OT Hebrews any worship of false gods, whether by images or otherwise, and finally the worship of Jeh through visible symbols (Hos 8 5.6; 10 5); and ultimately in the NT idolatry came to mean, not only the giving to any creature or human creation the honor or devotion which be- longed to God alone, but the giving to any human desire a precedence over God’s will (1 Cor 10 14; Gal 5 20; Col 3 5; 1 Pet 4 3). The neighboring gods of Phoenicia, Canaan, Moab—Baal, Melkart, Astarte, Chemosh, Moloch, etc—were particularly attractive to Jerus, while the old Sem calf-worship seriously affected the state religion of the Northern Kingdom (see GoLDEN CaF). Asearly asthe Assyr and Bab periods (8th and 7th cents. BC), various deities from the Tigris and Euphrates had intruded themselves—the worship of Tammuz becoming a little later the most popular and seductive of all (Ezk 8 14)—while the worship of the sun, moon, stars and signs of the Zodiac became so intensely fascinating that these were introduced even into the temple itself (2K 1716; 21 3-7; 28 4.12; Jer 19 18; Ezk 8 16; Am 5 26). The special enticements to idolatry as offered by these various cults were found in their deification of natural forces and their appeal to primitive human desires, esp. the sexual; also through associations produced by intermarriage and through the appeal to patriotism, when the help of some cruel deity was sought in time of war. Baal and Astarte wor- ship, which was esp. attractive, was closely asso- ciated with fornication and drunkenness (Am 2 7.8; cf 1 K 14 23 f), and also appealed greatly to magic and soothsaying (e.g. Isa 2 6; 3 2; 8 19). Sacrifices to the idols were offered by fire (Hos 4 13); libations were poured out (Isa 57 6; Jer 7 18); the first-fruits of the earth and tithes were pre- sented (Hos 2 8); tables of food were set before them (Isa 65 11); the worshippers kissed the idols or threw them kisses (1 K 19 18; Hos 13 2; Job 31 27); stretched out their hands in_ adoration (Isa 44 20); knelt or prostrated themselves before them and sometimes danced about the altar, gash- ing themselves with knives (1 K 18 26.28; for a fuller summary see HB). Even earlier than the Bab exile the Heb prophets taught that Jeh was not only superior to all other gods, but reigned alone as God, other deities being nonentities (Lev 19 4; Isa 2 8.18.20; 19 1.3; 31 7; 44 9-20). The severe satire of this period proves that the former fear of living demons supposed to inhabit the idols had disappeared. These prophets also taught that the temple, ark and sacrifices were not essential to true spiritual worship (e.g. Jer 3 16; Am § 21-25). These prophecies produced a strong reaction against the previously popular idol- worship, though later indications of this worship are not infrequent (Ezk 14 1-8; Isa 42 17). The Maccabean epoch placed national heroism plainly on the side of the one God, Jeh; and_although Gr and Egyp idols were worshipped in Gaza and As- calon and other half-heathen communities clear down to the 5th or 6th cent. of the Christian era, yet in orthodox centers like Jerus these were despised and repudiated utterly from the 2d cent. BC on- ward. See also Gorpen Car; Gops; ImacEs; ‘TERAPHIM. Lirerature.—Wm. Wake, A_ Discourse concerning the Nature of Idolatry, 1688; W. R. Smith, Lectures on the Religion of the Semites; EB. B. Tylor, Prim. Culture; J. G. Frazer, Golden Bough (3 vols); L. R. Farnell, Evolution of Religion, 1905; Baudissin, Studien zur semitischen Reh- gionsgeschichte; Baethgen, Der Gott Israels u. die Gdtter der Heiden, 1888. CampEen M. Cosern IDUEL, id’ii-el (I8ovqAos, Idouélos): 1 Esd 8 43, EVm “Arrey” (q.v.). IDUMAEA, id-t-mé’a, IDUMAEANS, id-t-mé’- anz. See Epo. IEDDIAS, yed-i/as, i-ed-i’as, AV Eddias (*1c58las, Ieddias): One who agreed to put away his foreign wife (1 Esd 9 26); called also ‘Jezeias.” IEZER, i-é’zér, IEZERITES, 1-2’zér-its CIS", ‘Tezer, Nu 26 30): Contracted from ABIE2zER (Josh 17 2, etc) (q.v.). IGAL, i’gal GR, yigh’al, “he [God] redeems”; LXX variously "Iya, Igdl, Tadd, Gadl, Iwhd, Lael): (1) One of the twelve spies sent by Moses from the wilderness of Paran; son of Joseph, tribe of Issa- char (Nu 18 7). (2) One of David’s heroes, son of Nathan of Zohah (2 § 23 36). In 1 Ch 11 38 he is “Joel [AN1T, yo°al], the brother of Nathan.” (3) Son of Shemaiah of the royal house of David, descendant of Zerubbabel (1 Ch 3 22, AV “‘Igeal’”). IGDALIAH, ig-da-li’a (WDIDM, yighdalyaha, “Jeh is great’’): Ancestor of certain persons who had a “chamber” in the temple in Jeremiah’s time (Jer 35 4). IGEAL, i’gé-al, 1'jé-al GOR, yigh’al, “he [i.e. God] redeems’’): A remote descendant of David (1 Ch 3 22, RV “Igal’’). IGNORANCE, ig’né-rans (M330, sheghdghah; &yvoa, dgnota): “Ignorance” is the tr of sh*gha- ghah, “wandering,” ‘going astray’ (Lev 4 2, etc “Sf a soul sin through ignorance,” RV“unwittingly,’ m ‘through error’; 5 15; Nu 15 24 ff; cf 35 11; Josh 20 3 ff; Eccl 5 6; 10 5, “an error”). In the Law sh*ghaghadh means “innocent error,’’ such as had to be taken with consideration in judgment (see passages referred to). “Ignorance’’ is also expressed hy the negative lo’ with yadha‘, “‘to know’ (Isa 56 10; 63 16; Ps 73 22); also by bi-bhelt da‘ath, lit. “in want of knowledge” (Dt 19 4; cf 4 12; Josh 20 5, tr “unawares,” “unwittingly’’). In the NT the words are agnoia, “absence of knowledge” (Acts 3 17; 17 30; Eph 4 18; 1 Pet 1 14); agnééma, “error” (He 9 7, RVm “Gr igno- rances’”’); agnésia, “ignorance” (1 Pet 2 15), “no knowledge” (1 Cor 15 34 RV); agnoéé, “to be with- out knowledge,” “ignorant’? (Rom 1 13; 10 3; 11 25, etc), “not knowing” (Rom 2 4, etc), “understood not” (Mk 9 32, ete), “ignorantly” (Acts 17 23, RV “in ignorance’; 1 Tim 1 13); ididtés, tr4 “igno- rant” (Acts 4 13), “unlearned” (1 Cor 14 16, RVm “him that is without gifts,” and so in vs 23.24), “rude” (2 Cor 11 6); agrdémmatos, once only in connection with ididtés (Acts 4 13, “unlearned and ignorant men’’); agrammatos corresponds to mod- ern ‘illiterate’ (cf Jn 7 15; Acts 26 24); ididtés originally denoted “the private man” as distin- guished from those with a knowledge of affairs, and took on the idea of contempt and scorn. In Philo it denoted the whole congregation of Israel as distinguished from the priests (De Vita Mosis, III. 29). With Paul (L Cor 14 16.23.24) it seems to denote “plain believers as distinguished from those with special spiritual gifts.’ In Acts 413 it may refer to the want of Jewish learning; certainly it does not mean ignorant in the modern sense. Paulin Rom 1 18.32 attributes the pre-Christian 1449 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Idolatry Tilyricum ignorance of God to “the ungodliness and un- righteousness of men, who hinder the truth in unrighteousness’ (but m has, with AV, “hold the truth, ef 1 Cor 7 30, Gr”); many, however (Alford, De Wette, Meyer and others), tr “hold back the truth.” A wilful ignorance is also referred to in Eph 4 17f; 2 Pet 3 5. But there is also a less blameworthy ignorance. Paul at Athens spoke of ‘times of ignorance’ which God had “overlooked” (Acts 17 30); Paul says of himself that he ‘obtained mercy, because [he] did it [against Christ] ignorantly in unbelief”? (1 Tim 1 13); Peter said to the Jews (Acts 3 17) that they and their rulers rejected Christ ‘in ignorance” (cf 1 Cor 2 8); and Jesus Himsclf prayed for those who crucified Him: ‘‘Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do’; (Lk 23 34); in He 5 2 the necessary qualification of a high priest is that he “can bear gently with , the ignorant and erring’—those who sin in igno- rance or go astray (cf 9 7, “blood, which he offereth for himself, and for the errors of the people,” m “Gr ignorances it increasing responsibility, and the “ignorance” that may be “overlooked”’ at one stage of the his- tory of men and nations may be blameworthy and even criminal at another. W. L. WaLKER IM, iim (09 , ‘tyim): Same as Iyim (q.v.). IJE-ABARIM, i-jé-ab’a-rim. See IyE-aBarim. IJON, jon (jPY, ‘yon; LXX in K has ‘Aly, Ain, or Nalv, Nain; in Ch 'Id, [6; Aldv, Aién): A town in the territory of Naphtali, first mentioned in connection with the invasion of Ben-hadad, in the reign of Baasha. It was cap- tured along with Dan and Abel-beth-maacah (1 K 15 20; 2 Ch 16 4). It shared with these cities a similar fate at the hands of Tiglath-pileser in the reign of Pekah (2 K 15 29). The name survives in that of Merj A‘yiwn, “meadow of springs,” a rich, oval-shaped plain to the N.W. of Tell el Kady, where the [atany turns sharply westward to the sea. The ancient city may be represented by Tell Dibbin, an important site to the N. of the plain. 5 W. Ewine IKKESH, ik’esh (UP, ‘“ikkésh, “crooked’’): A Tekoite, father of Ira, one of David’s “thirty” (2 S 23 26; 1 Ch 11 28; 27 9). ILAI, 14-4, 7H 99, Way): A mighty man of David (1 Ch 11 29); called Zalmon in 2 § 23 28. ILIADDN, i-li’a-dun, il’i-ad-un ?EAuaSotv, Elia- doin, 1 Esd 5 58; AV Eleadun): Possibly corres- ponding to Henadad in Ezr 3 9. ILL, il, ILL-FAVORED, il-fa’vérd. FAVOREDNESS. ILLUMINATION, i-l0-mi-na’shun: He 10 32 AV, only, “the former days, in which, after ye were illuminated [RV “enlightened”’], ye endured a great fight of afflictions.’ The vb. is g¢wrl{w, photizo, rendered in 6 4 by ‘‘enlightened” and in both pas- sages (and not elsewhere in the NT) being used to describe complete conversion. The vb., indeed, is used in such a technical way that Syr VSS render by “baptized,” and it is not perhaps impossible that the author of He had baptism definitely in mind. (In the early church baptism is frequently described as “illumination,” e.g. Justin, A pol., 1.61.) But this probably would go too far; the most that can be said is that he means the state of mind of a full Christian and not that of a catechumen (cf also Bar 4 2 AV; Sir 25 11). Burton Scotr Easton See Evit- ’). Growing light, however, brings with’ ILLUSTRIOUS, i-lus’tri-us, THE (Savpacrés, thaumastés): A title of rank and merit attached to the name of Bartacus, the father of Apame (1 Esd 4 29, AV “the admirable). Instead of “the illus- trious”’ we should possibly read ‘‘colonel”’ (Ant, XI, iii, 5; HB,s.v.). See Bartacus; APAME. ILLYRICUM, i-lir’i-kum = (’TAAvpixdv, — TTluri- kén): A province of the Rom Empire, lying E. and N.E. of the Adriatic Sea. In his Ep. to the Rom Paul emphasizes the extent of his missionary activities in the assertion that “from Jerus, and round about even unto Illyricum, 1 have fully preached the gospel of Christ’? (16 19). An examination of this statement involves three ques- tions: What is the force of the preposition ‘‘even unto” (uéxpt, méchri)? What meaning is borne by the word Illyricum? and, At what period of his missionary career did Paul reach the limit here spoken of? In Gr, as in Eng., the preposition “unto” may either be exclusive or inclusive. In other words, Paul may mean that he has preached 1. Force of throughout Macedonia as far as the “even unto” Illyrian frontier, or his words may involve a journey within Illyricum itself, extending perhaps to Dyrrhachium (mod. Durazzo) on the Adriatic seaboard, which, though belonging politically to Macedonia, lay in “Gr Illyria.” But since no word is said in the Acts of any extension of Paul’s travels beyond the confines of Macedonia, and since the phrase, “I have fully preached,” precludes a reference to a hurried or cursory tour in Illyricum, we should probably take the word “unto” in its exclusive sense, and under- stand that Paul claims to have evangelized Mace- donia as far as the frontier of Illyricum. What, then, does the word “Tllyricum” denote? It is sometimes used, like the Gr terms Illyris and Illyria, to signify a vast area lying 2. Meaning between the Danube on the N. and of “Illyri- Macedonia and Thrace on the S., ex- cum’”’ tending from the Adriatic and the Alps to the Black Sea, and inhabited by a number of warlike and semi-civilized tribes known to the Greeks under the general title of Illyrians (Appian, JUyr. 1; Suetonius, Tiberius, 16); it thus comprised the provinces of Jllyricum (in the nar- rower sense), Pannonia and Moesia, which for cer- tain financial and military purposes formed a single administrative area, together with a strip of coast land between Dalmatia and Epirus and, at a later date, Dacia. Appian (Illyr. 6) even extends the term to include Raetia and Noricum, but in this he appears to be in error. But Illyricum has also a narrower and more precise meaning, denoting a single Roman province, which varied in extent. with the advance of the Roman conquest but was finally organized in 10 AD by the emperor Augustus. At first it bore the name superior provincia Illyricum or simply Illyricwm; later it came to be known as Dal- matia (Tac. Annals, iv.5; Jos, BJ, II, xvi; Dio Cassius, xlix.36, etc). In accordance with Paul’s habitual usage of such terms, together with the fact that he employs a Gr form which is a transliteration of the Lat Illyricum but does not occur in any other extant Gr writer, and the fact that he is here writing to the church at Rome, we may conclude that in Rom 16 19 IIlyricum bears its more re- stricted meaning. The Romans waged two Illyrian wars: in 229-228 BC and in 219 BC, but no province was formed until 167, when, after the fall of the Macedonian s = power, Illyria received its provincial con- : Hele stitution (Livy, xlv.26). At this time ion to it extended from the Drilo (mod. Drin) Rome to Dalmatia, which was gradually subju- gated by Rom arms. In 59 BO Julus Caesar received as his province Illyricum and Gaul, and Image THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1450 later Octavian and his generals, Asinius Pollio and Stati- llus Taurus, waged war there with such success that in 27 BC, at the partition of the provinces between Augustus and the Senate, INyricum was regarded as wholly pacified and was assigned to the latter. Renewed disturbances led, however, toits transference to the emperorin11 BC. Two years later the province was extended to the Danube, but in 9 AD, at the close of the 2d Pannonian War, it was divided into two separate provinces, Pannonia and Illyricum (Dalmatia). The latter remained an imperial province, administered by a consular legatus Augusti pro practore residing at Salonae (mod. Spalato), and two legions were stationed there, at Delminium and at Bur- num. One of these was removed by Nero, the other by Vespasian, and thenceforward the province was garri- soned only by auxiliary troops. It fell into three judicial circuits (convenius), that of Scardona comprising Li- burnia, the northern portion of the province, while those of Salonae and Narona made up the district of Dalmatia in the narrower sense. The land was rugged and moun- tainous, and civilization progressed but slowly; the Ro- mans, however, organized 5 Rom colonies within the province and a considerable number of municipia. The extension of Paul’s preaching to the Illyrian frontier must be assigned to his 3d missionary ? journey, i.e. to his 2d visit to Mace- 4. Paul’s donia. His movements during the lst Relation to visit (Acts 16 12—17 15) are too fully Illyricum _recorded to admit of our attributing it to that period, but the account in Acts 20 2 of his second tour is not only very brief, but the words, ‘‘when he had gone through those parts,” suggest an extensive tour through the province, occupying, according to Ramsay, the summer and autumn of 56 AD. See also DatMatta. Lireraturse.—A. M. Poinsignon, Quid praecipue apud Romanos adusque Diocletiani tempora Illyricum fuerit (Paris, 1846); Zippe, Die rémische Herrschaft in Illyrien bis auf Augustus PPeipzig, 1877); H. Cons, La province romaine de Dalmatie (Paris, 1882); T. Mommsen, CIL, III, pp. 279 ff; T. Mommsen et J. Marquardt, Manuel des antiguités romaines (Fr. T), 1X, 171 ff. M. N. Topo IMAGE, im’ay (poy, celem; elxdv, eikén): Its usage falls under 3 main heads. (1) ‘Image’ as object of idolatrous worship (tr® about a dozen words, including M202, masgékhah, “molten image’ (Dt 9 12, ete]; M282, maceébhah, in AV tr? “image” or “pillar,” in RV always “‘pillar’’ [Ex 23 24, ete]; 3B , pesel, “graven image’ [Ex 20 4, etc]; ¢elem, “image” [2 K 11 18, etc]; etkin, “image’’ [e.g. Rev 14 9]); (2) of man as made in the image of God; (3) of Christ as the image of God. Here we are concerned with the last two usages. For “Gmage’”’ in connection with idolatrous practices, see Ipotatry; Imaces; Pruuar; Trraruim, etc. -L. Man as Made in the Divine Image.—To define man’s fundamental relation to God, the priestly writer in Gen uses two words: “image” 1. In (celem) and “‘likeness’’ (d*mith); once the OT employing both together (Gen 1 26; cf 5 3), but elsewhere one without the other, “image” only in 1 27; 9 6, and “likeness” only in 5 1. The priestly writer alone in the OT uses this expression to describe the nature of man, though the general meaning of the passage Gen 1 26 f is echoed in Ps 8 5-8, and the term itself re- appears in Apoc (Sir 17 3; Wisd 2 23) and in the NT (see below). : . ' The idea is important in relation to the Bib. doctrine of man, and has figured prominently in theological discussion. The following are some of the questions that arise: (1) Is there any distinction to be understood between “image” and ‘‘likeness’’? Most of the Fathers, and some jater theologians, attempt to distinguish between them. (a2) Some have referred “‘image" to man's bodliy form, and ‘‘likeness"’ to his spiritual nature (Justin Martyr, Trenaeus). (b) Others, esp. the Alexandrian Fathers, understood by the ‘‘Image”’ the mental and moral endow- ments native to man, and by the “‘iikeness'’ the Divine perfections which man can only gradually acquire by free development and moral conflict (Clement of Alex- andria and Origen), or which Is conferred on man as a gift of grace. (c) This became the basis of the later Roman Catholic distinction between the natural gifts of rationality and freedom (=the image), and the super- natural endowments of grace which God bestowed on man after He had created him (the likeness=donum superadditum). The former remained after the Fall, though in an enfeebled state; the latter was lost through sin, but restored by Christ. The early Protestants re- jected this distinction, maintaining that supernatural righteousness was part of the true nature and idea of man, i.e. was included in the ‘‘image,’’ and not merely externally superadded. Whatever truth these distinc- tions may or may not contain theologically, they cannot be exegetically inferred from Gen 1 26, where {as is now generally admitted) no real difference is intended, We have here simply a ‘‘duplication of synonyms (Driver) for the sake of emphasis, The two terms are elsewhere used interchangeably. (2) What, then, is to be understood by the Di- vine image? Various answers have been given. (a) Some of the Fathers (influenced by Philo) sup- posed that the “image” here = the Logos (called “the image of the invisible God” in Col 1 15), on the pattern of whom man was created. But to read the Logos doctrine into the creation narrative is to ignore the historic order of doctrinal develop- ment. (6) That it connotes physical resemblance to God (see (1), (a) above; so in the main Skinner, ICC, in loc.). It may be admitted that there is a secondary reference to the Divine dignity of the human body; but this does not touch the essence of the matter, inasmuch as God is not represented as having physical form. (c) That it consists of dominion over the creatures (Socinian view; so also Gregory of Nyssa, Chrysostom, etc). This would involve an unwarranted narrowing of the idea. It is true that such “dominion” is closely associated with the image in Gen 1 26 (cf Ps 8 6-8). But the “image of God” must denote pri- marilf man’s relation to his Creator, rather than his relation to the creation. Man’s lordship over Nature is not identical with the image, but is au effect of it. (d) It is best to take the term as refer- ring to the whole dignity of man, in virtue of his fundamental affinity to God. It implies the pos- session by man of a free, self-conscious, rational and moral personality, like unto that of God—a nature capable of distinguishing right and wrong, of choosing the right and rejecting the wrong, and of ascending to the heights of spiritual attainment and communion with God. This involves a separa- tion of man from the beast, and his supremacy as the culmination of the creative process. (8) Does the term imply man’s original perfec- tion, lost through sin? The old Protestant divines maintained that the first man, before the Fall, possessed original righteousness, not only in germ but in developed form, and that this Divine image was destroyed by the Fall. Exegetically considered, this is certainly not taught by the priestly writer, who makes no mention of the Fall, assumes that the image was transmitted from father to son (cf Gen 5 1 with 6 3), and naively speaks of post-diluvian men as created in the image of God (Gen 9 6; ef 1 Cor 11 7; Jas 3 9). Theologically considered, the idea of the perfect holiness of primitive man is based on an abstract conception of God’s work in creation, which precludes the idea of development, ignores the progressive method of the Divine govern- ment and the essential place of effort and growth in human character. It is more in harmony with modern conceptions (a) to regard man as originally endowed with the power of right choice, rather than with a complete character given from the first; and (b) to think of the Divine image (though seriously defaced) as continuing even in the sinful state, as man’s inalienable capacity for goodness and his true destination. Ifthe Divine image in man is a self- conscious, rationa] and ethical personality, it can- not be a merely accidental or transitory attribute, but is an essential constituent of his being. 1451 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Image Two features may be distinguished in the NT doctrine of the Divine image in man: (1) man’s first creation in Adam, (2) his second 2. In or new creation in Christ. As to (1), the NT the doctrine of the OT is assumed in the NT. Paul makes a special appli- cation of it to the question of the relation of husband and wife, which is a relation of subordination on the part of the wife, based on the fact that man alone was created immediately after the Divine image (1 Cor 11 7). Thus Paul, for the special purpose of his argument, confines the meaning of the image to man’s lordly authority, though to infer that he regards this as exhausting its significance would be quite unwarranted. Man’s affinity to God is im- plied, though the term “image’’ is not used, in Paul’s sermon to the Athenians (Acts 17 28f, man the “offspring”? of God). See also Jas 3 9 (it is wrong to curse men, for they are “‘made after the likeness of God’’). (2) More characteristic of the NT is the doctrine of the new creation. (a) The redeemed man is said to be in the image of God (the Father). He is “renewed unto knowledge after the image of him that created him” (Col 3 10), i.e. of God the Crea- tor, not here of Christ or the Logos (as some) (cf Eph 4 24, “after God”). Though there is here an evident reference to Gen 1 26f, this does not imply that the new creation in Christ is identical with the original creation, but only that the two are analogous. To Paul, the spiritual man in Christ is on a higher level than the natural (‘psychical’) man as found in Adam (cf esp. 1 Cor 15 44-49), in whom the Divine image consisted (as we have seen) in potential goodness, rather than in full perfection. Redemption is infinitely more than the restoration of man’s primitive state. (b) The Christian is further said to be gradually transformed into the image of the Son of God. This progressive metamorphosis involves not only moral and spiritual likeness to Christ, but also ultimately the Chris- tian’s future glory, including the glorified body, the “passing through a gradual assimilation of mind and character to an ultimate assimilation of His dééa, déxa, the absorption of the splendor of His presence” (Sanday and Headlam, Rom, 218; see Rom 8 29; 1 Cor 15 49; 2 Cor 3 18; and ef Phil 3 21; 1 Jn 3 2). Hl. Christ the Image of God.—In 3 important pas- sages in EV, the term “image’’ defines the relation of Christ to God the Father; twice in Paul: ‘the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God” (2 Cor 4 4); ‘who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation” (Col 1 15); and once in He: “who being the efful- gence of his glory, and the very image of his sub- stance’ (1 3). These statements, taken in their contexts, register the highest reach of the Christol- ogy of the Epp. , In the two Pauline passages, the word used is eikén, which was generally the LXX rendering of celem (Vulg imago); it is derived from efxw, eik0, touxa, éotka, “to be like,” “regemble,” and means that which resembles an object and reprosents it, as a copy represents the original. In He 1 3 the word used is xapaxrhp (charaktér), which is found here only in the NT, and is tr4 in Vulg figura, AV “express image,’ RV “very image,” RVm “im- press.” It is derived from xapdeow (chardssé), ‘‘to engrave,’ and has passed through the following meanings: (1) an engraving instrument (active sense); (2) the engraved stamp or mark on the instrument (passive sense); (3) the impress made by the instrument on wax or other object; (4) hence, generally, the exact image or expression of any per- gon or thing as corresponding to the original, the 1. The Terms distinguishing feature, or traits by which a person or thing is known (hence Eng. words “character,” “characteristic’’). The word conveys practically the same meaning as eikon; but Westcott distin- guishes them by saying that the latter “gives a complete representation, under conditions of earth, of that which it figures,” while charaktér ‘conveys representative traits only’? (Westcott on He 1 3). The idea here expressed is closely akin to that of the Logos doctrine in Jn (1 1-18). Like the Logos, the Image in Paul and in He is the 2. Meaning Son of God, and is the agent of creation as Applied as well as the medium of revelation. to Christ “What a word (logos) is to the ear, namely a revelation of what is within, an image is to the eye; and thus in the expression there is only a translation, as it were, of the same fact from one sense to auother”’ (Dorner, System of Ch. D., ET, III, 178). AsImage, Christ is the visible representation and manifestation of the invisible God, the objective expression of the Divine nature, the face of God turned as it were toward the world, the exact likeness of the Father in all things except being the Father. Thus we receive “the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of deus Christ” (2 Cor 4 6). He is the facsimile of od. Is Christ described as the Image of God in His preincarnate, His incarnate, or else His exalted state? It is best to say that different 3. To What passages refer to different states, but State Does that if we take the whole trend of NT It Refer? teaching, Christ is seen to be essen- tially, and in every state, the Image of - God. (a) In He 1 3 the reference seems to be to the eternal, preincarnate Son, who is inherently and essentially the expression of the Divine substance. So Paul declares that He subsisted originally in the form of God (év poppy Geot trdpxwv, en morphé theo. hupdrchon, Phil 2 6). (6) In Jn 118; 12 45; 14 9, though the term image is not used, we have the idea of the Avstorical Jesus as a perfect reve- lation of the character and glory of God. (c) In the two Pauline passages (2 Cor 4 4; Col 1 15), the reference is probably to the glorified, exalted Christ; not to His preéxistent Divine nature, nor to His temporal manifestation, but to His ‘‘whole Person, in the divine-human state of His present heavenly existence’ (Meyer). These passages in their cumulative impressions convey the idea that the Image is an inalienable property of His person- ality, not to be limited to any stage of His existence. Does this involve identity of essence of Father and Son, as in the Homoousion formula of the Ni- cene Creed? Not necessarily, for man 4. Theo- also bears the image of God, even in logical his sinful state (see I above), a fact Implications which the Arians sought to turn to their advantage. Yet in the light of the context, we must affirm of Christ an absolutely unique kinship with God. In the Col passage, not only are vast cosmic and redemptive functions assigned to Him, but there is said to dwell in Him “all the fulness of the Godhead bodily” (1 19; 2 9). In He not only is the Son the final revelation of God to men, the upholder of the universe, and the very image of the Divine nature, but also the effulgence (dratyacua, apatiigasma) of God’s glory, and there- fore of one nature with Him as the ray is of one essence with the sun (1 1-3). The superiority of the Son is thus not merely one of function but of nature. On the other hand, the figure of the “image” certainly guards against any Sabellian identification of Father and Son, as if they were but modes of the one Person; for we cannot identify the pattern with its copy, nor speak of anyone as an image of himself. And, finally, we must not Image of God Images THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1452 overlook the affinity of the Logos with man; both are the image of God, though the former in a unique sense. The Logos is at once the prototype of hu- manity within the Godhead, and the immanent Divine principle within humanity. Both in Paul and in He we have an echo of the Jewish doctrine of Wisdom, and of Philo’s doctrine of the Logos. Inthe Alexandrine Book 5. Relation of Wisd, written probably under Stoic to Pre- influence, Divine Wisdom is pictorially Christian represented as “an effulgence [apau- Thought gasma} from everlasting light, and an unspotted mirror of the working of God, and an image [eikdn] of His goodness” (7 26). Philo repeatedly calls the Logos or Divine world- principle the image [eik6n, charaktér] of God, and also describes it as an effulgence of God. But this use of current Alexandrian terminology and the superficial resemblance of ideas are no proof of conscious bor- rowing on the part of the apostles. There is this fundamental distinction, that Philo’s Logos is not a self-conscious personality, still less a historical mdi- vidual, but an allegorical hypostatizing of an ab- stract idea; whereas in Paul and He, as in John, the Divine archetype is actually realized in a historical person, Jesus Christ, the Son and Revealer of God. D. Mratt Epwarns IMAGE OF GOD. See Gon, Imacs or. IMAGERY, im’aj-ri (MWA, maskith, “carved figure’): Only in Ezk 8 12, “every man in his chambers of imagery,’ i.e. dark chambers on whose walls were pictures in relief representing all kinds of reptiles and vermin, worshipped by elders of Israel. Some maintain that the cult was of foreign origin, either Egyp (Bertholet, Comm. on Ezk), or Bab (Redpath, Westminster Comm. on Ezk); others that it was the revival of ancient superstitions of a totemistic kind which had survived in obscure circles in Israel (W. R. Smith, Lectures on the Reli- gion of the Semites, rev. ed, 357). The word here rendered “imagery” is elsewhere in AV tr¢ “image” (of stone) (Lev 26 1, RV “figured stone’’), “pic- tures” (Nu 38 52, RV “figured stones’; Prov 26 11, RV “network’’); twice it means imagination, con- ceit, ie. a mental picture (Ps 73 20; Prov 18 11). “Imagery” occurs once in Apoc (Sir 38 27 AV, els GuorGoa fwypaglay, eis homordsai zdgraphian, RV “to preserve likeness in his portraiture’). D. Mrati Enwarps IMAGES, im’éj-iz (DDY, celem; elxdv, cikén): . Definition . Origin Early Developments . Bible References Palestinian Customs . Some Technical Terms (D Maccébhah (“pillar'’) (2) 'Ashérah (‘‘grove"') 3) Hamman (‘‘sun-image’’) 6. Obscure Bible References (1) Golden Calf Jeroboam's Calves i Brazen Serpent (3) Teraphim (4) Image of Jealousy (5) Chambers of Imagery (6) Ephod LITERATURE Images, as used here, are visible representations of supposedly supernatural or divine beings or powers. They may be (1) themselves objects of worship, (2) pictures, em- bodiments or dwelling-places (temple, ark, pillar, priests) of deities wor- shipped, (3) empowered instruments (amulets, charms, etc) of object or objects worshipped, (4) pictures or symbols of deities reverenced though not worshipped. These images may be shapeless blocks, or symmetrically carved figures, or objects of Nature, such as animals, sun, moon, stars, etc. ao PONS 1. Defi- nition These visible objects may sometimes be considered, esp. by the uninstructed, as deities, while by others in the small community they are thought of as in- struments or symbolizations of deity. Even when they are thought of as deities, this does not exclude a sense and apprehension of a spiritual godhead, since visible corporeal beings may have invisible souls and spiritual attributes, and even the stars may be thought of as “seats of celestial spirits.” An idol is usually considered as either the deity it- self or his permanent tenement; afetish is an object which has been given a magical or divine power, either because of its having been the temporary home of the deity, or because it has been formed or handled or otherwise spiritually influenced by such deity. The idol is generally communal, the fetish private; the idol is protective, the fetish is usually not for the common good. (See Jevons, Idea of God in Early Religions, 1910.) Relics and sym- bolic figures do not become “images” in the objec- tionable sense until reverence changes to worship. Until comparatively recent times, the Hebrews seem to have offered no religious objection to ‘“ar- tistic”’ images, as is proved not only from the de- scription of Solomon’s temple, but also from the discoveries of the highly decorated temple of Jeh at Syene dating from the 6th cent. BC, and from ruins of synagogues dating from the pre-Christian and early Christian periods (PEF, January, 1908; Expos, December, 1907; Expos T, January and February, 1908). The Second Commandment was not an attack upon artists and sculptors but_upon idolaters. Decoration by means of graven figures was not anciently condemned, though, as Jos shows, by the time of the Seleucidae all plastic art was regarded with suspicion. The brazen serpent was probably destroyed in Hezekiah's time because it had ceased to be an ancient artistic relic and had become an object of worship (see below). So the destruction of the ark and altar and temple, which for so long a time had been the means of holy worship, became at last a prophetic hope (Isa 6 7; Jer 3 6; Am 5 25; Hos 6 6; cf Zec 14 20). While the temple is not naturally thought of as an “image,” it was as truly so as any Bethel. An idol was the temple in miniature—a dwelling-place of the god. When an image became the object of worship or a means by which a false god was wor- shipped, it became antagonistic to the First and Second Commandments respectively. The learned author of the art. on “Image Wor- ship” in the HB (11th ed) disposes too easily of this question when he suggests that 2. Origin image-worship is “a contmmuance by adults of their childish games with dolls... .. Idolatrous cults repose largely on make- believe.” Compare the similar statement made from a very different standpoint by the author of Great Is Diana of the Ephesians, or the Original of Idolatry (1695): ‘' All Superstitions are to the People but like several sports to children, which varying in their several seasons yield them pretty entertainment," etc. No universal institution or custom is founded wholly on superstition. If it does not answer to some real human need, and “‘if its foundations are not laid broad and deep in the nature of things, it must perish” (J. G. Fraser, Psyche’s Task, 1909, 103; cf Salomon Reinach, Revue des études grecques, 1906, 324). Image-worship is too widespread and too natural to humanity, as is proved In modern centuries as well as in the cruder earlier times, to have its basis and source in any mere external and accidental circumstances. All modern research tends to corroborate our belief that this is psycho- logical rather than ecclesiastical in its origin. It is not imposed externally; it comes from within, . 1453 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Image of God Images and naturally accompanies the organic unfold- ment of the human animal in his struggle toward self-expression. This is now generally acknowl- edged to be true of religious feeling and instinct (see esp. Rudolf Eucken, Christianity and _ the New Idealism, 1909, ch i; I. King, The Develop- ment of Religion, 1910); it ought to be counted equally true of religious expression. Neither can the origin of image-worship or even of magical rites be fully explained, as Fraser thinks, by the ordi- nary laws of association. These associations only become significant because the devoted worshipper already has a body of beliefs and generalizations which make him attentive to the associations which seem to him religiously or magically important. (Jastrow, Aspects of Rel. Belief and Practice in Baby- lonia and Assyria; cf James H. Leuba, Psy- chological Origin and Nature of Religion, 1909; Study of Religions, 1911). So animism must be regarded as a philosophy rather than as an original religious faith, since 1t is based on an “explanation of phenomena rather than an attitude of mind toward the cause of these phenomena” (#B, 11th ed, art. ‘‘Animism,” and cf Héfiding, Philosophy of Re- ligion, 1906, 138). In whatever ways the various image-worshipping cults arose historically—whether from a primitive demonology or from the apotheo- sis of natural objects, or from symbolism, or a false connection of cause with effect—in any case it had some human need behind it and human nature beneath it. The presence of the image testifies to faith in the supernatural being represented by the image and to a desire to keep the object of worship near. Prayer is easier when the worshipper can see his god or some sacred thing the god has honored’ (ef M. L’abbé E. Van Drival, De Vorigine et des sources de Vidolatrie, Paris, 1860). The first man was not born with a totem-pole in his fist, nor did the earliest historic men possess images. They lacked temples and 3. Histor- altars and ephods and idols, as they ical Begin- lacked the fire-stick and _ potter’s nings and wheel. Religion, which showed itself Early De- so strong in the next stage of human velopment life, must have had very firm begin- nings in the prehistoric period; but what were its external expressions we do not yet certainly know, excepting in the methods of burying and caring for the dead. It seems probable that primitive historic man saw in everything that moved an active soul, and that he saw in every extraordi- nary thing in earth or heaven the expression of a supernatural power. Yet reflective thinking began earlier than Tylor and all the older scientific anthro- pologists supposed. Those earlier investigators were without extended chronological data, and although ingenuity was exercised in systematizing the beliefs and customs of modern savages, it was necessarily impossible always to determine in this way which were the most primitive cults. Exca- vations in Babylonia, Egypt and elsewhere have enabled us for the first time to trace with some chronological certainty the religious expressions of earliest historic man. That primitive man was so stupid that he could not tell the difference bctween men and things, and that therefore totemism or fetishism or a low form of animism was necessarily the first expression of religious thought is a theory which can no longer be held very buoyantly in the face of the new and striking knowledge, material and religious, which is now seen to be incorporated in some of the most ancient myths of mankind. (See e.g. Winckler, Die jingsten Kampfe wider den Panbabylonismus, 1907; Jeremias, The OT in the Light of the Ancient Hast, 2 vols, 1911.) The pan- Bab theory, which makes so much use of these texts, is not certain, but the facts upon which the theory depends areclear. It is a suggestive fact that among the carliest known deities or symbols of deities men- tioned in the most ancient inscriptions are to be found the sun, moon, stars and other great forces of Nature. Out of these conceptions and the mys- tery of life—which seems to have affected early mankind even more powerfully than ourselves— sprang the earliest known religious language, the myth, which antedated by aeons our oldest written texts, since some of these myths appear fully formed in the oldest texts. Rough figures of these solar and stellar deities are found from very early times in Babylonia. So in the earliest Egyp texts the sun appears as divine and the moon as “the bull among the stars,’ and rough figures of the gods were carved in human or animal form, or these are rep- resented pictorially by diadems or horns or ostrich feathers, as far back as the [id Dynasty, while even earlier than this stakes and pillars and heaps of stones are sacred. (See further, HDB, 5th vol, 176 ff; Erman, A Handbook of Egyp Rel.; Steindorf, Rel. of the Ancient Egyptians, 1905.) These rude and unshaped objects do not testify, as was once supposed, to a lower form of religious development than when sculptured images are found. The shapeless fetish, which not long ago was generally accepted as the earliest form of image, really repre- sents a more advanced stage and higher form of religious expression than the worship of a beauti- fully or horribly carved image. It has been gen- erally conceded since the days of Robertson Smith that it takes at least as much imagination and reflection to see an expression of deity in imageless matter as in the carved forms. Rude objects un- touched by human hand, even in the most highly developed worships, have been most prized. The earliest images were probably natural objects which, because of their peculiar shapes or functions, were thought of either as divine or as made sacred by the touch of deity. Multiplied copies of these ob- jects would naturally be made when worshippers increased or migrations occurred. While images may have been used in the most early cults, yet the highest development of image-worship has occurred among the most civilized peoples. Both deities and idols are less numerous in the early than in the later days of a religion. This is true in India, Assyria, Babylonia, and Egypt, as all experts now agree. Idols are not found among uncivilized peoples, such as the Bushmen, Fuegians, Eskimos, etc. (See eg. Allen Menzies, History of fel., 1895.) Images of the gods presuppose a power of discrimination that could only be the result of reflection. The earliest idols known among the Semites were rude stone pillars or unshapen blocks. These, as the fetish, were probably adored, not for themselves, but for the spirit that was supposed to be in them or to have touched them. Deities and idols are multiplied easily, not only by philological, geographical and social causes, but through inter- tribal and international associations. One thing absolutely proved by recent excavations has been the extent to which the representations of local deities have been modified by the symbolic art of surrounding nations. Babylonia, for example, was influenced by the Syro-Hittite religious art at least as much as by that of Egypt (William Hayes Ward, Cylinders and Other Ancient Oriental Seals, 1909; Clay, Amurru, 1910). Even in adjacent localities the same deity varied greatly in its pic- torial representation. See Pauestins ExpiLora- TION, and Revue biblique, XIV, 315-48. With the possible exception of one reign in Egypt, during which Ikhnaton refused to allow any deities to be worshipped excepting the sun disc and himself, idolatry outside of the Heb kingdom was never made a crime against the state until the days of Con- Images THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1454 stantine. Theodosius (392 AD) not only placed sacrifices and divination among the capital crimes, but placed a penalty upon anyone who entered a heathen temple. ‘The dignity of the image in common thought in Bible times may be seen from the fact that man is said to have been made in God’s image 4. Bible (D2%, celem; cf 1S 6 5; Nu 33 52), References and Christ is said to be “the image of and Pales- the invisible God” (eixdév, eikén; tinian ef Col 115 with Rom 1 23). The Customs heathen thought of the sun and stars and idols as being images of the gods, but the Hebrews, though Jeh’s temple was image- less, thought of normal humanity as in some true sense possessing a sacred resemblance to Deity, though early Christians taught that only Christ was the Father’s “image” in unique and absolute perfection. See Imace. The ordinary words for “image” by a slight change came to mean vermin, carrion, false gods, no gods, carcases, dung, etc. Heathen gods were undoubtedly accounted real beings by the early Hebrews, and the images of these enemies of Jeh were doubtless looked upon as possessing an evil associated (?) power. In the earlier OT era, images, idols, and false gods are synonymous; but as early as the 8th cent. BC Heb prophets begin to reach the lofty conception that heathen gods are non-existent, or at least practi- cally so, when compared with the ever-living Jeh, while the idols are ‘‘worthless things’ or ‘“non- entities” (Isa 2 8.18.20; 10 10.11; 191; 31 7; ef Jer 14 14; Ezk 30 13; note the satiric term *élilim, as contrasted with the powerful ’éldhim). The many ordinary terms used by the Hebrews for an idol or image mean “copy,” stmulacrum, “likeness,” “representation.” These are often, however, so compounded as technically to express a particular form, as “graven” or ‘“‘carved” image (e.g. Ex 20 4; 2 Ch 33 7) of wood or stone, i.e. one cut into shape by a tool; “molten image” (e.g. Ex 32 4; Lev 19 4), i.e. one cast out of melted metal (standing image) (Lev 26 1 AV, and see below), etc. However, a few of the OT terms and modes of worship are unusual, or have a more diffi- cult technical meaning, or have been given a new interest by new discoveries, and such deserve a more extended notice. MA, maccébhah: These were upright stone _ pillars, often mentioned in the OT, sometimes as abodes (Bethels) or symbols of deity— 6. Most esp. as used by the heathen—but also Important as votive offerings, memorial and grave Technical stones (Gen 28 18; 31 45; 35 14.20; Terms Josh 24 26; 18712). The rever- ence for these stones is closely con- nected with that found among all Sem peoples for obelisks (Gen 33 20; 365 7), cairns (Gen 28 18; Josh 4 6), and circles (Josh 4 3.5.20). Rough stone pillars from time immemorial were used in Sem worship (Kittel, Hist of the Hebrews, Il, 84). They were thought of primitively as dwelling- places of deity, and the stones and the spots where they stood were therefore accounted sacred. From very early times the mystery of life pressed itself upon human attention, and these stones were viewed as phallic images. These images were at first rough and undifferentiated, but became later well defined as maleorgans. At Tell Zakariyah the end of one is sculptured to represent a human face. Some sort of phallicism underlies all early Sem religion, the form of which is determined by the attention paid to the date palm, to the breeding of flocks, to as- trology, and to social life. This phallicism did not always represent coarse thought, but sometimes a very profound spiritual conception; cf GoLDEN Car, and note Wiedemann’s statement in HDB, V, 180 that in Egypt the gods Hu, “Taste,” and Sa, “Perception,” were created from the blood of the sun-god’s phallus. These images of fertility and reproduction were naturally connected im Canaan with the worship of the Baals or “lords” of each locality, upon whose favor as possessor of the land fertility depended. They were also naturally associated with the cult of Astarte, the female counterpart of all the Baals (see AstarTs). In the OT the Baalim and Asherim are almost invariably classed together, although the latter were wooden posts dedicated to a particular goddess, while “Baal” was merely a title which could be given to any male Sem deity, and sometimes even to_his female associate. The macgébhoth were set up in a “high place” (q.v.), attracting reverence because of its ‘elevation, isolation and mystery” (Vincent). Originally these pillars were not considered as idols, but were naturally erected to Jeh (Gen 28 18; 31 45; 35 14; Ex 24 4), and even Isaiah (19 19) and Hosea (3 4) approve them, though pillars dedi- cated to idols must of course be destroyed (Ex 23 24; 3413; Jer 43 13; Ezk 26 11). Only im late times or by very far-sighted law-givers were the mageebhath erected to Jeh condemned; but after the centralization of the Jeh-worship in Jerus, these pillars were condemned, even when set up In the name of Jeh, and the older places of worship with their indiscriminate rituals and necessary heathen affiliations were also wisely discarded (Lev 26 1; Dt 16 22; see also GoLpEN CaLF). MTOR, ’dshérah: Perhaps a goddess (see ASHE- RAH), but as ordinarily used in the OT, a sacred tree or stump of a tree planted in the earth (Dt 16 21) or a pole made of wood and set up near the altar (Jgs 6 26; 1 K 16 33; Isa 17 8). It has been supposed that these were primarily symbols of a goddess ‘Ashorah or Ashtoreth (Kuenen, Baethgen), and they were certainly in primitive thought connected with the tree cult and the sacred groves so univer- sally honored by the Semites (see esp. W. R. Smith, Religion of the Semites, 169, 487; Stade, Geschichte, 160 ff; Fraser, Golden Bough, II, 56-117; John O'Neill, Night of the Gods, II, 57); but the tree of life is closely connected in texts and pictures with the human organ of generation, and there can be no doubt that there is a phallic meaning connected with this sacred stake or pole, as with the magcébhéth Uescribed above. See references in HDB under ‘'‘Asherah,"' and cf Transactions of the Victoria Institute, XXXIX, 234; Winckler, Keilin- schriftliches Textbuch zum AT. As these wooden posts from earliest times represented the ideas of fertility and were connected with the mystery of life, they naturally became the signs and symbols in many lands of the local gods and goddesses of fertility. Astarte was by far the most popular deity of ancient Pal. See Asurorets. The figures of Astarte from the 12th to the 9th cent. BC, as found at Gezer, have large hips, disclosing an exaggerated idea of fecundity. In close connection with the Astarte sanctuaries in Pal were found numberless bodies of little children, none over a week old, undoubtedly representing the sacrifice of the firstborn by these Canaanites (R.A.S. Macalister, Excavation of Gezer, 3 vols). These Asherim were erected at the most sacred Heb sanctuaries, at Samaria (2 K 18 6), Bethel (2 K 23 15), and even in the Temple of Jerus (2 K 23 6). The crowning act, of King Josiah’s reforma- tion was to break down these images (2 K 23 14). As the astrological symbol of Baal was the sun, Astarte is often thought of as the moon-goddess, but her symbol was Teally Venus. mr She was, however, sometimes called “ Queen of Heaven” (Jer 7 18; 44 17.19; butseeZATW, VI, 123-30). TOD, hamman, AV “images,” “idols”; RV “sun- images” (Lev 26 30; 2 Ch 14 5; 34 4.7; Isa 17 8; 27 9; Ezk 6 4. 6): This worship may originally have come from Babylonia, but the reverence of the sun under the name Baal-hamman had long been common in Pal before Joshua and the Israelites entered the country. These sun-images were probably obelisks or pillars connected with the worship of some local Baal. The chariot and horses of the sun, mentioned (2 K 23 11) as having an honored place at the western entrance of the 1455 Jerus Temple, represented not a local but a foreign - cult. In Bab temples, sacrifices were made to the sun-chariot, which seems to have had a special sig- nificance in time of war (Pinches, HDB, IV, 629; see also CHARIOTS OF THE Sun). (1) Golden Calf and Jeroboam’s Calves (see GoLDEN CALF). (2) Brazen Serpent (Nu 21 4-9; 2K 6. Obscure 18 4).—The serpent, because of its Bible strange, lightning-like power of poison- References ous attack, its power to shed its skin, and to paralyze its prey, hasbeen the most universally revered of all creatures. Living serpents were kept in Bab temples. So the cobra was the guardian of royalty in Egypt, sym- bolizing the kingly power of life and death. Inmy- thology, the serpent was not always considered a bad demon, enemy of the Creator,but often appears as the emblem of wisdom, esp. in connection with health- giving and life-giving gods, such as Ea, savior of man- kind from the flood, and special ‘god of the physi- cians’’ in Babylon; Thoth, thegod of wisdomin DEL who healed the eye of Horus and brought Osins to life again; Apollo, the embodiment of physical per- fection, and his son, Aesculapius, most famous giver of physical and moral health and curer of disease among the Greeks. Among the Hebrews also a seal (1500-1000 BC) shows a worshipper before a horned serpent raised on a pole (Wm. Hayes Ward). In Phoen mythology the serpent is also connected with wisdom and long life, and it is found on the oldest Heb seals and on late Jewish talismans (Revue biblique internationale, July, 1908, 382-94); at Gezer, in Pal, a small “brazen serpent”? (a cobra) was found in the “cave of oracles,’ and in early Christian art Jesus the Lord of Life is often repre- sented standing triumphantly upon the serpent or holding it in His fist. In the Heb narrative found in Nu 21, the serpent evidently appears as a well- known symbol representing the Divine ability to cure disease, being erected before the eyes of the Israelites to encourage faith and stop the plague. It was not a totem, for the totem belongs to a single family and is never set up for the veneration of other families (Ramsay, Cities of Si. Paul, 39). Hezekiah destroyed it because it was receiving idolatrous worship (2 K 18 4), though there is no hint that such worship was ever a part of the official temple cult (Benzinger); for if this had been done, the earlier prophets could hardly have remained silent. The above explanation seems preferable to the one formerly offered that the serpent was merely a copy of the disease-bearer, as the images offered by the Philis were copies of the ulcers that plagued them (1 S 6 4). Sce further Nu- HUSHTAN. (3) Teraphim (E°PWA, terdphim)—These are usually considered household gods, but this does not necessarily include the idea that they were images of ancestors, though this is not improbable (Nowack, Hebrew Archaeology, II, 23; HDB, II, 190); that they were images of Jeh is a baseless supposition (see Kautasch, HDB, V, 643). Some- times they appear in the house (1 8 19 13.16); sometimes in sanctuaries (Jgs 175; 18 14); sometimes as carried by travelers and armies (Gen 31 30; Ezk 2121). They are never directly spoken of as objects of worship (yet cf Gen 31 30), but are mentioned in connection with wizardry (2 K 23 24), and as a means of divination (Ezk 21 21; Zec 10 2), perhaps not necessarily inconsistent with Jeh-worship (Hos 3 4). They were some- times small and could be easily hidden (Gen 31 34); at other times larger and in some way resembling a human being (1 5 19 13). Jewish commentators thought the ¢*raphim were in early times mummi- fied human heads which were represented in later THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Images centuries by rude images (Moore, Crit. and Exeg. Comm. on Jgs, 1895, 382; see esp. Chwolsohn, Die Ssabier u. der Ssabismus, — II, 19, 150). Customs of divination by means of such heads were not un- known. In Israel the tréphim were sometimes certainly used in consult- ing Jeh(Jgs 17 5; 18 14 ff), though their use was later officially condemned (2 K 23 24). The traphim in the home doubtless corre- spond in use to the Epxop (which see) in the sanctu- ary, and therefore these are frequently connected. Certain small rude images have lately been uncovered in Pal by Bliss, at Tell el- Hesy, and by Sellin,’ at Tell Ta‘annuk, which are supposed to be teraphim. (4) Image of jealousy QD , semel).—It is not cer- tain what this statue was which was set up by the door of the inner gate of the Jerus temple (Ezk 8 3). It was no doubt some idol, perhaps the image of the Asherah (2 K 21 7; 23 6), which certainly had penouey been set up in the temple and may have een there again in this day of apostasy. ‘‘Jeal- ousy” is not the name of the idol, but it was prob- ably called “image of jealousy’’ because in a peculiar manner this partic image seems to have been drawing the people from the worship of Jeh and therefore provoking Him to jealonsy. (5) Chambers of imagery (MDW “WT, hadhré maskithd).—Does Ezekiel mean that in his heart every man in his chambers of imagery was an idol-worshipper, or does this refer to actual wall decorations in the Jerus Temple (Ezk 8 11.12)? Most expositors take it literally. W. R. Smith has been followed almost if not quite universally in his supposition that a debased form of vermin- worship is described in the “creeping things and abominable beasts” (ver 10). But while this low and ignorant worship was an ancient cult, it had been banished for centuries from respectable heathen worship, and it seems inconceivable that these Israelites who were of the highest class could have fallen to these depths, or if they had done so that the Tammuz and sun-worship should have been considered so much worse (vs 13.14). To the writer it seems more probable that the references are to Egyp or Gr mysteries which would be described by a Hebrew just as Ezekiel describes this secret chamber. It is now known that the Gr mysteries experienced a revival at exactly this era, and it was probably this revival which was making itself felt in Jerus, for Gr influence was at this time greatly affecting Pal (see Duruy, Hist of Greece, II, 126-80, 374; Cobern, Comm. on Ezk and Dn, 80-83, 280-82; and separate arts., CHAMBERS OF Imacury; Imacery). (6) Ephod (T°DN, ’éphddh).—There is no doubt that this was the name of a vestment or ritual loin cloth of linen worn by common priests and temple servants and on special occasions by the king (1 8 218; 22 18; 2 36 14). The ephod of the high priest was an ornamental waist coat on the front of which was fastencd the holy breastplate con- taining the pocket in which were the Urim and Thummim (Ex 28 6.30; 29 5; 39 2-5; Lev 8 28). There are several passages, however, which have con- vinced many scholars that another ephod is mentioned which must be an image of Jeh (see Epson). The chief from “Household God’ Gezer. Imagination Immanuel THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1456 passages relied upon are Jgs 8 26.27, where Gideon made an ephod with 1,700 shekels of gold and ‘‘set"’ this in Ophrah, where it became an object of worship. So in Jgs 17 4; 18 14-20, Micah provides an ephod as well as an image and pillar for his sanctuary; in 1S 21 9 the sword of Goliath is preserved behind the ephod; while in various places the will of Jeh is ascertained, not by putting on the ephod, but by “bringing it near” and ‘‘bearing’’ and ‘‘carrying” it (1 S 23 6.9; 30 7, etc). On the basis of these passages Kautzsch (HDB, V, 641) concludes most inconsistently that the ephod appears “exclusively as an image of Jeh.”” Driver, after an examination of each text, concludes that just in one passage (Jgs 8 27) the term ‘‘ephod” is certainly used of the gold casing of an image, and that therefore it may also have this meaning in other passages (HDB, I, 725). It does not seem quite certain, however, that a cere- monial vestment heavily ornamented with gold might not have been ‘‘set” or “‘erected”’ in a holy place where later it might become an object of worship. If this had been an idolatrous image, would Hosea have deplored its loss (Hos 3 4), and would its use not have been for- bidden in some Bible passage ? Kautzsch's view that the ephod meant primarily the garment used to clothe the Divine image, which after- ward gave its name to the image itself, is a guess unsus- tained by the Scriptures quoted or, I think, by any archaeological parallel. We conclude that there is no certain proof that this was an image of Jeh, though it was used ritualistically in receiving the oracles of Jeh (cf Kuenen, Religion of Israel, I, 100; Kittel, Hist of the Hebrews, II, 42; Konig, Die Hauptprobleme, 59-63). See also IpoLatry; Catr, GOLDEN. LITERATURE.—See esp. W. R. Smith, Religion of the Semites; E. B. Tylor, Primitive Culture; J. G. Frazer, Golden Bough (8 vols); Baethgen, Beztrdge zur sem. Rel.-Gesch.; Kittel, Hist of the Hebrews; Nowack, Heb rch., ; Banudissin, Studien 2. sem. Rel.-Gesch. For recent excavations, L. P. H. Vincent, Canaan d'aprés Vexpl. récente, 1907; R.A. S. Macalister, The Excavation of Gezer (1912); m. Hayes Ward, Cylinders and Other Ancient Oriental Seals, 1909. Campen M. Copern IMAGINATION, i-maj-i-na’shun (A271, yécer, MAIMW, sheriruth; Sidveva, didnoia): ‘Imagina- tion’’ is the tr of yécer, properly “a shaping,’’ hence “a thonght”’ (Gen 6 5; 8 21; Dt 31 21; 1 Ch 28 9; 29 18). In Isa 26 3 yécer is tr? “mind” (AVm “thought” or ‘‘imagination”’), ‘‘whose mind is stayed on thee” (RVm “or imagination”); in Ps 103 14 it is “frame”; of sh*rtrdth, “obstinacy,” “stubborn- ness’ (Dt 29 19; Jer 317; 7 24; 9 14; 118; 13 10; 16 12; 18 12; 23 17); m Ps 81 12 AV it is, ‘‘lust,” m “hardness or imaginations’; 3 + of mahdshebheth, “thought” or “purpose” in AV (Prov 618; Lam 3 60.61); once of dianoia, “mind,” “understanding” (Lk 1 51); of logismés, “reason- ing’ (2 Cor 10 5); and of dialogismés, “reasoning through’ (Rom 1 21 AV). — : RV gives “stubbornness’’ in each instance where sh'rirtth is in AV tr? “imagination”; in Prov 6 18 ARV has “purposes”; RV has “devices’’ (Lam 3 60.61) and “reasonings’”’ (Rom 1 21), ‘“imagina- tion” for “conceit”? (Prov 18 11), and (ERV) for “device’’ (Lam 3 62). ‘ “Imagination” is frequent in Apoe, e.g. Ecclus 22 18 (dianééma); 37 3 (enthimema, “wicked imagi- nation’’); 40 2 (dialogismos, RV ‘“‘expectation’’). W. L. WALKER IMAGINE, i-maj‘in (QUM, hadshabh; pedrerda, meletdd): The word most frequently tr? “to im- agine’’ in the OT, only in AV and ERV, not in ARV, is hdshabh, ‘to bind,” “combine,” “think’’ (Job 6 26; Ps 10 2; 2111; 140 2; Hos 7 15; Nah 1 9.11; Zec 7 10; 8 17); we have also haghah in AV and ERV, but not in ARV, “to meditate,” “mutter,” “speak” (Ps 2.1; 38 12); zamam, “to devise” (Gen 11 6 AV); harash, “to grave,” “de- vise’ (Prov 12 20 AV); hathath, “to break in upon,” to “attack unjustly” (Ps 62 3 AV); mele- tad, “‘to meditate’ (Acts 4 25). W. L. WaLKER IMALCUE, i-mal-kii’é (Ipadxovh, Imalkoué; AV Simalcue): An Arabian prince to whom Alexander Balas entrusted the upbringing of his young son Antiochus. Tryphon, who had formerly been on the side of Alexander, persuaded Imalcue to set up the young Antiochus (Antiochus VI) against Demetrius, who had incurred the enmity of his men of war (1 Mace 11 39.40). Antiochus confirmed Jonathan in the high-priesthood and appointed him to be one of the king’s friends (ver 57). In Jos (Ant, XIII, v, 1) the name is given as Malchus. J. Hurcsison IMLA, im’la, IMLAH (72°07, yimlah, “fulness’’?): ier) of the prophet Micaiah (1 K 22 8.9; 2 Ch 18 7.8). IMMACULATE CONCEPTION, i-mak’t-lat kon- sep’shun, THE: ‘ The historic designation of the Roman Catholic dogma promulgated by Pope Pius IX on December 8, 1854, in the Papal Bull entitled 1. Defini- “Ineffabilis Deus.”” The term is often tion incorrectly applied, even by those : whose intelligence should make such an error impossible, to the VizGiIn BirTH or CHRIST v.). Fy central affirmation of this proclamation, which was read in St. Peter’s in the presence of over two hundred bishops, is expressed in 2. State- the following words: It is proclaimed ment of the “by the authority of Our Lord Jesus Dogma Christ and the blessed Apostles Peter and Paul and in our own authority, that the doctrine which holds the blessed Virgin Mary to have been, from the first instant of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of Almighty God, in view of the merits of Christ Jesus the Saviour of Mankind, preserved free from all stain of original sin, was revealed by God, and is, therefore, to be firmly and constantly believed by all the faithful’’ (see Schaff, A History of the Creeds of Christendom, I, 211, 212). (1) Drawn from specifically Protestant principles. —Objections to the dogma are mainly two: (a) the claim to authority upon which the 3. Objec- proclamation rests. There is every tions to the reason to believe that one of the major Dogma motives to the entire transaction was the wish, on the part of Pius and his advisers, to make an unmistakable assertion of absolute doctrinal authority by the Rom pontiff. To Protestants of all shades of opinion there would be unbearable offence in the wording of the decree, even if assent could be given to the doctrine it- self. The whole vital issue of the Reformation is involved in the use by an ecclesiastic of the words ‘Gn our own authority” in addition to the words “by the authority of Our Lord Jesus Christ and the blessed Apostles Peter and Paul.’ (b) The ten- dency to Mariolatry in the entire movement. As we shall see, the ascription of Divine honors to Mary is avoided in the public statement of the dogma and in the defence of it by Roman Catholic writers, but one has but to survey the course of discussion leadmg up to the publication of 1854, and subsequent to it, to discover a growing tendency to lift Mary out of the realm of human beings and to endow her with Divine attributes and functions. An extended discussion of Mariolatry lies beyond the range of this art. (see Mary); it is only neces- sary to point out the obvious connections (see Roman Catholic Dictionary and church histories, sub loce.). a _ (2) Drawn from Roman Catholic principles —It is far from the truth to suppose that there are no objections to this modern dogma save those which are specifically Protestant. From the viewpoint of the devout Roman Catholic, and for the sake of the prestige of the papacy, this particular dogma seems to have been unfortunately chosen. (a) It has no basis in Scripture. The only at- tempt made to provide a Scriptural argument is 1457 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Imagination Immanuel by using a vague and unsatisfactory || between Mary and Eve before the Fall, to be found in the writings of certain church Fathers who did not hold the papal dogma but unconsciously provided a slender and most insecure basis for it (see infra). Most Roman Catholic writers are intelligent enough to admit that the theory of inspired tradition alone can be appealed to in support of the idea. The ordinary and ouly tenable argument is that the ecclesiastical promulgation and acceptance of the doctrine prove its apostolic origin (see Catholic Dictionary, sub loc.). (b) It weakens the authority of the church. It would almost seem as if the doctrines of ecclesias- tical authority and particularly of papal infalli- bility had, in this uufortunate proclamation, reached a reductio ad absurdum for the comfort of their foes. Notice with care the historical standing of this dogma: (a) The acknowledged absence of all posi- tive evidence for apostolic origin and primitive authority (see Catholic Dictionary ut supra). (8) The abundant positive evidence that the principal Fathers of the early church did not believe in the sinlessness of Mary (see list of names and references given by H. C. Sheldon, Histpry of the Christian Church, sub loc.). (vy) The uncertain and equivocal testimony per contra drawn from the early Fathers. They are practically confined to the following: Ephrem Syrus (Carmina, Hymn 27, strophe 8), where he says ‘Truly it is Thou and Thy mother only who are fair altogether. For in Thee there is no stain and in Thy mother no spot”; St. Augustine (De Natura et Gratia, cap. 26), ‘Two were made simple, innocent, perfectly like each other, Mary and Eve,” etc. To these may be added the words of Irenaeus: ‘The knot of Eve’s disobedience was untied by Mary’s obedience’”’ (Catholic Dictionary, 422). In regard to these three passages it may reasonably be contended that even if these state- ments necessarily implied the Immaculate Con- ception of Mary, which they certainly do not, they would still have to be estimated against the many weighty statements which may be brought forward on the other side. (8) The prolonged coutroversy over the doctrine. From the earliest time when the idea of Mary’s miraculous freedom from sin appears, up to the Old Catholic agreement of 1874, devout and faithful Roman Catholics have pro- tested against the addition of this unscriptural dogma to the faith of the church. Bonaventura (Locus Theol., VII, 1) says: ‘‘All the saints who have made mention of this matter, with one mouth have asserted that the blessed Virgin was conceived in original sin.” With the statement of the Old Catholic agreement we may safely sum up the ecclesiastical situation, even from the viewpoint of those who hold to the doctrinal validity of tradi- tion. Art. K reads: ‘We reject the New Rom doctrine of the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary, as being contrary to the tra-~ dition of the first 13 centuries, according to which Christ alone is conceived without siu.” (3) Drawn from general considerations of Chris- tian doctrine—The most serious objectious to this offensive and gratuitous dogma are not at all specifically Protestant but, rather, broadly Chris- tian. It is necessary at this point to assure our- selves that we understand (as many Protestants evidently do not) just what is meant by the doctrine as a doctrine. According to the accepted Roman Catholic explanation, Mary, at the supposed stage of her conception when the soul was actually in- fused into the body waiting for it, received the special grace of God whereby she was delivered from all stain of original sin. The point which Protestants need esp. to note is that, according to Roman Catholic ideas, this gracious act of God was performed on the basis of the foreseen merits of Christ’s sacrifice. This tones down the offensive- ness of the doctrine in that it does not per se imply the equality of Mary with Christ, but rather the contrary, in so far as the grace betowed upon her was gained by anticipation from Him. Roman Catholic writers naturally emphasize this fact in recommending the doctrine to Protestant mlnds. None the less the offence remaius. The “Immacu- late Conception” necessarily implies the “immacu- late life,” and on the same basis of supernatural grace, else would the special miracle have occurred in vain and the fall of Adam been repeated in Mary. Hence, a full account of the doctrine would be that Mary was completely and miraculously redeemed at her conception and completely and miraculously kept from sin throughout her whole life. Apart from all questious as to the rightful place of Mary in Christian thought, this idea involves utter doc- trinal confusion. It means that Mary never be- came a true human being and never lived a true human life. Redemption by a miraculous process begun at conception and carried on throughout the life is an utter impossibility, for the Holy Spirit does not work impersonally, and miraculous holiness which is holiuess of a purely Divine character, with- out a free, codperating human factor, is no human holiness at all. This dogma reads Mary out of the human family, reduces her to an image and makes her life a phantasm. Moreover, the parallels which a adduced in its support are not true parallels at all. Our Lord’s sinlessness was not mechanically guaranteed by His miraculous conception (sce VirRGIN BrrtH) but was His own achievement through the Holy Spirit granted to Him and per- sonally appropriated. The Hallowing of Children at the Font (see Catholic Dictionary, 470a), the sanctifying of those “separated from the womb’’ (Gal 1 15) to God’s service, does not imply the miraculous guarantee of artificial sinlessness, but such a gracious influeuce as enables the subject freely co6perating to obtain victory over sin as a controlling principle. Actual sin and need of for- giveness is not praetermitted by such special grace. We can only say, in conclusion, that every reason, which usually operates in a Christian mind to insure rejection of a false teaching, ought to preclude the possibility of accepting this peculiar dogma which is Seripturally baseless, historically unjustified and doctrinally unsound. Lireraturs.—The best simple and reasonably fair- minded discussion of this dogma from the Roman Catholic viewpoint is to be found in the Catholic Dic- tionary already mentioned, where wide references will be found. For the Protestant view consult any authori- tative church history, esp. that of Professor H. C. Sheldon where copious references to Patristic lit. will be found. Louis MatrHzews SwEET IMMANUEL, i-man’ti-el (OS IBY, ‘immana’él): The name occurs but 3 t, twice in the OT (Isa 7 14; 8 8), and once in the NT (Mt 1 23). Itisa Heb word signifying ‘‘God is with us.” The form “Emmanuel” appears in LXX (’Eupavoupd, Em- manouél). In 735 BC Ahaz was king of Judah. The king- dom of Israel was already tributary to Assyria (2 K 16 19.20). Pekah, king of Is- 1. Isaiah rael, a bold and ambitious usurper, Rebukes and Rezin, kiug of Syria, formed an Ahaz alliance, the dual object of which was, first, to organize a resistance against Assyria, and second, to force Ahaz to codperate in their designs against the common tyrant. Inthe event of Ahaz’ refusal, they planned to depose him, and to set the son of Tabeel, a choice of their own, upon the throne of David. To this end they waged war against Judah, advancing as far as Jerus itself, but without complete success (Isa 7 1). Ahaz, a Immanuel Immortal THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1458 weak king, and now panic-stricken, determined to invoke the aid of Tiglath-pileser, king of Assyria (2 K 16 7). This he actually did at a later stage in the war (6 9; 15 29). Such a course would in- volve the loss of national independence and the payment of a heavy tribute. At this period of crisis, Isaiah, gathering his disciples around him (Isa 8 16), is told to deliver a message to the king. Ahaz, though making a show of resistance against the coalition, is in reality neither depending upon the help of Jeh nor upon the courage of his people. Isaiah, in an effort to calm his fears and prevent the fatal alliance with Assyria, offers him a sign. This method is specially characteristic of this prophet. Fearing to commit himself to the policy of Divine dependence, but with a pretense at religious scruples, “Neither will I tempt Jeh,” the king refuses (Isa 7 12). The prophet then chides him bitterly for his lack of faith, which, he says, not only wearies men, but God also (7 18). He then proceeds to give him a sign from God Himeelf, the sign of “Immanuel” (7 14). Theinter- pretation of this sign is not clear, even 2. The apart from its NT application to Sign of hrist. The Heb word tr ‘virgin’ “Imman- in EV means, more correctly, “bride,” uel” in the OE sense of one who is about to become a wife, or is still a young wife. Ps 68 25 EV gives ‘‘damsels.”’ Isaiah predicts that a young bride shall conceive and bear a son. The miracle of virgin-conception, therefore, is not implied. The use of the definite article before ‘“‘virgin” (hd-‘almah) does not of it- self indicate that the prophet had any particular FOUnE woman in his mind, as the Heb idiom often uses the definite article indefinitely. The fact that two other children of the prophet, like Hosea’s, bore prophetic and mysterious names, invites the conjecture that the bride referred to was his own wife. The hypothesis of some critics that a woman of the harem of Ahaz became the mother of Heze- kiah, and that he was the Immanuel of the prophet’s thought is not feasible. Hezckiah was at least 9 years of age when the prophecy was given (2 K 16 2). Immanuel, in the prophetic economy, evidently stands on the same level with Shear-jashub (7 3) as the embodiment of a great idea, to which Isaiah again appeals in Isa 8 8 (see Isarau, VII). The question as to whether the sign given to Ahaz was favorable or not presents many difficulties. Was it a promise of good or a threat of 3. Was Ita judgment? It is evident that the Promise or prophet had first intended an omen of a Threat? deliverance and blessing (7 4.7). Did the king’s lack of faith alter the nature of the sign? Ver 9, ‘‘If ye will not believe,” etc, implies that it might have done so. The omission of ver 16, and esp. the words “‘whose two kings thou abhorrest,” greatly simplifies this theory, as “the land,’ singular, would more naturally refer to Judah than to Syria and Ephraim collectively. The omen would then become an easily interpreted threat, referring to the overthrow of Judah rather than that of her enemies. Immanuel should eat curdled milk and honey (ver 15), devastation re- ducing the land from an agricultural to a pastoral one. The obscure nature of the passage as it stands suggests strongly that it has suffered from interpolation. The contrary theory that the sign was a promise and not a prediction of disaster, has much to commend it, though it necessitates greater freedom with the text. The name “Immanuel” im- plies the faith of the young mother of the child in the early deliverance of her country, and a rebuke to the lack of that quality in Ahaz. It is certain also that Isaiah looked for the destruction of Syria and Ephraim, and that, subsequent to the Assyr invasion, salvation should come to Judah through the remnant that had been faithful (11 11). The fact that the prophet later gave the name of Maher- shalal-hash-baz to his new-born son, a name of good omen to his country, further strengthens this posi- tion. The omission of vs 15.17 would make the sign a prophecy of the failure of the coalition. It is plain, whichever theory be accepted, that something must be eliminated from the passage to insure a consistent reading. The question now presents itself as to what was the relation of Immanuel to the Messianic prophe- Should the emphasis be laid cies. 4. Its Re- upon ‘‘a virgin,’”’ the son, or the name lation to itself? For traditional interpretation the Mes- the sign lay in the virgin birth, but sianic Hope the uncertainty of implied virginity in the Heb noun makes this interpre- tation improbable. The identification of the young mother as Zion personified, and of the ‘‘son’’ as the future generation, is suggested by Whitehouse and other scholars. But there is no evidence that the term ‘almah was used at that time for_personifi- cation. The third alternative makes Immanuel a Messiah in the wider use of the term, as antici- pated by Isaiah and his contemporaries. There can be little doubt but that there existed in Judah the Messianic hope of a national saviour (2 8 7 12). Isaiah is expecting the arrival of one whose character and work shall entitle him to the great names of 9 6. In him should dwell all the fulness of God. He was to be “of the stem of Jesse,’ the bringer of the Golden Age. The house of David is now beset by enemies, and its reigning repre- sentative is weak in faith. The prophet therefore announces the immediate coming of the deliverer. If he had intended the virgin-conception of Christ in the distant future, the sign of ‘‘Immanuel” would have possessed no immediate significance, nor would it have heen an omen to Ahaz. With regard to the Messianic idea, Mic 5 3 (‘‘until the time that she who travaileth hath brought forth’) is of impor- tance as indicating the prevalent thought of the time. Recent evidence shows that even in Babylonia and Egypt there existed expectations of a divinely born and wonderful saviour. To this popular tradition the prophet probably appealed, his hearers being easily able to appreciate the force of oracular lan- guage that is to us obscure. There is much to con- firm the view, therefore, that the prophecy is Messianic. The use of the word as it relates to the virgin birth of Christ and the incarnation cannot be dealt with here (see PrERson oF Cunist). 5. The These facts, however, may be noted. Virgin The LXX (which has parthénos, Birth “virgin’”) and the Alexandrian Jews _ interpreted the passage as referring to the virgin birth and the Messianic ministry. This interpretation does not seem to have been sufficiently prominent to explain the rise of the idea of miraculous virgin conception and the large place it has occupied in Christological thought. See Vircin BIrts. ARTHUR WALWYN Evans IMMER, im’ér (V8 , ’immaér): (1) A priest of David’s time (1 Ch 24 14), whose descendants are mentioned in Ezr 2 37; 10 20; Neh 3 29; 7 40; 11 13. (2) A priest of Jeremiah’s time (Jer 20 1). (3) A place in Babylonia (Ezr 2 59; Neh 7 61). IMMORTAL, i-mér’tal, IMMORTALITY, im-or- tal’i-ti (G@avacla, athanasia, 1 Cor 16 53; 1 Tim 6 16, dp0apola, aphiharsta, lit. “incorruption,” Rom 27; 1 Cor 15; 2 Tim 1 10, &d@aptos, dphthartos, 1459 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Immanuel Immortal ie eee ’ Rom 1 23; 1 Cor 15 52; 1 Tim 1, Preliminary—Need of Definition and Distinction 2. Bihiicai Conception I. Tue Narourat Berrer 1. Its Origin 2. Phiiosophicai Arguments (1) The Soul Spirituai Soul not Inherentiy Indestructihie a Capacities of Human Nature 3) The Moral Argument Il. Tue Brsticat Docrrinz—txs OT 1. Starting-Point—Man's Reiation to God Man's Nature 2. Sin and Death 3. Grace and Redemption—The True Immortaiity Deliverance from Sheol 4. Later Jewish Thought Til. Tue Crristian Hore 1. Immortality through Christ (1) Survival of the Soul 2) Union with Christ in Unseen Worid 3) The Resurrection 4) The Wicked Also Raised 5) Eternal Life 2. Contrasts LITERATURE In hardly any subject is it more necessary to be careful in the definition of terms and clear dis- tinction of ideas, esp. where the Bib. 1. Prelimi- doctrine is concerned, than in this of nary— ‘Immortality.’ By “immortality” is Need of frequently meant simply the survival Definition of the soul, or spiritual part of man, and Dis- after bodily death. It is the assertion tinction of the fact that death does not end all. The soul survives. This is commonly what is meant when we speak of “a future life,” “a future state,” ‘a hereafter.” Not, however, to dwell on the fact that many peoples have no clear conception of an immaterial “soul” in the modern sense (the Egyptians, e.g. distinguished several parts, the Ka, the Ba, etc, which survived death; often the surviving self is simply a ghostly resem- blance of the earthly self, nourished with food, offerings, etc), there is the more serious considera- tion that the state into which the surviving part is supposed to enter at death is anything but a state which can he described as “‘ife,’’ or worthy to be dignified with the name “immortality.” It is a state peculiar to “death” (see DEATH); in most cases, shadowy, inert, feeble, dependent, joyless; a state to be dreaded and shrunk from, not one to be hoped for. If, on the other hand, as in the hope of immortality among the nobler heathen, it is con- ceived of, as for some, a state of happiness—the clog of the body being shaken off—this yields the idea, which has passed into so much of our modern think- ing, of an “immortality of the soul,” of an imperish- ableness of the spiritual part, sometimes supposed to extend backward as well as forward; an inherent indestructibility. It will be seen as we advance, that the Bib. view is different from all of these. The soul, indeed, sur- vives the body; hut this disembodied 2. Biblical state is never viewed as one of com- Conception - plete “life.”’ For the Bible “immor- tality’’ is not merely the survival of the soul, the passing into “Sheol” or “Hades.” This is not, in itself considered, “life’’ or happiness. The “immortality” the Bible contemplates is an immortality of the whole person—body and soul together. It implies, therefore, deliverance from the state of death. It is not a condition simply of future existence, however prolonged, but a state of hlessedness, due to redemption and the possession of the “eternal life’ in the soul; it includes resur- rection and perfected life in both soul and body. The subject must now he considered more particu- larly in its different aspects. I. The Natural Belief.—In some sort the belief in the survival of the spirit or self at death is a practically universal phenomenon. To what is it taccabler A favorite hypothesis with anthro- pologists is that it has ita origin in 1. Its dreams or visions suggesting the con- Origin tinued existence of the dead (cf H. Spencer, Eccles. Instit., chs i, xiv). Before, however, a dream can suggest the survival of the soul, there must be the idea of the soul, and of this there seems a simpler explanation in the con- sciousness which even the savage possesses of some- thing within him that thinks, feels and wills, in distinction from his bodily organs. At death this thinking, feeling something disappears, while the body remains. What more natural than to sup- pose that it persists in some other state apart from the body? (Cf Max Miiller, Anthrop. Religion, 281.) Dreams, etc, may help this conviction, hut need not create it. It1s only as we assume such a deeper root for the belief that we can account for its uni- versality and persistence. Iiven this, however, while an instinctive presumption, can hardly be called a proof of survival after death, and it does not yield an idea of “immortality” in any worthy sense. It is at most, as already said, a ghostly redupli- cation of the earthly life that is thus far reached. (1) The soul spiritual—The more philosophical arguments that are adduced for the soul’s immor- tality (or survival) are not all of equal 2. Phil- weight. The argument based on the osophical metaphysical essence of the soul (see Arguments Plato’s Phaedo) is not in these days felt to be satisfying. On the other hand, it can be maintained against the materialist on irrefragable grounds that the soul, or thinking spirit, in man is immaterial in Nature, and, where this is granted, there is, or can be, no proof that death, or physical dissolution, destroys this con- scious spirit. The presumption is powerfully the other way. Cicero of old argued that death need not even be the suspension of its powers (cf Tusc. Disp. i.20); Butler reasons the matter from analogy (Anal., I, ch i); modern scientists like J. S. Mill (Three Essays, 201) and Professor Huxley (Life and Letters, I, 217 ff; cf William James, Ingersoll Lecture) concede that immortality cannot be dis- proved. The denial one hears from various sides more frequently than formerly is therefore not warranted. Still possibility is not certainty, and there is nothing as yet to show that even if the soul survives death, its new state of existence has in it anything desirable. It was hinted that one use which the Greeks made of the metaphysical argument was to prove the indestructibility of the soul—its immortality in the sense of having no beginning and no end. This is not the Christian doctrine. The soul has no such inherent indestructibility. It is dependent on God, as everything else is, for its continued existence. Did He withdraw His sustaining power, it would cease to exist. That it does continue to exist is not doubted, but this must be argued on other grounds. (2) Capacities of human nature—A much more apprehensihle argument for immortality—more strictly, of a future state of existence—is drawn from the rich capacities and possibilities of human nature, for which the earthly life affords so brief and inadequate a sphere of exercise. It is the characteristic of spirit that it has in it an clement of infinitude, and aspires to the infinite. The best the world can give can never satisfy it. It has in it the possibility of endless progress, and ever higher satisfaction. It was this consideration which led Kant, with all his theoretical skepticism, to give immortality a place among his “doctrinal belicfs” (see his Critique of Pure Reason, Bohn’s tr, 590-91), and moved J. §. Mill to speak of it as the only hope Immortal Impediment THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1460 which gave adequate scope to the human faculties and feelings, ‘‘the loftier aspirations being no longer kept down by a sense of the insignificance of human life by the disastrous feeling of ‘not worth while’”’ (Three Essays, 249). Yet when these arguments are calmly weighed, they amount to no more than a proof that man is constituted for immortality; they do not afford a guarantee that this destiny might not be forfeited, or if they yield such a guarantee for the good, they hardly do so for the wicked. The belief, in their case, must depend on other con- siderations. (3) The moral argument.—It is, as Kant also felt, when we enter the moral sphere that immortality, or the continued existence of the soul, becomes a practical certainty to the earnest mind. With moral personality is bound up the idea of moral law and moral responsibility; this, in turn, necessitates the thought of the world as a moral system, and of God as moral Ruler. The world, as we know it, is certainly a scene of moral administration—of pro- bation, of discipline, of reward and penalty—but as obviously a scene of incomplete moral adminis- tration. The tangled condition of things in this life can satisfy no one’s sense of justice. Goodness is left to suffer; wickedness outwardly triumphs. The evil-doer’s own conscience proclaims him answerable, and points to future judgment. There is need for a final rectification of what is wrong here. But while a future state seems thus called for, this does not of itself secure eternal existence for the wicked, nor would such existence be “immortality’’ in the positive sense. In view of the mystery of sin, the lamp of reason grows dim. For further light we must look to revelation. : Il. The Biblical Doctrine—the OT.—The Bib. view of immortality starts from man’s relation to God. Man, as made in the image i. Starting- of God (Gen 1 27), is fitted for the Point— knowledge of God, for fellowship with Man’s Him. This implies that man is more Relation than an animal; that he has a life to God which transcends time. In it already lies the pledge of immortality if man is obedient. Man’s nature-—With this corresponds the ac- count given of man’s creation and original state. Man is a being composed of body and soul; both are integral parts of his personality. He was created for life, not for mortality. The warning, “In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die’? (Gen 2 17), implies that if man con- tinued obedient he would live. But this is not an immortality of the soul only. It is a life in the body (cf Gen 3 22). Its type is such cases as Enoch and Flijah (Gen 6 24; 2K 2 11.12; ef Ps 49 15; 73 24). The frustration of this original destiny of man comes through sin. Sin entails death (see DEATH). Death in its physical aspect is a sepa- 2. Sin and ration of soul and body—a breaking Death up of the unity of man’s personality. In one sense, therefore, it is the de- struction of the immortality which was man’s original destiny. It does not, however, imply the extinction of the soul. That survives, but not in a state that can be called “‘life.’’ It passes into Sheol —the sad, gloomy abode of the dead, in which there is no joy, activity, knowledge of the affairs of earth, or (in the view of Nature) remembrance of God, or praise of His goodness (on this subject, and the Heb belief in the future state generally, see Escra- ToLoGY or THE OT; Deatx; Sueon). This is not future “life’’-—not “immortality.” It is the part of grace and redemption to restore immortality in the true sense. Had the world been left to develop in sin, no further hope could have come to it. The picture of Sheol would have become ever darker as the idea of retribution grew stronger; it could never become 8. Grace brighter. But God’s grace iter- and Re- vened: “Deliver him from going down demption— to the pit, I have found a ransom” the True (Job 33 24). God’s mercy breaks in Immortality on the hopelessness of man’s lot. He gives to man His promises; makes His covenant with man; admits man to His fellowship (Gen 3 15; 44; 6 24; 6 8.9; 12 1-3; 16, etc). In this fellowship the soul was raised again to its true life even on earth. But this held in it also a hope for the future. The promises placed in the forefront as tokens of God’s favors were indeed predominatingly temporal—promises for this life -—but within these (the kernel within the shell) was the supreme possession of God Himself (Ps 4 6f; 16 2). This held in it the hope of redemption and the principle of every good. Deliverance from Sheol.—Here we reach the core of the OT hope of immortality. Such fellowship as the believer had with God could not be lost, even in Sheol; beyond that was deliverance from Sheol. In their highest moments it was this hope that sustained patriarchs, psalmists, prophets, in their outlook on the future. Doubt might cloud their minds; there might be seasons of darkness and even despair; but it was impossible in moments of strong faith to believe that God would ever really desert them. The eternal God was their dwelling-place; beneath them were everlasting arms (Dt 33 27; cf Ps 90 1). Their hope of immortality, therefore, was, in principle, the hope not merely of an “immor- tality of the soul,” but likewise of resurrection—of complete deliverance from Sheol. Thus it is clearly in the impassioned outburst of Job (19 25-27; ef 14 13 ff), and in many of the psalms. The hope always clothes itself in the form of complete deliv- erance from Sheol. Thus in Ps 17 141i, the wicked have their portion “in this life,’ but, “‘As for me, I shall behold thy face in righteousness; I shall be satisfied, when I awake, with thy likeness’? (ARV “with beholding thy form’’); and in Ps 49 14{, the wicked are “appointed as a flock for Sheol,” but “God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol; for he will receive me” (same expression as that regarding Enoch, Gen 6 24; ef Ps 73 24). It will be remembered that when Jesus expounded the declaration, “I am the God of Abraham,’ ete, it was as a pledge of resurrection (Mt 22 31f). The idea comes to final expression in the declaration in Dnl of a resurrection of the just and unjust (12 2). For further development and illustration see Es- CHATOLOGY OF THE OT. Later Jewish thought carried out these ideas of the OT to further issues. A blessed future for the righteous was now accepted, and 4, Later was definitely connected with the idea Jewish of resurrection. The wicked remained Thought in Sheol, now conceived _of as a place of retribution. The Gentiles, too, shared this doom. See EscHatouoey. Il. The Christian Hope.—In full consonance with what is revealed in part in the OT is the hope of immortality discovered in the NT. 1. Immor- The ring of this joyful hope is heard tality in every part of the apostolic writings. through “Blessed be the God and Father of our Christ Lord Jesus Christ,” says Peter, “who ' according to his great mercy begat us again unto a living hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead, unto an inheritance incor- ruptible, and undefiled, and that fadeth not away, reserved in heaven for you” (1 Pet 1 3f). Paul declares, “‘Our Saviour Christ Jesus, who... . brought life and immortality [incorruption] to 1461 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Immortal Impediment light through the gospel” (2 Tim 1 10). In Rom 27 he had spoken of those who “by patience in well-doing seek for glory and honor and incorrup- tion, eternal life.’ This immortality, it is seen, is pat of the eternal life bestowed through Jesus on elievers. Itis guaranteed by Christ’s own resurrec- tion and life in glory. The nature of this hope of the gospel may now he further analyzed. (1) Survival of the soul.—The soul survives the body. A future state for both righteous and wicked is plainly declared by Jesus Himself. ‘He that be- ieveth on me,” He said to Martha, “though he die, yet shall he live; and whosoever liveth and be- lieveth on me shall never die’ (Jn 11 25f). To His disciples He said, “If I go and prepare a place for you, I come again, and will receive you unto myself; that where J am, there ye may be also” (Jn 14 3). Cf His words to the penitent thief: “To-day shalt thou be with me in Paradise’ (Lk 23 43). The survival of both righteous and wicked is implied in the parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Lk 16 19-31). So in many other places (e.g. Mt 5 29f; 10 28; 11 21-24; 12 41, etc). The same is the teaching of the epp. The doctrine of a future judgment depends on and presupposes this truth (Rom 2 5-11; 2 Cor 5 10, ete). (2) Union with Christ in unseen world.—Death for the redeemed, though a result of sin, does not destroy the soul’s relation to God and to Christ. The eternal life implanted in the soul in time blos- soms in its fruition into the life and blessedness of eternity (Rom 8 10f; Phil 1 21; Col 1 27). The soul is, indeed, in an incomplete state till the resur- rection. It ‘‘waits for our adoption, to wit, the redemption of our body” (Rom 8 23). But its state, though incomplete, is still a happy one. Hades has lost its gloom, and is for it a “Paradise” (Lk 23 43). It dwells in a chamber of the Father’s house (Jn 14 2f; 17 24). It is to be, even in the unclothed state (“absent from the body’’), ‘‘at home with the Lord” (2 Cor 6 8). It is for it an object of desire to be “with Christ” in that state after death (Phil 1 21). The pictures in Rev, though highly figurative, indicate a condition of great blessedness (Rev 7 9-17). (3) The resurrection —The fulness of the blessed- ness of immortality implies the resurrection. The resurrection is a cardinal article of Christ’s teaching (Mt 22 29-32; Jn 5 25-29; 11 23-26). He Him- self is the Lord of life, and life-giver in the resur- rection (Jn 6 21.25.26; 11 25, “I am the resurrec- tion, and the life’). The resurrection of believers is secured by His own resurrection. Jesus died; He rose again (see Resurrection). His resur~ rection carries with it the certainty of the resur- rection of all His people. This is the great theme of 1 Cor 16. As Christ lives, they shall live also (Jn 14 19). The believers who are alive at His Parousia shall be changed (1 Cor 16 51; 1 Thess 4 17); those who are dead shall be raised first of all (1 Thess 4 16). The resurrection body shall be a body like to Christ’s own (Phil 3 21)—incor- ruptible, glorious, powerful, spiritual, immortal (1 Cor 16 42 ff.58f). This is not to be confused with sameness of material particles (vs 37f), yet there is the connection of a vital bond between the old body and the new. This is the hope of the be- liever, without which his redemption would not be complete. (4) The wicked also raised—The wicked also are raised, not, however, to glory, but for judgment (Jn 5 29; Acts 24 15; Rev 20 12-15). Thesame truth is implied in all passages on the last judgment. Excluded from the blessedness of the righteous, their state is described by both Jesus and His apostles as one of uttermost tribulation and an- guish (eg. Mt 25 46; Mk 9 43-50; Rom 2 8f). This is not “immortality” or “life,” though the con- tinued existence of the soul is implied in it (see PounisuMentT, Evertastinc; Herxzt; Rerrisv- TION). (5) Eternal life—The condition of the blessed in their state of immortality is one of unspeakable felicity of both soul and body forever. ‘There are, indeed, degrees of glory—this is carefully and con- sistently taught (Mt 26 14 ff; Lk 19 12ff; 1 Cor 3 10-15; 16 41; Phil 3 10-14; 2 Tim 47f; 1 Jn 2 28)—but the condition as a whole is one of perfect satisfaction, holiness and blessedness (cf Mt 13 43; 26 34; Rom 2 7.10; Rev 22 3 ff, etc). The bless- edness of this eternal state includes such elements as the following: (1) restoration to God’s image and likeness to Christ (1 Cor 16 49; 2 Cor 3 18; Eph 4 24; Col 3 10; 1 Jn 3 2); (2) perfect holi- ness in the possession of God’s Spirit (2 Cor 7 1; Phil 1 6; Rev 21 27; 22 4.11); (8) the unveiled vision of God’s glory (Rev 22 4; ef Ps 17 15); (4) freedom from all sorrow, pain and death (Rev 21 3f); (5) power of unwearied service (Rev 22 3). The contrast between the Bib. view of immor- tality and that of heathenism and of the schools will now be obvious. It is not mere 2. Contrasts future existence; not a bare, abstract immortality of the soul; it is the result of redemption and of renewal by God's spirit; it embraces the whole personality, soul and body; itis not shared by the unholy; it includes the perfec- tion of rational, moral and spiritual blessedness, in an environment suitable to such glorified existence. As such it is the supreme prize after which every believer is called to strive (Phil 3 13 f). Lireratvury.—Ingersoll Lectures on Immortality, by Professor William James, Professor Osler, etc; Salmond, Christian Doctrine of Immortality; Orr, Christian View of God and the World, Lects iv, v, with App. to v; works specified in art. on EscuatoLooyr. James ORR IMMUTABILITY, i-mi-ta-bil’i-ti, IMMUTA- BLE, i-mii‘ta-b’l (Gperd@eros, ametdihetos): Occurs in He 6 17.18 of the unchangeableness of the Di- vine counsel. It is the perfection of Jeh that He changes not in character, will, purpose, aim (Mal 3 6; so of Christ, He 13 8). See FarraruLness; UNCHANGEABLE. IMNA, im‘na (72907, yimna'): A descendant of Asher (1 Ch 7 35). IMNAG, im’na (1}"0", yémnah): (1) Eldest son of Asher (Gen 46 17, AV “‘Jim- nah’; Nu 26 44, AV “Jimna’; 1 Ch 7 30). (2) A Levite of Hezekiah’s time (2 Ch 31 14). IMNITES, im/nits ((272", yimni): Descendants of Imnan (q.v.[1]) (Nu 26 44, AV “Jimnites”). IMPART, im-pArt’ (perab(Sap1, metadidomi, ‘to share’): “They... . imparted [AV “added”] nothing to me’’ (Gal 2 6); that is, did not propose any correction or addition to my teaching. ‘That T may impart unto you some spiritual gift’? (Rom 1 11) expresses the apostle’s hope that the Rom be- lievers may increase in faith and love through his teaching and influence. “To impart unto you... . our own souls” (1 Thess 2 8) meant to spend their utmost strength and to expose their lives in their service. IMPEDIMENT, im-ped’i-ment: Found in Mk 7 32, “had an impediment in his speech,” as a tr of poylharos, mogilalos, comp. of péyos, mégos, “toil” and Ad2os, ldlos, “‘speech,’”’ i.e. one who speaks with difficulty. In the LXX the word is used as a tr of DON, lam, “dumb” (Isa 36 6). Implead Imputation THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1462 _ IMPLEAD, im-pléd’ (Acts 19 38 AV, “Let them implead one another’): ‘“Implead’”’ means ‘‘to sue at law,” hence RV “Let them accuse one another.” Court days are kept, let them prosecute the suit in court and not settle matters in riot. é¢yxanely, egkalein, means “‘to call in,” “to call to account.” IMPORTABLE, im-pdor’ta-b’] (8veBderakros, dusbdstaktos): An obsolete word, meaning ‘‘unbear- able’’ (Lat im, ‘not,’ portabilis, ‘“bearable’’) found in Pr Man, “Thine angry threatening [RV “the anger of thy threatening’’] toward sinners is im- portable”; cf Rheims version, Mt 23 4, “heavy burdens and importable’’; Chaucer (“Clerk’s Tale” C.T.), “For it were importable though they wolde.” IMPORTUNITY, im-por-ti’ni-ti: Occurs only in Lk 11 8, where it is the rendering of dvatdea, anaideia (WH, évaidla, anaidia). This Gr word implies an element of impudent insistence rising to the point of shamelessness which the Eng. word ‘importunity” fails to express, thus weakening the argument of the parable, which is that if by shame- less insistence a favor may be won, even from one unwilling and ungracious, still more surely will God answer the earnest prayer of His people. God’s willingness to give exceeds our ability to ask. The parable teaches by way of contrast, not by parallel. Davin Foster Estzs IMPOSITION, im-pé-zish’un, OF HANDS. See Hanns, Imrosition (LAYING oN) OF. IMPOSSIBLE, im-pos’i-b’l (vb. a$vvaréo, adu- natéd; adj &Btvaros, adtnatos): “To be impossi- ble” is the tr of adunated, “to be powerless,” “im- potent” (Mt 17 20; Lk 1 37, RV “void of power’); adunatos, ‘powerless,’ etc, is tr? “impossible” (Mt 19 26; Mk 10 27; Lk 18 27; He 6 4.18; 11 6; ‘“Gmpossible”’ in He 6 4 is in RV transferred to ver 6); anéndektos, ‘not to be received” or “accepted,” is also tr? “impossible’’ (Lk 17 1). In several of these passages it is affirmed that “nothing is impos- sible with God,’”’ but, of course, this means nothing that is consistent with the Divine nature, e.g. (as He 6 18) it is not possible for God to lie. So, when it is said that nothing is impossible to faith, the same limitation applies and also that of the mind or will of God for us. But much more is possible to a strong faith than a weak faith realizes, or even believes. WALKER IMPOTENT, im’pé-tent (do¥evéo, asthenéa, aSbvatos, adunatos): The vb. signifies “to be with- out strength,’”’ and derivatives of it are used inJn 5 3.7 AV and Acts 4 9 to characterize the paralyzed man at Bethesda and the cripple at the Temple gate. For the same condition of the Lystra lame man the word adunatos is used, which is synonymous. In these cases it is the weakness of disease. In this sense the word is used by Shakespeare (Love’s Labor Lost, V, ii, 864; Hamlet, I, ii, 29). The impotent folk referred to n the Epistle of Jeremy (Bar 6 28) were those weak and feeble from age and want; cf ‘impotent and snail-paced beggary” (Richard [I], IV, iii, 53). ALEX. MACALISTER IMPRISONMENT, im-priz’n-ment. See Poun- ISHMENTS; PRISON. IMPURITY, im-pi’ri-ti. See UNCLEANNEsS. IMPUTATION, im-pii-ta’shun: I. Meanino anp UsE oF THE TERM II. Tre Tureeroup Ust& or THE TERM IN THEOLOOY Original Sin, Atonement, Justification III. Tse Scriprorat Basis or THese Doctrines 1. Imputation of Adam’s Sin to His Posterity 2. Imputation of the Sins of His People to Christ 3. Imputation of the Righteousness of Christ to His People LivERATURE I. Meaning and Use of the Term.—The word “imputation,” according to the Scriptural usage, denotes an attributing of something to a person, or a charging of one with anything, or a setting of something to one’s account. This takes place some- times in a judicial manner, so that the thing im- puted becomes a ground of reward or punishment. The word is used in AV a number of times to trans- late the Heb vb. hashabh and the Gr vb. logizomav. These words, both of which occur frequently in Scripture, and which in a number of instances mean simply ‘‘to think,” express the above idea. That this is the case is clear also from the other Eng. words used in AV to translate these Heb and Gr words, as, for example, “to count,” “‘to reckon,” ‘“‘to esteem.” Thus hdshabh is tr? in AV by the vb. “‘to impute” (Lev 718; 17 4; 28 19 19); by the vb. “to reckon” (2 8 4 2); by “to count’’ as some- thing (Lev 26 31 EV). The vb. in 158 22 15 is DW, stm. Similarly, logizomat is tr¢ by the vb. “‘to impute’ (Rom 4 6.8.11.22.23.24; 2 Cor 5 19; Jas 2 23); by the vb. “to count” (Rom 2 26; 4 3.5); “to account’ (Gal 3 6); and by the vb. ‘‘to reck- on” (Rom 4 4.9.10). In RV the word used to render logizomai is the vb. ‘‘to reckon.” These synonyms of the vb. “to impute” bring out the idea of reckoning or charging to one’s ac- count. It makes no difference, so far as the meaning of imputation is concerned, who it is that imputes, whether man (1 8 22 15) or God (Ps 32 2); it makes no difference what is imputed, whether a good deed for reward (Ps 106 301) or a bad deed for punishment (Lev 17 4); and it makes no differ- ence whether that which is imputed is something which is personally one’s own prior to the imputa- tion, as in the case above cited, where his own good deed was imputed to Phinehas (Ps 106 301), or something which is not personally one’s own prior to the imputation, as where Paul asks that a debt not personally his own be charged to him (Philem ver 18). In all these cases the act of imputation is simply the charging of one with something. It denotes just what we mean by our ordinary use of the term. It does not change the inward state or character of the person to whom something is im- puted. When, for example, we say that we impute bad motives to anyone, we do not mean that we make such a one bad; and just so in the Scripture the phrase “to impute iniquity’? does not mean to make one personally bad, but_simply to lay iniquity to his charge. Hence when God is said ‘‘to impute sin’ to anyone, the meaning is that God accounts such a one to be a sinner, and consequently guilty and liable to punishment. Similarly, the non- imputation of sin means simply not to lay it to one’s charge as a ground of punishment (Ps 32 2). In the same manner, when God is said “to impute righteousness’’ to a person, the meaning is that He judicially accounts such a one to be righteous and entitled to all the rewards of a righteous person (Rom 4 6.11). Hl. The Threefold Use of the Termin Theology.— Three acts of imputation are given special promi- nence in the Scripture, and are implicated in the Scriptural doctrines of Original Sin, Atonement and Justification, though not usually expressed by the words hashabh and logizomai. “Because, how- ever, of its “forensic” or “judicial” meaning, and possibly through its use in the Vulg to translate logizomai in Rom 4 8, the term “imputation” has ~ been used in theology in a threefold sense to denote the judicial acts of God by which the guilt of Adam’s sin is imputed to his posterity; by which the sing 1463 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Implead Imputation of Christ’s people are imputed to Him; and by which the righteousness of Christ is imputed to His people. The act of imputation is precisely the same in each case. It is not meant that Adam’s sin was personally the sin of his descendants, but that it was set to their account, so that they share its guilt and penalty. It is not meant that Christ shares personally in the sins of men, but that the guilt of His people’s sin was set to his account, so that He bore its penalty. It is not meant that Christ’s people are made personally holy or inwardly right- eous by the imputation of His righteousness to them, but that His righteousness is set to their ac- count, so that they are entitled to all the rewards of that perfect righteousness. These doctrines have had a place in the theology of the Christian church from the earliest Christian cents., though the doctrine of the imputation of the righteousness of Christ was first fully and clearly stated at the time of and following the Reformation. The first two of these doctrines have been the pos- session of the entire Christian church, while the third one of them is affirmed by both the Reformed and Lutheran branches of Protestantism. iif. The Scriptural Basis of These Doctrines.— These three doctrines have a basis in the Scripture, and underlie the Scripture doctrines of Original Sin, Atonement, and Justification. The doctrine of the imputation of Adam’s sin to his posterity is implied in the account of the Fall in Gen 2 and 3, taken in connection 1. Imputa- with the subsequent history of the tion of human race as recorded in Gen and Adam’s Sin in the rest of the OT. Many ancient to His and modern interpreters regard this Posterity narrative as an allegorical, mythical or symbolical representation in his- torical form, either of a psychological fact, i.e. of something which takes place in every individual, or of certain general truths concerning sin. By some exegetes, following Kant, it has been held to depict an advance of the race in culture or ethical knowledge (Reuss; against which view cf Budde, Clemen); by others it has been regarded as a sym- bolical representation of certain truths concerning sin (Oehler, Schultz); by others it has been regarded as historical (Delitzsch). This latter view is the one which accords with the narrative itself. It is evidently intended as historical by its author, and is so regarded by the NT writers. It is, moreover, introduced to explain, not an advance of the race, but the entrance of sin into the world, and the con- nection of certain penal evils with sin. It does this by showing how these evils came upon Adam as a punishment for his disobedience, and the sub- sequent history shows that his posterity were sub- jected to the same evils. It is true that the threat of punishment to Adam in case of disobedience was made to him alone, and that the penalties threat- ened are said to have come only upon him and Eve (Gen 3 16-19). Nevertheless, it is clear from the account of the subsequent history of the race that it actually shared in the punishments inflicted upon Adam, and that this was in consequence of his sin. . This implies that in Gen 2 16f are contained the terms of a covenant in which Adam acted as the representative of the race. If, therefore, the race shares in the penalty of Adam’s sin, it must also share in his guilt or the judicial obligation to suffer punishment. And this is precisely what the the- ology of the entire Christian church has meant by saying that the guilt of Adam’s sin was imputed to his posterity. This is in accordance with God’s method of dealing with men in other recorded in- stances (Gen 19 15; Ex 20 5; Dt 1 37; 3 26); and the assertion of the principle of personal re- sponsibility by Ezekiel and Jeremiah against an abuse of the principle of representative responsi- bility implies a recognition of the latter (Ezk 18 2.4; 33 12; Jer 31 29). The universality of sin and death is not brought into connection with the Fall of Adam by the other OT writers. This is done, however, by Paul. In 1 Cor 16 21f, Paul says that the death of all men has its cause in the man Adam in the same way in which the resurrection from the dead has its cause in the man Christ. The death of all men, accord- ingly, is not brought about by their personal sins, but has come upon all through the disobedience of Adam. Upon what ground this takes place, Paul states in the passage Rom 5 12-21. He intro- duces the subject of Adam’s relation to the race to illustrate his doctrine of the justification of sinners on the ground of a righteousness which is not per- sonally their own. In order to do this he takes the truth, well known to his readers, that all men are under condemnation on account of Adam’s sin. The comparison is between Adam and Christ, and the specific point of the comparison is imputed sin and imputed righteousness. Hence in ver 12 Paul does not mean simply to affirm that as Adam sinned and consequently died, so men sin and die. Nor can he mean to say that just as God established a precedent in Adam’s case that death should follow sin, so He acts upon this precedent in the case of all men because all sin, the real ground of the reign of death being the fact that all sin, and the formal ground being this precedent (B. Weiss); nor that the real ground is this precedent and the subordi- nate ground the fact that all sin (Hiinefeld). Neither can Paul intend to say that all men are sub- ject to death because they derive a corrupt nature from Adam (Fritzsche); nor that men are con- demned to die because all have sinned (Pfleiderer). Paul’s purpose is to illustrate his doctrine of the way in which men are delivered from sin and death by the way in which they are brought into con- demnation. The main thought of the passage is that, just as men are condemned on account of the imputation to them of the guilt of Adam’s sin, so they are justified on account of the imputation to them of the righteousness of Christ. Paul says that it was by one man that sin and death entered into the world, and it was by one man that death passed to all men, because all were implicated in the guilt of that one man’s sin (ver 12). In proof of this the apostle cites the fact that death as a punishment was reigning during a period in which the only possible judicial ground of this fact must have been the imputation of the guilt of that one man’s sin (vs 13.14). Hence there is a precise parallel between Adam and Christ. Just as men are condemned on account of Adam’s disobedience, so they are justified on account of the obedience of Christ (vs 18.19). The thought of the passage is imputed sin and imputed righteousness as the ground of condemnation and of justification respectively. That our sins are imputed to Christ is not ex- pressly stated in the Scripture, but is implied in those passages which affirm that Christ “bore 2. The our sins,” and that our iniquities were Imputation “laid upon him” by Jeh. To bear of the Sins inquity or sin, though it may some- of His times mean to bear it away or remove People to it, is an expression often applied in Christ Seripture to persons charged with guilt and subjected to the punishment of their own sin (Lev 5 17; 7 18; 19 8; 22 9). That the Heb vb. nasd@’ has this meaning is also indicated by its being interchanged with the vb. sabhal, which means ‘‘to bear as a burden” and is used to denote the bearing of the punishment of sin (Isa 53 11). In the OT sacrificial system, which according to the NT is typical of the sacrifice of Imputation THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1464 Christ, the imposition of hands on the head of the victim signified the substitution of it for the offender and the transfer of his guilt to it. This idea is brought out clearly in the case of the two goats on the great Day of Atonement (Lev 16). When, therefore, the Servant of Jeh in Isa 58 is said ‘“‘to bear iniquity” (ver 11), or that “the chastisement of our peace was upon him ’’(ver 5), or that ‘‘Jeh hath laid [lit. “‘caused to fall’’] on him the iniquity of us all’’ (ver 6), the idea expressed is that Christ bore the punishment of our sin vicariously, its guilt having been imputed to Him. The thought of the prophecy is, as Delitzsch says, that of vicarious punishment, which implies the idea of the imputa- tion of the guilt of our sins to Christ. The same idea underlies these expressions when they occur in the NT. When Peter wishes to hold up Christ as an example of patience in suffering, he takes up the thought of Isa, and adduces the fact that Christ “his own self bare our sins in his body upon the tree’ (1 Pet 2 24). The context indi- eates that Peter had the prophecy of Isa 63 in mind, so that his meaning is, not that Christ carried our sins even up to the cross, but that in His death on the cross Christ bore the punishment of our sin, its guilt having been imputed to Him. The same thought is expressed by the writer of the Ep. to the He, where the contrast between the first and second advents of Christ is made to hinge upon the fact that in the first He came to be sacrificed as a sin- bearer, burdened with the guilt of the sin of others, whereas in His second coming He will appear with- out this burden of imputed or vicarious guilt (He 9 28). Paul also gives expression to the same thought when he says that Christ was “made to be sin on our behalf?’ (2 Cor 5 21), and that He became ‘‘a eurse for us” (Gal 3 13). In the former passage the idea of substitution, although not ex- pressed by the preposition hupér which indicates that Christ’s work was for our benefit, is neverthe- less clearly implied in the thought that Christ, whose sinlessness is emphasized in the ver, is made sin, and that we sinners become righteous in Him. Paul means that Christ was made to bear the enalty of our sin aud that its guilt was imputed to Flim in precisely the same way in which we sinners become the righteousness of God in Him, ie. by the imputation of His righteousness to us. The same thought is expressed in Gal 3 13, where the statement that Christ was made a curse for us means that He was made to eudure the curse or penalty of the broken law. In all these passages the under- lying thought is that the guilt of our sin was imputed to Christ. The righteousness upon the ground of which God justifies the ungodly is, according to Paul, witnessed to in the OT (Rom 8 21). 3. The Im- In order to obtain the blessedness putation of which comes from a right relation to the Right- God, the pardon or non-imputation of eousness of sin is necessary, and this takes place Christ to through the ‘‘covering” of sin (Ps 32 His People 1.2). The nature of this covering by the viearious bearing of the penalty of sin is made elear in Isa 63. It is, moreover, the teaching of the OT that the righteousness which God demands is not to be found among men (Ps 130 3; 143 2; Isa 64 6). Accordingly, the proph- ets speak of 9 righteousness which is not from man’s works, but which is said to be in Jeh or to come from Him to His people (Isa 32 16f;, 46 23 ff; 54 17; 568 8; 61 3; Jer 61 10; Hos 10 12). This idea finds its clearest expression in connection with the work of the Messiah in Jer 33 16, where Jerus is called “Jeh our righteousness” because of the coming of the Messianic king, and in Jer 23 6 where the same name is given to the Messiah to express His significance for Israel. Although the idea of the imputation of righteousness is not explicitly asserted in these passages, the idea is not merely that the righteousness spoken of is recognized by Jeh (Cremer), but that it comes from Him, so that Jeh, through the work of the Messiah, is the source of His people’s righteousness. me This idea is taken up by Paul, who makes explicit the way in which this righteousness comes to sin- ners, and who puts the idea of imputed righteous- ness at the basis of his doctrine of Justification. By the righteousness of Christ Paul means Christ’s legal status, or the merit acquired by all that He did in satisfying the demands of God’s law, includ- ing what has been called His active and passive obedience. Notwithstanding the fact that most of the modern expositors of Paul’s doctrine have denied that he teaches the imputation of Christ’s obedience, this doctrine has a basis in the apostle’s teaching. Justification leads to life and final glori- fication (Rom 5 18; 8 30); and Paul always con~ ceives the obtaining of life as dependent on the ful- filment of the law. _ If, therefore, Christ secures life for us, it can only be in accordance with this prin-~ ciple. Accordingly, the apostle emphasizes the element of obedience in the death of Christ, and places this act of obedience at the basis of the sinner’s justification (Rom 5 18). He also repre-- sents the obedience of the cross as the culminatin point of a life of obedience on Christ’s part (Ph 2 8). Moreover, Paul affirms that our redemption from all the demands of the law is secured by the fact that Christ was born under law (Gal 4 4). This cannot be restricted to the fact that Christ was under the curse of the law, for He was born under law and the result of this is that we are free from all of its demands. This doctrine is also im- plied in the apostle’s teaching that Justification is absolutely gracious, taken in connection with the fact that it leads to a complete salvation. The importance in Paul’s thought of the doctrine of the imputation of the righteousness of Christ to the believer can be seen from the fact that the ques- tion how righteousness was to be obtained occupied a central place in his religious consciousness, both before and after his conversion. The apostle’s conversion by the appearance of the risen Christ determined his conception of the true way of ob- taining righteousness, since the resurrection of Christ meant for Paul the condemnation of his ee past search for righteousness by works of the aw. That the imputation of the righteousness of Christ to the believer does lie at the basis of Paul’s doctrine of Justification can be further seen from the fact that Justification is absolutely free and unmerited so far as the sinner is concerned (Rom 3 24; 6 15; Gal 5 4; Tit 3 7); its object being one who is ungodly (Rom 4 5); so that it is not by works (Rom 3 20.28; Gal 2 16; 3 11; 5 4; Phil 3 9); and yet that it is not a mere pardon of sin, but is a strictly ‘forensic’? or judicial judgment freeing the sinner from all the elaims of the law, an granting him the right to eternal life. This last truth is plain because God’s retributive righteous- ness lies at the basis of Paul’s doctrine of Justifi- cation (Rom 2); is manifested in it (Rom 8 25 f); because Christ’s expiatory work is its ground (Rom 3 25); and because our redemption from the curse of the law rests upon Christ’s having borne it for us, and our redemption from all the demands of the law depends upon their fulfilment by Christ (Gal 3 13; 4 4). Hence the gracious character of Jus- tification, according to Paul, does not consist in its being merely a gracious pardon without any judi- cial basis (Ritsch!); or in God’s acceptance of a subjective righteousness produced by Him in the 1465 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Imputation sinner (Tobac); or in the acceptance of faith in- stead of a perfect righteousness (Cremer). The gracious character of Justification consists for Paul in the fact that the righteousness on the ground of which God justifies the ungodly is a righteous- ness which is graciously provided by God, and which Paul contrasts with his own righteousness which comes from law works (Phil 3 9). The sinner, therefore, is pardoned and accepted as a righteous person, not on account of anything in himself, but only on account of what Christ has done for him, which means that the merits of Christ’s suffering and obedience are imputed to the sinner as the ground of his justification. This truth is explicitly affirmed by Paul, who speaks of God’s imputing righteousness without works, and of righteousness being imputed (Rom 46.11). The idea of the imputation of righteous- ness here is made clear by the context. The one who is declared righteous is said to be “ungodly” (4 5). Hence he is righteous only by God’s impu- tation of righteousness to him. This is also clear from the contrast between imputation according to grace and according to debt (4 4). He who seeks righteousness by works would be justified as a reward for his works, in antithesis to which, impu- tation according to grace would be the charging one with a righteousness which he does not possess. Accordingly, at the basis of Justification there is a reckoning to the sinner of an objective righteous- ness. This same idea is also implied and asserted by Paul in the parallel which he draws between Adam and Christ (Rom 5 18f). The apostle says that just as men are condemned on account of a sin not their own, so they are justified on account of a righteousness which is not their own. The idea of imputed sin and imputed righteousness, as was said, js the precise point of the parallelism between con- demnation in Adam and justification in Christ. This is also the idea which underlies the apostle’s contrast of the Old and New Covenants (2 Cor 3 9). The New Covenant is described as a “ministry of righteousness,” and contrasted with the Old Covenant which is described as a ‘‘ministry of con- demnation.” If, therefore, this last expression does not denote a subjective condition of men under the old dispensation, but their relation to God as objects of His condemnation, righteousness must denote the opposite of this relation to the law, and must depend on God’s judicial acquittal. Thesame truth is expressed by Paul more concretely by say- ing that Christ has been “‘made unto us righteous- ness from God”’ (1 Cor 1 30). Here the concrete mode of expression is chosen because Paul speaks also of Christ being our sanctification and redemp- tion, so that an expression had to be chosen which would cover all of these ideas. One of the clearest statements concerning this objective righteousness is Phil 39. The apostle here affirms that the righteousness which the believer in Christ obtains is directly opposite to his own righteousness. This latter comes from works of the law, whereas the former comes from God and through faith in Christ. It is, therefore, objective to man, comes to him from God, is connected with the work of Christ, and is mediated by faith in Christ. The idea clearly stated in this last passage of a righteousness which is objective to the sinner and which comes to him from God, i.e. the idea of a new legal standing given to the believer by God, explains the meaning, in most cases, of the Pauline phrase “righteousness of God.’’ This phrase is used by Paul 9 t: Rom 1 17; 3 5.21f.25f; 103 (twice); 2 Cor 5 21. It denotes the Divine attribute of righteousness in Rom 3 5.25f. The customary exegesis was to regard the other instances as de- noting the righteousness of a sinner which comes to him from God, in accordance with Phil 3 9. More recently Hacring, following Kélbing in general, has interpreted all these instances as denoting God’s justifying action. But this interpretation is most strained in 2 Cor 5 21, where we are said to “be- come the righteousness of God,” and in Rom 10 3-6, where the righteousness of God is identified with the righteousness which comes from faith, this latter being contrasted with man’s own inward righteousness. That a righteousness of man which he receives from God is here referred to, is confirmed by the fact that the reason given for the error of the Jews in seeking a righteousness from law works is the fact that the work of Christ has made an end of this method of obtaining righteousness (Rom 10 4). This righteousness, therefore, is one of which man is the possessor. The phrase, however, cannot mean a righteousness which is valid in God’s sight (Luther), although this thought is elsewhere ex- pressed by Paul (Rom 3 20; Gal 3 11). It means a righteousness which comes from God and of which He is the author. This is not, however, by making man inwardly righteous, since all the above passages show the purely objective character of this right- eousness. It is the righteousness of Phil 3 9; the righteousness which God imputes to the believer in Christ. Thus we “become the righteousness of God” in precisely the same sense in which Christ was ‘made to be sin’ (2 Cor 5 21). Since Christ was made sin by having the guilt of our sin im- puted to Him so that He bore its penalty, Paul must mean that we “become the righteousness of God” in this same objective sense through the impu- tation to us of the righteousness of Christ. In the same way, in Rom 10 3, the contrast between God’s righteousness and the Jew’s righteousness by works of the law shows that in each case righteousness denotes a legal status which comes from God by imputation. It is this same imputed righteousness which makes the gospel the power of God unto sal- vation (Rom 1 17), which has been revealed by the law and the prophets, which is received by faith in Christ by whose expiatory death God’s retrib- utive righteousness has been made manifest (Rom 3 21.22.25.26), and which is represented by Peter as the object of Christian faith (2 Pet 1 1). In two passages Paul affirms that Abraham be- lieved God and “it was imputed to him for right- eousness’ (Rom 43AV; Gal36). The old Arminian theologians, and some modern exegetes (H. Cremer) assert that Pau] means that Abraham’s faith was accepted by God instead of a perfect righteousness as the meritorious ground of his justi- fication. This, however, cannot be the apostle’s meaning. It is diametrically opposed to the context where Paul introduces the ease of Abraham for the very purpose of proving that he was justified _with- out any merit on his part; it is opposed to Panl’s idea of the nature of faith which involves the renun- ciation of all claim to merit, and is a simple resting on Christ from whom all its saving efficacy is de- rived; and this interpretation is also opposed to Paul’s doctrine of the absolutely gracious character of Justification. The apostle in these passages wishes to illustrate from the case of Abraham the gracious character of Justification, and quotes the untech- nical language of Gen 15 6. His meaning is simply that Abraham was justified as a believer in God, and not as one who sought rightcousness by works. See Sin; ATONEMENT; JUSTIFICATION. Litzrarurs.—Besides the Comm., see works on OT Theology by Dillmann, Davidson, Oehler, Schultz; and on NT Theology by H. Holtzmann, B. Weiss, Schmidt; also Chemnitz, De Vocabulo Imputationis, Loc. Theol., 1594, II, 326 ff; J. Martin, The Imputation of Adam's Sin, 1834, 20-46; Clemen, Die Christliche Lehre von der Sunde, I, 1897, 151-79; Dietzsch, Adam_und_ Christus, 1871; Hiinefeld, Rom § 12-21, 1895; Crawford, The Doctrine of the Holy Scripture Respecting the Atonement?, Imrah Infinite THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1466 1876, 33-45, 188-90. Cf also the appropriate sections in the works on the Scripturo doctrine of Justification, aad esp. on Paul's doctrine of Justification, e.g. Owen, Justification, Ist Am. ed, 185-310; Ritschl, Die Christ- liche Lehre von der Rechtfertigung und Verséhnung, IT, 1882, 303-31; B6hl, Von der Rechtfertigung durch den Glauben, 1890, 115-23; Ndésgen, Schriftbeweis fir die evangel, Rechfertiquagslehre, 1901, 147-96; Pfleiderer, Die Paulinische Rechtfertigung, ZWT (Hiigenfeid her- ausg.), 1872, 161-200, Paulinism, ET, I, 171-86; with which compare Pfleiderer’s later view of Paul's teach- ings, 2d ed, 1890, 178-89, G. Schwarz, Justitia Impu- tata? 1891; H. Cremer, Paulinische Rechtfertigungslehre’, 1900, 329-49; Tobac, Le probléme de la justification dans Saint Paul, 1908, 206-25. On Paul's doctrine of the righteousness of God, of the many monographs the follow- ing may be mentioned: Fricke, Der Paulinische Grund- begriff der Stxatogivy Geou, erértert auf Grund v. Rém. III, 21-26, 1888, Kdibing, Studien zur Paulinische Theologie, TSK, 1895, 7-51; Hiring, Accatocivy deod, bet Paulus, 1896. CaspaR WisTaR HopcE IMRAH, im’ra (1707, yimrah): A descendant of Asher (1 Ch 7 36). IMRI, im’ri (78 , *imri): (1) A Judahite (1 Ch 9 4). (2) Father of Zaccur who helped to rebuild the walls of Jerus under Nehemiah (Neh 3 2). IN: A principal thing to notice about this prep., which in AV represents about 16 Heb and as many Gr words and preps., is that, in hundreds of cases (esp. in the OT, but frequently also in the NT) in RV the rendering is changed to more exact forms (“‘to,”’ “unto,” “by,” “pon,” Hate “with,” “among,” “for,” “throughout,” etc; ef e.g. Gen 6 16; 13 8; 17 7.912; 181; Ex 817; Lev 19, etc); while, nearly as often, “in” is substituted for divergent forms of AV (eg. Gen 2 14; 17 11; 31 54; 407; 4917; Ex 8 14.24; Lev 3 17; 4 2, etc). The chief Gr prep. év, en, is frequently adhered to as ‘in’? in RV where AV has other forms (‘Swith,” “among,” ete; cf “in” for “with”? in John’s baptism, Mt 3 11, and ||; ‘in the tombs” for “among the tombs,” Mk 6 3). In 2 Thess 22, “shaken in mind” in AV is more correctly rendered in RV “shaken from [apé] your mind.” There are numerous such instructive changes. JAMES ORR IN THE LORD (& Kvplo, en Kurid): A favorite Pauline expression, denoting that intimate union and fellowship of the Christian with the Lord Jesus Christ which supplies the basis of all Chris- tian relations and conduct, and the distinctive ele- ment in which the Christian life has its specific character. Cf the synonymous Pauline phrases, “in Christ,’ ‘in Christ Jesus,” and the Johannine expressions, “being in Christ,” “abiding in Christ.” “In the Lord’’ denotes: (1) the motive, quality, or character of a Christian duty or virtue, as based on union with Christ, e.g. “Free to be married to whom she will; only in the Lord’ (1 Cor 7 39), i.e. provided the marriage be consistent with the Christian life. Cf 1 Cor 15 58; Phil 3.1; 4 1.2. 4.10; Eph 6 1.10; Col 3 18, ete; (2) the ground of Christian unity, fellowship, and brotherly salu- tation, e.g. Rom 16 2.8.22; 1 Cor 16 19; Col 4 7; (3) it is often practically synonymous with ‘“Chris- tian” (noun or adj.), ‘as Christians’ or “as a Christian,” e.g. ‘Salute them of the household of Narcissus, that are in the Lord,’’ ie. that are Christians (Rom 16 11); “I... . the prisoner in the Lord,’’ ie. the Christian prisoner (Eph 4 1); ef Rom 16 13; 1 Cor 9 1.2; Eph 6 21 (‘faith- ful minister in the Lord’’=faithful Christian min- ister); Col 4 17 (see Grimm-Thayer, Lez. of NT, év, en, I, 6) D. Miatu Enwarns INCANTATION, in-kan-ta’shun. See Macic. INCARNATION, in-kar-na/shun. See Prrson or CHRIST. INCENSE, in’sens (WTOP, ktérah; in Jer 44 21, "OP, kitter; in Mal 1 11, "OP, batar, “In every place incense shall be offered unto my name”; the word m2, lebhonah, tr4 “incense” in several passages in Isa and Jer in AV, is properly “‘frankin- cense,”’ and is so rendered in RV): The offering of incense, or burning of aromatic substances, is common in the religious ceremonies of nearly all nations (Egyptians, Babylonians, Assyrians, Phoenicians, etc), and it is natural to find it holding @ prominent place in the tabernacle and temple- worship of Israel. The newer critical theory that incense was a late importation into the religion of Israel, and that the altar of incense described in Ex 30 1 ff is a post-exilian invention, rests on pre- suppositions which are not here admitted, and is in contradiction to the express notices of the altar of incense in 1 K 6 20.22; 7 48; 9 25; ef 2 Ch 4 19 (see discussion of the subject by Delitzsch in Luthardt’s Zeitschrift, 1880, 113 ff). In the de- nunciation of Eli in 1S 2 27 ff, the burning of incense is mentioned as one of the functions of the priesthood (ver 28). The “smoke” that filled the temple in Isaiah’s vision (Isa 6 4) may be pre- sumed to be the smoke of incense. The word ketorah itself properly denotes “smoke.” For the altar of incense see art. on that subject, and TaBER- NACLE and TEMPLE. The incense used in the tab- ernacle service—called ‘sweet incense’ (k*toreth ha-sammim, Ex 25 6, etc)—was compounded ac- cording to a definite prescription of the perfumes, stacte, onycha, galbanum and pure frankincense (Ex 30 34f), and incense not so compounded was rejected as “strange incense” (ktdrah zérah, 30 9). In the offering of incense, burning coals from the altar of burnt offering were borne in a censer and. put upon the altar of incense (the “golden altar” before the oracle), then the fragrant incense was sprinkled on the fire (cf Lk 1 9f). Ample details of the rabbinical rules about incense may be seen in the art. “Incense,” in DB. See CENnsER. Figuratively, incense was symbolical of ascending prayer. The multitude were praying while Zach- arias offered incense (Lk 1 10, @vulaua, thumiama), and in Rev 5 8; 8 3f, the incense in the heavenly temple is connected and even identified (5 8) with ‘the prayers of the saints.” James ORR INCEST, in’sest. INCONTINENCY, in-kon’ti-nen-si (dxpacia, akrasia, ‘without control’): In 1 Cor 7 5, it evi- dently refers to lack of control in a particular matter, and signifies unchastity. In Mt 23 25, the Gr word is tr4 in both AV and ARV by “excess.” INCORRUPTION, in-ké-rup’shun (4d@apeta, aphtharsia): Occurs in 1 Cor 16 42.50.53.54, of the resurrection body, and is twice used in RV for AV ‘Gmmortality’ (Rom 27; 2 Tim110m). See IMMORTALITY. See CrIMEs. INCREASE, in’krés (noun), in-krés’ (vb.): Em- ployed in the Eng. Bible both as vb. and as noun, and in both cases to represent a number of different words in the original. As a vb. it is used in the ordinary sense of the term. As a noun it is usually used of plant life, or of the herds and flocks, to denote the fruitage or the offspring; more rarely of money, to denote the interest. As examples of the different terms tr? by this word, students who read Heb or Gr may compare Dt 7 22; Prov 16 21; Job 10 16 AV; 12 23; Nu 18 30; Dt 7 13; Ezk 22 12 in the OT, and Jn 3 30; 1 Cor 3 6; Col 2 19; Eph 4 16 in the NT. : Russett BensaMIn MILLER 1467 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Imrah Infinite INDIA, in’di-a (3M, hodda; 4 "Iv8unh, hz Indiké): The name occurs in canonical Scripture only in Est 1 1; 8 9, of the country which marked the eastern boundary of the territory of Ahasuerus. The Heb word comes from the name of the Indus, Hondu, and denotes, not the peninsula of Hindu- stan, but the country drained by that great river. This is the meaning also in 1 Esd 3 2; Ad Est 3 2; 16 1. Many have thought that this country is intended by Havilah in Gen 2 11 and that the Indus is the Pishon. The drivers of the elephants (1 Mace 6 37) were doubtless natives of this land. The name in 1 Macc 8 9 is certainly an error. India never formed part of the dominions of An- tiochus the Great. It may possibly be a clerical error for “Tonia,’’ as Media is possibly a mistake for Mysia. Ifthe Israelites in early times had no direct relations with India, many characteristic Indian products seem to have found their way into Pales- tinian markets by way of the Arabian and Syrian trade routes, or by means of the Red Sea flects (1 K 10 11.15; Ezk 27 15 ff, etc). Among these may be noted “horns of ivory and ebony,’’ “cassia and calamus,” almug (sandalwood), apes and pea~- cocks. : W. Ewine INDIGNITIES, in-dig’ni-tiz. See PunisHMENTs. INDITE, in-dit’: AV Ps 45 1, “My heart is in- diting a good matter’; RV “My heart overfloweth with a goodly matter,” is in harmony with UN, rdhash, “to bubble up”; cf LXX é&npetéaro, exéreixato, “to pour out.’ “Indite”’ in Eng. is becoming obsolete. It may mean “to dictate,” “to invite,” ‘to compose.” In the latter meaning it is used in the above passage. INFANCY, in’fan-si, GOSPEL OF THE. See APOCRYPHAL GOSPELS. INFANT, in‘fant, BAPTISM. See Baptism. INFANTICIDE, in-fan’ti-sid. See Crimes. INFIDEL, in’fi-del (Gmoros, dpistos, “unbe- lieving,” ‘“incredulous’”’): AV has this word twice: “What part hath he that believeth with an infidel?” (2 Cor 6 15); “If any provide not for his own, .... 48 worse than an infidel” (1 Tim 5 8). In both passages ERV and ARV have “‘unbeliever” in harmony with numerous other instances of the use of the Gr apistos. The word nowhere corresponds to the modern conception of an infidel, one who denies the existence of God, or repudiates the Chris- tian faith; but always signifies one who has not be- come a believer in Christ. It was formerly so used in Eng., and some of the older VSS have it in other - passages, besides these two. It is not found in the OT, but “infidelity” (incredulity) occurs in 2 Esd 7 44 [114]. Wiiuiam OwrEn CarvER INFINITE, in’fin-it, INFINITUDE, in-fin’i-vid: The word “infinite” occurs 3 t only in the text of AV (Job 22 5; Ps 147 5; Nah 3 9) 1. Scripture and once in m (Nah 2 9). In Ps 147 Use 5, “His understanding is infinite,’’ it represents the Heb “WO PR, ’én mispar, “no number’; in the other passages the Heb Vp TR, ’an kee Job 22 5, of iniquities) and MEP PR, en kéceh (Nah 8 9, of strength of Ethio- pia and Egypt; AVm 2 9, of “spoil’’), meaning ‘“‘no end.” RV, therefore, renders in Job 22 5, “Neither is there any end to thine iniquities,”” and drops the marginal reference in Nah 2 9. Pg 147 5 is thus the only passage in which the term is directly applied to God. It there correctly conveys the idea of absence of all limitation. There is nothing beyond the compass of God’s understand- ing; or, positively, His understanding 2. Applica- embraces everything there is to know. tion to God Past, present and future; all things pos- sible and actual; the inmost thoughts and purposes of man, as well as his outward actions, lie bare to God’s knowledge (He 4 13; see Om- NISCIENCE). While, however, the term is not found, the truth that God is infinite, not only in His understanding, but in His being and all His perfec- 8. Infinity tions, natural and moral, is one that Universally pervades all Scripture. It could not Implied be otherwise, if God was unoriginated, exalted above all limits of time, space and creaturehood, and dependent only on Himself. The Dib. writers, certainly, are far from thinking in metaphysical categories, or using such terms as “Self-existence,”’ ‘“absoluteness,”’ “unconditioned,” yet the ideas for which these terms stand were all of them attributed in their conceptions to God. They did not, e.g. conceive of God as having been born, or as having a beginning, as the Bab and Gr gods had, but thought of Him as the ever-existing One (Ps 90 1.2), and free Creator and Disposer of all that exists. This means that God has self-existence, and for the same reason that He is not bound by His own creation. He must be thought of as raised above all creaturely limits, that is, as infinite. The anthropomorphisms of the Bible, indeed, are often exceedingly naive, as when Jeh is said to “go down”’ to see what is being done (Gen 4. Anthro- 11 5.7; 18 21), or to “repent” of His pomor- actions (Gen 6 6); but these repre- phisms sentations stand in contexts which show that the authors knew God to be unlimited in time, space, knowledge and power (cf Gen 6 7, God, Creator of all; 11 8.9, universal Ruler; 18 25, universal Judge; Nu 23 19, inca- pable of repentance, etc). Like anthropomorphisms are found in Dt and the Prophets, where it is not doubted that the higher conceptions existed. In this infinity of God is implied His unsearchableness (Job 117; Ps 145 3; Rom 11 33); conversely, the latter attribute implies His infinity. This infinitude of God is displayed in all His attributes—in His eternity, omnipresence, ornis- cience, omnipotence, ete—on which see 5. Infinity the separate arts. As regards the a Perfection proper conception of infinity, one has Nota chiefly to guard against figuring it Quantity under too quaniitative an aspect. Quantitative boundlessness is the nat- ural symbol we employ to represent infinity, yet reflection will convince us that it is inadequate as applied to a spiritual magnitude. Infinitude in power, e.g. is not an infinite quantity of power, but the potentiality in God of accomplishing without limit everything that is possible to power. It is a perfection, not a quantity. Still more is this appar- ent in moral attributes like love, righteousness, truth, holiness. These attributes are not quanti- ties (a quantity can never be truly infinite), but perfections; the infinity is qualitative, consisting in the absence of all defect or limitation in degree, not in amount. The recollection of the fact now stated will free the mind from most of the perplexities that have been raised by metaphysical writers 6. Errors as to the abstract possibility of the Based on coexistence of infinite attributes in Quantita- God (thus e.g. Mansel); the recon- tive Con- _cilability of God’s infinity with His ceptions Personality, or with the existence of a finite world; the power of the human mind to conceive infinity, etc. How, it is asked, Infirmity Ink-horn THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1468 can the idea of infinity get into our finite minds? It might as well be asked how the mind can take in the idea of the sun’s distance of some 90 millions of miles from the earth, when the skull that holds the brain is only a few cubic inches in capacity. The idea of a mile is not a mile big, nor is the idea of infinity too large to be thought of by the mind of man. The essence of the power of thought is its capacity for the universal, and it cannot rest till it has apprehended the most universal idea of all— the infinite. JAMES ORR INFIRMITY, in-far’mi-ti (71, dawah, Ten; halah, T1270, mahdlah; doévera, asthéneia): This word is used either in the sing. or pl. (the latter only in the NT) and with somewhat varying sig- nification. (1) As sickness or bodily disease (Jn 5 5; Mt 817; Lk 6 15; 82; I Tim 6 23). In the last instance the affections seem to have been dyspeptic, the discomfort of which might be re- lieved by alcohol, although the disease would not be cured thereby. It is probable that this condition of body produced a certain slackness in Timothy’s work against which Paul several times cautions him. In Lk 7 21 RV has ‘diseases,’’ which is a better rendering of the Gr nosén, used here, than the AV ‘‘nfirmities.”’ (2) Imperfections or weaknesses of body (Rom 6 19; 2 Cor 11 30 AV; 12 5.9.10 AV; Gal 4 13). (8) Moral or spiritual weaknesses and defects (Ps 77 10; Rom 8 26; 151; He 4 15; 5 2; 7 28). In this sense it is often used by the classic Eng. writers, as in Milton’s ‘the last infirmity of noble minds”; cf Caesar, IV, iii, 86. The infirmity which a man of resolution can keep. under by his will (Prov 18 14) may be either moral or physical. In Lk 13 11 the woman’s physical infirmity is ascribed to the influence of an evil spirit. Avex. MacarisTER INFLAME, in-flam’, ENFLAME, en-flim’ (p27, dalak): ‘“To inflame’ in the meaning ‘‘to excite passion” is found in Isa 6 11, “till wine inflame them.’’ In some AV passages (e.g. Isa 57 5) we find ‘‘enflaming’’ with the same meaning; cf AV Sus ver 8 and Sir 28 10 AV (RV “‘inflame’’). INFLAMMATION, in-fla-ma’shun (Mp3, dal- leketh; $tyos, rhigos): Only in Dt 28 22, was con- sidered by Jewish writers as “burning fever,” by LXX asaformofague. Both this and typhoid fever are now, and probably were, among the commonest of the diseases of Pal. See Fever. In Lev 13 28 AV has “inflammation” as the rendering of ¢dre- bheth, which LXX reads charaktér, and for which the proper Eng. equivalent is “scar,” as in RV. INFLUENCES, in’fldc-ens-iz (DIY, ma- ‘ddhannéth): This word occurs only in Job 38 31 AV, “Canst thou bind the sweet influences of Pleiades?’ RV “the cluster of the Pleiades,” m “or chain, or sweet influences’; Delitzsch, Dillmann and others render “fetters,”’ that which binds the group together; “‘influences,” if correct, would refer to the seasons, which were believed to be regu- lated, so far, by the Pierapes (q.v.). In Wisd 7 25, it is said of Wisdom that she is ‘‘a pure influence [apérrhoia, RV “effluence’”’] flowing from the glory of the Almighty.” W. L. WALKER INGATHERING, in’gath-ér-ing, FEAST OF. See Feasts anp Fasts; Booru. INHABIT, in-hab’it, INHABITANT, in-hab’it- ant (BW, ydshabh, “to sit,” ‘Temain, ‘‘dwell,” “inhabit,” j2UW, shakhén, “to settle down,” “tabernacle,” “dwell”; sarowéw, katoikéd, “‘to settle,” dwell”): See Dwrtt. The vb. “to in- habit,”? now used only transitively, had once an intransitive meaning as well. Cf Cowper, Olney Hymns, XIV, “Who built it, who inhabits there?" So in 1 Ch 6 9 AV, “‘And eastward he inhabited unto the entering in of the wilderness’ (but RV “dwelt’’). We have the obsolete inhabiters for ‘nhabitants’ in Rev 8 18 AV (but RV ‘‘them that dwell”) and Rev 12 12 AV (but omitted in RV). The rare inhabitress (fem.) is found only in Jer 10 17m; ‘the church called the inhabitress of the gardens” (Bishop Richardson). D. Mratt Epwarps INHERITANCE, in-her'i-tans (M2732, nahdlah, “something inherited,” “occupancy,” “heirloom,” “estate,” “portion”): The word is used in its widest application in the OT Scriptures, referring not only to an estate received by a child from its parents, but also to the land received by the children of Israel asa gift from Jeh. And in the figurative and poeti- cal sense, the expression is applied to the kingdom of God as represented in the consecrated lives of His followers. In a similar sense, the Psalmist is represented as speaking of the Lord as the portion of his inheritance. In addition to the above word, the King James Version tr* as inheritance, TWA, morashah, ‘a, possession,” ‘‘heritage”’ (Dt 33 4; Ezk 33 24); MW, yrushshah, “something occu- pied,” “a patrimony,” “‘possession” (Jgs 21 17); P2, héek, “smoothness,” “allotment” (Ps 16 5); kAnpovopéw, kléronoméé, “to inherit’ (Mt 5 5, ete); xAnpovéuos, kléronédmos, “heir? (Mt 21 38, ete); KAnpovoula, kléronomia, “heirship,” ‘patrimony,’ “possession”; or xAfpos, kléros, “‘an acquisition,” “portion,” “heritage,’ from «Anpbw, klérdd, ‘to assign,’’ ‘‘to allot,” ‘‘to obtain an inheritance’ (Mt 21 38: Lk 12 13; Acts 7 5; 20 32; 26 18; Gal 3 18; Eph 1 11.14.18; 5 5; Col 1 12; 3 24: Hel 4,915; 11 8; 1 Pet 1 4). The Pent distinguishes clearly between real and personal property, the fundamental idea regarding the former being the thought that the land is God’s, given by Him to His children, the people of Israel, and hence cannot be alienated (Lev 26 23.28). In order that there might not be any respecter of persons in the division, the lot was to determine the specific piece to be owned by each family head (Nu 26 52-56; 33 54). In case, through necessity of circumstances, a homestead was sold, the title could pass only temporarily; for in the year of Jubilee every homestead must again return to the original owner or heir (Lev 25 25-34). Real estate given to the priesthood must be appraised, and could be redeemed by the payment of the ap- praised valuation, thus preventing the transfer of real property even in this case (Lev 27 14-25). Inheritance was controlled by the following regu- lations: (1) The firstborn son inherited a double portion of all the father’s possession (Dt 21 15-17); (2) the daughters were entitled to an inheritance, provided there were no sons in the family (Nu 27 8); (3) in case there were no direct heirs, the brothers or more distant kinsmen were recognized (vs 9-11); in no case should an estate pass from one tribe to another. The above points were made the subject of statutory law at the instance of the daughters of Zelophehad, the entire case being clearly set forth in Nu 27, 36. Frank E. Hirsca INIQUITY, in-ik’wi-ti (1, ‘awon; dvopta, anomia): In the OT of the 11 words tr4 “iniquity,” by far the most common and important is ‘awén {about 215 t). Etymologically, it is customary to explain it as meaning lit. “crookedness,” ‘“per- 1469 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Infirmity Ink-horn verseness,”’ i.e. evil regarded as that which is not straight or upright, moral distortion (from MY, ‘iwwah, “to bend,” “make crooked,” “‘pervert’’), Driver, however (following Lagarde), maintains that two roots, distinct in Arab., have been confused in Heb, one=‘‘to bend,” “pervert”? (as above), and the other=“‘to err,” ‘‘go astray’; that ‘dwénis derived from the latter, and consequently ex- presses the idea of error, deviation from the right path, rather than that of perversion (Driver, Notes on Sam, 135n.) Whichever etymology is adopted, in actual usage it has three meanings which almost imperceptibly pass into each other: (1) iniquity, (2) guilt of iniquity, (3) punishment of iniquity. Primarily, it denotes “not an action, but the char- acter of an action’’ (Oehler), and is so distinguished from “sin” (hatta’th). Hence we have the expres- sion “the iniquity of my sin’’ (Ps 32 5). Thusthe meaning glides into that of “guilt,” which might often take the place of “iniquity” as the tr of ‘awén (Gen 16 16; Ex 847; Jer 2 22, etc). From “suilt” it again passes into the meaning of “punish- ment of guilt,” just as Lat piaculum may denote both guilt and its punishment. The transition is all the easier in Heb because of the Heb sense of the in- timate relation of sin and suffering, e. g. Gen 4 13, “My punishment is greater than I can bear’; which is obviously to be preferred to AVm, RVm “Mine iniquity is greater than can be forgiven,” for Cain is not so much expressing sorrow for his sin, as com- plaining of the severity of his punishment; cf 2 K 79 (RV “punishment,’’ RVm “iniquity”); Isa 6 18 (where for “iniquity” we might have ‘‘punish- ment of iniquity,’ as in Lev 26 41.43, ete); Isa 40 2 (‘iniquity,’ RVm “punishment’’). The phrase ‘‘bear iniquity’’ is a standing expression for bearing its consequences, i.e. its penalty; generally of the sinner bearing the results of his own iniquity (Lev 17 16; 2017.19; Nu 14 34; Ezk 44 10, etc), but sometimes of one bearing the iniquity ot another vicariously, and so taking it away (e.g. Ezk 4 4f; 18 19f). Of special interest in the lattcr sense are the sufferings of the Servant of Jeh, who shall “bear the iniquities’ of the people (Isa 63 11; cf ver 6). Other words frequently tr4 “iniquity” are: TJS, ’awen, lit. ‘“‘worthlessness,” ‘‘vanity,’’ hence “naughtiness,” “mischief” (47 t in AV, esp. in the phrase ‘workers of iniquity,’ Job 4 8; Ps 5 5; 6 8; Prov 10 29, etc); ‘adwel and ‘awiah, lit. “per- verseness” (Dt 32 4; Job 6 29 AV, etc). In the NT “iniquity” stands for anomia=prop., ‘the condition of one without law,” “lawlessness” (so tri in 1 Jn $ 4, elsewhere “iniquity,” e.g. Mt 7 23), a word which frequently stood for ‘a@wdn in LXX; and adikia, lit. “unrighteousness” (e.g. Lk 13 27). D. Miaut Epwarps INJOIN, in-join’. INJURIOTUS, in-j6d’ri-us, in-ji’ri-us (bBpiorhs, hubristés, ‘‘insolent’’): In former usage, the word was strongly expressive of insult as well as hurtful- ness. Soin 1 Tim 1 13. In Rom 1 380 the same adj. is tr? ‘‘insolent’”’ (AV “despiteful’’). IN JURY, in’ju-ri, in’j66-ri. See Ensoin. See CRIMEs. INK, ink (11, d*y, from root meaning “slowly flowing,” BDB, 188; pédav, mélan, “black’’): Any fluid substance used with pen or brush to form written characters. In this sense ink is mentioned once in the Heb Bible (Jer 36 2) and 3 t in the Gr NT (2 Cor 3 3; 2 Jn ver 12; 3 Jn ver 13), and it is implied in all references to writing on papyrus or on leather. The inference from the “blotting out” of Ex 82 33 and Nu 6 23 that the Heb ink was a lamp-black and gum, or some other dry ink, is confirmed by the general usage of antiquity, by the later Jewish prejudice against other inks (OTJC, 71 n.) and by a Jewish receipt referring to ink- tablets (Drach, ‘‘Notice sur l’encre des Hébreux,’’ Ann. philos. chrét., 42, 45, 358). The question is, however, now being put on a wholly new basis by the study of the Elephantine Jewish documents (Meyer, Papyrusfund?, 1912, 15, 21), and above all of the Harvard Ostraca from Samaria which give actual specimens of the ink in Pal in the time of Ahab (Harvard Theol. Review, Jan. 1911, 136-43). It is likely, however, that during the long period of Bible history various inks were used. The official copy of the law in the time of Ptolemy Philadelphus was, according to Jos (Ant, XII, ii, 11), written in gold, and the vermilion and red paints and dyes men- tioned in Jer 22 14; Ezk 23 14, and Wisd 13 14 (miltd kat phiket) were probably used also for writing books or coloring incised inscriptions. See literature under Writinc; esp. Krauss, Talm, Arch. 3, 148-53; Gardthausen, Gr Pal, 1911, I, 202-17, and his bibliographical references passim. E. C. Ricnarnpson INK-HORN, ink’hérn (NOP=NUP, keseth= keseth, BDB, 903): This term “inkhorn” occurs 3 t in Ezk 9 (vs 2.3.11), in the phrase “writer’s inkhorn upon his loins” (or ‘“‘by his side’). The word is more exactly “implement case,” or ‘‘writing-case”’ (a) Ink-Wells and Pen-Case with Ink-Well. (calamarium atramentarium, theca calamaria, theca libraria, graphiaria). This may have heen the Egyp palette (Budge, Mummy, 350-52) seen so often in the monuments of all periods, or the later form of pen-case with ink-well attached, which is a modified form adapted for ink carried in fluid form. The Egyp palette was carried characteristically over the shoulder or under the arm, neither of which methods is strictly “upon the loins.” The manner of carrying, therefore, was doubtless in the girdle, as in modern oriental usage (Benzinger, Heb Archaeol., 185). A good example of the pen-case and ink- well writing-case (given also in Garucci, Darem- (b) Scribe’s Palette. berg-Saglio, Gardthausen, etc) is given from the original in Birt, Die Buchrolle in der Kunst, 220, and is reproduced (a) in this article, together with (6) an Egyp palette. Whether the form of Hzekiel’s case approached the palette or the ink-well type prob- ably depends on the question of whether dry ink or fluid ink was used in Exekiel’s time (see Ivx). Compare Hieronymus ad loc., and for literature, Inn Innocents see Writine, and esp. Gardthausen, Gr Pal, 1911, IT, 193-94. E. C. Ricnarpson INN (oa, malon; twavSoxetov, pandocheton, ka- tadkupa, katdluma): The Heb word malén means lit. a “night resting-place,” and might 1. Earliest be applied to any spot where caravans Night Rest- (Gen 42 27; 43 21 AV), individuals ing-Places (Ex 4 24; Jer 9 2), or even armics (Josh 4 3.8; 2 K 19 23; Isa 10 29) encamped for the night. In the slightly altered form m¢lénah, the same word is used of a night- watchman’s lodge in a garden (Isa 1 8; 24 20, AV “cottage”’). The word in itself does not imply the presence of any building, and in the case of caravans and travelers was doubtless originally, as very often at the present day, only a convenient level bit of ground near some spring, where baggage might be unloaded, animals watered and tethered, and men rest on the bare ground. Nothing in the OT suggests the occupancy of a house in such cases. The nearest approach to such an idea occurs in Jer 41 17m, where géraih kimham is tr4 ‘the lodging- place of Chimham,” but the text is very doubtful and probably refers rather to sheepfolds. We can- not say when buildings were first used, but the need of shelter for caravans traveling in winter, and of protection in dangerous times and districts, would lead to their introduction at an early period in the history of trade. It is noteworthy that all the indisputable desig- nations of “inn” come in with the Gr period. Jos (Ant, XV, v, 1; BJ, I, xxi, 7) speaks 2. Public of “public inns” under the name of Inns katagogai, while in the Aram. Jewish writings we meet with ’ushpiza’, from Lat hospitium, and ’akhsanya’ from the Gr xenia; the NT designation pandocheion has passed into the Aram. pundhek@’ and the Arab. funduk. All these are used of public inns, and they all correspond to the modern “khan” or ‘‘caravanserai.’”? These are to be found on the great trade routes all over the East. In their most elaborate form they have almost the strength of a fortress. They consist of a great quadrangle into which admission is gained through a broad, strong gateway. The quad- rangle is inclosed on all sides by a 2-story building, the windows in the case of the lower story opening only to the interior. The upper story is reached by stairways, and has a gangway all around, giving access to the practically bare rooms which are at the disposal of travelers. Interior of Vizir Khan, Aleppo. There is usually a well of good water in the center of the quadrangle, and travelers as a rule bring their own food and often that of their 3. Their animals (Jgs 19 19) withthem. There Evil Name are no fixed payments, and on depar- ture, the arranging of hagg el-khan gon- erally means a disagreeable dispute, as the inn- keepers are invariably untruthful, dishonest and THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1470 oppressive. They have ever been regarded as of infamous character. The Rom laws in many places recognize this. In Mish, Yebhamdth, xvi.7 the word of an innkeeper was doubted, and Mish, ‘Abbodhah Zarah, ii.4 places them in the lowest scale of deg- radation. The NT is quite clear in speaking of “Rahab the harlot”? (He 11 31; Jas 2 25). he Tg designates her an ‘innkeeper,’ while Rashi tr? zonah as “a seller of kinds of food,” a mean- ing the word will bear. Kimhi, however, accepts both meanings. This evil repute of public inns, together with the Sem spirit of hospitality, led the Jews and the esrly Christians to prefer to recommend the keeping of open house for the en- tertainment of strangers. In the Jewish Morning Prayers, even in our day, such action is linked with great promises, and the NT repeatedly (He 13 2; 1 Pet 4.9; 3 Jn ver 5) commends hospi- tality. It is remarkable that both the Talm (Shab 127a) and the NT (He 13 2) quote the same passage (Gen 18 3) in recommending it. The best-known khans in Pal are Khan Jubb- Yusuf, N. of the Lake of Galilee, Khan el-Tujjar, under the shadow of Tabor, Khan el-Lubban (ct Jgs 21 19), and Khan Hadrur, midway between Jerus and Jericho. This last certainly occupies the site of the inn referred to in Lk 10 34, and it is not without interest that we read in Mish, Yebhamath, xvi.7, of another sick man being left at that same inn. See illustration, p. 64. The Gr word kataluma, though implying a ‘“‘loos- ing’’ for the night, seems rather to be connected with the idea of hospitality in a private 4. Guest house than in a public inn. Luke Chambers’ with his usual care distinguishes be- tween this and pandocheion, and his use of the vb. katalud (Lk 9 12; 19 7) makes his meaning clear. In the LXX, indeed, malin is sometimes tr? kataluma, and it appears in 1 8 9 22 for lishkah, AV “parlour.’”’ It is the word used of the “upper room” where the Last Supper was held (Mk 14 14; Lk 22 11, “guest-chamber’’), and of the place of reception in Bethlehem where Joseph and Mary failed to find quarters (Lk 2 7). It thus corresponds to the spare or upper room in a private house or in a village, i.e. to the manzil adjoining the house of the sheikh, where travelers received: hos- pitality and where no payment was expected, except a trifle to the caretaker. In Jerus such payments were made by leaving behind the earthenware vessels that had been used, and the skins of the ani- nals that had been slaughtered (Ydmda’ 12a). Judging from the word used, and the conditions implied, we are led to believe that Joseph and Mary had at first expected reception in the 5. Birth upper room or manzil at the house of of Christ the sheikh of Bethlehem, probably a ; friend and member of the house of David; that in this they were disappointed, and had to content themselves with the next best, the elevated platform, alongside the interior of the stable, and on which those having the care of the animals generally slept. It being now the season when they were in the fields (Lk 2 8), the stable would be empty and clean. There then the Lord Jesus was born and laid in the safest and most con- venient place, the nearest empty manger alongside of this elevated platform. Humble though the cir- cumstances were, the family were prescrved from all the annoyance and evil associations of a public khan, and all the demands of delicacy and privacy were duly met. W. M. Curistip INNER MAN. Sec Inwanp Man. INNOCENCE, in’6-sens, INNOCENCY, in’- sen-si, INNOCENT, in’é-sent (127, zakhu, TP, 1471 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inn Innocents nikkayon, DIT, hinndém, OD, haph, “p2, naki; G8g0s, athéos): AV and ARV have innocency in Gen 20 5; Ps 26 6; 73 13; Dnl 6 22; Hos 8 5. In Dnl the Heb is 2akhu, and the innocence ex- pressed is the absence of the guilt of disloyalty to God. In all the other places the Heb is nikkayon, and the innocence expressed is the absence of pollu- tion, Hos having reference to the pollution of idol- atry, and the other passages presenting the cleansing under the figure of washing hands. AV has in- nocent not fewer than 40 +t. In one place (1 K 2 31) the Heb is hinndém, meaning ‘‘undeserved,” or “without cause,’ and, accordingly, ARV, in- stead of “innocent blood .. . . shed,” has ‘“‘blood . . . .8hed without cause.’ In another place (Job 33 9) the Heb is haph, meaning “scraped,” or ‘Molished,” therefore “clean,” and refers to moral purity. In all the other places the Heb is nahi, or its cognates, and the idea is doubtless the absence of pollution. In more than half the Passages ‘Gn- nocent”’ is connected with blood, as “blood of the innocent,” or simply “innocent blood.” In some places there is the idea of the Divine acquittal, or forgiveness, asin Job 9 28: “I know that thou wilt not hold me innocent” (cf Job 10 14, where the the same Heb word is used). The NT has “inno- cent’ twice in connection with blood—‘innocent blood,” and “innocent of the blood” (Mt 27 4.24). EH. J. Forrester INNOCENTS, in’é-sents, MASSACRE, mas’‘a- kér, OF THE: . MEANING AND HisTorY OF THE TERM II. Awnatysis or Narrative wita SreciaL REFER- ENCE TO Motive 1. Focus of Narrative—Residence at Nazareth 2. Corollaries from Above Facts 3. Marks of Historicity I. Meaning and History of the Term.—The con- ventional, ecclesiastical name given to the slaughter by Herron I (q.v.) of children two years old and under in Bethlehem and its environs at the time of the birth of Christ (Mt 2 16). The accepted title for this event may be traced through Augustine to Cyprian. Trenaeus (d. 202 AD) calls these children “mar- tyrs,”’? and in a very beautiful passage interprets the tragedy which ended their brief lives as a gra-~ cious and tender ‘‘sending before’’ into His kingdom by the Lord Himself. Cyprian (d. 258 AD) says: “That it might be manifest that they who are slain for Christ’s sake are innocent, innocent infancy was put to death for his name’s sake’”’ (Ep. lv.6). Augustine (b. 354 AD), following Cyprian, speaks of the children, formally, as ‘the Innocents’’ (Comm. on Ps 43 5). The ecclesiastical treatment of the incident is remarkable because of the exaggeration which was indulged in as to the extent of the massacre and the number of victims. At an early date the Gr church canonized 14,000, and afterward, by a curious mis- interpretation of Rev 14 1.38, the number was increased to 144,000. According to Milman the liturgy of the Church of England retains a reminiscence of this ancient error in the use of Rev 14 on Holy Innocents’ Day (see History of Christianity, I, 107, n. e). This exaggeration, of which there is no hint in the NT, is worthy of note because the most serious general argument against the historicity of the narrative is drawn from the silence of Jos. As in all probability there could not have been more than twenty chil- dren involved (ef Farrar, Life of Christ, I, 45, n.), the incident could not have bulked very largely in the series of horrors perpetrated or planned by Herod in the last months of his life (see Farrar, The Herods, 144). Il. Analysis of Narrative with Special Reference to Motive.—In estimating the value of such a nar- rative from the viewpoint of historicity, the first and most important step is to gauge the motive. Why was the story told? This question is not always easy to answer, but in the present instance there is a very simple and effective test at hand. In Mit’s infancy section (chs 1 and 2) there are five quotations from the OT which are set into the nar- rative of events. These five quotations 1. Focus of represent the cardinal and outstanding Narrative— points of interest. The quotations are Residence placed thus: (1) at the Virgin Birth at Nazareth (1 23); (2) at the birth at Bethlehem (2 6); (8) at the visit to Egypt (2 15); (4) at the murder of the children (2 18); (5) at the Nazareth residence (2 23). It will be noticed at once as peculiar and significant that no quotation is attached to the visit of the Magi. This omission is the more noteworthy because in Nu 24 7; Ps 72 15; Isa 60 6, and numerous references to the in- gathermg of the Gentiles there are such beautiful and appropriate passages to link with the visit of the strangers from thefar East. This peculiar omis- sion, on the part of a writer so deeply interested in prophecy and its fulfilment and so keen to seize upon appropriate and suggestive harmonies, in a section constructed with a view to such harmonies, can be explained only on the ground that the visit of the Magi did not, in the writer's view of events, occupy a eritical point of especial interest. Their visit is told, not for its own sake, but because of its connection with the murder of the children and the journey to Egypt. The murder of the children is of interest because it discloses the character of Herod and the perils surrounding the newborn Messiah. It also explains the visit to Egypt and the sub- sequent residence at Nazareth. The latter is evi- dently the objective point, because it is given a place by itself and marked by a quotation. Moreover, the one evidence of overstrain in the narrative is in the ambiguous and obscure statement by which the OT is brought into relationship with the Nazareth residence. ‘The center of interest in the entire sec- tion which is concerned with Herod and the Magi isthe Nazareth residence. The story is told for the express purpose of explaining why the heir of David, who was born at Bethlehem, lived at Nazareth. This brings the narrative of Mt into striking relationship with that of Lk. The latter’s concern is to show how it was that the Messiah who lived at Nazareth was born at Bethlehem. We have here one of the undesigned unities which bind together these two narratives which are seemingly so diver- gent. That Mt says nothing about a previous residence at Nazareth and that Lk says nothing about a forced return thither may be explained, in accordance with the balance of probabilities, on the ground, either that each evangelist was ignorant of the fact omitted by himself, or that in his condensed and rapid statement he did not see fit to mention it. In any case the harmony immeasurably outweighs the discrepancy. The fact that the focus of the entire narrative lies in the residence of Jesus at Nazareth effectually disposes of a number of current hypotheses as to its ; origin. 2. Corol- (1) The idea that it is merely legend told laries from for the purpose of literary embellishment. Above Facts The dovetailing of what would be the main - item into the rest of the narrative and its subordination to secondary features cannot be explained on this hypothesis. The absence of adorn- ment by available passages from the OT alone is con- clusive on this point (see Allen, ‘‘ Matthew,’ ICC, 14, 15). (2) The idea that the story is told for the Durpece of illustrating the scope of the Messiah's influence beyond Israel. Here, again, the subordinate position assigned to the story of the Magi together with the absence of OT material is conclusive. Moreover, the history of the Magi is abruptly dropped with the statement of their Innocents Inspiration THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1472 return home. Interest in them flags as soon as_their brief connection with the movement of the history through Herod ceases. And the intensely Hebraic char- acter of Mt’s infancy section as a whole is incidental evidence pointing in the same direction (cf remarks of the writer, Birth and Infancy of Jesus Christ, 70f (3) The idea that the story is told to emphasize the wonder-element in connection with the birth of Christ. The facts contradict this. In addition to the primary consideration, the pupordtaate position, there are others of great value. That the agi were providentially guided to the fect of the Messiah is evidently the firm conviction of the narrator. The striking feature of the story is that with this belief in his mind he keeps so strictly within the limits of the natural order. In vs 9 and 12 only is there apparent exception. Of these the state- ment in ver 9 is the only one peculiar to this part of the narrative. Two things are to be remembered concerning it: It is clear that the verse cannot be interpreted apart from a clear understanding of the whole astronomical occurrence of which it forms a part. It is also evident that ver 9 must not be interpreted apart from the context. From the viewpoint of a wonder-tale the writer makes a fatal blunder at the most critical point of his story. The popular notion that the Magi were miraculously led to the Messiah finds no support in the text. The Magi did not come to Beth- lehem, but to Jerus, asking: ‘‘ Where is he that is born King of the Jews?'’ Ver 9 comes after this statement and after the conclave called by Herod in which Beth- \ehem was specified. In view of all this it seems clear that the Magi were led, not miraculously, but in accord- ance with the genius of their own system, and that the Providential element lay in the striking coincidence of their visit and the birth of Jesus. The interest of the writer was not in the wonder-element, else, infallibly, he would have sharpened its outlines and expurgated all amhiguity as to the nature of the occurrence. We may now glance at the positive evidence for the historicity of the event. (1) The centering of the narrative 3. Marks of upon the residence of Jesus at Naza- Historicity reth. This not only brings Lk’s Gospel in support of the center, but groups the story around a point of known interest to the first generation of believers. It is interesting to note that the residence in Egypt has independent backing of a sort. There are in existence two stories, one traced by Origen through Jews of his own day to earlier times, and the other in the Talm, which connect Jesus with Egypt and attempt to account for His miracles by reference to Egyp magic (see Plummer, “Matthew,” Fx. Comm., 17,18). (2) The fact that the story of the Magi is told so objectively and with such personal detachment. Both Jews and early Christians had strong views both as to astrology and magic in genera] (see Plummer, op. cit., 15), but the author of this Gospel tells the story without emphasis and without com- ment and from the viewpoint of the Magi. His interest is purely historical and matter-of-fact. (3) The portrait of Herod the Great. So far as Herod is concerned the incident is usually discussed with exclusive reference to the savagery involved. By many it is affirmed that we have here a hostile and unfair portrait. This contention could hardly be sustained even if the question turned entirely upon the point of savagery. But there is far more than savagery in the incident. (a) In the first place there is this undeniable element of inherent proba- bility in the story. Practically all of Herod’s murders, including those of his beloved wife and his sons, were perpetrated under the sway of one emotion and in obedience to a single motive. They were in practically cvery instance for the purpose of consolidating or perpetuating his power. He nearly destroyed his own immediate family in the half-mad jealousy that on occasion drove him to the very limits of ferocity, simply because they were accused of plotting against him. The accusations were largely false, but the suspicion doomed those accused. The murder of the Innocents was another crime of the same sort. The old king was obsessed by the fear of a claimant to his petty throne; the Messianic hope of the Jews was a perpetual secret torment, and the murder of the children, in the attempt to reach the child whose advent threatened him, was at once so original in method and so char- acteristic in purpose as to give an inimitable veri- similitude to the whole narrative. There are also other traits of truth. (6) Herod’s prompt discovery of the visit of the Magi and their questions is in harmony with what we know of the old ruler’s watchfulness and his elaborate system of espionage. (c) Characteristic also is the subtlety with which he deals with the whole situation. How striking and vivid, with all its rugged simplicity, is the story of the king’s pretended interest in the quest of the strangers, the solemn conclave of Jewish leaders with himself in the réle of earnest inquirer, his ur- gent request for information that he may worship also, followed by his swift anger (note that é@v- ud0n, ethumdthé, “was wroth,” ver 16, is not used elsewhere in the NT) at being deceived, and the blind but terrible stroke of his questing vengeance. All these items are so true to the man, to the atmosphere which always surrounded him, and to the historic situation, that we are forced to conclude, either that we have veracious history more or less directly received from one who was an observer of the events described, or the work of an incomparably clever romancer. Louis MattHews SWEET INORDINATE, in-ér’di-nat (“‘ll-regulated,”’ hence “immoderate,’”’ “excessive”; Lat in, “not,” ordinatus, ‘set in order’): Only twice in AV. In each case there is no corresponding adj. in the orig- inal, but the word was inserted by the translators as being implied in the noun. It disappears in RV: Ezk 23 11, ‘in her inordinate love’ (RV ‘in her doting’); 332, ‘dghabhah, “lust”; Col 3 5 “‘in- ordinate affection” (RV ‘“passion’’); mds, pdthos, a word which in classical Gr may have either a good or a bad sense (any affection or emotion of the mind), but in the NT is used only in a bad sense (passion). D. Miatt Epwarps INQUIRE, in-kwir' OND, sha@’al, “to ask,’ “de- sire’; {nréw, zatéd, “to seek’); A form sometimes employed with reference to the practice of divina- tion, as where Saul “inquires of” (or ‘‘consults’’) the witch of Endor as to the issue of the coming battle (1 S 28 6.7) (see Divination). In Job 10 6, “to inquire [WP3, bakash] after iniquity’’ signifies to bring to light and punish for it, and Job asks distractedly if God’s time is so short that He is in a hurry to find him guilty and to pun- ish him as if He had only a man’s few days to live. “To inquire of Jeh’’ denotes the consultation of oracle, priest, prophet or Jeh Himself, as to a certain course of action or as to necessary supplies (Jgs 20 27 AV, “to ask”; 1K 225; 1899 [WOT, da rash]; 10 22AV; 28 21; 6 19.23; Ezk 36 37). “To inquire [1p3, bakar) in his temple” (palace) means to find out all that constant fellowship or unbroken intercourse with God can teach (Ps 27 4). Prov 20 25 warns against rashness in making a vow and afterward considering (bakar, “to make inquiry”’) as to whether it can be fulfilled or how it may be cluded. In the AV, the tr of several Gr words: diaginésko, “‘to know thoroughly” (Acts 28 15); epizétéd, ‘to seck after’ (Acts 19 39); suzetéo, “to seek to- gether” (Lk 22 23); exetdzo, “to search out” (Mt 10 11). M. O. Evans INQUISITION, in-kwi-zish’un (WTI, darash, “to follow,” “diligently inquire,” ‘‘question,” “search” [Dt 19 18; Ps 9 12], WPA, bakash, “to search out,” “‘to strive after,” “inquire” [Est 2 23]): The term refers, as indicated by these passages, first of all to a careful and diligent inquiry necessary 1473 to ascertain the truth from witnesses in a court, but may also refer to a careful examination into circum- stances or conditions without official authority. INSCRIPTION, in-skrip’shun (vb. émypido, epigrdpho, “to write upon,” “inseribe’’): The word occurs once in EV in Acts 17 23 of the altar at Athens with the inscription ‘“To an Unknown God.” On inscriptions in archaeology, see ARCHAEOLOGY; Assyria; Bapyion1a, etc. INSECTS, in’sckts: In EV, including the mar- ginal notes, we find at least 23 names of insects or words referring to them: ant, bald locust, bee, beetle, cankerworm, caterpillar, creeping thing, cricket, crimson, flea, fly, gnat, grasshopper, honey, hornet, locust, louse, (lice), moth, palmer-worm, sandfly, scarlet-worm, silk-worm. These can be referred to about 12 insects, which, arranged sys- tematically, are: Hymenoptera, ant, bee, hornet; Lepidoptera, clothes-moth, silk-worm; Sitphonap- tera, flea; Diptera, fly; Rhynchota, louse, scarlet- worm; Orthoptera, several kinds of grasshoppers and locusts. The word ‘“‘worm”’ refers not only to the scarlet- worm, but to various larvae of Lepidoptera, Coleop- tera, and Diptera. ‘“‘Creeping things” refers indefi- nitely to insects, reptiles, and beasts. In the list of 23 names given above honey and bee refer to one insect, as do crimson and scarlet. Sandfly has no place if “lice” be retained in Ex 8 16 ff. Bald locust, beetle, canker-worm, cricket, and palmer- worm probably all denote various kinds of grass- hoppers and locusts. When the translators of EV had to do with two or more Heb words for which there was only one well-recognized Eng. equivalent, they seem to have been content with that alone, if the two Heb words occurred in different passages; e.g. 2bhabh, “fly” (Eccl 101; Isa 7 18), and ‘arabh, ‘fly’ (Ex 8 21 ff). On the other hand, they were put to it to find equivalents for the insect names in Lev 11 22; Joel 1 4,andelsewhere. For sal’ am (Lev 11 22) they evidently coined “bald locust,” following a statement of the Talm that it had a smooth head. For gézém and yelek they im- ported “palmer-worm” and “canker-worm,” two old Eng. names of caterpillars, using ‘caterpillar’ for hastt. The AV ‘‘beetle’”’ for hargol is absolutely inappropriate, and the RV “cricket,” while less objectionable, is probably also incorrect. The Eng. language seems to lack appropriate names for different. kinds of grasshoppers and locusts, and it is difficult to suggest any names to take the places of those against which these criticisms are directed. See under the names of the respective insects. See also ScorPIon and Sprpger, which are not included here because they are not strictly insects. Aurrep Evy Day INSPIRATION, in-spi-ra’shun: 1. Meaning of Terms . Occurrences in the Bible . Consideration of Important Passages (1) 2 Tim 3 16 we 4 filled 5. His Testimony That God Is Author of Scripture 6. Similar Testimony of His Immediate Followers 7. Their Identification of God and Scripture 8. The ‘‘Oracles of God” : 9. The Human Element _iu Scripture 10. Activities of God in Giving Scripture 11. General Problem of Origin: God's Part 12. How Human Qualities Affected Scripture. dential Preparation i 13. ‘“Inspiration’’ More than Mere ‘‘ Providence” 14. Witness of NT Writers to Divine Operation 15. ‘Inspiration”’ and ‘‘Revelation”’ 16. Scriptures a Divine-Human Book ? 17. Scripture of NT Writers Was the OT 18. Inclusion of the NT LiveRaTURE Provi- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA SS Innocents Inspiration The word ‘inspire’ and its derivatives seem to have come into Middle Eng. from the Fr., and have been employed from the first (early in 1. Meaning the 14th cent.) in a considerable num- of Terms ber of significations, physical and meta- phorical, secular and religious. The derivatives have been multiplied and their applica- tions extended during the procession of the years, until they have acquired a very wide and varied use. Underlying all their use, however, is the constant implication of an influence from without, producing in its object movements and effects beyond its native, or at least its ordinary powers. The noun “inspiration,” although already in use in the 14th eent., seems not to occur in any but a theo- logical sense until late in the 16th cent. The specifically theological sense of all these terms is governed, of course, by their usage in Lat theology; and this rests ultimately on their employment in the Lat Bible. In the Vulg Lat Bible the vb. in- spiro (Gen 2 7; Wisd 15 11; Ecclus 4 12; 2 Tim 3 16; 2 Pet 1 21) and the noun inspiratio (28 22 16; Job 32 8; Ps 18 15; Acts 17 25) both occur 4 or 5 t in somewhat diverse applications. In the development of a theological nomenclature, however, they have acquired (along with other less frequent applications) a technical sense with reference to the Bib. writers or the Bib. books. The Bib. books are called inspired as the Divinely determined products of inspired men; the Bib. writers are called inspired as breathed into by the Holy Spirit, so that the product of their activities transcends human powers and becomes Divinely authoritative. Inspiration is, therefore, usually defined as a supernatural influence exerted on the sacred writers by the Spirit of God, by virtue of which their writings are given Divine trustworthi- ness. Meanwhile, for Eng.-speaking men, these terms have virtually ceased to be Bib. terms. They natur- ally passed from the Lat Vulg into the 2. Occur- Eng. VSS made from it (most fully rencesin into the Rheims-Dovay: Job 32 8; the Bible Wisd 1511; Ecclus 412; 2 Tim 3 16; 2 Pet 1 21). But in the de velopment of the Eng. Bible they have found ever- decreasing place. In the EV of the Apoc (both AV and RY) “inspired” is retained in Wisd 15 11; but in the canonical books the nominal form alone occurs in AV and that only twice: Job 32 8, “But there is a spirit in man: and the inspiration of te Almighty giveth them understanding’; and 2 Ti 3 16, “All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for cor- rection, for instruction in righteousness.” RV removes the former of these instances, substituting “breath” for “inspiration”; and alters the latter so as to read: ‘Every scripture inspired of God is also profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correc-’ tion, for instruction which is in righteousness,” with a marginal alternative in the form of, “Every scripture is inspired of God and profitable,” ete. The word “inspiration” thus disappears from the Eng. Bible, and the word “inspired” is left in it only once, and then, let it be added, by a distinct and even misleading mistranslation. For the Gr word in this passage—edrvevoros, theépneustos—very distinctly does not mean ‘‘in- spired of God.’’ This phrase is rather the render- ing of the Lat, divinitus inspirata, restored from the Wyclif (‘Al Scripture of God ynspyridis . .. .’’) and Rhemish (‘‘All Scripture inspired of God is ...”) V8S of the Vulg. The Gr word does not even mean, as AV tr? it, “given by inspiration of God,’”’ although that rendering (inherited from Tindale: “All Scripture given by inspiration of God is... .”? and its successors; cf Geneva: ‘The Inspiration THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1474 whole Scripture is given by inspiration of God and is... .”) bas at least to say for itself that it is a somewhat clumsy, perhaps, but not misleading, paraphrase of the Gr term in the theological lan- guage of the day. The Gr term has, however, nothing to say of inspiring or of inspiration: it speaks only of a “spiring’’ or “spiration.”” What it says of Scripture is, not that it is “breathed into by God” or is the product of the Divine “inbreath- ing’’ intoits human authors, but that it is breathed out by God, ‘“God-breathed,” the product of the creative breath of God. In a word, what is de- clared by this fundamental passage is simply that the Scriptures are a Divine product, without any indication of how God has operated in producing them. No term could have been chosen, however, - which would have more emphatically asserted the Divine production of Scripture than that which is here employed. The “breath of God” is in Scrip- ture just the symbol of His almighty power, the bearer of His creative word. ‘By the word of Jeh,”’ we read in the significant parallel of Ps 33 6, ‘were the heavens made, and all the host of them by the breath of his mouth.” And it is particularly where the operations of God are energetic that this term (whether 1, rah, or WW), neshamah) is em- ployed to designate them—God’s breath is the irresistible outflow of His power. When Paul de- clares, then, that ‘every scripture,” or ‘all scripture” is the product of the Divine breath, ‘is God- breathed,”’ he asserts with as much energy as he could employ that Scripture is the product of a specifically Divine operation. (1) 2 Tim 3 16: In the passage in which Paul makes this energetic assertion of the Divine origin of Scripture be is engaged in explain- 3. Impor- ing the greatness of the advantages tant which Timothy had enjoyed for learn- Passages ing the saving truth of God. He had had good teachers; and from his very infancy he had been, hy his knowledge of the Scrip- tures, made wise unto salvation through faith in Jesus Christ. The expression, “‘sacred writings,” here employed (ver 15), is a technical one, not found elsewhere in the NT, it is true, but occurring cur- rently in Philo and Jos to designate that body of authoritative books which constituted the Jewish ‘“Law.’? It appears here anarthrously because it is set in contrast with the oral teaching which Timo- thy had enjoyed, as something still better: he had not only had good instructors, but also always “an open Bible,” as we should say, in his hand. To enhance yet further the great advantage of the possession of these Sacred Scriptures the apostle adds now a sentence throwing their nature strongly up to view. They are of Divine origin and there- fore of the highest value for all holy purposes. There is room for some difference of opinion as to the exact construction of this declaration. Shall we render “Bvyery Scripture’ or ‘‘All Scripture'’?_ Shall we render “Every (or all] Scripture is God-hreathed and [there- fore] profitable,’ or ‘Every for all) Scripture, being God-hreathed, is as well profitahle’’? No douht both questions are interesting, but for the main matter now engaging our attention they are hoth indifferent. Whether Paul, looking hack at the Sacred Scriptures he had just mentioned, makes the assertion he is ahout to add, of them distributively, of all their parts, or col- lectively, of their entire mass, is of no moment: to say that every part of these Sacred Scriptures is God-hreathed and to say that the whole of these Sacred Scriptures is God-hreathed, is, for the main matter, all one. Nor is the difference great hetween saying that they are in all their parts, or in their whole extent, God-hreathed and therefore profitable, and saying that they are in all their parts, or in their whole extent, because God-breathed as well profitahle. In hoth cases these Sacred Scriptures are declared to owe their value to their Divine origin; andin both cases this their Divine origin is energetically asserted of their entire fabric. On the whole, tho prefer- able construction would seem to be, "Every Scripture, seeing that it is God-hreathed, is as well profitable. In that case, what the apostle asserts is that the Sacred Scriptures, in their every several passage—for it is just “passage of Scripture’ which “Seripture'' in this dis- tributive use of it signifles—is the product of the cre- ative breath of God, and, hecause of this its Divine origi- nation, is of supreme value for all holy purposes. It is to he ohserved that the apostle does not stop here to tell us either what particular books enter into the collection which he calls Sacred Scriptures, or hy what precise operations God has produced them. Neither of these subjects entered into the matter he had at the mo- ment in hand. It was the value of the Scriptures, and the source of that value in their Divine origin, which he required at the moment to assert; and these things he asserts, leaving to other occasions any further facts con- cerning them which it might be well to emphasize. It is also to he ohserved that the apostle does not tell us here everything for which the Scriptures are made val- uahle by their Divine origination. He speaks simply to the point immediately in hand, and reminds Timothy of the value which these Scriptures, by virtue of their Divine origin, have for the ‘‘man of God.” Their spirit- ual power, as God-breathed, is all that he bad occasion here to advert to. Whatever other qualities may accrue to them from their Divine origin, he leaves to other occasions to speak of. (2) 2 Pet 119-21: What Paul tells us here about the Divine origin of the Scriptures is en- forced and extended by a striking passage in 2 Pet (1 19-21). Peter is assuring his readers that what had been made known to them of “the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ” did not rest on ‘cunningly devised fables.” He offers them the testi- mony of eyewitnesses of Christ’s glory. And then he intimates that they have better testimony than even that of eyewitnesses. ‘We have,” says he, “the prophetic word” (EV, unhappily, ‘the word of prophecy”): and this, he says, is “more sure,” and therefore should certainly be heeded. He refers, of course, to the Scriptures. Of what other “prophetic word” could he, over against the testimony of the eyewitnesses of Christ’s ‘excellent glory” (AV) say that ‘ we have” it, that is, it isin ourhands? And he proceeds at once to speak of it plainly as ‘‘Serip- tural prophecy.” You do well, he says, to pay heed to the prophetic word, because we know this first, that ‘every prophecy of scripture... .” It admits of more question, however, whether by this phrase he means the whole of Scripture, designated according to its character, as prophetic, that is, of Divine origin; or only that portion of Scripture which we discriminate as particularly prophetic, the immediate revelations contained in Scripture. The former is the more. likely view, inasmuch as the entirety of Scripture is elsewhere conceived and spoken of as prophetic. In that case, what Peter has to say of this “every prophecy of scripture’’—the exact equivalent, it will be observed, in this case of Paul’s ‘every scripture’ (2 Tim 3 16)-——applies to the whole of Scripture in allits parts. What hesays of it is that it does not come “of private interpre~ tation”; that is, it is not the result of human inves- tigation into the nature of things, the product of its writers’ own thinking. This is as much as to say it is of Divine gift. Accordingly, he proceeds at once to make this plain in a supporting clause which contains both the negative and the positive declaration: ‘For no prophecy ever came [m “was brought”’} by the will of man, but it was as borne by the Holy Spirit that men spoke from God.” In this singularly precise and pregnant statement there are several things which require to be carefully observed. There is, first of all, the emphatic de- nial that prophecy—that is to say, on the hypothesis upon which we are working, Scripture—owes its origin to human initiative: ‘No prophecy ever was brought—‘came’ is the word used in the EV text, with ‘was brought’ in RVm—by the will of man.” Then, there is the equally emphatic assertion that its source lies in God: it was spoken by men, in- deed, hut the men who spoke it “spake from God.” And a remarkable clause is here inserted, and thrown forward in the sentence that stress may fall 1475 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inspiration on it, which tells us how it could be that men, in speaking, should speak not from themselves, but from God: it was “as borne’’—it is the same word which was rendered “was brought’? above, and might possibly be rendered “brought” here—“by the Holy Spirit” that they spoke. Speaking thus under the determining influence of the Holy Spirit, the things they spoke were not from themselves, but from God. Here is as direct an assertion of the Divine origin of Scripture as that of 2 Tim 3 16. But there is more here than a simple assertion of the Divine origin of Scripture. We are advanced somewhat in our understanding of how God has produced the Scriptures. It was through the instrumentality of men who “spake from him.” More specifically, it was through an operation of the Holy Ghost on these men which is described as “bearmg” them. The term here used is a very specific one. It is not to be confounded with guiding, or directing, or controlling, or even leading in the full sense of that word. It goes beyond all such terms, in assigning the effect produced specifically to the active agent. What is “borne” is taken up i the “bearer,’”’ and conveyed by the “bearer’s’”’ power, not its own, to the “bearer’s” goal, not its own. The men who spoke from God are here declared, therefore, to have been taken up by the Holy Spirit and brought by His power to the goal of His choosing. The things which they spoke under this operation of the Spirit were therefore His things, not theirs. And that is the reason which is assigned why “the prophetic word’’ is so sure. Though spoken through the in- strumentality of men, it is, by virtue of the fact that these men spoke “‘as borne by the Holy Spirit,” an immediately Divine word. It will be observed that the proximate stress is laid here, not on the spiritual value of Scripture (though that, too, is seen in the background), but on the Divine trustworthi- ness of Scripture. Because this is the way every prophecy of Scripture “has been brought,”’ it affords a more sure basis of confidence than even the tes- timony of human eyewitnesses. Of course, if we do not understand by ‘the prophetic word” here the entirety of Scripture described, according to its character, as revelation, but only that element in Scripture which we call specifically prophecy, then it is directly only of that element in Scripture that these great declarations are made. In any event, however, they are made of the prophetic element in Scripture as written, which’ was the only form in which the readers of this Ep. possessed it, and which is the thing specifically intimated in the phrase “every prophecy of scripture.” ‘These great declarations are made, therefore, at least_of large tracts of Seripture; and if the entirety of Scripture is intended by the phrase ‘‘the prophetic word,”’ they are made of the whole of Scripture. (3) Jn 10 34f: How far the supreme trust- worthiness of Scripture, thus asserted, extends may be conveyed to us by a passage in one of Our Lord’s discourses recorded by John (Jn 10 34-35). The Jews, offended by Jesus’ “making himself God,” were in the act to stone Him, when He defended Himself thus: “Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods? If he called them gods, unto whom the word of God came (and the scripture cannot be broken), say ye of him, whom the Father sancti- fied [m “consecrated’’] and sent unto the world, Thou blasphemest; because I said, I am the Son of God?” It may be thought that this defence is inadequate. It certainly is incomplete: Jesus made Himself God (Jn 10 33) in a far higher sense than that in which “Ye are gods’’ was said of those “unto whom the word of God came’: He had just declared in unmistakable terms, ‘I and the Father areone.’”’ But it was quite sufficient for the imme- diate end in view—to repel the technical charge of blasphemy based on His making Himself God: it is not blasphemy to call one God in any sense in which he may fitly receive that designation; and certainly if it is not blasphemy to call such men as those spoken of in the passage of Scripture adduced gods, because of their official functions, it cannot be blasphemy to call Him God whom the Father consecrated and sent into the world. The point for us to note, however, is merely that Jesus’ defence takes the form of an appeal to Scripture; and it is important to observe how He makes this appeal. In the first place, He adduces the Scriptures as law: “Is it not written in your law?” He demands. The passage of Scripture which He adduces is not written in that portion of Scripture which was more specifically called “the Law,” that is to say, the Pent; nor in any portion of Scripture of formally legal contents. It is written in the Book of Pss; and in a particular psalm which is as far as possible from presenting the external characteristics of legal enactment (Ps 82 6). When Jesus adduces_this passage, then, as written in the “law’’ of the Jews, e does it, not because it stands in this psalm, but because it is a part of Scripture at large. In other words, He here ascribes legal authority to the entirety of Scripture, in accordance with a con- ception common enough among the Jews (cf Jn 12 34), and finding expression in the NT occasionally, both on the lips of Jesus Himself, and in the writings of the apostles. Thus, on a later occasion (Jn 15 25), Jesus declares that it is written in the “law’’ of the Jews, ‘“‘They hated me without a cause,” a clause found in Ps 35 19. And Paul assigns pas- sages both from the Pss and from Isa to “the Law” (1 Cor 14 21; Rom 3 19), and can write such a sentence as this (Gal 4 21f): “Tell me, ye that desire to be under the law, do ye not hear the law? For it is written ... .”’ quoting from the narra- tive of Gen. We have seen that the entirety of Scripture was conceived as “prophecy”; we now see that the entirety of Scripture was also conceived as “law’’: these three terms, the law, prophecy, Scripture, were indeed, materially, strict synonyms, as our present passage itself advises us, by varying the formula of adduction in contiguous verses from “law? to “scripture.’ And what is thus implied in the manner in which Scripture is adduced, is immediately afterward spoken out in the most explicit language, because it forms an_ essential element in Our Lord’s defence. It might have been enough to say simply, ‘Is it not written in your law?” But Our Lord, determined to drive His appeal to Scripture home, sharpens the point to the utmost by adding with the highest emphasis: “and the scripture cannot be broken.’ This is the reason why it is worth while to appeal to what is ‘“written in the law,” because ‘‘the scripture cannot be broken.” The word “broken” here is the com- mon one for breaking the law, or the Sabbath, or the like (Jn 6 18; 7 23; Mt 5 19), and the mean- ing of the declaration is that it is impossible for the Scripture to be annulled, its authority to be with- stood, or denied. The movement of thought is to the effect that, because it is impossible for the Scripture—the term is perfectly general and wit- nesses to the unitary character of Scripture (it is all, for the purpose in hand, of a piece)—to be with- stood, therefore this particular Scripture which is cited must be taken as of irrefragable authority. What we have here is, therefore, the strongest pos- sible assertion of the indefectible authority of Scrip- ture; precisely what is true of Scripture is that it “cannot be broken.’ Now, what is the particular thing in Scripture, for the confirmation of which the indefectible authority of Scripture is thus invoked? It is one of its most casual clauses—more than that, Inspiration the very form of its expression in one of its most casual clauses. This means, of course, that in the Saviour’s view the indefectible authority of Scrip- ture attaches to the very form of expression of its most casualclauses. It belongs to Scripture through and through, down to its most minute particulars, that it is of indefectible authority. It is sometimes suggested, it is true, that Our Lord’s argument here is an argumentum ad homi- nem, and that His words, therefore, express not His own view of the authority of Scripture, but that of His Jewish opponents. It will scarcely be de- nied that there is a vein of satire running through Our Lord’s defence: that the Jews so readily al- lowed that corrupt judges might properly be called “gods,” but could not endure that He whom the Father had consecrated and sent into the world should call Himself Son of God, was a somewhat pungent fact to throw up into such a high light. But the argument from Scripture is not ad hominem but e concessu; Scripture was common ground with Jesus and His opponents. If proof were needed for so obvious a fact, it would be supplied by the circumstance that this is not an isolated but a rep- resentative passage. The conception of Scripture thrown up into such clear view here supplies the ground of all Jesus’ appeals to Scripture, and of all the appeals of the NT writers as well. Every- where, to Him and to them alike, an appeal to Scripture is an appeal to an indefectible authority whose determination is final; both He and they make their appeal indifferently to every part of Scripture, to every element in Scripture, to its most incidental clauses as well as to its most fundamental principles, and to the very form of its expression. This attitude toward Scripture as an authoritative document is, indeed, already intimated by their constant designation of it by the name of Scripture, the Scriptures, that is “the Document,” by way of eminence; and by their customary citation of it with the simple formula, “It is written.’ What is written in this document admits so little of question- ing that its authoritativeness required no asserting, but might safely be taken for granted. Both modes of expression belong to the constantly illustrated habitudes of Our Lord’s speech. The first words He is recorded as uttering after His manifestation to Israel were an appeal to the unquestionable authority of Scripture; to Satan’s temptations He opposed no other weapon than the final “It is writ- ten’! (Mt 4 4.7.10; Lk 4 4.8). And among the last words which He spoke to His disciples before He was received up was a rebuke to them for not understanding that all things “which are written in the law of Moses, and the prophets, and psalms” concerning Him—that is (ver 45) in the entire “Scriptures’—‘must_ needs be’ (very emphatic) “fulfilled” (Lk 24 44). “Thus it is written,” says He (ver 46), as rendering all doubt absurd. For, as He had explained earlier upon the same day (Lk 24 25 ff), it argues only that one is “foolish and slow of heart’ if he does not ‘believe in” (if his faith does not rest securely on, as on a firm founda- tion) “all” (without limit of subject-matter here) “that the prophets’ (explained in ver 27 as equiva- lent to “all the scriptures’’) ‘have spoken.” The necessity of the fulfilment of all that is written in Seripture, which is so strongly asserted in these last instructions to His disciples, is 4. Neces- frequently adverted to by Our Lord. sary Ful- He repeatedly explains of occurrences filment of occasionally happening that they have Scripture come to pass ‘that the scripture might be fulfilled” (Mk 14 49; Jn 13 18; 17 12; cf 12 14; Mk 9 12.13). On the basis of Scriptural declarations, therefore, He announces with confidence that given events will certainly THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA | 1476 occur: ‘All ye shall be offended [lit. “scandalized”’] in me this night: for it is written... .” (Mt 26 31; Mk 14 27; cf Lk 20 17). Although holding at His command ample means of escape, He bows before on-coming calamities, for, He asks, how otherwise “should the scriptures be fufilled, that thus it must be?’ (Mt 26 54). It is not merely the two disciples with whom He talked on the way to Emmaus (Lk 24 25) whom He rebukes for not trusting themselves more perfectly to the teaching of Scripture. ‘Ye search the scriptures,” he says to the Jews, in the classical passage (Jn 5 39), “because ye think that in them ye have eter- nal life; and these are they which bear witness of me; and ye will not come to me, that ye may have life’ These words surely were spoken more in sorrow than in scorn: there is no blame implied either for searching the Scriptures or for thinking that eternal life is to be found in Scripture; ap- proval rather. What the Jews are blamed for is that they read with a veil lying upon their hearts which He would fain take away (2 Cor 3 15f). “Ye search the scriptures’—that is right: and “even you” (emphatic) “think to have eternal life in them’’—that is right, too. But “it is these very Scriptures’ (very emphatic) “which are bearing witness” (continuous process) “of me; and” (here is the marvel!) “ye will not come to me and have life!’’—that you may, thatis, reach the very end you have so properly in view in searching the Scriptures. Their failure is due, not to the Scriptures but to themselves, who read the Scriptures to such little purpose. . Quite similarly Our Lord often finds occasion to express wonder at the little effect to which Scrip- ture had been read, not because it had 5. Christ’s heen looked into too curiously, but Testimony because it had not been looked into That God earnestly enough, with sufficiently Is Author simple and robust trust in its every declaration. ‘‘Have ye not read even this scripture?’ He demands, as He adduces Ps 118 to show that the rejection of the Messiah was al- ready intimated in Scripture (Mk 12 10; Mt 21 42 varies the expression to the equivalent: ‘Did ye never read in the scriptures?’’). And when the indignant Jews came to Him complaining of the Hosannas with which the children in the Temple were acclaiming Him, and demanding, ‘‘Hearest thou what these are saying?” He met them (Mt 21 16) merely with; “Yea: did ye never read, Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings thou has perfected praise?” The underlying thought of these passages is spoken out when He intimates that the source of all error in Divine things is just ignorance of the Scriptures: “Ye do err,’ He declares to His ques- tioners, on an important occasion, “not knowing the scriptures” (Mt 22 29); or, as it is put, perhaps more forcibly, in interrogative form, in its || in another Gospel: “Is it not for this cause that ye err, that ye know not the scriptures?’ (Mk 12 24). Clearly, he who rightly knows the Scriptures does not err. The confidence with which Jesus rested on Scripture, in its every declaration, is further illustrated in a passage like Mt 19 4. Certain Pharisees had come to Him with a question on divorce and He met them thus: ‘Have ye not read, that he who made them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, For this cause shall a man leave his father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife; and the two shall become one flesh? .... What therefore God hath joined to- gether, let not man put asunder.”’ The point to be noted is the explicit reference of Gen 2 24 to God as its author: “He who made them... . said”; “what therefore God hath joined together.” Yet this passage does not give us a saying of God’s 1477 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inspiration recorded in Scripture, but just the word of Scripture itself, and can be treated as a declaration of God’s only on the hypothesis that all Scripture is a decla- ration of God’s. The || in Mk (10 5 ff) just as truly, though not as explicitly, assigns the passage to God as its author, citing it as authoritative law and speaking of its enactment as an act of Gad’s. And it is interesting to observe in passing that Paul, having occasion to quote the same passage (1 Cor 6 16), also explicitly qnotes it as a Divine word: “For, The twain, saith he, shall become one flesh’’— the ‘“‘he” here, in accordance with a usage to be noted later, meaning just “God.” Thus clear is it that Jesus’ occasional adduction of Seripture as an anthoritative document rests on an ascription of it to God as its author. His tes- timony is that whatever stands written in Scripture is a word of God. Nor can we evacuate this testi- mony of its force on the plea that it represents Jesus only in the days of His flesh, when He may be sup- ‘posed to have reflected merely the opinions of His day and generation. The view of Scripture He announces was, no doubt, the view of His day and generation as well as His own view. But there is no reason to doubt that it was held by Him, not because it was the current view, but because, in His Divine-human knowledge, He knew it to be true; for, even in His humiliation, He is the faith- ful and true witness. And in any event we should bear in mind that this was the view of the resur- rected as well as of the humiliated Christ. It was after He had _ suffered and had risen again in the power of His Divine life that He pronounced those foolish and slow of heart who do not believe all that stands written in all the Scriptures (Lk 24 25); and that He laid down the simple ‘Thus it is written” as the sufficient ground of confident belief (Lk 24 46). Nor can we explain away Jesus’ testimony to the Divine trustworthiness of Scrip- ture by interpreting it as not His own, but that of His followers, placed on His lips in their reports of His words. Not only is it too constant, minute, inti- mate and in part incidental, and therefore, as it were, hidden, to admit of this interpretation; but it so pervades all our channels of information con- cerning Jesus’ teaching as to make it certain that it comes actually from Him. It belongs not only to the Jesus of our evangelical records but as well to the Jesus of the earlier sources which underlie our evangelical records, as anyone may assure himself by observing the instances in which Jesus adduces the Scriptures as Divinely authoritative that are recorded in more than one of the Gospels (e.g. ‘It is written,” Mt 4 4.7.10 [Lk 4 4.8.10]; Mt 11 10; (Lk 7 27]; Mt 21 13 [Lk 19 46; Mk 11 17]; Mt 26 31 [Mk 14 21]; “the scripture’ or “the scriptures,’ Mt 19 4 [Mk 10 9]; Mt 21 42 (Mk 12 10; Lk 20 17]; Mt 22 29 [Mk 12 24; Lk 20 37]; Mt 26 56([Mk 14 49; Lk 24 44]). These passages alone would suffice to make clear to us the testimony of Jesus to Scripture as in all its parts and declarations Divinely authoritative. The attempt to attribute the testimony of Jesus to His followers has in its favor only the undeniable fact that the testimony of the writers 6. Similar of the NT is to precisely the same Witness of effect as His. They, too, cursorily Apostles speak of Scripture by that pregnant name and adduce it with the simple “Tt is written,” with the implication that whatever stands written in it is Divinely authoritative. As Jesus’ official life begins with this “It is written”’ (Mt 4 4), so the evangelical proclamation begins with au “Even as it is written” (Mk 1 2); and as Jesus sought the justification of His work in a solemn ‘Thus it is written, that the Christ should suffer, and rise again from the dead the third day” (Lk 24 46 ff), so the apostles solemnly justified the Gospel which they preached, detail after detail, by appeal to the Scriptures, “That Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures” and “That he hath been raised on the third day according to the scrip- tures” (1 Cor 16 3.4; cf Acts 8 35; 17 3; 26 22, and also Rom 117; 3 4.10; 4.17; 11 26; 14 11; 1 Cor 119; 29; 3 19; 16 45; Gal 3 10.18; 4 22.27). Wherever they carried the gospel it was as a gospel resting on Scripture that they proclaimed it (Acts 17 2; 18 24.28); and they encouraged themselves to test its truth by the Scriptures (Acts 17 11). The holiness of life they inculcated, they based on Scriptural requirement (1 Pet 1 16), and they commended the royal law of love which they taught by Scriptural sanction (Jas 2 8). Every detail of duty was supported by them by an appeal to Scripture (Acts 23 5; Rom 12 19). The cir- cumstances of their lives and the events occasion- ally occurring about them are referred to Scripture for their significance (Rom 2 26; 8 36; 9 83; 11 8; 15 9.21; 2 Cor 4 13). As Our Lord declared that whatever was written in Scripture must needs be fulfilled (Mt 26 54; Lk 22 37; 24 44), so His followers explained one of the most startling facts which had occurred in their experience by pointing out that “it was needful that the scripture should be fulfilled, which the Holy Spirit spake before by the mouth of David’ (Acts 1 16). Here the ground of this constant appeal to Scripture, so that it is enough that a thing “is contained in scripture” (1 Pet 2 6) for it to be of indefectible authority, is plainly enough declared: Scripture must.needs be fulfilled, for what is contamed in it is the declaration of the Holy Ghost through the human author. What Scripture says, God says; and accordingly we read such remarkable declarations as these: ‘For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, For this very purpose did I raise thee up” (Rom 9 17); “And the scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the gospel beforehand unto Abraham, .... In thee shall all the nations be blessed” (Gal 3 8). These are not instances of simple personification of Scripture, which is itself a sufficiently remarkable usage (Mk 15 28; Jn 7 3842; 1937; Rom 43; 10 11; 11 2; Gal 4 30; 1 Tim 5 18; Jas 2 23; 4 5f), vocal with the conviction expressed by James (4 5) that Scripture canuot speak in vain. They indi- cate a certain confusion in current speech between “Seripture’”’ aud “God,” the outgrowth of a deep- seated conviction that the word of Scripture is the word of God. It was not “Scripture” that spoke to Pharaoh, or gave his great promise to Abraham, but God. But “Scripture” and “God” lay so close together in the minds of the writers of the NT that they could naturally speak of ‘Scripture’ doing what Scripture records God as doing. It was, however, even more natural to them to speak casually of God saying what the Scriptures say; and accordingly we meet with forms of speech such as ‘these: “Wherefore, even as the Holy Spirit saith, To-day if ye shall hear His voice,” ete (He 3 7, quoting Ps 95 7); “Thou art God .. . . who by the mouth of thy servant David hast said, Why did the heathen rage,” etc (Acts 4 25 AV, quoting Ps 21); “He that raised him from the dead .... hath spoken on this wise, I will give u... . becanse he saith also in another [place] ... 2 (Acts 13 34, quoting Isa 55 3 and Ps 16 10), and the like. The words put into God’s mouth in each case are not words of God recorded in the Scriptures, but just Scripture words in themselves. When we take the two classes of passages together, in the one of which the Scriptures are spoken of as God, while in the other God is spoken of as if He were the Scriptures, we may perceive how close Inspiration THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1478 the identification of the two was in the minds of the writers of the NT. _ This identification is strikingly observable in certain catenae of quotations, in which there are brought together a number of passages 7. Identifi- of Scripture closely connected with cation of one another. The first chapter of the God and Ep. to the He supplies an example. Scriptures We may begin with ver 5: “For unto which of the angels said he’—the subject being necessarily “God’—‘‘at any time, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee ?”— the citation being from Ps 2 7 and very appro- priate in the mouth of God—“‘and again, I will be to him a Father, and he shall be to me a Son?”’— from 2 § 7 14, again a declaration of God’s own— “And when he again bringeth in the firstborn into the world he saith, And let all the angels of God worship him’’—from Dt 32 43, LXX, or Ps 97 7, in neither of which is God the speaker—“And of the angels he saith, Who maketh his angels winds, and his ministers a flame of fire’—from Ps 104 4, where again God is not the speaker but is spoken of in the third person—‘but of the Son he saith, Thy throne, O God, etc’’—from Ps 45 6.7 where again God is not the speaker, but is addressed—“ And, Thou, Lord, in the beginning,’ etc—from Ps 102 25-27, where again God is not the speaker but is addressed—‘‘But of which of the angels hath he said at any time, Sit thou on my right hand?”’ ete —from Ps 110 1, in which God is the speaker. Here we have passages in which God is the speaker and passages in which God is not the speaker, but is addressed or spoken of, indiscriminately assigned to God, because they all have it in common that they are words of Scripture, and as words of Scrip- ture are words of God. Similarly in Rom 15 9 ff we have a series of citations the first of which is introduced by ‘‘as it is written,” and the next two by “again he saith,” and “again,” and the last by “and again, Isaiah saith,”’ the first being from Ps 18 49; the second from Dt 32 438; the third from Ps 117 1; and the last from Isa 11 10. Only the last (the only one here assigned to the human author) is a word of God in the text of the OT. This view of the Scriptures as a compact mass of words of God occasioned the formation of a desig- nation for them by which this their 8. “Oracles character was explicitly expressed. of God” Thisdesignation is “the sacred oracles,” “the oracles of God.” It occurs with extraordinary frequency in Philo, who very com- monly refers to Scripture as “the sacred oracles” and cites its several passages as each an “oracle.” Sharing, as they do, Philo’s conception of the Scrip- tures as, in all their parts, a word of God, the NT writers naturally also speak of them under this designation. The classical passage is Rom 8 2 (cf He 6 12; Acts 7 38). Here Paul begins an enumeration of the advantages which belonged to the chosen people above other nations; and, after declaring these advantages to have been great and numerous, he places first among them all their possession of the Scriptures: “What advantage then hath the Jew? or what is the profit of circum- cision? Much every way: first of all, that they were intrusted with the oracles of God.” That by “the oracles of God” here are meant just the Holy Scriptures in their entirety, conceived as a direct Divine revelation, and not any portions of them, or elements in them more esp. thought of as revelatory, is perfectly clear from the wide con- temporary use of this designation in this sense by Philo, and is put beyond question by the presence in the NT of habitudes of speech which rest on and grow out of the conception of Scripture embodied in this term. From the point of view of this desig- nation, Scripture is thought of as the living voice of God speaking in all its parts directly to the reader; and, accordingly, it is cited by some such formula as “it is said,’ and this mode of citing Scripture duly occurs as an alternative to “it is written” (Lk 4 12, replacing “it is written’? in Mt; He 3°15; ef Rom 4 18). It is due also to this pomt of view that Scripture is cited, not as what God or the Holy Spirit “said,” but what He “says,” the present tense emphasizing the living voice of God speaking in Scriptures to the indi- vidual soul (He 3 7; Acts 13 35; He 1 7.8.10; Rom 15 10). And esp. there is due to it the pecul- iar usage by which Scripture is cited by the simple “saith,” without expressed subject, the subject being too well understood, when Scripture is ad- duced, to require stating; for who could be the speaker of the words of Scripture but God only (Rom 15 10; 1 Cor 616; 2 Cor62; Gal3 16; Eph 4 8; 6 14)? The analogies of this preg- nant subjectless “saith’’ are very widespread. It- was with it that the ancient Pythagoreans and Pla- tonists and the mediaeval Aristotelians adduced each their master’s teaching; it was with it that, in certain circles, the judgments of Hadrian’s great jurist Salvius Julianus were cited; African stylists were even accustomed to refer by it to Sallust, their great model. There is a tendency, cropping out occasionally, in the OT, to omit the name of God as superfluous, when He, as the great logical sub- ject always in mind, would be easily understood (cf Job 2023; 21°17; Ps 1142; Lam 4 22). So, too, when the NT writers quoted Scripture there was no need to say whose word it was: that lay beyond question in every mind. This usage, accordingly, is a specially striking intimation of the vivid sense which the N'T writers had of the Divine origin of the Scriptures, and means that in citing them they were acutely conscious that they were citing immediate words of God. How completely the Scriptures were to them just the word of God may be illustrated by a passage like Gal 3 16: “He saith not, And to seeds, as of many; but as of one, And to thy seed, which is Christ.” We have seen Our Lord hanging an argument on the very words of Scripture (Jn 10 34); elsewhere His reasoning depends on the particular tense (Mt 22 32) or word (Mt 22 43) used in Scripture. Here Paul’s argument rests similarly on a grammatical form. No doubt it is the grammatical form of the word which God is recorded as having spoken to Abraham that isin question. But Paul knows what grammat- ical form God employed in speaking to Abraham only as the Scriptures have transmitted it to him; and, as we have seen, in citing the words of God and the words of Scripture he was not accustomed to make any distinction between them. It is probably the Scriptural word as a Scriptural word, therefore, which he has here in mind: though, of course, it is possible that what he here witnesses to is rather the detailed trustworthiness of the Scriptural record than its direct divinity—if we can separate two things which apparently were not separated in Paul’s mind. This much we can at least say without straining, that the designation of Scripture as “scripture” and its citation by the formula, ‘It is written,” attest primarily its indefectible authority; the designation of it as “oracles’’ and the adduction of it by the for- mula, “It says,’ attest primarily its immediate divinity. Its authority rests on its divinity and its divinity expresses itself in its trustworthiness; and the NT writers in all their use of it treat it as what they declare it_to be—a God-breathed document, which, because God-breathed, is through and through trustworthy in all its assertions, authoritative in all its declarations, and down to its last particular, the very word of God, His “oracles.” 1479 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inspiration That the Scriptures are throughout a Divine book, created by the Divine energy and speaking in their every part with Divine author- 9. Human ity directly to the heart of the readers, Element in is the fundamental fact concerning Scripture them which is witnessed by Christ and the sacred writers to whom we owe the NT. But the strength and constancy with which they bear witness to this primary fact do not prevent their recognizing hy the side of it that the criptures have come into being by the agency of men. It would be inexact to say that they recog- nize a human element in Scripture: they do not parcel Scripture out, assigning portions of it, or elements in it, respectively to God and man. In their view the whole of Scripture in all its parts and in all its elements, down to the least minutiae, in form of expression as well as in substance of teaching, is from God; but the whole of it has been given by God through the instrumentality of men. There is, therefore, in their view, not, indeed, a human element or ingredient in Scripture, and much less human divisions or sections of Scripture, but a human side or aspect to Scripture; and they do not fail to give full recognition to this human side or aspect. In one of the primary passages which has already been before us, their conception is given, if somewhat broad and very succinct, yet clear expression. No ‘prophecy,’ Peter tells us (2 Pet 1 21), ‘ever came by the will of man; but as borne by the Holy Ghost, men spake from God? Here the whole initiative is assigned to God, and such complete contro] of the human agents that the product is truly God’s work. The men who speak in this “prophecy of scripture” speak not of them- selves or ont of themselves, but from “God”: they speak only as they are “borne by the Holy Ghost.” But it is they, after all, who speak. Scripture is the product of man, but only of man speaking from God and under such a control of the Holy Spirit as that in their speaking they are “borne’’ by Him. The conception obviously is that the Scrip- tures have been given by the instrumentality of men; and this conception finds repeated incidental expression throughout the NT. It is this conception, for example, which is ex- pressed when Our Lord, quoting Ps 110, declares of its words that ‘David himself said in the Holy Spirit” (Mk 12 36). There is a certain emphasis here on the words being David’s own words, which is due to the requirements of the argument Our Lord was conducting, but which none the less sin- cerely represents Our Lord’s conception of their origin. They are David’s own words which we find in Ps 110, therefore; but they are David’s own words, spoken not of his own motion merely, but “in the Holy Spirit,” that is to say—we could not better paraphrase it—‘‘as borne by the Holy Spirit.” In other words, they are ‘“God-breathed” words and therefore authoritative in a sense above what any words of David, not spoken in the Holy Spirit, could possibly be. Generalizing the matter, we may say that the words of Scripture are con- ceived by Our Lord and the NT writers as the words of their human authors when speaking “in the Holy Spirit,” that is to say, by His initiative and under His controlling direction. The conception finds even more precise expression, perhaps, in such a statement as we find—it is Peter who is speaking and itis again a psalm which is cited—in Acts 1 16, “The Holy Spirit spake by the mouth of David.” Here the Holy Spirit is adduced, of course, as the real author of what is said (and hence Peter’s certainty that what is said will be fulfilled); but David’s mouth is expressly designated as the instrument (it is the instrumental preposition that is used) by means of which the Holy Spirit speaks the Scripture in question. He does not speak save through David’s mouth. Accordingly, in Acts 4 25, ‘the Lord that made the heaven and earth,’ acting by His Holy Spirit, is declared to have spoken another psalm ‘through the mouth of .... David,’ His “Servant”; and in Mt 13 35 still another psalm is adduced as “spoken through the prophet” (cf Mt 2 5). In the very act of energetically assert- ing the Divine origin of Scripture the human instrumentality through which it is given is con- stantly recognized. The NT writers have, there- fore, no difficulty in assigning Scripture to its hu- man authors, or in discovering in Scripture traits due to its human authorship. They freely quote it by such simple formulae as these: ‘Moses saith” (Rom 10 19); ‘Moses said’ (Mt 22 24; Mk 7 10; Acts 3 22); ‘Moses writeth’” (Rom 10 5); “Moses wrote’ (Mk 12 19; Lk 20 28); “Isaiah .... saith’ (Rom 10 20); ‘Isaiah said” (Jn 12 89); “Isaiah crieth’? (Rom 9 27); “Isaiah hath said before’ (Rom 9 29); ‘‘said Isaiah the prophet” (Jn 1 23); ‘did Isaiah prophesy’ (Mk 7 6; Mi 15 7); “David saith’? (Lk 20 42; Acts 2 25; Rom 11 9); “David said” (Mk 12 36). It is to be noted that when thus Scripture is adduced by the names of its human authors, it is a matter of complete in- difference whether the words adduced are comments of these authors or direct words of God recorded by them. As the plainest words of the human authors are assigned to God as their real author, so the most express words of God, repeated by the Scriptural writers, are cited by the names of these human writers (Mt 15 7; Mk 7 6; Rom 10 5 19.20; cf Mk 7 10 from the Decalogue). To say that “Moses” or “David says,” is evidently thus only a way of saying that “Scripture says,’’ which is the same as to say that ‘God says.” Such modes of citing Scripture, accordingly, carry us little be- yond merely connecting the name, or perhaps we may say the individuality, of the several writers with the portions of Scripture given through each. How it was given through them is left meanwhile, if not without suggestion, yet without specific ex- planation. We seem safe only in inferring this much: that the gift of Scripture through its human authors took place by a process much more intimate than can be expressed by the term ‘dictation,’ and that it took place in a process in which the control of the Holy Spirit was too complete and pervasive to permit the human qualities of the secondary authors in any way to condition the purity of the product as the word of God. The Geis in other words, are conceived by the writers of the NT as through and through God’s book, in every part expressive of His mind, given through men after a fashion which does no violence to their nature as men, and constitutes the book also men’s book as well as God’s, in every part expressive of the mind of its human authors. If we attempt to get behind this broad statement and to obtain a more detailed conception of the activities by which God has given the 10. Activi- Scriptures, we are thrown back upon ties of God somewhat general representations, sup- in Giving ported by the analogy of the modes Scripture of God’s working in other spheres of His operation. It is very desirable that we should free ourselves at the outset from in- fluences arising from the current employment of the term “inspiration” to designate this process. This term is not a Bib. term and its etymological impli- cations are not perfectly accordant with the Bib. conception of the modes of the Divine operation in giving the Scriptures. The Bib. writers do not con- ceive of the Scriptures as a human product breathed into by the Divine Spirit, and thus heightened in its qualities or endowed with new qualities; but as a Inspiration THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1480 Divine product produced through the instrumen- tality of men. They do not conceive of these men, by whose instrumentality Scripture is produced, as working upon their own initiative, though ener- gized by God to greater effort. and higher achieve- ment, but as moved by the Divine initiative and borne by the irresistible power of the Spirit of God along ways of His choosing to ends of His appoint- ment. The difference between the two conceptions may not appear great when the mind is fixed ex- clusively upon the nature of the resulting product. But they are differing conceptions, and look at the production of Scripture from distinct points of view —the human and the Divine; and the involved mental attitudes toward the origin of Scripture are very diverse. The term “inspiration” is too firmly fixed, in both theological and popular usage, as the technical designation of the action of God in giving the Scriptures, to be replaced; and we may be thankful that its native implications lie as close as they do to the Bib. conceptions. Meanwhile, however, it may be justly insisted that it shall receive its definition from the representations of Scripture, and not be permitted to impose upon our thought ideas of the origin of Scripture derived from an analysis of its own implications, etymo- logical or historical. The Scriptural conception of the relation of the Divine Spirit to the human authors in the production of Scripture is better ex- pressed by the figure of “bearing” than by the figure of ‘‘inbreathing’’; and when our Bib. writers speak of the action of the Spirit of God in this relation as a breathing, they represent it as a “breathing out” of the Scriptures by the Spirit, and not a “breathing into’’ the Scriptures by Him. So soon, however, as we seriously endeavor to form for ourselves a clear conception of the precise nature of the Divine action in this 11. General “breathing out” of the Scriptures— Problem of this “bearing” of the writers of the Origin: Scriptures to their appointed goal of God’s Part the production of a book of Divine trustworthiness and indefectible au- thority—we become acutely aware of a more deeply lying and much wider problem, apart from which this one of inspiration, technically so called, cannot be profitably considered. This is the general prob- lem of the origin of the Scriptures and the part of God in all that complex of processes by the inter- action of which these books, which we call the sacred Scriptures, with all their peculiarities, and all their qualities of whatever sort, have been brought into being. For, of course, these books were not produced suddenly, by some miraculous act— handed down complete out of heaven, as the phrase goes; but, like all other products of time, are the ultimate effect of many processes codperating through long periods. There is to be considered, for instance, the preparation of the material which forms the subject-matter of these books: in a sacred history, say, for example, to be narrated; or in a religious experience which may serve as a norm for record; or in a logical elaboration of the contents of revelation which may be placed at the service of God’s people; or in the progressive revelation of Divine truth itself, supplying their culminating contents. And there is the preparation of the men to write these books to be considered, a preparation physical, intellectual, spiritual, which must have attended them throughout their whole lives, and, indeed, must have had its beginning in their remote ancestors, and the effect of which was to bring the right men to the right places at the right times, with the right endowments, impulses, acquirements, to write just the books which were designed for them. When “‘inspiration,’’ technically so called, is super- induced on lines of preparation like these, it takes on quite a different aspect from that which it bears when it is thought of as an isolated action of the Divine Spirit operating out of all relation to his- torical processes. Representations are sometimes made as if, when God wished to produce sacred books which would incorporate His will—a_ series of letters like those of Paul, for example—He was reduced to the necessity of going down to earth and painfully scrutinizing the men He found there, seeking anxiously for the one who, on the whole, promised best for His purpose; and then violently forcing the material He wished expressed through him, against his natural bent, and with as little loss from his recalcitrant characteristics as possible. Of course, nothing of the sort took place. If God wished to give His people a series of letters like Paul’s, He prepared a Paul to write them, and the Paul He brought to the task was a Paul who spon- taneously would write just such letters. If we bear this in mind, we shall know what esti- mate to place upon the common representation to the effect that the human character- 12. Effect istics of the writers must, and in point of Human of fact do, condition and qualify the Qualities: writings produced by them, the impli- Providential cation being that, therefore, we cannot Preparation get from man a pure word of God. As light that passes through the colored glass of a cathedral window, we are told, is light from heaven, but is stained by the tints of the glass through which it passes; so any word of God which is passed through the mind and soul of a man must come out discolored by the personality through which it is given, and just to that degree ceases to be the pure word of God. But what if this per- sonality has itself been formed by God into precisely the personality it is, for the express purpose of communicating to the word given through it just the coloring which it gives it? What if the colors of the stained-glass window have been designed by the architect for the express purpose of giving to the light that floods the cathedral precisely the tone and uality it receives from them? What if the word of od that comes to His people is framed by God into the word of God it is, precisely by means of the qualities of the men formed by Him for the pur- pose, through which it is given? When we think of God the Lord giving by His Spirit a body of authoritative Scriptures to His people, we must remember that He is the God of providence and of grace as well as of revelation and inspiration, and that He holds all the lines of preparation as fully under His direction as He does the specific operation which we call technically, in the narrow sense, by the name of “inspiration.” The production of the Scriptures is, in point of fact, a long process, in the course of which numerous and very varied Divine activities are involved, providential, gracious, miraculous, all of which must be taken into account in any attempt to explain the relation of God to the production of Scripture. When they are all taken into account we can no longer wonder that the resultant Scriptures are constantly spoken of as the pure word of God. We wonder, rather, that an additional operation of God—what we call spe- cifically “inspiration,” in its technical sense—was thought necessary. Consider, for example, how a piece of sacred history—say the Book of Ch, or the great historical work, Gospel and Acts, of Luke—is brought to the writing. There is first of all the preparation of the history to be written: God the Lord leads the sequence of occurrences through the development He has designed for them that they may convey their lessons to His people: a “teleological” or “aetiological” character is in- herent in the very course of events. Then He pre- pares a man, by birth, training, experience, gifts 1481 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inspiration of grace, and, if need be, of revelation, capable of appreciating this historical development and eager to search it out, thrilling in all his being with its ‘lessons and bent upon making them clear and effect- ive to others. When, then, by His providence, God sets this man to work on the writing of this history, will there not be spontaneously written by him the history which it was Divinely intended should be written? Or consider how a psalmist would be prepared to put into moving verse a piece of normative religious experience: how he would be born with just the right quality of religioussensibility, of parents through whom he should receive just the right hereditary bent, and from whom he should get precisely the right religious example and train- ing, in circumstances of life in which his religious tendencies should be developed precisely on right lines; how he would be brought through just the right experiences to quicken in him the precise emo- tions he would be called upon to express, and finally would be placed in precisely the exigencies which would cali out their expression. Or consider the providential preparation of a writer of a didactic epistle—by means of which he should be given the intellectual breadth and acuteness, and be trained in habitudes of reasoning, and placed in the situations which would call out precisely the argumentative presentation of Christian truth which was required of him. When we give due place in our thoughts to the universality of the providential government of God, to the minuteness and completeness of its sway, and to its invariable efficacy, we may be in- clined to ask what is needed beyond this mere provi- dential government to secure the production of sacred books which should be in every detail abso- lutely accordant with the Divine will. The answer is, Nothing is needed beyond mere providence to secure such books—provided only that it does not lie in the Divine pur- 13. “Inspi- pose that these books should possess ration” qualities which rise above the powers More than of men to produce, even under the *Provi- most complete Divine guidance. For dence” providence is guidance; and guidance can bring one only so far as his own power can carry him. If heights are to be scaled above man’s native power to achieve, then some- thing more than guidance, however effective, is necessary. This is the reason for the superinduc- tion, at the end of the long process of the production of Scripture, of the additional Divine operation which we call technically “inspiration.” By it, the Spirit of God, flowing confluently in with the providentially and graciously determined work of men, spontaneously producing under the Divine directions the writings appointed to them, gives the product a. Divine quality unattainable by human powers alone. Thus these books become not merely the word of godly men, but the immediate word of God Himself, speaking directly as such to the minds and hearts of every reader. The value of “inspi- ration’? emerges, thus, as twofold. It gives to the books written under its ‘‘bearing” a quality which is truly superhuman; a trustworthiness, an author- ity, a searchingness, a profundity, a profitableness which is altogether Divine. And it speaks this Divine word immediately to each reader’s heart and conscience; so that he does not require to make his way to God, painfully, perhaps even uncertainly, through the words of His servants, the human in- struments in writing the Scriptures, but can listen directly to the Divine voice itself speaking imme- diately in the Scriptural word to him. That the writers of the NT themselves conceive the Scriptures to have been produced thus by Di- vine operations extending through the increasing ages and involving a multitude of varied activities, can be made clear by simply attending to the occasional references they make to this or that step in the process. It lies, for example, on the 14, Witness face of their expositions, that they of NT looked upon the Bib. history as teleo- Writers logical. Not only do they tell us that to This “whatsoever things were written afore- time were written for our learning, that through patience and through comfort of the scriptures we might have hope’ (Rom 165 4; ef Rom 4 23.24); they speak also of the course of the historical events themselves as guided for our bene- fit: “Now these things happened unto them by way of example’’—in a typical fashion, in such a way that, as they occurred, a typical character, or pre- dictive reference impressed itself upon them; that is to say, briefly, the history occurred as it did in order to bear a message to us—‘‘and they were written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the ages are come” (1 Cor 10 11; ef ver 6). Ac cordingly, it has become a commonplace of Bib. ex- position that “the history of redemption itself is a typically progressive one’ (Kiiper), and is “in a manner impregnated with the prophetic element,” so as to form a “part of a great plan which stretches from the fall of man to the first consummation of all things in glory; and, in so far as it reveals the mind of God toward man, carries a respect to the future not less than to the present’ (P. Fairbairn). It lies equally on the face of the NT allusions to the sub- ject that its writers understood that the preparation of men to become vehicles of God’s message to man was not of yesterday, but had its beginnings in the very origin of their being. The call by which Paul, for example, was made an apostle of Jesus Christ was sudden and apparently without antecedents; but it is precisely this Paul who reckons this call as only one step in a long process, the beginnings of which antedated his own existence: ‘But when it was the good pleasure of God, who separated me, even from my mother’s womb, and called me through his grace, to reveal hisSon in me” (Gal 1 15.16; cf Jer 1 5; Isa 49 1.5). The recognition by the writers of the NT of the experiences of God’s grace, which had been vouchsafed to them as an integral element in their fitting to be the bearers of His gospel to others, finds such pervasive expression that the only difficulty is to select from the mass the most illustrative passages. Such a statement as Paul gives in the opening verses of 2 Cor is thoroughly typical. There he represents that he has been afflicted and comforted to the end that he might “be able to comfort them that are in any affliction, through the comfort wherewith” he had himself been “comforted of God.” For, he explains “Whether we are afflicted, it is for your comfort and salvation; or whether we are comforted, it is for your comfort, which worketh in the patient endur- ing of the same sufferings which we also suffer” (2 Cor 146). Itis beyond question, therefore, that the NT writers, when they declare the Scriptures to be the product of the Divine breath, and explain this as meaning that the writers of these Scriptures wrote them only as borne by the Holy Spirit in such a fashion that they spoke, not out of them- selves, but “from God,” are thinking of this opera- tion of the Spirit only as the final act of God in the roduction of the Scriptures, superinduced upon a ong series of processes, providential, gracious, miraculous, by which the matter of Scripture had been prepared for writing, and the men for writing it, and the writing of it had been actually brought to pass. It is this final act in the production of Scripture which is technically called “inspiration”; and inspiration is thus brought before us as, in the minds of the writers of the NT, that particular operation of God in the production of Scripture Inspiration Instrument THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1482 which takes effect at the very poimt of the writing of Scripture—understanding the term ‘writing’ here as inclusive of all the processes of the actual composition of Scripture, the investigation of docu- ments, the collection of facts, the excogitation of conclusions, the adaptation of exhortations as means to ends and the like—with the effect of giving to the resultant Scripture a specifically supernatural character, and constituting 1t a Divine, as well as human, book. Obviously the mode of operation of this Divine activity moving to this result is con- ceived, in full accord with the analogy of the Divine operations in other spheres of its activity, in provi- dence and in grace alike, as confluent with the human activities operative in the case; as, in a word, of the nature of what has come to be known as “immanent action.” It will not escape observation that thus ‘‘nspira- tion” is made a mode of ‘‘revelation.” We are often exhorted, to besure, to distinguish 15. “Inspi- sharply between “inspiration” and ration’? and ‘revelation’; and the exhortation is “Revela- just when “‘revelation’’ is taken in one tion” of its narrower senses, of, say, an ex- ternal manifestation of God, or of an immediate communication from God in words. But “inspiration” does not differ from “revelation” in these narrowed senses as genus from genus, but as a species of one genus differs from another. That operation of God which we call “inspiration,” that is to say, that operation of the Spirit of God by which He “‘bears’’ men in the process of com- posing Scripture, so that they write, not of them- selves, but “from God,” is one of the modes in which God makes known to men His being, His will, His operations, His purposes. It is as distinctly a mode of revelation as any mode of revelation can be, and therefore it performs the same office which allrevelation performs, that is to say, in the express words of Paul, it makes men wise, and makes them wise untosalvation. All “special” or ‘“‘supernatural’’ revelation (which is redemptive in its very idea, and occupies a place as a substantial element in God’s redemptive processes) has precisely this for its end; and Scripture, as a mode of the redemptive revelation of God, finds its fundamental purpose just in this: if the “‘imspiration”’ by which Scripture is produced renders it trustworthy and authorita- tive, it renders it trustworthy and authoritative only that it may the better serve to make men wise unto salvation. Scripture is conceived, from the point of view of the writers of the NT, not merely as the record of revelations, but as itself a part of the redemptive revelation of God; not merely as the record of the redemptive acts by which God is saving the world, but as itself one of these redemp- tive acts, having its own part to play in the great work of establishing and building up the kingdom of God. What gives it a place among the redemp- tive acts of God is its Divine origination, taken in its widest sense, as inclusive of all the Divine operations, providential, gracious and expressly supernatural, by which it has been made just what it is—a body of writings able‘to make wise unto salvation, and profitable for making the man of God perfect. What gives it its place among the modes of revelation is, however, specifically the cul- minating one of these Divine operations, which we call “inspiration”; that is to say, the action of the Spirit of God in so “bearing” its human authors in their work of producing Scripture, as that in these Scriptures they speak, not out of themselves, but “from God.” It is this act by virtue of which the Scriptures may properly be called ‘God- breathed.” , It has been customary among a certain school of writers to speak of the Scriptures, because thus “inspired,’’ as a Divine-human book, and to appeal to the analogy of Our Lord’s Divine-human per- sonality to explain their peculiar quali- 16. Scrip- ties as such. The expression calls tures a attention to an important fact, and Divine- the analogy holds good a certain dis- Human tance. There are human and Divine Book? sides to Scripture, and, as we cursorily : examine it, we may perceive in it, alter- nately, traits which suggest now the one, now the other factor in its origin. But the analogy with Our Lord’s Divine-human personality may easily be pressed beyond reason. There is no hypostatie union between the Divine and the human in Scrip- ture; we cannot parallel the ‘‘inscripturation’’ of the Holy Spirit and the incarnation of the Son of God. The Scriptures are merely the product of Divine and human forces working together to produce 4 product in the production of which the human forces work under the initiation and prevalent di- rection of the Divine: the person of Our Lord unites in itself Divine and human natures, each of which retains its distinctness while operating only in rela- tion to the other. Between such diverse things there can exist only a remote analogy; and, in point of fact, the analogy in the present instance amounts to no more than that in both cases Divine and human factors are involved, though very _differ- ently. Inthe one they unite to constitute a Divine- human person, in the other they codperate to per- form a Divine-human work. Even so distant an analogy may enable us, however, to recognize that as, in the case of Our Lord’s person, the human nature remains truly human while yet it can never fall into sin or error because it can never act out of relation with the Divine nature into conjunction with which it has been brought; so in the case of the production of Scripture by the conjoint action of human and Divine factors, the human factors have acted as human factors and have left their mark on the product as such, and yet cannot have fallen into that error which we say it is human to fall into, because they have not acted apart from the Divine factors, by themselves, but only under their unerring guidance. The NT testimony is to the Divine origin and qualities of ‘Scripture’; and “Scripture” to the ‘ writers of the NT was fundamentally, 17. Scrip- of course, the OT. In the primary ture of NT passage, in which we are told that Writers “every”? or “all Scripture” is “God- Was the OT breathed,”’ the direct reference is to the “sacred writings’ which Timothy had had in knowledge since his infancy, and these were, of course, just the sacred books of the Jews (2 Tim 3 16). What is explicit here is implicit in all the allusions to inspired Scriptures in the NT. Accordingly, it is frequently said that our entire testimony to the inspiration of Scripture concerns the OT alone. In many ways, however, this is overstated. Our present concern is not with the extent of ‘Scripture’ but with the nature of ‘Scripture’; and we cannot present here the con- siderations which justify extending to the NT the inspiration which the NT writers attribute to the OT. It will not be out of place, however, to point out simply that the NT writers obviously them- selves made this extension. They do not for an instant imagine themselves, as ministers of a new covenant, less in possession of the Spirit of God than the ministers of the old covenant: they freely recognize, indeed, that they have no sufficiency of themselves, but they know that God has made them sufficient (2 Cor 8 5.6). They prosecute their work of proclaiming the gospel, therefore, in full confidence that they speak “by the Holy Spirit” (1 Pet 1 12), to whom they attribute both the 1483 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inspiration Instrument matter and form of their teaching (1 Cor 2 18). They, therefore, speak with the utmost assurance of their teaching (Gal 1 7.8); and they issue com- mands with the completest authority (1 Thess 4 2.14; 2 Thess 3 6.12), making it, indeed, the test of whether one has the Spirit that he should recog- nize what they demand as commandments of God (1 Cor 14 37). It would be strange, indeed, if these high claims were made for their oral teaching and commandments exclusively. In point of fact, they are made explicitly also for their written in- junctions. It was “the things’ which Paul was ‘writing,’ the recognition of which as commands of the Lord, he makes the test of a Spirit-led man (1 Cor 14 37). It is his “word by this epistle,” obedience to which he makes the condition of Chris- tian communion (2 Thess 3 14). There seems in- volved in such an attitude toward their own teach- ing, oral and written, a claim on the part of the NT writers to something very much like the ‘‘inspira- tion” which they attribute to the writers of the OT. And all doubt is dispelled when we observe the NT writers placing the writings of one another in the same category of ‘Scripture’ with the 18. Inclu- books of the OT. The same Paul who, sion of NT in 2 Tim 3 16, declared that ‘every’ or ‘all scripture is God-breathed’ had already written in 1 Tim 6 18: “For the scripture saith, Thou shall not muzzle the ox when he treadeth outthecorn. And, Thelaborer is worthy of his hire.” The first clause here is derived from Dt and the sec- ond from the Gospel of Lk, though both are cited as together constituting, or better, forming part of the “Scripture” which Paul adduces as so authori- tative as by its mere citation to end all strife. Who shall say that, in the declaration of the later ep. that “all’’ or “every’’ Scripture is God- breathed, Paul did not have Lk, and, along with Lk, whatever other new books he classed with the old under the name of Scripture, in the back of his mind, along with those old books which Timothy had had in his hands from infancy? And the same Peter who declared that every “prophecy of scrip- ture’ was the product of men who spoke “from God,” being ‘borne’ by the Holy Ghost (2 Pet 1 21), in this same ep. (3 16), places Paul’s Epp. in the category of Scripture along with whatever other books deserve that name. For Paul, says he, wrote these epp., not out of his own wisdom, but “ac- cording to the wisdom given to him,’ and though there are some things in them hard to be understood, yet it is only “the ignorant and unstedfast’’ who wrest these difficult passages—as what else could be expected of men who wrest ‘‘also the other Scriptures” (obviously the OT is meant)—“unto their own destruction’? Is it possible to say that Peter could not have had these epp. of Paul also lurking somewhere in the back of his mind, along with “the other scriptures,’’ when he told his readers that every “prophecy of scripture’ owes its origin to the prevailing operation of the Holy Ghost? What must be understood in estimating the testi- mony of the NT writers to the inspiration of Scrip- ture is that “Scripture” stood in their minds as the title of a unitary body of books, throughout the gift of God through His Spirit to His people; but that this body of writings was at the same time under- stood to be a growing aggregate, so that what is said of it applies to the new books which were being added to it as the Spirit gave them, as fully as to the old books which had come down to them from their hoary past. It is a mere matter of detail to deter- mine precisely what new books were thus included by them in the category “Scripture.” They tell us some of them themselves. Those who received them from their hands tell us of others. And when we put the two bodies of testimony together we find that they constitute just our NT. _ It is no pressure of the witness of the writers of the NT to the in- spiration of the Scripture, therefore, to look upon it as covering the entire body of ‘‘Scriptures,”’ the new books which they were themselves adding to this aggregate, as well as the old books which they had received as Scripture from the fathers. Whatever can lay claim by just right to the appellation of ‘Scripture,’ as employed in its eminent sense by those writers, can by the same just right lay claim to the “inspiration’”’ which they ascribe to this “Scripture.” Litsraturs.—J. Gerhard, Loci Theolog., Locus 1; F, Turretin, Instit. Theol., Locus Il; B. de Moor, Comm, in J, Marckit Comp., cap. ii; C. Hodge, Syst. Theol., New York, 1871, I, 151-86; eury B. Smith, The Inspiration of the Holy Scriptures, New York, 1855, new ed, Cincin- nati, 1891; A. ene tae Encyclopedie der heilige God- geleerdheid, 1888-89, 11, 347 ff, ET; Ene of Sacred Theol., New York, 1898, 341-563; also De Schrift het woord Gods, Tiel, 1870; H. Bavinck, Gereformeerde Dogmatiek?, Kampen, 1906, I, 406-527; R. Haldane, The Vertal In- spiration of the Scriptures Established, Edinburgh, 1830; J. T. Beck, Hinleitung in das System der christlichen Lehre, Stuttgart, 1838, 2d ed, 1870; A. G. Rudelbach, “Die Lehre von der Inspiration der heil. Schrift,’ Zeitschrift. fir die gesammte Lutherische_Theologie und Kirche, 1840, 1, 1841, 1, 1842, 1; 8. R. L. Gaussen, Théopneustie ou inspiration Bee des saintes écritures?, Paris, 1842, ET by E. N. Kirk, New York, 1842; also Theopneustia; the Plenary Inspiration of the Holy Scriptures, David Scott's tr, reédited and revised hy B. W. Carr, with a preface by C. H. Spurgeon, London, 1888; William Lee, The Inspiration of the Holy Scriptures, Donellan Lecture, 1852, New York, 1857; James Ban- nerman, Inspiration: the Infailible Truth and Divine Authority of the Holy Scriptures, Edinburgh, 1865; F. L. Patton, The NE OH of the Scriptures, Philadelphia, 1869 (reviewing Lee and Bannerman); Charles Elliott, Treatise on the Inspiration of the Holy Scriptures, Edinburgh, 1877; A. A. Hodge and B. B. Warfield, “Inspiration,'’ Presbyterian Review, April, 1881, also tract, Philadelphia, 1881; R. Watts, The Rule of Faith and the Doctrine of Inspiration, Edinburgh, 1885; A. Oave, The Inspiration of the OT Inductively Considered, London, 1888: B. Manly, The Bible Doctrine of Inspira- tion, New York, 1888; W. Rohnert, Die Inspiration der heiligen Schrift und ihre Bestreiter, Leipzig, 1889; A.W. Dieckhof®, Die Inspiration und_Irrthumlosigkeit der heiligen Schrift, Leipzig, 1891; J. Wichelhaus, Die Lehre der heiligen Schrift, Stuttgart, 1892; J. Macgregor, The Revelation and the Record, Edinburgh, 1893; J. Urquhart, The Inspiration and Accuracy of the Holy Scriptures, London, 1895; ©. Pesch, De Inspiratione Sacrae Scrip- turae, Freiburg, 1906; James Orr, Revelation and Inspira- tion, London, 1910. ; ‘ BENJAMIN B, WARFIELD INSTANT, in’stant, INSTANTLY, in’stant-li: Derivative from Lat insiare. Found in Eng. with various meanings from the 15th cent. to the present time. _ Instant is used once in Isa 29 5 in the sense of immediate time; elsewhere in the sense of urgent, pressing; Lk 23 23, where ‘were instant”’ isthe AV tr of the vb. éréxewvro, epékeinto; Rom 12 12, where it is mvolved in the vb. tpooxaprepéw, proskarteréd; cf Acts 6 4. In 2 Tim 4 2 it stands for the ex- pressive vb. éricryf, epistathi, ‘stand to.” _ Instantly (urgently, stedfastly) is the AV render- ing of two different Gr phrases, srovdalws, spou- datos, found in Lk 7 4; and éy éxrevelg, en ekte- neta, in Acts 26 7. In both cases ARV renders “earnestly.”’ Russert Bensamin Miter INSTRUCTION, in-struk’shun. Evucation; ScHoou. INSTRUMENT, in’stréo-ment ("93, #3; in Gr pl. 84Aa, hépla, Rom 6 13): The word in the OT is used for utensils for service, chiefly in connection with the sanctuary (cf Ex 25 9; Nu 4 12.26.32; 1K 19 21; 1Ch9 29; 2 Ch 416, AV); for weapons of war (1S 8 12; 1 Ch 12 33.37, etc); notably for musical imstruments. See Music. The members of the body are described by Paul (Rom 6 13) as ‘‘imstruments” to be used in the service of righteousness, as before they were in the service of unrighteousness. See CaTEcuist; Instruments Intercession INSTRUMENTS OF MUSIC (O°W"SU, shalz- shim): Thus RV and AV (1 S 18 6), RVm “‘tri- are or ‘‘three-stringed instruments.” See UsIC. INSURRECTION, in-su-rek’shun: The word in Ps 64 2 AV is changed in RV into “tumult”; in Ezr 4 19 (vb.) it represents the Aram. NW}, n°sa’, to ‘lift up oneself.”” In the NT ordows, stdsis, is rendered “insurrection” in Mk 15 7 AV (where cf the vb. “made insurrection’’), but in Lk 23 19.25 “sedition.” RV correctly renders ‘‘insurrection’’ throughout; also in Acts 24 5 “insurrections’’ for AV “sedition.” INTEGRITY, in-teg’ri-ti (OF, tém, WAR, tum- mah): The tr of tom, “simplicity,” ‘soundness,’ “completeness,’’ rendered also “upright,” ‘“‘per- fection.” Its original sense appears in the phrase ltom (1 K 22 34; 2 Ch 18 33), “A certain man drew his bow at a venture,’’ m ‘Heb, in his sim- plicity’’ (cf 2 § 16 11, “in their simplicity’). It is tr? “integrity” (Gen 20 5.6; 1 K 9 4; Ps 7 8; 95 21; 261.11; 41 12: 78 72; Prov 191; 20 7), in all which places it seems to carry the meaning of simplicity, or sincerity of heart and intention, truthfulness, uprightness. In the pl. (tummi%m) it is one of the words on the breastplate of the high priest (Ex 28 30; Dt 33 8; Ezr 2 63; Neh 7 65), - one of the sacred lots, indicating, perhaps, ‘‘inno- cence” or “integrity” (LXX alétheia). See URIM AND Tsoummim. Another word tr? “integrity’’ istummah, from tamam, ‘‘to complete,” “‘be upright,”’ “‘perfect,”’ only in Job 2 3.9; 27 5; 31 6; Prov 11 3. The word ‘integrity’? does not occur in the NT, but its equivalents may be seen in ‘“‘sincerity,’’ “truth,” the ‘pure heart,’’ the “‘single eye,” etc. In the above sense of simplicity of intention it is equivalent to being honest, sincere, genuine, and is fundamental to true character. W. L. Wacker INTELLIGENCE, in-tel’i-gens (A, bin): Oc- curs only once in AV as the tr of bin, “to dis- criminate’ (frequently tr? “to understand’’), in Dnl 11 30 AV, “fhe shall] have intelligence with them that forsake the holy covenant,’? RV renders “have regard unto them.” ‘Intelligence’? occurs in 2 Macc 3 9 AV, in the sense of information (so INTEND, in-tend’, INTENT, in-tent’: Early Eng. words derived from Lat and used in AV, sometimes in RV, to translate a number of different expressions of the original. Intend is sometimes used in Eng. in the literal sense of Lat intendere, ‘to stretch,”’ but in the Eng. Bible it is used only of the direction of the mind toward an object. Sometimes it is used of mere design (uéAkw, mélld), Acts 5 85 AV; 20 13; or of desired action (6é\#, thélo), Lk 14 28 AV; again of a fixed purpose (fovAcua, borlomai), Acts 5 28; 12 4; or, finally, of a declared intention (amar), Josh 22 33 AV; 2 Ch 28 13 AV. Intent is used only of purpose, and is the tr some- times of a conjunction (l*bha'dbhur), 2S 17 14; (ema‘an),2 KK 10 19; (iva, hina), Eph 3 10; some- times of an infinitive of purpose, 1 Cor 10 6; or of a preposition with pronoun (els rofro, eis tovito), Acts 9 21, and sometimes of a subst. (Aédvw, légd), Acts 10 29. This variety of original expressions repre- sented in the Eng. by single terms is an interesting illustration of the extent of interpretation embodied in our Eng. Bible. RussELL BENJAMIN MiLLER INTERCESSION, in-ter-sesh’un (732, pagha', ‘“o make intercession”; originally ‘‘to strike upon,”’ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1484 or “against’; then in a good sense, “to assail any- one with petitions,” “to urge,” and when on behalf of another, “to intercede” [Ruth 1 16; Jer 7 16; 27.18; Job 21 15; Gen 23 8; Isa 53 12; Jer 86 25]. A similar idea is found in évrevbts, én- teuxis, used_as ‘‘petition,’ and in the NT “inter- cession.” The Eng. word is derived from Lat intercedo, “to come between,’’ which strangely has the somewhat opposed meanings of “obstruct’’ and “to interpose on behalf of’’ a person, and finally “to intercede.” The growth of meaning in this word in the various languages is highly suggestive. In the Gr NT we find the word in 1 Tim 2 1; 4 5; évruyxdve, entugchdnd, is also found in Rom 8 26-34): Etymology and Meaning of Term in the OT and NT TI. Man’s Intercession ror His Fevtow-Man . Patriarchal Examples . Intercessions of Moses . The Progress of Religion, Seen in Moses’ In- tercessions : Intercessory Prayer in Israel’s Later History The Rise of Official Intercession i Samuel as an Intercessor as Judge, Priest aud Prophet . Intercession in the Poetic Books . The Books of Wisdom . The Prophets’ Succession to Moses and Samuel 10. The Priest and Intercession 11. Intercession in the Gospels 12. Intercessory Prayers of the Church 13. Intercession Found in the Epistles II. Invercession. Perrectep 1N CuHrist’s OFFICE AND IN THE CHURCH III. Intercession oF THE Hoty Spirit The meaning of the word is determined by its use in 1 Tim 2 1, “I exhort, therefore, first of all, that supplications, prayers, interces- Etymology sions, thanksgivings, be made for all and Mean- men’’; where the different kinds of ing of Term prayers appear to be distimguished. Considerable discussion has arisen on the exact meaning of these words. ‘Augustine refers them to the liturgy of the Eucharist. This seems to be importing the significance of the various parts of the ceremony as observed at a time much later than the date of the passage in question. ‘‘Suppli- cations” and “prayers” refer to general and specific petitions; ‘‘intercessions’’ will then have the mean- ing of a request concerning others. Intercession is prayer on behalf of another, and naturally arises from the instinct of the human heart—not merely prompted by affection and inter- est, but recognizing that God’s relation to man is not merely individual, but social. Religion thus involves man’s relations to his fellow-man, just as in man’s social position intercession with one on behalf of another is a common incident, becoming, in the development of society, the function of ap- pointed officials; as in legal and courtly procedure, so in religion, the spontaneous and affectionate prayer to God on behalf of another grows into the regular and orderly service of a duly appointed priesthood. Intercession is thus to be regarded: (1) as the spontaneous act of man for his fellow- man; (2) the official act of developed sacerdotalism; (3) the perfecting of the natural movement of hu- manity, and the typified function of priesthood in the intercession of Christ and the Holy Spirit. I. Man’s Intercession for His Fellow-Man.— Many such prayers are recorded in Scripture. The sacrificial act of Noah may have been 1. Patri- partly of this nature, for it is followed archal by a promise of God on behalf of the Examples race and the earth at large (Gen 8 20- 22). Such also is Abraham’s prayer for Ishmael (Gen 17 18); Abraham’s prayer for Sodom (Gen 18 23-33); Abraham for Abimelech (Gen 20 17). Jacob’s blessing of Joseph’s sons is of the nature of intercession (Gen 48 8-23). His 1485 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Instruments . Intercession dying blessing of his sons is hardly to be regarded as intercessory; itis, rather, declarative, although in the case of Joseph it approaches intercession. The absence of distinct intercessory prayer from Abra- ham to Moses is to be observed, and shows how in- tensely personal and individual the religious con- sciousness was still in its undeveloped quality. In Moses, however, the social element finds a further development, and is interesting as taking up the spirit of the Father of the Faithful. Moses is the ereator of the national spirit. He lifts religion from its somewhat selfish character in the patriarchal life to the higher and wider plane of a national and racial fellowship. The progressive character of the Divine leading of man is found thus in the development of the inter- cessory spirit, e.g. Moses’ prayer for the 2. Inter- removal of plagues (Ex 15 25f); for cessions of water at Rephidim (17 4); for victory Moses over Amalek (17 8-16); prayer for the people aftcr the golden calf (Ex 32 11-14.21-34; 33 12f); after the renewal of the tables of stone (34 9); at the sctting forth and stopping of the Ark (Nu 10 35f); after the burning at Taberah (Nu 11 2); for the healing of Miriam’s leprosy (12 13); after the return of the spies (14 13-19); after the destruction by serpents (Nu 21 7); for direction in the case of the daughters of Zelophehad (27 5); for a successor (27 15); recital of his prayer for the people for their entrance into Canaan (Dt 3 23f); recital of his prayer for the people after the worship of the golden calf (9 18 ff); recital of prayers for the rebellious people (Dt 9 25-29); a command to him who pays his third-year tithes to offer prayer for the nation (26 15); Moses’ final blessing of the tribes (Dt 33). This extensive series of the intercessory prayers of Moses forms a striking illustration of the growth of religion, represented by the founder 3. The of the national life of Israel. It is the Progress of history of an official, but it is also the Religion history of a leader whose heart was Seen in the filled with the intensest patriotism and Interces- regard for his fellows. None of these sions of prayers are perfunctory. They are Moses the vivid and passionate utterances of aman full of Divine enthusiasm and human affection. They are real prayers wrung from a great and devout soul on occasions of deep and criticalimportance. Apart from their importance in the history of Israel, they are a noble record of a great leader of men and servant of God. in the history of Joshua we find only the prayer for the people after the sin of Achan (Josh 7 6-9), although the communicators fom agoe to J opus are . numerous. aint intercessory note may 4. Interces he heard in Dehorah's song (Jgs 5 31), sory Prayer though itis almost silenced hy the stern and in Later warlike tone of the poem. Gideon's prayer History of seems to reécho something of the words of Moses (Jgs 6 13), and accords with the na- Israel tional and religious spirit of the great leader who helped in the formation of the religious life of his people (see Jgs 6 24), notwithstanding the evident lower plane on which he stood (Jgs 8 27), which may account partially for the apostasy after his death (Jgs 8 331). Manoah's prayers (Jgs 13) 5. The Rise may he noted. (‘The satisfaction of Micah of Official at securing a priest for his house, and the * _ subsequent story, belong rather to the his- Intercession tory of official intercession [Jgs 18; see below], as also the inquiry of the people through Phinehas at Shiloh qn 20 27f], and the peo- ple’s mourning and prayer [Jes 21 2 f).) Samuel is the real successor of Moses, and in connection with his life intercession again appears more distinct and effective. Hannah’s song, though chiefly of thankfulness, is not without the inter- cessory spirit (1 S 2 1-11). So also of Samuel’s prayer at Mizpeh (1 S 7 5), and the recognition by the people of Samuel’s place (1 5 7 8f; see also 8 6.21; 10 17-25; 12 19) (for the custom of in- quiring of the Lord through a secr see 1 5 9 6-10); Samuel’s prayer for Saul (1 8 15 11); 6. Samuel Saul’s failure to secure inquiry of God, as an Inter- even through intercession (1 8 28 6); cessor in Saul’s final appeal through the witch His Func- of Endor (1 5S 28 7-20); David’s tions as prayer to God (28 7 18); David’s Judge, prayer for deliverance of the people Priest and from pestilence (2 8 2417); Solo- Prophet mon’s prayer for wisdom to govern the people (1 K 3 5-15); Solomon’s prayer at the dedication of the temple (1 K 8 12-61); Jeroboam’s appeal to the man of God to pray for the healing of his hand (1 K 13 6); Elijah’s prayer for the widow’s son (1 K 17 20); Elijah’s prayer for rain (1 K 18 42); HElisha’s praycr for the widow’s son (2 K 4 33); Elisha’s prayer for the opening of the young man’s eyes (2 K 6 17); Hezekiah’s appeal to Isaiah (2 K 19 4); Hezc- kiah’s prayer (2 K 19 14-19); Josiah’s command for prayer concerning the “book that is found” (2 K 22 13). In Ch we find David’s prayer for his house (1 Ch 17 16-27); David’s prayer for de- liverance from the plague (21 17); Dada prayer for the people and for Solomon at the offering of gifts for the temple (29 10-19); Solomon’s prayer at the consecration of the temple (2 Ch 6 1-42); Asa’s prayer (14 11); Jehoshaphat’s prayer (2 Ch 20 5-13); Hezekiah’s prayer for the people who had not prepared to eat the Passover (2 Ch 30 18); Josiah’s command for prayer concerning the book (34 21). In the Prophets we note Ezra’s prayer (Ezr 9 5-15); Nehemiah’s prayer (Neh 1 5-11); aa prayer of the Levites for the nation (Neh 9 4- 38). The poetic books furnish a few examples of inter- cessory prayer: Joh's intercession for his children (Joh 5); Job's regret at the absence of inter- 7. Inter- cession (Job 16 21); the Lord’s command aS that Joh should pray for his friends (Joh 42 cession in 8). Itisremarkable that the references to the Poetic intercession in the Pss are few; butit must Books not he forgotten that the psaln is generally a lyrical expression of an intense suhjective c condition. This does not seem in the con- sciousness of Israel to have reached an altruistic devel- opment. The Pss express very powerfully the sense of obligation to God, consciousness of sin, indignation against the sin of others. Occasionally the patriotic spirit leads to prayer for Israel; but only rarely does any deep sense of interest in the welfare of others appear to possess the hearts of Israel's singers. In Ps 12 there is a hint of the intercessory office of the Son, which reflects, pernepe the growth of the Messianic spirit in the mind of Isracl; Ps 20 is intercessional; it is the prayer of a people for their king. In Ps 25 22 we find a prayer for the redemption of Israel, as in Ps 28 9. In Ps 35 13 the Psalmist refers to his intercession for others. Butthe “ prayerreturned into mine own hosom,’’ and the final issue of the prayer hecomes rather denun- ciatory than intercessional. The penitence of Ps 51 rises into a uote of prayer for the city (ver 18). Some- times (Ps 60, and perhaps Ps 67), the prayer is not indi- vidual hut for the community, though even there it is hardly intercession. A common necessity makes a common prayer. In Ps 69 there is the recognition of the injury that folly and sin may do to others, and a kind of compensatory note of intercession is heard. Ps 72 is regarded by some as the royal father's prayer for his son and successor, but the reading of the title adopted by RV takes even this psalm from the category of inter- cession. In Asaph’s aschil (Ps 74), intercession is more distinct; it is a prayer for the sanctuary and the people in their desolation and calamity. Asaph appears to have caught something of the spirit of Moses, as in Ps 79 he again praysfor the deliverance of Jerus; while a faint echo of the intercessory plea for the nation is beard in Ethan's psalm (Ps 89). It sounds faintly in Ps 106. In Ps 12 we seem to hreathe a larger and more liberal spirit. It contains the appeal to pray for the peace of Jerus (ver 6), as if the later thought of Israel had begun to expand heyond the mere limits of personal penitence, or desire for deliverance, or denunciation of the enemy. In one of the Songs of Degrees (Ps 125), there is the somewhat severely ethical prayer: ‘‘Do good, O Jch, unto these that are good.” ‘The yearning for the salvation of man as man has not yet heen born. The Christ must come before the fulness of Divine love is shed abroad in the hearts even of the pious. This .Intercession Inter. of Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1486 comparative ahsence of intercessory prayer from the service-book of Israel, and its collected expressions of spiritual experience, is instructive. references to those who needed prayer; hut for the most part these references are descriptive of their wickedness, or denunciatory of their hostility to the Psalmist. The Book of Pss is thus a striking commentary on the growth of Israel's spiritual life. Intense as it is in its perception of God and His claim on human righteousness, it is only when the supreme revelation of Divine love and the regard for universal man has appeared in the person of Our Lord that the large and loving spirit which inter- cession signifies is found in the experience and expressions of the pious. In the Wisdom hooks there is little, if any, reference to intercession. But they deal rather with ethical char- acter, and often on a merely providential 8 The and utilitarian hasis. Itis noticeable that Wisdom the only reference to Pleading a cause is said to he hy the Lord Himself as against the Books injustice of man (Prov 22 23): “Jeh will plead their (the poor’s] cause."” Action on behalf of others does not appear to have heen very highly regarded hy the current ethics of the Israelite. A kind of negative heipfulness is indicated in Prov 24 28: ‘‘Be not a witness against thy neighhor without’ cause”; and it is significant that the office of advocate was not known among the Jews until they had come under the authority of Rome, when, not knowing the forms of Rom law, they were ohliged to secure the aid of a Rom lawyer hefore the courts. Such practitioners were found in the provinces (Cic. pre Coelie c. 30); Tertullus (Acts 24 1) was such an advocate, In the prophetical books the note of intercession reappears. The prophet, though primarily a mes- senger from God to man, has also 9. The something of the character of the inter- Prophets’ cessor (see Isaiah’s call, Isa 6). Isa Succession 25,26 exhibit the intercessory char- to Moses __ acteristics. The request of Heac- and Samuel kiah for the prayers of Isaiah (Isa 37 4), and the answer of the Lord implied in ver 6, recall the constantly recurring service of Moses to the people. Hezekiah himself becomes an intercessor (vs 14-21). In Jer 4 10 intercession is mingled with the words of the messen- ger. The sin of the people hinders such prayers as were offered on their behalf (Jer 7 16; cf 11 14; 14 11). Intercessory prayers are found in Jer 10 23 ff; 14 7 ff.19-22. The message of Zedekiah re- questing Jeremiah’s help is perhaps an instance of seer-inquiry as much as intercession (Jer 21 1f; ef 18 919). In Jer 42 4, the prophet consents to the request of Johanan to seek the Lord on behalf of the people. The Book of Lam is naturally con- ceived in a more constantly recurring spirit of inter- cession. In the prophecies Jeremiah has been the messenger of God to the people. But, after the ca- tastrophe, in his sorrow he appeals to God for mercy upon them (Lam 2 20; 6 1.19). Ezekiel in the same way is rather the seer of visions and the pro- phetic representative of God. Yet at times he appeals to God for the people (Ezk 9 8; 11 13). In Dnl we find the intercession of his three friends sought for in order to secure the revelation of the king’s dream (Dnl 2 17); and Daniel’s prayer for Jerus and her people (Dnl 9 16-19). In the Minor Prophets intercession rarely appears; even in the graphic pictures of Jonah, though the work itself shows the enlarging of the conception of God’s relation to humanity outside of Israel, the prophet himself exhibits no tenderness and utters no pleas for the city against which he had been sent to prophesy, and receives the implied rebuke from the Lord for his want of sympathy, caring more for the perished gourd than for the vast population of Nineveh, whom the Lord, however, pitied and spared (Jon 4). Even the sublime prayer of Hab 8 has only a suggestion of intercession. Zec 6 13 relieves the general severity of the prophetic mes- sage, consisting of the threatenings of judgment, by the gleam of the promise of a royal priest whose office was partially that of an intercessor, though the picture is darkened by the character of the We find continued ~ priesthood and the people, whose services had heen selfish, without mercy and compassion (Zec 7 4.7). Now the spirit of tenderness, the larger nature, the loving heart, are to be restored to Israel (Zec 8 16- 23). Other nations than Israel will share in the mercy of God. In Mal 2 7 we find the priest rebuked for the loss of his intercessory character. How far intercession was regarded as a special duty of the priesthood it is not very easy to determine. The priestly office_itself 10. The was undoubtedly intercessory. In the Priest and offering of the sacrifice even for the Intercession individual, and certainly in the nation- al functions, both of the regular and the occasional ceremonies, the priest represented the individual or the community. In Joel 2 17 the priests are distinctly hidden to “weep between the porch and the altar, and let them say, Spare thy people, O Jeh.’ Mal 19 appeals to them for intercession to God, and the graphic scene in 1 Mace 7 33-38 shows the priests interceding on behalf of the people against Nicaner. In the NT, all prayer necessarily takes a new form from its relation to Our Lord, and in this inter- cessory prayer shares. At the outset, 11. Inter- Christ teaches prayer on behalf of cession in those “which despitefully use you” the Gospels (Mt 5 44 AV). How completely does this change the entire spirit of prayer! We breathe a new atmosphere of the higher revela- tion of love. The Lord’s Prayer (Mt 6 9-13) is of this character. Its initial word is social, do- mestic; prayer is the address of children to the Father. Even though some of the petitions are not original, yet their place in the prayer, and the general tone of the Master’s teaching, exhibit the social and altruistic spirit, not so pervasive of the older dis- pensation. ‘Thy kingdom come’ leads the order of petitions, with its essentially intercessory char- acter. The forgiveness of others, which is the measure and plea of our own forgiveness, brings even those who have wronged us upon the same plane as ourselves, and if the plea be genuine, how can we refuse to pray for them? And if for our enemies, then surely for our friends. In Mt 7 11f, the good things sought of the Father are to be inter- preted as among those that if we desire from others we should do to them. And from this spirit the intercessory prayer cannot be absent. We find the spirit of intercession in the pleas of those who sought Christ’s help for their friends, which He was always so quick to recognize: the centurion for his servant (Mt 8 13); the friends of the paralytic (Mt 9 2-6), where the miracle was wrought on the ground of the friends’ faith. Of a similar character are the re- quests of the woman for her child and the Lord’s response (Mt 15 28); of the man for his lunatic son (17 14-21). There is the suggestion of the intercessory spirit in the law of trespass, specifically followed by the promise of the answer to the prayer of the two or three, agreed and in fellowship (Mt 18 15-20), with the immediately attached precepts of forgiveness (vs 21-35). A remarkable instance of intercession is recorded in Mt 20 20-23, where the mother of Zebedee’s sons makes a request on behalf of her children; the added expression, ‘‘wor- shipping him,” raises the occasion into one of inter- cessory prayer. Our Lord’s rebuke is not to the prayer, but to its unwisdom. It is needless to review the cases‘ in the other Gospels. But the statement of Mk 6 5f, that Christ could not perform mighty works because of unbelief, sheds a flood of light upon one of the im- portant conditions of successful intercession, when contrasted with the healing conditioned by the faith of others than the healed. One of the most distinct. examples of intercessory prayer is that of 1487 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Intercession Inter. of Christ the Lord’s intercession for Peter (Lk 22 31 f), and for those who crucified Him (Lk 23 34). The place of intercession in the work of Christ is seen clearly in Our Lord’s intercessory prayer (see INTERCESSION oF Curist), where it is commanded by definite precept and promise of acceptance. The promise of the answer to prayer in the name of Christ is very definite (Jn 16 24). Christ’s high-priestly prayer is the sublimest height of prayer to God and is inter- cessory throughout (Jn 17); Jn 16 26 does not, as some have held, deny His intercession for His disciples; it only throws open the approach to God Himself. ‘ Acts introduces us to the working of the fresh ele- ments which Christ gave to life. Hence the prayers of the church becomeChristian prayers, 12. Inter- involving the wider outlook on others cessory and on the world at large which Chris- Prayers tianity has bestowed on men. The of the prayer of the assembled believers upon Church the liberation of the apostles breathes this spirit (Acts 4 24-80). The con- secrating prayer for the seven was probably inter- cessory (Acts 6 6; cf Acts 1 24). How pathetic is the plea of Stephen for his murderers (Acts 7 60)! How natural is intercession (Acts 8 24)! Peter at Joppa (Acts 9 40); the church making prayer with- out ceasing for Peter (Acts 12 5.12); the prayer for Barnabas and Saul at Antioch (Acts 13 3); Paul and Barnabas praying for the churches (Acts 14 23); the church at Antioch commending Paul and Silas to the grace of God (Acts 15 40); Paul and the elders of Ephesus (Acts 20 36), are all examples, more or less defined, of intercessory prayer. In the Epp. ‘we may expect to find intercession more distinctly ed with the relation of prayer through ae Sela satey us many Sarita ne is Epp.: for the Romans (Rom ; the 13. Inter- Spirit's interceding (8 27); Paul's prayer cession for his race (10 1); hisrequest for prayers Found in (15 30); the help that he found from the : rayer of his friends (2 Cor 1 11); prayer the Epistles nes the Corinthian church (2 Cor 13 7); for the Ephesians (Eph 1_16—23; 3 14- 21; see also Eph 6 18; Phil 1 3-11.19; Col 1 3.9; 4 3; 1 Thess 1 2; 5 23.25; 2 Thess 1 2); a definite com- mand that intercession be made for all men and for kings and those in authority (1 Tim 2 1.2); his prayer for Timothy (2 Tim 1 3); for Philemon (ver 4); and prayer to be offered for the sick by the elders of the church (Jas § 14-18: see also He 18 18-21; 1 Jn § 14 ff). I. Intercession Perfected in Christ’s Office and in the Charch.—This review of the intercession of the Scriptures prepares us for the development of a specific office of intercession, perfectly realized in Christ. We have seen Moses complying with the people’s request to represent them before God. In a large and generous spirit the leader of Israel intercedes with God for his nation. It was natural that this striking example of intercessory prayer should be followed by other leaders, and that the gradually developed system of religious worship should furnish the conception of the priest, and esp. the high priest, as the intercessor for those who came to the sacrifice. This was particularly the signifi- cance of the great Day of Atonement, when after offering for himself, the high priest offered the sac- rificeforthe whole people. Thisofficial act, however, does not do away with the intercessory character of prayer as offered by men. We have seen how it runs through the whole history of Israel. But it is found much more distinctly in the Christian life and apparently in the practice of the Chris- tian assembly itself. Paul continually refers to his own intercessory prayers, and seeks for a similar service on his own behalf from those to whom he writes. Intercession is thus based upon the natural tendency of the heart filled by love and a deep sym- pathetic sense of relation to others. Christ’s inter- -cessory prayer is the highest example and pattern of this form of prayer. His intercessions for His disciples, for His crucifiers, are recorded, and the sacred record rises to the supreme height in the prayer of Jn 17. In this prayer the following char- acteristics are to be found: (1) It is based upon the intimate relation of Jesus to the Father. This gives to such prayer its justification; may it be said, its right. (2) It follows the completest fulfilment of duty. It is not the mere expression of desire, even for others. It is the crown of effort on their behalf. He has revealed God to His disciples. He has given to them God’s words; therefore He prays for them (Jn 17 6.7-9). (8) It recognizes the Di- vine, unbroken relation to the object of the prayer: “T am no more in the world, and these are in the world, and I come to Thee. Holy Father, keep,” etc (ver 11). (4) The supreme end of the prayer is salvation from the evil of the world (ver 15). (5) The wide sweep of the prayer and its chief ob- jects—unity with God, and the presence with Christ, and the indwelling of the Divine love. The prayer is a model for all intercessory prayer. See, further, InrERcEsSION oF CuRistT; PRAYERS OF CHRIST; OFFrices oF CHRIST. IH, Intercession of the Holy Spirit.—In connec- tion with the subject of intercession, there arises a most interesting question as to whether the Holy Spirit is not presented in Scriptures as an inter- cessor. The text in which the doctrine seems to be taught is that of Rom 8 26f: “In like manner the Spirit also helpeth our infirmity: for we know not how to pray as we ought; but the Spirit himself maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered; and he that searcheth the hearts knoweth what is the mind of the Spirit, because he maketh intercession for the saints according, to the will of God.” By far the larger number of exposi- tors have understood by the Spirit, the Holy Spirit. The older commentators, in general, refer to the Holy Spirit. Tholuck, Ewald, Philippi, Meyer, most of the Amer. theologians and Eng. commenta- tors, as Shedd, Alford, Jowett, Wordsworth, inter- pret it in the same way. Lange and Olshausen refer it to the human spirit. Undoubtedly the “groanings” have led_to the denial of the reference to the Holy Spirit. But the very form of the word tr? “helpeth’’ indicates coédperation, and this must be of something other than the spirit of man him- self. The undoubted difficulties of the passage, which are strongly urged by Lange (see Lange’s Comm. on Rom 8 26), must be acknowledged. At the same time the statement seems to he very clear and definite. An explanation has been given that the Holy Spirit is here referred to as dwelling in us, and thus making intercession. The Divine Spirit is said to be a Spirit of supplication (Zec 12 10). The distinction which is made between the inter- cession of Christ in heaven in His priestly office and that of the Holy Spirit interceding within the souls of believers, referred to by Shedd (see Comm. on Rom), woust be carefully used, for if pressed to its extreme it would lead to the materialization and localization of the Divine nature. Moreover, may not the intercession of Our Lord be regarded as being partially exemplified in that of the Spirit whom He has declared to be His agent and repre- sentative? If Christ dwells in believers by His Spirit, His intercession, esp. if subjective in and with their spirits, may properly be descrihed as the inter- cession of the Holy Ghost. Lu. D. Bevan INTERCESSION OF CHRIST: The general con- ception of Our Lord’s mediatorial office is specially suramed up in His intercession in which He appears in His high-priestly office, and also as interceding with the Father on behalf of that humanity whose cause He had espoused. Inter. of Christ Interpretation THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1488 The function of priesthood as developed under Judaism involved the position of mediation be- tween man and God. The priest 1. Christ’s represented man, and on man’s behalf Intercession approached God; thus he offered sacri- Viewed in fice, interceded and gave to the offerer Its Priestly whom he represented the benediction Aspect and expression of the Divine accept- ance. (For the various forms of these offerings, see special articles.) As in sacrifice, so in the work of Christ, we find the proprietary rights of the offerer in the sacrifice. For man, Christ as one with man, and yet in His own personal right, offers Himself (see Rom 5; and cf Gal 4 5 with He 2 11). There was also the transfer of guilt and its conditions, typically by laying the hand on the head of the animal, which then bore the sins of the offerer and was presented to God by the priest. The acknowledgment of sin and the surrender to God is completely fulfilled in Christ’s offering of Himself, and His death (cf Lev 3 2.8.18; 16 21; with Isa 538 6; 2 Cor 5 21). Our Lord’s inter- cessory quality in the sacrifice of Himself is not only indicated by the imputation of guilt to Him as representing the sinner, but also in the victory of His life over death, which is then given to man in God’s acceptance of His representative and sub- stitute. In the Ep. to the He, the intercessory character of Our Lord’s high-priestly office is transferred to the heavenly condition and work of Christ, where the relation of Christ’s work to man’s condition is regarded as being still continued in the heavenly place (see He 9 11-28). This entrance into heaven is once for all, and in the person of the high priest the way is open to the very presence of God. From one point of view (He 10 12) the priestly service of the Lord was concluded and gathered up into His kingly office (vs 13.14-18). But from another point of view, we ourselves are bidden to enter into the Holiest Place; as if in union with Christ we too become a kingly priesthood (He 10 19-22; and cf 1 Pet 2 9). It must not be forgotten, however, that this right of entrance into the most Holy Place is one that depends entirely upon our vital union with Christ, He appears in heaven for us and we with Him, and in this sense He fulfils the second duty of His high- priestly office as intercessor, with the added con- ception drawn from the legal advocacy of the Rom court. The term tr? “Advocate” in 1 Jn 2 2 is mapdkrnros, pardklétos, which in Jn 14 16 is tr4 “Comforter.” The word is of familiar use in Gr for the legal advocate or patronus who appeared ou behalf of his client. Thus, in the double sense of priestly and legal representative, Our Lord is our intercessor in Heaven. Of the modes in which Christ carries ont His inter- cessory office, we can have no knowledge except so far as we may fairly deduce them from the phrase- ology and suggested ideas of Scripture. As high priest, it may surely be right for us to aid our weak faith by assuring ourselves that Our Lord pleads for us, while at the same time we must be careful not to deprave our thought concerning the glorified Lord by the metaphors and analogies of earthly relationship. The intercessory work of Christ may thus_be represented: He represents man before God in His perfect nature, His exalted office and His completed work. The Scripture word for this is (He 9 24) “to appear before the face of God for us.” There is also an active intercession. This is the office of Our Lord as advocate or paraklétos. That this conveys some relation to the aid which one who has broken the law receives from an advocate cannot be overlooked, and we find Christ’s intercession in this aspect brought into connection with the texts which refer to justification and its allied ideas (see Rom 8 34; 1 Jn 2 1). i In Prayers or Curist (q.v.), the intercessory character of many of Our Lord’s prayers, and esp. that of Jn 17, is considered. And it 2. Christ's has been impossible for Christian Intercessory thought to divest itself of the idea Work from that the heavenly intercession of Christ the Stand- is of the order of prayer. It is im- point of possible for us to know; and even if Prayer Christ now prays to the Father, it can be in no way analogous to earthly prayers. The thought of some portion of Christen- dom distinctly combined prayer in the heavenly work of the Lord. There is danger in extreme views. Scriptural expressions must not be driven too far, and, on the other hand, they must not be emptied of all their contents. Modern Protestant teaching has, in its protest against a merely physical concep- tion of Our Lord’s state and occupation in heaven, almost sublimed reality from His intercessory work. In Lutheran teaching the intercession of Our Lord was said to be “‘vocal,”’ “‘verbal” and “oral.” It has been well remarked that such forms of prayer re- quire flesh and blood, and naturally the teachers of the Reformed churches, for the most part, have con- tented themselves (as for example Hodge, Syst. Theol., II, 593) with the declaration that ‘‘the intercession of Christ includes: (1) His appearing before God in our behalf, as the sacrifice for our sins, as our high priest, on the ground of whose work we receive the remission of our sins, the gift of the Holy Spirit, and all needed good; (2) de- fence against the sentence of the law and the charges of Satan, who is the great accuser; (3) His offering Himself as onr surety, not only that the demands of justice shall be shown to be satisfied, but that His people shall be obedient and faithful; (4) the obla- tion of the persons of the redeemed, sanctifying their prayers, and all their services, rendering them acceptable to God, through the savor of his own merits.” : Even this expression of the elements which con- stitute the intercession of the Lord, cautions and spiritual as it is in its application to Christian thought and worship, must be carefully guarded from a too complete and materialistic use. With- out this care, worship and devont thought may become degraded and fall into the mechanical forms by which Onr Lord’s position of intercessor has been reduced to very little more than an imaginative and spectacular process which goes on in some heavenly place. It must not be forgotten that the metaphorical and symbolic origin of the ideas which constitute Christ’s intercession is always in danger of dominating and materializmg the spiritual real- ity of His intercessional office. Lu. D. BEvAN INTEREST, in’tér-est (JWJ, neshekh, NWO, mashsha’; téKos, t6kos): The Heb word neshekh is from a root which means ‘‘to bite’; thus interest is “something bitten off.” The other word, mashsha’, means “lending on interest.”’ The Gr term is from the root tikté, ‘to produce” or “beget,”’ hence in- terest is something begotten or produced by moncy. The Heb words are usually tr¢ “usury,” but this meant the same as interest, all interest being reck- oned as usury. Long before Abraham’s time money had been loaned at a fixed rate of interest in Babylonia and almost certainly in Egypt. The CH gives regula- tions regarding the lending and borrowing of money, the usual interest being 20 per cent. Sometimes it was only 112 and 134, as shown by contract tab- lets. In one case, if the loan was not paid in two months, 18 per cent interest would be charged. 1489 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Inter. of Christ Interpretation Corn, dates, onions, etc, were loaned at interest. Thus Moses and Israel would be familiar with com- mercial loans and interest. In Israel there was no system of credit or commercial loans in Moses’ time and after. A poor man borrowed because he was poor. The law of Moses (Ex 22 25) forbade loan- ing at interest. There was to be no creditor and no taker of interest among them (Lev 25 36.37). Dt permits them to lend on interest to a foreigner (Dt 23 19.20), but not to a brother Israelite. That this was considered the proper thing in Israel for centuries is seen in Ps 15 5, while Prov 28 8 im- plies that it was an unusual thing, interest being generally exacted and profit made. Ezekiel con- demns it as a heinous sin (Ezk 18 8.13.17) and holds up the ideal of righteousness as not taking interest (22 12). Isa 24 2 implies that it was a business in that age, the lender and borrower being social types. Jeremiah implies that there was not always the best feeling between lenders and borrowers (16 10). According to Neh 6 7.10, rich Jews were lending to others and exacting heavy interest. Ne- hemiah condemns such conduct and forbids its con- tinuance, citing himself as an example of lending without interest. The lenders restored 1 per cent of that exacted. In the NT, references to interest occur in the parable of the Pounds (Lk 19 23) and of the Talents (Mt 25 27). Here the men were expected to put their master’s money out at interest, and condem- nation followed the failure to do so. Thus the principle of receiving interest is not condemned in the OT, only it was not to be taken from a brother Israelite. In the NT it is distinctly encouraged. See also Usury. J. J. REEvE INTERMEDDLE, in-tér-med”l (A9Y, ‘arabh, “to mix up [self] with something,” “mingle in,” “share,” ‘take interest in”): The word occurs only once (Prov 14 10) in a passage descriptive of “‘the ultimate solitude of each man’s soul at all times.” “The heart knoweth its own bitterness.” ‘‘Nor even the tenderest heart, and next our own, Knows half the reasons why we smile and sigh.” (Cf1 K 8 38.) Something thereis in every sorrow which no one else can share. “And a stranger doth not intermeddle with its joy,” not necessarily in an interfering or any offensive way, but simply does not share or take any interest in the other’s joy. For “intermeddleth with’ (Prov 18 1 AV), RV gives ‘“rageth against” (m ‘‘quarrelleth with”). M. O. Evans INTERMEDIATE, in-tér-mé’di-at, STATE. See EscuatoLoey or THE NT. INTERPRETATION, in-tir-pré-ta’shun: Is a generic term and may refer to any work of litera- ture. Referred specifically to the sacred 1. General Scriptures, the science of interpretation Principles is generally known as hermencutics, while the practical application of the principles of this science is exegesis. In nearly all cases, interpretation has in mind the thoughts of another, and then, further, these thoughts expressed in another language than that of the interpreter. In this sense it is used in Bib. research. A person has interpreted the thoughts of another when he has in his own mind a correct reproduction or photo- graph of the thought as it was conceived in the mind of the original writer or speaker. It is accordingly a purely reproductive process, involving no origi- nality of thought on the part of the interpreter. If the latter adds anything of his own it is etsegesis and not exegesis. The moment the Bible student has in his own mind what was in the mind of the author or authors of the Bib. books when these were written, he has interpreted the thought of the Scriptures. The interpretation of any specimen of literature will depend on the character of the work under consideration. A piece of poetry and a chapter of history will not be interpreted according to the same principles or rules. Particular rules that.are legiti- mate in the explanation of a work of fiction would be entirely out of place in dealing with a record of facts. Accordingly, the rules of the correct inter- pretation of the Scriptures will depend upon the character of these writings themselves, and the principles which an interpreter will employ in his interpretation of the Scriptures will be in harmony with his ideas of what the Scriptures arc as to origin, character, history, etc. In the nature of the case the dogmatical stand of the interpreter will mate- rially influence his hermeneutics and exegesis. In the legitimate sense of the term, every interpreter of the Bible is “prejudiced,” i.e. is guided by certain principles which he holds antecedently to his work of interpretation. If the modern advanced. critic is right in maintaining that the Bib. books do not differ in kind or character from the religious books of other ancient peoples, such as the Indians or the Persians, then the same principles that he applies in the case of the Rig Veda or the Zend Avesta he will employ also in his exposition of the Scriptures. If, on the other hand, the Bible is for him a unique collection of writings, Divinely inspired and a reve- lation from the source of all truth, the Bible student will hesitate long before accepting contradictions, errors, mistakes, etc, in the Scriptures. The Scriptures are a Divine and human product combined. That the holy men of God wrote as they were moved by the Spirit is the claim of the Scriptures themselves. Just where the line of demarkation is to be drawn between the human and the Divine factors in the production of the sacred Scriptures materially affects the principles of inter- preting these writings (see NsPiration). That the human factor was sufliciently potent to shape the form of thought in the Scriptures is evident on all hands. Paul does not write as Peter does, nor John as James; the individuality of the writer of the different books appears not only in the style, choice of words, etc, but in the whole form of thought also. There are such things as a Pauline, a Johannine and a Petrine type of Christian thought, although there is only one body of Christian truth under- lying all types. In so far as the Bible is exactly like other books, it must be interpreted as we do other works of literature. The Scriptures are written in Heb and in Gr, and the principles of forms and of syntax that would apply to the ex- planation of other works written in these lan- guages and under these circumstances must be applied to the OT and NT also. Again, the Bible is written for men, and its thoughts are those of mankind and not of angels or creatures of a differ- ent or higher spiritual or intellectual character; and accordingly there is no specifically Bib. logic, or rhetoric, or grammar. The laws of thought and of the interpretation of thought in these matters pertain to the Bible as they do to other writings. But in regard to the material contents of the Scriptures, matters are different and the principles of interpretation must be different. God is the author of the Scriptures which He has given through human agencies. Hence the contents of the Scriptures, to a great extent, must be far above the ordinary concepts of the human mind. When John declares that God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son to redeem it, the inter- preter does not do justice to the writer if he finds in the word “God” only the general philosophical 2. Special Principles Interpretation Ir-ha-heres 4 é THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1490 conception of the Deity and not that God who is our Father through Christ; for it was the latter thought that was in the mind of the writer when he penned these words. Thus, too, it is a false inter- pretation to find in “Our Father’ anything but this specifically Bib. conception of God, nor is it possible for anybody but a believing Christian to utter this prayer (Mt 6 9) in the sense which Christ, who taught it to His disciples, intended. Again, the example of Christ and His disciples in their treatment of the OT teaches the principle that the tpse dizit of a Scriptural passage is to be interpreted as decisive as to its meaning. In the about 400 citations from the OT found in the NT, there is not one in which the mere “It is written” is not regarded as settling its meaning. Whatever may be a Bible student’s theory of inspiration, the teachings and the examples of interpretation found in the Scriptures are in perfect harmony in this matter. These latter facts, too, show that in the inter- pretation of the Scriptures principles must be ap- plied that are not applicable in the explanation of other books. As God is the author of the Scrip- tures He may have had, and, as a matter of fact, m certain cases did have in mind more than the human agents through whom He spoke did themselves understand. The fact that, in the NT, persons like Aaron and David, institutions like the law, the sacrificial system, the priesthood and the like, are interpreted as typical of persons and things under the New Covenant shows that the true significance, e.g. of the Levitical system, can he found only when studied in the light of the NT fulfilment. Again, the principle of parallelism, not for illus- trative but for argumentative purposes, is a rule that can, in the nature of the case, be applied to the interpretation of the Scriptures alone and not else- where. As the Scriptures represent one body of truth, though in a kaleidoscopic variety of forms, a statement on a particular -subject in one place can be accepted as in harmony with a statement on the same subject elsewhere. In short, in all of those characteristics in which the Scriptures are unlike other literary productions, the principles of interpretation of the Scriptures must also be unlike those employed in other cases. Owing chiefly to the dogmatical basis of her- meneutics as a science, there has been a great di- vergence of views in the history of the church as to the proper methods of interpretation. It is one of the char- acteristic and instructive features of the NT writers that they absolutely refrain from the allegorical method of interpretation current in those times, particularly in the writings of Philo. Not even Gal 4 22, correctly understood, is an excep- tion, since this, if an allegorical interpretation at all, is an argumentum ad hominem. The sober and grammatical method of interpretation in the NT writers stands out, too,in bold and creditable con- trast to that of the early Christian exegetes, even of Origen. Only the Syrian fathers seemed to be an exception to the fantasies of the allegorical methods. The Middle Ages produced nothing new in this sphere; but the Reformation, with its formal principle that the Bible and the Bible alone is the rule of faith and life, made the correct gram- matical interpretation of the Scriptures practically a matter of necessity. In modern times, not at all prolific in scientific discussions of hermeneutical principles and practices, the exegetical methods of different interpreters are chiefly controlled by their views as to the origin and character of the Scrip- tural books, particularly in regard to their inspi- ration. 8. Histori- cal Data Lrrsraturs.—Terry, Bib. Hermeneutics, New York, 1884. Here the literature is fully given, as also in Weid- ner’s Theol. Enc, I, 266 ff. G. H. ScuonpE INTERPRETATION OF TONGUES. See Tonauzs, INTERPRETATION OF. INTERROGATION, in-tér-d-ga’shun (éepdrypa, eperéteéma): This word is not found at all in AV, and once only in ARV (1 Pet 3 21), where it replaces the word “answer” of AV. This change according to Alford and Bengel is correct. ‘The interrogation of a good conscience’ may refer to the question asked of a convert before baptism (cf Acts 8 37), or the appeal of the convert to God (ef 1 Jn 8 20-21). The opportunity to do this was given in baptism. INTER-TESTAMENTAL, _in-tér-tes-ta-men’tal, HISTORY AND LITERATURE. See Between THE TESTAMENTS. INTREAT, in-trét’, INTREATY, in-trét’i (EN- TREAT): The two forms are derived from the same vb. In 1611 the spelling was indifferently ‘in- treat” or ‘“entreat.”’ In editions of AV since 1760 ‘“Gntreat’’ is used in the sense of “to beg’; ‘‘en- treat’’ in the sense of ‘deal with.” As examples of ‘“Gntreat’’? see Ex 8 8, “Intreat the Lord” (¢é‘ak); Ruth 1 16, “Intreat me not to leave thee” (pagha‘) ; 2 Cor 8 4, ‘praying us with much intreaty” (wapd- Kdynows, pardklésis). In Gen 25 21 “intreat’’ is used to indicate the success of a petition. For entreat see Gen 12 16, “He entreated Abraham well’; Acts 27 3, “And Julius courteously en- treated Paul’ (¢:AavOpadrws xpyodueros, philanthré- pis chrésémenos, lit. “to use in a philanthropic way’’); cf also Jas 3 17, where edredys, eupeithés, lit. “easily persuaded,” is tr4 ‘‘easy to be entreated.”’ RV changes all passages of AV where “intreat’’ is found to “entreat,’’ with the exception of those mentioned helow. The meaning of “entreat’’ is “to ask,’’ “to beseech,” “to supplicate”’: Job 19 17 reads ‘“‘and my supplication to the children” (han- néthi, AV “though I intreated for the children,” RVm “I make supplication”). Jer 15 11 reads, “I will cause the enemy to make supplication” (Azph- ga‘tt), instead, AV “I will cause the enemy to en- treat”? (RVm “TI will intercede for thee with the enemy’). 1 Tim 51 changes AV “intreat”’ to “exhort.” Phil 4 3 renders AV “entreat’’ by “be- seech.”’ Russett BensamMin Mitier INWARD, in’wérd, MAN: A Pauline term, nearly identical with the “hidden man of the heart”’ (1 Pet 34). The Gr original, 6 Zow (also Zow6er) dvopwros, ho és6 (ésdthen) dnthrapos (Rom 7 22) is lexigraphically defined “the internal man,” i.e. “soul,” “conscience.” It is the immaterial part of man—mind, spirit—in distinction from the “out- ward man” which “perishes’ (2 Cor 4 16 AV). As the seat of spiritual influences it is the sphere in which the Holy Spirit does His renewing and saving work (Eph 3 16). The term “inward man’ can- not be used interchangeably with “the new man,” for it may still be ‘corrupt,’ and subject to “vanity” and “alienated from the life of God.” Briefly stated, it is mind, soul, spirit—God’s image in man— man’s higher nature, intellectual, moral, and spirit- ual. Dwicet M. Prarr INWARD PART: A symbolic expression in the OT represented by three Heb words: VI , hedher, “chamber,”’ hence inmost bowels or breast; ming, tuhath, “the reins”; 2, kerebh, “midst,” “middle,” hence heart. Once in the NT (Zowfev, ésathen, ‘from within,” Lk 11 39). The viscera (heart, 1491 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Interpretation Ir-ha-heres liver, kidneys) were supposed by the ancients to be the seat of the mind, feelings, affections: the high- est organs of the psyche, ‘the soul.’ The term in- cludes the intellect (“wisdom in the inward parts,” Job 38 36); the moral nature (“inward part is very wickedness,” Ps 5 9); the spiritual (“my law in their inward parts,’ Jer 31 33). Its adverbial equivalent in Bib. use is “inwardly.” INwarp Man (q.v.) is identical in meaning. : Dwicat M. Prarr IOB, yob (AN, yobh; AV Job): Third son of Issachar (Gen 46 13). In || passages (Nu 26 24; 1 Ch 7 1) the name is Jashub (270), yashabh), wale the VSS in Gen also support as the correct orm. IPHDEIAH, if-dé’ya (A1D", yiphdeyah, “Jeh redeems’’; AV Iphedeiah): A descendant of Benja- min (1 Ch 8 25). IPHTAH, if’ta (TMD", yiphtah; AV Jiphtah): An unidentified town in the Shephelah of Judah, named with Libnah, Ether and Ashan (Josh 16 43). IPHTAH-EL, if’ta-el (NMED, yiphiah-él; AV Jiphtah-el): The valley of Iphtah-el lay on the N. border of Zebulun (Josh 19 14.27). N.W. of the plain of el-Battauf stands a steep hill, con- nected only by a low saddle with the hills on the N. Thename Tell Jéfat suggests the Jotapata of Jos (BJ, III, vi, i; vii, i, etc), and the place answers well to his description. It probably corresponds to the ancient Iphtah-el. In that case the valley is most probably that which begins at Tell Jéadt, passes round the 8. of Jebel Kaukab, and, as Wady .’Abelltn, opens on the plain of Acre. W. Ewinea IR, ir (WY, ‘ir): A descendant of Benjamin (1 Ch 7 12), called Iri in ver 7. IRA, i’'ra (NVWY, ‘ara’; Etpas, Hiras): (1) A person referred to in 2 § 20 26 as “‘priest”’ (so RV correctly; AV “a chief ruler,” ARV “chief minister”) unto David. The tr of RV is the only possible one; but, according to the text, Ira was ‘a Jairite,” and thus of the tribe of Manasseh (Nu 32 41) and not eligible to the priesthood. On the basis of the Pesh some would correct “Jairite” of 2S 20 26 into “Jattirite,” referring to Jattir, a priestly city within the territory of Judah (Josh 21 14). Others point to 25 8 18 m, “David's sons were priests,’ as an indication that in David’s time some non-Levites were permitted to serve— in some sense—as priests. id (2) An “Ithrite,” or (with a different pointing of the text) a “Jattirite,”’ one of David’s “thirty” (28 23 38||1 Ch 11 40); possibly identical with (1). (3) Another of David’s “thirty,” son of Ikkesh of Tekoa (2 S 28 26; 1 Ch 11 28) and a captain of the temple guard (1 Ch 27 9). F. K. Farr TRAD, frad (W499, ‘tradh; LXX Ta848, Gai- déd): Grandson of Cain and son of Enoch (Gen 4 18). IRAM, ‘ram (OY°9, ‘ir@m; LXX variously in Gen): A “chief” of Edom (Gen 36 43]|1 Ch 1 54). IR-HA-HERES, ir-ha-hé’rez (O° VY, Sr ha- heres, according to the MT, Aq, Theodotion, LXX, AV and RV; according to some Heb MSS, Sym- machus, and the Vulg, OUT "YF, ‘ir ha-heres): : A city of Egypt referred to in Isa 19 18. Jewish quarrels concerning the temple which Onias built in Egypt have most probably been responsible for the altering of the texts of some of the early MSS, and “that day.” it is not now possible to determine absolutely which have been altered and which accord with the original. This difference in MSS gives rise to different opinions among authorities here to be noted. Most of the discussion of this name arises from this uncertainty and is hence rather profitless. The starting-point of any proper discussion of Ir- ha-h is that the words are by Isaiah and that they are prophecy, predictive prophecy. They belong to that portion of the prophecies of Isa which by nearly all critics is allowed to the great prophet. Nothing but unfounded speculation or an unwill- ingness to admit that there is any predictive proph- écy can call in question Isaiah’s authorship of these words. Then the sense of the passage in which these words occur imperatively demands that they be accounted predictive prophecy. Isaiah plainly refers to the future, “‘shall be called’; and makes a definite statement concerning what shall take place in the future (19 18-24). The reality of predictive prophecy may be discussed by those so inclined, but that the intention of the author here was to utter predictive prophecy does not seem to be open to question. For the verification of this prediction by its fulfilment in history we shall inquire con- cerning: (1) the times intended: “that day”; (2) the “five cities’; (3) ‘Ir-ha-heres.”’ The prophet gives a fairly specific description of It was at least to begin when “there shall be five cities in the land of Egypt 1. The that speak the language of Canaan, Times In- and swear to Jeh of hosts” (ver 18), tended: and ‘In that day shall there be an “That Day” altar to Jeh in the midst of the land of Egypt, and a pillar at the border there- of to Jeh” (ver 19). There was to be also some inroad made upon the heathenism of Egypt by the message of the Lord (vs 21f), and about that time a deliverer should arise in Egypt (ver 20), and all this should take place before the power of the land of Assyria should pass away (vs 23 f). The first historical fulfilment of these words is ‘found at the period when Onias built his imitation of the Temple of Jerusalem at the place 2. The called by the Greeks Leontopolis (Tell “Five el-Yehudiyeh), and the worship of Cities” Jeh was set up at Elephantine, and the Jews were a great power at Alexandria and at Tahpanhes. While any of these latter three might have contained the “pillar,” the “altar” would thus be either at Leontopolis or the other one of the ‘five cities’ which cannot be named with much probability. The great deliverer would seem to be Alexander. Some think that the conversion of the Egyptians indicated in vs 21.22 is furthered, though sti not completed, in the Christian invasion of the ist cent., and again in the success of modern Chris- tian missions in Egypt. It will be seen that it does not follow from what has been said that Leontopolis was Ir-ha-h as some seem to think. It is not said by the 3. “Ir-ha- prophet that the place where was the heres” “altar”? was called Ir-ha-h, even if it were certain that the altar was at Leontopolis. Nevertheless, Leontopolis may be Ir-ha-h. The problem is not in the first place the identification of the name, but the determination of Which one of the “five cities’? was destroyed. The expression “shall be called the city of destruction” seems clearly to indicate that Ir-ha-h is not a name at all, but merely a descriptive appellation of that city which should ‘‘be destroyed.’”’ It still remains 4o inquire whether or not this was an independent appellation, or whether, more probably, it bore some reldtion to the name of that city at the time at which the prophet wrote, a play upon the sound, or the significance of the name or both of these, Isaac i THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1492 either through resemblance or contrast. If Gesen- ius is right, as he seems to be, in the opinion that “in the idiom of Isa Ir-ha-h means simply ‘the city that shall be destroyed,’ ” then the original problem of finding which one of the cities was destroyed seems to be the whole problem. Still, in the highly- wrought language of Isaiah and according to the gen- jus of the Heb tongue, there is probably a play upon words. It is here that the consideration of the name itself properly comes in and probably guides usrightly. Speculation, by Gesenius, Duhm, Cheyne and others, has proposed various different readings of this name, some of them requiring two or three changes in the text to bring it to its present state. Speculation can always propose readings. On was sometimes called ‘“Heres” and meant “‘house of the sun,” which would be both tr‘ and transliterated into Heb ha-heres and might have ‘ir (“city”) pre- fixed. Naville, through his study of the great Har- ris papyrus, believed that the old Egyp city which later was called Leontopolis (Tell el-Yehudiyeh) was immediately connected with On and called “House of Ra,” also ‘House of theSun.” Thus this name might be both transliterated and tr4 into the Heb ha-heres and have ‘ir prefixed. The difference between this expression and “‘Ir-ha-h” which Isaiah used is only the difference between h and h. So that Ir-ha-h is most probably a predictive prophecy concerning the disaster that was to over- take one of the ‘‘five cities,” with a play upon the name of the city, and that city is either On, the later Heliopolis, or the ancient sacred city about 4 miles to the N. of On, where Onias was to build his temple and which later became Leontopolis (Tell- el-Yehudiyeh). No more positive identification of Ir-ha-h is yet possible. M. G. Kyte IRI, ri (UY, *r2). IRIJAH, i-ri’ja (IMRT, yir'tydyh, “Jeh sees’): A captain at the gate of Benjamin in Jerus, who arrested Jeremiah the prophet on suspicion of in- tending to desert to the Chaldaeans (Jer 37 13.14). IR-NAHASH, tr-na’hash, ir-na’hash (WT WP, “ir nahash): A town of Judah of which Tehinnah is called the “father,”’ probably meaning “founder” (1 Ch 4 12). EVm suggests the tr “city of Na- hash.” IRON, urn (2793, barzel; ol8npos, sidéros): It is generally believed that the art of separating iron from its ores and making it into useful forms was not known much earlier than 1000 BC, and that the making of brass (bronze) antedates it by many centuries, in spite of the frequent Bib. ref- erences where brass and iron occur together. This conjecture is based upon the fact that no specimen of worked iron has been found whose antiquity can be vouched for. The want of such instruments, however, can be attributed to the ease with which iron corrodes. Evidence that iron was used is found, for example, in the hieroglyphics of the tomb of Rameses III, where the blades of some of the weapons are painted blue while others are painted red, a distinction believed to be due to the fact that some were made of iron or steel and some of brass. No satisfactory proof has yet been presented that the marvelous sculpturing on the hard Egyp granite was done with tempered bronze. It seems more likely that steel tools were used. After the dis- covery of iron, it was evidently a long time in re- placing bronze. This was probably due to the difficulties in smelting it. An old mountaineer once described to the writer the process of iron smelting as it was carried on in Mt. Lebanon in past centu- ries. As a boy he had watched his father, who was See In; Unitas. a smelter, operate one of the last furnaces to be fired. For each firing, many cords of wood, esp. green oak branches, were used, and several days of strenuous pumping at the eight bellows was neces- sary to supply the air blast. As a result a small lump of wrought iron was removed from the bottom of the furnace after cooling. The iron thus won was carried to Damascus where it was made into steel by workers who kept their methods secret. This process, which has not been worked now for years, was undoubtedly the same as was used by the ancients. It is not at all unlikely that the Lebanon iron, transformed into steel, was what was referred to as “northern iron” in Jer 16 12 (AV). In many districts the piles of slag from the ancient furnaces are still evident. : ; Aside from the limited supply of iron ore in Mt. Lebanon (cf Dt 8 9), probably no iron was found in Syria and Pal. It was brought from Tarshish (Ezk 27 12) and Vedan and Javan (Ezk 27 19), and probably Egypt (Dt 4 20). _ Mite Oe The first mention of iron made in the Bible is in Gen 4 22, where Tubal-Cain is mentioned as ‘“‘the forger of every cutting instrument of brass and iron.” It is likely that the Jews learned the art of metallurgy from the Phoenicians (2 Ch 2 14) (see Crarts). Iron was used in Bib. times much asitistoday. For a description of a smith at work see Ecclus 88 28. Huge city gates, overlaid with strips of iron (Ps 107 16; Isa 45 2), held in place by crude square-headed nails (1 Ch 22 3), are still a familiar sight in the larger cities of Pal and Syria (Acts 12 10). Threshing instruments were made of iron (Am 1 3); so also harrows (28 12 31), axes (ib; 2 K 6 6; see Ax), branding irons (1 Tim 4 2), and other tools (1 K 6 7). There were iron weapons (Nu 35 16; Job 20 24), armor (2 S 23 7), horns (1 K 22 11), fetters (Ps 105 18), char- iots (Josh 17 16), yokes (Jer 28 14), breastplates (Rev 9 9), pens (chisels) (Job 19 24; Jer 17 1), sheets or plates (Ezk 4 3), gods (Dnl 5 4), weights (1 8 17 7), bedsteads (Dt 3 11). Iron was used extensively in building the temple. See Merats. Figurative: ‘‘The iron furnace’ is used meta- phorically for affliction, chastisement (Dt 4 20; Ezk 22 18-22). Iron is also employed fig. to repre- sent barrenness (Dt 28 23), slavery (‘yoke of iron,” Dt 28 48), strength (‘‘bars of iron,” Job 40 18), severity (“rod of iron,” Ps 2 9), captivity (Ps 107 10), obstinacy (‘ron sinew,” Isa 48 4), fortitude (“iron pillar,’ Jer 1 18), moral deteriora- tion (Jer 6 28), political strength (Dnl 2 38), destructive power (“iron teeth,” Dnl 7 7); the cer- tainty with which a real enemy will ever show his hatred is as the rust returning upon iron (Ecclus 12 10 AV, RV “brass’”’); great obstacles (“walls of iron,” 2 Mace 11 9). James A. Parca IRON, i’ron (JN, yir’dn): One of the fenced cities in the territory of Naphtali, named with Migdal-el and En-hazor (Josh 19 38). It is repre- sented by the modern Yaran, a village with the Tuins of a synagogue, at one time used as a monas- tery, fully 6 miles W. of Kedes. IRPEEL, dr’pé-el, ir/p&el ONE, yirp’ el): An unidentified city in Benjamin (Josh 18 27). It may possibly be represented by Rafat, a ruin to the N. of el-J%, the ancient Gibeon. a IRREVERENCE, i-rev’ér-ens. Sce Crime, CriMEs, IRRIGATION, ir-i-ga’shun: No equivalent for this word is found in Bib. writings, although the use of wrigation for maintaining vegetable life is fre- quently implied (Eccl 2 5.6; Isa 58 11). To one 1493 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA In Isaac ee familiar with the methods of irrigation practised in Pal, Syria and Egypt, the passage, “where thou sowedst thy seed, and wateredst it with thy foot, as a garden of herbs” (Dt 11 10), is easily explained. The water is brought in channels to the gardens, where it is distributed in turn to the different square plots bounded by banks of earth, or along the rows of growing vegetables planted on the sides of the trenches. In stony soil the breach in the canal leading to a particular plot is opened and closed with a hoe. Any obstruction in the trench is similarly removed, while in the soft, loamy soil of the coastal plain or in the Nile valley these opera- tions can be done with the foot, a practice still commonly seen. Egyptian Water Wheel. The remains of the great irrigation works of the ancient Egyptians and Babylonians leave no doubt as to the extent to which they used water to redeem the deserts. In Pal and Syria there was less need (Dt 10 7; 11 11) for irrigation. Here there is an annual fall of from 30 to 40 in., coming principally during the winter. This is sufficient for the main crops. The summer supply of vegetables, as well as the fruit and mulberry trees, requires irrigation. Hardly a drop of many mountain streams is allowed to reach the sea, but is used to water the gardens of the mountain terraces and plains. This supply is now being supplemented by the introduction of thousands of pumps and oil engines for raising the water of the wells sufficiently to run it through the irrigation canals. Where a spring is small, its supply is gathered into a birket, or cistern, and then drawn off through a large outlet into the trenches, sometimes several days being required to fill the cistern. In Eccl 2 6, Solomon is made to say, ‘‘I made me pools of water, to water therefrom the forest.” This passage helps to explain the uses of the so-called Pools of Solomon, 8S. of Jerus. In this same district are traces of the ancient terraces which were probably watered from these pools. See AGRICULTURE; GAaRnEN. JAMES A. PATCH _IR-SHEMESH, ir-shé’mesh, ir-shé’mesh ("°F WW, ‘ir shemesh, “city of the sun”). See Beru- SHEMESH ; HERES. IRU, 7i’roo (VY , ‘ird): Eldest son of Caleb (1 Ch 4 15); probably to be read Ir, the syllable -u being the conjunction “and” belonging to the following word. ISAAC, i’zak: I. Name 1. Root, Forms, Analogues 2. Implication II. Famity ann KinpRED % 1. Birth and Place in the Family 2. Relation to the Religious Birthright 3. Significance of Marriage Ill. Story or Lire 4 1. Previous to Marriage 2. Subsequent to Marriage IV. Brisiicat REFERENCES . In the OT 2. In the NT V. Views OrHer THAN THE HistToRIcaL I. Name.—This name has the double spelling, PRE, yichak, and PTW, yishak (Toad, Isadk), corresponding to the two forms in 1. Root, which appears the root meaning “to Forms and laugh’”—aroot that runs through nearly Analogues all the Sem languages. In Heb both ¢Ghak and sdhak have their cognate nouns, and signify, in the simple stem, “to laugh,” in the intensive stem, ‘to jest, play, dance, fondle,” and the like. The noun yichdr, meaning “fresh oil,” from a root ¢ahar (‘‘to be bright, conspicuous”), proves that nouns can be built on precisely the model of yighdk, which would in that case signify “the laughing one,’’ or something similar. Yet Barth (Die Nominalbildung in den semitischen Sprachen, § 154, 6 and c) maintains that all proper names be- ginning with yddh prefixed to the root are really pure imperfects, i.e. verbal forms with some subject to be understood if not actually present. Hence Isaac would mean “laughs”: either indefinite, ‘‘one laughs,” or “he laughs,” viz. the one understood as the subject. There are some 50 Heb names that have a similar form with no accompanying subject. Of these sometimes the meaning of the root is quite obscure, sometimes it is appropriate to any sup- posable subject. Each is a problem by itself; for the interpretation of any one of them there is little help to be gained from a comparison with the others. What subject, then, is to be understood with this imperfect vb. yighak? Or is no definite subject to be supplied? (1) ’Zl, God, may be supplied: ‘God laughs.” Such an expression might be understood of the Divine benevolence, or of the fearful laughter of scorn for His enemies (Ps 2 4), or, euphemistically, of the Divine wrath, the ‘terrible glance,” as of Moloch, etc (so Meyer, Israeliten und thre Nachbarstimme, 255). (2) Some human per- son: “‘he laughs.” So, for example, he himself, viz. the child who receives the name; or, the father; or, the brother (not the mother, which would require tichak). In the light now of these possibilities we turn to the narratives of Isaac’s birth and career and find the following subjects suggested: (a) father, Gen 17 17; (0) indefinite, ‘one laughs” (not “she laughs,” see above), Gen 18 12-15; 216; (c) brother, Gen 21 9; (d) himself, Gen 26 8. Of these passages the last two show the vb. in the in- tensive stem in the signification of (c) “‘mock” (?), and (d) “dally.” We find this same vb. in these senses in Gen 19 14 and 39 14.17, in the stories of Lot and of Joseph, and it is possible that here also in the story of Isaac it has no more connection with the name Isaac than it has there with the names Lot and Joseph. However this may be, there is ob- viously one interpretation of the name Isaac, which, required in two of the passages, is equally appro- priate in them all, viz. that with the indefinite sub- ject, “one laughs.” Consideration of the sources to which these passages are respectively assigned by the documentary hypothesis tends only to con- firm this result. I, Family and Kindred.—The two things in Isaac’s life that are deemed worthy of extensive treatment in the sacred narrative are his birth and his marriage. His significance, in fact, centers in his transmission of what went before him to what came after him. Hence, his position in his father’s family, his relation to its greatest treasure, the reli- gious birthright, and his marriage with Rebekah are the subjects that require special notice in this connection. 2. Impli- cation Isaac Isaiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1494 The birth of Isaac is represented as peculiar in these respects: the age of his parents, the purity of his lineage, the special Divine promises 1. Birth accompanying. What in Abraham’s and Place life is signalized by the Divine “call” in the from his father’s house, and what in Family Jacob’s life is brought about by a : series of providential interpositions, seems in Isaac’s case to become his by his birth. His mother, who is not merely of the same stock as Abraham but actually his half-sister, is the legal wife. As her issue Isaac is qualified by the laws of inheritance recognized in their native land to be- come his father’s heir. But Ishmael, according to those laws, has a similarly valid claim (see ApRra- HAM, IV, 2), and it is only i express command that Abraham is led to abandon what was apparently both custom and personal preference, to “cast out the bondwoman and her son,” and to acquiesce in the arrangement that ‘‘in Isaac shall thy seed be called.” But the birthright of Isaac was of infinitely more importance than the birthright in the family of any other wealthy man of that day. All 2. Relation that limitless blessing with which to the Re- Abraham set forth under God’s leader- ligious ship was promised not only +o him but Birthright to his “seed”; it was limitless in time as well as in scope. To inherit it was of more consequence to Isaac than to inherit any number of servants, flocks or wells of his father’s acquisition. A sense of these relative values seems to have been a part of Isaac’s spiritual endowment, and this, more than anything else related of him, makes him an attractive figure on the pages of Gen. The raising up of a “seed” to be the bearers of these promises was the prime concern of Isaac’s life. Not by intermarriage with the 3. Signifi- Canaanites among whom he lived, but cance of by marriage with one of his own peo- Marriage ple, in whom as much as in himself should be visibly embodied the separ- ateness of the chosen family of God—thus primarily was Isaac to pass on to @ generation as pure as his own the heritage of the Divine blessing. Rebekah enters the tent of Isaac as truly the chosen of God as was Abraham himself. dif, Story of Life.—Previous to bis marriage Isaac’s life is a part of the story of Abraham; after his marriage it merges into that of his children. It is convenient, therefore, to make his marriage the dividing-line in the narrative of his career. A child whose coming was heralded by such signal marks of Divine favor as was Isaac’s would be, even apart from other special considera- 1. Previous tions, a welcome and honored member to Marriage of the patriarchal household. The covenant-sign of circumcision (which Isaac was the first to receive at the prescribed age of 8 days), the great feast at his weaning, and the disinheritance of Ishmael in his favor, are all of them indications of the unique position that this child held, and prepare the reader to appreciate the depth of feeling involved in the sacrifice of Isaac, the story of which follows thereupon. The age of Isaac at the time of this event is not stated, but the fact that he is able to carry the wood of the offering shows that he had probably attained his full growth. The single question he asks his father and his other- wise unbroken silence combine to exhibit him in a favorable light, as thoughtful, docile and trustful. The Divine interposition to save the lad thus de- voted to God constitutes him afresh the bearer of the covenant-promise and justifies its explicit renewal on this occasion. From this point onward the biographer of Isaac evidently has his marriage in view, for the two items that preceded the long 24th ch, in which Rebekah’s choice and coming are rehearsed, are, first, the brief genealogical para- graph that informs the reader of the development of Nahor’s family just as far as to Rebekah, and second, the ch that tells of Sarah’s death and burial —an event clearly associated in the minds of all with the marriage of Isaac (see 24 3.36.67). Di- vine interest in the choice of her who should be the mother of the promised seed is evident in every line of the ch that dramatizes the betrothal of Isaac and Rebekah. Their first meeting is described at its close with the tender interest in such a scene nat- ural to every descendant of the pair, and Isaac is sketched as a man of a meditative turn (ver 63) and an affectionate heart (ver 67). The dismissal of the sons of Abraham’s concu- bines to the “East-country” is associated with the statement that Isaac inherited all that 2. Subse- Abraham had; yet it has been re- quent to marked that, besides supplying them Marriage with gifts, Abraham was doing them a further kindness in thus emancipating them from continned subjection to Isaac, the future head of the clan. After Abraham’s death we are ex- pressly informed that God “blessed Isaac his son” in fulfilment of previous promise. The section entitled “the téldhath [generations] of Isaac’ extends from 25 19+0 35 29. At the opening of it Isaac is dwell- ing at Beer-lahai-roi (25 11), then at Gerar (26 1.6) and “the valley of Gerar’ (26 17), then at Beer- sheba (26 23; 28 10), all localities in the Negeb or “South-country.”’ But after the long narrative of the fortunes of Jacob and his family, occupying many years, we find Isaac at its close living where his father Abraham had lived, at Hebron. | For 20 years Isaac and Rebekah remained child- less; it was only upon the entreaty of Isaac that God granted them their twin sons. A famine was the usual signal for emigration to Egypt (cf Gen 12 10; 42 2); and Isaac also appears to have been on his way thither for the same cause, when, at Gerar, he is forbidden by God to proceed, and occa- sion is found therein to renew to him the covenant- promise of his inheritance: land, posterity, honor and the Divine presence (26 1-4). But Isaac had also received from his father tradi- . tions of another sort; he too did not hesitate to say to the men of Gerar that his wife was his sister, with the same intent to save his own life, but without the same justification in fact, as in the case of Abraham’s earlier stratagem. Yet even the dis- covery by the king of Gerar of this duplicity, and repeated quarrels about water in that dry country, did not suffice to endanger Isaac’s status with the settled inhabitants, for his large household and great resources made him a valuable friend and a danger- ous enemy. The favoritism which Isaac showed for one son and Rebekah for the other culminated in the painful scene when the paternal blessing was by guile ob- tained for Jacob, and in the subsequent enforced absence of Jacob from his parental home. Esau, too, afforded no comfort to his father and mother, and ere long he also withdrew from his father’s clan. The subsequent reconciliation of the brothers per- mitted them to unite at length in paying the last honors to Isaac on his decease. Isaac was buried at Hebron where his parents had been buried (Gen 49 31), and where his place of sepulture is still honored. IV. Biblical References.—There is a great con- trast between Abraham and Jacob on the one hand, and Isaac on the other, with respect to their promi- nence in the lit. of the nation that traced to them its descent. Tobe sure, when the patriarchs as a group are to be named, Isaac takes his place in the stereo- typed formula of “Abraham, Isaac and Jacob,’’ or “Israel” (so 23 t in the OT, 7 t in the NT). 1495 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA “Isaac Isaiah But apart from this formula Isaac is referred to | wise be understood as echoes of original myths. Even in the OT only as follows. During the lifetime of Jacob the names of Abraham and Isaac 1. Inthe are repeatedly linked in the same way OT as are all three subsequently: they form for that age the dynasty of the covenant. But several times Jacob calls Jeh the ‘God (or, the Fear; see infra) of Isaac, because Isaac is his own immediate predecessor in this chain of the faithful. Isaac is called the “gift”? of God to Abraham, in the farewell address of Joshua, just as Jacob and Esau are called God’s “gifts” to Isaac (Josh 24 3f; cf Koran, Sura 6 84). The “house of Isaac” is used by Amos as a || expression for ‘Tsrael,” and ‘the high places of Isaac” for “the sanctuaries of Israel” (Am 7 16.9), in the same way as ‘‘Jacob” is often used elsewhere (LXX in ver 16 reads “Jacob”). Other references to Isaac are simply as to his father’s son or his children’s father. He fares betterinthe NT. For, besides the gene- alogical references, Isaac’s significance as the first to receive circumcision on the 8th day 2. In is remembered (Acts 7 8); his posi- the NT tion as first of the elect seed is set. forth Rom 9 7); his begetting of two sons so unlike in their relation to the promise as were Esau and Jacob is remarked (Rom 9 10); the facts of his being heir to the promise, a child of old age, and, though but one, the father of an innumerable progeny, are emphasized in He 11 (vs 9-12), which also discovers the deeper significance of his sacrifice and restoration to his father (vs 17-19; cf Jas 2 21); and in the same context is noticed the faith in God implied in Isaac’s blessing of his sons. But Isaac receives more attention than anywhere else in that famous passage in Gal (4 21-31), in which Paul uses Isaac and his mother as allegorical representa- tions of Christians who are justified by faith in the promise of God, and are the free-born heirs of all the spiritual inheritance implied in that promise. Even Isaac’s persecution by Ishmael has its counter- part in the attitude of the enemies of Paul’s gospel toward him and his doctrines and converts. V. Views Other than the Historical.—Philo, the chiet allegorizer of Scriptural narratives, has little to say of Isaac, whom he calls ‘‘the self-instructed nature.” But modern critics have dissolved his personality by repre- senting him as the personification of au ethnic group. “ All Israel,”’ writes Wellhausen (Prol., 6th ed, 316), ‘is qoubed with the people of Edom under the old name saac (Am 7 9.16)... . the material here is not mythical (as in Gen 1-11] but national.” And just as Israel plus Edom had little or no significance in national customs or spontical events, when compared on the one hand with Israel alone (=Jacob), and with Israel plus Edom plus Moab and Ammon (=Abraham) on the other hand; so likewise the figure of Isaac is colorless and his story brief, as compared with the striking figures of Jacob on the one hand and of Abraham on the other hand, and the circumstantial stories of their lives. Other scholars will have none of this natlonal view, because they believe Isaac to be the name of an ancient deity, the local numen of Beersheba. Stark, whom others have followed, proposes to interpret the phrase tra “the Fear of Isaac” in Gen 31 42.53 as the name of this god used by his worshippers, the Terror Isaac, Isaac the terrible god. For the sense of Isaac in that case see above under I, 2, (1). Meyer (loc. cit.) defends the transfer of the name from a god to the hero of a myth, by comparing the sacrifice of Isaac (‘‘the only story in which Isaac plays an independent réle”!) with the Gr myth of Iphigenia’s sacrifice (Hesiod, Euripides, etc), in which the by-name of a goddess (Iphigenia) identified with Artemis has passed to the intended victim rescued by Artemis from death. | : The most recent critical utterances reject both the foregoing views of Isaac as in conflict with the data of Gen. Thus Gunkel (Schriften des AT, 5te Lieferung, 1910, 41) writes: ‘Quite clearly the names of Abraham, Isaac, and all the patriarchal women are not tribal names..... The interpretation of the figures of Gen as nations furnishes by no means a general key.”” And again: ‘‘ Against the entire assumption that the principal patriarchal figures are originally gods, is above all to be noted that the names Jacob and Abraham are proved by the Bab to be personal names in current use, and at the same time that the sagas about them can in no Winckler’s more than bold attempt to explain these sagas as original calendar-myths must be pronounced a complete failure.’’ Yet Gunkel and those who share his position are careful to distinguish their own view from that of the “ apologetes,'' and to concede no more than the bare fact that there doubtless were once upon a time persons named Abraham, Isaac, ete. For these critics Isaac Is slnoly a name about which have crystal- lized cycles of folk-stories, that have their parallels in other lands and languages, but have received with a Heb name also a local coloring and significance on the ilps of successlve Heb story-tellers, saga-builders and finally collectors and editors; ‘‘ Everyone who knows the history of sagas ls sure that the saga is not able to preserve through the course of so many centuries, a true picture’ of the patrlarchs. See also Anranam, end. J. Oscar Born ISAAC, TESTAMENT OF. See Aprocatyrtic LITERATURE, ISAIAH, i-za’ya, i-zi’a: Name Personal History Call Literary Genius and Style Traditions concerning His Martyrdom Period Anely sis and Contents Isaiah’s ao el Chronologically Arranged The Critical Problem 1) The History of Criticism 3) The Disintegration of ‘‘ Deutero-Isaiah’”’ 3) Recent Views 4) The Present State of the Question 5) Reasons for Dissecting the Book 6) Arguments for One Isaiah a) The Circle of Ideas b} The Literary Style c) Historical Refereuces (d) The Predictive Element {e) Cyrus a Subject of Prediction LivBRaTURE Of all Israel’s celebrated prophets, Isaiah is the king. The writings which bear his name are among the profoundest in all literature. One great theme —salvation by faith—stamps them all. Isaiah is the St. Paul of the OT. ; In Heb WWW, yshatyaha, and MD, ysha'yah; Gr “Hoatas, Hsaias; Lat Hsaias and Isaias. His name was symbolic of his message. Like “Joshua,’’ it means “Jeh saves,” or “Jeh is salvation,” or “salvation of Jeb.” Isaiah was the son of Amoz (not Amos). He seems to have belonged to a family of some rank, as may be inferred from his easy access 2. Personal to the king (Isa 7 3), and his close History intimacy with the priest (8 2). Tradi- tion says he was the cousin of King Uzziah. He lived in Jerus and became court preacher. He was married and had two sons: Shear-jashub, his name signifying ‘a remnant shal] return” (7 3), and Maher-shalal-hash-baz, “hasting to the spoil, hurrying to the prey,” sym- bolic of Assyria’s mad lust of conquest (8 3). Jew- ish tradition, based upon a false interpretation of 7 14, declares he was twice married. In the year that King Uzziah died, Isaiah, ap- parently while worshipping in the temple, received a call to the prophetic office (ch 6). 3. Call He responded with noteworthy alac- rity, and accepted his commission, though he knew from the outset that his task was to be one of fruitless warning and exhortation (6 9-13). Having been reared in Jerus, he was well fitted to become the political and religious counselor of the nation, but the experience which prepared him most for his important work was the vision of the majestic and. thrice-holy God which he saw in the temple in the death-year of King Uzziah. There is.no good reason for doubting that this was his inaugural vision, though some regard it as a vision which came to him after years of experience in preaching and as intended to deepen his spirituality. While this is SON Grup COBO 1. Name Isaiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1496 the only explicit “vision” Isaiah saw, yet his entire book, from first to last, is, as the title (1 1) suggests, a “vision.” His horizon, both political and spiritual, was practically unbounded. Jn a very true sense, as Delitzsch says, he was “the universal prophet of Israel.” _ For versatility of expression and brilliancy of imagery Isaiah bad no superior, not even a rival. His style marks the climax of Hebrew 4, Literary literary art. Both his periods and Genius and descriptions are most finished and Style sublime. He is a perfect artist in words. Beauty and strength are characteristic of his entire book. Epigrams and metaphors, particularly of flood, storm and sound (1 18; 5 18.22; 8 8; 10 22; 28 17.20; 30 28.30), interrogation and dialogue (6 8; 10 8.9), antithe- sis and alliteration (1 18; 3 24; 17 10.12), hyper- bole and parable (2 7; 5 1-7; 28 23-29), even paranomasia, or play upon words (5 7; 7 9), char- acterize Isaiah’s book as the great masterpiece of Hebrew literature. He is also famous for his rich- ness of vocabulary and synonyms. For example, Ezekiel uses 1,535 words; Jeremiah, 1,653; the Psalmists 2,170; while Isaiah uses2,186. Isaiah was also an orator: Jerome likened him to Demosthenes; and a poet: he frequently elaborates his messages in rhythmic or poetic style (12 1-6; 25 1-5; 26 1-12; 38 10-20; 42 1-4; 49 1-9; 5049; 52 13—53 12; 60-62; 66 5-24); and in several in- stances slips into elegiac rhythm, e.g. in 37 22-29 there is a fine taunting poem on Sennacherib, and in 14 4-23 another on the king of Babylon. As Driver observes, ‘‘Isaiah’s poetical genius is superb.” Nothing definite or historical is known concerning the prophet's end. Toward the close of the 2d cent. AD, however, there was a tradition to the B. Tradi- effect that he suffered martyrdom in the és heathen, reaction which occurred under tions con- King Manasseh, because of certain cerning His speeches concerning God and the Holy M dom ity which his contemporaries alleged arty: were contrary to the law. Indeed the Jewish Mishna explicitly states that Manasseh slew him, Justin Martyr also (150 AD), in his controversial dialogue with the Jew Trypho, re- proaches the Jews with this accusation, ‘‘ whom ye sawed asunder with a wooden saw''; this tradition is further confirmed by a Jewish Apocalypse of the 2d cent. AD, entitled, The Ascension of Isaiah, and by Epiphanius in his so-called Lives of the Prophets. It is harely possible that there is an allusion to his martyrdom in He 11 37, which reads, ‘They were stoned, they were sawn asunder,”’ but this is by no means certain. In any case Isaiah robably survived the great catastrophe of the siege of Waris by Sennacherib in 701 BC, and possibly also the death of Hezekiah in 699 BC; for in 2 Ch 32 32 it is stated that Isaiah wrote a hiography of King Hezekiah. If so, his prophetic activity extended over a period of more than 40 years. Dr. G._A. Smith extends it to ‘more than 50" (Jerusalem, II, 180; cf Whitehouse, 'Tsaiah,'' New Cent. Bible, 1, 72). According to the title of his book (1 I), Isaiah prophesied during the reigns of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah, kings of Judah. 6. Period He dates his inaugural vision (6 1) in Uzziah’s death-year, which was approximately 740 BC. This marks, therefore, the beginning of his prophetic ministry. And we know that he was still active as late as the siege of Jerus by Sennacherib in 701 BC. Hence the minimum period of his activity as a prophet was from 740 to 701 BC. Asa young man Isaiah witnessed the rapid development of Judah into a strong commercial and military state; for under Uzaiah Judah at- tained a degree of prosperity and strength never before enjoyed since the days of Solomon. Walls, towers, fortifications, a large standing army, a port for commerce on the Red Sea, increased inland trade, tribute from the Ammonites, success 1n war with the Philis and the Arabians—all these became Judah’s during Uzziah’s long and prosperous reign of 52 years. But along witb power and wealth came also avarice, oppression, religious formality and corruption. The temple revenues indeed were greatly increased, but religion and life were too frequently dissociated; the nation’s progress was altogether material. During the reign of Jotham (740-736 BC), who for several years was probably associated with his father as co-regent, a new power began to appear over the eastern horizon. The Assyrians, with whom Ahab had come in contact at the battle of Karkar in 854 BC, and to whom Jehu had paid tribute in 842 BC, began to manifest anew their characteristic lust of conquest. _Tiglath- pileser III, who is called ‘“‘Pul” in 2 K 15 19 and reigned over Assyria from 745 to 727 BC, turned his attention westward, and in 738 BC reduced Arpad, Calno, Carchemish, Hamath and Damascus, causing them to pay tribute. His presence in the West led Pekah, king of North Israel, and Rezin, king of Damascus, to form an alliance in order to resist further encroachment on the part of Assyria. When Ahaz refused to join their confederacy they resolved to dethrone him and set in his stead the son of Tabeel upon the throne of David (2 K 16 5; Isa 7 6). The struggle which ensued is commonly known as the Syro-Ephraimitic war (734 BC)— one of the great events in Jsaiah’s period. Ahaz in panic sent to Tiglath-pileser for help (2 K 16 7), who of course responded with alacrity. The result was that the great Assyrian warrior sacked Gaza and carried all of Galilee and Gilead into captivity (734) and finally took Damascus (732 BC). Ahaz was forced to pay dearly for his protection and Judah was brought very low (2 K 15 29; 16 7-9; 2 Ch 2819; Isa 71). The religious as well as the political effect of Ahaz’ policy was de- cidedly baneful. To please Tiglath-pileser, Ahaz went to Damascus to join in the celebration of his victories, and while there saw a Syrian altar, a pattern of which he sent to Jerus and had a copy set up in the temple in place of the brazen altar of Solomon. Thus Ahaz, with all the influence of a king, introduced idolatry into Jerus, even causing his sons to pass through the fire (2 K 16 10-16; 2 Ch 28 3). Hezekiah succeeded Ahaz, beginning to rule at the age of 25 and reigning 29 years (727-699 BC). Isaiah was at least 15 years his senior. The young king inherited from his father a heavy burden. The splendor of Uzziah’s and Jotham’s reigns was rapidly fading before the ever-menacing and avari- cious Assyrians. Hezekiah began his reign with reformation. ‘He removed the high places, and brake the pillars, and cut down the Asherah” (2 K 18 4.22). He even invited the surviving remnant of North Israel to join in celebrating the Passover (2 Ch 301). But Israel’s end was drawing near. Hoshea, the vacillating puppet-king of North Israel (730-722 BC), encouraged by Egypt, refused longer to pay Assyria his annual tribute (2 K 17 4); whereupon Shalmaneser IV, who had succeeded Tiglath-pileser, promptly appeared before the gates of Samaria in 724 BC, and for 3 weary years be- sieged the city (2 K_17 5). Finally, the city was captured by Sargon II, who succeeded Shalmaneser IV in 722 BC, and 27,292 of Israel’s choicest people (according to Sargon’s own description) were de- ported to Assyria, and colonists were brought from Babylon and other adjacent districts and placed in the cities of Samaria (2 K 17 6.24). Thus the kingdom of North Israel passed into oblivion, and Judah was left ever after quite exposed to the direct ravages, political and religious, of her Assyrio-Bab neighbors. In fact Judah herself barely escaped destruction by promising heavy tribute. This was the second great, political crisis during Isaiah’s min- istry. Other crises were soon to follow. One was the desperate illness of King Hezekiah, who faced 1497 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah sss assured death in 714 BC. Being childless, he was seriously concerned for the future of the Davidic dynasty. He resorted to prayer, however, and God graciously extended his life 15 years (2 K 20; Isa 38). His illness occurred during the period of Baby- lon’s independence under Merodach-baladan, the ever-ambitious, irresistible and uncompromising enemy of Assyria, who for 12 years (721-709 BC) maintained independent supremacy over Babylon. Taking advantage of Hezekiah’s wonderful cure, Merodach seized the opportunity of sending an embassy to Jerus to congratulate him on his recovery (712 BC), and at the same time probably sought to form an alliance with Judah to resist Assyr su- premacy (2 K 20 12ff; Isa 39). Nothing, how- ever, came of the alliance, for the following year Sargon’s army reappeared in Philistia in order to discipline Ashdod for conspiraey with the king of Egypt (711 BC). The greatest crisis was yet to come. Its story is as follows: Judah and her neighbors groaned more and more under the heavy exactions of Assyria. Accordingly, when Sargon was assassinated and Sennacherib came to the throne in 705 BC, rebellion broke out on all sides. Merodach-baladan, who had been expelled by Sar- gon in 709 BC, again took Babylon and held it for at least six months in 703 BC. Hezekiah, who was encouraged by Egypt and all Philistia, except Padi of Ekron, the puppet-king of Sargon, refused longer to pay Assyria tribute (2 K 18 7). Meanwhile a strong pro-Egyp party had sprung up in Jerus. In view of all these circumstances, Sennacherib in 701 BC marched westward with a vast army, sweeping everything before him. Tyre was in- vested though not taken; on the other hand, Joppa, Eltekeh, Ekron, Ashkelon, Ammon, Moab, and Edom all promptly yielded to his demands. Heze- kiah was panic stricken and hastened to bring rich tribute, stripping even the temple and the palace of their treasures to do so (2 K 18 13-16). But Sennacherib was not satisfied. He overran Judah, capturing, as he tells us in his inscription, 46 walled towns and smaller villages without number, earry- ing 200,150 of Judah’s population into captivity to Assyria, and demanding as tribute 800 talents of silver and 80 talents of gold, in all over $1,500,000; he took also, he claims, Hezekiah’s daughters and palace women, seized his male and female singers, and carried away enormous spoil. But the end was not yet. Sennacherib himself, with the bulk of the army, halted in Philistia to reduce Lachish; thence he sent a strong detachment under his com- mander-in-chief, the Rabshakeh, to besiege Jerus (2 K 18 17—19 8; Isa 36 2—37 8). As he de- scribes this blockade in his own inscription: “I shut up Hezekiah in Jerus like a bird in a cage.” The Rabshakeb, however, failed to capture the city and returned to Sennacherib, who meanwhile had completely conquered Lachish, and was now warring against Libnah. A second expedition against Jerus was planned, but hearing that Tirhakah (at that time the commander-in-chief of Egypt’s forces and only afterward “king of Ethiopia”) was ap- proaching, Sennacherib was forced to content him- self with sending messengers with a letter to Heze- kiah, demanding immediate surrender of the city (2K 19 Off; Isa 37 9ff). Hezekiah, however, through Isaiah’s influence held out; and in due time, though Sennacherib disposed of Tirhakah’s army without difficulty, his immense host in some mysterious way—by plague or otherwise—was suddenly smitten, and the great Assyr conqueror was forced to return to Nineveh; possibly because Merodach-baladan had again appeared in Baby- lonia. Sennacherib never again returned to Pal, so far as we know, during the subsequent 20 years of his reign, though he did make an independent expedition into North Arabia (691-689 BC). This. invasion of Judah by Sennacherib in 701 BC was the great political event in Isaiah’s ministry. Had it not been for the prophet’s statesmanship, Jcrus might have capitulated. As it was, only a small, insignificantly small, remnant of Judah’s popula- tion escaped. Isaiah had at this time been preach- ing 40 years. How much longer he labored is not known. There are six general divisions of the book: (1) chs 1-12, propheeies concerning Judah and Jerus, closing with promises of restoration 7. Analysis and a psalm of thanksgiving; (2) chs and 13-23, oracles of judgment and salva- Contents tion, for the most part concerning those foreign nations whose fortunes affected Judah and Jerus; (3) chs 24-27, Jeh’s world- judgment in the redemption of Israel; (4) chs 28- 36, a cycle of prophetic warnings against alliance with Egypt, closing with a prophecy concerning Edom and a promise of Israel’s ransom; (5) chs 36-39, history, prophecy and song intermingled; serving both as an appendix to chs 1-35, and as an introduction to chs 40-66; (6) chs 40-66, prophecies of comfort and salvation, and also of the future glory awaiting Israel. By examining in detail these several divisions we can trace better the prophet’s thought. Thus, chs 1-12 unfold Judah’s social sins (chs 1-6), and her political entanglements (chs 7-12); ch 1 is an introduction, in which the prophet strikes the chief notes of his entire book: viz. thoughtlessness (vs 2-9), formalism in worship (vs 10-17), pardon (vs 18~28) and judgment (vs 24-31). Chs 2-4 contain three distinct pictures of Zion: (@) her exaltation (2 2-4), (6) her present idolatry (2 5—4 1), and (c) her eventual purification (4 2-6). Ch 6 con- tains an arraignment of Judah and Jerus, composed of three parts: (a) a parable of Jeh’s vineyard (vs 1-7); (6) a series of six woes pronounced against insatiable greed (vs 8-10), dissipation (vs 11-17), daring defiance against Jeh (vs 18.19), confusion of moral distinctions (ver 20), political self-conceit (ver 21), and misdirected heroism (vs 22.23); and (c) an announcement of imminent judgment. The Assyrian is on the way and there will be no escape (vs 24-30). Ch 6 recounts the prophet’s inaugural vision and commission. It is really an apologetic, standing as it does after the prophet’s denunciations of his contemporaries. When they tacitly object to his message of threatening and disaster, he is able to reply that, having prononnced “woe” upon himself in the year that Kmg Uzziah died, he had the authority to pena woe upon them (6 5). Plainly Isaiah tells them that Judah’s sins are well- nigh hopeless. They are becoming spiritually in- sensible. They have eyes but they cannot see. Only judgment can avail: “the righteous judgment of a forgotten God” awaits them. A “holy seed,” however, still existed in Israel’s stock (6 18). Coming to chs 7-12, Isaiah appears in the réle of a practical statesman. He warns Ahaz against political entanglements with Assyria. The section 7 1—9 7 is a prophecy of Immanuel, history and prediction being intermingled. They describe the Syro-Ephraimitic uprising in 736 BO, when Pekah of North [Israel and Rezin of Damascus, in attempting to defend themselves against the Assyr- jans, demanded that Ahaz of Jerus should become their ally. But Ahaz preferred the friendship of Assyria, and refused to enter into alliance with them. And in order to defend himself, he applied to Assyria for assist- ance, sending ambassadors with many precious treasures, both royal and sacred, to bribe Tiglath-pileser. It was at this juncture that Isaiah, at Jeh's bidding, expostulates with Ahaz concerning the fatal step he is about to take, and as @ practical statesman warns Ahaz, ‘the king of No-Faith,"’ that the only path of safety lies in loyalty to Jeh and keeping clear of foreign alliances; that ‘‘ God is with us" for salvation; and that no ‘‘conspiracy" can Isaiah ossibly be successful unless God too is against us. hen, however, the prophet’s message of promise and salvation finds no welcome, he commits it to his disciples, bound up and sealed for future use; assuring his hearers that unto them a child is horn and unto them a son is iven, in whose day the empire of David will be estah- shed upon a basis of justice and righteousness. The Messianic scion is the ground of the prophet’s hope; which hope, though unprecedented, he thus early in his ministry commits, written and sealed, to his inner circle of ‘‘disciples."" See, further, ImmaNnvuEL. The section 9 8—10 4 contains an announcement to North Israel of accumulated wrath and impend- ing ruin, with a refrain (9 12.17.21; 10 4). Here, in an artistic poem composed of four strophes, the prophet describes the great calamities which Jeh has sent down upon North Israel but which have gone unheeded: foreign invasion (9 8-12), defeat in battle (9 13-17), anarchy (9 18-21), andimpend- ing captivity (10 1-4). Yet Jeh’s judgments have gone unheeded: ‘‘For all this his anger is not turned away, but his hand is stretched out still.’ Divine discipline has failed; only judgment remains. In 10 5-34, Assyria is declared to be an instru- ment of Jeh, the rod of Jeh’s anger. Chs 11-12 predict Israel’s return from exile, including a vision of the Messiah’s reign of ideal peace. For Isaiah’s vision of the nation’s future reached far beyond mere exile. To him the downfall of Assyria was the signal for the comméncement of a new era in Israel’s history. Assyria has no future, her downfall is fatal; Judah has a future, her calamities are only disciplinary. An Ideal Prince will be raised up in whose advent all Nature will rejoice, even dumb animals (11 1-10). A second great exodus will take place, for the Lord will set His hand again ‘‘the second time’ to recover the remnant of His people ‘from the four corners of the earth” (11 11.12). In that day, ‘Ephraim shall not envy Judah, and Judah shall not vex Ephraim” (11 13). On the contrary, the reunited nation, redeemed and occu- pying their rightful territory (11 14-16), shall sing a hymn of thanksgiving, proclaiming the salvation of Jeh to all the earth (ch 12). Chs 13-23 contain oracles of judgment and sal- vation, for the most part concerning those foreign nations whose fortunes affected Judah and Jerus. They are grouped together by the editor, as similar foreign oracles are in Jer 46-51 and Ezk 25-32. Isaiah’s horizon was world-wide. First among the foreign prophecies stands the oracle concerning Babylon (18 1—14 23), in which he predicts the utter destruction of the city (13 2-22), and sings a dirge or taunt-song over her fallen king (14 4-23). The king alluded to is almost beyond doubt an Assyr (not a Bab) monarch of the 8th cent.; the brief prophecy immediately following in 14 24-27 concerning Assyria tacitly confirms this interpre- tation. Another brief oracle concerning Babylon (21 1-10) describes the city’s fall as imminent. Both oracles stand or fall together as genuine prophecies of Isaiah. Both seem to have been written in Jerus (13 2; 21 9.10). It cannot be said that either is absolutely unrelated in thought and language to ‘Isaiah’s age (14 13; 21 2); each foretells the doom t® fall on Babylon (13 19; 21 9) at the hands of the Medes (18 17; 21 2); and each describes the Israclite§ as already in exile—but not necessarily ail Israel. : The section 14 24-27 tells of the certain de- struction of the Assyrian. ; The passage 14 28-32 is an oracle concerning Philistia. Chs 15-16 are ancient oracles against Moab, whose dirgelike meter resembles that of chs 13-14. It is composed of two separate prophecies belong- ing to two different periods in Isaiah’s ministry (16 13.14). The three points of particular interest in the oracle are: (1) the prophet’s tender sym- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1498 pathy for Moab in her affliction (15 5; 16 11). Isaiah mingles his own tears with those of the Moab- ites. As Delitzsch says, “There is no prophecy in the Book of Isa in which the heart of the prophet is so painfully moved by what his spirit beholds and his mouth must prophecy.” (2) Moab’s pa- thetic appeal for shelter from her foes; particularly the ground on which she urges it, namely, the Mes- sianic hope that the Davidic dynasty shall always stand and be able to repulse its foes (16 5). The prophecy is an echo of 9 5-7. (3) The promise that a remnant of Moab, though small, shall be saved (16 14). Wearied of prayer to Chemosh in his high places, the prophet predicts that Moab will seek the living God (16 12). : The passage 17 1-11 is an oracle concerning Damascus and North Israel, in which Isaiah predicts the fate of the two allies—Syria and Ephraim—in the Syro-Ephraimitic war of 734 BC, with a promise that only a scanty remnant will survive (17 6). In 17 12-14, the prophet boldly announces the com- plete annihilation of Judah’s unnamed foes—the Assyrians. ; Ch 18 describes Ethiopia as in great excitement, sending ambassadors hither and thither—possibly all the way to Jerus—ostensibly seeking aid in making preparations for war. Assyria had already taken Demeecns (732 BC) and Samaria (722 BC), and consequently Egypt and Ethiopia were in fear of invasion. Isaiah bids the ambassadors to return home and quietly watch Jeh thwart Assyria’s self- confident attempt to subjugate Judah; and he adds that when the Ethiopians have seen God's hand in the coming deliverance of Judah and Jerus (701 BOC), they will bring a present to Jeh to His abode in Mount Zion. Ch 19, which is an oracle concerning Egypt, con- tains both a threat (vs 1-17) and a promise (vs 18- 25), and is one of Isaiah’s most remarkable foreign messages. Egypt is smitten and thereby led to abandon her idols for the worship of Jeh (vs 19-22). Still more remarkable, it is prophesied that in that day Egypt and Assyria will join with Judah in a triple alliance of common worship to Jeh and of blessing to others (vs 23-25). Isaiah’s missionary outlook here is wonderful! Ch 20 describes Sargon’s march against Egypt and Ethiopia, containing a brief symbolic prediction of Assyria’s victory over Egypt and Ethiopia. By donning a captive’s garb for three years, Isaiah attempts to teach the citizens of Jerus that the siege of Ashdod was but a means to an end in Sar- gon’s plan of campaign, and that it was sheer folly for the Egyp party in Jerus, who were ever urging reliance upon Egypt, to look in that direction for help. 21 11.12 is a brief oracle concerning Seir or Edom, ‘the only gentle utterance in the OT upon Israel’s hereditary foe.” Edom is in great anxiety. The prophet’s answer is disappointing, though its tone is sympathetic. 21 13 ff is a brief oracle con- cerning Arabia. It contains a sympathetic appeal to the Temanites to give bread and water to the caravans of Dedan, who have been driven by war from their usual route of travel. Ch 22 is concerning the foreign temper within the theocracy. It is composed of two parts: (1) an oracle “of the valley of vision,” i.e. Jerus (vs 1-14); and (2) a philippic against Shebna, the comptroller of the palace. Isaiah pauses, as it were, in his series of warnings to foreign nations +o rebuke the foreign temper of the frivolous inhabit- ants of Jerus, and in particular Shebna, a high official in the government. The reckless and God- ignoring citizens of the capital are pictured as in- dulging themselves in hilarious eating and drinking, when the enemy is at that very moment standing before the gates of the city. Shebna, on the other 1499 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah ‘hand, seems to have been an ostentatious foreigner, perhaps a Syrian by birth, quite possibly one of the Egyp party, whose policy was antagonistic to that of Isaiah and the king. Isaiah’s prediction of Shebna’s fall was evidently fulfilled (36 3; 37 2). Ch 23 is concerning Tyre. In this oracle Isaiah predicts that Tyre shall be laid waste (ver 1), her commercial glory humbled (ver 9), her colonies become independent of her (ver 10), and she herself forgotten for “seventy years” (ver 15); but “after the end of seventy years,” her trade will revive, her business prosperity will return, and she will dedi- cate her gains in merchandise as holy to Jeh (ver 18). The third great section of the Book of Isa em- braces chs 24-27, which tell of Jeh’s world-judgment, issuing in the redemption of Israel. These prophe- cies stand closely related to chs 18-23. They ex- press the same tender emotion as that already observed in 15 5; 16 11, and sum up as in one grand finale the prophet’s oracles to Israel’s neigh- bors. For religious importance they stand second to none in the Book of Isa, teaching the necessity ef Divine discipline and the glorious redemption awaiting the faithful in Israel. They are a spiritual commentary on the great Assyr crisis of the 8th cent.; they are messages of salvation intended, not for declamation, but for meditation, and were prob- ably addressed more particularly to the prophet’s inner circle of ‘disciples’ (8 16). These chapters partake of the nature of apocalypse. Strictly speaking, however, they are prophecy, not_apoca- lypse. No one ascends into heaven or talks with an angel, as in Dn!l 7 and Rev 4. They are apocalypse only in the sense that certain things are predicted as sure to come to pass. Isaiah was fond of this kind of prophecy. He frequently lifts his reader out of the sphere of mere history to paint pictures of the far-off, distant future (2 2-4; 42-6; 11 6-16; 30 27-33). In ch 24 the prophet announces a general judg- ment of the earth (i.e. the land of Judah), and of “the city” (collective, for Judah’s towns), after which will dawn a better day (vs 1-15). The prophet fancies he hears songs of deliverance, but alas! they are premature; more judgment must follow. In ch 25 the prophet transports himself to the period after the Assyr catastrophe and, identifying himself with the redeemed, puts into their mouths songs of praise and thanksgiving for their deliverance. Ws 6-8 describe Jeh’s bountiful banquet on Mount Zion to all nations, who, in keeping with 2 2-4, come up to Jerus, to celebrate “a, feast of fat things,’ rich and marrowy. While the people are present at the banquet, Jeh gra- ciously removes their spiritual blindness so that they behold Him as the true dispenser of life and grace. He also abolishes violent death, that is to say, war (cf 2 4), and its sad accompaniment, “tears,”’ so that “the earth” (i.e. the land of Judah) is no longer the battlefield of the nations, but the blessed abode of the redeemed, living in peace and happiness. The prophet’s aim is not political but religious. In 26 1-19 Judah sings a song over Jerus, the impregnable city of God. The prophet, taking again his stand with the redeemed remnant of the nation, vividly portrays their thankful trust in Jeh, who has been unto them a veritable “Rock of Ages” (ver 4m). With hope he joyfully exclaims, Let Jeh’s dead ones live! Let Israel’s dead bodies arise! Jeh will bring life from the dead! (ver 19). This is the first clear statement of the resurrection in the OT. But it is national and restricted to Israel (cf ver 14), and is merely Isaiah’s method of expressing a hope of the return of Israel’s faithful ones from captivity (cf Hos 6 2; Ezk 37 1-14; Dnl 12 2). In 26 20—27 13 the prophet shows that Israel’s chastisements are salutary. He begins by exhort- ing his own people, his disciples, to continue a little longer in the solitude of prayer, till God’s wrath has shattered the world-powers (26 20—27 1). He next predicts that the true vineyard of Jeh will henceforth be safely guarded against the briars and thorns of foreign invasion (27 2-6). And then, after showing that Jeh’s chastisements of Israel were light compared with His judgments upon other nations (27 7~11), he promises that if Israel will only repent, Jeh will spare no pains to gather “one by one” the remnant of His people from Assyria and Egypt (cf 11 11); and together they shall once more worship Jeh in the holy mountain at Jerus (27 12.13). The prophet’s fundamental standpoint in chs 24-27 is the same as that of 2 2-4 and chs 13-238. Yet the prophet not infrequently throws himself forward into the remote future, oscillating back- ward and forward between his own times and those of Israel’s restoration. It is esp. noteworthy how he sustains himself in a long and continued trans- portation of himself to the period of Israel’s redemp- tion. He even studies to Jdentify himself with the new Israel which will emerge out of the present chaos of political events. His visions of Israel’s redemption carry him in ecstasy far away into the remote future, to a time when the nation’s suffer- ings are all over; so that when he writes down what he saw in vision he describes it as a discipline that is past. For example, in 25 1-8 the prophet, trans- ported to the end of time, celebrates in song what he saw, and describes how the fall of the world- empire is followed by the conversion of the heathen. In 26 8.9he looks back into the past from the stand- point of the redeemed in the last days, and tells how Israel longingly waited for the manifestation of God’s righteousness which has now taken place, while in 27 7~9 he places himself in the midst of the nation’s sufferings, in full view of their glorious future, and portrays how Jeh’s dealings with Israel have not been the punishment of wrath, but the discipline of love. This kind of apocalypse, or popes, indeed, was to be expected from the very eginning of the group of prophecies, which are introduced with the word “Behold!” Such a man- ner of introduction is peculiar to Isaiah, and of itself leads us to expect a message which is unique. The practical religious value of these prophecies to Isaiah’s own age would be very great. In a eriod of war and repeated foreign mvasion, when Bu few men were left in the land (24 6.13; 26 18), and Judah’s cities were laid waste and desolate (24 10.12; 25 2; 26 5; 27 10), and music and gladness were wanting (24 8), when the nation still clung to their idols (27 9) and the Assyrians’ work of destruction was still incomplete, other calami- ties being sure to follow (24 16), it would certainly be comforting to know that forgiveness was still possible (27 9), that Jeh was still the keeper of His vineyard (27 3.4), that His judgments were to last but for a little moment (26 20), and that though His people should be scattered, He would soon care- fully gather them “‘one by one” (27 12.13), and that in company with other nations they would feast together on Mt. Zion as Jeh’s guests (26 6. 7.10), and that Jerus should henceforth become the center of life and religion to all nations (24 23; 25 6; 27 13). Such faith in Jeh, such exhortations and such songs and confessions of the redeemed, seen in vision, would be a source of rich spiritual comfort to the few suffering saints in Judah and Jerus, and a guiding star to the faithful disciples of the prophet’s most inner circle. Chs 28-35 contain a cycle of prophetic warnings against alliance with Egypt, closing with a prophecy Isaiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1500 concerning Edom and a promise of Israel’s ransom. As in 5 8-23, the prophet indulges in a series of six woes: (1) Woe to drunken, scoffing politicians (ch 28). This is one of the great chapters of Isaiah’s book. In the opening section (vs 1-6) the prophet points in warning to the proud drunkards of Ephraim whose crown (Samaria) is rapidly fading. He next turns to the scoffing politicians of Jerus, rebuking esp. the bibulous priests who stumble in judgment, and the staggering prophets who err in vision (vs 7-22); closing with a most instructive parable from agriculture, teaching that God’s judgments are not arbitrary; that as the husbandman does not plow and harrow his fields the whole year round, so God will not punish His people forever; and as the husbandman does not thresh all kinds of grain with equal severity, no more will God discipline His people beyond their deserts (vs 23-29). (2) Woe ‘to formalists in religion (29 1-14). Isaiah’s second woe is pronounced upon Ariel, the altar-hearth of God, i.e. Jerus, the sacrificial center of Israel’s worship. David had first inaugurated the true worship of Jeh in Zion. But now Zion’s. worship has become wholly conventional, formal, and therefore insincere; it is learned by rote (ver 13; cf 110-15; Mic 6 6-8). Therefore, says Isaiah, Jeh is forced to do an extraordinary work among them, in order to bring them back to a true knowledge of Himself (ver 14). (8) Woe to those who hide their plans from God (29 15-24). What their plans are, which they are devising in secret, the prophet does not yet disclose; but he doubtless alludes to their intrigues with the Egyptians and their purpose to break faith with the Assyrians, to whom they were bound hy treaty to pay annual tribute. Isaiah bravely remonstrates with them for supposing that any policy will suc- ceed which excludes the counsel and wisdom of the Holy One. They are but clay; He is the potter. At this point, though somewhat abruptly, Isaiah turns his face toward the Messianic future. In a very little while, he says, Lebanon, which is now overrun by Assyria’s army, shall become a fruitful field, and the blind and deaf and spiritually weak shall rejoice in the Holy One of Israel. (4) Woe to the pro-Egyp party (ch 30). Isaiah’s fourth woe is directed against the rebellious poli- ticians who stubhornly, and now openly, advocate making a league with Egypt. They have at length succeeded apparently iu winning over the king to their side, and an embassy is already on its way to Egypt, bearing across the desert of the exodus rich treasures with which to purchase the friendship of their formeroppressors. Isaiah now condemns what he can no longer prevent. Egypt is a Rahab “sit- still,” i.e. a mythological sea-monster, menacing in mien but laggard in action. When the crisis comes, she will sit still, causing Israel only shame and confusion. (5) Woe to those who trust in horses and chariots (chs 31-32). Isaiah’s fifth woe is a still more vehement denunciation of thase who trust in Egypt’s horses and chariots, and disregard the Holy One of Israel. Those who do so forget that the Egyp- tians are but men and their horses flesh, and that mere flesh cannot avail in a conflict with spirit. Eventually Jeh means to deliver Jerus, if the chil- dren of Israel will but turn from their idolatries to Him; and in that day, Assyria will be vanquished. A new era will dawn upon Judah. Society will be regenerated. The renovation will begin at the top. Conscience also will be sharpened, and moral distinctions will no longer be confused (32 1-8). As Delitzsch puts it, ‘“The aristocracy of birth and wealth will be replaced by an aristocracy of char- acter.”’ The careless and indifferent women, too, in that day will no longer menace the social welfare of the state (32 9-14); with the outpouring of Jeh’s spirit an ideal commonwealth will emerge, in which social righteousness, peace, plenty and security will abound (32 15-20). } (6) Woe to the Assyr destroyer (ch 33). Isaiah’s last woe is directed against the treacherous spoiler himself, who has already laid waste the cities of Judah, and is now beginning to lay siege to Jerus (701 BC). The prophet prays, and while he prays, behold! the mighty hosts of the Assyrians are routed aud the long-besieged but now triumphant inhabit- ants of Jerus rush out like locusts upon the spoil which the vanishing adversary has been forced to leave behind. The destroyer’s plan to reduce Jerus has come to naught. The whole earth beholds the spectacle of Assyria’s defeat and. is filled with awe and amazement at the mighty work of Jeh. Only the righteous may henceforth dwell in Jerus. Their eyes shall behold the Messiah-king in his beauty, reigning no longer like Hezekiah over a limited and restricted territory, but over a land unbounded, whose inhabitants enjoy Jeh’s peace and protection, and are free from all sin, and there- fore from all sickness (vs 17-24). With this beau- tiful picture of the Messianic future, the prophet’s woes find an appropriate conclusion. Isaiah never pronounced a woe without adding a corresponding promise. In chs 34-36, the prophet utters a fierce cry for justice against “all the nations,” but against Edom in particular. Histone is that of judgment. Edom is guilty of high crimes against Zion (84 8 f), there- fore she is doomed to destruction. On the other hand, the scattered ones of Israel shall return from exile and “obtain gladness and joy, and sorrow and sighing shall flee away” (ch 35). Chs 36-39 contain history, prophecy and song intermingled. These chapters serve both as an appendix to chs 1-35 and as an introduction to chs 40-66. In them three important historical events are narrated, in which Isaiah was a prominent factor: (1) thedouble attempt of Sennacherib to ob- tain possession of Jerus (chs 36-37); (2) Hezekiah’s sickness and recovery (ch 38); (8) the embassy of Merodach-baladan (ch 89). With certain im- portant omissions and insertions these chapters are duplicated almost verbatim in 2 K 18 18— 20 19. They are introduced with the chronological note, “Now it came to pass in the fourteenth year of king Hezekiah.” Various attempts have been made to solve the mystery of this date; for, if the author is alluding to the siege of 701 BC, difficulty arises, because that event occurred not in Heze- kiah’s “14th” but 26th year, according to the Bib. chronology of his life; or, if with some we date ‘Hezekiah’s accession to the throne of Judah as 720 BC, then the siege of 701 BC occurred, as is evi- dent, in Hezekiah’s 19th year. It is barely possible of course that “the 14th year of king Hezekiah’’ was the 14th of the “15 years” which were added to his life, but more probably it alludes to the 14th of his reign. On the whole it is better to take the phrase as a general chronological caption for the entire section, with special reference to ch 38, which tells of Hezekiah’s sickness, which actually fell in his 14th year (714 BC), and which, coupled with Sargon’s expected presence at Ashdod, was the great personal crisis of the king’s life. Sennacherib made two attempts in 701 BC to reduce Jerus: one from Lachish with an army headed by the Rabshakeh (836 2—37 8), and an- other from Libnah with a threat conveyed by mes- sengers (37 9ff). The brief section contained in 2 K 18 14-16 is omitted from between vs 1 and 2 of Isa 36, because it was not the prophet’s aim at this time to recount the nation’s humiliation. 1501 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah Isaiah’s last “word” concerning Assyria (87 21-35) is one of the prophet’s grandest predictions. It is composed of three parts: (1) a taunt-song, in ele- giac rhythm, on the inevitable humiliation of Sen- nacherib (vs 22-29); (2) a short poem in different rhythm, directed to Hezekiah, in order to encourage his faith (vs 30-32); (3) a definite prediction, in less elevated style, of the sure deliverance of Jerus (vs 33-35). Isaiah’s prediction was literally fulfilled. The section 38 9-20 contains Hezekiah’s Song of Thanksgiving, in which he celebrates his re- covery from some mortal sickness. It is a beautiful plaintive “writing”; omitted altogether by the author of the Book of K (cf 2 K 20). Hezekiah was sick in 714 BC. Two years later Merodach- baladan, the veteran arch-enemy of Assyria, having heard of his wonderful recovery, sent letters and a present to congratulate him. Doubtless, also, olitical motives prompted the recalcitrant Baby- onian. But be that asit may, Hezekiah was greatly flattered by the visit of Merodach-baladan’s en- voys, and, in a moment of weakness, showed them all his royal treasures. This was an inexcusable blunder, as the sight of his many precious posses- sions would naturally excite Bab cupidity to possess Jerus. Isaiah not only solemnly condemned the king’s conduct, but he announced with more than ordinary insight that the days were coming when all the accumulated resources of Jerus would be carried away to Babylon (89 3-6; cf Mic 4 10). This final prediction of judgment is the most mar- velous of all Isaiah’s minatory utterances, because he distinctly asserts that, not the Assyrians, who were then at the height of their power, but the Babylonians, shall be the instruments of the Divine vengeance in consummating the destruction of Jerus. There is absolutely no reason for doubting the genuineness of this prediction. In it, indeed, we have a prophetic basis for chs 40-66, which follow. Coming now to chs 40-66, we have prophecies of comfort, salvation, and of the future glory await- ing Israel. These chapters naturally fall into three sections: (1) chs 40-48, announcimg deliverance from captivity through Cyrus; (2) chs 49-57, de- scribing the sufferings of the “Servant” of Jeh, this section ending like the former with the retrain, “There is no peace, saith my God, to the wicked” (57 21; cf 48 22); (3) chs 58-66, announcing the final abolition of all national distinctions and the future glory of the people of God. Ch 60 is the characteristic chapter of this section, as ch 53 is of the second, and ch 40 of the first. Entering into greater detail, the first section (chs 40-48) demonstrates the deity of Jeh through His unique power to predict. The basis of the comfort which the prophet announces is Israel’s incomparable God (ch 40). Israel’s all-powerful Jeh in comparison with other gods is incomparable. In the prologue (40 1-11) he hears the four voices: (1) of grace (vs 1.2); (2) of prophecy (vs 3-5); (3) of faith (vs 6-8), and (4) of evangelism (vs 9-11). Then, after exalting the unique character of Israel’s all-but-forgotten God (vs 12-26), he exhorts them not to suppose that Jeh is ignorant of, or indiffer- ent to, Israel’s misery. Israel must wait for sal- vation. They are clamoring for deliverance pre- maturely. Only wait, he repeats; for with such a God, Israel has no reason to despond (vs 27-31). In ch 41 he declares that the supreme proof of Jeh’s sole deity is His power to predict. He in- quires, “Who hath raised up one from the east?” Though the hero is left unnamed, Cyrus is doubt- less in the prophet’s mind (cf 44 28; 45 1). He isnot, however, already appearing upon the horizon of history as some fancy, but rather predicted as sure to come. The verb tenses which express com- pleted action are perfects of certainty, and are used in precisely the same manner as those in 3 8; 6 13; 21 9. The answer to the inquiry is, “I, Jeh, the first, and with the last, I am he” (41 4). Israel is Jeh’s servant. The dialogue continues; but it is no longer between Jeh and the nations, as in vs 1-7, but between Jeh and the idols (vs 21-29). Ad- dressing the dumb idols, Jeh is represented as saying, Predict something, if you are real deities. As for myself, I am going to raise up a hero from the north who will subdue all who oppose him. And I an- nounce my purpose now in advance “from the be- ginning,” “beforetime,” before there is the slightest ground for thinking that such a hero exists or ever will exist. (ver 26), in order that the future may verify my prediction, and prove my sole deity. I, Jeh, alone know the future. In vs 25-29, the prophet even projects himself into the future and speaks from the standpoint of the fulfilment of his prediction. This, as we saw above, was a char- acteristic of Isaiah in chs 24-27. In 42 1—43 13 the prophet announces also a spiritual agent of redemption, namely, Jeh’s ‘Serv- ant.” Not only a temporal agent (Cyrus) shall be raised up to mediate Israel’s redemption, which is the first step in the process of the universal sal- vation contemplated, but a spiritual factor. Jeh’s “Servant” shall be employed in bringing the good tidings of salvation to the exiles and to the Gentiles also. In 42 1-9 the prophet describes this ideal figure and the work he will execute. The glorious future evokes a brief hymn of thanksgiving for the redemption which the prophet beholds in prospect (42 10-17). Israel has long been blind and deaf to Jeh’s instructions (42 18.19), but now Jeh is determined to redeem them even at the cost of the most opulent nations of the world, that they may publish His law to all peoples (42 18—43 13). In 18 1444 23 forgiveness is made the pledge of deliverance. Jeh’s determination to redeem Israel is all of grace. Salvation is a gift. Jeh has blotted out their transgressions for His own sake (43 25). “This passage,’ Dillmann observes, ‘marks the highest point of grace in the OT.” Gods of wood and stone are nonentities. Those who manufacture idols are blind and dull of heart, and are “feeding on ashes.” The section 44 9-20is a most remorseless exposure of the folly of idolatry. In 44 24—45 25 the prophet at length names the hero of Israel’s salvation and describes his mission. He is Cyrus. He shall build Jerus and lay the foundations of the temple (44 28); he shall also subdue nations aud let the exiles go free (45 1.13). He speaks of Cyrus in the most extraordinary, almost extravagant terms. He is Jeh’s “shepherd’ (44 28), he is also Jeh’s “‘anointed,”’ ie. Messiah (45 1), “the man of my counsel” (46 11), whom Jeh has called by name, and surnamed without his ever knowing Him (45 3.4); the one “whom Jeh loveth” (48 14), whose right hand Jeh upholdeth (45 1), and who will perform all Jeh’s pleasure (44 28); though but “a ravenous bird from the east”? (46 11). The vividness with which the prophet speaks of Cyrus leads some to suppose that the latter is already upon the horizon. This, how- ever, isa mistake. Scarcely would a contemporary have spoken iu such terms of the real Cyrus of 538 BC. The prophet regards him (i.e. the Cyrus of his own prediction, not the Cyrus of history) as the fulfilment of predictions spoken long before. That is to say, in one and the same context, Cyrus is both predicted and treated as a proof that pre- diction is being fulfilled (44 24-28; 45 21). Such a phenomenon in prophecy can best be explained by supposing that the prophet projected himself into the future from an earlier age. Most ex- traordinary of all, in 45 14-17, the prophet soars in imagination until he sees, as a result of Cyrus’ Isaiah victories, the conquered nations renouncing their idols, and attracted to Jeh as the Saviour of all man- kind (45 22). On any theory of origin, the predictive element in these prophecies is written large. Chs 46-47 describe further the distinctive work of Cyrus, though Cyrus himself is but once referred to. Particular emphasis is laid on the complete collapse of the Bab religion; the prophet heing apparently more concerned with the humiliation of Babylon’s idols than with the fall of the city itself. Of course the destruction of the city would imply the defeat of her gods, as also the emancipation of Israel. But here again all is in the future; in fact Jeh’s incomparable superiority and unique deity are proven by His power to predict “the end from the beginning” and bring His prediction to pass (46 10.11). Ch 47 is a dirge over the downfall of the imperial city, strongly resembling the taunt-song over the king of Babylon in 14 4-21. Ch 48 is a hortatory summary and recapitulation of the argument contained in chs 40-47, the prophet again emphasizing the following points: (1) Jeh’s unique power to predict; (2) that salvation is of grace; (3) that Cyrus’ advent will be the crowning proof of Jeh’s abiding presence among His people; (4) that God’s chastisements were only disciplinary; and (5) that even now there is hope, if they will but accept of Jeh’s proffered salvation. Alas! that there is no peace or salvation for the godless (48 20-22). Thus ends the first division of Isaiah’s remarkable ‘‘vision” of Israel’s deliverance from captivity through Cyrus. The second section (chs 49-67) deals with the spiritual agent of salvation, Jeh’s suffering ‘‘Serv- ant.” With ch 49 the prophet leaves off attempt- ing further to prove the sole deity of Jeh by means of prediction, and drops entirely his descrip- tion of Cyrus’ victories and the overthrow of Baby- lon, in order to set forth in greater detail the charac- ter and mission of the suffering “Servant” of Jeh. Already, in chs 40-48, he had alluded several times to this unique and somewhat enigmatical personage, speaking of him both collectively and as an indi- vidual (41 8-10; 42 1-9.18-22; 43 10; 44 1-5. 21-28; 45 4; 48 20-22); but now he defines with greater precision both his prophetic and priestly functions, his equipment for his task, his sufferings and humiliation, and also his final exaltation. Alto- gether in these prophecies he mentions the “Serv- ant” some 20 t. But there are four distinctively “so-called ‘“Servant-Songs” in which the prophet seems to rise above the collective masses of all Israel to at least a personification of the pious within Israel, or better, to a unique Person embodying within himself all that is best in the Israel within Isracl. They are the following: (1) 42 1-9, a poem descriptive of the Servant’s gentle manner and world-wide mission; (2) 49 1-13, describing the Servant’s mission and spiritual success; (3) 50 4-11, the Servant’s soliloquy concerning His perfection through suffering; and (4) 52 183—53 12, the Serv- ant’s vicarious suffering and ultimate exaltation. In this last of the four ‘Servant-Songs’’ we reach the climax of the prophet’s inspired symphony, the acme of Heb Messianic hope. The profoundest thoughts in the OT revelation are to be found in thissection. Itis a vindication of the “Servant,” so clear and so true, and wrought out with such pathos and potency, that it holds first place among Mes- sianic predictions. Polycarp called it “the golden passional of the OT.” It has been realized in Jesus Christ. Chs 58-66 describe the future glory of the people of God. Having described in chs 40-48 the tem- poral agent of Israel’s salvation, Cyrus, and in chs 49-67 the spiritual agent of their salvation, the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1502 “Servant” of Jeh, the prophet proceeds in this last section to define the conditions on which salvation may be enjoyed. He begins, as before, with a gels imperative, “Cry aloud, spare not’’ (cf 40 1; 9 1). In ch 58 he discusses true fasting and faithful Sabbath observance. aes In ch 59 he beseeches Israel to forsake their sins. It is their sins, he urges, which have hidden Jeh’s face and retarded the nation’s salvation. In vs 9ff the prophet identifies himself with the people and leads them in their devotions. Jeh is grieved over Israel’s forlorn condition, and, seeing their helplessness, He arms himself like a warrior to interfere judicially (vs 15-19). Israel shall be redeemed. With them as the nucleus of a new na-~ tion, Jeh will enter anew into covenant relation, and put His Spirit upon them, which will abide with them henceforth and forever (vs 20-21). ; Chs 60-61 describe the future blessedness of Zion. The long-looked-for “light”? (cf 59 9) begins to dawn: ‘Arise, shine; for thy light is come, and the glory of Jeh is risen upon thee’ (60 1). The prophet pauses at this point to paint a picture of the redeemed community. Asin 2 3.4, the Gentiles are seen flocking to Zion, which becomes the mis- tress of the nations. Foreigners build her walls, and her gates are kept open continually without fear of siege. The Gentiles acknowledge that Zion is the spiritual center of the world. Even Israel’s oppressors regard her as “‘the city of Jeh,” as “an eternal excellency,”’ in which Jeh sits as its ever- lasting light (60 10-22). In ch 61, which Drummond has called “the pro- gram of Christianity,” the “Servant” of Jeh is again introduced, though anonymously, as the herald of salvation (vs 1-3). The gospel monologue of the “Servant” is followed by a promise of the restora- tion and blessedness of Jerus (vs 4-11). Thus the prophecy moves steadily forward toward its goal _in Jesus Christ (cf Lk 4 18-21). In 62 1—63 6 Zion’s salvation is described as drawing near. The nations will be spectators of the great event. A new name which will better symbolize her true character shall be given to Zion, namely, Hephzi-bah, ‘“My delight is in her’; for Jerus shall no more be called desolate. On the other hand, Zion’s enemies will all be vanquished. In a brief poem of peculiar dramatic beauty (63 1-6), the prophet portrays Jeh’s vengeance, as a victorious warrior, upon all those who retard Israel’s deliverance. Edom in particular was Israel’s in- satiate foe. Hence the prophet represents Jeh’s judgment of the nations as taking place on Edom’s unhallowed soil. Jeh, whose mighty arm has wrought salvation, returns as victor, having slain all of Israel’s foes. In 63 7—64 12, Jeh’s “‘servants” resort to prayer. They appeal to Jeh as the Begetter and Father of the nations (63 16; 64 8). With this thought of the fatherhood of God imbedded in his language, Isaiah had opened his very first oracle to Judah and Jerus (cf 1 2). As the prayer proceeds, the lan- guage becomes increasingly tumultuous. The people are thrown into despair because Jeh seems to have abandoned them altogether (63 19). They recognize that the condition of Jerus is desperate. “Our holy and our beautiful house, where our fathers praised thee, is burned with fire; and all our pleasant places are laid waste’ (64 11). Such language, however, is the language of fervent prayer and must not be taken with rigid literalness, as 63 18 and 3 8 plainly show. Finally, in chs 65-66, Jeh answers His people’s supplications, distinguishing sharply between His own “servants” and Israel’s apostates. Only His chosen “seed” shall be delivered (65 9). Those 1503 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah who have obdurately provoked Jeh by sacrificing in gardens (65 3; 66 17), offering libations to Fortune and Destiny (65 11), sitting among the graves to obtain oracles from the dead, and, like the Egyptians, eating swine’s flesh and broth of abominable things which were supposed to possess magical properties, lodging in vaults or crypts in which hesthen mysteries were celebrated (65 4), and at the same time fancying that by celebrating such heathen mysteries they are holier than others and thereby disqualified to discharge the ordinary duties of life (65 5)—such Jeh designs to punish, measuring their work into their bosom and destroy- ing them utterly with the sword (65 7.12). Onthe other hand, the “servants’’ of Jeh shall inherit His holy mountains. They shall rejoice and sing for joy of heart, and bless themselves in the God of Amen, ie.in the God of Truth (65 9.14.16). Jeh will create new heavens and a new earth, men will live and grow old like the patriarchs; they will possess houses and vineyards and enjoy them; for an era of idyllic peace will be ushered in with the coming of the Messianic age, in which even the natures of wild animals will be changed and the most rapacious of wild animals will live together in harmony (65 17-25). Religion will become spirit- ual and decentralized, mystic cults will disappear, incredulous scoffers will be silenced. Zion’s popu- lation will be marvelously multiplied, and the people will be comforted and rejoice (66 1-14). Further- more, al] nations will flock to Zion to behold Jeh’s glory, and from one new moon to another, and from one Sabbath to another, all flesh will come up to worship in Jerus (66 15-23). It is evident that the Book of Isa closes, prac- tically as it begins, with a polemic against false worship, and the alternate reward of the righteous and punishment of the wicked. The only essential difference between the prophet’s earlier and later oracles is this: Isaiah, in his riper years, on the basis of nearly half a century’s experience as a preacher, paints a much brighter eschatological picture than was possible in his early ministry. His picture of the Messianic age not only transcends those of his contemporaries in the 8th cent. BC, but he pene- trates regions beyond the spiritual horizon of any and all OT seers. Such language as that contained in 66 1.2, in particular, anticipates the great prin- ciple enunciated by Jesus in Jn 4 24, namely, that “God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship in spirit and truth.” To attempt to date such oracles as these on the basis of internal evi- dence is an absolute impossibility. Humanly speak- ing, one age could have produced such revelations quite as easily as another. Butno age could have produced them apart from the Divine spirit. | The editorial arrangement of Isaiah’s prophecies is very suggestive. In the main they stand in chronological order. That is to say, 8. Isaiah’s all the dates mentioned are in strict Prophecies historical sequence; e.g. 6 1, “In the Chronologi- year that king Uzziah died” (740 BC); cally Ar- 7 1, “In the days of Ahaz” (736 ff ranged § BC); 14 28, “In the year that king Ahaz died” (727 BC); 20 1, ‘In the year that Tartan came unto Ashdod, when Sargon the king of Assyria sent him” (711 BC); 36 1, “In the 14th year of king Hezekiah” (701 BC). These points are all in strict chronological order. Taken in groups, also, Isaiah’s great individual messages are likewise arranged in true historical sequence; thus, chs 1-6 for the most part belong to the last years of Jotham’s reign (740-736 BC); chs 7-12, to the period of the Syro-Ephraimitic war (734 BC); ch 20, to the year of Sargon’s siege of Ashdod (711 BC); chs 28-32, to the invasion of Judah by Sen- nacherib (701 BC); while the distinctively promis- sory portions (chs 40-66), as is natural, conclude the collection. In several minor instances, how- ever, there are notable departures from a rigid chronological order. For example, ch 6, which describes the prophet’s initial call to preach, follows the rebukes and denunciations of chs 1-6; but this is probably due to its being used by the prophet asan apologetic. Again, the oracles against foreign nations in chs 13-23 belong to various dates, being grouped together, in part, at least, because of their subject-matter. Likewise, chs 38-39, which give an account of Hezekiah’s sickness and Merodach- baladan’s embassy to him upon his recovery (714— 712 BC), chronologically precede chs 36-37, which describe Sennacherib’s investment of Jerus (701 BC). This chiastic order, however, in the last instance, is due probably to the desire to make chs 36-37 (about Sennacherib, king of Assyria) an appropriate conclusion to chs 1-35 (which say much about Assyria), and, on the other hand, to make chs 38-39 (about Merodach-baladan of Baby- lon) a suitable introduction to chs 40-66 (which speak of Babylon). The attempt to date Isaiah’s individual messages on the basis of internal criteria alone, is a well-nigh impossible task; and yet no other kind of evidence is available. Often passages stand side by side which point in opposite directions; in fact, certain sections seem to be composed of various fragments dating from different periods, as though prophecies widely separated from each other in time had been fused together. In such cases much weight should be given to those features which point to an early origin, because of the predominatingly predictive character of Isatiah’s writings. Isaiah always had an eye upon the future. His semi-historical and biographical prophecies are nat- urally the casiest to date; on the other hand, the form of his Messianic and eschatological discourses is largely due to his own personal temper and psy- chology, rather than to the historical circumstances of the time. The following is a table of Isaiah’s prophecies chronologically arranged: Chs 1-6 written probably c 740-736 4-19 a a ce 734-732 15 1—16 12; 17 ie a c 734 13 1—14 23 ve Ey between 732-722 14 24-27 . ee 732-722 14 28-32 5 oe c 727 23 ee “ shortly before 722 54-27 a 7 a * 723 58 1-6 “ ; 7 439 19 “ : ce 720 38 ; ce 714 39 . a c 712 21 11.12.13-17 oe e711 22 15-25 - a e 7il 21 1-10 : ¢ 709 22 1-10 s - c 709 28 7—83 24 ss ‘* shortly before 701 18 Be pe ce 701 34-35 es ~ e 701 36-37 tf ** soon after 701 40-66 iF ‘ noire: “01 The prophet’s standpoint in chs 40-66 is that of Isaiah himself. For if Isaiah, before 734 BC, in passages confessedly his own, could describe Judah’s cities as already “burned with fire,” Zion as de- serted as “a booth in a vineyard” (1 7.8), Jerus as ‘cuined,’”’ Judah as ‘‘fallen” (3 8), and Jeh’s people as already “gone into captivity’ (6 13), surely after all the destruction and devastation wrought on Judah by Assyria in the years 722, 720, 711, and 701 BC, the same prophet with the same poetic license could declare that the temple had been “trodden down’ (63 18) and “burned with fire,” and all Judah’s pleasant places “laid waste” (64 11); and, in perfect keeping with his former prom- ises, could add that “they shall repair the waste cities, the desolations of many generations” (61 4; cf 44 26; 58 12). Isaiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1504 Or again, if Isaiah the sou of Amoz could comfort Jerus with promises of protection when the Assyrian (734 BC) should come like an overflowing river (8 9.10; 10 24.25); and conceivea beautiful parable of comfort like that contained in 28 23-29; and insert among his warnings and exhortations of the gloomy year 702 BC ‘so many precious promises of a brighter future which was sure to follow Sen- nacherib’s invasion (29 17-24; 30 29-33; 31 8.9); and, in the very midst of the siege of 701 BC, con- ceive of such marvelous Messianic visions as those in 33 17-24 with which to dispel the dismay of his compatriots, surely the same prophet might be con- ceived of as seizing the opportunity to comfort those in Zion who survived the great catastrophe of 701 BC. The prophet who bad done the one was pre- pared to do the other. There was one circumstance of the prophet’s position after 701 BC which was new, and which is too often overlooked, a circumstance which he eould not have employed to anything like the same degree as an argument in enforcing his message prior to the Assyrian’s overthrow and the deliver- ance of Jerus. It was this: the fulfilment of former predictions as proof of Jeh’s deity. From such pas- sages we obtain an idea of the prophet’s true his- torical position (42 9; 44 8; 46 21; 46 10; 48 3). Old predictions have already been fulfilled (6 11-13; 29 8; 30 31; 31 8; 37 7.30), on the basis of which the prophet ventures to predict new and even more astounding things concerning the overthrow of Babylon by Cyrus, and Israel’s deliverance through him from their captors (48 6). Isaiah’s book is signally full of predictions (7 8.10ff; 8 4.8; 9 11.12; 10 26 ff; 14 24-27; 16 14; 17 9.12-14; 20 4-6; 21:16; 22 19ff; 23 15; 38 5), some of which, written down and sealed, were evidently committed by the prophet to his inner circle of disciples to be used and verified by them in subsequent crises (8 16). Failure to recognize this element in Isaiah’s book is fatal to a true interpretation of the prophet’s real message. “For about twenty-five centuries,” as A. B. Davidson observes (OT Prophecy, 1908, 244), “no one dreamt of doubting that Isaiah the 9. The son of Amoz was the author of every Critical part of the book that goes under his Problem name; and those who still maintain the unity of authorship are accus- tomed to point, with satisfaction, to the unanimity of the Christian church on the matter, till a few German scholars arose, about a century ago, and called in question the unity of this book.” Tradi- tion is unanimous in favor of the unity of the book. (1) The history of criticism.—The critical dis- integration of the book began with Koppe, who in 1780 first doubted the genuineness of ch 60. Nine years later Doederlein suspected the whole of chs 40-66. He was followed by Rosenmueller, who was the first to deny to Isaiah the prophecy against Babylon in 13 1—14 23. Eichhorn, at the begin- ning of the last century, further eliminated the oracle against Tyre in ch 23, and he, with Gesenius and Ewald, also denied the Isaianic origin of chs 24-27. Gesenius also ascribed to some unknown prophet chs 15 and 16. Rosenmueller then went farther, and pronounced against chs 34 aud 36, and not long afterward (1840) Ewald questioned chs 12 and 33. Thus by the middle of the 19th cent. some 37 or 38 chapters were rejected as no part of Isaiah’s actual writings. In 1879-80, the cele- brated Leipzig professor, Franz Delitzsch, who for years previous had defended the genuineness of the entire book, finally yielded to the modern critical position, and in the new edition of his commentary published in 1889, interpreted chs 40-66, though with considerable hesitation, as coming from the close of the period of Bab exile. About the same time (1888-90), Drs. Driver and G. A. Smith gave opular impetus to similar views in Great Britain. Gas 1890, the criticism of Isa has been even more trenchant and microscopic than before. Duhm, Stade, Guthe, Hackmann, Cornill and Marti ou the Continent, and Cheyne, Whitehouse, Box, Glaze- brook, Kennett, Gray, Peake, and others in Great Britain and America have questioned portions which hitherto were supposed to be genuine. (2) The disintegration of ‘‘Deutero-Isaiah.”— Even the unity of chs 40-66, which were supposed to he the work of the “Second” or ‘““Deutero-Isaiah,” is now given up. What prior to 1890 was supposed to be the unique product of some celebrated but anonymous seer who lived in Babylonia about 550 BC is today commonly divided and subdivided and in large part distributed among various writers from Cyrus to Simon (538-164 BC). At first it was thought sufficient to separate chs 63-66 as a later addition to “Deutero-Isaiah’s” prophecies; but more recently it has become the fashion to dis- tinguish between chs 40-55, which are claimed to have been written by “‘Deutero—Isaiah”’ in Babylonia about 549-538 BC, and chs 56-66, which are now alleged to have been composed by a ‘‘Trito-Isaiah” about 460-445 BC. (3) Recent views—Among the latest to investi- gate the problem is Professor R. H. Kennett of Cambridge, Eng., who, in his Schweich Lectures (The Composition of the Book of Isa in the Light of Hist and Archaeology, 1910, $4 ff), sums up the results of investigations as follows: (a) all of chs 3, 5, 6, 7, 20 and 31, and large portions of chs 1, 2,4, 8, 9, 10, 14, 17, 22 and 23, may be assigned to Isaiah the son of Amoz; (b) all of chs 13, 40 and 47, and large portions of chs 14, 21, 41, 43, 44, 45, 46 and 48, may be assigned to the time of Cyrus; (c) all of chs 15, 36, 37 and 39, and portions of chs 16 and 38, may be assigned to the period between Nebu- chadnezzar and Alexander the Great, but cannot be dated precisely; (d) the passage 23 1-14 may be assigned to the time of Alexander the Great; (e) all of chs 11, 12, 19, 24-27, 29, 30, 32-36, 42, 49-66, and portions of chs 1, 2, 4, 8, 9, 10, 16, 17, 18, 23, 41, 44, 45, 48 may be assigned to the 2d cent. BC (167-140 BC). Professor C. F. Kent, also (Sermons, Epistles, and Apocalypses of Israel's Prophets, 1910, 27 ff), makes the foliowing critical observations on chs 40-66. e@ says: ‘“‘The prophecies of Haggai and Zechariah ... . afford by far the best approach for the study of the difficult problems presented by Isa 40-66..... 6-6' are generally recognized as post-exilic. .... In Isa not confined to the latter part of the book. .... The fact, on the one hand, that there are few, if any, allu- sions to contemporary events in these chapters, and on the other hand, that little or nothing is known of the condition and hopes of the Jews euting. this period (the closing years of the Bab exile) makes the dating of these prophecies possible, although far from certain. .... Also, the assumption that the author of these chapters lived in the Bab exile is not supported by a close exam- ination of the prophecies themselves. “Possibly their author was one of the few who, like Zerubbabel, had been born in Babylon aud later returned to Pal. He was also dealing with such broad and universal problems that he gives few indications of his date and place of abode; but all the evidence that is found points to Jerns as the place where he lived and wrote..... The prophet’'s interest and point of view center throughout in Jerus, and he shows himself far more familiar with conditions in Pal than in distant Babylon. Most of his Niustra- tions are drawn from the agricultural life of Pal. His vocabulary is also that of a. man dwelling in Pal, and in this respect is in marked contrast with the synonyms employed by Ezekiel, the prophet of the Bab exile." That is to say, two of the most recent investi- gators of the Book of Isa reach conclusions quite at variance with the opinions advocated in 1890, when Delitzsch so reluctantly allowed that chs 40- a 1505 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah ESE 66 may have sprung from the period of Bab exile. Now, it is found that these last 27 chs were written after the exile, most probably in Pal, rather than in Babylonia as originally claimed, and are no longer considered addressed primarily to the suffer- ing exiles in captivity as was formerly urged. (4) The present state of the question —The present state of the Isa-question is, to say the least, con- fusing. Those who deny the integrity of the book may be divided into two groups, which we may call moderates and radicals. Among the moderates may be included Drs. Driver, G. A. Smith, Skinner Kirkpatrick, Koenig, A. B. Davidson, Barnes and Whitehouse. These all practically agree that the following chs and vs are not Isaiah’s: 11 10-16; 12; 13 1—14 23; 16 1—16 12; 21 1-10; 24-27; 34-35; 36-39; 40-66. That is to say, some 44 chs out of the whole number, 66, were not written by Isaiah; or, approximately 800 out of 1,292 vs are not genuine. Among the radicals are Drs. Cheyne, Duhm, Hackmann, Guthe, Marti, Kennett and Gray. These all reject approximately 1,030 vs out of the total 1,292, retaining the following only as the genuine product of Isaiah and his age: 1 2-26. 29-31; 2 6-19; 3 1.5.8.9.12-17; 4 1; 5 1-14.17-29; 6; 7 1-8.22; 9 8—10 9; 10 13.14.27-32; 17 1-14; 18; 20; 22 1-22; 28 1-4.7-22; 29 1-6.9.10.13-15: 30 1-17; 31 1-4. That is, only about 262 vs out of the total 1,292 are allowed to be gennine. ‘This is, we believe, a fair statement of the Isa~question as it exists in the hands of divisive critics today. On the other hand there have been those who have defended and who still defend the essential unity of Isaiah’s entire book, e.g. Strachey (1874), Nagelsbach (1877), Bredenkamp (1887), Donglas (1895), W. H. Cobb (1883-1908), W. H. Green (1892), Vos (1898-99), Thirtle (1907), Margoliouth (1910) and O. T. Allis (1912). (5) Reasons for dissecting the book.—The funda~- mental axiom of criticism is the dictum that a prophet always spoke out of a definite historical situation to the present needs of the people among whom he lived, and that a definite historical sit- uation shall be pointed out for each prophecy. This fundamental postulate, which on the whole isreason- able and perfectly legitimate if not overworked, underlies all modern criticism of OT prophecy. It is not possible, however, always to trace a mere snatch of sermonic discourse to a definite historical situation apart from its context. Moreover, the prophets often spoke consciously, not only to their own generation, but also tothe generations to come. Isaiah in particular commanded, “Bind thou up the testimony, seal the law among my disciples” (8 16); that is, preserve my teachings for the future. Again in 80 8, he says, ‘‘Now go, . . . . inscribe it in a book, that tf may be for the time to come for ever and ever.” Andalsoin 42 23, “Who is there among you that will give ear to this? that will hearken and hear for the time to come?” Certain false presuppositions often govern critics in their disintegration of the book. Only a few examples need be given by way of illustration: (a) According to some, ‘the conversion of the heathen” lay quite beyond the horizon of any 8th- cent. prophet; consequently, Isa 2 2-4 and all similar passages which foretell the conversion of those outside the chosen people are to be relegated to an age subsequent to Isaiah. . (6) To others, “the picture of universal peace”’ in Isa 11 1-9 is a symptom of late date, and therefore this section and all kindred ones must bedeleted. (c) To others, the thought of “universal judgment”? upon “the whole earth” in 14 26 and elsewhere quite tran- scends Isaiah’s range of thought. (d) To others still, the apocalyptic character of chs 24-27 repre- sents a phase of Heb thought which prevailed in Israel only after Ezekiel. (e) Even to those who are considered moderates ‘the poetic character’ of a passage like ch 12, and the references to a “return” from captivity, as in 11 11-16, and the promises and consolations such as are found in ch 33 are cited as grounds for assigning these and similar passages to a much later age. Radicals deny in toto the existence of all Messianic passages among Isaiah’s own predictions, relegating all Messianic hope to a much later age. But to deny to the Isaiah of the 8th cent. all catholicity of grace, all universalism of salvation or judgment, every highly developed Messianic ideal, every rich note of promise and comfort, all sublime faith in the sacrosanct character of Zion, as some do, is unwarrantably to create a new Isaiah of greatly reduced proportions, a mere preacher of righteousness, a statesman of not very optimistic vein, and the exponent of a cold ethical religion without the warmth and glow of the messages which are actually ascribed to the prophet of the 8th cent. As a last resort, certain critics have appealed to 2 Ch 86 22.23 as external evidence that chs 40-66 existed as a separate collection in the Chronicler’s age. But the evidence obtained from this source is so doubtful that it is well-nigh valueless. For it is not the prediction of Isa concerning Cyrus to which the Chronicler points as Jeremiah’s, but the “70 years” of Bab supremacy spoken of in ver 21, which Jeremiah actually did predict (cf Jer 25 11; 29 10). On the other hand, chs 40-66 were cer- tainly ascribed to Isaiah as early as 180 BC, for Jesus Ben-Sirach, the author of Ecclus, speaks of Isaiah as the prophet who “saw by an excellent spirit that which should come to pass at the last, and comforted them that mourned in Zion” (Ecclus 48 20ff; cf Isa 40 1ff). Furthermore, there is absolutely no proof that chs 1-39, or chs 40-66, or any other section of Isaiah’s prophecies ever existed by themselves as an independent collection; nor is there any substantial ground for supposing that the promissory and Messianic portions have been sys- tematically interpolated by editors long subse- quent to Isaiah’s own time. The earlier prophets presumably did more than merely threaten. (6) Arguments for one Isaiah.—It is as unreason- able to expect to be able to prove the unity of Isa as to suppose that it has been disproved. Internal evidence is indecisive in either case. There are arguments, however, which corroborate a belief that there was but one Isaiah. Here are some of those which might be introduced: (a) The circle of ideas, which are strikingly the same throughout the entire book: For example, take the characteristic name for God, which is almost peculiar to Isaiah, “the Holy One of Israel.” This title for Jeh occurs in the Book of Isa a total of 25 t, and only 6 t elsewhere in the OT, one of which is a || passage in K. This unique epithet, “the Holy One of Israel,” interlocks all the various portions with one another and stamps them with the personal imprimatur of him who saw the vision of the majestic God seated upon His throne, high and lifted up, and heard the angelic choirs singing: “Holy, holy, holy, is Jeh of hosts: the whole earth is full of his glory” (6 3). The presence of this Divine title in all the different sections of the book is of more value in identifying Isaiah as the author of all these prophecies than though his name had been inserted at the beginning of every chapter, for the reason that his theology—his conception of God as the Holy One—is woven into the very fiber and texture of the whole book. It occurs 12 t in chs 1-39, and 13 t in chs 40-66; and it is simply unscientific to say that the various alleged authors of the disputed portions all employed the same title Isaiah through imitation (cf 1 4; 5 19.24; 10 20; 12 6; 17:7; 29:19; 30 11.12.15; 311; 87 23; also 41 14.16.20; 43 3.14; 45 11; 47 4; 48 17; 49 7; 64 5; 56 5; 60 9.14; elsewhere, only iu 2 K 19 22; Ps 71 22; 78 41; 89 18; Jer 50 29; 51 5). Another unique idea which occurs with consid- erable repetition in the Book of lsa is the thought of a “highway” (cf 11 16; 35 8; 403; 48 19; 49 11; 57 14; 6210). Another characteristic idea is that of a “remuant”’ (cf 1 9; 10 20.21.22; 11 11.16; 14 22.30; 159; 16 14; 17 3; 2117; 28 5; 37 31; 46 3; cf 65 8.9). Another striking trait of the book is the position occupied by ‘‘Zion”’ in the prophet’s thoughts (cf 2 3; 4 5; 18 7; 24 23; 98 16; 29 8; 30 19: 31 9; 38 5.20; 34 8: 46 13: 49 14; 51 3.16; 521; 59 20; 60 14; 62 1.11; 66 8). Still another is the oft-repeated expression, “pangs of a woman in travail’’ (cf 18 8; 21 3; 26 17.18; 42 14; 54 1; 66 7). These, and many others less distinctive, psychologically stamp the book with an individuality which it is difficult to account for, if it be broken up into countless fragments and dis- tributed, as some do, over the centuries. (b) The literary style: As negative evidence, literary style is not a very safe argument; for, as Professor McCurdy says, “In the case of a writer of Isaiah’s environments, style is not a sure cri- terion of authorship” (History, Prophecy and the Monuments, II, 317,n.). Yetitis certainly remark- able that the clause ‘for the mouth of Jeh hath spoken it’’ should be found 3 t in the Book of Isa, and nowhere else in the OT (cf 1 20; 40 5; 58 14). And it is noteworthy that the phrase, “streams of water,” should occur twice in Isa and nowhere else (cf 30 25; 44 4 in the Heb). And very peculiar is the tendency on the prophet’s part to emphatic reduplication (cf 2 7.8; 6 3; 8 9; 24 16.23; 40 1; 43 11.25; 4815; 6112; 5719; 6210). In fact, it is not extravagant to say that Isaiah’s style differs widely from that of every other OT prophet, and is as far removed as possible from that of Eze- kiel and the post-exilic prophets. (c) Historical references: Take, for example, first, the prophet’s constant reference to Judah and Jerus, his country and its capital (1 7-9; 3 8; 24 19; 25 2; 40 2.9; 62 4); likewise, to the temple and its ritual of worship and sacrifice. In 1 11-15, when all was prosperous, the prophet complained that the people were profuse and formal in their ceremonies and sacrifices; in 43 23.24, on the con- trary, when the country had beeu overrun by the Assyrian and Sennacherib had besieged the city, the prophet reminds them that they had not brought to Jch the sheep of their burnt offerings, nor honored Him with their sacrifices; while in 66 1-3.6.20, not only is the existence of the Temple and the ob- servance of the ritual presupposed, but those are sentenced who place their trust in the material temple, and the outward ceremonials of temple- worship. As for the “exile,’”’ the prophet’s attitude to it throughout is that of both anticipation and realization. Thus, in 7 1, judgment is only threat- ened, not yet inflicted: “Che righteous is taken away from the evil to come.’ That is to say, the exile is described as still future. On the other hand, in 3 8, “Jerus is ruined, and Judah is fallen,” which seems to describe the exile as in the past; yet, as everybody admits, these are the words of Isaiah of the 8th cent. In 11 11.12, the prophet says, “The Lord will set his hand again the second time to recover the remnant of his people... . from the four corners of the earth.” To interpret such a statement literally and mechanically without regard to 8th-cent. conditions, or to Isaiah’s mani- fest attitude to the exile, leads to confusion. No prophet realized so keenly or described so vividly the destiny of the Hebrews. : THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1506 (d) The predictive element: This is the strongest proof of the unity of the Book of Isa. Prediction is the very essence of prophecy (cf Dt 18 22); Isaiah was preéminently a prophet of the future. With unparalleled suddenness, he repeatedly leaps from despair to hope, from threat to promise, and from the actual to the ideal. What Professor Kent says of “Deutero-Isaiah” may with equal justice be said of Isaiah himself: ‘While in touch with his own age, the great unknown prophet lives in the at- mosphere of the past and the future” (Sermons, Epistles, and Apocalypses of Israel’s Prophets, 28). Isaiah spoke to his own age, but he also addressed himself to the ages to follow. His verb tenses are characteristically futures and prophetic perfects. Of his book A. B. Davidson’s words are particu- larly true: ‘Jf any prophetic book be examined . it will appear that the ethical and religious teaching is always secondary, and that the essential thing in the book or discourse is the prophet’s out- look into the future’ (HDB, art. ‘Prophecy and Prophets,” IV, 119). Isaiah was exceptionally given to predicting: thus (a) before the Syro-Ephraimitic war (734 BC), he predicted that within 65 years Ephraim should he broken to pieces (7 8); and that before the child Maher-shalal-hash-baz should have knowledge to cry, ‘‘My father,’ or “My mother,’’ the riches of Damascus and the spoil of Sa- maria should he carried away (8 4; cf'7 16). These are, however, hut two of numerous predictions, as shown ahove, among his earlier prophecies (cf 1 27.28; 2 2-4; 6 13; 10 20-23; 11 6-16; 17 14). (8B) Shortly before the downfall of Samaria in 722 BC, Isaiah predicted that Tyre should he forgotten 70 years, and that after the end of 70 years her merchandise should be holiness to Jeh (23 15.18). (y). In like manner prior to the siege of Ashdod in 711 BC, he proclaimed that within 3 years Moab should he brought into contempt (16 14), and that within a year all the glory of Kedar should fail (21 16). (6) And not long prior to the siege of Jerus by Sen- nacherib in 701 BC, he predicted that in an_ instant, suddenly, a multitude of Jerusalem's foes should he as dust (29 5); that yet a very little while and Lehanon should be turned into a fruitful field (29 17); and that Assyria shouid be dismayed and fall by the sword, but not of men (30 17.31; 31 8). And more, that for days heyond a year, the careless women of Jerus should be tronbled (82_10.16—-20); and that the righteous in Zion should see Jerus a quiet habitation, and return and come with singing (83 17 ff; 35 4.10); but that Sen- nacherih, on the contrary, should hear tidings and return ae shooting an arrow into the city (37 7.26-29. declare. .... THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Isaiah OO Tr — SseSsSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSsSSSSSSSSSsSSSSsee Thave called him; . .. . from the beginning I have not spoken in secret” (48 6-8.14~16). explicit and emphatic. 1507 this time, even hidden things. .... Yea, from of old thine ear was not opened..... Who among them hath declared these things? .... I, even I, have spoken; yea, Such predictions are (e) Cyrus a subject of prediction: From all the above-mentioned explicit and oft-repeated pre- dictions one thing is obvious, namely, that great emphasis is laid by the prophet on prediction throughout the entire Book of Isa. And it must be further allowed that “Cyrus” is represented by the author as predicted, from any point of view. The only question is, Does the prophet emphasize the fact that he himself is predicting the coming of Cyrus? or that former predictions concerning Cyrus are now, as the prophet writes, coming to pass before his readers’ eyes? Canon Cheyne’s remark upon this point is instructive. He says: “The editor, who doubtless held the later Jewish theory of prophecy, may have inferred from a number of passages, esp. 41 26; 48 3.6.14, that the first ap- pearance of Cyrus had been predicted by an ancient prophet, and observing certain Isaianic elements in the phraseology of these chapters, may have identi- fed the epic with Isaiah’ (Intro to the Book of sa, 238). Dr. G. A. Smith likewise allows that Cyrus is the ful- filment of former predictions. .He says: ‘‘Nor is it possible to argue, as some have tried to do, that the prophet is predicting these things as if they had already happened. For as part of an argument for the unique divinity of the God of Israel, Cyrus, ‘alive and irresistible,’ and already accredited with success, is pointed out as the unmistakable proof that former prophecies of a deliverance for Israel are already coming to pass, Cyrus, in short, is not pre- sented as a prediction, but as a proof that a prediction is being fulfilled” (HDB, art. “Isaiah,” 493). And further he says: ‘‘The chief claim, therefore, which chs 40 ff make for the God of Israel is His power to direct the history of the world in conformity to a long-predicted and faithfully followed purpose. This claim starts from the proof that Jeh has long before predicted events now happening or about to happen, with Cyrus as their center. But this is much more than a proof of isolated redictions, though these imply ommniscience. It is a eclaration of the unity of history sweeping to the high ends which have been already revealed to_Israel—an exposition, in short, of_the Omnipotence, Consistence, and qeactuness of the Providence of the one true God" (ib, e It is obvious, therefore, in any case, whether these chapters are early or late, that Cyrus is the subject of prediction. It really makes little difference at which end of history one takes his stand, whether in the 8th cent. BC with Isaiah, or in the 6th cent. BC with ‘“Deutero-Isaiah.” Cyrus, to the author of these chs, is the subject of prediction. In other words, whether indeed the author is really pre- dicting Cyrus in advance of all apparent fulfilment, or Cyrus is the fulfilment of some ancient prediction by another, does not alter the fact that Cyrus was the subject of prediction on the part of somehody. Accordingly, as was stated at the outset, the whole question is, which does the prophet emphasize, (a) the fact that he himself is predicting? or, (6) that former predictions by someone else are now before his eyes coming to pass? The truth is, the prophet seers to live in the atmosphere of the past and the future ag well as in the present, all of which are equally vivid to his prophetic mind. This isa pecul- iar characteristic of Isaiah. It is seen in the ac- count he gives of his inaugural vision (ch 6), of which Delitzsch remarks that it is “like a predic- tion in the process of being fulfilled.” The same is true of chs 24-27. There the prophet repeatedly projects himself into the future, and speaks from the standpoint of the fulfilment of his predictions. It is esp. true of chs 40-48. At one time the prophet emphasizes the fact that he is predicting, and a little later he describes his predictions as coming to pass. When, accordingty, a decision is mate as to when the author predicted Cyrus, it is more natural to suppose that he was doing so long before Cyrus’ actual appearance. This, in fact, is in keeping with the test of true prophecy contained in Dt 18 22: “When a prophet speaketh in the name of Jeb, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which Jeh hath not spoken; the prophet hath spoken it presumptuously, thou shalt not be afraid of him.” Besides, there is a similar explicit pre- diction in the OT, namely, that of King Josiah, who was foretold by name two centuries before he came (1 K 13 2; cf 2 K 23 15.16). Dr. W. H. Cobb in the Journal of Bib. Literature and Exegesis, 1901, 79, pleads for a ‘‘sbrinkage of Cyrus,” because Cyrus figures only in chs 40-48, and is then dismissed. Dr. Thirtle, on the other hand, argues that the name ‘Cyrus’ is a mere appellative, being originally not Kdéresh (Cyrus), but héresh (‘“workman,” “‘artificer,”” ‘“image- breaker’), and that 44 27.28 is a gloss (cf OT Problems, 244-64). But in opposition to these views the present writer prefers to write Cyrus large, and to allow frankly that he is the subject of extraordinary prediction. For the very point of the author’s argument is, .hat he is predicting events which Jeh alone is capable of foretelling or bringing to pass; in other words, that prescience is the proof of Jeh’s deity. Isaiah lived im an age when Jeh’s secrets were first revealed privately unto His serv- ants the prophets (cf Am 3 7). Political condi- tions were unsettled and kaleidoscopic, and there was every incentive to predict. That Isaiah actu- ally uttered wonderful predictions is attested, furthermore, both by Jesus Ben-Sirach in Ecclus 48 20-25 (written c 180 BC), and by Jos in his Ant, XI, i, 1, 2 (dating from ¢ 100 AD); and these are ancient traditions worthy of credence. Recently, Mr. Oswald T. Allis, after a thorough and exhaustive critical investigation of “the numerico-climactic structure” of the poem in Isa 44 24-28, concludes that “the most striking and significant features of the poem favor the view that while the utterance was significant in and of itself, it was chiefly significant in view of the exceptional circumstance under which it was spoken, i.e. in view of its early date. The chronological arrangement of the poem assigns the Restoration and Cyrus to the future. The perspective of the poem, together with the abrupt change of person in the 2d strophe, argues that the future is a remote future. And finally the carefully constructed double climax attaches a significance to the definiteness of the utterance which is most easily accounted for if this future was so remote that a definite disclosure con- cerning it would be of extraordinary importance.” And he further alleges that “it is impossible, if justice is done to the plain declarations of Scrip- ture, to limit the prophetic horizon of the prophet Isaiah to the preéxilic period and that .. . . when the form of the poem is recognized, there is every reason to assign it to a preéxilic prophet, to Isaiah, since the form of the poem is admirably calculated to emphasize the fact that Cyrus and the Restora- tion belong to a distant future, and to make it clear that it is just because of this fact that the definite- ness of the prophecy, the mention of Cyrus by name is so remarkable and of such unique significance’ (Bib. and Theol. Studies, by the members of the Faculty of Princeton Theological Seminary, Cen- tennial vol, 1912, 628-29). After all, why should men object to prediction on so large a scale? Unless there is definiteness about any given prediction, and unless it tran- scends ordinary prognostication, there is no especial value in it. Should it be objected, however, that prediction of so mimute a character is “abhorrent to reason,” the answer is already at band; it may Isaiah, Ascen. of Ishmael THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1508 be abhorrent to reason, but it is a handmaid to faith. Faith has to do with the future, even as prediction has to do with the future; and the OT is preéminently a book which encourages faith. There is really no valid objection to the prediction of Cyrus. For the one outstanding differentiating characteristic of Israel’s religion is predictive prophecy. The Hebrews certainly predicted the coming of a Mes- siah. Indeed, the Hebrews were the only people of antiquity whose “Golden Age” lay in the future rather than in the past. Accordingly, to predict the coming of a Cyrus as the human agent of Israel’s salvation is but the reverse side of the same prophet’s picture of the Divine agent, namely, the ohedient, Suffering Servant of Jeh, who would redeem Israel from its sin. Deny to Isaiah the son of Amoz the prediction concerning Cyrus, and it is but logical to go farther and to deny to him the Messianic hope which is usually associated with his name. Deny to Isaiah the son of Amoz the predictions concern- ing a return from captivity, and the prophecies of his book are robbed of their essential character and unique perspective. Emasculate those portions of the Book of Isa which unveil the future, and they are reduced to a mere vaticinium ex eventu, and their religious value as Divine oracles is largely lost. Litsrature.—So much has been written on Isalah’s prophecies that only a selected list can be given here: I. Commentaries on Isa: Owen_C. Whitehouse, The New Century Bible, 2 vols, 1905; J. Skinner, The Cam- bridge Bible for Schools and Colleges, 2 vols, 1896-98; W. E. Barnes, The Churchman’s Bible, 2 vols, 1901-3; G. A. Smith, The Expostior’s Bible, 2 vols, 1888-90; Franz Delitzsch, Clark's Foreign Theological Library, 2 vols, 1892; ©. von Orelli, Clark's Foreign Theological Library, 1895; T. K. Cheyne, The Prophecies of Isaiah, 2 vols, 1892; G. W. Wade, Westminster Commentaries, 1911; G. H. Box, The Book of Isa, 1909; G. B. Gray, ICC, I, chs i-xxvii, 1912; II, chs xxviii-_Ixvi (forthcoming), by G. B. Gray and A. S. Peake; J. E. McFadyen, ‘Book of the Prophecies of Isaiah’? (The Bible for Home and School), 1910; G. Campbell Morgan, The Analyzed Bible, 2 vols, 1910; Alex. Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture, 2 vols, 1906; H. G. Mitchell, Isaiah: A Study of cha 1-12, 1897; Niagelsbach in Lange’s Bibelwerk, Eng. ed, 1878; J. A. Alexander, 1865; H. Ewald, Eng. ed, 1876-81; John Calvin, Eng. ed, 1850; R. Lowth, 1778; Vitringa, 1732; W. Gesenius, 1820-21; F. Hitzig, 1833; C. J. Bredenkamp, 1887; A. Dillmann, 1890, as revised by Kittel, 1898; B. Duhm, in Nowack's Handkommentar zum Fea 1892; K. Marti, 1900; A. Condamin (Rom Cath.), Il. Introduction and Criticism: 8. R. Driver, Isaiah, His Life and Times, in ‘‘The Men of the Bible Series,”’ 1888; T. K. Cheyne, Iniro to the Book of Isa, 1895; W. R. Smith, The Prophets of Israel, 2d ed, 1896; A. F. Kirk- patrick, The Doctrine of the Prophets, 1892; J. W. Thirtle, OT Problems, 1907; W. E. Barnes, An Exom. of Isa 24-27, 1891; G. Douglas, Isaiah One and His Book One, 1895; J. Kennedy, A Popular Argument for the Unity of Isa, 1891; E. Koenig, The Exiles’ Baok of Consolation, 1899; G. C. Workman, The Servant of Jeh, 1907; M. G. Glaze- brook, Studies in the Book of Isa, 1910; R. H. Kennett, The Composition of the Book of Isa in the Light of History and Archaeology, 1910; R. R. Ottley, Isa according to Hackmann, Die Zukunftserwartung des of Israel, Isa 44 24-28,” in Bib. and Theol. Studies, Princeton’s Centennial Commemoration vol, 1912, 579— 634: J. Hastings, The Great Texts of the Bible, 1910; C. S. Robinson, The Gospel in Isa, 1895; E. Sievers, Me- trische Studien, 1901; G. L. Robinson, The Boek of Isa, 1910; H. Guthe, Das Zukunfisbild des Jesaia, 1885; Feldmann, Der Knecht_Gottes, 1907; W. Urwick, The Servant of Jeh, 1877; K. Cramer, The Historical Back- Gradad of Isa 56-66, 1905; A. B. Davidson, OT Prophecy, Ifl. Arts. in Journals and Dictionaries: W. H. Cobb in JBL, 1891, II; 1895, Land II; 1898, 1; 1901, I; 1908, I; F. Brown, JBL, 1890, 1; W. H. Cobh, in the BS, 1882; G. A. Smith, art. ‘‘Isaiah” in HDB, 1899; T. K. Cheyne, in the ZB, 1901, and in the Enc Brit, 11th ed, 1910; Jas. Robertson, in the Illustrated Bible Dict., 1908; E. Koenig, inthe Standard Bible Dict., 1909; A. Klostermann and J. A. Kelso, in The New Sch-Herz, 1910; A. Kloster- mann in the RE, 1900; G. Vos, Presbyterian and Reformed Review, 1898; D. S. Margoliouth, in The Temple Dict., 1910; OC. A. Briggs, art. ‘‘ Analysis of Isa 40-62" in Harper Memorial Volume. Gsorce L. Ropinson ISAIAH, ASCENSION OF. See Arocatyptic LITERATURE. ISCAH, iz’ka, is’ka (MDO", yiskah): Daughter of Haran and sister of Milcah the wife of Nahor (Gen 11 29), Tradition identifies her with Sarai, Abram’s wife; but without sufficient reason. ISCARIOT, is-kar’i-ot. ISDAEL, is’da-el (‘IoSafA, Isdaél): In 1 Esd 6 33; called “Giddel” in Ezr 2 56. ISH (W", ’ish): In the following Heb proper names, a prefix meaning “man of,’ or, collectively, “men of’: Ish-bosheth, Ishhod, Ish-tob (but RV correctly “the men of Tob”). See also Esupaat, EsHpan; Iscariot. ISHBAAL, ish’ba-al. See IsH-BOSHETH. ISHBAH, ish’ba (maw, yishbah): A member of the tribe of Judah, father of Eshtemoa (1 Ch 4 17). ISHBAK, ish’bak (p2W", yishbak): A name in the list of sons of Abraham by Keturah (Gen 25 2||1 Ch 1 32). These names probably represent tribes; the tribe of Ishbak has not been certainly identified. ISHBI-BENOB, ish-bi-bé’nob (A224 "2D", yishbi bhendbh): One of the four “born to the giant in Gath” who were slain by David and his men (28 21 15-22). Ishhi-benob was slain by Abishai, and David’s life saved by the act (vs 16.17). ISH-BOSHETH, ish-bo’sheth (MPD-WN, "ish- bésheth, “man of shame’; ‘IerBoobé, Iesbosthé): Called SYD, ’eshba'al, “man of Baal” (1 Ch 8 are? 33), and "WW", ytshwi, “man of Jeh’’(?), perhaps for WIR, ‘ishtyd (18 14 49). Cf Esupaan and Isuvi (AV “Ishui’). We probably have the right meaning of the name in Eshbaal and Ishvi, the words Baal and Jeh being frequently interchanged. The change to Ish-bosheth, “man of shame,” in 2S, where the story of his shameful murder is re- lated, may be better explained as reference to this (see MEPHIBOSHETH, whose name was also changed from Merib-baal for similar reasons), than to find here a suggestion of Baal-worship, but see HPN, 121, where the change is explained as a correction of the scribes, in consequence of prophetic protests. One of the sons of Saul (1 Ch 8 33; 9 39; 18S 14 49) who, when his father and brothers were slain in the battle of Gilboa (1 S 31 1 ff), was pro- claimed king over Israel by Abner, the captain of Saul’s host, at Mahanaim (258 2 8ff). Ish- bosheth was 40 years old at this time and reigned over Israel 2 years (28 2 10). Judah, however, proclaimed David its king. The consequence was war (2 8 2 12ff). The house of David pre- vailed against the house of Saul (2 § 3 1), but the war did not come to a close until Abner, angry on account of the rebuke he suffered from I. for his unlawful intimacy with Rizpah, Saul’s concubine, joined David (25 3 6ff). David’s condition to return to him Michal, his wife, before peace could be made, was fulfilled by I. (2 $3 14 f), but it was not until after Abner’s death that I. seems to have given up hopes of retaining his power (28 4 1 ff). The shameful murder of I. by his own captains is recorded in 2 8 4 5ff. David punished the mur- derers who had expected reward and buried I. in the grave of Abner at Hebron (2 S 4 12f). . Artur L. BREsLico ISHHOD, ish’hod (THUD, ’ishehddh, “man of majesty’’): A man of the tribe of Manasseh (1 Ch 7 18, AV “Ishod’’). See Jupas IscaRioT. 1509 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA }saiah, Ascen. of ISHI, ish’] (VW, yish'z, “salutary’”’): (1) A Jerahmeelite (1 Ch 2 31); the genealogy may denote his membership by blood, or only by adoption, in the tribe of Judah. (2) A Judahite (1 Ch 4 20). (3) A Simeonite, whose sons led 500 of their tribe against the Amalekites in Mt. Seir (1 Ch 4 42). (4) One of the chiefs of Manasseh E. of the Jor- dan (1 Ch 6 24). ISHI, ish’t, shi CW", ‘tshi, “my husband”; LXX 6 dvip pov, ho anér mou): The name symbolic of Jeh’s relation to Israel which Hosea (2 16) de- clares shall be used when Baali, “my lord,’’ has become hateful on account of its associations with the worship of the Baals. ISHIAH, i-shi’ya. See Issurau. ISHIJAH, i-shi’ja. See Issmisaug. . ISHMA, ish’ma (N12, yishma’, from the root yasham, ‘‘to lie waste,’’ therefore meaning ‘‘deso- late’): A brother of Jezrecl and Idbash, ‘‘the sons of the father of Etam’” (1 Ch 4 3). They were brothers of Hazzelelponi. ISHMAEL, ish’mi-el ONvAw, yishma’é’l, “God heareth,”” or “God may,” “shall hear”; "Iopaf, Ismaél): (1) The son of Abraham by Hagar, the Egyp slave of his wife Sarah. The circumstances con- nected with his birth reveal what seems to us to be a very strange practice. It was customary among ancient peoples to correct the natural defect of barrenness by substituting a slave woman. In our narrative, this is shown to be authorized and brought about by the legitimate wife with the understanding that the offspring of such a union should be regarded as her own: “It may be that I shall obtain children by her,” lit. “that I shall be builded by her” (Gen 16 2 The hopes of Sarah were realized, for Hagar gave birth to a son, and yet the outcome was not fully pleasing to Abraham’s wife; there was 1, Birth one serious drawback. As soon as Hagar “saw that she had conceived,” her behavior toward her mistress underwent a radi- cal change; she was “despised in her eyes.” But for the intervention of the angel of Jeh, the boy might have been born in Egypt. For, being dealt with hardly (or humbled) by Sarah, the handmaid fled toward that country. On her way she was told by the angel to return to her mistress and submit herself “under her hands.” She obeyed, and the child who was to be as ‘‘a wild ass among men” was born when his father was 86 years old (Gen 16 7-16). At the age of 13 years the boy was circumcised (Gen 17 25) in accordance with the Divine com- mand received by Abraham: “Every 2. ,Circum- male among you shall be circum- cision cised’”’ (Gen 17 10). Thus young Ish- mael was made a party to the cove- nant into which God had entered with the lad’s father. The fact that both Abraham and his son were circumcised the same day (Gen 17 26) un- doubtedly adds to the importance of Ishmael’s par- taking of the holy rite. He was certainly made to understand how much his father loved him and how deeply he was concerned about his spiritual welfare. We may even assume that there was a time when Abraham looked upon Ishmael as the promised seed. His error was made clear to him when God promised him the birth of a son by Sarah. At first this seemed to be incredible, Abraham being 100 years of age and Sarah 90. And yet, how could he dis- believe the word of God? His cherished, though mistaken, belief about Ishmael, his doubts regarding the possibility of Sarah’s motherhood, and the first faint glimmer of the real meaning of God’s promise, all these thoughts found their expression in the fervid wish: “O that Ishmael might live before thee!’ (Gen 17 18). Gradually the truth dawned upon the patriarch that God's thoughts are not the thoughts of men, neither their ways His ways. But we have no reason to believe that this entire changing of the mental attitude of Abraham toward Ishmael reacted unfavorably on his future treatment of this son “born of the flesh” (cf Gen 21 11). If there were troubles in store for the boy likened by the angel of Jeh to a wild ass, it was, in the main, the youngster’s own fault. When Isaac was weaned, Ishmael was about 16 years of age. The weaning was made an occasion for great celebration. But it seems the 3. Banish- pleasure of the day was marred by the ment objectionable behavior of Ishmael. “And Sarah saw the son of Hagar the Egyp .... mocking” (Gen 219). Her jealous motherly love had quickened her sense of obser- vation and her faculty of reading the character of children. We do not know exactly what the word used in the Heb for “mocking” really means. The LXX and the Vulg render the passage: ‘When Sarah saw the scn of Hagar... . playing with Isaac,” and St. Paul followed a later tradition when he says: “He that was born after the flesh perse- cuted him that was born after the Spirit” (Gal 4 29). Lightfoot (in his notes to the Ep. to the Gal) says: ‘‘At all events the word seems to mean mock- ing, jeering.’’ At any rate, the fact remains that Sarah objected to the bringing up of the son of promise together with the “mocker,” and so both mother and son were banished from the tents of Abraham. Now there came a most critical time in the life of young Ishmael. Only some bread and a bottle of water were ‘put on the shoulder’ of Hagar by Abraham when he expelled her with her son. Aim- lessly, as it seems, the two walked about in the wilderness of Beersheba. The water was soon spent, and with it went all hope and energy. The boy, being faint with thirst and tired out by his constant walking in the fierce heat of the sun, seemed tobe dying. Sohis mother put him rapidly down in the shade of some plant. (We do not share the opinion of some writers that the narrative of Gen 21 8ff represented Ishmael as a little boy whom his mother had carried about and finally flung in the shade of some shrub. Even if this passage is taken from a different source, it is cer- tainly not in conflict with the rest as to the age of Ishmael.) After this last act of motherly love— what else could she do to help the boy?—she re- tired to a place at some distance and resignedly ex- pected the death of her son and perhaps her own. For the 2d time in her life, she had a marvelous experience. ‘God heard the voice of the lad”’ and comforted the unhappy mother most wonderfully. Through His angel He renewed His former promise regarding her son, and then He showed her a wellof water. The lad’s life was saved and, growing up, he became in time an archer. He lived in the wilderness of Paran and was married by his mother to an Egyp wife (Gen 21 21). When Abraham died, his exiled son returned to assist his brother to bury their father (Gen 26 9). In the same chapter we find the names 4. His of Ishmael’s 12 sons (vs 12 ff) and a Children brief report of bis death at the age of 137 years (ver 17). According to Gen 28 9 he also had a daughter, Mahalath, whom Esau took for his wife; in Gen 36 3 her name is given as Basemath. sent History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1510 The character of Ishmael and his descendants (Arabian nomads or Bedouins) is very accurately and vividly depicted hy the angel of 5. De- Jeh: ‘He shall be as a wild ass among scendants men; his hand shall be against every Man, and every man’s hand against him” (Gen 16 12). These nomads are, indeed, roaming the wilds of the desert, jealous of their in- dependence, quarrelsame and adventurous. We may well think of their progenitor as of a proud, undaunted and rugged son of the desert, the very counterpart of the poor hoy lying half dead from fatigue and exposure under the shrub in the wilder- ness of Beersheha. The person and the history of Ishmael, the son of Abra- ham, ‘‘born after the flesh,” is of special interest to the student of the NT because St. Paul uses him, 6. Inthe in theEp.totheGal, asa type of those Jews who cling to the paternal religion in such a NT manner as to be unable to discern the tran- sient character of the OT institutions, and esp. those of the Mosaic law. By doing so they could not be made to see the true meaning of the law, and instead of embracing the grace of God as the only means of ful- filling the law, they most bitterly fought the central doc- trine of Christianity and even persecuted its advocates. Like Ishmael, they were born of Hagar, the handmaid or slave woman; like him, they were Ahraham’s sons only ‘after the flesh,"' and _ their ultimate fate is foreshadowed in the casting out of Hagar and her son. They could not expect to maintain the connection with the true Israel, and even incase they should acclaim Christ their Messiah they were not to be the leaders of the church or the ex- pounders of its teachings (Gal 4 21-28). (2) The son of Nethaniah (Jer 40 8—41 18; cf 2 K 25 23-25). It is a dreary story of jealousy and treachery which Jeremiah has recorded in chs 40, 41 of his book. After the destruction of Jerus and the deportation of the better class of Jewish citizens, it was necessary to provide for some sort of a government in the depopulated country. Pub- lic order had to be restored and maintained; the crops of the fields were endangered and had to be taken care of. It was thus only common political prudence that dictated to the king of Babylon the setting up of a governor for the remnant of Judah. He chose Gedaliah, the son of Ahikam, for the diffi- cult position. The new officer selected for his place of residence the city of Mizpah, where he was soon joined by Jeremiah. All the captains of the Jewish country forces came to Mizpah with their men and put themselves under Gedaliah’s orders (Jer 40 13). Ishmael the son of Nethaniah, the son of Elishama ‘‘of the seed royal’? (2 K 26 25) was among their number—all of which must have been rather gratifying to the new governor. But he was destined to be cruelly disappointed. A traitor was among the captains that had gathered around him. Yet the governor might have pre- vented his dastardly scheme. Johanan, the son of Kareah, and other loyal captains warned him of the treachery of Ishmael, telling him he was induced by Baalis, the Ammonite king, to assassinate the governor. But the governor’s faith in Ishmael was not to be shaken; he even looked upon Joha- nan’s report as false and calumnious (Jer 40 16). About 2 months after the destruction of Jerus, Ishmael was ready to strike the mortal blow. With 10 men he came to Mizpah, and there, at a banquet given in his honor, he killed Gedaliah and all the Jews and Chaldacans that were with him. He suc- ceeded in keeping the matter secret, for, 2 days after the horrible deed, he persuaded a party of 80 pious Jews to enter the city and killed all but 10 of them, throwing their bodies into a pit. These men were coming from the ruins of the Temple with the offer- ings which they had intended to leave at Jerus. Now they had found out, to their great distraction, that the city was laid waste and the Temple de- stroyed. So they passed by Mizpah, their beards shaven, their clothes rent, and with cuts about their persons (Jer 41 5). We may, indeed, ask indig- nantly, Why this new atrocity? The answer may he found in the fact that Ishmael did not kill all of the men. He spared 10 of them because they promised him some hidden treasures. This shows his motive. He was a desperate man and just then carrying out a desperate undertaking. He killed those peaceful citizens because of their money, and money he needed to realize his plans. They were those of a traitor to his country, inasmuch as he intended to deport the inhabitants of Mizpah to the land of his high confederate, the king of the Am- monites. Among the captives were Jeremiah and the daughters of the Jewish king. But his efforts came to naught. When Johanan and the other captains were told of Ishmael’s unheard-of actions, they immediately pursued the desperate adven- turer and overtook him by the “great waters that are in Gibeon.’’ Unfortunately, they failed to capture Ishmael; for he managed to escape with eight men to the Ammonites. See, further, Grpa- LIAH. (3) A descendant of Benjamin and the son of Azel (1 Ch 8 38; cf 9 44). (4) The father of Zebadiah who was “the ruler of the house of Judah, in all the king’s [Jehoshaphat, 2 Ch 19 8] matters” (2 Ch 19 11). ; (5) The son of Jehohanan, and a “captain of hundreds,” who lived at the time of Jehoiada and Joash (2 Ch 23 1). ; (6) One of the sons of Pashhur the priest. He was one of those men who had married foreign women and were compelled to “put away their wives” (Ezr 10 22). WititiamM Baur ISHMAEL (Icpasa, Ismaél): (1) AV “Ismael” (Jth 2 23), the son of Abraham by Hagar. (2) 1 Esd 9 22 (AV, RV “‘Ismael”’), corresponding to Ishmael in Ezr 10 22. See preceding art. ISHMAELITES, ish’mi-el-its (O"SNINW, yish- mé lim): The supposed descendants of Ishmael, the son of Abraham and Hagar, whom Abraham sent away from him after the birth of Isaac (Gen 21 j4-21). The sons of Ishmael are given in Gen 25 13.14; they were twelve in number and gave rise to as many tribes, but the term Ishmaelite has a broader signification, as appears from Gen 37 28. 36, where it is identified with Midianite. From Gen 16 12 it may be inferred that it was applied to the Bedawin of the desert region E. of the Jordan generally, for the character there assigned to Ish- mael, “His hand shall be against every man, and every man’s hand against him,” fits the habits of Bedawin in all ages. Such was the character of the Midianites as described in Jgs 7, who are again identified with the Ishmaelites (8 24). These ref- erences show that the Ishmaelites were not confined to the descendants of the son of Abraham and Hagar, but refer to the desert tribes in general, like “the children of the east’? (Jgs 7 12). . H. Porter ISHMAIAH, ish-ma’ya (“2Y2U", yishmatyah, ‘Jeh is hearing’): (1) A man of Gibeon, chief of David's 30 great warriors, who came to him at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 4, AV “Ismaiah’’). (2) Chief of the armed contingent of the tribe of Zebulun, which served David in the monthly order of the tribes (1 Ch 27 19). ISHMEELITES, ish’mécl-its (NPD, yish- melt). See IsHMAELITEs. ISHMERAI, ish’mé-ri (WW, yishmeray, from shamar, meaning ‘to hedge about,” i.e. “io guard,” 1811 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA [shmael Israel, History of and therefore a “guard,” “‘protector’): A deseend- ant of Benjamin, son of Epaal, resident of Jerus, one of the “heads of fathers’ houses throughout their generations, chief men’ (1 Ch 8 18). ISHOD, i’shod, ish’od (THAW, ’ishehddh): AV 1 Ch 7 18 for IsHHon (q.v.). ISHPAH, ish’pa (MED, yishpah, “firm,” “strong’): A man of the tribe of Benjamin, of the house of Beriah (1 Ch 8 16). ISHPAN, ish’pan (jBW , yishpan, lit. “he will hide’): Descendant of Benjamin, son of Shashak, one of “the chief men, heads of fathers’ houses”; lived at Jerus (1 Ch 8 22). ISH-SECHEL, ish’sé-kel (3 DN, “ish sekhel, “man of discretion’): Ezra, at one time in need of ministers for the house of God, sent ‘unto Iddo the chief at the place Casiphia.” ‘And according to the good hand of our God upon us they brought us a man of discretion [m “‘Ish-sechel’’], of the sons of Mahli, the son of Levi, the son of Israel” (Ear 8 18). This is the only reference to Ish-sechel. ISH-TOB, ish’tob (ATQ WX, ’ish tabh, ARV “the men of Tob’): A place in Pal, probably a small kingdom, large enough, however, to supply at least 12,000 men of valor to the children of Ammon in their struggle against Joab, David’s general (2 S 10 6.8). See Isx. ISHUAH, ish’d-a, ISUAH, is’ti-a (TIW>, yish- wah, lit. “he will level’). See Isuuar; IsHvau; IsuHvI. ISHUAI, ish’t-i, ISHUI, ish’i-i (I, yishu7, “level’’). See Isuvi. ISHVAH, ish’va (MNW", yishwah, “even,” “level’’; AV Ishuah and Isuah): Second son of Asher (Gen 46 17; 1 Ch 7 30). As only the families of his brothers Ishvi, etc, are mentioned in Nu 26 44, the supposition is that he left no issue. ISHVI, ish’vi (W", yishwi, “equal’’): (1) The third son of Asher (Gen 46 17; 1 Ch 7 30), and founder of the family of the Ishvites (Nu 26 44, AV “Jesuites’), AV ‘Tsui,’ “Jesui,’”’ and “Tshui.”” 2) The name is also found among the sons of Saul (1 S 14 49), AV “Ishui.” ISLAND, i’land, ISLE, il ([1] "&, *z, “island” or ‘isle’; ARV has “eoast” or ‘“coast-land” in Isa 20 6; 23 2.6; RVm has “coast-lands”’ in Gen 10 5; Isa 11 11; 24 15; 69 18; Jer 25 22; Ezk 39 6; Dnl 11 18; Zeph 2 11; RVm has “sea-coast” in Jer 47 4. [2] pl. DYN, 'tytm, AV “wild beasts of the islands,” RV ‘wolves,’ RVm “howling creatures” [Isa 13 22; 34 14; Jer 50 39]. [3] vyclor, néston, “small island” [Acts 27 16]. [4] vfjcos, nésos, ‘island’ [Acts 13 6; 27 26; 28 1.7.9.11; Rev 1 9; 6 14; 16 20]): Except as noted above, ‘2 in RV is tr? “‘isle”’ or “island.”’ Arvap (q.v.), a Phoen island-eity N. of Tripoli, Syria, is mentioned in Gen 10 18; 1 Ch 116; Ezk 27 8.11. This and Tyre were the only important islands on the coast, both of them very small. We find references to Kittim or Chittim, Cyprus (Gen 104; Nu 24 24; 1 Ch17; Isa 93 1.12; Jer 210; Ezk 27 6; Dnl 11 30); to Elishah, perhaps Carthage (Gen 10 4; 1 Ch 1 7; Ezk 27 7); to “isles of the nations’ (Gen 10 5; Zeph 2 11) 5 to “isles of the sea’ (Est 10 1; Isa 11 11; 24 15; Ezk 26 18); to ‘‘Tarshish and the isles’ (Ps 72 10; cf Isa 66 19); to “isle [RVm “‘sea-coast”] of Caphtor”’ (Jer 47 4). Communica- tion with these islands or distant coasts is kept up by the Tyrians (Ezk 27 3.15). The Jews were not a maritime people, and in early times their geo- graphical knowledge was very limited. Of 32 OT passages referring to ‘island’ or “‘isle,”’ 25 are in Isa, Jer, and Ezk. In the NT, besides the passages noted above, and Patmos (Rev 1 9), various islands are mentioned by name in connection with the voy- ages of St. Paul, e.g. Cyprus, Crete, Lesbos, Samos, Samothrace, Chios, Melita, Sicily (Syracuse, Acts 28 12). “Jackals” is a perfectly possible tr of ‘tym (AV “wild beasts of the islands,’ RV “wolves,” RVm “howling creatures”). See Coast; GEOGRAPHY; JACKAL; WOLF. Aurrep Exiy Day ISLES OF THE GENTILES (Gen 10 5): ARV ‘Ssles [m ‘‘coast-lands”] of the nations,”’ said of the territories of the sons of Japheth. The reference is to the eoasts of the Western Mediterranean, with their islands (cf ‘isles of the sea,” Est 10 1; Ezk 26 18, etc). See TaBLe or Narrons. ISMACHIAH, is-ma-ki’a (WWD, yismakh- yaha, “Jeh will sustain”): One of the “overseers under the hand of Conaniah and Shimei his brother, by the appointment of Hezekiah the king, and Azariah the ruler of the house of God” (2 Ch 31 18). ISMAEL, is’m4-el. See IsHmar.. ISMAERUS, is-ma-é’rus (Iepdypos, Ismdéros): AV “Omaerus’” (1 Esd 9 34), corresponding to Amram ion Ezr 10 34. ISMAIAH, is-ma’ya. ISPAH, is’pa. ISRAEL, iz’ra-el. ISRAEL, HISTORY OF THE PEOPLE: INTRODUCTORY 1. Sources (1) The OT *5 Josephus (3) The Monuments 2. Religious Character of the History . Onieins oF IsRAEL IN Pre-Mosaic Times 1. Original Home 2. 3 See Isumatau. See Isupan, See Jacos. Ethnographical Origin . Patriarchal Origins and History (1) Patriarchal Conditions—Gen 14 $33 Ideas of God 3) Descent into Egypt II. Nationality UNDER MossEs 1. Israel in Egypt (1) Chronology 2) Moses 2. Historical Character of the Exodus 0 Egyptian Version of the Exodus 3 Geographical Matters (3) The Wilderness Sojourn {4) Entrance into Canaan III. Periop or THE JUDGES 1. General Character of Period . The Different Judges — . Chronology of the Period . Loose Organization of the People HE Kinepom: IsRaEL-JuDAH Samuel The Kingdom of Saul David who IV. Solomon . Division of the Kingdom . Sources of the History of the Kingdom . Chronological Matters V. Periop or tHE Separatep Krnopoms 1. Contrasts and Vicissitudes of the Kingdoms 2. The Successive Reigns—Jeroboam I, etc 3. The Literary Prophets VI. Time oF THE BABYLONIAN EXILE 1. Influence of the Exile 2. Daniel 2 3. Elephantine Papyri NOSP WD Pap Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1512 VII. Return rrom tHe EXiLe anp THE ResTORATION 1. Career of Cyrus 2. First_ Return under Zerubbabel (1) Building of the Temple (2) Haggai and Zechariah 3. Ezra and Nehemiah Malachi Tue Jews uNpDER ALEXANDER aNp His Suc- CESSORS 1. Spread of Hellenism 2. The Hasmoneans 3. Herod IX. Tus Romans 1. Division of Territory 2. Destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans Later Insurrection of Bar-Cochba 3. Spiritual Life of Period Appearance of Jesus Christ LITERATURE Introductory.—The chief and best source from which we can learn who this people was and what was its history is the Bible itself, esp. 1. Sources the OT, which tells us the story of this people from its earliest beginnings. (1) In the OT —The origins of Israel are narrated in Gen; the establishment of the theocracy, in the other books of the Pent; the entrance into Canaan, in the Book of Josh; the period preceding the kings, in the Book of Jgs; the establishment of the mon- archy and its development, in the Books of 8, and the opening chapters of the Books of K, which latter report also the division into two kingdoms and the history of these down to their overthrow. The Books of Ch contain, || with the books already men- tioned, a survey of the historical development from Adam down,to the Bab captivity, but confine this account to the theocratical center of this history and its sphere. Connected with Ch are found the small Books of Ezr and Neh, which probably origi- nally constituted a part of Ch, but which pass over the Exile and begin at once with the story of the Return. Then, too, these two books contain only certain episodes in the history of the Return, which were of importance for the restoration of the Jewish theocracy, so that the story found in them is any- thing but complete. With the 5th cent. BC the Bib. narrative closes entirely. For the succeeding centuries we have nothing but some scattered data; but for the 2d pre-Christian cent. we have a new source in the Books of the Macc, which give a con- nected account of the struggles and the rule of the Asmoneans, which reach, however, only from 174 to 185 BC. The historical value of the OT books is all the greater the nearer the narrator or his sources stand in point of time to the events that are recorded; e.g. the contents of the Books of K have in general greater value as historical sources than what is reported in the Books of Ch, written at a much later period. Yet it is possible that a later chronicler could have made use of old sources which earlier narrators had failed to employ. This is the actual state of affairs in connection with a considerable number of matters reported by the Bib. chroniclers, which supplement the exceedingly meager extracts furnished by the author of the Books of K. Then, further, the books of the prophets possess an ex- traordinary value as historical sources for the special reason that they furnish illustrations of the histori- cal situation and events from the lips of contempora- ries. As an example we can refer to the externally flourishing condition of the kingdom of Judah under King Uzziah, concerning which the Books of K report practically nothing, but of which Ch give details which are confirmed by the testimony of Isaiah. (2) Josephus ——A connected account of the his- tory of Israel has been furnished by Flavius Jose- phus. His work entitled Jewish Antiquities, how- ever, as far as trustworthiness is concerned, is again considerably inferior to the Books of Ch, since the later traditions of the Jews to a still greater extent VIII. influenced his account. Only in those cases in which he could make use of foreign older sources, such as the Egyp Manetho or Phoen authors, does he furnish us with valuable material. Then for the last few centuries preceding his age, he fills out a certain want. Esp. is he the best authority for the events which he himself passed through and which he reports in his work on the Jewish Wars, even if he is not free from certain personal prejudices (see JosErpHUS, Fiavius). For the customs and usages of the later Jewish times the traditions de- posited in the Talm are also to be considered. Much less than to Jos can any historical value be credited tothe Alexandrian Jew, Philo. Theforeign authors, e.g. the Gr and the Lat historians, contain data only for the story of the nations surrounding Israel, but not for the early history of Israel itself. (3) The Monuments On the other hand, the early history of Israel has been wonderfully en- riched in recent times through the testimonies of the monuments. In Pal itself the finds in historical data and monuments have been, up to the present time, rather meager. Yet the excavations on the sites of ancient Taanach, Megiddo, Jericho, Gezer and Samaria have brought important material to light, and we have reasons to look for further archae- ological and literary finds, which may throw a clear light on many points that have remained dark and uncertain. Also in lands round about Pal, impor- tant documents (the Moabite Stone; Phoen inscrip- tions) have already been found. Esp. have the discovery and interpretation of the monuments found in Egypt, Assyria and Babylonia very materi- ally advanced our knowledge of the history of Israel. Not only has the connection of the history of this people with universal history been clearly illumi- nated by these finds, but the history of Israel itself has gained in tangible reality. In some detail matters, traditional ideas have given way to clearer conceptions; e.g. the chronology of the OT, through Assyriological research, has been set on a safer foundation. Butallin all, these archaeological dis- coveries have confirmed the confidence that has been placed in the Bib. historical sources. It is true that the rulos applied to profane history cannot, without modification, be applied to the his- torical writings of the Hebrews. The 2. Religious Bib. narrators are concerned about Character something more than the preservation of the of historical facts and data. Just as History little is it their purpose to glorify their people or their rulers, as this is done’ on the memorial tablets of the Egyp, the Assyr, and the Bab kings. Looked at merely from the standpoint of profane history, there are many omis- sions in the OT historical books that are found objectionable. Sometimes whole periods are passed over or treated very briefly. Then, too, the political pragmatism, the secular connection in the move- ments of the nations and historical events, are often scarcely mentioned. The standpoint of the writer is the religious. This appears in the fact that this history begins with the creation of the world and reports primitive traditions concerning the origin of mankind and their earliest history in the light of the revelation of the God of Israel, and that it makes this national history a member in the general historical development of mankind. Nor was this first done by the author of the Pent in its present shape. Already the different documentary sources found combined in the Pent, namely E, J and P, depict the history of Israel according to the plan which the Creator of the world had with this people. Also, when they narrate the national vicissitudes of Israel, the writers are concerned chiefly to exhibit clearly the providential guidance of God. They give special prominence to those events in which 1518 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of the hand of God manifests itself, and describe with full detail the lives of those agents of whom Jeh made use in order to guide His people, such as Moses, Samuel, David, Solomon and others. But it is not the glory of these men themselves that the writers aim to describe, but rather their im- portance for the spiritual and religious greatness of Israel. Let us note in this connection only the extreme brevity with which the politically success- ful wars of David are reported in 28; and how frag- mentary are the notices in which the author of the Books of K reports the reigns of the different kings; and how briefly he refers for all the other details | of these kings to books that, unfortunately, have been lost for us. But, on the other hand, how full are the details when the Bible gives us its account of the early history of a Samuel or of a David, in which the providential guidance and protection of Jeh appear in such a tangible form; or when it describes the building of the temple by Solomon, so epoch-making for the religious history of Israel, or the activity of such leading prophets as Elijah and Elisha. Much less the deeds of man than the deeds of God in the midst of His people constitute the theme of the narrators. These facts explain, too, the phenomenal impartiality, otherwise unknown in ancient literatures, with which the weaknesses and the faults of the ancestors and kings of Israel are reported by the Bib. writers, even in the case of their most revered kings, or with which even the most dis- graceful defeats of the people are narrated. It cannot indeed be denied that this religious and fundamental characteristic is not found to the same degree in all the books and sources. The oldest narratives concerning Jacob, Joseph, the Judges, David and others reveal a naive and childlike natur- alness, while in the Books of Ch only those things have been admitted which are in harmony with the regular cultus. The stories of a Samson, Jeph- thah, Abimelech, Barak, and others impress us often as the myths or stories of old heroes, such as we find in the traditions of other nations. But the author of the Book of Jgs, who wrote the introduc- tion to the work, describes the whole story from the standpoint of edification. And when closely ex- amined, it is found that the religious element is not lacking, even in the primitive and naive OT narra- tive. ‘This factor was, from the outset, a unique characteristic of the people and its history. To this factor Israel owed its individuality and existence as a separate people among the nations. But in course of time it became more and more conscious of its mission of being the people of Jeh on earth, and it learned to understand its entire history from this viewpoint. Accordingly, any account of Israel’s history must pay special attention to its religious development. For the significance of this history lies for us in this, that it constitutes the preparation for the highest revelation in Christ Jesus. In its innermost heart and kernel it is the history of the redemption of mankind. This it is that gives to this history its phenomenal character. The persons and the events that constitute this history must not be measured by the standards of everyday life. If in this history we find the provi- dential activities of the living God operative in a unique way, this need not strike us as strange, since also the full fruit of this historical development, namely the appearance of Jesus Christ, transcends by far the ordinary course of human history. On the other hand, this history of Israel is not to be regarded as a purely isolated factor. Modern re- searches have shown how intimately this history was interwoven with that of other nations. Already, between the religious forms of the OT and those of other Sem peoples, there have been found many relations. Religious expressions and forms of worship among the Israelites often show in lan- guage and in cultus a similarity to those of the an- cient Canaanites, the Phoenicians, the Syrians, the Babylonians, and the Egyptians. But it is a mis- take to believe that the history and the religion of Israel are merely an offspring of the Bab. As the Israelites clung tenaciously to their national life, even when they were surrounded by powerful nations, or were even scattered among these na- tions, as in the Exile, thus too their religion, at least in its official representatives, bas been able at all times to preserve a very high originality and independence under the influence of the Divine Spirit, who had filled it. I. Origins of Israel in Pre-Mosaic Times.—The Israelites knew at all times that Canaan was not their original home, but that their 1. Original ancestors had immigrated into this Home land. What was their earlier and earliest home? Tradition states that they immigrated from Haran in the upper Eu- phrates valley. But it is claimed that they came to Haran from Ur of the Chaldees, i.e. from a city in Southern Babylonia, now called Mugheir. This city of Ur, now well known from Bab inscriptions, was certainly not the original home of the ancestors of Israel. They rather belonged to a purely Sem tribe, which had found its way from’ Northern Arabia into these districts. A striking confirma- tion of this view is found in a mural picture on the rock-tombs of Benihassan in Upper Egypt. The foreigners, of whom pictures are here given (from the time of the XIIth Dynasty), called Amu, namely Bedouins from Northern Arabia or from the Sinai peninsula, show such indisputable Jewish physiognomies that they must have been closely related to the stock of Abraham. Then, too, the leader of the caravan, Ebsha‘a (Abishua), has a name formed just like that of Abraham. When, in later times, Moses fled to the country of the Midianites, he doubtless was welcomed by such tribal relatives. The Israelites at all times laid stress on their ethnographical connection with other nations. They knew that they were intimately 2. Ethno- related to a group of peoples who have graphical the name of Hebrews. But they Origin traced their origin still farther back to the tribal founder, Shem. Lin- guistics and ethnology confirm, in general, the closer connection between the Sem tribes mentioned in Gen 10 21 ff. Undeniable is this connection in the cases of Assur, Aram, and the different Arabian tribes. A narrower group of Semites is called Hebrews. ‘This term is used in Gen in a wider sense of the word than is the case in later times, when it was employed as a synonym for Israel. According to its etymology, the word signified “‘those beyond,” those who live on the other side of the river or have come over from the other side. The river meant is not the Jordan, but the Euphrates. About the same time that the ancestors of Israel were immi- grating into Canaan and Egypt, other tribes also emigrated westward and were called, by the Ca- naanites and by the Egyptians, ‘ibhrim. This term is identical with Habiri, found in-the Am Tab, in which complaint is made about the inroads of such tribes. The Israelites cannot have been meant here, but related tribes are. Possibly the Egyp Apriu is the same word. The Israelites declared that they were descended from @ particular family. On account of the patriarchal char- acter of their old_tribal life, it is not a 8. Patri- matter of douht that, as a fact, the tribe archal did grow out of a single family. The tri- SEs bal father, Abraham, was without a doubt Origins and the head of the small tribe, which through History its large family of_children developed into different tribes. Only we must not forget that such a tribe could rapidly be enlarged by receiving Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1514 into lt also serfs and clients (cf Gen 14 14). These last- mentioned also regarded the head of the tribe as their father and considered themselves as his ‘‘sons,"’ without really being his descendants. Possibly the tribe that immigrated first to Haran and from there to Canaan was already more numerous than would seem to be the case according to tradition, which takes into considera- tion only the leading personalities. Secondly, we must remember that the Israelites, because of their patriarchal life, had become accustomed to clothe all the relations of nations to nations in the scheme of the family. In this way such genealogies of nations as are found in Gen 10 and 11 originated. Here peoples, cities and countries have also been placed in the genealogies, without the author himself thinking of individual persons in this connection, who had borne the names, e.g. of Mizraim (Egypt), Cush (Ethiopia), etc, and were actually sons of Ham. The purpose of the genealogy in this form is to express only the closer or more remote relationship or connection to a group of nations. Gen 25 1ff also is a telling example, showing how independently these groups are united. A new wife (Keturah) does not_at this place fit into the family history of Abraham. But the writer still wants to make mention of an Arabian group, which was also related to Israel by blood, but in fact stood more distant from the Israelites than did the Ishmaelites. Out of this systematic further development of the living tradition, however, one difficulty arises. It is not in all place easy, indeed not always possible, to draw the e between what is reliable tradition and what is a freer continuation. But it is a misinterpretation of the his- torical situation, when the entire history of the patri- archs is declared to be incredihle, and when in such sharply defined personalities as Abraham, Jacob, Joseph, and others, only personifications of tribes are found, the later history of which tribes is said to be embodied in the lives of these men; e.g. the name Abraham cannot have been the impersonal name of a tribe or of agod. It is found as the name of a person on old Bab tablets (Abu ramu); but originally in the nomadic tribe was doubtless pronounced ‘abhi ram, i.e. ‘‘My father [God] is exalted.'' The same is true of the name Jacob (really Jakoh-el); cf Joseph (Joseph-el), Ishmael, and others, which find their analogies in old Arabian names. (1) Patriarchal conditions—Gen 14.—Further, the conditions of life which are presupposed in the history of the Patriarchs are in perfect agreement with those which from the Am Tab we learn existed in Canaan. While formerly it was maintained that it would have been impossible for a single tribe to force its way into Canaan at that time when the country was thickly populated, it is now known that at that very time when the ancestors of the Israelites entered, similar tribes also found their way into the land, sometimes in a peaceable way, sometimes by force. Egypt for the time being had control of the land, but its supremacy was at no place very strong. And the ‘tbhrim, as did others who forced their way into the country, caused the inhabitants much trouble. Esp. does Gen 14, the only episode in which a piece of universal history finds its way into the story of the tribal ancestors, turn out to be a document of great value, which reflects beautifully the condition of affairs m Asia. Such expeditions for conquest in the direction of the Mediterranean lands were undertaken at an early period by Bab rulers, Sargon I of Akkad and his son Naram Sin. The latter undertook an expe- dition to the land of Magan along the exact way of the expedition described in Gen 14, this taking place in the days of Amraphel, i.e. Hammurabi. The fact that the latter was himself under an Ela- mitic superior is in perfect agreement with the story of the inscriptions, according to which the famous Hammurabi of Babylon had first freed himself from the supremacy of Elam. The fact that Ham- murabi, according to accepted chronology, ruled shortly after the year 2000 BC, is also in agreement with Bib. chronology, which places Abraham in this very time. These expeditions into the country Martu, as the Babylonians call Syria, had for their purpose chiefly to secure booty and to levy tribute. That the allied kings themselves took part in this expedition is not probable. These were punitive expeditions undertaken with a small force. This ch 14 of Gen seems to be a translation of an old cuneiform tablet. As a rule the stories of the patri- archal age for a long time were handed down orally, and naturally were modified to a certain extent. Then, too, scholars have long since discovered different sources, out of which the story in its present form has been compiled. This fact explains some irregularities in the story: e.g. the chronological data of the document P, which ar- ranges its contents systematically, do not always har- monize with the order of events as reported by the other two leading documents, E and J, the first of which is per- haps the Ephraimitic and the second the Judaic version of the story. But, under all circumstances, much greater than the difference are the agreements of the sources. They, contain the same picture of this period, which certainly has not been modified to glorify the partici- pants. Itis easily seen that the situation of the fathers, when they were strangers in the land, was anything but comfortable. A poetical or perfectly fictitious popular account would have told altogether different deeds of heroism of the founder of the people. The weaknesses and the faults of the fathers and mothers in the patri- archal families are not passed over in silence. But the fact that Jeh, whom they trusted at all times, helped them through and did not suffer them to be destroyed, but in them laid the foundation for the future of His people, is the golden cord that runs through the whole history. And in this the difference between the indi- vidual characters finds a sharp expression; e.g. Abra- ham's magnanimity and tender feeling of honor im refer- ence to his advantage in worldly matters find their ex- pression in narratives which are ascribed to altogether different sources, as Gen 13 8ff (J), 14 22 ff (special source); 23.7ff (P). In what an altogether different way Jacob insists upon his advantage! This consist- ency in the way in which the different characters are portrayed must awaken confidence in the historical character of the narratives. Then, too, the harmony with Egyp manners and customs in the story of a even in its minutest details, as these have been empha- sized particularly by the Egyptologist Ebers, speaks for this historical trustworthiness. (2) Ideas of God.—Further, the conception of God as held by these fathers was still of a primitive char- acter, but it contains the elements of the later re- ligious development (see IskaEL, RELIGION OF). (3) Descent into Egypt.—During a long period of famine the sons of Jacob, through Divine provi- dence, which made use of Joseph as an instrument, found refuge in Egypt, in the marshes of which country along the lower Nile Sem tribes had not seldom had their temporary abodes. The land of Goshen in the N.E. part of the Delta, Ed. Naville (The Shrine of Saft-el-Henneh and the Land of Goshen, London, 1887) has shown to be the region about Phakusa (Saft-el-Henneh). These regions had at that time not yet been made a part of the strictly organized and governed country of Egypt, and could accordingly still be left to such nomadic tribes. For the sons of Jacob were still wandering shepherds, even if they did, here and there, after the manner of such tribes, change to agricultural pursuits (Gen 26 12). If, as is probable, at that time a dynasty of Sem Hyksos was ruling in lower Egypt, it is all the more easily understood that kindred tribes of this character were fond of settling along these border districts. On account of the fertility of the amply watered districts, men and animals could increase rapidly, and the virile tribe could, in the course of a few centuries, grow into a powerful nation. One portion of the tribes pastured their flocks back and forth on the prairies; another builded houses for themselves among the Egyptians and engaged in agricultural pursuits and in garden- ing (Nu 11 5). Egyp arts and trades also found their way among this people, as also doubtless the art of writing, at least in the case of certain indi- viduals. In this way their sojourning in this country became a fruitful factor in the education of the people. This stay explains in part the fact that the Israelites at all times were more receptive of culture and were more capable than their kins- men, the Edomites, Ammonites and Moabites, and others in this respect. Moses, like Joseph, had learned all the mysteries of Egyp wisdom. On the other band, the sojourn in this old, civilized country was a danger to the religion of the people of Israel. According to the testimony of Josh 24 14; Ezk 20 7 ff; 23 8.19, they adopted many 1515 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of heathen customs from their neighbors. It was salutary for them, that the memory of this sojourn was embittered for them by hard oppression. If, Nationality under Moses.—It is reported in Ex 1 8 that a new Pharaoh ascended the throne, who knew nothing of Joseph. This 1. Israel doubtless means that a new dynasty in Egypt came into power, which adopted a new policy in the treatment of the Sem neighbors. The expulsion of the Hyksos had pre- ceded this, and the opposition to the Semitics had become more acute. The new government devel- oped a strong tendency to expansion in the direction of the N.E. Under these circumstances it is not sur- prising that the laws of the empire were vigorously enforced in these border districts and that an end was made to the liberties of the unwelcome shepherd tribes. Thisled to constantly increasing measures of severity. In this way the people became more and more unhappy and finally were forced to emigrate. (1) Chronology —lIt is still the current convic- tion that the Pharaoh of the oppression was Ramescs II, a king who was extraordinarily am- bitious of building, whose long reign is by Eduard Meyer placed as late as 1310 to 1244 BC. His son Merenptah would then be the Pharaoh of the Exodus. But on this supposition, Bib. chronology not only becomes involved in serious difficulties, since then the time of the Judges must be cut down to unduly small proportions, but certain definite data also speak in favor of an earlier date for the Exodus of Israel. Merenptah boasts in an inscrip- tion that on an expedition to Syria he destroyed the men of Israel (which name occurs here for the first time on an Egyp monument). And even the father of Rameses II, namely Seti, mentions Asher among those whom he conquered in Northern Pal, that is, in the district afterward occupied by this tribe. These data justify the view that the Exodus already took place in the time of the XVIIIth Dynasty, a thing in itself probable, since the energetic rulers of this dynasty naturally have inaugurated a new method of treating this province. The oppression of Israel would then, perhaps, be the work of Thoth- mes III (according, to Meyer, 1501-1447 BC), and the Exodus would take place under his successor, Amenophis II. In harmony with this is the claim of Manetho, who declares that the ‘Lepers,”’ in whom we recognize the Israelites (see below), were expelled by King Amenophis. The length of the sojourn of the Israelites in Egypt, according to Gen 15 13 (P), was in round numbers 400 years; more exactly, according to Ex 12 40f (P), 430 years. But the last-mentioned passage in LXX reads, “the sojourn of the sons of Jacob, when they lived in Egypt and in the land of Canaan.” (The same reading is found in the Sam text, only that the land of Canaan precedes that of Egypt.) Since, according to this source (P), the Patriarchs lived 215 years in Canaan, the sojourn in Egypt would be reduced also 215 years. This is the way in which the synagogue reckons (cf Gal 3 17), as also Jos (Ant, II, xv, 2). In favor of this shorter period appeal is made to the genealogical lists, which, however, because they are incomplete, cannot decide the matter. In favor of a longer duration of this sojourn we can appeal, not only to Gen 15 13 (LXX has the same!), but also to the large number of those who left Egypt according to Nu 1 and 26 (P), even if the number of 600,000 men there mentioned, which would presuppose a nation of about two million souls, is based on a later calculation and gives us an impos- sible conception of the Exodus. (2) Moses.—While no account has been preserved. concerning the sojourn of the Israelites in Egypt, the history of the Exodus itself, which signifies the birth of Israel as a nation, isfully reported. In this crisis Moses is the prophetical mediator through whom the wonderful deed of God is accomplished. All the deeds of God, when interpreted by this prophet, become revelations for the people. Moses himself had no other authority or power than that which was secured for him through his office as the organ of God. He was the human instrument to bring about the synthesis between Israel and Jeh for all times. He had, in doing this, indeed pro- claimed the old God of the fathers, but under the new, or at any rate hitherto to the people unknown, name of Jeh, which is a characteristic mark of the Mosaic revelations to such an extent, that the more accurate narrators (H and P) begin to make use of this name only from this period of time on. In the name of this absolute sovereign, God, Moses claims liberty for Israel, since this people was Jeh’s firstborn (Ex 4 22). The contest which Moses carries on in the name of this God with Pharaoh becomes more and more a struggle between this God and the gods of Egypt, whose earthly repre- sentative Pharaoh is. The plagues which come over Egypt are all founded on the natural conditions of the country, but they occur in such extraordinary strength and rapidity at Moses’ prediction, and even appear at his command, that they convince the people, and finally Pharaoh himself, of the omnipotence of this God on the soil of this country. In the same way the act of deliverance at the Red Sca can be explained as the coéperation of natural causes, namely wind and tide. But the fact that these elementary forces, just at this critical time, proved so serviceable to the people of God and de- structive to their enemies, shows unmistakably the miraculous activity of God. This the Israelites experienced still further on the journey through the desert, when they were entirely dependent on Di- vine leadership and care. The outcome of these experiences, and at the same time its grandest demonstration, was the conclusion of the covenant at Mt. Smmai. From this time on Jeh was Israel’s God and Israel was the people of Jeh. This God claimed to be the only and ahsolute ruler over the tribes that were now inwardly united into one nation. From this resulted as a matter of_course, that Moses as the recognized organ of this God was not only the authority, who was to decide in all dis- putes concerning right, but also the one from whom a new and complete order of legal enactments pro- ceeded. Moses hecame the lawgiver of Israel. Even if the history of the origin of the OT covenant is uniqne in character, it is nevertheless profitable to take note of an analogy which is found in a related people and which is adapted to make much in Israel's history clearer. Mohammed also, after he had at the critical oint of his career persuaded his followers to migrate rom their homes, soon after, in Medina, concluded a covenant, according to which he, as the recognized speaker of Allah, claimed for himself the right to decide in all disputes. He, too, in his capacity as the prophet of God, was consulted as an infallible authority in al) questions pertaining to the cultus, the civil and the crimi- nal laws, as also in matters Bi tere to politics and to war. And his decisions and jndgments, uttered in the name of Allah, were written down and. afterward col- lected. This Koran, too, became the basis of sacred law. And by causing the hitherto divided and antagonistic tribes to subject themselves to Allah, Mohammed united these his followers into a religious communion and in this way, too, into a national body. Mohammed has indeed copied the prophecy, of earlier times, bnt the work of Moses was original in character and truly inspired by God. The historical character of the exodus out of Egypt cannot be a matter of doubt, though some suspect that the entire nation did not 2. Histori- take part in the march through the cal Char- Red Sea, but that certain tribes had acter of the before this already migrated toward Exodus the East. We must not forget that the song of victory in Ex 15 does not mention a word about Pharaoh’s being himself de- Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1516 stroyed in going through the Sea. It is only the late Ps 136 15 that presupposes this as a certainty. That an entire nation cannot emigrate in a single night cannot be maintained in view of the fact that the inhabitants of the same Wadi-Tumildt, through which Israel marched, so late as the last century, emigrated in a single night and for similar reasons (ef Sayce, Monuments, 249). (1) Egyptian version of the Exodus —The fact that, the Egyp monuments report nothing of this episode, so disgraceful to that people, is a matter of course, in view of the official character of these accounts and of their policy of passing over in abso- lute silence all disagreeable facts. And yet in the popular tradition of the people, which Manetho has handed down, there has bee preserved some evidence of this event. It is indeed true that what this author reports about the Hyksos (see above) does not belong here, as this people is not, as Jos thinks, identical with the Israelites. However (CAp, I, xxvi, 5 ff), he narrates a story which may easily be the tradition concerning the exodus of the chil- dren of Israel as changed by popular use. King Amenophis, we are told, wanted to see the gods. A seer, who bore the same name, promised that his wish would be gratified under the coudition that the country would be cleansed of lepers and all others that were unclean; and it is said that he accord- ingly drove 80,000 such persons into the stone quarries E. of the Nile. As the seer was afraid that these measures would be displeasing to the gods and bring upon the land a subjection of 13 years to the supremacy of foreigners, he gave up to these lepers the former city of the Hyksos, Avaris by name. Here they appointed a priest by the name of Osarsiph, later called Moses, as their chief, who gave them a special body of laws and in these did not spare the sacred animals. He also carried on war against the Egyptians, the Hyksos helping him, and he even governed Egypt for 13 years, after which he and his followers were driven out into Syria. Similar stories are found in Chaero- moun, Lysimachus, and others (CAp, I, xxxii, 36; cf Tacitus, Hist. v.3-5). Wheu we remember that it is nonsense to permit lepers to work in stone quarries and that the Egyptians also otherwise call the Semites Aatu, i.e. “plague,” then this story must be regarded as referring to such a non-Egyp nation. Hecataeus of Abdera has a report of this matter which is much more like the Bib. story, to the effect, namely, that a plague which had broken out in Egypt led the people to believe that the gods were angry at the Egyptians because they had neg- lected the religious cultus; for which reason they expelled all foreigners. A part of these is said to have migrated under the leadership of Moses to Judaea and there to have founded the city of Jerus (cf Diodorus Siculus x1.3; ef xxxvi.1). (2) Geographical matters.—The Red Sea, through which the Israelites went under the leadership of Moses, is without a doubt the northern extension of this body of water, which in former times reached farther inland than the present Gulf of Suez; cf Edouard Naville, The Store-City of Pithom and the Route of the Exodus, 1885; and The Route of the Exodus, 1891. This savant is entitled to the credit of having identified the station Sukkoth on the basis of the monuments; it is the modern Tell-Mashtta and identical with Pithom, which was the name of the sanctuary at that place. Later the city was called Herodpolis. The route accordingly went through the modern Wadi-Tumildi to the modern Bitter Sea, N. of Suez. It is a more difficult task to trace the route geographically on the other side of the Sea. For it is a question whether “the Mountain of Jeh,” which formed the goal of the journey, is to be located on the Sinai peninsula, or in the land of the Edomites, or even on the western coast of Arabia. A. H. Sayce and others reject the traditional location of Sinai on the peninsula named after this mountain, and declare that the Israelites marched directly eastward toward the Gulf of Akaba. The reasons for this are found in the work of Sayce, The Verdict of the Monuments, 263 fi. But even if on this supposition a number of diffi- culties fall away, there nevertheless are many argu- ments in favor of the traditional location of Sinai, esp. the grandeur of the chain itself, for which a rival worth mentioning has not been discovered in the land of the Edomites or in Northwestern Arabia. The Sinai traveler, E. H. Palmer, has also shown how splendidly the surroundings of the Sinai chain, esp. the Jebel Musa with the Ras Sufsafeh, is adapted for the purpose of concluding a covenant. (3) The wilderness sojourn.—The duration of the sojourn in the “desert” is everywhere (as in Am 5 25) given as 40 years. In harmony with this is the fact that only a few of those who had come out of Egypt lived to enter Canaan. The greater part of these 40 years the Israelites seem to have spent at Kadesh. At any rate, there was a sanctuary at that place, at which Moses administered justice, while the different tribes probably were scattered over the prairies and over the tillable districts. The central sanctuary, which Moses established, was the Tabernacle, which contained the Ark of the Cove- nant, the sanctissimum. This sacred ark with the cherubim above it represents the throne of God, -who is thought to be enthroned ahove the cherubim. The ark itself is, as it were, His footstool. As in Egyp sanctuaries not infrequently the most sacred laws are deposited beneath the feet of the statue of the gods, thus the sacred fundamental laws of God (the Decalogue), on two tablets, were deposited in this ark. This Ark of the Covenant presupposes an invisible God, who cannot be represented by any image. The other laws and ordinances of Moses covered the entire public and private legislation, given whenever the need for these made it necessary to determine such matters. In giving these laws Moses connected his system with the old traditional principles already current among the tribes. This fact is confirmed by the legal CH, which contains remarkable parallels, esp. to Ex 20—23 19. But Moses has elevated the old traditional laws of the tribes and has given them a more humane character. By putting every enactment in the light, of the reli- gion of Jeh, and by eliminating everything not in harmony with this religion, he has raised the people spiritually and morally to a higher plane. Among the people, the undercurrents of super- stition aud of immorality were indeed still strong. At the outset Moses had much to contend with in the opposition of the badly mixed mass of the peo- ple. And the fact that he was able for the period of 40 years to hold the leadership of this stubborn people without military force is a phenomenal work, which shows at all hands the wonderful co- operation of Jeh Himself. However, he did not indeed succeed in raising the entire people to the plane of his knowledge of God and of his faith in Go This generation had to die in the wilderness, because it lacked the sanctified courage to take pos- session of the land of promise. But the foundation had been laid for the theocracy, which must not in any way be identified with a hierarchy. (4) Entrance into Canaan—It was Joshua, the successor of Moses, who was enabled to finish the work and to take possession of the land. Not far from Jericho he led the people over the Jordan aud captured this city, which had been considered im- pregnable. After that, with his national army, he conquered the Canaaunitish inhabitants in several decisive battles, near Gibeon and at the waters of Caan Ve NRE Re fi “ISRAEL” STELE IN MUSEUM AT CAIRO 1517 Merom, and then went back and encainped at Gilgal on the Jordan. After this he advanced with his tribe of Ephraim into the heart of the land, while the southern tribes on their part forced thelr way into the districts assigned to them. Without reasons this account has beeu attacked as unre- liable, and critics have thought that originally the different tribes, at their own initiative, either peace- ably or by force, had occupied their land. But it is entirely natural to suppose that the inhabitants of the country who had allied themselves to resist this occupation by Israel, had first to be made sub- missive through several decisive defeats, before they would permit the entrance of the tribes of Israel, which entrance accordingly often took place without a serious struggle. That the occupation of the land was not complete is shown in detail in Jgs 1. Also in those districts in which Israel had gained the upper hand, they generally did not wage the war of annihilation that Moses had commanded, but were content with making the Canaanites, by the side of whom they settled, bondmeu and sub- jects. This relation could, in later time, easily be reversed, esp. in those cases in which the original inhabitants of the country were in the majority. Then, too, it must be remembered that the latter enjoyed a higher state of civilization than the Is- raelites. It was accordingly an easy matter for the Israelites to adopt the customs and the ideas of the Canaanites. But if this were done, their religion was also endangered. Together with the sacred “holy places” (baméth) of the original in- habitants, the altars and the sanctuaries there found also came into possession of the Israelites. Among these there were some that had been sacred to the ancestors of Israel, and with which old mem- ories were associated. As a consequence, it readily occurred that Israel appropriated also old symbols and religious ceremonies, and even the Baals and the Astartes themselves, however little this could be united in principle with the service of Jeh. But if the Israelites lost their unique religion, then their connection with the kindred tribes and their na- tional independence were soon matters of history. They were readily absorbed by the Canaanites. III. Period of the Judges.—In such a period of weakened national and religious life, it could easily happen that Israel would again lose 1. General the supremacy that it had won by the Character sword. It was possible that the of Period Canaanites could again bring into their power larger parts of the land. Also energetic and pushing nomadic tribes, such as the Ammonites, the Moabites, or other warlike peoples, such as the Philis, could bring the country under subjection, as actually did occur in the period of the Judges. The Book of Jgs reports a number of such instances of the subjection of Israel, which did not extend over the whole land, and in part occurred in different sections of the country at the same time. Judah and Simeon, the two tribes in the south, as a rule took no part in these contests, and had their own battles to fight; and the same is true of the tribes E. of the Jordan, among whom Northern Manasseh and Ephraim were in closest alliance. After a longer or shorter period of op- pression, there followed in each case a revival of the national spirit against such oppression. And in all these cases the popular hero who became the liber- ator appealed to the religious consciousness that formed a bond of union between all the Israelitish tribes and their common God Jeh. In however wild a manner the youthful vigor of the people may have found its expression on these occasions, they are nevertheless conscious of the fact that they are waging a holy war, which in every case also ended with the victory over the heathen spirit and false THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of worship that had found their way into Israel. The most precious historical monument from these times is the song of Deborah (Jgs 5), which, like a mirror, reflects faithfully the conditions of affairs, and the thoughts of that age. Jgs 17-21 belong to the beginning of this period. The first of these old stories narrates the emigration of a large portion of the tribe of Dan to the extreme north of the country and the origin of idolatry in that region (chs 17,18). But the second story, too, both in form and contents, is, at least in part, very old and its historical value is amply protected against the attacks of modern critics by Hos 9 9; 10 9. This story reports a holy war of revenge against the tribe of Benjamin, which was unwilling to render satisfaction for a nefarious crime that had been committed at Gibeah in its territory. In the feeling of close solidarity and of high responsibility which appears in connection with the punishment of this crime, we still see the influence of the periods of Moses and Joshua. First it is narrated of a king of Aram-naharaim that he had oppressed Israel for a period of 8 years Jgs 3 8). This probably means a 2. The king of the Mitanni (Sayce, Monu- Different ments, 297, 304), who at that time Judges were trying to force their way through Canaan into Egypt. It was Othniel, the Kenazite, belonging to a tribe that was related to Judah, who delivered Israel. A second liber- ator was the Benjamite Ehud, who delivered the southeastern portion of the country from the servi- tude of Eglon, the king of the Moabites, by putting the latter to death (Jgs 3 12ff), On a greater scale was the decisive battle against the Canaan- itish kings in the north, when these had formed an alliance and had subjected Israel for a period of 20 years. At the appeal of Deborah, Barak con- quered Sisera, the hostile king and leader of a mighty army of chariots, in the plain of Kishon (Jgs 4,6). Inthe same region the battle of Gideon was fought with the plundermg Bedouin swarms of the Midianites, who had repeatedly oppressed Israel (chs 6-8). Abimelech, an unworthy son of the God-fearing hero, after the death of his father, had established a local kingdom in Shechem, which stood for only a short time and came to a disgraceful end. Little more than the names are known to us of Tola, of the tribe of Issachar, and of Jair, in Gilead (10 1 ff). More fully is the story of Jephthah told, who delivered the country from the Ammonites coming from the east (ch 11), with which was also connected a struggle with the jealous Ephraimites (ch 12); and still more fully are the details reported of the personal contests of the Nazirite dimen belonging to the tribe of Dan, against the Philis making their inroads from the south, and who for many years proved to be the most dangerous enemies of Israel. All these heroes, and a few others not so well known, are called judges, and it is regularly re- ported how long each of these “judged” Israel. They were not officials in the usual sense of the term, but were liberators of the people, who, at the inspiration of Jeh, gave the signal for a holy war, After the victory they, as men of Jeh, then enjoyed distinction, at least in their own tribes; and in so far as it was through their doing that the people had been freed, they were the high- est authorities in political, legal, and probably, too, in religious questions. They are called judges in conscious contradistinction from the kingly power, which in Israel was recognized as the exclusive prerogative of Jeh, so that Gideon declined it as improper when the people wanted to make him king (8 22f). The people recognized the Spirit of Jeh in the fierce energy which came over these Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1518 men and impelled them to arouse their people out of their disgraceful lethargy. For this reason, too, they could afterward be trusted in making their judicial decisions in harmony with the mind and the Spirit of God, as this had been done already by the prophetess Deborah in the time of oppression. Yet, at least in the case of Samson (notwithstand- ing 16 31), it is not probable that he ever was en- gaged in the administration of justice. It is not even reported of him that he fought at the head of the people, but he carried on his contests with the Philis in behalf of himself individually, even if, as one consecrated of God, he were a witness for the power of God. The chronology of the period of the Judges ex- hibits some peculiar difficulties. If we add together the data that are given in succession 3. Chro- in the Book of Jgs, we get from Jgs nology of 3 8—16 31,410yearsaltogether. But the Period this number is too large to make it har- monize with the 480 years mentioned in 1K 61. Jewish tradition (e.g. Sédher ‘Olam) accordingly does not include the years of oppression in this sum, but makes them a part of the period of the individual judges. In this way about 111 years are eliminated. But evidently the redactor of the Book of Jgs did not share this view. Modern critics are of the opinion that the writer has dove- tailed two chronological methods, one of which counted on the basis of periods of forty years each, while the other was more exact and contained odd numbers. In this way we can shorten this period as does the Sédher ‘Olam. At any rate, it is justifiable, and is suggested by 10 7, to regard the oppression by the Ammonites (10 8 ff) and the oppression by the Philis (3 1ff) as contemporaneous. other events, too, which in the course of the narra- tive are related as following each other, may have taken place at the same time or in @ somewhat different sequence, as the author used different sources for the different events. But for this very reason his story deserves to be credited as historical. Such characters as Deborah, Jephthah, Ehud, Gideon, Abimelech and Samson are described as tangible historical realities. Even if, in the case of the last-mentioned, oral tradition has added decorative details to the figure, yet Samson cannot possibly be a mere mythological character, but must have been a national hero characteristic of this period, in whom are represented the abundance of physical and mental peculiarities characteristic of the youthful nation, as also their good-natured indifference and carelessness over against their treacherous enemies. The lack of a central political power made itself felt. all the more in the period of the Judges, since, because of the scattered condition of 4, Loose the people in the country that had Organiza- been so minutely parceled out, and tion of the because of the weakening of the reli- People gious enthusiasm of the preceding age, the decper unity of heart and mmd was absent. It is indeed incorrect to imagine that at this time there was a total lack of governmental authority. A patriarchal organization had been in force from the beginning. The father of the family was the lawful head of those belonging to him: and a larger clan was again subject to an “elder,” with far-reaching rights in the adminis- tration of law, but also with the duty to protect his subordinates, and in case of want to support them. Unfortunately we are nowhere informed how these elders were chosen or whether their offices were hereditary. Only a very few passages, such as Isa 3 6f, throw a certain light on the subject. This institution of the elders Moses had already found established and had developed farther (Ex 18 13 ff). It was retained in all the periods of Israel’s history. When the people began to live together in larger centers, as a natural consequence bodies of such city elders were established. The tribes, too, had “elders” at their head. But for @ united action of the whole nation this arrange- ment did not suffice; and esp. in the case of war the people of Israel felt that they were at a dis- advantage compared with their enemies, who had kings to lead them. For this reason the desire for a king steadily grew in Israel. The dictators of the period of the Judges satisfied their needs only for the time being. IV. The Kingdom: Israel-Judah.—In the time when the Israelites were oppressed by the Philis the need of a king was esp. felt. As Samson had come to his death in servitude, the people them- selves thus, at the close of this period of glorious victories, were under the supremacy of a warlike race, which had only in recent times settled on the western coast of Pal, and from this base was forcing its conquests into the heart of the country. ; After the most disastrous defeats, during which even the Ark of the Covenant was lost, there arose for the people, indeed, a father and a deliverer in the person of Samuel, who saved them during the most critical period. What his activity meant for the uplift of the people cannot be estimated too highly. He was, above all, during peace the faithful watchman of the most, sacred possessions of Israel, a prophet such as the people had not seen since the days of Moses; and he doubtless was the founder of those colonies of prophetical disciples who were in later times so influential in the development of a theo- eratical spirit in Israel. He guarded the whole nation also with all his power, by giving to them laws and cultivating piety in the land. But as Samuel, too, became old and the people concluded for good reasons that his rule would have no worthy successors, their voice 1. Samuel 2. The could no longer be silenced, and they Kingdom demanded a king. Samuel tried in of Saul vain to persuade the people to desist from their demand, which to him seemed to be an evidence of distrust in the provi- dence of Jeh, but was himself compelled, by inspi- ration of God, to submit to their wishes and anoint the new king, whom Jeh pointed out to him. It is indeed maintained by the critics that there are several accounts extant in S concerning the selection of Saul to the kingdom, and that these accounts differ in this, that the one regards the kingdom as a blessing and the other as a curse. The first view, which is said to be the older, is claimed to be found in 1S 9 1-10.16, and 11; while the second is said to be in 8; 10 17-27; 11 12-14. Whatever may be the facts in regard to these sources, this is beyond any doubt, that Samuel, the last real theocratic leader, established the kingdom. But just as little can the fact be doubted, that he took this step with inner reluctance, since in his eyes this innovation meant the discarding of the ideals of the people to which he himself had remained true during his lifetime. The demand of the people was the outgrowth of worldly motives, but Jeh brought it about, that the “Anointed of Jeh” signified an advance in the history of the kingdom of God. Saul himself, at first, in a vigorous and efficient manner, solved the immediate problems and over- came the enemies of his people. But he soon began to conceive of his kingdom after the manner of heathen kingdoms and did not subject himself to Jeh and His appointed representative. There soon arose an open conflict between him and Samuel; and the fact that the Spirit of God had departed 1519 from him appears in his melancholy state of mind, which urged him on to constantly increasing deeds of violence. That under these circumstances God’s blessing also departed from him is proved by the collapse of his life’s work in his final failures against the Philis. In contrast with this, David, his successor, the greatest king that Israel ever had, had a correct conception of this royal office, and 38. David even in his most brilliant successes did not forget that be was called to rule only as “the servant of Jeh” (by which name he, next to Moses, is called oftenest in the Bible). As a gifted ruler, he strengthened his kingdom from within, which, considering the heterogeneous char- acter of the people, was not an easy matter, and extended it without by overpowering jealous neigh- bors. In this way it was he who became the real founder of a powerful kingdom. The conquest of Jerus and its selection as the capital city also are an evidence of his political wisdom. It is indeed true that he, too, had his personal failings and that he made many mistakes, which caused him political troubles, even down to his old age. But his humil- ity at all times made him strong enough again to subject himself to the hand of Jeh, and this humility was based on the attitude of his spirit toward Jeh, which shows itself in his Pss. In this way he really came to be a connecting link between God and his people, and upon this foundation the prophets built further, who prophesied a still closer union of the two under a son of David. While Saul was a Benjamite, David was of the tribe of Judah, and was for a short time the king of this tribe in Hebron, before the other tribes, be- coming tired of the misrule of a descendant of Saul, also voluntarily chose him as their king. He soon after this established as the center of his new king- dom the city of Jerus, which really was situated on the territory that had been assigned to Benjamin; and he also set this city apart as the religious center of the people by transferring the Ark of the Cove- nant to this place. In this way David, through his wisdom and his popular bravery, succeeded in uniting the tribes more firmly under his supremacy, and esp. did he bring the tribe of Judah, which down to this time had been more for itself, into closer connection with the others. Israel under David became a prominent kingdom. This position of power was, as a matter of fact, distasteful to their neighbors round about. The Philis tried to destroy the ambitious kingdom, but were themselves re- peatedly and definitely overpowered. But other neighboring people, too, who, notwithstanding the fact that David did not assume an offensive atti- tude toward them, assumed a hostile attitude toward him, came to feel his superiority. Particularly severe and tedious was the war against the allied Ammonites and Syrians; and although the Edom- ites, too, regarded this as a favorable time for at- tacking Israel, this struggle also ended in a complete triumph for David. The surrounding countries became subject to him from the Mediterranean Sea to Hamath (2 8 8 9), and from the territory of the Lebanon, the inhabitants of which assumed a friendly attitude, to the borders of Egypt, which also recognized the new rule. Solomon, the son of David, developed inwardly the powerful kingdom which he had inherited. To his father he seemed to be the right 4. Solomon man for this because of his peaceful temperament and his high mental abilities. He justified the hopes placed in him. Out of love to Jeh he built the temple on Mt. Zion, regulated the affairs of state and the administra~ tion of justice, and by commercial treaties with the Phoenicians (King Hiram) brought about great THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of prosperity in the land. His was the “golden” period in Israel. The culture and civilization, too, of the people were materially advanced by Solomon as he widened their horizon and introduced the lit- erature of Proverbs, which had up to this time been more extensively cultivated by the neighboring people (Edom, Arabia, Egypt). He even developed this literature into a higher type. On the other hand, the brilliant reign of Solomon brought serious dangers to thenew kingdom. His liberal-mindedness in the treatment of his foreign wives, in permitting them to retain their heathen worship, probably because he thought that in the end it was the same Divinity which these women worshipped under a different form, endangered the theocracy with its serious cultus and its strict morality. Through this conduct the king necessarily forfeited the sym- pathy of the most pious Israelites. At the same time, his love for magnificent structures surpassed the measure which was regarded as correct for the “Anointed of Jeh.” Then, too, his efforts, in them- selves justifiable, to establish a more perfect organ- ization of the monarchy, produced a great deal of dissatisfaction. Solomon did not understand, as did his father, how to respect the inherited liberty-loving tendencies of his people. The heavy services and taxation, to which the people were compelled to sub- mit, were deeply felt, most of all by the Ephraimites, _ who at times had exhibited a jealous spirit, and could not forget their lost hegemony. So long, indeed, as the wise Solomon and his ad- visers were at the helm, the various rebellious tend- encies could not make themselves §. Division felt. But after his death the catas- of the trophe came. His son, Rehoboam, at Kingdom the Diet in Shechem, at which the Ephraimites placed before him a kind of capitulation before his coronation, showed that he did not at all understand the situation. His domineering attitude brought things to a head, and he must have been glad that at least the tribe of Judah remained faithful to him. The northern tribes chose for their king Jeroboam (I), who before this had already taken part in rebellious agitations, as the kingdom had been predicted to him by the prophet Ahijah (1 K 11 2 ff). Israel was torn into two parts. With this rupture the powerful kingdom estab- lished by David had reached its end. In regard to this flourishing period in Israel’s 6. Sources history we are, on the whole, well of the His- informed through the sources. Esp. tory of the in 28 9-20 and 1 K 2,3, we have Kingdom a narrator who must have been a con- , temporary of the events recorded. Klostermann surmises that this may have been Ahimaaz, the son of Zadok (2 S 16 27); while Duhm, Budde, Sellin and others believe it to have been the priest Abiathar. Less unity is in evidence in the first Book of 8, containing the history of the youth of David, which evidently was often de- scribed. The Books of Ch have only secondary value for the life of David. These books narrate in full detail the story of the preparations made by David for the erection of the temple and of his organization of the Levites. In regard to the reign of Solomon, the Books of K report more fully. Concerning the later kings, they generally give only meager extracts from more complete sources, which excerpts, however, have been shown to be reliable. The interest which the narrator has in telling his story is the religious. Esp. does he carefully note the fact as to the relation of the different kings to the cultus. Special sources have been used in com- piling the detailed stories of the great prophets Elijah and Elisha, which are inserted in the history of the two kingdoms. On the other hand, the Books Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1520 of Ch pass over entirely all reference to the work of the prophets of the Northern Kingdom, as they ignore the entire history of the Ephraimitic kingdom since the interest of these books is centered on the sanctuary in Jerus. Also in the case of the Judacan history, the much older Books of K deserve the precedence. Yet we owe to the writer of Ch a number of contributions to this history, esp. where he has made a fuller use of the sources than has been done by the author of the Books of K. The suspicion that everything which Ch contains, beyond what is to be found in K, is unhistorical, has turned out to be groundless. Thus, e.g., it would be impossible to understand the earlier prophecies of Isaiah under Jotham at all, if it did not appear from Ch to what prosperity and influ- ence the people of Jerus had by that time again attained. For it is only Ch that give us an account of the flourishing reign of his predecessor Uzziah, who is treated but briefly in K. The chronology of the earlier portions of the period of the Kings is dependent on the date of the division of the kingdom. This date 7. Chrono- can be decided on the basis of the logical careful chronological data of the Matters Books of K, which do not indeed agree in all particulars, but are to be adjusted by the Assyr chronology. If we, with Kamp- hausen, Oettli and Kittel, regard the year 937 BC as the time of the division of the kingdom, then Solomon ruled from 977 to 937; David, from 1017 to 977. The length of the reign of Saul is not known, as the text of 1S 13 1 is defective. It is very probable that we can credit him with about twenty years, according to Jos (Ant, X, viii, 4), i.e. from about 1037-1017. In this case David transferred the seat of government to Jerus about the year 1010, and the completion of the erection of the temple of Solomon took place m 966. But this basal date of 937 is not accepted as correct by all scholars. Klostermann places the date of the rupture of the kingdom in the year 978; Koehler, in 973. For later chronological data, Assyr sources are an im- portant factor. The Assyrians were accustomed to call each year after the name of an official (imu), and eponym lists are extant for 228 years. In these reference is made to an eclipse of the sun, which astronomically has been settled as having taken place on July 15, 763. We have in this list then the period from 893 to 666. On this basis, it is made possible to determine the exact dates of the different military expeditions of the Assyr rulers and their conflicts with the kings of Judah - and Israel, on the presupposition, however, that the Assyr inscriptions here used really speak of these kings, which in a number of cases is denied. Valuable help for determining the chronology of this period is the fall of Samaria in the year 722 and the expedition of Sennacherib against Jerus in 701, and then the fall of Jerus in 587 and 586. The distribution of the years between these dates to the individual kings is in places doubtful, as the numbers in the text are possibly corrupt, and in the synchronistic data of the Books of K mistakes may have been made. V. Period of the Separated Kingdoms.—The two separated kingdoms differed materially. The kingdom of Ephraim was the more 1. Contrasts powerful of the two. It embraced, and Vicis- according to an inaccurate usage of situdes of the words, 10 tribes; and to this the King- kingdom the vassals, such as Moab, doms as a rule remained subject, until they emancipated themselves. But, on the other hand, this Northern Kingdom was less firm spiritually. Even the resident city of the king changed frequently, until Omri founded the city of Samaria, which was well adapted for this purpose. The dynasties, too, were only of short duration. It occurred but rarely that one family was able to maintain its supremacy on the throne through several generations. A revolu- tionary character remained fixed in this kingdom and became its permanent weakness. On the other hand, the smaller and often overpowered kingdom of Judah, which faithfully adhered to the royal line of David, passed through dangerous crises and had many unworthy rulers. But the legitimate royal house, which had been selected by Jeh, constituted spiritually a firm bond, which kept the people united, as is seen, e.g., by a glance at the addresses of Isaiah, who is thoroughly filled with the con- viction of the importance of the house of David, no matter how unworthy the king who happened to rule might appear to him. In a religious respect, also, the arbitrary break with Zion proved to be fatal for the Northern Kingdom. Jeroboam.—It is true that faithful prophets of Jeh, such as the Abijah of Shiloh mentioned above, and Shemaiah (1 K 12 22 ff), pro- 2. The Suc- claimed that the fateful division of the cessive kingdom was a Divinely intended Reigns judgment from Jeh. But they soon were compelled to reach the conclusion that Jeroboam did not regard himself as a servant of Jeh, but as a sovereign who, through his own power and through the favor of the people, had secured the rule, and hence could arbitrarily decide all matters in reference to the cultus and the sacred sanctuaries of the people. According to his own will, and for political reasons, he established the new national sanctuary at Bethel, and another at Dan. At both shrines he caused Jeh to be wor- shipped under the image of a calf, which was to constitute a paganizing opposition to the Ark of the Covenant on Mt. Zion, even if it was the idea that Jeh, the God of the Covenant, was to be worshipped in these newimages. In doing this, the king followed ancient national customs, which had broken with the purity of the Mosaic religion (concerning, image- worship in Dan we have heard before. See GoLpEN Catr). His sojourn in Egypt, too, where he had lived as a fugitive, had doubtless furnished the king incentives in this direction. He created a priest- hood that was submissive to his wishes, and dis- regarded the opposition of the few prophets who protested against the policy of the king. His suc- cessors, too, walked “in the ways of Jeroboam.”’ The independent prophets, however, did not die out, but, rather, prophecy developed its greatest activity in this very Northern Kingdom. As arule, in its work it stood in opposition to the government, but at times it succeeded in gaining the recognition of the rulers. Omri.—The earliest times of the divided king- doms are, from a political point of view, character- ized by the fact that the kingdoms on the Euphrates and the Tigris, namely Assyria and Babylon, still had enough to do with themselves, and did not yet make any inroads into the Mediterranean lands; but, rather, it was the Syrians who first caused a good deal of trouble to the Northern Kingdom. Jero- boam did not succeed in founding a dynasty. Already his son Nadab was eliminated by a usurper Baasha. The latter’s son too, Elah, was murdered, after a reign of two years. It was not, however, his murderer Zimri, or Tibni, who strove to secure the kingdom for himself, but Omri who became king (1 K 16), and who also attained to such prominence abroad that the cuneiform inscriptions for a long time after call Israel ‘the land of Omri.” His ability as a ruler was seen in the fact that the establish- ment of Samaria as the capital city was his work. The inscription on the Mesha stone reports that he 1521 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of algo established the sovereignty of Israel vigorously on the east side of the Jordan. Ahab.—His son Ahab, too, was an energetic and brave ruler, who succeeded in gaining a number of victories over the Syrians, who were now beginning to assume the offensive in a determined manner. Then, too, he was politic enough to win over to his interests the kingdom of Judah, with which his redecessors had lived in almost constant warfare. n this policy he succeeded, because the noble and large-hearted king Jehoshaphat was more receptive to such fraternal relations than was good for him. An expedition jointly undertaken by these two kings against Syria brought Jehoshaphat into ex- treme danger and ended with the death of Ahab. Ahab’s fate was his wife Jezebel, the daughter of the Phoen king Ethbaal (Ithobal, according to Jos, Ant, VIII, xiii, 2 and CAp, I, 18), who had been a priest of Astarte. This intermarriage with a fanatical heathen family brought untold and end- less misfortune over all Israel. This bold and scheming woman planned nothing less than the overthrow of the religion of Jeh, and the substi- tution for it of the Baal and the Astarte cultus. As a first step she succeeded in having the king tolerate this religion. The leading temple in the new resi- dent city, Samaria, was dedicated to the Baal cultus. Already this introduction of a strange and lascivious ethnic religion was a great danger to the religion and the morals of the people. Hosts of Baal priests, ecstatic dervishes, traversed the country. Soon the queen undertook to persecute the faithful worshippers of Jeh. The fact that these men protested against the tolerance of this foreign false religion was interpreted as disobedience ou their part to the king. Many faithful prophets were put to death. At this critical period, when the existence of the religion of Jeh was at stake, the prophet Elijah, the Tishbite, appeared on the stage, and through a bitter struggle reéstablished the worship of Jeh. However, the fateful influence that this woman exerted was thereby not yet de- stroyed. It extended to Judah also. Rehoboam.—In the kingdom of Judah, apart from the apostasy of different tribes, which left him only the vigorous tribe of Judah and portions of Benja- min, Dan, Simeon, and Levi, Rehoboam experienced also other calamities, namely, a destructive invasion and tribute imposition by King Shishak of Egypt (Egyp Sheshonk, founder of the XXIId Dynasty; 1K 14 25f; cf 2 Ch 12 2ff). While under Sol- omon the relations of Israel to the Egyp court had in the beginning been very friendly, this was changed when a new dynasty came to the throne. After Jeroboam had failed in his first revolutionary project, he had found refuge at the court of Shishak ad 11 40). It is possible that Jeroboam made the Egyp king lustful for the treasures of Jerus. The Egyptians did not, as a matter of fact, stop at the Ephraimitic boundaries, but in part also in- vaded the territory of Jeroboam; but their chief objective was Jerus, from which they carried away the treasures that had been gathered by Solomon. On the temple wall of Karnak this Pharaoh_has inscribed the story of this victory and booty. From the names of the cities found in this inscription, we learn that this expedition extended as far as Megiddo and Taanach. : Abijah—Rehoboam was succeeded by his son Abijah, or Abijahu, according to Ch (the Abijam of K is hardly correct). He ruled only 3 years. But even during this short reign he was compelled to engage in a severe struggle with Jeroboam (1 K 15 6; see details in 2 Ch 13). Asa.—In every respect the reign of the God- fearing Asa, who sought to destroy the heathenism that had found its way into the cultus, was more fortunate. He also experienced Jeh’s wonderful help when the Cushite Zerah made an incursion into his land (2 Ch 14 8 ff), ie. probably Osor- kon I, who, however, did not belong to an Ethiopian dynasty. Possibly he is called an Ethiopian be- - cause he came into the country with Nubian troops. Less honorable was his conduct in the conflict. with Baasha. When he was sorely pressed by the latter he bought, through the payment of a large tribute, the assistance of the Syrian king, Ben-hadad I, who up to this time had been an ally of Baasha. This bribing of foreigners to fight against their own covenant people, which was afterward often re- peated, was rebuked by a bold prophet in the presence of the pious king, but the prophet was compelled to suffer abuse for his open testimony (2 Ch 16 7 ff). Jehoshaphat —A much more noble conduct charac- terized the dealings of Jehoshaphat in relation to the Northern Kingdom. His fault was that he entered too fully into the selfish offers of friendship made by Ahab. The worst step was that, in order to confirm his covenant, he took for his son Jehoram as wife, Athaliah, the danghter of Jezebel. Jehoshaphat was a chivalrous ally, who also joined Ahab’s son, Jehoram, in a dangerous war against the Moabites; as this people under their king Mesha had made themselves free from Israel and had taken the offen- sive against them. For the inner affairs of the king- dom his reign was more fortunate. He was a God- fearing and an energetic prince, who did much to elevate the people in a material and a religious way and perfected its political organization. Nor did he fail to secure some noteworthy successes. How- ever, the fact that the warning words of the prophets who rebuked him because of his alliance with the half-heathenish house of Omri were not the fanati- cal exaggerations of pessimistic seers, appears at once after his death. Jehoram.—His son Jehoram, after the manner of oriental despots, at once caused his brothers to be put to death, of which doubtless his wife Athaliah wasthe cause. This woman transplanted the policy of Jezebel to Judah, and was scheming for the down- fall of the house of David and its sanctuary. Under Jehoram the power of Judah accordingly began to sink rapidly. Edom became independent. The Philis and the Arabians sacked Jerus. Even the royal princes, with the exception of Ahaziah, the youngest son of Athaliah, were expelled. When the latter ascended the throne she had the absolute power in her hands. Jehu.—During this time the judgment over the house of Omri was fast approaching. The avenger came in the person of the impetuous Jehu, who had been anointed king by one of the disciples of Elisha in the camp of Ramoth in Gilead. According to i K 19 16, the order had already been given to Elijah to raise this man to the throne; but the com- pliance with this command appears to have been delayed. As soon as Jehu became aware that he was entrusted with this mission, he hastened to Jezreel, where Ahaziah, king of Judah, was just paying a visit to Jehoram, and slew them both. With heartless severity he extended this slaughter, not only to all the members of the house of Omri, together with Jezebel, but also to those numerous members of the Davidiec royal house who fell into his hands. He likewise destroyed the adherents of Baal, whom he had invited to their death in their sanctuary at Samaria. Deserved as this judgment. upon the house of Jeroboam was (2 K 10 30), which Jehu, according to higher command, carried out, he did this in an unholy mind and with hardness and ambitious purpose. The puritanical Rechab- ites had sanctioned his action; but as more and more the true character of Jehu began to reveal Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1522 itself, he lost the sympathies of the pious, and Hosea announced to his house the vengeance for his bloody crimes at Jezreel (Hos 1 4). _ The Assyrians.—In Jehu’s reign occurred the inroads toward the W. on the part of the Assyrians. This people already in the time of Ahab, under their king, Shalmaneser IJ, had forced their way as far as Karkar on the Orontes, and had there fought a battle in 854 with the Syrians and their allies, among whom Ahab is also mentioned, with 2,000 chariots and 10,000 soldiers. If this is really Ahab, the king of Israel, which is denied hy some, then he, at that time, fought against Assyria in conjunction with the Syrians, who otherwise had been so bitterly attacked by him. The Assyrians boast of this vic- tory, but seem to have won it at a heavy price, as they did not press on farther westward. When in 842 Shalmaneser came a second time, Jehu was certainly not among the allies of the Syrians. The Assyrians do not seem, on this occasion, to have been opposed by so powerful a league, and were able to attack the Syrians whom they conquered at Saniru (Hermon, Anti-Lebanon) in a much more determined manner. They laid siege to Damascus and laid waste the surrounding country. The Hauran and Bashan were made a desert. In their march of victory they pressed forward as far as the Mediterranean. Phoenicia and other countries hrought tribute. Among these nations Shal- maneser expressly mentions Jahua (‘“‘Jehu, the son of Omri’ [!]), who was compelled to deliver up gold and silver bars and other valuable possessions. But this expensive homage on the part of Jehu did not help much. Shalmaneser came only once more (839) into this neighborhood. After this the Assyrians did not appear again for a period of 35 years. All the more vigorously did the Syrians and other neighboring people make onslaughts on Israel. How fearfully they devasted Israc] appears from Am 1. Jehoahaz.—Under his son Jehoahaz the weakness of Israel became still greater. In his helplessness, the Lord finally sent him a deliverer (2 K 13 3 ff) This deliverer was none other than the Assyr king, Adad-nirari III (812-783), who, through a military incursion, had secured anew his supremacy over Western Asia, and had besieged the king of Damas- cus and had forced him to pay an immense tribute. In this way Israel, which had voluntarily rendered submission to him, was relieved of its embarrass- ment by the weakening of Syria. Jehoash, the son of Jehoahaz, experienced more favorable conditions. He also conquered Amaziah, the king of Judah; and his son, Jeroboam IT, even succeeded in restoring the old boundaries of the kingdom, as the prophet Jonah had predicted (2 K 14 24 ff). His reign was the last flourishing period of the kingdom of Ephraim. See, further, IsRazt, KINGDOM OF. Athaliah.—The kingdom of Judah, in the mean- while, had passed through severe crises. The most severe was caused by that Athaliah, who, after the murder of her son Ahaziah by Jehu, had secured absolute control in Jerus, and had abused this power in order to root out the family of David. Only one son of the king, Joash, escaped with his life. He, a boy of one year, was hidden in the temple by a relative, where the high priest Jehoiada, who belonged to the party opposed to the heathen- minded queen, concealed him for a period of 6 years. When the boy was 7 years old Jehoiada, at a well- timed moment, proclaimed him king. His eleva- tion to the throne, in connection with which event the terrible Athaliah was put to death, introduced at the same time an energetic reaction against the heathendom that had found its way even into Judah, and which the queen had in every way favored. Joash was predestined to bea theocratic king. And, in reality, in the beginning of his reign of 40 years, he went hand in hand with the priests and the prophets of Jeh. After Jehoiada’s death, however, he tolerated idolatrous worship among the princes (2 Ch 24 17 ff), and by doing so came into con- flict with the faithful prophet Zechariah, the son of his benefactor Jehoiada, who rebuked him for his wrong, and was even stoned. A just punishment for this guilt was recognized in the misfortune which overtook the king and his country... The Syrian king, Hazael, when he was engaged in an expedi- tion against Gath, also took possession of Jerus and made it pay tribute, after having apparently in- flicted a severe defeat on the people of Judah, on which occasion many princes fell in the battle and Joash himself was severely wounded. Toward the end of his reign there was also much dissatisfac- tion among his suhjects, and some of his courtiers finally murdered him (2 K 12 20f). Amaziah.—However, his son Amaziah, who now ascended the throne, punished the murderers. The king was successful in war against the Edomites. This made him bold. He ventured to meet Joash, the king of Israel, in battle and was defeated and captured. The people of Judah suffered the deepest humiliation. A large portion of the walls of Jerus was torn down (2 K 14 11 ff). Amaziah did not feel himself safe even in his own capital city, be- cause of the dissatisfaction of his own subjects, and he fled to Lachish. Here he was murdered. So deep had Judah fallen, while Jeroboam II succeeded in raising his kingdom to an unthought-of power. Uzziah.—But for Judah a turn for the better soon set in under Uzziah, the same as Azariah in K, the son of Amaziah, who enjoyed a long and prosperous reign. Prosperous as Israel outwardly appeared to be dur- ing the reigns of these two kings, Jeroboam II and Uzziah, the religious and moral condi- 3. The tions of the people were just as little Literary satisfactory. This is the testimony Prophets of the prophets Amos and Hosea, as also of Isaiah and Micah, who not much later began their active ministry in Judah. It is indeed true that these were not the first prophets to put into written form some of their prophetic utterances. The prophecies of Obadiah and Joel are by many put at an earlier date, namely Obadiah under Jehoram in Judah, and Joel under Joash in Judah. At any rate, the discourses of the prophets from this time on constitute an important con- temporaneous historical source. They illustrate esp. the spiritual condition of the nation. Through- out these writings complaints are made concerning the heathen superstitions and the godless cultus of the people, and esp. the corruption in the admin- istration of the laws, oppression of the poor and the helpless by the rich and the powerful, and pride and luxury of all kinds. In all these things the rophets see a terrible apostasy on Israel’s part. ut also the foreign policy of the different kings, who sought help, now of the one and then of the other of the world-powers (Egypt, Assyria), and tried to buy the favor of these nations, the prophets regarded as adultery with foreign nations and as infidelity toward Jeh. As a punishment they an- nounced, since all other misfortunes sent upon them had been of no avail, an invasion through a con- queror, whom Amos and Hosea always indicate shall be Assyria, and also deportations of the people into a heathen land, and an end of the Jewish state. Improbable as these threats may have seemed to the self-satisfied inhabitants of Samaria, they were speedily realized. Successors of Jeroboam II.—After the death of Jeroboam, the strength of the Northern Kingdom 1523 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of collapsed. His son Zechariah was able to maintain the throne for only 6 months, and his murderer Shallum only one month. The general Menahem, who put him out of the way, maintained himself as king for 10 years, but only by paying a heavy tribute to the Assyr ruler Pul, i.e. Tiglath-pileser III, who ruled from 745-727 (ef 2 K 16 19f). Pekah.—His son Pekahiah, on the other hand, soon fell by the hands of the murderer Pekah (2 K 15 25), who allied himself with Syria against Judah. The latter, however, invited the Assyrians to come into the country; and these, entering in the year 734 BC, put an end to the reign of this usurper, aneee he was actually put to death as late as 730 Hoshea.—The last king of the Northern Kingdom, Hoshea (730-722 BC), had the Assyrians to thank for his throne; but he did not keep his fidelity as a vassal very long. As soon as Tiglath-pileser was dead, he tried_to throw off the Assyr yoke. But his successor Shalmaneser IV (727-723 BC), who already in the first year of his reign had again subdued the rebellious king Elulaios of Syria, soon compelled Hoshea also to submit to his authority. Two years later Hoshea again joined a conspiracy with the Phoenicians against Assyria, in which they even counted on the help of the Egyp king, who in the Bible is called So or Seve (Egyp name is Shabaka). Now the Assyrians lost all patience. They at once came with their armies. Hoshea seems to have voluntarily submitted to the power of the Great King, who then made him a captive. The people, however, continued the struggle. Samaria, the capital city, was besieged, but did not fall until the 3d year (722 BC) into the hands of the enemy. Shalmaneser, in the mean- while, had died and Sargon II had become his suc- cessor. The city was indeed not destroyed, but a large portion of the inhabitants, esp. the leaders, were deported and transplanted to Northern Meso- potamia and to Media. Sargon states that the number of deported Israelites was 27,290. Promi- nent persons from other cities were also doubtless to be included in those deported. On the other hand, the Assyr king settled Bab and Syrian prison- ers of war in Samaria (721 BC), and in the year 715 BC, Arabs also. But the country, to a great extent, continued in a state of desolation, so that Esar- haddon (680-668 BC) and Ashurbanipal (667-626 BC) sent new colonists there, the last mentioned sending them from Babylonia, Persia and Media (ef 2 K 17 24 ff). In these verses the Bab city of Cuthah is several times mentioned, on account of which city the Jews afterward called the Samari- tans Cuthites. This report also makes mention of the religious syncretism, which of necessity re- sulted from the mixture of the people. But we must be careful not to place at too small figures the number of Israelites who remained in the country. It is a great exaggeration when it is claimed, as it is by Friedrich Delitzsch, that the great bulk of the inhabitants of the country of Samaria, or even of Galilee, was from this time on Babylonian. Uzziah and Jotham—The kingdom of Judah, however, outlived the danger from Assyria. As King Uzziah later in his life suffered from leprosy, he had Jotham as a co-regent during this period. The earliest discourses of Isaiah, which belong to this period (Isa 2-4, 6), show that in Jerus the people were at that time still enjoying the fruits oe prosperity of a long period of peace. But immediately after the death of Jotham, when the youthful Ahaz began to rule, the onslaught of the allied Syrians and Ephraimites took place under Rezin, or better Rezon, and Pekah. This alliance purposed to put an end to the Davidic reign in Jerus, probably for the purpose of making this people, too, a member of the league against the dan- gerous Assyrians. The good-sized army of Judah seems to have fallen a victim to the superior power of the allies before the situation described in Isa 7 could be realized, in which the siege of the city is described as already imminent. The Edomites also at that time advanced against Judah. Elath, the harbor city on the Red Sea, from which Uzziah, too, as had been done by Solomon long before, sent out trading vessels, at that time came into their power. For 2 K 16 6 probably speaks of Edom and not of Aram (cf 2 Ch 28 17). In his anxiety, Ahaz, notwithstanding the advice of. Isaiah to the contrary, then appealed to the king of Assyria, and the latter actually put in his appearance in 734 BC and overcame the power of Syria and Ephraim, as we have seen above. However, the intervention of this world-power brought no benefit to Judah. Without this disgraceful appeal to a heathen ruler, Jeh, according to the promise of Isaiah, would have protected Jerus, Aa Ahaz had only believed. And the Assyrians did not prevent the Philis and the Edomites from falling upon Judah. The Assyrians themselves soon came to be the greatest danger threatening Judah. Ahaz, however, was an unstable character in religious affairs, and he copied heathen forms of worship, and even sacrificed his son to the angry sun-god, in order to gain his favor. The tribute that the people had to pay to Assyria was already a heavy burden on this little kingdom. Hezekiah -—His noble and God-fearing son, Hezekiah (724-696 BC), was also compelled to suffer from the consequences of this misgovernment. The temptation was great to enter into an alliance with his neighbors and the Egyptians, so strong in cavalry, for the purpose of ridding Judah of the burdensome yoke of the Assyrians. In vain did Isaiah warn against such unworthy self-help. At the advice of the ministers of Hezekiah, and because of the trust put in Egypt, the tribute was finally refused to the Assyrians. Hezekiah also -sought to establish closer connections with Merodach- baladan, the king of Babylon and the enemy of the Assyrians, when the latter, after a dangerous sick- ness of the king, had sent messengers to Jerus in order to congratulate him on the restoration of his health. This story, found in 2 K 20, belongs chronologically before 2 K 18 13 ff, and, more accu- rately, in the 14th year of Hezekiah mentioned in 18 13. However, the expedition of Sennacherib which is mistakenly placed in that year, took place several years later: according to the Assyr monu- ments, in the year 701 BC. Sennacherib.—In the year 702 BC Sennacherib, with a powerful army, marched over the Lebanon and subdued the rebellious Phoenicians, and marched along the seacoast to Philistia. The in- habitants of Ekron had sent their king, Padi, who sympathized with the Assyrians, to Hezekiah. Sennacherib came to punish Ekron and Ascalon. But he was particularly anxious to overpower Judah, which country his troops devastated and depopulated. Now Hezekiah recognized his dan- ger, and offered to submit to Sennacherib. The latter accepted his submission conditionally on the payment of a burdensome tribute, which Hezekiah delivered faithfully (2 K 18 14-16). Then Sen- nacherib was no longer satisfied with the tribute alone, but sent troops who were to despoil Jerus. Isaiah, who surely had not sanctioned the falling away from the Assyr supremacy and had prophe- sied that the inhabitants of Jerus would suffer a severe punishment, from that moment, when the conqueror had maliciously broken his word, spoke words of comfort and advised against giving up the city, no matter how desperate the situation seemed to be (Isa 37 1 ff). The city was then not given Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1524 up, and Sennacherib, on account of a number of things that occurred, and finally because of a pesti- lence which broke out in his army, was compelled to retreat. He did not return to Jerus, and later met his death by violent hands. This deliverance of Jerus through the miraculous providence of God was the greatest triumph of the prophet Isaiah. Within his kingdom Hezekiah ruled successfully. He also purified the cultus from the heathen influ- ences that had forced their way into it, and was a predecessor of Josiah in the abolition of the sacri- fices on the high places, which had been corrupted by these influences. Manasseh.—Unfortunately, his son Manasseh was little worthy of succeeding him. He, in every way, favored the idolatry which all along had been growing secretly. He maugurated bloody perse- cutions of the faithful prophets of Jeh. According to a tradition, which it must be confessed is not supported by undoubted testimony, Isaiah also, now an old man, became a victim of these perse-~ cutions. Images and altars were openly erected to Baal and Astarte, Even in the temple-house on Mt. Zion, an image of Astarte was standing. As a result of this ethnic cultus, immorality and sen- suality found their way among the people. At the same time the terrible service of Moloch, in the valley of Hinnom, demanded the sacrifice of chil-~ dren, and even a son of the king was given over to this worship. The Book of Ch, indeed, tells the story of a terrible affliction that Manasseh suffered, namely that an Assyr general dragged him in chains to Babylon for having violated his promises to them, but that he was soon released. This is not at all incredible. He seems to have taken part in a rebellion, which the brother of the Assyr king, who was also vice-king in Babylon, had inaugu- rated. This sad experience may have forced Ma- nassch to a certain kind of repentance, at least, so that he desisted from his worst sacrileges. But his son Amon continued the old ways of his father, until after a brief reign be was put to death. Josiah.—Much more promising was his young son Josiah, who now, only 8 years old, came to the throne. It is quite possible that, in view of such frequent changes in the disposition of the successors to the throne, his mother may have had great in- fluence on his character. Concerning Josiah, see 2 K 22 1ff. With increasing clearness and con- sistency, he proceeded to the work of religious reformation. A special impetus to this was given by the finding of an old law book in the temple, the publication of which for the first time revealed the fearful apostasy of the times. The finding of this book in the temple, as narrated in2 K 22 3 ff, took lace in connection with the restoration of that uilding on a larger scale, which at that time had been undertaken. And very probably Edouard Naville is right in believing, on the basis of Egyp analogies, that this document had been imbedded in the foundation walls of the building. Whether this had been done already in the days of Solomon is not determined by this fact. From the orders of Josiah we can conclude that the book which was found was Dt, which lays special stress on the fact that there shall be a central place for the cultus, and also contains such threats as those must have been which frightened Josiah. But under no circum- stances was Dt a lawbaok that had first been written at this time, or a fabrication of the priest Hilkiah and his helpers. It would rather have been possible that the discovered old law was rewritten in changed form after its discovery and had been adapted to the language of the times. The people were obliged to obey the newly discovered law and were in- structed in it. : Jeremiah.—The prophet Jeremiah also, who a few years before this had been called to the pro- phetic office, according to certain data in the text, participated in this proclamation of the law of the covenant throughout the land. This change for the better did not change the tendency of his pro- phetic discourses, from what these had been from the beginning. He continued to be the accuser and the prophet of judgment, who declared that the destruction of the city and of the temple was near at hand. He looked too deeply into the inner cor- ruption of his people to be misled by the external transformation that was the result of a command of the ruler. And only too soon did the course of events justify his prediction. With the person of the God-fearing Josiah, the devotion of the people to the law was also buried and the old curse every- where broke out again. ; The Chaldaeans.—In a formal way Jeremiah was probably influenced by the incursions of the Scyth- lans, which occurred during his youth, and who about this time marched from the plain of Jezreel toward Egypt (cf Herodotus 1.103 ff); which event also made a gloomy impression on his contemporary Ezekiel, as appears from his vision of Gog in the land of Magog. However, we are not to suppose that Jeremiah, when describing the enemy coming from the north, whom he saw from the time of his call to the prophetic office, meant merely this band of freebooters. The prophet had in mind a world- power after the type of the Assyrians, who always came from the north into Canaan. The Assyrians indeed were in process of disintegration, and Nine- veh fell under the attacks of the Medes and the Persians in the year 607-606 BC. The heir of the Assyr power was not Egypt, which was also striving for universal supremacy, but was the Babylonian, or rather, more accurately, the Chaldaean dynasty of Nabopolassar, whose son Nebuchadnezzar had overpowered the Egyptians at Carchemish in 605 BC. From this time on Jeremiah had pointed out the Chaldaeans and Nebuchadnezzar, who soon afterward became their king, as the agents to carry out the judgment on Jerus. Already a few years before this Judah’s good star had gone down on the horizon. When Pharaoh- necho II came to Pal by the sea route, in order to march northeast through the plain of Jezreel, to give the final and fatal blow to the sinking kingdom of the Assyrians, King Josiah opposed him on the plain of Megiddo, probably because of his obliga- tions as a vassal to the king of Assyria. In the battle of Megiddo (609 BC), Josiah was mortally wounded. No greater calamity could have be- fallen Judah than the death of this king, who was deeply mourned by all well-meaning people, and who was the last of the house of David that was a credit to it. The successors of Josiah—By popular election the choice now fell on Jehoahaz, a younger son of Josiah, called by Jeremiah (22 11) Shallum. But he found no favor with Necho, who took him pris- oner in his camp at Riblah and carried him to Egypt (2 K 23 30ff). The Egyp king himself selected Jehoiakim, hitherto called Eliakim, an older son of Josiah, who had been ignored by the people, to be king in Jerus, a prince untrue to Jeh, conceited, luxury-loving and_hard-hearted, who, in addition, through his perfidious policy, brought calamity upon the land. He formed a conspiracy against Nebuchadnezzar, to whom he had begun to pay tribute in the 5th year of his reign, and in this way brought it about that the Syrians, the Moabites and the Ammonites, who had taken sides with the Assyrians, devastated the land of Judah, and that finally the king of Babylon himself came to Jerus to take revenge. It is not clear what was the end of this king. According to 2 Ch 1525 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of 36 6, compared with 2 K 24 6, he seems to have died while yet in Jerus, and after he had already fallen into the hands of his enemies. His son Jehoiachin did not experience a much better fate. After ruling three months he was taken to Babylon, where he was a prisoner for 37 years, until he was pedoned (2K 24 8 ff; 26 27 ff). Together with ehoiachin, the best portion of the inhabitants of Jerus, about 10,000 men, esp. the smiths and the builders, were deported. Zedekiah, the last king of Judah.—Once more the Babylonians set up a king in Jerus in the person of Zedekiah, an uncle of Jehoiachin, and accordingly a son of Josiah, called Mattaniah, who afterward was called Zedekiah. He governed for twelve years (597-586 BC), and by his life, morally and religiously corrupt, sealed the fate of the house and of the kingdom of David. The better class among the leading and prominent people had been ban- ished. As a result, the courtiers of the king urged him to try once again some treacherous schemes against the Bab rulers and to join Egypt in a con- spiracy against them. However earnestly Jeremiah and Ezekiel warned against this policy, Zedekiah nevertheless constantly yielded to his evil advisers and to the warlike patriotic party, who were de- termined to win Back in battle the independence of thecountry. While he atfirst, through an embassy, had assured the Great King of his loyalty (Jer 29 3), and still in the 4th year of his reign had person- ally visited in Babylon as a mark of his fidelity (Jer 51 59), he was induced in the 9th year of his reign to make an alliance with the Egyptians against the Babylonians and to refuse to render obedience to the latter. Nebuchadnezzar soon came and sur- rounded the city. At the announcement that an Egyp army was approaching, the siege was again raised for a short time. But the hope placed by Zedekiah on his ally failed him. The Babylonians began again to starve out the city. After a siege of 18 months, resistance proved futile. The king tried secretly to break through the circle of be- siegers, but in doing so was taken prisoner, was blinded by the Bab king and taken to Babylon. The majority of the prominent men and state officials, who were taken to the encampment of the con- queror in Riblah, were put to death. The con- quered city of Jerus, esp. its walls and towers, together with the temple, were totally destroyed. Nearly all the inhabitants who could be captured after the slaughter were dragged into captivity, and only people of the lower classes were left be- hind in order to cultivate the land (2 K 26 11). Gedaliah, a noble-minded aristocrat, was appointed governor of the city, and took up his residence in Mizpah. At this place it seemed that a new kernel of ihe people was being gathered. Jeremiah also went there. However, after two months this good beginning came to an end. Gedaliah was slain by Ishmael, the son of Nethaniah, an anti-Chaldaean, a fanatical and revengeful descendant of the house of David. The murderer acted in coéperation with certain Ammonitish associates and fled to the king of Ammon. The Jews in later times considered the murder of Gedaliah as an especially great national calamity, and fasted on the anniversary of this crime. And as the people also feared the revenge of the Babylonians, many migrated to Egypt, com- pelling Jeremiah, now an old man, to accompany them, although he prophesied to them that no good would come of this scheme. They first stayed at the border city Tahpanhes, near Pelusium, and then scattered over Upper and Lower Egypt. VI. Time of the Babylonian Exile.—The in- habitants of Judah, who had been deported by Nebuchadnezzar at different times, were settled by him in Babylonia, e.g. at the river Chebar (Ezk 1 1), near the city of Nippur. From Hilprecht’s excavations of this city, it has been learned that this river, or branch of the Euphrates 1. Influence river, is to be found at this place, and of the is not to be confounded with the river Exile Chaboras. In the same way, the many contract-tablets with Jewish names which have been found at Nippur, show that a large Jewish colony lived at that place. Of the fate of these banished Jews for a period of 50 years, we hear almost nothing. But it is possible to learn what their condition was in exile from the Book of Ezk and the 2d part of Isa. Land was assigned to them here, and they were permitted to build houses for themselves (Jer 29 5ff), and could travel around this district without restraint. They were not prisoners in the narrow sense of the word. They soon, through diligence and skill in trade, attained to considerable wealth, so that most of them, after the lapse of half a century, were perfectly satisfied and felt no desire to return home. For the spiritual development of the people the exile proved to be a period of great importance. In the tst- place, they were separated from their native soil, and in this way from many temptations of heathenism and idolatry, and the like. The terrible judgment that had come over Jerus had proved that the prophets had been right, who had for a long time, but in vain, preached genuine repentance. This did not prove to be without fruit (cf Zec 1 6). While living in the heathen land, they naturally became acquainted with heathendom in a more crass form. But even if many of the Jews were defiled by it, in general the relations of the Israel- ites toward the idol-worshipping Babylonians were antagonistic, and they became all the more zeal- ous in the observance of those religious rites which could be practised in a foreign Jand, such as rest on the Sabbath day, the use of meats, circumcision, and others. But with marked zeal the people turned to the spiritual storehouse of their traditions, namely their sacred literature. They collected the laws, the history, the hymns, and treasured them. It was also a noteworthy progress that such prophets as Ezekiel, Jeremiah and Daniel received prophetic visions while on heathen soil. The people also learned that the heathen, in the midst of whom they lived, became receptive of the higher truths of Israel’s religion. Esp. does the 2d part of Isa, chs 40-66, show that they began to understand the missionary calling of Israel among the nations of the world. The Book of Dnl reports how a God-fearing and law-abiding Jew, through his prophecies, attained to prominent positions of influence at 2. Daniel the courts of different rulers. From the Book of Ezk we learn that the prophets and the elders cared for the spiritual wants of the people, and that they held meetings, at which indeed it was not permitted to offer sacrifices, but at which the word of Jeh was proclaimed. ere we find the beginnings of what afterward was the synagogue-system. A remarkable picture of the Jewish diaspora in Upper Egypt is furnished by recently discovered papyri at Elephantince. From these it 3. Ele- appears that in the 6th cent. BC, not phantine only a large and flourishing Jewish Papyri colony was to be found at: this place, but also that they had erected here a fine temple to Jeh where they brought their sacrifices . to which they had been accustomed at home. In an Aram. letter, still preserved and dating from the year 411 BC, and which is addressed to the governor Bagohi, in Judaea, these Jews complain that their temple in Yéb (Hlephantine, near Syene) had been destroyed in the same year. It also states that Israel, History of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1526 this temple had been spared on one occasion by Cambyses, who was in Egypt from 525 to 521 BC. The answer of Bagohi also has been preserved, and he directs that the temple is to be built again and that meal offerings and incense are again to be in- troduced. Probably intentionally, mention in this letter is made only of the unbloody sacrifices, while in the first letter burnt sacrifices also are named. The sacrifices of animals by the Jews would probably have aroused too much the anger of the devotees of the divine ram, which was worshipped at Syene. Up to the present time we knew only of the much later temple of the high priest Onias IV at Leontopolis (160 BC). Cf Jos, Ant, X1I, iii, 1-3; BJ, VH, x, 2, 3. VII. Return from the Exile andthe Restoration. —In the meanwhile there was a new readjustment of political supremacy among the world- powers. The Pers king, Koresh (Cyrus), first made himself free from the supremacy of Media which, after the capture of the city Ecbatana, became a part of his own kingdom (549 BC). At that time Na- bonidus was the king in Babylon (555-538 BC), who was not displeased at the collapse of the kingdom of the Medes, but soon learned that the new ruler turned out to be a greater danger to himself, as Cyrus subjugated, one after the other, the smaller kingdoms in the north. But Nabonidus was too unwarlike to meet Cyrus. He confined himself to sending his son with an army to the northern boundaries of his kingdom. On the other hand, the king of the Lydians, Croesus, who was related by marriage to King Astyages, who had been snb- dued by Cyrus, began a war with Cyrus, after he had formed an alliance with Egypt and Sparta. In the year 546 BC, he crossed the river Halys. Cyrus approached from the Tigris, and in doing so already entered Bab territory, conquered Croesus, took his capital city Sardis, and put an end to the king- dom of Lydia. The pious Israelites in captivity, under the tutelage of Deutero-Isaiah, watched these events with the greatest of interest. For the prophet taught them from the beginning to see in this king “the deliverer,’’ who was the instrument of Jeh for the return of the Israelites out of captivity, and of whom the prophets had predicted. And this expectation was fulfilled with remarkable rapidity. The victorious and aggressive king of Persia could now no longer be permanently checked, even by the Babylonians. It was in vain that King Nabonidus had caused the images of the gods from many of his cities to be taken to Babylon, in order to make the capital city invincible. This city opened its doors to the Pers commander Ugbaru (Gobryas) in 588 BC, and a few months later Cyrus himself entered the city. This king, however, was mild and conciliatory in bis treatment of the people and the city. He did not destroy the city, but commanded only that a portion of the walls should be razed. However, the city gradually, in the course of time, became ruins. Cyrus also won the good will and favor of the subjugated nations by respecting their religions. He returned to their shrines the idols of Nabonidus, that had been taken away. But he was particularly con- siderate of the Jews, who doubtless had complained to him of their fate and had made known to him their prophecies regarding him as the coming deliverer. In the very first year of his reign over Babylon he issued an edict (2 Ch 36 22f; Ezr 1 1 ff) that permitted the Jews to return home, 1. Career of Cyrus 2. First with the command that they should Return again erect their temple. For this under purpose he directed that the temple- Zerubbabel vessels, which Nebuchadnezzar had taken away with him, should be returned to them, and commended that those Israelites who voluntarily remained in Babylon should contribute money for the restoration of the temple. At the head of those to be returned stood Sheshbazzar, who is probably identical with Zerub- babel, although this is denied by some scholars; and also the high priest, Joshua, a grandson of the high priest, Seraiah, who had been put to death by Nebuchadnezzar. They were accompanied by only a small part of those in exile, that is by 42,360 men and women and children, male and female servants, esp. from the tribes of Judah, Benjamin and Levi, but of the last-mentioned tribes more priests than other Levites. After several months they safely arrived in Pal, probably 537 BC. Some of them settled down in Jerus, and others in sur- rounding cities and villages. They erected the altar for burnt sacrifices, so that they were again able in the 7th month to sacrifice on it. Building the temple——The cornerstone of the temple was also solemnly laid at that time in the 2d year of the Return (Ezr 3 8 ff). But the erectionof the temple must have been interrupted in a short time, since it was not until the 2d year of Darius (520 BC), at the urgent appeal of the prophets Hag- gai and Zechariah, that the work of building was energetically prosecuted. For this reason many scholars deny this cornerstone-laying in the year 536 BC. However, it still remains thinkable that several attempts were made at this work, since the young colony had many difficulties to contend with. Then, too, the memoirs of Ezra and Nehemiah, which have been worked over by the author of Ch, report the history of these times only in parts. The his- torical value of these literary sources has been con- firmed by those Aram. papyri found in Upper Egypt. In the year 516 BC, after 4 years of building, the temple was completed and dedicated. After this we have no information for a 3. Ezra period of 58 years. Then we learn and that Ezra, the scribe, in the 7th year Nehemiah of Artaxerxes [I (458 BC), came with a new caravan of about 1,500 men with women and children from Babylon to the Holy Land. He had secured from the king the command to establish again in the land of the Jews the law, in which he was a prominent ex- pert, and he tried to do this by earnest admoni- tions and instructive discourses addressed to the people. The acme of the activity of Ezra was the meeting of the people described in Neh 8-10 on the Feast of the Tabernacles, on which occasion the entire nation solemnly came under obligation to observe the law. According to the present position of these chapters this act took place in 444 BC; but it is probable that it happened before the arrival of Nehemiah, whose name would accordingly have to be eliminated in 8 9. This pericope would then belong to the memoirs of Ezra and not to those of Nehemiah. After some years there came to help Ezra in his work, Nehemiah, a pious Jew, who was a cupbearer to the king, and at his own request was granted leave of absence in order to help the city of Jerus, which he had heard was in dire straits. Its walls were in ruins, as the neighboring nations had been able to hinder their rebuilding, and even those walls of the city that had been hastily re- stored, had again been pulled down. Nehemiah came in the year 445-444 BC from Shushan to Jerus and at once went energetically to work at rebuilding the walls. Notwithstanding all oppositions and in- trigues of malicious neighbors, the work was suc- cessfully brought to a close. The hostile agitations, in so far as they were not caused by widespread envy and hatred of the Jews among the neighboring peoples, had a religious ground. Those who returned, as the people of Jeh, held themselves aloof from the peoples living 1527 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, History of round about them, esp. from the mixed pcoples of Samaria. Samaria was the breeding-place for this hostility against Jerus. The governor at that place, Sanballat, was the head of this hostile league. The Jews had declined to permit the Samaritans to codperate in the erection of the temple and would have no religious communion with them. The Samaritans had taken serious offence at this, and they accordingly did all they could to prevent the building of the walls in Jerus, which would be a hindrance to their having access to the temple. But Nehemiah’s trust in God and his energy over- came this obstacle. The policy of exclusiveness, which Ezra and Nehemiah on this occasion and at other times followed out, evinces a more narrow mind than the preéxilic prophets had shown. In the refusal of intermarriage with the people living around them they went beyond the Mosaic law, for they even demanded that those marriages, which the Israelites had already contracted with foreign women, should be dissolved. But this exclusiveness was the outcome of legal conscientiousness, and at this period it was probably necessary for the self- preservation of the people of Jeh. Malachi.—From the prophecies of Malachi, who was almost a contemporary of the two mentioned, it can be seen that the marriages with the foreign women had also brought with them a loosening of even the most sacred family ties (Mal 2 14f). After an absence of 12 years, Nehemiah again returned to Shushan to the court; and when he later returned to Jerus he was compelled once more to inaugurate a stringent policy against the lawlessness which was violating the sanctity of the temple and of the Sabbath commandment. He also expelled a certain Manasseh, a grandson of the high priest, who had married a daughter of Sanballat. This Manasseh, according to Jos (Ant, XI, viii, 2), erected the sanctuary on Mt. Gerizim, and established the priesthood at that place. This is no doubt correct. These accounts of Jos are often combined without cause with the times of Alexander the Great, al- though they transpired about 110 years earlier. The history of the Jews in the last decades of the Pers rule is little known. Under Artaxerxes ITI (Ochus), they were compelled to suffer much, when they took part in a rebellion of the Phoenicians and Cyprians. Many Jews were at that time banished to Hyrcania on the southern coast of the Caspian Sea. The Pers general, Bagoses, came to Jerus and forced his way even into the temple (Jos, Ant, XI, vii, 1). He undertook to install as high priest, in the place of John (Jochanan), his brother Joshua (Jesus). The latter, however, was slain by the former in the temple. For the first time the office of the high priest appears as more of a political position, something that it never was in the pre- exilic times, and according to the law was not to be. VIN. The Jews under Alexander and His Suc- cessors.—As the Jews were then tired of the rule of the priests, they were not dissatisfied 1. Spread with the victorious career of Alex- of Hellen- ander the Great. He appears to ism have assumed a friendly attitude toward them, even if the story reported by Jos (Ant, XI, vili, 4) is scarcely historical. The successors of Alexander were also, as a rule, tolerant in religious matters. But for political and geographical reasons, Pal suffered severely in these times, as it lay between Syria and Egypt, and was an object of attack on the part of both the leading ruling families in this period, the Ptolemies in Egypt and the Seleucidae in Syria. At the same time Hellenism, which had been so powerfully ad- vanced by Alexander as a factor of civilization and culture, penetrated the land of Israel also. Gr culture and language spread soon in Pal and in many places was supreme. The more strict adherents of Judaism recognized in this a danger to the Mosaic order of life and religion, and all the more zealously they now adhered to the traditional ordinances. These were called the hdsidhim, or the Pious (‘Aovdaior, Hasidatoi, 1 Macc 2 42; 7 13; 2 Macc 14 6). The world-transforming Hellenistic type of thought spread esp. among the aristocrats and the politically prominent, and even found adherents among the priests, while the hdsidhim belonged to the less conspicuous ranks of the people. A struggle fer life and death was caused between these two tendencies by the Syrian king, Antiochus [V (Epiphanes), inte whese hands the sever- 2. The eignty of Pal had fallen. He undertook Hasmo- nothing less than to root out the hated Jewish religion. Jn the year 168 BC he neans commanded that the temple of Jeh in F , Jerus should be dedicated to the Olym- pian Jupiter and ferbade mest stringently the observ- ance ef the Sabbath and circumcision. A large portion ef the peeple did net resist his oppression, but adapted themselves to this tyrannical heathendom. Others suffered and died as martyrs. Finally in the year 167 BC a priest, Mattathias, gave the signal fer a deter- mined resistance, at the head ef which stood his brave sons, the Hasmeneans, or Maccabees. First his son Judas undertook the leadership of the faithful. He succeeded in freeing Jerus frem the Syrians. He restored the temple en Mt. Zion. The temple was dedicated anew and was given over te the eld cultus. After a number of victorious campaigns, Judas Maccabaeus died the death of a here in 161 BC. His brother, Jonathan, who teek his place at the head of the mevement, tried to secure the independence ef the land rather through deliberate planning than threugh military power. He assumed, in additien to his secular power, alse the high- precsily dignity. After his death by violence in 143 BC, e was succeeded by his brother Simen as the bearer of this deuble honor. The Hasmoneans, however, rapidly became werldly minded and lest the sympathies of the hdsidhim. The son of Simen, Jehn Hyrcanus (135-106 BO), breke entirely with the Pious, and his family, after his death, came to an end in disgraceful struggles for ewer. The rule of the land fell into the hands of ered, a tyrant of Idumaean origin, whe was supported by the Romans. Frem 37 BC he was the recegnized king ef Judah. See Asmonnans; Maccasens. IX. The Romans.—After the death of Herod (4 BC), the kingdom, according to his last will, was to be divided among his three sons. 1. Division Archelaus received Judaea; Antipas, of Territory Galilee and Peraea; Philip, the border lands in the north. However, Arche- laus was soon deposed by the Romans (6 AD), and Judaea was made a part of the province of Syria, but was put under a special Roman procurator, who resided in Caesarea. These procurators (of whom the best known was Pontius Pilate, 26-36 AD), had no other object than to plunder the land and the people. In this way a conflict was gradually generated between the people and their oppressors, which ended with the destruction of Jerus by 2. Destruc- the Romans in 70 AD. As early as tion of 40 AD this rupture almost took place, Jerusalem when the Syrian legate Petronius, at by the the command of Caligula, undertook Romans to place a statue of the emperor in the temple of Jerus. On this occasion King Agrippa I, who was again ruling the whole territory of Herod, succeeded in adjusting the conflict. His son Agrippa II was given a much smaller kingdom (40-100 AD). He, too, sought to prevent the people from undertaking a struggle with the Romans, butin vain. By his unscrupulous treatment of the people, the procurator Gessius Florus drove the Jews into an insurrection. The party of the Zealots gained the upperhand. Florus was compelled to leave Jerus (66 AD). Even the good-sized army which Cestius Gallus commanded could not get control of the city, but was completely overpowered by the Jews on its retreat at Beth- horon. Now the entire country rose in rebellion. The Romans, under the leadership of Vespasian, Israel, History of tm INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, King. of advanced with considerable power and first con- quered Galilee, then under Jos (67 AD). In Jerus, in the meanwhile, different parties of the Jews were still fighting each other. Titus, the son of Ves- pasian, took the chief command after Vespasian had already conquered the E. Jordan country and the western coast, but had hastened to Rome in order to become emperor. Titus completely sur- rounded the city a few days before the Passover festival in the year 70. On the northern side the Romans first broke through the first and newest city wall, and after that the second. The third offered a longer resistance, and at the same time famine wrought havoc in Jerns. At last the battle raged about the temple, during which this structure went up in flames. According to the full descrip- tion by Jos (BJ, VI, iv, 3 ff), Titus tried to prevent the destruction of the temple; according to Sul- picius Severus (Chron. II, 20), however, this de- struction was just what he wanted. A few forti- fied places yet maintained themselves after the fall of Jerus, e.g. Machaerus in the E. Jordan country, but they could not hold out very long. Later insurrection of Bar-Cochba.—Once again the natural ambition for independence burst out in the insurrection of Bar-Cochba (132-35 AD). Pious teachers of the law, esp. Rabbi Akiba, had enkindled this fire, in order to rid the country of the rule of the Gentiles. However, notwithstanding some temporary successes, this insurrection was hopeless. Both the city and the country were desolated by the enraged Romans still more fear- fully, and were depopulated still more than in 70. From that time Jerus was lost to the Jews. They lived on without a country of their own, without any political organization, without a sanctuary, in the Diaspora among the nations. The spiritual and religious life of the Jews during the period preceding the dissolution of the state was determined particularly by the 8. Spiritual legalistic character of their ideals and Life of the their opposition to Hellenism. Their Period religion had become formalistic to a great extent since their return from the exile. The greatest emphasis was laid on obe- dience to the traditional ordinances, and these latter were chiefly expositions of ceremonial usurpers. Appearance of Jesus Christ—The crown of the history of Israel-Judah was the appearance of Jesus Christ. Looked at superficially, it may indeed appear as though His person and His life had but little affected the development of the national his- tory of Israel. However, more closely viewed, we shall see that this entire history has its goal in Him and finds its realization in Him. After full fruit had developed out of this stock, the latter withered and died. He was to be the bearer of salvation for all mankind. Lrrearature.—The earliest historian of Israel was the Jew, Flavius Josephus, in the 1st Christian cent. His example found few followers in the early church, and we mention only the Chronicle of Sulpicius Severus. The subject is handled theologically by Augustine in his De Civitate Det. It was only in the 17th cent. that a keen interest was awakened in this subject. Cf esp. James Usher, Annales Veteris et Novi Testamenti, Loudon, 1605; J. B. Bousset, Discours sur [histoire untverselle, Paris, 1681; Humphrey Prideaux, The Old and the New Testament Connected in the History of the Jews and Neighboring Nations, 2 vols, London, 1716; S. Shukford, The Sacred and Profane History of the World Connected, London, 1727, this work treating the subject apologeti- cally against the Deists. Cf also J. Saurin, Discours historiques, Amsterdam, 1720. Cocceius and his school systematized this history on the basis of their theological tenets, e.g. Gurtler, Systema theol. prophetica, Frankfurt, 1724. ore systematic is the work of Vitringa, Hypothe- sts historiae et chronologiae sacrae, Frankfurt, 1708. The Lutheran church furnished the excellent work of Franz Budde, Historia Eccles. Veteris Testamenti, Jena, 1715. In the 18th cent., Bengel’s school furnished some good histories of Israel, such as M. F. Roos's Binleitung in die bibl, Geschichte, 1700. More popular is the work of J. 1528 J. Hess. The best Catholic work from this time is J. Jahn's Archaeologie, 1802; while the Rationalistic period furnished Lorenz Bauer's Geschichte der hebr. Nation, 1800. In the 19th cent. the rationalistic and the con- servative tendencies run paralicl, and a new impulse was given to the study of this history by the phenomenal archaeological finds in Egypt and in Assyria and Babylon. Critical reconstruction of Israel's history characterizes the works of Reuss, Graf, Kuenen, Wellhausen. Other works of prominence are the Geschichte des Volkes Gottes, hy Ewald; Kurtz, Geschichte des alten Bundes (these are tra); Hitzig, Geschichte des Volkes Israel, with critical tendency. The work of August Koehler, Lehrbuch der btblischen Geschichte, AT, is positive, while Wellhausen’s Geschichte Israels is a classic of the advanced school. Other works mostly critical are the histories of Renan, Kuenen, Stade, Winckler, Piepenbring, Cornill, Guthe, Cheyne, and others. Kittel’s Geschichte der Hebrder (tr4) is more moderate in tone. For the NT the richest storehouse is Schtirer’s Geschichte des jiidischen Volkes im GZeitalter Jesu Christi (tra); Hausrath’s Neutesta- mentliche Zettgeschichte is also good. From the Jewish standpoint this history has been treated by S. Fried- lander, Geschichte des Israel-Volkes; and J. M. Jost, Geschichte der Israeliten; Moritz Raphall, Post-biblical History of the Jews from the Close of the OT till the De- struction of the Second Temple, in the Year 70. fi Among English works may be especially mentioned Milman's History of the Jews and Stanley's, Lectures on the History of the Jewish Church, with smaller works by Ottley and others. ‘ oe : American works on the subject from the critical point of view are a History of the Heb People, by Kent, and a History of the Jewish People by Kent and Riggs in the “Historical Series for Bible Students,"’ published by Messrs. Scribner. Cf also McCurdy, History, Proghecy and the Monuments; Toy, Judatsm and Christianity; H.P. Smith, OT History. C. von ORELLI ISRAEL, KINGDOM OF: I. Tue First Perrop 1. The Two Kingdoms 2. The Ist Dynasty 3. The IId Dynasty 4, Civil War II. Pxrrriop or tHe Syrian Wars 1. The IlId Dynasty . World-Politics . Battle of Karkar Loss of Territory Reform of Religion Revolution The [Vth Dynasty Renewed Prosperity . Anarchy Ill, Deowne anp Faun 1. Loss of Independence 2. Decline 3. Extinction 4. Summary LIvERATURB I. The First Period.—The circumstances leading up to the foundation of the Northern Kingdom of Israel, or the Kingdom of the Ten 1. The Two Tribes, have been detailed under the Kingdoms heading Kincpom or Jupan. From a secular point of view it would be more natural to regard the latter as an offshoot from the former, rather than the converse. But not only is the kingdom of Judah of paramount importance in respect of both religion and literature, but its government also was in the hands of a single dy- nasty, whereas that of the Northern Kingdom changed hands no less than 8 t, during the two and a half cents. of its existence. Moreover, the South- ern Kingdom lasted about twice as long as the other. No sooner had Jeroboam I been elected the first tuler of the newly founded state than he set about Inanaging its affairs with the energy 2. The Ist for which he was distinguished (1 K Dynasty 11 28). To complete the disruption : he established a sanctuary in opposi- tion to that of Jerns (Hos 8 14), with its own order of priests (2 Ch 11 14; 13 9), and founded two capital cities, Shechem on the W. and Penuel on the E. of the Jordan (1 K 12 25). Peace seems to have been maintained between the rival govern- ments during the 17 years’ reign of Rehoboam, but on the accession of his son Abijah war broke out (li K 16 6.7; 2 Ch 13 3ff). Shortly afterward Jeroboam died and was succeeded by his son Nadab, OWN AMP Ors 1529 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 18!el, History of Israel, King. of who was a year later assassinated, and the Ist Dynasty came to an end, after an existence of 23 years, being limited, in fact, to a single reign. The turn of the tribe of Issachar came next. They had not yet given aruler to Israel; they could claim none of the judges, but they 3. The IId_ had taken their part at the assembling Dynasty of the tribes under Deborah and Barak of Naphtali. Baasha began his reign of 24 years by extirpating the house of his predecessor (1 K 15 29), just as the ‘Abbd4sids annihilated the Umeiyads. The capital was now Tirzah (1 K 1417; Cant 6 4), a site not yet identified. His Judaean contemporary was ASA (q.v.), who, like his father Abijah, called in the aid of the Syrians against the Northern Kingdom. Baasha was unequal to the double contest and was forced to evacuate the ground he had gained. His son Elah was assassinated after a reign of a year, as he himself had assassinated the son of the founder of the preceding dynasty, and his entire family and adherents were massacred (1 K 16 11). The name of the assassin was Zimri, an officer of the charioteers, of unknown origin and tribe. But the kingship was always elective, and 4. Civil War the army chose Omri, the commander- in-chief, who besieged and took Tir- zah, Zimri setting the palace on fire by his own hand and perishing in the flames. A second pre- tender, Tibni, a name found in Phoenician and Assyrian, of unknown origin, sprang up. He was quickly disposed of, and security of government was reéstablished. Il. Period of the Syrian Wars.—The founder of the new dynasty was Omri. By this time the Northern Kingdom was so much a 1. The Id united whole that the distinctions of Dynasty tribe were forgotten. We do not know to what tribe Omri and his successors belonged. With Omri the political sphere of action of Israel became wider than it had been before, and its internal affairs more settled. His civil code was in force long after his dynasty was extinct, and was adopted in the Southern Kingdom (Mic 6 16). The capital city, the site of which he chose, has remained a place of human habitation till the present day. Witbin the last few years, remains of his building have been recovered, showing a great advance in that art from those believed to go back to Rehoboam and Solomon. He was, however, unfortunate in his relations with Syria, having lost some towns and been forced to grant certain trading concessions to his northern neighbors (1 K 20 34). But he was so great a king that long after his death the Kingdom of the Ten Tribes was known to the Assyrians as ‘“‘the house of Omri.” Contemporarily with this dynasty, there occurred a revival of the Phoen power, which exerted a power- ful influence upon the Israelite kings 2. World- and people, and at the same time the Politics Assyrians once more began to inter- fere with Syrian politics. The North- ern Kingdom now began to play a part in the game of world-politics. There was peace with Judah, and alliance with Phoenicia was cemented by the marriage of Ahab, it seems after his father’s death, with Jezebel, the daughter of Ethbaal (1 K 16 31). This led to the erection of a temple in Samaria in which the Tyrian Baal was worshipped, while side by side with it the worship of Jeh was carried on as before. Jt seems as if the people had fallen back from the pure monotheism of Moses and David into what is known as henotheism. Against this relapse Elijah protested with final success. Ahab was a wise and skilful soldier, without rashness, but- also without decision. He defeated a Syrian coali- tion in two campaigns (1 K 20) and imposed on Ben-hadad the same conditions which the latter had imposed on Omri. With the close of the reign of Asa in Judah, war ceased between the two Israelite kingdoms and the two kings for the first time became friends and fought side by side (1 K 22). In the reign of Ahab we note the henncine of decay in the state in regard to personal liberty and equal justice. The tragedy of Naboth’s vineyard would not have happened but for the influence of Tyrian ideas, any more than in the case of the famous windmill which stands by the palace of Sans Souci at Potsdam. A further improvement in the art of building took place in this reign. The palace of Ahab, which has recently been recovered by the excavations carried on by the Harvard University Expedition under Dr. G. A. Reisner, shows a marked advance in fine- ness of workmanship upon that of Omri. The object of Ben-hadad’s attack upon Ahab seems to have been to compel him to join a league founded to resist the encroachments of 3. Battle | Assyria upon the countries bordering of Karkar upon the Mediterranean. The con- federates, who were led by Ben-hadad, and of whom Ahab was one, were defeated by Shal- maneser II in the battle of Karkar. The date is known from the inscriptions to have been the year 854-853. It is the first quite certain date in Heb history, and from it the earlier dates must be reck- Hed be working backward. Ahab seems to have seized the moment of Syria’s weakness to exact by force the fulfilment of their agreement on the part of Ben-hadad (1 K 22). On the other hand, the king of Moab, Mesha, appears to have turned the same disaster to account throwing off his allegiance io 4. Loss of Israel, which dated from the time of Territory David, but had apparently lapsed until it was enforced anew by Omri (M8, ll. 4 ff, but 1. 8 makes Omri’s reign + half Ahab’s=40 years). Ahab’s son and _ successor Jehoram (omitting Ahaziah, who is chiefly notable as a devotee of Baal-zebub, the god of Ekron), with the aid of Jehoshaphat and his vassal, the king of Edom, attempted to recover his rights, but in vain (2 K 3). It may have been in consequence of the failure of this expedition that the Syrians again besieged Samaria and reduced it to great straits (2 K 6 24; 7), but the date is uncertain. Jehoram replied with a counter-attack upon the E. of the Jordan. It was no doubt owing to his connection with the king of Judah that Jehoram so far modified the worship and ritual as to remove the 5. Reform worst mnovations which had come to of Religion prevail in the Northern Kingdom (2 K 3 1-3). But these half-measures did not satisfy the demands of the time, and in the revolution which followed both he and his dynasty were swept away. ‘The dynasty had lasted, ac- cording to the Bib. account, less than half a century. The religious reformation, or rather revolution, which swept away almost entirely both royal houses, bears a good deal of resemblance to 6. Revolu- the Wahhdbi rising in Arabia at the tion beginning of the 18th cent. It_took its origin from prophetism (1 K 19 16), and was supported by the Rechabite Jonadab. The object of the movement headed by Jehu was nominally to revenge the prophets of Jeh put to death by order of Jezebel, but in reality it was much wider and aimed at nothing less than rooting out the Baal-worship altogether, and enforcing a return to the primitive faith and worship. Just as the Wahbhabis went back to Mohammed’s doctrine, as contained in the Kor’4n and the Tradition, and as the Rechabites preserved the simplicity of the early desert life, so Jehu went back to the state of things Israel, King. of Israel, Rel. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1530 as they were at the foundation of the Northern Kingdom under Jeroboam I. Jehu’s reforms were carried out to the letter, and the whole dynasty of Omri, which was responsible for the innovations, was annihilated 7. IVth like its predecessors. The religious Dynasty fervor, however, soon subsided, and Jehu’s reign ended in disaster. Ha- zael, whose armies had been exterminated by the forces of Assyria, turned his attention to the eastern territory of Israel. In the turbulent land of Gilead, the home of Elijah, disappointed in its hopes of Jehu, he quickly established his supremacy (2 K 10 32 ff). Jehu also appreciated the significance of the victories of Assyria, and was wise enough to send tribute to Shalmaneser II. This was in the year 842. Under his son and successor Jehoahaz the fortunes of Israel continued to decline, until Hazael imposed upon it the most humiliating conditions (Am 1 3-5; 2 K 13 1 ff). Toward the end of the reign of Jehoahaz, however, the tide began to turn, under the leadership of a military genius whose name has not 8. Renewed been recorded (2 K 13 5); and the Prosperity improvement continued, after the death of Hazael, under his son Je- hoash (Joash), who even besieged and plundered Jerus (2 K 14 8 ff). But it was not until the long reign of Jeroboam II, son of Jehoash, that the fron- tiers of Israel, were, for the first time since the begin- ning of the kingdom, restored to their ideal limits. Even Damascus and Hamath were subdued (2 K 14 28). But the prosperity was superficial. Jero- boam II stood at the head of a military oligarchy, who crushed the great mass of the people under them. The tribune of the plebs at this time was Amos of Tekoa. His Cassandra-like utterances soon ful- filled themselves. The dynasty, which had been founded in blood and had lasted some 90 years, on the accesssion of Jeroboam’s son Zachariah gave place to 12 years of anarchy. Zachariah was almost immediately assassinated by Shallum, who within a month was in turn assas- sinated by Menahem, a soldier of the 9, Anarchy tribe of Gad, stationed in Tirzah, to avenge the death of his master. The low social condition of Israel at this time is de- picted in the pages of Hos. The atrocities per- petrated by the soldiers of Menahem are mentioned by Jos (Ané, IX, xi, 1). III, Decline and Fall.—Meantime Pul or Pulu had founded the second Assyr empire under the name of Tiglath-pileser III. Before 1. Loss of conquering Babylonia, he broke the Independ- power of the Hittites in the W., and ence made himself master of the routes leading to the Phoen seaports. As the eclipse of the Assyr power had allowed the expansion of Israel under Jeroboam II, so its revival now crushed the independence of the nation for- ever. Menahem bought stability for his throne by the payment of an immense bribe of 1,000 talents of silver, or $2,000,000, reckoning the silver talent at $2,000. The money was raised by means of an assessment of 50 talents each upon all the men of known wealth. The payment of this tribute is mentioned on the Assyr monuments, the date being 738. Menahem reigned 10 years. His son Pekahiah was, soon after his accession, assassinated by one of his own captains, Pekah, son of 2. Decline Remaliah, who established himself, with the help of some Gileadites, as king. He formed an alliance with Rezin of Damas- cus against Israel, defeating Ahaz in two pitched battles, taking numerous captives, and even reach- ing the walls of Jerus. The result was disastrous to both allies. Ahaz called in the aid of the Assyr- ians. Tiglath-pileser put an end to the kingdom of Damascus, and deported the inhabitants of Northern and Eastern Pal. The kingdom of Israel was re- duced to the dimensions of the later province of Samaria. Pekah himself was assassinated by Ho- shea, who became king under the tutelage of the Assyr overlord. The depopulated provinces were filled with colonists from the conquered countries of the East. The year is 734. Hoshea was never an independent king, but the mere vassal of Assyria. He was foolish enough to withhold the annual tribute, and to 8. Extinc- turn to Egypt for succor. Meanwhile, tion Tiglath-pileser III had been succeeded by Shalmaneser IV. This king laid siege to Samaria, but died during the siege. The city was taken by his successor Sargon, who had seized the throne, toward the end of the year 722. The Northern Kingdom had lasted 240 years, which fall into three periods of about 80 years each, the middle period being the period of 4. Sum- theSyrian wars. Asit was fully formed mary when it broke off from the Southern Kingdon, its history shows no develop- ment or evolution, but is made up of undulations of prosperity and of decline. It was at its best imme- diately after its foundation, and again under Jero- boam II. It was strong under Baasha, Omri and Ahab, but generally weak under the other kings. Every change of dynasty meant a period of anarchy, when the country was at the mercy of every in- vader. The fortunes of Israel depended entirely on those of Assyria. When Assyria was weak, Israel was strong. Given the advance of Assyria, the destruction of Israel was certain. This was necessary and was clearly foreseen by Hosea (9 3, etc). The wonder is that the little state, surrounded by such powerful neighbors, lasted as long as it did. See, further, Isnanz, History oF, V. LirERATURE.—The most important works. are Ewald, Geschichte des Volkes Israel (ET by Martinean and Glover); elihausen, Geschichte Israels; Deren- bourg, Essai sur l'histoire... . de la Palestine; and there are many more. Ewald is best known to Eng. readers through the medinm of Dean Stanley's Lectures on the History of the Jewish Church. See further under Curono.tocy; IsRaEL, and arts. on individual kings. Tuomas HunTER WEIR ISRAEL, RELIGION OF: I. Intropuction: Husroricayn CONSIDERATION OF THE RELIGION OF IsRABL II. Hisroricat OuTLINE 1. Pre-Mosaic Religion of the Ancestors of Israel (1) The Traditional View (2) The Modern View (3) A Higher Conception of the Deity; ’ilu, 'é 34 Totemism, Animism, etc 5) Conception of God (6) Cultus 2. The Mosaic Covenant with Jehovah (1) The Covenant-Idea 2 The Covenant-God, Jehovah 3) Monotheism of Moses (4) Impossibility of Representing Jehovah by an mage (3) Ethical Character of the God of Moses 6) The Theocracy (7) The Mosaic Cultus 3. The Religion of Israel before the 8th Century BC (1) Decay of Religion in Canaan (2) The Theocratic Kingdom (3) Religious Ideals of the Psalms from the Time of David (4) Wisdom Literature from the Time of Solo- mon 5) The Sanctuary on Mt. Zion 6) The Religion of the Kingdom of Ephraim 7) Elijah and Elisha 4. Development of the Religion of Israel from the 8th Cent. BC to the Exile es The Writing Prophets 2) Their Opposition to the Cultus 4 5 6 Their Preaching of the Judgment Their Messianic Promises Reformations Destruction of Jerusalem 1531 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, King. of Israel, Rel. of 5. The Babylonian Exile | 33 Spiritual Purification through the Exiie 2) Relations to the Gentile World 6. Religion of the Post-exilic Period 1) Life under the Law 2) Hellenism Pharisees and Sadducees (4) Essenes (5) Pesitive Connections between Judaism and Hellenism : (6) Apocaiyptic Literature IfI. Conenusion: CHaracteristic FEATURES OF THE RE .IGIon or IsRraBu 1, The Living God 2. The Reiation of Man te This God LITERATURE I. Introduction.—In former times it was the rule to draw out of the OT its religious contents ouly for dogmatic purposes, without making any distinction between the different books. These writings were all regarded as the documents of the Divine revelation which had been given to this people alone and not to others. At the present time the first inquiry in the study of these books deals historically with the religious development of the Israelites. This religion was not of a strictly uniform nature, but is characterized by a devel- opment and a growth, and in the centuries which are covered by the OT books it has passed through many changes. trends among the people and very different degrees in the extent of their religious knowledge. The common people were at times still entangled in crude heathen ideas, while the bearers of a higher Divine light ranked vastly above them. And even in those times, when these enlightened teachers secured full recognition, there occurred relapses into lower forms of religion on the part of the masses, esp. because the influence of the nations surround- ing Israel at all times made itself felt in the religious life and thoughts of the latter. And even when the correct teachings were accepted by the people, a malformation of the entire religion could readily occur through a petrifaction of the religious life. It is the business of the science of the history of religion to furnish a correct picture of this develop- ment, which in this article can be done only in the - form of a sketch. One of the recent results of the science of the history of religion is the knowledge that the religion of Israel itself, and not merely the corruptions ‘of this religion, stood in a much closer connection with other religions than had in former times been sup- posed. The wealth of new data from the history of oriental nations lately secured has shown that it is not correct to regard the religion of Israel as an isolated phenomenon, but that considerable light is thrown upon it from analogous facts from sur- rounding regions. Of especial importance in this respect is the study of Assyr and Bab antiquities, with their rich and illustrative monuments, and, by the side of these, also those of Egypt; and, further, although these are indeed much smaller in number, the inscriptions and monuments of a number of peoples situated much nearer to Israel and ethnologically more closely connected with them, such as the Moabites, Aramaeans, Arabians, Canaanites, Phoenicians, and others. For later times, Parsiism is an esp. important factor. These antiquities have shown that between the religion of Israel and the religions of these nations there existed such close connections that a relation- ship between them cannot be denied. It is indeed true that these similarities are mostly of a formal nature, but they nevertheless point to similar con- ceptions of the Divine Being and of the relation of man to this Being. We find such connecting links in the cultus, in the traditions concerning the creation of the world, concerning the earliest history of man- Then, too, in the different periods. of this development there were various religious - kind, ete; further, in the conception of what is legally right and of the customs of life; in the ideas concerning death and the world beyond; concerning the souls of men and the supernatural spiritual world, and elsewhere. These analogies and related connections have appeared so pronounced to some savants, especially Assyriologists, that they are willing to find in the religion of the Israelites and Jews only a reflection of the Bab, or of what they call the “religion of the ancient Orient.’? But over against this claim, a closer and deeper investigation shows that a higher world of thought and ideals at all times permeates the Israelitish religion and gives to it a unique character and a Divine truth, which is lacking in all other religions and which made Israel’s religion capable of becoming the basis of that highest Divine revelation which through Christ came forth from it. We will here briefly sketch the progress of the development of this religion, and then formulate a summary of those characteristics which distinguish it from the other religions. Il. Historical Outline.—(1) The traditional view. —tThe sources for this period are meager. Yet what has been reported concerning 1. Pre- the religion of the period of the Pa- Mosaic triarchs is enough to give us a picture Religion of of their conception of the Deity. And the Ances- this picture is more deserving of accept- tors of ance than is the representation of the Israel matter by the traditional dogmatics of the church and also that of those modern scholars who are under the spell of the evo- lutionary idea, and who undertake to prove in the Bib. history of Israel the complete development from the lowest type of fetishism and animism to the heights of ethical monotheism. The views of the old church teachers were to the effect that the doctrine concerning the one true God had been communicated by God to Adam in its purity and perfection, and by him had been handed through an unbroken chain of true confessors of the faith (Seth, Noah, etc), down to Abraham. But this view does not find confirmation in the Bib. record. On the contrary, in Josh 24 2.15, it is even ex- pressly stated ot the ancestors of Abraham that they had worshipped strange gods in Chaldaea. And the ancestors of the people, Abraham, Jacob, and others, do not appear on the stage of history with a teachable creed, but themselves first, learn to know gradually, in the school of life, the God whom they serve, after He has made Himself known to them in extraordinary manifestations. Abraham does not yet know that Jeh does not demand any human sacrifices. Jacob still has the narrow view, that the place where he has slept is the entrance portal to heaven (Gen 28 16.17). Omnipresence and omniscience are not yet attributes which they asso- ciate with their idea of the Divinity. They still stand on a simple-minded and primitive stage, as far as their knowledge of the living God is concerned. (2) The modern view.— Over against this, modern scholars describe pre-Mosaic Israel as yet entirely entangled in Sem heathen ideas, and even regard the religion of the people in general, in the post-Mosaic period down to the 8th cent. BC, as little better than this, since in their opinion the Jeh-religion had not thoroughly permeated the ranks of the common people, and had practically remained the possession of the men, while the women had con- tinued to cultivate the ancient customs and views. W. R. Smith and Wellhausen have pointed to cus- toms and ideas of the pre-Islamic Arabs, and 8.1. Curtiss to such in the modern life of oriental tribes, which are claimed to have been the property of the most ancient Sem heathen tribes, and these scholars use these as the key for the ancient Israelitic rites Israel, Rel. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1532 and customs. But even if much light is thrown from these sources on the forms of life and cultus as depicted by the Scriptures, much caution must be exercised in the use made of this material. In the first place, neither those Arabs of the 6th cent. AD, nor their successors of today, can be regarded as ‘‘primitive Semites.” In the second place, it is a question, even if in the earliest period of Israel such customs are actually found, what they really signified for the tribe of Abraham. Weare here not speaking of a prehistoric religion, but of the religion of that tribe that came originally from Ur of the Chaldees, and migrated first by way of Haran to Canaan, and then to Egypt. In this tribe such primitive cus- toms, perhaps, had long been spiritualized. For these Hebrews cannot be regarded as being as uncivilized as are the New Zealanders, or the Indians of North America, or those Bedouins who have never left the desert; for they had lived in Babylonia for a long period, even if, while there, they had with- drawn themselves as much as possible from the more cultured life of the cities. The patriarchs were in touch with the civilization of the Babylonians. We do not, indeed, want to lay special stress on the fact that they lived in Ur and in Haran, two cities of the moon-god, the worship of which divinity shows monotheistic tendencies. But the history of the family of Abraham, e.g. his relation to Sarah and Hagar, shows indisputable influence of Bab legal ideas. Probably, too, the traditions concerning the beginnings of history, such as the Creation, the Deluge, and the like, were brought from Babylon to Canaan by the tribe of Abraham. (3) A higher conception of the Deity; ’ilu, ’él.— But this tribe had come to Babylonia from North- ern Arabia. It is a very important fact that the oldest Arabian inscriptions, namely the Minaean and the Sabaean, lead us to conclude that these tribes entertained a relatively high conception of the Deity, as has been shown by Professor Fritz Hommel. The oldest Arabian proper names are not found combined with names of all kinds of gods, but with the simple ilu, ’é, or God, or with "ii, “my God.” Then, too, God is often circumscribed by the nouns expressing relationship, such as ’abh2, “my father,’ or ’ah2, “my brother,” or ’ammi, “my uncle,” and others, which express an intimate rela- tionship betwecn man and his God. Correspond- ing to these are also the old Sem proper names in Canaan, as also the name Abraham, i.e. ’Abhi- ram, “my father is exalted,” or Ishmael, and many others. We accordingly must believe that the an- cestors of Abraham immigrated into Babylon with a comparatively highly developed religion and with a uniform conception of God. Here their faith may have been unfavorably influenced, and it is not impossible that the religious disagreement between the patriarch and his neighbors may have been a reason for his migration. Abraham himself is regarded by the Canaanites as a “friend of God,” who stands in an intimate relationship with his God, and he is accordingly to be regarded, not merely as a secular, but also as a religious tribal head, an Imdm, a prophetical personality. _ (4) Totemism; animism, ete.—Still less is it cor- rect. to ascribe to this tribe the lowest religious stage possible, namely that of fetishism or of totemism (worship of demons or worship of animals) and the like. Some think they find evidences of the wor- ship of animals in Israel. The fact that some Israelites were regarded as descendants of Leah (“wild cow”[?]), others of Rachel (‘‘mother sheep”), is claimed to refer to the fact that these animals were totems of the tribe, i.e. were worshipped as ancestors. But for this claim there is no scintilla of proof. These names of women, esp. in the case of a nomadic tribe, can be explained in a much more simple way. The calves that appear in later timcs as images of Jeh are just as little a proof for the claim that calves were worshipped by the an- cestors of Israel as divinities. We read nothing of such an image before the sojourn in Egypt, and after that time this image was always regarded symbolically. The fact, again, that from the days of Moses, and without a doubt earlier than this, certain animals were not allowed to be eaten, does not justify the conclusion which Professor B. Stade and others have drawn from it, viz. that these ani- mals were in olden times regarded as divine (tabu), and for that reason were not permitted to be eaten, and only afterward were avoided as “unclean.” The list of unclean animals in Lev 11 and Dt 14 speaks for an altogether different reason for regard- ing them as unclean. It is not at all thinkable that these many, and as a rule unclean and low class of animals, were at one time accorded divine honor, while the higher and cleaner class had been ex- cluded from this distinction. We have accordingly no reason for finding animal worship here. On the other hand, it is self-evident, in the case of such an old nomadic tribe, that man stood in a more familiar relationship to his animals, and for this reason the slaughter of these was a more significant matter than was afterward the case. This was done only ‘on extraordinary occasions, and it readily was ac- corded areligious consecration. Seealso ToTEMism. The idea is also emphatically to be rejected, that in the pre-Mosaic period mere animism prevailed in Israel—the worship of spirits and of demons. It has been tried in vain to show that in the most primitive period of Israel’s religion the worship of ancestors occupied a prominent place. As Pro- fessor Emil Kautzsch has emphasized, the argu- ments which have been drawn from the mourning customs of the Israelites in favor of this claim (as this is done by F. Schwally, Das Leben nach dem Tode, nach den Vorstellungen des alten Israel und des Judentums, Giessen, 1892) are altogether inade- quate, as is also the appeal to the marriage with a deceased wife’s sister, as though the purpose of the institution was to secure for the deceased who had died without issue somebody who would attend to his worship. Because of the strongly developed mundane character of the religious life in Israel, it is natural that it was regarded as a calamity if there was no issue who kept alive the memory of the departed in the tribe. But even if the argu- ment from the mourning customs of Israel were more convincing than is actually the case, and that gifts, such as food, oil, and the like, were placed in the tomb of the departed, as was often done by the Canaanites, yet this would be in the ancient Israel- itish religion a matter of subordinate importance, which could readily be explained on the ground of natural feelings. 1t could never be made to appear plausible that all religions had grown out of such a cultus. lf the teraphim are to be regarded as having been originally images of ancestors, which is quite plausible, then they would indeed represent a continuous ancestral cultus, as the people evidently kept these images in their houses in order to attract to themselves blessings, to avert misfortunes and to secure oracles. But these dolls, modeled after the form of human beings, already in the period of the Patriarchs were regarded as a foreign element and in contradiction to the more earnest religious sentiments (cf Gen 31 19; 35 2.4). _ That Israel, like all ancient peoples, did at one me pass through an “animistic” stage of religious development could best be proved, if at all, from their conception of the soul. Among the purifi- cations those are esp. necessary which are demanded by the presence of a dead body in the same room with the living, as the living are defiled by the soul 1533 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA of the deceased in leaving the body (Nu 19 14). Even the uncovered vessels are defiled by his soul- substance (19 15). This, however, is a biological conception, which has nothing to do with the con- ception of the Deity. Or are those perhaps right, who think that the primitive Israelites had accepted animism in this sense, that they did not as yet worship any actual divinities, but only a multitude of spirits or demons, be these ghosts of departed human beings or the spirits of Nature, local numina? In favor of this last-mentioned view, appeal is made to this faet, that in the ancient Sem world loeal divinities with very circumseribed spheres of power are very often to be met with, esp. at springs, trees, oases, at which a demon or divinity is regarded as having his abode, who is described as the ba‘al or master in this place; cf sueh loeal names as Baal-tamar, Baal-hermon, and others. Such local spirits would then be the ’élohim, out of which would grow more mighty divinities of whole cities and countries. To these it would be necessary yet to add those spirits which were worshipped by individual tribes, partly spirits of ancestors, who also eould have grown into higher divinities, while the rest of the mass of deities, good naga had to content themselves with a lower rank. As against this, we must above all consider the fact that in ancient Israel the demons played a very subordinate r6le. The contrast in this regard with Babylonia is phenomenal. It is probably the ease that at all periods in Israel there existed a belief in unclean spirits, who perhaps lived in the desert (cf the EY YYW , s*‘trim), or in the demoniacs, and could otherwise, too, do much harm. But they are not described as having much influence on man’s life. How few indications of such a view can be found and how little most of these indications prove we can see in the work of H. Duhm, Die bésen Geister im AT, Tiibingen, 1906. After the Bab exile, and still more after the longer sojourn of the Israel- ites in Babylon, their imagination was to a much greater degree than before saturated by the faith in spirits. Then the closer study of such Sem bealim teaches us that they were not originally con- eeived in such a narrow sense. They are very often of a solar nature, celestial powers who have their abode at a particular place, and there produce fertility, but in this special function represent a general power of Nature. Thesameis the ease with the tribal divinities. These are by no means merely the personifications of the small power of a particular tribe, but claim to be absolute beings, which shows that they are regarded as higher di- vinities which the tribe has appropriated and adapted to its own political ideas. We accordingly have no right to think that such a divinity was to be regarded as really confined to a particular hill, or even to a certain stone or tree where it was wor- shipped. The rock or stone or tree divinities of the ancient Arabs are celestial powers, who have only taken their abode at these places, even, if popular superstition did actually identify them with sueh stones or trees. It is therefore a misconception of the actual state of affairs when the conclusion is drawn that stone-worship is meant when Jacob erects a stone monument, the mag¢cébhah at Bethel, and anoints it with oil, and when this is understood to be a low type of fetishism. Stones are to the present day, for the wandering tribes, the signs by which impor- tant, localities, esp. sacred places, are designated. The symbolical significance of such stones may be quite different, as also the relation which a divinity is thought to sustain to such a stone monument. For this reason, too, the judgment of the Bible con- Israel, Rel. of cerning such objects is quite different. Only then, when they are symbols of idolatry, as the hamma- nim, i.e. representations of the sun-god, ba‘al hammédn, are they everywhere rejected in the OT. In the same way a mighty tree, esp. if it is found near a spring of water, is in the Orient, by its very nature, a proof of the life-produeing God. Such a tree naturally suggests that it is a place where divine life can be felt. Trees that have been made saered by manifestations of the divinities or have been eonsecrated by the memory of a great personality, esp. the oak, the terebinth, the palm, were regarded as favorite places beneath which the divinity was sought. Only in that case, as was indeed common in Canaan, when the unhallowed powers of Nature were here adored, was this custom reprehensible in the eyes of the prophets. The ’'déshérim, too, are of a decidedly heathen eharaeter, as these trunks of trees were symbols of the goddess Ashera. Further, it was a favorite custom to worship the divinities on the high places, for the reason that they were regarded as in or attached to the heavens. Only because of the heathen worship which was prac- tised on these béméth were they, in later times, so hateful to the prophets. (5) Conception of God—In answer to the ques- tion, what ideas the patriarchs, the pre-Mosaie leaders of the people of Israel, entertained concern- ing God, attention must first of all be drawn to the faet that God spoke to some of these personally, be this in one form of manifestation or in another. These men heard the word of God with their own ears, and that, too,in the most important moments of their lives. In the case of Abraham, these reve- lations are fundamental for him and for his people. The prophetie factor, which goes through the entire history of Israel and constitutes the life-principle that fills its religion and causes its further develop- ment, is at the very first beginnings the source whence the knowledge of God is taken. This pre- supposes a personal God; and, as a matter of fact, a fixed personality is demanded by the character of such a God. His “I” impresses itself upon man with absolute power and demands his serviee en- tirely. This “I’’ constantly remains the same, and everywhere evinces the same power, be this in Haran or in Canaan or in Egypt, and whether it manifests itself to Abraham or to Isaac or to Jacob. This oneness is not formulated as a didactic propo- sition, but as a living reality: only this God existed for His adherents. These appeal to Him at all times with equal success. The manifestations of this God may be of a different kind at different times. He is even entertained, on one occasion, as a personal guest by His friend Abraham, together with two companions (Gen 18 1 ff). On another occasion (Gen 16 17) Abraham beholds Him in symbolical form as a burning and fiery furnace (probably to be regarded as similar to the movable altar discovered by Sellin in Taanach). But these are to be regarded as special favors shown by God. In general it was the rule that God could not be seen without the beholder suffering death. Then, too, the conviction is very old, that what man sees in the case of such theophanies cannot have been God Himself, but that He had manifested Himself through a subordinate agent, an angel (this is par- tieularly the ease in the document E in Gen). This angel, however, has no significance in himself, but is only the creature-veil, out of which God Himself speaks in the first person. In the most elementary manner this formal limitation of God appears in Gen 11 5, where He goes to the trouble of deseend- ing from heaven in order to look at something on earth; and in 18 21, when He desires to_go to Sodom personally, in order to convince Himself that what He has intended to send upon this city Israel, Rel. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1534 is also the right thing. It is indeed possible to find in the first instance some traits of irony, and possibly in the second case the epic details may have added something. However, God is no longer spoken of in such a human way in the post-Mosaic times. This shows that the document J at this place con- tains material that is very old. All the more is it to be noted what exalted conceptions of God pre- vail already in these narratives. He dwells in heaven (11 5; 19 24), something that has without reason been claimed not to have been the idea enter- tained in the older period. He is the God of the world, who exercises supremacy over all the nations. He rules with justice, checks pride, avenges injus- tice, and that, too, not only in a summary manner on whole countries, but also in such a way that He takes into consideration every individual and saves the one just man out of the midst of the mass of sinners (18 25; 19). Jn short, He is already the true God, although yet incompletely and primi- tively grasped in His attributes. This God, ruling with omnipotent power in Na- ture and history, has entered into a special relation- ship with the tribe of Abraham. He has become the Covenant-God of the patriarch, according to the testimony of the old document J in Gen 165. We accordingly find here already the consciousness that that God who rules over the world has entered into a special relationship with one small nation or tribe. This fact appears also in this, that Abram (Gen 14) acknowledges the highest God of the priest-king Melchizedek (Gen 14 20 ff) as his God, as the founder of heaven and of earth, and identifies Him with his own Covenant-God Jeh. (6) Cultus ——As far as the cultus is concerned, it can be stated that at this period it was still of a simple, but solemn and dignified character. The people preferred to worship their God at such places where He had manifested Himself, usually on a high place, on which an altar had been erected. There were no images of the Divinity extant. As the word MATA, mizbeh, “altar,” shows, the sacri- fices were usually bloody. Human sacrifice had already in the days of Abraham been overcome by the substitution of an animal, although in olden times it may have been practised, perhaps, as the sacrifice of the firstborn; and in later times, too, through the influence of the example of heathen nations, it may have found its way into Israel now and then. Both larger and smaller animals were sacrificed, as also fowls. The idea that prevailed in this connection was that God, too, enjoyed the food which served man as his sustenance, although God, in a finer way, experienced as a pleasure only the scent of the sacrifices, as this ascended in the flame and the smoke (Gen 8 21). But the mam thing was the blood as the substratum of the soul. The fruits of the field, esp. the first-fruits, were also offered. Of liquid offerings, it is probable that in primitive times water was often brought, as this was often a costly possession; and in Canaan, oil, which the inhabitants of this country employed extensively in their sacrifices (Jgs 9 9, something that is confirmed also by recent excavations); also wine (Jgs 9 13). As the ancient burnt or whole sacrifices (Gen 8 20) give expression to reverence, thankfulness, the prayer for protection or the granting of certain favors, the people from the very beginning also instituted sacrificial feasts, which gave expression to the covenant with God, the communion with the Covenant-God. In this act the sacrifice was divided between God and those who sacrificed. The latter ate and drank joyously before God after the parts dedicated to Him had been sacrificed, and esp. after the blood had been poured around the altar. The idea that this was the original form of the sacrifice and that gift- sacrifices were introduced only at a later period when agriculture had been introduced is not con- firmed by historical evidences. That man felt himself impelled, by bringing to his God gifts of the best things he possessed, to express his depend- ence and gratitude, is too natural not to have been from the beginning a favorite expression of religious feeling. In connection with the sacrifices the name of God was solemnly called upon. J even says that this was the name Jeh (Gen 4 25), while E and P tell us that this name came into use only through Moses. ; : as According to P (Gen 17 10 ff), circumcision was already introduced by Abraham in his tribe as the sign of the covenant. There are good reasons why the introduction of this custom is not like that of so many other ceremonies attributed to Moses. The custom was without doubt of an older origin. From whatever source it may have been derived in its earlier ethnological stage, for the Israelites circumcision is an act of purification and of conse- cration for connection with the congregation of Jeh. A special priesthood, however, did not yet exist in this period, as the head of the family and of the tribe exercised the priestly functions and rights (cf Gen 35 1 ff), although the peoples in- habiting Canaan at that time had priests (Gen 14 18). (1) The covenant-idea.—Israel claims that its existence as a nation and its special relation to Jeh begins with its exodus from Egypt 2. The and with the conclusion of the cove- Mosaic nant at Mt. Sinai (ef Am 3 2; 9 7). Covenant As the preparation for this relation with goes back to one individual, viz. Jehovah Abraham, thus it is Moses through whom God delivered His people from bondage and received them into His covenant (see concerning Moses as a prophet and mediator of the covenant, IskaEL, History or). It is a matter of the highest significance for the religion of Israel that the relation of this people to Jeh was not one which existed by the nature of things, as was the ease with the other oriental tribal and national religions, but that it was the outgrowth of a his- torical event, in which their God had united Him- self with them. The conception of a covenant, upon which Jeh entered as a matter of free choice and will, and to which the people voluntarily gave their assent, is not an idea of later date in the reli- gious history of Israel, which grew out of the pro- phetic thoughts of the 8th and 7th cents. BC, as has been claimed, but is found, as has been made prominent by Professor Fr. Giesebrecht (Die Geschichtlichkeitt des Sinaibundes, 1900), already in the oldest accounts of the conclusion of the covenant (E, J), and must be aseribed to the Mosaic age. This includes the fact, too, that this cove- nant, which unites Jeh with Israel, could not be of an indissoluble character, but that the covenant was based on certain conditions. The superficial opinion of the people might often cause them to forget this. But the prophets could, in later times, base their proclamations on this fact. Further, the thought is made very prominent that this covenant imposed ethical duties. While the di- vinities of other nations, Egyp, Bab, Phoen, de- manded primarily that their devotees should erect temples in their honor and should bring them an abundance of sacrifices, in Israel the exalted and ethical commandment is found in the forefront. The covenant relation to the God of Israel can legitimately be found only where the relation to one’s fellow-man is normal and God-pleasing (Decalogue). (2) The Covenant-God, Jehovah—The special revelation which Moses received is characterized 1535 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, Rel. of by the word Jehovah ( Yahweh) as a name for God. This name, according to the well-authenticated report of Ex 6 3 (P), which is supported also by E, had not been “known” to the fathers. This does not necessarily mean that nothing had been known of this name. Bab prayers often speak of an “unknown god,” and in doing this refer to a god with whom those who prayed had not stood in personal relation. The God of the fathers ap- peared to Moses, but under a name which was not familiar to the fathers nor was recognized by them. Tn agreement with this is the fact that only from the time of Moses proper names compounded with some abbreviation of Jeh, such as Jah, Jahu, Jeho, are found, but soon after this they became very common. Accordingly, it would be possible that such names were in scattered cases found also before the days of Moses among the tribes of Israel, and it is not impossible that this name was familiar to other nations. The Midianites esp., who lived originally at Mt. Sinai, have been mentioned in this connection, and also the Kenites (Stade, Budde), some scholars appealing for this claim to the influ- ence which, according to Ex 18, Jethro had on the institutions of Moses. However, the matters men- tioned here refer only to legal procedure (cf vs 14 ff). We nowhere hear that Moses took over the Jeh-worship from this tribe. On the contrary, Jethro begins only at this time (Ex 18 11) to wor- ship Jeh, the God of Moses, and the common sacri- ficial meal, according to ver 12, did not take place in the presence of Jeh, but, accommodating it to the guest, in the presence of Elohim. Then we nowhere hear that the Kenites, who lived together with the Israelites, ever had any special prominence in the service of Jeh, as was the case, e.g., with the Median Magi, who had charge of the priesthood among the Persians, or with the Etruscans among the Romans, who examined the entrails. Yet the Kenites would necessarily have enjoyed_ special authority in the Jeh-cultus, if their tribal God had hecome the national God of Israel. The only thing that can be cited in favor of an Arabian ori- gin of the name of Jeh is the Arab. word-form, 3, hawah, for WT, hayah. On the other hand, a number of facts indicate that Ja or Jau as a name for God was common in Syria, Philistia and Baby- lonia; cf Joram, son of the king of Hamath (2 8 8 10), and Jaubidi, the king of this city, who was removed by Sargon. In these cases, however, Tsraelitish influences may have been felt. Fried- rich Delitzsch claims to have discovered the names Jahve-ilu and Jahum-ilu on inscriptions as early as the times of Hammurabi.’ But his readings are sharply attacked. However this may be, the name God as proclaimed by Moses was not only something new for Israel, but was also announced by him (possibly also with a new pronunciation, Yahweh instead of Yahu) with a new signification. At any rate, the explanation in Ex 3 14 (E), “I Am Tuatl Am,” for doubting which we have no valid reasons, indicates a depth in the conception of God which far surpasses the current conceptions of the Syrian and the Bab pantheon. It would, perhaps, be easier to find analogous thoughts in Egyp specula- tions. But this absolute God of Moses is not the idea of speculative priests, but is a popular God who claims to control all public as well as private life. (3) Monotheism of Moses.—Attempts have been _ made to deny the monotheistic character of this God, and some have thought that the term “monol- atry” would suffice to express this stage in man’s knowledge of God, since the existence of other gods was not denied, but rather was presupposed (ef passages like Ex 16 11), and it was only forbidden to worship any god in addition to Jeh (20 3). However, this distinction is fundamental, and separates, in kind, the religion of Moses from that of the surrounding nations. For among these latter, the worship of more than one divine being at the same time was the rule. The gods of the Phoeni- cians, the Aramaeans, and the Babylonians are, like those of the Egyptians, beings that spontane- ously increase in number. They are divided into male and female groups of two, while in Heb there is not even a word extant for goddess, and the idea of a female companion-being to Jeh is an impossi- bility, Then, too, it is characteristic of the ethnic god that he is multiplied into many b«'altm, and does not feel it asa limitation or restriction when kindred divinities are associated with him. How- ever, the Jeh of Moses does not suffer another being at His side, for the very reason that He claims to be the absolute God. Passages like Ex 15 11, too, purpose chiefly only to express His unique char- acter; but if He is without any equals among the gods, then He is the only one who can claim to be God; and it is in the end only the logical dog- matic formulation of the facts in the case. when we are told in Dt, “Jeh he is God; there is none else besides him” (4 35.39; 6 4; cf Ps 18 32). This does not exclude the fact that also in later times, when monotheism had been intelligently accepted, mention is still made of the gods of the heathen as of real powers (cf, e.g. Jer 49 1). This was rather the empirical method of expression, which found its objective basis in the fact that the heathen world was still in possession of some real spiritual power. Most of all, the popular faith or the superstition of the people could often regard the gods of the other nations as ruling in the same way as Jeh did in Israel (cf, e.g. 2 Ch 28 23). But the idea that the faithful worshippers of Jeh after the days of Moses ever recognized as equal and of the same rank with their own God the gods of the heathen must be most emphatically denied, as also the claim that these Israelites assigned to Jeh only restricted pone over a small territory. This surely would ave been in flat contradiction to the well-known history of the Mosaic period, in which Jeh had demonstrated His superiority over the famous gods of Egypt in so glorious a manner. Cf on this point James Robertson, Harly Religion, 4th ed, 297 ff (against Stade). (4) Impossibility of representing Jeh by an image. —The 2d principle which the Mosaic Decalogue establishes is that Jeh cannot be represented by any image. In this doctrine, too, there is a con- scious contrast to the nations round about Israel (in addition to Ex 20 4, cf Dt 5 8; also Ex 24 17). That in the last-mentioned passage only molten images are forbidden, while those hewn of stone or made of wood might be permitted, is an arbitrary claim, which is already refuted by the fact that the Mosaic sanctuary did not contain any image of Jeh. The Ark of the Covenant was indeed a visible symbol of the presence of God, but it is a kind of throne of Him who sits enthroned invisibly above the cherubim, as has been shown above, and accordingly does not admit of any representation of God by means of an image. This continued to be the case in connection with the central sanctuary, with the exception of such aberrations as are already found in Ex $2 and which are regarded as a viola- tion of the Covenant, also at the time when the sanctuary was stationed at Shiloh. The fact that at certain local cults Jeh-images were worshipped is to be attributed to the influence of heathen sur- roundings (cf on this point J. Robertson, loc. cit., 215 ff). (5) Ethical character of the God of Moses.—A further attribute of the God of Moses, which exalts Him far above the ethnic divinities of the surround- ing peoples, is His ethical character. This appears Israel, Rel. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1536 in the fact that His principles inculcate fundamental ethical duties and His agents are chiefly occupied with the administration of legal justice. Moses himself became the lawgiver of Isracl. The spirit of this legislation is deeply ethical. Only we must not forget that Moses cannot have originated these ordinances and laws and created them as some- thing absolutely new, hut that he was compelled to build on the basis of the accepted legal customs of the people. But he purified these legal usages, which he found in use among the people, through the spirit of his knowledge of God, protected as much as possible the poor, the weak, the enslaved, and elevated the female sex, as is shown by a comparison with related Bab laws (CH). Then, too, we must not forget that the people were com- paratively uneducated, and esp. that a number of crude classes had joined themselves to the people at that time, who had to be stringently handled if their corrupt customs were not to infect the whole nation. The humane and philanthropic spirit of the Mosaic legislation appears particularly pro- nounced in Dt, which, however, represents a later reproduction of the Mosaic system, but is entirely the outcome of Mosaic principles. Most embar- rassing for our Christian feeling is the hardness of the Mosaic ordinances in reference to the heathen Canaanites, who were mercilessly to be rooted out (Dt 7 2; 20 16f). Here there prevails a concep- tion of God, which is found also among the Moab- ites, whose King Mesha, on his famous monument, boasts that he had slain all the inhabitants of the city of Kiriath-jearim as “a spectacle to Chemosh, the god of Moab.” According to Dt 7 2 ff, the explanation of this hardness is to be found in the fact that such a treatment was regarded as a Di- vine judgment upon the worshippers of idols, and served at the same time as a preventive against the infection of idolatry. (6) The theocracy.—The vital principle of the organization which Moses gave to his people, Jos ‘(CAp, II, 16) has aptly called a theocracy, be- cause the lawgiver has subordinated all relations of life to the government of his God. It is entirely incorrect when Wellhausen denies that there is a difference between theocracy and hierarchy. Not the priesthood, but Jeh alone, is to rule all things in Israel, and Jeh had many other organs or agents besides the priests, esp. the prophets, who not rarely, as the representatives of the sovereign God, sharply opposed themselves to the priests. The theocratical principle, however, finds its expression in this, that public and private life, civil and crim- inal law, military and political matters were all controlled by religious principles. (7) The Mosaic cultus—As a matter of course, Moses also arranged the cultus. He created a holy shrine, the tabernacle, which contained the Ark of the Covenant, and in its general arrangements became the model of the sanctuary or temple built in later times. He appointed sacred seasons, in doing which he connected these with previously customary festival days, but he gave sharper di- rections concerning the Sabbath and gave to the old festival of spring 2 new historical significance as the Passover. Moses further appointed for this sanctuary a priestly family, and at the same time ordained that the tribe to which this family be- longed should assume the guardianship of the sanctuary. The lines separating the rights of the priests and of the Levites have often been changed since his time, but the fundamental distinctions in this respect go back to Moses. In the same way Moses has also, as a matter of course, put the sacred rites, the celebrations of the sacrifices, the religious institutions and ceremonies, into forms suitable to that God whom he proclaimed. This does not T mean that all the priestly laws, as they are now found recorded in the Pent, were word for word dictated by him. The priests were empowered to pronounce Térah, i.e. Divine instruction, on this subject, and did this in accordance with the direc- tions received through Moses. Most of these in- structions were at first handed down orally, until they were put into written form in a large collec- tion. But in the priestly ordinances, too, there is no lack of traces to show that these date from the period of Moses and must at an early time have een put into written form. : (1) Decay of religion in Canaan.—Upon the in- tense religious feeling produced by the exodus from Egypt and the events at Mt. Smai, 3. The there followed a relapse, in connection Religion of with which it appears that in this Israel Mosaic generation the cruder tenden- before the cies were still too pronounced to en- 8th Cent. dure the great trial of faith demanded BC by the conquest of the land of Canaan. In the same way, the heroic struggles of Joshua, carried on under the directions of Jeh and resultmmg in the conquest of the country, were followed by a reaction. The zeal for battle weak- ened; the work of conquest was left unfinished; the people arranged to make themselves at home in the land before it had really been won; peace was con- cluded with the inhabitants. This decay of theo- cratic zeal and the occupation of the land by the side of and among the Canaanites had a direful influence on the Jeh-religion as it had been taught the people by Moses. The people adopted the sanctuaries of the country as their own, instead of rooting them out entirely. They took part in the festivals of their neighbors and adopted their customs of worship, including those that were bane- ful. The local Baals, in whose honor harvest and autumn festivals were celebrated as thanksgiving for their having given the products of the earth, were in many places worshipped by the Israelites. The possibility of interpretig the name Baal in both a good and bad sense favored the excuse that in doing this the people were honoring Jeh, whom in olden times they also unhesitatingly called their Baal, as their Lord and the master of the land and of the people. By the side of the Jeh-altars they placed the Asherah, the sacred tree, really as a symbol of the goddess of this name; and the stone pillars (hammanim), which the original inhabitants had erected near their sanctuaries, were also held in honor, while the heathen ideas associated with them thereby found their way into the religious conscious- ness of the people. Sorcery, necromancy, and similar superstitions crept in. And since, even as it was, a good deal of superstition had continued to survive among the people, there came into existence, in the period of the Judges, a type of popular reli- gion that was tinged by a pronounced heathenism and had but little in common with the theocratical principles of Moses, although the people had no intention of discarding the God of Moses. Char- acteristic of this religious syncretism during the time of the Judges was the rise of the worship of images dedicated to Jeh in Dan (Jgs 17 and 18) and probably also at Ophrah (8 27), as also human sacrifices (ch 11). (2) The theocratic kingdom —But during this period pronounced reactions to the true worship of Jeh were not lacking. The heroes who appeared on the arena as liberators from the yoke of the op- © pressors recalled the people to Jeh, as was done like- wise by the prophets and prophetesses. Samuel, the greatest among this class, was at the same time a prophet and reformer. He again brought the people together and tried to free them from the con- tamination of heathenism, in accordance with the 1537 Mosaic ordinances, and at the same time prepared for a new future by the establishment of colonies of prophets and by the establishment of the kingdom. This latter innovation seemed to be at variance with the principles of a strict theocracy. It is the merit of Samuel that he created the theocratic king- dom, by which the anointed of Jeh himself was to become an important agent of the supreme rule of Jeh. It is indced true that the first king, Saul, did not realize this ideal, but his successor, David, ap- reciated it all the more. And even if David was ar from realizing the ideal of a theocratic king, he nevertheless continued to be the model which prophecy tried to attain, viz. a king who was per- sonally and most intimately connected with Jeh, and who, as the servant of Jeh, was to realize en- tirely in his own person the mission of the people to become the servants of Jeh, and was thus to furnish the guaranty for the harmony between Israel and their God, and bring rich and unalloyed blessings upon the land. (3) Religious ideals of the Psalms since David.— In this way the covenant-relation became a personal one through “the anointed one of Jeh.”’ In general, religion in Israel became more personal in character in the days of the earlier kings. Before this time the collective relation to God prevailed. Only as a member of the tribe or of the nation was the indi- vidnal connected with Jeb, which fact does not exclude the idea that this God, for the very reason that He rules according to ethical principles, also regards the individual and grants him His special protection and requites to him good or evil accord- ing to his deeds. The Heb hymns or “psalms,” which David originated, give evidence of a more intimate association of the individual with his God. The very oldest of these psalms, a number of which point to David as their author, are not liturgical congre- gational hymns, but were originally individual prayer- songs, which emanated from percna experiences, but were, in later times, employed for congregational use. The prejudice, that only in later times such expressions of personal piety could be expected, is refuted by anal- ogous cases among other nations, esp. by the much more ancient penitential and petitionary prayers of the Babylonians, in which, as a rule, the wants of the indi- vidual and not those of the nation constitute the con- tents. These Bab penitential prayers show that among this people, too, the feeling of guilt as the cause of mis- fortune was very, vivid, and that they regarded repent- ance and confession as necessary in order to secure the forgiveness of the gods. However, the more exalted character of the Israelitish conception of God appears jn a most pronounced way in this comparison, since the Babylonian feels his way in an uncertain manner in order to discover what god or goddess he may have offended, and not rarely tries to draw out the sympathy of the one divinity over against the wrath of another. But much more can, this difference be scen in this, that the heathen singer is concerned only to get rid of the evil or the misfortune that oppresses him. The com- munion with his god whose favor he seeks to regain is in itself of no value for him. In David's case the matter is altogether different, as he knows that he is bound to Jeh by a covenant of love (Ps 18 2), and_ his heart delights in this communion, more than it does in all earthly possessions (Ps 4 8); and this is even more so in the case of the author of Ps 73 25-26. Such words would, for good reasons, be unthinkable in the case of a Bab psalmist. In the times of those earliest kings of Isracl, which, externally, constituted the most flourishing period in their history, unless tradition is entirely at fault, the spiritual world of thought also was enriched by the Wisdom literature of the Proverbs, the earliest examples of which date back to Solomon. (4) Wisdom literature since Solomon.—This hokhmah, or Wisdom literature, is marked hy the peculiarity that it ignores the special providential guidance of Israel and their extraordinary relation to their God, and confines itself more to the general revelation of God in Nature and in the history of mankind, but in doing this regards the fear of God as the beginning of wisdom, and at all times has the practical purpose of exhorting to a moral and God-pleasing life, 'The idea that this cosmopolitan tendency is to he attributed to Gr influences, and accord- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, Rel. of ingly betrays a later period as the time of Its origin, is to he rejected, as far as Prov and Job are concerned. The many passages in Prov that speak of conduct over against the king show a preéxilic origin. The universalistic character of this literature must he ex- plained on other grounds, It resulted from this, that this roverh-wisdom is not the sole, exclusive property of srael and was not first cultivated among them, but was derived from abroad. The Edomites were esp. con- spicuous in this respect, as the Book of Job shows, in which the Israelitish author introduces as speakers masters of this art from this tribe and others adjoining it. We can also compare the superscriptions in Prov 30 1; 31 1, in which rouns ot proverbs from Arabian principalities are introduced. Accordingly, this wisdom was regarded as a common possession of Israel and of their neighbors. This is probably the reason why the authors of this class of literature refrain from natlonal reference and reminiscences. That the liberal-minded Solomon was the one to introduce this proverb-wisdom, or at any rate cultivated it with special favor, is in itself probable, and is confirmed hy the fact that the Queen of Sheba (South Arabia) came to Jerus in order to listen to his wisdom. But this also presupposes that in her country a similar class of wisdom was culti- vated. This was also the case in Egypt in very early antiquity, and in Egyp literature we have collections of proverhs that remind us of the proverbs of Solomon (ct Transactions of the Third International Congress of the History of Religions, Oxford, 1908, I, 284 ff; see Wispom). (5) The sanctuary on Mt. Zion. —The kingdom of David and of Solomon not only externally marks the highest development of the history of Israel, but intellectually, too, prepared the soil out of which henceforth the religious life of the nation drew its sustenance. It was esp. under David a significant matter, that at this time the higher spiritual powers were in harmony with the political. This found its expression in the Divine election of David and his seed, which was confirmed by prophetical testament (2 8 7). Hand in hand with this went the selec- tion of Mt. Zion as the dwelling-place of Jeh. David, from the beginning, was desirous of establish- ing here the theocratical center of the people, as he had shown by transferring the Ark of the Covenant to Jerns. In the same way Solomon, by the erec- tion of the Temple, sought to strengthen and suit- ably equip this central seat. As a matter of course, the sacred shrines throughout the land did not thereby at once lose their significance. But the erection of the sanctuary in Jerus was not at all intended +o establish a ‘royal chapel’’ for the king, as Wellhausen has termed this structure, but it claimed the inheritance of the tabernacle in Shiloh, and the prophets sanctioned this claim. (6) Religion in the Kingdom of Ephraim.—The division of the kingdom after the death of Solomon which, as it was, had not been too large, proved politically disastrous. It also entailed a retro- gression in religious matters. The centralizing tendencies of the preceding reigns were thwarted. Jeroboam erected other sacred shrines; esp. did he make Bethel a “king’s sanctuary” (Am 7 13). At the same time he encouraged religious syncretism. It is true that the gold-covered images of heifers (by the prophets, in derision, called ‘‘calves’’) were intended only to represent the Covenant-God Jeh. However, this representation in the form of images, an idea which the king no doubt had brought back with him from his sojourn in Egypt, was a conces- sion to the corrupt religious instincts in the nation, and gave to the Ephraimitic worship an inferior character in comparison with the service in the Temple in Jerus,where no images were to be found. But in other respects, too, the arbitrary conduct of the king in the arrangement of the cultus proved to be a potent factor in the Northern Kingdom from the beginning. The opposition of independent prophets was suppressed with all power. Never- theless, the prophetic agitation continued to be a potent spiritual factor, which the kings themselves could not afford to ignore. This proved to be the case particularly when the Israel, Rel. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1538 dynasty of Omri, who established a new capital city, Samaria, openly favored the introduction of Phoen idolatry. Ahab’s wife, Jezebel, even suc- ceeded in having a magnificent temple erected in the new capital to her native Baal, and in crushing the opposition of the prophets who were faithful to Jeh. It now became a question of life and death, so far as the religion of Jeh was concerned. The struggle involved not only certain old heathen cus- toms in the religion of the masses, dating back to the occupation of Canaan, but it was the case of an invasion of a foreign and heathen god, with a clearly defined purpose. His voluptuous worship was not at all in harmony with the serious character of the Mosaic religion, and it seriously menaced, in a people naturally inclined to sensuality, the rule of the siringent and holy God of Mt. Sinai. The tricky and energetic queen was already certain that she had attained her purpose, when an opponent arose in the person of Elijah, who put all her efforts to naught. (7) Elijah and Elisha.—In his struggle with the priests of Baal, who deported themselves after the manner of modern dervishes, we notice particularly the exalted and dignified conception of God inl kK 18. When in this chapter Jeh and Baal are con- trasted, the idea of Elijah is by no means that these gods have in their own territory the same rights as Jeh in Canaan and Israel. Elijah mocks this Baal because he is no God at all (18 21), and the whole worship of the priests convinces him that they are not serving a real and true God, but only the prod- uct of their imagination (18 27). This is mono- theism, and certainly not of a kind that has only recently been acquired and been first set up by Eli- jah, but one that came down from the days of Moses. Elijah proves himself to be a witness and an advocate of the God of Sinai, who has been betrayed in a treacherous manner. The fact that he inflicts a dire and fateful punishment on the idol- atrous priests of Baal is also in perfect agreement with the old, stringent, Mosaic, legal code. Only such severity could atone for the fearful crime against the God of the country and of the covenant, and could save the people from apostasy. How- ever, the theophany at Mt. Sinai (1 K 19 11 ff) shows clearly that not His external and fearful power, but His calm and deep character was felt by Elijah to be the distinguishing mark of his God. His successor, Elisha, after the storm had cleared the religious atmosphere in the country, in the per- formance of his prophetic duties was able again to show forth more emphatically the fatherly care and the helpful, healing love of his God. In general, the political retrogression of the nation and the opposition of those in power, which the prophets and the faithful worshippers of Jeh in later times were compelled to experience often enough, served greatly to intensify and to spiritnalize their religion. The unfortunate situation of the present, and the weaknesses and failures in the actual state of the theocracy, directed their eyes to the future. The people began to study the wonderful ways of God in dealing with His people, and they began to look to the end of these dealings. A proof of this is found in the comprehensive accounts contained in the old history of the covenant-people as recorded in the Pentateuchal documents E and J, which were composed during this period. Whether these ex- tend beyond and later than the period of Joshua or not, can remain an open question. In any case, there existed written accounts also concerning the times of the Judges, and concerning the history of Samuel, David and Solomon, which in part were written down soon after the events they record, and which, because of their phenomenal impartiality, point to an exceptionally high prophetic watchtower from which the ways of God with His people were ob- served. (1) The writing prophets —The spiritual develop- ment of the deeper Israelitish religion was the business of the prophets. At the 4, Develop- latest, from the 8th cent. BC, and ment of probably from the middle of the 9th, Israel’s we have in written form their utter- Religion ances and discourses. Larger collec- from the _ tions of such prophecies were certainly 8th Cent. left by Amos and Hosea, These BC to the prophets stood entirely on_the basis Exile of the revelations which by Moses had been made the foundation of Israel’s religion. But in contrast to the superficial and mistaken idea of the covenant of Jeh entertained by their contemporaries, these prophets make clear the true intentions of this covenant, and at the same time, through their new inspiration, advance the religious knowledge of the people. (2) Their opposition to the cultus——This appears particularly in their rejection of the external and unspiritual cultus of their age. Over against the false worship of God, which thinks to satisfy God by the offering of sacrifices, they proclaim the true worship, which consists above all things in the ful- filment of the duties of the law and of love toward their fellow-men. They denounce as a violation of the covenant not only idolatry, the worship of strange gods, and the heathen symbols and customs which, in the course of time, had crept into the serv- ice of Jeh, but they declare also that the religion which is based solely on the offering of sacrifices is worthless, since God, who is in no way dependent on any services rendered by men, does not care for such sacrifices, but is concerned about this, that His commands be observed, and that these consist above all things in righteousness, upright- ness in the dealings of man with man, and in mercy on the poor, the weak, the defenceless, who cannot secure justice for themselves. (Cf, e.g. 1S 15 22; Hos 6 6; Isa 1 11 ff; Jer 7 21 ff, and other passages equally pointed. See on this subject, J. Robertson, Early Religion, etc, 440 ff.) Such a transfer of the center of religion from the cultus to practical ethical life has no analogy whatever in other Sem and ancient religions. Yet it is not something absolutely new, but is a principle that has developed out of the foundation laid by Moses, while it is in most pronounced contrast to the com- mon religious sentiments of mankind. The pro- phetic utterances that condemn the unthinking and the unconsecrated cultus must not be misunder- stood, as though Isaiah, Jeremiah and others had been modern spiritualists, who rejected all external forms of worship. In this case they wonld have ceased to be members of their own people and children of their own times. What they absolutely reject is only the false trust put in an opus operatum, i.e. a mechanical performance of religious rites, which had been substituted for the real and _ heartfelt exercise of religion. Then, too, we are not justified in drawing from passages such as Jer 7 22 the conclusion that at this time there did not yet exist in written form a Mosaic sacrificial code. Such a code is found even in the Book of the Covenant, recognized by critics as an older Pent document (Ex 20-23, 34), and the fact that the Sabbath commandment is found in the Decalogue does not prevent Isaiah from writing what he has penned in 113.14. That at this period, already, there were extant many written ordinances is demanded by Hos 8 12, and the connection shows that cultus- ordinances are meant. We must accordingly take the prophet’s method of expression into considera- tion, which delights in absolute contrasts in cases where we would speak relatively. But this is not 1539 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, Rel. of intended to weaken the boldness of the prophetic thoughts, which purpose to express sharp opposi- tion to the religious ideas current at that time. (8) Their preaching of the judgment.—The con- ception of God and Divine things on the part of the popes was the logical development of the reve- ations in the days of Moses, and after that time, concerning the nature and the activity of God. The God of the prophets is entirely a personal and living God, i.e. He enters into the life of man. His holiness is exaltation above Nature and the most pronounced antagonism to all things unclean, to sin. Sin is severely dealt with by God, esp., as has already been mentioned, the sin of showing no love and no mercy to one’s neighbor. Because they are saturated with this conviction of the absolute holiness of God, the preéxilic prophets proclaim to their people more than anything else the judg- ment which shall bring with it the dissolution of both kingdoms and the destruction of Samaria and of Jerus, together with its temple. First, its de- struction is proclaimed to the Northern Kingdom; later on to the Southern. In doing this, these in- spired men testify that Jeh is not inseparably bound to His people. Rather He Himself calls the de- stroyer to come, since all the nations of the world are at His command. (4) Their Messianic promises—~However, the prophets never conclude purely negatively, but they always see on the horizon some rays of hope, which promise to a “remuant’’ of the people better times. A ‘day of Jeh” is coming, when He will make His final settlement with the nations, after they have carried out His judgment on His people. Then, after the destruction of the gentile world, He will establish His rule over the world. This fundamental thought, which appears again and again with constantly increasing clearness, often takes the form that a future king out of the house of David, in whom the idea of the “anointed of Jeh”’ has been perfectly realized, will first establish in Judahb-Israel a pure rule of God, and then also gain the supremacy of the world. Some critics have claimed that all of these Messianic and eschatological predictions date from the post- exilic period. In recent years a reaction against this view has set in, based on the belief that in Egypt and Babylonia also similar expectations are found at an early period. These promises, when they are more clearly examined, are found to beso intimately connected with the other prophecies of Isaiah, Hosea, and others, that to separate them would be an act of violence. In their most mag- nificent character, these pictures of the future are found in Isa, while in Jer their realization and spiritualization have progressed farther. (5) Reformations—While the prophets are char- acterized by higher religious ideas and ideals, the religion of the masses was still strongly honey- combed with cruder and even heathen elemenis. Yet there were not totally wanting among the common people those who listened to these pro- phetic teachers. And esp. in Judaea there were times when, favored by pious kings, this stricter and purer party obtained the upper hand. This was particularly the case under the kings Jehosha- phat, Hezekiah, and Josiah. During the reigns of these kings the cultus was reformed. Hezekiah ‘and Josiah attacked particularly the local sanc- tuaries and their heathen worship (called baméth), and concentrated the sacrificial cultus in Jerus. In doing this they were guided by the faithful priests and prophets and by the ancient Mosaic directions. Josiah, who, more thoroughly thau others, fought against the disintegration of the Jeh-cultus, found his best help in the newly discovered Book of the Law (Dt). That the sacrifices should be made at one place had been, as we saw, an old Mosaic arrangement. However, Moses had foreseen that local altars would be erected at places where special revelations had been received from Jeh (Ex 20 24-25). In this way the numerous altars at Bethel, on Carmel, and elsewhere could claim a certain justi- fication, only they were not entitled to the same rank as the central sanctuary, where the Ark of the Covenant stood and where the sons of Aaron performed their priestly functions. Dt demands more stringently that all real sacrificial acts shall be transferred to this central point. This rule Josiah carried out strictly. The suppression of the current sacrifices on high places by the fall of the Northern Kingdom aided in effecting the collapse of such shrines, while the sanctuary in Jerus, because it was delivered from the attack of the Assyrians, won a still greater recognition. (6) Destruction of Jerusalem.—However, imme- diately after the death of Josiah, the apostasy from Jeh again setin. The people thought that they had been deserted by Him, and they now more than before sought refuge in an appeal to a mixture of gods derived from Babylonia, Egypt, Persia and elsewhere. Ezk 8 and 9 describe this syncretism which made itself felt even in the temple-house in Jerus. The people were incapable of being made better and were ripe for destruction. The temple, too, which it was thought by many could not be taken, was doomed to be destroyed from its very foundations. (1) Spiritual purification through the Exile— A mighty change in the religion of Israel was occa- sioned by the deportation of the 5. The wealthier and better educated Jews Babylonian to Babylon and their sojourn there for Exile a period of about 50 years, and by the still longer stay of a large portion of the exiles in this country. The nation was thus cut off from the roots of the native heathendom in Pal and also from the external organization of the theocracy. This brought about a purification and a spiritualization, which proved to be a great bene- fit for later times, when the political manifestation of their religious life had ceased, and the personal element came more into the foreground. Jeremiah and Ezekiel emphasize, each in his own way, the value of this religion for the individual. _A spiritual communion came into being during the Exile, which found its bond of union in the word of Jeh, and which insisted on serving God without a temple and external sacrificial cultus (which, however, was still found among the exiles in Egypt). Separated from their homes, they collected all the more dili- gently the sacred memories and traditions, to which Ezekiel’s plans for the temple belong. Their sacred literature, the Téraéh or Law, the prophetical books, the historical writings, the Pss, and other literature were collected, and in this way preparations were made for the following period. (2) Relations to the gentile world—The most earnest classes of Jews, at least, absolutely declined to have anything to do with the Bab religion and worship. They saw here the worship of images in its most repulsive and sensual form, and they also learned its absolute impotency when the haughty Chaldaean empire was overthrown. Deutero- Isaiah (Isa 40-66) shows that the Israelites now become more conscious than ever of the great value of their own religion with its Creator of heaven and earth over against this variegated Pantheon of changeable gods in forms of wood and metal images. From this time on, the glory of the Creator of the universe and His revelation in the works of Nature were lauded and magnified with a new zeal and more emphatically than ever before. This same prophet, however, proclaims also the new fact of the Israel, Rel. of Issachar THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1540 mission-call of Israel among the nations of the world. This people, he declares, is to become the instru- ment of Jeh to make the Gentiles His spiritual subjects. But as this people in its present condi- tion is little fit for this great service, he sees with his prophetic eye a perfect “Servant of Jeh,”’ who carries out this mission, a personal, visible ‘‘Servant of Jeh,”’ who establishes the rule of God upon earth, by becoming, in the first place, for Israel a second Moses and Joshua, but who then, too, wins over the heathen nations by this message. He accordingly takes the place of the prophesied future Son of David. However, He is not a personal ruler, but carries out His work through mere spiritual power and in low- liness and weakness. Indeed, His suffering and death become the atonement to wipe out the guilt of His people (Isa 53). We can see in this further development of the deepening and spiritualization of the eschatological hopes how strongly the un- accustomed misfortunes and surroundings of the exiles had influenced them. Notwithstanding all their antagonism to the aberrations of the heathen world, the Israelites yet learned that among the Gentiles there was also some receptivity for the higher truths. The worshippers of Jeh felt them- selves more akin to the Persians than to the Baby- lonians, as the former served without images a god which was conceived as one and as an exalted divine being. Thoughts taken from Parsiism are also found in the later literature of Israel, although it is not the case that the idea of Satan was first taken from this source. The doctrine of the resur- rection of the dead for the judgment also can be gained from OT premises. However, the religion of the Babylonians was not without influence on that of the Jews. It is indeed out of the question that it was only during the Exile that the Jews took over the accounts of the Creation and the Deluge and others similar to the Bab, as these are found in Gen 1-11. But the development of the angelology shows the evidences of later Bab and Pers influences. And esp. does demonology play a more important role in post-exilic times than ever before, particularly about the beginnings of the Christian era. Magic art, too, entered largely into the faith of later Judaism, and it can be shown that both of these came from Bab sources. (1) Life under the law.—The people which returned from the Exile was a purified congregation of Jeh, willing to serve Him. They 6. The aimed to reéstablish the theocracy. Post-exilic This latter had not, indeed, because Religion of the loss of the political independence of the people, the same importance as formerly, but the religious cultus and the religious life of the people were all the more stringently ob- served. The post-exilic period is characterized by religious legalism. The people were exceedingly zealous in observing the old ordinances, and tried to find righteousness in the correctness with which the Mosaic law was observed, as this was now de- manded by the teachers of this law. The prophet of the Exile, Ezekiel, had taken the lead in this par- ticular, and had laid great emphasis on the formal ordinances, although in connection with this he also insisted upon real moral earnestness. But it was an easy matter that in the course of time an external work-righteousness and petrifaction of true religion should arise. Yet the later prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, even if they do ascribe a greater importance to external matters than the preéxilic prophets did, show that they are the spiritual heirs of these earlier seers. They teach a healthy ethical and sanctifying type of practical religion and continue to proclaim the hopes for an expansion and spiritualization of the King- dom of God. The leaders of these times, Zerub- babel, Ezra, Nehemiah, show a pronouncedly an- tagonistic attitude toward the neighboring nations and also toward those inhabitants of the country who did not live under the law. However, their intolerance, esp. toward the Samaritans, can be readily understood from the principle of the self- preservation of the people of Jeh. The law came to be the subject of the most care- ful study, and the teachers of the law collected, even to the minutest details, the oral traditions with reference to its meaning and to the proper observ- ance of the different demands, so that already before the time of Christ they were in possession of an ex- tensive tradition, which was afterward put down in written form in the Mish. The writing of history was also carefully cultivated. The Books of Ch show from what viewpoint they described the past; the temple and the cultus were the center of interest. In the same way the psalm-poetry, esp. the temple- song, flourished again. These later hymns are pretty and regular, but no longer show the bold spirit of the older pss. In many cases, older songs are made use of in these later hymns in a new way. Of the proverb-literature of the later post-exilic times, the Wisd of Jesus Sirach, or Ecclus, is an instructive example. Notwithstanding its great similarity to the old Prov, the prevailing and lead- ing points of view have become different in char- acter. The conception of Wisd has assumed a specifically Jewish and theocratic character. (2) Hellenism—But the Jewish exclusiveness found a dangerous opponent, esp. from the days of Alexander the Great, in the new Hellenism. Hel- lenistic language, culture, customs and world- ideas overwhelmed Pal also. While the Pious (hdsidhim) all the more anxiously fortified them- selves behind their ordinances, the worldly-minded gave themselves up fully to the influence that came from without. In the first half of the 2d cent. BC there arose, aS a consequence, a bloody struggle against the inroads of this heathendom, when Antiochus Epiphanes undertook to suppress the religion of the Jews, and when the Asmoneans began their holy war against him. (3) Pharisees and Sadducees—But within the people of Israel itself there were found two parties, one strict and the other lax in the observance of the law. The leaders of the former were the highly popular Pharisees, who, according to their name, were the “Separatists,”’ separated from the common and lawless masses. They tried to surpass each other in their zeal for the traditional ordinances and pious observances. However, among them it was also possible to find real piety, although in the NT records, where they are described as taking a hostile attitude toward the higher and the highest form of Divine revelation, they appear at their worst. Their rivals, the Sadducees, were less fanatical in their observance of the demands of the law and more willing to compromise with the spirit of the times. To this party belonged many of the more prominent priests. But this party evinced less real religious life than did the Pharisees. (4) Essenes.—Then, too, in the time of Jesus, there were not lacking indications of the influence of foreign religions, as is apparent in the case of the Essenes. This party advocated dualistic ideas, as these are later found among the Mandaeans. (5) Positive connections between Judaism and Hellenism.—In_Alexandria a friendly exchange of ideas between Hellenism and Judaism was brought about. Here the OT was tr‘ into the Gr. This tr, known as the Septuagint (LXX), shows as yet but few signs of the Gr spirit; rather, a pronounced influence of legal and ritualistic Judaism. On the other hand, apologetical opposition to Hellenism appears to a more marked degree, among others, 1541 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Israel, Rel. of Issachar in the apocryphal work known as ‘‘Wisd of Solo- mon,” in which we find a positive defence of wisdom as the principle of revelation over against the Epi- curean world-wisdom of Hellenism. In doing this, the book leans on Platonism and Stoicism. The hokhmah, or wisdom of the old Jewish lit., has been Hellenized. Philo goes still farther in adapting Judaism to Gr taste and to humanism. A more liberal conception of inspiration also appears in the reception of contemporaneous literary products into the OT Canon, even of some books which had originally been written in the Gr language. The means observed in adapting national Hebraism to Hellenistic universalism was the allegorical method of interpretation, which Philo practised exten- sively and which then passed over to the Christian chureh Fathers of the Alexandrian school. This school constitutes the opposite extreme to the rab- binical, which clung most tenaciously to the letter of the sacred texts. (6) Apocalyptic literature —A unique phenomenon at the close of the Bib. and in the earliest post-Bib. period is, finally, the Apocatypric LiTERATURE (q.v.). Since the days of the Maccabees we find the custom in certain Jewish circles, by using the old prophecies and adapting them to the events of the times, of drawing up a systematic picture of the future. Theauthorship of these writings was usually ascribed to one of the ancient saints, e.g. to Enoch, or Abraham, or Moses, or Elijah, or Solomon, or Baruch, or Ezra, or others. The model of these Apocalypses is the Book of Dal, which, on the basis of older visions, in the times of the oppression by Antiochus Epiphanes, pictures, in grand simplicity, the development of the history of the world down to the final triumph of the Kingdom of God over the kingdoms of the world. HI. Conclusion.—When we consider this whole development, it cannot be denied that the religion of Israel passed through many changes. It grew and purified and spiritualized itself out of its own inherent strength; but it also suffered many re- lapses, when hindering and corrupting influence gained the upper hand. But it received from with- out not only degenerating influences, but_also much thatinspired and developed its growth. Its original and native strength also shows itself in this, that without losing its real character it was able to ap- propriate to itself elements of truth from without ae assimilate these. If we ask what the specific and unique character of this religion was, by which it was distinguished from all other religions of antiquity, 1. The and by reason of which it alone was Living and capable of producing from itself the Holy God highest revelation in Christ, it must be answered that its uniqueness lies, most of all, in its conception of God and of Divine things, and of God’s relation to the world. The term “monotheism” but inadequately expresses this peculiarity; for monotheistic tendencies are found also in other nations, and in Israel monotheism often shows itself in a strongly corrupted form. The advantage of Israel lies in its close contact. with the living God. From the beginning of Israel’s history a strictly personal God gave testimony of Himself to different personalities with a decision which demanded absolute submission; and, in addition, this was a holy God, who elevated mankind above Nature and above themselves, a God who stood in the most absolute contrast to all that was impure or sinful, but at the same time was wonderful in His grace and His mercy to the sinner. This direct revelation of God to specially chosen bearers of the Divine truth goes through the entire history of Israel. Through this factor this religion was being constantly purified and unfolded further. The Israelites learned to conceive God in a more spirit- ual, correct, and universal manner, the more they advanced in experience and culture. But this God did not thereby become a mere abstract being, separated from mankind, as was the case with sa many nations. He always continued to be a living God who takes an active partin the livesofmen. We need notice only those prophets who describe the greatness of God in the grandest way, such as Hosea, Isaiah, Deutero-Isaiah, who depict also the personal life of God in the boldest way through anthropomorphisms. c In agreement with this, too, we find that this religion demands the personal subjection of men to God, As was the case with all the 2. Relation religions of antiquity, that of the OT, of Man to too, was originally rather a tribal and This God a national religion than one of the indi- vidual. This brought with it the demand for the external observance of the tribal customs in the name of religion. However, the traditional customs and legal ordinances had already been sifted and purified by Moses. And, as a matter of necessity, in a religion of such a pronounced personal nature, the personal relation of the indi- vidual to God must become more anc more a matter of importance. This idea became deeper and more spiritual in the course of time and developed into a pure love for God. It did not prevent this reli- gion from becoming petrified, even during the Exile, when the doctrines and the cultus were most cor- rectly observed. But the vital kernels found em- bedded in the revelation of God constantly proved their power of rejuvenation. And at that very time when the petrified legalism of Pharisaism attained its most pronounced development, the most perfect fruit of this religion came forth from the old stem of the history of Israel, namely Christ, who unfolded Judaism and converted it into the religion of salvation for the entire world. Lirserature.—Of the lit. on the religion of Israel we may yet make per cala mention of the following: The textbooks on OT Theology by Oehler, 1891 (also ET), of Dillmann, 1895. The Kuenen-Wellhausen school is Peleg re by Kuenen, De Godsdienst van Israel, 1869 {also ET); Stade, Biblische Theologie des AT, 1905; Marti, Theologie des AT, 1903; Smend, Lehrbuch der AT Religionsgeschichte, 1899; cf also the works of Robertson Smith, esp. his lectures on The Religion of the Semites. Against this radical school, see, in addition to the work of Dillmann, James Robertson, Early Religion _of Israel, 1893. On thesubject of Semitism in general, S. I. Curtiss, Ursemitische Religion im Volksleben des heutigen Orients, 1903 (also ET); Baethgen, Beitrdge zur, semitischen Reli- gionsgeschichte, 1880; M. J. Lagrange, Etudes sur les reli- gions sémitiques, 1905. The relation of Israel to the Assyr and Bab religions is discussed by Hugo Winckler in several works; cf also Fritz Hommel, Alttestamentliche Ueberlie- ferungen, 1897 (also ET); Sayce, The Higher Criticism and the Verdict of the Monuments, 1895; Alfred Jeremias, Das AT im Lichte des alten Orients, 1906; a good brief summary is found in Sellin, Die AT Religion im Rahmen der andern Altorientalischen, 1908. Full details are givenin Kautzsch, “ Religion of Israel," in HDB, extra vol, 1904. For the last centuries before Christ see particularly, Schiirer, Geschichte des jiidischen Volkes_im Zeitalter Jesu Christi, 1907 (also ET). The modern Jewish standpoint is repre- sented by Montefiore, Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as Illustrated by the History of the Ancient Hebrews, 1892. é C. von ORELLI ISRAELITE, iz’ri-el-it, ISRAELITISH, iz'ra- el-it-ish: Belonging to the tribes of Isrart (q.v.). Occurs 4 t in the NT: of Nathanael (Jn 1 47); used by Paul (Rom 9 4; 11.1; 2 Cor 11 22). ISSACHAR, is’a-kér CUDWW, yissals*]khar; LXX, Swete ‘Iocaydp, Issachdr; Tisch., Isséchar, so also in the NT, Treg. and WH): (1) The 9th son of Jacob, the 5th borne to him by Leah (Gen 30 17f). His birth is in this passage connected with the strange story of Reuben and his mandrakes, and the name given him is ap- parently conceived as derived from ’tsh sakhar, “‘a Issachar Ittai THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1542 hired workman.’ There is a play upon the name in this sense in Gen 49 15, ‘He bowed his shoulder to bear, and became a servant under 1. The taskwork.” Wellhausen (Test der Bich. Name Sam., 95) thinks that the second ele- ment of the name may dencte a deity; and Sokar, an Egyp god, has been suggested. The name in that case would mean “worshipper of Sokar.”’ Practically nothing is preserved of the personal his- tory of this patriarch beyond his share in the common actions of the sons of Jacob. Four sons were born to him before Jacob’s family removed to Egypt (Gen 46 13). In that land he died and was buried. At Sinai the tribe numbered 54,000 men of war over 20 years of age (Nu 1 29). At the end of the wanderings the numbers had grown to 2. The 64,300 (Nu 26 25). In the days of Tribe David, the Chronicler puts the figures at 87,000 (1 Ch 7 5). See Num- BERS. The place of Issachar in the desert-march was with the standard of the tribe of Judah (along with Zebulun) on the E. side of the tabernacle (Nu 2 5), this group forming the van of the host (10 14f). The rabbis say that this standard was of 3 colors, sardine, topaz and carbuncle, on which were inscribed the names of the 3 tribes, bearing the figure of a lion’s whelp (Tg, pseudo. Jon. on Nu 2 3). The captain of the tribe was Nethanel ben- Zuar (Nu 1 8, etc). Later this place was held by Igal ben-Joseph, the tribal representative among the spies (Nu 13 7). The prince chosen from Issachar to assist in the division of the land was Paltiel ben-Azzan (34 26). The position of I. at the strange ceremony near Shechem was on Mt. Gerizim, “‘to bless the people’ (Dt 27 12). Sixteen cities of Issachar are mentioned in Josh 19 17 ff, but the only indications of boundaries are Tabor in the N. and Jordan in the E. 3. The We gather elsewhere that the territory Tribal of this tribe marched on the N. with Territory Zebulun and Naphtali (19 11.33); on the W. with Manassch and possibly Asher (17 10); and on the 8. with Manasseh (ver 11). It does not seem to have had any point of contact with the sea. The portion of Issachar, therefore, included the plain of Esdraelon, Tabor, the hill of Moreh, and the slopes E. to the Jordan. The fortresses along the 8. edge of the plain were held by Manasseh. Tola, a man of Issachar, held Shamir, a stronghold in Mt. Ephraim (Jgs 10 1). To Manasseh was given Beth-shean with her “towns” (Josh 17 11). No reliable line can be drawn for the S. border. The district thus indi- cated was small; but it embraced some of the most fruitful land in Pal. By the very riches of the soil Issachar was tempted. “He saw a resting-place that it was good, and the land that it was pleasant; and he bowed his shoulder to bear, and became a servant under taskwork” (Gen 49 15). ‘The mountain” in Dt 33 19 may possibly be Tabor, on which, most likely, there was an ancient sanc- tuary and place of pilgrimage. This would _cer- tainly be associated with a market, in which Issa- char and Zebulun, the adjoining tribes, would be able to enrich themselves by trade with the pil- grims from afar. Issachar took part in the battle with Sisera (Jgs 5 15). To Israel Issachar gave one judge, Tola (Jgs 10 1), and two kings, Baasha and his son (1 K 16 27, etc). Of the 200 “heads” of the men of Issachar who came to David at Hebron it is said that they were “men that had understanding of the 4. Men of times, to know what Israel ought to Issachar do” (1 Ch 12 32). According to the Tg, this meant that they knew how to ascertain the periods of the sun and moon, the intercalation of months, the dates of solemn feasts, and could interpret the signs of the times. A com- pany from Issachar came to the celebration of the Passover when it was restored by Hezekiah (2 Ch 30 18). Issachar has a portion assigned to him in Ezekiel’s ideal division of the land (48 25); and he appears also in the list in Rev (7 7). (2) A Korahite doorkeeper, the 7th son of Obed- edom (1 Ch 26 5). W. Ewine ISSHIAH, is-shi’a (W7W , yishshiyahd, “Jeh exists”; AV Ishiah): (1) Mentioned among David’s heroes, a great- grandson of Tola (1 Ch 7 3). (2) Mentioned among the men who came to David at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 6; AV “Jesiah’’). (3) A member of the priesthood of the house of Rehabiah (1 Ch 24 21; AV “Jesiah’’). (4) Another Levitical priest of the house of Uzziel (1 Ch 23 20; 24 25). ISSHIJAH, is-shi’ja (7"W", yishshiyah, “Jeh lends”; AV Ishijah): A man of the household of Harim, named among those who, at Ezra’s command, were induced to put away their “strange wives’’ (Ezr 10 31). Also called ‘“Aseas” (1 Esd 9 32). ISSUE, ish’t: (1) (M240, maledheth, O'NENT, ce’éea’zm; onéppo, spérma, ‘“‘seed’’): Offspring, descendants (Gen 48 6; Isa 22 24; Mt 22 25 AV). (2) (YBN, zirmah; RB, yaca’ [vb]; piers, rhisis): A gushing of fluid (semen, Ezk 23 20; water, 47 8; blood, Lk 8 48). See next article. ISSUE (OF BLOOD) (2°, zdbh, ANT, zubh; pots, rhisis, atudppoos, haimérrhoos): When used as a description of a bodily affection the word signifies: (1) A discharge, the consequence of un- cleanness and sin (Lev 15 2ff; Nu 5 2). As such it was one of the judgments which were to afflict the family of Joab (2 S 3 29); (2) a hemor- rhage, either natural (Lev 12 7, where the word used is makér, lit. a “fountain’’), or the consequence of disease (Mt 9 20; Mk 6 25; Lk 8 48). ISSUES, ish’iz (MINIM, taca’ath, lit. “out- goings’): (1) Ways of escape (Ps 68 20 AV); (2) free moral choices (Prov 4 23). ISTALCURUS, is-tal-ki’rus (Iotadkoipos, [s- talkotiros): 1 Esd 8 40, corresponding to Zabbud in Ezr 8 14. In Swete’s text the name is Istakal- kos. ISUAH, is’t-a. See Isuvau. ISUI, is’ti-i. ISVAH, is’va. See Isuv1, See Isuvan. ITALA, it’a-la, VERSION. See Latin VERSION, Tue OLD; VULGATE. ITALIAN, i-tal’yan, BAND. See Bano. ITALY, it’a-li (Iradta, Jialia): At first confined as a name to the extreme southern part of the Italian peninsula in the region now called Calabria, whence its application was gradually extended. In Gr usage of the 5th cent. BC, the name was applied to the coasts as far as Metapontum and Posidonia, being synonymous with Oenotria. The Oenotrians are represented as having assumed the name of Italians (Itali) from a legendary ruler Italus (Dionysius, 1.12.35; Vergil, Aen. 1.583). The extension of Rom authority seems to have given 1543 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Issachar Ittai this name an ever-widening application, since it was used to designate their allies generally. As early as the time of Polybius the name Italy was some- times employed as an appellation for all the country between the two seas (Tyrrhenian and Adriatic) and from the foot of the Alps to the Sicilian Straits (Polyb. 1.6; ii.14; 11.39.54), although Cisalpine Gaul was not placed on a footing of complete equality with the peninsula as regards administra- tion until shortly after the death of Julius Caesar. From the time of Augustus the term was used in pepateally its modern sense (Nissen, Italische andeskunde, I, 57-87). The name Italy occurs 3tin the NT: Acts 18 2, Aquila “lately come from Italy,’’ because of the expulsion of the Jews from Rome under Claudius; Acts 27 1, the decision that Paul be sent to Italy; He 13 24, salutation from those “of Italy.’ The adj. form is found in the appellation, ‘Italian band” (cohors Italica, Acts 10 1). The history of ancient Italy, in so far as it falls within the scope of the present work, is treated under Rome (q.v.). GrorcE H. ALLEN ITCH (O17 ,", hares; Yopa, psdra): Only in Dt 28 27, where it probably refers to the parasitic skin disease of that name which is very common in Pal. It is due to a small mite, Sarcoptes scabiei, which makes burrows in the skin and somctimes causes extensive crusts or scabs, attended with a severe itching. It is very easily communicated from per- son to person by contact, and can be cured only by destruction of the parasite. This disease disquali- fied its victims for the priesthood (Lev 21 20). ITHAT, ith’a-i. ITHAMAR, ith’a-mar (Wat, ‘tthamar, “land” or “island of palms’: Gesenius; or ‘father of Tamar,” "&, ’%, being perhaps for "28, abhi: Cook in EB—though both derivations are uncertain): The 4th son of Aaron (Ex 6 23; 28 1; 1 Ch 6 3), Eleazar being the 3d, Nadab and Abihu the 1st and 2d. While Nadab and Abihu were prematurely cut off for offering strange fire before the Lord (Lev 10 1.2; Nu 3 4; 26 61), and Eleazar was appointed chief of the tribe of Levi (Ex 6 23.25) and ultimately succeeded Aaron (Ex 28 1), Ithamar was made the treasurer of the offerings for the Tabernacle (Ex 38 21), and superintendent of the Gershonites and Merarites in the service of the Tabernacle (Nu 4 28.33). In the time of Eli the high-priesthood had come to be in his family, but how, and whether before Eli’s day or first in Eli’s person, is not told and need not be conjectured. W.R. Smith in ZB (art. “Eli’’), on the strength of 1S 2 27.28, holds that the priesthood was origi- nally in Eli’s line; but the words ‘the house of thy father’ do not necessarily mean only the house of Ithamar, but may, and most probably do, refer to Aaron and his descendants, of whom Ithamar was one. Nor does the cutting off of Eli’s family from the priesthood and the setting in their place of “a faithful priest,’’ who should do everything according to Jeh’s will and walk before Jeh’s anointed forever, find its complete fulfilment in the deposition of Abiathar or Ahimelech, his son, and the installation of Zadok in the time of Solomon (1 K 2 35; 1 Ch 29 22; see Zapox). A de- scendant of Ithamar, Daniel by name, is mentioned among the exiles who returned from Babylon (Ezr 8 2). T. WHITELAW ITHIEL, ith’i-el (OXMMN , Uhv él, “God is’’): (1) A son of Jeshaiah of the tribe of Benjamin, mentioned among the inhabitants of Jerus in Nehe- miah’s day (Neh 11 7). See Irrar. (2) The name is perhaps also found in the oracle of Agur (Prov 30 1). See IrHimn anp Ucat. ITHIEL AND UCAL (2x) SS°ON, ‘zthi’al w°ukhal): Names of the two men to whom Agur the son of Jakeh spoke his words (Prov 30 1). The purport of introducing these persons is strange and obscure; the margin proposes therefore, by the use of a different pointing, to read the verse, ‘“The man said, I have wearied myself, O God, I have wearied myself, O God, and am consumed,” thus doing away with the proper hames; a reading which corresponds not inaptly with the tone of the suc- ceeding verses. See Acur; Proverss, Book or, II, 6. Joun FraNKLIN GENUNG ITHLAH, ith’la (M2, yithlah; AV Jethlah): An unidentified town in the territory of Dan, named with Aijalon and Elon (Josh 19 42). ITHMAH, ith’ma (WAM, yithmah, “purity’’): A citizen of the country of the Moabites, David’s deadly enemies, yet mentioned as one of the king’s heroes (1 Ch 11 46). ITHNAN, ith’nan (]35", yithnan): A town in the S. of Judah mentioned along with Hazor and Ziph (Josh 15 23), apparently the ‘“Ethnan” of Je- rome (Onom 118 13). Not identified. _ ITHRA, ith’ra (SM, yithra’, “abundance”): The father of Amasa, commanding general in the rebel army of Absalom. It seems that his mother was Abigail, a sister or half-sister of King David (1 Ch 2 17). She is called the sister of Zeruiah, Joab’s mother (2 § 17 25). In this same passage Ithra is called an “Israelite,”’ but in 1 Ch 2 17; 1 K 2 5.32, we read: ‘Jether the Ishmaelite.” ITHRAN, ith’ran (}4N", yithran, “excellent’’): (1) A descendant of Seir the Horite, son of Di- shon (Gen 36 26; 1 Ch 1 41). (2) One of the sons of Zophah of the tribe of Asher (1 Ch 7 37). ITHREAM, ith’ré-am (D975, yithram, “resi- due of the people’): The 6th son born to David at Hebron. His mother’s name was Eglah (2 8 3 5; 1 Ch 3 3). ITHRITE, ith’rit (NM, yithri, “excellence,” ‘“‘preéminence’’): A family in Israel, whose home was Kiriath-jearim (1 Ch 2 53). Among the 37 heroes of David, two are mentioned who belonged to this family, Ira and Gareb (2 8 23 38; 1 Ch 11 40). ; ITTAH-KAZIN, it-a-ka’zin (PEP WAY, ‘wttah kagin): Josh 19 13 AV for Eth-kazin. Ittah is | correctly Eth with Hé locale, meaning “toward Eth.” ITTAI, it’4-1, it’] CRS, 'ittay, SN, ithay): (1) A Gittite or native of Gath, one of David’s chief captains and most faithful friends during the rebellion of Absalom (2 § 16 11-22; 18 2.4.12). The narrative reveals David’s chivalrous and un- selfish spirit in time of trouble, as well as the most self-sacrificing loyalty on the part of Ittai. He seems to have but recently left his native city and joined David’s army through personal attachment to the king. David rapidly promoted him. Hear- ing of Absalom’s rebellion and approach to Jerus, he flees with David. The latter remonstrates, urges him to go back and join Absalom, as he is a foreigner and in exile. His interests are in the Ituraea Jaare-oregim THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1544 capital and with the king; there is no reason why he should be a fugitive aud perhaps suffer the loss of everything; it would be better for him, with his band of men, to put himself and them at the service of Absalom, the new king. ‘Mercy and truth be with thee,” says David in his magnanimity. Ittai, with a double oath, absolutely refuses to go back, but will stand by David until the last. Remon- strance being useless, the monarch orders him across the river, doubtless glad that he had such a doughty warrior and faithful friend by his side. On mustering his hosts to meet Absalom, David makes Ittai a chief captain with the intrepid Joab and Abishai. He doubtless did his part in the battle, and as nothing more is said of him it is pos- sible that he fell in the fight. (2) A Benjamite, one of David’s 30 mighty men (2 8 23 29; 1 Ch il 31, “Ithai’’). J. J. ReEEvE ITURAEA, it-i-ré@’a (Irovpala, Iiouraia): The term occurs only once in Scripture, in the definition of Philip’s territory: tés Itouratas kai 1. The Trachonitidos chéras, which AV ren- Word an ders: “‘of Ituraea and of the region of Adjective Trachonitis,” and RV: ‘the region of Ituraea and Trachonitis” (Lk 3 1). Sir W. M. Ramsay has given reasons for the belief that this word was certainly never used as a noun by any writer before the time of Eusebius (Hzpos, 1894, IX, 51 ff, 143 ff, 288 ff). It must be taken as an adj. indicating the country occupied by the Ituraeans. The descent of the Ituraeans must probably be traced to Jetur, son of Ishmael (Gen 25 15), whose progeny were clearly numbered among 2. The the Arabian nomads. According to Ituraeans Eupolemus (c 150 BC), quoted by Eusebius (Praep. Evang. IX, 30), they were associated with the Nabataeans, Moabites and Ammonites against whom David warred on the E. of the Jordan. They are often mentioned by Lat writers; their skill in archery seems greatly to have impressed the Romans. They were skilful archers (Caesar, Bell. Afr. 20); a lawless (Strabo, xvi.2.10) and predatory people (Cicero, Philipp. ii.112). In the Lat inscriptions Ituracan soldiers have Syrian names (HJP, I, ii, 326). They would therefore be the most northerly of the confederates opposed to David (supra), and their country may naturally be sought in the neighbor- 3. Indica- hood of Mt. Hermon. There is tions of nothing to show when they moved Their from the desert, to this district. Aris- Territory tobulus made war against the Itu- raeans, compelled many of them to be circumcised, and added a great part of their terri- tory to Judaea, 140 BC (Ant, XII, xi, 3). Dio Cassius calls Lysanias “king of the IJturaeans’’ (xlix.32), and from him Zenodorus leased land which included Ulatha and Paneas, 25 BC. The capital of Lysanias was Chalcis, and he ruled over the land from Damascus to the sea. Jos speaks of Soemus as a tetrarch in Lebanon (Vita, 11); while Tacitus calls him governor of the Ituraeans (Ann. xii.23). The country of Zenodorus, lying between Tracho- nitis and Galilee, and including Paneas and Ulatha, | Augustus bestowed on Herod, 20 BC (Ant, XV, x, 3). In defining the tetrarchy of Philip, Jos names Batanea, Trachonitis and Auranitis, but says nothing of the Ituraeans (Ant, XVII, xi, 4; BJ, ll, vi, 3). Paneas and Ulatha were doubtless in. cluded, and this may have been Ituraean territory (LJP, I, ti, 333). It seems probable, therefore, that the Ituraeans dwelt mainly in the mountains, and in the broad valley of Coele-Syria; but they may also have oecupied the district to the 8.E. of Hermon, the modern Jédar. It is not possible to define more closely the Ituraean country; indeed it is not clear whether St. Luke intended to indicate two separate parts of the dominion of Philip, or used names which to some extent overlapped. It has been suggested that the name Jédiur may be derived from the Heb "07, y*tur, and so be equivalent to Ituraea. But the derivation is im- possible. W. Ewina IVAH, i’va. See Ivvag. IVORY, i'vé-ri ({1] JW, shen, “tooth” [tr4 “ivory,” 1 K 10 18; 22 39; 2 Ch 917; Ps 46 8; Cant 514; 7 4: Esk 276.15; Am3 15; 6 4]; [2] DATIW, shenhabbim; LXX d8évres. Aehdvrevor, odéntes elephdntinoi, “elephants’ teeth” [I K 10 22; 2 Ch 9 211; [8] éehdvrivos, elephdntinos, “of ivory” [Rev. 18 12]): Shén occurs often, meaning “tooth” of man or beast. In the passages cited it is tr? in EV “ivory” (cf ‘‘crag,” 15 14 4.5; “cliff,” Job 39 28 bis; ‘“flesh-hook of three teeth,’ IS 2 13). Shenhabbim is thought to be a con- tracted form of shen ha-ibbim, i.e. ha, the art., and 4bbim, pl. of ’ibbah or *ibba’; cf Egyp ab, ebu, ‘‘ele- phant,” and cf Lat ebur, “ivory’’ (see Liddell and Scott, s.v. @dgas). On the other hand, it may be a, question whether bim is not a sing. form connected with the Arab. fil, “elephant.” If the word for “elephant” is not contained in shenhabbim, it occurs nowhere in the Heb Bible. Ivory was probably ob- tained, as now, mainly from the African elephant. It was rare and expensive. It is mentioned in connec- tion with the magnificence of Solomon (1 K 10 18.22), being brought by the ships of Tarshish (2 Ch 9 17.21). An “ivory house” of Ahab is mentioned in 1 K 22 39. It is mentioned among the luxuries of Israel in the denunciations of Amos (3 15; 6 4). It occurs in the figurative language of Ps 45 8; Cant 5 14; 74. It is used for ornamentation of the ships of the Tyrians (Ezk 27 6), who obtain it with ebony through the men of Dedan (ver 15). It is among the merchandise of Babylon (Rev 18 12). We do not learn of the use of elephants in war until a few centuries before the Christian era. In I Macc 8 6, there is a reference to the defeat of Antiochus the Great, “having an hundred and twenty elephants,” by Scipio Africanus in 190 BC. 1 Mace 1 17 speaks of the invasion of Egypt by Antiochus Epiphanes with an army in which there were elephants. 1 Macc 6 28-47 has a detailed account of a battle between Antiochus Eupator and Judas Maccabaens at Bethsura (Beth-zur), There were 32 elephants. Upon the “beasts”? (@npla, théria) there were “‘strong towers of wood’’; “There were also upon every one two and thirty strong men, that fought upon them, beside the Indian that ruled him.” In Job 40 15, AVm has for “behemoth,’’ “the elephant, as some think.” ALFRED Ety Day IVORY, TOWER OF (jm 539%, mighdal ha- shén): In Cant 7 4 the neck of Shulammite is com- pared in whiteness and stateliness to a (or the) tower of ivory. The def. art. may suggest that the comparison is with some actual tower in or near Jerus; but more probably the language is simply a figure. IVVAH, iv’a (AY, ‘iwwah; ’AB&, Abd [= Add], Aud, Aud, 2 K 18 34, Oi800, Oudot, 2 K 19 13, Elephants’ Tusks Brought to Thothmes III. 1545 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Ituraea Jaare-oregim apparently due to a misreading): The name is wanting in the MT and LXX of Isa 36 19. Ivvah was a eity apparently conquered by the Assyrians, and is mentioned by them, in the vs quoted, with Hamath and Arpad, Sepharvaim and Hena. It has been assimilated with the Avva of 2 K 17 24 ag one of the places whence Sargon brought captives to Samaria, and identified with Hit on the Euphrates, between Anah and Rama- dieh, but this seems improbable, as is also the sug- gestion that it is Emma, the modern ‘Imm, between Antioeh and Aleppo. Hommel (Expos T, April, 1898, 330) upholds the view that Hena and Ivvah, or, as he prefers to read, Avvah, are not places at all, but the names of the two chief gods of Hamath, Arpad and Sepharvaim. This would be eonsistent with 2 K 18 34; but 19 13: ‘Where is the king .... of Sepharvaim, of Hena, and Ivvah?” and 17 31, where the gods of Sepharvaim are stated to be Adrammeleeh and Anammeleeh, raise serious difficulties. In all probability, the identification of Ivvah depends upon the eorreet loealization of the twofold Sepharvaim, of whieh Hena and Ivvah may have been the names. The identifieation of Sepharvaim with the Bab Sip(p)ar is now praeti- cally abandoned. See SEPHARVAIM. T. G. Pincurs IVY, i/vi (ktoeds, kissds): The only mention of the word in all the sacred writings is in 2 Mace 6 7 in connection with the oppression of the Jews by Antiochus Epiphanes: ‘On the day of the king’s birth every month they were brought by bitter constraint to eat of the saerifiees; and when the feast of Baechus (Dionysus) was kept, the Jews were compelled to go in procession to Dionysus, carrying ivy,” this plant (Hedera helix) being sacred to the Gr god of wine and of the eulture of the vine (ef Eur. Bacchae, passim). It was of ivy or of pine that the “corruptible crown” of the famous Isthmian games was made (1 Cor 9 25). : J. HurcHison TVAR, é-yir’. See Iyvar. IYE-ABARIM, i-yé-ab’a-rim (OMIZIT MY, ‘iyé hé-‘ibhartm, “the heaps of the Abarim’; AV Tje-abarim; in Nu 21 11 LXX reads B, Kadyhel, Chalglet): A place in the journeyings of Israel named after Oboth, said to be “in the wilderness which is before Moab, toward the sunrising’ (Nu 21 11), “in the border of Moab” (33 44). The indieations of position here given are not sufficient to guide to any identification, and, so far, nothing has been discovered in the distriet to help us. Called simply ‘Iyim” (AV “Tim”) in Nu 33 45. TYIM, i’yim (DY, ‘tytm, “‘heaps’’—the form of which, "9, ‘tyé, is the constr.): (1) A short form of the name Iye-abarim (Nu 33 45). JAAKAN, ja’a-kan. JAAKOBAH, ja-a-ko’ba, ja-ak’o-ba (MPI, ya‘dkobhah, for meaning ef Jacos, I, 1, 2): 1 Ch 4 36, a Simeonite prince. JAALA, ja’a-la, j3-a’la (Nd, ya‘dla’, meaning unknown, Neh 7 58) and JAALAH (71293, ya- ‘dlah, “mountain goat” [?], Ezr 2 56): The name of a family of returned exiles, “ehildren of Solomon’s servants” =“Jeeli”’ in 1 Esd 5 33. JAALAM, ja’a-lam: AV for Jauam (q.v.). See BEEROTH-BENE-JAAKAN. (2) A town in the territory of Judah (Josh 15 29; EV wrongly “Iim’’). It lay in the extreme ar ‘toward the border of Edom.” It is not iden- tified. : TYYAR, é-yir’ (WS, ’iydr; *Idp, Idr): The 2d month of the Jewish year, corresponding to May. It is not mentioned in the Bible. See CaLenpar. IZEHAR, iz’é-hiar, i’zé-har (Nu 3 19 AV). IzHaR. IZHAR, iz/har (WIE, yichar, “the shining one”): (1) The father of Korah (Nu 16 1), deseended from a Kohathite Levite of this name, whose de- scendants formed a family, in the tribe of Levi (Ex 6 18.21; Nu 3 19.27; 1 Ch 6 18.38). (2) A descendant of Judah, whose mother’s name was Helah. ARVm gives the name Zohar (1 Ch 4 7). IZHARITES, iz’har-its ("WX., yichdri): The deseendants of Izhar, son of Kohath, and grandson of Levi (Nu 3 19.27). In David's reign some of these were ‘‘over the treasures of the house of Jeh”’ (1 Ch 26 23), others “were for the outward busi- ness over Israel, for officers and judges’’ (ib, ver 29). IZLIAH, iz-li’a yen, yizlv’ah, “Jeh delivers’’; AV JEZLIAH): A son of Elpaal, of the tribe of Benjamin (1 Ch 8 18). IZRAHIAH, iz-ra-hi’a (TTI, yizrahyah, “Teh appears, or shines’’): (1) A descendant of Issachar, grandson of Tola, only son of Uzzi (1 Ch 7 3). (2) The leader of the singing at the purification of the people, on the oeeasion of Nehemiah’s refor- mation; here rendered ‘“‘Jezrahiah” (Neh 12 42). IZRAHITE, iz’ra-hit (TM, yierah, ‘ising, shining’): Shamhuth, the captain of the 5th monthly course (1 Ch 27 8), is called an ‘‘Tzra- hite.”’” The name may be derived from the town or family of Izrah, but more likely is a eorrup- tion ee the word ‘“Zerahite,’’ deseendant of Zerah of Judah. See IZRI, iz‘ri ("E", yicri, “creator,” ‘“former’’): A man of the “sons of Jeduthun,” leader of the fourth band of musicians, who served in the sane- tuary (1 Ch 26 11). Identical with Zeri (ver 3). IZZIAH, iz-i’a (M49, yizeiyah, “Jeh unites”; AV Jeziah): One of the faithful Jews who put away their foreign wives. He belonged to the family of Parosh (Ezr 10 25; 1 Esd 9 26, “Ted- dias’’). JAANAI, ja’a-ni: AV for Janat (q.v.). JAAR, jaar (122, ya‘ar, “forest’”’ or “wood”’): Is only once taken as a proper name (Ps 132 6 RVm), “We found it in the field of Jaar.”” It may be a shortened form of the name Kiriath-jearim, where the ark had rested 20 years. See Kirrats- JEARIM. JAARE-OREGIM, ja’a-ré-6r'Gjim, -ér’e-gim (DAN WIT), ya‘dré’Gr'ghim): In2 8 21 19, given as the name of a Bethlehemite, father of Elhanan, who is said to have slain Goliath the Gittite (cf Jaareshiah Jechin aad Boaz THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1546 1§ 17). The name is not' likely to be a man’s name; the second part means “weavers” and occurs also as the last word of the verse in the MT, so it is probably a scribal error here due to repetition. The first part is taken to be (1) an error for 97, ya‘ir (see JarR), which is to be read in the || section in 1 Ch 20 5; (2) in2 S 23 24 Elhanan is the son of Dodo, also a Bethlehemite, and Klostermann would read here Dodai as the name of Elhanan’s father. - Davin Francis RoBERTS JAARESHIAH, ja-ar-é-shi’a (WWII1, ya‘dresh- yah, meaning unknown): In 1 Ch 8 27, a Benja- mite, “son” of Jeroham. AV has “Jaresiah.”’ JAASAI, ja’a-si, JAASAU, ja’a-sé. See Jaasu. JAASIEL, ja-a’si-el Ox wy, ya‘dst’ al, “God makes” [?]): In 1 Ch 11 47, a Mezobaite, one of “the mighty men of the armies,” and probably= “Jaasiel” of 1 Ch 27 21, ‘the son of Abner,’ and a Benjamite tribal prince of David’s. AV ‘‘Jasiel.” JAASU, j4’a-stii (RV and Kethibh, Mwy, ya‘dst, meaning uncertain); JAASAI(RVm and Keré, WY, ya‘dsdy), and JAASAU (AV): In Ezr 10 37, one of those who had married foreign wives. LXX tr* the consonantal text as a vb., kat epoiésan, “and they did.’ 1 Esd 9 34 has ‘‘Eliasis.” JAAZANIAH, ja-az-a-ni’a (INTS7, ya’dzan- yaha, in 2 IX 26 23; Ezk 8 11; TQINT, ya’dzan- yah, in Jer 36 3; Ezk 11 1, “Jeh hears”): (1) In 2 K 26 23, “son of the Maacathite,”’ and one of the Judaean “captains of the forces’ who joined Gedaliah, the Bab governor appointed by Nebuchadrezzar over Judah, at Mizpah. He is the “Jezaniah” of Jer 40 8; 42 1. Though not men- tioned by name, he was presumably one of those captains who joined Johanan in his attack on Ish- mael after the latter had slain Gedaliah (Jer 41 11- 18). He is also the same as Azariah of Jer 43 2, a name read by LXX B in 42 1 also. Jer 43 5 relates how Johanan and his allies, Jaazaniah(= Azariah) among them, left Judah with the remnant, and took up their abode in Egypt. (2) In Jer 36 3, son of Jeremiah (not the prophet), and a chief of the Rechabite clansmen from whose “staunch adherence to the precepts of their ances- tor” Jeremiah ‘points a lesson for his own country- men’? (Driver, Jer, 215). (3) In Ezk 8 11, son of Shaphan, and one of the seventy men of the elders of Israel whom Ezekiel saw in a vision of Jerus offering incense to idols. (4) In Ezk 11 1, son of Azzur, and one of the 25 men whom Ezekiel saw in his vision of Jerus, at the E. door of the Lord’s house, and against whose iniquity he was commanded to prophesy (11 1-13). Davip Francis Rosperts JAAZER, ja’a-zér (“°TD2, ya‘dzér). See Jazun. JAAZIAH, ja-a-zi’a (UTS2, ya'dziyaha, “Jeh strengthens”): In 1 Ch 24 26.27, a Levite, “son” of Merari. But the MT is corrupt. LXX B reads Ofed (Ozeid), which some take to suggest Uzziah (cf 27 25); see Curtis, Crit. and Exeget, Comm. on the Books of Ch, 274-75; Kittel, ad loc. JAAZIEL, ja-a’zi-cl ONT, yade?ad, “God strengthens’): In 1 Ch 15 18, a Levite, one of the musicians appointed to play upon instruments at the bringing up of the ark by David. Kittel and Curtis, following LXX ’OfejA (Ozetél), read “Uz- ziel,”’ the name they adopt for Aziel in ver 20, and for Jeiel in 16 5. JABAL, ja’bal (227, yabhal, meaning uncertain): In Gen 4 20, a son of Lamech by Adah. He is called ‘the father of those who dwell in tents and [with] herds. 80 Gunkel, Gen’, 52, who says that the corresponding word in Arab. means “the herds- man who tends the camels.” Skinner, Gen, 120, says that both Jabal and Jubal suggest Sah, yobhal, which in Phoen and Heb “means primarily ‘ram,’ then ‘ram’s horn’ as a musical instrument, and finally “oyous music’ (in the designation of the year of Jubilee).”” See also Skinner, Gen, 103, on the sup- posed connection in meaning with Abel. Davin Francis Roserts JABBOK, jab’ok (p33, yabbok, “luxuriant river’): A stream in Hastern Pal first named in the history of Jacob, as crossed by the patriarch on his return from Paddan-aram, after leaving Mahanaim (Gen 32 22 ff). On the bank of this The Jabbok (Nahr ez-Zerka). river he had his strange conflict with an unknown antagonist. The Jabbok was the northern bound- ary of the territory of Sihon the Amorite (Nu 21 24). It is also named as the border of Ammon (Dt 3 16). It is now called Nahr ez-Zerkd, ‘‘river of blue,” referring to the clear blue color of its water. It rises near to ‘Ammdn—Rabhath Ammon—and makes a wide circuit, flowing first to the E., then to the N.W., until it is joined by the stream from Wady Jerash, at which point it turns westward, and flows, with many windings, to the Jordan, the confluence being just N. of ed-Damiyeh. It drains a wider area than any other stream E. of the Jordan, except the Yarmik. The bed of the river is in a deep gorge with steep, and in many places precipi- tous, banks. It is a great cleft, cutting the land of Gilead in two. It is lined along its course by a Inxuriant growth of oleander which, in season, lights up the valley with brilliant color. The length of the stream, taking no account of its innumerable windings, is about 60 miles. The mouth of the river has changed its position from time to time. In the lower reaches the vegetation is tropical. The river is fordable at many points, save when in full flood. The particular ford referred to in Gen 32 cannot now be identified. W. Ewine JABESH, ja’besh (2, yabhesh): A short form of JABESH-GILEAD: (q.v.). JABESH-GILEAD, ja’besh-gil’é-ad (I9>a wa), yabhésh gil‘ddh; or simply W721, yabhish, “dry”): A city E. of the Jordan, in the deliverance of which from Nahash the Ammonite Saul’s military prowess was first displayed (1 S 11 1ff). At an earlier time the inhabitants failed to share with their brethren in taking vengeance upon Benjamin. ‘This laxity was terribly punished, only 400 virgins being spared alive, who afterward became wives to the Benja- mites (Jgs 21). The gratitude of the inhabitants to Sanl was affectingly proved after the disaster to 1547 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jaareshiah Jachin and Boaz that monarch on Gilboa (1 S 31). David, hearing of their deed, sent an approving message, and sought to win their loyalty to himself (2 S 2 4 if). Robin- son (BR, II, 39) thought it might be represented by ed-Deir, about 6 miles from Pella. (Fa@hil), on the southern bank of Waédy Yabis. The distance from Pella agrees with the statement of Onom (s.v.). Others (Oliphant, Land of Gilead, 2771; Merrill, East of Jordan, 430, etc) would identify it with the ruins of Meriamin, about 3 miles 8.E. of Pella, on the N. of Wady Yabis. The site remains in doubt; but the ancient name still lingers in that of the valley, the stream from which enters the Jordan fully 9 miles 8.E. of Beisan. W. Ewina JABEZ, (var, (“height’’]): (1) Place: An unidentified town probably in the territory of Judah, occupied by scribes (1 Ch 2 55). For an ingenious reconstruction of the passage see EB, s.v. (2) Person: The head of a family of Judah, noted for his “honorahle”’ character, though “his mother bare him with sorrow’ (1 Ch 4 9.10), ya‘bé¢ being interpreted as if it stood for ya‘gébh, “he causes pain.” The same play upon words recurs in his prayer, ‘‘that it be not to my sorrow!” His request was granted, “and the sorrow implied by his omi- Hous coal was averted by prayer” (Dummelow, in loc.). JABIN, ja’bin (7937, yabhin, “one who is intelli- gent,” ‘‘discerning.” The word may have been a hereditary royal title among the northern Canaan- ites. Cf the familiar usage of par‘dh melekh mig- rayim): (1) “The king of Hazor,”’ the leading city in Northern Pal, who led an alliance against Joshua. He was defeated at the waters of Merom, his city was taken and he was slain (Josh 11 1-9). (2) “The king of Canaan, that reigned [or had reigned] in Hazor.” It is not clear whether he dwelt in Hazor or Harosheth, the home of Sisera, the captain of his host at the time of the story nar- rated in Jgs. He oppressed Israel in the days pre- ceding the victory of Deborah and Barak. To the Israelites he must have been but a shadowy figure as compared with his powerful captain, Sisera, for the song makes no mention of him and there is nothing to indicate that he even took part in the battle that freed Israel (Jgs 4 2.7.17.23.24 bis; Ps 83 9.10). Exta Davis Isaacs ja’ bez ya'bég, “sorrow” JABNEEL, jab’né-el, JABNEH, jab/ne ON?23, yabhn’ él, “God is builder’; LXX AcBva, Lebnd, Swete reads Lemnd, Apoc "lapvia, Jamnia, "Tapvela, lamneia): (1) A town on the northern border of the land assigned to Judah, near the western sea, mentioned in connection with Ekron (Josh 16 11). The place ig now represented by the modern village of Yebna which stands upon a hill a little to. the 8. of the Nahr Rubin, about 12 or 13 miles 8. of Jaffa, on the road from there to Askelon, and about 4 miles from the sea. It had a port, now called Mina Rubin, a short distance 8. of the mouth of the river, some remains of which still exist. Its harbor was superior to that of Jaffa (PEFS, 1875, 167-68). It does not occur in the Heb text of the OT except in the passage mentioned, but it appears under the form “Jabneh” (7937, yabhneh) in 2 Ch 26 6, as is evident from the mention of Gath and Ashdod in connection with it. LXX reads Teuvd (Gemnd, Jabneh) where the Heb reads MAT), wa-yammah, “even unto the sea,’”’ in Josh 15 46, where Ekron and Ashdod and other cities and villages are men- tioned as belonging to Judah’s inheritance. Jos (Ant, V, i, 22) assigns it to the tribe of Dan. We have no mention of its being captured by Joshua or occupied by Judah until the reign of Uzziah who captured it and demolished its wall, in connection with his war upon the Philis (2 Ch 26 6). The position of J. was strong and was the scene of many contests, both in the period of the monarchy and that of the Maccabees. It is mentioned frequently in the account of the wars of the latter with the Syrians. It was garrisoned by the Seleucid kings, and served as a base for raiding the territory of Judah. When Judas Maccabaeus defeated Gor- gias and the Syrians he pursued them to the plains of J., but did not take the fortress (1 Macc 4 15). Gorgias was there attacked by the Jewish generals Joseph and Azarias, contrary to Judas’ orders, who were repulsed with loss (6 56-60; Jos, Ant, XII, viii, 6). Apollonius occupied it for King Deme- trius (1 Mace 10 69); and Cendebeus for Antio- chus, and from there harassed the Jews (15 40). Judas burned the port and navy of J. (2 Mace 12 8-9). It was taken by Simon in 142 BC (Jos, Ant, XII, vi, 7; BJ, I, ii, 2), together with Gazara and Joppa, but was restored to its inhabitants by Pom- pey in 62 BC (Ant, XIV, iv, 4), and was rebuilt by Gabinius in 57 BC (BV, I, viii, 4). It was restored to the Jews by Augustus in 80 AD. Herod gave it to his sister Salome and she bequeathed it to Julia, the wife of Augustus (Ani, XVIII, ii, 2; BJ, II, ix, L). The town and region were pros- perous in Rom times, and when Jerus was besieged by Titus the Sanhedrin removed to J., and it after- ward became the seat of a great rabbinical school (Milman, Hist Jews, II, 411-12), but was sup- pressed in the persecution under Hadrian. An- tonius allowed it to be revived, but it was again suppressed because of hostile language on the part of the rabbis (ib, 451-52). The Crusaders built there the castle of Ibelin, supposing it to be the site of Gath. It was occupied by the Saracens, and various inscriptions in Arab. of the 13th and 14th cents. have been found there (SWP, II, 441-42). (2) A town of Naphtali mentioned in Josh 19 33, and supposed to be the site of the modern Yemma, S.W. of the sea of Galilee (SWP, I, 365). It is the Kefr Yama of the Talm. H. Porter JACAN, ja’kan (129772, ya‘kdn, meaning not known; AV Jachan): A chief of a family descended from Gad (1 Ch 6 13). JACHIN, jakin ([32, yakhin, “he will estab- lish’’): (1) The 4th son of Simeon (Gen 46 10; Ex 6 15; Nu 26 12). In 1 Ch 4 24 his name is given as “Jarib” (cf AVm, RVm). ‘“Jachinites,” the patronymic of the family, occurs in Nu 26 12. (2) Head of the 21st course of priests in the time of David (1 Ch 24 17). It is used as a family name in 1 Ch 9 10, and as such also in Neh 11 10, where some of the course are included in the list of those who, having returned from Babylon, will- ingly accepted the decision of the lot, and abandoned their rural retreats to hecome citizens and guardians of Jerus (vs 1 f). JAMES CRICHTON JACHIN, ja’kin, AND BOAZ (7°39, yakhin, “the shall establish’; T22, bd‘az, “in it is strength,” 1K 7 15-22; 2 K 26 16.17; 2 Ch 3 15-17; Jer 52 17): These were the names of the two bronze pillars that stood before the temple of Solomon. They were not used in supporting the building; their appearance, therefore, must have been solely due to moral and symbolic reasons. What these are it is not easy to say. The pillars were not Jacimus Jacob THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1548 altar pillars with hearths at their top, as supposed by W. R. Smith (Religion of the Semites, 191, 468); rather they were “‘pillars of witness,” as was the pillar that witnessed the contract between Jacob and Laban (Gen 31 52). A difficulty arises about the height of the pillars. The writers in K and Jer affirm that the pillars before the porch were 18 cubits high apiece (1 K 7 15; Jer 52 21), while the Chronicler states that they were 35 cubits (2 Ch 3 15). Various methods have been suggested of reconciling this discrepancy, but it is more probable that there is a corruption in the Chronicler’s num- ber. On the construction of the pillars and their capitals, see TeMpLE. At the final capture of Jerus they were broken up and the metal of which they were composed was sent to Babylon (2 K 26 13. 16). In Ezekiel’s ideal temple the two pillars are represented by pillars of wood (40 49). W. Saaw CaLpecotr JACIMUS, ja’si-mus (Ani, XII, ix, 3). See Are CIMUS. JACINTH, ja’sinth. See Hyacryrg; Srongs, Precious. JACKAL, jak’él: (1) DRE, tannim, “jackals,” AV ‘‘dragons’”’; cf Arab. wes; tindn, “wolf”; ow and cf P 3M, tannin, Arab. uns , tinnin, “sea monster” or “monster,” ERV “dragon” (Job 712m; Ps 74 13; 148 7; Isa 27.1; 619; Jer 51 34), “serpent”? (Ex 7 9.10.12; Dt 32 33; Ps 91 13), AV ‘‘whale” (Gen 1 21; Job 7 12); but PRN, tannin, “jackals,” AV “sea monsters” (Lam 4 3), “‘jackal’s well,’ AV “dragon well” (Neh 2 13), and tannim, “monster,” AV and ERV “dragon” (Ezk 29 3; 32 2). (2) B™N, ’tyim, “wolves,” AV “wild beasts of the islands’; cf "&, ’7, pl. OWN, tym, “island”; also MEN , ’ayyah, “a ery,” Vv ITS, ’dwah, “to cry,” “to howl’; Arab. er , ‘auwa’, “to bark” (of dogs, wolves, or jackals); ss! als "ibn 'dwa’, collo- quially wails, wowt, “jackal.” (3) BMX, ciytm, “wild beasts of the desert.” (4) EIN, ’ohim, “doleful creatures.” “Jackals” occurs as a tr of tannim, AV “dragons,” in Job 30 29; Ps 44 19; Isa 13 22; 3413; 35 7; 48 20; Jer 9 11; 10 22; 14 6; 49 33; 51 37; of the fem. pl. form tanndth in Mal 1 3, and of tannin in Neh 213 and Lam 4 3. Tannim is variously referred to a root meaning ‘“‘to howl,” and to a root meaning “‘to stretch out,” trop. “to run swiftly, ie. with outstretched neck and limb extended” (Ges.). Either derivation would suit “wolf” equally as well as “jackal.” The expression in Jer 10 22, “‘to make the cities of Judah a deso- lation, a dwelling-place of jackals,” seems, however, esp. appropriate of jackals. The same is true of Isa $4 13; Jer 9 11; 49 33, and 61 37. : The jackal (from Pers shaghdl), Canis aureus, is found about the Mediterranean except in Western Europe. It ranges southward to Abyssinia, and eastward, in Southern Asia, to farther India. It is smaller than a large dog, has a moderately bushy tail, and is reddish brown with dark shadings above. It is cowardly and nocturnal. Like the fox, it is destructive to poultry, grapes, and vegetables, but is less fastidious, and readily devours the remains of others’ feasts. Jackals generally go about in small companies. Their peculiar howl may frequently be heard in the evening and at any time in the night. It begins with a high-pitched, long-drawn-out cry. This is repeated two or three times, each time in a higher key than before. Finally there are several short, loud, yelping barks. Often when one raises the cry others join in. Jackals are not infrequently confounded with foxes. They breed freely with ora a Jackal (Canis aureus). While tannim is the only word tr4 “jackal” in EV, the words ’iyim, ciyim, and ’ohim deserve atten- tion. They, as well as tannim, evidently refer to wild creatures inhabiting desert places, but it is difficult to say for what animal each of the words stands. All four (together with bendth ya'dnah and s*‘irim) are found in Isa 13 21.22: “But wild beasts of the desert [¢tyim] shall lie there; and their houses shall be full of doleful creatures [’ohim]; and ostriches [b°ndth ya‘dénah] shall dwell there, and wild goats [s*‘tr7m] shall dance there. And wolves [’tytm] shall cry in their castles, and jackals [tannim] in the pleasant palaces.” In AV ‘tytm (Isa 18 22; 34 14; Jer 50 39) is trd ‘wild beasts of the islands" (cf ‘tyim, ‘‘islands"’). Vm has merely the transliteration iim, RV ‘‘wolves,”” RVm “howling creatures."’ Gesenius suggests the jackal, which is certainly a howler. While the wolf has a hlood-curdling howl, it is much more rarely heard than the jackal. Ciyim (Ps 72 9; 74 14; Isa 13 21; 23 13; 34 14; Jer 50 39) has been considered akin to czyah, ‘drought’ (ct ‘eree ciyah, ‘‘a dry land" [Ps 63 1}), and is tr? in RV as follows: Ps 72 9, ‘‘ they that dwell in the wilderness"; 74 14, ‘‘the people inhabiting the wilderness”: Isa 23 13, ‘‘them that dwell in the wilderness,’’ RVm ‘the beasts of the wilderness"; Isa 13 21; 34 14; Jer 50 39, ‘wild beasts of the desert.'' There would be some difficulty in referring ¢tyim in Ps 72 9 to beasts rather than to men, but that is not the case in Ps 74 14 and Isa 23 13. ‘‘ Wild cats'' have been suggested. ‘Ohim, ‘‘doleful creatures."’ perhaps onomatopcetic, occurs only in Isa 13 21. The tr ‘“‘owls"’ has been sug- gested, and is not unsuitable to the context. It is not impossible that tannim and ’iyim may be different names of the jackals. "Iyim, ciyim, and tannim occur together also in Isa 34 13.14, and ’tyim and ¢giyim in Jer 60 39. Their similarity in sound may have much to do with their colloca- tion. The recognized word for “wolf,” z2’ébh (cf Arab. dhi’), occurs 7 t in the OT. See Dracon; Wo.F; ZodLoeyr. ALFRED Ety Day JACKAL’S WELL (PIA PY, ‘én ha-tannin; LXX has ry tay cundv, pégé tin sukén, “fountain of the figs’; AV dragon well): A well or spring in the valley of Hinnom between the “Gate of the Gai” and the Dung Gate (Neh 2 13). No such source exists in the Wady er Rabdbi (see Hinnom) today, although it is very probable that a well sunk to the rock in the lower parts of this valley might strike a certain amount of water trickling down the valley- bottom. G. A. Smith suggests (Jerus, I, ch iv) that this source may have arisen as the result of an 1549 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jacimus Jacob earthquake, hence the name “dragon,” and have subsequently disappeared; but it is at lcast as likely: that it received its name from the jackals which haunted this valley, as the pariah dogs do today, to consume the dead bodies which were thrown there. See Hinnom; Jackat. E. W. G. MastermMsn JACOB, ja’kub: I. Name 1, Form and Distribution 2. Etymology and Associations II. Piace in tHe PatTRiarcHat Succession 1. As Son of Isaac and Rebekah 2. As Brother of Esau 8. As Father of the Twelve Ill. Broeraray 1. With Isaac in Canaan 2. To Aram and Back 3. In Canaan Again 4, Last Years in Egypt CaaRACTER AND BELIEFS 1. Natural Qualities 2. Stages of Development 3. Attitude toward the Promise 4. How Far a '‘ Type” of Israel V. Rersrences Outsipe or Genesis 1. In the OT 2. In the NT VI. Mopsrn Inrzerprerations or Jacos 1. Personification of the Hebrew Nation 2. God and Demi-Go 3. Character of Fiction i Name.—Apy (5 t DIPYY, ya'dkabh; ‘laxsp, Iakdb, is in form a vb. in the Kal impf., 3d masc. sing. Like some 50 other Heb names of this same 1. Form and form, ne has ne: subject for the vb. ae istri ion pressed. ut there are a number of inde- Dismibuuge endent indications that Jacob belongs to that large class of names consisting of a vb. with some Divine name or title (in this case "£1) as the subject, from which the common abbreviated form is derived by omitting the subject. (a) In Bab documents of the period of the Patriarchs, there occur such personal names as Ja-ku-bi, Ja-ku-ub-ilu (the former doubtless an ab- breviation of the latter), and Aq-bu-@ (cf Aq-bi-a-hu), according to Hilprecht a syncopated form for A-qu(?) -bu(-f), like Agq-bi-ili alongside of A-qa-bi-ili; all of which may he associated with the same root Spy, ‘akabh, as appears in Jacob (see H. Ranke, Early Bab Personal Names, 1905, with annotations by Professor Hilprecht as editor, esp. pp. 67, 113, 98 and 4). (b) In the list_of places in Pal conquered by the Pharaoh Thut- mose III appears a certain J‘qb'r, which in Egyp char- acters represents the Sem letters DRApD. ya &kébh-'él, and which therefore seems to show that in the earlier half of the 15th cent. BC (so Petrie, Breasted) there was a place (not a tribe; see W. M. Miller, Asien und Europa, 162 ff) in Central Pal that bore a name in some way connected with ‘‘Jacoh.'’ Moreover, a Pharaoh of the Hyksos period hears a name that looks like ya‘dékabh-' él (Spiegelbere, Orientalische Literaturzeitung, VII, 130). (c) In the Jewish tractate Pirké 'Abhoth, iii.1, we read of a Jew named ‘Akabhydh, which is a name composed of the same verbal root as that in Jacoh, together with the Divine name Yahz@ (i.e. Jeh) in its common abbreviated form. It should be noted that the personal names ‘Akkibh and Ya'dkobhah (accent on penult) also occur in the OT, the former borne by no less than 4 different persons; also that in the Palmyrene inscriptions we find a person named 3PYMY, a name in which this same vb. 539 is preceded by the name of the god ‘Ate, just as in ‘Akabhyah it is followed hy the name Yahi. : Such being the form and distribution of the name, it remains to inquire: What do we know of its etymology and what were the associations it con- IV. 5 « veyed to the Heb ear? : 2 syel The vh. in all its usages is capahle of ogy an deduction, by simple association cf ideas, Associations from the noun “heel."’ ‘‘To heel’ might mean: (a) ‘‘to take hold of by the heel” (so prohably Hos 12 3: cf Gen 27 36); (b) ''to follow with evil intent,” ‘to aD aa or in general ''to de- ceive” (so Gen 27 36; Jer,9 4, where the parallel, ‘yo ahout with slanders,’’ is interesting because the word so tr4 is akin to the noun “foot,’’ as "supplant" is to heel’); (c) '‘to follow with good intent," whether as a slave (cf our Eng. ‘‘to heel,” of a dog) for service, or as a guard for protection, hence ‘‘to guard” (so in Ethiopic), ‘to keep guard over"’ and thus ‘to restrain"’ (so Job 37 4): (d) “to follow,” ‘to succeed,” ‘‘to take the place of another’’ (so Arab., and the Heb noun ap? cs ‘gkebh, ‘‘consequence,”’ ‘‘recompense,’’ whether of reward or punishment). | 2 : Among these four significations, which most commends itself as the original intent in the use of this vb. to form a proper name? The answer to this question depends upon the degree of strength with which the Divine name was felt to be the subject of the vb. As Jacob-el, the simplest interpretation of the name is undouhtedly, as Baethgen urges (Beitrdge zur sem. Religionsgeschichte, 158), ‘‘God rewardeth" ([d] above), like Nathanacl, ‘*God hath given," etc. But we have already seen that centuries before the time when Jacob is said to have heen born, this name was shortened by dropping the Divine subject; and in this shortened form it would he more likely to call up in the minds of all Semites who used it, associations with the primary, physical notion of its root ({a] above). Hence there is no ground to deny that even in the patriarchal peed this familiar personal name Jacob lay ready at hand—a name ready made, as it were—tfor this child, in view of the peculiar circum- stances of its birth; we may say,indeed, one could not escape the use of it. (A parallel case, perhaps, is Gen 88 28.30, Zerah; cf Zerahiah.) The associations of this root in everyday use in Jacob’s family to mean ‘‘to supplant" led to the fresh realization of its appropriate- ness to his character and conduct when he was grown ([b] above). This construction does not interfere with a connection between the patriarch Jacob and the ** Jacob-els’’ referred to above (under 1, [b]), should that connection on other grounds appear probable. Such a longer form was perhaps for every “Jacob” an alter- native form of his name, and under certain circumstances may have been used by or of even the patriarch Jacob. Il. Place in the Patriarchal Saccession.—In the dynasty of the “heirs of the promise,’ Jacob takes his place, first, as the successor of 1. AsSon Isaac. In Isaac’s life the most sig- of Isaac and nificant single fact had been his mar- Rebekah riage with Rebekah instead of with a woman of Canaan. Jacob therefore represents the first generation of those who are determinately separate from their environment. Abraham and his household were immigrants in Canaan; Jacob and Esau were natives of Canaan in the second generation, yet had not a drop of Canaanitish blood in their veins. Their birth was delayed till 20 years after the marriage of their parents. Rebekah’s barrenness had certainly the same effect, and probably the same purpose, as that of Sarah: it drove Isaac to Divine aid, demanded of him as it had of Abraham that ‘faith and pa- tience”’ through which they ‘inherited the promises” (He 6 12), and made the children of this pair also the evident gift of God’s grace, so that Isaac was the better able “by faith” to “bless Jacob and Esau even concerning things to come” (He 11 20). These twin brothers therefore share thus far the same relation to their parents and to what their parents transmit to them. But here 2. As the likeness ceases. “Being not yet Brother born, neither having done anything of Esau good or bad, that the purpose of God according to election might stand, not of works, but of him that calleth, it was said unto {Rebecca], The elder shall serve the younger” (Rom 9 11.12). In the Gen-narrative, without any doctrinal assertions either adduced to explain it, or deduced from it, the fact is nevertheless made as clear as it is in Malor Rom, that Esau is rejected, and Jacob is chosen as a link in the chain of in- heritance that receives and transmits the promise. With Jacob the last person is reached who, for his own generation, thus sums up in a single indi- vidual ‘‘the secd” of promise. He 3. As becomes the father of 12 sons, who are Father of the progenitors of the tribes of the the Twelve ‘peculiar people.” It is for this reason that this people bears his name, and not that of his father Isaac or that of his grandfather Abraham. The “children of Israel,”’ the “house of Jacob,” are the totality of the seed of the promise. The Edomites too are children of Isaac. Ishmaelites equally with Israel- ites boast of descent from Abraham. But the twelve tribes that called themselves ‘Israel’ were all descendants of Jacob, and were the only de- scendants of Jacob on the agnatic principle of family-constitution. Jacob THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1550 Hl. Biography.—The life of a wanderer (Dt 26 5 RVm) such as Jacob was, may often be best di- vided on the geographical principle. Jacob’s career falls into the four distinct periods: that of his residence with Isaac in Canaan, that of his residence with Laban in Aram, that of his inde- pendent life in Canaan and that of his migration to Egypt. _ Jacob’s birth was remarkable in respect of (a) its delay for 20 years as noted above, (b) that condi- tion of his mother which Jed to the 1. With Divine oracle concerning his future Isaac in greatness and supremacy, and (c) the Canaan unusual phenomenon that gave him his name: “he holds by the heel” (see above, I, 2). Unlike his twin brother, Jacob seems to have been free from any physical pecul- iarities; his smoothness (Gen 27 11) is only predi- cated of him in contrast to Esau’s hairiness. These brothers, as they developed, grew apart in tastes and habits. Jacob, like his father in his quiet manner of life and (for that reason perhaps) the companion and favorite of his mother, found early the opportunity to obtain Esau’s sworn renunciation of his right of primogeniture, by taking advantage of his habits, his impulsiveness and his fundamental indifference to the higher things of the family, the things of the future (25 32). It was not until long afterward that the companion- scene to this first “‘supplanting” (27 36) was en- acted. Both sons meanwhile are to be thought of simply as members of Isaac’s following, during all the period of his successive sojourns in Gerar, the Valley of Gerar and Beersheba (ch 26). Within this period, when the brothers were 40 years of age, occurred Esau’s marriage with two Hittite women. Jacob, remembering his own mother’s origin, bided his time to find the woman who should be the mother of his children. The question whether she should be brought to him, as Rebekah was to Isaac, or he should go to find her, was settled at last by a family feud that only his absence could heal. This feud was occasioned by the fraud that Jacob at Rebekah’s behest practised upon his father and brother, when these two were minded to nullify the clearly revealed purpose of the oracle (25 23) and the sanctions of a solemn oath (26 33). Isaac’s partiality for Esau arose perhaps as much from Esau’s resemblance to the active, impulsive nature of his mother, as irom the sensual gratification afforded Isaac by the savory dishes his son’s hunt- ing supplied. At any rate, this partiality defeated itself because it overreached itself. The wife, who had learned to be eyes and ears for a husband’s failing senses, detected the secret scheme, counter- plotted with as much skill as unscrupulousness, and while she obtained the paternal blessing for her favorite son, fell nevertheless under the painful necessity of choosing between losing him through his brother’s revenge or losing him by absence from home. She chose, of course, the latter alternative, and herself brought about Jacob’s departure, by pleading to Isaac the necessity for obtaining a woman as Jacob’s wife of a sort different from the Canaanitish women that Esau had married. Thus ends the first portion of Jacob’s life. It is no young man that sets out thus to escape a brother’s vengearice, and perhaps to find a wife at length among his mother’s kindred. 2. To Aram It was long before this that Esau at and Back the age of forty had married the Hit- tite women (cf 26 34 with 27 46). Yet to one who had hitherto spent his life subor- dinate to his father, indulged by his mother, in awe of a brother’s physical superiority, and “dwelling in tents, a quiet [domestic] man” (25 27), this journey of 500 or 600 miles, with no one to guide, counsel or defend, was as new an experience as if he had really been the stripling that he is sometimes represented to have been. All the most significant chapters in life awaited him: self-determination, love, marriage, fatherhood, domestic provision and administration, adjustment of his relations with men, and above all a personal and independent religious experience. : Of these things, all were to come to him in the 20 years of absence from Canaan, and the last was to come first; for the dream of Jacob at Beth-el was of course but the opening scene in the long drama of God’s direct dealing with Jacob. Yet it was the determinative scene, for God in His latest and fullest manifestation to Jacob was just ‘‘the God of Beth-el” (35 7; 48 3; 49 24). With the arrival at Haran came love at once, though not for 7 years the consummation of that love. Its strength is naively indicated by the writer in two ways: impliedly in the sudden output of physical power at the well-side (29 10), and expressly in the patient years of toil for Rachel’s sake, which “seemed unto him but a few days for the love he had to her” (29 20). Jacob is not pri- marily to be blamed for the polygamy that brought trouble into his home-life and sowed the seeds of division and jealousy in the nation of the future. Although much of Israel’s history can be summed up in the rivalry of Leah and Rachel—Judah and Joseph—yet it was not Jacob’s choice but Laban’s fraud that introduced this cause of schism. At the end of his 7 years’ labor Jacob received as wife not Rachel but Leah, on the belated plea that to give the younger daughter before the elder was not the custom of the country. This was the first of the “ten times” that Laban “changed the wages” of Jacob (81 7.41). Rachel became Jacob’s wife 7 days after Leah, and for this second wife he ‘‘served 7 other years.” During these 7 years were born most of the sons and daughters (37 35) that formed the actual family, the nucleus of that large caravan that Jacob took back with him to Canaan. Dimah is the only daughter named; 30 21 is obviously in preparation for the story of ch 34 (see esp. 34 31). Four sons of Leah were the oldest: Reuben, with the right of primogeniture, Simeon, Levi and Judah. Next came the 4 sons of Bilhah and Zilpah, the personal slaves of the two wives (cf ABRaHaM, IV, 2); the two pairs of sons were probably of about the same age (cf order in ch 49). Leah’s 5th and 6th sons were separated by an interval of uncertain length from her older group. And Joseph, the youngest son born in Haran, was Rachel’s first child, equally beloved by his mother, and by his father for her sake (33 2; cf 44 20), as well as because he was the youngest of the eleven (87 3). Jacob’s years of service for his wives were fol- lowed by 6 years of service rendered for a stipulated wage. Laban’s cunning in limiting the amount of this wage in a variety of ways was matched by Jacob’s cunning in devising means to overreach his uncle, so that the penniless wanderer of 20 years before becomes the wealthy proprietor of countless cattle and of the hosts of slaves necessary for their care (32 10). At the same time the apology of Jacob for his conduct during this entire period of residence in Haran is spirited (81 36-42); it is apparently unanswerable by Laban (ver 43); and it 1s confirmed, both by the evident concurrence of Leah and Rachel (vs 14-16), and by indications in the narrative that the justice (not merely the par- tiality) of God gave to each party his due recom- pense: to Jacob the rich returns of skilful, patient industry; to Laban rebuke and warning (vs 5-13. 24.29.42), The manner of Jacob’s departure from Haran was determined by the strained relations between 1551 his uncle and himself. His motive in going, how- ever, is represented as being fundamentally the desire to terminate an absence from his father’s country that had already grown too long (31 30; cf 30 25)—a desire which in fact presented itself to him in the form of a revelation of God’s own pur- pose and command (31 3). Unhappily, his clear record was stained by the act of another than him- self, who nevertheless, as a member of his family, entailed thus upon him the burden of responsibility. Rachel, like Laban her father, was devoted to the superstition that manifested itself in the keeping and consulting of t*raéphim, a custom which, whether more nearly akin to fetishism, totemism, or ancestor- worship, was felt to be incompatible with the wor- ship of the one true God. (Note that the ‘‘teraphim” of 31 19.34f are the same as the ‘‘gods” of vs 30.32 and, apparently, of 35 2.4.) This theft furnished Laban with a pretext for pursuit. What he meant to do he probably knew but imperfectly himself. Coercion of some sort he would doubtless have brought to bear upon Jacob and his caravan, had he not recognized in a dream the God whom Jacob worshipped, and heard Him utter a word of warning against the use of violence. Laban failed to find his stolen gods, for his daughter was as crafty and ready-witted ashe. The whole adventure ended in a formal reconciliation, with the usual sacrificial and memorial token (31 43-55). After Laban, Esau. One danger is no sooner escaped than a worse threatens. Yet between them lies the pledge of Divine presence and pro- tection in the vision of God’s host at Mahanaim: just a simple statement, with none of the fanciful detail that popular story-telling loves, but the sober record of a tradition to which the supernatural was matter of fact. Even the longer passage that pre- serves the occurrence at Peniel is conceived in the same spirit. What the revelation of the host of God had not sufficed to teach this faithless, anxious, scheming patriarch, that God sought to teach him in the night-struggle, with its ineffaceable physical memorial of a human impotence that can compass no more than to cling to Divine omnipotence (32 22-32). The devices of crafty Jacob to disarm an offended and supposedly implacable brother proved as useless as that bootless wrestling of the night before; Esau’s peculiar disposition was not of Jacob’s making, but of God’s, and to it alone Jacob owed his safety. The practical wisdom of Jacob dictated his insistence upon bringing to a speedy termination the proposed association with his changeable brother, amid the difficulties of a jour- ney that could not be shared by such divergent social and racial elements as Esau’s armed host and Jacob’s caravan, without discontent on the one side and disaster on the other. The brothers part, not to meet again until they meet to bury their father at Hebron (35 29). Before Jacob’s arrival in the S. of Canaan where his father yet lived and where his own youth had been spent, he passed through a period 3. In of wandering in Central Pal, somewhat Canaan similar to that narrated of his grand- Again father Abraham. To any such nomad, wandering slowly from Aram toward Egypt, a period of residence in the region of Mt. Ephraim was a natural chapter in his book of travels. Jacob’s longer stops, recorded for us, were (1) at Succoth, E. of the Jordan near Peniel, (2) at Shechem and (8) at Beth-el. Nothing worthy of record occurred at Succoth, but the stay at Shechem was eventful. Gen 34, which tells the story of Dinah’s seduction and her brother’s revenge, throws as much light upon the relations of Jacob and the Canaanites, as does ch 14 or ch 23 upon Abraham’s relations, or ch 26 upon THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jacob Isaac’s relations, with such scttled inhabitants of the land. There is a strange blending of moral and immoral elements in Jacob and his family as por- trayed in this contretemps. There is the persistent tradition of separateness from the Canaanites be- queathed from Abraham’s day (ch 24), together with a growing family consciousness and sense of superiority (34 7.14.31). And at the same time there is indifference to their unique moral station among the environing tribes, shown in Dinah’s social relations with them (ver 1), in the treachery and cruelty of Simeon and Levi (vs 25-29), and in Jacob’s greater concern for the security of his possessions than for the preservation of his good name (ver 30). It was this concern for the safety of the family and its wealth that achieved the end which dread of social absorption would apparently never have achieved—the termination of a long residence where there was moral danger for all. For a second time Jacob had fairly to be driven to Beth-el. Safety from his foes was again a gift of God (35 5), and in a renewal of the old forgotten ideals of con- secration (vs 2-8), he and all his following move from the painful associations of Shechem to the hallowed associations of Beth-el. Here were re- newed the various phases of all God’s earlier com- munications to this patriarch and to his fathers before him. The new name of Israel, hitherto so ill deserved, is henceforth to find realization in his life; his fathers’ God is to be his God; _his seed is to inherit the land of promise, and is to be no mean tribe, but a group of peoples with kings to rule over them like the nations round about (35 9-12). No wonder that Jacob here raises anew his monument of stone—emblem of the “Stone of Israel” (49 24)— and stamps forever, by this public act, upon ancient Luz (35 6), the name of Beth-el which he had pri- vately given it years before (28 19). Losses and griefs characterized the family life of the patriarch at this period. The death of his mother’s Syrian nurse at Beth-el (85 8; cf 24 59) was followed by the death of his beloved wife Rachel at Ephrath (35 19; 48 7) in bringing forth the youngest of his 12 sons, Benjamin. At about the same time the eldest of the 12, Reuben, for- feited the honor of his station in the family by an act that showed all too clearly the effect of recent association with Canaanites (35 22). Finally, death claimed Jacob’s aged father, whose latest years had been robbed of the companionship, not only of this son, but also of the son whom his par- tiality had all but made a fratricide; at Isaac’s grave in Hebron the ill-matched brothers met once more, thenceforth to go their separate ways, both in their personal careers and in their descendants’ history (35 29). Jacob now is by right of patriarchal custom head of all the family. He too takes up his residence at Hebron (87 14), and the story of the family fortunes is now pursued under the new title of ‘‘the gener- ations of Jacob” (37 2). True, most of this story revolves about Joseph, the youngest of the family save Benjamin; yet the occurrence of passages like ch 38, devoted exclusively to Judah’s affairs, or 46 8-27, the enumeration of Jacob’s entire family through its secondary ramifications, or ch 49, the blessing of Jacob on all his sons—all these prove that Jacob, not Joseph, is the true center of the narrative until his death. As long as he lives he is the real head of his house, and not merely a super- annuated veteran like Isaac. Not only Joseph, the boy of 17 (37 2), but also the self-willed elder sons, even a score of years later, come and go at his bidding (chs 42-45). Joseph’s dearest thought, as it is his first thought, is for his aged father (43 7.27; 44 19; and esp. 45 3.9.13.23, and 46 29). Jacob THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1552 It is this devotion of Joseph that results in Jacob’s migration to Egypt. What honors there Joseph can show his father he shows him: he 4. Last presents him to Pharaoh, who for Years in Joseph’s sake receives him with dig- Egypt nity, and assigns him a home and sus- tenance for himself and all his people as honored guests of the land of Egypt (47 7-12). Yet in Beersheba, while en route to Egypt, Jacob had obtained a greater honor than this reception by Pharaoh. He had found there, as ready to respond to his sacrifices as ever to those of his fathers, the God of his father Isaac, and had received the gra- cious assurance of Divme guidance in this mo- mentous journey, fraught with so vast a significance for the future nation and the world (46 1-4): God Himself would go with him into Egypt and give him, not merely the gratification of once more embracing his long-lost son, but the fulfilment of the covenant-promise (15 13-16) that he and his were not turning their backs upon Canaan forever. Though 130 years of age when he stood before Pharaoh, Jacob felt his days to have been “few” as well as “evil,” in comparison with those of his fathers (47 9). And in fact he had yet 17 years to live in Goshen (47 28). These last, days are passed over without record, save of the growth and prosperity of the family. But at their close came the impartation of the an- cestral blessings, with the last will of the dying patriarch. After adopting Joseph’s sons, Manas- seh and Ephraim, as his own, Jacob blesses them, preferring the younger to the elder as he himself had once been preferred to Esau, and assigns to Joseph the “double portion” of the firstborn—that “‘preéminence” which he denies to Reuben (48 22; 49 4). In poetry that combines with the warm emotion and glowing imagery of its style and the unsurpassed elevation of its diction, a lyrical fervor of religious sentiment which demands for its author a personality that had passed through just such a course of tuition as Jacob had experienced, the last words of Jacob, in ch 49, mark a turning-point in the history of the people of God. This is a trans- lation of biography into prophecy. On the assump- tion that it is genuine, we may confidently aver that it was simply unforgetable by those who heard it. Its auditors were its theme. Their descend- ants were its fulfilment. Neither the one class nor the other could ever let it pass out of memory. It was “by faith,” we are well reminded, that Jacob “‘blessed” and ‘‘worshipped” ‘‘when he was dying” (He 11 21). For he held to the promises of God, and even in the hour of dissolution looked for the fulfilment of the covenant, according to which Canaan should belong to him and to his seed alter him. He therefore set Joseph an example, by “giving commandment concerning his bones,” that they might rest in the burial-place of Abraham and Isaac near Hebron. To the accomplishment of this mission Joseph and all his brethren addressed themselves after their father’s decease and the 70 days of official mourning. Followed by a “very great company” of the notables of Egypt, including royal officials and representatives of the royal family, this Heb tribe carried up to sepulture in the land of promise the embalmed body of the patriarch from whom henceforth they were to take their tribal name, lamented him according to custom for 7 days, and then returned to their temporary home in Egypt, till their children should at length be “called” thence to become God’s ‘‘son” (Hos 11 1) and inherit His promises to their father Jacob. IV. Character and Beliefs.—In the course of this account of Jacob's career the inward as well as the outward fortunes of the man have somewhat ap- peared. Yet a more comprehensive view of the kind of man he was will not be superfluous at this point. With what disposition was he endowed— the natural nucleus for acquired characteristics and habits? Through what stages did he pass in the development of his beliefs and his character? In particular, what attitude did he maintain toward the most significant thing in his life, the promise of God to his house? And lastly, what resemblances may be traced in Israel the man to Israel the nation, of such sort that the one may be regarded as ‘‘typi- cal” of the other? These matters deserve more than a passing notice. rH) From his father, Jacob inherited that domesticity and affectionate attachment to his home circle which appears in his life from begin- 1. Natural ningtoend. He inherited shrewdness, Qualities initiative and resourcefulness from Rebekah—dqualities which she shared apparently with her brother Laban and all his family. The conspicuous ethical faults of Abraham and Isaac alike are want of candor and want. of courage. It is not surprising, therefore, to find the same failings in Jacob. Deceit and cowardice are visible again and again in the impartial record of his life. Both sprmg from unbelief. They belong to the natural man. God’s transformation of this man was wrought by faith—by awakening and nourishing in him a simple trust in the truth and power of the Divine word. For Jacob was not at any time in his career indifferent to the things of the spirit, the things unseen and belonging to the future. Unlike Esau, he was not callous to the touch of God. Whether through inheritance, or as a fruit of early teaching, he had as the inesti- mable treasure, the true capital of his spiritual career, a firm conviction of the value of what God had promised, and a supreme ambition to obtain it for himself and his children. But against the Divine plan for the attainment of this goal by faith, there worked in Jacob constantly his natural quali- ties, the non-moral as well as the immoral qualities, that urged him to save himself and his fortunes by “works’—by sagacity, cunning, compromise, pertinacity—anything and everything that would anticipate God’s accomplishing His purpose in His own time and His own way. In short, “the end justifies the means” is the program that, more than all others, finds illustration and rebuke in the character of Jacob. Starting with such a combination of natural endowments, social, practical, ethical, Jacob passed through a course of Divine tuition, 2. Stages which, by building upon some of them, of Devel- repressing others and transfiguring the opment remaider, issued in the triumph of grace over nature, in the transforma- tion of a Jacob into an Israel. This tuition has been well analyzed by a recent writer (Thomas, Genesis, III, 204 f) into the school of sorrow, the school of providence and the school of grace. Under the head of sorrow, it is not difficult to recall many experiences in the career just reviewed: long exile; disappointment; sinful passions of greed, anger, lust_and envy in others, of which Jacob was the victim; perplexity; and, again and again, bereave- ment of those he held most dear. But besides these sorrows, God's providence dealt with him in ways most remarkable, and per- haps more instructive for the study of such Divine dealings than in the case of any other character in the OT. By alternate giving and withholding, by danger here and deliverance there, by good and evil report, now by failure of “‘best laid schemes” and now by success with seemingly inadequate means, God developed in him the habit—not native to him as it seems to have been in part to Abraham and to Joseph —of reliance on Divine power and guidance, 1553 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jacob of accepting the Divine will, of realizing the Divine nearness and faithfulness. And lastly, there are those admirably graded lessons in the grace of God, that were imparted in the series of Divine appearances to the patriarch, at Beth-el, at Haran, at Peniel, at Beth-el again and at Beersheba. For if the substance of these Divine revelations be compared, it will be found that all are alike in the assurance (1) that God is with him to bless; (2) that the changes of his life are ordained of God and are for his ultimate good; and (3) that he is the heir of the ancestral promises. It will further be found that they may he arranged In a variety of ways, according as one or another of the revelations he viewed as the climax. Thus (1), agreeing with the chronological order, the appearance at Beer- sheha ae well be regarded as the climax of them all. Abraham had gone to Egypt to escape a famine (12 10), but be went without revelation, and returned with bitter experience of his error. Isaac essayed to go to Egypt for the same cause (26 1f), and was prevented hy reve- lation. Jacob now goes to Egypt, but he goes with the express approval of the God of his fathers, and with the emmy assurance that the same Divine providence which ordained this removal (§Q 20) will see that it does not frustrate any of the promises of God. ‘his was a crisis in the history of the ‘‘Kingdom of God"' on a par with events like the Exodus, the Exile, or the Return. (2) In its significance for his personal history, the first of these revelations was unique. Beth-el witnessed Jacob's choice, evidently for the first time, of his fathers’ God as his God. And though we find Jacob later toler- ating idolatry in his household and compromising his religious testimony by sin, we never find a hint of his own unfaithfulness to this first and final religious choice. This is further confirmed by the attachment of his later revelations to this primary one, as though this lent them the significance of continuity, and made possible the unity of his religious experience. So at Haran it was the “God of Beth-el’’ who directed his return (31 13); at Shechem it was to Beth-el that he was directed, in order that he might at length fulfil his Beth-el vow, by erect- ing there an altar to the God who had there appeared to him (35 1); and at Beth-el finally the promise of former years was renewed to him who was henceforth to he Israel (vs 9-15). (3) Though thus punctuated with the supernatural, the only striking bit of the marvelous in all this biography is the night scene at Peniel. And this too may justly be claimed as a climax in Jacoh’s development. There he first received his new name, and though he deserved it as little in many scenes thereafter as he had deserved it hefore, yet the same could be said of many a man who has ‘‘seen the face of God,” but has yet to grasp, like Jacob, the lesson that the way to overcome is through the pel ples but clinging importunity of faith. (4) Rather than in any of the other scenes, however, it was at Beth-el the second time that the patriarch reached the topmost rung on the ladder of development. As already noticed, the substance of all the earlier reve- lations is here renewed and combined. It is no wonder that after this solemn theophany we find Jacob, like Moses later, ‘enduring as seeing him who is invisible’ (He 11 27), and ‘‘waiting for the salvation’’ (Gen 49 18) of a God ‘who is not ashamed of him, to he called Boies (He 11 16), but is repeatedly called ‘'the God of Jacoh.” Finally, such a comparison of these revelations to Jacob reveals a variety in the way God makes Himself known. In the first revelation, naturally, the effort is made chiefly to impress upon its recip- ient the identity of the revealing God with the God of his fathers. And it has been remarked already that in the later revelations the same care is taken to identify the Revealer with the One who gave that first revelation, or else to identify Him, as then, with the God of the fathers. Yet, m addition to this, there is a richness and suitability in the Divine names revealed, which a mechanical theory of literary sources not only leaves unexplained but fails even to recognize. At Beth-el first it is Jeh, the personal name of this God, the God of his fathers, who enters into a new personal relation with Jacob; now, of all times in his career, he needs to know God by the differential mark that distinguishes Him absolutely from other gods, that there may never be confusion as to Jeh’s identity. But this matter is settled for Jacob once for all. Thenceforth one of the ordinary terms for deity, with or without an attributive adjunct, serves to lift the patriarch’s soul into communication with his Divine Inter- locutor. The most general word of all in the Sem tongues for deity is ’Hl, the word used in the revelations to Jacob at Haran (81 13), at Shechem (86 1), at Beth-el the second time (35 11) and at Beersheba (46 3). But it is never used alone. Like Allah in the Arab. language (=the God), so ‘El with the definite article before it serves to des- ignate in Heb a particular divinity, not deity in general. Or else ’Hi without the article is made definite by some genitive phrase that supplies the necessary identification: so in Jacob’s case, El- beth-el (85 7; cf 31 13) or El-Elohe-Israel (33 20). Or, lastly, there is added to ’H? some determining title, with the force of an adjective, as Shaddai (tr4 “Almighty”’) in 86 11 (cf_48 3). In clear dis- tinction from this word, ’Hl, with its archaic or poetic flavor, is the common Heb word for God, Flohim. But while ’Hléhim is used regularly by the narrator of the Jacob-stories in speaking, or in letting his actors speak, of Jacob’s God, who to -the monotheistic writer is of course the God and his own God, he never puts this word thus abso- lutely into the mouth of the revealing Deity. Jacob can say, when he awakes from his dream, ‘This is the house of ’Elohkim,’ but God says to him in the dream, “I am the God [Elohim] of thy ‘ather” (28 17.13). At Mahanaim Jacob says, “This is the host of ’Hlahim” (32 2), but at Beersheba God says to Jacob, “I am... . the God ['Hlahim] of thy father” (46 3). Such are the distinctions maintained in the use of these words, all of them used of the same God, yet chosen in each case to fit the circumstances of speaker, hearer and situation. The only passage in the story of Jacob that might appear to he an exception does in fact hut prove the rule. At Peniel the angel of God explains the new name of Israel hy saying, ‘‘Thou hast striven with God ['Elahim] and with men, and hast prevailed.’’ Here the contrast with ''men” proves that 'Eléhim without the article is just. the_right expression, even on the lips of Deity: neither Deity nor humanity has prevailed against Jacob Throughout the entire story of Jacob, therefore, his relations with Jeh his God, after they were once established (28 13-16), are narrated in terms that emphasize the Divinity of Him who had thus entered into covenant-relationship with him: His Divinity —that is to say, those attributes in which His Divinity manifested itself in His dealings with Jacob. From the foregoing, two things appear with respect to Jacob’s attitude toward the promise of God. First, with all his faults and 3. Attitude vices he yet was spiritually sensitive; toward the he responded to the approaches of his Promise God concerning things of a value wholly spiritual—future good, moral and spiritual blessings. And second, he was capable of progress in these matters; that is, his reaction to the Divine tuition would appear, if charted, as a series of elevations, separated one from another, to be sure, by low levels and deep declines, yet each one higher than the last, and all taken collectively lifting the whole average up and up, till in the end faith has triumphed over sight, the future over present good, a yet unpossessed but Divinely promised Canaan over all the comfort and honors of Egypt, and the aged patriarch lives only to “wait for Jeh’'s salvation” (49 18). The contrast of Jacob with Fsau furnishes per- haps the best means of grasping the significance of these two facts for an estimate of Jacob’s atti- tude toward the promise. For in the first place, Esau, who possessed so much that Jacob lacked— directness, manliness, a sort of bonhomie, that made him superficially more attractive than his brother —Esau shows nowhere any real “sense” for things Jacob THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1554 spiritual. The author of Hebrews has caught the man in the flash of a single word, “profane” (6é- Bydos, bébélos)—of course, in the older, broader, etymological meaning of the term. Esau’s desires dwelt in the world of the non-sacred; they did not aspire to that world of nearness to God, where one must ‘put off the shoes from off his feet, because the place whereon he stands is holy ground.’ And in the second place, there is no sign of growth in Esau. What we see him in his father’s encamp- ment, that we see him to the end—so far as appears from the laconic story. With the virtues as well as the vices of the man who lives for the present— forgiving when strong enough to revenge, conde- scending when flattered, proud of power and independent of parental control or family tradition —Esau is as impartially depicted by the sacred his- torian as if the writer had been an Edomite instead of an Israelite: the sketch is evidently true to life, both from its objectivity and from its coherence. Now what Esau was, Jacob was not. His fault in connection with the promises of God, the family tradition, the ancestral blessing, lay not in despising " them, but in seeking them in immoral ways. Good was his aim; but he was ready to “do evil that good might come.” He was always tempted to be his own Providence, and God’s training was clearly directed, both by providential leadings and by gracious disclosures, to this corresponding purpose: to enlighten Jacob as to the nature of the promise; to assure him that it was his by grace; to awaken personal faith in its Divine Giver; and to supple- ment his “faith” by that “patience” without which none can “inherit the promises.” The faith that accepts was to issue at length in the faith that waits. A nation was to take its name from Jacob-Israel, and there are some passages of Scripture where it is uncertain whether the name designates the nation or 4. How Far its ancestor. In their respective relations “Type”? to God and to the world of men and na- a _ftype tions, there is a true sense in which the of Israel father was a ‘‘type" of the children. It is probahly only a play of fancy that would discover a parallel in their respective careers, hetween the successive stages of life in the father's home (Canaan), life in exile, a return, and a second exile. But it is not fanciful to note the resemblance hetween Jacob's character and that of his descendants. With few exceptions the qualities mentioned ahove (IV, 2) will be found, mutatis mutandis, to he equally appli- cable to the nation of Israel. And even that curriculum in which the patriarch learned of God_may he viewed as a type of the school in which the Heh people—not all of them, nor even the mass, but the ‘‘remnant” who approximated to the ideal Israel of the prophets, the “servant of Jeh'’—were taught the lessons of faith and patience, of renunciation and consecration, that appear with growing clearness on the pages of Isaiah, of Habak- kuk, of Jeremiah, of Malachi. This is apparently Hosea's point of view in 12 2-4.12. z : A word of caution, however, is needed at this point. There are limits to this equation. Even critics who regard Jacob under his title of Israel as merely the eponymous hero, created by legend to be the forefather of the nation (cf below, VI, 1), must confess that Jacob as Jacob is no such neutral creature, dressed only in the colors of his children's racial qualities. There is a large residuum in Jacob, after all parallelisms have been traced, that refuses to fit the lines of Heb national char- acter or history, and his typical relation in fact lies chiefly in the direction of the covenant-inheritance, after the fashion of Malachi's allusion (Mal 1 2), interpreted by Paul (Rom 9 10-13). V. References Outside of Genesis.—Under his two names this personage Jacob or Israel is more frequently mentioned than any other in the whole of sacred history. Yet in the vast majority of cases the nation descended from him is intended by the name, which in the form of “Jacob” or “Israel” contains not the slightest, and in the form “children of Israel,’’ “house of Jacob” and the like, only the slightest, if any, allusion to the patriarch himself. But there still remain many passages in both Testaments where the Jacob or Israel of Gen is clearly alluded to. There is a considerable group of passages that refer to him as the last of the patriarchal triumvirate —Abraham, Isaac and Jacob: so 1. In particularly of Jeh as the “God of the OT Abraham, Isaac and Jacob,” and of the covenant-oath as having been “sworn unto Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.” And naturally the nation that is known by his name is frequently called by some phrase, equivalent to the formal bené yisra’él, yet through its unusualness Jending more significance to the idea of their deri- vation from him: so “‘seed of Jacoh” and (frequently) “house of Jacob {Israel].’’ But there are a few OT passages outside of Gen in which so much of Jacob’s history has been preserved, that from these allusions alone a fair notion might have been gathered concerning the Hebrews’ tradition of their common ancestor, even if all the story in Gen had been lost. These passages are: Josh 24 3.4.32; Ps 105 10-23; Hos 12 2-412; Mal12f. Be- sides these, there are other allusions, scattered a word here and a sentence there, from all of which together we learn as follows. God gave to Isaac twin sons, Esau and Jacob, the latter at birth taking the former by the heel. God elected Jacob to be the recipient of the covenant-promise made to his father Isaac and to his grandfather Abraham; and this choice involved the rejection of Esau. Jeh appeared to Jacob at Beth-el and told him the land of Canaan was to be his and his seed’s after him forever. Circumstances not explained caused Jacob to flee from his home in Canaan to Aram, where he served as a shepherd to obtain a wife as his wage. He became the father of 12 sons. He strove with the angel of God and prevailed amid earnest supplication. His name was by Jeh Himself changed to Israel. Under Divine pro- tection as God’s chosen one and representative, his life was that of a wanderer from place to place; once only he bought a piece of land, for a hundred pieces, near Shechem, from Hamor, the father of Shechem. A famine drove him down to Egypt, but not without providential preparation for the reception there of himself and all his family, through the remarkable fortunes of his son Joseph, sold, exiled, imprisoned, delivered, and exalted to a posi- tion where he could dispose of rulers and nations. In Egypt the children of Jacob multiplied rapidly, and at his death he made the sons of Joseph the heirs of the only portion of Canaanitish soil that he had acquired. From this it appears, first, that not much that is essential in the biography of Jacob would have perished though Gen had been lost; and, second, that the sum of the incidental allusions outside Gen resemble the total impression of the narratives in Gen—in other words, that the Bib. tradition is self-consistent. And it runs back to a date (Hosea, 8th cent. BC) little farther removed from the events recounted than the length of time that separates our own day from the Norman conquest, or the Fall of Constantinople from the Hegira, or Jesus Christ from Solomon. In the NT also there are, besides the references to Jacob simply as the father of his nation, several passages that recall events in his life 2. Inthe or traits of his character. These are: NT Jn 4 5.6.12; Acts 7 12.14-16; Rom ; 9 10-13; He 11 9.20f. Inthe conver- sation between Jesus and the Samaritan woman it appears that the Samaritans cherished the association of Jacob with the ground he bought near Shechem, and with the well he dug while sojourning there with his sons and his flocks; they prided themselves on its transmission to them through Joseph, not to the hated Jews through Judah, and magnified them- selves in magnifying Jacob’s “greatness” and calling 1555 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jacob him “our father.’ Stephen’s speech, as Luke reports it, includes in its rapid historical flight a hint or two about Jacob beyond the bare fact of his lace in the tribal genealogy. Moved by the amine prevailing in Egypt and Canaan, Jacob twice dispatches his sons to buy grain in Egypt, and the second time Joseph is made known to his brothers, and his race becomes manifest to Pharaoh. At Joseph’s behest, Jacob and all the family remove to Egypt. There all remain until their death, but the “fathers” (Joseph and his brethren; cf Jerome, Episiola eviii, ed. Migne) are buried in the family possession near Shechem. (Here emerges one of those divergences from the OT tradition that are a notable feature of Stephen’s speech, and that have furnished occasion for much speculation upon their origin, value and implications. See comms. on Acts.) Paul’s interest in Jacob appears in con- nection with his discussion of Divine election, where he calls attention to the oracle of Gen 25 23 and to the use already made of the passage by Malachi (1 2f), and reminds his readers that this choice of Jacob and rejection of Esau was made by God even before these twin sons of Isaac and Rebecca were born. Finally, the author of He, when charting the heroes of faith, focuses his glass for a moment upon Jacob: first, as sharing with Abraham and Isaac the promise of God and the life of unworldly, expectant faith (He 11 9); and second, as receiving from Isaac, and at his death transmitting to his grandsons, blessings that had value only for one who worships and believes a God with power over “things to come” (vs 20f). VI. Modern Interpretations of Jacob.—For those who see in the patriarchal narratives anything— myth, legend, saga—rather than true biography, there is, of course, a different interpretation of the characters and events portrayed in the familiar Gen-stories, and a different value placed upon the stories themselves. a paet from the allegorizing treatment accorded them by Philo the Jew and early Christian writers of like mind (see specimen in AsraHam), these views helong to modern criticism. To critics who make Heh history begin with the settlement of Canaan by the nomad Israelites fresh from the desert, even the Mosaic age and the Egyp residence are totally unhistorical—much more so these tales of a pre-Mosaic patriarchal age. Yet even those writers who admit the broad outlines of a residence of the tribes in Egypt, an exodus of some sort, and a founder of the nation named Moses, are for the most part skeptical of this cycle of family figures and fortunes in a remote age, with its nomads wander- ing between Mesopotamia and Canaan, and to and fro in Canaan, its circumstantial acquaintance with the names and relationships of each individual through those 4 long patriarchal generations, and its obvious foreshadowing of much that the later tribes were on this same soil to act out cents. later. This, we are told, is not history. Whatever else it may be, it is not a reliable account of such memorable events as compel their own immortality in the memories and through the written records of mankind. The commonest view held, collectively of the entire narrative, specifically of Jacob, is that which sees here the precipitate from a pure 1. Personi- solution of the national character and fication of fortunes. Wellhausen, e.g., says (Pro- the Hebrew legomena’, 316): ‘The material here Nation is not mythical, but national; there- fore clearer [viz. than in Gen 1-11] and in a certain sense historical. To be sure there is no historical knowledge to be gained here about the patriarchs, but only about the time in which the stories concerning them arose in the people of Israel; this later time with its inward and outward char- acteristics is here unintentionally projected into the gray antiquity and mirrored therein like a glorified phantasm . ... [p. 818] Jacob is more real- istically drawn than the other two [Abraham and Isaac].”’ In section IV, 4, above, we observed that, while many of Jacob’s personal qualitics pre- figured the qualities of the later Heb people, there were some others that did not at all fit this equation. Wellhausen himself remarks this, in regard to the contrast between warlike Israel and the peaceful ancestors they invented for themselves. In his attempt to account for this contrast, he can only urge that a nation condemned to eternal wars would naturally look back upon, as well as forward to, a golden age of peace. (An alternative explana- tion he states, only to reject.) He fails to observe that this plea does not in the least alter the fact—his plea is indeed but.a restatement of the fact—that this phenomenon is absolutely at variance with his hypothesis of how these stories of Jacob and the rest came to be what they are (see Meyer, Die Israeliten und ihre Nachbarstémme, 250 ff). This general view, which when carried to its extreme implications (as by Steuernagel, Die Hin- wanderung der tsraelitischen Stdmme in Kanaan, 1901) comes perilously near the reduc- 2. God and tio ad absurdum that is its own refuta- Demi-God tion, has been rejected by that whole group of critics, who, following Néldeke, see in Jacob, as in so many others of the patriarchs, an original deity (myth), first abased to the grade of a hero (heroic legend), and at last degraded to the level of a clown (tales of jest or marvel). Adherents of this trend of interpretation differ widely among themselves as to details, but Jacob is generally regarded as a Canaanitish deity, whose local shrine was at Shechem, Beth-el or Peniel, and whose cult was taken over by the Hebrews, their own object of worship being substituted for him, and the out- standing features of his personality being made over into a hero that Israel appropriated as their national ancestor, even to the extent of giving him the secondary name of Israel. Stade attempted a combination of this “mythical” view with the “national” view in the interest of his theory of primitive animism, by making the patriarch a ‘mythological figure revered as an eponymous hero.” This theory, in any form, requires the assumption, which there is nothing to support, that Jacob (or Jacob-el) is a name originally belonging to a deity and framed to fit his supposed character. At first, then, it meant “’HI deceives” or ‘El recompenses” (so B. Luther, ZATW, 1901, 60 ff; cf also the same writer, as well as Meyer himself, in the latter’s Israeliten, etc, 109 ff, 271 ff). Meyer proposes the monstrosity of a nominal sentence with the tr, ‘‘ ‘He deceives’ is ’Hl.” Thus the first element of the name Jacob came to be felt as the name itself (= “Jacob is God”’), and it was launched upon its course of evolution into the human per- sonage that Gen knows. It suffices to say with regard to all this, that in addition to its being inher- ently improbable—not to say, unproved—it goes directly in the face of the archaeological evidence adduced under I, 1, above. The simple fact that Jacob(-el) was a personal name for men, of every- day occurrence in the 2d-3d millenniums BC, is quite enough to overthrow this whole hypothesis; for, as Luther himself remarks (op. cit., 65), the above evolution of the name is essential to the “mythical” theory: ‘when this alteration took place cannot be told; yet it has to be postulated, since otherwise it remains inexplicable, how personal names could arise out of these formations [like Jacob-el] by rejection of the ’H1.” The inadequacy of the two theories hitherto ad- vanced to account for the facts of Gen being thus evident, Gunkel and others have ex- 3. Character plicitly rejected them and enunciated of Fiction a third theory, which may be called the saga-theory. According to Gun- kel, ‘‘to understand the persons of Gen as nations Jacob Jael THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1556 is by no means a general key to their interpretation” ; and, “‘against the whole assumption that the prin- cipal patriarchal figures are originally gods is this fact first and foremost, that the names Jacob and Abraham are shown by the Bab to be customary personal names, and furthermore that the tales about them cannot be understood at all as echoes of original myths.” In place of these discredited views Gunkel (cf also Gressmann, ZATW, 1910, 1 ff) makes of Jacob simply a character in the stories (marvelous, humorous, pathetic and the like) current in ancient Israel, esp. on the lips of the professional story-teller. Whereas much of the material in these stories came to the Hebrews from the Babylonians, Canaanites or Egyptians, Jacob himself is declared to have belonged to the old Heb saga, with its flavor of nomadic desert life and sheep-raising. ‘The original Jacob may be the sly shepherd Jacob, who fools the hunter Esau; another tale, of the deceit of a father-in-law by his son-in-law, was added to it—the more naturally because both are shepherds; a third cycle, about an old man that loves his youngest son, was trans- ferred to this figure, and that youngest son received the name of Joseph at a time when Jacob was identi- fied with Israel’s assumed ancestor ‘Israel.’ Thus our result is, that the most important patriarchs are creations of fiction” (Schriften des AT, 5te Lieferung, 42). It is so obvious that this new attitude toward the patriarchs lends itself to a more sympathetic criticism of the narrative of Gen, that critics who adopt it are at pains to deny any intention on their part of rehabilitating Jacob et al. as historical figures. “Saga,” we are told, “is not capable of preserving through so many cents. a picture” of the real character or deeds of its heroes, even sup- posing that persons bearing these names once actu- ally lived; aud we are reminded of the contrast between the Etzel of saga and the Attila of history, the Dietrich of saga and the Theodoric of history. But as against this we need to note, first, that the long and involved course of development through which, ex hypothest, these stories have passed before reaching their final stage (J, 9th cent. BC; Gunkel, op. cit., 8, 46) involves a very high antiquity for the earlier stages, and thus reduces to a narrow strip of time those “so many cents.” that are sup- posed to separate the actual Jacob from the Jacob of saga (cf Apranam, VII, 4); and second, that the presuppositions as to the origin, nature and value of saga with which this school of criticism operates are, for the most part, only an elaborate statement of the undisputed major premise in a syllogism, of which the minor premise is: the Gen- stories are saga. Against this last proposition, however, there lie many weighty considerations, that are by no means counterbalanced by those resem- blances of a general sort which any student of comparative literature can easily discern (see also Baethgen, op. cit., 158). James Oscar Boyp JACOB (AP32, ya'dkobh; "ToxoB, Takob): (1) The patriarch (see preceding art.). (2) The father of Joseph the husband of Mary (Mt ‘1 15.16). (3) Patronymic denoting the Israelites (Isa 10 21; 14 1; Jer 10 16). JACOB, TESTAMENT OF. See Apocatyprtic LITERATURE. JACOB’S WELL (anyh tod ‘IaxoB, pégé tov Takéb): In Jn 4 3 ff we read that Our Lord “left Judaea, and departed again into Galilee. And he must needs pass through Samaria. So he cometh to a city of Samaria, called Sychar, near to the parcel of ground that Jacob gave to his son Joseph: and Jacob’s well was there.” When Jacob came to Shechem on his return from Paddan- 1. Position aram he encamped “before,’’ i.e. E. of of Well the city, and bought the land on which he had spread his tent (Gen 33 18f). This is doubtless the “portion” (Heb shtkhem) spoken of in Gen 48 22; although there it is said Jacob’s Well. to have been taken with sword and bow from the Amorites. Where the pass of Shechem opens to the E., near the northern edge of the valley, lies the traditional tomb of Joseph. On the other side of the vale, close to the base of Gerizim, is the well universally known as Bir Ya'kiub, “the well of Jacob.” The position meets perfectly the require- ments of the narrative. The main road from the 8. splits a little to the E., one arm leading westward through the pass, the other going more directly to theN. It is probable that these paths follow pretty closely the ancient tracks; and both would be fre- quented in Jesus’ day. Which of them He took we cannot tell; but, in any case, this well lay in the fork between them, and could be approached with equal ease from either. See Sycrar. In the chapter quoted, it is said that Jacob dug the well (ver 12). The OT says nothing of this. With the copious springs at ‘Ain 2. Why ‘Askar and Balatd, one might ask Dug why a well should have been dug here at all. We must remember that in the East, very strict laws have always governed the use of water, esp. when there were large herds to be considered. The purchase of land here may not have secured for Jacob such supplies as he required. There was danger of strife between rival herdsmen. The patriarch, therefore, may have dug the well in the interests of peace, and also to preserve his own independence. Jew, Samaritan, Moslem and Christian agree in associating this well with the patriarch Jacob. This creates a strong presumption in 3. Consen- favor of the tradition: and there is no sus of good reason to doubt its truth. Stand- Tradition ing at the brink of the well, over- i shadowed by the giant bulk of Geri- zim, one feels how naturally it would be spoken of as “this mountain,” For long the well was unprotected, opening among the ruins of a vaulted chamber some feet below the surface of the ground. Major Anderson describes it (Recovery of Jerus, 465) as having “a narrow opening, Just wide enough to allow the body of a 1557 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jacob Jael man to pass through with arms uplifted, and this narrow neck, which is about 4 ft. long, opens into the well itself, which is eylindrically 4. Descrip- shaped, and about 7 ft. 6in.in diameter. tion The mouth and upper part of the well are built of masonry, and the well appears to have been sunk through a mixture of alluvial soil and limestone fragments, till a com- pact bed of mountain limestone was reached, having horizontal strata which could be easily worked; and the interior of the well presents the appear- ance of having been lined throughout with rough ma- sonry.” The depth was doubtless much greater in ancient times; but much rubbish has fallen into it, and now it is not more than 75 ft. deep. It is fed by no spring, nor is the water conducted to it along the surface, as to a cistern. Its supplies depend entirely upon rainfall and percolation. Possibly, therefore, the water may never have approached the brim. The woman says ‘‘the well is deep.” Pégé, “spring,’ does not, therefore, strictly apply to it, but rather “tank” or “reser- voir,” phréar, the word actually used in vs 11f. The modern inhabitants of Nablés highly esteem the “light”? water of the well as compared with the “heavy” or “hard” water of the neighboring springs. It usually lasts till about the end of May; then the well is dry till the return of the rain. Its contents, therefore, differ from the ‘‘living” water of the perennial spring. From the narratives of the pilgrims we learn that at different times churches have been built over the well. The Moslems probably demolished the last of them after the overthrow of the Crusaders in 1187. A description of the ruins with drawings, as they were 30 years ago, is given in PEF, II, 174, ete. A stone found in 1881 may have been the original cover of the well. It measures 3 ft. 9 in.X 2 ft. 7 in.X1 ft. 6 in. The aperture in the center is 13 in. in diameter; and in its sides are grooves worn by the ropes used in drawing up the water (PEFS, 1881, 212 ff). ANG Some years ago the plot of ground containing the well was purchased by the authorities of the Gr church, and it has been surrounded by awall. A chapel has been built over the well, and a large church is being erected beside it. W. Ewine JACUBUS, ja-ki’bus (IdxovBos, Idkoubos; B reads Iarsoiboos): In1 Esd 9 48=“Akkub” in Neh 8 7, a Levite who helped in the exposition of the law. JADA, ja’da (9M, yadha‘, “the knowing one’): Son of Onam and grandson of Jerahmeel by his wife Atarab (1 Ch 2 26.28.32). JADA, ja’dé, ja-da’a (1, yiddd, Kethibh; 72, yadday, Keré AV; but RV IDDO): In Ezr 10 43, one of those who had married foreign wives. RVm has “Jaddai” (=“Edos,” 1 Esd 9 35). See Inno. JADDAI, jad’, jad’4-i. JADDUA, jad’t-a, ja-di’a (572, “known’’): ; (1) One of the “chiefs of the people” who with Nehemiah sealed the covenant, thus signifying their voluntary acceptance of the law and _their solemn promise to submit to its yoke (Neb 10 21 (Heb 22]). (2) Son of Jonathan or Johanan, and great- grandson of Eliashib, the bigh priest in Nehemiah’s time (Neh 12 11.22). He is the last of the high priests mentioned in the OT, and held office during the reign of Darius the Pers, i.e. Darius ITI Codo- 5. Present Condition See Ippo; Japau. yaddiin, mannus, the last king of Persia (336-332 BC), who was overthrown by Alexander the Great. It is doubtless to him that Jos refers in his romantic account of Alexander’s entrance into Jerus (Ant, XI, viii, 4f; vii, 2; viii, 7). James Cricuton JADDUS, jad’us (B, *Ia&Sots, Iaddowvis; A, *Io8- Sovs, Joddotis): AV has ‘‘Addus’=Barzillai (Kzr 2 61; Neh 7 63). J. was removed from the office of the priesthood because he could not prove his right to it after the return to Jerus under Zerub- babel (1 Esd & 38). He is called Barzillai in the OT, because he married Augia, the daughter of Zorzelleus (Barzillai the Gileadite, in the OT). Cf BaRzi.ial. JADON, ja’don (j17", yddhon, perhaps “he will judge” or “‘plead’’): One who helped to rebuild the wall of Jerus in company with the men of Gibeon and of Mizpah (Neh 3 7). He is called the “Mer- onothite,”’ and another Meronothite is referred to in 1 Ch 27 30, but there is no mention of a place Meronoth, Jadon is the name given by Jos (Ant, VIII, viii, 5; ix, 1) to “the man of God” from Judah who confronted Jeroboam as he burned incense at the altar in Bethel, and who was afterward deceived by the lie of the old prophet (1 K 13). Jos may probably have meant Iddo the seer, whose visions concerning Jeroboam (2 Ch 9 29) led to his being identified in Jewish tradition with “the man of God” from Judah. JAMES CRICHTON JAEL, ji’el (> , yatél, “a wild or mountain goat,” as in Ps 104 18; 'IaqA, Jaél): The wife of Heber the Kenite and the slayer of Sisera (Jgs 4 17-22; 6 2-31). Jael emerges from obscurity by this single deed, and by the kindest construction can hardly be said to have reached an enviable fame. The history of this event is clear. For years Jabin the king of Canaan had oppressed Israel. For twenty years the Israelites had been subject to him, and, in largest measure, the instru- ment of their subjugation had been Sisera, the king’s general, the ‘‘man of the iron chariots.”” Deborah, a prophetess of Israel, by her passion for freedom, had roused the tribes of Israel to do battle against Sisera. They defeated him at “‘Taanach by the waters of Megiddo,’’ but Sisera sought in flight to save himself. He came to the “oaks of the wander- ers,’ where the tribe of Heber lived. Here he sougbt, and was probably invited, to take shelter in the tent of Jael (4 17-18). There are two accounts of the subsequent events—one a prose narrative (4 19-22), the other a poetic one, fnund in Deborah’s song of triumph (5 24-27). The two accounts are as nearly in agreement as could be expected, considering their difference in form. It is evident that the tribe of Heber was regarded by both parties to the struggle as being neutral. They were descendants of Jethro, and hence had the confidence of the Israelites. Though they had suffered somewhat at the hands of the Canaanites they had made a formal contract of peace with Jabin. Naturally Sisera could turn to the tents of Heber in Kedesh-naphtali with some confidence. The current laws of hospitality gave an added ele- ment of safety. Whether Jael met Sisera and urged him to enter her tent and rest (4 18), or only in- vited him after his appeal for refuge, the fact remains that he was her guest, was in the sanctuary of her home, and protected by the laws of hospi- tality. She gave him milk to drink, a mantle for covering, and apparently acquiesced in his request that she should stand guard at the tent and deny his presence to any pursuers. When sleep came to the wearied fugitive she took a ‘‘tent-pin, and took a hammer in her hand, and went softly unto him, Jagur Jambri THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1558 and smote the pin into his temples” (ver 21), and having murdered him, goes forth to meet Barak the Israelitish general and claims the credit for her deed. Some critics suggest that Sisera was not asleep when murdered, and thus try to convert Jael’s treachery into strategy. But to kill your guest while he is drinking the milk of hospitality is little less culpable than to murder him while asleep. There is no evidence that Sisera offered Jael any insult or violence, and but little proba- bility that she acted under any spiritual or Divine suggestion. It is really impossible to justify Jael’s act, though it is not impossible to understand it or properly to appreciate Deborah’s approval of the act as found in 6 24. The motive of Jacl may have been a mixed one. She may have been a sympathizer with Israel and with the religion of Israel. But the narrative scarcely warrants the interpretation that she felt herself as one called to render “‘stern justice on an enemy of God” (Exposi- tor’s Bible). Jael was unquestionably prudential. Sisera was in flight and Barak in pursuit. Probably her sympathy was with Barak, but certainly reflec- tion would show her that it would not be wisdom to permit Barak to find Sisera in her tent. She knew, too, that death would be Sisera’s portion should he be captured—therefore she would kill him and thus cement a friendship with the con- queror. As to Deborah’s praise of Jael (5 24), there is no call to think that in her hour of triumph she was either capable of or intending to appraise the moral quality of Jael’s deed. Her country’s enemy was dead and that too at the hand of a woman. The woman who would kill Sisera must be the friend of Israel. Deborah had no question of the propriety of meting out death to a defeated persecutor. Her times were not such as to raise this question. The method of his death mattered little to her, for all the laws of peace were abrogated in the times of war. Therefore Jael was blessed among women by all who loved Israel. Whether Deborah thought her also to be worthy of the blessing of God we may not tell. At any rate there is no need for us to try to justify the treachery of Jael in order to explain the words of Deborah. C. E. Scoenx JAGOR, ja’gur (1737, yaghtr): An unidentified town on the Edomite frontier of Judah in the S. (Josh 15 21). JAH, ja. JAHATH, ja’hath (M7, yahath, perhaps for MAM, yahieh, TM, yahdtheh, “he [God] will snatch up’’): (1) Son of Reaiah, son of Shobal, a descendant of Judah, and father of Ahumai and Lahad, the families of the Zorathites (1 Ch 4 2). (2) A frequent name for a descendant of Levi: (a) Son of Libni, son of Gershom, the eldest son of Levi (1 Ch 6 20.43 [Heb 6 5.28], where “son of Libni’” is omitted). (b) Son of Shimei, son of Gershom (1 Ch 23 10f). (c) One of the “sons” of Shelomoth, a descend- ant of Izhar, son of Kohath, the second son of Levi (1 Ch 24 22). . (d) A descendant of Merari, the third son of Levi, and an overseer in the repairing of the temple in the reign of Josiah (2 Ch 84 12). James CricuTon JAHAZ, jahaz (702, yahag, Isa 15 4; Jer 48 34, MET}, yahdcdh, or NEM, yaheah, Nu 21 23; Dt 2 32; Josh 13 18; 21 36, AV ‘“‘Jahazah”; Jgs 11 20; Jer 48 21; 1 Ch 6 78, ‘“Jahzah”): This is the place where in a great battle Israel over- See Gop, NAMEs OF. whelmed Sihon king of the Amorites, and then took possession of all his territory (Nu 21 23, etc). It is named along with Beth-baal-meon and Kedemoth (Josh 13 18), with Kedemoth (21 37) pointing to a position in the S.E. of the Amorite territory. It was given to Reuben by Moses, and was one of the cities in the portion of that tribe assigned to the Merarite Levites. Mesha (MS, ll. 18 ff) says that the king of Israel dwelt in Jahaz when at war with him. Mesha drove him out, and the city passed into the hands of Moab. It is re- ferred to as a city of Moab in Isa 15 4; Jer 48 21. 34. Cheyne thinks that either Jahaz or Kedemoth must be represented today by the important ruins of Umm er-Resés, about 23 hours N. of Dibon toward the desert (EB, s.v.). No certain identi- fication is possible. W. Ewing JAHAZIAH, ja-ha-zi'a: AV for JanzE1au (q.v.). JAHAZIEL, ja-ha’zi-el (ONIN, yahdzi’ al, “God sees’’): (1) In 1 Ch 12 4 (Heb ver 5), one of David's recruits at Ziklag, a Benjamite or maybe a Judaean. (2) In 1 Ch 16 6, one of two priests appointed by David to sound trumpets before the ark on its journey to Jerus. LXX B, A, read ‘Uzziel.” (3) In 1 Ch 23 19; 24 23, a Levite, “‘son” of Hebron, a Kohathite. Kittel, followmg LXX, reads ‘‘Uzziel.” (4) In 2 Ch 20 14, an Asaphite, son of Zechariah. He encouraged King Jehoshaphat of Judah and his subjects to fight against the Moabite and Ammonite invaders. (5) In Ezr 8 5, an ancestor of one of the families of the Restoration. Read probably ‘‘of the sons of Zattu, Sheconiah the son of J.,” following 1 Esd 8 32 (=Jezelus). Davip Francis Roperrs JAHDAI, ja’dé-t, ja/di (“ITP, yahday, “Ich leads” [?]; Baer reads "3119, yehday): In 1 Ch 2 Whe 47, where six sons of J. are mentioned. ‘The name has been taken as that of another wife or concubine of Caleb; more probably Jahdai is a descendant of Caleb, whose name, in the original connection, has fallen from the text” (Curtis, Ch, 96). JAHDIEL, ja/di-el (ONT, yahdvad, “God gives joy’): In 1 Ch & 24, head of a Manassite family. JAHDO, j4’d6 Car, yahdd, meaning uncer- tain; Kittel suggests “IT?, yahday=Jahdai): In 1 Ch 5 14, a Gileadite. JAHLEEL, ja’lécl (ONSTM, yahl’al, “wait for God!’): In Gen 46 14; Nu 26 26, a “son” (ie. clan) of Zebulun. JAHLEELITES, jalécl-its, THE (NOMAD, ha- yahl° elt, coll. with art.): In Nu 26 26, the descend- ants of the clan of Jahleel. JAHMAI, ja’ma-i, ja’mi (AT, yahmay, per- haps="AIN), yahmeyah, “may Jeh protect!’): In 1 Ch 7 2, head of a clan of Issachar. JAHWEH, yi’we. JAHZAG, ji’za. See Janaz. JAHZEEL, ja’zéel (ONY, yahe’al, “God di- vides,” “apportions”): In Gen 46 24; Nu 26 48; and 23 MSSin1 Ch 7 13; and JAHZIEL (EM, yahdcv él, same meaning ag above): 1 Ch 7 13, a “son” (clan) of Naphtali. See Gon, Namus or. 1559 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jagur Jambri JAHZEELITES, ja’zé-cl-its, THE ("SNYM7T, ha- yah” él7, coll. with art.): In Nu 26 48, descendants of the clan of Jahzeel. JAHZEIAH, ji-zé’ya, ja’zé-ya (T2TM2, yahe- yah, ‘Jeb sees’’): In Ezr 10 15, son of Tikvah, and a contemporary of Ezra. It is disputed whether he and Jonathan opposed or supported Ezra in the matter of prosecuting those who had. married foreign wives = Ezekias, 1 Esd 9 14, or Ezias. See JONATHAN, 9. Two translations of the Heb phrase (nist by Thy, ‘amadh ‘al-zo’th) are given: (1) ‘‘stood over this matter,” ie. supported Ezra; _so AV _(‘‘were employed in this matter’), and so LXX, 1 Esd 9 14, RVm. This is supported by ver 4, ‘‘Let now our princes be appolnted for all the assembly,’’ where the same phrase is found. (2) RV “stood up against this matter,’ so BDB, Gesenius, Bertheau, Stade. oth translations can be supported by ls in Heb. The context is better suited by the former renderlng. Davin Francis Roperts JAHZERAH, ja’zéra, ja-zé’'ra (TVII1, yah- zérah, meaning unknown): In 1 Ch 9 12, an an- ogee of Maasai and apparently =‘‘Ahzai”’ of Neh 1 13. JAHZIEL, ja’zi-el. JAILOR, jal’ér. JAIR, ja’ér: (1) Jair (TR), yar, giving light”): (a) Son, i.e. descendant of Manasseh (Nu 32 41; Dt 314; Josh 18 30; 1K 413; 1 Ch 2 22 f). According to 1 Ch 2 21f he was the son of Segub, son of Hezron, a descendant of Judah, who married the daughter of Machir, son of Manasseh. He was thus descended both from Judah and Manasseh. At the time of the conquest he distin- guished himself by taking the tent-villages Hav- VOTH-JAIR (q.v.). The accounts of his exploit are difficult to harmonize (see ICC on above passages). Some would identify him with the Jair of Jgs 10 3, holding that Manasseh’s settlement in Northern Gilead and Bashan took place, not before Israel's passage of the Jordan, but after the settlement of the tribe onthe W. For a criticism of this view see HGHL, 577, n. He is said to have had 30 See JAHZEEL. See Prison. “he enlightens” or “one (b) One of the judges. sons, who rode on 30 ass colts, and who had as many cities, known as Havvoth-jair (Jgs 10 3.4). One tradition identifies (a) and (6). Others reconcile the two narratives by interpreting the word “son” in a non-literal sense. (c) The father of Mordecai (Est 2 5). In the Apoc (Ad Est 11 2) his name is given as “Jairus”’ (‘Idecpos, Ideiros). (2) Jair (Keré “7, yar, “he arouses”; Ke thibh "97, ya‘ar; a different name from [1] above): The father of Elhanan, the giant-slayer (1_Ch 20 5). In the || passage (2 S 21 19) bis name is given as “Jaare-oregim,” but the text should be corrected to Jair, “oregim’”’ (’Or¢ghim) having crept in from the line below through a copyist’s error. James CRICHTON JAIRITE, j8’Gr-it (IN, ya’iri, “of Jair’): In 2S 20 26, Ira the Jairite is ‘chief minister unto David.” He was a descendant of Jair who was a Manassite (Nu 32 41, etc) and whose territory was in Gilead. LXX Lue and Syr suggest “M!, yattir7, “Jattirite,” i.e. a native of Jattir mentioned in 1 8 30 27 asone of the towns friendly to David when he was in Ziklag. It is not improbable that a native of Jattir would be given such a post by David. See Tra, and cf 2 8 23 38. JAIRUS, ja’i-rus, j4-i’rns (’Ideupos, Ideiros; 1 Esd 6 31; Ad Est 11 2). See Arrus; Jar. JAIRUS, ja'i-rus, j4-i’rus ("Idepos, Ideiros): A tuler in a synagogue near Capernaum whose only daughter, aged about 12 years, was raised from the dead by Jesus (Mt 9 18-26; Mk 5 22-43; Lk 8 41-56). The accounts of the miracle are sub- stantially the same, but vary in detail. According to Mk and Lk the arrival of Jairus in Capernaum fell immediately after the return of Jesus from Gadara, but according to Mt the sequence of events was that Jesus had returned to Capernaum, had called Matthew, had joined the feast of the publi- cans, and had just finished His discourse on fast- ing when Jairus came to Him. Mt and Mk both testify to the great faith of Jairus, who besought of Jesus that He should but lay His hand upon the maid and she should live. According to Mt she was already dead when Jairus came to Capernaum; according to the others she was on the point of death; but all agree as to her death before the arrival of Jesus and His followers at her abode. Mt implies that Jesus alone was present at the actual raising; Mk and Lk state that Peter, James, John and the parents were also there. The healing of the woman with the issue of blood by Jesus on the way is given by all. C Kerr JAKAN, ja’kan (7722", ya‘dkan). aero JAKEH, ja’ke (M27, yakeh, perhaps from Arab. root meaning “carefully religious’; Np, yake’, as if from N"P, 2’): The father of Agur, the author of the sayings recorded in Prov 301. Nothing is known of either Jakeh or Agur. The immediate con- nection in the Heb text of ha-massd’, “the prophecy” or “burden” (AV “even the prophecy,” RV ‘the oracle”) with n’um, “oracle”? (AV “spake,” RV “saith’) is quite exceptional, while the ver is un- intelligible and the text, as the LXX shows, is evi- dently corrupt. The best emendation is that which changes ha-massa’, ‘‘the prophecy,” into ha-massa’t, “the Massaite,’’ or into mimmassda’, “of Massa” (RVm), Massa being the name of the country of an Ishmaelite tribe (cf Gen 25 14; 1 Ch 1 30; Prov 31 1RVm). See Acur. James CricuTon JAKIM, ja’kim (3°P?, yakim, “he [God] lifteth up”; ef Ex1aKim): (1) A Benjamite, a son of Shimei (1 Ch 8 19). (2) A priest, the head of the 12th of the 24 courses into which the priests were divided (1 Ch 24 12). JALAM, ja’lam (Dey, ya‘ldm, according to BDB following LXX ’Iey\ép, Ieglém, in Gen, from Vv by, ‘alam, meaning “‘to conceal”; according to Gunkel, Gen’, 390, from ox, ya@él, ‘“mountain- goat?’; see HPN, 90, n. 5; AV Jaalam): In Gen 36 5.14.18; 1 Ch 1 35, asonof Esau, mentioned as the 2d son by Oholibamah; probably an Edomite clan. See JAAKAN, JALON, ja'lon CAS, yalén, meaning unknown): Jn 1 Ch 4 17, ason of Ezrah, a Judahite. JAMBRES, jam’bréz. See JaNNes ann JaM- BRES. JAMBRI, jam’bri (oi viol "IapBpelv, hoi huiot lambrein; 1 Mace 9 36-41): The sons of Jambri are said to have come out of Medeba (originally Med’ba), a city of the Moabites, and subsequently a possession of the Amorites, and to have carried off John, the brother of Jonathan, who succeeded Judas Maccabaeus as leader of the Jews. The James THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1560 Israelites got possession of the place and assigned it to the tribe of Reuben. No mention is made elsewhere of the Jambri. In Jos (Ant, XIII, i, 2) they are called “sons of Amaraeus.” JAMES, jamz (IdxwBos, Fécdbos): English form of Jacob, and the name of 3 NT men of note: (1) The Son _of Zebedee, one of the Twelve Apostles (6 rod ZeBeSalov, ho tov: Zebedatou): I. In NT.—To the Synoptists alone are we indebted for any account of this James. He was the son of Zebedee and the brother of 1. Family John (Mt 421; Mk119; Lk65 Relations, 10). As the Synoptists generally place etc the name of James before that of John, and allude to the latter as ‘the brother of James,” it is inferred that James was the elder of the two brothers. His mother’s name was probably Salome, the sister of the mother of Jesus (ef Mt 27 56; Mk 15 40; Jn 19 25), but this is disputed by some (cf BRETHREN OF THE LoRD). J. was a fisherman by trade, and worked along with his father and brother (Mt 4 21). According to Lk, these were partners with Simon (5 10), and this is also implied in Mk (1 19). As they owned several boats and employed hired servants (Lk 6 11; Mk 1 20), the establishment they possessed must have beeu considerable. The call to J. to follow Christ (Mt 4 18-22; Mk 1 16-20; Lk 5 1-11) was given by Jesus as He was walking by the sea of Galilee (Mt 4 18). There He saw ‘James the son of Zebedee, and John his brother, in the boat with Zebedee their father, mending their nets; and hecalled them. And they straightway left the boat and their father, and followed him” (Mt 4 21.22). The account of Lk varies in part from those of Mt and Mk, and con- tains the additional detail of the miraculous draught of fishes, at which J. and John also were amazed. This version of Lk is regarded by some as an amalgamation of the earlier accounts with Jn 21 1-8. As the above incident took place after the im- prisonment of John the Baptist, when Jesus had departed into Galilee (Mt 4 12; Mk 8. Proba- 1 14), and as there is no mention of J. tion and among those who received the pre- Ordination liminary call recorded by John (cf Jn 1 35-51; 3 24, and cf ANDREW), it is probable that while Peter and Andrew made the pilgrimage to Bethany, J. and the other partners remained in Galilee to carry on the business of their trade. Yet, on the return of Peter and Andrew, the inquiries of J. must have been eager concerning what they had seen and heard. His mind and imagination became filled with their glowing ac- counts of the newly found ‘‘Lamb of God” (Jn 1 36) and of the preaching of John the Baptist, until he inwardly dedicated his life to Jesus and only awaited an opportunity to declare his allegiance openly. By this is the apparently abrupt nature of the call, as recorded by the Synoptists, to be ex- plained. After a pened of companionship and probationership with his Master, when he is men- tioned as being present at the healing of Simon’s wife’s mother at Capernaum (Mk 1 29-381), he was ordained one of the Twelve Apostles (Mt 10 2; Mk 317; Lk 6 14; Acts 1 13). ; From this time onward he occupied a prominent place among the apostles, and, along with Peter and John, became the special confi- 4, Apostle- dant of Jesus. These three alone of 2. First Call ship the apostles were present at the rais- ing of Jairus’ daughter (Mk 6 37; Lk 8 51), at the Transfiguration (Mt 17 1-8; Mk 9 2-8; Lk 9 28-36), and at the Agony in the Garden of Gethsemane (Mt 26 36-46; Mk 14 32-42). Shortly after the Transfiguration, when Jesus, having “‘stedfastly set his face to go to Jerusa- lem” (Lk 9 51), was passing through Samaria, the ire of J. and John was kindled by the ill reception accorded to Him by the populace (Lk 9 53). They therefore asked of Jesus, ‘Lord, wilt thou that we bid fire to come down from heaven, and con- sume them?” (Lk 9 54). “But he turned, and re- buked them” (ver 55). It was probably this hot- headed impetuosity and fanaticism that won for them the surname “Boanerges, which is, Sons of thunder,” bestowed on them when they were or- dained to the Twelve (Mk 3 17). Yet upon this last occasion, there was some excuse for their action. The impression left by the Transfiguration was still deep upon them, and they felt strongly that their Lord, whom they had lately beheld “in his glory” with “countenance altered” and “glistering raiment,” should be subjected to such tdignities by the Samaritans. Upon the occasion of Jesus’ last journey to Jerus (Mk 10 32), the two brothers gave expression to this presumptuous impetuosity in a more selfish manner (Mk 10 35-45). Presum- ing on their intimacy with Jesus, they made the request of him, “Grant unto us that we may sit, one on thy right hand, and one on thy left hand, in thy glory” (Mk 10 37). In the account of Mt (20 20-28), the words are put in the mouth of their mother. The request drew forth the rebuke of Jesus (Mk 10 38), and moved the ten with indig- nation (Mk 10 40); but by the words of their Lord peace was again restored (Mk 10 42-45). After the arrival of Jesus in Jerus, when He “sat on the mount of Olives over against the temple,” J. was one of the four who put the question to Him concerning the last things (Mk 18 3.4). He was also present when the risen Jesus appeared for the 3d time to the disciples and the miraculous draught of fishes was made at the sea of Tiberias (Jn 21 1-14). J. was the first martyr among the apostles, being slain by King Herod Agrippa I about 44 AD, shortly before Herod’s own death. 5. Death The vehemence and fanaticism which were characteristic of J. had made him to be feared and hated among the Jewish enemies of the Christians, and therefore when ‘Herod the king put forth his hands to afflict certain of the church... . he killed J. the brother of John with the sword” (Acts 12 1.2). Thus did J. fulfil the prophecy of Our Lord that he too should drink of the cup of his Master (Mk 10 39). I. In Apocryphal_Literature.—According to the “Genealogies of the Twelve Apostles’? (cf Budge, Con- tendings of the Apostles, II, 49), ‘‘Zebedee was of the house of Levi, and his wife of the house of Judah. Now, because the father of James loved him greatly he counted him among the family of his father Levi, and similarly because the mother of John loved him greatly, she counted him among the family of her father Judah. And they were surnamed ‘Children of Thunder,’ for they were of both the priestly house and of the royal house.’ The Acts of St. John, a heretical work of the 2d cent., referred to by Clement of Alexandria in his Hypotyposis and also by Eusebius (#2, III, 25), gives an account of the call of J. aud his presence at the Trans- figuration, similar in part to that of the Gospels, but giving fantastic details concerning the supernatural nature of Christ's body, and how its appearances brought confusion to J. and other disciples (cf Hennecke, Hand- buch zu den neutestamentlichen Apokryphen, 423-59). The Acts of St. James in India (cf Budge, II, 295-303) tells of the missionary journey of J. and Peter to India, of the appearance of Christ to them in the form of 2 beautiful young man, of their healing a blind man, and of their imprisonment, miraculous release, and their conversion of the cone According to the Martyrdom of St. James (Budge, II, 304-8), J. preached to the I2 trihes scattered abroad, and persuaded them to give their first-fruits to the church instead of to Herad. The accounts of his trial and death are similar to that in Acts 12 1-2. J. is the patron saint of Spain. The legend of his preaching there, of his death in Judaea, of the trans- 1561 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA James Portalon of his body under the guidauce of angels to tia and of the part that his miraculous appearances played in the history of Spain, is given in Mrs. Jameson’s acred and Legendary Art, I, 230-41. (2) James the son of Alphaeus (6 tod ?AAdalov, ho tot Alphatou; for etymology, etc, of James, see ahove): ne of the Twelve Apostles (Mt 10 3; Mk 3 18; Lk 615; Acts 1138). By Mt and Mk he is coupled with Thaddaeus, and by Lk and Acts with Simon Zclotes. As Matthew or Levi is also called the son of Alphaeus (cf Mt 9 9; Mk 2 14), it is possible that he and James were brothers. According to the Genealogies of the Apostles (cf Budge, Contendings of the Apostles, II, 50), James was of the house of Gad. The Martyrdom of St. James, the son of Alphacus (cf Budge, ib, 264-66) records that James was stoned by the Jews for preaching Christ, and was “buried by the Sanctuary in Jerus.” This James is generally identified with James the Little or the Less, the brother of Joses and son of Mary (Mt 27 56; Mk 16 40). In Jn 19 25 this Mary is called the wife of Cleophas (AV) or Clopas (RV), who is thus in turn identified with Alphaeus. There is evidence in apocryphal lit. of a Simon, a son of Clopas, who was also one of the disciples (cf NaTHANAEL). If this be the same as Simon Ze- lotes, it would explain why he and James (i.e. as being brothers) were coupled together in the apos- tolic lists of Lk and Acts. Some have applied the phrase “his mother’s sister” in Jn 19 25 to Mary the wife of Clopas, instead of to a separate person, and have thus attempted to identify James the son of Alphaeus with James the brother of Our Lord. For a further discussion of the problem, see Bretx- REN OF THE LoRD. (3) James, ‘‘the Lord’s brother” (6 a8eAdds rod Kvplov, ho adelphés tou Kurtou): I. NT References.—This James is mentioned by name only twice in the Gospels, i.e. when, on the visit of Jesus to Nazareth, the country- 1. Inthe men of Our Lord referred in con- Gospels temptuous terms to His earthly kindred, in order to disparage His preaching (Mt 13 55; Mk 6 3). As J. was one of “his brethren,” he was probahly among the group of Christ’s relatives who sought to interview Him during His tour through Galilee with the Twelve (Mt 12 46). By the same reasoning, he accompanied Jesus on His journey to Capernaum (Jn 2 12), and joined in attempting to persuade Him to depart from Galilee for Judaea on the eve of the Feast of Tabernacles (Jn 7 3). At this feast J. was present (7 10), but was at this time a non-heliever in Jesus (cf 7 5, “Even his brethren did not helieve on him’’). Yet the seeds of conversion were being sown within him, for, after the crucifixion, he remained in Jerus with his mother and brethren, 2.Inthe and formed one of that earliest. band Epistles of believers who “with one accord continued stedfastly in prayer” (Acts 1 14). While there, he probably took part in the election of Matthias to the vacant apostleship (Acts 1 15-25). J. was one of the earliest wit- nesses to the resurrection, for, after the risen Lord had manifested Himself to the five hundred, “he was seen of James” (1 Cor 15 7 AV). By this his growing belief and prayerful expectancy received confirmation. About 37 or 38 AD, J., “the Lord’s brother” (Gal 1 19), was still in Jerus, and had an interview there for the first time with Paul, when the latter returned from his 3 years’ sojourn in Damascus to visit Cephas, or Peter (Gal 1 18. 19; cf Acts 9 26). In several other passages the name of J. is coupled with that of Peter. Thus, when Peter escaped from prison (about 44 AD), he gave instructions to those in the house of John Mark that they should immediately inform “James and the brethren” of the manner of his escape (Acts 1217). By the time of the Jerus convention, ie. about 51 AD (cf Gal 2 1), J. had reached the posi- tion of first overseer in the church (cf Acts 16 13. 19). Previous to this date, during Paul’s ministry at Antioch, he had dispatched certain men thither to further the mission, and the teaching of these had caused dissension among the newly converted Christians and their leaders (Acts 15 1.2; Gal 2 12). The conduct of Peter, over whom J. seems to have had considerable influence, was the prin- cipal matter of contention (cf Gal 2 11 ff). How- ever, at the Jerus convention the dispute was ami- cably settled, and the pillars of the church, J., John and Cephas, gave to Paul and Barnabas the right hand of fellowship (Gal 2 9). The speech of J. on this occasion (Acts 15 13-29), his sympathy with the religious needs of the gentile world (ver 17), his desire that formalism should raise no bar- rier to their moral and spiritual advancement (vs 19.20.28.29), and his Jarge-hearted trihutes to the “beloved Barnabas and Paul” (vs 25.26), indicate that J. was a leader in whom the church was blessed, a leader who loved peace more than faction, the spirit more than the law, and who perceived that religious communities with different forms of ob- servance might still live and work together in com- mon allegiance to Christ. Once more (58 AD), J. was head of the council at Jerus when Paul made report of his labors, this time of his 3d missionary journey (Acts 21 17 ff). At this meeting Paul was admonished for exceeding the orders he had received at the first council, in that he had en- deavored to persuade the converted Jews also to neglect. circumcision (Acts 21 21), and was com- manded to join in the vow of purification (Acts 21 23-26). There is no Scriptural account of the death of J. From 1 Cor 9 5 it has been inferred that he was married. This is, however, only a con- jecture, as the passage refers to those who “lead about a sister, a wife” (AV), while, so far as we know, J. remained throughout his life in Jerus. This J. has been regarded as the author of the Ep. of Jas, ‘a servant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ”; cf Jamus, Eristrz or, Also, for details concerning his relationship to Christ, cf BrerarENn or THE Lorn. I. References in Apacryphal Literature.—J. figures in one of the miraculons events recorded in the gnostic “Gospel of the Infancy, by Thomas the Israelite phi- losopher,"’ being cured of a snake-hite by the infant Jesus (cf Hennecke, Handbuch zu den neutestamentlichen Apokryphen, 73). According to the Gospel of the He- brews (cf ib, 11-21), J. had also partaken of the cup of of the Lord, and refused to eat till he had seen the risen Lord. Christ acknowledged this tribute by appearing to J. first. In the Acts of Peter (cf Budge, Contendings of the Apostles, JI, 475), it is stated that “‘three days after the ascension of our Lord into heaven, James, whom our Lord called _his ‘brother in _ the flesh,’ consecrated the Offering and we all drew nigh to partake thereof: and when ten days had passed after the ascension of our Lord, we all assembled in the holy fortress of Zion, and we stood up to say the prayer of sanctification, and we made supplication unto God and hesought Him with humility, and James also entreated Himeconcerning the descent of the Holy Ghost upon the Offering.’ The Preaching of St. James the Just (ef Budge, Ii, 78-81) tells of the appointment of J. to the bishopric of Jerus, of his preaching, bealing of the sick and casting out of devils there. This is confirmed by the evidence of Clement of Alexandria (Kuseh,, H#, II, ue In the Martyrdom of St. James the Just (cf Budge, II, 82-89), it is stated that J., ‘‘the youngest of the sons of Joseph," alienated, by his preaching, Piobsata from her husband Ananus, the governor of _Jerus. Ananus therefore In- flamed the Jews against J., and they hurled bim down from off the pinnacle of the temple. egesippus, quoted by Eusebius (H £, II, 23), and Jos (Ant, XX, ix, 1), testify to the general truth of this. Jt is thus probable that James was martyred about 62 or 63 AD. Besides the ep. which bears his name, J. was also the reputed author of the Protevangelium Jacobi, a work James, Ep. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1562 which originated in the 2d cent. and received later addi- tions (cf Henn, NA, 47-63; also JosperpH, HusBaNnp oF Mary). ie C. M. Kerr JAMES, EPISTLE OF: I. CwaractTrristics OF THE EristLe 1. Jewis 2. Authoritative 3. Practical II. Avtrsor or tae Epistis ItI. Styte or tae Epistie Plainness Good Greek . Vividness . Duadiplosis . Figures of Speech Unlikeness to Paul . Likeness to Jesus IV. Dace or tre Epistite V. History or tae Epistis VI. Messacs or tos EristLte To Our Times 1. To the Pietist 2. To the Sociologist 3. To the Student of the Life and Character of Jesus LitERATURE I. Characteristics of the Epistle-——The Ep. of Jas is the most Jewish writing in the NT. The Gospel according to Mt was written 1. Jewish for the Jews. The Ep. to the He is addressed explicitly to them. The Apocalypse is full of the spirit of the OT. The Ep. of Jude is Jewish too. Yet all of these books have more of the distinctively Christian element in them than we can find in the Ep. of Jas. If we eliminate two or three passages containing references to Christ, the whole epistle might find its place just as properly in the Canon of the OT as in that of the NT, as far as its substance of doctrine and contents is concerned. That could not he said of any other hook in the NT. There is no mention of the in- carnation or of the resurrection, the two funda- mental facts of the Christian faith. The word “sospel’’ does not occur in the ep. There is no sug- gestion that the Messiah has appeared and no presentation of the possibility of redemption through Him. The teaching throughout is that of a lofty morality which aims at the fulfilment of the re- quirements of the Mosaic law. It is not strange therefore that Spitta and others have thought that we have in the Ep. of Jas a treatise written by an unconverted Jew which has been adapted to Chris- tian use by the interpolation of the two phrases containing the name of Christ in 11 and 2 1. Spitta thinks that this can be the only explanation of the fact that we have here an ep. practically ignoring the life and work of Jesus and every dis- tinctively Christian doctrine, and without a trace of any of the great controversies in the early Chris- tian church or any of the specific features of its propaganda. This judgment is a superficial one, and rests upon superficial indications rather than any appreciation of the underlying spirit and prin- ciples of the book. The spirit of Christ is here, and there is no need to label it. The principles of this ep. are the principles of the Sermon on the Mount. There are more ||s to that Sermon in this ep. than can be found anywhere else in the NT in the same space. The ep. represents the idealiza- tion of Jewish legalism under the transforming in- fluence of the Christian motive and life. It is not a theological discussion. It is an ethical appeal. It has to do with the outward life for the most part, and the life it pictures is that of a Jew informed with the spirit of Christ. The spirit is invisible in the ep. as in the individual man. It is the hody which appears and the outward life with which that body has to do. The body of the ep. is Jewish, and the outward life to which it exhorts is that of a profoundly pious Jew. The Jews familiar with the OT would read this ep. and find its language and tone that to which they were accustomed in their sacred books. Jas is evidently written by a NIGP 9 BO Jew for Jews. Itis Jewish in character throughout. This is apparent in the following particulars: (1) The ep. is addressed to the 12 tribes which are of the Dispersion (1 1). The Jews were scattered abroad through the ancient world. From Babylon to Rome, wherever any community of them might be gathered for commercial or social purposes, these exhortations could be carried and read. Probably meeting-place is called “your synagogue” ( : (3) Abraham is mentioned as “our father’ (2 21). (4) God is given the OT name, “the Lord of Sa- baoth” (5 4). (5) The law is not to be spoken against nor judged, but reverently and loyally obeyed. It is a royal law to which every loyal Jew will be subject. It is a law of liberty, to be freely obeyed (2 8-12; 4 11). (6) The sins of the flesh are not inveighed against in the ep., but those sins to which the Jews were more conspicuously liahle, such as the love of money and the distinction which money may bring (2 2-4), worldliness and pride (4 4-6), impatience and murmuring (5 7-11), and other sins of the temper and tongue (3 1-12; 4 11.12). (7) The illustrations of faithfulness and patience and prayer are found inOT characters, in Abraham (2 21), Rahab (2 25), Job (6 11), and Elijah (5 17.18). The whole atmosphere of the ep. is Jewish. The writer of this ep. speaks as one having authority. He is not on his defence, as Paul so often is. There is no trace of apology 2. Authori- in his presentation of the truth. His tative official position must have been recog- _ nized and unquestioned. He is as sure of his standing with his readers as he is of the absoluteness of his message. No OT lawgiver or prophet was more certain that he spoke the word of the Lord. e has the vehemence of Elijah and the assured meekness of Moses. He has been called ‘the Amos of the NT,’’ and there are para- graphs which recall the very expressions used by OS and which are full of the same Hery eloquence and pro- hetic fervor. Both fill their writings with metaphors awn from the sky and the sea, from natural objects and domestic experiences. Both seem to be country. bred aud to be in sympathy with simplicity and poverty. Both inveigh against the luxury and the cruelty of the idle rich, and both abhor the ceremonial and the ritual which are substituted for individual righteousness. Malachi was not the last of the prophets. John the Baptist was not the last prophet of the Old Dispensation. The writer of this ep. stands at the end of that prophetic line, and he is greater than John the Baptist or any who have preceded him because he stands within the borders of the kingdom of Christ. He speaks with authority, as a messenger of God. He belongs to the goodly fellow- ship of the prophets and of the apostles. He has the authority of both. There are 54 imperatives in the 108 verses of this ep. The ep. is interested in conduct more than in creed. It has very little formulated theology, less than any other ep. in the NT; but 3. Practical it insists upon practical morality . throughout. It begins and it closes with an exhortation to patience and prayer. It preaches a gospel of good works, based upon love to God and love to man. It demands liberty, equality, fraternity for all. It enjoins humility and justice and peace. It prescrihes singleness of purpose and stedfastness of soul. It requires ohedience to the law, control of the passions, and control of the tongue. Its ideal is to be found in a good life, characterized by the meekness of wis- dom. The writer of the ep. has caught the spirit of the ancient prophets, but the lessons that he teaches are taken, for the most part, from the Wisdom lit. of the OT and the Apoc. His direct quotations 1563 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA James, Ep. of are from the Pent and the Book of Prov; but it has been estimated that there are 10 allusions to the Book of Prov, 6 to the Book of Job, 5 to the Book of Wisd, and 15 to the Book of Ecelus. This Wis- dom lit. furnishes the staple of his meditation and the substance of his teaching. He has little or nothing to say about the great doctrines of the Christian church. He has much to say ahout the wisdom that cometh down from above and is pure, peaceable, gentile, easy to he entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, without hypocrisy (3 15-17). The whole ep. shows that the author had stored his miud with the rich treasure of the ancient wisdom, and his material, while offered as his own, is both old and uew. The form is largely that of the Wisdom lit. of the Jews. It has more parallels with Jesus the son of Sirach than with any writer of the sacred books. The substance of its exhortation, however, is to be found in the Synoptics and more particularly in the Sermon on the Mount. Its wisdom is the wisdom of Jesus the son of Joseph, who is the Christ. These are the three outstanding characteristics of this ep. In form and on the surface it is the most Jew- ish and least Christian of the writings in the NT, Its Christianity is latent and not apparent. Yet it is the most authoritative in its tone of auy of the epp. in the NT, unless it be those of the apostle John. John must have occupied a position of undisputed primacy in the Christian church after the death of all the other apostles, when he wrote his epp. It is noteworthy thai the writer of this ep. assumes a tone of like authority with that of John. John was the apostle of love, Paul of faith, and Peter of hope. This writer is the apostle of good works, the apostle of the wisdom which manifests itself in peace and PUL, mercy and morality, and in obedience to the royal law, the law of liberty. In its union of Jewish form, authoritative tone, and insistence upon practical morality, the ep. is unique among the NT books. il. Author of the Epistle.—The address of the ep: states that the writer is “James, a servant of od and of the Lord Jesus Christ” (1 1). The tradition of the church has identified this James with the brother of Our Lord. Clement of Alex- andria says that Peter and James and John, who were the three apostles most honored of the Lord, chose James, the Lord’s brother, to be the bishop of Jerus after the Lord’s ascension (Euseb., HEH, II, 1). This tradition agrees well with all the no- tices of James in the NT books. After the death of James the brother of John, Peter was thrown into prison, and having been miraculously released, he asked that the news be sent to James and to the brethren (Acts 12 17). This James is evidently in authority in the church at this time. In the apostolical conference held at Jerus, after Peter and Paul and Barnabas had spoken, this same James sums up the whole discussion, and his de- cision is adopted by the assembly and formulated in a letter which has some very striking |{s in its phraseology to this ep. (Acts 15 6-29). When Paul came to Jerus for the last time he reported his work to James and all the elders present with him (Acts 21 18). In the Ep. to the Gal Paul says that at the time of one of his visits to Jerus he saw none of the apostles save Peter and James the Lord’s brother (Gal 1 18.19). At another visit he re- ceived the right hand of fellowship from James and Cephas and John (Gal 2 9). At a later time cer- tain who came from James to Antioch led Peter into backsliding from his former position of toler- ance of the Gentiles as equals in the Christian church (Gal 2 12). - All of these references would lead us to suppose that James stood in a position of supreme authority in the mother-church at Jerus, the oldest church of Christendom. He presides in the assemblies of the church. He speaks the final and authoritative »word. Peter and Paul defer to him. Paul men- tions his name before that of Peter and John. When he was exalted to this leadership we do not know, but all indications seem to point to the fact that at a very early period James was the recognized executive authority in the chureh at Jerus, which was the church of Pentecost and the church of the apostles. All Jews looked to Jerus as the chief seat of their worship and the central authority of their religion. Al! Christian Jews would look to Jerus as the primitive source of their organization and faith, and the head of the chureh at Jerus would be recognized by them as their chief authority. The anthoritative tone of this ep. comports well with this position of primacy ascribed to James. All tradition agrees in describing James as a Hehrew of the Hebrews, a man of the most rigid and ascetic morality, faithful in his observance of all the ritual regu- Jations of the Jewish faith. Hegesippus tells us that he was holy from his mother’s womb. He drank no wine nor strong drink. He ate no flesh. He alone was per- mitted to enter with the priests into the holy place, and he was found there frequently upon his knees begging forgiveness for the people, and his Imees became hard like those of a camel in consequence of his constantly bending them in his worship of God and asking forgive- uess for the people (Euseb., H#, II, 23). He was called James the Just. All had confidence in his sincerity and integrity, and many were persuaded by him to helieve on the Christ. This Jew, faithful in the observance of all that the Jews held sacred, aud more devoted to the temple-worship than the most pious among them, was a good choice for the head of the Christian church. _The blood of David flowed in his veins. He had all the Jew’s Bode in the special privileges of the chosen race. The ews respected him and the Christians revered him. No man amoug them commanded the esteem of the entire population as much as he. f , os (Ant, XX, ix) tells us that Ananus the high priest had James stoned to death, and that the most equitable of the citizens immediately rose in revolt against such a lawless procedure, and Ananus was deposed after only three months’ rule. This testimony of Jos simply sub- stantiates all that we know from other sources concern- ing the high standing of James in the whole community. Hegesippus says that James was first thrown from a pin- nacle of the temple, and then they stoned_him because he was not killed by the fall, and he was finally beaten over the head with a fuller’s cluh; and then he adds significantly, ‘‘Immediately Vespasian besieged them” (Euseb., HE, II, 23). There would seem to have been quite a widespread conviction among hoth the Christians and the Jews that the afflictions which fell upon the holy city and the chosen people in the following years were in part a visitation because of the great crime of the murder of this just man. We can understand how a man with this reputation and character would write an ep. so Jew- ish in form and substance and so insistent in its demauds for a practical morality as is the Ep. of Jas. Il the characteristics of the ep. seem explicable on the suppo- sition of authorship hy James the brother of the Lord. We accept the church tradition without hesitation. HI, The Style of the Epistle.-—The sentence con- struction is simple and straightforward. It re- minds us of the Eng. of Bunyan and 1. Its DeFoe. There is usually no good Plainness reason for misunderstanding anything James says. He puts histruth plainly, and the words he uses have no hidden or mystical meanings. His thought is transparent as his life. It is somewhat surprising to find that the Gr of the Ep. of Jas is better than that of the other NT writers, with the single exception of 2. Its Good the author of the Ep. to the Hebrews. Greek Of course this may be due to the fact that James had the services of an amanuensis who was a Gr scholar, or that his own MS was revised by such a man; but, although un- expected, it is not impossible that James himself may have been capable of writing such Gr as this. It is not the good Gr of the classics, and it is not the pour and proviucial Gr of Paul. There is more care for iterary form than in the uncouth Fates of the gentile apostle, aud the vocabulary would seem to indicate an acquaintance with the literary as well as the commercial and the conversational Gr. ‘‘Galilee was studded with Gr towns, and it was certainly in the power of any Gali- Jean to gain a knowledge of Gr... .. We may reason- ably eur ose that our author would not have scrupled to avail himself of the opportunities within his reach, 80 as to master the Gr language, and learn something of Gr philosophy. This would be natural, even if we think of James as impelled only by a desire to gain wisdom and James, Ep. of knowledge for himself; but if we think of him also as the principal teacher of the Jewish believers, many of whom were Hellenists, instructed in the wisdom of Alexandria, then the natural bent would take the shape of duty: he would be a student of Gr in order that he might be a more effective instructor to his own people’’ (Mayor, The Ep. of St. James, ccxxxvi). The Gr of the ep. is the studied Gr of one who was not a native to it, but who had famil- iarized himself with its literature. James could have done so and the ep. may be proof that he did. James is never content to talk tn abstractions. He always sets a picture before his own eyes and those of his readers. He has the 3. Its dramatic instinct. He has the secret Vividness of sustained interest. He is not dis- cussing things in general but things in particular. He is an artist and believes in con- crete realities. At the same time he has a touch of poetry in him, and a fine sense of the analogies running through all Nature and all life. The doubting man is like the sea spume (1 6). The rich man fades away in his goings, even as the beauty of the flower falls and perishes (1 11). The syna- gogue scene with its distinction between the rich and the poor is set before us with the clear-cut im- pressiveness of a cameo (2 1-4). The Pecksniffian philanthropist, who seems to think that men can be fed not by bread alone but by the words that proceed magnificently from his mouth, is pilloried here for all time (2 15.16). The untamable tongue that is set on fire of hell is put in the full blaze of its world of iniquity, and the damage it does is shown to be like that of a forest fire (3 1-12). The picture of the wisdom that comes from above with its sevenfold excellences of purity, peaceableness, gentleness, mercy, fruitfulness, impartiality, sin- cerity, is worthy to hang in the gallery of the world’s masterpieces (3 17). The vaunting tradesmen, whose lives are like vanishing vapor, stand there before the eyes of all in Jerus (4 13-16). The rich, whose luxuries he describes even while he denounces their cruelties and prophesies their coming day of slaughter, are the rich who walk the streets of his own city (5 1-6). His short sentences go like shots straight to the mark. We feel the impact and the impress of them. There is an energy behind them and a reality in them that makes them live in our thought. His abrupt questions are like the quick interrogations of a cross-examining lawyer (2 4-7.14.16; 3 11.12; 4 1.4.5.12.14). His prov- erbs have the intensity of the accumulated and compressed wisdom of the ages. They are irredu- cible minimums. They are memorable sayings, trea- sured in the speech of the world ever since his day. Sometimes James adds sentence to sentence with the repetition of some leading word or phrase (1 1-6.19-24; 3 a It ie bhp painful style oF oe who is ~ not altogether at home wit e language 4. Its D _ hich he has chosen as the vehicle of las diplosis thought. It is the method by which a, dis- cussion could, be continued indefinitely. Nothing but the vividness of the imagery and the inten- sity of the thought saves James from fatal monotony in the use of this device. James has a keen eye for illustrations. He is not blind to the beauties and wonders of Nature. He sees what is happening on every hand, 5. Its and he is quick to catch any homi- Figures of letical suggestion it may hold. Does Speech he stand by the seashore? The surge that is driven by the wind and tossed reminds him of the man who is unstable in all his ways, because he has no anchorage of faith, and his convictions are like driftwood on a sea of doubt (1 6). Then he notices that the great ships are tumed about by a small rudder, and he thinks how the tongue is a small member, but it accomplishes great things (3 4.5). Does he walk under the sun- light and rejoice in it as the source of so many good and perfect gifts? He sees in it an image of the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1564 goodness of God that is never eclipsed and never exhausted, unvarying for evermore (117), He uses the natural phenomena of the land in which he lives to make his meaning plain at every turn: the flower of the field that passes away (1 10.11), the forest fire that sweeps the mountain side and like a living torch lights up the whole land (3 5), the sweet and salt springs (8 11), the fig trees and the olive trees aud the vines (3 12), the seed-sowing and the fruit-bearing (3 18), the morning mist immediately lost to view (4 14), the early and the latter rain for which the husbandman waiteth patiently (6 7). : : There is more of the appreciation of Nature in this one short ep. of Jas than in all the epp. of Paul put together. Human life was more interesting to Paul than natural scenery. However, James is interested in human life just as profoundly as Paul. He is constantly endowing inanimate things with living qualities. He represents sin as a harlot, conceiving and bringing forth death (1 15). The word of truth has a like power and conceives and brings forth those who live to God’s praise (1 18). Pleasures are like gay hosts of enemies in a tourna- ment, who deck themselves bravely and ride forth with singing and laughter, but whose mission is to wage war and to kill (4 1.2). The laborers may be dumb in the presence of the rich because of their dependence and their fear, but their wages, fraudu- lently withheld, have a tongue, and cry out to high heaven for vengeance (6 4). What is friendship with the world? It is adultery, James says (4 4). The rust of unjust riches testifies against those who have accumulated them, and then turns upon them and eats their flesh like fire (5 3). James observed the man who glanced at himself in the mirror in the morning, and saw that his face was not clean, and who went away and thought no more about it for that whole day, and he found in him an illus- tration of the one who heard the word and did not do it (1 23.24). The ep. is full of these rhetorical figures, and they prove that James was something of a poet at heart, even as Jesus was. He writes in prose, but there is a marked rhythm in all of his speech. He has an ear for harmony as he has an eye for beauty everywhere. The Pauline epistles hegin with salutations and close with benedictions. They are filled with autobiographical touches and personal messages. one 6. Its Un- of these things appear here. The ep. likeness begins and ends with all abruptness. Ti has an address, but no thanksgiving. to Paul There are no personal messages and no . indications of any intimate personal rela- tionship hetween the author and his readers. They are his ‘‘heloved brethren.’’ He knows their needs and their sins, but he may never have seen their faces or visited their homes. The ep. is more like a prophet’s appeal to a nation than 2 personal letter. Both the substance of the teaching and the method of its presentation remind us of the dis- courses of Jesus. James says less 7. Its Like- about the Master than any other ness to writer in the NT, but his speech is Jesus more like that of the Master than the speech of any one of them. There are at least ten parallels to the Sermon on the Mount in this short ep., and for almost everything that James has to say we can recall some statement of Jesus which might have suggested it. When the parallels fail at any point, we are inclined to suspect that James may be repeating some unrecorded utterance of Our Lord. He seems absolutely faith- ful to his memory of his brother’s teaching. He is the servant of Jesus in all his exhortation and per- suasion. Did the Master shock His disciples’ faith by the. loftiness of the Christian ideal He set before them in His great sermon, ‘Ye therefore shall be perfect, 1565 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA James, Ep. of as your heavenly Father is perfect’? (Mt 5 48)? | remember how Jesus proceeded in His sermon to James sets the same high standard in the very fore- i front of his ep.: ‘Let patience have its perfect work, that ye may be perfect and entire, lacking in nothing” (1.4). Did the Master say, “Ask, and it shall be given you” (Mt 7 7)? James says, ‘If any of you lacketh wisdom, let him ask of God .... 3 and itshall be given him” (1 5). Did the Master add a condition to His sweeping promise to prayer and say, “Whosoever... . shall not doubt in his heart, but shall believe that what he saith cometh to pass; he shall have it” (Mk 11 23)? James hastens to add the same condition, “Let him ask in faith, nothing doubting: for he that doubteth is like the surge of the sea driven by the wind and tossed” (1 6). Did the Master close the great sermon with His parable of the Wise Man and the Foolish Man, saying, ‘Every one that heareth these words of mine, and doeth them, shall be likened unto a wise man. And every one that heareth these words of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man” (Mt 7 24. 26)? James is much concerned about wisdom, and therefore he exhorts his readers, ‘“Be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deluding your own selves’? (1 22). Had the Master declared, “If ye know these things, blessed are ye if ye do them” (Jn 13 17)? James echoes the thought when he says, ‘A doer that worketh, this man shall be blessed in his doing” (1 25). Did the Master say to the disciples, ‘“Blessed are ye poor: for yours is the kingdom of God” (Lk 6 20)? James has the same sympathy with the poor, and he says, ‘“Hearken, my beloved brethren; did not God choose them that are poor as to the world to be rich in faith, and heirs of the kingdom which he promised to them that love him?” (2 5). Did the Master inveigh against the rich, and say, “‘Woe unto you that are rich! for ye have received your consolation. Woe unto you, ye that are full now! for ye shall hunger. Woe unto you, ye that laugh now! for ye shall moum and weep” (Lk 6 24.25)? James bursts forth into the same invective and prophesies the same sad reversal of fortune, ““Conie now, ye rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming upon you” (6 1). ‘Cleanse your hands, ye sin- ners; and purify your hearts, ye doubleminded. Be afflicted, and mourn, and weep: let your laughter be turned to mourning, and your joy to heaviness” (4 8.9). Had Jesus said, “Judge not, that ye be not judged” (Mt 7 1)? James repeats the ex- hortation, “Speak not one against another, brethren. He that... . judgeth his brother ... . judgeth the law: ... . but who art thou that judgest thy neighbor?” (4 11.12). Had Jesus said, “Who- soever shall humble himself shall be exalted’? (Mt 23 12)? Wefind the very words in James, ““Humble yourselves in the sight of the Lord, and he shall exalt you” (4 10). Had Jesus said, “I say unto ou, Swear not at all; neither by the heaven, for it is the throne of God; nor by the earth, for it is the footstool of his feet..... But let your speech be, Yea, yea; Nay, nay: and whatsoever is more than these is of the evil one” (Mt 5 34-37)? Here in James we come upon the exact ||: “But above all things, my brethren, swear not, neither by the heaven, nor by the earth, nor by any other oath; but let your yea be yea, and your nay, nay; that ye fall not under judgment” (6 12). We remember how the Master began the Sermon on the Mount with the declaration that even those who mourned and were persecuted and reviled and reproached were blessed, in spite of all their suffer- ing and trial. Then we notice that James begins his ep. with the same paradoxical putting of the Christian faith, “Count it all joy, my brethren, when ye fall into manifold trials” (1 2ARVm). We set forth the spiritual significance and the assured permanence of the law; and we notice that James treats the law with the same respect and puts upon it the same high value. He calls it “the perfect law” (1 25), “the royal law” (2 8), the “law of liberty” (2 12). We remember what Jesus said about forgiving others in order that we ourselves may be forgiven; and we know where James got his authority for saying, “Judgment is without mercy to him that hath showed no mercy” (2 13). We remember all that the Master said about good trees and corrupt trees being known by their fruits, “Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?” (Mt 7 16-20). Then in the Ep. of Jas we find a like question, ‘Can a fig tree, my brethren, yield olives, or a vine figs?” (3 12). We remember that the Master said, ‘“Know ye that he is nigh, even at the doors” (Mt 24 33). We are not surprised to find the statement here in James, ‘Behold, the judge standeth before the doors’ (6 9). These reminiscences of the sayings of the Master meet us on every page. It may be that there are many more of them than we are able to identify. Their number is sufficiently large, however, to show us that James is steeped in the truths taught by Jesus, and not only their substance but their phraseology constantly reminds us of Him. IV. Date of the Epistle.—There are those who think that the Ep. of Jas is the oldest ep. in the NT. Among those who favor an early date are Mayor, Plumptre, Alford, Stanley, Renan, Weiss, Zahn, Beyschlag, Neander, Schneckenburger, Thiersch, and Dods. The reasons assigned for this conclusion are: (1) the general Judaic tone of the ep., which seems to antedate admission of the Gentiles in any alarming numbers into the church: but since the ep. is addressed only to Jews, why should the Gentiles be mentioned in lt, whatever its date? and (2) the fact that Paul and Peter are sup- posed to have quoted from Jas in their writing; but this matter of quotation is always an uncertain one, and It has been ably argued that the quotation has been the other way about. ‘ Others think that the ep. was written toward the close of James’s life. Among these are Kern, Wie- singer, Schmidt, Briickner, Wordsworth, and Farrar. These argue (1) that the ep. gives evidence of a con- siderable lapse of time in the history of the church, sufficient to allow of a declension from the spiritual fervor of Pentecost and the estahlishmeut of distinctions among the brethren; but any of the sins mentioned in the ep. in all probability could have been found in the church in any decade of its history. (2) James has a position of established authority, and those to whom he writes are not recent converts but members in long standing; but the position of James may have been established from a very early date, and in an encyclical of this sort we could not expect any indication of shorter or longer Membership in the church. Doubtless some of those addressed were recent converts, while others may have been members for many years. (3) There are references to persecutions and trials which fit the later rather than the earlier date; but all that is said on this subject might be suitable in any period of the presidency of James at Jerus. (4) There are indications of a long and disap- pointing delay in the Second Coming of the Lord in the repeated exhortation to patience in waiting for it; but on the other hand James says, ‘‘The coming of the Lord is at hand,” and ‘‘ The judge standeth before the doors”’ (5 7-9). The same passage is cited in proof of a belief that the immediate Sppearance of the Lord was expected, as in the earlicst period of the church, and in proof that there had been a disappointment of this earlier belief and that it had been succeeded by a feeling that there was need of patience in waiting for the coming so long delayed. It seems clear to us that there are no decisive proofs in favor of any definite date for the ep. It must have been written before the martyrdom of James in the year 63 AD, and at some time during his presidency over the church at Jerus; but there is nothing to warrant us in coming to any more definite conclusion than that Davidson, Hilgenfeld, Baur, Zeller, Hausrath, von Soden, Jiilicher, Har- James, Ep. of amin THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1566 nack, Bacon and others date the ep. variously in the post-Pauline period, 69-70 to 140-50 AD. ‘The arguments for any of these dates fall far short of proof, rest largely if not wholly upon conjectures and presuppositions, and of course are inconsistent with any belief in the authorship by James. V. History of the Epistle.—Eusebius classed Jas among those whose authenticity was disputed by some. “James is said to be the author of the first of the so-called Catholic Epp. But it is to be ob- served that it is disputed; at least, not many of the ancients have mentioned it, as is the case likewise with the ep. that bears the name of Jude, which is also one of the seven so-called Catholic Epp. Nevertheless, we know that these also, with the rest, have been read publicly in most churches” (HE, II, 23). Eusebius himself, however, quotes Jas 4 11 as Scripture and Jas 5 13 as spoken by the holy apostle. Personally he does not seem dis- posed to question the genuineness of the ep. There are ||s in phraseology which make it possible that the ep. is quoted in Clement of Rome in the Ist cent., and in Ignatius, Polycarp, Justin Martyr, the Ep. to Diognetus, Irenaeus, and Hermas in the 2d cent. It is omitted in the canonical list of the Muratorian Fragment and was not included in the Old Lat version. Origen seems to be the first writer to quote the ep. explicitly as Scripture and to assert that it was written by James the brother of the Lord. It appears in the Pesh version and seems to have been generally recognized in the East. Cyril of Jerus, Gregory of Nazianzus, Ephraem of Edessa, Didymus of Alexandria, received it as canonical. The 3d Council of Carthage in 397 AD finally settled its status for the Western church, and from that date in both-the East and the West its canonicity was unquestioned until the time of the Reformation. Erasmus and Cajetan revived the old doubts con- cerning it. Luther thought it contradicted Paul and therefore banished it to the appendix of his Bible. “James,” he says, “has aimed to refute those who relied on faith without works, and is too weak for his task in mind, understanding, and words, mutilates the Scriptures, and thus directly contradicts Paul and all Scriptures, seeking to accomplish by enforcing the law what the apostles successfully effect by love. Therefore J will not lace his Ep. in my Bible among the proper leading Foals?! (Werke, XIV, 148). He declared that it was a downright strawy ep., as compared with such as those to the Rom and to the Gal, and it had no real evangelical character. This judgment of Luther is a very hasty and regrettable one. The modern church has refused to accept it, and it is generally conceded now that Paul and James are m perfect agreement with each other, though their presentation of the same truth from opposite points of view brings them into apparent contradiction. Paul says, ‘“By grace have ye been saved through faith .... not of works, that no man should glory” (Eph 2 8.9). “We reckon therefore that a man is justified by faith apart from the works of the law’? (Rom 3 28). James says, ‘Faith, if it have not works, is dead in itself” (2 17). “Ye see that by works a man is justified, and not only by faith” (2 24). With these passages before him Luther said, “Many have toiled to reconcile Paul with James . . . . but to no purpose, for they are contrary, ‘Faith justifies’; ‘Faith does not justify’; J will pledge my life that no one can reconcile those propositions; and if he succeeds he may call me a fool” (Colloquia, II, 202). Jt would be difficult to prove Luther a fool if Paul and James were using these words, faith, works, and justification, in the same sense, or even if each were writing with full consciousness of what the other had written. They both use Abraham for an example, James of justification by works, and Paul of justification by faith. How can that be possible? The faith meant by James is the faith of a dead orthodoxy, an intellectual assent to the dogmas of the church which does not result in any practical righteousness in life, such a faith as the demons have when they believe in the being of God and simply tremble before Him. The faith meant by Paul is intellectual and moral and spiritual, affects the whole man, and leads him into conscious and vital union and communion with God. It is not the faith of demons; itis the faith that redeems. Again, the works meant by Paul are the works of a dead legalism, the works done under a sense of com- pulsion or from a feeling of duty, the works done in ohedience to a law which is a taskmaster, the works of a slave and not of ason. ‘These dead works, he declares, can never give life. The works meant by James are the works of a believer, the fruit of the faith and love born in every believer’s heart and manifest in every believer's life. The possession of faith will insure this evidence in his daily conduct and conversation; and without this evidence the mere profession of faith will not save him. The justifi- cation meant by Paul is the initial justification of the Christian life. No doing of meritorious deeds will make a man worthy of salvation. He comes into the kingdom, not on the basis of merit but on the basis of grace. The sinner is converted not by doing anything, but by believing on the Lord Jesus Christ. He approaches the threshold of the king- dom and he finds that he has no coin that is current there. He cannot buy his way in by good works; he must accept salvation by faith, as the gift of God's free grace. The justification meant by James is the justification of any after-moment in the Christian life, and the final justification before the judgment throne. Good works are inevitable in the Christian life. There can be no assurance of salvation without them. Paul is looking at the root; James is looking at the fruit. Paul is talking about the beginning of the Christian life; James is talking about its con- tinuance and consummation. With Paul, the works he renounces precede faith and are dead works. With James, the faith he denounces is apart from works and is a dead faith. Paul believes in the works of godliness just as much as James. He prays that God may estab- lish the Thessalonians in every good work (2 Thess 217). He writes to the Connthians that ‘‘God is able to make all grace abound unto” them; that they, “having always all sufficiency in everything, may abound unto every good work” (2 Cor 9 8). He declares to the Ephesians that ‘we are his work- manship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God afore prepared that we should walk in them” (Eph 2 10). He makes a formal statement of his faith in Rom: God “will render to every man according to his works: to them that by patience in well-doing seek for glory and honor and incor- ruption, eternal life: but unto them that are fac- tious, and obey not the truth, but obey unrighteous- ness, shall be wrath and indignation, tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that worketh evil, of the Jew first, ‘and also of the Gr; but glory and honor and peace to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gr” (Rom 2 6-10). This is the final justification discussed by James, and it is just as clearly a judgment by works with Paul as with him. On the other hand James believes in saving faith as well as Paul. He begins with the statement that the proving of our faith works patience and brings perfection (1 3.4). He declares that the prayer of faith will bring the coveted wisdom (1 6). He describes the Christian profession as a holding 1567 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA James, Ep. of Jamin “the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory” (2 1). He says that the poor as to the world are rich in faith, and therefore heirs to the kingdom (2 5). He quotes the passage from Gen, “Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned unto him for righteousness” (2 23), and he explicitly asserts that Abraham’s “faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect” (2 22). The faith mentioned in all these passages is the faith of the professing Christian; it is not the faith which the sinner exercises in accepting salvation. James and Paul are at one in declaring that faith and works must go hand in hand in the Christian life, and that in the Christian’s experience both faith without works is dead and works without faith are dead works. They both believe in faith working through love as that. which alone will avail in Christ Jesus (Gal 5 6). Fundamentally they agree. Super- ficially they seem to contradict each other. That is because they are talking about different things and using the same terms with different meanings for those terms in mind. VI. The Message of the Epistle to Our Times.— There are those who talk holiness and are hypo- crites; those who make profession of 1. To the _ perfect love and yet cannot live peace- Pietist ably with their brethren; those who are full of pious phraseology but fail in practical philanthropy. This ep. was written for them. It may not give them much comfort, but it ought to give them much profit. The mys- ticism that contents itself with pious frames and phrases and comes short in actual sacrifice and de- voted service will find its antidote here. The antinomianism that professes great confidence in free grace, but does not recognize the necessity for corresponding purity of life, needs to ponder the practical wisdom of this ep. The quictists who are satisfied to sit and sing themselves away to everlast- ing bliss ought to read this ep. until they catch its bugle note of inspiration to present activity and continuous good deeds. All who are long on theory and short on practice ought to steep themselves in the spirit of James; and since there are such people in every community and in every age, the message of the ep. will never grow old. The sociological problems are to the front today. The old prophets were social reformers, and James is most like them in the NT. Much 2. To the that he says is applicable to present- Sociologist day conditions. He lays down the right principles for practical philan- thropy, and the proper relationships between master and man, and between man and man. If the teach- ings of this ep. were put into practice through- out the church it would mean the revitalization of Christianity. It would prove that the Christian religion was practical and workable, and it would go far to establish the final brotherhood of man in the service of God. The life of Our Lord is the most important life in the history of the race. It will always be a sub- ject of the deepest interest and study. 3. To the Modern research has penetrated every Student of contributory realm for any added light the Life and upon the heredity and the environ- Character ment of Jesus. The people and the of Jesus land, archacology and contemporary history, have been cultivated inten- sively and extensively for any modicum of knowl- edge they might add to our store of information concerning the Christ. We suggest that there is a field here to which sufficient attention has not yet been given. James was the brother of the Lord. His ep. tells us much about himself. On the sup- position that he did not exhort others to be what he would not furnish them an example in being, we read in this ep. his own character writ large. He was like his brother in so many things. As westudy the life and character of James we come to know more about the life and character of Jesus. Jesus and James had the same mother. From her they had a common inheritance. As far as they reproduced their mother’s characteristics they were alike. They had the same home training. As far as the father in that home could succeed in putting the impress of his own personality upon the boys, they would be alike. It is noticeable in this con- nection that Joseph is said in the Gospel to have been “a just man” (Mt 1 19 AV), and that James came to be known through all the early church as James the Just, and that in his ep. he gives this title to his brother, Jesus, when he says of the un- righteous rich of Jerus, ““Ye have condemned and killed the just” man (6 6 AV). Joseph was just, and James was just, and Jesus was just. The brothers were alike, and they were like the father in this respect. The two brothers seem to think alike and talk alike to a most remarkable degree. They represent the same home surroundings and human environment, the same religious training and inherited characteristics. Surely, then, all that we learn concerning James will help us the better to understand Jesus. They are alike in their porvical insight and their prac- tical wisdom. ‘They are both fond of figurative speech, and it seems always natural and unforced. The dis- courses of Jesus are filled with birds and flowers and winds and clouds and all the sights and sounds of rural life in Pal. The writings of James abound in reference to the fleld flowers and the meadow grass and the salt fountains and the burning wind and the early and the latter rain. They are alike in mental attitude and in spiritual alertness. They have much in common in the material equipment of their thought. James was well versed in the apoc lit. May we not reasonably conclude that Jesus was just as familiar with these books as he? James seems to have acquired a comparative mastery of the Gr language and to have had some acquaintance with the Gr philosophy. Would not Jesus have been as well furnished in these lines as he? What was the character of James? All tradition testifies to his personal purity and persistent devotion, commanding the reverence and the respect of all who knew him. As we trace the various elements of his character manifesting themselves in his anxieties and exhortations in this ep., we find rising before us the image of Jesus as well as the portrait of James. He is a single-minded man, stedfast in faith and patient in trials. He is slow to wrath, but very quick to detect any sins of speech and hypocrisy of life. He is full of humility, but ready to champion the cause of the oppressed and the poor. He hates all insincerity and he loves wisdom, and he believes in prayer and prac- tises it in reference to both temporal and spiritual good. He believes in absolute equality in the house of God. He is opposed to anything that will establish any dis- tinctions between brethren in their place of pore: He believes in prec philanthropy. He helieves that the right sort of religion will lead a man to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to kcep himself un- spotted from the world. A pure religion in his estima- tion will mean a pure man. He believes that we ought to practise all that we preach. As we study these characteristics and opinions of the younger brother, does not the image of his and our Elder Brother grow ever clearer before our eyes? Lirerarore.—Works on Introduction: by Zahn, Weiss, Jiilicher, Salmon, Dods, Bacon, Bennett and Adeney; MacClymont, The NT and Its Writers; Farrar, The Messages of the Books, and Early Days of Christianity; Fraser, Lectures on the Bible; Godet, Bib. Studies. Works on the Apostolic Age: | McGiffert, Schaff, Hausrath, Weizsicker. Commentaries: Mayor, aes Beyschiag, Dale, Huther, Plummer, Plumpire, er. Dorremus ALmy Hayes JAMES, PROTEVANGELIUM, pri-té-van-jel’- j-um, OF. See APocRYPHAL GosPELs. JAMIN, ja’min (727, yamin, “right hand”): (1) In Gen 46 10; Ex 6 15; Nu 26 12; 1 Ch 4 24,a “son” (clan) of Simeon. Jaminites Jareb THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1568 (2) In1 Ch 2 27, a Judahite, “son” of Ram and grandson of Jerahmeel. (3) In Neh 8 7, a Levite (?), one of those who “caused the people to understand” the Torah when Ezra enforced it=“Iadinus”’ in 1 Esd 9 48. JAMINITES, j4’min-its CJ%055 , ha-yamini, coll. with art.): In Nu 26 12, descendants of Jamin ((1} above). JAMLECH, jam’lek (T2702, yamlékh, “may he [God] cause to reign”): A “prince” or chief of the tribe of Simeon (1 Ch 4 34). If ver 41 refers to the preceding list, he lived in the time of Hezekiah. JAMNIA, jam’‘ni-a. JAMNITES, jam/’nits ('Iapvirar, Jamnittai): The inhabitants (2 Macc 12 9) of Jamnia, the ancient Jabneel, a town on the northern border of Judah near the sea. Its port and navy were burned by Judas Maccabaeus (loc. cit.). See JABNEEL. JANAI, ja’nd-i, ja’/nt C297, ya‘nay, “he answers”; as to whether final y is the third radical, or may be taken as equivalent to the Divine name Yah, see HPN, 149-51): A chief of a family descended trom Gad (1 Ch 5 12, AV “Jaanai’’). JANGLING, jan’gling (waraodoyla, mataiologia, “vain discourse,” “babbling’’): This word is not found in ARV; once only in AV (1 Tim 16). ARV has ‘‘vain talking,’’ instead of “vain jangling,” and evidently means proud, self-conceited talking against what God has revealed and against God Himself. JANIM, ja’nim (0°)2, yantm; AV Janum): A place in the Hebron uplands named with Eshan and Beth-tappuah (Josh 15 53); unidentified. JANNAI, jan’4-1 (‘Iavval, Jannat, Tisch., Treg., WH;; ’Iavvd, Jannd, TR; AV Janna); An ancestor of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy, the 5th before Joseph, the husband of Mary (Lk 3 24). JANNES, jan’éz, AND JAMBRES, jam’bréz (Iavvias kal 'lapBpas, Jannés kat Iambrés, 2 Tim 3.8): These are the names of two magicians in ancient Egypt, who withstood Moses 1. Egyptian before Pharach. This is the only Magicians place where the names occurin the NT, and they are not mentioned in the OT at all. In Ex 7 11.22 Egyp magicians are spoken of, who were called upon by Pharaoh to oppose Moses and Aaron: ‘Then Pharaoh also called for the wise men and the sorcerers: and they also, the magicians of Egypt, did in like manner with their enchantments.” Jannes and Jambres were evidently two of the persons referred to in this passage. It should be observed that the word tr? here ‘‘magi- cians” occurs also in Gen 41 8 in connection with Pharaoh’s dreams: Pharaoh “sent and called for all the magicians of Egypt, and all the wise men thereof.’ RVm reads for ‘‘magicians,”’ “or sacred scribes.” The Heb word is hartummitm, and means sacred scribes who were skilled in the sacred writing, that is in the hieroglyphics; they were a variety of Egyp priests. J. and J. were doubtless members of one or other of the various classes spoken of in the passages in Ex and Gen, the wise men, the sorcerers, and the magicians or sacred scribes. J. and J., one or both, are also men- 2. Men- tioned hy Pliny (23-79 AD), by Apuleius tioned by (c130AD), bothof whomspeak ot Moses Pliny and and Jannes as famous magicians of an- Others tiquity. The Pythagorean philosopher Numenius (2d cent. AD) speaks of J. and J. as Egyp hierogrammateis, or sacred scribes. There are many curious Jewish traditions regarding J. and J. These traditions, which are found in the ; Tg and elsewhere, are full of contradic- 3. Tradi- tions and impossibilities and anachronisms. tions They are to the effect that J. and J. were 3 sons of Balaam, the soothsayer of Pethor. Notwithstanding this impossibility in the matter of date, they were said to have withstood Moses 40 years pre- viously at the court of Pharaoh, to whom it was also said, they so interpreted a dream of that king, as to foretell the birth of Moses and cause the oppression of the Israelites. They are also said to have become proselytes, and it is added that they left Egypt at the Exodus, among the mixed multitude. They are reported to have instigated Aaron to make the golden calf. The traditions of their death are also given in a varying tash- ion. They were said to have been drowned in the Red Sea, or to have been put to death after the making of the golden calf, or during the slaughter connected with the name of Phinehas. According to Origen (Comm. on Mt 27 8) there was an apocryphal book—not yet rediscovered— 4. Origen’s called “The Book | of J. , and J.” Statem ant Origen’s statement is that in 2 Tim 3 8 Paul is quoting from that book. In the Targumic lit. “Mambres” occurs as a vari- ant reading instead of “Jambres.” It is thought that Jambres is derived from an Aram. 5. Deriva- root, meaning “to oppose,” the parti- tion ciple of which would be Mambres. The meaning of either form is ‘he who opposes.” Jannegis perhaps a corruption of Joannes or [ohannes (John). Joun RUTHERFURD JANNES AND JAMBRES, BOOK OF: An apocryphal work condemned by Pope Gelasius. See preceding art., JANNES AND JAMBRES. JANOAH, ja-nd’a (O19, yandth, “resting- place’): (1) A place named on the eastern boundary of Ephraim (Josh 16 6f; AV “Janohah”). Onom (s.v. “Jano’’) places it in Akrabattine, 12 Rom miles EH. of Neapolis (Vablis). This points definitely to Khirbet Yanan. On a hill near by, the Moslems show the Makam of Neby Nan, the father of Joshua. (2) A town in the uplands of Naphtali, mentioned as having been captured and depopulated by Tiglath- pileser. It is named with Abel-beth-maacah and Kedesh (2 K 15 29). It may be identical with Yanuh, a village about 6 miles E. of Tyre. W. Ewine JANUM, ja’num (Keré D9, yandm, Kethibh D3", yantm). See Jani. JAPHETH, ja‘feth (D2, yepheth; MP7, ya- pheth; *Iape@, Idpheth): This name, in Gen 9 27, seems to he explained by the phrase 1. Ety- “may God make wide [yapht, ARV mologies of “enlarge’’| for Japheth,” where yapht Japheth and Japheth are represented by the same consonants, but with different vowel-points. The root of yapht is pathah, “‘to make wide.” This etymology, however, is not universally accepted, as the word-play is so obvious, and the association of Japheth with Shem (‘dark’’) and Ham (“‘black”) suggests a name on similar lines —either gentilic, or descriptive of race. Japheth has therefore been explained as meaning “fair,” from yaphah, the non-Sem and non-Hamitic races known to the Jews heing all more or less white- skinned. The Tg of Onkelos agrees with the EV, but that of Jonathan has “God shall beautify Japheth,” as though from yaphah. The immediate descendants of J. were seven in number, and are represented by the nations desig- ‘ nated Gomer, Magog, Madai, Javan, 2. His De- Tubel, Mesech, and Tiras; or, rough- scendants ly, the Armenians, Lydians, Medes, _ Greeks, Tibarenians, and Moschians, the last, Tiras, remaining still obscure. ‘The sons 1569 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jaminites Jareb of Gomer (Ashkenaz, Riphath and Togarmah) were all settled in the West Asian tract; while the sons of Javan (Elisah, Tarshish, Kittim and Dodanim or Rodanim) occupied the Mediterranean coast and the adjacent islands. _In Gen 9 27, as in other passages, Japheth occu- pies the 3d place in the enumeration of the sons of Noah, but he is really regarded as the 3. His 2d son, Ham being the youngest. In Place the genealogical table, however (Gen among the 10 1/ff), the descendants of Japheth Sons of are given first, and those of Shem last, Noah in order to set forth Sem affinities at greater length. Though this would seem to indicate that the fair races were the least known to the Jews, it implies that the latter were well disposed toward them, for Japheth was (ulti- mately) to dwell in the tents of Shem, and therefore to take part in Shem’s spiritual privileges. It seems unlikely that the Gr giant-hero, Tapetos, father of Prometheus, who was regarded by the Greeks as the father of the human race, 4, Japheth has any connection with the Heb and Japetos Japheth. The original of the Heb record probably belongs to a date too early to admit borrowing from the Gr, and if the name had been borrowed by the Greeks from the Hebrews, a nearer form might be expected. See SHem; Ham; Taste or Nations. T. G. Pincues JAPHETH, ja’feth (Idhe0, Idpheih): A region mentioned only in Jth 2 25, where no particulars are given which may lead to its identification. Holofernes ‘‘came unto the borders of Japheth, which were toward the south, over against Arabia.’’ JAPHIA, ja-fi’a, jaf’i-a (2"D7, yaphi", perhaps “tall”; cf Arab.; *Lép0a, Jéphtha): (1) King of Lachish, one of the 5 “kings of the Amorites’’ who allied themselves together in an expedition against Gibeon on account of its treaty with the Israelites (Josh 10 3-5). After their discomfiture by Joshua in the battle of Beth-horon (ver 10), “one of the most important in the history of the world” (Stanley), they fled and hid them- selves in the cave at Makkedah (ver 16). As Joshua passed, he was informed of this, but, unwill- ing to delay his pursuit of the fugitives, he ordered great stones to be rolled unto the mouth of the cave, leaving a guard in charge (vs 17f). On the com- pletion of his victory, Joshua returned, to Makkedah and commanded the Israelites to bring forth the imprisoned kings, and summoned the chiefs of his army to plant their feet upon their necks. Then he put them to death; and after he had hung their bodies on 5 trees, he ordered the Israelites in the evening to take them down and cast them into the cave (vs 22-27). (2) (LXX "legids, Iephiés, Ilagué, Iaphié): One of the sons of David who were born to him at Jerus (286 15;1Ch37; 146). James Cricuton JAPHIA, ja-fi’a, jaf’i-a (27°29, yaphia*): A town on the southern boundary of Zebulun named with Chisloth-tabor and Daberath (Josh 19 12). It is represented by the modern Yafd, about 1} miles S.W. of Nazareth, near the foot of the hills. It was one ef the places fortified by Jos (Vita, 45; BJ, I, xx, 6). JAPEHLET, jaf‘let (u25" , yaphlét, “he escapes”’[?]): In1 Ch 7 32.33, a “son” of Heber, an Asherite. JAPHLETI, jaf’lé-ti, jaf-le’ti: AV in Josh 16 3, where Heb is "Q25710, ha-yaphiéi, ‘‘the Japhletites,” RV, a clan said to border on the territory of Joseph, but not mentioned elsewhere. JAPHO, ja’fs: AV and ARVm in Josh 19 46 for Joppa (q.v.). JAR, jar. JARAH, ja’ra (W197, ya'rah, “honey-comb” [?]): A descendant of King Saul (1 Ch 9 42); but LXX B, A, have *la8é, Jadé= 91, ya‘dah, a name found in LXX of 1 Ch 8 36, where MT has MIPIM, yhd‘addah, Jehoaddah. Some Heb MSS have ya‘dah in 9 42, and it should probably be accepted as the correct reading there, for ya‘déh= Jehoaddah y*hi‘addah, linguistically; cf Jonathan and Jehonathan, etc. JAREB, ja’reb, jar’eb (AN, ydrébh, “let him contend’; LXX 'Iapety, Zareim): Is mentioned twice in Hos (6 13; 10 6) as an Assyr 1. Obscurity king who received tribute from Israel. See BARREL. of the We do not, however, know of an Assyr Name king of that name, or of such a place as is indicated by ‘‘the king of Jareb” (6 18 AVm). Sayce (HCM, 417) thinks Jareb may possibly be the earlier name of Sargon who took Samaria in 722 BC, as the passages in which it appears seem to relate to the last struggles of the Northern Kingdom. This conjecture he bases on the probability that the successor of Shalmaneser IV, following the example of other usurpers of the Assyr throne before him, assumed the name of Sar- gon. Those who hold that Hosea’s prophecies are probably not later than 734 BC reject this view. If we take the Heb text in 5 13 asit stands (melekh yarébh), Jareb cannot be regarded as the name of a person, owing to the absence of the 2. Meaning art. before melekh, “king,” which is of the Word always inserted in such a case. It is probably an epithet or nickname applied to the Assyr king, as is suggested by RVm (“a king that should contend’) and AVm (“the king that should plead’’), being derived from the y/ ribh, ‘“‘to strive.” The rendering would then be “King Com- bat,”’ “King Contentious,” indicating Assyria’s general hostility to Israel and the futility of apply- ing for help to that quarter against the will of Jeh. Some suggest that for melekh ydrébh we should read malki rabh (2 being the old nominative termination), or melekh rabh, ‘Great King,” a title frequently ap- plied to Assyr monarchs. Others, following the LXX, would read melekh ram, “High King.” The historical reference, if it be to any recorded incident, may be to the attempt of Menahem, king of Israel in 738 BC, to gain over the 3. Histori- Assyrians by a large subsidy to Pul, cal Ref- who assumed the name of Tiglath- erence pileser (2 K 16 19). In this case, as both Ephraim and Judah are men- tioned in the protasis, we should have to suppose that Ephraim made application on behalf of both kingdoms. If “Judah” be inserted before “sent” to complete the parallel, then the clause would be interpreted of Ahaz, king of Judah, who offered a heavy bribe to Tiglath-pileser to help him to with- stand the combined attack of Rezin of Syria and Pekah of Israel (2 K 16 7f). But perhaps there may be no particular allusions in the two clauses of the apodosis, but only a reference to a general tend- ency on the part of both kingdoms to seek Assyr aid. Cheyne would make a violent change in the verse. He would substitute ‘Israel’ for “Judah” as war- ranted by Hos 12 2, insert ‘Israel’ be- 4, Other fore ‘‘sent,’’ change ’ashshur, ‘‘Assyria,”’ Views into miccur, the North Arabian land of Musri, ‘references to which underlie many passages in the OT,” and for melekh yarebh, he would read melekh ‘érabhi, “king of Arabia.’”’ For other views see JCC. JAMES CRICHTON Jared. Jattir THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1570 JARED, ja’red (TI), yeredh, “‘descent”; pausal form, “i'J}, ya@redh, in Gen 5 15; 1 Ch 1 2, hence EV “Jared” for “Jered”; *Iapé5, Jaréd): In Gen 5 15-20; 1 Ch 1 2; Lk 3 37, son of Mahalaleel and father of Enoch. AV has “Jered” in 1 Ch 1 2. The name is supposed by Budde to denote a degenera- tlon of the human race, the first five generations being righteous, their successors not, except Enoch and Noah. The name has been identified with that of Irad (GJ, ‘iradh), Gen 4.18. See Skinner, Gen, 117, 129, 131, JARESIAH, jar-é-si’a: AV for JAARESHIAE (q.v.). JARHA, jar’ha M72, yarha‘, meaning unknown): An Egyp slave of Shesham, ahout Eli’s time (cf HPN, 235), who married his master’s daughter, and hecame the founder of a house of the Jerahmeelites (1 Ch 2 34 ff). JARIB, ja’rib, jar’ib (A", yaribh, “he contends,” or ‘takes [our] part,”’ or “conducts [our] case’): (1) In 1 Ch 4 24, a “son” (lan) of Simeon= ‘Jachin’’ of Gen 46 10; Ex 6 15; Nu 26 12. (2) In Ezr 8 16, one of the “chief men’ for whom Ezra sent, and dispatched hy him to Casiphia to es ministers for God’s house=“Joribus” (1 Esd 8 44). (3) In Ezr 10 18, a priest who had married a foreign wife=‘“Joribus” (1 Esd 9 19). JARIMOTH, jar’i-moth (‘Iapipdé, Jariméth): 1 Esd 9 28; called “Jeremoth” in Ezr 10 27. JARMUTH, jar’muth (MAT, yarmath): (1) A city of the Canaanites in the Shephelah (Josh 165 35) of Judah whose “‘king,”’ Piram, joined the league of the “five kings’’ against Joshua (Josh 10 3-5), was defeated at Gibeon and slain at Mak- kedah (ver 23). One of the 31 “kings” defeated in Joshua’s campaign (Josh 12 11). In Josh 15 35 it is mentioned in conjunction with Adullam, Socoh and Azekah, and in Neh 11 29 with Zorah, Zanoah and Adullam. Cheyne (ZB) suggests that the ““Maroth” of Mic 1 12 may be a copyist’s error for Jarmuth. In Onom (OS? 182 31; 266 38) mention is made of a ‘Ieppoxds, Iermochés, or Jer- mucha, 10 Rom miles N.E. of Eleutheropolis (Beit Jibrin). The site of this once important place is Khirbet el Yarmik, a ruin, with many old walls and cisterns, on the top of a hill 1,465 ft. above sea- level. It is nearly 2 miles N.W. of Bett Nattij, from which it is visible, and 8} miles, as measured on map, N.N.E. of Bett Jibrin. Cf PEF, III, 128, Sh XVIII. ; (2) A city of Issachar belonging to the ‘children of Gershon, of the families of the Levites’” (Josh 21 29); in the duplicate list in 1 Ch 6 73 we have Ramoth, while in the LXX version of Josh 21 29 we have, in different VSS, Rhemmdth or Ierméth. In Josh 19 21 ‘“Remeth” occurs (in Heb) in the lists of cities of Issachar; in the LXX Rhémmas or Rhamdth. The name was probably “Remeth” or “Ramoth,” but the place has never been identified with any certainty. See Ramora. . E. W. G. MasterMan JAROAH, ja-ré’a (192, ydroh, meaning un- known): A Gadite chief (1 Ch 5 14). But the text is doubtful; see Curtis, Ch, 124. JASAELUS, jas-a-é/lus (Iacdndos, Iasdélos; B, Asdélos; AV Jasael, ja’sa-el [1 Esd 9 30]): Called “Sheal” in Ezr 10 29. JASHAR, ja’shar, jash’ar, BOOK OF (190 “W3, sépher ha-yashar; AV Book of Jasher, m “‘the book of the upright’’): The title of an ancient Heb national song-book (Lit. “book of the righteous one’) from which two quotations are made in the OT: (1) Josh 10 12-14, the command of Joshua to the sun and moon, “Sun, stand thou still upon Gibeon. ...»~ Is not this written in the book of Jashar?” (see BeTu-noron; LXX in this place omits the reference to Jashar); and (2) 2 § 1 18 ff, “the song of the bow,’’ or lament of David over Saul and Jonathan. (3) Some conjecture a third extract in 1 K 8 12, “Then spake Solomon, Jeh hath said that he would dwell in the thick darkness.””? The words of Jeh are quoted by LXX in ver 53 as ‘‘written in the book of the song”’ (en biblié tés odés), and it is pointed out that the words “the song’’ (in Heb “Wi, ha-shir) might easily be a corruption of “WM, ha-yashaér. A similar confusion (“song” for “righteous”’) may explain the fact that the Pesh Syr of Josh has for a title ‘the hook of praises or hymns.” The book evidently was a well-known one, and may have been a gradual collection of religious and national songs. It is conjectured that it may have included the Song of Deborah (Jgs_ 5), and older pieces now found in the Pent (e.g. Gen 423.24; 9 25-27; 27 27-29); this, however, is uncertain. On the curious theories and speculations of the rabbis and others about the book (that it was the Book of the Law, of Gen, etc), with the fantastic reconstructive theory of Dr. Donaldson in his Jas- har, see the full art. in HDB. JAMES ORR JASHEN, ja’shen, jash’en (JU?, ydshén, “asleep” [?]): Seemingly the father of some of David’s thirty valiant men (2 8 23 32f). TheMT reads ‘“Eliahba the Shaalbonite, the sons of Jashen, Jonathan, Shammah the Hararite,....” 1 Ch 11 33f has “‘Eliahha the Shaalbonite, the sons of Hashem the Gizonite, Jonathan the son of Shagee the Hararite ....” Itisclear that ‘sons of” area dittography of the last three consonants of the pre- vious word. LXX, Lucin2 Sand1 Ch has 6 Tovvl, ho Gount, ‘the Gunite,” for “the Gizonite,” perhaps correctly (cf Gen 46 24; Nu 26 48 for “Guni,” “Gunite”’). So 2 8 23 32 may be corrected thus: “Eliahba the Shaalbonite, Jashen the Gunite, Jona- than the son of Shammah the Hararite.” Jashen thus becomes one of the thirty =“‘Hashem”’ of 1 Ch 11 34. Davin Francis Roperts JASHER, ja’shér, jash’ér, BOOK OF: AV for JaSHAR (q.v.), and see BeTH-HoRON, BATTLE oF. JASHOBEAM, ja-shd’bé-am (OP 2? W., yashobh- ‘am, probably “people will return’; see discussion of names compounded with DY, ‘am, in HPN, 41-59): Jashoheam is mentioned in three passages (1 Ch 11 11; 12 6 [Heb 7]; 27 2f), but opinions vary as to the number of persons referred to. In 1 Ch 11 11 he is called ‘the son of a Hachmonite”’ (reference unknown) and “the chief of the three” (“three,’’ the best reading; RV “thirty”; AV, RVm “captains”), mighty men of David. He is said to have slain 300 (800 in 2 8 23 8) at one time, ie. one after another. , Lhe gibbérim, or heroes, numbered 600 and were di- vided into bands of 200 each and subdivided into smaller bands of 20 each, with a captain for each company large and small. Jashobeam had command of the first of the three bands of 200 (see Ewald, HI, III, 140f; Stanley, JC, Il, 78). From the indefiniteness of the descrip- tion, “three of the thirty chief,” he can hardly be re- garded as one of the three mighty men who broke through the ranks of the Philis, and brought water from the well of Bethlehem to David on the hill-fortress of Adullam (1 Ch 11 15-17), and the fact that ‘‘the thirty’ have not yet been meutioned would seem to indicate that this story is not in its proper place. But ‘‘Jashobeam"' here (1 Ch 11 11) is probably an error for ‘‘Ishbaal,’”’ the reading of many of the MSS of the LX_X (HPN, 46, n.). In the || passage (2 S 23 8) he is called “Josheb- basshebeth, a Tahchemonite.” This verse, however, 1571 is probably corrupt (RVm), and the text should be corrected in accordance with Ch to ‘Ishbaal, the Hachmonite.” In 1 Ch 27 2f Jashobeam is said to have been “the son of Zabdiel,” of the family of Perez, and the commander-in-chief of the division of David’s army which did duty the first month. The army consisted of 12 divisions of 24,000 each, each division serving a month in turn. In 1 Ch 12 6 (Heb 7) Jashobeam is mentioned among those who joined David at Ziklag in the time of Saul, and is described as a Korahite, probably one belonging to a family of Judah (cf 2 48). James CricHTon JASHUB, ja’shub, jash’ub (Q1W2, ydshubh; 2°07, yashtbh, in Ch, but Keré 2W7, yadshibh, “he returns’): (1) In Nu 26 24; 1 Ch 7 1, a “son” (clan) of Issachar. Gen 46 13 has incorrectly Iob, but LXX Jashub. (2) In Ezr 10 29, one of those who had married foreign wives= ‘‘Jasubus’ in 1 Esd 9 30. ( (3) In Isa 7 3, part of the name SHmaAR-JASHUB q.v.). JASHUBI-LEHEM, ja-shoo-bi-lé’hem (1307 DMD, ydshubhi-lehem): A name in 1 Ch 4 22 where commentators insert TA, béth, between the two words and translate “[and] returned to Beth- lehem.”’ JASHUBITES, ja’shub-its, jash’ub-its, THE CAWS , ha-ydshubhi, coll. with art.): In Nu 26 24, descendants of JasHus (q.v. [1]). JASIEL, ja’si-cl, jas'i-cl ON WI", ya'dsi’ él, “God is maker,’ 1 Ch 11 47 AV). See JaasrEen. JASON, j2’sun (‘Idcav, Iésdn): A common name among the Hellenizing Jews who used it for Jesus or Joshua, probably connecting it with the Gr vb. idsthai (“to heal”). (1) Son of Eleazar, sent (161 BC) by Judas Maccabaeus with other deputies to Rome “to make a league of amity and confederacy” (1 Mace 8 17; Jos, Ant, XII, x, 6), and perhaps to be identified with (2). (2) The father of Antipater who went as am- bassador of Jonathan to Rome in 144 BC (1 Macc 12 16; 14 22; Ant, XIII, v, 8). (8) Jason of Cyrene, a Jewish historian, who is known only from what is told of him in 2 Mace 2 19-23. 2 Maccis in fact simply an abridgment in one book of the 5 books written by Jason on the Jewish wars of liberation. He must have written after 162 BC, as his books include the wars under Antiochus Eupator. (4) Jason the high priest, second son of Simon II and brother of Onias III. The change of name from Jesus (Jos, Ant, XII, v) was part of the Hel- lenizing policy favored by Antiochus Epiphanes from whom he purchased the high-priesthood by a large bribe, thus excluding his elder brother from the office (2 Macc-4 7-26). He did everything in his power to introduce Gr customs and Gr life among the Jews. He established a gymnasium in Jerus, so that even the priests neglected the altars and the sacrifices, and hastened to be partakers of the “unlawful allowance” in the palaestra. The writer of 2 Macc calls him “that ungodly wretch” and “vile’ Jason. He even sent deputies from Jerus to Tyre to take part in the worship of Her- cules; but what he sent for sacrifices, the deputies expended on the “equipment of galleys.” After 3 years of this Hellenizing work he was supplanted in 172 BC in the favor of Antiochus by Menelaus who gave a large bribe for the high priest’s office. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jared Jattir Jason took refuge with the Ammonites; on hearing that Antiochus was dead he tried with some suc- cess to drive out Menelaus, but ultimately failed (2 Macc 5 5ff). He took refuge with the Am- monites again, and then with Aretas, the Arabian, and finally with the Lacedaemonians, where he hoped for protection ‘‘as being connected by race,” and there “perished miserably in a strange land.” (5) A name mentioned in Acts 17 5-9 and in Rom 16 21. See following article. J. Hurcurson JASON, ja’sun (’Idcwv, Idsén): A Gr name as- sumed by Jews who bore the Heb name Joshua. This name is mentioned twice in the NT. (See also preceding article.) (1) Jason was the host of St. Paul during his stay in Thessalonica, and, during the uproar or- ganized by the Jews, who were moved to jealousy by the success of Paul and Silas, he and several other “brethren’’ were severely handled by the mob. When the mob failed to find Paul and Silas, they dragged Jason and “certain brethren’’ before the politarchs, accusing Jason of treason in receiving into his house those who said ‘There is another king, one Jesus.’ The magistrates, being troubled, took security from them, and let them go. There are various explanations of the purpose of this security. ‘‘By this expression it is most probahly meant that a sum of money was deposited with the magistrates, and that the Christian community of the plas made themselves responsible that no attempt should be made against the supremacy of Rome, and that peace should be maintained in Thessalonica itself'’ (Conybeare and Howson, St. Paul). Ramsay (St. Paul the Traveller) thinks that the security was given to prevent Paul from returning to Thessalonica and that St. Paul refers to this in 1 Thess 2 18. The immediate departure of Paul and Silas seems to show the security was given that the strangers oe leave the city and remain absent (Acts 17 5-9). (2) Jason is one of the companions of St. Paul who unite with him in sending greetings to the Rom Christians (Rom 16 21). He is probably the same person as (1). Paul calls him a kinsman, which means a Jew (cf Rom 9 3; 16 11.21). 8. F. Hunter JASPER, jas’pér, JASPIS, jas’pis. See Sronus, PrReEcIovs. JASUBUS, ja-st’bus (’IdcovBos, Idésoubos): An Israelite who in the time of Ezra had to put away his foreign wife (1 Esd 9 30); called “Jashub” in Ezr 10 29. JATAL, ja’tal (1 Esd 5 28). See Arar. JATHAN, ja’than (‘Ia@dv, Jaihén; &, Nathan): For “Jonathas’” in AV, which is the Lat form for the Heb “Jonathan.” Jonathan was brother of Ananias and “son of that great Sammaias”’ (Tob 6 13). JATHBATH, jath’bath. See Jorparnan. JATHNIEL, jath’ni-el GNIN2, yathni’él, “God lives’): Fourth “son” of Meshelemiah, a Kora- hite (1 Ch 26 2). JATTIR, jat/ér (WN, yottir, and “Wl, yaitir): A town in the hill country of Judah, mentioned in conjunction with Shamir and Socoh (Josh 16 48); one of the cities given to the “children of Aaron the priest”? (Josh 21 14; 1 Ch 6 57). David after his victory over the Amalekites sent a present of the spoil from Ziklag “to them that were in Jattir” (1 § 30 27). It is now Khirbet ‘Aittr, an important ruin, in the extreme 8. of the hill country, 5 miles S.E. of Javan Jedidah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1572 edh Dhartyeh and 20 miles S.E. of Beit Jibrin. This must correspond to the “very large village Jethira’”’ which is mentioned in Onom (119 27; 138 3; 134 24, etc) as 20 miles S.E. of Eleutheropolis (i.e. Beit Jibrin). The site is full of caves. See PEF, III, 408, Sh XXV. E. W. G. MasterMan JAVAN, ja’van (J)? yawdn, meaning unknown): (1) In Gen 10 24=1 Ch 15.7 (LXX ‘Iwvdp, Toudn); Isa 66 19; Ezk 27 13 (LXX ‘EAAds, Hellds, Greece); Dnl 8 21m; 10 20; 112; Zec 9 13; Joel 3 6 (Heb 4 6) (LXX of Eddnves, hoi Héllénes, ie. “Greeks’’), “son” of Japheth, and ‘father’ of Elishah, Tarshish, Kittim, and Rodarim, i.e. Rhodes Gncorrectly ‘““Dodanim” in Gen 10 4). Javan is the Gr Idwr, Id6n, or "Ié(¢)wv, Ié(v)dn, and in Gen and 1 Ch=the Ionian Greeks of Asia Minor, prob- ably here=Cyprus. The reference in Ezk 27 13 (from which that in Isa 66 19 is copied) is the country personified. In Joel the pl. D7), y-wanim, isfound. In Dnl the name is extended to the Greeks generally. Corrohoration of the name is found in Assyr (KB, II, 43). “The Pers Yauna occurs in the same double reference from the time of Darius; cf Aesch. Pers., 176, 562”? (Skinner, Gen, 198). In Egyp the word is said to be y*v¢n-(n)a; in the Am Tab Yivana is mentioned as being im the land of Tyre. See HDB, II, 5526. (2) Place (Ezk 27 19); name wanting in LXX. Davin Francis RoBerts JAVELIN, jav'lin, jav’e-lin. See ARMor; Arms. JAW, jé om, Ichi, “cheek [bone],” ‘jaw [bone]’’), JAWBONE, jo’bon, JAW TEETH: In Job 41 2, RV gives ‘“‘pierce his jaw through with a hook” for AV “bore his jaw through with a thorn” (see Hoox; LeviaTHan). Ps 22 15, “My tongue cleaveth to my jaws [malkéth],”’ is descriptive of the effect of a fever or physical torture, a dryness and a horrible clamminess. Malkohayim is an ancient dual form meaning the two jaws, and, metaphorically, malkoeh indicates that which is caught between the jaws, booty, prey, including captives (Nu 31 11.26.32; Isa 49 24f). Figurative: (1) Of the power of the wicked, with a reference to Divine restraint and discipline: ‘J brake the jaws [Heb “great teeth’’] of the nn- righteous” (Job 29 17; Prov 30 14); ef Ps 58 6, “Break out the great teeth [malia‘oth, “jaw teeth’’] of the young lions, O Jeh.”’ Let the wicked be deprived of their ability for evil; let them at least be disabled from mischief. LX X reads “God shall break,” etc. (Cf Edmund Prys’s Metrical Para- phrase of the Pss, in loc.) “A bridle... . in the jaws of the peoples” (Isa 30 28; cf 2 K 19 28) is descriptive of the ultimate check of the Assyr power at Jerus, “as when a bridle or lasso is thrown upon the jaws of a wild animal when you wish to catch and tame him” (G. A. Smith, fsa, I, 235). Cf Ezk 29 4 (concerning Pharaoh); 38 4 (con- cerning Gog), “I will put hooks in [into] thy jaws.” (2) Of human labor and trials, with a reference to the Divine gentleness: ‘I was to them as they that lift up the yoke on their jaws” (Hos 11 4), or ‘take the yoke off their jaws,’ as the humane driver eased the yoke with his hands or ‘lifted it forward from neck to the jaws’; or it may perhaps refer to the removal of the yoke in the evening, when work is over. Jawbone (Jgs 15 15 ff). See RaMaTH-LEHI. M. O. Evans JAZER, ja’zér (AIV2 or WIY?, yatzér; LXX ‘Tativ, Iazén in A; & ? Tazér): In some cases, ¢.g. Nu 21 32, AV reads “Jaazer.’ ‘This was a city of the Amorites E. of the Jordan taken, along with its towns, by Moses, and occupied by the tribe of Gad (Nu 21 32; 32 35). The country was very fertile, and its spacious pasture-lands attracted the flock- masters of Gad (32 1), the southern horder of whose territory it marked (Josh 18 25). It was assigned to the Merarite Levites (Josh 21 39; 1 Ch 6 81). The place was reached by Joab when_taking the census (2 § 24 5). Inthe 40th year of King David mighty men of valor were found here to whom he intrusted the oversight in Reuben and Gad “for every matter pertaining to God, and for the affairs of the king” (1 Ch 26 32f). The fruitfulness of the country is alluded to in Isa 16 8f; Jer 48 82. (Note: “Sea of’? Jazer in this verse has arisen through accidental repetition of ydm, “sea,’’ from the preceding clause.) The city was taken from the Ammonites hy Judas Maccabaeus, and burned (1 Mace 5 7.8; Ant, XII, viii, 1). Onom places Jazer 10 Rom miles W, of Philadelphia (‘Amm4n), and about 15 miles from Heshbon, where a great stream rises, which flows into the Jordan. Many would identify it with Khirbet Sar, on the 8. of Wady Sir, about 5 miles W. of 'Ammdn. The perennial stream from Wéddy Sir reaches the Jordan by Wéddy el-Kefrein. Cheyne (HB, s.v.) suggests Yajaz on Wady Zorby, a tributary of the Jabhok, with extensive Rom remains. It lies a little way to the E. of ef Jubeihat (‘‘ Jogbehah,"’ Nu 32 35). It is situated, however, to the N. and not to the W. of ‘Amman, where Onom places it. Neither identification is certain. W. Ewine JAZIZ, ja’ziz (T, yaziz, meaning uncertain): The Hagrite who was over David’s flocks (1 Ch 27 30 [Heb 31). JEALOUSY, jel’ns-i (ANP, kin’ah; Cijdos, zélos): Doubtless, the root idea of hoth the Gr and the Heb tr? “jealousy” is “warmth,” “‘heat.’”’ Both are used in a good and a bad sense—to represent right and wrong passion. When jealousy is attributed to God, the word is used in a good sense. The language is, of course, anthropomorphic; and it is based upon the feeling in a hushand of exclusive right in his wife. God is conceived as having wedded Israel to Himself, and as claiming, therefore, exclusive devotion. Dis- loyalty on the part of Israel is represented as adultery, and as provoking God to jealonsy. See, e.g., Dt 32 16.21; 1 K 14 22; Ps 78 58; Ezk 8 3; 16 38.42; 23 25; 36 5; 38 19. When jealousy is attributed to men, the sense is sometimes good, and sometimes bad. In the good sense, it refers to an ardent concern for God’s honor. See, e.g., Nu 26 11 (cc 1 K 1910; 2K 10 16); 2 Cor 11 2 (cf Rom 10 2). In the bad sense, it is fonnd in Acts 7 9; Rom 13 18; 1 Cor 3 3; 2 Cor 12 20; Jas 3 14.16. The “law of jealousy” is given in Nu 5 11-81. It provided that, when a man suspected his wife of conjugal infidelity, an offering should be brought to the priest, and the question of her guilt or inno- cence should be subjected to a test there carefully prescribed. The test was intended to he an appeal to God to decide the question at issue. See ApuL- TERY; SAacRLFICE. E. J. Forrester JEALOUSY, IMAGE OF. See Imacus. JEALOUSY, WATER OF. See Avutrsry, (2). JEARIM, jé’a-rim, jé-4’rim, MOUNT(O™ 9750, har-y‘drim): A mountain by the side of which passed the border of Judah (Josh 15 10). It is mentioned here only, and is identical with CxHEs- ALON (q.V.). ATHERAI, jé-ath’éri (RV), JEATERAI, jé- at/é-ri (AV) CUMS, y’ath*ray, meaning unknown): A descendant of Gershom, ‘“‘son” of Levi (1 Ch 621 {Heb 6]), and probably an ancestor of Asaph (so 1573 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA jarani commentators) ; in_vs 39-43 the corresponding | nouncing it. The Jebusites seem ultimately to name is ‘“Ethni.” The difference in the Heb words | have blended with the Israelitish population. is not great. JAMES ORR JEBERECHIAH, je-ber-é-ki’a (23937, y*bhe- rekhyaha, ‘“Jeh blesses’): The father of the Zech- ariah whom Isaiah (8 2) took as a witness of his prophecy against Syria and Ephraim (¢ 734 BC). JEBUS, jé’bus (0°27, ybhiig; 'TeBods, Ieboris): In Jgs 19 10.11, “Jebus (the same is Jerus)”; 1 Ch 11 4.5, ‘“Jerus (the same is Jebus).” It was once thought that this was the first name of Jerus, as indeed might be suggested by the Bib. references, but it is now known from the Am Tab that Uru- sa-lem was a name used centuries before the time of David (see JERUSALEM, I). It would appear prob- able that the name ‘“Jebus’’ was evolved By the He- brews as an alternate name, and possibly they may have imagined an earlier name, for Jerus from JEBUSITE (q.v), the name of the local tribe who owned the district in the first centuries of Israel’s occupation of Canaan. E. W. G. MasTERMAN JEBUS, jé’bus, JEBUSI, jeb’t-si, JEBUSITE, jeb’fi-zit (0322, y*bhas, “DIA, ha-y*bhiist): ‘“Je- bus” is an old name for Jerus (Jgs 19 10.11; 1 Ch 4.5 || 28 5 6-9, “the same is Jerus’; see pre- ceding article). ‘Jebusi’” (lit. “Jebusite’’) is also used as a name for the city in AV (Josh 18 16.28; cf 16 8); RV correctly renders ‘“‘Jebusite’’ (see JERUSALEM). “Jebusites,’’ for the people (in AV Gen 15 21; Ex 3 8.17, etc), does not occur in Heb in the pl.; hence in RV is always rendered in the sing., “Jebusite.’’ The ‘‘Jebusite” is said in Gen 10 16; 1 Ch 1 14 to be the 3d son of Canaan, ie. of the country of Canaan. Elsewhere he repre- sents a tribe separate from the Canaanites. He stands between Heth and the Amorite (cf Nu 13 29; Josh 11 3; Ezk 16 3.45). In the lists of the peoples inhabiting Pal the “Jebusite’’ is always placed last, a fact indicative, probably, of their smaller number. . ; To what race the Jebusites belonged is doubtful. Their name does not seem Sem, and they do not make their appearance till after the patriarchal period. The original name of Jerus was Bab, Uru-Salim, ‘‘ the city of Salim,” shortened into Salem in Gen 14 18 and in ‘the inscriptions of the Egyp kings Ramses II and Ramses III. In the Am Tab (1400 BC) Jerus is still known as Uru-Salim, and its king bears a Hittite name, implying that it was at the time in the possession of the Hittites. His enemies, however, were closing around him, and one of the tablets shows that the city was eventually captured and its king slain. These enemies would seem to have been the Jebusites, since it is after this peed that the name '‘Jebus’’ makes its appearance for the first time in tbe OT (Jgs 19 10.11). The Jebusite king at the time of the conquest was Adoni-zedek, who met bis death at Beth-horon (Josh 10 1 ff; in ver 5 the word “Amorite’”’ is used in its Bab sense to denote the inhabitants of Canaan generally). The Jebusites were a mountain tribe (Nu 13°29; Josh 11 3). Their capital “Jebus” was taken by the men of Judah and burned with fire (Jgs 1 8), but they regained possession of, and held, the fortress till the time of David (2 8 6 6 ff). When Jerus was taken by David, the lives and property of its Jebusite inhabitants were spared, and they continued to inhabit the temple-hill, David and his followers settling in the new City of David on Mit. Zion (Josh 16 8.63; Jgs 1 21; 19 11). And as Araunah is called “king” (2 8 24 23), we may conclude that their last ruler also had been al- lowed to live. His name is non-Sem, and the vari- ous spellings of it (cf 1 Ch 21 15, ‘Ornan”) indicate that the Heb writers had some difficulty in pro- JECAMIAH, jek-a-mi’a: AV for JeKamian (q.v.). JECHILIAH, jek-i-li’a (717597, ykhilyah). See JECcHOLIAH; Kethibh and 2 Ch 26 3 RV, where Keré is 17399, y*kholyah= “‘Jecoliah” (AV). JECHOLIAH, jek-é-li’a (A70757, yckholyaha; 21 15 2AV="7%D", ykholyah, Keré in 2 Ch 26 3, ‘‘Jeh is able’’ or ‘“Jeh has been able’): The mother of King Uzziah (Azariah) of Judah. RV has “Jecoliah” in 2 K and so AV in 2 Ch. JECHONIAS, jek-d-ni'as (Iexovias, Iechontas, AV; Gr form of “Jechoniah,’”’ RY): (1) The altered form of Jehoiachin (Ad Est 11 4; Bar 1 3.9; Mt 1 11.12). The last but one of the kings of Judah. (2) The son of Zeelus (1 Esd 8 92), called “Shec- aniah’”’ in Kar 10 2. ’ JECOLIAN, jek-é-li’a: 2 K 15 2; 2 Ch 26 3 AV; see JECHILIAH; JECHOLIAH. JECONIAH, jek-é-ni’a. See JEHOIACHIN. JECONIAS, jek-5-ni’as (’Iexovias, Iechontas): (1) One of the chiliarchs who made great gifts of sheep and calves at the Passover of Josiah (1 Esd 1 9); called “Conaniah” in 2 Ch 36 9. (2) One reading makes Jeconias (not Joachaz) son of Josiah in 1 Esd 1 34m. JEDAIAH, jé-da’ya, jé-di’a: (1) (WIT, ydha'yah, ‘Jeb knows’): (a) A priest in Jerus (1 Ch 9 10; 24 7). (b) Ezr 2 36=Neh 7 39, where “children of Jedaiah” are mentioned=“Jeddu” in 1 Esd 6 24. (c) J. is among “‘the priests and the Levites’’ that returned with Zerubbabel (Neh 11 10; 12 6.19). : 32 Another priest of the same name (Neb 12 (e). One of the exiles whom Zechariah was com- manded to send with silver and gold to Jerus. LXX -does not take the word as a proper name (Zec 6 10.14). (2) (WT, y*dhayah, “Teh throws’ [?]): (a) Father of a Simeonite prince (1 Ch 4 37). (b) One of the repairers of the wall of Jerus (Neh 3 10). Davip Francis Roserts JEDDU, jed’oo (*1é80v, Iéddou): Called Jn- DAIAH (q.v. 1, [b]) in canonical books (1 Hsd 5 24). JEDEUS, je-dé’us (‘IeSaios, Iedatos): Called ApalaxH (q.v.) in Ezr 10 29 (1 Esd 9 30). JEDIAEL, jé-di'd-el EXOT, ydhi'a’ él, “God makes known’’[?]): (1) A “son” of Benjamin or probably of Zebu- lun (1 Ch 7 6.10.11). See Curtis, Ch, 145-49, who suggests emending the name to dybmn ,» yahl? él, Jahleel, in agreement with Gen 46 24, (2) One of David’s mighty men (1 Ch 11 45), probably=the Manassite who deserted to David at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 20 [Heb 21)). | (3) A Korahite doorkeeper in David’s reign (1 Ch 26 2). JEDIDAH, jédi'da (TPT), ydhidhah, “be- loved’): Mother of King Josiah of Judah, daughter of Adaiah of Bozkath (2 K 22 1). Jedidiah Jehoash THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1574 JEDIDIAH, jed-i-di’a (MITT, y*dhidh-yah, “the beloved of Jeh’’): The name conferred by God ose Nathan upon Solomon at his birth (2 8 JEDUTHUN, jé-di’thun. _ JEELL, jet (lenAl, Jetzt): Called ‘“Jaalah”’ ee 2 56 and “Jaala’”’ in Neh 7 58 (1 Esd 5 JEELUS, jé-é'lus (’IeqAos, Teélos): Called ‘“Je- hiel” in Ezr 10 2 (1 Esd 8 92). JEEZER, jé-@sér (AV) (AIDR, “tezer; RV IEZER): The name of aclan of Gilead (Nu 26 30), but read sTmaxd , la’abhi'ezer, i.e. “of Abiezer” (cf Josh 17 2). See Anrezer. JEEZERITES, jé-é’zér-its. JEGAR-SAHA-DUTHA, jé-gir-sa-ha-dti’tha, (NMITIDW 739, yghar sahddhitha’; LXX Bovvés paptupel, Bounds marturei, “{the] mound witnesses’): The name given by the Aramaean, Laban, to the “cairn of witness,’ called by Jacob GaLEEp (q.v.) (Gen 31 47). The rest of the second part of this name appears again in Job 16 19, where "U0, sahddhi, should be rendered with RV, “he that voucheth for me,” i.e. “my witness.” JEHALLELEL, jé-bal’élel (RV), JEHALELEEL, j&haleléel (AV) OND, yhallel’él, “he shall praise God’’): (1) A Judahite (1 Ch 4 16). i A Levite, a descendant of Merari (2 Ch 29 See AsaPH. See ABIEZER. IZ JEHDEIAHN, je-dé’ya, ja’dé-ya GNM), yehds- yahu, “may Jeh give joy!’’): (1) A Levite, head of the family of Shubael (1 Ch 24 20). (2) An officer of David “over the asses” (1 Ch 27 30). JEHEZKEL, jéhez’kel (RV), JEHEZEKEL, jé-hez’é-kel (AV) (RPI, yhezke’l, “God strength- ens’’) . (1) A priest of David’s time (1 Ch 24 16). (2) Jehezkel in Ezk 13 AVm, for EzExreL (q.v.). JEHIAH, jé&hi’a (3M, yhiyah, “may Jeh live!”’): Keeper of the ark with Obed-edom (1 Ch 15 24), but in ver 18 the name is D8°P7, y*?al, Ie1ex (q.v.) JEHIEL, jé-hi’el ONT), yhal, “may God live!’’): (1) a Levite, one of the musicians appointed to play upon instruments at the bringing up of the ark by David (1 Ch 15 18.20; 16 5); Jehieli, jé-hi’é-1i Cbs, yhi ai): A patronymic of this name (1 Ch 26 21.22), but Curtis (Ch, 286-87) reads “‘Jehiel [ver 21] and his brethren Zetham and Joel”’ (ver 22); cf 23 8, where the three seem to be brothers. See (2) above. (2) A Gershonite, head of a Levitical house (1 Ch 23 8; 29 8). (3) Son of a Hachmonite; he was “with the king’s [David’s] sons,” i.e. their tutor (1_Ch 27 32). (4) A son of King Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 21 2). (5) In 2 Ch 29 14 AV, where Keré is 2837, yha’él, RV “Jehuel,” a Hermanite Levite who took part in cleansing the temple in Hezekiah’s reign. (6) An overseer in Hezekiah’s reign (2 Ch 31 18). (7) One of the three “rulers’’ of the temple in Hezekiah’s reign (2 Ch 35 8). L (8) Father of Obadiah, a returned exile (Ear 8 9)=‘‘Jezelus” of 1 Esd 8 35. i F (9) Father of Shecaniah (Ezr 10 2)=“Jeelus” of 1 Esd 8 92. He was a “son” of Elam, and so probably the same as “Jehiel’’ in Ezr 10 26, one of those who had married foreign wives = “‘Jezrielus” of 1 Esd 9 27. (10) A “son” of Harim, and one of those who had married foreign wives (Ezr 10 21) =‘‘Hiereel” of 1 Esd 9 21. (41) AV in 1 Ch 9 35=Jermn (q.v. [2]). (12) AV in 1 Ch 11 44=Jerer (q.v. [8)). Davip Francis Rosperts JEHIZKIAH, jé-hiz-ki’a (*03PTN, ychizktyahu, “Jeh strengthens’): One of the Ephraimite chiefs (2 Ch 28 12) who with Obed are said to have op- posed the enslavement of the Judahites taken cap- tive by Pekah in his war against Ahaz (c 734 BC). JEHOADDABH, jé-hé-ad’a (RV), JEHOADAH, j&ho’a-da (AV) (AVM, yho'addah, “‘Jeh has de- posed” or “numbered’”’): A descendant of King Saul (1 Ch 8 36), called “Jarah”’ in 1 Ch 9 42, where LXX has "Iadd, Jadd=V397, ya'dah. See Japan. JEHOADDAN, jé-hé-ad’an (JI7WM , yhd‘addan, meaning unknown): In 2 Ch 25 1; and Keré, AV in 2 K 14 2, where Kethibh aud RV are “Jehoad- din? (JY, yhd'addin), the mother of King Amaziah of Judah. JEHOADDIN, jé-hé-ad’in. See JeEHoappan. JEHOAHAZ, jé-bhd’a-haz, j6-hé-a’haz (INV, yho’ahdz, “Jeh has grasped”; ’Iwaxds, Jdachds; 2K 13 1-9): (1) Son of Jehu, and 11th king of Israel. He is stated to have reigned 17 years. Jos was already aware (Ant, IX, viii, 5) of the chrono- logical difficulty involved in the cross-references in vs 1 and 10, the former of which states that 1. Chro- Jehoahaz began to reign in the 23d year 1 of of Jehoash of Jerus, and reigned 17 years; nology while the latter gives him a successor in Reign Jehoash’s 37th year, or 14 years later. Jos alters the figure of ver 1 to 21; and, to meet the same difficulty, the LXX (Aldine ed) changes 37 to 39 in ver 10. The difficulty may be met by sup- posing that Jehoahaz was associated with his father Jehu for several years in the government of the country hefore the death of the latter, and that these years were counted as a part of his reign. This view has in its favor the fact that Jehu was an old man when he died, and may have been incapacitated for the full discharge of ad- ministrative duties before the end came. The accession of Jehoahaz as sole ruler may be dated about 825 BC. When Jehoahaz came to the throne, he found a discouraged and humiliated people. The territory beyond Jordan, embracing 23 tribes, 2. Low or one-fourth of the whole kingdom, Condition had been lost in warfare with the of the Syrian king, Hazael (2 K 10 32.33). Kingdom A heavy annual subsidy was still pay- able to Assyria, as by his father Jehu. The neighboring kingdom of Judah was still un- friendly to any member of the house of Jehu. Elisha the prophet, though then in the zenith of his influence, does not seem to have done anything toward the stability of Jehu’s throne. Specially did Israel suffer during this reign from the eontinuance of the hostility of Damascus (2 K 13 3.4.22). Hazael had been selected, 3. Israel together with Jehu, as the instrument and Syria by which the idolatry of Israel was to be punished (1 K 19 16). Later the instruments of vengeance fell out. On Jehu’s death, the pressure from the east on Hazael was 1575 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jedidiah Jehoash greatly relieved. The great conqueror, Shalma- neser II, had died, and his son Samsi-Ramman IV had to meet a revolt within the empire, and was busy with expeditions against Babylon and Media during the 12 years of his reign (824-812 BC). Dur- ing these years, the kingdoms of the seaboard of the Mediterranean were unmolested. They coincide with the years of Jehoahaz, and explain the freedom which Hazael had to harass the dominions of that king. Particulars of the several campaigns in which the troops of Damascus harassed Israel are not given. The life of Elisha extended through the 3 4, Th reigns of Jehoram (12 years), Jehu (28 » 2ne years) and Jehoahaz (12 or 13 years), Elisha into the reign of Joash (2 K 18 14). ft Episodes is therefore prohahle that in the memora-~ bilia of his life in 2 K 4-8, now one and now ancther king of Israel should figure, and that some of the episodes there recorded belong to the reign of Jehoahaz. There are evidences that strict chronological order is not observed in the narrative of Elisha, e.g. Gehazi appears in waiting on the king of jsrael in 8 5, after the account of his leprosy in 5 27. The terrible siege of Samaria in ch 7 is generally referred to the reign of Jehoram; hut no atmosphere is so suitable to it as that of the reign of Jehoahaz, in one of the later years of whom it may have occurred. The statement in 13 7 that ‘the king of Syria destroyed them, and made them like the dust in threshing,” and the statistics there given of the depleted army of Jehoahaz, would ccrre- spond with the state of things that siege implies. In this case the Ben-hadad of 2 K 6 24 would he the son of Hazael (13 3). Jehoahaz, like bis father, maintained the calf- worship in Bethel and Dan, and revived also the cult of the Asherah, a form of Canaan- 5. His itish_ idolatry introduced by Ahab Idolatry (1 K 16 33). It centered round a sacred tree or pole, and was probably connected with phallic worship (cf 1 K 16 18, where Maacah, mother of Asa, is said to have “made an abominable image for an Asherah” in Jerus). The elose of this dark reign, however, is bright- ened by a partial reform. In his distress, we are told, “Jehoahaz besought Jeh, and 6. Partial Jeb hearkened unto him” (2 K 13 4). Reform If the siege of Samaria in ch 6 belongs to his reign, we might conneet this with his wearing ‘‘sackeloth within upon his flesh” (ver 30)—an act of humiliation only accidentally discovered by the rending of his garments. Ver 5 goes on to say that “Jeh gave Israel a saviour, so that they went out from under the hand of the Syrians.” The “saviour” may refer to Joash, under whom the deliverance began (13 25), or to Jeroboam Il, of whom it is declared that by him God “saved” Israel (14 27). Others take it to refer to Ramman-nirart III, king of Assyria, whose conquest of Damascus made possible the victories of these kings. See JEHoasH. W. Saaw CaupEecorr (2) A king of Judah, son and successor of Josiah; reigned three months and was deposed, 608 BC. Called “Shallum” in Jer 22 11; ef 1 Ch 3 15. The story of his reign is told in 2 K 23 30-35, and in a. briefer account in 2 Ch 36 1-3. The historian of 2 K characterizes his reign as evil; 2 Ch passes no verdict upon him. On the death of his father in battle, which threw the realm into confusion, he, though a younger son (cf 2 K 23 31 with 23 36; 1 Ch 315 makes him the fourth son of Josiah), was raised to the throne by “the people of the land,” the same who had secured the accession to his father; see under Josrau. Perhaps, as upholders of the stcrling old Davidic idea, which his father had carried out so well, they saw in him a better hope for its integrity than in his elder brother Jehoiakim (Eliakim), whose tyrannical tendencies may already have been too apparent. The prophets also seem to have set store by him, if we may judge by the sympathetic mentions of him in Jer 22 11 and Ezk 19 3.4. His career was too short, however, to make any marked impression on the history of Judah. Josiah’s ill-advised meddling with the designs of Pharaoh-necoh (see under Jostan) had had, in fact, the ill effect of plunging Judah again into the vortex of oriental politics, from which it had long been comparatively free. The Egyp king imme- diately concluded that so presumptuous a state must not be left in his rear unpunished. Arrived at Riblah on his Mesopotamian expedition, he put Jchoahaz in bonds, and later carried him prisoner to Egypt, where he died; raised his brother Je- hoiakim to the throne as a vassal king; and im- posed on the realm a fine of a hundred talents of silver and a talent of gold. So the fortunes of the Judaean state, so soon after Josiah’s good reign, began their melancholy change for the worse. Joun Franxuin Genune (3) In 2 Ch 2117; 265 23=Anazzan, king of Judah (q.v.) 2 K 8 25 ff; 2 Ch 22 1 ff). JEHOASH, jé-ho’ash, the uncontracted form of JOASH (WNIT, yhd’ash, UN, yo'ash, “Jeh hath bestowed”; ef 2 K 11 2.21; 12 1 19; 2 Ch 24 1, etc; "Iwas, TGds): (13 The 9th king of Judah; son of Ahaziah and Zibiah, a woman of Beersheba (2 K 11-12; 2 Ch 22 10—24 27). Jehoash was 7 years old at his accession, and reigned 40 years. His accession may be placed in 852 BC. Some inelude in the years of his reign the 6 years of Athaliah’s usur- pation. When, on Athaliah’s usurpation of the throne, she massacred the royal princes, J. was saved from her unnatural fury by the action of his 1. His aunt Jehosheba, the wife of Jehoiada, Early the high priest (2 K 111.2; 2 Ch Preser- 22 10.11). During 6 years he was con- vation cealed in the house of Jehoiada, which adjoined the temple; hence is said to have been “hid in the house of Jeh”—a perfectly legitimate use of the phrase according to the idiom of the time. During these formative years of J.’s early life, he was under the moral and spiritual influence of Jehoiada—a man of lofty character 2. The and devout spirit. At the end of 6 Counter- _—s years, a counter-revolution was plan- Revolution ned by Jehoiada, and was successfully carried out on a Sabbath, at one of the great festivals. The accounts of this revolution in K and Ch supplement each other, but though the Levitical interest of the Chronicler is apparent in the details to which he gives prominence, the narratives do not necessarily collide, as has often been represented. The event was prepared for by the young king being privately exhibited to the 5 captains of the ‘executioners’ (RV “‘Carites’’) and “runners’ (2 K 114; 2 Ch 23 1). These en- tered into covenant with Jehoiada, and, by his direction, summoned the Levites from Judah (2 Ch 23 2), and made the necessary arrangements fer guarding the palace and the person of the king. In these dispositions both the royal body-guard and the Levites seem to have had their parts. J. next appears standing on a platform in front of the temple, the law of the testimony in his hand and the crown upon his head. Amid acclamations, he igs anointed king. Athaliah, rushing on the scene with cries of ‘‘treason” (see ATHALIAH), is driven forth and slain. A new covenant is made between Jeh and the king and people, and, at the conclusion of the ceremony, a great procession is formed, and the king is conducted with honor to the royal house (2 K 11 19; 2 Ch 23 20), Thus auspiciously did the new reign begin. Jehoash Jehohanan THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1576 Grown to manhood (cf the age of his son Amaziah, 2 K 14 25), J. married two wives, and by them had sons and daughters (2 Ch 24 3). 3. Repair His great concern at this period, how- of the ever, was the repair of the temple— Temple the “house of Jeh’’—which in the : reign of Athaliah had been broken up in many places, plundered, and allowed to become dilapidated (2 K 12 5.12; 2 Ch 24 7). To meet the expense of its restoration, the king gave orders that all monies coming into the temple, whether dues or voluntary offerings, should be appropriated for this purpose (2 K 12 4), and from the account in Ch would seem to have con- templated a revival of the half-shekel tax appointed by Moses for the construction of the tahernacle (2 Ch 24 5.6; cf Ex 30 11-16; 38 25). To en- force this impost would have involved a new census, and the memory of the judgments which attended David’s former attempt of this kind may well have had a deterrent effect on Jehoiada and the priest- hood. “The Levites hastened it not,” it is declared (2 Ch 24 5). Time passed, and in the 23d year of the king’s reign (his 30th year), it was found that the breaches of the house had still not been repaired. 4. A New A new plan was adopted. It was Expedient arranged that a chest with a hole bored in its lid should be set up on the right side of the altar in the temple-court, under the care of two persons, one the king’s scribe, the other an officer of the high priest, and that the people should be invited to bring voluntarily their half-shekel tax or other offerings, and put it in this box (2 K 12 9; 2 Ch 24 8.9). Gifts from wor- shippers who did not visit the altar were received by priests at the gate, and brought to the box. The expedient proved brilliantly successful. The people cheerfully responded, large sums were con- tributed, the money was honestly expended, and the temple was thoroughly renovated. There re- mained even a surplus, with which gold and silver vessels were made, or replaced, for the use of the temple. Jehoiada’s long and useful life seems to have closed soon after. With the death of this good man, it soon became evident that the strongest pillar of the state was removed. It is recorded that ‘‘J. did 5. The that which was right in the eyes of King’s De- Jeb all his days wherein Jehoiada the clension riest instructed him’ (2 K 12 2), ut after Jehoiada had been honor- ably interred in the sepulchers of the kings (2 Ch 24 16), a sad declension became manifest. The princes of Judah came to J. and expressed their wish for greater freedom in worship than had been permitted them by the aged priest. With weak complaisance, the king ‘‘hearkened unto them” (ver 17). Soon idols and Asherahs began to be set up in Jerns and the other cities of Judah. Unnamed prophets raised their protests in vain. The high priest Zechariah, a worthy son of Jehoiada, testi- fied in his place that as the nation had forsaken Jeh, he also would forsake it, and that disaster would follow (ver 20). Wrathful at the rebuke, the king gave orders that Zechariah should be stoned with stones in the temple-court (ver 21). This was done, and the act of sacrilege, murder, and ingrati- tude was perpetrated to which Jesus seems to refer in Mt 23 35; Lk 11 51 (“son of Barachiah” in the former passage is probably an early copyist’s gloss through confusion with the prophet Zechariah). The high priest’s dying words, “Jeh look upon it, and require it,” soon found an answer. Within a year of Zechariah’s death, the armies of Hazael, the Syrian king, were ravaging and laying waste Judah. The city of Gath fell, and a hattle, the place of which is not given, placed Jerns at the mercy of the foe (2 K 12 17; 2 Ch 24 23.24). To save the capital from the indignity of 6. Calami- foreign occupation, J., then in dire ties and sickness, collected all the hallowed Assassi- things of the temple, and all the gold nation of the palace, and sent them to Ha- zael (2 K 12 17.18). This failure of his policy, in both church and state, excited such popular feeling against J., that a conspiracy was formed to assassinate him. His physical suffer- ings won for him no sympathy, and two of his own officers slew him, while asleep, in the fortress of Millo, where he was paying a visit (ver 20). He was buried in the city of David, but not in the royal sepulchers, as Jehoiada had been (2 Ch 24 25). J. is mentioned as the father of Amaziah (2 K 14 1; 2 Ch 26 25). His contemporaries in Israel were Jehoahaz (2 K 18 1) and Jehoash (2 K 13 10). (2) The son of Jehoahaz, and 12th king of Israel (2 K 13 10-25; 14 8-16; 2 Ch 25 17-24). Je- hoash reigned for 16 years. His acces- 1. Accession sion may be placed in 813 BC. There and Reign were almost simultaneous changes in the sovereignties of Judah and of As- syria—Amaziah succeeding to the throne of Judah in the 2d year of J., and Ramman-nirari III coming to the throne of Assyria in 811 BC—which had important effects on the history of Israel in this reign. During the three previous reigns, for half a cen- tury, Elisha had been the prophet of Jeh to Israel. He was now aged and on his deathbed. 2. Elisha Hearing of his illness, the young king and came to Dothan, where the prophet Jehoash was, and had a touching interview with him. His affectionate exclamation, “My father, my father, the chariots of Israel and the horsemen thereof”? (2 K 13 14; ef 2 12), casts a pleasing light upon his character. On his lips the words had another meaning than they bore when used by Elisha himself at Elijah’s translation. Then they referred to the “appearance’’ which parted Elisha from his master; now they referred to the great. service rendered by the prophet to the kingdom. Not only had Elisha repeatedly saved the armies of Israel from the ambushes prepared for them by the Syrians (2 K 6 8-23), but he had given assurance of the relief of the capital when it was at its worst extremity (6 24 ff). ToJ., Elisha’s presence was indeed in place of chariots and horse. The truth was anew demonstrated by the promise which the dying prophet now madeto him. Direct- ing J. in the symbolical action of the shooting of certain arrows, he predicted three victories over the Syrians—the first at Aphek, now Fik, on the E. of the Lake of Galilee—and more would have been granted, had the faith of the king risen to the oppor- tunity then afforded him (6 15-19). An interesting light is thrown by the annals of Assyria on the circumstances which may have made these victories of J. possible. Ram- 3. Assyria man-nirari III, who succeeded to the and throne in 811 BC, made an expedition Damascus against Damascus, Edom and Philistia, in his account of which hesays: “Ishut up the king [of Syria] in his chief city, Damascus. abe He clasped my feet, and gave himself up. . . ... His countless wealth and goods I seized in Damascus.” With the Syrian power thus broken during the remainder of this ruler’s reign of 27 years, it may be understood how J. should be able to recover, as it is stated he did, the cities which Ben-hadad had taken from his father Jehoahaz (2 K 13 25). Schrader and others see in this Assyr ruler the “saviour” of Israel alluded to in 1577 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jehoash Jehoiachin 2 K 18 5; more usually the reference is taken to be to J. himself, and to Jeroboam II (cf 2 K 14 27). The epitome of J.’s reign is very brief, but the favorable impression formed of him from the acts of Elisha is strengthened by another 4. War gained from the history of Amaziah with Judah of Judah (2 K 14 8-16; 2 Ch 25 : 17-24). For the purpose of a southern campaign, Amaziah had hired a large contingent of troops from Samaria. Being sent back unem- ployed, these mercenaries committed ravages on ther way home, for which, apparently, no redress was given. On the first challenge of the king of Judah, J. magnanimously refused the call to arms, but on Amaziah persistmg, the peace established nearly 80 years before by J choshaphat (1 K 22 44) was broken at the battle of Beth-shemesh, in which Amaziah was defeated and captured. Jerus opened its gates to the victor, and was despoiled of all its treasure, both of palace and temple. A portion of the wall was broken down, and hostages for future behavior were taken to Samaria (2 K'14 138.14). J. did not long survive his crowning victory, but left a resuscitated state, and laid the foundation for a subsequent rule which raised 5. Character Israel to the zenith of its power. Jos gives J. a high character for godliness, but, like each of his predecessors, he followed in the footsteps of Jeroboam I in permitting, if not en- couraging, the worship of the golden calves. Hence his conduct is pronounced “evil” by the historian (2 K 1311). He was succeeded by his son Jeroboam II. W. Saaw CaLpEcotTr JEHOHANAN, jé-hé-ha’nan ([21M, yhona- nan, “Jeh is [or has been] gracious”): (1) A Korahite doorkeeper in David’s reign, ‘‘son”’ of Meshelemiah (1 Ch 26 3). LXX, Luc, has “Jehonathan.” (2) One of the five captains over King Jehosha- phat’s army (2 Ch 17 15), probably father of Ishmael, “son of J.” (2 Ch 23 1). (3) Ezr 10 6 (AV has “Johanan”) = “Johanan” of Neh 12 22.23=“Jonathan” of Neh 12 11, “son” of Eliashib (Ezr 10 6; but “grandson” in Neh 12 11). He was high priest in Ezra’s time= “Jonas” in 1 Esd 9 1 (AV “Joanan’’). (4) One of those who had married foreign wives Sone 28) =“Joannes” RV, “Johannes” AV (1 Esd 9). (5) Son of Tobiah, the Ammonite, Nehemiah’s opponent (Neh 6 18, AV “Johanan’’). ae Head of the priestly family of Amariah (Neb (7) A priest present at the dedication of the walls of Jerus (Neh 12 42). (8) The name in the Heb of 2 Ch 28 12. See JoHANAN, (7). Davip Francis Roserts JEHOIACHIN, je-hoi’a-kin (270M, yhdya- khin, “Jeh will uphold”; called also “Jeconiah” in 1Ch 316; Jer 241; 119239, ykhonyah, “Jeh will be stedfast,’” and ‘‘Coniah” in Jer 22 24.28; AWD, konydhu, “Jeh has upheld him”; *Iwaxetp, Toakeim): A king of Judah; son and successor of Jehoiakim; reigned three months and surrendered to Nebuchadnezzar; was carried to Babylon, where, _after being there 37 years a prisoner, he died. The story of his reign is told in 2 K 24 8-16, and more briefly in 2 Ch 36 9-10. Then, after the reign of his successor Zedekiah and 1. Sources the final deportation are narrated, the account of his release from prison 37 years afterward and the honor done him is given as the final paragraph of 2 K (25 27-30). The same thing is told at the end of the Book of Jer (62 31-34). Neither for this reign nor for the succeeding is there the usual reference to state annals; these seem to have been discontinued after Jehoiakim. In Jer 22 24-30 there is a final pronouncement on this king, not so much upon the man as upon bis inevi- fable fate, and a prediction that no descendant of his shall ever have prosperous rule in Judah. Of the brief reign of J. there is little to tell. It was rather a historic landmark than a reign; but its year, 597 BC, was important as the 2. His date of the first deportation of Jewish Reign captives to Babylon (unless we except the company of hostages carried away in Jehoiakim’s 3d [4th] year, Dnl 11-7). His coming to the throne was just at or near the time when Nebuchadnezzar’s servants were besieging Jerus; and when the Chaldaecan king’s arrival in person to superintend the siege made apparent the futility of resistance, J. surrendered to him, with all the royal household and the court. He was carried prisoner to Babylon, and with him ten thousand captives, comprising all the better and sturdier element of the people from prince to crafts- man, leaving only the poorer sort to constitute the body of the nation under his successor Zedekiah. With the prisoners were carried away also the most valuable treasures of the temple and the royal palace. Ever since Isaiah fostered the birth and education of a spiritually-minded remnant, for him the vital hope of Israel, the growth and influ- 3. The Two ence of this clement in the nation Elements has been discernible, as well in the persecution it has roused (see under Manasseq), as in its fiber of sound progress. It is as if a sober sanity of reflection were curing the people of their empty idolatries. The feeling is well expressed in snch a passage as Hab 2 18-20. Hitherto, however, the power of this spiritual Israel has been latent, or at best mingled and pervasive among the various occupations and interests of the people. The.surrender of Jehoiachin brings about a segmentation of Israel on an unheard-of principle: not the high and low in wealth or social position, but the weight and worth of all classes on the one side, who are marked for deportation, and the refuse element of all classes on the other, who are left at home. With which element of this strange sifting Jeremiah’s prophetic hopes are identified appears in his parable of the Good and Bad Figs (Jer 24), in which he predicts spiritual integrity and upbuilding to the captives, and to the home-staying remainder, shame and calamity. Later on, he writes to the exiles in Babylon, advising them to make themselves at home and be good citizens (Jer 29 1-10). Asfor the hapless king, ‘this man Coniah,” who is to be their captive chief in a strange land, Jeremiah speaks of him in a strain in which the stern sense of Jeh’s inexorable purpose is mingled with tender sym- pathy as he predicts that this man shall never have a descendant on David's throne (Jer 22 24-30). It is as if he said, All as Jeh has ordained, but—the pity of it! In the first year of Nebuchadnezzar’s successor, perhaps by testamentary edict of Nebuchadnezzar himself, a strange thing occurred. 4, Thirty- J., who seems to have been a kind of seven Years hostage prisoner for his people, was Later released from prison, honored above all the other kings in similar case, and thenceforth to the end of his life had his portion at the royal table (2 K 25 27-30; Jer 62 31-34). This act of clemency may have been due to some such good influence at court as is described in the Book of Dnl; but also it was a tribute to the good conduct of that better element of the people of ae THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1578 which he was hostage and representative. It was the last event of Judaean royalty; and suggestive for the glimpse it seems to afford of a people whom the Second Isaiah could address as redeemed and forgiven, and of a king taken from durance and judg- ment (cf Isa 53 8), whose career makes strangely vivid the things that are said of the mysterious ‘Servant of Jeh.” JOHN FRANKLIN GENUNG JEHOIADA, jéhoi’a-da (PTI, yhdyadha’, “Jeh knows”; *IwSde, [adde): (1) Father of Benaiah, the captain of David’s body-guard (2 § 8 18; 20 23; 23 20.22; 1K 1 8, etc). J. was ‘the son of a valiant man of Kab- zeel” (2 § 23 20), but commentators read with LXX and Ewald, ‘“Benaiah (the son of Jehoiada) aman of valour.” Kabzeel was a town belonging to Judah on the border of Edom in the 8S. (Josh 15 21). Ini Ch 27 5, we read “Benaiah, the son of Jehoiada the priest, chief,’ RV, but RVm has “chief minister’ wrongly. Yet J. is nowhere else called a priest or even a Levite, though in 1 Ch 12 27 (Heb 28) a J. is mentioned as a military “leader of the house of Aaron,’’ who came to David to Hebron with other members of the house of Levi. In 1 Ch 27 34 there is named among David’s counsellors, “J. the son of Benaiah,”’ where some commentators would read with two MSS, “‘B., the son of J.” though Curtis, Crit. and Exeget. Comm. onthe Books of Ch, 295, keeps the MT. (2) Priest in the reigns of Ahaziah, Queen Athaliah, and Jehoash (Joash) of Judah (2 K 11 4—12 16 [Heb 17)=2 Ch 23 1—24 14; 2 Ch 22 11; 24 14-16.17-20.22.25). In 2 K 12 10 (Heb 11) he is called “high priest,’ and is the first to be given that title, but as the priest lived in the temple, there is no meaning in saying that he “‘came up,” so commentators omit the words, “and the chief priest.” According to 2 Ch 22 11, he had married Jehoshabeath (=Jehosheba), the daughter of the king, i.e. Jehoram. (a) The account in 2 Ch 23 1-21 differsin many respects from that in 2 K 11 4-20, but even the latter has its problems, and Stade 1. Jehoiada (ZATW, 1885, 280ff) pomted out and the two sources in it. This view is ac- Revolt cepted by many. A reader is struck against at once by the double reference to the Athaliah death of Athaliah (vs 16.20), and the construction of the Heb for “making a covenant” is different in ver 4 from that in ver 17. Stade holds that there is one narrative in 11 4-12.18d-20 and another in vs 13-184. In the first, J. makes an agreement with the cap- tains of the foreign body-guard, and arranges that both the incoming and outgoing temple-guard shall be kept in the temple at the time when the guard should be changed on the Sabbath, and also that the young prince, Jehoash, who had been kept in hiding, shall be proclaimed. The captains do this, and the prince is crowned and proclaimed (vs 4-12). Then officers are set up in the temple, and Jehoash is taken to the royal palace and enthroned. The revolt proves popular with the people of Jerus and those of the district, and Athaliah is slain in the palace. But there are difficulties in this narrative, though the above gives the trend of events; ver 5 refers to a third of the guard who ‘‘came in on the sabbath,”’ and ver 7 to two companies who “go forth on the sabbath"; the Tfeb is, ‘‘they that enter the sabbath" and ‘‘they that go out of the sabbath,""| Ver 9 makes clear the connec- tion between vs 5 and 7. But ver 6 introduces a diffl- culty: it seems to denote a division of those who ‘‘enter”’ into three divisions, i.e. the two in ver 6 and one in ver 5. Tf ver 6 be omitted, as is proposed by_many, this diffi- eulty vanishes. But there still remains the question oi the change of guards. Commentators say that ‘‘ they who enter the sabbath" are those who leave the temple and enter their quarters at the beginning of the Sabbath, presumably, while ‘‘those who go out’’ are those who leave their quarters to mount guard. This is not impossible as an explanation of the Heb. It is further believed that the guard at the temple on the Sabbath was double that on other days. The other eld ee held by older commentators is that on the Sabbath the guard was only half its usual size; this gives another meaning to the Heb phrases. On the other hand, it may be held that the revolt took place at the close of the Sabbath, and that the double-sized guard was kept by J. even after the usual-sized one had come to take their place. It should be added that Wellhausen proposed to read nayy (ge*adhoth), ‘‘armlets’’ (cf Isa 3 19), for MATY Cedhath), “testimony,” in ver 12; and in ver 19 the words ‘‘and all the people of the land" are held to be an addition. (b) The 2d narrative (vs 138-18a) begins suddenly. Presumably its earlier part was identical with the earlier part of the 1st narrative, unless ver 6 was a part originally of this 2d account. Athaliah hears the noise of the people (ver 13, where “the guard” is a gloss and so to be omitted), and comes to the temple, where she witnesses the revolt and cries, “Tyeason! treason!”” J. orders her to be put forth (omit “between the ranks’ in ver 15), so that she should not be slain in the temple, and sheis murdered at one of the palace entrances (ver 16, where RV, following LXX of 2 Ch 23 15, tr* the first sentence wrongly: it should be “So they laid hands on her’’), J. then makes the king and the people enter into a solemn covenant to be Jeh’s people, and the result is the destruction of the temple of Baal, and the death of Mattan, its priest (vs 17.18a)._ This 2d narrative gives a religious significance to the revolt, but it is incomplete. The other narrative presents a very naiural course of events, for it was absolutely neces- sary for J. to secure the allegiance of the royal foreign body-guard. : (c) The account in 2 Ch 23 1-21, though following that of 2 K in the main, differs from it considerably. The guard is here composed of Levites; it does not men- tion the foreign body-guard, and relates how the revolt was planned with the Levites of the cities of Judah—a method which would have become known to Athaliah and for which she would have made preparations, no doubt. Ch makes it a wholly religious movement, while 2 K gives two points of view. The value of the Chroni- cler’s account depends largely on one's estimate of the Books of Ch and one’s views as to the development of the Jewish priestly system. A. Van Hoonacker, Le sacerdoce lévitique dans la loi et dans l'histoire des Hébreux, 93-100, defends the account in 2 Ch. The part which J. played in the restoration of the temple buildings is described in 2 K 11 2112 16 (Heb 12 1-17) ||2 Ch 24 1-14. Here 2. Jehoiada again the narratives of 2 K and 2 Ch andthe differ to a large extent. Restoration (a) According to 2 K (i) the priests of the are commanded by Jehoash to devote Temple the dues or free-will offerings of the people to repairing the breaches in the temple. They fail to do so, and (ii) J. is sum- moned by the king and rebuked. Then (iii) a new regulation is put into force: the offerings, except the guilt offerings and sin offerings, are no longer to be given to the priests, but to be put into a chest provided in the temple for the purpose. (iv) The money got in this way is devoted to repairing the temple, but (v) none of it is used to provide temple vessels. (6) Ch, on the other hand, (i) relates that the priests and Levites are commanded to go through Judah to collect the necessary money. They “has- tened it not.” Then (ii) J. is summoned to account for this disobedience, and (iii) a chest is put outside the temple to receive the tax commanded by Moses. (iv) This the people pay willingly, and the temple is repaired. There is such a surplus that (v) there is money also to provide vessels for the temple. _ It is at least questionable whether the additions in 2 Ch are trustworthy; the contradictions against 2 K are clear, and the latter gives the more likely 1579 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jehoiada Jehoiakim narrative, although Van Hoonacker (op. cit., 101- 14) defends the former. . According to 2 Ch 24 15, J. lived to be 130 years old, and was buried among the kings—a unique distinction. (8) AV in Neh 3 6=Jo1apa (q.v.). (4) There is a Jehoiada, the priest mentioned in Jer 29 26, in whose stead Zephaniah was declared priest by Shemaiah in a letter. Giesebrecht takes him to be the same as the prlest of Athaliah's time (see [2] above), but Duhm says that nothing is known of him. In any case, Zephaniah could not have been the direct successor of the well-known Jehoiada, and so the reference can scarcely be to him if it is to have any meaning. Davin Francis Roserts JEHOIAKIM, jé-hoi'a-kim (D9P719) ,, yrhoyakim, “Jeh will establish”; "Iwaxelp, [dakeim): The name given him by Pharaoh-necoh, who raised him to the throne as vassal king in place of his brother Jehoa- haz, is changed from Eliakim (PR, *elyakim, “God will establish’). The change compounds the name, after the royal Judaean custom, with that of Jeh; it may also imply that Necoh claims Jeh’s authorization for his act, as in a similar way Sen- nacherib had claimed it for his invasion of Judah (2 K 18 25). He has represented the campaign with which Josiah interfered as undertaken by Divine command (’Hl, 2 Ch 35 21); this episode of it merely translates the authorization, rather arrogantly, into the conquered nation’s dialect. A king of Judah, elder (half-) brother and suc- cessor of Jehoahaz; reigned 11 years from 608 BC. I. Sources for His Life and Time.—The circum- stances of his accession and raising of the indemnity _ to Pharaoh-necoh, followed by a brief 1. Annalistic résumé of his reign, are narrated in 2K 23 34—246. The naming of the source for ‘the rest of his acts’? (24 5) is the last reference we have to “‘the book of the chronicles of the kings of Judah.” The acccount in 2 Ch 36 5-8, though briefer still, mentions Nebuchadnezzar’s looting of the temple at some uncertain date in his reign. Neither account has any good to say of J.; to the writer of 2 K, however, his ill fortunes are due to Jeh’s retributive justice for the sins of Manasseh; while to the Chronicler the sum of his acts, apparently connected with the desecration of the sanctuary, is characterized as “the abomina- tions which he did.”” For “‘the rest of his acts’’ we are referred, also for the last time, to the “book of the kings of Israel and Judah.” : For the moral and spiritual chaos of the time, and for prophecies and incidents throwing much light on the king’s character, Jeremiah has 2. Prophetic a number of extended passages, not, however, in consecutive order. The main ones clearly identiflable with this reign are: 22 13-19, inveighing against the king's tyrannies and predetng his ignominious death; ch 26, dated in the eginning of his reign and again predicting (as had been predicted before in % 12-15) the destruction of the temple; ch 25, dated in hls 4th year and Predicuing the conquest of J udah and snrrounding nations by Nebuchad- nezzar; ch 36, dated in the 4th and 5th years, and telling the story of the roll of prophecy which the king destroyed; ch 45, an appendix from the 4th year, reassuring Baruch the scribe, in terms of the larger prophetic scale, for his dismay at what he had to write; ch 46, also an appen- dix, a reminiscence of the year of Carchemish, containing the oracle then pronounced agalnst Egypt, and giving words of the larger comfort to Judah. ‘the Book of the prophet Habakkuk, written in this relgn, gives expression to the prophetic feeling of donbt and dismay at the unrequited ravages of the Chaldaeans against a people more righteous than they, with a sense of the value of stedfast faith and of Jeh's world-movement and purpose which explains the seeming enormity. JI. Character and Events of His Reign.—The reign of J. is not so significant for any personal im- press of his upon his time as for the fact that it fell in one of the most momentous epochs of ancient history. By the fall of Nineveh in 606 to the assault of Nebuchadnezzar, then crown prince of the rising Bab empire, Assyria, “the rod 1. The of [Jeh’s] anger” (Isa 10 5), ended Epoch its arrogant and inveterate sway over the nations. Nebuchadnezzar, coming soon after to the Chaldaean throne, followed up his victory by a vigorous campaign against Pharaoh-necoh, whom we have seen at the end of Josiah’s reign (see under Josiau) advancing toward the Euphrates in his attempt to secure Egyp do- minion over Syria and Mesopotamia. The en- counter took place in 605 at Carchemish on the northern Euphrates, where Necoh was defeated and driven back to the borders of his own land, never more to renew his aggressions (2 K 24 7). The dominating world-empire was now in the hands of the Chaldaeans, “that bitter and hasty nation” (Hab 1 6); the first stage of the movement by which the world’s civilization was passing from Sem to Aryan control. With this world-movement Israel’s destiny was henceforth to be intimately involved; the prophets were already dimly aware of it, and were shaping their warnings and promises, as by a Divine instinct, to that end. It wason this larger scale of things that they worked; it had all along been their endeavor, and continued with in- creasing clearness and fervor, to develop in Israel a conscience and stamina which should be a leaven- ing power for good in the coming great era (cf Isa 23-4; Mic 4 1-3). Of all these prophetic meanings, however, neither the king nor the ruling classes had the faintest reali- zation; they saw only the political 2. The exigencies of the moment. or did: King’s the king himself, in any patriotic way, Perverse _rise even to the immediate occasion. Character As to policy, he was an unprincipled opportunist: vassal to Necoh to whom he owed his throne, until Necoh himself was de- feated; enforced vassal to Nebuchadnezzar for 3 years along with the other petty kings of Western Asia; then rebelling against the latter as soon as he thought he could make anything by it. As to responsibility of administration, he had simply the temper of a despotic self-indulgent Oriental. He raised the immense fine that Necoh imposed upon him by a direct taxation, which he farmed out to unscrupulous officials. He indulged himself with erecting costly royal buildings, employing for the purpose enforced and unpaid labor (Jer 22 13-17); while all just interests of his oppressed subjects went wholly unregarded. As to religion, he let, mat- ters go on as they had been under Manasseh, prob- ably introducing also the still more strange and heathenish rites from Egypt and the East of which we see the effects in Ezk 8 5-17. And meanwhile the reformed temple-worship which Josiah had introduced seems to have become a mere formal and perfunctory matter, to which, if we may judge by his conspicuous absence from fast and festal occasions (e.g. Jer 26, 36), the king paid no atten- tion. His impious act of cutting up and burning Jeremiah’s roll (36 23), as also his vindictive pur- suit and murder of Uriah for prophesying in the spirit of Jeremiah (26 20-23), reveal his antipathy to any word that does not prophesy “smooth things” (cf Isa 30 10), and in fact a downright perversity to the name and will of Jeh. With the onset of the Chaldaean power, prophecy, as represented in the great seers whose words remain to us, reached a crisis which only time and the 3. The consistent sense of its larger issues could , heti enable it to weather. Isaiah, in his time, Prophetic had stood for the inviolability of Zion, and Attitude a miraculous deliverance had vindicated his sublime faith. But with Jeremiah, conditions had changed. The idea thus engendered, that the temple was bound to stand and with it Jerus, Jehoiarib Jehoshaphat THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1580 an idea confirmed by Josiah’s centralizing reforms, had hecome a superstition and a presumption (cf Jer 7 4); and Jeremiah had reached the conviction that it, with its wooden rites and glaring abuses, must go: that nothing short of a clean sweep of the old religious fetishes could cure the inveterate unspirituality of the nation. This conviction of his must needs seem to many like an in- consistency—to set prophecy against itself, And when the Chaldaean appeared on the scene, his counsel of sub- mission and prediction of captivity would seem a double inconsistency; not only a traversing of a tested prophecy, but treason to the state. his was the situation that he had to encounter; and for it he gave his tender feelings, his liberty, his life. It is in this reign of J. that, for the sake of Jeh's word and purpose, he is engulfed in the deep tragedy of _his career. And in this he must be vir- tually alone. Habakkuk is indeed with him in sym- pathy; but his vision is not so clear; he must weather disheartening doubts, and cherish the faith of_the righteous (Hab 2 4), and wait until the vision of Jeh’s secret purpose clears (Hah 2 1-3). If the prophets themselves are thus having such an equivocal crisis, we can imagine how forlorn is the plight of Jeh’s ‘‘remnant,” who are dependent on prophetic faith and courage to guide them through the depths. The humble nucleus of the true Israel, which is some day to he the nation’s redeeming element, is undergoing a stern seasoning. After Syria fell into Nebuchadnezzar’s power, he seems to have established his headquarters for some years at Riblah; and after J. 4. Harass- attempted to revolt from his authority, ing and he sent against him guerilla bands Death from the neighboring nations, and de- tachments from his Chaldaean garri- sons, who harassed him with raids and depredations. In 2 Ch 36 6.7, itis related that Nebuchadnezzar carried some of the vessels of the temple to Baby- lon and bound the king im fetters to carry him also to Babylon—the latter purpose apparently not carried out. This was in J.’s 4th year. In Dnl 1 1.2, though ascribed to Jehoiakim’s 3d year, this same event is related as the result of a siege of Jerus. It is ambiguously intimated also that the king was deported; and among ‘‘the seed royal and of the nobles’ who were of the company were Daniel and his three companions (Dn! 1 3.6). The manner of J’s death is obscure. It is merely said (2 K 24 6) that he ‘“‘slept with his fathers’; but Jos (Ant, X, vi, 3), perhaps assuming that Jeremiah’s prediction (Jer 22 19) was fulfilled, states that Neb- uchadnezzar slew him and cast his body outside the walls unburied. JoHN FRANKLIN GENUNG JEHOLARE, jé-hoi’arib QU, yhayaribh, “Jeh pleads’ or ‘“‘contends’’): A priest in Jerus (1 Ch 9 10); the name occurs again in 1 Ch 24 7 as the name of a family among, the 24 courses of priests =the family Joiarib (A"721", ydyaribh, same meaning as above, Neh 12 6), the head of which is Mattenai in Neh 12 19. In Neh 11 10 we should probably read ‘Jedaiah and Joiarib” for “Jedaiah the son of Joiarib” (cf 1 Ch 910). Jehoiarib= Joarib in 1 Mace 2 1. JEHONADAB, jéhon’a-dab (A721, yhdnd- dhabh, either “Jeh is noble” or “‘liberal,’”’ or ‘“Jeh has impelled’) = Jonadab (2721, ydnadhabh, same meaning): (1) Jehonadab in Heb of 2 8 13 5; but Jonadab in EV, and in Heb and EV of 13 3.32.35; son of Shimeah, King David’s brother. He was friendly with Amnon his cousin, and is said to be “a very shrewd [RV ‘‘subtle’’] man.’’ He planned to get Tamar to wait upon Amnon. Two years after, when Absalom had murdered Amnon, and David had heard that all the king’s sons were assassinated, J. assured him that only Amnon was killed; and his reassuring tone is justified (ver 35); possibly he knew of Absalom’s intentions. LXX, Luc, has “Jonathan” in 18 3 ff; and in 28 21 21 || 1 Ch 20 7, there is mentioned a son of Shimei (= “Shim- ea,” 1 Ch 20 7=“Shammah,” 18 16 9), whose name is Jonathan. See JonaTHAN, (4). (2) Jehonadab in 2 K 10 15.23; in Heb of Jer 35 8.14.16.18=Jonadab in Jer 35 6.10.19, and EV of 35 8.14.16.18, “son” of Rechab, of the Kenite clan (1 Ch 2 55). J. is described in 2 K 10 as an ally of Jehu in the abolition of Baal-worship in Samaria. Jehu met him after slaying the son of Ahab (10 15); the second part of the verse should probably be tr¢ ‘And he greeted him and said to him, Is thy heart upright [with me] as my heart is with thee? And Jehonadab answered, Yes. Then spake Jehu [so LXX], If so, give me thy hand.’ In Jer 35 (where EV has Jonadab throughout), he is called the “father” of the Rechabites, who derived from him their ordinances for their- nomadic life and abstention from wine. See RecHas, Rz- CHABITES. Davip Francis RoBERtTs JEHONATHAN, jéhon’a-than (JZ, yhona- than, “Jeh has given’): The name is the same as Jonathan: the Heb has the two forms for the same person sometimes; sometimes only one is found. See Jonatuan. The form “Jehonathan” occurs as follows in EV: (1) A Levite who took part in teaching the Torah in the cities of Judah under Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 17 8 EV and Heb). (2) Head of the priestly family of Shemaiah (Neh 12 18 EV and Heb). oo AV and Heb in 1 Ch 27 25; see JonaTHan, JEHORAM, je-hi’ram, written also in the abbre- viated form, JORAM (O77), yhoram, OID, yoram, “‘Jeh is high”; RV retains ‘Joram’ for Heb yhorém in 2 K 9 15-24): (1) Ninth king of Israel (2 K 1 17—9 28), son of Ahab and Jezebel, successor to his brother Ahaziah, who died childless. He began to reign 853 BC, and reigned 12 years (2 K 3 1; 8 16). The statement in 2 K 1 17, “‘the second year of Je- horam,”’ follows a system of chronology common to the Lucian group of MSS, in which the 1st year of Jehosha- phat falls in the 11th year of Omri; the 24th year of Jehoshaphat in the lst year of Ahaziah; and the Ist year of Jehoram in the 2d year of Jehoram of Judah. The double chronology (2 K 1 17 and 2 K 8 1) is due to the intention of the compiler of K to refer all the acts of Elisha to the reign of Jehoram, thus dislocating the order of events in that reign. Elisha, however, survived Jehoram many years, and it is possible that some of the events are to he referred to subsequent reigns. It is difficult to estimate the religious character of J. Apparently the fierce fanaticism of Jezebel and the boldness of Ahab reappear 1. His in the son in the form of duplicity and Religious superstition. The attempt of Jezebel Policy to substitute Baal for Jeh bad failed. The people were on the side of Jeh. Otherwise Jehu could not have carried out his bloody reform. All the worshippers of Baal in the land could be gathered into one temple of Baal (2 K 10 18 ff). Evidently J. feared the people. Accordingly he posed as a reformer by putting away the pillar of Baal (2 K 3 2), while secretly he worshipped Baal (3 13a). Nevertheless, when he got into straits, he expected to receive the help of Jeh (8 136). He had not learned that a dual nature is as impossible as a union of Baal and Jeh. Immediately upon his accession, J. came into conflict with Mesha, king of Moab (2 K 8 4 ff). The account of the conflict is of special 2. The interest because of the supplementary Moabite information concerning Mesha_fur- War nished by the Moabite Stone. There ; we learn (11. 1-8) that Moab became tributary to Israel in the days of Omri, and remained so for forty years, but that it rebelled in the days of Ahab. This probably brings us to the statement in 2K 3 4 ff that Mesha “rendered unto the king of 1581 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jehoiarib Jehoshaphat Israel the wool of a hundred thousand lambs, and of a hundred thousand rams,” and that “when Ahab was dead, ... . the king of Moab rebelled against the king of Israel.” The victories of Mesha, glorified by the M §, possibly took place before the events of 2K 3 4ff. Accordingly, J. resolved to recover the allegiance of the Moabites. He called to his aid the ally of his father, Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, and the latter’s vassal, the king of Edom. J. was enter- tained at Jerus (Jos, Ant, IX, iii, 1). The allies marched against Moab by the longer route, around the southern end of the Dead Sea, indicating that Moab was fortified against attack from the W., and that Israel was weak in the East Jordan country. After the allies had been miraculously delivered from perishing for lack of water, they devastated the land and sacked the cities, and finally they succeeded in shutting up Mesha in Kir-hareseth. Driven to despair, Mesha offered his eldest son upon the wall as a burnt offering to Chemosh. This seems to have caused the tide to turn, for “there was great wrath against Israel,” and the allies returned to their own land, apparently having failed to secure a last- ing advantage. . Assuming that 2 K 4-8 belong to the reign of J., it appears that the Syrians made frequent incursions into the land of Israel, perhaps more 3. The in the nature of plundering robber Conflicts bands than invasions by a regular army with Syria (2 K 6). Finally, however, Ben-hadad in person invaded the country and be- sieged Samaria. The inhabitants were reduced to horrible straits by famine, when the oppressors took sudden flight and Israel was saved. In the years 849, 848, and 845, Shalmaneser II invaded Syria. It is probable that during this period J. recovered Ramoth-gilead, which had fallen to Syria under Ahab. Hazael succeeded Ben-hadad as ruler of Syria, and his first act, after having murdered his predecessor, was to regain Ramoth-gilead. In the defence of the city, J., who was assisted by his nephew, Ahaziah, was wounded, and returned to Jezreel to be healed of his wounds. J. left the army at Ramoth-gilead under the com- mand of Jehu, a popular captain of the host. While J. was at Jezreel, Elisha sent a prophet 4, The Con- to anoint Jehu as king of Israel. Jehu spiracy of had been a witness of the dramatic Jehu scene when Elijah hurled the curse of Jeh at Ahab for his crime against Naboth. Jehu at once found in himself the instru- ment to bring the curse to fufilment. Accordingly, he conspired his crime against J. With a company of horsemen he proceeded to Jezreel, where Ahaziah was visiting his sick uncle, J. J. suspected treach- ery, and, in company with Ahaziah, he rode out to’ meet Jehu. On his question, “Is it peace, Jehu?” he received a brutal reply that no longer left him in doubt as to the intention of the conspirator. As J. turned to flee, Jehu drew his bow and shot him in the back so that the arrow pierced his heart. His dead body was thrown into the plat of ground that had belonged to Naboth. (2) King of Judah, son of Jehoshaphat (2 K 8 16-24; 2 Ch 21 1-20), he began to rule about 849 and reigned 8 years. With reference to the chronological difficulty introduced by 2 K 1 17, see (1) above. , In the beginning of the reigns of Ahab and Je- hoshaphat, an attempt was made to end the old feud between Israel and Judah. At the 1. His suggestion of Ahab, the two kingdoms, Marriage _ for the first time, joined forces against the common foe from the N., the Syrians. To seal the alliance, Athaliah, daughter of Jezebel and Ahab, was married to J., son of Je- hoshaphat. Thus Jehoram was brother-in-law to (1) above. No doubt this was considered as a mas- ter stroke of conciliatory policy by the parties inter- ested. However, it proved disastrous for Judah. Beyond a doubt, the unholy zeal of Jezebel included the Baalizing of Judah as well as of Israel. This marriage was a step in that direction. “A man shall leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife.” J.didso. ‘He walked in the ways of the kings of Israel, as 2. His did the house of Ahab” (2 K 8 18). Idolatry According to 2 Ch 21 11.13, J. not only accepted the religion of Athaliah, but he became a persecutor, compelling the inhabit- ants of Jerus and of the land to Raa apostates. Because of his gross idolatry and his wickedness, he is said (2 Ch 21 12 ff) to have received a de- nunciatory letter from the prophet 3. The Elijah, which, however, had no effect Letter of | on him. But this leads to a chrono- Elijah logical difficulty. Was Elijah still alive? The inference from 2 K 3 11 is that hewasnot. Then, too, the Chronicler other- wise never mentions Elijah. Oettli is of the opinion that one should either read “Elisha” for ‘EHlijah,” or else consider the letter to have been the con- ception of a later writer, who felt that Elijah must have taken note of the wickedness of J. and his wife, Athaliah, daughter of Ahab. In the latter event, the letter might be called a haggadic Midrash. A man’s religion cannot be divorced from his character. Baalism had in it the elements of tyranny and civic unrighteousness. 4. His In keeping with his religion, and in Character true oriental fashion, J. began his reign by murdering his brothers, and other princes of the land, to whom Jehoshaphat had given valuable gifts and responsible positions. The only event belonging to his reign re- 5. The corded in K is the revolt of Edom. Revolt of © Edom was subdued by David, and, Edom probably with the exception of a tem- porary revolt under Solomon (1 K 11 14 ff), it had remained subject to the united king- dom or to Judah until the revolt under J. The text is somewhat obscure, but both accounts indicate that the expedition of J. against Edom ended in failure. In the account we are told that at the same time Libnah revolted. Perhaps the revolt of Libnah should be taken in connection with the invasion of the Philis and of _ the Arabians, mentioned in 2 Ch 21. 6. The Raid Libnah was located on the south- into Judah western border of Judah. Since it was a border city, it is possible that the compiler of K considered it as belonging to Philistia. In the account in Ch, J. is represented as having lost all his possessions and all his family, save Jehoahaz, the youngest of his sons, when the town was sacked and the palace plundered by the invading force of Philis and Arabians. The account appears to be based upon reliable sources. In his last days, he was afflicted with a frightful disease in the bowels. His death was unregretted, and his burial without honor. Con- 7. His trast, however, 2 K 8 24 with 2 Ch Death 21 20. Ahaziah, also called Jehoahaz, his younger son, then became king in his stead. S. K. Mosiman JEHOSHABEATH, jé-hé-shab’éath (npawine : yhoshabh‘ath, “Jeh is an oath’): In 2 Ch 22 11= JEHOSHEBA (q.v.) of 2 K 11 2. JEHOSHAPHAT, jé-hosh’a-fat (QDWIN", yho- shaphat, ‘“Jeh has judged’’): (1) King of Judah. See separate article. (2) Son of Ahilud. He was recorder under David Jehoshaphat Jehovah-Jireh THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1582 Ps 8 16; 20 24; 1 Ch 18 15) and Solomou (1 K (3) Son of Paruah, and Solomon’s overseer in Issachar to provide victuals for the royal household for one month of the year (1 K 4 17). (4) Son of Nimshi, and father of Jehu, king of Northern Israel (2 K 9 2.14). His name is omitted in 9 20 and 1 K 19 16, where Jehu is called ‘‘son of Nimshi.” (5) AV (but not Heb) in 1 Ch 15 24; RV correctly JOSHAPHAT (q.v.). Davip Francis Roperts JEHOSHAPHAT, jéhosh’a-fat (ODEBWIT, yho- shaphat, ‘‘Jeh judges’): The 4th king of Judah, son of Asa. His mother was Azubah, the daughter of Shilhi, of whom nothing further is known. He was 35 years of age at his accession, aud reigned 25 years, c 873-849 BC. The history of his reign is contained in 1 K 22 41-50 and m 2 Ch 17 1— 211. The narrative in 1 K 22 1-35a@ and iu 2 K 3 4ff belongs to the history of the Northern Kingdom. The absence from K of the details con- tained in 2 Ch affords no presumption against their truth. Neither do high numbers, embellished statements, and the coloring of the writer’s own age destroy the historical perspective. The reign of J. appears to have been one of un- usual religious activity. It was, however, charac- terized not so much by striking reli- 1. His gious measures as it was by the religious Religious spirit that pervaded every act of the Policy king, who sought the favor of Jeh in every detail of his life (2 Ch 17 3.4). He evidently felt that a nation’s character is de- termined by its religion. Accordingly, he made it his duty to purify the national worship. The “sodomites,” i.e. those who practised immorality in the worship of Jeh in the temple precincts, were banished from the land (1 K 22 46). The Asherim were taken out of Judah (2 Ch 17 6; 19 3), and “the people from Beer-sheba to the hill-country of Epbraim were brought back uuto Jeh, the God of their fathers’ (19 4). Because of his zeal for Jeh, J. is rewarded with power and “riches and houor in abundance” (17 5). Believing that religion and morals, the founda- tion and bulwarks of civilization, suffer from igno- rance, J. introduced a system of public 2. His iustruction for the whole land (2 Ch System of 17 7 ff). He appointed a commission, Public In=- composed of princes, Levites and struction priests, to go from city to city to in- struct the people. Their instruction was to be based on the one true foundation of sound morals and healthy religious life, “the book of the law of Jeh”! (17 7-9). Next in importance to J.’s system of public in- struction, was his provision for the better admin- istration of justice. He appointed 3. His judges to preside over courts of com- Judicial mon pleas, which he established in all Institutions the fortified cities of Judah. In addi- tion to these local courts, two courts of appeal, an ecclesiastical and a civil court, were established at Jerus to be presided over by priests, Levites, and leading nobles as judges. At the head of the ecclesiastical court of appeal was the high priest, and a layman, ‘“‘the ruler of the house of Judah,” headed the civil court of appeal (2 Ch 19 4-11). The insistence that a judge was to be in character like Jeh, with whom there is “no iniquity . .. . nor respect of persons, nor taking of bribes” (19 7), is worthy of note. According to 2 Ch 17 2, J. began his reign with defensive measures against Israel. Furthermore, he built castles and cities of store in the land of Judah, “and he had many works,” probably mili- tary supplies, “in the cities of Judah” (17 13). He appears to have had a large 4, His standing army, including cavalry (1 Military K 22 4; 2 Ch 17 14 ff). However, Defences the numbers in 2 Ch 17 14 ff seem to be impossibly high. Godliness and security at home were followed by respect and peace abroad. The fact that the Philis and the Arabians brought 5. His tribute (17 11), and that Edom had Foreign no king (1 K 22 47), but a deputy Policy instead, who possibly was appointed by J., would indicate that he held the suzerainty over the nations and tribes bordering Judah on the 8. and W. Holding the suzerainty over the weaker nations, and being allied with the stronger, J. secured the peace for the greater part of his reign (1 Ch 17 10) that fostered the internal development of the kingdom. In contrast to the former kings of Judah, J. saw greater benefit in an alliance with Israel than in civil war. Accordingly, the old feud between the two kingdoms (1 K 14 Alliance 30; 15 6) was dropped, and J. made with Ahab peace with Israel (22 44). The po- litical union was cemented by the marriage of Jehoram, son of J., to Athaliah, daughter of Ahah and Jezebel. Shortly after the marnage, J. joined Ahab in a campaign against Syria (2 Ch 18 1-3). In view of the subordinate position that J. seems to take in the campaign (1 K 22 4.30), and in view of the military service rendered to Jehoram (2 K 3 4 ff), Judah seems to have become a dependency of Israel. Nevertheless, the union may have contributed to the welfare and prosperity of Judah, and it may have enabled J. to hold the suzerainty over the neighboring nations. However, the final outcome of the alliance with the house of Omri was disastrous for Judah. The introduction into Judah of Baalism more than counterbalanced any political and material advantage gained, and in the succeeding reigns it indirectly led to the Gore oe extinction of the royal family of Judah 11 1 ff). Ju spite of the denunciation of the prophet Jehu for his expedition with Ahab, thus “help[ing) the wicked” (2 Ch 19 2), J. entered into 6. His 7. His Al- asimilar alliance with Jehoram of Israel liance with (2 K 3 4ff). On the iuvitation of Je- Jehoram horam to join him in an expedition against Moab, J. was ready with the same set spcech of acceptance as in the case of Ahab (2 % 37; cf 1 K 22 4). For the details of the expedition see Jenoram, (1). The Chronicler has given us a very remarkable account of a victory gained by J. over the Moabites and Ammonites. No doubt he made 8. Victory useof acurreut historical Midr. Many over the find the historical basis of the Midr in Moabites the events recorded in 2 K 83 4ff. and Am- However, the localities are different, monites and there a defeat is recorded, while in this case we have a victory. The story in outline bears the stamp of probability. 1 K 22 45 seems to suggest wars of J. that are not men- tioned in K. The tribes mentioned in the account are represented as trying to make permanent settle- ment in Judah (2 Ch 20 11). In their advauce through theS. of Judah, they were doubtless harassed by the shepherd population of the country. J., according to his custom, sought the help of Jeh. The invadiug forces fell to quarreling amoug them- selves (2 Ch 20 23), and destroyed one another. The spoil was great because the invaders had brought ee ies goods with them, expecting to remain in the and. 1583 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jehoshaphat Jehovah-Jireh The destruction of J.’s fleet is recorded in 1 K 22 48.49 and in 2 Ch 20 35-37. However, the two accounts are quite different. 9. Destruc- According to K, J. built ships of Tar- tion of Je- shish to sail to Ophir for gold, but the hoshaphat’s vessels were wrecked at Ezion-geber. Fleet Thereupon Ahaziah offered to assist ; J. with seamen, but J. refused to enter into the alliance. According to Ch the alliance had been formed, and together they built ships at Ezion-geber, which were destroyed because J. had made an alliance with the wicked king of Israel. In view of J.’s other alliances, the Chronicler may be in the right. Ch, however, misunderstood the term “‘ships of Tarshish.” ‘at hand at the resurrection. This, too, was an ordinary place for Jewish graves in preéxilic times (2 K 23 6, etc). The valley today, esp. that part adjacent to the temple, is crowded with Moslem and Jewish graves. A worthless tradition indicates the tomb of Jehoshaphat himself close to the so- called “Pillar of Absalom.” See Krna’s Vaz. There is not the slightest reason for believing that this is the spot referred to by Joel—indeed he may have spoken of an ideal spot only. The valley of the Kidron is a nehal (“ravine”), not an ‘émek (“broad valley”). It is impossible not to suspect that there is some connection between the name Jehoshaphat and the name of a village near the head of this valley—Shdphat; perhaps at one time VALLEY oF JEmosHAPHAT (LooginG N.E.).- J. died at the age of 60. Jos says (Ant, IX, iti, 2) that he was buried in a magnificent manner, for he had imitated the actions of 10. His David. The kingdom was left to Death Jehoram, who inaugurated the begin- ning of his reign by causing the mas- sacre of his brethren. 8. K. Mosman JEHOSHAPHAT, VALLEY OF (ODUM poy, ‘étmek ythdshaphat; the latter word means ‘“‘Jeh judgeth,” and ‘émek, “wide,” “open valley”; LXX hé kotlds Idsaphdt): The name is used in Joel 3 2.12 of the scene of Judgment: “Let the nations bestir themselves, and come up to the valley of Jehosha- phat; for there will I sit to judge all the nations round about” (ver12). ‘The valley of decision” (or “sharp judgment’) is another name the prophet gives to this spot (ver 14). Some have identified it with the valley (‘@mek) of Beracan (q.v.) of 2 Ch 20 26, where King Jehoshaphat obtained a great victory, but this is improbable. Since the 4th cent. AD the Kipron (q.v.) valley has been named the Valley of J. The tradition is now strongest among the Moslems who point out the exact scene of the Judgment; the Bridge As Sirdt, dividing heaven and hell, is to stretch across this valley from the Haram area to the Mount of Olives. It is, however, the ambition of every pious Jew to be buried on the slopes of this valley, to be it was Wédy Shdphat, which name would readily suggest the traditional one. See GEHENNA. E. W. G. MasTerman JEHOSHEBA, jé-hosh’é-ba, jé-hé-shé’ba (JID, yhoshebha‘, “Jeh is an oath’): Called ‘“Jehosha- beath” in 2 Ch 22 11; daughter of Jehoram king of Judah, possibly by a wife other than Athaliah (2 K 11 2). According to 2 Ch 22 11, she was the wife of Jehoiada, the priest. She hid Jehoash, the young son of King Ahaziah, and so saved his life from Queen Athaliah. JEHOSHDA, jé-hosh’t-a (YW, yhdshue’, “Jeh is deliverance,” or ‘is opulence”): The usual Heb form of the name ‘Joshua’; it occurs in AV of Nu 13 16 (ARV ‘‘Hoshea’’); and in some editions of AV in 1 Ch 7 27, where others have the form “Jehoshuah” (4 being wrongly added at the end). See Josaua, son of Nun. JEHOVAH, Names of, IT, 5. JEHOVAH-JIREH, jé-ho'va-ji’re (ANT TIM, yahweh yir'eh, “Jeh sees”): The name given by Abraham to the place where he had sacrificed a ram provided by God, instead of his son Isaac (Gen 22 14). The meaning plainly is that the Lord sees and provides for the necessities of His jé-hd’va, je-ha’va. See Gop, feporah-Nissi_ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1584 servants. There is an allusion to ver 8 where JEHOZADAK, jéhoz’a-dak Pir, yhoga- Abraham says, “God will provide himself [RVm “will see for himself”’] the lamb for a burnt offering.” The ver (14 AV) goes on to connect the incident with the popular proverb, “In the mount of the Lord it shall be seen” (RV “provided”), RVm suggests “‘he shall be seen.” “The mount of Jeh” in other places denotes the temple hill at Jerus (Ps 24 3; Isa 2 3, etc). With changes of the punctuation very different readings have been sug- gested. According to Swete’s text: ‘(And A. called the name of that place [the] ‘Lord saw’ [aorist] in order that they may say today: ‘In the mountain {the} Lord was seen’’’ (aorist). LXX reads, ‘In the mountain Jeh seeth,” or “‘will see.” If there is merely a verbal connection between the clauses we should most naturally read, ‘In the mount of Jeh one is seen [appears],’’ i.e. men, people, appear —the reference being to the custom of visiting the temple at pilgrimages (Driver, HDB, s.v.). But if the connection of the proverb with the name “Jehovah-jireh” depends on the double: sense of the word ‘‘see,” then the best explanation may be, Jeh sees the needs of those who come to worship before Him on Zion, and there ‘‘is seen,” i.e. reveals Him- self to them by answering their prayers and supply- ing their wants. His ‘‘seeing,”’ in other words, takes practical effect in a “being seen” (ibid). W. Ewtne JEHOVAH-NISSI, j-nis'i CO] MM, yahweh nissi, “Jeh is my banner’): So Moses named the altar which he reared to signalize the defeat of the Amalekites by Israel under Joshna, at Rephidim (Ex 17 15). LXX translates “the Lord my refuge,” de- riving nissi from O43, nis, ‘‘to flee.” Tg Onkelos reads, “Moses built an altar and worshipped on it before Jeh, who had wrought for him miracles’ (O72, nissin). The suggestion is that the people should rally round God as an army gathers round its standard. He it is who leads them to victory. JEHOVAH, SERVANT OF. See Servant or JEHOVAH. JEHOVAH-SHALOM, j.-sha’lom my mm, yahweh shalom, ‘‘Jeh is peace’): This was the name given by Gideon to the altar he built at Ophra, in allusion to the word spoken to him by the Lord, “Peace be unto thee” (Jgs 6 24). It is equivalent to “Jeh is well disposed.” JEHOVAH-SHAMMAB, j.-sham’a (TAY TIM, yahweh shammah, ‘‘Jeh is there”): The name ta be given to the new Jerus, restored and glorified, as seen in the vision of Ezk (48 35m; cf Rev 21 3). Jeh returns to the temple which He had forsaken, and from that time forward the fact of supreme importance is that He 7s there, dwelling in the midst of His people. JEHOVAH-TSIDKENU (CIDKEND), j.-tsid- kent, tsid’kéni (PTS TN, yahweh cidhkéna, “Jeh [is] our righteousness”): The symbolic name given (1) to the king who is to reign over the restored Israel (Jer 23 6); (2) to the state or capital (33 16). JEHOZABAD, jéhoz’a-bad (T3T, yhoza- bhddh, ‘‘Jeh has bestowed’): (1) A servant of King Jehoash of Judah. Ac- cording to 2 KK 12 21 (22), he was a son of Shomer, but 2 Ch 24 26 makes him “son of Shimrith the Moabitess.”’ (2) A Korahite doorkeeper, son of Obed-edom (1 Ch 26 4). (3) A Benjamite, one of King Jchoshaphat’s warriors (2 Ch 17 18). dhak, ‘‘Jeh is righteous”): Priest at the time of the captivity under Nebuchadrezzar (1 Ch 6 14.15 [Heb 5 40.41]). He was the father of Joshua (Jeshua) the priest (Hag 1 1.12.14; 2 2.4; Zec 6 11). V has Josedech in Hag and Zec. Same as “Jozadak” (PIE1, yocadhak, same meaning) in Ezr 3 2.8; 5 2; 10 18; Neh 12 26; and= “Josedek”’ (AV “Josedec”) of 1 Esd 5 5.48.56; 6 2; 9 19; Sir 49 12. JEHO, jé’hn (NM, yehw’; meaning uncertain, perhaps ‘Jeh is he?; 1 K 19 16.17; 2 K 9, 10; Elo, Hiow): Son of Jehoshaphat, and descendant of Nimshi, hence commonly called “the son of Nimshi”; 10th king of Israel, and founder of its IVth Dynasty. Jehu reigned for 28 years. His accession may be reckoned at ¢ 752 BC (some date a few years later). Jehu's Tribute—from Obelisk of Shalmaneser. A soldier of fortune, J. appears first as an officer in the body-gnard of Ahab. To himself we owe the information that he was present 1. Officer at the judicial murder of Naboth, and of Ahab that Naboth’s sons were put to death with their father (2 K 9 26). He was in attendance when Ahab drove from Samaria to inspect his new possession in Jezreel, and was wit- ness of the dramatic encounter at the vineyard between the king and the prophet Elijah (cf 1 K 21 16 ff). Years after, J. reminded Bidkar, his captain (lit. “thirdsman,” in chariot), of the decom they had there heard pronounced upon Ahab and his house (2 K 9 25 ff). It was in fulfilment of this doom that J. at that time ordered the body of the slain Jehoram to be thrown into the inclosure which had once been Naboth’s (ver 26). Ahab’s temporary repentance averted the punishment from himself for a few years (1 K 21 27-29), but the blow fell at the battle of Ramoth-gilead, and J. would not be unmindful of the prophet’s words as he beheld the dogs licking Ahab’s blood as they washed his chariot “by the pool of Samaria” (22 38). A different fate awaited Ahab’s two sons. The elder, Ahaziah, died, after a short reign, from the effects of an accident (2 K 1). He 2. Jehoram was succeeded by his brother Jehoram, at Ramoth- who toward the close of his reign of gileadand 12 years (2 K 3 1) determined on an Jezreel attempt to recover Ramoth-gilead, ; where his father had been fatally stricken, from Hazael, of Syria. Ramoth-gilead was taken (2 K 9 14), but in the attack the Israel- itish king was severely wounded, and was taken to Jezreel to be healed of his wounds (ver 15). The city meanwhile was left in charge of J. and his fellow-captains. At Jezreel he was visited by Ahaziah, of Judah, who had taken part with him in the war (8 28.29; 9 16). The time was now ripe for the execution of the redicted vengeance on the house of Ahab, and to lisha the prophet, the successor of Elijah, it fell 1585 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA ]2fovah-Nissi to take the decisive step which precipitated the crisis. Hazael and J. had already been named to Elijah as the persons. who were to 3. The execute the Divine judgment, the one Anointing as king of Syria, the other as king of Jehu —_- of Israel (1 K 19 15-17). Elijah was aa. doubtless aware of this commission, which it was now his part, as respected J., to ful- fil. A messenger was hastily dispatched to Ramoth- gilead, with instructions to seek out J., take him apart, anoint him king of Israel in Jeh’s name, and charge him with the task of utterly destroying the house of Ahab in punishment for the righteous blood shed by Ahab and Jezebel. The messenger was then to flee. This was done, and J., the sacred oil poured on his head, found himself alone with this appalling trust committed to him (2 K 9 1-10). Events now moved rapidly. J.’s companions were naturally eager to know what had happened, and on learning that J. had been 4. The anointed king, they at once impro- Revolution vised a throne by throwing their gar- —Death of ments on the top of some steps, blew Jehoram the trumpet, and proclaimed, “J. is king.” Not a moment was lost. No one was permitted to leave the city to carry forth tid- ings, and J. himself, with characteristic impetuos- ity, set out, with a small body of borsemen, in his chariot to Jezreel. Bidkar was there as charioteer (9 25). As they came within sight of the city, a watchman reported their advance, and niessengers were sent to inquire as to their errand. These were ordered to fall into the rear. This conduct awaken- ed suspicion, and Jehoram and Ahaziah—who was still with his invalided kinsman—ordered their chariots, and proceeded in person to meet J. The companies met at the ill-omened field of Naboth, and there the first stroke of vengeance fell. The anxious query, ‘Is it peace?’ was answered by a storm of denunciation from J., and on Jehoram turning to flee, an arrow from J.’s powerful bow shot him through the heart, and he sank dead in his chariot. Ahaziah likewise was pursued, and smitten “‘at the ascent of Gur, which is by Ibleam.” He died at Megiddo, and was taken to Jerus for burial in the sepulcher of the kings (9 11-28). A somewhat variant account of Ahaziah’s death is given in 2 Ch 22 9. It is possible that J. came to Megiddo or its neighborhood, and had to do with his end there. The slaughter of Jehoram was at once followed by that of the chief instigator of all the crimes for which the house of Ahab suffered—the queen- 5. Death mother Jezebel. Hot from the pur- of Jezehel suit of Ahaziab, J. pressed on Jezreel. Jezebel, now an aged woman, but still defiant, had painted and attired herself, and, looking from her window, met him as he drove into the palace court, with the insulting question, “Is it peace, thou Zimri, thy master’s murderer?” (cf 1 K 16 9-12). J.’s answer was an appeal for aid from those within. Two or three eunuchs of the palace gave signs of their concurrence. These, at J.’s bidding, threw Jezebel down into the court- yard, where, lying in her blood, she was trodden under foot by the chariot borses. When, a little later, her remains were sought for burial, she was found to have been almost wholly devoured by the dogs—a lurid commentary on Elijah’s earlier threatening, which was now recalled (2 K 9 30- 37). J. was an intrepid minister of judgment, but the pitiless zeal, needless cruelty, and, afterward, deceit, with which he executed his mission, with- draw our sympathy from him, as it did that of a later prophet (Hos 1 4). : The next acts of J. reveal yet more clearly his thoroughness of purpose and promptitude of action, while they afford fresh exhibitions of his ruthless- ness and unscrupulousness of spirit. Samaria was the capital of the kingdom, and head- 6. Slaughter quarters of the Baal-worship intro- of Ahah’s duced by Jezebel, though it is recorded Descend- of Jehoram that he had removed, at ants least temporarily, an obelisk of Baal which his father had set up (2 K 3 2; cf 10 26). The city was still held for the house of Ahab, and 70 of Ahab’s “sons’’—to be taken here in the large sense of male descendants—resided in it (40 1.6). J. bere adopted a bold and astute policy. He sent letters to Samaria challenging those in authority to set up one of their master’s sons as king, and fight for the city and the king- dom. The governors knew well that they could make no effective resistance to J., and at once humbly tendered their submission. J., in a second message, bade them prove their sincerity by de- livering to him the heads of the 70 princes of Ahab’s house in baskets. This they did, by their act irrevocably committing themselves to J.’s cause (ver 9). The ghastly relics were piled up in two heaps at the gate of Jezreel—a horrible object- lesson to any still inclined to hesitate in their alle- giance. Friends and partisans of the royal house shared the fate of its members (ver 11). Apart from the faultiness in the agent's motive, the deeds now recounted fell within the letter of J.'s com- mission. As much cannot be said of the h deeds of blood that follow. J. had killed 7. Slaug tet Ahaziah, king of Judah. Now, on his way of Ahaziah’s to Samaria, he met acompanyof 42 persons, Brethren described as ‘‘hbrethren of aziah "*— evidently blood-relations of various de- grees, as Ahaziah’s own brethren had been earlier slain by the Arabians (2 Ch 21 17; 92 1)—and, on learning who they were, and of their purpose to visit their kinsfolk at Jezreel, gave orders that they be slain on the spot, and their bodies ignominiously thrown in- to the pit (or ‘‘cistern’’) of the shearing-house where he had encountered them. It was a cruel excess for which no sufficient justification can he pleaded (2 K 10 12-14). Still less can the craft and violence be condoned by which, when he reached Samaria, J. evinced his “geal for Jeh” (ver 16) in the extirpa- 8. Massacre tion of the worshippers of Baal. J. of the Wor- had secured on his side the support of shippers of a notable man—Jehonadab the son of Baal Rechab (vs 15.16; ef Jer 35 6-19)— and his entrance into Samaria was sig- nalized by further slaying of all adherents of Ahab. Then, doubtless to the amazement of many, J. proclaimed himself an enthusiastic follower of Baal. A great festival was organized, to which all prophets, worshippers, and priests of Baal were invited from every part of Israel. J. himself took the leading part in the sacrifice (ver 25). Vestments were dis- tributed to distinguish the true worshippers of Baal from others. Then when all were safely gathered into “the house of Baal,’ the gates were closed, and 80 soldiers were sent in to massacre the whole de- luded company in cold blood. None‘escaped. The temple of Baal was broken up. Thus, indeed, ‘J. destroyed Baal out of Israel” (ver 28), but at what a frightful cost of falsehood and treacherous deal- ing! (2K 10 18-28). The history of J. in the Bible is chiefly the history of his revolution as now narrated. His reign itself is summed up in a few vs, chiefly occu- 9. Wars ied with the attacks made by Hazael, with Hazael king of Syria, on the trans-Jordanic territories of Israel (10 32.33). These districts were overrun, and remained lost to Israel till the reign of J.’s great-grandson, Jeroboam II (2 K 14 28). is i irection, viz. to the annals of Assyria, See nee oe ony Waar information we noseees the reign of J. In these annals, fortunately, some Po aresting notices are preserved. In 854 BC was fought Jehubbah Jeremiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1586 the great battle of Karkar (a place between Aleppo and Hamath), when Shalmaneser Ii, king of Assyria, de- feated a powerful combination formed 10. Assyrian 48ainst him (Damascus, Hamath, Philistia, Noti Ammon, etc). Among the allies on this oc- ouces casion is mentioned ‘‘ Ahabbu of Sir’ilaa,”’ who took the third place with 2,000 chariots and 10,000 footmen. There is a difficulty in supposing Ahab to have been still reigning as late as 854, and Well- hausen, Kamphausen and others have suggested that Ahab’s name has been confused with that of his successor Jehoramin the Assyrannals. Kittel, in his History of the Hebrews (£1, 233, ET) is disposed to accept this view. .G. Smith, in his Assyr Hponym Canon (179), is of the opinion that the tribute lists were often carelessly compiled and in error as to names. The point of interest is that from this time Israel was evidently a tributary of Assyria. _ With this accord the further notices of Israel in_the inscriptions of Shalmaneser II, two in number. Both belong to the year 842 BC and _ relate 11. Tribute to J. On Shalmaneser's Black Obelisk 5 is a pictorial representation of ‘‘ the tribute of Jehu of P ; . son of Omri.” An ambassador kneels before the conqueror, and presents his gifts. They include silver, gold, a gold cup, gold vessels, a golden ladle, lead, a staff for the king’s hand, scepters. An allusion to the same event occurs in the annals of Shalmaneser’s campaign against Hazael of ‘At that time I received the tribute Syria in this year. Onri.’ of the Tyrians, Sidonians, of J., son of There are some indications that in his latter years, which were clouded with misfortune, J. associated with himself his son Jehoahaz in the government (cf2 K 13 1.10, where Jehoahaz comes to the throne in the 23d, and dies in the 37th year of Jehoash of Judah—14 years—yet has a total reign of 17 years). J. is not mentioned in Ch, except in- cidentally in connection with the death of Ahaziah ae 22 9), and as the grandfather of Jehoash (25 1 The character of J. is apparent from the acts re- corded of him. His energy, determination, prompti- tude, and zeal fitted him for the work he had to do. It was rough work, and was executed with relentless thoroughness. Probably gentler meas- ures would have failed to eradicate Baal-worship from Israel. His impetuosity was evinced in his furious driving (2 K 9 20). He was bold, daring, unscrupulous, and masterful and astute in his policy. But one seeks in vain in his character for any touch of magnanimity, or of the finer qualities of the ruler. His ‘zeal for Jeh” was too largely a cloak for merely worldly ambition. The blood- shed in which his rule was founded early provoked a reaction, and his closing years were dark with trouble. He is specially condemned for tolerating the worship of the golden calves (2 K 10 29-31). Nevertheless the throne was secured to his dynasty for four generations (10 30; cf 15 12). W. Saw CaLpEcorr JEHUBBAHG, jé-hub’a (MAM, yhubbah, meaning unknown): A descendant of Asher, mentioned in 1 Ch 7 34, where Keré is MAM), whubbah, “and Hubbah,” but Kethibh is MAM, yahbah; LXX B follows Keré. JEHUCAL, j&hi’kal (2257, yhakhal, probably meaning ‘“Jeh is able’): A courtier sent by King Zedekiah to Jeremiah to ask the prophet to pra: for the king and the people (Jer 37 3). Most VS except LXX, with 38 1, have ‘“Jucal’?? O2a™, yikhal, same meaning). JEHUD, jé’hud (717), yhudh): A town in the lot of Dan named between Baalath and Bene-berak (Josh 19 45). The only possible identification seems to be with el-Yehudiyeh, which lies about 8 miles E. of Jaffa. JEHUDI, jé-ho’di CT, yhudhi, properly “a Jew’): An officer of King Jehoiakim (Jer 36 14.21. 23). He was sent by the princes to summon Baruch to read the roll containing Jeremiah’s prophecies to them; he afterward read them to the king, who destroyed them. His name is note- worthy, as also is that of his grandfather Cushi (i.e. “Ethiopian’’), and the two are said to point to a foreign origin. JEHUDIJAH, jé-bt-di’ja (1 Ch 4 18 AV). See Ha-JEHUDIJAH. JEHUEL, jéhi’el (Kethibh 2837, yha’al; but Keré 28°17", yh?’ él, i.e. “Jehiel” AV, in 2 Ch 29 14): A Levite; see JBHIEL, (5). JEHUSH, jé’hush (1 Ch 8 39). JEIEL, jéj’el CT, ye? a, meaning unknown): (1) A Reubenite (1 Ch 6 7). (2) In 1 Ch 8 29, added in RV from 9 35, where Kethibh is ‘“Jeuel,” an ancestor of King Saul; AV “Jehiel.”” (3) One of David’s mighty men (1 Ch 11 44). AV is “Jehiel”; Kethibh is ‘Jeuel.” | (4) A Levite, keeper of the ark with Obed-edom (1 Ch 15 18.21; 16 5; 2 Ch 20 14), called “Je- hiah” in 1 Ch 15 24. (5) A Levite (1 Ch 16 5)=“Jaaziel” of 1 Ch 15 18 (q.v.). : (6) Ascribe under King Uzziah (2 Ch 26 11). (7) A chief of the Levites, present at King Jo- siah’s great Passover feast (2 Ch 36 9). | ; (8) One of those who had married foreign wives (Ezr 10 43)=‘‘Juel” in 1 Esd 9 35. . (9) AVin2 Ch 29 14; see Jenten, (5). (10) AV in Ezr 8 13; see JEvsL, (8). Davip Francis Roperts JEKABZELi, jékab'zé-el Od YAP , yckabhe’ él, “God gathers’; Neh 11 25). See Kaszrgt. JEKAMEAM, jek-a-mé’am, j&kam’é-am (OP"p", ykam‘am, probably “may kinsman establish’’): Head of a Levitical house (1 Ch 23 19; 24 23). The meaning of the name depends upon that of DY (‘am) in compound names; see HPN, 46, 51 ff. JEKAMIAG, jek-a-mi’a (M37, ytkamyah, “may Jeh establish”): (1) A Judahite, son of Shallum (1 Ch 2 41). (2) Ason of King Jeconiah (Jehoiachin); in AV ‘Jecamiah”’ (1 Ch 3 18). JEKUTHIEL, jé-kt'thi-el Gxnp., yckiahi él, meaning doubtful): A Judahite (1 Ch 4 18). The meaning ao be “preservation of God,” or perhaps the same as SNMP", yokthe’él, “Joktheel,” the name of aplace in Josh 15 38; 2 K 14 7. JEMIMAR, jé-mi’ma (WA" , yemimah, perhaps a diminutive meaning “little dove’): The first daughter of Job (42 14), born after his restoration from affliction. JEMNAAN, jem’né-an ('Iepvaav, Jemndan): A city on the coast of Pal; mentioned among those affected by the expedition of Holofernes (Jth 2 28; 3 1 ff). The name is used for Jabniel, generally called ‘“Jamnia’’ by the Gr writers. JEMUEL, jémiel Oxwa, yem@él, meaning unknown): A “son” of Simeon (Gen 46 10; Ex 6 15)=“‘Nemuel” in Nu 26 12; 1 Ch 4 24. Syr version has ‘‘Jemuel’’ in the 4 passages, but Gray (HPN, 307, n. 6) thinks ‘‘Jemuel’' is more probably a cor- rection in Gen than ‘‘Nemuel”’ in Nu. JEOPARD, jep’ard, JEOPARDY, jep’ar-di: The Eng. word referred originally to a game where See JEuss, (3). 1587 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jehubbah Jeremiah the chances were even (from OFr. jeu parti); trans- ferred thence to designate any great risk. In the NT, represented by the Gr vb. kinduneid (Lk 8 23; 1 Cor 15 30). In the OT (Jgs 6 18) for a Heb idiom, “despise the soul,” i.e. they placed a smal] value upon their lives (Vulg “offered their souls to death”); for elliptical expression, “went with their lives,” in 2 S 23 17m. JEPHTHAH, jef’tha (MIAD", yiphtah, “opened,” or “opener,” probably signifying “Jeh will open”; "TepOde, Tephthde; used as the name of a place, as in Josh 16 43; 19 14; of aman, Jgs 10 6—12 7): Ninth judge of the Israelites. His antecedents are obscure. Assuming Gilead to be the actual name of his father, his mother was a harlot. He was driven from home on account of his illegitimacy, and went to the land of Tob in Eastern Syria (Jgs 11 2.3). Here he and his followers lived the life of freebooters. The Israelites beyond the Jordan being in danger of an invasion by the Ammonites, J. was invited by the elders of Gilead to be their leader (11 5.6). Remembering how they had expelled him from their territory and his heritage, J. demanded of them that in the event of success in the struggle with the Am- monites, he was to be continued as leader. This condition being accepted he returned to Gilead (11 7-11). The account of the diplomacy used by J. to prevent the Ammonites from invading Gilead is possibly an interpolation, and is thought by many interpreters to be a compilation from Nu 20-21. It is of great interest, however, not only because of the fairncss of the argument used (11 12-28), but also by virtue of the fact that it con- tains a history of the journey of the Israelites from Lower Egypt to the banks of the Jordan. This history is distinguished from that of the Pent chiefly by the things omitted. If diplomacy was tried, it failed to dissuade the Ammonites from seek- ing to invade Israel. J. prepared for battle, but before taking the field paused at Mizpeh of Gilead, and registered a vow that if he were successful in battle, he would offer as a burnt offering to Jeh whatsoever should first come from his doors to greet him upon his return (11 29-31). The battle is fought, J. is the victor, and now his vow returns to him with anguish and sorrow. Returning to his home, the first to greet him is his daughter and only child. The father’s sorrow and the courage of the daughter are the only bright lights on this sordid, cruel conception of God and of the nature of sacri- fice. That the sacrifice was made seems certain from the narrative, although some critics choose to substitute for the actual death of the maiden the setting the girl apart for a life of perpetual virginity. The Israclitish laws concerning sacri- fices and the language used in 11 39 are the chief arguments for the latter interpretation. The entire narrative, however, will hardly bear this construction (11 34-40). J. was judge in Israel for 6 years, but appears only once more in the Scripture narrative. The men of Ephraim, offended because they had had no share in the victory over the Ammonites, made war upon Gilead, but were put to rout by the forces under J. (12 1-6). C, E. Scaenk JEPHUNNEH, jé-fun’e (7127, y’phunneh, mean- ing uncertain): (1) Father of Caleb (Nu 13 6; 14 6.30, etc). According to Nu 13 6, he was of the tribe of Judah; according to 32 12; Josh 14 6, a Kenizzite; the Keniz- zites were incorporated in Judah (cf 1 Ch 4 13-15). (2) Ason of Jether, an Asherite (1 Ch 7 38). JERAH, jé’ra (772, yerah): A son of Joktan (Gen 10 26 ||1 Ch 1 20). No district Jerah has been discovered. However, Yurakh in Yemen and Yarah in Hijaz are places named by the Arab. geographers. The fact that the word in Heb means “moon” has led to the following suggestions: the Bana Hilal (‘‘sons of the new moon”) in the N. of Yemen; Ghubb el-Kamar (“the bay of the moon”), Jebel el-Kamar (“the mountains of the moon’) in Eastern Hadramant. But in Southern Arabia wor- ship of the moon has caused the word to bulk largely in place-names. JERAHMEEL, jé-ra’mé-el ONAN, y*rahm a, “may God have compassion!”): (iy In 1 Ch 2 9.25.26.27.33.42, he is described as the son of Hezron, the son of Perez, the son of Judah by Tamar his daughter-in-law (Gen 38). In 18 27 10 is mentioned the neghebh of the Jerahmeelites, jé-rai/mé-el-its ((PNAMMD , ha-yrah- m° élt, a collective noun), RV “the South of the Jerahmeelites.”’ The latter is a tribal name in use probably before the proper name, above; their cities are mentioned iu 1 S 30 29. Cheyne has radical views on J. See EB, 8.v.; also T. Witton Davies in Review of Theology and Philosophy, III, 689-708 (May, 1908); and Cheyne’s replies in Hibbert Journal, VII, 182-51 (October, 1908), and Decline and Fall of the Kingdom of Judah. (2) A Merarite Levite, son of Kish (1 Ch 24 29). (3) “The king’s son,” RV and AVm (Jer 36 26). RVm, AV have “son of Hammelech,”’ taking the word yan aS aproper name. He was “probably a royal prince, one who had a king among his an- cestors but not necessarily son of the ruling king; so 38 6; 1 K 22 260; esp. Zeph 1 8 written at a time when the reigning king, Josiah, could not have had a grown-up ‘son’” (Driver, Jer, 224,n.¢). J. was with two others commanded by Jehoiakim to arrest Jeremiah and Baruch. : : Davin Francis Roserts JERECHU, jer’é-ki, AV Jerechus, jer’é-kus (1 Esd 5 22). See Jenicuo. JERED, jé’red (T)3, yeredh, “descent”): A Judahite, father of Gedor (1 Ch 4 18). See also JARED. JEREMAI, jer’é-mi, jer-é-ma'i (27), yrémay, meaning unknown): One of those who had married foreign wives (Ezr 10 33). See Jeremias (1 Esd 9 34). JEREMIAH, jer-é-mi’a ([a] WANN), yirmeyaha, or [b] shorter form, "A'S", yirmeyah, both differently explained as “Jeh establishes [so Giesebrecht], whom Jeh casts,” i.e. possibly, as Gesenius suggests, “appoints” [A. B. Davidson in HDB, II, 569a], and “Jeh looseneth” [the womb]; see BDB): The form (b) is used of Jeremiah the prophet only in Jer 27 1; 28 5.6.10.11.12b.15; 29 1; Ezr 1 1; Dnl 9 2, while the other is found 116 t in Jer alone. In 1 Esd 1 28.32.47.57; 2 Esd 2 18, EV has “Jeremy,” so AV in 2 Macc 2.1.5.7; Mt 217; 279; in Mt 16 14, AV has “Jeremias,” but RV in 2 Macc and Mt has “Jeremiah.” i: : (1) The prophet. See special article. Of the fol- lowing, (2), (8) and (4) have form (a) above; the others the form (0). : (2) Father of Hamutal (Hamital), the mother of King Jehoahaz and King Jeboiakim (2 K 23 31; 24 18 || Jer 62 1). (3) A Rechabite (Jer 36 3). ; (4) In 1 Ch 12 13 (Heb 14), a Gadite. (5) In 1 Ch 12 10 (Heb 11), a Gadite. — (6) In 1 Ch 12 4 (Heb 5), a Benjamite(?) or Judaean. (4), (5) and (6) all joined David at Ziklag. Jeremiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1588 (7) Head of a Manassite family (1 Ch 5 24). (8) A priest who sealed the covenant with Nehe- miah (Neh 10 2), probably the same as he of 12 34 who took part in the procession at the dedication of the walls of Jerus. (9) A priest who went to Jerus with Zerubbabel from exile and became head of a priestly family of that name (Neh 12 1). Davin Francis RoBerts JEREMIAH, jer-é-mi’a: . Name and Person . Life of Jeremiah . The Personal Character of Jeremiah . The Prophecies of Jeremiah . The Book of Jeremiah . Authenticity and Integrity of the Book - Relation to the LXX LireERATURE The name of one of the greatest prophets of Israel. The Heb 377, yirmeyahi, abbreviated to 717), yirm'yah, signifies either 1. Name ‘“Jeh hurls’ or “Jeh founds.” LXX and Person reads ‘Iepulas, Termias, and the Vulg Jeremias. As this name also occurs not infrequently, the prophet is called ‘the son of Hilkiah” (1 1), who is, however, not the high priest mentioned in 2 K 22 and 23, as it is merely stated that he was “of the priests that were in Anathoth” in the land of Benjamin. In Anathoth, now Anda, a small village 13 hours N.E. of Jerus, lived a class of priests who belonged to a side line, not to the line of Zadok (cf 1 K 2 26). J. was called by the Lord to the office of a prophet while still a youth (1 6) about 20 years of age, in the 13th year of King Josiah (1 2; 25 2. Life of 3), in the year 627 BC, and was active Jeremiah in this capacity from this time on to the destruction of Jerus, 586 BC, under kings Josiah, Jehoahaz, Jehoiakim, Jehoiachin, and Zedekiah. Even after the fall of the capital city he prophesied in Egypt at least for several years, so that his work extended over a period of about 50 years in all. At first he probably lived in Anathoth, and put in his appearance publicly in Jerus only on the occasion of the great festivals; later he lived in Jerus, and was there during the terrible times of the siege and the destruction of the NTO Crib Gobo city. ‘Alchough King Josiah was God-fearing and willing to serve Jeh, and soon inaugurated his reformation according to the law of Jeh (in the 18th year of his reign), yet J., at the time when he was called to the prophetic office, was not left in doubt of the fact that the catastrophe of the judgment of God over the city would soon come (1 11 ff); and when, after a few years, the Book of the Law was found in the temple (2 K 22 and 23), J. preached ‘the words of this covenant” to the people in the town and throughout the land (11 1-8; 17 19-27), and exhorted to obedience to the Divine command; but in doing this then and afterward he became the object of much hostility, esp. in his native city, Anathoth. Even his own brethren or near rela- tives entered into a conspiracy against him by de- claring that he was a dangerous fanatic (12 6). However, the condition of J. under this pious king was the most happy in his career, and he lamented the latter’s untimely death in sad lyrics, which the author of Ch was able to use (2 Ch 35 25), but which have not come down to our times. Much more unfavorable was the prophet’s condi- tion after the death of Josiah. Jehoahaz-Shallum, who ruled only 3 months, received the announce- ment of his sentence from J. (22 10ff). Jehoiakim (609-598 BC) in turn favored the heathen worship, and oppressed the people through his love of luxury and by the erection of grand structures (Jer 22 13 ff). In addition, his politics were treacherous. He conspired with Egypt against his superior, Nebuchadnezzar. Epoch-making was the 4th year of Jehoiakim, in which, in the battle of Carchemish, the Chaldaeans gained the upper hand in Hither Asia, as J. had predicted (46 1-12). Under Jehoiakim J. delivered his great temple dis- course (7-9; 10 17-25). The priests for this reason determined to have the prophet put to death (ch 26). However, influential elders inter- ceded for him, and the princes yet showed some justice. He was, however, abused by the authorities at the appeal of the priests (ch 20). According to 36 1ff, he was no longer permitted to enter the place of the temple. For this reason the Lord com- manded him to collect his prophecies in a book- - roll, and to havethem read to the people by his faithful pupil Baruch (ch 36; cf ch 45). The book fell into the hands of the king, who burned it. However, J. dictated the book a second time to Baruch, together with new additions. Jehoiachin or Coniah (22 24 ff), the son of Je- hoiakim, after a reign of 3 months, was taken into captivity to Babylon by Nebuchadnezzar, together with a large number of his nobles and the best part of the people (Jer 24 1; 29 2), as the prophet had predicted (22 20-30). But conditions did not Improve under Zedekiah (597-586 BC). | This king was indeed not as hostile to J. as Jehoiakim had been; but all the more hostile were the princes and the generals, who were now in command after the better class of these had been deported to Baby- lon. They continually planned rebellion against Babylon, while J. was compelled to oppose and put to naught every patriotic agitation of this kind. Finally, the Bab army came in order to punish the faithless vassal who had again entered into an alliance with Egypt. J. earnestly advised sub- mission, but the king was too weak and too coward- ly as against his nobles. A long siege resulted, which caused the direst sufferings im the life of J. The commanders threw him into a vile prison, charging him with being a traitor (87 11 ff). The king, who consulted him secretly, released him from prison, and put him into the “court of the guard” (387 17 ff), where he could move around freely, and could again prophesy. Now that the judgment had come, he could again speak of the hopeful future (chs 32, 33). Also chs 30 and 31, probably, were spoken about this time. But as he continued to preach submission to the people, those in authority cast him into a slimy cistern, from which the pity of a courtier, Ebed-melech, delivered him (39 15-18). He again returned to the court of the guard, where he remained until Jerus was taken. After the capture of the city, J. was treated with great consideration by the Babylonians, who knew that be had spoken in favor of their government (39 11 ff; 40 1ff). They gave him the choice of going to Babylon or of remaining in his native land. He decided for the latter, and went to the governor Gedaliah, at Mizpah, a man worthy of all confi- dence. But when this man, after a short time, was murdered by conscienceless opponents, the Jews who had been left: in Pal, becoming alarmed and fearing the vengeance of the Chaldaeans, determined to emigrate to Egypt. J. advised against this most earnestly, and threatened the vengeance of Jeh, if the people should insist upon their undertaking (42 1 ff). But they insisted and even compelled the aged prophet to go with them (43 1ff). Their first goal was Tahpanhes (Daphne), a town in Lower Egypt. At this place he still continued to preach the word of God to his fellow-Israelites; of the latest of his preserved discourses in 43 8-13, as also the sermon in ch 44, delivered at a somewhat later time but yet before 570 BC. At that time J. must have been from 70 to 80 years old. He 1589 at Daphne by the Jews (Jerome, Adv. Jovin, ii, 37; Tertullian, Contra Gnosi., viii; Pseudepiphan,, De Proph., ch viii; Dorotheus, 146; Isidorus, Ort. et Obit. Pair., ch xxxviil). However, this report is not well founded. The same is the case with the rabbinical tradition, according to which he, in com- pany with Baruch, was taken from Egypt to Baby- lon by Nebuchadnezzar, and died there (Sédher ‘Olam Rabba’ 26). The Book of Jer gives us not only a fuller account of the life and career of its author than do the books f of the other prophets, but we also 3. Personal learn more about his own inner and Character personal life and feelings than we do of Jeremiah of Isaiah or any other prophet. From this source we learn that he was, by nature, gentle and tender in his feelings, and sym- pathetic. A decided contrast to this is found in the hard and _unmerciful judgment which it was his mission to announce. God made him strong and firm and immovable like iron for his mission (1 18; 15 20). This contrast between his naturally warm personal feelings and his strict Divine mis- sion not rarely appears in the heart-utterances found in his prophecies. At first he rejoiced when God spoke to him (15 16); but soon these words of God were to his heart a source of pain and of suffering (15 17 ff). He would have preferred not to utter them; and then they burned in his breast as a fire (20 7ff; 239). He personally stood in need of love, and yet was not permitted to marry (16 1f). He was compelled to forego the pleasures of youth (15 17). He loved his people as nobody else, and yet was always compelled to prophesy evil for it, and seemed to be the enemy of his nation. This often caused him to despair. The enmity to which he fell a victim, on account of his declaration of nothing but the truth, he deeply felt; see his complaints (9 1 ff; 12 5f; 15 10; 17 14-18; 18 23, and often). In this sad antagonism between his heart and the commands of the Lord, he would perhaps wish that God had not spoken to him; he even cursed the day of his birth (15 10; 20 14-18; ef Job 3 1ff). Such complaints are to be carefully distinguished from that which the Lord through His Spirit communicated to the prophet. God rebukes him for these complaints, and demands of him to repent and to trust and obey Him (15 19). This discipline makes him all the more unconquerable. Even his bitter denunciations of his enemies (11 20 ff; 15 15, 17 18; 18 21-23) originated in part in his passionate and deep nature, and show how eat is the difference between him and that perfect ufferer, who prayed even for His deadly enemies. But J. was nevertheless a type of that Suffering Saviour, more than any of the OT saints. He, as a priest, prayed for his people, until God forbade him to do so (7 16; 11 14; 14 11; 18 20). He was compelled more than all the others to suffer through the anger of God, which was to afflict his people. The people themselves also felt that he meant well to them. A proof of this is seen in the fact that the rebellious people, who always did the contrary of what he had commanded them, forced him, the unwelcome prophet of God, to go along with them, to Egypt, because they felt that he was their good genius. 2 What J. was to preach was the judgment upon Judah. As the reason for this judgment J. every- where mentioned the apostasy from 4. The Jeh, the idolatry, which was practised Prophecies on baméth, or the “high places” by of Jeremiah Judah, as this had been done by Israel. Many heathenish abuses had found their way into the life of the people. Outspoken THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA probably died soon after this in Egypt. The | heathenism had been introduced by such men as church Fathers report that he was stoned to death | King Manasseh, even the sacrifice of children to the Jeremiah honor of Baal-Molech in the valley of Hinnom (7 31; 19 5; 32 35), and the worship of “‘the queen of heaven” (7 18; 44 19). It is true that the reformation of Josiah swept away the worst of these abominations. But an inner return to Jeh did not result from this reformation. For the reason that the improvement had been more on the surface and outward, and was done to please the king, J. charges up to his people all their previous sins, and the guilt of the pica generation was yet added 6 this (16 lif). Together with religious insin optity went the moral corruption of the people, such as dis- honesty, injustice, oppression of the helpless, slander, and the like. Compare the accusations found in & 1ff.7f£.26 ff; 6 7.13; 75.9; 9 26.8; 17 Off; 21 12; 22 13 ff; 23 10; 29 23, etc. Esp. to the spiritual leaders, the priests and prophets, are these things charged up. The judgment which is to come in the near future, as a, punishment for the sins of the people, is from the outset declared to be the conquest of the country through an enemy from abroad. In this way the heated caldron with the face from the N., in the vision containing the call of the prophet (1 13 ff), is to be understood. This power in the N. is not named until the 4th year of Jehoiakim (ch 25), where Nebuchadnezzar is definitely designated as the conqueror. It is often thought, that, in the earlier years of his career, J. had in mind the Scythians when he spoke of the enemies from the N., esp. in chs 4-6. The Scythians (according to Herodotus i.103 ff) had, probably a few years before J.’s call to the prophetic office, taken pos- session of Media, then marched through Asia Minor, and even forced their way as far as Egypt. They crossed through Canaan, passing by on their march from E. to W., near Beth-shean (Scythopolis). The ravages of this fierce people probably influenced the language used by J. in his prophecies (cf 4 11 ff; 6 15 ff; 6 3.22 ff). But it is unthinkable that J. expected nothing more than a plundering and a booty-seeking expedition of the Scythian nomad hordes. Chariots, such as are described in 4 13, the Scythians did not possess. Moreover, it must not be forgotten that J. from the outset speaks of a deportation of his people to this foreign land (3 18; & 19), while an exile of Israel in the country of the Scythians was out of the question. At all events from the 4th year of Jehoiakim, J. regards the Chaldaeans as the enemy who, according to his former announcement, would come from the N. It is possible that it was only in the course of time that he reached a clear conviction as to what nation was meant by the revelation from God. But, upon further reflection, he must have felt almost certain on this subject, esp. as Isaiah (39 6), Micah (4 10), and, soon after these, Habakkuk had named Baby- lon as the power that was to carry out the judgment upon Israel. Other prophets, too, regard the Baby- lonians as belonging to the northern group of na- tions (cf Zec 6 8), because they always came from the N., and because they were the legal successors of the Assyrians. ~ | In contrast to optimistic prophets, who had hoped to remedy matters in Israel (6 14), J. from the beginning predicted the destruction of the city and of the sanctuary, as also the end of the Jewish na- tion and the exile of the people through these enemies from abroad. According to 25 11; 29 10, the Bab supremacy (not exactly the exile) wasto con- tinue for 70 years; and after this, deliverance should come. Promises to this effect are found only now and then in the earlier years of the prophet (3 14 fi; 12 14ff; 16 14f). However, during the time of the siege and afterward, such predictions are Jeremiah Jeremy, Ep. of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1590 more frequent (cf 23 1 ff; 24 6f; 47 2-7; and in the “Book of Comfort,” chs 30-33). _ What characterizes this prophet is the spiritual inwardness of his religion; the external theocracy he delivers up to destruction, because its forms were not animated by God-fearmg sentiments. Ex- ternal circumcision is of no value without imner purity of héart. The external temple will be de- stroyed, because it has become the hiding-place of sinners. External sacrifices have no value, because those who offer them are lacking in spirituality, and this is displeasing to God. The law is abused and misinterpreted (8 8); the words of the prophets as a rule do not come from God. Even the Ark of the Covenant is eventually to make way for a glori- ous presence of the Lord. The law is to be written in the hearts of men (31 31 ff). The glories of the Messianic times the prophet does not describe in detail, but their spiritual character he repeatedly describes in the words “Jeh our righteousness”’ (23 6; 33 16). However, we must not overesti- mate the idealism of J. He believed in a realistic restoration of the theocracy to a form, Just as the other prophets (cf chs 31, 32, 38-40). As far as the form of his prophetic utterances is concerned, J. is of a poetical nature; but he was not only a poet. He often speaks in the meter of an elegy; but he is not bound by this, and readily passes over into other forms of rhythms and also at times into prosaic speech, when the contents of his discourses require it. The somewhat monoto- nous and elegiac tone, which is in harmony with his sad message to the people, gives way to more lively and varied forms of expression, when the prophet speaks of other and foreign nations. In doing this he often makes use of the utterances of earlier prophets. The first composition of the book is reported in 36 1ff. In the 4th year of Jehoiakim, at the command of Jeh, he dictated all of the prophe- 5. The cies he had spoken down to this time Book of to his pupil Baruch, who wrote them Jeremiah oon a roll. After the destruction of this book-roll by the king, he would not be stopped from reproducing the contents again and making additions to it (86 32). In this we have the origin of the present Book of Jer. This book, however, not only received further additions, but has also been modified. While the discourses may originally have been arranged chronologically, and these reached only down to the 4th year of King Jehoiakim, we find in the book, as it is now, as early as 21 1ff; 23 1ff; 26 1ff, discourses from the times of Zedekiah. However, the 2d edition (36 28) contained, no doubt, ch 25, with those addresses directed against the heathen nations extant at that time. The lack of order, from a chronological point of view, in the present book, is attributable also to the fact that historical accountsor appendices concerning the career of J. were added to the book in later times,.e.g. chs 26, 36, 36 and others; and in these additions are also found older discourses of the prophet. Beginning with ch 37, the story of the prophet during the siege of Jerus and after the destruction of the city is reported, and in con- nection with this are his words and discourses belonging to this period. It is a question whether these pieces, which are more narrative in character, and which are the prod- uct of a contemporary, probably Baruch, at one time constituted a book by themselves, out of which they were later taken and incorporated in the book of the prophet, or whether they were inserted by Baruch. In favor of the first view, it may be urged that they are not always found at their proper places chronologically; e.g. ch 26 is a part of the temple discourse in chs 7-9. However, this ‘Book of Baruch,”’ which is claimed by some critics to have existed as a separate book beside that of Jer, would not furnish a connected biography, and does not seem to have been written for biographical purposes. It contains introductions to certain words and speeches of the prophet and statements of what the consequences of these had been. Thus it is more probable that Baruch, at a later time, made supple- mentary additions to the original book, which the prophet had dictated without any personal data. But in this work the prophet himself may have coéperated. At places, perhaps, the dictation of the prophet ends in a narrative of Baruch (19 14— 0. 6), or vice versa. Baruch seems to have written a historical introduction, and then J. dictated the prophecy (27 1; 18 1; 32 1ff, and others). Of course, the portions of the book which came from the pen of Baruch are to be regarded as an authentic account. However, critics have denied to J. and his pupil certain sections of the present book, and they claim that these belong to a later date. 6. Authen- Among these is 10 1-16, containing a ticity and warning to those in the exile against Integrity of idolatry (and related to Isa 40 ff), the Book which, it is claimed, could not possibly in this form and fulness be the work of J. Also 17 19-27 is without reason denied to J., upon the ground that he could not have thought of emphasizing the Sabbath law. He was, however, no modern idealist, but respected also the Divine ordinances (cf 11 1-8). Then ch 26 is rejected by some, while others attack esp. vs 12-14 and 27- 38; but in both cases without reason. On the other hand, we admit that ver 25 and also vs 13f are later additions. The words, ‘all that is written in this book, which J. hath prophesied against all the nations,” are probably a superscription, which has found its way into the text. In ver 26 the words, “and the king of Sheshach shall drink after them,” are likewise considered spurious. Sheshach is rightly regarded here, as in 61 41, asa cipher for “Babel,” but the use of ’Ai-bash (a cipher in which the order of the letters of the Heb alphabet is re- versed, M for &, W for 3, etc, hence SHtSHaKH= BaBHeL, see the comms.) does not prove spurious- ness. The sentence is not found inthe LXX. The attacks made on chs 30 and 31 are of little moment. 33 14-26 is not found in the LXX, and its contents, too, belong to the passages in Jer that are most vigorously attacked. Critics regard J. as too spirit- ual to have perpetnated the Levitical priesthood. In ch 39, vs 1.2.4-10 are evidently additions that do not belong to this place. The remaining portion can stand. Among the discourses against the nations, chs 46-61, those in 46 1-12, spoken immediately pre- ceding the battle of Carchemish, cannot be shown to be unauthentic; even vs 13-28 are also genuine. The fact, however, is that the text has suffered very much. Nor are there any satisfactory reasons against the prophecy in chs 47-49, if we assume that J. reasserted some of his utterances against the heathen nations that did not seem to have been entirely fulfilled. Chs 60 and 61, the discourses against Babylon, have the distinct impress of J. This impression is stronger than the doubts, which, however, are not without weight. The events in 61 59 ff, which are not to be called into question, presuppose longer addresses of J. against Babylon. The possibility, however, remains that the editing of these utterances as found in the present book dates from the time after 586 BC. That any in- fluence of Deutero-Isaiah or later authors can be traced in Jer cannot be shown with any certainty. Ch 52 was written neither by Jeremiah nor for his book, but is taken from the Books of K, and is found there almost verbatim (2 K 24, 25). 1591 A special probiem is furnished by the relation of the text of Jer to the Alexandrian version of the Seventy (LXX). Not anly does the Heh form of 7, Relation the hook differ from the Gr materially, to the LXX much more than this is the case in other Oo the books of the OT, but the arrangement, too, is a different one. The oracle concerning the heathen nations (chs 46-51) is in the LXX found in the middle of ch 25, and that, too, in an altogether differ- ent order (viz. 49 35 f.46; 60; 51; 47 1-7; 49 7-22; 49 1-5.28-33.23-27; 48). In addition, the readings throughout the bock in many cases are divergent, the text in the LXX heing in general shorter and more com- pact. The Gr text has ahout 2,700 Heb wards less than ule Authenie Heb text, and is thus ahout one-eighth orter. As far as the insertion of the addresses against the heathen nations in ch 29 is concerned, the Gr order is certainly not more original than is the Heb. It rather tears apart, awkwardly, what is united in ch 25, and has probahly been caused by a misunderstanding. The words of 25 13 were regarded as a hint that here the discourses against the heathen were to follaw. Then, too, the order of these discourses in the Gr text is less natural than the one in Heb. In regard to the readings of the text, it has been thought that the text of the LXX deserves the preference on account of its brevity, and that the Heh text had been increased hy additions. However, in general, the Gr version is very free, and often is done without an understanding of the subject; and there are reasons to believe that the translator shortened the text, when he thought the style of Jeremiah too heavy. Then, too, where he met with repetitions, he probahiy would omit; or did so when he found trouble with the matter or the language. This does not deny that his tr in many places may he correct, and that addi- tions may have heen made to the Heb text. LiteratuRE.—Calvin, Praelectiones in Librum FPro- phetiae Jer ef Thren, Geneva, 1653; Sebastian Schmidt, Commentarii in libr. prophet. Jer, Argent, 1685. _Modern comm. hy Hitzig, Ewald, Graf, Nagelsbach, Keil; also Cheyne (Pulpit Comm.), Peake, Duhm, and von Orelli. C. von ORELLI JEREMIAH, EPISTLE OF. See JEREmMy, THE EPIstLe oF. JEREMIAH, THE LAMENTATIONS OF. See LAMENTATIONS. JEREMIAS, jer-é-mi'as (Iepeplas, Ieremias): (1) Named among the sons of Baani as one of those who had married foreign wives (1 Esd 9 34). In Ezr 10 33 we find, ‘“Jeremai’’ among the sons of Hashum. In 1 Esd it should come in 9 33 before Manasses. (2) See Jenremrau (general art.). JEREMIEL, jer-é-mi’el (Lat Hieremihel, al. Jeremiel, “El hurls” or ‘El appoints”): AVm and RV in 2 Esd 4 36 for AV “Uriel.’’ He is here called the “archangel”? who answers the questions raised by the souls of the righteous dead. He is perhaps identical with Ramiel of Apoc Bar or Remiel of Eth Enoch. .JEREMOTH, jer’é-moth ({e] M27, and [6] mwa), yremoth, [c] NVA, yrimoth, meaning un- known): Of the following (1) has form (6), (5) the form (c), the rest (a). (1) In 1 Ch 7 8 (AV “Jerimoth’’), and (2) In 1 Ch 8 14, Benjamites. Cf Jerowam, (2). (3) In 1 Ch 23 23, and (4) in 1 Ch 26 22= ‘Jerimoth,’’ 24 30; heads of Levitical houses. (5) A Naphtalite, one of David’s tribal princes (1 Ch 27 19); AV ‘“Jerimoth.” (6) (7) (8) Men who had married foreign wives. In Ezr 10 26 (=“‘Hieremoth,” 1 Esd 9 27); ver 27 (=“Jarimoth,” 1 Esd 9 28); ver 29 (=“Hiere- moth,” 1 Esd 9 30); the Keré of the last is N27}, wramoth, ‘and Ramoth”; so RVm, AV. AVID FRANCIS ROBERTS JEREMY, jer’e-mi. See Jenmmian (general art.). JEREMY, jer’e-mi, THE EPISTLE OF (Em- erody ‘Tepeplov, Epistolé Ieremiou) : 1. Name 2. Canonicity and Position 3. Contents THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jeremiah Jeremy, Ep. of 4. Original Language 5. aeeery ate and Aim 6. Text and Verslons Liveraturs In MSS BA the title is simply “An Epistle of Jeremiah.” But in B, etc, there is a superscription introducing the letter: “Copy of a letter 1. Name which Jeremiah sent to the captives about to be Jed to Babylon by [Pesh adds Nebuchadnezzar] the king of the Babylonians, to make known to them what had been commanded him by God.”” What follows is a satirical exposure of the folly of idolatry, and not a letter. The idea of introducing this as a letter from Jeremiah was probably suggested by Jer 29 1 ff. The early Gr Fathers were on the whole favorably disposed toward this tract, reckoning it to be a part of the Canon. It is therefore 2. Canon- included in the lists of canonical icity and writings of Origen, Epiphanius, Cyril Position of Jerus and Athanasius, and it was so authoritatively recognized by the Council of Laodicea (860 AD). In most Gr MSS of the LXX (BA Codd. March, Chisl, in the Syr Hex), it follows Lam as an independent piece, closing the supposed writings of Jeremiah. In the best- known printed edd of the LXX (Tischendorf, Swete, etc), the order is Jer, Bar, Lam, Ep. Jer. In Fritzsche, Lid, Apoc VT Graece, Ep. Jer stands between Bar and Tob. But in Lat MSS, including those of the Vulg, it is ap- ended to Bar, of which it forms ch 6, though it really has nothing to do with that hock. This last is the case with Protestant edd (EV, etc) of the Apoc, a more intel- ligible arrangement, as Jer and Lam do not occur in the Apoc, and the Bib. Baruch was Jeremiah’s amanuensis. In the so-called letter (see 1, above) the author shows the absurdity and wickedness of heathen worship. The Jews, for their sins, will 8. Contents be removed to Babylon, where they will remain 7 gencrations. In that land they will be tempted to worship the gods of the people. The writer's aim is ostensibly to warn them beforehand by showing how helpless and use- less the idols worshipped are, and how immoral as well as silly the rites of the Bab religion are. For similar polemics against idolatry, see Isa 44 9-19 (which in its earnestness resembles the Ep. Jer closely); Jer 10 3-9; Ps 115 4-8; 136 15-18; Wisd 13 10-19; 15 13-17. That the Ep. Jer was composed in Gr is the opin- jon of practically all scholars. There are no marks of translation; the Gr is on the whole 4, Original good, and abounds in such rhetorical Language terms as characterized the Gr of Northern Egypt about the beginning of our era. There is no trace of a Heb original, though Origen has been mistakenly understood to say there was one in his day (see Schiirer, GJV, III, 467). Romanist writers defend a Heb original, and point to some Hebraisms (ver 44 and the use of the fut. for the past), but these can be matched in admittedly Hellenistic Gr writings. The writer was almost certainly a resident in Alexandria toward the close of the last cent. BC. The Gr of the book, the references to 5. Author- Egyp religion (ver 19, where the Feast ship, Date of Lights at Sais—Herod. ii.62—is ,and Aim referred to), and the allusion to the Ep. Jer in 2 Macc 2 2, denied by Schtirer, etc, make the above conclision very probable. The author had in mind the dangers to the religion of his fellow-countrymen presented by the fascinating forms of idolatry existing at Alexandria. Certainly Jeremiah is not the author, for the book was written in Gr and never formed part of the Heb Canon. Besides, the treatment is far below the level of the genuine writings of that prophet. Jeriah Jeroboam THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1592 (1) The Greek.—This ep. occurs in the principal MSS of the LXX uncials (BA QI contain 7b—24a, etc) and cursives (except 70, 96, 229). 6. Text (2) The Syriac_—P follows the Gr, but and very freely. The Syr H follows the text ‘ of B closely, often at the expense of Syr Versions idioms. (3) The Latin.—The Vulg is made direct from the Gr. There is a different Lat VS published by Sabatier in his Bib. Sacr. Lat Versiones Antiquas, II, 734 ff. It is freer than the Vulg. (4) There are also Arabic (following A), Coptic (ed Quat- remére, 1810), and Ethiopic (cd Dilimann, 1894) versions. Lrireratrore.—See under Arocrypaa for Comm. and editions. But note in addition to the lit. mentioned in the art. the folowing: Reusch, Erkldr. des B. Baruch, 1853; Daubanton, ‘Het Apok boek 'EmaroAy "lepepiov,” Theol. Studien, 1888, 126-38. - T. Wirron Davies JERIAH, jéri’a CN"), yrriyaha, “founded of Jeh”): In 1 Ch 23 19; 24 23=“Jerijah” (P, yriyah), 26 31, head of a Levitical house: called chief of the Hebronites in 24 23 (cf ver 30). JERIBAI, jer’i-bi, jer-i-ba’? CI“, yribhay, meaning uncertain): One of David’s mighty men of the armies (1 Ch 11 46); one of the names not found in the list in 2 S 23 24-29a., JERICHO, jer’i-ko (the word occurs in two forms. In the Pent, in 2 K 25 5 and in Ezr, Neh, Ch it is written IW), yréhd; WI, yrihé, elsewhere): In 1 K 16 34 the final letter is 1, hé, instead of 1, waw. The termination wéw is thought to preserve the peculiarities of the old Can. dialect. In the LXX. we have the indeclinable form, *Iep:xé, Teri- ché (Swete has the form Jereiché as well), both with and without the fem. art.; in the NT ‘Iepe xo, Tereiché, once with the fem. art. The Arab. is er-Riha. According to Dt 32 49 it stood opposite Nebo, while in 34 3 it is called a city grove of palm trees. It was surrounded with a wall (Josh 2 15), and provided with a gate which was closed at night (2 5), and was ruled over by aking. When captured, vessels of brass and iron, large quantities of silver and gold, and “‘a goodly Babylonish gar- ment”? were found in it (7 21). It was on the western side of the Jordan, not far from the camp of Israel at Shittim, before crossing the river (2 1). The city was on the “‘plains’’ (4 13), but so close to “the mountain” on the W. (probably the cliffs of Quarantania, the traditional scene of Christ's temptation) that it was within easy reach of the spies, protected by Rahab. It was in the lot of Benjamin (18 21), the border of which ascended to the “‘slope [EV “‘side’’] of J. ou the N.” (18 12). Authorities are generally agreed in locating the ancient city at Tel es-Sultan, a mile and a half N.W. of modern J. Here there is a mound 1,200 ft. long and 50 ft. in height supporting 4 smaller mounds, the highest of which is 90 ft. above the base of the main mound. Site of Ancient Jericho. The geological situation (see Jornpan Vater) sheds great light upon the capture of the city by Joshua (Josh 6). Ifthe city was built as we suppose it to have been, upon the unconsolidated sedimentary, deposits which accumulated to a great depth in the Jordao valley during the enlargement of the Dead Sea, which took place in Pleistocene (or glacial) times, the sudden falling of the walls becomes easily credible to anyone who believes in the personality of God and in His power either to fore- know the future or to direct at His will the secondary causes with which man has to deal in Nature. The nar- rative does not state that the blowing of the rams’ horns of themselves effected the falling of the walls. It was simply said that at a specified juncture on the 7th day the walis would fall, and that they actually fell at that juncture, The miracle may, therefore, be regarded as either that of prophecy, in which the Creator by foretelling the course of things to Joshua, secured the junction of Divine and human activities which constitutes a true miracle, or we may regard the movements which brought down the walls to be the result of direct Divine action, such as is exerted by man when he produces an explosion of dyna- mite at a particular time and place. The phenomena are just such as occurred in the earthquake of San Fran- cisco in 1906, where, according to the report of the scientific commission appointed by the state, ‘the most violent destruction of buildings was on the made ground. This ground seems to have behaved during the earth- quake very much in the same way as jelly in a bowl, or as a semi-liquid in atank.’’ Santa Rosa, situated on the valley floor, ‘underlain to a considerable depth by loose or slightly coherent geological formations, .... 20 miles from the rift, was the most severely shaken town in the state and suffered the greatest disaster relatively to its population and extent” (Report, 13 and15). Thus an earthquake, such as is easily provided for along the margin of this great Jordan crevasse, would produce exactly the phenomena here described, and its occurrence at the time and place foretold to Joshua constitutes it @ miracle of the first magnitude. Notwithstanding the curse pronounced in Josh 6 26 AV, prophesying that whosoever should rebuild the city ‘‘he shall lay the foundations thereof in his firstborn,” it was rebuilt (1 K 16 34) by Hiel the Bethelite in the days of Ahab. The curse was lit- erally fulfilled. Still David’s messengers are said to have “tarried at Jericho” in his day (2 S 10 5; 1 Ch 19 5). In Elisha’s time (2 K 2 5) there was a school of prophets there, while several other references to the city occur in the OT and the Apoe (2 Ch 28 15, where it is called “‘the city of palm- trees’; 2 K 25 5; Jer 39 5; Ezr 2 34; Neh 3 2; 7 36; 1 Macc 9 50). Jos describes it and the fertile plain surrounding it, in glowing terms. In the time of Christ, it was an important place yield- ing a large revenue to the royal family. But the eity which Herod rebuilt was on a higher elevation, at the base of the western mountain, probably at Beit Jubr, where there are the ruins of a small fort. Jericho was the place of rendezvous for Galilean pilgrims desiring to avoid Samaria, both in going to and in departing from Jerus, and it has been visited at all times by thousands of pilgrims, who go down from Jerus to bathe in the Jordan. The road lead- ing from Jerus to Jericho is still infested by robbers who hide in the rocky caverns adjoining it, aud ap- pear without warniug from the tributary gorges of the wadies which dissect the mountain wall. At the present time Jericho and the region about is occupied only by a few hundred miserable inhabit- auts, deteriorated by the torrid climate which pre- vails at the low level about the head of the Dead Sea. But the present barrenness of the region is largely due to the destruction of the aqueducts which formerly distributed over the plain the waters brought down through the wadies which descend from the mountains of Judaea. The ruins of many of these are silent witnesses of the cause of jts decay. Twelve aqueducts at various levels formerly branched from the Wdédy Kelt, irrigating the plain both N. and S. Remains of Rom masonry arefound iu these. In the Middle Ages they were so repaired that an abundance and variety of crops were raised, including wheat, barley, millet, figs, grapes and sugar cane. See further PALEsTINE (RECENT EXPLORATION). Grorcr FREDERICK WRIGHT JERIEL, j@'ri-el, jer’i-cl ON, yrVal, “founded of God”’; ef JertaH): A chief of Issachar (1 Ch 7 2). JERIJAH, jé-ri’ja (1 Ch 26 31). See Junran. 1593 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jeriah Jeroboam Se eee ea JERIMOTH, jer’i-moth (see Jzremora, [c]): (1) A Benjamite (1 Ch 7 7). (2) A Benjamite who joined David at Ziklag, or perhaps a Judaean (1 Ch 12 5 [Heb 6]). (3) In 1 Ch 24 30=Juremorn, (4) (q.v.). &) A Levite musician in David’s time (1 Ch B 4). (5) Son of David and father of Mahalath, Reho- boam’s wife (2 Ch 11 18). He is not mentioned (2 8 3 2-5; 6 14-16; 1 Ch 3 1-9; 14 4-7) among the sons of David’s wives, so Curtis (Ch, 369) thinks that he was either the son of a concubine, or possibly the name is a corruption of “Ithream” aym, yithram, 1 Ch 3 8). (6) A Levite overseer in Hezekiah’s time (2 Ch 31 18). Davin Francis RosBerts 2 JERIOTH, jer'i-oth, jer’i-dth (MIN, yrt'ath, “Ttent-] curtains”): In 1 Ch 2 18, where MT is corrupt, Kittel in his comm. and in Bib. Heb reads “Caleb begat [children] of Azubah his wife, Jerioth.” Wellhausen (De Gent. et Fam. Jud., 33) reads, “Caleb begat [children] of Azubah his wife, the daughter of Jerioth.’”’ According to EV, Caleb had two wives, but the context does not bear this out. J. H. Michaelis regarded J. as another name for Azu- bah. See Curtis, Comm. on Ch, 92. JEROBOAM, jer-é-bi’am (O72, yarobh'am; LXX ‘IepoBodp, Hierobodm, usually assumed to have been derived from 1" and DY, and signifying “the people contend,” or, ‘‘he pleads the people’s cause’): The name was borne by two kings of Israel. (1) Jeroboam I, son of Nebat, an Ephraimite, and of Zeruah, a widow (1 K 11 26-40; 12—14 20). He was the first king of Israel after the disruption of the kingdom, and he reigned 22 years (937-915 BC). The history of J. is contained in 1 K 11 26-40; 12 1—14 20; 2 Ch 10 1—11 4; 11 14-16; 12 15; 13 3-20, and in an insertion in the 1. Sources LXX after 1 K 12 24(a-z). This in- sertion covers about the same ground as the MT, and the LXX elsewhere, with some additions and variations. The fact that it calls J.’s mother a pérné (harlot), and his wife the Egyp princess Ano (cf 1 K 11); that J. is punished by the death of his son before he has done any wrong; that the episode with the prophet’s mantle does not occur until the meeting at Shechem; that J. is not proclaimed king at.all—all this proves the passage inferior to the MT. No doubt it is a fragment of some historical work, which, after the manner of the later Midr, has combined history and tradition, making rather free use of the historical kernel. J. as a highly gifted and valorous young Ephraimite, comes to the notiee of Solomon early in his reign (1 K 11 28; ef 9 15.24). 2. His Rise Having noticed his ability, the king and Revolt made ie overseer of the fortifica- tions and public work at Jerus, and placed him over the levy from the house of Joseph. The faet that the latter term may stand for the whole of the ten tribes (cf Am 5 6; 6 6; Ob ver 18) indicates the importance of the position, which, however, he used to plot against the king. No doubt he had the support of the people in his designs. Prejudices of long standing (28 19 40f; 20f) were augmented when Israelitish interests were made subservient to Judah and to the king, while enforced labor and burdensome taxation filled the people’s hearts with bitterness and jealousy. J., the son of a widow, would be the first to feel the gall of oppression and to give voice to the suffering of the people. Im addition, he had the approval of the prophet Ahijah of the old sanetuary of Shiloh, who, by tearing his new mantle into twelve pieces and giving ten of them to J., informed him that he was to become king of the ten tribes. Jos says (Ant, VIII, vii, 8) that J. was elevated by the words of the prophet, ‘‘and being a young man of warm temper, and ambitious of greatness, he could not be quiet,” but tried to get the government into his hands at once. For the time, the plot failed, and J. fled to Egypt where he was recetved and kindly treated by Shishak, the successor to the father-in- law of Solomon. The genial and imposing personality of Solomon had been able to stem the tide of discontent ex- cited by his oppressive régime, which at 3. The his death burst all restraints. Never- Revolt of theless, the northern tribes, at a popu- the Ten lar assembly held at Shechem, solemnly Tribes promised to serve Rehoboam, the son of Solomon, who had already been pro- claimed king at Jerus, on condition that he would lighten the burdens that so unjustly rested upon them. Instead of reeetving the magna charia which they expected, the king, in a spirit of despotism, gave them a rough answer, and Jos says “‘the people were struck by his words, as it were, by an iron hammer” (Ant, VIII, viii, 3). But despotism lost the day. The rough answer of the king was met by the Marseillaise of the people: ‘What portion have we in David ? Neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse: To your tents, O Israel: Now see to thine own house, David" (1 K 12 16). Seeing the turn affairs had taken, but still unwill- ing to make any concessions, Rehoboam sent Adoram, who had been over the levy for many years (1 K 6 14; 12 18), and who no doubt had quelled dissatisfaction before, to force the people to submission, possibly by the very methods he had threatened to employ (1 K 12 14). However, the attempt failed. The aged Adoram was stoned to death, while Rehoboam was obliged to flee ignomini- ously back to Jerus, king only of Judah (1 K 12 20). Thus the great work of David for a united kingdom was shattered by inferiors, who put per- sonal ambitions above great ideals. As soon as J. heard that Solomon was dead, he returned from his forced exile in Egypt and took up his residence in his native town, 4, The Zeredah, in the hill country of Ephraim Election (LXX 1 K 12 20ff). The northern tribes, having rejected the house of David, now turned to the leader, and perhaps insti- gator of the revolution. Jeroboam was sent for and raised to the throne by the choice and approval of the popular assembly. Divinely set apart for his task, and having the approval of the people, J. nevertheless failed to rise to the greatness of his opportunities, and his kingdom degenerated into a mere military monarchy, never stronger than the ruler who chanced to occupy the throne. In trying to avoid the Scylla that threatened its freedom and faith (1 K 11 33), the nation steered into the Charybdis of revolution and anarehy in which it finally perished. Immediately upon his aceession, J. fortified Shechem, the largest city in Central Israel, and made it his eapital. Later he fortified 5. Political Penuel inthe E. Jordan country. Ac- Events eording to 1 K 14 17, Tirzah was the capital during the latter part of his reign. About J.’s external relations very little is known beyond the fact that there was war between him and Rehoboam constantly (1 K 14 30). In 2 Ch 13 2-20 we read of an inglorious war with Abijah of Judah. When Shishak invaded Judah (1 K 14 25f), he did not spare Israel, as appears from his inscription on the temple at Karnak, where a list of the towns captured by him is given. These belong to Northern Israel as well as to Judah, Jeroboam Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1594 showing that Shishak exacted tribute there, even if he used violence only in Judah. The fact that J. successfully managed a revolution but failed to establish a dynasty shows that his strength lay in the power of his personality more than in the soundness of his principles. Despite the success of the revolution politically, J. descried in the halo surrounding the temple and its ritual a danger which threatened 6. His the permanency of his kingdom. He Religious _justifiably dreaded a reaction in favor Policy of the house of David, should the people make repeated religious pil- grimages to Jerus after the first passion of the rebel- lion had spent itself. He therefore resolved to establish national sanctuaries in Israel. Accord- ingly, he fixed on Bethel, which from time imme- morial was one of the chief sanctuaries of the land (Gen 28 19; 35 1; Hos 12 4), and Dan, also a holy place since the conquest, as the chief centers of worship for Israel. J. now made “two calves of gold” as symbols of the strength and creative power of Jeh, and set them up in the sanctuaries at Bethel and Dan, where altars and other sacred objects already existed. It appears that many of the priests still in the land were opposed to his image-worship (2 Ch 11 13 ff). Accordingly, he found it necessary to institute a new, non-Levitical priesthood (1 K 13 33). A new and popular festi- val on the model of the feasts at Jerus was also established. J.’s policy might have been considered as a clever political move, had it not contained the dangerous appeal to the lower instincts of the masses, that led them into the immoralities of heathenism and hastened the destruction of the nation. J. sacrificed the higher interests of reli- gion to politics. This was the “‘sin of Jeroboam the son of Nebat, wherewith he made Israel to sin” (1 K 12 30; 16 26). It may be that many of the prophets sanctioned J.’s religious policy. Whatever the attitude of the majority may have been, there was 7. Hostility no doubt a party who strenuously of the opposed the image-worship. Prophets (1) The anonymous prophet.—On the very day on which J. inaugurated the worship at the sanctuary at Bethel ‘a man of God out of Judah” appeared at Bethel and pub- licly denounced the service. The import of his message was that the royal altar should some day be desecrated by a ruler from the house of David. The prophet was saved from the wrath of the king only by a miracle. ‘‘The altar also was rent, and the ashes poured out from the altar.” This narra- tive of 1 K 18 is usually assumed to belong to a later time, but whatever the date of compilation, the general historicity of the account is little affected It. ey The prophet Ahijah.—At a later date, when J. had realized his ambition, but not the ideal which the prophet had set before him, Ahijah predicted the consequences of his evil policy. J.’s eldest son had fallen sick. He thought of Ahijah, now old and blind, and sent the queen in disguise to learn the issue of the sickness. The prophet bade her to announce to J. that the house of J. should be extirpated root and branch; that the people whom be had seduced to idolatry should be uprooted from the land and transported beyond the river; and, severest of all, that her son should die. 8. His J. died in the 22d year of his reign, Death having “bequeathed to posterity the reputation of an apostate and a suc- cession of endless revolutions.” S. K. Mosrman (2) Jeroboam II (2 K 14 23-29), son of Joash and 13th king of Israel; 4th sovereign of the dy- nasty of Jehu. He reigned 41 years. His accession may be placed c 798 BC (some date lower). J. came into power on the crest of the wave of prosperity that followed the crushing of the su- premacy of Damascus by his father. 1. His By his great victory at Aphek, followed Warlike by others, Joash had regained the ter- Policy ritory lost to Israel in the reigns of Jehu and Jehoahaz (2 K 13 17.25). ‘This satisfied Joash, or his death prevented further bostili- ties. J., however, then a young man, resolved on a war of retaliation against Damascus, and on further conquests. The condition of the eastern world favored his projects, for Assyria was at the time engaged, under Shalmaneser IJI and Assurdan III, in a life-and-death struggle with Armenia. Syria being weakened, J. determined on a bold attempt to conquer and annex the whole kingdom of which Damascus was the capital. The steps of the cam- paign by which this was accomplished are unknown to us. The result only is recorded, that not only the intermediate territory fell into J.’s hands, but that Damascus itself was captured (2 K 14 28). Hamath was taken, and thus were restored the eastern boundaries of the kingdom, as they were in the time of David (1 Ch 13 5). From the time of Joshua “the entrance of Hamath’’ (Josh 13 5), a narrow pass leading into the valley of the Lebanons, had been the accepted northern boundary of the promised land. This involved the subjection of Moab and Ammon, probably already tributaries of Damascus. J.’s long reign of over 40 years gave time for the collected tribute of this greatly increased territory to flow into the coffers of Samaria, and 2. New the exactions would be ruthlessly en- Social forced. The prophet Amos, a con- Conditions temporary of J. in his later years, dwells on the cruelties inflicted on the trans-Jordanic tribes by Hazael, who ‘‘threshed Gilead with threshing instruments of iron’? (Am 13). All this would be remembered now, and wealth to which the Northern Kingdom had been unaccustomed flowed into its treasuries. The hovels of unburned brick in which the citizens had lived were replaced by ‘houses of hewn stone’ (Am 5 11). The ivory house which Ahab built in Samaria (1 K 22 39; decorations only are meant) was imitated, and there were many “great houses” (Am 3 15). The sovereign had both a winter and a summer palace. The description of a banqueting scene within one of these palatial abodes is lifelike in its portraiture. The guests stretched themselves upon the silken cushions of the couches, eating the flesh of lambs and stall-fed calves, drinking wine from huge bowls, singing idle songs to the sound of viols, themselves perfumed and anointed with oil (Am 6 4-6). Meanwhile, they were not grieved for the affliction of Joseph, and cared nothing for the wrongdoing of which the country was full. Side by side with this luxury, the poor of the land were in the utmost distress, A case in which a man was sold into slavery for the price of a pair of shoes seems to have come to the prophet’s knowledge, and is twice referred to by him (Am 2 6; 8 6). _ With all this, and as part of the social organiza- tion, religion of a kind flourished. Ritual took the place of righteousness; and in a 8. Growth memorable passage, Amos denounces of Cere- the substitution of the one for the monial other (Am 6 21 ff). The worship Worship took place in the sanctuaries of the golden calves, where the votaries prostrated themselves before the altar clothed in garments taken in cruel pledge, and drank sacri- ficial wine bought with the money of those who were 1595 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jeroboam Jerusalem fined for non-attendance there (Am 2 8). There were subsidiary temples and altars at Gilgal and Beersheba (Am 4 4; 5 5; 8 14). Both of these places had associations with the early history of the nation, and would be attended by worshippers from Judah as well as from Israel. Toward the close of his reign, it would appear that J. had determined upon adding greater splendor and dignity to the central shrine, in 4, Mission correspondence with the increased of Amos wealth of the nation. Amos, about the same time, received a commission to go to Bethel and testify against the whole pro- ceedings there. He was to pronounce that these sanctuaries should be laid waste, and that Jeh would raise the sword against the house of J. (Am 7 9). On hearing his denunciation, made probably as he stood beside the altar, Amaziah, the priest of Bethel, sent a messenger to the king at Samaria, to tell him of the ‘‘conspiracy”’ of Amos, and that the land was not able to bear all his words. The messenger bore the report that Amos had declared ‘J. shall die by the sword,” which Amos had not done. When the messenger had gone, priest and prophet had a heated controversy, and new threatenings were uttered (Am 7 10-17). The large extension of territory acquired for Israel by J. is declared to have been the realization of a prophecy uttered earlier by Jonah, 5. Prophecy the son of Amittai (2 K 14 25)— of Jonah the same whose mission to Nineveh forms the subject of the Book of Jon (1 1). tis also indicated that the relief which had now come was the only alternative to the utter ex- tinction of Israel. But Jeh sent Israel a ‘‘saviour”’ (2 K 13 5), associated by some with the Assyr king Ramman-nirari III, who crushed’ Damascus, and left Syria an easy prey, first to Jehoash, then to J. (see JenoasH), but whom the historian seems to connect with J. himself (2 K 14 26.27). J. was succeeded on his death by his weak son Zechariah (ver 29). W. Saaw CaupEecorr JEROHAM, jéro’ham (00, yrdham, ‘may he be compassionate!’’): (1) An Ephraimite, the father of Elkanah, and randfather of Samuel (1811; 1 Ch 6 27.34 [Heb 12.19]): Jerahmeel is the name in LXX, B, in 1 S and in LXX, L+MSS, in I Ch. (2) A Benjamite (1 Ch 8 27), apparently= Jeremorts, (2) (cf ver 14), and probably the same as he of 1 Ch 9 8. (3) Ancestor of a priest in Jerus (1 Ch 9 12= Neh 11 12). ‘ (4) A man of Gedor, father of two of David’s Benjamite recruits at Ziklag, though Gedor might be a town in Southern Judah (1 Ch 12 7 [Heb 8)]). (5) Father of Azarel, David’s tribal chief over Dan (1 Ch 27 22). 3 (6) Father of Azariah, one of the captains who supported Jehoiada in overthrowing Queen Atha- liah (2 Ch 23 1). Davin Francis Rosperts JERUBBAAL, jer-u-ba’al, jé-rub’i-al O73, ytrubba‘al, “let Baal contend’’): The name given to Gideon by his father, Joash, and the people in recognition of his destruction of the altar of Baal at Ophrah (Jgs 6 32). For this name the form “Jerubbesheth” (2 S 11 21) was substituted after the analogy of “Ishbosheth” and “Mephibosheth,” in which bosheth, the Heb word for “shame,” dis- placed the word ba‘al, no doubt because the name resembled one given in honor of Baal. See G1pEoNn. JERUBBESHETH, jer-ub-bé’sheth, jé-rub’é- sheth (NWA, y'rubbesheth, sce JERUBBAAL for meaning): It is found once (28 11 21) for Jz- RUBBAAL. The word nua, bésheth, ‘shameful thing,’ was sub- stituted by later editors of the text for $9, ba‘al, “lord,” in the text of Jer 3 24; Hos 9 10; in2 8 2 8, etc, we find Ish-bosheth=Eshhaal (Ishbaal) in I Ch 8 33; 9 39. The reasou for this was reluctance to pro- nounce the word Ba'‘al, which had by their time been assoclated with Canaanitic forms of worship. In 2S 11 21 LXX, Lue, has '‘Jerohoal,'"’ which LXX, B, has cor- rupted to Jeroboam.”’ ERIBBAAL; MEPHIBOSHETH; and see GB, Intro, 400ff. Fora NT case cf Rom 11 4 and see Sanday and Headlam ad loc. See JerusBaaL. Davin Francis Roperts JERUEL, jé-r60'el, jer’dd-el ONT, yri’el, “founded by El’’): Jahaziel prophesied that King Jehoshaphat should meet the hordes of Moabites and Ammonites, after they had come up by the “ascent of Ziz,” “at the end of the valley [i.e. wady), before the wilderness of Jeruel’? (2 Ch 20 16). The particular part of the wilderness intended, is unknown. Cheyne (#B) thinks this may be an error for the Jezreel of Judah, mentioned in Josh 15 56, etc. See JEzREEL. JERUSALEM, je-rd0’sa-lem: I. Toe Name 1. In Cuneiform 2. In Hebrew 3. In Greek and Latin 4. The Meaning of Jerusalem 5. Other Names II. Gworogy, CLIMATE AND SPRINGS 1. Geology 2. Climate and Rainfall 3. The Natural Springs III. Tae Natura. Sits 1. The Mountains Around 2. The Valleys 3. The Hills IV. Gunerau Toroorarny or JeErusauEM 1. Description of Josephus 2. Summary of the Names of the Five Hills 3. The Akra 4. The Lower City 5. City of David and Zion V. Excavations aNnp ANTIQUITIES Robinson Wilson, and the Palestine Exploration Fund Warren and Conder Manudslay Schick Clermont-Ganneau Bliss and Dickie Jernsalem Archaeological Societies =e City's WALLS AND GaTEs The Existing Walls Wilson's Theory The Existing Gates Buried Remains of Earlier Walls The Great Dam of the Tyropceon Ruins of Ancient Gates . Josephus’ Description of the Walls . First Wall . Second Wall ‘ 10. Third Wall 11. Date of Second Wall 12. Nehemiah's Acconnt of the Walis 13. Valley Gate : 14. Dung Gate 15. Fountain Gate 16. Water Gate 17. Horse Gate 18. Sheep Gate 19. Fish Gate 20. “Old Gate” _ 21. Gate of Ephraim 22. Tower of the Furnaces 23. The Gate of Benjamin 24. Upper Gate of the Temple 25. The Earlier Walls ANTIQUARIAN REMAINS CONNECTED WITH THRE Water SuPPLY ‘ 1. Gihon: The Natural Spring The Aqueduct of the Canaanites Warren's Shaft Hezekiah’s ‘' Siloam" Aqueduct Other Aqueducts at Gihon Bir ByyQb Varieties of Cisterns Birket Israél Pool of Bethesda . The Twin Pools : . Birket Hammam el Batrak QOS SR Gor ihe 29 BO Et VI. 4 te $001 OUR Cobo VII. ESonnampmy ee Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1596 12. Birket Mamilla 13. Birket es Sultan 14. ‘‘Solomon's Pools” 15. Low-Level Aqueduct 16. High-Level Aqueduct 17. Dates of Construction of These Aqueducts VIII. Tomas, Antiquarian Remains anp HccLEsras- TICAL SITES - ‘“The Tomhs of the Kings"’ 2. ‘Herod's Tomh" ‘‘ Absalom’s Tomh” . The “Egyptian Tomb” . The ‘Garden Tomh" Tomb of ‘‘Simon the Just’ Other Antiquities Ecclesiastical Sites IX. History Tell el-Amarna Correspondence Joshua's Conquest Site of the Jebusite City David Expansion of the City Solomon . Solomon's City Wall The Disruption (933 BC) . Invasion of Shishak (928 BC) 10. City Plundered by Arabs 11. Hazael King of Syria Bought Off (797 BC) 12. Capture of the City by Jehoash of Israel 13. Uzziah's Refortification (779-740 BC) 14. Ahaz Allies with Assyria (736-728 BC) 15. Hezekiah's Great Works 16. His Religious Reforms 17. Manasseh’s Alliance with Assyria 18. His Repair of the Walls 19. Josiah and Religious Reforms (640-609 BC) 20. Jeremiah Prophesies the Approaching Doom 21. Aenea mezzar Twice Takes Jerusalem 58 22. Cyrus and the First Return (538 BC) 23. Nehemiah Rehuilds the Walls 24. Bagohi Governor 25. Alexander the Great 26. The Ptolemaic Rule 27. Antiochus the Great 28. Hellenization of the City under Antiochus Epiphanes iy 29. Capture of the City (170 BC) 30. Capture of 168 BC | 31. Attempted Suppression of Judaism 32. The Maccahean Rehellion 33. The Dedication of the Temple (165 BC) 34. Defeat of Judas and Capture of the City 35. His Death (161 BC) 36. Jonathan's Restorations | 37. Boyne of City to Antiochus Sidetes (134 38. Hasmonean Buildings 39. Rome's Intervention 40. Pompey Takes the City hy Storm 41. Julius Caesar Appoints Antipas Procurator (47 BC) 42. Parthian Invasion 43. Reign of Herod the Great (87-4 BC) 44. Herod's Great Buildings 45. Herod Archelaus (4 BC-6 AD) 46. Pontius Pilate 47. King Agrippa 48. Rising against Florus and Defeat of Gallus 49. The City Besieged hy Titus (70 AD) 50. Party Divisions within the Besieged Walls 51. Capture and Utter Destruction of the City 52. Rehellion of Bar-Cochba 53. Hadrian Builds lia Capitolina 54. Coustantine Builds the Church of the Anas- tasis 55. The Empress Eudoxia Rebuilds the Walls 56. Justinian 57. Chosroes II Captures the City 58. Heracleus Enters It in Triumph 59. Clemency of Omar 60. The Seljuk Turks and Their Cruelties 61. Crusaders Capture the City in 1099 62. The Kharizimians 63. Ottoman Turks Obtain the City (1517 AD) X. Mopern JERUSALEM 1. Jews and ‘‘ Zionism" : 2. Christian Buildings and Institutions LItvERATURE I. The Name.—The earliest mention of Jerus is in the Am Tab (1450 BC), where it appears in the 1. In ious SUS Se eeds Live this we are ave Ur-sa-li-immu on the Assyr monn- Cineiora ments of the 8th cent. BC. The most ancient Bib. form is DSWIN, y*rasha- lém, shortened in Ps 76 2 (cf Gen 14 18) to Salem, but in MT we have it vocalized: pep, yr asha- laim. In Jer 26 18; Est 2 6; 2 Ch 25 1; 32 9 we PIG ErP ge QDI EMP O98 have D™SW397, yrishdlayim, a form which occurs on the Jewish coins of the Revolt and also in Jewish literature; it is commonly used by 2. In modern Talmudic Jews. The form Hebrew with the ending -aim or -ayim is in- terpreted by some as being a dual, re- ferring to the upper and lower Jerus, but such forms occur in other names as implying special solemnity; such a pronunciation is both local and late. In the LXX we get "Iepovcakyu (Ierousalém), constantly reflecting the earliest and the common : Heb pronunciation, the initial letter 3.In Gr being probably unaspirated; soon, and Latin however, we meet with ‘Iepovogdju (Hierousalém)—with the aspirate—the common form in Jos, and ‘IepordAvpa ( Hieroséluma) in Mace (Books I-IV), and in Strabo. This last form has been carried over into the Lat writers, Cicero, Pliny, Tacitus and Suetonius. It was re- placed in official use for some centuries by Hadrian’s Aelia Capitolina, which occurs as late as Jerome, but it again comes into common use in the docu- ments of the Crusades, while Solyma occurs at various periods as a poetic abbreviation. In the NT we have ‘Iepoveadyjp (Hierousalém), particularly in the writings of St. Luke and St. Paul, and rad ‘lepoctAupa (id Hieroséluma) elsewhere. The AV of 1611 has Ierosalem in the OT and Hieru- salem in the NT. The form Jerusalem first occurs in French writings of the 12th cent. With regard to the meaning of the original name there is no concurrence of opinion. The oldest known form, Uru-sa-lim, has been 4. The considered by many to mean either Meaning the “City of Peace’ or the “City of of Jeru- [the god] Salem,” but other inter- salem preters, considering the name as of R Heb origin, interpret it as the ‘‘pos- session of peace’ or “foundation of peace.” It is one of the ironies of history that a city which in all its long history has seen so little peace and for whose possession such rivers of blood have been shed should have such a possible meaning, for its name. Other names for the city occur. For the name Jebus see Jesus. In Isa 29 1, occurs the name SN7AN, ’Gr7’ a, probably ‘‘the hearth of God,” and in 1 26 the “city of right- eousness.”” In Ps 72 16; Jer 32 24f; Ezk 7 23, we have the term V9O, hair, “the city’’ in contrast to “the land.” A whole group of names is connected with the idea of the sanctity of the site; ‘tr ha-kddhesh, the “holy city” occurs in Isa 48 2; 62 1; Neh 11 1, and yrushadlayim ha-k¢dhéshah, “Jerusalem the holy’’ is inscribed on Simon’s coins. In Mt 4 5; 27 53 we have 4 ayla wéXs, hé hagia pédlis, “the holy city,” and in Philo, ‘Iepérodis, Hierépolis, with the same meaning. In Arab. the common name is Beit el Makdis, “the holy house,” or el Mukaddas, ‘‘the holy,” or the common name, used by the Moslems everywhere today, el Kuds, a shortened form of el Ktids esh Sheréf, ‘the noble sanctuary.” Non-Moslems usually use the Arab. form Yeru- salém. II. Geology, Climate and Springs.—The geology of the site and environs of Jerus is comparatively simple, when studied in connection 1. Geology with that of the land of Pal as a whole (see GEoLoGy oF PaLEsTINE). The outstanding feature is that the rocks consist en- tirely of various forms of limestone, with strata containing flints; there are no primary rocks, no sandstone (such as comes to the surface on the E. of the Jordan) and no volcanic rocks. The lime- 5. Other Names 1597 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem stone formations are in regular strata dipping toward the 8.E., with an angle of about 10°. On the high hills overlooking Jerus on the E., 8.E. and 8.W. there still remain strata of consider- able thickness of those chalky limestones of the post-Tertiary period which crown so many hilltops of Pal, and once covered the whole land. On the “Mount of Olives,” for example, occurs a layer of conglomerate limestone known as NG@ri, or “fire- stone,” and another thicker deposit, known as Ka‘kili, of which two distinct strata can be dis- tinguished. In these layers, esp. the latter, occur pockets containing marl or haur, and in both there are bands of flint. Over the actual city’s site all this has been de- nuded long ages ago. Here we have three layers of limestone of varying density very clearly dis- tinguished by all the native builders and masons: 1) Mizzeh helu, lit. ‘sweet mizzeh,”’ a hard, reddish-grey layer capable of polish, and reaching in places to a depth of 70 ft. or more. The “holy tock’’ in the temple-area belongs to this layer, and much of the ancient building stone was of this nature. (2) Below this is the Melekeh or “royal’’ layer, which, though not very thick—35 ft. or so—has been of great importance in the history of the city. This rock ig peculiar in that when first exposed to the air it is often so soft that it can be cut with a knife, but under the influence of the atmosphere it hardens to make a stone of considerable durability, useful for ordinary buildings. The great impor- tance of this layer, however, lies in the fact that in it have been excavated the hundreds of caverns, cisterns, tombs and aqueducts which honeycomb the city’s site. (3) Under the Melekeh is a Cenomanian limestone of great durability, known as Mizzeh Yehudeh, or “Jewish mizzch.’’ It is a highly valued building stone, though hard to work. Geologically it is distinguished from Mizzeh helu by its containing ammonites. Characteristically it is a yellowish- grey stone, sometimes slightly reddish. A variety of a distinctly reddish appearance, known as Miz- zeh ahmar, or ‘red mizzeh,’’? makes a very orna- mental stone for columns, tombstones, etc; it takes a high polish and is sometimes locally known’ as “marble.” This deep layer, which underlies the whole city, comes to the surface in the Kidron valley, and its impermeability is probably the explanation of the appearance there of the one true spring, the ‘Vir- gin’s Fount.” The water over the site and environs of Jerus percolates with ease the upper layer, but is conducted to the surface by this hard layer; the comparatively superficial source of the water of this spring accounts for the poorness of its quality. The broad features of the climate of Jerus have probably remained the same throughout history, although there is plenty of evidence 2. Climate that there have been cycles of greater and and lesser abundance of rain. The Rainfall almost countless cisterns belonging to all ages upon the site and the long and complicated conduits for bringing water from a distance, testify that over the greater part of his- tory the rainfall must have been, as at present, only seasonal. As a whole, the climate of Jerus may be con- sidered healthy. The common diseases should be largely preventable—under an enlightened govern- ment; even the malaria which is so prevalent is to a large extent an importation from the low-lying country, and could be stopped at once, were efficient means taken for destroying the carriers of infection, the abundant Anopheles mosquitoes. On account of its altitude and its exposed position, almost upon the watershed, wind, rain and cold are all more excessive than in the maritime plains or the Jordan valley. Although the winter’s cold is severely felt, on account of its comciding with the days of heaviest rainfall (cf Ezr 10 9), and also because of the dwellings and clothes of the inhabitants being suited for enduring heat more than cold, the actual lowest cold recorded is only 25° F., and frost occurs only on perhaps a dozen nights in an average year. During the rainless summer months the mean tem- perature rises steadily until August, when it reaches 73.6° F., but the days of greatest heat, with tem- perature over 100° F. in the shade at times, occur commonly in September. In midsummer the cool northwest breezes, which generally blow during the afternoons and early night, do much to make life healthy. The most unpleasant days occur in May and from the middle of September until the end of October, when the dry southeast winds— the sirocco—blow hot and stifling from over the deserts, carrying with them at times fine dust sufficient in quantity to produce a marked haze in the atmosphere. At such times all vegetation droops, and most human beings, esp. residents not brought up under such conditions, suffer more or less from depression and physical discomfort; malarial, “‘sandfly,’’ and other fevers are apt to be peculiarly prevalent. ‘‘At that time shall it be said... . to Jerus, A hot wind from the bare heights in the wilderness toward the daughter of rs people, not to winnow, nor to cleanse’ (Jer During the late summer—except at spells of sirocco—heavy ‘‘dews” occur at night, and at the end of September or beginning of October the “former” rains fall—not uncommonly in tropical downpours accompanied by thunder. After this there is frequently a dry spell of several weeks, and then the winter’s rain falls in December, January and February. In some seasons an abundant rainfall in March gives peculiar satisfaction to the inhabit- ants by filling up the cisterns late in the season and by producing an abundant harvest. The average rainfall is about 26 in., the maximum recorded in the city being 42.95 in. in the season 1877-78, and the minimum being 12.5 in. in 1869-70. An abun- dant rainfall is not only important for storage, for replenishment of the springs and for the crops, but as the city’s sewage largely accumulates in the very primitive drains all through the dry season, it requires a considerable force of water to remove it. Snow falls heavily in some seasons, causing considerable destruction to the badly built roofs and to the trees; in the winter of 1910-11 a fall of 9 in. occurred. There is only one actual spring in the Jerus area, and even to this some authorities would deny the name of true spring on account of the 3. The comparatively shallow source of its Natural origin; this is the intermittent spring Springs known today as ‘Ain Umm ed deraj (lit. “spring of the mother of the steps’’), called by the native Christians ‘Ain Sitti Miriam (the “spring of the Lady Mary’’), and by Europeans commonly called “The Virgin’s Fount.” All the archaeological evidence points to this as the original source of attraction of earliest occu- pants of the site; in the OT this spring is known as GrHon (q.v.). The water arises in the actual bottom, though apparent west side, of the Kidron valley some 300 yds. due 8. of the south wall of the Haram. The approach to the spring is down two flights of steps, an upper of 16 leading to a small level platform, covered by a modern arch, and a lower, narrower flight of 14 steps, which ends at the mouth of a small cave. The water has its actual source in a long cleft (perhaps 16 ft. long) running E. and Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1598 W. in the rocky bottom of the Kidron valley, now many feet below the present surface. The western or higher end of the cleft is at the very entrance of the cave, but most of the water gushes forth from the lower and wider part which lies underneath the steps. When the water is scanty, the women of Siloam creep down into the cavity under the steps and fill their water-skins there; at such times no water at all finds its way into the cave. At the far end of the cave is the opening of that system of ancient tunnel-aqueducts which is described in VI, below. This spring is “intermittent,” the water rising rapidly and gushing forth with considerable force, several times in the 24 hours after the rainy season, and only once or twice in the dry. This “intermittent”? condition of springs is not. uncom- mon in Pal, and is explained by the accumulation of the underground water in certain cavities or cracks in the rock, which together make up a reser- voir which empties itself by syphon action. Where the accumulated water reaches the bend of the syphon, the overflow commences and continues to run until the reservoir is emptied. Such a phe- nomenon is naturally attributed to supernatural agency by the ignorant—in this case, among the modern fellahin, to a dragon—and natives, specially Jews, visit. the source, even today, at times of its overflow, for healing. Whether this intermittent condition of the fountain is very ancient it is im- possible to say, but, as Jerome (Comm. in Esa, 86) speaks of it, it was probably present in NT times, and if so we have a strong argument for finding here the “Pool of Bethesda.” See BeruEspa. In ancient times all the water flowed down the open, rocky valley, but at an early period a wall was constructed to bank up the water and convert the source into a pool. Without such an arrange- ment no water could find its way into the cave and the tunnels. The tunnels, described below (VI), were constructed for the purpose (1) of reaching the water supply from within the city walls, and (2) of preventing the enemies of the Jews from getting at the water (2 Ch 32 4). The water of this source, though used for all purposes by the people of Siloam, is brackish to the taste, and contains a considerable percentage of sewage; it is quite unfit for drinking. This condition is doubtless due to the wide distribution of sewage, both intentionally (for irrigation of the gardens) and unintentionally (through leaking sewers, etc), over the soil over- lying the rocks from which the water flows. In earlier times the water was certainly purer, and it is probable, too, that the fountain was more copious, as now hundreds of cisterns imprison the waters which once found their way through the soil to the deep sources of the spring. The waters of the Virgin’s Fount find their way through the Siloam tunnel and out at ‘Ain Silwdén (the “spring” of Siloam), into the Pool of Siloam, and from this source descend into the Kidron valley to water the numerous vegetable gardens belonging to the village of Siloam (see S1zoaM). The second source of water in Jerus is the deep well known as Bir Eyytb, “Job’s well,” which is situated a little below the point where the Kidron valley and Hinnom meet. In all probability it derivesits modern name from a legend in the Koran (Sura 88 5.40-41) which narrates that God com- manded Job to stamp with his foot, whereupon a spring miraculously burst up. The well, which had been quite lost sight of, was rediscovered by the _ Crusaders in 1184 AD, and wasby them cleaned out. It is 125 ft. deep. The supply of water in this well is practically inexhaustible, although the quality is no better than that of the ‘‘Virgin’s Fount’’; after several days of heavy rain the water overflows underground and bursts out a few yards lower down the valley as a little stream. It continues to run for a few days after a heavy fall of rain is over, and this “flowing Kidron’’ is a great source of attraction to the native residents of Jerus, who pour forth from the city to enjoy the rare sight of running water. Somewhere in the neighborhood of Bir Eyydb must have lain ‘En-Rogel, but if that were once an actual spring, its source is now buried under the great mass of rubbish accumulated here (see EN-ROGEL). ; Nearly 600 yds. 8. of Bir Eyydb is a small gravelly basin where, when the Bir Eyydb overflows, a small spring called ‘Ain el Lozéh (the “spring of the almond’) bursts forth. It is not a true spring, but is due to some of the water of Job’s well which finds its way along an ancient rock-cut aqueduct on the west side of the Wddy en Nar, bursting up here. The only other possible site of a spring in the Jerus area is the Hammém esh Shef4, ‘“‘the bath of healing.” This is an underground rock-basin in the Tyropceon valley, within the city walls, in which water collects by percolation through the débris of the city. Though once a reservoir with probably rock-cut channels conducting water to it, it is now a deep well with arches erected over it at various periods, as the rubbish of the city gradually accumulated through the centuries. There is no evidence what- ever of there being any natural fountain, and the water is, in the dry season, practically pure sewage, though used in a neighboring Turkish bath. G. A. Smith thinks that the JackaL’s WELL (q.v.) mentioned by Nehemiah (2 13), which must have been situated in the Valley of Hinnom, may possibly have been a temporary spring arising there for a few years in consequence of an earthquake, but it is-extremely likely that any well sunk then would tap water flowing along the bed of the valley. There is no such “spring” or “well” there today. Ill. The Natural Site.-—Modern Jerus occupies a situation defined geographically as 31° 46’ 45” N. lat., by 35° 18’ 25’ KE. long. It lies in the midst of a bare and rocky plateau, the environs being one of the most stony and least fruitful districts in the habitable parts of Pal, with shallow, grey or reddish soil and many outcrops of bare limestone. Like all the hill slopes with a southeasterly aspect, it is so thoroughly exposed to the full blaze of the summer sun that in its natural condition the site would be more or less barren. Today, however, as aresult of diligent cultivation and frequent watermg, a considerable growth of trees and shrubs has been produced in the rapidly extending suburbs. The only fruit tree which reaches perfection around Jerus is the olive. The site of Jerus is shut in by a rough triangle of higher mountain ridges: to the W. runs the main ridge, or water parting, of Judaea, 1. The which here makes a sweep to the west- Mountains ward. From this ridge a spur runs Around 8.E. and E., culminating due E. of the city in the Mount or Otives (q.v.), nearly 2,700 ft. above sea-level and about 300 ft. above the mean level of the ancient city. Another spur, known as Jebel Deir abu Tor, 2,550 ft. high, runs E. from the plateau of el Bukei‘a and lies 8.W. of the city; it is the traditional ‘Hill of Evil Coun- sel.” The city site is thus dominated on all sides by these higher ranges—‘‘the mountains [that] are round about Jerus’’ (Ps 125 2)—so that while on the one hand the ancient city was hidden, at any considerable distance, from any direction except the 8.E., it is only through this open gap toward the desert_and the mountains of Moab that any wide outlook is obtainable. This strange vision of wilder- ness and distant mountain wall—often of exquisite loveliness in the light of the setting sun—must all through the ages have been the most familiar and the 1599 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem most potent of scenic influences to the inhabitants of Jerus. _ Within the enfolding hills the city’s proper site is demarked by two main valleys. That on the W. and 8.W. commences in a hollow occu- 2. The pied by the Moslem cemetery around Valleys the pool Birket Mamilla. The valley runs due E. toward the modern Jaffa Gate, and there bends 8., being known in this upper part of its course as the Wady el Més. Inthissouth- ern course it is traversed by a great dam, along which the modern Bethlehem road runs, which converts a large area of the valley bed into a great pool, the Birket es Sultan. Below this the valley—under the name of Wddy er Rabdbi—bends 8.E., then E., and finally S.E. again, until near Bir Eyydb it joins the western valley to form the Wady en Nér, 670 ft. be- low its origin. This valley has been very generally identified as the Valley of Hinnom (see Hinwom). Hills and Valleys of Jerusalem with Modern Names. The eastern valley takes a wider sweep. Com- mencing high up in the plateau to the N. of the city, near the great water-parting, it descends as a wide and open valley in a southeasterly direction until, where it is crossed by the Great North Road, being here known as Waddy el Jéz (the “Valley of the Wal- nuts’), it turns more By E. It gradually curves to the S., and as it runs E. of the city walls, it receives the name of Wady Sitti Miriam (the “Valley _ of the Lady Mary’). Below the S.E. corner of the temple-area, near the traditional “Tomb of Absalom,” the valley rapidly deepens and takes a direction slightly to the W. of 8. It passes the “Virgin’s Fount,”’ and a quarter of a mile lower it is joined by el Wad from the N., and a little farther on by the Wddy er Rababi from the W. South of Bir Eyytb, the valley formed by their union is con- tinued under the name of Wddy en Nér to the Dead Sea. This western valley is that commonly known as the Brook Kidron, or, more shortly, the ““Brook”’ (nahal), or ravine (see Kipron), but named from the 5th cent. onward by Christians the VALLEY oF JEHOSHAPHAT (q.v.). The rocky tongue of land inclosed between these deep ravines, an area roughly speaking, a little over one mile long by half a mile wide, is further subdivided into a number of distinct hills by some shallower valleys. The most ~y prominent of these—indeed the only one noticeable to the superficial observer today—is the great central valley known to modern times by the single name el Wad, “the valley.’ It commences in a slight depression of the ground a little N. of the modern “Damascus Gate,” and after entering the city at this gate it rapidly deepens—a fact largely disguised today by the. great accumulation of rub- bish in its course. It traverses the city with the Haram to its east, and the Christian and Moslem quarters on rapidly rising ground to its west. Its course is observed near the Bab es Silseleh, where it is crossed by an ancient causeway, but farther S. the valley reappears, having the walls of the Haram (near the “wailing place” and ‘‘Robinson’s arch’’) on the E., and steep cliffs crossed by houses of the Jewish quarter on the W. It leaves the city at the ‘“Dung Gate,” and passes with an open curve to the E., until it reaches the Poo! of Siloam, below which it merges in the Wédy Sitti Miriam. This is the course of the main valley, but a branch of great importance in the ancient topography of the city starts some 50 yds. to the W. of the modern Jaffa Gate and runs down the Suwaikat Allan, gen- erally known to travelers as ‘David's Street,” and thus easterly, along the Tarik bab es Silseleh, until it merges in the main valley. The main valley is usually considered to be the Tyropceon, or ‘“Cheese- mongers’ Valley” of Jos, but some writers have attempted to confine the name esp. to this western arm of it. Another interior valley, which is known rather by the rock contours, than by surface observations, being largely filled up today, cuts diagonally across the NE. corner of the modern city. It has no moodern name, though it is sometimes called “St. Anne’s Valley.” It arises in the plateau near ‘“Herod’s Gate,’’? known as es Sahra, and entering the city about 100 yds. to the E. of that gate, runs S.S.E., and leaves the city between the N.E. angle of the Haram and the Golden Gate, joining the Kidron valley farther S.E. The Birket Israé runs across the width of this valley, which had far more influence in determining the ancient topography of the city than has been popularly recognized. There is an artificially made valley between the Haram and the buildings to its north, and there is thought by many to be a valley between the 8.E. hill, commonly called “Ophel” and the temple-area. Such, then, are the valleys, great and small, by which the historic hills on which the city stood are defined. All of them, particularly in their southern parts, were considerably deeper in ancient times, and in places the accumulated débris is 80 ft. or more. All of them were originally torrent beds, dry except immediately after heavy rain. The only perennial outflow of water is the scanty and intermittent stream which overflows from the Pool of Siloam, and is used to irrigate the gardens in the Wady Stiiti Miriam. The E. and W. valleys isolate a roughly quadri- lateral tongue of land running from N.W.W. to §.S.E., and tilted so as to face 8.E. 3. The This tongue is further subdivided by Hills el Wad into two long ridges, which merge iuto each other in’ the plateau to the N. The western ridge has its actual origin considerably N. of the modern wall, being part of the high ground lying between the modern Jaffa road to the W., and the commencement of the Kidron valley to the E. Within the city walls it rises as high as 2,581 ft. near the northwestern corner. Jt is divided by the west branch of the Tyropceon valley into two parts: a northern part—the north- western hill—on which is situated today the Church of the Holy Scpulchre and the greater part of the “Christian quarter’ of the city, and a southern hill— Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1600 the southwestern—which is connected with the northwestern hill by but a narrow saddle—50 yds. wide—near the Jaffa Gate. This hill sustains the citadel (the so-called ‘Tower of David’’), the bar- racks and the Armenian quarter within the walls, and the Coenaculum and adjacent buildings outside the walls. This hill is from 2,500 to 2,350 ft. high along its summit, but drops rapidly on its south- western, southern and southeastern sides. In its central part it falls much more gently toward the pone hill across the now largely filled valley el ad. The eastern ridge may be reckoned as beginning at the rocky hill el-Hdhemtyeh—popularly known as Gordon’s Calvary—but the wide trench made here by quarrying somewhat obscures this fact. The ridge may for convenience be regarded as presenting three parts, the northeastern, central or central-eastern, and southeastern summits. The northeastern hill within the modern wall supports the Moslem quarter, and rises in places to a height of over 2,500 ft.; it narrows to a mere neck near the “Ecce Homo” arch, where it is joined to the bar- racks, on the site of the ancient Antonia. Under the present surface it is here separated from the temple summit by a deep rocky trench. The central, or central-eastern, summit is that appearing as es Sakhra, the sacred temple rock, which is 2,404 ft. high. This is the highest pomt from which the ground rapidly falls E., W., and 8., but the natural contours of the adjacent ground are much obscured by the great substructures which have been made to sustain the temple platform. The sloping, southeastern, hill, S. of the temple- area appears today, at any rate, to have a steady fall of from 2,350 ft. just 8. of the Haram southern wall to a little over 2,100 ft. near the Pool of Siloam. It is a narrow ridge running in a somewhat curved direction, with a summit near 200 ft. above the Kidron and 100 ft. above the bed of the Tyropceon. In length it is not more than 600 yds., in width, at its widest, only 150 yds., but its chief feature, its natural strength, is today greatly obscured on ac- count of the rubbish which slopes down its sides and largely fills up its surrounding valleys. In earlier times, at least three of its sides were protected by deep valleys, and probably on quite two-thirds oi its circumference its summit was surrounded by natural rocky scarps. According to Professor Guthe, this hill is divided from the higher ground to the N. by a depression 12 ft. deep and 30-50 yds. wide, but this has not been confirmed by other ob- servers. The city covering so hilly a site as this must ever have consisted, as it does today, of houses terraced on steep slopes with stairways for streets. IV. General Topography of Jerusalem.—From the foregoing description of the ‘natural site,’ it will be seen that we have to deal with 5 natural subdivisions or hills, two on the western and three on the eastern ridges. In discussing the topography it is useful to com- mence with the description of Jos, wherein he gives to these 5 areas the names common in 1. Descrip- his day (BJ, V, iv, 1,2). He says: tion of “The city was built upon two hills Josephus which arc opposite to one another and have a valley to divide them asunder. .... Now the Valley of the Cheesemongers, as it was called, and was that which distinguished the hill of the upper city from that of the lower, ex- tended as far as Siloam’’ (ib, V, iv, 1). Here we get the first prominent physical feature, the bisec- tion of the city-site into two main hills. Farther on, however, in the same passage—one, it must be admitted, of some obscurity—Jos distinguishes 5 distinct regions: (1) The Upper City or Upper Market Place: (The hill) “which sustains the upper city is much higher and in length more direct. Accordingly, it was called the citadel (¢povptor, phrotrion) of King David .... butitis by uscalled the Upper Market Place.” This is without dispute the southwestern hill. (2) Akra and Lower City: “The other hill, which was called Akra, and sustains the lower city, was double-curved” (dugixupros, amphikurtos). The description can apply only to the semicircular shape of the southeastern hill, as viewed from the “upper city.’ These names, “Akra”’ and “Lower City,” are, with reservations, therefore, to be ap- plied to the southeastern hill. (3) The Temple Hill: Josephus’ description here is curious, on account of its indefiniteness, but there can be no question as to which hill he intends. He writes: “Over against this is a third hill, but naturally lower than the Akra and parted formerly from the other by a flat valley. However, in those times when the Hasmoneans reigned, they did away with this valley, wishing to connect the city with the temple; and cutting down the summit of the Akra, they made it lower, so that the temple might be visible over it.’ Comparison with other passages shows that this “third hill” is the central-eastern— the ‘‘Temple Hill.”’ (4) Bezetha: “It was Agrippa who encompassed the parts added to the old city with this wall (ie. the third wall) which had been all naked before; for as the city grew more populous, it gradually crept beyond its old limits, and those parts of it that stood northward of the Temple, and joined that hill to the city, made it considerably larger, and oceasioned that hill which is in number the fourth, and is called ‘Bezetha,’ to be inhabited also. It lies over against the tower Antonia, but is divided from it by a deep valley, which was dug on purpase. ... . . This new-built part of the city was called ‘Bezetha’ in our language, which, if interpreted in the Gr language, may be called the ‘New City.’” This is clearly the northeastern hill. (5) The Northern Quarter of the City: From the account of the walls given by Jos, it is evident that the northern part of his “first wall” ran along the northern edge of the southwestern hill; the second wall inclosed the inhabited part of the north- western hill, Thus Jos writes: “The second wall took its beginning from the gate which they called Gennath in the first wall, and inclosing the northern quarter only reached to the Antonia.’ This area is not described as a separate hill, as the inhabited area, except on the §., was defined by no natural valleys, and besides covering the northwestern hill, must have extended into the Tyropceon valley. Here then we have Josephus’ names for these five districts: (1) Southwestern Hill, ‘Upper City” and ‘Upper Market Place’; also the 2. Summary Phrourion, or ‘fortress of David.” of Names From the 4th cent. AD, this hill has. of the Five also been known as “Zion,” and on it Hills today is the so-called “Tower of David,” built on the foundations of two of Herod’s great towers. (2) Northwestern Hill: ‘The northern quarter of the city.” This district does not appear to have had any other name in OT or NT, though some of the older authorities would place the “Akra” here (see infra). ‘Today it is the “Christian quarter’ of Jerus, which centers round the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. (3) Northeastern Hill: ‘Bezetha”’ or “New City,” even now a somewhat sparsely inhabited area, has no name in Bib. literature. (4) Central-eastern Hill: The “third hill” of Jos, clearly the site of the Temple which, as Jos says (BJ, V, v), “was built upon a strong hill.’ In 1601 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem earlier times it was the “threshing-floor of Araunah the Jebusite.”” On the question whether it has any claims to be the Moriah of Gen 22 2, as it is called in 2 Ch 3 1, see Morisu. The temple hill is also in many of the Heb writings called Zion, on which point see Zion. (5) Southeastern Hill: This Jos calls “Akra” and “Lower City,’’ but while on the one hand these names require some elucidation, there are other names which have at one period or another come to be applied to this hill, viz. “City of David,” “Zion” and “Ophel.’’ These names for this hill we shall now deal with in order. In spite of the very definite description of Jos, there has been considerable difference of opinion regarding the situation of the ‘‘Akra.”’ 3. The Various parts of the northwestern, Akra the northeastern, the southeastern hills, and even the central-eastern it- self, have been suggested by earlier authorities, but instead of considering the various arguments, now largely out of date, for other proposed sites, it will be better to deal with the positive arguments for the southeastern hill. Jos states that in his day the term ‘“Akra” was applied to the southeastern hill, but in references to the earlier history it is clear that the Akra was not a whole hill, but a definite fortress (dxpa, édkra=‘‘fortress’’). (1) It was situated on the site, or on part of the site, which was considered in the days of the Macca- hees to have been the “City of David.” Antiochus Epiphanes (168 BC), after destroying Jerus, “forti- fied the city of David with a great and strong wall, with strong towers and it became unto them an Akra”’ (1 Macc 1 33-36). The formidable for- tress—known henceforth as “the Akra’’—hecame a constant menace to the Jews, until at length, in 142 BC, it was captured by Simon, who not only razed the whole fortress, but, according to Jos (Ant, XIII, vi, 7; BJ, V, iv, 1), actually cut down the hill on which it stood. He says that “they all, labouring zealously, demolished the hill, and ceasing not from the work night and day for three whole years, brought it to a level and even slope, so that the Temple became the highest of all after the Akra and the hill upon which it was built had been removed” (Ant, XIII, vi, 7). The fact that at the time of Jos this hill was evidently lower than the temple hill is in itself sufficient argument against any theory which would place the Akra on the northwestern or southwestern hills. (2) The Akra was close to the: temple (1 Macc 13 52), and from its walls the garrison could actually overlook it (1 Macc 14 36). Before the hill was cut down it obscured the temple site (ib). (3) It is identified by Jos as forming part, at Icast, of the lower city, which (see below) bordered upon the temple (cf BY, , i, 4; V, iv, 1; vi, 1). (4) The LXX identifies the Akra with Millo (2S 5 9; 1 K 9 15-24; 2 Ch 32 5). Mineine that the original Akra of the Syrians was on the southeastern hill, it is still a matter of some difficulty to determine whereabouts it stood, esp. as, if the statements of Jos are correct, the nat- ural configuration of the ground has been greatly altered. The most prominent point upon the southeastern hill, in the neighborhood of Gihon, appears to have been occupied by the Jebusite for- tress of Zion (q.v.), but the site of the Akra can hardly be identical with this, for this became the “City of David,’ and here were the venerated tombs of David and the Judaean kings, which must have been destroyed if this hill was, as Jos states, cut down. On this and other grounds we must look for a site farther north. Sir Charles Watson (PEFS, 1906, 1907) has produced strong topo- graphical and literary arguments for placing it where the al Aksa mosque is today; other writers are more inclined to put it farther south, some- where in the neighborhood of the massive tower discovered by Warren on the “Ophel’’ wall (see Mitio). If the account of Jos, written two cen- turies after the events, is to be taken as literal, then Watson’s view is the more probable. Jos, as we have seen, identified the Akra of his day with the Lower City. This latter is not a name occurring in the Bible because, 4, The as will be shown, the OT name for Lower City this part was “City of David.” That by Lower City Jos means the south- eastern hill is shown by many facts. It is actually the lowest part of the city, as compared with the “Upper City,’ Temple Hill and the Bezetha; it is, as Jos describes, separated from the Upper City by a deep valley—the Tyropcon; this southeastern hill is ‘‘double-curved,’’ as Jos describes, and lastly several passages in his writings show that the Lower City was associated with the Temple on the one end and the Pool of Siloam at the other (cf Ant, XIV, xvi, 2; BJ, II, xvii, 5; IV, ix, 12; VI, vi, 3; vii, 2). In the wider sense the “Lower City’? must have included, not only the section of the city covering the southeastern hill up to the temple precincts, where were the palaces (BJ, V, vi, 1; VI, vi, 3), and the homes of the well-to-do, but also that in the valley of the Tyropceon from Siloam up to the “Council House,”’ which was near the northern “first wall” (cf BJ, V, iv, 2), a part doubtless inhabited by the poorest. It is clear (2 S 5 7; 1 Ch 11 5) that the citadel “Zion’’ of the Jebusites became the “‘City of David,” or as G. A. Smith calls it, ‘David's 5. City of Burg,’ after its capture by the He David and brews. The arguments for placing Zion “Zion”? on the southeastern hill are given elsewhere (see Zion), but a few acts relevant esp. to the “City of David’’ may be mentioned here: the capture of the Jebusite city by means of the gutter (2 8 6 8), whichis most reason- ably explained as “Warren’s Shaft” (see VII); the references to David’s halt on his flight (2 S 165 23), and his sending Solomon to Gihon to be crowned (1 K 1 33), and the common expression ‘“‘up,”’ used in describing the transference of the Ark from the City of David to the Temple Hill (1 K 8 1; 2 Ch 5 2; cf 1 K 9 24), are all consistent with this view. More convincing are the references to Hezekiah’s aqueduct which brought the waters of Gihon “down on the west side of the city of David’ (2 Ch 32 30); the mention of the City of David as adjacent to the Pool of Shelah (or Shiloah; cf Isa 8 6), and the “king’s garden” in Neh 3 15, and the position of the Fountain Gate in this passage and Neh 12 87; and the statement that Manasseh built ‘“‘an outer wall to the City of David, on the west side of Gihon’’ in the nahal, i.e. the Kidron valley (2 Ch 33 14). The name appears to have had a wider significance as the city grew. Originally “City of David” was only the name of the Jebusite fort, but later it be- came equivalent to the whole southeastern hill. In the same way, Akra was originally the name of the Syrian fort, but the name became extended to the whole southeastern hill. Jos looks upon “City of David” and ‘‘Akra’”’ as synonymous, and applies to both the name ‘Lower City.” For the names Ophel and Ophlas see OPHEL. V. Excavatians and Antiquities.—During the last hundred years explorations and excavations of a suc- cession of engineers and archaeologists have furnished an enormous mass of observations for the understanding of the condition of ancient Jerus. Some of the more important are as follows: n 1833 Messrs. Bonomi, Catherwood and Arundale made a first thorongh survey of the Haram (temple-area), Jerusalem a work which was the foundation of all subsequent maps for over a quarter of a century. In 1838, and again in 1852, the famous American traveler and divine, Rev. E. Robinson, D.D., visited E the land as the representative of an Ameri- 1. Rohinson can society, and made a series of brilliant ‘ tapout hical investigations of profound importance to all students of the Holy Land, even today. n 1849 Jerus was surveyed by Lieuts. Aldrich and Symonds of the Royal Engineers, and the data acquired were used for a map constructed by Van de Vilde and published by T. Tobler. In 1857 an American, J. T. Barclay, published another Inap of Jerus and its environs ‘“‘from actual and minute survey made on the spot." In 1860-63 De Vogiié in the course of some elahorate researches in Syria explored the site of the sanctuary. In 1864-65 a committee was formed in London to con- sider the sanitary condition of Jerus, esp. with a view to furnishing the city with a satisfactory water- i supply, and Lady Burdett-Contts gave 2. vison £500 toward a proper survey of Jerus and and the its environs as a preliminary step. Cap- Palestine tain Gater Tieutenant-General Sir Charles) A ‘ilson, R.E., was lent by the Ordnance Eaplongeu Survey Department of Great Britain for und, the purpose. The results of this survey, ? and of certain tentative excavations and observations made at_the same time, were so encour- aging that in 1865 ‘‘The Palestine Exploration Fund"’ was constituted, ‘‘for the purpose of investigating the archaeology, geography, geology, and natural history of the Holy Land." During 1867-70 Captain (ater Lieutenant-General Sir Charles) Warren, R.E., carried out @ series of most exciting and original excavations all over 3. Warren the site of Jerus, esp. around the Haram. Cond During 1872-75 Lieutenant (ater Lieu- and Conder tenant-Colonel) Gonder, R.E., in the course of the great survey of Western Pal, pace further contributions to our knowledge of the Holy ity. In 1875 Mr. Henry Maudslay, taking advantage of the occasion of the rebuilding of ‘' Bishop Gobat's Boys’ School,'’ made a careful examination of 4. Mauds- the remarkable rock cuttings which are zy now more or less incorporated into the lay school buildings, and made considerable excavations, the results being described in PEFS (April, 1875). In 1881 Professor Guthe made @ series of important excavations on the southeastern hill, commonly called ‘*QOphel,’’ and also near the Pool of Siloam; his reports were published in ZDPV, 1882. The same year (1881), the famous Siloam inscription was discovered and was first reported by Herr Baurath Schick, a resident in Jerus who from 1866 8. Schick Until his death in 1901 made a long series ° of observations of the highest importance on the topography of Jerus. He had unique opportunities for scientifically examining the buildings in the Haram,and the results of his study of the details of that locality are incorporated in his wonder- ful Temple model. He also made a detailed report of the ancient aqueducts of the city. Mostimportant of all were the records he so patiently and faithfully kept of therock levels in all parts of the city's site whenever the digging of foundations for buildings or other excavations gave access to the rock. His contributions to the PHF and ZDPYV run into hundreds of articles. M. Clermont-Ganneau, who was resident in Jerus in the French consular service, made for many years, from 1880 onward, a large number of .acute 6. Clermont- 0°bservations on the archaeology of Jerus 4 and its environs, many of which were pub- Ganneau jished by the PEF. Another name honored in connection with the careful study of the topography of Jerus over somewhat the same period is that of Rev. Selah Merrill, D.D., for many years U.S. consul in Jerus. : In 1894-97 the Palestine Exploration Fund conducted an elaborate series of excavations with a view to determin- ing In particular the course of the ancient 7. Bliss southern walls under the direction of Mr. d T. J. Bliss (son of Rev. Daniel Bliss, D.D., ane then president of the Syrian Protestant Dickie College, Beirat), assisted by Mr. A. C. Dickie as architect. After plcking up the buried foundatlons of walls at the southeastern corner where ‘‘Maudslay’s scarp'’ was exposed In the Protestant cemetery, Bliss and Dickie followed them all the way to the Pool of Siloam, across the Tyropceon and on to ‘'Ophel'—and also in other directions. Dis- coveries of great interest were also made in the neigh- borhood of the Pool of Siloam (see S110Am). hs Following upon these excavations a number of private investigations have heen made by the Augustinians in a large estate they have acquired on the E. side of the tradItional hill of Zion. In 1909-11 a party of Englishmen, under Captain the Hon. M. Parker, made a number of explorations with very elaborate tunnels upon the hill of Ophel, imme- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1602 diately above the Virgin's Fount. In the course of their work, they cleaned out the whole Siloam aqueduct, find- ing some new passages; they reconstructed the Siloam Pool, and they completed Warren's previous investiga- tion in the neighborhood of what has been known as ‘‘Warren's Shaft.” . There are several societies constantly engaged in ob- serving new facts connected with the topography of ancient Jerus, notably the School of Ar- 8. Jerusa- chaeology connected with the University 1 Ar. of St. Stephens, under the Dominicans; €m AI- the American School of Archaeology; the chaeological German School of Bib. Archaeology under Societies Professor Dalman, and the Palestine Ex- ploration Fund. VI. The City’s Walls and Gates.—Although the existing walls of Jerus go hack in their present form to but the days of Suleiman the Mag- 1. The nificent, ¢ 1542 AD, their study is an Existing essential preliminary to the under- Walls standing of the ancient walls. The total circuit of the modern walls is 4,326 yds., or nearly 24 miles, their average height is 35 ft., and they have altogether 35 towers and 8 gates—one of which is walled up. They make a rough square, with the four sides facing the cardinal points of the compass. The masonry is of various kinds, and on every side there are evidences that the present walls are a patchwork of many periods. The northern wall, from near the northwestern angle to some distance E. of the ‘(Damascus Gate,” lies parallel with, though somewhat inside of, an ancient fosse, and it and the gate itself evidently follow ancient lines. The eastern and western walls, following as they do a general direction along the edges of deep valleys, must be more or less along the course of earlier walls. The eastern wall, from a little south of St. Stephen’s Gate to the southeastern angle, contains many ancient courses, and the gen- eral line is at least as old as the time of Herod the Great; the stretch of western wall from the so- called “Tower of David” to the southwestern corner is certainly along an ancient line and has persisted through very many centuries. This line of wall was allowed to remain undestroyed when Titus leveled the remainder. At the northwestern angle are some remains known as Kala‘at Jaldd (“Goliath’s castle”), which, though largely mediae- val, contain a rocky core and some masonry of Herodian times, which are commonly accepted as the relics of the lofty tower Psephinus. The course of the southern wall has long been a difficulty; it is certainly not the line of wall before Titus; it has none of the natural ad- 2. Wilson’s vantages of the western and eastern Theory walls, and there are no traces of any great rock fosse, such as is to be found on the north. The eastern end is largely built upon the lower courses of Herod’s southern wall for his enlarged temple-platform, and in it are still to be found walled up the triple, single and double gates which lead up to the Temple. The irregular line followed by the remainder of this wall has not until recent times received any explanation. Sir Charles Wilson (Golgotha and the Holy Sepulchre) suggests the probable explanation that the line of wall from the southwestern to the ‘Zion Gate’ was deter- mined by the legionary camp which stood on the part of the city now covered by the barracks and the Armenian quarter. Allowing that the remains of the first wall on the N. and W. were utilized for this fortified camp (from 70-132 AD), and supposing the camp to have occupied the area of 50 acres, as was the case with various European Rom camps, whose remains are known, the southern camp wall would have run along the line of the existing south- ern walls. This line of fortification having been thus selected appears to have been followed through the greater part of the succeeding centuries down to modern times. The line connecting the two ex- AGTIVA NOUCIN WOU WHIVSnNar 40 TIVM JO UANUOO am 1603 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem tremities of the southern wall, thus determined by the temple-platform and legionary camp, respec- tively, was probably that first followed by the south- ern wall of Hadrian’s city Aflia. Of the 8 existing city gates, on the west side there is but one, Béb el Khulil (the “Gate of Hebron’), commonly known to travelers as the 3. The Jaffa Gate. It is probably the site of Existing several earlier gates. On the N. there Gates are 3 gates, Bab Abd’ul Hamid (named after the sultan who made it) or the “New Gate’; Bab el ‘amdd (‘‘Gate of the Columns’’), now commonly called the “Damascus Gate,” but more anciently known as ‘St. Stephen’s Gate,” and clearly, from the existing remains, the site of an earlier gateway; and, still farther east, the Bab es Sahirah (“Gate of the Plain’ "), or “Herod’s Gate.” On the east side the only open gate is the Béb el ‘Asbat (“Gate of the Tribes’), commonly called by native Christians, Bab Sittt Miriam (“Gate of the Lady Mary’’), but in European guide-books called “St. Stephen’s Gate.’”’ A little farther 8., near the northeastern corner of the Haram is the great walled-up Byzantine Gate, known as Béb ed Dahariyeh (‘Gate of the Conqueror’’), but to Euro- peans as the “Golden Gate.” This structure has been variously ascribed to Justinian and Heraclius, _ but there are massive blocks which belong to a more ancient structure, and early Christian tra- dition places the ‘Beautiful Gate’’ of the Temple bere. In the southern wall are two city gates; one, insignificant and mean, occupies the center of ed Wad and is known as Béb el Mugharibeh (“Gate of the Moors’), and to Europeans as the “Dung Gate’; the other, which is on the crown of the western hill, traditional Zion, is the important Bab Nebi Daoud (‘‘Gate of the Prophet David’’), or the “Zion Gate.” All these gates assumed their present form at the time of the reconstruction of the walls by Suleman the Magnificent, but the more important ones occupy the sites of earlier gates. Their names have varied very much even since the times of the Cru- saders. The multiplicity of names for these va- rious gates—they all have two or three today—and their frequent changes are worth noticing in con- nection with the fact that in the OT history some of the gates appear to have had two or more names. ORR nt bog Mente St. Stephen’s Gate. As bas been mentioned, the course of the present southern wall is the result of Rom reconstruction of the city since the time of Titus. To Warren, Guthe, Maudslay and Bliss we owe a great deal of certain knowledge of its more ancient course. These explorers have shown that in all the pre-Rom period (and at least one period since) the contin- uation southward of the western and eastern ridges, as well as the wide valley between—an area now but sparsely inhabited—was the site of at once the most crowded life, and the most stirring scenes in the Heb history of the city. The sanctity of the Holy Sepulchre has caused the city life to center itself more and more around :that sanctuary, thereby greatly confusing the ancient topography for many centuries. (1) Warren’s excavations revealed: (4) a mas- sive masonry wall 46 ft. E. of the Golden Gate, which curved toward the W. at ita 4. Buried northern end, following the ancient Remains rock contours at this spot. It is of Earlier probable that this was the eastern Walls wall of the city in pre-Herodian times. Unfortunately the existence of a large Moslem cemetery outside the eastern wall of the Haram precludes the possibility of any more exca- vations in this neighborhood. (6) More important remains in the southeastern hill, commonly known as “Ophel.”’ Here commencing at the south- eastern angle of the Haram, Warren uncovered a wall 144 ft. thick running 8. for 90 ft. and then S.W. along the edge of the hill for 700 ft. This wall, which shows at least two periods of construc- tion, abuts on the sanctuary wall with a straight joint. Along its course were found 4 small towers with a projection of 6 ft. and a face from 22 to 28 ft. broad, and a great corner tower projecting 413 ft. irom the wall and with a face 80 ft. broad. The face of this great tower consists of stones one to two ft. high and 2 or 3 ft. long; it is founded upon rock and stands to the height of 66 ft. Warren considers that this may be ha-mighdal ha-ydcé or “tower that standeth out’’ of Neh 3 25. (2) In 1881 Professor Guthe picked up frag- mentary traces of this city-wall farther south, and im the excavations of Captain Parker (1910-11) further fragments of massive walls and a very an- cient gate have been found. (8) Maudslay’s excavations were on the sonth- western hill, on the site occupied by ‘Bishop Gobat’s School” for boys, and in the adjoining Anglo- German cemetery. The school is built over a great mass of searped rock 45 ft. sq., which rises to a height of 20 ft. from a platform which surrounds it and with which it is connected by a rock-cut stairway; upon this massive foundation must have stood a great tower at what was in ancient times the southwestern corner of the city. From this point a scarp facing westward was traced for 100 {t. northward toward the modern southwestern angle of the walls, while a rock scarp, in places 40 ft. high on the outer or southern side and at least 14 ft. on the inner face, was followed for 250 ft. eastward until it reached another great rock pro- jection with a face of 43 ft. Although no stones were found in sifu, it is evident that such great rock cuttings must have supported a wall and tower of extraordinary strength, and hundreds of massive squared stones belonging to this wall are now in- corporated in neighboring buildings. (4) Bliss and Dickie’s work commenced at the southeastern extremity of Maudslay’s scarp, where was the above-mentioned massive projection for a tower,and here were found several courses of masonry still in situ. This tower appears to have been the point of divergence of two distinct lines of wall, one of which ran in a direction N.E., skirting the edge of the southeastern hill, and probably joined the line of the modern walls at the ruined masonry tower known as Burj el Kebrit, and another run- ning 8.E. down toward the Pool of Siloam, along the edge of the Wady er Rébébi (Hinnom). The former of these walls cannot be very ancient, be- cause of the occurrence of late Byzantine mold- ings in its foundations. The coenaculum was in- cluded in the city somewhere about 485-450 AD (see IX, 55), and also in the 14theent. Bliss eon- siders it probable that this is the wall built in 1239 Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1604 by Frederick II, and it is certainly that depicted in the map of Marino Sanuto (1321 AD). Although these masonry remains are thus comparatively late, there were some reasons for thinking that at a much earlier date a wall took a similar direction along the edge of the southwestern hill; and it is an attractive theory, though unsupported hy any very definite archaeological evidence, that the wall of Solomon took also this general line. The wall running 8.E. from the tower, along the edge of the gorge of Hinnom, is historically of much greater importance. Bliss’s investigations showed that here were remains belonging to several periods, covering altogether considerably over a millennium. The upper line of wall was of fine masonry, with stones 1 ft. by 3 ft. in size, beautifully jointed and finely dressed; in some places this wall was founded upon the remains of the lower wall, in others a layer of débris intervened. It is impossible that this upper wall can be pre-Rom, and Bliss ascribes it to the Empress Eudoxia (see [X, 55). The lower wall rested upon the rock and showed at least 3 periods of construc- tion. In the earliest the stones had broad margins and were carefully jointed, without mortar. This may have been the work of Solomon or one of the early kings of Judah. The later remains are evi- dently of the nature of repairs, and include the work of the later Judaean kings, and of Nehemiah and of all the wall-repairers, down to the destruction in 70 AD. At somewhat irregular intervals along the wall were towers of very similar projection and breadth to those found on Warren’s wall on the southeastern hill. The wall foundations were traced—except for an interval where they passed under a Jewish cemetery—all the way to the mouth of the Tyropeeon valley. The upper wall disap- peared (the stones having been all removed for later buildings) before the Jewish cemetery was reached. During most periods, if not indeed in all, the wall was carried across the mouth of the Tyropoon valley upon a great dam of which the 5. The massive foundations still exist under Great Dam the ground, some 50 ft. to the EK. of of the the slighter dam which today supports Tyropeon the Birketel Hamra (seeSttoaM). This ancient dam evidently once supported a pool in the mouth of the Tyropceon, and it showed evidences of having undergone buttressing and other changes and repairs. Although it is clear that dur- ing the greater part of Jewish history, before and after the captivity, the southern wall of Jerus crossed upon this dam, there were remains of walls found which tended to show that at one period, at any rate, the wall circled round the two Siloam pools, leaving them outside the fortifications. In the stretch of wall from “Maudslay’s Scarp” to the Tyropmon valley remains of 2 city gates were found, and doubtful indications 6. Ruins of of 2 others. The ruins of the first of Ancient these gates are now included in the Gates new extension of the Anglo-German cemetery. The gate had door sills, with sockets, of 4 periods superimposed upon each other; the width of the entrance was 8 ft. 10 in. during the earliest, and 8 ft. at the latest period. The character of the masonry tended to show that the gate belonged to the upper wall, which is appar- ently entirely of the Christian era. If this is so, this cannot be the “‘Gate of the Gai’ of Neh 3 13, although the earlier gate may have occupied this site. Bliss suggests as a probable position for this gate an interval between the two contiguous towers IV and V, a little farther to the E. Another gate was a small one, 4 ft. 10. in. wide, marked only by the cuttings in the rock for the door sockets. It lay a little to the W. of the city gate next to be described, and hoth from its position and its insignificance, it does not appear to have been an entrance to the city; it may, as Bliss suggests, have given access to a tower, now destroyed. The second great city gateway was found some 200 ft. S. of the Birket el Hamra, close to the south- eastern angle of the ancient wall. The existing remains are bonded into walls of the earlier period, but the three superimposed door sills, with their sockets—to be seen uncovered today in situ— mark three distinct periods of long duration. The gate gave access to the great main street running down the Tyropceon, underneath which ran a great rock-cut drain, which probably traversed the whole central valley of the city. During the last two periods of the gate’s use, a tower was erected—at the exact southeastern angle—to protect the entrance. The earliest remains here probably belong to the Jewish kings, and it is very probable that we have here the gate called by Neh (3 13) the ‘Dung Gate.’’ Bliss considered that it might be the “Fountain Gate’ (Neh 3 15), which, however, was probably more to the E., althongh Bliss could find no remains of it surviving. The repairs and alterations here have been so extensive that its disappearance is in no way surprising. The Foun- tain Gate is almost certainly identical with the “Gate between the Two Walls,’ through which Zedekiah and his men of war fled (2 K 25 4; Jer. 39 4; 527). The most definite account of the old walls is that of Jos (BJ, V, iv, 1, 2), and though it referred pri- marily to the existing walls of his day, 7. Josephus’ it is a convenient one for commencing Description the historical survey. He describes of the Walls three walls. The first wall “began on the N., at the tower called Hippi- cus, and extended as far as the Xistus, and then joining at the Council House, ended at the west- ern cloister of the temple.’”’” On the course of this section of the wall there is no dispute. The tower Hippicus was close to the present Jaffa Gate, and the wall ran from here almost due W. to the temple-area along the southern edge of the western arm of the Tyropceon (see III, 2, above). It is probable that the Haret ed Dawdyeh, a street run- ning nearly parallel with the neigh- 8. First boring “David Street,’? but high up Wall above it, lies above the foundations of this wall. It must have crossed the main Tyropceon near the Tarik bab es Silsilel, and joined the western cloisters close to where the Mehkemeh, the present “Council House,” is sit~ uated. Jos traces the southern course of the first wall thus: “It began at the same place [i.e. Hippicus], and extended through a place called Bethso to the gate of the Essenes; and after that it went south- ward, having its bending above the fountain Siloam, when it also bends again toward the E. at Solomon’s Pool, and reaches as far as a certain place which they called ‘Ophlas,’ where it was joined to the eastern cloister of the temple.” Although the main course of this wall has now been followed with pick and shovel, several points are still uncertain. Bethso is not known, but must have heen close to the southwestern angle, which, as we have seen, was situated where ‘Bishop Gobat’s School” is today. It is very probably identical with the ‘Tower of the Furnaces’ of Neh 3 11, while the “Gate of the Essenes” must have been near, if not identical with, the “Gate of the Gai” of ver 13. The description of Jos certainly seems to imply that the mouth of the Siloam aqueduct (‘fountain of Siloam’) and the pools were hoth outside the fortification. We have seen from these indications in the underground remains that this was the case at one period. Solomon’s Pool is very probably represented by the 1605 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem modern Birket el Hamra. It is clear that the wall from here to the southeastern angle of the temple- platform followed the edge of the southeastern hill, and coincided farther north with the old wall ex- cavated by Warren. As will be shown below, this first wall was the main fortification of the city from the time of the kings of Judah onward. In the time of Jos, this first wall had 60 towers. Probable Course of the Three Walls Described by Josephus. The ‘‘Second Wall"’ was probably added in the days of the Hasmonean rulers; the “Third Wall'’ was commenced hy Herod Agrippa 1 and hurriedly finished shortly before the siege by Titus. The Second Wall of Jos ‘‘took its beginning from that gate which they called ‘Gennath,’ which be- longed to the first wall: it only en- compassed the northern quarter of the eity and reached as far as the tower : Antonia” (ib). In no part of Jerus topography has there been more disagreement than upon this wall, both as regards its curve and as regards its date of origin. Unfortunately, we have no idea at all where the ‘‘Gate Gennath’’ was. The Tower Antonia we know. The line must have passed in a curved or zigzag direction from some unknown point on the first wall, i.e. between the Jaffa Gate and the Haram to the Antonia. A con- siderable number of anthorities in the past and a few careful students today would identify the general course of this wall with that of the modern northern wall. The greatest objections to this view are that no really satisfactory alternative course has been laid down for the third wall (see below), and that it must have run far N. of the Antonia, a course which does not seem to agree with the description of Jos, which states that the wall “went up” to the Antonia. On the other hand, no certain remains of any city wall within the pea north wall have ever been found; fragments ave been reported by various observers (e.g. the piece referred to as forming the eastern wall of the so-called “Pool of Hezekiah’; see VII, ii, below), but in an area so frequently desolated and rebuilt upon—where the demand for squared stones must always have been great—-it is probable that the traces, if surviving at all, are very scanty. This is the case with the south wall excavated by Bliss (see VI), and that neighborhood has for many 9. Second Wall centuries been unbuilt upon. It is quite probable that the area included within the second wall may have been quite small, merely the buildings which clustered along the sides of the Tyropceon. Its 40 towers may have been small and built close together, because the position was, from the mili- tary aspect, weak. It must be remembered that it was the unsatisfactory state of the second wall which necessitated a third wall. There is no abso- lute reason why it may not have excluded the greater part of the northwestern hill—and with it the site of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre—but there is no proof that it did. The date of the second wall is unknown (see below). This third wall, which was commenced after the time of Christ by Herod Agrippa I, is described in more detail by Jos. It was begun 10. Third upon an elaborate plan, but was not Wall finished in its original design because Agrippa feared Claudius Caesar, “lest he should suspect that so strong a wall was built in order to make some innovation in public affairs’ (BJ, V, iv, 2). It, however, at the time of the siege, was of a breadth of over 18 ft., and a height of 40 ft., and had 90 massive towers. Jos describes it as beginning at the tower Hippicus (near the Jaffa Gate), “‘where it reached as far as the north quarter of the city, and the tower Psephinus.’’ This mighty tower, 135 it. high, was at the northwestern corner and overlooked the whole city. From it, according to Jos (BJ, V, vi, 3), there was a view of Arabia (Moab) at sunrising, and also of “the utmost limits of the Heb possessions at the Sea westward.’ From this corner the wall turned eastward until it came over against the monuments of Helene of Adiabene, a statement, however, which must be read in connection with another passage (Ant, XX, iv, 3), where it says that this tomb “was distant no more than 3 furlongs from the city of Jerus.” The wall then “extended to a very great length” and passed by the sepulchral caverns of the kings—which may well be the so-called ‘“Solomon’s Quarries,’ and it then bent at the “Tower of the Corner,’’ at a monument which is called the Monu- ment of the Fuller (not identified), and joined to the old wall at the Kidron valley. The commonly accepted theory is that a great part of this line of wall is that pursued by the modern north wall, and Kal‘at el Jalud, or rather the foundation of it, that marks the site of Psephinus. The Damascus Gate is certainly on the line of some earlier gate. The ‘Tower of the Corner” was prob- ably about where the modern Herod’s Gate is, or a little more to the E., and the course of the wall was from here very probably along the southern edge of the “St. Anne’s Valley,”’ joining on to the N.E. corner of the Haram a little 8. of the present St. Stephen’s Gate. This course of the wall fits in well with the description of Jos. If. the so-called ““Tombs of the Kings” are really those of Queen Helena of Adiabene and her family, then the distance given as 3 fur- longs is not as far out as the distance to the modern wall; the distance is actually 33 furlongs. Others, following the learned Dr. Robinson, find it impossible to believe that the total circuit of the walls was so small, and would carry the third wall considerably farther north, making the general line of the modern north wall coincide with the second wall of Jos. The supporters of this view point to the description of the extensive view from Psephinus, and contend that this presupposed a site on still higher ground, e.g. where the present Russian buildings now are. They also claim that the state- ment that the wall came “over against’’ the monu- ment of Queen Helena certainly should mean very much nearer that monument than the present walls. Dr. Robinson and others who have followed him Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1606 have pointed to various fragments which they claim to have been pieces of the missing wall. The present writer, after very many years’ residence in Jerus, watchmg the buildings which in the last 25 years have sprung up over the area across which this line of wall is claimed to have run, has never seen a trace of wall foundations or of fosse which was in the very least convincing; while on the other hand this area now being rapidly covered by the modern suburb of Jerus presents almost everywhere below the surface virgin rock. There is no evidence of any more buildings than occasional scattered Rom villas, with mosaic floors. The present writer has rather unwillingly come to the opinion that the city walls were never farther north than the line they follow today. With respect to the objection raised that there could not possibly have been room enough between the two walls for the “Camp of the As- syrians,’’ where Titus pitched his camp (BJ, V, vii, 3), any probable line for the second wall would leave a mean of 1,000 ft. between the two walls, and in several directions considerably more. The proba- ble position of the “Camp of the Assyrians’’ would, according to this view, be in the high ground (the northwestern hill) now occupied by the Christian quarter of the modern city. The question of what the population of Jerus was at this period is dis- cussed in IX, 49, below. For the other great build- ings of the city at this period, see also IX, 43-44, below. Taking then the walls of Jerus as described by Jos, we may work backward and see how the walls ran in earlier periods. The third wall 11. Date of does not concern us any more, as it Second was built after the Crucifixion. With Wall respect to the second wall, there is a great deal of difference of opinion re- garding its origm. Some consider, like Sir Charles Watson, that it does not go back earlier than the Probable Course of Walls and Position of the Principal Gates from Hezekiah till Long after Nehemiah. (The N.E. corner is necessarily doubtful.) N.B.—The fortress Zion, renamed by David ‘‘City of David," became in later times ‘‘Akra,'' the fortross of the Syrians. Hasmoneans; whereas others (e.g. G. A. Smith), be- cause of the expression in 2 Ch 82 5 that Hezekiah, after repairing the wall, raised ‘‘another wall with- out,” think that this wall goes back as far as this monarch. The evidence is inconclusive, but. the most probable view seems to be that the “first wall,” as described by Jos, was the only circuit of wall from the kings of Judah down to the 2d cent. BC, and perhaps later. ae The most complete Scriptural description we have of the walls and gates of Jerus is that given by Nehemiah. His account is valuable, 12. Nehe- not only as a record of what he did, miah’s but of what had been the state of the Account of walls before the exile. It is perfectly the Walls clear that considerable traces of the old walls and gates remained, and that his one endeavor was to restore what had been before—even though it produced a city enclosure much larger than necessary at his time. The relevant passages are Neh 2 13-15, the account of his night ride; 3 1-82, the description of the re- building; and 12 31-39, the routes of the two pro- cessions at the dedication. roe fs Re In the first account we learn that Nehemiah went out by night by the Vatney Gare (q.v.), or Gate of the Gai, a gate (that is, opening) 13. Valley into the Gai Hinnom, and probably at Gate or near the gate discovered by Bliss in what is now part of the Anglo- German cemetery; he passed from it to the Dung Gate, and from here viewed the walls of the city. This, with considerable assurance, may 14. Dung be located at the ruined foundations Gate of a gate discovered by Bliss at the southeastern corner of the city. The line of wall clearly followed the south edge of the southwestern hill from the Anglo-German cemetery to this point. He then proceeded to the Fountain Gate, the site of which has not been re- 15. Fountain covered, but, as there must have been Gate water running out here (as today) from the mouth of the Siloam tunnel, is very appropriately named here. Near by was the Kine’s Poon (q.v.), probably the pool—now deeply buried—which is today represented by the Birket el Hamra. Here Nehemiah apparently thought of turning into the city, “but there was no place for the beast that was under me to pass” (2 14), so he went up by the Nahal (Kidron), viewed the walls from there, and then retraced his steps to the Valley Gate. There is another possibility, and that is that the King’s Pool was the pool (which certainly existed) at Gihon, in which case the Fountain Gate may also have been in that neighborhood. All the archaeological evidence is in favor of the wall having crossed the mouth of the Tyropceon by the great dam at this time, and the propinquity of this structure to the Fountain Gate is seen in Neh 3 15, where we read that Shallum built the Fountain Gate ‘“‘and covered it, and set up the doors thereof . . . . and the bars thereof, and the wall of the pool of Shelah [see Sttoam] by the Kina’s GARDEN [q.v.], even unto the stairs that go down from the city of David.” All these localities were close together at the mouth of el Wad. Passing from here we can follow the circuit of the city from the accounts of the rebuilding of the walls in Neh 3 15f. The wall from here was carried “over against the sepulchres of David,” which we know to have stood in the original “City of David” above Gihon, past “the pool that was made,” and “the house of the Gibborim” (mighty men)—both unknown sites. It is clear that the wall is being carried along the edge of the south- eastern hill toward the temple. We read of two angles in the wall—both needed by the geographical conditions—the high priest’s house, of “the tower that standeth out’’ (supposed to have been un- aoe by Warren), and the wall of the OpHEL q.v.). 1607 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem There is also mention of a Water Gate in this position, which is just where one would expect a road to lead from the temple-area down 16. Water to Gihon. From the great number of Gate companies engaged in building, it may be inferred that all along this stretch of wall from the Tyropceon to the temple, the de- struction of the walls had been specially great. Proceeding N., we come to the Horse Gate. This was close to the entry to the king’s house (2 K 11 16; 2 Ch 23 15; Jer 31 17. Horse 40). The expression used, “above” Gate the Horse Gate, may imply that the gate itself may have been uninjured; it may have been a kind of rock-cut passage or tunnel. It cannot have been far from the present southeastern angle of the city. Thence “repaired the priests, every one over against his own house’ —the houses of these people being to the E. of the temple. Then comes the Gare or HaMMIPHKAD (q.v.), the ascent (or “upper chamber,’’ m) of the corner, and finally the Susee GaTe 18. Sheep (q.v.), which was repaired by the Gate goldsmiths and merchants. This last gate was the pomt from which the circuit of the repairs was traced. The references, Neh 8 1.31; 12 39, clearly show that it was at the eastern extremity of the north wall. The details of the gates and buildings in the north wall as described by Nehemiah, are difficult, and certainty is impossible; this side must always neces- sarily have been the weak side for defence because it was protected by no, or at best by very little, natural valley. As has been said, we cannot be certain whether Nehemiah is describing a wall which on its western two-thirds corresponded with the first or the second wall of Jos. Taking the first theory as probable, we may plan it as follows: W. of the Sheep Gate two towers are mentioned (Neh 3 1; 12 39). Of these Hanane (q.v.) was more easterly than Hamman (q.v.), and, too, it would appear from Zec 14 10 to have been the most northerly point of the city. Probably then two towers occupied the important hill where afterward stood the fortress Baris and, later, the Antonia. At the Hammeah tower the wall would descend into the Tyropceon to join the eastern extremity of the first wall where in the time of Jos stood the Council House (BJ, V, iv, 2). It is generally considered that the Fish Garr (q.v.) (Neh 3 3; 12 39; Zeph 110; 2 Ch 33 14) stood across the Tyropceon in 19. Fish much the same way as the modern Gate Damascus Gate does now, only con- siderably farther 8. It was probably so dalled because here the men of Tyre sold their fish (Neh 13 16). It is very probably identical with the “Middle Gate’ of Jer 39 3. With this region are associated the MisHNEH (q.v.) or “‘sec- ond quarter’ (Zeph 1 10m) and the Maxres# (q.v.) or “mortar”? (Zeph 1 11). The next gate westward, after apparently a con- siderable interval, is tr? in EV the “Op Gate” q.v.), but is more correctly the “Gate 20. “Old of theold.. . .”; what the word thus Gate’? qualified is, is doubtful. Neh 3 6m suggests “old city” or ‘old wall,” whereas Mitchell (Wall of Jerus according to the Book of Neh) proposes “old pool,” taking the pool _in question to be the so-called ‘Pool of Hezekiah.’ According to the view here accepted, that the account of Neh refers only to the first wall, the ex- pression “old wall’? would be peculiarly suitable, as here must have been some part of that first wall which went back unaltered to the time of Solomon. The western wall to the extent of 400 cubits had been rebuilt after its destruction by Jehoash, king of Israel (see IX, 12, below), and Manasseh had repaired all the wall from Gihon round N. and then W. to the Fish Gate. This gate has also been identified with the Sha‘ar ha-Pinnah, or “Corner Gate,” of 2K 14 13; 2 Ch 25 23; Jer 31 38; Zec 14 10, and with the Sha‘ar ha-Ri'shén, or ‘First Gate,” of Zec 14 10, which is identified as the same as the Corner Gate; indeed ri’shén (‘‘first’’) is prob- ably a textual error for ydshdn (“old”). If this is so, this ‘‘Gate of the Old” or ‘Corner Gate’? must have stood near the northwestern corner of the city, somewhere near the present Jaffa Gate. The next gate mentioned is the Gate of Ephraim (Neh 12 39), which, according to 2 K 14 13; 2 Ch 25 23, was 400 cubits or 600 ft. 21, Gate of from the Corner Gate. This must Ephraim have been somewhere on the western wall; it is scarcely possible to believe, as some writers would suggest, that there could have been no single gate between the Corner Gate near the northwestern corner and the Valley Gate on the southern wall. The “Broad Wall” appears to correspond to the southern stretch of the western wall 22. Tower as far as the ‘Tower of the Furnaces” of the or ovens, which was probably the Furnaces extremely important corner tower now incorporated in “Bishop Gobat’s School.’ This circuit of the walls satisfies fairly well all the conditions; the difficulties are chiefly on the N. and W. It is a problem how the Gate of Ephraim comes to be omitted in the account of the repairs, but G. A. Smith suggests that it may be indicated by the expression, ‘‘throne of the governor ‘ beyond the river’ (Neh 3 7). See, however, Mitchell (loc. cit.). If the theory be accepted that the second wall already existed, the Corner Gate and the Fish Gate will have to be placed farther north. Probable Course of Solomon's Wall. In OT as in later times, some of the gates appear to have received different names at various times. Thus the Sheep Gate, at the north- 23. The eastern angle, appears to be identical Gate of with the Gate of Benjamin or Upper Benjamin Cate of Benjamin (Jer 20 2; 37 13; 38 7); the prophet was going, appar- ently, the nearest way to his home in Anathoth. Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1608 In Zec 14 10 the breadth of the city is indicated, where the prophet writes, “She shall be lifted up, and shall dwell in her place, from Benjamin’s gate unto the place of the first gate, unto the corner gate.’ The Upper Gate of the Temple (2 K 15 35; 2 Ch 27 3; cf 2 Ch 23 20; Ezk 9 2) is probably another name for the same gate. It 24. Upper must be remembered the gates were, Gate of the as excavations have shown us, re- Temple duced to a minimum in fortified sites: they were sources of weakness. The general outline of the walls and gates thus followed is in the main that existing from Nehemiah back until the early Judaean monarchy, and possi- bly to Solomon. centered round it. The three sources of supply have been (1) springs, (2) cisterns, (3) aqueducts. (1) The natural springs have been described in II, 3; but connected with them, and esp. with the city’s greatest and most venerated source, the Gihon, there are certain antiquarian remains of great interest. : , : ~ (a) The “Virgin’s Fount,” ancient Gihon, arises, as has been described (II, 3), in a rocky cleft in the Kidron valley bottom; under natural 1. Gihon: conditions the water would run along The Natural the valley bed, now deeply buried Spring under débris of the ancient city, and doubtless when the earliest settlers made their dwellings in the caves (which have been excavated) on the sides of the valley near the spring, All \ Teg! yy it Fe Semr-DiacramMatic PLan or ‘‘ Warren's SHarr’? anp Orner Rock Passaces (Mopiriep FROM WARREN, PEF). 1, Steps leading to the Virgin's Fount (Gihon). pendicular shaft 40 feet high. Parker's Shaft. Of the various destructions and repairs which occurred during the time of the monarchy, a suffi- cient account is given in IX below, on 25. The the history. Solomon was probably Earlier the first to inclose the northwestern Walls hill within the walls, and to him usually is ascribed all the northern and western stretch of the ‘First Wall’; whether his wall ran down to the mouth of the Tyropceon, or only skirted the summit of the northwestern hill is un- certain, but the latter view is probable. David was protected by the powerful fortifications of the Jebusites, which probably inclosed only the south- eastern hill; he added to the defences the fortress Miz0 (q.v.). It is quite possible that the original Jebusite city had but one gate, on the N. (2 S 15 2), but the city must have overflowed its narrow limits during David’s reign and have needed an extended and powerful defence, such as Solomon made, to secure the capital. For the varied history and situation of the walls in the post-Bib. period, see IX (‘‘History’’), below. VII. Antiquarian Remains Connected with the Water-Supply.—In a city like Jerus, where the prob- lem of a water-supply must always have been one of the greatest, it is only natural that some of the most ancient and important works should have 2. Fissure in the rocky valley bed from which spring arises. waters, 4. Cave at the commencement of the rock aequeduct. 5. Commencement of the Siloam (Hezekiah’s) aqueduct. 9. Lofty cave-like tunnel leading to shaft. 8. Ancient wall constructed to dam up the 6, 7. Other aqueducts. 8. Per- 10. The chasm, now cleared to the bottom. 11. Warren's Arch. 12, Captain they and their flocks lived on the banks of a stream of running water in a sequestered valley among waterless hills. From, however, a comparatively early period—at the least 2000 BC—efforts were made to retain some of the water, and a solid stone dam was built which converted the sources into a pool of considerable depth. Either then, or some- what later, excavations were made in the cliffs over- hanging the pool, whereby some at least of these waters were conducted, by means of a tunnel, into the heart of the southeastern hill, “Ophel,”’ so that the source could be reached from within the city walls. There are today two systems of tunnels which are usually classed as one under the name of the “Siloam aqueduct,” but the two systems are probably many centuries apart in age. The older tunnel begins in a cave near the source and then runs westward for a distance of 67 ft.; at the inner end of the tunnel there is a perpendicu- 2. The lar shaft which ascends for over 40 ft. Aqueduct and opens into a lofty rock-cut passage of the which runs, with a slight lateral curva- Canaanites ture, to the N., in the direction of the : surface. The upper end has been partially destroyed, and the roof, which had fallen in, was long ago partially restored by a masonry arch. At this part of the passage the floor is 1609 abruptly interrupted across its whole width by a deep chasm which Warren partially excavated, but which Parker has since conclusively shown to end blindly. It is clear that this great gallery, which is 8 to 9 ft. wide, and in places as high or higher, was eonstructed (a natural cavern possibly utilized in the process) to enable the inhabitants of the walled- in city above it to reach the spring. It is in fact a similar work to the great water-passage at Guzen (q.v.), which commenced in a rock-cut pit 26 ft. deep and descended with steps, to a depth of 94 ft. 6 in. below the level of the rock surface; the slop- ing passage was 23 ft. high and 13 ft. broad. This passage which could be dated with certainty as before 1500 BC, and almost certainly as early as 2000 BC, was cut out with flint knives and apparently was made entirely to reach a great underground source of water. The discovery of this Gezer well-passage has thrown a flood of light upon the “Warren's Shaft” in Jerus, which would appear to have 3. Warren’s been made for an exactly similar pur- Shaft pose. The chasm mentioned before may have been an effort to reach the source from a higher point, or it may have been made, or later adapted, to prevent ingress by means of the system of tunnels into the city. This passage is in all probability the ‘watercourse’ (“15% , ¢in- nor) of 2 5 6 8 up which, apparently, Joab and his men (1 Ch 11 6) secretly made their way; they must have waded through the water at the source, ascended the perpendicular shaft (a feat performed in 1910 by some British officers without any assistance from ladders), and then made their way into the heart of the city along the great tunnel. Judging by the similar Gezer water tunnel, this great work may not only have existed in David’s time, but may have been constructed as much as 1,000 years before. The true Siloam tunnel is a considerably later work. It branches off from the older aqueduct at a point 67 ft. from the entrance, and 4, Heze- after running an exceedingly winding kiah’s course of 1,682 ft., it empties itself “Siloam” into the Pool of Siloam (total length Aqueduct 1,749ft.). The whole canal is rock cut; it is 2 to 3 ft. wide, and varies in height from 16 ft. at the south end to 4 ft. 6 in. at the lowest point, near the middle. Thecondition of this tunnel has recently been greatly changed through Captain Parker’s party having cleared out the accumulated silt of centuries; before this, parts of the channel could be traversed only with the greatest difficulty and discomfort. The primitive nature of this con- struction is shown by the many false passages made, and also by the extensive curves which greatly add to its length. This latter may also be partly due to the workmen following lines of soft strata. M. Clermont-Ganneau and others have thought that one or more of the great curves may have been made deliberately to avoid the tombs of the kings of Judah. The method of construction of the tunnel is narrated in the Siloam Inscription (see Sttoam). It was begun simultaneously from each end, and the two parties met in the middle. It is a remarkable thing that there is a difference of level of only one foot at each end; but the lofty height of the southern end is probably due to a lowering of the floor here after the junction was effected. It is practically certain that this great work is that referred to in 2 K 20 20: ‘Now the rest of the acts of Hezekiah, and all his might, and how he made the pool, and the conduit, and brought water into the city, are they not written in the book of the chronicles of the kings of Judah?’ And in 2 Ch 32 30: “This same Hezekiah also stopped the upper spring of the waters of Gihon, and brought them straight down on the west side of the city of David.” THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem In addition to these two conduits, which have a direct Scriptural intcrest, there are remains of at least two other aqueduects which take 5. Other their origin at the Virgin’s Fount— Aqueducts one a channel deeply cut in rock along at Gihon the western sides of the Kidron valley, found by Captain Parker, and the other a built channel, lined with very good cement, which takes its rise at a lower level than any of the other & Birket Mamilla & Ague duty, Birk et The Water-Supply. conduits close to the before-mentioned rocky cleft from which the water rises, and runs in a very wind- ing direction along the western side of the Kidron. This the present writer has described in PEFS, 1902. One of these, perhaps more probably the former, may be the conduit which is referred to as Shiloah (shiloh), or “conducted” (Isa 8 6), before the construction of Hezekiah’s work (see Sito). There are other caves and rock-cut channels around the ancient Gihon which cannot fully be described here, but which abundantly confirm the sanctity of the site. (b) Bir Eyyfb has a depth of 125 ft.; the water collects at the hottom in a large rock-hewn chamber, and it is clear that it has been deep- 6. Bir ened at some period, because at the Eyyaib depth of 113 ft. there is a collecting chamber which is now replaced by the deeper one. Various rock-cut passages or stair- cases were found by Warren in the neighborhood of this well. (2) The cisterns and tanks Every ancient site in the hill country of Pal is riddled with cisterns for the storage of rain water. In 7. Varieties Jerus for very many centuries the of Cisterns private resident has depended largely upon the water collected from the roof of his house for all domestic purposes. Such cisterns lie either under or alongside the dwelling. Many of the earliest of these excavations are bottle-shaped, with a comparatively narrow mouth cut through the hard Mizzeh and a large rounded exeavation made in the underlying Melekeh (see II, 1 above). Other ancient cisterns are cavities hewn in the rock, of irregular shape, with a roof of harder rock and often several openings. The later forms are vaulted over, and are either cut in the rock or sometimes partially built in the superlying rubbish. Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1610 _ For more public purposes large cisterns were made in the Haram, or temple-area. Some 3 dozen are known and planned; the largest is calculated to contain 3,000,000 gallons. Such structures were made largely for the religious ritual, but, as we shall see, they have been supplied by other sources than the rainfall. In many parts of the city open tanks have been constructed, such a tank being known in Arab. as a birkeh, or, followed by a vowel, birket. With most of these there is considerable doubt as to their date of construction, but probably none of them, in their present form at any rate, antedates the Rom period. Within the city walls the largest reservoir is the Birket Israél which extends from the northeastern angle of the Haram westward for 360 8. Birket ft. It is 125 ft. wide and was origi- Israél nally 80 ft. deep, but has in recent years been largely filled up by the city’s refuse. The eastern and western ends of this pool are partially rock-cut and partly masonry, the masonry of the former being a great dam 45 ft. thick, the lower part of which is continuous with the ancient eastern wall of the temple-area. The sides of the pool are entirely masonry because this reservoir is built across the width of the valley referred to before (III, 2) as ‘St. Anne’s Valley.” Other parts of this valley are filled with débris to the depth of 100 ft. The original bottom of the reservoir is covered with a layer of about 19 in. of very hard concrete and cement. There was a great conduit at the eastern end of the pool built of mas- sive stones, and connected with the pool by a per- forated stone with three round holes 5} in. in diame- ter. The position of this outlet shows that all water over a depth of 22 ft. must have flowed away. Some authorities consider this pool to have been preéxilic. By early Christian pilgrims it was identi- fied as the ‘Sheep Pool” of Jn 5 2, and at a later period, until quite recent times, it was supposed to have been the Pool of Bethesda. 9. Pool of The discovery, a few years ago, of the Bethesda long-lost Piscina in the neighborhood of the ‘Church of St. Anne,” which was without doubt the Pool of Bethesda of the 5th cent. AD, has caused this identification to be abandoned. See Breruuspa. To the W. of the Birket Israél are the ‘‘twin pools” which extend under the roadway in the neighbor- hood of the ‘“‘Ecce Homo” arch. The 10. The western one is 165 ft. by 20 ft. and the Twin Pools castern 127 ft. by 20ft. M.Clermont- Ganneau considers them to be iden- tical with the Pool Struthius of Jos (BJ, V, xi, 4), but others, considering that they are actually made in the fosse of the Antonia, give them a later date of origin. In connection with these pools a great aqueduct was discovered in 1871, 23-3 ft. wide and in places 12 ft. high, running from the neighborhood of the Damascus Gate—but destroyed farther north —and from the pools another aqueduct runs in the direction of the Haram. On the northwestern hill, between the Jaffa Gate and the Church of the Sepulchre there is a large open reservoir, known to the modern 11. Birket inhabitants of the city as Birket Ham- Hammam mdm el Batrak, ‘the Pool of the Pa- el Batrak triarch’s Bath.” It is 240 ft. long (N. to §.), 144 ft. broad and 19-24 ft. deep. The cement lning of the bottom is cracked and practically useless. | The eastern wall of this pool is particularly massive, and forms the base of the remarkably level street Haret en Nasara, or “Christian Street”; it is a not improbable theory that this is actually a fragment of the long-sought “second” wall. If so, the pool, which is proved to have once extended 60 ft. farther north, may have been constructed originally as part of the fosse. On the other hand, this pool appears to have been the Amygdalon Pool, or “Pool of the Tower” (posyan mo32, berekhath ha-mighdalin), men- tioned by Jos (BJ, V, xi, 4), which was the scene of the activities of the 10th legion, and this seems inconsistent with the previous theory, as the events described seem to imply that the second wall ran outside the pool. The popular travelers’ name, ‘‘Pool of Hezekiah,” given to this reservoir is due to the theory, now quite discredited, that this is the pool referred to in 2 K 20 20, ‘“He made the peek and the conduit, and brought water into the city.” Other earlier topographists have identified it as the “upper pool” of Isa 7 3; 36 2. The Birket Hammém el Batrak is supplied with water from the Birket Mamilla, about } mile to the . This large pool, 293 ft. long by 12. Birket 193 ft. broad and 193 ft. deep, lies Mamilla in the midst of a large Moslem ceme- tery at the head of the Wady Més, the first beginning of the Wdédy er Rabébi (Hinnom). The aqueduct which connects the two pools springs from the eastern end of the Birket Mamilla, runs a somewhat winding course and enters the city near the Jaffa Gate. The aqueduct is in bad repair, and the water it carries, chiefly during heavy rain, is filthy. In the Middle Ages it was supposed that this was the “Upper Pool of Gihon” (see GrHon), but this and likewise the “highway of the FULLER’s Fieip” (q.v.) are now located elsewhere. Wilson and others have suggested that it is the ‘“‘Serpent’s Pool” of Jos (BJ, V, iii, 2). Titus leveled “all the places from Scopus to Herod’s monument which adjoins the pool called that of the Serpent.” Like many such identifications, there is not very much to be said for or against it; it is probable that the pool existed at the time of the siege. It is likely -that this is the Beth Memel of the Talm (Talm Bab, ‘Eribhin 616; Sanhedhrin 24a; Beré’shith Rabba’ 51). The Birket es Sulian is a large pool—or, more strictly speaking, inclosure—555 ft. N. and 8. by : 220 ft. E. and W. It is bounded on 13. Birket the W. and N. by a great curve of the es Sultan low-level aqueduct as it passes along and then across the Wddy er Rébébi. The southern side consists of a massive dam across the valley over which the Bethlehem carriage road runs. The name may signify either the “great” pool or be connected with the fact that it was re- constructed in the 16th cent. by the sultan Suleiman ibn Selim, as is recorded on an inscription upon a wayside fountain upon the southern wall. This pool is registered in the cartulary of the Holy Sepulchre as the Lacus Germani, after the name of a knight of Germanus, who built or renovated the poolin 1176 AD. Probably a great part of the pool is a catchment area, and the true reservoir is the rock-cut birkeh at the southern end, which has recently been cleaned out. It is extremely difficult to believe that under any conditions any large pro- portion of the whole area could ever have even been filled. Today the reservoir at the lower end holds, after the rainy season, some 10 or 12 ft. of very dirty water, chiefly the street drainage of the Jaffa road, while the upper two-thirds of the inclosure is used as a cattle market on Fridays. The water is now used for sprinkling the dusty roads in dry seasons. The Pool of Siloam and the now dry Birket el Hamra are described under Stroam (q.v.). There are other tanks of considerable size in and around the city, e.g. the Birket Sitti Miriam, near “St. Stephen’s Gate,’ an uncemented pool in the Wéady Jéz, conuected with which there is a rock- cut aqueduct and others, but they are not of suffi- cient historical importance to merit description here. 1611 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem (3) The conduits bringing water to the city from a distance are called the “high-level” and “low- level” aqueducts respectively, because 14. ‘*Solo- they reached the city at different levels mon’s —the former probably somewhere Pools” near the present Jaffa Gate, the latter at the temple-platform. The low-level aqueduct which, though out of repair, can still be followed along its whole course, conveyed water from three great pools 15. Low- in the Wady ‘Artas, 7 miles 8. of Level Jerus. They are usually called “Solo- Aqueduct mon’s pools,’ in reference perhaps partly to Eecl 2 6: “I made me pools of water, to water therefrom the forest. where trees were reared,’’ but as any mighty work in Pal is apt to be referred to the wise king of Israel, much stress cannot be laid on the name. These three storage reservoirs are constructed across the breadth of the valley, the lowest and largest being 582 ft. long by 177 ft. broad and, at the lowest end, 50 ft. deep. Although the overflow waters of ‘Ain es Sdleh, commonly known as the “sealed fountain” (cf Cant 4 12), reach the pools, the chief function was probably to collect the flood waters from the winter rains, and the water was passed from tank to tank after purification. There are in all four springs o Shafer JERUSALEM & Wady ef Ward HERODIUIT PLAN OF THE ENVIRONS OF JERUSALEM e TO ILLUSTRATE THE a AQUEDUCTS The “Low Level“Agueduct (hus The “High Level“Ayueduel ,, The Wady BiarKhari2? Aqueduct to the Herodium Modern tron Pipe Conduit eee Bisket Arrib Mee (Modifud from Schick) in this valley which supply the aqueduct which still conveys water to Bethlehem, where it passes through the hill by means of atunnel and then, after running, winding along the sides of the hill, it enters another tunnel now converted into a storage tank for Jerus; from this it runs along the mountain sides and along the southern slopes of the site of Jerus to the Haram. The total length of this aqueduct is nearly 12 miles, but at a later date the supply was increased by the construction of a long extension of the conduit for a further 28 miles to Wddy ‘Arrab on the road to Hebron, another 5 miles directly S. of the pools. Here, too, there is a reservoir, the Birket el ‘Arrab, for the collection of the flood-water, and also several small springs, which are conducted in a number of underground rock-cut channels to the aqueduct. The total length of the low-level aqueduct is about 40 miles, and the fall in level from Birket el ‘Arrab (2,645 ft. above sea-level) at its far end to el Kés, the termination in the Haram Jerus (2,410 ft. above sea-level), is 235 ft. The high-level aqueduct commences in a remark- able chain of wells connected with a tunnel, about 4 miles long, in the Wddy Biar, “the 16. High- Valley of Wells.’ Upward of 50 Level wells along the valley bottom sup- Aqueduct plied each its quotient; the water thence passed through a pool where the solid matter settled, and traversed a tunnel 1,700 ft. long into the ‘Artas valley. Here, where its level was 150 ft. above that of the low-level aque- duct, the conduit received the waters of the “sealed fountain,” and finally ‘delivered them in Jerus at a level of about 20 ft. above that of the Jaffa Gate’ (Wilson). The most remarkable feature of this conduit is the inverted syphon of perforated lime- stone blocks, forming a stone tube 15 in. in diameter, which carried the water across the valley near Rachel’s Tomb. On a number of these blocks, Lat inscriptions with the names of centurions of the time of Severus (195 AD) have been found, and this has led many to fix a date to this great work. So good an authority as Wilson, however, con- siders that these inscriptions may refer to repairs, and that the work is more probably Herodian. Unless the ac- counts of Jos (BJ, V, iv, 4; II, xvii, 9) are exag- gerated, Herod must have had some means of bringing abundant running water into the city at the level obtained by this conduit. The late Dr. Schick even suggested a date as early as Hyrcanus (135-125 BC). With regard to the low-level aque- duct, we have two definite data. First Jos (Ant, XVIII, ili, 2) states that Pontius Pilate “undertook to bring a current of water to Jerus, and did it with the sacred money, and derived the origin of the stream from the distance of 200 furlongs,” over 22 miles; in BJ, II, ix, 4 he is said to have brought the water “from 400 furlongs’”—probably a copyist’s error. But these references must either be to restorations or to the extension from Wéddy ‘Arrab to Wddy ‘Artas (28 miles), for the low-level aqueduct from the pools to Jerus is certainly the same con- struction as the aqueduct from these pools to the “Frank Mountam,” the Herodium, and that, according to the definite statements of Jos (Ant, XV, ix, 4; BJ, I, xxi, 10), was made by Herod the Great. On the whole the usual view is that the high-level aqueduct was the work of Severus, the low-level that of Herod, with an extension south- ward by Pontius Pilate. Jerus still benefits somewhat from the low-level aqueduct which is in repair as far as Bethlehem, though all that reaches the city comes only through a solitary 4-in. pipe. The high-level aqueduct is hopelessly destroyed _and can be traced only in places; the wells of Wady Bidar are choked and use- less, and the long winding aqueduct to Wddy ‘Arrab is quite broken. VUI. Tombs, Antiquarian Remains, and Ec- clesiastical Sites.—Needless to say all the known ancient tombs in the Jerus area have been rifled of 17. Dates of Con- struction of These Aqueducts Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1612 their contents long ago. The so-called Tombs of the Kings in the Wady el Jéz are actually the monu- ment of Queen Helena of Adiabene, 1. The a convert to Judaism (c 48 AD). Jos “Tombs of (Ant, XX, iv, 3) states that her bones, the Kings” with those of members of her family, _ were buried “at the pyramids,” which were 3 in number and distant from Jerus 3 fur- longs. A Heb inscription upon a sarcophagus found here by De Sauley ran: mmzba my, (carah malkethah), “Queen Sarah,” possibly the Jewish name of Queen Helena. On the western side of the Wddy el Més (tbe higher part of Hinnom), is a very interesting Gr 2. ‘“‘Herod’s tomb containing beauti- . Tomb” fully carved sarcophagi. . These are commonly Ay known as ‘“Herod’s Tombs” (although \ Herod the Great was buried on the \ Herodium), and, according to Schick, ‘ one of the sarcophagi may have be- longed to Mariamne, Herod’s wife. A more probable theory is that this is the tomb of the high priest Ananias (BJ, V, xii, 2). On the eastern side of the Kidron, near the southeastern angle of the Haram, are 3 conspicuous 3. “Absa= tombs. The most north- lom’s erly, Tantir Fer‘on, gener- Tomb” ally called ‘“Absalom’s Tomb,” is a Gr-Jewish tomb of the Hasmonean period, and, according to Conder, possibly the tomb of Alexander Jannaeus (HDB, art. _ “Jerusalem”). S. of this is the tra ** ' ESN we know by a square Heb inscription — = AR over the pillars to be the family tomb 9-77" of certain members of the priestly iS family (1 Ch 24 15), of the Beni Hazir. 4 It may belong to the century before Christ. The adjoining traditional tomb of Zachariah is a monolithic monument cut out of the living rock, 16 ft. sq. and 30ft. high. It hassquare pilasters at the corners, Ionic pillars between, and a pyramidal top. Its origin is unknown; its traditional name is due to Our Lord’s word in Mt 23 35; Lk 11 51 (see ZACHARIAH). A little farther down the valley of the Kidron, at the commencement of the village of Siloam, is 4. The another _rock-cut tomb, the so-called ‘Egyptian Egyp Tomb, or according to some, Tomb” “the tomb of Solomon’s Egyp wife.” It is a monolith 18 ft. sq. and 11 ft. high, and the interior has at one time been used as a chapel. It is now Russian property. It probably belongs to much the same period as the three before- mentioned tombs, and, like them, shows strong Egyp influence. _ The so-called ‘Tombs of the Judges” belong to the Rom period, as do the scores of similar excava- tions in the same valley. The ‘Tombs of the Prophets” on the western slopes of the Mount of Olives are now considered to belong to the 4th or 5th Christian century. Near the knoll over Jeremiah’s Grotto, to the W. and N.W., are a great number of tombs, mostly Christian. The more northerly members of the group are now included in the property of the Dommicans attached to the Church of St. Stephen, but one, the southernmost, has attracted ditional “Grotto of St. James,” which ARON VY NY og RERG Oe SSSR eg ERD a great deal of attention because it was sup- posed by the late General Gordon to be the tomb of Christ. In its condition when 6. The found it was without doubt, like its ‘Garden neighbors, a Christian tomb of about Tomb” the 5th cent., and it was full of skeletons. Whether it may originally have been a Jewish tomb is unproved; It cer- tainly could not have been recognized as a site of any sanctity until General Gordon promulgated his theory (see PHFS, 1892, 120-24; see also Gotr GOTHA). & 18 Arch \\\ x3 f \ Present Suapacelont, . S.q Pe ’ ¢ F Cots ba id Scale of Feet i \S3 SG INE Plan Showing Results of Warren's Excavations at ‘ Robinson's Arch.” The Jews greatly venerate a tomb on the eastern side of the Wddy el J6z, not far 8. of the great North Road; they consider it to be 6. Tomb of the tomb of Simon the Just, but it is ‘Simon the in all probability not a Jewish tomb Just” at all. Only passing mention can here be made of certain remains of interest connected with the exterior walls of the Haram. The foundation walls of the temple-platform are built, 7. Other specially upon the E., 8. and W., of Antiquities magnificent blocks of smooth, drafted masonry with an average height of 34 ft. One line, known as the “master course,” runs for 600 ft. westward from the southeastern angle, with blocks 7 ft. high. Near thesoutheastern angle at the foundation itself, certain of the blocks were found by the Palestine Exploration. Fund engineers to be marked with Phoen characters, which it was supposed by many at the time of their discovery indicated their Solomonic origin. It is now gen- 1613 erally held that these ‘masons’ marks” may just as well have been used in the time of Herod the Great, and on other grounds it is held that all this magnificent masonry is due to the vast reconstruc- tion of the Temple which this great’ monarch initiated (see TemMpLe). In the western wall of the Haram, between the southwestern corner and the “Jewish wailing place,” lies ‘“‘Robinson’s Arch.” It is the spring of an arch 50 ft. wide, projecting from the temple-wall; the bridge arising from it had a span of 50 ft., and the pier on the farther side was discovered by Warren. Under the bridge ran a contemporary paved Rom street, and beneath the unbroken pavement was found, lying inside a rock aqueduct, a voussoir of an older ane This bridge connected the temple-inclosure with the upper city in the days of the Hasmonean kings. It was broken down in 63 BC by the Jews in anticipation o the attack of Pompey (Ant, XIV, iv, 2; BJ, I, vii, 2),, but was rebuilt Herod in 19 BC (BJ, VI, vui, 1; vi, 2), and finally destroyed in 70 AD. Nearly 600 ft. farther N., along this western temple-wall is Wilson’s Arch, which lies under the surface within the causeway which crosses the Tyropceon to the Bab es Silseleh of the Haram; although not itself very ancient there are here, deeper down, arches belonging to the Herodian causeway which here approached the temple- platform. With regard to the common ecclesiastical sites visited by pious pilgrims little need be said here. The congeries of churches that ‘is in- 8. Eccle- cluded _under that name of Church siastical of the Holy Sepulchre includes a great Sites many minor sites of the scenes of the Passion which have no serious claims. Besides the Holy Sepulchre itself—which, apart from its situation, cannot be proved or disproved, as it has actually been destroyed—the only impor- tant site is that of “Mount Calvary.” All that can be said is that if the Sepulchre is genuine, then the site may be also; it is today the hollowed-out Ary? Robinson’s Arch. shell of a rocky knoll incased in marble and other stones and riddled with chapels. See Goueotua. The coenaculum, close to the Moslem ‘‘Tomb of David” (a site which has no serious claims), has been upheld by Professor Sanday (Sacred Sites of the Gospels) as one which has a very strong tradition THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1. Tell el- Jerusalem in its favor. The most important evidence is that of Epiphanias, who states that when Hadrian visited Jerus in 130, one of the few buildings left standing was “the little Church of God, on the site where the disciples, returning after the Ascension of the Saviour from Olivet, had gone up to the Upper room, for there it had been built, that is to say in the quarter of Zion.”” In connection with this spot there has been pointed out from early Christian times the site of the House of Caiaphas and the site of the death of the Virgin Mary—the Dormitio Sanciae Virginis. It isin consequence of this latter tradition that the German Roman Catholics have now erected here their magnificent new church of the Dormition. A rival line of traditions locates the tomb of the Virgin in the Kidron valley near Gethsemane, where there is a remarkable under- ground chapel belonging to the Greeks. IX. History.— Pre-Israelite period—The begin- nings of Jerus are long before recorded history: at various points in the neighborhood, e.g. at el Bukei‘a to the S.W., and at the northern extremity of the Mount of Olives to the N.E., were very large settlements of Paleolithic man, long before the dawn of history, as is proved by the enormous quantities of celts scattered over the surface. It is certain that the city’s site itself was occupied many centuries before David, and it is a traditional view that the city called Satem (q.v.) (Gen 14 18), over which Melchizedek was king, was identical with Jerus. The first certain reference to this city is about 1450 BC, when the name Ur-u-salem occurs in several letters belonging to the Am Tab correspondence. In 7 of these Amarna letters occurs the name Abd Khiba, Corre- and it is clear that this man was spondence “king,” or governor of the city, as the representative of Pharaoh of Egypt. In this correspondence Abd Khiba represents him- self as hard pressed to uphold the rights of his suzerain against the hostile forces which threaten to overwhelm him. Incidentally we may gather that the place was then a fortified city, guarded partly by mercenary Egyp troops, and there are reasons for thinking that the then ruler of Egypt, Amenhotep IV, had made it a sanctuary of his god Aten—the sun-disc. Some territory, possibly ex- tending as far west as Ajalon, seems to have been under the jurisdiction of the governor. Professor Sayce has stated that Abd Khiba was probably a Hittite chief, but this is doubtful. The corre- spondence eloses abruptly, leaving us in uncer- tainty with regard to the fate of the writer, but we know that the domination of Egypt over Pal suffered an eclipse about this time. At the time of Joshua’s invasion of Canaan, ADONI-ZEDEK (q.v.) is mentioned (Josh 10 1-27) as king of Jerus; he united with the 2. Joshua’s kings of Hebron, Jarmuth, Lachish Conquest and Eglon to fight against the Gibeon- ites who had made peace with Joshua; the 5 kings were defeated and, being captured in hiding at the cave Makkedah, were all slain. An- other king, AnonI-BEzExK (q.v.) (whom some identify with Adoni-zedek), was defeated by Judah after the death of Joshua, and after being mutilated was brought to Jerus and died there (Jgs 1 1-7), after which it is recorded (ver 8) that Judah “fought against Jerus, and took it .... and set the city onfire.”’ But it is clear that the city remained in the hands of the “Jebusites’”’ for some years more (Jgs 1 21; 19 11), although it was theoretically reck- oned on the southern border of Benjamin (Josh 15 8; 18 16.28). David, after he had reigned 74 years at Hebron, determined to make the place his capital and, about 1000 BC, captured the city. Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1614, _ Up to this event it is probable that Jerus was like other contemporary fortified sites, a compara- tively small place encircled with power- 3. Site of ful walls, with but one or perhaps two the Jebu- gates; it is very generally admitted site City that this city occupied the ridge to the S. of the temple long incorrectly called “Ophel,” and that its walls stood upon steep rocky scarps above the Kidron valley on the one side, and the Tyropoeon on the other. We have every reason to believe that the great system of tunnels, known as “Warren’s Shaft” (see VII, 3, above) existed all through this period. F Jerusalem of the Jebusites, as Captured by David. The account of the capture of Jerus by David is obscure, but it seems a probable explanation of a difficult passage (2 8 5 6-9) if 4. David — we conclude that the Jehusites, relying upon the extraordinary strength of their position, challenged David: ‘“Thou shalt not come in hither, but the blind and the lame shall turn thee away” (ver 6 m), and that David directed his followers to go up the “watercourse”’ and smite the “lame and the blind’”—a term he in his turn applies mocxingly to the Jebusites. “And Joab the son of Zeruiah went up first, and was made chief” (1 Ch 11 6). It seems at least probable that David’s men captured the city through a sur- prise attack up the great tunnels (see VII, 3, above). David having captured the stronghold “Zion,” renamed it the “City of David” and took up his residence there; he added to the strength of the fortifications “round about from the Mitzo [q.v.] and onward”; with the assistance of Phoeu work- men supplied by Hiram, king of Tyre, he built him- self ‘“‘a house of cedar” (2 S 5 11; cf 7 2). Theark of Jeh was brought from the house of Obed-edom and lodged in a tent (2 8 6 17) in the “city of David’ (cf 1K 81). The threshing-floor of Araunah (2 8 24 18), or Ornan (1 Ch 21 15), the Jebusite, was later purchased as the future site of the temple. The Jerus which David captured was small and compact, hut there are indications that during his reign it must have increased considerably by the growth of suburbs outside the Jebusite walls. The population must have been increased from several sources. The influx of David’s followers doubtless eaused many of the older inhabitants to be crowded out of the walled area. There ap- 5. Expan- pear to have been a large garrison” sion of (28 15 18; 20 7), many officials and the City priests and thcir families (2 S 8 16—- 18; 20 23-26; 23 8 ff), and the various members of David’s own family and their relatives (2S 6 13-16; 14 24.28; 1 K 1 5.53, etc). It is impossible to suppose that all these were crowded into so narrow an area, while the incidental mention that Absalom lived two whole years in Jerus without seeing the king’s face implies suhurbs (2 8 14 24. 28). The new dwellings could probably extend northward toward the site of the future temple and northwestward into and up the Tyropceon valley along the great north road. It is improbable that they could have oceupied much of the western hill. With the accession of Solomon, the increased magnificence of the court, the foreign wives and their establishments, the new officials 6. Solomon and the great number of work people brought to the city for Solomon’s great buildings must necessarily have enormously swelled the resident population, while the recorded build- ings of the city, the temple, the king’s house, the House of the Daughter of Pharaoh, the House of the Forest of Lebanon, the Throne Hall and the Pillared Hall (1 K 7 1-8) must have altered the whole aspect of the site. In consequence of these new buildings, the sanctuary together with the houses of the common folk, a new wall for the city was necessary, and we havea statement twice made that Solomon built “the wall of Jerus round ahout” (1 K 3 1; 9 15); it is also recorded that he built Millo (9 15.24; 11 27), and that “‘he repaired the breach of the city of David his father’ (11 27). The question of the Millo is discussed elsewhere (see Miii0); the “breach” re- ferred to may have been the connecting wall needed to include the Millo within the complete circle of fortifications, or else some part of David's fortifica- tion which his death had left incomplete. As regards the ‘Wall of Jerus” which Solomon | built, it is practically certain that it was, on the N. and W., that described by Jos as the 7. Solo- First Wall (see VI, 7 above). The mon’s City vast rock-cut scarps at the south- Wall western corner testify to the massive- ness of the building. Whether the whole of the southwestern hill was included is a matter of doubt. Inasmuch as there are indications at Bliss’s tower (see VI, 4d above) of an ancient wall running northeasterly, and inclosing the summit of the southwestern hill, it would appear highly prob- able that Solomon’s wall followed that line; in this case this wall must have crossed the Tyropeon at somewhat the line of the existing southern wall, and then have run southeasterly to join the western wall of the old city of the Jebusites. The temple and palace buildings were all inclosed in a wall of finished masonry which made it a fortified place by itself—as it appears to have been through Heb history -—and these walls, where external to the rest of the city, formed part of the whole circle of fortification. Although Solomon built so magnificent a house for Jeh, he erected in the neighborhood shrines to other local gods (1 K 11 7.8), a lapse ascribed largely to the influence of his foreign wives and con- sequent foreign alliances. The disruption of the kingdom must have been a severe blow to Jerus, which was left the capital, no longer of a united state, but of a petty 8. The tribe. The resources which were at Disruption the command of Solomon for the (933 BC) building up of the city were suddenly . cut off by Jeroboam’s avowed policy, while the long state of war which existed between 1615 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem the two peoples—a state lasting 60 years (1 K 14 30; 15 6.16; 22 44)—must have been very inju- rious to the growth of commerce and the arts of peace. In the 5th year of Rehoboam (928), Shishak (Sheshonk) rig ae Egypt came up against Jerus - (1 14 25 ff) and took “the fenced 9. Invasion cities of Judah” (2 Ch 12 4 AV). It of Shishak has been commonly supposed that he (928 BC) besieged and captured Jerus itself, but as there is no account of the destruction of fortifications and as the name of this city has not been deciphered upon the Egyp records of this campaign, it is at least as probable, and is as con- sistent with the Scriptural references, that Shishak was bought off with ‘‘the treasures of the house of Jeh, and the treasures of the king’s house’ and ‘fall the shields of gold which Solomon had made” (1 K 14 26). : _It is clear that by the reign of Jehoshaphat th city had again largely recovered its importance (cf 1 K 22), but in his son Jehoram’s 10. City reign (849-842 BC) Judah was in- Plundered vaded and the royal house was pillaged by Arabs by Philis and Arahs (2 Ch 21 16-17). Ahaziah (842 BC), Jehoram’s son, came to grief while visiting his maternal relative at Jez- reel, and after being wounded in his chariot near Ihleam, and expiring at Megiddo, his body was carried to Jerus and there buried (2 K 9 27-28). Jerus was now the scene of the dramatic events which center round the usurpation and death of Queen Athaliah (2 K 11 16; 2 Ch 23 15) and the coronation and reforms of her grandson Joash (2 K 12 1-16; 2 Ch 24 1-14). After the death of the good priest Jehoiada, it is recorded (2 Ch 24 15 ff) that the king was led astray by the princes of Judah and forsook the house of Jeh, as a, consequence of which the Syrians under Hazael 11. Hazael came against Judah and Jerus, slew King of the princes and spoiled the land, Joash Syria giving him much treasure from hoth Bought Off palace and temple (2 K 12 17.18; (797 BC) 2% Ch 24 23). Finally Joash was as- sassinated (2 K 12 20.21; 2 Ch 24 25) “at the house of Millo, on the way that goeth down to Silla.” During the reign of Amaziah (797-729 BC), the murdered king’s son, a victory over Edom appears to have so elated the king that he 12. Capture wantonly challenged Jehoash of Israel of the City to battle (2 K 14 8f). The_ two by Jehoash armies met at Beth-shemesh, and Judah of Israel was defeated and ‘fled every man to his tent.”’ Jerus was unable to offer any resistance to the victors, and Jehoash “brake down the wall of Jerus from the gate of Ephraim unto the corner gate, 400 cubits” and then returned to Samaria, loaded with plunder and hostages (ver 14). Fifteen years later, Amaziah was assassinated at Lachish whither he had fled from a conspiracy; nevertheless they brought his body upon horses, and he was buried in Jerus. Doubtless it was a remembrance of the humilia- tion which his father had undergone which made Uzziah (Azariah) strengthen his posi- 13. Uzziah’s tion. He subdued the Philis and the Refortifica- Arabs in Gar, and put the Ammonites tion (779- to tribute (2 Ch 26 7.8). He ‘built 740 BC) towers in Jerus at the corner gate, and at the valley gate, and at the turnings [LXX] of the walls, and fortified them” (ver 9). He is also described as having made in Jerus “engines, invented by skilful men, to be on the towers and upon the battlements, wherewith to shoot arrows and great stones” (ver 15). The cily during its long peace with its northern neigh- bors appears to have recovered something of her prosperity in the daysof Solomon. During his reign the city was visited by a great earthquake (Zec 14 4; Amiil; cf Isa9 10; 296; Am411; 8 8). Jotham, his son, built ‘‘the upper gate of the house of Jeh” (2 K 16 35; 2 Ch 27 3), probably the same as the “upper gate of Benjamin” (Jer 20 2). He also built much on the wall of Ophel—probably the ancient fortress of Zion on the southeastern hill (2 Ch 27 3); see OPHEL. His son Ahaz was soon to have cause to be thank- ful for his father’s and grandfather’s work in forti- fying the city, for now its walls were 14. Ahaz successful in defence against the Allies with kings of Syria and Israel (2 K 16 Assyria 5.6); but Ahaz, feeling the weakness (736-728 of his little kingdom, hought with silver BC) and gold from the house of Jeh the alliance of Tiglath-pileser, king of Assyria. He met the king at Damascus and paid him a compliment by having an altar similar to his made for his own ritual in the temple (vs 10-12). His reign is darkened by a record of heathen prac- tices, and specially by his making ‘‘his son to pass through the fire’’—as a human sacrifice in, appar- aay, the Valley of Hinnom (1 K 16 3-4; cf 2 Ch 8 3). Hezekiah (727-699 BC), his son, succeeded to the kingdom at a time of surpassing danger. Samaria, and with it the last of Israel’s kingdom, 15. Heze- had fallen. Assyria had with diffi- kiah’s Great culty been bought off, the people were Works largely apostate, yet Jerus was never so great and so inviolate to prophetic eyes (Isa 7 4f; 8 8.10; 10 28f; 14 25-32, etc). Early in his reign, the uprising of the Chaldaean Merodach- baladan against Assyria relieved Judah of her greatest danger, and Hezekiah entered into friendly relations with this new king of Babylon, showing his messengers all his treasures (Isa 39 1.2). At this time or soon after, Hezekiah appears to have undertaken great works in fitting his capital for the troublous times which lay hefore him. He sealed the waters of Gihon and brought them within the city to prevent the kings of Assyria from getting access to them (2 K 20 20; 2 Ch 32 4.30). See Sitoam. It is certain, if their tunnel was to be of any use, the southwestern hill must have heen entirely en- closed, and it is at least highly probable that in the account (2 Ch $2 5), he “built up all the wall that was broken down, and built towers thereon [ml], and the other wall without,” the last phrase may refer to the stretch of wall along the edge of the southwestern hill to Siloam. On the other hand, if that was the work of Solomon, “the other wall” may have been the great buttressed dam, with a wall across it which closed the mouth of the Tyro- poeon, which was an essential part of his scheme of preventing a besieging army from getting access to water. He also strengthened Mix1o (q.v.), on the southeastern hill. Secure in these fortifications, which made Jerus one of the strongest walled cities in Western Asia, Hezekiah, assisted, as we learn from Sennacherib’s descriptions, hy Arab merce- naries, was able to buy off the great Assyr king and to keep his city inviolate @ K 18 13-16). A second threatened attack on the city appears to be referred to in 2 K 19 9-37. Hezekiah undertook reforms. ‘He removed the high places, and brake the pillars, and cut down the Asherah: and he brake in pieces 16. His the brazen serpent that Moses had Religious madeand ... . he called it Nehush- Reforms tan,’ i.e. a piece of brass (2 K 18 4). Manasseh succeeded his father when but 12, and reigned 55 years (698-643) in Jerus (2 K 21 1). He-was tributary to Esarhaddon Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1616 and Ashurbanipal, as we know from their inscrip- tions; in one of the latter’s he is referred to as king “of the city of Judah.” The king of Assyria who, it is said (2 Ch 33 11; cf Ant, X, iii, 2), carried Manasseh in chainsto Babylon, was probably Ashur- banipal. How thoroughly the country was per- meated by Assyr influence is witnessed by the two cuneiform tablets recently found at Gezer belonging to fee Assyr monarch’s reign (PEFS, 1905, 206, etc). The same influence, extending to the religious sphere, is seen in the record (2 K 21 5) that Ma- nasseh “‘built altars for all the host of 17. Ma- heaven in the two courts of the house nasseh’s of Jeh.” There are other references Alliance to the idolatrous practices introduced with by this king (cf Jer 7 18; 2 K 23 5. Assyria 11.12, etc). He also filled Jerus from one end to the other with the innocent blood of martyrs faithful to Jeh (2 K 21 16; cf Jer 19 4). Probably during this long reign of external peace the population of the city much in- creased, particularly by the influx of foreigners from less isolated regions. Of this 18. His king’s improvements to the fortifica- Repair of tions of Jerus we have the statement the Walls (2 Ch 33 14), “He built an outer wall to the city of David, on the west side of Gihon in the valley, even to the entrance at the fish gate.” This must have been a new or rebuilt wall for the whole eastern side of the city. He also compassed about the OpHEn (q.v.) and raised it to a very great height. Manasseh was the first of the Judahic kings to be buried away from the royal tombs. He was buried (as was his son Amon) “in the garden of his own house, in the garden of Uzza” (2 K 21 18). These may be the tombs referred to (Ezk 43 7-9) as too near the temple precincts. In the reign of Josiah was found the “Book of the Law,” and the king in consequence instituted radical reforms (2 K 22, 23). Kidron 19. Josiah smoked with the burnings of the and Reli- Asherah and of the vessels of Baal, and gious Tophethin the Valley of Hinnom wasde- Reforms filed. Atlength after a reign of 31 years (640-609 (2 K 23 29.30), Josiah, in endeavor- BC) ing to intercept Pharaoh-necoh from : combining with the king of Babylon, was defeated and slain at Megiddo and was buried “in his own sepulchre” in Jerus—probably in the same locality where his father and grandfather lay buried. Jehoahaz, after a reign of but 3 months, was carried captive (2 K 23 34) by Necoh to Egypt, where he died—and apparently was buried among strangers (Jer 22 10-12). His brother Eliakim, renamed Jehoiakim, succeeded. In the 4th year of. his reign, Egypt was defeated at Car- chemish by the Babylonians, and as a consequence Jehoiakim had to change from subjection to Egypt to that of Babylon (1 K 23 35 ff). During this time Jeremiah was actively foretelling in 20. Jere- — streets and courts of Jerus (5 1, etc) the miah approaching ruin of the city, messages Prophesies which were received with contempt the Ap- and anger by the king and court (Jer proaching 36 23). In consequence of his revolt Doom against Babylon, bands of Chaldaeans, Syrians, Moabites and Ammonites came against him (2 K 24 2), and his death was inglorious (2 K 24 6; Jer 22 18.19). His son Jehoiachin, who succeeded him, went out with all his household and surrendered to the approaching Nebuchadnezzar (597), and was car- ricd to Babylon where he passed more than 37 years (2 K 26 27-30). Jerus was despoiled of all its treasures and all its important inhabitants. The king of Babylon’s nominee, Zedekiah, after 11 years rebelled against him, and consequently Jerus was besieged for a year and a half until 21. Nehu- “famine was sore in the city.”” On the chadnezzar 9th of Ab all the men of war “fled by Twice night by the way of the gate between Takes the two walls, which was by the king’s Jerusalem garden,” ic. near the mouth of the (586 BC) Tyropceon, and the king “went by the way of the Arabah,” but was over- taken and captured “in the plains of Jericho.” A terrible punishment followed his faithlessness to Babylon (2 K 25 1-7). The city and the temple were despoiled and burnt; the walls of Jerus were broken down, and none but the poorest of the land “to be vinedressers and husbandmen” were left behind (2 K 25 8f; 2 Ch 36 17f). It is probable that the ark was removed also at this time. With the destruction of their city, the hopes of the best elements in Judah turned with longing to : the thought of her restoration. It is 22. Cyrus possible that some of the remnant left and the in the land may have kept up some First Return semblance of the worship of Jeh at (538 BC) the temple-site. At length, however, when in 538 Cyrus the Persian became master of the Bab empire, among many acts of a similar nature for the shrines of Assyr and Bab gods, he gave permission to Jews to return to rebuild the house of Jeh (Ezr 1 if). Over 40,000 (Ezr 1, 2) under Sheshbazzar, prince of Judah (Ezr 1 8.11), governor of a province, returned, bringing with them the sacred vessels of the temple. The daily sacri- fices were renewed and the feasts and fasts restored (3 3-7), and later the foundations of the restored temple were laid (3 10; 5 16), but on account of the opposition of the people of the land and the Samaritans, the building was not completed until 20 years later (6 15). The graphic description of the rebuilding of the walls of Jerus in 445 by Nehemiah gives us the fullest account we have of these forti- 23. Nehe- fications at any ancient period. It is miah Re- clear that Nehemiah set himself to builds the restore the walls, as far as possible, Walls in their condition before the exile. The work was done hurriedly and under conditions of danger, half the workers being armed with swords, spears and bows to protect the others, and every workman was a soldier {Neh 4 13.16-21). The rebuilding took 52 days, but could not have been done at all had not much of the material lain to hand in the piles of ruined masonry. Doubtless the haste and limited resources resulted in a wall far weaker than that Nebuchadnezzar destroyed 142 years previously, but it followed the same out- line and had the same general structure. For the next 100 years we have scarcely any historical knowledge of Jerus. A _ glimpse is afforded by the papyri of Elephantine 24, Bagohi where we read of a Jewish community Governor in Upper Egypt petitioning Bagohi, the governor of Judaea, for permission to rebuild their own temple to Jeh in Egypt; inci- dentally they mention that they had already sent an unsuccessful petition to Johanan the high priest and his colleagues in Jerus. In another document we gather that this petition to the Pers governor was granted. These documents must date about 411-407 BC. Later, probably about 350, we have somewhat ambiguous references to the destruc- tion of Jerus and the captivity of numbers of Jews in the time of Artaxerxes (III) Ochus (358- 337 BC). With the battle of Issus and Alexander's Pales- tinian campaign (c 332 BC), we are upon surer 1617 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem historical ground, though the details of the account (Ant, XI, viii, 4) of Alexander’s visit to Jerus itself are considered of doubtful authenticity. 26. Alex- After his death (823 BC), Pal suffered ander the much from its position, between the Great Ptolemies of Egypt and the Seleucidae of Antioch. Each became in turn its suzerain, aud indeed at one time the tribute ap- oat been divided between them (Ant, , iv, 1). In 321 Ptolemy Soter invaded Pal, and, it is said (Ant, XII, i, 1), captured Jerus by a ruse, entering the city on the Sabbath as if anxious 26. The to offer sacrifice. He carried away Ptolemaic many of his Jewish prisoners to Egypt Rule and settled them there. In the struggles between the contending monarchies, although Pal suffered, the capital itself, on account of its isolated position, remained undis- turbed, under the suzerainty of Egypt. In 217 BC, Ptolemy (IV) Philopator, after his victory over Antiochus III at Raphia, visited the temple at Jerus and offered sacrifices; he is reported (3 Macc 1) to have entered the “Holy of Holies.” The comparative prosperity of the city during the Egyp domination 1s witnessed to by Hecataeus of Abdera, who is quoted by Jos; he even puts the population of the city at 120,000, which is probably an exaggeration. At length in 198, Antiochus the Great having conquered Coele-Syria in the epoch-making battle at Banias, the Jews of their own accord 27. Anti- went over to him and supplied his ochus the army with plentiful provisions; they Great assisted him in besieging the Egyp garrison in the Axra (q.v.) (Ant, XII, iii, 3). Jos produces letters in which Antiochus records his gratification at the reception given him by the Jews and grants them various privileges (ib). We have an account of the ReoepeR yy of the city about this time (190-180 BC) by Jesus ben Sira in the Book of Ecclus; it is a city of crowded life and manifold activities. He refers in glowing terms to the great high priest, Simon ben Onias (226-199 BC), who (Ecclus 50 1-4) had repaired and fortified the temple and strengthened the walls against a siege. The letter of Aristeas, dated probably at the close of this great man’s life (c 200 BC), gives a similar picture. It is here stated that the compass of the city was 40 stadia. The very considerable prosperity and religious liberty which the Jews had enjoyed under the Egyptians were soon menaced under the new ruler; the taxes were in- creased, and very soon fidelity to the tenets of Judaism came to be regarded as 28. Helleni- treachery to the Seleucid rule. Under zation of | Antiochus Epiphanes the Helleniza- the City tion of the nation grew apace (2 Macc under An- 4 9-12; Ant, XII, v,1); at the request tiochus of the Hellenizing party a “place of Epiphanes exercise’’ was erected in Jerus (1 Macc 14; 2 Mace 4 7f). The Gymna- sium was built and was soon thronged by young priests; the Gr hat—the pétasos—became the fashionable headdress in Jerus. The Hellenistic party, which was composed of the aristocracy, was so loud in its professed devotion to the king’s wishes that it is not to be wondered at that Antiochus, who, on a visit to the city, had been received with rap- turous greetings, came to think that the poor and pious who resisted him from religious motives were largely infected with leanings toward his enemies in Egypt. The actual open rupture began when tidings reached Antiochus, after a victorious though politically barren campaign in Egypt, that Jerus had risen in his rear on behalf of the house of Ptol- emy. Jason, the renegade high priest, who had been hiding across the Jordan, had, on the false report of the death of Antiochus, suddenly returned and re-possessed himself of the city. Only the Akra remained to Syria, and this was crowded with Menelaus and those of his followers who had escaped the sword of Jason. Antiochus lost no time; he hastened (170 BC) against Jerus with a 29. Capture great army, captured the city, massa- of the City cred the people and despoiled the (170 BC) temple (1 Mace 1 20-24; Ant, XII, v, 3). Two years later Antiochus, balked by Rome in Egypt (Polyb. xxix.27; Livy xlv.12), appears to have determined that in Jerus, at any rate, he would have no sympathizers with Egypt. He sent his chief collector of tribute (1 Mace 1 29), who attacked the city 30. Capture with strong force and, by means of of 168 BC stratagem, entered it (ver 30). After he had despoiled it, he set it on fire and pulled down both dwellings and walls. He massacred the men, and many of the womenand children he sold as slaves (1 Mace 1 31-35; 2 Macc 5 24). He sac- rificed swine (or at least a sow) upon the holy altar, and caused the high priest himself— 31. At- a Greek in all his sympathies—to par- tempted take of the impure sacrificial feasts; Suppression he tried by barbarous cruelties to sup- of Judaism press the ritual of circumcision (Ant, AI, v, 4).. In everything he endeav- ored, in conjunction with the strong Hellenizing party, to organize Jerus as a Gr city, and to secure his position he built a strong wall, and a great tower for the Akra, and, having furnished it well with armor and victuals, he left a strong garrison (1 Macc 1 33-35). But the Syrians had overreached themselves this time, and the reaction against persecution and attempted religious suppression produced the great uprising of the Maccabeans. The defeat and retirement of the Syrian com- mander Lysias, followed by the death of Antiochus Epiphanes, led to an entire reversal 32. The of policy on the part of the Council of Maccabean the boy-king, Antiochus V. A general Rebellion amnesty was granted, with leave to restore the temple-worship in its an~ cestral forms. The following year (165 BC) Judas Maccabaeus found “the sanctuary desolate, and the altar profaned, the gates burned up, and shrubs growing in the courts as in a forest . . . . and the priests’ chambers pulled down” (1 Macc 4 28). He at once saw to the reconstruction of the altar and restored the temple-services, an event celebrated ever after as the ‘Feast of the Ded- 33. The ication,” or hdnukkah (1 Macc 4 52- Dedication 59; 2 Macc 10 1-11; Ant, XII, vii, 7; of the ef Jn 10 22). Judas also “builded up Temple Mt. Zion,” i.e. the temple-hill, making (1665 BC) itafortress with “high walls and strong towers round about,” and set a garrison in it (1 Macc 4 41-61). The Hellenizing party suffered in the reaction, and the Syrian garrison in the Akra, Syria’s one hold on Judaea, was closely invested; 34. Defeat but though Judas had defeated three of Judas Syrian armies in the open, he could not and Capture expel this garrison. In 163 BC a great of the City Syrian army, with a camel corps and many elephants, came to the relief of the hard-pressed garrison. lLysias, accompanied by the boy-king himself (Antiochus V), approached the city from the S. via Bats-zor (q.v.). At Beth-zachariah the Jews were defeated, and Judas’ brother Eleazar was slain, and Jerus was soon captured. The fort on Mt. Zion which surrounded the sanctuary was surrendered by treaty, but when the king saw its strength, he broke hig oath and destroyed the fortifications (1 Macc 6 Jerusalem THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1618 62). But even in this desperate state Judas and his followers were saved. A certain pretender, Philip, raised a rebellion in a distant part of the empire, and Lysias was obliged to patch up a truce with the nationalist Jews more favorable to Judas than before his defeat; the garrison in the Akra remained, however, to remind the Jews that they were not independent. In 161 BC another Syrian general, Nicanor, was sent against Judas, but he was at first won over to friendship and when, later, at the instigation of the Hellenistic party, he was compelled to attack Judas, he did so with hastily raised levies and was defeated at Adasa, a little N. of Jerus. Judas was, however, not long suffered to celebrate his triumph. A month later Bacchides appeared before Jerus, and in April, 161, Judas was slain in battle with him at Berea. 35. His Both the city and the land were re- Death arrisoned by Syrians; nevertheless, (1461 BC) by 152, Jonathan, Judas’ brother, who was residing at Michmash, was virtual ruler of the land, and by astute negotiation between Demetrius and Alexander, the rival claimants to the throne of Antioch, Jonathan gained more than any of his family had ever done. He was appointed high priest and stratégés, or deputy for the king, in Judaea. He repaired the city and restored the temple-fortress with squared stones (1 Macc 10 10-11). He made the walls higher and built up a great part of the eastern wall which 36. Jona- had been destroyed and “repaired that than’s which was called Caphenatha”’ (1 Restora- Mace 12 36-37; Ani, XIII, v, ii); tions he also made a great mound between the Akra and the city to isolate the Syrian garrison (ib). Simon, who succeeded Jonathan, finally captured the Akra in 139, and, according to Jos (Ant, XIII, vi, 7), not only destroyed it, but par- 37. Sur- tially leveled the very hill on which it render of stood (see, however, 1 Macc 14 36.37). City to John Hyrcanus, 5 years later (134 BC), Antiochus was besieged in Jerus by Antiochus Sidetes Sidetes in the 4th year of his reign; (184 BC) during the siege the Syrian king raised 100 towers each 3 stories high against the northern wall—possibly these may subsequently have been used for the foundations of the second wall. Antiochus was finally bought off by the giving of hostages and by heavy tribute, which Hyrcanus is said to have obtained by opening the sepulcher of David. Nevertheless the king “broke down the fortifications that encompassed the city” (Ané, XIII, viii, 2-4). During the more prosperous days of the Has- monean rulers, several important buildings were erected. There was a great palace on 38. Has- the western (southwestern) hill over- monean looking the temple (Ant, XX, viii, 11), Buildings and connected with it at one time by means of a bridge across the Tyro- poeon, and on the northern side of the temple a citadel—which may (see VIII, 7 above) have been the successor of one here in preéxilic times—known as the Baris; this, later on, Herod enlarged into the Antonia (Ant, XV, xi, 4; BJ, V, v, 8). In consequence of the quarrel of the later Has- monean princes, further troubles fell upon the city. In 65 BC, Hyrcanus Ii, under the 39. Rome’s instigation of Antipas the Idumaean, Intervention rebelled against his brother Aristobulus, to whom he had recently surrendered his claim to sovereignty. With the assistance of Aretas, king of the Nabataeans, he besieged Aristo- bulus in the temple. The Rom general Scaurus, bowever, by order of Pompey, compelled Aretas to retire, and then lent his assistance to Aristo- bulus, who overcame his brother (Ané, XIV, ii, 1-3). Two years later (63 BC) Pompey, having been met by the ambassadors of both parties, bear- ing presents, as well as of the Pharisees, came him- self to compose the quarrel of the rival factions, and, being shut out of the city, took it by 40. Pompey storm. He entered the “Holy of Takes the Holies,” but left the temple treasures City by unharmed. The walls of the city were Storm demolished; Hyrcanus II was reinstated high priest, but Aristobulus was car- ried a prisoner to Rome, and the city became tributary to the Rom Empire (Ant, XIV, iv, 1-4; BJ, I, vii, 1-7). The Syrian proconsul, M. Lucin- ius Crassus, going upon his expedition against the Parthians in 55 BC, carried off from the temple the money which Pompey had left (Ant, XIV, vii, 1). In 47 BC Antipater, who for 10 years had been gaining power as a self-appointed adviser to the weak Hyrcanus, was made a Rom citizen 41. Julius and appointed procurator in return Caesar for very material services which he had Appoints been able to render to Julius Caesar Antipater in Egypt (Ant, XIV, viii, 1, 3, 5); at Procurator the same time Caesar granted to (47 BC) Hyrcanus permission to rebuild the walls of Jerus besides other privileges (Ant, XIV, x, 5). Antipater made his eldest son, Phasaclus, governor of Jerus, and committed Galilee to the care of his able younger son, Herod. In 40 BC Herod succeeded his father as procu- rator of Judaea by order of the Rom Senate, but the same year the Parthians under Pacorus 42. Parthian and Barzapharnes captured and plun- Invasion dered Jerus (Ant, XIV, xiii, 3.4) and reéstablished Antigonus (BJ, 1, xiii, 13). Herod removed his family and treasures to Massada and, having been appointed king of Judaea by Antony, returned, after various adventures, in 37 BC. Assisted by Sosius, the Rom proconsul, he took Jerus by storm after a 5 months’ siege; by the promise of liberal reward he restrained the soldiers from sacking the city (Ant, XIV, xvi, 2-3). During the reign of this great monarch Jerus as- sumed a magnificence surpassing that of all other ages. In 24 BC the king built his vast palace 43. Reign in the upper city on the southwestern of Herod hill, near where today are the Turkish the Great barracks and the Armenian Quarter. (87-4 BC) He rebuilt the fortress to the N. of the temple—the ancient Baris—ou a great scale with 4 lofty corner towers, and renamed it the Antonia in honor of his patron. He celebrated games in a new theater, and constructed a hippodrome (BJ, II, iii, 1) or amphitheater (Ant, XV, viii, 1). He must necessarily have strengthened and repaired the walls, but such work was outshone by the 4 great towers which he erected, Hippicus, Pharsael and Mariamne, near the present Jaffa 44, Herod’s Gate—the foundations of the first two Great are supposed to be incorporated in the Buildings present so-called ‘Tower of David’— and the lofty octagonal tower, Psephi- nus, farther to the N.W. The development of Herod’s plans for the reconstruction of the temple was commenced in 19 BC, but they were not com- pleted till 64 AD (Jn 2 20; Mt 241.2; Lk 21 5.6). The sanctuary itself was built by 1,000 specially trained priests within a space of 18 months (11-10 BC). The conception was magnificent, and resulted in a mass of buildings of size and beauty far surpassing anything that had stood there before. Practically all the remains of the foundations of the temple-enclosure now surviving in connection with the Haram belong to this period. In 4 BC—the year of the Nativity—occurred the disturbances fol- lowing upon the destruction of the Golden Eagle 1619 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem which Herod had erected over the great gate of the temple, and shortly afterward Herod died, having prowelely shut up many of the leading Jews in the podrome with orders that they should be slain when he passed away (BJ, I, xxxiii, 6). The ac- cession of Archelaus was signalized by Passover riots which ended in the death of 3,000, an after- result of the affair of the Golden Eagle. Thinking that order had been restored, Archelaus set out for Rome to have his title confirmed. During his absence Sabinus, the Rom proc- 45. Herod urator, by mismanagement and greed, Archelaus raised the city about his ears, and the (4BC-6AD)next Passover was celebrated by a massacre, street, fighting and open robbery. Varus, the governor of Syria, who had hastened to the help of his subordinate, suppressed the rebellion with ruthless severity and crucified 2,000 Jews. Archelaus returned shortly afterward as ethnarch, an office which he retained until _his exile in 6 AD. During the procuratorship of Coponius (6-10 AD) another Passover riot occurred in conse- quence of the aggravating conduct of some Sa- maritans. During the procuratorship of Pontius Pilate (26-37 AD) there were several disturbances, cul- minating in a riot consequent upon 46. Pontius his taking some of the ‘“‘corban” or Pilate sacred offerings of the temple for the construction of an aqueduct (Ant, XVIU, iii, 2)—probably part at least of the “low- level aqueduct” (see VII, 15, above). Herod Agrippa I inclosed the suburbs, which had grown up N. of the second wall and of the temple, by what Jos calls the ‘“Third Wall’ (see V, above). His son, King Agrippa, built—about 56 AD—a large addition to the old Hasmonean palace, from which he could overlook the temple- 47. King area. This act was a cause of offence Agrippa to the Jews who built a wall on the western boundary of the Inner Court to shut off his view. In the quarrel which ensued the Jews were successful in gaining the support of Nero (Ant, XX, viii, 11). In 64 AD the long rebuilding of the temple-courts, which had been begun in 19 BC, was concluded. The 18,000 work- men thrown out of employment appear to have been given “unemployed work” in “paving the city with white stone’ (Ant, XX, ix, 6-7). Finally the long-smouldering discontent of the Jews against the Romans burst forth into open rebellion under the criminal incom- 48. Rising petence of Gessius Florus, 66 AD against (Ant, XX, xi, 1). Palaces and pub- Florus and lic buildings were fired by the angered Defeat of multitude, and after but two days’ Gallus siege, the Antonia itself was captured, set on fire and its garrison slain (BJ, IL, xvii, 6-7), Cestius Gallus, hastening from Syria, was soon engaged in a siege of the city. The third wall was captured and the suburb BuzEetua (q.v.) burnt, but, when about to renew the attack upon the second wall, Gallus appears to have been seized with panic, and his partial withdrawal developed into an inglorious retreat in which he was pursued by the Jews down the pass to the Beth-horons as far as Antipatris (BJ, TI, xix). This victory cost the Jews dearly in the long run, as it led to the campaign of Vespasian and the eventual crushing of all their national 49. The hopes. Vespasian commenced the con- City Be- quest in the north, and advanced by sieged by slow and certain steps. Being recalled Titus to Rome as emperor in the midst of (70 AD) the war, the work of besieging and capturing the city itself fell to his son Titus. None of the many calamities which had happened to the city are to be compared with this terrible siege. In none had the city been so mag- nificent, its fortifications so powerful, its population so crowded. It was Passover time, but, in addition to the crowds assembled for this event, vast num- bers had hurried there, flying from the advancing Rom army. The loss of life was enormous; ref- ugees to Titus gave 600,000 as the number dead (BJ, V, xiii, 7), but this seems incredible. The total population today within the walls cannot be more than 20,000, and the total population of modern Jerus, which covers a far greater area than that of those days, cannot at the most liberal esti- mate exceed 80,000. Three times this, or, say, a quarter of a million, seems to be the utmost that is credible, and many would place the numbers at far less. The siege commenced on the 14th of Nisan, 70 AD, and ended on the 8th of Elul, a total of 134 days. The city was distracted by 50. Party internal feuds. Simon held the upper Divisions and lower cities; John of Gischala, the within the temple and ‘‘Ophel’; the Idumaeans, Besieged introduced by the Zealots, fought only Walls for themselves, until they relieved the city of their terrors. Yet another party, too weak to make its counsels felt, was for peace with Rome, a policy which, if taken in time, would have found in Titus a spirit of reason and mercy. The miseries of the siege and the destruc- tion of life and property were at least as much the work of the Jews themselves as of their conquerors. On the 15th day of the siege the third wall (Agrip- pa’s), which had been but hastily finished upon the approach of the Romans, was captured; the second wall was finally taken on the 24th day; on the 72d day the Antonia fell, and 12 days later the daily sacrifice ceased. On the 105th day—the ominous 9th of Ab—the temple and the lower 61. Capture city were burnt, and the last day and Utter found the whole city in fiames. Only Destruction the three great towers of Herod, Hip- of the City picus, Pharsael and Mariamne, with the western walls, were spared to pro- tect the camp of the Xth Legion which was left to guard the site, and ‘in order to demonstrate to posterity what kind of city it was and how well fortified”; the rest_of the city was dug up to its foundations (BJ, VII, i, 1). For 60 years after its capture silence reigns over Jerus. We know that the site continued to be garrisoned, but it was not to any extent rebuilt. In 130 AD it was visited by Hadrian, who found 52. Rebel- but few buildings standing. Two years lion of Bar- later (132-35 AD) occurred the last, great Cochba rebellion of the Jews in the uprising of Bar-Cochba (‘‘son of a star’’), who was encouraged by the rabbi Akiba. With the suppression of this last effort for freedom by Julius Severus, the remaining traces of Judaism were stamped out, and it is even said (Talm Jerus, Te'dénith 4) that the very site of the temple was ploughed up by T. Annius Jrmaem ew THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem, 1620 Rufus. An altar of Jupiter was placed upon the temple- site, and Jews were excluded from Jerus on pain of death. In 138 Hadrian rebuilt the city, giving it the name Alia Capitolina. The line of the Southern wall of Alia ee penal Nena ay the outers a ortification o e grea om legionary 53, Hadrian camp on the western (southwestern) hill, Builds and it is probahle that it was the general Elia line of the existing southern wall. At any Capitolina rate, we know that the area occupied by the coenaculum and the traditional ‘* Tomb of David"’ was outside the walls in the 4th cent. An equestrian statue of Hadrian was placed on the site of the ‘' Holy of Holies’’ (Jerome, Comm. on Isa 2 8; Mt 24 15). An inscription now existing in the southern wall of the temple-area, in which occurs the name of Hadrian, may have belonged to this monument, while a stone head, discovered in the neighborhood of Jerus some 40 years ago, may have belonged to the statue. Either Hadrian himself, or one of the Antonine erences erected a temple of Venus on the northwestern hill, where subsequently was built the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (Kuseb., Life of Constantine, III, 36). The habit of pilgrimage to the holy sites, which appears to have had its roots far back in the 2d cent. (see Turner, Journal of Theological Studies, I, 551, quoted by Sanday, Sacred Sites of the Gospels, 75-76), seems to have increas- ingly flourished in the next two centuries; beyond this In 333 AD, by order of Constantine, the new church of the Anastasis, marking the supposed site of the Holy regarding this site and the Holy Cross oe alleged to have heen found there, are re- of doubtful veracity. The building must of the have been magnificent, and covered a Anastasis existing church. In 362 Julian is said to have attempted to rebuild the temple, but doubtful. ‘ At some uncertain date before 450 the coenaculum and walls. This is the condition depicted in the Madeba Mosaic and also that described by Eucherius who, writing “now receives within itself Mt. Zion, which was once outside, and which, lying on the southern side, overhangs of the emperor Valentinian who is known to have done some reconstruction of the walls. II, took up her residence in Jerus and rebuilt the walls upon their ancient lines, bringing the we know little of the city. Sepulchre, was begun. The_ traditions corded some time after the events and are the Church considerably larger area than that of the the work was interrupted by an explosion. The story is ‘Church of the Holy Zion’’ were incorporated within the between 345-50 AD, states that the circuit of the walls the city like a citadel.’’ It is possible this was the work In 450 the empress Eudoxia, the widow of Theodosius whole of the southwestern hill, as well as 56. The the Pool of Siloam, within ‘the circuit Empress §(Evagarius, Hist. Eccles., I, 22). At any Eudoxia rate, this inclusion of the pool existed in Rebuilds the walls described by Antoninus Martyr in 560 AD, and it is confirmed by Bliss’s the Walls work (see above VI, 4). She also built the church of St. Stephon, that at the Pool of Slloam and others. | The emperor Justinian, who was perhaps the greatest of the Christian builders, erected the great Church of St. Mary, the remains of which are now considered by some authorities to be in- corporated in the el 4ksa Mosque; he built also a ‘'Church of St. Sophia’”’ in the “Pretorium,’’i.e. on the site of the Antonia (see, however, Pratorium), and a hospital to the W. of the temple. The site of the temple itself appears to have remained in ruins down to the 7th cent. In 614 Pal was conquered by the Pers Chosroes I1, and the Jerus churches, includ- 56. Justin- ian 57. Chos- ing that of the Holy Sepulchre, were de- roes II stroyed, an event which did much to prepare Captures the way for the Moslem architects of half the Ci a century later, who freely used the columns eCity of these ruined churches in the building of the ''Dome of the Rock.” ‘ In 629 Heracleus, aeene meanwhile made peace with the successor of Chosroes II, reached Jerus in triumph, bearing back the captured fragment of the He entered the city through the cross. 58. Herac- “Golden Gate,’’ which indeed is believed leus Enters by many to have reached its arenenit form It in through sr restore ons. a pata ‘ of Christendom was but short. Seven Triumph years earlier had occurred the historic fiight of Mohammed from Mecca (the Hegira), and in 637 the victorious followers of the Prophet appeared in the Holy City. After a short siege, it capitulated, but the khalif Omar treated the Christians with generous mercy. The Christian sites 2 - were spared, but upon the temple-site, Be ra which up to this had apparently been oc- ency 9 cupied by no important Christian building Omar but was of peculiar sanctity to the Mos- lems through Mohammed’s alleged visions there, a wooden mosque was erected, capable of accom- modating 3,000 worshippers. This was replaced in 691 AD by the magnificent Kubbet es Sahrah, or ** Dome of the Rock,” built by ‘Abd’ul Malek, the YOth khalif. For some centuries the relations of the Christians and Moslems ap- pear to have been friendly: the historian el Mukaddasi, writing in 985, describes the Christians and Jews as having the upper hand in Jerus. In 969 Pal passed into the power of the Egyp dynasty, and in 1010 her ruler, the mad Hakim, burnt many of the churches, which, how- ever, were restored in a poor way. ks In 1077 Isar el Atsis, a leader of the Seljuk Turks con- quered Pal from the N., drove out the Egyptians and massacred 3,000 of the inhabitants of 60. The Jerus. The cruelty of the Turks—in Seli contrast, be it noted, with the conduct of eljuk the Arab Moslems—was the immediate Turks and cause of the Crusades. In 1098 the city Their was retaken by the Egyp Arabs, and the a following year was again captured after Cruelties 4 40 days’ seige by the soldiers of the First Crusade, and Godfrey de Bouillon became the first king. Great huilding activity marked the next 80 peaceful years of Lat rule: numbers of churches were built, but, until toward the end of 61. Cru. this period, the walls were neglected. In iB 3 1177 they were repaired, but 10 years saders Cap- jater failed to resist the arms of the vic- ture the torious Saladin. The city surrendered, but City in 1099 the inhabitants were spared. In 1192 y Saladin repaired the walls, but in 1219 they were dismantled by orders of the sul- tan of Damascus. In 1229 the emperor Frederick IT of Germany obtained the Holy City by treaty, on condition that he did not restore the fortifications, a stipulation which, being broken by the inhabitants 10 years later, brought down upon them the vengeance of the emir of Kerak. Nevertheless, in 1243 the city was again restored to the Christians unconditionally. The following year, however, the Kharizimian Tartars —a wild, savage horde from Central Asia—hurst into Pal, carrying destruction before them; they seized Jerus, massacred the people, 62. The and rifled the tombs of the Lat kings. Khari- Three years later they were ejected from zimians Pal by the Egyptians who in their turn retained it until,-in 1517, they were con- quered by the Ottoman Turks, who still hold it. The greatest of their sultans, Suleiman the Magnificent, huilt the present walls in 1542. In 1832 Mohammed Ali with his Egyp forces came 63. Ottoman and captured the city, but 2 years later : the fellahin rose against his rule and for Turks Ob- a time actually gained possession of the tain the city, except the citadel, making their City in 1517 entrance through the main drain. The y besieged citadel was relieved by the arrival of Ibrahim Pasha from Egypt with rein- forcements. The city and land were restored to the Ottoman Turks by the Great Powers in 1840. X. Modern Jerusalem.—The modern city of Jerus has about 75,000 inhabitants, of whom over two-thirds are Jews. Until about 50 years ago the city 1. Jews and Was confined within its 16th-cent. walls, “Zionism”? the doors of its gates locked every night, ionism'” and even here there were considerable 2 ,areas unoccupied. Since then, and par- ticularly during the last 25 years, there has been a rapid growth of suburbs to the N., N.W., and W. of the old city. This has been largely due to the steady stream of immigrant Jews from every part of the world, particularly from Russia, Roumania, Yemin, Persia, Bokhara, the Caucasus, and from all parts of the Turkish empire. This influx of Jews, a large proportion of whom are extremely poor, has led to settlements or ‘‘colonies’’ of various classes of Jews being erected all over the plateau to the N.—an area never huilt upon before—but also on other sides of the city. With the exception of the Bokhara Colony, which has some fine huildings and occupies a lofty and salubrious situation, most of the settlements are mean cottages or ugly alms- houses. With the exception of a couple of hospitals, there is no Jewish public building of any architectural pretensions. The “Zionist” movement, which has drawn so many Jews to Jerus, cannot be called a suc- cess, as far as this city is concerned, as the settlers and thelr children as a rule either steadily deteriorate physi-~ cally and morally—from constant attacks of malaria, combined with pauperism and want of work—or, in the case of the energetic and enlightened, they emigrate— to America esp.; this emigration has been much stimu- lated of late by the new law whereby Jews and Chris- tians must now, like Moslems, do military service. , The foreign Christian pounce represents all na- tions and all sects; the Roman church is rapidly sur- passing all other sects or religions in the importance of their buildings. The Russians are well represented by their extensive enclosure, which includes a large cathe- dral, a hospital, extensive hospice in several blocks, and a handsome residence for the consul-general, and hy the churches and other buildings on the Mount of Olives. The Germans have a successful colony belonging to the “Temple"’ sect to the W. of Jerus near the railway sta- 1621 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusalem Jerusalem, New tlon, and are worthily represented hy several handsome huildings, e.g. the Protestant ‘‘ Church of the Redeemer,” bullt on the site and on the fround lan of a fine church helonging to the Knights of St. John, the new (Roman Catholic) Church of the Dormition on ‘‘Mount Zlon," with an adjolning Benedictine convent, a very handsome Roman Catholic hospice outside the Damascus Gate, the Kaiserin Augusta Victoria Sanatorium on the Mount of Olives, and a Protestant J ohanniter Hospice In the city, a large general hospital and a leper hospltal, a consulate and two large schools. In influence, both secular and religious, the Germans have rapidly galned ground in the last 2 decades. British influence has much diminished, relatively, The British Ophthalmic Hospital, belonging to the “Order of the Knights of St. John,” the Eng. Mision Boe Palneinn te te pander + te ews Society, the Bishop Gobat's Schoo 2. Christian 379 Eng. College connected with the Buildings Church Missionary Society, 3 Anglican and 4 areacuns oF ae ea aeons St. are eorge's Collegiate Church adjoins the re- Institutions sigence of the Anglican bishop, and a few : small schools comprise the extent of public bulldings connected with British societies. France and the Roman Catholic church are worthily represented by talked-of improvements. There are numerous hotels, hesides extensive accommodations in the religious hos- pices, and no less than 15 hospitals and asylums. Litsraturs.—This is enormous, but of very unequal value and much of it out of date. For all purposes the best hook of reference is Jerus from the Earliest Times to AD 70, 2 vols, hy Principal G. A. Smith. It contains references to all the lit. To this book and to its author it is impossible for the present writer adequately to ex- press his indehtedness, and no attempt at acknowledg- ment in detail has heen made in this art. In supple- ment of the ahove, Jerus, by Dr. Selah Merrill, and Jerus in Bible Times, hy Professor Lewis B. Paton, will be found useful. The latter is a condensed account, esp. valuable for its illustrations and its copious references. Of the arts. in the recent Bible Dictionaries on Jerus, that hy Conder in HDB is perhaps the most valuable. Ot guide-books, Baedeker’s Guide to Pal and Syria (1911), by Socin and Benzinger, and Barnahe Meistermann’s (R.C.) New Guide to the Holy Land (1909), will he found useful; also Hanauer's Walks about Jerus. On ele Climate and ieee Senay: Hull's “Memoir on Physical Geography and Geology of Ara- bian Petraea, Pal, and Adjoining Districts,” PEF; and Mopvern JeRvusALEM (wiTH Poo, of Hezegian IN ForeGRrounp). the Dominican monastery and seminary connected with the handsome church of St. Stephen—rehuilt on the plan of an old Christian church—hy the Ratisbon (Jesuit) Schools, the Hospital of St. Louis, the hospice and Church of St. Augustine, and the monastery and seminary of the “white fathers” or Fréres de la mission algérienne, whose headquarters center round the heautifully re- stored Church of 8t. Anne. Not far from here are the convent and school of the Seurs de Sion, at the Ecce Homo Church. Also inside the walls near the New Gate is the residence of the Lat Patriarch—a cardinal of the Church of Rome—with a church, the school of the Fréres de la doctrine chrétienne, and the schools, hospi- tal and convent of the Franciscans, who are recognized among their coreligionists as the ‘‘ parish priests’’ in the city, having been established there longer than the numerous other orders. . All the various nationalities are under their respective consuls and enjoy extra-territorial rights. Besides the Turkish post-office, which is very inefficiently managed, the Austrians, Germans, French, Russians and Italians all have post-offices open to all, with special ‘‘ Levant stamps. The American mail is delivered at the French post-office. There are four chief hanks, French, Ger- man, Ottoman and Anglo-Pal (Jewish). As may be supposed, on account of the demand for land for Jewish settlements or for Christian schools or convents, the price of such property has risen enormously. Unfortu- nately in recent years all owners of land—and Moslems have not been slow to copy, the foreigners—have taken to inclosing their property with high and unsightly walls, greatly spoiling both the walks around the city and the prospects from many points of view. The increased development of carriage traffic has led to considerahle dust in the dry season, and mud in winter, as the roads are metaled with very soft limestone. The Jerus-Jaffa Railway (a Fr. company), 54 miles long, which was opened in 1892, has steadily increased its traffic year by year, and is now a very paying concern. There is no real municipal water-supply, and no public sewers for the new suhurbs—though the old city is drained by a leaking, ill-constructed mediaeval sewer, which opens just below the Jewish settlement in the Kidron and runs down the Wady en Nér. A water-supply, new sewers, electric trams and electric lights for the streets, are all much- Blankenhorn," Geology of the Nearer Environsof Jerus,” ZDPV, 1905; Chaplin, ‘‘Climate of Jerus," PEFS, 1883; Glaisher, ‘‘ Meteorol. Observations in Pal,’”’ special pamphlet of the Palestine Exploration Fund; ilder- scheid, ‘‘Die Niederschlagsverhiltnisse Pal in alter u. neuer Zeit,” ZDPV (1902); Huntington, Pal and Its Transformation (1911); Andrew Watt, ‘Climate in Hebron,"’ etc, Journal of the Scottish Meteorological So- ciety (1900-11); Schick, ‘‘Die Wasserversorgung der Stadt Jerus,” ZDPV, 1878; Wilson ‘‘Water Supply of Jerus,"’ Proceedings of the Victoria Institute, 1906; Mas- terman, in BW, 1905. On Archaeology and Topography: PEF, vol on Jerus, with accompanying maps and plans; Clermont- Ganneau, Archaeological Researches, I, 1899 (PEF); William, Holy City (1849); Rohinson, Bib. Researches (1856); Wilson, Recovery of Jerus (1871); Warren Underground Jerus (1876); Vincent, Underground Je- rusalem (1911); Guthe, ''Ausgrabungenin Jerus,"" ZDPV, V; Bliss and Dickie, Excavations in Jerus (1894-97): Sanday, Sacred Sites of the Gospels (1903); Mitchell, “The Wall of Jerus according to the Book of Neh,” JBL (1903); Wilson, Golgotha and the Holy Sepulchre (1906); Kuemmel, Materialien z. Topographie des alten Jerus; also numerous reports in the PEFS; Zeitschrift des deutschen Pal Vereins; and the Revue biblique. On History: hesides Bible, Apoc, works of Jos, and History of Tacitus: Besant and Palmer, History of Jerus; Conder, Judas Maccabaeus and Latin Kingdom of Jerus; Le Strange, Pal under the Mosiems (1890); C. F. Kent, Biblicai Geography and History (1911). Bevan, Jerus under the High-Priests; Watson, The Story of Jerus. E. W. G. Masrerman JERUSALEM, NEW (Iepovoadhp xawh, Hie- rousalém kainé): This name occurs in Rev 21 2 (ver 10, “holy city’). The conception is based on prophecies which predict a glorious future to Jerus a‘ter the judgment (Isa 562 1). In Rev, however, it is not descriptive of any actual locality on earth, but allegorically depicts the final state of the church (‘‘the bride,” “the wife of the Lamb,” 21 2.9), when the new heaven and the new earth shall Jerusha Jesse THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1622 have come into being. The picture is drawn from a twofold point of view: the new Jerus is a restora- tion of Paradise (21 6; 22 1.2.14); it is also the ideal of the theocracy realized (21 3.12.14.22). The latter viewpoint explains the peculiar representa- tion that the city descends “out of heaven from God”’ (21 2.10), which characterizes it as, on the one hand, a product of God’s supernatural work- manship, and as, on the other hand, the culmination of the historic process of redemption. In other NT passages, where the theocratic point of view is less prominent, the antitypical Jerus appears as having its seat in heaven instead of, as here, coming down from heaven to earth (cf Gal 4 26; He 11 10; 12 22). See also REVELATION oF JOHN. . GEERHARDUS Vos JERUSHA, jé-ro0’sha (NWI, yrasha’, ‘taken possession of,” i.e. “married’): In 2 K 15 33= “Jerushah” (MWIN), yerishah, same meaning) of 2 Ch 27 1, the mother of King Jotham of Judah. Zadok was her father’s name; he may be the priest of 1 Ch 6 12 (Heb & 38). JESHAIAH, jé-sha’ya, jé-shi’a ([a] IW), yesha'- yaha; [b] WWW, yshatyah, “deliverance of Jeh”; [2] [3] below have form [a], the others form [6]): (1) Son of Hananiah, and grandson of Zerub- babel, according tc 1 Ch 3 21, AV “Jesaiah.” But commentators follow Heb (and RVm) in the first part of the verse, and LXX, Vulg, Syr in the second part, thus reading, ‘‘And the son of Hananiah [was] Pelatiah, and Jeshaiah [was] his son, and Arnan his son,”’ etc, thus making J. a grandson of Hananiah. (2) A “son” of Jeduthun, and like him a temple musician; head of the family of that name (1 Ch 25 3.15). (3) A Levite, ancestor of Shelemoth, one of David’s treasurers (1 Ch 26 25). (4) A descendant of Elam; he went with Ezra from Babylon to Jerus (Ezr 8 7)=‘“‘Jesias” (RV), “Josias’ (AV), 1 Esd 8 33. (5) A descendant of Merari and a contemporary of Ezra (Ear 8 19)=‘“‘Osaias’” of 1 Esd 8 48. (6) A Benjamite (Neh 11 7), AV “Jesaiah.” Davin Francis RoBEeRtTs JESHANAH, jesh’a-na, jé-sha’na (IW, ysha- nah): A town named with Bethel and Ephron among the places taken by Abijah from Jeroboam (2 Ch 18 19). Most scholars are agreed that the same name should be read instead of JWO, ha-shen, in 1 S$ 7 12. Itis probably identical with the Iedvas, Isénas, of Jos (Ant, XIV, xv, 12). It is represented by the modern ‘Ain Sinia, 3} miles N. of Bethel, with a spring and interesting ancient remains. JESHARELAH, jesh-a-ré’la (MEN W, sar’ alah, meaning doubtful): One of the (or probably a family of) Levitical musicians (1 Ch 25 14), called “Asharelah” in ver 2. The names should be written “‘Asarelah’’ and ‘‘Jesarelah.” JESHEBEAB, jé-sheb’é-ab (ANW", yeshebh’abh, meaning uncertain): A Levite of the 14th course (1 Ch 24 13). Kittel and Gray (HPN, 24) read with LXX, A, “Ishbaal”; the name is omitted in LXX, B, and the change in MT as well as the omission in LXX may be due to the word bae‘al forming part of the name. Cf JERUBBESHETH. JESHER, jé’shér (alh > yesher, or Ww. yesher, “uprightness”): A son of Caleb (1 Ch 2 18). JESHIMON, jé-shé’mon, jesh’i-mon (jaw "4, ha-y’shimon, “the desert,’ and in RV so tr¢; but in AV, Nu 21 20; 28 28; 1S 23 19.24; 26 1.3, “Jeshimon” as a place-name. In Nu LXX reads 4 Epnpos, hé érémos, “the desert”; inl] S LXX reads Teroatpdv, Tessaimin): In these passages probably two districts are referred to: (1) The “desert” N. of the Dead Sea, which was overlooked from Pisgah (Nu 21 20; 23 28). This is the bare and sterile land, saturated with salt, lying on each side of the Jordan N. of the Dead Sea, where for miles practi- cally no vegetable life can exist. (2) The sterile plateau W. of the steep cliffs bordering the western shores of the Dead Sea. Here between the lower slopes of the Judaean hills, where thousands of Bed- -ouin live and herd their flocks, and the more fertile borders of the sea with their oases (‘Ain Feshkhah, ‘Ain Jidy, etc), is a broad strip of utterly waterless land, the soft chalky hills of which are, for all but a few short weeks, destitute of practically any vegeta- tion. The Hill of Hachilah was on the edge of this desert (1 S 23 19; 26 1.3), and the Arabah was to its south (1 S 28 24). It is possible that the refer- ences in Nu may also apply to this region. The word “Jeshimon” (y‘shimén) is often used as a common noun in referring to the desert of Sinai (Dt 32 10; Ps 78 40; 106 14; Isa 43 19, etc), and except in the first two of these references, when we have “wilderness,” it is always tr’ “desert.” Althongh used in 7 passages in poetical parallelism to midhbar, tr? “wilderness,” it really means a much more hopeless place; in a midhbaér animals can be pastured, but a y*shtmon is a desolate waste. E. W. G. MastermMan JESHISHAI, je-shish’4-1 (UW 2", yshishay, “aged’’): A Gadite chief (and family?) (1 Ch 5 14). JESHOHAIAH, jesh--ha’ya, jesh-6-hi’a as, yshohayah, meaning unknown): A prince in Simeon (1 Ch 4 36). JESHDUA, jesh’ii-a, JESHUAH, je-shi’a (102, yeshu**, “Jeh is deliverance’ or ‘opulence’; cf JOSHUA): (1) AV ‘Jeshuah,” head of the 9th course of priests, and possibly of “the house of Jeshua”’ (1 Ch 24 11; Ezr 2 36; Neh 7 39). (2) A Levite of Hezekiah’s time (2 Ch $1 15). (3) Son of Jozadak=Joshua the high priest (Ezr 23;3 2.8; 43; 52; 10 18; Neh 7 7; 12 1.7.10. ne ise JosHua (4)=“Jesus’’ (1 Esd 5 48 and Sir (4) A man of Pahath-moab, some of whose de- scendants returned from Babylon to Jerus with creas (Ezr 2 6; Neh 7 11)=“Jesus” (1 Esd 8). (5) Head of a Levitical house which had over- sight of the workmen in the temple (Ezr 2 40; 39; Neh 7 43). He is mentioned agam in Neh 8 7 as taking part in explaining the Torah to the people, in 9 4f (cf 12 8) as leading in the wor- ship, and in 10 9 (Heb 10) as sealing the covenant; this J. is called son of Azaniah (Neh 10 9). To these references should be added probably Neh 12 24, where commentators read, “Jeshua, Binnui, Kad- miel” for ‘“Jeshua the son of Kadmiel.”’ Perhaps Jozabad (Ezr 8 33) is a “‘son”’ of this same Jeshua; ef Ezr 8 33=1 Esd 8 63, where AV is “Jesu,” RV “Jesus.” He is the same as Jessue (AV), Jesus (RV) (1 Esd 5 26). ; 2 a Father of Ezer, a repairer of the wall (Neh (7) Josuva, son of Nun (Neh 8 17) (q.v.). Davip Francis Roperts JESHOUA, jesh’t-a, jé-shi’a (9107, yeshue'): A place occupied by the children of Judah after their return from captivity (Neh 11 26), evidently, from the places named with it, in the extreme S. of Judah. It may correspond with the Shema of Josh 16 26, 1623 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jerusha Jesse and possibly to the Sheba of 19 2. The site may be Khirbet Sd‘weh, a ruin upon a prominent hill, Tell es Sa‘weh, 12 miles E.N.E. of Beersheba. The hill is surrounded by a wall of large blocks of stone. PEF, III, 409-10, Sh XXV. JESHURUN, jéshi’run, jesh’d-run (77, yshurdn, “upright one,’”’? Dt 32 15; 33 5.26; Isa 44 2): LXX tr® it “the beloved one” (qyarnuéves, égapéménas, the perf. part. passive of agapdd), and in Isa 44 2 adds ‘Israel’; Vulg has dilectus in Dt 32 15, elsewhere rectissimus; Aq., Symm., Theod. have “upright.” For the form, Duhm compares WR0aT, zbhulun, Zebulun. (1) The name used to be explained as a diminutive form, a pet name, and some, e.g. Cornill, Schultz (OT Thea. ET, H, 29, n.12) still explain it so, “the righteous little people.” But there is no evidence that the ending -tn had a diminutive force. (2) Most moderns take it as a poetical or ideal title of Israel, derived from “W", ydshar, “upright’’; it is held to contain a tacit reference to the word Israel (oxen , yisra@ él), of which the first three consonants are almost the same as those of “Jeshurun”; in Nu 23 10 the term ‘the righteous ones” (O"7|", ysha@rim) is supposed to contain a similar reference. Most commentators compare also ‘‘the Book of Jashar,’’ and it has been held that ‘Jashar’ is similarly a name by which Israel is called. See JasHan. Following Bacher (ZATW, 1885, 161 ff), com- mentators hold that in Isa this new name, a coinage due to the author of Second Isaiah and adopted in Dt, stands in contrast to Jacob, ‘the supplanter,” as his name was explained by the Hebrews (cf Hos 12 2-4). Israel is here given a new name, “the upright, pious one,” and with the new name goes a new chance in life, to live up to its meaning. Driver (Dt, 361) says that in Dt 32 15 ‘‘where the context is of declension from its ideal [it is] applied reproach- fully. ‘Nomen Recti pro Israele ponens, ironice eos perstringit qui a rectitudine defecerant’ (Calv.). Elsewhere it is used as a title of honor.” AV has ‘Jesurun” in Isa 44 2. Davip Francis RoBerts JESIAH, jé-si’a (1 Ch 23 20AV). Sce Issurau. _ JESIAS, jé-si’as (Ierlas, [esias; AV Josias [1 Esd 8 33]): Corresponding to Jeshaiah, son of Athaliah (Ezr 8 7). JESIMIEL, jé-sim’i-el OND, y’simi’ él, “God establishes”): A prince of Simeon (1 Ch 4 36). JESSE, jes’é (UH, yishay, meaning doubtful; according to Gesenius it=‘“‘wealthy”; Olshausen, Gram., §§ 277 f, conjectures 17 UW, yésh yah, “Jeh exists’; Wellhausen [1 5 14 49] explains it as "WAN, 'dbhishay [see ApisHat]; "lecoat, Jessai; Ruth 4 17.22; 158 16; 17; 20; 22; 25 10; 28 201; 231; 1K 1216; 1Ch10 14; 12 18; Ps 72 20; Isa 11 1.10 [=Rom 15 12]); Mt 1 5.6; Acts 13 22): Son of Obed, grandson of Boaz, and father of King David. The grouping of the refer- ences to J. in 1 S is bound up with that of the grouping of the whole narrative of David and Saul. See SamurL, Booxs or. There seem to be three main veins in the narrative, so far as J. is concerned. (1) In1 § 16 1-18, where J. is called the Bethle- hemite. Samuel is sent to seek among J.’s sons a successor to Saul. Both Samuel and J. fail to discern at first Jeh’s choice, Samuel thinking that it would be the eldest son (ver 6), while J. had not thought it worth while to call the young- est to the feast (ver 11). (2) (2) In 18 16 14-23, Saul is mentally dis- turbed, and is advised to get a harpist. David “the son of J. the Bethlehemite’”’ is recommended by a courtier, and Saul sends to J. for David. “And J. took ten loaves [so emend and translate, and not as RV, ‘an ass laden with bread"’], and, a [skin] bottle of wine, and a kid, and sent them" to Saul as a present with David, who becomes a courtier of Saul's with his father’s consent. (b) The next mention of J is in three contemp- tuous references by Saul to David as ‘‘the son of J.” in 20 27.30.31, part of the quarrel-scene between Saul and Jonathan. (But it is not quite certain if ch 20 belongs to the same source as 16 14-23.) In answer to the first reference, Jonathan calls his friend ‘‘David,’’ and Saul repeats the phrase “the son of J.,” abusing Jonathan personally (ver 30, where the meaning is uncertain). The reference to David as “the son of J.’ here and in the following verse is contemptuous, not because of any reproach that might attach itself to J., but, as Budde remarks, because ‘“‘an upstart is always contemptuously referred to under his father’s name” in courts and society. History repeats itself! (c) Further references of a like kind are in the 2 6-23, viz. in vs 7.8.13 by Saul, and repeated in ver 9. ‘ ane (d) The final one of this group is in 25 10, where Nabal See asks ‘‘Who is David? and who is the son 6 i (3) The parts of 17—18 5 which are omitted by LXX B, ie. 17 12-31.41.48b.50.55—18 6a. Here J. is mentioned as ‘an Ephrathite of Beth-lehem- judah” (ver 12, not ‘‘that” Ephrathite, which is a grammatically impossible tr of the MT), Ephrath or Ephrathah being another name for Bethlehem, or rather for the district. He is further said to have eight sons (ver 12), of whom the three eldest had followed Saul to the war (ver 18). J. sends David, the shepherd, to his brothers with pro- visions (ver17). Afterward David, on being brought to Saul and asked who he is, answers, ‘‘I am the son of thy servant J. the Bethlehemite'’ (ver 58). J. is also de- scribed (ver 12) as being ‘'in the days of Saul an old man, advanced in years” (so emend and translate, not as RV, ‘‘stricken in years among men"’). The mention of his having 8 sons in ver 12 is not in agreement with 1 Ch 2 13-15, which gives only 7 sons with two sisters, but where Syr gives 8, adding, from 27 18, Elihu which MT has there probably by corruption (Curtis, Ch, 88). 1 8 16 10 should be tr¢ ‘‘and J. made his 7 sons to pass before Samuel” (not as RV, AV, ‘'seven of his sons"’). Budde (Kurz. Hand-Komm., '‘Samuel,"’ 114) holds 16 1-13 to be a late Midr, and (ib, 123 f) omits (a) ‘'that’’ in 17 12; (6) also ‘and he had 8 sons" as due to a wrong inference from 16 10; (c) the names of the 3 eldest in 17 13; (d) ver 14b; he then changes 15a, and reads thus: (12) ‘' Now D. was the son of an Ephrathite of Bethlehem- Judah, whose name was J., who was .... [years] old at the time of Saul. (3) And the 3 eldest sons of J. had marched with Saul to the war, (14) and David was the youngest, (15) and David had remained to feed his iauhere sheepat Bethlehem. (16) Now the Philis came,” etc. According to all these narrativesin 1 8, whether all 3 be entirely independent of one another or not, J. had land in Bethlehem, probably outside the town wall, like Boaz (see Boaz) his grandfather (Ruth 4 17). In 22 3.4 David intrusts his father and mother to the care of the king of Moab, but from 20 29 some have inferred that J. was dead (although most critics assign 22 3 at any rate to the same stratum as ch 20). Jonathan tells Saul that David wanted to attend a family sacrificial feast at. Bethlehem (20 29). MT reads, “And he, my brother, has commanded me,’’ whereas we should probably read with LX X, ‘‘and my brethren have commanded me,"'i.e. the members of the clan, as we have farther on in the verse, ‘‘Let me get away, I pray thee,and see my brethren.” As to J.’s daughters, see ABroarL; AHASH. (4) Of the other references to J., the most note- worthy is that in Isa 11 1: ‘’There shall come forth a shoot out of the stock of Jesse, and a branch out of assage, y Doeg Jesting Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1624 his roots shall bear fruit,” ie. out of Jesse's roots (ef Rev 6 5). “Why J. and not David?” asks Duhm; and he answers, ‘“‘Becanse the Messiah will be a second David, rather than a descendant of David.” Marti explains it to mean that he will be, not from David, but from a collateral line of descent. Duhm’s explanation suggests a paral- lelism between David and Christ, of whom the former may be treated as a type similar to Aaron and Melchizedek in He. Saul might pour contempt upon ‘‘the son of J.,” but Isaiah has given J. here a name above all Heb names, and thus does Provi- dence mock “society.”’? See also Root oF JESSE. Davin Francis RoBeRtTs JESTING, jest’ing: Used from Tindale down as the tr of evrpaweda, eutrapelia (Eph 5 4). Aris- totle uses the original in his Ethics iv.14 as an equivalent of “quick-witted,” from its root mean- ing “something easily turned,” adding that, since the majority of people love excessive jesting, the word is apt to be degraded. This is the case here, where it clearly has a flavor of the coarse or licen- tions. JESUI, jes’ti-i. JESUITES, jes’ti-its. See Isuvr. JESURUN, jé-si’run, jes’i-run. JESUS, jé’zus (Inoods, Tésous, for PWW, ychoshu*): (1) Joshua, son of Nun (AV Acts 7 45; He 4 8; ef 1 Mace 2 55; 2 Esd 7 37). (2) (8) High priest and Levite. Sce Jesuva, 2, 5. (4) Son-of Sirach. See Srracu. (5) An ancestor of Jesus (Lk 3 29, AV “Jose”’). (6)- (7) See the next three articles. JESUS CHRIST, jée’zus krist (Incots Xpiorrds, Tésous Christés) : Tus Names OrpER or TREATMENT See Isxvt. See JEsHURUN. I. Ti. Parr I. Inrropuctory I. Tus Sources 1. In General 2. Denial of Existence of Jesus 3. Extra-Christian Notices 4. The Gospels (1) The Synoptics (2) The Fourth Gospel Tur PREPARATION 1. Both Gentile and Jewish 2. OT Preparation 3. Post-exilian Preparation THE OvutrwaRp SITUATION 1. The Land Its Divisions 2. Political Situation Changes in Territory 3. The Religious Sects (1) The Scribes (2) The Pharisees (3) The Sadducees (4) The Essenes Tue CaRONOLOGY 1. Date of the Birth of Jesus 2. Date of Baptism 3. Length of Ministry 4, Date of Christ's Death Part II. Tse Propiems or THE Lire or Jesus I. Tue Mirac.es 1. The “Modern” Attitude 2. Supernatural in the Gospels Tue MusstansHip Fier 1. Reserve of Jesus and Modern Criticism 2. A Growing Revelation Kinepom anp ArocaLyPsE 1. The Kingdom—Present or Future? 2. Apocalyptic Beliefs Tae CHARACTER AND CLAIMS 1. Denial of Christ’s Moral Perfection 2. Sinlessness and the Messianic Claim Part III. Covurss or tran Earra.y Lire or Jesus 1. Divisions of the History 2. Not a Complete “Life” TL, III. Iv. II. III. IV. A. I. II. III Iv. III. IV. FROM THE NATIVITY TO THE BAPTISM AND TEMPTATION Tue Nativity Oboe 6. 7 . Hidden Piety in Judaism . Birth of the Baptist . The Annunciation and Its Results . The Birth at Bethlehem (1) The Census of Quirinius (2) Jesus Born . The Incidents of the Infancy (1) The Visit of the Shepherds APN (2) The Circumcision and Presentation in the Temple (3) Visit of the Magi Flight to Egypt and Return to Nazareth Questions and Objections (L) The Virgin Birth (2) The Genealogies Tur YEaRs or SILENCE—TxHE TWELFTH YEAR 1. 2. The Human Development Jesus in the Temple Tue FoRERUNNER AND THE BartisM 1. 2. The Preaching of John The Coming Christ Jesus Is Baptized THE TEMPTATION 1. 2. 3. Temptation Follows Baptism Nature of the Temptation Stages of the Temptation Its Typical Character B. THE EARLY JODAEAN MINISTRY Tae TusTIMONIEs OF THE Baptist 1. 2. The Synoptics and John Threefold Witness of the Baptist Tse First Discretes 1. 2. Spiritual Accretion “Son of Man” and ‘“‘Son of God’ Tue First Events 1. 2. 3. A. The First Miracle The First Passover, and Cleansing of the Temple The Visit of Nicodemus Jesus and John JOURNEY TO GALILEE—THE WoMAN OF SAMARIA 1. Withdrawal to Galilee . The Living Water . The True Worship . Work and Its Reward GALILEAN MINISTRY AND VISITS TO THE FEASTS - The Scene . The Time First Pertod—-From the Beginning of the Minisiry in I. II. III. Galilee till the Mission of the Twelve Oprenino INcIDENTS POOR . Healing of Nohleman’s Son . The Visit to Nazareth . Call of the Four Disciples . At Capernaum a) Christ’s Teaching b) The Demoniac in the Synagogue Demon-Possession: Its Reality c) Peter’s Wife’s Mother d) The Eventful Evening From tHe First GaLiLbeaAN CIRCUIT TILL THE CHOICE OF THE APOSTLES 1. 2. 3. The First Circuit Capernaum Incidents a) Cure of the Paralytic . b) Call and Feast of Matthew The Unnamed Jerusalem Feast a) The Healing at Bethesda 6b) Son and Father ce) The Threefold Witness . Sabbath Controversies a) Plucking of the Ears of Grain b) The Man with the Withered Hand ce) Withdrawal to thé Sea . The Choosing of the Twelve a) The Apostolic Function b) The Lists ec) The Meu From THE SERMON ON THE Mount TILL THE ParR- ABLES OF THE Kinopom—A Sxconp Circovlt 1. The Sermou on the Mount a) The Blessings b) True Righteousness—the Old and the New Law ce) Religion and Hypocrisy—True and False Motive d) The True Good and Cure for Care e) Relation to the World’s Evil—the Conclu- sion . Intervening Incidents a) Healing of the Centurlon's Servant b) The Widow of Nain’s Son Raised c) Embassy of John’s Disciples—Christ and His Generation d) The First Anointing—the Woman Who Was a Sinner o> 1625 3. 4. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesting Jesus Christ Second Galilean Circuit—Events at Capernaum a) Galilee Revisited b) Cure of Demoniac—Discourse ou Blasphemy The Sign of Jonah ¢) Christ’s Mother and Brethren eaching in Parables Parables of the Kingdom IV. From THe Crossina To GADARA TO THE MissI0N oF THE TweL_ve—A TuHIRp Circuir 1. 2. 3. Crossing of the Lake—Stilling of the Storm a) Aspirants for Discipleship b) The Storm Calmed The Gadarene (Gerasene) Demoniac ate Daughter Raised—Womanu with Issue of oo a) Jairus’ Appeal and Its Result db) The Afflicted Woman Cured . Incidents of Third Circuit . The Twelve Sent Forth—Discourse of Jesus a) The Commission b) Counsels and Warnings Second Peritod—After the Mission of the Twelve till the Departure from Galilee I. From tas Doeatsa or ton Baptist tity tHE Dis- COURSE ON THE BREAD OF LIFE 1. 2. 3. 4, The Murder of the Baptist and Herod’s Alarms The Feeding of the Five Thousand Walking on the Sea Gennesaret—Discourse on the Bread of Life Peter’s First Confession II, From Disrutes wity TRH PHARISEES TILL THE TRANSFIOURATION 1. 2. Jesus and Tradition—Outward and Inward ‘urity Retirement to Tyre and Sidon—the Syrophoeni- cian Woman 3. At Decapolis—New Miracles a) The Deaf Man b) Feeding of the Four Thousand 4, Leaven of the Pharisees, etc—-Cure of Blind 5. an At Caesarea Philippi—the Great Confession— First Announcement of Passion 6. The Transfiguration—the Epileptic Boy III. From Private JouRNnY THROUOH GALILEE TILL RetuRN FROM THE Feast oF TanERNACLES 1. Galilee and Capernaum a) Second Announcement of the Passion b}) The Temple Tax ce) Discourse on Greatness and Forgiveness (1) Greatness in Humility (2) Tolerance (3) The Erring Brother (4) Parable of Unmerciful Servant 2. The Feast of Tabernacles—Discourses, etc a) The Private Journey—Divided Opinions b) Christ’s Self-Witness ec) The Woman Taken in Adultery d) The Cure of the Blind Man e) The Good Shepherd Chronological Note D. LAST JOURNEY TO JERUSALEM—JESUS IN PERAEA I. From Leavine GALILEB TILL THE FEAST OF THE DeEpDicaTION 1. Rejected by Samaria 2. Mission of the Seventy 3. 4. The Lawyer's Question—Parable of Good Samaritan Discourses, Parables, and Miracles a) Original to Luke bd) The Infirm Woman—the Dropsied Man ec) Parable of the Great Supper d) Counting the Cost 5. Martha and Mary 6. Feast of the Dedication II. From tse Anops aT BETHABARA TILL THE Rals- INO OF LAZARUS 1. 2. 3. Parables of Lost Sheep, Lost Piece of Silver and Prodigal Son_ | Parables of the Unjust Steward and the Rich Man and Lazarus The Summons to Bethany—Raising of Lazarus III, From tue Retirement To EPuHRaIM TILL THE ARRIVAL aT BETHANY 1. Retreat to Ephraim Poy on . The Journey Resumed . Cure of the Lepers . Pharisaic Questionings a) Divorce bd) Coming of the Kingdom c) Parable of the Unjust Judge he Spirit of the Kingdom a) Parable of Pharisee and Publican b) Blessing of the Babes c) The Rich Young Ruler . Third Announcement of the Passion The Rewards of the Kingdom a) Parable of the Laborers in the Vineyard b) The Sons of Zebedee 8. Jesus at Jericho a) The Cure of Bartimacus b) Zacchaeus the Publican c) Parable of the Pounds Arrival at Bethany E. THE PASSION WEERK—BETRAYAL, TRIAL, AND CRUCIFIXION I. Tae Events Precepino tue Last Supper 1, The Chronology 2. The Anointing at Bethany 3. The Entry into Jerusalem Jesus Weeping over Jerusalem—Return to Betl- any 4. Cursing of the Fig Tree—Second Cleansing of the Temple Were There Two Cleansings ? 5. The Eventful Tuesday a) The Demand for Authority—Parables 1) The Two Sons—the Wicked Husbandmen 2) The Marriage of the King’s Son b) Ensnaring Questions, etc (1) Tribute to_Caesar—the Resurrectlon— the Great Commandment (2) David's Son and Lord ce) The Great Deuunciation d) The Widow's Offering e) The Visit of the Greeks f) Discourse on the Last Things g) Parables of Ten Virgins, Talents and Last Judgment 6. A Day of Retirement 7. An Atmosphere of Plotting—Judas and the Priests II, From tee Last SuprPak TILL TRE Cross 1. The Chronology 2. The Last Supper a) The Preparation b) Dispute about Precedence—Washing of the Disciples’ Feet—Departure of Judas Fy The Lord's Supper d) The Last Discourses—Intercessory Prayer e) The Departure and Warning 3. Gethsemane—the Betrayal and Arrest a) Agony in the Garden b) Betrayal by Judas—Jesus Arrested 4. Trial before the Sanhedrin Legal and Historical Aspects a) Before Annas and Caiaphas—the Unjust Judgment b) The Threefold Denial ec) Remorse and Suicide of Judas 5. Trial before Pilate a) The Attitude of the Accusers b) The Attitude of Pilate (1) Jesus Sent to Herod (2) “‘Not This Man, but Barabbas" (3) ‘‘Ecce Homo” (4) A Last Appeal—Pilate Yields ce) The Attitude of Jesus III. Tue Crucifixion aNpD BuRIAL 1. The Crucifixion a) On the Way ‘ b) Between the Thieves—the Superscription— the Seamless Robe The Mocking—the Penitent Thief—Jesus and His Mother d) The Great Darkness—the Cry of Desertion 2) Last Words and Death of Jesus f) The Spear-Thrust—Earthquake and Rending of the Veil 2. The Burial a) The New Tomb b) The Guard of Soldiers F, THE RESURRECTION AND ASCENSION The Resurrection a Fundamental Fact 1. The Resurrection a) The Easter Morning—the Open Tomb (1) The Angel and the Keepers 2) Visit of the Women 3) The Angelic Message Visit of Peter and John— Appearance to Mary Report to the Disciples—Incredulity Other Easter-Day Appearances (Kmmaus, Jerusalem) d) The Second Appearance to the Eleven—the Doubt of Thomas The Galilean Appearances (1) At the Sea of Tiberias—the Draught of Fishes—Peter's Restoration (2) On the Mountain—the Great Commis- sion— Baptism f) Appearance to James g) The Last Meeting 2. The Ascension nd & b Need €. ~ € Part IV. Eprirooun: Tue Apostouic TEacuino 1. After the Ascension 2. Revelation through the Spirit 3. Gospels and Epistles _ 4, Fact of Christ's Lordship Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1626 5. Significance of Christ’s Person 6. Significance of the Cross and Resurrection 7. Hope of the Advent LITERATURE _ Jesus Christ: The Founder of the Christian re- ligion; the promised Messiah and Saviour of the world; the Lord and Head of the Christian church. I. The Names.—(1) “Jesus” ([ésous) is the Gr equivalent of the Heb “Joshua” (QWW, yhdshu'), meaning ‘Jehovah is salvation.” It stands therefore in the LXX and Apoc for “Joshua,” and in Acts 7 45 and He 4 8 likewise represents the OT Joshua; hence in RV is in these passages rendered “Joshua.” In Mt 1 21 the name is commanded by the angel to be given to the son of Mary, “for it is he that shall save his people from their sins” (see below on “Nativity”). It is the personal name of the Lord in the Gospels and the Acts, but generally in the Epistles appears in combination with “Christ’’ or other appellative (alone in Rom 3 26; 4 24; 1 Cor 12 3; 2 Cor 11 4; Phil 2 10; 1 Thess 4 14; He 7 22: 10 19, etc). (2) “Christ” (Christos) is the Gr equivalent of the Heb ‘Messiah’ (T°WA, mashith; cf in the NT, Jn 141; 425, ‘Messiah”), 2. Christ meaning “anointed” (see Messtau). It designates Jesus as the fulfiller of the Messianic hopes of the OT and of the Jewish people. it will be seen below that Jesus Himself made this claim. After the resurrection it became the current title for Jesus in the apostolic church. Most frequently in the Epistles He is called ‘Jesus Christ,’ sometimes “Christ Jesus” (Rom 8 1.2.39; 1 Cor 1 2.30; 415; Eph 11; Phil 11; Coll 4.28 AV; 1 Thess 2 14, etc), often ‘“‘Christ” alone (Rom 116 AV; 5 6.8; 6 48.9; 8 10, etc). In this case “Christ” has acquired the force of a proper name. Very frequently the term is associated with “Lord” (kuérios)—“the [or “‘our’’] Lord Jesus Christ” (Acts 11 17; 15 11 AV; 1631 AV; 20 21; 28 31; Rom 17; 6 1.11; 13 14; 1 Cor 16 28, etc). IL Order of Treatment.—Iin studying, as it is proposed to do in this art., the earthly history of Jesus and His place in the faith of the apostolic church, it will be convenient to pursue the following order: First, as introductory to the whole study, certain questions relating to the sources of our knowledge of Jesus, and to the preparation for, and circum- stances of, His historical appearance, invite care- ful attention (Part I). Next, still as preliminary to the proper narra- tive of the life of Jesus, it is desirable to consider certain problems arising out of the presentation of that life in the Gospels with which modern thought is more specially concerned, as determining the attitude in which the narratives are approached. Such are the problems of the miracles, the Messiah- ship, the sinless character and supernatural claims of Jesus (Part II). The way is then open for treatment in order of the actual events of Christ’s life and ministry, so far as recorded. These fall into many stages, from His nativity and baptism till His death, resurrection and ascension (Part JII). A final division will deal with Jesus as the exalted Lord in the aspects in which He is presented in the teaching of the Epistles and remaining writings of the NT (Part 1V). Part I. InrropucTory I, The Sources.—The principal, and practically the only sources for our knowledge of Jesus Christ are the four Canonical Gospels—distinction being made in these between the first three (Synop- tic) Gospels, and the Gospel of John. Nothing, 1. Jesus either in the few notices of Christ in non-Christian authors, or in the references in the other books of the NT, or in later Christian lit., adds to 1. InGen- the information which the Gospels eral already supply. The so-called apocry- phal Gospels are worthless as authori- ties (see s.v.); the few additional sayings of Christ (cf Acts 20 35) found in outside writings are of doubtful genuineness (cf a collection of these in Westcott’s Intro to the Study of the Gospels, Appendix C; see also Loata). It marks the excess to which skepticism has gone that writers are found in recent years who deny the very existence of Jesus Christ (Kalt- 2. Denial hoff, Das Christus-Problem, and Die of Existence Enistehung des Christenthums; Jensen, of Jesus Das Gilgamesch-Epos, 1; Drews, Die Christusmythe; cf on Kalthoff, Schweit- zer, The Quest of the Historical Jesus, ET, 313 ff; Jensen is reviewed in the writer’s The Resurrection of Jesus, ch ix). The extravagance of such skep- ticism is its sufficient refutation. Of notices outside the Christian circles the fol- lowing may be referred to. (1) Josephus—There is the famous 3. Extra- passage in Jos, Ant, XVIII, ii, 3, Christian commencing, ‘(Now there was about Notices this time, Jesus, a wise man, if it be lawful to call him a man,” etc. It is not unlikely that Jos had some reference to Jesus, but most agree that the passage in question, if not entirely spurious, has been the subject of Chris- tian interpolation (on the lit. and different views, see Schirer, Jewish People in the Time of Christ, Div II, vol II, 143 ff; in support of interpolation, Edersheim on “Josephus,” in Dict. of Christ. Biog.). (2) Tacitus—-The Rom historian, Tacitus, in a well-known passage relating to the persecution of Nero (Ann. xv.44), tells how the Christians, already “a great multitude” (ingens multitudo), derived their name ‘from one Christus, who was executed iu the reign of Tiberius by the procurator of Judaea, Pontius Pilate.” (3) Suetonius also, in his account of Claudius, speaks of the Jews as expelled from Rome for the raising of tumults at the instigation of one ‘‘Chres- tus” (impulsore Chresto), plainly a mistake for “Christus.” The incident is doubtless that referred to in Acts 18 2. The four Gospels, then, with their rich contents, Temain as our primary sources for the knowledge of the earthly life of Jesus. 4. The (1) The Synoptics—It may be taken Gospels for granted as the result of the best criticism that the first three Gospels (Mt, Mk, Lk) all fall well within the apostolic age (cf Harnack, Alichr. Lit., Pref; see GospE.s). The favorite theory at present of the relations of these Gospels is, that Mk is an independent. Gospel, resting on the teaching of Peter; that Mt and Lk have as sources the Gospel of Mk and a collection of discourses, probably attributable to the apostle Matthew (now commonly called Q); and that Lk has a third, well-authenticated source (Lk 1 1-4) peculiar to himself. The present writer is disposed to allow more independence to the evangelists in the embodying of a tradition common to all; in any case, the sources named are of unexceptionable authority, and furnish a strong guaranty for the reliability of the narratives. Thesupreme guaranty of their trustworthiness, however, is found in the narratives themselves; for who in that (or any) age could imagine a figure so unique and perfect as that of Jesus, or invent the incomparable sayings and parables that proceeded from His lips? Much of Christ’s teaching is high as heaven above the minds of men still. 1627 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ (2) The Fourth Gospel.—The Fourth Gospel stands apart from the Synoptics in dealing mainly with another set of incidents (the Jerusalem ministry), and discourses of a more private and intimate kind than those belonging to the Galilean teaching. Its aim, too, is doctrinal—to show that Jesus is “the Son of God,” and its style and mode of conception are very different from those of the Synoptic Gospels. Its contents touch their narratives in only a few points (as in Jn 6 4-21). Where they do, the resemblance is manifest. It is obvious that the reminiscences which the Gospel contains have been long brooded over by the apostle, and that a certain interpretative element blends with his narration of incidents and discourses. This, however, does not warrant us in throwing douht, with so many, on the genuineness of the Gospel, for which the external evidence is exceptionally strong (cf Sanday, The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel; Drummond, Character and Authorship of the Fourth Gospel; and see Jon, GosPEL or). The Gospel is accepted here as a genuine record of the sayings and doings of Jesus which it narrates. Il. The Preparation.—In the Gospels and throughout the NT Jesus appears as the goal of OT revelation, and the point to which 1. Both all providential developments tended. Gentile and He came, Paul says, in “the fulness Jewish of the time’ (Gal 4 4). It has often been shown how, politically, intellec- tually, morally, everything in the Graeco-Roman world was ready for such a universal religion as Jesus brought into it (cf Baur’s Hist of the Church in the First Three Cents., ET, ch i). The prepa- ration in Israel is seen alike in God’s revelations to, and dealings with, the chosen people in the patriarchal, Mosaic, monarchical and prophetic periods, and in the developments of the Jewish mind in the centuries immediately before Christ. As special lines in the OT preparation may be noted the ideas of the Messianic king, a ruler of David’s house, whose reign would be 2. OT Prep- righteous, perpetual, universal (cf Isa aration 7 13—9 7; 32 1.2; Jer 33 15.16; Ps 2 1-10, etc); of a Righteous Sufferer (Ps 22, etc), whose sufferings are in Isa 53 declared to have an expiatory and redeeming character; and of a Messianic kingdom, which, breaking the bounds of nationalism, would extend through the whole earth and embrace all peoples (cf Isa 60; Ps 87; Dni 2 44; 7 27, etc). The kingdom, at the same time, is now conceived of under a more spiritual aspect. Its chief blessings are forgiveness and righteousness. The age succeeding the return from exile wit- nessed a manifold preparation for the advent of Christ. Here may be observed the 3. Post- decentralization of the Jewish religious exilian ideals through the rise of synagogue Preparation worship and the widespread dispersion of the race; the contact with Hellenic culture (as in Philo); but esp. the marked sharpen- ing of Messianic expectations. Some of these were of a crude apocalyptic character (see APOCALYPTIC LITERATURE; EscHATOLOGY oF THE OT); many were political and revolutionary; but some were of a purer and more spiritual kind (cf Lk 2 25.38). To these purer elements Jesus attached Himself in His preaching of the kingdom and of Himself as its Lord. Even in the gentile world, it is told, there was an expectation of a great One who about this time would come from Judaea (Tac. Hist. v.13; Suet. Vespas. 4). I, The Outward Situation.—Of all lands Pal was the most fitted to be the scene of the culminat- ing revelation of God’s grace in the person and work of Jesus Christ, as before it was fitted to be the abode of the pcople chosen to receive and pre- serve the revelations that prepared the way for that final manifestation. At once cen- 1. The tral and secluded—at the junction of Land the three great continents of the Old World, Asia, Africa and Europe—the highway of nations in war and commerce—touching mighty powers on every hand, Egypt, Syria, Assyria, kingdoms of Asia Minor, as formerly more ancient empires, Hittite and Babylonian, now in contact with Greece and Rome, yet singularly inclosed by mountain, desert, Jordan gorge, and Great Sea, from ready entrance of foreign influ- ences, Pal has a place of its own in the history of revelation, which only a Divine wisdom can have given it (cf Stanley, Sinat and Palestine, Part II, ch ii; G. A. Smith, Hist. Geog. of the Holy Land, Book I, chs i, ii; Lange, Life of Christ, I, 246 ff). Its divisions —Pal, in the Rom period, was di- vided into four well-defined provinces or districts— Judaea, with Jerus as its center, in the S., the strong- hold of Jewish conservatism; Samaria, in the middle, peopled from Assyrian times by mixed settlers (2 K 17 24-34), preponderatingly heathen in origin, yet now professing the Jewish religion, claiming Jewish descent (cf Jn 4 12), possessing a copy of the law (Sam Pent), and a temple of their own at Gerizim (the original temple, built by Manasseh, ¢ 409 BC, was destroyed by John Hyrcanus, 109 BC); Galilee —Galilee of the Gentiles’ (Mt 4 15; cf Isa 9 1) —in the N., the chief scene of Christ’s ministry, freer and more cosmopolitan in spirit, through a large infusion of gentile population, and contact with traders, etc, of varied nationalities: these in Western Pal, while on the E. , “beyond Jordan,” was Peraea, divided up into Peraea proper, Batanaea, Gaulonitis, Ituraea, Trachonitis, Decapolis, ete (cf Mi 4 25; 19 1; Lk 31). The feeling of bitterness between Jews and Samaritans was intense (Jn 4 9). The language of the people throughout was ARAMAIC (q.v.), but a knowledge of the Gr tongue was widely diffused, especially in the N., where intercourse with Gr-speaking peoples was habitual (the NT writings arein Gr). Jesus doubtless used the native dialect in His ordinary teaching, but it is highly probable that He also knew Gr, and was acquainted with OT Scriptures in that language (the LXX). In this case He may have sometimes used it in His pireach- ing (cf Roberts, Discussions on the Gospels). The miserable story of the vicissitudes of the Jewish people in the cent. succeeding the great persecution of Antiochus Epiphanes 2. Political and the Maccabean revolt—a story Situation made up of faction, intrigue, wars, murders, massacres, of growing degen- eracy of rulers and nation, of repeated sackings of Jerus and terrible slaughters—till Herod, the Idumaean, misnamed ‘‘the Great,’ ascended the throne by favor of the Romans (87 BC), must be read in the books relating to the period (Ewald, Hist of Israel, V; Milman, Hist of Jews; Schiiver, Hist of the Jewish People in Time of Christ, Div I, Vol I; Stanley, Jewish Church, III, etc). Rome’s power, first invited by Judas Maccabaeus (161 BC), was finally established by Pompey’s capture of Jerus (63 BC). Herod’s way to the throne was tracked by crime and bloodshed, and murder of those most nearly related to him marked every step in his advance. His taste for splendid buildings—palace, temple (Mt 24 1; Jn 2 20), fortresses, cities (Se- baste, Caesarea, etc)—and lavish magnificence of his royal estate and administration, could not con- ceal the hideousness of his crafty, unscrupulous selfishness, his cold-blooded cruelty, his tyrannous oppression of his subjects. ‘Better be Herod’s hog than his son,’”’ was the comment of Augustus, when he heard of the dying king’s unnatural doings. Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1628 _Changes in territory—aAt the time of Christ’s birth, the whole of Pal was united under Herod’s rule, but on Herod’s death, after a long reign of 37 (or, counting from his actual accession, 34) years, his dominions were, in accordance with his will, confirmed by Rome, divided. Judaea and Samaria (a few towns excepted) fell to his son Archelaus (Mt 2 22), with the title of “ethnarch”; Galilee and Peraea were given to Herod Antipas, another son, with the title of “‘tetrarch” (Mt 14 1; Lk 3 1.19; 23 7; Acts 18 1); Herod Philip, a third son, re- ceived Ituraea, Trachonitis, and other parts of the northern trans-Jordanic territory, likewise as ‘“te- trarch” (Lk 3 1; cf Mt 14 3; Mk 6 17). A few years later, the tyranny of Archelaus provoked an appeal of his subjects to Augustus, and Archelaus, summoned to Rome, was banished to Gaul (7 AD). Thereafter Judaea, with Samaria, was governed by a Roman procurator, under the oversight of the prefect of Syria. ? In the religious situation the chief fact of interest is the place occupied and prominent part played y the religious sects—the Pharisees, 3. The Re- the Sadducees, and (though unmen- ligious tioned in the Gospels, these had an Sects important influence on the early history of the church) the Essenes. The rise and characteristics of these sects can here only be alluded to (see special arts.). (1) The scribes.—From the days of Ezra zealous attention had been given to the study of the law, and an order of men had arisen—the “scribes’’— whose special business it was to guard, develop and expound the law. Through their labors, scrupulous observance of the law, and, with it, of the innumer- able regulations intended to preserve the law, and apply it in detail to conduct (the so-called “tradi- tion of the elders,” Mt 15 2 ff), became the ideal of righteousness. Thesects first appear in the Mac- cabean age. The Maccabean conflict reveals the existence of a party known as the ‘‘Assidaeans” (Heb hésidhim), or ‘pious’ ones, opposed to the lax Hellenizing tendencies of the times, and staunch observers of the law. These in the beginning gave brave support to Judas Maccabaeus, and doubtless then embraced the best elements of the nation. (2) The Pharisees—From them, by a process of deterioration too natural in such cases, developed the party of legalists known in the Gospels as the “Pharisees” (‘‘separated”’), on which Christ’s stern- est rebukes fell for their self-righteousness, ostenta- tion, pride and lack of sympathy and_ charity (Mt 6 2ff; 23; Lk 18 9-14). They gloried in an excessive scrupulosity in the observance of the ex- ternals of the law, even in trivialities. To them the multitude that knew not the law were ‘‘accursed” (Jn 7 49). To this party the great body of the scribes and rabbis belonged, and its powerful influ- ence was eagerly sought by contending factions in the state. ; : (3) The Sadducees.—Alongside of the Pharisees were the “‘Sadducees” (probably from ‘‘Zadok’’)— rather a political and aristocratic clique than a religious sect, into whose possession the honors of the high-priesthood and other influential offices hereditarily passed. They are first met with by name under John Hyrcanus (135-106 BC). The Sadducees received only the law of Moses, inter- preted it in a literal, secularistic spirit, rejected the Pharisaic traditions and believed in neither resur- rection, angel nor spirit (Acts 23 8). Usually in rivalry with the Pharisees, they are found combin- ing with these to destroy Jesus (Mt 26 3-5.57). (4) The Essenes.—The third party, the ‘“Essenes,” differed from both (some derive also from the As- sidaeans) in living in fraternities apart from the general community, chiefly in the desert of Engedi, on the N.W. shore of the Dead Sea, though some were found also in villages and towns; in rejecting animal sacrifices, etc, sending only gifts of incense to the temple; in practising celibacy and community of goods; in the wearing of white garments; in certain customs (as greeting the sunrise with prayers) sug- gestive of oriental influence. They forbade slavery, war, oaths, were given to occult studies, had secret doctrines and books, etc. As remarked, they do not appear in the Gospel, but on account of cer- tain resemblances, some have sought to establish a connection between them and John the Baptist and Jesus. In reality, however, nothing could be more opposed than Essenism to the essential ideas and spirit of Christ’s teaching (cf Schirer, as above, Div II, Vol II, 188 ff; Kuenen, Hibbert Lects on National Religions and Universal Religions, 199- 208; Lightfoot, Colossians, 114~79). . IV. The Chronology.—The leading chronological questions connected with the life of Jesus are dis- cussed in detail elsewhere (CHRON oF THE NT; Quirintvs, etc); here it is sufficient to indicate the general scheme of dating adopted in the present art., and some of the grounds on which it is preferred. The chief questions relate to the dates of the birth and baptism of Jesus, the duration of the ministry and the date of the crucifixion. Though challenged by some (Caspari, Bosanquet, Conder, etc, put it as late as 1 BC) the usual date for the death of Herod the Great, 1. Date of March, 4 BC (year of Rome 750), may the Birth be assumed as correct (for grounds of of Jesus this dating, see Schiirer, op. cit., Div I, Vol I, 464-67). The birth of Jesus was before, and apparently not very long before, this event (Mt 2). It may therefore be placed with probability in the latter part of the previous year (5 BC), the ordinary dating of the commencement of the Christian era being thus, as is generally recog- nized, four years too late. There is no certainty as to the month or day of the birth. The Christmas date, December 25, is first met with in the W. in the 4th cent. (the eastern date was January 6), and was then possibly borrowed from a pagan festival. December, in the winter season, seems unlikely, as unsuitable for the pasturing of flocks (Lk 2 8), though this objection is perhaps not decisive (Andrews, Conder). A more probable date is a couple of months earher. The synchronism with Quirinius (Lk 2 2) is considered in connection with the nativity. The earlier datings of 6, 7, or even 8 BC, suggested by Ramsay, Mackinlay and others, on grounds of the assumed Rom census, astronomi- cal phenomena, etc, appear to leave too long an interval before the death of Herod, and conflict with other data, as Lk 3 1 (see below). John is said by Luke to have begun to preach and baptize “in the fifteenth year of Tiberius” (Lk 3 1), and Jesus “was about thirty years 2. Date of of age” (ver 23) when He was bap- Baptism tized by John, and entered on His : ministry. If the 15th year of Tiberius is dated, as seems most likely, from his association with Augustus as colleague in the government, 765 AUC, or 12 AD (Tac. Ann. i8; Suet. on Augustus, 97), and if Jesus may be supposed to have been baptized about 6 months after John commenced his work, these data combine in bring- ing us to the year 780 AUC, or 27 AD, as the year of Our Lord’s baptism, in agreement with our former conclusion as to the date of His birth in 5 BC. To place the birth earlier is to make Jesus 32 or 33 years of age at His baptism—an unwar- rantable extension of the “about.” In accord with this is the statement in Jn 2 20 that the temple had been 46 years in building (it began in 20-19 BC) at the time of Christ’s first Passover; therefore in 1629 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ 780 AUC, or 27 AD (cf Schiirer, op. cit., Div I, Vol I, 410). The determination of the precise duration of Our Lord’s ministry involves more doubtful elements. Setting aside, as too arbitrary, schemes 3. Length which would, with some of the early of Ministry Fathers, compress the whole ministry into little over a single year (Browne, Hort, etc)—a view which involves without authority the rejection of the mention of the Passover in Jn 6 4—there remains the choice between a two years’ and a three years’ ministry. Both have able advocates (Turner in art. ‘Chronology,” and Sanday in art. “Jesus Christ,” in HDB, advocate the two years’ scheme; Farrar, Ramsay, D. Smith, etc, adhere to the three years’ scheme). An important point is the view taken of the un- named “feast” in Jn 6 1. John has already named a Passover—Christ’s first—in 2 13.23; another, which Jesus did not attend, is named in 6 4; the final Passover, at which He was crucified, appears in all the evangelists. If the “feast” of Jn 5 1 (the art. is probably to be omitted) is also, as some think, a Passover, then John has four Passovers, and a three years’ ministry becomes necessary. It is claimed, however, that in this case the ‘‘feast’”’ would almost certainly have been named. It still does not follow, even if a minor feast—say Purim— is intended, that we are shut up to a two years’ ministry. r. Turner certainly goes beyond his evidence in affirming that “while two years must, not more than two years can, be allowed for the interval from Jn 2 13.23 to Jn 11 55.” The two years’ scheme involves, as will be seen on con- sideration of details, a serious overcrowding and arbitrary transposition of incidents, which speak to the need of longer time. We shall assume that the ministry lasted for three years, reserving reasons till the narrative is examined. On the hypothesis now accepted, the crucifixion of Jesus took place at the Passover of 30 AD. On the two years’ scheme it would fall a 4. Date of year earlier. On both sides it is Christ’s agreed that it occurred on the Friday Death of the week of the Passover, but it is disputed whether this Friday was the 14th or the 15th day of the month. The Gospel of John is pleaded for the former date, the Synoptics for the latter. The question will be considered in connection with the time of the Last Supper. Meanwhile it is to be observed that, if the 15th is the correct date, there seems reason to believe that the 15th of Nisan fell on a Friday in the year just named, 783 AUC, or 30 AD. We accept this pro- visionally as the date of the crucifixion. Parr II. Tse Prospiems or THE Lire or Jrsus I. The Miracles.—Everyone is aware that the presence of miracle in the Gospels is a chief ground of the rejection of its history by the 1. The representatives of the ‘‘modern”’ school. “Modern” It is not questioned that it is a super- Attitude natural person whose picture is pre- sented in the Gospels. There is no real difference between the Synoptics and John in this respect. “Even the oldest Gospel,” writes Bousset, ‘is written from the standpoint of faith; already for Mark, Jesus is not only the Messiah of the Jewish people, but the miraculous eternal Son of God, whose glory shone in the world” (Was wissen wir von Jesus? 54, 57). But the same writer, interpreting the “modern” spirit, declares that no account embracing supernatural events can be accepted as historical. ‘The main characteristic of this modern mode of thinking,” he says, “rests upon the determination to try to explain every- thing that takes place in the world by natural causes, or—to express it in another form—it rests on the determined assertion of universal laws to which all phenomena, natural and spiritual, are subject” (What Is Religion? ET, 283). With such au assumption it is clear that the Gospels are condemned before they are read. Not only is Jesus there a supernatural 2. Super- person, but He is presented as super- natural in natural in character, in works, in the Gospels claims (see below); He performs miracles; He has a supernatural birth, and a supernatural resurrection. All this is swept away. It may be allowed that He had remarkable gifts of healing, but these are in the class of “faith- cures” (thus Harnack), and not truly supernatural. When one seeks the justification for this self- confident dogmatism, it is difficult to discover it, except on the ground of a pantheistic or monistic theory of the universe which excludes the personal God of Christianity. If God is the Author and Sus- tainer of the natural system, which He rules for moral ends, it is impossible to see why, for high ends of revelation and redemption, a supernatural econ- omy should not be engrafted on the natural, achiev- ing ends which could not otherwise be attained. This does not of course touch the question of eyi- dence for any particular miracle, which must be judged of from its connection with the person of the worker, and the character of the apostolic witnesses, The well-meant effort to explain all miracles through the action of unknown natural laws—which is what Dr. Sanday calls ‘making both ends meet” (Life of Christ in Recent Research, 302)—breaks down in the presence of such miracles as the instanta- neous cleansing of the leper, restoration of sight to the blind, the raising of the dead, acts which plainly imply an exercise of creative power. In such a life as Christ’s, transcendence. of the ordinary powers of Nature is surely to be looked for. I. The Messiahship.—aA difficulty has been found in the fact that in all the Gospels Jesus knew Him- self to be the Messiah at least from 1. Reserve the time of His baptism, yet did not, of Jesus even to His disciples, unreservedly and Modern announce Himself as such till after Criticism Peter’s great confession at Caesarea Philippi (Mt 16 13 ff). On this seem- ing secrecy the bold hypothesis has been built that Jesus in reality never made the claim to Mes- siahship, and that the passages which imply the contrary in Mk (the original Gospel) are unhis- torical (Wrede; cf on this and other theories, Schweitzer, The Quest of the Historical Jesus, ET; Sanday, The Life of Christ in Recent Research). So extreme an opinion is rejected by most; but modern critics vic with each other in the freedom with which they treat the testimony of the evangel- ists on this subject. Baldensperger, e.g., supposes that, Jesus did not attain full certainty on His Messiahship till near the time of Peter’s confession, and arbitrarily transposes the earlier sections in which the title ‘Son of Man” occurs till after that event (Das Selbsibewusstsein Jesu, 2d ed, 246). Bousset thinks that Jesus adopted the Messianic réle as the only one open to Him, but bore it as a “hurden’’ (cf his Jesus). Schweitzer connects it with apocalyptic ideas of a wildly fantastic char- acter (op. cit., ch xix). There is, however, no need for supposing that Peter’s confession marks the first dawn of this knowledge in the minds of the apostles, Rather was it the exalted expression Growing of a faith already present, which had Revelation long been maturing. The baptism and temptation, with the use of the title “Son of Man,” the tone of authority in His teaching, His miracles, and many special incidents, « 2. A Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1630 show, as clearly as do the discourses in John, that Jesus was from the beginning fully conscious of His vocation, and His reserve in the use of the title sprang, not from any doubt in His own mind as to His right to it, but from His desire to avoid false associations till the true nature of His Messiah- ship should be revealed. The Messiahship was in process of self-revelation throughout to those who had eyes to see it (cf Jn 6 66-71). What it in- volved will be seen later. HI. Kingdom and Apocalypse.—Connected with the Messiahship is the idea of the “Kingdom of God” or “of heaven,” which some in 1. The modern times would interpret in a Kingdom— purely eschatological sense, in the Present or light of Jewish apocalyptic conceptions Future ? (Johannes Weiss, Schweitzer, etc). The kingdom is not a. thing of the present, but wholly a thing of the future, to be introduced by convulsions of Nature and the Parousia of the Son of Man. The language of the Lord’s Prayer, “Thy kingdom come,” is quoted in support of this contention, but the next petition should guard against so violent an inference. “Thy will be done,” Jesus teaches His disciples to pray, ‘‘as in heaven, so on earth” (Mt 6 10). The kingdom is the reign of God in human hearts and lives in this world as well as in the next. It would not be wrong to define it as consisting essentially in the supremacy of God’s will in human hearts and human affairs, and in every department of these affairs. As Jesus describes the kingdom, it has, in the plain meaning of His words, a present heing on earth, though its perfection is in eternity. The parables in Mt 13 and elsewhere exhibit it as founded by the sowing of the word of truth (Sower), as a mingling of good and evil elements (Tares), as growing from small beginnings to large propor- tions (Mustard Seed), as gradually leavening hu- manity (Leaven), as of priceless value (Treasure; Pearl; cf Mt 6 33); as terminating in a judgment (Tares, Dragnet); as perfected in the world to come (Mt 13 43). It was a kingdom spiritual in nature (Lk 17 20.21), universal in range (Mt 8 11; 21 43, etc), developing from a principle of life within (Mk 4 26-29), and issuing in victory over all opposition (Mt 21 44). [t is difficult to pronounce on the extent to which Jesus was acquainted with current apocalyptic beliefs, or allowed these to color the 2. Apoca- imagery of parts of His teachings. lyptic These beliefs certainly did not furnish Beliefs the substance of His teaching, and it may be doubted whether they more than superficially affected even its form. Jewish apocalyptic knew nothing of a death and resurrec- tion of the Messiah and of His return in glory to bring in an everlasting kingdom. What Jesus taught on these subjects sprang from His ,own Messianic consciousness, with the certainty He had of His triumph over death and His exaltation to the right hand of God. It was in OT prophecy, not in late Jewish apocalypse, that His thoughts of the future triumph of His kingdom were grounded, and from the vivid imagery of the prophets He borrowed most of the clothing of these thoughts. Isa 53, e.g., predicts not only the rejection and death of the Servant of Jehovah (vs 3.7-9.12), but the prolongation of His days and His victorious reign (vs 10-12). Dnl, not the Book of En, is the source of the title, ‘Son of Man,” and of the imagery of coming on the clouds of heaven (Dnl 7 13). The ideas of resurrection, etc, have their ground in the OT (see EscHaToLocy oF THE OT). With the extravagant, unspiritual forms into which these conceptions were thrown in the Jewish apoca- lyptic books His teaching had nothing in common. The new apocalyptic school represented by Schweit- zer reduces the history of Jesus to folly, fanaticism and hopeless disillusionment. IV. The Character and Claims.—Where the Gospels present us in Jesus with the image of a flawless character—in the words of the 1. Denial writer to the Hebrews, “holy, guileless, of Christ’s undefiled, separated from sinners” (He Moral Per- 7 26)—modern criticism is driven by fection an inexorable necessity to deprive Jesus of His sinless perfection, and to impute to Him the error, frailty, and moral infirmity that belong to ordinary mortals. In Schweitzer’s por- traiture (cf op. cit.), He is an apocalyptic enthusias- tic, ruled by illusory ideals, deceiving Himself and others as to who He was, and as to the impending end of the world. Those who show a more ad- equate appreciation of Christ’s spiritual greatness are still prevented by their humanitarian estimate of His person and their denial of the supernatural in history from recognizing the possibility of His sinlessness. It may confidently be said that there is hardly a single writer of the modern school who grants Christ’s moral perfection. To do so would be to admit a miracle in humanity, and we have heard that miracle is by the highest rational neces- sity excluded. This, however, is precisely the point on which the modern so-called “historical-critical” mode of presentation most obviously breaks down. The ideal of perfect holiness in the Gospels which has fascinated the conscience of Christendom for 18 cents., and attests itself anew to every candid reader, is not thus lightly to be got rid of, or ex- plained away as the invention of a church gathered out (without the help of the ideal) promiscuously from Jews and Gentiles. It was not the church— least of all such a church—that created Christ, but Christ that created the church. (1) The sinlessness assured —The sinlessness of Jesus is a datum in the Gospels. Over against a sinful world He stands as a Saviour who is Himself without sin. His is the one life in humanity in which is presented a perfect knowledge and unbroken fellowship with the Father, undeviating obedience to His will, unswerving devotion under the severest strain of temptation and suffering to the highest. ideal of goodness. The ethical ideal was never raised to so absolute a height as it is in the teaching of Jesus, and the miracle is that, high as it is in its unsullied purity, the character of Jesus corresponds with it, and realizes it. Word and life for once in history perfectly agrec. Jesus, with the keenest sensitiveness to sin in thought and feeling as in deed, is conscious of no sin in Himself, confesses no sin, disclaims the presence of it, speaks and acts con- tinually on the assumption that He is without it. Those who knew Him best declared Him to be without sin (1 Pet 2 22; 1 Jn 35; cf 2 Cor 5 21). The Gospels must be rent in pieces before He image of a perfect holiness can be effaced from them. (2) What this implies ——How is this phenomenon of a sinless personality in Jesus to be explained? It is itself a miracle, and can only be made credible by a creative miracle in Christ’s origin. It may be argued that a Virgin Birth does not of itself secure sinlessness, but it will hardly be disputed that at least a sinless personality implies miracle in its production. It is precisely because of this that the modern spirit feels bound to reject it. In the Gospels it is not the Virgin Birth by itself which is invoked to explain Christ’s sinlessness, but the supernatural conception by the Holy Spirit (Lk 1 35). It is because of this conception that the birth is a virgin one. No explanation of the super- natural element in Christ’s Person is more rational or credible (see below on “‘Nativity’’). 1631 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ If Jesus from the first was conscious of Himself as without sin, and if, as the converse of this, He knew Himself as standing in an un- 2. Sinless- broken filial fellowship with the Father, nessand He must early have become conscious the Mes- of His special vocation, and learnt to sianic Claim distinguish Himself from others as one called to bless and save them. Here is the true germ of His Messianic consciousness, from which everything subsequently is unfolded. He.stood in a rapport with the Father which opened His spirit to a full, clear revelation of the Father’s will regarding Himself, His mission, the kingdom He came to found, His sufferings as the means of salvation to the world, the glory that awaited Him when His earthly work was done. In the light of this revelation He read the OT Scriptures and saw His course there made plain. When the hour had come He went to John for baptism, and His brief, eventful ministry, which should end in the cross, began. Thisis the reading of events which intro- duces consistency and purpose into the life of Jesus, and it is this we mean to follow in the sketch now to he given. Part III. Course or THE Eartaiy Lire or JESUS The wonderful story of the life of the world’s Redeemer which we are now to endeavor to trace falls naturally into several divisions: 1. Divisions A. From the Nativity to the Bap- of the His- tism and Temptation. tory B. The Early Judaean Ministry. C. The Galilean Ministry and Visits to the Feasts. D. The Last Journey to Jerusalem. E. The Passion Week—Betrayal, Trial, and Cru- cifixion. F. The Resurrection and Ascension. To avoid misconception, it is important to remember, that, rich as are the narratives of the Gospels, materials do not exist for 2. Nota a complete biography or “Life” of Complete Jesus. There is a gap, broken only “Life” by a single incident, from His infancy till His 30th year; there are cycles of events out of myriads left unrecorded (Jn 21 25); there are sayings, parables, longer discourses, con- nected with particular occasions; there are general summaries of periods of activity comprised in a few verses. The evangelists, too, present their materials each from his own standpoint—Matthew from the theocratic, Mark from that of Christ’s practical activity, Luke from the universalistic and human-sympathetic, John from the Divine. In re- producing the history respect must be had to this focusing from distinct points of view. A. FROM THE NATIVITY TO THE BAPTISM AND TEMPTATION I. The Nativity.—OT prophecy expired with the promise on its lips, ‘‘Behold, I send my messenger, and he shall prepare the way before 1. Hidden. me: and the Lord, whom ye seek, will Piety in suddenly come to his temple; and the Judaism messenger of the covenant, whom ye desire, behold, he cometh, saith Je- hovah of hosts” (Mal 3 1). In the years immedi- ately before Christ’s birth the air was tremulous with the sense of impending great events. The fortunes of the Jewish people were at their lowest ebb. Pharisaic formalism, Sadducean unbelief, fanatical Zealotry, Herodian sycophantism, Roman oppression, seerned to have_crushed out. the last sparks of spiritual religion. Yet in numerous quict circles in Judaea, and even in remote Galilee, little godly bands still nourished their souls on the prom- ises, looking for “the consolation of Israel’? and “redemption of Jerusalem” (Lk 2 25.38). _Glimpses of these are vouchsafed in Zacharias and Elisabeth, in Simeon, in Anna, in Joseph and Mary (Lk 1, 2; Mt 1 18 ff). It was in hearts in these circles that the stirrings of the prophetic spirit began to make themselves felt anew, preparing for the Advent (cf Lk 2 27.36). In the last days of Herod—perhaps in the year 748 of Rome, or 6 BC—the aged priest Zacharias, of the course of Abijah (1 Ch 24 10; 2, Birth of cf Schirer, Div II, Vol I, 219 ff), was the Baptist ministering in the temple at the altar (Lk 1) of incense at the hour of evening prayer. Scholars have reckoned, if on somewhat precarious grounds, that the ministry of the order to which Zacharias belonged fell in this year in the month of April or in early October (cf Andrews, Life of Our Lord). Now a wonderful thing happened. Zacharias and his wife Elisabeth, noted for their blameless piety, were up to this time childless. On this evening an angel, appear- ing at the side of the altar of incense, announced to Zacharias that a son should be born to them, in whom should be realized the prediction of Malachi of one ‘coming in the spirit and power of Elijah to prepare the way of the Lord (cf Mal 4 5.6). His name was to be called John. Zacharias hesitated to believe, and was stricken with dumbness till the promise should be fulfilled. It happened as the angel had foretold, and at the circumcision and naming of his son his tongue was again loosed. Zacharias, filled with the Spirit, poured forth his soul in a hymn of praise—the Benedictus (Lk 1 5-25.57-80; cf JoHn THE BaPTIst). Meanwhile yet stranger things were happening in the little village of Nazareth, in Galilee (now en- Nasirah). There resided a young 8. The An- maiden of purest character, named nunciation Mary, betrothed to a carpenter of the and Its Re- village (cf Mt 13 55), called Joseph, sults (Lk 1: who, although in so humble a station, 26-56; Mt was of the lineage of David (cf Isa 11 1:18-25) 1). Mary, most probably, was like- wise. of Davidic descent (Lk 1 32; on the genealogies, see below). The fables relating to the parentage and youth of Mary in the Apoc- ryphal Gospels may safely be discarded. To this maiden, three months before the birth of the Baptist, the same angelic visitant (Gabriel) appeared, hailing her as “highly favored” of God, and announcing to her that, through the power of the Holy Spirit, she should become the mother of the Saviour. The words ‘Blessed art thou among women,” in AV of ver 28 are omitted by RV, though found below (ver 42) in Elisabeth’s salutation. They give, in any case, no support to Mariolatry, stating simply the fact that Mary was more honored than any other woman of the race in being chosen to be the mother of the Lord. (1) The amazing message-—The announcement itself was of the most amazingimport. Mary herself was staggered at the thought that, as a virgin, she should become a mother (ver 34). Still more sur- prising were the statements made as to the Son she was to bear. Conceived of the Holy Spirit (Lk 1 35; Mt 1 18), He would he great, and would be called “the Son of the Most High” (Lk 1 32)— “the Son of God” (ver 35); there would be given to Him the throne of His father David, and His reign would be eternal (vs 32.33; cf Isa 9 6.7); He would be “holy” from the womb (ver 35). His name was to be called Jesus (ver 31; cf Mt 1 21), denoting Him as Saviour. The holiness of Jesus is here put in connection with His miraculous conception, and surely rightly. In no case in the history of mankind has natural generation issued Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1632 in a being who is sinless, not to say superhuman. The fact that Jesus, even in His human nature, was supernaturally begotten—was ‘‘Son of God’’—does not exclude the higher and eternal Sonship according to the Divine nature (Jn 1 18). The incarnation of such a Divine Being as Paul and John depict, itself implies miracle in human origin. On the whole message being declared to her, Mary accepted what was told her in meek humility (Lk 1 38). (2) The visit to Elisabeth—With the announce- ment to herself there was given to Mary an indica- tion of what had befallen her kinswoman Elisabeth, and Mary’s first act, on recovering from her astonish- ment, was to go in haste to the home of Elisabeth in the hill country of Judaea (vs 39ff). Very naturally sbe did not rashly forestall God’s action in speaking to Joseph of what had occurred, but waited in quietness and faith till God should reveal in His own way what He had done. The meeting of the two holy women was the occasion of a new outburst of prophetic inspiration. Elisabeth, moved by the Spirit, greeted Mary in exalted lan- guage as the mother of the Lord (vs 42-45)—a confirmation to Mary of the message she had received; Mary, on her part, broke forth in rhyth- mical utterance, ‘“My soul doth magnify the Lord,” etc (vs 46-56). Her hymn—the sublime Magnificat —is to be compared with Hannah’s (1 § 2 1-11), which furnishes the model of it. Mary abode with Elisabeth about three months, then returned to her own house. (3) Joseph’s perplexity. Here a new trial awaited her. Mary’s condition of motherhood could not long be concealed, and when Joseph first became aware of it, the shock to a man so just (Mt 1 19) would be terrible in its severity. The disappearance of Joseph from the later gospel history suggests that he was a good deal older than his betrothed, and it is possible that, while strict, upright and conscientious, his dis- position was not as strong on the side of sympathy as so delicate a case required. It is going too far to say with Lange, ‘‘He encountered the modest, but unshakably firm Virgin with decided doubt; the first Ebionite’’; but so long as he had no support beyond Mary’s word, his mind was in a state of agonized perplexity. His first thought was to give ary a private “bill of divorcement’”’ to avoid scandal (ver 19). Happily, his doubts were soon set at rest by a Divine intimation, and he hesitated no longer to take Mary to be his wife (ver 24). Luke’s Gospel, which confines itself to the story of Mary, says nothing of this episode; Matthew’s narrative, which bears evidence of having come from Joseph himself, supplies the lack by showing how Joseph came to have the confidence in Mary which enabled him to take her to wife, and become sponsor for her child. The trial, doubtless, while it lasted, was not less severe for Mary than for Joseph—a prelude of that sword which was to “pierce through [her] own soul” (Lk 2 35). There is no reason to believe that Joseph and Mary did not subsequently live in the usual relations of wedlock, and that children were not born to them (ef Mt 18 55.56, etc). Matthew gives no indication of where the events | narrated in his first chapter took place, first men- tioning Nazareth on the occasion of _ 4. The the return of the holy family from Birth at Egypt (2 23). In 2 1 he transports Bethlehem us to Bethlehem as the city of Christ’s (Mt 2:1; birth. It is left to Luke to give an Lk 2:1-7) account of the circumstances which brought Joseph and Mary to Bethle- hem—thus fulfilling prophecy (Mic 5 2; Mt 2 5.6) —at this critical hour, and to record the lowly manner of Christ’s birth there. (1) The census of Quirinius—The emperor Augustus had given orders for a general enrolment throughout the empire (the fact of periodical enrol- ments in the empire is well established by Professor W. M. Ramsay in his Was Christ Born at Bethlehem ?), and this is stated to have been given effect to in Judaea when Quirinius was governor of Syria (Lk 2 1.2). The difficulties connected with the enrolment or census here mentioned are discussed in the art. Quiminius. It is known that Quirinius did con- duct, a census in Judaea in 6 AD (cf Acts 5 37), but the census at Christ’s birth is distinguished from this by Luke as “the first enrolment.” The diffi- culty was largely removed when it was ascertained, as it has been to the satisfaction of most scholars, that Quirinius awas twice governor of Syria—first, after Herod’s death, 4-1 BC, and again in 6-11 AD. The probability is that the census was begun under Varus, the immediate predecessor of Quirinius— or even earlier under Saturninus—but was delayed in its application to Judaea, then under Herod’s jurisdiction, and was completed by Quirinius, with whose name it is officially connected. That the enrolment was made by each one going to his own city (ver 3) is explained by the fact that the census was not made according to the Rom method, but, as befitted a dependent kingdom, in accordance with Jewish usages (cf Ramsay). ‘ (2) Jesus born.—It must be left undecided whether the journey of Mary to Bethlehem with Joseph was required for any purpose of registration, or sprang simply from her unwillingness to be separated from Joseph in so trying a situation. To Bethlehem, in any case, possibly by Divine monition, she came, and there, in the ancestral city of David, in circum- stances the lowliest conceivable, brought forth her marvelous child. In unadorned language—very different from the embellishments of apocryphal story—Luke narrates how, when the travelers arrived, no room was found for them in the “inn’— the ordinary eastern khan or caravanserai, a Square enclosure, with an open court for cattle, and a raised recess round the walls for shelter of visitors— and how, when her babe was born, Mary wrapped Him in swaddling clothes, and laid Him ina manger. The wearied pair having, according to Luke, been crowded out of, and not merely within, the inn, there is every probability that the birth took place, not, as some suppose, in the courtyard of the inn, but, as the oldest tradition asserts (Justin Martyr, Dial. with Trypho, 78), in a cave in the neighbor- hood, used for similar purposes of lodgment and housing of cattle. High authorities look favorably on the “cave of the nativity” still shown, with its inscription, Hic de virgine Maria Jesus Christus natus est, as marking the sacred spot. In such incredibly mean surroundings was “the only begot- ten of the Father” ushered into the world He came to redeem. How true the apostle’s word that He “emptied” Himself (Phil 2 7)! A problem lies in the very circumstances of the entrance into time of such a One, which only the thought of a voluntary humiliation for saving ends can solve. Born, however, though Jesus was, in a low con- dition, the Father did not leave Him totally with- out witness to His Sonship. There 5. The In- were rifts in the clouds through which cidents of thehidden glory streamed. The scenes the Infancy in the narratives of the Infancy exhibit (Lk 2:8-39; a strange commingling of the glorious Mt 2:1-12) and the lowly. (1) The visit of the shepherds.—To shepherds watching their flocks by night in the fields near Bethlehem the first disclosure was made. The season, one would infer, could hardly havebeen winter, though it is stated that there is frequently an interval of dry weather in Judaea between the middle of December and the middle of February, when such 1633 a keeping of flocks would be possible (Andrews). The angel world is not far removed from us, and as angels preannounced the birth of Christ, so, when He actually came into the world (cf He 1 6), angels of God made the night vocal with their songs. First, an angel appearing in the midst of the Divine glory—the “Shekinah”—announced to the sorely alarmed shepherds the birth of a ‘Saviour who was Christ the Lord” at Bethlehem; then a whole chorus of the heavenly host broke in with the refrain, “Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace among men in whom He is well pleased” (lit. ‘men of good pleasure’’)—since, the Christmas hymn of the generations (Lk 2 1~14)._ Theshepherds, guided as to how to recognize the babe (ver 12), went at once, and found it to be even as they had been told. Thence they hastened to spread abroad the tidings— the first believers, the first worshippers, the first preachers (vs 15~20). Mary cherished the sayings in the stillness of her heart. (2) The circumcision and presentation in the temple. —Jewish law required that on the 8th day the male child should be circumcised, and on the same day He received His name (cf. Lk 1 59-63). Jesus, though entirely pure, underwent the rite which de- noted the putting off of fleshly sin (Col 2 11), and became bound, as a true Israelite, to render obedience to every Divine commandment. The name “Jesus” was then given Him (Lk 2 21). On the 40th day came the ceremony of presentation in the temple at Jerus, when Mary had to offer for her purifying (Lev 12; Mary’s was the humbler offering of the poor, ‘‘a pair of turtle-doves, or two young pigeons” [Lev 12 8; Lk 2 24]), and when the first-born son had to be redeemed with 5 shekels of the sanctuary (Nu 18 15.16; about $3.60). The observance was an additional token that Christ—personally sin- less—did not shrink from full identification with our race in the responsibilities of its sinful condition. Ere it was completed, however, the ceremony was lifted to a Diviner level, and a new attestation was given of the dignity of the child of Mary, by the action and inspired utterances of the holy Simeon and the aged ‘prophetess Anna. To Simeon, a righteous and devout man, “looking for the con- solation of Israel,’’ it bad been revealed that he should not die till he had seen the Lord’s Christ, and, led by the Spirit into the temple at the very time when Jesus was being presented, he recognized in Him the One for whom he had waited, and, taking Him in his arms, gave utterance to the beau- tiful words of the Nunc Dimittis—‘Now lettest thou thy servant depart, Lord,” etc (Lk 2 25-32). He told also how this child was set for the falling and rising of many in Israel, and how, through Him, a sword should pierce through Mary’s own soul (vs 34.35). Entering at the same hour, the proph- etess Anna—now in extreme old age (over 100; a constant frequenter of the temple, ver 37)—con- firmed his words, and spoke of Him to all who, like herself, looked “‘for the redemption of Jerus.”’ (3) Visit of the Magi—It seems to have been after the presentation in the temple that the incident took place recorded by Matthew of the visit of the Magi. The Magi, a learned class belonging originally to Chaldaea or Persia (see Mact), had, in course of time, greatly degenerated (cf Simon Magus, Acts 8 9), but those who now came to seek Christ from the distant East were of a nobler order. They appeared in Jerus in- quiring, “Where is He that is born King of the Jews?” and declaring that they had seen His star in the East, and had come to worship Him (Mt 2 2). Observers of the nightly sky, any significant, appearance in the heavens would at once attract their attention. Many (Kepler, Ideler, etc; cf Ramsay, op. cit., 215 ff) are disposed to connect THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ this “‘star’’ with a remarkable conjunction—or series of conjunctions—of planets in 7-6 BC, in which case it is possible that two years may have elapsed (cf the inquiry of Herod and his subsequent action, vs 7.16) from their observation of the sign. On the other hand, the fact of the star reappearing and seeming to stand over a house in Bethlehem (ver 9) rather points to a distinct phenomenon (cf BrTauE- HEM, STaR OF). The inquiry of the Magi at once awakened Herod’s alarm; accordingly, having ascer- tained from the scribes that the Christ should be born at Bethlehem (Mic 5 2), he summoned the Magi, questioned them as to when exactly the star appeared, then sent them to Bethlehem to search out the young child, hypocritically pretending that he also wished to worship Him (Mt 2 7.8). Herod had faith enough to believe the Scriptures, yet was foolish enough to think that he could thwart God’s purpose. Guided by the star, which anew appeared, the wise men came to Bethlehem, offered their gifts, and afterward, warned by God, returned by another road, without reporting to Herod. It is a striking picture—Herod the king, and Christ the King; Christ a power even in His cradle, inspiring terror, attracting homage! The faith of these sages, unre- polled by the lowly surroundings of the child they ad discovered, worshipping, and laying at His feet their gold, frankincense and myrrh, is a splendid anticipation of the victories Christ was yet to win among, the wisest as well as the humblest of our race. Herod, finding himself, as he thought, befooled by the Magi, avenged himself by ordering a massacre of all the male children of two years old, and under, in Bethlehem and its neighborhood (vs 16-19). This slaughter, if not recorded elsewhere (cf, however, Macrobius, quoted by Ramsay, op. cit., 219), is entirely in keeping with the cruelty of Herad’s dis- position. Meanwhile, Joseph and Mary had been withdrawn from the scene of danger (ver 17 con- nects the mourning of the Bethlehem mothers with Rachel’s weeping, Jer 31 15). The safety of Mary and her threatened child was provided for by a Divine warning to retire for a time to Egypt (mark the recurring expres- 6. Flight to sion, “the young child and his mother” Egypt and —the young child taking the lead, vs Return to 11.13.14.20.21), whither, accordingly, Nazareth they were conducted by Joseph (ver (Mt 2:18- 14). The sojourn was not a long one. 15.19-23) Herod’s death brought permission to return, but as Archelaus, Herod’s son (the worst of them), reigned in Judaea in his father’s stead (not king, but “ethnarch’’), Joseph was direeted to withdraw to Galilee; hence it came about that he and Mary, with the babe, found themselves again in Nazareth, where Luke anew takes up the story (2 39), the thread of which had been broken by the incidents in Mt. Matthew sees in the return from Egypt a refulfiling of the ex- periences of Israel (Hos 11 1), and in the settling in Nazareth a connection with the OT prophecies of Christ’s lowly estate (Isa 11 1, néger, ‘branch’; Zec 8 8; 6 12, etc). p The objections to the credibility of the narratives of the Virgin Birth have already partly been adverted ue re ae the SaaS Mary; i HE Virgin. Birra; and ‘the vwriter’s 7. ora volume, The Virgin Birth of Christ.) an jec= (1) Phe Virgin Birth_—The narrativesin ions Mt and Lk are attested by all MSS and 3 VSS genuine Parts of their respective Gos- pels, and as coming to usin theirintegrity. Thenarrative of Lk is generally recognized as resting on an Aram. basis, which, from its diction and the primitive character of its conceptions, belongs to the earliest age. While in Luke's narrative everything is presented from the standpoint of Mary, in Mt it is Joseph who is in the forefront, sug- gesting that the virgin mother is the source of information in the one case, and Joseph himself in the other. The narratives are complementary, not contradictory. That Mk and Jn do not contaiu narratives of the Virgin Birth Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1634 cannot be wondered at, when it is remembered that Mark's Gospel begins of purpose with the Baptism of John, and that the Fourth Gospel aims at setting forth the Divine descent, not the circumstances of the earthly nativity. ‘‘The Word became flesh” (Jn 1 14)—every- thing is already implied in that. Neither can it be objected to that Paul does not in his letters or public preaching base upon so essentially private a fact as the miraculous conception—at a time, too, when Mary probably still lived. With the exception of the narrow- est sect of the Jewish Ebionites and some of the gnostic sects, the Virgin Birth was universally accepted in the early church. . (2) The genealogies (Mt 1 1-17; Lk 3 23-28).—Difi- culty is felt with the genealogies in Mt and Lk (one de- scending, the other ascending), which, while both profess- ing to trace the descent of Jesusfrom David and Abraham (Lk from Adam), yet go entirely apart in the pedigree after David. See on this the art. GENEALOGIES OF JESUS Curtist. A favorite view is that Mt exhibits the legal, Lk the natural descent of Jesus. There is plausibility in the supposition that though, in form, a genealogy of Joseph, Lk’s is really the genealogy of Mary. It was not custom- ary, itis true, to make out pedigrees of females, but the case here was clearly exceptional, and the passing of Jo- seph into the family of his father-in-law Heli would enable the list to be made out in his name. Celsus, in the 2d cent., appears thus to have understood it when he derides the notion that through so lowly a woman as the carpenter's wife, Jesus should trace His lineage up to the first man (Origen, Con. Cel., ii.32; Origen's reply pro- ceeds onthesame assumption. Cf art. on ‘ Genealogies” in Kitto, IT). II. The Years of Silence—the Twelfth Year.— With the exception of one fragment of incident— that of the visit to Jerus and the 1. The Temple in His 12th year—the Canoni- Human De- cal Gospels are silent as to the history velopment of Jesus from the return to Nazareth (Lk 2:40. till His baptism by John. This long 52) period, which the Apocryphal Gospels crowd with silly fables (see APocRYPHAL GosPeEzs), the inspired records leave to be regarded as being what it was—a period of quiet development of mind and body, of outward uneventfulness, of silent garnering of experience in the midst of the Nazareth surroundings. Jesns “grew, and waxed strong, filled with wisdom; and the grace of God was upon him... . advanced in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and men” (Lk 2 40.52). The incarnation was a true acceptance of humanity, with all its sinless limitations of growth and development. Not a hint is offered of that omniscience or omnipotence which theology has not infrequently imputed to Jesus even as child and boy. His schooling was probably that of the ordi- nary village child (He could read, Lk 4 17 ff, and write, Jn 8 6-8); He wrought at the carpenter's bench (cf Mk 6 3; Justin Martyr, following tra- dition, speaks of Him as making “ploughs and yokes,” Dial., 88). His gentleness and grace of character endeared Him to all who knew Him (Lk 2 52). No stain of sin clouded His vision of Divine things. His after-history shows that His mind was nourished on the Scriptures; nor, as He pondered psalms and prophets, could His soul remain un- visited by presentiments, growing to convictions, that He was the One in whom their predictions were destined to be realized. Every year, as was the custom of the Jews, Joseph and Mary went, with their friends and neighbors, in companies, to Jerus to 2. Jesusin the Passover. When Jesus was 12 the Temple years old, it would seem that, for (Lk 2:41- the first time, He was permitted to 50) accompany them. It would be to Him a strange and thrilling experience. Everything He saw—the hallowed sites, the motley crowd, the service of the temple, the very shocks His moral] consciousness would receive from contact with abounding scandals—would intensify His feel- ing of His own unique relation to the Father. Every relationship was for the time suspended and merged to His thought in this higher one. It was His Father’s city whose streets He trod; His Father’s house He visited for prayer; His Father’s ordi- nance the crowds were assembled to observe; His Father's name, too, they were dishonoring by their formalism and hypocrisy. It is this exalted mood of the boy Jesus which explains the scene that follows—the only one rescned from oblivion in this interval of growth and preparation. When the time came for the busy caravan to return to Nazareth, Jesus, acting, doubtless, from highest impulse, ‘“tarried behind” (ver 43). In the large company His absence was not at first missed, but when, at the evening halting-place, it became known that He was not with them, His mother and Joseph returned in deep distress to Jerus. Three days elapsed before they found Him in the place where naturally they should have looked first—His Father’s house. There, in one of the halls or cham- bers where the rabbis were wont to teach, they discovered Him seated “in the midst,” at the feet of the men of learning, hearing them discourse, asking questions, as pupils were permitted to do, and giving answers which awakened astonishment by their penetration and wisdom (vs 46.47). Those who heard Him may well have thought that before them was one of the great rabbis of the future! Mary, much surprised, asked in remonstrance, “Son, why hast thon thus dealt with us?” evoking from Jesus the memorable reply, ‘(How is it that ye sought me? knew ye not that I must be in my Father’s honse?”’ or ‘‘about my Father’s business?” AV (vs 48.49). Here was the revelation of a self- consciousness that Mary might have been prepared for in Jesus, but perhaps, in the common inter- course of life, was tending to lose sight of. The lesson was not unneeded. Yet, once it had been given, Jesus went back with Joseph and Mary to Nazareth, and ‘‘was subject unto them’; and Mary did not forget the teaching of the incident (ver 51). Wf. The Forerunner and the Baptism—~Time passed, and when Jesns was nearing His 30th year, Judaea was agitated by the message 1. The of a stern preacher of righteousness Preaching who had appeared in the wilderness of Jo by the Jordan, proclaiming the immi- (Mt 3:1-— nent approach of the kingdom of 12; Mk 1: heaven, summoning to repentance, 1-8; Lk 3: and baptizing those who confessed 1-18) their sins. Tiberius had succeeded Augustus on the imperial throne; Judaea, with Samaria, was now a Rom province, under the procurator Pontius Pilate; the rest of Pal was divided between the tetrarchs Herod (Galilee) and Philip (the eastern parts). The Baptist thus appeared at the time when the land had lost the last vestige of self-government, was politically divided, and was in great ecclesiastical confusion. Nurtured in the deserts (Lk 1 80), John’s very appearance was a protest against the luxury and self-seeking of the age. He had been a Nazarite from his birth; he fed on the simplest products of nature—locusts and wild honey; his coarse garb of camel’s hair and leathern girdle was a return to the dress of Elijah (2 K 1 8), in whose spirit and power he appeared (Lk 1 17) (see Jonn THE Baptist). The coming Christ.—John’s preaching of the king- dom was unlike that of any of the revolutionaries of his age. It was a kingdom which could be entcred only through moral preparation. It availed nothing for the Jew simply that he was a son of Abraham. The Messiah was at hand. He (John) was but a voice in the wilderness sent to prepare the way for that Greater than himself. The work of the Christ would be one of judgment and of mercy. He would lay the axe at the root of the tree—would winnow the chaff from the wheat—yet would baptize with 1635 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit (Mt 3 10-12; Lk 815-17). Those who professed acceptance of his message, with its condition of repentance, John baptized with water at the Jordan or in its neighborhood (cf Mt 3 6; Jn 1 28; 3 23). _ John’s startling words made a profound impres- sion. All classes from every part of the land, including Pharisees and Sadducees 2. Jesus Is (Mt 3 7), came to his baptism. John Baptized was not deceived. He saw how little (Mt 3:13- change of heart underlay it all. The 17; Mk 1: Regenerator had not yet come. But 9-11; Lk one day there appeared before him 3:21.22) One whom he intuitively recognized ; as different from all the rest—as, indeed, the Christ whose coming it was his to herald. John, up to this time, does not seem to have personally known Jesus (cf Jn 1 31). He must, however, have heard of Him; he had, besides, received a sign by which the Messiah should be recognized (Jn 1 33); and now, when Jesus pre- sented Himself, Divinely pure in aspect, asking baptism at his hands, the conviction was instantane- ously flashed on his mind, that this was He. But how should he, a sinful man, baptize this Holy One? “TI have need to be baptized of thee, and comest thou to me?” (Mt 3 14). The question is one which forces itself upon ourselves—How should Jesus seek or receive a “baptism of re- pentance”’? Jesus Himself puts it orf the ground of meetness. “Suffer it now: for thus it becometh us to fulfil all righteousness” (ver 15). The Head was content to enter by the same gateway as the members to His specific vocation in the service of the kingdom. In submitting to the baptism, He formally identified Himself with the expectation of the kingdom and with its ethical demands; sepa- rated Himself from the evil of His nation, doubtless with confession of its sins; and. devoted Himself to His life-task in bringing in the Messianic salva- tion. The significance of the rite as marking His consecration to, and entrance upon, His Messianic career, is seen in what follows. As He ascended from the water, while still ‘‘praying” (Lk 3 21), the heavens were opened, the Spirit of God descended like a dove upon Him, and a voice from heaven declared: ‘‘This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased” (Mt 3 16.17). It is needless to inquire whether anyone besides John (cf Jn 1 33) and Jesus (Mt 3 16; Mk 1 10) received this vision or heard these words; it was for them, not for others, the vision was primarily intended. To Christ’s consecration of Himself to His calling, there was now added the spiritual equipment necessary for the doing of His work. He went forward with the seal of the Father’s acknowledgment upon Him. IV. The Temptation.—On the narrative of the baptism in the first three Gospels there follows at once the account of the temptation of 1. Tempta- Jesus in the wilderness. The psy- tion Follows chological naturalness of the incident Baptism is generally acknowledged. The bap- (Mt 4:1-_ tism of Jesus was a crisis in His experi- 11; Mk 1: ence. He had been plenished by the 13.14; Lk Spirit for His work; the heavens had 4:1-13) been opened to Him, and His mind was agitated by new thoughts and emotions; He was conscious of the possession of new powers. There was need for a period of retire- ment, of still reflection, of coming to a complete understanding with Himself as to the meaning of the task to which He stood committed, the methods He should employ, the attitude He should take up toward popular hopes and expectations. He would wish to be alone. The Spirit of God led Him (Mt 41; Mk 112; Lk 41) whither His own spirit also impelled. It is with a touch of similar motive -end (Mt 4 2ff; Lk 4 2 ff). that Buddhist legend makes Buddha to be tempted by the evil spirit Mara after he has attained en- lightenment. The scene of the temptation was the wilderness of Judaea. Jesus was there 40 days, during which, it is told, He neither ate nor drank 2. Nature (cf the fasts of Moses and Elijah, of the Ex 24 18; 34 28; Dt 9 18; 1 K 19 Temptation 8). Mk adds, “He was with the wild beasts” (ver 13). The period was probably one of intense self-concentration. During the whole of it He endured temptations of Satan (Mk 1 13); but the special assaults came at the We assume here a real tempter and real temptations—the question of diabolic agency being considered after. This, however, does not settle the form of the temptations. The struggle was probably an inward one. It can hardly be supposed that Jesus was literally trans- ported by the devil to a pinnacle of the temple, then to a high mountain, then, presumably, back again to the wilderness. The narrative must have come from Jesus Himself, and embodies an ideal or para- bolic element. ‘‘The history of the temptation,” Lange says, ‘Jesus afterwards communicated to His disciples in the form of a real narrative, clothed in symbolical language” (Comm. on Mt, 83, ET). The stages of the temptation were three—each in its own way a trial of the spirit of obedience. (1) The first temptation was to distrust. Jesus, after His long fast, was an hungered. He had become conscious also of super- 8. Stages natural powers. The point on which of the the temptation laid hold was His Temptation sense of hunger—the most over- mastering of appetites. “If thou art the Son of God, command that these stones become bread.”’. The design was to excite distrustful and rebellious thoughts, and lead Jesus to use the powers entrusted to Him in an unlawful way, for private and selfish ends. The temptation was promptly met by a quotation from Scripture: “Man shall not live by bread alone,” etc (Mt 4 4; Lk 4 4; cf Dt 8 3). If Jesus was in this position, it was His Father who had brought Him there for urposes of trial. Man has a higher life than can Be sustained on bread; a life, found in depending on God’s word, and obcying it at whatever cost. (2) The second temptation (in Lk the third) was to presumption. Jesus is borne in spirit (cf Ezk 40 1.2) to a pinnacle of the temple. From this dizzy elevation He is invited to cast. Himself down, relying on the Divine pee “He shall give His angels charge over thee,” etc (cf Ps 91 11.12). In this way an easy demonstration of His Messiah- ship would be given to the crowds below. The temptation was to overstep those bounds of humility and dependence which were imposed on Him as Son; to play with signs and wonders in His work as Messiah. But again the tempter is foiled by the word: ‘Thou shalt not make trial of [try experi- ments with, propose tests, put to the proof] the Lord thy God” (Mt 4 7; Lk 4 12; cf Dt 6 16). (3) The third temptation (Lk’s second) was to worldly sovereignty, gained by some small concession to Satan. From some lofty elevation—no place on a geographical map—the kingdoms of the world and the glory of them are flashed before Christ’s mind, and all are offered to Him on condition of one little act of homage to the tempter. It was the tempta- tion to choose the easier path by some slight pander- ing to falsehood, and Jesus definitely repelled it by the saying: ‘‘Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve’ (Mt 4 10; Lk 4 8). Jesus had chosen His path. The Father's way of the cross would be adhered to. Typical character—The stages of the tempta- Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1636 tion typify the whole round of Satanic assault on man through body, mind, and spirit (Lk 4 13; cf 1 Jn 2 16), and the whole round of Messianic temptation. Jesus was constantly being tempted (a) to spare Himself; (6) to gratify the Jewish sign- seekers; (c) to gain power by sacrifice of the right. In principle the victory was gained over all at the commencement. His way was henceforth clear. B. THE EARLY JUDAEAN MINISTRY I. The Testimonies of the Baptist—While the Synoptics pass immediately from the temptation of Jesus to the ministry in Galilee after 1. The Synoptics 412; Mk 114.15; Lk 4 14), the and John Fourth Gospel furnishes the account, full of interest, of the earlier ministry of Jesus in Judaea while the Baptist. was still at liberty. The Baptist had announced Christ’s coming; had baptized Him when He appeared; it was now his privilege to testify to Him as having 2. Threefold come, and to introduce to Jesus His Witness of first disciples. the Baptist John’s work had assumed propor- (Jn 1:19- tions which made it impossible for the 37) ecclesiastical authorities any longer to ignore it (cf Lk 3 15). A deputation consisting of priests and Levites was accordingly sent to John, where he was baptizing at Bethany beyond Jordan, to put to him categori- a) First cal questions about his mission. Who Testimony was he? And by what authority did —Jesus and he baptize? Was he the Christ? or Popular Elijah? or the expected prophet? (cf 6 Messianic 14; 7 4; Mt 16 14). To these ques- Expectation tions John gave distinct and straight- (vs 19-28) forwardreplhes. He was not the Christ, not Elijah, not the prophet. His an- swers grow briefer every time, ‘I am not the Christ’’; “T am not’; “No.” Who was he then? The answer was emphatic. He was but a “voice” (cf Isa 40 3)—a preparer of the way of the Lord. In their midst already stood One—not necessarily in the crowd at that moment—with whose greatness his was not to be compared (vs 26.27). John utter- ly effaces himself before Christ. The day after the interview with the Jerus depu- ties, John saw Jesus coming to him—probably fresh from the temptation—and bore a b) Second second and wonderful testimony to His Testimony Messiahship. Identifying Jesus with —Christ the subject of his former testimonies, and the Sin and stating the ground of his knowl- of the edge in the sign God had given him World (vs (vs 30-84), he said, ‘‘Behold, the Lamb 29-34) of God, that taketh away the sin of the world” (ver 29). The words are rich in suggestion regarding the character of Jesus, and the nature, universality and efficacy of His work (cf 1 Jn 35). The “Lamb” may point specifically to the description of the vicariously Suffering Servant of Jeh in Isa 53 11. The third testimony was borne “again on the morrow,” when John was standing with two of his disciples (one Andrew, ver 40, the c) Third other doubtless the evangelist himself). Testimony Pointing to Jesus, the Baptist repeated —Christ his former words, “Behold, the Lamb and the of God.” While the words are the Duty of the same, the design was different. In the Disciple first “behold” the idea is the recogni- (vs 35-37) tion of Christ; in the second there is a call to duty—a hint to follow Jesus. On this hint the disciples immediately acted (ver 37). Itis next to be seen how this earliest ‘follow- ing” of Jesus grew. the imprisonment of the Baptist (Mt - Il. The First Disciples——John's narrative shows that Jesus gathered His disciples, less by a series of distinct calls, than by a process of 1. Spiritual spiritual accretion. Men were led to Accretion Him, then accepted by Him. This (Jn 1: process of selection left Jesus_at the 37-61) close of the second day with five real and true followers. The history con- futes the idea that it was first toward the close of His ministry that Jesus became known to His dis- ciples as the Messiah. In all the Gospels it was as the Christ that the Baptist introduced Jesus; it was as the Christ that the first disciples accepted and confessed Him (vs 41.45.49). The first of the group were Andrew and John— the unnamed disciple of ver 40. These followed Jesus in consequence of their Master’s a) Andrew testimony. It was, however, the few and John— hours’ converse they had with Jesus Discipleship in His own abode that actually decided as the Fruit them. To Christ’s question, “What of Spiritual seek ye?’’ their answer was practically Converse ‘Thyself.’ ‘The mention of the time (vs 87-40) —the 10th hour, i.e. 10 AM—is one of the small traits that mark St. John. He is here looking back on the date of his own spirit- ual birth” (Westcott). : John and Andrew had no sooner found Christ for themselves (‘‘We have found the Messiah,” ver 41) ‘than they hastened to tell others of b) Simon their discovery. Andrew at once Peter— sought out: Simon, his brother, and Discipleship brought him to Jesus; so, a ae a Result of sought Nathanael (ver 45). Christ’s Personal unerring eye read at once the quality Testimony of the man whom Andrew introduced (vs 41.42) to Him. “Thou art Simon the son of John: thou shalt be called Cephas’— “Rock” or “Stone” (ver 42). Mt 16 18, therefore, is not the original bestowal of this name, but the con- firmation of it. The name is the equivalent of “Peter’’ (Péiros), and was given to Simon, not with any official connotation, but because of the strength and clearness of his convictions. His general stead- fastness is not disproved by His one unhappy failure. (Was it thus the apostle acquired the name ‘‘Peter’’?) The fourth disciple, Philip, was called by Jesus Himself, when about to depart for Galilee (ver 43). Friendship may have had its influence c) Philip— on Philip (like the foregoing, he also the Result was from Bethsaida of Galilee, ver 44), of Scriptural but that which chiefly decided him was Evidence the correspondence of what he found (vs 43.44) in Jesus with the prophetic testimonies (ver 45). Philip sought Nathanael (of Cana of Galilee, 21 2)—the same probably as Bartholomew the Apostle —and told him he had found Him of d) Nathan- whom Moses in the law and the proph- ael—Disci- ets had written (ver 45). Nathanael pleship an doubted, on the ground that the Mes- Effect of siah was not likely to have His origin Heart- in an obscure place like Nazareth (ver Searching 46; cf_7 52). Philip’s wise answer Power was, “Come and see”; and when Na- (vs 45-51) thanael came, the Lord met him with a ae. word which speedily rid him of his hesitations. First, Jesus attested His seeker’s sin- cerity (‘“‘Behold, an Israelite indeed,” etc, ver 47); then, on Nathanael expressing surprise, revealed to him His knowledge of a recent secret act of medita- tion or devotion (“when thou wast under the fig tree,” etc, ver 48). The sign was sufficient to con- vince Nathanael that he was in the presence of a superhuman, nay a Divine, Being, therefore, the Christ—‘‘Son of God . . . . King of Israel’”’ (ver 49). Jesus met his faith with further self-disclosure. Na- 1637 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ thanael had believed on comparatively slight evi- dence; he would see see things: heavens opened, and the angels of God ascending and descending upon the Son of Man (ver 51). The allusion is to Jacob’s vision (Gen 28 10-22)—a Scripture which had possibly been the theme of Philip’s meditation in his privacy. Jesus puts Himself in place of that mystic ladder as the medium of reopened communi- cation between heaven and earth. The name ‘Son of Man"’—a favorite designation of Jesus for Himself—appears here for the first time in the Gospels. It is disputed whether it was a 9. “Son of Current. Messlanic title (see Son or Man), Paes but at jieast it had this force on the lipsof Man’ and Jesus Himself, denoting Hlm as the pos- “Son of sessor of a true humanity, and as standing God” in a representative relation to mankind unl- versally. It is probably borrowed from Dnl 7 13and appearsin the Book of En (see Apocatyptic Lirerators). The higher title, ‘‘Son of God,” given to Jesus by Nathanael, could not, of course, as yet carry with it the transcendental associations of John's Prologue (1 1.14.18), but it evidently conveyed an idea of superhuman dignity and unique relation to God, snch as the better class of minds would seem to have sean to the Messiah (cf Jn § 18; 10 33ff; Mt HWE. The First Events-—-An interval of a few weeks is occupied by a visit of Jesus to Cana of Gali- lee (Jn 2 1 ff) and a brief sojourn in Capernaum (ver 12); after which Jesus returned to Jerus to the Passover as the most appropriate place for His public manifestation of Himself as Messiah (vs 13 ff). The notes of time in Jn suggest that the Passover (beginning of April, 27 AD) took place about three months after the baptism by John (cf 1 43; 2 1.12). Prior to His public manifestation, a more private unfolding of Christ’s glory was granted to the disci- ples at the marriage feast of Cana of 1. The First Galilee (cf ver 11). The marriage was Miracle doubtless that of some relative of the (Jn 2:1-11) family, and the presence of Jesus at the feast, with His mother, brethren and disciples (as Joseph no more appears, it‘may be con- cluded that he was dead), is significant as showing that His religion is not one of antagonism to natural relations. The marriage festivities lasted seven days, and toward the close the wine provided for the guests gave out. Mary interposed with an indirect suggestion that Jesus might supply the want. Christ’s reply, lit. “Woman, what is that to thee and to me?” (ver 4), is not intended to convey the least tinge of reproof (cf Westcott, in Joc.), but inti- mates to Mary that His actions were henceforth to be guided by a rule other than hers (cf Lk 2 51). This, however, as Mary saw (ver 5), did not pre- clude an answer to her desire. Six waterpots of stone stood near, and Jesus ordered these to be filled with water (the quantity was large; about 50 gal- lons); then when the water was drawn off it was found changed into a nobler element—a wine purer and better than could have been obtained from any natural vintage. Theruler of the feast, in ignorance of its origin, expressed surprise at its quality (ver 10). The miracle wassymbolical—a “‘sign’”’ (ver 11)—and may be contrasted with the first miracle of Moses— turning the water into blood (Ex 7-20). It points to the contrast between the old dispensation and the new, and to the work of Christ as a transforming, enriching and glorifying of the natural, through Divine grace and power. After a brief stay at Capernaum (ver 12), Jesus went up to Jerus to keep the Passover. There it was His design formally to manifest Himself. Other “sions’’ He wrought at the feast, leading many to believe on Him—not, however, with a deep or enduring faith (vs 23-25)—but the special act by which He signalized His appearance was His public cleansing of the temple from the irreligious trafficking with which it had come to be associated. A like incident is related by the Synoptics at the close of Christ’s ministry (Mt 21 12.13; Mk 11 15-18; Lk 19 45.46), and it is a 2. The question whether the act was actually First repeated, or whether the other evan- Passover, gelists, who do not narrate the events and Cleans- of the early ministry, simply record it ing of the out of its chronological order. In any Temple case, the act was a fitting inaugura- (vs 13-25) tion of the Lord’s work. A regular market was held in the outer court of the temple. Here the animals needed for sacrifice could be purchased, foreign money exchanged, and the doves, which were the offerings of the poor, be obtained. It was a busy, tumultuous, noisy and unholy scene, and the “‘zeal” of Jesus burned within Him—had doubtless often done so before—as He witnessed it. Arming Himself with a scourge of cords, less as a weapon of offence, than as a symbol of authority, He descended with resistless energy upon the wrangling throng, drove out the dealers and the cattle, overthrew the tables of the money- changers, and commanded the doves to be taken away. Let them not profane His Father’s house (Jn 2 14-16). Noone seems to have opposed. All felt that a prophet was among them, and could not resist the overpowering authority with which He spake and acted. By and by, when their courage revived, they asked Him for a “sign” in evidence of His right todo such things. Jesus gave them no sign such as they demanded, but uttered an enig- matic word, and left them to reflect on it, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up”’ (ver 19). The authenticity of the saying is sufficiently vouched for by the perverted use made of it at Christ's trial (Mt 26 61 ||). It is a word based on the foresight which Christ had that the conflict now commencing was to end in His rejection and death. “The true way to destroy the Temple, in the eyes of Jesus, was to slay the Messiah. .... If it is in the person of the Messiah that the Temple is laid in ruins, it is in His person it shall be raised again”’ (Godet). The disciples, after the resurrection, saw the meaning of the word (Jn 2 22). As a sequel to these stirring events Jesus had a nocturnal visitor in the person of Nicodemus—a Pharisee, a ruler of the Jews, a “‘teach- 3. The Visit er of Israel” (ver 10), apparently no of Nicode- longer young (ver 4). His coming by mus (Jn 3: night argues, besides some fear of man, 1-12) a constitutional timidity of disposition (cf 19 39); but the interesting thing is that he did come, showing that he had been really impressed by Christ’s words and works. One rec- ognizes in him a man of candor and uprightness of spirit, yet without adequate apprehensions of Christ Himself, and of the nature of Christ’s kingdom. Jesus he was prepared to acknowledge as a Divinely * commissioned teacher—one whose mission was ac- credited by miracle (ver 2). He was interested in the kingdom, but, as a morally living man, had no doubt of his fitness to enter into it. Jesus had but to teach and he would understand. (1) The new birth—Jesus in His reply laid His finger at once on the defective point in His visitor’s relation to Himself and to His kingdom: ‘Except one be born anew, he cannot see the kingdom of God” (ver 3); “Except one be born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God”’ (ver 5). Nicodemus was staggered at this demand for a spiritual new birth. Thereis reason to beheve that proselytes were baptized on being received into the Jewish church, and their baptism was called a “new birth.’ Nicodemus would therefore be familiar with the expression, but could not see that it had any applicability to him. Jesus teaches him, on the other hand, that he also needs a new birth, Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1638 and this, not through water only, but through the Spirit. The change was mysterious, yet plainly manifest in its effects (vs 7.8). If Nicodemus did not understand these “earthly things” — the evidence of which lay all around him—how should he under- stand “heavenly things,” the things pertaining to salvation? (2) ‘Heavenly things.’’—These “heavenly things” Jesus now proceeds to unfold to Nicodemus: ‘‘As Moses lifted up the serpent,” ete (ver 14). The “lifting up” is a prophecy of the cross (cf 12 32-34). The brazen serpent is the symbol of sin conquered and destroyed by the death of Christ. What follows in 3 16-21 is probably the evangelist’s expansion of this theme—God’s love the source of salvation (ver 16), God’s purpose not the world’s condemna- tion, but its salvation (vs 17.18) the self-judgment of sin (vs 19 ff). : Retiring from Jerus, Jesus commenced a ministry in Judaea (ver 22). It lasted apparently about 6 months. The earlier Gospels pass over 4. Jesus it. This is accounted for by the fact and John that the ministry in Judaea was still (Jn 3:22- preparatory. Jesus had publicly as- 36) serted His Messianic authority. A little space is now allowed to test the result. Meanwhile Jesus descends again to the work of pro- phetic preparation. His ministry at this stage is hardly distinguishable from John’s. He summons to the baptism of repentance. His disciples, not Himself, administer the rite (3 23; 4 2); hence the sort of rivalry that sprang up between His baptism and that of the forerunner (3 22-26). John was baptizing at the time at Aenon, on the western side of the Jordan; Jesus somewhere in the neighbor- hood. Soon the greater teacher began to eclipse theless. ‘All men came to Him” (ver 26). John’s reply showed how pure his mind was from the nar- row, grudging spirit which characterized his follow- ers. To him it was no grievance, but the fulfilment of his joy, that men should be flocking to Jesus. He was not the Bridegroom, but the friend of the Bride- groom. They themselves had heard him testify, “T am not the Christ.’ It lay in the nature of things that Jesus must increase; he must decrease (vs 27-30). Explanatory words follow (vs 31-36). IV. Journey to Galilee—the Woman of Samaria. —Toward the close of this Judaean ministry the Baptist appears to have been cast into 1. With- rison for his faithfulness in reproving drawal to Herod Antipas for taking his brother Galilee Philip’s wife (cf Jn 3 24; Mt 14 3- 5 ||). It seems most natural to connect the departure to Galilee in Jn 4 3 with that narrated in Mt 3 13 |, though some think the imprisonment of the Baptist did not take place till later. The motive which Jn gives was the hostility of the “Pharisees, but it was the imprisonment of the Baptist which led Jesus to commence, at the time He did, an independent ministry. The direct road to Galilee lay through Samaria; hence the mem- orable encounter with the woman at that place. Jesus, being wearied, paused to rest Himself at Jacob’s well, near a town called Sychar, now ’ Askar. It was about the sixth hour—or 6 2. The o’clock in the evening. The time of Living year is determined by ver 35 to be Water “four months” before harvest, i.e. December (there isno reason fornot tak- ing this literally). It suits the evening hour that the woman of Samaria came out to draw water. (Some, on a different reckoning, take the hour to be noon.) Jesus opened the conversation by asking from the woman a draught from her pitcher. The prover- bial hatred between Jews and Samaritans filled the woman with surprise that Jesus should thus address Himself to her. Still greater was her surprise when, as the conversation proceeded, Jesus announced Himself as the giver of a water of which, if a man drank, he should never thirst again (vs 13.14). Only gradually did His meaning penetrate her mind, ‘‘Sir, give me this water,” etc (ver 15). The request of Jesus that she would call her husband led to the discovery that Jesus knew all the secrets of her life. She was before a prophet (ver 19). As in the case of Nathanael, the heart-searching power of Christ’s word convinced her of His Divine claim. | The conversation next turned upon the right place of worship. The Samaritans had a temple of their own on Mount Gerizim; the Jews, on 3. The the other hand, held to the exclusive True validity of the temple at Jerus. Which Worship was right? Jesus in His reply, while pronouncing for the Jews as the cus- todians of God’s salvation (ver 22), makes it plain that distinction of places is no longer a matter of any practical importance. A change was immi- nent which would substitute a universal religion for one of special times and places (ver 20). He enunciates the great principle of the new dispensa- tion that God is a Spirit, and they who worship Him must do so in spirit and in truth. Finally, when she spoke of the Messiah, Jesus made Himself defi- nitely known to her as the Christ. To this poor Samaritan woman, with her receptive heart, He unveils Himself more plainly than He had done to priests and rulers (ver 26). The woman went home and became an evangelist to her people, with notable results (vs 28.39). Jesus abode with them two days and con- 4, Work firmed the impression made by her tes- and Its timony (vs 40-42). Meanwhile, He Reward impressed on His disciples the need of i earnest sowing and reaping in the serv- ice of the Kingdom, assuring them of unfailing re- ward for both sower and reaper (vs 35-38). He Himself was their Great Example (ver 34). : Cc. THE GALILEAN MINISTRY AND VISITS 'fO THE FEASTS Galilee was divided into upper Galilee and lower Galilee. It has already been remarked that upper Galilee was inhabited by a mixed pop- 1. The ulation—hence called “Galilee of the Scene Gentiles” (Mt 4 15). The highroads of commerce ran through it. It was “the way of the sea” (AV)—a scene of constant traffic. The people were rude, ignorant, and super- stitious, and were densely crowded together in towns and villages. About 160 BC there were only a few Jews in the midst of a large heathen popula- tion; but by the time of Christ the Jewish element had greatly increased. The busiest portion of this busy district was round the Sea of Galilee, at the N.E. corner of which stood Capernaum—wealthy and cosmopolitan. In Nazareth, indeed, Jesus met with a disappointing reception (Lk 4 16-30; Mt 13 54-57; cf Jn 4 43-45); yet in Galilee generally He found a freer spirit and greater receptiveness than among the stricter traditionalists of Judaea. It is assumed _here that Jesus returned to Galilee in December, 27 AD, and that His ministry there lasted till late in 29 AD (see Chronology” above). 2. The On the two years’ scheme of the public Time ministry, the Passover of Jn 6 4 has to be taken as the second in Christ’s ministry— therefore as occurring at an interval of only 3 or 4 months after the return. This seems impossible in view of the crowding of events it involves in so short a time—opening incidents, stay in Capernaum (Mt 4 13), three circuits in ‘all Galilee" (Mt 4 23-25 [{; Lk § 1-4: Mt 9 35-38; Mk 6 6), lesser journeys and excursions (Sermon on Mount: Gadara); and the dislocations it necessitates, e.g. the plucking of ears of corn (about Pass- over time) must be placed after the feeding of the 5,000, | etc. It is simpler to adhere to the three years’ scheme. A division of the Galilean ministry may then fitly be made into two periods—one preceding, the other suc- 1639 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ ceeding the Mission of the Twelve in Mt 10 ||. One reason for this division is that after the Mission of the Twelve the order of events is the same in the first three evangelists till the final departure from Galilee. First Period—From the Beginning of the Ministry in Galilee tll the Mission of the Twelve I. Opening Incidents—From sympathetic Sa- maria (Jn 4 39), Jesus had journeyed to unsym- pathetic Galilee, and first to Cana, 1. Healing where His first miracle had been of Noble- wrought. The reports of His miracles man’s Son in Judaea had come before Him (ver (Jn4:43-64) 45), and it was mainly His reputation as a miracle-worker which led a noble- man—a courtier or officer at Herod’s court—to seek Him at Cana on behalf of his son, who was near to death. Jesus rebuked the sign-seeking spirit (ver 48), but, on the fervent appeal being repeated, He bade the nobleman go his way: his son lived. The man’s prayer had been, ‘“Come down”; but he had faith to receive the word of Jesus (ver 50), and on his way home received tidings of his son’s recovery. The nobleman, with his whole household, was won for Jesus (ver 53). This is noted as the second of Christ’s Galilean miracles (ver 54). A very different reception awaited Him at Naza- reth, “His own country,’ to which He next came. We can scarcely take the incident recorded 2. The in Lk 4 16-80 to be the same as that Visit to in Mt 13 54-58, though Matthew’s Nazareth habit of grouping makes this not im- (Mt 4:13; possible. ‘The Sabbath had come, and Lk 4:16-30) on His entering the synagogue, as was His wont, the repute He had won led to His being asked to read. The Scripture He se- lected (or which came in the order of the day) was Isa 61 1ff (the fact that Jesus was able to read from the synagogue-roll is interesting as bearing on His knowledge of Heb), and from this He proceeded to amaze His hearers by declaring that this Scripture was now fulfilled in their ears (ver 21). The ‘“‘words of grace” he uttered are not given, but it can be understood that, following the prophet’s guidance, He would hold Himself forth as the predicted ‘“Serv- ant of Jehovah,” sent to bring salvation to the poor, the bound, the broken-hearted, and for this purpose endowed with the fulness of the Spirit. The idea of the passage in Isa is that of the year of jubilee, when debts were canceled, inheritances re- stored, and slaves set free, and Jesus told them He had come to inaugurate that “acceptable year of the Lord.” At first He was listened to with ad- miration, then, as the magnitude of the claims He was making became apparent to His audience, a very different spirit tock possession of them. ‘Who was this that spoke thus?’ ‘Was it not Joseph’s son? (ver 22). They were disappointed, too, that Jesus showed no disposition to gratify them by working before them any of the miracles of which they had heard so much (ver 23). Jesus saw the gathering storm, but met it resolutely. He told His hearers He had not expected any better reception, and in reply to their reproach that He had wrought mira- cles elsewhere, but had wrought none among them, quoted examples of prophets who had done the same thing (Elijah, Blisha, vs 24-28). This com- pleted the exasperation of the Nazarenes, who, springing forward, dragged Him to the brow of the hill on which their city was built, and would have thrown Him down, had something in the aspect of Jesus not restrained them. With one of those looks we read of occasionally in the Gospels, He seems to have overawed His townsmen, and, passing in safety through their midst, left the place (vs 28-30). ; After leaving Nazareth Jesus made His way to Capernaum (probably Tell Hum), which thereafter seems to have been His headquarters. He “dwelt” there (Mt 4 13). It is called in Mt 91, “his own city.” Before teaching in Caper- 8. Callof naum itself, however, He appears to the Four have opened His ministry by evangcliz- Disciples ing along the shores of the Sea of Gali- (Mt 4:17- lee (Mt 4 18; Mk 1 16; Lk 6 1), and 22; Mk 1: there, at Bethsaida (on topographical 16-22; Lk questions, see special quay took 6:1-11) His first step in gathering His chosen disciples more closely around Him. Hitherto, though attached to His person and cause, the pairs of fisher brothers, Simon and Andrew, James and John—these last the “sons of Zebedee” —had not been in constant attendance upon Him. Since the return from Jerus, they had gone back to their ordinary avocations. The four were “part- ners’ (Lk 5 10). They had “hired servants” (Mk 1 20); therefore were moderately well off. The time had now come when they were to leave “all,” and follow Jesus entirely. Luke alone records the striking miracle which led to the call. Jesus had been teaching the multitude from a boat borrowed from Simon, and a) The now at the close He bade Simon put Draught of out into the deep, and let down his Fishes (Lk nets. Peter told Jesus they had toiled 5:1-9) all night in vain, but he would obey His word. The result was an immense draught of fishes, so that the nets were breaking, and the other company had to be called upon for help. Both boats were filled and in danger of sink- ing. Peter’s cry in so wonderful a presence was, ‘Depart from me; for I am’a sinful man, O Lord.” The miracle gave Jesus opportunity for the word He wished to speak. It is here that Mt and Mk take up the story. The boats had b) “Fishers been brought to shore when, first to of Men” Simon and Andrew, afterward to James and John (engaged in ‘‘mending their nets,” Mt 4 21; Mk 1 19), the call was given: “Come ye after me, and I will make you fishers of men.” At once all was left—boats, nets, friends —and they followed Him. ‘Their experience taught them to have large expectations from Christ. Jesus is now found in Capernaum. Aun: early Sabbath—perhaps the first of His stated residence in the city—was marked by notable 4. AtCa- events. pernaum The Sabbath found Jesus as usual (Mt 4:13; in the synagogue—now as teacher. Lk 4:31) The manner of His teaching is spe- cially noticed: ‘He taught them as having authority, and not as the scribes’ (Mk 1 22). The scribes gave forth nothing of their own. They but repeated the dicta of the great a) Christ’s authorities of the past. It was a sur- Teaching _ prise to the people to find in Jesus One (Mk 1:22. whose wisdom, like waters from a clear 27; Lk 4: fountain, came fresh and_ sparkling 32) from Hisownlips. The authority also with which Jesus spoke commanded attention. He sought support in the opinion of no others, but gave forth His statements with firmness, decision, dignity and emphasis. While Jesus was teaching an extraordinary inci- dent occurred. A man in the assembly, described as possessed by “an unclean spirit” b) The (Mk 1 28; Lk 4 33), broke forth in Demoniac cries, addressing Jesus by name (“‘Jesus, in the thou Nazarene’), speaking of Him as Synagogue “the Holy One of God,” and asking (Mk 1:23- “What have we to do with thee? Art 27; Lk 4: thou come to destroy us?” The dis- 33-37) eased consciousness of the sufferer bore a truer testimony to Christ’s dignity, holiness and power than most of those present could Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1640 have given, and instinctively, but truly, construed His coming as meaning destruction to the empire of the demons. At Christ’s word, after a terrible paroxysm, from which, however, the man escaped unhurt (Lk 4 35), the demon was cast out. More than ever the people were “amazed” at the word which had such power (Mk 1 27). Demon-possession—its reality.—'This is the place to say a word on this terrible form of malady—demon- possession—met with so often in the Gospels. Was it a@ reality? or a hallucination? Did Jesus believe in it? Itis difficult. to read the Gospels, and not answer the last question in the affirmative. Was Jesus, then, mistaken? This also it is hard to believe. If there is one subject on which Jesus might be expected to have clear_vision—on which we might trust His insight—it was His relation to the spuitual world with which He stood in so close rapport. as He likely then to be mis- taken when He spoke so earnestly, so profoundly, so fre- quently, of its hidden forces of evil? There is in itself no improbability—rather analogy suggests the highest probability—of realms of spiritual existence outside our sensible ken. That evil should enter this spiritual world, and that human life should he deeply implicated with that evil—that its forces should have a mind and will organiz- ing and directing them—are not beliefs to be dismissed with scorn. The presence of such beliefs in the time of Christ is commonly attributed to Bab, Pers or other foreign influences. It may be questioned, however, whether the main cause was not something far more real— an actual and permitted ‘‘hour and the power of darkness’ (Lk 22 53) in the kingdom of evil, discovering itself in manifestations in the bodies and souls of men, that could be traced only to @ supernatural cause (see Demontrac Posszssion). (The present writer discusses the subject in an art. in the Sunday School Times for June 4, 1910. It would be Puen even to say that the instance in the Gospels have no modern parallels. See a striking aper in Good Words, edited by Dr. Norman MacLeod, ‘or 1867, on “The English Demoniac.”) It should be noted that all diseases are not, as is sometimes affirmed, traced to demonic influence. The distinction between other diseases and demonic possession is clearly maln- tained (cf Mt 4 24; 10 1; 11 5,etc). Insanity, epilepsy, blindness, dumbness, etc, were frequent accompaniments of possession, but they are not identifled with it. Jesus, on leaving the synagogue, entered the house of Peter. In Mk it is called ‘‘the house of Simon and Andrew” (1 29). Peter c) Peter’s was married (cf 1 Cor 9 5), and ap- Wife’s parently his mother-in-law and brother Mother lived with him in Capernaum. It was (Mt 8:14. an anxious time in the household, for 15; Mk 1: the mother-in-law lay “sick of a fever” 29-31; Lk —“‘a great fever,’’ as Luke the physi- 4:38.39) cian calls it. Taking her by the hand, Jesus rebuked the fever, which in- stantaneously left her. The miracle, indeed, was a double one, for not only was the fever stayed, but strength was at once restored. ‘She rose up and ministered unto them” (Lk 4 39). The day’s labors were not yet done; were, in- deed, scarce begun. The news of what had taken place quickly spread, and soon the d) The extraordinary spectacle was presented Eventful of ‘the whole city’ gathered at the door Evening of the dwelling, bringing their sick of (Mt 8:16; every kind to be healed. Demoniacs Mk 1:32- were there, crying and being rebuked, 34; Lk 4: but multitudes of others as well. The 40.41) Lord’s compassion was unbounded. He rejected none. He labored un- weariedly till every one was healed. His sympathy was individual: ‘‘He laid his hands on every one of them” (Lk 4 40). Il, From First Galilean Circuit till Choice of the Apostles.—The chronological order in this sec- tion is to be sought in Mk and Lk; 1. The First Mt groups for didactic purposes. Circuit (Mk The morning after that eventful 1:35-45; Sabbath evening in Capernaum, Jesus Lk 4:42- took steps for a systematic visitation 44; cf Mt of the towns and villages of Galilee. 4:23-25) The task He set before Himsclf was prepared for by early, prolonged, soli- tary prayer (Mk 1 35; many instances show that Christ’s life was steeped in prayer). His disciples followed Him, and reported that the_multitudes sought Him, Jesus intimated to them Hisintention of passing to the next towns, and forthwith com- menced a tour of preaching and heal- a) Its Scope ing “throughout all Galilee.” Even if the expression ‘‘all Galilee” is used with some latitude, it indicates a work of very extensive compass. It was a work likewise methodically con- ducted (cf Mk 6 6: “went round about the vil- lages,”’ lit. “in a circle”). Galilee at this time was extraordinarily populous (ef Jos, BJ, III, iti, 2), and the time occupied by the circuit must have been considerable. Mt’s condensed picture (4 23-25) shows that Christ’s activity during this period was incredibly great. He stirred the province to its depths. His preaching and miracles drew enor- mous crowds after Him. This tide of popularity afterward turned, but much of the seed sown may have produced fruit at a later day. The one incident recorded which seems to have belonged to this tour was a sufficiently typical one. While Jesus was in a certain city b) Cure of a man “full of leprosy” (Lk 6 12) the Leper came and threw himself down before (Mt 8:2-4; Him, seeking to be healed. The man Mk 1:40— did not even ask Jesus to heal bim, 45; Lk 5: but expressed his faith, ‘If thou wilt, 12-16) thou canst make me clean.” The man’s apparent want of importunity was the very essence of his importunity. Jesus, ‘moved by his earnestness, touched him, and the man was made whole on the spot. The leper was enjoined to keep silence—Jesus did not wish to pass for a mere miracle-worker—and bade the man show himself to the priests and offer the appointed sacri- fices (note Christ’s respect for the legal institu- tions). The leper failed to keep Christ’s charge, and published his cure abroad, no doubt much to his own spiritual detriment, and also to the hin- drance of Christ’s work (Mk 1 45). His circuit. ended, Jesus returned to Capernaum (Mk 2 1; lit. “after days’). Here again His fame at once drew multitudes to see 2. Caper- and hear Him. Among them were naum now persons of more unfriendly spirit. Incidents Pharisees and doctors, learning of the new rabbi, had come out of ‘every village of Galilee and Judaea and Jerusalem” (Lk 5 17), to hear and judge of Him for themselves. The chief incidents of this visit are the two now to be noted. In a chamber crowded till there was no standing room, even round the door, Jesus wrought the cure upon the paralytic man. The scene a) Cure of was a dramatic one. From Christ’s the Para- words “son,” lit. ‘child’ (Mk 2 5), lytic (Mt 9: we infer that the paralytic was young, 2-8; Mk but his disablement seems to have been 2:1-12; Lk complete. It was no easy matter, 6:17-26) with the doorways blocked, to get the man brought to Jesus, but his four bearers (ver 3) were not easily daunted. They climbed the flat roof, and, removing part of the covering above where Jesus was, let down the man into the midst. Jesus, pleased with the inventive- ness and perseverance of their faith, responded to their wish. But, first, that the spiritual and tem- poral might be set in their right relations, and the attitude of His hearers be tested, He spoke the higher words: ‘‘Son, thy sins are forgiven’? (ver 5). At once the temper of the scribes was revealed. Here was manifest evasion. Anyone could say, “Thy sins are forgiven.’’ Worse, it was blas- phemy, for ‘‘who can forgive sins but one, even God?’ (ver 7). Unconsciously they were conceding to Christ the Divine dignity Heclaimed. Jesus per- 1641 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ ceives at once the thoughts of the cavilers, and proceeds to expose their malice. Accepting their own test, He proves His right to say, “Thy sing are forgiven,” by now saying to the palsied man, “Take up thy bed and walk” (vs 9.11). At once the man arose, took his bed, and went forth whole. The multitude were “amazed” and “glorified God” (ver 12). The call of Matthew apparently took place shortly after the cure of the paralytic man. The feast was possibly later (cf the con- b) Call and nection with the appeal of Jairus, Feast of Mt 9 18), but the cal and the feast Matthew are best taken together, as they are (Mt 9:9- im all the three narratives. 13; Mk 2: (1) The call—Mattbew is called 13-17; Lk “Levi” by Luke, and ‘Levi, the son of §:27-32) Alphaeus’” by Mark. By occupation he was a “publican” (Lk 6 27), collector of custom-dues in Capernaum, an impor- tant center of traffic. There is no reason to suppose that Matthew was not a man of thorough upright- ness, though naturally the class to which he belonged was held in great odium by the Jews. Passing the place of toll on His way to or from the lake-side, Jesus:called Matthew to follow Him. The publican must by this time haveseen and heard much of Jesus, and could not but keenly feel His grace in calling one whom men despised. Without an instant’s delay, he left all, and followed Jesus. From publican, Matthew became apostle, then evangelist. (2) The feast.—Then, or after, in the joy of his heart, Matthew made a feast for Jesus. To this feast be invited many of his own class—‘‘publicans and sinners” (Mt 9 10). Scribes and Pharisees were loud in their remonstrances to the disciples at what seemed to them an outrage on all propriety. Narrow hearts cannot understand the breadth of grace. Christ’s reply was conclusive: ‘They that are whole have no need of a physician, but they that are sick,” etc (Mk 2 17, etc). (8) Fasting and joy.—Another line of objection was encountered from disciples of the Baptist. They, like the Pharisees, ‘fasted oft”? (Mt 9 14), and they took exception to the unconstrained way in which Jesus and His disciples entered into social life. Jesus defends His disciples by adopting a metaphor of John’s own (Jn 3 29), and speaking of Himself as the heavenly bridegroom (Mk 2 19). Joy was natural while the bridegroom was with them; then, with a sad forecast of the end, He alludes to days of mourning when the bridegroom should be taken away (ver 20). A deeper answer follows. The spirit of His gospel is a free, spon- taneous, sonal, spirit, and cannot be confined within the old forms. To attempt to confine His religion within the outworn forms of Judaism would be like putting a patch of undressed cloth on an old garment, or pouring new wine into old wine- skins. The garment would be rent; the wine- skins would burst (vs 21.22 ||). The new spirit must make forms of its own. At this point is probably to be introduced the visit to Jerus to attend “a feast,’”’ or, according to another reading, “the feast’? of the 3. The Un- Jews, recorded in Jn 6. The feast named may, if the article ig admitted, have Jerusalem been the Passover (April), though in Feast that case one would expect it to be (jn 68) named; it may have been Purim (March), only this is not a feast Jesus might be thought eager to attend; it may even have been Pentecost (June). In this last case it would succeed the Sabbath controversies to be mentioned later. Fortunately, the determination of the actual feast has little bearing on the teaching of the chapter. ‘Bethesda (‘house of mercy”) was the name given to a pool, fed by an intermittent spring, possessing healing properties, which was situated a) The by the sheep-gate (not “market,” AV), Healing at i.e. nearthetemple, onthe E. Porches Bethesda were erected to accommodate the (vs 1-16) invalids who desired to make trial of the waters (the mention of the angel, ver 4, with part of ver 3, is a later gloss, and is justly omitted in RV). On one of these porches lay an impotent man. His infirmity was of long standing—38 years. Hopedeferred was making his heart sick, for he had no friend, when the waters were troubled, to put him into the pool. Others invariably got down before him. Jesus took pity on this man. He asked him if he would be made whole; then by a word of power healed him. The cure was instantaneous (vs 8.9). It was the Sab- bath day, and as the man, at Christ’s command, took up his bed to go, he was challenged as doing that which was unlawful. The healed man, how- ever, rightly perceived that He who was able to work so great a cure had authority to say what should and should not be done on the Sabbath. Meeting the man after in the temple, Jesus bade him “sin no more”’—a hint, perhaps, that his previous infirmity was a result of sinful conduct (ver 14). Jesus Himself was now challenged by the authori- ties for breaking the Sabbath. Their strait, arti- ficial rules would not permit even of b) Son and acts of mercy on the Sabbath. This Father (vs_ led, on the part of Jesus, to a momen- 17-29) tous assertion of His Divine dignity. He first justified Himself by the example of His Father, who works continually in the upholding and government of the universe (ver 17)—the Sabbath is a rest from earthly labors, for Divine, heavenly labor (Westcott)—then, when this increased the offence by its suggestion of “equality” with the Father, so that His life was threatened (ver 18), He spoke yet more explicitly of His unique relationship to the Father, and of the Divine prerogatives 1t conferred upon Him. The Jews were right: if Jesus were not a Divine Person, the claims He made would be blasphemous. Not only was He admitted to intimacy with the Divine counsel (vs 20.21; ef Mt 11 27), but to Him, He averred, was committed the Divine power of giving hfe (vs 21.26), of judgment (vs 22.27), of resurrection—spiritual resurrection now (vs 24.25), resurrection at the last day (vs 28.29). It was the Father's will that the Son should be honored even as Himself (ver 23). These stupendous claims are not made without adequate attestation. Jesus cites a: threefold witness: (1) the witness of the Bap- c) The tist, whose testimony they had been Threefold _ willing for a time to receive (vs 33.35); Witness (2) the witness of the Father, who by (vs 30-47) Christ’s works supported His witness to Himself (vs 36-38); (3) the witness of the Scriptures, for these, if read with spiritual discernment, would have led to Him (vs 39.45-47). Moses, whom they trusted, would condemn them. Their rejection of Jesus was due, not to want of light, but to the state of the heart: “I know you, that ye have not the love of God in yourselves” (ver 42); ‘“How can ye believe,” ete (ver 44). Shortly after His return to Galilee, if the order of events has been rightly apprehended, Jesus became involved in new disputes with 4. Sabbath the Pharisees about Sabbath-keeping, Contro- Possibly we hear in these the echoes versies of the charges brought against Him at the feast in Judaea. Christ’s conduct, and the principles involved in His replies, throw valuable light on the Sabbath institution. Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1642 The first dispute was occasioned by the action of the disciples in plucking ears of grain and rubbing them in their hands as they passed a) Plucking through the grainfields on a Sabbath of the Ears (the note of time “second-first,’’ in of Grain Lk 6 1 AV, is omitted in RV. In (Mt 12:1- any case the ripened grain points to 8; Mk 2: a time shortly after the Passover). 23-28; Lk The law permitted this liberty (Dt 6: 1-6) 23 25), but Pharisaic rigor construed it into an offence to do the act on the Sabbath (for specimens of the minute, trivial and vexations rules by which the Pharisees converted the Sabbath into a day of wretched constraint, see Farrar’s Life of Christ, Edersheim’s Jesus the Mes- siah, and similar works). Jesus, in defending His disciples, first quotes OT precedents (David and the showbread, an act done apparently on the Sabbath, 1 S 216; the priests’ service on the Sabbath—“One greater than the temple” was there, Mt 12 6), in illustration of the truth that necessity overrides positive enactment; next, falls back on the broad principle of the design of the Sabbath as made for man—for his highest physical, mental, moral and spiritual well-being: ‘The sabbath was made for man,” ete (Mk 2 27). The claims of mercy are paramount. The end is not to be sacrificed to the means. The Son of Man, see asserts lordship over the Sabbath (ver 28 |\). The second collision took place on “another sabbath” (Lk 6 6) in the synagogue. There was present a man with a withered hand. b) The Man The Pharisees themselves, on this with the occasion, eager to entrap Jesus, seem Withered to have provoked the conflict by a Hand (Mt question, ‘Is it lawful to heal on the 12:10-14; sabbathday?”’ (Mt 12 10). Jesus met Mk 3:1-6; them by an appeal to their own prac- Lk 6:6-11) tice in permitting the rescue of a sheep that had fallen into a pit on the Sabbath day (vs 11.12), then, bidding the man stand forth, retorted the question on themselves, ‘Is it lawful on the sabbath day to do good, or to do harm? to save a life, or to kill?” (Mk 3 4)—an allusion to their murderous intents. On no reply being made, looking on them with holy indignation, Jesus ordered the man to stretch forth his hand, and it was at once perfectly restored. The effect was only to inflame to ‘‘madness” (Lk 6 11) the minds of His adversaries, and Pharisees and Herodians (the court-party of Herod) took counsel to destroy Him (Mk 3 6 |). Jesus, leaving this scene of unprofitable conflict, quietly withdrew with His disciples to the shore, and there continued His work of teach- c) With- ing and healing. People from all the drawal to neighboring districts flocked to His the Sea ministry. He taught them from a (Mt 12:15- little boat (Mk 3 9), and healed their 21; Mk 3: sick. Mt sees in this a fulfilment of 7-9) the oracle which is to be found in Isa 42 1-4, The work of Jesus was growing on His hands, and friends and enemies were rapidly taking sides. The time accordingly had come for select- 5. The ing and attaching to His person a defi- Choosing nite number of followers—not simply of the disciples—who might be prepared to Twelve carry on His work after His departure. (Mt 10: This He did in the choice of twelve 1-4; Mk 3: apostles. The choice was made in 13-19; Lk early morning, on the Mount of Beati- 6:12-16; tudes, after a night spent wholly in Acts 1:13) prayer (Lk 6 12). “Apostle” means “one sent.” On the special function of the apostle it is sufficient to say here that those thus set apart were chosen for the special end of being Christ’s witnesses and accredited ambassadors to the world, a) The able from personal knowledge to bear Apostolic testimony to what Christ had been, Function said and done—to the facts of His life, death and resurrection (cf Acts 1 22. 23; 2 22-32; 3 15; 10 39; 1 Cor 16 3-15, etc); but, further, as instructed by Him, and endowed with His Spirit (cf Lk 24 49; Jn 14 16.17.26, etc), of being the depositaries of His truth, sharers of His authority (cf Mt 10 1; Mk 3 15), messengers of His gospel (cf 2 Cor 6 18-21), and His instruments in laying broad and strong the foundations of His church (cf Eph 2 20; 3 5). So responsible a calling was never, before or after, given to mortal men. Four lists of the apostles are given—in Mt, Mk, Lk, and Acts (1 13, omitting Judas). The names are given alike in all, except that b) The “Judas, the son for brother] of James” Lists (Lk 6 16; Acts 1 13) is called by Mt “Lebbaeus,” and by Mk ‘‘Thaddaeus.” The latter names are cognate in meaning, and all denote the same person. ‘‘Bartholomew” (son of Tolmai) is probably the Nathanael of Jn 1 47 (cf 21 2). The epithet ‘‘Cananaean” (Mt 10 4; Mk 3 18) marks “Simon” as then or previously a mem- ber of the party of the Zealots (Lk 6 15). In all the lists Peter, through his gifts of leadership, stands first; Judas Iscariot, the betrayer, stands last. There is a tendency to arrangement in pairs: Peter and Andrew; James and John; Philip and Bartholo- mew; Thomas and Matthew; lastly, James, the son of Alphaeus, Judas, son or brother of James, Simon the Zealot and Judas Iscariot. The list contains two pairs of brothers (three, if “brother” be read with Judas), and at least one pair of friends (Philip and Nathanael). All the apostles were men from the humbler ranks, yet not illiterate, and mostly comfortably circum- stanced. All were Galileans, except c) The Men the betrayer, whose name “Iscariot” i.e. ‘man of Kerioth,” marks him as a Judaean. Of some of the apostles we know a good deal; of others very little; yet we are warranted in speaking of them all, Judas excepted, as men of honest minds, and sincere piety. The band held within it a number of men of strongly contrasted types of character. Allusion need only be made to the impetnous Peter, the contemplative John, the matter-of-fact Philip, the cautious Thomas, the zealous Simon, the conservative Matthew, the ad- ministrative Judas. The last-named—Iscariot— is the dark problem of the apostolate. We have express testimony that Jesns knew him from the beginning (Jn 6 64). YetHechosehim. Thechar- acter of Judas, when Jesus received him, was doubt- less undeveloped. He could not himself suspect the dark possibilities that slept in it. His association with the apostles, in itself considered, was for his good. His peculiar gift was, for the time, of service. In choosing him, Jesus must be viewed as acting for, and under the direction of, the Father (Jn 5 19; 17 12). See special arts. on the several apostles. HE. From the Sermon on the Mount till the Par- ables of the Kingdom—a Second Circuit—The choice of the apostles inaugurates a 1. The new period of Christ’s activity. ltsfirst Sermon on most precious fruit was the delivery to the Mount the apostles and the multitudes who _ thronged Him as He came down from the mountain (Lk 6 17) of that great manifesto of His kingdom popularly known as the Sermon on the Mount. The hill is identified by Stanley (Sinai and Pal, 368) and others with that known as ‘‘the Horns of Hattin,’ where “the level place” at the top, from which Christ would come down from one 1643 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ —_H_ >TO of the higher horns, exactly suits the conditions of the narrative. The sick being healed, Jesus seated Himself a little higher up, His disciples near Him, aud addressed the assembly (cf Mt 7 28.29). The season of the year is shown by the mention of the ‘Tilies” to be the summer. Its scope—His words were weighty. His aim was at the outset to set forth in terms that were un- mistakable the principles, aims and dispositions of His kingdom; to expound its laws; to exhibit its righteousness, both positively, and in contrast with Pharisaie formalism and hypoerisy. Only the lead- ing ideas can he indicated here (see BraTrTupEs; Sermon on Mount; Etutcs or Jesus), Matthew, as is his wont, groups material part of which is found in other conneetions in Lk, but it is well to study the whole in the well-ordered form in which it ap- pears in the First Gospel. In marked contrast with the lawgiving of Sinai, Christ’s first words are those of blessing. Passing at once to the dispositions of the heart, a) The He shows on what inner conditions the Blessings _ blessings of the kingdom depend. His (Mt 5:1- _ beatitudes (poverty of spirit, mourning, 6; Lk 6 meekness, hunger and thirst after 20-26) righteousness, etc) reverse all the world’s standards of judgment on such matters. In the possession of these graces consists true godliness of eharacter; through them the heirs of the kingdom beeome the salt of the earth, the light of the world. The obligation rests on them to let their light shine (cf Mk 4 21-23; Lk 8 16; 11 33). Jesus defines His relation to the old law—not a Destroyer, but a Fulfiller—and proceeds to exhibit the nature of the true righteousness b) True in eontrast to Pharisaic literality and Righteous- formalism. Through adherence to the ness—the latter they killed the spirit of the law. Old and the With an absolute authority—“But I New Law say unto you”—Jesus leads every- (Mt 6:17— thing back from the outward letter to 48; Lk 6: the state of the heart. Illustrations 27-36) are taken from murder, adultery, swearing, retaliation, hatred of ene- mies, and a spiritual expansion is given to every precept. The sinful thought or desire holds in it the essence of transgression. The world’s stand- ards are again reversed in the demands for non- resistanee to injuries, love of enemies and requital of good for evil. i Pursuing the contrast between the true right- eousness and that of the scribes and Pharisees, Jesus next draws attention to motive c) Religion in religion. The Pharisees erred not and Hy- simply in having regard only to the pocrisy— letter of the Law, but in acting in True and morals and religion from a false motive. False Mo- He had furnished the antidote to their tive (Mt 6: literalism; He now assails their osten- 1-18; cf Lk tation and hypocrisy. Illustrations 11: 1-8) are taken from almsgiving, prayer and fasting, and in connection with prayer the Lord’s Prayer 1s given as a model (Lk intro- duces this in another context, 11 1-4). The true motive in religious acts is to please God; the same motive should guide us in the choice of what is to be our supreme good. d) The True Earthly treasure is not to be put above Good and heavenly. The kingdom of God and Cure for His righteousness are to be first in our Care (Mt 6: desires. The eye is to besingle. The 19-34; cf true cure for worldly anxiety is then Lk 11: found in trust of the heavenly Father. 34-36; 12: His children are more to God than 22-34) fowls and flowers, for whom His care in Nature is so conspicuously manifest. Seeking first the kingdom they have a pledge—no higher conecivable—that all else they need will be granted along with it (this seetion on trust, again, Lk places differently, 12 22-34). Jesus finally proeeeds to.speak of the relation of the disciple to the evil of the world. That evil has been considered in its hostile attitude e) Relation to the diseiple (Mt 5 38 ff); the ques- to the tion is now as to the disciple’s free rela- World’s tions toward it. Jesus ineuleates the Evil—the duties of the disciple’s bearing himself Conclusion wisely toward evil—with charity, with ‘ (Mt 7:1- eaution, with prayer, in the spirit: of 29; Lk 6: ever doing as one would be done by— 87-49; cf and of being on his guard against it. 11:9-13) The temptation is great to follow the worldly crowd, to be misled by false teachers, to put profession for praetice. Against these perils the disciple is energetically warned. True religion will ever be known by its fruits. The discourse closes with the powerful similitude of the wise and foolish builders. Again, as on an earlier occasion, Christ’s auditors were astonished at His teaching, and at the authority with which He spoke (Mt 7 28.29). A series of remarkable incidents are next to be noticed. (1) The healing of the centurion’s servant ap- parently took place on the same day as the delivery of the Sermon on the Mount (Lk 7 2. Inter- 1.2). It had been a day of manifold vening and exhausting labors for Jesus. A Incidents walk of perhaps 7 miles brought Him back to Capernaum, the crowds ac- companying. Yet no sooner, on His return, does He hear a new appeal for help than His love replies, “T will eome and heal him.” The a) Healing suppliant was a Rom centurion—one of the Cen- who had endeared himself to the Jews turion’s (Lk 7 5)—and the request was for the Servant healing of a favorite servant, paralyzed (Mt 8:1.5- and tortured with pain. First, a depu- 18; Lk 7: tation sought Christ’s good offices, 1-10) then, when Jesus was on the way, a seeond message eame, awakening even Christ’s astonishment by the magnitude of its faith. The centurion felt he was not worthy that Jesus should come under his roof, but let Jesus speak the word only, and his servant would be healed. “TI have not found so great faith,’ Jesus said, ‘no, not in Israel.” The word was spoken, and, on the return of the messengers, the servant was found healed. The exciting events of this day gathered so great a crowd round the house where Jesus was as left Him no leisure even to eat, and His b) The friends, made anxious for His health, Widow of sought to restrain Him (Mk 3 20.21). Nain’s Son It was probably to escape from this Raised (Lk local excitement that Jesus, “soon 7:11-17) — afterwards,” is found at the little town : of Nain, a few miles 8.E. of Nazareth. A great multitude still followed Him. Here, as He entered the city, occurred the most wonderful of the works He had yet wrought. A young man—the only son of a widowed mother—was heing carried out for burial. Jesus,in compassion, stopped the mournful procession, and, in the ealm certainty of His word Bene obeyed, bade the young man arise. On the instant life returned, and Jesus gave the son back to his mother. The amazement of the people was tenfold intensified. They felt that the old days had comeback: that God had visited His people. It was apparently during the journey or eircuit which embraced this visit to Nain, and as the result of the fame it brought to Jesus (Lk 7 17.18; note the allusion to the dead being raised in Christ’s reply to John), that the embassy was sent from the . Jesus Christ Baptist in prison to ask of Jesus whether He was indeed He who should come, or would they look for another. It was a strange question c) Embassy on the lips of the forerunner, but is of John’s probably to be interpreted as the ex- Disciples— pression of perplexity rather than of Christ and actualdoubt. Thereseems no question His Gen- but that John’s mind had been thrown eration (Mt into serious difficulty by the reports 11:2-30; which had reached him of the work Lk 7: 18-35) of Jesus. Things were not turning out as he expected. It was the peaceful, merciful character of Christ’s work which stumbled John. The gloom of his prison wrought with his disappointment, and led him to send this message for the satisfaction of himself and his disciples. (1) Christ’s answer to John.—If doubt there was, Jesus treated it tenderly. He did not answer di- rectly, but bade the two disciples who had been sent go back and tell John the things they had seen and heard—the blind receiving their sight, the lame walking, the deaf cured, the dead raised, the Gospel preached. Little doubt the Messiah had come when works like these—the very works predicted by the prophets (Isa 35 5.6)—were being done. Blessed were those who did not find occasion of stumbling in Him. Jesus, however, did more. By his em- bassy John had put himself in a somewhat false po- sition before the multitude. But Jesus would not have His faithful follower misjudged. His was no fickle spirit. Jesus nobly vindicated him as a prophet and more than a prophet; yea, a man than whom a greater had not lived. Yet, even as the new dispensation was higher than the old, one “‘but little” in the kingdom of heaven—one sharing Christ’s humble, loving, self-denying disposition— was greater even than John (Mt 11 11). (2) A perverse people—Christ’s grace-—The im- plied contrast between Himself and John led Jesus further to denounce the perverse spirit of His own generation. The Pharisees and lawyers (Lk 7 30) had rejected John; they were as little pleased with Him. Their behavior was like children objecting to one game because it was merry, and to another because it was sad. The flood of outward popu- larity did not deceive Jesus. The cities in which His greatest works were wrought—Chorazin, Beth- saida, Capernaum—remained impenitent at heart. The heavier would be their judgment; worse even than that on Tyre and Sidon, or on Sodom itself. Over against their unbelief Jesus reasserts His dig- nity and declares His grace (Mt 11 25-30). All authority was His; He alone knew and could reveal the Father (mo claims in Jn are higher). Let the heavy laden come to Him, and He would give them rest (parts of these passages appear in another con- nection in Lk 10 12-21). Yet another beautiful incident connected with this journey is preserved by Lk—the anointing of Jesus in Simon’s house by a woman d) The who was a sinner. In Nain or some First other city visited by Him, Jesus was Anointing— invited to dine with a Pharisee named the Woman Simon. His reception was a cold one Who Wasa (vs 4446). During the meal, a Sinner (Lk woman of the city, an outcast from 7:36-60) respectable society—one, however, as the story implies, whose heart Jesus had reached, and who, filled with sorrow, love, shame, penitence, had turned from her life of sin, entered the chamber. There, bathing Christ’s feet with her tears, wiping them with her tresses, and imprinting on them fervent kisses, she anointed them with a precious ointment she had brought with her. Simon was scandalized. Jesus could not be a right-thinking man, much less a prophet, or He . would have rebuked this misbehavior from such THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1644 a person. Jesus met the thought of Simon’s heart by speaking to him the parable of the Two Debtors (vs 41.42). Of two men who had been freely for- given, one 500, the other 50 shillings, which would love his creditor most? Simon gave the obvious answer, and the contrast between his own reception of Jesus and the woman’s passionate love was immediately pointed out. Her greater love was due to the greater forgiveness; though, had Simon only seen it, he perhaps needed for- 3. Second giveness even more than she. Her Galilean faith saved her and she was dismissed Circuit— inpeace. But again the question arose, Events at ‘Who is this that even forgiveth sins?” Capernaum Luke introduces here (Lk 8 1-4) a (Lk 8:1~4. second Galilean circuit of Jesus, after 19-21; Mt the return from which a new series 12:22-50; of exciting incidents took place at Ca- Mk 3:22- pernaum. 35; cf Lk The circuit was an extensive one— 11:14-36) “went about through cities and villages (lit. “according to city and village”J, preaching.” During this journey Jesus was attended by the Twelve, and by devoted women (Mary _ Magdalene, Joanna, wife of Herod’s a) Galilee steward, Susanna, and others), who Revisited ministered to Him of their substance (LE 8:1-4) (vs 2.3). At the close of this circuit Jesus returned to Capernaum. Jesus, no doubt, wrought numerous miracles on demoniacs (cf Lk 8 1.2; out of Mary Magdalene He is said to have cast 7 demons—per- b) Cure of haps a form of speech to indicate the Demoniac— severity of the possession). Thedemo- Discourse niac now brought to Jesus was blind on Blas- and dumb. Jesus cured him, with the phemy double result that the people were filled with amazement: ‘Can this be the son of David?” (Mt 12 23), while the Phari- sees blaspbhemed, alleging that Jesus cast out demons by the help of Beelzebub (Gr Beelzeboul), the prince of the demons (see s.v.). A quite similar incident is narrated in Mt 9 32-34; and Lk gives the discourse that follows in a later con- nection (11 14 ff). The accusation may well have been repeated more than once. Jesus, in reply, points out, first, the absurdity of supposing Satan to be engaged in warring against his own kingdom (Mt 18 25 ff |; here was plainly a stronger than Satan); then utters the momentous word about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. All other blasphemies—even that against the Son of Man (Mt 12 32)—may be forgiven, for they may proceed from ignorance and misconception; but deliberate, perverse rejection of the light, and attributing to Satan what was manifestly of God, was a sin which, when matured—and the Pharisees came perilously near committing it—admitted of no forgiveness, either in this world or the next, for the very capacity for truth in the soul was by such sin destroyed. Mk has the strong phrase, “is guilty of an eternal sin’ (3 29). Pertinent words follow as to the root of good and evil in character (Mt 12 33-37). See BuaspHemy, The sign of Jonah.—Out of this discourse arose the usual Jewish demand for a “sign” (Mt 12 38; ef Lk 11 29-32), which Jesus met by declaring that no sign would be given but the sign of the prophet Jonah—an allusion to His future resurrec- tion. He reiterates His warning to the people of His generation for their rejection of greater light than had been enjoyed by the Ninevites and the Queen of Sheba. , Two incidents, not dissimilar in character, interrupted this discourse—one the cry of a woman in the audience (if the time be the same, Lk 11 27. 28), “Blessed is the womb that bare thee,” etc, 1645 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ to which Jesus replied, ‘Yea rather, blessed are they that hear the word of Gad, and keep it’”’; the other, a message that His mother and brethren ce) Christ’s (doubtless anxious for His safety) de- Mother and sired to speak with Him. To this, Brethren _— stretching out His hand toward His disciples, Jesus answered, ‘Behold, my mother and my brethren” (Mk 3 34), etc. Kinship in the spiritual kingdom consists in fidelity to the will of God, not in ties of earthly relationship. On the same day on which the preceding dis- courses were delivered, Jesus, seeing the multitudes, passed to the shore, and entering a 4. Teaching boat, inaugurated a new method in in Parables His public teaching. This was the (Mt 13:1~ speaking in parables. Similitude, 52; Mk 4: metaphor, always entered into the 1-34; Lk teaching of Jesus (cf Mt 7 24-27), 8:4-16; 13: and parable has once been met with 18-21) (Lk T 41.42); now parable is sys- tematically employed as a means of imparting and illustrating important truths, while yet veiling them from those whose minds were hostile and unreceptive (Mk 4 10-12; Lk 8 9.10). The parable thus at once reveals and conceals. The motive of this partially veiled teaching was the growing hostility of the Pharisees. In its nature the parable (from a verb signifying “to place side by side”) is a representation in some form of earthly analogy of truths relating to Divine and eternal things (see ParaBLE). The parables of the king- dom brought together in Mt 13 form an invaluable series, though not all were- spoken in public (cf Mt 13 36-52), and some may belong to a later occasion (cf Lk 18 18-21). Mk adds the parable of the Seed Growing Secretly (4 26-29). Of three of the parables (the Sower, the Tares, the Dragnet), Jesus Himself gives the interpretation. Parables of the kingdom.—In series the parables at once mirror the origin, mixed character and development of the kingdom in its present imper- fect earthly condition, and the perfection which awaits it after the crisis at the end. In the parable of the Sower is represented the origin of the kingdom in the good seed of the word, and the varied soils on which that seed falls; in the Seed Growing Secretly, the law of orderly growth in the kingdom; in the parable of the Tares, the mixed character of the subjects of the kingdom; in those of the Mustard Seed and Leaven, the progress of the kingdom—external growth, internal transformative effect; in those of the Treasure and Pearl the finding and worth of the kingdom; in that of the Dragnet the consummation of the kingdom. Jesus compares His disciples, if they understand these things, to householders bringing out of their treasure “things new and old” (Mt 13 52). IV. From the Crossing to Gadara to the Mission of the Twelve—a Third Circuit.—It was _on the evening of the day on which He spoke 1. Crossing the parables—though the ee oHoloey of the Lake of the incident seems unknown to L —Stillmg (8 22)—that Jesus bade His disciples of the cross over to the other side of the Storm (Mt lake. At this juncture He was accosted 8:18-27; by an aspirant for discipleship. Mat- Mk 4:36- thew gives two cases of aspirants; 41; Lk 8: Luke (but in a different connection, 22-25; cf 9 57-62), three. Luke’s connection 9:57-62) (departure from Galilee) is perhaps preferable for the second and third; but the three may be considered together. The three aspirants may be distinguished as, (a) The forward disciple: he who in an atmosphere of enthusiasm offered himself under impulse, without counting the cost. The zeal of this would-be follower Jesus checks with the pathetic words, ‘The foxes have holes,” etc (Mt 8 20; Lk 9 58. (6) The procrastinating disciple. The first candidate needed repression; the second needs im- a) Aspirants pulsion. He would follow Jesus, but for Dis- jirst let him bury hisfather. There had cipleship come a crisis, however, when the Lord’s claim was paramount: “Leave the dead to bury their own dead” (Mt 8 22). There are at times higher claims than mere natural rela- tionships, to which, in themselves, Jesus was the last to be indifferent. (c) The wavering disciple. The third disciple is again one who offers himself, but his heart was too evidently still with the things at home. Jesus, again, lays His finger on the weak spot, ‘‘No man, having put his hand to the plow, and looking back,” ete (Lk 9 62). As mentioned, the latter two cases tally better with a final depar- ture from Galilee than with a temporary crossing of the lake. The inland lake was exposed to violent and sudden tempests. One of these broke on the dis- ciples’ boat as they sailed across. b) The Everyone’s life seemed in jeopardy. Storm Jesus, meanwhile, in calmest repose, Calmed was asleep on a cushion in the stern (Mk 4 38). The disciples woke Him almost rudely: ‘‘Teacher, carest thou not that we perish?” Jesus at once arose, and, reproving their want of faith, rebuked wind and waves (‘‘Peace, be still”). Immediately there was a great calm. It was a new revelation to the disciples of the majesty of their Master. ‘Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him?”’ The lake being crossed, Jesus and His disciples came into the country of the Gadarenes (Mt), or Gerasenes (Mk, Lk)—Gadara being 2. The the capital of the district (on the to- Gadarene pography, cf Stanley, Sinai and Pal, (Gerasene) 380-81). From the lake shore rises a Demoniac mountain in which are ancient tombs. (Mt 8:28- Here Jesus was met by a demoniac 34; Mk 5: (Mt mentions two demoniacs: 1-20,Lk 8: Henry’s quaint comment is, “If there 26-39) were two, there was one.” Possibly one was the fiercer of the two, the other figuring only as his companion). The man, as de- scribed, was a raving maniac of the worst type (Mk 5 3-5), dwelling in the tombs, wearing no clothes (Lk 8 27), of supernatural strength, wounding himself, shrieking, etc. Really possessed by ‘an unclean spirit,’ his consciousness was as if he were indwelt by a “legion” of demons, and from that consciousness he addressed Jesus as the Son of God come for their tormenting. In what follows it is difficult to distinguish what belongs to the broken, incoherent consciousness of the man, and the spirit or spirits who spake through him. In the question, “What is thy name?” (Mk 6 9) Jesus evidently seeks to arouse the victim’s shat- tered soul to some sense of its own individuality. On Jesus commanding the unclean spirit to leave the man, the request was made that the demons might be permitted to enter a herd of swine feeding near. The reason of Christ’s permission, with its result in the destruction of the herd (“rushed down the steep into the sea”) need not be too closely scrutinized. It may have had an aspect of judg- ment on the (possibly) Jewish holders of the swine; or it may have had reference to the victim of the possession, as enabling him to realize his deliver- ance. Whatever the difficulties of the narrative, none of the rationalistic explanations afford any sensible relief from them. The object of the miracle may be to exclude rationalistic explanations, by giving a manifest attestation of the reality of the demon influence. When the people of the city came they found the man fully restored—‘clothed Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1646 and in his right mind.” Yet, with fatal short- sightedness, they besought Jesus to depart from their borders. The man was sent home to declare to his friends the great things the Lord had done to him. Repelled by the Gerasenes, Jesus received a warm welcome on His return to Capernaum on the western shore (Mk 6 21). It was 8. Jairus’ probably at this point that Matthew Daughter gave the feast formerly referred to. Raised— It was in connection with this feast, Woman Matthew himself informs us (9 18), with Issue _ that Jairus, one of the rulers of the of Blood (Mt synagogue, made his appeal for help. 9:18-26; His little daughter, about 12 years Mk 6:21- old (Lk 8 42), was at the point of 43; Lk 8: death; indeed, while Jesus was coming, 40-56) she died. The ruler’s faith, though real, was not equal to the centurion’s, who believed that Jesus could heal without being present. Jesus came, and having expelled the pro- fessional mourners, in sacred privacy, a) Jairus’ only the father and mother, with Peter, Appeal and James and John being permitted to Its Result enter the death-chamber, raised the girl to life. It is the second miracle on record of the raising from the dead. On the way to the ruler’s house occurred another wonder—a miracle within a miracle. A poor woman, whose case was a specially b) The distressing one, alike as regards the Afflicted nature of her malady, the length of Woman its continuance, and the fruitlessness of Cured her application to the physicians, crept up to Jesus, confident that if she could but touch the border of His garment, she would be healed. The woman was ignorant; her faith was blended with superstition; but Jesus, reading the heart, gave ber the benefit she desired. It was His will, however, that, for her own good, the woman thus cured should not obtain the blessing by stealth. He therefore brought her to open con- fession, and cheered her by His commendatory word. At this point begins apparently a new evangelistic tour (Mt 9 35; Mk 6 6), extending methodically to “all the cities and villages.” To it 4. Incidents belong in the narratives the healing of of Third two blind men (cf the case of Barti- Circuit (Mt maeus, recorded later); the cure of a 9:27-38; demoniac who was dumb—a similar 13:53-58; casetothatin Mt 12 22; and asecond Mk 6:1-6) rejection at Nazareth (Mt, Mk). The incident is similar to that in Lk 4 16-30, and shows, if the events are different, that the people’s hearts were unchanged. Of this cir- cuit Mt gives an affecting summary (9 35-38), em- phasizing the Lord’s compassion, and His yearning tor more laborers to reap the abundant harvest. Partly with a view to the needs of the rapidly growing work and the training of the apostles, and partly as a witness to Israel (Mt 10 5. The 6.23), Jesus deemed it expedient to Twelve Sent send the Twelve on an independent Forth—Dis- mission. The discourse in Mt attached course of to this event seems, as frequently, Jesus (Mt to be a compilation. Parts of it are 10; Mk 6: given by Luke in connection with the 7-13; Lk 9: mission of the Seventy (Lk 10 1 ff; 1-6; cf Lk the directions were doubtless similar 10:2-24; in both cases); parts on other occasions 12:2-12, (Lk 12 2-12; 21 12-17, etc; cf Mk etc) 13 9-13). The Twelve were sent out two by two. Their work was to be a copy of the Master’s -—to preach the gospel and to heal the sick. To this end they were endowed with authority over unclean spirits, and over all manner of sickness. They were to go forth free from all encumbrances—no money, no scrip, no changes of raiment, no staff (save that in their hand, Mk 6 8), sandals only a) The on their feet, etc. They were to rely Commission for support on those to whom they preached. They were for the present to confine their ministry to Israel. The saying in Mt 10 23, “Ye shall not have gone through the cities of Israel, till the Son of man be come,” ap- parently has reference to the judgment on the nation, not to the final coming (cf 16 28). The mission of the Twelve was the first step of Christianity as an aggressive force in society. Jesus speaks of it, accordingly, in the light b) Counsels of the whole future that was to come and out of it. He warns His apostles Warnings faithfully of the dangers that awaited them; exhorts them to prudence and circumspection (‘wise as serpents,” etc); holds out to them Divine promises for consolation; di- rects them when persecuted in one place to flee to another; points out to them from His own case that such persecutions were only to be expected. He assures them of a coming day of revelation; bids them at once fear and trust God; impresses on them the duty of courage in confession; inculcates in them supreme love to Himself. That love would be tested in the dearest relations. In itself peace, the gospel would be the innocent occasion of strife, enmity and division among men. Those who re- ceive Christ’s disciples will not fail of their reward. When Christ. had ended His discourse He pro- ceeded with His own evangelistic work, leaving the disciples to inaugurate theirs (Mt 11 1). Second Period—After the Mission of the Twelve till the Departure from Galilee I. From the Death of the Baptist till the Discourse on Bread of Life.—Shortly before the events now to be narrated, John the Baptist had 1. The been foully murdered in his prison Murder of by Herod Antipas at the instigation the Baptist of Herodias, whose unlawful marriage and Herod’s with Herod John had unsparingly Alarms (Mt condemned. Jos gives as the place of 14:1-12; the Baptist’s imprisonment the for- ME 6:14-__ tress of Machaerus, near the Dead Sea 29; Lk 9: (Ant, XVIII, v, 2); or John may have 7-9; cf 3: been removed to Galilee. Herod 18-20) would ere this have killed John, but was restrained by fear of the people (Mt 14 5). The hate of Herodias, however, did not slumber. Her relentless will contrasts with the vacillation of Herod, as Lady Macbeth in Shake- speare contrasts with Macbeth. A birthday feast gave her the opening she sought for. Her daughter Salome, pleasing Herod by her dancing, obtained from him a promise on oath to give her whatever she asked. Prompted by Herodias, she boldly de- manded John the Baptist’s head. The weak king was shocked, but, for his oath’s sake, granted her what she craved. The story tells how the Baptist’s disciples reverently buried the remains of their mas- ter, and went and told Jesus. Herod’s conscience did not let him rest. When rumors reached him of a wonderful teacher and miracle-worker in Galilee, be leaped at once to the conclusion that it was John risen from the dead. Herod cannot have heard much of Jesus before. An evil conscience makes men cowards. Another Passover drew near (Jn 6 4), but Jesus did not on this occasion go up to the feast. Returning from their mission, the apostles re- ported to Jesus what they had said and done (Lk 9 10); Jesus had also heard of the Baptist’s fate, and of Herod’s fears, and now proposed to His disciples a retirement to a desert place across the 1647 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ lake, near Bethsaida (on the topography, ef Stanley, op. cit., 375, 381). As it proved, however, the mul- titudes had observed their departure, 2. The and, running round the shore, were at Feeding of the place before them (Mk 6 38). the Five The purpose of rest was frustrated, Thousand but Jesus did not complain. He pitied (Mt 14:13- the shepherdless state of the people, 21; Mk 6: and went out to teach and heal them. 30-44; Lk The day wore on, and the disciples sug- 9:10-17; gested that the fasting multitudeshould Jn 6:1-14) disperse, and seek victualsin the nearest towns and villages. This Jesus, who had already proved Philip by asking how the people should be fed (Jn 6 5), would not permit. With the scanty provision at command—d loaves and 2 fishes—He fed the whole multitude. By His bless- ing the food was multiplied till all were satisfied, and 12 baskets of fragments, carefully collected, re- mained over. It was a stupendous act of creative power, no rationalizing of which can reduce it to natural dimensions. The enthusiasm created by this miracle was in- tense (Jn 6 14). Mt and Mk relate (Lk here falls for a time out of the Synopsis) that Jesus 3. Walking hurriedly constrained His disciples to on the Sea enter into their boat and recross the (Mt 14:22— lake—this though a storm was gath- 33; Mk 6: ering—while He Himself remained in 45-52; Jn the mountainalonein prayer. Jngives 6:16-21) the key to this action in the statement : that the people were about to take Him by force and make Him a king (ver 15). Three hours after midnight found the disciples still in the midst of the lake, “distressed in rowing” (Mk 6 48), deeply anxious because Jesus was not, as on a former occasion, with them. At last, at the darkest hour of their extremity, Jesus was seen approaching in a way unlooked-for—walking on the water. Every new experience of Jesus was a surprise to the disci- ples. They were at first terrified, thinking they saw a spirit, but straightway the well-known voice was heard, “Be of good cheer: it is I; be not afraid.” In the rebound of his feelings the impulsive Peter asked Jesus to permit him to come to Him on the water (Mt). Jesus said “‘Come,” and for the first moment or two Peter did walk on the water; then, as he realized his unwonted situation, his faith failed, and he began to sink. Jesus, with gentle chiding, caught him, and assisted him back into the boat. Once again the sea was calmed, and the disciples found themselves safely at land. To their adoring minds the miracle of the loaves was eclipsed by this new marvel (Mk 6 52). ; On the return to Gennesaret the sick from all quarters were brought to Jesus—the commence- ment apparently of a new, more general 4. Gennes- ministry of healing (Mk 6 56). Mean- aret—Dis- while—here we depend on Jn—the course on people on the other side of the lake, the Bread when they found that Jesus was gone, of Life (Mt took boats hastily, and came over to 14:34-36; Capernaum. They found Jesus ap- Mk 6:53- parently in the synagogue (ver 59). In 56; Jn6: reply to their query, ‘Rabbi, when 22-71) camest thou hither?” Jesus first rebuked the motive which led them to follow Him—not because they had seen in His miracles “sions” of higher blessings, but because they had eaten of the loaves and were filled (ver 26)—then spoke to them His great discourse on the bread from heaven. “Work,” He said, “for the food which abideth unto eternal life, which the Son of man shall give unto you” (ver 27). When asked to authenti- cate His claims by a sign from heaven like the manna, He replied that the manna also (given not by Moses but by God) was but typical bread, and surprised them by declaring that He Himself was the true bread of life from heaven (vs 35.51). The bread was Christ’s flesh, ‘given for the life of the world; His fiesh and blood must be eaten and drunk (a spiritual appropriation through faith, ver 63), if men were to have eternal life. Jesus of set purpose had put His doctrine in a strong, testing manner. The time had come when His hearers must make their choice between a spiritual acceptance of Him and a break with Him altogether. What He had said strongly offended them, both on account of the claims implied (ver 42), and on account of the doc- trine taught, which, they were plainly told, they could not receive because of their carnality of heart (vs 43.44.61-64). Many, therefore, went back and walked no more with Him (vs 60.61.66); but their defection only evoked from the chosen Twelve a yet more confident confession of their faith. ‘Would ye also go away?” Peter's first confession.—Peter, as usual, spoke for the rest: “Lord, to whom shall we go? .. . . We have believed and know that thou art the Holy One of God” (ver 69). Here, and not first at- Caesarea, Philippi (Mt 16 16), is Peter’s brave confession of his Master’s Messiahship. Twelve thus confessed Him, but even of this select. circle Jesus was com- Poy to say, “One of you [Judas] is a devil” (Jn 6 70.71). IL From Disputes with the Pharisees till the Transfiguration—The discourse in Capernaum seems to mark a turning-point in the Lord’s minis- try in Galilee. Soon after we find Him ceasing from public teaching, and devoting Himself to the in- struction of His apostles (Mt 15 21; Mk 7 24, etc). Meanwhile, that Christ’s work in Galilee was at- tracting the attention of the central authorities, is shown by the fact that scribes and 1. Jesus Pharisees came up from Jerus to watch and Tradi- Him. They speedily found ground of tion—Out- complaint against Him in His uncon- ward and ventional ways and His total disregard Inward of the traditions of the elders. They Purity (Mt specially blamed Him for allowing His 15:1-20; disciples to eat bread with “common,” Mk& 7:1-23) i.e. unwashen hands. Here was a point on which the Pharisees laid great gtress (Mk 7 3.4). Ceremonial ablutions (washing “diligently,” Gr “with the fist”; “‘baptizings” of person and things) formed a large part of their re- ligion. These washings were part of the “oral tra- dition” said to have been delivered to Moses, and transmitted by a succession of elders. Jesus set all this ceremonialism aside. It was part of the “hypocrisy” of the Pharisees (Mk 7 6). When questioned regarding it, He drew a sharp distinc- tion between God’s commandment in the Scriptures and man’s tradition, and accused the Pharisees (in- stancing “Corban” [q.v.], in support, vs 10-12) of making “void” the former through the latter. This led to the wider question of wherein real defilement consisted. Christ’s rational position here is that, it did not consist in anything outward, as in meats, but consisted in what came from within the man: as Jesus explained afterward, in the outcome of his heart or moral life: “Out of the heart of men evil thoughts proceed,” etc (vs 20-23). Christ’s saying was in effect the abrogation of the old ceremonial distinctions, as Mk notes: “making all meats clean” (ver 19). The Pharisees, naturally, were deeply offended at His sayings, but Jesus was unmoved. Every plant not of the Father’s planting must be rooted up (ver 13). ° From this point Jesus appears, in order to escape notice, to have made journeys privately from place to place. His first retreat was to the borders, or neighborhood, of Tyre and Sidon. From Mk 7 31 it is to be inferred that He entered the heathen ter- Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1648 ritory. He could not, however, be hid (Mk 7 24). It was not long ere, in the house into which He had entered, there reached Him the 2. Retire- cry of human distress. A woman came ment to to Him, a Greek (or Gentile, Greek- Tyre and speaking), but Syrophoenician by race. Sidon—the Her “‘little daughter” was grievously Syrophoeni- afflicted with an evil spirit. Flinging cian Woman herself at His feet, and addressing (Mt 15:21- Him as “‘Son of David,” she besought 98; Mk 7: His mercy for her child. At first 24-30) Jesus seemed—yet only seemed—to repel her, speaking of Himself as sent only to the lost sheep of Israel, and of the un- meetness of giving the children’s loaf to the dogs (the Gr softens the expression, ‘‘the little dogs’’). With a beautiful urgency which won for her the boon she sought, the woman seized on the word as an argu- ment in her favor. ‘ven the dogs under the table eat. of the children’s crumbs.’”’ The child at Jesus’ word was restored. Christ’s second retreat was to Decapolis—the district of the ten cities—E. of the Jordan. Here also He was soon discovered, and 3. At Decap- followed by the multitude. Sufferers olis—New were brought to Him, whom He Miracles cured (Mt 15 30). Later, He fed the (Mt 15: 29- crowds. 39; Mk 7: The miracle of the deaf man is at- 31-37; 8: tested only by Mk. The patient was 1-10) doubly afflicted, being deaf, and having an impediment in hisspeech. The cure presents several peculiarities—its privacy (ver 33); the actions of Jesusin putting his fingers into his ears, etc (a mode of speech by signs to the a) The Deaf deaf man); His “sign,’’ accompanied Man (Mk _ with prayer, doubtless occasioned by 7:32-37) something in the man’s look; the word Ephphathd (ver 34)—‘Be opened.” The charge to those present not to blazon the deed abroad was disregarded. Jesus desired no cheap popularity. The next miracle closely resembles the feeding of the Five Thousand at Bethsaida, but the place and : numbers are different; 4,000 instead of b) Feeding 5,000; 7 loaves and a few fishes, in- of Four Thousand of fragments instead of 12 (Mark’s term (Mt 15:32- denotes a larger basket). There is no 39; Mk 8: reason for doubting the distinction of 1-9) the Thee (cf Mt 16 9.10; Mk 8 19.20). Returning to the plain of Gennesaret (Magdala, Mt 16 39 AV; parts of Dalmanutha, Mk 8 10), Jesus soon found Himself assailed by 4. Leaven His old adversaries. Pharisees and of the Phari-Sadducees were now united. They sees, etc— came “trying” Jesus, and asking from Cure of Him a “sign from heaven’—some Blind Man signal Divine manifestation. ‘Sigh- (Mt 16:1- ing deeply” (Mk) at their caviling 12; Mk 8: spirit, Jesus repeated His word about 11-26) the sign of Jonah. The times in which they lived were full of signs, if they, so proficient in weather signs, could only see them. To be rid of such questioners, Jesus anew took boat to Bethsaida. On the way He warned His disciples against the leaven of the spirit they had just encountered. The disciples misunder- stood, thinking that Jesus referred to their for- getfulness in not taking bread (Mark states in his graphic way that they had only one loaf). The leaven Christ referred to, in fact, represented three spirits: (1) the Pharisaic leaven—formalism and hypocrisy; (2) the Sadducean leaven—rationalistic skepticism; (3) the Herodian leaven (Mk 8 15)— political expediency and temporizing. Arrived at stead of 5 loaves and 2 fishes; 7 baskets: Bethsaida, a miracle was wrought on a blind man resembling in some of its features the cure of the deaf man at Decapolis. In both cases Jesus took | the patients apart; in both physical means were used—the spittle (“spit on his eyes,’ Mk 8 23); in both there was strict injunction not to noise the cure abroad. Another peculiarity was the gradual- ness of the cure. It is probable that the man had not been blind from his birth, else he could hardly have recognized men or trees at the first opening. It needed that Jesus should lay His hands on Him before he saw all things clearly. The next retirement of Jesus with His disciples was to the neighhorhood of Caesarea Philippi, near the source of the Jordan. This was 5. At Caesa- the northernmost point of His journey- rea Philippi ings. Here, ‘‘on the geographical —The Great frontier between Judaism and heathen- Confession ism” (Liddon), Our Lord put the —First An- momentous question which called forth nouncement Peter’s historical confession. of Passion (1) The voices of the age and the exter- (Mt 16:13- nal truth—The question put to the 28; Mk 8: Twelvein this remote region was: ‘“Who 27-30; Lk do men say that the Son of man is?” 9:18-27) “Son of man,” as already said, was the familiar name given by Jesus to Himself, to which a Messianic significance might or might not be attached, according to the prepos- sessions of His hearers. First the changeful voices of the age were recited to Jesus: ‘Some say John the Baptist; some, Elijah,” etc. Next, in answer to the further question: ‘But who say ye that I am ?” there rang out from Peter, in the name of all, the unchanging truth about Jesus: ‘Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” In clearness, boldness, decision, Peter’s faith had attained a height not reached before. The confession embodies two truths: (1) the Divinity, (2) the Messiahship, of the Son of man. Jesus did honor to the con- fession of His apostle. Not flesh and blood, but the Father, had revealed the truth to him. Here at length was “rock”? on which He could build a church. Reverting to FPeter’s original name, Simon Bar-Jonah, Jesus declared, with a play on the name “Peter” (pétros, “rock,” ‘piece of rock’’) He had before given him (Jn 1 42), that on this “rock” (pétra), He would build His church, and the gates of Hades (hostile evil powers) would not prevail against it (Mt 1618). The papacy has reared an unwarrantable structure of pretensions on this passage in supposing the “rock” to be Peter personally and his successors in the see of Rome (none such existed; Peter was not bishop of Rome). It.is not Peter the individual, but Peter the confessing apostle— Peter as representative of all —that Christ names “rock”; that which consti- tuted him a foundation was the truth he had con- fessed (cf Eph 2 20). This is the first NT men- tion of a “church” (ekklésia). The Christian church, therefore, is founded (1) on the truth of Christ’s Divine Sonship; (2) on the truth of His Messiah- ship, or of His being the anointed prophet, priest and king of the new age. A society of believers confessing these truths is a church; no society which denies these truths deserves the name. To this confessing community Jesus, still addressing Peter as representing the apostolate (cf Mt 18 18), gives authority to bind and loose—to admit and to exclude. Jesus, it is noted, bade His disciples tell no man of these things (Mt 16 20; Mk 8 30; Lk 9 21). (2) The cross and the disciple —The confession of Peter prepared the way for an advance in Christ’s teaching. From that time, Matthew notes, Jesus began to speak plainly of His approaching suffer- ings and death (16 21). There are in all three 1649 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ solemn announcements of the Passion (Mt 16 21-23; 17 22.23; 20 17-19 ||). Jesus foresaw, and clearly foretold, what would befall Him at Jerus. He would be killed by the authorities, but on the third day would rise again. On the first announcement, following His confession, Peter took it upon him to expostulate with Jesus: “Be it far from thee, Lord,” etc (Mt 16 22), an action which brought upon him the stern rebuke of Jesus: “Get thee behind me, Satan,” ete (ver 23). The Rock-man, in his fall to the maxims of a worldly expediency, is now identified with Satan, the tempter. This principle, that duty is only to be done when personal risk is not entailed, Jesus not only repudiates for Himself, but bids His disciples repudiate it also. The disciple, Jesus says, must be prepared to deny himself, and take up his cross. The cross is the symbol of anything distressing or painful to bear. There is a saving of life which is a losing of it, and what shall a man be profited if he gain the whole world, and forfeit his (true, higher) life? As, however, Jesus had spoken, not only of dying, but of rising again, so now He encourages His disciples by announcing His future coming in glory to render to every man according to His deeds. That final coming might be distant (cf Mt 24 36); but (so it seems most natural to interpret the saying 16 28 ||) there were those living who would see the nearer pledge of that, in Christ’s coming in the triumphs and successes of His kingdom (cf Mk 9 1; Lk 9 27; Mt 26 64). About eight days after the announcement of His passion by Jesus, took place the glorious event of the transfiguration. Jesus had spoken 6. The of His future glory, and here was a Transfigura- pledge of it. In strange contrast tion—the with the scene of glory on the summit Epileptic of the mountain was the painful sight Boy (Mt which met Jesus and His three com- 17:1-20; | panions when they descended again to Mk 9:2-29; to the plain. : Lk 9:28-43) Tradition connects the scene of the transfiguration with Mount Tabor, but it more probably took place on one of the spurs of Mount Hermon. Jesus had ascended the moun- tain with Peter, James and John, for a) The prayer. It was while He was praying Glory of the the wonderful change happened. For Only once the veiled glory of the only Begotten begotten from the Father (Jn 1 14) was permitted to burst forth, suffusing His person and garments, and changing them into a dazzling brightness. His face did shine as the sun; His raiment became white as light (‘‘as snow, AV, Mk). Heavenly visitants, recognized from their converse as Moses and Elijah, appeared with Him and spoke of His decease (Lk). A voice from an enveloping cloud attested: “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.” Little wonder the disciples were afraid, or that Peter in his con- fusion should stammer out: “It is good for us to be here: if thou wilt, I will make here three taber- nacles [booths].”” This, however, was not per- mitted. Earth is not heaven. Glimpses of heavenly glory are given, not to wean from duty on earth, but to prepare for the trials connected therewith. The spectacle that met the eyes of Jesus and the chosen three as they descended was distressing in the extreme. A man had_ brought b) Faith’s his epileptic boy—a sore sufferer and Entreaty dumb—to the disciples to see if they and Its could cast out the evil spirit that pos- Answer sessed him, but they were not able. Their failure, as Jesus showed, was a failure of faith; none the less did their discomfiture afford a handle to the gainsayers, who were not slow to take advantage of it (Mk 9 14). The man’s ap- peal was now to Jesus, ‘If thou canst do anything,” cte (ver 22). The reply of Jesus shifted the “canst” to-the right quarter, “If thou canst [believe]”’ (ver 23). Such little faith as the man had revived under Christ’s word: “I believe; help thou mine unbelief.” The multitude pressing around, there was no call for further delay. With one energetic word Jesus expelled the unclean spirit (ver 25). The first effect of Christ’s approach had been to induce a violent paroxysm (ver 20); now the spirit terribly convulsed the frame it was compelled to relinquish. Jesus, taking the boy’s hand, raised him up, and he was found well. The lesson drawn to the disciples was the omnipotence of faith (Mt 17 19.20) and power of prayer (Mk 9 28.29). From Private Journey through Galilee till Return from the Feast of Tabernacles.—Soon after the last-mentioned events Jesus passed 1. Galilee privately through Galilee (Mk 9 30), and Caper- returning later to Capernaum. naum During the Galilean journey Jesus made to His disciples His 2d announce- ment of His approaching sufferings and death, accompanied as before by the assurance of His re- surrection. The disciples still could a) Second not take in the meaning of His words, Announce- though what He said made them ‘‘ex- ment of ceeding sorry” (Mt 17 23). Passion(Mt The return to Capernaum was 17:22.23; marked by an incident which raised Mk 9:30— the question of Christ’s relation to 33; Lk 9: temple institutions. The collectors of 44.45) tribute for the temple inquired of Peter: “Doth not your teacher pay the half- shekel?” (Gr didrachma, or double drachm, worth about 32 cents or 1s.4d.). The origin of this tax was in the half-shekel of atonement-money b) The of Ex 30 11-16, which, though a special Temple Tax contribution, was made the basis of (Mt 17:24 later assessment (2 Ch 24 4-10; in 27) Nehemiah’s time the amount was one- third of a shekel, Neh 10 32), and its object was the upkeep of the temple worship (Schiirer). The usual time of payment was March, but Jesus had probably been absent and the inquiry | was not made for some months later. Peter, hasty as usual, probably reasoning from Christ’s ordinary respect for temple ordinances, answered at once that He did pay the tax. It had not occurred to him that Jesus might have something to say on it, if formally challenged. Occasion therefore was taken by Jesus gently to reprove Peter. Peter had but recently acknowledged Jesus to be the Son of God. Do kings of the earth take tribute of their own sons? ‘The half-shekel was suitable to the subject- relation, but not to the relation of a son. Never- theless, lest occasion of stumbling be given, Jesus could well waive this right, as, in His humbled con- dition, He had waived so many more. Peter was ordered to cast his hook into the sea, and Jesus foretold that the fish he would bring up would have in its mouth the necessary coin (Gr statér, about 64 cents or 2s. 8d.). The tax was paid, yet in such a way as to show that the payment of it was an act of condescension of the king’s Son. On the way to Capernaum a dis- c) Dis- pute had arisen among the disciples as course on to whoshould be greatest in the Messi- Greatness anic kingdom about tobeset up. The and For- fact of such disputing showed how giveness largely even their minds were yet dom- (Mt 18:1— inated by worldly, sensuous ideas of 35; Mk 9: the kingdom. Now, in the house (Mk 33-50; Lk 9 33), Jesus takes occasion to check 9:46-50) their spirit of ambitious rivalry, and to inculeate much-needed lessons on greatness and kindred matters. Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1650 (1) Greatness in humility—First, by the example of a little child, Jesus teaches that humility is the rdot-disposition of His kingdom. It alone admits to the kingdom, and conducts to honor in it. He is greatest who humbles himself most (Mt 18 4), and is the servant of all (Mk 9 35). He warns against slighting the “‘little ones,” or causing them to stumble, and uses language of terrible severity against those guilty of this sin. (2) Tolerance——The mention of receiving little ones in Christ’s name led John to remark that he had seen one casting out demons in Christ’s name, and had forbidden him, because he was not of their company. ‘Forbid him not,” Jesus said, ‘for there is no man who shall do a mighty work in my name, and be able quickly to speak evil of me. For he that is not against us is for us’ (Mk 9 39.40). (3) The erring brother.—The subject of offences leads to the question of sins committed by one Chris- tian brother against another. Here Christ incul- cates kindness and forbearance; only if private rep- resentations and the good offices of brethren fail, ig the matter to be brought before the church; if the brother repents he is to be unstintedly forgiven (“seventy times seven,’”’ Mt 18 22). If the church is compelled to interpose, its decisions are valid (under condition, however, of prayer and Christ’s presence, vs 18-20). (4) Parable of the Unmerciful Servant—To en- force the lesson of forgiveness Jesus speaks the para- ble of the Unmerciful Servant (Mt 18 23-35). Himself forgiven much, this servant refuses to for- give his fellow a much smaller debt. His lord visita him with severest punishment. Only as we for- give others can we look for forgiveness. The Gospel of Jn leaves a blank of many months between chs 6 and 7, covered only by the state- ment, ‘“‘After these things, Jesus walked 2. The in Galilee” (7 1). In this year of His Feast of ministry Jesus had gone neither to the Tabernacles feast of the Passover nor to Pentecost. —Dis- The Feast of Tabernacles was now at courses, etc hand (October). To this Jesus went up (Jn 7—10: and Jn preserves for us a full record o 21) His appearance, discourses and doings there. The brethren of Jesus, still unpersuaded of His claims (ver 5), had urged Jesus to go up with them to the feast. ‘Go up,” in their sense, a) The included a public manifestation of Private Himself as the Messiah. Jesus replied Journey— that His time for this had not yet come. Divided Afterward He went up quietly, and in Opinions _ the midst of the feast appeared in the (Jn 7:1-10) temple as a teacher. The comments made about Jesus at the feast before His arrival vividly reflect the divided state of opinion regarding Him. ‘He isagood man,” thought some. “Not so,” said others, ‘“‘but He leadeth the multi- tude astray.’ His teaching evoked yet keener divi- sion. While some said, “Thou hast a demon” (ver 20), others argued, ‘‘When the Christ shall come, will he do more signs?” etc (ver 31). Some de- clared, “This is of a truth the prophet,” or ‘This is the Christ’; others objected that the Christ was to come out of Bethlehem, not Galilee (vs 40-42). Yet no one dared to take the step of mo- lesting Him. Christ’s wisdom and use of the Scriptures excited surprise. Jesus met this surprise by stating that His knowledge was from the Father, and with ref- erence to the division of opinion about Him laid down the principle that knowledge of the truth was the result of the obedient will: “If any man willeth to do his will, he shall know of the teaching, whether it is of God” (ver 17). It was objected that they knew who Jesus was, and whence He came. In a sense, Jesus replied, this was true; in a deeper sense, it was uot. He came from the Father, whom they knew not (vs 28.29). The b) The Test last and great day of the feast—the of Truth— eighth (Nu 29 35)—brought with it Christ’s a new self-attestation. Jesus stood Self- and cried, “If any man thirst, let him Witness; come unto me and drink. He that a Foiled believeth on me... . from within him Purpose shall flow rivers of living water” (vs (vs 14-52) 37.38). The words are understood to have reference to the ceremony of pouring out a libation of water at this feast—the libation, in turn, commemorating the gilt of water at the striking of the rock. The evangelist inter- prets the saying of the Spirit which believers should receive. Meanwhile, the chief priests and Pharisees had sent officers to apprehend Jesus (ver 32), but they returned without Him. ‘Why did ye not bring him?” The reply was confounding, ‘‘Never man so spake” (vs 45.46). The retort was the poor one, ‘‘Are ye also led astray?” In vain did Nico- demus, who was present, try to put in a moderating word (vs 50.51). It was clear to what issue hate like this was tending. The discourses at the feast are at this point in- terrupted by the episode of the woman taken in adul- tery (8 1-11), which, by general con- c) The sent, does not belong to the original Woman text of the Gospel. It is probably, Taken in however, an authentic incident, and Adultery— illustrates, on the one hand, the eager- Continued ness of the official classes to find an ac- Self-Wit- cusation against Jesus, and, on the ness (ch 8) other, the Saviour’s dignity and wisdom in foiling such attempts, His spirit of mercy and the action of conscience in the accusers. In His continued teaching, Jesus put forth even higher claims than in the foregoing discourse. As He had applied to Himself the water from the rock, so now He applied to Himself the symbolic meaning of the two great candelabra, which were lighted in the temple court during the feast and bore refer- ence to the pillar of cloud andfire. “I am the light of the world,’’ said Jesus (ver 12). Only a Divine being could put forth such a claim as that. The Jews objected that they had only His witness to Himself. Jesus replied that no other could bear adequate witness of Him, for He alone knew whence He came and whither He went (ver 14). But the Father also had borne witness of Him (ver 18). This discourse, delivered in the “treasury” of the temple (ver 20), was soon followed by another, no man yet daring to touch Him. This time Jesus warns the Jews of the fate their unbelief would entail upon them: “Ye shall die in your sins” (ver 24), Ad~- dressing Himself next specially to the Jews who believed in Him, He urged them to continuance in His word as the condition of true freedom. Re- seutment was again aroused at the suggestion that the Jews, Abraham’s seed, were not iree. Jesus made clear that the real bondage was that of sin; only the Son could make spiritually free (vs 34~36). Descent from Abraham meant nothing, if the spirit was of the devil (vs 39-41). A new conflict was pro- voked by the saying, “If a man keep my word, he shall never see death” (ver 51). Did Jesus make Himself greater than Abraham? The controversy that ensued resulted in the sublime utterance, “Be- fore Abraham was born, I am” (ver 58). The Jews would have stoned Him, but Jesus eluded them, and departed. The Feast of Tabernacles was past, but Jesus was still in Jerus. Passing by on a Sabbath (ver 14), He saw a blind man, a beggar (ver 8), well known to have been blind from his birth. ‘The narrative of the cure and examination of this blind man is 1651 adduced by Paley as bearing in its inimitable cir- cumstantiality every mark of personal knowledge on the part of the historian. The man, d) The cured in strange but symbolic fashion Cure of the by the anointing of his eyes with clay Blind Man (thereby apparently sealing them more (ch 9) firmly), then washing in the Pool of : Siloam, became an object of immediate interest, and every effort was made by the Pharisees to shake his testimony as to the miracle that had been wrought. The man,’ however, held to his story, and his parents could only corroborate the fact that their son had been born blind, and now saw. ‘The Pharisees themselves were divided, some reasoning that Jesus could not be of God because He had broken the Sabbath—the old charge; others, Nicodemus-like, standing on the fact that a man who was a sinner could not do such signs (vs 15.16). The healed man applied the logic of common-sense: “Tf this man were not from God, he could do nothing”’ (ver 33). The Pharisees, impotent to deny the wonder, could only cast him out of the synagogue. Jesus found him, and brought him to full confession of faith in Himself (vs 35-38). Yet another address of Jesus is on record arising out of this incident. In continuation of His reply to the question of the Pharisees (9 40), e) The “Are we also blind?” Jesus spoke to Good them His discourse on the Good Shep- Shepherd herd. Flocks in eastern countries are (10:1-21) gathered at night into an inclosure sur- rounded by a wall or palisade. This is the ‘‘fold,”’ which is under the care of a “porter,” who opens the closely barred door to the shepherds in the morning. As contrasted with the legitimate shepherds, the false shepherds “enter not by the door,”’ but climb over some other way. The al- lusion is to priests, scribes, Pharisees and gener- ally to all, in any age, who claim an authority within the church unsanctioned by God (Godet). Jesus now gathers up the truth in its relation to Himself as the Supreme Shepherd. From His fundamental relation to the church, He is not only the Shepherd, but the Door (vs 7-14). To those who enter by Him there is given security, liberty, provision (ver 9). In his capacity as Shepherd Christ is preémi- nently all that a faithful shepherd ought tobe. The highest proof of His love is that, as the Good Shep- herd, He lays down His life for the sheep (vs 11.15. 17). This laying down of His life is not an accident, but is His free, voluntary act (vs 17.18). Again there was division among the Jews because of these remarkable sayings (vs 19-21). Chronological note—Though John does not mention the fact, there is little doubt that, after this visit to Jerus, Jesus returned to Galilee, and at no long interval from His return, took His final departure southward. The chronology of this Slosing eriod in Galilee is some- what uncertain. Some would place the visit to the Feast of Tahernacles hefore the withdrawal to Caesarea Philippi, or even earlier (cf Andrews, Life of Our Lord, ete); Bue the order adopted above appears preferable. D. LAST JOURNEY TO JERUSALEM—JESUS IN PERAEA An interval of two months elapses between vs 21 and 22 in Jn 10—from the Feast of Tabernacles (Oc- tober) till the Feast of the Dedication Departure (December). This period witnessed from the final withdrawal of Jesus from Galli- Galilee lee. Probably while yet in Galilee He sent forth the seventy disciples to pre- pare His way in the cities to which He should come (Lk 10 1). Repulsed on the borders of Samaria (Lk 9 51-53), He passed over into Peraea (“beyond Jor- dan”), where he exercised a considerable ministry. The record of this period, till the entry into Jerus, belongs in great part to Luke, who seems to have had a rich spccial source relating to it (9 51—19 27). THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ The discourses in Lk embrace many passages and sections found in other connections in Mt, and it is difficult, often, to determine their proper chrono- logical place, if, as doubtless sometimes happened, portions were not repeated. i. From Leaving Galilee till the Feast of the Dedi- cation.—Conscious that He went to suffer and die, Jesus steadfastly set His face to go to 1. Rejected Jerus. His route was first by Samaria by Samaria —an opportunity of grace to that peo- (Lk 9: ple—but here, at a border village, the messengers He sent before Him, prob- ably also He Himself on His arrival, were repulsed, because of His obvious intention to go to Jerus (ver 53). James and John wished to imitate Elijah in calling down fire from heaven on the rejecters, but Jesus rebuked them for their thought (RV omits the reference to Elijah, and subsequent clauses, vs 55.56). In the present connection Luke inserts the inci- dents of the three aspirants formerly considered (9 57-62; cf p. 1645). It was sug- 2. Mission gested that the second and third cases of the may belong to this period. Seventy (Lk A new and ent onut step was now 10:1-20) taken by Jesus in the sending out of 70 disciples, who should go before Him, two by two, to announce His coming: in the cities and villages He was about to visit. The number sent indicates how large a following Jesus had now acquired. (Some see a symbolica!l meaning in the number 70, but it is difficult to show what it is.) The directions given to the messengers are similar to those formerly given to the Twelve (9 1-5; ef Mt 10); a passage also found in Mt in a different connection (11 21-24) is incorporated in this dis- course, or had originally its place in it (vs 13-15). In this mission Jesus no longer made any secret of His Messianic character. The messengers were to proclaim that the kingdom of God was come nigh to them in connection with His impending visit (ver 9). The mission implies that a definite route was marked out by Jesus for Himself (cf 13 22), but this would be subject to modification according to the reception of His emissaries (vs 10.11.16). The cir- cuit need not have occupied a long time with so many engaged in it. The results show that it aroused strong interest. Later the disciples re- turned elated with their success, emphasizing their victory over the demons (ver 17). Jesus bade them rejoice rather that their names were written in heaven (ver 20). Again a passage is inserted (vs 21.22) found earlier in Mt (11 25-27; cf also vs 23.24, with Mt 13 16.17). Jesus had now passed “beyond the Jordan,” i.e. into Peraea, and vast crowds waited on His teach- ing (cf Mt 19 1f; Mk 10 1; Lk 12 1). 3. The At one place a lawyer put what he Lawyer’s meant to be a testing question, ‘What Question— shall Ido toinherit eternal life?” Jesus Parable of referred him to the great command- Good Sa- ments of love to God and one’s neigh- maritan (Lk bor, eliciting the further query, “And 10:26-37) who is my neighbor?” In reply Jesus spoke to him the immortal parable of the Good Samaritan, and asked who proved neigh- bor to him who fell among the robbers. The lawyer could give but one answer, ‘‘He that showed mercy on him.” ‘‘Go,” said Jesus, “and do thou like- wise.” The incident of Martha and Mary, which Luke inserts here (vs 38-42), comes in better later, when Jesus was nearer Bethany. At this place Luke brings together a variety of discourses, warnings and exhortations, great parts of which have already been noticed in earlier contexts. It does not follow that Lk has not, Jesus Christ in many cases, preserved the original connection. This is probably the case with the Lord’s Prayer (11 1-4), and with portions of what 4. Dis- Mt includes in the Sermon on the courses, Mount (e.g. 11 9-13.33-36; 12 22-34; Parables, cf 18 24-27 with Mt 7 13.14.22.23), and and in other discourses (e.g. 11 42-52 Miracles =Mt 23 23-36; 12 2-12=Mt 10 26- (Lk chs il 33; 12 42-48=Mt 24 45-51; 13 18- -14) ’ 21, parables of Mustard Seed and Leaven=Mt 13 31.32, ete). Of matter original to Lk in these chs may he noted such passages as that on the Friend at Midnight (11 5-8), the incident of the man who a) Original wished Jesus to hid his brother divide to Luke his inheritance with him, to whom Jesus spoke the parable of the Rich Fool (12 13-21), the parable of the Barren Fig Tree, called forth by the disposition to regard certain Gali- leans whom Pilate had slain in a tumult at the temple, and eighteen on whom the tower of Siloam had fallen, as sinners above others (13 1-9: ‘‘Nay,” said Jesus, ‘but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish”), and most of the teaching in ch 14, referred to helow. In 11 37.38, we have the mention of a Pharisee inviting Jesus to dine, and of his astonishment at the Lord’s neglect of the customary ablutions before eating. Ver 53 gives a glimpse of the fury to which the scribes and Pharisees were aroused by the severity of Christ’s denunciations. They “began to press upon him vehemently .... laying wait for him, to catch something out of his mouth.” In 13 31 ff it is told how the Pharisees sought to frighten Jesus from the district by telling Him that Herod would fain kill Him. Jesus bade them tell that ‘‘fox” that His work would go on uninterruptedly in the brief space that remained (‘‘day”’ used enigmatically) till He was “perfected” (ver 32). The woe on ders (vs 34.35) is given by Mt in the discourse in c 3 Of the miracles in this section, the casting out of the demon that was dumb (11 14 ff) is evidently the same incident as that already noted b) The in Mt 12 22ff. Two other miracles Infirm are connected with the old accusation Woman— of Sabbath hreaking. One was the the Drop- healing in a synagogue on the Sabbath sied Man day of a woman bowed down for 18 years with “a spirit of infirmity” (13 10-17); the other was the cure on the Sabbath of a man afflicted with dropsy at a feast in the house of a ruler of the Pharisees to which Jesus had been in- vited (14 1-6). The motive of the Pharisee’s invi- tation, as in most such cases, was hostile (ver 1). In both instances Jesus met the objection in the same way, by appealing to their own acts of hu- ey, to their animals on the Sabbath (13 15.16; 4 5). This feast at the Pharisee’s house had an inter- esting sequel in the discourse it led Jesus to utter against vainglory in feasting, and on c) Parable the spirit of love which would prompt of the Great to the table being spread for the help- Supper less and destitute rather than for the selfish enjoyment of the select few, closing, in answer to a pious ejaculation of one of the guests, with the parable of the Great Supper (14 7-24). The parables with its climax in the invita- tion to bring in the poor, and maimed, and blind, and those from the highways and hedges, was a commentary on the counsels He had just becn giv- ing, but it had its deeper lesson in picturing the rejection by the Jews of the invitation to the feast God had made for them in His kingdom, and the call that would be given to the Gentiles to take their place. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1652 The injunctions to the multitudes as to the sac- rifice and cross-hearing involved in discipleship are pointed by the examples of a man d) Counting building a tower, and a king going to the Cost war, who count the cost before enter- ing on their enterprises (vs 25-35). At or about this time—perhaps before the inci- dents in Lk 14—Jesus paid the visit to Jerus at the Feast of the Dedication described in 5. Martha Jn 10 22-39, This seems the fitting and Mary place for the introduction of the epi- sode of Martha and Mary which Luke narrates a little earlier (10 38-42). The “village” into which Jesus entered was no doubt Bethany (Jn 11 1). The picture given by Luke of the con- trasted dispositions of the two sisters—Martha active and “serving” (cf Jn 12 2), Mary retiring and contemplative—entirely corresponds with that in Jn. Martha busied herself with preparations for the meal; Mary sat at Jesus’ feet, and heard His word. To Martha’s complaint, as if her sister were idling, Jesus gave the memorable answer, ‘‘One thing is needful: for Mary hath chosen the good part,” etc (Lk 10 42). The Feast of the Dedication, held in December, was in commemoration of the cleansing of the temple and restoration of its worship after its 6. Feast of profanation by Antiochus Epiphanes the Dedica- (164 BC). Great excitement was oc- tion (Jn 10: casioned by the appearance of Jesus at 22-39) this feast, and some asked, “How long dost thou hold us in suspense? If thou art the Christ, tell us plainly.” Jesus said He had told them, and His works attested His claim, but they were not of His true flock, and would not believe. To His own sheep He gave eternal life. The Jews anew wished to stone Him for claiming to be God. Jesus replied that even the law called the judges of Israel “gods”? (Ps 82 6, “I said, Ye are gods, and all of you sons of the Most High”): how could it then be blasphemy for Him whom the Father had sanctified and sent into the world to say of Himself, “I am the Son of God’? The Jews sought to take Him, but He passed from their midst. i, From the Abode at Bethabara till the Raising of Lazarus.—After leaving Jerus Jesus went beyond Jordan again to the place where John at first, bap- tized (Jn 10 40; cf1 28, calledin AV “Bethahara,” in RV “Bethany,” distinct from the Bethany of ch 11). There He “abode,” implying a prolonged stay, and many resorted to Him. This spot, sacred to Jesus by His own baptism, may be regarded now as His headquarters from which excursions would be made to places in the neighborhood. Several of the incidents recorded by Luke are probably con- nected with this sojourn. The stronger the opposition of scribes and Pharisees to Jesus became, the more by natural affinity did the classes regarded as out- 1. Parahles cast feel drawn to Him. He did not of Lost repel them, as the Pharisees did, but Sheep, ate and drank with them. Publicans Lost Piece and sinners gathered to His teaching, of Silver, and He associated with them. The Prodigal murmuring was great: ‘This man re- Son (Lk 15) ceiveth sinners, and eateth with them.” The defence of Jesus was in parables, and the Pharisees’ reproach may be thanked for three of the most beautiful parables Jesus ever spoke—the Lost Sheep (cf Mt 18 12-14), the Lost Piece of Silver, and the Prodigal Son (ch 15). Why does the shepherd rejoice more over the one lost sheep brought back than over the ninety-nine that have not gone astray? Why does the woman rejoice more over the recovery of her lost drachma than over all the coins safe in her keeping? Why does the father rejoice more over the prodigal son come back 1653 in rags and penitence from the far country than over the obedient but austere brother that had never left the home? The stories were gateways into the inmost heart of God. There is joy in heaven over one sinner that repenteth more than over ninety- nine Just persons that need no repentance (ver 7). _ Two other parables, interspersed by discourses (in part again met with in other connections, cf 16 13 with Mt 6 24; ver 16 with Mt 11 2. Parables 12; ver 18 with Mt 6 32; 19 9, etc), of the were spoken at this time—that of the Unjust Unjust Steward (16 1-9) and that of Steward, the Rich Man and Lazarus (vs 19-31). the Rich The dishonest steward, about to be dis- Man and _ missed, utilized his opportunities, still Lazarus dishonestly, to make friends of his (Lk 16) master’s creditors; let the “children _ of light” better his example by right- eously using mammon to make friends for them- selves, who shall receive them into everlasting habi- tations. The rich man, pampered in luxury, let the afflicted Lazarus starve at his gate. At death—in Hades—the positions are reversed: the rich man is in torment, stripped of all he had enjoyed; the poor man is at rest in Abraham’s bosom, compensated for all he suffered. It is character, not outward estate, that determines destiny. The unmerciful are doomed. Even a messenger from the unseen world will not save men, if they hear not Moses and the prophets (ver 31). In this connection Lk (17 1-10) places exhorta- tions to the disciples on occasions of stumbling, for- giveness, the power of faith, renunciation of merit (“We are unprofitable servants”), some of which are found elsewhere (cf Mt 18 6.7.15.21, etc). While Jesus was in the trans-Jordanic Betha- bara, or Bethany, or in its neighborhood, a message came to Him from the house of Martha 3. The and Mary in the Judaean Bethany (on Summons the Mount of Olives, about 2 miles E. to Bethany from Jerus), that His friend Lazarus —Raising (“he whom thou lovest’’) was sick. of Lazarus The conduct of Jesus seemed strange, (Jn 11) for He abode still two days where He was (Jn 11 6). As the sequel showed, this was only for the end of a yet more wonderful manifestation of His power and love, to the glory of God (ver 4). Meanwhile Lazarus died, and was buried. When Jesus announced His intention of going into Judaea, the disciples sought hard to dis- suade Him (ver 8); but Jesus was not moved by the fears they suggested. He reached Bethany (a distance of between 20 and 30 miles) on the fourth day after the burial of Lazarus (ver 17), and was met on the outskirts by Martha, and afterward by Mary, both plunged in deepest sorrow. Both breathed the same plaint: “Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died” (vs 21.32). To Martha Jesus gave the pledge, ‘“Thy brother shall rise again,’”’ strengthening the faith she already had expressed in Him (ver 22) by announcing Himeelf as “the resurrection, and the life’ (vs 25.26); at Mary’s words He was deeply moved, and asked to be taken to the tomb. Here, it is recorded, “Jesus wept” (ver 35), the only other instance of His weep- ing in the Gospels being as He looked on lost Jerus (Lk 19 41). The proof of love was manifest, but some, as usual, suggested blame that this miracle- worker had not prevented His friend’s death (ver 37). Arrived at the rock-tomb, Jesus, still groan- ing in Himself, caused the stone at its mouth to be removed, and, after prayer, spoke with a loud voice, “Lazarus, come forth” (ver 43). The spirit re- turned, and the man who had been dead came forth bound with his grave-clothes. He was released and restored to his sisters. __ A Even this mighty deed did not alter the mind of the ; THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ Pharisees, who held a council, and decided, on the ad- vice of Caiaphas (ver 50), that for the safety of the nation it was “expedient” that this man should die. The circumstantiality of this beautiful narrative speaks irresistibly for its historical truth, and the objections raised by critical writers center really in their aversion to the miraculous as such. UI. From the Retirement to Ephraim till the Arrival at Bethany.—The hostility of the ruling classes was now so pronounced that, in 1. Retreat the few weeks that remained till Jesus to Ephraim should go up tothe Passover, He deemed (Jn 11:54- it advisable to abide in privacy at 57) a city called Ephraim (situation un- certain). That He was in secrecy dur- ing this period is implied in the statement (ver 57) that if anyone knew where He was, he was to inform the chief priests and Pharisees. The 2. The retirement would be for Jesus a period Journey of preparation for the ordeal before Resumed Him, as the wilderness had been for the commencement of His ministry. On His leaving this retreat to resume His advance to Jerus the narratives again become rich in incident and teaching. It is not easy to define the route which brought Jesus again to the border line between Samaria and Galilee (Lk 17 11), but, in traversing 8. Cure of this region, He was met by ten lepers, the Lepers who besought Him for a cure. Jesus (Lk 17: bade them go and show themselves to 11-19) the priests, and on the way they were cleansed. Only one of the ten, and he a Samaritan, returned to give thanks and glorify God. Gratitude appeared in the unlikely quarter. At some point in this journey the Pharisees sought to entrap Jesus on the question of divorce. Was it lawful for a man to put away his wife 4. Pharisaic for every cause? (Mt 19 3). Jesus Question- in reply admitted the permission to ings divorce given by Moses (Mk 10 3-5), but declared that this was for the hard- ness of their hearts, and went back tga the original institution of marriage in which the two so joined were declared to be “one flesh.” Only a) Divorce one cause is admissible as a ground of (Mt 19:3-— separation and remarriage (Mt 19 9; 12; Mk 10: cf 6 31.32; Mk has not even the ex- 1-12) ception, which is probably, however, implied). Comments follow to the dis- ciples in Mt on the subject of continence (vs 10-12). See Divorce. Another question asked by the Pharisees of Jesus was as to when the kingdom of God should come. The expectation excited by His own b) Coming ministry and claims was that it was of the near; when should it appear? Re- Kingdom buking their worldly ideas, Jesus (Lk 17: warned them that the kingdom did 20-37) not come “with observation’’—was not a “‘Lo, there! Lo, here!’; it was “within” them, or “in their midst,” though they did not perceive it. In the last decisive coming of the Son of Man there would be no dubiety as to His presence (vs 24.25). He adds exhortations as to the suddenness of His coming, and the separations that would ensue (vs 26-37), which Mt gives as part of the great discourse on the Last Things in ch 24, In close connection with the foregoing, as fur- nishing the ground for the certainty that this day of the Son of Man would come, Jesus c) Parable spoke the parable of the Unjust Judge. of the Un- This judge, though heedless of the just Judge claims of right, yet yielded to the (Lk 18:1-8) widow’s importunity, and granted her justice against her adversary. How much more surely will the righteous, long-suffering Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1654 God avenge His own elect, who cry unto Him day and night (vs 7.8)! Yet men, in that supreme hour, will almost have lost faith in His coming (ver 8). ee A series of sayings and incidents at this time throw light upon the spirit of the kingdom. : The spirit of self-righteousness 1s 5. The rebuked and humble penitence as the Spirit of the condition of acceptance is enforced in Kingdom the parable of the Pharisee and Pub- lican. The Pharisee posing in his self- complacency at his fastings and tithes, and thanking God for his superiority to others, is set in vivid con- trast to the abased publican, standing a) Parable afar off, and able only to say, “‘God, be of Pharisee thou merciful to me a sinner’ (ver 13). and Publi- Yet it was he who went down to his can (Lk 18: house “justified” (ver 14). 9-14) A similar lesson is inculcated in the beautiful incident of the blessing of the babes. The disciples rebuked the mothers for bringing their little ones, but Jesus, “moved with indignation’ (Mk), received and blessed b) Blessing the babes, declaring that to such (to of the them and those of like spirit) belonged Babes (Mt the kingdom of heaven. ‘Suffer the 19:13-15; little children, and forbid them not, to Mk 10:13- come unto me,” etc. 16; Lk 18: A third illustration—this time of the 15-17) peril of covetousness—is afforded by the incident of the rich young ruler. This amiable, blameless, and evidently sincere young man (‘Jesus looking upon him loved him,” Mk 10 21) knelt, and addressing c) The Rich Jesus as “Good Teacher,” asked what Young he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus Ruler (Mt first declined the term ‘“‘good,” in the 19: 16-30; easy, conventional sense in which it Mk 10: wag applied, then referred the ruler to 17-31; Lk the commandments as the standard 18:18-30) of doing. All these, however, the young man averred he had observed from his youthup. Hedid not know himself. Jesus saw the secret hold his riches had upon his soul, and revealed it by the searching word, “If thou wouldest be perfect, go, sell that which thou hast,” ete (Mt 19 21; cf Mk, ‘One thing thou lackest,” etc). This was enough. The young man could not yield up his ‘great possessions,’ and went away sorrowing. Jesus bases on his refusal earnest warnings against the love of riches, and points out, in answer to a question of Peter, that loss for His sake in this life is met with overwhelmingly great compensations in the life to come. Not unconnected with the foregoing teachings is the third solemn announcement to the disciples, so hard to be persuaded that the kingdom 6. Third was not immediately to be set up in Announce- glory, of His approaching sufferings ment of the and death, followed by resurrection. Passion The disciples had been ‘‘amazed” and (Mt 20:17— “afraid” (Mk) at something strange 19; Mk 10: in the aspect and walk of Jesus as they 32-34; Lk were on the way, going to Jerus (cf 18:31-338) Lk 951). His words gave the ex- planation. With them should be taken what is said in a succeeding incident of His baptism of suffering (Mk 10 38.39; cf Lk 12 50). The spirit of the kingdom and sacrifice for the kingdom have already been associated with the idea of reward, but the principles underlying 7. The this reward are now made the subject Rewards of of special teaching. the King- First by the parable of the Laborers dom in the Vineyard the lesson is inculcated that reward in the kingdom is not ac- cording to any legal rule, but is governed by a Di- vine equity, in accordance with which the last may often be equal to, or take precedence of, the first. The laborers were ‘hired at different a) Parable hours, yet all at the end received the of the same wage. The murmuring at the Laborers generosity of the householder of those in the Vine- who had worked longest betrayed a de- yard (Mt _fectiveness of spirit which may explain 20:1-17) why they were not more highly re- warded. In strictness, the kingdom is a gift of grace, in the sum total of its blessings one and the same to all. : Still there are distinctions of honor in God’s king- dom, but these are not arbitrarily made. This is the lesson of the reply of Jesus to the b) The plea of the mother of the sons of Zebe- Sons of dee, James and John, with, apparently, Zebedee the concurrence of the apostles them- (Mt 20:20- selves, that they might sit one on the 28; Mk 10: right hand and the other on the left 35-45) hand in His kingdom. It was a bold and ambitious request, and naturally moved the indignation of the other apostles. Still it had its ground in a certain nobility of spirit. For when Jesus asked if they were able to drink of His cup and be baptized with His baptism, they an- swered, “We are able.” Jesus told them they should share that lot of suffering, but to sit on His right hand and on His left were not favors that could be arbitrarily bestowed, but would be given to those for whom it had been prepared of His Father—the preparation having regard to character and fitness, of which the Father alone was judge. Jesus went on to rebuke the spirit which led one to seek promi- nence over another, and laid down the essential law, ‘‘Whosoever would become great among you shall be your minister,” enforcing it by His own never-to-be-forgotten example, “Even as the Son of man came not to be ministered unto, but to min- ister, and to give his life a ransom for many” (Mt 20 28; Mk 10 45). Accompanied by a great throng, possibly of pil- grims to the feast, Jesus drew near to the influential city of Jericho, in the Jordan valley, 8. Jesus at about 17 miles distant from Jerus. Jericho Here two notable incidents marked His progress. As they approached the city (Lk) (Mt and Mk place the incident as they “went out”) a blind beg- gar, Bartimaeus, hearing that ‘Jesus a) The the Nazarene” (Mk) passed by, loudly Cure of called on Him as the ‘Son of David” Bartimaeus to have mercy onhim. The multitude (Mt 20:29- would have restrained the man, but 34; Mk 10: their rebukes only made him the more 46-52; Lk urgent in his cries. Jesus stopped in 18:35-43) His way, called the blind man to Him, then, when he came, renewing his appeal, healed him. The cry of the beggar shows that the Davidic descent, if not the Messiahship, of Jesus was now known. Mt varies from the other evangelists in speaking of “two blind men,” while Mt and Mk, as noted, make the cure take place on leaving, not on entering the city. Not improbably there are two healings, one on entering Jericho, the other on going from the city, and Matthew, after his fashion, groups them together (Luke’s language is really indefinite; lit. “as they were near to Jericho”). The entrance of Jesus into Jericho was signalized by a yet more striking incident. The chief collect- or of revenue in the city was Zacchaeus, b) Zacchae- rich, but held in opprobrium (“a sin- us the Pub- ner”) because of his occupation. Being lican (Lk little of stature, Zacchaeus had climbed 19:1-10) into the branches of a sycomore tree to see Jesus as He passed. To his amazement, and that of the crowd, Jesus stopped 1655 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ on His way, and called Zacchaeus by name to hasten to come down, for that day He must abide at his house. Zacchaeus joyfully received Him, and, moved to a complete change in his views of duty, declared his purpose of giving half his goods to the poor, and of restoring fourfold anything he might have taken by false accusation. It was a revolution in the man’s soul, wrought by love. “Today,” Jesus testified, “‘is salvation come to this house. ... . For the Son of man came to seek and to save that which was lost.” The expectations of the multitude that the king- dom of God should immediately appear led Jesus to speak the parable of the Pounds, fore- c) Parable warning them that the consummation of the they looked for might be longer de- Pounds layed than they thought, and impress- (Lk 19: ing on them the need of loyalty, 11-27) faithfulness and diligence, if that day, when it came, was not to prove dis- astrous to them. The nobleman went into a “far country” to receive a kingdom, and his ten servants were to trade with as many pounds (each=100 drachmas) in his absence. On his return the faith- ful servants were rewarded in proportion to their diligence; the faithless one lost what he had; the rebellious citizens were destroyed. ‘Thus Jesus fore- shadowed the doom that would overtake those who were plotting against Him, and checked hopes that disregarded the moral conditions of honor in His kingdom. Arrival at Bethany—From Jericho Jesus moved on to Bethany, the abode of Lazarus and his sisters. To His halt here before His public entrance into Jerus the next events belong. E. THE PASSION WEEK—BETRAYAL, TRIAL AND CRUCIFIXION We reach now the closing week and last solemn events of the earthly life of Jesus. The importance attached to this part of their narra- Importance tives is seen by the space the evangel- of the Last ists devote to it. Of the Gospels of Events Mit and Mk fully one-third is devoted to the events of the Passion Week and their sequel in the resurrection; Luke has several chs; John gives half his Gospel to the same period. It is obvious that in the minds of the evangelists the crucifixion of Jesus is the pivot of their whole narrative—the dénowement to which everything tends from the first. : L. The Events Preceding the Last Supper.—The arrival in Bethany is placed by John ‘six days before the Pass- over’? (12 1). Assuming that the public 1. The entry into Jerus took place on the Sun- day, and that the 14th of Nisan fell on the Chronology foliowing Thursday, this would lead to the arrival being placed on the Friday or Saturday preceding, according to the mode of reckoning. It is in the highest degree unlikely that Jesus would jour- ney from Jericho on the Jewish Sabbath; hence He may be’supposed to have arrived on the Friday evening. The supper at which the anointing by Mary took place would be on the Saturday (Sabhath) evening. Mt and Mk con- nect it with events two days hefore the Passover (Mt 26 2; Mk 14 1), but parenthetically, in a way which leaves the other order open. ‘This beautiful deed occurred at a supper given in honor of Jesus at the house of one Simon, a leper (Mt and Mk)—probably cured by 2. The Jesus—at which Martha, Mary and Anointing Lazarus were guests. Martha aided at Bethany in serving (Jn 12 2). In the course (Mt 26:6- of the meal, or at its close, Mary 13; Mk 14; brought a costly box of nard (valued by 3-9; Jn Judas at ‘300 shillings,” about $50, or 12: 1-9) £10; cf ARVm on Jn 6 7), and with the perfume anointed the head (Mt, Mk) and feet (Jn) of Jesus, wiping His feet with her hair (Mt and Mk, though not mentioning the “feet,” speak of the “body” of Jesus). Indignation, insti- gated by Judas (Jn), was at once awakened at what was deemed wanton waste. How much better had the money been given to the poor! Jesus vindi- cated Mary in her loving act—a prophetic anoint- ing for His burial—and declared that wherever His gospel went, it would be spoken of for a memorial of her. It is the hearts from which such acts come that are the true friends of the poor. The chief priests were only the further exasperated at what was happening, and at the interest shown in Lazarus, and plotted to put Lazarus also to death (Jn 12 10). On the day following—Palm Sunday — Jesus made His public entry as Messiah into Jerus. All the evangelists narrate this event. 3. The The Mount of Olives had to be crossed Entry into from Bethany, and Jesus sent two Jerusalem disciples to an adjacent village—prob- (Mt 21:1— ably Bethphage (this seems to have 11; Mk 11: been also the name of a district)— 1-11; Lk whereanassand its colt would be found 19:29-44; tied. These they were to bring to n 12: Him, Jesus assuring them of the per- 12-19) mission of the owners. Garments were thrown over the colt, and Jesns seated Himself on it. In this humble fashion (as Mt and Jn note, in fulfilment of prophecy, Zec 9 9), He proceeded to Jerus, from which a multitude, bearing palm branches, had already come out to meet Him (Jn). Throngs accompanied Him, going before and after; these, spreading their garments, and strewing branches in the way, hailed Him with hosannas as the Son of David, the King of Israel, who came in the name of the Lord. Very different were the feelings in the breasts of the Pharisees. “Behold,” they said, “how ye prevail nothing; lo, the world is gone after him’ (Jn 12 19). They bade Jesus rebuke His disciples, but Jesus replied that if they were silent, the very stones would cry out (Lk 19°40). Jesus weeping over Jerusalem—return to Bethany. —One incident in this progress to Jerus is related only by Lk (19 41-44). As at a bend in the road Jerus became suddenly visible, Jesus paused and wept over the city, so blind to its day of visitation, and so near to its awful doom. Not His own suffer- ings, but the thought of Jerusalem’s guilt and woes, filled Him with anguish. On reaching the city, Mark’s testimony is explicit that He did no more than enter the temple, and ‘look round on all things’ (11 11). . Then eventide having come, He returned to Bethany with the Twelve. The morning of Monday found Jesus and His disciples again on their way to the city. Possibly the early hours had been spent by 4, Cursing Jesus in solitary prayer, and, as they of the Fig went, it is recorded that “he hungered.” Tree— A fig tree from which, from its foliage, Second fruit might have been expected, stood Cleansing invitingly by the wayside, but when of Temple Jesus approached it, it was found to 21:12-22; have nothing but leaves—a striking Mk 11:12-— symbol of the outwardly religious, but 26; Lk 19: spiritually barren Jewish community. 45-48) And in this sense Jesus used it in pro- nouncing on it the word of doom, “No man eat fruit from thee henceforward for ever” (Mk). Next morning (Tuesday), as the disciples passed, the tree was found withered from the roots. Mt combines the events of the cursing and the withering, placing both on thesecond day, but Mk more accurately distinguishes them. Jesus used the surprise of the disciples as the occasion of a lesson on the omnipotence of faith, with added counsels on prayer. Were there two cleansings ?—Pursuing His journey on the first morning, Jesus reached the temple, and there, as His first act, is stated by Mt and Mk to Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1656 have cleansed the temple of the traders. It is a difficult question whether this is a second cleansing, or the same act as that recorded by John at the beginning of the ministry (Jn 2 18-22; see above), and here narrated out of its chronological order. The acts are at least quite similar in character and significance. In favor of a second cleansing is the anger of the priests and scribes (Mk 11 18; Lk 19 47), and their demand next day for His authority. No other incidents are recorded of this visit to the temple, except the healing of certain blind and lame, and the praises of the children, ‘(Hosanna to the son of David’”—an echo of the previous day’s proceed- ings (Mt 21 14-16). In the evening He went back to Bethany. Far different is it with the third day of these visits of Jesus to the temple—the Tuesday of the Passion Week. This is crowded with parables, 5. The discourses, incidents, so numerous, Eventful impressive, tragical, as to oppress the Tuesday mind in seeking to grasp how one short day could embrace them all. It was the last day of the appearance of Jesus in the temple (Jn 12 36), and marks His final break with the authorities of the nation, on whom His words of denunciation (Mt 23) fell with overwhelming force. The thread of the day’s proceedings may thus be briefly traced. On His first appearance in the temple on the Tues- day morning, Jesus was met by a demand from the chief priests, scribes and elders (rep- a) The resentatives of the Sanhedrin), for the Demand for authority by which He acted as He Authority— did. Jesus met them by a counter- Parables question, “The baptism of John, was (Mt 21: it from heaven, or from men?’ The 23—22:14; dilemma was obvious. If John was Mk 11:27 Divinely accredited, why did they not —12:12; accept his testimony to Jesus? Yet Lk 20: 1-18) they feared to say his mission was of men, for John was universally esteemed aprophet. They could therefore only Jamely reply: ‘We cannot tell’ (AV). Matters had now come to an issue, and Jesus, reverting to the method of parable, set forth plainly their sin and its results to themselves and others. The Two Sons—the Marriage of the King’s Son—The parables spoken on this occasion were: that of the Two Sons, one who said “I go not,” but afterward repented and went, the other who said, “I go, sir,” but went not— pointing the moral that the publicans and _harlots went into the kingdom of God before the self-right- eous leaders who rejected the preaching of John (Mt 21 28-82); that of the Wicked Husbandmen, who slew the servants, and finally the son, sent to them, and were at length themselves destroyed, the vineyard being given to others—a prophecy of the transferring of the kingdom to the Gentiles (Mt, Mk, Lk); and that of the Marriage of the King’s Son (Mt 22 2-14), akin to that of the Great Supper in Lk 14 16-24 in its gathering in of the outcasts to take the place of those who had been bidden, but distinguished from it by the feature of the wedding garment, the lack of which meant being thrust into the outer darkness. The Pharisees easily perceived that these parables were spoken of them (Mt 21 45; Mk 12 12; Lk 20 19), and were correspond- ingly enraged, yet dared not touch Jesus for fear of the people. The attempt was next made on the part of the Pharisees, Herodians and Sadducees—now joined in a common cause—to ensnare Jesus by captious and compromising questions. These attempts He met with a wisdom and dignity which foiled His adversaries, while He showed a ready apprecia- tion of a candid spirit when it presented itself, Wicked Husbandmen—the- and turned the point against His opponents by putting a question on the Davidic sonship of the Messiah. by Ensnar- (1) Tribute to Caesar—the Resurrec- ing Ques- tion—the Great Commandment.—First tions, ete the Pharisees with the Herodians sought (Mt 22:1- to entrap Him by raising the question 46; Mk 12: of the lawfulness of tribute to Caesar. 13-37; Lk By causing them to produce a denarius 20:19-44) bearing Caesar’s image and superscrip- tion, Jesus obtained from them a recog- nition of their acceptance of Caesar’s authority, and bade them render Caesar’s things to Caesar, and God’s to God. The Sadducees next tried Him with the puzzle of the wife who had seven husbands, leading up to denial of the resurrection; but Jesus met them by showing that marriage relations have no place in the resurrection life, and by pointing to the implication of a future life in God’s word to Moses, “I am the God of Abraham,” etc. God “is not the God of the dead, but of the living,” a fact which carried with it all the weight of resurrection, as needed for the completion of the personal life. The candid scribe, who came last with His question as to which commandment was first of all, had a different reception. Jesus met Him kindly, sat~ isfied him with His answer, and pronounced him ‘not far from the kingdom of God” (Mk 12 34). (2) David's Son and Lord—The adversaries were silenced, but Jesus now put to them His own ques- tion. If David in Ps 110 could say “Jeh saith unto my lord, Sit thou on my right hand,” etc, how was this reconcilable with the Christ being David’s son? The question was based on the acceptance of the oracle as spoken by David, or one of his house, of the Messiah, and was intended to suggest the higher nature of Christ as one with God in a Divine sover- eignty. David’s son was also David’s Lord. At this point, in audience of the multitudes and of His disciples in the temple, Jesus delivered that tremendous indictment of the scribes c) The and Pharisees, with denunciations of Great De- woes upon them for their hypocrisy nunciation and iniquity of conduct, recorded most (Mt 23; fully in Mt 23. A more tremendous ME 12:38-— denunciation of a class was never 40; Lk 20: uttered. While conceding to the 45-47; cf scribes and Pharisees any authority Lk 11: they lawfully possessed (vs 2.3), Jesus specially dwelt on their divorce of ; practice from precept. They said and did not (ver 3). He denounced their perver- sion of the right, their tyranny, their ostentation, their keeping back others from the kingdom, their zeal in securing proselytes, only to make them, when gained, worse than themselves, their immoral cas- uistry, their scruples about trifles, while neglecting essentials, their exaltation of the outward at the expense of the inward, their building the tombs of the prophets, while harboring the spirit of those that killed the prophets. He declared them to be foul and corrupt to the last degree: ‘sons of Gehenna’ (vs 15.33). So awful a condition meant ripeness fordoom, On them, through that law of retribution which binds generation with generation in guilt and penalty, would come all the righteous blood shed since the days of Abel (the allusion to “Zachariah son of Barachiah,” ver 35, is unmistakably to 2 Ch 24 21—this being the last book in the Heb Canon— but “Barachiah” seems a confusion with Zec 1 1, perhaps through a copyist’s gloss or error), At the close indignation melts into tenderness in the affecting plaint over Jerus—“O Jerusalem, Jerusa- lem, . . . . how often would I have gathered thy children together,” etc (vs 37-89)—words found in Lk in an earlier context_(13 34.35), but assuredly also appropriate here. For other parts of the dis- 1657 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ course found earlier, cf Lk 11 39-52. All seems to have been gathered up afresh in this final accusa- tion. It can be imagined that the anger of the Pharisees was fierce at such words, yet they did not venture openly to touch Him. Before finally leaving the temple, Jesus seems to have passed from the outer court into the women’s court, and there to have sat down near d) The the receptacles provided for the gifts Widow’s of the worshippers. Many who were Offering wealthy cast of their gold and silver into (Mk 12:41- the treasury, but the eye of Jesus singled 44; Lk 21: out one poor widow who, creeping up, 1-4) cast in two mites (Gr leptd, the smallest of coins), which made up but a farth- ing. It was little, but it was her all, and Jesus immortalized her poor offering by declaring that, out of her want, she had given more than the wealth- jest there. Gifts were measured in His sight by the willingness that prompted them, and by the sac- rifice they entailed. It is perhaps to this crowded day, though some place it earlier in the week (on Sunday or Monday), that the incident should be referred of e) The the request of certain Greeks to see Visit of the Jesus, as related in Jn 12 20 ff. Who Greeks (Jn these Greeks were, or whence they 12:20-86) came, is unknown, but they were evi- dently proselytes to the Jewish faith, and men of asincere spirit. ‘Their request was made through Philip of Bethsaida, and Philip and An- drew conveyed it to Jesus. It is not said whether their wish was granted, but we can hardly doubt that it was. Jesus evidently saw in the incident a prelude of that glory that should accrue to Himself through all men being drawn to Him (vs 23.32). But He saw as clearly that this “glorifying” could only be through His death (vs 24.33), and He uni- versalized it into a law of His Kingdom that, as a grain of wheat must fall into the earth and die if it is to be multiplied, so only through sacrifice can any life be made truly fruitful (vs 24.25). The thought of death, however, always brought trouble to the soul of Jesus (ver 27), and a voice from the Father was given to comfort Him. The multitude thought it thundered, and failed to apprehend the meaning of the voice, or His own words about being “lifted up” (vs 29.34). Jesus had now bidden farewell to the temple. As He was going out, His disciples—or one of them f) Dis- magnificence of the buildings of the course on temple, eliciting from Him the startling Last Things reply that not one stone should be left (Mt 24; Mk upon another that should not be thrown 13; Lk 21: down. Later in the evening, when 5-36) seated on the Mount of Olives on their return journey, in view of the temple, Andrew, James and John (Mk) asked Him privately when these things should be, and what would be the signs of their fulfilment. In Mt the question is put more precisely, “When shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming [parousta], and of the end of the world?” (or “consummation of the age’). It is in answer to these complex ques- tions that Jesus spoke His great discourse on the destruction of Jerus and His final coming, some of the strands in which it is difficult now to disentangle. In the extended report in Mt 24 certain passages appear which are given elsewhere by Luke (cf ik 17 20-37). It may tend to clearness if a distinction be observed between the nearer event of the de- struction of Jerus—also in its way a coming of the Son of Man—and the more remote event of the final parousia. The former, to which vs 15-28 more specially belong, seems referred to by the “these things” in ver 34, which, it is declared, shall be ful- (Mk)—called His attention to the | filled in that generation. Of the final parousia, on the other hand, it is declared in ver 36 that “of that day and hour knoweth no one, not even the angels of heaven, neither the Son, but the Father only” (cf Mk 13 32). The difficulty occasioned by the “immediately” of ver 29 is relieved by recalling the absence of perspective and grouping of future events in all apocalyptic prophecy—the consum- mation ever rising as the background of the imme- diate experience which is its prelude. The dis- course then divides itself into a general part (vs 4-14), delineating the character of the entire period till the consummation (false Christs and prophets, wars, tribulations, apostasies, preaching of the gos- el to all nations, etc); a special part relating to the impending destruction of the city, with appropriate warnings (vs 15-28); and a closing part (vs 32-51) relating mainly to the final parousia, Bit not without reference to preceding events in the extension of Christ’s kingdom, and ingathering of His elect (vs 30.31). Warning is given of the suddenness of the coming of the Son of Man, and the need of being prepared for it (vs 37-51). The whole is a massive prophecy, resting on Christ’s consciousness that His death would be, not the defeat of His mission, but the opening up of the way to His final glorifi- cation and triumph. To this great discourse on the solemnities of the end, Jesus, still addressing His disciples, added three memorable parables of instruction and g) Parables warning (Mt 25)—the first, that of of Ten the Ten Virgins, picturing, under the Virgins, figure of virgins who went to meet the Talents bridegroom with insufficient, provision and Last of oil for their lamps, the danger of Judgment being taken unawares in waiting for (Mt 25) the Son of Man; the second, that of the Talents, akin to the parable in Lk of the Pounds (19 11-27), emphasizing the need of diligence in the Lord’s absence; the third, that of the Sheep and Goats, or Last Judgment, showing how the last division will be made according as dis- cipleship is evinced by loving deeds done to those in need on earth—such deeds being owned by Christ the King as done to Himself. Love is thus declared to be the ultimate law in Christ’s kingdom (cf 1 Cor 13); the loveless spirit is reprobated. ‘‘These shall go away into eternal punishment: but the righteous into eternal life” (ver 46). Lk 21 37.38 might suggest that Jesus taught in the temple every day till the Thursday of the Pass- over; if, however, the denunciation 6. A Day took place, as nearly all agree, on Tues- of Retire- day, an exception must be made of the ment (cf Wednesday, which Jesus probably Jn 12:36) spent in retirement in Bethany in prep- aration of spirit for His last great con- flict (others arrange differently, and put some of the preceding events in this day). The summary in Jn 12 36-43 connects the blindness of mind of the Pharisees with Isaiah’s vision (6 10), and with the prophecy of the rejected Servant (63 1). The plot for the destruction of Jesus was mean- while maturing. Two days before the Passover (Tuesday evening), Jesus forewarned 7. An At- the disciples of His approaching be- mosphere of trayal and crucifixion (Mt 26 2); and Plotting— probably at that very hour a secret Judas and meeting of the chief priests and elders the Priests was being held in the court of the house (Mt 26:1-5. of the high priest, Caiaphas (Mt), to 14-16; Mk consult as to the means of putting Him 14:1.2.10. to death. Their resolve was that it 11; Lk 22: should not be done on the feast day, 1-6) lest there should be a tumult; but the appearance of Judas, who since the anointing had seemingly meditated this step, speed- Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1658 ily changed their plans. For the paltry sum of 30 pieces of silver (shekels of the sanctuary, less than $20 or £4; the price of a slave, Ex 21 32; cf Zec 11 12), the recreant disciple, perhaps persuading himself that he was really forcing Jesus to an exer- cise of His Messianic power, agreed to betray his Lord. The covenant of infamy was made, and the traitor now ouly waited his opportunity to carry out his project. il, From the Last Supper till the Cross.—A question of admitted difficulty arises in the comparison of the Synop- tics and Jn as tothe dates of the Last Supper 1. The and of the crucifixion. The Synoptics seem 1 clearly to place the Last Supper on the Chronology evening of the 14th of Nisan (ia Jewish reckoning, the beginning of the 15th), and to identify it with the ordinary paschal meal (Mt 26 17— 19). The crucifixion then took place on the 15th. Jn, on the contrary, seems to place the supper on the day before the Passover (13 1), and the crucifixion on the 14th, when the Passover had not yet been eaten (18 28; 19 14). Many, on this ground, affirm an irreconcilable dis- crepancy between Jn and the Synoptics, some (e.g. Meyer, Farrar, less decisively Sanday) preferring Jn; others (Strauss, Baur, Schmiedel, etc) using the fact to discredit Jn. By those who accept both accounts, various modes of reconciliation are proposed. A favor- ite opinion (early_church writers; many moderns, as Godet, Westcott, Farrar) is that Jesus, in view of His death, anticipated the Passover, and ate His parting meal with His disciples on the evening of the 13th; others (e.g. Tholuck, Luthardt, Edersheim, Andrews, D. Smith), adhering to the Synoptics, take the view, here shared, that the apparent discrepancy is accounted for by a somewhat freer usage of terms in Jn. Details of the discussion must be sought in the works on the sub- ject. The case for the anticipatory view is well given in Westcott, Intro to the Study of the Gospels, 339 ff; and in Farrar, Life of Christ, Excur. X; a good statement of that for the Synoptics may be seen in Andrews, Life of Our Lord; cf Tholuck, Comm. on Jn, on 13 1; Lut- hardt, Comm. on Jn, on 13 1; 18 28; D. Smith, Days of His Flesh, App. II. The language of the Synop- tists (‘the first day of unleavened bread, when they sacrificed the passover,’ Mk 14 12) leaves no douht that they intended to identify the Last Supper with the regular Passover, and it is hardly conceivahle that they could he mistaken on so vital a point of the apostolic tradition: This also was the view of the churches of Asia Minor, where John himself latterly resided. On the other hand, the phrase to ‘‘eat the passover’’ in Jn 18 28 may very well, in John’s usage, refer to participation in the special sacrifices which formed a chief feature of the proceedings on the 15th. The allusion in Jn 13 1 need mean no more than that, the Passover now impend- ing, Jesus, loving His aaules to the end, gave them a special token of that love during the meal that ensued. The ‘ preparation of the passover” in Jn 19 14.31 most naturally refers to the preparation for the Sahbath of the Passover week, alluded to also by the Synoptics (Mt 27 62; Mk 15 42; Lk 23 54). The objections based on rabbinical regulations ahout the Sabbath are con- vincingly met by Tholuck (see also Andrews). We assume, therefore, that Our Lord ate the Passover with His disciples at the usual time—the evening of the 14th of Nisan (i.e. the beginning of the 15th). In the scene in the upper chamber, at the observ- ance of the Last Supper, we enter the holy of holies of this part of the Lord’s history. It 2. The Last is difficult, in combining the narratives, Supper (Mt to be sure of the order of all the par- 26:17-35; ticulars, but the main events are clear. Mk 14:12— They may be exhibited as follows: 31; Lk 22- On “the first day of unleavened 7-38; Ju bread’’—Thursday, 14th of Nisan— 13; cf Jesus bade two of His disciples (Lk Cor 11: names Peter and John) make the need- 23-25) ful preparations for the observance of the Passover. This included the saeri- ficing of the lamb at the temple, and the securing of a guest-chamber. Jesus bade the disciples follow aman whom they would meet bearing a) The Preparation stopped they would find one willing to receive them. The master of the house, doubtless a disciple, at once gave them “a large upper room furnished and ready” (Mk); there they made ready. Evening being come, Jesus and the Twelve assem- bled, and took their places for the meal. a pitcher, and at the house where he © from Ju 13 23 that John reclined next to Jesus (on the right), and the sequel shows that Judas and Peter were near on the other side. It b) Dispute was probably this arrangement that about gave rise to the unseemly strife for pre- Precedence cedence among the disciples narrated —Washing in Lk 22 24-30. The spirit thus dis- of the Dis- played Jesus rebuked, as He had more ciples’ Feet than once had occasion to do (cf Mk 9 >-Depart- 33-37); then (for here may he inserted ure of the beautiful incident in Jn 13 1 ff), Judas rising from the table, He gave them an amazing illustration of His own precept, “He that is chief [let him become] as he that doth serve I am in the midst of you as he that serveth” (Lk 22 26.27), in divesting Himself of His garments, girding Himself with a towel, and per- forming the act of a servant in washing His disciples’ feet. Peter’s exclamation must have expressed the feelings of all: ‘Lord, dost thou wash my feet?” The act of the Divine Master was a wonderful lesson in humility, but Jesus used it also as a parable of something higher. ‘If I wash thee not [1.e. if thou art not cleansed by the receiving of my word and spirit, which this washing symbolizes], thou hast no part with me’”’; then on Peter’s further impulsive protest, “Lord, not my feet only, but also my hands and my head,” the word: ‘He that is bathed needeth not save to wash his feet, but is clean every whit”’ (i.e. sanctification of the inner man is once for all, but there is need for cleansing from the sins of the daily walk). Resuming His place at the table, He bade them imitate the example He had just given them. Is it 1?—An ominous word had accompanied the reply to Peter, ‘“Ye are not all clean” (Jn 13 10.11). As the supper proceeded, the meaning of this was made plain. Judas, who had already sold his Master, was at the table with the rest. He had permitted Jesus to wash his feet, and remained un- moved by that surpassing act of condescending love. Jesus was “troubled in spirit,’ and now openly declared, “One of you shall betray me” (the Gr word means lit. “deliver up”: ef Lk 22 4.6,and RVm throughout). It was an astounding announcement to the disciples, and from one and another came the trembling question, ‘Lord, is it I?” Jesus answered that it was one of those dipping his hand with Him in the dish (Mk), and spoke of the woe that would overtake the betrayer (“Good - were it for that man if he had not been born’). John, at a sign from Peter, asked more definitely, “Who is it?” (Jn). Jesus said, but to John only, it was he to whom He would give a sop, and the sop was given to Judas. The traitor even yet sought to mask his treachery by the words, “Is it I, Rabbi?” and Jesus replied, though still not aloud, “Thou hast said” (Mt); then, as Satanic passion stirred the breast of Judas, He added, “What thou doest, do quickly’ y (Jn). Judas at once rose and went out— into the night (13 30). The disciples, not compre- hending his abrupt departure, thought some errand had been given him for the feast or for the poor. Jesus was relieved by his departure and spoke of the glory coming to Himself and to His Father, and | of love as the mark of true discipleship (13 31-35). The forms of the observance of the Passover by the Jews are given elsewhere (see Passover). Luke alone of the NT writers speaks of 2 c) The cups (22 17.20); in Jewish practice 4 Lord’s cups were used. The ‘Western’ text Supper D omits Lk’s 2d cup, from which some _, (ef Sanday, HDB) infer duplication, but this is not necessary. Lk’s 1st cup (ver 17) may be that with which the paschal supper opened; the 2d cup—that mentioned by all the writers— We gather | was probably the 3d Jewish cup, known as “the cup 1659 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ of blessing” (cf 1 Cor 10 16). Some, however, as Meyer, make it the 4th cup. It is implied in Mt, Mk, Jn, that by this time Judas had gone. Left thus with His own, the essentials of the paschal meal being complete, Jesus proceeded, by taking and distributing bread and wine, associating them with His body and blood, soon to be offered in death upon the cross, to institute that sacred rite in which, through all ages since (though its simplicity has often been sadly obscured) His love and sacrifice have been commemorated by His church. There are variations of phrase in the different accounts, but in the essentials of the sacramental institution there is entire agreement. Taking bread, after thanks to God, Jesus broke it, and gave it to the disciples with the words, ‘‘This is my body”; the cup, in like manner, after thanksgiving, He gave them with the words, “This is my blood of the cov- enant [in Lk and Paul, ‘‘the new covenant in my blood’’] which is poured out for many” (Mt adds, “unto remission of sins’). Lk and Paul add what is implied in the others: “This do in remembrance of me” (Lk 22 19; 1 Cor 11 24). Nothing could more plainly designate the bread and wine as holy symbols of the Lord’s body and blood, offered in death for man’s redemption, and sealing in His blood a hew covenant with God; nor, so long as the rite is observed in its Divine simplicity, as Jesus insti- tuted it, will it be possible to expunge from His death the character of a redeeming sacrifice. In touching words Jesus intimated that He would no more drink of the fruit of the vine till He drank it new with them in their Father’s Kingdom (on the doctrinal aspects, see Eucuarist; SACRAMENT; Lorp’s SupPER). The Supper was over, and parting was imminent, but Jesus did not leave the holy chamber till He had poured out. His inmost heart in those d) The Last tender, consolatory, profoundly spirit- Discourses ual addresses which the beloved disciple —Initer- has preserved for us in the 14th, 15th cessory and 16th chs of his Gospel, followed Prayer by the wonderful closing intercessory prayer of ch17. He was leaving them, but their hearts were not to be disquieted, for they would see Him again (14 18; 16 16 ff), and if, ere long, He would part with them again in visible form, it was only outwardly He would be separated from them, for He would send them the Holy Spirit, the Paraclete, who would take His place, to guide them into all truth, and bring all things to their remem- brance that He had said to them (14 16.17; 16 26; 16 7-14). If He went away, it was to prepare a place for them, and He would come again to receive them to Himself in His Father’s house (14 1-3); let them meanwhile show their love to Him by keep- ing Hig commandments (14 15.23.24). In the Spirit He Himself and the Father would dwell in the souls that loved Him (14 21-23). The intimacy of their union with Him would be like that of branches in the vine; only by abiding in Him could they bring forth fruit (16 1 ff). They would have tribulations (16 18 ff; 16 1.2), but as His dying bequest He left them His own peace (14 27); that would sustain their hearts in all trial (16 33). With many such promises did He comfort them in view of the terrible ordeal through which they were goon to pass; then, addressing His Father, He prayed for their holy keeping, and their final ad- mission to His glory (17 9-18.24). ; These solemn discourses finished, Jesus and His disciples sang a hymn (the “Hallel’”) and departed to go to the Mount of Olives. Comparing the evangelists, one would infer that the conversation in which Jesus foretold the denial of Peter at least commenced before they left the chamber (Lk 22 31 ff; Jn connects it, probably through relation of subject, with the exposure of Judas, 13 36-38); but it seems to have continued on the way (Mt, Mk). Jesus had spoken of their being e) The “offended” in Him that night. In Departure his exaltation of spirit, Peter declared and Warn- that though all should be offended in ing Him, he would never be offended. Jesus, who had already warned Peter that Satan sought to have him, that he might sift him as wheat (Lk 22 31; but “I made supplica- tion for thee,” etc), now told him that before the cock should crow, he would thrice deny Him. Peter stoutly maintained that he would die rather than be guilty of so base an act—so little did he or the others (Mt 26 35; Mk 14 31) know themselves! The enigmatic words in Lk 22 36 about taking scrip and sword point metaphorically to the need, in the times that were coming upon them, of every lawful means of provision and self-defence; the succeeding words show that “sword” is not intended to be taken literally (ver 38). Descending to the valley, Jesus and His disciples, crossing the brook Kidron (‘‘of the cedars’’), en- tered the “garden” (Jn) known as 3. Geth- Gethsemane (‘‘oil-press”), at the foot semane— of the Mount of Olives. Here took the Betrayal place the agony, which is the proper and Arrest commencement of the Passion, the (Mt 26:36- betrayal by Judas and the arrest of 66; Mk 14: Jesus. 32-52; Lk During the evening the thoughts of 22:39-53; Jesus had been occupied mainly with Jn 18:1-12) His disciples; now that the hour had come when the things predicted con- cerning Him should have fulfilment (Lk 22 37: “your hour, and the power of darkness,” ver 53), it was inevitable that mind and spirit a) Agony should concentrate on the awful bodily in the and mental sufferings that lay before Garden Him. It was not the thought of physi- cal sufferirig alone—from that also the pure and sensitive humanity of Jesus shrank with natural horror—but death to Him, the Holy One and Prince of Life, had an indescribably hateful character as a hostile power in humanity, due to the judgment of God on sin, and now descending upon Him through the workings of the vilest of human passions in the religious heads of His nation. What anguish to such an One, filled with love and the desire to save, to feel Himself rejected, betrayed, deserted, doomed to a malefactor’s cross—alone, yet not alone, for the Father was with Him! (Jn 16 32). The burden on His spirit when He reached Gethsemane was already, as the language used shows, all but unendurable—“amazed,” ‘‘sore troubled,” “My soul is exceeding sorrowful even unto death’ (Mk). There, bidding the other dis- ciples wait, He took with Him Peter, and James, and John, and withdrew into the recesses _of the garden. Leaving these also a little behind, He sank on the ground in solitary ‘‘agony” (Lk), and “with strong crying and tears” (He 5 7), poured out His soul in earnest supplication to His Father. ‘Let this cup pass away from me”’—it could not be, but thus the revulsion of His nature was expressed— “howbeit not what I will, but what thou wilt.” The passage in Lk (22 44), “His sweat became as it were great drops of blood,” etc, though omitted in certain MSS, doubtless preserves a genuine trait. Returning to the three, He found them overpowered with sleep: even the support of their wakeful sym- pathy was denied Him! ‘Watch and pray,” He gently admonished them, “that ye enter not into temptation.” A second and third time the same thing happened—wrestling with God on His part, sleep on theirs, till, with Divine strengthening (Lk 2241), victory was attained, and calm restored. Jesus Christ “Sleep on now,” He said to His disciples (the crisis is past; your help can avail no more): ‘‘Arise, let us be going” (the future has to be faced; the be- trayer is at hand. See the remarkable sermon of F. W. Robertson, II,-sermon 22). The crisis had indeed arrived. Through the dark- ness, even as Jesus spoke, was seen flashing the light of torches and lanterns, revealing a b) Betrayal mingled company of armed men— by Judas— Rom soldiers, temple officers (Jn), others—sent by the chief priests, scribes and elders, to apprehend Jesus. Their guide was Judas. It had been found impracticable to lay hands on Jesus in public, but Judas knew this retreat (Jn 18 2), and had arranged, by an act of dastardly treachery, to en- able them to effect the capture in privacy. The sign was to beakiss. With an affectation of friend- ship, only possible to one into whose heart the devil had truly entered (Lk 22 3; Jn 13 27), Judas advanced, and hailing Jesus as ““Master,”’ effusively kissed Him (Mt 26 49; Mk 14 45m). Jesus had asked, ‘‘Betrayest thou the Son of man with a kiss?” (Lk); now He said, ‘‘Friend, do that for which thou art come” (Mt). The soldiers essayed to take Jesus, but on their first approach, driven back as by a supernatural power, they fell to the ground (Jn). A proof thus given of the voluntariness of His sur- render (cf Mt 26 53: ‘Thinkest thou that I cannot beseech my Father,” etc), Jesus, remarking only on the iniquity of secret violence when every day they had opportunity to take Him in the temple, submitted to be seized and bound. At this point Peter, with characteristic impetuosity, remember- ing, perhaps, his pledge to die, if need be, with Jesus, drew a sword, and cut off the right ear of the high priest’s servant, Malchus (Jn gives the names). If he thought his deed justified by what Jesus had earlier said about “swords” (Lk 22 36.38), he was speedily undeceived by Jesus’ rebuke (Mt 26 52; Jn 18 11), and by His healing of the ear (Lk; the last miracle of Jesus before His death). How little this flicker of impulsive boldness meant is shown by the general panic that immediately followed. ‘All the disciples,” it is related, “left him, and fled’’ (Mt, Mk). Mk tells of a young man who had come upon the scene with only a linen cloth cast about his naked body, and who fied, leaving the cloth behind (14 51.52). Not improbably the young man was Mark himself. It would be about midnight when Jesus was ar- rested, and He was at once hurried to the house of Caiaphas, the high priest, where in 4. Trial expectation of the capture, a company before the of chief priests, scribes and elders— Sanhedrin members of the Sanhedrin—were al- (Mt 26:57— ready assembled. Here the first stage 76; 27:1- in the trial of Jesus took place. 10; Mk 14: 53-72; 15: The legal and constitutional questions connected with the trlal of Jesus are con- 1; Lk 22: sidered in the art. on Jesus Cunist, ARREST 54-71; Jn 42ND TritaL OF; see also Dr. Taylor Innes, %on, The Trial of Jesus Christ; on the powers 18:12-27; of the Sanhedrin, see SANHEDRIN, and cf cf Acts Schiirer, Jewish People, etc, II, 1, pp. 163 ff. 1:18.19) There seems Ilttle doubt that, while certaln judiclal forms were observed, the trial was illegal in nearly every particular. The arrest itself was arbitrary, as not founded on any formal accusation (the Sanhedrin, however, seems to have ar- rogated to itself powers of this kind; cf Acts 4 1 ff); but the night session, lack of definite charge, search for testimony, interrogation of accused, haste in condem- nation, were unquestionabiy in flagrant violation of the established rules of Jewlsh judicial procedure In such cases. It is to be remembered that the death of Jesus had already been decided on by the heads of the Sanhedrin, so that the trlal was wholly a means to a foregone conclusion. On the historlcal side, certain difficulties arise. Jn seems to make the first interrogatlon of Jesus take place before Annas, father-in-law to Caiaphas (on Annas, see below; though deposed 15 years before, he retained, in reality, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1660 all the dignity and influence of the high-priesthood; cf Lk 3 2; Acts 46); after which He is sent to Cajaphas (Jn 18 13.14.19-24), The narrative is simplified if either (1) vs 19-23 are regarded as a preliminary interrogatory by Annas till matiers were prepared for the arraignment hefore Caiaphas; or (2) ver 24 is taken as retrospective (in the sense of ‘‘had sent,”’ asin AV), and the interrogation is included in the trial by Caiaphas (cf ver 19: ‘‘the high priest’). Annas and Caiaphas may be presumed from the account of Peter's denials to have occupied the same Official residence: else Annas was present on this night to he in readiness for the trial. The frequently occurring term “chief priests’' denotes the high priests, with those who had formeriy held this rank, and members of their families (cf Schiirer, op. cit., 203 if). They formed, with the scribes, the most important element in the Sanhedrin. First Jesus was led before Annas, then by him, after a brief interview, was transferred, still bound, to Caiaphas. Annas had been de- posed, as above noticed, much earlier (15 AD), but still retained the name and through his sons and relations, as the Unjust long as he lived, exercised much of the Judgment authority of high priest. Like all those holding this high office, he and Caiaphas were Sadducees. Annas—if he is the questioner in Jn 18 19-23—asked Jesus concern- ing His disciples and His teaching. Such interroga- tion was unlawful, the duty of the accuser, in Jewish law, being to produce witnesses; properly, there- fore, Jesus referred him to His public teaching in the temple, and bade him ask those who heard Him there. An officer standing by struck Jesus with his hand for so speaking: an indignity which Jesus endured with meek remonstrance (vs 22.23). (1) An illegal session—Meanwhile a company of the Sanhedrin had assembled (23 sufficed for a quorum), and Jesus was brought before this tri- bunal, which was presided over by Caiaphas. A hurried search had been made for witnesses (this, like the night session, was illegal), but even the suborned testimony thus obtained (‘false witnesses’) was found useless for the purpose of establishing, constructively or directly, a charge of blasphemy against Jesus. At length two witnesses were pro- duced who gave a garbled version of the early saying of Jesus (Jn 2 19) about destroying the temple and rebuilding it in three days. To speak against the temple might be construed as speaking against God (cf Mt 23 16.21; Acts 6 13.14), but here too the witnesses broke down through lack of agree- ment. At all costs, however, must Jesus be con- demned: the unprecedented course therefore was taken of seeking a conviction from the mouth of the accused Himself. Rising from his seat, the high priest adjured Jesus by the living God to tell them whether He was the Christ, the Son of God (in Mk, “Son of the Blessed’’). In using this title, Caiaphas had evidently in view, as in Jn 6 18; 10 33, a claim to equality with God. The supreme moment had come, and Jesus did not falter in His reply: “Thou hast said.” Then, identifying Himself with the Son of Man in Daniel’s vision (7 13.14), He sol- emnly added, “Henceforth [from His resurrection on] ye shall see the Son of man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming on the clouds of heaven.” It was enough. Without even the pretense of in- quiry into the truth or falsehood of the claim, the high priest rent his garments, exclaiming, ‘“He hath spoken blasphemy,” and by assent of all Jesus was adjudged worthy of death. Abuse and insult fol- lowed. The minions of the Sanhedrin were per- mitted to spit on the condemned One, smite Him, blindfold and mock Him, saying, ‘Prophesy unto ~ us, thou Christ: who is he that struck thee?”’ Then, with further blows, He was led away (Mt 26 68). (2) A morning confirmation.—To give color of judicial sanction to these tumultuous and wholly irregular night proceedings, a more formal meeting of the Sanhedrin was convened as soon as day a) Before Annas and Caiaphas— 1661 had dawned (Mt 271; Mk 151; Lk 22 66-71). Probably the irregularities were held to be excused by the urgency of the occasion and the solemnities of the feast. Jesus was again brought forward; new questions were put which He declined to an- swer. Possibly a new avowal of His Messiahship was made (more probably Luke includes in this scene, the only one he records, some of the particulars of the earlier proceedings). ‘The judgment of the past night was confirmed. ; While this greatest moral tragedy of the trial and condemnation of Jesus was in process, a lesser, but still awful, tragedy in the history of a b) The soul was being enacted in the court Threefold of the same building (from this the Denial chamber in which the Sanhedrin sat was visible), in the threefold denial of his Master by the apostle Peter. Peter, who had followed ‘‘afar off” (Lk), had gained access to the court through an unnamed disciple, whom it is easy to identify with John (Jn 18 15). As he stood warming himself at a fire which had been kindled, the maid who had admitted them (Jn), gazing atten- tively at Peter, said boldly, “Thou also wast with Jesus the Galilean” (Mt 26 69). Unnerved, and affrighted by his surroundings, Peter took the readi- est mode of escape in denial. “I know him not.” His heart must have sunk within him as he framed the words, and the crowing of a cock at the moment (Mk—perhaps an hour after midnight), reminding him of his Master’s warning, completed his dis- comfiture. Guiltily he withdrew to the porch, only a little after to be accosted by another (the maid had spoken to her neighbors, Mk), with the same charge. More afraid than ever, he declared again, “T know not this man,” and, seeing he was not be- lieved, strengthened the denial with an oath. Yet a third time, an hour later, a bystander (or several, Mk), this time founding on his Galilean speech, ronounced, “Of a truth thou art one of them.’ eter, to clear himself, cursed and swore, anew dis- claiming knowledge of his Lord. To this depth had the boastful apostle fallen—as low, it might seem, as Judas! But there was a difference. As Peter spoke the cock again crew—the cockcrow which gives its form to three of the narratives (Mk alone mentions the double cockcrowing). At the game instant, either from within, or as He was being led forth, Jesus turned and looked on His erring disciple. That look—so full of pity, sorrow, re- proach—could never be forgotten! Its effect was instantaneous: ‘Peter went out, and wept bitterly.” Peter’s heartfelt repentance has its counterfoil in the remorse of Judas, which, bitter as it also was, cannot receive the nobler name. First, c) Remorse Judas sought to return the 30 shekels and Suicide paid him as the price of blood (‘I be- of Judas trayed innocent blood”); then, when callously rebuffed by the priests and elders, he flung down the accursed money in the sanctuary, and went and hanged himself. Mt and Acts seem to follow slightly divergent traditions as to his end and the purchase of the potter’s field. The underlying facts probably are that the priests applied the money, which they could not put into the treasury (Mt), to the purchase of the field, where, either before or after the purchase, Judas destroyed himself (Acts: falling and bursting asun- der), assigning ‘it as a place to bury strangers in. Its connection with Judas is attested by its name, “Akeldama,” “the field of blood.” The Jews might condemn, but they had no power to execute sentence of death (Jn 18 31). This power had been taken from them by the Romans, and was now vested in the Rom governor. The rocurator of Judaea was Pontius Pilate, a man hated by the Jews for his ruthless tyranny (see PraTE), THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ yet, as the Gospels show him, not without a sense of right, but vacillating and weak-willed in face of mob clamor, and risk to his own in- 5. Trial terests. His residence in Jerus (“Prae- before torium,” ERV “palace’’) was probably Pilate (Mt Herod’s former palace (thus Schiirer, 27:2.11- G. A. Smith, etc), on the tesselated 31; Mk 15: pavement (In 19 13) in the semicir- 1-20; Lk cular front of which was placed the 23:1-25; tribunal (béma) from which judgments Jn 18:28- were delivered. It was to_ this place 40; 19: Jesus was now brought. The events 1-16) took place when it was “early” (Jn 18 28), probably between 6 and 7 AM (cf 19 14, Rom computation). Jesus was taken within the Praetorium, but His accusers were too scrupulous about defilement at the Passover festival (Jn 18 28) to a) Attitude enter the building. Pilate therefore of the came out to hear their accusation. Accusers They would fain have had him endorse their condemnation without further inquiry, but this he would not do. They would not have it that it was a simple question of their law, yet had to justify their demand for a death sentence (ver 31). They based, therefore, on the alleged revolutionary character of Christ’s teaching, His forbidding to pay tribute to Caesar (a false charge), His claim to be a king (Lk 28 2.5), to all which charges Jesus answered not a word (Mk 16 3.5). At a later stage, after Pilate, who knew very well that no mere sedition against the Rom power had called forth all this passion (witness the choice of Barabbas), had repeatedly declared that he found no crime in Jesus (Mk 15 14; Lk 23 4.14.22; Jn 18 38; 19 4.6), the real spring of their action was laid bare: ‘‘We have a law, and by that law he ought to die, because he made himself the Son of God” (Jn 19 7). When it was seen how this declaration made Pilate only the more unwilling to yield to their rage, return was made to the politi- cal motive, now in the form of personal threat: ‘‘If thou release this man, thou art not Caesar’s friend” (ver 12). This was Pilate’s weak point, and the Jews knew it. The clamor grew ever louder, ‘‘Cru- cify him, crucify him.” Hate of Jesus and national degradation could go no farther than in the cry, “We have no king but Caesar’ (ver 15). Pilate was from the first impressed with the inno- cence of Jesus, and was sincerely anxious, as his actions showed, to save Him from the b) The terrible and ignominious death’ His Attitude of implacable enemies were bent on in- Pilate flicting upon Him. His crime was that, as Rom judge, he finally, against his own convictions, through fear of a charge of dis- loyalty to Caesar, yielded up to torture and death One whom he had pronounced guiltless, to gratify the brutal passions of a mob. By Pilate’s own ad- missions, Christ’s death was, not a punishment for any crime, but a judicial murder. First, through private examination, Pilate satisfied himself that the kingship Jesus claimed (“Thou sayest”’) carried with it no danger to the throne of Caesar. Jesus was a king indeed, but His kingdom was not of this world; was not, like earthly kingdoms, supported by violence; was founded on the truth, and gathered its subjects from those that received the truth (Jn 18 36.37). The indifference to the name of truth which the jaded mind of Pilate confessed (‘‘What is truth?’”’) could not hide from him the nobility of soul of the Holy One who stood before him. He declared publicly, “I find no fault in this man,” and thereafter sought means of saving Him, at least of shifting the responsibility of His condemnation from himself to others. : (1) Jesus sent to Herod—Hearing in the clamor Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA ‘ 1662 round the judgment seat that Jesus was a Galilean, and remembering that Herod Antipas, who had jurisdiction in that region, was in the city, Pilate’s first expedient was to send Jesus to Herod, to be examined by him (Lk 23 6-11). This act of cour- tesy had the effect of making Herod and Pilate, who had been at enmity, again friends (ver 12); otherwise it failed of its object. Herod was pleased enough to see One he had so often heard about— even thought in his flippancy that a miracle might be done by Him—but when Jesus, in presence of “that fox’? (Lk 13 32), refused to open His mouth in answer to the accusations heaped upon Him, Herod, with his soldiers, turned the matter into jest, by clothing Jesus in gorgeous apparel, and sending Him back as a mock-king to Pilate. (2) “Not this man, but Barabbas.’”’—Pilate’s next thought was to release Jesus in pursuance of a Jew- ish custom of setting free a prisoner at the feast, and to this end, having again protested that no fault had been found in Him, offered the people the choice between Jesus and a notorious robber and murderer called Barabbas, then in prison. Just then, as he sat on the judgment seat, a message from his wife regarding a dream she had (‘Have thou nothing to do with that righteous man,’ Mt 27 19) must strongly have influenced his superstitious mind. Pilate could hardly have conceived that the multi- tude would prefer a murderer to One so good and pure; but, instigated by the priests, they perpe- trated even this infamy, shouting for the release of Barabbas and the crucifixion of Jesus. (3) ‘““Hece Homo.”’—Pilate’s weakness now began to reveal itself. He proposed to ‘‘chastise” (scourge) Jesus—why “chastise,” if He was innocent?—then release Him. But this compromise, as was to be anticipated, only whetted the eagerness for blood, and the cries grew ever louder, ‘Crucify him.” Pilate, however, as if yielding to the storm, did deliver Jesus to be scourged (scourging—a fearful infliction—preceded crucifixion), the cruelty being aggravated by the maltreatment of the soldiers, who, outstripping former mockeries, put on His head a crown of thorns, arrayed Him in a purple robe, and rained blows upon His bleeding face and form. It seems to have been a design of Pilate to awake pity, for once again he brought Jesus forth, and in this affecting guise, with new attestation of His in- nocence, presented Him to the people in the words, “Behold, the man!’ (Jn 19 5). How hideous the mockery, at once to declare of such an one, “I find no crime in him,” and to exhibit Him to the crowd thus shamefully abused! No pity dwelt in these hearts, however, and the shouts became still an- grier, ‘‘Crucify him.” (4) A last appeal—Pilate yields—The words of the leaders, ‘““He made himself the Son of God,” spoken as a reason for putting Jesus to death (Jn 19 7), struck a new fear into the heart of Pilate. It led him again to enter the Praetorium, and inquire of this strange prisoner, unlike any he had ever seen, “Whence art thou?” Jesus was silent. ‘‘Knowest thou not,” asked Pilate, “that I have power to re- lease thee, and have power to crucify thee?” Jesus answered only that he, Pilate, had no power over Him at all save what was given him of God; the greater therefore was the crime of those who had subjected Him to this abuse of Divinely given power. Again Pilate went out and sought to release Him, but was met by the fierce cries that foreboded com- plaint to Caesar (Jn 19 12). A tumult seemed imminent, and Pilate succumbed. Here probably (though possibly after the choice of Barabbas) is to be placed the washing of his hands by Pilate—a vain disclaiming of his responsibility—recorded_in Mt 27 24, and the awful answer of the people, ‘‘His blood be on us, and on our children” (ver 25). Pilate now ascends the judgment seat, and, fully conscious of the iniquity of his procedure, pronounces the formal sentence which dooms Jesus to the cross. The trial over, Jesus is led again into the Praeto- rium, where the cruel mockery of the soldiers is resumed in intensified form. ‘The Holy One, thorn- crowned, clad in purple, a reed thrust into His hand, is placed at the mercy of the whole band, who bow the knee in ridicule before Him (‘“Hail, King of the Jews’), spit upon Him in contempt, smite Him on the head with the reed (Mt, Mk). Then, stripped of the robe, His own garments are put on Him, in preparation for the end. In all this hideous scene of cruelty, injustice, and undeserved suffering, the conspicuous feature in the bearing of Jesus is the absolute c) The calmness, dignity and meekness with Attitude which He endures the heaviest_ wrongs of Jesus and insults put upon Him. The pic- ture in Isa 63 7.8 is startling in its fidelity: ‘‘When he was afflicted he opened not his mouth; as a lamb that is led to the slaughter, ‘and as a sheep that before its shearers is dumb, so he opened not his mouth. By oppression and judg- ment he was taken away,” etc. There is no return of the perturbation of Gethsemane. As if the strength won there had raised Him into a peace that nothing could shake, He passed through the frightful physical exhaustion, mental strain, agony of scourging, suffering from wounds and blows, of that terrible night and morning, with unbroken fortitude and unembittered spirit. Not a word of complaint passes His lips; He makes no reply to accusations; when reviled, He reviles not again; He takes all with submission, as part of the cup the Father has given Him to drink. It is a spectacle to move the stoniest heart. Well to remember that it is the world’s sin, in which all share, that mingled the bitter draught! Hf. The Crucifixion and Burial—Crucifixion was the form of punishment reserved by the Romans for slaves, foreigners and the vilest 1. The criminals, and could not be inflicted Crucifixion ona Rom citizen. With its prolonged (Mt 27:31— and excruciating torture, it was the 66; Mk 165: most agonizing and ignominious death 20-41; Lk which the cruelty of a cruel age could 23:26-49; devise. Jewish law knew nothing of Jn 19: it (the ‘banging on a tree’ of Dt 21 22. 16-37) 23, was after death; cf Gal 3 13), yet to it the Jewish leaders hounded Pilate on to doom their Messiah. The cross was no doubt of the usual Rom shape (see Cross). The site of Golgotha, ‘‘the place of a skull’ (in Lk “Calvary,” the Latinized form), is quite uncertain. It may have been a slight mound resembling a skull (thus Meyer, Luthardt, Godet, etc), but this is not known. It is only plain that it was outside the wall, in the im- mediate vicinity of the city (see note below on sepulcher). The time of the crucifixion was about 9 AM (Mk 15 25). The day (Friday) was the preparation’ for the Sabbath of the Passover week (Mt, Mk, Lk; cf Jn 19 14.31). It was part of the torment of the victim of this horrible sentence that he had to bear his own cross (according to some only the patibu- a) On the lum, or transverse béaen' to the place Way of execution. As Jesus, staggering, possibly fainting, under this burden, passed out of the gate, a stranger coming from the country, Simon, a man of Cyrene, was laid hold of and compelled to carry the cross (such an one would not be punctilious about rabbinical rules of travel, especially as it was not the regular Sabbath). Jesus, however, was not wholly unpitied. In the crowd following Him were some women of Jerus, who be- wailed and lamented Him. The Lord, turning, 1663 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ‘BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ bade these weep, not for Him, but for themselves and for their children. ‘‘If they do these things in the green tree, what shall be done in the dry?” (Lk 23 27-31). Golgotha being reached, the crucifixion at once took place under the care of a centurion and a quaternion of soldiers. With ruthless b) Between blows, hands and feet were nailed to the Thieves the wood, then the cross was reared —the (the perpendicular part may, as some Superscrip- think, have first been placed in posi- tion—the tion). As if toemphasize, from Pilate’s Seamless point of view, the irony of the pro- Robe ceedings, two robbers were crucified ’ with Jesus, on right and left, an unde- signed fulfilment of prophecy (Isa 63 12). It was doubtless when being raised upon the cross that Jesus uttered the touching prayer—His lst word on the cross (its genuineness need not be questioned, though some ancient MSS omit)—‘‘Father, for- give them; for they know not what they do” (Lk). Above His head, according to custom, was placed a tablet with His accusation, written in three lan- guages, Heb, Gr and Lat. The chief priests took offence at the form, ‘“This is the King of the Jews,” and wished the words changed to, “He said, I am King,” etc, but Pilate curtly dismissed their com- laint: “What I have written I have written’? (Jn). hether Jesus still wore the crown of thorns is doubtful. The garments of the Crucified were di- vided among the soldiers, but for His inner garment, woven without seam, they cast lots (cf Ps 22 18). A draught of wine mingled with an opiate (gall or myrrh), intended to dull the senses, was offered, but refused. The triumph of Christ’s enemies now seemed com- plete, and their glee was correspondingly unre- strained. Their victim’s helplessness c) The was to them a disproof of His claims. Mocking— Railing, and wagging their heads, they the Peni- taunted Him, ‘If thou art the Son of tent Thief God, come down from the’cross”’; ‘‘He —Jesus saved others; himself he cannot save.” and His At first the robbers who were crucified Mother with Him (possibly only one) joined in this reproach, but ere long there was a change. The breast of one of the malefactors opened to the impression of the holiness and mceek- ness of Jesus, and faith took the place ofscorn. He rebuked his neighbor for reviling One who had “‘done nothing amiss”; then, addressing Jesus, he prayed: “Jesus, remember me when thou_comest in thy kingdom.” The reply of Jesus—His 2d word on the cross—surpassed what even the penitent in these strange circumstances could have anticipated, ‘“To- day shalt thou be with me in Paradise” (Lk). A not less touching incident followed—perhaps pre- ceded—this rescue of a soul in its last extremity. Standing near the cross was a group of holy women, one of them the mother of Jesus Himself (Jn 19 25: Mary the mother of Jesus, Mary’s sister, Mary the wife of Clopas—some identify the two latter—Mary Magdalene). Mary, whose anguish of spirit may be imagined, was supported by the disciple John. Beholding them—His 3d word from the cross-—Jesus tenderly commended His mother to the care of John; to Mary, “Woman, behold, thy son”; to Jobn, “Behold, thy mother.” From that time Mary dwelt with John. : Three hours passed, and at noon mocking was hushed in presence of a startling natural change. The sun’s light failed (Lk), and a deep darkness, lasting for 8 hours, settled over theland. The dark- ness was preternatural in its time and occasion, whatever natural agencies may have been con- cerned in it. The earthquake a little later (Mt) would be due to the same causes. It was as if Nature veiled itself, and shuddered at the enormity of the crime which was being perpetrated. But the outer gloom was only the symbol of a yet d) The more awful darkness that, toward the Great close of this period, overspread the soul Darkness— of Jesus Himself. Who shal] fathom the the Cry of depths of agony that lay in that awful Desertion cry—the 4th from the cross—that burst p loudly from the lips of Jesus, “li, Eli, lama sabachthant”—“My God, My God, why hast thou forsaken me’ (or, “Why didst thou for- sake me?”’)—words borrowed from Ps 22 1! It was before remarked that death was not a natural event to Jesus, but ever had in it to His mind its signifi- cance as a judgment of God on sin. Here it was not simply death that He experienced in its most. cruel form, but death bereft of the sensible comforts of the Father’s presence. What. explanation of that mystery can be found which does not take into account with Isa 53 (cf Jn 1 29) His character as Sin-Bearer, even as the unbroken trust with which in His loneliness He clings to God (“My God’’) may be felt to have in it the element of atonement? On this, however, the present is not the place to dwell. The end was now very near. The victim of crucifixion sometimes lingered on in his agony for days; but the unexampled strain of e) Last body and mind which Jesus had under- Words and gone since the preceding day brought Death of an earlier termination to His suffer- Jesus ings. Light was returning, and with it peace; and in the consciousness that all things were now finished (Jn 19 28), Jesus spoke again—the 5th word—“I thirst” (Jn). A sponge filled with vinegar was raised on a reed to His lips, while some who had heard His earlier words (“Eli, Eli,” etc), and thought He called for Elijah, said, “Let us see whether Elijah cometh to save him” (Mt). With a last effort, Jesus cried aloud—6th and memorable word—‘It is finished,’ then, in a final utterance—the 7th—commended His spirit to God: “Father into thy hands I commend my spirit” (Lk). Following on this word, bowing His head, He surrendered Himself to death. It will be seen that of the 7 words spoken from the cross, 3 are preserved by Lk alone (1st, 2d, 7th), 3 by Jn alone (8d, 5th, 6th), while the 4th ery (“#li, Eli,” etc) occurs only in the first 2 evangelists (Mt and Mk, however, speak of Jesus ‘crying with a loud voice’’ at, the close). Jesus had died; the malefactors still lived. It was now 8 o’clock in the afternoon, and it was de- sired that the bodies should not remain f) The. upon the cross on the approaching Spear- Sabbath. Permission was therefore Thrust— obtained from Pilate for the soldiers Earthquake to break the legs of the crucified (cruri- and Rend- fragium), and so hasten death. When ing of the it was discovered that Jesus was Veil already dead, a soldier, possibly to make sure, pierced His side with a spear, and John, who was present, notices as a spe- cial fact that “there came out, blood and water” (19 34). Whether this means, as Stroud and others have contended, that Jesus literally died of rupture of the heart, or what other physiological explana- tion may be given of the phenomenon, to which the apostle elsewhere attaches a symbolical significance (1 Jn 5 6), need not be here discussed (see BLoop AND WarTeR). This, however, was not the only startling and symbolically significant fact attend- ing the death of Jesus. A great darkness had pre- luded the death; now, at the hour of His expiry, the veil of the temple (i.e. of the inner shrine) was rent from top to bottom—surely a sign that the way into the holiest of all was now opened for mankind Jesus Christ (He 9 8.12)—and a great earthquake shook the city and rent the rocks. Mt connects with this the statement that from the tombs thus opened “many bodies of the saints . .. . were raised; and coming forth out of the tombs after his resurrection they entered into the holy city and appeared unto many” (27 52.53). There is nothing in itself improbable, though none of the other evangelists mention it, in such an early demonstration being given of what the Lord’s death and resurrection meant for be- lievers. In other ways the power of the cross was revealed. A dying robber had been won to penitence; now the centurion who commanded the soldiers was brought to the avowal, “Truly this was the Son of God” (Mt, Mk; in Lk, “a righteous man”). The mood of the crowd, too, was changed since the morning; they “returned, smiting their breasts’ (Lk 23 48). “Afar off,’ speechless with sorrow, stood the women who had followed Jesus from Galilee, with other friends and disciples. The evangelists name Mary Magda- lene, Mary, the mother of James and Joses, Salome (Mk), and Joanna, the wife of Chuza, Herod’s steward (Lk). Jesus had conquered hearts on His cross; now His death reveals friends from the wealthier classes, hitherto kept back by fear (Jn 19 2. The 38.39), who charge themselves with Burial (Mt His honorable burial. One was Joseph 27:57-66; of Arimathaea, a just man, “looking cf 28:11- for the kingdom of God,” of whom the 15; Mk 165: interesting fact is recorded that, 42-47; Lk though a member of the Sanhedrin, 23: 60-56; “he had not consented to their coun- Jn 19: sel and deed” (Lk); the other was 38-42) Nicodemus, he alo came to Jesus by night (Jn 3 1.2; 19 39), mentioned again only in Jn 7 50-52, where, also as a member of the Sanhedrin, he puts in a word for Jesus. Joseph of Arimathaea takes the lead. “Having dared,” as Mk says (15 43, Gr), he begged the body of Jesus from Pilate, and having ob- a) The tained it, bought linen cloth wherein New Tomb to wrap it, and reverently buried it in a new rock-tomb of his own (Mt, Mk), ‘where never man had yet lain’ (Lk). Jn furnishes the further particulars that the tomb was in a “garden,” near where Jesus was crucified (19 41.42). He tells also of the munificence of Nico- demus, who brought as much as 100 pounds (about 75 lbs. avoir.) of spices—“‘a mixture of myrrh and aloes” (ver 39), with which to enwrap the body of Jesus. This is not to be thought of as an “anoint- ing’: rather, the spices formed a powder strewn between the folds of the linen bandages (cf Lut- hardt, Comm. on Jn 19 40). The body, thus pre- pared, was then placed in the tomb, and a great stone rolled to the entrance. The burial was of necessity a very hurried one, which the holy women who witnessed it—Mary Magdalene and Mary the mother of Joses are specially mentioned (Mt, Mk) —purposed to supplement by an anointing when the Sabbath was past (cf Lk 23 56). Though Jesus was dead, the chief priests and Pharisees were far from easy in their minds about Him. Mysterious words of His had b) The been quoted about His building of the Guard of | temple in three days; possibly Judas Soldiers had told something about His sayings (Mt) regarding His death and rising again on the 3d day; in any case, His body was in the hands of His disciples, and they might remove it, and create the persuasion that He had risen. With this plea they went to Pilate, and asked from him a watch of soldiers to guard the tomb. To make assurance doubly sure, they sealed the tomb with the official seal. The result of their efforts THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1664 was only, under Providence, to provide new evi- dence of the reality of the resurrection! The uncertainty attaching to the site of Golgotha attaches also to the site of Joseph’s rock-tomb. Opinion is about equally divided in favor of, and against, the traditional site, where the Church of the Holy Sepulchre now stands. A principal ground of uncertainty is whether that site originally lay within or without the second wall of the city (cf Stanley, Sinai and Pal, 457 ff; G. A. Smith, Jerus, II, 576; a good conspectus of the different opinions, with the authorities, is given in Andrews, Part VII). F. THE RESURRECTION AND ASCENSION The resurrection of Jesus, with its completion in the ascension, setting the seal of the Father’s accept- ance on His finished work on earth, The Resur- and marking the decisive change from rectiona His state of humiliation to that of Funda- exaltation, may be called in a true mental Fact sense the corner stone of Christianity (cf 1 Cor 15 14.17). It was on the preaching of Christ crucified and risen that the Christian church was founded (e.g. Acts 2 32-36; 1 Cor 15 3.4). Professor Harnack would dis- tinguish between “the Easter faith’ (that Jesus lives with God) and ‘‘the Easter message,’”’ but the church never had any Easter faith apart from the Easter message. The subversion of the fact of the resurrection is therefore a first task to which unbe- lief addresses itself. ‘The modern spirit rules it out a priori as miraculous. The historical fact is de- nied, and innumerable theories (imposture, theories of swoon, of hallucination, mythical theories, spirit- ualistic theories, etc) are invented to explain the belief. None of these theories can stand calm examination (see the writer’s work, The Resurrec- tion of Jesus). The objections are but small dust of the balance compared with the strength of the evidence for the fact. From the standpoint of faith, the resurrection of Jesus is the most credible of events. If Jesus was indeed such an One as the gospel history declares Him to be, it was impossible that death should hold Him (Acts 2 24). The resurrection, in turn, confirms His claim to be the Son of God (Rom 1 4). With the narratives of the resurrection are here included, as inseparably connected, those of the appearances of Jesus in Jerus and 1. The Galilee. The accounts will show that, Resurrec- while the body of Jesus was a true body, tion (Mt identical with that which suffered on 28; Mk 16; the cross (it could be seen, touched, Lk 24; Jn handled), it exhibited attributes which 20,21; 1 showed that Jesus had entered, even Cor 15:3-8) bodily, on a new phase of existence, ata in which some at least of the ordinary limitations of body were transcended. Its condi- tion in the interval between the resurrection and the ascension was an intermediate one—no longer simply natural, yet not fully entered into the state of glorification. “I am not yet ascended .... I ascend” (Jn 20 17); in these two parts of the one saying the mystery of the resurrection body is comprised. The main facts in the resurrection narratives stand out clearly. ‘According to all the Gospels,”’ the arch-skeptic Strauss concedes, a) The “Jesus, after having been buried on the Easter Friday evening, and lain during the Morning— Sabbath in the grave, came out of it the Open restored to life at daybreak on Sun- Tomb day” (New Life of Jesus, I, 897, ET). ; Discrepancies are alleged in detail as to the time, number, and names of the women, num- ber of angels, etc; but most of these vanish on careful examination. The Synoptics group their material, while Jn gives a more detailed account of particular events. 1665 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ (1) The angel and the keepers.—No eye beheld the actual resurrection, which took place in the early morning, while it was still dark. Mt records that there was “a great earthquake,” and tells of the descent of an angel of the Lord, who rolled away the stone, and sat upon it. Before his dazzling aspect the keepers became as dead men, and after- ward fled. The chief priests bribed them to conceal the facts, and say the body had been stolen (Mt 28 2-4,11-15). (2) Visit of the women —The first intimation of the resurrection to the disciples was the discovery of the empty tomb by the women who had come at early dawn (Mt 28 1; Mk 162; Lk 241; Jn 20 1) with spices, prepared to anoint the body of Jesus (Mk 16 1; cf Lk 23 56). Apparently ig- norant of the guard, the women were concerned on their way as to who should roll away the stone from the door of the tomb (Mk 16 3), and were much surprised to find the stone rolled away, and the tomb open. There is no need for supposing that the women mentioned all came together. It is much more probable that they came in different groups or companies— perhaps Mary Magdalene and the other Mary, or these with Salome, first (Mt, Mk; ef the “we” of Jn 20 2); then Joanna and other members of the Galilean band (Lk). (On the appearance of Jesus to Mary, see below.) (8) The angelic message. — As the women stood, perplexed and affrighted, at the tomb, they received @ vision of angels (Mt and Mk speak only of one angel; Lk and Jn mention two; all allude to the dazzling brightness), who announced to them that Jesus had risen (‘‘He is not here; for he is risen; . . . « come, see the place where the Lord lay’’), and bade them tell His disciples that He went before them to Galilee, where they should see Him (Mt, Mk; Lk, who does not record the Galilean appear- ances, omits this part, and recalls the words spoken by Jesus in Galilee, concerning His death and re- surrection; ef Mt 16 21). The women departed with “trembling and astonishment” (Mk), yet “with great joy’? (Mt). Here the original Mk breaks off (ver 8), the remaining vs being an ap- pendix. But it is granted that Mk must originally have contained an account of the report to the dis- ciples, and of an appearance of Jesus in Galilee. The narrative in Jn enlarges in important respects those of the Synoptics. From it we learn that Mary Magdalene (no companion is named, b) Visit of but one at least is implied in the “we” Peter and of ver 2), concluding from the empty John— tomb that the body of Jesus had been Appearance removed, at once ran to carry the news to Mary to Peter.and John (“They have taken (Jn; cf Mk away the Lord out of the tomb, and 16:9.10; we know not where they have laid Lk 24: him”). These apostles lost no time 12.24) in hastening to the spot. John, who arrived first, stooping down, saw the linen cloths lying, while Peter, entering, beheld also the napkin for the head rolled up in a place by itself. After John likewise had entered (‘He saw, and be- lieved’’), they returned to their home. Meanwhile Mary had come back disconsolate to the tomb, where, looking in, she, like the other women, had a vision of two angels. Jt was then that Jesus ad- dressed her, ‘‘Why weepest thou?” At first she thought it was the gardener, but on Jesus tenderly naming her, ‘‘Mary,”’ she recognized who it was, and, with the exclamation, ‘‘Rabboni” (‘Teacher’), would have clasped Him, but He forbade: ‘“Touch me not,” ete (ver 17, m “Take not hold on me”), ie. “Do not wait, but hasten to tell my disciples that I am risen, and ascend to my Father’’ (the ascension-life had already begun, altering earlier relations). Report to the disciples—incredulity The appear- ance of Jesus to the other women (Mt 28 9.10) is referred to below. It is probable that, on the way back, Mary Magdalene rejoined her sisters, and that the errand to the disciples—or such of them as could be found—was undertaken together. Their report was received with incredulity (Lk 24 11; ef Mk 16 11). The visit of Peter referred to in mek 12 is doubtless that recorded more precisely in Jn, Ten appearances of Jesus altogether after His resurrection are recorded, or are referred to; of these five were on the day of resurrec- c) Other tion. They are the following: Easter-Day (1) The first is the appearance to Appear- Mary Magdalene above described. ances (2) The second is an appearance to (Emmaus, the women as they returned from the Jerusalem) tomb, recorded in Mt 28 9.10. Jesus met them, saying, “All hail,” and as they took hold of His feet and worshipped Him, He renewed the commission they had received for the disciples. Some regard this as only a general- ization of the appearance to Mary Magdalene, but it seems distinct. (3) An appearance to Peter, attested by both Lk (24 34) and Paul (1 Cor 15 5). This must have been early in the day, probably soon after Peter’s visit to the tomb. No particulars are given of this interview, so marked an act of grace of the risen Lord to His repentant apostle. The news of it occasioned much excitement among the disciples (Lk 24 34). (4) The fourth was an appearance to two disci- ples on their way from Jerus to Emmaus—a village about two hours distant (Lk 24 12-35; Mk 16 12.13). They were conversing on the sad events of the last few days, and on the strange tidings of the women’s vision of angels, when Jesus overtook them, and entered into conversation with them. At first they did not recognize Him—a token, as in Mary’s case, of change in His appearance—though their hearts burned within them as He opened to them the Scriptures about Christ’s suffermgs and glory. As the day was closing, Jesus abode with them to the evening meal; then, as He blessed and brake the bread, ““Their eyes were opened, and they knew him; and he vanished out of their sight”? (Lk 24 30.31). They hastily rose, and returned to the corapany of disciples at Jerus. According to Mk 16 13, their testimony, like that of the women, was not at first believed. (5) The fifth appearance was that to ‘‘the eleven,” with others, in the evening—an appearance recorded by Luke (24 36 ff), and John (20 19-23), and al- luded to by Paul (1 Cor 15 5). The disciples from Emmaus had just come in, and found the company thrilling with excitement at the news that the Lord had appeared to Simon (Lk). The doors were closed for fear of the Jews, when suddenly Jesus appeared in their midst with the salutation, ‘Peace be unto you” (Lk, Jn; doubt is unnecessarily cast on Lk 24 36.40, by their absence from some West- em texts). The disciples were affrighted; they thought they had seen a spirit (Lk); ‘“disbelieved for joy” (Lk 24 41). To remove their fears, Jesus showed them His hands and His feet (in Jn, His side), and ate before them (Lk). He then breathed on them, saying, ‘“‘Receive ye the Holy Spirit,” and renewed the commission formerly given to remit and retain sins (Jn; cf Mt 18 17.18). The breath- ing was anticipative of the later affusion of the Spirit at Pentecost (cf Jn 7 39; Acts 2); the authority delegated depends for its validity on the possession of that Spirit, and its exercise according to the mind of Christ (cf eg. 1 Cor 5 3). The incident strikingly illustrates at once the reality of Jesus Christ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1666 Christ’s risen body, and the changed conditions under which that body now existed. Eight days after this first appearance—i.e. the next Sunday evening—a second appearance of Jesus to the apostles took place in the same d) The chamber and under like conditions Second (“the doors being shut’’). The pecul- Appearance iar feature of this second meeting was to the the removal of the doubt of Thomas Eleven— who, it is related, had not been present the Doubt on the former occasion. Thomas, of Thomas devoted (cf Jn 11 16), but of naturally questioning temperament (14 5), re- fused to believe on the mere report of others that the Lord had risen, and demanded indubitable sensible evidence for himself. Jesus, at the second appearance, after salutation as before, graciously gave. the doubting apostle the evidence he asked: “Reach hither thy finger, and see my hands,” ete (Jn 20 27), though, as the event proved, the sign was not needed. The faith and love of the erst- while doubter leaped forth at once in adoring con- fession: ‘My Lord and my God.” It was well; but Jesus reminded him that the highest faith is not that which waits on the evidence of sense (“Blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed,” ver 29). The scene now shifts for the time to Galilee. Jesus had appointed to meet with His disciples in Galilee (Mt 26 32; Mk167; cf e) The Mk 14 28). Prior, however, to this Galilean meeting—that recorded in Mt 28 16- Appear- 20, probably to be identified with the ances appearance “to above five hundred brethren at once,’? mentioned by Paul (1 Cor 15 6)—there is another appearance of Jesus to seven disciples at the Lake of Galilee, of which the story is preserved in Jn 21 1-23. (1) At the Sea of Tiberias—the draught of fishes— Peter's restoration—The chapter which narrates this appearance of Jesus at the Lake of Galilee (‘Sea of Tiberias”) is a supplement to the Gospel, but is so evidently Johannine in character that it may safely be accepted as from the pen of the beloved disciple (thus Lightfoot, Meyer, Godet, Alford, etc). The appearance itself 1s described as the third to the disciples (ver 14), i.e. the third to the apostles collectively, and in Jn’s record seven disciples are stated to have been present, of whom five are named—Peter, Thomas, Nathanael (probably to be identified with Bartholomew), and the sons of Zebedee, James and John. The disciples had spent the night in fishing without result. In the morning Jesus—yet unrecognized—appeared on the beach, and bade them cast down their net on the right side of the boat. The draught of fishes which they took revealed to John the presence of the Master. “It is the Lord,” he said to Peter, who at once flung himself into the lake to go to Jesus. On landing, the disciples found a fire of coals, with fish placed on it, and bread; and Jesus Himself, after more fish had been brought, distributed the food, and, it seems implied, Himself shared in the meal. Still a certain awe—another indication of a mysterious change in Christ’s appearance—restrained the dis- ciples from asking openly, ‘Who art thou?” (ver 12). It was not long, however (‘‘when they had broken their fast’’), before Jesus sufficiently dis- closed Himself in the touching episode of the res- toration of Peter (the three-fold question, ‘“Lovest thou me?” answering to the three-fold denial, met by Peter’s heartfelt, “Yea, Lord; thou knowest that I love thee,” with the words of reinstatement, “Feed my lambs,” ‘‘Feed my sheep”). In another way, Jesus foretold that Peter would have the oppor- tunity of taking back his denial in the death by which he should glorify God (vs 18.19; tradition says he was crucified head-downward). Curious inquiries were set aside, and attention recalled to duty, ‘Follow thou me” (ver 22). ee (2) On the mountain—the Great Commission— baptism.—Though only the eleven apostles are named in Matthew’s account (28 16), the fact of an ‘appointment’ for a definite time and place (“the mountain”), and the terms in which the mes- sage was given to the “disciples,” suggests a collect- ive gathering such as is implied in Paul’s “above five hundred brethren at once” (1 Cor 15 6). The company being assembled, Jesus appeared; till, at first, with that element of mystery in His appear- ance, which led some to doubt (ver 17). Such doubt would speedily vanish when the Lord, aunonneiny Himself as clothed with all authority in heaven an earth, gave to the apostles the supreme commission to “make disciples of all the nations’ (vs 18-20; ef Mk 16 15, “Go ye into all the world,” etc). Discipleship was to be shown by baptism “into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (one name, yet threefold), and was to_be followed by instruction in Christ’s commands. Be- hind the commission, world-wide in its scope, and binding on every age, stands the word of never- failing encouragement, ‘Lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world.” Doubts of the genuineness of these august utterances go as a rule with doubt of the resurrection itself. Jt will be noticed that the Lord’s Supper and Baptism are the only sacraments instituted by Jesus in His church. Paul records, as subsequent to the above, an ap- pearance of Jesus to James, known as “‘the Lord’s brother” (1 Cor 15 7; ef Gal 1 19). No particulars are given of this appear- ance, which may have occurred either in Galilee or Jerus. James, so far as known, was not a believer in Jesus before the crucifixion (cf Jn 7 3); after the ascen- sion he and the other brethren of Jesus are found in the company of the disciples (Acts 1 14), and he became afterward a chief ‘‘pillar” of the church at Jerus (Gal 1 19; 2 9). This appearance may have marked the turning-point. The final appearance of Jesus to the apostles (1 Cor 15 7) is that which Luke in the closing verses of his Gospel (44-53), and in f) Appear- ance to James g) The Acts 1 3-12, brings into direct rela- Last tion with the ascension. In the Gos- Meeting pel Luke proceeds without a break from the first appearance of Jesus to “the eleven” to His last words about “‘the promise of my Father’; but Acts 1 shows that a period of 40 days really elapsed during which Jesus repeatedly “appeared” to those whom He had chosen. This last meeting of Jesus with His apostles was mainly occupied with the Lord’s exposition of the pro- phetic Scriptures (Lk 24 44-46), with renewed commands to preach repentance and remission of sins in His name, “beginning from Jerus” (vs 47. 48; cf Acts 1 8), and with the injunction to tarry in Jerus till the Spirit should be given (ver 49; ef Acts 14.5). Then He led them forth to Olivet, ‘over against Bethany,” and, while blessing them, ‘‘was carried up into heaven’ (vs 50.51; cf Acts 1 10.12). Jesus had declared, ‘‘I ascend unto my Father” (Jn 20 17), and Luke in Acts 1 narrates the cir- cumstances of that departure. Jesus 2. The might simply have ‘‘vanished” from Ascension the sight of His disciples, as on pre- (Lk 24:60- vious occasions, but it was His will to 53; Acts 1: leave them in a way which would vis- 6-14; cf Mk ibly mark the final close of His asso- 16:19) ciation with them. They are found, ; as in the Gospel, “assembled” with Him at Jerus, where His final instructions are given. 1667 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ Then the scene insensibly changes to Olivet, where the ascension is located (Acts 112). The disciples inquire regarding the restoration of the kingdom to Israel (even yet their minds are held in these tem- poral conceptions), but Jesus tells them that it is not for them to know times and seasons, which the Father had set within His own authority (ver 7). Far more important was it for them to know that within the next days they should receive power from the Holy Spirit to be witnesses for Him to the utter- most part of the earth (ver 8). Even as He spake, He was taken up, and a cloud received Him out of their sight (ver 9). Then, as the apostles stood gazing upward, two heavenly messengers appeared, who comforted them with the assurance that in like manner as they had seen Jesus ascend into heaven, so also would He come again. For that return the church still prays and waits (cf Rev 22 20). See, further, ASCENSION. Retracing their steps to Jerus, the apostles joined the larger company of disciples in the ‘“‘upper room” where their meetings seem to have been habitually held, and there, with one accord, to the number of about 120 (Acts 1 15), they all continued sted- fastly in prayer till “the promise of the Father’’ (Lk 24 49; Acts 1 4) was, at Pentecost, hestowed npon them. Part IV. Epinocue: THe Arostotic TEACHING The earthly life of Jesus is finished. With His res- urrection and ascension a new age begins. Yet the work of Christ continues. As Luke 1. After the expressively phrases it in Acts 1 1.2, Ascension the Gospels are but the records of “all that, Jesus began both to do and to teach, until the day in which he was received np.” It is beyond the scope of this art. to trace the suc- ceeding developments of Christ’s activity through His church and by His Spirit; in order, however, to bring the subject to a proper close, it is necessary to glance, even if briefly, at the light thrown back by the Spirit’s teachings, after the ascension, on the significance of the earthly life itself, and at the en- largement of the apostles’ conceptions about Christ, consequent on this, as seen in the Epistles and the Apocalypse. It was the promise of Jesus that, after His de- parture, the Spirit would be given to His disciples, to teach them all things, and bring to 2. Revela- their remembrance all that He had tion through said to them (Jn 14 26). It was not the Spirit a new revelation they were to receive, but illumination and guidance of their minds into the meaning of what they had received already (Jn 16 13-15). This promise of the Spirit was fulfilled at Pentecost (Acts 2). Only a few personal manifestations of Jesus (Acts 7 55.56; 22 17.18; 28 11) are recorded after that. event—the two chief being the appearance to Paul on the way to Damascus (1 Cor 15 8; cf Acts 9 3 ff, etc), and the appearance in vision to John in Patmos (Rev 1 10 ff). The rest was internal revelation (cf Gal 1 12.16; Eph 1 17; 3 3-5). The immense advance in enlargement and clearness of view—aided, no doubt, by Christ’s parting instructions (Lk 24 44- 48; Acts 1 2)—is already apparent in Peter’s discourses at Pentecost; but it is not to be supposed that much room was not left for after-growth in knowledge, and deepened insight into the connec- tion of truths. Peter, e.g., had to be instructed as to the admission of the Gentiles (Acts 10 11); the apostles had much gradually to learn as to the relations of the law (cf Acts 15; 21 20 ff; Gal 2, etc); Panl received revelations vastly widen- ing the doctrinal horizon; both John and Paul show progressive apprehension in the truth about Christ. It is therefore a question of much interest how the apostolic conceptions thus gained stand related to the picture of Jesus we have been 3. Gospels studying in the Gospels. It is the con- and Epistles tention of the so-called “historical” (anti-supernaturalistic) school of the day that the two pictures do not correspond. The transcendental Christ of Paul and John has little in common, it is affirmed, with the Man of Nazareth of the Synoptic Gospels. Theories of the “origins of Christianity” are concocted proceeding on this assumption (cf Pfleiderer, Weizsicker, Bousset, Wernle, etc). Such speculations ignore the first conditions of the problem in not accepting the self- testimony of Jesus as to who He was, and the ends of His mission into the world. When Jesus is taken at His own valuation, and the great fact of His resurrection is admitted, the alleged contradictions between the “‘Jesus of history’’ and the ‘Christ of faith” largely disappear. It is forgotten how great a change in the center of gravity in the conception of Christ’s person and work was necessarily involved in the 4. Fact of facts of Christ’s death, resurrection and Christ’s exaltation to the right hand of power. Lordship The life is not ignored—far from it. Its influence breathes in every page, e.g. of Paul’s epistles. But the weakness, the limi- tations, the self-suppression—what Paulin Phil 2 7 calls the ‘“emptying’’—of that earthly life have now been left behind; the rejected and crucified One has now been vindicated, exalted, has entered into His glory. This is the burden of Peter’s first ad- dress at Pentecost: ‘God hath made him both Lord and Christ, this Jesus whom ye crucified” (Acts 2 86). Could anything look quite the same after that? The change is seen in the growing substitu- tion of the name ‘“Christ’’ for “Jesus” tee at be- ginning of art.), and in the habitual speaking of Jesus as “Lord.” With belief in the lordship of Jesus went neces- sarily an enlarged conception of the significance of His person. The elements were all 5. Signifi- there in what the disciples had seen cance of and known of Jesus while on earth Christ's (In 114; 1 Jn 1 1-3), but His ex- Person altation not only threw back light upon His claims while on earth—confirmed, interpreted, completed them—but likewise showed the ultimate ground of these claims in the full Di- vine dignity of His person. He who was raised to the throne of Divine dominion; who was worshipped with honors due to God only; who was joined, with Father and with Holy Spirit as, codrdinately, the source of grace and blessing, must in the fullest sense be Divine. There is not such a thing as honorary Godhead. In this is already contained in substance everything taught about Jesus in the epistles: His preéxistence (the Lord’s own words had suggested this, Jn 8 58; 17 5, etc), His share in Divine attri- butes (eternity, etc), in Divine works (creation, ete, 1 Cor 8 6; Col 1 16.17; He 1 2; Rev 1 8; 3 14, etc), in Divine worship (Phil 2 9-11; Rev 6 11.12, etc), in Divine names and titles (He 1 8, etc). It is an extension of the same conception when Jesus is represented as the end of creation—the ‘Head” in whom all things are finally to be summed up (Eph 110; cf He 2 6-9). These high views of the per- son of Christ in the Epistles are everywhere assumed to be the possession of the readers. Jesus had furnished His disciples with the means of understanding His death as a necessity of His Messianic vocation, endured for the salvation of the world; but it was the resurrection and exalta- tion which shed light on the utmost meaning of this also. Jesus died, but it was for sins. He was a propitiation for the sin of the world (Rom 3 25; Jegus Christ, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1 Jn 2 2; 4 10). He was ‘made sin’ for us (2 Cor 6 21). -The strain of Isa 53 runs through the a NT teaching on this theme (cf 1 Pet 6. Signifi- 1 19; 2 22-25, etc). Jesus’ own word cance of the “ransom” is reproduced hy Paul (1 Tim Cross and 26). The song of the redeemed is, Resurrec- ‘Thou didst purchase unto God with tion thy blood men of every tribe,” etc ; (Rev 6 9). Is it wonderful, in view of this, that in the apostolic writings—not in Paul only, but in Pet, in Jn, in He, and Rev, equally—the cross should assume the decisive im- portance it does? Paul only works out more fully in relation to the law and the sinner’s justification a truth shared hy all. He himself declares it to be ee, common doctrine of the churches (1 Cor 15 3.4). The newer tendency is to read an apocalyptic character into nearly all the teaching of Jesus (cf Schweitzer, Quest of the Historical 7. Hope of Jesus). This is an exaggeration, but the Advent that Jesus taught His disciples to look for His coming again, and connected with that coming the perfection of His kingdom, is plain to every reader of the Gospels. It will not he denied that the apostolic church retained this fea- ture of the teaching of Jesus. In accordance with the promise in Acts 1 11, it looked for the glorious reappearing of its Lord. The Epistles are full of this hope. Even Jn gives it prominence (1 Jn 2 28; 3 2). In looking for the parousia as something immediately at hand, the early believers went even beyond what had been revealed, and Paul had to rehuke harmful tendencies in this direction (2 Thess 2). The hope might be cherished that the coming would not long be delayed, but in face of the express declarations of Jesus that no one, not the angels, not even the Son, knew of that day and hour (Mt 24 36; Mk 13 32), and that the Father had set these things in His own authority (Acts 1 7; ef also such intimations as in Mt 13 30; 24 14; 25 19; 28 19; Lk 19 11, etc), none could affirm this with certainty. Time has proved—proved it even in the apostolic age (2 Pet 3 3.4)—that the Ad- vent was not so near as many thought. In part, perhaps, the church itself may be to blame for the delay. Still to faith the Advent remains the great fixed event of the future, the event which overshadows all others—in that sense is ever near—the polestar of the church’s confidence that righteousness shall triumph, the dead shall! be raised, sin shall be judged and the kingdom of God shall come. LirErators.—The lit. on the life and teaching of Jesus is so voluminous, aud represents such diverse standpoints, that it would be unprofitable to furnish an extended catalogue of it. It may be seen prefixed to any of the larger books. On the skeptical and ration- alistic side the best account of the lit. will be found in Schweitzer's book, From Reimarus to Wrede (ET, Quest of the Historical Jesus). Of modern believing works may be specially named those of Lange, Weiss, Ellicott, Eders- heim, Farrar, D. Smith. Dr. Sanday's book, The Life of Christ in Recent Research, surveys a large part of the field, and is preparatory to an extended Life from Dr. Sanday's own pen. His art. in HDB has justly attracted much attention. Schiirer's Hist of the Jewish People in the Time of Jesus Christ (ET, 5 vols; a new German ed has been published) is the best authority on the external conditions. The works on NT Bib. theology (Reuss, Weiss, Schmid, Stevens, etc) deal with the teaching of Jesus; see also Wendt, The Teaching of Jesus (ET). Works and arts. on the Chronology, on Harmony of the Gospels, on geog- raphy and topography (cf esp. Stanley, G. A. Smith) are legion. A good, comprehensive book on these topics is Andrews, Life of Our Lord (rev. ed). The present writer has published works on The Virgin Birth of Christ and The Resurrection of Jesus. On the relations of gospel aud epistle, see J. Denney, Jesus and the Gospel. See also the various arts. in this Enc, on Gospris; Tus Person or Cuarist; Ernics or Jesus; Virein Birra; Jesus Curist, ARREST aND TrRiaL Or; RESURRECTION; ASCENSION; Puariskes; SappucEEs; Herop; JErusaLemM, etc. JAMES ORR 1668 JESUS CHRIST, ARREST AND TRIAL OF: 1, Jewish and Roman Law 2. Difficulties of the Subject 3. Illustrations of Difficulties I. Tus Arrest 1, Preparatory Steps 2, The Arrest in the Garden 3. Taken to the City Il. Tus Jewisa Triar 1. The Jewish Law The Mishna . Criminal Trials The Trial of Jesus 2 The Preliminary Examination . The Night Trial . False Witnesses A Browbeating Judge The Morning Session 10. Powers of the Sanhedrin 11. Condemnation for Blasphemy 12. Summary III. Tas Roman Triau 1. Taken before Pilate POM EYR 9989 2. Roman Law and Procedure 3. Full Trial Not Desired 4. Final Accusation . 5. Examination, Defence and Acquittal 6. Fresh Accusations 7. Reference to Herod 8. Jesus or Barabbas 9. Behold the Man! 10. Pilate Succumbs to Threats 11. Pilate Washes His Hands 12. The Sentence : 13. Review This subject is of special interest, not only on account of its inherent importance, hut more par- ticularly on account of its immediately preceding, and leading directly up to what is the greatest tragedy in human history, the crucifixion of Our Lord. It has also the added interest of being the only proceeding on record in which the two great legal systems of antiquity, the Jewish and the Roman, which have most largely influenced modern legislation and jurisprudence, each played a most important part. The coexistence of these two systems in Judaea, aud their joint action in bringing about the tremendous results in question, were made possible by the 1. Jewish generous policy pursued by Rome in allow- dR ing conquered nations to retain their an- ay oman cient laws, institutions and usages, in so Law far as they were compatible with Rom sovereignty and supremacy. Not only so, but, in a large degree, they permitted these laws to be administered by the officials of the subject peoples. This privilege was not granted absolutely, but was permitted only solong as it was not abused. It might be withdrawn at any time, and the instances in which this was done were by no means rare. Of the matters considered in this article, the arrest of Jesus and the proceedings before Annas, Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin took place professedly under Jewish law; the proceedings hefore Pilate and the reference to Herod, under Rom law. It is very difficult to construct from the materials in the four Gospels a satisfactory continuous record of the arrest, and of what may be 2. Diffi- called the twofold trial of Jesus. The culties of | Gospels were written from different the Subject viewpoints, and for different purposes, : each of the writers selecting such par- ticulars as seemed to him to he of special importance for the particular ohject he had in view. Their reports are all very brief, and the proper chrono- logical order of the various events recorded in different. Gospels must, in many cases, he largely a matter of conjecture. The difficulty is increased by the great irregularities and the tumultuous character of the proceedings; by our imperfect knowledge of the topography of Jerus at this time (29 AD); also hy the fact that the reports are given mainly in popular and not in technical language; and when the latter form is used, the technical terms have had to be tr4 into Gr, either from the Heb or from the Lat. 1669 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ, For instance, opinions are divided as to where Pilate resided when in Jerus, whether in the magnificent palace huiit by Herod the Great, or in the castie 3. Ilustra- of Antonia; as to where was the paiace tions of occupied by Herod Erle ie during ane Pass- , A ;,.whether Annas an: aiaphas occu- Difficulties pied different portions of the same alace, F .,0Fr whether they iived in adjoining or different residences; whether the preliminary examination of Jesus, recorded by John, was before Annas or Caiaphas, and as to other similar matters. It is very satisfactory, however, to know that, although it is sometimes difficult to decide exactiy as to the best way of harmonizing the different accounts, yet there is nothing irreconcilable or contradictory in them, and that there is no materiai point in the history of the very important proceedings faiiin, within the scope of this articie which is seriousiy affecte by_any of these debatabie matters. For a clear historicai statement of the events of the conciuding day in the life of Our Lord before His cruci- fixion, see the article on Jesus Curist. The present article will endeavor to consider the matters relating to ee arrest and triai from a iegai and constitutionai point ew. _ I. The Arrest.—During the last year of the min- istry of Jesus, the hostility of the Jews to Him had greatly increased, and some six months before they finally succeeded in accomplishing their purpose, they had definitely resolved to make away with Him. Atthe Feast of Tabernacles they sent officers (the temple-guards) to take Him while He was teaching in the temple (Jn 7 32); but these, after listening to His words, returned without having made the attempt, giving as a reason that ‘never man so spake” (ver 46). After His raising of Lazarus, their determination to kill Him was greatly intensified. A special meet- ing of the council was held to consider the matter. There Caiaphas, the high priest, strongly advocated such a step on national grounds, and on the ground of expediency, quoting in support of his advice, in a cold-blooded and cynical manner, the Jewish adage that it was expedient that one man should die for the people, and that the whole nation perish not. Their plans to this end were frustrated, for the time being, by Jesus withdrawing Himself to the border of the wilderness, where He remained with His disciples (Jn 11 47-54). On His return to Bethany and Jerus, six days before the Passover, they were deterred from carry- ing out their design on account of His manifest popularity with the people, as evidenced by His triumphal entry into Jerus on the first day of the Passover week (Palm Sunday), and by the crowds who thronged around Him, and listened to His teachings in the temple, and who enjoyed the dis- comfiture of the Pharisees, Sadducees and Hero- dians, as they successively sought to entangle Him in His talk. : Two days before the Passover, at a council meet- ing held in the palace of Caiaphas, they planned to accomplish their purpose by subtlety, but “not during the feast, lest a tumult arise among the people” (Mt 26 3-5; Mk 141.2). While they were in this state of perplexity, to their great relief Judas came to them and agreed to betray his Master for money (Mt 26 14-16; Mk 14 10.11). This time they determined not to rely solely upon their own temple-guards or officers to execute their warrant or order of arrest, fearing that 1. Prepara- these officials, being Jews, might again tory Steps be fascinated by the strange influence which Jesus exercised over His country- men, or that His followers might offer resistance. They therefore applied to Pilate, the Rom proc- urator (governor), for the assistance of a band of Rom soldiers. He granted them a cohort (Gr spetra, 400 to 600 men) from the legion then quar- tered in the castle of Antonia, which adjoined and overlooked the temple-area. The final arrange- ments as to these would probably be completed while Judas was at the supper room. It has been suggested that the whole cohort would not go, but only a selection from them. However, it is said that Judas “received the band [cohort] of soldiers” (Jn 18 3), and that they were under the command of a chief captain (Gr chiliarch, Lat tribune, ver 12). If there had not been more than 100 soldiers, they would not have been under the command of a captain, but the chief officer would have been a centurion. The amazing popularity of Jesus, as shown by His triumphal entry into the city, may have led the authorities to make such ample provi- sion against any possible attempt at rescue. The Garden of Gethsemane, in which Judas knew that Jesus would be found that night, was well known to him (Jn 18 2); and he also knew the time he would be likely to find his Master there. Thither at the proper hour he led the band of sol- diers, the temple officers and others, and also some of the chief priests and elders themselves; the whole being described as “a great multitude with swords and staves’ (Mt 26 47). Although the Easter full moon would be shining brightly, they also carried “lanterns and torches” (Jn 18 3), in order to make certain that Jesus should not escape or fail to be recognized in the deep shade of the olive trees in the garden. On their arrival at the garden, Jesus came forward to meet them, and the traitor Judas gave them the appointed signal by kissing Him. As 2. The the order or warrant was a Jewish one, Arrestin the temple officers would prohably be the Garden in front, the soldiers supporting them as reserves. On Jesus announcing to the leaders that He was the one they sought, what the chief priests had feared actually oc- curred. There was something in the words or bearing of Jesus which awed the temple officers; they were panic-stricken, went backward, and fell to the ground. On their rallying, the impetuous Peter drew his sword, and cut off the ear of one of them, Malchus, the servant of the high priest (Jn 18 6-10). On this evidence of resistance the Rom captain and soldiers came forward, and with the assistance of the Jewish officers bound Jesus. Under the Jewish law this was not lawful before condemnation, save in exceptional cases where resistance was either offered or apprehended. Even in this trying hour the concern of Jesus was more for others than for Himself, as witness His miracle in healing the ear of Malchus, and His request that His disciples might be allowed their liberty (Jn 18 8). Notwithstanding His efforts, His followers were panic-stricken, probably on account of the vigorous action of the officers and soldiers after the assault by Peter, ‘‘and they all left him and fled” (Mk 14 50). lt is worthy of note that: Jesus had no word of blame or censure for the Rom officers or soldiers who were only doing their sworn duty in supporting the civil authorities; but His pungent words of reproach for not having attempted His arrest while He was teaching openly in the temple were reserved for “the chief priests, and captains of the temple, and elders” (Lk 22 52), who had shown their in- ordinate zeal and hostility by taking the unusual, and for those who were to sit as judges on the case, the improper and illegal course of accom- panying the officers, and themselves taking part in the arrest. The whole body departed with their prisoner for the city. From the first three Gospels one might infer that they went directly to the pal- 8. Taken to ace of Caiaphas, the high priest. the City In the Fourth Gospel, however, we are told that they took him first to Annas (Jn 18 13). Jesus Christ, Arrest, Trial THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1670 Why they did so we are not informed, the only state- ment made being that he was the father-in-law of Caia- phas (ver 13). He had been the high priest from 7 AD to 15 AD, when he was deposed by Valerius Gratus, the Rom _ procurator. He was still the most influential member of the Sanhedrin, and, being of an aggressive disposition, it may be that it was he who had given in- structions as to the arrest, and that they thought it their duty to report first to him. Annas, however, sent Jesus bound to Caiaphas (ver 24). Having delivered over their prisoner, the Rom soldiers would proceed to their quarters in the castle, the temple officials retaining Jesus in their charge. Meanwhile, the members of the Sanhedrin were assembling at the palace of the high priest, and the preliminary steps toward the first or Jewish trial were being taken. Il. The Jewish Trial.—It is the just boast of those countries whose jurisprudence had its origin in the common law of England, that their 1. The Jew- system of criminal law is founded upon ish Law the humane maxims that everyone is presumed to be innocent until he is proved to he guilty, and that no one is bound to criminate himself. But the Jewish law went even farther in the safeguards which it placed around an accused person. In the Pent it is provided that one witness shall not he sufficient to convict any man of even a minor offence. “One witness shall not rise up against a man for any iniquity, or for any sin, i any sin that he sinneth: at the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall a matter be established” (Dt 19 15). These principles of the Mosaic law were elaborated and extended in the system which grew up after the return from Babylon. It was hegun hy 2. The the men of the Great Synagogue, and was Mishn afterward completed by the Sanhedrin isona which succeeded them. Up to the time of __,,Our Lord, and for the first two centuries of the Christian era, their rules remained largely in an oral or unwritten form, until they were compiled or codi- fied in the Mish by Rabbi Judah and his associates and successors in the early part of the 3dcent. Itis generally conceded by both Jewish and Christian writers that the main DEV YISIOLS therein found for the protection of accused persons, had been long incorporated in the oral law and were recognized as a part of it in the time of Annas and Caiaphas. | The provisions relating to criminal trials, and esp. to those in which the offence was punishable by death, MUSTO Very Stringent and were tae framed 2 iminal in e interest o e@ accused. Amon a ee Y al them were the following: The trial ae rials he begun by day, and if not completed before night it must be adjourned and resumed by day; the quorum of judges in capital cases was 23, that being the quorum of the Grand Council; a verdict of acquittal, which required only a majority of one, might be rendered on the same day as the trial was completed; any other verdict could only be rendered on a subsequent day and required a majority of at least two; no prisoner could be convicted on his own evidence; it was the duty of a judge to see that the interests of the accused were fully protected. The modern practice of an information or complaint and a preliminary investigation before a magistrate was wholly unknown to the Jewish law and foreign to its genius. The examination of the witnesses in open court was in reality the beginning of a Jewish trial, and the crime for which the accused was tried, and the sole charge he had to meet, was that which was disclosed by the evi- dence of the witnesses. Let us see how far the foregoing principles and rules were followed and observed in the proceedings before the high priest in the present 4. The instance. The first step taken in the Trial of trial was the private examination of Jesus Jesus hy the high priest, which is recorded only in Jn 18 19-23. Opin- ions differ as to whether this examination was con- ducted by Annas at his residence before he sent Jesus to Caiaphas (ver 24), or by the latter after Jesus had been delivered up to him. Calaphas was actually the high priest at the time, and had been for some years. Annas had heen deposed from the office about 14 years previously by the Rom procu- rator; but he was still accorded the title (Acts 4 6). Many of the Jews did not concede the right of the proc- urator to depose him, and looked upon him as still the rightful high priest. He is also said to have been at this time the vice-president of the Sanhedrin. The arguments as to which of them is called the high ek by John in this passage are based largely upon two dlffer- ent renderings of Jn 18 24. In AV the verse reads ‘‘Now Annas had sent him hound unto Caiaphas the high priest,’ a reading based upon the 7R whichimplies that Jesus had been sent to Caiaphas before the exami- nation. On the other hand, RV, following the Gr text adopted by Nestle and others, reads, “Annas therefore sent him hound unto Caiaphas the high priest,” implying that Annas sent him to Caiaphas on account of what had taken place in the examination. However, it is not material which of these two leading members of the Sanhedrin conducted the examination. The same may also he said as to the controversy regarding the residence of Annas at the time, whether it was in some part of the official palace of the high priest or elsewhere. The im- portant matters are the fact, the time, and the manner of the examination by one or other of these leading members of the council, not the precise place where, or the particular person by whom, it was conducted. The high priest (whether Annas or Caiaphas) proceeded to interrogate Jesus concerning His dis- ciples and His doctrine (Jn 18 19). 5. The Pre- Such a proceeding formed no part of a liminary regular Jewish trial, and was, more- Examina- over, not taken in good faith; but tion with a view to entrapping Jesus into admissions that might be used against Him at the approaching trial before the council. It appears to have heen in the nature of a private examination, conducted probably while the mem- bers of the council were assembling. The dignified and appropriate answer of Jesus pointedly brought before the judge the irregularity he was committing, and was a reminder that His trial should begin with the examination’of the witnesses: ‘I spake openly to the world; I ever taught in the synagogue, and in the temple, whither the Jews always resort; and in secret have I said nothing. Why askest thou me? Ask them which heard me, what I have said unto them: behold, they know what I said” (vs 20.21 AV). The reply to this was a blow from one of the officers, an outrageous proceeding which appears to have passed unrebuked by the judge, and it was left to Jesus Himself to make the appro- priate protest. The next proceeding was the trial before the council in the'palace of Caiaphas, attended at least by the quorum of 23. This was an 6. The illegal meeting, since a capital trial, Night Trial as we have seen, could not either be egun or proceeded with at night. Some of the chief priests and elders, as previously stated, had been guilty of the highly improper act for judges, of taking part in and directing the arrest of Jesus. Now, “the chief priests and the whole council” spent the time intervening be- tween the arrest and the commencement of the trial in something even worse: they “sought false witness against Jesus, that they might put him to death” (Mt 26 59). This, no doubt, only means that they then collected their false witnesses and instructed them as to the testimony they should give. For weeks, ever since the raising of Laza- rus, they had been preparing for such a trial, ee wu: ie ee : eu plage day forth they ook counsel that they might put hi i Gn 53) y might put him to death Caiaphas, as high priest and president of the San- hedrin, resided at the meeting of the council. The oath administered to witnesses in a Jewish court was an extremely solemn invocation, and it makes 1671 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus CBrist, one shudder to think of the high priest pronouncing these words to perjured witnesses, known by him to have been procured by the judges before him in the manner stated. But even this did not avail. Although “many bare false witness against him,” yet on account of their having been imperfectly tutored qT. False by their instructors, or for other cause, Witnesses “their witness agreed not together” _ . (Mk 14 56), and even these prejudiced and partial judges could not find the concurring testimony of two witnesses required by their law (Dt 19 15). The nearest approach to the necessary concur- rence came at last from two witnesses, who gave a distorted report of a figurative and enigmatic state- ment made by Jesus in the temple during His early ministry: ‘‘Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up” (Jn 219). The explanation is given: ‘‘He spake of the temple of his body’ (ver 21). The testimony of the two witnesses is reported with but slight variations in the two first Gospels as follows: “This man said, I am able to destroy the temple of God, and to build it in three days” (Mt 26 61); and ‘We heard him say, I will destroy this temple that is made with hands, and in three days I will build another made without hands” (Mk 14 58). Whether these slightly different statements represent the discrepancies in their tes- timony, or on account of some other variations or contradictions, the judges reluctantly decided that ‘not even so did their witness agree together’ (ver 59). Caiaphas, having exhausted his list of witnesses, and seeing the prosecution on which he had set his heart in danger of breaking down for 8. A Brow- the lack of legal evidence, adopted a beating blustering tone, and said to Jesus, Judge “Answerest thou nothing? what is it which these witness against thee? But Jesus held his peace’ (Mt 26 62.63), relying on the fact that the proseeution had utterly failed on account of the Jack of agreement of two witnesses on any of the charges. As a final and desperate resort, Caiaphas had recourse to a bold strategic move to draw from Jesus an admission or confession on which he might base a condemnation, similar to the attempt which failed at the preliminary exami- nation; but this time fortifying his appeal by a solemn adjuration in the name of the Deity. He said to Jesus: “I adjure thee by the living God, that thou tell us whether thou art the Christ, the Son of God. Jesus saith unto him, Thou hast said: nevertheless I say unto you, Henceforth ye shall see the Son of man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming on the clouds of heaven’’ (vs 63.64). Caiaphas, although knowing that under the law Jesus could not be convicted on His own answers or admissions, thereupon in a tragic manner “rent his garments, saying, He hath spoken blasphemy: what further need have we of witnesses? behold, now ye have heard the blasphemy: what think ye? They answered and said, He is worthy of death” (vs 65.66). 3 The night session then broke up to meet again after daybreak in order to ratify the decision just come to, and to give a semblance of le- gality to the trial and verdict. The closing scene was one of disorder, in which they spat in their prisoner’s face and buffeted him (vs 67.68, Lk 22 63-65). Th following morning, ‘‘as soon as it was day,” the council reassembled in the same place, and Jesus was led into their presence (Lk 22 66). There were probably a number of the council present who had not attended the night session. For the benefit of these, and perhaps to give an appearance of legality to the proceeding, the high priest began the trial anew, but not with the examination of witnesses which had proved such a 9. The failure at the night session. He pro- Morning ceeded at once to ask substantially the Session same questions as had finally brought out from Jesus the night before the answer which he had declared to be blasphemy, and upon which the council had ‘‘condemned him to be worthy of death” (Mk 14 64). The meeting is mentioned in all the Gospels, the details of the ex- amination are related by Luke alone. When asked whether He was the Christ, He replied, ‘‘If I tell you, ye will not believe: and if I ask you, ye will not answer. But from henceforth shall the Son of man be seated at the right hand of the power of God” (Lk 22 67-69). This answer not being suf- ficient to found a verdict of blasphemy upon, they all cried out, ‘“‘Art thou then the Son of God?” To this He gave an affirmative answer, ‘Ye say that I am. And they said, What further need have we of witness? for we ourselves have heard from his own mouth” (vs 70.71). It will be observed that neither at the night nor at the morning session was there any sentence pro- nounced upon Jesus by the high priest. 10. Powers There was on each occasion only what of the San- would be equivalent to a verdict of hedrin guilty found by a jury under our modern criminal practice, but no sentence passed upon the prisoner by the presiding judge. When Judaea lost the last vestige of its independence and became a Rom province (6 AD), the Benhadad ceased to have the right to inflict capital punishment or to administer the law of life and death. This jurisdiction was thenceforth transferred to the Rom procurator. The San- hedrin submitted very reluctantly to this cur- tailment of its powers. A few years later it exercised it illegally and in a very riotous manner in the case of Stephen (Acts 7 58). Annas, how- ever, of all men, had good reason not to violate this law, as his having done so during the absence of the procurator was the cause of his being de- posed from the office of high priest by Valerius Gratus (15 AD). The proceedings may have been taken before the high priest in the hope that Pilate might be induced to accept the verdict of the Sanhedrin as conclusive that Jesus had been guilty of an offence punishable by death under the Jewish law. Now what was the precise crime or crimes for which Jesus was tried at these two sittings of the council? The first impression would 11. Con- probably be that there was no connec- demnation tion between the charge of destroying for Blas- the temple and building another in phemy three days, and His claiming to be the Son of God. And yet they were closely allied in the Jewish mind. The Jewish nation being a pure theocracy, the overthrow of the temple, the abode of the Divine Sovereign, would mean the overthrow of Divine institutions, and be an act of treason against the Deity. The profession of ability to build another temple in three days would be construed as a claim to the possession of supernatural power and, consequently, blasphemy. ‘As to the other claim which He Himself made and confessed to the council, namely, that He was the Christ, the Son of God, none of them would have any hesitation in concurring in the verdict of the high priest that it was rank blasphemy, when made by one whom they regarded simply as a Galilean peasant. : : To sum up:. The Jewish trial of Our Lord was absolutely illegal, the court which condemned Him being without jurisdiction to try a capital offence, Jesus Christ, Arrest, Trial THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1672 which blasphemy was under the Jewish law. Even if there had been jurisdiction, it would have been irregular, as the judges had rendered 12. Sum- themselves incompetent to try the mary case, having been guilty of the viola- tion of the spirit of the law that re- quired judges to be unprejudiced and impartial, and carefully to guard the interests of the accused. Even the letter of the law had been violated in a number of important respects. Among these may be mentioned: (1) some of the judges taking part in and directing the arrest; (2) the examination before the trial and the attempt to obtain admis- sions; (3) endeavors of the judges to procure the testimony of false witnesses; (4) commencing and continuing the trial at night; (5) examining and adjuring the accused in order to extort admissions from Him; (5) rendering a verdict of guilty at the close of the night session, without allowing a day to intervene; (7) holding the morning session on a feast day, and rendering a verdict at its close; and (8) rendering both verdicts without any legal evidence. HI. The Roman Trial.—Early on the mornin of Friday of the Passover week, as we have ab ready seen, “the chief priests with the elders and scribes, and the whole council’ held a consulta- tion (Mk), in the palace of the high priest; and after the examination of Jesus and their verdict that He was guilty of blasphemy, they took coun- sel against Him “to put him to death” (Mt), this being, in their judgment, the proper punishment for the offence of which they had pronounced Him guilty. For the reasons already mentioned, they came to the conclusion that it would be necessary to invoke the aid of the Rom power in 1. Taken carrying out this sentence. They before thereupon bound Jesus, and led Him Pilate away and delivered Him up to Pilate, who at this time probably occupied, while in Jerus, the magnificent palace built by Herod the Great. Jesus was taken into the judgment hall of the palace or Praetorium; His accusers, unwill- ing to defile themselves by entering into a heathen house and thereby rendering themselves unfit to eat the Passover, remained outside upon the marble pavement. The proceedings thus begun were conducted under a system entirely different from that which we have thus far been considering, both in its nature 2. Roman and its administration. The Jewish law Law and was a part of the religion, and In its growth and development was adminis- Procedure tered in important cases by a large body of trained men, who were obliged to follow strictly a well-defined procedure. The Rom law, on the other hand, had its origin and growth under the stern and manly virtues and the love of justice which char- acterized republican Rome, and it still jealously guarded the rights and privileges of Rom citizens, even in a con- quered province. Striking illustrations of this truth are found in the life of St. Paul (see Acts 16 35-39; 22 24-29; 25 10-12). | The lives and fortunes of the natives in an imperial province like Judaea mney be said to have been almost completely at the mercy of the Rom procu- rator or governor, who was responsible to his imperial mas- ter alone, and not even to the Rom senate. Pilate there- fore was well within the mark when, at a later stage of the trial, being irritated at Jesus remaining silent when questioned by him, he petulantly exclaimed: ‘‘Speakest thou not unto me? knowest thou not that I have power to release thee, and have power to crucify thee?” (Jn 19 10). While, however, the procurator was not com- pelled in such cases to adhere strictly to the prescribed procedure, and had a wide discretion, he was not allowed Le solate: or depart from the establlshed principles of e law. On this occasion, Pilate, respecting the scruples of the chief priests about entering the palace, went outside at their request, apparently leaving Jesus in the Praetorium. He asked them the usual for- mal question, put at the opening of a Rom trial: “What accusation bring ye against this man? They answered and said unto him, If 3. Full he were not an evil-doer, we should not Trial Not have delivered him up unto thee” Desired (Jn 18 29f AV). Pilate could see at once that this was a mere attempt to evade the direct question he had asked, and was not such an accusation as disclosed any offence known to the Rom Jaw. Affecting to treat it with disdain, and as something known only to their own law, he said, “Take him yourselves, and judge him according to your law. The Jews said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death” (ver 31).. , : Perceiving that Pilate would not gratify their desire to have Jesus condemned on the verdict which they had rendered, or for an 4, Final offence against their own law only, Accusation “they began to accuse him, saying, We found this man perverting our nation, and forbidding to give tribute to Caesar, and saying that he himself is Christ a king’? (Lk 23 2). This was an accusation containing three charges, much like a modern indictment containing three counts. Pilate appears to have been satisfied that there was nothing in the first two of these charges; but the third ‘was too serious to be ignored, esp. as it was a direct charge of majesias or treason, the greatest crime known to the Rom law, and as to which the reigning emperor, Tiberius, and his then favorite, Sejanus, were particularly sen- sitive and jealous. The charges in this case were merely oral, but it would appear to have been in the discretion of the procurator to receive them in this form in the case of one who was not a Rom citizen. The accusers having been heard, Pilate returned to the Praetorium to examine Jesus regarding the last and serious accusation. The Four 5. Exami- Gospels give in the same words the nation, De- question put to him by Pilate, ‘‘Art fence and thou the King of the Jews?’ The Acquittal _ first three record only the final affirma- tive answer, “Thou sayest,” which if it stood alone might have been taken as a plea of guilty; but John gives the intervening discussion which explains the matter fully. He tells us that Jesus did not answer the question directly, but asked Pilate, “Sayest thou this of thyself, or did others tell it thee concerning me?” (Jn 18 34) (apparently not having been outside when the charges were made). On being told that it came from the chief priests, He went on to explain that His kingdom was not of this world, but was a spirit- ual kingdom. Being again asked if He was a king, He replied in effect, that He was a king in that sense, and that His subjects were those who were of the truth and heard His voice (vs 35-37). Pilate, being satisfied with His explanation, ‘went out again unto the Jews,” and apparently having taken Jesus with him, he mounted his judgment seat or movable tribunal, which had been placed upon the tesselated pavement, and pronounced his verdict, “T find in him no fault at all’ (ver 38 AV, RV “I find no crime in him’’). According to the Rom law, this verdict of ac- quittal should have ended the trial and at once secured the discharge of Jesus; but 6. Fresh instead it brought a volley of fresh Accusations accusations to which Jesus made no reply. Pilate hesitated, and hearing a charge that Jesus had begun His treasonable teaching in Galilee, the thought occurred to him that he might escape from his dilemma by sending Jesus for trial to Herod Antipas, the tetrarch of 1673 Galilee, who was then in Jerus for the feast, which he accordingly did (Lk 23 7). Herod had long been desirous to sce Jesus— “hoped to see some miracle done by him,” and “questioned him in many words; but 7. Refer- he answered him nothing.” The ence to chief priests and scribes, who had Herod followed him from the Praetorium to the Maccabean palace, which Herod was then occupying, “stood, vehemently accus- ing” Jesus (vs 8-10). “That fox,” however, as Jesus had called him (Lk 13 32), was too astute to intermeddle in a trial for treason, which was a dan- gerous proceeding, and possibly he was aware that Pilate had already acquitted Him; in which case a retrial by him would be illegal. He ‘and his soldiers, probably irritated at the refusal of Jesus to give him any answer, mocked Him, and array- ing Him in a gorgeous robe, no doubt in ridicule of His claim to be a king, sent Him back to Pilate. This reference to Herod in reality formed no effective part of the trial of Jesus, as Herod declined the jurisdiction, although Pilate sought to make use of it in his subsequent discussion with the chief priests. The only result was that Herod was flattered by the courtesy of Pilate, the enmity between them ceased, and they were made friends (Lk 23 11.12.15). On their return, Pilate resumed his place on the judgment seat outside. What followed, however, properly formed no part of the legal 8. Jesus or trial, as it was a mere travesty upon Barabbas law as well as upon justice. Pilate resolved to make another attempt to secure the consent of the Jews to the release of Jesus. To this end he summoned not only the chief priests and the rulers, but “the people” as well (Lk 23 18), and after mentioning the failure to prove any of the charges made against Jesus, he reminded them of the custom of releasing at the feast a prisoner selected by them, and offering as a compromise to chastise or scourge Jesus before releasing Him. At this point Pilate’s anxiety to release Jesus was still further increased by the mes- sage he received from his wife concerning her dis- turbing dream about Jesus and warning him to “have... . nothing to do with that righteous man” (Mt 27 19). Meanwhile, the chief priests and elders were busily engaged in canvassing the multitude to ask for the release of Barabbas, the notable robber, and destroy Jesus (ver 20). When Pilate urged them to release Jesus, they cried out all together, “Away with this man, and release unto us Barabbas”; and upon a further appeal on behalf of Jesus they cried, “Crucify, crucify him.” A third attempt on his part met with no better result (Lk 23 18-23). The Fourth Gospel alone records a final attempt on the part of Pilate to save Jesus. He scourged Him, it has been suggested, with a 9. Behold view to satisfying their desire for His the Man! punishment, and afterward appealing to their pity. He allowed his soldiers to repeat what they had seen done at Herod's palace, and place a crown of thorns upon His head, array Him in a purple robe, and render mock hom- age to Him as king of the Jews. Pilate went out to the Jews with Jesus thus arrayed and bleeding. Again declaring that he found no fault in Him, he presented Him, saying, “Behold, the man!” This was met by the former cry, ‘“‘Crucify him, crucify him.” Pilate replied, ‘“Take him yourselves . .. . for I find no crime in him.” The Jews referred him to their law by which He deserved death because He made Himself the Son of God. This alarmed Pilate’s superstitious fears, who by this time appears to have wholly lost control of himself. He took THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jesus Christ, Arrest, Trisl Jesus into the palace and said to Him, ‘(Whence art thou? But Jesus gave him no answer.” Irritated at His silence, Pilate reminded Him of his absolute powcr over Him. The mysterious answer of Jesus as to the source of power still further alarmed him, and he made new efforts to securc His discharge (Jn 19 1-9). The Jews were well awarc that Pilate was arbi- trary and cruel, but they had also found that he was very sensitive as to anything that 10. Pilate might injuriously affect his official Succumbs position or his standing with his mas- to Threats ter, the emperor. As a last resort they shouted to him, ‘‘If thou release this man, thou art not Caesar’s friend: every one that maketh himself a king speaketh against Caesar” (ver 12). The prospect of a charge of his aiding and abetting such a crime as treason, in addi- tion to the other charges that a guilty conscience told him might be brought against him, proved too much for the vacillating procurator. He brought Jesus out, and sat down again upon the judgment seat placed upon the pavement. He made one more appeal, “Shall I crucify your King?” The chief priests gave the hypocritical answer, “We have no king but Caesar” (ver 15). Pilate finally suc- cumbed to their threats and clamor; but took his revenge by placing upon the cross the superscription that was so galling to them, ‘‘Tus Kine or THE Jaws.” Then occurred the closing scene of the tragedy, recorded only in the First Gospel, when Pilate washed his hands before the multitude 11. Pilate (a Jewish custom), saying to them, Washes His “I am innocent of the blood of this Hands righteous man; see ye to it.” The reply was that dreadful imprecation, “His blood be on us, and on our children” (Mt 27 24.25). Pilate resumes his place upon the judgment seat, the fatal sentence at last falls from his lips, and Jesus is delivered up to be crucified. 12. The Now, how far were these proceed- Sentence ings in accordance with the Rom law under which they purported to have been taken and conducted? In the first place, Pilate, as procurator, was the proper officer to try the charges brought against Jesus. 13. Review In the next place he acted quite prop- erly in declining to entertain a charge which disclosed no offence known to the Rom law, or to pass a sentence based on the verdict of the Sanhedrin for an alleged violation of the Jewish law. He appears to have acted in accordance with the law, and indeed in a judicial and praiseworthy manner in the trial and disposition of the threefold indictment for treason (unless it be a fact that Jesus was not present when these accusations were brought against Him outside the Praetorium, which would be merely an irregularity, as they were made known to him later inside). Pilate’s initial mistake, which led to all the others, was in not discharging Jesus at once, when he had pronounced the verdict of acquittal.: All the subsequent proceedings were contrary to both the letter and the spirit of the law. Al- though Pilate took his place upon the judgment seat, his acts, properly speaking, were not those of a judge, and had no legal force or value; but were rather the futile attempts of a weak and vacillating politician to appease an angry mob thirsting for the blood of an innocent countryman. The carrying out of a sentence imposed in such circumstances, and under such conditions, may not inaptly be described as a judicial murder. Joun James MacuarEN Jesus, Geneal. of HE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jezebel 1674 JESUS, GENEALOGY OF. See GENEALOGY OF JESUS. JESUS JUSTUS, jé@zus jus’tus (Inoots 6 deys- pevos 'loteros, [ésous ho legimenos Ioustos, “Jesus that is called Justus,’ Col 4 11): One of three friends of Paul—the others being Aristarchus and Mark— whom he associates with himself in sending salutations from Rome to the church at Colossae. Jesus Justus is not mentioned elsewhere in the NT, and there is nothing more known about him than is given in this passage in Col, viz. that he was by birth a Jew—‘‘of the circumcision”— that he had been converted to Christ, and that he was one of the inner circle of intimate friends and associates of the apostle during his first Rom cap- tivity. The words also contain the information that at a stage in Paul's imprisonment, when the welcome extended to 1. A Jew by Birth him by the Christians in Rome on his 2, He Re~ arrival there had lost its first warmth, and ains True when in consequence, prohahly, of their fear mal of persecution, most of them had proved to Paul untrue and were holding aloof from him, J. J. and his two friends remained faith- ful. It would be pressing this passage unduly to make it mean that out of the large number—hundreds, or perhaps even one or two thousands—who composed the membership of the church in Rome at this time, and who within the next few years proved their loyalty to Christ by their stedfastness unto death in the Ne- ronic persecution, all fell away from their affectionate allegiance to Paul at this difficult time. The words cannot be made to signify more than that it was the Jewish section of the church in Rome which acted in this unworthy manner—only temporarily, it is to he hoped. But among these Jewish Christians, to such dimensions had this defection grown that Aristarchus, Mark and J. J. alone were the apostle’s fellow-workers unto the kingdom of God. These three alone, at that particular time—from among the Jewish Christians—were helping him in the work of the gospelin Rome. That this de- fection refers to the Jewish section of the church and not to the converts from among the Gentiles, is evident from many considerations. It seems to be proved, for example by ver 14 of the same chapter (i.e. Col 4 14), as well as by Philem ver 24, in hoth of which passages Paul names Demas and Luke as his fellow-laborers, and Luke was not a Jew hy hirth. But in the general failure of the Christians in Rome in their conduct toward Paul, it is with much affection and pathos that he writes concerning Aristarchus, Mark, and J. J., ‘‘ These only are my fellow- workers unto the kingdom of God, men that have heen a comfort unto me.” Joun RUTHERFURD JETHER, jé’thér ("%)", yether, ‘“abundance’’): (1) Ex 4 18 RVm, AVm. See JETHRO. (2) Gideon’s eldest son (Jgs 8 20), who was called upon by his father to slay Zebah and Zal- munnah, but “feared, because he was yet a youth.” The narrative there (8 4ff) should be connected with that of 6 34, where Gideon is followed by his clan, and not with that of ch 7, where he has 300 picked men. The captives would be taken to Or- pah, Gideon’s home, and slain there. (3) Father of Amasa (1 K 2 5.32); he was an Ishmaelite according to 1 Ch 2 17=“Ithra, the Israelite’ of 2S 17 25, where ‘‘the Ishmaelite”’ should be read for “‘the Israelite.” (4) A Jerahmeelite (1 Ch 2 32 bis). (5) A Judahite (1 Ch 4 17). (6) A man of Asher (1 Ch 7 38)=“Ithran” of ver 37. Davip Francis RoBerts JETHETH, jé’theth (1)", ythéth, meaning un- known): A chief (or clan) of Edom (Gen 36 40 || 1 Ch 1 51), but probably a mistake for “Jether” =“Tthran’”’ (Gen 36 26), JETHLAKH, jcth’la (2m, yithlah). See Irauan. JETHRO, jeth’ré, je’thro AIM, yithro, ‘‘excel- lence,” Ex 3 1; 4 18b; 18 1-12 [in 4 18a, probably a textual error, "4", yether, ‘‘Iether,”’ AVm, RVm]; ve? LXX always ’Io0ép, Iothér): The priest of Midian and father-in-law (hdthén) of Moses. It is not easy to determine the relation of J. to Reuel and Hobab. If we identify J. with Reuel as in Ex 218; 31 (and in Ant, III, ili; V, ji, 3), we must connect ‘‘ Moses’ father-in- 1, His Re- j27"" ‘in Nu 10 29 immediately with lation to “Reuel” (AV ‘“Raguel”’), and make Hohab Reuel and the brother-in-law of Moses. But while Hobab it is possible that héthen may be used in akss the wider sense ofa wife's relative, it is nowhere trd ‘‘hrother-in-law’’ except in Jgs 1 16;_4 11 (‘‘father-in-law,"" AV, RVm). If we insert, as Ewald suggests (HI, II, 25), ‘Jethro son of before ‘‘Reuel”’ in Ex 2 18 (cf LXX ver 16, where the name “Jethro” is given), we would then identify J. with Hobab, the son of Reuel, in Nu 10 29, taking ‘‘ Moses father-in-law” to refer back to Hobah. Against this identification, however, it is stated that J. went away into his own country without any effort on the part of Moses to detain him (Ex 18 27), whereas Hohah, though at first he refused to remain with the Israelites, seems to have yielded to the pleadings of Moses to hecome their guide to Canaan (Nu 10 29-32; Jgs 1 16, where Kittel reads ‘‘Hobab the Kenite"; 4 11). It may he noted that while the father-in-law of Moses is spoken of as a “Midianite" in Ex, he is called a ‘‘ Kenite"’ in Jgs 1 16; 411. From this Ewald infers that the Midianites were at that time intimately blended with the Amalekites, to which tribe the Kenites belonged (HI, II, 44). When Moses fled from Egypt he found refuge in Midian, where he received a hearty welcome into the household of J. on account of the 2. His courtesy and kindness he had shown Hearty to the priest’s 7 daughters in helping Reception them to water their flock. This of Moses friendship resulted in J. giving Moses his daughter, Zipporah, to wife (Ex 2 15-21). After Moses had been for about 40 years in the service of his father-in-law, the angel of the Lord appeared to him in the burning bush as he was keeping the flock at Horeb, commanding him to return to Egypt and deliver his enslaved brethren out of the hands of Pharaoh (8 1 ff). With J.’s consent Moses left Midian to carry out the Divine commission (4 18). When tidings reached Midian of “all that God had done for Moses, and for Israel’ in delivering them from Egyp bondage, J., with a 3. His natural pride in the achievements of Visit to his relative, set out on a visit to Moses, Moses in taking Zipporah and her two sons with the Wilder- him (Ex 18 1-12). On learning of ness his father-in-law’s arrival at the ‘mount of God,’ Moses went out to meet him, and after a cordial exchange of courtesies they retired to Moses’ tent, where a pleasant inter- view took place between them. We are told of the interest J. felt in all the particulars of the great de- liverance, how he “rejoiced for all the goodness which Jeh had done to Israel,” and how the con- viction was wrought within him that Jeh was “greater than all gods; yea, in the thing wherein they dealt proudly against them” (ver 11). In this condition so expressed there is evidently a reference to the element by which the Egyptians thought in their high-handed pursuit they would be able to bring back Israel into bondage, but by which they were themselves overthrown. _ It is worth noting that in the religious service in which J. and Moses afterward engaged, when J., as priest, offered a burnt offering, and Aaron with all the elders of Israel partook of the sacrificial feast, prominence was given to J. over Aaron, and thus a priesthood was recognized beyond the limits of Israel. This visit of J. to Moses had important conse- quences for the future government of Israel (Ex ; _ 18 18-27). The priest of Midian 4. His Wise became concerned about his son-in- Counsel law when he saw him occupied from morning to night in deciding the dis- putes that had arisen among the people. The labor 1675 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 4848, Geneal. of Jezebel this entailed, J. said, was far too heavy a burden for one man to bear. Moses himself would soon be worn out, and the people, too, would become weary and dissatisfied, owing to the inability of one judge to overtake all the cases that were brought before him. J., therefore, urged Moses to make use of the talents of others and adopt a plan of gradation of judges who would dispose of all cases of minor importance, leaving only the most difficult for him to settle by a direct appeal to the will of God. Moses, recognizing the wisdom of his father- in-law’s advice, readily acted upon his suggestion and appointed ‘‘able men out of all Israel, and made them heads over the people, rulers of thousands, rulers of hundreds, rulers of fifties, and rulers of tens.’ Thereafter, J. returned to his own country. The story of J. reveals him as a man of singular attractiveness and strength,in whom a kind, con- siderate disposition, a deeply religious 5. His spirit, and a wise judgment all met Character in happy combination. And this an- and In- cient priest of Midian made Israel and fluence all nations his debtors when he taught the distinction between the legislative and the judicial function, and the importance of securing that all law be the expression of the Divine will, and that its application be entrusted only to men of ability, piety, integrity and truth (Ex 18 21). JamMEs CRICHTON JETUR, jé’tur (170, ytdr, meaning uncertain): A “son” of Ishmael (Gen 26 15 jj) 1 Ch 1 31); against this clan the two and a half tribes warred (1 Ch 5 18f); they are the Ituraeans of NT times. See Irurazra. JEUEL, jé-t’el, ji’el Ox _y @ él, meaning un- known): ; (1) A man of Judah (1 Ch 9 6); the name is not found in the || of Neh 11 24. (2) A Levite, AV ‘‘Jeiel” (2 Ch 29 138). (3) A companion of Ezra, AV ‘“‘Jeiel’’ (Ezr 8 13). (4) The name oceurs also as K°thibh in 1 Ch 9 35; 2 Ch 26 11. See Jemmt, (2), (6). JEUSH, jée’ush (W197, y‘ush, probably “he pro- tects,’ “he comes to help”; see TPN, 109; Kethibh is OD, yish, in Gen 36 5.14; 1 Ch 7 10): (1) A “son” of Esau (Gen 36 5.14.18; 1 Ch 1 35). “The name is thought by some to be identical with that of an Arabian lion-god Yagut...., meaning ‘helper,’ whose antiquity is vouched for by inscriptions of Thamud”’ (Skinner, Gen, 482). (2) A Benjamite (1 Ch 7 10), but probably a Zebulunite. See Curtis, Ch, 145 ff. (3) A descendant of King Saul, AV “Jehush” (1 Ch 8 39). ; (4) A Gershonite Levite (1 Ch 23 10.11). (5) A son of King Rehoboam (2 Ch 11 19). Davip Francis Ropers JEUZ, je’uz (7197, yde, “he counsels’): The eponym of a Benjamite family (1 Ch 8 10). W, ju, jo0, JEWESS, JEWISH, ji'ish, joo'ish ote a aL Beane yhadhim; "Lov8ato., Toudatoi; adj.f. DTW), ychudhith; "lovbaikés, Jou- daikés): ‘““Jew’’ denotes originally an inhabitant of Judah (2 K 16 6 applies to the two tribes of the Southern Kingdom), but later the meaning was extended to embrace all descendants of Abraham. In the OT the word occurs a few times in the sing. (Est 2 5; 3 4, ete; Jer 34 9; Zee 8 23); very fre- quently in the pl. in Ezr and Neh, Est, and in Jer and Dnl. The adj. in the OT applies only to the “Jews’ language” or speech (2 K 18 26.28 | Neh 13 24; Isa 36 11.13). “Jews” (always pl.) is the familiar term for Israelites in the Gospels (esp. in Jn), Acts, Epp., ete. ‘Jewess”’ occursin 1 Ch 4 18; Acts 16 1; 24 24. In Tit 1 14 a warning is given against ‘Jewish fables” (in Gr the adj. is found also in Gal 2 14). The “‘Jews’ religion” (Ioudaismés) is referred to in Gal 1 13.14. On the ‘Jews’ lan- guage,”’ see LANGUAGES OF THE OT; on the “Jews’ religion,” see IsranL, RELIGION or. JAMES ORR JEWEL, ji’el, js0’el: An ornament of gold, silver or of precious stones in the form of armlet, bracelet. anklet, nose-ring, etc. Oriental dress yields itself freely to such adornment, to which there are many allusions in Scripture. A frequent term in Heb is kelt (“utensil,’”’ “vessel’’), coupled with mention of “gold” or “silver” or both (Gen 24 53; Ex 3 22; 11 2; 12 35; 35 22: 1 § 6 8.15, ete; RVin2 Ch 32 27 tr® ‘‘vessels’). In Cant 1 10, where AV has “rows [of jewels],”” RV has “plaits [of hair]’’; in 7 1, the word is from a root halah, meaning “to adorn.” ‘In 3 instances in AV “jewel’’ represents the Heb nezem (Prov 11 22; Isa 3 21; Ezk 16 12); ARV changes Prov 11 22 to “ring” (LXX here=“‘earring’’), and both ERV and ARV have “ring” in Ezk 16 12. The familiar phrase in Mal 3 17, “in that day when I make up my jewels,” becomes in ERV, “in the day that I do make, even a peculiar treasure’ (m “or, wherein I do make a peculiar treasure’), and im ARV, “even mine own possession, in the day that I make’ (m “or, do this”). See, further, ORNamENT; Dress; Stones, PRECIOUS. JAMES ORR JEWRY, ji’ri, joo’ri: In Dn] 6 13 AV, where RV has ‘Judah’; in the NT, in two places in AV Lk 23 5; Jn 7 1, where RV has correctly “Judaea’ (Ioudata) (q.v.). JEWS, jiiz, jo6z. See Jew. JEZANIAH, jez-a-ni’a (UT), yzanyahi, prob- ably “Jeh hears’; cf JaazaniaH): In Jer 40 8, and also 42 1 where LXX has “‘Azariah,”’ as in 48 2 (see Driver, Jer)=Jaazaniau, (1) (q.v.). JEZEBEL, jez’é-bel (AhN, "tzebhel, “unexalted,” “anhusbanded” [?]; "Le{aBed, Iezdbel; see BDB; 1 K 16 31; 18 4.13.19; 19 1.2; 21 5ff; 2 K 9 7ff.30ff; Rev 2 20): Daughter of Ethbaal, king of the Zido- nians, i.e. Phoenicians, and queen of Ahab, king of Northern Israel. Ahab (c 874-853 BC) carried out a policy, which his father had perhaps started, of making alliances with other states. The alliance with the Phoenicians was cemented by his marriage with J., and he subsequently gave his daughter Athaliah in marriage to Jehoram, son of Jehosha- phat, king of Judah. His own union with Jezebel is regarded as asin in 1 K 16 31, where the MT is difficult, being generally understood as a question. The LXX tr*: “And it was not enough that he should walk in the sins of Jeroboam ben Nebat, he also took to wife Jezebel,”’ etc. The Heb ean be pointed to mean, ‘‘And it was the lightest thing for him to walk in the sins of Jeroboam ben Nebat, he also took to wife Jezebel, and went and served Baal and wor- shipped him,” i.e. all the other sins were light as compared with the marriage with Jezebel and the serving of Baal (cf Mic 6 16). Is this a justifiable view to take of the marriage? One answer would be that Ahab made a wise alliance; that Baal- worship was not non-Heb, that Ahab named his children not after Baal but after Jeh (cf Ahaziah, Jehoram, Athaliah), and that he consulted the prophets of Jeh (cf 1 K 22 6); further, that he only did what Solomon had done on a much larger scale; it may be added too that Ahab was in favor of religious toleration, and that Elijah and not the king is the persecutor. What then can be said for Jezebel Joab THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1676 the unfavorable verdict of the Heb historians? That verdict is based on the results and effects of the marriage, on the life and character of J., and in that life two main incidents demand attention. This is not described; it is only referred to in 1 K 18 4, “when J. cut off the prophets of Jeh”; and this shows the history of the time to 1. Perse- be incompletely related. In 1 K 18 cution of 19 we are further told that ‘450 Jeh’s prophets of Baal ate at her table’ Prophets (commentators regard the reference to “400 prophets of the Asherah”’ as an ad- dition). In 1 K 19 1 Ahab tells J. of the slaughter of the prophets of Baal by Elijah, and then J. (19 2) sends a messenger to Elijah to threaten his life. This leads to the prophet’s flight, an object which J. had in view, perhaps, for she would hardly dare to murder Elijah himself. 2 K 9 7 regards the massacre of Ahah’s family as a punishment for the persecution of the prophets by J. Ahab expresses a desire to possess the vineyard neigh- boring upon his palace in Jezreel, owned by Nahoth, who refuses to part with the family inherit- 2. Jezebel’s ance though offered either its money value s or a better vineyard in exchange. Ahab Plot Against is depressed at this, and J., upou finding the Naboth cause of his melancholy feelings, asks him (1 K 21) sarcastically if he is not king, suggesting that as king his wishes should he imme- diately jie by his subjects. She there- upon plots to secure him Nahoth's vineyard. J. sends letters sealed in Ahah's name to the elders of Naboth's township, and bids them arrange a public fast and make Naboth ‘‘sit at the head of the people"’ (RVm), a phrase taken by some to mean that he is to be arraigned, while it is explained hy others as meaning that Naboth is to be given the chief place. Two witnesses—a sufficient number for that purpose—are to be brought to accuse Naboth of blasphemy and treason. This is done, and Naboth is found guilty, and stoned to death. The property is confiscated, and falls to the king (vs 1-I6). lijah hears of this, and is sent to threaten Ahab with Divine vengeance; dogs shall lick his dead hody (ver 19). But in vs 20-23 this prophecy is made, not con- cerning Ahab but against Jezebel, and ver 25 attributes the sins of Ahab to her influence over him. The prophecy js fulfilled in 2 K 9 30-37. Ahaziah and Jehoram had succeeded their father Ahab; the one reigned for 2 years (1 K 22 51), the other 12 years (2 K 3 Jehu heads a revolt against the house of Ahah, and one day comes to Jezreel. J. had ‘‘ painted her eyes, and attired her head," and sees Jehu coming. She greets him sarcastically as his master's murderer. Ac- cording to MT, Jehu asks, “‘ Who is on my side? who?”’ but the text is emended by Klostermann, following LXX in the main, ‘' Who art thou that thou shouldest find fault with me?" i.e, thou art but a murderess thyself. She is then thrown down and the horses tread upon_her (reading ‘‘they trod'’ for ‘‘he trod"' in ver 33). When search is afterward made for her remains, they are found terribly mutilated. Thus was the prophecy fulfilled. (Some comms. hold that Nahoth's vineyard and Ahah’s garden were in Samaria, and Nahoth a Jezreelite. The words, ‘‘which was in Jezreel,”’ of 1 K 21 I are wanting in L.XX, which has ‘‘And Naboth had a vineyard by the threshing-floor of Ahab king of Samaria.'’ But cf 1K 18 45; 21 23; 2 K 8 29; 9 10.15 7.307.) See Anap; JEau. The character of J. is seen revived in that of her daughter, Athaliah of Judah (2 K 11); there is no doubt that J. was a powerful person- 3. Jezebel’s ality. She brought the worship of Character the Phoen Baal and Astarte with her into Heb life, and indirectly introduced it into Judah as well as into the Northern King- dom. In judging her connection with this propa- gation, we should bear in mind that she is not a queen of the 20th cent.; she must be judged in company with other queens famous in_ history. Her religious attitude and zeal might profitably be compared with that of Mary, queen of Scots. It must also be remembered that the introduction of any religious change is often resented when it comes from a foreign queen, and is apt to be misunder- stood, e.g. the attitude of Greece to the proposal of Queen Olga to have an authorized edition of the Bible in modern Gr. , On the other hand, although much may be said that would be favorable to J. from the religious standpoint, the balance is heavy against her when we remember her successful plot against Naboth. It is not perhaps blameworthy in her that she upheld the religion of her native land, although the nat- ural thing would have been to follow that of her adopted land (cf Ruth 1 16f). The superiority of Jeh-worship was not as clear then as it is to us today. It may also be held that Baal-worship was not unknown in Heb life (cf Jgs 6 25 f), that Baal of Canaan had become incorporated with Jeh of Sinai, and that there were pagan elements in the worship of the latter. But against all this it: must be clear that the Baal whom J. attempted to intro- duce was the Phoen Baal, pure and simple; he was another god, or rather in him was presented an idea of God very different from Jeh. And further, “in Phoenicia, where wealth and luxury had been enjoyed on a scale unknown to either Israel or the Canaanites of the interior, there was a refinement, if one may so speak, and at the same time a prodi- gality of vicious indulgences, connected with the worship of Baal and Astarte to which Israel had hitherto been a stranger... .. It was like a cancer eating into the vitals or a head and heart sickness resulting in total decay (Isa 1 6). In Israel, moral deterioration meant political as well as spiritual death. The weal of the nation lay in fidelity to Jeh alone, and in His pure worship’ (7PM, §213). The verdict of the Heb historian is thus sub- stantiated. J. is an example—an extreme one no doubt—of the bad influence of a highly developed civilization forcing itself with all its sins upon a community less highly civilized, but possessed of nobler moral and religious conceptions. She has parallels both in family and in national life. For a parallel to Elijah’s attitude toward J. cf the words of Carlyle about Knox in On Heroes and Hero- Worship, IV, esp. the section, ‘“We blame Knox for his intolerance,” etc. In Rev 2 20, we read of Jezabel, “the woman Jezebel, who calleth herself a prophetess’; not “thy wife” (i.e. the wife of the bishop) RVm, but as Mof- fat (Expos Gr Test.) aptly renders, ‘‘that Jezebel of a woman alleging herself a prophetess.’’ Some members of the church at Thyatira ‘‘under the sway of an influential woman refused to separate from the local guilds where moral interests, though not ostensibly defied, were often seriously com- promised..... Her lax principles or tendencies made for a connection with foreign and compro- mising associations which evidently exerted a dan- gerous influence upon some weaker Christians in the city.” Her followers ‘prided themselves upon their enlightened liberalism (ver 24).” Moffat rejects both the view of Schtirer (Theol. Abhand- lungen, 39{), that she is to be identified with the Chaldaean Sibyl at Thyatira, and also that of Selwyn making her the wife of the local asiarch. “It was not the cults but the trade guilds that formed the problem at Thyatira.” Sce also Zahn, Intro to the NT, § 73, 0.7; Anas; Baau; Exiag. : Davi Francis Roperts JEZELUS, je-zé'lus, jez'é-lus (’letq\os, Iezélos): (1) In 1 Esd 8 32; called ‘“Jahaziel” in Ezr 8 5. (2) In 1 Esd 8 35; called “Jehiel” in Ezr 8 9. " JEZER, je'zér (IZ), yecer, “form” or “purpose”): “son” of Naphtali (Gen 46 24; Nu 26 49: 1 Ch: 7 13): oor , JEZERITES, jé’zér-its, THE (ET, ha-yigri [collective with art.]): Descendants of “Jezer”’ (Nu 26 49). JEZIAH, jé-zi'a. See Izztaz. 1677 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jezebel Joab JEZIEL, jé’zi-cl, jé-ziel (Kethibh is DX", y'2i’él, or D84TY, yzd’el; Keré SNM, yezi’al= “God gathers,” perhaps): One of David’s Benjamite recruits at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 3). JEZLIAH, jez-li’a. JEZOAR, jé-zi/ar. See IzHar. JEZRAHIAH, jez-ra-hi’a. See IzraHran. JEZREEL, jez‘ré-el, jez‘rél (SNP, yizr'e’l, “God soweth”’): (1) A city on the border of the territory of Issachar (Josh 19 18). It is named with Chesul- loth and Shunem (modern Jksal and 1. Territory Sdlam). It remained loyal to the house of Saul, and is mentioned as part of the kingdom over which Abner set Ish- bosheth (2 S 2 9). From Jezreel came the tidings of Saul and Jonathan’s death on Gilboa, which brought disaster to Mephibosheth (2 8 4 4). The city plays no important part in the history till the time of Ahab. Attracted, doubtless, by the fine position and natural charms of the place, he made it one of his royal residences, building here a palace (1 K 211). This was evidently on the eastern wall; and the gate by which Jehu entered was over- looked by the quarters of Queen Jezebel (2 K 9 30f). ‘The royal favor naturally enhanced the dignity of the city, and ‘elders’ and ‘nobles’ of Jezreel are mentioned (1 K 21 8, etc). Under the influence of Jezebel, an institution for the worship of Baal was founded here, from which, probably, the men were drawn who figured in the memorable con- test with Elijah on Carmel (2 K 1011). ‘“Thetower in Jezreel” was part of the defences of the city. It commanded a view of the approach up the valley from Beth-shean—the way followed by the hordes of the E., who, from time immemorial, came west- ward for the rich pasture of the plain (2 K 9 17). It was necessary also to keep constant watch, as - the district E. of the Jordan was always more un- settled than that on the W.; and danger thence might appear at any moment. The garden of Naboth seems to have lain to the E. of the city (2 K 9 21), near the royal domain, to which Ahab desired to add it as a garden of herbs (1 K 21 1 ff). See Nasora. This was the scene of the tragic meetings between Elijah and Ahab (1 K 21 17 ff), and between Jehu and Joram and Ahaziah (2 K 9 21). Joram had returned to Jezreel from Ramoth- gilead to be healed of his wounds (9 15). By the gateway the dogs devoured Jezebel’s body (vs 31 ff). Naboth had been stoned to death outside the city (1 K 21 13). Jos lays the scene by the fountain of Jezreel, and here, he says, the dogs licked the blood washed from the chariot of Ahab (Ant, VIII, xv, 6). This accords with 1 K 21 19; but 22 38 points to the pool at Samaria. The site of Jezreel must be sought in a position where a tower would command a view of the road coming up the valley from Beth-shean. It has long been See Iziian. 2. Identi- the custom to identify it wlth the modern eeu village, Zer‘in, on the northwestern spur of fication Gilboa. This meets the above condition; and it also agrees with the indications in Onom as lying between Legio (Lejjan) and Scythopolis (Beisan). “Recently, however, Professor A. R. S. Mac- alister made a series of excavations here, and failed to find any evidence of ancient Israelite occupation. This casts douht upon the identification, and further excavatlon is necessary before any certain conclusion can be reached. For the “fountain which is in Jezreel,’' see Harop, WELL OF. (2) An unidentified town in the uplands of Judah (Josh 15 56), the home of Ahinoam (1 S 27 38, etc). W. Ewine JEZREEL, VALE OF. See EsprarLon, PLAIN OF. JEZREELITE, jez’ré-cl-it, jez/rélit CONT, ha-yizr@lt): Applied to Naboth, a native of Jez- reel (1) (1 K 21 1, ete). JEZREELITESS, jez‘ré-cl-it-ea, jez‘rél-it-es (MSRM , yizre’lith, “of Jezreel,” fem.): Applied to Ahinoam, one of David’s first two wives, a native of Jezreel in Judah (1 S 27 3; 305; 25 2 2; 32; 1 Ch 3 1). JEZRIELUS, jez-ri-é’lus (’Tetpejdos, Tezriélos; AV Hierielus; 1 Esd 9 27): Corresponding to “‘Jehiel’’ in Ezr 10 26. JIBSAM, jib’sam. JIDLAPH, jid'laf (99°, yidhlaph, perhaps “he weeps”): A “son” of Nahor (Gen 22 22). JIMNA, JIMNAG, jim’na (73'0", yimnah, per- haps=“good fortune’): A “son” of Asher (Gen 46 17, AV “Jimnah”’; Nu 26 44, AV “Jimna”’), whereas RV has Imnag (q.v.). JIMNITES, jim’nits, THE (same as “Jimna,” only collective with the def. art.; Nu 26 44 AV, where RV has “Imnites’’): Descendants of Jimna or Imna. JIPHTAH, jif'ta (MD?, yiphiah). JIPHTHAHEL, jif’tha-el. JOAB, jO’ab (ANT, ys'abh, ‘“Jeh is father’; TwdB, Tad): (1) Sori of Zeruiah, David’s sister. He was ‘captain of the host”’ (cf 2 S 19 13) under David. (a) Joab is first introduced in the narrative of the war with Abner, who supported the claims of Ishbosheth to the throne against those 1. Joab of David (28 2 8—3 1). The two and Abner armies met, and on Abner’s suggestion a tournament took place between 12 men from each side; a general engagement follows, and in this J.’s army is victorious. Asahel, J.’s brother, is killed in his pursuit of Abner, but the latter’s army is sorely pressed, and he appeals to J. for a cessation of hostilities. J. calls a halt, but declares that he would not cease had Abner not made _his plea. (b) 2S 3 12-29. Abner visits David at, Hebron, and makes an alliance with David. He then leaves the town, apparently under royal protection. J. is absent at the time, but returns immediately after Abner’s departure, and expostulates with David for not avenging Asahel’s death, and at the same time attributes a bad motive to Abner’s visit. He sends a message, no doubt in the form of a royal command, for Abner to return; the chief does so, is taken aside ‘“‘into the midst of the gate” (or as LXX and commentators read, ‘into the side of the gate,” 3 27), and slain there by J. David pro- claims his own innocence in the matter, commands J. as well as the people to mourn publicly for the dead hero (3 31), composes a lament for Abner, and pronounces a curse upon J. and his descendants (ver 30 is regarded as an editorial note, and com- mentators change ver 39). (a) 28 10 1-14; 1 Ch 19 1-15. David sends ambassadors with his good wishes to Hanun on his ascending the throne of the Ammon- 2. The Am- ites; these are ill-treated, and war See Ipsam. See IPHTAH. See IpHTAHEL. monite follows, David’s troops being com- War: manded by J. On finding himself Death of placed between the Ammonites on the Uriah one hand, and their Syrian allies on the other, he divides his army, and himself leads one division against the Syrians, Joab Job, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1678 leaving Abishai, his brother, to fight the Ammonites; the defeat of the Syrians is followed by the rout of the Ammonites. (b) 28 10 15-19; 1 Ch 19 16-19 describes a second war between Hadarezer and David. J. is not mentioned here. (c) 2 § 11 1 narrates the resumption of the war against the Ammonites; J. is in command, and the town of Rabbah is besieged. Here occurs the account of David’s sin with Bathsheba, omitted by Ch. David gets J. to send Uriah, her husband, to Jerus, and when he refuses to break the soldier’s vow (11 6-13), J. is used to procure Uriah’s death in the siege, and the general then sends news of it to David (11 14-27). After capturing the ‘water- city’ of Rabbah, J. sends for David to complete the - capture and lead the triumph himself (12 26-29). (a) The next scene depicts J. attempting and succeeding in his attempt to get Absalom restored to royal favor. He has noticed that 3. Joab and “the king’s heart is toward Absalom” Absalom (14 1), and so arranges for “a wise woman” of Tekoa to bring a supposed complaint of her own before the king, and then rebuke him for his treatment of Absalom. The plan succeeds. David sees J.’s band in it, and gives him permission to bring Absalom to Jerus. But the rebel has to remain in his own house, and is not allowed to see his father (14 1-24). (b) Absalom attempts to secure J.’s intercession for a complete restoration to his father’s confidence. J. turns a deaf ear to the request until his field is put on fire by Absalom’s command. He then sees Absalom, and gets David to receive his prodigal son back into the royal home (14 28-33). (c) Absalom revolts, and makes Amasa, another nephew of David, general instead of J. (17 24f). David flees to Mahanaim, followed by Absalom. J. is given a third of the army, the other divisions being led by Abishai and Ittai. He is informed that Absalom has been caught in a tree (or thicket), and expostulates with the informer for not having killed him. Although he is reminded of David's tender plea that Absalom be kindly dealt with, he dispatches the rebel himself, and afterward calls for a general halt of the army. When David gives vent to his feelings of grief, he is sternly rebuked by J., and the rebuke has its effect (17—19 8a). 28 19 8b-15. On David’s return to Jerus, Amasa is made ‘‘captain of the host” instead of J. (19 13). Then Sheba revolts, Amasa 4. Joab and loses time in making preparation for Amasa quelling it, and Abishai is bidden by David to take the field (20 6). The Syr VS reads ‘‘J.” for “Abishai” in this verse, and some commentators follow it, but LX X supports MT. J. seems to have accompanied Abishai; and when Amasa meets them at Gibeon, J., on pretense of kissing his rival, killshim. Hethen assumes com- mand, is followed by Amasa’s men, and arranges with a woman of Abel beth-maacah to deliver to him Sheba’s head. The revolt is then at an end. J. subsequently opposed David’s suggestion of a census, but eventually carried it out (2 S 24 1-9; 1 Ch 21 1-6), yet 1 Ch 21 6 and 27 5. Joab’s 24 relate that he did not carry it Death out fully. He was one of Adonijah’s supporters in his claim to the throne (1 K 1 7.19.41). For this he had to pay the penalty with bis life, being slain at the altar in the “Tent of Jeh” (1 K 2 28-34) by Benaiah, who acted upon Solomon’s orders. His murderer became his suc- cessor as head of the army. 1 K 2 5 makes David advise Solomon not to forget that J. slew Abner and Amasa, and 1 K 11 14-22 contains a reference to the dread of his name in Edom. 1 Ch 11 6 makes him win bis spurs first at the capture of Jerus, but 2S 2, 3 are previous in time to this event (cf 2 85 6-10), and 1 Ch 11 8 makes him repair the city, while 1 Ch 26 28 refers to a dedication of armor by him. In summing up J.’s character, we must remember the stirring times in which he lived. That he was a most able general, there is no doubt. 6. Joab’s He was, however, very jealous of his Character position, and this accounts for Amasa’s murder, if not partially for that of Abner too: if he was afraid that Abner would sup- plant him, that fear may be held to be justified, for Amasa, who had not been too loyal to David did take J.’s place for a time. But blood revenge for Asahel’s death was perhaps the chief cause. Yet even when judged in the light of those rough times, and in the light of eastern life, the murder of Abner was a foul, treacherous deed (see Trumbull, Studies in Oriental Social Life, 129-31). } J. opposed the census probably because It was an innovation. His rebuke of David’s great grief over Absalom’s death can only be characterized as just; he is the stern warrior who, after being once merciful and forgiving, will not again spare a deceitful rebel; and yet David shows how a father’s conduct toward a prodigal, rebellious son is not regulated by stern justice. J.’s unswerving loyalty to David leads one to believe that no dis- loyalty was meant by his support of Adonijah, who was really the rightful heir to the throne. But their plans were defeated by those of the harem, and J. had to pay the price with his life. Taken as a whole, his life, as depicted in the very reliable narrative of 2 S and 1 K, may be said to be as characteristic of the times as that of David himself, with a truly Homeric ring about it. He was a great man, great in military prowess and also in personal revenge, in his loyalty to the king as well as in his stern rebuke of his royal master. He was the greatest of David’s generals, and the latter’s success and glory owed much to this noblest of that noble trio whom Zeruiah bore. (2) A Judahite, father or founder of Ge-harashim . (1 Ch 4 14, “valley of craftsmen’? RVm). See GE-HARASHIM. (3) A family of returned exiles (Ezr 2 6 || Neh 7 11; Ezr 8 9; 1 Esd 8 35). (4) See ATROTH-BETH-JOAB. : Davip Francis RoBERTS JOACHAZ, jo’a-kaz (Iwxét, Lochdz, "lexovlas, fechonias): Son of Josiah (1 Esd 1 34). In Mt ‘1 11 “Jechoniah”’ is the reading. JOACIM, jd’a-sim. See Joakim. JOADANUS, jo-a-da’nus (IwaSdvos, Jdaddnos): In 1 Esd 9 19, apparently, through some corrup- tion; the same as Gedaliah, a son of Jeshua, the son of Jozadak, in Ezr 10 18. JOAH, jo’a (IRN, yo’ah, “Jeh is brother’): _(1) Son of Asaph and recorder under King Heze- kiah (2 K 18 18.26; Isa 36 3.11.22); he was one of the 3 officers sent by the king to speak to the Assyr envoys at the siege of Jerus (c 701 BC). (2) In 1 Ch 6 21 (Heb 6); 2 Ch 29 12, a Levite (son of Zimmah)=‘‘Ethan” of 1 Ch 6 42 (Heb 27). (3) A son of Obed-edom (1 Ch 26 4). ; (4) Son of Joahaz and recorder under King Josiah (2 Ch 34 8). JOAHAZ, ji’a-haz (TNT, yo’ahaz, “Jeh has grasped” =‘‘Jehoahaz’’): (1) Father of Joan (4) (2 Ch 34 8). (2) RV and Heb in 2 K 14 1 for Jehoahaz, king of Israel. See JnHoauaz. 1679 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joab Job, Book of _(3) RV and Heb in 2 Ch 36 2.4 for Jenoanaz, king of Judah (q.v.). JOAKIM, AV Joacim): (1) Jehoiakim, king of Judah and Jerus (1 Esd 1 37-39; Bar 1 3). (2) Jehoiachin, son of (1) (1 Esd 1 48). (3) Son of Jeshua (1 Esd 5 5), called by mistake son of Zerubbabel; in Neh 12 10.26 his name occurs as in 1 Esd, among the priests and Levites who returned to Jerus with Zerubbabel. (4) High priest of Jerus in the time of Baruch (Bar 1 7). (5) High priest in Jerus in the days of Judith who F along with “the ancients of the children of Israel,’ welcomed the heroine back to the city after the death of Holofernes (Jth 4). He cannot be identi- fied with any of the high priests in the lists given in 1 Ch or in Jos, Ant, X, viii, 6. The word means “the Lord hath set up.” It is probably symbolical, and tends with other names occurring in the narra- tive to establish the supposition that the book was a work of imagination composed to support the faith of the Jews in times of stress and difficulty. (6) The husband of Susanna (Sus vs 1 ff), perbaps here also a symbolical name. J. Horcuison jo’a-kim (Iwaxely, Idaketm; - JOANAN, jé-a’nan (Ieavay WH, Idandn; 'To- avva TR, Idannd; AV Joanna): (1) A grandson of Zerubbabel in the genealogy of Jesus according to St. Luke (3 27). (2) Theson of Eliasib(1 Esd 9 1 AV, RV Jonas”). JOANNA, jé-an’a (Clwdva, Jédna, or 'Iwdvva, Iédnna): The wife of Chuzas, Herod’s steward. She was one of the “women who had been healed of evil spirits and infirmities” which “ministered unto him [AV, i.e. Jesus, or “them” RV, ie. Jesus and His disciples] of their substance,” on the occa- sion of Jesus’ tour through Galilee (Lk 8 2.3). Along with other women she accompanied Jesus on His last journey from Galilee to Jerus, and was present when His body was laid in the sepulcher (Lk 28 55). She was thus among those who pre- pared spices and ointments, who found the grave empty, and who “told these things unto the apostles”: (Lk 28 56—24 10). C. M. Kerr JOANNES, jé-an’es, jé-an’éz (Twdvvys, [odnnés; AV Johannes): (1) Son of Acatan (1 Esd 8 38), called also “Johanan” in Ezr 8 12. (2) Son of Bebai (1 Esd 9 29), called “Jehohan- an’ in Ezr 10 28. JOARIB, ja’a-rib’ ("IwapiB, Zdarib; AV Jarib): Ancestor of Mattathias (1 Macc 14 29), given as “Joarib” in AV of 1 Macc 2 1; he was chief of the first of the 24 courses of priests in the reign of David. Varieties of the name are Jarib, Joarib, and Je- hoiarib (1 Ch 24 7). JOASH, jo’ash (UNM, yad’ash, “Ich is strong” or “Jeh has bestowed’’; ’Iwds, Jods): ; (1) Father of Gideon, of the clan of Abiezer and the tribe Manasseh (Jgs 6 11.29.30.31; 7 14; 8 13.29.32). Gideon declares (6 15) that the family is the poorest in Manasseh, words similar to those of Saul (1 S 9 21), and not to be taken too literally. J. would be a man of standing and wealth, for Gideon was able to command 10 servants to destroy the altar and the Asherah (Jgs 6 27.34), and also to summon the whole clan to follow him. Further, the altar that J. had was that used by the com- munity (6 28), so that he would be the priest, not only of his own family qué paterfamilias, but also of the community in virtue of his position as chief. When Gideon destroyed the altar and the Asherah or sacred pillar by it, J. refused to deliver his son to death, declaring that Baal, if he was a god, should aveuge himself (cf Elijah in 1 K 18). (2) Called ‘‘the king’s son” (1 K 22 26; 2 Ch 18 25; cf Jer 36 26; 38 6), or, less probably, “‘the son of Hammelech,’’ RVm; perhaps a son of Ahab. Micaiah the prophet was handed over to his custody and that of Amon by Ahab. (3) A Judahite, descendant of Shelah (1 Ch 4 2 ). (4) A Benjamite recruit of David at Ziklag. Commentators read here, ‘J. the son of Shemaiah {or Jehoshamai], the Gibeathite” (1 Ch 12 3). (5) In2 K 11 2, ete=Jehoash, king of Judah. (6) In2 K 13 9, ete=Jehoash, king of Northern Israel. Daviv Francis RoBERTS JOASH (W715, yo'ash, “Jeh has aided”): (1) A Benjamite, or, more probably, a Zebulunite (1 Ch 7 8). (2) One of David’s officers; J. was ‘over the eellars of oil”? (1 Ch 27 28). JOATHAM, jo’a-tham (Iwé@ap, Iddtham): AV for RV “Jotham” (Mt 19). See JorHam (the king). JOB, job (AVS, ’Zydbh, meaning of name doubt- ful; some conjecturing “object of enmity,” others “he who turns,” etc, to God; both uncertain guesses; '168, [6b): The titular hero of the Book of Job, represented as a wealthy and pious land- holder who lived in patriarchal times, or at least conditions, in the land of Uz, on the borders of Idumaea. Outside of the Book of Job he is mentioned by Ezekiel (Ezk 14 14.20) as one of 3 great personages whose representative righteousness would presumably avail, if that of any mdividuals could, to redeem the nation; ‘the other two being Noah, an ancient patriarch, and Daniel, a con- temporary of the prophet. It is difficult to deter- mine whether J. was an actual personage or not. If known through legend, it must have been on account of some such experience as is narrated in the book, ah experience unique enough to have become a otent household word; still, the power and in- finence of it is due to the masterly vigor and exposi- tion of the story. It was the J. of literature, rather than the J. of legend, who lived in the hearts of men; a character so commanding that, albeit fictitious, it could be referred to as real, just as we refer to Hamlet or Othello. It is not the way of Heb writers, however, to evolve literary heroes from pure imagination; they crave an authentic basis of fact. It is probable that such a basis, in its essen- tial outlines, existed under the story of Job. Itis not necessary to suppose, however, that the legend or the name was known to Israel from ancient times. Job is introduced (Job 1 1) as if he had not been known before. The writer, who through- out the book shows a wide acquaintance with the world, doubtless found the legend somewhere, and drew its meanings together for an undying message to his and all times. JouN FRANKLIN GENUNG JOB, BOOK OF: I. INTRODUCTORY 1. Place in the Canon 2. Rank and Readers Il. Tue Lirerary Framework 1. Setting of Time, Place and Scene 2, Characters and Personality 3. Form and Style If. THe Course or THe Story A) To Job’s Blessing and Curse 1. His ‘Autumn Days” . The Wager in Heaven . The Silent Friends 4, Whose Way Is Hid wre Job, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1680 B) To Joh’s Ultimatum of Protest 1. The Veiled Impeachment 2. Wisdom Insipid, Friends Doubtful 3. Crookedness of the Order of Things 4. No Mediation in Sight C) To Job’s Ultimatum of Faith 1. Detecting the Friends’ Faise Note 2. Staking All on Integrity 3. ‘Ifa Man Die” 4. The Surviving Next of Kin D) To Job’s Verdict on Things as They Arc | Climax and Subsidence of the Friends’ Charge 2. The Reai Cause of Job’s Dismay 3. Manhood in the Ore 4. Job Reads His Indictment E£) The Dénouement 1. The Self-constituted Interpreter 2. The Whirlwind and the Voice 3. The Thing That Is Right 4. The Restored Situation IV. Tue Prospiem ano THE PURPOSE 1. Beyond the Didactic Tether 2. What Comes of Limiting the Purpose 3. The Book’s Own Import of Purpose 4. Problem of the Intrinsic Man V. Consroprations or AGE ANo Serrino 1. Shadowy Contacts with History 2. Place in Bib. Literature 3. Parallels and Echoes LiveRATURE I. Introductory.—The greatest production of the Heb Wisdom literature, and one of the supreme literary creations of the world. Its 1. Place in place in the Heb Canon corresponds the Canon to the high estimation in which it was held; it stands in the 3d section, the “writings” (kethabhim) or Hagiographa, next after the two great anthologies Pss and Prov; apparently put thus near the head of the list for weighty read- ing and meditation. In the Gr Canon (which ours follows), it is put with the poetical books, standing at their head. It is one of 3 Scripture books, the others being Pss and Prov, for which the later Heb scholars (the Massoretes) employed a special system of punctuation to mark its poetic character. The Book of Job was not one of the books desig- nated for public reading in the synagogues, as were the Pent and the Prophets, or for 2. Rank occasional reading at feast seasons, as and were the 5 megilloth or rolls. It was Readers rather a book for private reading, and one whose subject-matter would appeal esp. to the more cultivated and thoughtful classes. Doubtless it was all the more intimately valued for this detachment from sanctuary associations; it was, like Prov, a people’s book; and esp. among the cultivators of Wisdom it must have been from its first publication a cherished classic. At any rate, the patriarch Job (though whether from the legend or from the finished book is not clear; see Jos) is mentioned as a well-known national type by Ezk (14 14.20); and James, writing to Jewish Christians (6 11), refers to the character of ithe patriarch as familiar to his readers. It was as one of the great classic stories of their lit., rather than as embodying a ritual or prophetic standard, that it was so universally known and cherished. I. The Literary Framework.—In view of the numerous critical questions by which the inter- pretation of the book has been beclouded—ques- tions of later alterations, additions, corruptions, dislocations—it may be well to say at the outset that what is here proposed is to consider the Book of Job as we have it before us today, in its latest and presumably definitive edition. It will be time enough to remove exerescences when a fair view of the book as it is, with its literary values and rela- tions, makes us sure that there are such; see III, below. Meanwhile, as a book that has reached a stage so fixed and finished that at any rate modern tinkering cannot materially change it, we may consider what its literary framework does to justify itself. And first of all, we may note that preémi- ~— nently among Scripture books it bears the matured literary stamp; both in style and structure it is a work, not only of spiritual edification, but of finished literary art. This may best be realized, perhaps, by taking it, as from the beginning it purports to be, as a continuously maintained story, with the consistent elements of plot, character scheme, and narrative movement which we nat- urally associate with a work of the narrator’s art. The story of the Book of Job is laid in the far-off patriarchal age, such a time as we find elsewhere represented only in the Book of Gen; a time long before the Israelitish state, with its religions, social and political organization, existed. Its place is “the land, of Uz,” a little-known region S.E. of Pal, on the borders of Edom; a place remote from the ways of thinking péculiar to Israelitish lawgivers, priests and prophets. Its scene is in the free open country, among mountains, wadies, pasture-lands, and rural towns, where the relations of man and man are more elemental and primitive, and where the things of God are more intimately apprehended than in the complex affairs of city and state. It is easy to see what the writer gains by such a choice of setting. The patriarchal conditions, wherein the family is the social and communal unit, enable him to, portray worship and conduct in their primal elements: religious rites of the simplest nature, with the family head the unchallenged priest. and intercessor (cf 1 4.5; 42 8), and without the austere exactions of sanctu- ary or temple; to represent God, as in the old folk-stories, as communicating with men in audible voice and in tempest; and to give to the patriarch or sheikh a function of counsel and succor in the community analogous to that of the later wise man or sage (cf ch 29). The place outside the bounds of Pal enables him to give an international or rather intercommunal tissue to his thought, as befits the character of the wisdom with which he is dealing, a strain of truth which Israel could and did share with neighbor nations. This is made further evi- dent by the fact that in the discourses of the book, the designation of God is not Jeh (with one excep- tion, 12 9), but Elohim or Eloah or Shaddai, appel- latives rather than names, common to the Sem peoples. The whole archaie scene serves to detach the story from complex conditions of civilization, and enables the writer to deal with the inherent and intrinsic elements of manhood. All the characters of the story, J. included, are from non-Palestinian regions. The chief spokes- man of the friends, Eliphaz, who is 2. Charac- from Teman, is perhaps intended to ters and represent a type of the standard and Personality orthodox wisdom of the day; Teman, ; and Edom in general being famed for wisdom (Jer 49 7; Ob vs 8.9). The characters of the friends, while representing in general a remark- able uniformity of tenet, are quite aptly individnal- ized: Eliphaz as a venerable and devout sage who, with his eminent penetrativeness of insight, com- bines a yearning compassion; Bildad more as a scholar versed in the derived lore of tradition; and Zophar more impetuous and dogmatic, with the dogmatist’s vein of intolerance. In Elihu, the young Aramaean who speaks after the others, the writer seems endeavoring to portray a young man’s positiveness and absoluteness of conviction, and with it a self-conceit that quite outruns his ability. The Satan of the Prologue, who makes the wager with Jeh, is masterfully individualized, not as the malignant tempter and enemy of mankind, but as a spint compact of impudent skepticism, who can appreciate no motive beyond self-advantage. Even the wife of J., with her peremptory disposition to 1. Setting of Time, Place and Scene 1681 make his affliction a personal issue with God, is not without an authentic touch of the elemental femi- nine. But high above them all is the character of J. himself, which, with all its stormy alternations of mood, range of assertion and remonstrance and growth of new conviction, remains absolutely con- sistent with itself. Nor can we leave unmentioned what is perhaps the hardest achievement of all, the sublime venture of giving the very words of God, in such a way that He speaks no word out of character noe measures His thought according to the standards of men. _The Prologue, chs 1 and 2, a few verses at the begin- ning of ch 32 (vs 1-6a), and the Epilogue (42 7-17) are written in narrative prose. The rest of 3. Form the hook (except the short sentences in- a Stl troducing the speaker) is In poetry; a and Style oetic tissue conforming to the type of the : is ater mdshal (see under Provers), which, in continuous series of couplets, is admirably adapted alike to imaginative subllmity and impassioned address. Beginning with J.’s curse of his day (ch 3), J. and his three friends answer each other back and forth in three rounds of speeches, complete except that, for reasons which the subject makes apparent, Zophar, the third friend, falls to speak the third time. After the friends are thus put to silence, J. speaks three times in succession (chs 26— 31), and then “the words of J. are ended.” At this point (ch 32) a fourth speaker, Elihu, hitherto unmen- tioned, is introduced and speaks four times, when he abruptly ceases in terror at an Sppeoaching whirlwind (8% 24). Jeh speaks from the whirlwind, two speeches, each of which J. answers briefly (40 8-5; 42 1-6), or rather declines to answer. Such, which we may sum- marize in Prologue (chs 1, 2), Body of Discussion (3— 42 6), and Epilogue (42 7-17), is the literary framc- work of the book. The suhstance of the hook is in a way dramatic; it cannot, however, be called so truly a drama as a kind of forum of debate; its movement is too rigid for dramatic action, and it lacks besides the give-and-take of dialogue. In a hook of mine published some years ago I ventured to call it ‘‘ The Epic of the Inner Life,’’ epic not so much in the technical sense, as in recognition of an underlying epos which for funda- mental] significance may he compared to the story under- lying the Prometheus Bound of Aeschylus, It will not do, however, to make too much of either of these forms as designating the Book of Job; either term has to he accommodated almost out of recognition, hecause the Heb literary forms were not conceived according to the Gr categories from which our terms ‘‘epic” and ‘‘dra- matic” are derived. A greater limitation on our appre- ciation of its form, I think, is Imposed by those who regard it as a mixture of forms. It is too generally di- vided between narrative and didactic dehate. To the Heb mind it was all a continuous narrative, in which the poetic discussion, though overweighting the current of visualized action, had nevertheless the movement and value of real events. It is in this light, rather than in the didactic, that we may most profitably regard it. Il, The Course of the Story.—To divide the story of J. into 42 parts, according to the 42 numbered chapters, fs in the last degree arbitrary. Nothing comes of it except convenience in reading for those who wish to take their Job in little detached bits. The chapter division was no part of the original, and a very insignificant step in the later apprehen- sion of the original. To divide according to the speeches of the interlocutors is better; it helps us realize how the conflict of views brought the various phases of the thought to expression; but this too, with its tempting three-times-three, turns out to be merely a framework; it corresponds only imperfectly with the true inwardness of the story’s movement; it is rather a scheme than a continuity. We are to bear in mind that this Book of Job is funda- mentally the inner experience of one man, as he rises from the depths of spiritual gloom and doubt to a majestic table-land of new insight and faith; the other characters are but ancillary, helps and foils, whose function is subordinate and relative. Hence, mindful of this inwardness of Job’s experience, I have ventured to trace the story in 5 main stages, naming them according to the landing-stage attained in each. The story begins (1 1-5) with a brief description of J. as he was before his trial began; the elements of his life, outer and inner, on which is to be THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Job, Book of raised the question of motive. A prosperous land- holder of the land of Uz, distinguished far and wide as the greatest (i.e. richest) of the sons A) To Job’s of the East, his inner character corre- Blessing sponds: to all appearance nothing lack- and Curse ing, a man “perfect and upright, and one that feared God, and turned away from evil.’ The typical Heb blessings of life were his to the full: wealth, honor, health, family. He is evidently set before us as the perfect example of the validity of the -established Wisdom-tenet, that righteousness and Wisdom are jdentical (see under Proverss, THe Boox or), and that this is manifest in its visible rewards. This period of his life J. describes afterward by retrospect as his “autumn days,’ when the friendship or intimacy (10, sddh) of God was over his tent (see 29 4, and the whole ch). Nor are we left without a glimpse into his heart: his constant attitude of 1. His worship, and his tender solicitude lest, “Autumn in their enjoyment of the pleasures of Days” life, his sons may have been disloyal to God (1 4.5). It is easy to see that not J. alone, but Wisdom as embodied in J., is postulated here for its supreme test. Nor is the test delayed, or its ground ambiguous when it comes. Satan proposes it. Two scenes are given (1 6-12; 2 1-6) from the 2. The court, of God, wherever that is; for Wager in they are overheard by the reader, not Heaven seen, and of course neither J. nor any inhabitant of earth is aware of them. In these scenes the sons of God, the spirits who rejoiced over creation (38 7), are come together to render report, and Satan, uninvited, enters among them. He is a wandering spirit, unanchored to any allegiance, who roams through the earth, prying and criticizing. There is nothing, it would seem, in which he cannot find some flaw or discount. To Jeh’s question if he has considered J., the man pers and upright, he makes no denial of the fact, ut raises the issue of motive: “Doth J. fear God for nought?” and urges that J.’s integrity is after all only a transparent bargain, a paying invest- ment with only reward in view. It is virtually an arraignment both of God’s order and of the essen- tial human character: of God’s order in connecting righteousness so intimately with gain; and of the essential human character, virtually denying that there is such a thing as disinterested, intrinsic human virtue. The sneer strikes deep, and J., the perfect. embodiment of human virtue, is its desig- nated victim. Satan proposes a wager, to the issue of which Jeh commits Himself. The trial of J. is carried out in two stages: first against his property and family, with the stipulation that it is not to touch him; and then, this failing to detach him from his allegiance, against his person in sore disease, with the stipulation that his life is te be spared. Jeh acknowledges that for once He is consenting to an injustice (2 3), and Satan, liar that he is, uses instrumentalities that men have ascribed to God alone: the first time, tempest and lightning (as well as murderous foray), the second time, the black leprosy, a fell disease, loathsome and deadly, which in men’s minds meant the immediate punitive stroke of God. The evil is as absolute as was the reward; a complete reversal of the order in which men’s wisdom had come to trust. But in the imme- diate result, Jeh’s faith in His noblest creature is vindicated. Urged by his wife in his extremity to “curse God and die,” J. remains true to his allegi- ance; and in his staunch utterance, “‘Jeh gave, and Jeh hath taken away; blessed be the name of Jeh,’’ J., a8 the writer puts it, ‘sinned not, nor attributed aught unbeseeming [29M , tiphlah, lit, “tasteless”] Job, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1682 to God.’ Such is the first onset of J.’s affliction and its result. It remains to be seen what the long issue, days and months of wretchedness, will bring forth. We are now to imagine the lapse of some time, perhaps several months (cf 7 3), during which J. suffers alone, an outcast from house 3. The and society, on a leper’s ash-heap. Silent Meanwhile three friends of his who Friends: have heard of his affliction make an appointment together and come from distant regions to give him sympathy and comfort (2 11-13). On arriving, however, they find things different from what they had expected; perhaps the ominous nature of his disease has developed since they started. What they find is a man wretched and outcast, with a disease (elephantiasis) which to them can mean nothing but the immediate vengeance of God. The awful sight gives them pause. Instead of condoling with him, they sit silent and dismayed, and for seven days and nights no word is spoken (cf Isa 53 3). What they were debating with themselves during that time is be- trayed by the after-course of the story. How can they bless one whom God has stamped with His curse? To do so would be taking sides with the wicked. Is it not rather their duty to side with God, and he safe, and let sympathy go? By this introduction of the friends and their averted atti- tude, the writer with consummate skill brings a new element into the story, the element of the Wisdom- philosophy; and time will show whether as a theoretical thing, cold and intellectual, it will retain or repress the natural outwelling of human friend- ship. And this silence is ominous. The man who, in the first onset of trial, blessed Jeh and set himself to bear in silence now opens his mouth to curse. His curse is directed, 4, Whose not against Jeh nor against the order Way Is Hid of things, but against the day of his birth. It is a day that has ceased to have meaning or worthfor him. Theday stands for life, for his individual life, a life that in the order of things should carry out the personal promise and fruitage for which it had been bestowed. And his quarrel with it is that he has lost its clue. Satan unknown to him has sneered because Jeh had hedged him round with protection and favor (1 10); but his complaint is that all this is removed without cause, and God has hedged him round with darkness. His way is hid (3 23). Why then was life given at all? In all this, it will be noted, he raises no train of intro- spection to account for his condition; he assumes no sinfulness, nor even natural human depravity; the opposite rather, for a baffling element of his case is his shrinking sensitiveness against evil and disloyalty (ef 3 25.26, in which the tenses should be past, with 1 5; see also 6 30; 1617). His plight has become sharply, poignantly objective; his inner self has no part in it. ‘Thus in this opening speech he strikes the keynote of the real, against which the friends’ theories rage and in the end wreck themselves. With all the gentle regret of having to urge a disagreeable truth the friends, beginning with Eliphaz, the wisest and most venerable, B) To Job’s enter upon their theory of the case. Ultimatum Eliphaz covers virtually the whole of Protest ground; the others come in mainly to echo or emphasize. Ue veils his re- proof in general and implicatory terms, the seasoned terms of wisdom in which Job himself is expert (4 3-5); reminds him that no righteous 1. The man perishes, but that men reap what Veiled they sow (4 7.8); adduces a vision that Impeach- _he had had which revealed to him that ment man, by the very fact of being mortal, is impure and iniquitous (4 17-19); implies that J.’s turbulence of mind precludes him from similar revelations, and jeopards his soul (5 1.2); advises him to commit his case to God, with the im- plication, however, that it is a case needing correc- tion rather than justification, and that the result in view is restored comfort and prosperity. As J. answers with a more passionate and detailed por- trayal of his wrong, Bildad, following, abandons the indirect impeachment and attributes the children’s death to their sin (8 4), saying also that if J. were pure and upright he might supplicate and regain God’s favor (8 5.6). He then goes on to draw a lesson from the traditional Wisdom lore, to the effect that sure destruction awaits the wicked and sure felicity the righteous (8 11-22). On J.’s following this with his most positive arraignment of God’s order and claim for light, Zophar replies with im- petuous heat, averring that J.’3 punishment is less than he deserves (11 6), and reproving him for his presumption in trying to find the secret of God (11 7-12). All three of the friends, with increasing emphasis, end their admonitions in much the same way; promising J. reinstatement in God’s favor, but always with the veiled implication that he must own to iniquity and entreat as a sinner. : To the general maxims of Wisdom urged against him, with which he is already familiar (cf 13 2), J.s objection is not that they are 2. Wisdom untrue, but that they are insipid Insipid, (6 6.7); they have lost their appli- Friends cation to the case. Yet it is pain to Doubtful him to think that the words of the Holy One should fail; he longs to die rather than deny them (6 9.10). One poignant element of his sorrow is that the intuitive sense (tashityah; see under Proverss, THE Book oF) is driven away from him; see 6 13. He is irritated by the insinuating way in which the friends beg the question of his guilt; longs for forthright and sincere words (6 25). It is this quality of their speech, in fact, which adds the bitterest. drop to his cup; his friends, on whom he had counted for sup- pal are deceitful like a dried-up brook (6 15-20); e feels, in his sick sensitiveness, that they are not sympathizing with him but using him for their cold, calculating purposes (6 27). Thus is introduced one of the most potent motives of the story, the motive of friendship; much will come of it when from the fallible friendships of earth he conquers his way by faith to a friendship in the unseen (ef 16 19; 19 27). With the sense that the old theories have become stale and pointless, though his discernnient of the evil of things is undulled by sin (6 30), 3. Crook- J. arrives at an extremely poignant edness of realization of the hardness and crook- the Order edness of the world-order, the result of Things both of what the friends are saying _ and of what he has always held in common with them. It is the view that is forced upon him by the sense that he is unjustly dealt with by a God who renders no reasons, who on the score of justice vouchsafes to man neither insight nor recourse, and whose severity is out of all proportion to man’s sense of worth (7 17) or right (9 17) or claim as a creature of His hand (10 8-14). Ch 9, which contains J.’s direct address to this arbitrary Being, is one of the most tremendous, not to say audacious conceptions in literature; in which a mortal on the threshold of death takes upon himself to read God a lesson in godlikeness. In this part of the story J. reaches his ultimatum of protest; a protest amazingly sincere, but not blasphemous when we realize that it is made in the interest of the Godlike. The great lack which J. feels in his arraignment of God is the lack of mediation between Creator and creature, the Oppressor and His victim. ‘There 1683 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Job, Book of is no umpire between them, who might lay his hand upon hoth, so that the wronged one might have a voice in the matter (9 32-35). The 4. No two things that an umpire might do: Mediation to remove God’s afflicting hand, and in Sight to prevent God’s terror from unman- __ ning His victim (see 13 20-22, as com- pared with the passage just cited), are the great need to restore normal and reciprocal relations with Him whose demand of righteousness is so inexorable. This umpire or advocate idea, thus propounded negatively, will grow to a sublime positive convic- tion in the next stage of J.’s spiritual progress (16 19; 19 25-27). _ As the friends finish their first round of speeches, in which a remote and arbitrary God is urged upon him as everything, and man so cor- C) To__—srupé and blind that he cannot but he Job’s Ulti- a worm and culprit (cf 25 4-6), J.’s matum of eyes, which hitherto have seen with Faith theirs, are suddenly opened. His first : complaint of their professed friend- ship was that it was fallible; instead of sticking to him when he needed them most (6 14), and in spite of his bewilderment (6 26), they were 1. Detect- making it virtually an article of traffic ing the (6 27), as if it were a thing for their Friends’ gain. It was not sincere, not intrinsic False Note to their nature, but an expedient. And now all at once he penetrates to its motive. They are deserting him in order to curry favor with God. That motive has prevented them from seeing true; they see only their theoretical God, and are respecting His person instead of responding to the inner dictate of truth and integrity. To his honest heart this is monstrous; they ought to be afraid of taking falseness for God (13 3-12). Nor does his inference stop with thus detecting their false note. If they are ‘“forgers of lies” in this respect, what of all their words of wisdom? They have heen giving him “proverbs of ashes’ (13 12); the note of false implication is in them all. From this point therefore he pays little attention to what they say; lets them go on to grossly exaggerated statement of their tenet, while he opens a new way of faith for himself, developing the germs of insight that have come to him. Having cut loose from all countenancing of the friends’ self-interested motives, J. now, with the desperate sense of taking his life in his 2..Staking hand and abandoning hope, resolves All on that come what will he will maintain Integrity his ways to God’s face. This, as he believes, is not only the one course for his integrity, but his one plea of salvation, for no false one shall appear hefore him. How tre- mendous the meaning of this resolve, we can think when we reflect how he has just taken God in hand to amend His supposed iniquitous order of things; and that he is now, without mediator, pleading the privilege that a mediator would secure (13 20.21; see ‘8, above) and urging a hearing on his own charges. The whole reach of his sublime faith is involved in this. In two directions his faith is reaching out; in both negatively at first. One, the belief in an Advocate, has already been broached, 3. “Tf a and is germinating from negative to Man Die” positive. The other, the question of ife after death, rises here in the same tentative way: using first the analogy of the tree which sprouts again after it is cut down (14 7-9), and from it inquiring, ‘If a man die—might he live again?’ and dwelling in fervid imagination on the ideal solution which a survival of death would bring (14 13-17), but returning to his reluctant negative, from the analogy of drying, waters (14 11) and the slow wearing down of mountains (14 18.19). As yet he can treat the idea only as a fancy; not yet a hope or a grounded conviction. The conviction comes by a nobler way than fancy by the way of his personal sense of the just and Godlike order. The friends in their 4, The second round of speeches have begun Surviving their lurid portrayals of the wicked Next of Kin man’s awful fate; but until all have spoken again he is concerned with a far more momentous matter. Dismissing these for the present as an academic exercise composed in cold blood (16 4.5), and evincing a heart hid from understanding (17 4), he goes on to recount in the most bitter terms he has yet used the flagrancy of his wrong as something that calls out for expiation like the blood of Cain (16 18), and breaks out with the conviction that his witness and voucher who will hear his prayer for mediation is on high (16 19-21). Then after Bildad in a spiteful retort has matched his complaint with a description of the calamities of the wicked (an augmented echo of Eliphaz), and he has pathetically bewailed the treachery of earthly friends (19 13.14.21.22), he mounts, as it were, at a bound to the sublime ulti- matum of his faith in an utterance which he would fain see engraved on the rock forever (19 23-29). “I know that my Redeemer liveth,” he exclaims; lit. my Go’el CDM , 90 diz), or next of kin, the person whose business in the old Heb idea was to maintain the rights of an innocent wronged one and avenge his blood. He does not recede from the idea that his wrong is from God (cf 19 6.21); but over his dust stands his next of kin, and as the result of this one’s intercession J., in his own integral person, shall see God no more a stranger. So confident is he that he solemnly warns the friends who have falsely impeached him that it is they, not he, who are in peril (19 28.29; cf 13 10.11). That in this conviction of a living Redeemer J.’s faith has reached firm and final ground is evi- dent from the fact that he does not D) To recur to his old doubts at all. They Job’s Ver- are settled, and settled right. But dict on now, leaving them, he can attend to Thingsas what the friends have been saying. They Are Zophar, the third speaker, following, presses to vehement extreme their iterated portrayal of the wicked man’s terrific woes; it seems the design of the writer to make them outdo themselves in frantic overstatement of their thesis. As Zophar ceases, and J. has thus, as it were, drawn all their fire, J. refutes them squarely, as we shall presently see. 1. Climax Meanwhile, in the course of his ex- and Sub-__ tended_ refutation, the friends begin sidence of a third round of speeches. Eliphaz, the Friends’ who has already taken alarm at the Charge tendency of J.’s words, as those of a depraved skeptic and ruinous to de- votion (15 4-6), now in the interests of his ortho- doxy brings in his bill of particulars. It is the kind of theoretical cant that has had large prevalence in dogmatic religion, but in J.’s case atrociously false. He accuses J. of the most heartless cruelties and frauds (22 5-11), and of taking occasion to indulge in secret wickedness when God was not looking (22 12~14); to this it is that he attributes the spiritual darkness with which J. is encompassed. Then in a beautiful exhortation—heautiful when we forget its unreal condition (22 23)—he ends by holding open to J. the way of reinstatement and peace. This is the last word of the friends that has any weight. Bildad follows J.’s next speech indeed very briefly (ch 25), giving a last feeble echo of their doctrine of total depravity; a reply which Job, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1684 J. ridicules and carries on in a kind of parody (ch 26). Zophar does not speak a third time at all. He has nothing to say. And this silence of his is the writer’s way of making the friends’ theory sub- side ingloriously. The idea that J. has a defensible cause or sees farther than they is wholly lost on the friends; to them he is simply a wicked man tor- 2. The mented by the consciousness of guilt, Real Cause and they attribute the tumult of his of Job’s thoughts to a wrath, or vexation, which Dismay blinds and imperils his soul (cf 5 2; 18 4). That is not the cause of his dismay at all, nor is it merely that his personal fate is inscrutable (cf 28 17m). He is confounded rather, even to horror, because the probable facts of the world-order prove the utter falsity of all that they allege. Leaving his case, the righteous man’s, out of the account, he sees the wicked just as pros- perous, just as secure, just as honored in life and death, as the righteous (21 5-15.29-33). The friends ought to see so plain a fact as well as he (21 29). To all outward appearance there is abso- lutely no diversity of fate between righteous and wicked (21 23-26). The friends’ cut-and-dried Wisdom-doctrine and their thrifty haste to justify God (cf 13 7.8) have landed them in a lie; the truth is that God has left His times mysterious to men (24 1). They may as well own to the full the baffling fact of the impunity of wickedness; the whole of ch 24 is taken up with details of it. Wis- dom, with its rigid law of reward and punishment, has failed to penetrate the secret. A hard régime of justice, work and wage, conduct and desert, does not sound the deep truth of God’s dealings, either with righteous or wicked. What then? Shall Wisdom go, or shall it rise to a higher level of out- look and insight? In some such dim inquiry as this, it would seem, J. goes on from where his friends sit silenced to figure some positive solution of things 3. Man- as they are. He begins with himself hood in and his stedfastly held integrity, seal- the Ore ing his utterance by the solemn Heb oath (27 2-6), and as solemnly dis- avowing all part or sympathy with the wicked (27 7; cf 21 16). He has already found a meaning in his own searching experience; he is being tried for a sublime assay, in which all that is permanent and precious in him shall come out as gold (23 10). But this thought of manhood in the ore 1s no monop- oly of his; it may hold for all. What then of the wicked? In a passage which some have deemed the lost third speech of Zophar (27 8-23), and which, indeed, recounts what all the friends have seen (27 12), he sets forth the case of the wicked in its true light. The gist of it is that the wicked have not the joy of God (27 10), or the peace of a permanent hope. It is in much the same tone as the friends’ diatribes, but with a distinct advance from out- ward disaster toward tendency and futility. The ore is not being purged for a noble assay; and this will work their woe. Then finally, in the celebrated ch 28, comes up the summary of wisdom itself. That remains, after all this testing of motive, a thing intact and elemental; and man’s part in it is just what J.’s life has been, to fear God and shun evil (28 28). 2 As the crowning pronouncement on things as they are, J. in his final and longest speech, describes in a beautiful retrospect his past life, 4. Job from his “autumn days” when the Reads His friendship of God was over his tent Indictment and he was a counselor and benefactor among men (ch 29), through this con- trasted time of his wretchcdness and _curse-betray- ing disease, when the most degraded despise him (ch 30), until now as he draws consciously near the grave, he recounts in solemn review the principles and virtues that have guided his conduct—a noble summary of the highest Heb ideals of character (ch 81). This he calls, in sublime irony, the indict- ment which his Adversary has written; and like a prince, bearing it upon bis shoulder and binding it to him like a crown, he is ready to take it with him beyond the bourn to the ee of his Judge. With this tremendous proposal, sanctioned Hebrew- fashion by a final curse if it prove false, the words of J. are ended. The friends are silenced, not enlightened. They have clung to their hard thesis to the stubborn end; postulating enough overt crime on J.’s £) The part to kill him (22 5-9), and clinching Dénoue- their hypothesis with their theory of ment innate depravity (4 18.19; 15 14.15; 25 4-6) and spiritual hebetude (6 2; 15 26.27; 22 10.11); but toward J.’s higher level of honest integrity and exploring faith they have not advanced one inch; and here they lie, fossil- ized dogmatists, fixed and inveterate in their odium theologicum—a far cry from the friendship that came from afar to condole and console. J., on the other hand, staking all on the issue of his integrity, has held on his way in sturdy con- sistency (cf 17°9), and stood his ground before the enigma of things as they are. Both parties have said their say; the story is evidently ready for its dénouement. J., too, is ready for the determining word, though it would seem he expects it to bespoken only in some unseen tribunal; the friends rather savagely wish that God would speak and reprove Job for his presumption (cf 11 5.11). But how shall the solution be brought about in this land of Uz where all may see? And above all, how shall it affect the parties concerned? A skilfully told story should not leave this out. For this determining pronouncement the writer has chosen to have both parties definitely repre- sented, apparently at their best. So, 1. The instead of proceeding at once to the Self-consti- summons from the whirlwind, he intro- tuted In- duces here a new character, Elihu, terpreter a young man, who has listened with y ; growing impatience to the fruitless discuasion, and now must set both parties right or burst (82 19). It is like the infusion of young blood into a theodicy too arrogant in its antiquity (ef 8 8-10; 15 10.18; 12 12 m, or better as ques- tion). This character of Elihu is conceived in a spirit of satire, not without a dash of grim humor. His self-confidence, not to say conceit, is strongly accentuated (32 11-22); he assumes the umpire function for which J. has pleaded (33 6.7; cf 9 33-35; 13 20-22); and is sure he represents the perfect in knowledge (86 2-4; 37 16). He speaks four times, addressing himself alternately to J. and the friends. His words, though designedly diffuse, are not without wisdom and beauty; he makes less of J.’s deep-seated iniquity than do the friends, but’ blames him for speaking in the wicked man’s idiom (34 7-9.36.37), and warns him against inclining more to iniquity than submission (36 21); but his pace contribution to the discussion is the view e holds of the chastening influence of dreams and visions (83 14-18; cf 7 18-15), and of the pains of disease (83 19-28), esp. if the sufferer has an ‘‘angel [messenger] interpreter” to reveal its mean- ing, such a one perhaps as Elihu feels himself to be. As he proceeds in his speech, his words indicate that a storm is rising; and so jong as it is distant he employs it to descant on the wonders of God in Nature, wonders which to him mean little more than arbitrary marvels of power; but as it ap- proaches neare. and shows exceptional phenomena 1685 as of a theophany, his words become incoherent, and he breaks off with an abject attempt to disclaim his pretensions. Such is the effect, with him, of the near presence of God. It overwhelms, paralyzes, stops the presumptuous currents of life. _ The writer of the book has not committed the literary fatuity of describing the whirlwind, except as Elihu has seen its oncoming, first 2. The with conceit of knowledge, then with Whirlwind wild access of terror—a description in and the which his essentially vapid personality Voice _ is reflected. For the readers the sig- _,, nificance of the whirlwind is in the Voice it incloses, the thing it says. And here the writer has undertaken the most tremendous task ever attempted by the human imagination: to make the Almighty speak, and speak in character. And one fatuity at least he has escaped; he has not made God bandy arguments with men, or piece together the shifting premises of logic. The whole of the two discourses from the whirlwind is descrip- tive; a recounting of observable phenomena of created nature, from the great elemental things, earth and sea and light and star and storm, to the varied wonders of animal nature—all things in which the questing mind of man may share, laying hold in his degree on its meaning or mystery. Thus, as a sheer literary personation, it fails at no point of the Godlike. It begins with a peremptory dis- missal of Elihu: “Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge?” (88 2). Then J. is bidden gird up his loins like a strong man, and listen and answer. The fact that J. alone, of all the company, can stand, as it were, on common terms with God is premonitory of the outcome. Of the two Divine discourses, the first (chs 38, 39) emphasizes more especially the unsearchable wis- dom of creation; and the lesson it brings home to J. is that a being who is great enough—or presump- tnons enough—to criticize and censure is great enough to resolve his own criticism (40 2). To this, of course, J. has no answer; he has presented his plea, which he neither adds to nor takes back (40 3-5). Resuming, then, the Voice in the second discourse (40 6—41 34) goes on to describe two great beasts, as it were, elemental monsters of Na- ture: Behemoth—probably the hippopotamus— vast in resisting and overcoming power, yet un- aware of it, and easily subduable by man; and Leviathan—probably the crocodile—a wonder of beautiful adaptedness to its function in Nature, yet utterly malignant, unsubduable, untamable. And the lesson brought home to J. by this strange dis- tribution of creative power is that he, who has called in question God’s right to work as He does, had better undertake to lower human pride and “tread down the wicked where they stand” (40 12), thus demonstrating his ability to save himself and manage mankind (40 14). By this illuminating thought J.’s trenchancy of demand is utterly melted away into contrition and penitence (42 1-6); but one inspiring effect is his, the thing indeed which he has persistently sought (cf 23 3): God is no more a hearsay, such as the friends have defended and his Wisdom has speculated about; his eye sees Him here on earth, and in his still unremoved afflic- tion, no stranger, but a wise and communable Friend, just as his confident faith had pictured he would, in some embodied sphere beyond suffering (19 27). Two of the parties in the story have met the august theophany, and it has wrought its effect on them according to the spirit of 3. The the man. The self-constituted inter- Thing That preter, Elihu, has collapsed as suddenly Is Right as he swelled up and exhibited him- self. The man of integrity, J., has reached the beatific goal of his quest. What now THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Job, Book of of. the friends who came from far to confirm their Wisdom, and who were so sure they were defend- ing the mind of God? They are not left without a sufficing word, addressed straight to their spokes- man Eliphaz (42 7); but their way to light is through the man whose honesty they outraged. Eliphaz’ closing words had promised mediatorial power to Job if he would return from iniquity and acquaint himself with God (22 30); Job is now the mediator, though he has held consistently to the terms they reprobated. And the Divine ver- dict on them is: ‘Ye have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant J. hath” (42 7). These are the words of the Being who acknowledged that in permitting this whole trial He was ‘swallow- ing Job up causelessly’ (2 3). J.’s honest and immensely revelatory words, anger, remonstrance, bold arraignment of God’s way and all, were ‘‘the thing that is right.’ There is no more tremendous Divine pronouncement in all Scripture than this. Here certain myopic students of the Book of Job think the story should end. It offends them, ap- parently, to see Satan’s work undone; - if they had had the making of the 4. The Restored story they would have left J. still Situation suffering, asif disinterested virtue could not be its own reward without it. The author, at least the final anthor, evidently did not think so; in the ideals and sanctions that prevailed in his age he knew better what he was about. It is not my business to cut the book to a modern pattern, but to note what is there. J. is restored to health, to double his former wealth, to family and honor and a ripe old age. These were what the friends predicted for him on condition of his owning to guilt and calling injustice desert; but in no word of his has he intimated that worldly reinstatement was his wish or his object, the con- trary rather. And what he sought he obtained, in richer measure than he sought; obtained it still in sufféring, and on earth, ‘“‘in the place where al! may see” (cf 34 26m). It is no discount to the value of this, nor on the other hand is it an essen- tial addition, to express it not only in spiritual terms, but in terms current among men. And one fundamental thing this restored situation shows, or at least takes for granted, namely, that the quarrel has not been with Wisdom itself, its essence or its sanctions, but only with its encroaching false motive. Deepened, not invaded, its Newtonian law that it is well with the righteous, ill with the wicked, remains intact, an external sanction to live by, in spite of temporal exceptions. A spiritual principle of great significance, too, seems to be indicated, as it were, furtively, in the words, “And Jeh turned the cap- tivity of J., when he prayed for his friends.” He had stood on his integrity demanding his right, and became a self-loathing penitent; out of dust and ashes he prayed for his friends, and became again such a power in health and wealth as he had been in his “autumn days.” ; IV. The Problem and the Purpose.—If the fore- going section has rightly shown that the main thrust and interest of the Book of Job 1. Beyond lies not in its debate but in its narra- the Didactic tive, we have therein the best clue to Tether its problem and its purpose. The snb- lime self-portrayal of a man who held fast his integrity against God and man and death and darkness tells its own story and teaches its own lesson, beyond the power of didactic propositions or deductions to compass. The book is not a sermon but a vital, throbbing uprise of the human spirit. It is warm with the life of sound manhood, the inner life with its hopes, its doubts, its convictions, its supreme affiance; to impose on this any tether of didacticism is to chill its spirit and make it dog- Job, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1686 matic and academic. The reading of its problem which mainly holds the field today is expressed in the question, ‘“Why does God afflict the righteous ?” and so the book is resolved into a theodicy, a justi- fication of God’s ways with man. Well, the friends of J. do their best to make their interpretation a theodicy, even outraging palpable fact to do it; they monopolize the didactic element of the poem; but their chief contention is that God does not afflict the righteous but the wicked, and that J. is a flagrant case in point who adds rebellion to his sin (cf 34 37). J. does not know why God afflicts the righteous; he only knows that it is a grievous fact, which to him seems utterly un-Godlike. God knows, undoubtedly, but He does not tell. Yet all the while an answer to the question is shaping itself in personality, in intrinsic manhood, in the sturdy truth and loyalty of J.’s spirit. So, going beyond the didactic tether, we may say that in a deeper sense God is justified after all; if such a result of desperate trial is possible in man, it is worth all the rigor of the experiment. But it is as truly an anthropodicy (excuse the word!) as a theodicy; it puts the essential man on a plane above all that Satan can prove by his lying sneers of self-interest, or the friends’ poisoning of the wells by their theory of natural depravity. It comes back after all to the story of J.; he lives the answer to the problem, his personality is the teaching. It is from this poiut of view that we can hest judge of the critical attacks that have been made on the structure and coherence of the Book of Job. The hook 2. What has suffered its full share of negative dis- C g integration at the hands of the critics; ‘OMeS 0 mostly suhjective it seems to me, coming Limiting froma too restricted view of its problem and the purpose, or from lack of that long patient induction which will not be content until Purpose it sees all the elements of its creative idea in fitting order and proportion. To limit the purpose to the issue of a debated theodicy, is to put some parts iu precarious tenure; accordingly, there are those to whom the Epilogue seems a superfluity, the Prologue an afterthought, ch 28 a fugitive poem put in to fill up—not to go on to still more radical excisions. On the score of regularity of structure, too, this limita- tion of design has had equally grave results. Elihu has perhaps fared the worst. He must go, the critics almost universally say, because forsooth he was not formally introduced in the Prologue; and naturally enough, as soon as he has received notice to quit, the language which in one view fits him so dramatically to his part hegins to bristle with Aramaisms (‘of the kindred of Ram,’ 32 2) aud strange locutions, the alleged marks of a later bungling hand. Then, further, Zophar must needs round ont the mechanical three-times-three of structure by coming up the third time; accordingly, J. is levied upon to coutribute some of his words (27 13-23) to help him ont. I need not go into further detail. The foregoing section has done something, I hope, to justify my conviction that the book has a homogeneous design and structure just as it is. Whatever its vicissitudes since the first draft was made, it may turn out after all that the last edition is the best. Weare not left in the dark as to the large purpose of the Book of Job, if we will follow its own indi- cations consistently. Satan’s ques- 3. The tion at the beginning, ‘‘Doth Job fear Book’s Own God for nought?” sets us on the track Import of of it. To give that question a Godlike Purpose and not a Satanic answer, to prove in the person of J. that man has it in him to make his life an unbought loyalty to the Divine, is a, purpose large enough to include many subsidiary purposes. But behind this appears, on the part of the author, a purpose which relates his story intimately to the intellectual tendencies of his day. The Book embodies, esp. in the theories of the friends, a searching epitome of the status to which the wisdom philosophy of his time had_arrived. That philosophy was a nobly founded theory of life; J. himself had been and continued (cf 28 28) thoroughly at one with it. Soundly identified with righteousness and piety, Wisdom had in religious idiom defined the elements of right and wrong living, and had in no uncertain terms fixed its sanctions of reward and penalty. But from a warm, pulsating life it had become an orthodoxy. Its rigid world had room for only two classes of men: the righteous, bound for the sure rewards of life; the wicked, bound for sure failure and destruction. It brooked no real exception to this austere law of being. But two grave evils were invading its system. One was its hard blindness to facts, or, what is as bad, its determination at all hazards to explain them away. From the psalms of the period (cf e.g. Pss 37, 49, 73) we can see how the evident. happiness and pros- perity of the wicked was troubling devout minds. The other was that under this prevailing philosophy life was becoming too cold-blooded and calculable a thing, a virtual feeder of self-interest. The doubt lay very near whether conduct so sanctioned was a thing intrinsic and sincere or a thing bought and sold. ‘This equivocal state of things could not long endure. Sooner or later Satan’s question of mo- tive must stab it to the heart; and we may be sure that to the author of the book the impulse to ask the question was not all Satanic. The interests of true wisdom, no less than of skepticism, demanded that the question of inner motive be raised aud solved. Nay, Jeh Himself, whom Satan mocked as abettor of the situation, was on trial. Have we not material here, then, for a sublime purpose, a mighty epic of test and trial and victory? Out of it, not J. alone, but Wisdom must emerge purified, enlightened, spiritualized. So much for the purpose of the book. The prob- lem corresponds to it. If we take it as the baffling problem of suffering, or more specifi- 4. Prohlem cally why God afflicts the righteous, of the the sufficing answer is, Jobiswhy. To Intrinsic give such essential integrity as his its Man ultimate proof and occasion is worth the injustice and the unmerited pain, In other words, the problem is more deeply con- cerned with man’s intrinsic nature than with God’s mysterious dealings. When God created man in His own image, did He endow him most funda- mentally with the spirit of commercialism, or with the spirit of unbought loyalty to the Godlike? And when created man was made fallible and mortal, did that mean an unescapable inherent depravity, or was the potency of noblest manhood still left at the center of his being? Here again J. is the embodied answer. The friends, veritable Cal- vinists before Calvin, urge depravity; they would exalt God by making man His utter contrast. But J.’s stedfast integrity proves that man, one man at least, is at heart sound and true. And if one man, then the potency of soundness exists in manhood. The book is indeed a theodicy; but still more truly it is a boldy maintained anthropodicy, a vindication of the intrinsic worth of man. V. Considerations of Age and Setting.—The questions who was the personal author of the Book of ‘Job, and what was its age, are at 1. Shadowy best only a matter of conjecture; and Contacts my revised conjecture, arrived at since with I wrote my Epic of the Inner Life, must History go for what it is worth. It seems to me much better to regard a story so homogeneous and interrelated as in the main the composition of one mind than to distribute it, as some critics do, among various authors, supple- menters, and editors. As to its age, there is so little identifiable contact with political or ecclesiastical history that its composition has been ascribed to many periods, from the time of Abraham to late in post-exilic times. The fact that its scene is laid in the patriarchal past and in a land outside of Pal indicates the author’s design to dissociate it from contemporary events and conditions; such contact 1687 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Job, Book of with these as exist, therefore, must be read between the lines. The book dees not hold with full con- sistency to patriarchal conditions. Job’s friends appeal with the complacency of wisdom-prospered men,to the ancient tenure of the land (16 19); and yet, as Job complains, the heartless greed of the landholding class in removing landmarks and op- pressing the poor (24 2-12) connotes the prevalence of such outrages as were denounced by Isaiah and Micah before the Assyr crisis. Such evils would not decrease under Manasseh and Jehoiakim, and might well be portrayed in reminiscence by an exilic writer. On the top of this consideration may be cited the most definite reference to a his- torical event that the book contains: the passage 12 17-25, which vividly describes, by an eye- witness (“‘Lo, mine eye hath seen all this,” 13 1), a wholesale deportation and humiliation of eminent persons, just like that told of Jehoiachin and his court, in 2 K 24 13-15. To my mind this is illuminative for the age of the book. It seems to have been written by one who saw the Chaldaean deportation of 587 BC. May I be suffered to carry the suggestion a step farther? It will be remem- bered that the chief personage of that, deportation was for 37 years a state prisoner in Babylon, at the end of which time he was “taken from durance and judgment” (cf Isa 63 8 AV) and lived thenceforth honored with kings (2 K 25 27-30=Jer 62 31-34). I take him to have been the original of the indi- vidualized Servant of Jeh described and describing himself in Second Isa. In one of his self-descrip- tions he says that, Jeh has given him “the tongue of them that are taught’’ (Isa 60 4); in another that Jeh has made his “mouth like a sharp sword” and himself ‘‘a polished shaft’’ (Isa 49 2). What he said or wrote is of course unidentifiable; but it is certain that in some cultural way he was a hidden power for good to his people. What if this Book of Job were a prison-made book, like Pilgrim’s Prog- ress and Don Quixote, but as much greater as the experience that underlay it was more momentous? I do not see but this suggestion is as probable as any that have been made; and some expressions of the book become thereby very striking, as for instance, the reference to prisoners (3 18.19), to the servant longing for release (7 2), the general sense of being despised, the several references to Job as “my servant Job” (1 8; 23; 42 7.8), the description of his restoration as a turned captivity, and his successful intercession for the friends (42 10; cf Isa 53 12). I would merely suggest the idea, however, not press it. If the Book of Job is a product of the time of Jehoia- chin’s imprisonment, it is in worthy and congenial lit- m erary company. Isaiah, fostering the faith i of a new-born spiritual ‘‘remnant,’’ had alee ™ gathered the elements of that sublime Bi 1¢a. vision (Isa 1 1) of Israel’s mission among Literature the nations which a later hand was even now, four generations after, working to supplement and finish, in a prophecy (Isa 40-66) which, as all recognize, constitutes the closest parallel in spirited idea to our book. Seers, priests and singers had long busled themselves with the literary treasures of the past; drawing out of dusty archives and putting into popular idiom the ancient laws and counsels of Moses (Db: see under Josrag); collecting and adapting the old Davidic psalms and composing new ones, as Hezekiah’s reorganization of the worship required. Ezekiel was at Tel Abib planning for the reconstruction of the temple, and perhaps by his use of the name Job’ yeiling a cryptic reference (Ezk 14 14.20). The affili- ations of the Book of Job, however, were more specifi- cally with the wisdom literature; and long before this the “‘men of Hezekiah” (Prov 25 1) had gathered their aftermath of the Solomonic proverde: to supplement the maxims which had been the educative pabulum of the people (see under Proverss, Boox OF). It was with the care and principle of this diffused instruction, now the most popular vein of literature, that the Book of Job concerned itself. That had become apparent as soon as the maxims were coérdinated in an anthology, and an Introduction to the collection had been composed, extolling Wisdom as the guide and savior of life. To a spiritually-mindéd thinker with the Heb genius for religion the motivatlon of Wisdom must sooner or later come. With its values should be apprehended also its unguarded points and tendencies. It was exposed to the one-sided drift of all popular things. Inan age when revision and deeper Insight were the literary order of the day, Wisdom would come in with the other strains of Nterature for purification and maturing; and there was not wanting an experience, the hasis of an almost unbe- lievable report (cf Isa 53 1) to give depth and poign- ancy to Joh’s personal story of suffering and integrity. In the amazing sureness and vigor of its message the Book of Job stands out unique and alone; but it is by no means without its lesser 3. Parallels parallels in faith and doubt, above and Echoes which it rises like a mountain above its retinue of foothills. Mention has been made above of a number of Pss (e.g. 37, 49, 73) which with different degrees of assurance wit- ness to the struggle of faith with the problem of the rampant and successful wicked. Ps 49, one of the pss of the sons of Korah, is esp. noteworthy, because it expressly employs the popular mashél, that is, the Wisdom vehicle, to convey a corrective lesson about unblest riches, drawing a conclusion not unlike that of Job 27 8-23, though in milder tone. Not less noteworthy also is the note of suffering and its mysteriousness which pervades many of the pss, esp. of Asaph and Heman; Pss 88 and 102 might both have been composed with special refer- ence to Hezekiah’s sickness and set beside his ps in Isa 38, but also they are so fully in the tone of Js complaint, esp. 88, that, Professor Godet, not unplausibly, conjectures that the Book of Job was written by its author Heman. Hezekiah’s deadly sickness itself (Isa 38), which was of a leprous nature, banishing him from the house of God, and which was miraculously healed—an experience re- garding which Hezekiah’s own writing (Isa 38 10- 20) is strikingly in the key of Job’s complaint— furnishes the nearest parallel to, or adumbration of, Job's affliction; but also in the accounts of the Servant of Jeh there are hints of a similar stroke of God’s judgment (cf Isa 62 14; 63 3). The pas- sage Job 7 17.18 has been called “a bitter parody” of Ps 8 4; it may be so, but the conditions are in utter contrast, and nothing can be concluded as to which is original and which echo. As to expression, the most remarkable parallel to Job, perhaps, is the passage Jer 20 14-18, in which, like Job, the prophet Jeremiah curses the day of his birth. This curse in Job would naturally be remembered by all readers as one of the most characteristic features of the book; and in like manner the curse in Jer may have stood out in the memory of his disciples, of whom the writer of Job may have been one, and figure in a similar literary situation. Ezekiel’s naming of Job along with Noah and Daniel (Ezk 14 14.20), asa type of atoning righteousness, is doubly remarkable if the writer of Job was a contemporary; he ma have taken the name from a well-known legend, and there may have underlain it a double meaning, known to an inner circle, referring cryptically to one whose real name it, might be impolitic to pronounce. Whenever written, the outline and meaning of J.’s momentous experience must have won speedily to a permanent place in the universal Heb memory; so that centuries afterward St. James could write to the twelve tribes scattered abroad (6 11), “Ye have heard of the patience of Job, and have seen the end of the Lord.” Literators.—A. B. Davidson, ‘‘The Book of Job” (Cambridge Bible for Schools), 1884; A. S. Peake, ‘‘ Job” (New Century Bible), 1905; S. R. Driver, The Book of Jab in the Revised Version, 1906; J. T. Marshall, The Book of Job, 1904; J. F. Genung, Epic of the Inner Life, 1891; G. G. Bradley, Lectures on Job in Westminster Abbey, 1887; F.'C. Cook in The Speaker's Commentary, 1882. Among German writers, A. Dillmann, Hiod erkldrt, 1891; K. Budde, Das Buch Hiob tibersetzt und Job, Test. of Joel THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1688 erkldrt, 1896 (see Expos T, VIII, iii); B. Duhm, Das Buch Hiob erkldrt, 1897; G. Beer, Der Text des Buches Hiob untersucht, 1897; Gibson, ‘‘The Book of Job” (Ozford Com- mentaries), 1899. JoHN FRANKLIN GENUNG JOB, TESTAMENT OF. See ApocaLyptic LITERATURE. JOBAB, jo’bab (241, yabhabh, perhaps ‘“‘howl- ing’; *IwBa8, J6bdb): (1) “Son” of Joktan (Gen 10 29; 1 Ch 1 23). See Taste or Nations. (2) An Edomite king (Gen 36 33.34; 1 Ch 1 44.45). (3) King of Madon (Josh 11 1). (4) 1 Ch 8 9; and (5) 1 Ch 8 18, Benjamites. The name is confused with that of Job in LXX of Job 42 17. JOCHEBED, jok’é-bed (291, ydkhebhedh, “‘Jeh is glory”): Daughter of Levi, wife of Amram and mother of Moses (Ex 6 20; Nu 26 59). Accord- ing ie Ex 6 20, she was asister of Kobath, Amram’s father. JOD, jod (1): Yédh, the tenth letter of the Heb alphabet. See ALpHaBEt; JoT; Yopu. JODA, jo’da (WH, *Iw84, Jédd; TR, "Iov5d, Toudd): (1) A Levite, whose sons were ‘‘over the works of the Lord,” corresponding to Sudias (1 Esd 5 26), Hodaviah (Ezr 2 40), Judah (Ezr 3 9), Hodevah (Neh 7 48). (2) An ancestor of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy (Lk 3 26, AV “Juda’”). JOED, jd’ed (WP, ya'edh, “Jeh is witness”): A “son” of Benjamin (Neh 11 7), wanting in 1 Ch 9 7. é JOEL, jé’el Oxn, yo’él, popularly interpreted as “Jeh is God”; but see HPN, 153; BDB, 222a): (1) The firstborn of Samuel (1 S 8 2; 1 Ch 6 33 (Heb 18], and supplied in RV of 1 Ch 6 28, correctly). (2) A Simeonite prince (1 Ch 4 35). (3) A Reubenite chief (1 Ch 5 4.8). (4) A Gadite chief, perhaps the same as (3) (1 Ch 5 12). He might be the chief of ‘‘a family or clan whose members might be reckoned as be- longing to either or both of the tribes” (Curtis, Ch, 122). (5) A Levite ancestor of Samuel (1 Ch 6 36 {Heb 21], called “Shaul” in ver 24 [Heb 9]). (6) A chief of Issachar (1 Ch 7 3). (7) One of David’s mighty men (1 Ch 11 38), brother of Nathan. 2 8 23 36 has “Igal son of Nathan,” and LXX B has “son” in 1 Ch, a read- ing which Curtis adopts. See Icat. (8) A_Levite (1 Ch 15 7.11.17), probably the J.of 1 Ch 23 8and 26 22. (9) David’s tribal chief over half of Manasseh (1 Ch 27 20). (10) A Levite of Hezekiah’s time (2 Ch 29 12). (11) One of those who had married foreign wives (Ezr 10 43)=‘Juel” of 1 Esd 9 35. (12) A Benjamite “‘overseer’’ in Jerus (Neh 11 9). (13) ’Iw%A, fdél, the prophet (Joel 1 1; Acts 2 16). See following article. 2 Davio Francis Roperts JOEL ORM, yo'el; ‘Tosd, 1561): I. Tue Propuer II, Tue Boox 1. Literary Form 2. Outline of Contents 3. Interpretation o ‘Literal 2) Allegorical 4. Indications of Date (1) Place in the Canon (2) Language and Style (3) Quotations (4) The Situation (a) Political 2) Ritwaustl ; G itualistic (5) ree Nations Mentioned or Omitted (6) Some Notable Expressions 5. View of Professor Merx 6. Connections with the NT LITERATURE f I. The Prophet.—The Book of Joel stands second in the collection of the Twelve Prophets inthe Heb Canon. The name O81, yd’él), meaning “Jeh is God,” seems to have been common, as we find a dozen other persons bearing it at various periods of the Bib. history. Beyond the fact that he was the son of Pethuel, there is no intimation in the book as to his native place, date, or personal history; nor is he mentioned in any other part of the OT; so that any information on these points must be matter of inference, and the consideration of them must follow some examination of the book itself. Il, The Book.—This takes largely the form of addresses, the occasion and scope of which have to be gathered from the contents. There 1. Literary is no narrative, properly so called, Form . except at one place (2 18), “Then was Jeh jealous for his land,’’ etc, and even there the narrative form is not continued. Yet, though the earlier portions at least may be the transcript of actual addresses in which the speaker had his audience before him, this would not apply to the later portions, in which also the direct address is still maintained (e.g. 3 11, ‘““Haste ye, and come, all ye nations round about’). This form of direct address is, indeed, characteristic of the style through- out (e.g. 2 21; 3 4.9.13). There is this also to be said of its literary character, that ‘‘the style of Joel is bright and flowing,” his ‘imagery and language are fine’ (Driver, LOT); “his book is a descrip- tion, clear, well arranged, and carried out with taste and vivacity, of the present distress and of the ideal future. J. may be reckoned among the classics of Heb lit. The need of a commentary for details, as is the case with Amos and Hosea, is here hardly felt” (Reuss, Das AT). The book in the original consists of 4 chapters, which, however, are in our VS reduced to 3, by making the portion which constitutes 2. Outline ch 3 in the Heb the concluding portion of Contents (vs 28-32) of ch 2. The book begins in gloom, and its close is bright. Up to 2 18 there is some great trouble or a succession of troubles culminating at 2 28-32 (ch 3 in Heb). And the concluding portion, ch 8 (ch 4 in Heb), in which the prophet projects his view into futunty, begins with judgment but ends with final blessed- ness. There is a progression in the thought, rising from the solid, sorely smitten earth to a region ethereal, and the stages of advance are marked by sudden, sharp calls (1 2.14; 3 9), or by the blasts a the ra which prelude the shifting scenes 1.15). Ch 1 begins with an address, sharp and peremp- tory, in which the oldest inhabitant is appealed to whether such a calamity as the present has ever been experienced, and all are called to take note so that the record of it may be handed down to re- motest posterity. The land has suffered from a succession of disasters, the greatest that could befall an agricultural country, drought and locusts. The two are in fact inextricably connected, and the fea- tures of both are mixed up in the description of their effects. The extent of the disaster is vividly de- picted by the singling out of the classes on whom the calamity has fallen, the drinkers of wine, the priests, 1689 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Job, Test. of Joel the vine-dressers, the husbandmen; and, toward the close of the chapter, the lower animals are patheti- cally introduced as making their mute a peal to heaven for succor (vs 18-20). Specially to Be noted is the manner in which the priests are introduced (ver 9), and how with them is associated the climax of the affliction. The prophet had just said “my land” (ver 6), “my vine” and ‘my fig-tree” (ver 7); and, though many modern expositors take the pro- noun as referring to the nation or people, it would appear more appropriate, since the people is ob- Jectively addressed, to regard the prophet as identi- fying himself with the God in whose name he is speaking. And then the transition to ver 8 be- comes intelligible, in which certainly the land is per- sonified as a female: ‘‘Lament like a virgin girded with sackcloth for the husband of her youth.” The underlying idea seems to be the conception of the land as Jeh’s and of Jeh as the ba‘al “lord,” or hus- band of people and land. ‘This is the idea so much in evidence in the Book of Hos, and so much per- verted by the people whom he addressed, who ascribed their corn and wine and oil to the Can. ba‘als, The idea in its purer form is found in the ‘land Beulah,” “married land” (Isa 62 4.5). If it was this that was in J.’s mind, the mention of the priests comes naturally. The products of the land were Jeh’s gifts, and the acknowledgment of His lordship was made byofferings of the produce laid on His altar. But if nothing was given, nothing could be offered; the ‘‘cutting off’’ of the meal and drink offerings was the mark of the widowhood and destitution of the land. Hence the pathetic long- ing (2 14) that at least. so much may be left as to assure the famished land that the supreme calamity, the loss of God, has not fallen. Thus the visitation is set in a religious light: the graphic description is more than a poetic picture.’ It is the Lord’s land that is wasted; hence the summons (1 14) to “ery unto Jeh,” and in the vs that follow the supplication by man and beast for deliverance. Ch 2 up to ver 17 seems to go over the same gronnd as ch 1, and it has also two parts || respec- tively to two parts of that chapter: 2 1-11 is || to 1 2-12, and 2 12-17 to 1 13-20. The former part in both cases is chiefly descriptive of the calamity, while the latter part 1s more hortatory. Yet there is an advance; for, whereas in 1 2-12 the attention is fixed on the devastation, in 2 1-11 it is the devas- tator, the locust, that is particularly described; also, in 2 12-17 the tone is more intensely religious: “Rend your heart, and not your garments” (ver 13). Finally it is to be noted that it is at the close of this portion that we get the first reference to external nations: “Give not thy heritage to re- proach, that the nations should use a byword against them: wherefore should they say among the peoples, Where is their God?” (ver17m). Ifthe view given above of 1 6-8 be correct, this is merely an expan- sion of the germinal idea there involved. And so it becomes a pivot on which the succeeding portion turns: “Then was Jeh jealous for his land, and had pity on his people” (2 18). There is a sharp turn at 2 18, marked by the sudden variation of the verbal forms. Just as in Am 7 10, in the midst of the prophet’s discourse, we come upon the narration, “Then Amaziah the riest, of Beth-el sent to Jeroboam,”’ etc, so here we EaveeBeoaaly to take the narrative to be the se- quence of the foregoing address, or,-more properly speaking, we bave to infer that what J. had coun- seled had been done. The fast had been sanctified, the solemn assembly had been called, all classes or their representatives had been gathered to the house of the Lord, the supplication had been made, and “then was Jeb jealous for his land, and _had pity on his people.” In point of fact, as the Heb student will perceive, all the vbs. from ver 15 may be read, with a change of the points, as simple perfects, with the exception of the vbs. for “weep” and “say” in ver 17, which might be descriptive imperfects. But no doubt the imperative forms are to be read, expressing as they do more graphically the doing of the thing prescribed. And, this sharp turn having been made, it will be noticed how the dis- course proceeds on a higher gradient, forming a counterpart to the preceding context. Step by step, in inverse order, we pass the former points, beginning opposite what was last the “reproach among the nations” (ver 19; cf ver 7), passing the destruction of the great army (ver 20; cf vs 1-11), then touching upon the various kinds of vegetation affected (vs 21-24; ef 1 12.10, etc), and ending with the reversal of the fourfold devastation with which the prophet began (ver 25; cf 14). So that what at the outset was announced as a calamity unprec- edented and unparalleled, now becomes a deliv- erance as enduring as God’s presence with His people is forever assured. Up to this point there has been an observable sequence and connection, so that, while the prophet has steadily progressed upward, we can look down from the point reached and see the whole course that has been traversed. But now in 2 28-32 (ch 3 in Heb) he passes abruptly to what “shall come to pass afterward.” And yet no doubt there was a connection of thought in his mind, of which we obtain suggestions in the new features of the description. There is ‘‘the sound of abundance of rain” (1 K 18 41) in this pouring out of the Spirit upon all flesh; in the sons and daughters, old men and young, servants and handmaidens, we seem to recognize the representative gathering of 2 15f, those engaged in the priestly function of suppli- cation here endued with prophetic gifts, ‘a king- dom of priests, and a holy nation” (Ex 19 6), all the Lord’s people become prophets (Nu 11 29). Again we see the sky overcast and sun and moon darkened before the great and terrible day of the Lord, as if the prophet had said: There shall be greater things than these; a new era is coming in which God’s hand will be laid more heavily upon the world, and His people will be quickened to a clearer vision of His working. The “day of Jeh’’ has yet to come in a fuller sense than the locust plague suggested, and there will be a more effective deliverance than from drought and dearth; but then as now there will be found safety in Mt. Zion and Jerus. This, however, implies some danger with which Jerus has been threatened; a “remnant,” an “escaped” portion involves a disaster or crisis out of which new life comes. And so the prophet goes on in ch 3 (ch 4 in Heb), still speaking of ‘those days’ and ‘‘that time,” to tell us of the greater deliverance from the greater trouble to which he has been alluding. There is nothing in the ante- cedent chapters to indicate what “that time” and “those days” are, or what the prophet means by bringing again the captivity of Judah and_Jerus. These are questions of interpretation. In the meantime, we may note the general features of the scene now set before us. A great assize is to be held in the valley of Jehoshaphat, in which “all nations” there assembled by Divine summons will be judged for offences against God's people and heritage (vs 1-8). And again, just as in chs 1, 2 the prophet exhibited the plague of locusts in two pictures, so here in vs 9-21 the picture of the great agsize is transformed into a bloody picture in the same valley, not so much of battle as of slaughter, a treading of the wine-press. There is a confused multitude in “the valley of decision”; sun and moon are darkened, and the stars withdraw their shining; the “‘day of Jeh” has finally come; and, when the Joel THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1690 din is silenced and clear light again falls upon the scene, all is peace and prosperity, the last of the enemies destroyed, and the Lord dwelleth in Zion. (1) Literal.—Thus the book forms a fairly intelligible and connected whole when we read in the lit. sense of the language. That is to say: a time of 3. Inter- continued drought combined with an un- . precedented visitation of locusts gives pretation = occasion to the prophet to call his people to the recognition of the Divine hand and to earnest supplication that the threatened ruin of people and land may he averted. The removal of the calamity is interpreted as a mark of restored Divine favor and an assurance of prosperity based on God’s unchangeable purpose of good to His people. But these great doings of Nature’s God suggest yet greater deeds of Israel’s God of a more spiritual kind, the outpouring, like copious showers, of Divine blessing, so that the whole community would be set on a higher level of spiritual apprehension. And thus the prophet is led on to speak of the "last things.’’ Judah and Jerus, highly distinguished and sig- nally protected, are hound up with a world-wide purpose; Israel, in a word, cannot be conceived apart from non- Israel. And as non-Israe] had in the past been an oppos- ing power, in the great ‘'day of Jeh,'’ wrong should be at last righted, the nations judged, and Israel and Israel's God be glorified. No douht the interpretation is not without difficulties. We may not he able to detect the motives of the sudden transitions, or to say how much of the purport of the latter part was in the prophet’s mind when he was engaged on the former part. And the description of the locust is so highly poetical that there is a temptation to see in it a reference to a great invading army. (2) Allegorical.—T bese considerations, combined with the undoubted eschatological strain of the closing part of the book, led early commentators (and they have had followers in modern times) to an allegorical inter- pretation of the locust, and to regard the whole hook as pointing forward to future history. Thus, in Jerome's time, the 4 names of the locust in 1] 4 were supposed to designate (1) the Assyrians and Babylonians, (2) the Medes and Persians, (3) the Macedonians and Antiochus Epiphanes, and (4) the,Romans. But, apart from _ the consideration that the analogy of prophecy would lead us to look for some actual situation or occurrence of his time as tbe starting-point of J.'’s discourse, a close ohservation and acquaintance with the habits of the locust confirm the prophet's description, albeit highly figurative and poetical, as minutely accurate in all its details. It is to be observed that, though spoken of as an army (and at the present day the Oriental calls the locust the '‘army of God"’), there is no mention of blood- shed. The designation ‘‘the northern one,” which has heen considered inappropriate because the locust comes from the parched plain of the eastern interior, need not cause perplexity; for tbe Heb, while it has names for the 4 cardinal points of the compass, has none for the intermediate points: Judaea might be visited by locusts coming from the N.E., or, coming from the E., they might strike the country at a point to the N. of Pal and travel southward. So the wind which destroys the locust (2 20) would be a northwesterly wind, driving the forepart into the Dead Sea and the hinder part into the Mediterranean. The Book of Joel has been assigned by different authorities to very various dates, ranging over 4 or 5 cents.; but, as will appear in the 4. Indica- sequel, it comes to be a question tions of whether the book is very early or very Date late, in fact, whether J. is perhaps the very earliest or the very last or among the last of the writing prophets. This diversity of opinion is due to the fact that there are no direct indications of date in the book itself, and that such indirect indications as it affords are held to be capa- ble of explanation on the one view or the other. It will be noticed also that, to add to the uncertainty, many of the arguments adduced are of a negative kind, i.e. consideration of what the prophet does not mention or refer to, and the argument from: silence is notoriously precarious. It will, therefore, be convenient to specify the indications available, and to note the arguments drawn from them in support of the respective dates. (1) Place in the Canon—An argument for a very early date is based upon the place of the book in the collection of the “twelve” minor prophets. It stands, in the Heb Bible, between Hos and Am, who are usually spoken of as the earliest '‘ writing prophets.” It is true that, in the LXX. collection, the order is different, viz. Hos, Am, Mic, Joel, Oh, Jon; which may indicate that as early as the time of the forma~ tion of the Canon of the Prophets there was uncertainty as to the place of Joel, Ob, and Jon, which contain no direct indication of their dates. But, seeing that there has evidently heen a regard to some chronological order, the hooks heing arranged according to the Assyr, Bah and Pers periods, it cannot be without significance that Joel has found a place so high up in the collection. The 3 indisputahly post-exilian hooks stand together at the end. If Joel‘is late, it must he as late as the latest of these, possibly a great deal later. But if that isso, there was tho greater likelihood of its date heing known to the collectors. It would be a very hazardous, assumption that prophetical books were not read or copied from the time of their first composition till the time they were gathered into a Canon. And, if they were so read and copied, surely the people who handled them took some interest in preserving the knowledge of their origin and authorship. In this connection, attention is directed to the resemblances to the Book of Am before which Joel stands. These are regarded by Reuss as favoring the early date. That large and beautiful passage with which the Book of Am opens dwells upon the thought that the threatenings, which had formerly been uttered against the nations, are about to receive their fulfilment, and that Jeh could not take back His word. Now it is just such a threatening that fills the last part of the Book of Joel. Indeed Amos begins his book with the very phrase in which J. opens his closing address, “‘Jeh will roar from Zion, and utter his voice from Jerus’” (Am 1 2; Joel 4 16). At the end of Am also the happy fertility of Canaan is described in similar terms to those in Joel (Am 9 13; Joel 3 18). Reuss, moreover, draws attention to the remarkable expression fonnd in Joel, and also, though in modified terms, in two Prophets of the Assyr period: “Beat your plow- shares into swords, and your pruning-hooks into spears,” says J. (3 10), whereas we have the oracle in Isa 2 4 and Mic 4 3, “They shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruning-hooks’”’; and it 1s suggested that, if these were current phrases, they were more likely to have been coined in the form employed by J. in earlier and less settled times, when sudden alarms of war called the peaceful husbandman to the de- fence of his fields and flocks. Further, it is pointed out that Amos reproaches the people of his day for impenitence, although Jeh had given them “clean- ness of teeth” and “want of bread” and had “with- holden the rain... . when there were yet three months to the harvest,’’ and smitten them with blasting and mildew and the palmer worm (Am 4 6-9); and all this is the more striking bedause J. represents the distress of his day as unprecedented in magnitude. To all this, advocates of the late date reply that we cannot determine the date of a book by its place in the Canon; for that the collectors were guided by other considerations. As to the resemblances to Am, it may have been on the strength of these very resemblances that the Book of Joel, bearing no date in itself, was placed beside that of Am. Moreover, it is maintained, as we shall see presently that J. has resemblances to other prophets, some of them confessedly of late date, proving that he was acquainted with writings of a very late time. (2) Language and style—Another argument for an early date is based upon the purity of the language and character of the style. The book is written In what may he described as classical Heh, and shows no trace of decadence of language. It is no doubt true that “the style is the man,” as is strikingly illustrated in the very different styles 6f Amos and Hosea, who were practically contemporaneous; so that arguments of this kind are precarious. Still, it is to be noted, that though there ls nothing archaic in the style of Joel, neither is there any- thing archaic in the style of Amos, who would, by the eon of Joel, be our earliest example of written ro i ‘s The pavecates of the very late date reply that the style of J. is too good to he archaic; and that his ad- mittedly classic style is to be explained by the supposition 1691 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joel that, living at a late tlme, he was a diligent student of corer prophetic lt., and molded his style upon the ssical. _ (8) Quotations —Here, therefore, must be men- tioned an argument much relied on by the advo- cates of a very late date. It is said that there are so many resemblances in thought and expression to other OT books that it is incredible that so many writers poser to the early date claimed for Joel should have quoted from this little book or ex- panded thoughts contained in it. A very elaborate comparison of J. with late writers has been made by Holzinger in ZATW, 1889, 89-131; his line of argument being that, while resemblances to un- doubtedly early writers may be explained as the work of a writer in the Renaissance imitating older models, the resemblances to others known to be late, such as Jer, Ezk, II Isa, Pss, Neh, Ch, etc, cannot he so explained if Joel is taken to be early. The principal passages in question are given in the Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges, ‘Book of Joel,” by Professor Driver, who also takes the view that Joel is late. The list is not, perhaps, so formidable as its length would imply. Both writers confess that from several of the passages no conclusion of any value can be drawn, and that there is always a difficulty in determining priority when similarities in diction are found. Many of the expressions quoted look as if they might have been commonplaces of the prophetical lit.; and, if it was possible for a very late writer to quote from so many antecedent writings, it was as possible and much easier for-a number of late writers to go back to the very earliest: prophets, esp. if their words were memorable and germinal. We have heard of the man who objected to Shake- speare because he was full of quotations; and there is perhaps not a line of Gray’s “Elegy” that has not been quoted somewhere, while some of his lines have become household words. But the strongest objection to this argument is this: if Joel had the minute acquaintance with antecedent writers and followed them so closely as is implied, he not only varies from them in essential particulars, but falls below them, as we shall see, in his anticipations of the future. (4) Sttuation.—We have now to look at features of a more concrete and tangible character, which promise to give more positive results. It is main- tained by the advocates of the late date that the situation and immediate outlook of the prophet are not only consistent with the late date but preclude any preéxilian date altogether. The elements of the situation are these: Whereas all the prophets before the downfall of Samaria (722 BC), and even Jeremiah and Ezekiel, mention the Northern King- dom, it is not once named or referred to in Joel; for the occurrence of the name “Israel’’ in 2 27; 3 2.16 cannot support this sense. Judah and Jerus fill our prophet’s actual horizon (2 1.82; 3 6.16f. 20); no king is mentioned or implied, but the elders with the priests seem to be the prominent and ruling class. Further, the temple and its worship are central (1 14; 2 15f) and so important that the cutting off of the meal offering and drink offering is tantamount to national ruin (1 9.18.16; 2 14). Again, there is no mention of the prevailing sins of preéxilian times, the high places with their corrupt worship, or indeed of any specific sin for which the people were to humble themselves, while fasting and putting on sackcloth seem to have a special virtue. All the circumstances, it is held, conform exactly to the time of the post-exilian temple and to no other time. The Northern Kingdom was no more, there was no king in Jerus, the temple was the center and rallying-point of national life, its ritual the pledge and guarantee of God’s presence and favor; the period of legalism had set in. It is confidently averred that at no period prior to the régime inaugurated by Ezra and Nehemiah was there such a conjunction of circumstances. (a) Political: In reply, it is urged in favor of the early date that there was a period in preéxilian time when such a situation existed, viz. the early years of the reign of Joash, when that prince was still an infant; for Jehoiada the priest acted prac- tically as regent after the death of Atbaliah, 836 BC (2 K 11 1-17). This would sufficiently ac- count for the absence of mention of a king in the book. At such a time the priesthood must have held a prominent pono and the temple would overshadow the pa ace in importance. The omis- sion of the Northern Kingdom may be accounted for by the fact that at that time the two kingdoms were on friendly terms; for the two royal houses were connected by marriage, and the kingdoms were in alliance (2 K 3 6 ff; 8 28 ff). Or the omission may have no more significance than the fact that J. was concerned with an immediate and near present distress and had no occasion to mention the Northern Kingdom. To show how unsafe it is to draw conclusions from such silence, it may be ob- served that throughout the first_5 chapters of Isa, larger in bulk than the whole Book of Joel, only Judah and Jerus are nientioned; and, even if it should be maintained that a part or the whole of these chapters dates from after the deportation of the ten tribes, still it is noteworthy that, when the prophet could have made as good use of a reference to the event as Jeremiah and Ezekiel, he does not do so. (b) Religious: The fact that there is no mention of specific national sins, and particularly of the worship of the high places, of which -preéxilian prophets have so much _to say, is made much of by advocates of the late date, Dr. A. B. Davidson, e.g., declaring it to be '' doubt- ful whether such a state of things existed at any time pHoL to the restoration from exile” (Expos, March, 1888); ut perhaps this argument proves too much. If we are to deduce the state of religion in J.'s day from what he does not say on the subject, 1+ may be douhted whether at any time, either before or after the exile, such a condition prevailed. The post-exilian prophets cer- tainly knew of sins in thelr time, sins, too; which restrained the rain and blasted the wine and oil and corn (Hag 1 11). For all that J. says on the subject, the condition of things implied is as consistent wlth the time of Je- hoiada as with that of Nehemiah. And what shall we say of Isalah's positive description of the condition of Jerus before his time: ‘the faithful city . ... she that was full of justice! righteousness lodged in her" (Isa 1 21)? hen was that? So also his promise: “T will restore thy judges as at the first, aud thy coun- sellors as at the beginning: afterward thou shalt he called The city of righteousness, a faithful town" (Isa 1 aap Higher praise cculd scarcely be bestowed, and there is nothing in the Book of Joel to imply that he assumed so much. (c) Ritualistic: Too much has been made of the references to ritual, as if they necessarily implied a post-exilian date. It is not legitimate here to assume that the idea of centralization of worship originated in Josiah’s days, and that the priestly legislation is post-exilian. The mention of ‘‘old men” or “elders” is no such indication. Well- hausen himself maintains that the expression every- where in Joel means nothing more than “old men’”’; and, even if it had an official connotation, the offi- cial elders are an old tribal institution in Israel. It may be noted here again that in the first 5 chapters of Isa elders also are mentioned, and more indubi- tably in an official sense, although the time was that of the monarchy (Isa 3 2.14). And as _to the sanctity of the temple, it will hardly be denied that in the time of Jehoiada the Jerus temple was a place of far more importance than any supposed local shrine, and esp. when there was a call to a united national supplication (see 2 K 11). In point of fact the alleged references to ritual are very few and in most general terms. The “fast’’ is not de- Joel THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1692 noted by the phrases in the legal codes, and was evidently on the footing of such observances as are common and instinctive at all times and among all persons (Jgs 20 26; 18 76; 28112; Jon 3 5 ff). And where in any law-code are priests enjoined to lie all night in sackeloth (1 13)? Or what prescription in any code requires young and old, bridegroom and bride, to press together into the temple (2 16)? And why should not any or all of these things have been done in face of a sudden emergency threatening the ruin of an agricultural people? Moreover, J., so far from ascribing virtue to these outward marks of humiliation in a legal- istic spirit, immediately after mentioning them says: “Rend your heart, and not your garments, and turn unto Jeh your God” (2 13). The only ritual references are to the meal offering and the drink offering (1 9.13; 2 14), and these were not characteristically post-exilian. Indeed, they may be regarded as primitive forms of offering, the produce of the ground without which, among an agricultural people, we can hardly imagine a system of offerings to exist. They are both ancient. Amos regards the meal offering as well known (5 22. 25), and Isaiah uses the word ‘‘vain oblations’’ in speaking of its abuse (Isa 1 13). And though the noun for drink offering is not mentioned in the older prophets, Hosea knows the related vb. and the act of pouring out wine to the Lord (Hos 9 4), and it may be asked whether it is likely that the people performed the act and had no name for the offering itself. Moreover, in an undisputed passage (2 K 16 13.15), both offerings are mentioned in the time of Ahaz. As for the contention that our prophet regards these offerings of so much importance that the cessation of them would be fatal, if our inter- pretation of 1 8f above be correct, the earlier date would be much more appropriate. It was not because the offering threatened to cease, but be- cause the thing offered threatened to be cut off, that J. was so perturbed. The popular view as to the relation of Jeh to His land was ancient, and had a foundation of truth; and in fact Hosea’s teaching would fitly follow and complete that of Joel. Fi- nally it is to be said that J.’s fine forecast of the out- pouring of the Spirit, and of the universal extension of prophetic activity is as far removed as possible from the “‘legalistie” tendency that set in after the exile. And if the argument from silence is of any force at all, it is surely a very remarkable thing that in a book of post-exilian times, there should be no mention of prince or governor, or even of high priest. (5) Foreign nations mentioned or omitted.—Allu- sions to foreign nations, or the absence of allusion, would obviously promise to afford indications of the time of the prophet; and yet here also the allusions have been adduced in support of either of the di- vergent dates. The facts here are as follows: In the fizrst two chapters, where the prophet, as is generally understood, is speaking of his own time and its pressing distress, there is no mention of any foreign nation, not even the kingdom of the ten tribes. The only expression which has been taken to be significant in this connection is the word tr@ “the northern” army (2 20), which some refer to the Assyrians, while others explain it of a northern army in late or apocalyptic time. In ch 3, however, when the prophet is speaking of ‘those days” and “that time” in the future, when the Lord “shall bring back the captivity of Judah and Jerus,” there is to be a gathering of “all nations” in the valley of Jehoshaphat (3 1f); and later on “all the nations” are summoned to appear in the same valley for judgment (3 11f). ‘Tyre, and Sidon, and all the regions of Philistia” are specially reproached (ver 4) because they have carried into their temples the sacred treasures, and have sold the children of Judah and Jerus unto the “sons of the Grecians” (ver 6); in recompense for which their sons and daughters are to be sold into the hand of the children of Judah, to be sold by them to “the men of Sheba, to a nation far off” (ver 8). Finally, at the close (vs 19f), “Egypt shall be a desolation, and Edom shall be a desolate wilderness, for the violence done to the children of Judah, because they have shed innocent blood in their land.” ‘ It is acknowledged that, on either hypothesis, there are difficulties in accounting for the presence or absence of names of foreign nations in this presentation. Those who advocate the late date point with confidence to the silence as to the king- dom of the ten tribes, or to the kingdom of Damas- cus, which, on their hypothesis, had passed away, and the equally significant silence as to Assyria, which had long ago been superseded by the Bab and Pers empires of the East. As to the mention of Tyre and Sidon and the coasts of Philistia (3 4-6), Driver says: ‘The particular occasion referred to by J. must remain uncertain: but the Phoenicians continued to act as slave-dealers long after the age of Amos: and the notice of Javan (Greece) suits better a later time, when Syrian slaves were in re- quest in Greece” (Cambridge Bible, ‘Joel,’ 17). The same writer says on 8 19: ‘There is so little that is specific in what is said in this verse with reference to either Egypt or Edom, that both countries are probably named (at a time when the Assyrians and Chaldaeans had alike ceased to be formidable to Judah) as typical examples of countries hostile to the Jews.” It is pointed out, moreover, that the enmity of Edom was particularly manifest at a late period when Jerus was destroyed by the Chaldaeans, and that this was remembered and resented long ae (Ob vs 10-16; Ezk 25 12ff; 35; Ps 3 On the hypothesis of the early date, it is urged that there was no occasion to refer to the Northern Kingdom. If it was friendly, the inclusive name of Israel for the whole people was sufficient to de- note this, and that it was not hostile in the early days of Joash has already been pointed out. As to Damascus, it was not till the last years of the reign of Joash that Hazael showed hostility to Jerus (2 K 12 17f); and danger from Assyria had not yet emerged, and appears only faintly in Am (3 11; 6 14). Then it is pointed ont that history records how, in the reign of Jehoram, the grandfather of Joash, “Edom revolted from under the hand of Judah, and made a king over them- selves” (2 K 8 20;2 Ch 21 8), and the historian adds that the revolt continued ‘‘unto this day.” It may well have been that in such a revolt the resident Judaeans in the land of Edom suffered the violence referred to in 3 19. Moreover, the Chronicler mentions that, in the same reign, ‘“Jeh stirred up against Jehoram the spirit of the Philis, and of the Arabians that are beside the Ethiopians: and they came up against Judah, and brake into it, and carried away all the substance that was found in the king’s house, and his sons also, and his wives,”’ etc (2 Ch 21 16f). This might be what is referred toin 3 4-6. If the royal family were carried away there would most probably be a deportation of other prisoners, who, taken by the seaboard Philis, would, through the great maritime power of the day, be sold to the distant Greeks. And here it is pointed out that Amos singles out the very nations men- tioned by J.: Philis, Tyre and Sidon and Edom, and reproaches them with offences such as J. specifies (Am 1 6-12). And then, it is added, if the book is as late as Nehemiah, why is nothing said of Samaritans, Mosbites, and Ammonites, who showed such marked hostility in his days (Neh 1693 219; 47; 61)? For Ezekiel also, from whom it issupposed J. derived his reference to the Edomites, mentions also Moabites and Ammonites as hostile to Israel (Ezk 25 1-11). And so far were Tyre and Sidon from being hostile in the days of Nehemiah that we read of similar arrangements being made with them, as in the time of Solomon, for the supply of materials for the rebuilding of the temple (Ezr 3 7). And why is not a word said of the Baby- Jonians, at whose hands Israel had suffered 80 much? So strongly, indeed, are these objections felt by Reuss, that he declares that, should the view of the late origin come to be finally accepted as the more probable, he would decide for a date after the Pers domination, i.e. subsequent to 332 BC. For, he says, the names of peoples introduced at the end of the book, Phoenicians, Egyptians, Philis, Edom- ites, must surely in some way have had an actual significance for the author, who cannot out of caprice have passed over Syrians, Assyrians, Chaldaeans, and Persians. Accordingly, if we are to have nothing to do with the pre-Assyr period, we must come down to the late Balser and Ptolemean dynasties, by whose hostile collisions Judaea was certainly involved in severe trouble. But then, how are we to account for the position of Joel so high up in the collection of prophetical writers? For, on this supposition, we should expect his book to stand in the third division of the Canon. (6) Some notable expressions.—There remain to be noticed some significant expressions which have a bearing on the question of date and, at first sight, seem to indicate a late origin. And yet there is a difficulty. For there is no doubt that our familiarity with the details of the great downfall of the Jewish state leads us to think of the destruction of Jerus when we read of the captivity or scattering of the people. There is, however, a saying in the Talm that a greater distress makes a lesser one forgotten; and the question is whether there may not have been national experiences at an earlier time to which such expressions might be applicable: or, in other words, how early such phrases were coined and became current. (a) “Bring back the captivity’: There is, first of all, uncertainty as to the origin of the phrase “bring back the captivity.” Some connect the word “captivity” (MAW, sh*bhath, MAW, shebhith) with the vb. “to take captive’ (T3WU, shabhah), while others make it the cognate noun of the vb. “to return” (350, shubh), with which it stands connected in the phrase “‘bring back the captivity of Judah and Jerus” (3 1). In the former case the reference would be to the return of captives taken in war, or the return of exiles from captivity; and that view has led to the trin our VS. On the latter view, the expression would mean the restoration of prosperity, of which use we have an undoubted example in the words: ‘Jeh turned the captivity of Job’ (Job 42 10). We can conceive either of - the views to have been the original, and either to be quite early. A main feature of early warfare was the carrying away of prisoners, and the return of such captives was equivalent to a restoration of prosperity. Or again, the relief from any illness or trouble might be expressed by saying that there was a restoration, as e.g. in Scotland a sick person ig said to have “got the turn.” As to the signifi- cance of the phrase in Joel, it is pomted out by the advocates of the early date that, in Nehemiah’s time, the exile was at an end, and the captivity “brought back” (Ps 126). On the other side it 13 said that, though the new order was set up at Jerus, there still remained many Israelites in foreign lands, and J., not satisfied with the meager community in Pal, looked forward to a fuller restoration; or other- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joel wise, that the words are used in the wider and more general sense of restored prosperity. That the phrase was in early use, and in the sense of bringing back captives, is scen in Am 9 14 and Hos 6 11. And it may be observed that the phraseology used by Am to denote going into captivity (Am I 5.15; 6 5.27; 7 17) is employed by the Jews to denote the Bab captivity, and is even used by modern Jews to express the present dispersion. And yet Amos speaks of an “entire captivity” of people in his day (Am 1 6.9m). (b) “Parted my land”: Then again, the expres- sion “parted my land” (3 2) does not seem very applicable to the breaking up of the state, for the land was not parted but absorbed in the great east- erm empires; nor does J. single out Assyrians, Babylonians, and Persians, by whom, if by any, a post-exilian parting of the land was effected. The expression would more fitly apply to such move- ments as the revolt of Edom and Libnah (2 K 8 22), and the successive losses of territory by which the great dominion of David and Solomon was reduced. This process, described as “cutting Israel short” (lit. “cutting off the ends,” 2 K 10 32 AV) is recorded as having begun in the time of Jehu, before the reign of Joash, when outlying parts of territory were smitten by Hazael of Damascus; and J., speaking in God’s name, may have used the expression “my land” as referring to the whole country. (c) “Scattered among the nations’: Whether the expression “scattered among the nations” (3 2) would be applicable to the Israelite inhabitants of such conquered territories or to those sold into slavery (3 6) may be disputed. The expression certainly suggests rather the dispersion following the downfall of the state. And yet it is noteworthy that, if so, J. is the only prophet who uses in that sense the vb. here employed, a very strange thing if he followed and borrowed from them all; for, both in Jer and Ezk, as well as in Dt, other vbs. are used. Jer indeed uses the vb. in comparing Israel to a scattered (or isolated) sheep which the lions have driven away (50 17); but the only other passage in which the word is plainly used of Israel being dispersed among the peoples in all the prov- inces of Persia is Est 3 8. (d) ‘“‘Reproach of the nations’: Then there is the passage: ‘‘Give not thy heritage to reproach, that the nations should rule over them” (or ‘use a byword against them”): “wherefore should they say among the peoples, Where is their God?” (2 17.19; cf m). Here it is to be noted that the idea involved is certainly much older than the time of the exile. In the time of Hezekiah, the ambassa- dors of Sennacherib delivered their taunting mes- sage, which is described as reproaching the living God (2 K 19 4). It was the method of ancient warfare, as is seen in the boasting of Goliath; for it is the same word that is used in that narrative, though rendered in our VS “defy” (1 S 17 10.25f. 36). And, if we read between the lines of the his- torical books, we shall see how common was this habit of “defying” or “reproaching,”’ and how sensi- tive the people were to it (e.g. 1 K 20 21.51.18. 28). All this is anterior to the earliest possible date of J., and proves that, at an early time, there was a consciousness in Israel that the fortunes of the people were bound up with the honor of the national God. It is not to be overlooked that it is in the early part of the book, when he is concerned with the drought and locust, that J. uses this expression. (e) “Strangers passing through”: Toward the ‘elose of the book it is predicted that, in the time of final glory, strangers shall no longer pass through Jerus (3 17). This again would certainly be appli- cable to a late time, after the land had suffered Jofanaine Theol, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1694 many hostile invasions. Yet it can well be under- stood how a prophet at a very early period, think- ing of the glorification of Zion, should imagine a state in which no “stranger” or foreigner should have a footing on the sacred soil, and Israel should dwell in solitary and preéminent exclusiveness. If so, the idea again is of a more primitive kind than the late date would suggest, esp. if we postulate a prophet who had deeply studied earlier prophets, to whom Jerus of the future was the religious me- tropolis of the world, and Zion the place to which all nations would flow (Isa 2 3; 56 7). (f) “Day of Jeh”: A word must be said, in con- clusion, in regard to the “day of Jeh’”’ which figures so prominently in the Book of Joel. In whatever sense it may originally have been employed, whether betokening weal or woe, the expression was an ancient one; for Amos refers to it as current in his day (6 18); and almost all the prophets refer to it in one way or another (Am 6 18-20; Isa 2 12; 13 6.9; 348; Jer 46 10; Lam 2 22; Ezk 30 3; Ob ver 15; Zeph 1 8.18; 2 2.3; Zec 14 1; Mal 4 5). So far as it bears upon the date of Joel the question is: How does his usage compare with those of the other prophets? We find that he uses the expression twice in connection with the visita- tion of the locust (1 15; 2 1), once after speaking of the outpouring of the Spirit (2 31), and once again near the close of the book (3 14). Now, in regard to the earliest occurrences, it will be perceived that J. ison a lower plane than succeeding prophets. He associates the approach of the day of the Lord with a heavy visitation upon material nature, precisely as the simple Oriental of the present day, on the occurrence of an eclipse, or at a visitation of locust or pestilence, begins to talk of the end of the world. And, though the point of view is shifted, and the horizon wider, at the close, it is to he remarked that the highest point attained is the conception of the day of the Lord as the deliverance and glorification of Israel: there is not a hint of that day being a time of testing and sifting of Israel itself, as in Amos and elsewhere (Am & 18-20; Isa 2 12). In fact, so far is he from going beyond the other prophets in his conception, that we may say J. leaves the matter at the point where Amos takes it up. In view of all these perplexing questions, Professor Ad. Merx had some reason for describing the Book ¥ f of ee Pa ee Ai ee ae . View of zenskind) o exegesis; and he publishe a fessor in 1879 a work, Die Prophetie des Joel ores und ihre Ausleger von den aeltesten Zeiten Merx bis zu den Reformatoren, in which, hesides giving a history of the interpretation, he combated the method hitherto employed, and punt forth a novel view of his own. Concluding, on the grounds usually maintained by the advocates of the late date, that Joel ls post-exllian, he makes a comparison of the book witb preceding prophetical lt., in order to show that J. derived his ideas from a study of it, and esp. that he followed step by step the prophecies of Ezekiel. Now in Ezekiel’s outlook, the overflowing of Judaea by the northern people, Gog, plays an important part (Ezk ee re 39 11), and this explalns J.’s reference in As to the precise date: not only is the second temple standing, but the city is surrounded by a wall (2 9); and this brings us down to the government of Nehemiah, after 445 BC; and the book of Neh shows that other prophets hesides Malachi lived_and found acceptance In those days (Neh 6 7.14)._ The circumstances were these. Not only the exile, but the restoration, is a thing of the past. We are to think of Jerus and Judah in the narrowest sense: the elders and all the Inhabitants of the land are addressed, a sort of senatus populusque Romanus, and with them are the priests presiding over an orderly ritual service at the temple. Judah Is un- affected by political movements; the conflict with the Samaritans has died down; Judah is leading a quiet life, of which nothing is recorded hecause there is nothing to record; and the people of the ten tribes have practically disappeared, being swallowed up among the heathen. This undisturbed period is employed in literary labor, as may be inferred from the well-known notice regarding Nehemiah’s collection of books (2 Macc 2 13f), and from the production of such works as Est, Jon, Koheleth, Mal, Ch, Ezr-Neh, etc. The making of books (Eccl 12_12) had not come to an end. 3 2 But now, if the older prophets were seriously studied (cf Dn) 9 2), what impression would they make on the mind of a man like J.?. Was the daily life that followed the time of Nehemiah in any degree a fulfilment of the hopes of a Deutero-Isaiah, a Jeremiah, an Ezekiel, a Zechariah? Could a member of the restored community coutemplate without painful feelings the lamentable condition of existence under the Pers government, the limitation of the people to a narrow territory, the sepa- ration from those still in the Dispersion, the irritation of the worship of the half-heathen Samaritans, the mixed marriages and general low condition, as contrasted with the glowing pictures of the prophets who had spoken of the last days? Such a contradiction between prophecy and event must have disturhed the minds of the more thoughtful; and so, while some said, ‘‘It is vain to serve God" (Mal 8 14), ‘They that feared Jeh spake one with another’’ (Mal 3 16), waiting in hope, believing that the present restoration could not be the true and final bringing back of the captivity. 5 To relieve his mind, J. will write a book, the result of his study; and it must depict the full and final con- summation. Living as he did, however, in quiet times, he had not, like earlier prophets, a historical situation to start from. Here, according to Merx, the genius of J. comes into play. Seeking for a type of the end of the world, which was to be the antitype, he found one in the deliverance of Israel from Egypt in the distant past. Just_as at that great crisis the people were rescued from bondage and brought into a wide and fertile land, so in the end Jeh would suhdue all Israel's enemies and place them in a_noble land, uncontaminated by strangers, while He Himself would he enthroned in majesty on Zion. But just as that deliverance was ushered in hy plagues, so also will he the “great day of Jen"; and asa signal type of the wholesale destruction of Israel's ene- mies, he seizes upon the plague of locusts and models his introduction upon Ex 10 4ff. J. had, no doubt, seen many a visitation of locusts; hut what we have before us In chs ] and 2 is not actual description but idealized picture, the groundwork of his eschatology. Accordingly, in the view of Merx, the whole Book of Joel is one piece. There is no historical transition at 2 10; in fact, there is no historical element in it at all. The end of the book being apocalyptical, the beginning, which forms with it a unity, must also relate to no event in J.'s days, but moves likewise in the period at the close of time. The people addressed are not the men of J.'s day, hut those who shall be alive when “that day"' is imminent: in a word, the reader is at 1 2 lifted into the air and placed at the beginning of the final judgment, at the moment when the apocalyptic locusts appear as heralds of the day. ‘ Merx’s view may be taken as an extreme and somewhat fanciful statement of the case for a late post-exilian date; and it does not seem to have found acceptance by the critics who start from a historical basis. Merx himself is fully aware that it is a revival of the allegorical and typical interpre- tation which had its vogue in earlier stages of exposition. But he defends himself on the ground that it was not the ancients who imposed the alle- gorical interpretation upon Scripture, but the original writers who were the first typologists and allegorists, as is notably seen in later books like Ezk and Dni. Whatever opinion may be held‘ on that subject, we must at least recognize the strongly marked eschatology of the book. But this does not of necessity imply a late date. It is no doubt true that the fully developed eschatology, as we see it in the apocalyptic literature of the extra- canonical hooks, came in after the cessation of prophecy proper. Yet prophecy, in its earliest phases, contemplated the distant future, and had its support in such an outlook. Professor A. B. Davidson has said: “Isaiah is the creator of the | eschatology of the OT and of Christianity, and it comes from his hand in a form go perfect that his successors can hardly add a sale touch to it” (Expos T, V, 297). The ancient oracle, found both in Isa and Mic (Isa 2 2-4; Mic 4 1-5), testifies to the triumphant and far-reaching hope of the older seers; and, before Isaiah’s time, both Amos (9 11-15) and Hosea (14 4-8) have their outlook to the final future. The remarkable thing about J., which makes the determination of his date so difficult, is that he seems now to go beyond and now to fall short of other prophets. If he is later than Eze- 1695 kiel and Jeremiah, he has nothing to say of the inclusion of Gentiles in the inheritance of Israel, bat contemplates the final destruction of all Israel’s enemies. If he is a contemporary of Malachi or later, he is less legalistic than that prophet; and whereas in Mal we see the beginning of the fading away of prophecy, J. looks for the time when the Spirit shall be poured out on all flesh, and the sons and daughters shall prophesy (2 28). _ It is this last element in the prophecy of J. that links his book particularly with the NT, for St. Peter quoted J.’s words in this passage 6. Connec- as fulfilled on the day of Pentecost, tion with when the Spirit was poured forth on the NT the assembled multitude (Acts 2 16 ff). Yet, even as the OT prophets one after another caught up the idea, unfolding and expand- ing it, so the NT writers see the approach of the day of the Lord in their own time (1 Thess 5 2; 2 Pet 3 10); for that day is always coming, always near, though still in the future. St. Paul saw the whole creation groaning and travailing in pain, as J. did, and the pouring out of the Spirit at Pentecost was part of, and also more than, the effusion seen by J. What J. said he said truly, though he could not say all. For “that day” has grown in significance as the ages have rolled on; men have seen its ap- proach in the various commotions and upheavals of the world, depicting its features in the colors of the changing times, now praying for it, now dread- ing its approach; and how far from precision are our thoughts in regard to it still! Yet, early or late, unerring is the sure word of prophecy in its essential burden. The concrete historical situations cramble away and leave the eternal truth as fresh as ever: “Jeh reigneth; let the earth rejoice’ (Ps 97 1); it is the hopeful burden of OT prophecy, for “‘right- eonsness and justice are the foundation of thy throne” (Ps 89 14). LirERaturReE (besides that cited above).—Credner, Der Proph. Joel tibersetzt u. erkldrt (1831); Wuensche, Die Weissagungen des Proph. Joel tibersetzt u. erkldrt (1872); the comm. on the Minor Propncteee Pusey, Orelli, Keil, Wellhausen, G. A. Smith; eyrick in Speaker's Com- mentary; Nowack, in Handkommentar zum AT; Marti, in Kurzer Hand-Commentar zum AT. . JAMES ROBERTSON JOELAH, jé-é’la (T2NPM, yo'e’lah, perhaps= mop, yoelah, “may he avail!’): One of David's recruits at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 7 [Heb 8]); a Benjamite or perhaps a Judaean (see Cartis, Ch, 195 f). JOEZER, jé-é'26r (MIP, yo'ezer, “Ieh is help”): One of David’s Benjamite recruits at Ziklag, though perhaps a Jaudaean (1 Ch 12 6 [Heb 7]). JOGBEHAG, jog’bé-bi (71733>, yoghbehah): A city in Gilead assigned to Gad and fortified by that tribe (Nu 32 35). It lay on the line along which Gideon chased the Midianites (Jgs 8 11), and the indication there leaves no doubt that it is repre- sented today by Ajbeihat. The name attaches to 3 groups of ruins which date from Rom times. The position is about.7 miles N.W. of ‘Amman, and about midway between that city and the town of es-Sall. It stands 3,468 ft. above the level of the Mediter- ranean. Liverature.—Oliphant, Land of Gilead, 232; Baede- ker-Socin, Pal. JOGLI, jog’li (227, yoghli, perhaps=“led into exile”): Father of Bukki, a Danite chief (Nu 34 22). JOHA, jo/’ha (NM, yoha’, meaning unknown, but perhaps=M8", yd’Gh, “Joah”’; see HPN, 283, n. 4): (1) A Benjamite (1 Ch 8 16). (2) One of David’s mighty men (i Ch 11 45). THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA eh ohannine Theol. JOHANAN, jé-ha’nan (j301, ydhanan, “Jeh has been gracious”; Iwavav, Joandn; cf JEHOHANAN): (1) Son of Kareah, and one of “‘the captains of the forces who were in the fields” (i.e. probably guerilla bands), who allied with Gedaliah, governor of Judah, after the fall of Jeras, 586 BC (2 K 26 23; Jer 40 7—48 7). He warned Gedaliah of the plot of Ishmael ben Nethaniah, who was instigated by the Ammonite king Baalis, to murder the governor; but the latter refused to believe him nor would he grant J. permission to slay Ishmael (40 8-16). After Ishmael had murdered Gedaliah and also 70 northern pilgrims, J. went in pursnit. He was joined by the onwilling followers of Ishmael, but the murderer escaped. Thereupon J. settled at Geruth-Chimham near Bethlehem (ch 41). As Ishmael’s plan was to take the remnant to the land of Ammon, so that of J. and his fellow-chiefs was to go to Egypt. They consulted the Divine oracle through Jeremiah, and received the answer that they should remain in Judah (ch 42). But the prophet was accused of giving false connsel and of being influenced by Baruch. The chiefs then resolved to go to Egypt, and forced Jere- miah and Barnch to accompany them (ch 43). (2) The eldest son of King Josiah (1 Ch 3 15), apparently = ‘‘Jehoahaz” (2 K 23 30-33). (3) Son of Elioenai, and a Davidic post-exilic prince (1 Ch 3 24). (4) Father of the Azariah who was priest in Solomon’s time (1 Ch 6 9.10 [Heb 5 35.36]). (5) A Benjamite recruit of David at Ziklag, bat perhaps a Judaean (1 Ch 12 4 [Heb 5}). (6) A Gadite recrnit of David at Ziklag (1 Ch 12 12 [Heb 13]). (7) Heb has “Jehohanan,” an Ephraimite chief (2 Ch 28 12). (8) A returned exile (Ezr 8 12) = ‘‘Joannes’’(1 Esd 8 38, AV “Johannes”’). (9) Neh 12 22.23=JeHonanan, (3). Daviv Francis Roperts JOHANNES, jé-han’es, jé-han’éz. See Joannzs. JOHANNINE, jé-han’in,-in, THEOLOGY, THE: I. Tus ANTECEDENTS 1. Personality of Writer 2. Earlier NT Writings 3. Christian Experience and Teaching of History 4. Widening Contact with Gentile World 5. The Odes of Solomon 6. Antagonism to Gnostic Speculation Il. Tas Divine Narvre 1. God Is Spirit Ged Is Life 3. God Is Light . 4. Ethical Attributes—God Is Righteous 5. God Is Love (1) The Love of God— (a) Primarily a Disposition (6) Embodied in Christ's Self-Sacrifice (c) Love in Redemption (2) Love Is God's Nature III. Tus INcAaRNATION 1. Historical Antecedents of the Logos-Doctrine 2. The Logos-Doctrine in St. John 3. oe Learns ton as Delineated In the Fourth ospe 4. The Incarnation In the First Epistle 5. Practical Implications of the Incarnation IV. Tue Hory Spirit . 1. The Work of the Spirit—in the Fourth Gospel Perpetuates, but also Intensifies the Con- sciousness of Christ 2. In the First Epistle (1) A Divine Teacher (2) Other Aspects 4 3. The Person of the Splrit His Deity Implied V. Doctrine oF SIN AND PROPITIATION 1. Sin 2, Propitlation (1) In the Gospel (2) In the Epistle (3) One with NT Teaching VI. Evernat Lire 1. Ethical Rather than Eschatological 2. Metaphysical Aspect Reply to Criticism » Johannine Theol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1696 3. Development of Doctrine (1) Source in God y (2) Mediated by Christ (3) Through the Spirit _ (4) The Diviue ‘' Begetting’’ (5) The ‘‘Children of God” (6) The Divine Abiding VII. Homan Natocre anp Its REGENERATION 1. The World 2. Two Classes in the Human Race VIII. Tae Cnurcn ann SackaMENTS 1. The Church 2. The Sacraments (1) Baptism (2) The Lord’s Supper IX. Escuaatoroor 1. Type of Thought Idealistic . Yet History Not Ignored . Nor Eschatology . Eschatological Ideas (1) Eternal Life (2) Antichrist 3) Resurrection {3} Judgment | (5) The Parousia 4 (a) A ‘'Manifestation”’ (b) Reiation to Believers Literature The materials for the following sketch of the Johannine theology are necessarily drawn from the Fourth Gospel and the Epp., chiefly the First Ep., of St. John. The question of authorship is not here considered (see articles on the GospEeL and on the Epp. of St. Jonn). These writings, whether by the same or by different authors, are equally saturated with that spiritual and theological atmosphere, equally characterized by that type of thought which we call Johannine, and which presents an interpreta- tion of Christianity scarcely less distinctive and original than Paulinism. Where there are differences in the point of view, these will be indicated. dL. The Antecedents of the Theology.—To attempt a full account of the historical sources and ante- cedents of the Johannine theology is 1. Person- beyond the scope of the present article; ality of but they may be briefly indicated. Writer Much must be attributed to the per- sonality of the great anonymous writer to whom we directly owe this latest develop- ment of NT thought. Only a thinker of first rank among the idealists and mystics, a mind of the Platonic order, moving instinctively in the world of supersensnous realities, absorbed in the passion for the infinite, possessing 1n a superlative degree the gift of spiritual intuition, could under any conditions have evolved a system of thonght having the special characteristics of this theology. Yet with all his originality the builder has raised his structure upon the foundation already laid in the teaching represented by the earlier Rob) 2. Earlier NT writings. The synoptic tradition, NT though freshly interpreted, is pre- Writings supposed. At certain points there is a strong affinity with the Ep. to the He. In the main, however, the Johannine doctrine may. be said to be a natural and inevitable devel- opment of Paulinism—the conclusion to which the earlier writer’s mind is visibly moving in e.g. the Ep. to the Col. ‘ Among the influences which have stimulated and guided this development, the first place belongs to the natural growth of Christian ex- 3. Christian perience and the teaching of history. Experience In the closing decades of the 1st cent., and Teach- Christianity was compelled by the ing of force of events to liberate itself more History completely from the husk of Jewish Messianism in which its Divine seed had first been deposited. The faith of the first Christian generation in the Messiahship of Jesus and the triumph of His cause had expressed itself (necessarily so, under the historical conditions) in vivid expectation of His Second Coming. He was only waiting behind the clouds, and would speedily return to the earth for the restitution of all things (Acts 8 21). Butafter the fall of Jerus this primitive apocalypticism became, with the passing years, more and more discredited; and the Christian faith had either to interpret itself afresh, both to its own con- sciousness and to the world, or confess itself “such stuff as dreams are made of.” It would be diffi- cult to overestimate the service which the Johan- nine theology must have rendered in this hazard- ous transition by transferring the emphasis of Christian faith from the apocalyptic to the spirit- ual, and leading the church to a profounder reali- zation of its essential and inalienable resources in the new spiritual life it possessed through the ever- living Christ. Eternal life was not merely a future felicity, but_a present possession; the most real coming of Christ, His coming in the Spirit. The Kingdom of God is here: the eternal is now. Such ue the great message of St. John to his age, and to all ages, ; In another direction, the widening contact of Christianity with the gentile world had stimulated the development of doctrine. A. dis- 4. Widen- entanglement from Jewish nationalism, ing Contact more complete than even St. Paul had with Gentile accomplished, had become a@ necessity. World lf Christianity was to find a home and a sphere of conquest in the Gr-Rom world—to recreate Enropean thought and civili- zation—the person of Christ must be interpreted as having a vastly larger significance than that of the Jewish Messiah. That this necessity hastened the process of thought which reached its goal in the Logos-doctrine of St. John cannot well be doubted. The way had so far been prepared by Philo and the Jewish-Alexandrian school. And while it is prob- ably mere coincidence that Ephesus, with which the activity of St. John’s later years is associated by universal tradition, was also the city of Heraclitus, who, 500 years earlier, had used the term Logos to express the idea of an eternal and universal Reason, immanent in the world, there is as little room as there can be motive for questioning that in the Johannine theology Christian thought has been in- fluenced and fertilized at certain points by contact with Hellenism. On the other hand it is possible that this Influence has heen overrated. Fresh material for the investlgation of the sources and connections of the Jo- 5. The eee pueoleey i pyaised at the recent discovery of the Odes of Solomon Odes of (J Rendel Harfis, M.A., Odes and Pools Solomon = of Solomon, Cambridge, 1909; Adolf Har- nack, Ein jidisch-christliches Psalmbuch aus dem ersten Jahrhundert, Leipzig, 1910). This col- lection of religious poems is regarded by its dis- coverer, Rendel Harris, as the work of a writer who, while not a Jew, was a member of a community of Chris- tians who were for the most part of Jewish extraction and beliefs. But though the Odes in their present form contain distinctly Christian elements (references, e.g, to the Son, the Incarnation, the Virgin Birth, the Pas- sion, the Descensus ad inferos), Harnack's closer analysls tends to the conclusion that in their original form they were purely Jewish, and that they have heen adapted to Christian use by a poe of interpolation. For the original work Harnack gives as a possihle date the he- ginning of the Christian era, the Ohristlan redaction fall- ing within the lst cent. Harnack recognizes a possihlllty that the redactor may have been acquainted with the Fourth Gospel. The religious feeling of the writer is throughoutindividual and mystical, rather than national- istic and Messianic. The characteristic atmosphere is strongly Johannine (we may quote in illustration only the nohle sentence from the 12th ode: “The dwelling-place of the Word }s man; and its truth is Love"). The Odes have, in common with the Johannine writings, such lead- ing conceptions as ‘‘ grace,” ‘' believing,”’ ‘‘knowledge,"’ truth,” “light,” “living water,” ‘life’ (for a full exhibitlon of the parallelisms, see article by R. H. Strachan, Expos T, October, 1910). Harnack asserts deliherately (p. 99) that in the Odes we possess ‘the presuppositions of the Johannine theology, apart from the historical Jesus Christ, and without any Messianic doctrine.” More recent criticism of the Odes, however, 1697 has resuited in great diversity of view regarding their origin. They have been assigaed to Gnosticism, and on the contrary to Montanilsm; and again are described (Bernard) as Christian baptismal hymns. In view of this division of critical oplnion, ail thatcan be said in the meantime is that the Odes testify to a collateral mystical development, the recognition of which necessitates a re- visioa of the estimates which have been made regarding the extent to which the Johannine theology is indebted to Hellenistic philosophy. One other factor in this theological development remains to be mentioned—antagonism to gnostic speculation. In the Gospel this has 6. Antago- left not a few traces, in the way both nism to of statement and omission; in the lst Gnostie Ep. scarcely any other danger to the Speculation faith and life of the church is appre- _ hended than the spreading influence of gnostic tenets (see Jonn, Epistu@s oF). St. John himself has been charged with gnostic tend- encies; but the truth rather is that to him Gnosti- cism must have been the more hateful and have seemed the more dangerous because its conceptions were at some points the caricature of hisown. In it he saw the real Antichrist, the “spirit of error,” giving fatally misleading solutions of those prob- lems which the human mind can never leave alone, but regarding which the one true light is the historic Christ. Gnosticism had lost all historical sense, all touch with reality. It moved in a world of sheer mythology and speculation; history became allegory; the incarnate Christ a phantasm. St. John took his stand only the more firmly upon his- torical fact, insisted the more strenuously upon the verified physical reality of the Incarnation. In many of its adherents Gnosticism had lost almost completely the moral sense; St. John the more vehemently asserts the inviolable moral purity of the Divine nature and of the regenerate life which is derived from it. Gnostic dualism had set God infinitely far from men as transcendent Being; St. John brings God infinitely near to men as Love; and sweeps away the whole complicated mythology of gnostic emanations, aeons and archons, by his doctrine of the Logos, coeternal and coequal with the Father, incarnate in Jesus, through whom humanity is made to participate in the very life of God—the life of all love, purity and truth. il. The Divine Nature.—One of the glories of the Johannine theology is its doctrine of God, its de- lineation of the Divine nature. This 1. GodIs is given in a series of intuitional Spirit affirmations which, though the manner of statement indicates no attempt at correlation, unite to form a complete organic con- ception. The first of these affirmations defines what is the Divine order of being: God is Spirit Wn 4 24). The central significance of this inexhaustible saying is defined by the context. The old local worships, whether at Jerus or Samaria, had implied some special local mode of Divine presence; and this naturally suggested, if it did not necessitate, the idea of some kind of materiality in the Divine nature. But God is spirit; and true worship must be an intercourse of spirit with spirit, having rela- tion to no local or material, but only to moral con- ditions. Thus the concept of the Divine spiritual- ity is both moral and metaphysical. The religious relation to God, as it exists for Christian faith, rests upon the fact that the Supreme Being is essentially moral, but also omnipresent and omniscient—the Divine Spirit whose will and percipiency act imme- diately and simultaneously at every point of exist- ence. Such a Being we utterly lack the power to comprehend. But only such a Being can he God, can satisfy our religious need—a Being of whom we are assured that nothing that is in us, good or evil, true or false, and nothing that concerns us, past, present or future, is hid from His immediate vision THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Johannine Theol. or barred against the all-pervading operation of His will. To realize that God is such a Being is to be assured that He can he worshipped with no mechani- cal ritual or formal observance: they that worship Him must worship Him “‘in spirit and in truth.” God, who is spirit, is further conceived as Life, Light, Righteousness and Love. Righteousness and Love are the primary ethical quali- 2. GodIs_ ties of the Divine nature; Life the Life energy by which they act; Light the self-revelation in which they are mani- fested throughout the spiritual universe. God is Life. He is the ultimate eternal Reality. He was “in the beginning” (Jn 1 1), or “from the begin- ning” (1 Jn 11; 213). These statements are made of the Logos, therefore a fortiori of God. But the Divine nature is not mere abstract being, infi- nite and eternal; it is being filled with that inscru- table elemental energy which we call Life. In God this energy of life is self-originating and self- sustaining (“The Father hath life in himeelf,” Jn & 26), and is the source of all life (Jn 1 3.4, RV m). For every finite being life is union with God according to its capacity. But the lower potencies of the creative Life do not come within the scope of the Johannine the- ology. The term is restricted in usage to its high- est ethical significance, as denoting that life of per- fect, holy love which is “the eternal life,”? the pos- session of which in fellowship with God is the chief end for which every spiritual nature exists. The elements present in the conception of the Divine life are these: (1) The ethical: the life God lives is one of absolute righteousness (1 Jn 2 29), and perfect love (1 Jn 49). (2) The metaphysical: the Divine life is nothing else than the Divine nature itself regarded dynamically, as the ground and source of all its own activities, the animating principle or energy which makes Divine righteous- ness and love to he not mere abstractions hut active realities. (3) In Johannine thought the Divine life is esp. an energy of self-reproduction. It is this by inherent moral necessity. Love cannot but seek to heget love, and righteousness to heget righteousness, in all heings capable of them. With St. John this generative activity of the Divine nature holds a place of unique prominence. It is this that constitutes the Fatherhood of God. Eternally the Father imparts Himself to the Son (Jn 5 26), the Word whose life from the hegin- ning consisted in His relation to the Father (1 Jn 1 2). To men eternal life is communicated as the result of a Divine hegetting (Jn 1 13; 3 5; 1 Jn 2 29; 3 9; 4 7, etc) by which they hecome ‘‘chil- dren of God” (Jn 112; 1 Jn 31, etc). (4) But God is not only the transcendent final source, He is also the immanené source of life. This is clearly implied in all those passages, too numerous to be quoted, which speak of God’s abiding in us and our abiding in Him. Life is maintained only through a continuous vitalizing union with Him, as of the branches with the vine (Jn 15 1-6). It must be observed, however, that St. John nowhere merges the idea of God in that of life. God is personal; life is impersonal. Theeternal life is the element common to the personality of God, of the Logos, and of those who are the “children of God.’ Any pantheistic manner of thinking is as foreign to St. John as to every other Bib. writer. God is not life only; He is light also (1 Jn 1 5). That God is life means that He is and is self-impart- ing; that He is light means that the Divine nature is by inward necessity self-revealing. (1) As the essential property of light is to shine, so God by His very nature of righteousness and love is necessitated to reveal Himself as being what He is, 3. God Is Light Johannine Theol, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1698 so as to become the Truth (4 é\7#Gea, hé alétheia), the object of spiritual perception (yivdexev, gind- skein), and the source of spiritual illumination to every being capable of receiving the revelation. “God is light, and in him is no darkness at all.”’ In God there ig nothing that hides, nothing that is hidden. The Divine character is utterly trans- parent—goodness without a shadow of evil. (2) This self-revelation of God is given in its perfect form in Jesus, the incarnate Word, who is the light of men (Jn 1 4), the light of the world (Jn 8 12; 9 5), the true light (Jn 19; 1 Jn 28). (8) Itis in their illumination by this Divine light that there exists, even for the sinful, a medium of moral fellow- ship with God. We can “come to the light” (Jn 3 19-21) and “walk in the light” (1 Jn 1 7). In the translucent atmosphere of the truelight, we, even while morally imperfect and impure, may come to have a common view of aspiritnal facts with God (1 Jn 1 8-10; 29.10). This is the basis of a spiritual religion, and distingnishes Christianity from all irrational superstitions and unethical ritualisms. In gnostic speculation the Divine nature was conceived as the ultimate spiritual essence, in eternal separation from all that is material 4, Ethical and mutable. But while St. John Attributes also, as we have seen, conceives it in this way, with him the conception is primarily and intensely ethical. The Divine nature, the communication of which is life and the revela- tion of which is light, has, as its two great attributes, Righteousness and Love; and with his whole soul St. John labors to stamp on the minds of men that only in righteousness and love can they walk in the light and have fellowship in the life of God. It is characteristic of St. John’s intuitional fashion of thought that there is no effort to correlate these two aspects of the ethical perfection of God; but, broadly, it may be said that they are respectively the nega- tive and the positive. Love is the sum of all that is positively right; righteousness the antithesis of all that is wrong, in character and conduct. God is righteous.—(1) That such righteousness— antagonism to all sin—belongs to, or rather is, the moral nature of God, and that this lies at the basis of Christian ethics is categorically affirmed. “If ye know that he is righteous, ye know that every one also that doeth righteousness is begotten of him” (1 Jn 2 29). (2) This righteousness which belongs to the inward character of God extends necessarily to all His actions: “If we confess our sing, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins’ (1 Jn 1.9). Whenon the ground of Christ’s propitiation God forgives those who by confessing their sins make forgiveness possible, He acts right- eously; and because He acts righteously, He acts also faithfully, that is, self-consistently. He does not “deny himself” (2 Tim 2 13), but does what is in accordance with His own unchangeable char- acter. (3) God’s righteousness is related impera- tively to the whole moral activity of His creatures, rendering sin inadmissible in them—inadmissible de jure in all, de facto in all who are “begotten of him.” This St. John maintains with unexampled vigor (cf 1 Jn 2 29; 3 68-10; 6 18). It is true, however, that in its doctrine of Divine righteous- ness the Johannine theology makes no notable con- tribution to the sum of NT thought, but simply restates in peculiarly forceful fashion the conception of it which pervades the whole Bib. revelation. (1) The love of God.—It is far otherwise with the next of the great affirmations which constitute its doctrine of God: God is Love. 5. GodIs Here Gospel and Epistle rise to the Love summit of all revelation, and for the first time clearly and fully enunciate that truth which is the innermost secret of existence. (a) Primarily a disposition: Love is primarily a disposition, a moral quality of the will. What this quality is is indicated by the fact that the typi- cal object of love in human relation is invariably our “brother.” It is the disposition to act toward others as it ig natural for those to do who have all interests in common and who realize that the full self-existence of each can be attained only in a larger corporate existence. It is the mysterious power by which egoism and altruism meet and coalesce, the power to live not only for another but in another, to realize one’s own fullest life in the fulfilment of other lives. It is self-communication which is also self-assertion. ; : (b) Embodied in Christ’s self-sacrifice: In history » love has its one perfect embodiment in the self- sacrifice of Christ. “Hereby know we love [ie. perceive what love is], because he laid down his life for us’ (1 Jn 3 16). The world had never been without love; but till Jesus Christ came and laid down Hislife for the men that hated and mocked and slew him, it had not known what love in its greatness and purity could be. : : (c) Love in redemption: But here history is the invisible translated into the visible. The self- sacrifice of Christ in laying down His life for us is the manifestation (1 Jn 4 9), under the conditions of time and sense, of the love of God, eternal and invisible. In the closely related || passages (Jn 3 16; 1 Jn 4 9.10) this is declared with matchless simplicity of statement. The Divine love is mani- fested in the magnitude of its gift—“‘his Son, his only begotten” (elsewhere the title is only ‘‘the Son” or “his Son” or “the Son of God’’). Other gifts are only tokens of God’s love; in Christ its all is be- stowed (cf Rom 8 32; Gen 22 12). The love of God is manifested further in the purpose of its gift— “that whosoever believeth on him should not perish, but have eternal life.” It is the self-determination of God, not only to rescue men from what is the sum and finality of all evils, but to impart the supreme and eternal good. But again, the love of God is manifested in the means by which this pur- pose is achieved. THis son is sent as ‘‘the propitia- tion for our sins.” God shrinks not from the utter- most cost of redemption; but in the person of His Son humbles Himself and suffers unto blood that He may take upon Himself the load of human guilt and shame. And the last element in the full conception of Divine love is its objects: ‘‘God so loved the world”; ‘Herein is love, not that we loved God, but that he loved us.” Its ineffable mystery reveals itself in its absolute spontaneity, its self-origination. Its fires are gelf-kindled; it shines forth in its purest splendors upon the un- attractive and unworthy. Such is the conception St. John sets before us. In_ this entirely sponta- neous, self-determined devotion of God to sinful men; this Divine passion to rescue them from sin, the supreme evil, and to impart to them eternal life, the supreme good; in this, which is evoked not by their worthiness but by thcir need, and goes to the uttermost length of sacrifice in bearing the utter- most burden of their sin and its inevitable conse- quences; in this, which is forever revealed in the mission of Jesus Christ, God’s only begotten Son, is love. (2) Love is God’s naturex—And God is love (1 Jn 4 8.16). (@) God is love essentially. Love is not one of God’s moral attributes, but that from which they all proceed, and in which they all unite. The spring of all His actions islove. (b) Therefore also His love is universal. In a special sense He loves those who are spiritually His children (Jn 14 23); but His undivided and essential love is given also to the whole world (Jn 8 16; 1 Jn 2 2). That is St. John’s great truth. He does not attempt to 1699 reconcile with it other apparently conflicting truths in his theological scheme; possibly he was not conacious of any need to do so. But of this he is sure—God is love. That fact must, in ways we cannot yet discern, include all other facts. (c) The love of God is eternal and unchangeable; for it does not depend on any merit or reciprocation in its object, but overflows from its own infinite ful- ness. We may refuse to it the inlet into our life which it seeks (Jn 3 19; 5 40); we may so identify ourselves with evil as to turn it into an antagonistic force. But as our goodness did not call it forth, neither can our evil cause it to cease. (d) If love is an essential, the essential attribute of God, it follows that we cannot ultimately conceive of God as a single simple personality. It is at this point that the fuller Johannine conception of multiple personality in the Godhead becomes most helpful, enabling us to think of the Divine life in itself not as an eternal solitude of self-contemplation and self- love, but as a life of fellowship (Jn 1 1; 1 Jn 1 2). The Godhead is filled with love. “The Father loveth the Son” (Jn 3 35); and the prayer of the Son for His followers is ‘‘that the love wherewith thou lovedst me may bein them” (Jn 17 26). The eternal giving and receiving of Divine love between the Father and the Son is, in the Johannine theology, an essential element of the Divine nature. Hl, The Incarnation.—The 2d great coutribu- tion of the Johannine writings to the development of Christian theology is their doctrine of Christ— the latest and most deliberate effort within NT times to relate intellectually the church’s faith in Jesus to its faith in God. In these writings the superhuman personality of Jesus is expressed by three titles which are used as practically synony- mous—“the Christ,” “the Son” (‘Son of God,” “only begotten Son of God”), the “Word”? (Logos). The last alone is distinctively Johannine. Historically, the Logos-doctrine of St. John has undoubted links of connection with certain_specu- lative developments both of Gr and Heb thonght. The Heraclitean use of the term “Logos” (see above, I) to express the idea of an eternal and all- embracing Reason immanent in the world was continued, while the con- ception was further elaborated, by the Stoics. On the other hand, the later developments of Heb thought show an increasing tendency to personify the self-revealing activity of God under such conceptions as the Angel, Glory, or Name of Jeh, to attach a peculiar significance to the ““Word”’ (m@' mera’) by which He created the heaven and the earth, and to describe “Wisdom” (Job, Prov) in something more than a figurative sense as His agent and eoworker. These approximations of Gr pan- theism and Heb monotheism were more verbal than real; and, naturally, Philo’s attempt in his doctrine of the Logos to combine philosophies so radically divergent was less successful than 1t was courageous. How far, and whether directly or indirectly, St. John is indebted to Philo and his school, are ques- tions to which widely different answers have been given; but some obligation, probably indirect, cannot reasonably be denied. It is evident, indeed, that both the idea and the term ‘‘Logos” were current in the Christian circles for which his Gospel and First Ep. were immediately written; in both its familiarity is assumed. Yet the _Johannine doctrine has little in common with Philo’s except the name; and it is just in its most essential fea- tures that it is most original and distinct. E As the OT begins with the affirmation, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth, so the Fourth Gospel begins with the similar affirma- tion, “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word 1. Histor- ical Ante- cedents of the Logos- Doctrine THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Johannine Theol. was with God, and the Word was God” (Jn 1 1). The Word was the medium of Divine action in crea- tion (Jn 1 3). Ia the Word was 2. The life, not merely self-existing but self- Logos- imparting, so that it became the light Doctrine in of men (Jn 1 4)—the true light, which, St. John coming into the world lighteth every man (Jn 19). And finally it is de- clared that this Divine Word became flesh and tabernacled among us, so that ‘‘we beheld his glory, glory as of the only begotten from the Father, full of grace and truth” (Jn 1 14). Here faith in Jesus as Divine has been traced back to, and grounded in, a duality within the Godhead itself. In the twofold mode of the Divine existence, it is seen that there is God who is just God (so to gay), God in Himself; and there is God-with-God, God who is God's other self, God going forth from Himself in thought and action. The first withont the second would be essence without manifestation, mind without utterance, light without effulgence, life without life-giving, fatherhood without sonship. It is seen that within the Divine Being there is one through whom, as there is also one from whom, all Divine energy goesforth. Above all it is seen that there is a Divine mode of existence in which it is inherently possible and natural for God to be imme- diately related to created being and even to become incarnate in humanity, as there is also a mode of Divine existence which cannot be immediately communicated or revealed to created life. Thus the Johannine doctrine is: first, that the Logos is personal and Divine, having a ground of personal being within the Divine nature (prés tén theén, “‘in relation to God”); and, second, that the Logos peosine flesh, was and is incarnate in the historical esus. In the Gospel the term “Logos” does not recur after the opening verses; yet the thesis of the Prologue, so far from being irrelevant, domi- 3. The In- nates the entire biographical presen- carnation tation. The creative and cosmic sig- as Delin- nificance of the Logos-Christ is natu- eated in the rally in the background; but it may Fourth be said of the Gospel that “the Word Gospel became flesh’ is ita text, and all the rest—miracle, incident, discourse—is comment. On the one hand, the reality of the “becoming flesh”’ is emphasized (e.g. Jn_ 4 6; 11 35; 19 1.2.3.17.28.34.38-40; 20 20.27). On the other hand, the human vesture only reveals the Divine glory within. On earth, Jesus isstill ‘‘the Son of man, who is in heaven” (3 13); the perfect revelation of the Father (14 9); the light of the world (8 12); the way, the truth and the life (14 6); the resur- rection (11 26); the final judge (5 22) and Saviour (4 42; 6 40) of men; the supreme moral author- ity (13 34; 14 15.21); the hearer of prayer (14 13.14); the giver of the Spirit (7 38.39; 16 7; 20 22); endowed with all the prerogatives of God (8 23; 10 30.36-38). In the First Ep. the central thesis is the complete, personal, and permanent identity of the historical Jesus with the Divine Being who is 4. The the Word of Life (1 1), the Christ Incarnation (4 2), the Son of God (5 5). This in the First is maintained in a vigorous polemic Epistle against certain heretical teachers whom the writer calls “antichrists,’? who in docetic fashion denied that Jesus is the Christ (2 22), or, more definitely, the ‘Christ. come in the flesh” (4 3), and who asserted that He “came” by water only and not by blood also (5 6; see Jonn, EristLes oF). Against this doctrine of a merely apparent or temporary association of Jesus with the Christ St. John bears vehement testimony. “Who is the liar but he that denieth that Jesus is Johannine Theol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA the Christ?” (2 22). ‘Every spirit that confesseth Jesus as Christ come in the flesh is of God: and every spirit that confesseth not Jesus is not of God’ (4 2.3). ‘‘Who is he that overcometh the world, but he that believeth that Jesus is the Son of God? This is he that came by water and blood, even Jesus Christ; not with the water only, but with the water and with the blood” (5 5.6). These passages all promulgate the same truth in substantially the same way. Without ceasing to be what He is, the Christ, the Son of God, has become Jesus; and Jesus, without ceasing to be truly human, is the Son of God. As to the manner of the incarnation—by what process of self-emptying or by what con- junction of Divine-human attributes the eternal Son became Jesus—the Johannine writings, like the NT everywhere, are silent. They proclaim Jesus Christ as human and Divine; but the distinguish- ing of what in Him was human and what Divine, or whether the one is distinct from the other, this they do not even consider. Gnosticism drew such a distinction; St. John does not. His one truth is that Jesus is the Son of God and the Son of God is Jesus, and that in Him the life of God was mani- fested (1 2) and is given (6 11) to men. In this truth, viewed in its practical consequences, St. John sees the core of the church’s faith and the root and safeguard of its life. (a) 6. Practical This alone secures and guarazitees the Implications Christian revelation of God; with its of the In- denial that revelation is canceled. carnation ‘‘Whosoever denieth the Son, the same hath not the Father’ (2 23). (6) Above all, it is only in the life and death of Jesus, the incarnate Son, that we possess a valid revelation of God’s self-sacrificing love. ‘Herein was the love of God manifested in us, that God hath sent his . . .. Son into the world that we might live through him” (4 9). With the denial of this the Christian ethic is drained of its very life-blood. There was no merely external and accidental connection be- tween Docetism and the moral indifferentism of the Gnostic. The natural result of making man’s salvation easy, so to say, for God, was to make it easy for man also—salvation by creed without con- duct (2 4.6; 3 7), knowledge without love (4 8), or love that paid its debts with goodly phrases and empty words (3 17.18). A docetic Christ meant docetic Christianity. (c) Finally, St. John sees in the incarnation the only possibility of a Divine redemption. It was not for a word or a formula he was concerned, but for the raising of humanity to Divine life through the God-man. The ultimate significance of the incarnation of the Son is that in Him the eternal life of God has flowed into our humanity and become a fountain of regenerative power to as many as receive Him (Jn 112). “He that hath the Son hath the life; he that hath not the Son of God hath not the life’ (1 Jn 5 12). This is the center of the Johannine Gospel—a Divine- human Christ, who stands in a unique, vital rela- tion to men, reproducing in them His own character and experiences as the vine reproduces itsclf in the branches, doing that, the mysterious reality of which is only expressed, not explained, when it is said that He is our “life” (Jn 14 19.20; 16 5). IV. The Holy Spirit.—In one direction the doc- trine of the Holy Spirit is uniquely developed in the Johannine writings. The concep- 1. The tion of the Spirit as the agent of Work of the Christ’s presence with and_ activity Spirit—in_ in the church is presented with a ful- the Fourth ness and clearness unequaled in the Gospel NT. The departing Christ promises to His friends a new presence, different from His own in that it was to be not a bodily but a spiritual presence, and yet really His own—a 1700 presence in which all and more than all the effects of His bodily presence would be perpetuated (Jn 14 18; 16 22). In truth, it was expedient for them that He should go away, in order that this other Paraclete should come (16 7). In the body His presence with His followers had been local and intermittent; in the Spirit He would come to take up His abode with them forever (14 16). Formerly He had been still external to them, but now was not only to dwell with them, but to be in them (14 17). Instead of the external voice of their Teacher addressing to them the words of eternal life, the should possess the very Spirit of truth (14 17), a well- spring of illumination from within, giving them an “understanding” to know Him that is true (1 Jn 6 20); and instead of His visible example before their eyes, an inward community of life with Him like that of the vine and the branches. The com- plete, vital, permanent union of Christ and His people, which had been prevented by the necessary limitations of a local, corporeal state of existence, would be attained, when for this there was sub- stituted the direct action of spirit upon spirit. Perpetuates, but also intensifies the consciousness of Christ—Thus the function of the Spirit which is chiefly emphasized in the Johannine writings is that by which He perpetuates but also intensifies, en- lightens, and educates the consciousness of Christ in the church and in the Christian life. In this respect His nature is the opposite of that of the Logos, the self-revealing God. The Holy Spirit never reveals Himself to human consciousness; He reveals the Son and the Father through the Son. His operations are wholly secret. and inscrutable, known only by their result (Jn 3 8). He is the silent inward monitor and remembrancer of the disciples (Jn 14 20); the illuminator, the revealer of Christ (16 14); aspirit of witness who both Him- self bears witness concerning Christ to His people and makes of them ready and joyful witness-bearers (15 26.27); a guide by whom a steady growth in knowledge is secured, leading gradually on to the full truth of Christ (16 12.13); a spirit of con- viction working in men an immediate certainty of the truth regarding sin and righteousness, and the Divine judgment which marks their eternal antag- onism (16 8-11). In the Ep. we find the promise of the Gospel accomplished iu actual experience. There is no reference to the manifold charismata of 2. Inthe the first age, the prophetic afflatus First excepted (1 Jn 41). But whether Epistle through the prophetic ‘‘medium’” or the normal Christian consciousness, the function of the Spirit is always to “teach” or to ‘‘witness” concerning Christ. This is finely brought out in the parallelism of 1 Jn 5 6: ‘This [Jesus Christ] is he that came’ (once for all fulfilling the Messiah’s mission); “It is the Spirit that beareth witness” (ever authenticating its Divine origin, interpreting its purpose and applying its results). The specific testimony the Spirit bears to Christ is defined (1 Jn 4 2.3). “Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is af God: and every spirit that confesseth not Jesus is not of God.” (1) A Divine Teacher.—The gift of the Spirit is an “anointing from the Holy One” (1 Jn 2 20); and the result of this “anointing” is that “ye know all things” (or that “ye all have knowledge”; the reading is doubtful), and ‘need not that any one teach you” (2 27). The apostle's comfort concerning his readers, encompassed as they are by the snares of Antichrist, is that they have a Divine Teacher, who continually enlightens their under- standing, strengthens their convictions and minis- 1701 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Johannine Theol. ters to them an invincible assurance of the truth of the Gospel. ‘The anointing abideth in you... . and teacheth you concerning all things.’ The spirit is not a source of independent revelation, but makes the revelation of Christ effectual. The truth is placed beyond all reach of controversy and passes into absolute knowledge: “Ye know all things.” It may be added that the history of Chris- tianity furnishes an always growing verification of this Johannine doctrine of a living power of witness and enlightenment present in the church, by which, notwithstanding the constant hindrance of human imperfection, the development of the Christian faith has been steadily advanced, its forgotten or neglected factors brought to, remembrance. Old truths have been presented in new aspects and filled with fresh life, and all has been brought to pass with marvelous adaptation to the church’s needs and in proportion to its receptivity. (2) Other Gipert te other directions the doctrine of the Spirit is less developed. The agency of the Spirit in regeneration is repeatedly and emphatically declared in a single passage (Jn 3 ae but is nowhere else re- ferred to either in the Gospel or the First Ep. More remarkable still, neither in Gospel nor Ep. is the Holy Spirit once spoken of as the Divine agent in sanctification. There is no passage resembling that in which St. Paul speaks of the ethical ‘‘fruit of the Spirit’ (Gal 5 22.23). The Spirit is the Spirit of truth, the revealer, the inspirer of faith, hut is never spoken of as the Spirit of love or holiness. If those who are begotten of God cannot sin, it is not hecause God's Spirit, but because ‘‘his seed,"’ ahideth in them (1 Jn 3 9). The explanation of this peculierly (which has been little, observed) in the Jo- annine theology may be that the Spirit's work of reveal- ing Christ is regarded as all-inclusive. Thus enabling Christ's disciples to abide in Him as the branch in the vine, He secures also their bringing forth ‘‘much fruit" in all Christlikeness of character and conduct. Passing now from the work to the Person, we observe that in the Fourth Gospel the attribution of personality to the Spirit reaches 3. The the acme of distinctness. He is Person of “another Paraclete’”’ (Jn 14 16m), per- the Spirit sonal as Christ Himself is personal; and all the functions ascribed to Him— to remind, to teach, to testify, to guide, to convict— are such as are possible only to a personal agent. Nor is it otherwise in the First Ep. The expressions in it which have been alleged (Pfleiderer and others) as inconsistent with personality (the “anointing,” 2 20; ‘‘He hath given us of his Spirit,” 4 13) require no such interpretation. The ‘‘anointing’’ denotes the Spirit, not in His essence or agency, but as the gift of the Holy One with which He anoints believers (ef Jn 7 38.39); and the expression ‘‘He hath given us of his Spirit”’ (as if the Spirit were a divisible entity) is no more incompatible with personality than is the saying ‘‘to Him whom he hath sent ....y God giveth not the Spirit by measure” (Jn 3 34), or than our speaking of Christians as having more or less of the Spirit. _ ; His Deity implied.—The essential Deity of the Spirit is nowhere explicitly asserted, but is neces- sarily implied in His relation both to Christ and to the church as the “other Paraclete.”’ There is not, however, the same theological development as is achieved regarding the Logos. The Divinity of Christ is grounded in an essential duality of being witbin the Godhead itself; but there is no similar effort to trace back the threefoldness in the revela- tion of God, as Father, Son and Spirit, to an essen- tial threefoldness in the Divine nature. The fact is that both historically and logically the doctrine of the Spirit as the third person in the Godhead depends upon that of the Divine Son as the second. It was through its living experience of the Divine in Christ that the church first developed its thought of God beyond the simple monotheism of the OT; but having advanced to the conception of a twofold Godhead, in which there is Fatherhood and Sonship, i Sin it was bound to enlarge it still further to that of a threefold Godhead—Father, Son and Spirit. The Son and the Spirit were equally manifestations of God in redemption, and must equally stand in essential relation to the Divine existence. V. Doctrine of Sin and Propitiation.—This theme is not elaborated. It is characteristic of the Johan- nine writings that salvation is looked at from the terminus ad quem rather than from the terminus a quo. The infinite good, eternal life, is more in view than the infinite evil, sin. It seems safe to say that the author of these writings at no time had that intense experience of bondage to the law of sin and of death which so colors St. Paul’s presen- tation of the gospel. It was, moreover, no part of his plan to expound the doctrine of propitiation; nor had he any original contribution to make on this head to the sum of NT thought. But it is a quite unwarrantable criticism which denies that the saving work of Christ, in the Johannine conception, con- sists in deliverance from sin. It is true that Christ not only takes away the sin of the world (Jn 1 29), but also draws it forth in its utmost intensity and guilt. All sin culminates in the rejection of Christ (15 22); the Spirit convicts men of sin because they “believe not’? on Him (16 9). “Every one that committeth sin is the bondservant of sin” (8 34); but what reveals the true character of this bondage is that in the presence of the light, men “loved the darkness” (3 19). That the malign quality and power of evil are fully revealed only in the presence of perfect goodness, that the brighter is the light, the darker is the shade of guilt created by its rejection—all this St: John teaches; but such teaching is by no means peculiar to him, and to infer from it that “to his mind sin in itself involves no moral culpability” is nothing more than a way- ward paradox. In the Ep. the guilt of sin as constituting an ob- jective disability to fellowship with God is strongly emphasized. “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves” (1 Jn 1 8). The phrase “to have sin’’ is peculiar to St. John, and specifically denotes the culpability of the agent (cf Jn 9 41; 15 22.24; 19 11). Sin is essentially that which needs God’s forgiveness (1 Jn 1 9; 2 1.2); and to this end an intercessor and a propitiation have been provided. Such culpability is universal: ‘If we say that we have not sinned, we’’—not only deceive our- selves—“we make him a liar” (1 Jn 1 10). A second passage (1 Jn 3 4-9) emphasizes the ethical quality of sin—its antagonism to the nature of God and of the children of God. The word which defines the constitutive principle of sin is “lawlessness” (1 Jn 3 4). Sin is fundamentally the denial of the absoluteness of moral obligation, the repudiation of the eternal law upon which all moral life is based. In other words, to sin is to assert one’s own will as the rule of action against the absolutely good will of God. But again, the Ep. gives the warning that “all unrighteousness is sin” (6 17). Everything that is not right is wrong, Every morally inferior course of action, however venial it may appear, is sin and contains the ele- ments of positive guilt. The perplexing topic of “sin unto death” demands too special treatment to be dealt with here. (1) In the Gospel—The paucity of reference in the Fourth Gospel to the propitiating aspect of Christ’s redemptive work has been seized upon as proof that, though the writer did not consciously reject the orthodox doctrine, it was really alien to his system. But such a criticism might be di- rected with almost equal force against the Synop- tics. It was no part of St. John’s plan, as has been 2. Propi- tiation Johannine Theol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1702 said, to expound a doctrine of propitiation; yet his frontispiece to the ministry of Jesus is ‘‘the Lamb of God that taketh away the sin of the world’; and, as Dr. Inge has pointed out, the same type of the Paschal Lamb underlies the whole narrative of the Passion. In the high-priestly prayer Our Lord expressly represents Himself as the covenant-sac- rifice which consecrates His disciples as the people of God (17 19); while the Synoptic ‘ransom for many” is paralleled by the interpretation of Christ’s death as effectual “for the nation; and not for the nation only, but that he might also gather together into one the children of God that are scattered abroad” (11 51.52; cf 1 Jn 2 2). (2) In the Epistle—In the Ep. the doctrinal statement is much more explicit. The fact of pro- Pitiation is placed in the forefront. The passage which immediately follows the Prologue (1 6—2 2) introduces a group of ideas—propitiation, blood, forgiveness, cleansing—which are taken directly from the sacrificial system of the OT, and are ex- pressed, indeed, in technical Levitical terms. The mode of action by which Christ accomplished and still accomplishes His mission as the Saviour of the world is: ‘He is the propitiation for our sins; and not for ours only, but also for the whole world” (2 2). Propitiation has its ultimate source in the moral nature of God. It is no device for inducing areluctant Deity to forgive; it is the way by which the Father brings back His sinning children to Him- self. In St. John’s conception it is the supreme act of God’s supreme attribute, love. ‘Herein is love” (4 10). Yet it is a real work of propitiation in which this love goes forth for man’s salvation— a work, that is, which expiates the guilt of sin, which restores sinful offenders to God by rendering their sin null and inoperative as a barrier to fellow- ship with Him. This propitiatory virtue is regarded as concentrated in the “blood of Jesus his Son” (1 7), that is to say, in the Divine-human life offered to God in the sacrifice of the cross. This, if we walk in the light as He is in the light, “cleanseth us from all sin’’—removes from us the stain of our guilt, and makes us clean in God’s sight. In virtue of this, Christ is the penitent sinner’s advocate (paraclete-helper) with the Father (21). The words ‘with the Father” are highly significant. Even the Father’s love can urge nothing in apology for sin, nothing that avails to absolve from its guilt. But there is one who can urge on our behalf what is at once the strongest condemnation of our sin and ‘plea for its remission—Himself, ‘Jesus Christ the righteous” (2 1). ‘And he [Himself] is the pro- pitiation for our sins.” St. John does not speak of Christ as “making propitiation’”; He, Himself, in virtue of all He is—Jesns Christ, in whom the Divine ideal of humanity is consummated, in whom the Father sees His own essential righteousness re- vealed, Jesus Christ the Righteons—is both pro- pitiation and intercession. The two acts are not only united in one person, bunt constitute the one reconciling work by which there is abiding fellow- ship between God and His sinning people. (8) One with NT teaching.—In this statement of the doctrine of propitiation, memorable as it is, there is nothing notably original. It tacitly pre- supposes, as NT teaching everywhere does, that God, in bestowing the sovereign grace of pardon and sonship, must deal truthfully and adequately with sin as a violation of the moral order; and with St. John, as with other NT writers, the necessity and efficacy of sacrifice as the means by which this is accomplished are simply axiomatic. His great contribution to Christian thought is the vision of the cross in the heart of the eternal love. How suggestive are these two statements when placed side by side! ‘Herein islove .... that he loved us, and sent his Son to be the propitiation for our sins” (1 Jn 4 10); and ‘‘Hereby know we love [recognize what it is], because he laid down his life for us” (8 16). God’s sending His Son and Christ’s laying down His life are moral equivalents. The sacrifice of Christ is the sacrificeof God. St. John’s doctrine of propitiation follows as a moral neces- sity from his doctrine of God. If God is love, nothing is more inevitably true than that He suffers on account of human sin; and to deny Him the power to help and save men by bearing their burden would be to deny to Him love’s highest prerogative. VI. Eternal Life.—The development of the con- ception of eternal life must be set along with the doctrine of the moral nature of God and the doc- trine of the incarnation as one of the greatest con- tributions of the Johannine theology to NT thought. With this conception the Gospel begins (1 4) and ends (20 31); and, in like manner, the Ep. (1 2; & 20). The designation most frequently employed is simply “the life” (hé 206); 17 tn the Gospel and 6 t in the First Ep. it is described qualitatively as “eternal”; but the adj. brings out only what is implicit in the noun. In harmony with the uni- versal Bib. conception, St. John regards life as the summum bonum, In which the reality of fellowship with God consists, which therefore fulfils the highest idea of being—‘“‘perfect truth in perfect action” (Westcott). Christ Himself is “the life’ (Jn 14 6), its only bestower and unfailing source (14 19). He came that we might have it abundantly (10 10). But this conception is uniquely developed in two directions. While the eschatological element is not lost, it is absorbed in the ethical. The 1. Ethical ideas of duration and futurity, which Rather than are properly and originally expressed Eschato- by the adj. “‘eternal’’ (aiénios=be- logical longing to an aeon—specifically to “the coming aeon”’), become secondary to that of timeless moral quality. Always life is regarded as a present possession rather than as future felicity (e.g. Jn 3 36; 20 31; 1 Jn 3 14. 15; 6 12). For St. John the question whether it is possible to make the best of both worlds is mean- ingless. Eternal life is the best, the Divine, kind of life, whether in this world or another. It is the kind of life that has its perfect: manifestation in Christ (1 Jn 1 2; 6 11). To possess that nature which produces thoughts and motives and desires, words and deeds like His, is to have eternal life. Metaphysically the conception undergoes a develop- ment which is equally remarkable, though in the judg- ment of many, of more questionable value. 2. Meta- It has already been seen (see above, II) hysical that life is conceived as the animating pay: principle or essence of the Divine nature, Aspect the inward energy of which all its activities are the manifold outgoing. And this conception is carried through with strict consistency. The spiritual life in men, which is ‘‘begotten of God,” is the vital essence, the mystic principle which is manifested in all the capacities and activities of Chris- tian personality. It does not consist in, and still less is it a result following, repentance, faith, ohedience or love; itis that of which they are the fruits and the evi- dences. Thus instead of ‘'This do, and thou shalt live’’ (Lk 10 2%), St. John says, conversely, ‘Every one also that doeth righteousness is Nati heen] begotten of’’ God (1 Jn 2 29); iustead_ of ‘‘The just shall live by faith’' (Rom 1 17 AV), ‘‘' Whosoever believeth that Jesus is the Christ is [=has been] hegotten of God’? (1 Jn § 1). The human activity 1s the result and proof of Divine life already imparted, not the condition or means of its attainment. In the Johannine concep- tion life is cause, not effect; not phenomenon, but essence; not the complex whole of the qualities, actlvi- ties and experiences of the spiritual man, hut that which makes them possihle—the inscrutable, Divinely com- municated principle (Jn $ 8) in which tho capacity for them is given and by which also it is realized. _. Reply to criticism.—This Johannine conception of lite is vigorously criticized as importing into the interpreta- tion of Christian experience principles and modes of thought borrowed from Gr philosophy. But the tend- ency to infer causes from effects and to reason from 1703 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Johannine Theol. phenomena to essence is not pecullar to Gr philosophy; it ls native to the human intellect. The Johannine conception of spiritnal life is closely analogous to the common conception of physical life. We do not con- ceive that a man lives because he breathes end feels and acts; we think and we say that he does these things because he lives, because there is in him that mystic rinciple we call life. Only to the thinker trained in the logic of empiricism is it possible to define life solely by its phenomena, as e.g. “the continuous adjustment of internal to external relatlons’’ (Spencer). The ordinary mind instinctively passes hehind the phenomena to an entity of which they are the manifestation. The Jo- hannine conception, moreover, lies_in the natural line of development for NT thought. It is implicit in that whole strain of Our Lord's synoptic teaching which regards doing as only the outcome of being, and which is emphasized in such utterances as “Either make the tree good, and its fruit good; or make the tree corrupt, and its fruit corrupt: for the tree is known by its fruit" (Mt 12 33); as aiso in the whole Pauline doctrine of the new creation and the mystical indweliing of Christ in the memhers of His hody. And while it is no doubt true that the Johannine conception of life was Imme- diately influenced by contact with Hellenism, it is one ee was sure, sooner or later, to emerge in Christlan eology. (1) Source in God.—In the development of the doctrine we note the following points. (a) The sole and absolute source of life is God, the 3. Develop- Father, revealed in Christ. “The ment of Father hath life in himself” (Jn 5 26). Doctrine He is the “living Father” by whom the Son lives (Jn 6 57); _ the “true God, and eternal life” (1 Jn & 20). Eternal life is nothing else than the immanence of God in moral beings created after His likeness; the Divine nature reproducing itself in human nature; the energy of the Spirit of God in the spiritual nature of man. This is its ultimate definition. (2) Mediated by Christ.—Of this life Christ is the sole mediator (Jn 6 33.57; 11 25; 146). The witness is that “‘God gave unto us eternal life, and this life isin hisSon’” (1 Jn 6 11). This mediation is grounded in the relation, eternally subsisting within the Godhead, of the Logos to the Father. The life manifested and seen in the historic Christ (i Jn 1 1) is “‘the life, the eternal life,” which existed in relation to the Father (1 Jn 1 2). By the incarnation of the Son the eternal life in its Divine fulness has become incorporate with human- ity, @ permanent source of regenerative power to “ag many as received him” (Jn 1 12). It is His own relation to the Father that He reproduces in men (Jn 17 23). ne’: (3) Through the Spirit—In the communication of this life the Spirit is the one direct agent (Jn 3 5-8; see above, under IV). (4) The Divine “‘begetting.”—The act of Divine self-communication is constantly and exclusively expressed by the word “beget” (gennén—Jn 1 13; 3 3.5-8; 1 Jn 2 29; 39, etc). The word is of far-reaching significance. It implies not only that life has its ultimate origin in God, but that its com- munication is directly and solely His act. In how literal a sense the Divine begetting is to be under- stood appears very strikingly in 1 Jn 3 9: “Who- soever is begotten of God doeth no sin; because his seed abideth in him.” The unique expression “hig seed” signifies the new life-principle which is the formative element of the “children of God.” This abides in him who has received it. It stamps its own character upon his life and determines its whole development. (5) The “children of God.”—Those who_are “begotten of God” are ipso facto “children of God” (iékna theo, In 1 12; 11 52; 1 Jn 3 1.2.10; 6 2). The term connotes primarily the direct, communi- cation of the Father’s own nature; and secondarily the fact that the nature thus communicated has not as yet reached its full stature, but contains the promise of a future glorious development. We are now children of God, but what it fully is to be children of God is not yet made manifest (1 Jn 3 2). Participation in this life creates a family fel- lowship (koindnia) at once human and Divine. Those who are begotten of God and walk in the light have “fellowship one with another” (1 Jn 1 7). They are “brethren” and are knit together by the instincts (1 Jn 5 1) and the duties of mu- tual love (Jn 13 34; 15 12; 1 Jn 3 16; 4 11) and of mutual watchfulness and intercession (1 Jn 5 16). On the Divine side they have fellowship “with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ”’ (1 Jn 1 3). In this Divine fellowship the life “begotten” 1s nourished and sustained; and no term is more characteristic of the Johannine vocabulary, alike in Gospel and Epp., than the word “abide” (ménein), by which this is expressed. There is, however, a noticeable difference in the modesof statement. In the Ep., the formulae almost exclusively employed are these: “God abides in us,” ‘‘We abide in God,” “God abides in us and we in him.” In the Gospel the reciprocal indwelling is that of Christ and His disciples (Jn 15 4-10), which has its Divine coun- terpart in that of the Father and theSon (Jn 14 10; 17 23; 15 10). This diversity is consistent with the different points of view occupied in the two documents. The Gospel is christocentric; the Ep., theocentric. In the one is given the concrete presentment, of the incarnate Son; in the other the immediate intuition of the Divine nature.revealed in Him. While the theme common to both is the ‘Word of life,’ the special theme of the Gospel is the Word who reveals and imparts the life; in the Ep. it is the life revealed and imparted by the Word, and the thought of the indwelling Christ is naturally carried up to the ultimate truth of the indwelling God. (6) The Divine abiding —The vitalizing union by which the Divine life is sustained in those who are begotten of God consists in two reciprocal activities, not separable and not identical—God’s (or Christ’s) abiding in us and our abiding in Him. As in the similitude of the vine and the branches (Jn 15 1-10), the life imparted is dependent for its suste- nance and growth upon a continuous influx from the parent source: as it is the sap of the vine that vitalizes the branches, producing leaf and blossom and fruit, so does the lifeof God support and foster in His children its own energies of love and truth and purity. But to this end the abiding of God in us has as its necessary counterpart our abiding in Him. We can respond to the Divine influence or reject it; open or obstruct the channels through which the Divine life flows into ours (Jn 15 6.7.10; 8 31). Hence abiding in God is a subject of in- struction and exhortation (Jn 16 4; 1 Jn 2 27f); and here the idea of persistent and stedfast pur- pose which belongs to the word menein comes clearly into view. As the abiding of God in us is the persistent and purposeful action by which the Divine nature influences ours, so our abiding in God is the persistent and purposeful submission of our- selves to that influence. The means of doing this are stedfast loyalty to the truth as it is revealed in Christ and announced in the apostolic Gospel (Jn 8 31; 15 7; 1 Jn 2 27), keeping God’s ecommand- ments (Jn 14 23; 15 10; 1 Jn 8 24), and loving one another (1 Jn 4 12.16). Thus only is the channel of communication kept clear between the source and the receptacle of life. . VI, Human Nature and Its Regeneration.—The necessity of regeneration is fundamental to the whole theological scheme (Jn 3 3.5.7). Life which consists in union with God does not belong to man as he is naturally constituted: those who know that they have eternal life know that it is theirs because they have ‘‘passed out of death into life’ (1 Jn 3 14; Jn 6 24). Johannine Theol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1704 The unregenerate state of human nature is specially connected with the Johannine conception of the “world” (késmos). This term has a peculiar elasticity of application; and Westcott’s definition—‘‘the order of finite being, regarded as apart from God’’—may be taken as expressing the widest idea that underlies St. John’s use of the word. When the kosmos is material, it signifies (1) the existing terrestrial creation (Jn 1 10; 18 1; 16 28), esp. as contrasted with the sphereof the heavenly and eter- nal. When it refers to humanity, it is either (2) the totality of mankind as needing redemption and as the object of God’s redeeming love (Jn 3 16; 1 Jn 22; 4 14), or (8) the mass of unbelieving men, hostile to Christ and resisting salvation (e.g. Jn 15 18). Of the world in this sense it is said that it has no perception of the true nature of God and the Divine glory of Christ (Jn 1 10; 17 25; 1 Jn 3 1); that it hates the children of God (Jn 16 18.19; 17 14;1 Jn 3 13); that the spirit of Antichrist dwells init (1 Jn 4 3.4); that toit belong the false proph- etsand their adherents (1 Jn 4 1.5); that it is under the dominion of the wicked one (Jn 12 31; 14 30; 1611; 1 Jn 5 19); thatthe constituents of its life are “‘the lust of the flesh and the lust of the eyes and the vainglory of life’ (1 Jn 2 16); that it pass- eth away (1 Jn 2 17); that Christ has conquered it (Jn 16 33), and that “‘whatsoever is begotten of God” conquers it (1 Jn & 4) by the power of faith in Him (i Jn 6 5). Thus the ‘world’ (in this darker significance) is composed of those who still love the darkness rather than the light (Jn 3 19), who, when Christ is presented to them, obstinately retain their blindness and enmity. Nevertheless, the “world” is not beyond the possibility of salva- tion. The Holy Spirit, acting in the Christian community, will convince the world with regard to sin and righteousness and judgment (Jn 16 8); and the evidence of the unity of Divine fellowship among Christ’s disciples will lead it to believe in His Divine mission (Jn 17 23). Thus it is true that St. John teaches “a distinc- tion of two great classes in the human race—those who are from above and those who are 1. The World 2. Two from beneath—children of light and Classes in children of darkness.” But that he the Human teaches this in any gnostic or semi- Race gnostic fashion is an assertion for which there is no real basis. He dis- tinguishes between those who love the light and those who love the darkness rather than the light, between those who “receive’’ Christ and those who ‘“will not” come unto Him that they may have life. This distinction, however, he traces to nothing in the natural constitution of the two classes, but solely to the regenerating act of God (Jn 1 13; 6 44), His doctrine of regeneration is, in fact, his solution of the problem created by the actual existence of those two classes among men—a problem which is forced upon every thoughtful Christian mind by the diverse and opposite results of evangelism. It is this that lies behind such utterances as these: ‘Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice” (Jn 18 37); ‘‘Ye believe not, because ye arenotof my sheep. My sheep hear my voice .... and they follow me” (Jn 10 26.27); “Every one that hath heard from the Father, cometh unto me. Noman can come unto me except it be given unto him of the Father” (Jn 6 45.65). In these and all similar passages, belief or unbelief in Christ, when He is presented, depends upon ante- cedent spiritual predisposition (St. John’s equiva~ lent to the Pauline predestination). There exists in certain persons what is lacking in others, a power of spiritual vision by which Christ is recognized, a capacity and a predisposition to receive Him. But this predisposition is not (any more than St. Paul’s predestination) theirs by gift of nature. St. John refuses to find its source in human personality (Jn 113; 1 Jn 61). The children of God are not a superior species of the genus home. They are men who have passed from death into life, and who have done so because they are begotten of God. St. John’s doctrine is thus the antithesis of Gnosticism. The gnostic distinction of two classes in the human race glorified men; its.proper and inevitable fruit was spiritual pride. The effect of St. John’s doc- trine is to humble man and glorify God, to satisfy the innermost Christian consciousness that not even for their appropriation of God’s gift in Christ can believers take credit to themselves; that in nothing can the human spirit do more than respond to the Divine, and that, in the last analysis, this power itself is of God. Regeneration in the Johan- nine sense is not to be identified with conversion. It is the communication of that vision of truth and that capacity for new moral activity which issue in conversion. The doctrine of regeneration con- tained in the Johannine writings is the fullest recog- nition in the NT that all the conscious experiences and activities of the Christian life are the result of God’s own inscrutable work of begetting in the depths of human personality, and of renewing and replenishing there, the energies of the Divine. VI. The Church and Sacraments.—While the word “‘church" is not found, the idea les near the base of the Johannine theology. The Divine life 1. The communicated to men creates a Divine Church brotherhood, a ‘‘fellowship’’ which is Ure. with the Father and “with his Son Jesus Christ’’ (1 Jn 1 3) and also “one with another’’ (1 Jn 1 7)—a fellowship which is consecrated by the self-consecration of Jesus (Jn 17 19), in whlch men are cleansed from all sin by His blood (1 Jn 1 7), and which is maintained hy His intercessory action as the Paraclete with the Father (1 Jn 2 1). This fellow- ship is realized in the actual Christian community and there only; but it is essentially inward and spiritual, not mechanically ecclesiastical, In the visible community spurious elements may intrude themselves, as is proved when schism unmasks those who, though they have be- longed to the external organization, have never heen partakers of its real life (1 J 2 19). Only among those who walk in the light of God does true fellowship exist (i Jn 1 7). From the doctrine of the Divine nature as llfe and light one might a priori infer the possibilities of a Jo- hannine view of the sacraments. It is 2. The evident that there is room in the Johan- Sacra- nine system of thought for a genuinely sacramental mode of Divine action—the ments employment of definite external acts, not ’ as symbols only, but as real media of Divine communication. On the other hand, the truth that God is not life only but light also—self-revealing as well as self-imparting—would_ necessarily exclude any magical ex opere operato theory hy which spiritual efficacy is attributed eitherto the paysicel elements in themselves or to the physical act of participation. And (though there is little or no explicit statement) such is the type of doctrine we actually find. With regard to all sacra- mental rites the universal principle applies: ‘It is the ae that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing’ (Jn (1) Baptism.—Yet baptlsm is the physical counter- part of the Spirit's work in regeneration, and great Im- portance is attached to it as the means of admission to the new lifeof the kingdom (Jn 3 5). (2) The Lord's Supper.—The omisslon of all reference to the Institution of the Lord's Supper (the incldent of the feet-washing and the proclamation of the new com- mandment taking its place in the Gospel-narrative) is thought to indicate that St. John was conscious of a tendency to attach a superstitious value to the outward observance, and desired emphatically to subordinate this to what was spiritual and essential. ‘The omisslon, to whatever motive it may have been due, is counter- balanced by the sacramental discourse (Jn 6). While the language of this discourse is not to be interpreted in a technically eucharistic sense, its purpose, or one of its purposes, undoubtedly, is to set forth the signifi- cance of the Lord's Supper in the largest light. Christ glves to men the bread of life, which is His own flesh and of, which men must eat that they may live (Jn 6 50- 55). He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood abideth in me and Tin him.” This eating and drinkIng is essentially of the Spirit. It signifies a derivation of life analogous to that of the Son Himself from the Father, 1705 “‘As the living Father sent me, and J live because of the Father; so he that eateth me, he also shall live be- cause of me” (ver 57). To ‘‘eat the flesh” of the Son of Man is to rece!ve spirltual nourishment from Him, to live by Hls life. Yet there is nothing In St. John's way of thinking to exclude a real sacramental efficiency. “The act which is nothing when it is performed igno- rantly and mechanically is of sovereign value to thosa who have apprehended its true meaning. The material elements represent the flesh and blood of Christ—His Divine Person given for the life of the world. He is present in them, not merely by way of symbol, but actually; but there must be something iu the recipient corresponding to the spiritual reality which is conveyed through the gift. The outward act of participation must be accompanied with belief in Christ and a true insight into the nature of His work and a will to know and serve Him. The sacrament becomes operative as the bread of life through this receptive spirit on the part of those who observe it"’ (Scott, The Fourth Gospel, 127-28), _ IX. Eschatology.—The type of mind revealed in the Johannine writings is one that instinctively leans to the ideal and the spiritual in 1. Type of its contemplation of life, graspin Thought what is of universal significance an Idealistic dwelling upon events only as they are the embodiment of eternal principles. Where this fashion of thought is so strongly devel- oped, the eschatological, like the historical, becomes secondary. In St. John there is but one life—the eternal; and there is but one world—the world of the ideal, which is also the only real. Yet he 2. Yet is not an idealist, pure and simple. History Not For him events are not merely sym- Ignored . bols; history is not allegory. The incarnation is a historical fact, the Parousia a future event. His thought does not move in a world of mere abstractions, a world in which nothing ever happens. His true distinction as a thinker lies in the success with which he unites the two strains of thought, the historical and the ideal. The word which may be said to express his conception of history is ‘manifestation’ (cf Jn 211; 98; but esp. 1 Jn 12; 2 19.28; 3 2.5.8; 49). The incarnation is only the mani- festation of ‘what was from the beginning’ (1 Jn 1 1.2); the mission of Christ, the manifestation of the love eternally latent in the depths of the Divine nature (1 Jn 4 9). The successive events of his- tory are the emergence into visibility of what already exists. In them the potential becomes actual. Thus St. John has an eschatology, as well as a history. He profoundly spiritualizes. He reaches down through the pictorial represen- 3. Nor Es- tations of the traditional apocalyptic, chatology and inquires what essential principle - each of these embodies. Then he discovers that this principle is already universally and inevitably in operation; and this, the present spiritual reality, becomes for him the primary thought. Judgment means essentially the sifting and separation, the classification of men according to their spiritual affinities. But every day men are thus classifying themselves by their attitude toward Christ; this, the true judgment of the world, is already present fact. So also the coming and presence of Christ must always be essentially a spiritual fact, and as such it is already a present fact. There is, in the deepest significance of the word, a perpetual coming of Christ in Christian experience. This, however, does not prevent St. John from firmly holding the certainty of a fuller manifestation of these facts in the future, when tendencies shall have reached a final culmination, and principles which are now apprehended only by faith will be revealed in all the visible magnitude of their consequences. We shall now briefly survey the Johannine pres- entation of the chief eschatological ideas. (1) Eternal life—It has already been said that THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Johannine Theol. the most distinctive feature in the conception of eternal life is that it is not a future immortal felicity so much as a present spiritual 4. Escha- state. The category of duration re- tological cedes before that of moral quality. Ideas Yet it has its own stupendous impor- tance. In triumphant contrast with the poor ephemeralities of the worldly life, he that doeth the will of God ‘‘abideth for ever” (1 Jn 2 17); and the complete realization of the life eternal is still in the future (Jn 4 36; 6 27; 12 25). (2) Antichrist—The view of Antichrist is strik- ingly characteristic. Tacitly setting aside the lurid figure of popular traditions, St. John grasps the essential fact that is expressed by the name and idea of Antichrist (=one who in the guise of Christ opposes Christ), and finds its fulfilment in the false teaching which substituted for the Christ of the ospel the fantastic product of gnostic imagination “i Jn 4 3). But in this he reads the sign that the world’s day has reached its last hour (1 Jn 2 18). (8) Resurrection.—While the Fourth Gospel so carefully records the proofs of Christ’s resurrection, noticeably little (in the Ep., nothing) is made of the thought of a future resurrection from the dead. For the Christian, the death of the body is a mere incident. ‘Whosoever liveth and believeth on me shall never die” (Jn 11 26; cf 8 51). Regenera- tion—union with Christ—is the true resurrection (Jn 6 50.51.58). And yet, again, the eschatolog- ical idea is not lost. Side by side with the easen- tial truth the supplementary and interpretative truth is given its right place. ‘‘Whoso eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood hath eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day” (Jn 6 54 AV). If Christ says “I am the life: whosoever liveth and believeth on me shall never die,” He also says ‘I am the resurrection: he that believeth on me, though he die, yet shall he live” (Jn 11 25). (4) Judgment.—As has already been said, St. John regards judgment as essentially a present fact of life. Christ does not pass judgment upon men— that is not the purpose of His coming (Jn 3 17; 12 47). Yet Christ is always of necessity judging men—compelling them to pass judgment upon themselves. For judgment He is come into the world (Ju 9 89). By their attitude toward Him men involuntarily but inevitably classify them- selves, reveal what spirit they are of, and auto- matically register themselves as being or as not being ‘‘of the truth” (Jn 18 37). Judgment is not the assigning of a character from without, but the revelation of a character from within. And this is not future, but present. ‘He that believeth not hath been judged... . because he hath not believed on the name of the only begotten Son of of God” (Jn 3 18). Yet the apostle indubitably looks forward to a future Day of Judgment (Jn 12 48; 1 Jn 417). Nor is this simply an “ conscious concession to orthodoxy.’ The judg- ment to come will be the full manifestation of the judgment that now is, that is to say, of the principles according to which men are in reality ap- proved or condemned already. What this present judgment, the classification of men by their rela- tion to Christ, ultimately signifies, is not at all realized by the “world,” is not fully realized even in Christian faith. There must be a day when all self-deception shall cease and all reality shall be manifested. (5) The Parousia.—In like manner the concep- tion of the Parousia is primarily spiritual. The substitution in the Fourth Gospel of the Supper Discourse (Jn 14-16) for the apocalyptic chapters in the Synopties is of the utmost significance. It is not a Christ coming ou the clouds of heaven that is presented, but a Christ who has come and is eee apesug THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1706 ever coming to dwell in closest fellowship with His people (see above under IV). Yet St. John by no means discards belief in the Parousia as a historical event of the future. Jf Christ’s abiding-place is in those that love Him and keep His word, there is also a Father’s House in which there are many abiding-places, whither He goes to prepare a place for them and whence He will come again to receive them unto Himself (Jn 14 2.3). Still more is this emphasized in the Ep. The command “Love not the world” is sharpened by the assurance that the world is on the verge, aye, in the process of dissolu- tion (1 Jn 217). The exhortation to “abide in him” is enforced by the dread of being put to shame at His impending advent (2 28). The hope of being made partakers in His manifested glory is the consummation of all that is implied in our being now children of God (1 Jn 8 2.3). (a) A “manifestation”: But this future crisis will be only the manifestation of the existing reality (3 2). The Parousia will, no more than the incarnation, be the advent of a strange Presence in the world. It will be, as on the Mount of Transfiguration, the outshining of a latent glory; not the arrival of one who is absent, but the self-revealing of one who is present. As to the manner of Christ’s appearing, the Ep. is silent. As to its significance, we are left in no doubt. It is a historical event; occurring once for all; the consummation of all Divine pur- pose that has governed human existence; the final crisis in the history of the church, of the world, and of every man. (b) Relation to believers: Especially for the chil- dren of God, it will be a coming unto salvation. “Beloved, now are we children of God, and it is not yet made manifest what we shallbe. Weknowthat, if he shall be manifested, we shall be like him; for we shall see him as he is” (1 Jn 3 2). Here the Johannine idea of “manifestation” is strikingly employed. ‘What we shall be” will be essentially what we are—children of God. No new element will be added to the regenerate nature. Allis there that ever will be there. But the epoch of full development is not yet. Only when Christ—the Christ who is already in the world—shall be mani- fested, then also the children of God who are in the world will be manifested as being what they are. They also will have come to their Mount of Trans- figuration. As eternal life here is mediated through this first manifestation (1 Jn 1 2), so eternal life hereafter will be mediated through this second and final manifestation. ‘We know that we shall be like him, because we shall see him as he is.’”’ It is true that here according to our capacity we behold Him as He is (Jn 1 14); but perception, now dim and wavering, will then be intense and vivid. The vision of the future is In some sense corporeal as well as spiritual. Sense and faith will coincide. It will then have ceased to be expedient that Christ should go away in order that the Spirit of truth may come. We shall possess in the same experience the privi- lege of the original eyewitnesses of the incarnate life and the inward ministry of the Spirit. And seeing Him as He is, we shall belike Him. Vision will beget likeness, and likeness again give clearness to vision. And as the vision is In some unconjec- turable fashion corporeal as well as spiritual, so also is the assimilation (cf Phil 8 21). The very idea of the spiritual body is that it perfectly corresponds to the character to which it belongs. The outward man will take the mold of the inward man, and will share with it its perfected likeness to the glori- fied manhood of Jesus Christ. Such is the farthest view opened to our hope by the Johannine escha- tology; and it is that which, of all others, has been most entrancing to the imagination and stimulating to the aspiration of the children of God. _ Literature.—The. following works may be men- tioned as treating specially of the Theology: B. Weiss, Der Johannische Lehrbegrif, Berlin, 1862; O, Holtz- mann, Das Johannes-Evangelium untersucht und erkldrt, Darmstadt, 1887; Beyschlag, Neutestameniliche Theo- logie, Halle, 1896: ‘“Pfleiderer, Das Urchristentum, Berlin, 1902, ET, Williams and Norgate, London; E. Haupt, Der erste Brief des Johannes, Colberg, 1869, ET, T. & T. Clark, Edinburgh; Grill, Untersuchungen uber die_Entstehung des vierten Fvangeliums, Tiibingen, 1902; G. B. Stevens, The Johannine Theology, New York, 1894: id, The Theology of the NT, 1899, also The Christian Doctrine of Salvation, 1905, _T. & T. Clark, Edinburgh; O. Cone, The Gospel and Its Earliest Inter- pretations, New York, 1893; Scott, The Fourth Gospel, Its Purpose and Theology, T. & T. Clark, 1906; Law, The Tests of Life: A Study of the First Ep. of St. John (dealing specially with the Theology), Edinburgh and New York, 1909; Denney, Jesus and the Gospel, New oe 1909; Judge, Cambridge Bib. Essays, Macmillan, R. Law JOHN, jon (Iwdvvns, Jédnnés): The name of several persons mentioned in the Apoc: (1) Father of Mattathias, grandfather of Judas Maccabaeus and his brothers (1 Macc 2 1). (2) Eldest son of Mattathias, surnamed Gappis q.v.). (3) Father of Eupolemus, one of the envoys sent to Rome by Judas Maccabaeus (1 Mace 8 17; 2 Mace 4 11). (4) John Hyrcanus, “a valiant man,” son of Simon, and nephew of Judas Maccabaeus (1 Mace 13 53; 16 1). See Asmonrans; MaccaBEEs. (5) One of the envoys sent to treat with Lysias (2 Mace 11 17). J. Hurcuison JOHN (Iwdvvys, Jadnnés): The name of 4 per- sons: (1) Joun THE Baptist (q.v.). (2) The apostle, the son of Zebedee, and brother of James (see JoHN, THE APOSTLE). (3) A relative of Annas the high priest, who sat in the Sanhedrin when Peter and John were tried (Acts 4 6). Lightfoot supposes bim to be the Jochanan ben Zacchai of the Talm, who, however, did not belong to the family of the high priest. Nothing is really known of him. (4) Joun Mark (q.v.). (5) Father of Simon Peter (Jn 1 42; 21 15.17, m “Gr Joanes: called in Mt 16 17, Jonah’). 8S. F. Huntsr _ JOHN, THE APOSTLE: The sources for the life of the apostle John are of various kinds, and of different degrees of trustworthiness. Sources of There are the references in the Synop- the Life of tic Gospels, which may be used simply St. John and easily without any preliminary critical inquiry into their worth as sources; for these Gospels contain the common tradition of the early church, and for the present purpose may be accepted as trustworthy. Further, there are the statements in Acts and in Gal, which we may use without discussion as a source for the life of St. John. There is next the universal tradi- tion of the 2d cent., which we may use, if we can show that the John of Ephesus, who bulks so largely in the Christian literature of the 2d and 3d cents., is identical with the son of Zebedee. Further, on the supposition that the son of Zebedee is the author of the Johannine writings of the NT, there is another source of unequaled value for the estimate of the life and character of the son of Zebedee in these writings. Finally, there is the considerable volume of tradition which gathered around the name of John of Ephesus, of which, picturesque and inter- esting though the traditions be, only sparing use can be made. I. Witness of the NT.—Addressing ourselves first to the Synoptic Gospels, to Acts and to Gal, we ask, What, from these sources, can we know of the apostle Jobn? A glance only need be taken 1707 hannine Theol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA eae the Apostle at the Johannine writings, more fully discussed elsewhere in relation to their author. That John was one of the two sons of Zebedee, that he became one of the disciples of Jesus, that at His call he forsook all and followed 1, The Jesus, and was thereafter continuously Synoptic with Jesus to the end, are facts familiar Gospels to every reader of the Synoptic Gospels. The call was given to John and to his brother James at the Sea of Galilee, while in a boat with their father Zebedee, “mending their nets” (Mt 4 21.22, and || passages). “Come ye after me,” said Jesus, “and I will make you to become fishers of men” (Mk 1 17; on the earlier call in Judaea, Jn 1 35 ff, see below). That Zebedee was a man of considerable wealth may be inferred from the fact that he had “‘hired servants” with him (Mk 1 20), and that his wife was one of those women who ministered of their substance to Jesus and His disciples (Mt 27 55.56). Comparison of the latter passage with Mk 15 40.41 identifies the wife of Zebedee, John’s mother, with Salome, and it seems a fair inference from Jn 19 25, though all do not accept it, that Mary, the mother of Jesus, and Salome, the wife of Zebedee, were sisters. On this view, James and John were cousins of Jesus, and were also related to the family of John the Baptist. The name of John appears in all the lists of the apos- tles given in the Synoptic Gospels (Mt 10 2 and |/s). While his name appears rarely in a position by itself, he is still one of the most prominent of the disciples. With Peter and James he is present at the raising of the daughter of Jairus (Mk 5 37; Lk 8 51 ff). These three were also present at the transfiguration (Mt 17; Mk 9; Lk 9). They were nearest to the Lord at the agony of Gethsemane. In all these cases nothing characteristic of John is to be noted. He is smply piecnt as one of the three, and therefore one of the most intimate of the dis- ciples. But there is something characteristic in an incident recorded by Luke (9 54), in which James and John are represented as wishing to call down fire on a Sam village, which had refused them hospital- ity. From this can be inferred something of the earnestness, zeal, and enthusiasm of the brothers, and of their high sense of what was due to their Master. Peter, James, John, and Andrew are the four who asked Jesus about the prophecies He had uttered: ‘Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign when these things are all about to be accomplished?” (Mk 13 4). Then there is the request of their mother as to the place she desired for her sons in the coming kingdom (Mk 10 35 ff). To Peter and John was entrusted the task of preparation for the keeping of the Passover (Lk 22 8). Once John stands alone, and asks what we may consider a characteristic question: “Teacher, we saw one casting out demons in thy name; and we forbade him, because he followed not us” (Mk 9 38; Lk 9 49). From these notices we see that John was in the front rank of the dis- ciples, and we see also that he was so far conscious of the position he held, and of the intimate connec- tion he had with the Master. We note further that John was a young man of fiery zeal, and of a tend- ency toward intolerance and exclusiveness. The zeal and the intolerance are in evidence in the desire to call down fire upon the Sam village, and the tendency toward exclusiveness is manifested in the request of his mother as to the place her sons were to occupy in the kingdom. ‘They desire to have the highest positions. These tendencies were not encouraged by Jesus. They were rebuked by Him once and again, but the tendencies reveal the men. In harmony with these notices of character and temperament is the name given to the brothers by Jesus, ‘‘Boanerges,”’ ‘Sons of thunder” (Mk 3 17), which, whatever else may be meant by it, means strength, unexpectedness, and zeal approaching to methods of violence. John isfound in company with Peter in the opening scenes in Acts. He is with Peter while the man at the gate was healed (8 1ff). He is 2. Acts and with Peter on the mission to Samaria Gal (8 14ff). He is with Peter and James, the Lord’s brother, at the interview with St. Paul recorded in Gal 2, and the three are described by St. Paul as the pillar apostles (2 9). This interview is of importance because it proves that John had survived his brother James, whose death is recorded in Acts 12; at all events that John and James were not killed by the Jews at the same time, as some now contend that they were. This contention is considered bclow. Much is to be learned of the apostle John from the Fourth Gospel, sesuming tbe Gospel to have been written by him. We learn from 3. The it that he was a disciple of John the Johannine Baptist (1 35), that he was one of the Writings: _first six disciples called by Jesus in His Gospel early ministry in Judaea (vs 37-51), and Rev’ and that he was present at all the scenes which he descrihes in the Gospel. We find later that he had a home in Jerus, and was acquainted with many there. To that home he took Mary, the mother of Jesus, whom the dying Saviour entrusted to his care (19 26.27). Much more also we learn of him and of his history, for the Gospel is a spiritual biography, a record of the growth of faith on the part of the writer, and of the way in which his eyes were opened to see the glory of the Lord, until faith seems to have become vision. He was in the inner circle of the disciples, indeed, nearest of all to Jesus, “the disciple whom Jesus loved” (13 23; 19 26; 20 2; 21 7.20), and, be- cause of that love, became the apostle of love (see, further, Joon, GosPEL oF; JoHN, EPIsTLEs oF; JOHANNINE THEOLOGY). The Book of Rev, likewise traditionally ascribed to John, bears important witness to the apostle’s banishment in later life to the isle of Patmos in the Aegean (1 9). There he received the visions re- corded in the book. The banishment probably took place in the reign of Domitian (see Paveie: TION), with whose practice it was entirely in con- sonance (on the severity of such exile, cf Sir W. M. Ramsay, Letters to the Seven Churches of Asia, ch viii). The testimony is of high importance in its bearing on the disputed question of John’s residence in Asia, a point now to be discussed. Hil. Alleged Early Martyrdom of John: Criticism of Evidence.—The consentient testimony of the church of the 2d cent. is that the later 1. Recent years of St. John were spent at Ephe- Denial of | sus, where he wrote his Gospel, and St. John’s gathered round him many disciples Residence (see the evidence drawn out in detail in Ephesus in Godet, Comm. on Gospel of St. John, 43 ff; ef also Lightfoot, ‘The School of Ephesus,” in Essays on the Work Entitled ‘‘Super- natural Religion’). Before, however, we can use the traditions connected with this residence at Ephesus, it is needful to inquire into the statement alleged to be made by Papias that John, the son of Zebedee, was killed by the Jews at an early date. It is plain, that, if this statement is correct, the apostle could not be the author of the Johannine writings in the NT, universally dated near the end of the 1st cent. The evidence for the statement that St. John was early killed by the Jews is thus summed up by Dr. Moffatt: ‘The evidence for the early martyrdom of John the son of Zebedee is, in fact, threefold: (a) a prophecy of Jesus pre- John, the Apostle John the Baptist THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1708 served in Mk 10 39=Mt 20 23, (b) the witness of Papias, and (c) the calendars of the church” (Intro to Lit. of NT, 602). Our lim- 2. Grounds its do not admit of an exhaustive of Denial examination of this so-called evi- dence, ,but, happily, an exhaustive examination is not needed. (a) The first head proceeds on an assumption which is not warranted, viz. that a prophecy of Jesus would not be allowed to stand, if it were not evidently fulfilled. In the present instance, a literal fulfilment of the prophecy (The cup that I drink ye shal! drink,"' etc) is out of the question, for there is no hint that either James or John was crucified. We must therefore fall back on the primary meaning of martyrdom, and recognize a ful- filment of the prophecy in the sufferings John endured and the testimony he bore for the Master's sake (thus Origen, etc). (b) Dr. Moffatt lays great stress on what he calls the testimony of Papias. But the alleged testimony of Papias is not found in any early authority, and then occurs in writers not of any great value from the point of view of critical investigation. Itis found in a passage of Georgius Hamartolus (9th cent.), and is held to be corroborated by a fragment of an epitome (7th or 8th cent.) of the Chronicle of Philip Sidetes (5th cent.), a thoroughly untrustworthy writer. The passage from Georgius may be seen in convenieut form in Lightfoot's Apostolic Fathers, 513-19. It tells that John survived to the time of Nerva, quotes 2 saying of Papias that he was killed by the Jews, states that this was in fulfilment of the prophecy of Jesus above referred to, and goes on to say, ‘‘So the learned Origen affirms in his interpreta~ tion of St. Matthew's Gospel, that John was martyred, declaring that he had learnt the last from the successors of the apostles” (Lightfoot, op. cit., 531). Fortunately, the statement of Origen can be tested, and it by no means, as Moffatt admits (op. cit., 604), bears out the meaning attached to it. Origeu is of opinion that the prophecy of Jesus was sufficiently fulfilled by the fact of John's banishment to Patmos and his sufferings there. This, according to him, is what tradition taught and what the prophecy meant. From the whole statement of Georgius, which expressly declares that John survived till the time of Nerva, nothing can be inferred in support of the so-called quotation from Papias. It is to be remembered that the writings of Papias were known to Trenaeus and to Eusebius, and it is inconceivahle that, if such_a statement was to be found in these, they would have ignored it, and have given currency to a statement contradictory toit. No stress, therefore, can be laid on the alleged quotation. We do not know its context, nor is there anything in the lit. of the first 3 centuries confirmatory of it. Iu the citation iu the epitome of Philip, Papias is made to speak of ‘‘John the divine”’ (ho theolégos). This title is not applied to John till the close of the 4th cent. (c) As regards the 3d line of evidence instanced by Dr. Moffatt—church calendars, in which James and John are commemorated together as martyrs—it is even more worthless than the other two. _On the nature and origin of these martyrologies, Dr. J. Drummond may be quoted: ‘‘'They were constructed in_ process of time out of local calendars. At some period in the 2d half of the 5th cent., a martyrology was formed by welding together a number of provincial calendars, Rom, Italian, Spanish, and Gallic, Into what was in effect a general martyrology of Western Europe. At Nicomedia, about the year 360, a similar eastern martyrology was formed out of the local calendars, and this was tr¢ with curtail- ments into Syr at Edessa about the year 400. It is a copy of this, made in 411, which is now in the British Museum” (Inguiry into Character and Authorship of the Fourth Gospel, 232). If this is a true account of the rise and origin of martyrologies we need not be surprised that Sir W. M. Ramsay speaks as follows: ‘‘That James and John, who were not slain at the same time, should be commemorated together, is the flimsiest_conceivable evidence that John was killed early in Jerns. The bracketing together of the memory of apostles who had some historical connection in life, but none in death, must be regarded as the worst side, historically speaking, of oe martyrologies"' (The First Christian Century, 49, note). Ill, The Ephesian Traditions.—Thus the early tra- ditions of the churches are available for the life of John the son or Zebedee: But ea Female many blank spaces in at life. ter 1, John the tie reterence to the pillar apostles in Gal, Apostle, and silence falls on the life of John, and we John the know nothing of his life and activity until Presbyter We read of his banishment to Patmos, and Y mect with those references to the old man at Ephesus, which occur In the Christian lit. of the 2d cent. One point of interest relates to the (genuine) qnotation from Papias, preserved by Eus. (HE, III, 39), regarding a “ Presbyter John,” @ disciple of the Lord, who was one of his living authoritles. Were there two Johns at Ephesus? Or was there only one? Or, if there was only one, was he John the Evangelist, or only John the Presbyter? Here there is every pos- sible variety of opinion. Many hold that there were two, and many that there was only one. Many who hold that there was only one, hold that the one was John the son of Zebedee; others hold, with equal assur- ance, that he was a distinct person. Obviously, it jis impossible to discuss the question adequately here. After dune consideration, we lean to the conclusion that there was only one John at Ephesus, and he the son of Zehedee. For the proof of this, impossible within our limits, we refer to the learned argument of John Chap- man, O.S.B., in his work John the Presbyter and the Fourth Gospel (1911). Into the traditions which cluster round John in Ephe- sus it is not necessary to enter in detail (cf Godet, op. cit., 57 ff). meroralng ues dare uur: q . versally accepted in the churc °. - pai vived till the time of Trajan’ (98 AD). 18 uC Striking and characteristic things are Traditions told of him in harmony with the touches we find in the Synoptic Gospels, The story of his rushing forth from the bath when Cerinthus, the heretic, entered it (Iren., Adv. Haer., iii.3, 4) recalls the characteristics of him whom Jesus called ‘‘son of thunder.” The same tone of exclusiveness, modified by larger experience, is found in the 1st Ep., which so fre- quently and so decisively discriminates between those who believe in Jesus and those who do not. IV. The Character of St. John. —The general character of this great apostle is already sufficiently apparent. While we recall the illustrative facts found in the Synoptics, that James and John were the two who wished to call down fire from heaven on the inhospitable village, that John was one of those who desired one of the chief places in the kingdom, that he it was who forbade the man to cast out demons in the name of Jesus because he followed not with them, we do not forget that on each of these occasions he was corrected and rebuked by the Master, and he was not the kind of man who could not profit by the rebuke of Jesus. So that vehemence of disposition was held in check, and, while still in existence, was under control, and allowed to have vent only on occasions when it was permissible, and even necessary. So in his writings, and in the reflections in the Gospel, we note the vehemence displayed, but now directed only against those who refused to believe in, and to acknowledge, Jesus. “A quiet and thoughtful temperament is by no means inconsistent with a certain vehemence, when, on occa- sions, the pent-up fire flashes forth; indeed, the very violence of feeling may help to foster an habitual quie- tude, lest word or deed should betray too deep an emo- tion. Then it is not without significance that, in the three narratives which are cited from the Gospels to prove the overbearing temper of John, we are expressly told that Jesus corrected him. Are we to suppose that these rebukes made no impression? Is it not more likely that they sank deep into his heart, and that the agony of beholding his Master's orucifixion made them ineffaceahle? Then, if not before, began that long development which changed the youthful son of thunder into the aged apostle of love’ (Drummond, op. cit., 410, 411). _ But love itself has its side of vehemence, and the intensity of love toward a person or a cause may be measured by the intensity of aversion and of hatred toward their contradictories. There are many re- flections in the Gospel and in the Epp. which dis- play this energy of hatred toward the work of the devil, and toward those dispositions which are under the influence of the father of lies. We simply notice these, for they poe that the fervent youth who was devoted to his Master carried with him to the end the same disposition which was charac- teristic of him from the beginning. Lrrerature.—In addition to books mentioned in art., see the listof worksappended to art.on Joan, GOSPEL OF, JAMES IvERACH JOHN THE BAPTIST (‘Iwdvys, Jadnés): I. Sources II. Parenrags TII, Eanuy Lira IV, Ministry 1. The Scene 2. His First Appearance 1709 3. His Dress and Manner 4. His Message 5. His Severity Baptism 1. Significance (1) Lustrations Required by the Levitical Law (2) Anticipation of Messianic Lustrations Foretoid by the Prophets (3) Proselyte Baptism a 2. Baptism of Jcsus VI. Imprisonment anno DeEatu 1. The Time 2. The Occasion VII. Jown anv His Discrpies 1, The Inner Circie 2. Their Training 3. Their Fideiity VIII, Joann anv Jesus 1. John's Reiation to Jesus 2. Jesus’ Estimate of John Lireratura I, Sources.—The sources of first-hand information concerning the life and work of John the Baptist are limited to the NT and Jos. Lk and Mt give the fuller notices, and these are in substantial agreement. The Fourth Gospel deals chiefly with the witness after the baptism. In his single notice (Ant, XVIII, v, 2), Jos makes an interesting ref- erence to the cause of John’s imprisonment. See VI, 2, below. II, Parentage.—John was of priestly descent. His mother, Elisabeth, was of the daughters of Aaron, while his father, Zacharias, was a priest of the course of Abija, and did service in the temple at Jerus. It is said of them that ‘they were both righteous before God, walking in all the command- ments and ordinances of the Lord blameless’ (Lk 16). This priestly ancestry is in interesting con- trast with his prophetic mission. Il. Early Life.—We infer from Luke’s account that John was born about six months before the birth of Jesus. Of the place we know only that it was a city of the hill country of Judah. Our defi- nite information concerning his youth is summed up in the angelic prophecy, “Many shall rejoice athisbirth. For he shall be great in the sight of the Lord, and he shall drink no wine nor strong drink; and he shall be filled with the Holy Spirit, even from his mother’s womb” (Lk 1 14-16), and in Luke’s brief statement, ‘And the child grew, and waxed strong in spirit, and was in the deserts till the day of his showing unto Israel” (1 80). The character and spiritual insight of the parents shown in the incidents recorded are ample evidence that his train- ing was a fitting preparation for his great mission. IV. Ministry.—The scene of the Baptist’s min- istry was partly in the wilderness of Southern Judaea and partly in the Jordan valley. Two 1. The locations are mentioned, Bethany or Scene Bethabara (Jn 1 28), and Aenon near Salim (Jn 3 23). Neither of these places can be positively identified. We may infer from Jn 3 2 that he also spent some time in Peraea beyond the Jordan. : i The unusual array of dates with which Luke marks the beginning of John’s ministry (Lk 3 1.2) reveals ig sense of the importance of the event 2. His First as at once the beginning of his pro- Appearance phetic work and of the new dispen- sation. His first public appearance is assigned to the 15th year of Tiberius, probably 26 or 27 AD, for the first Passover attended by Jesus can hardly have been later than 27 AD (Jn 2 20). : John’s dress and habits were strikingly suggestive of Elijah, the old prophet of national judgment. His desert habits have led some to 3. His Dress connect him with that strange com- and Manner pany of Jews known as the Essenes. ; There is, however, little foundation for such a connection other than his ascetic habits and the fact that the chief settlement of this sect ; hn, the Apostle THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA jenn lea Baptist was near the home of his youth. It was natural that he should continue the manner of his youthful life in the desert, and it is not improbable that he intentionally copied his great prophetic model. It was fitting that the one who called men to repentance and the beginning of a self-denying life should show renunciation and self-denial in his own life. But there is no evidence in his teaching that he required such asceticism of those who accepted his baptism. The fundamental note in the message of John was the announcement of the near approach of the Messianic age. But while he an- 4. His nounced himself as the herald voice Message preparing the way of the Lord, and because of this the expectant multi- tudes crowded to hear his word, his view of the na- ture of the kingdom was probably quite at variance with that of his hearers. Instead of the expected day of deliverance from the foreign oppressor, it was to be a day of judgment for Israel. It meant good for the penitent, but destruction for the ungodly. “He will gather his wheat into the garner, but the chaff he will burn up with ... . fire” (Mt 3 12). “The axe also lieth at the root of the trees: every tree therefore that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire’ (Lk 3 9). Yet this idea was perhaps not entirely unfamiliar. That the delay in the Messiah’s coming was due to the sinfulness of the people and their lack of repentance, was a commonplace in the message of their teachers eaters Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah, I, 9), The call to repentance was then a natural message of preparation for such a time of judgment. But to John repentance was a very real and radical thing. It meant a complete change of heart and life. “Bring forth... . fruits worthy of repent- ance” (Lk 8 8). What these fruits were he made clear in his answers to the inquiring multitudes and the publicans and soldiers (3 10-14). Itis notice- able that there is no reference to the usual cere- monies of the law or to achange of occupation. Do good; be honest; refrain from extortion; be con- tent with wages. John used such violence in addressing the Phari- sees and Sadducees doubtless to startle them from their self-complacency. How hope- 5. His lessly they were blinded by their sense Severity of security as the children of Abraham, and by their confidence in the merits of the law, is attested by the fact that these par- ties resisted the teachings of both John and Jesus to the very end. With what vigor and fearlessness the Baptist ressed his demand for righteousness is shown by is stern reproof of the sin of Herod and Herodias, pee led to his imprisonment and finally to his death. V. Baptism.—The symbolic rite of baptism was such an essential part of the work of John that it not only gave him his distinctive title 1. Signifi- of “the Baptist” (6 Bamrrtirys, ho cance baptistés), but also caused his message to be styled “preaching the baptism of repentance.” That a special virtue was ascribed to this rite, and that it was regarded as a neces- sary part of the preparation for the coming of the Messiah, are shown by its important place in John’s preaching, and by the eagerness with which it was sought by the multitudes. Its significance may best be understood by giving attention to its historical antecedents, for while John gave the rite new sig- nificance, it certainly appealed to ideas already familiar to the Jews. (1) Lustrations required by the Levitical law.— The divers washings required by the law (Lev 11- 15) have, without doubt, areligiousimport, Thisis John the Baptist John, Egistlec ot THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1710 shown by the requirement of sacrifices in connec- tion with the cleansing, esp. the sin offering (Lev 14 8.9.19.20; ef Mk 1 44; Lk 2 22). The desig- nation of John’s baptism by the word famritey, baptizein, which by NT times was used of cere- monial purification, also indicates some historical connection (cf Sir 34 25). (2) Anticipation of Messianic lustrations foretold by prophets —John understood that his baptism was a preparation for the Messianic baptism antici- pated by the prophets, who saw that for a true cleansing the nation mnst wait until God should open in Israel a fountain for cleansing (Zec 13 1), and should sprinkle His people with clean water and give them a new heart and a new spirit (Ezk 36 25.26; Jer 33 8). His baptism was at once a preparation and a promise of the spiritual cleans- ing which the Messiah would bestow. “I indeed baptize you with water unto repentance: but he that cometh after me ... . shall baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire’ (Mt 3 11m). (3) Proselyte baptism.—According to the teaching of later Judaism, a stranger who desired to be adopted into the family of Israel was required, along with circumcision, to receive the rite of baptism as a means of cleansing from the ceremonial unclean- ness attributed to him as a Gentile. While it is not possible to prove the priority of this practice of proselyte baptism to the baptism of John, there can be no doubt of the fact, for it is inconceivable, in view of Jewish prejudice, that it would be bor- rowed from John or after this time. While it seems clear that in the use of the rite of baptism John was influenced by the Jewish customs of ceremonial washings and proselyte baptism, his baptism differed very essentially from these. The Levitical washings restored an unclean person to his former condition, but baptism was a preparation for a new condition. On the other hand, proselyte baptism was administered only to Gentiles, while John required baptism of all Jews. At the same time his baptism was very different from Christian baptism, as he himself declared (Lk 3 16). His was a baptism of water only; a preparation for the bap- tism ‘in the Spirit” which was to follow. It is also to be observed that it was a rite complete in itself, and that it was offered to the nation as a preparation for a specific event, the advent of the Messiah. We may say, then, that as a “baptism of repent- ance” it meant a renunciation of the past life; as a cleansing it symbolized the forgiveness of sins (Mk 1 4), and as preparation it implied a promise of loyalty to the kingdom of the Messiah. We have no reason to believe that Jesus experienced any sense of sin or felt any need of repentance or forgiveness; but as a Divinely appointed preparation for the Messianic kingdom His submission to it was appropriate. While the multitudes flocked to the Jordan, Jesus came also to be baptized with the rest. ‘John would have hindered him, saying, I 2. Baptism have need to be baptized of thee, and of Jesus comest thou to me? But Jesus answering said unto him, Suffer it now: for thus it becometh us to fulfil all righteousness” (Mt 3 13-15). Wherein was this act a fulfilment of righteousness? We cannot believe that Jesus felt any need of repentance or change of life. May we not regard it rather as an identification of Himself with His people in the formal consecration of His life to the work of the kingdom? VI. Imprisonment and Death.—Neither the exact time of John’s imprisonment nor the period of time between his imprisonment and _ his 1. The death can be determined. On the Time occasion of the unnamed feast of Jn 6 1, Jesus refers to John’s witness as already past. At least, then, his arrest, if not his death, must have taken place prior to that inci- dent, i.e. before the second Passover of Jesus’ min- istry. ‘ According to the Gospel accounts, John was im~- prisoned because of his reproof of Herod’s marriage with Herodias, the wife of his brother 2. The Philip (Lk 3 19.20; ef Mt 14 3.4; Occasion Mk 6 17.18). Jos says (Ant, XVIII, vy, 2) that Herod was influenced to put John to death by the “fear lest his great influence over the people might put it in his power or inclina- tion to raise a rebellion. Accordingly, he was sent a prisoner, out of Herod’s suspicious temper, to Machaerus, and was there put to death.” This account of Jos does not necessarily conflict with the tragic story of the Gospels. If Herod desired to punish or destroy him for the reasons assigned by the evangelists, he would doubtless wish to offer as the public reason some political charge, and the one named by Jos would be near at hand. VII. John and His Disciples.—Frequent refer- ence is made in the Gospel narrative to the disciples of John. As the multitudes crowded 1. The to his baptism, it was natural that he Inner should gather about him an inner circle Circle of men who should receive special instruction in the meaning of his work, and should aid him in the work of baptism, which must have soon increased beyond his power to per- form alone. It was in the formation of this inner circle of immediate followers that he prepared a sure foundation for the work of the Messiah; for it was from this inner group that the disciples of Jesus were mainly drawn, and that with his consent and through his witness to the superior worth of the latter, and the temporary character of his own mission (Jn 1 29-44). ; ro Concerning the substance of their training, we know from the disciples of Jesus (Lk 11 1) that it included forms of prayer, and from his own disciples (Mt 9 14) we learn that frequent fastings were observed. We may be sure also that he taught them much concerning the Messiah and His work. There is abundant evidence of the great fidelity of these disciples to their master. This may be observed in their concern at the over- 3. Their shadowing popularity of Jesus (Jn 3 Fidelity 26); in their loyalty to him in his im- prisonment and in their reverent treat- ment of his body after his death (Mk 6 29). That John’s work was extensive and his influence lastin is shown by the fact that 20 years afterward Pau found in far-off Ephesus certain disciples, including Apollos, the learned Alexandrian Jew, who knew no other baptism than that of John (Acts 19 1-7). VHI. John and Jesus.—John assumed from the first the réle of a herald preparing the way for the ‘approaching Messianic age. He clear- 2. Their Training 1. John’s ly regarded his work as Divinely ap- Relation pointed (Jn 1 33), but was well aware to Jesus of his subordinate relation to the Mes- siah (Mk 1 7) and of the temporary character of his mission (Jn 3 30). The Baptist’s work was twofold. In his preaching he warned the nation of the true character of the new kingdom as a reign of righteousness, and by his call to repent- ance and baptism he prepared at least a few hearts for a sympathetic response to the call and teaching of Jesus. He also formally announced and bore frequent personal testimony to Jesus as the Messiah. There is no necessary discrepancy between the synoptic account and that of the Fourth Gospel in reference to the progress of John’s knowledge of the Messianic character of Jesus. According to Mt 3 14, John is represented as declining at first to baptize Jesus because he was conscious of His 1711 superiority, while in Jn 1 29-34 he is represented as claiming not to have known Jesus until He was manifested by the heavenly sign. The latter may mean only that, He was not known to him definitely as the Messiah until the promised sign was given. The message which John sent to Jesus from prison seems strange to some in view of the signal testi- monies which he had previously borne to His charac- ter. This need not indicate that he had lost faith in the Messiahship of Jesus, but rather a perplexity at the course of events. The inquiry may have been in the interest, of the faith of his disciples or his own re- lief from misgivings due to Jesus’ delay in assuming the expected Messianic authority. John evidently held the prophetic view of a temporal Messianic king- dom, and some readjustment of view was necessary. Jesus was no less frank in His appreciation of John. If praise may be measured by the worth of the one by whose lips it is spoken, 2..Jesus’ then no man ever received such praise Estimate as he who was called by Jesus a shining of John light (Jn 5 35), more than a prophet Mt 11 9), and of whom He said, “Among them that are born of women there hath not arisen a greater than John the Baptist” (Mt 11 11). If, on the other hand, He rated him as less than the least m the kingdom of heaven, this was a limitation of circumstances, not of worth. Jesus paid high tribute to the Divine character and worth of John’s baptism; first, by submitting to it Himself as a step in the fulfilment of all right- eousness; later, by repeated utterance, esp. in asso- ciating it with the birth of the Spirit as a necessary condition of inheriting eternal life (Jn 3 5); and, finally, in adopting baptism as a symbol of Chris- tian discipleship. Lirrexnature.—The relative sections in the Gospel Comm., in the Lives of Christ, and the arts. on John the Baptist in the several Bible dicts. There are a number of monographs which treat more minutely of details: W. C. Duncan, The Life, Character and Acts of John the Baptist, New York, 1853; Erich Haupt, Johannss der Téufer, Giitersloh, 1874; H. Kohler, Johannes der Tdufer, Halle, 1884; R. C. Houghton, John the Baptist: His Life and Work, New York, 1889; H. R. Reynolds, John the Baptist, London, 1890; J. Feather, John the Baptist, Edinburgh, 1894; George Matheson in Repre- sentative Men of the NT, 24-66, Edinburgh, 1905; T. Innitzer, Johannes der Tdaufer, Vienna, 1908; A. T. Robertson, John the Loyal, New York, 1911. Russet, BensamMin MILLER JOHN, THE EPISTLES OF: ‘I. Genera, CHARACTER : 1. A True Letter 2. Subject-Matter t 3. Characteristlcs of the Writer 4. Style and Diction Poxremicat Aim . Gnosticism . Docetism . Antinomianism . Cerinthus TRUCTURE AND SuMMARY . The Prologue, 1 1-4 . First Cycle, 1 5—2 28 The Christian Life as Fellowshlp with God (Walking in the Light) Tested by Righteous- ness, Love and Belief (a) Paragraph A, 1 8—2 6 (b) Pareprepe B, 2 7-17 {2 ositively di) Negatively (c) Male Se h C, 2 18-28 3. Second Cycle,2 29-4 6 Divine Sonship Tested by Righteousness, Love and Belief a Paragraph A, 2 29—3 10a II. 1 2. 3 4 III. 8 1 2 (6) Paragraph B, 3 100-246 (c) Paragraph C, 3_24b—4 6 4, Third Cycle, 4 7 21 Clore Correlation of Righteousness, Love and Belie (a) Section I, 4 7—§ 3a (i) Paragraph A, 4 7-12 fi Paragraph B, 4 13-16 iii (6) Section I Verepren C, 4 17—§ 3a a) oe 7; i) Paragrap 5 BB Paragraph B, 5 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA | 41), dangers (2 26; 3 7; John the Baptist John, Epistles of Canonicity 4ND AUTHORSHIP 1. Traditionai View 2. Critical Views 3. Internal Evidence V. ReuatTionsHip To THE FourtH GosPren . Common Characteristics . Coincidences of Vocabulary . Divergences of Vocabulary . Arguments agalnst Unity of Authorship . Conclusion 6. Question of Priority LiveERATURE Among the 7 NT epp. which from ancient times have been called “catholic,” there is a smaller group of three in which the style alike of thought and lan- guage points to a common authorship, and which are traditionally associated with the name of the apostle John. Of these, again, the first differs widely from the other two in respect not only of intrinsic importance, but of its early reception in the church and unquestioned canonicity. Iv. uP ON Tus First Epistus I. General Character.—Not only is the Ep. an anonymous writing; one of its unique features among the books of the NT is that it 1. ATrue does not contain a single proper Letter name (except Our Lord’s), or a single definite allusion, personal, historical, or geographical. It is a composition, however, which a person calling himself ‘‘I” sends to certain other persons whom he calls “‘you,”’ and is, in form at least, a letter. The criticism which has denied that it is more than formally so is unwarranted. It does not fall under either of Deissmann’s categories —the true letter, intended only for the perusal of the person or persons to whom it is addressed, and the ep., written with literary art and with an eye to the public. But it does possess that character of the NT epp. in general which is well described by Sir William Ramsay (Letters to the Seven Churches of Asia, 24): ‘They spring from the heart of the writer and speak direct to the heart of the readers. They were often called forth by some special crisis in the history of the persons addressed, so that they rise out of the actual situation in which the writer conceives the readers to be placed; they express the writer’s keen and living sympathy with and partici- pation in the fortunes of the whole class addressed, and are not affected by any thought of a wider public. .... On the other hand, the letters of this class express general principles of life and con- duct, religion and ethics, applicable to a wider range of circumstances than those which called them forth; and they appeal as emphatically and inti- mately to all Christians in all time as they did to those addressed in the first mstance.” The Ist Ep. of St. John could not be more exactly character- ized than by these words. Though its main features are didactic and controversial, the personal note is frequently struck, and with much tenderness and depth of feeling. Under special stress of emotion, the writer’s paternal love, sympathy and solicitude break out in the affectionate appellation, “little children,” or, yet more endearingly, ‘“‘my little children.” Elsewhere the prefatory ‘‘beloved” shows how deeply he is stirred by the sublimity of his theme and the sense of its supreme importance to his readers. He shows himself intimately ac- quainted with their religious environment (2 19; 6 21), attainments (2 12-14.21), achievements (4 4) and needs (3 19; 6 13). Further, the Ep. is addressed primarily to the circle of those among whom the author has habitually exercised his ministry as evangelist and teacher. He has been wont to announce to them the things concerning the Word of Life (1 1.2), that they might have fellowship with him (1 3), and now, that his (or their) joy may be full, he John, Epistles of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1712 writes these things unto them (1 4). He writes as light shines. Love makes the task a necessity, but also a delight. There is no NT writing which is throughout more vigorously controversial: for the satisfactory in- terpretation of the Ep. as a whole, 2. Subject- recognition of the polemical aim that Matter pervades it is indispensable. But it is true also that there is no such writing in which the presentation of the truth more widely overfiows the limits of the immediate occasion. The writer so constantly lifts up against the error he combats, the simple, sublime and satisfying facts and principles of the Christian revelation, so lifts up every question at issue into the light of eternal truth, that the Ep. pursues its course through the ages, bringing to the church of God the vision and the inspiration of the Divine. The influence of the immediate polemical purpose, however, is manifest, not only in the contents of the Ep., but in its limitations as well. In a sense it may be said that the field of thought is a narrow one. God is seen exclusively as the Father of Spirits, the Light and Life of the universe of souls. His creatorship aud government of the world, the providential aspects and agencies of salvation, the joys and sorrows, hopes and fears that spring from the ter- restrial conditions and changes of human life, their disciplinary purpose and effect—to all this the Ep. contains no reference. The themes are exclu- sively theological and ethical. The writer’s imme- diate interest is confined to that region in which the Divine and human vitally and directly meet—to that in God which is communicable to man, to that in man by which he is capar Dei. The Divine nature as life and light, and love and righteousness; the Incarnation of this Divine nature in Jesus, with its presuppositions and consequences, metaphysical and ethical; the imparting of this Divine nature to men by regeneration; the antithesis to it—sin— and its removal by propitiation; the work of the Holy Spirit; the Christian life, the mutual indwell- ing of God and man, as tested by its beliefs, its antagonism to sin, its inevitable debt of love— such are the fundamental themes to which every idea in the Ep. is directly related. The topics, if few, are supremely great; and the limitations of the field of vision are more than compensated by the profundity and intensity of spiritual perception. The Ep. is in a sense impersonal to the last de- gree, offering a strange contrast to that frankness of self-revelation which gives such 3. Charac- charm to St. Paul’s letters; yet few teristics of writings so clearly reveal the deepest the Writer characteristics of the writer. We feel in it the high serenity of a mind that lives in constant fellowship with the greatest thoughts and is nourished at the eternal fountain- head; but also the fervent indignation and vehe- ment recoil of such a mind in contact with what is false and evil. It has been truly called ‘‘the most passionate” book in the NT. Popular instinct has not erred in giving to its author the title, ‘“Apostle of Love.’ Of the various themes which are so wonderfully intertwined in it, that to which it most of all owes its unfading charm and imperishable value is love. Itrises to its sublimest height, to the apex of al] revelation, in those passages in which its author is so divinely inspired to write of the eternal life, in God and man, as love. But it is an inveterate misconception which re- gards him solely as the exponent of love. Equally he reveals himself as one whose mind is dominated by the sense of truth. There are no words more characteristic of him than “true” (aléhinds, de- noting that which both ideally and really corre- sponds to the name it bears) and “the truth” (alétheia, the reality of things sub specie aelernitatis). To him Christianity is not only a principle of ethics, or even a way of salvation; it is both of them, be- cause it is primarily the truth, the one true dis- closure of the realities of the spiritual and eternal world. ‘Thus it is that his thought so constantly develops itself by antithesis. Each conception has its fundamental opposite: light, darkness; life, death; love, hate; truth, falsehood; the Father, the world; God, the devil. There is no shading, no gradation in the picture. No sentence 1s more characteristic of the writer than this: “Ye know that no lie is of the truth” (2 21m). But again, his sense of these radical antagonisms is essentially moral, rather than intellectual. It seems impos- sible that any writing could display a more impas- sioned sense, than this Ep. does, of the tremendous imperative of righteousness, a more rigorous intol- erance of all sin (2 4; 3 4.8.9.10). The absolute antagonism and incompatibility between the Chris- tian life and sin of whatsoever kind or degree is maintained with a vehemence of utterance that verges at times upon the paradoxical (8 9; 5 18). So Iong as the church lays up this Ep. in its heart, it can never lack a moral tonic of wholesome severity. : The style is closely, though perhaps unconscious- ly, molded upon the Heb model, and esp. upon the parallelistic forms of the Wisdom lit. 4, Style and One has only to read the Ep. with an Diction attentive ear to-perceive that, though using another language, the writer had in his own ear, all the time, the swing and ca- dences of Heb verse. The diction is inartificial and unadorned. Not a simile, not a metaphor (except the most fundamental, like ‘walking in the light”) occurs. The limitations in the range of ideas are matched by those of vocabulary and_by the unvarying simplicity of syntactical form. Yet limited and austere as the literary medium is, the writer handles its resources often with consummate skill. The crystalline simplicity of the style per- fectly expresses the simple profundity of the thought. Great spiritual intuitions shine like stars in sen- tences of clear-cut gnomic terseness. Historical (1 1) and theological (1 2; 4 2) statements are made with exquisite precision. The frequent reiteration of nearly the same thoughts in nearly the same language, though always with variation and enrichment, gives a cumulative effect which is singularly impressive. Such passages as 2 14-17, with its calm challenge to the arrogant materialism of the world—‘‘And the world passeth away, and the lust thereof: but he that doeth the will of God abideth for ever’’—or the closing vs of the Ep., with their thrice-repeated triumphant ‘we know” and their last word of tender, urgent admonition, have a solemn magnificence of effect which nothing but such simplicity of language, carrying such weight of thought, could produce. If it has been true of any writer that “le style est ’homme,”’ it is true of the author of this Ep. If. Polemical Aim.—The polemical intention of the Ep. has been universally recognized; but there has been diversity of opinion as to its actual object. By the older commentators, generally, this was found in the perilous state of the church or churches . addressed, which had left their first love and lapsed into Laodicean lukewarmness. But the Ep. gives no sign of this, and it contains many passages that are Inconsistent with it (2 13.14.20.21.27; 4 4; 5 18-20). The danger which immediately threat- ens the church is from without, not from within. There is a “spirit of error’ (4 6) abroad: in the world. From the church itself (2 18), many “false prophets” have gone forth (4 1), corrupters of the gospel, veritable antichrists (2 18). And it may be as- 1713 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Epistles of serted as beyond question that the peril against which the Ep. was intended to arm the church was the spreading influence of some form of Gnosticism. The pretensions of Gnosticism to a higher esoteric knowledge of Divine things seems to- be clearly referred to in several passages. In 2 4.6.9, e.g. one might suppose that they are almost verbally quoted (‘He : that saith’; “I know Him”; “I abide in Him”; “I am in the light’). When we observe, moreover, the prominence given through- out to the idea of knowledge and the special sig- nificance of some of these passages, the conviction grows that the writer’s purpose is not only to refute the false, but to exhibit apostolic Christianity, be- lieved and lived, as the true Gnosis—the Divine reality of which Gnosticism was but a fantastic caricature. The confidence he has concerning his readers is that they “know him who is from the be- ginning,” that they “know the Father” (2 18). “Every one that loveth is begotten of God, and knoweth God” (4 7); and the final note upon which the Ep. closes is: ‘We know him that is true, and we are in him that is true” (5 20). The knowledge of the ultimate Reality, the Being who is the eternal life, is for Christian and Gnostic alike the goal of aspiration. But it is against two closely related developments of gnostic tendency, a docetic view of the incarna- tion, and an antinomian view of morals, that the Ep. is specifically directed. Both of these sprang nat- urally from the dualism which was the fundamental and formative principle of Gnosticism in all its many forms. According to the dualistic conception of existence, the moral schism of which we are conscious in experience is original, eternal, inherent in the nature of beings. There are two independent and antagonistic principles of being from which severally come all the good and all the evil that exist. The source and the seat of evil were found in the materia] element, in the body with its senses and appetites, and in its sensuous earthly environ- ment; and it was held inconceivable that the Di- vine nature should have immediate contact with the material side of existence, or influence upon it. To such a view.of the universe Christianity could be adjusted only by a docetic interpretation of the Person of Christ. A real incarnation 2. Docetism was unthinkable. The Divine could enter into no actual union with a cor- poreal organism. The human nature of Christ and the incidents of His earthly career were more or less an illusion. And it is with this docetic sub- version of the truth of the incarnation that the “antichrists” are specially identified (2 22.23; 4 2.3), and against it that St. John directs with whole- hearted fervor his central thesis—the complete, per- manent, personal identification of the historical Jesus with the Divine Being whois the Word of Life (1 1), the Christ (4 2) and the Son of God (6 5): ‘Jesus is the Christ come in the flesh.” In Jn 6 6 there isa still more definite reference to the special form which ostic Christology assumed in the teaching of Cernthius and his school. According to Irenaeus (Adv. Haer., i.26, 1) this Cerinthus, who was St. John’s prime antagonist in Ephesus, taught that Jesus was the son of Joseph and Mary, and was dis- tinguished from other men only by superiority in justice, prudence and wisdom; that at His baptism the heavenly Christ descended upon Him in the form of a dove; that on the eve of His Passion, the Christ again left Jesus, so that Jesus died and rose again, but the Christ, being spiritual, did not suffer. That is to say, that, in the language of the Ep., the Christ ‘“‘came by water,” but not, as St. John strenuously affirms, “by water and blood.... not with the water only, but with the water and 1. Gnosti- cism with the blood” (6 6). He who was baptized of John in Jordan, and He whose life-blood was shed on Calvary, is the same Jesus and the same Christ, the same Son of God eternally. A further consequence of the dualistic interpre- tation of existence is that sin, in the Christian mean- ing of sin, disappears. It is no longer 3. Anti- a moral opposition (anemia), in the nomianism human personality, to good; it is a physical principle inherent in all non- spiritual being. Not the soul, but the flesh is its organ; and redemption consists, not in the renewal of the moral nature, but in its emancipation from the flesh. Thus it is no mere general contingency, but a definite tendency that is contemplated in the repeated warning: “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. .... If we say that we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us” (1 8.10). With the nobler and more earnest spirits the prac- tical corollary of this irreconcilable dualism in human nature was the ascetic life; but to others the same principle readily suggested an opposite method of achieving the sou]’s deliverance from the yoke of the material—an attitude of moral indiffer- ence toward the deeds of the body. Let the duality of nature be boldly reduced to practice. Let body and spirit be regarded as separate entities, each obeying its own laws and acting according to its own nature, without mutual interference; the spiritual nature could not be involved in, nor affected by, the deeds of the flesh. Vehement opposition to this deadly doctrine is prominent in the Ep.— in such utterances as ‘Sin is lawlessness” (3 4) and its converse ‘‘All unrighteousness is sin’ (6 17), but esp. in the stringent emphasis laid upon actual conduct, “doing” righteousness or “doing” sin. The false spiritualism which regards the contempla- tion of heavenly things as of far superior importance to the requirements of commonplace morality is sternly reprobated: ‘Little children, let no man lead you astray: he that doeth righteousness is righteous, even as he is righteous” (3 7); and the converse application of the same doctrine, that the mere “‘doing” of sin is of little or no moment to the “spiritual” man, is met with the trenchant declara- tion, “He that doeth sin is of the devil” (3 8). The whole passage (2 29—3 10) presupposes, as familiar to its readers, a doctrine of moral indifferentism according to which the status of the spiritual man is not to be tested by the commonplace facts of moral conduct. It is only as a passionate contradiction of this hateful tenet that the paradoxical language of 3 6.9 and 6 18 can be understood. To the same polemical necessity is due the unique- ly reiterated emphasis which the Ep. lays upon brotherly love, and the almost fierce tone in which the new commandment is promulgated. To the Gnostic, knowledge was the sum of attainment. “They give no heed to love,” says Ignatius, ‘‘caring not for the widow, the orphan or the afflicted, neither for those who are in bonds nor. for those who are released from bonds, neither for the hungry nor the thirsty.” That a religion which banished or neglected love should call itself Christian or claim affinity with Christianity excites St. John’s hottest indignation; against it he lifts up his su- preme truth, God is love, with its immediate conse- quence that to be without love is to be without capacity for knowing God (4 7.8). The assumption of a lofty mystical piety apart from dutiful conduct in the ordinary relations of life is ruthlessly under- lined as the vaunt of a self-deceiver (4 20); and the crucial test by which we may assure our self- accusing hearts that we are “of the truth” is love “not in word, neither with the tongue; but in deed and truth” (3 18). John, Epistles of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1714 The question is raised whether the polemic of the Ep. is directed against the same persons throughout or whether in its two branches, the Christological and the ethical, it has different objects of attack. The latter view is maintained on the ground that no charge of libertine teaching or conduct is brought against the “antichrists,’ and there is no proof that docetism in Asia Minor lay open to such a charge. But the other view has greater probability. The Ep. suggests nothing else than that the same spirit of error which is assailing the faith of the church (4 6) is also a peril to the moral integrity of its life (3 7). And if there is no proof that docetism in Asia Minor was also antinomian, there is no proof that it was not. The probability is that it was. Docetism and the emancipation of . the Gober both natural fruits of the dualistic theory of life. The name which unvarying tradition associates with the Ep., as St. John’s chief antagonist in Ephesus, is that-of Cerinthus. Un- 4. Cerinthus fortunately the accounts which have come down to us of Cerinthus and his teaching are fragmentary and confused, and those of his character, though unambiguous, come only from his opponents. But it is certain that he held a docetic view of the incarnation, and, according to the only accounts we possess, his character was that of a voluptuary. So far as they go, the historical | data harmonize with the internal evidence of the Ep. itself in giving the impression that the different tendencies it combats are such as would be naturally evolved in the thought and practice of those who held, as Cerinthus did, that the material creation, and even the moral law, had its origin, not in the Supreme God, but in an inferior power. Wf, Stracture and Summary.—In the judgment of many critics, the Ep. possesses nothing that can be called an articulate structure of thought, its aphoristic method admitting of no logical develop- ment; and this estimate has a large measure of support in the fact that there isno NT writing regard- ing the plan of which there has been greater variety of opinion. The present writer believes, neverthe- less, that it is erroneous, and that, in its own unique way, the Ep. is a finely articulated composition. The word that best describes the author’s mode of thinking is “spiral.” The course of thought does not move from point to point in a straight line. It is like a winding staircase—always revolving around the same center, always recurring to the same topics, but at a higher level. Carefully following the topical order, one finds, e.g., a paragraph (2 3-6) insisting upon practical righteousness as a guaranty of the Christian life; then one finds this treated a second time in 2 29— 3 10a; and yet again in 6 3 and 5 18. Similarly, we find a paragraph on the necessity of love in 2 7-11, and again in 3 105-20, and yet again in 4 7-13, and also in 4 17—5 2. So also, a paragraph con- cerning the necessity of holding the true belief in the incarnate Son of God in 2 18-28, in 4 1-6, and the same subject recurring in 4 13-16 and 5 4-12. And we shall observe that everywhere these indis- pensable characteristics of the Christian life are applied as tests; that in effect the Ep. is an ap- aratus of tests, Its definite object being to furnish its readers with the necessary criteria by which they may sift the false from the true, and satisfy them- selves of their being “begotten of God.” ‘These things have I written unto you, that ye may know that ye have eternal life’ (5 13). These fundamental tests of the Christian life—doing right- eousness, loving one another, believing that Jesus is the Christ come in the fiesh—are the connecting themes that bind together the whole structure of the Ep, Thus if we divide the Ep. into 3 main sections, the first ending at 2 28, the second at 4 6, the result is that in the first and second of these sec- tions we find precisely the same topics coming in precisely the same order; while in the third section (4 7—6 21), though the sequence is somewhat different, the thought-material is exactly the same. The leading themes, the tests of righteousness, love, and belief, are all present; and they alone are present. There is, therefore, a natural division of the Ep. into these three main sections, or, as they might be descriptively called, ‘cycles,’ in each of which the same fundamental themes appear. On this basis we shall now give a brief analysis of its structure and summary of its contents. The writer announces the source of the Christian reve- lation—the historical manifestation of the eternal Di- vine life in Jesus Christ—and declares 1. The himself a personal witness of the facts in Prologue which this manifestation has been given. gue, Here, at the outset, he hoists the flag 1:14 under which he fights. The incarnation is not seeming or temporary, but real. That which was from the beginning—''the eternal life, which was with the Father'’—is identical with ‘‘that which we have heard, that which we have seen with our eyes, that which we bebeld, and our hands handled."’ Phe Christian life, as fellowship with God (walking inthe Light) tested by righteousness, love and belief. —The basis of the whole section is the announcement: 2. First “God is light, and in him is no darkness at- Cyel ail'' (ver 5). What God is at once deter- ycle, mines the condition of fellowship with 1:6—2:28 Him; and this, therefore, isset forth: first, negatively (1 6): ‘if wesay that we have fellowship with him and walk in the darkness''; then, ositively (1 7): ‘if we walk in the light, as he isiu the ight.’" What, then, is it to walk in the light, and what to walk in darkness? The answer is given in what foilows. (a) Paragraph A,1 8—2 6 (walking in the Light tested by righteousness): First, in confession of sin (1 8—2 2), then in actual obedience (2 3-6). The first fact upon which the fight of God impinges in human life is sin; and the first test of walking in the light is the recognition and confession of this fact. Such confession is the first step into fellowship with God, becanse it brings us under the cieansing power of the blood of Jesus, His Son (1 7), and makes His intercession available for us (2 1). But the light not only reveals sin; its greater function is toreveal duty; and to walk in the light is to keep God's commandments (2 3), His word (2 5), and to walk even as Christ walked (2 6). (o) Paragraph B, 2 7-17 (walking in the Light tested by love): @) Positively: The old-new commandment (2 7-11). Love is the commandment which is “old,” because familiar to the readers of the Ep. from their first acquaintance with the rudiments of Christianity (2 7); but also *‘new,’’ because ever fresh and living to those who have fellowship with Christ in the true light which is now shining for them (2 8). On the contrary, ‘‘He that salth he is In the light and hateth his brother, is in the darkness" (2 9). The antithesis is then repeated with variation and enrichment of thought (vs 10.11). (Then follows a parenthetical address to the readers [vs 12-14]. This being treated as a parenthesis, the unity of the paragraph at once becomes apparent.) (il), Negatively: If walking in_the iight has its guar- anty in loving one's “brother,” it is tested no less by not loving ‘the world.'’ One cannot at the same time articipate in the life of God and in a moral life which 8 governed by the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, and the valn-glory of the worid. (c) Paragraph C, 2 18-28 (walking in the Light tested hy belief): The iight of God not only reveals sin and duty, the children of God (our ‘‘brother") and “the world” in their true character; it aiso reveals Jesus In His true character, as the Christ, the incarnate Son of God. And ali that cails itself Christianity is to be tested by its reception or rejection of that ‘truth. In this paragraph light and darkness are not Sx presaly referred to; but the continuity of thought with the pre- ceding paragraphs is unmistakable. Throughout this first division of the Ep. the point of view is that of fellowship with God, through receiving and acting accord- pe the light which His self-revelation sheds upon all things in the spirituai realm. Unreal Christianity in every form is comprehensively a “lie.” It may be the antinomian ‘‘iie"’ of him who says he has nosin (1 8) yet Is indifferent to pooping God's commandments (2 4), the jie of lovelessness (2 9), or the lie of Antichrist, who, clean spirituai enlightenment, yet denies that Jesus is the Christ (2 22). Divine sonship tested by righteousness, love and belief. —The first main division of the Ep. began with the assertion of what God is as seif-reveaiing—light. He 1715 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Epistles of becomes to us the light in which we behold our sin, our duty, our brother, the world, Jesus the Christ; and only in acknowledging and loyally acting 3. Second out the truth thus revealed can we have Cycle fellowship with God. This second division, ycle, on the other hand, begins with the asser- 2:29—4:6 tion of what the Divine nature is in Itself, and thence deduces the essential char- acteristics of those who are ‘‘ hegotten of God." (a) Paragraph A, 2 293 10a (Divine sonship tested by righteousness): This test is inevitable, ‘If ye know that he is righteous, ye know that every one aiso that doeth righteousness is begotten of him" (2 29). But this new idea, ‘' begotten of God."' arrests for a time its orderly development. The writer is carried away by wonder and thanksgiving at the thought that sinful man should be brought into such a relation as this to God. “Behold what manner of love!" he exclaims. This ‘leads him to contemplate, further, the present conceai- ment of the glory of God's chiidren, and the splendor of its future manifestation (8 1.2). Then the thought that the fulfilment of this hope is necessarily conditioned by present endeavor after moral likeness to Christ (ver 3) leads back to the main theme, that the life of Divine sonship Js by necessity of nature one of absolute antago- nism to all sin. This necessity is exhibited (1) in the light of the moral authority of God—sin is lawlessness (ver 4); (2) in the light of Christ's character, in which there is no sin, and of the purpose of His mission, which is to take away sin (vs 5-7); (3) in the light of the diabolic origin of sin (ver 8); (4) in the light of the God- begotten quality of the Christian life (ver 9). Finally, in this is declared to_be the manifest distinction be- vacen ae children of God and the children of the devll ver > (b) Paragraph B, 3 10b-24a (Divine sonship tested by love): This test is inevitable (vs 106.11). The thought is then developed pictorially instead of_ dialectica ly. Cain is the prototype of hate (ver Aa) Cain's spirit ig reproduced in the world (ver ae ove is the sign of having passed from death into life (ver 14a); the ab- sence of it, the sign of abiding in death (vs 145.15). In glorious contrast to the sinister figure of Cain, who sacrifices his brother's life to his morbid self-love, is the figure of Christ, who sacrificed His own life in love to us His brethren (ver 16a); whence the inevitable inference that our life, if one with His, must obey the same law (ver 166). Genuine love consists not in words, but In deeds (vs 17.18); and from the evidence of such love alone can we rightly possess confidence toward God (vs 19.20) in prayer (ver 22). Then follows recapitu- lation (vs 23.24), combining, under the category of “‘commandment,”’ love and also belief on His Son Jesus Christ. Thus a transition is made fo Paragraph Cc. (c) Paragraph C, 3 24b—4 6 (Divine sonship tested by belief): This test is inevitable (3 24b).. ** We know that he abideth in us, by the Spirit which he gave us''; and the Spirit ‘which he gave us” is the Spirit that “confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh” 42). On the contrary, the Spirit that confesseth not esus is the spirit of Antichrist (ver 3). Then follows a characterization of those who receive the true and of those who receive the faise teaching (vs 4—6). Closer correlation of righteousness, love and belief.— In this closing part, the Hp. rises to its loftiest heights; but the logical analysis of it is more diffl- 4, Third cult, It may be divided into two main Cycle, 4:7— cesta dealing respectively with love and Sie elief. 6:21 (a) Szcrion I, 4 7—5 3a, on love.— Gi) Paragraph A, 4 7-12: This paragraph ounds more deeply than before the test of love. Love is indispensable, because God is love (vs7.8). The proof that God is love is the mission of Christ (ver 9); which is also the absolute revelation of what love, truly so calied, is (ver 10). But this love of God imposes upon us an unescapable obligation to love one another (ver 11); and only from the fulfilment of this can we obtain the assurance that ‘God abideth in us" (ver 12). Gi) Paragraph B, 4 13-16: This paragraph strives to show the inner relation between Christian belief and Christian love. The true belief is indispensable as a uaranty of Christian life, because the Spirit of God is ts author (ver 13). The true helief is that ‘‘ Jesus is the Son of God" (vg 14.15). In this is found the vital ground of Christian love (ver 16). zy Gii) Paragraph C, 4 17—5 3a: Here the subject is the effect, motives and manifestations of brotherly love. The effect is confidence toward God (vs 17.18); the mo- tives: (1) God's love to us (ver 19); (2) that the only possible response to this is to love our brother (ver 20); (3) that this is Christ’s commandment (ver 21); (4) that it is the natural instinct of spiritual kinship (5 1). But true love is inseparable from righteousness. We truly love the children of God only when_we love God, and we love God only when we keep His command- ments (vs 2.3a). (b) pee lap re II, § 36-21, on belief.—(i) Paragraph A, 5 36-12: Righteousness is possible only through belief. Tt is our faith that makes the commandments ‘not grievous” because it overcomes the world (vs 36.4). Then follows a restatement of the contents of the true bellef, specially directed against the Cerinthian heresy (vs 5.6); then an expositlon of the " witness '' upon which thls belief rests (vs 7-10); then a reiterated declaration of its being the test and guaranty of possessing eternal IMfe (vs 11.12). (il) Paragraph B, § 13-21: This closing paragraph sets forth the great triumphant certainties of Christian belief: its certainty of eternal lite (ver 13), and of pre- valling In prayer ts 14.15). Then the writer guards himself by citing an instance in which such certainty is unattainabie—prayer for those that sin unto death— and reminds his readers that all unrighteousness, though not sin unto death, is sin (vs 16.17). He then resumes the great certainties of Christian hellet: the certainty that the Christian life stands always and everywhere for righteousness, absolute antagonism to all sin (ver 18); the certainty of the moral gulf between it and the lIlfe of the world (ver 19); its certainty of ltself, of the facts on which 1t rests, and the supernatural power which has given perception of these facts (ver 20). With an abrupt, affectionate call to those who know the true God to beware of yielding thelr trust and dependence to “idois,"’ the Ep. ends. IV. Canonicity and Authorship.—As to the reception of the Ep. in the church, it is needless to cite any later witness than Eusebius 1. Tradi- (¢ 325), who classes it among the books tional View (homolegoumena) whose canonical rank was undisputed. It is quoted by Dionysius, bishop of Alexandria (247-65), by the Muratorian Canon, Cyprian, Origen, Tertullian, Clement of Alexandria, and Irenaeus. Papias (who is described by Irenaeus as a “hearer of John and a companion of Polycarp”) is stated by Eusebius to have “used some testimonies from John’s former ep.”’; and Polycarp’s Ep. to the Philippians (e 115) contains an almost verbal reproduction of 1 Jn 4 8. Reminiscences of it are traced in Athenagoras (c 180), the Ep. to Diognetus, the Ep. of Barnabas, more distinctly in Justin (Dial. 123) and in the Didache; but it is possible that the earliest of these indicate the currency of Johannine expressions in certain Christian circles rather than acquaintance with the Ep. itself. The evidence, however, is indisputable that this Ep., one of the latest of the NT books, took immediately and permanently an unchallenged position as a writing of inspired author- ity. It is no material qualification of this state- ment to add that, in common with the other Jo- hannine writings, it was rejected, for dogmatic reasons, by Marcion and the so-called Alogi; and that, like all the catholic epp., it was unknown to the Canon of the ancient Syrian church, and is stated to have been ‘abrogated’? by Theodore (bishop of Mopsuestia, 8393-428 AD). The verdict of tradition_is equally unanimous that the Fourth Gospel and the First Ep. are both the legacy of the apostle John in his old age to the 2. Critical church. All the Fathers already men- a tioned as quoting the Ep. (excepting Poly- Views carp, but including Irenaeus) quote it as the work of St. John; and, until the end of the 16th cent., this opinion was held as unquestion- able. The first of modern scholars to chalienge it was Joseph Scaliger (1540-1609), who rejected the entire trio of Johannine Epp. as unapostolic; and In later times a dual authorship of the Gospel and the First Ep. has been maintained by Baur, H. J. Holtzmann, Pfieiderer, von Soden, and others; although on this particular point other adherents of the critical school, like Jiilicher, Wrede and Wernle, accept the traditional view. Thus two questions are raised: first, what light does the Ep. shed upon the personality of its own author? And second, whether or not 3. Internal the Gospel and the Ep. are from the Evidence same hand. Now, while the Ep. furnishes no clue by which we ean identify the writer, it enables us very distinctly to class him. His relation to his readers, as we have seen, is intimate. The absence of explicit reference to either writer or readers only shows how intimate it was. For the writer to declare his identity was superfluous. Thought, language, tone—all were too familiar to be mistaken. The Ep. bore its author’s signature in every line. His position John, Epistles ofp THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1716 toward his readers was, moreover, authoritative. As has already been said, the natural interpretation of 1 2.3 is that the relation between them was that of teacher and taught. (By this fact we may account for the enigmatic brevity of such a passage as that on the “three witnesses.” The writer intended only to recall fuller oral expositions formerly given of the same topics.) The writer is at any rate a person of so distinctive eminence and recognized authority that it is not necessary to remind the readers either who he is or by what circumstances he is compelled now to address them through the medium of writing; their knowledge of both facts is taken for granted. And all this agrees with the traditional account of St. John’s relation to the churches of Asia Minor in the last decades of the Ist cent. Further, the writer claims to be one of the original witnesses of the facts of the incarnate life: “That which was from the beginning, that which we have heard, that which we have seen with our eyes, that which we beheld, and our hands handled, concerning the Word of life (and the life was manifested, and we have seen, and bear witness, and declare unto you the life, the eternal life, which was with the Father, and was manifested unto us); that which we have seen and heard declare we unto you also, that ye also may have fellowship with us” (1 1-3). To understand the ‘“Word of life’’ here as the gospel (Westcott, Rothe, Haupt) seems to the present writer frankly impossible; and not less so the theories by which the words “what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes,” etc, are regarded as utterances of the “faith-mysticism”’ or the ‘‘col- lective testimony” of the early church. It is diffi- cult to imagine words more studiously adapted to convey the impression that the writer is one of the original, first-hand witnesses of Christ’s life and res- urrection (‘that what we beheld, and our hands handled”; ef Lk 24 39). At furthest, the use of such language is otherwise compatible with veracity only on the supposition that the writer was recog- nized by the church as so closely identified with the original witnesses that he could speak of their testimony as virtually his own. But, apart from the presumption that he cannot have been one of the actual disciples of Jesus, there is really nothing to besaid for thissupposition. So far as theinternal evidence is concerned, the ancient and unbroken tradition which assigns it to the apostle John must be regarded as holding the field, unless, indeed, the traditional authorship is disproved by arguments of the most convincing kind. Whether the argu- ments brought against the apostolic authorship of the Johannine writings as a whole possess this character.is too large a question to be investigated here. Yet the kernel of it lies in small compass. It is whether room can be found within the 1st cent. for so advanced a stage of theological development as is reached in the Johannine writings, and whether this development can be conceivably attributed to one of Our Lord’s original] disciples. To neither of these questions, as it appears to the present writer, is a dogmatically negative answer warranted. If within a period comparatively so brief, Christian thought had already passed through the earlier and later Pauline developments, and through such a development as we find in the Ep. to the He, there is no obvious reason why it may not have attained to the Johannine, within the lifetime of the last survivor of the apostles. Nor, when we consider the nature of the intellectual influences, within and without the church, by which the apostle John was surrounded, if, as tradition says, he lived on to a green old age in Ephesus, is there any obvious reason why he may not have been the chief instru- ment of that development. V. Relationship to the Fourth Gospel.—The further question remains as to the internal evidence the Ep. supplies regarding its relation 1. Common to the Fourth Gospel. Prima facie, Character- the case for identity of authorship is istics overwhelmingly strong. The two writings are equally saturated with that spiritual and theological atmosphere; they are equally characterized by that type of thought which we call Johannine and which presents an interpretation of Christianity not less original and distinctive than Paulinism. Both exhibit the same mental and moral habit of viewing every subject with an eye that stedfastly beholds radical antago- nisms and is blind to approximations. There isin both the same strongly Heb style of composition; the same development of ideas by parallelism or antithesis; the same repetition of keywords like “begotten of God,” “abiding,” “keeping his com- mandments”; the same monotonous simplicity in the construction of sentences, with avoidance of relative clauses and singular parsimony in the use of connecting particles; the same apparently tauto- logical habit of resuming consideration of a subject from a slightly different point of view; the same restricted range of vocabulary, which, moreover, is identical to an extent unparalleled in two independ- ent writings. The evidence for these statements cannot be pre- sented here in full; but the following are some of the words and phrases characteristic of 2. Coinci- both and not found elsewhere in the dences of NT—the Word, joy fulfilled, to see Vocabulary (or behold) and bear witness, to do the truth, to havesin, Paraclete, to keep the word (of God or Christ), to abide (in God or in Christ), the true light, new commandment, little children (feknia), children (paidia), to abide for ever, begotten of God, to purify one’s self, to do sin, to take away sins, works of the devil, to pass from death into life, murderer, to lay down one’s life, to be of the truth, to give commandment, to hear (=to hear approvingly), no man hath beheld God at any time, knowing and believing, Saviour of the world, water and blood, to overcome the world, to receive witness, to give eternal life, to have eternal life (in present sense), to believe in the name. The following are some of the terms common to both, which are found very rarely elsewhere in the NT: Beginning (=past eternity), to be manifested (9 t in each), to bear witness (6 t in the Ep., 33 t in the Gospel, once only in Mt, once in Lk, not at all in Mk), light (metaphorical), walk (metaphorical), to lead astray, to know (God, Christ, or Spirit, 8 t in the Ep., 10t in the Gospel), true (aléthinés), to confess Jesus (elsewhere only in Rom 10 9), children of God, to destroy (léein, elsewhere only in 2 Pet), the spirit of truth, to send (apostéllein, of mission of Christ), only begotten son, to have the witness (else- where only in Apoc), to hear (=to answer prayer). On the other hand, the divergences of vocabulary are not More numerous than might be expected in two writings by the same author but 3. Diver- of different literary form. The rather gences of notable difference in the choice and Vocabulary use of particles is accounted for by : the fact that dialogue and narrative, of which the Gospel is largely composed, are foreign to the Ep. The discrepancy, when closely exam- ined, sometimes turns out to be a point of real simi- larity. Thus the particle ogn occurs nearly 200 t in the Gospel, not at all in the Ep. But in the Gospel it is used only in narrative, no occurrence of it being found, e.g. in chs 14-16. Of the words and phrases contained in the Ep., but not in the Gospel, the great majority are ac- counted for by the fact that they are used in con- 1717 nection with topics which are not dealt with in the Gospel. Apart from these, the following may be noted, the most important being italicized: Word of life, fellowship, to confess sins (nowhere else in the NT), to cleanse from sin, propitiation (hilasmés, nowhere else in the NT), perfected or perfect love, last hour, Antichrist, anointing, to give of the spirit, to have (Father, Son) boldness (Godward), Pa- rousia, lawlessness, seed (of God), come in the flesh, God is love, Day of Judgment, belief (pistis), to make God a liar, understanding. As regards style and diction, therefore, it seems impossible to con- ceive of two independent literary productions having a more intimate affinity. The relation between them in this respect is far closer than that between the Acts of the Apostles and the Third Gospel, or even any two of St. Paul’s Epp., except those to the Eph and the Col. Arguments for a dual authorship are based chiefly on certain theological emphasis and develop- ments in the Ep., which are absent 4. Argu- from the Gospel; and invariably these ments arguments have been pressed with against complete disregard of the fact that the Unity of one writing purports, at least, to be a Authorship Gospel, the other, an utterance of the writer in propria persona. If, for example, it is urged that the words ‘He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins” have a more Pauline ring than any utterance of the Fourth Gospel, or that the conceptions in the Ep. of pro- pitiation, intercession, and cleansing, are presented in a more explicit and technical form than _in the Gospel, it is a fair reply to ask, Why not? Is it to be accepted as a canon of criticism that the writer of that Gospel must necessarily have put all his own theological expressions into the mouth of Him whose teaching he proposed to report? Much is made of the assertion that in the matter of the last things the Ep. recedes from the idealism of the Gospel, placing itself more nearly in line with the traditional apocalyptic eschatology. Whereas the Gospel speaks of Christ’s bodily departure as the necessary condition of His coming again in the Spirit to make His permanent abode with His dis- ciples (Jn 16 7), the writer of the Ep. thinks of a visible Parousia as nigh at hand (2 28); and where- as the Gospel conceives of judgment as a present spiritual fact. (Jn 3 18.19), the Ep. clings to the “popular” idea of a Judgment Day. But it ought to be noted that in the Ep., as compared with the Gospel, the eschatological perspective is foreshort- ened. The author writes under the conviction that “the world is passing away” and that the ‘ast hour” of its day has come (2 17.18). And it is an unwarrantable assumption that he must, if he wrote the Gospel, have been guilty of the manifest anachronism of importing this conviction into it also. Apart from this the fundamental similarities between the eschatology of the Ep. and that of the Gospel are far more striking than the differences. In both, eternal life is conceived of as a present and not merely a future possession. In both, Christ’s presence is an abiding reality—‘‘Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ” (1 3). If the Gospel speaks of the revelation of Christ as bringing present and inevitable “judg- ment” into the world, the Ep. is saturated with the same thought. If, on the other band, the Ep. speaks of a visible future Parousia, this is plainly implied in Jn 5 28.29. If the Ep. makes a single reference to the Day of Judgment (4 17),the Gospel has 6 passages which speak of the “last day,” and in these the “last day” is explicitly the day of resurrection (11 24) and of judgment (12 48). In the two writings different features of the escha- tological picture may be made more or less con- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Epistles of spicuous; but there is no such diversity as to war- rant the hypothesis of a separate authorship. Again, it is urged that in the Ep. the conception of the Logos is modified in the direction of conformity to traditional doctrine. The conception of the personal, preéxistent Logos, who “in the beginnin was,” and ‘‘was with God,” and ‘‘was God” (1 1 was new, it is said, and, because of its gnostic tinge, suspect; and was therefore avoided and becomes in the Ep. the depersonalized ‘‘Word of life’ (1 1). But why should the “Word of life” necessarily signify anything less personal than the phraseology of the Gospel? The phraseology in both cases is exactly adapted to its purpose. In the Gospel, ‘‘in the beginning was the Word . . . . and the Word became flesh” is right, because it sums up the con- - tents of the Gospel, announces its subject, the his- tory of the Incarnate Logos. In the Ep., the ‘‘Word of life” is right, because the theme is to be the life, not as to its historical manifestation in Jesus, but as to its essential characteristics, whetber in God or in man. Other arguments of a similar kind which have been put forward need not be considered. On the whole, it seems clear that, while there are between the Gospel and the Ep. differences of emphasis, perspective and point of view, these cannot be held as at all counterbalancing, on the question of authorship, the unique similarity of the two writings in style and vocabulary and in the whole matter and manner of thought, together with the testi- mony of a tradition which is ancient, unanimous and unbroken. Regarding the question of priorlty as between the two writings, the only certainty is that the Ep. presup- poses its readers’ acquaintance with the * substance of the Gospel (otherwise such 6. Question expressions as ‘Word of life,” ‘new of Priority 6. Conelu- sion commandment” would have been unin- telligible); but that does not imply its posterior uy to the composition of the Gospel in literary orm. By Lightfoot and others it is supposed to have heen written simultaneously with the Gospel. and dis- patched along with it as a covering letter to its original readers. In view, however, of the independence and first- rate importance of the Ep., it is difficult to think of it as having originated in this way; and by the majority of scholars it is regarded as later than the Gospel and sep- arated from it by an appreciable interval. hat it was written with a ‘’mediating’’ purpose (Pfieiderer), to “popularize’’ the ideas of the Gospel (Weizsacker), or to correct and tone down what in it was obnoxious to the feeling of the church, and at the same time to add certain links of connection (such as propitiation, Para- clete, Parousia) with the traditional type of doctrine, or to emphasize these where they existed (Holtzmann), is a theory which rests on an extremely slender hasis; the theory that it was written as a protest agalnst gnostic appropriation of the Fourth Gospel itself (Jiilicher) has no tangible basis at all. That there was an appreciable interval between the two writings is probable enough. Gnostic tendencies have meanwhile hardened into more definite form. Many false prophets have gone out into the world. The ‘“‘antichrists'’ have declared themselves. The time has come for the evangelist to focns the rays of his Gospel upon the malignant growth which Is acutely endangering the life of the church. LITERATURE.—Commentaries are numerous and ex- cellent. The most important are those by Calvin, Licke, Ebrard, Haupt (of fine insight but grievous verbosity), Huther (speclally valuable for its conspectus of all earlier exegesis), Westcott (a magazine of materials for the student of the Ep.), Alexander (in the Speaker's Comm.), Rothe (original, beautiful, profound), B. Weiss, H, J. Holtzmann, Plummer (in Cambridge _Gr NT— scholarly and very serviceable); Brooke (in ICC, excel- lent). Among the numerous expositions of the Ep. are those by Neander, Candllsh, aurice, Alexander (Ezx- ositor's Bible), Watson, J. M. Gibbon (Eternal Life), Findlay (Fellowship in the Life Eternal), Law (The Tests of Life—combined exposition and commentary); among pooks on Introduction, those hy Weiss. Bleek, Hilgenfeld, Holtzmann, Jiilicher, Zahn, Salmon, Gloag, Peake; and, among books of other kinds, the relevant sections in Bey- schlag, NT Theology; Pfleiderer, Urchristenthum; Har- nack, Geschichte der altchristl. Litteratur; Farrar, Early Days of Christianity; McGiffert, History of Christianit in the Apostolic Age; Stevens, Johannine Theology and John, Epistles of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1718 Theology of the NT; articles by Salmond in HDB; by Schmiedel in ZB, and by Hiring in Theologische Ab- handlungen, Carl von Wetzsdcker .... gewidmet. In German, the fullest investigation of the relationship of the Ep. to the Fourth Gospel will be found in a series of arts. by H. J. Holtzmann in the Jahrbiicher fir pro- destantische Theologie (1882-83); in English, in Brooke's comm., in Law, Tests of Life, 339-63. See also Drum- mond, Character and Authorship of the Fourth Gospel, Tse Seconp aNp Turrp Episties It is not surprising that these brief and fugitive Epp. are among the NT writings which have had the hardest struggle for canonical rec- 1. Canon- ognition. One is probably, the other icity and certainly, a private letter; and neither Authorship the same reason nor the same oppor- tunity for their circulation existed, as in the case of church letters. ‘The 2d Ep. con- tains little that isdistinctive; the 3d Ep. is occupied with a vexatious episode in the internal history of a single congregation. Both are written by a person who designates himself simply as “the Preshyter’’; and the names of the person (or church) to which the one is addressed and of the church with whose affairs the other is concerned are alike unknown. The fact, therefore, that, in spite of such obstacles, these letters did become widely known and event- ually attained to canonical rank is proof of a gen- eral conviction of the soundness of the tradition which assigned them to the apostle John. Like all the catholic epp., they were unknown to the early Syrian church; when 1 Jn, 1 Pet and Jas were received into its Canon, they were still excluded, nor are they found even in printed edi- tions of the Syr NT till 1630. They were not acknowledged by the school of Antioch. Jerome distinguishes their authorship from that of the 1st Ep. They are classed among the disputed books by Eusebius, who indicates that it was questioned whether they belonged to the evangelist or ‘‘possi- bly to another of the same name as he.” Origen remarks that “not all affirm them to he genuine”; and, as late as the middle of the 4th cent., the effort to introduce them in the Latin church met with Opposition in Africa (Zahn). On the other hand, we find recognition of their Johannine authorship at an early date, in Gaul (Irenaeus); Rome (Muratorian Canon, where, however, the reading is corrupt, and it is doubtful whether their authorship is ascribed or denied to the apostle John); Alexandria (Clement, who is reputed by Eusebius to have commented upon them, and who in his extant works speaks of John’s “larger epistle,” implying the existence of one or more minor epp.); Africa (Cyprian reports that 2 Jn was appealed to at the Synod of Carthage, 256 AD). DSionsaian: Origen’s disciple and suc- cessor, speaks of John’s calling himself in them “the Presbyter.”” Eusebius, though conscientiously placing them among the anttlegomena, elsewhere writes in a way which indicates that he himself did not share the doubt of their authenticity. The internal evidence confirms the ultimate decision of the early church regarding these letters. Quite evidently the 2d Ep. must have been written by the author of the Ist, or was an arrant and apparently purposeless piece of plagiarism. The 3d Ep. is inevitably associated with the 2d by the superscription, “the Preshyter,’ and by other links of thought and phraseology. The mention of this title opens up a wide ques- tion. The famous extract from Papias (Euseb., HE, II, 39) vouches for the existence, 2. The among those who were or had been his Presbyter contemporaries, of a certain ‘‘Preshy- ter” John (see JoHN, Gosprn or, IT, 5). Jerome, moreover, speaks of the two smaller Epp. as, in contrast with the Ist, ascribed to the Presbyter (De Vir. Illusir., ix); Eusebius inclines to ascribe to him the Book of Rev; and modern critics, like Weizsacker and Harnack, have improved upon the hint by finding in this shadowy personage the author of the Fourth Gospel. Into this far- reaching controversy, we cannot here enter. Itmay be noted, however, that whether, in the confusedly written passage referred to, Papias really intends to distinguish between John the Apostle and John the Presbyter is a point still in debate; and that Eusebius (Hvangelica. Demonstratio, III, 5) does not regard the title “‘Presbyter” as inapplicable to St. John, but observes that in his Epp. he “either makes no mention of himself or calls himself presbyter, nowhere apostle or evangelist.” Dionysius, too, remarks that “in the 2d and 3d Epp. ascrihed to him, he writes anonymously, as the Presbyter.” These Fathers, both exceptionally learned men and presumably well acquainted with primitive usage, saw nothing anomalous, although they did see something characteristic, in the fact, or supposed fact, that an apostle should designate himself by the lowlier and vaguer title. In the very sentence from Papias already referred to, the apostles are called “preshyters”; not to say that in the NT it- self we have an instance of an apostle’s so styling himself (1 Pet 6 1). . To sum up, it is evident that no one desiring falsely to secure apostolic prestige for his produc- tions would have written under so indistinctive a title; also, that these brief and very occasional letters could never have won their way to general recognition and canonical rank unless through general conviction of their Johannine authorship— the very history of these Epp. proving that the early church did not arrive at a decision upon such matters without satisfying itself of the trustworthi- ness of the tradition upon which a claim to canon- icity was founded; finally, the internal evidence testifies to an authorship identical with that of the Ist Ep., so that the evidence cited regarding this is available also for those. These letters, along with St. Paul’s to Philemon, are the only extant remains of a private apostolic correspondence which must have included many such, and for this reason, apart from their intrinsic worth, possess an interest, material and biographical, peculiar to themselves. We proceed to consider the two Epp. separately, and since an interesting question arises as to whether the 2d is that referred to in ver 9 of the 3d, it will be convenient to reverse the canonical order in dealing with them. The Third Episile.—This brief note gives a uniquely authentic and intimate glimpse of some aspects of church life as it existed in Asia Minor (this may be taken as certain) somewhere ahout the end of the Ist cent. It concerns a certain episode in the history of one of the churches under the writer’s supervision, and incidentally furnishes character-sketches of two of its members, the large- hearted and hospitable Gaius, to whom it is written (and whom it is merely. fanciful to identify with any other Gaius mentioned in the NT), and the loquacious, overbearing Diotrephes; also of the faithful Demetrius, by whose hand probably the letter is sent. The story which may be gathered from the Ep. seems to be as follows. A band of itinerant teachers had been sent out, by the Pres- byter’s authority, no doubt, and furnished by him with letters of commendation to the various churches, and among others to that of which Gaius and Diotrephes were members. Diotrephes, however, whether through jealousy for the rights of the local community or for some personal reason, not only declined to receive the itinerant teachers, but exerted his authority to impose the same course of action upon the church as a whole, even to the 1719 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Epistles of length of threatening with excommunication (ver 10) those who took a different view of their duty. Gaius alone had not been intimidated, but had wel- comed to his home the repulsed and disheartened teachers, who when they returned (to Ephesus, probably) had testified to the church of his cour- ageous and large-hearted behavior (ver 6). A 2d time, apparently, the teachers are now sent forth (ver 6), with Demetrius as their leader, who brings this letter to Gaius, commending his past conduct (ver 5) and encouraging him to persevere in it (ver6). The Presbyter adds that he has dispatched a letter to the church also (ver 9); but evidently he has little hope that it will be effectual in over- coming the headstrong opposition of Diotrephes; for he promises that he will speedily pay a personal visit to the church, when he will depose Diotrephes from his pride of place and bring him to account for his scornful ‘“‘prating’ and overbearing conduct (ver 10). So far as appears, the cause of friction was purely personal or administrative. There is no hint of heretical tendency in Diotrephes and his party. Pride of place is his sin, an inflated sense of his own importance and a violent jealousy for what he regarded as his own prerogative, which no sees identified with the autonomy of the local church. The Second Epistle—The letter is addressed to “the elect lady” (better, to “the lady Electa’’). Its tone throughout is peculiarly affectionate; there is a warmer rush of emotion, esp. in the opening verses, than is characteristic of St. John’s usual reserve. But in these verses the keynote of the Ep. is struck—truth. The writer testifies his love for his correspondent and her children “in truth” j this love is shared by all who “know the truth’ (ver 1), and it is ‘for the truth’s sake which abideth in_us, and it shall be with us for ever” (ver 2). . What follows (vs 4-9) is in effect an epitome of the Ist Ep. After declaring his joy at finding certain of her children ‘“‘walking in truth,’”’ he proceeds to expound, quite in the style of the lst Ep., what “walking in truth” is. It is to love one another (ver 5; ef 1 Jn 2 7-11); but this love is mani- fested in keeping God’s commandments (ver 6a; cf 1 Jn 5 2.3); and no less in stedfast adherence to the genuine doctrine of the Gospel (cf,1 Jn 3 23). “For many deceivers are gone forth into the world, even they that confess not that Jesus Christ cometh in the flesh” (ver 7; cf 1 Jn 4 1-3). Then follows an exhortation to stedfastness (ver 8), and a warning that whoever in the name of progress departs from this teaching “hath not God,” while he who abides in it “hath both the Father and the Son” (ver 9; cf 1 Jn 2 23.24). This-leads up to the immediately practical point, a warning to ex- tend no hospitality and show no friendliness to the false teachers (vs 10.11); and the Ep. closes with the hope of a speedy and joyful meeting “face to face’’ of the writer and his correspondent, to whom he conveys greetings from the children of her “elect sister. Whether the “‘elect lady,” or “lady Electa” of his letter is a real person or the personification of a church is a point which has been debated from ancient times and is still unsolved. The solution has been found, it is true, if we can accept the hypothesis (put forward by Zahn and Schmiedel and adopted by Findlay) that this is the letter referred to in 8 Jn ver 9. It ig urged on behalf of this supposition that the two Epp. are curiously identical in phraseology. In both the writer begins by describing his correspondent as one whom “T love in truth”; in both he uses a distinctive phrase (echdrén lian), 2 In ver 4, “TI rejoice greatly,” not found elsewhere in the NT to declare his joy at finding “thy [my] children walking in the truth”; and in both he concludes by saying that he has “many things to write,” but that, looking forward to an early interview “face to face,” he will not commit these further thoughts to “paper and ink.” It is argued that “none but a chancery clerk could have clung so closely to his epistolary formulae” in two private letters written at different periods. But the force of this argument largely vanishes when we look at the formulae in question. If a modern writer may conclude hundreds of friendly letters by subscribing himself “yours sincerely,” or something equivalent, why may not the Presbyter have commenced these two and many similar letters by assuring his correspondents that he sincerely loved them? And again, one in his official position must often have had occasion to say that he hoped soon to pay a personal visit, in view of which, writing at greater length was unnecessary. Even if the likeness in phraseology makes it probable that the two letters were written simultaneously, this by no means proves that the one was written to Gaius, the other to the church of which Gaius and Dio- trephes were members. Zahn calculates that 2 Jn would occupy 32 lines, and 3 Jn not quite 31 lines of ancient writing, and infers that the author used two pages of papyrus of the same size for both letters; but why we are to identify 2 Jn with the letter mentioned in 3 Jn because both happen to fill the same size of note paper is not quite clear. On the other hand, the difficulties m the way of this attractive hypothesis are too substantial to be set aside. The two Epp. belong to entirely different situations. Both deal with the subject of hospitality; but the one forbids hospitality to the wrong kind of guests, and says nothing about the right kind, the other enjoins hospitality to the right kind and says nothing about the wrong kind. In the one the writer shows himself alarmed about the spread of heresy, in the other, about the insubor- dination of a self-important official. Is it conceiv- able that the Presbyter should send at thesame time a letter to Gaius in which he promises that he will speedily come with a rod for Diotrephes (who had carried the church along with him), and another to the church in which that recalcitrant person was the leading spirit, in which he expresses the hope that when he comes and speaks face to face their ‘Joy may be made full’—a letter, moreover, in which the real point at issue is not once touched upon? Such a procedure is scarcely imaginable. We are still left, then, with the question What kind of entity, church or individual, is entitled ‘‘the _lady Electa’”? (See Execr Lapy, where reasons are given for preferring this tr.) The address of the letter is certainly much more suggestive of an indi- vidua] than of a church. After all that has been so persuasively argued, notably by Dr. Findlay (Fatoibenie in the Life Eternal, ch iii), from the symbolizing of the church as the Bride of Christ, it remains very hard for the present writer to sup- pose that, in the superscription of a letter and with- out any hint of symbolism, anyone could address a particular Christian community as “the elect lady” or the “Jady elect.”” On the other hand, the difficulties urged against the personal interpretation are not so grave a8 sometimes represented. The statement, “I have found certain of thy children walking in truth,” does not imply that others of them were not doing so, but emphasizes what had come under the writer’s personal observation. Nor can we pronounce the elevated and didactic love of the letter more suitable to a church than to an individual without taking into account the character, position and mutual relations of the correspondents. The person (if it was a person) addressed was evidently a Christian matron of high social standing—one able in a special degree to John, Gospel of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1720 dispense hospitality, and of wide influence, one beloved of ‘‘all them that know the truth,” whose words would be listened to and whose example would be imitated. And, in view of the ominous spreading of the leaven of Antichrist, it is not diffi- cult to suppose that the Presbyter should write to such a person in such a strain. Nor does there seem to be anything esp. odd in the fact of the children of a private family sending their respects to their aunt through the apostle John (Findlay). If he was intimate with that family, and in their immediate vicinity at the time of writing, it appears a natural thing for them to have done. Possibly Dr. Harris’ “exploded” “prehistoric countess of Huntington” is not so far astray as a modern equiva- lent of the lady Electa. Literature.—On the 2d and 3d Epp. see Comms.: Liicke, Huther, Ebrard, Holtzmann, Baumgarten, Westcott, Plummer, Bennett, Brooke: Expositions: Findlay, Fellowship in the Life Eternal; 8. Cox, The Private Letters of St. Paul and St. John; J.M. Gibbon, The Eternal Life. JOHN, GOSPEL OF: I. IntRopuctTory 1. Scope of Gospel 2. State of Opinion as to Date of Appearance, etc II. Externan Evipencr ror THE Fourts GosPrer 1. At End of 2d Cent. 2. Irenaeus—Theophilus 3. Middle of 2d Cent. 4. Ignatins, etc 5. John the Presbyter 6. Summary VII. Cuaracteristics OF THE GOSPEL: EvipeNnce 1. General Lines of Attack and Defence 2. Unwarrantahle Critical Presuppositions 3. Real Aim of Gospel—Results (1) Relation to Synoptics (2) Time Occupied in the Gospel (3) A Personal Record {4) Reminiscences of an Eyewitness {3} Reminiscence Illustrated 6) Conclusions IV. Procress anp DEVELOPMENT IN THE GosPEL 1. The Presentation of Jesus in the Gospel (1) Alleged Absence of Development in Char- acter of Jesus (2) Alleged ‘‘ Autonomy” of Jesus (3) ‘‘Inconceivability’’ of Logos-Presentation 2. The Logos-Doctrine of the Prologue 3. Growth of Faith and Development of Unhelief (1) Early Confessions 3 33 Growth of Faith in the Disciples 3) Gradual Disclosure of Messiahship: Growth of Unbelief R. Law INTERNAL LITERATURE If, Introductory.—The Fourth Gospel has a form peculiar to itself, as well as a characteristic style and attitude, which mark it as a unique document among the books of the NT. (1) There is a prologue, consisting of 1 1-18, of which something will be said later on. (2) There is a series of scenes and discourses from the life of Jesus, descriptive of Himself and His work, and marking the gradual development of faith and unbelief in His hearers and in the nation (1 19—12 50). (3) There isa more detailed account of the closing events of the Passion Week—of His farewell intercourse with His disciples (chs 13-17), of His arrest, trials, cruci- fixion, death, and burial (chs 18-19). (4) There are the resurrection, and the manifestations of the risen Lord to His disciples on the resurrection day, and on another occasion eight days after (20 1-29). This is followed by a paragraph which describes the purpose of the Gospel, and the reason why it was written (vs 30.31). (5) Finally, there is a sup- plementary ch (21), which has all the characteristic marks of the Gospel as a, whole, and which probably, therefore, proceeds from the same pen (thus Light- foot, Meyer, Alford, etc; some, as Zahn, prefer to take the ch as the work of a disciple of St. John). The concluding vs (24.25) of this ch read: ‘This is the disciple that beareth witness of these things, and 1. Scope of Gospel wrote these things: and we know that his witness is true. And there are also many other things which Jesus did,” ete. ‘(We know that his witness is true seems to be a testimony on the part of those who knew as to the identity of the disciple, and the trust- worthinessof his witness. Nor has this earliest testi- mony been discredited by the attacks made on it, and the natural meaning has been vindicated by many competent writers. The present tense, “beareth witness,” indicates that the ‘‘disciple” who wrote the Gospel was still alive when the testimony was given. As to the time of the appearance of the Johannine literature, apart from the question as to the author- ship of these writings, there is now a 2. State of growing consensus of opinion that it Opinion as_ arose at the end of the Ist cent., or at to Date of the beginning of the 2d. This is held Appearance by those who assign the authorship, not to any individual writer, but to a school at Ephesus, who partly worked up traditional material, and elaborated it into the form which the Johannine writings now have; by those also, as Spitta, who disintegrate the Gospel into a Grund- schrift and a Bearbeitung (cf his Das Johannes- Evangelium als Quelle der Geschichte Jesu, 1910). Whether the Gospel is looked on as a compilation of a school of theologians, or as the outcome of an editor who utilizes traditional material, or as the final outcome of theological evolution of certain Pauline conceptions, with few exceptions the ap- pearance of the Johannine writings is dated early in the 2d cent. One of the most distinguished of these exceptions is Schmiedel; another is the late Professor Pfleiderer. One may respect Pfleiderer in the region of philosophical inquiry, but im criti- cism he is a negligible quantity. And the writings of Schmiedel on the Johannine question are rapidly passing into the same category. Thus the appearance of the Johannine writings at the end of the 1st cent. may safely be accepted as a sound historical conclusion. Slowly the critics who assigned their appearance to the middle of the 2d cent., or later, have retraced their steps, and assign the emergence of the Johannine writings to the time mentioned. This does not, of course, settle the questions of the authorship, composition and trustworthiness of the Gospel, which must be determined on their merits, on the grounds of ex- ternal, and still more of internal, evidence, but it does clear the way for a proper discussion of them, and gives us a terminus which must set a limit to all further speculation on matters of this kind. Hf, External Evidence for the Fourth Gospel.— Only an ontline of the external evidence for the Fourth Gospel, which concerns both date and authorship, can be given in this article. Fuller information may be sought in the Intros to the Commentaries on the Gospel, by Godet, Westcott, Luthardt, Meyer; in Ezra Abbot’s The Fourth Gospel and Its Authorship; in Zahn’s Intro to the NT, III; in Sanday’s The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel; in Drummond’s The Character and Author- ship of the Fourth Gospel. All these and many others defend the Johannine authorship. On the other side, reference may be made to the author of Supernatural Religion, of which many editions have appeared. Among recent works, Moffatt’s Intro io the NT, and B. W. Bacon’s Fourth Gospel in Research and Debate, may be mentioned as denying the Johannine authorship. . The external evidence is as follows. At the end of the 2d cent., the Christian church was in pos- session of four Gospels, which were 1. AtEnd used as sacred books, read in churches of 2d Cent. in public worship, held in honor as authoritative, and treated as part of a Canon of Scripture (see GospEis). One of these 1721 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Gospel of was the Fourth Gospel, universally ascribed to the apostle John as its author. We have the evidence on this point of Irenaeus, of Tertullian, of Clement of Alexandria, a little later of Origen. Clement is witness for the belief and practice of the church in Egypt and its neighborhood; Tertullian for the church in Africa; and Irenaeus, who was brought up in Asia Minor, was a teacher at Rome, and was bishop of Lyons in Gaul, for the churches in these lands. The belief was so unquestioned, that Ire- naeus could give reasons for it which would of them- selves have convinced no one who had not already had the conviction which the reasons were meant to sustain. To discount the evidence of Irenaeus, Tertullian and Clement on the ground of the desire to find apostolic authorship for their sacred books, is not argument but mere assertion. There may have been such a tendency, but in the case of the four Gospels there is no proof that there was neces- sity for this at the end of the 2d cent. For there is evidence of the belief in the apostolic authorship of two Gospels by apostles, and of two by compan- ions of the apostles, as an existing fact in the churches long, before the end of the 2d cent. The importance of the testimony of Irenaeus is measured by the efforts which have been made to invalidate his witness. But these at- 2. Irenaeus tempts fail in the presence of his his- —tTheophi- torical position, and of the means at lus his command to ascertain the belief of the churches. There are many links of connection between Irenaeus and the apos- tolic age. There is specially his connection with Polycarp. He himself describes that relationship in his letter to Florinus, a fellow-disciple of Poly- carp, who had lapsed into Gnosticism, in which he says, ‘“‘I remember the events of that time more clearly than those of recent years. For what boys learn, growing with their mind, becomes joined with it; so that I am able to describe the very place in which the blessed Polycarp sat as he discoursed, and his goings out and comings in, and the manner of his life, and his physical appearance and his dis- courses to the people, and the accounts which he gave of his intercourse with John and the others who had seen the Lord” (Euseb., HE, V, 20: Mc- Giffert’s tr). We cannot say what was the age of Irenacus at that time, but he was of sufficient age to receive the impressions which, after many years, he recorded. Polycarp was martyred in 155 AD, and he had been a Christian for 86 years when he wag martyred. Thus there was only one link be- tween Jrenaeusand the apostolicage. Another link was constituted by his association with Pothinus, his predecessor in Lyons. Pothinus was a very old man when he was martyred, and had in his posses- sion the traditions of the church of Gaul. Thus, Trenaeus, through these and others, had the oppor- tunity of knowing the belief of the churches, and what, he records is not only his own personal testi- mony, but the universal tradition of the church. With Irenaeus should be adduced the apologist Theophilus (c 170), the earliest writer to mention St. John by name as the author of the Gospel. In prefacing a quotation from the commencement of the prologue, he says, ‘This is what we learn from the sacred writings, and from all men animated by the Spirit, amongst whom John says’”’ (Ad Autol., ii.22). Theophilus is further stated by Jerome to have composed a Harmony of the four Gospels (De Viris Itlusir., 25). From Irenaeus and Theophilus we ascend nearer to the middle of the 2d cent., and here we encounter the Diatessaron of Tatian, on which much need not be said. The Diatessaron is likewise a Har- mony of the four Gospels, and this Harmony dates not later than 170. It begins with the 1st ver of the Fourth Gospel, and ends with the last ver of the appendix to the Gospel. Tatian was a pupil of Justin Martyr, and that fact alone 8. Middle renders it probable that the ‘‘“Memoirs of 2d Cent. of the Apostles,” which Justin quotes so often, were those which his pupil afterward combined in the Diatessaron. That Justin knew the Fourth Gospel seems clear, though we cannot argue the question here. If he did, it follows that it was in existence about the year 130. But there is evidence that helps us to trace the influence of the Fourth Gospel back to the year 110. “The first clear traces of the Fourth 4. Ignatius, Gospel upon the thought and language etc of the church are found in the Epp. of Ignatius (¢ 110 AD). How unmis- takable these traces are is shown by the fact that not infrequently this dependence of Ignatius upon John has been used as an argument against the gen- uineness of the Ignatian letters’ (Zahn, Intro, III, 176). This argument may now be safely used since the Epp. have been vindicated as historical docu- ments by Lightfoot and by Zahn. If the Ignatian Epp. are saturated with the tone and spirit of the Johannine writings, that goes to show that this mode of thought and expression was prevalent in the church of the time of Ignatius. Thus at the beginning of the 2d cent., that distinctive mode of thought and speech which we call Johannine had an existence. A further line of evidence in favor of the Gospel, which need only be referred to, lies in the use made of it by the Gnostics. That the Gospel was used by the Valentinians and Basilides has been shown by Dr. Drummond (op. cit., 265-343). To estimate aright the force of the above evi- dence, it is to be remembered that, as already ob- served, there were many disciples of 5. John the the John of Ephesus, to whom the Jo- Presbyter hannine writings were ascribed, living far on in the 2d cent.—bishops like Papias and Polycarp, the “presbyters’’ so often men- tioned by Irenaeus—forming a chain connecting the time of the origin of the Gospel with the latter half of the century. Here arises the question, recently so largely canvassed, as to the identity of ‘the presbyter John” in the well-known fragment. of Papias preserved by Euseb. (H#, ITI, 39). Were there, as most, with Euseb., understand, two Johns— apostle and presbyter (cf e.g. Godet)—or was there only one? If only one, was he the son of Zebedee? On these points wide difference of opinion prevails. Harnack holds that the presbyter was not the son of Zebedee; Sanday is doubtful; Moffatt believes that the presbyter was the only John at Ephesus. Zahn and Dom J. Chapman (John the Presbyier and the Fourth Gospel, 1911) think also that there was only one John at Ephesus, but he was the son of Zebedee. It is hardly necessary to discuss the question here, for the tradition is explicit which connected the Gospel with the apostle John during the latter part of his residence in Ephesus—a resi- dence which there is no sufficient ground for dis- puting (see JoHN, THE APOSTLE). ; On a fair consideration of the external evidence, therefore, we find that it is unusually strong. It is very seldom the case that conclusive 6. Summary proof of the existence and influence of a writing can be brought so near to the time of its publication as in the case of the Fourth Gospel. The date of its publication is at the end of the 1st cent., or at the latest in the beginning of the2d. Traces of its influence are found in the Epp. of Ignatius. The lst Ep. of Jn is. quoted in the Ep. of Polycarp (ch 7). The thought and style of the Gospel had influenced Justin Martyr. It is one of the four interwoven in the Diatessaron of John, Gospel of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1722 Tatian. It was quoted, commented on, and inter- preted by the Gnostics. In truth the external evi- dence for the early date and Johannine authorship of the Fourth Gospel is as great both in extent and variety as it is for any book of the NT, and far greater than any that we possess for any work of classical antiquity. The history of the controversy on the Johannine authorship is not here entered into. Apart from the obscure sect of the Alogi (who attributed the Gospel to Cerinthus!) in the 2d cent., no voice was heard in chal- lenge of the authorship of St. John till the close of the 17th cent., and serious assault did not begin till the 19th cent. (Bretschneider, 1820, Strauss, 1835, Weisse, 1838, Baur and his school, 1844 and after, Keim, 1865, etc). The attacks were vigorously repelled by other scholars (Olshausen, Tholuck, Neander, Ebrard, Bleek, etc). Some adopted, in various forms and degrees, the hypothe- sis of an apostolic basis for the Gospel, regarded as the work of a later hand (Weizsicker, Renan, etc), From this point the controversy has proceeded with an in- creasing dogmatism on the side of the opponents of the genuineness and trustworthiness of the Gospel, but not less firmness on the part of its defenders. The present state of opinion is indicated in the text. II. Characteristics of the Gospel: Internal Evi- dence.—The external evidence for the Fourth Gos- el is criticized, but it is chiefly on 1. General internal grounds that the opposition Lines of to the Johannine authorship and his- Attack and torical trustworthiness of the Gospel Defence is based. Stress is laid on the broad contrast which admittedly exists in style, character and plan, between the Fourth Gos- pel and the Synoptics; on its supposed philosophi- cal dress (the Logos-doctrine); on alleged errors and contradictions; on the absence of progress in the narrative, etc. The defence of the Gospel is usually conducted by pointing out the different aims of the Gospel, rebutting exaggerations in the above objections, and showing that in a multitude of ways the author of the Gospel reveals his identity with the apostle John. He was, e.g., a Jew, a Palestinian Jew, one familiar with the topography of Jerus, ete, an apostle, an eyewitness, the disciple whom Jesus loved (13 23; 202; 21 7.20). The attestation in 21 24 of those who knew the author in his life- time is of the greatest weight in this connection. Instead of following these familiar lines of argument (for which see Godet, Luthardt, Westcott, Ez. Abbot, Drummond, etc, in works cited), a confir- mation is here sought on the linesof a fresh compre- hensive study. The study of the Johannine writings in general, and of the Fourth Gospel in particular, has been approached in many ways and from various points 9. Unwar- of view. One of the most common of bl these ways, in recent works, is that which raptable = assumes that here we have the product Critical of Cuitieg ihe eee on ane thats cts. ;~ closed in the other Gospels, an at these Presupposi facts have been Tnodified by the experience tions of the church, and reflect the conscious- ness of the church at the end of the 1st cent. or the beginning of the 2d. By this time, it is assumed that the’church, now mainly a gentile church, has been greatly influenced by Gr-Rom culture, that she has been reflecting on the wonder of her own history, and has so modified the original tradition as to assimi- late it to the new environment, Inthe Fourth Gospel, it ls said, we have the highest and most elahorate pres- entation of the outcome of the process. Staring with St. Paul and his influence, Professor B. W. Bacon traces for us the whole process until a school of theolo- gians at Ephesus produced the Johannine writings, and the consciousness of the church was satisfled with the completeness of the new _presentatlon_of Christianity (cf his Fourth Gospel in Research and Debate). Hellen- Istic ideas in Heb form, the facts of the Gospel so trans- formed as to be acceptable to the Hellenlstic mind—this is what scholars of this class find in the Fourth Gospel. Others again come to the Gospel with the presupposi- tlon that it is intended to present to the reader a com- plete view of the life of Jesus, that it Is intended to supplement and to correct the statements of the Synoptles and to present Christ in such a form as to meet the new needs of the church at the beginning of the 2d cent. Others find a polemical alm in the Gospel. Welzsiicker e.g. finds a strong polemic aim against the Jews. He says, ‘There are the objections raised by the Jews’ against the church after its secession has been consum- mated, and after the development of the person of its Christ has passed through its most essential stages. It Is not a controversy of the lifetime, but that of the school carried back into the history of the life’’ (Apos- tolic Age, II, 222). One would have expected that a statement so forcibly put would have been supported by some evidence; that we might have some historical evidence regarding a controversy_ between Jew and church beyond what we have in the Fourth Gospel itself. But nothing is offered by Weizsicker except the dictum that these are controversial topics carried on in the school, and that they are anachronisms as they stand. As it happens, we know from the Dial, between Justin Martyr and Trypho what were the topics discussed be- tween Jew and Christian in the middle of the 2d cent., and it is sufficient to say that these topics, as reported by Justin, mainly regarded the interpretation of the OT, and are not those which are discussed in the Fourth Gospel. . Perhaps the most surprising of_all the presupposi- tions with regard to the Fourth Gospel is that which lays great stress on the supposition that the book was largely intended to vindicate a Christian doctrine of the sacraments which flourished at the beginning of the 2d cent. According to this presupposition, the Fourth Gospel set forth a doctrine of the sacraments which laced them in a unique position as a means of salvation. hile scarcely contending that the doctrine of the sacra- ments held by the church of the 2d cent. had reached that stage of development which meets us in the mediae- val church, it is, according to this view, far on the way toward that goal afterward reached. We do not dwell on this view, for the exegesis that finds sacramentarian- ism in the Fourth Gospel is hopeless. That ceapel does not put the sacraments in the place of Christ. nally, we do not find the contention of those who affirm that the Fourth Gospel was written with a view of making the gospel of Jesus more acceptable to the Gentiles any more satisfactory. As a matter of fact, the Gospel which was most acceptable to the Gentiles was the Gospel according to Mt. It is more frequently quoted than any other. In the writings of the early church, it is quoted as often as all the other Gospels put together. The Fourth Gospel did not come into prominence in the Christian church until the rise of the Christological con- troversies in the 3d cent. When, after dwelling on these ways of approach- ing the Fourth Gospel, and reading the demands made on the Gospel by those who 3. Real Aim approach it with these presuppositions of Gospel— and demands, we turn to the Gospel Results itself, and ask regarding its aim and purpose, wefind asimpleanswer. The writer of it expressly says: “Many other signs therefore did Jesus in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book: but these are written, that ye may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing ye may have life in his name” (20 30.31). Pursuing this clue, and putting away all the presuppositions which bulk so largely in introductions, exegeses, histories of the apostolic and sub-apostolic ages, one meets with many surprises. (1) Relation to Synoptics—In relation to the Synoptics, the differences are great, but more sur- prising is the fact that the points of contact between these Gospels and the Fourth Gospel are so few. The critics to whom reference has been made are unanimous that the writer or the school who com- piled the Johannine writings was indebted to the Synoptics for almost all the facts embodied in the Fourth Gospel. Apart, however; from the Passion Week, only two points of contact are found so ob- vious that they cannot be doubted, viz. the feeding of the 5,000, and the walking on the sea (6 4-21). The healing of the child of the royal officer (4 46- 53) can scarcely be identified with the healing of the centurion’s servant (Mt, Lk); but even if the identi- fication were allowed, this is all we have in the Fourth Gospel of the events of the ministry in Galilee. There is a ministry in Galilee, but the earlier ministry in Judaea and in Galilee began before John was cast into prison (3 24), and it has no parallel in the Synoptics. In fact, the Fourth Gospel assumes the existence of the other three, and does not anew convey the knowledge which can be 1723 gathered from them. It takes its own way, makes its own selections, and sets these forth from its own point of view. It has its own principle of selection: that plainly indicated in the passage already quoted. The scenes depicted, the works done, the words spoken, and the reflections made by the writer, are all directed toward the aim of enabling the readers to believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God. In the writer’s view this would issue in their ob- taining life in His name. -(2) Time occupied in the Gospel.—Accepting this principle for our guidance, we turn to the Gospel, and the first thing that strikes the reader is the smal} amount of the real time filled up, or occupied, by the scenes described in the Gospel. We take the night of the betrayal, and the day of the crucifixion. The things done and the words spoken on that day, from one sunset to another, occupy no fewer than 7 chs of the Gospel (chs 13-19). Apart from the supplementary ch (21), there are 20 chs in the Gos- pel, containing 697 vs, and these 7 chs have 257 vs. More than one-third of the whole given to the min- istry is thus occupied with the events of one day. Again, according to Acts 1 3, there was a min- istry of the risen Lord which lasted for 40 days, and of all that happened during those days John records only what happened on the day of the resurrection, and on another day 8 days after (ch 20). The in- cidents recorded in the other Gospels fall into the background, are taken for granted, and only the signs done on these two days are recorded here. They are recorded because they are of significance for the purpose he has in hand, of inducing belief in the truth that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God. If we continue to follow the clue thus afforded, we shall be surprised at the fewness of the days on which anything was transacted. As we read the story of the Fourth Gospel, there are many indi- cations of the passing of time, and many precise statements of date. We learn from the Gospel that the ministry of Jesus probably lasted for 3 years. We gather this from the number of the feasts which He attended at Jerus. We have notes of time spent in journeys, but no account of anything that happened during them. The days on which any- thing was done or anything said are very few. We are told precisely that ‘‘six days before the passover Jesus came to Bethany, where Lazarus was” (12 1ff), and with regard to these 6 days we are told only of the supper and the anointing of the feet of Jesus by Mary, of the entry into Jerus, the visit of the Greeks, and of the impression which that visit made on Jesus. We have also the reflections of the evangelist on the unbelief of the Jews, but nothing further. We know that many other things did happen on these days, but they are not recorded in this Gospel. Apart from the two days during which Jesus dwelt in the place where he was, of which days nothing is recorded, the time occupied with the raising of Lazarus is the story of one day (ch 11). So it is also with the healing of the blind man. The healing is done one day, and the controversy regard- ing the significance of that healing is all that 1 re- corded of another day (ch 9). What is recorded in ch 10 is the story of two days. The story of the 7th and 8th chs, interrupted by the episode of the woman taken in adultery, which does not belong to the Gospel, is the story of not more than two days. The story of the feeding of the 5,000 and of the subsequent discourse (ch 6) is the story of two days. It is not necessary to enter into fuller detail. Yet the writer, as remarked, is very exact in his notes of time. He notes the days, the number of days on which anything was done, or when anything was said. We make these remarks, which will be obvious to every reader who attends to them, mainly for the purpose of showing that the Gospel on the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Gospel of face of it does not intend to, at least does not, set forth a complete account of the life and work of Jesus. It gives at the utmost an account of 20 days out of the 1,000 days of Our Lord’s ministry. This is of itself sufficient to set aside the idea of those who deal with the Fourth Gospel as if it were meant to set aside, to supplement, or to correct, the accounts in the Synoptics. Plainly it was not written with that purpose. (8) A personal record —Obviously the book pro- fesses to be reminiscences of one who had personal experience of the ministry which he describes. The personal note is in evidence all through the book. It is present even in the prologue, for in that ver in which he describes the great fact of the incarna- tion he uses the personal note, ‘““We beheld his glory” (1 14). This might be taken as the keynote of the Gospel. In all the scenes set forth in the Gospel the writer believes that in them Jesus mani- fested forth His glory and deepened the faith of His disciples. If we were to ask him, when did he behold the glory of the incarnate Word, the answer would be, in all these scenes which are described in the Gospel. If we read the Gospel from this point of view, we find that the writer had a different conception of the glory of the incarnate Word from that which his critics ascribe to him. He sees a glory of the Word in the fact that He was wearied with His journey (4 6), that He made clay of the spittle and anointed the eyes of the blind man with the clay (9 6), that He wept at the grave of Lazarus (11 35), that He groaned in the spirit and was troubled (ver 38), and that He could sorrow with a sorrow unspeakable, as He did after the interview with the Greeks (12 27). For he records al! these things, and evidently thinks them quite consistent with the glory of the incarnate Word. A fair exe- gesis does not explain these things away, but must take them as of the essence of the manifested glory of the Word. The Gospel then is professedly reminiscences of an eyewitness, of one who was personally present at all the scenes which he describes. No doubt the reminiscences often pass into reflections on the meaning and significance of what he describes. He often pauses to remark that the disciples, and he himself among them, did not understand at the time the meaning of some saying, or the significance of some deed, of Jesus (2 22; 12 16, etc). At other times we can hardly distinguish between the words of the Master and the reflections of the dis- ciple. But in other writings we often meet with the same phenomenon. In the Ep. to the Gal, e.g., Paul writes what he had said to Peter at Antioch: “Tf thou, being a Jew, livest as do the Gentiles, and not as do the Jews, how compellest thou the Gentiles to live as do the Jews?” (Gal 2 14). Shortly after, he passes into reflections on the situation, and it is impossible to ascertain where the direct speech ends and the reflections begin. So it is in the Fourth Gospel. It is impossible in many instances to say where the words of Jesus end and the reflec- tions of the writer begin. So it is, e.g., with his record of the witness of the Baptist in ch 3. The record of the Baptist’s words may end with the sentence, ‘‘“He must increase, but I must decrease” (ver 30), and the rest may be the reflections of the writer on the situation. (4) Reminiscences of an eyewitness—The phe- nomena, of the Gospel are thus, apparently at least, reminiscences of an eyewitness, with his reflections on the meaning of what he has experienced. He was present at the scenes which he describes. He was present on the night on which the Master was betrayed; he was present in the hall of the high priest; he was present at the cross, and bears testi- mony to the reality of the death of Jesus (18 15; 1724 John, Gospel of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 19 35). As we read the Gospel we note the stress he lays on ‘“‘witness.’”” The term frequently occurs (1 7.8.19; 3 11.26.33; 6 31; 12 17; 21 24, etc), and is used to set forth the verified facts of expe- rience. In these testimonies we have an unusual combination of elevated thought and minute ob- servation. At one time the evangelist soars aloft in- to a spiritual world, and moves with ease among the richest and highest elements of spiritual experience. Using common words, he yet reads into them the deepest meanings regarding man, the world, and God which have ever entered into the mind of man. Sublime mysticism and open-eyed_ practical sense meet in his wonderful writings. Above all, we are impressed with his sense of the supreme value of the historical. All his spiritual meanings have a his- torical basis. This is as apparent in the Ist Ep. as it is in the Gospel, and in the Gospel it is conspicu- ous. While his main interest is to focus the minds of his readers on Jesus, His work and His word, yet unconsciously he has written his own spiritual biography. We gradually become aware, as we read ourselves sympathetically into the spirit of the Gospel, that we are following the line of a great spiritual awakening, and are tracing the growth of faith and love in the life of the writer, until they become the overmastering tone of his whole life. On the one hand, the book is a grand objective revelation of a unique life, the story of the self- revelation of the Son_of God, of the revelation of the Father in Jesus Christ, moving onward to its consummation through the contrasted develop- ments of faith and unbelief on the part of them who received Him, and on the part of them who received Him not. On the other hand, it has a subjective unity in the heart of the writer, as it tells of how faith began, of how faith made progress, until he came to the knowledge of the Son of God. We can enter into the various crises through which he passed, through which, as they successively passed, he won the assurance which he so calmly expresses; and these supply him with the key by means of which he is able to unlock the mystery of the rela- tions of Jesus to the world. The victory of faith which he sets forth was first won iu his own soul. This also is included in the significant phrase, ‘“‘We beheld his glory” (1 14). (5) Reminiscence illustrated —The Gospel receives powerful confirmation from reflection on the nature of reminiscence generally. A law of reminiscence is that, when we recall anything, or any occurrence, we recall it in its wholeness, with all the accessories of its accompaniments. As we tell it to others, we have to make a selection of that only which is need- ful to convey our meaning. Inartistic natures do not make a selection; they pour out everything that arises in the memory (cf Dame Quickly in Shakespeare). The finer qualities of reminiscence are abundantly ‘lluetrated in the Fourth Gospel, and furnish an independent proof that it is from the pen of an eyewitness. It is possible within reason- able limits to give only a few examples. Observe first the exact notes of time in ch 1 and the special notes of character in each of the 6 disciples whom Jesus met on the first 4 days of Hisministry. Mark the peculiar graphic note that Nathanael was under the fig tree (ver 50). Pass on tonotice the 6 water- pots of stone set at Cana after the manner of the Jews’ purifying (2 6). We might refer in this con- nection to the geographical remarks frequently made in the course of the narrative, indicative of an intimate knowledge of Pal, and to the numerous allusions to Jewish laws, customs, beliefs, religious ceremonies, usually admitted now to be accurate, and illustrative of familiar knowledge on the part of the writer. Our main object, however, is to call attention to those incidental things which have no symbolical significance, but are set down because, as the main happening was recalled, these arose with it. He again sees the “lad” with the 5 barley loaves and 2 fishes (6 9); remembers that Mary sat still in the house, when the active Martha went forth to meet the Lord as He approached Bethany (11 20); recalls the appearance of Lazarus as he came forth bound hand and foot with grave-clothes (ver 44). He has a vivid picture before him as he recalls the washing of the disciples’ feet (13 1-15), and the various attitudes and remarks of the dis- ciples during the whole of that eventful night. He still sees the attitude of the soldiers who came to arrest Jesus (18 3-8), the flashing of Peter’s sword (ver 10), the share of Nicodemus in the burying of Jesus, and the kinds and weights of the spices brought by him for the embalming of the body (19 38-40). He tells of the careful folding of the linen cloths, and where they were placed in the empty tomb (20 4-8). These are only some of those vivid touches due to reminiscence which none but an eyewitness could safely make. Looking hack on the past, the evangelist recalls the various scenes and words of the Lord in their wholeness as they happened, and he chooses those living touches which bear the mark of reality to all readers. ‘ (6) Conclusions—These touches of vivid reality warrant the conclusion that the writer in this Gospel is depicting scenes in a real life, and is not drawing onhisimagination. Looking back on his own spirit- ual history, he remembered with special vividness those words and works of Christ which determined his own life, and led him on to the full assurance of faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God. The Gospel can be understood from this point of view: it does not seem to us that it can be understood from any other, without ignoring all the phenomena of the kind now indicated. When the Gospel is ap- proached from this point of view, set forth by itself, one can afford to neglect many of the elaborate discussions which have arisen regarding the possible displacement of certain chs (Spitta, etc). Much, e.g., has been made of the sudden transference of the scene from Galilee to Judaea as we pass from ch 4 to ch 5, and the equally sudden transference back to Galilee (6 1). Many suggestions have been made, but they all proceed on the supposition that the reminiscences were meant to be continuous, which it has been seen is not the case. While it is very likely that there is a sequence in the writer’s thought, yet this need not compel us to think of displacements. Taken as they are in the Gospel, the selected proofs, whether they occur in Judaea or in Galilee, in all instances indicate progress. They illustrate the manifested glory of Jesus, on the one hand, and the growth of faith and the development of unbelief on the other. This, however, opens up a separate line of objec- tion and inquiry to which attention must now be given. IV. Progress and Development in the Gospel.— It is an objection often urged against the view of the apostolic authorship of the Fourth Gospel that in it there is no progress, no development, no crisis, nothing, e.g., to correspond with the significance of the confession of St. Peter at Caesarea Philippi (Mt 16 13-17 ||).. This is held to be true alike of the character of Jesus, which, under the influence of the Logos-doctrine of the prologue, exhibits no development from first to last, and of the attitude of the disciples, whose faith in Jesus as the Christ is likewise represented as complete from the begin- ning. In reality the opposite is the case. In the course of the Gospel, as already said, the glory of the Lord is ever more completely manifested, and the disciples attain to a deeper faith, while the unbe- lief of those who reject Him becomes more fixed, 1725 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA John, Gospel of until it is absolute. nearer examination. The objection from the presentation of Jesus in the Gospel takes different forms, which it is desir- able to consider separately. 1. The Pres- (1) Alleged absence of development entation of in the character of Jesus.—It is affirmed, Jesus in the first, that there is no development in Gospel the character of Jesus in the Fourth Gospel, none of those indications such as we have in the Synopties of widening horizons, no recognition of the fact that the meaning, pur- pose and issue of His calling became clearer to Him as the days passed by. To this assertion there are two answers. The first is, that in a series of scenes from the activity of Jesus, selected for the definite purpose set forth in the Gospel, there is no need to demand a continuous history of His ministry. Selection is made precisely of those scenes which set forth His insight into human character and motive, His power of sympathetic healing, His command over Nature, and His supreme authority over man and the world. The other remark is, that even in the Fourth Gospel there are hints of a crisis in the ministry of Our Lord, during which He came to a clearer recognition of the fuller meaning of His mission (e.g. the visit of the Greeks, ch 12). I+ will be seen further, below, that it is not true in this Gospel, any more than in the Synopties, that Jesus is represented as publicly proclaiming Himself as the Messiah from the first. (2) Alleged “autonomy” of Jesus—Akin to the above is the objection to the historicity of the Gos- pel that in it Jesus is represented as always directing His own course, maintaining an attitude of aloof- ness to men, refusing to be influenced by them. This, it is held, results from the dominance of the Logos-idea in the prologue. Thereply is that there is really no essential difference between the attitude of Jesus in these respects in the Synoptics and in Jn. In all alike He maintains an attitude of author- ity. In the Synoptics He can say, “I say unto you”’ (Mt 5 22.28.32, etc). In them also He claims to be the teacher of absolute truth, the Saviour, the Ruler, the Judge, of men. In this regard there is no new claim made in the Fourth Gospel: ‘No one cometh unto the Father, but by me” (14 6). But He had said, “(Come unto me.... and I will give you rest’? (Mt 11 28). A claim to authority over men is thus common to all the Gospels. In all of them, too, in the Fourth no less than in the others, there is on the part of Jesus loyalty, sub- mission, subordination to the Father. In fact this ig more conspicuous in the Fourth Gospel than in the Synoptics: ‘The Father is greater than I” (14 28). ‘The words He speaks are the Father’s words; the works He does are the Father’s (5 19.20; 7 16. 18, ete): “This commandment received I from my Father” (10 18). In all the Gospels it is one con- sistent, gracious Figure who appears. » (3) ‘“Inconceivability” of Logos-presentation.— A further objection, which aims at showing that this Gospel could not be the work of ‘‘a primitive apos- tle,” may be noticed, partly from the eminence of him who makes it, and partly from the interest of the objection itself. In his work on The Apos- tolic Age, Weizsicker says, ‘It is a puzzle that the beloved disciple of the Gospel, he who reclined at table next to Jesus, should have come to regard and represent his whole former experience as a life with the incarnate Logos of God. It is impossible to imagine any power of faith and philosophy so great as thus to obliterate the recollection of a real hfe and to substitute for it thismarvelous pictureof a Divine being. We can understand that Paul, who had not known Jesus, who had not come into contact with the man, should have been opposed to the tradition This will appear clearly on of the eyewitnesses, the idea of the heavenly man, and that he should have substituted the Christ who was spirit for His earthly manifestation, pro- nouncing the latter to be positively a stage above which faith must rise. For a primitive apostle it is inconceivable. The question is decided here and finally here” (II, 211). It is easy to say, ‘Fora primitive apostle it is inconceivable,” yet we know that a primitive apostle believed that Jesus rose from the dead, that He was exalted a Prince and Saviour, that He was seated at the right hand of God, that He was Lord of all (Acts 2 22-36). If we grant that the primitive church believed these things, it cannot be fairly said that the further step taken in the Fourth Gospel is inconceivable. In truth, the objection of Weizsicker is not taken against the Fourth Gospel; it is equally effective against Christianity in general. If Jesus be what He is said to be in the Synoptic Gospels, and if He be what the primitive church held Him to be, the leading conception of the Fourth Gospel is credible and conceivable. If Christianity is credible, the Fourth Gospel adds nothing to the difficulty of faith; rather it gives an additional ground for a rational faith. It is proper at this point that a little more should be said on the Logos-doctrine itself, in its bearing on the presentation of Christ in this 2. The Gospel (for the philosophical and his- Logos- torical aspects of the doctrine, see Doctrine Locos). Obviously the great interest of the of the author of the reminiscences and Prologue reflections in the Fourth Gospel is in the personal life of the Master whom he had known so intimately. To him this real historical life was everything. On it he brooded, on it he meditated, and he strove to make the sig- nificance of it ever more real to himself first, and to others afterward. How shall he make the reality of that life apparent to all? What were the rela- tionships of that person to God, to man, and to the world? What Jesus really was, and what were His relations to God, to man, and to the world, John endeavors to make known in the prologue. This real person whom he had known, revered, loved, was something more than was apparent to the eyes of an ordinary observer; more even than had been apparent to His disciples. How shall this be set forth? From the Gospel it is evident that the his- torical person is first, and the attempt to set forth the meaning of the person is second. The pro- logue is an attempt to find language to set forth fitly the glory of the person. The Logos-doctrine does not descend on the historic person as a gar- ment from without; it is an endeavor to describe what John had grown to recognize as the essential meaning of the person of Jesus. It is not a specu- lative theory we have here, not an endeavor to think out a theory of the world or of God; it is an attempt to find suitable language for what the writer recognizes to be a great fact. We need not, therefore, seek an explanation of St. John’s Logos- doctrine in the speculation of Heraclitus, in the theories of theStoics, even in the eclecticism of Philo. The interests of these men are far removed from the atmosphere of the Fourth Gospel. They desired a theory of the universe; John sought to set forth the significance of a personal historical life. In the prologue he set forth that life, and he chose a word which he filled up with concreter meaning, a mean- ing which included the deepest teaching of the OT, and the highest thought of his contemporaries. The teaching of St. Paul, esp. in the epp. of the captivity, approaches very closely to that of the Fourth Gospel. Thus it 1s not a right method to bring the Logos-doctrine to the imterpretation of the Fourth Gospel, and to look at all the phenomena John, Gospel of Jonah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1726 of the Gospel as mere illustrations of that doctrine. The right method is the reverse. The Logos- doctrine has no concreteness, no living reality, taken apart from the personal life which was mani- fested to the apostle. The prologue represents what John had come to see as to the meaning of the per- sonality he had historically known. He sets it forth once for all in the prologue, and never once in the Gospel does he refer to it again. We can understand that Logos-doctrine when we look at it in the light of those manifestations recorded in the Gospel, manifestations which enabled St. John to behold His glory; we cannot understand the manifestations if we look at them merely as illus- trations of an abstract philosophical theorem. In brief, the Fourth Gospel is concrete, not abstract; it is not the evolution or the demonstration of a theory, but the attempt to set forth a concrete per- sonality, and to find fitting words to express the significance of that personality as St. John had grown to see it. As it is with the character of Jesus, so it is with the alleged absence of development in the faith of the disciples. Careful inquiry shows 3. Growth this objection also to be unfounded. of Faith and (1) Early confessions —Here again, Develop- _it is said, we see the end from the be- ment of ginning. Inch 1 Jesusistwice greeted Unbelief as the Messiah (vs 41.45), and twice described as the Son of God (vs 34. 49). The Baptist at this early stage points to Him as “‘the Lamb of God, that taketh away the sin of the world’ (ver 29). Reference is made to the case of Nicodemus (3 1 ff), to the Samaritans (4 41f), and other incidents of the same kind, with the view of proving that at this early stage of the ministry of Our Lord such confessions are unlikely, and even impossible. It is to be noticed, however, that the confessions in these cases are represented as the outcome of special manifestations on the part of Jesus to the persons who make them. And the manifestations are such as to justify the psychologi- cal possibility of the confession. It isso in the case of Nathanael. Nor is the objection to the testimony of John the Baptist of a kind which admits of no answer. For the Baptist, according to the Synop- ties, had found his own credentials in Isa 40. There he found himself and his mission, and described himself, as we find it in the Fourth Gospel, “I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness, Make straight the way of the Lord, as said Isaiah the prophet” (1 238; cf Mt 33; Mk 12.3). We find also that when John ‘‘heard in the prison the works of the Christ,’ and “sent by his disciples and said unto him, Art thou he that cometh, or look we for another?” (Mt 11 2), the answer of Jesus was 2 reference to a passage in Isa 61. Ac- cording to Jesus these were the true signs of the Messianic kingdom. Is there any reason why we should not say that, as John found his own ereden- tials in Isa 40, he would also have found the charac- ter and signs of the Coming One in the description of the suffering servantin ch 63? If hedid so, what more simple than that he should describe the Com- ing One as the Lamb of God, that taketh away thesin of the world? In His answer to John, Jesus simply asks him to read farther on in that prophesy which had already meant so much for him. (2) Growth of faith in the disciples —Apart from what may be made of these early confessions, it may fairly be said that there are many signs of a growth of faith on the part of the disciples. Carry- ing with us the fact that each of these confessions had its ground in a particular manifestation of the glory of Christ, we go on to passages which prove how imperfect was the faith of the disciples. It is to be remembered also that John has only one word to describe all the phases of faith, from the slight- est impression up to whole-hearted conviction and thorough surrender. We may refer to the careful and exhaustive treatment of the meanings of the word “‘believing”’ by E. A. Abbott in his work, Johannine Vocabulary. In the Fourth Gospel the vb. is always used, and never the noun. As the word is used, itdenotes theimpression made, whether that impression is slight and transient, or deep and abiding. Successive steps of acceptance are seen as the disciples advance to complete and absolute faith. As we read the Gospel, we perceive that Jesus did test and try the faith of His disciples, and made His deeds and His words both tests of faith, and a means for its growth. As the result of the words on the bread of life, we find that many of His dis- ciples said, ‘“This is a hard saying; who can hear it?”’ (6 60), and on account of the difficulty of His words, “Many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him” (ver 66). On His appeal to those who did not go away it is found that the difficulty became really an opportunity to them for a larger faith (vs 68.69). The incidents and events of the night of the betrayal, and the conversations on that night, prove how incomplete were the faith and confidence of the disciples; how far they were from a full understanding of the Master’s purpose. Nor is it until after the resurrection, and the glad- ness of seeing their risen Lord in the upper room, that faith obtained a complete victory, and attained to full possession of itself. (3) Gradual disclosure of Messiahship: Growth of unbelief —On the other side, there is as mani- festly an evolution of unbelief from the passing doubt of the moment on to the complete disbelief in Jesus, and utter rejection of Him. It is only fair here to the Gospel to observe that the confessions to which we have already referred are on the part of individuals who came into special relationship with Jesus. Such is the case with regard to Nathanael, Nicodemus, the woman of Samaria and the Samaritan people, and the writer places the reader in that close relationship so that he who reads may believe. But such close relation- ship to Jesus is only the lot of a few in this Gospel. It is not true, as already remarked, that in this Gospel Jesus is represented as definitely proclaim- ing Himself as the Messiah. There is something of the same reserve here as there is in the Synoptics. He did not assert His claim; He left it to be inferred. His brethren hint that He ought to put His claims really to the test (7 3f). An account of the doubts and speculations regarding Him is given in ch 7. The people hesitate, and inquire, and speculate, Is He a good man, or a deceiver? (ver 12) Had He really a mission from God? (vs 14 ff)—all of which goes to prove that only certain individuals had such intimate knowledge of Him as to lead to acceptance. In ch 10 we read, ‘‘And it was the feast of the dedi- cation at Jerus: it was winter; and Jesus was walk- ing in the temple in Solomon’s porch. The Jews therefore came round about him, and said unto him, How long dost thou hold us in suspense? If thou art the Christ, tell us plainly’? (10 22-24). “Tt is very clear,” as Dr. Sanday says, “that no sharply defined issue was set before the people. They are left to draw their own conclusions; and they draw them as well as they can by the help of such criteria as they have. But there is no ent- weder .... oder... .—either Messiah or not Messiah—peremptorily propounded by Jesus Him- self’ (The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel, 164). The sum of the matter as regards the development of unbelief is given by the evangelist in the words: ‘Though he had done so many signs before them, yet they believed not on him” (12 37). On the 1727 other hand, the culmination of faith is seen in the word of the Lord to Thomas: “Because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed” (20 29). Lireratury.—Besides Comms. and other works mentioned in the art., with valuable arts. on the Gospel in Dicts. and Encs, the following may be consulted: M. Dods, comm. on ‘Fourth ae “in Expositor's Gr Test.: Jiilicher, Einleitung in das NT* (1906, ET); E. A. Abbott, Johannine Vocabulary (1905), and Johannine Grammar (1906); H. J. Holtzmann, Evangelium, Briefe und Offen- barung des Johannes, hesorgt von W. Bauer (1908); Essays on Some Bib. Questions of the Day b embers of the University of Cambridge, edited by be. Swete (1909), Essay IX, ‘'The Theology of the Fourth Gos- el,’ by W. H. Inge, and Essay X, ‘‘The Hlstorical alue of the Fourth Gospel,”’ Be . E. Brooke; Schmie- del, The Johannine Writings (HT, 1908); J. Armitage Robinson, The Historical Character of St. John’s Gospel (1908); Askwith, The Historical Value of the Fourth Gospel (1910); Ezra Abbot, External Evidence of the Fourth Gospel, edited by J. H. Thayer (1891); Lowrie, The Doctrine of St. John (1899). James IvERACH JOHN MARK. See Mars, Jonn. JOHN, THE REVELATION OF. See Reve- LATION OF JOHN. JOIADA, joi’a-da OTN, yoyddha', “Jeh knows”; cf JEHOIADA): (1) A repairer of the Jerus walls (Neh 3 6); AV “Jehoiada.” (2) Son of Eliashib the high priest (Neh 12 10. 11.22; 13 28). JOIAKIM, joi’a-kim (°p7", yoyakim, “Jeh raises up’; cf JeHo1aKim; Joxim): Son of Jeshua and Said of Eliashib, the high priest (Neh 12 10. 12.26). JOIARLB, joi’a-rib (A917, y5yaribh, “Jeh pleads” or “contends”; cf JEHOIARIB): (1) A “teacher” of Ezra’s time (Ezr 8 16). (2) A Judahite (Neh 11 5). (3) In Neh 11 10; 12 6.19=JeHoIaRiB (q.v.). JOIN, join: Of the NT words, koild@, lit. ‘glue,” “weld together,” and its compounds, designate the closest form of personal union, as in Lk 16 15; 1 Cor 6 16; Eph 6 31. In the words of institution of marriage, suzetignumi is used (Mt 19 6; Mk 10 9, lit. “yoke together”; cf Gen 2 24). JOKDEAM, jok’dé-am (O77P", yok*dh*‘am): An unidentified city of Judah, named with Maon, Car- mel and Ziph (Josh 15 56). It probably lay to the 8. of Hebron. JOKIM, jo’kim (O°p™, ydkim, “Jeh raises up”; of Jenoraxim; Joraxim): A Judahite, de- scendant of Shelah (1 Ch 4 22). JOKMEAM, jok’mé-am (PAP), yokm*am): A town in Mt. Ephraim assigned to the Kohathite Levites (1 Ch 6 68), named along with Gezer and Beth-horon. Its place is taken by Kibzaim in Josh 21 22 (in LXX here the name is omitted). It is mentioned again in 1 K 4 12 (AV wrongly “Jok- neam”’), where it seems to indicate some position to the E. of Ephraim. So far no identification is possible. JOKNEAM, jok’né-am (OF}P7, yokn‘am): A royal city of the Canaanites taken by Joshua and described as “in Carmel”: (Josh 12 22), in the ter- ritory of Zebulun, and allotted to the Merarite Levites (21 34). The border of Zebulun “reached to the brook that is before Jokneam” (19 11). In 1K 4 12 the name appears in AV where, with RV, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Nee of we should read “Jokmeam.” Onom places it 6 Rom miles from Lejio (Lejjiin) on the way to Pto- lemais (Acre). This points to Tell Kaiman, a striking mound on the eastern slope of Mt. Carmel. To the E. of it runs the “torrent bed” of the Kishon. It stands about 300 ft. above the valley to the N. of it, and the sides are steep. It is crowned by the ruins of an 18th-cent. fortress. A little lower down are the remains of a small chapel. There are fine springs at the foot (PEFM, I, 69f). In Jth_7 3 it appears as “Cyamon” (Kvayév, Kuamén). It is the “Mons Cain” of the Middle Ages. ‘In the Sam Book of Jgs it is noticed as the scene of a conflict between the Hebrews and the Giants; and Joshua is said to have been shut up here in magic walls of brass, till on sending a dove to the Heb king of Gilead, he was rescued” (Conder, HDB, s.v.). ; W. Ewina JOKSHAN, jok’shan (]W}7, yokshén, meaning unknown): Son of Abraham and Keturah (Gen 25 2.3 || 1 Ch 1 32). Tuch suggested that yokshan =yoktaén (Gen 10 25-29); see HDB, s.v.; Skinner, Gen, 350. JOKTAN, jok’tan (JEP?, yokfdn, meaning un- known): “Son” of Eber, and ‘father’ of 13 tribes (Gen 10 25.26.29; 1 Ch 1 19.20.28). JOKTHEEL, jok’thé-el, jok’thél ORM? , yoke- the’ él): (1) A city in the Shephelah of Judah named be- pubs Mizpeh and Lachish (Josh 15 38); unidenti- ed. (2) A city in Edom formerly called Sela, taken by Amaziah after the battle in the Valley of Salt, and by him called Joktheel (2 K 14 7). See Szua. JONA, jo’na. JONADAB, jon’a-dab. See JEHoNADAB. See Jonan; Jonas. JONAH, jd’na (19M, yondh, “dove”; "Iwvas, Tonds): (1) According to 2 K 14 25, Jonah, the son of Amittai, of Gath-hepher, a prophet and servant of Jeh, predicted the restoration of the land of -Israel to its ancient boundaries through the efforts of Jeroboam II, The prophet lived and labored either in the early part of the reign of Jeroboam (790— 750 BC), or during the preceding generation. He may with great probability be placed at 800-780 BC. His early ministry must have made him popular in Israel; for he prophesied of victory and expansion of territory. His native village of Gath- aes was located in the territory of Zebulun (Josh 19 13). (2) According to the book bearing his name, Jonah the son of Amittai received a command to preach to Nineveh; but he fled in the opposite direction to escape from the task of proclaiming Jeh’s message to the great heathen city; was arrested by a storm, and at his own request was hurled into the sea, where he was swallowed by a great fish, remaining alive in the belly of the fish for three days. When on his release from the body of the fish the command to go to Nineveh was renewed, J. obeyed and announced the overthrow of the wicked city. When the men of Nineveh repented at the preaching of the prophet, God repented of the evil He had threatened to bring upon them. J. was grieved that the oppressing city should be spared, and waited in the vicinity to see what would be the final outcome. An intense patriot, J. wished for the destruction of tbe people that threatened to swallow up Israel. He thought that Jeh was too merciful to the heathen oppressors. By the lesson Jonah, Book of Jonas THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1728 of the gourd he was taught the value of the heathen in the sight of Jeh. It is the fashion now in scholarly circles to treat the Book of Jonah as fiction. The story is said to be an allegory or a parable or a symbolic narrative. Why then did the author fasten upon a true and worthy prophet of Jeh the stigma of rebellion and. narrowness? On the theory that the narrative is an allegory, J. Kennedy well says that “the man who wrote it was guilty of a gratuitous insult to the memory of a prophet, and could not have been in- spired by the prophet’s Master thus to dishonor a faithful servant.” (3) Our Lord referred on two different occasions to the sign of Jonah the prophet (Mt 12 38-41; Lk 11 29-32; Mt 16 4). He speaks of J.’3 ex- perience in the belly of the fish as parallel with His own approaching entombment for three days, and cites the repentance of the Ninevites as a rebuke to the unbelieving men of his own generation. Our Lord thus speaks oul of the physical miracle of the preservation of Jonah in the body of the fish and of the moral miracle of the repentance of the Nine- vites, and without the slightest hint that He re- garded the story as an allegory. JoHN RicHarp SAMPEY JONAH, THE BOOK OF: This little roll of four short chapters has given rise to almost as much discussion and difference of opinion as the first four chapters of Gen. It would be presumptuous to think that one could, in a brief article, speak the final word on the questions in debate. I. Contents of the Book.—The story is too well known to need retelling. Moreover, it would be difficult to give the events in fewer words than the author employs in his classic narrative. One event grows out of another, so that the interest of the reader never flags. Whenthe call came to Jonah to preach in Nineveh, hefled in the opposite direction, hoping thus to escape from his unpleasant task. He was 1. Jonah afraid that the merciful God would for- Disobe- give the oppressing heathen city, if it dient, 1: should repent at his preaching. Jonah 1-3 was a narrow-minded patriot, who feared that Assyria would oneday swal- low up his own littlenation; and so he wished to do nothing that might lead to the preservation of wicked Nineveh. Jonah was willing to prophesy to Israel; he at first flatly refused to become a foreign missionary. The vessel in which the prophet had taken pas- sage was arrested by a great storm. The heathen sailors inferred that some god must be 2. Jonah angry with some person on board, and Punished, cast lots to discover the culprit. When 1; 4-16 the lot fell upon Jonah, he made a 3 complete confession, and bravely sug- gested that they cast him overboard. The heathen mariners rowed desperately to get back to land, but made no progress against the storm. They then prayed Jeh not to bring innocent blood upon them, and cast Jonah into thesea. As the storm prompt- ly subsided, the heathen sailors offered a sacrifice to Jeh and made vows. In this part of the story the mariners give an example of the capacity of the Gentiles to perform noble deeds and to offer accept- able worship to Jeh. Jeh prepared a great fish to swallow Jonah and to bear him in his body for three days and nights. Surprised to find himsclf aliveand con- 3. Jonah scious in the body of the fish, the Miraculous- prophet prayed to his God. Already ly Pre- y faith he speaks of his danger as a served, past experience. The God who had 1:17—2:10 saved him from drowning in the depths of the sea will yet permit him once more to worship with loud thanksgiving. At the command of Jeh the fish vomits out Jonah upon the dry land. The almost inevitable grotesqueness of this part of the story is one of the strongest arguments against, the view that the Book of Jon is literal history and not a work of the imagination. Upon the renewal of the command to go to Nine- veh, Jonah obeyed, and marching through the streets of the great city, he cried, “Yet 4. Jonah’s forty days, and Nineveh shall be over- Ministry in thrown!” His message was_ so brief Nineveh, that he may well havespoken it in good 3:1-4 Assyrian. If the story of his deliverance from the sea preceded him, or was made known through the prophet himself, the effect of the prophetic message was thereby greatly heightened. The men of Nineveh repented at the preaching of Jonah, the entire city uniting in fasting and prayer. So great was the anxiety of 5. The the people that even the lower animals Ninevites were clothed in sackeloth. The men Repent, of Nineveh turned from deeds of 3: 6-10 violence (‘‘their evil way’) to seek the forgiveness of an angry God. Jeh deeided to spare the city. Jonah breaks out into loud and bitter complaint when he learns that Nineveh is to be spared. He decides to encamp near the city to see 6. A Nar- what will become of it. He hopes it row Prophet may yet be overthrown. Through a versus the gourd vine Jeh teaches the prophet a Merciful great lesson. If such a mean and God, 4:1-11 perishable plant could come to have real value in the eyes of the sullen prophet, what estimate ought to be put on the lives of the thousands of innocent children and helpless cattle in the great city of Nineveh? ‘These were dearer to the God of heaven than Jonah’s protect- ing vine could possibly be to him. Il. The Aim of the Book.—The main purpose of the writer was to enlarge the sympathies of Israel and lead the chosen people to undertake the great, missionary task of proclaiming the truth to the heathen world. Other lessons may be learned from the subordinate parts of the narrative, but this is the central truth of the Book of Jon. Kent well expresses the author’s main message: ‘In his wonderful picture of God’s love for all mankind, and of the Divine readiness to pardon and to save even the ignorant heathen, if they but repent according to their light, he has anticipated the teaching of the parable of the Prodigal Son, and laid the foundation for some of the broadest faith and the noblest missionary aetivity of the present generation” (Sermons, Epistles, etc, 420). Il, Is the Book History?—Most of the early in- terpreters so understood it, and some excellent scholars still hold this view. If Jesus 1. What thought of the story as history and so Did Our —_— taught, that fact alone would settle Lord the question for the devout believer. Teach? On two, possibly three, different occa- sions He referred to Jonah (Mt 12 38- 41; 164; Lk 11 29-32). It is significant that Jesus brought the two great miracles of the Book of Jon into relation with Himself and His preaching. As Jonah was three days and three nights in the body of the fish, so should the Son of Man be three days in the heart of the earth. Themen of Nineveh repented at the preaching of Jonah, while the con- temporaries of Jesus for the most part rejected His message. It is the fashion now among advanced critics to treat Mt 12 40 as an addition to the words of Jesus, though there is no manuscript evidence in favor of regarding the verse as an inter- polation. G. A. Smith, among recent scholars, holds the view that Jesus did not mean to teach the historicity of Jonah’s experience in the fish. 1729 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jona Book of 5 lt matters not whether that illustration be drawn from the realms of fact or of poetry” (BTP, II, 508). In a footnote Dr. Smith says: ‘‘Suppose we tell slothful people that theirs will be the fate of the man who buried his talent, is this to commit us to the bellef that the personages of Christ's parables actually existed? Or take the homl- letic use of Shakespeare’s dramas—as Macbeth dld,’ or ‘as Hamlet said.” Does it commit us to the historical reality of Macheth or Hamlet? Any preacher amon us would resent being bound by such aninference. An if we resent this for ourselves, how chary we should he about seeking to bind Our Lord by it.”’ Notwithstanding Principal Smith’s skilful pres- entation of his case, we still think that Our Lord regarded the miracles of the fish and the repentance of the Ninevites as actual events. Orelli puts the matter judiciously: ‘It is not, indeed, proved with eonclusive necessity that, if the resurrection of Jesus was a physical fact, Jonah’s abode in the fish’s belly must also be just as historical. On this point also the saying, ‘A greater than Jonah is here,’ holds good. But, on the other hand, how arbitrary it is to assert, with Reuss, that Jesus regarded Jonah’s history as a parable! in it a sign, a powerful! evidence of the same Divine power which showed itself also in His dying in order to live again and triumph in the world. Whoever, therefore, feels the religious greatness of the book, and accepts as authoritative the attitude taken to its historical import by the Son of God Himself, will be led to accept a great act of the God who brings down to Hades and brings up again, as an actual experience of Jonah in his flight from his Lord” (The Twelve Minor Prophets, 172, 3). Most modern critical scholars since Kleinert (1868) and Bloch (1875) have regarded the Book of Jon as a work of the imagination. 2. Modern Some prefer to call it an allegory, Critical others a parable, others a prose poem, Views others a didactic story, others a mid- rash, others a symbolical book. Keil, Pusey, Delitzsch, Orelli, J. Kennedy and others have contended for the historical character of the narrative. A few treat it as a legend containing a kernel of fact. Cheyne and a few other scholars assert that in the symbolic narrative are imbedded mythical clements. The trend of critical opinion, even in evangelical circles, has of late been toward the symbolical interpretation. Radical critics boldly set aside the teaching of Jesus as erroneous, while the more evangelical take refuge either in the doctrine of the Kenosis (Phil 2 5-8), or in the prin- ciple of accommodation. The last explanation might commend itself to the devout student, viz. that Jesus did not think it worth while to correct the views of his contemporaries, had Our Lord not spoken more than once of the sign of Jonah, and in such detail as to indicate His acceptance of the en- tire narrative with its two great miracles. IV. Authorship and Date.—The old view that Jonah was the author is still held by some scholars, though most moderns place the book in the late exilic or post-exilic times. A few Aram.words occur in the _ Heb text. The question in debate is whether the language of Tere in the days of Jeroboam IT had taken over words from the Aramaic. There had certainly been a century of close political and com- mercial contact between Israel and the Aramaeans of Damaseus, so that it would not be surprising to meet with Aram. words in a prophet of Samaria. Hosea, in the generation following Jonah, betrays little evidence of Aram. influence in his style and vocabulary. Of course, the personal equation is a factor that ought not to be overlooked. If the author was a Judaean, we should probably have to think of the post-exilic period, when Aram. began to displace Heb as the vernacular of the Jews. The Book of Jon is anonymous, and we really do not know who the author was or when he lived. The “Christ is using an illustratlon: On the contrary, Jesus saw - view that Jonah wrote the story of his own disobe- dience and his debate with the merciful God has not been made wholly untenable. V. The Unity of the Book.—Nachtigal (1799) contended that there were three different authors of widely different periods. Kleinert (1868) held that two parallel narratives had been woven together in chs 3 and 4. Kaufmann Kohler (1879) contended that there were a considerable number of glosses and interpolations besides some transpositions of material. W. Béhme, in 1887, advanced the most radical theory of the composition of the roll. He partitioned the story among two authors, and two redactors or eupElementeess A few additional glosses were charged to later hands. Even radical critics treat Béhme’s theory as one of the curiosities of criticism. Winckler (AOF, II, 260 ff) tried to improve the story by a few transpositions. Hans Schmidt (1905) subjects the roll of Jonah to a searching criticism, and concludes that a good many changes have been made from religious motives. Budde follows Winckler and Schmidt both in trans- posing and in omitting some material. Sievers (1905) and Erbt (1907) tried to make of the Book of Jon a poem; but they do not agree as to the meter. Sievers regards the roll as a unit, while Erbt con- tends for two main sources besides the prayer in ch 2. Bewer, in ICC (1912), is far more conser- vative in both textual and literary criticism, recog- nizing but few glossesin our present text and arguing for the unity of the story apart from the insertion of the psin ch 2. Nearly all recent critics assign Jonah’s prayer to a writer other than the author of the narrative about Jonah, but opinions vary widely as to the manner in which the psalm found its way into the Book of Jon. Bewer holds that it was probably put on the margin by a reader and afterward crept into the text, the copyist inserting it after ver 2, though it would more naturally follow ver11. Bewerremarks: ‘The literary connections with various post-exilic pss argue for a post-exilic date of the ps. But how early or how late in the post-exilic period it belongs we cannot tell. The Heb is pure and no Aram. influence is apparent.” It is evident, then, that the presence or absence of Aram. influence does not alone settle the question of the date of the document. Geography and the personal equation may be more important than the question of date. Bewer recognizes the fact that the ps in Jon is not a mere cento of quotations from the Pss. “The phrases it has in common with other pss,’ writes Professor Bewer, ‘were the common property of the religious language of the author’s day” (p. 24). Those who still believe that David wrote many of the pss find no difficulty in believing that a prophet of 780 BC could have drawn upon his knowledge of the Psalter in a prayer of thanks- giving to Jeh. ; LireratureE.—Among comms. covering the twelve Minor Prophets, see esp. Pusey (1861), Keil (E'T, 1880), von Orelli (ET, 1893), Wellhausen (1898), G. A. Smith (1898). Among speclal comms. on Jon, consult Klei- nert, in Lange (ET, 1875); Perowne, in Cambridge Bible (1897); Bewerin ICC (1912). See also C. H. H. uae, Biblical Essays (1886); H.C.'Trumbull, ‘‘ Jonah in Nineveh,” JBL, XI (1892); J. Kennedy, Book of Jon Cleo) Konig in HDB; Cheynein EB. For more elaborate bibliography see Bewer in ICC, 25-27. Joun Ricuarp SAMPEY JONAM, jd/nam (Tovép, Iéndm, WH; ‘lovdy, Téndn, TR; AV Jonan): An ancestor of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy (3 30). JONAN, jo’nan. JONAS, jd’nas (’Iwvds, Jonds; AV Jonan): (1) Son of Eliasib (1 Esd 9 1). (2) Corresponds in 1 Esd 9 23 to “Eliezer’’ in Ezr 10 23. See Jonam. Jonas Joppa JONAS, jd’nas (IM, ydnah, or 21", yohdnan; *Twva, Tond): (1) The name given in Mt 12 39-41; 16 4; Lk 11 29-32 AV to the OT prophet Jonah (RV renders “Jonah’’). See Jonan. (2) (Iwdvys, Todnés): The name given in Jn 21 15.16 AV to the father of the apostle Simon Peter. Nothing further is known of him, except the differ- ent forms of hisname. In Jn 1 42 AV he is called Jona (cf also Mt 1617 AV). In Jn 1 42; 21 15. 16 RV he is called John, with the marginal note “Gr Joanes.”” In Mt 16 17 RV Simon Peter is called Simon Bar-Jonah. Jonas may be a contraction for Joanes (Keim). It has also been suggested that the father of Simon may have had a double name, Jona-Johannes (cf F. H. Chase in HDB, art. “John, father of Simon Peter”). C. M. Kerr JONATH ELEM REHOKIM, jo’nath @lem ré-ho’kim ("PM poy ni, ydnath ’élem rehokim) (Ps 56, title): ‘The silent dove of the far ones” (i.e. either of far-off lands, or among aliens), or ‘“The dove of the distant terebinths,” in either case indi- eating the tune to the melody of which the ps was to be sung. See Psatms; Sona. JONATHAN, jon’a-than GOV, yhanathan, JR, yonathan, ‘‘Jeh has given’; "lavaddv, Jdna- than; cf JEHONATHAN): (1) (Heb yhGnathan): The young ‘‘Levite” of Jgs 17, 18 referred to by name in 18 30, where he is called “the son of Gershom, the son of Moses,” and where AV has ‘‘Manasseh”’ for Moses, following the MT in which the letter nan of Manasseh is “suspended.” Rashi states the reason thus: ‘‘Because of the honor of Moses was the nan written so as to alter thename."’ The orlginal word was Moses, but it was thought undesirable that a descendant of his should have anything to do with jmages; and soJ. wasmade to have affinity (metaphorically) with Manasseh. Seo GB, Intro, 335-38. J. was a Levitical Judahite of Beth-lehem-judah, who came to the house of Micah, in the hill country of Ephraim, and hired himself as a priest in Micah’s sanctuary (17 1-13). The Danites sent 5 men north to spy for new territory, and on their way the spies came to the house of Micah, where they found J. and consulted the oracle through him (18 1-5). Having received a favorable answer, they set out and came to Laish, and on their return south they advised that au expedition be sent thither (18 6-10). Their clansmen accordingly sent out a band of warriors who on their way passed by Micah’s house. The spies informed their comrades of the ephod and teraphim and images there, and they seized them, inducing J. at the same time to accompany them as their priest (vs 11-20). At Laish he founded a priesthood which was thus de- scended from Moses (ver 30). It has been held that there are two sources in the narra- tive in Jgs 17, 18 (see Moore, Jgs, 365-72). The section is important because of the light it throws on life and re- ligion in early Israel. Tho ''Levites'' were not all of one tribe (see Moore, op. cit., 383-84); there were priests who claimed descent from Moses as well as Aaronite priests; and images were common in early Heb worship (cf Gen 81 30ff; Jes 8 27; 1 8 19 13). (2) Son of King Saul. See separate art. (3) (Heb y*héndihan, ydndthan, 2 8 16 27.36; 17 17.20; 1K 1 42.43): Son of Abiathar the priest. He acted with Ahimaaz as courier to inform David of events at Jerus during Absalom’s revolt. It was he who also brought to Adonijah the news of Solomon’s accession. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA (3) The prophet Jonah (2 Esd 1 39; Tob 14 (4) (Heb yhdnathan, 2 § 21 21 || 1 Ch 20 7): s 1730 Son of Shimei or Shimea, David’s brother; he is said to be the slayer of Goliath. See JeHonapaB (1). (5) (2 8 28 32, Heb yhonathan = 1 Ch 11 34, Heb yanathan): One of David’s mighty men. See JASHEN. (6) (Heb yandihén, 1 Ch 2 32.33): A Jerah- meelite. (7) (Heb y*hondthan, and so 1 Ch 27 25 AV): Son of Uzziah, and one of David’s treasurers. (8) (Heb ychénathan, 1 Ch 27 32): A dadh of David, RV “uncle,” RVm “brother’s son”; if he was David’s nephew, he will be the same as (4) above. He ‘‘was a counsellor” to David, and “‘a man of understanding, and a scribe.” (9) (Heb yonathan, Kar 8 6; 1 Esd 8 32): Father of Ebed, a returned exile. (10) (Heb yénathan, Ezr 10 15; 1 Esd 9 14): One who either supported (RV) or opposed (RVm, AV) Ezra in the matter of foreign marriages; see JAHZEIAH. ; (11) (Heb yondthan, Neh 12 11): A priest, de- scendant of Jeshua (Joshua) =‘‘Johanan” (12 22.23); see JEHOHANAN, (3). : (12) (Heb yénathan, Neh 12 14): A priest. (13) (Heb yénaithan, Neh 12 35): A priest, father of Zechariah. (14) (Heb yhandthan, Jer 37 15.20; 38 26): A scribe in whose house Jeremiah was imprisoned. (15) (Heb yonathan, Jer 40 8): Son of Kareah; a Judahite captain who joined Gedaliah after the fall of Jerus. (16) (‘IwvdOns, Tondihés, 1 Macc 2 5; 9-18; and "Ivabdv, Inathin, 2 Mace 8 22; Swete reads Jond- thés): The Maccabee surnamed Apphus in 1 Macc 2 5, son of Mattathias. (17) Son of Absalom (1 Macc 13 11). He was sent by Simon the Maccabee to capture Joppa (cf 11 70, where there is mentioned a Mattathias, son of Absalom). (18) A priest who led in prayer at the first sacri- fice after the return from exile (2 Macc 1 23). , Davip Francis Roperts JONATHAN (jFIWD, yhonathan; also 727, yonathan, “Jeh has given”; *Iwvaddv, lonaihdn): The eldest son of Saul, the first king 1. Three of Israel, of the tribe of Benjamin. Periods The life of J., as far as we are told : about him, falls naturally into 3 periods. _ (1) First period—He comes on the scene as the right hand and lieutenant of his father in his early struggles to beat off the hostile tribes, esp. the Am~ monites (1 S 11), who beset the territory of Israel on all sides. As soon as Saul had gained his first decisive victory, the people rallied to him in great numbers, so that he was able to count upon 3,000 men whenever they took the field. These were divided into two small armies, Saul retaining 2,000 and making Michmash his headquarters, the rest being stationed at Gibeah under J., some 5 miles distant as the crow flies. J. thus commanded the base, while his father led the fighting force. This position of comparative inactivity does not appear to have been much to the taste of J. Midway between the two camps was a Phili outpost at Geba, facing Michmash across the pass of that name, a valley with steep sides, now the Wddi Suweinit. Saul does not seem to have felt himself strong enough to commence hostilities against the Philis, and took means to increase the forces at his disposal. The Philis no sooner heard that the Israclites had cast off their yoke (1 8 13 3b: for “Let the Hebrews hear,” read ‘The Hebrews have revolted,” after LXX), than they came out in great 1731 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jonas Joppa numbers (13 5). They seem to have compelled Saul to evacuate Michmash, which they occupied, Saul falling back on Gibeah (13 16) and Gilgal with a greatly reduced following (13 3.4a seems to be a summary anticipation, in Heb style, of the events detailed in ch 14). In spite of this, J., accompanied only by his armor-bearer, surprised the Phili out- post at Geba (14 5, “Gibeah” should be “Geba”), which was killed to a man. This feat precipitated a general engagement, in which the Israelites, whose only weapons appear to have been their farming implements (13 20), Saul and J. alone being armed with iron swords and spears, routed their enemies. The completeness of the victory was impaired by the superstitious action of Saul in refusing to allow the people to eat until the day was over (14 24). As this order was unwittingly broken by J., Saul wished to have him executed; but this the people refused to allow, as they clearly recognized that the credit of the victory was due to the energetic action of J. in striking before the enemy had time to con- centrate. (In the Heb text there is some confusion _ between Gibeah and Geba; cf 10 5m and 13 3.) (2) Second period.—The 2d period of the life of J.is that of his friendship for David. The narrative is too well known to need recapitulating, and the simple tale would only be spoiled by telling it in other words. J.’s devotion to David was such that he not only took his part against his father, Saul (chs 18, 19), but was willing to surrender to him his undoubted claim to become Saul’s successor (ch 20). Their last meeting took place in the “desert” of Ziph, to the 8S. of Hebron, some time ae had been driven into outlawry (23 (3) Third period.—The 3d phase of J.’s life is that of the exile of David, when Saul was directing his energies to combat what he no doubt considered the rebellion of the son of Jesse. During this civil war, if that can be called war in which one of the two sides refuses to take the offensive against the other, J. remained entirely passive. He could not take part in proceedings which were directed against his friend whom he believed to be destined to occupy the place which he himself should in the ordinary course of events have filled. We therefore hear no more of J. until the encroachments of the Philis once more compelled Saul to leave the pursuit of the lesser enemy in order to defend himself against the greater. Saul’s last campaign against the Philis was short and decisive: it ended in the defeat of Gilboa and the death of himself and his sons. The men of Jabesh-gilead, out of gratitude for Saul’s rescue of their town at the beginning of his reign, crossed over to Beth-shan, on the walls of which town the Philis had hung in chains the bodies of Saul and Jonathan, and took them down under cover of darkness and carried them to Jabesh. There they burned the bodies after the manner of the primitive inhabitants of the land, and buried the bones. : ‘ If we may judge from the little which has been handed down to us concerning him, J. must have been one of the finest spirits that ever 2. His lived. His character ie as das as ous Character knowledge goes, nearly perfect. e was athletic and brave (1 8 14 13; 28 1 22.23). He could keep his plans secret when secrecy was necessary in order to carry them to a successful issne (14 1), and could decide on what course of action to follow and act upon it on the instant. His attack upon the Phili garrison at Geba (or Gibeah, if we adopt the reading of the LXX and Tg of 13 3; cf 10 5) was delivered at the right moment, and was as wise as it was daring. Tf he had a fault, from a military point of view, 1t 3. Military Qualities ae have been an inability to follow up an advan- tage. The pursuit of the Philis on the occasion referred to ended with nightfall. In this respect, however, he perhaps cannot be censured with justice, as he never had an entirely free hand. J.’s independence and capacity for acting on his own responsibility were combined with devotion to his father. While holding his own 4. Filial opinion and taking his own course, Piety he conformed as far as possible to his father’s views and _ wishes. While convinced of the high deserts of David, he sought by all means to mitigate Saul’s hatred toward him, and up to @ certain point he succeeded (19 6). Filial duty could not have been more severely tested than was that of J., but his conduct toward both his father and his friend is above criticism. Only on one occasion did his anger get the better of him (20 34) under gross provocation, Saul having im- pugned the honor of J.’s mother (20 30 LXX) Ahinoam (14 50), and attempted his life. The estrangement was momentary; Saul and Jonathan were undivided in life and in death (2 § 1 23 to be so read). But it is as the befriender of David that J. will always be remembered. He is the type of the very perfect friend, as well as of the chival- 5. Friend- rous knight, for all time. His devotion ship for to David was altogether human; had David it been dictated by a superstitious belief in David’s destiny as the future ruler of his people (23 17), that belief would have been shared by Saul, which was not the case (20 31). In disinterestedness and willingness to efface his own claims and give up his own titles the conduct of J. is unsurpassed, and presents a pleasing con- trast to some of the characters with whom we meet in the Bible. In this respect he resembles ‘Alt, the cousin and son-in-law of Muhammad, who was the bravest of the brave, save when fighting in his own cause, and who had no ambition to fill the highest posts. So J. preferred to serve rather than to com- mand (1 8 23 17). J. and David stand for the highest ideal of Heb friendship, as do Damon and Pythias in Gr lit. We may be sure that J. won the affection of the people. His squire was ready to follow him any- where (14 7). David’s devotion to 6. Inspired him seems to have heen sincere, Affection althongh it unfortunately coincided with his own self-interest. J. appears to have inspired as great an affection as he himself felt (1 S 20 41; 2 8 1 26). His quarrel with his father was largely due to the solicitude of the latter for his son’s interests (1 S 18 29; 20 31). Jonathan’s sons were, in common with his brother’s, killed in the wars. One alone—Merib- baal (Mephibosheth)—survived. J.’s 7. His De- posterity through him lasted several scendants generations. A table of them is given inl Ch 8 33 ff || 9 40 ff (cf2 8 9 12). They were famous soldiers and were, like their an- cestors, distinguished in the use of the bow (1 Ch 8 40). THomas HunteR WEIR JONATHAS, jon’a-thas (Swete reads *Ia@dv, Taihdn, in B; Na@év, Nathén, in &): The Lat form of the common name ‘‘Jonathan” (Tob 5 13). See JaTHAN. It is sometimes represented as Nathan. JOPPA, jop’a (127, yaphd, NID? yapha’ ; *léwwrn, Iépp2): In Josh 19 46 AV called “Japho,” a city in the territory allotted to Dan; but j. Ancient there is nothing to show that in pre- Notices exilic times it ever passed into Israel- itish hands. “The gate of Joppa” is mentioned in the Am Tab (214, 32f; cf 178, 20), Joppa Jordan THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1782 as guarded by an Egyp officer for Amenhotep IV. It was conquered by Thothmes III, and old Egyp records speak of the excellence of its gardens and fruit trees. Sennacherib claims to have taken J. after a siege (KB, 2, 93). To J., the Chronicler tells us, the cedars of Lebanon were brought in floats for transportation to Jerus by the workmen of the king of Tyre (2 Ch 2 16). The 2. Biblical city does not appear in the history as References Philistine, so we may, perhaps, infer that it was held by the Phoenicians, the great seamen of those days. It was donbtless a Phoen ship that Jonah found here, bound for Traditional House of Simon the Tanner. Tarshish, when he fied from the presence of the Lord (Jon 18). In Ezra’s time, again, cedars were bronght here for the buildings in Jeras (Ear 3 7). Having been brought by messengers from Lydda to J., Peter here raised the dead Dorcas to life (Acts 9 36f). On the roof of Simon’s house by the sea, the famous vision was vouchsafed to this apostle, from which he learned that the gospel was designed. for Jew and Gentile alike (Acts 10 1 ff; 11 5 ff). The men of J., having treacherously drowned some 200 Jews, Judas Maccabaens fell upon the town “and set the haven on fire by 3. History night, and burned the boats, and put from Maec- to the sword those that had fled cabean thither” (2 Macc 12 3 ff). Jonathan Times took the city, in which Apollonins had placed a garrison (1 Macc 11 47 ff). It was not easy to hold, and some years later it was captured again by Simon, who garri- soned the place, completed the harbor and raised the fortifications (1 Macc 12 86f; 13 11; 14 5-34). It is recorded as part of Simon’s glory that he took it “for a haven, and made it an entrance for the isles of the sea,” the Jews thus possessing for the first time a seaport through which commerce Through the Rocks at Joppa. might be fully developed. It was taken by Pompcy and joined to the province of Syria (Ant, XIV, iv, 4; BJ, I, vii, 7). Caesar restored it to the Jews under Hyrcanus (Ant, XIV, x, 6). It was among the cities given by Antony to Cleopatra (XV, iv, 1). Caesar added it to the kingdom of Herod (vii. 3; BJ, I, xx, 3), and at his death it passed to Arche- lans (Ant, XVII, xi, 4; BJ, Il, vi, 3). At his deposition it was attached to the Rom province. The inhabitants were now zealous Jews, and in the Rom wars it suffered heavily. After a massacre by Cestius Gallus, in which 8,400 of the people perished, it was left desolate. Thns it became a resort of the enemies of Rome, who turned pirates, and preyed upon the shipping in the neighboring waters. The place was promptly captured and destroyed by Vespasian. The people took to their boats, but a terrific storm burst upon them, dashing their frail craft to pieces on the rocks, so that vast numbers perished (BJ, III, ix, 2-4). At a later time it was the seat of a bishopric. During the Crusades it had a checkered history, being taken, now by the Christians, now by the Moslems. It was captured by the French under Kleber in 1799. It was fortified by the English, and afterward ex- tended by the Turks (Baedeker, Pal, 130). The modern Yafa is built on a rocky mound 116 ft, high, at the edge of the sea. A reef of rocks runs parallel ? to the shore a short distance out. It may 4, Descrip- be rounded in calm weather by lighter tion vessels, and it affords a certain amount of rotection. There is a gap in the reef through which the boats pass that meet the steamers calling here. In time of storm the passage is dangerous. On one of these rocks Perseus is said to have rescued the chained Andromeda from the dragon. Y4é/fé is a pros- perons town, profiting much by the annual streams of pilgrims who pass through it on their way to visit the holy places in Pal. A good trade is done with Egypt, Syria and Constantinople. Soap, sesame, wheat and oranges are the chief exports. Thefamous gardens and orange groves of Jaffa form one of the main sights of interest. The Christians and the Moslems have rival traditions _as to the site of the house of Simon the tanner. The remains of the house of Tabitha are also pointed out. From Jaffa to Jerus the first railway in Pal was built. : W. Ewine JORAH, jo’ra (TIM, ydrah, meaning uncertain, perhaps “‘harvest-born”’): A family which returned with Zerubbabel (Ezr 2 18)=‘‘Hariph” of Neh 7 24=“‘Arsiphurith” (AV “Arzephurith’”) of 1 Esd 5 16. JORAL, jo’ra-i on, yoray, “whom Jeh teaches”’): A Gadite chief, but possibly the name of a clan (1 Ch 6 13). JORAM, jo’ram (D7, ydrdm, “Jeh is exalted”; cf JEHORAM): (1) Son of Toi (or Ton, according to LXX, B, and 1 Ch 18 9.10), sent by his father to greet David (28 8 10)=‘Hadoram” (1 Ch 18 9.10) aform pre ferred by commentators in 2 S also. (2) Same as Jehoram, king of Judah (2 K 8 21- 24; 11 2; 1 Ch 311; Mt 1 8 [‘Iwpdu, Tardm)). (3) Same as Jehoram, king of Northern Israel (2 K 8 29; ef 2 K 9 15 RVm). (4) Unform 8, ydram): A Levite (1 Ch 26 25). (5) (Iwpéu, Iorém, 1 Esd 1 9) = “Jozabad” (2 Ch 36 9); see JozaBan (4). JORDAN, jér’dan (JI, yardén, “flowing down- ward”; ‘Iop8avns, Iordénés): The Jordan river proper begins at the junction of four streams (the Bareighit, the Hdsbany, the Leddan, and the Bdnias), in the upper part of the plain of Lake Haleh. The Bar- erghit receives its supply of water from the hills on the W., which separate the valley from the river Litany, and is the least important of the four. The Hasbdny is the longest of the four (40 miles), issuing from a great fountain at the western foot of Mt. Hermon near Hasbeiya, 1,700 ft. above the sea, 1. Source 1733 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joppa Jordan and descends 1,500 ft. in its course to the plain. The Leddan is the largest of the four streams, issuing in several fountains at the foot of the mound Tell el-kddy (Dan, or Laish) at an elevation of 505 ft. above the sea. The Bénias issues from a cele- brated fountain near the town of Bantas, which is identified as the Caesarea Philippi associated with the transfiguration. The ancient name was Paneas, originating from a grotto consecrated to the god Pan. At this place Herod erected a temple of white marble dedicated to Augustus Caesar. This is probably the Baal-gad of Josh 11 17 and 12 7. Its altitude is 1,100 ft. above tide, and the stream falls about 600 ft. in the 5 miles of its course to the head of the Jordan. The valley of Lake Hdleh, through which the Jordan wends its way, is about 20 miles long and 5 miles wide, bordered on either side 2. Lake by hills and mountains attaining ele- Hfleh vations of 3,000 ft. After flowing 4 or 5 miles through a fertile plain, the Jordan enters a morass of marshy land which nearly fills the valley, with the exception of 1 or 2 miles between it and the base of the mountains upon the western side, This morass is almost impenetrable by reason of bushes and papyrus reeds, which in places also render navigation of the channel diffi- cult even with a canoe. Lake Hdaleh, into which the river here expands, is but 7 ft. above tide, and is slowly contracting its size by reason of the accu- mulation of the decaying vegetation of the surround- ing morass, and of the sediment brought in by the river and three tributary mountain torrents. Its continued existence is evidence of the limited period through which present conditions have been main- tained. It will not. be many thousand years before it will be entirely filled and the morass be changed into a fertile plain. When the spies visited the region, the lake must have been much larger than it ig now. At the southern end of Lake Hdleh, the valley narrows up to a width of a few hundred yards, and the river begins its descent into levels below the Mediterranean. The river is here only about 60 ft. broad, and in less than 9 miles descends 689 ft. through a narrow rocky gorge, where it meets the delta which it has deposited at the head of the Sea of Galilee, and slowly winds its way to meet its waters. Throughout this delta the river is easily fordable during a great part of the year. The Sea of Galilee occupies an expansion of the Jordan valley 12 miles long and from 3 to 6 miles wide. The hills, reaching, in general, 8. Sea of 1,200 or 1,500 ft. above the lake, come Galilee down close to its margin on every side. On the E. and S. they are mainly of volcanic origin, and to some extent of the same character on the N.W. side above Tiberias. In the time of Christ the mouth of the river may have been a half-mile or more farther up the delta than now. ‘As all the sediment of the upper Jordan settles in the vicinity of the delta near Capernaum, a stream of pellucid water issues from 4, The the southern end of the lake, at the Yarmiik modern town of Kerak. Before it reaches the Dead Sea, however, it becomes overloaded with sediment, From Kerak the opening of the valley is grand in the extreme. A great plain on the E. stretches to the hills of De- capolis, and to the S., as far as the eye can reach, through the Ghér which descends to the Dead Sea, bordered by mountain walls on either side. Four or five miles below, it is joinéd on the E. by the Yarmak, the ancient Hieromax, the largest of all its tributaries. The débris brought down by this stream has formed a fertile delta terrace 3 or 4 miles in diameter, which now, as in ancient times, is an attractive place for herdsmen and agriculturists. The valley of the Yarmdk now furnishes a natural grade for the Acre and Damascus Railroad, as it did for the caravan routes of early times. The town of Gadara lies upon an elevation just 8. of the Yarmtk and 4 or 5 miles E. of the Jordan. i Carta Z Jordan Leaving the Sea of Galilee. Ten miles below the lake, the river is joined on the W. by Wady el-Bireh, which descends from the vicinity of Nazareth, between Mt. Tabor and Endor, and furnishes a natural entrance from the Jordan to Central Galilee. An aqueduct here still furnishes water for the upper terrace of the Ghér. Wady el-Arab, with a small perennial stream, comes in here also from the E. Twenty miles below Lake Galilee the river is joined by the important Wddy el-Jélad, which de- scends through the valley of Jezreel 5..El-Ghiér between Mt. Gilboa and the range of the Little Hermon (the hill Moreh of Jgs 71). This valley leads up from the Jordan to the val- ley of Esdraelon and thence to Nazareth, and fur- nished the usual route for Jews going from Jerus to Nazareth when they wished to avoid the Samaritans. This route naturally takes one past BeisGn (Beth- shean), where the bodies of Saul and Jonathan were exposed by the Philis, and past Shunem and Nain. There is a marked expansion of the Ghér opposite Beisan, constituting an important agricultural dis- trict. The town of Pella, to which the Christians fled at the time of the destruction of Jerus, lies upon the E. side of the Ghér; while Jabesh-gilead, where the bodies of Saul and Jonathan were finally taken by their friends and cremated, is a little farther up the slope of Gilead. Twenty miles farther down, the Ghér, on the E., is joined by Wady Zerka (the brook Jabbok), the second largest tributary, sepa- rating Ammon from Gilead, its upper tributaries flowing past Ammon, Mizpeh, and Ramoth-gilead. It was down this valley that Jacob descended to Succoth. A few miles below, the Wady Farah, whose head is at Sychar between Mts. Ebal and Gerizim, de- scends from the W., furnishing the natural route for Jacob’s entrance to the promised land. At Damieh (probably the Adam of Josh 3 16), the Ghér is narrowed up by the projection, from the W., of the mountain ridge terminating in Kurn Sartabeh, which rises abruptly to a height of 2,000 ft. above the river. The section of the Ghér between Damich and the Dead Sea is of a pretty uniform width of 10 to 12 miles and is of a much more uniform level than the upper portions, but its fertility is interfered with by the lack of water and the difficulty of irrigation. From the vicinity of Jericho, an old Rom road follows up the Wady Nawatimeh, which furnished Joshua a natural line of approach to Ai, while through the Wady el-Kelt ig opened the natural road to Jerus. Both Ai and the Mount of Olives are visible from this point of the Ghér. Jordan Jordan Valley THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1734 In a direct line it is only 70 miles from Lake Gali- lee to the Dead Sea, and this is the total length of the lower plain (the Zér); but so numer- 6. The Zér ous are the windings of the river across the flood plaim from one bluff to the other that the length of the river is fully 200 miles. Col. Lynch reported the occurrence of 27 rapids, which wholly interrupted navigation, and many others which rendered it difficult. The major part of the descent below Lake Galilee takes place before reach- ing Damieh, 1,140 ft. below the Mediterranean. While the bluffs of the GAér, upon either side of the Zor, are nearly continuous and uniform below Damieh, above this point they are much dissected Notwithstanding the great number of fords where it is possible to cross at low water, those which were so related to the lines of travel as to be of much avail were few. Beginning near the mouth of the J. and proceeding northward, there was a ford at el- Henu leading directly from Jericho to the high- lands N.E. of the Dead Sea. Two or three miles farther to the N. is the ford of the pilgrims, hest known of all, at the mouth of Wady Kelt. A few miles farther up the river on the road leading from Jericho to es-Sali, near the mouth of the Wddy Nimrin, there is now a bridge where the dependence was formerly upon the ford. Just below the mouth of the Wady Zerka (Jabbok) is the ford of Damieh, Tue River JorpAN. by the erosion of tributary streams. Still, nearly everywhere, an extended view brings to light the original uniform level of the sedimentary de- posits formed when the valley was filled with ee to a height of 650 ft. (see AraBan; Drap BA). The river itself averages about 100 ft. in width when confined strictly within its channel, but in the early spring months the flood plain of the Zér is completely overflowed, bringing into its thickets a great amount of driftwood which increases the difficulty of penetrating it, and temporarily drives out ferocious animals to infest the neighboring country. According to Conder, there are no less than 60 fording-places between Lake Galilee and the Dead Sea. For the most part it will be seen 7. The that these occur at rapids, or over bars Fords of deposited by the streams which de- Jordan scend from one side or the other, as for example, below the mouths of the Yarmik, Jabbok, Jalad and Kelt. These fords are, however, impassable during the high water of the winter and spring months. Until the occupation by the Romans, no bridges were built; but they and their successors erected them at various places, notably below the mouth of the Yarmdk, and the Jabbok, and nearly opposite Jericho. where the road from Shechem comes down to the river. A bridge was at one time built over the river at this point; but owing to a change in the course of the stream this is now over a dry water-course. The next important crossing-place is at the opening of the valley of Jezreel coming in from the W. where probably the Bethabara of the NT should he located. Upon this ford a number of caravan routes from E. to W. converge. The next impor- tant crossing-place is at el-Mujamia, 2 or 3 miles below the mouth of the Yarmik. Here, also, there was a Rom bridge. There are also some traces of an ancient bridge remaining just below the exit of the river from Lake Galilee, where there was a ford of special importance to the people residing on the shores of this lake who could not afford to cross in boats. Between Lake Galilee and Lake Hileh, an easy ford leads acrosa the delta of the stream a little above its junction with the lake; while 2 or 3 miles below Lake Hdleh is found ‘‘the bridge of Jacob’s daughters’? on the line of one of the principal routes between Damascus and Galilee. Above Lake Hdaleh the various tributaries are easily crossed at several places, though a bridge is required to cross the Bareighit near its mouth, aud another on the Hdshany on the main road from Caesarea Philippi to Sidon, at el-Ghagar. Grorce Freperick WRIGHT ‘ 1735 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jordan Jordan Valley JORDAN VALLEY: As more fully detailed else- The surface of this old lake bed has also been where (see ARABAH; DEap SEa; GEOLOGY oF PaLEstTINE), the Jordan valley in its 1. Physical lower portion occupies a remarkable Peculiarities depression in the earth’s surface, reach- ing its greatest depth in the Dead Sea, the surface of which is 1,300 ft., the bottom 2,600 ft. below tide level, the portion of the basin below the level of the sea being about 100 miles in length and from 10 to 15 miles in breadth at base, and from two to three times that distance between the bor- dering summits of the mountains and plateaus on either side. In the early prehistoric period, cor- responding with the Glacial epoch, this depression was filled with water to a height of 1,400 ft. (see references above) which gradually disappeared by evaporation as present climatic conditions came on. At an elevation of approximately 650 ft. above the Dead Sea, very extensive sedimentary deposits were made, which, while appearing only in frag- ments along the shores of the Dead Sea, are con- tinuous over the bottom of the valley (the so-called Ghér), farther N. These deposits are from 100 to 900 ft. thick, consisting of material which was brought down into the valley by the tributary mountain streams descending from each side, while the water stood at this higher level. Naturally these deposits slope gradually from the sides of the valley toward the center, the coarser material of the deposits being nearer the sides, and the amount of sediment being much increased opposite the mouths of the larger streams. The deposit was at first continuous over the entire Ghér, or valley, but has since been much dissected by the J. river and its tributaries. The J. itself has eroded a channel through the soft sediment, 100 ft. more or less deep, from Lake Galilee to the Dead Sea, a distance in a straight line of about 70 miles. At first this channel was narrow, but it has been constantly enlarged by the stream as it has meandered from side to side, undercutting the banks so that they cave into the river and are washed down to fill up the Dead Sea, a process which is esp. familiar to residents upon the banks of the Mississippi and Missouri rivers. This narrow gorge is called the Zér, and will hereafter be referred to under thisname. The Zér at present averages about 3 mile wide, the most of which is occupied by a flood plain extending from the banks of the river to the foot of the sedimentary bluffs on either side. This flood plain is so overgrown with brush and reeds that it is practically impenetrable, except by wild beasts, which, according to Scriptural references, have infested it from earliest times, among which may be mentioned the lion, the tiger, the wild boar. During the spring months, when the snows are melting from Mt. Hermon and cloud- bursts are sending sudden torrents of water down the river courses from the plateau of Gilead and the mountains of Samaria, the J. “overflows all its banks,” i.e. covers this flood plain and drives out the beasts to infest the neighborhood for a short time. much dissected by the tributary streams which come in from either side, they having cut channels across the Ghér down to a depth corresponding to that of the Zér. As a consequence the roads leading up the valley find it necessary to hug the base of the mountains on either side to avoid the abrupt de- scent into the channels of the tributary streams, which are deepest near their mouths. Another natural consequence of these physical peculiarities is that agriculture cannot be carried on except as water to irrigate the level surfaces of the Ghér is carried out from the higher levels of the perennial streams. There are many remains of such aque- ducts for irrigation constructed in early times. These are now almost all in ruins and unused. Merrill, however, estimates that 200 sq. miles of the J. valley, over which the surface is as level as a prairie, and as free from stones, could be irrigated at the present time and made as fruitful as the valley of the Nile. But: from time immemorial settled agriculture in the Ghér has been rendered precarious by the incursions of the nomadic tribes, who periodi- cally come down from the desert regions on the E. Two descriptions (the first from my own journal) of the general views obtained of the J. valley from adjoining elevated points will give 2. Two De- vividness to our conceptions of this scriptions remarkable depression. “Tt was the middle of Decemher when, after wading all day across the southern flanks of Mt. Hermon, through snow knee-deep for our horses, we descended helow the clouds and the snow to the brink of the eastern mountain wall overlooking the upper valley ofthe J. It was a sight ever to be remembered, with the glistering peak of Mt. Hermon to ourright, and the jagged walls of the horders of Naphtali stretching across the horizon on the W., only a few miles away, while hetween and at our feet were the green fields of the upper J. valley, through which ran the silver thread of the river, broadening out into the expanded waters of Lake Merom. Over the plain could dimly he seen the black tents of the Arabs, and the husbandmen plowing the fields for an early harvest. No wonder the spies were impressed with the attractiveness and fertility of the region."’ This of the upper J. valley. Dr. Merrill gives the following description of the view of the lower J. valley from the summit of Kurn_Séar- tabeh, March 23: “Jebel esh Sheikh [Mt. Hermon] was covered with snow, and_so_was the Lehanon range farther to the W. and N. Lake Merom and the vol- canic peaks on the plain to the E. of it and S. of Her- mon were distinctly seen, likewise the Sea of Galilee, the hills ahout Safed, the hills W. of Tiherias and the slope from their summit, which inclines toward Mt. Tahor; also Gamala and Gadara, all the range of Jebel ‘Ajlan or hills of Gilead, Kulat er Rubad, Jebel Metsera and Jebel Osha, the mountains of Moah, and the Dead Sea. But the mere naming of different points that can he seen gives no adequate idea of the extent and magnifi- cence of the prospect which one enjoys from the top of this strange landmark. Hills to the W. obstruct the view in that direction, and to the E. nothing can be seen Berane the highest part of the Moah and Gilead ranges, but it is the north-and-south sweep which makes the prospect a glorious one. No language can picture correctly the J. valley, the winding stream, the jungles on its hanks, the strange Ghér with its white, ragged sides, the vast plain of the valley, throngh and in the middle of which the lower Ghér [the Zér] is sunk, the dense green oases formed here and there hy some moun- tain stream, and the still, lifeless sea, as bright and motionless as molten lead, lying far to the S., ending the great valley and touching the mountains on either side! This is an outline merely, but I cannot summon to my aid words which will describe it more accurately. The J. valley or Ghér, in front of Sartabeh, is about 8 miles wide, and looks like a vast plain. The lower Ghér [Zér] is the ragged channel cut down along the middle of the large one. This distinction of the upper and lower Ghér is hy no means so strikingly defined ahove the mouth of the Zerka as it is helow that point, and all the way thence to the Dead Sea.” Considered in detail the valley may be divided, as Conder suggests, into 8 sections. “First the portion between Banias and the Haleh, where it is some 5 miles broad, with steep cliffs some 2,000 ft. high on either side and a broad marsh between. Secondly, from the Hdleh to the Sea of Galilee, Jordan Valley Joseph THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1736 where the stream runs close to the eastern hills, and about 4 miles from the base of those on the W., which rise toward the high Safed 3. Division mountains, more than 3,500 ft. above into Eight the lake. Thirdly, for 13 miles from Sections the S. end of the Sea of Galilee to the neighborhood of Beisdén. Here the valley is only 13 miles broad W. of the river, and about 3 on the E., the steep cliffs of the plateau of Kaukab el Hawa on the W. reaching an altitude of 1,800 ft. above the stream. “South of Beisdn is the 4th district, with a plain W. of J., 12 miles long and 6 miles broad, the line of hills on the E. being straight, and the foot of the mountains on this side about 2 miles from the river. In the neighborhood of Beisdn, the cross-section of the plain shows 3 levels: that of the shelf on which Beisdn stands, about 300 ft. below sea-level; that. of the Ghér itself, some 400 ft. lower, reached by an almost precipitous descent; and that of the Zér, or narrow trench, from a half to a quarter of a mile wide, and about 150 ft. lower still. The higher shelf extends westward to the foot of Gilboa; it dies away on the §., but on the N. it gradually rises into the plateau of Kaukab and to the western table-land above the sea of Galilee, 1,800 ft. above J. “After leaving the Beisdn plain, the river passes through a narrow valley 12 miles long and 2 or 3 miles wide, with a raised table-land to the W., having a level averaging about 500 ft. above the sea. The Beisdén plain is full of springs of fresh water, some of which are thermal, but a large cur- rent of salt, warm water flows down Wddy Maleh, at the northern extremity of this 5th district. “Tn the 6th district, the Damieh region, the valley again opens to a width of about 3 miles on the W., and 5 on the E. of J. The great block of the Kurn Sdrtibeh bere stands out like a bastion, on the W., 2,400 ft. above the river. Passing this mountain, the 7th district is entered—a broad valley extend- ing from near Fusdil to ‘Oshel Ghirdb, N.of Jericho. In this region the Ghér itself is 5 miles broad, W. of the river, and rather more on the E. The lower trench or Zér is also wider here and more distinctly separated from the Ghér. A curious geographical feature of this region was also discovered by the Survey party. The great affluents of the Fér’ah and ‘Aujeh do not flow straight to J., but turn S. about a mile W. of it, and each runs, for about 6 miles, nearly parallel with the river; thus the mouth of the Fér’ah is actually to be found just where that of the next valley is shown on most maps. The 8th and last district is that of the plain of Jericho, which, with the corresponding basin (Ghér- es-Seisebin) E. of J., measures over 8 miles N. and S., and more than 14 across, with J. about in the middle. The Zér is here about a mile wide, and some 200 ft. below the broad plain of the Ghér.” Owing to its depression below sea-level the climate of the lower J. valley is even more than tropical. In the summer months the thermome- 4. Climate: ter scarcely falls below 100° F., even Fauna and in the night; but during the winter Flora months, though the days are hot, the thermometer frequently goes down to 40° in the night time. The fauna of this part of the J. valley and about the Dead Sea is said by Tristram (SWP, “Fauna and Flora’’) to be identical with that now existing in Ethiopia. Of the mammalia characteristic of this general region, 34 are Ethiopian and 16 Indian, though there is now no possible connection with either Ethiopia or India. The fish of the J. show close affinity to many species of the Nile and of the lakes and rivers of tropical Africa. Many species of birds, also, now confined to the lower basin and the Dead Sea, are related to Ethiopian and Indian species. The flora is equally interesting. Out of 162 species of plants found at the S.W. corner of the Dead Sea, 135 species are African in their affinity. In the marshes of Lake Hiuleh, many acres are covered with the papyrus plant, which became extinct in Egypt long ago, and 1s now found in Africa only in the Upper Nile beyond the 7th degree of N. lat. The most common trees and plants of the J. valley are the castor-oil plant and the oleander. flourishing esp. about Jericho, several varieties of the acacia tree, the caper plant, the Dead Sea apple (Solanum Sodomaewm) the oser tree of the Arabs, tamarisks, Agnus castt (a flowering bam- boo), Balanites Aegyptiaca (supposed to be the balm of Gilead), Populus Euphratica (a plant found all over Central Asia but not W. of the J.), and many tropical plants, among which may be mentioned Zygophyllum coccineum, Boerhavia,I ndigofera, several Astragali, Cassias, Gymnocarpum, and Nitraria. Georcr FREDERICK WRIGHT JORIBUS, jor'i-bus (’Iép.Bos, Jéribos; AV Joribas): (1) In1 Esd 8 44, called ‘“Jarib’’ in Ezr 8 16. (2) In1 Esd 9 19, called “‘Jarib’ in Ezr 10 18. JORIM, jo’rim (’‘Twpelp, Ldreim, from Dam, yhoram, D1, yordm): An ancestor of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy (Lk 3 29). JORKEAM, jér’ké-am (BYP, york*am; AV Jorkoam): This is probably to be taken as the name of a town, the ‘father’ or “founder” of which was Raham (1 Ch 2 44). It may be identical with “Jokdeam” of Josh 15 56. JOSABAD, jos’a-bad. See Jozapan. JOSABDUS, jé-sab’dus (’IwcaB86s, Tdsabdés, 1 Esd 8 63; probably identical with ’IwtaBdsos, Idzabddos, in 9 23): The same as Jozabad of Ezr 8 33; 10 23 (qv.). _ JOSAPHAT, jos’a-fat (‘Iecaddr, Tdsaphdt, AV in Mt 1 8 for JeHosHapHatT [q.v.]): A king of Judah, mentioned in Mt’s genealogy of Christ. JOSAPHIAS, jos-a-fi’as ("Iwcaptas, Idsaphias, 1 Esd 8 36): Called “Josephiah”’ in Ezr 8 10. _ JOSE, j6’sé (Iwo4, Tdsé): AV form for “Jesus” (CIyoots, Tésois) in Lk’s genealogy (8 29), RV Gr. JOSECH, jo’sek (Iwohx, Toséch, WH; Ioohd, Toséph, TR; AV Joseph): An ancestor of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy (8 26). JOSEDECH, jos’é-dek, JOSEDEK, jos’édek (‘lwoedéx, Jdsedék): Father of Jeshua (1 Esd 65 5). In Hag 11 RV, the relationship is described as “Joshua the son of JrnozapaK [q.v.], the high priest.” JOSEPH, jo’zef (20%, yoséph; ’lartd, [aséph): (1) The 11th son of Jacob and 1st of Rachel (see separate art.). (2) The father of Igal of Issachar, 1. Inthe one of the 12 spies (Nu 18 7), OT (3) A son of Asaph (1 Ch 25 2.9). ; (4) A man of the sons of Bani, who had married a foreign wife (Ezr 10 42). (5) A priest of the family of Shebaniah in the days of Joiakim (Neh 12 14). 1737 (1) Son of Zacharias, defeated by Gorgias c 164 BC (1 Macc 6 18.56.60). (2) Called a brother of Judas Macca- 2. In the baeus in 2 Macc 8 22, probably by Apoc mistake for John. (8) Great-grandfather of Judith (Jth 8 1). (1) The husband of Mary, the mother of Jesus (see special art.). 3. In the oe Jesus according to AV (Lk 8 24.26. 30); the name of two according to RV, which reads ‘‘Josech” in Lk 3 26. (4) A Jew of Arimathaea in whose sepulcher Jesus was buried (Mt 27 57, etc; see art.). (5) One of the brethren of Jesus, according to RV (Mt 13 55, AV “Joses”). AV and RV pee have ‘Joses’ in Mt 27 56; Mk 6 3; 15 (6) Joseph Barsabbas (Acts 1 23; see art.). (7) Joseph, surnamed Barnabas (Acts 4 36, AV “Joses’’; see BARNABAS). S. F. Hunter JOSEPH, jé’zef (AOD, yoséph, “He will add”; LXX 'Iworf, [dséph. The narrative [Gen 30 23. 24] indicates not so much a double etymology as the course of Rachel’s thoughts. The use of FOX, *dsaph, “He takes away,” suggested to her mind by its form in the future, 101", ydséph, “He will add,” “And she called his name J., saying, Jeh add to me another son’’): I. Tus Joszra Story, a Literary Question 1. An Independent Original or an Adaptation? 2. A Monograph or a Compilation ? (1) An Analytical Theory Resolving It into a Mere Compilation (2) A Narrative Full of Gems (a) The Brothers Presented; Joseph Weep- ing (b) The Scene between the Brothers of Joseph and the Steward (c) Judah's Speech (d) Revelation of Joseph to His Brethren (3) The Argument from Chronology Supporting It as a Monograph . Il. Tue Story or Joseru, a BroGrRaPay 1. A Bedouin Prince in Canaan 2. A Bedouin Slave in Egypt 3. The Bedouin Slave Becomes Again the Bedouin Prince 4, The Prime Minister 5. The Patriarch LitERATURE The eleventh son of Jacob. The Bib. narra- tive concerning J. presents two subjects for con- sideration, the J. story, a literary question, and the story of J., a biography. It is of the first importance to consider these questions in this order. Cheyne in #'B reaches such conclusions concerning the J. story that the story of J. is mutilated almost beyond recognition as a hiography at all. Driverin HDB holds that the J. story was ‘‘in all probability only committed to writing 700-800 years" later than the time to which J. is attributed, points out that J.’s name was also the name of a tribe, and concludes that ‘‘the first of these facts at once destroys all guarantee that we possess in the J. narrative a literal record of the facts,”" and that “the second fact raises the further question whether the figure of J., in part or even as a whole, is a reflection of the history and characteristics of the tribe projected upon the past in the individual form.’’ But he draws hack from this view and thinks it ‘‘ more probable that there was an actual person J., afterward... . rightly or wrongly regarded as the ancestor of the tribe... . who underwent substantially the experience recounted of him in Gen.’ In the presence of such critical notions concerning the literature in which the narrative of J. is embodied, it is clear that until we have reached some conclusions concerning the J. story, we Cannot be sure that there is any real story of J. to relate. IL. The Joseph Story, a Literary Question.—This literary problem will be solved, if satisfactory answers may be found to two questions: Is it an independent original or an adaptation? Suit- (2, 3) The name of 3 ancestors of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA — Joresn Valley oseph able material for such an adaptation as would produce a J. story has been sought at either end of the line of history: J. the pro- 1. An Inde- genitor and J. the tribe. The only pendent contestant for the claim of being an Original or early original of which the J. story an Adapta- might be an adaptation is the nasty tion? “Tale of Two Brothers” (RP, series I, . vol II, 137-46). This story in its essential elements much resembles the J. story. But such events as it records are common: why not such stories? What evidence does this ‘‘Tale of Two Brothers’ afford that the J. story is not an independent original ? Are we to suppose that because many French romances involve the demi-monde, there was therefore no Madame de Pompadour? Are court scandals so unheard of that ancient Egypt cannot afford two? And why impugn the genuineness of the J. story because the “ Tale of Two Brothers'’ resembles it? Is anyone so ethereal in his passions as not to know by instinct that the essential elements of such scandal are always the same? The difference in the narrative is chiefly in the telling. At this latter point the J. story and the ‘‘Tale of Two Brothers’' bear no resemblance whatever. If the chaste beauty of the Bib. story be observed, and then one turn to the ‘Tale of Two Brothers” with sufficient knowledge of the Egyp tongue to perceive the coarseness and the stench of it, there can be no question that the J. story is independent of such a literary source. To those who thus sense both stories, the claim of the ‘‘Tale of Two Brothers” to be the original of the J. story cannot stand for a moment. If we turn from J. the progenitor to J. the tribe, still less will the claim that the story is an adaptation bear careful examination. The perfect naturalness of the story, the utter absence from its multitudinous details of any hint of figurative language, such as personification always furnishes, and the absolutely accurate reflection in the story of the Egypt of J.’s day, as revealed by the many discoveries of which people of 700-800 years later could not know, mark this theory of the reflection of tribal history and characteristics as pure specu- lation. And besides, where in all the history of literature has it been proven that a tribe has been thus successfully thrown back upon the screen of antiquity in the ‘individual form”? Similar mis- takes concerning Menes and Minos and the heroes of Troy are a warning to us. Speculation is legiti- mate, so long as it does not cut loose from known facts, but gives no one the right to suppose the existence in unknown history of something never certainly found in known history. So much for the first question. Isitamonographoracompilation? The authorof amonograph may makelarge use of literary materials, and the editor of a compilation may 2. A Mono- introduce much editorial comment. graph ora Thus, superficially, these different kinds Com- of composition may much resemble pilation? each other, yet they are, in essential character, very different the one from the other. A compilation is an artificial body, an automaton; a monograph is a natural body with a living soul in it. This story has oriental pecul- iarities of repetition and pleonastic expression, and these things have been made much of in order to break up the story; to the reader not seeking grounds of partition, 1t is one of the most unbroken, simply natural and unaffected pieces of narrative literature in the world. Ifit stood alone or belonged to some later portion of Scripture, it may well be doubted that 1t would ever have been touched by the scalpel of the literary dissector. But it belongs to the Pent. There are manifest evidences all over the Pent of the use by the author of material, either - documentary or of that paradoxical unwritten lit. which the ancients handed down almost without Joseph THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1738 the change of a word for centuries. (1) An analyti- cal theory has been applied to the Pent as a whole, to_ resolve it into a mere compilation. Once the principles of this theory are acknowledged, and allowed sway there, the J. story cannot be left un- touched, but becomes a necessary sacrifice to the system. A sight of the lifeless, ghastly fragments of the living, moving J. story which the analysis leaves behind (cf EB, art. “Joseph”) proclaims that analysis to have been murder. There was a life in the story which has been ruthlessly taken, and that living soul marked the narrative as a mono- graph. (2) Where else is to be found such a com- pilation? Here is one of the most brilliant pieces of literature in the world, a narrative full of gems: (a) the account of the presentation of the brothers in the presence of J. when he was obliged to go out to weep (Gen 43 26-34), and (6) the scene between the terrified brothers of J. and the steward of his house (Gen 44 6-13), (c) Judah’s speech (Gen 44 18-34), (d) the touching close of the revelation of J. to his brothers at last (Gen 45 1-15). The soul of the whole story breathes through all of these. Where in all literature, ancicnt or modern, is to be found a mere compilation that is a great piece of literature? So far removed is this story from the characteristics of a compilation, that we may challenge the world of literature to produce another monograph in narrative literature that sur- passes it. (3) Then the dates of Egyp names and events in this narrative strongly favor its origin so early as to be out of the reach of the compilers. That attempts at identification in Egyp of names written in Heb, presenting as they do the peculiar difficulties of two alphabets of imperfectly known honetic values and uncertain equivalency of one in terms of the other, should give rise to differences of opinion, is to be expected. The Egyp equiva- lents of Zaphenath-paneah and Asenath have been diligently sought, and several identifications have been suggested (Brugsch, Egypt under the Pha- raohs, 122; Budge, History of Egypt, V, 126-27). That which is most exact phonetically and yields the most suitable and natural meaning for Zaphe- nath-paneah is by Lieblein (PSBA, 1898, 204-8). It is formed like four of the names of Hyksos kings before the time of J., and means “the one who fur- nishes the nourishment of life,” ic. the steward of therealm. The name Asenath is found from the XIth Dynasty on to the XVIIIth. Potiphar is mentioned as an Egyptian. Why not of course an Egyptian? The narrative also points distinctly to conditions obtaining under the Hyksos kings. When the people were like to perish for want of food they promised J. in return for help that they would be “servants of Pharaoh” (Gen 47 18-25). This suggests a previous antagonism to the govern- ment, such as the Hyksos kings had long to contend with in Egypt. But the revolution which drove out the Hyksos labored so effectually to eradicate every trace of the hated foreigners that it is with the utmost difficulty that modern Egyptological re- search has wrested from the past some small items of information concerning them. Is it credible that the editor of scraps, which were themselves not written down until some 700-800 years later, should have been able to produce such a life-story fitting into the peculiar conditions of the times of the Hyksos? Considered as an independent literary problem on its own merits, aside from any entan- gling necessities of the analytical theory of the Pent, the J. story must certainly stand as a monograph from some time within distinct memory of the events it records. If the J. story be an independent origi- nal and a monograph, then there is in reality to be | considered the story of J. : Il, The Story of Joseph.—It is unnecessary to recount here all the events of the life of J., a story so incomparably told in the Bib. narrative. It will be sufficient to touch only the salient points where controversy has raged, or at which archaeology has furnished ‘special illumination. The story of_J. begins the tenth and last natural division of Gen in these words: “The generations of Jacob” (Gen 37 2). Up to this point the unvarying method of Gen is to place at the head of each division the an- nouncement “the generations of” one of the patri- archs, followed immediately by a brief outline of the discarded line of descent, and then to give in . detail the account of the chosen line. There is to be now no longer any discarded line of descent. All the sons of Jacob are of the chosen people, the depositary of the revelation of redemp- tion. So this division of Gen begins at once with the chosen line, and sets in the very foreground that narrative which in that generation is most vital in the story of redemption, this story of J. begin- ning with the words, “J., being seventeen years old, was feeding the flock with his brethren” (Gen 87 2). J. had been born in Haran, the firstborn of the beloved Rachel, who died at the birth of her second son Benjamin. A motherless lad among the sons of other mothers felt the jealousies of the sit- uation, and the experience became a temptation. The “evil report” of his brethren was thus natu- rally carried to his father, and quite as naturally stirred up those family jealousies which set his feet in the path of his great career (87 2-4). In that career he appears as a Bedouin prince in Canaan. The patriarchs of those times were all sheiks or princes of those semi-nomadic rovers who by the peculiar social and civil customs of 1A that land were tolerated then as they Bedouin are to this day under the Turkish Prince in government in the midst of farms and Canaan settled land tenure. Jacob favored Rachel and her children. He put them hindermost at the dangerous meeting with Esau, and now he puts on J. a coat of many colors (Gen 37 3). The appearance of such a coat a little earlier in the decoration of the tombs of Benihassan among Palestinian ambassadors to Egypt probably indicates that this garment was in some sense cere- monial, a token of rank. In any case J., the son of Jacob, was a Bedouin prince. Did the father by this coat indicate his intention to give him the pre- cedence and the succession as chieftain of the tribe? It is difficult otherwise to account for the insane jealousy of the older brethren (Gen 87 4). Ac- cording to the critical partition of the story, J.’s dreams may be explained away as mere reflections or adaptations of the later history of J. (cf Penta- TEUCH). In a real biography the striking provi- dential significance of the dreams appears at once. They cannot be real without in some sense being prophetic. On the other hand they cannot be other than real without vitiating the whole story as a truthful narrative, for they led immediately to the great tragedy; a Bedouin prince of Canaan becomes a Bedouin slave in Egypt. The plot to put J. out of the way, the substitution of slavery for death, and the ghastly device for de- ceiving Jacob (Gen 37 18-36) are 2. ABed- perfectly natural steps in the course ouin Slave of crime when once the brothers had in Egypt set out upon it. The counterplot of Reuben to deliver J. reflects equally his own goodness and the dangerous character of the other brothers to whom he did not dare make a direct protest. Critical discussion of ‘‘ Ishmaelites’’ and ‘‘Mldianltes"’ and ‘‘'Medanites’’ presents some interesting things and many clever speculations which may well be considered on their own merits by those interested in ethnology and ee ri “3052 ernest aw SHEEP AT DOTHAN 1739 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joseph etymologies. Many opinlons advanced may prove to be correct. But let It be noted that they are for the most part pure speculation, Almost nothing is known of the interrelatiou of the trans-Jordanic tribes in that age other than the few hints in the Bible. And who can say what manner of persons might be found In a caravan which had wandercd about no one knows where, or how long, to pick up trade _before it turned into the northern caravan route? Until archaeology supplies more facts it is folly te attach much importance to such speculations (Kyle, The Deciding Voice of the Monuments in Bib. Criticism, 221). In the slave market in Egypt, J. was bought by Potiphar, an officer of Pharaoh, “an Egyptian.” The significant mention of this fact fits exactly into a place among the recovered hints of the history of those times, which make the court then to be not Egyp at all, but composed of foreigners, the dynasty of Hyksos kings among whom an ‘Egyptian’ was so unexpected as to have his nationality mentioned. _ Js native nobility of character, the pious train- ing he had received in his father’s house, and the favor of God with him gave him such prosperity that his master intrusted all the affairs-of his house- hold to him, and when the greatest of temptations assails him he comes off victorious (ch_39). There is strong ground for the suspicion that Potiphar did not fully believe the accusation of his wife against J. The fact that J. was not immediately put to death is very significant. Potiphar could hardly do less than shut him up for the sake of appearances, and perhaps to take temptation away from his wife without seeming to suspect her. It is noticeable also that J.’s character soon triumphed in prison. Then the same Providence that superintended his dreams is leading so as to bring him before the king (chs 40, 41). i ; The events of the immediately preceding history prepared J.’s day: the Hyksos kings on the throne, those Bedouin princes, “shepherd 3. The kings” (Petrie, Hyksos and_ Israelite Bedouin Cities), the enmity of the Egyptians Slave Be- against this foreign dynasty so that comes they accounted every shepherd an Again the “abomination” (46 34), the friendly Bedouin relation thus created between Pales- | Prince tinian tribes and Egypt, the princely character of J., for among princes a prince is a prince however small his principality, and last of all the manifest favor of God toward J., and the evident understanding by the Pharaohs of Sem religion, perhaps even sympathy with it (41 39). All these constitute one of the most majestic, Godlike movements of Providence re- vealed to us in the word of God, or evident any- where in history. The same Providence that presided over the boy prince in his father’s house came again to the slave prince in the Egyp prison. The interpretation of the dreams of the chief butler and the chief baker of Pharaoh (40—41 1-24) brought him at last through much delay and selfish forgetfulness to the notice of the king, and another dream in which the same cunning hand of Providence is plainly seen (ch 41) is the means of bringing J. to stand in the royal presence. The stuff that dreams are made of interests scarcely less than the Providence that was super- intending over them. As the harvest fields of the semi-nomadie Bedouin in Pal, and the household routine of Egypt in the dreams of the chief butler and the chief baker, so now the industrial interests and the religious forms of the nation appear in the dreamsof Pharaoh. The “‘seven kine” of the goddess Hathor supplies the number of the cows, and the doubling of the symbolism in the cattle and the grain points to the two great sources of Egypt’s welfare. The Providence that had shaped and guided the whole course of J. from the Palestinian home was consummated when, with the words, “TInasmuch as thou art a man in whom is the spirit of God,” Pharaoh lifted up the Bedouin slave to be again the Bedouin prince and made him the prime minister. The history of “kings’ favorites” is too well known for the elevation of J. to be in itself incredible. Such things are esp. likely to take place 4, The among the unlimited monarchies of the Prime Orient. The late empress of China had Minister | been a Chinese slave girl. The investi- ture of J. was thoroughly Egyp—the “collar,” the signet “ring,” the “chariot” and the outrunners who cried before him ‘“Abrech.” The exact meaning of this word has never been certainly ascertained, but its general import may be seen illus- trated to this day wherever in the East royalty rides out. The policy adopted by the prime min- ister was far-reaching, wise, even adroit (Gen 41 25-36). It is impossible to say whether or not it was wholly just, for we cannot know whether the corn of the years of plenty which the government laid up was bought or taken as a tax levy. The policy involved some despotic power, but J. proved a magnanimous despot. The deep and subile statesmanship in J.’s plan does not fully appear until the outcome. It was probably through the policy of J., the prime minister, that the Hyksos finally gained the power over the people and the mastery of the land. Great famines have not been common In Egypt, but are not unknown. The only one which corresponds well to the Bible account is that one recorded in the iuscrip- tlon of Baba at el Kab, trd by Brugsch. Some scarce! justifiable lon dat have been made to discredit Brugsch in his account of that inscription. The monument still remains and is easily visited, but the inscription is so mutilated that it presents many difficulties. The severity of the famine, the length of its duration, the preparation by the government, the distribution to the people, the success of the efforts for relief and even the time of the famine, as far as It can be determined, corre- spond well to the Bible account (Brugsch, Egypt under the Pharaohs, ch vi). The way in which such famines in Egypt come about has been explained by a movement of the sudd, a sedgelike growth in the Nile, so as to clog the upper river (Wright, Scientific Confirmations, 70-79). J.’3 brethren came “with those that came,” ie. with the food caravans. The account does not imply that the prime minister presided in person at the selling of grain, but only that he knew of the coming of his brethren and met them at the market place. The watchfulness of the government against “spies,”’ by the careful guarding of the entrances to the land, may well have furnished him with such information. Once possessed with it, all the rest, of the story of the interviews follows naturally (cf traditions of J., Jew Enc). | The long testing of the brethren with the attend- ant delay in the relief of the father Jacob and the family (chs 42-45) has been the subject of much discussion, and most ingenious arguments for the justification of J. All this seems unnecessary. J. was not perfect, and there is no claim of perfec- tion made for him in the Bible. Two things are sufficient to be noted here: one that J. was ruler as well as brother, with the habits of a ruler of almost unrestrained power and authority and burdened with the necessity for protection and the obligation to mete out justice; the other that the deliberateness, the vexatious delays, the subtle diplomacy and playing with great issues are thor- oughly oriental. It may be also that the perplexi- ties of great minds make them liable to such va- garies. The career of Lincoln furnishes some curious parallels in the parleying with cases long after the great president’s mind was fully made up and action taken. The time of these events and the identification of J. in Egypt are most vexed questions not con- clusively settled. Toffteen quite confidently pre- Joseph Barnabas Joseph’s Dream THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1740 sents in a most recent identification of J. much evi- dence to which one would like to give full credence (Toffteen, The Historical Exodus). But aside from the fact that he claims two exodi, two J.s, two Aarons, two lawgivers called Moses, and two givings of the law, a case of critical doublets more astound- ing than any heretofore claimed in the Pent, the evidence itself which he adduces is very far from conclusive. It is doubtful if the texts will bear the translation he gives them, esp. the proper names. The claims of Rameses II, that he built Pithom, compared with the stele of 400 years, which he says he erected in the 400th year of King Nubti, seems to put J. about the time of the Hyksos king. This is the most that can be said now. The burial of Jacob is in exact accord with Egyp customs. The wealth of the Israelites who retained their posses- sions and were fed by the crown, in contrast with the poverty of the Egyptians who sold everything, prepares the way for the wonderful growth and in- fluence of Israel, and the fear which the Egyptians at last had of them. “And J. died, being 110 years old,” an ideal old age in the Egyp mind. The reputed burial place of J. at Shechem still awaits examination. Joseph stands out among the patriarchs in some respects with preéminence. His nobility of char- acter, his purity of heart and life, 5. The his magnanimity as aruler and brother Patriarch make him, more than any other of the OT characters, an illustration of that type of man which Christ was to give to the world in perfection. J. is not in the list of persons dis- tinetly referred to in Scripture as types of Christ— the only perfectly safe criterion—but none more fully illustrates the life and work of the Saviour. He wrought salvation for those who betrayed and rejected him, he went down into humiliation as the way to his exaltation, he forgave those who, at least in spirit, put him to death, and to him as to the Saviour, all must come for relief, or perish. LireraturE.—Comms, on Gen; for rabbinical lit., ef Seligsohn in Jew Enc, some very interesting and curious traditions: Ebers, Egypten und die Biicher Moses; “The Tale of Two Brothers,'’ RP, series I, vol II, 137- 46; Wilkinson-Birch, The Manners and Customs of the Ancient Egyptians; Erman, Life in Ancient Egypt. M. G. Kye JOSEPH BARNABAS. See BARNABAS. JOSEPH BARSABBAS, bir-sab’as (BaprafPas, Barsabbds, or BapoaBas, Barsabis; AV Barsabas, bar’sa-bas; for etymology, etc, of Joseph, see general art. on JosErH): Joseph Barsabbas was surnamed Justus (Acts 1 23). Barsabbas was probably a patronymic, i.e. son of Sabba or Seba. Other inter- pretations given are “son of an oath,” “son of an old man,” “son of conversion,” “son of quiet.” It is likely that the ‘Judas called Barsabbas’’ of Acts 15 22 was his brother. Ewald considers that both names refer to the same person, but this is improbable. J. was one of those who accompanied the apostles “all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and went out among us, beginning from the baptism of John, unto the day that he was received up from us” (Acts 1 21.22). At the meeting of the brethren under the presidency of Peter in Jerus shortly after the crucifixion, he was, therefore, proposed along with Matthias as a suitable candidate for the place in the apostleship left vacant by the treachery and death of Judas Iscariot; but was unsuccessful (Acts 1 15-26). According to Eusebius (H£, I, 12), J. was one of the 70 (Lk 10 1), and Papias reeords the oral tradition that he drank a cup of poison without harm (cf Mk 16 18). The Acts.of St. Paul, a work belonging to the 2d cent. and first mentioned by Origen, relates that Barsabbas, Justus the Flatfoot and others were imprisoned by Nero for protesting their faith in Christ, but that upon a vision of the newly martyred Paul appearing to the emperor, he ordered their immediate release. C. M. Kerr JOSEPH, HUSBAND OF MARY (for etymology, etc, of Joseph, see Josrpn): Joseph, the carpenter (Mt 13 55), was a “just man” (Mt 1. Refer- 1.19 AV), who belonged to Nazareth euces in NT (Lk 2 4). He was of Davidiec descent (Mt 1 20; Lk 2 4), the son of Heli (Lk 8 23) or Jacob (Mt 1 16), the husband of Mary (Mt 1 16), and the supposed father of Jesus (Mt 13 55; Lk 3 23; 4 22; Jn 1 45; 6 42). (1) Before the Nativity—The Gospels of Mt and Mk alone give any detailed reference to J. and the birth of Jesus, and their accounts vary in part. Lk begins with the Annunciation to Mary at Nazareth (Lk 1 26-38). Overwhelmed with the tidings, Mary departed ‘“‘with haste’’ ‘into the hill country, .... into a city of Judah,” to seek communion with Elisabeth, with whom she had been coupled in the Annunciation by the angel Gabriel (Lk 1 39-55). After abiding with her about three months she returned ‘‘unto her own house” (Lk 1 56 AY). The events recorded in Mt 1 18-24 probably took place in the interval between this return and the birth of Jesus. During Mary’s visit to Elisabeth, J.had likely remained in Nazareth. The abrupt and probably unexplained departure of his espoused wife for Judah (cf the phrase “with haste’), and her condition on her return, had caused him great mental distress (Mt 1 18-20). Though his indig- nation was tempered with mercy, he was minded to put her away “‘privily,” but the visitation of the angel in his sleep relieved him from his dilemma, and he was reconciled to his wife (Mt 1 24). The nar- rative is then continued by St. Luke. While J. and Mary still abode in Nazareth, ‘there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus, that all the world should be enrolled” (Lk 2 1). ‘And all went to enrol themselves, every one to his own city’ (Lk 2 3). Being of the house and lineage of David, J. went up with Mary, who was “great with child,’ from Galilee, “out of the city of Nazareth, into Judaea, to the city of David, which is called Beth- lehem”’ (Lk 2 4.5), and there Jesus was born (Lk 27; ef Mt 2 1). (2) After the Nativity—(a) St. Luke’s account: The two accounts now diverge considerably. Ac- cording to Lk, the Holy Family remained for a time at Bethlehem and were there visited by the shep- herds (Lk 2 8-20). After a sojourn of 40 days for the purification (ef Lk 2 21.22; Lev 12), J. de- parted with his wife for Jerus “to present” the infant Jesus “‘to the Lord” and to offer up sacrifice according to the ancient law (Lk 2 24). There he was present at the prophesying of Simeon and Anna concerning Jesus, and received the blessing of the former (Lk 2 34). After “they had accom- plished all things according to the law of the Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Naz- areth” (Lk 2 39). Every year, at the Passover, they made this journey to Jerus (Lk 2 41). The care and solicitude of J. and Mary for the boy Jesus and their grief at His temporary loss are also re- corded (Lk 2 45.48.51). There is evidence that, though Mary “‘kept all these things in her heart,” J. at least had no understanding then of the Divine oe of the charge committed to his care (Lk 2 (0) St. Matthew’s account: But according to Mt it was from the Wise Men of the East that Jesus received homage at Bethlehem (Mt 2 I-11). There is no further mention of the dedicatory journey to Jerus, or of the return to Nazareth. 1741 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joseph Barnabas Joseph’s Dream Instcad, it is stated that on the departure of the Wise Men from Bethlehem, J. was warncd in a dream of the impending wrath of Herod, and escaped with his wife and the infant Jesus into Egypt (Mt 2 13.14). Upon the death of Herod, an angel appeared to J., and he returned to the land of Israel (Mt 2 19-21). His original intention was to settle once more in Judaea, but on learning that Arche- laus, the son of Herod, was ruler there, “he with- drew into the parts of Galilee, and came and dwelt in a city called Nazareth” (Mt 2 22.23). (c) The proper sequence of the two narratives: ‘The narrative of Mt would thus imply that the Holy Family had no connection with Nazareth previous to their return from Egypt. It has, however, been suggested by Ramsay that Mt mercly reports what was common knowledge, and that Lk, while quite cognizant of this, supplemented it in his own Gospel with details known only to the Holy Family, and in part to the mother alone (cf Sir W. Ramsay, Was Christ Born at Bethlehem? 78-79). A com- parison of the two Gospel narratives makes it clear that the visitation of the Wise Men fell on a later date than that of the shepherds. The latter took place immediately after the Nativity (cf Lk 2 11. 15.16, “is born... . this day,” “let us now go,” “and they came with haste’). On the other hand, when the Wise Men came to Jerus, Christ was already born (cf Mt 2 1). Time was required for this journey to Jerus and the consultation of Herod with the chief priests (Mt 2 4); and during this interval the events recorded in Lk 2 8-39 had taken place. That there was sufficient time for this is attested also by the fact that Herod’s decree was directed against children up to two years of age (Mt 2 16). Thus it was after the return of the Holy Family to Nazareth, and on a further visit to Bethlehem, implied by Mt but not recorded by Lk, that the infant Jesus received the adoration of the Wise Men. Jesus being born in 6 BC, this took place in 5 BC, and as Herod died in 4 BC, J. may have missed only one of the Passovers (cf Lk 2 41) by his flight into Egypt. (For a full discus- sion, cf Ramsay, op. cit.) As no mention is made of J. in the later parts of the Gospels where the Holy Family is referred to (cf Mt 12 46; Lk 8 19), it is commonly supposed that he died before the com- mencement of the public ministry of Christ. If a type is to be sought in the character of J., it is that of a simple, honest, hard-working, God- fearing man, who was possessed of 2. Character large sympathies and a warm heart. Strict in the observance of Jewish law and custom, he was yet ready when occasion arose to make these subservient to the greater law of the Spirit. Too practical to possess any deep insight into the Divine mysteries or eternal significance of events which came within his knowledge (cf Lk 2 50), he was quick to make answer to what he per- ceived to be the direct call of God (cf Mt 1 24). Originally a ‘(just man” (AV), the natural clemency within his heart prevailed over mere justice, and by the promptings of the Holy Spirit that clemency was transferred into a strong and enduring love (cf Mt 1 24). J. is known to us only as a dim figure in the background of the Gospel narratives, yet his whole-hearted reconciliation to Mary, even in the face of possible slanderings by his neighbors, his complete self-sacrifice, when he left all and fled into Egypt to save the infant Jesus, are indicative that he was not unworthy to fulfil the great trust which was imposed upon him by the Eternal Father. rding to St. James, a parece. ee roam a ag sta but with later additions (cf Hennecke, Neutestamentliche Apokryphen, ty: gives a detailed account of the marriage of the aged with Mary, of their journey to Bethlehem, and of the birth of Jesus. A similar gospel, reputed to be hy Thomas the philosopher, of later origin and ostic tendency (cf Hennecke, 63-73), narratcs several fantas- tic, miraculous happenings in the domestic 3. Refer- life of the Holy Family, and the dealings ences in of Joseph with the teachers of the youth- hal ful Jesus. Other legends, from Syr or Apocryphal fgyp sources, also dealing with the In- Literature fancy, in which J. figures, are extant. The chief is The History of Joseph the Carpenter (cf Hennecke, Handbuch der neutestamentlichen Apokryphen, 95-105)._ This contains an account of the death and burial of J. at the age of 110, and of the entreatles of Mary to Christ to save him. Its aim was to show forth Christ as the Saviour, even at the last hour, and the rightful manner of Christian death. J. has received a high place in the Calendar of the Roman Catholic Saints, his feast being celebrated on March 19. C. M. Kener JOSEPH OF ARIMATHAEA (a4mé ’Apipabalas, apé Arimathaias; for etymology, etc, of Joseph, see gen. art. on JosePrH): Joseph of Arimathaea— a place the locality of which is doubtful, but lying probably to the N.W. of Jerus—was a “rich man” (Mt 27 57), “a councillor of honorable estate,’ or member of the Sanhedrin (Mk 15 43; Lk 23 50), “a good and righteous man . . . . who was looking for the kingdom of God’ (Lk 23 50; Mk 16 43), and “himself was Jesus’ disciple’ (Mt 27 57; Jn 19 38). Although he kept his discipleship secret “for fear of the Jews” (Jn 19 38), he was yet faith- ful to his allegiance in that he absented himself from the meeting which found Jesus guilty of death (cf Lk 23 51; Mk 14 64). But the condemnation of his Lord awakened the courage and revealed the true faith of J. On the evening after the cruci- fixion he went “boldly” to Pilate and begged the body of Jesus. There is a fine touch in that he himself took down the body from the cross. With the assistance of Nicodemus he wound it in fine linen with spices (ef Mt 27 57, J. was a “rich man”) and brought it to the new sepulcher in the garden near the place of His crucifixion. There they “laid him in a tomb that was hewn in stone, where never man had yet lain” and ‘rolled a stone against the door of the tomb’ (cf Mt 27 57-60; Mk 15 42-46; Lk 23 50-53; Jn 19 38-42). In this was held to be the fulfilment of the prophecy of Isa &3 9, The Gospel of St. Peter, written probably in Syria about the middle of the 2d cent., gives a slightly different account. According to this J., ‘the friend of Pilate and the Lord,” was present at the trial of Jesus, and imme- diately upon its conclusion besonght of Pilate that he might have the body for burial. This was granted, and after the crucifixion the Jews handed the body over to J. (cf Hennecke, Neutestamentliche Apokryphen, 27-30), Legends of a later origin record that J. was sent by Philip from Gaul to Britain along with 11 other disciples in 63 AD, and built an oratory at Glastonbury (cf Per.ip THE APostLe), that he bronght the Holy Grail to Eng- land, and that he freed Ireland from snakes. C. M. Kerr JOSEPH, PRAYER OF: An OT pscudepigraph, no. 3 in the Stichometry of Nicephorus (Westcott, Canon of the NT’, 571), with the length given as 1,100 lines, and no. 5 in the List of Sixty Books (West- cott, 568). The work is lost, and the only quota- tions are in Origen (In Joan., ii.25, Eng.in Anie- Nicene Fathers, IX, 341; In Gen.,iii.9,12). Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are said to have been created before every work, but Jacob-Israel is the greatest, “the firstborn of every living creature,” the “first minister in God’s presence,” greater than the angel with whom he wrestled. The purport may be anti-Christian, the patriarchs exalted in place of Christ; cf, per- haps, En 71 (but not so in Charles’s 1912 text), but Origen’s favorable opinion of the book proves that the polemic could not have been very direct. Literature.—GJV, 4th ed, ITI, 359-60; Dillmann in PRE, 2d ed, XII, 362; cf Beer in 3d ed, XVI, 256; Fabricius, Codex pseudep. Vet. Test., 1, 761-71. Burton Scorr Haston JOSEPH’S DREAM. See Astronomy, II, 6; JOSEPH. Joseph, Gospel of THF INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joshua 1742 JOSEPH, THE CARPENTER, GOSPEL OF. See APOCRYPHAL GOSPELS. JOSEPHUS, jé-sé’fus (Idenpos, Léséphos; B reads @écynwos, Phésépos): In 1 Esd 9 34, corre- sponding to “Joseph” in Ezr 10 42. JOSEPHUS, jé-sé’fus, FLAVIUS, fla’vi-us: Was born at Jerus 37-38 AD, and died at Rome early in the 2d cent., when is not known pre- 1. Early cisely. His father and mother be- Life and longed to families of the priestly Beliefs aristocracy; consequently he received an excellent education, becoming fa- miliar, not only with Jewish, but with Hellenistic, culture. When 16 years old he resorted to one Banus, an Essense (q.v.), in the desert of Engedi, with whom he remained for 3 years, absorbing occult, lore, and practising the ascetic life. It might have been expected from his social position that, on his return to Jerus, he would join the SappuceeEs (q.v.); but, his Essene experience hav- ing indoctrinated him with ceremonialism, he pre- ferred to become a PHARISEE (q.v.). He evidently believed, too, that. the Pharisees were akin to the Stoics, who were then influential in the Hellenistic world. During his absence in the desert, the mis- government of the Rom procurators at Jerus had grown apace. And the ineptitudes and injustices of Felix, Alhanus and Florus were succeeded by anarchy under Annas, the high priest (62). Ac- cordingly, the Zza.ors (q.v.) plotted against Rom rule. Rebellion simmered, and many of the dis- affected were transported to Rome to be dealt with there. Among these were several priests, whom Jos knew. About the year 64, he went to Rome to plead for them, met shipwreck on the voyage, was rescued with a few survivors and was brought to port at Puteoli. Here he met Alityrus, a Jewish actor, who happened to be in the good graces of Poppaea, Nero’s consort. The empress, a Jewish proselyte, espoused his cause at Rome, and showed him many favors. At the capital, he also dis- cerned the power of the Romans and, in all prob- ability, grew convinced of the hopelessness of armed revolt. On his return to Jerus, he found his people set upon insurrection, and was forced, possibly against his better judgment, to make common cause with them. The first part of his public career is concerned with the great struggle that now began. When war broke out, Jos was appointed governor of Galilee, the province where the Rom attack would first fall. He had no military fitness 2. Public for command, but the influence of his Career friends and the exigencies of politics thrust the office upon him. The Zealots soon found that he did not earry out the necessary preparations with thoroughness, and they tried to compass hisremoval. But he was too influ- ential, too good a politician also, to be undermined. Surana by enemies among his own folk, who even attempted to assassinate him, he encountered several dangerous experiences, and, at length, flying from the Romans, was beleaguered with his army in Jotopata, near the Lake of Gennesaret, in May, 67. The Jews withstood the siege for 47 days with splendid courage, till Titus, assaulting under cover of a mist, stormed the stronghold and massacred the weary defenders. Jos escaped to a cave where, with his usual adroitness, he saved himself from death at the hands of his companions. The Romans soon discovered his hiding-place, and haled him before Vespasian, the commander-in-chief. Jos worked upon the superstitions of the general, and so ingratiated himself that Vespasian took him to Alexandria in his train. Having been liberated by his captor, he adopted the family name of the Flavians, according to Rom custom. Returning to Pal with Titus, he proceeded to mediate between the Romans and the Jews, earning the suspicion of the former, the hatred of the latter. His wonted diplomacy preserved him from anything more serious than a wound, and he was an eyewitness of the terrible events that marked the last days of Jerus. Then he accompanied Titus to Rome for the TrrumPH (q.v.). Here he lived the remainder of his days, in high favor with the ruling house, and relieved from all anxiety about worldly goods by lavish imperial patronage. He was thus enabled to devote himself to literary pursuits. The works of Jos render him one of the most valuable authorities for the student of NT times. They are as follows: (1) Concerning 3. Works the Jewish War, written before 79; we have the Gr tr of this history by the author; there are 7 books: I, the period from Antio- chus Epiphanes (175 BC) to Herod the Great (4 BC); II, from 4 BC to 66 AD, covering the early events of the War; III, occurrences in Galilee in 67 AD; IV, the course of the War till the siege of Jerus; V and VI, the investment and fall of Jerus; VII, the aftermath of the rebellion. While this work igs not written with the objective accuracy of scientific history, it is credible on the whole, except where it concerns the réle played by the author. (2) The Antiquities of the Jews, written not later than 94 AD. In this Jos purports to relate the entire history of his race, from the beginning till the War of 66 AD. The 20 books fall naturally into 5 divisions, thus: (a) I-X, from prehistoric times till the Captivity, in other words, the period related in the OT substantially; (0) XI, the age of Cyrus; (c) XII-XIV, the beginnings of the Hellenistic period, from Alexander the Great, including the Maccabean revolt, till the accession of Herod the Great; (d) XV-XVII, the reign of Herod; (e) XVIII-XX, from Herod’s death till the War of 66. While it cannot be called an apology for the Jews, this work betrays the author’s consciousness of the disfavor with which his people were viewed through- out the Rom Empire. Jos does what he can to disabuse the Gr-Rom educated classes, although he shows curious obliquity to the grandeur of Heb religion. Allin all, the work is disappointing; but it contains many details and sidelights of first im- portance to investigators. (3) The treatise called, since Jerome, Against Apion, is Josephus’ most inspiring performance. The older title, Concern- ing the High Antiquity of the Jews, tells us what it contains—a defence of Heb religion against the libels of heathendom. It is in two books. The vituperation with which Jos visits Apion is unim- portant in comparison with the defence of Mosaic religion and the criticism of paganism. Here the author’s character is seen at its best; the air of Worldly Wiseman has been dropped, and he ap- proaches enthusiasm. (4) His last work is the Vita or Autobiography, a misleading title. It is an echo of old days in Galilee, directed against the traductions of an associate, Justus of Tiberias. We have Jos at his worst here. He so colors the narra- tive as to convey a totally wrong impression of the part he played during the great crisis. In exten- uation, it may be said that his relations with the imperial court rendered it difficult, perhaps impos- sible, for him to pursue another course. Lirzeraturn.—wW. D. Morrison, The Jews under Rom Rule (London, 1890); E. Schtirer, History of the Jewish Peopleinthe Time of Jesus Christ, div I, voll (Edinburgh, 1890); A. Hansrath, History of NT Times, IV, div VI1,ch ii (London, 1895); H. Graetz, History of the Jews from the Earliest Times to the Present Day, II, ch x (London, 1891); art. “Josephus” in Jew Enc. Transiations by Whiston (many edd), and of The War of the Jews, by Traill and Taylor (London, 1862). R. M. WENLEY 1743 JOSES, j6'séz, j6’zez (?Iwofjs, I sés): (1) One of the brethren of Jesus (Mk 6 3; in Mt 13 55 the Gr is “Joseph,”’ and RV so renders). (2) A son of Mary, perhaps identical with (1) (Mt 27 56; Mk 16 40.47). See Breturen or THE LorRD. (3) A name of Barnabas (Acts 4 36 AV, where again Gr and RV have “Joseph’’). See BaRNaABas. JOSHAH, jo’sha (MWS, yoshah, “Jeh’s gift”): A descendant of Simeon, chief in his family (1 Ch 4 34.38). JOSHAPHAT, josh’a-fat (UW, ydshaphat, “Jeh has judged”; cf JEHOSHAPHAT): (1) One of David’s mighty men (i Ch 11 483), a “Mithnite,” but not inclyded in the list of 2 8 23. (2) A priest and trumpeter of David’s time (1 Ch 15 24), AV “Jehoshaphat.” JOSHAVIAH, josh-a-vi’a (TWN, ydshawyah, allied form to JosHag [q.v.]): Son of Elnaam, one of the band of braves who served David (1 Ch 11 46), omitted from the list of 2 8 28, which is less complete and differs in detail. JOSHBEKASHAH, josh-bé-k4’sha, josh-bé-kash’a (AWWpaw , yoshb-kashah, “son” of Heman; 1 Ch 26 4.24): The last 8 or 9 names in ver 4 are taken by commentators to be not names but the words of aprayer. See OTJC?, 143, n.; Curtis, Chron, 278, 280; SBOT. JOSHEB-BASSHEBETH, jé-sheb-ba-shé’beth (FAW. AW, ydshebh ba-shebheth): This proper name in RV takes the place of the tr ‘‘that sat in the seat” in AV (2 S 23 8). The phrase so rendered is meaningless. The text has evidently suffered cor- ruption. There can be no doubt that a proper name isintended. This, according to the || passage in 1Ch11 11, should be Jasbobeam. Some scholars think that this also is a corruption, and by a process of emendation arrive at ‘“Eshhaal” as the correct name (Driver, Heb Text of S; SBOT, ad loc.). JOSHIBIAH, josh-i-bi’a (TMIWM, ysshibhyah, “Jeh sets,” or ‘‘causes to dwell”; AV Josibiah): A Simeonite (1 Ch 4 35). JOSHUA, josh’t-a ([a] PWN, yhoshan, [6] PVM, yhoshur’, “Jeh is deliverance” or ‘‘opu- lence”; ef JesHua; ’Iynvods, [ésots): (1) Joshua the son of Nun; the name has the Heb form (a) abovein Dt 3 21; Jgs 2 7; elsewhere the form (b), except in Neh 8 17, where it is of the form yéshi*' (See Jesnus); cf also Nu 18 8.16; Dt 32 44. See following article. : (2) In 18 6 14.18 (form [b6]), the Bethshemite in whose field stood the kine that brought the ark from the Philistines. ; (3) In 2 K 28 8 (form [b]), governor of Jerus in the time of Josiah. (4) The high priest at Jerus after the return. See separate article. 8. F. Hunter JOSHUA: I. Form snp SIGNIFICANCE or Nama Il. Hisrory or tae Lire or Josuva . First Appearance . The Minister of Moses . One of the Spies . The Head of the People ; (1) His First Act—Sending of the Spies 2) Crossing of the Jordan 03) Capture of Jericho 4) Conquest of Ai and Bethel & Reading of the Law on Mt. Ebal PONE THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA anaes Gospel of (8) The Gibeonltes (7) Conquest of the South 8) Northern Conquests 9) Allotment of Territory ne Cities of Refuge 11) Final Address and Death III. Sources or History IV. CHARACTER AND Work or JosHvua I. Form and Significance of Name.—The name Joshua, a contracted form of Jehoshna (WWW, PVN, yhoshue'), which also appears in the form Jeshua (2702, Neh 8 17), signifies ‘‘Jeh is deliver- ance” or “salvation,” and is formed on the analogy of many Israelite names, as Jehoiakim ("P77 , yhoyakim), “Jeh exalteth,” Jehohanan (J, yhohanan), “Jeh is gracious,” Elishua or Elisha (DNDN, aisha’, NWN, aisha), “God is de- liverance,” Elizur (MAREN, "Eictr), “God is a rock,” etc. In the narrative of the mission of the spies in Nu 18, the name is given as Hoshea (VO, hoshé', ve 8.16; cf Dt 32 44), which is changed by Moses to Joshua (ver 16). In the passage in Dt, however, the earlier form of the name is regarded by Dr. Driver (Comm. in loc.) as an erroneous read- ing. The Gr form of the name is Jesus ("Inco0ds, Tésons, Acts 7 45; He 4 8, RV “Joshua,” but AV “Jesus’ in both passages), and this form appears even in the passages cited above from Neh and Dt. In Nu 13 ‘8.16, however, LXX has Atoy, Hausé. The name occurs in later Jewish history, e.g. as that of the owner of the field in which the ark rested after its return from the land of the Philis (1 8 6 14.18), and appears to have become esp. frequent after the exile (Ezr 2 40; Zec 3 lab, etc). It is also found (Jeshua) with a local signification as the name of one of the “‘villages’’ in Southern Judaea, where the repatriated Jews dwelt after their return from Babylon (Neh 11 26). Il. History of the Life of Joshua.—The narrative of the life of Joshua, the son of Nun, is naturally divided into two parts, in which he held entirely different positions with regard to the people of Israel, and discharged different duties. In the earlier period he is the servant and minister of Mosca, loyal to his leader, and one of his most trusted and valiant captains. After the death of Moses he himself succeeds to the leadership of the Israelite host, and conducts them to a settlement in the Promised Land. The service of the earlier years of his life is a preparation and equipment for the office and responsibility that devolved upon him in the later period. The first appearance of J. in the history is at Rephidim, on the way from the wilderness of Sin to Horeb. Neither the exact site of 1. First Rephidim nor the meaning of the name Appearance can be determined; the Israelites, however, apparently came to Rephi- dim before they approached the rich oasis of Feirdn, for at the former place ‘‘there was no water for the people to drink” (Ex 171). The fact that the host encamped there seems to assume the existence of wells; either, therefore, these were found to be dry, or they failed before the wants of the great host were satisfied. The Amalekités, wandering desert tribes, claimed the ownership of the wells, and, resenting the Israelite intrusion, swooped down npon them to drive them away and to enrich them- selves with the spoil of their possessions. Under the command of J., the Israelites won a complete victory in a battle that seems to have been pro- longed until sunset; the fortunes of the battle varying with the uplifting or falling of Moses’ hands, which were accordingly supported by Aaron and Hur throughout the day (vs 11 ff). A curse Joshua THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1744 and sentence of extermination prononnced against Amalek were formally written down and communi- cated to J., apparently that, as the future leader of Israel, he might have it in charge to provide for their fulfilment. It is evident also that at this period J. was no young and untried warrior. Although no indica- tion of his previous history is given, his name is introduced into the narrative as of a man well known, who is sufficiently in the confidence of Moses to be given the chief command in the first conflict in which the Israelites had been engaged since leaving Egypt. The result justified the choice. And if, during the march, he had held the position of military commander and organizer under Moses, as the narrative seems to imply, to him was due in the first instance the remarkable change, by which within the brief space of a month the undisciplined crowd of serfs who had fled from Egypt became a force sufficiently resolute and compact to repel the onset of the Amalekite hordes. In all the arrangements for the erection and service of the tabernacle, J. the warrior naturally has no place. He is briefly named 2. The (Ex 24 13) as the minister of Moses, Minister accompanying him apparently to the of Moses _ foot of the mount of God, but remain- ing behind with the elders and Aaron and Hur, when Moses commenced the ascent. A similar brief mention is in 32 17, where he has rejoined Moses on the return of the latter from the mount with the two tables of the testimony, and is unaware of the outbreak of the people and their idolatrous worship of the molten calf in the camp; cf 33 11, where again he is found in the closest. attendance upon his leader and chief. No further reference is made to J. during the stay of the Israelites at Sinai, or their subsequent journey- ings, until they found themselves at Kadesh-barnea on the southern border of the Promised Land (Nu 13). His name is once mentioned, however, in an earlier ch of the same book (Nu 11 28), when the tidings are brought to Moses that two men in the camp of Israel, Eldad and Medad, had been in- spired to prophesy. There he is described in har- mony with the previous statements of his position, as Moses’ minister from his youth. Jealous of his leader’s prerogative and honor, he would have the irregular prophesying stopped, but is himself checked by Moses, who rejoices that the spirit of God should rest thus upon any of the Lord’s people. Of the 12 men, one from each tribe, sent forward by Moses from Kadesh to ascertain the character of the people and land before him, 8. One of two only, Hoshea the Ephraimite, the Spies whose name is significantly. changed to Joshua (13 8.16), and Caleb the Judahite, bring back a report encouraging the Israelites to proceed. The account of the mission of the spies is repeated substantially in Dt 1 22-46. There, however, the suggestion that spies should be commissioned to examine and report upon the land comes in the first instance from the people them- selves. In the record of Nu they are chosen and sent by Moses under Divine direction (13 1f). The two representations are not incompatible, still less contradictory. The former describes in an altogether natural manner the human initiative, probable enough in the circumstances in which the Israelites found themselves; the latter is the Divine control and direction, behind and ahove the affairs of men. The instructions given to the spies (vs 17 ff) evidently contemplated a hasty survey of the entire region of the Negeb or southern borderland of Pal up to and inciuding the hill country of Judaea; the time allowed, 40 days (ver 25), was too brief to accomplish more, hardly long enough for this purpose alone. They were, moreover, not only to ascertain the character of the towns and their inhabitants, the quality and products of the soil, but to bring back with them specimens of the fruits (ver 20). An indication of the season of the year is given in the added clause that “the time was the time of first-ripe grapes.’”? The usual months of the vintage are September and October (cf Lev 23 39); in the warm and sheltered valleys, however, in the neighborhood of Hebron, grapes may some- times he gathered in August or even us early as July. The valley from which the fruits, grapes, figs and pomegranates were brought was known as the valley of Eshcol, or the “cluster” (Nu 13 23 f; 32 9; Dt 1 24). No hesitating or doubtful account is given by all the spies of the fertility and attractiveness of the country; but in view of the strength of its cities and inhabitants only J. and Caleb are confident of the ability of the Israelites to take possession of it. Their reports and exhortations, however, are over- borne by the timidity and dissuasion of the others, who so entirely alarm the people that they refuse to essay the conquest of the land, desiring to return into Egypt (Nu 14 3f), and attempt to stone J. and Caleb (14 10). These two alone, therefore, were exempted from the sentence of exclusion from the Promised Land (vs 24.30.38; 26 65; 32 12; Dt 1 25 ff). The remainder of the spies perished at once by a special visitation (Nu 14 36); and the people were condemned to a 40-year exile in the wilderness, a year for each day that the spies had been in Pal, until all the men of that genera- tion ‘from twenty years old and upward” were dead (14 29; 26 64f; 32 11 ff). An abortive at- tempt was made to invade the land in defiance of the prohibition of Jeh, and ended in failure and disastrous defeat (vs 40ff; Dt 1 41 ff; cf 21 1-3). Upon the events of the next 38 or 40 years in the life of Israel an almost unbroken silence falls. The wanderers in the wilderness have no _ history. Some few events, however, that are recorded without note of time, the rebellion of Korah, Dathan and Abi- ram, and the breaking out of the plague because of the people’s murmuring, and probably others (Nu 15 32-36; 16f), appear to belong to this period. In none of them does J. take an active part, nor is his name mentioned in connection with the campaigns against Sihon and Og on the BE. of the Jordan. When the census of the people is taken in the plains of Moab opposite Jericho, J. and Caleb with Moses himself are found to be the only survivors of the host that 40 years previously came out of Egypt (26 63 ff). As the time of the death of the great leader and lawgiver drew near, he was commissioned formally to appoint J. as his successor and to hand over to him and to Eleazar the priest the duty of finally apportioning the conquered territory among the several tribes (27 18 ff; 32 28; 34 17; cf Dt 1 38; 3 28; 31 3.7.23; 349). Some of these pas- sages anticipate the direct Divine commission and encouragement recorded in Josh (1 1.5 ff) and given to him after the death of Moses. The history of J. in his new capacity as supreme head and leader of the people in several instances recapitulates as it were the history of 4. The his greater forerunner. It was not Head of the unnatural that it should be so; and People the similarity of recorded events affords no real ground for doubt with regard to the reliability of the tradition concerned. The position in which Israel now found itself on the E. of the Jordan was in some respects not unlike that which confronted Moses at Kadesh- barnea or before the crossing of the Red Sea. J., however, was faced with a problem much less diffi- cult, and in the war-tried and disciplined host at 1745 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joshua his command he possessed an instrument immensely more suitable and powerful for carrying out his purpose. (1) Sending of the spies.—His first act was to send spies from Shittim to ascertain the character of the country immediately opposite on the W. of the Jordan, and esp. the position and strength of Jericho, the frontier and fortified city which first stands in the way of an invader irom the E. who proposes to cross the river by the fords near its mouth (Josh 2 2). In Jericho the spies owed their lives to the quick inventiveness of Rahab (cf He 11 31), who concealed them on the roof of her house from the emissaries of the king; and returning to J., they reported the prospects of an easy victory and conquest (vs 23 f). There were doubtless special reasons which Induced J. to essay the crossing of the Jordan at the iower fords opposite Jericho. Higher up the river a probably easier crossing-place led directly into Central Pal, a district in which BU pron his advance would not have been obstructed by fortified cities such as confronted him farther south: which therefore would seem to offer the advantages of an open and ready entrance into the heart of the country. is decision was probably influenced by a desire to possess himself of a fortified base at Jericho and in the neighboring cities. The favorable report of the spies also proved that there would be no great diff- culty in carrying out this plan. (2) Crossing of the Jordan.—The actual crossing of the river is narrated in chs 3,4. The city of Jericho was built in a plain from 12 to 14 miles wide formed by the recession of the hills that border the valley of the Jordan from the Sea of Galilee to the Dead Sea, and stood at the mouth of the valley of Achor (7 24.26; 16 7). The modern village of Ertha is built at a short distance S.E. of the ancient site, and Gilgal lay half-way to the river. At the latter place the fixed camp was established after the taking of Jericho, and Gilgal formed for some considerable time the base of operations, where the women and children remained in safety while the men were absent on their warlike expeditions. There also the tabernacle was erected, as the symbol and center of national life, and there apparently it remained until the time came for the removal to Shiloh (18 1). : Within the plain the stream has excavated a tortuous bed to a depth of 200 ft. below the surface, varying from an eighth of a mile to a mile in breadth. In ordinary seasons the waters are confined to a small portion of the channel, which is then crossed opposite Jericho by two fords where the depth does not exceed 2 or 3 ft. When the river is low it may be erossed elsewhere. In times of flood, however, the water rises and fills the entire channel from bank to bank, so that the fords become impractica- ble. It is expressly stated that it was at such a time of flood that the Israelites approached the river, at the “time of harvest,’ or in the early spring (8 15). The priests were directed to carry the ark to the brink of the river, the waters of which, as soon as their feet. touched them, would be cut off, and a dry passage afforded. The narrative therefore is not to be understood as though it indi- cated that a wall of water stood on the right and left of the people as they crossed; the entire breadth of the river bed was exposed by the failure of the waters from above. See JoRDAN. An interesting parallel to the drying up of the Jordan before J. is recorded by an Arab. historian of the Middle Ages, who writes to explain a natural but extraordinary occurrence, without any thought of the miraculons or any apparent knowledge of the passage of the Israelites. During the years 1266-67 AD, a Mohammedan sultan named Beybars was engaged in building a bridge over the Jordan near Damieh, a place which some have identi- fled with the city Adam (Josh 3 16); but the force of the waters repeatedly carried away and destroyed his work. On one night, however, in December of the latter year, the river ceased entirely to flow. The opportunity was seized, and an army of workmen so strengthened the bridge that it resisted the flood which came down upon it the next day, and stood firm. It was found that at some distance up the river, where the valley was nar- row, the banks had been undermined by the runnin water and had fallen in, thus comiplevely, amming bac the stream. It seems not improbable that it was by agency of this character that a passage was secured for the Israelites; even as 40 years earlier a ‘‘strong east wind" had been employed to drive back the waters of the Red Sea before Moses. At the command of J., under Divine direction, the safe crossing of the Jordan was commemorated by the erection at Gilgal of 12 stones (4 3-9.20 ff), one for each of the tribes of Israel, taken from the bed of the river. In ver 9itisstated that 12 stones were set up in the midst of the river. The state- ment is probably a misunderstanding, and a mere confusion of the tradition. It is not likely that there would be a double commemoration, or an erection of stones in a place where they would never be seen. At Gilgal also the supply of manna ceased, when the natural resources of the country became available (5 12). The date of the passage is given as the 10th day of the Ist month (4 19); and on the 14th day the Passover was kept at Gilgal in the plains of Jericho (6 10). For the 2d time, also, at the crisis of the first entrance into the land J. was encouraged for his work by a vision and Divine promise of assistance and direction (6 13-15). (3) Capture of Jericho—The narrative that follows, of the taking of Jericho, illustrates, as would naturally be expected in the case of a city so sit- uated, the effeminate and unwarlike character of its inhabitants. There was apparently little or no fighting, while for a whole week J. with priests and people paraded before the walls. III. Tut Duat Monarcuy War between Two Kingdoms . First Reform of Religion Two Kingdoms at Peace Two Kingdoms Contrasted __ . Revolution in the Northern Kingdom . Effect on the Southern Kingdom Davidic House at Lowest Ebb . Begins to Recover 9. Reviving Fortunes 10. Monarchy Still Elective 11. Government by Regents 12. Period of Great Prosperity 13. Rise of Priestly Caste 14. Advent of Assyria 15, Judah a Protectorate _ 16. Cosmopolitan Tendencies IV. Periop oF DECLINE 1. Judah Independent 2. Reform of Religion 3. Egypt and Judah 4. Traffic in Horses 5. Reaction under Manasseh 6. Triumph of Reform Party 7. Babylonia and Judah | 8. End of Assyrian Empire 9. After Scythian Invasion 10. Judah Again Dependent 11. Prophets Lose Influence 12. The Deportations 13. Summary I, Canaan before the Monarchy.—Some 4,000 years BC the land on either side of the valley of the Jordan was peopled by a race who, to whatever stock they belonged, were not Semites. CONT Crim GON 1. The It was not until about the year 2500 BC Coming that the tide of Sem immigration began of the to flow from North Arabia into the coun- Semites tries watered by the Jordan and the Euphrates. One of the first waves in this human tide consisted of the Phoeni- cians who settled in the N.W., on the seashore; they were closely followed by other Can. tribes who occupied the country which long bore their name. The Canaanites are known to us chiefly from the famous letters found at Tell Amarna in Egypt which describe the political state of the country 2. The during the years 1415-1360 BC—the C: it! years of the reigns of Amenophis ITI and anaamites [V. Canaan was at this time slipping out ‘ of the hands of Egypt. The native princes were in revolt: tribute was withheld; and but few Egyp garrisons remained. Meantime a fresh tide of invasion was hurling its waves against the eastern frontiers of the land. The newcomers were, like their predecessors, Sem Bedawin from the Syrian desert. Among them the Am Tab name the Chabiri, who are, no doubt, the people known to us as the Hebrews. The Hebrews are so named by those of other nation- ality after one of their remoter ancestors soon 10 24), or because they had come from beyond 8. The (Cébher) the Jordan or the Euphrates. Of Israelite themselves they spoke collectively as Israel. Israel was a name assumed by Confederacy the eponymous hero of the nation whose real name was Jacob. Similarly the Arablan prophet belonged to the tribe called from its ancestor Koraish, whose name was Fibr. The people of Israel were a complex of some 12 or 13 tribes. These 12 trlbes were divided into two main sections, one sec- tion tracing its descent from Leah, one of Jacob’s wives, and the other section tracing its descent from Rachel, his other wife. The names of the tribes which claimed to be descended from Leah were Reuben, Simeon, Levi, Judah, Issachar, Zebuiun, and, indirectly, Gad and Asher; those which claimed to be descended from Rachel were Joseph, which was divided into two clans; Eph- raim_ and Manasseh, Benjamin, and, indirectly, Dan and Naphtali. The rivalry between these two’ ercat divisions runs all through the national history of the Hebrews, and was only brought to anend by the annihi- lation of one of the pppoatng tackions (Isa 11 13). But not only was the Israelitish nation a combination of many clans; it was united also to other tribes which could not claim descent from Israel or Jacob. Such tribes were the'Kenites and the Calebites. Toward such the pure Israelite tribes formed asort of aristocracy, very much as, to change the parallel, the tribe of Koraish did among the Arabs. It was rarely that a commander was appointed from the allied tribes, at least in the ear- lier years of the national life, We find exactly the same state of things obtaining in the history of the Arabian conquests. All through that history there runs the rivalry between the 4, Migra- South Arabian_ tribes descended from tion into Kahtan (the Heb Joktan, Gen 10 25, etc) ‘and the northern or Ishmaelite tribes Canaan of Modar. It is often stated that the 2 OT contains two separate and irrecon- cilable accounts of the ey ale of Canaan by the Is- raeclites. According to the Book of Josh, it is’ said the 1759 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judah Judah, Kingdom invaslon was a movement of the whole people of Israel under the leadership of Joshua; aucordine PS the Book of Jgs, It consisted of a series of expeditions made by Individual tribes each on its own account (Jgs 1 2.10, etc). But agaln, in the history of the Arabs we find proces, the same apparent discrepancy. For Persia, yria and Egypt were conquered by the Arabs as a whole; but at the same tlme no tribe lost its Individuality; each tribe made expeditions on Its own account, and turned its arms agalnst rival tribes even in the enemy’s country. On the confines of China in the E. and in Spain on the W., the arms of the Yemen’s trlbes were employed in the destruction of those of Modar as fiercely as ever they had been within Arabia itself. The bond which united the Israelite tribes, as well as those of Kayin (the eponym of the Kenites) and Caleb, was that of the common worship of Jeh. 5. The As Mohammed united all the Fribes of Bond of Arabia into one whole by the doctrine of Uni monotheism, so did Moses the Israclite mon. tribes by giving them a common object ; of worship. And the sherifs or descend- ants of ‘Ali today occupy a position very like what the Levites and the descendants of Aaron must have maln- tained in Israel. In order to keep the Israelite nation pure, intermarriage with the inhabitants of the invaded country was forbidden, though the prohibition was not observed (Jgs 3 5f). So too, the Arab women were not permitted to marry non-Arabs during the first years of conquest. It is customary to date the beginning of monarchy in Israel from Saul the son of Kish, but in point of fact many early leaders were kings in fact if 6. Early not in name, Moses and Joshua may be Rul compared with Mohammed and his caliph Le (properly khaltfa) or ‘‘successor,’’ Abu Bekr. Their word was law; they reigned supreme over a united nation. Moreover, the word “king” (melekh) often means, both in Heb and Arab., nothing more than governor of a town, or local resident. There was more than one ‘‘king’’ of Midian (Jgs 8 12). Balak seems to have been only a king of Moab (Nu 22 4), Before the monarchy proper, the people of Israel formed, in theory, a theocracy, as did also the Arabs under the caliphs. n reality they, were ruled 7. The by Temporary kings called judges (sho- ud phét, the Carthaginian sufes), Their Judges office was not hereditary, though there were exceptions (cf Jgs 9). On the other hand, the government of the Northern Kingdom of Israel was practically an elective monarchy, so rarely were there more than two of the same dynasty. The judge again was usually appointed in order to meet some special crises, and the theoretically ideal state of things ‘was one in which there was no visible head of the state— a@ republic without a president. These intervals, how- ever, always ended in disaster, and the eppelaiaaent ot another judge. The first king also was elected to cope with a specially serious crisis. The main distinction between judge and king was that the former, less than the latter, obscured the fact of the true King, upon the recognition of whom alone the continued existence of the uation depended. The rulers then became the ‘‘elders’’ or sheilchs of the tribes, and as these did not act in unison, the nation lost its solidarity and became an easy prey to any invader. During the period of the Judges a new factor entered into the disturbed politics of Canaan. This was an invader who came not from the eastern 8. Heredi- 0d southern deserts, but from the west- ‘i ; ern sea. Driven out of Crete by invaders tary Kings from the mainland, the last remnants ot the race of Minos found refuge on the shores of the country which ever after took from them the name it still bears—Philistin or Palestine. At the same time the Ammonites and Midianites were pee ne into the country from the E. (i 8 11)... Caught between these two opposing forces, the tribes of Israel were threat- ened with destruction. It was felt that the temporary sovereignty of the judge was no longer equal to the sit- uation. The supreme authority must be permanent. It was thus the monarchy was founded. Three motives are given by tradition as leading ie to this step. The pretext alleged by the elders or sheikhs is the worthless- ness and incapacity of Samuel’s sons, who he intended should succeed him (1 8 8). The immediate canse was the double pressure from the Philis (1 S 9 16) and the Ammonite king (12 12). The real reason was that the system of government by elective kings or judges had proved a failure and had completely broken down. The times called for a hereditary monarchy. ‘IL The First Three Kings.—The most warlike of the clans of Israel shortly before this had been that of Benjamin—one of the Rachel 1. The tribes. The national sanctuary, with Benjamite the ark and the grandson of Aaron as King priest, was at Bethel in their territory. Moreover, they had defeated the combined forces of the other tribes in two pitched battles. They had at last been defeated and almost exterminated, but they had recovered much of their strength and prestige (Jgs 20; 1S 4 12). From this tribe the first king was chosen (see Sau). He, however, proved unequal to his task. After some years spent in war with the Philis and in repressing euponed disloyalty at home, he was defeated and illed. Meantime, one of the less-known clans was coming to the front. ‘The territory of the tribe of J.layim the 8. After its occupation (ef Jgs 1 2.3), the tribe of J. appears to have settled down to the care of its flocks and herds. It is not mentioned in the Song of Deborah. None of the judges be- longed to it, unless Ibzan, who seems to have been of little account (Jgs 12 8f). Under the leadership of Davin (q.v.), this tribe now came to the front, and proved in the end to be endowed with by far the greatest vitality of all the tribes. It outlived them all, and survives to this day. The Rachel tribes, led by Benjamin and Ephraim (2 S 2,3), resisted for some time the hegemony of J., but were obliged in the end to 2. Rachel submit. Under David Israel became and Leah again a united whole. By making Tribes Jerus his capital on the borders of J. and Benjamin, he did much to insure the continuance of this union (cf 1 Ch 9 3). The union, however, was only on the surface. By play- ing off the Rachel tribes, Benjamin and Ephraim, against the rest, Absalom was able to bring the whole structure to the ground (2 § 16 ff), the tribe to which Saul belonged being esp. disloyal (2 § 16 5 ff). Nor was this the only occasion on which the smoldering enmity between the two houses burst out into flame (2 5 20). As soon as the strong hand of David was removed, disaffection showed itself in several quarters (1 K 11 14 ff), and esp. the aspiration of the tribe of Ephraim, after independence was fomented by the prophets (11 26 ff). Egypt afforded a convenient asylum for the disaffected until opportunity should ripen. They had not long to wait. Solomon was succeeded by Rehoboam, who found it politic to hold a coronation ceremony at Shechem as well, presumably, as at Jerus. 3. The Dis- The malcontents found themselves ruption strong enough to dictate terms. These Rehoboam rejected, and the northern tribes at once threw off their allegiance to the dynasty of David. The disruption thus created in the Israelite nation was never again healed. The secession was like that of the Moors in Spain from the ‘Abb4sid caliphs. Henceforth “Israel,” except in the Chronicler, denotes the Northern Kingdom only. In that writer, who does not recognize the kingdom of the ten tribes, it means Judah. It is usual at the present day to recognize in the Northern Kingdom the true Israelite kingdom. Certainly in point of extent of territory and_in resources it was far the greater of the two. But as regards intellectual power and influence, even down to the present day, not to mention continuity of dynasty, the smaller kingdom is by far the more important. It is, therefore, treated here as the true representa- tive of the nation. Lying, as it did, in the imme- diate vicinity of Jerus, the tribe of Benjamin could hardly do otherwise than throw in its lot with that of J. Bethel, which became one of the religious capitals of the Northern Kingdom, although nomi- nally within their territory, in fact belonged to Ephraim (Jgs 1 22 ff). With this union of op- posing interests may be compared that of the ‘Alids and ‘Abbasids, both belonging to the house of Mo- hammed and both aspirants to the caliphate, against the house of Umeiya. Judah, Kingdom THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1760 HI, The Dual Monarchy.—Rehoboam made no decisive attempt to bring back the recalcitrant tribes to their ‘allegiance (i K 12 21 ff), 1. War though the two countries made raids, between one upon the other (14 30). For his Two King- own security he built numerous for- doms tresses, the remains of some of which ‘have, it is probable, been recovered within recent years (2 Ch 11 5 ff). These excited the suspicion of Shishak of Egypt, who invaded the country and reduced it to vassalage (1 K 14 25 ff). Under Rehoboam’s son Abijah, actual war broke out between the two kingdoms (165 6 as cor- rected in ver 7; 2 Ch 13). The war was con- tinued during the long reign of his son Asa, whose opponent, Baasha, built a fort some 6 miles N. of Jerus in order to cut off that city from com- munication with the N. Asa confessed his weak- ness by appealing for help to Ben-hadad of Damas- cus. The end justified the means. The fort was demolished. The reign of Asa is also remarkable for the first of those reformations of worship which recur at intervals throughout the history of the 2. First Southern Kingdom. The high places Reform of were not yet, however, considered ille- Religion gitimate (1 K 165 14; but ef 2 Ch 14 5). He also, like his grandfather, was a builder of castles, and with a similar, though more fortunate, result (2 Ch 14 6.9ff). Asa’s old age and illness helped to bring to the rival kingdoms peace which lasted beyond his own reign (1 K 5 23). An effect of this peace is seen in the expanding foreign trade of the country under his successor Jehoshaphat. He rebuilt the navy as 3. Two in the days of Solomon, but a storm Kingdoms ruined the enterprise (i K 22 48f). at Peace During this reign the two kingdoms came nearer being united than they had done since the disruption. largely due to the Northern Kingdom having been greatly weakened by the wars with Syria and Assyria, and having given up the idea of annexing the smaller country. Moreover, Jehoshaphat had married his son Joram (Jehoram) to Ahab’s daughter Athaliah. From a religious point of view, the two states reacted upon one another. Jehoram of Israel inaugurated a reformation of worship in the North- ern Kingdom, and at the same time that of J. was brought into line with the practice of the sister kingdom (2 K 8 18). The peace, from a political point of view, did much to strengthen both countries, and enabled them to render mutual assistance against the common foe. Up to the death of Jehoram of Israel, which synchro- nized with that of Joram and Ahaziah of J., 6 kings had reigned In J. Of these the first 4 died in their beds and were buried in their own 4, Two mausoleum. During the same period of Kingdoms about 90 years there were in Israel 9 kings Contrasted divided into 4 dynasties. The second king of the Ist Dynasty was immediate] assassinated and the entire family annihi- lated. Precisely the same fate overtook the IId Dy- nasty. Then followed a civil war in which two pre- tenders were killed, one perishing by his own hand. ‘he IIId Dynasty lasted longer than the first two and counted 4 kings. Of these one was defeated and killed in battie and another assassinated. The fate of the kings of Israel is very like that of the middle and later ‘Abbasid caliphs. The murder of his brothers by the Judaean Jehoram, a proceeding once regular with the sultans of Turkey, must also be put down to the Influence of his Israelite wife. It was obvious that a crisis was impending. Edom and Libnah had thrown off their allegiance, and the Philis had attacked and plundered Jerus, even the king’s sons being taken prisoners, with the exception of the youngest (2 Ch 21 16). More- over, the two kingdoms had become so elosely This was no doubt . united, not only by intermarriage, but also in religion and politics, that they must stand and fall together. The hurricane which swept 6. Revolu- away the northern dynasty also carried tion in the off the members of the southern royal Northern house more nearly connected with Kingdom Ahab, and the fury of the queen- mother Athaliah made the destruction complete (2 K 11 1). ; For 6 years the daughter of Ahab held sway in Jerus. The only woman who sat on the throne of David was a daughter of the hated 6. Effect Ahab. In her uniqueness, she thus on the holds a place similar to that of Shejer Southern ed-Durr among the Memldk sultans Kingdom of Egypt. The character of her reign is not described, but it can easily be iapeined She came to her inevitable end 6 years ater. Successive massacres had reduced the descend- ants of David until only one representative was left. Jehoram, the last king but one, had 7. Davidic murdered all his brothers (2 Ch 21 House at 4); the Arab marauders had killed Lowest Ebb his sons except the youngest (22 1; ef 2117). The youngest, Ahaziah, after the death of his father, was, with 42 of his “brethren,” executed by Jehu (2 K 10 14). Fi- nally, Athaliah “destroyed all the_seed royal.” The entente with the Northern Kingdom had brought the Davidic dynasty to the brink of extinction. But just as ‘Abd er-Rahm4n escaped from the slaughter of the Umeiyads to found a new dynasty in Spain, so the Davidic dynasty made 8. Begins a fresh start under Joash. The church to Recover had saved the state, and naturally the years that followed were years in which the religious factor bulked large. The temple of Baal which Athaliah had built and sup- ported was wrecked, the idols broken, and the priest killed: A fund was inaugurated for the repair of the national temple. The religious enthusiasm, however, quickly cooled. The priests were found to be diverting the fund for the restoration of the temple to their own uses. A precisely similar diversion of public funds occurred in connection with the Karawtyin mosque in Fez under the Almoravids in the 12th cent. The reign which had begun with so much promise ended in clouds and darkness (2 K 12 17 ff; 2 Ch 24 17 ff; Mt 23 35), and Joash was the first of the Judaean kings to be assassinated by his own people (2 K 12 20f). By a curious coincidence, a new king ascended the throne of Syria, of Israel and of Judah about the same time. The death of: Hazael, 9. Reviving and accession of Ben-hadad III led Fortunes _to a revival in the fortunes of both of the Israelite kingdoms. The act of clemency with which Amaziah commenced his reign (2 K 14 5.6; Dt 24 16) presents a pleasing contrast to the moral code which had come to pre- vail in the sister kingdom; and the story of his hiring mercenaries from the Ephraimite kingdom (2 Ch 25 5-10) sheds a curious light on the relations subsisting between the two countries, and even on those times generally. It is still more curious to find him, some time after, sending, without provoca- tion, a challenge to Jehoash; and the capture and release of Amaziah evinces some rudimentary ideas of chivalry (2 K 14 8 ff). The chief event of the reign was the reconquest of Edom and taking of Petra (2 K 14 7). The principle of the election of kings by the people was in force in Judah, although it seemed to be in 1761 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judah, Kingdom abeyance since the people were content to limit their choice to the Davidie line. But it was exercised when occasion required. 10. Mon- Joash had been chosen by the popu- archy Still lace, and it was they who, when the Elective public discontent culminated in the assassination of Amaziah, chose his 16-year-old son Uzziah (or Azariah) to succeed him. The minority of the king involved something equivalent to a regency. As Jehoiada at first carried on the government for Joash, 11. Govern- so Uzziah was at first under the tutelage ment by of Zechariah (2 Ch 26 5), and the Regents latter part of his reign was covered b _ by the regency of his son Jotham. It is obvious that with the unstable dynasties of the north, such government by deputy would have been impracticable. The reign of Uzziah (2 Ch 26) was one of the most glorious in the annals of the Judacan king- : dom. The Philis and southern Arabs, 12. Period who had been so powerful in the of Great reign of Jehoram, were subdued, and Prosperity other Bedawin were held in check. The frontiers were strengthened with numerous castles. Now that Edom was again annexed, the Red Sea trade wasresumed. Irriga- tion was attended to, and the agricultural resources of the country were developed. Uazziah also estab- lished a standing army, properly equipped and trained. Artillery, in the shape of catapults and other siege engines, was manufactured. It is ob- vious that in this reign we have advanced far be- yond the earlier and ruder times. In this and the preceding reigns, we notice also how the priests are becoming a distinct and power- ful caste. Zadok and Abiathar were 18. Rise of no more than the domestic chaplains Priestly of David. The kings might at pleasure Caste discharge the functions of the priest. But the all-powerful position of Je- hoiada seems to have given the order new life; and in the latter part of the reign of Uzziah, king and priest come into conflict, and the king comes off second-best (2 Ch 26 16 ff). ; ? Uzziah is the first king of J. to be mentioned in the Assyr annals. He was fighting against “Pul” in the years 742-740. The advent of the 14. Advent great eastern power upon the scene of of Assyria Judaean politics could end but in one way—as it was soon to do with Israel also. The reign of Jotham may be passed over as it coincided almost entirely with that of his father. But in the following reign we find J. already paying tribute to Assyria in the year of the fall of Damas- cus and the conquest of the East-Jordan land, the year 734. . During the regency of Jotham, the effeminacy and luxury of the Northern Kingdom had already begun to infect the Southern (Mic 1 9; 15. Judah a 6 16), and under the irresolute Ahaz Protectorate the declension went on rapidly. This rapprochement in morals and customs did not prevent Israel under Pekah joining with Rezin of Syria against J., with no less an object than to subvert the dynasty by placing an Ara~ maean on the throne (Isa 7 6). What the result might have been, had not Isaiah taken the reins out of Ahaz’ hands, it is impossible to say. As it was, J. felt the strain of the conflict for many a year. The country was invaded from other points, and many towns were lost, some of which were never recovered (2 Ch 28 17 ff). In despair Ahaz placed himself and his country under the protection of Assyria (2 K 16 7 ff). : iy: It was a part of the cosmopolitan tendencies of the time that the worship became tarnished with foreign innovations (2 K 16 10). The temple for the first time in its history was closed (2 Ch 28 24). Altars of Baal were set up in all the 16. Cosmo- open spaces of Jerus, each representing politan some urban god (Jer 11 13). About Tendencies the closing of the temple Isaiah would not be greatly concerned. Perhaps it was his suggestion (cf Isa 1). The priests who were supreme in the preceding reigns had lost their influence: their place had been taken by the prophets. The introduction of Baalism, however, was no doubt due to Ahaz alone. IV. Period of Decline.—The following reign— that of Hezekiah—was, perhaps as 2 result of the disappearance of the Northern King- 1. Judah dom, a period of reformation. Isaiah Inde- is now supreme, and the history of the pendent times will be found in his biography. It must have been with a sigh of relief that Hezekiah saw the Northern Kingdom dis- appear forever from the scene. The relations of the two countries had been too uniformly hostile to make that event anything but an omen for good. It was no doubt due to Isaiah that Hezekiah sought to recover the old independence of his country. Their patriotism went near to be their own undoing. Sennacherib invaded Pal, and Hezekiah found him- self shorn of everything that was outside the walls of Jerus. Isaiah’s patriotism rose to the occasion; the invading armies melted away as by a miracle; J. was once more free (2 K 18 13 ff). A curious result of Sennacherib’s invasion was the disappearance of the high places—local shrines where Levitical priests officiated in 2. Reform opposition to those of the temple. of Religion When the Judaean territories were limited to the city, these of necessity vanished, and, when the siege waa over, they were not restored. They were henceforward regarded as illegal. It is generally held by scholars that this reform occurred later under Josiah, on the discovery of the ‘‘Book of the Law” by Hilkiah in the temple (2 K 22 8), and that this book was Dt. The high places, however, are not mentioned in the law book of Dt. The reform was probably the work of Isaiah, and due to considerations of morals. The Judaeans had always had a friendly feeling toward Egypt. When the great eastern power became threatening, it was to Egypt 3. Egypt they turned for safety. Recent exca- and Judah vation has shown that the influence of Egypt upon the life and manners of Pal was very great, and that that of Assyria and Babylonia was comparatively slight, and generally confined to the N. In the reign of Hezekiah a powerful party proposed an alliance with Egypt with the view of check-mating the designs of Assyria (2 K 17 4; Isa 30 2.3; 31 1). Hezekiah followed Isaiah’s advice in rejecting all alliances. The commercial and other ties which bound Pal to Egypt were much stronger than those between Pal and e East. One of the most considerable 4, Traffic of these was the trade in horses. This ee traffic had been begun by Solomon (1 K in Horses 10 28f). The chict seat of the trade in Pal_was_Lachish (Mic 1 13). In their nomadic state the Israelites had used camels and donkeys, and the use of the horse was looked upon with suspicion by the prophets (Dt 17 16; Zec 9 10). When the horse is spoken of in the OT, it is as the chief weapon of the enemies of the nation (Ex 15 1; Jgs 5 22, etc). On the death of Hezekiah, the nation reverted to the culture and manners of the time of Ahaz and even went farther than he in corrupt 6. Reaction practices. Esp. at this time human under sacrifice became common in Israel (Mic Manasseh 6 7). The influence for good of the prophets had gone (2 K 21). There is a curious story in 2 Ch 33 11f that Manasseh Judah, Kingdom [ym INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judah, Territory 1762 was taken captive by the Assyrians, and, after spending some time in eaptivity in Babylon, re- formed and was restored to his throne. His son, however, undid these reforms, and public discon- tent grew to such an extent that he was assassinated (2 KK 24 19 ff). Once more the tide turned in the direction of reform, and on this occasion it rose higher than ever before. The reformation under Josiah 6. Triumph was never again wholly undone. The of Reform enthusiasm of the iconoclasts carried Party them far beyond the frontiers of Judah (2 Ch 34 6), for on this oceasion they were backed up by the newly found ‘Book of the Law.” All boded well for a prosperous reign, but unforeseen disasters came from without. The Scythian invasion swept over Southwestern Asia (Jer 1 14-16; 6 1, etc). The storm passed, and hope rose higher than before, for the power of Assyria had been shattered forever. Already in 722, when Sargon seized the throne on the death of Shalmaneser, Babylonia had re- volted, and crowned Marduk-baladan 7. Baby- king (Isa 39 1). Hezekiah received lonia and a deputation from Babylonia (2 K Judah 20 12 ff), no doubt in the hope of freeing himself from the Assyr danger by such an alliance. The revolt of Merodach- baladan was maintained for 12 years; then it was suppressed. There was, however, a second revolt of Babylonia on the accession of Sennacherib, Sar- gon’s son, in 705, which went on till 691, and the events referred to in 2 K 20 may have happened at this time, for Hezekiah’s reign seems to have ended prosperously. Sennacherib was assassinated in 681 (Isa 87 38) and was succeeded by his son Esar-haddon, who rebuilt Babylon, razed to the ground 8. Endof by his father, and under whom the Assyrian province remained quiet. In 674 hos- Empire tilities with Egypt broke out, and that country was overrun, and TirmaKan (q.v.) was expelled in 670. Two years later, however, occurred the revolt of Egypt and the death of Esar-haddon. Assur-bani-pal succeeded, and Egypt regained her independence in 660. The revolt of Babylonia, the incursion of the Scythians (Jer 1 14 ff) and the death of Assur-bani-pal fol- lowed. Two more kings sat on the throne of Assyria, and then Nineveh was taken by the com- bined Scythians (Mandor) and Babylonians (Herod. i.74; Nah; Zeph 2 13-15; Hab 1 5f). The Seythian tempest passed quickly, and when it was over the Assyr peril was no more. Pharaoh- necoh seized the opportunity to avenge 9. After the injuries of his country by the inva- Scythian sion of the erstwhile Assyr territories. Invasion Josiah, pursuing the policy of alliance with Babylonia inaugurated by Heze- kiah, endeavored to arrest his progress. He was aioe and mortally wounded at Megiddo (Zee 12 11). By the foolhardy action of Josiah, J. lost its inde- pendence. The people, indeed, elected Jehoahaz (Shallum) king, but he was imme- 10. Judah diately deposed and earried to Egypt Again De- by the Pharaoh (Jer 22 10 ff; Ezk pendent 19 3f), who appointed Jehoiakim (Eliakim) as vassal-king. After the defeat of the Pharaoh at Carchemish, the old Hittite stronghold, by Nebuchadrezzar, Jehoia- kim submitted, and J. became a dependency of Babylon. There must have been some return of prosperity, for Jehoiakim is denounced for his luxury and extravagance and oppressive taxation (Jer 22 13 ff), but the country was raided by the neighboring Bedawin (2 K 24 2), and Jehoiakim came to an untimely end (Jer 22 19). , The prophets were no longer, as under Hezekiah, all-powerfulin the state. The influence of Jeremiah was no doubt great, but the majority 11. Prophets was against him. His program was Lose In- both unpopular in itself and it had fluence the fatal defect of being diametrically opposed to that of Isaiah, the patriot- politician (if such there be), who had saved the state from shipwreck. Isaiah had preached reliance upon the national God and through it the political independence of the nation. It was the sad duty of Jeremiah to advise the surrender of the national independence to the newly risen power of Babylon. (Jer 21 4.9; 38 2, etc). Isaiah had held that the Holy City was impregnable (2 K 19 32); Jeremiah was sure that it would be taken by the Chaldaeans (Jer 32 24.43). Events proved that each prophet was right for the time in which he lived. Jehoiakim was the only Judaean king who was a vassal first to one overlord and then to another. J. took a step downward in his reign. 12. The It was under him also that the first Deporta- deportation of the Judaeans oeeurred tions (Dnl 1 1-17). He was succeeded by his son Jehoiachin who, on account of a rebellion which closed the reign of his father, was ere long deported, along with the best of the nation (Jer 22 24 ff; Ezk 19 5ff), A 3d son of Josiah, Mattaniah, was set on the throne under the title of Zedekiah. Against the advice of Jeremiah, this, the last king of J., declared himself independent of Babylon, and threw in his lot with Egypt under Pharaoh Hophra (Apries), thus breaking his oath of fealty (Ezk 17 15 ff). On the advance of the Chaldaeans, J. was deserted by her allies, the Edom- ites and Philis (see Boox or Os), and soon only Lachish (Tell el-Hesy), Azekah (probably Tell Zaka- rya) and Jerus remained in the hands of Zedekiah. The siege of the city lasted two years. It was taken on the fatal 9th of Ab in the year 586. Zedekiah’s family was put to the sword, and he himself was taken to Babylon. Egypt shared the fate of J., with whom she had been often so closely connected, and Hophra was the last of the Pharaohs. The kingdom of J. had lasted 480 years, counting from its commencement, exactly twice as long as the kingdom of Israel, counting from 13. Sum- the disruption. No doubt this longer mary existence was due in the first place to the religious faith of the people. This is clear from the fact that the national religion not only survived the extinction of the nation, but spread far beyond its original territories and has endured down to the present day. But there were also circumstances which conspired to foster the growth of the nation in its earliest and most critical period. One of these was the comparative isola- tion and remoteness of the country. Neither the kingdom of Israel nor that of Judah is for a moment to be compared to those of Egypt and Assyria. Even the combined kingdom under David and Sol- omon hardly deserves that comparison; and sepa- rate, the Northern Kingdom would be about the size of New Hampshire and the Southern Kingdom about that of Connecticut. Thesmaller kingdom survived the larger because it happened to be slightly farther removed from the danger zone. Even had the two kingdoms held together, it is impossible that they could have withstood the expansion of Assyria and Babylonia on the one side and of Egypt on the other. The Egyp party in Judaean polities in the times of Isaiah and Jeremiah were so far in the right, that, if J. could have maintained her inde- pendence in alliance with Egypt, these two countries combined might have withstood the power of 1763 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judah, Kingdom Judah, Territory Assyria or Babylon. But it is because this ancient race, tracing its descent from remote antiquity, preserved its religious, at the expense of its national, independence, that its lit. continues to mold much of the thought of Europe and America today. See Isrant, Kinepom or, Tsomas Hunter WEIR JUDAH, TERRITORY OF (TAM, yehadhah): I. Grooraraicat Data 1. The Natural Boundaries 2. The Natural Divisions of Judah (1) The Maritime Plain (2) The Shephelah (3) The Hill Country of Judah II. Tue Tries or Jupau anv Its Territory III. Tse Bounparins or tun Kinepom or Jupan Literature I. Geographical Data.—Although the physical conformation of Western Pal divides this land into very definite areas running longitudinally N. and §., yet all through history there has been a recognition of a further—and politically more important— division into 3 areas running transversely, known in NT times as Galilee, Samaria and Judaea. These districts are differentiated to some extent by dis- tinctive physical features which have in no small degree influenced the history of their inhabitants. The southernmost of these regions possesses on 3 sides very definite natural boundaries: to the W. the Medi- terranean, to the E. the Dead Sea, aud 1. The the Jordan, and to the S. 60 miles, N. to 8., Natural of practically trackless desert, a frontier at as secure as sea or mountain range. On Boundaries the N. no such marked “‘scientific frontier” exists, and on this the one really accessible side, history bears witness that tho frontier has heen pushed backward and forward. The most ideal natural northern frontier, which only became the actual one com- paratively late in Heb times (see Jupana), is that which passes from the river ‘Aujeh in the W., up the Wady Deir Balat, by the wide and deep Wdady Ishar to' Akrabbeh and thence E. to the Jordan. A second natural frontier com- mences at the same line on the W., but after following the Wady Deir Baldt, branches off southward along the Wady Nimr (now traversed by the modern carriage road frem Jerus to Nablés), crosses the water-parting close to thelofty Tell Asha@r, and runs successively down the Wddy Sanieh and the W ddy' Aujeh and hy the eastern river‘ Aujeh to the Jordan. This division-line is one conformahle to the physical features, hecause north of it the table-lands of “*Judaea”’ give place to the more broken mountain groups of * Samaria.”’ Auother less natural, though much more historic, frontier is that which traverses the Valeof Ajalon, follows the Beth-horon pass, and, after crossing the cen- tral plateau near el Jib (Gibeon) and er Ram (Ramah of Benjamin), ruus down the deep and rugged Waddy Suweintt, between Jeba' (Geha) and Mukhmas (Mich- mash), to Jericho and the Jordan. It_was along this line that the great frontier fortresses, Bethel, Gibeon, Ramah, Adasa, Geba and_Michmash, were erected. Such, on the N., S., E., and W., were the natural bound- aries of the southern third of Pal; yet in all history the laud thus inclosed scarcely ever formed a homogeneous whole. Within these boundaries lay four very different types of land—the maritime plain, the “lowland” or Shephelah, the “hill country” and, 2. The Nat-included usually with the last, the ural Divi- desert or Jeshimon. : sions of (1) The maritime plain, the “land Judah of the Philis’ (1 $8 61; 271; 2K 8 2; Zeph 2 5), was ideally though never actually, the territory of Judah (cf Josh 15 45-47); it may have been included, as it is by some modern writers, as part of the Shephelah, but this jg not the usual use of the word. It is a great stretch of level plain or rolling downs of very fertile soil, capable of supporting a thriving population and cities of considerable size, esp. near the sea- coast. , b: (2) The Shephelah (sh¢phelah), or “lowland” of Judah (Dt 17; Josh 91; 112.16; 15 33-44; 1K 10 27; 1 Ch 27 28; Jer 17 26).—In_ these references the word is variously rendered in AV, usually as ‘‘vale” or ‘valley,’ sometimes, as in the last two, as “plain.” In RV the usual rendering is “lowland.” In 1 Macc 12 38, AV has ‘“Shephela”’ | and R “plain country.’ The word ‘Shephelah” appears to survive in the Arab. Sifla about Beti Jebrin. This is a very important region in the history of Judah. It ls a district consisting mainly of rounded hills, 500- 800 ft. high, with fertile open valleys full of corn flelds; caves abound, and there are abundant evidences of a once crowded population. Situated as it is between the ‘hill country ’’ and the maritime plaln, it was the scene of frequent skirmishes between the Hebrews and_ the Philis; Judah failed to hold it against the Philis who kept it durlng most of their history. © Shephelah Is some- what sharply divided off from the central mountain mass by a remarkable series of palleve running N. and 8. Commencing at the Vale of Ajalon and passing 8., we have in succession the Wddy el Ghurdb and, after crossing the Wddy es Siwdn, the Wddy en Najil, the Wady es Sunt (Elah) and the Wady es Sar. It 1s noticeable that the western extremity of the most historic northern frontier of ancient Judah—that limited hy the Vale of Ajalon in the W.—appears to have heen determined by the presence of this natural feature. N, of this the hills of Samaria flatten out to the plain without any such intervening valleys. (3) The hill country of Judah is by far the most characteristic part of that tribe’s possessions; it was on account of the shelter of these mountain fastnesses that this people managed to hold their own against their neighbors and hide away from the conquering armies of Assyria and Egypt. No other section of the country was so secluded and protected by her natural borders. It was the environment of these bare hills and rugged valleys which did much to form the character and influence the lit. of the Jews. The hill country is an area well defined, about 35 miles long and some 15 broad, and is protected on three sides by natural frontiers of great strength; on the N. alone it has no “scientific frontier.”’ On the 8. lay the Negeb, and beyond that the almost waterless wilderness, a barrier con- sisting of a series of stony hills running E. and W., difficult for a caravan and almost impracticable for an army. On the W. the hills rise sharply from those valleys which delimit them from the Shephe- lah, but they are pierced by a series of steep and rugged defiles which wind upward to the central table-land. At the northwestern corner the Beth- horon pass—part of the northern frontier line— runs upward from the wide Vale of Ajalon; this route, the most historic of all, has been associated with a succession of defeats inflicted by those hold- ing the higher ground (see Bretu-HoRon). 8S. of this is the Wady ‘Ali, up which runs the modern carriage road to Jerus, and still farther S. lies the winding rocky defile, up part of which the railway from Jaffa is laid, the Wady es Surdr. A more im- portant valley, because of its width and easier gradient, is the great Vale of Hlah (Waddy eg Sunt), to guard the highest parts of which (now the Wady es Sar) was built the powerful fortress of Beth-zur (2 Ch 11 7, etc), which Jos (Ani, XIII, v, 6) de- scribes as ‘‘the strongest place in all Jndaea’’ (see Bets-zur). Up this pass the Syrians successfully with the aid of elephants (Ant, XII, ix, 4) invaded Judaea. The eastern frontier of the hill country is one of extraordinary natural strength. Firstly, there were the Jordan and the Dead Sea; then along all but the northernmost part of the eastern frontier lay a long line of semi-precipitous cliffs, in places over 1,000 ft. high, absolutely unscalable and pierced at long intervals by passes all steep and dangerous. Within this again came a wide area of waterless and barren desert, the Wilderness of Judah (or Judaea) known in EV as Jgsuimon (q.v.). To the northeasterly part of the frontier, where the ascent from the Jericho plain to the mountains presents no special difficulty in gradation, the waterless condition of the Jeshimon greatly restricted the possible routes for an enemy. The natural position for the first line of defence was the fortified city of Jericho, but as a froutier fortress Judah, Territory Judas Iscariot she failed from the days of Joshua onward (see JerIcHo). From Jericho four roads pass upward to the plateau of Judah; unlike the corresponding passes on the western frontier, they do not traverse any definite line of valley, but in many places run actually along the ridges. These roads are: (a) The earllest historically, though now the least frequented, is the most northerly, which passes westward at the back of ancient Jericho (near ‘Ain es Sultan) and ascends by Michmash and Ai to Bethel; (+) the route traversed by the modern Jerus- Jericho road; (c) the more natural route which enters the hills by Wdady Joreif Ghasal and runs hy Nebi Misa, joining the line of the modern carriage road a mile or so after passing the deserted ruin of the Saracenic Khan el Ahmar. ere runs the road for the thousands of pil- grims who visit the shrine of Nebi Masa in the spring. (d) The most natural pass of all is hy way of Wddy el Kuneiterah, across the open plateau of el Bukeia‘' and over the shoulder of Jebel ef Muntdr to Bethlehem. From ‘Ain Feshkhah @ very steep road, probably ancient, ascends to join this last route in el Bukeia'. From En- gedi (‘Ain Jidy) a steep ascent—almost a stairway— winds ahruptly to the plateau above, whence a_road passes northwesterly hy the Wddy Husaseh past Tekoa to Bethlehem and Jerus, and another branch goes west to Hebron and Juttah. Somewhere along these routes must have lain the “Ascent of Ziz’’ and the “Wilderness of Jeruel,’’ the scene of the events of 2 Ch 20. The hill country of Judah is distinguished from other parts of Pal by certain physical characteristics. Its central part is a long plateau—or really series of plateaus— running N. and S., very stony and barren and sup- plied with but scanty springs: “‘dew’’ is less plenti- ful than in the north; several of the elevated plains, e.g. about Bethlehem, Beit Jéla and Hebron, are well suited to the growth of corn and olive trees; in the sheltered valleys and on the terraced hillsides to the W. of the water-parting, vines, olives, figs and other fruit trees flourish exceedingly. There is evidence everywhere that cultivation was far more highly developed in ancient times; on most of the hill slopes to the W. traces of ancient ter- races can still be seen (see Botany). This district in many parts, esp. on its eastern slopes, is preémi- nently a pastoral land, and flocks of sheep and goats abound, invading in the spring even the desert itself. This last is ever in evidence, visible from the environs of all Judah’s greater cities and doubtless profoundly influencing the lives and thonghts of their inhabitants. The altitude attained in this “hill country” is usually below 3,000 ft. in the north (e.g. Ramallah, 2,850 ft., Nebi Samwil, 2,935 ft.), but is higher near Hebron, where we get 8,545 ft. at Ramet el Khulil. Many would limit the term “hill country of Judaea”’ to the higher hills centering around Hebron, but this is unnecessary. Jerus is situated near a lower and more expanded part of the plateau, while the higher hills to its north, are, like that city itself, in the territory of Benjamin. IL, The Tribe of Judah and Its Territory. —In Nu 26 19-22, when the tribes of the Hebrews are enumerated “in the plains of Moab by the Jordan at Jericho” (ver 3), Judah is described as made up of the families of the Shelanites, the Perezites, the Zerahites, the Hezronites and the Hamulites, “These are the families of Judah according to those ‘that. were numbered of them,” a total of 76,500 (ver 22). In Jgs 1 16 we read that the Kenites united with the tribe of J., and from other references (Josh 14 6-15; 15 13-19; Jgs 1 12-15.20) we learn that the two Kenizzite clans of Caleb and Othniel also were absorbed; and it is clear from 1S 27 10; 30 29 that the Jerahmeclites—closely connected with the Calebites (cf 1 Ch 2 42)—also formed a part of the tribe of J. The Kenizzites and Jerahmeelites were probably of Edomite origin (Gen 36 11; cf 1 Ch 2 42), and this large admix- ture of foreign blood may partly account for the com- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1764 parative isolation of J. from the other tribes (e.g. she is not mentioned in Jgs 5). The territory of the tribe of J. is described ideally in Josh 15, but it never really extended over the maritime plait to the W. ‘The natural frontiers to the W. and E. ave already been descrihed as the frontiers of the “hill country"; to the 8. the houndary is descrihed as going “even to the wilderness of Zin southward, at the utter- most part of the south,” i.e. of the Negeb (ver 1), and (ver 3) as far south as Kadesh-barnea, i.e. the oasis of Ain Kadis, 50 miles 8. of Beersheha, far in the desert; the position of the ‘‘ Ascent of Akrabhbim,”’ i.e. of scorpions, is not known. The “Brook of Egypt’ is generally accepted to he the Wadyel'Arish, The factis, the actual frontier shaded off imperceptibly into the desert—varying perhaps with the possibilities of agriculture and depend- ing therefore upon the rainfall. The cities mentioned as on the boundaries, whose sites are now lost, prohably Neen) marked the edge of the habitable area (see EGEB), The northern boundary which separated the land of J. from that of Benjamin requires brief mention. The various localities mentioned in Josh 1§ 5-12 are dealt with in separate articles, but, omitting the very doubtful, the following, which are generally accepted, will show the general direction of the boundary line: The horder went from the mouth of the Jordan to Beth-hoglah (‘Ain Hajlah), and from the Valley of Achor (Wddy Kelt) by the ascent of Adummin ( Tdla‘at ed Dumm) to the waters of En Shemesh Qrobanly ‘Ain Haud), En Rogel (Bir Eyy@b), aud the Valley of Hinnom (Wddy er Rabdébi). The line then crossed the Vale of Rephaim (el Bukeia') to the waters of Nephtoah (Lifta), Kiriath-jearim peers, el ‘Enab), Chesalon (Kesla), Beth-shemesh ‘Ain Shems), Ekron (‘Akir), and Jabneel (Yebnah), ‘‘and the goings out of the horder were at the sea.’ Accord- ing to the above line, Jerus lay entirely within the hounds of Benjamin, though, according to a tradition recorded in the Talm, the site of the altar was in a piece of land helonging to Judah. The above frontier line can be followed on any modern map of Pal, and if it does not In many parts describe a natural frontier, it must be remembered that the frontiers of village and town pos- sessions in modern Pal are extremely arhitrary, and though undetermined by any natural limits such as streams or mountain summits, they persist from gen- eration to generation, and this too during periods—not long past—when there was constant warfare between different clans. ae The territory of J. was small; even had it included all within its ideal boundaries, it would have heen no more than 2,000 sq. miles; actually it was nearer 1,300 sq. miles, of which nearly half was desert. Ill, The Boundaries of the Kingdom of Judah.— These were very circumscribed. In 2 Ch 11 5-12 there is a list of the cities—chiefly those on the frontier—which Rehoboam fortified. On the E. were Bethlehem, Etam and Tekoa; and on the W. and 8.W. were Beth-zur, Soco, Adullam, Gath, Mareshah, Ziph, Adoraim, Lachish, Azekah, Zorah, Aijalon and Hebron. The sites of the great majority of these are known, and they are all upon the borders of the Shephelah or the hill country. It will be seen too that the military preparation then made was against an attack from the W. In the 5th year of the reign of Rehoboam the expected attack came, and Shishak (Sheshenq I) of Egypt swept over the land and not only conquered all J. and Jerus, but, according to the reading of some authorities in the account of this campaign given in the great temple of Karnak, he handed over to Jeroboam of Israel certain strongholds of Judah. The usual northern frontier between the two Heb kingdoms appears to have been the southernmost of the three natural lines described in I above, namely by the Valley of Ajalon on the W. and the Gorge of Michmash (Wady Suweini#) on the E. Along the_central plateau the frontier varied. Bethel (1 _K 12 29; 2 K 10 29; Am 3 14; 4 4; 7 10.13; Hos 10 15) belonged to Israel, though once it fell to J. when Abijah took it and with it Jeshanah (‘Ain Sinia) and Ephron (probably ef Taiyibeh) (2 Ch 18 19). Geba (Jeba’), just to the .of the Wady Suweinit, was on the northern frontier of J., hence instead of the old term “from Dan to Beer-sheba,” we read now of “from Geba to Beer- sheba” (2 K 23 8). Baasha, king of Israel, went S. and fortified Ramah (er Ram, but 4 miles from Jerus) against J. (1 K 15 17), but Asa stopped his 1765 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judah, Territory Judas Iscariot work, removed the fortifications and with the ma- terials strengthened his own frontier at Geba and Mizpah (1 K 16 21.22), In the Jordan valley Jericho was held by Israel (1 K 16 34; 2 K 2 4). After the Northern Kingdom fell, the frontier of J. appears to have extended a little farther N., and Bethel (2 K 23 15-19) and Jericho (to judge from Ezr 2 34; Neh 3 2; 7 36) also became part of the kingdom of J. For the further history of this dis- trict see Jupama. LirEraturE.—See esp. HGHL, chs viii-xv; PEF, III, and Saunders, Intro to ‘he Survey of Western Pal. H_ . W. G. Masterman JUDAH AT (AV UPON) THE JORDAN (FIV MW, yhidhah ha-yardén): A place mark- ing the eastern limit of the territory of Naphtali (Josh 19 34). It is generally thought among scholars that the text is corrupt; but no very prob- able emendation has been suggested. ‘Thomson (LB, Il, 466) proposes to identify it with Seiyid Jehida, a small white-domed sanctuary about 3 miles to the 8.E. of Tell el-Kady. JUDAISM, joo’daé-iz’m. See Israzi, ReLicion OF. JUDAS, j60’das (’IovSas, Jotdas; Heb ‘“‘Judah’’): (1) A Levite mentioned in 1 Esd 9 23=Junag Gr form of (2) Judas Maccabaeus, 3d son of Mattathias (1 Mace 2 4). See Maccasess. (3) Judas, son of Chalphi, a Jewish officer who supported Jonathan bravely at the battle of Hazor (1 Mace 11 70; Ant, XIII, v, 7). : (4) A person of good position in Jerus at the time of the mission to Aristobulus (2 Macc 1 10); he has been identified with Judas Maccabaeus and also with an Essene prophet (Ant, XIII, xi, 2; BJ, TI, 5). 5) Son of Simon the Maccabee, and brother of John Hyrcanus (1 Mace 16 2). He was wounded in the battle which he fought along with his brother against Cendebaeus (1 Macc 16 1 ff; Ant, XIII, vii, 3), and was murdered by Ptolemy the usurper, his brother-in-law, at Dok (1 Macc 16 11 ff). J. Hurcaison JUDAS, JUDA: (1) The name of an ancestor of Jesus (Lk 3 30). In AV it occurs also in Lk 3 26, but RV has “Joda” (WH ‘Iwéd, Todd). (2) Judas Iscariot (see separate art.). (3) One of the brothers of Jesus (Mt 13 55; Mk 6 3). See Jupz. . (4) An apostle, “not Iscariot” (Jn 14 22). He is generally identified with Lebbaeus (Mt 10 3) and Thaddaeus (Mk 3 18). See Leppazvus; THap- pagus. He is called Jupas or James (q.v.) (Lk 6 16; Acts 1 13), which means ‘‘the son of James,” not (AV) “the brother of James.” , (5) A Galilean who stirred up rebellion “in the days of the enrolment” (Acts 6 87). See Jupas oF GALILEE. . (6) One with whom Paul lodged in Damascus, whose house was in “the street which is called Straight” (Acts 9 11). Nothing further is known of him. A house is pointed out as his, in a lane off the Straight Street. (7) Judas Barsabbas (Acts 15 22.27.32; see separate art.). 8. F. Hunter JUDAS BARSABBAS, bdr-sab’as (‘IotSas Bap- caBBas, Jovdas Barsabbds): Judas was, with Silas, a delegate from the church in Jerus to the gentile Christians of Antioch, Syria and Cilicia. They were appointed to convey the letter containing the decision of “the apostles and the elders, with the whole church” regarding the attitude to be taken by gentile Christians toward the Mosaic law, and also to explain ‘the same things by word of mouth.” They accompanied Paul and Barnabas to Antioch, and, ‘being themselves also prophets,” i.e. preachers they not only handed over the epistle but stayed some time in the city preaching and teaching. They seem to have gone no farther than Antioch, for ‘they were dismissed in peace from the brethren unto those that had sent them forth,” and it was Paul and Silas who some time afterward strength- ve ji churches in Syria and Cilicia (Acts 15 0.41), According to ver 34 AV, Judas returned to Jerus without Silas, who remained at Antioch and afterward became Paul's companion (ver 40). The oldest MSS, however, omit ver 34, and it is therefore omltted from . It was probably a marginal note to explain ver 40, and in time it crept into the text. Judas and Silas are called ‘‘chief men among the brethren” (ver 22), probably elders, and ‘‘ prophets” (ver 32). Barsabbas being a patronymic, Judas was prob- ably the brother of Joseph Barsabbas. He cannot be identified with any other Judas, e.g. “Judas not Iscariot” (Jn 14 22). We hear no more of Judas after his return to Jerus (Acts 16 22 ff). S. F. Hunter JUDAS ISCARIOT, is-kar’i-ot (Tot8as Iokapid- tns, Iovidas Iskariétés, ie. “ish keriydth, ‘Judas, man of Kerioth”’): One of the twelve apostles and the hetrayer of Jesus; for etymology, etc, see JUDAS. i i. Life.—Judas was, as his second name indicates, a native of Kerioth or Karioth. The exact locality of Kerioth (cf Josh 15 25) is doubtful, but it lay probably to the 8. of Judaea, being identified with the ruins of el Karjetein (cf A. Plummer, art. “Judas Iscariot” in HDB). He was the son of Simon (Jn 18 2) or Simon Iscariot (In 6 71; 13 26), the meaning of Iscariot explaining why it was applied to his 1. Name father also. The first Scriptural refer- and Early ence to J. is his election to the apostle- History ship (cf Mt 10 4, Mk 319; Lk 6 16). He may have been present at the preaching of John the Baptist at Bethany be- yond Jordan (cf Jn 1 28), but more probably he first met Jesus during the return of the latter through Judaea with His followers (cf Jn 3 22). Accord- ing to the Gospel of the Twelve Apostles (see Simon THE Cananakan), J. was among those who received the call at the Sea of Tiberias (cf Mt 4 18-22). : For any definite allusion to J. during the interval lying between his call and the events immediately preceding the betrayal, we are in- 2. Before debted to St. John alone. These the Be- allusions are made with the manifest trayal purpose of showing forth the nefarious character of J. from the beginning; and in their sequence there is a gradual develop- ment and growing clearness in the manner in which Jesus makes prophecy regarding his future betrayer. Thus, after the discourse on the Bread of Life in the synagogue of Capernaum (Jn 6 26-59), when many of the disciples deserted Jesus (ver 66) and Peter protested the allegiance of the apostles (ver 69), Jesus answered, ‘Did not I choose you the twelve, and one of you is a devil” (ver 70). Then follows St. John’s commentary, “Now he spake of Judas the son of Simon Iscariot, for he it was that should betray him, being one of the twelve” (ver 71), implying that Judas was already known to Jesus as being in spirit one of those who ‘went back, and walked no more with him” (ver 66). But the situation, however disquieting it must have been to the ambitious designs which probably actuated J. in his acceptance of the apostleship (cf Judas Iscariot = THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jude, Epistle o: 1766 below), was not sufficiently critical to call for imme- diate desertion on his part. Instead, he lulled his fears of exposure by the fact that he was not men- tioned by name, and continued ostensibly one of the faithful, Personal motives of a sordid na- ture had also influence in causing him to remain. Appointed keeper of the purse, he disregarded the warnings of Jesus concerning greed and hypocrisy (cf Mt 6 20; Lk 12 1-3) and appropriated the funds to his own use. As a cloak to his avarice, he pretended to be zealous in their administration, and therefore, at the anointing of Jesns’ feet by Mary, he asked “Why was not this ointment sold for 300 shillings, and given to the poor? Now this he said, not because he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and having the bag took away what was put therein” (Jn 12 5.6; cf also Mt 26 7-13; Mk 14 3-8). Yet, although by this craftiness J. concealed for a time his true nature from the rest of the disciples, and fomented any discontent that 3. The Be- might arise among them (cf Mk 14 trayal 4), he now felt that his present source of income could not long remain secure. The pregnant words of his Master regarding the day of his burial (cf Mt 26 12; Mk 14 8; Jn 12 7) revealed to His betrayer that Jesus already knew well the evil powers that were at work against Him; and it is significant that, according to Mt and Mk, who alone of the synoptists mention the anointing, J. departed immediately afterward and made his compact with the chief priests (cf Mt 26 14.15; Mk 14 10.11; ef also LE 22 3-6). But his ab- sence was only temporary. He was present at the washing of the disciples’ feet, there to be differen- tiated once more by Jesus from the rest of the Twelve (cf “Ye are clean, but not all” and “He that eateth my bread lifted up his heel against me,” Jn 13 10.18), but again without being named. It seemed as if Jesus wished to give Judas every opportunity, even at this late hour, of repenting and making his confession. For the last time, when they had sat down to eat, Jesus appealed to him thus with the words, ‘“‘One of you shall betray me” (Mt 2621; Mk 1418; Lk 2221; Jn 13 21). And at the end, in answer to the anxious queries of His disciples, ‘Is it I?’ He indicated his betrayer, not by name, but by asign: “He it is, for whom I shall dip the sop, and give it him” (Jn 13 26). Immediately upon its reception, J. left the supper room; the opportunity which he sought for was come (cf Jn 13 30; Mt 26 16). There is some doubt as to whether he actually received the eucharistic bread and wine previous to his departure or not, but most modern commentators hold that he did not. On his departure, J. made his way to the high priests and their followers, and coming upon Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane, he betrayed his Master with a kiss (Mt 26 47-50; Mk 14 43. 44; Lk 22 47; Jn 18 2-5). After the betrayal, Mk, Lk and Jn are silent as regards J., and the accounts given in Mt and Acts of his remorse and death vary in de- 4. His tail. According to Mt, the actual Death condemnation of Jesus awakened Ju- das’ sense of guilt, and becoming still more despondent at his repulse by the chief priests and elders, “he cast down the pieces of silver into the sanctuary, and departed; and he went away and hanged himself.” With the money the chief priests purchased the potter's field, afterward called ‘the field of blood,” and in this way was fulfilled the prophecy of Zechariah (11 12-14) ascribed by Matthew to Jeremiah (Mt 27 3-10). The account given in Acts 1 16-20 is much shorter. It men- tions neither Judas’ repentance nor the chief priests, but simply states that J. “obtained a field with the reward of his iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed ont” (ver 18). The author of Acts finds in this the fulfilment of the prophecy in Ps 69 25. The Vulg rendering, ““When he had hanged himself, he burst asunder,’”? suggests a means of reconciling the two accounts. z According to a legendary account mentioned by Papias, the death of J. was due to elephantiasis (cf Hennecke, Neutestamentliche Apokryphen, 5). A so-called “Gospel of Judas’? was in use among the gnostic sect of the Cainites. HI, Character and Theories.—Much discussion and controversy have centered, not_only around the dis- crepancies of the Gospel narratives of J., 1. Joined but also around his character_and the roblems connected with it. That. the the Apostles betrayer of Jesus should also be one of the to Betra’ chosen Twelve has given_opportunity for Jesu y the attacks of the foes of Christianity from esus the earliest times (cf Orig., Con. Cel., 11.12); and the difficulty of finding any proper solution has proved so great that some have been in- duced to regard J. as merely a personification of the spirit of Judaism. The acceptance of this view would, however, invalidate the historical value of much of the Scriptural writings. Other theories are put forward in explanation, viz. that J. joined the apostolic band with the definite intention of betraying Jesus. The aim of this intention has again received two different inter- pretations, both of which seek to elevate the character of J., and to free him from the charge of sordid motives and cowardly treachery. According to one, J. was @ strong patriot, who saw in Jesus the foe of his race and its ancient creed, and therefore betrayed Him in the in- terests of his country. This view is, however, irrecon- cilable with the rejection of J. by the chief priests (cf Mt 27 3-10). According to the other, J. regarded him- self as a true servant of Christianity, who assumed the réle of traitor to precipitate the action of the Messiah and induce Him to manifest His miraculous powers by calling down the angels of God from heaven to help Him (cf Mt 26 53). His suicide was_further due to his disappointment at the failure of Jesus to fulfil his expectations. This theory found favor in ancient times with the Cainites (cf above), and in modern days with De Quincey and Bishep Whately. But the terms and manner of denunciation employed by Jesus in regard to J. (cf also Jn 17 12) render this view also untenable. Another view is that J. was foreordained to be the traitor: that Jesus was conscious from the first that He was to suffer death on the cross, and chose J. because He knew that he should betray 2. Fore- = Him and thus fulfil the Divine decrees ordained (cf Mt 26 54). Those holding this view to Bea base their arguments on the omniscience Traitor of Jesus implied in Jn 2 24, Jesus ‘‘knew all men’; Jn 6 64, ‘‘Jesus knew from the beginning who should betray him," and Jn 18 4, ‘‘knowing all the things that were coming upon him."’ Yet to take those texts lit. would mean a ’ too rigid application of the doctrine of predestination. It would treat J. as a mere instrument, as a means and not an end in the hands of a higher power; it would render meaningless the appeals and reproaches made to him by Jesus and deny any real existence of that per- sonal responsibility and sense of guilt which it was Our Lord’s very, purpose to awaken aud stimulate in the hearts of His hearers. John himself wrote after the event, but in the words of Our Lord there was, as we have seen, a growing clearness in the manner in which He foretold His betrayal. The omniscience of Jesus was greater than that of a mere clairvoyant who claimed to foretell the exact course of future events. It was the oemniscience of one who knew on the one hand the ways of His Eternal Father among men, and who, on the other, penetrated into the deepest recesses of human character and beheld there all its secret feelings and motives and tendencies. Although a full discussion of the character of J. would of necessity involve those ultimate problems of Free Will and Original Sin (West- 3. Betrayal cott) which no theology can ade- the Result quately solve, the theory which re- of Gradual gards the betrayal as the result of a Develop- gradual development within the soul ment of J. seems the most practical. It is an. significant that J. alone among the disciples was of southern extraction; and the differ- ences in temperament and social outlook, together with the petty prejudices to which these generally give rise, may explain in part, though they do not 1767 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judas Iscariot Jude, Epistle of justify, his after treachery—that lack of inner sympathy which existed between J. and the rest of the apostles. He undoubtedly possessed a certain business ability, and was therefore appointed keeper of the purse. But his heart could not have been clean, even from the first, as he administered _ even his primary charge dishonestly. The cancer of this greed spread from the material to the spirit- ual. To none of the disciples did the fading of the dream of an earthly kingdom of pomp and glory bring greater disappointment than to J. The cords of love by which Jesus gradually drew the hearts of the other disciples to Himself, the teaching by which He uplifted their souls above all earthly things, were as chafing bonds to the selfishness of J. And from his fettered greed and disappointed am- bition sprang jealousy and spite and hatred. It was the hatred, not of a strong, but of an essentially weak man. Instead of making an open breach with his Lord, he remained ostensibly one of His followers: and this continued contact with a good- ness to which he would not yield (cf Swete on Mk 14 10), and his brooding over the rebukes of his Master, gave ready entrance for “Satan into his soul.” But if he “knew the good and did not do it” (ef Jn 13 17), so also he was weak in the carry- ing out of his nefarious designs. It was this hesi- tancy, rather than a fiendish cunning, which induced him to remain till the last moment in the supper room, and which prompted the remark of Jesus ‘What thou doest, do quickly” (Jn 13 27). Ofa piece with this weak-mindedness was his attempt to cast the blame upon the chief priests and elders (cf Mt 27 3.4). He sought to set himself right, not with the innocent Jesus whom he had betrayed, but with the accomplices in his crime; and because that world which his selfishness had made his god failed him at the last, he went and hanged himself. It was the tragic end of one who espoused a great cause in the spirit of speculation and selfish ambi- tion, and who weighed not the dread consequences to which those impure motives might lead him (cf also Bruce, Training of the Twelve; Latham, Pastor Pastorum; Stalker, Trial and Death of Jesus Christ). C. M. Kerr JUDAS ISCARIOT, GOSPEL OF: A ‘Gospel of Judas” is mentioned by Irenaeus (Adv. Haer., 1.81), Epiphanius ( Haer., xxxviii.1), Theodoret, etc, as current in the gnostic sect of the Cainites, to whom Judas was a hero. It must have been in existence in the 2d cent., but no quotation is given from it (see Baring-Gould, Lost and Hostile Gospels, III, ch v). JUDAS, NOT ISCARIOT (‘TotSas, otx 6 Ioka- ptdrys, Todas ouch ho Iskaridtés): One of the Twelve Apostles (Jn 14 22). See Jupas oF James; Lepparus; THADDAEUS. - JUDAS MACCABAEUS. See MaccaBazus. JUDAS OF DAMASCUS. See Jupas, (6). JUDAS OF GALILEE (6 Tadudatos, ho Gali- lafos): Mentioned in Acts 6 37 as the leader of an insurrection occasioned by the census of Quirinius in 7 AD (see Quirinius). He, and those who obeyed him, it is said, perished in that revolt. Jos also repeatedly mentions Judas by this same name, “the Gahlean,’ and speaks of his revolt (Ant, XVIII, i, 6; XX, v,2; BJ, I, viii, 1; xviii,8, VIL, viii, 1), but in Ant, XVII, i, names him a Gaulo- nite, of the city of Gamala. As Gamala was in Gau- lonitis, not far from the eastern shore of the Sea of Galilee, it may he regarded as belonging to that province. The party of Judas seems to have been identified with the Zealots. James ORR JUDAS OF JAMES (‘IotSas *IaxéPov, Ioidas Iakodbou): One of the twelve apostles (Lk 6 16; Acts 1 13; for etymology, etc, see Jupas), AV has the reading ‘‘brother of James,” and RV reads “‘son of James.’’? The latter is to be preferred. In Jn 14 22 heis described as ‘Judas (not Iscariot).’”’ The name corresponds with the ‘“Thaddaeus” or ‘‘Leb- baeus whose surname was Thaddaeus” of Mt 10 3 AV and Mk 3 18 (cf Tuannarvs). The identifica- tion of Thaddaeus with Judas is generally accepted, though Ewald and others hold that they were different. persons, that Thaddaeus died during Christ’s lifetime, and that Judas was chosen in his lace (cf Bruce, Training of the Twelve, 34). If the V is accepted as the correct rendering of Lk 6 16 and Acts 1 13, this Judas cannot be identified either with the Juda (Mk 6 3 AV), Judas (Mk 6 3 RV), or Judas (Mt 13 55), the brother of Jesus; or with the Judas (Jude ver 1 RVm) or Jude (Jude ver 1 AV), the bréther of James, whether these two latter Judases are to be regarded as the same or not. The only incident recorded of Judas of James isin Jn 14 22, where during Christ’s address to the disciples after the last supper he put the question, “Lord, what is come to pass that thou wilt manifest thyself unto us, and not unto the world?” C. M. Kerr JUDAS, THE LORD’S BROTHER. See Junz. JUDDAG, jud’a. See Jurran. JUDE, jodd (‘Iev8as, Jovdas): Brother of the Lord, and author of the Ep. of Jude. See Jupas or James and following article. JUDE, THE EPISTLE OF: The Writer I. Jupz’s Position 1n THE CANON II. Tas Occasion or Its Composition III. Description or THE LIBERTINES AND APOSTATES IV. Rexatron or Jupe To THe Seconp EristiE oF Prerer 1. Resemblances 2. Differences 3. Further Contrasts 4. Summary 5. Evidence of Priority of Peter 6. Confirmatory References VY. Dares or THE Epistle VI. Tuas Lisertines or Jupe’s Hristie Literature The writer of this short ep. calls himself Jude or Judas ( Iovéas, Joudas). His name was a common one among the Jews: there were few The Writer others of more frequent use. Two among the apostles bore it, viz. Judas, mentioned in Jn 14 22 (cf Lk 6 16), and Judas Iscariot. . Jude describes himsclf as ‘‘a servant of Jesus Christ, and brother of James” (ver 1). The James here mentioned is no doubt the person who is called ‘‘the Lord’s brother’ (Gal 119), the writer of the ep. that bears his name. Neither of the two was an apostle. The opening sentence of Jude simply affirms that the writer is a ‘servant of Jesus Christ.”” This, if anywhere, should be the appropriate place for the mention of his apostle- ship, if he were an apostle. The appellation ‘‘serv- ant of Jesus Christ” ‘‘is never thus barely used in an address of an ep. to designate an apostle’ (Alford). Phil 1 1 has a similar expression, ‘‘Paul and Timothy, servants of Jesus Christ,” but ‘“the designation common to two persons necessarily sinks to the rank of the inferior one.” In other in- stances “servant” is associated with ‘apostle’ (Rom 11; Tit 11), Jude vs 17.18 speaks of the “apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ; that they said to you”’—language which an apostle would hardly use of his fellow-apostles. In MK 6 3 are found the names of those of whom Jesus is said to be the brother, namely, James and Jude, Epistle of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Joses, and Judas and Simon. It is quite generally held by writers that the James and Judas here men- tioned are the two whose epp. are found in the NT. It is noteworthy, however, that neither of them hints at his relationship with Jesus; their unaffected humility kept them silent. Jude mentions that he is the ‘‘brother of James,” perhaps to give authority and weight to his words, for James was far more distinguished and influential than he. The infer- ence seems legitimate that Jude addresses Chris- tians among whom James was highly esteemed, or, if no longer living, among whom his memory was sacredly revered, and accordingly it is altogether probable that Jude writes to the same class of read- ers as James—Jewish Christians. James writes to the ‘Twelve Tribes of the Dispersion.” Jude likewise addresses a wide circle of believers, viz. the “called, beloved in God the Father, and kept for Jesus Christ” (ver 1). While he does not desiguate aspecial and distinct class, yet as James’s ‘“‘brother,”’ as belonging to the family of Joseph, and as in some true sense related to the Lord Jesus Himself, it seems probable, if not certain, that his Ep. was intended for Christian Hebrews who stood in urgent need of such testimony and appeal as Jude offers. I. Jude’s Position in the Canon.—It is now and for a long while has been an assured one. Its rank, though not altogether that of 1 Pet and 1 Jn, is high, for centuries indeed undoubted. Almost from the beginning of the Christian era men every way qualified to speak with authority on the ques- tion of genuineness and authenticity indorsed it as entitled to a place in the NT Scriptures. Origen repeatedly quotes it, in one place describing it as an “ep. of but few lines, but full of powerful words of heavenly grace” (Matt., tom. X,17). But Origen knew that it was not universally received. Clement of Alexandria ‘‘gave concise expositions of all the canonical Scriptures, not omitting the controverted books—the Ep. of Jude and the other Catholic epp.”’ (quoted by Westcott, Can., 322-23 and Salmon, Intro, 493). Tertullian (Cult. Fem.i.3) in striving to establish the authority of the Book of Enoch urges as a crowning argument that it is quoted by “the apostle Jude.” _‘‘We may infer that Jude’s Ep. was an unquestioned part of Tertullian’s Canon.” Athanasius inserted it in his list of NT books, but Eusebius placed it among the disputed books in his classification. The Canon ‘of Muratori includes Jude among the books of Scripture, though it omits the Epp. of Jas, Pet and He. This is one of the carliest documents coutaining a list of the NT books now known. By the great majority of writers the date of the fragment is given as c 170 AD, as it claims to have been written not long after Pius was bishop of Rome, and the latest date of Pius is 142- 57 AD. The words of the document are, ‘The Shepherd was written very recently in our own time by Hermas, while his brother Pius sat in the chair of the Church of Rome.” Twenty or twenty-five years would probably satisfy the period indicated by the words, ‘‘written very recently in our own time,”’ which would fix the date of the fragment at c170 AD. Salmon, however, strongly inclines to a later date, viz. ¢ 200-210 AD, as does Zahn. Zahn (Intro to the NT, 11,259, ET), and Professor Chase (HDB) are of the decided opinion that the Didache, Il. 7: “Thou shalt not hate anyone, but some thou shalt rebuke, and for some thou shalt pray, and some thou shalt love above thine own soul [or life],’’ is founded on Jude ver 22. Dr. Philip Schaff dates the Didache be- tween 90-100 AD. L’Abbé E. Jacquier (La doctrine des Douze Apotres, 1891) is persuaded that the famous document was written not later than 80 AD. It appears, therefore, more than probable that the Ep. of Jude was known and referred to as Scripture some time before the end of the 1st cent. From the survey _we have thus rapidly taken of the field in which the Ep. circulated, we may couclude that in Pal, at Alexandria, in North Africa, and at Rome, it was received as the veritable letter 1768 oF Jude, ‘‘the servant of Jesus Christ, and brother of ames.”” The chief reason why it was rejected by some and re- garded with suspicion by others in primitive times is its quotation from the apocryphal Book of Enoch, so Jerome informs us (Vir. Iil., 4). It is possible that Jude had in mind another spurious writing, viz. the Assumption of Moses, when he spoke of the contention of Michael the archangel with the devil about the body of Moses (ver 9). This, however, is not quite certain, for the date assigned to that writing is c 44 AD, and although Jude might have seen and read it, yet its composition is so near his own day that it could hardly have exerted much influence on his mind. Besides, the brevity of the ED: and its dealing with a special class of errorists would limit to a certain extent its circulation among Christians, All this serves to explain its refusal by some and the absence of reference to it by others. Il. The Occasion of Its Composition.—Jude, after his brief introduction (vs 1.2), explains very defi- nitely why he writes as he does. He indicates dis- tinctly his anxiety on behalf of the saints (ver 3): ‘Beloved, while I was giving all diligence to write unto you of our common salvation, I was con- strained to write unto you exhorting you to contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all de- livered unto the saints.”’ He had received very distressing knowledge of the serious state into which the Christian brotherhood was rapidly drifting, and he must as a faithful servant of Jesus Christ exhort them to stedfastness and warn them of their danger. He had in mind to write them a doctrinal work on the salvation common to all Christians. Perhaps he contemplated the composition of a book or treatise that would have discussed the great subject in an exhaustive manner. But in face of the perils that threatened, of the evils already present in the community, his purpose was indefinitely postponed. We are not told how he became acquainted with the dangers which beset his fellow-believers, but the conjecture is probably correct that it was by means of his journeys as an evangelist. At any rate, he was thoroughly con- versant with the evils in the churches, and he deals with them as befitted the enormities that were practised and the ruin that impended. The address of the Ep. is remarkable for the affection Jude expresses for these saints. Obvious- ly they are distinct from the libertines of whom he speaks with such solemn condemnation. They were the faithful who kept aloof from the ungodly that surrounded them, and who held fast to the truth they had been taught. Jude describes them as those ‘‘that are called, beloved in God the Father, and kept for Jesus Christ: Mercy unto you and peace and love be multiplied.” At the close of the Ep. he commends them “unto him that is able to guard you from stumbling, and to set you before the presence of his glory without blemish in exceed- ing joy.”” A separated and devoted band they cer- tainly were, a noble and trustworthy company of believers for whose well-being Jude was supremely anxious. HI. Description of the Libertines and Apostates. —It is needful to gaze with steady vision on the hideous portrait Jude furnishes of these depraved foes, if we are to appreciate in any measure the force of his language and the corruption already wrought in the brotherhood. Some of their foul teachings and their vicious practices, not all, are here set down. (1) Surreptitious foes.—For there are certain men crept In privily .... ungodly men” (ver 4). They are enemies who felgn to be friends, and hence In reallty are sples and traitors; like a stealthy beast of prey the creen inke the company of the godly, actuated by evil . (2) Perverters of grace and deniers of Christ.—'' Turn- ing the grace of our God into lasciviousness, and denying our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ” (ver 4). They are those who by a vile perverseness turn the grace and the liberty of the Gospel into a means for gratifylng their Peo eeiens: and who in doctrine and life repudiate their Master and Lord. 1769 ,__ (3) Censorious and arrogant detractors.—‘'In thelr dream- ings defile the flesh, and set at nought dominion, and rail at dignities"’ (ver 8). Destitute of true reverence, they raii at the holiest and best things, and sit in judg- ment on aii rule and all authority. They have the proud tongue of the iawiess: ‘‘Our lips are our own: who is iord over us?" (Ps 12 4). Ane Ignorant calumniators and brutish sensualists.— “These raii at whatsoever things they know not: and what they understand naturaliy, like the creatures with- out reason, in these things are they destroyed"' (ver 10). What they do not know, as something lofty and nobis, they deride and denounce; what they know is that which mabavers to their disordered appetites and their dehased astes. (5) Hypocrites and deceivers.—'‘These are they who are hidden rocks in your iove-feasts when they feast with you, shepherds that without fear feed themselves; clouds without water.... autumn trees without fruit.... wild waves of the sea... . wandering stars, for whom the biackness of darkness hath been reserved forever” (vs 12.13). A most graphic picture of the insincerity, the depravity, and the doom of these insoients! And yet they are fonnd in the bosom of the Christian body, even sitting with the saints at their iove-feasts! (6) Grumblers, fault-finders, pleasure-seekers, boasters, parasites.—'' These are murmurers, complainers, waiking after their own lusts . . . . showing respect of persons for the sake of advantage” (vcr 16). They impeach Divine wisdom, are tho foesof peace and quietness, boast of thelr capacities to manage things, and yet they can he serviie, even sycophants, when thereby advantage is secured. (7) Schismatics and sensualists—‘‘These are they who make separations, sensuai, having not the Spirit” (ver 19). It was characteristic of the faise teachers and mockers who had invaded the Christian church that they drew lines of demarkation between themseives and others, or between different ciasses of believers, which the Holy Spirit did not warrant, hut which was the product of their own crafty and wicked wills. There seems to be a hint in these words of incipient Gnosticism, that fatal heresy that hoasted of a recondite knowledge, a deep mystery which oniy the initiated possessed, of which the great mass of Christians were ignorant, Jude brands the pretension as the offspring of their own sensuality, not at all of God's Spirit. Such is the forbidding portrait drawn of the libertinesin the Ep. But Jude adds other and eveu darker features. He furnishes a number of exam- ples of apostates and of apostasy which disclose even more strikingly the spirit and the doom of them that pervert the truth, that deny the Lord Jesus Christ, and that mock at the things of God. These all mark a fatal degeneracy, a “‘falling away,” which bodes nothing but evil and_ judgment. Against the corrupters and skeptics Jude writes with a vehemence that in the NT is without a parallel. Matters must have come to a dreadful pass when the Spirit of God is compelled to use such stern and awful language. IV. Relation of Jude to the Second Epistle of Peter.—The relation is confined to 2 Pet 2—3 4. A large portion of Peter’s Ep., viz. ch 1 and 3 5-18, bears no resemblance to Jude, at least no more than does Jas or 1 Pet. Between the sections of 2 Pet indicated above and Jude the parallelism is close, both as to the subjects treated and the historical illustrations introduced, and the lan- guage itself to some considerable extent is common to both. All readers must be impressed with the similarity. Accordingly, it is very generally held by interpreters that one of the writers copied from the other. There is not entire agreement as to which of the two epp. is the older, that is, whether Peter copied from Jude, or Jude from Peter. Perhaps a majority favor the former of the two alternatives, though some of the very latest and most learned of those who write on Intro- ductions to the NT hold strongly to the view that Jude copied from 2 Pet. Reference is made particn- larly to Dr. Theodore v. Zahn, whose magnificent work on Introduction has been but recently trd into Eng., and who argues convincingly that Jude copied from 2 Pet. , However, it must be admitted that there are in the two epp. as pronounced differences and diver- 1. Resem- blances THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Jude, Epistle of gences as there are resemblances. If one of the two did actually copy from the other, he was care- ful to add, subtract, and change what 2. Differ- he found in his “source’’ as best suited ences his purpose. A servile copyist he cer- tainly was not. He maintained his independence throughout, as an exact comparison of the one with the other will demonstrate. If we bring them into close proximity, following the example of Professor Lumby in the ‘‘Bible Comm.” (Intro to 2 Pet), we shall discover a marked difference between the two pictures drawn by the writers. darker and more sinister is that of Jude. i certainly in Peter, becomes appalling in ubjoined are proofs of the fact above stated: alarmin Jude. 2 Pet 21 But there arose faise prophets also among the peopie, as among you aiso there shali be false teachers 2 Pet 21 who shaii privily bring in destructive heresies, deny- ing even the Master that bonght them... . 2 Pet 23 And in covetousness shaii they with feigned words make merchandise of you We cannot fail to perceive how much The evil, Jude ver 4 For there are certain men creptin privily.... Jude ver 4 .... ungodly men, turnin the grace of God into iasci- viousness, and denying our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ. Jude ver 16 ..... « Murmurers, com- plainers, walking after their own lusts (and their mouth speaketh great swelling words), showing respect of persons for the sake of ad- vantage. These contrasts and comparisons between the two epp. prove (1) that in Jude the false teachers are worse, more virulent than in Peter, and (2) that in Peter the whole description is predictive, whereas in Jude the deplorable condition is actually present. If 2 Pet is dependent on Jude, if the apostle cited from Jude, how explain the strong predictive ele- ment in his opening verses (2 Pet 2 1-3)? If as Peter wrote he had lying before him Jude’s letter, which represents the corrupters as already within the Christian community and doing their deadly work, his repeated use of the future tense is ahso- lutely inexplicable. Assuming, however, that he wrote prior to Jude, his predictions become per- fectly intelligible. No doubt the virus was working when he wrote, but it was latent, undeveloped; far worse would appear; but when Jude wrote the poison was widely diffused, as vs 12.19 clearly show. The very life of the churches was endangered. 2 Pet 2 4.5 Jude vs 5.6 For if God spared not ....The Lord, having theangeis when theysinned saved a peopie out of the .... and spared not the land of Egypt, afterward ancient world, but pre- destroyed them... . and served Noah with seven angelsthat... . left thelr others...-+ proper habitation .... Peter speaks of the angels that sinned, Jude of their apostasy. Peter makes prominent the sal- vation of Noah and his family when 8. Further the flood overwhelmed the world of the Contrasts ungodly, while Jude tells of those who, delivered from bondage, afterward were destroyed because of their unbelief. He speaks of no rescue; we know of but two who sur- vived the judgments of the wilderness and who entered the Land of Promise, Caleb and Joshua. Peter mentions the fate of the guilty cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, but he is careful to remind us of the deliverance of righteous Lot, while Jude makes prominent their nameless crimes and consigns them to ‘the punishment of eternal fire,’ but he is silent on the rescue of Lot. Manifestly Jude’s illustra- tions are darker and more hopeless than Peter’s. Jude, Epistle of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judge 1770 Peter instances Balaam as an example of one who loved the hire of wrongdoing and who was rehuked for his transgression. But Jude cites three notable instances in the OT to indicate how far in apostasy and rehellion the libertines had gone. Three words mark their course, rising into a climax, “way,” “error,” ‘‘gainsaying.’’? They went in the way of Cain, i.e. in the way of self-will, of hate, and the spirit of murder. Moreover, they “ran riotously in the error of Balaam for hire.’”’ The words denote an activity of viciousness that enlisted all their eagerness and all their might. Balaam’s error was one that led into error, one that seduced others into the commission of the like sins. _The reference seems to be to the whole career of this heathen prophet, and includes his betrayal of the Israelites through the women of Moah (Nu 31 16). Balaam is the prototype of Jude’s libertines, hoth in_his covetousness and his seductive counsel. Further- more, they “perished in the gainsaying of Korah.” This man with 250 followers rehelled against the Divinely appointed leaders and rulers of Israel, Moses and Aaron, and sought to share their author- ity in Israel, if not to displace them altogether. Comparable with these rehels in ancient Israel are the treacherous and malignant foes whom Jude so vigorously denounces. Peter speaks of them as “daring, self-willed, they tremble not to rail at dignities: whereas angels, though greater in might and power, bring not a rail- ing judgment against them before the Lord’ (vs 10.11). Jude is more specific: These dreamers “defile the flesh, and set at. nought dominion, and rail at dignities.” They repudiate all authority, despise every form of lordship, and revile those in positions of power. He cites the contention of Michael the archangel with the devil about the hody of Moses, and yet this lofticst of the heavenly spirits brought no railing judgment against the ad- versary. Jude’s description is more vivid and definite: he describes an advanced stage of apostasy. Very noteworthy is Jude vs 22.23. He here turns again to the loyal and stedfast believers whom he addresses at the beginning of his letter, and he gives them directions how they are to deal with those who were ensnared by the wily foes. (The text in ver 22 is somewhat uncertain, but the revision is fol- lowed.) There were some who were “in doubt.” They were those who had been fascinated hy the new teaching, and although not captured by it, they were engaged in its study, were drawn toward it and almost ready to yield. On these the faithful were to have mercy, were to convince them of their danger, show them the enormities to which the false system inevitably leads, and so win them back to Christ’s allegiance. As if Jude said, Deal with the wavering in love and fidelity; but rescue them if possible. There were others whose peril was greater: “And some save, snatching them out of the fire.’ These were identified with the wicked, were scorched hy the fires of destruction and hence almost beyond reach of rescue; hut if possible they are to he saved, however scathed and blackened. Others still there were who were in worse state than the preceding, who were polluted and smirched hy the foul con- tamination of the guilty seducers, and such were to he saved, and the rescuers were to fear lest they should he soiled by contact. with the horrible defile- ment. This is Jude’s tremendous summary of the shameful work and frightful evils wrought in the bosom of the church hy the libertines. He dis- closes in these trenchant verses how deeply sunk in sin the false teachers were, and how awful the ruin they had wrought. The description is quite unparalleled in 2 Pet. The shadings in Jude are darker and deeper than those in 2 Pet. The comparison between the two writings war- rants, we believe, the following conclusions: (1) that Peter and Jude have in view the 4, Summary same corrupt parties; (2) that Peter paints them as godless and extremely dangerous, though not yet at their worst; while Jude sets them forth as depraved and as lawless as they can well he; (3) that Peter’s is the older writing and that Jude was acquainted with what the apostle had written. Stronger evidence than any yet produced of Peter’s priority is now to be submitted, and here hi avail ourselves in part of Zahn’s array of evi- ence. Jude asserts with great positiveness that (ver 4) certain men had crept in privily into the Christian fold, “even they who were of old 5. Evi- written of beforehand unto this con- dence of | demnation, ungodly men.” Obviously Priority of Jude is here speaking of the enemies Peter whom he afterward goes on to describe and denounce in his Ep. He dis- tinctly affirms that these foes had been of old written of and beforehand designated unto ‘this condem- nation.” He clearly has in mind an authoritative writing that spoke of the identical parties Jude himself deals with. He does not tell us whose writing it is that contains the ‘‘condemnation” of the errorists; he only declares that there is such a Scripture existing and that he is acquainted with it. Now, to what writing does he refer? Not to any OT prophecy, for none can be found that answers to the words. Nor yet to the prediction of Enoch (va 14.15), for it speaks of the advent of the Lord in judgment at the last day, whereas Jude applies his reference to the ungodly who were then present in the Christian assemblies, corrupting the churches with their wicked teaching and practices. “In 2 Pet 2—3 4, we have a prophecy which exactly suits, namely, the announcement that false teachers whose theory and practice exactly correspond to those godless hearers of the Christian name in Jude will appear among a certain group of Jewish Chris- tian churches’? (Zahn). Peter’s account of them is so particular that Jude would encounter no diffi- culty in identifying them, He is furnished hy the apostle with such characteristics of them, with such illustrations and even words and phrases that he has only to place the description alongside of the reality to see how completely they match. It may be objected that the words, ‘‘were of old written of heforehand,”’ denote a long period, longer than that which elapsed between the two epp. But the ohjection is groundless. The original term for “of old” (pdlat) sometimes indicates but a brief space of time, e.g. Mk 16 44 (according to the text of Weymouth aud Nestle, and RV) relates that Pilate asked the centurion if Jesus had been “any while” (palat) dead, which limits the term to a few hours. In 2 Cor 12 19 the word occurs, and there it must be restricted to Paul’s self-defence which occupies the part of the Ep. preceding, and hence does not extend beyond a day or two. Probably some years lie hetween the composition of these two epp., ample time to justify Jude’s use of the word if he is referring to 2 Pet 2—3 4, as we certainly believe he is, This interpretation of Jude ver 4 is confirmed by Jude vs 17.18. These verses are intimately con- nected with 2 Pet 32-4. Jude’s 6. Confirm readers are told to keep in remem- atory brance the words spoken by the apos- References tles of Christ, namely, ‘‘In the last _ time there shall he mockers, walking after their own ungodly lusts.” Peter writes, ‘that in the last days mockers shall come with mockery, walking after their own lusts.” The resemblance 1771 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA yaaee Epistle of of the one passage to the other is very close, indeed, they are almost identieal. Both urge their readers to remember what had been said by the aposiles of the Lord Jesus Christ, and both speak of the immoral scoffers who would invade or had invaded the Christian brotherhood. But Peter distinctly asserts that these mockers shall appear in the last days. His words are, ‘“‘Knowing this first, that in the last days mockers shall eome with mockery, walking after their own lusts.’ Jude writes that “in the last time there shall be mockers, walking after their own ungodly lusts.’? The phrases, ‘‘the last days,”’ and ‘‘the last time,” denote our age, the dispensation in which we live, as He 1 2 proves. Peter puts the appearance of the scoffers in the future, whereas Jude, after quoting the words, sig- nificantly adds, “These are they who make separa- tions, sensual, having not the Spirit.” He means, of course the mockers just mentioned, and he affirms they are now present. With Peter they are yet to eome when he wrote, but with Jude the prediction is already fulfilled, so far as the seoffers are con- eerned. Therefore Jude’s writing is subsequent to Peter’s, and if there be copying on the part of either, it is Jude who copies. Peter mentions “your aposties,’’ including himself in the phrase, but Jude does not employ the pl. pronoun, for he was not_of the apostolic body. But why the pl., “apostles”? Because at least one other apostle had spoken of the perilous times which were coming on the church of God. Paul unites his testimony with that of Peter, and writes, ‘‘ But know this, that in the last days grievous times shall come" (2 Tim 3 1-5). His pre- diction is near akin to that of Peter; it belongs apparent- y to the same historic time and to_the same perilous class of evil-doers aud corrupters. In 2 Pet 3 15 the apostle lovingly and tenderly speaks of_his ‘‘ brother Paul,’’ and says suggestively that in his Ep. he speaks of these things—no doubt about the scoffers of the last days amoug the rest. He certainly seems to have Paul in mind when he penned the words, ‘‘ Knowing this first, that in the last days mockers shall come." Hecre, then, is positive ground for the reference in Jude ver 4 to a writing concerning those who had crept into the fold and who were of old doomed to this condemna- tion, with which writing his readers were acquainted; they had it in the writing of the apostles Peter and Paul both, and so were forewarned as to the impending danger. Jude’s Ep. is subsequent to Peter's. V. Date of the Epistle.—There is little or no agreement as to the year, yet the majority of writers hold that it belongs to the latter half of the 1st cent. Zahn assigns it to 70-75 AD; Lumby, e¢ 80 AD; Salmon, before the reign of Domitian (81 AD); Sieffert, shortly prior to Domitian; Chase, not later than 80 AD, probably within a year or two of the Pastoral Epp. Zahn strongly insists on 64 AD as the date of Peter’s death. If the 2d Ep. bearing his name is authentic, the apostle eould not possibly have eopied from Jude, for Jude’s letter was not in existence when he died. Even on the supposition that he suffered death 65-66 AD, there could have been no copying done save by Jude, for it is almost demonstrable that Jude was written after the de- struction of Jerusin 70 AD. If 2 Pet is pseudony- mous and written about the middle of the 2d cent., as some confidently affirm, it has no right to a place in the Canon nor any legitimate relation to Jude. If genuine, it antedates Jude. VI. The Libertines of Jude’s Epistle.—Their character is very forcibly exhibited, but no informa- tion is given us of their origin or to what particular region they belonged. They bore the Christian name, were of the loosest morals, and were guilty of shameful excesses. Their influence seems to have been widespread and powerful, else Jude would not denounee them in such severe language. Their guilty departure from the truth must not be confounded with the Gnosticism of the 2d cent., though it tended strongly in that direetion; 11 was a Ist-cent. defeetion. Were they newly risen sen- sualists, without predecessors? To some extent their forerunners had already appeared. Sensuality in some of its grosser forms disgraced the church at Corinth (1 Cor 5 1-13; 6 138-20). Inthe eommon meals of this congregation which ended in the eclebration of the Lord’s Supper, they indulged in revelry and gluttony, some of them even being intoxicated (1 Cor 11 17-22). Participation in a heathen festival exposed the Christians to the danger of sharing in idolatry, and yet some of the Corin- thians were addicted to it (1 Cor 8; 10 14-32). In reading of the state of things in the church at Colosse, one perceives how fatal certain views and practices there would soon become if suffered to grow (Col 2 16-23; 3 5-11). Twenty years after the probable date of Jude, in some of-the churches of Asia Minor, wieked parties flourished and domi- nated Christian assemblies that were closely allied in teaching and conduct with the ungodly of Jude. The Nicolaitans, and the ‘woman Jezebel, who calleth herself a prophetess; and she teacheth and seduceth my servants to commit fornication, and to eat things sacrificed to idols’ (Rev 2 20) belong to the same company of libertines as those of Jude. It should be no surprise to us with these examples before us, that according to Jude there were found in the bosom of the Christian community moral delinquents and shameless profligates whose con- duet shocks our sense of propriety and decency, for the like evils, though not so flagrant, troubled the churches in Paul’s lifetime. Jude brands them as enemies and apostates. He pronounces their doom in the words of Enoch: “Behold, the Lord came with ten thousands of his holy ones, to execute judgment upon all” (vs 14.15). It is generally believed that this prophecy of Enoch is quoted by Jude from the apocryphal Book of Enoch. Granting such quotation, that fact does not warrant us to affirm that he indorsed the book. Paul cites from three Gr poets: from Aratus (Acts 17 28), from Menander (1 Cor 15 33; see Earle, Euripides, ‘‘Medea,” Intro, 30, where this is attributed to Euripides), and from Epimenides (Tit 1 12). Does anyone imagine that Paul indorses all that these poets wrote? To the quotation from Epimenides the apostle adds, ‘‘This testimony is true’ (Tit 1 18), but no one imagines he means to say the whole poem is true. So Jude cites a potee from a non-eanonical book, not because he accepts the whole book as true, but this particular predietion he receives as from God. ‘Whence the writer of Enoeh derived it is unknown. It may have been cherished and transmitted from generation to generation, or in some other way faithfully preserved, but at any rate Jude aceepted it as authentic. Paul quotes a saying of the Lord Jesus (Acts 20 35) not recorded in the Gospels, but whence he derived it is unknown. As much may be said of this of Enoch which Jude receives as true. Lirsraturs.—Zahn, Intro ta NT; Salmon, Intro to NT; Westcott, Canon of NT; Purves, Apostolic Age; Alford, Gr Test.; Plumptre, Comm., ‘‘Cambridge Bible Series’’; Lillie, Comm. on 1 and 2 Pet; Bigg, ICC; Vincent, Word Studies. Wiiuram G. Mooreseap JUDEA, j66-dé’a: In Ezr 5 8 for “Judah”; thus RV. In the NT the form is Jupaza (q.v.). JUDGE, juj (WNW, shophet; NT 8ixa0cris, dikas- tés, kpiths, krités): In the early patriarchal times the heads of families and the elders of the tribes were the judges (cf Gen 38 24), and their authority was based on custom. In the wilderness Moses alone was the judge until Jethro suggested a scheme of devolution. On his advice Moses divided the people into groups of thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens, and over each group a wise and good man was set as a judge. Thereafter only the most im- portant cases were brought before Moses (Ex 18 Judges, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1772 13-26; Dt 19-17). This arrangement ceased to be practicable when the children of Israel settled down in Canaan. Although David took counsel with the heads of thousands and hundreds (1 Ch 13 1), it need not be assumed that this was a con- tinuation of the plan adopted by Moses. Probably the local courts were not organized till the time of David. In the days of the Judges justice was ad- ministered by those who had risen by wisdom or valor to that rank (Jgs 4 5). An organized cir- cuit court was established by Samuel, who judged cases himself, and also made his sons judges (1 S 716; 81). After the monarchy was instituted, the king tried all cases, when requested to do so by the wronged person, in the palace gate (1 K 7 7; Prov 20 8). There was no public prosecutor (2 § 14 4; 15 2-6; 1 Ch 18 14; 1 K 3 16; 2K 15 5). Under David and Solomon there were probably local courts (1 Ch 23 4; 26 29). Je- hoshaphat organized a high court of justice (2 Ch 19 8). The prophets often complain bitterly that the purity of justice is corrupted by bribery and false witness (Isa 1 23; 65 23; 101; Am 5 12; 6 12; Mic 3 11; 7 3; Prov 6 19; 12 17; 18 5). Even kings sometimes pronounced unjust sentences, esp. in criminal cases (1 S 22 6-19; 1 K 22 26; 2 K 21 16; Jer 36 26). An evil king could also bend local courts to do his will, as may be gathered from the case of Naboth’s vineyard (1 K 21 1-18). The first duty of a judge was to execute absolute justice, showing the same impartiality to rich and poor, to Jew and foreigner. He was forbidden to accept bribes or to wrest the judgment of the poor (Ex 23 6-8; Dt 16 19). He must not let himself be swayed by popular opinion, or unduly favor the poor (Ex 23 2.3). The court was open to the public (Ex 18 13; Ruth 4 1.2). Each party presented his view of the case to the judge (Dt 1 16; 25 1). Possibly the accused appeared in court clad in mourning (Zec 38). The accuser stood on the right hand of the accused (Zec 8 1; Ps 109 6). Sentence was pro- nounced after the hearing of the case, and the judgment carried out (Josh 7 24.25). The only evidence considered by the court was that given by the witnesses. In criminal cases, not less than two witnesses were necessary (Dt 19 15; Nu 36 30; Dt 17 6; ci Mt 18 16; 2 Cor 13.1; 1 Tim 6 19). In cases other than criminal the oath (see OaTH) was applied (Ex 22 11; cf He 6 16). The lot was sometimes appealed to (Josh 7 14-18), esp. in private disputes (Prov 18 18), but this was exceptional. When the law was not quite definite, recourse was had to the Divine oracle (Lev 24 12; Nu 16 34). Pau, LEVERTOFF JUDGES, juj’iz, BOOK OF: 1. Title 2. Place in the Canon 3. Contents ( Introductory, 1—2 5 (2) Central and Main Portiou, 2 6—16 (3) An Appendix, 17-21 . Chronology . Authorship and Sources . Relation to Preceding Books . Relation to LXX aud Other VSS . Religious Purpose and Valne LITERATURE The Eng. name of the Book of Jgs is a tr of the Heb title (D°ODW, shdphetim), which is reproduced in the Gr Kprral, Kritai, and the Lat Liber Judicum. In the list of the : canonical books of the OT given by Origen (epud Euseb., HE, VI, 25) the name is transliterated Zagparetu, Saphateim, which repre- sents rather ‘judgments’ (sh*phdtim; xpluara, krimata) than “judges.” A passage also is quoted from Philo (De Confus. Linguarum, 26), which ONO 1. Title indicates that he recognized the same form of the name; compare the Gr title of “Kingdoms” (Ba- oirelat, Basiletat) for the four books of § and K. In the order of the Heh Canon the Book of Jgs in- variably occupies the 7th place, folowiug immediately upon Josh and preceding 8S and K. With 2. Place in these it formed the group of the four the Canon ‘“‘earlier prophets” (O°7WN" DN). nebhi'im ri’shénim), the first moiety of the 2d great_division of the Heb Scriptures. As such the Book of Jgs was classified and regarded as ‘“‘ prophetical, equally with the other historical books, on the grouud of the religious and spiritual teaching which its history conveyed. In the rearrangement of the books, which was yndertaken for the purposes of the Gr tr and Canon, Jgs maintained its posaer as 7th in order from the he- ginning, but the short historical Book of Ruth was removed from the place which it held among the Rolls (meghilloth) in the 3d division of the Jewish Canon, and attached to Jgs as a kind of appendix, prohably hecause the narrative was understood to presuppose the same conditions and to have reference to the same period of time. The Gr order was followed in all later VSS, and has maintained itself in modern Bibles. Origen (loc. cit.) even states, prohably hy a mere misunderstanding, that Jgs and Ruth were comprehended hy the Jews under the one title Saphatetm. The Book of Jgs consists of 3 main parts or divisions, which are readily distinguished. (1) Introductory (1—2 &).—A brief 3. Contents summary and recapitulation of the events of the conquest of Western Pal, for the most part parallel to the narrative of Josh, but with a few additional details and some diver- gences from the earlier account, in particular emphasizing (1 27-36) the general failure of the Israelites to expel completely the original inhabit- ants of the land, which is described as a violation of their covenant with Jeh (2 1-3), entailing upon them suffering and permanent weakness. The introductory ver (1 1), which refers to the death of Joshua as having already taken place, seems to be intended as a general indication of the historical period of the book as a whole; for some at least of the events narrated in 1—2 5 took place during Joshua’s lifetime. (2) The central and main portion (2 6—16).— A series of narratives of 12 “judges,” each of whom in turn, by his devotion and prowess, was enabled to deliver Israel from thraldom and oppression, and for a longer or shorter term ruled over the people whom he had thus saved from their enemies. Each successive repentance on the part of the people, however, and their deliverance are followed, on the death of the judge, by renewed apostasy, which entails upon them renewed misery and servitude, from which they are again rescued when in response to their prayer the Lord “raises up” for them another judge and deliverer. Thus the entire history is set as it were in a recurrent framework of moral and religious teaching and warning; and the lesson is enforced that it_is the sin of the people, their abandonment of Jeh and persistent idolatry, which entails upon them calamity, from which the Divine long-suffering and forbearance alone makes for them a way of escape. (a) 2 6—8 6: A second brief introduction, con- ceived entirely in the spirit of the following narra- tives, which seems to attach itself to the close of the Book of Josh, and in part repeats almost verbally the account there given of the death and burial of Israel’s leader (Jgs 2 6-9 || Josh 24 28-31), and proceeds to describe the condition of the land and people in the succeeding generation, ascribing their misfortunes to their idolatry and repeated neglect of the warnings and commands of the judges; closing with an enumeration of the peoples left in the land, whose presence was to be the test of Israel’s willingness to obey Jeh and at the same time to prevent the nation from sinking into a con- dition of lethargy and ease. 1773 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judges, Book of (b) 3 7—3 11: Judgeship of Othniel who de- livered Israel from the hand of Cushan-rishathaim. (c) 3 12-30: Victory of Ehud over the Moabites, to whom the Israelites had been in servitude 18 years. Ehud slew their king Eglon, and won for the nation a long period of tranquillity. (d) 3 31: Ina few brief words Shamgar is named as the deliverer of Israel from the Philis. The title of “judge” is not accorded to him, nor is he said to have exercised authority in any way. It is doubt- ful, therefore, whether the writer intended him to be regarded as one of the judges. (e) Chs 4,5: Victory of Deborah and Barak over Jabin the Can. king, and death of Sisera, cap- tain of his army, at the hands of Jael, the wife of a Kenite chief; followed by a Song of Triumph, de- scriptive and commemorative of the event. (f) Chs 6-8: A 7-year oppression at the hands of the Midianites, which is described as peculiarly severc, so that the land became desolate on account of the perpetual raids to which it was subject. After a period of hesitation and delay, Gideon de- feats the combined forces of the Midianites and Amalekites and the “‘children of the east,” i.e. the wandering Bedawin bands from the eastern deserts, in the valley of Jezreel. The locality and course of the battle are traced by the sacred writer, but it is not possible to follow his account in detail because ef our inability to identify the placesnamed. After the victory, Gideon is formally offered the position of ruler for himself and his descendants, but refuses; nevertheless, he seems to have exercised a measure of restraining influence over the people until his death, although he himself and his family apparently through covetousness fell away from their faithful- ness to Jch (8 27.33). (g) Ch 9: Episode of Abimelech, son of Gideon by a concubine, who by the murder of all but one of his brethren, the legitimate sons of Gideon, secured the throne at Shechem for himself, and for 3 years ruled Israel. After successfully stamping out a revolt at Shechem against his authority, he is himself killed when engaged in the sicge of the citadel or tower of Thebez by a stone thrown by a woman. (h) () 10 1-5: Tola and Jair are briefly named as successive judges of Israel for 23 and 22 years respectively. ; (j) 10 6—12 7: Oppression of Israel for 18 years by the Philis and Ammonites. The national de- liverance is effected by Jephthah, who is described as an illegitimate son of Gilead who had been on that account driven out from his home and had become the captain of a band of outlaws. Jeph- thah stipulates with the elders of Gilead that if he undertakes to do battle on their behalf with the Ammonites, he is afterward to be recognized as their ruler; and in accordance with the agreement, when the victory has been won, he becomes judge over Israel (11 91; 12 7). See JmpurHag. (k) @) (m) 12 8-15: Three of the so-called “minor”? judges, Ibzan, Elon and Abdon, judged Israel in succession for 7, 10 and 8 years respectively. As they are not said to have delivered the nation from any calamity or oppression, it is perhaps to be understood that the whole period was a time of rest and tranquillity. . (n) Chs 18-16: The history of Samson (see separate art.). ; 13) An Disa chs 17-21.—The final section, in the nature of an appendix, consisting of two nar- ratives, independent apparently of the main portion of the book and of one another. They contain no indication of date, except the statement 4 t repeated that “in those days there was no king in Israel” (17 6; 18 1; 19 1; 21 25). The natural inference is that the narratives were committed to writing in ; site and renaming it ‘“‘Dan.” the days of the monarchy; but the events themselves were understood by the compiler or historian to have taken place during the period of the Judges, or at least anterior to the establishment of the king- dom. The lawless state of society, the violence and disorder among the tribes, would suggest the same conclusion. No name of a judge appears, however, and there is no direct reference to the office or to any central or controlling authority. Jos also seems to have known them in reverse order, and in a position preceding the histories of the judges themselves, and not at the close of the book (Ant, V, ii, 8-12; iii, 1; see E. Konig in HDB, II, 810). Even if the present form of the narratives is thus late, there can be little doubt that they contain elements of considerable antiquity. (a) Chs 17-18: The episode of Micah the Ephraimite and the young Levite who is conse- crated as priest in his house. A war party, how- ever, of the tribe of Dan during a migration north- ward, by threats and promises induced the Levite to accompany them, taking with him the priestly ephod, the household goods of his patron, and a costly image which Micah had caused to be made. These Micah in vain endeavors to recover from the Danites. The latter sack and burn Laish in the extreme N. of Pal, rebuilding the city on the same There they set up the image which they had stolen, and establish a rival priesthood and worship, which is said to have endured ‘‘all the time that the house of God was in Shiloh” (18 31). (b) Chs 19-21: Outrage of the Benjamites of Gibeah against the concubine of a Levite lodging for a night in the city on his way from Bethlehem to the hill country of Ephraim. The united tribes, after twice suffering defeat at the hands of the men of Benjamin, exact full vengeance; the tribe of Ben- jamin is almost annihilated, and their cities, includ- ing Gibeah, are destroyed. In order that the tribe may not utterly perish, peace is declared with the 600 survivors, and they are provided with wives by stratagem and force, the Israelites having taken a solemn vow not to permit intermarriage between bles own daughters and the members of the guilty tribe. The period covered by the history of the Book of Jgs extends from the death of Joshua to the death of Samson, and adds perhaps a later 4. Chro- reference in 18 31, “all the time that nology the house of God was in Shiloh” (cf 1813). It is, however, difficult, perhaps impossible, to compute in years the length of time that the writer had in mind. That he pro- ceeded upon a fixed chronological basis, supplied probably by tradition but modified or arranged on @ systematic principle, seems evident. The diffi- culty may be due in part to the corruption which the figures have suffered in the course of the transmis- sion of the text. In 1 K 6 1 an inclusive total of 480 years is given as the period from the Exodus to the building of the Temple in the 4th year of the reign of Solomon. This total, however, includes the 40 years’ wandering in the desert, the time occu- pied in the conquest and settlement of the Promised Land, and an uncertain period after the death of Joshua, referred to in the Book of Jgs itself (2 10), until the older generation that had taken part in the invasion had passed away. There is also to be reckoned the 40 years’ judgeship of Eli (1 S 4 18), the unknown length of the judgeship of Samuel (7 15), the years of the reign of Saul (cf 1 S 13 1, where, however, no statement is made as to the length of his reign), the 40 years during which David was king (1 K 2 11), and the 4 years of Solomon before the building of the Temple. The recurrence of the number 40 is already noticeable; but if for Judges, Book of Judges, Period of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1774 the unknown periods under and after Joshua, of Samuel and of Saul, 50 or 60 years be allowed—a moderate estimate—there would remain from the total of 480 years a period of 300 years in round numbers for the duration of the times of the Judges. It may be doubted whether the writer conceived of the period of unsettlement and distress, of alternate oppression and peace, as lasting for so long a time. The chronological data contained in the Book of Jgs itself are as follows: Years Oppression of Cushan-rishathaim, king of Meso- POUCA S?:S) cares seas heed eohtas seat b Sueuiente Sa Deliverance by Othniel and rest (3 11).. Oppression of Eglon, king of Moab (3 14 Deliverance hy Ehud and rest (3 30).... Oppression of Jahin, king of Canaan (4 3) Deliverance hy Barak and rest (5 31) 40 Oppression of Midian (6 1).........-......00. 7 Deliverance hy Gideon and rest (8 28)......... 40 Rule of Abimelech (9 22)...........00 00 ce euee 3 Judgeship of Tola (10 2).........--...2.00008 23 Judgeship of Jair (10 3)... 2... cee eee eee 22 Oppression of the Philis and Ammonites (10 8)..18 Deliverance by Jephthah, aud his judgeship (12 7) 6 Judgeship of Ibzan (12 9). ets Judgeship of Elon (12 11) .10 Judgeship of Abdon (12 14) 1. 8 Oppression of the Philis (13 1)................ 40 Judgeship of Samson (15 20; 16 31)........... 20 Atotal of 410 years, or, if the years of foreign oppression and of the usurpation of Abimelech are omitted, of 296. It has been supposed that in some instances the rule of the several judges was contemporaneous, not successive, and that therefore the total period during which the judges ruled should be reduced accordingly. In itself this is sufficiently probable. It is evident, however, that this thought was not in the mind of the writer, for in each case he de- scribes the rule of the judge as over “Israel” with no indication that ‘Israel’ is to be understood in a partial and limited signification. His words must therefore be interpreted in their natural sense, that in his own belief the rulers whose deeds he related exercised control in the order named over the entire nation. Almost certainly, however, he did not intend to include in his scheme the years of oppres- sion or the 3 years of Abimelech’s rule. If these be deducted, the resultant number (296) is very near the total which the statement in 1 K 6 1 suggests. No stress, however, must be laid ypon this fact. The repeated occurrence of the number 40, with its double and half, can hardly he accidental. The same fact was noted above in connection with earlier and later rulers in Israel. It suggests that there is present an element of artificiality and conscious arrangement in the scheme of chronology, which makes it impossible to rely upon it as it stands for any definite or reliable historical con- clusion. Within the Book of Jgs itself no author is named, nor is any indication given of the writer or writers who are responsible for the form in 6. Author- which the book appears; and it would ship and seem evident, also, that the 3 parts or Sources divisions of which the book is com- posed are on a different footing as regards the sources from which they are drawn. The Talmudic tradition which names Samuel as the author can hardly be seriously regarded. The historical introduction presents a form_of the traditional narrative of the conquest of Pal which is parallel to but not identical with that contained in the Book of Josh. Brief and discon- nected as it is, it is of the greatest value as a his- torical authority, and contains elements which in origin, if not in their present form, are of consider- able antiquity. The main portion of the book, comprising the narratives of the judges, is based upon oral or written traditions of a local and perhaps a tribal character, the value of which it is difficult to estimate, but which undoubtedly in some in- stances have been more carefully preserved than in others. In particular, around the story of Sam- son there seem to have gathered elements derived from the folklore and the wonder-loving spirit of the countryside; and the exploits of a national hero have been enhanced and surrounded with a glamor of romance as the story of them has passed from lip to lip among a people who themselves or their forefathers owed so much to his prowess. Of this central part of Jgs the Song of Deborah (ch 5) is the most ancient, and bears every mark of being a contemporary record of a remarkable conflict and victory. The text is often difficult, almost unin- telligible, and has so greatly suffered in the course of transmission as in some passages to be beyond repair. As a whole the song is an eloquent and impassioned ode of triumph, ascribing to Jeh the great deliverance which has been wrought for His people over their foes. : The narratives of Jgs, moreover, are set InN a framework of chronology and of ethical comment and teaching, which are probably independent of one another. The moral exhortations and the lessons drawn from hardships and sufferings, which the people of Israel incur as the consequence of their idolatry and sin, are conceived entirely in the spirit of Dt, and even in the letter and form bear a con- siderable resemblance to the writings of that book. In the judgment of some scholars, therefore, they are to be ascribed to the same author or authors. Of this, however, there is no proof. It is possible, but perhaps hardly probable. They certainly belong to the same school of thought, of clear-sighted doctrine, ofreverent piety, and of jealous concern for the honor of Jeh. With the system of chronology, the figures and dates, the ethical commentary and inferences would seem to have no direct relation. The former is perhaps a later addition, based in part at least upon tradition, and applied to existing accounts, in order to give them their definite place and succes- sion in the historical record. Finally, the three strands of traditional narrative, moral comment, and chronological framework were woven into one whole by a compiler or reviser who completed the book in the form in which it now exists. Concerning the absolute dates, however, at which these processes took place very little can be determined. The two concluding episodes are distinct, both in form aud character, from the rest of the book. They do not relate the life or deeds of a judge, nor do they, explicitly at least, convey any moral teaching or warning. They are also mutually independent. It would seem there- fore that they are to be regarded as accounts of national events or experiences, preserved by tradition, which, because they were understood to have reference to the period of the Judges, were included in this book. The internal nature of the narratives themselves would sug- gest that they belong rather to the earlier than the later part of the time during which the judges held rule; and their ancient character is similarly attested. There is no clue, however, to the actual date of their composition, or to the time or circumstauces under which they were incorporated in the Book of Jgs. The discussion of the relation of the Book of Jgs to the generally recognized sources of the Pent and to Josh has been in part anticipated in 6. Relation the previous paragraph. In the earliest to Preced- introductory section of the book, and ing Books in some of the histories of the judges, esp. in that of Gideon (chs 6-8), it is not difficult to distinguish two threads of nar- rative, which have been combined together in the account as it now stands; and by some scholars these are identified with J and E in the Pent. The conclusion, however, is precarious and uncertain, for the characteristic marks of the Pent ‘sources’ are in great measure absent. There is more to be said for the view that regards the intro- duction (1—2 5), with its verbal parallels to Josh as derived ultimately from the history of JE, from which, however, very much has been omitted, 1775 and the remainder adapted and abbreviated. Eveu this moderate conclusion cannot be regarded as definitely established. The later author or com- piler was in possession of ancient documents or traditions, of which he made use in his composite narrative, but whether these were parts of the same historical accounts that are present in the books of Moses and in Josh must be regarded as_undeter- mined. There is no trace, moreover, in Jgs of ex- tracts from the writing or school of P; nor do the two concluding episodes of the book (chs 17-21) prea any features which would suggest an identi- noation with any of the leading ‘‘sources” of the ent. The moral and religious teaching, on the other hand, which makes the varied national experiences in the times of the Judges a vehicle for ethical in- struction and warning, is certainly derived from the same school] as Dt, and reproduces the whole tone and spirit of that book. There is no evidence, however, to identify the writer or reviser who thus turned to spiritual profit the lessons of the age of the Judges with the author of Dt itself, but he was animated by the same principles, and endeavored in the same way to expound the same great truths of religion and the Providence of God. There are two early Gr tr: of the Book of Jgs, which seem to be on the whole independent of one another. These are Peprescuied hy the two great . uncial MSS, (Vatican) and A (Alexan- 7. Relation drine). With the former is associated a to LXX group of cursive MSS and the Sahidic or and Other Upper Egyp VS. It is therefore probahle Versions that the tr is of Egyp origin, and by some it has heen identified with that of He- 5 sychius. It has heen shown, moreover, that in this hook, and probably elsewhere, the ancient character of the text of B is not always maintained, but in parts at least betrays a later origin. The other VS is contained in A and the majority of the uncial and cursive MSS of the Gr texts, and, while certainly a real and independent tr from the original, is thought hy some to show acquaintance with the VS of B. There is, however, no definite evidence that B's tr is really older. Some of the cursives which agree in general with A form sub-groups; thus the recension of Lucian is believed to he represented by a small number of cursives, the text of which is printed by Lagarde (Librorum VT Canonicorum, Pars Prior, 1883), and is substantially identical with that in the “Complutensian Polyglot'’ (see G. F. Moore, Critical and Exegetical Comm. on Jgs, Edinhurgh, 1895, xllii ff). Itis probable that the true original text of the LXX is not represented completely either by the one or the other VS, but that it partially underlies both, and may be traced in the conflicting readings which must he judged each on its own merits. Of the other pEnee VSS, the Old Lat and the Hexa- plar Syr, together with the Armenian and the Ethiopic, attach themselves to a sub-group of the MSS associated with A. The Bohairic VS of the Book of Jgs has not hitherto been published, but, like the rest of the OT, its text would no doubt he found to agree substantially with B. Jerome's tr follows closely the MT, and is independent of hoth Gr VSS; and the Pesh also is a direct rendering from the Heh. Thus the main purpose of the Book of Jgs in the form in which it has been preserved in the OT is not to record Israel’s past for its 8. Religious own sake, or to place before the writer’s Purpose contemporaries a historical narrative and Value of the achievements of their great men and rulers, but to use these events and the national experiences of adversity as a text from which to educe religious warning and instruction. With the author or authors spiritual edification is the first interest, and the facts or details of the his- tory, worthy of faithful records, because it is the history of God’s people, find their chief value in that they are and were designed to be admonitory, exhibiting the Divine judgments upon idolatry and sin, and conveying the lesson that disobedience and rebellion, a hard and defiant spirit that was for- getful of Jeh, could not fail to entail the same disastrous consequences. The author is preémi- nently a preacher of righteousness to his fellow- countrymen, and to this aim all other elements in THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judges, Book of Judges, Period of the book, whether chronological or historical, are secondary and subordinate. In his narrative he sets down the whole truth, so far as it has become known to him through tradition or written docu- ment, however discreditable it may be to his nation. There is no ground for believing that he either ex- tenuates on the one hand, or on the other paints in darker colors than the record of the transgressions of the people deserved. Neither he nor they are to be judged by the standards of the 20th cent., with its accumulated wealth of spiritual experience and long training in the principles of righteousness and truth. But he holds and asserts a lofty view of the character of Jeh, of the immutability of His wrath against obstinate transgression and of the certainty of its punishment, and yet of the Divine pitifulness and mercy to the man or nation that turns to Him with a penitent heart. The Jews were not mistaken when they counted the Book of Jgs among the Prophets. It is prophecy, more than history, becanse it exhibits and enforces the per- manent, lessons of the righteousness and justice and loving-kindness of God. Lirerature.—A complete hibliography of the lit. up to date will he found in the Dicts. s.v. Cay DB, 1893; HDB, II, 1899; EB, II, 1901; cf G. F. Moore, Critical and Exegetical Comm. on Jgs, Edinhurgh, 1895; SBOT, Leipzig, 1900; R. A. Watson, “ Jgs"' and ‘‘Ruth,"’ in Exposttor’s Bible, 1889: G. W. Thatcher, ‘‘Jgs’’ and “Ruth,"' in Century Bible; 8. Oettli, ‘‘ Das Deuteronomium und die Biicher Josua und Richter,"" in Kurzgefasster Kommentar, Miinchen, 1893; K. Budde, ‘‘Das Buch der Richter,’ in Kurzer Hand-Kommentar zum AT, Tubingen, 1897; W. Nowack, ‘'Richter,"’ in Hand- kommentar zum AT, 1900. A. 8. GEDEN JUDGES, PERIOD OF: I. Sources Ii. CuHronoiooy III. Generar Pourrticat Situation 1. The Canaanites 2. Foes Without IV. Main Events 1. Struggles of Individual Trihes 2. Civil Strife. 3. The Six Invasions 4. Need of Central Government V. Reuoious ConpitTions VI. TuroLooicaAl INTERPRETATION LiTERATURS I. Sources.—Our chief sources of information are the Book of Jgs and 1 § 1-12. The material con- tained in these is not all of the same age. The oldest part, by common consent, is the Song of Deborah (Jgs 8). It is a contemporaneous docu- ment. The prose narratives, however, are also early, and are generally regarded as presenting a faithful picture of the times with which they deal. The Book of Ruth, which also refers to this period, is probably in its present form a later composition, but there is no adequate ground for denying to it a historical basis (Kénig, Finleitung, 286 ff; Kent, Student's OT, I, 310 f). Il. Chronology.—The period of the Judges extends from the death of Joshua to the estahlishment of the monarchy. How long a time elapsed hetweeu these limits is'a matter of wide difference of opinion. The chronological data in the Book of Jgs, i.e. omitting Eli and Samuel, make a total of 410 years. But this is in- consistent with 1 K 6 1, where the whole period from the Exodus to the 4th year of Solomon is reckoned at 480 years. Various attempts have been made to har- monize these divergent figures, e.g. hy eliminating the 70 years attributed to the Minor Judges (10 1-5; 7-15), hy not couuting the 71 years of foreign domina- tion, and by the theory that some of the judges were contemporaneous. It is probable that the 480 years of 1 K 6 1 was a round numher and did not rest on exact records. Indeed, it is douhtful if there was any fixed calendar in Israel before the time of the mouarchy. The only way then to determine the length of the period of the Judges is from the date of the Exodus. The com- mon view is that the Exodus took place during or just after the reign of Merenptah in the latter half of the 13th cent. BC. This, however, leaves hardly more than 150 years to the period of the Judges, for Saul's reign fell in the 2d half of the 11th cent. BC. Hence some, to whom this seems too short, assign the Exodus to the Judges, Period of Judgment, Last THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1776 reign of Amenophis II, about 1450 BC. This harmon- izes with the 480 years of 1 K 6 1, and is supported by other considerations (POT, 422-24), Still others have connected the Exodus with the expulsion of the Hyksos about 1580 BC (G. A. Pare and this would fit in very well with the chronological data in the Book of Jgs. The objection to the last two views is that they require a rather long period of snbjection of the Israelites in Canaan to Egypt, of which there is no trace in the Book of Jgs. See, further, Jupoxzs, Boox or, IV. III. General Political Situation.—The death of Joshua left much land yet to be possessed by the Israelites. The different tribes had 1. The received their respective allotments Canaanites (Jgs 1 3), but the actual possession of the territory assigned each still lay in the future and was only gradually achieved. The Canaanites remained in the land, and were for a time a serious menace to the power of Israel. They retained possession of the plains and many of the fortified cities, e.g. Gezer, Harheres, Aijalon, Shaal- bim, and Jerus on the northern border of Judah (Jga 1 21.29.35), and Bethshean, Ibleam, Taanach, Megiddo, and Dor along the northern border of Manasseh (Jgs 1 27.28). Besides these foes within Canaan, the Israelites had enemies from without to contend with, viz. the Moabites, Midianites, Ammonites, and Philis. The danger from each of these quarters, except that from the Philis, was successfully warded off. The conflicts in which the Israelites were thus involved were all more or less local in character. In no ease did all the tribes act together, though the duty of such united action is clearly taught in the Song of Deborah, at least so far as the 10 northern tribes are concerned. The omission of Judah and Simeon from this ancient song is strange, but may not be so significant as is sometimes supposed. The judges, who were raised up to meet the various emergencies, seem to have exercised jurisdiction only over limited areas. In general the different tribes and clans acted independently of each other. Local home rule prevailed. ‘Every man did that which was right in his own eyes” (Jgs 17 6). That Canaan was not during this period subdued and kept in subjection by one of the great world- powers, Egypt or Babylonia, is to_be regarded as providential (HPM, I, 214f). Such subjection would have made impossible the development of a free national and religious life in Israel. The Cushan-rishathaim of Jgs 8 7-10 was more likely a king of Edom than of Mesopotamia (Paton, Early History of Syria and Palestine, 161-62). IV. Main Events.—Much of what took place during this period is unrecorded. Of the struggles through which the individual tribes 1. Struggles passed before they succeeded in estab- 2. Foes Without of Indi- lishing themselves in the land, little vidual is known. One interesting episode Tribes is preserved for us in Jgs 17,18. A considerable portion of the tribe of Dan, hard pressed by the Amorites (Jgs 1 34f), migrated from their allotted home W. of Judah to Laish in the distant north, where they put the inhabitants to the sword, burnt the city and then rebuilt it under the name of Dan. This took place early in the period of the Judges, apparently during the first generation after the conquest (Jgs 18 30). At about the same time also (Jgs 20 28) seems to have occurred the war with Benjamin (Jgs 19- 21), which grew out of an outrage per- 2. Civil petrated at Gibeah and the refusal Strife of the Benjamites to surrender the ee guilty parties for punishment. The historicity of this war has been called in question, but it seems to be attested by Hos 99; 10 9. And that civil strife in Israel was not otherwise unknown during this period is clear from the expe- riences of Gideon (Jgs 8 1-3) and Jephthah (Jgs 12 1-6), not to mention those of Abimelech (Jgs 9). It is a current theory that the tribes of Simeon and Levi early in this period suffered, a serious reverse (Gen 49 5-7), and that a reflection of this event is to be found in Gen 34; but the data are too uncertain to warrant any confidence in this view. Six wars with other nations are recorded as taking place in this period, and each called forth its judge or judges. Othniel delivered the Is- 3. The Six raelites from the Mesopotamians or Invasions Edomites (Jgs 3 7-11), Ehud from the Moabites (3 12-30), Deborah and Barak from the Canaanites (chs 4, 5), Gideon from the Midianites (chs 6-8), and Jephthah from the Ammonites (10 6-12.17). In the strife with the Philis, which was not terminated during this period, Samson (Jgs 13-16), Eli (1 8 4-6), and Samuel (18 73-14; 9 16) figure. Of these six wars those which brought Othniel, Ehud and Jephthah to the front were less serious and significant than the other three. The conflicts with the Canaanites, Midianites and Philis mark distinct stages in the history of the period. Aas After the first successes of the Israelites in Canaan a period of weakness and disintegration set in. The Canaanites, who still held the fortified cities in the plain of Esdraelon, banded themselves together and terrorized the region round about. The Hebrews fled from their villages to the caves and dens. None had the heart to offer resistance (Jgs 5 6.8). It seemed as though they were about to be subdued by the people they had a short time before dispossessed. Then it was that Deborah appeared on the scene. With her passionate ap- peals in the name of Jeh she awakened a new sense of national unity, rallied the discouraged forces of the nation, and administered a final crushing defeat upon the Ganaanites in the plain of Megiddo. But the flame thus kindled after a time went out. New enemies came from without. The Midianites invaded the land year after year, robbing it of its produce (Jgs 6 1.3). This evil was suddenly put an end to by the bold stroke of Gideon, whose vic- tory was long treasured in the public memory (Isa 9 4; 10 26; Ps 83 9-12). But the pees at least of Manasseh and perhaps also of Ephraim, now realized that it was no longer safe to depend upon such temporary leadersbip. They needed a permanent organization to ward off the dangers that beset them. They therefore offered the king- ship to Gideon. He formally declined it (Jgs 8 22.23), but still set up a government at Ophrah which the people looked upon as hereditary (Jgs 9 2). He was succeeded by his son Abimelech, who, after slaying all but one of his 70 brothers, assumed the title of king. The new kingdom, how- ever, was of short duration. It ended after three years with the ignominious death of the king. A great danger was needed before the people of Israel could be welded into unity and made to see the necessity of a strong central gov- 4. Need of ernment. This came eventually from Central the Philis, who twice defeated the Government Israelites in battle, captured the ark, and overran a large part of the country (1 8 4-6). In the face of such a foe as this it was clear that only a strong and permanent leadership of the whole people would suffice (1 S 9 15; 10 1); and thus the rule of the Judges gave way to the monarchy. V. Religious Conditions.—The Heb mind to which Moses addressed himself was not a tabula rasa, and the Palestinian world into which the Israelites entered was not an intellectual blank. Formative influences had for ages been at work on the Heb mind, and Pal had long been inhabited by 1777 dges, Period of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA ti aerien Last a people with fixed institutions, customs and ideas. When then Israel settled in Canaan, they had both a heathen inheritance and a heathen environment to contend with, It should therefore occasion no surprise to find during this period such lapses from the purity of the Mosaic faith as appear in the ephod of Gideon (Jgs 8 24-27), the images of Micah (Jgs 17-18), and the sacrifice of Jephthah’s daughter (11 34-40). In the transition from a nomadic to an agricultural life it was inevitable that the Hebrews with their native heathen pro- clivities would adopt many of the crude and even immoral religious customs and beliefs of the people among whom they settled. But the purer Mosaic faith still had its representatives. The worship of the central sanctuary at Shiloh remained imageless. Leaders like Deborah and Samuel revived the spirit of Moses. And there can hardly be a doubt that in many a quiet home a true and earnest piety was cultivated like that in the home of Elimelech and Naomi. VI. Theological Interpretation.—The Bib. his- torian was not content simply to narrate events. What concerned him most was the meaning lying back of them. And this meaning he was interested in, not for its own sake, but because of its appli- cation to the people of his own day. Hence inter- mingled with the narratives of the period of the Judges are to be found religious interpretations of the events recorded and exhortations based upon them. The fundamental lesson thus inculcated is the same as that continually insisted upon by the prophets. The Divine government of the world is based upon justice. Disobedience to the moral law and disloyalty to Jeh means, therefore, to Israel suffering and disaster. All the oppressions of the period of the Judges arose in this way. Relief and deliverance came only when the people turned unto Jeh. This religious pragmatism, as it is called, does not lie on the surface of the events, so that a naturalistic historian might see it. But itis a corre- late of the ethical monotheism of the prophets, and constitutes the one element in the OT which makes the study of Israel’s history supremely worth while. Lirerature.—Jos, Ant, V, ii-vi, 5; Ottley, Short His- tory of the Hebrews, 101-24: Kittel, History of the Hebrews, II, 60f, 2d Ger. ed, II, 52-135. ALBERT CorNELIUS Knupson JUDGING, juj'ing, JUDGMENT, juj’ment: Often in the OT for “to act as a magistrate’ (Kx 18 13; Dt 116; 16 18, etc), justice being ad- ministered generally by “elders” (Ex 18 13-27), or “kings” (1 8 8 20) or “priests” (Dt 18 15); applied to God as the Supreme Judge (Ps 9 7.8; 10 18; 96 13; Mic 4 3, ete; Ps 7 8: “Jeh min- istereth judgment,” vividly describes a court scene, with Jeh as Judge). . Often in the NT, ethically, for (1) “to decide,” “sive a verdict,” “declare an opinion” (Gr krind); (2) “to investigate,” “scrutinize” (Gr anakrin6) ; (3) “to discriminate,” “distinguish” (Gr diakriné). For (1), see Lk 7 43; Acts 15 19; for (2) see 1 Cor 2 15; 4 3; for (3) see1 Cor 11 31; 14 29m. Used also forensically in Lk 22 30; Acts 26 10; and applied to God in Jn 6 22; He 10 30. The judg- ments of God are the expression of His justice, the formal declarations of His judgments, whether em- bodied in words (Dt 6 1 AV, RV “statutes”’), or deeds (Ex 6 6; Rev 16 7), or in decisions that are yet to be published (Ps 36 6). Man’s consciousness of guilt inevitably associates God’s judgments as declarations of the Divine justice, with his own con- demnation, i.e. he knows that a strict exercise of justice means his condemnation, and thus “judg- ment” and “condemnation” become in his mind synonymous (Rom & 16); hence the prayer of Ps 143 2, “Enter not into judgment’; also, Jn 6 29, “the resurrection of judgment” (AV “damnation’’); 1 Cor 11 29, ‘eateth and drinketh judgment” (AV “damnation”’). ; H. E. Jacogs JUDGMENT, DAY OF. See Jupement, Last. JUDGMENT HALL, juj’ment hél (rd rpavradprov, 6 prattérion, ‘Then led they Jesus . . . . unto the hall of judgment . . . . and they themselves went not into the judgment hall” [Jn 18 28 AV]; ‘Then Pilate entered into the judgment hall again’ [18 33. AV]; “[Pilate] went again into the judgment hall” [19 9]; “He commanded him to be kept in Herod’s judgment hall” [Acts 23 35]): “Judgment hall” is one of the ways in which AV translates praitdrion, which it elsewhere renders “Praetorium” (Mk 15 16); ‘the common hall” (Mt 27 27). In this passage ERV_ renders it “palace”; in Jn 18 33; 19 9; Acts 23 35, “pal- ace’’ is also given by ERV; in Phil 1 13, AV renders ““palace,’”’ while RV gives “the praetorian guard.” Praitérion accordingly is tr¢ in all these ways, “Praetorium,” “the common hall,” ‘the judgment hall,” “the palace,” “the praetorian guard.” In the passages in the Gospels, ARV renders uni- formly ‘‘Praetorium.”’ The word originally meant the headquarters in the Rom camp, the space where the general’s tent stood, with the camp altar; the tent of the com- mander-in-chief. It next came to mean the military council, meeting in the general’s tent. Then it came to be applied to the palate in which the Rom governor or procurator of a province resided. In Jerus it was the magnificent palace which Herod the Great had built for himself, and which the Rom proc- urators seem to have occupied when they came from Caesarea to Jerus to transact public business. Praitérion in Phil 1 13 has heen variously ren- dered, ‘“‘the camp of the practorian soldiers,’ ‘the praetorian guard,” ete. For what is now believed to be its true meaning, see PRAETORIUM. JoHN RUTHERFURD JUDGMENT, LAST: In Christian theology the Last Judgment is an act in which God interposes directly into human history, brings 1. A Tran- the course of this world to a final close, scendental determines the eternal fate of human Doctrine —_ beings, and places them in surround- ings spiritually adapted to their final condition. The concept is purely transcendental, and is to he distinguished from the hope that. God will interfere in the history of this world to deter- mine it undeviatingly toward good. The tran- scendental doctrine is possible only when an exalted idea of God has been attained, although it may after- ward be united with crasser theories, as in certain naive conceptions of Christianity at the present day. In the religion of Israel, the doctrine of the Last Judgment arose from “transcendentalizing’ the concept of the ‘Day of the Lord.” 2. The Just as hope of immortality replaced Doctrine in desire for length of days on earth, just the Religion as for ‘‘the rejuvenation of Pal’’ was of Israel substituted “an eternal abode in a new earth,” so the ideal of a military vic- tory over Israel’s enemies expanded into God’s solemn condemnation of evil. The concept thus strictly defined is hardly to be sought in the OT, but Dnl 12 1-3 may contain it. The first unequivocal assertion would appear to be in En 91 17, where the final state is contrasted with a preceding reign of earthly happiness. (If there has been no redac- tion in the latter part of this section, its date is prior to 165 BC.) Hereafter the idea is so preva- Jent in the Jewish writings that detailed reference is needless. But itishy no means universal. Writ- ings touched with Gr thought (En 108; 4 Mace; Judgment Seat Judith, Book of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1778 Philo) are content with an individual judgment at death. A unique theory is that of the Test. XII P (Levi 18 8-14, e.g.), where the world grows into final blessedness without catastrophe. But much more common is the persistence of the non-transcendental ideas, ingrained as they were in the thought of the people (even in Philo; cf his prophecy of national earthly glory in Ezcr 9). This type of thought was so tenacious that it held its own alongside of the transcendental, and both points of view were accepted by more than one writer. Then the earthly happiness precedes the heavenly (as in En 91), and there are two judgments, one by the Mes- siah and the other by God (2 Esd_7; Syr Bar 29, 30). So in Rev, where in ch 19 Christ overcomes the enemies in battle-symbolism and establishes the Millennium, while the Last Judgment is held by God (20 11 ff). Otherwise the Messiah is never the judge except in the Parables of Enoch, where He appears as God’s vicar uniformly (in 47 3 God fixes the time of judgment only). Possibly in Wisd 4 16; 5 1 menshare in the judgment-act but other- wise they (and angels) appear only as “assessors” or as executors of the sentence. In Wisd 3 8, ‘Sudging” is used in the OT sense of “rule” (Jgs 3 10, etc), as is the case in Mt 19 28 || Lk 22 30; 1 Cor 6 2.3 (in the last case with the word in two senses). Further studies in the variation of the (rather conventionally fixed) details of the judgment will interest the special student only. For discussions of the relevant Bib. passages, see Day or THE Lorp; EscuatoLtocy; Parousia. The doctrine has real religious value, for it insists on a culmination in the evolution (or degeneration!) of the race as well as of the individual. So it is contrasted with the pessimism of natural science, which points only toward the gradual extinction of humanity through the cooling of the sun. Literature.—The variations of the concept are treated fully only in Volz, Jtidische Eschatologie. For general lit. see EscoatTo.toar; Parovsta. Burton Scotr Baston JUDGMENT SEAT (Pipa, béma, “a raised place,” “platform,” “tribune,” Mt 27 19; Jn 19 13; see GaBBATHA; Acts 12 21 m [text ‘‘throne’]; 18 12.16 ff; 26 6.17): In Gr law courts, one béma was provided for the accuser, another for the ac- cused; but in the NT the word designates the official seat of a judge, usually of the Rom governor; also of the emperor (Acts 25 10); then of God (Rom 14 10), of Christ (2 Cor 5 10). The word xpirijpuwy», kritérion, “a tribunal,” “bench of judges” (Jas 2 6) occurs also in t Cor 6 2-4, and is there tr¢ in RVm by “tribunals.” See also Junaz. JUDICIAL, j66-dish’al, BuinpNESss, JUDICIAL. JUDICIAL COURTS. See Courts, Jupictau. BLINDNESS. See JUDICIAL HARDENING. See Happen. JUDITH, joo’dith (for etymology, article): (1) A wife of Esau, daughter of Beeri the Hittite (Gen 26 34). (2) The heroine of the Book of Jth in Apoc—a pious, wealthy, courageous, and patriotic widow who delivered Jerus and her countrymen from the assault of Holofernes, the general of Nebuchad- nezzar who had arranged the expedition which aimed at making Nebuchadnezzar the object of universal human worship. The 8th and following chapters of the book describe her actions which resulted in the cutting off of the head of Holofernes, the rout of the Assyr army, and the de- liverance of the Jews. See Jupitu, Book or. see next JUDITH, BOOK OF: I. Name TI. Canonicity III. Contents IV. Fact or Fiction? V. Dare 1. Probably during the Maccabean Age 2. Other Opinions (1) Invasion of Pompey (2) Insurrection under Bar Cochba VI. OrnicinaL LANGUAGE . WERSIONS 1. Greek 2. Syriac 3. Latin 4. Hebrew LiItBRATURE I. Name,—This apocryphal book is called_after the name of its principal character Judith (N77, yhadhith, “a Jewess’; *Iov5(0, Toudith, *lov599, Toudéth). The name occurs in Gen 26 34 and the corresponding mase. form (77), y*hadhi, ‘a Jew’’) in Jer 36 14.21.23 (name of a scribe). In other great crises in Heb history women have played a great part (cf Deborah, Jgs 5, and Esther). The Books of Ruth, Est, Jth and Susannah are the only ones in the Bible (including the Apoc) called by the names of women, these women being the principal characters in each case. Hf. Canonicity.—Though a tale of Jewish patriotism written originally in Heh, this book was never admitted into the Heb Canon, and the same applies to the Book of Tob. But hoth Jth and_ Tob were recognized as canonical by the Council of Carthage (397 AD) and by the Council of Trent (1545 AD). Though, however, all Romanists include these books in their Bible (the Vulg), Protestant VSS of the Bible, with very few exceptions, exclude the whole of the Apoc (see ApocrypHA). In the X and Vulg, Tob and Jth (in that order) follow Neh and precede Est. In the EV of the Apoc, which _un- fortunately for its understanding stands alone, 1 Esd, 2 Esd, Tob aud Jth occupy the first place and in the order named. In his tr of the Apoc, Luther, for some unex- pitied reason, puts Jth at the head of the apocryphal ooks, Wisdom taking the next place. IIT. Contents.—The book opens with an account of the immense power of Nebuchadnezzar, king of Assyria, whose capital was Nineveh. (In the days of the real Nebuchadnezzar, Assyria had ceased to be, and its capital was destroyed.) He calls upon the peoples living in the western country, including Pal, to help him to subdue a rival king whose power he feared—Arphaxad, king of the Medes (other- wise quite unknown). But as they refused the help he demanded, he first conquered his rival, annexing his territory, and then sent his general Holofernes to subdue the western nations and to punish them for their defiance of his authority. The Assyr general marched at the head of an army 132,000 strong and soon took possession of the lands N. and E. of Pal, demolishing their idols and sanctuaries that Nebuchadnezzar alone might be worshipped as god (chs 1-3). He now directed his forces against the Jews who had recently returned from exile and newly rebuilt and rededicated their temple. Having heard of the ruin of other temples caused by the invading foe, the Jews became greatly alarmed for the safety of their own, and fortified the mountains and villages in the south, providing themselves with food to meet their needs in the event of war. At the urgent request of Joakim (“Eliakim” in the Vulg and Pesh), the inhabitants of Bethulia (so the Lat, Eng., and other VSS, but Bervhova, Betulotia is more correct according to the Gr) and of Betomestham (both places otherwise un- known) defended the adjoining mountain passes which commanded the way to Jerus. Holofernes at once laid siege to Bethulia, and by cutting off the water supply aimed at starving the people to sub- mission. But he knows little of the people he is seeking to conquer, and asks the chiefs who are with him who and what these Jews are. Achior, the Am- monite chief, gives an account of the Israelites, con- 1779 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judgment Seat Judith, Book of cluding that when faithful to their God they were invincible, but that when they disobeyed Him they were easily overcome. Achior is for this saying expelled and handed over to the Jews. After hold- ing out for some days, the besieged people insisted that Onias their governor should surrender. This he promises to do if no relief comes in the course of five days. A rich, devout and beautiful widow called Judith (daughter of Merari, of the tribe of- Simeon (8 1]), hearing of these things, rebukes the murmurers for their lack of faith and exhorts them to trust in God. As Onias abides by his promise to the people, she resolves to attempt another mode of deliverance. She obtains consent to leave the fortress in the dead of night, accompanied by her maidservant, in order to join the Assyr camp. First of all she pniye earnestly for guidance and success; then doffing her mourning garb, she puts on her most gorgeous attire together with jewels and other ornaments. She takes with her food allowed by Jewish law, that she might have no neces- sity to eat the forbidden meats of the Gentiles. Passing through the gates, she soon reaches the Assyrians. First of all, the soldiers on watch take her captive, but on her assuring them that she is a fugitive from the Hebrews and desires to put Holofernes in the way of achieving a cheap and easy victory over her fellow-countrymen, she is warmly welcomed and made much of. She reiter- ates to Holofernes the doctrine taught by Achior that these Jews can easily be conquered when they break the laws of their Deity, and she knows the necessities of their situation would lead them to eat food prohibited in their sacred laws, and when this takes place she informs him that he might at once attack them. Holofernes listens, applauds, and is at once captured by her personal charms. He agrees to her proposal and consents that she and her maid should be allowed each night to say their prayers out in the valley near the Heb fortress. On the 4th night after her arrival, Holofernes arranges a banquet to which only his household servants and the two Jewesses are invited. When allis over, by a preconcerted plan the Assyr general and the beautiful Jewish widow are left alone. He, however, is dead drunk and heavily asleep. With his own scimitar she cuts off his head, calls her maid who puts it into the provision bag, and together they leave the camp as if for their usual prayers and join their Heb compatriots, still frantic about the immediate future. But the sight of the head of their arch foe puts new heart into them, and next day they march upon the enemy now in panic at what had happened, and win an easy victory. Judith became ever after a heroine in Jewish ro- mance and poetry, a Heb Joan of Arc, and the tale of the deliverance she wrought for her people has been told in many languages. For later and shorter forms of the tale see VII, 4 (Heb Midrashes). IV. Fact or Fiction?—The majority of theolo- gians down to the 19th cent. regarded the story of Jth as pure history; but with the exception of O. Wolf (1861) and von Gumpach, Protestant scholars in recent times are practically agreed that the Book of Jth is a historical novel with a purpose similar to Dnl, Est and Tob. Schiirer classes it with “parenetic narratives” (pardnetische Erzdh- lung). The Heb novel is perhaps the earliest of all novels, but it is always a didactic novel written to enforce some principle or principles. Roman Catholic scholars defend the literal historicity of the book, though they allow that the proper names are more or less disguised. But the book abounds with anachronisms, inconsistencies and impossi- bilities, and was evidently written for the lesson it teaches: obey God and trust Him, and all will be well. The author had no intention to teach history. Torrey, however, goes too far when he says (see Jew Enc, “Book of Jth’) that the writer aimed at nothing more than to write a tale that would amuse. A tone of religious fervor and of intense patriotism runs through the narrative, and no opportunity of enforcing the claims of the Jewish law is lost. Note esp. what is taught in the speeches of Achior (5 12-21) and Judith (8 17-24; cf 11 10), that, trusting in God and keeping His commandments, the nation is invulnerable. According to the narrative Nebuchadnezzar has been for 12 years king of Assyria and has his capital at Nineveh, though we know he never was or could be king of Assyria. He became king of Babylon in 604 BC, upon the death of his father Nabopolas- sar, who in 608 had destroyed Assyria. The Jews had but recently returned from exile (4 3; 5 19), but were independent, and Holofernes knew nothing about them (6 3). Nebuchadnezzar died in 561 BC and the Jews returned under Cyrus in 538. Bethulia to which Holofernes lay siege was other- wise quite unknown: it is probably a disguised form of Béh Elohim or Béth 'Hloh, “house of God,” and means the place where God is with His people. The detailed description of the site is but part of the writer's art; it was the place which every army must pass on its way to Jerns. As a matter of fact, there is no such position in Pal, and least of all Shechem, which Torrey identified with Bethu- lia. We know nothing besides what ch 1 tells us of “Arphaxad who reigned over the Medes in Ecbatana’’; on the contrary, in every other mention of the name it stands for a country or a race (see Gen 10 22.24; 11 10-13). V. Date.—It is evident that this religious ro- mance was prompted by some severe persecution in which the faith of the Jews was 1. During sorely tried, and the writer’s domi- the Macca- nant aim is identical with that of the bean Age author of Dnl, viz. to encourage those suffering for their religion by giving instances of Divine deliverance in the darkest hour. “Only trust and keep the law; then deliverance will unfailingly come’—that is the teaching. Jth might well have been written during the persecution of the Maccabean age, as was almost certainly the Book of Dnl. We have in this book that zeal for orthodox Judaism which marked the age of the Maccabees, and the same strong belief that the war in which the nation was engaged was a holy one. The high priest is head of the state (see 4 6), as suiting a period when the religious interest is upper- most and politics are merged in religion, thongh some say wrongly that John Hyrcanus (135-106 BC) was the first to combine priestly and princely dignities. We have another support for a Macca- bean date in the fact that Onias was high priest during the siege of Bethulia (4 6), the name being suggested almost certainly by Onias III, who be- came high priest in 195 (or 198) BC, and who died in 171 after consistently opposing the Hellenizing policy of the Syrians and their Jewish allies. That the persecutions of Antiochus Epiphanes (175-164 BC) supply as good a background for this book as any other event in Jewish history is the least that can besaid; but one may not be dogmatic on the matter, as similar conditions recurred in the nation’s history, and there is no external or internal evidence that fixes the date definitely. The follow- ing scholars decide for a date in the Maccabean age: Fritzsche, Ewald, Hilgenfeld, Schiirer, Ball, Cornill and Lébr. The author was certainly a resident in Pal, as his local knowledge and interestsshow; and from his punctilious regard for the law one may judge that he belonged to the Hasidaean (hdstdhim) party. Since he so often mentions Dothan (Gr Dothae, Dothaim) (3 9; 4 6; 7 3.18; 8 3), it is Judith, Book of Justice THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1780 probable that he belonged to that neighborhood. Though, however, the author wrote in the time of the Maccabees, he seems to set his history in a framework that is some 200 years earlier, as Néldeke (Die altlest. Lit., 1868, 96; Aufsdtze zur persischen Geschichte, 1887, 78) and Schiirer (GJV, III, 323 ff) show. In 350 BC, Artaxerxes Ochus (861-338 BC) invaded Phoenicia and Egypt, his chief generals being Holofernes (2 4, etc) and Bagoas (12 11), both of whom are in Jth officials of King Nebu- chadnezzar and take part in the expedition against the Jews. This was intended probably to disarm the criticism of enemies who might resent any writ- ing in which they were painted in unfavorable colors. (1) Invasion of Pompey.—That it was the invasion of Pompey which gave rise to the hook is the opinion held by Gaster. If this were so, Jth and the Ps 2. Other Sol arose under the pressure of the same Salty circumstances (see Ryle and James, The Opinions Psalms of Solomon, XL, aud J. Rendel about the Harris, Zhe Odes and_Psalms of Solomon, Date Ill), But in the Ps Sol the supreme ruler is a king (17 22), not a high priest (Jth 4 6). Besides, anyone who reads the Ps Sol and Jth will feel that in the former he has to do with a different and later age. rae es Insurrection under Bar Cochba.—Hitzig (who held that the insurrection under Bar Cochba, 132 AD, is the event referred to), Volkmar and Graetz_date this book in the days of the emperor Trajan (or Hadrian ?). Volkmar gives himself much trouble iu his attempt to prove that the campaigns of Nehuchadnezzar stand really for those of Trajan. But itis a sufficient refuta- tion of this opinion that the book is quoted by Clement of Rome (55), who died in 100 AD, and whose reference to the book shows that it was regarded in his day as authoritative and even as canonical, so that it must have been written long before. VI. Original Language.—That a Heb or (less. likely) an Aram. original once existed is the opinion of almost all modern scholars, and the evidence for this seems conclusive. There are many Hebraisms in the book, e.g. év rats qudpacs, en tails hémérais (‘Sn the days of,” 1 7, and 9 t besides); the frequent use of o¢ddpa, sphédra, in the sense of the Heb NA, m’sdh, and even its repetition (also a Hebra- ism, 4 8); ef émt wodd opbdpa, ept pol sphédra (6 18) and rA#G0s rodd ofbdpa, pléthos poli sphédra (2 17). Note further the following: ‘Let not thy eye spare,” etc (2 11; cf Ezk 6 11, ete); ‘as I live” (in an oath, 2 12); “God of heaven” (6 8; 11 17); “son of man,” parallel with ‘‘man,” and in the same sense (8 16); “and it came to pass when she had ceased crying,” etc (10 1); ‘the priests who serve in Jerus before the face of our God” (11 138). In16 3 we have the words: ‘Fora god that shatters battle is [the] Lord.” Now “Lord” without the article can be only the Heb “Yahweh,” read always *ddhonay, “Lord.” But the phrase, ‘to shatter battle,” 1s not good Gr or good sense. The Heb words shdbhath (‘‘to rest”; cf shabbath, ‘Sabbath’’) and shdbhar (‘to break”) are written much alike, and in the original Heb we must have had the causative form of the first vb.: “A God that makes war cease is [the] Lord” (see Ps 46 9). Moreover, the Heb idiom which strengthens a finite vb. by placing a cognate (absolute) infinitive before it is represented in the Gr of this book in the usual form in which it occurs in the LXX (and in Welsh), viz. a participle followed by a finite vb. (see2 13). The present writer has noted other examples, but is prevented by lack of space from adding them here. That the original book was Heb and not Aram. is made extremely likely by the fact that the above examples of Heb idiom are peculiar to this language. Note esp. the idiom, “and it came to pass that,” etc (2 4), with the implied “waw consecutive,” and what is said above about 11 13, where the senseless Gr_ arose through the confusion of two similarly written Heb (not Aram.) words. There are cases also of mistakes in the Gr text due to wrong tr from the Heb, asin 1 8 (where for ‘‘nations” read “cities” or “mountains”); 22 (where for “concluded,” Heb aa , wa-ykhal, read “revealed,” Do, wa-yr- ghal); 3 1.9.10 (see Fritasche, s.v.), etc. VII. Versions. —The Gr text appears in three forms: (1) that of the principal Gr uncials (A, B, agreeing closely), which is followed in printed editions of the 1. Greek LXX; (2) that of codd. 19, 108 (Lucian's > GTee: text), an evident revision of (1); (3) cod. : 58 which closely resembles (2) and with which the Old Lat and Pesh agree in most points. There are two extant Syr VSS, hoth of them depend- ent on the Gr text (3) noted above. The Pesh is given in Walton's Poluaie ane me ec aC revised form in Lagarde, Lib. Vet. Tes 2. Syriac "hoe Syr, 104-26. ‘The so-called Hexa- plar Syr text was made by Paul of Tella in the 6th cent. (1) The Old Lat seems to have been made from the Gr text, cod. 58 (see above). (2) Jerome made his Lat 8 (with which the Vulg is identical) from 3. Latin a lost Chaldee VS. That this last is not : the original text of the hook is certain. be- cause neither Origen nor his Jewish teachers knew anything of a Heb or Aram. text of Jth. Several late Heb VSS of the book have been found, no one of them with strong claims to be cousidered the original text, though Gaster (see #B, IT, 4, Hebrew (601,2,642) does make such @ claim for the ve S$ found, edited and tr’ by _him (see Midrashes pgpa, XVI, 156-63), The Heb_ mid- rashes were made to be read in Jewish homes and vary according to the circumstances of their origin. But they agree in these points: Proper names are often omitted. Jerus is the scene of action, the wars being those of the Maccabees. Judith is a Jewish maiden and daughter of Ahitah, according to the Gaster MS, and she_helongs apparently to the Maccabean family. It is Nicanor who is beheaded, the occasion heing the Feast of Dedication; in the Gaster MS it is the king who is kiNed. Translations of these midrashes may he seen in Jellinck, Beth Hammidrash, I, 130-41; II, 12f; Lepsius, Zeitschr. fir wiss. Theologie, 1867, 337 ff; Ball, Speaker's Apoc, I, 25 ff; Scholz, Comm.?, Anhange I and II; Gaster, op. cit. _Gaster argues that the much shorter form of the tale in his MS is older than the longer VS. But if a writer were to expand a short story, he would hardly be likely to invent several proper names and to change others. It is probable that Judith came to be represented as a pure maiden (a virgin) under the influ- ence of the low conception of marriage fostered in the mediaeval Christian church. Lireraturs.—For the editions of the Gr text and for comms. on the Apoc, see under ArocrypHaL LitEeRa- tuRE. But on Jth note in particular the commen- taries by Fritzsche and Ball, the latter containing elab- orate hibliography. But the following must in addition be mentioned: Scholz, Commentar tiber das Buch Judith und iiber Bel und Drache, 1896; _@ 2d ed has appeared; A. S. Weissmann, Das Buch Judith historisch-kritisch beleuchtet, Wien, 1891; Schiirer, GJ V4, III, 230-37, with full bibliography; cf HJ P, II, iii, 32-37; Pentin, The Apoe in English Lit., Judith, 1908; aud the relevant articles in the Bible dicts., esp. that by F. C. Porter in HDB. ; T. Witton Daviss JUEL, joo’el ({1] "Iowé, Found; [2] *ToufA, Touél): E (1) 1 Esd 9 34=“Uel” in Ezr 10 34. (2) 1 Esd 9 85=“‘Joel” in Ezr 10 48. JUGGLERY, jug’lér-i (yonrla, goétia): The word occurs once in 2 Macc 12 24 RVm (AV “craft,” RV ‘‘crafty guile’). JUICE, j00s, jis: -The word occurs once in Cant 8 2 (tr of OD OY, ‘dsis, RVm “sweet wine’), and once in RVm of Job 6 6, where for ‘‘the white of an egg’ m reads, “the juice of purslain.”’ LXX has pijpacw Kevois, rhémasin kenots, “empty words.” JULIA, joo'li-a (Tovdta, Toulia): The name of a Rom Christian to whom St. Paul sent greetings, the wife or sister of Philologus with whose name hers is coupled (Rom 16 15). The name points to a member of the imperial household. JULIUS, j6o'li-us (’TotAvos, Jovilios): The cen- turion of the Augustan cohort under whose charge Paul was sent a prisoner to Rome (Acts 27 1.8). See Anmy, Roman; Banp, AUGUSTAN. JUMPING, jum’ping. See Games. 1781 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Judith, Book of Justice JUNIAS, j60’ni-as or JUNIA, joo’ni-a (Iovvias, Tountas, "Iovvla, Iounia): One to whom, with Andronicus, greetings are sent by Paul at the close of his letter to the Romans (Rom 16 7). The name may be masc., Junias, a contraction of Ju- nianus, or fem. Junia; itis Iountan, the accus. form, that is given. In all probability this is the masc., Junias. Paul defines the two as (1) ‘‘my kinsmen,” (2) “my fellow-prisoners,’”’ (3) ‘‘who are of note among the apostles,”’ and (4) “who also have been in Christ before me.” (1) They were Jews. Paul calls the Jews “my brethren,” ‘‘my kinsmen according to the flesh” (Rom 9 3). Because Prisca and Aquila, a Jew and Jewess, are not designated as kinsfolk, Cony- beare and Howson suppose “‘the epithet to denote that the persons mentioned were of the tribe of Benjamin.”’ (2) They had been companions of Paul in some unrecorded imprisonment. The phrasc denotes more than the fact that they, like Paul, had suffered imprisonment for the sake of Christ. 3) This may mean (a) that they were well known to the apostolic circle (so Gifford and Weiss), or (b) distinguished as apostles. The latter is probably correct, ‘‘apostle’’ being used in a wide sense (cf 1 Cor 15 7). The prophetic ministry of the early church consisted of apostles, prophets and teachers (1 Cor 12 28; Eph 411), the apostles being missionaries in the modern sense (see Lindsay, Church and Ministry, ch iii). Some apostles were missionaries sent out by particular churches (Acts 13 2.3; 2 Cor 8 23; Phil 2 25). (4) They were among the first converts, “early disciples” like Mnason of Cyprus (Acts 21 16). ee . 8. F. Hunter JUNIPER, j60’ni-pér (OF, rothem; faeuev, rhathmén, 1 K 19 4f, m “broom”; Ps 120 4,m “broom”; Job 30 4 tr “broom”): This is quite certainly the Arab. ratam (Retama retem, N.O. Leguminosae), a va- riety of broom which is one of the most characteristic shrubs of the deserts of Southern Pal and southward to ‘Egypt. Though the shade it affords is but scanty, in the absence of other shrubs it is frequently used by desert travelers as a refuge from the sun’s scorching rays (cf 1 K 19 4). The root yields good charcoal, giving out much heat (Ps 120 4). For people to be reduced to chew it for nourishment betokens the lowest depth of starvation (Job 30 4). Indeed so hopeless is this root as a source ‘ of food that many commentators believe that the accepted text is in error, and by altering a single letter, substituting 7 for ™, they get a readin 1 which has been adopted in RVm, “to warm them instead of “their meat,” which certainly is much more probable. E. W. G. Masterman Retem Bush (Retama retem). PITER, joo’pi-tér, ji'pi-tér (Zets, Zetis): oppiter” is pienabied in 2 Mace 6 2; Acts 14 12.13, with “Zeus” in the RVm in all cases. In addition the Gr stem appears in domrerobs, diopetous, in Acts 19 35, EV “which fell down from Jupiter’; but the word means “from the clear sky” (cf “from heaven” in the RVm). “Jupiter”? was considered the Lat equivalent of the Gr ‘‘Zeus,”’ the highest god in the developed Gr pantheon, and Zeus in turn, in accord with the syncretism of the period, was identified with countless deities in the local cults of Asia Minor and elsewhere. So in Acts 14 12.13, “Zeus”? and ‘Hermes’ are local deities that had been renamed. On the other hand, the Zeus of 2 Macc 6 2 is the genuine Gr deity, who had been adopted as a special patron by Antiochus Epiphanes and to whose temple in Athens Antiochus had con- tributed largely. The title “Olympius” (2 Macc 6 2) is derived from the early worship on Mt. Olym- pus, but had come to be thonght one of the god’s highest appellations; Xenios, “protector of stran- gers,’’ was a title in a cult particularly popular with travelers. See ABomMINATION oF DESOLATION, and Smith, HGH L, 333-34. Burton Scott Easton JUPITER AND MERCURY. See Asrroxoey, Ill, 1; Mercury; Jupiter. JURISDICTION, joo-ris-dik’shun (éovela, exousia): The word exousia is well known in NT ‘Gr. It is derived from the word ézestt, and sug- gests the absence of any hindrance to an act. It contains the idea of right and might (Cremer). In the NT it means right, authority, capability (Rom 9 21); power, strength (Mt 9 8); right and might (Jn 5 27). Thusit gets the meaning of the powers of the magistrate, which it bears in later Gr (Tit 3 1; Rom 13 1-3). And in this sense it is used in Lk 23 7, where it is tr? “Jurisdiction.” JUSHAB-HESED, j6o’shab-hé’sed (TOM AD, yushabh hesedh, “loving-kindness is returned”): Son of Zerubbabel. The name is probably sym- bolical (1 Ch 3 20); ef Sauan-JasHus. JUSTICE, jus’tis (WPTY, edhakah, PTL, cedhek; Stcacorivyn, dikatostiné): The original Heb and Gr words are the same as those rendered “right- eousness.” This is the common rendering, and in about half, the cases where we have ‘‘just’”? and ‘justice’ in AV, ARV has changed to “righteous” and “righteousness.” It must be constantly borne in mind that the two ideas are essentially the same. See RIGHTEOUSNESS. Justice had primarily to do with conduct in rela- tion to others, esp. with regard to the rights of others. It is applied to business, 1. Human where just weights and measures are Justice demanded (Lev 19 35.36; Dt 25 13— 16; Am 8&5; Prov 111; 16 11; Ezk 45 9.10). It is demanded in courts, where the rights of rich and poor, Israelite and sojourner, are equally to be regarded. Neither station nor bribe nor popular clamor shall influence judge or witness. “Justice, justice shalt thou follow’ (Dt 16 20m; ef vs 18-20; Ex 23 1-3.6-9). In general this justice is contrasted with that wickedness which “feared not God, and regarded not man” (Lk 18 2). In a larger sense justice is not only giving to others their rights, but involves the active duty of establishing their rights. So Israel waits upon God’s justice or cries out: ‘The justice due to me [lit. “‘my justice’’] is passed away from my God” (Isa 40 27). Jeh is to show her to be in the right as over against the nations. Justice here becomes mercy. To ‘“‘seek justice’? means to “relieve the oppressed, judge the fatherless, plead for the widow” (Isa 117; cf 11.4; Jer 22 15.16; Ps 82 2-4). Thesame idea appearsin Dt 24 12.13; Ps 87 21.26; 112 4-6, where the tr is “righteous” instead of ‘ust.’ oth this conception of justice the full meaning of Justice justification THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1782 the NT is not yet reached. It does not mean sin- lessness or moral perfection. Job knows the sin in his heart (Job 13 23.26; 7 21), and yet speaks of himself as a just or righteous man (12 4; 13 18). The Psalmist confidently depends upon the right- eousness of God though he knows that no man is righteous in God’s sight (Ps 143 1.2; cf 7 8; 18 20-24). It is not a lack of humility or dependence upon God when the Psalmist asks to be judged according to his righteousness. In relation to God, the just, or rightcous, man is the one who holds to God and trusts in Him (Ps 33 18-22). This is not the later Judaistic legalism with its merit and reward, where God’s justice is simply a matter of giving each man what he has earned. The word “justice” does not occur in the NT, and in most cases where we find “just” in AV it is changed to “righteous” in ARV. The idea of jus- tice or righteousness (remembering that these are essentially the same) becomes more spiritual and ethicalin the NT. It is a matter of character, and God’s own spirit is the standard (1 Jn 3 7; Mt 5 48). The mere give-and-take Justice is not enough. We are to be merciful, and that to all. The ideal is righteousness, not rights. As Holtz- mann says, ‘““The keynote of the Sermon on the Mount is justitia and not jus.” God’s justice, or righteousness, is founded in His essential nature. But, just as with man, it is not something abstract, but is seen in His 2. Justice relation to the world. It is His king- of God ship establishing and maintaining the right. It appears as retributive jus- tice, ‘that reaction of His holy will, as grounded in His eternal being, against evil wherever found.” He cannot be indifferent to good and evil (Hab 1 13). The great prophets, Isaiah, Micah, Amos, Hosea, all insist: upon Jeh’s demand for righteous- ness. But this is not the main aspect of God’s justice. Theology has been wont to set forth God’s justice as the fundamental fact in His nature with which we must reconcile His mercy as best, we may, the two being conceived as in conflict. a matter of fact, the Scriptures most often conceive God’s justice, or righteousness, as the action of His mercy. Just as with man justice means the relief of the oppressed and needy, so God’s justice is His kingly power engaged on behalf of men, and justice and mercy are constantly joined together. Heis ‘‘a just God and a Saviour” (Isa 45 21). “I bring near my righteousness [or ‘‘justice”] .. . . and my salvation shall not tarry’ (Isa 46 13; cf Ps 51 14; 103 17; 7115; 116 5; Isa 51 5.6). The “Tighteous acts of Jeh” mean His deeds of deliverance (Jgs 5 11). And so Israel sings of the justice, or judgments, or righteousness of Jeh (they are the same), and pro- claims her trust in these (Ps 7 17; 35 23.24.28; 36 6; 140 12.13; 60 5.6; 94 14.15; 103 6; 143 1). The NT, too, does not lack the idea of retributive justice. The Son of Man “shall render unto every man according to his deeds’ (Mt 16 27; cf 25 14-46; Lk 12 45-48; Rom 2 2-16; 6 23; 2 Cor 510; Col 3 24.25; 2 Thess 18.9; He 2 2.3; 10 26-31). But God’s justice is far more than this. The idea of merit and reward is really superseded by a higher viewpoint in the teaching of Jesus. He speaks, indeed, of recompense, but it is the Father and not the judge that gives this (Mt 6 1.4.6.18). And it is no mere justice of earth, because the reward transcends all merit (Mt 24 46.47; Mk 10 30; Lk 12 37). This is grace not desert (Lk 17 10). And the parable of Mt 20 1-15 gives at length the deathblow to the whole Judaistic scheme of merit and reward. And God’s justice is not merely gracious, but redemptive. It not simply apportions rights, it establishes righteousness. Thus, just asin the OT, the judge is the Saviour. The difference is simply here: in the OT the salvation was more national and temporal, here it is personal and spiritual. But mercy is opposed to justice no more here than inthe OT. Itis by the forgiveness of sins that God establishes righteousness, and this is the supreme task of justice. Thus it is that God is at the same time “just, and the justifier of him that hath faith in Jesus” (Rom 3 26). ‘He is faithful and right- eous [or ‘‘just’’; sec AV] to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 Jn 1 9). Lirzrature.—see Comm., and Bih. Theologies under “Justice” and ‘‘Righteousness,’’ and esp. Cremer, Bib.- Theol. Lex. of NT Gr. Harris Frankuin Ratt JUSTIFICATION, jus-ti-fi-ka’shun (PY , cedhek, vb. PIX, cadhék; LXX and NT S:xalopa, dikaidma, Stxalwors, dikatdsis, vb. Sinaidw, dikaidd, ‘justifica- tion,” “to justify,” in a legal sense, the declaring just or righteous. In Bib. lit. &xatotv, dikaioin, without denying the real righteousness of a person, is used invariably or almost invariably in a declara- tive or forensic sense. See Simon, HDB, I, 826; Thayer, Grimm, and Cremer under the respective words): I. Tae Writtnes or Pact 1. Universality of Sin 2. Perfection of the Law of God 3. Life, Work and Death of the Atoning Saviour (1) Paul’s Own Experience (2) The Resurrection Connected with the Death 3 (8) Faith, Not Works, the Means of Justifica- ion 3 Baptism Also Eliminated (5) Elements of Justification fe) Forgiveness of Sins _ b) Declaring or a peaving as Righteous (6) Justification Has to Do with the Individual II. Tae Oraer NT Waittnes 1. The Synoptic Gospels 2. John’s Writings 3. 1 Peter and Hebrews 4. Epistle of James III. Taz OT IV. Later DeveLorpMent or THE Doctrine 1. Apostolic and Early Church Fathers 2. Council of Trent 3. Luther 4. Schleiermacher 5. Meaning and Message to the Modern Man LiteERatuRE I. The Writings of Paul.—In this article refer- ence will first be made to the writings of Paul, where justification receives its classic ex- 1. The Uni- pression, and from there as a center, versality the other NT writers, and finally the of Sin OT, will be drawn in. According to é Paul, justification rests on the foliow- ing presuppositions: The universality of sin. All men are not only born in sin (Eph 2 3), but they have committed many actual transgressions, which render them liable to condemnation. Paul proves this by an appeal to the OT witnesses (Rom 3 9 ff), as well as by universal experience, both of the heathen (1 18-32) and Jews (2 17-28; 3 9). _ The perfection of the Law of God and the neces- sity of its perfect observance, if justification is to come by_ it (3 10). The modern 2. The notion of God as a good-natured, more Perfection or less nonchalant ruler, to whom per- of the Law fect holiness is not inexorable, was not of God that of Paul. If one had indeed kept the law, God could not hold him guilty (2 13), but such an obedience never existed. Paul had no trouble with the law as such. Those who have tried to find a difference here between Gal and Rom have failed. The reminder that the law was ordained by angels (Gal 3 19) does not mean that it was not also given by God. It might be reckoned in a sense among the elements of the world (késmos, 1783 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Justice Justification 4 3), as it is an essential part of an ordered universe, but that docs not at all mean that it is not also holy, right and good (Rom 7 12). It was added, of course, on account of transgressions (Gal 3 19), for it is only a world of intelligent, free spirits capable of sin which needs it, and its high and beautiful sanctions make the sin seem all the more sinful (Rom 7 18). _It was fundamental in Paul’s thinking that Christ died for our sins, according to the Scriptures (1 Cor : In due season He died for the 3. The Life, ungodly (Rom 5 6); while we were Work and yet: sinners He died for us (ver 8); we Death of are justified in His blood (ver 9), and the Atoning it is through Him that we are saved Saviour from the wrath (ver 9). While we were enemies we were reconciled to God through the death of His Son (ver 10), being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus whom God set forth as a pro- pitiation (8 24.25). There is no reconciliation, no justification, except through and by and for Christ. (1) Paul's own experience—Paul's own experience can- not he left out of the account. He lived through the doctrine, as well as found it through illumination of the Spiritin the OT, It was not that he had only outwardly kept the law. He had been jealous for it, and bad been blameless in_every requirement of its righteousness (Phil 3 6). What was borne in upon him was how little such hlamelessness could stand before the absolute standard of God. Just how far he was shaken with doubts of this kind we cannot say with certainty; but it seems impossible to conceive the Damascus conver- sion scene in the case of such an upright man and stren- uous zealot without supposing a psychological prepara- tion, without supposing doubts as to whether his ful- filling of the law enabled him to stand before God. Now, for a Pharisaically educated man like himself, there was no way of overcoming these doubts but in a renewed struggle for his own righteousness shown in the fiery zeal of his Damascus journey, pressing on even in the blazing light of noonday. This conversion broke down his pen esop ny of life, his Lebensgewissheit, his assur- ance of salvation through works of the law done never so conscientiously and perfectly. The revelation of the glorified Christ, with the assurance that He, the God-sent Messiah, was the very one whom he was persecuting, destroyed his dependence on his own righteousness, @ righteousness which had led him to such shocking conse- quences. Although this was for him an individual ex- erience, yet it had universal applications. It showed im that there was an inherent weakness in the law through flesh, that is, through the whole physical, psy- chical and spiritual nature of man considered as sinful, as working only on this lower plane, and that the law needed bracing and illuminating by the Son, who, though sent in the likeness of the flesh of sin, yet _(as an offering) for sin condemned sin and cast it out (Rom 8 Phe the end that the law might be fulfilled in those who through Him walk not after the flesh but after the Spirit (ver 4). That was the glory of the new righteousness thus revealed. If the law had been able to do that, to give life, Christ need not have come, righteousness would have been by the law (Gal 3 21). But the facts show that the law was not thus able, neither the law written on the heart given to all, nor the law given to Moses (Rom 1 18-3 19). Therefore every mouth is stopped, and all flesh is silent before God. On the ground of law-keeping, what the modern man would call morality, our hope of salvation has been shattered. The law has spoken its judgment against us (Gal 3 10). It cannot therefore lead us to righteousness and life, nor was that its supreme intention: 1 was a pedagogue or tutor (“paidagog6s"') to lead us to Christ that we might be justified by faith (ver 24; see Ihmels in RE’, 16, 483-84). ‘What made Paul to differ from his companions in the faith was that his own bitter experience under the reve- lation of Christ had led him to these facts. (2) The resurrection connected with the death_— It was remarked above that the ground of justifi- cation according to Paul is the work of Christ. This means esp. His death as a sacrifice, in which, as Ritschl well says (Rechifertigung und Verséhnung, 3. Aufl., 1899, TT, 157), the apostles saw exercised the whole power of Hisredemption. But that death cannot be separated from His resurrection, which first awakened them to a knowledge of its decisive worth for salvation, as well as finally confirmed their faith in Jesus as the Son of God. ‘‘The ob- jective salvation,” says Ritschl (p. 158), “which was connected with the sacrificial death of Christ and which continued on for the church, was made secure by this, that it was asserted also as an attri- bute of the resurrected one,’’ who was delivered up for our trespasses, and was raised for our justifi- cation (Rom 4 25). But this last expression is not to be interpreted with literal preciseness, as though Paul intended to distinguish between the forgive- ness of sins as brought about by the death, and justification, by the resurrection, for both forgive- ness and justification are identified in 4 6-8. It was the resurrection which gave Christians their assurance concerning Christ (Acts 17 31); by that resurrection He has been exalted to the right hand of God, where He maketh intercession for His people (Rom 8 34), which mediatorship is founded upon His death—the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world (Rev 13 8m; ef Gr text). B. Weiss well says: ‘It was by the certainty of the exaltation of Christ to Messianic sovereignty brought about by the resurrection that Paul attained to faith in the saving significance of His death, and not conversely. Accordingly, the assurance that God cannot condemn us is owing primarily to the death of Christ, but still more to His resurrection and exaltation to God's right hand (Rom § 34), inasmuch as these first prove that His death was the death of the mediator of salvation, who has redeemed us from condemnation. .... The ob- jective atonement was accomplished by the death of Christ, but the appropriation of it in justification is Possible only if we believe in the saving significance of is death, and we can attain to faith in that only as it is sealed by the resurrection” (Bik. Theol. of NT, I, 436-37). (3) Faith, not works, the means of justification — The means or condition of justification is faith (Rom 3 22.25.26.28, etc) which rests upon the pure grace of God and is itself, therefore, His gift, (Eph 28). This making faith the only instrument of . justification is not arbitrary, but because, being the receptive attitude of the soul, it is in the nature of the case the only avenue through which Divine blessing can come. The gifts of God are not against the laws of the soul which He has made, but rather are in and through those laws. Faith is the hand outstretched to the Divine Giver, who, though He sends rain without our consent, does not give sal- vation except through an appropriate spiritual response. This faith is not simply belief in his- torical facts, though this is presupposed as to the atoning death (Rom 3 25), and the resurrection (10 9) of Jesus, but is a real heart reception of the gift (ver 10), and is therefore able to bring peace in our relation to God (5 1). The object of this faith is Jesus Christ (3 22, etc), through. whom only comes the gift of righteousness and the reign- ing in life (6 17), not Mary, not angels, not doc- trine, not the church, but Jesus only. This, to be sure, does not exclude God the Father as an object of faith, as the redeeming act of Christ is itself the work of God (2 Cor 6 19), whose love expressed itself toward us in this way (Rom 6 8). Faith in the only one God is always presupposed (1 Cor 8 6), butit was the apostolic custom rather to refer repentance to God and faith to Christ (Acts 20 21). But the oneness of God the Father and Christ the Son in a work of salvation is the best guaranty of the Divinity of the latter, both as an objective fact and as an inner experience of the Christian. The justification being by faith, it is not by works or by love, or by both in one. It cannot be by the former, because they are lacking either in time or amount or quality, nor could they be accepted in any case until they spring from a heart renewed, for which faith is the necessary presupposition. It cannot be by the latter, for it exists only where the Spirit has shed it abroad in the heart (Rom 56 5), the indispensable prerequisite for receiving which is faith. This does not mean that the crown of Chris- Justification THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1784 tianity is not love, for it is (1 Cor 13 13); it means only that the root is faith. Nor ean love be foisted in as a partial condition of justification on the strength of the word often quoted for that purpose, “faith working through love” (Gal 5 6). The apostle is speaking here only of those who are already ‘fn Christ,” and he says that over against the Galatian believers bringing in a lot of legal observ- ances, the only availing thing is not circumcision or its lack, but faith energizing through love. Here the interest is, as Ritschl says (II, 343), in the king- dom of God, but justification proper has reference to the sinner in relation to God and Christ. See the excellent remarks of Bruce, St. Paul’s Con- ception of Christianity, 1894, 226-27. At the same time this text reveals the tremendous ethical reli- gious force abiding in faith, according to St. Paul. It reminds us of the great sentence of Luther in his preface to the Ep. to the Rom, where he says: “Faith is a Divine work within us which changes and renews us in God according to Jn 1 13, ‘who were born not of blood, nor of the, will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God.’ This destroys the old Adam and makes new creatures of us in heart, will, disposition, and all our powers. Oh, faith is a living, active, jealous, mighty thing, in- asmuch as it cannot possibly remain unproductive of good works” (Werke, Erl. Ausg., 63, 124-25). # Baptism also eliminated.—Not only are good works and love removed as conditions or means of justification of the sinner, but baptism is also eliminated. According to Paul, it is the office of baptism not to justify, but to cleanse, that is, symbolically to set forth and seal the washing away of sin and the entrance into the new life by a dramatic act of burial, which for the subject and all witnesses would mark a never-to-be-forgotten era in the history of the believer. ‘‘Baptism,'’ says Weiss (I, 454), ‘‘presupposes faith in Him as the one whom the church designates as Lord, and also binds to adherence to Him which excludes every dependence upon any other, inasmuch as He has acquired a claim upon their devotion by the saving deed of His self-surrender on the cross." So important was baptism in the religious atmosphere at that time that hyperbolical expressions were used to express its cleansing and illuminating office, but these need not mislead us. We must interpret them accord- ing to the fundamental conceptions of Christianity as areligion of the Spirit, not of magic nor of material media. Baptism pointed to a complete parting with the old life by previous renewal through faith in Christ, which re- newal baptism in its turn sealed and announced in a climax of self-dedication to him, and this, while sym- bolically and in contemporary parlance of both Jew and Gentile called a new birth, was prohably often actually so in the psychological experience of the baptized. But while justification is often attributed to faith, it is never to baptism. (5) Elements of justification—What are the ele- ments of this justification? There are two: (a) Forgiveness of sins (Rom 4 5-8; cf Acts 13 38. 39). With this are connected peace and recon- ciliation (Rom 6 1.9.10; cf 10 11). (6) The de- claring or approving as righteous or just (Rom 3 21-30; 4 2-9,22; 5 1.9-11.16-21, etc). C. F. Schmid is perfectly right when he says that Paul (and James) always uses dikaioun in the sense of esteeming and pronouncing and treating as righteous, both according to the measure of the law (Rom 2 13; 3 20) and also according to grace (Bib. Theol. of the NT, 1870, 497). The word is a forensic one, and Godet goes so far as to say that the word is never used in all Gr lit. for making righteous (Comm. on Rom, ET, I, 157, Amer. ed, 95). This is shown further by the fact that it is the ungodly who are justified (Rom 4 5), and that the justification is a reckoning or imputation (logtzesthai) of righteousness (Rom 4 6.22), not an infusing or making righteous. The contrast of “to justify” is not “to be a sinner,” but is “to accuse” or ‘‘to condemn” (Rom 8 33.34), and the contrast of “justification” is ‘condemnation” (6 18). Besides, it is not the infusing of a new life, of a new holiness, which is counted for righteousness, but it is faith which is so counted (Rom 4 5; Phil 3 9). That upon which God looks when He justi- fies is not the righteousness He has imparted or is to impart, but the atonement He has made in Christ. Itis one of the truest paradoxes of Chris- tianity that unless a righteous life follows, there has been no justification, while the justification itself is for the sake of Christ alone through faith alone. It is a “status, rather than a character,” says Stevens (The Pauline Theology, 1892, 265); “it hears the stamp of a legal rather than of an ethical conception,’ and he refers to the elaborate and con- vineing proof of the forensic character of Paul’s doctrine of justification,” in Morison, Exposition of Romans, ch III, 163-200. An interesting illus- tration of how further study may correct a wrong impression is given by Lipsius, who, in his Die Paulinische Rechfertigungslehre, 1853, maintained that righteousness or justification meant not ‘“ex- clusively an objectively given external relation to God, but always at the same time a real inner con- dition of righteousness” (p. 10), whereas in his Lehr- buch der evangelisch-protesiantischen Dogmatik, 1876, 8. Aufl., 1898, he makes the righteousness of God properly an “objective gift of grace, not simply in the sense in which the OT just one judged his position of salvation as a gift of grace, but as a righteousness specially reckoned and adjudicated by way of grace and acknowledged before the judgment (or court, Gericht) of God (Rom 4 6; ef vs 1-8.11; 3 23; Gal 36). This is always the meaning of dtkaioun, dikaiotisthai, or dikaiosis in Paul. It consists in the not-reckoning of sins,” ete (p. 658). Of course justification is only a part of the process of salvation, which includes regen- eration and sanctification, but these are one thing and justification is another. (6) Justification has to do with the individual. — Finally it is asked whether justification in Paul’s mind has to do with the individual believer or with the society or Christian congregation. Ritschl (II, 217f) and Sanday-Headlam (The Ep. to the Rom, 122-23) say the latter; Weiss (I, 442), the former. It is indeed true that Paul refers to the chureh as purchased with Christ’s blood (Acts 20 28, or God’s blood, according to the two oldest MSS and ancient authorities; cf Eph & 25), and he uses the pronoun ‘‘we” as those who have received re- demption, ete (Col 114; Eph 2 18); but it is evident on the other hand that faith is an indi- vidual matter, a thing first between man and his God, and only after a man has been united to Christ by faith can he enter into a spiritual fellow- ship with fellow-believers. Thereforé the subject of justification must be in the first place the indi- vidual, and only in the second place and by conse- quence thesociety. Besides, those justified are not the cleansed and sanctified members of churches, but the ungodly (Rom 4 5). As to the argument fr fl “ Headlam, it se ey ee char Bre preteen of baptism as taking place in the Christian community with believers and for believers, that that for and to which they are baptized is not justification, but the death and resurrection of Christ (6 3.4), and that the right- eousness of God has been manifested not through bap- tism but through falth in Jesus Christ unto all that be- lieve (3 22), being justified freely, not through baptism, but through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus (ver 24). With Paul baptism has always a mystical significance as symbolizing and externally actualizing union with the death of the Lord, and would be both Impossible and impertinent in the case of those not already believers in Christ and thus inwardly united to His society. Il, The Other NT Writings.—So much for Paul. Let us now take a glance at the other NT books. It is a commonplace of the theology that is called “modern” or “critical,” that Paul and not Jesus is the founder of Christianity as we know it, that 1785 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Justification the doctrines of the Divinity of Christ, atonement, justification, etc, are Paul’s work, and not his Mas- ter’s. There is truth in this. It was part of the humiliation of Christ as well as His pedagogical method to live, teach and act under the conditions of His time and country, on the background of Pal of 30 AD; and it was specially His method to do His work and not His disciples’, to live a life of love and light, to die for the sins of the world, and then go back to the Father that the Holy Spirit might come and lead His followers into all truth. p, kal, “swift”): A priest among those who returned with Zerubbabel (Neh 12 1). He represented the family of Sallai (Neh 12 20). KAMON, ka’mon (jp, kamon; AV Camon): The place where Jair was buried (Jgs 10 3-5). It is possibly represented either by Kamm or Kumeim, ruins which lie about 6 and 7 miles respectively to the &.S.E. of Umm Keis. See further Havvota- sain. The ruins of Kamm, about 200 yds. square, crown a small elevation, and point to an important place in the past. There are large rock-hewn cis- terns to the S. Among the ruins of Kumein, which are not considerable, a few mud huts are built, occupied today by about 200 souls (Schumacher, Northern 'Ajlan, 137). j KANAH, ka’na (“3p , kanah, “reeds’’): (1) The name of a “brook,” ie. wddy, or “tor- rent bed,” which formed part of the boundary between Ephraim and Manasseh (Josh 16 8; 17 9). The border of Ephraim went out westward from Tappush to the brook Kanah, ending at the sea; the border of Manasseh from Tappuah, which be- longed to Ephraim, ‘‘went down unto the brook of Kanah, southward of the brook.” There seems no good reason to doubt the identification of “the brook Kanah’” with the modern Wady Kanah. The transition from the heavy & to the lighter & is easy, so the phonetic difficulty is not serious. The stream rises in the 8.W. of Shechem, flows through Wady Ishkar, and, joining the ‘Aujeh, reaches the sea not far to the N. of Jaffa. Guérin, influenced, apparently, by the masses of reeds of various kinds which fill the river, argues in favor of Nahr el-Falik, to the N. of Arsiéf. He identifies it with Nahr el- Kasab, “river of reeds,’’ mentioned by Beha ed-Din, the Moslem historian. But this last must be iden- tified with Nahr el-Mafjir, 13 miles farther N., too far N. for “the brook Kanah.” (2) A town on the northern boundary of Asher (Josh 19 28), probably identical with the village of Kana, about 7 miles 8.E. of Tyre (SWP, I, 51, 64, Sh I). Ewina KAPH, kif (>) 5. J.J): The 11th letter of the Heb alphabet; transliterated in this Encyclopaedia as k, with daghesh, and kh (=German ch) without daghesh. It came also to be used for the number 20. For name, etc, see ALPHABET. Kareah Kenezite THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1790 KAREAH, ka-ré’a (TP, kdréh, “bald head’’): The father of Johanan and Jonathan, who after the fall of Jerus joined Gedaliah at Mizpah (2 K 25 23; Jer 40 8). KARIATHIARIUS, ki-ri-ath-i-a’ri-us (Kapiaés- apiés, Kariathiariés; B reads Kartatheiareiés; AV Kiriathiarim [{ Esd 65 19])=Kiriath-jearim in Neh T 29, KARKA, kar’ka (APP PS , ha-karka‘ah—with the art. and M locale; AV Karkaa): A place in the S. of Judah, between Addar and Wddy el-‘Arish (Josh 15 3). Onom speaks of a village in Judah lying toward the wilderness, named Akarka. It cannot now be identified. The name means “the pave- ment,” or “ground.” KARKOR, kar’kor ((P7p, karkér): An uni- dentified place where Gideon surprised and over- whelmed the remnants of the army of Zeba and Zalmunnah (Jgs 8 10ff). It probably corre- sponds to Karkar mentioned by Shalmaneser II, 8. of Hamath (KB, I, 173). KARTAH, kar’ta (UIP, kartah): A city in the territory of Zebulun, assigned to the Levites (Josh 21 34). It is not identified. Possibly it is a vari- ant of Karrats, or of Karan (q.v.). KARTAN, kar’tan (JP, kartan): A city in the territory of Naphtali, given to the Gershonite Levites (Josh 21 32). It is called Kiriathaim in 1 Ch 6 76. Kartan may be a contraction of this. Cheyne (EB, s.v.) suggests that both names may be corruptions from ‘“Chinnereth.” Neither is mentioned in Josh 19 32.38, in the list of Naph- talite cities, while Chinnereth is. KATTATH, kat’ath (NOP, kattath): A city in the territory of Zebulun, named with Iphtah-el, Na- halel, and Shimron (Josh 19 15), perhaps to be identified with Kitron (Jgs 1 30), from which Zebulun did not expel the Canaanites; and with Kartah (Josh 21 34), which was given to the Merarite Levites. The Bab Talm (Meg. 6a) identi- fies Kattath with Sepphoris, the modern Seffiriyeh (but see Neubauer, Géographie du Talmud, 191). The Jerus Talm takes it as identical with Ketdnith, Kuteineh, to the W. of Esdraelon. It should probably, however, be sought near to Shimron, the modern Semitiniyeh. W. Ewina KEDAR, ké’dar (TP, kédhar; KySdp, Kédér): Second in order of the sons of Ishmael (Gen 25 13 ||} 1 Ch 1 29). The name occurs as typical of a distant eastern country in opposition to the lands of the Mediterranean (Jer 2 10). The author of Second Isa introduces this tribe in company with Nebaioth, and both are represented as owners of flocks (Isa 60 7). Evidence of their nomadic habits appears in Jer 49 28.29, where they are classed among the Bené-Kedhem, and mention is made of their flocks, camels, tents, curtains and furniture. They are spoken of (Isa 42 11) as dwelling in hdgérim (‘villages’), from which it would appear that they were a somewhat settled tribe, corresponding to the Arab. hadariya or “‘town- dwellers,” as distinct from wabariya or ‘nomads.” Ezekiel (27 21) gives another hint of their pastoral nature where, in his detailed picture of the wealth of Tyre, Kedar and Arabia provide the Tyrians with lambs, rams and goats. The fame of the tribe is further reflected in Isa 21 16.17 (the only allu- sion to their might in war), and in the figurative references to their tents (Ps 120 5; Cant 15). In this last passage where the tents are made symbolic of dark beauty, the word kddhar (‘‘to be black’’) may have been in the writer’s mind. The settlements of Kedar were probably in the N.W. of Arabia, not far from the borders of Pal. Assyr in- scriptions have thrown light upon the history of the tribe. There Kedar is mentioned along with the Arabs and Nebaioth, which decides its identity with Kedar of the OT, and there is found also an account of the conflicts between the tribe and King Assurbanipal (see Margo- liouth in HDB). Of the Ishmaelite tribes, Kedar must have been one of the most important, and thus in later times the name came to be applied to all the wild tribes of the desert. It is through Kedar (Arab. ketdar) that Muslim genealogists trace the descent of Mo- hammed from Ishmael. A. 8, Fuiron KEDEMAH, ked’é-ma, ké-dé’ma (MATP, kédhe- mah, “eastward’’): Son of Ishmael (Gen 265 16), head of aclan (1 Ch 1 31). See KapmMonits. KEDEMOTH, ked’é-moth, ké-dé’moth (N1O%p, kedhémath, ‘eastern parts’): From the wilderness to which this town gave its name, Moses sent mes- sengers to Sihon, king of the Amorites in Heshbon (Dt 2 26). It was given by Moses to the tribe of Reuben (Josh 13 18), and assigned to the Merarite Levites (21 37; 1 Ch 679). It must probably be sought on the upper course of the Arnon. Buhl (GAP, 268) suggests that it may be identified with Umm er-Resas. See Janaz. KEDESH, ké’desh (WIP, kedhesh; Ka&qs, Kéddés): (1) One of the “uttermost cities’? of Judah “toward the border of Edom in the 8S.” (Josh 15 23). Possibly it is to be identified with Kaprss- BARNEA (q.v.); otherwise it is strange that this latter should be omitted from the list. Dillmann would identify it with Kddus, to the 8. of Hebron, mentioned by Mukaddasi. ; (2) A town in the territory of Issachar, given to the Gershonite Levites (1 Ch 6 72).: In the list of Joshua (21 28) its place is taken by Kisuron (q.v.). Conder suggests identification with Tell Abu Kadés, near Megiddo. (3) Kedesh-naphtali, the famous city of refuge in the uplands of Naphtali. It is called “Kedesh,” simply, in Josh 12 22, etc; Kedesh- naphtali in Jgs 46; Tob12; Ke- desh in Galilee in Josh 20 7, etc. It was assigned to the Gershonite Levites (1 Ch 6 76). From the name “holy,” we gather that it was a sanctuary from old time. It was therefore a place of asylum, and only preserved its ancient character in this respect when chosen as one of the cities of refuge. It was the home of Barak, and here his host assembled. When the Assyrians invaded the land under Tiglath-pileser, it was among the first cities to be captured, and its inhabitants were deported (2 K 15 29). Near Kedesh was fought the great battle between Jona- than the Maccabee and Demetrius (1 Mace 11 63 ff). Jos says that in his time it belonged to the Tyrians, lying between their land and that of Gali- lee (Ant, XIH, v, 6; BJ, IL, xviii, 1; IV, ii, 3, etc). Onom places it 20 miles ‘from Tyre, near to Paneas. It is represented by the modern village of Kedes, which lies on the plateau tothe W. of el-Huleh. It crowns a tell which runs out in a low ridge into the little plain to the W. Near the fountain, which rises under the ridge to the N., are the most inter- esting of the ancient remains. There are many fine sarcophagi, some of them being used as water- ing-troughs. From, its lofty situation, Kedesh commanded a spacious view over a richly varied Kedesh- naphiali 1791 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kareah Kenezite landscape, with smiling cornfields, and hills clothed with oak and terebinth. Ewine KEDESH (1 Macc 11 63.73, A, KySes, Kédes; AV Cades): Scene of a battle between Judas Mac- cabaeus and the forces of Demetrius. Scc Kepvrsn- NAPHTAL!, under KepzEsx, 3. KEDESH-NAPHTALI, Kapzsg, 3. KEEPER, kép’ér, KEEPERS (mostly from AU, shamar; tdat, philar): The word is used of keepers of sheep, vineyards, doors, prisons (in Gen 39 21 ff, sar; ef Acts 5 23), ete. In Eccl 12 3, “The keepers of the house shall tremble,” the allu- sion is to the decay of bodily powers, the ‘‘keepers”’ being specially the arms, which had become feeble through age. KEHELATHAH, ké-bé-la'tha, ké-hel’a-tha (ANSP , kehélathah, “gathering,” “‘assembly’’): A desert camp of the Israelites between Rissah and Mt. Shepher (Nu 33 22.23). Situation is unknown. See WANDERINGS OF ISRAEL. ké’desh-naf’ta-li. See KEILAH, kéi’la (OP, ke‘alah; Keevdép, Keeilém): (1) A city of the Shephelah mentioned (Josh 15 44) along with Nezib, Achzib and Mareshah. Among those who repaired the walls of Jerus was ‘“‘Hasha- biah, the ruler of half the district of Keilah, for his district. After him repaired their brethren, Bavvai the son of Henadad, the ruler of half the district of Keilah” (Neh 3 17.18). It is, however, from the story of the wandering of David that we have most information regarding this place. It was a city with gates 1. David and bars (18S 23 7). The Philis and Keilah came against it and commenced rob- bing the threshing-floors. David, after twice inquiring of Jeh, went down with his 600 men (ver 13) and ‘fought with the Philis, and brought away their cattle, and slew them with a great slaughter.” Saul hearing that David and his men were within a fortified town “summoned all the people to war, to go down to Keilah, to be- siege David and his men” (ver 8). Then David asked Abiathar the priest to bring him an ephod, and he inquired of Jeh whether, if Saul came, the men of Keilah would surrender him to save that city; hearing from Jeh, ‘“They will deliver thee up,” he and all his men escaped from Keilah and went into the wilderness. The reputed strength of Keilah ig confirmed by its mention in 5 tablets in the Am Tab under the name of Kilta (qilti, Petrie) with Gedor, Gath, Rabbah and Gezer. Although other identifications were proposed by the older topographers, there is now a general con- sensus of opinion that the site of this 2, Identifi- city is Khurbet Kila (Jos, Ant, VI, cation xiii, 1, in his account of David’s ad- venture calls the place ‘Killa’’). It is a hill covered with ruins in the higher part of Wady es Sar, 1,575 ft. above sea-level, whose ter- raced sides are covered with cornfields. The Onom (Lat text) states that it was 8 miles from Eleutheropolis, which is about the distance of Kh. Kila from Beit Jibrin. Beit Nusib (Nezib) is a couple of miles away, and Tell Sandahannah (Mare- shah) but 7 miles to the W. (Josh 16 44). An early Christian tradition states that the prophet Habakkuk was buried at Keilah. (2) The Garmite (q.v.), 1 Ch 4 19; see PEP, 314, Sh XXI. E. W. G. MasterMan KELAIAH, kéla’ya, ké-li'a (TP, kelayah, “swift for Jeh’’[?]; KwAlos, Kélios, B, Kévos, Kénos): One of the priests who had “foreign wives’ (Ezr 10 23, also “Kelita’’). In || list of 1 Esd 9 23, he again has a double name—Colius”’ and “Calitas.”” A “Kelita” is named as helping Ezra at the ex- pounding of the law (Neh 8 7; cf1 Esd 9 48, ‘Ca- litas’), and also among the signatories of the covenant (Neh 10 9; for nature of covenant see vs 28ff). They may not, however, be the same person. KELITA, kel/i-ta, ké-li’ta (NO"DD, lia’ “dwarf”’). See Krnaran. KEMUEL, kem’t-cl, ké-mi’el ONP, kema’al, “God’s mound”): (1) Nephew of Abraham (Gen 22 21), father of Aram, whom Ewald identifies with Ram of Job 32 2; but cf Gen 10 22, where Aram is described as one of the children of Shem. They may not be the same person. (2) Prince of Ephraim, one of the land commis- sioners who divided Canaan (Nu 34 24). (3) A Levite, father of Hashabiah, one of the tribal princes of David’s time, a ruler among the Levites (1 Ch 27 17). KENAN, ké’nan (]2°p, kéndn; Kawév, Kaindn): Ason of Enosh, the son of Seth (Gen 6 9.10.12.13. 14; 1 Ch1 2). AV form (except in 1 Ch 1 2), is ‘‘Cainan.” KENATH, ké’nath (PP, kendth; Kaé0, Kadth, Kaandth in LXX, A): A city in Bashan, taken along with its ‘‘daughters,” i.e. ‘villages’ from the Amor- ites by Nobah who gave it_his own name (Nu 82 42), It was recaptured by Geshur and Aram (1 Ch 2 23). It is probably identical with the modern Kanawat, which is built on the site, and largely from the materials of an ancient city. It lies about 16 miles to the N. of Bosra eski Sham, the Bostra of the Romans, on both sides of Wady Kanawat, where, descending from the slopes of Jebel ed-Druze, it plunges over a precipice, forming a picturesque waterfall. On the plateau above the modern village, there is a striking collection of Rom and Christian remains, the shapely forms of many columns lend- ing distinction to the scene. One large building is associated with the name of the patriarch Job— Makam Ayytb. The position commands a spa- cious and interesting view over the whole of the Hauradn. The identification has been rejected by Socin (Baedeker, Pal, 207), but his reasons are not given. Moore (Jgs, 222) also rejects it, but for reasons that are not convincing. W. Ewine KENAZ, ké’naz, KENEZ, ké’nez (TI), kenaz, “hunting”): (1) A “duke” of Edom, grandson of Esau (Gen 86 11.15.42; 1 Ch 1 36.53). (2) Father of Othniel (Josh 15 17; Jgs 1 43; 39.11; 1 Ch 4 13). (3) The unidentified k*naz of 1 Ch 4 15, who appears to be a descendant of (2). There is, how- ever, some difficulty with the passage here. KENEZITE, ké/nez-it (IP, kenizzt; Kevefaios, Kenezaios): AV in Gen 16 19 and RV uniformly, spell ‘“‘Kenizzite.” The Kenezites were the clan whose name-father was Kenaz (q.v.). Their land, along with that of their Canaanite tribes, was promised to Abram (Gen 15 19). To this clan belonged Jephunneh, the father of Caleb (Nu 32 12; Josh 14 6.14). It had evidently been absorbed by the tribe of Judah. If the Kenezites went down Kenites Key THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1792 with Jacob into Egypt, they may have become iden- tified with his family there. KENITES, ké/nits (WP, ha-keni, "PT, ha- ként; in Nu 24 22 and Jgs 411, Pp, kayin; oi Kevaior, hot Kenatoi, of Kivain, hot Kinatot): A tribe of nomads named in association with various other peoples. They are first mentioned along with the Kadmonites and Kenizzites among the peoples whose land was promised to Abram (Gen 15 19). Balaam, seeing them from the heights of Moab, puns upon their name, which resembles the Heb ken, “a nest,” prophesying their destruction although their nest was “‘set in the rock’’—possibly a reference to Sela, the city. Moses’ father-in-law, Jethro, is called “the priest of Midian” in Ex 3 1; 18 1; but in Jgs 1 16 he is described asa Kenite, showing a close relation between the Kenites and Midian. At the time of Sisera’s overthrow, Heber, a Kenite, at ‘‘peace’ with Jabin, king of Hazor, pitched his tent far N. of his ancestral seats (Jgs 417). There were Kenites dwelling among the Amalekites in the time of Saul (1 § 15 6). They were spared because they had ‘‘showed kindness to all the children of Israel, when they came up out of Egypt.” David, in his answer to Achish, links the Kenites with the inhabitants of the S. of Judah (27 10). Among the ancestors of the tribe of Judah, the Chronicler includes the Kenite Ham- math, the father of the Rechabites (1 Ch 2 55). These last continued to live in tents, practising the ancient nomadic customs (Jer 35 6 ff). The word kéni in Aram. means “smith.” Pro- fessor Sayce thinks they may really have been a tribe of smiths, resembling ‘‘the gipsies of modern Europe, as well as the traveling tinkers or black- smiths of the Middle Ages’ (HDB, s.v.). This would account for their relations with the different peoples, among whom they would reside in pursuit of their calling. In Jos they appear as Kenetides, and in Ant, IV, vii, 3 he calls them “the race of the Shechemites.”’ W. Ewine KENIZZITE, ken’i-zit. See Kmnuzire. KENOSIS, kénd’sis: The word ‘“kenosis” (xévwots, kéndsis) has entered theological language from Phil 2 7, where in the sentence he ‘‘emptied himself’’ the Gr vb. is ekéndsen. ‘‘Kenosis,” then, the corresponding, noun, has become a technical term for the humiliation of the Son in the incarnation, but in recent years has acquired a still more techni- cal sense, i.e. of the Son’s emptying Himself of certain attributes, esp. of omniscience. (1) The theological question involved was one about as far as possible from the minds of the Chris- tians of the apostolic age and appar- 41. The NT ently one that never occurred to St. Paul. For in Phil 2 7 the only “‘emp- tying” in point is that of the (external) change from the “form of God” to the “form of a servant.” Elsgwhere in the NT it'is usually taken as a matter of course that Christ’s knowledge was far higher than that of other men (Jn 2 24 is the clearest example). But passages that imply a limitation of that knowledge do exist and are of various classes. Of not much importance are the entirely incidental references to the authorship of OT passages where the traditional authorship is considered erroneous, as no other method of quotation would have been possible. Somewhat different are the references to the nearness of the Parousia (esp. Mt 10 23; 24 29). But with these it is always a question how far the exact phraseology has been framed by the evangelists and, apart from this, how far Christ may not have been consciously using current imagery for the impending spiritual revolution, although knowing that the details would be quite different (see Parousta). Limitation of knowl- edge may perhaps be deduced from the fact that Christ could be amazed (Mt 8 10, etc), that He could be really tempted (esp. He 4 15), or that He possessed faith (He 12 2; see comm.). More explicitly Christ is said to have learned in Lk 2 52; He 5 8. And, finally, in Mk 13 32 || Mt 24 36, Christ states categorically that He is ignorant of the exact time of the Parousta. (2) An older exegesis felt only the last of these passages as a real difficulty. A distinction con- structed between knowledge naturally possessed and knowledge gained by experience (i.e. although the child Jesus knew the alphabet naturally, He was obliged to learn it by experience) covered most of the others. For Mk 13 32 a variety of explana- tions were offered. The passage was tr? ‘‘neither the Son, except the Father know it,” a tr that can be borne by the Gr. But it simply transfers the difficulty by speaking of the Father’s knowledge as hypothetical, andis an impossible tr of Mt 24 36, where the word “only” is added. The explanations that assume that Christ knew the day but had no commission to reveal it are most unsatisfactory, for they place insincere words in His mouth; “It is not for you to know the day” would have been the inevitable form of the saying (Acts 1 7). (1) Yet the attempt so to misinterpret the verses is not the outcome of a barren dogmatic prejudice, but results from a dread lest real injury 2. Dog- be done to the fundamentals of Chris- matic tian consciousness. Not only does the mind of the Christian revolt from seeing in Christ anything less than true God, but it revolts from finding in Him two centers of personality—Christ was One. But as omniscience ig an essential attribute of God, it is an essential attribute of the incarnate Son. So does not any limitation of Christ’s human knowledge tend to vitiate a sound doctrine of.the incarnation? Cer- tainly, to say with the upholders of the kenosis in its “classical’’ form that the Son, by an exercise of His will, determined to be ignorant as man, is not helpful, as the abandonment by God of one of His own essential attributes would be the prepos- terous corollary. (2) Yet the Bib. data are explicit, and an explanation of some kind must be found. And the solution seems to lie in an ambiguous use of the word ‘‘knowledge,” as applied‘to Christ as God and as man. When we speak of a man’s knowledge in the sense discussed in the kenotic doctrine, we mean the totality of facts present in his intellect, and by hisiguorance we mean the ab- sence of a fact or of facts from that intellect. Now in the older discussions of the subject, this intel- lectual knowledge was tacitly assumed (mystical theology apart) to be the only knowledge worthy of the name, and so it was at the same time also assumed that God’s knowledge is intellectual also —"“God geometrizes.’ Under this assumption God’s knowledge is essentially of the same kind as man’s, differing from man’s only in its purity and extent. And this assumption is made in all dis- cussions that speak of the knowledge of the Son as God illuminating His mind as man. (3) Modern critical epistemology has, however, taught man a sharp lesson in humility by demonstrating that the intellect is by no means the perfect instrument that it has been assumed to be. And the faults are by no means faults due to lack of instruction, evil desires, etc, but are resident in the intellect itself, and inseparable from it as an intellect. Certain recent writers (Bergson, most notably) have even built up a case of great strength for regarding the intellect as a mere product of utilitarian develop- ment, with the defects resulting naturally from such 1793 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kenites Key an evolution. More esp. does this restriction of the intellect seem to be true in religious knowledge, even if the contentions of Kant and (esp.) Ritschl be not fully admitted. Certain it is, in any case, that even human knowledge is something far wider than intel- lectual knowledge, for there are many things that we know that we never could have learned through the intellect, and, apparently, many elements of our knowledge are almost or quite incapable of transla- tion into intellectual terms. Omnniscience,’ then, is by no means intellectual omniscience, and it is not to be reached by any mere process of expansion of an intellect. An “omniscient intellect” is a con- tradiction in terms. (4) In other words, God’s omniscience is not merely human intellectual knowl- edge raised to the infinite power, but something of an entirely different quality, hardly conceivable to human thought—as different from human intel- lectual knowledge as the Divine omnipotence is different from muscular strength. Consequently, the passage of this knowledge into a human intellect is impossible, and the problem of the incarnation should be stated: What effect did Divine omnis- cience in the person have on the conscious intellect, of the manhood? There is so little help from the past to be gained in answering this question, that it must remain open at present—if, indeed, it is ever capable of a full answer. But that ignorance in the intellect of the manhood is fully consistent with omniscience in the person seems to be not merely a safe answer to the question as stated, but an in- evitable answer if the true humanity of Christ is to be maintained at all. Literature.—Sanday’s Christology and Personality, 1911, and La Zouche, The Person of Christ in Modern Thought, 1912, are among the latest discussions of the subject, with very full references to the modern literature. Burton Scorr Easton KERAS, ké’ras (Klpas, Kiras): In 1 Esd 6 29, the head of a family of temple-servants, called “Keroz’’ in Ezr 2 44; Neh 7 47. KERCHIEF, kér’chif (MBDA, mispahoth; ém- BédAaa, epibélaia): Occurs only in Ezk 13 18.21, in a passage which refers to some species of divination. Their exact shape or useisunknown. They were ap- parently long veils or coverings put over the heads of those consulting the false prophetesses and reaching down to the feet, for they were for “per- sons of every stature.” KEREN-HAPPUCH, ker’en-hap’uk, ké’ren- hap’uk (JABM JAP, keren happukh, “thorn of anti- mony,” i.e. beautifier; LXX 'Apoddelas képas, Amaltheias kéras): The 3d daughter of Job (Job 42 14), born after his restoration from affliction. Antimony, producing a brilliant black, was used among the Orientals for coloring the edges of the eye- lids, making the eyes large and lustrous. Hence the suggestiveness of this name of an article of the ladies’ toilet, a little horn or receptacle for the eye-paint. KERIOTH, ké'ri-oth, -dth (NPP, kriyath): (1) A city of Moab, named with Beth-meon and Bozrah (Jer 48 24.41). Here was a sanctuary of Chemosh, to which Mesha says (M §, ]. 13) he dragged “the altar hearths of Davdoh.’ It may ossibly be represented by the modern Kurata, acne Diban and ‘Attartis. Some (e.g. Driver on Am 2 2) think it may be only another name for Ar-Moab. Buhl (GAP, 270) would identify it with Kir of Moab (Kerak). No certainty is yet possible. (2) A city of Judah (Josh 16 25; RY Kenriotu- HEZRON [q.v.]), possibly the modern el-Kuryatain, to the N.E, of Tell ‘Arad. Ewine _ KERIOTH-HEZRON, ké’ri-oth-heg/ron (NTP JIM, keriydth hecrén; Josh 15 25 says, “The same is Hazor”’; AV “Kerioth and Hezron which is Hazor’): One of the cities in the “south” of Judah. Robinson (BR, II, 101) identifies it with the ruined site of Kuryatain, 44 miles N. of Tell ‘Arad. It has been suggested that Kerioth was the birth place of Jupas Iscarior (q.v.). Cf Kenriota, 2. KERNEL, k@r‘nel (O°2E77,, hargannim, EV “‘ker- nels”; LXX reads siémphullon used by Aristopha- nes as=olives from which oil has been pressed, later,in same, of raisin pulp): Mentioned in Nu 6 4 along with 37, zagh, tr? “husks.” This tr, ‘‘ker- nels” or “grape stones,” is from the Tg and Talm, but is doubtful, and it may be the word should be tr? “sour grapes.” KEROS, ké’ros (OMP , bérds, ‘fortress’ [?]): One of the Nethinim (Ezr 2 44; Neh 7 47), an order appointed to the liturgical offices of the temple. See Neruinim. ; KESIL, ké’zil (Orion). See Astronomy. KESITAH, kes’i-ta, ke-sé’ta (TQ°WP, ksitah). See Prece or Money. KETAB, ke’tab (KyraB, Katdb): Ancestor of a family of Nethinim (1 Esd 6 30). KETTLE, ket”l: In EV only in 1 § 2 14 for didh, ‘“‘a vessel for cooking.” The same word in 2 Ch 35 13 is rendered “caldrons,” and in Job 41 20 (Heb 12), ‘‘pot.” Ps 81 6 (Heb 7) (AV “nots’’) belongs rather to another signification of the word (RV “basket,” for carrying clay or bricks). KETURAH, ke-tii’rii, ke-too’ra (TWVIOP , ketairah; Xerrotpa, Cheitoura, ‘“incense’’): The second wife of Abraham (Gen 25 1; 1 Ch 1 32f). Accord- ing to the Bib. tradition, he contracted this second marriage after the death of Sarah (cf Gen 23), and very likely after the marriage of Isaac (cf Gen 24). It is not improbable that,’as some writers have sug- geated, this change in the life of his son prompted Abraham to remarry in order to overcome the feel- ing of lonesomeness caused by Isaac’s entering the state of matrimony. 1 Ch 1 32 (and also Gen 25 6) shows us that K. was not considered to be of the same dignity as Sarah who, indeed, was the mother of the son of promise, and, for obvious reasons, the sons of Abraham’s concubines were separated from Isaac. She was the mother of 6 sons representing Arab tribes 8. and E. of Pal (Gen 25 1-6), so that through the offspring of Keturah Abraham became “the father of many nations.” WitiiaM Baur KEY, ké (MDS, maphieeh, an ‘‘opener”’; ef krels, kleis, “that, which shuts”): Made of wood, usually with nails which fitted into correspond- ing holes in the lock, or rather bolt (Jgs 3 25). Same is rendered ‘‘opening” in 1 Ch 9 27. See Hovse. : Figurative: Used fig. for power, since the key was sometimes worn on the shoulder as a sign of official authority (Isa 22 22). In the NT it is used several times thus fig.: of Peter: “the keys of the kingdom of heaven” (Mt 16 19); of Christ, in Rev, having the “keys of death and of Hades’’ (1 18), also having ‘‘the key of David” (3 7). An angel was given “the key of the pit of the abyss” (9 Keys, Power of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1794 1; 20 1). Our Lord accused the teachers of the Jaw of His day of taking away “‘the key of knowl- Daal t _ ant ; Egyptian Key. edge” from men, that is, locking the doors of truth against them (Lk 11 52; cf Mt 23 13). Epwarp Baaspy PoLiarp KEYS, kéz, POWER OF: I. Taz Prosuems InNvotvep 1. The Keys; and the Binding and Loosing 2. Meaning of the Statements 3. How Peter Is Related to These Powers 4, Is the Primary Idea That of Position and Authority ? TI. Views Maintaitnep 1. Agent of the Power 2. Nature of the Power 3. Scope of the Power III. Dara ror Decipine THE Quzstions INVOLVED . Passages Employing the Terms ‘‘Key,” ‘‘ Bind- ing and Loosing’’ . Related Passages . Examples of Exercise of This Power ONCLUSION . Nature of the Power . Agent of the Power 3. Scope of the Power There is no more stubbornly contested conception in Christian terminology. The thought connects itself immediately with Mt 16 19, but it is hardly correct to say that it originates there, for the con- troversy is one that grows out of the conflict of forces inherent in the institutional development of religion and of society. It must have arisen, in any event, if there had been no such word as that in Mt 16 19, although not in the same terms as it is now found. Since the Reformation it has been recognized, by Catholic and Protestant, that on the interpretation of this passage depends the authority of the Church of Rome and its exclusive claims, so far as their foundation in Scripture is concerned; while on the other hand there is involved the ‘“‘va- lidity” of the “sacraments,” “ordinances” and “orders” of Protestantism and the very hope of salvation of Protestants. I. The Problems Involved.—The crucial passage has two declarations, commonly spoken of as promises to Peter: to him Christ will 1. The give the keys of the kingdom of Keys; and heaven; whatsoever he shall bind on the Binding earth shall be bound in heaven, while and Loosing whatsoever he shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. How are the facts of having committed to him the keys and the function of binding and loosing related? Are they two forms of one declaration? Is the first gencral, and the second a specific sphere of its appli- cation? Both statements are made in figurative terms. That of the keys is supposed to be drawn from the duties of the chief steward of a house, or establish- ment. The idea of the keys of a city turned over to some distinguished person is advanced, but is hardly to be considered. We need, then, to QeN Iv. Ne know the functions of the chief steward and how they apply to the kingdom of heaven, and to Peter as its steward. What was Peter to 2. Meaning bind and loose, men or things, per- of the sonsor teachings? Numerous examples Statements could be cited of the use of these terms to signify forbidding (binding) and per- mitting (loosing) conduct as legitimate under the law of the OT (Lightfoot, McClintock and Strong, Schaff-Herzog, Hastings, etc). The strict school of Shammai bound many things loosed by the laxer school of Hillel (Broadus, Mt). Is this conclusive that Jesus is here giving Peter authority for “‘lay- ing down the law for his fellow-disciples,” “‘author- ity to say what the law of God allows, and what it forbids,”’ ‘the power of legislation for the church’’? (Cf Mason in HDB, IV, 30.) Ecclesiastical contentions turn esp. on Peter’s relation to these words of Jesus. Do they signify powers and “‘privileges’’ conferred on 3. How Peter, exclusively or representatively? Peter Is Are they official or personal? Do Related to they belong to other apostles, and to These other officers besides apostles? Can Powers the powers be exercised by individuals or by the church alone? If any be- sides Peter have these powers, do they pass to them from Peter, and how? What,seems to the writer a fundamental question here is either passed over very lightly or entirely omitted in the discussions of this sub- 4.Isthe ject. Did Jesus mean by these words Primary to confer on Peter, or on anyone to Idea That whom they may apply, authority, or of Position obligation; privilege, or responsibility? and Does He promise position, or does He Authority? impose duty? These alternatives are not necessarily exclusive, but the inter- pretation of the thought will be determined in no small measure by where the stress is laid. Hl. Views Maintained.—The possibilities have been exhausted in the interpretations and appli- cations advocated. It is not possible 1. Agent of to classify on lines of the creeds, ex- the Power cept very generally, for there is little } uniformity of view existing within the various communions. (1) Generally speaking, the Roman Catholic church gives to Peter a unique position. Her theologians also agree that all the powers and privi- leges of Peter descend to his successors in the vicarate of Christ. When the question is raised of the extension of these prerogatives beyond Peter and the popes, all sorts of views are held, concern- ing both the fact and the method of that extension. (2) Among Protestants there is general agree- ment that the church is the agent of this power, but there is not uniformity as to the nature of the au-~ thority or the manner of its exercise. _ (8) Some think that Peter has no peculiar rela- tion to the keys; that these words were spoken to him only as the first who gave expression to that conception and experience, on the basis of which Jesus commits the keys of the kingdom to any be- liever in Him as the Christ of God. We may summarize the more important views as to Peter thus: (a) the power committed to him alone and exercised, (i) at Pentecost, or (ii) at Pentecost, Caesarea and other places; (6) the power committed to Peter and to the other apostles, in- cluding Paul, discharged by them, and descended to no others; (c) the power conferred on Peter officially and on his official successors; (d) the power conferred on Peter and the other apostles and to such as hold their place in the church; (e) that the power belongs to Peter as representative of the church, and so to the church to be exercised (i) by 1795 the officials of the church, Gi) by the officials and those to whom they commit it, (iii) by all priests and persons allowed to represent the church, de facto, (iv) by the church in its councils, or other formal and official decisions, (v) by the church in a less formal way than (iv), (vi) by all members of the church as representing it without specific com- mission; (f) that it belongs to the Christian as such, and so is imposed upon, or offered to, all Christians. There is general—not absolute—agreement that the holder of the keys is to admit men into the kingdom. It is not agreed that the 2. Nature holder of the keys may, or can, deter- of the mine who are members of the kingdom. Power Both sides are taken. Some think that the power is that of announcing authoritatively the conditions of entrance, while others insist that the holder of the keys also deter- mines what individuals have accepted the conditions. (1) There is strong support for the view that the primary function of the keys lies in determining the teaching of the kingdom, main- 3. Scope of taining purity of doctrine. Emphasis the Power _ is laid on the use of the neuter, ‘‘what- soever’’—not ‘‘whomsoever”—with the binding and loosing. This would lead, however, to the secondary and implied function of declaring who had or had not accepted the teaching of the kingdom. (2) In the Roman Catholic church we find insist- ence on distinguishing between the general authority of the keys in all affairs of the church and religion, and the binding and loosing which they specifically apply to absolution. Only on this last are Catho- lics in full agreement. That the church administers salvation is held by Rom and Gr Catholics and by not a few Protestants, although Protestants do not, as a tule, claim exclusive power in salvation as do the others. Absolution is held to be a general (derived) priestly function, while the authority of the keys resides in the pope alone. . (3) Eminent Catholic authorities admit that the Fathers generally understood the keys to sig- nify the power of forgiving sins, and that they seldom make any reference to the supremacy of Peter. But they claim that rarely the Fathers do take “‘Christ’s promise in the fuller meaning of the gift of authority over the church.” Suarez was the first to develop the doctrine that it conferred on Peter and his successors authority in its widest sense, administrative and legislative. / (4) The extension of the authority of the keys to include civil matters is a contention of the Rom church, shared in modified form by some Protes- tants. Indeed the relation of ecclesiastical to civil authority must be said still to be awaiting clear definition in Protestantism. Macedo (De Clavibus Petri) claims the theologians of the church for the civil authority of the keys. Joyce in the Catholic Enc affirms that he is unable to verify this claim, but, on the contrary, finds that the opponents of the extension of the authority of the church to civil matters use Mt 16 19 in support of their posi- tion on the ground that to Peter were committed the keys of the kingdom of heaven, not of the kingdoms of this world. I, Data for Deciding the Questions Involved.— We must first examine the Scriptures employing the terms we seek to define. (1) Mt 1. Passages 16 19, the crucial passage, is part of a Employing paragraph over which there is no end of the Terms controversy. The incident at Caesarea “Key,” Philippi was understood then and after- “Binding” ward to mark an epoch in the life and “Loos- and teaching of Jesus. Having elicit- ing” ed Peter’s confession, Jesus pronounces a benediction on him because his in- sight represented a Divinely mediated experience THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Keys, Power of of fundamental significance in His own plan and mission. Jesus goes on to say: “And I also say unto thee, that thou art Peter [‘a stone’’], and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of Hades shall not prevail against it” (ver 18). The controversy rages about ‘Peter’ (wérpos, pétros) and the “rock” (mérpa, pétra), “gates of Hades,” and ‘prevail against it.” Are the church to be built on the rock and the kingdom whose keys are to be given to Peter the same? Such a shifting of figure is not conclusive against the thought. Perhaps the church is the organic form of the king- dom, tts personal content and expression on earth at any given time. This church exists wherever men consciously accept and are included in the kingdom. The kingdom will always embrace in- fluences, institutions, individuals, not be reckoned in any organized or visible church. The church has never had—in the nature of the case can never have—one complete organization including all the organized life of the kingdom, or even of the church. Any claims to this are contradicted by facts obvious at every moment of history. The change in figure from ver 18 to ver 19 is not conclusive against sup- posing the church to be built in him. But it seems far better to understand that Peter is the first stone in the building, while the foundation is that vital experience in which Peter came to know Jesus as the Christ, the Son of God. On this is erected the church, out of those living stones (Al@oe fGvres, lithot zontes, 1 Pet 2 4) that know and confess Jesus the Christ. The transition is thus easy to giving Peter the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and the reason for giving them to him rather than to any other may be found in the fact that he is now the first so to enter into the kingdom as to be fitted for church functions. It is not needful to determine, for our purpose, the exact meaning of “gates of Hades” and their not prevailing against the church (cf various comms.). It is clear that the church is to persist in the life of the world and so the kingdom will not lack or- ganized and aggressive expression. Nor does the relation of binding and loosing depend at all upon the critical question of reading or omitting “and” between the two parts of the verse. The conviction could hardly be escaped that the latter function is intimately related to the former, and is either di- rectly or mdirectly involved within it. (2) The pl. “keys,” occurs elsewhere only in Rev 1 18, where the Christ represents Himself as hold- ing the keys of death and of Hades. The word “Hades” might connect this with Mt 1619. The immediate occasion for the statement is that He who was dead, is alive; He has not only overcome death in His own person but has conquered it and its realm, so that they can no more have power ex- cept as subject to Him, since He holds their keys. Men on earth will either fall under the power of death and Hades or they must enter the kingdom of heaven. If the living Christ has the keys of the kingdom in the hands of Peter, or other friends, and holds the keys of its enemies in His own hands, the work will go on with success. It is not certain that the two passages can properly be so closely con- nected, but they thus afford just the assurance that is contained for the churches in Rev. (3) In Rev 8 7 Christ appears in the character, “he that is holy, he that is true, he that hath the key [sing.] of David, he that openeth and none can shut, and that shutteth and none openeth.” The idea is not restricted but indicates mastery over all things in the Messianic kingdom, its own operations and all forms of opposition. In the next verse, as a specific instance, He has set before the church at Philadelphia an open door (opportunity and prog- ress) which none can shut. Ci as to this Eph 1 22. eke Power of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA eys 1796 _ (4) It seems to be taken for granted that Jesus, in Mt 46 19, had direct reference to Isa 22 22, yet the passage is not Messianic except in a general sense and on the assumption that the power of Jeh over the nations in the OT is wielded by the Christ in the NT (see JEHovag; Lorp). Eliakim is to have absolute power, holding the key of the house of David. The use of the words “open” and ‘‘shut,”” as well as the general conception, connects the passage rather with Rev 3 7. (5) Rev 9 1; 201 are to be taken together. “The key of the pit of the abyss” in the hands of the angel or angels signifies, in these specific cir- ees the same power as that indicated in 8. (6) In Lk 11 52 Jesus pronounces a woe upon the “lawyers” who had “taken away the key of knowledge” from the people, neither entering in nor allowing those about to go in, toenter. The knowl- edge of God and Divine things was in the control, in great measure, of these scribes. This connects the figure directly with the idea of Mt 16 19, and the connection is emphasized by comparing Mt 23 2f; and is made definite by the word of Jesus in Mt 18 52 with which is to be compared Lk 12 42, where it would not be allowable to suppose that Jesus meant to limit the idea of “the faithful and wise steward” to Peter. This passage with the references seems to be highly important for our subject. Light is to be drawn from several passages that do not use the exact terms of Mt 16 19, hut that deal with the same general ideas. (1) Mt 18 18 places the respon- sibility for binding and loosing on all disciples (18 1), and the reason is ex~ plained in the assured presence of the Christ, Him- self in any company of two or three who have come together in prayer touching any matter in His name, i.e. as His representatives. ‘The immediate refer- ence is to matters of discipline in the effort to rescue any “brother” from sin. The passage is to be taken of sin generally, for the reading “‘against thee” (ver 15) is to be rejected, in spite of both revised VSS. The reference of binding and loosing here to the man is conclusive against limiting the idea in 16 19 to teaching (cf also Lk 17 1ff). It is also to be noted that the responsibility is placed upon the individual Christian to codperate with others when necessary. ; (2) Mt 9 8 shows that the multitude recognized that God had given power on earth to pronounce forgiveness of sins, and apparently they do not limit this power to the Divine Person, for they do not yet know Him as such. (3) Jas 5 14 ff recognizes the value of elders, and probably of others also, in securing the forgiveness of them that have sinned. ‘ (4) What one must regard as the proper starting- point for studying this subject is Jn 20 21 ff. Ap- pearing to ten of the apostles and to others on the first night after the resurrection, Jesus says: ‘‘As the Father sent me, even so send you. And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and saith unto them, Whose soever sins ye forgive, they are forgiven unte them; whose soever ye retain, they are retained.” By comparing this with the corre- sponding account in Lk 24 we see that Jesus is directing that they shall carry on His work (see also Jn 14 12-14; 15 15.16), that He teaches them at length of the nature of His work as seen in the OT, and that the method of their work is to be preach- ing repentance and remission of sins in His name among all nations. Significant for our purpose are the presence of others than the apostles, the gift of the Holy Spirit, His own self-projection in His messengers, and the solemn statement that the sins 2. Related Passages of men will be retained or forgiven as it is done through these followers. : (1) It is remarkable that there is no distinct reference to this authority of the keys in the records of the work of the apostles and others 3. Examples in the NT. Their consciousness seems of Exercise most of all to have been dominated of This by the fact that they were witnesses of Power Jesus, and this corresponds exactly with the point of emphasis in all the various forms and occasions of the giving of the com- mission (see Acts 2 32; 3 15; 4 33; 5 32; 10 39.41; 13 31; 1 Pet 5 1; cf Carver, Missions in the Planof the Ages). It is said of Paul and Barnabas (Acts 14 27) that after their first missionary journey they rehearsed to the church at Antioch ‘‘all things that God had done with them, and that he had opened a door of faith unto the Gentiles.” At Pentecost and at other times Peter was the chief speaker, and so opened the door of the kingdom. Referring to his preaching to Cornelius and his friends, Peter reminds the saints in the conference at Jerus (Acts 15) that God made choice among them, that by his mouth the Gentiles should hear the word of God and be- lieve, but this was said by way of conciliating the Jewish party and not as claiming any priority in authority. It was Philip, the deacon-evangelist, who first preached to the S anians (Acts 8), and some “men of Cyprus and Cyrene, who, when they were come to Antioch, spake unte the Greeks also, preaching the Lord Jesus” (Acts 11 20), the first example of “opening a door of faith” to full heathen. Peter appears in the Jerus conference with no authority above that of other apostles and elders. By reference to Gal 2 we see that Paul was here only as a matter of prudence and fraternity, not recognizing any authority to legislate for his churches or his ministry. The decision there reached is promulgated as that of the brethren as a body, loosing all the law of Moses save four matters that were ‘necessary’ on account of fundamental morals and of the universal presence of Jews in every city (Acts 15 20 f.28f). In the sense of teaching Christian conduct all Paul’s letters are examples of binding and loosing. (2) As to binding and loosing sins Peter speaks in the cases of Ananias and Be autirs (Acts 5), Simon Magus (ch 8), and in deciding upon the bap- tism of Cornelius and his household (10 48). Paul speaks with equal boldness in the judgment of Elymas (13 10), where we are told that he was under the Spirit; passes upon the faith of a dozen men at Ephesus, and requires their new baptism after instruction (19 3-7); commands the church at Corinth to turn over to Satan the incestuous man (1 Cor 5 5; ef 1 Tim 1 20), and later urges the man’s restoration to loving fellowship, declaring that he has been forgiven (2 Cor 2 5ff)._ Obscure men like Philip (Acts 8) and Ananias of Damascus in the case of Paul himself (Acts 9) exercised the same sort of judgment as to the forgiveness and reception of men into the fellowship. IV. Conclusion.—We sum up what seems to be the teaching of Scripture. We conclude that the power is not a special privilege and 1, Nature extraordinary authority, but a re- of the sponsibility intrusted by Jesus Christ Power as the method of extending His work. . There is in it nothing magical, mys- terious, or arbitrary; not ecclesiastical or official, but spiritual and primarily personal. The keys of the kingdom of heaven are first of all the gospel of salvation through Jesus Christ. By this means men are admitted into the kingdom. The fully attested method of using the keys is that of wit- nessing personally to an experience of Jesus Christ. He was conferring power for saving and not for 1797 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA meee of barring from salvation. Let it be borne in mind always that Jesus was offering Peter not power but duty, not privilege but responsibility. Neither of these terms, “power” and “privilege,” that have come to be associated with the gift of the keys occurs with that gift in the words of the Master. The keys are primarily for admitting to the kingdom of heaven, not for barring from the church. The holder of the keys is any man with that ex- perience that called forth from Jesus the assurance that Peter should have the keys. 2. Agent Such a man will be in fellowship and of the codperation with like men, in a church, Power and the Spirit of Jesus will be present ; _ in them, so that their decisions and their testimony will be His as well as theirs. There is a corporate, or church, agency, therefore, and the man who would ignore that lacks the experience or the Spirit needful for the use of the keys. Yet the church is never to overshadow or exclude the indi- vidual responsibility and authority. It is to be understood that the keys of the king- dom of heaven confer no political authority or power, save that of holy and redemp- 3. Scope _ tive influence. The kingdom of Jesus of the is not of this world. Its power is Power spiritual and is to be exercised always primarily in the saving of men. Men do not need to be locked out of the kingdom. They are out, and too contented to remain so. It does happen that evil men seek to take possession of the kingdom for evil ends, and then it is that the au- thority rests in spiritual men to exclude. Men that are to be brought into the kingdom of heaven are now in sin, and where the duty of releasmg them is not discharged by Christians, the sinners are left bound in their sins. There is also involved of necessity the duty of declaring not only the conditions of entrance into the kingdom, but the courses of conduct appropriate tothe kingdom. It is thus that binding and loosing in teaching devolve upon the holders of the keys. To that extent, and in that sense, alone, is there the power of “legislating’’ within the kingdom. This is only interpreting and applying the principles that are given us in the Scriptures. See further As- SOLUTION; ImposiTiON of Hanns; Peter; Rock. Wiuiam Owen CARVER KEZIAH, ké-zi’a (WEP, kei'ah, “cassia”; Kaota, Kasia, A, Kassia): The 2d daughter of Job (Job 42 14), born after his restoration from afflic- tion. The word “cassia” became a feminine name from the fragrance of the flower. KEZIZ, ké’ziz (Y"XP, cig). See Emux-xeziz. KHAN, kan, kan. See Inn. KIBROTH-HATTAAVAH, kib-roth-ha-ta’a-va, kib-roth- (VINE MP, kibhrith ha-ta’dwah, “the graves of greed”): A desert camp of the Israelites, one day’s journey from the wilderness of Sinai. There the people lusted for flesh to eat, and, a great number of quails being sent, a plague resulted; hence the name (Nu 11 34; 33 16; Dt 9 22). KIBZAIM, kib-za’im, kib’zi-im. See JoKMEAM. KICK (Aakrite, laktizs): In the famous vision on the road to Damascus the unseen voice said to Saul: “Why persecutest thou me? It is hard for thee to kick against the goad” (Acts 9 4f; 26 14). The words are omitted from the best MSS in 9 4. This was a familiar proverb in both Gr and Lat lit., and refers to the severer goading received by an ox which kicks back at the goad used to guide or urge him on. The words seem to mean that Paul’s paroxysm of persecution was a painful as well as profitlesas resistance to the pricks of conscience by which God was leading him into the light. KID: (1) “TH, g’dht (Ex 23 19, etc); (2) fem. gdhiyah (Isa 11 6, etc); (3) DY M7, gedhi ‘izetm, EV “kid,” lit. “kid of the goats,” AVm (Jgs 6 19, etc); (4) TY, ‘Zz, lit. “goat” (Dt 14 21; 1 K 20 27); (5) DIY PW, & Gr Sizzim, AV “kid of the goats,” RV “he-goat” (Gen 37 31; Lev 9 3, etc); (6) eptdos, ériphos (Lk 16 29). See Goat. KIDNAPPING, kid’nap-ing (MANSTEALING): The term itself occurs only in the NT (4véparodior}s, andrapodistés =“‘manstealer”’)in 1 'Tim 110. The crime was directly forbidden in the Heb law (Ex 21 16; Dt 24 7), and was made punishable with death. KIDNEYS, kid’niz (always in the pl.: M93, kelayoth; veppot, nephrot;' Lat. renes, whence the Eng. “reins’”’): “Reins” and “kidneys” are syno- nyms, but AV undertook a distinction by using the former word in the figurative, the latter in the literal passages. ERV has followed AV exactly, but ARV has retained “reins” only in Job 16 13; Lam 3 18; Rev_2 23, elsewhere substituting “heart,” except in Ps 139 13, where “inward parts” isused. AV and ERV also have “reins” for D727, hdlagdyim, in Isa 115 (ARV “‘oins’). The physiological function of the kidneys is not referred to in the Bible, but has been introduced (quite wrongly) by AVm to Lev 16 2; 22 4. (1) The kidneys owe their importance in the Bible partly to the fact that they are imbedded in fat, and fat of such purity that “fat of the kid- neys”’ was a proverbial term for surpassing excel- lence (Dt 82 14m). For the visceral fat was the part of the animal best adapted for sacrificial burn- ing, and hence came to be deemed peculiarly sacred (Lev 7 22-25; 18 216). Accordingly, the kid- neys with the fat surrounding them were burned in every sacrifice iu which the entire animal was not consumed, whether in peace (Lev 3 4.10.15; 9 19), sin (Ex 29 13; Lev 4 9; 8 16; 9 10), or trespass (Lev 7 4) offerings; cf the “ram of consecration” (Ex 29 22; Lev 8 25). So in Isa 34 6, “fat of the kidneys of rams” is chosen as a typical sacrifi- cial term to parallel “blood of lambs and goats.” (2) The position of the kidneys in the body makes them particularly inaccessible, and in cutting up an animal they are the last organs to be reached. Consequently, they were a natural symbol for the most hidden part of a man (Ps 139 13), and in Job 16 13 to “cleave the reins asunder” is to effect the total destruction of the individual (cf 19 27; Lam 313). This hidden location, coupled with the sacred gacrificial use, caused the kidneys to be thought of as the seat of the innermost moral (and emotional) impulses. So the reins instruct (Ps 16 7) or are “pricked” (Ps 73 21), and God can be said to be far from the reins of sinners (Jer 12 2). In all of these passages “conscience” gives the exact meaning. So the reins rejoice (Prov 23 16), cause torment (2 Esd 5 34), or tremble in wrath (1 Macc 2 24). And to “know” or ‘try the reins” (usually joined with “the heart”) is an essential power of God’s, denoting His complete knowledge of the nature of every human being (Ps 79; 26 2; Jer 11 20; 17 10; 20 12; Wisd 16; Rev 2 23). See Far; Psycnotocy; Sac- nirice. Cf RS?, 379-80, and for Gr sacrificial paral- lels Journal of Philology, XTX (1890), 46. The an- atomical relations are well exhibited in the plate in SBOT, “Leviticus.” Burton Scorr Easton Kidron King, Kingdom THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1798 KIDRON, kid’ron (Ke8pa4v, Kedrén; AV Cedron): A place which, in obedience to Antiochus Sidetes, Cendebaeus fortified (1 Macc 16 39 ff), to which, when defeated, he fled, hotly pursued by John and Judas, sons of Simon the Maccahee, who burned the city (16 4ff). It is named along with Jamnia (Yebna) and Azotus (Esdud). It is possibly iden- tical with katrah, a village about 3 miles 8.W. of ‘akir (Ekron). KIDRON, THE BROOK (ji4p 579, nahal kidhron; in Jn 18 1 [AV Cedron], 6 xewpdppous tév Kédpev, ho cheimdrrhous tén Kédroén, according to RVm, the last two words are to be considered as meaning “of the cedars.”” The Heb word has been very generally accepted as from “Ip, kdadhar, “to become black,” but it is an attractive sugges- tion [Cheyne] that it may be a phonetic varia- tion of JIN, giddéron, ‘‘a spot for inclosures for cattle,’’ of which latter there must have been many around thenow buried caves which lay at the base of the cliffs around the spring Gihon): The Nahal Kidhron is the valley known today as the Wddy Sitti Miriam, which lies between the eastern walls of Jerus and the Mount 1. WAdy of Olives. It commences in the pla- Sitti teau_to the N. of the city, and after Miriam making a wide sweep S.E., under the name Wddy el Jéz (“Valley of the Walnuts”), passes S. until level with the south- eastern corner of the temple-area where its bed is Kidron, Looking S.E. from the Wall of Jerusalem. spanned by an old bridge; here the bottom of the valley, 40ft. beneath the present surface level, is 400 ft. below the temple-platform. From this point it narrows and deepens gradually, bending slightly W. of S., and, after receiving the Tyropceon valley, joins a little farther S.W. with the Valley of Hinnom to form the Wddy en Ni ar, which winds on through the ‘‘wilderness of Judaea’’ to the Dead Sea. Where the three valleys run together is a large open space filed with gardens (the Kine’s GarpeEns, q.v.), which are kept irrigated all the year round by means of the overflow waters from the ‘Ain Silwdn (see SitoaM). It is where the Hinnom valley runs into the Kidron that some would locate Topueta (q.v.). Except at the irrigated gardens, the ravine is a dry valley containing water only during and immedi- ately after heavy rain, but in ancient times the rocky bottom—now buried beneath many feet of rich soil—must have contained a little stream from Gihon for at least some hundreds of yards. This was the “brook that flowed through the midst of the land” (2 Ch 82 4). The length of the valley from its head to Bir Eyydb is 23 miles. Since the 4th cent. AD, this valley has been known as the Vatiey or JnenosHaPHat (q.v.), and from quite early times it was a favorite situation for mterments (2 K 23 4.6.12; 2 Ch 34 4.5); it is by Moslem and Jewish tradition the scene of the last judgment, and was known to the Moslems in the Middle Ages as Wddy Jehannum; 2. Tradi- see Gensenna. It is probable that the tions “graves of the common people,’’ where King Jehoiakim cast the body of the prophet Uriah, were here (Jer 26 23), and it has been suggested, with less probability, that here too may have been the scene of Ezekiel’s vision of the “valley of dry bones’’ (Ezk 37; cf Jer 31 40). The Fields of Kidron (2 K 23 4), though gen- erally identified with the open, lower part of this valley, where it is Joined by the Tyro- 3. The peon valley, may more probably have Fields of | been in the upper part where the wide Kidron expanded valley receives the name Wady el Jéz; this part is actually on the road to Bethel. The most dramatic scene associated with the Kidron is that recorded in connection with its earliest Scriptural mention (2 S 15 4, Histori- 23), when David, flying before his cal Asso- _ rebellious son Absalom, here stood on ciations the Jerus side of the valley while all his adherents passed over. ‘‘And all the country wept with a loud voice, and all the people passed over: the king also himself passed over the brook Kidron .... toward the way of the wilderness.”? The passing over this brook ap- pears to have been viewed as the solemn abandon- ment of the Jerus territory (cf 1 K 2 37). In1 K 16 13; 2 Ch 15 16, we read that Asa burnt at the brook Kidron ‘‘an abominable image for an Asherah” which Maacah, his mother, had set up. In the reforms of Hezekiah, ‘all the uncleanness that they found in the temple of Jeh’”’ was carried by the Levites to the brook Kidron (2 Ch 29 16); “Allthe altars for incense took they away, and cast them into the brook Kidron” (30 14). This local- ity was again used in the reforms of Josiah when the king “brought out the Asherah from the house of Jeh, without Jerus, unto the brook Kidron, and burned it at the brook Kidron, and beat it to dust, and cast the dust thereof upon the graves of the com- mon people” (2 K 23 6). Thesame treatment was given to the vessels made for Baal, the Asherah and the host of heaven (ver 4), and the two idolatrous altars of Manasseh (ver 12). Jos (Ant, IX, vii, 3) states that Athaliah was slain in the valley of Kidron, but this does not quite tally with the ac- count (2 K 11 16). It was a valley associated with graves and the ashes of abominations, but it was prophesied that it should be ‘“‘holy unto Jeh” (Jer 31 40). Twice it is mentioned simply as “‘the valley,” nahal (2 Ch 83 14; Neh 215). Very different from these earlier scenes is the last Scriptural reference (Jn 18 1), when Jesus “went forth with his disciples over the brook Kidron” for His last hours of spiritual struggle and prayer before the turmoil of the end. E. W. G. Masterman KILAN, kilan (Kudv, Kilén; AV Ceilan): Mentioned with Azetas in 1 Esd 6 15; their sons returned among, the exiles with Zerubbabel. The names do not appear in the lists of Ezr and Neh. KIMAH, ki’ma (Pleiades). KIN. See Kinprep. KIN, NEXT OF. See Kinsman. KINAH, ki’na (TP, kindh): An unidentified town on the southern boundary of Judah, toward Edom (Josh 15 22). The word kindh means “elegy,” ‘“dirge,” “lament for the dead.” The name, however, may have been derived from the See ASTRONOMY. 1799 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kidron King, Kingdom Kenites, "3°?, who had settlements in the S. (1S 27 10, etc). KINDNESS, kind’nes (70M, hesedh; xpynorérys, chrést6tés): “Kindness” in the OT is (with one ex- ception) the tr of hesedh, “kindness,” “favor,” “mercy,” etc, used chiefly of man but also of God (Gen 20 13; 40 14; 18 156; 20 14.15; 28 93; Neh 9 17; Ps 141 5; Isa 54 8.10, etc); tobh, “‘good,’’ is once so tr? (2 8 2 6). In the NT chréstotés, “usefulness,” “beneficence,” is rendered “kindness” 4 t in AV (2 Cor 6 6; Eph 2 7; Col 3 12; Tit 3 4, and in Gal 6 22 RV) 3, see GENTLE- ness; Goopness, Philanthropia, “love of man- kind,” is tr4 “kindness” (Acts 28 2), and phila- delphia, “love of the brotherhood” (2 Pet 1 7, ERV “love of the brethren,” ARVm “Gr, love of the brethren’). For ‘'kindness” (Ps $1 21) RV has “‘lovingkindness,” and ARV in other places where the reference is to God; for ‘‘shew," ‘‘shewed kindness" (Josh 2 12) ‘‘deal,’' ‘dealt kindly’’; for The desire of man is his kindness’’ (Prov 19 22) ARV has ‘'That which maketh a man to be desired is his kindness,'’ ERV ‘‘The desire of man is [the measure of) his kindness,” like ARV in m; for ‘‘merci- ful kindness’? (Ps 117 2) ARV has ‘‘lovingkindness," ERV “mercy”; both have ‘‘lovingkindness’ (Ps 119 76); for “of reat kindness’’ (Neh 9 17; Joel 2 13; Jon 4 2) ARV has ‘‘abundant_in lovingkindness,’’ ERV “plenteous in_mercy’’; has ‘‘kindness’’ for “mercy” (Gen 39 21); for “pity” (Job 6 14); for ‘‘goodness’’ (Prov 20 6); ‘favor and kindness"’ ARV, for '‘graceand favor” (Est 2.17). See LovincxinpNzss; Mercy. W. L. WaLker KINDRED, kin’dred: Several words are rendered “kindred” in AV. MN, ’ah, “brother,’’ was used loosely among Hebrews for a member of the same tribe or family, arelative; and isonce tré “kindred’”’ (1 Ch 12 29AV). Once also somewhat loosely ag the tr of MITA, moddha‘ath, lit. “acquaintance” (Ruth $ 2; ef same root in 2 1, rendered “‘kins- man”); once, for the figurative expression, “men of thy redemption” (T2N4, g’ ullah, referring to the law of the redemption of land by kinsmen, Lev 25 25). The two most common words for kindred are: (1) ms, méledheth, “related by birth” (Gen 12 1; 244.7; 31 3.13; 329; 43 7; Nu 10 30; Est 2 10.20; 8 6); (2) MAMEWA, mishpahah, “family” (Gen 24 38.40.41; Josh 6 23; Ruth 23; 1 Ch 16 28; Job 32 2; Ps 22 27; 96 7). In the NT (several times), yévos, génos, “‘kindred by birth,” so, of same family, tribe or race (Acts 4 6; 7 13.19 RV “race’”’); s0 also ouvyyévea, sug- géneia (Lk 161; Acts 7 3.14). In AV_ vay, phulé, ‘“‘tribe,” rendered “kindred” (Rev 1 7; 5 9; 79; 119; 18 7; 14 6), but better “tribe” as in RV. sarpid, pairid, rendered “kindred” in Acts 3 25, is better ‘“families,” asin RV. Epwarp Bacpy PoLtiarD KINE, kin: (1) D°DSN, ’dlaphim, pl. of FN, ’eleph, “ox,” or “cow,” ARV ‘‘cattle,” AV and ERV’ “kine? (Dt 7 13; 28 4.18.51); (2) "p3, bakadr, “ox” or “cow,” ARV “herd,” AV and ERV “kine” (Dt 32 14; 2 8 17 29); (3) N18, parath, pl. of M8, parah, “young cow” or “heifer,” RV “kine” in Gen 41 2-27; 1867-14; Am 41; in Gen 32 15, ARV has “cows.” See Carrie; Cow. KING, KINGDOM, king’dum: I. Kine xo; 1. Etymology and Definition 2. Earliest Kings. ‘ 3. Biblical Signification of the Title Il. Krnopom 1. Israel's Theocracy - 2. Period of Judges 3. Establishment of the Monarchy . Appointment of King . Authority of the King . Duties of the King . The Symbols of Royal Dignity Maintenance and Establishment 1) Income 2) The Royal Court 9. Short Character Sketch of Israel’s Kingdom LiteRATURE I. King.—The Heb word for king is J%'A, melekh; its denominative q>0 , malakh, ‘to reign,” “to be king.”’ The word is apparently derived from the V¥ mlkh which de- 1. Ety- vee mology and notes: (1) in the Arab. (the, vb., and Definition & - 5 , n.), “to possess,”’ “to reign,”’ in- WNO oR asmuch as the possessor is also lord and ruler; (2) in the Aram. (72%), and Assyr ‘‘counsel,”’ and in the Syrian “‘to consult”; cf Lat consul. If, as has been suggested, the root idea of “‘king”’ is “counsellor” and not “ruler,” then the rise of the kingly office and power would be due to intellectual superiority rather than to physical prowess. And since the first form of monarchy known was that of a “city-state,” the office of king may have evolved from that of the chief “elder,” or intellec- tual head of the clan. The first king of whom we read in the Bible was Nimrod (Gen 10 8-10), who was supposedly _the founder of the Bab empire. His- 2. Earliest torical research regarding the kings Kings of Babylonia and Egypt corroborates this Bib. statement in so far as the ancestry of these kings is traced back to the carliest times of antiquity. According to Isa 19 11, it was the pride of the Egyp princes that they could trace their lineage to most ancient kings. The Ca- naanites and Philis had kings as early as the times of Abraham (Gen 14 2; 20 2). Thus also the Edomites, who were related to Israel (Gen 36 31), the Moabites, and the Midianites had kings (Nu 22 4; 31 8) earlier than the Israelites. . In Gen 14 18 we read of Melchizedek, who was a priest, and king of Salem. At first the extent of the dominion of kings was often very limited, as appears from 70 of them being conquered by Adoni- bezek (Jgs 1 7), 31 by Joshua (Josh 12 7 ff), and 82 being subject to Ben-hadad (1 K 20 1). The earliest Bib. usage of this title “king,’’ in consonance with the general oriental practice, de- notes an absolute monarch who exer-~ 8. Biblical cises unchecked control over his sub- Significa~ jects. In this sense the title is applied tion of the to Jeh, and tohuman rulers. No con- Title stitutional obligations were Jaid upon the ruler nor were any restrictions put upon his arbitrary authority. His good or bad conduct depended upon his own free will. The title “king” was applied also to dependent kings. In the NT it is used even for the head of a province (Rev 17 12). To distinguish him from the smaller and dependent kings, the king of Assyria bore the title “king of kings.” Hl, Kingdom.—The notable fact that Israel attained to the degree of a kingdom rather late, as compared with the other Sem nations, does not imply that Israel, before the establishment of the monarchy, had not arrived at the stage of consti- tutional government, or that the idea of a king- dom had noroom in the original plan of the founder of the Heb nation. For a satisfactory explana- tion we must take cognizance of the unique place that Israel held among the Sem peoples. It is universally recognized that Israel was a singular community. From the beginning of its existence as a nation it bore the character of a re- ligious and moral community, a theocratic common- King, Kingdom THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1800 wealth, having Jeh Himself as the Head and Ruler. The theocracy is not to be mistaken for a hierarchy, nor can it strictly be identified with 1, Israel’s any existent form of political organiza- Theocracy tion. It was rather something over and above, and therefore independ- ent of the political organization. It did not super- sede the tribal organization of Israel, but it supplied the centralizing power, constituting Israel a nation. In lieu of a strong political center, the unifying bond of a common allegiance to Jeh, i.e. the common faith in Him, the God of Israel, kept the tribes together. The consciousness that Jeh was Israel’s king was deeply rooted, was a national feeling, and the inspiration of a true pa- triotism (Ex 16 18; 196; Jgs 6). Jch’s king- ship is evinced by the laws He gave to Israel, by the fact that justice was administered in His name (Ex 22 28), and by His leading and aiding Israel in its wars (Ex 14 14; 15 3; Nu 21 14; 15 18 17; 25 28). This decentralized system which characterized the early government of Israel politi- cally, in spite of some great disadvantages, proved advantageous for Israel on the whole and served a great providential purpose. It safeguarded the individual liberties and rights of the Israelites. When later the monarchy was established, they enjoyed a degree of local freedom and self-control that was unknown in the rest of the Sem world; there was home rule for every community, which admitted the untrammeled cultivation of their inherited religious and social institutions. From the political point of view Israel, through the absence of a strong central government, was at a great disadvantage, making almost impossible its development into a world-empire. But this barrier to a policy of self-aggrandizement was a decided blessing from the viewpoint of Israel’s providential mission to the world. It made pos- sible the transmission of the pure religion in- trusted to it, to later generations of men without destructive contamination from the ungodly forces with which Israel would inevitably have come into closer contact, had it not been for its self-contained character, resulting from the fashion of a state it was providentially molded into. Only as the small and insignificant nation that it was, could Israel perform its mission as “the depository and perpetuating agency of truths vital to the welfare of humanity.” Thus its religion was the central authority of this nation, supplying the lack of a centralized government. Herein lay Israel’s unique- ness and greatness, and also the secret of its strength as a nation, as long as the loyalty and devotion to Jeh lasted. Under the leadership of Moses and Joshua who, though they exercised a royal authority, acted merely as representatives of Jeh, the influence of religion of which these lead- ers were a personal embodiment was still so strong as to keep the tribes united for common action. But when, after the removal of these strong leaders, Israel no longer had a standing representative of Jeh, those changes took place which eventually necessitated the establishment of the monarchy. In the absence of a special representative of Jeh, His will as Israel’s King was divined by the use of the holy lot in the hand of the highest 2. Period priest. But the lot would not supply of Judges the place of a strong personal leader. Besides, many of the Israelites came under the deteriorating influence of the Can. wor- ship and began to adopt heathenish customs. The sense of religious unity weakened, the tribes became disunited and ceased to act in common, and as a result they were conquered by their foes. Jeh came to their assistance by sending them leaders, who released the regions where they lived from foreign attacks. But these leaders were not the strong religious personalities that Moses and Joshua had been; besides, they had no official authority, and their rule was only temporary and local. It was now that the need of a centralized political government was felt, and the only type of per- manent organization of which the age was cog- nigant was the kingship. The crown was offered to Gideon, but he declined it, saying: ‘“Jeh shall rule over you” (Jgs 8 22.23). The attempt of his son, Abimelech, to establish a kingship over Shechem and the adjacent country, after the Canaanitic fashion, was abortive. The general political condition of this period is briefly and pertinently described by the oft-recur- ring statement in Jgs: ‘‘In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes.”’ Not until the time of Samuel was a formal king- dom established over Israel. An attempt to ameli- orate conditions by a union of civil 3. Estab- and _ religious functions in the hands lishment of Eli, the priest, had failed through of the the degeneracy of his sons. Similarly Monarchy the hopes of Israel in a hereditary judgeship had been disappointed through the corruption of the sons of Samuel. The Philis were threatening the independence and hope of Israel. Its very existence as a distinct race, and consequently the future of Jeh’s religion, impera- tively demanded a king. Considering that it was the moral decline of the nation that had created the necessity for a monarchy, and moreover that the people’s desire for a king originated from a purely national and not from a religious motive, the un- willingness of Samuel, at first, to comply with the demand for a king is not surprising. Even Jeh declared: ‘‘They have not rejected thee but they have rejected me,’”’ etc. Instead of recognizing that they themselves were responsible for the fail- ures of the past, they blamed the form of govern- ment they had, and put all their hopes upon a king. That it was not the monarchy as such that was objectionable to Jeh and His prophet is evidenced by the fact that to the patriarchs the promise had been given: ‘Kings shall come out of thy loins” (Gen 17 6; 35 11). In view of this Moses had mdde provision for a kingship (Dt 17 14-20). According to the Mosaic charter for the kingship, the monarchy when established must be brought into consonance with the fact that Jeh was Israel’s king. Of this fact Israel had lost sight when it requested a kingship like that of the neighboring peoples. Samuel’s gloomy prognostications were perfectly justified in view of such a kingship as they desired, which would inevitably tend to selfish despotism (1 8 8 11f). Therefore God directs Samuel to give them a king—since the introduction of a kingship typifying the kingship of Christ lay within the plan of His economy—not according to their desire, but in accordance with the instructions of the law concerning kings (Dt 17 14-20), in order to safeguard their liberties and prevent the forfeiture of their mission. According to the Law of Moses Jeh was to choose the king of Israel, who was to be His representative. é The choice of Jeh in the case of Saul 4. Appoint- is implied by the anointing of Saul by ment of Samuel and through the confirmation King of this choice by the holy lot (1 S 10 ; ; 1-20). This method of choosing the king did not exclude the people altogether, since Saul was publicly presented to them, and acknowl- edged as king (1 § 10 24). The participation of the people in the choice of their king is more pro- nounced in the case of David, who, having been designated as Jeh’s choice by being anointed by 1801 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA King, Kingdom Samuel, was anointed again by the elders of Israel before he actually became king (2 8 2 4). The anointing itself signified the consccration to an office in the theocracy. The custom of anointing kings was an old one, and by no means pecular to Israel (Jgs 9 8.15). The hereditary kingship began with David. Usually the firstborn succeeded to the throne, but not necessarily. The king might choose as his successor from among his sons the one whom he thought best qualified. The king of Israel was not a constitutional monarch in the modern sense, nor was he an auto- crat in the oriental sense. He was 5. Author- responsible to Jeh, who had chosen ity of the him and whose vicegerent and servant King he was. Furthermore, his authority “a _. Was more or less limited on the re- ligious side by the prophets, the representatives of Jeh, and in the political sphere by the “elders,” the representatives of the people, though as king he stood above all. Rightly conceived, his kingship in relation to Jeh, who was Israel’s true king, im- plied that he was Jeh’s servant and His earthly sub- stitute. In relation to his subjects his kingship demanded of him, according to the Law, “that his heart be not lifted up ahove his brethren’”’ (Dt 17 20). In a summary way the king was held responsible for all Israel as the Lord’s people. His main duty was to defend it against its enemies, 6. Duties and for this reason it devolved upon of the King him to raise and maintain a standing army; and it was expected of him that he be its leader in case of war (1S 8 20). In respect to the judiciary the king was a kind of supreme court, or court of final appeal, and as such, as in the days of Solomon, might be approached by his most humble snbjects (28.15 2; 1 K 3 16 ff). Legislative functions he had none and was himself under the Jaw (1 K 21 4; Dt 17 19). The king was also in a way the summus episcopus in Israel. His very kingship was of an entirely religious character and implied a unity of the heavenly and earthly rule over Israel through him who as Jeh’s substitute sat “upon the throne of the kingdom of Jeh over Israel”? (1 Ch 17 14; 28 5; 29 23), who was “Jeh’s anointed’ (1 8 24 10; 26 9; 25 1 14), and also bore the title of “son of Jeh” and “the first-born,” the same as Israel did (Ex 4 22; Hos 111; 28 7 14; Ps 89 27; 2 7). Thus a place of honor was assigned to the king in the temple (2 K 11 4; 23 3; Ezk 46 1.2); be- sides, he officiated at the national sacrifices (esp. mentioned of David and Solomon). He prayed for his people and blessed them in the name of Jeh (28 6 18; 24 25;1 K 3 4.8; 8 14.55.62; 9 25). Apparently it was the king’s right to ap- point’ and dismiss the chief priests at the sanctu- aries, though in his choice he was doubtless re- stricted to the Aaronites (1 Ch 16 37.39; 28 8 17; 1 K 2 27.35). ‘The priesthood was under the king’s supervision to such an extent that he might concern himself about its organization and duties (1 Ch 15 16.23.24; 1646), and that he was responsible for the purity of the cult and the main- tenance of the order of worship. In general he was to watch over the religious life and conduct of his people, to eradicate the high pee and every form of idolatry in the land (2 18 4). Ezk 45 22 demands of the prince that he shall provide at the Passover a bullock for a sin offering for all the people. ; The marks of royal dignity, besides the beautiful robes in which the king was attired (1 K 22 10), were: (1) the diadem (“J2, nézer) and the crown (MII, ‘dfarah, 2 S 1 10; 2 K 11 12; 2 8 12 30), the headtire; (2) the scepter (DAW, shébhet), originally a long, straight staff, the primitive sign of dominion and authority (Gen 49 10; Nu 17; Isa 14 5; Jer 48 17; Ps 7. The 29; 465 7). Saul had a spear (18S Symhols of 18 10; 22 6); (8) the throne (NG, Royal kiss@, 1 K 10 18-20), the symbol of Dignity majesty. Israel’s kings also had a palace (1 K 7 1-12; 22 39; Jer 22 14), a royal harem (2 S 16 21), and a body- guard (2S 8 18; 16 18). (1) Income.—(a) According to the custom of the times presents were expected of the subjects (1 8 10 27; 16 20) and of foreigners 8. Mainte- (28 8 2; 1 K 5 1ff; 10 25; 2 Ch 32 nance and 23), and these often took the form of Establish- an annual tribute. (b) In time of ment war the king would lay claim to his share of the booty 2 8S 8 11; 12 30; 1 Ch 26 27). (©) Various forms of taxes were in vogue, as a part of the produce of the land (1 K 9 11;_ 18 17 25), forced labor of the Canaanites (1 K 9 20; 2 Ch 2 16) and also of the Israelites (1 K 6 18; 11 28; 12 4), the first growth of the pasture lands (Am 7 1), toll collected from cara- vans (1 K 10 15). (d) Subdued nations had to pay a heavy tribute (2 K 3 4). (e) The royal domain often comprised extensive possessions (1 Ch 27 25-31). (2) The royal court—The highest office was that of the princes (1 K 4 2), who were the king’s ad- visers or counsellors. In. 2 K 25 19 and Jer 52 25 they are called “they that saw the king’s face” (cf also 1 K 12 6, ‘“‘stood before Solomon”). The following officers of King David are mentioned: the captain of the host (commander-in-chief), the captain of the Cherethites and the Pelethites (body- guard), the recorder (chronicler and reminder), the scribe (secretary of state), the overseer of the forced labor, the chief ministers or priests (confidants of the king, usually selected from the royal family) (2.8 8 16-18; 20 23-26). During the reign of Solomon other officers were added as follows: the overseer over the twelve men “who provided victuals for the king and his household” (1 K 4 5.7), the officer over the bouse- hold (1 K 4 6; 18 3) (steward, the head of the palace who had “‘the key” in his possession, Isa 22 22); the king’s friend (1 K 4 5; 1 Ch 27 33) is probably the same as the king’s servant mentioned among the high officials in 2 K 22 12. It is not stated what his duties were. Minor officials are servants, cupbearer (1 K 10 5), keeper of the ward- robe (2 K 22 14; 10 22), eunuchs (chamherlains, not mentioned before the division of the kingdom) (1 K 22 9; 2 K 8 6). No higher conceptions of a good king have ever been given to the world than those which are pre- sented in the representations of king- 9. Short ship in the OT, both actual and ideal. Character Though Samuel’s characterization of Sketch of . the kingship was borne out in the Israel’s example of a great number of kings of Kingdom Israel, the Divine ideal of a true king came as near to its realization in the case of one king of Israel, at least, as possibly no- where else, viz. in the case of David. Therefore King David appears as the type of that king in whom the Divine ideal of a Jeh-king was to find its perfect realization; toward whose reign the kingship in Israel tended. The history of the king- ship in Israel after David is, indeed, characterized by that desire for political aggrandizement which bad prompted the establishment of the monarchy, wile was contrary to Israel's Divine mission as the peculiar people of the Jeh-king. When Israel’s kingdom terminated in the Bab exile, it became evi- dent that the continued existence of the nation was King, Christ as THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1802 possible even without a monarchical form of govern- ment. Though a kingdom was established again under the Maccabees, as a result of the attempt of Antiochus to extinguish Israel’s religion, this king- dom was neither as perfectly national nor as truly religious in its character as the Davidic. It soon became dependent on Rome. The kingship of Herod was entirely alien to the true Israelitish conception. It remains to be said only that the final attempt of Israel in its revolt against the Rom Empire, to establish the old monarchy, resulted in its down- fall as a nation, because it would not learn the lesson that the future of a nation does not depend upon political greatness, but upon the fulfilment of its Divine mission. Literaturse.—J. P. McCurdy, History, Prophecy and the Monuments; Riehm, Handwérterbuch des bibl. Alter- tums; HDB; Kinzler, Bibl. AT. 8S. D. Press KING, CHRIST AS: J. Tue Reaciry or Cxnist’s KinesHip 1. The OT Foreshadowings la the Psalms and Prophets 2. The Gospel Presentation (1) Christ's Claim to Be King 2) Christ's Acceptance of the Title (3) Christ Charged and Condemned as King (4) The Witness of the Resurrection and of Apostolic Preaching (5) The Testimony of the Epistles and Apoc- alypse II. Curist's Tirte to Kinesuir 1. By Birth 2. By Divine Appointment 3. By Conquest 4. By the Free Choice of His People III. Tse Nature or Curist’s KincsHir 1. Spiritual 2. Universal (1) Kingdom of Grace, of Power (2) Kingdom of Glory 3. Eternal I. The Reality of Christ’s Kingship.—There can be no question but that Christ is set before us in Scripture as a king. The very title Christ or ‘‘Mes- siah”’ suggests kingship, for though the priest is spoken of as “‘anointed,”’ and full elucidation of the title as applied to Jesus must take account of His threefold office of prophet, priest and king, yet generally in the OT it is the king to whom the epithet 1s applied. We may briefly note some of the OT predictions of Christ as king. The first prediction which represents the Christ as having dominion is that of 1. The OT Jacob concerning the trihe of Judah: Fore~ “‘Until Shiloh come; and unto him shall J the obedience of the peoples he’’ (Gen 49 shadowings 10); then kingly dignity and dominion are suggested hy the star and scepter in Balaam's prophecy (Nu 24 15-17). As yet, however, Israel has no king hut God, hut when afterward a king is given and the people hecome familiar with the idea, the prophecies all more or less have a regal tint, and the coming one is preéminently the coming king. In the Pss and Prophets —We can only indicate a few of the many royal_predictions, hut these will readily suggest.others. In Ps 2 the voice of Jeh is heard above all the tumult of earth, declaring, ‘‘ Yet I have set my king upon my holy hill of Zion.” Soin Pss 24, 45, 72, 89 and 110 we have special foreshadowings of the Mes- sianic king. The hahe that Isaiah sees horn of a virgin is also the ‘‘ Prince of Peace” (Isa 9 6.7), of the increase of whose government there shall be no end, and as the rophet gazes on him he joyfully exclaims: ‘‘ Behold, a ing shall reign in righteousness"’ (Isa 82 1). Jeremiah, the prophet of woe, catches bright glimpses of his coming Lord, and with rapture intensified hy the Su ourns sorrow cries: ‘‘Behold, the days come, saith Jeh, that will raise unto David a righteous Branch, and he shall reign as king and deal wisely, and shall execute justice and righteousness in the land” (28 5). Ezekiel, dwelling amid his wheels, secs in the course of Providence many revolutions, hut they are all to hring about the dominion of Christ: “I will overturn, overturn, overturn... . until he come whose right it is; and J will give it him” (21 rae Daniel sees the rise and progress, the decline and fall of many mighty empires, hut heyond all he sees the Son of man inheriting an everlasting kingdom (7 13). Hosea sees the repentant people of Israel in the latter days seeking Jeh their God, and David (the greater David) their king (8 5). Micah sees the everlasting Ruler coming out of Bethlehem clad in the strength and. majesty of Jeh, who shall ‘‘be great unto the ends of the earth’ (5 4). Zechariah, exulting in His near approach, cries: ‘‘ Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion; shout, ie daughter of Jerus: hehold, thy king cometh unto thee (9 9), and he follows His varied course through gloom and through glory, until the strong conviction is born in his heart and expressed in the glowing words: ‘‘Jeh shail be King over all the earth” (14 9). The more extreme higher critics would, of course, deny that these are direct predictions of Jesus Christ, hut most, if not all, would admit that they are ideal representations which were only fully realized in Jesus of Nazareth. The Gospels present Christ as king. Mt, trac- ing His genealogy, gives special prominence to His royal lineage as son of David. He 2. The tells of the visit of the Magi who in- Gospel quire for the newborn king of the Jews, Presenta- and the scribes answer Herod’s ques- tion tion by showing from Micah’s prophecy that the Christ to be born in Bethle- hem would be a “governor,” and would rule, “be shepherd of my people Israel” (2 5.6). Lk’s account of the Nativity contains the angel’s dec- laration that the child to be born and named Jesus would occupy the throne of David and reign over the house of Jacob forever (1 32.33). In John’s account of the beginning of Christ’s ministry, one of His early disciples, Nathanael, hails Him as “King of Israel” (1 49), and Jesus does not repn- diate the title. If Mark has no such definite word, he nevertheless describes the message with which Jesus opens His ministry as the “gospel” of ‘the kingdom of God” (1 14.15). The people nurtured in the prophetical teaching expect the coming one to be a king, and when Jesus seems to answer to their ideal of the Messiah, they propose taking Him by force and making Him king (Jn 6 15). (1) Christ’s claim to be king—Christ Himself claimed to be king. In claiming to be the Messiah He tacitly claimed kingship, but there are specific indications of the claim besides. In all His teach- ing of the kingdom it is implied, for though He usually calls it the “kingdom of God” or “of heaven,”’ yet it is plain that He is the administrator of its affairs. He assumes to Himself the highest place in it. Admission into the kingdom or ex- clusion from it depends upon men’s attitude toward Him. In His explanation of the parable of the Tares, He distinctly speaks of His kingdom, identi- fying it with the kingdom of God. “The Son of man shall send forth his angels, and they shall gather out of his kingdom all things that cause stumbling, and them that do iniquity..... Then shall the righteous shine forth as the sun in the kingdom of their Father’ (Mt 13 41-43). He speaks of some seeing ‘‘the Son of man coming in his kingdom” (Mt 16 28), of the regeneration, ‘when the Son of man shall sit on the throne of his glory’ (Mt 19 28), of Himself under the guise of a nobleman who goes “into a far country, to receive for himself a kingdom,” and does receive it (Lk 19 12-15). (2) Christ’s acceptance of the title—When the mother of John and James comes asking that her two sons may occupy the chief places of honor in His kingdom, He does not deny that He is a king and has a kingdom, while indicating that the places on His right and left hand are already determined by the appointment of the Father (Mt 20 21-23). He deliberately takes steps to fulfil the prediction of Zec: “Behold, thy king cometh,” and He ac- cepts, approves and justifies the hosannas and the homage of the multitude (Mt 21 1-16; Mk 11; Lk 19; Jn 12). In His great picture of the coming judgment (Mt 25), the Son of man sits upon the throne of His glory, and it is as “the king’’ that He blesses and condemns. The dying thief prays, “Remember me when thou comest in thy king- dom” (Lk 23 42), and Jesus gives His royal re- sponse which implies full acceptance of the position. 1803 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA King, Christ as (3) Christ charged and condemned as king —His claim throughout had been so definite that His enemies makc this the basis of their charge against Him before Pilate, that He said that “he himself is Christ a king,’ and when Pilate asks, “Art thou the King?’ He answers, ‘Thou sayest,’? which was equivalent to “yes” (Lk 23 2.3). In the fuller account of Jn, Jesus speaks to Pilate of ‘‘my king- dom,” and says ‘Thou sayest that I am a king. To this end have I been born” (Jn 18 37). His claim is perpetuated in the superscription of the cross in the three languages: ‘This is the King of the Jews,” and although the priests wished it to be altered so as to detract from His claim, they yet affirm the fact of that claim when they say: ‘Write not, The King of the Jews; but, that he said, I am King of the Jews” (Jn 19 21). The curtain of His earthly life falls upon the king in seeming failure; the taunt of the multitude, ‘Let the Christ, the King of Israel, now come down from the cross” (Mk 16 32), meets with no response, and the title on the cross seems a solemn mockery, like the elaborate, cruel jest of the brutal soldiers clothing Him with purple, crowning Him with thorns and hailing Him King of the Jews. : (4) The witness of the resurrection and of apos- tolic preaching.—But the resurrection throws new light upon the scene, and fully vindicates His claims, and the sermon of Peter on the day of Pentecost proclaims the fact that the crucified one occupies the throne. ‘‘Let all the house of Israel therefore know assuredly, that God hath made him both Lord and Christ, this Jesus whom ye crucified” (Acts 2 36). The early preaching of the apostles, as re- corded in the Acts, emphasizes His lordship, His kingship; these men were preachers in the literal sense—heralds of the king. (5) The testimony of the Epistles and Apocalypse. —We need not consider in detail the testimony of the Epp. The fact that Christ is king is every- where implied and not infrequently asserted. He is “Lord of both the dead and the living’ (Rom 14 9). He is risen “to rule over the Gentiles” (Rom 15 12). “He must reign, till he hath put all his enemies under his feet”? (1 Cor 15 25). He is at the right hand of God “above all rule, and author- ity,” ete (Eph 1 20-22). Evil men have no ‘nheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God” (Eph 6 5), and believers are “translated into the kingdom of the Son of his love” (Col 1 13). He has been given the name that is above every name “that in the name of Jesus every knee should bow,” ete (Phil 2 9-11). Those who suffer with Christ are to “reign with him” (2 Tim 2 12), at “his appearing and his kingdom” (2 Tim 4 1), and He will save them “unto his heavenly kingdom” (2 Tim 4 18); “the eternal kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ”? (2 Pet 111). Of the Son it is said: “Thy throne, O God, is for ever and ever” (He 1 8), and He is a King-Priest “after the order of Mol omaedeey] ae q ee fons nee lypse, appropriately, the predominant aspect o Chriet rehse of a king. He is the “ruler of the kings of the earth” (Rev 1 5), “King of the ages” (Rev 16 3), “King of kings’ (17 14; 19 16), “and he shall reign for ever and ever’ (11 15). The reality of Christ’s kingship is thus placed be- yond all doubt. : Il. Christ’s Title to Kingship.—After the analogy of earthly kingships it might be said that Jesus Christ is a king by birth. He was 1. By Birth born a king. His mother, like His reputed father, “was of the house and family of David?’ (Lk 2 4). The angel in an; nouncing His birth declares that He will occupy the throne of His father David. The Pharisees have no hesitation in affirming that the Christ would be Son of David (Mt 22 45; Mk 12 35; Lk 20 41). Frequently in life He was hailed as “Son of David,” and after His ascension, Peter declares that the promise God had made to David that ‘‘of the fruit of his loins he would set one upon his throne’ (Acts 2 30) was fulfilled in Jesus of Nazareth; while Paul declares that the gospel of God was “concerning his Son, who was born of the seed of David according to the flesh’ (Rom 1 3). So that on the human side He had the title to king- ship as son of David, while on the Divine side as Son of God He had also the right to the throne. David was king by Divine choice and appoint- ment, and this was the ideal in the casc of his successors. The figment of ‘Divine 2. By Di- right’—by virtue of which modern vine Ap- kings have claimed to rule—was, in the pointment first instance, a reminiscence of the Bib. ideal. But the idcal is realized in Christ. Of the coming Messianic King, Jeh said: ‘Yet I have set my king upon my holy hill of Zion” (Ps°2 6), and the great proclamation of Pentecost was an echo of that, decree: “Let all the house of Israel therefore know assuredly, that God hath made him both Lord and Christ, this Jesus whom ye crucified” (Acts 2 36), while the apostle declares that ‘(God highly exalted him, and gave unto him the name which is above every name” (Phil 2 9), and again and again the great OT word of Jeh is applied to Christ: “Sit thou on my right hand, till I make thine enemies the footstool of thy feet’? (He 1 13). Often in the olden times kingship was acquired by conquest, by superior prowess. According to one etymology of our word “king,” it 3. By Con- means the “able man,” ‘the one who quest can,” and everyone remembers Car- lyle’s fine passage thereon. In the high- est sense, this is true of Christ, who establishes His sway over men’s hearts by His matchless prowess, the power of His infinite love and the charm of His perfect character. Except in the most autocratic form of kingship, some place has been given to the suffrage of the people,.and the other phases of the 4. By the title have been confirmed and ratified Free Choice by the voice of the people as they cry, of His “God save the king!’ and no king is People well established on the throne if he is not supported by the free homage of his subjects. Christ as king wins the love of His people, and they gladly acknowledge His sway. They are of one heart to make Him king. JH. The Nature of Christ’s Kingship.—We know that the Jews expected a material kmgdom, marked by earthly pomp and state; a kingdom on the lines of the Davidic or Solomonic kingdom, and others since have made the same mistake. The Scriptures plainly declare, Christ Himself clearly taught, that His kingship was spiritual. “My kingdom,” said He, “is not of 1. Spiritual this world” (Jn 18 36), and all the representations given of it are all con- sistent with this declaration. Some have empha- sized the preposition ek here, as if that made a difference in the conception: ‘My kingdom is not of this world.” Granted that the preposition indi- cates origin, it still leaves the statement an assertion of the spirituality of the kingdom, for if it is not from this kosmos, from this earthly state of things, it must be from the other world—not the earthly but the heavenly; not the material but the spiritual. The whole context shows that origin here includes character, for Christ adds, “If my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews.” Because it is of an unworldly origin, it is not to be propagated by King, Christ as Kingdom of God THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1804 worldly means, and the non-use of worldly means declares it to be of an unworldly character. So that to assert that Christ means that His kingdom was not to arise out of this world, but to come down from heaven, is not at all to deny, but rather, in- deed, to declare its essential spirituality, its unworld- liness, its otherworldliness. Throughout the NT, spirituality appears as the prevailing characteristic of Christ’s reign. Earthly kingdoms are based upon material power, the power of the sword, the power of wealth, etc, but the basal factor of Christ’s kingdom is righteousness (Mt 5 20; 6 33; Rom 1417; Hel 8, ete). The ruling principle in earthly kingdoms is selfish or sectional or national aggrandizement; in the kingdom of Christ it is truth. Christ is king of truth. “Art thou a king then?” said Pilate. “TI am,’’ said Christ (for that is the force of ‘thou say- est that Iam a king’). “To this end have I been born, and to this end am I come into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth,” and He adds “very one that is of the truth heareth my voice’ (Jn 18 37). Elsewhere He says: “I am the... . truth” (Jn 14 6), and at the head of the armies of heaven He still wears the title “Faithful and True” (Rev 19 11); but if righteousness and truth occupy such a prominent place in His kingdom, it follows that it must be distinguished by its spirituality. His immediate subjects are spiritual men and women; its laws are spiritual; its work is spiritual; all the forces emanating from it, operating through it, centering in it, are spiritual. The Jewish idea of the Messiah’s reign was a narrow national one. For them it meant the glori- fication of the sons of Abraham, the 2. Uni- supremacy of Judaism over all forms versal of faith and all systems of philosophy; the subjection to Jewish sway of the haughty Roman, the cultured Greek and the rude barbarian. The Messiah was to be a greater king than David or Solomon, but still a king after the same sort; much as the limits of the kingdom might extend, it would be but an extension on Jewish lines; others might be admitted to a share in its privileges, but they would have to become natural- ized Jews, or occupy a very subordinate place. The prophetic ideal, however, was a universal kingdom, and that was the conception indorsed and empha- sized by Christ. (For the prophetic ideal such pas- sages may be noted as Pss 2, 22, 72; Isa 11 10; Dnl 7 13.14, etc.) Of course, the predictions have a Jewish coloring, and people who did not apprehend the spirituality might well construe this amiss; but, closely examined, it will be found that the prophets indicate that men’s position in the coming kingdom is to be determined by their relation to the king, and in that we get the preparation for the full NT ideal. The note of universality is very marked in the teaching of Christ. All barriers are to be broken down, and Jews and Gentiles are to share alike in the privileges of the new order. ‘Many shall come from the east and the west, and shall sit down with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, in the kingdom of heaven” (Mt 8 11), and stranger still to the Jewish ear: ‘The sons of the kingdom shall be cast forth into the outer darkness” (Mt 8 12). In the parables of the kingdom (Mt 13), the field, in which is sown the good seed of the kingdom, is the world, and the various other figures give the same idea of unlimited extent. The same thought is suggested by the declaration, ‘‘Other sheep I have, which are not of this fold” (Jn 10 16), also by the confident affirmation: ‘I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto myself’ (Jn 12 32), and so with many other statements of the Gospels. The terms of the commission are enough to show the universal sovereignty which Christ claims over men: “Go ye therefore,’ He says, as possessing all authority in heaven and on earth, “and make disciples of all the nations’ (Mt 28 19), coupled with the royal assurance, ‘‘Ye shall be my witnesses .... unto the uttermost part of the earth” (Acts 1 8). The Book of Acts shows, in the carrying out of the commission, the actual widening of the borders of Christ’s kingdom to include believers of all na- tions. Peter is taught, and announces clearly, the great truth that Gentiles are to be received upon the same terms as the Jews. But through Paul as the apostle of the Gentiles this glorious truth is most fully and jubilantly made known. In the dogmatic teaching of his Epp. he shows that all barriers are broken down, the middle wall of the fence between Jew and Gentile no longer exists. Those who were aliens and strangers are now made nigh in Christ, and “are no more strangers and sojourners, but ye are fellow-citizens with the saints, and of the household of God” (Eph 2 19). That household, that commonwealth, is, in Pauline lan- guage, equivalent to the kingdom, and in the same Ep. he describes the same privileged position as being an “inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God” (5 5). The Saviour’s kingdom cannot be bounded by earthly limits, and all attempts to map it out according to human rules imply a failure to recognize the true Scriptural idea of 1ts universality. (1) Kingdom of grace—of power.—Most of what we have said applies to that phase of Christ’s king- dom which is generally called his kingdom of grace; there is another phase called the kingdom of power. Christ is in a special sense king in Zion, king in His church—that 1s universal in conception and des- tined to be so in reality—but He is also king of the universe. He is “head over all things’; Eph 1 22; Col 1 18, and other passages clearly intimate this. He rules over all. He does so not simply as God, but as God-man, as mediator. It is as me- diator that He has the name above every name; it is as mediator that He sits upon the throne of uni- versal power. (2) Kingdom of glory —There is also the phase of the kingdom of glory. Christ’s reign now is truly glori- ous. The essential spirituality of it implies its glory, for as the spiritual far surpasses the material in value, so the glory of the spiritual far transcends the glory of the material. The glory of worldly pomp, of physical force, of human prowess or genius, must ever pale before the glory of righteousness, truth, spirituality. But Christ’s kingdom is glorious in another sense; it is a heavenly kingdom. It is the kingdom of grace into which saved sinners now enter, but it 1s also the kingdom of heavenly glory, and in it the glorified saints have a place. Entrance into the kingdom of grace in this earthly state secures entrance into the kingdom of glory. _ Right- ly does the church confess: “Thou art the King of Glory, O Christ.” The kingdom is yet to assume an externally glorious form. That is connected with the appearing of Christ (2 Tim 4 1), the glory that shall be revealed, the heavenly kingdom. The kingdom in that stage cannot be entered by flesh and blood (1 Cor 15 50), man in his mortai- ity—but the resurrection change will give the fit- ness, when in the fullest sense the kingdom of this world shall have “become the kingdom of our Lord, and of his Christ” (Rev 11 15). It would be easy to multiply quotations in proof of this. The great passage in Dnl 7 emphatically de- clares it. The echo of this is heard in 3. Eternal the angel’s announcement: ‘“He shall reign over the house of Jacob for ever; and of his kingdom there shall be no end” (Lk 1 33). The reign of 1,000 years which so greatly occupies the thoughts of so many brethren, whatever we may 1805 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA King, Christ as Kingdom of God decide as to its nature, is but an episode in the reign of Christ. Heisreigning now, He shall reign forever. ‘Rev 11 15, above quoted, is often cited as applying to the millennium, but it goes on to say “and he shall reign [not for 1,000 years simply, but] for ever and ever.” So, many of the glowing predictions of the OT, which are often assigned to the millennium, indi- cate no limit, but deal with the enduring and eternal. _ The difficult passage in 1 Cor 15 24-28 must be interpreted in the light of those declarations con- cerning the eternity of Christ’s reign. It is evi- dently as mediator that He delivers up the kingdom to the Father. The dispensation of mediator comes to anend. All has been done according to the pur- pose of redemption. All the ransomed are finally gathered home. He sees of the travail of His soul and is satisfied. Obdurate enemies are subdued. God’s glory has been fully vindicated. The Son becoming subject to the Father, God governs di- rectly and is all in all. But the Son in some sense still reigns and through Him God’s glory will ever shine, while the kingdom eternally rests upon redemption. We may summarize by saying tbat Christ is king of truth, king of salvation (Mt 21 5; Zec 9 9); king of grace; king of peace (Lk 19 38; He 7 2); king of righteousness (He 1 8; 7 2); king of glory (Mt 25 31-34); king eternal; king of saints, king of the ages; king of kings (Rev 19 16). “Upon his head are many diadems’” (Rev 19 12). See also Curist, OrFricEs or. ARCHIBALD M’Caia KING OF THE JEWS: The title applied in mockery of Jesus, and put by Pilate on His cross (Mt 27 29.37 || Mk 16 26, etc). See Jesus Cunist; Kina, CurisT as. KINGDOM OF GOD (OF HEAVEN), THE (h Barttela rSv obpavdv—rod Oeod, hé basileia tin ouranén—tot. theo): I. Meganina anp ORIGIN or THE TERM 1. Place in the Gospels 2. ‘‘ Kingdom of Heaven”’ and ‘“‘ Kingdom of God”’ 3. Relation to the OT (Daniel, etc) II. Irs Use py Jesus—Conrrast wits JEwise Con- CEPTIONS Current Jewish Opinions . Relation of Jesus to Same . Growing Divergence and Contrast . Prophetic Character of the ‘‘ Temptation" Modern ‘Futuristic’ Hypothesis (J. Welss, Schweitzer) Weakness of This View . Positive Conceptions of Jesus III. Tue Ipes in History 1. Apostolic and Post-apostolic Age 2. Early Christian Centuries 3. Reformation Period 4, Later Ideas IV. Pract 1n THEOLOGY 1. Danger of Exaggeration 2. Elements of Living Power in Idea LIvERATURE The “kingdom of God” is one of the most remark- able ideas and phrases of all time, having begun to be used very near the beginnings of history and continuing in force down to the present day. I. Meaning and Origin of the Term.—Its use by Jesus is by far its most interesting aspect; for, in the Gynop uate, at least, it is His 1. Place in watchword, or a comprehensive term the Gospels for the whole of His teaching. Of this the ordinary reader of Scripture may hardly be aware, but it becomes evident and sig- nificant to the student. Thus, in Mt 4 23, the commencement of the ministry is described in these words, “And Jesus went about in all Galilee, teach- ing in their synagogues, and preaching the gospel of the kingdom, and healing all manner of disease and all manner of sickness among the people”; and, somewhat later, in Lk 8 1, the expansion of His activity is described in the following terms, “And No pone it came to pass soon afterwards, that he went about through cities and villages, preaching and bringing the good tidings of the kingdom of God, and with him the twelve.” When the Twelve are sent forth by themselves, the purpose of thcir mission is, in ‘Lk 9 2, given in these words, “And he sent them forth to preach the kingdom of God, and to heal the sick.” In Mt 13 11, the parables, which formed so large and prominent a portion of His teaching, are aenoi ata: collectively ‘the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven”; and it will be remembered how many of these commence with the phrase, ‘“The kingdom of heaven is like.” In these quotations, and in others which might easily be adduced, it will be observed that the phrases “the kingdom,” ‘the king- 2. *King- dom of God,” ‘the kingdom of dom of heaven’? are used interchangeably. Heaven” The last of the three, ‘‘the kingdom of and ‘‘King- heaven,’’ is confined to the First Gos- dom of pel, which does not, however, always God” make use of it; and it is not certain what may have been the reason for the substitution. The simplest explanation would be that heaven is a name for God, as, in the parable of the Prodigal Son, the penitent says, “I have sinned against heaven,’’ and we ourselves might say, “Heaven forbid!’ It is not, however, im- probable that the true meaning has to be learned from two petitions of the Lord’s Prayer, the one of which is epexegetic of the other, ‘“Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven.” Here the disciples are instructed to pray that the kingdom of God may come, but this is equivalent to the petition that the will of God may be done on earth; Jesus is, however, aware of a region in the universe where the will of God is at present being perfectly and universally done, and, for reasons not difficult to surmise, He elevates thither the minds and hearts of those who pray. The kingdom of heaven would thus be so entitled because it is already realized there, and is, through prayer and effort, to be transferred thence to this earth. Although, however, the phrase held this master- position in the teaching of Jesus, it was not of His invention. It was employed before 3. Relation Him by John the Baptist, of whom we to OT read, in Mt 3 1f, “And in those days (Daniel, etc) cometh John the Baptist, preaching in the wilderness of Judaea, saying, Repent ye; for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.” Indeed, the phrase is far older; for, on glancing toward the OT, we come at once, in Dnl 2 44, toa passage where the young prophet, explaining to the monarch the image of gold, silver, iron and clay, which, in his dream, he had seen shattered by “a stone cut out without hands,” interprets it as a succession of world-kingdoms, destined to be de- stroyed by ‘a kingdom of God,” which shall last forever; and, in his famous vision of the “son of man” in 7 14, it is said, “There was given him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all the peoples, nations, and languages should serve him: his dominion is an everlasting dominion, which shall not pass away, and his kingdom that which shall not be destroyed.’ : These passages in Dnl form undoubtedly the roximate source of the phrase; yet the idea which it represents mounts far higher. From the first the Jewish state was governed by laws believed to be derived directly from heaven; and, when the people demanded a king, that they might be like other nations, they were reproached for desiring any king but God Himself. With this sublime con- ception the actual monarchy was only a com- promise, the reigning monarch passing for Jeh’s representative on earth. In David, the man after Kingdom of God THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1806 God’s own heart, the compromise was not unsatis- factory; in Solomon it was still tolerable; but in the majority of the kings of both Judah and Israel it was a dismal and disastrous failure. No wonder that the pious sighed and prayed that Jeh might take to Himself His great power and reign, or that: the prophets predicted the coming of a ruler who would be far nearer to God than the actual kings aud of whose reign there would be no end. Even when the political kingdom perished and the people were carried away into Babylon, the intelligent and truly religious among them did not cease to cherish the old hope, and the very aspect of the world- powers then and subsequently menacing them only widened their conceptions of what that kingdom must be which could overcome them all. The return from Babylon seemed a miraculous confirma- tion of their faith, and it looked as if the day long prayed for were about to dawn. Alas, it proved a day of small things. The era of the Maccabees was only a transitory gleam; in the person of Herod the Great a usurper occupied the throne; and the eagles of the Romans were hovering on the horizon. Still Messianic hopes flourished, and Messianic language filled the mouths of the people. IL Its Use by Jesus—Contrast with Jewish Con- ceptions.—Schiirer, in his History of the Jewish People in the Time of Jesus Christ 1. Current (II, 11, 126 ff), has drawn up a kind Jewish of Messianic creed, in no fewer than Opinions eleven articles, which he believes was extensively diffused at this period. The Sadducees, indeed, had no participation in these dreams, as they would have called them, being absorbed in money-making and courtiership; but the Pharisees cherished them, and the Zealots received their name from the ardor with which they embraced them. The true custodians, however, of these conceptions were the Prosdechomenoi, as they have been called, from what is said of them in the NT, that they “waited for the kingdom of God.” To this class belonged such men as Nicodemus and Joseph of Arimathea (Lk 23 51), but it is in the beginning of the Gospel of Lk that we are intro- duced to its most numerous representatives, in the groups surrounding the infant Baptist and the infant Saviour (Lk 2 25.38); and the truest and amplest expression of their sentiments must be sought in the inspired hymns which rose from them on this occasion. The center of their aspirations, as there depicted, is a kingdom of God—not, how- ever, of worldly splendor and force, but of right- eousness and peace and joy in the Holy Ghost; beginning in humility, and passing to exaltation only through the dark valley of contrition. Baek was the circle in which both the Baptist and Jesus were reared, and it was out of this atmos- phere that the conception of the 2. Relation kingdom of God came into thei: minds. of Jesus It has frequently been said that, in to Same making use of this term, Jesus accom- modated Himself to the opinions and language of His fellow-countrymen; and there is truth in this, because, in order to secure a footing ou the solid earth of history, He had to connect His own activity with the world in which He found Himself. Yct the idea was native to His home and His race, and therefore to Himself; and it is not improbable that He may at first have been un- aware of the wide difference between His own thoughts on the subject and those of His con- temporaries. When, however, He began, in the course of His ministry, to speak of the kingdom of God, it soon became manifest that by Him and by His con- temporaries it was used iu different senses; and this contrast went on increasing until there was a great gulf fixed between Him and them. The difference cannot better be expressed thau by say- ing, as is done by B. Weiss, that He 8. Growing and they laid the accent on different Divergence halves of the phrase, they emphasizing and “the kingdom” and He “of God.” Contrast They were thinking of the expulsion of the Romans, of a Jewish king and court, and of a world-wide dominion going forth from Mt. Zion; He was thinking of righteousness, holiness and peace, of the doing of the will of God on earth as it is done in heaven. So earthly and fantastic were the expectations of the Jewish multitude that He had to escape from their hands when they tried to take Him by force and make Him a king. The authorities never acknowledged the pretensions of One who seemed to them a religious dreamer, and, as they clung to their own conceptions, they grew more and more bitter against One who was turning the most cherished hopes of a nation into ridicule, besides threatening to bring down on them the heavy band of the Roman. And at last they settled the controversy between Him and them by nailing Him to a tree. At one time Jesus had felt the glamor of the popular Messianic ideas, and at all times He must have been under temptation to accom- 4. Prophetic modate His own ideas to the prej- Character udices of those on whose favor His of the success seemed to be dependent. The “Temp- struggle of His mind and will with such tation” solicitations is embodied in what is called the Temptation in the Wilder- ness (Mt 4 1-11). There He was tempted to accept the dominion of the world at the price of compromise with evil; to be a bread-king, giving panem et circenses; and to curry favor with the multitude by some display, like springing from the pinnacle of the temple. The incidents of this scene look like representative samples of a long experience; but they are placed before the commencement of His publie activity in order to show that. He had already overcome them; and throughout His min- istry He may be said to have been continually de- claring, as He did in so many words at its close, that His kingdom was not of this world.. It is very strange that, in spite of this, He should be believed, even by Christian scholars, to have held a purely futuristic and apocalyptic view 5. Modern of the kingdom Himself. He was all the “Puturistic” time expecting, it is said, that the heavens ‘“ would open and the kingdom descend from Hypothesis heaven to earth, a pure and perfect work Gg: Weiss, of God. This is exactly what was ex- Schweitzer) pected by_the Jewish multitude, as is Zz stated in Lk 19 11; and it is precisely sy et what the authorities believed Him to be anticipating. The controversy between Him and them was as to whether Jeh would intervene on His behalf or not; and, when no intervention took place, they be- lieved they were justified in condemning Him. The premises being conceded, it is difficult to deny the force of their argument. If Jesus was all the time looking out for an appearance from heaven which never arrived, what better was He than a dreamer of the ghetto? ‘ It was by Johannes Weiss that this hypothesis was started in recent times; and it has been worked out by Schweitzer as the final issue of modern 6. Weak- = speculation on the life of Christ (see his ness of LS ihe teeta) Heese But in tidy osition to it can be quoted not a few This View sayings of Jesus which indicate that, in His view, the kingdom of God had al- ready begun and was making progress during His earthly ministry, and that it was destined to make progress not hy catastrophic and apocalyptic interference with the course of Providence, but, as the grain grows— first the blade, then the ear, after that the full corn in the ear (Mk 4 26-29). Of such sayings the most remarkable is Lk 17 201, ‘And being asked by the Phar- isees, when the kingdom of God cometh, he answered them and said, The kingdom of God cometh not with observation: neither shall they say, Lo, here! or, Theret for lo, the kingdom of God is within you."’ _‘'Observa- tion,” in this quotation, is an astronomical term, de- noting exactly such a manifestation in the physical 1807 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kingdom of God heavens as Jesus is assumed to have been looking for; so that He denies in so many words the expectation attributed to Him by those representatives of modern scholarship. In the nature of the case the kingdom must have been growing from stage to stage during His earthly ae ministry. He Himself was there, 7. Positive embodying the kingdom in His person; Conceptions and the circle gathered around Him of Jesus partook of the blessings of the king- dom. This circle might have grown large enough to be coextensive with the country; and, therefore, Jesus retained the consciousness of being the Messiah, and offered Himself in this char- acter to His fellow-countrymen by the triumphal entry into Jerus. But the citizens of the kingdom had to enter it one by one, not in a body, as the Jews were expccting. Strait was the gate; it was the narrow gate of repentance. Jesus began by repeating the initial word of the teaching of His forerunner; and He had too much reason to con- tinue repeating it, as the hypocrisy and worldliness of Pharisees and Sadducees called for denunciation from His lips. To the frailties of the publicans -and sinners, on the contrary, He showed a strange mildness; but this was because He knew the way of bringing such sinners to His feet to confess their sins themselves. To .the penitent He granted pardon, claiming that the Son of man had power on earth to forgive sins. Then followed the expo- sition of righteousness, of which the Sermon on the Mount is a perfect specimen. Yet it commences with another watchword—that of blessedness, the ingredients of which are set forth in all their com- prehensiveness. In the same way, in other pas- sages, He promises “rest,” ‘‘peace,’”’ and the like; and again and again, where He might be expected to employ the term “kingdom of God,” He substi- tutes “life” or “eternal life.’ Such were the blessings He had come into the world to bestow; and the most comprehensive designation for them all was “the kingdom of God.” It is true, there was always imperfection attach- ing to the kingdom as realized in His lifetime, be- cause He Himself was not yet made perfect. Stead- ily, from the commencement of the last stage of His career, He began to speak of His own dying and rising again. ‘To those nearest Him such language was at the time a total mystery; but the day came when His apostles were able to speak of His death and ascension as the crown and glory of His whole career. When His life seemed to be plunging over the precipice, its course was so diverted by the rovidence of God that, by dying, He became the edeemer of mankind and, by missing the throne of the Jews, attained to that of the universe, be- coming King of kings and Lord of lords. UL The Idea in History.—After the death of Jesus, there soon ensued the destruction of the Jew- ish state; and then Christianity went 1. Apos- forth among the nations, where to tolic and _— have spoken of it as a kingdom of God Post-apos- would have unnecessarily provoked tolic Age hostility and ealled forth the accusa- tion of treason against the powers that be. Hence it made use of other names and let “the kingdom of God” drop. This had commenced even in Holy Scripture, where, in the later books, there is a growing infrequency in the use of the term. This may be alleged as proof that Jesus was being forgotten; but it may only prove that Christianity was then too much alive to be trammeled with words and phrases, even those of the Master, being able at every stage to find new language to express its new experience. In the early Christian centuries, “the kingdom of God” was used to designate heaven itself, in which from the first the development of the kingdom was to issue; this, in fact, being not infrequently the meaning of the phrase even in the 2. Early mouth of Jesus. The Alexandrian Christian thinkers brought back the phrase to Centuries designate the rule of God in the con- science of men. St. Augustine’s great work bears a title, De Civiiate Dei, which is a tr of our phrase; and to him the kingdom of God was the ehurch, while the world outside of the church was the kingdom of Satan. From the time of Charle- magne there were in the world, side by side, two powers, that of the emperor and that of the pope; and the history of the Middle Ages is the account ot the conflict of these two for predominance, each pre- tending to struggle in the name of God. The ap- proaching termination of this conflict may be seen ‘in Wycliffe’s great work De Dominio Diino, this title also being a tr of our phrase. During the struggles of the Reformation the battles of the faith were fought out under other watchwords; and it was rather among 3. Refor- such sectaries as the Baptists, that mation names like Fifth Monarchy and Rule Period of the Saints betrayed recollection of the evangelic phraseology; but how near, then and subsequently, the expression of men’s thoughts about authority in church and state came to the language of the Gospels could easily be demonstrated, for example, from the Confessions and Books of Discipline of the Scottish church. The very phrase, “‘the kingdom of God,” re- appeared at the close of the Reformation period among the Pietists of Germany, who, as 4. Later their multiplying benevolent and mis- Ideas sionary activities overflowed the narrow boundaries of the church, as it was then understood, spoke of themselves as working for the kingdom of God, and found this more to their taste than working for the church. The vague and humanitarian aspirations of Rationalism sometimes assumed to themselves the same title; but it was by Ritschl and his followers that the phrase was brought back into the very heart of theology. In the system of Ritschl there are two poles—the love of God and the kingdom of God. The love of God enfolds within itself God’s purpose for the world, to be realized in time; and this progressive realiza- tion is the kingdom of God. It fulfils itself esp. in the faithful discharge of the duties of everyone’s daily vocation and in the recognition that in the course of Providence all things are working together for good to them that love God. IV. Place in Theology.—There are those to whom it appears self-evident that what was the leading phrase in the teaching of Jesus 1. Danger must always be the master-word in of Exag- theology; while others think this to geration be a return from the spinit to the letter. Even Jesus, it may be claimed, had this phrase imposed upon Him quite as much as He chose it for Himself; and to impose it now on theology would be to entangle the movements of Christian thought with the cerements of the dead. . This is an interesting controversy, on both sides of which much might be said. But im the phrase “the kingdom of God” there are ele- 2. Elements ments of living power which can never of Living passaway. (1) It expresses the social Power in side of Christianity. A kingdom im- Idea plies multitude and variety, and, though religion begins with the indi- vidual, it must aim at brotherhood, organization and expansion. (2) It expresses loyalty. However much kings and kingdoms may fail to touch the imagination in an age of the world when many Kingdom of Israel Kings, Books of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1808 countries have become or are becoming republican, the strength to conquer and to endure will always have to be derived from contact with personalities. God is the king of the kingdom of God, and the Son of God is His vicegerent; and without the love of God the Father and the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ no progress can be made with the Christian- ization of the world. (3) It keeps alive the truth, suggested by Jesus in the Lord’s Prayer, that the doing of the will of God on earth is the one thing needful. This is the true end of all authority in both church and state, and behind all efforts thus directed there is at work the potency of heaven. (4) It reminds al] generations of men that their true home and destiny is heaven. In not a few of Our Lord’s own sayings, as has been remarked, our phrase is obviously only a name for heaven; and, while His aim was that the kingdom should be es- tablished on earth, He always promised to those aiding in its establishment in this world that their efforts would be rewarded in the world to come. The constant recognition of a spiritual and eternal world is one of the unfailing marks of genuine Christianity. Lirsraturse.—See the works on NT Theology by Weiss, Beyschlag, Holtzmann, Feine, Schlatter, Weinel, Stevens, Sheldon; and on the Teaching of Jesus by Wendt, Dalman, Bruce; Candlish, The Kingdom of God; Robertson, Regnum Dei; Stalker, The Ethic of Jesus. James STALKER KINGDOM OF ISRAEL. See Israen, Kinc- “DOM OF. KINGDOM OF JUDAH. See Jupau, Kinc- DOM OF. KING’S DALE. See Date, Kine’s. KING’S GARDEN (PaO, gan-ha-melekh) : In Neh 3 15, mention is made of ‘‘the pool of Shelah by the king’s garden”; in 2 K 26 4; Jer 52 7, “All the men of war fled by night by the way of the gate between the two walls, which was by the king’s garden’; see also Jer 39 4. The “king’s winepresses” (Zec 14 10), which must have been to the extreme S. of the city, were clearly in this neighborhood. The references all point to the one situation in Jerus where it is possible for gardens to flourish all the year round, namely, the part of the Kidron valley below the Tyropoeon which is watered by the overflow from the Pool of Siloam (see Sinoam). Here the vegetable gardens of the peasants of Siloam present an aspect of green fresh- ness unknown elsewhere in Jerus. E. W. G. Masrerman KING’S MOTHER: The queen-dowager occu- pied a very important position at the court of the kings of Israel, e.g. Bathsheba (1 K 2 19); Maacah (15 13); Athaliah (2 Ch 22 2); and Ne- hushta (2 K 24 8; Jer 13 18). See Queen; QUEEN MorTHER. KING’S POOL (428 MIR, berékhath ha- melekh): This is possibly the Pool of Siloam (Neh 2 14), and may have been so named as being near to the “king’s garden.” KING’S VALE (72 py, ‘émek ha-melekh; LXX in Gen reads 6 pedion [‘‘the plain’’] basilé6s, in 2 8, hé koilds [‘‘valley’”’] tou basiléis; AV King's Dale): The place where the king of Sodom met Abram (Gen 14 17), and the situation of Absalom’s monument (2 § 18 18). It was identical with the Vale of Shaveh, and was evidently near Salem, the city of Melchizedek (Gen 14 17). If Sate (q.v.) is Jerus, then Absalom’s pillar was also near that city, Jos writes (Ant, VII, x, 3), “Absalom had erected for himself a marble pillar in the king’s dale, two furlongs [stadia] from Jerus, which he named Absalom’s Hand.” In all probability this “pillar” was a rough upright stone—a maccébhah—but its site is lost. The traditional Gr-Egyp tomb of perhaps 100-200 years BC which has been hewn out of the rock on the eastern side of the Kidron valley is manifestly misnamed “Absalom’s pillar,’ and the Kidron ravine (mahal) cannot be the King’s Vale (‘émek). E. W. G. MasterMan KINGS, BOOKS OF: I. Titte II. Scorr TIY. Craracter or Booxs anp Position in Hesrew Canon 1. Purpose 2. Character of Data IV. Historicau Vauus 1. Treatment of Historical Data 2. Chronology 3. Value of Assyrian Records 4, Plan V. Composition 1. Nature of the Books 2. Sources 3. Kent's Scheme 4. Jand E VI. Dats LITERATURE I, Title—The Heb titlereads, D°D2, mlakhim, “kings,’”’ the division into books being based on the LXX where the Books of Kings are numbered 3d and 4th, the Books of Kingdoms (BactAcwy», Basileton) the Books of Samuel being numbered respectively 1st and 2d. Theseparation in the Heb into 2 Books of Kings dates to the rabbinic Bible of Daniel Bomberg (Venice, 1516-17), who adds in a footnote, “Here the non-Jews [i.e. Christians] begin the 4th Book of Kings.” The Heb Canon treats the 2 Books of S as one book, and the 2 Books of K as one. Hence both AV and RV read incor- rectly, ‘The First Book of Kings,” even the use of the article being superfluous. Hl. Scope.—The Books of K contain 47 chs (I, 22 chs; II, 25 chs), and cover the period from the conspiracy of Adonijah and the accession of Solomon (975 BC) to the liberation of Jehoiachin after the beginning of the Exile (561 BC). The subject-matter may be grouped under certain heads, as the last days of David (1 K 1—2 11); Solomon and his times (1 K 2 12—11 43); the Northern Kingdom to the coming of Assyria (1 K 12 16— 2 K 17 41) (937-722 BC), including 9 dynastic changes; the Southern Kingdom to the coming of Babylon (1 K 12 1—2 K 26 21, the annals of the two kingdoms being given as || records until the fall of Israel) (937-586 BC), during which time but one dynasty, that of David, occupied the throne; the period of exile to 561 BC (2 K 25 22-30). A simpler outline, that of Driver, would be: (1) Solo- mon and his times (1 K 1-11); (2) Israel and Judah to the fall of Israel (1 K 12—2 K 17); Judah to the fall of Jerus (586 BC), and the captivity to the liberation of Jehoiachin (561 BC) (2 18-25). “Above all, there are th feat i i which, in the mind of the patho: a bi prima pores as shown by the prominence he gives ther in his narra- tive. (1) The dynasty of David is invested with pe- culiar dignity. his had two aspects. It pointed back to the Divine election of the nation in the past, and gave the guaranty of indefinite national perpetuity in the fnture. The promise of ‘the sure mercies of David’ was a powerful uniting influence in the Exile. (2) The Temple and Its service, for which the writer had such special regard, contributed greatly to the phase of na- tional character of snbseqnent times. ‘With all the draw- backs and defacements of pure worship here was the stated regular performance of sacred rites, the develop- ment and regulation of priestly order and ritual law which stamped themselves so firmly on later Judaism. (3) Above all, this was the period of bloom of OT prophecy. Though more is said of men like Elijah and ilisha, who have left no written words, we must not 1809 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kingdom of Israel Kings, Books of forget the desires of preéxiiian prophets, whose writings have come down to us—men who, against the opposi- tion of rulers and the indifference of the people, testi- fied to the morai foundation on which the nation was con- stituted, vindicated Divine righteousness, rebuked sin, and held up the ideal to which the nation was called.”— Robertson, Temple BD, 369 f. Ill. Character of Books and Position in Hebrew Canon.—The Books of K contain much historical material, yet the historical is not their primary purpose. What in our Eng. Bibles pass for his- torical books are in the Heb Canon prophetic books, the Books of Josh, Jgs, 18,2 8,1 Kand2 K being classed as the ‘Earlier Prophets.” The chief aim of these books is didactic, the im- parting of great moral lessons backed up by well- known illustrations from the nation’s 1. Purpose history and from the lives of its heroes and leaders. Accordingly, we have here a sort of historical archipelago, more con- tinuous than in the Pent, yet requiring much bridging over and conjecture in the details. The historical matter includes, in the case of the kings of Israel, the length of the reign and the death; in the ease of the kings of 2. Charac- Judah there are included also the age ter of Data atthe dateof accession, thename of the mother, and mention of the burial. The beginnings of the reigns in each case are dated from a point in the reign of the contemporary ruler, eg. 1 K 16 1: “Now in the 18th year of king Jeroboam the son of Nebat began Abijam to reign over Judah.” IV. Historical Value.—These books contain a large amount of authentic data, and, along with the other books of this group which con- 1. Treat- —stitnte a contemporaneous narrative, ment of Josh, Jgs, 1 8, 2 8, must be accorded Historical high rank among ancient documents. Data To be sure the ethical and religious value is first and highest, nevertheless the historical facts must be reckoned at their true worth. Discrepancies and contradictions are to be explained by the subordination of historical de- tails to the moral and religious purpose of the books, and to the diversity of sources whence these data are taken, that is, the compilers and editors of the Books of K as they now stand were working not for a consistent, continuous historical narrative, but for a great ethical and religious treatise. The his- torical material is only incidental and introduced by way of illustration and confirmation. For the oriental mind these historical examples rather than the rigor of modern logic constitute the nnanswer- able argument. There cannot be as much said relative to the chrono- logical value of the books. Thus, e.g., there is a ques- tion as to the date of the close of Ahaz 2. Chro- reign. According to 2 K 18 10, Samaria nology fell in the 6th year of Hezekiah’s reign. The kings who followed Hezekiah aggre- gate 110 years; 586+4+110+29 (Hezekiah, 2 K 18 2) = 725. But in 2 K 18 13 we learn that Sennacherib’s invasion came in the 14th year of Hezckiah’s reign. Then 701+14=715. With this last agrees the account of Hezekiah's sickness (2 K 20) In explanation of 2 K 18 13, however, it is urged_by some that the writer has subtracted the 15 years of 2 K 20 6 from the 29 years of Hezekiah’s reign. Again, e.g. in 1K 61, we learn that Solomon began to build the temple 430 ears ‘after the children of Israei were come out of the and of Egypt’? (LXX here reads 440 years). This would make between Moses and David 12 generations of 40 years each. Bunt counting the Exodus in the reign of Merenptah, 1225-1215 BC, and the beginning of the erection of the temple 975 BC, or after, we could not make out more than (1225-975) 250 years. Further, if the total length of reigns in Israel and Judah as re- corded in the || accounts of K be added for the two king- doms, the two amounts do not agree. And, again, it is not certain whether in their annals the Hebrews pre- dated or post-dated the reigns of their kings, i.e. whether the year of a king’s death was counted his last year and the ‘first year of his successor’s reign, or whether the following year was counted the first year of the succeed- ing king a Curtis in HDB, I, 400, 1,f; Martiin £B, I, coll. 777 ff). The Babylonians and Assyrians were 3. Value more skilled and more careful chronologers, of Assyrian and it is by reference to their accounts of y. the same or of contemporary events that Records a sure footing isfound. Hence the value of such monuments as those of Shalmaneser IV and Sennacherib—and here mention should be made also of the Moabite Stone. The plan of the books is prevailingly 4, Plan chronological, although at tlmes the ma- —8 15, the Elisha stories). terial is arranged in groups (e.g. 2 K 2 1 V. Composition.—The Books of K are of the nature of a compilation. The compiler has fur- nished a framework into which he has 1. Nature arranged the historical matter drawn of the from other sources. There are chrono- Books logical data, citations of authorities, judgments on the character and deeds of the several rulers, and moral and religious teach- ings drawn from the attitude of the rulers in matters of religion, esp. toward heathen cults. The point of view is that of the prophets of the national party as one against foreign influence. ‘Both in point of view and in phraseology the compiler shows himself to be strongly influenced by Dt.” (The principal editor is styled RD, i.e. Deuteronomic Redactor.) The Deuteronomic Jaw was the touchstone, and by his loyalty to, or apostasy from, that standard, each king stands approved or condemned. This influence also appears in passages where the editor takes liberties in the expansion and adaptation of material. There is marked recurrence of phrases occurring elsewhere chiefly or even wholly in Dt, or in books showing Deuteronomic influence (Bur- ney in HDB, II, 859f). In 2 K 17 we havea test of the nation on the same standards; cf also 1 K 23f; 9 1-9; 2K 146; Dt 24 16. In numerous instances the sources are indicated, as “the book of the acts of Solomon” (1 K 11 41), “the chronicles of the kings of Judah” 2. Sources (1 K 14 29), “the chronicles of the kings of Israel” (1 K 16 31). A score or more of these sources are mentioned by title in the several books of the OT. Thus “the history of Samuel the seer,” “the history of Nathan the prophet,” ‘the history of Gad the seer” (1 Ch 29 29); “the prophecy of Ahijah the Shilonite,” “the visions of Iddo the seer concerning Jeroboam the son of Nebat” (2 Ch 9 29; cf 2 Ch 12 15; 13 22; 20 34; 32 32). Thus the “book of the kings of Israel” is mentioned 17 t (for all kings ex- cept Jehoram and Hoshea); the “book of the chronicles of the kings of Judah” is mentioned 15 t (for all except Ahaziah, Athaliah, Jehoahaz, Je- hoiachin and Zedekiah). Whether the compiler had recourse to the archives themselves or to a work based on the archives is still a question. Kent, Student’s OT (II, chart, and pp. lx-xxvi), gives the following scheme for showing the sonrces: (1) Early stories about the Ark (c 950 3. Kent’s BC or earlier), Saul stories and David Scheme stories (950-900 BC) were united (c 850 BC) to make early Judacan Saul and David stories. With these last were combined (c 600 BC) popular Judaean David stories (c 700 BC), later Ephraimite Samnel narratives (c 650 BC), and very late popular prophetic traditions (650-600 BC) in a first edition of the Books of 8. (2) Annals of Solomon (c 950 BC), early temple records (950-900 BC), were united (c 800 BC) with popular Solomon traditions (850-800 BC) in a ‘ Book of the Acts of Solomon.” A Jeroboam history (900-850 BC), an Ahab history (c 800 BC), and a Jehu history (c 750 BC) were_united with the annals of Israel (after 950 to c 700 BC) in the “Chronicles of the Kings of Israel"? (700 or after), Early Ephraimite Elisha narra- tives (800-750 BC), influenced by_a Samaria cycle of Elisha stories (750-700 BC) and a Gilgal cycle of Elisha stories (700-650 BC), were joined about 600 BC with the ‘Book of the Acts of Solomon” and the “' Chronicles of the Kings of Israel’ in a ‘first edition of the Books of Kings.” Bed (3) The first edition of S, the first edition of K and Kings’ Sepulchres Kiriath-jearim THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1810 Isa, stories (before 550 BC) were united (c 550 BC) ina final revision of S and K. (4) From ‘‘annals of Judah" (before 900 to 650 BC or after), temple records (before 850 to after 650 BC), and a Hezekiah history (c 650 BC), was drawn material for the ‘‘ Chronicles of the kings of Judah’’ (¢c 600 BC). (5) From this last work and the final revision of 8 and K was taken material for a ‘‘Midhrash of the Book of the kings of Israel and Judah" (c 300 BC), and from this work, the final revision of S and K, anda eae temple history (after 400)—itself from the final revision of 8 and K—came the Books of Ch (c 250 BC). The distinctions between the great documents of the Pent do not appear so clearly here. The summary, (“epitome'') is the work of a Jewish re- 4. Jand E dactor; the longer narratives (eg. 1 K F 17—2 K 8; 13 14-21) ‘‘are written in a bright and chaste Heb style, though some of them exhibit slight peculiarities of diction, due, doubtless (in part), to their North Israelitish origin’’ (E). The writers of these narratives are thought to have been prophets, in most cases from the Northern Kingdom. VI. Date.—There are numerous data bearing on the date of K, and indications of different dates appear in the books. The closing verses bring down the history to the 37th year of the Captivity (2 K 25 27); yet the author, incorporating his materials, was apparently not careful to adjust the dates to his own time, asin 1 K 8 8; 12 19; 2 K 8 22; 16 6, which refer to conditions that passed away with the Exile. The work was probably composed before the fall of Jerus (586 BC), and was revised during or shortly after the Exile, and also supplemented by the addition of the account of the downfall of the Judacan kingdom. There are traces of a post-exilic hand, as, e.g., the mention of “the cities of Samaria” (1 K 18 32), implymg that Samaria was a province, which was not the case until after the Exile. The existence of altars over the land (1 K 19 10), and the sanctuary at Carmel, were illegal according to the Deuteronomic law, as also was the advice given to Elisha (2 K 3 19) to cut down the fruit trees in time of war (Dt 20 19). Lirerators.—K. Budde, Das Buch der Richter, Mohr, Leipzig; John Skinner, ‘‘Kings,'’ in New Century Bible, Frowde, New York; C. F. Burney, Notes on the Heb Text of the Books of K, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1903; R. Kittel, Die Bicher der Kénige, Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, Leipzig, 1900; I. Benzinger, Die Bucher .der Kénige, Mohr, 1899; C. F. Kent, Student's OT, Scribner, 1905; S. R. Driver, Intro io the Lit. of the OT, Scribner, new rev. ed, 1910; J. E. McFadyen, Jntro to the OT, Armstrong, New York, 1906; Carl H. Cornill, Einleitung in die kanonischen Bicher AT, Mohr, 6th ed, 1908; A. F. Kirkpatrick, The Divine Library of the OT, Macmillan, 1891. Wa iace N. STearns- KINGS’ SEPULCHRES (2 Ch 21 20). See Jeru- saLem, VIII. KINSFOLK, kinz’fok. See Kinprep. KINSMAN, kinz’man, KINSWOMAN, kinz’- woom-an: Most frequently of the xh, goal, the one who had a right to “redeem”; referring to the custom of avenging the blood of a slain kinsman; hence, a blood relative (Nu 5 8; Ruth 2 20; 3 9.12; 4 1.3.6.8.14; cf “performing the part of a kinsman,” Ruth 3 13); in Ruth 2 1, better ren- dered “‘acquaintance.” Also AAP, kardbh, one near, rendered “kinsman” (Ps, 38 11); probably better, ‘neighbor.’ Once, INW, sh’ér, “flesh kin,” ren- dered “kinsman” (Nu 27 11; cf Lev 18 6; 25 49; 20 19; 21 2, rendered “‘kin’’). scuyyevis, suggenés, “of same race”’ (cf cvyyévera, suggéneia, “kindred”’), used of blood relationship of varying degrees of nearness (Lk 14 12; Jn 18 26; Acts 10 24; Rom 9 3; 16 7.11.21). Rendered “kin” in Mk 6 4, Kinswoman: “NW, sh°’ér, “kin by blood,” or “by flesh” (cf above; also Lev 18 121; also ef 18 6, “near of kin” AV); also same root,’ fem. form, MIND, sha’drah (Lev 18 17), is tra “kinswoman.” In Prov 7 4, “Call understanding thy kinswoman”’ might be more accurately rendered, “thy familiar friend,” RVm (from 9714, médha', acquaintance”); ef similar rendering of méddha‘ath, under KinpRED. Lk 1 36 RV, “kinswoman” (cvyyevls, suggenis), AV “cousin” (suggenés); same is rendered ‘‘kins- folk” (1 58 RV). Epwarp Bacsy PoLLARD KIR, ktir, kir (WP, bir): The meaning of Kir is “ineclosure” or ‘walled place,’’ and it is therefore doubtful whether it is a place-name 1. Meaning in the true sense of the word. In2 K 16 9 it is mentioned as the place whither Tiglath-pileser IV carried the Syrian (Aramaean) captives which he deported from Damascus after he had taken that city. In Am 1 5 the prophet announces that the people of Syria (Aram) shall go into captivity unto Kir, and in 9 7 it is again referred to as the place whence the Lord had brought the Syrians (Aramaeans) as Israel had been brought out of Egypt, and the Philis from Caphtor. Except in one MS (LXX, A), where it appears as the Libyan Cyrene (2 K 16 9), it is never ren- dered in the LXX as a place-name. 2. How Thus the place whence the Syrians Rendered were brought (Am 9 7) is not Ki, in LXX but “the deep” or “the ditch” (LXX éx BéGpov, ek béthrou, ‘“pit’’), probably a tr of some variant rather than of the word ‘Kir’ itself. Comparing the Assyr-Bab kiru (for gtru), “wall,” “inclosure,” ‘“nterior,’’ or the like, Kir might have the general meaning of a place parted off for the reception of exiled captives. Parallels would be Kir Moab, ‘‘the inclosure of Moab,” Kir Heres or Kir Hareseth, “the inclosure of brick” (LXX hoi lithoi tov totchou). It seems probable that there was more than one place to which the Assyrians transported captives or exiles, and if their practice was to place them as far as they could from their native land, one would expect, for Palestinian exiles, a site or sites on the eastern side of the Tigris and Euphrates. In Isa 22 5 occurs the phrase, ‘‘a breaking down. of the walls, and a crying to the mountains” (mkar- kar ktr w*-sh6“* el ha-hdr—‘‘asurround- 3. An ing of the wall,” ete, would be better), Emendation and the mention of kir and shd«* here of Isa 22:5 has caused Fried. Delitzsch to suggest that we have to read, instead of kir, ko‘, combined with sho“, asin Ezk 23 23. Follow- ing this, but retaining ir, Cheyne translates ‘(Kir undermineth, and Shoa‘ is at the mount,’’ but others accept Delitzsch’s emendation, Winckler conjectur- ing that the rendering should be “Who stirreth up Koa‘ and Shoa‘ against the mountain” (Alitest. Untersuchungen, 177). In the next verse (Isa 22 6) Kir is mentioned with Elam—a position which a city for western exiles would require. The mention of Elam as taking the quiver, and Kir as uncovering the shield, apparently against 4. Soldiers (the valley of the vision” (in or close Paar to Jerus), implies that soldiers from of Kir in A these two places, though one might fa expect them to be hostile to the As- : : _Syrians in general, were to be found in their armies, probably as mercenaries. See Fried. Delitzsch, Wo tag das Paradies? 233; Schrader, COT, 425. T. G. Princess KIR OF MOAB (A874 “Pp, kir ma’abh; LXX has 76 teiyos, i6 teichos, ‘the wall,” “fortress”): The _ ame, at least in this form, appears 1. Identi- only once (Isa 15 1) as that of a city fication in Moab. It is named with Ar of R ; _ Moab, with which possibly it may be identical, since ‘ar or ‘ir is the Heb equivalent of 1811 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Sings’ Sepulchres Kiriath-jearim the Moabite Kir. The Tg hence reads ‘‘Kerak in Moab.” ‘There can be no doubt that the Kerak here intended is represented by the modern town of that name, with which, consequently, Kir Moab is almost universally identified. It must always have been a place of importance. It is mentioned as Charakméba (XapaxuoBa) in the Acts of the Council of Jerus (586 AD) and by the early geog- raphers. It dominated the great caravan road connecting Syria with Egypt and Arabia. The Crusaders therefore directed attention to it, and held possession from 1167 till it fell again into the hands of the Moslems under Saladin, 1188. The Chroniclers speak of it as in el Belka, and the chief city of Arabia Secunda. Under the title of Petra Deserti the Crusaders founded here a bishop’s see. The Gr bishop of Petra still has his seat in Kerak. ‘Kerak stands upon a lofty spur projecting west- ward from the Moab platean, with Wady ‘Ain Franjy on the 8., and Wady el-Kerak 2. Descrip- on the N., about 10 miles from the tion Dead Sea. The sides of the mountain sink sharply into these deep ravines, which unite immediately to the W., and, as Wady _ el-Kerak, the great hollow runs northwestward to the sea. It is a position of great natural strength, being connected with the uplands to the E. only by anarrow neck. It is 3,370 ft. above the level of the sea. The mountains beyond the adjacent valleys are much higher. The place was surrounded by a strong wall, with five towers, which can still be traced in its whole length. The most northerly tower is well preserved. The most interesting build- ing at Kerak is the huge castle on the southern side. It is separated from the adjoining hill on the right by a large artificial moat; and itis provided with a reservoir. A moat also skirts the northern side of the fortress, and on the E. the wall has a sloped or battered base. The castle is then separated from the town. The walls are very thick, and are well preserved. Beneath the castle is a chapel in which traces of frescoes are still visible. In days of an- cient warfare the place must have been practically impregnable. It could be entered only by two roads passing through rock-cut tunnels. The main danger must always have been failure of water supply. There are springs immediately outside the city; but those alone would not be sufficient. Great cisterns were therefore constructed in the town and also in the castle. The half-nomadic inhabit- ants of Kerak today number some 1,140 families (Musil, Arabia Petraea, III, 97). The Gr church claims about 2,000 souls; the rest are Moslems. They are wild and fearless people, not greatly in- clined to treat strangers with courtesy and kindness. In the spring of 1911 the town was the center of a rising against the government, which was not quelled until much blood had been shed. W. Ewine KIRAMA, ki-ra’ma, kir’a-ma (Kipapé, Kiramd; AV Cirama): The people of K. returned with Zerubbabel from Babylon (1 Esd 6 20); the “Ramah” of Ezr 2 26 (q.v.). KIR-HARESETH, kér-har’&seth, -ha-ré’seth (MBWITVP , kir-hdreseth, Isa 16 7; in 2 K 3 25 AV reads Kir-haraseth [pausal form]); KIR-HERES (WY VP, kir heres, Jer 48 31.36; in Isa 16 11 AV yeads Kir-haresh [pausal form]): Modern scholars unanimously identify this city with Kir of Moab. In Jehoram’s invasion of Moab it alone withstood his attack; and on the city wall the king of Moab sacrificed his son (2 K 3 25 ff). It was obviously the capital, ie. Kir Moab. The name ig generally taken to mean “city of the sun.” Cheyne, however, points out (ZB, s.v.): (1) that this explanation was unknown to the ancients; (2) that ‘‘kir” is nowhere supposed to mean “‘city,”’ except in the compound names Kir-heres, Kir- hareseth, and Kir Moab; (8) that heres, “sun,”’ nowhere has a fem. ending, and (4) that Isa 16 7 (LXX and Aq.) indicates d and not r in the second part of the name (Aéceé, Déseth). He suggests, therefore, that we should possibly read NWN Np, kiryath hddhashah, “new city.” W. Ewine KIRIATH, kir’i-ath (O74P, kiryath, “city”; AV Kirjath): Mentioned (Josh 18 28) as a city of Benjamin; has been identified with Kuriet el ‘Enab, “town of grapes,” a prosperous town on the highroad between Jerus and Jaffa; it is sometimes spoken of by the inhabitants as Kurieh. It is, however, generally thought that Kiriath here stands for Kirrara-sEarm (q.v.). See PHF, III, 132, Sh XVII. KIRIATHAIM, kir-i-a-tha’‘im (ODP, kirya- thayim, “two cities”; AV Kirjathaim): (1) A city in the uplands of Moab formerly held by Sihon, and given by Moses to Renben, who is . said to have fortified it (Nu 32 87; Josh 13 19). It is named along with Elealeh and Nebo in the former passage, and with Sibmah in the latter. It was in the hands of Moab in Mesha’s time, and he claims to have fortified it (M§,1.10). For Jeremiah (48 1.23) and Ezekiel (25 9) it is a Moabite town. Onom identifies it with Coraitha, a Christian vil- lage 10 Rom miles W. of Madeba. This is the modern Karaiyaét, about 11 miles W. of Madeba, and 5 miles E. of Machaerus. This, however, may represent Kerioth, while the towns with which it is named would lead us to look for Kiriathaim to the N. of Wady Zerka Ma‘in. From this city was named Shaveb-kiriathaim, “the plain of Kiria- thaim” (Gen 14 5). (2) A city in the territory of Naphtali, assigned to the Gershonite Levites (1 Ch 6 76), correspond- ing to “Kartan” in Josh 21 32. W. Ewinae KIRIATH-ARBA, kir-i-ath-ir’ba. See Hzesron. KIRIATH-ARIM, kir-i-ath-a’rim (Ezr 2 25). See KiniaTH-JEARIM. KIRIATH-BAAL, kir-i-ath-ba’al. JEARIM. See Krrrata- KIRIATH-HUZOTH, kir-i-ath-hi’zoth, k.-hi’ 26th (Mz np, kiryath hugoth, “city of streets”; LXX reads modes erratrewv, péleis epailedn, “city of villages,” from which we may infer a reading MEN, hdcérath, for TEN, hucdth; AV Kirjath- huzoth): A place to which, after their meeting, Balak and Balaam went together (Nu 22 39). They met at “the City of Moab” (ver 36), which is probably identical with Kir or Moas (q.v.); Kiriath-huzoth was probably therefore not far from that city. Some would identify it with Kiriathaim; some with Kerioth; as yet there is no certainty. KIRIATH-JEARIM,, kir-i-ath-jé’a-rim, k.-jé-a/rim (BMT NM DP, kryath-y“arim, “city of thickets” ; LXX 4 més "Iapelp, he pdlis Iareim; AV Kirjath- jearim): One of the four chief cities of the Gibeon- ites (Josh 9 17); a city of Judah (Josh 16 60), evidently an ancient Sem “high place,” hence the name ‘‘Kiriath-Baal” (ib); it was one of the places on the border line between Judah and Benjamin (Josh_18 14.15; 15 11 [where it is called ‘“Baalah’’]; ef 1 Ch 13 6). It is mentioned as in Judah (Josh 15 60; 18 14; Jgs 18 12), but if Kiriara (q.v.) Kiriath Kiss is identical with it, it is mentioned as belonging to Benjamin (Josh 18 28; in 2 8 6 2, Baale-judah). Jgs 18 12 records that the men of Dan set forth out of Zorah and Eshtaol and encamped in Mahan- eh-dan behind (W. of) Kiriath-jearim. 1. Scrip- (InJgs 18 25 Mahaneh-dan [“thecam ture Refer- of Dan’’] is described as between Zora ences and Eshtaol; see MAHANEH-DAN.) To this sanctuary the ark of Jeh was brought from Beth-shemesh by the people of Kiriath- jearim, and they “brought it into the house of Ruined Church at Kuriet. Abinadab in the hill [m ‘‘Gibeah’’], and sanctified Eleazar his son to keep the ark of Jeh” (1 S 7 1). Here it abode twenty years (ver 2; 2 S 6 2-4; cil Ch 13 6; 2 Ch 14). Clearly it was in the hills somewhere to the E. of Beth-shemesh. The prophet Uriah-ben-Shemaiah, killed by Jehoi- akim, belonged to Kiriath-jearim (Jer 26 20f). In Ezr 2 25 (cf Neh 7 29), this place occurs under the name “‘Kiriath-arim.” In 1 Esd 5 19 the name occurs as “Kiriathiarius.”’ The exact position of this important Israelite sanctuary has never been satisfactorily settled. Some of the data appear to be contra- 2. Position dictory. For example, Jos (Ant, VI, i, 4) says it was a city in the neigh- borhood of Beth-shemesh, while Eusebius and Jerome (Onom) speak of it (“Cariathiareim’’) in their day as a village 9 or 10 miles from Jerus on the way to Lydda. But it is open to doubt whether the reputed site of their day had any serious claims. Any suggested site should fulfil the following condi- tions: (1) It must harmonize with the boundary line of Judah and Benjamin between two known points—the ‘‘waters of Nephtoah,” very generally supposed to be Lifta, and Chesalon, certainly Keslé (Josh 16 10). (2) It should not be too far removed from the other cities of the Gibeonites— Gibeon, Chephirah and Beeroth—but those places, which are all identified, are themselves fairly widely apart. (3) Mahaneh-dan (‘‘the camp of Dan’’) is described as between Zorah and Eshtaol, and was W. of Kiriath-jearim; this, and the statement of Jos that it was in the neighborhood of Beth- shemesh, makes it probable that the site was near the western edge of the mountains of Judah. Zorah (now Sara‘), Eshtaol (now Esha‘a) and Beth- shemesh (now ‘Ain Shems), are all within sight of each other close to the Vale of Sorek. (4) The site should be a sanctuary (or show signs of having been such), and be at least on a height (Gibeah, 1 S 7 im). (5) The name may help us, but it is as well to note that the first part of the name, in the form “Kirathiarius” (1 Esd 5 19), appears to have sur- vived the exile rather than the second. The first suggested identification was that of Robinson (BR, II, 11,12), viz. Kuriet el ‘Enab, the “town of grapes,” a flourishing little town about 9 miles W. of Jerus on the carriage road to Jaffa. The district around is still fairly well wooded (cf “Jearim THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1812 y*drim=“‘thickets”). This village is commonly known as Abu Ghésh, from the name of a robber chieftain who, with his family, flour- 3. Sug- ished there in the first half of the last gested century. Mediaeval ecclesiastical tra- Identifi- dition has made this place the Anathoth cations of Jer, and ahandsome church from the time of the Crusades, now thoroughly repaired, exists here to mark this tradition. This site suits well as regards the border line, and the name Kuriet is the exact equivalent of Kiriath 3 it also fits in with the distance and direction given in the Onom, but it cannot be called satisfactory in all respects. Séba, in the neighborhood, has, on account of its commanding position, been selected, but except for this one feature it has no special claims. The late Colonel Conder has very vigor- ously advocated the claims of a site he discovered on the south side of the rugged Wady Ismae‘n, called Khurbet ‘Erma, pointing out truly that ‘Erma is the exact equivalent of ‘Arim (Ezr 2 25), Un- fortunately the 2d part of the name would appear from the references in 1 Esd and in Onom to be that part which was forgotten long ago, so that the argument even of the philological—the strongest— grounds cannot be of much value. The greatest objections in the minds of most students are the unsuitability of the position to the requirements of the Judah-Benjamin frontier and its distance from the other Gibeonite cities. The present writer suggests another site which, in his opinion, meets at least some of the require- ments better than the older proposals. Standing on the hill of Beth-shemesh and looking N.W., with the cities of Zorah (Sur‘ah) and Eshtaol (Eshi’a) full in view, a lofty hill crowned by a considerable forest catches the eye. The village a little below the summit is called Beit Mahsir, and the hilltop itself is the shrine of a local saint known as Sheikh el Ajam. So “‘holy” is the site, that no trees in this spot are ever cut, nor is fallen brushwood removed. There is a Wely or sanctuary of the saint, and round about are scores of very curious and appar- ently ancient graves. Southward from this site the eye follows the line of Judaean hills—probably the Mt. Jearim of Josh 15 10—until it strikes the outstanding point of Keslé (Chesalon), some 2 miles to the S. If the ark was taken here, the people of Beth-shemesh could have followed its progress almost the whole way to its new abode. Although the name, which appears to mean “‘besieged’”’ or “confined,” im no degree helps, in all the other re- spects (see 2 above), this site suits well the condi- tions of Kiriath-jearim. Lirerature.—See PEFS, 1878, 196-99; PEF, III, 43-52; HGHL, 2251; BR, II, 111; Buhl, GAP, Index. E. W. G. Masterman KIRIATH-SANNAH, kir-i-ath-san’a (730 MP, kiryath sannah; AV Kirjath Sannah): In Josh 15 49 it is called ‘‘Debir,” and is identical with Kirrata- SEPHER (q.v.). As 7éds ypauudrwr, pdlis grammd- ton, “city of books,” is the reading in LXX, the most natural explanation is that M50, sanndah, is a copyist’s error for "BO, sépher, but Sayce con- siders this an ancient Can. name meaning “city of instruction,” and that it occurs in the Am Tab in the form “‘Bit’ sani.” KIRIATH-SEPHER, kir-i-ath-se'fér (7DO NP, kiryath spher; tri by many, as if it were Heb, as “house of books.” LXX qwéAts ypappdrwv, pélis grammdion; AV Kirjath Sepher; other suggestions have been made: ‘“‘border-town” [Moore] or “‘toll- town” [G. A. Smith]): In two || passages (Josh 16 15f; Jgs 1 11f), it is mentioned as identical with Desir (q.v.), which has been frequently identified with edh-Dhaheriyeh. Sayce would place 1813 Kiriath-sepher to the W. of Gath. See PEFS, 1893, 33-35. KIRJATH, kir’jath, kir’jath. See Kiriars. KIRJATH-ARBA, kdr-jath-ar'ba, kir-jath-ar’ba. See K1R1aATH-aRBA, KIRJATH-BAAL, kir-jath-ba’al, kir-jath-ba’al. See KrriaTH-JEARIM. KIRJATHAIM, kdr-ja-tha’im, kir-ja-tha’im. See KiriaTHaM. KISEUS, kis-é'us (Kicets, Kisevis; LXX, B (Swete] reads Keisaios; AV Cisai): The great- grandfather of Mordecai (Ad Est 11 2). See Kisu, (5). KISH, kish (W°P, kish; Kls, Kis, Kels, Kets, “bow,” “power”): The name of five persons men- tioned in the Bible: (1) The son of Abiel and the father of Saul, the first king of Israel. He was of the tribe of Benja- min, of the family of the Matrites (1 8 9 1; 14 51; ef Acts 13 21; 1 § 10 21). According to 1 Ch 8 33 and 9 39, “‘Ner begat K.” By reading ‘“Ner begat Abner’ (cf 1S 14 51; 1 Ch 26 28), the difficulty is at least partly overcome. In 1 Ch 12 1, K. is also mentioned as the father of Saul, and again in 2 § 21 14, we are told that the sepulcher of K. was located in the country of Benjamin, in Zela. His place of residence seems to have been at Gibeah. (2) Another K. is mentioned (1 Ch 8 29f; 9 35 f) as the son of Jeiel and his wife Maacah. He is usually supposed to be the uncle of Saul’s father. (3) A Levite, the son of Mahli the Merarite (1 Ch 23 211; cf 24 29). (4) Another Merarite Levite in the time of Heze- kiah (2 Ch 29 12). (5) The great-grandfather of Mordecai, of the tribe of Benjamin (Est 2 5). WILLIAM BAuUR KISHI, kish’t (Wp, kishi, “‘snarer,” ‘“fowler’): Father of Ethan, one of the singers David “set over the service of song’’ in the house of the Lord (1 Ch 6 31); the ‘“Kushaiah” of 1 Ch 15 17 (cf 1 Ch 6 44). KISHION, kish’i-on, kish’yon (JMWP, kishyon): A city in the territory of Issachar (Josh 19 20), given to the Gershonite Levites (21 28; AV wrongly “Kishon”). The || passage in 1 Ch 6 72 reads “Kedesh’’ instead of “Kishion.”” The true reading is probably JIWIP, kidhshon. Conder suggests a likely identification with Tell Aba Kedes, not far from Taanach. KISHON, ki’shon, kish’on (J1W°?, bishon; Keaodév, Keisin): The “watercourse” or ‘torrent stream” along the banks of which the great battle was fought between Israel, led by Deborah and Barak, and the army of Sisera, in the waters of which so many perished (Jgs 4 7, etc). It is probably certo earlier as ‘the brook that_is before Jokneam” (Josh 19 11; see JoxngzaM). It appears again as the scene of Elijah’s slaughter of the prophets of Baal (1 K 18 40). “The torrent” par excellence in the district is the modern el-Mukatia‘, a stream which drains all the plain of Esdraelon to the W. of the watershed—a line drawn from Iksdl to Nain, and thence to el-Fuleh and Zer‘in. All the water E. of this line, from the Nazareth hills, Tabor and Little Hermon, flows down Wddy esh-Sherrar and Nekr Jalad into the Jordan. The Kishon THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA iiath-jearim collects the streams from the western slopes of Gil- boa in the rainy season; and the water from the strong spring at Jenin. Contributions also come from the copious fountains in the neighborhood of Megiddo. At Sa‘adiyeh, again, some 3 miles E. of Haifa, its volume is largely increased by springs rising at the base of Carmel, on the edge of the plain of Acre. From Jenin in the 8.E., the deep torrent bed follows a westerly direction, with numerous windings cutting the plain in two, until it reaches the pass at’the northeastern base of Carmel. Through the gorge between the moun- tain and the hills of Galilee it reaches the plain of Acre. From Sa‘adiyeh it flows in a deep sluggish stream through the marsh-land to the sea near Haifa. In this part the crocodile is said to have been seen at times. In the summer season the water from the springs is largely ahsorbed by irrigation, and the upper reaches of the river are soon dry. The bed runs along the bottom of a trench some 20 ft. deep through the plain. It is easily crossed at the fords by those who know how to avoid the localities of the springs. In time of heavy rains the trench is swiftly filled, and the soft soil of the plain goes to mud. Remembering this, it is easy to understand the disaster that overwhelmed the heavily armed cavalry and chariots of Sisera. The chief ford for long was to the W. of the gorge where the stream issues into the plete of Acre, on the highway from Haifa to Nazareth. ere it is now spanned by a substantial bridge, while the railway crosses a little higher up. At the mouth of the river it is generally easily forded on‘the sand bank thrown up by the waves beating against the current of the stream. The main traffic here is now carried hy a wooden bridge. The phrase nahal k*dhimim in Jgs 6 21 is not easy of interpretation. EV translates, ‘that an- cient river’; G. A. Smith, “torrent of spates”; while others think it may refer to a stream other than the Kishon. Guthe suggests that both names may be derived from those of places adjoining the river. Kishén may possibly mean the “tortuous” stream, referring to the windings of its course. W. Ewine KISLEV, kis'lef (1202, kisléw; AV Chisleu, RV “Chislev’’): The 9th month of the Jewish year, corresponding to December. The word is found in Neh 1 1 and Zec 7 1. The derivation is un- certain. See Catennar. KISS (pW), ndshak; idéw, philéd, naracidréw kataphiléd, pnp, philéma): The kiss is common in eastern lands in salutation, etc, on the cheek, the forehead, the beard, the hands, the feet, but not (in Pal) the lips (Cheyne, EB, s.v. ‘‘Salutations’’). In the Bible there is no sure instance of the kiss in ordinary salutation. Wehave in the OT nashak, ‘to kiss,”’ used (1) of relatives (which seems the origin of the practice of kissing; cf Cant 8 1, “Oh that thou wert as my brother . . . . 1 would kiss thee; yea, and none would despise me”); Gen 27 26.27 (Isaac and Jacob); 29 11 (Jacob and Rachel); 33 4 (Esau and Jacob); 45 15 (Joseph and his brethren); 48 10 (Jacob and Joseph’s sons); 60 1 (Joseph and his father); Ex 4 27 (Aaron and Moses); 18 7 (Moses and Jethro, united with obeisance); Ruth 1 9.14 (Naomi and her daughters-in-law—a fare- well); 2S 14 33 (David and Absalom); 1 K 19 20 (Blisha and his parents—a farewell); see also Gen 29 13; 31 28.55; Tob 76; 10 12. (2) Of friendship and affection; cf 1S 20 41 (David and Jonathan); 28 16 5 (Absalom and those who came to him); 19 39 (David and Barzillai—a fare- well); 20 9 (Joab and Amasa); Prov 27 6 (‘‘the kisses [n’shthah] of an enemy’); 1 Esd 4 47 (“the king stood up, and kissed him”). (3) Of love; cf Cant 1 2, “Let him kiss me with the kisses [nshi- kah] of bis mouth”; Prov 7 13 (of the feigned love of “the strange woman’), (4) Of homage, perhaps; ef 1 S 10 1 Samuel after anointing David king); Kite Know THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1814 Gen 41 40, ‘Unto thy word shall all my people be ruled,’? RVm “order themselves,” or “‘do homage,” AVm “Heb be armed or kiss” (ndshak); Ps 2 12, “Kiss the son” (ARV), ERVm ‘Some versions render, ‘Lay hold of [or receive] instruction’; others, ‘Worship in purity’’’; some ancient VSS give ‘Kiss [or, do homage] purely.’ (5) Of ¢dolatrous practices; cf 1 K 19 18; Hos 18 2 (cf 8 5.6; 10 5); Job 31 27, probably, “kissing the hand to the sun or moon”? (cf vs 26.27). See ApoRaTION. (6) A figurative use may be seen in Ps 85 10; Prov 24 26; Ezk 3 13, where “touched” is ndshak (see AVm). (7) In Ad Est 18 13 we have “I could have been content ... . to kiss the soles of his feet,” and in Ecclus 29 5, “Till he hath received, he will kiss a man’s hands”—marks of self-humiliation or abase- ment. In the NT we have philed, “‘to kiss,” “to be friendly,” and kataphiles, “to kiss thoroughly,” “to be very friendly’’—the first in Mt 26 48; Mk 14 44; Lk 22 47, of the kiss with which Judas betrayed his Master. This was probably meant to be taken as an expression of special regard, which is expressed by the kataphiled of Mt 26 49; Mk 14 45; the same word is used of the woman who kissed the feet of Christ (Lk 7 38.45); of the father’s greeting of the returning prodigal (15 20); and of the farewell to Paul of the Ephesian Christians (Acts 20 37); philéma, “a kiss,” “a mark of friend- ship,’”’ is used by Our Lord as that which Simon omitted to give him (which may refer to ordinary hospitality), but which the woman had bestowed so impressively (Lk 7 45); of the kiss of Judas (Lk 22 48); and of the “holy kiss’? wherewith Christians greeted each other, which, according to the general usage we have seen, would be as the members of one family in the Lord, or as specially united in holy love (Rom 16 16; 1 Cor 16 20; 2 Cor 13 12; 1 Thess 5 26; 1 Pet 56 14). There is reason to believe that, as a rule, men only thus greeted men, and women, women. In the Apos Const (3d cent.) it is so enjoined. W. L. WaLkKErR KITE, kit (TN, ’ayyah; Ucrivos, tktinos; Lat Milvus tetinus or regalis): A medium-sized member of the hawk tribe (see Hawk). This bird is 27 in. long, of bright reddish-brown color, has sharply pointed wings and deeply forked tail. It issupposed to have exceptionally piercing eyes. It takes moles, mice, young game birds, snakes and frogs, as well as carrion for food. Its head and facial expression are unusually eagle-like. It was common over Pal in winter, but bred in the hills of Galilee and rough mountainous places, so it was less conspicu- ous in summer. It is among the lists of abomina- tions (see Lev 11 14 and Dt 14 13). Itis notable that this is the real bird intended by Job to be used as that whose eye could not trace the path to the silver mine: : “That path no bird of prey knoweth, Neither hath the falcon's eye seen it’ (Job 28 7). The word used here in the original Heb is ’ayyah, which was the name for kite. Our first translators used ‘vulture’; our latest efforts give “falcon,” a smaller bird of different markings, not having the kite’s reputation for eyesight. GENE StTRaTTon-PoRTER KITHLISH, kith’lish (W729), kithlish). See. CHITLISH. KITRON, kit’ron (IIOP, kitrén): An unidenti- fied place in Zebulun, not possessed by the tribe (Jgs 1 30). It may be identical with Kattath of Josh 19 15. In the Talm it is identified with Sepphoris, which is represented by the modern village of Seffariyeh. KITTIM, kit’im (O°M3, kittim, Isa 23 12; Jer 210; EMM, kittzyim, apparently pl. of kictt [not found, but cf (4) below]; Kyro, 1. Two Kétioi, Klrwo, Kitiot, Knyrvelp, Ke- Usages of tieim, Jer 210; Xerrielp, Chetiteim, the Name Xertielv, Chetiiein): In Gen 10 4 the word is applied to the descendants of Javan, and indicates, therefore, the Gr-Lat races, whose territory extended along the coasts of the Mediterranean, and included its islands. By the side of Kittim are mentioned Elishah, Tarshish, and Dodanim (=Rodanim of 1 Ch 1 7), generally ex- plained respectively as Sicily with Southern Italy, Spain and Rhodes. In its narrower sense Kittim appears simply to have stood for the island of Cyprus ——it is mentioned between Bashan (=Pal) and the isles of Elishah in Ezk 27 6.7, and with this Isa 23 1.12 agree, Kittim occurring in these passages be- tween Tarshish, Tyre and Sidon. The oldest etymology is apparently that of Jos, who connects Kittim with the well-known old Cypriote city Kition (Citium) (Ant, 2. In Its I, vi, 1), testifying to the settling of Limited the Kittim on the island. This word Sense he further connects with Chethima, from Chethimus, and states that it was on account of Cyprus being the home of those people that all islands were called Chethim by the Heb. The derivation of an ancient Chethim from Chethimus, however, would make the m to be a radical, and this, with the substitution of Ch (= Kh) for K, renders his proposed etymology somewhat doubttul. The statement of Jos, that “all islands, and the greatest part of the sea-coast, are called Chethim [=Kittim] by the Hebrews,” on the 3. InIts other hand, must be taken as the tes- Extended timony of one well acquainted with the Sense opinions of the learned world in his time. In Jer 210 and Ezk 27 6 the isles of Kittim are expressly spoken of, and this confirms the statement of Jos concerning the ex- tended meaning of the name. This would explain its application to the Rom fleet in Dnl 11 30 (so the Vulg), and the Macedonians in 1 Macc 1 1 (Xerrielu, Chetiteim) and 8 5 (Kitians). In the latter passage the Gr writer seems to have been thinking more of the Cyprian Kition than of the Heb Kittim. According to Herodotus (vii.90), Cyprus was colonized from Greece, Phoenicia, and Ethiopia. Referring to the plundering of the 4. Coloniza- temple of Aphrodite at Askalon by tion of the Scythians (1.105), he states that her Cyprus temple in Cyprus was an offshoot from that ancient foundation, as reported by the Cyprians themselves, Phoenicians having founded it at Cythera, on arriving from Syria. The date of the earliest Phoen settlements in Cyprus is unknown, but it has been suggested that they were anterior to the time of Moses. Naturally they brought with them their religion, the worship of the moon-goddess Atargatis (Derceto) being introduced at Paphos, and the Phoen Baal at Kition. If Kition_be, then, a Sem word (from the same root as the Heb Kittim), it has been transferred from the small band of Phoen settlers which it at first desig- nated, to the non-Sem Japhethites of the W. Kition occurs in the Phoen inscriptions of Cyprus under the forms K(i)t(t) and K(z)t(t)t, the latter being by far the more common (CIS, I, 1, 10,11,14,19, etc). _ The early history of Cyprus is uncertain. Accord- ing to the Assyr copy of Sargon of Agade’s omens, that king (about 3800 BC in the opinion of Naboni- dus; 2800 BC in the opinion of many Assyriolo- gists) is said to have crossed ‘‘the sea of the setting sun” (the Mediterranean), though the Bab copy 1815 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kite Know makes it that of “the rising sun’”’—i.e. the Pers Gulf. Be this as it may, General Cesnola discovered at Curium, in Cyprus, a seal-cylinder 5. Its Suc- apparently inscribed ‘‘MAr-Istar, son. cessive of Ilu-bani, servant [worshipper] of Masters N arim-Sin,” the last named being the deified son of Sargon. In the 16th cent. BC, Cyprus was tributary to Thothmes III. About the year 708 BC, Sargon of Assyria received the submission of the kings of the district of Ya’, in Cyprus, and set up at Citium the stele bearing his name, which is now in the Royal Museum at Berlin. Esarhaddon and his son AsSSur-bant-Apli each re- ceived tribute from the 10 Cyprian princes who acknowledged Assyr supremacy. The island was conquered by the Egyp king Amasis, and later formed part of the Pers empire, until the revolt of Evagoras in 410 BC. The Assyrians knew the island under the name of Yad(a)nanu, the ‘‘Wedan” (Vedan) of Ezk 27 19 RV (ayce, PSBA, 1912, 26). If the orthodox date for the composition of Gen be accepted, not only the Phoenicians, but also the Greeks, or a people of Gr-Lat stock, 6. The must have been present in Cyprus, Races before the time of Moses, in sufficient Therein number to make them the predomi- and Their nant portion of the population. As Languages far as can be judged, the Phoenicians occupied only the eastern and southern ortion of the island. Paphos, where they had Built a temple to Ashtoreth and set up an ’dshérah (a pillar symbolizing the goddess), was one of their principal settlements. The rest of the island was apparently occupied by the Aryans, whose presence there caused the name of Kittim to be applied to all the Gr-Lat countries of the Mediterranean. Gr and Phoen were the languages spoken on the island, as was proved by George Smith’s demon- stration of the nature of the non-Phoen text of the inscription of King Melek-yathon of Citium (370 BC). The signs used in the Gr-Cyprian inscrip- tions are practically all syllabic. The many influences which have modified the Cyprian race are reflected in the ancient art, which shows the effect of Bab, Egyp, 7. The Phoen and Gr contacts. Specimens Testimony are to be found in many museums, but of Cyprian the finest collection of examples of Art Cyprian art is undoubtedly that of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. Some of the fulltength figures are life-size, and the better class of work is exceedingly noteworthy. See Cyprus. T. G. Pincuses KNEADING, néd’ing. See Brean, III, 2. KNEE, né, KNEEL, nél (‘‘knec,” 2, berekh; Aram, M278, ‘arkhubbah; yévu, gonu; “kneel”; J2B, barakh; Aram. JR, berakh; yovuwerta, gonupetés): Most of the uses are obvious, and the figurative use of “knees” as the symbol of strength (Job 4 4; He 12 12, etc) needs no explanation. The disease of the knees mentioned in Dt 28 35 is perhaps some form of leprosy. In Job 3 12 the “d:nees” seem to be used for the lap, as the place where a child receives its first care. Three times in Gen the knees appear in connection with primi- tive adoption customs. In 30 3 a fiction is enacted that, purports to represent Rachel as the actual mother of Bilhah’s children. By a somewhat similar rite in 48 12, Jacob (the “‘knees” here are Jacob’s, not Joseph’s) adopts Ephraim and Manas- seh, so that they are counted as two of the twelve patriarchs and not as members of a single Joseph tribe. In the same way Machir’s children are adcpted by Joseph in 50 23, and this is certainly connected with the counting of Machir (instead of Manasseh) as one of the tribes in Jgs 6 14. See Trises; and for the idea underlying this paternal adoption, ef Turco. From among classical instances of the same customs compare Homer, Odyssey, xix. 401 ff, where Autolukos, grandfather of Ulysses, re- ceives the newborn grandchild on his knees and gives him hisname. Thus also we have to under- stand the numerous representations in Egyp sculp- ture, showing the king as an infant on the knees or the lap of a goddess. Kneeling was less commonly an attitude of prayer among the Jews than was standing, but references to kneeling are of course abundant. For kneeling (or prostrating one’s self) before a superior, see ATTITUDE, 2; SALUTATION. Burton Scorr Easton KNIFE, nif: (1) M9979, ma’ dkheleth, lit. an in- strument for eating; but used of large knives for slaying animals, cutting up a carcase or a sacrificial victim (Gen 22 6.10; Jgs 19 29; Prov 30 14). (2) AW, herebh, rendered generally “sword,” but in Josh 5 2.3 of stone knives for circumcision (cf Ex 4 25), probably of similar knives in 1 K 18 28, used by Baal prophets in gashing themselves. In Ezk 6 12 AV, “knife,” probably better RV, Egyptian Stone Knives. Assyrian Bronze Knives. (Brit. Mus.) “sword.”? (3) 2K, ta‘ar, usually rendered “razor,” in combination with \DOM, ha-sdphér, ‘knife of the writer,” or “penknife” (Jer 36 23). (4) Dop>rya, mahdlaphim, “‘slaughter-knives’” (Ezr 19). (5) P2W, sakkin, Aram., “knife” (Prov 23 2). Early knives were commonly made of sharp stones, esp. of flint, later of bronze and iron. The former re- mained in use in religious ceremonies long after the latter were in common use. Knives were not gen- erally used at meals, meats being cut into bits before served, and bread being broken into fragments. Herod used a knife for paring apples, and attempted suicide with the instrument (Jos, Ant, XVII, vii, 1; BJ, I, xxxiii, 7). Epwarp Bacspy PoLLarD KNOCK, nok (kpotw, krovd): The oriental house was fitted with heavy doors which were bolted and locked with wooden keys too large to be carried about, so that even a member of the household could not secure entrance until in response to his knock or call the door should be opened by someone within. At night the delay would be increased by the difficulty of arousing the inmates sleeping within the inner chambers. To persons familiar with such experiences, the words of Jesus concern- ing a higher entrance, “Knock, and it shall be opened unto you” (Mt 7 7; Lk 12 36), would have a unique force not easy for us to appreciate. Russe_L BenyamMin MILLER EKNOP, nop: In Ex 25 31 ff; 37 17 ff (kaphtor), part of the ornaments of the golden candlestick; in 1 K 6 18; 7 24 (p*ka'tm), gourd-like ornaments of the lining of Solomon’s temple, and of the brazen sea (in 1 K 6 18, RVm “‘gourds’’). See Canpiz- stick, GoLDEN; TEMPLE; Sra, Tor Morten. KNOW, né, KNOWLEDGE, nol’ej, nol'ij Gn Heb chiefly 91), yadha‘, noun NYT, datath; in Gr ywaoko, gindskd, of8a, ofda; “to know fully,” Koa Korahites emiywaoke, epigindskd, noun yvaors, gnésis, émlyva- os, epignésis): Knowledge strictly is the appre- hension by the mind of some fact or truth in accord- ance with its real nature; in a personal relation the intellectual act is necessarily conjoied with the element of affection and will (choice, love, favor, or, conversely, repugnance, dislike, etc). Knowledge is distinguished from “‘opinion” by its greater cer- tainty. The mind is constituted with the capacity for knowledge, and the desire to possess and in- crease it. The character of knowledge varies with its object. The senses give knowledge of outward appearances; the intellect connects and reasons about these appearances, and arrives at general laws or truths; moral truth is apprehended through the power inherently possessed by men of dis- tinguishing right and wrong in the light of moral principles; spiritual qualities require for their ap- prehension spiritual sympathy (‘‘They are spiritu- ally judged,” 1 Cor 2 14). The highest knowledge possible to man is the knowledge of God, and while there is that in God’s infinity which transcends man’s power of comprehension (Job 11 7.9), God is knowable in the measure in which He has revealed Himself in creation (Rom 1 19.20, “that which is known of God,” etc), and supremely in Jesus Christ, who alone perfectly knows the Father, and reveals Him to man (Mt 11 27). This knowledge of God in Jesus Christ is “life eternal” (Jn 17 3). Knowl- edge is affirmed of both God and man, but with the wide contrast that God’s knowledge is absolute, unerring, complete, intuitive, embracing all things, past, present, and future, and searching the inmost thoughts of the heart (Ps 139 1.23); whereas man’s is partial, imperfect, relative, gradually acquired, and largely mixed with error (“Now we see in a mirror darkly .. .. in part,” 1 Cor 13 12). All these points about knowledge are amply brought out in the Scripture usage of the terms. A large part of the usage necessarily relates to natural knowledge (sometimes with a carnal connotation, as Gen 4 1.17), but the greatest stress also is laid on the possession of moral and spiritual knowledge (e.g. Ps 119 66; Prov 1 4.7.22.29; 8 10, etc; Lk 177; Rom 15 14; 2 Pet 1 5.6). The_ highest knowledge, as said, is the knowledge of God and Christ, and of God’s will (Hos 6 6; Rom 11 33; Eph 1 17; 4 13; Phil 1 9; 3 8; Col 1 9.10, etc). The moral conditions of spiritual knowledge are continually insisted on (“If any man willeth to do his will, he shall know of the teaching, whether it is of God,” Jn 7 17). On the other hand, the pride of intellectual knowledge is condemned; it must be joined with love (‘Knowledge puffeth up,’’ 1 Cor 8 1). The stronger term epignésis is used to de- note the full and more perfect knowledge which is possessed in Christ, the conditions of which are humility and love. Of knowledge as connoting favor, choice, on the part of God, there are many examples (Ps 1 6, ‘Jeh knoweth the way of the righteous”; Gal 4 9, ‘know God, or rather to be known by God”; cf Rom 8 29, “whom he fore- knew”). See FoREKNOWLEDGE. James ORR KOA, ko’a Op, ko"): A people named with Pekod and Shoa as enemies of Jerus (Ezk 23 23). Their location was probably N.E. of Babylonia. KOHATH, ko’hath, KOHATHITES, ko’hath-its (MNP, kehath, P., kohathi; Kaé0, Kadth): Second son of Levi, and ancestor of Moses and Aaron (Gen 4611; Ex 6 16-20; Nu 317; 1 Ch61, etc). The Kohathites formed one of the three divisions of the tribe of Levi; the other two being the Ger- shonites and the Merarites (Nu 3 17 ff). The Kohathites consisted of four families, the Amramites, the Izharites, the Hebronites, and the Uzzielites THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1816 (Nu 3 19.27, etc). Their place in the wilderness was on the southern side of the tabernacle (Nu 3 29), and their number is given (from a month old) as 8,600 (ver 28). Their special charge was ‘“‘the ark, and the table, and the candlestick, and the altars, and the vessels of the sanctuary wherewith they minister, and the screen, and all the service thereof” (ver 31; cf 7 9). After the conquest 23 cities were assigned thera by lot (Josh 21 4.5 ff). In David’s time and after, Heman, a Kohathite, and his family had a prominent place in the service of the music of the sanctuary (1 Ch 6 33 ff; 16 41 fi; 26 1 ff); David likewise divided the Levites into courses (the Kohathites, 23 12-20; 24 20-25). We read of the Kohathites in the reign of Jehosha- phat at Engedi (2 Ch 20 19), and in connection with the cleansing of the temple under Hezekiah (2 Ch 29 12.14). JAMES ORR KOHELETH, ké-hel’eth (MOMP, kaheleth). See Ecc.estastes. KOLAIAH, ké-la’ya, ké-li’a (M2'P, kalayah, “voice of Jeh’’): (1) A Benjamite, son of Maaseiah (Neh 11 7). (2) Father of Ahab, a false prophet and a lecher- ous man (Jer 29 21-23). KONAE, ko’né (Kova, Kond): Some MSS have xéyas, kémas, from which we have in AV “‘the vil- lages.”’ The name occurs in the account of the measures taken to secure the country against Holofernes (Jth 4 4). If Kéna be correct, we may possibly identify the place with Cyamon. KOPH, kof (P, kdph): The 19th letter of the Heb alphabet; transliterated in this Encyclopaedia as k (intense). It came also to be used for the num- ber 100. For name, etc, see ALPHABET. KOR, kor. See Cor. KORAH, k6’ra (MJP , korah, “baldness,” possibly; Képe, Kére): (1) One of the 3 sons of Oholibamah, Esau’s Hivite wife. The account says that the 3 were born in Canaan before Esau withdrew to the Seir mountain country. They are mentioned 3 t in the brief account from 3 points of view (Gen 36 5.14. 18; 1 Ch 1 35), the 3d mention being in the list of “chiefs.” (2) One of the sons of Eliphaz, the son of Adah, Esau’s Hittite wife (Gen 36 16). He is mentioned as one of the Edomite ‘‘chiefs.” If one has the habit, finding a statement any- where, of thinking that the statement ought to be changed into something else, he will be interested in the attempts to identify these Edomite Korahs with Korah (8). (3) A son of Hebron (1 Ch 2 43), the son of Mareshah, mentioned in the Caleb group of families in Judah. (4) Theson of Izhar the son of Kohath the son of Levi (Ex 6 16 ff; Nu 16 1; 1 Ch 6 18.31-38), a@ younger contemporary of Moses. There may have been generations, omitted in the record, between Izhar and K.; that is a natural way of accounting for Amminadab (1 Ch 6 22-30). This Korah is best known as the man whom the opening earth is said to have swallowed up along with his associates when they were 1. The challenging the authority of Moses Catastrophe and Aaron in the wilderness (Nu 16, in the 17). K. is presented as the principal Wilderness in the affair. The company is spoken of as his company, and those who were swallowed up as being “all the men that apper- 1817 tained unto K.” (Nu 16 11.32). It is under his name that the affair is referred to (Nu 26 9; 27 3). But Dathan and Abiram of the tribe of Reuben are not much less prominent than K. In Nu 16 and 26 they are mentioned with K., and are mentioned without him in Dt 11 6 and Ps 106 17. Another Reubenite, On, the son of Peleth, was in the con- spiracy. Jt has been inferred that he withdrew, but there is no reason either for or against the infer- ence. Haually baseless is the inference that Zelo- phehad of Manasseh joined it, but withdrew (Nu 27 3). The account implies that there were other Levites in it besides K. (Nu 16 7-10), and it par- ticularly mentions 250 “men of renown,’’ princes, such men as would be summoned if there were a public assembly (Nu 16 2.17.35). These men, apparently, were of different tribes. The position taken by the malcontents was that “all the congregation are holy, every one of them,” and that it was therefore a usurpation for Moses and Aaron to confine the functions of an incense- burning priest to Aaron alone. Logically, their objection lay equally against the separation of Aaron and his sons from the rest of the Levites, and against the separation of the Levites from the rest of the people. On the basis of this, Moses made expostulation with the Levites. He arranged that K. and the 250, along with Aaron, should take their places at the doorway of the tent of meeting, with their censers and fire and incense, so that Jeh might indicate His will in the matter. Dathan and Abiram insolently refused his proposals. The record says that K.’s “whole congregation,” including himself and the 250 with their censers, met Moses and Aaron and “all the congregation’ of Israel at the doorway of the tent of meeting. For the purposes of the transaction in hand the tent was now “the mishkan of K., Dathan and Abiram,” and their followers. Jeh directed Moses to warn all other persons to leave the vicinity. Dathan and Abiram, however, were not at the mishkan. The account says that Moses, followed by the elders of Israel, went to them to their tents; that he warned all persons to leave that vicinity also; that Dathan and Abiram and the households stood near the tents; that the earth opened and swallowed them and their property and all the ad- herents of K. who were on the spot; that fire from Jeh devoured the 250 who offered incense. The narrative does not say whether the deaths by fire and by the opening of the earth were simultaneous. It does not say whether K.’s sons participated in the rebellion, or what became of K. himself. In the allusion in Nu 26 we are told, apparently, that K. was swallowed up, and that “the sons of K. died not.’ The deaths of the principal offenders, by fire and by being swallowed up, were followed by a plague in which 14,700 perished (Nu 16 49 [Heb 17 14)). Any appreciative reader sees at once that we have here either a history of certain miraculous facts, or a wonder- story devised for teaching religious lessons. As a story it is artistically admirable— 2. Critical Sumeiently complicated to be interesting, Treatments but clear and graphic and to the point. In of This the feb there are 2 or 3 instances of in- complete grammatical construction, such Story as abound in the early literary products of any language, when these have been fortunate enough to escape editorial polishing. In such a case it is possibly not unwise just to take a story as it stands. Nothing will be added to either its religious or its literary value by subjecting it to doubtful alleged iti rocesses. y came ea Cer one has committed himself to certain criti- cal traditions concerning the Hex, that brings him under obligation to lead this story into conformity with the rest of his theory. Attempts of this kind have been numer- ous. Some hold that the K. of this narrative is the Edomite K., and that Peleth means Phili, and that our story originally grew out of some claim made by Edom- ites and Philis. Itis held that the story of K. was origi- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Koa Korahites nally one story, and that of Dathan and Abiram an- other, and that someone manipulated the two and put them together. See the treatments of the Book of Nu in Driver, Intro; Addis, Documents of the Hex; Carpen- ter and Battersby, Hex; Bacon, Ez; Paterson on Nu, in the Polychrome Buble. These and other like works give source-analyses of our story. Some of the points they make are plausible. In such a case no one claims any adequate basis of fact for his work; each theory is simply a congeries of ingenious guesses, and no two of the guessers guess alike. As in many other Blb. instances, one of the results of the alleged critlcal study is the resolving of a particularly fine story into two or more supposed earlier stories each of which is absolutely bald and crude and uninteresting, the earlier stories and the combining of these into their present form betas alike regarded as processes of legend- ary accretion. The necessary inference is that the fine story we now have was not the product of some gifted mind, gulded by facts and ey literary and religious in- spiratlon, but is an accidental result of mere patchwork. Such a theory does not commend itself to persons of lit- erary appreciation. Witus J. BescHer KORAHITES, ko’ra-its CMP, korht), SONS OF KORAH (3p "23, bené korah; in AV appears also as Korhite, Kohathite, Kore): This phrase is used to denote Assir and Elkanah and Abiasaph, Korah’s 3 individual sons (Ex 6 24; cf Nu 26 11). But its more frequent use, and that to which interest attaches, is in the titles of some of the Pss. The genealogical details concerning K. are rather full. In 3 places we find the list of the 7 successive generations closing with the prophet Samuel and his son Joel (1 Ch 6 31-38.22-30; 1 11.20; 8 2); the two in Ch mention most of the generations between K. and Joel. The fragmentary lists in 1 Ch 9, 25, 26 connect the list with the 4 generations following Joel (1 Ch 6 33; 9 19-31, 26 1ff), and with 2 generations in the very latest Bible times (1 Ch 9 31). The adj. “Korhite"’ appears also in AV as ‘Korathite,” “Kore,"’ and ‘‘Korahite,"’ the last being the form pre- ferred in ERV. lt is used 4 t in the sing. Once it designates an individual (1 Ch 9 31); 3 _t it denotes the successors of K. taken collectively (Ex 6 24; Nu 26 58; 1 Ch 26 19); 4 t it is used in the pl., denoting the members of this succession of men (1 Ch 9 19; 12 6; 26.1; 2.Ch 20 19). As variants of this use, ‘‘the sons of the Korahites'’ appears once, and ‘‘the children of the Korahites"’ once (1 Ch 26 19; 2 Ch 20 19). In these various passages the K. families are counted like the other Levitical families. In 1 Ch 12 6 we have an account of 5 men who are desig- nated as “the Korahites,” who joined David when he was at Ziklag—Elkanah, Isshiah, Azarel, Joezer, Jashobeam. They are described as expert warriors, esp. with the bow and sling, and as being “of Saul’s brethren of Benjamin.” Some of them may plausi- bly be identified with men of the same name men- tioned elsewhere. These Korahites may have been cousins of the Samuel family, and they may have resided not very far apart. The record speaks with some emphasis of a line of K. doorkeepers. In the latest OT times one Mattithiah, “the first-born of Shallum the Korahite,’’ held ‘‘the office of trust over the things that were baked in pans" (1 Ch 9 31). Shallum was ‘‘the son of Kore, the son of Ebiasaph, the son of Korah.'"’ In this expression 15 or more genera- tions are omitted between Ebiasaph and Kore, and per- haps as many between Kore and Shallum. The record roceeds to supply some of the omitted names between ore and Shallum. The representative of the line in David's time was “Zechariah the son of Meshelemiah’' {ver 21). In all periods the Korahites were ‘‘ keepers of the thresholds of the tent.’' Back in the time of ‘“‘Phine- has the son of Eleazar,”’ ‘‘ their fathers had been over the camp of Jeh”’ (vs 19.20). Zechariah was, in his time, “porter of the door of the tent of meeting'’ (ver 21), and Shallum was still the chief of the porters (ver 17). ‘he record for David's tlme supports and supplements this. It says that the doorkeepers, ane to the arrange- ments made by David, included a K. contingent, its leading men being Meshelemiah and his son Zechariah (1 Ch 26 1.2.9.14), and that Meshelemiah was ‘‘the son of Kore, of the sons of Asaph.’ Adopting the com- mon conjecture that Asaph is here a variant for Ebiasaph, we have here the same abridgment of the genealogical list asin 1 Ch 9. More interesting, however, than the fighting Korahites of Benjamin, or the doorkeeping Kora- Korahites Lacedaemonians THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1818 hites who claimed succession from Moses to Nehe- miah, are the “sons of Korah” who were somehow connected with the service of song. One of the genealogies is introduced by the statement: ‘These are they whom David set over the service of song in the house of Jeh, after that the ark had rest. And they ministered with song before the taber- nacle of the tent of meeting, until Solomon had built the house of Jeh in Jerus” (1 Ch 6 31.32). Then the writer proceeds to mention first ‘“Heman the singer, the son of Joel, the son of Samuel,” and so on, carrying the genealogy back to Korah and Levi. After thus mentioning Heman, he speaks of “his brother Asaph, who stood on his right hand,” and traces Asaph’s descent back to Gershom the son of Levi; and then says, “and on the left hand their brethren the sons of Merari.” Of these the prin- cipal leader is Ethan (otherwise called Jeduthun), and his descent is here traced back to Levi. In this way we are introduced to David's 3 great lead- ers in choral and orchestral music. Among them Heman the Korahite has at first the place of primacy, though Asaph, later, comes to the front. The events just re- ferred to are mentioned again, more in detail, in the account of David's hringing the ark to Jerus. ‘There it is said that at the suggestion of David ‘‘the Levites appointed Heman the son of Joel,’’ and also Asaph and Ethan, ‘‘and with them” several others, ‘their brethren of the second degree’ (1 Ch 15 17.18). The record proceeds to speak of the services of “the singers, Heman, Asaph, and Ethan," and their associates, in the pageantry of the bringing of the ark to Jerus. After that, it says, Asaph had charge of the services of thanksgiving and praise before the ark in Jerus, while Heman and Jedu- thun served in the high place at Gibeon (1 Ch 16 4 ff. 37.39-42). Later, the record says (1 Ch 25), David made an elaborate organization, under Asaph and Heman and Jeduthun, for prophesying with song and instru- mental music. As the records of David’s time, according to the Chronicler, thus attribute to him great achieve- ments in sacred music and song, so the records of subsequent times reiterate the same thing. David's interest in sacred music is mentioned in connection with Solomon’s temple, in connection with the times of Joash and Hezekiah and Josiah, in connec- tion with the institutions and exploits of the times after the exile (e.g. 2 Ch 7 6; 23 18; 29 25 ff; 35 15; Ezr 3.10; Neh 12 2436.45.46). Asaph and Heman and Jeduthun led the magnificent choir and orchestra at the dedication of the temple (2 Ch 6 12). One of the sons of Asaph prophesied, and the sons of the Korahites sang at the crisis in the time of Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 20 14.19). The sons of Asaph and the sons of Heman and the sons of Jeduthun were present, and there was instrumental music and lond singing, according to the appoint- ment of David and his associates, at the time of Hezekiah’s Passover (2 Ch 29 18 ff). Singing, and Asaph and Heman and Jeduthun and David have an important place in the record concerning Josiah. And the records of the post-exilian times make the singers and the “sons of Asaph” and the arrangements of David as conspicuous as the law of Moses itself. Add to this that the names Asaph or Heman or Ethan or Jeduthun, or the designation ‘the sons of Korah” are attached to 25 or more of the Pss (e.g. Pss 42-49, 50, 62, 72-85), and we have a body of testimony that is at least abundant and intelli- gible. It is to the effect that there was elaborate organization, on a large scale, in connection with the musical services of the temple at Jerus; that this began in the time of David, as a part of the preparation for building the temple, under the in- fluence of the family traditions of the prophet Samuel; and that the movement continned in the generations following David, either surviving the exile, or being revived after the exile. In connec- tion with this movement, the phrases ‘“‘sons of Korah,” “sons of Asaph,” ‘sons of Heman,’’ ‘“‘sons of Jeduthun” denote, in some cases, merely lineal descent; but in other cases they denote each an aggregate of persons interested in sacred song and music—a guild or society or succession or group— arising out of the movement which originated in David’s time. See, for example, “sons of Asaph” (1 Ch 25 1.2; 2 Ch 20 14; cf ver 19; 29 13; 36 15; Ezr 2 41; 3 10; Neh 7 44; 11 22) and “sons of Korah’’ in the titles of Pss 42-49 and 84, 85, 87-89. Traces of these aggregates appear in the times of Solomon, of Jchoshaphat, of Joash, of Hezekiah, of Josiah, of Zerubbabel, of Ezra and Nehemiah. If a person holds that the mention of an event in Ch is to be regarded as proof that the event never occurred, that person will of course deny that the testimony thus cited is true to fact. He is likely to hold that the guilds of singers arose in the exile, and that, some generations after Nehemiah, they fabricated for themselves the ecclesiastical and physical pedigrees now found in the Books of Ch. If, however, we accord fair play to the Chron- icler as a witness, we shall be slow to discredit the minute and interfitting testimony which he has placed before us. Wiuus J. BEECHER _KORATHITES, ko’rath-its: In AV for ‘Kora- hites,”” Nu 26 58. See Korag, 4. KORE, ko'ré (7p , kare’, “one who proclaims’’): (1) A Levite of David’s time, descended from Kohath and Korah. See Koray, 4. Shallum, chief doorkeeper in the latest Bible times, is de- scribed as ‘‘the son of Kore, the son of Ebiasaph, the son of Korah” (1 Ch 9 19). This expression omits the generations between Shallum and K., and those between K. and Ebiasaph, perhaps 15 generations or more in each case. The context supplies two of the omitted names, of the time of David, Meshelemiah and his son Zechariah (1 Ch 9 21.22). The record for the time of David mentions these two, with some particulars, callmg Meshel- emiah the son of K. (1 Ch 26 1.2.9.14). It de- scribes them as “‘Korahites” “of the sons of Asaph.” It is usual to regard this last clanse as a variant for ‘‘the son of Ebiasaph,’”’ thus making the de- scription identical with that in 1 Ch 9 19. With this understanding, the text claims that ‘the Korahites,” K. and Meshelemiah and Zechariah, come midway in a line of sanctuary ministrants, extending continuously from Moses to Nehemiah. (2) “The son of Imnah the Levite, the porter at the east gate,”’ who ‘was over the freewill-offerings,” in the time of Hezekiah (2 Ch 31 14). Very likely in the same line with (1) above. (3) In 1 Ch 26 1 AV for Koranrrss (q.v.). Wiis J. BeEcuar KORHITES, kér’hits: In AV for ‘Korahites” in Ex 624; 1Ch 126; 261; 2 Ch 2019. See Koraug, 3. KOZ, koz. See Haxxoz. KUSHAIAH, kti-sha’ya, k-shi’a (AMBP , kusha- yah, “bow of Jeh”): A Merarite Levite (1 Ch 15 17), called in 1 Ch 6 44 Kisuz (q.v.). 1819 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA \ LAADAH, 1a’a-da ("399 . la‘dah): A descendant of Judah (1 Ch 4 21). LAADAN, la’a-dan. See Lapan. LABAN, 1a’ban: The person named Laban ap? ; labhan; AaBdv, Labdn, possibly connected with the v¥ meaning ‘‘to be white,” from which in Heb the adj. meaning ‘white’ has just this form) is first intro- duced to the reader of Gen in the story of the wooing of Rebekah (ch 24). He belonged to that branch of the family of Terah that was derived from Abraham’s brother Nahor and his niece Milcah. The gene- alogy of this branch is traced in Gen 22 20-24; but, true to its purpose and the place it occupies in the book, this genealogy brings the family down to Rebekah, and there stops without mentioning Laban. Accordingly, when Rebekah is introduced in the narrative of ch 24, she is referred to (vs 15.24) in a way that recalls to the reader the genealogy already given; but when her brother Laban is introduced (ver 29), he is related to his sister by the express announcement, ‘‘And Rebekah had a brother, and his name was Laban.” In this ch he takes prominent part in the reception of Abraham’s servant, and in the determination of his sister’s future. That brothers had an effective voice in the marriage of their sisters is evident, not only from extra-Bib. sources, but from the Bible itself; see e.g. Cant 8 8. In Gen 24, however, Laban is perhaps more prominent than even such custom can explain (cf vs 31.50.55), and we are led to see in him already the same forcefulness and egotism that are abundantly shown in the stories from his later life. The man’s eager hospitality (ver 31), coming immediately after his mental inventory of the gifts bestowed by the visitor upon his sister (ver 30), has usually, and justly, been regarded as a proof of the same greed that is his most conspicuous character- istic in the subsequent chapters. | ietoe: The story of that later period in Laban’s life is so interwoven with the career of Jacob that little need here be added to what is said of Laban in Jaco, III, 2 (q.v.). By the time of Jacob’s arrival he is already a very old man, for over 90 years had elapsed since Rebekah’s departure. Yet even at the end of Jacob’s 20 years’ residence with him he is represented as still energetic and active (31 19.23), not only ready for an emergency like the pursuit after Jacob, but personally superintending the management of his huge flocks. His home is in Haran, “‘the city of Nahor,” that is, the locality where Nahor and his family remained at the time when the rest of Terah’s descendants emigrated to Canaan (11 31; 12 5). Since Haran, and the region about it where his flocks fed, be- longed to the district called Aram (see Pappan- ARAM; Mesopotamia), Laban is often called _‘‘the Aramaean” (EV ‘the Syrian,” from LXX 6 Ztpos, ho Stiros); see 26 20; 28 5; 81 20.24. It is uncer- tain how far racial affinity may be read into this term, because the origin and mutual relationships of the various groups or strata of the Sem family are not yet clear. For Laban himself it suffices that he was a Semite, living within the region early occupied by those who spoke the Sem dialect that we call Aramaic. This dialect is represented in the narrative of Gen as already differentiated from the dialect of Canaan that was Jacob’s mother-tongue; for “the heap of witness,’ erected by uncle and nephew before they part (31 47), is called by the one Jegar-saha-dutha and by the other Galeed— phrases which are equivalent in meaning, the former L Korahitea Lacedaemonians Aram., the latter Heb. (Ungnad, Hebrdische Gram- matik, 1912, $6, puts the date of the differentiation of Aram. from ‘‘Amurritish” at “about 1500 BC”; Skinner, “Genesis,” JCC, argues that ver 47 is a gloss, following Wellhausen, Dillmann, et al.) The character of Laban is interesting to observe. On the one hand it shows a family likeness to the portraits of all his relations in the patriarchal group, preéminently, however, to his sister Rebekah, his daughter Rachel, and his nephew Jacob. The nearer related to Laban such figures are, the more conspicuously, as is fitting, do they exhibit Laban’s mingled cunning, resourcefulness, greed and _self- complacency. And, on the other hand, Laban’s character is sui generis; the picture we get of him is too personal and complex to be denominated merely a “type.” It is impossible to resolve this man Laban into a mythological personage—he is altogether human—or into a tribal representative (e.g. of “Syria” over against ‘Israel’ = Jacob) with any degree of satisfaction to the world of scholar- ship. Whether a character of reliable family tra- dition, or of popular story-telling, Laban is ‘‘a char- acter’’; and his intimate connection with the chief preraeee in Israel’s national recollections makes it ighly probable that he is no more and no less his- torical than Jacob himself (cf Jacos, VI). J. Oscar Boyp LABANA, lab’a-na (AaBavd, Laband, 1 Esd 5 29): Called Lebanah in Ezr 2 45. LABOR, 1a’bér (2°39, y*ghi*, bap , ‘dmal; kémos, képos): The word (noun and vb.) denoting hard work or “toil” (thus in RV of Dt 26 7; Josh 7 3; Rev 2 2) represents several Heb and Gr words, chiefly those above. Occasionally, as in Hab 3 17 (ma‘éséh), it stands for ‘fruit of labor.” Some- times, in conjunction with “travail,” it refers to childbirth (Gen 35 16.17, ydladh; cf 1 Thess 2 9; 2 Thess 3 8). Examples of the word in the ordi- nary sense are: of y*ghi*, Gen 31 42; Job 39 11. 16; Ps 128 2; of ‘amal, common in Eccl 1 3.8; 2 10.11.18, etc; of kopos, 1 Cor 16 58 (“your labor is not vain,” etc); 1 Thess 1 3 (‘‘work of faith and labor of love’; ef He 6 10); 1 Tim 5 17 (“labor in the word and in teaching’). See Work; SLAVERY. JAMES ORR LACCUNUS, lak’i-nus (Aakkotvos, Lakkovnos; AV Lacunus): One of the sons of Addi who returned with Ezra and had married a foreign wife (1 Esd 9 31). The name does not, as might have been expected, occur in Ezr 10 30. See note on the passage (in Lange’s Comm.) as to the reconciliation of the lists in 1 Esd and Ear. LACE, las Gane , pathil, variously rendered in Gen 38 18.25; Ex 39 3; Nu 16 38; 19 15; Jgs 16 9; Ezk 40 3): In modern Eng. the noun “lace’’ usually denotes a delicate ornamental fabric, but in the word in the sense of ‘‘that which binds” is still in perfectly good use, esp. in such combina- tions as “shoelace,” etc. It is this latter signif- icance that is found in Ex 28 28 (‘‘They shall bind .... with a lace of blue’); 28 37; 39 21. 31, and in Sir 6 30 AV, kddcua, klésma (RV “rib- and”’). LACEDAEMONIANS, las-é-dé-m3’ ni-anz (Zraptidrar, Spartidtat; once only AakeSainévio, Lakedaiménioi, 2 Macc 5 9): The inhabitants of Sparta or Lacedaemon with whom the Jews claimed some kinship and formed alliances (1 Macc 12 Lachish Laish 2.5.6.20.21; 14 20.23; 15 23; 2 Macc 6 9). The alliance mentioned in 1 Macc 12 5-23 is based, among other grounds, on that of a common descent of Jews and Lacedaemonians from Abraham, for which the only probable presumption—suggested by Ewald—is the similarity of names, “Pelasgi” and Peleg son of Eber (Gen 10 25; 11 16). This has been reasonably objected to, and perhaps the most that can be said on this point is that the belief in some relationship between the Jews and the Lacedaemonians seems to have prevailed when 1 Mace was written. The alliance itself is said to have been formed (1 Mace 12 20) between Areus, king of the Lacedaemonians and Onias the high priest; but it is not easy to make out a consistent chronology for the transaction. For the renewal of the alliance (c 144 BC) by Jonathan (1 Macc 12 5-18) and again by Simon (1 Mace 14 16-23), something can be said, as the Greeks had finally been deprived of independence in 146 BC, and Sparta was only obliged to lend assistance to Rome and may be supposed to have been doing so in help- ing the Jews against Syria. It is possible, too, that as against Syrian Hellenism the Jews were anxious to show that they had the assistance of distinguished Greeks, though the actual power of Sparta was much reduced from that of former times. The facts, at least of the alliance and the correspondence, seem to be sufficiently attested, though it is not easy to reconcile all the particulars. Jos (Ant, XII, iv, 10; X11, v, 8; XIV, xii, 2.3) gives the correspondence at greater length than the writer of the Maccabees. : J. Hurcsison LACHISH, la’kish (72D, lakhish; LXX Aaxls, Lachis [Josh 15 39], Maxés, Machés): A town in the foothills of the Shephelah on the 1. Location border of the Phili plain, belonging to Judah, and, from the mention of Eglon in connection with it, evidently in the southwestern portion of Judah’s territory. Onom locates it 7 miles from Eleutheropolis (Beit Jibrin) toward Daroma, but as the latter place is uncertain, the indication does not help in fixing the siteof L. The city seems to have been abandoned about 400 BC, and this circumstance has rendered the identifica- tion of the site difficult. It was formerly fixed at Umm Lokis, from the similarity of the name and because it was in the region that the Bib. references to L. seem to indicate, but the mound called Tell el- Hesy is now generally accepted as the site. This was first suggested by Conder in 1877 (PEFS, 1878, 20), and the excavations carried on at the Tell by the Pal Exploration Fund in 1890-93 con- firmed his identification. Tell el-Hesy is situated on a wady, or valley, of the same name (Wédy el- Hesy), which runs from a point about 6 miles W. of Hebron to the sea between Gaza and Askelon. It is a mound on the very edge of the wady, rising some 120 ft. above it and composed of débris to the depth of about 60 ft., in which the excavations revealed the remains of distinct cities which had been built, one upon the ruins of another. The earliest of these was evidently Amorite, and could not have been later than 1700 BC, and was perhaps two or three centuries earlier (Bliss, Mound of Many Cities). The identification rests upon the fact that the site corresponds with the Bib. and other historical notices of L., and esp. upon the dis- covery of a cuneiform tablet in the ruins of the same character as the Am Tab, and containing the name of Zimridi, who is known from these tablets to have been at one time Egyp governor of L. The tablets, which date from the latter part of the 15th or early part of the 14th cent. BC, give us the earliest in- formation in regard to L., and it was then an Egyp dependency, but it seems to have revolted and joined with other towns in an attack upon Jerus, which was THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Se 1820 also an Egyp dependency. It was perhaps com- pelled to do so by the Khabiri who were then raiding this region. The place was, like Gaza, an impor- tant one for Egypt, being on the frontier and on the route to Jerus, and the importance is secn in the fact that it was taken and destroyed and rebuilt so many times. We first hear of it in the history of Israel when Joshua invaded the land. It was then an Amorite city, and its king, Japhia, joined the confederacy formed by Adonizedek, king of Jerus, to resist Joshua. They were defeated in the remarkable battle at Gibeon, and the five confederate kings were captured and ut to death at Makkedah (Josh 10 passim; 12 11). ‘- was included in the lot of Judah (15 39), and it was rebuilt, or fortified, by Rehoboam (2 Ch 11 5.9). It was besieged by Sennacherib in the reign of Hezekiah and probably taken (2 K 18 13) when he invaded Judah and besieged Jerus, but the other references to the siege leave it doubtful 2. History STKE? FO Ry Sennacherib on His Throne before Lachish. Layard's Monuments of Nineveh, (Kouyunjik.) (2 K 18 14.17; 19 8; 2 Ch 32 9; Isa 36 2; 37 8). The Assyr monuments, however, render it cer- tain that the place was captured. The sculptures on the walls of Sennacherib’s palace picture the storming of L. and the king on his throne receiving the submission of the captives (Ball, Light from the East, 190-91). ‘This was in 701 BC, and to this period we may assign the enigmatical reference to . in Mic 1 13, ‘Bind the chariot to the swift steed, O inhabitant of Lachish: she was the begin- ning of sin to the daughter of Zion.” The cause of the invasion of Sennacherib was a general revolt in Phoenicia, Pal, and Philistia, Hezekiah joining in it and all asking Egypt for aid (Rawlinson, Five Great Monarchies of the Ancient Eastern World, ch ix). Isaiah had warned Judah not to trust in Egypt (Isa 20 5.6; 30 1-5; 31 1), and as L. was the place where communication was held with Egypt, being a frontier fortress, perhaps even having an Egyp garrison, it would be associated with the “sin” of the Egyp alliance (HGHL, 234). _ The city was evidently rebuilt after its destruc- tion by Sennacherib, for we find Nebuchadnezzar fighting against it during his siege of Jerus (Jer 34 7). It was doubtless destroyed by him, but we are informed by Nehemiah (11 30) that some of the returned Jews settled there after the captivity. It is very likely that they did not reoccupy the site of the ruined city, but settled as peasants in the territory, and this may account for the transference of the name to Umm Lakis, 3 or 4 miles from Tell 1821 el-Hesy, where some ruins exist, but not of a kind to suggest Lachish (Bliss, op. cit). No remains of any importance were found on the Tell indicating its occupation as a fortress or city later than that destroyed by the king of Babylon, but it was oceu- pied in some form during the crusades, Umm Lakis eing held for a time by the Hospitallers, and King Richard is said to have made it a base of operations in his war with Saladin (HGHL). The Tell itself, if occupied, was probably only the site of his camp, and it has apparently remained since that time without inhabitants, being used for agricultural urposes only. See further, PaLestine (REcENT XPLORATION), III, 1. H. Porter LACK (forms of 101) , hagér, “to lack,” PR, ’ayin, ‘nought’’): This word in its various forms has the usual meaning of “want,” “need,” ‘‘deficiency.” There is but little change in the use of the word in the different VSS. Sometimes one of the common synonyms is exchanged for the word itself, e.g. in the OT, 1 8 21 15 RV has “lack” (“Do I lack madmen?) where AV has ‘need of’; Prov 5 23, ‘for lack,’’ instead of ‘‘without’; 6 32, ‘void of” for “lacketh”; 10 21, “lack” for “want”; 31 11, “lack” for “need”; Isa 59 15, “lacking’”’ for “fail- eth.” In the NT “lack” is the tr of vorepéw, hus- teréd, lit. “to be behind,” and évdeyjs, endeés, “in want.” In Lk 8 6, RV reads “had no’ instead of “lacked” in AV. In 2 Cor 11 9, RV gives “my want” for ‘which was lacking to me” in AV; in Col 1 24 “that which is lacking” for “that which is behind”; Jas 2 15 “lack” for “destitute.” It will readily be seen that sometimes the slight variation helps to explain the meaning. G. H. GERBERDING LACUNUS, la-kii’nus. See Laccunus. LAD: In the OT this word occurs as the tr of na‘ar, “young person,” “child,” “servant,” RV properly ‘substituting “servant” in 2 K 4 19; Jgs 16 26 is another passage where either sense of the original word may be intended. The word occurs in the NT in Jn 6 9 as the tr of waddpiov, paidd- rion; in Acts 20 12, ais, pats (AV ‘‘young man”). LADAN, 1a’dan (7792, la‘dan; AV Laadan): (1) A descendant of Ephraim, and an ancestor of Joshua (1 Ch 7 26). (2) A Levite of the family of Gershon (1 Ch 23 7.8.9; 26 21), also called Lrsni (q.v.). LADANUM, lad’a-num (U2, ld): Gen 37 25 RVm; elsewhere Myrru (q.v.). LADDER, lad’ér. See S1zaz, 4, (¢). LADDER OF TYRE (1H katpag [dard ris kAlpaxos| Tépov, Hé klimax [apd tés klimakos] Tirou): Not mentioned in the OT or the NT, butin Apoc (1 Mace 11 59), where it is said that Antiochus VI, after having confirmed Jonathan in the high-priesthood, appointed his brother Simon captain over the terri- tory included between the Ladder of Tyre and the borders of Egypt. The Ladder has been located at different points on the coast between Tyre and Acre, such as the Ras el-‘Abyadh (“Promontorium Album” of the ancient geographers), about 7 miles §. of Tyre, and Ras en-Nakirah, about 6 miles farther 8., and Ras el-Musheirifeh, a little farther on. These are capes jutting westward into the sea from the ridge which runs parallel to the general line of the coast. These capes project more than a mile into the sea, and present a very bold and pre- cipitous front from 200 to 300 ft. in height. The ascent on either side of the promontory is very THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE. ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lachish Laish steep, and at Ras el-‘Abyadh steps were cut in the white rock, which led to the identification of this point with the Ladder, but a reference to Jos (BJ, II, x, 2) leads to a different conclusion. He locates it 100 stadia N. of Acre, which corresponds fairly well with the southern limit of the whole promon- tory, which is about 12 miles N. of Acre, but not at all with Ras el-‘Abyadh. The altitude of el- Musheirifeh is greater than that of el-‘Abyadh and may have had steps cut in it similar to the latter. It is more probable that the L. was here, or at en- Nakéarah, but the term applied to the whole prom- ontory, which offered a serious obstacle to the passage of armies, or even caravans, since the ap- proach is precipitous on either side, and at Ras el-‘Abyadh the road skirts the edge of a sheer preci- pice, where a misstep would hurl one into the sea some 200 ft. below. The application of the term to the whole promontory seems to be indicated by Jos, since he speaks of 1t as one of the mountains which encompass the plain of Ptolemais (Acre) and the highest of all. This would not be true of any one of the three capes mentioned, but would be if the hills behind, which form their base, were in- cluded. That it was designated as the Ladder of Tyre rather than of Acre was probably due to the fact that the promontory is nearer the former city (see Thomson, LB, II, ed 1882; SWP, name-lists, 8.V.). H. Porter LADE, lad, LADING, lad’ing: ‘To lade” in the sense of ‘‘to load’ is retained by RV in nearly all passages where the word occurs in AV (but cf AV and RV reading of Ps 68 19; Isa 46 1), ‘They laded us with such things’ (Acts 28 10 AV). The érirlOnus, epitithémi, ‘to put on,’ is rendered by RV, “They put on board such things.” Lk 11 46 RV reads “‘ye load”’ instead of AV “ye lade.” Lading (gopriov, phortion) is found in Acts 27 10 in its usual meaning, ‘‘the lading of a ship.” LADY, 1la’di: This word should be taken in the sense of “mistress” in Isa 47 5.7 (Heb g*bhereth) (so ARV). In Jgs 5 29; Est 1 18 it is the tr of another Heb word (sarah), best rendered “princess” (so RV in Est, but not in Jgs). In 2 Jn vs 1.5 it is the tr of xuvpia, kurta, which some interpreters regard as a proper name. See Cyria; Joun, EpistLes oF; Exect Lapy. LAEL, la’el (8D, la él, “belonging to God”): Father of Eliasaph, the prince of the father’s house of the Gershonites (Nu 3 24). LAHAD, la’had (12, lahadh): A descendant of Judah (1 Ch 4 2), LAHAI-ROI, la-hi’roi, la-hi-r6'i, la’/hi-roi (12 “N71, lahay rd’t). See BEER-LAHAI-ROI. LAHMAM, 1a’mam (D'9"? , lahmam): A town in the Judaean Shephelah (Josh 15 40, RVm “Lah- mas’), possibly the modern el- Lahm, 23 miles 8. of Beit Jibrin. LAHMAS, la’mas. See Laumam. LAHMI, la’mi ("7A , lahmi): According to 1 Ch 20 5, the brother of Goliath of Gath. See EL- HANAN. LAISH, la‘ish (89 , layish): (1) A city in the upper Jordan valley, apparently colonized by the Sidonians, which was captured by the Danites and called Dan (q.v.) (Jgs 18 7, ete; ee THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1822 Isa 10 30 AV). In Josh 19 47 the name appears | 11 6, “the portion of their cup.” In En 67 4ff as ‘‘Leshem.”’ (2) A Benjamite, father of Palti or Paltiel, to whom Michal, David’s wife, was given by Saul (1 S 25 44; 28 3 15). LAISHAH, 1a-i’sha, 14’ish-a (ma , layshah, AV Laish): A place named in Isa 10 30 with Gallim and Anathoth. It should apparently be sought on the N. of Jerus. Some would identify Gallim with Beit Jala, near Bethlehem. Conder suggests ‘Psawi- yeh on the eastern slope, to the N.N.E. of the Mount of Olives. LAKE, lak (Alpvy, imné): The word is used (Lk 5 1.2; 8 22.23.33) of the Lake of Gennesaret or Sea of Galilee, and (Rev 19 20; 20 10.14.15; 21 8) of the “lake of fire and brimstone.” Lakes are not abundant in Syria and Pal. The Dead Sea, which might be called a lake, is in most places in EV called the Salt Sea. It is called by the Arabs Bahr Lit, Sea of Lot. It is a question whether the Waters of Merom (Josh 11 5.7) can be identified with the Haleh, a marshy lake in the course of the Upper Jordan, N. of the Sea of Galilee. E. of Damascus on the edge of the desert there are saltish lakes in which the water of the rivers of Damascus (see 2 K & 12) is gathered and evapo- rates. Inthe Lebanon W. of Ba‘albek is the small Lake Yamméneh, which is fed by copious springs, but whose water disappears in the latter part of the summer, being drained off by subterranean channels. The Lake of Humg on the Orontes is artificial, though ancient. On the lower Orontes is the Lake of Antioch. ALFRED ELy Day LAKE OF FIRE (Aipvn rot aupés, limnd tov purés): Found in Rev 19 20; 20 10.14(bis).15. Rev 21 8 has ‘‘the lake that burneth with fire and brimstone.” The brimstone in connection with “the lake of fire” occurs also in Rev 19 20 and 20 10, the latter being a backward reference to the former passage. In Rev 20 14 the words, ‘‘This ig the second death, even the lake of fire,” are either a gloss originally intended to elucidate ver 15 through a reference to 20 6, or, if part of the text, formed originally the close of ver 15, whence they became displaced on account of the identity of the words once immediately preceding them in ver 15 with the words now preceding them in ver 14. The ‘dake of fire’ can be called ‘‘the second death” only with reference to the lost among men (ver 15), not with reference to death and Hades (ver 14). In all the above references “the lake of fire” appears as a place of punishment, of perpetual torment, not of annihilation (20 10). The beast (19 20); the pseudo-prophet (19 20; 20 10); the devil (20 10); the wicked of varying description (20 15; 21 8), are cast into it. When the same is affirmed of death and Hades (20 14), it is doubtful whether this is meant as a mere figure for the cessation of these two evils personified, or has a more realistic background in the existence of two demon-powers so named (cf Isa 26 8; 1 Cor 15 26.54 ff; 2 Esd 731). The Scriptural source for the conception of “the lake of fire’ lies in Gen 19 24, where already the fire and the brimstone occur together, while the locality of the catastrophe described is the neigh- borhood of the Dead Sea. The association of the Dead Sea with this fearful judgment of God, to- gether with the desolate appearance of the place, rendered it a striking figure for the scene of escha- tological retribution. The two other OT passages which have “fire and brimstone’ (Ps 11 6; Ezk 88 22) are dependent on the Gen passage, with which they have the figure of “‘raining”’ in common. In Rev 21 8, ‘‘their part’ seems to allude to Ps the Dead Sea appears as the place of punishment for evil spirits. Of late it has been proposed to derive “the lake of fire’ from “the stream of fire” which destroys the enemies of Ahura in the Zoroastrian eschatology; so Bousset, Die Offenbarung Johannis, 1906, 483, 434. But the figures of a stream and a lake are different; cf 2 Esd 13 9-11, where a stream of fire proceeds from the mouth of the Mes- siah for the destruction of His enemies. Besides, the Pers fire is, in part, a fire of purification, and not of destruction only (Bousset, 442), and even in the apocalyptic Book of En, the fires of purification and of punishment are not confounded i En 67 4 with 90 20). The OT fully explains the entire conception. GEERHARDUS Vos LAKE OF GENNESARET, ge-nes’a-ret. See GALILEE, SEA OF. LAKK0DM, Jak’um (BAp?, lakkam; AV Lakum): An unidentified town on the border of Naphtali, named with Adami, Nekeb and Jabneel, apparently nearer the Jordan (Josh 19 33). LAMA. See Ext, Exit, nama SABACHTHANI. LAMB, lam: (1) The most used word is wap, kebhes, “a young ram’; cf Arab. eee kebsh, “ram”; often of sacrifices; (fem.) nwa , kabhsah, or MWAD, kibhsah, ‘ewe lamb” (2 8 12 3); by transposition AWD, kesebh, and fem. MAW, kisbah (Gen 80 40; Lev 3 7; 6 6). (2) "3, kar, “lamb” (Dt 82 14; 18 169; 2K 3 4). (3) MW, seh, “one” of the flock (Gen 22 7; Lev 5 7). (4) JRZ- Ze ca’n, ‘‘sheep,” “goats,” “flock”; cf Arab. ,. La, da’n, “sheep” (Ex 12 21); and JRX JB, ben ¢o'n (Ps 114 4). (5) MPC, dalek, “young lamb”; cf Arab. Ab: , tali, “young lamb”; and DNrD, tl@im (18 7 9; Isa 40 11; 65 25). (6) PTaN , ’immerin (zr 6 9.17; 7 17). (7) &pvas, drnas, acc. pl. (Lk 10 3); dim. apvlov, arnion (Jn 21 15; Rev 5 6, etc). (8) apvés, amnds (Jn 1 29.36; Acts 8 32; 1 Pet 119). See SHeEp. ALFrep E1ty Day LAMB OF GOD (6 dpvés rod Qcot, ho amnéds tor theo): This is a title specially bestowed upon Our Lord by John the Baptist (Jn 1 29-36), ‘‘Be- hold, the Lamb of God, that taketh away the sin of the world!” In XIJ P—an apocryphal book, prob- ably of the 2d_cent.—we have the term used for the Messiah, ‘Honor Judah and Levi, for from them shall arise for you the Lamb of God, saving all na- tions by grace.” But the term does not seem to have been of any general use until it received its distinctly Christian significance. It has been gen- erally understood as referring to the prophetic lan- guage of Jer 11 19, and Isa 53 7. It is far more probable, however, that the true source of the expression is to be found in the impor- ‘ tant place which the “lamb” occupies 1. Sacrifi- in the sacrifices, esp. of the PC. In cial Sense these there was the lamb of the daily of the Term morning and evening sacrifice. How ‘ familiar this would be to the Baptist, being a member of a priestly family! On the Sab- bath the number of the offerings was doubled, and at some of the great festivals a still larger number were laid upon the altar (see Ex 29 38; Nu 28 3.9.13). The lamb of the Passover would also occupy a large place in the mind of a devout Israel- 1823 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Laishah Lamech ite, and, as the Passover was not far off, it is quite possible that John may have referred to this as well as to other suggested ideas connected with the lamb. The sacrificial significance of the term seems to be far more probable than the mere comparison of the character of Our Lord with meekness and gentle- ness, a8 suggested by the words of the prophets, although these contain much more than the mere reference to character (see below). That this became the clearly defined conception of apostolic teaching is clear from passages in Paul and Peter (1 Cor 6 7; 1 Pet 1 18f). In the Book of Rev the reference to the Lamb occurs 27 t. The word here used differs from that in Jn. The amnés of the Gospel has become the arnion of the Apocalypse, a diminutive form suggestive of affection. This is the word used by Our Lord in His rebuke and for- giveness of Peter (Jn 21 15), and is peculiarly touched therefore with an added meaning of_pa- thetic tenderness. Westcott, in his Comm. on Jn 1 29, refers to the conjecture that there may have been flocks of lambs passing by on their way to Jerus to be used at the feast. This is possible, but fanciful. : As applied to Christ, the term certainly suggests the meekness and entleness of Our Lord’s nature and work, but could not have been used by John without containing some reference to the place which the lamb bore in the Judaic ritualism. The significance of the Baptist’s words has been variously understood. Origen, Cyril, Chrysostom, among the ancients, Lucke, DeWette, 2. As Meyer, Ewald, Alford, among the Variously moderns, refer it to Isa 58 7; Grotius, Understood Bengel, Hengstenberg, to the paschal lamb; Baumgarten-Crusius, etc, to the sin offering; Lange strongly urges the influence of the passage in lsa 53, and refers to John’s de- scription of his own mission under the influence of the second part of Isa, in which he is supported by Schaff. The importance of the_Isa-thought is found in Mt 8 17; Acts 8 32; 1 Pet 2 22-25. It is to be observed that the LXX in Isa 63 _7 translates the Heb word for sheep (seh), by the Gr word for lamb. ver 10, the 8. As Set prophet’s “suffering one” is said to Forth by have made “his soul an offering for Isaiah sin,” and in ver 4 “he hath borne our griefs,” where bearing involves the conception of sin offering, and as possessing Justi- fying power, the idea of “taking away.” John indeed uses not the LXX word ¢épew (phérein), but alpe (airein), and some have maintained that this simply means “put away,” or “support,” or “endure.” But this surely loses the suggestion of the associated term “lamb,” which John could not have employed without some reference to its sacri- ficial and therefore expiatory force. What Lange calls a “germ perception” of atonement must cer- tainly have been in the Baptist’s mind, esp. when we recall the Isa-passages, even though there may not have been any complete dogmatic conception of the full relation of the death of Christ to the sal- vation of a world. Even the idea of the bearing of the curse of sin may not be excluded, for it was impossible for an Israelite like John, and esp. with his surroundings, to have forgotten the significance of the paschal lamb, both in its memorial of the judgment of Egypt, as well as of the deliverance of Tsrael. Notwithstanding every effort to take out of this striking phrase its deeper meanings which involve most probably the combination of all the sources above described, it must ever remain one of the richest mines of evangelical thought. It occupies, in the doctrine of atonement, a position analogous to that brief word of the Lord, “God isa Spirit” (Jn 4 24), in relation to the doctrine of God. The Lamb is defined as “of God,” that is, of Di- vine providing. See Isa 53; Rev 5 6; 13 8. Its ae and appointed office is indicated by the definite article, and whether we refer the conception to a specific sacrifice or to the general place of a lamb in the sacrificial institution, they all, as being ap- pointed by and specially set apart for God, suggest the close relation of Our Lord to the Divine Being, and particularly to His expiatory sacrifice. Lu. D. Bevan LAME, lim (MOB, piséh, MD), nakhth; xwrés, cholés): a: ; (1) The condition of being unable or imperfectly able to walk, which unfitted any descendant of Aaron so afflicted for service in the priesthood (Lev 21 18), and rendered an animal unsuitable for sac- rifice (Dt 16 21). The offering of animals so blem- ished was one of the sins with which Malachi charges the negligent Jews of his time (Mal 1 8-13). (2) Those who suffered from lameness, such as Mephibosheth, whose limbs were injured by a fall in childhood (28 4 4; 93). In the prophetic description of the completeness of the victory of the returning Israelites, it is predicted that the lame shall be made whole and shall leap like a hart (Jer 31 8; Isa 36 6). The unfitness of the lame for warfare gives point to the promise that the lame shall take the prey (Isa 33 23). Job in his graphic description of his helpfulness to the weak before his calamity says, ‘‘And feet was I to the lame” (Job 29 15). The inequality of the legs of the lame is used in Prov 26 7 as a similitude of the inaptness with which a fool uses a parable. In the enigmatical and probably corrupt passage describing David's capture of Jerus, the lame and blind are mentioned twice. In 2 8 § 6 it was a taunt on the are of the Jebusites that even a garrison of cripples would suffice to keep out the Israelites. The allusion in ver 8 may be read, ‘‘Whosoever smiteth the Jebusites let him . . . . slay hoth the lame and blind, which hate David's soul,” asitisin LXX. The Vulg says, “David had offered a reward on that day to the man who should smite the Jebusite and reach the water pipes of the houses, and remove the blind and lame who hated David's soul.'' It is possible, however, that Budde's emendation is more correct and that it is_a threat agalnst the indiscriminate slaughter of the Jebusites: ““Whoso slayeth a Jebusite shal! bring his neck into eril; the lame and blind are not hated of David's soul."’ Khe proverbial saying quoted in ver 8 cannot be correct as rendered in_AV, for we read in Mt 21 14 that the lame came to Our Lord in the temple and were healed. The healing of the lame by Our Lord is recorded in Mt 11 5; 16 30.81; 21 14; Lk 7 22; 14 18. For the apostolic miracles of healing the lame, see Crippte. In He 12 13 the Christians are coun- seled to courage under chastisement, lest their despair should cause that which is lame to be “turned out of the way.” Auex, MAcALISTER LAMECH, 1a’mek (7799, lemekth; Adpex, Lémech, “s strong youth’’[?]): (1) The name is first mentioned in Gen 4 18-24. Here L., the son of Methushael, is named as the last of the descendants of Cain. He was the father of Jabel, Jubal, Tubal-cain, and Naamah. As the husband of two wives, viz. Adah and Zillah, he furnishes the first recorded instance of polygamy. It is very instructive to note that this “father of polygamy” at once becomes the first blustering tyrant and a braggadocio; we are fully permitted to draw this conclusion from his so-called “sword- lay’ (Gen 4 23f). He does not put his trust in God, but in the weapons and implements invented by his sons, or rather these instruments, enhancing the physical and material powers of man, are his God. He glories in them and misconstrues the Divine kindness which insured to Cain freedom from the revenge of his fellow-men. (2) Another L. is mentioned in Gen 5 25.28 (ef 1 Ch 1 3; Lk 3 36), the son of Methuselah Lamedh Lamp THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1824 and the father of Noah. His words (Gen 6 29) show the great difference between this descendant of Seth and the descendant of Cain. While the one is stimulated to a song of defiance by the worldly inventions of his sons, the other, in pro- phetical mood, expresses his.sure belief in the coming of better times, and calmly and prayerfully awaits the period of comfort and rest which he expected to be ushered in by his son Noah. Wriii1am Baur LAMEDH, 18’meth (5): The 12th letter of the Heb alphabet; transliterated in this Encyclopaedia asl. It came also to be used for the number 30. For name, etc, see ALPHABET. LAMENT, la-ment’. See Music. LAMENTATION, lam-en-ta’shun. III, 2; IV, 4, 5, 6. See Buriat, LAMENTATIONS, lam-en-ta’shunz, BOOK OF —The Lamentations of Jeremiah: This is a col- lective name which tradition has given to 5 elegies found in the Heb Canon that lament the fate of destroyed Jerus. The rabbis call this little book ’Hkhah (D8, “how’’), according to the word of lament with which it begins, or kinoth (12). On the basis of the latter term the LXX calls it Sp%vor, thrénot, or Lat Threni, or ‘“Lamentations.” The little book consists of 5 lamentations, each one forming the contents of a chapter. The first 4 are marked by the acrostic use of the alphabet. In addition, the kinah (“elegy”) meter is found in these hymns, in which a longer line (8 or 4 accents) is followed by a shorter (2 or 3 accents). In chs 1 and 2 the acrostic letters begin three such double lines; in ch 4, however, two double lines. In ch 3 a letter controls three pairs, but is repeated at the beginning of each line. In ch 6 the alphabet is wanting; but in this case too the number of pairs of lines agrees with the number of letters in the Heb alphabet, i.e. 22. In chs 2, 3 and 4, the letter ‘ayin follows pé, as is the case in Ps 34. Ch 1, however, follows the usual order. These 5 hymns all refer to the great national catastrophe that overtook the Jews and in par- ticular the capita] city, Jerus, through 3. Contents the Chaldaeans, 587-586 BC. The sufferings and the anxieties of the city, the destruction of the sanctuary, the cruelty and taunts of the enemies of Israel, esp. the Edomites, the disgrace that befell the king and his nobles, priests and prophets, and that, too, not without their own guilt, the devastation and ruin of the country—all this is described, and appeal is made to the mercy of God. A careful sequence of thought cannot be expected in the lyrical feeling and in the alphabetical form. Repetitions are found in large numbers, but each one of these hymns emphasizes some special feature of the calamity. Ch 3 is unique, as in it one person describes his own peculiar sufferings in connection with the general calamity, and then too in the name of the others begins a psalm of repentance. This person did not suffer so severely because he was an exceptional sinner, but because of the unrighteousness of his people. These hymns were not written during the siege, but later, at a time when the people still vividly remem- bered the sufferings and the anxieties of that time and when the impression made on them by the fall of Jerus was still as powerful as ever. _Who is the author of these hymns? Jewish tra- dition is unanimous in saying that it was Jeremiah. The hymns themselves are found anonymously in 1. Name 2. Form the Heb text, while the LXX has in one anadditional statement, the Heb style of which would lead us to conclude that it was found in the origi- 4, Author nal from which the version was made. This statement reads: “And it came to pass, after Israel had been taken away captive and Jerus had been laid waste, that Jeremiah sat weeping, and uttered this lamentation over Jerus and said.” The Tg also states that Jeremiah was the author. The rabbis and the church Fathers have no doubts on the subject. Jerome (cf on Zec 12 11) thinks that 2 Ch 36 25 refers to these hymns. The same is said by Jos (Ant, X, v, 1). If this were the case, then the writer of Ch would have regarded Lam as having been written because of the death of Josiah. But this misunderstanding is not to be ascribed to him. It was easily possible that he was acquainted with lamentations of such a nature, but which afterward were lost. At all events, Jeremiah was by nature adapted to the composition of such elegies, as is proved by his book of prophecies. Only in modern times has the authorship of these hymns by Jeremiah been seriously called into ques- tion; and it is now denied by most critics. For this they give formal and material reasons. The language of these lamentations shows many simi- larities to the discourses of Jeremiah, but at the same time also many differences. The claim that the alphabetical scheme is not worthy of Jeremiah is a prejudice caused by the taste of our times. Heb poets had evidently been making use of such methods for a long time, as it helps materially in memorizing. At the time of the first acute suffer- ing on account of the destruction of Jerus, in fact, he would probably not have made use of it. But we have in this book a collection of lamentations written some time after this great catastrophe. The claim has also been made that the views of Jeremiah and those of the composer or the com- posers of these poems differ materially. It is said that Jeremiah emphasizes much more strongly the guilt of the people as the cause of the calamity than is done in these hymns, which lament the fate of the people and find the cause of it in the sins of the fathers (5 7), something that Jeremiah is said not to accept (Jer 31 29f). However, the guilt of the people and the resultant wrath of God are often brought out in these hymns; and Jeremiah does not deny (81 29 f) that there is anything like inherited guilt. He declares rather that in the blessed future things would be different in this respect. Then, too, we are not to forget that if Jeremiah is the author of these patriotic hymns, he does not speak in them as the prophet and the appointed accuser of his people, but that he is at last permitted to speak as he humanly feels, although there is no lack of prophetical reminiscences (cf Lam 4 21f). In these hymns he speaks out of the heart that loves his Jerus and his people, and he utters the priestly prayer of intercession, which he was not allowed to do when announcing the judgment over Israel. The fact that he also evinces great reverence for the unfortunate king and his Divinely given hereditary dignity (4 20), although as a prophet he had been compelled to pronounce judgment over him, would not Ne unthinkable in Jeremiah, who had shown warm sympathies also for Jehoiachim (22 24.28). A radical difference of sentiment between the two authors is not to be found. On the other hand, a serious difficulty arises if we claim that Jeremiah was not the author of Lam in the denunciations of Lam over the prophets of Jerus (2 14; 4 13). How could the great prophet of the Destruction be so ignored if he himself were not the author of these sentiments? If he was himself the author, we can easily understand this omission. In his book 1825 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lamedh Lamp of prophecies he has spoken exactly the same way about the prophets. To this must be added, that Lam 3 forces us to regard Jeremiah as the author, because of the personal sufferings that are here described. Compare esp. 8 14.37 f. 53 ff. 61.63. What other person was during the period of this catastrophe the cynosure of all eyes as was the prophet, esp., too, because he was guiltless? The claim that here, not an individual, but the personi- fied nation is introduced as speaking, is altogether improbable, and in some passages absolutely im- possible (vs 14.48). This little book must accordingly be closely con- nected with the person of Jeremiah. If he himself is the author, he must have composed it in his old age, when he had time and opportunity to live over again all the sufferings of his people and of himself. It is, however, more probable, esp. because of the language of the poems, that his disciples put this book in the present shape of uniform sentential utterances, basing this on the manner of lamenta- tions common to Jeremiah. In this way the origin of ch 3 can be understood, which cannot arti- ficially be shaped as his sayings, as in this case the personal feature would be more distinctly expressed. It was probably compiled from a number of his utterances. In the Heb Canon this book is found in the third division, called kthabhim, or Sacred Writings, t gether with the Pss. However, the LXX adds t's book to Jer, or rather, to the Book of Bar, found rext after Jer. The Hebrews count it among the 5 meghillath, or Rolls, which were read on promi- nent anniversary days. The day for the Lamenta- tion was the 9th of Ab, the day of the burning of the temple. In the Roman Catholic church It is read on the last three days of Holy Weck. : Lirerature.—Comms. of Thenius, Ewald, Nigels- bach, Gerlach, Keil, Cheyne, Oettli, Léhr, Budde; art. by Robertson Smith on ‘‘Lamentations’’ in ZB. C. von ORELLI LAMP, LAMPSTAND, lamp’stand (173, 73, 3; nir, nér, pd, lappidh, Phoen “p> , lampadh, whence Aaprds, lampds; X5x vos, lichnos, is also used): Nér or nir is properly “light” or “a light-giving thing,” hence “lamp,” and is so rendered in RV, but often “candle’ in AV. Its use in connection with the tabernacle and the temple (Ex 26 37 ff; 2 Ch 4 20 f), where oil was employed for light (Ex 35 14; Lamps: Figs. 1, 2. Lev 24 2), shows that this is its proper meaning. Lappidh is properly “a torch” and is thus rendered generally in RV, but “lamp” in Isa 62 1, where it is used asa simile. AV renders it “lamp’’ usually, but “torch” in Nah 2 31; Zee 12 6. In Job 12 5 RV renders it “for misfortune,’ regarding it as composed of the noun 3", pidh, and the preposi- tion 2, 1. Lampas in Gr corresponds to it, but luchnos is also rendered in RV “lamp,” while AV gives “candle,” as in Mt 5 15 and corresponding passages in the other Gospels. Lamps were in use in very remote times, though we have few allusions to them in the early history of Egypt. There are indications that 1. Forms they were used there. Niches for and History lamps are found in the tombs of Tell el-Amarna (Arch. Survey of Egypt, Am Tab, PartIV, 14). Lampstands are also represented (ib, Part III, 7). Torches were of course used before lamps, and are mentioned in Gen (15 17 RV), but clay lamps were used in Canaan by the Amorites before the Israelites took possession. The excava- Lamps: tions in Pal have furnished thousands of specimens, and have enabled us to trace the development from about 2000 BC onward. The exploration carried out at Lachish (Tell Hesy) and Gezer (Tell Jezer) by the Pal Exploration Fund has given ample material for the purpose, and the numerous examples from tombs all over Pal and Syria have supplied a great variety of forms. : “Lamp” is used in the sense of a guidein Ps 119 105; Prov 6 23, and for the spirit, which is called the lamp of Jeh in man (Prov 20 27), and it of course often signifies the light itself. It is used also for the son who is to succeed and represent his father (1 K 165 4), and it perhaps is employed in this sense in the phrase, “The lamp of the wicked shall be put out” (Job 21 17; Prov 13 9; and perhaps Job 18 6). The early Can. or Amorite lamp was a shallow, saucer-like bowl with rounded bottom and vertical rim, slightly pointed or pinched on one side where the lighted end of the wick was placed (Fig. 1). This form continued into Jew- ish times, but was gradu- ally changed until the spout was formed by drawing the rim of the sides together, forming a narrow open channel, the remainder of the rim being rolled outward and flat- tened (Fig. 2), the bottom being also flattened. This was the early Heb pattern and persisted for centu- ries. The open bowl was gradually closed in, first at the spout, where the rim of one side was lapped over the other, and finally the whole surface was closed with only an orifice in the center for receiving the oil, and at the same time the spout was lengthened. This trausforma- tion is seen in Fig. 3, a lamp of the Seleucid period, or from 300 BC. These lamps have usually a cir- cular foot and sometimes a string-hole on one side. The next development was a circular bowl with a somewhat shorter spout, sometimes being only a bulge in the rim, so that the orifice for the wick falls in the rim, the orifice for filling being quite small 2. Figura- tive Use Lamp: Fig. 5. Lamp Language of NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA at the bottom of a saucer-like depression in the center of the bow]. There is sometimes a loop handle affixed on the side opposite to the spout. Sometimes the handle is horizontal, but commonly vertical (Fig. 4). This form is called Roman, and the bowl is often ornamented with mythological human or animal figures (Fig. 5). Other forms are Lamps: Figs. 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. elongated, having numerous wick holes (Fig. 6). The mythological and animal forms were rejected by the Jews as contrary to their traditions, and they made lamps with various other designs on the bowl, such as vine leaves, cups, scrolls, ete (Figs. 7-11). One very marked Jewish design is the seven- branched candlestick (Ex 25 32) of the temple (Fig. 12). The lamps of the parable of the Ten Virgins were probably similar to these (Mt 25 1 ff). The latest form of the clay lamp was what is called Byzantine, the bowl of which has a large orifice in the center and tapers gradually to the spout (Fig. 13); they are ornamented commonly with a palm branch between the cen- tral orifice and the wick- hole, or with a cross. Sometimes there is an in- scription on the margin (Fig. 13). The words on this read ws xv[piov] deve macwKadrn? Phés kulriou] pheni pasin kalé,“Thelight of the Lord shines to all (beautifully ?7].’ Others read, ‘‘The Lord is my light”; “beautiful light,” etc. These inscriptions determine the period as being Christian. In Rom times, and earlier also, bronze was much used for the finer lamps, often with covers for the orifice and sometimes with chain and ring for hanging (Fig. 14). Very elaborate designs in this material occur. These terra-cotta lamps are found in the tombs and burial places throughout Pal and Syria, and they were evidently de- posited there in connec- tion with the funeral rites. Very few are found in Can. tombs, but they be- come numerous in later times and esp. in the early Christian centuries. The symbolism in their use for funeral purposes is indi- cated by the inscriptions above mentioned (see PEFS, 1904, 326 ff; Er- plorationsin Pal, by Bliss. Macalister and Wunsch, 4to, published by the Pal Exploration Fund). These lamps were used by the peasants of the country downto recent times, when petroleum has superseded olive oil for lighting. The writer has seen lamps of the Jewish and Rom Lamp: Fig. 12. Lamp: Fig. 13. 1826 period with surface blackened with recent usage. Olive oil was commonly used, but terebinth oil also (Thomson, LB, III, 472). H. PorTER LAMPSACUS, lamp’sa-kus. See SampsaMezs. LANCE, lans, LANCER, lan’sér, LANCET, lan’- set. See Armor, ITI, 4, (3); 1 K 18 28 RV “lances.” LAND ([1] PS, ’erec; [2] MATS, ’ddhamah, [3] 71D , sadheh, ‘“‘a piece of land”; [4] yf, gé, “earth”; [5] aypds, agrés, ‘field’; [6] x#pa, chdra, “region”; [7] xeplov, chérion, dim. of chéra; [8] &qpés, zérés, “dry land’; [9] MIS, ’ezrah, “native,” AV “born in the land,” “born among you,” RV ‘home-born” [Lev 19 34; 24 16; Nu 16 30]; “‘like a green tree in its native soil’ [Ps 37 35]): ’Ereg occurs hun- dreds of times and is used in much the same way as ’ddhamah, which also occurs often: e.g. ‘land of Egypt,” ’ereg migrayim (Gen 13 10), and ’adhmath micgrayim (Gen 47 20). The other words occur less often, and are used in the senses indicated above. See Country; Earru. Autrrep Ery Day LAND-CROCODILE (RV), Jand-crok’é-dil (03, koth; LXX yopasdtéwv, chamailéon, Lev 11 30; AV Chameleon): 6h is found only here, meaning an animal, the fifth in the list of unclean ‘creeping things.”’ Elsewhere is it tr4 ‘‘strength” or “power,” and it has been thought that here is meant the desert monitor, Varanus griseus, a gigantic lizard, which is common in Egypt and Pal, and which attains the length of 4 ft. “Chameleon,” which AV has here, is used by RV for tinshemeth (AV ‘‘mole’), the eighth in the list of unclean “creeping things” (ef nasham, ‘‘to breathe”; tr4 “swan” in ver 18 m). While it is by no means certain what animal is meant, there could be no objection to “monitor” or “desert monitor.” ‘‘Land-crocodile”’ is objec- tionable because it is not a recognized name of any animal. See CHAMELEON; LIZARD. Atrrep Exty Day LAND LAWS. See Acrarian Laws. LANDMARK, land’mark (Daag, gbhal, lit. “boundary”): The boundary may have been marked, as at present, simply by a furrow or stone. The iniquity of removing a landmark is frequently insisted on (Dt 19 14; 27 17; Prov 22 28; 23 10; Job 24 2 [g*bhalah]), its removal being equiva- lent to theft. LANE, lan (popm, rhvimé): An alley or bypath ofacity. Occursoncein Lk 14 21, ‘Go out quick- ly into the streets and lanes of the city’; elsewhere tr? “street,” e.g. Mt 6 2; Acts 9 11; Ecclus 9 7; Tob 13 18. LANGUAGE, lan’gw4j, OF THE NEW TESTA- MENT (Greek). See Arnamatc Lanauaag, also: I. aoe VERNACULAR koin€é tHe LANGUAGE OF THE 1. The Old Point of View 2. The Revolution 3. The Proof of the New Position 3) The Papyri ® The Ostraka vs The Inscriptions Modern Greek (5) Historical and Comparative Grammar 4, Characteristics of the Vernacular koing TI. Literary ELEMENTS IN THE III. Tue Semitic Inriuusnce IV. Inpivipvar Pecuriarities oF THE NT Writers V. THE koiné Spoken sy Jesus LITERATURE I. The Vernacular ‘*koine’’ the Language of the NT.—The ghost of the old Purist controversy is now laid to rest for good and all. The story 1827 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 42™? Language of NT of that episode has interest chiefly for the historian of language and of the vagaries of the human in- tellect. See Winer-Thayer, Grammar 1. The Old of the Idiom of the NT, 1869, 12-19, Point of and Schmiedel’s Winer, § 2, for a sketch View of this once furious strife. In the 17th cent. various scholars tried to prove that the Gr of the NT was on a par with the literary Attic of the classic period. But the Hebraists won the victory over them and sought to show that it was Hebraic Gr, a special variety, if not dialect, a Bib. Gr. The 4th ed of Cremer’s Biblico-Theo- logical Lexicon of NT Gr (tr4 by W. Urwick, 1892) quotes, with approval, Rothe’s remark (Dogmatik, 1863, 238): “We may appropriately speak of a language of the Holy Ghost. ‘or in the Bible it is evident that the Holy Spirit has been at work, moulding for itself a distinct- ively religious mode of expressiou out of the language of the country which it has chosen as its sphere, and transforming the linguistic elements which it found ready to hand, and even conceptions already existing, into a shape and form “Appropriate to itself and all its own.”’ : e Cremer adds: have a very clear and striking proof of this in NT Gr.” This was only twenty years ago and fairly repre- sented the opinion of that day. Hatch in 1889 (Essays in Bib. Gr, 34) held that with most of the NT words the key lay in the LXX. But Winer (Winer-Thayer, 20) had long ago seen that the vernacular koiné was “‘the special foundation of the diction of the NT,” though he still admitted “a Jewish-Gr, which native Greeks did not entirely understand” (p. 27). He did not see the practical identity of NT Gr with the vernacular koiné— (“common’” Greek), nor did Schmiedel in the 8. Auflage of Winer (I. Theil; II. Theil, erstes Heft 1894-97). In the second ed of his Grammar of N T Gr (ET by Thackeray, 1905, 2), Blass sees the dawn of the new day, though his book was first written beforeit came. Viteau (tude sur le grec du Nouveau Testament, I, Le verbe, 1893, II, Le sujet, 1896) occupies wholly the old position of a Judaic Gr. An extreme instance of that view is seen in Guuille- mard’s Hebraisms in the Gr Testament (1879). A turn toward the truth comes with H. A. A. Kennedy’s Sources of the NT Gr (1895). He finds the explanation of the vocabulary 2. The of both the LXX and the NT to be Revolution the vernacular which he traces back to Aristophanes. It is a good exercise to read Westcott’s discussion of the “Language of the NT” in DB, III (1888), andthen turn to Moulton, “Language of the NT,” in the 1-vol HDB. West- cott says: ‘The chief peculiarities of the syntax of the NT lie in the reproduction of Heb forms.” Moulton remarks: ‘‘There is noreason to believe that any NT writer who ever lived in Pal learned Gr only as a foreign language when he went abroad.” Still better is it to read Moulton, ‘New Testament Greek in the Light of Modern Discovery” in Cam- bridge Biblical Essays (1909, 461-505); Deiss- mann, Idght from the Ancient Hast (1911); or Angus, “The koiné, the Language of the NT,” Princeton Review, January, 1910, 42-92. The revolution has come to stay. It is now clear that the Gr of the NT is not a jargon nor a patois. In all essential respects it is just the vernacular koiné of the 1st cent. AD, the lingua franca of the Gr- Rom empire, the legacy of Alexander the Great’s conquest of the East. This world-speech was at bottom the late Attic vernacular with dialectical and provincial influences. It was not a decaying tongue, but a virile speech admirably adapted _to the service of the many peoples of the time. The able article in vol IIT of HDB on the ‘‘Language of the NT” by Dr. J. H. Thayer appeared in 1900, and illustrates how quickly an encyclopaedia article may become out of date. There is a wealth of knowledge here displayed, as one would expect, but Thayer still speaks of “this species of Greek,” “this peculiar idiom,” ‘Jewish Greek,” though he sees that its basis is ‘‘the common or spoken Greek.” The last topic discussed by him is “Problems.” He little thought that the biggest “problem” so near solution was the character of the language itself. It was Adolph Deissmann, then of Heidel- berg, now of Berlin, who opened the new era in the knowledge of the language of the NT. His Bibel- studien (zumeist aus den Papyri und Inschrifien zur Geschichte der Sprache, des Schrifitums und der Religion des hellenistischen Judentums und des Urchristentums) appeared in 1895. In this epoch- making volume he proved conclusively from the papyri and the inscriptions that many of the seem- ing Hebraisms in the LXX and the NT were com- mon idioms in the vernacular koiné. He boldly claimed that the bulk of the Hebraisms were falsely so termed, except in the case of translating Gr from the Heb or Aram. or in “perfect’’ Hebraisms, gen- uine Gr usage made more common by reason of similarity to the Sem idiom. In 1897 he produced Neue Bibelstudien, sprachgeschichtliche Beitrage zumetst aus den Papyri und Inschriften zur Er- kldrung des Neuen Testaments. In 1901 (2d ed in 1903) these two volumes were trd as one by A. Grieve under the title Bible Studies. Deissmann's other volumes have confirmed his thesis. The most important are New Light on the NT (1907), The Philology of the Gr Bible (1908), Licht vom Osten (1908), Light from the Ancient East (tr by Strachan, 1910), St. Paul in the Light of Social and Religious His- tory (1912). In Light from the Ancient Fast, Deissmann illustrates the NT language with much detail from the papyri, ostraka and Inscriptions. He is now at work on a new lexicon of the NT which will make use of the fresh knowledge from these sources. The otherwise helpful work of E. Preuschen, Vollstandiges griechisch-deutsches Handwérterbuch zu den Schriften des Neuen Testaments und der uibrigen urchristlichen Literatur (1908-10), fails to utilize the papyri and inscriptions while drawing on the LXX and the NT Apoc and other early Christian literature. But this has been done by Ebeling in his Griechisch-deutsches Wérterbuch zum NT, 1913. The next step was made by A. Thumb, the great philologian, in his Griechische Sprache im Zeitalier des Hellerismus; Beitrége zur Geschichte und Beurteilung der “koinz,” 1901, in which the real character of the koiné was for the first time properly set forth. Winer and Blass had both lamented the need of a grammar of the koing, and that demand still exists, but Thumb went a long way toward supplying it in this volume. It is to he hoped that he will yet prepare a grammar of the koiné. Thumb's interests cover the whole range of comparative philology, but he has added in this field ‘‘Die Forschungen tiber die helle- nistische Sprache in den Jahren 1896-1901," Archiv fir Papyrusforschung, II, 396 f; ‘‘ Prinzipienfragen der Koiné-Forschung,"’ Neue Jahrb. fir das ki. Ailt., 1906; “Die sprachgeschichtliche Stellung des biblischen Griech- isch,’’ Thevlogische Rundschau, V, 85-99. The other most important name to add is that of J. Hope Moulton, who has the credit of being the first to apply the new knowledge directly to the NT Gr. His Grammar of NT Gr, I, Prolegomena (1906, 2d ed, 1906, 3d ed, 1908, Ger. tr in 1911, Hinlei- tung in die Sprache des NT) is a brilliant piece of work and relates the Gr of the NT in careful detail to the vernacular koiné, and shows that in all im- portant points it is the common Gr of the time and not a Hebraic Gr. Moulton probably pressed his point too far in certain respects in his zeal against Hebraisms, but the essential position of Deissmann and Moulton is undoubtedly sound. Moulton had previously published the bulk of this material as ‘‘Grammatical Notes from the Papyri," The Expositor, 1901, 271-82; 1903, 104-21, 423-39; Language of NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1828 The Classical Review, 1901, 31-37, 434-41; 1904, 106- 12, 151-55; ‘‘Characteristics of NT Gr," The Ez- posttor, 1904, In 1909 appeared his essay, Greek in the Light of Modern Discovery (see above). Since 1908, The Expositor has had a series of papers by J. H. Moul- ton and George Milligan called ‘Lexical Notes from the Papyri,’”’ which are very useful on the lexical side of the language. Thus the study is fairly launched on its new career. In 1900, A. T. Robertson produced a Syllabus on the NT _Gr Syn- tax from the standpoint of comparative philology, which was rewritten in 1908, with the added view- point of the papyri researches, as A Short Gram- mar of the Gr NT (2d ed, 1909, 3d ed, 1912; trans- lations in Italian in 1910, Ger. and Fr. in 1911, Dutch in 1912). In October, 1909, S. Angus pub- lished a good article in the Harvard Theological Review on “Modern Methods in NT Philology,” followed in January, 1910, by another in the Prince- ton Review on “The koiné, the Language of the NT.” The new knowledge appears also in Jakob Wacker- nagel, “Die griechische Sprache” (pp. 291-318, 2d ed, of Die griechische und lateinische Literatur wnd Sprache, 1907). LL. Radermacher has set forth very ably “‘die sprachlichen Vorgange in ihrem Zusam- menhang,” in his Neutestameniliche Grammatik: Das Griechisch des Neuen Testaments im Zusammenhang mat der Volkssprache. Itisin reality the background of the NT Gr and is a splendid preparation for the study of the Gr NT. A full discussion of the new knowledge in grammatical detail has been prepared by A. T. Robertson under the title 4 Grammar of the Gr NT in the Light of Historical Research (in press). Moulton and Schmiedel are planning also to complete their works. The proof of the new position is drawn from several sources: (1) The papyri—These rolls have lain in the museums of the world many years and attracted little attention. For lists of the chief 3. The collections of the papyri see Moulton, Proof of Prolegomena, 259-62; Milligan, Se- the New lections from the Gr Papyri, xi, xii; Position Mayser, Grammatik der griechischen Papyrt aus der Ptolemderzeit; Laut- und Wortlehre, vii-x; Deissmann, Light from the Ancient Hast, 20-41; Robertson, Grammar of the Gr NT, Bibliography. New volumes of papyri as a result of recent explorations in Egypt are pub- lished each year. See Papyrus, and in the other encyclopaedias s.v. Most of the papyri discovered belong to the period of the koiné (the first three centuries BC and AD in round numbers), and with great wealth of illustration they show the life of the common people of the time, whether in Egypt or Herculaneum (the two chief regions represented). There are various degrees of culture shown, as can be seen in any of the large volumes of Grenfell and Hunt, or in the handbooks of Lietzmann, Griechische Papyri (1905), and of Milligan, Greek Papyri (1910). They come from the scrap-heaps of the long ago, and are mainly receipts, contracts, letters of busi- ness or love, military documents, etc. They show all grades of culture, from the illiterate with phonetic spelling to the man of the schools. But we have here the language of life, not of the books. Ina most startling way one notes the similarities of vocabulary, forms, and syntax between the lan- guage of the papyri of the Ist cent. AD and that of the NT books. As early as 1778, F. W. Sturz made use of the Charta Borgiana, ‘‘the first papyrus ever brought to Europe” (Deissmann, Light from the Ancient East, 39), and in 1841 Thiersch like- wise saw the value of the papyri for the philology of the LXX. But the matter was not pressed. Lightfoot threw out a hint about the value of letters of the people, which was not followed till Deissmann - saw the point; cf Moulton, Prol., 242. It is not necessary here to illustrate the matter at length. Deissmann takes up in detail the ‘‘Biblical” words in Thayer’s Lexicon, and bas no difficulty in finding most of them in the papyri (or inscriptions). Thus wrnpopopéw, plérophoréd, is shown to be common in the papyri. See Deissmann, Bible Studies and Light from the Ancient East, for extensive lists. The papyri show also the same meanings for many words once thought peculiar to the Bible or the NT. An instance is seen in the official sense of apeofv- repos, presbiteros, in the papyri, 6 mpeoBurepos ris xduns, ho presbiteros tés komés (Pap. Lugd. A 35f), “without doubt an official designation” (Deissmann, Bible Studies, 155). So ddedpés, adelphés, for members of the community, dvacrpo¢, anastrophé, for manner ‘of life, dvrinuyis, antilém- psis, “help,” Aeroupyta, lettourgta, ‘public service,” wdpotxos, pdrotkos, ‘‘sojourner,’ ete (Deissmann, Light from the Ancient East, 107). R. Helbing (Grammatik der Septuaginta, 1908) and H. St. John Thackeray (A Grammar of the OT in Gr according to the LX X, 1909) have applied the new knowledge to the language of the LXX, and it has been dis- cussed with much ability in the first volumes. The use of the papyri for grammatical purposes is made easier by the excellent volume of E. Mayser, Grammatik der griechischen Papyri aus der Ptole- méderzeit; Laut- und Wortlehre (1906), though his “Syntax,” is still a desideratum. Useful also is G. Crénert, Memoria Graeca Herculanensis (1903). (2) The ostraka.—The literature on this subject is still small in bulk. In 1899 Ulrich Wilcken pub- lished Griechische Ostraka aus Aegypten und Nubien, and in 1902 W. E. Crum produced his book of Chris- tian ostraka called Coptic Ostraca from the Collec- tions of the Egypt Exploration Fund, the Cairo Museum, and Others. This was followed in 1905 by H. R. Hall’s Coptic and Gr Teats of the Christian Period from Ostraka, Stelae, etc. These broken pieces of pottery were used by the lowest classes as writing material. It was very widely used because it was so very cheap. Wilcken has done more than anyone else to collect and decipher the ostraka. Deissrnann (Light from the Ancient East, 46) notes that Cleanthes the Stoic “wrote on ostraka or on leather’ because too poor to buy papyrus. So he quotes the apology of a Christian for using potsherd for a letter: ‘“‘“Excuse me that I cannot find papyrus as I am in the country” (Crum, Coptic Ostraca, 55). The use of dréxw, apéchd, on an ostrakon for a receipt in full, illustrates well the frequent use of this word in the NT (Deissmann, Light from the Ancient East, 111). (3) The inscriptions—Here caution must be used since many of the inscriptions give, not the vernacular, but the literary language. The official (legal and military) decrees often appear in very formal style. But a number do preserve the ver- nacular idiom and often have the advantage of being dated. These inscriptions are chiefly on stone, but some are on metal and there are a few wax tablets. The material is vast and is constantly growing. See list of the chief collections in Deiss- mann’s Light fromthe Ancient East, 10-20. Boeckh is the great name here. As early as 1779 Walch (Observationes in Matt. ex graecis_inscriptionibus) made use of Gr inscriptions for NT exegesis, and R. A. Lipsius says that his father (K. H. A. Lipsius, author of Grammatische Untersuchungen viber die biblische Gracitat) “contemplated a large grammar of the Gr Bible in which he would have availed himself of the discoveries in modern epigraphy” (Deissmann, Light, etc, 15). Schmiedel has made good use of the inscriptions so far in his revision of Winer; H. A. A. Kennedy (Sources of NT Gr, 1895), 1829 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Language of NT H. Anz (Subsidia ad Cogn., etc, 1894), R. Helbing (Grammatik der Septuaginia, 1908), J. Psichari (Essai sur le Grec de la Septante, 1908), H. St. John Thackeray (A Grammar of the OT in Gr according to the LXX, 1909), and R. Meister (Prol. zu einer Grammatik der Septuaginia, 1907) turned to good account the inscriptions for the linguistic problems of the LXX, as indeed Hatch (Essays in Bib. Gr, 1889) had already done. W. Dittenberger added some valuable “Grammatica et ortho- graphica” to his Orientis Graeci Inscriptiones Se- lectae (2 vols, 1908, 1905). See also E. L. Hicks and G. F. Hill, Gr Historical Inscriptions (1901), and Hicks’s paper “(On Some Political Terms Em- ployed in the NT,” Classical Review, 1887, 4 ff, 42 ff. W. M. Ramsay’s Cities and Bishoprics of Phrygia (2 vols, 1895, 1897) and his other works show keen insight in the use of the inscriptions. Deissmann’s Bible Studies (1895, 1901) applicd the knowledge of the inscriptions to the L and to the NT. In his Light from the Ancient East (1910) copious use is made of the inscriptions for NT study. Moulton (Prol., 1906, 258 f, for lists) is alive to the value of the inscriptions for NT grammar, as indeed was Blass (Grammatik des neutestamentlichen Griechisch, 1896) before him. Cf, further, G. Thieme, Die Inschriften von Mag- nesia am Mdander und das Neue Testament (1906); 'T. Nigeli, Der Wortschatz des Apostels Paulus (1905), and J. Rouffiac, Recherches sur les caractéres du Grec dans le NT iagnes les Inscr. de Prigne (1911). Special treatises or phases of the grammar of the Iinscrip- tions appear in Meisterhans-Schwyzer, Grammatik der attischen Inschriften (1900); Nachmanson, Laute und Formen der magnetischen Inschriften( 1896); Schweizer, Grammatik der pergamenischen Inschriften (1898). Moulton and Milligan have drawn freely also on the inscriptions for their “Lexical Studies” running in The Expositor (1908-). The value of the in- scriptions for the Gr of the NT is shown at every turn. For instance, mpwréroxos, pratétokos, is no longer a “Biblical” word. It appears in a metrical inscription (undated) of Trachonitis on a tomb of a pagan “high priest” and “friend of the gods” (Deissmann, Light, etc, 88); ef Kaihel, Epigram- mata Graeca, etc, no. 460. Even_dydrn, agape, occurs on a pagan inscription of Pisidia (Papers of the American School of Classical Studies at Athens, 2, 57). See, further, W. H. P. Hatch’s “Some Illustrations of NT Usage from Gr Inserip- tions of Asia Minor,” Journal of Bib. Ivt., 1908, 134-46. ae (4) Modern Greek.—As early as 1834 Heilmeier saw that the modern Gr vernacular went back to the koing (Moulton, Prol., 29), but it is only in _ reeent years that it was clearly seen that the modern Cr of the schools and usually in the newspapers 1s artificial, and not the real vernacular of today. Mullach’s work (Grammatik der griechischen Vul- garsprache, 1856) was deficient in this respect. But Jannaris’ Historical Gr Grammar (1897) carries the history of the vernacular Gr along with the literary style. Hatzidakis, Hinleitwng in die neu- griechische Grammatik, 1892, clears the air very much and connects the modern Gr with the NT. But it is to Thumb that we are indebted for the best |. knowledge of the vernacular (4 dyuorcxy, hé démoatiké) as opposed to the literary language (9 xaSapeiovea, ha katharetiousa) of today. Mitsotakis (Praktische Grammatik, 1891) had treated both together, though Wied (Die Kunst, die neugriechische Volk- sprache) gave only the vernacular. But Wied is only elementary. Thumb alone has given an ade- quate treatment of the modern Gr vernacular, showing its unity and historical contact with the vernacular koin@ (Handbuch der neugriechischen Volkssprache, 1895; Thumb-Angus, Handbook of Modern Greek Vernacular, 1912). Thus one can see the living stream of the NT speech as it has come on down through the ages. It is impossible to overestimate the importance of modern Gr vernacular in the knowledge of NT Gr. The dis- Brean of the optative, the vanishing of the infinitive before ta, hina, and itacism are but in- stances of many others which are luminous in the light of the modern Gr vernacular. See Psichari, Essais de grammaire historique néo-grecque (1886-89). (5) Historical and comparative grammer.—From this source the koin@ gets a new dignity. It will take one too far afield to sketch here the linguistic revolution wrought since the publication of, and partly caused by, Bopp’s Verglachende Gram- matik (1857), following Sir Wm. Joncs’s discovery of Sanskrit. The great work of Brugmann and Delbriick (Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen, I-V, 1892-1909) marks the climax of the present development, though many workers have won distinction in this field. The point to accent here is that by means of comparative philology the Gr language is seen in its proper relations with other languages of the Indo-Germanic family, and the right interpretation of casc, preposition, mode, tense, voice, etc, is made possible. The old traditional empiricism is relegated to the scrap-heap, and a new grammatical science consonant with the facts has taken its place. See Delhriick, Intro to the Study of Language (1882), Giles, Short Manual of Comparative Philology (1901), for a résumé of the facts. Wright, Comparative Grammar of the Gr Language (1912), applies the new learning to the Gr tongue. The progress in classical scholarship is well shown by Sandys in his History of Classical Scholarship (-IiL 1906—- 8) and by Gudeman, Geschichte der klass. Phil- ologie, 2. Aufl, 1909. Innumerahle monographs have enriched the lit. of this subject. It is now feasible to see the Gr language as a whole, and grasp its historical unity. Seen in this light the koiné is not a dying tongue ora corrupt dialect. Itisa normal and natural evolution of the Gr dialects into a world-speech when Alexander’s conquests made it possible. The vernacular koiné which has developed into the moderu Gr vernacular was itself the direct descendant of the Attic vernacular which had its roots in the vernacular of the earlier dialects. The dialectical developments are closely sketched by Thumb, Handbuch der griechischen Dialekte (1909), and by Buck, Intro to the Study of Gr Dialects (1910), not to mention the older works of Hoffmann, Meister, etc. Jannaris has undertaken in his His- torical Gr Grammar (1897) to sketch and interpret the facts of the Gr tongue throughout its long career, both in its literary and vernacular aspects. He has succeeded remarkably well on the whole, though not quite secing the truth about the modern Gr vernacular. Schanz is seeking to lay the founda- tion for still better work by his Beitrdge zur his- torischen Syntax der griechischen Sprache (1882-). But the NT student must be open to all the new light from this region, and it is very great. See, further, Dicterich, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der griech. Sprache von der hellen. Zeit (1898). As already indicated, the Gr of the NT is in the main just the vernacular koiné of the Ist cent. AD, though Gr as used by men of ability 4, Charac- and varying degrees of culture. The teristics of most penne difference between the the Ver- vernacular koiné and the literary nacular Attic is seen in the vocabulary. The “koiné” writers in the literary koing show more likeness to the classic Attic, but even they reveal the changes due to the intervening centuries. There was, of course, no violent break. The changes came gradually and naturally. It is mainly at this point that Deissmann has done such Language of NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1830 brilliant work in his Bible Studies and other books. He has taken the lists of “Biblical” and “ecclesias- tical” words, as given by Cremer and Thayer, and has shown from the papyri, ostraka, inscriptions, or koiné writers that they are not peculiar to the Bible, but belong to the current speech of the time. The proof is so overwhelming and extensive that it cannot be given here. Some words have not yet been found im the non-Bib. koing, but they may be any day. Some few words, of course, belong to the very nature of Christianity (xpeortavés, christianés, for instance), but drécrodos, apédstolos, Barriopss, baptismés, mdpoxos, pdrotkos, cvva- yoyh, sunagogé, and hundreds of others can no longer be listed as “Biblical.” New meanings come to old words also. Cf daudnov, daiménion. It is interesting to note that the NT shows many of the words found in Aristophanes, who caught up the vernacular of his day. The koiné uses more words from the lower strata of society. Aris- totle likewise has many words common in the kotné, since he stands at the parting of the ways between the old dialects and the new koiné of Alex- ander’s conquests. The koiné develops a fondness for compound and even double compound (ses- quipedalian) words; cf, for instance, dvexdipynros, anekdiégétos; dvexdddyros, anekldlétos; dvetepedvntos, anexeretiinétos; dvramoxplvouat, antapokrinomai; olxo- decmérys, oikodespétés; édcybyuxos, oligépsuchos; mpocavaTdypsw, prosanaplér66; svvayridapBdvopar, sunantilambdnomai; brepevrvyxdvu, huperentugchané; xpvaodaxrinios, chrusodaktilios, etc. The use of diminutives is also noteworthy in the koiné as in the modern Gr: cf 6vydrpiov, thugdirion; krwdpov, kli- nérion; xopdovov, kordsion; xuvdptov, kundrion; évdpuv, ondrion; épdpr, opsdrion; mhoidpiov, ploidrion; wriov, dtion, etc. Theformation of words by juxta- position is very common as in rAnpo-dopéw, pléro- phorébd, xetpb-ypagov, cheiré-graphon. In phonetics it is to be noticed that et, o, 9, 7, v, ¢ all had the value of @é in “feet.” This itaclsm was apparent in the early koiné. So ai=e and o and » were not sharply distinguished. The Attic rr became ac, save in a few instances, like éAdrrw, elditd, xpelr- twy, kretiton. The tendency toward de-aspira- tion (cf Jonic) was manifest; cf 颒 édrids, eph’ helpidz, for the reverse process. Elision is lesa fre- quent than in Attic, but assimilation is carried farther. The variable final consonants » and s are used generally before consonants. We find -e- for -te- as in ety, Ovéels, outheis, and ynéels, métheis, are common till 100 BC, when they gradually disappear before ovdels, oudeis, and padels, médets. In general there is less sense of rhythm and more simplicity and clearness. Some of the subtle refinements of form and syntax of the classic did not survive in the koiné vernacular. In accidence only a few points may be noted. In substantives the Ionic -pys, -rés, is frequent. The Attic second declension vanishes. In the third de- clension forms like werav, mikian, show assimilation to the first. Both xdpuv, chérin, and xdpera, chdrita, occur. Contraction is sometimes absent (cf Ionic) as in épéwv, oréon. Adjectives show forms like dopadiv, asphalén, and indeclinable ri%jpns, plérés, appears, and wav, pdn, for wdvra, pdnta (cf péyay, mégan), Svot, dust, for dvotv, duoin. The dual is gone. Even the dual pronouns éxdrepos, hekd- teros, and wérepos, péteros, are rare. Tis, tts, is occasionally used like 8oris, hdstis. “Os édv, hés edn, is more frequent than és av, hés dn, in the Ist cent. AD. The two conjugations blend more and more into one, as the w-forms vanish. There is some confusion in the use of -éw and -ew-verbs, and new presents occur like droxrévyw, apokténnd, énrdvw, optind, otHaw, sléko. The forms ~yivopat, ginomat, yiwéoxw, gindské, are the rule now. There is much increase in aorists like érxa, éscha, and imperfects like efya, eicha. The form -ogav, -osan (exocav, etchosan, €oxocav, éschosan) occasionally appears. Quite frequent is a perfect like dédwxap, dédékan, and the augment is often absent in the plu- perfect as in dedaxe, dedéket. Per contra, a double augment occurs in dmrexarécry, apekaiést?, and a treble augment in #vegxOyoav, Eneéchihésan. The temporal augment is often absent with diphthong as in olxodou46y, oikodométhé. The koiné has -Twoav, -losan, not -vTw», -nién. In syntax the tendency is toward simplicity, to short sentences, the paratactic construction, and the sparing use of articles. The vernacular Koiné avoids both the bombast of Asianism and the artificiality of Atti- cism. There is, indeed, more freedom in violating the rules of concord as to gender, number, and case. The nominativus pendens is common. The com- parative does duty often for the superlative adjec- tive, and the superlative generally has the elative sense. The accusative 1s increasingly common with verbs. The line between transitive and _in- transitive verbs is not a hard-and-fast one. The growth in the use of prepositions both with nouns and in composition is quite noticeable, but some of the older prepositions, like du@t, ampht, are vanish- ing. The cases used with various prepositions are changing. The instrumental use of é», en, is very common. Many new adverbial and prepositional phrases have developed. The optative is nearly dead and the infinitive (apart from the use of rod, lou, év TQ, en 16, els 76, eis t6, with the infinitive) is decaying before tva, hina. The future part. is rare. Mj, mé, begins to encroach on o@, ou, with infinitives and participles. The periphrastic conjugation is specially common. The direct discourse is more frequent than the indirect. The non-final use of ta, hina, is quite noticeable. There are, besides, dialectical and provincial peculiarities, but these do not destroy the real unity of the vernacular koiné any more than do individual traits of separate - writers. Il, Literary Elements in the NT.—Deissmann (Light from the Ancient East, 245) is disposed to deny any literary quality to the NT books save the Ep. to the He. “The Ep. to the He shows us Christianity preparing for a flight from its native levels into the higher region of culture, and we are conscious of the beginnings of a Christian world- literature.” He speaks of it also as ‘a work which seerns to hang in the background like an intruder among the NT company of popular books.’”’ One feels that this is an extreme position and cannot be justified by the facts. It is true that Peter and John were dypdéuparot cal t&rat, agrdémmatot kat idiétat (Acts 4 13), and not men of the schools, but this was certainly not the case with Luke and Paul who were men of literary culture in the truest sense. Luke and Paul were not Atticists, but that artificial idiom did not represent the best type of culture. Deissmann admits that the NT has be- come literature, but, outside of He, he denies any literary quality in its composition. Paul, for in- stance, wrote only “letters,” not “epistles.”’ But Romand Eph confront us. See Milligan, Gr Papyri, xxxi, for a protest against the sweeping statement of Deissmann on this point. One need not go to the extreme of Blass, “Die rhythmische Komposi- tion des Hebr. Briefes,” Theol. Studien und Kritik, 1902, 420-61; Die Rythmen der asiatischen und rémischen Kunstprosa, 1905, to find in Hebrews and Paul’s writings illustrations of the artificial rules of the Asianists. There is undoubtedly rhythm in Paul’s eloquent passages (cf 1 Cor 13, 15), but it is the natural poetic quality of a soul aflame with high passions, not conformity to rules of rhetoric. To deny literary quality to Luke and 1831 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Language of NT Paul is to give a narrow meaning to the word “literary” and to be the victim of a theory. Christianity did make use of the vernacular koiné, the wonderful world-speech so providentially at hand. But the personal equation figured here as always. Men of culture differ in their conversa- tion from illiterate men and more nearly approxi- mate literary style. It is just in Luke, Paul, and the author of He that we discover the literary flavor of men of ability and of culture, though free from artificiality and pedantry. The eloquence of He is that of passion, not of the art of Asianism. Indeed, the Gospels all show literary skill in the use of material and in beauty of language. The Gospel of Jn has the rare elevation and dignity of the highest type of mind. There is no Atticistic tendency in the NT as in Jos, Ant. There is no osing for the present or for posterity. It is the anguage of life, the vernacular in the main, but rising at times from the very force of passion to high plateaus of emotion and imagination and poetic grace from the pens of men of real ability, and in some instances of high culture. Il. The Semitic Influence.—It is no longer pos- sible to explain every variation in the NT from the classic Attic by the term Hebraism. That easy solution has disappeared. Sooth to say, when the true character of the vernacular koiné is understood, there is not very much left to explain. The NT Gr as a rule is just normal koing. Milligan (Gr Papyri, xxx) admits on the part of Moulton “an overtendency to minimize” the “presence of un- doubted Hebraisms, both in language and gram- mar.” That is true, and is due to his strong reac- tion against the old theory of so many Hebraisms. The Semiticisms (Hebraisms and Aramaisms) are very natural results of the fact that the vernacular koiné was used by Jews who read the Heb Bible and the LXX tr, and who also spoke Aram. as their native tongue. The LXX, as tr of Gr, directly from the Heb (or Aram.), has a much greater number of these Semiticisms. See Swete, An Intro to the OT in Gr (1900), for the salient facts. Thackeray in his Grammar of the OT in Gr (1909) shows “‘the xow}—the basis of Septuagint Gr” in §3, and in §4 discusses ‘‘the Sem element in Septuagint Gr.” The matter varies in different parts of the LXX, but in all parts the Sem influence goes far beyond what it is in the NT. In the NT we have free composition in Gr, except in certain portions of the Gospels and Acts where Aram. originals (oral or written) lie beyond the Gr text. So in particular Lk 1, the words of Jesus in Lk 2, and the opening chapters of Acts. See Dalman, Words of Jesus (1902), and J. T. Marshall, “The Aram. Gospel,” Expos, Ser. IV vols H-VIII; see also Aramaic supra, There is, to some extent, translation-Gr, as in the LXX. The quotations from the OT are either from the Heb original, or, a3 most fre- quently, from the LXX. In either case we have translation-Gr again. These two classes cover the more obvious Semiticisms if we add Heb names (persons and places) and other transliterations like &Badiev, abaddin, dddndotia, allélovia. The Gr of the LXX does not, of course, give a true picture of the Gr spoken by the Jews in Alexandria or Pal. But the constant reading of the LXX was bound to leave its impress on the style of the people (cf the King James Version and the Eng. lenguece): The surprise, in fact, is not the number of Semiti- cisms, but, all things considered, the fewness of them. Luke, just because he was a Gentile and so noted the Hebraisms in the LXX, shows rather more of them than the other NT writers: ef mpocééero rotrov méuyat, prosétheto triton pémpsat (Lk 20 12). Some of the points of style so common in the LXX find occasional || in the papyri or inscriptions, like Br\éruv Brérw, blépin bléps, xapG xalpw, chard chatro, 8»... . durév, hon... . autén. Others are more obviously imitations of the Heb style, as in dpécxey dvarriby rivos, aréskein endpidn tinos, rather than dpéoxev roi, aréskein tint. But there is a certain dignity and elevation of style so char- acteristic of the Heb OT that reappears in the NT. The frequent use of «at, kat, in parts of the NT reminds one of the LXX and the Heb waw. There is, besides, an indefinable tone in the NT that is found in the OT. Swete ( Apocalypse of Si. John, cxx) laments the tendency to depreciate unduly the presence of Hebraisms in the NT. The pendulum may have swung too far away from the truth. It will strike the level, but we shall never again be able to fill our grammars and comms. with explana- tions of so many peculiar Hebraisms in the NT. On the whole the Gr NT is standard vernacular koiné. IV. Individual Peculiarities of NT Writers.— There is not space for an extended discussion of this topic. The fact itself calls for emphasis, for there is a wide range in style between Mark’s Gos- pel and He, 1 Pet and Rom, Luke’s Gospel and the Apocalypse. There are no Atticists found in the NT (cf 4 Mace in the LXX and Jos), but there are the less literary writings (Mt, Mk, the Johan- nine books, the other catholic epp.) and the more literary writings (Luke’s writings, Paul’s Epp., and He). But even so, no hard-and-fast line can he drawn. Moulton, Cambridge Biblical Essays, 484, thinks 2 Pet more like the Atticistic writings, “though certainly the Atticists would have scorned to own a book so full of ‘solecisms.’’’ Moulton assumes that 2 Pet is pseudepigraphic, and does not credit the notion that the crude ‘‘Babu’”’ Gr, to use Ab- bott’s term, may be Peter’s own uncorrected style (cf Acts 4 13), while 1 Pet may have the smoothing effect of Silvanus’ hand (cf 1 Pet 6 12). A similar explanation is open concerning the grammatical lapses of the Apocalypse, since John is also called aypdyuaros, agrdmmatos, in Acts 4 13, whereas the Gospel of Jn may have had the revision of the elders of Ephesus (cf Jn 21 24). But whatever the explanation, there is no doubt of the wide di- vergencesof style between different books and groups of books in the NT list. The Lukan, Johannine, Petrine, Pauline groups stand apart, but with cleavages within each group. Harnack (Luke the Physician, 1907; The Sayings of Jesus, 1908; The Acts of the Apostles, 1909; The Date of the Acts of the Apostles, 1911) has accepted and strengthened the contention of Hawkins (Horae Synopticae, 2d ed, 1909) and of Hobart (Medical Language of Luke, 1882) that the medical terms in the Gospel of Luke and of Acts show that the books were written by the same writer and that a physician, and so Luke. The diversities in style here and there are chiefly due to the sources of information used. Even in the Pauline books, which form so well-marked a collection, striking diversities of language and style appear. But these letters cover a period of some 15 years of intense activity and mental and spiritual development, and treat a great variety of topics. They properly reflect the changing phases of Paul’s preaching of the cross of Christ in different places and under varying cir- cumstances and confronting ever fresh problems. The plays of Shakespeare offer a useful parallel. Even in Paul’s old age, in the Pastoral Epistles the stamp of Paul’s spirit is admitted by those who admit erly Pauline fragments; cf J. Weiss, Bei- trége zur Paulinschen Rhetorik (1897). The style is indeed the man, but style is also the function of the subject, and style varies with different periods of a man’s life. E. A. Abbott has made an ex- cellent discussion of the Johannine Vocabulary Languagesof OT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1832 (1905) and of Johannine Grammar (1906), but special grammars of each writer are hardly to be expected or desired. But Nageli has begun a study of Paul’s vocabulary in his Wortschatz des Apostels Paulus (1905). The Gospel of Mt shows very little of that Hebraism that’ one would expect from the general purpose and tone of the book. It is possible, of course, that the supposed original was in Aram., or, if in Gr, of a more Hebraistic type. Whether the present Gr Mt made use of Mark’s Gospel and a collection of Logia (Q), we do not know. Cer- tainly Mark’s Gospel is written in colloquial koiné with little evidence of the culture of the schools. Mark is a faithful reporter and does his work with rare simplicity and vividness. He reveals clearly the Aram. background of Christ’s teaching. The writings of James and Jude do not show that only Gr was spoken in the home at Nazareth, nor that they used only Aram. These two epp. are evidently free compositions in Gr with much of the freshness of imagery so manifest in the parables of Jesus Himself. ‘This brief sketch does not do justice to the richness and variety of language in the books of the NT. V. The ‘‘koine’’ Spoken by Jesus.—See Ara- marc LancuaGg for proof that Jesus spoke that language as the vernacular of the people of Pal. But Christ spoke the koiné also, so that the NT is not an idiom that was unknown to the Master. Gwilliam (1-vol HDB, “Language of Christ’) does still deny that Jesus spoke Gr, while Roberts takes the other extreme in his book, Gr the Language of Christ and His Apostles (1888). Per conira again, Jilicher considers it impossible to suppose that Jesus used Gr (art. “Hellenism” in #B). J. E. H. Thomson, ‘The Language of Pal during the Time of Our Lord” (Temple, Bible Dict.) argues convincingly that Pal was bi-lingual and that Jesus knew and spoke Gr as well as Aram. Peter evi- dently spoke in Gr on the Day of Pentecost and was understood by all. Paul was understood in Jerus when he spoke in Gr (Acts 21 37). Jesus taught in Decapolis, a Gr region, in the region of Tyre and Sidon (Gr again). Galilee itself was largely inhabited by Gentiles who spoke Gr. At the time of the Sermon on the Mount, we read that people were present from Decapolis and Pcraea, besides the mixed multitude from Galilee, Judaea, and Jerus (Mt 4 25; Lk 6 17). Thomson proves also that in Matthew’s Gospel the quotation from the OT in the words of Jesus is from the LXX, while Matthew’s own quotations are from the Heb. The case seems clear. It is not possible to say always when Jesus spoke Gr and when Aramaic. That would depend on the audience. But itis practically certain that Christ Himself knew and spoke at will the vernacular koiné, and thus had this linguistic bond with the great world of that era and with lovers of the Gr Test. today. Lirzraturs.—The lit. on this subject is very exten- sive. The most important volumes have been mentioned in the discussion above. A. T. Ropertson LANGUAGES, lan’gwaj-es, OF THE OLD TESTAMENT: I, Tar Semitic LanouacgEs 1. Members of Semitic Famlly 2. The Name Hebrew 8. Old Hebrew Literature II. History or TRE Hesrew LAnecvuaoEe . Oldest Form of Language The Hebrew of the OT Its Uniformity The Cause Thereof Differences Dune to Age Differences of Style Forelgn Influences Poetry and Prose Home of the Hebrew Language . Its Antiquity . When Hebrew Became a Dead Language ROL SNO oe Mr iad III. Cuizr Cuaaractenristics or HEBREW . Characteristic Sounds . Letters Representing Two Sounds Consonants Representing Vowels The Syllable Three-Letter Roots Conjugations or Derived Stems . Absence of Tenses The Pronouns Formatiou of Nouns . Internal Inflexion . Syntax of the Verb . Syntax of the Noun 13. Poverty of Adjectives IV. BrBricat ARAMAIC 1. Aramaic Portions of the OT - | all ood cael WH SONS OUP oto 2. Phonology 3. Grammar 4. Syntax 5. Aramaic More Decadent than Hebrew V. Lirerary CHARACTERISTICS OF THE SEMITES 1. Concrete and Abstract 2. View of Nature 3. Pictorial Imagination 4. Prose and Poetry 5. Hebrew Easy of Translation LitERATURB There were only two languages employed in the archetypes of the OT books (apart from an Egyp or Pers or Gr word here and there), namely, Heb and Bib. Aram., both of which belong to the great family of languages known as Semitic. I. The Semitic Languages.—The languages spoken in Southwestern Asia during the historical period dealt with in the Bible have been named Shemitic, after the son of Noah from whom the ma- jority of peoples speaking these languages—Arabs, Hebrews, Aramaeans and Assyrians (Gen 10 21 ff) ~—were descended. To show, however, that the description does not fit exactly the thing described— the Elamites and Lydians having probably not spoken a Shemitic language, and the Canaanites, including Phoenicians, with the colonists descended from those at Carthage and elsewhere in the Medi- terranean coast lands, as well as the Abyssinians (Ethiopians), who did, being reckoned descendants of Ham (Gen 9 18; 10 6 ff)—the word is now gen- erally written “Semitic,” aterm introduced by Hich- horn (1787). These languages were spoken from the Caspian Sea to the 8. of Arabia, and from the Mediterranean to the valley of the Tigris. The following list shows the chief members of this family: (1) South Semitie or Arabic, in- 1. Members cluding the language of the Sahaean of Semitic (Himyaritic) inscriptions, as well as Family Ge’ez or Ethiopic. Arab. is now spoken from the Caucasus to Zanzi- bar, and from the East Indies to the Atlantic. (2) Middle Sem or Canaanitish, including Heb, old and new, Phoen, with Punic, and Moabitish (language of MS). (3) North Sem or Aram., including (a) East Aram. or Syrian (language of Syrian Christians), language of Bab Talm, Mandaean;: (6) West or Palestinian Aram. of the Tgs, Palestinian Talm (Gemara), Bib. Aram. (‘‘Chaldee’’), Samaritan, language of Nabataean inscriptions. P (4) Hast Sem—language of Assyr-Bab inscrip- ions. With the exception of a few chapters and frag- ments mentioned below, the OT is written entirely in Heb. In the OT itself this lan- 2. The guage is called “‘the Jews’”’ (2 K 18 26. Name 28). In Isa 19 18 it is called pocti- Hebrew cally, what in fact it was, “the lan- _ guage [Heb “lip”] of Canaan.” In the appendix to the LXX of Job it is called Syriac; and in the introduction to Ecclus it is for the first time—that is, in 130 BC—named Heb. The term Heb in the NT denotes the language of the OT in Rev 9 11, but in Jn 6 2; 19 13.17 this term means the vernacular Aramaic. In other passages it is 1833 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Languages of OT doubtful which is meant. Jos uses the same name for both. From the time of the Tgs, Heb is called “the sacred tongue” in contrast to the Aram. of everyday use. The language of the OT is called Old Heb in contrast to the New Heb of the Mish, the rabbinic, the Spanish poetry, etc. Of Old Heb the remains are contained almost entirely in the OT. A few inscriptions have been recovered, i.e., the Siloam Inscriptions, 3. Old a Heb calendar, a large number of Hebrew ostraka from Samaria, a score of pre- Literature exilic seals, and coins of the Macca- bees and of the time of Vespasian and Hadrian. Literaturs.—EH. Renan, Histoire générale et systems comparé des langues sémitiques; F. Hommel, Die semit. Valker u. Sprachen; the comparative grammars of Wright and Brockelmann; CIS; art. ‘‘Semitic Languages" in Enc Brit, and Murray's Illustrated Bible Dict. Il. History of the Hebrew Language.—Heb as it appears to usin the OT is in a state of decadence corresponding to the present position of spoken Arabic. In the earliest period it no doubt resem- bled the classical Arabic of the 7th and following centuries. The variations found between the various strata of the language occurring in the OT are slight compared with the difference between modern and ancient Arabic. Heb was no doubt originally a highly inflected language, like classical Arabic. The noun had three cases, nom., gen., and acc., end- 1. Oldest ing in um, im, am, respectively, as in Form of the Sabaean inscriptions. Both vbs. Language and nouns had three numbers (sing., dual and pl.) and two genders, masc. and fem. In the noun the dual and pl. had two cases. The dual and 2d and 3d pers. pl. and 2d pers. sing. fem. of the impf. of the vb. ended in nan. In certain positions the m of the endings um, im, am in the noun was dropped. The vb. had three moods, indicative, subjunctive, and jussive, ending in u, a, and - respectively; as well as many forms or stems, each of which had an active and passive voice. In the Heb of the OT most of these inflexions have disappeared. Of the three cases of the noun only the acc. am has survived in a few 2. The adverbial forms, such as ’omnam, Hebrew of “truly.” The dual has entirely dis- the OT appeared from the vb., and also from the noun, with the exception of things that occur in pairs, such as hand, eye, which have no pl. The nom. case of the dual and pl. of the noun has disappeared, and the oblique case is used for both. Except in cases of poetic archaism the final nan of the vb. has been lost,. and, as the final vowels have fallen away in vbs., as well as in nouns, the result is that the jussive forms serve for indic. and subj. also. Many of the forms or stems have fallen into desuetude, and the passive forms of two alone are used. , One of the most remarkable facts connected with the Heb of the OT is that although that lit. extends through a period of over 1,000 years, there is almost no difference betwoen the language of the oldest parts and that of the latest. This phenomenon is susceptible of several explanations. In the first place, nearly the whole of the OT lit. is religious in character, and as such the earliest. writings would become the model for the later, just as the Kor4n —the first prose work composed in Arab. which has survived—has become the pattern for all future compositions. The same was true for many cen- turies of the influence of Aristophanes and Euripides upon the language of educated Greeks, and, it is said, of the influence of Confucius upon that of the learned Chinese. 3. Its Uni- formity But a chief cause is probably the fact that the Sem languages do not vary with time, but with lace. The Arab. vocabulary used 4. The in Morocco differs from that of Egypt, Cause but the Arab. words used in each of Thereof these countries have remained the same for centuries—in fact, since Arab. began to be spoken in them. Similarly, the slight differences which are found in the various parts of the OT are to be ascribed, not to a difference of date, but to the fact that some writers belonged to the Southern Kingdom, some to the Northern, some wrote in Pal, some in Babylonia (cf Neh 13 23.24; Jgs 12 6; 18 3). The OT lit. falls into two main periods: that composed before and during the Bab exile, and that which falls after the exile. But 5. Differ- even between these two periods the ences Due differences of language are compara- to Age tively slight, so that it is often difficult or impossible to say on linguistic grounds alone whether a particular chapter is pre- or post-exilic, and scholars of the first rank often hold the most contrary opinions on these points. For instance, Dillmann places the so-called docu- ment P before D in the regal period, whereas most critics date D about 621 and P about 444 BC. It is needless to add that the various writers differ from one another in point of style, but these var- iations are infinitesimal compared with 6. Differ- those of Gr and Lat authors, and are ences of due, as has been said above, largely Style to locality and environment. Thus the style of Hosea is quite different from that of his contemporary Amos, and that of Deutero-Isa shows very distinctly the mark of its place of composition. A much more potent factor in modifying the lan- guage was the influence of foreign languages upon Heb, esp. in respect to vocabulary. 7. Foreign The earliest of these was probably Influences LEgyp, but of much greater importance was Assyr, from which Heb gained a large number of loan words. It is well known that the Bab script was used for commercial purposes throughout Southwestern Asia, even before the He- brews entered Canaan (see Text), but the influence of Babylon upon Pal seems to have been greatly exaggerated. The main point of contact is in the mythology, which may have been common to both peoples. In the later, esp. post-exilic stages of the language, many Aramaisms are found in respect to syntax as well as vocabulary; and in later phases still, Pers and even Gr words are found. As in other languages, so in Heb, the vocabulary of the poetical lit. differs from that of the prose writers. In Heb, however, there is 8. Poetry not the hard-and-fast distinction be- and Prose tween these two which obtains in the classics. _ Whenever prose becomes elevated by the importation of feeling, it falls into a natural rhythm which in Heb constitutes poetry. Thus most of the so-called prophetical books are poetical in form, Another mark of poetry is a return to archaic grammatical forms, esp. the restoration of the final nan in the vb. The form of Sem which was indigenous in the land of Canaan is sometimes called Middle Sem. Before the Israclites entered the 9. Home of country, it was the language of the the Hebrew Canaanites from whom the Hebrews Language took it over. That Heb was not the language of Abraham before his migra- tion appears from the fact that he is called an Aramaean (Dt 26 5), and that Laban’s native language was Aramaic (Gen 31 47). , lap- idhath, “flames,” ‘torches’; AV_ Lapidoth): eborah’s husband (Jgs 4 4). The Heb name is a fem. pl. like Jeremoth (1 Ch 7 8), Naboth (1 K 211). The pl. is probably intensive. Jewish interpreters have identified Lappidoth (‘flames’’) with Barak (‘lightning’). Some have taken the words rendered “wife of Lappidoth”’ (ésheth lap- pidhath) as a description of Deborah, and have tr? them, ‘woman of lights,” i.e. maker of wicks for the sanctuary; or “woman of flames,” referring to her prophetic zeal. These explanations are more interesting than probable. Joun A. LEEs LAPWING, lap’ wing (MD°357, dukhiphath; trop, épops): A tr used in early VSS, now universally admitted to beineorrect. The lapwing had a crest, and resembled in size and color the hoopoe (Upupa epops). It appears in the lists of abominations only (Lev 1119 AV and Dt 1418 AV, RV Hoopor, q.v.). The lapwing is a plover, and its flesh and eggs are delicious food. LASCIVIOUSNESS, la-siv’i-us-nes (aeéAyeua, asélgeia, ‘‘licentiousness,” ‘‘wantonness,” ‘“un- bridled lust,” ‘“shamelessness,”’ “outrageousness”) : Etymologists assign three probable sources of aselgeia, viz.: (1) from_a compound of a priv. and Zeayn, Sélgé, a Pisidian city whose inhabitants accord- ing to Thayer (NT Lexicon) “excelled in strictness of morals,’ but according to ,. Trench a place whose people ‘were infa- mous for their vices'’; (2) from a compound of a intense, and gaacyeiv, salagetn, ‘to raise a disturbance or noise’’: (3) from a compound of a priv. and c¢Ayuw, sélgd, or GéAyw, thélgo, ‘exciting disgust or displeasure."’ It evidently means conduct and character that is unhecoming, inde- cent, unrestrainedly shameless. 1. Sources Mk uses it in 7 22 with uncertainty as to the vice meant. Paul (2 Cor 12 21) classes it with un- cleanness and fornication as sins to be 2. As Used repented of; also (Gal 5 19; ef Wisd inthe NT 14 26, ‘“wantonness”) puts it in the same catalogue with other works of the flesh; and (Eph 4 19) he refers to some aged . ones so covetous that they made trade of them- selves by giving “themselves up to lasciviousness.”’ The same word is tr4 ‘“‘wantonness” in Rom 13 13, meaning wanton manner, filthy words, unchaste movements of the body. Peter (1 Pet 4 3) men- tions those who “walked in lasciviousness, lusts, winebibbings, revellings, carousings, and abominable idolatries.”” He speaks (2 Pet 2 2) of “lascivious doings” (AV “pernicious ways”); (2 7) “lascivious life’ (AV “filthy conversation”); and (2 18) of “Jasciviousness” (AV “‘wantonness’’), as a means “to entice in the lusts of the flesh.” Jude ver 4 probably does not refer to any form of sensuality in using the word descriptive of ‘ungodly men” Lasea Latin Version, oi@ THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1840 who perverted the faith of some and denied our ouly Master. Witutiam Eywarp RarretTy LASEA, la-sé’a (Adcaa, Ldsaia): A town on the 8. coast of Crete, 5 miles E. of Fair Havens (Acts 27 8). The ruins were examined in 1856 by Rev. G. Brown (see CH [Sé.P], ch xxii, 640). If St. Paul’s ship was detained long at this anchorage, it would be necessary to purchase stores from Lasea; and this in addition to the inconvenience of the roadstead (see Farr Havens) would probably ex- plain the captain’s reluctance to winter there. LASHA, 1a’sha (90>, lasha‘): A place named on the southern boundary of the Canaanites along with Gomorrah, Adnah and Zeboiim (Gen 10 19). Onom identifies it with the hot springs at Callir- rhoé in Wady Zerkad Ma‘in, on the E. of the Dead Sea; in this agreeing with Tg Jerus. This position, however, seems too far to the N., and possibly the site should be sought on the W. of the Arabah. The absence of the article (cf Josh 15 2) prevents identification with the promontory el-Lisén, which tuns into the sea from the eastern shore. Well- hausen (Comp. des Hex., 15) thinks we should read nw, lésham, as the letters ‘2 (m) and ¥ (°) are like each other in their Palmyrene form. We should then have indicated the boundary from Gaza to the Dead Sea, and then from the Dead Sea to Leshem, ie. Dan. This is very precarious. No _identifi- cation is possible. W. Ewine LASSHARON, la-sha’ron, la-shar’on gangs, lashsharon or la-sharén, AV Sharon): A royal city of the Canaanites taken by Joshua, named with Aphek (Josh 12 18). Possibly we should here follow the reading of LX X (B), “‘the king of Aphek in Sharon.’ Onom (s.v. ‘“Saron’’) mentions a region between Mt. Tabor and the Lake of Tiberias called Sarona. This is probably represented by the ancient site Sarona, on the plateau 63 miles 8.W. of Tiberias. If MT is correct, this may be the place intended. LAST DAY. See Day, Last. LAST DAYS. See Escuatonocy or tHe OT. LAST TIME, TIMES (kxaipis tcyaros, kairés éschatos, xpovos tryaros, chrénos éschatos [also 1.], frxarov tod xpdvov, éschaton tov chrénou, dpa éoxdrn, héra eschdté): In AV this phrase occurs in 1 Pet 15; 1 20 (pl.); 1 Jn 2 18; Jude ver 18. RV has, in 1 Pet 1 20, “at the end of the times,’ and in 1 Jn 2 18, ‘‘the last hour,’”’ in closer adherence to the Gr. The conception is closely allied to that of ‘‘the last day,” and, like this, has its root in the OT conception of ‘the end of days.”’ In the OT this designates the entire eschatological period as that which the present course of the world is to issue into, and not, as might be assumed, the closing section of history. It is equivalent to what was later called “the coming aeon” (see Escuatotocy or THE NT). In the NT, on the other hand, the phrase ‘‘the last time” does mark the concluding section of the present world-period, of the present aeon. _ In three of the NT passages the consciousness expresses itself that these “last times’’ have arrived, and that the period extending from the appearance or the resurrection of Christ until His Second Coming is the closing part of the present age, that the writer and readers are living in “the last times.” In one passage (1 Pet 1 5) “the last time” is projected farther forward into the future, so that it comes to mean the’ time immediately preceding the reappearance of Christ. Both usages can be readily explained. The days of the Messiah were to the OT writers part of the future world, although to the later Jew- ish chiliasm they appeared as lying this side of it, because differing from the world to come in their earthly and temporal character. To the early Christians the days of the Messiah appeared more closely assimilated in character to the future world, so that no reason existed on this score for not in- cluding them in the latter. Still it was also real- ized that the Messiah in His first appearance had not brought the full realization of the coming world, and that only His return from heaven would con- summate the kingdom of God. Accordingly, the days in which they lived assumed to them the char- acter of an intermediate period, marked off on the one hand from the previous development by the appearance of the Messiah, but equally marked off from the coming aeon by His reappearance in glory. From a formal point of view the representation resembles the Jewish chiliastic scheme, but with a twofold substantial difference: (a) the chiliastic scheme restricts the Messiah and His work to the last days, and does not carry Him over into the coming world, whereas to the Christian the coming world, no less than the last days, is thoroughly Messianic; (b) to the Jewish point of view both the days of the Messiah and the coming world lie in the future, whereas to the Christian the former have already arrived. It remained possible, however, from the Christian point of view to distinguish within the last times themselves between the imme- diate present and the future conclusion of this period, and this is done in 1 Pet 1 5. Also in 1 Jn 2 18 the inference that “the last hour’ has come is not drawn from the presence of the Mes- siah, but from the appearance of the anti-Christian power, so that here also a more contracted concep- tion of the last stage of history reveals itself, only not as future (1 Pet 1 5), but as present thence ‘hour’? not “time’’). For literature see EscHaToLocy oF THE NT. EERHARDUS Vos LASTHENES, las’the-néz (Aacdévys, Lasthénés): A highly placed official under King Demetrius II, Nicator. He is called the king’s “kinsman” (AV “cousin’’) and “father” (1 Macc 11 31.32; Jos, Ant, XIII, iv, 9), but these are to be taken as court titles rather than as denoting blood-relationship. According to Jos (Ani, XIII, iv, 3) he was a native of Crete, and raised an army for the king when he made his first descent upon the coast, and rendered him ultimately successful in wresting the throne of Syria from Alexander Balas (1 Macc 10 67; Ant, XII, iv, 3). The letter addressed to L. indicates that he was probably prime minister or grand vizier of the kingdom. J. Hurcuison LATCHET, lach’et (JIWW, serakh; twas, himds): Leather thong used for tying on sandals (see Gen 14 23; Mk17||). The stooping to untie the dusty shoe-latchet was esteemed by Orientals a service that was at once petty and defiling, and was usually assigned to menials. LATIN, lat’in: Was the official language of the Rom Empire as Gr was that of commerce. In Pal Aram. was the vernacular in the rural districts and remoter towns, while in the leading towns both Gr and Aram. were spoken. These facts furnish the explanation of the use of all three tongues in the inscription on the cross of Christ (Mt 27 37; Mk 15 26; Lk 23 38; Jn 19 19). Thus the charge was written in the legal language, and was techni- cally regular as well as recognizable by all classes of the people. The term “Latin” occurs in the NT only in Jn 19 20, ‘Pwyaicrl, Rhomaisti, and in Lk 23 1841 38, ‘Pwyatkots (ypdupacw), Rhomaikots (grdémmasin), according to NX ADN. It is probable that Tertullus made his plea against Paul before Felix (Acts 24) in Lat, though Gr was allowed in such provincial courts by grace of the judge. It is probable also that Paul knew and spoke Lat; ef W. M. Ramsay, Pauline and Other Studies, 1906, 65, and A. Souter, “Did Paul Speak Lat?” Eapos, April, 1911. The vernacular Lat had its own history and develop- ment with great influence on the ecclesiastical ter- minology of the West. See W. Bury, ‘The Holy Latin Tongue,” Dublin Review, April, 1906, and Ronsch, [tala und Vulgata, 1874, 480f. There is no doubt of the mutual influence of Gr and Lat on each other in the later centuries. See W. Schulze, Graeca Latina, 1891; Viereck, Sermo Graecus, 1888. : It is doubtful if the Lat syntax is clearly per- ceptible in the koiné (see LANGUAGE OF THE NT). : Deissmann (Light from the Anctent East, 117 f) finds rte Sidwur, ergastan didémi (operam dare) in an aeremenus papyrus letter of the vulgar type from 2d cent. BC (cf Lk 12 58). A lead tablet in Amorgus has «pive td dixarav, krind t6 dikaion (cf Lk 12 57). The papyri (2d cent. AD) give cuvaipw Adyor, sunatra légon (cf Mt 18 23f). Moulton (Ezpos, February, 1903, 115) shows that 7d ixavdv maecv, 16 hikanén potein (satisfacere), is as old as Polybius. Even ovp- BovdArov Aap Bdvew, sumbodtlion lambénein (concilium capere), may go with the rest like ob oy, s% épss (Mt 27 4), for wideris (Thayer). Moulton (Prol., 21) and Thumb (Griechische Sprache, 121) consider the whole matter of syntactical Latinisms in the NT inconclusive. But see also C. Wessely, ‘Die lateinischen Elemente in der Gricitit d. agypt. Papyrusurkunden,”’ Wien. Stud., 24; Laforcade, Influence du Latin sur le Grec, 83-158. There are Lat words in the NT: In particular Lat proper names like Aquila, Cornelius, Claudia, Clemens, Crescens, Crispus, Fortunatus, Julia, Junia, etc, even among the Christians in the NT besides Agrippa, Augustus, Caesar, Claudius, Felix, Festus, Gallo, Julius, etc. Besides wefind in the NT current Lat commercial, financial, and official terms like docdpiov, assdrion (as), 8nvdpiovy, déndrion (denarius), Kevruplwy, ken- turion (centurio), Kijvoos, kénsos (census), xodpdvrys, kodrdntés (quadrans), Kohwvia, kolonia (colonia), xovoerwdla, kaustodta (custodia), Aeyedv, legedn (legio), Avriov, léntion (linteum), dBeprives, labertinas (liber- tinus), dtrpa, litra (litra), udxeddov, mdkellon (macel- lum), peuBpdva, membrana (membrana), pldor, milion (mille), wbd0s, médios (modius), éorns, xéstés (sex- tarius), Tparépor, prattorion (praetorium), oixdpws, sikdrios (stcarius), opextyOov, simikinthion (semi- cinctium), covddpv, souddrion (sudarium), omexov- Adrwp, spekouldtor (speculator), rafépra, tabérna (taberna), rirdos, thtlos (titulus), peddvys, phelénes (paenula), ¢bpov, phéron (ferum), dpayéddor, phra- géllion (flagellum), dparyehdbw, phragell6é (flagelio), xdprns, chdrtés (charta ?), x@pos, chéros (chorus). Then we meet such adjectives as ‘Hpwdvavel, Heéradianot, Pdirrjowm, Philippésiot, Xpirriavol, Christianot, which are made after the Lat model. Mark’s Gospel shows more of these Lat words out- side of proper names (cf Rom 16), as is natural if his Gospel were indeed written in Rome. See also Latin Version, THE OLD. Lrrerarurs.—Besides the lit. already mentioned see Schtirer, Jewish People in the Time of Christ, Div II, vol I, 43 ff; Krauss, Griechische und lateinische Lehn- wérter im Talmud (1898, 1899); Hoole, Classical Ele- ment in the NT (1888); Jannaris, Historical Gr Grammar (1897); W. Schmid, Atticismus, etc (1887-97); Kapp, Latinismis merito ac falso susceptis (1726); Georgi, De Latinismis NT (1733); Draeger, Historische Syntax der lat. Sprache (1878-81); Pfister, Vulgdrlatein und Vulgdr=- griechisch (Rh. Mus., 1912, 195-208). A. T. Ropertson LATIN VERSION, THE OLD: I. The Motive of Translation ——_—s_ 2. Multipliclty of Latin Translations in the 4th Century 3. The Latin Bible before Jerome 4, First Used in North Africa THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lasea Latin Version, Old . Cyprian's Bible . Tertullian's Blble ‘ . Possible Eastern Origln of Old Latin . Classification of Old Latin MSS . Individual Character!stics 10. Value of Old Latin for Textual Criticism Lirararura The claim of Christianity to be the one true reli- gion has carried with it from the beginning the obli- gation to make its Holy Scriptures, 1. The’ containing the Divine message of sal- . Motive of vation and life eternal, known to all Translation mankind. Accordingly, wherever the first Christian evangelists carried the gospel beyond the limits of the Gr-speaking world, one of the first requirements of their work was to give the newly evangelized peoples the record of God's revelation of Himself in their mother tongue. It was through the LXX tr of the OT that the great truths of revelation first became known to the Gr and Rom world. It is generally agreed that, as Christianity spread, the Syr and the Lat VSS were the first to be produced; and tr* of the Gospels, and of other books of the Old and NT in Gr, were in all probability to be found’in these languages before the close of the 2d cent. Of the earliest translators of the Bible into Lat no record has survived. Notwithstanding the care- ful investigations of scholars in recent OOD or 2. Multi- years, there are still many questions plicity of relating to the origin of the Lat Bible Latin to which only tentative and provisional Transla- answers can be given. It is therefore tions in the more convenient to begin a study of 4th Century its history with Jerome toward the close of the 4th cent. and the com- mission intrusted to him by Pope Damasus to pro- duce a standard Lat version, the execution of which gave to Christendom the Vulg (see VuLGaTE). The need for such a version was clamant. There existed by this time a mutiplicity of tr® differing from one another, and there was none possessed of commanding authority to which appeal might be made in case of necessity. It was the consideration of the chaotic condition of the existing tr®, with their divergences and variations, which moved Damasus to commission Jerome to his task and Jerome to undertake it. We learn particulars from the letter of Jerome in 383 transmitting to his patron the first instalment of his revision, the Gos- pels. “Thou compellest me,” he writes, “to make a new work out of an old so that after so many copies of the Scriptures have been dispersed throughout the whole world I am as it were to occupy the post of arbiter, and seeing they differ from one another am to determine which of them are in agreement with the original Gr.” Anticipating attacks from critics, he says, further: ‘If they maintain that con- fidence is to be reposed in the Lat exemplars, let them answer which, for there are almost as many copies of tr® as MSS. _ But if the truth is to be sought from the majority, why not rather go back to the Gr original, and correct the blunders which have been made by incompetent translators, made worse rather than better by the presumption of unskilful correctors, and added to or altered by careless scribes?” Accordingly, he hands to the Pontiff the four Gospels to begin with after a care- ful comparison of old Gr MSS. From Jerome’s contemporary, Augustine, we obtain a similar picture. “Translators from Heb into Gr,’”’ he says (De Doctrina Christiana, ii.11), “can be numbered, but Lat translators by no means. For whenever, in the first ages of the faith, a Gr MS came into the bands of anyone who had also a little skill in both languages, he made bold to translate it forthwith.’”’ In the same context he mentions “‘an innumerable variety of Lat transla- Latin Version, Old TW" INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA aver tors,” “a, crowd of translators.”? His advice to read- ers is to give a preference to the Itala, “which is more faithful in its renderings and more intelligible in its sense.’ What the Itala is, has been greatly discussed. Formerly it was taken to be a summary designation of all the VSS before Jerome’s time. But Professor Burkitt (Texts and Studies, IV) strongly urges the view that by this term Augustine designates Jerome’s Vulg, which he might quite well have known and preferred to any of the earlier trs. However this may be, whereas before Jerome there were those numerous tr*, of which he and Augustine complain, after Jerome there is the one preéminent and commanding work, produced by him, which in course of time drove all others out of the field, the great Vulg edition, as it came to be called, of the complete Lat Bible. We are here concerned with the subject of the Lat Bible before the time of Jerome. The MSS which have survived from the earlier 3. The period are known by the _ general Latin designation of Old Latin. When we Bible ask where these first tr® came into ex- before istence, we discover a somewhat sur- Jerome prising fact. It was not at Rome, as we might have expected, that they were first required. The language of Christian Rome was mainly Gr, down to the 3d cent. St. Paul wrote the Ep. to the Romin Gr. When Clem- ent of Rome in the last decade of the Ist cent. wrote an ep. in the name of the Roman church to the Corinthians, he wrote in Gr. Justin Martyr, and the heretic Marcion, alike wrote from Rome in Gr. Out of 15 bishops who presided over the Rom see down to the close of the 2d cent., only four have Lat names. Even the pagan emperor Marcus Aurelius wrote his Meditations in Gr. Ii there were Christians in Rome at that period whose only lan- guage was Lat, they were not sufficiently numer- ous to be provided with Christian literature; at least none has survived. It is from North Africa that the earliest Lat lit- erature of the church has come down to us. The church of North Africa early received 4, First a baptism of blood, and could point Used in to an illustrious roll of martyrs. It North had also a distinguished list of Lat Africa authors, whose Lat might sometimes be rude and mixed with foreign idioms, but had a power and a fire derived from the truths which it set forth. One of the most eminent of these Africans was Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, who won the martyr’s crown in 257. His genuine works consist of a num- ber of short treatises, or tracts, and numerous letters, all teeming with Scripture quotations. It is certain that he employed a version then and there in use, and it is agreed that “his quotations are carefully made and thus afford trustworthy standards of African Old Latin in a very early though still not me earliest stage” (Hort, Intro to the NT in Gr, 8). Critical investigation has made it clear that the version used by Cyprian survives in a fragmentary copy of St. Mark and St. Matthew, 6. Cyprian’s now at Turin in North Italy, called Bible Codex Bobbiensis (k), and in the frag- ments of the Apocalypse and Acts contained in a palimpsest at Paris called Codex Floriacensis (h). It has been found that another MS, Codex Palatinus (e) at Vienna, has a text closely akin to that exhibited in Cyprian, although there are traces of mixture init. The text of these MSS, together with the quotations of the so-called Speculum Augustini (m),is known among scholars as African Old Latin. Another MS with an inter- esting history, Codex Colbertinus (c) contains also 1842 a valuable African element, but in many parts of the Gospels it stdes also with what is called the European Old Latin more than with k ore. Codex Bobbiensis (k) has heen edited with a learned in- troduction in the late Bishop John Wordsworth’s Old Latin Bib. Texts, the relation of & to Cyprian as well as to other Old Latin texts being the subject of an elaborate investigation by Professor Sanday. That Cyprian, who was not acquainted with Greek, had a written version before him which is here identified is certain, and thus the illustrious bishop and martyr gives us a fixed point in the history of the Lat Bible a century and a half earlier than Jerome. We proceed half a century nearer to the fountain- head of the African Bible when we take up the tes- timony of Tertullian who flourished 6. Tertul- toward the close of the 2d cent. He lian’s Bible differed from Cyprian in being a com- petent Gr scholar. He was thus able to translate for himself as he made his quotations from the LXX or the Gr NT, and is thus for us by no means s0 safe a witness to the character or exist- ence of a standard version. Professor Zahn (GK, I, 60) maintains with considerable plausibility that before 210-240 AD there was no Lat Bible, and that Tertullian with his knowledge of Gr just tr¢ as he went along. In this contention, Zahn is not sup- ported by many scholars, and the view generally is that while Tertullian’s knowledge of Gr is a dis- turbing element, his writings, with the copious quotations from both OT and NT, do testify to the existence of a version which had already been for some time in circulation and use. Who the African Wycliffe or Tindale was who produced that version has not been recorded, and it may in fact have been the work of several hands, the result, as Bishop Westcott puts it, of the spontaneous efforts of African Christians (Canon of the NT7, 263). Although the evidence has, up to the present time, been regarded as favoring the African origin of the first Lat tr of the Bible, recent investi- 7. Possible gation into what is called the Western Eastern text of the NT has yielded results Origin of pointing elsewhere. It is clear from Old Latin a comparison that the Western type of text has close affinity with the Syr witnesses originating in the eastern provinces of the empire. The close textual relation disclosed between the Lat and the Syr VSS has led some authorities to believe that, after all, the earliest Lat version may have been made in the East, and possibly at Antioch. But this is one of the problems awaiting the discovery of fresh material and fuller investiga- tion for its solution. We have already noticed the African group, so designated from its connection with the great African Fathers, Tertullian and esp. 8. Classi- Cyprian, and comprising k, e, and to fication of some extent h and m. The antiquity Old Latin of the text here represented is attested MSS by these African Fathers. When we come down to the 4th cent. we find in Western Europe, and esp. in North Italy, a second type of text, which is designated European, the precise relation of which to the African has not been clearly ascertained. Is this an independent text which has arisen on the soil of Italy, or is it a text derived by alteration and revision of the African as it traveled north- ward and westward? This group consists of the Codex Vercellensis (a) and Codex Veronensis (b) of the 4th or 5th cent. at Vercelli and Verona re- spectively, and there may be included also the Codex Vindobonensis (2) of the 7th cent. at Vienna. These give the Gospels, and a gives for St. John the text as it was read by the 4th-cent. Father, Lucifer 1843 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Latin Version, Old Laver of Cagliari in Sardinia. The Lat of the Gr-Lat MS D (Codex Bezae) known as d, and the Lat of the translator of Irenacus are classed with this group. Still later, Professor Hort says from the middle of the 4th cent., a third type, called Italic from its more restricted range, is found. It is represented by Codex Brixianus (f) of the 6th cent., now at Brescia, and Codex Monacensis (g) of the 7th cent., at Munich. This text is probably a modified form of the European, produced by revision which has brought it more into accord with the Gr, and has given it a smoother Lat aspect. The group has received this name because the text found in many of Augustine’s writings is the same, and as he expressed a preference for the Itala, the group was designated accordingly. Recent investigation tends to show that we must be careful how we use Augustine as an Old Latin authority, and that the Itala may be, not a pre-Vulg text, but rather Jerome’s Vulg. This, however, is still uncertain; the fact remains that as far as the Gospels are con- cerned, f and g represent the type of text most used by Jerome. That all these groups, comprising in all 38 codices, go back to one original is not impossible. Still there may have been at first local VSS, and then an official version formed out of them. When 9. Indi- Jerome’s revision took hold of the vidual church, the Old Latin representatives Character= for the most part dropped out of notice. istics Some of them, however, held their ound and continued to be copied down to the 12th and even the 13th cent. Codex cis an example of this; it is a MS of the 12th cent., but as Professor Burkitt has pointed out (Texts and Studies, IV, “Old Latin,” 11) “it came from Lan- guedoc, the country of the Albigenses. Only among heretics isolated from the rest of Western Christianity could an Old Latin text have been written at so late a period.’ An instance of an Old Latin text copied in the 13th cent. is the Gigas Holmiensis, quoted as Gig, now at Stockholm, and so called from its great size. It contains the Acts and the Apocalypse of the Old Latin and the rest of the NT according to the Vulg. It has to be borne in mind that in the early centuries complete Bibles were unknown. Each group of books, Gos- pels, Acts and Catholic eae Pauline Epp., and Rev for the NT, and Pent, Historical Books, Pss and Prophets for the OT, has to be regarded sepa- rately. It is interesting, also, to note that when Jerome revised, or even retranslated from the LXX, Tob and Jth of the Apoc, the greater number of these books, the Wisd, Ecclus, 1 and 2 Macc, and Bar were left unrevised, and were simply added to the Vulg from the Old Latin version. : ; These Old Latin tr® going back in their earliest forms to nearly the middle of the 2d cent. are very early witnesses to the Gr text from 10. Value which they were made. They are of Old Latin the more valuable inasmuch as they for Textual are manifestly very literal tr. Our Criticism great uncial MSS reach no farther back than the 4th cent., whereas in the Old Latin we have evidence—indirect. indeed and requiring to be cautiously used—reaching back to the 2d cent. The text of these MSS is neither dated nor localized, whereas the evidence of these VSS, coming from a particular province of the church, and being used by Fathers whose period is definitely known, enables us to judge of the type of Gr text then and there in use. In this con- nection, too, it is noteworthy that while the vari- ations of which Jerome and Augustine complained were largely due to the blunders, or natural mis- takes, of copyists, they did sometimes represent various readings in the Gr originals. Lrrpraturse.—Wordsworth and White, Old Latin Biblical Texts, 4 vols; F. C. Burkitt, ‘‘The Old Latin and the Itala,’’ Texts and Studies, IV; ‘‘Old Lat VSS" by H. A. A. Kennedy in HDB; ‘“ Bibeliibersetzungen, Lateinische’’ by Fritzsche-Nestle in PRE; Intros to Textual Criticism of the NT by Scrivener, Gregory, Nestle, and Lake. T. Nrcou LATTER DAYS. Sce Escuatoioey or THE OT. LATTICE, lat’is. See Hovuss, II, 1, (9). LAUD, léd: A vb. meaning “‘to praise,’’ used in Rom 15 11 AV,and Ps 117 1; 145 4. RV cither should have avoided the word altogether or else should have used it much more acer a ame preferably the latter, as the word is not obsolete in liturgical Eng. LAUGHING-STOCK, Jaf’ing-stok: Something set up to be laughed at; thrice in RV the tr of PpInw, shok, “laughter,” ete (Job 12 4 bis; Jer 20 7; cf Jer 48 26.27.39; Lam 3 14). See Mock, Mocxina. LAUGHTER, laf’tér (PO, ¢ahak, POW, sahak, “to laugh,” PINW, shok, “laughter”; yeddw, geldo, karayehdw, katageldd): (1) Laughter as the expres- sion of gladness, pleasurable surprise, is the tr of cGhak (Gen 17 17; 18 12.13.15; 21 6), which, however, should perhaps be “laugh at me,’’ not “with me,” as AV and RV (so Delitzsch and others; see also Hastings in HDB), not in the sense of derision, but of surprise and pleasure. In the same ver for “God hath made me to laugh,” RV gives in m, “hath prepared laughter for me,” and this gave his name to the son, the promise of whose birth evoked the laughter (Yighak, Isaac); gelad (Lk 6 21.25) has the same meaning of gladness and rejoicing; s°hdk, “laughter,’’ has also this sense (Job 8 21; Ps 126 2). It is, however, “laughed to scorn” in Job 12 4; RV “laughing-stock’’; so Jer 20 7; cf 48 26.27.39; Lam 3 14, “derision.” (2) Sahak is used (except Job 29 24; Eccl 3 4) in the sense of the laughter of defiance, or derision (Job 5 22; 41 29); in Piel it is often tr? “play,” “play- ing,’ “merry.” (8) ZLé'agh is “to scorn,” “to laugh to scorn” (2 K 19 21; Neh 2 19); sdhak has also this sense (2 Ch 30 10); ¢thok (Ezk 23 32); sthok (Job 12 4); katagelad (Mt 9 24; Mk 6 40; Lk 8 53); the simple gelad occurs only in Lk 6 21.25; see above. Katagelad is found in Jth 12 12, “laugh to scorn” (Ecclus 7 11; 20 17; 1 Macc 10 70, RV ‘‘derision’’). For “laugh” (ob 9 23) RV has “mock”; for “mocked of his neighbor” and “laughed to scorn’’ (Job 12 4) “laughing-stock”; for “shall rejoice in time to come” (Prov 31 25), “Jaugheth at the time to come’; “laughter’’ for “laughing” (Job 8 21). W.L. Watker LAUNCH, lanch, lénch. See Suips ann Boars, IH, 1. LAVER, la’vér (19, kiyor): Every priest in attendance on the altar of Jeh was required to wash his hands and his feet before entering 1. In the upon his official duties (Ex 30 19 ff). Tabernacle To this end a laver was ordered to be made as part of the tabernacle equipment (30 17-21; 38 8). Its composition was of brass (bronze), and it consisted of two parts, the bow] and its pedestal or foot (30 18, etc). This first laver was a small one, and was made of the hand mirrors of the women in attendance upon the altar (38 8). Its place was between the altar and the tabernacle (40 30). See Tanzrnacts. The difficulty as to the washing of parts of the sacrificial carcases was overcome, in the temple of Lawinthe NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1844 Solomon, by the construction of ‘10 lavers’ and a “molten sea” (1 K 7 23-37; 2 Ch 4 2-6; see Tempter; Sea, Mouren). We learn 2 Inthe from 2 Ch4 6 that the ‘‘sea” was for Temple the priests to wash in—therefore took the place of the laver in the taber- nacle—and the lavers were used as baths for por- tions of the burnt offerings. The lavers them- selves were artistic works of unusual merit for that age. Like that in the tabernacle, each had its own stand or base, which was cast in a separate piece from the laver. These bases rested on wheels which allowed of the laver being moved from one part of the court to another without being turned about. Five stood on the north and five on the south side of the temple. They were ornamented with “lions, oxen, and cherubim,” and on a lower level, with a series of wreaths or festoons of flowers (1 K 7 27-87). In modern speech, the lavers may be described as so many circular open tanks for the storage of water. Each laver contained 40 baths (about 320 gals.) of water. Its height was 5 cubits, the locomotive machinery being 3 cubits in height, and the depth of the bowl or tank, judging from its capacity, about 2 cubits. The last we hear of the lavers, apart from their bases, is that the idolatrous king Ahaz cut off the border of the bases, and removed the bases from them ( K 1617). During the reign of Jehoiakim, Jere- mniah foretold that the molten sea and the bases (there being then no lavers) should be carried to Babylon (Jer 27 19). A few years later it is recorded that the bases were broken up, and the brass of which they were made was carried away (Jer 52 17). The Gr word (Aourpév, loutrén) occurs twice in the NT. In Eph 5 26, Paul says that Christ gave Himself for the church ‘‘that he might 3. The sanctify it, having cleansed it by the Laver in washing [Gr “laver’’] of water with the the NT word”; and in Tit 3 5 he says that we are saved “through the washing [Gr “laver’’] of regeneration and renewing of the Holy Spirit.” In these passages the reference is to the constant physical purity demanded of the Jewish priests when in attendance upon the temple. Christians are “‘a holy priesthood,” and are cleansed not by water only, but, in the former passage, “with the word” (cf Jn 15 3); in the latter, by the “renewing of the Holy Spirit” (cf Ezk 36 25; Jn 35). The feet-washing mentioned by Jesus is emblematic of the same thing (Jn 13 10). W. Saaw CaupEcotr LAW, 16, IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. The Term “Law”; Austin’s Definition of Law I. Law in Txt Gosre.s 1. The Law in the Teaching of Christ ql) Aon of the Law Upheld in the Sermon on the Mount. : (a) Christ and Tradition {2 Sin of Murder ce) Adultery and Divorce (d) Oaths (e) Retaliation (f) Love to Neighbors—Love of Enemies (2) Other References to the Law in the Teaching of Christ (a) Traditions of the Elders and the 5th Commandment (b) Christ's Answer to the Young Ruler o Christ’s Answer to the Lawyer d) References in the Fourth Gospel 2. The Law in Relation to the Life of Christ (1) In His Infancy (2) In His Ministry 3. The Law in Relation to the Death of Christ (1) Christ Charged with Blasphemy under the Jewish Law (2) Christ Charged with Treason under the Roman Law 4. How Christ Fulfilled the Law in All Its Parts II. Law in tHe Acts or THE APOSTLES 1. Stephen's Witness 2. Practice of Peter and Paul 3. Allusions to the Roman Law Ill. Lawin THe EpisTues 1. In Romans . In Galatians : 2 - In the Other Pauline Epistles . In the Epistle to the Hebrews . In the Epistle of James . In the Epistles of Peter and John LirERATURE The Gr word for “law” is véuos, némos, derived from vépw, némb, “to divide,” “distribute,” “ap- portion,” and generally meant anything established, anything received by usage, a custom, usage, law; in the NT a command, law. It may not he amiss to note the definition of law given by a celebrated authority in jurisprudence, the late Mr, John Austin: ‘‘A law, in the most general Ot Go bo Austin’s and comprehensive acceptation in which Definition the term, in its literal meaning, is em- 7 0 ployed, may be said to be a rule laid down of Law for the guidance of an intelligent being, by an éntelligent being having pore over him.” Under this comprehensive statement, he classifies ‘‘laws set hy God to His human creatures, and laws set by men tomen."’ After analyzing the three ideas, command as the expression of a particular desire; duty or obligation, signifying that one is bound or obliged by the command to pursue a certain course of conduct, and sanction, in- dicating the evil likely to be incurred by disohedience, he thus summarizes: ‘‘The ideas or notions compre- hended hy the term command are the following: (1) a wish or desire conceived by a rational being that another rational being shall do or forbear; (2) an evil to pro- ceed from the former and to be incurred by the latter in case the latter comply not with the wish; (3) an expression or intimation of the wish by words or other signs.” This definition makes it clear that the term “laws of nature’? can he used only in a metaphorical sense, the metaphorical application being suggested as Austin shows by the fact that uniformity or stahility of conduct is one of the ordinary consequences of a law proper, consequently, ‘‘ Wherever we observe @ uniform order of events, or @ uniform order of coexisting phe- nomena, we are prone to impute that order to a law set by its author, though the case presents us with nothing that can be likened to a sanction or a duty.” As used in the NT it will be found generally that the term “law” bears the sense indicated by Austin, and includes ‘‘com- mand,” ‘‘duty”’ and ‘‘sanction.” I. Law in the Gospels.—Naturally we first turn to the Gospels, where the word “law’’ always refers to the Mosaic law, although it has different appli- cations. That law was really threefold: the Moral Law, as summed up in the Decalogue, the Cere- monial Law, prescribing the ritual and all the typi- cal enactments, and what might be called the Civil or Political Law, that relating to the people in their national, political life. The distinction is not closely observed, though sometimes the reference emphasizes one aspect, sometimes another, but generally the whole Law without any discrimination is contemplated. Sometimes the Law means the whole OT Scriptures, as in Jn 10 34; 12 34; 16 25. At other times the Law means the Pent, as in Lk 24 44, The Law frequently appears in the teaching of Christ. Inthe Sermon on the Mount He refers most specifically and fully to it. It is fre- 1. The Law quently asserted that He there exposes in the the imperfection of the Law and sets Teaching His own authority against its author- of Christ ity. But this seems to be a super- ; ficial and an untenable view. Christ indeed affirms very definitely the authority of the Law: “Think not that I came to destroy the law or the prophets” (Mt 5 17). Here the term would seem to mean the whole of the Pent. “I came not to destroy, but to fulfil. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass away from the law, till all things be accomplished’? (Mt 6 17.18). A similar utterance is recorded in Lk 16 17: “It is easier for heaven and earth to pass away, than for one tittle of the law to fall.” (1) Authority of the Law upheld in the Sermon on the Mount.—The perfection and permanence of the Law as well as its authority are thus indicated, 1845 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lawin the NT and the following verse in Mt still further empha- sizes the authority, while showing that now the Lord is speaking specifically of the moral law of the Decalogue: ‘Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven” (6 19). These impressive sentences should be borne in mind in considering the utterances that follow, in which there seems a contrast between the Law and His own teaching, and from which has been drawn the inference that He condemns and practically abrogates the Law. What Jesus really does is to bring out the fulness of meaning that is in the Law, and to show its spirituality and the wideness of its reach. He declares that the righteousness of His disciples must exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees (ver 20). Their righteous- ness consisted largely in a punctilious observance of the external requirements of the Law; the dis- ciples must yield heart obedience to the inner spirit of the Law, its external and internal requirements. (a) Christ and tradition: Jesus then proceeds to point out the contrast, not so much between His own teaching and that of the Law, as between His interpretation of the Law and the interpretation of other teachers: “Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time’’ (AV), “to them of old time” RV (ver 21). Either rendering is grammatically allowable, but in either case it is evidently not the original utterance of Moses, but the traditional interpretation, which He had in view. “Ye have heard that it was said’; Christ’s usual way of quoting the OT is, “It is written” or some other formula pointing to the written Word; and as He has just referred to the written Law as a whole, it would be strange if He should now use the formula “Tt, was said” in reference to the particular pre- cepts. Evidently He means what was said by the Jewish teachers. (b) Sin of murder: This is further confirmed by the citations: ‘‘Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment.’ The second clause is not found in the Pent as a distinct statement, but it is clearly the generalization of the teachers. Christ does not set Himself in opposition to Moses; rather does He enjoin ohedience to the precepts of the scribes when, sitting in Moses’ seat, they truly expound the Law (Mt 93 1-8). But these teachers had so expounded the command as if it only referred to the act of murder; 50 Christ shows the f and true spiritual meaning of it: “But I say unto you, that every one who is angry with | his brother shall be in danger of the judgment” (ver 22). See Murper. P (c) Adultery and divorce: Again, ‘‘ Ye have heard that it was said, Thou shalt not commit adultery’’ (ver 27). The traditional teaching confined this mainly to the out- ward act, ‘But I say unto you,’ says Christ, that adul- tery pertains even to the lustful thought’ (ver 28). In dealing with this matter He passes to the law of divorce which was one of the civil enactments, and did not stand on the same level with the moral precept against com- mitting adultery, nay, the very carrying out of the civil provision might lead to a real breach of the moral pre- cept, and in the interests of the precept itself, in the very desire to uphold the authority of the moral law, Christ ronounces against divorce on any pound save that of ornication. Later on, as recorded in Mt 19 3-9, He was questioned ahout this same law of divorce, and again He condemns the light way in which divorce was treated by the Jews, and affirms strongly the sanctity of the marriage Institution, showing that it was antecedent to the Mosaic code—was from the beginning, and derived its binding force from the Divine pronouncement in Gen 2 24, founded upon the nature of things; while as to the Mosaic law of divorce, He declares that it was ermitted on account of the hardness of their hearts, at that no other cause than fornication was sufficient to dissolve the marriage tie. This civil enactment, justi- fled originally on account of the inability of the people to rise to the true moral ideal of the Decalogue, Christ claims authority to transcend, but in doing so He vindi- cates and upholds the law which said, ‘‘ Thou shalt not commit adultery.” See Diverce. * (d) Oaths: The next precept Jesus cites is one partly civil and partly ritual, concerning the taking of oaths. The words are not found in the Pent as a definite enact- ment; they are rather a gathering up of several utter- ances (Lev 19 12; Nu 80 2; Dt 28 21), and again the form of the citation suggests that it is the rabhinical interpretation that is In question. But the kind of swearing allowed by the law was the very opposite of ae 8 profane swearing. It was intended, indeed, to uard the 3d commandment against taking the name of eh In vain, Christ in condemning the flippant oaths allowed by the rahbis was really asserting the authority of that 3d command; He was enforcing its spirituality_and . claiming the reverence due to the Divine name. Into the question how far the words of Christ hear upon oath- taking in a court of law we need not enter. His own response to the adjuration of the high priest when ractically put upon His oath (Mt 26 63.64) and other T instances (Rom 1 9; 2 Cor 1 23; Gal 1 20; Phil 18; 1 Thess 2 5; He 6 16.17; Rev 10 5.6) would tend to show that such solemn appeals to God are not embraced in Christ's prohibition: “Swear not at all’; but undoubtedly the ideal epoch is that of the simple asseveration, the ‘‘ Yes’ or “No” of the man, who, con- scious that he speaks in the presence of God, reckons his word inviolable, needing no strengthening epithet, though as hetween man and man an oath may be necessary for confirmation and an end of strife. See Oars. (e) Retaliation: He next touches upon the ‘‘law of retaliation": ‘‘an eye for an eye’’ (ver 38), and con- sistently with our understanding of the other sayings, we t) that here Christ is dealing with the traditional interpretation which admitted of personal revenge, of men taking the law into their own hands and revenging themseives. Such a pracuce Christ utterly condemns, and inculcates instead gentleness and forbearance, the outcome of love even toward enemies. This law, in- deed, finds place ane the Mosaic provisions, hut it appears there, not as allowing personal spite to gratify itself in its own way, hut as a political enactment to he carried out by the magistrates and so to discountenance rivate revenge. Christ shows that the spirit of His ospel received by His people would supersede the necessity for these requirements of the civil code; al- though His words are not to he interpreted quite lit- erally, for He Himself when smitten on the one cheek did not turn the other to the smiter (Jn_ 18 22.23), and the Poerle of the law of retaliation still holds good in the legislative procedure of all civilized nations, and according to the NT teaching, will find place even in the Divine procedure in the day of judgment. See also PUNISHMENT. Ue i (f) Love to neighbors; love of enemies: The last saying mentioned in the Sermon clearly reveals its rah- binical character: ‘‘'Thou shalt love thy neighbor, and hate thine enemy” (Mt § 43). The first part is indeed the injunction of the Law, the second part is an unwar- rantable addition to it. It is only this part that Christ virtually condemns when He says, ‘‘But I say unto you, Love your enemies’’ (ver 44). That the interpretation of these teachers was unwarrantahle may he seen from many passages in the Pent, the Prophets and the Pss, which set forth the more spiritual aspect of the Law’s zeguieren and as to this particular precept, we need only refer to Prov 25 21.22, ‘‘lf thine enemy be hungry, give him bread to eat.’’ Christ while condemning the addition unfolds the spiritual import of the command itself, for the love of neighbor rightly interpreted involves love of enemies; and so on another occasion (Lk 10 25- 37) He answers the lawyer’s question, ‘‘ Who is my neigh- hor?" hy the parable of the Good Samaritan, showing that everyone in need is our neighhor. See also For- GIVENESS; WRATH. The last reference in the Sermon on the Mount to the Law fully bears out the idea that Christ really upheld the authority while elucidating the spirituality of the Law, for He declares that the principle embodied in the “Golden Rule” is a de- duction from, is, indeed, the essence of, ‘‘the law and the rophets” (Mt 7 12). (2) Other references to the Law in the teaching of Christ.—We can only glance at the other references to the Law in the teaching of Christ. In Mt 11 13, “For all the prophets and the law prophesied until John,” the Law in its teaching capacity is in view, and perhaps the whole of the Pent is meant. In Mt 12 1-8, in rebutting the charge brought against His disciples of breaking the Sabbath, He cites the ease of David and his men eating the showbread, which it was not lawful for any but the priests to artake of; and of the priests doing work on the Rabbath day which in other men would be a breach of the Law; from which He deduces the conclusion that the ritual laws may be set aside under stress of necessity and for a higher good. In that same chapter (vs 10-13) He indicates the lawfulness of healing—doing good—on the Sabbath day. Lawinthe NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA (a) Traditions of the elders and the 5th com- mandment: In Mt 15 1-6 we have the account of the Pharisees complaining that the disciples transgressed the traditions of the elders by eating with unwashed hands. Jesus retorts upon them with the question: ‘(Why do ye also transgress the commandment of God hecause of your tradition?” citing the specific case of the 5th commandment which was evaded and virtually broken by their ingenious distinction of korban. This is a very instructive incident in its hearing upon the point which we have sought to enforce—that it was the traditional interpretation and not the Law itself which Jesus condemned or corrected. (b) Christ’s answer to the young ruler: To the young ruler (Mt 19 16-42) He presents the com- mandments as the rule of life, obedience to which is the door to eternal life, especially emphasizing the manward aspect of the Law’s claims. The young man, professing to have kept them all, shows that he has not grasped the spirituality of their requirements, and it is further to test him that Christ calls upon him to make the “great renun- ciation” which, after all, is not in itself an additional command so much as the unfolding of the spiritual and far-reaching character of the command, ‘“‘Love thy neighbor as thyself.” (c) Christ’s answer to the lawyer: To the lawyer who asks Him which is the great commandment in the Law, He answers by giving him the sum of the whole moral law. ‘Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. ‘This is the great and first com- mandment. And a second like unto it is this, Thou ee love thy neighbor as thyself’? (Mt 22 35-39). “There is none other commandment greater than these,” and in that of Matthew He says, ‘‘On these two commandments the whole law hangeth, and the prophets” (ver 40); both utterances showing the high estimation in which He held the Law. (d) References in the Fourth Gospel: In His dis- cussion with the Jews, recorded in Jn 7, He charges them with failure to keep the Law: ‘Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you doeth the law?” (ver 19). And referring to the healing of the impotent man on the Sabbath day, a deed which had roused their ire, He shows how one law may conflict with another. Moses had enjoined cir- cumcision, and sometimes the time for circumcising would fall on the Sahbath day. Yet with all their reverence for the Sabbath day, they would, in order to keep the law of circumcision, perform the rite on the Sabbath day, and so, He argues, it is un- reasonable +o complain of Him hecause on the Sabbath day He had fulfilled the higher law of doing good, healing a poor sufferer. In none of all Christ’s utterances is there any slight thrown upon the Law itself; it is always held up as the standard of right and its authority vindicated. The passages we have considered show the place of the Law in the teaching of Christ, but we also find that He had to sustain a practical 2. The Law relation to that Law. Born under the in Relation Law, becoming part of a nation which to the Life honored and venerated the Law, every of Jesus art of whose life was externally regu- Christ ated by it, the life of Jesus Christ could not fail to he affected hy that Law. We note its operation: (1) In His infancy —On the eighth day He was circumcised (Lk 2 21), thus being recognized as a member of the covenant nation, partaking of its privileges, assuming its responsibilities. Then, according to the ritual law of purification, He is presented in the temple to the Lord (Lk 2 22-24), while His mother offers the sacrifice enjoined in the In Mark’s report (Mk 12 31), He adds,. 1846 “law of the Lord,” the sacrifice she brings patheti- cally witnessing to her poverty, “‘a pair of turtle doves, or two young pigeons” being the alternative allowed to those who were not able to provide a lamb (Lev 12). The Divine approval is set upon thig consecrating act, for it is while it is being done concerning Him after ‘the custom of the law” (ver 27), that the Spirit of God comes upon Simeon and prompts the great pee which links all the Messianic hopes with the Babe of Bethlehem. Again, according to the Law His parents go up to the Passover feast when the wondrous child has reached His 12th year, the age when a youthful Jew assumed legal responsibility, becoming ‘‘a son of the Law,” and so Jesus participates in the festal observances, and His deep interest in all that con- cerns the temple-worship and the teaching of the Law is shown by His absorption in the conversation of the doctors, whose questions He answers so intelligently, while questioning them in turn, and filling them with astonishment at His understanding (Lk 2 42-47). (2) In His minisiry—In His ministry He ever honors the Law. He reads it in the synagogue. He heals the leper hy His sovereign touch and word, hut He bids him go and show himself to the priest and offer the gift that Moses commanded (Mt 8 4). And again, when the lepers appeal to Him, His response which implies the healing is, ‘(Go and show yourselves unto the priests” (Lk 17 14). He drives out of the temple those that defile it (Mt 21 12.13; Jn 2 15-17), hecause of His zeal for the honor of His Father’s house, and so, while showing His author- ity, emphasizes the sanctity of the temple and its services. So, while claiming to be the Son in the Father’s house, and therefore above the injunctions laid upon the servants and strangers, He neverthe- less pays the temple-tax exacted from every son of Israel (Mt 17 24-27). He attends the various feasts during His ministry, and when the shadows of death are gathering round Him, He takes special pains to ohserve the Passover with His disciples. Thus to the ceremonial law He renders continuous ohedience, the motto of His life practically being His great utterance to the Baptist: “Suffer it now: for thus it hecometh us to fulfil all righteousness” (Mt 3 15). If He obeyed the ceremonial law, unquestionably He obeyed the moral law. His keenest-eyed enemies could find no fault in Him in regard to His moral conduct. His absolute sinless- ness attests the translation of the moral law into actual life. We enter uot upon the theological question as to the relation of the death of Christ to the penal inflictions of the Law Divinely enforced on hehalf of 3. The Law Sitners—that touches the doctrine of the in Relation Atonement—we only note the fact that His death was brought about in professed tothe Death accordance with the Law. The chief of Jesus Tiests, in hatred, sent officers to take Christ im, but overawed by His matchless 18 eloquence, these officers returned empty- : handed, In their chagrin, the chict fricats can only say that the people who follow Him now not the Law and are cursed (Jn 7 49). Nicode- mus, on this occasion, ventures to remonstrate: ‘Doth our law judge a man, except it first hear from himself?” (ver 51). This sound legal principle these men are bent on disregarding; their one desire is to put an end to the life of this man, who has aroused their jealousy and hatred, and at last when they get Him into their ands, they strain the forms of the Law to accompllsh their purpose. There is no real charge that can he brought against Him. They dare not bring up the plea that Te broke the Sabbath, for again and again He has answered their cavils on that score. He has broken no law; all they can do is to bribe false witnesses to testify some- thing to His discredit. _The trumpery charge, founded upon a distorted reminiscence of His utterance about destroying the temple, threatens to break down. (1) Christ charged with blasphemy in relation to the Jewish law.—Then the high eer et adjures Him to say upon oath whether or not He claims to he the Christ, the Son of the Living God. Such a claim would assured- 1847 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Law inthe NT W. if unfounded, be blasphemy, and according to the aw, be punishable by death. Ona previous occasion the Jews threatened to stone Him for this—to them—blas- poemone claim. Now when Jesus calmly avows that e is the Son of God, the high priest, rending his clothes, declares that no further proof is needed. e has con- fessed to the blasphemy, and unanimously the council votes Him worthy of death (Mt 26; Mk'14; Lk 99). It Jesus Christ were not what He claimed to be, then the priesus were right in holding Him guilty of blasphemy; t never occurred to them to consider whether the claim after all might not be true. (2) Christ charged with treason under the Roman law.— Not only is the Jewish law invoked to accomplish His death, but also the Rom law. On one other occasion Christ had come into touch with the law of Rome, viz. when asked the ensnaring questlon by the Herodians as to the lawfulness of giving tribute to Caesar (Mt 99 17; Mk 12 14; Lk 20 22). Now the Jews need the Rom_ governor's authorization for the death penalty, and Jesus must be tried before him. The charge cannot now be blasphemy—the Rom law will have nothing to Say to that—and so they trump up a charge of treason against Caesar. _ _ In preferring it, they practically renounce their Mes- sianic hopes, ‘The charge, however, breaks down before the Rom tribunal, and only by playing on the weakness of Pilate do they gain their end, and the Rom law decrees His death, while leaving the Jews to sce to the carrying out of the sentence. In this the evangelist sees the ful- filment of Christ’s words concerning the manner of His death, for stoning would have been the Jewish form of the death penalty, not crucifixion. See Jesua Cunist, III, £), ii, 3, 4 Looking at the whole testimony of the Gospels, we can see how it was that Christ fulfilled the Law. He fulfilled the moral law by obeying, 4. How by bringing out its fulness of meaning, Christ Ful- by showing its intense spirituality, filled the and He established it on a surer basis Law in All than ever as the eternal law of right- lis Parts eousness. He fulfilled the ceremonial and typical law, not only by conform- ing to its requirements, but by realizing its spiritual significance. He filled up the shadowy outlines of the types, and, thus fulfilled, they pass away, and it is no longer necessary for us to observe the Pass- over or slay the daily lamb: we have the substance in Christ. He also cleared the Law from the tra- ditional excrescences which had gathered round it under the hands of the rabbis. He showed that the ceremonial distinction between meats clean and unclean was no longer necessary, but showed the importance of true spiritual purity (Mt 16 11; Mk 7 18-23). He taught His disciples those great principles when, after His resurrection, “be- ginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he interpreted to them in all the scriptures the thmgs concerning himself’ (Lk 24 27). And as_ He opened their mind that they might understand the Scriptures, He declared, “These are my words which I spake unto you, while I was yet with you, that all things must needs be fulfilled, which are written in the law of Moses, and the prophets, and the psalms, concerning me” (Lk 24 44). John sums this up in his pregnant phrase, ‘The law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ’? (Jn 1 17). The grace was in con- trast to the condemnation of the moral law, the truth was the antithesis to the shadowy outline of the types and ceremonies. ¥ Il. Law in the Acts of the Apostles.—Without considering questions of authenticity and historicity in relation to this book which professes to be the earliest church history, we briefly note the place of the Law therein indicated. In the book we have an account of the transition frem Judaism to fully developed Christianity, and the Law comes into view in various ways. The disciples, like other Jews, observe the feast of Pentecost, and even after the descent of the Spirit, they frequent the temple and observe the hours of prayer, The full-orbed gospel poses by Stephen arouses the suspicion and enmity of the stricter sects of the Jews, who accuse him before the council of speaking blasphemous words against the holy place and the Law. But this was the testi- mony of suborned witnesses, having 1. Stephen’s doubtless its foundation in the fact Witness that Stephen’s teaching emphasized the grace of the gospel. Stephen’s own defence honors the Law as given by Moses, ‘“‘who received living oracles’? (Acts 7 38), shows how disloyal the people had been, and closes by charging them not only with rejecting and slaying the Right- eous One, but of failing to keep the Law ‘‘as it was ordained by angels’ (7 53). Peter’s strict observance of the ceremonial law is shown in connection with his vision which teaches him that the grace of God may pass 2. Practice beyond the Jewish pale (Acts 10). of Peter Paul’s preaching emphasizes the ful- and Paul filling the Scriptures, Law and Proph- ecy, by Jesus Christ. The gist of his message, as given in his first reported sermon, is, “By him everyone that believeth is justified from all things, from which ye could not be justified by the law of Moses” (13 38f). The coriversion of the Gentiles brings up the question of their relation to the ceremonial law, specifically to circumcision. The decision of the council at Jerus treats circum- cision as unnecessary for the Gentiles, and only enjoins, in relation to the Mosaic ritual, abstinence from things strangled and from blood (ch 15). The after-course of events would show that this pro- vision was for the time of transition. Paul, though strongly opposed to the idea of imposing circum- cision on the Gentiles, nevertheless without incon- sistency and as a concession to Jewish feeling, cir- cumcises Timothy (16 3), and himself fulfils the ceremonial enactments in connection with the taking of a vow (18 18). He also, following the advice of James, who wished him to conciliate the myriads of believing Jews who were zealous for the Law, and to show them the falseness of the charge that he taught the Jews among the Gentiles ‘‘to forsake Moses”’ (apostasy from Moses), took upon him the ceremonial duty of purifying the ‘four men that have a vow on them” (21 20-26). This involved the offering of sacrifices, and the fact that Paul could do so shows that for the Jews the sacrificial system still remained in force. The sequel to the trans- action might raise the question whether, after all, the procedure was a wise one; it certainly did not fulfil the expectations of James. Later on, in his defence before Felix, Paul claims to be loyal to the Jewish faith, worshipping in the temple, and ‘‘be- lieving all things which are according to the law, and which are written in the prophets” (24 11-14); and in his address to the Jewish leaders in Rome, he declares that he has ‘done nothing against the people, or the customs of our fathers’ (28 17), and he seeks to persuade them concerning Jesus, “‘both fro ae law of Moses and from the prophets’ : In the Acts we find several allusions to law other than Jewish. In ch 16 Paul comes into collision with the Rom law. Beaten and im- 3. Allusions prisoned by the magistrates of Philippi, to the he is afterward offered the oppor- Roman Law tunity of quietly slipping away, but standing on his dignity as a Rom citizen, he demands that the magistrates themselves, who had violated the law by publicly beating un- condemned Romans, should come and set them free. This same right as a Rom citizen Paul again asserts when about to be scourged by the command of the centurion (22 25), and his protest is successful in averting the indignity. His trial before Felix and Festus well illustrates the procedure under the Rom law, and his appeal, as a Rom citizen, to Caesar had important results in his life. Lawinthe NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA HI. Law in the Epistles.—The word is used both with and without the article, but though in some cases the substantive without the article refers to law in general, yet in many other places it undoubt- edly refers to the Law of Moses. Perhaps, as has been suggested, it is that, where it does refer to the Mosaic Law, the word without the article points to that law, not so much as Mosaic, but in its quality as law. But speaking generally, the word with and without the article is used in reference to the Law of Moses. (1) Law as a standard.—In Rom Paul has much to say about law, and in the main it is the moral law that he has in view. In this great 1.In ep., written to people at the center of Romans the famous legal system of Rome, many of them Jews versed in the law of Moses and others Gentiles familiar with the idea of law, its nature, its scope and its sway, he first speaks of the Law as a standard, want of conformity to which brings condemnation. He shows that the Gentiles who had not the standard of the revealed Law nevertheless had a law, the law of Nature, a law written upon their heart and conscience. Rom jurisprudence was familiar with the concep- tion of a law of Nature, which became a law of nations (jus gentium), so that certain principles could be assumed as obtaining among those who had not the knowledge of the Rom code; and in accord- ance with these principles, the dealings between Romans and barbarians could be regulated. Pawul’s conception is somewhat similar, but is applied to the spiritual relations of man and God. (2) Gentiles condemned by the law of Nature— But the Gentiles, not having lived up to the light of that law, are condemned. They have violated the dictates of their own conscience. And the Jews, with the fuller light of their revealed law, have equally failed. In this connection Paul incidentally lays down the great principle that “Not the hear- ers of the Jaw are just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified’ (Rom 2 13). His great aim, in the ep., is to show that justification is by faith, but he here asserts that if anyone would have justification through law, then he must keep that law in all its details. The Law will pronounce the doer of it justified, but the mere hearing of the. Law without doing it will only increase the con- demnation. ‘‘As many as have sinned without the law shall also perish without the law: and as many as have sinned under the law shall be judged by the law’ (2 12). Paul does not pronounce upon the question whether a Gentile may be saved by following the light of Nature; he rather emphasizes the negative side that those who have failed shall perish; they have light enough to condemn, is his oint. P (8) Allmen under condemnation.—Having proved that both Jews and Gentiles are under sin, he closes his great indictment with the statement: ‘“Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it speaketh to them that are under the law; that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may be brought under the judgment of God” (3 19). Thus the Law shuts up into condemnation. It is impossible for any sinner to be justified “by the works of the law’; the Law not only condemns but ‘through the law cometh the knowledge of sin” (3 20). It shows how far short men have come of God’s requirements. It is a mirror in which the sinner secs his defilement, but the mirror cannot cleanse, though it shows the need of cleansing. (4) The redeeming work of Christ providing righteousness apart from the Law.—Then setting forth the great redemption of Jesus Christ, the apostle shows that it provides what the Law had failed to provide, a righteousness which can satisfy 1848 the requirements of the Law; a righteousness that is indeed “apart from the law,’’ apart from all mnen’s attempts to keep the Law, but is neverthe- less in deepest harmony with the principles of the Law, and has been witnessed “by the law and the prophets” (3 21). (In this passage the “law” seems to mean the Pent, and in ver 19, in view of the preceding citations from the Pss, it appears to mean the whole OT Scriptures.) Since the right- eousness secured by Christ comes upon the sinner through faith, manifestly the works of the Law can have nothing to do with our obtaining of it. But so far is faith-righteousness from undermining the Law, that Paul claims that through faith the Law is established (3 31). (5) Abraham’s blessings came not through the Law.—Proceeding to show that his idea of justi- fication by faith was no new thing, that the OT saint had enjoyed it, he particularly shows that Abraham, even in his uncircumcised state, received the blessing through faith; and the great promise to him and his seed did not come through the Law, but on the principle of faith. (6) Law worketh wrath and intensifieth the evil of sin.—Indeed, so far from blessing coming to sinners by way of the Law, the “law worketh wrath” (4 15); not wrath in men against the Law’s restric- tions as some have argued, but the holy wrath of God so frequently mentioned by the apostle in this ep. The Law worketh wrath, inasmuch as when disobeyed it brings on the sinner the Divine dis- approval, condemnation; it enhances the guilt of sin, and so intensifies the Divine wrath against it; and it, in a sense, provokes to sin: the sinful nature rebels against the restrictions imposed by the Law, and the very fact of a thing being forbidden arouses the desire for it. This seems what he means in a subsequent passage (5 20), ‘‘And the law came in besides, that the trespass might abound”; as if the very multiplying of restrictions intensified the tendency to sin, brought out the evil in human nature, shgwed the utter vileness of the sinful heart and the terrible nature of sin, and thus made the need for salvation appear the greater, the very desperateness of the disease showing the need for the remedy and creating the desire for it; the abounding of sin preparing the way for the super- abounding of grace. That the presence of Law enhances the evil of sin is further shown by the statement, ‘‘But where there is no law, neither is there transgression’ (4 15); transgression— pard- basis—the crossing of the boundary, is, in the strict sense, only possible under law. But there may be sin apart from a revealed law, as he has already proved in the 2d chapter. (7) Law in the light of the parallel between Adam and Christ.—In the 5th chapter, dealing with the parallel between Adam and Christ he says: “For until the Jaw sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law” (6 13). He cannot mean that men were not held responsible for their sin, or that sin was not in any sense reckoned to their account, for he has in that 2d chapter proved the opposite; but sin was not so imputed to them as to bring upon them the punishment of death, which they nevertheless did suffer, and that is traced by him to the sin of Adam. These, he says, had not sinned after the likeness of Adam’s trans- gression (ver 14); they had not transgressed a positive command as he did, although they had undoubtedly violated the law of conscience, and knew that they were sinners. In drawing out the parallel between Adam and Christ, he plainly indi- cates that as Adam’s transgression of law brought condemnation on the race, so Christ’s obedience to the Law brings justification. . (8) Law and righteousness—So far he may be 1849 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lawin the NT said to have spoken of the Law in regard to the ‘sinner, and it is mainly the Law in its judicial aspect, the Law in relation to righteousness. The Law reveals righteousness, the Law demands righteousness, the Law condemns for unrighteous- ness. Redemption is a working out of righteousness. The Law witnesses to the perfeet righteousness of Christ. The righteousness secured by Christ meets all the requirements of the Law, while gloriously transeending it. The righteous penalty of the Law has been borne by Christ; the righteous require- ments of the Law have been fulfilled by Christ. That perfeet righteousness seeured apart from the Law, but satisfying to the Law, eomes to men not through their relation to the Law, but through faith. Now he proceeds to consider the Law in relation to the saint. (9) The saint and the Law—The believer justi- fied through Christ has died with Christ. The “old man”—the sinful nature—has been crucified with Christ; the eondemning power of the Law has terminated in the death of Christ, and through the death of the believer with Christ he has freedom from the condemnation of the Law. “He that hath died is justified from sin” (6 7). But though in one aspect the believer is dead, in another he is alive. He dies with Christ, but he rises spiritually with Him, and thus spiritually alive he is “to yield,” “to present” his ‘members as instruments of right- eousness unto God” (ver 13), and for his comfort he is assured that in this new sphere of life sin shall not have power to bring him under the condemna- tion of the Law—‘‘Sin shall not have dominion over you: for ye are not under law, but under grace’ (6 14). His relationship to the Law has been altered through his union with Christ, and this fact the apostle proceeds to illustrate. He enounces the principle that “the law hath dominion over a man for so long a time as he liveth” (71). Death dissolves all legal objections. The believer, spirit- ually dead, is not under the dominion of the Law. (10) Illustrated by the law of the husband.—The specific case is then given of a married woman bound hy law to her husband, but freed from that law through his death, and in the application, he says, ‘‘ Wherefore, my brethren, ye also were made dead to the law through the body of Christ’ (7 4). If the Law in this metaphorical descrip- tion is the husband while the soul is the wife, as has heen Most generally understood by Commentators, then the application is based on the general thought of death dis- solving the legal obligation, the death of the husband involves the death of the woman as a wife, and so he can speak of the death of the believer rather than of the death ofthe Law. Another explanation of the metaphor is that the old sinful state is the hushand to which the ego, the personality, was bound hy the Law, but that the sinful state being brought to death through Christ, the personality is free to enter into union with Christ. Whatever view is adopted, the leading thought of the apostle is clear, that through the death of Christ the believer is free from the Law: ‘‘ But now we have heen discharged from the law, having died to that wherein we were held” (7 6). (11) The purity and perfection of the Law in its own sphere.—The question ig then raised, “Is the law sin?” (ver 7). The thought is repudiated as unthinkable, but he goes on to show how the law was related to sin, giving from his own experience the exemplification of what he had stated in the 3d chapter, that by the Law is the knowledge of sin. The Law revealed his sin; the Law aroused the opposition of his nature, and through the working of sin under the prohibition of the Law, he found the tendeney to be death. Nevertheless, there is no doubt in his mind that the Law is not responsible for the sin, the Law is not in any manner to be blamed, ‘The law is boly, and the commandment holy, and righteous, and good” (ver 12). Sin in the light of the holy Law is shown to be exceeding sinful, and the Law itself is known to be spiritual. We need not deal with the difficult passage that follows concerning the inner conflict. There has always been much discussion as to whether this is a conflict in the soul of the unregenerate man or of the regenerate—we believe it is in the regenerate, setting forth the experience of the believer—but whatever view is taken, it is elear that the law eannot bring deliverance; the higher part of man’s nature, or the regenerate nature according to the interpreta- tion one adopts, may ‘‘consent unto the law that it is good” (ver 16), may even ‘‘delight in the law of God”’ (ver 22); but there is another Jaw at work, the law of sin in the members, and the working of this law means captivity and wretehedness from whieh deliveranee ean only come through Jesus Christ (vs 23-25). The word “law” in these verses is used in the sense of principle, “the law of my mind,” “the law of sin,’”’ “the law in my members’; but over against all is the law of God. (12) Freedom from the penal claims of the Law.—~ The deseription of the Law as holy, righteous and ood, as spiritual, as the object of delight to a true hear is enough to show that the deliverance which the Christian enjoys is freedom from the penal claims and condemning power of the Law. ‘his is borne out by the exulting conelusion: ‘‘There is therefore now no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus’ (8 1). The Law’s claims, satisfied by Christ, no longer press upon those who are in Him. When the apostle adds, ‘For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus made me free from the law of sin and of death” (8 2), he is using “law” in the general sense as a prineiple or power of producing ordered action, and “the law of the Spirit of life’ may be taken to mean the method of the Spirit’s working, and indeed may well be a way of describing the gospel itself—the new law, through which the Spirit operates. The other phrase, “law of sin and death,’’ is not to be taken as meaning the Law of Moses, but the law, the principle of sin producing death mentioned in the previous chapter, unless we think of it as the holy Law which gives the knowl- edge of sin and brings the condemnation of death. The failure of the Law to produce a satisfactory result is definitely attributed to the weakness of the flesh, which is in effect reflecting the statement of the previous chapter, but all that the Law could not accomplish is accomplished through the work of Christ. In Christ sin is eondemned, and in those who are brought into union with Him the righteous- ness of the Law is fulfilled. (18) The Law remains as @ rule of life for the believer—Thus the Law is not abrogated. It remains as the standard of righteousness, the “rule of life’ for believers. The utmost holiness to which they can attain under the influence of the Holy Spirit, is still the ‘righteousness’ which the Law requires. That the apostle’s teaching is far removed from Antinomianism is shown, not only by all that he says in these ehapters about the believer’s new life of absolute spiritual service, but by the specific statement in Rom 13 8-10, which at once preseribes the commandments as rules of life in Eph 6 2 he cites and enforces the 5th commandment) and shows how true obedienee is possible. ‘(Owe no man anything, save to love one another: for he that loveth his neighbor hath fulfilled the law.’’ Then, after specifying several of the commands, he de- clares that these and all other commands are “summed up in this word, namely, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.” The man in Christ has found the true principle of obedience. He has entered into the true spirit of the holy law. That is all summed up in love, and he having received the love of Christ, living in His love, sees the Law not ag a stern taskmaster condemning, but as a bright vision alluring. He indeed sees the Law embodied in Christ, and the imitation of Christ Lawinthe NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1850 involves obedience to the Law, but he fulfils the Law not simply as a standard outside, but as a living principle within. Acting according to the dictates of the love begotten at the cross, his life is conformed to the image of Christ, and in so far is conformed to the Law—‘‘Love therefore is the fulfilment of the law.” In 13 1-7, though the word “law” does not occur, Paul indicates the relation of the Christian to the Rom law, to the sovereignty of Rome in general, showing that “the powers that be are ordained of God” and that in the ideal they are reflections of Divine authority, and as such are to be obeyed. In the Ep. to the Gal, Paul has also a great deal to say about the Law, but as we have dealt so fully with the conception given in Rom, we 2. Inthe can only briefly note the teaching of Epistle to the Galatian Ep. the Galatians (1) Law in relation to grace and spiritual liberty—In general, we may say that as the Law in relation to righteousness was the prominent feature in Rom, in Gal it is the Law in relation to grace and spiritual liberty, and while it was almost exclusively the moral law that Paul had in view in Rom, in Gal it is rather the Law of Moses in its entirety, with special emphasis upon the ceremonial. He introduces the subject by referring to the episode at Antioch, when he had to rebuke Peter for his ‘‘dissimulation” (2 13). He shows the inconsistency of those who knew that they had been “justified by faith in Christ, and not by the works of the law” (ver 16), compelling the gentile Christians to live according to the Law, and sums up with the striking statement, ‘For I through the law died unto the law, that I might live unto God” (ver 19). The Law in revealing his sin and pronouncing condemnation, drove him to Christ for justification. Crucified with Christ he has entered into such vital union with Christ that his whole self-life is dominated by the Christ-life: “It is no longer I that live, but Christ liveth in me” (ver 20). Here we have the same line of thought as in Rom; then Paul goes on to show that all the blessings of grace which these Christians enjoy have come to them uot by way of the Law, but “by the hearing of faith’? (8 2-5). Again, citing the case of Abraham as an instance of justification by faith, he shows how utterly opposed the Law is to the grace that brings salvation, ‘For as many as are of the works of the law are under a curse’’ (ver 10), but in gracious contrast, ‘Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law’ (ver 13), having Himself borne the curse, and so the blessing of Abraham can come upon the Gentiles through faith (ver 18). (2) The function of the Law not to give life, but to guide life —As in Rom, he shows that the promise of the inheritance was apart from the Law, was given 430 years before the Law was promulgated, and answers the question as to the purpose of the Law, by saying, “It was added because of trans- gressions”’ (3 19), the thought already noted in Rom. Yet the Law was not in its nature opposed to the promise. If any law could have given life, “could make alive,” then so perfect was the Law of Moses that it would have served the purpose; ‘Verily, righteousness would have been of the law’ (ver 21). The Law was never meant to give life to those who had it not. ‘‘He that doeth them shall live in them” (ver 12), but the doing implies the possession of life, and the Law only guarantees the continuance of life while it is perfectly obeyed. Law coutrols life, but cannot confer life. It regu- lates life, but cannot restore life. It may impel to righteousness, but it cannot impart righteousness. (3) The Law our schoolmaster—The Law, he shows, was our schoolmaster, our pedagogue, “‘to bring us unto Christ” (ver 24), The Grecian youth was under the charge of a pedagogue during his minority, one part of the pedagogue’s duty being to take the boy, unwilling enough sometimes, to schoo]. In the sense already shown in Rom, the moral law by showing us our sinfulness leads us to Christ; but here we may take the Law as a whole, including all the ceremonial and typical observances which were designed to lead the people to Christ. (4) The bondage of the Law.—But while there was undoubtedly much of privilege for the people under the Mosaic dispensation, there was also some- thing of bondage. And so Paul says, ‘““We were kept in ward under the law’ (ver 23), and in the next chapter, he speaks of the child, though heir to a great estate, being “under guardians and stewards until the day appointed of the father’ (4 2), which seems to be the same thought as under the pedagogue, and this he calls a state of “bond- age’ (ver 3). The Law guarded and tutored and restrained; the great typical observances, though foreshadowing the grace of the gospel, were yet, in their details, irksome and burdensome, and the mass of rules as to every part of the Jew’s conduct proved to be, speaking after the present-day man- ner, a system of red tape. Little was left to the free, spontaneous action of the spirit; the whole course of the Jew from the cradle to the grave was carefully marked out. (5) Sonship and its freedom from the Law’s re- strictions.—But in the fulness of time “God sent forth his Son, born of a woman, born under the law, that he might redeem them that were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of sons’ (4 4f). The gospel of the grace of God embodied in Christ shows its gracious character in that it not only answers the requirements of the moral law and removes its condemnation; fulfils, and by ful- filling abrogates the typical observer of the cere- monial law, but also abolishes all the directions and restrictions given to the Jews as a separate people, and brings its subjects into a condition of liberty where the renewed spirit under the mighty love of Christ can act spontaneously, the great principles of the mora] law remaining as its guide, while the minute rules needed for the infancy of the race are no longer appropriate for the ‘‘sons of God, through faith, in Christ Jesus’ (8 26). Andso Paul warns these Christians against turning back to the “weak and beggarly rudiments” and observing “months, and seasons, and years” (4 9.10). In the remaining Epp. of Paul, little is said of the Law, and we need only indicate the connections in which the word occurs. In 1 Cor 7 3. Inthe 39 there is a reference to the wife being Other “bound by the law as long as ber hus- Pauline band liveth” (AV). _ The word “law,” Epistles however, is omitted from the critical texts andfromRV. In thesameep. (9 8.9; 14 21.34) the word is used of the Pent or the Scripturesasa whole. In 9 20 Paul refers to his practice of seeking to win men to Christ by accom- modating himself to their standpoint, ‘‘to them that are under the law, as under the law’’; and in 15 56 occurs the pregnant statement, an echo of Rom “The power of sin is the law.’’ In 2 Cor the wor does not occur, though the Jegal system is referred to as the ministration of death, in contrast to the gospel ministration of the Spirit (ch 3). The word “aw” is once used in Eph (2 15), in reference to the work of Christ not only producing harmony between God and man, but between Jew and Gentile: “abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances,’ also spoken of as “the middle wall of partition,” and referring esp. to the ceremonial enactments. In Phil 3 5.6.9 we have the fine autobiographical passage wherein we see the self-righteous Pharisee 1851 reckoning himself “‘blameless”’ in the eye of the Law, until convinced of his sin, and led to find in Christ the righteousness ‘which is through faith,” instead of his own righteousness ‘‘which is of the law’’ (ver 9). The word does not occur in Col, but the thought is found of the spiritual circumcision in contrast to the physical, the blotting out through the work of the cross, of the bond written in ordinances and the consequent deliverance of the believer from the bondage of ceremonial observances (2 11-17), those being affirmed to be ‘‘a shadow of the things to come,”’ Christ being the glorious substance. In 1 Tim 1 8.9, we have the two pregnant statements that “the law is good, if a man use it lawfully,” and that “law is not made for a righteous man, but for the lawless.” The word ‘law’ occurs 14t in this ep., and a great deal of attention is given to the subject, but it is generally the law in its ceremonial 4. Inthe and typical aspect that is in question. Epistle It is not necessary to look at the matter to the in detail, but simply to indicate the . Hebrews line of teaching. (1) Harmony with the Pauline teaching.—The ancient doubt as to the authorship of the ep. seems today to have crystallized into certainty, albeit the grounds for a con- clusion are no stronger than formerly, but in the desire to prove the non-Pauline authorship, too much empha- sis is perhaps laid upon the supposed un-Pauline char- acter of the teaching. There is, after all, profound har- mony between the teaching of the Pauline Epp. and the teaching of He, and the harmony applies to this matter of the Law. Whilo-Paul, as we have seen, gives promi- nence in Rom to the moral law, in Gal and elsewhere he deals with the ceremonial law, in much the same way, though not so fully, as the writer to the Hebrews. Such utterances as, ‘‘Our Passover also hath been sacrificed, even Christ’ (1 Cor 5 7); ‘‘The rock was Christ’; “Now these things were our examples” (types of us) (1 Cor 10 4-6); ‘‘Which are a shadow of the things to come; but the body is Christ’s'’ (Col 2 17) areexactly in line with the teaching of Hebrews. (2) The Law transcended by the gospel_—The author shows how the Law, which was a word spoken through angels, is transcended by the gospel, which has been spoken by the Lord of the angels, and so demands greater reverence (He 2 2-4), and all through the ep. it is the transcendent glory of the gospel dispensation introduced by Christ and ascribed to Him, which is made to shine before us. (3) Law of priesthood.—The author deals specifi- cally in chs 7 and 8 with the law of priesthood, showing that Christ’s Priesthood, “after the order of Melchisedck,” surpasses in glory that of the Aaronic priesthood under the law; not only sur- passes but supersedes it; the imperfect gives place to the perfect; the shadowy to the real; the earthly to the heavenly; the temporal to the eternal. And as Paul justifies his doctrine of justification apart from the deeds of the Law by reference to the OT teaching, so here the writer finds in the OT pre- diction of the New Covenant, the basis for all his reasoning, and in his reference to the description of the New Covenant, he is at one with Paul in regard to the moral law, seeing it as now written on the heart, and becoming an internal power, rather than an external precept. See New Covsz- NANT. : (4) The law of the sanctuary and the sacrifices.— He next deais with the law of the sanctuary, and in connection therewith considers the law of the gacrifices (chs 9-10), and in the same way shows that Christ makes good all that the tabernacle and its services typified, that His one, all-perfect eternal sacrifice takes the place of the many imper- fect temporary sacrifices offered under the Law. At the best the Law had ‘“a shadow of the good things to come” (10 1). The shadow was useful for the time being, the people were greatly privi- leged in having it, it directed them to the great Figure who cast the shadow. The whole ceremonial THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA | Law in the NT system was really a system of grace at the heart of it; in spite of its external rubrics which might well be abused, it made provision for satisfying for the time the breaches of the law; the sacrifices themselves could not take away sin, but periodical forgiveness was conveyed through them, by virtue of their relation to the Coming One. Now the great sacrifice having been offered, eternal redemp- tion is secured, perfect forgiveness obtained, free access into the heavenly Holy Place assured, and the eternal inheritance provided. The Substance of all the shadows has appeared, the shadows pass away, and the great truth indicated by Christ Him- self is now fully made known through His Spirit- taught servants. Christ, who ‘is the end of the law [the moral law] unto righteousness to every one that believeth’? (Rom 10 4), is also the end of the ceremonial law, the full realization of all its types and shadows. James mentions the “law” 10 t in his ep., and in each case it is the moral law. The influence of the Sermon on the Mount is seen through- 6. Inthe out the ep., and some distinct echoes Epistle of of it are heard, as e.g. the injunction, James “Swear not [at all] (6 12). James has nothing hut good to say of the Law, and that fact in the light of the influence of the Sermon on the Mount is enough to show that Christ, in that wonderful discourse, did not disparage the Law, far less abrogate it, but rather exalted and reinforced it. James taught by Christ exalts the Law, glorifies it, in fact seems almost to identify it with the gospel, for in ch 1, when speaking of the Word and the importance of hearing and doing it, he in the same breath speaks of looking into ‘‘the perfect law, the law of liberty” (ver 25). And indeed, it is just possible, as some think, that he means the gospel by the epithet, although it seems better to take it as the Law tr¢ in the gospel, the Law looked at in its spirituality, as the guide of ee Christian man who has entered into the spirit of it. Even in the OT, as Pss 19 and 119 specifically show, it was possible for spiritually-minded men to see the beauty of the Law and find delight in its precepts. In 2 8 he speaks of the “royal law,’’ and that here he does mean the Mosaic Law is beyond doubt, since he cites the particular requirement, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself,”’ in this agreeing with his Master and with Paul, finding in love of neighbor the sum of the Law and its true fulfilment. Respect of persons, he affirms, is a breach of this “royal law,” and leads to those in- dulging in it being “‘convicted” by the law of trans- gression (ver 9). He then affirms the solidarity of the Law, so that a breach of it in one particular is a breach of the whole, and makes a man “guilty of all” (ver 10), a far-reaching principle which Paul had also indicated when quoting in Gal the words, “Cursed is every one who continueth not in all things that are written in the book of the law, to do them” (Gal 3 10), and when in Rom 7 he showed that the conviction that he had broken the 10th com- mandment made him realize that he had broken the whole Law. James then exhorts his readers to speak and act as those who are to be judged by “a law of liberty” (2 12), so that he sets no limit to the range of that law. Finally,in 4 11, he warns them by implication against speaking against the Law or judging the Law, that is, to assume the place of judge instead of “doer of the law.’ James could not have used such language unless he had a profound conviction of the perfection of the Law. And it is the perfection of the Law as arule of life for spiritual men redeemed from its condemnation that James considers it, and so we can call it the perfect law, the law of hberty, the Royal Law. Lawinthe OT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1852 In the Epp. of Peter and John, the word “law” does not occur, but Peter shows that the holiness of God remains as in the Pent the 6. Inthe standard of life, and the example of Epistles of Christ shows the way (1 Pet 2 21), Peter and while in the church is found the spirit- John ual realization of the sanctuary, priest- hood and sacrifices of the old economy (1 Pet 2 5-9). Peter has one reference to the Rom law, enjoining upon his readers obedience to it in the political sphere. John enjoins the keeping of the commandments, these being apparently the commandments of Christ (1 Jn 2 3.4; 6 2), and the test of keeping the commandments is love of the brethren, while hatred of a brother is, as in the Sermon on the Mount, murder. All sin is “law- lessness” (3 4), and the sum of all law-keeping is love of God and love of the brethren, and so the summary of the old Law is echoed and endorsed. Literaturs.—Chiefly the works on NT theology (Weiss, Beyschlag, Schmid, etc), and on Christian ethics (Martensen, Dorner, Harless, etc), with comms. on Pauline Epp. (Rom, etc); Ritschl, Enisiehung der altk. Kirche (2d ed); Zahn, Das Gesetz Gottes nach der Lehre und der Erfahrung des Apostels Paulus; J. Denney, DB. Arcatpato M’Caie LAW IN THE OLD TESTAMENT: I. Terms Usep 1. Torah ( Law’) 2. Synonyms of Téréh (1) Migwah (‘'Command"’) (2) ‘Edhah (‘' Witness," '' Testimony’’) (3) Mishpatim ( Judgments’') (4) Hukkim (‘'Statutes’’) (5) Pikkidhim (‘'Precepts”’) II, THe Written Recorp or tHe Law 1. The Critical Dating of the Laws 2. Groups of Laws in P 3. The Book of the Covenant (1) Judgments. Compared with Code of Ham- murabi (2) Basis of Law of Covenant. Earlier Cus- toms . The Book of the Law of Dt 31 . The Law of Holiness . The Final Compilation III. Tur General CaaracTER AND DeEsIGN OF THE 1. The Civil Law 1) Servants and the Poor Q) Punishments 3) Marriage (4) Sabbaths and Feasts 2. The Ceremonial Law (1) Origin of Sacrifice (2) The Levitical Ritual (3) The Law Truly a Torah IV. Tue Passine Away or THE LAW LITERATURE Law, at least as custom, certainly existed among the Hebrews in the times before Moses, as appears from numerous allusions to it, both in matters civil and ceremonial, in the earlier Scriptures. But we have no distinct account of such law, either as to its full contents or its enactment. Law in the OT practically means the Law promulgated by Moses (having its roots no doubt in this earlier law or custom), with sundry later modifications or addi- tions, rules as to which have been inserted in the record of the Mosaic law. The following are matters of pre-Mosaic law or custom to which allusion is made in Gen and Ex: the offering of sacrifice and the use of altars (Gen passim); the religious use of pillars (Gen 28 18); purification for sacrifice (35 2); tithes (14 20; 28 22); circumcision (17 10; Ex 4 25f); inquiry at a sanctuary (Gen 26 22); sacred feasts (Ex 6 1, etc); priests (Ex 19 22); sacred oaths (Gen 14 22); marriage customs (16; 24; 25 6; 29 16-30); birthright (25 31-34); elders (24 2; 607; Ex 3 16); homicide (Gen 9 6), etc. We proceed at once to the Law of Moses. I, Terms Used.—The Heb word rendered “‘law’’ in our Bibles is M70, torah. Other synonymous your words either denote (as indeed does térah itself) aspects under which the Law may be regarded, or different classes of law. Torah is from hérah, the Hiphil of yérah. The root meaning is “to throw”; hence in Hiphil the word means “to point out’ (as by throwing out the hand), and so “to direct”; and térah is “direction.” Torah may be simply “human direction,” as the ‘Jaw of thy mother’ in Prov 1 8; but most often in the OT it is the Divine law. In the sing. it often means a law, the pl. being used in the same sense; but more frequently ¢drah in the sing. is the general body of Divinely given law. The word tells nothing as to the way in which the Law, or any part of it, was first given; it simply points out the general purpose of the Law, viz. that it was for the guidance of God's people in the various matters to which it relates. This shows that the end of the Law lay beyond the mere obedience to such and such rules, that end being instruction in the knowledge of God and of men’s relation to Him, and guidance in living as the children of such a God as He revealed Him- self to be. This is dwelt upon in the later Scrip- tures, notably in Pss 19 and 119. In the completed Canon of the OT, téraéh techni- cally denotes the Pent (Lk 24 44) as being that division of the OT Scriptures which contains the text of the Law, and its history down to the death of Moses, the great lawgiver. (1) Migwa@h, “command” (or, in pl., “com- mands’’), is a term applied to the Law as indi- cating that it is a charge laid upon 1. Torah 2. Syno- men as the expression of God’s will, nyms of and therefore that it must be obeyed. Torah (2) ‘Hdhah, ‘witness’ or “testi- mony” (in pl. “testimonies”), is a designation of God’s law as testifying the principles of His dealings with His people. So the ark of the covenant is called the ‘ark of the testimony” (Ex 25 22), as containing ‘‘the testimony’? (ver 16), i.e. the tables of the Law upon which the covenant was based. The above terms are general, applying to the tarah at large; the two next following are of more restricted application. (3) Mishpatim, ‘judgments’: Mishpatin the sing. sometimes means Judgment in an abstract sense, as in Gen 18 19; Dt 32 4; sometimes the act of judging, as in Dt 16 18.19; 179; 2417. But “judgments” (in the pl.) is a term constantly used in connection with, and distinction from, statutes, to indicate laws of a particular kind, viz. laws which, though forming part of the tarah by virtue of Divine sanction, originated in decisions of judges upon cases bronght before them for judgment. See further: below. : (4) Hukkim, “statutes” (lit. “laws engraven”’), are laws immediately enacted by a lawgiver. “Judg- ments and statutes’ together comprise the whole law (Lev 18 4; Dt 41.8 AV). So also we now distinguish between consuetudinary and statute law. (5) Pikkddhim, “precepts”: This term is found only in the Pss. It seems to mean rules or coun- sels provided to suit the various circumstances in which men may be placed. The term may perhaps be meant to apply both to the rules of the actual térah, and to others found, e.g. in the writings of prophets and “wise men.” II, The Written Record of the Law.—The enact- ment of the Law and its committal to writing must be distinguished. With regard to the former, it is distinctly stated (Jn 1 17) that “the law was given through Moses”; and though this does not neces- sarily imply that every regulation found in the Pent is his, a large number of the laws are expressly as- cribed to him. As regards the latter, we are dis- tinctly told that Moses wrote certain laws or col- 1853 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Law in the OT lections of laws (Ex 17 14; 24 4.7; Dt 31 9). These, however, form only a portion of the whole legislation; and therefore, whether the remaining portions were written by Moses, or—if not by him —when and by whom, is a legitimate matter of inquiry. _ It is not necessary here to discuss the large ques- tion of the literary history of the Pent, but it must briefly be touched upon. The Pent certainly appears to have reached its present form by the gradual piecing together of diverse materials. Dt being a separate composition, a distinction would seem to have been clearly established by critical examination between a number of paragraphs in the remaining books which apparently must once have formed a narrative by themselves, and other paragraphs, partly narrative but chiefly legislative and statistical, which appear to have been subse- quently added. Without endorsing any of the critical theories as to the relation of these, one to the other, or as to the dates of their composition, we may, in a general way, accept the analysis, and adopt the well-known symbol JE to distinguish the former, and P the latter. Confining ourselves to their legislative contents, we find in JE a short but very important body of law, the Law of the Cove- nant, stated in full in Ex 20-23, and repeated as to a portion of it in Ex 34 10-28. All the rest of the legislation is contained in P and Dt. We are distinctly told in Ex that the law con- tained in Ex 20-23 was given through Moses. Re- jecting this statement, critics of the 1. The school of Wellhausen affirm that its Critical true date must be placed considerably Dating of later than the time of Joshua. They the Laws maintain that previous to their con- quest of Canaan the Israelites were mere nomads, ignorant of agriculture, the practice of which, as well as their culture in general, they first learned from the conquered Canaanites. There- fore (so they argue), as the law of Ex 20-28 pre- supposes the practice of agriculture, it cannot have been promulgated until some time in the period of the Judges at the earliest; they place it indeed in the early period of the monarchy. All this, however, is mere assumption, support for which is claimed in some passages in which a shepherd life is spoken of, but with utter disregard of others which show that both in the patriarchal period and in Egypt the Israelites also cultivated land. See B. D: Eerdmans, “Have the Hebrews Been No- mads?” Expos, August and October, 1908. It can indeed be shown that this law was throughout in harmony with what must have been the customs and conceptions of the Israelites at the age of the exodus (Rule, OT Institutions). Professor Kerdmans in his Alitestamentliche Studien, Part III (1910), vigorously defends the Mosaic origin of the Book of the Covenant. ; The same critics bring down the date of the legis- lation of Dt to the time of Josiah, or at most a few years earlier. They affirm (wrongly) that the chief object of Josiah’s reformation narrated in 2K 23 was the centralization of worship at the temple in Jerus. They rightly attribute the zeal which carried the reform through to the discovery of the “Book of the Law” (22 8). Then arguing that the frequent previous practice of worship at high places implied the non-existence of any law_to the con- trary, they conclude that the rule of Dt 12 was a rule recently laid down by the temple priesthood, and written in a book in Moses’ name, this new book being what was “found in the house of Jeh.” But this argument is altogether unsound: its grave difficulties are well set ont in Miller’s Are the Critics Right? And_here again careful study vindicates the Mosaic character of the law of Dt as a whole and of Dt 12in particular. M. Edouard Naville in La découvcrie de ta loi sous le roi Josias propounds a theory which he supports by a most interest- ing argument: that the book found was a founda- tion deposit, which must therefore have been built over by masonry at the erection of the temple by Solomon. Equally unsound, however plausible, are the arguments which would make the framing of the Levitical ritual the work of the age of Ezra. The difficulties created by this theory are far greater than those which it is intended to remove. On this also see Méller, Are the Critics Right? Rejecting these theories, it will be assumed in the present art. that the various laws are of the dates ascribed to them in the Pent; that whatever may be said as to the date of some “of the laws,” all which are therein ascribed to Moses are truly so ascribed. ‘ The laws in P are arranged for the most part in groups, with which narrative is sometimes inter- mingled. These e.g. are some of the 2. Groups groups: Ex 25-31; Lev 1-7; 11-15; of Laws Nu 1-4, etc. The structure an in P probable history of these groups are very interesting. That many of them must have undergone interpolation appears certain from the following considerations. Each of the groups, and often one or more paragraphs within a group, is headed by a recurring formula, ‘“‘Jeh spake unto Moses [or unto Aaron, or unto Moses and Aaron], saying.” We might at first expect that the contents of each group or paragraph so headed would consist solely of what ooh had said unto Moses or Aaron, but this is not always so. Not infrequently some direction is found within such a paragraph which cannot have been spoken to Moses, but must have come into force at some later date. Unless then we reject the statement of the formula, unless we are prepared to say that Jeh did not speak unto Moses, we can only conclude that these later directions were at some time in- serted by an editor into paragraphs which originally contained Mosaic laws only. That this should have been done would be perfectly natural, when we consider that the purpose of such an editor would be not only to preserve (as has been done) the record of the original Law, but to present a manual of law complete for the use of his age, a manual (to use a modern phrase) made complete to date. That the passages in question were indeed inter- polations appears not only from the fact that their removal rids the text of what otherwise would be grave discrepancies, but because the passages in question sometimes disturb the sequence of the context. Moreover, by thus distinguishing be- tween laws promulgated (as stated) by Moses, and laws to which the formula of statement was not intended to apply, we arrive at the following im- ortant result. It is that the former laws can all e shown to be in harmony one with another and with the historical data of the Mosaic age; while the introduction of the later rules is also seen to be what would naturally follow'by way of adaptation to the circumstances of later times, and the gradual unfolding of Divine purpose. It would be much too long a task here to work this out in detail: it has been attempted by the writer of this article in OT Institutions, Their Origin and Devel- opment. Two instances, however, may he mentioned. Instances of interpolation.—In Ex 12 43 ff (ERV) we read, ‘' This is the ordinance of the passover: there shall no alien eat thereof; but every man’s servant that is hought for money, when thou hast circumcised him, then shall he eat thereof. A sojourner and a hired servant shall not eat thereof.”’ This was the original Mosaic rule introduced hy the formula.in ver 43. But in vs 48.49 it is said that sojourners (when circumcised) may Lawinthe OT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1854 eat of the passover. This was plainly a relaxation of later date, made in accordance with the principle which is enlarged upon in Isa 56 3-8. According to Lev 23 34.39a.40-42, the Feast of Tabernacles was a feast of seven days only. This was the Mosaic rule as: appears from the formula in ver 33, and in certain other passages. But as a development in the feast’s observance, an eighth day was subsequently added, and therefore insertions to that effect were made here at vs 36 and 39b. The introduction of this addi- tional day would be in keeping with that elaboration in the observance of the "set teasts’’ which we find in Nu 28 and 29, as compared with the simpler observance of the same days ordered in Lev 28. Here again the formula in Nu 28 1 plainly covered a few verses imme- diately following, but not the whole content of the two chapters. : Premising then the existence in writing from an early age of numerous groups of Mosaic laws and their subsequent interpolation, the ultimate com- pilation of these groups together with other matter and their arrangement in the order in which we now find them must have been the work, perhaps indeed of the interpolator, but in any case of some late editor. These numerous groups do not, how- ever, make up the whole legislative contents of the Pent; for a very large portion of these contents consists of three distinct books of law, which we must now examine. These were the ‘Book of the Covenant,” the “Book of the Law” of Dt 31 26, and the so-called ‘‘Law of Holiness.” ; This book, expressly so named (Ex 24 7), is stated to have been written by Moses (24 3.4). It must have comprised the contents of 3. The Ex 20-23. The making of the cove- Book of the nant at Sinai, led up to by the reveal- Covenant ing words of Ex 3 12-17; 6 2-8; 19 3-6, was a transaction of the very first importance in the religious history of Israel. God’s revelation of Himself to Israel being very largely, indeed chiefly, a revelation of His moral attributes (Ex 84 6.7), could only be effectively apprehended by a people who were morally fitted to receive it. Hence it. was that Israel as a nation was now placed by God in a stated relation to Himself by means of a covenant, the condition upon which the covenant was based being, on His people’s part, their obe- dience to a given law. This was the law contained in the “Book of the Covenant.” ; Ti consisted of “words of Jeh” and “judgments” (Ex 24 3 AV). The latter are contained in Ex 21 1—22 17; the former in ch 20, in the remaining portion of ch 22, and ch 28. The “judgments” (ARV “ordinances’’) relate entirely to matters of right between man and man; the “words of Jeh” relate partly to these and partly to duties dis- tinctively religious. (1) The judgments compared with Code of Hammurabi. —The "‘judgments"' appear to be taken ‘trom older consuetudinary law; not necessarily comprising the whole of that law, but so much of it as it pleased God now to stamp with His express sanction and to embody in this Covenant Law. They may well be compared with those contained in the so-called Code of Ham- murabi, king of Babylon, who is thought to have been the Amraphel of Gen 14. These are called ‘'the judg- ments of righteousness which amare the mighty king confirmed.’ The resemblances in form and in subject between the two sets of judgments” are very striking. All alike have the same structure, beginning with a hypothetical clause, ‘‘if so and so,” and then giving the rule applicable in the third person. All alike relate entirely to civil, as distinguished from religious, matters, to rights and duties between man and man. All seem to have had a similar origin in judgments passed in the first place on causes brought hefore judges for sere both sets therefore represent consuetudinary aw. : (2) Basis of the law of the covenant on earlier custom and conception.—It is remarkable that, alike in matters ot right between man and man, and in matters relating directly to the service of God, the Law of the Covenant did little Gf anything) more than give a new and Di- vinely attested sanction to requirements which, being already familiar, appealed to the general conscience of the community. If, indeed, in the ‘‘words of Jeh” there was any tightening of accustomed moral or (more particularly) rellgious requlremeuts, e.g. In the first and second commandments of the Decalogue, it would seem to have been by way of enforcing convictions which must have been already gaining hold upon the minds of at least the more thoughtful of the people, and that in large measure through the lessons impressed upon them by the events of their recent history. In no other way could the Law of the Covenant have appealed to their conscience, and so formed a foundation on which the covenant could be securely based. As in the "judgments" we have a ratification of old consuetudinary law; as again in the second table of the Decalogue we have moral rules in accordance with a standard of moral right—no doubt already acknowledged very similar indeed to that of the ‘‘ negative confession’ in the Egyp Book of the Dead; so in the more especially religious rules of the Law of the Covenant we find, not new rules or an establishment of new institutions, but a new sanction of what was already old. These ‘‘ words of Jeh’’ assume the rendering of service to Jeh: they do not enjoin it as if it were a new thing, but they enjoin that the Israelites shall not add to His service also the service of other gods (Ex 20 3; 23 24). They assume the observance of the three ‘‘feasts,’’ they enjoin that these shall he kept to Jeh—"' unto me,” i.e. ‘unto me only"’ (vs 14.17). They assume the making of certain offerings to Jeh, they enjoin that these shall be made liber- ally—" of the first,” i.e. of the best—and without delay (22 29f). They assume the rendering of worship by sacrifice, and the existence of an accustomed ritual, and therefore they do not lay down any scheme of ritual, but they give a few directions designed to guard against idolatry, or any practices tending either to irreverence or to low and false concep ilons of God (Ex 20 4-6.23-— 26; 22 31; 23 181). While insisting upon the observ- ance of the three ‘‘feasts,"’ spoken of as already accus- tomed, it is remarkable that they contain no command to keep the Passover, which as an annual observance was not yet an accustomed thing. This absence of ritual directions is indeed _ very no- ticeable. It was in the counsel of God that He would in the near future establish a reconstituted ritual, based upon what was already traditional, but containing cer- tain new elements, and so framed as more and more to foster spiritual conceptions of God and a higher ideal of holiness. This however was as yet a thing of the future. No mention therefore was made of it in the Law of the Covenant; that law was so restricted as that It should at once appeal to the general conscience of the people, and so be a true test of their desire to do what was right. This would be the firm basis on which to build pee higher things. It is impossible to estimate the true character of the subsequent legislation, i.e. of what in bulk is by far the larger part of the aera rast by first grasping the true character and motive of the Covenant, and the Covenant Law. See also Covenant, Boox or; PENTATEUCH. Immediately after the making of the Covenant, Moses was called up into the mount, and there re- ceived instructions for the erection of 4. The the tabernacle, these being followed Book of the in due course by the rules of the re- Law of constituted ceremonial of which the Dt 31 tabernacle was to be the home. All these for the present we must pass over. Having arrived on the E. of the Jordan, Moses, now at the close of his career, addressed discourses to the people, in which he earnestly exhorted them to live up to the high calling with which God had called them, in the land of which they were about to take possession. To this end he embodied in his discourse a statement of the Law by which they were to live. And then, as almost his last public act, he wrote “the words of this law in a book,” and directed that the book should be placed “by the side of the ark of the covenant” (Dt 31 24-26). What now was this book? Was it Dt, in whole or in part? The most reasonable answer to this question is that the book actually written by Moses comprised at least the contents of Dt 5-26 and 28. Whether the whole or any parts of the remaining contents of Dt also formed part of this book, or were subsequently added to it, the whole being brought by a process of editing to our present Dt, is again a legitimate matter of inquiry. Characteristics of Deuteronomy.—Regarding Dt 5-26 and 28 (with or without parts of other chap- ters) as the “book” of Dt 31 24-26, we find that it is a manual of instruction for the people at large—it is not a priest’s manual. It deals with matters of morals, and of religion in its general principles, but eS SEO aT Aon RAR = TR ORE ss z Sato at i oie ae z ae rae ; i ass CODE OF HAMMURABI 1855 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Law in the OT only subordinately with matters of ritual: it warns against perils of idolatry and superstitious cor- ruptions, common in the service of other gods, but which might by no means be mixed up with Jeh’s service: it insists upon righteous conduct between man and man, and very strongly inculcates hu- manity toward the poor and the dependent: it enjoins upon those in authority the impartial main- tenance of right, as also fairness, moderation and mercy, in the administration of law and the inflic- tion of punishment: it sets forth the fear of God as the guide of His people’s actions, and the love of God in response to His mercy toward them. It does not lay down any scheme of ritual, though it gives rules (14 3-21) as to things which might not be eaten as unclean; it also gives directions as to the disposal of tithes (14 22-29; 26 12); it enlarges upon the direction in the Law of the Covenant for the observance of the three “feasts,’’ adding to this the observance of the Passover (ch 16); it lays down a law (expressed conditionally) restricting to one sanctuary the offering of at least the more solemn sacrifices (ch 12); and it frequently inculcates liber- ality toward the Levites, both on account of the sacred services rendered by them, their dispersal among the tribes, and the precarious character of their livelihood. Like the Law of the Covenant it assumes the existence of an accustomed ceremonial, and it is remarkable that when there is occasion to do so it makes use of phraseology (ch 12) similar to that of the ritual laws of Moses in Lev and Nu. It is quite possible that some interpolations may have been made in the text of chs 5-26, but not on any sufficient scale to affect the general character of the original book. This ‘Book of the Law” then was an expansion of the Law of the Covenant, en- forcing its principles, giving directions in greater detail for carrying them out, and setting them in a framework of exhortation, warning and encourage- ment. Thus its relation to the covenant is indi- cated by Dt 26 16-19; 29 1. This is that “book of the Law of Moses’ of which frequent mention is made in the books of K, Ch, Ezr and Neh. In marked contrast to the numerous rules, some- times intermingled with narrative, which we find in Ex 26-40; Lev 1-16, and through- 6. The Law out Nu, we have in Lev 17-26 a col- of Holiness lection of laws which evidently was once a book by itself. This, from its constant insistence upon holiness as a motive of conduct, has been called “the Law of Holiness.” Though it contains many laws stated to have been spoken by Jeh to Moses, we are not told by whom it was written, and therefore its authorship and date are a fair subject of inquiry. In its general design it bears much resemblance to the Law of the Covenant, and the Book of the Law contained in Dt. Asin them, and esp. in the latter, the laws are set up in a parenetic framework, the whole closing with promise of reward for obedience and a threat of punishment for disobedience (cf Ex 23 20-33; Lev 26; Dt 28). Like them it deals much with moral duties: chs 19 and 20 are practically an expansion of the Decalogue; but it deals also more than they do with ceremonial. With regard to both it sets forth as the motive of obedience the tule, “Be ye holy, for I am holy.” — its date is to be found in jee eoncention of. Riosnnersst The idea found in the Prophets and the NT that moral wrongdoing renders unclean must be based upon some earlier conception, viz. upon the OT conception of ritual uncleanness. Now ritual uncleanness was originally physical uncleanness only; the idea of moral right or wrong did not enter into it at all: this is perfectly clear from the whole contents Cee ee Or ne on eced l ! ene rae. pail saa in eo pnete ineludine the earlier prophets, a, and Isaiah. In H we find an interme- Amos. dneoption, We find that whereas in Lev 11-15 sexual acts which were iawful rendered_unciean equally with those which were unlawful, in H adultery and incest are denounced as rendering specially unclean, the idea heing that their technical uncleanness hecame more | intensely unciean through their immorality (Lev 18 24-30). Similarly, converse with familiar spirits and wizards, which probeply) involved physical defilement (perhaps through the ingredients used in charms), is mentioned as specially causing defilement, prohably as such technical defilement wouid he intensified hy the unlawfulness of dealing with familiar spirits and wizards at ail (Lev 19 31). Sins, however, which did not in themselves entaii physicai uncleanness, such e.g. as injustice, are not mentioned in H as rendering unclean, though they are so regarded in the Prophets. First, then, we have ritual uncieanness, which is physical only in the rules of Lev 11-15 (Mosaic rules undoubtedly embodying a pre-Mosaic conception); lastly, we have moral wrong in itself rendering unclean, in the Pss and the Prophets; intermediately we have the transitional conception in H. The date therefore of the Law of Holiness may be Mosaic, hut must be considerably earlier than the earliest of the writing prophets. The remaining groups of Mosaic laws would appear to have been extant in their original form (i.e. without interpolation), no doubt 6. The in the custody of the priesthood for Final Com- probably a very considerable time, it pilation may have been for centuries, before their final compilation in their present form. The arrangement of these groups as they now stand, before and after H and with narrative intermingled, is by no means haphazard, as it might at first appear. (1) Exodus.—As the directions for the erection of the tahernacle with the purpose of its several parts were given to Moses immediately after the making of the covenant, they foliow the account of it immediately. Thus Ex contains the history of the covenant-making, of what led up to it, and of what immediately followed puede. the provision of the home for the covenant-wor- ship. (2) Leviticus.—This book follows with the rules of that worship; not indeed with all its details, but with an account of all that was essential to it. First (in Lev 1— 7) we have the law of sacrifice, including what was so esp. peculiar to the covenant-worship, the law of the sin offering. Then in chs 8-10 we have the consecration of the tahernacle and its contents, the consecration of its priests and the inanguration of the newly prescribed system of worship. Then in chs 11-15 we have the rules for purification from ritual uncleanness, without which it would have been impossibie for this system of covenant- worship to be carried on. Then there foliows in Lev 16 the account of the ceremonies of the Day of Atonement, the crown and completion of the whole. Thus in these 16 chapters we have an account of the essentials of the newly instituted covenant-worship. And then imme- diately we have in the Law of Holiness the great. motive that underlay both this ceremonial law and the preceding moral and religious law_of the Book of the Covenant, viz. the principle that God’s people must be holy, be- cause He is holy. The emphasizing of this principle in H thus closes this whole statement of law, as its first enunciation had introduced it in Ex 19 6. (3) Numbers.—The purpose of Nu is supplementary. Nu 1-6, containing the numhering and ordering of the tribes and rules as to the representative Levitical min- istry, sets forth the corporate character of Israel’s serv- ice of God. The Israelites were not to be a mere aggre- gation of tribes, but a single nation, the bond of their union heing the covenant with God. The camp itself, ordered and carefully guarded against pollution, was to he a symbol of this holy unity. Chs 7-10 narrate the remaining occurrences at Sinai, including (9 1-14) the important account of the first commemorative Passover. The remaining chapters contain, alternately, a narrative of events following the departure from Sinai and groups of laws usually in some way connected with the events narrated, but ail of them supplementary to the more essential laws already recorded. (4) Deuteronomy.—As @ separate work and _ hased upon sayings and doings at the very close of the 40 years, Dt naturally follows last. UI. The General Character and Design of the Law.—Both in civil matters and in ceremonial the Law had to deal with men who lived in a compara- tively early age of human history. Its rules were necessarily adapted in both departments to the standards of the age. At the same time they in- culeated principles, the working out of which would by degrees bring about a great advance in men’s con- ceptions both of what is true and of what is right. lawinthe OT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA. 1856 As J. B. Mozley says (Lectures on the OT), “The morality of a progressive revelation is not the moral- ity with which it starts but that with 1. The Civil which it concludes”; yet the excellence Law of the OT Law is evident, not only in its great underlying principles, but in the suitability of its individual rules to promote moral advance. (1) Servants and the poor—We have already noted the similarity between the “judgments” of Ex 20 and 21 and the “judgments” of Hammurabi, in respect to form and subject. Notwithstanding the practical wisdom found in many of the latter, there is in one matter a marked contrast in spirit between them and the former, for while both the Law of the Covenant and its enlargement in Dt guarded the interest of and secured justice, and mercy too, to slaves and the poor, the laws of Ham- murabi were framed rather in the interests of the well-to-do. Cf (e.g.) with the rule as to a runaway slave in Dt 23 15f, the following (CH, § 16): ‘If a man has harbored in his house a manservant or a maidgservant fugitive from the palace, or a poor man, and has not produced them at the demand of the commandant, the owner of that house shall be put to death.” The Law indeed permitted slavery, an institution universal in the ancient world, but it made provisions which must very greatly have mitigated its hardship. It was en- joined, both in Ex and in Dt, that after six years’ service a Heb manservant should “go out free for nothing,’”’ unless he himself preferred to remain in servitude (Ex 21 2-6; Dt 15 12-18). The rule in Ex 21 7-11 as to women servants was not ex- actly the same, but it nevertheless guarded their interests, while Heb women servants were afterward included in the rule of Dt 15 12. A still greater amelioration was brought in by a later rule con- nected with the law of the Jubilee as set ont in Lev 25 39-55. Again, though servitude was permitted on account of debt, or as a rescue from poverty (Ex 21 2.7; Dt 15 12), manstealing was a capital offence (Ex 21 16). (2) Punishments—The rule of Ex 21 22-25 (“eye for eye,” etc; cf Lev 24 19.20; Dt 19 16- 19) sounds harsh to us, but while the justice it sanctioned was rough and ready according to the age, it put a restraint on vindictiveness. The punishment might be so much, but no more: and the same spirit of restraint in punishment is seen in the rule as to flogging (Dt 25 2f). Similarly the rule that murder was to be avenged by ‘the avenger of blood,” a rule under the circumstances of the age both necessary and salutary, was pro- tected from abuse by the appointment of places of refuge, the rule with respect to which was designed to prepare the way for a better system (see Ex 21 12-14; Nu 36 9-24; Dt 19 1-18). (8) Marriage—The marriage customs of the Mosaic age permitted polygamy and concubinage, marriage by purchase or by capture in war, slave- marriage, and divorce. The Law allowed the con- tinuance of these customs, but did not originate them; on the contrary, its provisions were designed to restrict the old license, giving protection to the weaker party, the woman, limiting as far as possible the evils of the traditional system, a system which ‘could not suddenly be changed, and preparing the way for a better. Consider the effect of the follow- ing rules: as to slave-wives (Ex 21 7-11); captives of war (Dt 21 10-14); plurality of wives (Dt 21 15-17); adultery (Ex 20 14.17; Dt 22 22); forni- cation (Dt 22 23-29; 23 17.18; Lev 21 9); divorce (Dt 24 1-4); Levirate marriage (Dt 25 5-10); in- cest (Lev 18 6-18); marriage of priests (Lev 21 7.10-15); royal polygamy (Dt 17 17). (4) Sabbaths and feasts——The law as to these, though partly ceremonial, yet served social ends. The Sabbath day gave to all, and particularly to servants and the poor, and domestic cattle too, a needful respite from daily toil; it also served men’s spiritual welfare, and did honor to God (Ex 23 12; Dt 6 14.15; Ex 31 12-17). The seventh year’s rest to the land —it also ‘‘a sabbath of solemn rest, a sabbath unto Jeh’”—was for the land’s re- cuperation, but it served also to safeguard common rights at perhaps a time of transition as to customs of land tenure: connected with it also there were rules as to release of slaves and relief of debtors (Ex 23 9-11; Lev 25 2-7; Dt 15 1-18). The ob- servance of the Sabbath year as a rest to the land seems to have fallen into disuse, perhaps as early as some 500 years before the Bab captivity (2 Ch 36 21), and it is probable that the Jubilee (the design of which seems to have been to adjust conflicting rights under new customs of land tenure and in the relation of employer to employed) was instituted to take its place (Lev 25). The law as to the an- nual feasts insured both the social advantages of festive gatherings of the Neato and their sancti- fication by the worship of God, and the public recog- nition of His hand in matters agricultural and politi- cal, which were either the occasion of, or connected with, these gatherings. Considerate liberality to the poor and dependent was, on these occasions, esp. enjoined (Ex 23 14-17; Dt 16 1-17; 12 12.18.19). We have already noted that the conception of sin as uncleanness, rendering the sinner therefore unfit for the presence of God, must 2. The have been an outgrowth from the earlier Ceremonial conception of purely ritual (physical) Law uncleanness. This development, and an accompanying sense of the hein- ousness of sin and of its need of atonement hy sacrifice, were undoubtedly brought about by the gradual working of the law of the sin offering (Lev 4 i—6 18; 12-15; 16). Similarly the rules as to guilt offerings (Lev 5 14—6 7) must by degrees have led to a true conception of repentance, as in- cluding both the secking of atonement throngh sacrifice and restitution for wrong committed. The sin offering was, however, a peculiarly Mosaic in- stitution, marking a development in the sacrificial system. The only sacrifices of which we have any trace in pre-Mosaic times were meal and drink offerings, whole burnt offerings and _ sacrifices (or, to use the Levitical term, peace offerings). (1) Origin of sacrifice—We read of the offering of sacrifice all through the patriarchal history, and farther back even than Noah in the story of Cain and Abel; and there can be ne doubt that the Levitical scheme of sacri- fice was based upen, and a development (under Divine ordering) of, the sacrificial system already traditional among the Hebrews. Sacrifice was undoubtedly of Divine origin; yet we have no account, or even hint of any formal institution of sacrifice. The sacrifices of Cain and Abel are spoken of in a way that leaves the impression that they were offered spontaneously, and the most probable assumption would seem to be that the very first offering of sacrifice was the outcome of a spontaneous desire (Divinely implanted, we may be Sure) in early men to render service to the higher Being of whose relation to themselves they were, if cver so dimly, conscious. Prehistcric research has not yet been ahle te present to us a distinct picture of primitive men; and even if the results of anthropology were more certain than they can yet claim te be, what in this connection we are con- cerned in is the conceptions, net of early men every- where, but of the early ancestors of the Heh race. However infantile their ideas may have heen and prebably were, there may well have been far more of elementary truth in them—in simple ldeas Divinely implanted—than students ef anthropelegy have any knowledge of. Sconer or later early men did make offerings to Ged; and as the Mosaic sacrificial system was certainly based upen the patriarchal, so we may fairly assume that the ideas underlying the latter were an cutgrowth from these which underlay the sacrifice of the patriarch's own still earlier ancestors. It is well observed hy Dr. A. B. Davidson (OT The- ology, p. 315) that the sacrifices of Cain and Abel are called 1857 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Law in the OT a@ minhah or present; and this idea of sacrifice as a gift to God most easily accounts for the facts with which we have to deal in the history of OT sacrifice. When early men first made offerings to God, they probably did so in the spirit of young children who give gifts to older persons without knowing whether, or in what way, the gifts will be of any use to them. They simpiy give in affection what is of value in their own eyes. The one only thing of prime value to the earliest men must have been food: hence offerings to God were everywhere in the first place Offerings of food. But here a difficulty must soon have arisen, for men must have become convinced very soon that the Divine Being did not feed upon the food offered, at least in men's way of feeding. Ultimately, among the Israelites, the idea of His actual feeding’ became eliminated altogcther (Ps §0 13.14), but in the mean- tlme the difficulty seems to have been met by the assump- tion that the Divine Being consumed an inner essence of food; and this being supposed to be set free by fire, food offered in sacrifice came to be burnt in order to fit it to become the food of God. This certainly appears from Lev 8 11.16 (cf Lev 21 6.8.17.21). Coming, however, to animal as distinguished from vegetable sacrifice, we do not find that its origin can be accounted for as at the first belng an offering of food. We learn from Lev 17 10-14 that the essential part of animal] sacrifice was the offering of the blocd, and that blood was offered because blood was life. The idea that lite can be given by giving blood lay at the root of a cus- tom which must have been well-nigh universal in primi- tive times, that of blood covenanting (see H. Clay Trum- bull, Blood Covenant). In this, two persons would give each to the other of his own blood, drawn from the living vein. Persons united in blood covenant were supposed, by the commingling of their blood, to become actual sharers of one life. To give to another of one’s own blood was to give one’s own life, i.e. one’s own self, with all the dedication of love and service which that would imply. Now a similar idea would seem to have lain at the root of the primitive offering of blood to God: it was the offering of the life of the offerer. In the very first blood offerings itis probable that the bicod offered was the blood of the offerer, and that there was no infliction of death—only in this way the dedi- cation of life. The dedicatory rite of circumcision may have been a survival of sacrifice in this its earliest form; so also what is narrated in 1 K 18 28. When, however, the blood offered had come to be the blood of a substi- tute, and that a substitute animal, the sacrifice would come (no doubt soon) to include the slaughter of the anima] and further the consumption, in whole or in part, of its carcase by fire as an offering of food. (2) The Levitical ritual—Whether the above theory be accepted or not, in so far as animal sacri- fice became an offcring of food, it would stand in line with vegetable sacrifice; but in both the excel- lence of the Levitical ritual stood in this, that while it was framed for a people whose conceptions were in a stage of transition, it was yet adaptable to higher conceptions, and fitted to become at length symbolical of purely spiritual truth. It was through the teaching, not only of prophets but of the Levitical ritual itself, and while it was still in full force, that the words of Ps 50 13.14 were uttered: “Will I eat the flesh of bulls, or drink the blood of goats? Offer unto God the sacrifice of thanksgiving; and pay thy vows unto the Most High.” The Levitical ritual, as respects animal sacrifice in particular, was so framed as, on the one hand, to keep alive the idea of sacrifice as the offer- ing of life, not of death, of life’s dedication, not its destruction, and therefore to make it a true type of Christ’s living sacrifice. On the other hand, the rules of sacrifice guarded against abuses which, as a matter of fact, sprang up widely among the heathen. The rule, e.g. in Lev 1 2 and elsewhere, that ‘ye shall offer your oblation of the cattle, even of the herd and of the flock,” excluded human sac- rifice. The rule that the first act in every sacrifice must be to slay the creature offered excluded the infliction of unnecessary suffering. The detailed rules as to the offering and disposal of the blood, and the varying modes of disposal of the carcase, kept alive the essential idea of all such sacrifice, and saved it from degenerating into a mere heaping up, as in Egypt, of altars with mere loads of food. The rules of the peace offering, clothing it always with 2 spiritual motive (see Lev 7 12.16), raised it to a level far above the sacrifice of that class among the surrounding heathen, guarding it against their licentious festivity (ef Hos 2 11-18; 4 13.14; Am 2 8; 5 21-23) and gross ideas as to the part of God in the feasting. (3) The Law truly a térah.—In every one of its departments the Law proved itself to be indeed a torah directing God’s people in the upward way; leading them on from the state of advancement, such as it was, to which they had already attained by Moses’ time, to higher and higher standards, both of faith and of duty, till they were prepared for the gospel of Christ, who Himself said of the old Law, “Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law till all be fulfilled” (Mt 5 18 AV). Meanwhile we have, in the teaching of the prophets, not a counter influence, not asystem rivaling the Law, but its unfolding, both inspired of God, both instruments in His progressive revelation. ‘To obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams’ were the words of Samuel, a faithful servant of the Law, and himself a frequent offerer of sacrifice. What the Law was to the heart of devout Israelites in the prophetic age is seen in the fervent words of Ps 119. IV. The Passing Away of the Law.—The great general principles of the Law were not transitory but abiding, and reappear under the gospel dispen- sation. Otherwise, however, i.e. in those particu- lars, whether ceremonial or civil, in which it was adapted to merely passing needs, the Law passed away when Christ came. It is not always realized that already before Christ came it had begun to pass away. The following are illustrations: (1) The whole rationale of the Levitical worship consisted in its being based upon the covenant made at Sinai, and the symbol of the Covenant was the ark containing the tables of the Law and surmounted by the mercy-seat. Therefore one of its most sig- nificant acts was the sprinkling of the blood of sin offering within the veil upon the mercy-seat, or without the veil, but yet before the mercy-seat. But this most significant act could no longer be per- formed when, after the Bab captivity, there was no longer either ark or mercy-seat. (2) The law that tithe should be paid to the Levites, a tithe only of it being paid by them to “Aaron the priest’. (Nu 18), was practicable so long as the priests were a small portion only of the whole Levitical body, as they appear in the history down to the middle period of the monarchy. But by the time of the exile they disappeared from his- tory except as actual temple ministrants, and, after the return from the exile, even these were in number a mere handful compared with the priests (Ear 2 36-42; 8 15-20.24-30; Neh 11 10-19). The at- tempt to revive the old law (Neh 10 38.39) was well-intentioned but impracticable: it was evi- dently soon abandoned (Neh 18 10-13; Mal 3 8- 10). We learn from Jos that tithes were regarded later as due to the priests, not to the Levites (Jos, Ant, XX, vili, 8; ix, 2). (8) That the Mosaic law as to divorce was to give place to one more stringent appears not only from Our Lord’s words in Mt 19 7-9, but from Mal 2 16. (4) It is probable that some of the supplementary rules in Nu may have been designed for temporary use only, and may have passed away before the close of the OT. It may have been so, e.g., with the law of Nu 5 11-31, a law probably most useful in the circumstances of the Mosaic age, and perhaps itself an endorsement of a pre-Mosaic custom. Lireraturs.—Driver, LOT, with which should be read Moller, Are the Critics Right? and Orr, POT; A.B. Davidson, Theology of the OT; J. B. Mozley, Ruling Ideas in Barly Ages; Rule, OT Institutions, Their Origin and Development; Kurtz, Sacrificial Worship of the OT; Hoonacker, Le sacerdoce lévitique; douard Navilie, Law, Judicial Lay, Laying THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1858 La découverte de la lot sous le roi Josias; H. Clay Trum- bull, The Blood Covenant; Milligan, Resurrection of Our Lord (274 ff, on ‘‘blood-offering’’). Utric Z. Rute LAW, JUDICIAL, j66-dish’al: This was the form of Divine law which, under the dominion of God, as the Supreme Magistrate, directed the policy of the Jewish nation, and hence was binding only on them, not on other peoples. The position of Jeh, as the Supreme Ruler, was made legally binding by a formal election on the part of the national assembly (Ex 19 3-8); and that there might be no question about the matter, after the death of Moses, Joshua, in accordance with instructions received by his great predecessor in the office of federal judge, in the public assembly caused the contract to renewed in connection with most solemn exer- cises (Josh 8 30-35). No legal contract was ever entered into with more formality and with a clearer understanding of the terms by the several parties than was the contract which made it binding on the Hebrews permanently to recognize Jeh as the Su- preme Ruler (Ex 24 3-8). He was to be acknowl- edged as the Founder of the nation (Ex 20 2); Sovereign, Ruler, and Judge (Ex 20 2-6); and in these capacities was to be the object of love, rever- ential fear and worship, service, and absolute ohe- dience. Flagrant disregard of their obligations to Him manifested in idolatry or blasphemy was re- garded as high treason, and like high treason in all nations and history was punishable by death (Ex 20 3-5.7; 22 20; Lev 24 16; Dt 17 2-5). The will of Jeh in critical cases was to be ascertained through special means (Nu 9 8; Jgs 1 1.2; 20 18. 23.28; 1 8 10 22). The ruling official recognized by the Hebrews as a nation was the chief magistrate, but he stood as Jeh’s vicegerent, and therefore combined various authorities in his person. We must distinguish the functions of the chief magistrate (1) under the republic, (2) under the constitutional monarchy, and (3) under the senatorial oligarchy after the Bab captivity. Moses was the first chief magis- trate under the republic; after him, Joshua, and the other judges. Under the constitutional monarchy, it was the king whose government was limited, for he was to be elected by the people; must be a native Hebrew; must not keep a large cavalry; must not support a harem; must not multiply riches; must be a defender of the national religion; must be guided by law, not whim; must he gracious and condescending to the people (Dt 17 15-20). After the Bab captivity, the senatorial oligarchy com- bined ecclesiastical and state authority, later sharing it with the Rom government. See also SANHEDRIN. Frank E. Hirsce LAW, ROMAN. See Roman Law. LAWFUL, 16’fo6l (usually UBW'A, mishpat, “re- lating to judgment,”’ or “a pronounced judgment”; p7IX , caddtk, ‘relating to that which is righteous’ or ‘just’; eon, éxesti, etvopos, etinomos, ‘that which is authorized according to law,” or “a privi- lege according to legitimate custom” [cf Ezk 18 5.19. 21.27; Isa 49 24; Mt_12 10; Acts 16 21; 19 39}): Used of persons: of God, as being righteous both in the punishment of the wicked and the reward- ing of the righteous (Ps 145 17 Heb); of man, as being just and equitable in all his dealings with his fellow-man (Ezk 33 19). It is used of things when the same are in accord with a pronounced judgment or a declared will of God, and thus pleas- ing in His sight (Mk 3 4). When the course of individual conduct is according to God’s law of righteousness, it is declared to be “lawful” (Ezk 33 19). The word is used in a forensic sense as de- claring the legal status of a person conforming to law. The idea of straightness, rigid adherence to God’s law, whether religious, civil or ceremonial, cannot be excluded from the definition of the word “lawful.” Neither AV nor ARV is consistent in its tr of the Heb and Gr words tr? “lawful.”’ Ofttimes the words “just?? and “Tighteous” are used. To arrive at the full and proper meaning of “lawful,” therefore, it is necessary that we study the passages containing these synonymous terms. The written Law of God is the recognized standard by which things, actions and persons are to be judged as being lawful or unlawful. Wiii1aM Evans LAWGIVER, lé’giv-ér (PPA, mhokek; vopobé- rns, nomothétés): There are two words, one Heb and one Gr, which are tr4 “lawgiver.’”’? The former occurs 7 t in the OT, and in AV in every case except Jgs 6 14 is thns tr’. In RV it bears the tr “law- giver” but twice (Dt 33 21; Isa 83 22), though in the other passages (Gen 49 10; Nu 21 18; Jgs 5 14; Ps 60 7; 108 8) this meaning is retained in the margin. The Gr word occurs in the NT but once (Jas 4 12), where it has a meaning that is almost the exact equivalent of the Heb word in Isa 33 22. In both passages God is declared to be the “lawgiver,’’ and in the NT passage is so called because He has the power to rule and judge, to save and destroy. Man is denied the authority to judge hecause he is not the lawgiver. God is the lawgiver, and therefore possesses the right to pronounce judgment (cf Isa, supra). The word, however, implies more than mere legislative func- tion; it also connotes the idea of ruling. Isaiah makes this very plain, since he adds to the statement that God is our judge and lawgiver the further declaration that He is also king. This meaning adheres in the very history of the word. Itis based upon the monarchical conception in which the legis- lative, judicial and administrative functions are all vested in one person. In Jas the two terms “‘law- giver and judge” express the idea of God’s absolute sovereignty. The vb. nomothetein occurs in He 7 11; 8 6, but it does not extend beyond the meaning “to enact laws.” The Heb word is restricted to poetic passages, and except in Isa 33 22 is applied to a tribal or kingly ruler. Moses is preéminently the lawgiver in Jewish and Christian circles, but it should be noted that in the Scriptures of neither is he given this title. The primary meaning of the vb. from which m*hokék is derived is “to cut,” “to carve,” and a derived meaning is “to ordain.’”” The mean- ing of the part. m*hdkek is based upon this last. It means (1) the symbol which expresses the law- maker’s authority, that is, the commander’s staff; and (2) the person who possesses the authority (Dt 33 21). It has the first of these meanings in Nu 21 18; Ps 60 7; 108 8, and probably in Gen 49 10, though here it may have the second meaning. The parallelism, however, seems to require an imper- sonal object to correspond to scepter, and so the reading of the text (RV) is to be preferred to that of the margin (Skinner, ad loc.). In Dt 33 21; Jgs 6 14; Isa 33 22, it means the person who wielded the symbol of authority, that is the pre- scriber of laws. In a primitive community this would be a military commander. In Gen 49 10 the “ruler’s staff” is the symbol of kingly authority (Driver), and this verse consequently implies the supremacy of Judah which came in with the Davidic kingdom. This word contains no reference to the Messiah. In Nu 21 18 there is an allusion to the custom of formally and symbolically opening fountains under the superintendence and at the instruction of the leader of the tribe. Such a custom seems to have been in vogue till compara- 1859 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Law, Judicial Lay, Laying tively modern times. Gray cites Budde in the New World for March, 1895, and Muir’s Mohamet and Islam, 348f. In Jgs 5 14 the word means ‘“‘mili- tary commander,” as the context shows. This is the meaning also in Dt 33 21, where it is affirmed that Gad obtained a position worthy of its warlike character. Tg, Vulg, Pesh, and some moderns have seen here a reference to the grave of Moses, but Nebo was in Reuben and not in Gad. W. C. Morro _ LAWLESS, lé’les (Gvopos, dnomos): While occur- ring but once in AV (1 Tim 1 9), is tr4 in various ways, e.g. “without law’ (1 Cor 9 21); “unlawful” (2 Pet 28 AV); “awless” (1 Tim 1 9); ‘‘trans- gressor’”’ (Mk 16 28; Lk 22 87); ‘wicked’ (Acts 2 23 AV; 2 Thess 2 8 AV). When Paul claims to be “without law,” he has reference to those things in the ceremonial law which might well be passed over, and not to the moral law. Paul was by no means an antinomian. Those are ‘lawless’? who break the law of the Decalogue; hence those who disobey the commandment, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother,” are lawless ( Tim 19). The civil law is also the law of God. Those breaking it are lawless, hence called ‘‘transgressors.’? Those who are unjust in their dealings are also “lawless’’; for this reason the hands of Pilate and those who with him unjustly condemned Jesus are called “wicked [unlawful] hands’ (Acts 2 23 AV). The most not- able example of lawlessness is the Antichrist, that ‘twicked [lawless] one’’ (2 Thess 2 8). Wituiam Evans LAWYER, lé’yér (vopixés, nomikés, “according or pertaining to law,”’ i.e. legal; as noun, “an expert in law,” “about the law,” “lawyer” [Mt 22 35; Lk 7 30; 10 25; 11 45.46.52; 14 3; Tit 3 13)): The work of the ‘lawyers,’ frequently spoken of as “‘scribes,”’ also known as ‘‘doctors’” of the law (Lk 2 46 m), was first of all that of jurists. Their business was threefold: (1) to study and interpret the law; (2) to instruct the Heb youth in the law; (3) to decide questions of the law. The first two they did as scholars and teachers, the last as ad- visers in some court. By virtue of the first-named function, they gradually developed a large amount of common law, for no code can go into such detail as to eliminate the necessity of subsequent legis- lation, and this usually, to a great extent, takes the form of judicial decisions founded on the code rather than of separate enactment. And so it was among the Hebrews. The provisions of their code were for the most part quite general, thus affording much scope for casuistic interpretation. As a result of the industry with which this line of legal development had been pursued during the centuries immediately preceding our era, the Heb law had become a very complicated science; and since it was forbidden to record these judicial decisions, a protracted study was necessary in order to commit them to memory. But since the law must have universal application, the views of the individual scribe could not be taken as a standard; hence the several disciples of the law must frequently meet for discussion, and the opin- ion of the majority then prevailed. To these meet- ings the youth interested in the study would be invited, that. they might memorize the formulas agreed upon and might clear up the points upon which they were uncertain by asking questions of the recognized doctors (Lk 2 46). Such centers of legal lore, of course, would seldom be found in rural communities; the authorities would natu- rally gather in large centers of populullons esp.—until 70 AD—in Jerus. While the deliverances of these law schools were purely theoretical, yet they stood in close relation to the practical. Whenever doubt arose regard- ing the application of the-law to a particular case, the question se referred to the Neateat awa or! by him to the nearest company of lawyers, perhaps to the Sanhe- driu; and the resultant decision was henceforth author- ity. Thus the lawyers became law makers, and after the destruction of Jerus, which brought au end to the exist- ence of the Sanhedrin, the rabbinical doctors were recog- nized as the absolute authority in such matters. Fre- uently a single lawyer of great rank, as for instance illel or Gamaliel I, might pronounce dicta of unques- tioned recognition with as much authority as a supreme court in our day, though sometimes his opinions were received and corrected by the legal tribunal, especially the Sanhedrin. Of course, frequently, these tribunals were under the sway of such a man's influence, so that what he said upon his own authority would be ratified in the assembly of the doctors. 7 The second function of the lawyers was that of teachers. The renowned rabbis always sought to gather a company of pupils about them whose business it was to repeat the teachers’ law formulas until they had ‘passed into their flesh and blood.” For the purposes of such instruction as well as for the discussion of the teachers and the students, there were special schoolhouses, which are often mentioned in connection with the synagogues as places of special merit and privilege. In Jerus, these law schools were conducted in the temple— probably in the hall dedicated to this special pur- pose (Mt 21 23; 26 55; Mk 14 49; Lk 2 46; 20 1; 2137; Jn 18 20). The students during the lectures sat on the floor, the teacher on a raised platform, hence the expression “‘sitting at the feet of” (Acts 22 3; Lk 2 46). Finally, the lawyers were called upon to decide cases in court or to act as advisers of the court. Before the destruction of Jerus, technical knowledge of the law was not a con- dition of eligibility to the office of judge. Anyone who could command the confidence of his fellow- citizens might be elected to the position, and many of the rural courts undoubtedly were conducted, as among us, by men of sterling quality but of limited knowledge. Naturally such men would avail themselves of the legal advice of any ‘“‘doctor” who might be within reach, esp. inasmuch as the latter was obliged to give his services gratuitously. And in the more dignified courts of large munici- palities, it was a standing custom to have a com- pany of scholars present to discuss and decide any new law points that might arise. Of course, fre- quently, these men were elected to the office of judge, so that practically the entire system of jurisprudence was in their hands. = s Frank E. Hirsca LAY, 14, LAYING, 14’ing: (1) B'W, sim, “to put,” and the Gr equivalent, rlOnp., ttthémi, are very frequently tr by ‘to lay.””. RV very often changes the AV rendering of stm, but never that of t&thémi: 1S 16 2, “how he set himself against him in the way’ (AV “he laid wait for him’); 2 K 11 16, “So they made way for her’ (AV “And they laid hands on her’); cf 2 Ch 23 15; Job 24 12, “God regardeth not the folly” (AV “God layeth not folly”); Job 34 23, ‘For he needeth not further to consider a man’ (AV “For he will not lay upon man more”); Isa 28 17, “And I will make justice the line” (AV “Judgment also will I lay to the line’); Job 17 3, “Give now a pledge” (AV “Lay down now”). (2) 7D3, nathan, lit. “to give,” is very commonly tr by ‘‘to lay.” RV changes the tr of AV in Ezk 4 5, “I have appointed”; Ezk 33 28f, “I will make the land a desolation” (AV “I will lay the land most desolate”). (3) “To lay” of AV is frequently rendered differently in RV; Isa 64 11, “I will set thy stones” (AV “lay thy stones’); Dt 29 22, “‘the sicknesses wherewith Jeh hath made it sick” (AV “sicknesses which the Lord hath laid upon’’). For other differences of RV and AV cf Dt 218; 2K 9 25m; 2K 12 11; Ezr 8 31; Ps 1045m; Isa 53 6; Jer 6 26; Mk 78; Lk 19 44; Jas 1 21; 1 Pet 2 1. In most of these passages the change of RV is due to the peculiar use of the word ‘to lay” Lazarus Leah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1860 in AV. The following expressions are found very frequently: “to lay hands on,’’ “‘to lay wait,’’ “‘to lay up,” “to lay aside,” “to lay upon,” “‘to lay down,’’ etc. : . “Laying of wait,’ AV, is rendered “lying in wait” in Nu 85 20ff; Acts 9 24 reads: ‘But their plot became known” (AV “But their laying await was known’’), The “laying on of hands” is.a very general expression. See Hanps, LayIne on oF. A. L. Brestica LAZARUS, f{az’a-rus (Adtapos, Ldzaros, an ab- ridged form of the Heb name Eleazar, with a Gr termination): Means ‘‘God has helped.” In LXX and Jos are found the forms ’Hdeatdap, Hleazdr, and ’Eadedtapos, Eledzaros. The name was common among the Jews, and is given to two men in the NT who have nothing to do with each other. The home of the Lazarus mentioned in Jn 11 1 was Bethany. He was the brother of Martha and Mary (Jn 11 1.2; see also Lk 10 38— 1. Lazarus 41). All three were esp. beloved by of Bethany Jesus (Jn 11 5), and at their home He more than once, and probably often, was entertained (Lk 10 38-41; Jn 11). Asin- timated by the number of condoling friends from Traditional Tomb of Lazarus. the city, and perhaps from the costly ointment used by Mary, the family was probably well-to- do. In the absence of Jesus, L. was taken sick, died, and was buried, but, after having lain in the ave four days, was brought back to life by the Saviour (Jn 11 3.14.17.43.44). As a result many Jews believed on Jesus, but others went and told the Pharisees, and a council was therefore called to hasten the decree of the Master’s death (Jn 11 45-53). Later, six days before the Passover, at a feast in some home in Bethany where Martha served, L. sat at table as one of the guests, when his sister Mary anointed the feet of Jesus (Jn 12 1-3). Many of the common people came thither, not only to see Jesus, but also the risen L., belicved in Jesus, and were enthusiastic in witnessing for Him during the triumphal entry, and attracted others from the city to meet Him (Jn 12 9.11.17.18). For that reason the priests plotted to murder L. (Jn 12 10). This is all that we really know about the man, for whether the Jews accomplished his death we are not informed, but it seems probable that, satiated with the death of Jesus, they left L. unmolested. Nothing is told of his experiences between death and resurrection (ef Tennyson, ‘In Memoriam,”’ xxxi), of his emotions upon coming out of the tomb, of his subsequent life (cf Browning, “A Letter to Karshish”’), and not a word of revelation does he give as to the other world. His resurrection has been a favorite subject for various forms of Chris- tian art, and according to an old tradition of Epi- phanius he was 30 years old when he was raised from the dead, and lived 30 years thereafter. As might be expected this miracle has been vigorously assailed hy all schools of hostile critics. Ingenuity has been exhausted in inventing ohjcctions to it. But all told, they really amount only to three. (1) The silence of the other Gospels.—There is here, no douht, some difficulty. But the desire of the early Christians, as many scholars think, to screen the family from danger may have kept the story from hecoming current in the oral tradition whence the Synoptics drew their materials, though Matthew was probably an eye- witness. But, in aay case, the Synoptics do not pretend to give all the deeds of Jesus, and in the repo.t by them we have few save those which were wrought in Galilee. Each of them has omitted elements of highest interest which others have preserved. Thus Lk alone gives us the raising of the widow's son at Nain. John, knowing that the others had omitted this, tells us what he had himself witnessed, since all danger to the family had long ago passed away, as it was of espccial intcrost to his story, and he had recorded no other case of resur- rection. At any rate, the Gospel writers do not seem to regard @ resurrection from the dead by the power of Jesus aS sO much more stupendous than other miracles, as they seem to modern scholars and to the Jews, and, moreover, the Synoptics do unconsciously attest this miracle by descrihing a sudden outburst of popular excitement in favor of Jesus which can be accounted for only by some extraordinary event. (2) The stupendous character of the miracle.—But to @ philosophical heliever in miracles this is no ohstacle at all, for to omnipotence there are no such things as hig miracles or little ones. Of course, Martha's statement as to the decomposition of the body was only her opinion of the peopenl ty. in the case, and He, who sees the end from the beginning and who had intended to raise L., might well in His providence haye watched over the body that it should not see corruption. When all is said, “He who has created the organic cell within inorganic matter is not incapable of reéstablishing life within the inanimate substance.” (3) Its non-use as an accusation against Jesus.—The objection that Jn_11 47-53 is inconsistent with the fact that in accusing Jesus before Pilate no mention is made of this miracle by the enemies of Jesus has little weight. Who would expect them to make such a self-convicting acknowledgment? The dismay of the priests at the miracle and their silence about it are perfectly compatible and natural. No one of the attempted explanations which deny the reality of the miracle can offer even a show of probability. That L. was just recovering from a trance when Jesus arrived; that it was an imposture arranged by the family and sanctioned by Jesus in order to overwhelm His enemies; that it was a fiction or parable tr4 into a fact and made up largely of synoptic materials, an alle- gorical illustration of the words, ‘I am the resurrection, and the life,’ a myth—such explanations require more faith than to believe the fables of the Talm. ‘They well illustrate the credulity of unbelief. The narrative holds together with perfect consistency, is distinguished by vivacity and dramatic movement, the people who take part in it are intensely real and natural, and the picture of the sisters perfectly agrees with the sketch of them in No morhid curiosity of the reader is satisfied. Invented stories are not like this. Even a Renan de- clares that it is a necessary link in the story of the final Catastrophe. The purpose of the miracle seems to have been: (1) to show Himself as Lord of life and death just before He should be Himself condemned to die; (2) to strengthen the faith of His disciples; (3) to convert many Jews; (4) to cause the priests to hasten their movements so as to be ready when His hour had come (Plummer, HDB, III, 87). In the parable in Lk 16 19-31, L. is pictured as in abject poverty in this world, but highly rewarded and honored in the next. It is the 2. The only instance of a proper name used Beggar in a parable by Jesus. Some think that he was a well-known mendicant in Jerus, and have even attempted to define his 1861 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lazarus Leah disease. But this is no doubt simple invention, and, since “in Christ’s kingdom of truth names indicate realities,” this was probably given because of its significance, suggesting the beggar’s faith in God and patient dependence upon Him. It was this faith and not his poverty which at last brought him into Abraham’s bosom. Not one word does L. speak in the parable, and this may also be sug- gestive of patient submission. He does not murmur at his hard lot, nor rail at the rich man, nor after death triumph over him. The parable is related to that of the Rich Fool (Lk 12 16-21). This latter draws the veil over the worldling at death; the other lifts it. It is also a counterpart of that of the Unjust Steward (Lk 16 1-13), which shows how wealth may wisely be used to our advantage, while this parable shows what calamities result from failing to make such wise use of riches. The great lesson is that our condition in Hades depends upon our conduct here, and that this may produce a complete reversal of fortune and of popular judg- ments. Thus L. represents the pious indigent who stood at the opposite extreme from the proud, cove- tous, and luxury-loving Pharisee. The parable made a deep impression on the mind of the church, so that the term “lazar,” no longer a proper name, has passed into many languages, as in lazar house, lazaretto, also lazzarone, applied to the mendicants of Italian towns. There was even an order, half-military, half-monastic, called the Knights of St. Lazarus, whose special duty it was to minister to lepers. The rich man is often styled Dives, which is not strictly a proper name, but a Lat adj. meaning “vich,’? which occurs in this passage in the Vulg. But in Eng. lit., as early as Chaucer, as seen in the ‘“Sompnoure’s Tale” and in “Piers Plowman,” it appears in popular use as the name of the Rich Man in this parable. In later theological lit. it has become almost universally current. The name Nineuis given him by Euthymius never came into general use, though the Sahidic version has the addition, ‘‘whose name was Ninue.” His sin was not in being rich, for Abraham was among the wealthiest of his day, but in bis worldly unbelief in the spiritual and eternal, revealing itself in ostenta- tious luxury and hard-hearted contempt of the poor. Says Augustine, ‘‘Seems he [Jesus] not to have been reading from that, book where he found the name of the poor man written, but found not the name of the rich, for that book is the book of life?” G. H. TREVER LEACH, léch. See Horseieacn. LEAD, led (FID, ‘dphereth): Lead was one of the first metals to be used in the free state, prob- ably because it was so easily obtained from its ores. Lead was found anciently in Egypt and the Sina- itic peninsula. There is no lead found in Pal proper, but in Northern Syria and Asia Minor it occurs in considerable quantities, usually associated with silver. These sources no doubt furnished an im~- ortant supply in Bible times. It was also brought y the Phoenicians from Spain (Tarshish) (Ezk 27 12) and the British Isles. : Lead waa used, as it still is, all along the Mediter- ranean shores for sinkers. Pieces of Egyp fish~ nets probably dating from 1200 BC are now pre- served in the British Museum, with their lead sink- ers still attached. Since lead was the heaviest metal known to the ancients, gold excepted, it was generally used for fish-lines and sounding lines (cf Acts 27 28), esp. in the dense waters of the Medi- terranean. Moses mentioned the sinking qualities of lead in the sea in his simile of the sinking of Pharach’s hosts “as lead in the mighty waters” (Ex 15 10). : oe Lead was used by the ancients for binding stones together. In most of the ancient ruins of Syria the Arabs have dug holes at the scams between stones in walls and columns in order to remove the iron, bronze, or lead thus used. In the museum of the Syrian Protestant College, Beirit, there are several specimens of cast-lead sarcophagi dating from the time of Christ. In Job 19 23.24, lead is mentioned as used in the engraving of permanent records. Two inferences might be drawn from this passage: either that the letters were cut with a chisel (pen) and then the cutting was filled with lead, or that sheets of lead were used as tablets on which to grave the record with an iron tool. Lead is frequently referred to along with iron, brass, silver and tin (Nu 31 22; Ezk 22 18.20; 27 12). The use of lead for plumblines is implied in Am 7 7.8; Zec 4 10; as a weight in Zec 5 7.8. That OT writers under- stood the use of lead for purifying gold is shown by Jer 6 29 and Ezk 22 18-22 (cf Mal 3 2.3). See Metats; REFINER. James A. Patou LEAF, lef, LEAVES, lévz: Used in three different senses, with reference: (1) To trees (m>7 , ‘Gleh, “a coming up”), Gen 3 7; 8 11; Lev 26 36 (O79, tereph); Ezk 17 9; @éddov, phillon. Figuratively (a) of spiritual blessings (Ezk 47 12; cf Rev 22 2) and prosperity (Ps 1 3); (6) of moral decay (Isa 64 6), and (c) of a formal, empty profession (Mt 21:19). (2) Toa book (not , deleth), Jer 36 23 (m “eolumns”; see ver 2); asthe parchment was gradu- ally unfolded the successive columns could be read. (8) To doors (92%, cala‘, “side,” yp, hela’, “a screen,” “hanging’’), 1 K 6 34. The door of the Holy Place consisted of two halves, but each half had two leaves (cf Ezk 41 24). M. O. Evans LEAGUE, lég. See Conreppracy. LEAH, lé’a (MN, leah; Acta, Leia, “weary,” “dull” [?], ‘wild cow’’): Rachel’s sister, and the elder daughter of Laban (Gen 29 16). We are told that her eyes were “tender” (M121, rakkdth). Gesenius renders it ‘weak,’ LXX do@evets, asthe- nets; accordingly, she was weak-eyed, but by no means “‘blear-eyed” (cf Vulg). Her eyes were lacking that luster which always and everywhere is looked upon as a conspicuous part of female beauty. Jos (Ant, I, xix, 7) says of her, Ti» dpc» od« ederpery, tén épsin ouk euprepé, which may safely be ren- dered, ‘‘she was of no comely countenance.” L. became the wife of Jacob by a ruse on the part of her father, taking advantage of the oriental cus- tom of heavily veiling the prospective bride. When taken to task by his irate son-in-law, Laban excused himself by stating it was against the rule of the place ‘‘to give the younger before the first-born” (Gen 29 21-26). Although Rachel was plainly preferred by Jacob to L., still the latter bore him six sons: Reuben, Simeon, Levi, Judah (Gen 29 31 ff), Issachar, Zebulun, and a daughter, Dinah (Gen 80 17-21}. Up to this time Rachel had not been blessed with children of her own. Thus the lesson is brought home to us that Jeh has a special and kindly regard for the lowly and despised, pro- vided they learn, through their troubles and afflic- tions, to look to Him for help and success. It seems that homely L. was a person of deep-rooted piety and therefore better suited to become instrumental in carrying out the plans of Jeh than her handsome, but worldly-minded, sister Rachel. When Jacob decided to return to the “land of his fathers,’ both of his wives were ready to accom- pany him (Gen 31 4.14). Before they reached the end of their journey their courage was sorely Leannoth Lebanon THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1862 tried at the time of the meeting between Jacob and his brother Esau. Although L. was placed between the handmaids in the front, and Rachel with her son Joseph in the rear, she still cannot have derived much comfort from her position. We may _well imagine her feeling of relief when she saw Esau and his 400 men returning to Seir (Gen 33 2.16). According to Gen 49 31, L. was buried at Mach- pelah. We cannot know for a certainty that she died before Jacob’s going down to Egypt, though it is very likely. If she went down with her hus- band and died in Egypt, he had her body sent to the family burying-place. Ruth 4 11 discloses the fact that her memory was not forgotten by future generatious. When Boaz took Ruth for a wife the witnesses exclaimed, ‘“‘Jeh make the woman that is come iuto thy house like Rachel and like Leah, which two did build the house of Israel.” Witi1am Baur LEANNOTH, lé-an’oth (Ps 88, title). See Psabns. LEAPING, lép'ing. See Games. LEASING, 1é2’ing (AT , kazabh, ‘‘to devise,’ “to fabricate,” hence “to lie’; occurs but twice in AV [Ps 4 2, RV “falsehood”; 5 6, RV ‘‘lies’’]; the Heb word is tr¢ “‘liars” [Ps 116 11]; “lie” or deceive [Job 6 28]): The idea of treachery, lying, and de- ceit, lies at the root of this word. Joab’s conduct is a good illustration of the meaning (2 8 3 27; 20. 8-10). In Ps 6 6 David is referring to the cunning, treachery, and falsehood of his adver- saries; ef 2S 13 28; 15 7-9. Doubtless David had a special person in mind as being guilty of ‘Jeasing,”” probably Ahithophel. Wiitutiam Evans LEATHER, leth’ér. See Sxry; Grrpip; Tan- NER. LEAVEN, lev’n (ANW, sar, PAM, hamec; ton, zimé; Lat fermentum): The nomadic ancestors of the Hebrews, like the Bedouin of today, probably made their bread without leaven; but leaven came to play a great part in their bread-making, their law and ritual, and their religious teaching (see Ex 12 15.19; 13 7; Lev 2 11; Dt 16 4; Mét 13 33; 16 6-12; Mk 8 15f; Lk 12 1; 13 21). (1) In bread-making.—The form of leaven used in bread-making and the method of using it were simple and definite. The ‘‘leaven” consisted always, so far as the evidence goes, of a piece of fermented dough kept over from a former baking. There is no trace of the use of other sorts of leaven, such as the lees of wine or those mentioned by Pliny (NH, xviii.26). Thelump of dough thus preserved was either dissolved in water in the kueadiug-trough before the flour was added, or was “hid” in the flour (AV “meal’’) and kneaded along with it, as was the case mentioned in the parable (Mit 13 33). The bread thus made was known as “leavened,” as dis- tinguished from ‘‘unleavened” bread (Ex 12 15, ete). See Brean. (2) In law and ritual.—The ritual prohibition of loaven during ‘‘the feast of unleavened bread” iu- cluding the Passover (Ex 23 15, etc) is a matter juviting restudy. For the historical explanation given in the Scriptures, see esp. Ex 12 34-39; 13 3ff; Dt 16 8. The antiquity of the prohibi- tion is witnessed by its occurrence in the earliest legislation (Ex 23 18; 34 25). A natural reason for the prohibition, like that of the similar exclusion of honey, is sought on the ground that fermentation implied a process of corruption. Plutarch voices this ancient view of the matter when he speaks of it as “itself the offspring of corruption, and corrupt- ing the mass of dough with which it is mixed.” Fermentatum is used in Persius (Sat., i.24) for “corruption.” For this reason doubtless it was excluded also from the offerings placed upon the altar of Jeh, cakes made from flour without leaven, and these only, being allowed. The regulation name for these “‘unleavened cakes’? was magcath (Lev 10 12). Two exceptions to this rule should be noted (Lev 7 13; cf Am 4 5): “leavened bread” was an accompaniment of the thank offering as leavened loaves were used also in the wave offering of Lev 23 17. Rabbinical writers regularly use leaven as a symbol of evil (Lightfoot). ; (3) In teaching—The figurative uses of leaven in the NT, no less than with the rabbins, reflect the ancient view of it as “corrupt and corrupting,” in parts at least, e.g. Mt 16 6 ||, and esp. the prover- bial saying twice quoted by Paul, “A little leaven leaveneth the whole lump” (1 Cor 6 6f; Gal 5 9). But as Jesus used it in Mt 13 33, “The king- dom of heaven is like unto leaven,’’ it is clearly the hidden, silent, mysterious, but all-pervading and transforming action of the leaven in the measures of flour that is the point of the comparison. Lirzerarure.—Nowack, Heb Arch., II, 145f; Talm, Berakhoth, 1%a; Lightfoot, Hor. Heb.on Mt 16 6. Gro. B. Eacer LEBANA, lé-ba’na, Ieb’a-na (N229, [*bhana’), or LEBANAH (7329, lebhanah, “white”’): Head of a family of returning exiles (Ezr 2 45; Neh 7 48; ef 1 Esd 5 29). LEBANON, leb’a-non (j1223, lbhanon; LXX AlBavos, Libanos; Vulg Libanus): Derived from the root 72>, labhen, “to be white,” probably from the snow which covers its summits the greater part of the year. ‘White mountains” are found in almost every couutry. The light color of the upper limestone 1. Name Anti-Lebanon: Souk-W 4dy-Barrada. : may, however, form a sufficient reason for the name. In prose the article is usually connected with the name. In poetry it is more often without. the article. In the LXX, however, the article is gen- erally present both in prose and poetry. The Lebanon range proper borders the east coast of the Mediterranean, for a distance of 100 miles, running N.N.E and 8.8.W. 2. General from the mouth of the Litany river, Description the classic Leontes (which enters the sea a little N. of Tyre), to the mouth of the Eleuthurus (Nahr el-Kebir), a few miles N. of Tripolis. This river comes through a depression between Lebanon and the Nuseiriyeh mountains, known as ‘‘the entrance to Hamath,” and connects with a caravan route to the Euphrates through Palmyra. For a considerable distance N. of the Litény, the mountain summits average from 4,000 to 6,000 ft. in height, and the range is more or less 1863 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leannoth Lebanon dissected by short streams which enter the Medi- terranean. Most prominent of these is the Nahr ez-Zaherany, which, after running 25 or 30 miles in a southerly direction through the center of the range, like the Litdny, turns abruptly W. opposite Mt. Hermon, reaching the sea between Tyre and Sidon. In roughly parallel courses Nahr el-'Awleh and Nahr Damur descend to the sea between Sidon and Beyrout, and Nahr Beyrout just N. of the city. Throughout this district the mountain recesses are more or less wooded. Opposite Beyrout the range rises in Jebel Sannin to an elevation of 8,560 ft. Thirty miles farther N.E. the summit is reached in Jebel Mukhmai, at an elevation of 10,225 ft., with several others of nearly the same height. An amphitheater here opens to the W., in which is sheltered the most frequented cedar grove, and from which emerges the Nahr Kadtsha (‘sacred stream’) which enters the Mediterranean at Tripolis. Snow is found upon these summits throughout the year (Jer 18 14), while formerly the level area between them furnished the snow fields from which a glacier descended several miles into the headwaters of the Kadisha, reaching a level of about 5,000 ft. The glacier deposited in this amphitheater a terminal moraine covering several sq. miles, which at its front, near Bsherreh, is 1,000 ft. in thickness. It is on this that the grove of cedars referred to is growing. The view from this summit reveals the geographi- cal features of the region in a most satisfactory manner. Toward the EH. lies Coele-Syria (the modern Buka), 7,000 ft. below the summit, bordered on the eastern side by the mountain wall of Anti- Lebanon, corresponding to the cliffs of Moab E. of the Jordan valley, opposite Judaea. This depression in fact is but a continuation of the great geological fault so conspicuous in the Jordan valley (see AraBaH). As one looks down into this valley, Ba*‘albek appears at the base of Anti-Lebanon, only 20 miles away. The valley is here about 10 miles wide, and forms the watershed between the Orontes and the Litany. To the N.E. the valley of the Orontes is soon obscured by intervening peaks, but to the S.W. the valley of the Litény closes up only where the glistering peak of Mt. Hermon pierces the sky, as the river turns abruptly toward the sea 40 miles distant. Toward the W., the blue waters of the Mediterranean, only 25 miles distant as the crow flies, show themselves at intervals through the gorges eut by the rapid streams which have fur- rowed the western flanks of the mountain (Cant 4 15); 3,500 ft. beneath is the amphitheater many sq. miles in area, filled with the terminal moraine from which the Kadisha river emerges, and on which the grove of cedars (cf 1 K 4 33; Ps 92 12; Hos 14 5) appears as a green spot in the center. On- ward to the W. the river gorge winds its way amid numerous picturesque village sites and terraced fields, every foot of which is cultivated by a frugal and industrious people. To the traveler who has made the diagonal journey from Beyrout to_the cedars, memory fills in innumerable details which are concealed from vision at any one time. He has crossed Nahr el-Kelb (‘Dog River’’), near its mouth, where he has seen Egyp and Assyr inscrip- tions dating from the time of Sennacherib’s inva- sion. Ascending this river, after passing numerous villages surrounded by mulberry and olive groves, vineyards, and fields of wheat, and pausing to study the ruins of a temple dating from Rom times and having crossed a natural bridge at Jisr el- Hagar with a span of 120 ft., rising 75 ft. above the stream, he arrives, at the end of the second day, at the ruins of the famous temple of Venus destroyed by the order of Constantine on account of the impurity of the rites celebrated in it. Here, too, is a famous gpring, typical of many others which gush forth on either side of the Lebanon range from beneath the thick deposits of limestone which everywhere crown its summit. The flow of water is enormous, and at certain seasons of the year is colored red with a mineral matter which the ancients regarded with mysterious reverence (see LB, III, 244). The lower part of the amphitheater is covered with verdure and a scanty growth of pine and walnut trees, but the upper part merges in the barren cliffs which lie above the snow line. Onward, alternately through upturned limestone strata, left by erosion in fantastic forms, and through barren areas of red sandstone, where the cedars of Lebanon would flourish if protected from the depredations of man and his domestic animals, he crosses by turns at higher and higher levels the headwaters of the Ibrahim, Fedar, Jozeh, Byblus and the Botrys rivers, and at length reaches, on the fourth day, the Ka- disha, 5 miles below the cedars of Lebanon. Viewed from the Mediterranean the Lebanon range pre- sents a continuous undulating outline of light- colored limestone peaks, the whole rising so abruptly from the sea that through most of the distance there is barely room for a road along the shore, while in places even that is prevented by rocky promon- tories projecting boldly into the sea. The only harbors of importance are at Beyrout and Tripolis, and these are only partially protected, being open to the N.W. The eastern face of the range falling down into Coele-Syria is very abrupt, with no foot- hills and but one or two important valleys. Geologically considered, the Lebanon consists of three conformable strata of rock thrown up in an anticline with its steepest face to the 3. Geology E. The lowest of these are several thousand ft. thick, consisting of hard limestone containing few fossils, the most character- istic of which is Cidaris glandaria, from which the formation has been named Glandarian limestone. In its foldings this has been elevated in places to a height of 5,000 ft. Through erosion it is exposed in numerous places, where it presents picturesque castellated columns, whose bluish-gray sides are beautifully fluted by atmospheric agencies. The second formation consists of several hundred feet of red-colored sandstone alternating with soft limestone and clay deposits, occasionally contain- ing a poor quality of bituminous coal, with pyrites and efflorescent salts. It is this that occasionally colors the water of the spring at Adonis. The char- acteristic fossil is Trigonia syriaca. Altogether this formation attains a thickness of 1,000 ft., and it is on its exposed surfaces that the most of the Lebanon pines are found. It contains also many signs of volcanic action. The third formation con- sists of hippurite limestone, a eretaceous formation, in some places almost wholly composed of fragments of the fossils from which it derives its name. This formation appears on all the highest summits, where in most cases it is nearly horizontal, and in places attains a thickness of 5,000 ft. Between the sum- mits of the range and the foothills this formation has been almost wholly carried away by erosion, thus exposing the underlying formations. Cre- taceous strata of still later age are found at low levels near the sea, which in places are covered by small deposits of Tertiary limestone, and by a porous sandstone of the Pleistocene age. The scenery of the western slopes of Lebanon is most varied, magnificent, and beautiful, and well calculated, as indeed it did, to impress 4. Scenery the imagination of the Heb pocts. Originally it was heavily covered with forests of pine, oak and cedar; but these have for the most part long since disappeared, except in the valley of Nahr Ibrahim, which is still thickly wooded with pine, oak and plane trees. Of the Lebaoth Lend, Loan THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1864 cedars there remain, besides the grove at the head of the Kadisha, only two or three, and they are of less importance. Every available spot on the western flanks of the Lebanon is cultivated, being sown with wheat or planted with the vine, the olive, the mulberry and the walnut. Irrigation is ex- tensively practised. When we let the eye range from the snowy summits of the mountain over all that lies between them and the orange groves of Sidon on the seashore, we understand why the Arabs say that “Lebanon bears winter on ita head, spring on its shoulders, autumn in its lap, while summer lies at its feet.’ In the more desolate places jackals, hyenas, wolves, and panthers are still found (ef 2 K 14 9). The original inhabitants of Lebanon were Hivites and Gebalites (Jgs 3 3; Josh 13 5.6). The whole mountain range was assigned to the 5. History Israelites, but was never conquered by them. It seemed generally to have been subject to the Phoenicians. At present it is occupied by various sects of Christians and Mo- hammedans, of whom the Maronites, Druzes and Orthodox Greeks are most active and prominent. Since 1860 the region has been under the protection of European powers with a Christian governor. No exact figures are available, but the population at present numbers probably about 275,000. Ruins of ancient temples are numerous through- out Lebanon. Bacon estimates that within a radius of 20 miles of Ba‘albek there are 15 ruined sun-temples, the grandeur and beauty of which would have made them famous but for the surpass- ing splendor of Ba‘albek. Anti-Libanus (Jth 17; Josh 18 5; Cant 7 4) is an extension northward of the great mountain system facing on the E, the great 6, Anti- geological fault most conspicuous in Lebanon __ the valley of the Jordan (sce Jorpan, VALLEY OF), extending from the Gulf of Akabah to Antioch on the Orontes River. The system begins at the Barada River just N. of Mt. Hermon, and, running parallel to Mt. Lebanon for 65 miles, terminates at Hums, the ‘entering in of Hamath.” The highest points of the range reach an elevation of over 8,000 ft. Eastward the range merges into the plateau of the great Syrian desert. South of Ba‘albek the Yahfufah, a stream of con- siderable importance, empties into the Litany, while the Barada (the “Abana” of Scripture), rising in the same plateau, flows eastward to Damascus, its volume being greatly increased by fountains coming in from the base of the dissected plateau. Lirerature.—The geographical and geological de- scriptions are largely obtained by the writer from an extended excursion through the region in the company of Professor Day of the Protestant College at Beyrout, whose knowledge of the region is most intimate and comprehensive. For more detailed information see Robinson, BRP?, II, 435 ff, 493; G. A. Smith, HGHL, 45 ff; Burton and Drake, Unexplored Syria; Benjamin W. Bacon, and G. F. Wright in Records of the Past, 1906, V, 67-83, 195-204; Baedeker-Socin, Pal. : Grorce Freprrick Wricut LEBAOTH, 1éba’oth, -oth (MAND>, lebha’ath): An unidentified city in the S. of the territory of Judah (Josh 15 32). It is the same as Beth- lebaoth of Josh 19 6, which, by a clerical error appears in 1 Ch 4 31 as “‘Beth-biri.” LEBBAEUS, le-bé’us (AcBBatos, Lebbaios): Men- tioned in Mt 10 3 AV as ‘“Lebbacus, whose sur- name was Thaddaeus” (RV omits); one of the twelve apostles. See THaDDAEUS. LEBONAH, 1é-bd’na (M3539, i’bhonah): A place on the great north road between Shiloh and Shechem (Jgs 21.19). It is represented by the modern Khén el-Lubbaén, about 3 miles W.N.W. of Seilan (“Shiloh”), on the way to Nablas. It is a wretched village lying on the slope of a hill, with many rock tombs in the vicinity. LECAH, lé’ka (Ip2, lékhah): A descendant of Judah (1 Ch 4 21). LEDGE, lej (25%), shalabh): The word in the sense of side-projection is used in 1 K 7 28.29 in connection with the bases of Solomon’s MoLTEN Sra (q.v.); in vs 35.36, where AV uses the same word, RV has “stay” (yadh, lit. “hand’”’). RV likewise has “ledge”? (round) for AV “compass’’ (karkobh) in the description of the altar in Ex 27 5; 38 4 (see AvTaR), and ARV substitutes “ledge”’ for “settle” (‘dzarah) in Ezk 43 14.17.20; 46 19. See TEMPLE. ‘ LEEKS, léks (WEN, hacir; Ta wpdca, id prdsa): This word, elsewhere tr? ‘grass,’ is in Nu 11 5 rendered “leeks” in all the ancient VSS, on account at Leek (Allium porrum). of its association with garlic and onions; such a use of the word occurs in the Talm. The leek (Allium jorrum) is much grown today in Pal, while in ancient gypt this vegetable was renowned, LEES, léz. See Wine. LEFT, left (28'2W , sama’l, “to go to the left,” “to au, turn to the left,” whip, Srila”, smo’l, “the left hand,” “bay, sema’lt, “belonging to the left,” “situated on the left’; dpirrepds, aristerdés, and euphemistically evévupos, eudnumos, lit. “having a good name,“ “of good omen”): The words are chiefly used in orientation with or without the addi- tion of the word “hand.’ So Abraham says to Lot: “If thou wilt take the left hand [semé’l], then I will go to the right; or if thou take the right hand, then I will go to the left. [sdma’l]’ (Gen 13 9). Frequently in Heb idiom the right hand and the left are mentioned together in order to express the idea “everywhere,” ‘“‘anywhere,”’ “altogether” (Gen 24 49; Ex 14 22.29; Nu 22 26; Dt 2 27; 6 32; 1865 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lebaoth Lend, Loan 2 Cor 6 7). In the geographical sense the left 1s synonymous with north (Gen 14 15; Josh 19 27; Ezk 16 46; Acts 213). While the left hand is considered as weaker than the right (sce EFTHANDED), it is the hand which holds the bow (Ezk 39 3). The left hand is the side from which bad omens come, and therefore less lucky and less honored than the right hand (see Hann, note). : H. L. E. Lusrine LEFTHANDED, left’hand-ed (72.772 7X, "ter yadh-yamin; LXX dpdorepodéfios, ampho- terodéxios, i.e. “ambidextrous” ): The Heb presents a combination of words signifying lit. a man whose right hand is impeded or lame, who therefore uses the left hand instcad, or one who by habit prefors the use of the left hand, where others use the right. It is interesting to note that in both instances, where the expression occurs in the Scripture, it refers to individuals belonging to the tribe of Ben- Jamiu (which name itself signifies “a son of the right hand”!), The first is Ehud, son of Gera, who killed Eglon, king of Moab, and thereby delivered Israel from paying tribute to the Moabites (Jgs 3 15). The other instance is that of the 700 selected Benjamites, who, though lefthanded, “could sling stones at a hair-breadth, and not miss” (Jgs 20 16; ef 1 Ch 12 2), H. L. E. Luzrine LEG ({1] PW, shak, Aram. PW, shok; [2] 373, kara‘, dual D193, kera‘ayim; [3] 41, reghel; ex&os, skélos; AV tr® also 52W, shobhel, and TITY, g“adhah, with “leg,” but mistakenly): (1) The first Heb word (shdk) denotes the upper leg, and is therefore synonymous with TuiaH (q.v.). It ex- presses metaphorically the muscular strength, and the pride of the runner. ‘He taketh no pleasure in the legs of a man” (Ps 147 10). ‘His legs are as pillars of marble, set. upon sockets of fine gold” (Cant 6 15). If the legs have lost their strength asin the lame or the Beri-beri patient, they become a@ metaphor for anything useless, inefficient or dis- appointing: ‘The legs of the lame hang loose; a0 is a parable in the mouth of fools’”’ (Prov 26 7). The Aram, form is found in the description of the image of Nebuchadnezzar, ‘‘its legs of iron” (Dnl 2 33). (2) Kara‘, dual k*rd‘ayim, the “leg,” “respecting the legs,” mentioned as a portion of the paschal lamb (Ex 12 9), or, usually, in connection with the head and the inwards, as a sacrificial portion (Ex 29.17; Lev 19.13; Am 312). The word des- ignates also the legs of leaping insects of the orthop- terous family, locusts, etc, which were permitted as food to the Israelites (Lev 11 21). &) Reghel, lit. “foot”? (q.v.), found in this sense only once: “He [Goliath] had greaves of brass upon his legs”’ (1 8 17 6). Two passages of wrong tr in AV have been cor- rected by RV. The virgin daughter of Babylon is addressed: ‘‘Make bare the leg, uncover the thigh” (Isa 47 2), RV renders: ‘Strip off the train [shé- bhel], uncover the leg,” the idea being that the gentle maid, who has been brought up in affluence and luxury, will have to don the attire of a slave girl and do menial work, for which her former garments are unsuited. The other passage is in Isa 3 20, where AV reads: “the bonnets, and the ornaments of the legs,’ RV corrects: ‘the head- tires [c**adhah], and the ankle chains.” ; In the NT the word “‘leg’” is found only in con- nection with the breaking of the legs of the persons crucified with the Saviour (Jn 19 31.32.33). We know from Rom and Gr authors that this was done as a coup de grace to shorten the miseries of criminals condemned to die on the cross. The practice bore the technical name of cxedoxorla, skelokopia, Lat crurifragium. The vb. ckedoxoe’v, skelokopein (“to break the legs”), is found in the apocryphal Gospel of St. Peter (4 14), where it ia distinctly stated that the legs of Jesus were not broken, that His sufferings on the cross might be extended, while the two malefactors crucified with Him were merci- fully dispatched in this way. The Res Gad consisted of some strokes with a heavy club or mallet, which always materially hastened the death of the sufferer, and often caused it almost imme- diately. Edersheim, in LTJM, II, 613, suggests that the break- ing of legs was an additional punishment, and that it was always followed hy a coup de gréce, the perforatic or percussio sub alas, a stroke with sword or lance into the side. This, however, is not horne out by any classical information which is known to me, and is contradicted hy the statement of the evangelist that Jesus received the percussio, while the malefactors endured the cruri- fragium. f on this subject, esp. for parallels from classical authors, Sepp, Das Leben Jesu, VII, 441, and Keim, Jesus von Nazara (ET), VIL, gos, note 3. . L. E, Luerine LEGION, lé@’jun. See Army; Army, RoMAN. LEGISLATION, 1lej-is-la’shun, OF SANCTITY. See Astronomy, I, 5 LEHABIM, 1é-ha’bim (pram , thabhim): -Named in Gen 10 13; 1 Ch 1 11 as descendants of Miz- raim. They are probably to be identified with the Lusim (q.v.), and the one word may be a corruption of the other. LEHI, lé’hi. See RamMatu-LeHl. LEMUEL, lem’i-el ON, Iema’al, or S10, lem@’él): A king whose words, an “oracle [taught him by his mother],” are given in Prov 31 1-9; and possibly the succeeding acrostic poem (vs 10-31) is from the same source. Instead of translating the word after this name as “oracle,’? some propose to leave it as a proper name, translating “‘king of Massa,” and referring for his kingdom to Massa (Gen 25 14), oneof the sons of Ishmael, supposedly head of a tribe or sheikh of a country. It is to be noted, however, that the words of Agur in the pre- vious chapter are similarly called massa’, “‘oracle,’’ with not so clear a reason for referrmg it to a country. See for a suggested reason for retaining the meaning “oracle” in both places, Proverss, Boox or, II, 6. JoHN FRANKLIN GENUNG anes LOAN, lén: The tr of 7 Heb and 2 Gr vbs.: In the OT: mb, lawaéh, ‘‘to join,” ‘cause to join,”’ “lend” (Ex 22 25; Dt 28 12.44; Ps 37 26; Prov 19 ’ 17); TW}, naehah, “to bite,” “lend” (Dt 1. Lexical 24 11; Jer 15 10); TVW}, ndshah (same Usages root as last, though different vb. stem, Hiphil), ‘to cause to bite,"’ “lend on usury” (Dt 15 2; 24 10): yw. nashakh, ‘‘to bite,” “lend” “[cause to lend] on usury” (Dt 23 19.20); yn2> nathan, “to give’ (Lev 25 37, RV ‘to give”); DAY, ‘abhat (Hiphil), ‘to cause to borrow,” "to lend” (Dt 15 6.8); Sew, sha’ al (Hiphil), ‘to cause to ask,” ‘‘to lend” (Ex 12 36, RV “ask”; 181 27), In LXX 8aveite, danetzé, Savigw, dantzé, “to lend,” trs ayy, DAY, and wy) in above passages and in Neh § 4; Proy 22 7, and Isa 24 2; xxpdw, kichrdo, also tre MID and yy (Ps 1125; Prov 13 11); Sdvecov(-cov), ddneion(-ion), “loan,” occurs in Dt 15 8.10; 24 11; 4 Mace 2 8, In the NT ‘‘lend” tre two Gr vbs., daneizo, ‘‘to lend money” (LK 6 34.35, usually in commercial sense); nixpnut, kichrémi, ‘to lend [as @ friendly act]”’ (Lk 11 5). The subst. “loan,” TDN, she’elah, occurs only once in the OT (1 8 2 20 AV and ERV), not at all in the NT. (1) Lending on interest to the poor is prohibited Lentils Leper, Leprosy THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1866 —— in the code in Ex 22 25, (2) In the code in Dt 15 1-6; 28 19.20; 24 10.11; 28 12.44, borrow- ing and lending are taken for granted 2. History as existing in Israel, but the creditor of Lending is required to release his Heb brother in the Bible as debtor in the 7th year (either the and Apoc- cancellation of the loan [so in Jewish rypha lit. and early Christian scholars] or sus- pension of payment that year [so most modern scholars]), though he may exact payment from a foreigner. Israel may lend, and will be able to lend, hecause of Jeh’s blessing, to other nations, but must not borrow from them. A pledge, or security, must not be taken in person by the creditor from the house of the debtor, nor kept over night, if the debtor be poor. (3) The code in Lev 25 35-38 requires that the Israelite receive no interest from his poor brother, because of the goodness of Jeh to Israel. (4) Notwithstanding the prohibition of the early laws against lending on interest or usury, the same seems to have become common in Isracl before the exile (Isa 24 2; Jer 15 10), was prac- tised on the return, and was an evi! to be corrected by Nehemiah (Neh 5 7.10). (5) According to Ps 37 26; 1125; Prov 19 17, lending to the needy was regarded as a mark of the pious Hebrew, but no interest is to be charged. (6) According to Apoc (Wisd 15 16; Sir 8 12; 18 33; 20 15. 29; 4 Macc 2 8), borrowing is discouraged, and lending is exalted as a mark of the merciful man. (7) Jesus teaches that His followers should lend, even to enemies, to men from whom they have no reasonable hope of expecting anything in return, because thus to do is to be like the Most High (Lk 6 34.35). He did not discuss lending for commer- cial purposes, and so does not necessarily forbid it. Lirrreraturnr.—See Driver on Dt 15 1-6; Benzinger, Heb Archéol. (1894), 3501; Oehler, OT Theol., 150, 10; Plummer on Lk 6 34.35. Cuaries B. WILtiaMs LENTILS, len’tila (DWTD, ‘ddhadshim; axéds, phakés; Gen 25 34; 2 8 17 28; 23 11; Ezk 4 9; AV Lentiles): These are undoubtedly identical with the Arab. ‘adas, a small, reddish bean, the Lentil (Zroum lens). product of Ervum lens, a dwarf leguminous plant, half a foot high, which is extensively cultivated in Pal as a summer crop. The flour is highly nutri- tious, and the well-known food, Revalenia arabica, is simply one form, specially prepared; ‘adas are highly esteemed in Pal, and are used in soup and as a “pottage’’ known as mujedderah. This last is of a reddish-brown color and is without doubt the “pottage” of Gen 25 34. Lentils were part of the provisions brought to David when fleeing from Absalom (2 S 17 28) and were used in the making of the hread for the prophet Ezekiel (4 9). Ina “plot of ground full of lentils,’? Shammah, one of David’s “mighty men,’’ stood and defended it and slew the marauding Philis (2 § 23 11.12). E. W. G. MasTerMan LEOPARD, lep’érd ([1] WAl, némeér [Cant 4 8; Isa 11 6; Jer 5 6; 13 23; Hos 18 7; Hab 1 8); cf Arab. (43, nimr, “leopard.” [2] Chald "23, nemar [Dnl 7 6]. [8] wapSadus, pdrdalis [Rev 13 2; Ecclus 28 23); cf O03, nimrim, Nimrim [Isa 15 6; Jer 48 34), M192, nimrah, Nimrah [Nu 382 3], and MWA) 73, beth-nimrah, Beth-nimrah [Nu 32 36; Josh 13 27}): The leopard is found through- Leopard (Felts leopardis). out Africa and ranges through Southern Asia from Asia Minor to Japan, being absent from Siberia and Central Asia. Its range is much the same as that of the lion, which latter, however, does not extend so far to the E. Like other animals of wide range, it has local varieties, but these shade into each other imperceptibly, and the one specific name, Felis pardus, includes all. Leopards live in some of the valleys E. and 8. of the Dead Sea, and in the mountains of Sinai and Northwestern Arabia. They have but rarely been seen of recent years in Lebanon or the more settled portions of Pal. So far as can be judged from skins which are available for comparison, the leopard of Pal is rather light in color, and is not as large as some found in Africa or India. It is not certain that the place-names, Nmrm, Nimran, and Bera-nimray (q.v.), have to do with na@mér, “leopard,” but their location is in Moab, where leopards are well known, even at the present day. One of the valleys entering the Dead Sea from the E., 8. of the Arnon, is called Wadi-en-Numeir (“valley of the little leopard”; numetr, dim. of nimr). In the Bible “leopard”? occurs mainly in fig- urative expressions, as a large and fierce beast. The leopard is mentioned with the lion and bear in Dn] 7 6; Hos 13 7; Rev 13 2; with the lion, wolf and bear in Isa 11 6; with the lion and wolf in Jer 5 6; with the lion alone in Ecclus 28 23; with the wolf alone in Hab 1 8. The leopard is smaller than the lion and the tiger, but is more active than either. Its swiftness is referred to in Hab 1 8: “Their horses also [of the Chaldaeans] are swifter than leopards.” The spots of the leopard are referred to in Jer 13 23: “Can the Ethiopian change his skin, or the leopard his spots?” The Gr wdpdadkis, pdrdalis, and mwdévOnp, pdn- thér, were both applied to the leopard. Panther” is sometimes used of large leopards, while in Amer- ica, with its corrupt form “painter,” it is one of the names applied to the cougar or puma, Felis concolor, 1867 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lentils Leper, Leprosy which, as the specific name implies, is not spotted like the leopard, or striped like the tiger. ALFRED Exy Day LEPER, lep’ér, LEPROSY, lep’ro-si (nyiy, cara‘ath; dpa, lépra): A slowly progressing and intractable disease characterized by subcutaneous nodules (Heb s°éth; LXX oulé; AV “rising’’), scabs or cuticular crusts (Heb sappahath; LXX sémasia) and white shining spots appearing to be deeper than the skin (Heb bahereth; LXX télaigéma). Other signs are (1) that the hairs of the affected part turn white and (2) that later there is a growth of “quick raw flesh.” This disease in an especial manner rendered its victims unclean; even contact with a leper defiled whoever touched him, so while the cure of other diseases is called healing, that of lep- rosy is called cleansing (except in the case of Miriam [Nu 12 13] and that of the Samaritan (Lk 17 15] where the word ‘‘heal’’ is used in refer- ence to leprosy). The disease is described in the Papyrus Ebers as ukhedu (the Coptic name for leprosy is ¢eht). It is also mentioned in ancient Indian and Japanese history. Hippocrates calls it “the Phoen disease,” and Galen names it ‘‘ele- phantiasis.”’?’ In Europe it was little known until imported by the returning soldiers of Pompey’s army after his Syrian campaign in 61 BC; but after that date it is described by Soranus, Aretaeus and other classic authors. The first OT mention of this disease is as a sign given by God to Moses (Ex 4 6 [J]), which may be the basis of the story in CAp, 1, 1. OT 31, that Moses was expelled from Instances Heliopolis on account of his being a leper (see also 1, 26 and Ant, III, xi, 4). The second case is that of Miriam (Nu 12 10), where the disease is graphically described (EP2). In Dt 24 8 there is a reference to the oral tradition concerning the treatment of lepers, without any details, but in Lev 13, 14 (PC) the rules for the recognition of the disease, the preliminary quar- antine periods and the ceremonial methods of cleansing are given at length. It is worthy of note that neither here nor elsewhere is there any mention of treatment or remedy; and Jehoram’s ejaculation implies the belief that its cure could be accomplished only by miracle (2 K 6 7). Group of Lepers Begging. The case of Naaman (2 K 6 1) shows that lepers were not isolated and excluded from society among the Syrians. The leprosy of Gehazi (2 K 5 27) is said to have been the transference of that of Naaman, but, as the wcubanon Pood ia long, it must have been miraculously cted on him. The four lepers of Samaria of 2 K 7 3 had been excluded from the city and were outside the gate. The leprous stroke inflicted on Uzziah (2 K 16 5; 2 Ch 26 23) for his unwarrantable assumption of the priestly office began in his forehead, a form of the disease peculiarly unclean (Lev 13 43-46) and requiring the banishment and isolation of the leper. It is remarkable that there is no reference to this disease in the prophetical writings, or in the Hagiographa. In the NT, cleansing of the lepers is mentioned as a specific portion of Our Lord’s work of healing, and was included in the commission 2. Leprosy given to the apostles. There are few inthe NT individual cases specially described, only the ten of Lk 17 12, and the leper whom Our Lord touched (Mt 8 2; Mk 1 40; _Lk 6 12), but it is probable that these are only a few out of many such incidents. Simon the leper (Mt 26 6; Mk 14 3) may have been one of those cured by the Lord. The disease is a zymotic affection produced by a microbe discovered by Hansen in 1871. It is con- tagious, although not very readily 3. Nature communicated by casual contact; in and Locality one form it is attended with anaes- of the thesia of the parts affected, and this, Disease which is the commonest variety now met with in the East, is slower in its course than those forms in which nodular growths are the most prominent featurcs, in which parts of the limbs often drop off. At present there are many lepers to be seen at the gates of the cities in Pal. It is likewise prevalent in other eastern lands, India, China, and Japan. Cases are also to be seen in most of the Mediterranean lands and in Norway, as well as in parts of Africa and the West Indies and in South America. In former times it was occasionally met with in Britain, and in most of the older English cities there were leper houses, often called “lazarets’” from the mistaken notion that the eczematous or varicose ulcers of Lazarus were leprous (Lk 16 20). Between 1096 and 1472, 112 such leper houses were founded in England. Of this disease King Robert Bruce of Scotland died. There was special mediaeval legislation excluding lepers from churches and forbidding them to wander from district to district. Leprosy has been some- times confounded with other diseases; indeed the Gr physicians used the name lepra for the scaly skin disease now called psoriasis. In the priestly legis- lation there was one form of disease (Lev 13 13) in which the whiteness covers all the body, and in this condition the patient was pronounced to be clean. This was probably psoriasis, for leprosy does not, until a very late stage, cover all the body, and when it does so, it is not white. It has been surmised that Naaman’s disease was of this kind. Freckled spots (Heb badhak), which were to be dis- tinguished from true leprosy (Lev 13 39), were either spots of herpes or of some other non-con- tagious skin disease. The modern Arab. word of the same sound is the name of a form of eczema. RV reads for freckled spot ‘‘tetter,”’ an old Eng. war on a root implying itchiness (see Hamlet, I, v, The komiletic use of leprosy as a type of sin is not Bib. The only Scriptural reference which might approach this is Ps 61 7, but this refers to Nu 19 18 rather than to the cleansing of the leper. The Fathers regarded leprosy as typical of heresy rather than of moral offences. (See Rabanus Maurus, Allegoria, s.v. ‘‘Lepra.’’) (1) Leprosy in garments——The occurrence of certain greenish or reddish stains in the substance of woollen or linen fabrics or in articles made of leather is described in Lev 18 47 ff, and when these stains spread, or, after washing, do not change their color, they are pronounced to be due to a fretting Leshem Levitical Cities THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1868 leprosy (¢dra‘ath mam’ereth), and such garments are to be burnt. As among the fellahin articles of clothing are worn for years and are often hereditary, it is little wonder that they become affected by vegetable as well as animal parasites, and that which is here referred to is probably some form of mildew, such as Penicillium or mold-fungus. The destruction of such garments is a useful sanitary precaution. Possibly this sort of decaying gar- ment was in Job’s mind when be compares him- self to a “rotten thing that consumeth, like a garment that is moth-eaten’? (18 28); see also Jude ver 23, “the garment spotted [espiléménon] by the flesh.” (2) Leprosy in the house (Lev 14 34 ff) —The occurrence of ‘hollow streaks, greenish or reddish,” in the plaster of a house is regarded as evidence that the wall is affected with leprosy, and when such is | observed the occupant first clears his house of furni- ture, for if the discoloration be pronounced leprous, all in the home would become unclean and must be destroyed. Then he asks the priest to inspect it. The test is first, that the etain is in the substance of the wall, and, second, that it is spreading. In case these conditions are fulfilled, it is pronounced to be leprosy and the affected part of the wall is taken down, its stones cast outside the city, its plaster scraped off and also cast outside the city; new stones are then built in and the house is newly plastered. Should the stain recur in the new wall, then the whole house is condemned ‘and must be destroyed ‘and its materials cast outside the city. The description is that of infection by some fungus attacking whatever organic material is in the mud plaster by which the wall is covered. If in wood- work, it might be the dry rot (Merulius lacrimans), but this is not likely to spread except where there is wood or other organic matter. It might be the efflorescence of mural salt (calcium nitrate), which forms floccnlent masses when decomposing nitro- genous material is in contact with lime; but that is generally white, not green or reddish. Consider- ing the uncleanly condition of the houses of the ordinary fellah, it is little wonder that such fungus growths may develop in their walls, and in such cases destruction of the house and its materials is a sani- tary necessity. It should be observed here that the attitude of the Law toward the person, garment or house sus- pected of leprosy is that if the disease 4, The be really present they are to be de- Legal clared unclean and there is no means Attitude provided for cure, and in the case of the garment or house, they are to be destroyed. If, on the other hand, the disease be proved to be absent, this freedom from the disease has to be declared by a ceremonial purification. This is in reality not the ritual for cleansing the leper, for the Torah provides none such, but the ritual for declaring him ceremonially free from the suspicion of having the disease. This gives a peculiar and added Jorce to the words, ‘‘The lepers are cleansed,” as a testimony to Our Lord’s Divine mission. ALEX. MACALISTER LESHEM, lé’shem. See Latsu. LESSAU, les’é (Acooaot, Lessaoi; AV Dessau): A place mentioned only in 2 Macc 14 16 as the scene of a battle hetween Nicanor and the Jews. “Dessau”’ of AV arises from confusion of A with A in the Gr. The place may be identical with Apasa (q.v.). LET (karéxw, katéchd): Usually in the sense of “permit” (AS leian), but also in Old Eng. with meaning of ‘‘hinder’” (AS lettan). This latter sense is found in 2 Thess 2 7 AV, “Only he who now let- teth will let,” where RV has, ‘“‘Only there is one that restraineth now.” LETHECH, lé’thek (qn>, lethekh): A liquid measure equivalent to half a homer (Hos 3 2m) and containing about 53 bushels. See WEIGHTS AND MEASURES. LETTER, let’ér. See Epistun. LETTERS, let’érz. See ALPHABET; WRITING. LETUSHIM, 1étoo’shim, 1éti’shim coia, letushtm): A Dedanite tribe in North Arahia (Gen 25 3). With it are connected the AssHURIM and Leumi (q.v.). LEUMMIM, lé-um’im (BAND, l’ummim): A Dedanite tribe of North Arahia, connected with the LetusHiIM (q.v.). LEVI, levi ("12, Iéwi; Aevt, Leut; WH Act, Leuet): (1) The 3d son of Jacob hy Leah. See separate article, (2) (3) Two ancestors of Jesus in Lk’s genealogy (Lk 3 24.29). (4) The apostle Matthew. See Martuew. LEVI (“IE, léwt; Aevel, Leuet): The third of Leah’s sons born to Jacob im Paddan-aram (Gen 29 34). In this passage the name is connected with the vb. lawah, ‘to adhere,’ or ‘‘be joined to,” Leah expressing assurance that with the birth of this third son, her husband might be drawn closer to her in the bonds of conjugal affection. There is a play upon the name in Nu 18 2.4, where direction is given that the tribe of Levi be “joined unto” Aaron in the ministries of the sanctuary. The etymology here suggested is simple and reason- able. The grounds on which some modern scholars reject it are purely conjectural. It is asserted, e.g., that the name is adjectival, not nominal, describing one who attaches himself; and this is used to sup- port the theory that the Levites were those who joined the Sem people when they left Egypt to return to Pal, who therefore were probably Egyp- tians. Others think it may be a gentilic form lé’ah, “wild cow’ (Wellhausen, Proleg., 146; Stade, GVI, 152); and thisis held to be the more probable, as pointing to early totem worship! Levi shared with Simeon the infamy incurred at Shechem by the treacherons slaughter of the Shechemites (Gen 34). Jacob’s displeasure was expressed at the time (ver 3), and the memory was still bitter to him in his last days (49 5f). The fate predicted for the descendants of Simeon and Levi (ver 7), in the case of the latter on account of the tribe’s stedfast loyalty in a period of stern test- ing, was changed to a blessing (Ex $2 26 ff). _In later lit. the action condemned by Jacob is men- tioned with approval (Jth 9 2 ff). Levi was in- volved in his brothers’ guilt with regard to Joseph (Gen 37), and shared their experiences in Egypt before Joseph made himself known (chs 42-45). Three sons, Gershon, Kohath, and Merari, were born to him in Canaan, and went down with the caravan to Egypt (46 11). Nothing further is known of the personal history of this patriarch. He died and found sepulture in Egypt. For the tribal history and possessions, see Prirsts anp LEVITES. W. Ewina LEVIATHAN, 1évi'a-than ([9%>, lwyathan [Job 41 1-34], from 7/ mp , awah, “to fold’’; cf Arab. 1869 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leshem Levitical Cities 79 9 name of the wry neck, Iynx torquilla, Ge pl abi-luwé, from kindred 7/, ys) lawé, ‘‘to bend”): (1) The word “leviathan” also occurs in Isa 27 1, where it is characterized as ‘the swift serpent .... the crooked serpent”; in Ps 104 26, where @ marine monster is indicated; also in Ps 74 14 and Job 3 8. The description in Job 41 has been thought by some to refer to the whale, but while the whale suits better the expressions denoting great strength, the words apply best on the whole to the crocodile. Moreover, the whale is very seldom found in the Mediterranean, while the crocodile is abundant in the Nile, and has been known to occur in at least one river of Pal, the Zarka, N. of Jaffa. For a discussion of the behemoth and levia- than as mythical creatures, see HB, s.v. ‘“Behe- moth” and “Leviathan.” The points in the de- scription which may well apply to the crocodile are the great invulnerability, the strong and close scales, the limbs and the teeth. It must be ad- mitted that there are many expressions which a modern scientist would not use with reference to the crocodile, but the Book of Job is neither modern nor scientific, but poetical and ancient. (2) See Astronomy, II, 2, 5. ALFRED Evy Day LEVIRATE, lev’i-rat, LAW. See Marriace. LEVIS, lé’vis (Acvls, Lewis): 1 Esd 9 14, properly the Levite of Ezr 10 15; ‘“Shabbethai the Levite” for ‘“‘Levis and Sabbateus.” LEVITES, 1é’vits. LEVITICAL, lé-vit'i-kal, CITIES: I. Leesa Provisions 1. Numhers See Prizsts anp LEVITES. 2. Deuteronomy II. Wes .iaausen'’s VIEW ITI. A.rernative View anp EvipENcE 1. Traces of the Cities 2. Wellhausen’s Arguments Answered 3. Van Hoonacker'’s Reply 4. Ezekiel’s Vision 5. Priestly Cities and Cities in Which Priests Dwell LITERATURE I. Legal Provisions.—Nu 35 1-8 provides that - 48 cities should be given to the Levites, each sur- rounded by a pasturage. The exact 1. Numbers details are not quite clear, for in the Heb, ver 4 would naturally be read as ineaning that the pasturage was a radius of 1,000 cubits from the city walls, while ver 5 makes each city the center of a square, each side of which was 2,000 cubits long. Extant variants in the V8S suggest, however, that the text has suffered slightly in transmission. Originally there seems to have been no discrepancy between the two verses, and it may be doubted whether the intent was that the city was always to be in the mathematical center of the patch. The Levites were to have the right of redeeming the houses at any time, and in default of redemption they were to go out in the Jubilee. The field was not to be sold (Lev 25 32f). . : Dt 18 8 undoubtedly recognizes patrimonial possessions of the Levites outside the religious capital, and sees no inconsistency with its earlier statement that Levi had no portion or inheritance with Asrael (ver 1). The explanation lies, in the fact that these cities were not a tribal portion like the territories of the secular tribes. The area occupied by the whole 48 jointly would only have amounted to Jess than 16 miles. IL Wellhausen’s View.—Josh 21 relates that this command was fulfilled by the allocation of 48 cities, but it is clear that some of those cities were 2. Deuter- onomy not in fact reduced into possession; see e.g. Josh 16 10; Jgs 1 29 as to Gezer, and Jgs 1 27 as to Taanach. Wellhausen treats the whole arrangement as fictitious. His main reasons are: (1) that the arrangement is physically impracticable in a moun- tainous country, and (2) that “there is not a his- torical trace of the existence of the Levitical cities.” Many remained in the hands of the Canaanites till a late period, while others were “important but by no means ecclesiastical towns’ (Prolegomena, 160). Two pages later he says that “four of them were demonstrably famous old seats of worship,” and conjectures that most, if not all, were ancient sanctuaries. He also regards Ezckiel’s scheme of a heave offering of land (ch 45) as the origin of the idea. Yet ‘‘Jerus and the temple, which, properly speaking, occasioned the whole arrangement, are buried in silence with a diligence which is in the highest degree surprising” (p. 164). If. Alternative View and Evidence.—In point of fact, there are traces of some of the Levitical cities in the later history. Such are 1. Traces Anathoth (1 K 2 26; Jer 11; 32), of the Jattir (2 8 20 26, where, as shown Cities in the art. Primsts anp Levirses [q.v.], Jattirite should be read for the Massoretic Jairite), Beth-shemesh (1 5 6 13- 15; see Prizsts anp Levires as to the text). (From Am 7 17 it appears that Amaziah of Bethel had land, but we do nat know that he was of Leviti- cal descent or where the land was.) Further, the fact that many other Levitical cities 2. Well- appear to have been centers of worship hausen’s points to the presence of priests. Was Arguments the great high place of Gibeon (1 K Answered 3 4) unserved by priests? It is surely natural to suppose that during the period between the capture of the Ark and its trans- port to Jerus there was a tendency for high places . to spring up in cities where there were priests rather than elsewhere; indeed there would probably be a disposition on the part of unemployed priests to go astray in a direction that would prove lucrative. With regard to the other objection, Van Hoon- acker’s answer is convincing: ‘As to the way in which the measurements were to be 3. Van carried out in the mountainous country Hoonacker’s of Pal, the legislator doubtless knew Reply what method was usually employed. : Besides, we are free to believe that he only gives these figures as approximate indications” (Sacerdoce lévitique, 433). The same writer’s reply to the theory that the idea originated with Ezekiel is wholly admirable. “Strictly we could ask . . . . whether 4. Ezekiel’s Ezekiel did not found himself on the Vision description of the camp of the Israel- ites in the desert. It is only too mani- fest that the division and appointment of the terri- _tory as presented in ch 48 of the prophet are scarcely inspired by practical necessities, that they have a very pronounced character of ideal vision; and ‘ag no fancy is pure fancy,’ we ought also to find the elements which are at the basis of Ezekiel’s vision. The tents of the tribe of Levi ranged around the tabernacle explain themselves in the PC; we may doubt whether the Levites, deprived of territory (Ezk 44 28) and nevertheless grouped on a common territory, in the conditions described in Ezk 48, explain themselves with equal facility. A camp is readily conceived on the pattern of a chessboard, but not the country of Canaan. We need not stop there. It is in fact certain that Eze- kiel here has in view the protection of the holiness of the temple from all profanation; and in the realm of the ideal, the means are appropriate to the end” (op. cit., 425 f). Leviticus Lastly there runs through Wellhausen’s discussion the confusion between a city where priests may be dwelling and a priestly city. There 5. Priestly were priests in Jerus, as there are today Cities and in London or Chicago; but none of Cities in these three places can be regarded as Which a priestly city in the same sense as the Priests Levitical cities. Not one of them has Dwell ever been a patrimonial city of priests, or could be the origin of such an arrangement. While therefore the whole of the cities mentioned in Josh 21 were certainly not reduced into pos- session at the time of the conquest, the Wellhausen theory on this matter cannot be sustained. Lireraturs.—J. Wellhausen, Prolegomena, 159-63; A. Van Hoonacker, Sacerdoce lévitigue, 423-35 (very brilliant and important). Haroutp M, WiENER LEVITICUS, Jé-vit’i-kus: I. Generau Data 1. Name 2. Character of Book 3. Unity of Book: Law of Holiness Examination of Critical Theory II. Structure : 1. Modern Analyses (1) Theories of Disintegration (2) Reasons for Dismemberment (3) Insufficiency of These Reasons 2. Structure of the Biblical Text (1) Structure in General (2) Structure of the Individual Pericopes III. Origin ; 1. Against the Wellhausen Hypothesis (1) The Argument from Silence (2) eeuude of Prophets toward Sacrificial stem (3) The People’s Disobedience ts} Indiscriminate Sacrificing (5) Dt and PC 2. Connection with Mosaic Period (1) PC and Desert Conditions (2) Unity and Construction Point to Mosaic ‘Origin IV. Tue SIGNIFICANCE 1. Positive (1) The Law Contains God’s Will (2) The Law Prepares for the UnderstandIng of Christianity (3) The Law as a Tutor unto Christ 2. Negative LITERATURE I. General Data.—The third book of. the Pent is generally named by the Jews according to the first word, 8771, wayyikra’ (Origen Otrxpd, Ouikrd, by the LXX called according to its contents Aevituxdy, Leuitikén, or Acvevtuxdv, Leueitikén, by the Vulg, accordingly, “Leviticus” [i.e. Lzber], sometimes “Leviticum’’). The Jews have also another name taken from its contents, viz. DIS NW, torath kohdénim, ‘Law of the Priests.” ree As a matter of fact ordinances pertaining to the priesthood, to the Levitical system, and to the cultus constitute a most important 2. Charac- part of this book; but specifically ter of Book religious and ethical commands, as we find them, e.g. in chs 18-20, are not wanting; and there are also some historical sections, which, however, are again connected with the matter referring to the cultus, namely the con- secration of the priests in chs 8 and 9, the sin and the punishment of two sons of Aaron, Nadab and Abihu (10 1 ff), and the account of the stoning of a blasphemer (24 10ff). Of the Levites, on the other hand, the book does not treat at all. They ate mentioned only once and that incidentally in 25 32 ff. The laws are stated to have been given bhar sinay (7 38; 261; 26 46; 27 34), which expression, on account of ch 11, in which Jeh is described as speaking to Moses out of the tent of meeting, is not to be tr? “upon” but “at” Mt. Sinai. The connection of this book with the pre- ceeding and following books, i.e. Ex and Nu, which 1. Name THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA . 1870 is commonly acknowledged as being the case, at least in some sense, leaves for the contents of Lev exactly the period of a single month, since the last chronological statement of Ex 40 17 as the time of the erection of the tabernacle mentions the Ist day of the 1st month of the 2d year of the Exodus, and Nu 1 1 takes us to the Ist day of the 2d month of the same year. Within this time of one month the consecration of the priests fills out 8 days (Lev 8 33; 91). A sequence in time is indicated only by 16 1, which directly connects with what is re- ported in ch 10 concerning Nadab and Abihu. In the same way the ordinances given in 10 6ff are connected with the events described in 8 1—10 5. The laws are described as being revelations of Jeh, generally given to Moses (cf 1 1; 4 1; 6 14; 6 19.24 [Heb 12.17]; 7 22.28, etc); sometimes to Moses and Aaron (cf 11 1; 13 1; 14 33; 15 1, etc), and, rarely, to Aaron alone (10 8). In 10 12 ff, Moses gives some directions to the priests, which are based on a former revelation (cf 6 16 [Heb 9] ff; 7 387 ff). In 10 16 ff, we have a difference of opinion between Moses and Aaron, or rather his sons, which was decided on the basis of an independent application of principles given in Lev. Most of these commands are to be announced to Israel (1 2; 4 2; 7 23.29; 9 3ff; 11 2; 12 2; 16 2; 18 2, etc); others to the priests (6 9.25 [Heb 2.18]; 21 2; 22 2, etc); or to the priests and the Israelites (17 2; 22 18), while the directions in reference to the Day of Atonement, with which Aaron was primarily concerned (16 2), beginning with ver 29, without a special super- scription, are undeniably changed into injunctions addressed to all Israel; cf also 21 24 and 21 2. As the Book of Ex treats of the communion which God offers on His part to Israel and which cul- minates at last in His dwelling in the tent of meeting (40 34 ff; cf under Exonus, I, 2), the Book of Lev contains the ordinances which were to be carried out by the Israelites in religious, ethical and cul- tural matters, in order to restore and maintain this communion with God, notwithstanding the im- perfections and the guilt of the Israelites. And as this book thus with good reason occupies its well- established place in the story of the founding and in the earliest history of the theocracy, so too even - a casual survey and intelligent glance at the con- tents of the book will show that we have here a well- arranged and organic unity, a conviction which is only confirmed and strengthened by the presentation of the structure of the book in detail (see under II, below). As a rule, crities are accustomed first of all to regard chs 17-26 or 26 as an independent section, y and find in these chapters a legal code 3. Unity of that is considered to have existed at Book: Law one time as a group by itself, before it of Holiness was-united with the other parts. It is indeed trve that a series of peculiarities have been found in these chapters. To these peculiarities belongs the frequent repetition of the formula: ‘I am Jeh your God” (18 2.4; 19 2.4, etc); or “I am Jeh” (18 5.6.21; 19 14.16, etc), or “I am Jeh.... who hath separated you" (20 24), or ‘‘who sanctifieth you” (20 8; 21 8.15.23, etc). To these ‘peculiarities belong the references in words, or, in fact, to the land of Canaan, Into which Israel is to be led (18 3.24 ff; 19 23 #f.29: 20 22 ff; 23; 25). and also to Beye, out of which He has led the people (18 3; 19 34; 223 33; 26 13.45, etc); as, further, the demand for sanctification (19 2), or the warning against desecration (19 12; 21 23, etc), both based on the holiness of Jeh. In addition, a number of peculiar expressions are repeatedly found in these chap- ters. Because of their contents these chapters have, slnce Klostermann, generally been designated hy the letter H (i.e. Law of Holiness); or, according to the sug- estion of Dillmann, by the letter S (i.e. Sinaitic Law), ecause, according to 25 1; 26 46, they are said to have been given at Mt. SInal, and hecause In certaln critical circles it was at one time claimed that these chapters contain old laws from the Mosaic period, although these had been changed in form. These earlier views have apparently now been discarded by the critics entirely. 1871 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus Examination of critical theory.—We, however, do not believe that it is at all justifiable to separate these laws as a special legal code from the other chapters. In the first place, these peculiarities, even if such are found here more frequently than elsewhere, are not restricted to these chapters ex- clusively. The Decalogue (Ex 20 2) begins with the words, ‘I am Jeh thy God, who brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bond- age.’ Ex 22 31 contains the demand, “Ye shall be holy men unto me.” Ex 29 44.45 contains a romise that, God will dwell in the midst of the sraelites, so that they shall learn that He is Jeh, their God, who has brought them out of Egypt in order to dwell in their midst as Jeh, their God (cf, further, Ex 6 6-8; 31 13f; Lev 10 10.11; 11 44; Nu 16 37-41; 33 521.55f; Dt 14 2.21). Itisa more than risky undertaking to find in these and in other sections scattered remnants of H, esp. if these are seen to be indispensable in the connec- tion in which they are found, and when no reason can be given why they should be separated from this collection of laws. Then, too, the differences of opinion on the part of the critics in assigning these different parts to H, do not make us favorably inclined to the whole hypothesis. Hoffmann, esp. (Die wichtigsien Instanzen gegen die Graf-Well- hausensche Hypothese, 16 ff), has shown how impos- sible it is to separate H from the other ordinances of the PC in so radical a manner. In saying this we do not at all wish to deny the peculiar character of these chapters, only we do not believe that ch 17 can be added or ch 26 can be taken away from this section; for in ch 17 all the characteristic peculiari- ties of the Holiness Law are lacking ; and, on the other hand, in ch 26 the expression ‘fam Jeh your God,” or a similar one in vs 12.13.44 f, is found. The subscription in ver 46 connects ch 26 with the preceding; and, further, the reference to the Sab- batical year as described in ch 26, found in 26 34f. 43,is not to be overlooked. Finally, also, other legal codes, such as that in the first Book of the Covenant (Ex 23 20-33) and that of Dt (27 11- 28 68) close with the offer of a blessing or a curse. The chapters under consideration (Lev 18-26) are most closely connected with each other solely through their contents, which have found expression in a particular form, without these facts being suffi- cient to justify the claim of their being a separate legal code. For since in chs 1-17 all those things which separate the Israelites from their God_have been considered and bridged over (cf chs 1-7, the laws concerning sacrifices; chs 8-10, the mediator- ship of the priests; chs 11-16, the unclean things; ch 16, the Day of Atonement; ch 17, the use made of blood), we find in chs 18-26 an account of the God-pleasing conduct, which admits of nothing that desecrates; namely, chs 18-20 contain laws dealing with marriage and chastity and other matters of a religious, ethical or cultural kind, together with the punishments that follow their transgression; chs 21 f determine the true character of the priests and of the sacred oblations; chs 23f, the conse- cration of the seasons, of life and death, etc; ch 26, the Sabbath and the Jubilee year; ch 26 contains the offer of a blessing or a curse. Chs 1-17 have, as it were, a negative character; chs 18-26 a posi- tive character. In chs 1-17 the consciousness of what is unclean, imperfect and guilty is awakened and the possibility of their removal demonstrated; while in chs 18-26 the norm of a holy life is set forth. Even if these two parts at certain places show so great a likeness that the occurrence of an interchange of ordinances could be regarded as possible, nevertheless the peculiar character of each part is plainly recognized; and this is also a very essential argument for the view that both parts have one and the same author, who intentionally brought the two parts into closer connection and yet separated the one from the other. On this supposition the peculiarities of chs 18-26 are suffi- ciently explained, and also the positive contents of these chapters and the fact that just these chapters are referred to in preéxilic lit. oftener than is the case with chs 1-17, and particularly the close con- nection between Ezk and H is to be regarded as a consequence of the common tendency of both authors and not as the result of their having used a common source (see Ezexiet, II, 2). In 26 46 we have what-is clearly a conclusion, which corre- sponds to 25 1; 7 37f; 11, and according]. regards chs 1-26 as a unity; while ch 27, whic treats of vows and of tithes, with its separate sub- scription in ver 34, shows that it is an appendix or a supplement, which is, however, in many ways connected with the rest of the book, so that this addition cannot, without further grounds, be re- garded as pointing to another author. Il, Stractare.—Modern criticism ascribes the entire Book of Lev, being a special legal code, to the PC. The questions which arise 1. Modern in connection with this claim will Analyses be discussed under III, below. At this point we must first try to awaken a consciousness of the fact, that in this special par- ticular, too, the documentary theory has entered upon the stage of total disintegration; that the reasons assigned for the separation of the sources are constantly becoming more arbitrary and sub- jective; and that the absurd consequences to which they consistently lead from the very outset arouse distrust as to the correctness of the process. Just as in the historical parts the critics have for long been no longer content with J (Jahwist) and 1 (Elohist), but have added a J‘ and J’, an Et and E?, and as Sievers and Gunkel have gone farther, and in detail have completely shattered both J and E into entirely separate fragments (see GENESIS), 80 P, too, is beginning to experience the same fate. It is high time that, for both the historical and the legal sections, the opposite course be taken, and that we turn from the dismemberment to the com- bination of these documents; that we seek out and emphasize those features which, in form and con- tent, unite the text into a clear unity. For this reason we lay the greatest stress on these in this section, which deals with the structure of the book, and which treats of the matter (1) negatively and . (2) positively (see also Exopvs, II (1) Theories of disintegration—We have already seen in the art. Day or Atonement (I, 2, [2]) in connection with Lev 16 an example of these at- tempts at dissection, and here still add several ex- amples in order to strengthen the impression on this subject. (a) General considerations: If we for the present dis- regard the details, then, according to Bertholet (Kurzer Hand-Kommentar zum Alten Testament), not only chs 17—- 96 (see, above, under I) at one time existed as a separate legal corpus, but also the sacrificial legislation in chs 1-7, and also the laws concerning the clean and the un- clean in chs 11-15. Concerning ch 16 see above. Then, too, ch 27 is regarded as a supplement and is ascribed to a different author. Finally, the so-called ‘fundamental document”’ of P (marked Pg) contained only parts from chs 9f (also a few matters from ch 8), as also one of the three threads of ch 16, for Lev 8-10, it is said, described the consecration of the priests demanded in Ex 26 ff, which also are regarded as a pat of Pg, and ch 16 1 is claimed to connect again with Lev 10 (cf on this point Day or ATONEMENT, I, 2). All these separate parts of Lev (i.e. chs 1-7, 8-10, 11-15, 16, 17-26, 27) are further divided into a number of more or less independent sub- parts; thus, e.g., chs 1-7, containing the sacrificial laws, are made to consist of two parts, viz. chs 1-5 and chs 6-7; or the laws concerning the clean and the unclean in chs 11-15 are divided into the separate pieces, chs 11 12; 13 1-46; and these are regarded as having existed at one time and in @ certain manner Independently and Leviticus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1872 separated from each other. But how complicated in detail the composition is considered to be, we can see from chs 17-26. (b) Chs 17-26 considered in detail: While Baentsch 30; ¢ 10. E 20 2(3).6(27); (vii) 20 9.10-21; 19 20; (viii) 21 10-5.7. 9-15.17b-24; 22 3.8.10~14.18-25.27-30; (ix) 23 10-20. 39-43; (x) 24 15-22, except vs 1608b; (xi) 25 2-7 (4). 18—22.35-38.39.400.42 £.47.53.55; (xii) 25 80.9b.100.13. 14-16.17.24f. In uniting these pieces Rh (the Redac- tor of theLaw of Holiness) seems to have added de suo the following: 17 5 (beginning); 18 20-5.21.24.26a,8.29; 19 33f.37; 20 4f.7f.22-26; 21 6.8; 22 2.9.15f.31-33; 23 22; 25 111; 26 1f. At the same time he united with these an older parenetic section, 26 3-45, which, by insert- ing vs 10.34 f.39-48, he changed into a concluding ad- dress of this small legal code. Atl the rest that is found in chs 17-26 seems to be the result of a revision in the spirit of P, not, however, as though originally it all came from the hand of Rp (Redactor P). That he rather added and worked together older pieces from P (which did not belong to Pg) is seen from an analysis of ch23..... As far as the time when these a were worked to- ether is concerned, we have a reliable terminus ad quem n a comparison of Neh 8 14-18 with Lev 23 36 (P). 39 ff (H). Only we must from the outset remember, that still, after the uniting of these different parts, the marks of the editorial pen are to be noticed in the follow- ing chs, 17-26, i.e. that after this union a number of addi- tions were yet made to the text. This is sure as far as 23 26-32 is concerned, and is probable as to 24 1-9. 10—-14.23; 25 32-34; and that this editorial work even went so far as to put sections from P in the place of parts of H can possibly be concluded from 24 1-9.” (c) Extravagance of critical treatment: This is also true of all the other sections, as can be seen by a reference to the books of Bertholet and Baentsch. What should surprise us most, the complicated and external manner in which our Bib. text, which has such a wonderful history back of it, is declared by the critics to have originated, or the keenness of the critics, who, with the ease of child’s play, are able to detect and trace out this growth and develop- ment of the text, and can do more than hear the ass grow? But this amazement is thrust into the Gecueroand when we contemplate what becomes of the Bible text under the manipulations of the critics. The compass of this article makes it im- possible to give even as much as a general survey of the often totally divergent and contradictory schemes of Baentsch and Bertholet and others on the distribution of this book among different sources; and still less possible is it to give a criti- cism of these in detail. But this critical method really condemns itself more thoroughly than any examination of its claims would. All who are not yet entirely hypnotized by the spell of the docu- mentary hypothesis will feel that by this method all genuine scientific research is brought to an end. If the way in which this book originated had been so complicated, it certainly could never have been again reconstructed. (2) Reasons for dismemberment—We must at this place confine ourselves to mentioning and dis- cussing several typical reasons which are urged in favor of a distribution among different authors. (a) Alleged repetitions: We find in the parts be- longing to P a number of so-called repetitions. In chs 1-7 we find a twofold discussion of the five kinds of sacrifices (1-5; 6 1 ff); in ch 20 punitive measures are enacted for deeds which had been described already in ch 18; in 19 3.30; 23 3; 26 2 the Sabbath command is intensified; in 19 5 ff; 22 29f, we find commands which had been touched upon already in 7 15 ff; 19 9f we find almost ver- bally repeated in 23 22; 24 2 ff repeats ordinances concerning the golden candlestick from Ex 27 20 ff, etc. The existence of these repetitions cannot be denied; but is the conclusion drawn from this fact correct? It certainly is possible that one and the same author could have handled the same ma- terials at different places and from different view- points, as is the case in chs 1-7 in regard to the sac- rifices. Chs 18 and 20 (misdeeds and punishments) are even necessarily and mutually supplementary. Specially important laws can have been repeated, in order to emphasize and impress them all the more}; or they are placed in peculiar relations or in a unique light (cf, eg., 24 1ff, the command in reference to the golden candlestick in the pericope chs 23-24; see below). Accordingly, as soon as we can furnish a reason for the repetition, it becomes unobjection- able; and often, when this is not the case, the ob- jections are unremoved if we ascribe the repeti- tions to a new author, who made the repetition by way of an explanation (see Exopvs, IT, 2, [5]). (6) Separation of materials: Other reasons will probably be found in uniting or separating materials that are related. That ch 16 is connected with chs 8-10, and these connect with Ex 25 ff, is said to prove that this had been the original order in these sections. But why should materials that are clearly connected be without any reason torn asunder by the insertion of foreign data? Or has the interpolator perhaps had reasons of his own for doing this? Why are not these breaks ascribed to the original author? The sacrificial laws in chs 1-7 are properly placed before Lev 8-10, because in these latter chapters the sacrifices are described as already being made (9 7.15, the sin offering; 9 7.12.16, the burnt offering; 9 17; 10 12, the meal offering; 9 18, the peace offering; 9 3f, all kinds). In the same way chs 11-15, through 15 31, are in- wardly connected with Lev 16, since these chap- ters speak of the defiling of the dwelling-place of Jeh, from which the Day of Atonement delivers (16 16f.33). As a matter of course, the original writer as well as a later redactor could ‘have at times also connected parts in a looser or more ex- ternal manner. In this way, in 7 22 ff, the com- mand not to eat of the fats or of the bload has been joined to the ordinances with reference to the use of the peace offerings in 7 19 ff. This again is the case when, in ch 2, vs 11-13 have been inserted in the list of the different kinds of meal offering; when after the general scheme of sin offerings, according to the hierarchical order and rank in ch 4, a number of special cases are mentioned in 5 1 ff; and when in 5 7 ff commands are given to prevent too great poverty; or when in 6 19 ff the priestly meal offerings are found connected with other ordinances with refer- ences to the meat offerings in general (6 14 ff); or when the share that belongs to the priest (7 8 ff) is found connected with his claim to the guilt offer- ing (7 1ff); or the touching of the meat offerin by something unclean (7 19 ff) is found connecte with the ordinances concerning the peace offerings; or when in ch 11 the ordinances dealing with the unclean animals gradually pass over into ordinances concerning the touching of these animals, as is already indicated by the subscription 11 4.6f (cf with ver 2). Still more would it be natural to unite different parts in other ways also. In this way the ordinances dealing with the character of the sacri- fices in 22 17-30 could, regarded by themselves, be placed also in chs 1-7. But in ch 22 they are also well placed. On the other hand, the character of chs 1-7 would have become too complicated if they were inserted here. In such matters the author must have freedom of action. (c) Change of singular and plural: Further, the fre- quent change between the sing. and the pl. in the ad- dresses found in the laws which are glven to a body of persons is without further thought used by the critics as a proof of a diversity of authors in the section undercon- 1873 sideration (cf 10 12; 19 9.11ff,15ff, etc). But how easily this change in numhers can be explained! In case the pl.is used, the hody of the people are regarded as hav- ing been distributed into individuals; and in the case of a more stringent application the pl. can at once be con- verted into the sing., since the author ‘ts thinking now only of separate individuals. Naturally, too, the sing. is used as soon as the author thinks again rather of the people as a whole. Sometimes the change is made suddenly within one and the same verse or run of thought; and this in itself ought to have banished the thought of a difference of authors !n such cases. In the case of an interpolator or redactor, it is from the outset all the more probable that he would have paid more attention to the erson used in the addresses than that this would have een done by the original writer, who was completely absorbed hy the subject-matter. Besides, such a change in numher is frequently found in other connections also; ef in the Book of the Covenant (Ex 22 20-25.29f; 23 off; cf Dt 12 2ff.13ff). In regard to these passages, also, the modern critics are accustomed to draw the same conclusion; and in these cases, too, this is hasty. In the same way the change in the laws from the 3d to the 2d person can hest he explained as the work of the lawgiver himself, before whose mind the persons addressed are more vividly present and who, when speaking in the 2d person, becomes personal (cf Lev 2 4 with 2 1-3, and also 1 2; 3 17; 6 18.21.25 7). (d) Proofs of religious development: A greater importance seemingly must be attributed to the reasons based on a difference in the terminology or on contradictions in the laws, as these appear to lead to areligio-historical development. But the following examples are intended to show how all- important it is to be slow in the acceptance of the materials which the critics offer in this connection. (3) Insufficiency of these reagons.— (a) In § 1-7, in the section treating of the sin offering (4 1—5 13), we find the word 'asham, which also signifies ‘‘guilt offering” (cf vs 14%; 7 1 if). Accordingly, it is claimed, the author of 5 1-7 was not yet acquainted with the difference be- tween the two kinds of offerings, and that this part is older than thatin 4 117; 5 14ff. However, in § 1 ff the word ‘dsham is evidently used in the sense of ‘'repent- ance,’ and does not signify ‘‘sin offering” at all; at any rate, already in vs 6f we find the characteristic term hatta'th to designate the latter, and thus this section appears as entirely in harmony with the connection. (b) Critics find a contradiction in 6 26; 7 33.7, and in 6 29; 7.31.6, since in the first case the officiating priest and in the other case the entire college of priests is described as participating in the sacrifice. In reply it is to be said that the first set of passages treat of the individual concrete cases, while the second set speak of the general principle. In 7% 8f, however, where the individual officiating priest is actually putin express con- trast with all the sons of Aaron, the matter under con- sideration is a difference in the meal offerings, which, beginning with ch 2, could be regarded as known. Why this difference is made in the use of this sacrifice is no longer intelligible to us, as we no longer retain these sacrifices, nor are we in possession of the oral instruction which possibly accompanied the written formulation of these laws; but this is a matter entirely independent of the question as to the author. (c) According to Ex 29 7;, Lev 4 3.5.16; 6 20.22; 8 12; 16 32; 21 10.12, the high priest is the only one who is anointed; while, on the other hand, in Ex 28 41; 29 21: 30 30; 40 15; Lev 7 36; 10 7, all the priests are anointed. But the text as it reads does not make \t impossible that there was a double anointing. Accord- ing to the first set of passages, Aaron is anointed in snch a@ manner that the anointing oil is poured out upon his head (cf esp. Ex 29 7 and Lev 8 12). Then, too, he and all his sons are anointed in such a way that a mixture of the oil and of the blood is sprinkled upon them and on their garments (cf esp. Ex 29 21 and Lev 8 30). Were we here dealing with a difference in reference to the theory and the ranks of the priesthood, as these dis- cussions were current at the time of the exile (see I11, below), then surely the victorious party would have seen to it that their views alone would have been reproduced in these laws, and the opposing views would have heen suppressed. But now both anointings are found side hy side, and even in one and the same chapter! (d) The different punishments prescribed for carnal intercourse with a woman during her periods in 15 24 and 20 18 are easily explained by the fact that, in the first passage, the periods are spoken of which only set in during the act, and in the second passage, those which had already set in before. rs x (e) As far as the difference in terminology is con- cerned, it must be remembered that in their claims the critics either overlook that intentional differences may decide the preference for certain words or expressions; or else they ignore the fact that it is possible in almost every section of a writer's work to find some expressions which are always, or at least often, peculiar to him; or THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus finally, they in an inexcusable way ignore the freedom of selection which a writer has between different syno- nyms or hls choice in using these. Allin all, it must be said that however much we acknowledge the keenness and the industry of the modern critics in clearing up many difficulties, and the fact that they bring up many questions that demand answers, it nevertheless is the fact that they take the matter of solving these problems entirely too easily, by arbitrarily claiming different authors, without taking note of the fact that by doing this the real difficulty is not removed, but ig Baty transferred to another place. What could possibly be accepted as satisfactory in one single instance, namely that through the thoughtlessness of an editor discrepancies in form or matter had found their way into the text, is at once claimed to be the regular mode of solving these difficulties— a procedure that is itself thoughtlessness. On the other hand, the critics overlook the fact that it makes little difference for the religious and the ethi- cal value of these commands, whether logical, sys- tematic, linguistic or aesthetic correctness in all their parts has been attained or not; to which must yet. be added, that a failure in the one particular may at the same time be an advantage in the other. In this respect we need recall only the anacoluths of the apostle Paul. ; (1) Structure in general—The most effective antidote against the craze to split up the text in the manner described above will be 2. Structure found in the exposition of all those of the features which unite this text into Biblical one inseparable whole. What we have Text tried to demonstrate in the arts. . Genesis; Exopus, II; Day or Atonement, I, 2 (cf also Ezexrot, I, 2, [2]) can be repeated at this point. The Book of Lev shows all the marks of being a well-constructed and or- ganic literary product, which in its fundamental characteristics has already been outlined under I above. And as this was done in the several articles just cited, we can here add further, as a confirma- tory factor in favor of the acceptance of an inner literary unity of the book, that the division of the book into its logical parts, even down to minute details, is here, as is so often the case elsewhere, not only virtually self-evident in many particulars, but that the use made of typical numbers in many passages in this adjustment of the parts almost forces itself upon our recognition. In other places the same is at least suggested, and can be traced throughout the book without the least violence to the text. The system need not be forced upon the materials. We often find sections but loosely con- nected with the preceding parts (cf under 1 above) and not united in a strictly logical manner, but which are nevertheless related in thonght and asso- ciation of ideas. In harmony with the division of the Book of Gen we find at once that the general | contents, as mentioned under I above, easily fall into 10 pericopes, and it is seen that these consist of 2 sets each of 5 pericopes together with an appendix. (a) Ten pericopes in two parts: Part I, the separation from God and the removal of this sep- aration: (i) chs 1-7; (ii) chs 8-10; (iii) chs 11-15; (iv) ch 16; (v) ch 17. Part II, the normal conduct of the people of God: (i) chs 18-20; (ii) chs 21-22; (iii) chs 23-24; (iv) ch 25; (v) ch 26. Appendix, ch 27; cf for the number 10 the division of Ex 1 8—7 7; 7 8—13 16; 13 17—18 27; also the Decalogue, 20 1 ff; 21 1—23 19; 32 1—35 1; and see Exopus, JI, 2; and in Lev probably 18 6-18; 19 9-18, and with considerable certainty 19 1-37 (see below). Leviticus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1874 (b) Correspondence and connections: I leave out of consideration in this case the question whether an intentional correspondence among the different parts be traced or not, even in their details. Thus, e.g., when the 2d pericope (chs 8-10 and 21f) treats particularly of the order of the priests, or when the 4th pericope of the 2d set (ch 25) states that the beginning of the Year of Jubilee fell on the 10th day of the 7th month, i.e. on the Day of Atonement as described in Lev 16, in the 4th pericope of the 1st set (cf 25 9 with 16 29); or when both sets close with two shorter pericopes, which evi- dently express high stages of development (chs 16 and 17, respectively, chs 25 and 26 treating of the Day of Atonement, of the use made of blood and the purposes of blood for the altar or the Juhilee Year, of the blessing and the curse). And, as far as the order in other respects is con- cerned, it is throughout to be regarded as founded in the snbject-matter itself that chs 1-17 must pre- cede chs 18-26. First that which separates the people from God must be removed, and then only is a God-pleasing conduct possible. Just as easily, and in agreement with the context, it is possible that the consecration of the priests in chs 8-10 pre- supposes the sacrificial térah (chs 1-7; ef under 1 above) and follows the latter, and is immediately introduced by the mention made of the installation sacrifices for which otherwise there are no reasons assigned in the concluding formula in 7 37 (cf 8 22-32). The Day of Atonement (ch 16), which in vs 16f and 33 is spoken of in connection with the punts of the sanctuary, is in turn introduced y chs 11-15, or more particularly by the remark in 15 31, where mention is made of the pollution of the dwelling-place of Jeh. And on the other hand, the ordinances dealing with the priests (chs 8-10) in 10 10, where the command is given to discriminate between what is holy and what is unholy and to teach Israel accordingly, already point to the con- tents of chs 11-15. The sacrifices, with which the first part in chs 1~7 begins, are taken up again by the conclusion in ch 17, in the commandment con- cerning the blood for the altar. The second part, too, already at the beginning (chs 18-20) in its religiously cultural and ethical ordinances, shows in the clearest possible manner what matters it proposes to discuss. In this way the systematic structure of the book is apparent in all particulars. Close connections: comparison with Ex: And, further, the different pericopes are also so closely connected among themselves and with the corre- sponding pericopes in the books of Ex and Nu, that many have thought it necessary to regard them as a special body of laws. But the connection is so close and involves all the details so thoroughly, that all efforts to divide and distribute them after the examples described under 1 above must fail absolutely. We shall now give the proofs for the different pericopes in Lev, but in such a manner as to take into consideration also Ex 26-31; 35 ff, treating of the tabernacle and its utensils and the Aaronitic priesthood, which are most intimately connected with Lev. All details in this matter will be left out of consideration. (a) Tabernacle and priesthood: That Lev 8-10 (the consecration of the ee etc), together with Ex 26 ff, constitutes a single whole is accepted on all hands. But the tent of meeting and its utensils, and also the priesthood, both with and without any emphasis on the Aaronitle origin, are presupposed also in almost each one of the other pericopes of Lev; cf for chs 1-17, e.g., 1 3.5; 3 2.8.13; 4.5.7.14.16.18; 6 26 (tent of meet- ing); 1 5.12; 8 5; 4 7.25.30; 6 12 (altar of burut sacrifices); 4 7.18 (altar of incense sacrifices); 4 6.17 (veil); 6 9.19 (court); 1 5.7.8.11; 2 2; 2.5.8.13; 6 9.14.16.20.25, etc (Aaron and his sons as priests); for chs 11-15 see 12 4.6; 14 11.28; 15 14.29.31 (sanctuary, tent of meeting, dwelling-place); 11 1; 12 61; 13 1 f: 14 27.33 ff; 15 1 (priesthood); for ch_16 see vs 2.7. 16f.20.23.33 (sanctuary and Holy of Holies, tent of meeting); 16 2.12 (veil); 16 2.13 ff (id of the Ark of the Covenant); 16 12.18.20.33 (altar); 16 1 ff (Aaronitic priesthood); for ch 17 see vs 4-6.9 (tent of meeting); vs 6.11 (altar); ver 5 (priesthood); for chs 18-20 see 19 30.21 (sanctuary of Jeh, tent of meeting); 19 22 (priesthood); for ch 21f see 21 12 (sanctuary); 21 23 (sanctuaries of Jeh); 21 23 (veil, altar); 21 17.21 (Aaron- itic priesthood); for chs 23, 24 see 28 2.4.21.24.27.36f (sanctuary); 24 1ff (candlestick, tent of meeting); 5 ff (table of showbread); 23 10.20 (priesthood); 24 3.9 (Aaronitic priesthood); for ch 26 see vs 2.11.31 (sanctuary, dwelling-place of Jeh, sanctuaries); for ch 27 see vs 10.33 (sanctuary); vs 8 ff (priesthood). (8) In the same way the sacrificial laws of chs 1-7 are mentioned in the following pericopes as matters that are well known. For chs 8-10 see 9 7.15 (sin offering); 9.7.12.16 (burnt offering); 9 17; 10 12 (meal offering); 9 18 (peace offering); 9 3f (all together); cf also Ex 29 14.18.28. In Lev 9 21; 10 14f (wave-breasts and heave-thigh) direct reference is made to 7 30-36. In the same manner 10 16 ff presupposes the ordinances dealing with the different ways of offering the sin offer- ings in 4 3ff.13ff; 6 24-30; for chs 11-15 see 12 6f: 14 12 ff (cf esp. 14 13 with 4 24); 14 21 ff; 15 14f. 29f; for ch 16 see vs 3.5 1.9.11.15.24 1.27; for ch 17 see vs 5 ff.8.11; for chs 18-20 see 19 6 ff.21f (here is there- fore the 'asham found in H, which is claimed to be of a later date); for ch 21f see 21 6.211; 22 17 ff.29f; for chs 23, 24 see 23 12f; 18 19.27.37; 24 9. for ch 26 see vs 301; for ch 27 cf vs 15.19.27.31 with § 16; 6 5. (y) Laws on clean and unclean: The laws in refer- ence to the clean and the unclean in chs 11-15 are also interwoven with the whole book. For chs 1-7 see 5 2f; 6 27; 7.19ff; for chs 8-10 see 10 10f; for ch 16 see vs 16.19; for ch 17 see vs 13.151; for chs 18-20 cf 20 25 with 11 44, and in general with ch 11; for chs 21 f see 21 10; 13 45; 22 3 ff with chs 13-15; for ch 27 see vs 11 and 27, as also ch 11. (6) The laws in reference to the Day of Atonement found in Lev 16 are prepared for by those found in chs 11- 15, viz. in 14 4 ff.49 ff (the ceremony with the two birds in connection with the purification from leprosy), and in 15 31 (cf 16 16.19; see above). For chs 23, 24 cf 23 26 ff with 16 29 ff, and for 25 9 with 16 29 see above; cf also Ex 30 10. (©) Ch 17 is reéchoed in chs 1-7 (7 26f) and in chs 18-20 (19 26). (¢) Finally ch 25 (Year of Rest and Year of Jubilee) i upboeed in ch 26 (vs 341.43) and in ch 27 (vs 17 The above, however, by no means exhausts this list of references and similar thoughts, and we have here given only some leading illustrations. What literary tricks must be resorted to when, over against this overwhelming mass of evidence, critics yet insist that the different parts of the book were originally independent writings, esp., too, when the entire tabernacle and utensils of the Aaronitic priesthood, the Day of Atonement, the Year of Jubilee, the whole sacrificial scheme and the laws dealing with the great festivals, the restriction of the slaying of the sacrificial animals to the central sanctuary, are regarded as the products of imagina- tion alone, according to the Wellhausen hypothesis (cf III, below, and see also Exonvus, III, 5; Day or AtoneMEnT, III, 1; Ezrxret, JI, 2). And how little is gained in addition when, as is sometimes done, in a most arbitrary manner, the statements found in chs 1-3 concerning the tabernacle of reve- lation (“tent of meeting”) and concerning Aaron's sons, or concerning Aaron and his sons together, are regarded as later additions. In Lev and. Ex 26 ff, 35 ff, everything is so entirely of one and the same character and has so clearly emanated from one and the same spirit, that it is impossible to separate from this product any constituent parts and to unite these into groups that were originally inde- pendent, then to split up these still further and to trace the parts to their sources, and even to con- struct a scheme of religious and historical develop- ment on this reconstruction of the sources. (2) Structure of the individuat pericopes.—As the windows and the column capitals of a mediaeval cathedral are arranged according to different schemes and this divergence is regarded as an enrichment of the structure, thus, too, we find it to be in the structure of the various pericopes of the Book of Lev. These latter, too, possess a certain symphony of different tones, but all are rhythmically arranged, and only when united do they produce the entire symphony. (a) The laws concerning the sacrifices (Lev 1- 1875 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus 7): In the first place, the five different kinds of sacrifices in Israel are mentioned in succession twice, in 1 1—7 21: Part I, chs 1-6, namely (i) ch 1, burnt offerings; (ii) ch 2, meal offering; (iii) ch 3, peace offerings; (iv) 4 1—6 13, sin offering; (v) 5 14-26, guilt offering; Part II, 6 1—7 21, namely (i) 6 8-18, burnt offerings; (ii) 6 14-23, meal offer- ing; (ii) 6 24-30, sin offering; (iv) 7 1-7 with appendix, vs 8-10, dealing with that part of the sacrifices which belongs to the priest (see under 1, above), guilt offering; (v) 7 11-21, peace offer- ings. With this is found connected in 7 22-27 the prohibition of the use of the fat or the blood, and in 7 28-36, the laws concerning the wave-breast and the heave-thigh. We have accordingly at once twelve of these laws (cf on Ex 25 1—30 10 in art. on Exopvs, I], 2, [5] and on Ezextan, I, 2,[5]). But even apart from this we have no right to ascribe chs 1-6 and 6 1—7 21, on the ground that they are duplicates, to different authors. _. That there is a difference between these two accounts is proved, not only by the fact that the first set of laws from chs 1-5 is addressed to all the Israelites (cf 1 2; 4 2), and the second set 6 8; 7 21 to Aaron and his sons (cf 6 9.25); but the second set has also in content a number of altogether different viewpoints as compared with the first set, so that the same author found himseif induced or compelled to write both sets. On the other - hand, the fact that both have the same author is evident from the very close connection between the two sections. In addition to the fact that both make mention of all five kinds of sacrifices, we can yet compare 3 5 with 6 22 (fat pieces of the peace offering over the burnt sacrifices upon the pieces of wood); and, further, the express reference of 6 17 to ch 4, while 6 30 presupposes the distinct separation of the sin offering, the blood of which is brought into the tent of meeting, from the other sacrifices, as these are given in 4 3 ff.13 ff over against 4 22 ff.27 ff. Ch 4, with its reference to the peace offerings (vs 10.26.31.35), is again most closely connected with ch 3. We must accordingly insist that the whole account is most intimately interwoven. Over against this, the omission within the first set, chs 1-5,in 5 14-16, of the ritual for the peace offering, is sufficiently explained only by the fact that this ritual was to be used in the second set (6 8—7 21), and here for the first time only in 7 1-15, which fact again speaks for the same author for both sets and against the supposition that they were merely mechanically united by a redactor. The fact that the second set 6 8—7 21 has a different order from that of chs 1-5, by uniting the sin offering immediately with the meal offering (6 24 ff with vs 14-23), is probably on account of the similar ordinances in 7 9 and 7 19 (natner of eating the meal offering and the sin offering). m the other hand, the position of the peace offering at the close of the second set (7 11 ff) furnished the pos- sibility of giving to the piece of the entire pericope em- braced in 7 22-27.28-36 a suitable conclusion; since 7 22 ff (prohibition of the eating of the fat and_the blood), connected with 7 19 ff, contained in 7 28 ff an ordinance that pertained to the peace offering (heave- breast and wave-thigh). At any rate, these last two pieces are to be regarded separately from the rest, since they are no longer addressed to the priests, as is 6 8— 7 21, but to all Israel; cf_7 23.29. n some other data less intimately connected with the matter, cf above under 1 : (b) Consecration of priests and related matters (Lev 8-10): In this pericope, as in the following, down to ch 17 inclusive, but esp. from ch 11 on, the principle of division on the basis of the number four predominates, in many cases in the details, +00; so that this could scarcely be regarded as an accidental feature (cf also the history of Abraham in Gen 12-26; further, in Ex 36 4—40 38; and in Exopvs, II, 2, [7]; Lev 16, under Day or ATONE- ment, I, 2, [1]); Dt 12-26, too, is probably to be di- vided on this principle, even to the minutest details (cf finally Lev 2i—22 16; 22 17-30; chs 23f and 26). (i) Ch 8, treating of the first seven days of the consecration of the priests: The outline is found in ver 2, namely Aaron, the sacred garments, the anointing oil, the bullock of the sin offering, two rams, unleavened bread (cf vs 6.7 ff.10 ff.14 ff.18 ff. 22 ff.26 ff). (ii) Ch 9 thefirst sacrifices of Aaron and his sons on the 8th day (vs 2-4 contain the outline, after the manner of 8 2; cf vs 7 ff.11 ff, the sin offering and the burnt offering of Aaron, with ver 2; also vs 15-18, treating of what the people brought for the sacrifices, with vs 3f; but it is to be noticed that the meal offering and the peace offering [vs 17.18] are given in inverted order from that found in vs 3f). Here too we find the number seven, if we add the burnt offering for the morning (ver 17). (iii) 10 1-7, the sin of Nadab and Abihu and their punishment by death; (iv) 10 8-20, ordinances concerning the priests, occasioned by 8 1—10 7 and provided with a new superscription in 10 8, namely (a) 10 8, dealing with the pro- hibition of the use of wine and intoxicants; (8) 10 9f, distinction between the holy and the unholy; (vy) 10 12-15, the eating of the sacred oblations; (5) 10 16-20, the treatment of the goat for the sin offering. (c) Laws concerning the clean and unclean (Lev 11-16): () ch 11, treating of clean and unclean ani- mals. The outline of the chief contents is found in 11 46 with a free transposition of one number. There are accordingly four pieces, viz. (a) vs 2-8, quadrupeds; (8) vs 9-12, water animals; (7) vs 13-23, birds (with an_appendix, treating of contact with the unclean, vs 24-28, which give a summary of the animals mentioned [«-+-y]; see under 1); (8) vs 29-45, the small animals upon the earth (again in four subdivisions, viz. [i] vs 29-38; [ii] vs 39 ff; [iti] vs 41; [iv] vs 44f). (ii) Ch 12 treats of women in confinement, also in four pieces (vs 2-4, birth of a male child; ver 5, birth of a female child; vs 6f, purification cere- mony; ver 8, ordinances in case of extreme poverty). These parts are not joined logically, but in a rather external manner. (iii) The passage 13 1—14 53, containing the laws of leprosy, with the subscription in 14 54 ff. (Because seven points are to be enumerated, ver 55 [garments and houses], this is not as in its further exposition separated from the other laws and is placed in their midst.) The exposition contains four pieces, viz. («) 13 1-44, leprosy on human beings (with concluding verses, 45f), with seven subdivisions, of which the first five longer ones are constructed along fairly parallel lines, and again can be divided into four sub-subdivisions, viz. vs 1-8; 9-17; 18-23; 24-28; 29-37; 38f; 40-44. The significance of the number seven for the struc- ture (see [2], [b], i, above) is akin to that found, e.g., in Ex 24 18b—31 18 (see Exonvs, II, 2, [5]); Lev 8, 9 (see above); Lev 23, 25, and 27; and possibly 26 3-13.14-39 (see below); finally, the whole Book of Ex is divided into seven parts (see Exopus, IT, 1). (8) 13 47-59, leprosy in connection with garments, with four subdivisions, namely vs 47-50; 51f; 53f; 55 ff. The last subdivision can again be readily separated into four sub-subdivisions, viz. vs 55; 56; 57; 58. (vy) 14 1-32, purifications (ver 2 being a special superscription), with 4 subdivisions, viz. (i) vs 2b-3a, the leper before the priest; (ii) vs 30-9, the purification ceremonies on the first seven days, again divided into 4 sub-subdivisions: vs 3bf; 5-7; 8; 9; (ii) vs 10-20, the ceremony of the eighth day (4 sacrifices, namely vs 12-18, guilt offering; ver 19a, sin offering; ver 19b, burnt offer- ing; ver 20, meal offering; in the 4 sacrifices (6 12—6 7) there are again 4 different actions: vs 14; 15f; 17; 18; (iv) vs 21-32 (in cases of poverty) (6) 14 33-53, leprosy in houses, with four subdi~ visions: vs 33-35; 36-38; 39-42; 43-53. (iv) Ch 16, sickness or natural issues, with 4 subdivisions, viz. (2) 16 I-15, checked or running issues together with their purification (vs 3-12 con- tain 12 laws: vs 3; 4a; 4b; 5; 6; 7; 8; 9; 10a; 10b; 11; 12); (6) vs 16-18, issue of seed; (y) vs 19-24, periods; (6) vs 25-30, other flows of blood and their Leviticus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1876 purification. a + 8 refer to men and y+ & to women; and in addition to these implied sugges- tions, as a+6 to dealing with abnormal issues and their purification ceremonies, +7 with normal issues. (d) The Day of Atonement (Lev 16): See IV, 1, (2), 2, and under ATONEMENT, Day oF. : (e) Uses and significance of the blood of sacri- fices (Lev 17): (i) Vs 3-7, only one place for kill- ing the sacrifices and the rejection of all foreign cultures; (ii) vs 8.9, only one place for sacrificing; (iii) vs 10-14, prohibitive of eating the blood; (iv) ver 15, pertaining to carcases of animals found dead or which have been torn by wild beasts. Here the form and the contents of the section have been brought into perfect harmony by the author. Vs 3 ff. 8ff. 10 ff.13 ff begin with same words, and each contains a similar formula in reference to the punish- ment, while logically vs 10 ff and 13 ff are evidently only subdivisions of the third part in vs 10-14, which treats of the prohibition of eating blood. In the fourth di- vision, again, while in snbstance connected with the rest, there is lacking the formal agreement with the first three divisions. (f) (g) (Lev 18-20, 21): These naturally fall each into 2 parts. Chs 18-20 contain (i) chs 18f, religious and ethical laws; (ii) ch 20, laws dealing with punishments. : (fi) Religious and ethical laws (chs 18f): (a) ch 18: Ordinances with reference to marriage and chastity. («#) 18 1-5, introductory; (8) vs 6-18, prohibition of marriage between kindred of blood; (vy) vs 19-28, prohibition of other sexual sins; (8) vs 24-30, warnings. The subdivision (8) can perhaps be divided into 10 subordinate parts, if it is permitted to combine the different degrees of relationship mentioned in vs 12-14 (viz. 7.8.9.10.11.12—14.15.16.17.18). Since (y) of itself manifestly consists of 5 ordinances (vs 19.20.21.22.23), this whole section, if we are permitted to divide (a) into 5commandments (vs 2.34.36.4.5) and (8) also into 5 (vs 241, 26-28.29.302.305), would contain 5X5 words; but this is uncertain. (6) Ch 19: various commands of the deepest significance. In order to discover the divisions of this chapter_we must note the characteristic for- mula, ‘lam Jeh, your God,” or asimilar expression, which often appears at the beginning and at the end of certain divisions, e.g. in series (1) (9) and (10), but which in the middle series appears in each case only once, and which in all the series is found also at the conclusion. In this way we can compute 10 tetralogues. Thus after the superscription in ver 2 containing a summary, we have (i) vs 3.4 (vs 3a.3).4a.40); (ii) vs 5-10 (vs 5f. 7.9.10); (iii) vs 11f (vs 11e.11ba.11b8.12); (iv) vs 13 f (vs 13a.13b.14¢.14b); (v) vs 15f (152.156.162.160); (vi) vs 17f£ (vs 174.176.182.185); (vii) vs 19-25 (vs 19a.19b.20-22.23-25); (viii) vs 26-28 (vs 264.26).27.28), (ix) 29-32 (vs 29.30.31.32); (x) vs 33-36 (vs 33.34.35.36) ; ver 37 constitutes the conclusion of the whole. (Note that the number ten here is certain in the conviction of the present writer; but he is not quite so sure of the number of subdivisions within the main divisions; we may have to do here with pentalogues and not with tetralognes. If this is the case, then the agreements with ch 18 would under certain circumstances he even greater.) Possibly groupings of two can yet form a closer union (cf on Ex 1-18, 21-23, Exonus, II, 2, [1-4]). At any rate (iii) and (iv) can be summarized under the general heading of defrauding one’s neighbors; (v) and (vi) under that of observation of the laws; (vii) and (viii) under that of heathen abuses; while (ix) and (x) perhaps intentionally mingle together the religious and cultural and ethical elements, in order thereby already to express that all these things are most intimately connected (but cf also vs 12.14. 17, in the middle sections). In vs 5 ff.20 ff.23 ff, ie author develops his subject somewhat more ully. (fii) Laws dealing with punishments (ch 20): The regulations in reference to punishments stand in such close relation to the contents of ch 18 and to parts of ch 19, that it is absolutely incompre- hensible how the critics can assign these three chapters to different authors. Even if certain regulations of ch 18 are not found here in ch 20 (vs 7.10.176.18), and even if another order has been followed, this variation, which doubtless also hangs together with a new grouping of the mate- rials, is rather an advantage than a disadvantage for the whole. It is impossible to conceive that a redactor would have altered anything in two entirely parallel and similar texts, or would him- self have written a parallel text differmg from the other. Ch 20 can probably be divided into 4 parts, viz. (i) vs 1-8, punishments for idolatry and witch- craft with a concluding formula, vs 7f; (ii) vs 9-18, punishment of death for ten crimes, all of which, with the exception of thefirst, are of a sexual nature (vs 9-18). It is a question whether the first in the second group (ver 14), i.e. the sixth in the whole series, was intended to be made prominent by the peculiar character of the punishment (burn- ing to death); (iii) vs 19-21, other sexual sins, with lighter punishments; (iv) vs 22-27, with 4 subdi- visions (warning, vs 22f; promise, ver 24; em- phatic repetitions of two commands already given, vs 25 ff; [cf with 11 44 ff, and in general with ch 11]; and ver 27 with 19 26.31; 206). Per- fectly certain in this chapter is the fact that the different kinds of punishments are likewise decisive for their order. It is doubtless not to be regarded as accidental that both at the beginning and at the end death by stoning is mentioned. (g) (Lev 21 1—22 33): (i) Laws concerning the quality of the priests (21 1-22.16); and (ii) con- cerning sacred oblations (22 17-30) with the sub- scription vs 31-33. (gi) Qualities of priests: 21 1—22 16 in four sec- tions (21 1 ff.10 77.16 ff; 22 1ff; note also in 21 18-20 the 12 blemishes; in 22 4-8 the 7 cases of uncleanness). (gii) Sacred oblations: 22 17-30 in four sections (22 18-20.21-25.26-28.29 f). (h) Consecration of seasons, etc (chs 23, 24): (i) ch 28, laws for the feasts (7 sections, viz. vs 3. 4 f.6-14.15-22.23-25 26-32.33-36, with the appen- dix that in every particular suits the connection, in vs 39 ffi, added to the feast of the tabernacles); (ii) 24 1-4, treating of the sacred candlestick, which represents the moral conduct of the Israelites, and for this reason suits admirably in the connection; as this is true also of (iii) 24 5-9, treating of the shewbread, which represents the results of the labor of Israel; (iv) 24 10-23, containing the report of the punishment of a blasphemer of God and of one who cursed. Probably the example was made of @ person who took the name of God in vain at the time which this chapter describes. But possihly there is a still closer connection to be found with that which precedes. The shewhread and the candlestick were found in the holy place, which with its ntensils pictured the relation of Israel’s char- acter to their God; while the utensils in the Holy of Holies indicated God’s relation to His people (cf Hengs- tenberg, Beitrdge, III, 644 ff). But since the holy place, in addition to the shewbread end the candlestick, con- tained only the incense altar, which symbolized the prayers of Israel, and as the blasphemer represents the exact opposite of prayer, it is probahle that in 24 10 ff prayer is indicated by its counterpart. This section consists of 4 parts, viz. vs 10-12; 13-14; 15-22 (giving a series of punishments for certain wrongdoings which are more or less closely connected with that found in the text); ver 23. (i) Sabbatic and Jubilee years (ch 25): Sabbatic aud Jubilee years in 7 sections, viz. vs 1-7; 8-12; 13-28; 29-34; 35-38; 39-46; 47-55. (7) Conclusion: Curse and blessing (ch 26): The grand concluding chapter, offering a curse and a blessing and containing all the prophetic utter- 1877 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus ances of later times in a nutshell, viz. (i) vs 1-2, repetition of four important demands (vs 1a.1b.2a. 2b); (ii) 26 3-13, the blessing, possibly to be di- vided into 7 stages, one more spiritual than the other; (iii) 26 4-89, the curse, possibly to be di- vided into seven stages, one more intense than the other (cf also the play on words 7 times repeated, in reference to shabbath, possibly found in vs 34 f, and certainly found in vs 18.21.24.27f); (iv) 26 40-45, the mercy finally shown by Jeh for His covenant’s sake. (k) Appendix: Finally, the appendix in ch 27, dealing with vows and tithes, in 7 parts, viz. vs 1-8; 9-13; 14-15; 16-21; 26f; 28-29; 30-33. HI. Origin.—As in the art. Atonement, Day oF, I, 2, (2), we took astand against the modern attempts at splitting up the text, and in III, 1 1. Against against the theory of the late origin the Well- of the whole pericope, we must, after hausen _ trying under II to prove ‘the unity of Hypothesis the Book of Lev, yet examine the : modern claim that the book as a whole is the product of later times. Since the entire book is ascribed to the PC (see II, 1 above), the answer to the question as to the time when it was written will depend on the attitude which we take toward the Wellhausen hypothesis, which insists that the PC was not published until the time of the exile in 444 BC (Neh 8-10). : _ CG) Argument from silence—One of the most important proofs for this claim is the “argument from silence’ (argumentum e silentio). How care- ful one must be in making use of this argument can be seen from the fact that, e.g., the high priest with his full title is mentioned but a single time in the entire Book of Lev, namely in 21 10; and that the Levites are not mentioned save once (25 82 ff), and then incidentally. As is well known, it is the adherents of the Wellhausen hypothesis themselves who now claim that the bulk of the entire literature of the OT originated in the post-exilic period and long after the year 444 BC. Leaving out of con- sideration for the present the Books of Ch, Ezr and Neh, all of which describe the history of Israel from the standpoint of P, we note that this later liter- ature is not any richer in its references to P than is the older literature; and that in those cases where such references are found in this literature assigned to a late period, it is just as difficult to decide whether these passages refer merely to a custom or to a codified set of laws. (2) Attitude of prophets toward sacrificial system. —A further proof against the preéxilic origin of the priestly legislation is found in what is claimed to be the hostile attitude of the prophets to the sacri- ficial system (cf Am 5 21ff; 441; Hos 6 6; Mic 6 6ff; Isa 111ff; Jer 6 20; 7 21ff; Ps 40 6; 508.9; 51 16f). But this cannot possibly be an absolute antithesis; for in this case, it would be directed also against the Books of the Covenant and, in part, too, against Dt, which books in Ex 20 24; 22 19; 28 18; 34 25; Dt 12 5£.11.13.17. 26; 15 19-23; 16 2.5f; 17 1; 18 1.3 also give directions for sacrifices, and which, at least in part, are yet regarded as older writings. Further, these passages under discussion are also, in part, as- signed to a later and even a very late period (cf even such cases as Ps 40 6; 50 8f; 51 16f; Mic 6 6 ff, and in addition also Mal 1 10), ie. they are assigned to a time in which, according to the views of the critics, the priestly laws are said to have had their origin or were already regarded as authorita- tive. Asa rule, the prophets make sacrifices, Sab- baths, sacred places and persons a part of their pictures of the future; cf, as far as sacrifices are concerned, e.g. Jer 17 26; 3114; 33 14ff. Fi- nally, Lev 26 31 shows how, under certain cir-° SUSIE, even P can declare sacrifices to be use- ess. (3) The people's disobedience.—Further, the transgressions of the Levitical Jaws in the course of Israel’s history cannot be regarded as a proof of the non-existence of the priestly legislation in pre- exilic times. This is clear from an analogous case. Idolatry was forbidden by the Books of the Cove- nant (Ex 20-24; 384), which are recognized as ancient documents; but according to 2 K 22 the pious king Josiah down to the year 622 BC takes no offence at idolatry. Even after the reformation, which had been inaugurated in consequence of the finding of the Book of the Law in the temple during the reign of Josiah (2 K 22f), idolatry was again practised in Israel, as is proved by Ezk 8 and Jer 44, notwithstanding that the Books of the Covenant and Dt already were extant at that time, even according to the views of the critics. But let us pass on to P itself, and not forget that the directions given for the Jubilee Year (Lev 25), according to Jewish tradition, were never actually observed. According to the reasoning of the critics, this law could not be in existence even in the present day. According to all reports the transgressions of the Divine ordinances began even as early as the Mosaic period; cf Ex 32 (J, E, golden calf); Am 6 25; Ezk 20; Dt 12 8 and also Lev 17 7 (sac- rifice to the Satyrs in PC). This condition of affairs can readily be understood because the reli- gion of Jeh does not claim to be an emanation from the spirit of the people, but the result of a revela- tion from on high. In the light of these facts can we be surprised, that in the times of the Judges, when a great prophetic leader was so often not to be found in Israel, the apostasy was so great and so widespread? But all of these cases of disobe- dience, that have been demonstrated as actual facts in Israel’s history, are not able to eliminate the fact that there are many data to prove the existence of a central sanctuary already in the earliest history of the people, which fact presupposes as a matter of course that there were also laws for the cultus in existence (see Exopus, III, 5). We must further not forget how the sacrifices of the sons of Samuel (18 2 11 ff), notwithstanding all their arbitrary conduct, presupposes such passages as Lev 7 30- 32; 1015; Ex 29 31f; Lev 831; Nu 6 19f; Lev 7 23-32; or that the high priest, as described in PC, is already before the year 444 BC as well- known a character as he is after the exile (cf Ezz- KEL, IT, 2); or that the question of Hag 2 11 ff takes into consideration a code of cultus-laws, and that the answer is given on the basis of Lev 6 27; Nu 19 22. (4) Indiscriminate sacrificing —To this must be added that the transgressions, to which the critics appeal in proof of their claims, and which they abuse for their own purposes, must in part be inter- preted differently from what they are. In the case of sacrificing indiscriminately at any place whatever, and by any person whatever, we have in many cases to deal with extraordinary instances of theophanies (cf Jgs 2 1 ff; 6 11 ff; 13 1 ff), as these had been foreseen in Ex 20 24. Even the Book of Dt does not insist throughout (cf 16 21) that the sacrifices must be made at one and the same place (cf also PC: Lev 24 31; Josh 22). After the rejection of Shiloh, at which the central sanctuary had been deposited, as recorded in 1 8 4, the cultural ordi- nances of PC, as we learn from Jer 7 11 ff; 26 6; Ps 78 59 ff, became more or less a dead letter. Even the Books of Ch, which throughout record history from the standpoint of the PC, at this period and down to the dedication of the temple take no offence at the cultural acts of a Solomon in contrast with their attitude toward the conduct of Leviticus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1878 Uzziah (see 2 Ch 16; 6 1-4; 7 1-7, as compared with 26 16 ff). In the same way the pious people in the Northern Kingdom, after it had, by Divine consent, been separated from the Southern, could not do otherwise than erect altars for themselves, since they could not participate in the worship of the calves in Bethel and Dan. Further, modern criticism overlooks the fact that what is regular and normal is much less liable to be reported in his- torical narrative than that which is irregular and abnormal. (5) Dt and PC, etce.—It is not possible at this place to enter into further details; we accordingly refer only to Exoovs, III and IV; Day or Atonement, ITI, and esp. Ezexiet, If, 2, where the proof has heen furnished that this prophet belongs to a later period than PC as far as Ezk 40-48 (containing his picture of the future) in gen- eral is concerned, and as far as Ezk 44 4 ff (where it is claimed that the prophet first introduces the distinction between priests and Levites) in particular is concerned. All the important problems that are connected with this matter, esp. the difficulties which result from the Well- hausen hypothesis, when the questions as to the purpose, the form, the success and the origin of the priestly legis- lation come under consideration, are discussed in my book, Are the Critics Right? The result of this investi- ation is all the more noteworthy, as I was myself ‘ormerly an adhereut of the Wellhausen school, but was forced to the conclusion that this hypothesis is un- tenable. We have here yet to refer to the one fact that the relation of Dt and the PC, as far as Lev in par- ticular is concerned, justifies the scheme of P fol- lowed by D as the historical order, while Well- hausen makes Dolder than P. Dt 10 8f; 33 8 ff presuppose more detailed ordinances in reference to the priests such as those which have been given in P. The book of Dt further takes into account different kinds of sacrifices (cf 12 5 f.11.13.17.26; 15 19-23; 17 1; 18 1.8, such as are described in Lev 1ff). The law in Dt 14 (ordinances with reference to what is clean) agrees almost word for word with Lev 11, and is in such perfect harmony with the linguistic peculiarities of PC, that Lev 11 must be regarded as the original, and not vice versa, Dt 24 &f refers directly to the injunctions concern- ing leprosy, as we find these in Lev 13f, and the Deuteronomic passage is doubtless modeled after that of Lev. Dt 12 15.22; 16 22 cannot be under- stood at all, except in the light of Lev 17 13. Dt 26 14 ff again expressly takes into account ideas that have been taken from Lev 22 3ff. As far as the laws dealing with the great feasts in Dt 16 are concerned, it is impossible to understand ver 9 without Lev 23 15 ff.10f; and the designation ‘feast of tabernacles’’ in vs 13 ff cannot even be understood without a reference to such a law as we find in Lev 23 39ff. The other passages to be discussed on this subject lead us to the following results. — Even if the Book of Dt were the product of the 7th cent. BC, the facts that have been stated above would nevertheless disprove the claim 2. Connec- of the Wellhausen hypothesis as to an tion with _—_exilic or post-exilic date for the PC. Mosaic But if Dt, even in its essential and Period fundamental parts, merely, is Mosaic (cf Are the Critics Right? 1-55), then the PC which is still older than Dt must also belong to the Mosaic period. (1) PC and desert conditions—This conclusion is in this point confirmed still further by a series of facts. As Dt permits the firstborn to be ran- somed (Dt 14 22 ff), but the PC demands their consecration in natura (Lev 27 26f; cf Nu 18 15 ff), the latter ordinances could be preferred and enforced only during the wandering in the desert, where the whole nation was in the neighborhood of the sanctuary. The fact that the ordinances deal- ing with the domestic celebration of the Passover in the private houses on the 14th of Nisan and the holy convocation on the 15th of Nisan at the sanc- tuary could be carried out only during the wander- ings in the desert (cf Ex 12 3ff.6; Lev 23 5; Nu 28 16; Lev 27 6ff; Nu 28 17ff), and that this was changed in Dt 16 5f to correspond to changed conditions, can be seen by reference to Exonus, III, 3. Still more important is a third command in Lev 17 in comparison with Dt 12. The command- ment that every animal that is to be slain is to be brought to the central sanctuary can have a pur- pose only for the Mosaic period, and could not even have been invented at a later period. Because of the entrance of Israel into Canaan, the Book of Dt changes this ordinance in such a way that from this time on the killing of the animals is permitted at any place (12 13 ff.20ff). The different commands in reference to the carcases of animals that have died and of those torn to pieces are all dependent on Lev 17. In Dt 14 21, it was possible to forbid the use of such animals absolutely for Israel, because from now on, and in contrast to Lev iT, the killing of sacrificial animals was permitted at any place (vs 13 ff). In Ex 22 30 all use of such meat could be forbidden, because Lev 17, with its command to bring all blood to the sanctuary, had not yet been given. Lev, now, on the other hand, forbids this use only to the priests (22 8), and sees in this use in the case of the other Israelites only a transi- tory defilement (cf Lev 17 15; 11 40); and in 7 24 forbids only the use of the fat, but not of the meat of these animals; for now, according to Lev 17 1 ff, all the killing is a sacrifice which only those who are clean were permitted to eat and which could not be secured at all times (cf Hoff- mann, op. cit., 23 f Our exposition of Lev 17 1 ff is, however, in another respect also of the greatest significance, for in vs 46.8f the tent of meeting is presupposed as existing; in vs 5.8 also different kinds of sacri- fices, and in ver 6 the priesthood; so that at once further ordinances concerning the tent of meeting, the sacrificial code, the priesthood, such as we find in Ex 26 ff; 35 ff; Lev 1-7; Ex 29; Lev 8—10 21 ff, were possible and necessary, and these very laws must probably originate in and date from the Mosaic period. This same conclusion is sustained by the following considerations. For what other source or time could be in harmony with such state- ments found very often in other parts of Lev also, as “into the camp” in 4 11 ff; 6 11; 13 46; 14 3.8 (unconscious contrast to later times); 14 33 ff.40. 41.45.53; 16 26-28; 24 10-23; or “‘into the desert,” in 16 10.21f. In 6 15.18; 6 6 (cf also 27 2ff), the words “according to thy estimation” are addressed personally to Moses. In 6 20 a calculation is based on the day on which Aaron was consecrated to the priesthood, while ver 22 is the first that has general coloring. Such hints, which, as it were, have only been accidentally scattered in the body of the laws, and which point to the situation of the lawgiver and of his times, are of especial value for the argument in favor of the Mosaic origin of these laws. Further, we everywhere find that Aaron and his sons are as yet the only incumbents of the priestly office (cf 1 5.7.8.11; 2.3; 3 13; 6 9.14.16, etc). All the laws claim to have been given through Moses or Aaron or through both at Mt. Sinai (see I above). And who, in later times, if it was the purpose to magnify the priesthood of Aaron, would have thought of inventing the fact that on the Day of Atonement and on other occasions it was necessary for Aaron to bring a burnt offering and a sin offer- ing for himself (Lev 16; 8-10; 6 19 ff), or that Moses in his view of a certain cultural act had been mistaken (cf Lev 10 16 ff)? The law concerning the Jubilee Year (Lev 25) presupposes that each «tribe is confined in its own district and is not inter- 1879 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus mingled with the other tribes, a presupposition which was no longer possible after t e occupation of Canaan, and is accordingly thinkable only in the Mosaic times. And now let us remember that this fact, when we recall (see II, above) that the unity of the book was proved, is a ground for claiming that the entire book dates from the Mosaic period. As far as Lev at least is concerned, there is nothing found in the book that calls for a later date. Lev 18 24 ff can be regarded as post-Mosaic only if we translate these verses thoughtlessly, as though the inhabitants of the country were here described as being expelled earlier. On.the other hand, in ver 24, just as is the case with the parallel passage, 20 22 fi, the idea is, without any doubt, that Israel is not yet in the Holy Land. Accordingly the waw consecutives at this place are to be regarded not as indicating temporal but logical sequences. In the passage 18 27, we further find the archaic form ha’al for ha’élleh; cf in the Pent Gen 19 8.25; 26 3.4; Dt 4 42; 7 22; 19 11. Just as little does ch 26 take us into the exilic period. Only dogmatical prejudices can take offence at prediction of the exile. Lev 26 cannot be regarded as a “prophecy after the event,” for the reason, too, that the resto- ration of the poe by God’s pardon is here prom- ised (cf vs 40 ff). And, too, the exile is not the only unishment with which Israel is threatened; and nally as far as Israel is concerned, by the side of the statements concerning their dwelling in one single country (vs 34.38.41.44), it is also said that they are to be scattered among many nations and countries (cf vs 23.36.39). (2) Unity and construction point to Mosaic origin.—If to this we yet add the unity of the thought and of the external construction, looking at the whole matter, we do not see anything that would lead us to accept a post-Mosaic period for this book. Then, too, it is from the outset in itself only probable that Moses gave his people a body of cultus-laws and did not leave this matter to chance. We need only think of the great réle which among the oriental peoples was assigned to their religious cultus. It is indeed nowhere said, in so many words, that Moses wrote even the laws of the PC. But the references made by Dt to the PC; the fact that Nu 33, which also is credited to Moses, is characterized by the style of PC; further, that the author of Dt could write in the style of P (cf Dt 14 with Lev 11); and, per contra, that the author of Lev 26 had the mastery of the style peculiar to Dt (cf Dt 28)—all this makes it probable that Moses even wrote these things himself; .at any rate, no reasons can be cited against this view. Very interesting in connection with the question of the unity of the Pent are the close connecting links between Ley 18 24 ff; 20 22ff, and JE. The question whether Moses in the composition of the book made use of his own notes or of those of others, cannot be decided; but this is an irrelevant matter. What the facts may be in reference to the develop- ment of other ordinances, which have taken differ- ent forms in the Books of the Covenant and in PC or in Dt and in PC, and whether the existence of these differences in the cases of particular laws compels us to accept later additions, cannot be dis- cussed at this place. Yet from the outset it is to be emphasized that already in the Mosaic period there could possibly have been reasons for chang- ing some of these laws; esp. was this so in the Book of Dt, just before the people entered the promised land (cf e.g. the laws concerning tithes, Dt 12 6.17 ff; 14 22 ff; 26 12 ff; Lev 27 30ff; Nu 18 20 ff, or the laws concerning contributions for sacri- fices, Dt 18 3; Lev 7 29 ff). Then, too, the decision whether this development took place as eariy as the time of Moses or not is not to be made agpendont ou the possibility of our being abie to explain the reasons for such changes. We iack both the daily practice in these culturai ordinances, as also the orai instruction which makes these ordinances inteili- ible. The manner in which in Lev iff the different nds of sacrifices are introduced sounds as though these were already known to the peopie and were practised by them, except in the case of sin and guiit offerings. s is further in harmony with earlier narratives, which already report concerning sacrifices. It is possible that in this way we can also explain a certain relationship between the Jewish sacrificial rituai and that of Babylon (cf Zimmern, Beiirdge zur Kenntnis der babyloniachen Religion). The ordinances in reference to the ciean and the unciean may aiso have emanated from religious and ethical ideas which are oider than Moses’ times. In this matter the thought was decisive, that everything that was impure, everything that suggested death or decay or sin or dispieasure to God, should be Heo separated and apart from the reiigion of Jeh. In ali such cases it is not the newness of the laws but their adaptability to the character and spirit of the Jeh-religion that is to be regarded as the decisive factor. IV. The Significance.—(1) The law contains God's will, although in transitory form. In the art. Ezex1eu under II, 2, (3) we have re- 1. Positive ferred to the fact that Leviticism is an important and necessary stage in the development of true religion, and that the entire OT did not advance heyond this stage and was not in- tended to go beyond it. The leading prophets (sa 40 ff, Jer, Ezk), even in their visions of the future, cling to the temple, sacrifices, holy obla- tions, sacred seasons and persons. Christianity was the first to discard this external shell, after it had ripened the kernel that was concealed in this shell (cf worship in the spirit and in the truth, Jn 4 20-24). Down to this time, kernel and shell were inseparably united. This must not be for- gotten, if we would appreciate the Book of Lev properly. It is true that this book to a large extent deals with laws and ordinances, to which we Chris- tians should not and need not return (cf the voice from heaven to Peter, Acts 10 15, ‘‘What God hath cleansed, make not thou common,” and Paul’s opposition to all work-righteousness that was based on compliance with these external institutions, e.g. in Rom, Gal, Col, as also his independent atti- | tude over against the Jewish law in those cases where it could not be taken into consideration as the way to salvation; cf Acts 21 17 ff; Rom 14 1ff; 1 Cor 9 19ff). But these laws and ordi- nances were something more than merely external matters, since they contained the highest religious thoughts. We surely should not forget from the outset that Lev 19 contains also the word, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself” (ver 18), a command which in vs 33f is even made to cover the strangers too, and which by Jesus, next to the absolute love demanded for God, is designated as the chief commandment of the law (Mt 22 39); and when in 19 17f the hatred of the brother and desire for revenge on him are forbidden, we already seem to breathe the atmosphere of Christianity. The entire ch 19 is, in addition, as it were, a sermon on almost all of the commandments of the Deca- logue, the abiding authority of which the Christian, after the example and interpretation of Jesus, will at once recognize. But as the Decalogue itself is found inclosed in the specifically Jewish national shell (cf Ex 20 2, exodus out of Egypt; ver 8, Sabbath commandment; ver 12, promise of the holy land; ver 17, slaves), so, too, this is the case in Lev 19 (cf vs 3.6 ff.20-22.23-25.29.30.33 f). But how little the specifically Levitical ordinances, in the narrower sense of the term, exclude the spirit- ual factor, and how closely they are interwoven with the deepest of thoughts, can be seen from ch 26, according to which all merely external sacrifices, into which formalism naturally the Levitical legal code could degenerate, do not protect from punish- ment, if the heart remains uncircumcised (vs 30 f.41), Leviticus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1880 Libnah Above all, there are four leading thoughts which are emphasized forcibly, particularly by the legal system of PC. In reality all times, all places, all property, all persons are sacred to God. But as it is impossible that this ideal should be realized in view of the imperfections and guilt of man, it was decided that certain particular seasons and places, gifts and persons should be separated from others, and that in these this sacredness should be realized as far as possible, and that these repre- sentatives should by their mere existence contin- ually remind the people of God’s more compre- hensive claims, and at the same time arouse and maintain the consciousness that their entire life was to be saturated by the thoughts of a holy God and His demands. From this point of view, none of the particular laws are worthless; and when they are once appreciated in this their central signifi- cance, we can understand that each law has its share in the eternal authority of the law (cf Mt 5 17f). Paul, too, who absolutely rejects the law as a way to salvation expresses no doubt that the law really contains the will of God (Rom 8 31); and he declares that it was the purpose of the send- ing of Jesus, that the demands made upon us by the law should be fulfilled; and in Rom 13 10 he tells us that love is the fulfilment of the law (cf ver 8); and according to Rom 7 12, it is certain that the law is holy and the commafidment is holy, righteous and good. (2) The law prepares for the understanding of Christianity But the ceremonial law, too, con- tains not only the demands of God’s will. It pre- pares also for the understanding of the work, the person and the mission of Jesus. In Ex 25 8; 29 45f; 40 34 ff the indwelling of God in the tent of meeting is declared, which prophesied the incarna- tion of God in Christ Jesus (Jn 1 14); and then the indwelling of God through the Holy Ghost in the Christian congregation (1 Pet 25; Eph 4 12) and in the individual (1 Cor 3 16; 6 19; 2 Cor 616; Jn 14 23). Through the sacrificial system in Lev 1-7, and the ordinances of the Day of Atonement (Lev 16), we are enabled to understand the character of sin, of grace and of the forgiveness of sin (cf AronemENT, Day or, TT). Let us remem- ber to what extent Jesus and Paul, the Ep. to the He, and the other NT writings operate with OT thoughts, particularly with those of Lev (priest- hood, sacrifices, atonement, Passover, signification of blood, etc), and Paul correctly says that the righteousness of God was prophesied, not only by the prophets, but also by the law (Rom 3 21). (8) The law as a tutor unto Christ—Finally, the ceremonial law too has the purpose to protect Israel from the errors of the heathen, a thought that, is esp. emphasized in the Law of Holiness (cf Lev 18 3.24 ff; 19 26 ff; 20 2 ff.22 ff; 26 1) and which is in harmony with the elementary stage of Israel’s education in the OT, when the people still stood in need of the “tutor... . unto Christ” (Gal 3 23f; 41). This already leads us over to the negative side, which Paul particularly emphasizes. The law is in itself holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good (Rom 7 12), but it has lost its power because the flesh 2. Negative of man is sinful (cf Rom 8 3); and thus it happens that the law is the occasion for sin and leads to a knowledge of sin and to an increase of sin (cf Rom 3 20; 4 15; 5 20; 7 13); and this shall be brought about according to the purposes of God in order that in upright hearts the desire for forgiveness should arise. It is true that nothing was so well adapted as were the details of the law, to bring to consciousness in the untutored mind that in which man yet came short of the Divine commands, And as far as the removal of the guilt was concerned, nothing was needed except the reference to this in order to make men feel their imperfections (cf He 7-10). God merely out of grace was for the time being con- tented with the blood of goats and of calves as a means for atonement; He was already counting on the forgiveness in Christ (Rom 3 25). All the sacrifices in Lev 1-7, e.g., did not make the ritual of the Day of Atonement superfluous (Lev 16); and in this case the very man who brought the sac- rifice was also a sinful creature who must first secure the forgiveness of God for himself. Only Jesus, at once the perfect priest and the perfect sacrifice, has achieved the perfect redemption. It according- ly remains a fact that the righteousness which avails before God can be secured only through faith in Jesus Christ, and not through the deeds of the law (Rom and Gal). _ The law with its incomplete atonement and with its arousing of the consciousness of sin drives man to Jesus; and this is its negative significance. Jesus, however, who Himself has fulfilled the de- mands of the law, gives us through His spirit the power, that the law with its demands (1, [1] above) may no longer stand threateningly over against us, but is now written in our hearts. In this way the OT law is fulfilled in its transitory form, and at the same time becomes superfluous, after its eternal contents have been recognized, maintained and surpassed. LitERaTURE.—Comms. by Ryssel, Lange, Keil, Strack, Baentsch, Bertholet; esp. for the Law of Holi- ness see Horst, Lev 17-26 and Ezk; Wurster, ZATW, 1884, 112 ff; Baentsch, Das Hetlighkeitsgesetz; Kloster- mann, Der Pentateuch, 368ff; Delitasch, Zettschrift fur kirch. Wissenschaft und Leben, 1880, 617 ff; Intros to the OT by Baudissin, Strack, Kuenen, Kénig, Cornill, Driver, Sellin; Archaeology, by_Benzinger, Nowack; History of Israel, by K6hler, Konig, Kittel, Octtli, Klostermann, Stade, Wellhausen; for kindred laws in Babylonia, cf Zimmern, Bettrdge zur Kenntnis der babyl. Religion; against the Graf-Wellhausen hypothesis, Moller, Are the Critics Right? (ib, ‘‘ Literature’'), and art. Ezexie. in this Encyclopaedia; Orr, POT; Wiener, EPC, OP; Hoffmann, Die wichtigsten Instanzen gegen die Graf-Wellhausensche Hypothese; Kegel, Wilh. Vatke und die Graf- Wellhausensche Hypothese. WILHELM M6LLER LEVY, lev’i. See War. LEWD, lid, LEWDNESS, lnd’nes (MAT, zim- mah, ATA, mzimmah, NND2, nabhlath; wovnpéds, ponérés, padiotpynpa, rhadioirgéma): There are three Heb words tr? “lewd,’’ “lewd- ness”: (1) Zimmah, meaning a ‘‘plan,” a ‘‘purpose,”’ so tr’ several times and then shading an the off into “evil plan’’; tr also “heinous crime,” “wicked purpose or device.” It is the most frequent word for “lewdness’’: Eizk 16 27, “lewd way’; found in Jgs 20 6; Ezk 16 27.43.58; 22 9.11; 23 21.27.29.35.44. 48.49; 2413; Hos 69. (2) M*zimmah means a “plan,” generally “{evil] machination’; used only in Jer 11 15, “lewdness.” (3) Nabhlaih, meaning “disgrace” in reference to females. Found only in Hos 2 10, ARVm ‘‘shame.” The word tr? “lewd,’”’ “lewdness’” in AV occurs only twice in the NT, and in each instance is more correctly tr? in RV by another word: 2. Inthe (1) Ponéros, found in Acts 17 5, tr¢in NT ARV “vile.” The Gr word elsewhere is tr? “bad,” “evil,” “grievous,” “‘harm- ful,” “malicious,”’ “wicked.” AV “lewd” gives the wrong impression. The idea of unchastity is not pret in the text or context. (2) Rhadiourgéma ikewise occurs only once, viz. Acts 18 14, and is correctly tr? in RV and ARV “wicked villany.” The thought of impurity or lewdness is foreign to the meaning in this connection. ‘; WittraM Epwarp RaFFety 1881 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Leviticus Libnah LIBANUS, lib’a-nus. See LeBanon. LIBATION, li-ba’shun. See Sacrirtce. LIBERAL, lib’ér-al, LIBERALITY, lib-ér-al’i-ti, LIBERALLY, lib’ér-al-i: The different forms of the word all refer to one who is generous, bountiful, willing and ready to give and to help. Both the Heb words of the OT and the Gr words of the NT tr4 into the Eng. word “liberal” have a deeper and nobler meaning than is generally conveyed by the Eng. word. {in Prov 11 25, the liberal” soul (nephesh berakhah) means a soul that carries a bless- ing. InIsa 32 5, ARV has “bountiful” where AV has “‘liberal,’”’ and in ver 8 “noble” takes the place of “liberal’’ (nadhibh). The principal Gr words are dm\érys, haplétés, lit. “simplicity,” ‘sincerity,’ and ydps, chdris, ‘grace,’ “favor.’ In 1 Cor 16 3, “bounty” substitutes “liberality.” It is well to bear in mind that a Bib. liberality can spring only out of a noble soul, and is Godlike in its genesis and spirit. G. H. Grrserpine LIBERTINES, lib’ér-tinz, li-bdr’ting (AvBeprivor, Libertinoi): These were among Stephen’s oppo- nents: ‘There arose certain of them that were of the synagogue called [the synagogue] of the Liber- tines, and of the Cyrenians, and of the Alexandrians, and of them of Cilicia and Asia, disputing with Stephen” (Acts 6 9). How many synagogues are denoted? The answer may aid in the interpretation of ‘‘Libertines’': (1) The words may be read as denoting one synagogue 4. “Syna- (Calvin). However (a) the number of yu. worshippers would be extremely large, (b) gogue of the bond of union is not obvious, (c) rab- the Liber- _binic tradition speaks of 480 synagogues tines” in Jerus. (2) The double één (‘‘of them") seems to denote two parties, the one con- sisting ‘‘of them that were of the syna- gogue called [the synagogue] of Libertines and Cy- renians and Alexandrians,” the other ‘‘of them_of Cilicia and Asia’? (Winer, Wendt, Holtzmann). But the second tén is dependent on synagogue. ‘'As Cy- renians and Alexandrians both belong to towns... . @ change of designation wonld be necessary when the Jews of whole provinces came to be mentioned: this being the case, the article could not but he repeated, without any reference to the tén before’’ (Alford). (3) There were three synagogues: (a) that of the Liber- tines, (b) that of the Cyrenians and Alexandrians and (c) that ‘‘of them of Cilicia and Asia" (Alford).. There is no grammatical reason for this division, but itis based on an interpretation of ‘Libertines.’ There were ‘‘Libertines,”’ Africans and Asiatics. (4) Each party had a separate synagogue (Schiirer, ausrath). The number of worshippers, their different origin and con- nections, and the number of synagogues in Jerus give weight to this view. (1) They are ‘‘freedmen,”’ liberated slaves or their descendants. Against this it is held that the Gr equivalent (apelettheroi) would have 2. Interpre- been used in this case. However, the tation of Rom designation would be common all “Liber- over the empire. In what sense were tines” they “freedmen’’? Various answers are given: (a) they were freedmen from Jewish servitude (Lightfoot); (b) they were Italian freedmen who had become proselytes; (c) they were “the freedmen of the Romans’’ (Chrysostom), the descendants of Jewish freedmen at Rome who had been expelled by Tiberius. In 63 BC Pompey had taken’ prisoners of war to Rome. These, being liberated by those who had acquired them as slaves, formed a colony on the banks of the Tiber (Philo, Legat. ad Caium). Tacitus relates that the senate decreed (19 AD) that a number of Jewish Liber- tines ‘should be transported to Sardinia, and that the rest should leave Italy, unless they renounced, before a certain day, their profane customs (Ann. ii, 85; see also Jos, Ant, XVIII, iii, 5). Many would naturally seek refuge in Jerus and build there a synagogue. (2) They are an African community, ‘here were two synagogues, one of which was Asiatic. In the other were men from two African towns (Cyrene and Alexandria), therefore the Libertines must have been African also, all forming an African synagogue, Various explanations are given: (a) They were inhabitants of Libertum, a town in Africa proper: an ‘‘Episcopus Ecclesiae Catholicae Libertinensis” sat in the Synod of Carthage (411 AD). (b) Some emend the text; Wetstein and Blass, following the Armenian VS, conjecture Lnbustinén, “of the Libystines.” Schulthess reads for “Libertines and Cyrenians” (Libertinén kat Kiirénatén) ‘Libyans, those about Cyrene’ (Lib- don tin katd Kurénén) (cf Acts 2 10). These emendations are conjectural; the MSS read “Libertines.” It seems, therefore, that 2, (1) (c) above is the correct interpretation. : 8. F. HuntTer LIBERTY, lib’ér-ti (M197, drér, DT, rahabh; KXevdepla, eleutherta): The opposite of servitude or bondage, hence applicable to captives or slaves set free from oppression (thus d‘ror, Lev 26 10; Isa 61 1, etc). Morally, the power which enslaves is sin (Jn 8 34), and liberty consists, not simply in external freedom, or in possession of the formal power of choice, but in deliverance from the darkening of the mind, the tyranny of sinful lusts and the enthral- ment of the will, induced by a morally corrupt state. In a positive respect, it consists in the possession of holiness, with the will and ability to do what is right and good. Such liberty is possible only in a renewed condition of soul, and cannot exist apart from godliness. Even under the OT’ godly men could boast of a measure of such liberty (Ps 119 45, rahabh, ‘“‘room,”’ ‘‘breadth’’), but it is the gospel of Christ. which bestows it in its fulness, in giving a full and clear knowledge of God, discovering the way of forgiveness, supplying the highest motives to holiness and giving the Holy Spirit to destroy the power of sin and to quicken to righteousness. In implanting a new life in the soul, the gospel lifts the believer out of the sphere of external law, and gives him a sense of freedom in his new filial relation to God. Hence the NT expressions about ‘‘the glorious liberty’’ of God’s children (Rom 8 21 AV; ef Gal 2 4; 6 13, etc), about liberty as resulting from the possession of the Spirit (2 Cor 3 17), about “‘the perfect law of liberty” (Jas 1 25). The instrument through which this liberty is imparted is ‘the truth” (Jn 8 82). Christians are earnestly warned not to presume upon, or abuse their liberty in Christ (Gal 6 13; 1 Pet 2.16). Jamus Orr LIBNAH, lib’na (a= , libhnah, ‘‘whiteness,” “transparency,” “pavement” [cf Ex 24 10 where min? , libhnath, is tr¢ “paved work’’ or a ‘‘compact foundation”]; AeBvé, Lebnd): (1) A desert camp of the Israelites between Rimmon-perez and Rissah (Nu 33 20.21). Prob- ably the same as Laban (Dt 1 1). See WanpvEr- ings of IsraEL. (2) A town in the Shephelah of Judah (Josh 15 42). “Joshua passed from Makkedah, and all Israel with him, unto Libnah, and fought against Libnah: and Jeh delivered it also, and the king thereof, into the hand of Israel... .. And Joshua passed from Libnah, and all Israel with him, unto Lachish, and encamped against it, and fought against it’? (Josh 10 29-31; 1215). It was one of the cities given to the ‘‘children of Aaron’”’ (Josh 21 18; 1 Ch 6 57). In the reign of Joram, Lib- nah joined the Edomites in a revolt against the king of Judah (2 K 8 22; 2 Ch 21 10). In the reign of Hezekiah, Libnah was besieged by Sennacherib (2 K 19 8; Isa 37 8). The wife of King Josiah Libni Libraries THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1882 was “Hamutal the daughter of Jeremiah of Lib- nah,” she was the mother of Jehoahaz and Zede- kiah (2 K 23 31; 24 18; Jer 52 1). The site of this important stronghold remains unknown. In the Onom it is described, under the name Lobana or Lobna, as near Eleutheropolis (Beit Jebrin). All the indications point to a site in the S.W. of the Shephelah, not very far from Laehish. The Palestine Exploration Fund sur- veyors suggested (PEF, III, 259) the commanding site ‘Ardk el Menshtyeh, or rather the white chalky mound 250 ft. high to the N. of this village, and Stanley proposed Tell es Safi. (Both these identi- fications are due to the interpretation of Libnah as meaning ‘“‘whiteness.’’) In the PEFS (1897, Sh XX) Conder suggests a ruin called el Bendéwy, 10 miles 8.E. of Lachish. E. W. G. MastermMan LIBNI, lib’nt (772, libhni): (1) Son of Gershon (Ex 6 17; Nu 3 18; 1 Ch 6 17.20). Families who traced their descent from Libni are called Libnites (Nu 3 21; 26 58). (2) A son of Merari (1 Ch 6 29). See Lanan. LIBNITES, lib’nits (750, ha-libhni). Lipn1. See LIBRARIES, li’bra-riz, li’brér-iz: . The Bible a Library Mythological and_Apocryphal Librarles . Libraries for the Dead Memory Libraries Prehistoric and Primitive Libraries Mesopotamian Period . Patriarchal Period Egyptian Period . The Exodus . Palestine at the Conquest . Period of the Judges . Saul to the Maccabees 13. NT Times 14. Bookcases and Buildings LiITeERaTuRE A library is a book or books kept for use, not for sale. A one-book library is just as much a library as a one-cell animal is animal. The earliest libra- ries, like the earliest plants and animals, were very simple, consisting of a few books or perhaps only a single tablet or manuscript. An arehive is a library of official documents not in active use; a registry, a library of going documents. The Bible is itself a library. During the Middle Ages it was eommonly ealled, first, “The Divine Library,” and then, ‘The Library” ered NE SOHN DOR WN 1. The (Bibliotheca), in the same exclusive Bible a sense as it isnow known as ‘‘The Book” Library (Biblia as Lat sing.). Even the word “Bible” itself is historically “Library” rather than “Book” (for it was originally the neuter pl. Biblia, “The Books’’; cf Dnl 9 2). The Bible is also a library in that it is an organized colleetion of books rather than a single work. This fact that the Bible is itself a library is in- ereasingly mentioned of late, esp. in OT studies (Kent, Narratives of the Beginnings of Heb History, 1, “The Old Testament as a Library’; Delitasch, Babel and Bible, 4, ‘the Old Testament, that small library of books of the most multifarious kind”). Its profound bearing on the theory of the composi- tion and inspiration of the Bible (ef Boor) has given the fact new significanee and makes an understand- ing of the nature of a library one of the best tools for the interpretation of the Bible in the face of modern problems. While it is not possible to elabo- rate this within these limits, it may be said briefly that the logical end of the application of the doctrine of evolution to books and libraries is that the Bible is, like man, the result of natural selection, and is as unique among books as man among the animals. And, whatever may be true of men, in the case of books the formation of a book-library by natural selection tends toward the elimination of error. The more numerous the individuals and the longer the period, the greater the reduction of error, so that the logical inference as to the Bible is that on purely natural grounds it may be, or is, the nearest approximation to inerrancy among books, because of its history as a library. “This does not quite lead to the position that the Bible is as unique among books as Jesus Christ among men, but under the doctrine of a creative Providence, it does imply what may be ealled real superhuman authorship and authority. Somewhat apart from historical libraries, but closely connected with Bible study, are the alleged superhuman libraries, libraries of, or written by, the 9. Myth gods, libraries for the dead and apocryphal Ria ytho- libraries. The Vedas are said to have ex- logical and jisted as a collection even before the Creator Apocryphal created Himself (Manu 121). Allreligions Librari have their book-gods—Thoth and Seshait, ibrarles Apollo, Hermes, Minerva, Ida, Bridget, Soma, Brahma, Odin, Kvasir, Ygdrasil and many others. To the ancient Babylonians the whole firmament was a library of ‘celestial tablets.’’ The mythological ideas often have important bearing on Bib. doctrines, e.g. the Creation, the Word, the Tree of Life, the Book of Life, the Holy Spirit. Apocryphal libraries include the library which Jeh is alleged to have formed on the 7th day of creation on a mount E, of the Garden of Eden, and other libraries ascribed to Enoch, Noah and Seth. See for this the OT pseudepigrapha, Another class of collections of real books, written or gathered for mythological purposes, is what_ may be called libraries for the dead. It is well 3. Libra- known that in most countries of antiquity, ries for at one time or another, and among primi- 1e tive people like the American Indians, in the Dead modern times, it has been the custom to bury with the dead the things which friends thought would be useful in the Elysian fields or happy hunting grounds, or on the way thither—the bow and horse of the warrior, the ushebti servants, children's playthings, the models of food objects, and so on. This same motive led also to the burying of books with the dead. For long periods in the histor of Egypt every Egyptian of any position was buried wit! one or more books. These books were not his chance possessions, buried with' him as, in some burials, all & man's personal belongings are, but books selected for their usefulness to him after death. For the most part these were of the nature of guidebooks to the way to the heavenly world, magic formulae for the opening of doors, instruction as to the right method of progress toward, or introduction into, paradise, etc. These books were afterward gathered together aud form what is now known as ‘‘the Book of the Dead’' and other such books. In modern times the actor or professional story-teller often has in memory a collection of remembered books which is in effect a library. Among primi- 4. Memory tive peoples the medicine-man was lit. a = i library of tribal traditions. The priests Libraries of India and the minstrels of Greece or of the Middle Ages often had a large reper- tory. By the prevailing theory of the origin of the books of the OT such memory traditions, transmitted orally, were the chief source of the Hex, but in view of what is now known of the library situation of the time, this must be doubted. In general terms it may be said that when man began not only to make but to keep records, libraries began. Even a memorial stone contains the germ 5. Pre~ of a mnemonic library. The primitive * ze medicine-man's collection of notched historic and message sticks, tallies, quipus or wampum Primitive belts is a great advance in complexity on Libraries these, and the simplest collection of pic- ture narratives of Hottentot or American eae: Indian, an advance on this. , likhi): A descendant of Manasseh (1 Ch 7 19). LILITH, lil’ith, li/lith. See Nraar-Monstsr. LILY, lili (JWAW, shashen [1 K 7 19], MEWW, shéshannah [2 Ch 4 5; Cant 211; Hos 14 5]; pl. [Cant 2 16; 4 5; 5 18; 62f; 72; Ecclus 39 14; 50 8]; kplvov, krinon [Mt 6 28; Lk 12 27]): The Heb is probably a loan word from the Egyp, the original s-sh-n denoting the lotus-flower, Nymphaea lotus. This was probably the model of the architectural ornament, tr? “lily-work,’”’ which appeared upon the capitals of the columns in the temple porch (1 K 7 19), upon the top of the pillars (ver 22) and upon the turned-back rim of the “molten sea’’ (ver 26). Botanically the word shdshannah, like the similar modern Arab. Susan, included in all probability a great many flowers, and was used in a way at least as wide as the popular use of the Eng. word “‘lily.”’ The expression “lily of the valleys” (Cant 2 1) has nothing to do with the plant of that name; the flowers referred to appear to have been asso- ciated with the rank herbage of the valley bottoms (Cant 4 5); the expression ‘His lips are as lilies” (6 13) might imply a scarlet flower, but more prob- ably m oriental imagery signifies a sweet-scented flower; the sweet scent of the lily is referred to in Ecclus 39 14, and in 50 8 we read of “‘lilies by the rivers of water.” The beauty of the blossom is implied in Hos 14 5, where Jeh promises that repentant Israel shall “blossom as the lily.” A ‘heap of wheat set about with lilies’ (Cant 7 2) probably refers to the smoothed-out piles of newly threshed wheat on the threshing-floors decorated by a circlet of flowers. The reference of Our Lord to the “‘ilies of the field” is probably, like the OT references, quite a general one. The Heb and the Gr very likely include not only any members of the great order Liliaceae, growing in Pal, e.g. asphodel, squill, hyacinth, ornithogalum (‘Star of Bethlehem’’), fritillaria, tulip and_colo- cynth, but also the more showy irises (‘“Tabor lilies,’ “purple irises,” etc) and the beautiful gladioli of the N.O. Irideae and the familiar nar- cissi of the N.O. Amaryllideae. In later Jewish lit. the lily is very frequently referred to symbolically, and a lotus or lily was commonly pictured on several Jewish coins. E. W. G. MastermMan LILY-WORE: The ornament of the capitals on the bronze pillars, Jachin and Boaz, in front of Solomon’s temple (1 K 7 19.22). See Laity; TEMPLE; JACHIN AND Boaz. LIME, lim ({1] ™W, sidh; cf Arab. oL&, shdd, “to plaster”; [2] ""3, gir; ef Arab. A > , jir, ‘“Byp- sum” or “quick-lime”’; [3] "2-"2Q4N, ’abhené-ghir): Sidh is tr4 “lime” in Isa 33 12, ‘And the peoples shall be as the burnings of lime, as thorns cut down, that are burned in the fire,” and in Am 2 1, “He burned the bones of the king of Edom into lime.” It is tr4 “plaster” in Dt 27 2, “Thou shalt set thee up great stones, and plaster them with plaster,” also in Dt 274. Gir is tr? “plaster” m Dnl 5 5, ‘wrote ... . upon the plaster of the wall.” In Isa 27 9 we have, ‘He maketh all the stones of the altar as chalkstones” (abhené-ghir). Everywhere in Pal limestone is at hand which can be converted into lime. The lime-kiln is a thick-walled, cylindrical or conical, roofless structure built of rough stones without mortar, the spaces between the stones being plastered with clay. It is usually built on the side of a hill which is slightly excavated for it, so that the sloping, external wall of the kiln rises much higher from the ground on the lower side than on the upper. The builders leave a passage or tunnel through the base of the thick wall on the lower side. The whole interior is filled with carefully packed fragments of limestone, and large piles of thorny-burnet and other shrubs to serve as fuel are gathered about the kiln. The fuel is intro- duced through the tunnel to the base of the lime- stone in the kiln, and as the fire rises through the mass of broken limestone a strong draft is created. Relays of men are kept busy supplying fuel day and night. By day a column of black smoke rises from the kiln, and at night the flames may be seen Limit Lion THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1894 bursting from the top. Several days are required to reduce the stone to lime, the amount of time depending upon the size of the kiln and upon the nature of the fuel. At the present day, mineral coal imported from Europe is sometimes employed, and requires much less time than the shrubs which are ordinarily used. See CHALKsTONE; Cuay. Aurrep Evy Day LIMIT, lim’it (033, gbhul, “bound’’): Occurs once in Ezk 43 12 (“limit’’ of holy mountain). “Limited” (Ps 78 41) and “‘limiteth” (6pi{w, horizo, He 4 7) are changed in RV to “provoked”’ (m re- tains “limited”) and ‘“‘defineth”’ respectively. LINE, lin (IP, kaw, 53, hebhel): Usually of a measuring line, as Jer 31 39; Ezk 47 3; Zec 1 16 (kaw); Ps 78 55; Am 7 17; Zec 2 1 (hébhel). Other Heb words mean simply a cord or thread (Josh 2 18.21; 1K 715; Ezk 403). In Ps 19 4 (kaw, “Their line is gone out through all the earth’’), the reference is probably still to measure- ment. (the heaven as spanning and bounding the earth), though the LXX, followed by Rom 10 18, takes it as meaning a musical cord (Péyvyos, phthéggos). The ‘‘line,” as measure, suggests a rule of conduct (Isa 28 10). For “line” in Isa 44 13, RV reads “pencil,” m “red ochre” (seredh), andin 2 Cor 10 16, “province,” m “limit” (kanén). Sce also Measurine Linr; Wesicuts anp Mras- URES. Jammus ORR LINEAGE, lin’é-4] (warp, patrid): Found only once in Lk 2 4 (AV, RV ‘family”), and signifying the line of paternal family descent. A word preg- nant in meaning among the Jews, who kept all family records with religious care, as may be seen from the long genealogical records found everywhere in the OT. LINEN, lin’en (73, badh, ‘‘white linen,” used chiefly for priestly robes, 73 , big, “byssus,” a fine white Egyp linen, called in the earlier writings UW, shésh; WD, pesheth, “flax,” [1O, sadhin; Bicros, bissos, o8dviov, othdnion, Alvov, linen, avwSdv, sindén): Thread or cloth made of flax. Ancient Egypt was noted for its fine linen (Gen 41 42; Isa 19 9). From it a large export trade was carried on with surrounding na- 1, History tions, including the Hebrews, who early learned the art of spinning from the Egyptians (Ex 35 25) and continued to rely on them for the finest linen (Prov 7 16; Ezk 27 7). The culture of flax in Pal probably antedated the conquest, for in Josh 2 6 we read of the stalks of flax which Rahab had laid in order upon the roof. Among the Hebrews, as apparently among the Canaanites, the spinning and weaving of linen were carried on by the women (Prov 31 13.19), among whom skill in this work was considered highly praiseworthy (Ex 35 25). One family, the house of Ashbea, attained eminence as workers in linen (1 Ch 4 21; 2 Ch 2 14). Linen was used, not only in the making of gar- ments of the finer kinds and for priests, but also for shrouds, hangings, and possibly for 2. General other purposes in which the most Uses highly prized cloth of antiquity would naturally be desired. The robes of the Heb priests consisted of 4 linen garments, in addition to which the high priest wore garments of other stuffs (Ex 28, 39; 3. Priestly Lev 6 10; 164; 18 2218; Ezk Garments 44 17.18). Egyp priests are said to have worn linen robes (Herod. 31.37). In religious services by others than priests, white linen was also preferred, as in the case of the infant Samuel (1 8 2 18), the Levite singers in the temple (2 Ch 6 12), and even royal person- ages (28614; 1 Ch 16 27). Accordingly, it was ascribed to angels (Ezk 9 2.3.11; 10 2.6.7; Dnl 10 5; 12 6.7). Fine linen, white and pure, is the raiment assigned to the armics which are in heaven following Him who is called Faithful and True (Rev 19 14). It is deemed a fitting symbol of the righteousness and purity of the saints (Rev 19 8). Garments of distinction were generally made of the same material: e.g. those which Pharaoh gave Joseph (Gen 41 42), and those which Mordecai wore (Est 8 15; cf also Lk 16 19). Even a girdle of fine linen could be used by a prophet as a means of attracting attention to his message (Jer 18 1). It is probable that linen wrappers of a coarser quality were used by men (Jgs 14 12.13) and women (Prov 31 22). The use of linen, how- ever, for ordinary purposes probably suggested unbecoming luxury (Isa 3 23; Ezk 16 10.13; cf also Rev 18 12.16). The poorer classes probably wore wrappers made either of unbleached flax or hemp (Ecclus 40 4; Mk 14 51). The use of a mixture called sha‘atnéz, which is defined (Dt 22 11) as linen and wool together, was forbidden in garments. The Egyptians used linen exclusively in wrapping their mummies (Herod. 1.86). many as one hundred yards were used in one band- 5. Shrouds age. Likewise, the Hebrews seem to have preferred this material for wind- ing-sheets for the dead, at least in the days of the NT (Mt 27 59; Mk 15 46; Lk 23 58; Jn 19 40; 20 5ff) and the Talm (Jerus Killayim 9 32b). The use of twisted linen (shésh moshzar) for fine hangings dates back to an early period. It was used in the tabernacle (Ex 26 1; 27 4. Other Garments 6. Hang- 9; 35; 36; 38; Jos, Ant, ITI, vi, 2), ings in the temple (2 Ch 3 14), and no doubt in other places (Mish, Ydma’, i1.4). Linen cords for hangings are mentioned in the description of the palace of Ahasuerus at Shu- shan (Est 1 6). Other uses are suggested, such as for sails, in the imaginary ship to which Tyre is compared (Ezk 27 7), but judging from the extrava- 7. Other gance of the other materials in the Uses ship, it is doubtful whether we may - infer that such valuable material as linen was ever actually used for this purpose. It is more likely, however, that it was used for cover- ings or tapestry (Prov 7 16), and possibly in other instances where an even, durable material was needed, as in making measuring lines (Ezk 40 3). Exta Davis Isaacs LINTEL, lin’tel. See Hovss, IT, 1,(4). LINUS, li’nus (Alves, Linos [2 Tim 4 21)): One of Paul’s friends in Rome during his second and last imprisonment in that city. He was one of the few who remained faithful to the apostle, even when most of the Christians had forsaken him. And writing to Timothy when he realized that his exe- cution could not be very far distant—for he was now ready to be offered, and the time of his depart- ure was at hand (2 Tim 4 6)—he sends greeting to Timothy from four friends whom he names, and Linus is one of them. There is a tradition that Linus was bishop of the church at Rome. “It is perhaps fair to assume, though of course there is no certainty of this, that the consecration of Linus to the government of the Rom church as its first bishop was one of the dying acts of the apostle Paul” (H.D.M. Spence, in Elicott’s NT Comm.on 2 Tim). Irenaeus—bishop of Lyons about 178 AD—in 1895 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Limit Lion his defence of orthodox doctrine against the Gnos- tics ‘‘appeals esp. to the bishops of Rome, as de- positarics of the apostolic tradition.” The list of Irenaeus commences with Linus, whom he identifies with the person of this name mentioned by St. Paul, and whom he states to have been “entrusted with the office of the bishopric by the apostles. .... With the many possibilities of error, no more can safely be assumed of Linus... . than that he held some prominent position in the Rom church” (Lightfoot’s “Dissertation on the Christian Min- istry,” in Comm. on Phil, 220 f). “Considering the great rarity of this Gr mytho- logical name as a proper name for persons, we cau hardly doubt that here, as Irenaeus has directly asserted, the same Rom Christian is meant who, according to ancient tradition, became after Peter and Paul the first bishop of Rome. Among the mythical characters in Apos Const, vii, 46 occurs Ianos ho Klaudias, who is declared to have been ordained by Paul as the first bishop of Rome. He is thus represented as the son or husband of the Claudia whose name comes after hisin 2 Tim 4 21. “These meager statements have been enlarged upon by Eng. investigators. The Claudia mentioned here is, they hold, identical with the one who, according to Mar- tial, married a certain Pudens (85-90 AD), and she, in turn, with the Claudia Rufina from Britain, who is then made out to be a danghter of the British king, Cogidum- nus, or Titus Claudius Cogidubnus. For a refutation of these assumptions, which, even chronologically con- sidered, are impossible, see Lightfoot, St. Clement, I, _ 76-79" (Zahn, Intro to the NT, 20). JoHN RUTHERFURD LION, li’un: (1) Occurring oftenest in the OT is TW, Varyéh, pl. NYS, 'drayoth. Another form, ""W&, ’dr7, pl. DUT, 'drayim, is found less often. Cf oR, dri'él, ‘* Ariel” (Ezr 8 16; Isa 29 1.2.7): Sean , har’él, “upper altar,’’ and Se. drv'él, ‘altar hearth” (Ezk 43 151); TON, ‘aryeh, “Arich” (2 K 15 25); “ORAN, "ar'eli, * Areli”’ and ‘‘ Arelites” (Gen 46 16; Nu 26 17). (2) ""DD. kephir, ‘young lion,’’ often tr? “Hon” (Ps 35 17; Prov 19 12; 28 1, ete). (3) Sou. shahal, tr4 ‘fierce lion" or “lion’’ (Job 4 10; 10 16; 28 8; Hos 5 14). (4) wd, lavish, tra “old lion’’ or “lion” (Job 4 11; Prov 30 30; Isa 30 6). Ct Arab. Gand, leith, “lion”; w>, lavish, ‘ Laish,” or ''Leshem’’ (Josh 19 47; Jgs 18 7.14.27.29); wd, layish, “Laish” (18 25 44; 283815). (5) 45, lebhi, pl. Da, kebha’im, “loness”; also wad, labhi’, and W95, ibhiya’ (Gen 49 9; Nu 28 24; 24 9); cf town in §. of Judah, Lebaoth (Josh 15 32) or Beth- lebaoth (Josh 19 6); also Arab. Bo, labwat, *'lioness"’; Sy) ee hate) (6) “Vid. gar, “454, oor, ‘‘whelp,” with ‘aryéh or a pronoun, e.g. “Jue dah is a lion's whelp,"' gar ‘aryéh (Gen 49 9); “young ones” of the jackal (Lam 4 3). Also wad or bené labhi’, ‘* whelps [sons] of the lioness’’ (Job 4 11); and PPS WDD. kephir 'drayéth, young lion," lit. *'the young of lions” (Jgs 14 5). In Job 28 8, AV has “‘lion's'whelps’’ for yow 32, bené shahac, RV “proud beasts.”’ RVm ‘‘sons of pride’; cf Job 41 34 (Heb 26). (7) Aéwv, lédn, “lion” (2 Tim 4 17; He 11 33; 1 Pet 5 8; Rev 47; 5 5; Wisd 11.17; Ecclus 4 30; 13 19; Bel 31.32.34). (8) oxvuvos, skimnos, ‘'whelp’’ (1 Macc 8 4). 1. Names Lebweh, a town in Coele-Syria. The lion is not found in Pal at the present day, though in ancient times it is known to have inhabited not only Syria and Pal but 2. Natural also Asia Minor and the Balkan pen- History insula, and its fossil remains show that it was contemporary with prehistoric man in Northwestern Europe and Great Britain. Its present range extends throughout Africa, and it is also found in Mesopotamia, Southern Persia, and the border of India. There is some reason to think that it may be found in Arabia, but its occur- rence there remains to be proved. The Asiatic male Jion does not usually have as large a mane as the African, but both belong to one species, Felis leo. Lion (Felis leo). Lions are mentioned in the Bible for their strength (Jgs 14 18), boldness (2 8 17 10), ferocity (Ps 7 2), and stealth (Ps 10 9; Lam 3 10). Therefore in prophetical refer- ences to the millennium, the lion, with the bear, wolf, and leopard, is men- tioned as living in peace with the ox, calf, kid, lamb and the child (Ps 91138; Isa 11 6-8; 665 25). The roaring of the lion is often mentioned (Job 4 10; Ps 104 21; Isa 31 4 [RV “growling”]; Jer 61 38; Ezk 22 25; Hos 1110). Judah is a “lion’s whelp” (Gen 49 9), likewise Dan (Dt 33 22). It is said of certain of David’s warriors (1 Ch 12 8) that their “faces were like the faces of lions.” David’s enemy (Ps 17 12) “‘is like a lion that is greedy of his prey.” ‘The king’s wrath is as the roaring of a lion” (Prov 19 12). God in His wrath is “unto Ephraim as a lion, and as a young lion to the house of Judah” (Hos 5 14). ‘The devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour” (1 Pet 6 8). ‘Lion’ occurs in the figurative language of Ezk, Dnl, and Rev. The figures of lions were used in the decorations of Solomon’s temple and throne (1 K 7 29.36; 10 19f). Nearly all references to the lion are figurative. The only notices of the lion in narrative are of the lion slain by Samson (Jgs 14 5); by David (1 § 17 34f); by Benaiah (28 23 20; 1 Ch 11 22); the prophet slain by a lion (1 K 13 24; also 1 K 20 36); the lions sent by the Lord among the set- tlers in Samaria (2 K 17 25); Daniel in the lions’ den (Dnl 6 16). In all these cases the word used igs ’aryéh or ’dri. The Arab. language boasts hundreds of names for the lion. Many of these are, however, merely adjs. used substantively. The com- 5. Vocabu- monest Arab. names are sab‘, ’asad, lary laith, and labwat, the last two of which are identified above with the Heb layish and labhi’. As in Arab., so in Heb, the richness of the language in this particular gives opportunity for variety of expression, as in Job 4 10.11: “The roaring of the lion [’eryéh], and the voice of the fierce lion [shahal}, 3. Figur- ative 4, Narra- tive Lip THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lit., Sub-apostol. 1896 And the teeth of the young lions [kephirim], are broken. The old lion [layish] perisheth for lack of prey, And the whelps of the lioness [bene labhi’] are scattered abroad.’? In Jgs 14 5-18, not less than three different terms, k*phir ’draydth, ’aryéh, and ’dri, are used of Samson’s lion. Autrrep Exy Day LIP (MDW, saphah, MDW, sepheth, “lip,” “lan- guage,”’ “speech,” “talk” [also “rim,” “border,” “shore,” “bank,” etc], ODW, sdpham, “[upper] lip,” “‘moustache,” “beard”; xeiAos, chetlos, “lip” [also once, ‘‘shore” in the quotation He 11 12= Gen 22 17]): (1) Lips stand in oriental idiom for speech or language, like “mouth,” ‘tongue’ ; there- fore they stand in parallelism. ‘The lip of truth shall be established for ever; but a lying tongue is but for a moment” (Prov 12 19). ‘“To shoot ont the lip” (Ps 22 7) means to make a mocking, contemptuous, scornful face. As the lips are the chief instrument of speech, we find numerous idiomatic phrases for “speaking,” such as: ‘‘the utterance of the lips” (Nu 30 6.8), ‘to proceed out of the lips” (Nu 30 12), ‘to open the lips” (Job 32 20), “‘to go out of the lips” (Ps 17 1). These ex- pressions do not convey, as a rule, the idea that the utterance proceeds merely out of the lips, and that it lacks sincerity and the consent of the heart, but occasionally this is intended, e.g. ‘“This people draw nigh unto me, and with their mouth and with their lips do honor me, but have removed their heart far from me” (Isa 29 13; cf Mt 15 8). The “fruit of the lips’ (Isa 57 19=He 13 15) and “calves of the lips’ (Hos 14 2 AV) designate the praise and thanksgiving due to God. ‘‘Fervent [AV “burning’’] lips” (Prov 26 23) are synonymous with eloquence. ‘‘To refrain the lips’ (Ps 40 9; Prov 10 19) means to keep silence, where the godless or unwise would wish to assert his rights. Numerous other expressions need uo further explana- tion, such as ‘‘perverse lips’' (Prov 4 24), ‘‘uncircum- cised lips’’ (Ex 6 12.30), ‘‘feigned lips" (Ps 17 1), ‘lying lips'’’ (Ps 31 18: Prov I0 18; 12 22), ‘‘ wicked for false] lips” (Prov 17 4), ‘‘unclean lips” (Isa 6 5), “strange (AV ‘‘stammering'’'] lips'' (Isa 28 11), ‘‘flatter- ing lips’ (Ps 12 2.3; Prov 7 21), ‘righteous lips" (Prov 16 13). (2) The Heb word sa@pham is found only in the phrase ‘‘to cover the lip or lips,” which is an ex- pression of mourning, submission and shame. The Oriental covers his lips with his hand or a portion of his garment, when he has been sunk into deep grief and sorrow. He expresses, thereby, that he cannot open his mouth at the visitation of God. Differently, however, from common mourners, Ezekiel was forbidden of God ‘‘to cover his lips” (Ezk 24 17; see also ver 22), i.e. to mourn in the usnal way over Israel’s downfall, as Israel had brought these judgments upon himself. The leper, victim of an incurable disease, walks about with rent clothes and hair disheveled, covering his lips, erying: ‘“Unclean, unclean!’ (Lev 18 45). The thought here is that even the breath of such a one may defile. The prophet calls upon all seers and diviners, to whom God has refused the knowledge of the future, to cover their lips in shame and con- fusion (Mic 8 7). H. L. E. Lurrina LIQUOR, lik’ér: Every sort of intoxicating liquor except the beverage prepared from the juice of the grape (yayin), according to the usage of the OT, is comprehended under the generic term 130, shékhar (cf shakhar, to ‘be drunk’’), rendered “strong drink” (cf Gr sikera in Lk 115). The two terms, yayin and shékhar, “wine” and “strong drink,” are often found together and are used by OT writers as an exhaustive classification of the beverages in use among the ancient Hebrews (Lev 10 9; 18 1 15; Prov 20 1, etc). See Winn; Drinx, STRONG. LIST: A variant of “lust” (see Lust), meaning “to wish,” found in AV of Mt 17 12 || Mk 9 183; Jn 3 8, as tr of Oéd\w, thélo, and in Jas 3 4 as tr of Bobrouar, bovilomai. The last case ERV has ren- dered ‘‘will,”’ and ARV has made the same change throughout. The word is obsolete in modern Eng., but Jn 3 8 is still used proverbially, “The wind bloweth where it listeth.” LITERATURE, lit’ér-a-tir, SUB-APOSTOLIC, sub-ap-os-tol’ik (Christian) : I. Epistie or CLEMENT TO THE CORINTHIANS - Authorship and Date - Occasion and Contents . Apologetic Testimony . Doctrinal Testimony . Office-Bearers and Organization . Ritual wE Didache . Dissepearance and Recovery ate DOV CODD II. 4 Pobre . Standpoint, Authorship and Object . Testimony to NT Writings 5. Contents and Notabilia III. Eristzzs of Ionarivs 1. Author and Date 2. Genuineness 3. Leading Ideas 4. Other Notahilia IV. Episttes or Potycarp 1. Date and Genuineness 2. Occasion and Contents 3. Notahilia V. Papras Fragments 1. Author and Date 2. Testimony to St. Matthew and St. Mark 3. Other Notabilia VI. Epistie or BARNABAS 1. Authorship 2. Date 3. Object and Contents 4. Notabilia VII. Pastor or Hermas 1. Authorship and Date 2. Object and Contents 3. Notabilia VIII. Seconp EpistLte or CLEMENT 1. Nature and Document 2. Date and Authorship 3. Contents 4. Notabilia IX. Aprorooy or ARISTIDES 1. Recovery and Date 2. Contents 3. Notabilia X. Justin Martyr 1. Incidents of Life 2. First Apology 3. Second Apology 4. Dialogue with Trypho the Jew 5. Notabilia Epistte to Dioonetus © 1. Date and Authorship 2. Contents LITERATURE The Sub-apostolic Age is usually held to extend from the death of St. John, the last surviving apostle, about 100 AD, to the death of Polycarp, St. John’s aged disciple (155-56 AD). The Chris- tian literature of this period, although as a whole of only moderate intrmsic value, is of historical interest and importance. This is owing to the light which it throws back on apostolic times, and the testimony borne to Christian life, thought, worship, work and organization during an age when the church was under the guidance, mainly, of men who had been associated with the apostles and who might be supposed, therefore, to know their mind. Some writings are omitted from this review, having been dealt with in previous articles. For the Protevangelium of James and the Gospel and Apocalypse of Peter see APocrYPHAL GOSPELS; ApocryPHAL Acts. For an account of extant fragments of Basilides and Valentinus, see GNosT1- cismM. For pseudo-Clementine writings see Parsr, EristLEs or; Simon Macus. XI, « 1897 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lip Lit., Sub-apostol. I. Epistle of Clement to the Corinthians.—Only the larger part had previously been extant, when the complete ep. was recovered in 1. Author- 1875 by Bryennios, bishop of Nicome- ship and dia. The high honor in which it was Date held by early Christendom is attested (1) by its position in Codex A, at the end of the NT, and in an ancient Syr MS, between the Catholic and Pauline Epp.;, (2) by its being publicly read in many churches down to the 4th cent. (ZH, ITI, 16). The work is anonymous, but sent in the name of the Rom church. Dionysius of Corinth (170 AD) refers to it as written by the agency of (did) Clement (HE, IV, 23); Clement of Alexandria states distinctly the Clementine author- ship (Strom., iv.17). The writer is evidently a leading office-bearer of his church, and is identi- fied with the Clement whom Eusebius designates as third “bishop” (or chief presbyter) of Rome after St. Peter, and as holding office between 92 and 101 AD (HE, III, 34). Clement is further identified by Origen (Comm. on St. John) and in HE, I, 15 with the Clement of Phil 4 3; but the name is too common and the interval too long to render this identity more than possible. Some conjecture the writer to be the consul, Flavius Clemens, whom Domitian (his cousin) put to death in 95 AD for alleged ‘‘atheism,” i.e. probably, profession of Chris- tianity (see Harnack, Gesch. Lit., 1, 253, note 1). But Clement the “bishop” is never otherwise re- ferred to as a martyr, and a member of the imperial family would hardly have been head of the Rom church without so signal a fact being noted by some contemporary or later writer. Lightfoot, with some probability, supposes (Apostolic Fathers, I, 61) that Clement was a “freedman or the son of a freedman, belonging to the household of Flavius Clemens.” From St. Paul’s time (Phil 4 22) the imperial household included Christians; and many slaves were men of culture. To such a Christian freedman’s influence the consul’s conversion may have been due. Internal evidence points to Clem- ent having been a Hellenist Jew or proselyte of Judaism; for he writes with some classical culture and with knowledge of OT history and of the LXX; his style, moreover, has a “strong Hebraistic tinge”’ (Lightfoot, p. 59). The date of the ep. is fixed approximately by a reference to a persecution at Rome in progress or very recent; this persecution (during Clement’s episcopate’) was doubtless that by Domitian in 95 AD. Clement’s Ep. is thus not strictly within the Sub-apostolic Age, but it is uni- formly included in sub-apostolic literature. The occasion was a church feud at Corinth, and the expulsion of some faithful presbyters. The writer . seeks to procure their restoration and 2. Occasion to heal the dissension. He quotes OT and examples of the evil issue of envy and Contents strife, and of the blessedness of humility, submission and concord. He adduces as a pattern the peace and harmony of Nature. In this connection occurs an anticipation of geographi- cal discovery, when the author writes (ch xx) of “the impassable ocean and_ the worlds beyond it’ (cf Seneca, Medea ii.375; Strabo i.4; Plut. Mor. ix.41). St. Paul’s warnings in 1 Cor about party spirit are recalled; a not unworthy echo of 1 Cor 13 is em- bodied; and the erring community is solemnly ad- monished. In the course of the letter, with obvious reference to 1 Cor 15, Clement introduces the resurrection, for which he argues from the OT and from natural analogles. He refers to the phoenix which lives 500 years, and, when dissolution approaches, builds a nest of spices into which it enters to die. As the flesh decays, however, a ‘‘ worm is generated, which is nurtured from the dead bird's Moisture and putteth forth wings.” The fable is men- tioned by Herodotus and Pliny. A lengthy prayer of intercession for “all sorts and conditions of men” is abruptly introduced near the end, in order, presumably, to imbue Corinthian Christians with that charity which they needed and which is the chief incentive to intercession. The ep. closes with a hopeful anticipation of restored concord and peace. Apologetic testimony is found to (1) books of the NT, viz. to the Pauline authorship of 1 Cor; t St. Mark’s Gospel, through which 8. Apolo- (ch xv) he quotes Isa 29 13, repro- getic Testi- ducing St. Mark’s variations from the mony LXX; to Acts, through which he simi- larly quotes (ch xviii) 1 S 13 14; to Rom, Eph, 1 Tim, Tit, Jas, 1 Pet (chs xxxv, xlvi, xxi, 1i, xlvi, xlix, respectively). The ||s between Clement and He are so numerous that the latter work has from early times been ascribed to him by some (HF, VI, 25). But the general type both of thought and of diction is dissimilar; (2) against the Tiibingen theory of essential divergence between the doctrine of St. Peter and of St. Paul. The chief presbyter of Rome could not have been ignorant of such divergence; yet he refers the partisanship of which the two apostles were victims entirely to the Corinthians, not at all to the apostles (ch xlix). Doctrinal testimony is found: (1) to the Trinity, “As God liveth and the Lord Jesus Christ liveth, and the Holy Spirit” (ch lviii); (2) to 4. Doctrinal the personality of Christ, ‘The Lord Testimony Jesus Christ, to whom be the glory and the majesty forever.’ In union and communion with Christ we have life, are sanc- tified, possess love, manifest godliness (ch i, xxxvi) ; (3) to the atonement: Clement ascribes to Christ’s death not merely subjective moral influence, but objective vicarious efficacy in securing our salvation, without any attempt, however, to explain the mys- tery. Christ hath “given his flesh for our flesh, his life for our lives” (ch xlix); (4) to justification which is distinctly enunciated as before God through faith (ch xxxii). But this faith (as in St. Paul’s writings) is a “faith which worketh” (ch xxxv), and such justification is consistent with our being justified by works before men; (5) to the inspiration of Scrip- ture, which is real (“the Holy Spirit saith’), but not verbal; for quotations are often inexact. Apocry- phal books are quoted, but not with a formula indicating Divine authority. ; (1) The basis of authority is not sacerdotal, but a combination of official succession and popular call; office-bearers are appointed “by 5. Office- the apostles or afterward by men of Bearers and repute with consent of the whole Organiza-_ ecclesia.”’ (2) Clement indicates no tion distinction between presbyter and bishop. Office-bearers designated as presbyters (chs xlvii, liv) are referred to (chs xlii, xliv) as filling the office of bishop. Addressing a church on congregational strife and insubordination, he refers to no single bishop in authority over the church. Had the episcopate, in the post-NT sense of mono-episcopate, been apostolically enjoined, surely the injunction would have been obeyed or enforced in Corinth. (3) None the less we discern in Clement’s own position and action the anticipa- tion of the later episcopate. Clement is an example of how, through the personal qualities and ecclesi- astical services of the man, the status of presiding presbyter developed out of seniority into superiority, out of representativeness into official authority. (4) The early germ of the papacy is disclosed in the passage: “If certain persons should be disobedient unto the words spoken by God through us, let them understand that they will entangle themselves in no slight transgression and peril’’ (ch lix). Lit., Sub-apostol. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1898 Such assumption by a revered man like Clement might give no offence, and the Corinthians plainly needed cor- rection. Still we have here the first stage in the process which ultimately issued in the Rom claim to universal spiritual supremacy. The assumption, however, is not grounded on Ciement’s own official position (he speaks always in the 1st person pl.), but on the superior dignity of the Rom church. The later theory of supremacy builds Rom authority on the primacy of St. Peter and his successors; but here the authority of the leading presbyter, in dealing with a provincial church, resis on the suggested primacy of the ecciesia in which he presides. (1) The long prayer (chs lix-lxi) bears internal evidence of liturgical character, through its balanced ; and rhythmical style, its somewhat re- 6. Ritual mote relevance to the special object of : the ep., and greater suitability for con- gregational worship, than as part of a counsel to a sister church. This internal testimony is confirmed by the correspondence of the prayer in certain verbal details with the earliest extant liturgies, particularly those of St. Mark and St. James, pomt- ing to the early use in the Rom church of forms of prayer afterward incorporated into these liturgies. While there is evidence that down at least to the time (148 AD) of Justin’s Ist Apology (ch ]xvii) a, minister offered up prayers of his own composition, this prayer of Clement’s Ep. indicates that before the close of the Apostolic Age, forms of supplication had begun to be introduced, not to the exclusion of “free prayer,” but simply as a mode of congre- gational devotion countenanced by a venerated leader of the church at Rome. (2) In ch Ivi Clem- ent writes abont “compassionate remembrance of them [i.e. the erring brethren] before God and the saints.” By the saints, however, are most probably meant, not the beatified dead, but the living Christian brotherhood, asin 1 Cor 1 2; 2 Cor 8 4. This ep. leaves on readers’ minds two different yet mutually compatihle impressions—impressions both apparently made on the early church, by which the letter was widely read at public worship and yet excluded from the Canon of Scriptures, We realize, on the one hand, ths inferiority of this writing to epp. of apostles. Clem- ent's mind is receptive, not creative; and the freshness of thought characteristic of NT writers is absent. What T book, moreover, contains such a foolish legend as that of the phoenix? On the other hand, this ep. breathes much of the spirit, as it adopts in considerable measure the phraseology and style of apostolic writings. ltis as if, although the sun of special inspiration had sunk below the horizon, there remained to the church for a while a spiritual afterglow. Il. The ‘‘Didache’’ or Teaching (longer title, “The Teaching of the Lord, by [did] the XII Apostles, to the Gentiles” ).—This work is quoted 1. Disap- as “Scripture,” without being named, pearance by Clement of Alexandria (c 170 AD, in and Re- Strom., 1.20). It is mentioned in HE, covery III, 25 as the “Teachings so-called of the Apostles,” “recognized by most ecclesiastical writers,’ although “not a genuine” composition of apostles. Athanasius (Fest. E'p., 39) denies its canonicity, but acknowledges its utility. The latest ancient reference to the work from per- sonal knowledge is by Nicephoros (9th cent.) who includes it among apocryphal writings. Thence- forth it disappears until its recent recovery in 1875 by Bryennios. There is no reliable external testimony to date. Re- semblances too considerable to be accidental exist be- tween the Didache and the Ep. of Barna- 2. Date bas; but opinion is divided asto priority of composition. Lightfoot and others favor a common lost source. As to internal evidence the simplicity of the Eucharist and of baptism as here described, with no formal admission to the catechumenate (ch vii); the use of “bishop” to de- note the same office-bearer as presbyter; and the expectation of an impending Second Advent— point to an early date. On the other hand it is unlikely that a writing which professes to give the Teaching of the Twelve would be issued until all or most apostles had passed away; and the writer seems to be acquainted with writings of St. John (Did., ix.2; x.2; x.5; see Schaff, Oldest Church Manual, 90). Probably the document went through a series of recensions (Harnack in Sch-Herz; Bartlet in DB, V), and the date or dates of composition may be put between 80 and 120 AD. The work does not profess to be written by apostles; but the author seems to be a Jewish Chris- tian, for he calls Friday ‘Prepara- tion Day,” and the style and diction are Hebraic. The work is neither Judaistic nor Ebionite: circumcision, the Sabbath, and special Mosaic ob- servances, areignored. From the book in whole or in part being addressed specially, al- though not exclusively, to Gentiles, we infer that the community among whom it was composed, while mainly Jewish Christian, made special provision for conversion and instruction of Gentiles. The doctrinal standpoint is neither Pauline nor anti- Pauline, but resembles that of Jas. Canon Spence (Teaching) conjectures plausibly that the author may be Simeon, cousin of James the Lord’s brother, who became chief presbyter of the Jewish Christian community, first at Jerus, afterward at Pella, until his martyrdom in 107 AD. Mt was certainly in the writer’s hands; for the Didache contains 22 quotations from, or reminis- cences of, that Gospel, extending over 3. Stand- point, Authorship and Object 4. Testi- ten chs of it. Particularly notable is mony to Did., viti.2, ‘‘Neither pray ye as the NT hypocrites, but as the Lord com- Writirgs manded in His Gospel; after this manner pray ye, Our Father,’ etc (see also vii.1; ix.5; xvi.6). There are also refer- ences to the Gospel of Lk (Did., iii.5, 16); St. John’s writings (see above); Acts (Did., iv.8), Rom (Did., iv.5), 2 Thess (Did., xiv.1), 1 Pet (Did.,i4). No extra-canonical saying of Our Lord is recorded. The contents and notabilia may be examined as follows: (1) Didactic (chs i-vi), intended for cate- chumens in preparation for baptism. 6. Contents This catechetical manual (the earliest an of its kind) opens with the words: Notahilia ‘There are two ways: one of life and one of death” (suggested probably by Jer 21 8). From this text the writer gives a sum- mary of Christian duty esp. toward our neighbor, based on the Decalogue, the Golden Rule, and the Sermon on the Mount, which is frequently quoted. Among notable precepts is a command to fast as well as pray for enemies; a warning against infanticide which, in the case of sickly infants, heathenism approved, and against augury and astrology as generating idolatry; an admonition not to “stretch out one’s hands for receiv- ing and to draw them in for giving"; an injunction to ‘share all things with thy brethren, and not to say that they are thine Own"; a command to ‘‘love some above thine own life’; and a quaint corrective against indis- criminate and ill-informed beneficence: ‘“‘Let thine alms sweat into thy hands until thou know to whom thou shouldest give.’’ , 1d’-‘ammi, “not my people’): The 2d son and 3d child of Gomer bath-Diblaim, wife of the prophet Hosea (Hos 1 9). An earlier child, a daughter, had been named Lo-ruhamah (rary, 1a’-ruhamah, “uncompas- sionated”). The names, like those given by Isaiah to his children, are symbolic, and set forth Hosea’s conviction that Israel has, through sin, forfeited Jeh’s compassion, and can no longer claim His pro- tection. Of the bearers of these names nothing further is known; but their symbolism is alluded to in Hos 2 1.23. This latter passage is quoted by Paul (Rom 9 25f). See Hosea; JEZREEL. Joun A. LEers LOCKS, loks ({i] ME", ¢iith, [2] F728, pera’, [3] MSTA, maklaphah, [4] MBP, brwiccah): See in general the article on Harr. (1) The first word, gicith, means really a tassel, such as is worn by the ‘ews on the four corners of the prayer-shaw! or iallith and on the ’arba‘ kan’photh (Dt 22 12), tré in the NT by xpdowedor, krdspedon (Mt 9 20; 14 36; 23 5; Mk 6 56; Lk 8 44). Once it is applied to a forelock of hair. The prophet Ezckiel, de- scribing his sensations_ which accompanied his vision of Jerus, says; “He put forth the form of a Sce Breab. hand, and took me by a lock of my head; and the Spirit lifted me up between earth and heaven, and brought me in the visions of God to Jerus” (Hzk 8 3), (2) The word pera‘ signifies the unshorn and disheveled locks of the Nazirite (Nu 6 5) or of the priests, the sons of Zadok (Ezk 44 20). (3) The Book of Jgs employs the word mahlaphah when speaking of the “seven locks” of Samson (Jgs 16 13.19), which really represent the plaited (ety- mologically, “interwoven”) strands of hair still worn in our days by youthful Bedouin warriors. (4) Kewiticcah (Cant 5 2.11) means the luxuriant hair of the Heb youth, who was careful of his ex- terior. It is called bushy (RVm “‘curling’’) and black as a raven. AV tr® also the word cammah with “locks” (Cant 4 1; 6 7; Isa 47 2), but RV has corrected this into “veil,’’ leaving the word “Jocks” in Cant 4 1m. H. L. E. Lurerine LOCUST, 1d’kust: The tr of a large number of Heb and Gr words: (1) may ‘arbeh, from v4 ma: rabhah, ''to increase" (cf Arab. G » raba’,’** to increase’’). (2) pybo. sal'am, from ohsolete 7/ py gal'am, "to swallow down,’ “to consume.” (3) San. har- “ow gal (ct Arab. de>) harjal, ‘'to run to the right or ore > ae harjalat, *‘a company of horses” or 1. Names left,” X an “a swarm of locusts,” Cea » harjawan, a kind of locust). (4) DIM. haghabh (cf Arab. YS, hajab, ‘to ow hide,"’ ‘‘to cover’'). (5) DY. gazam (cf Arab. Cy jazam, “to cut off"). (6) Pd, yelek, trom / PPd, ae lakak, ‘‘to lick" (ct Arab. aha! laklak, “‘to dart out the tongue" {used of a serpent]). (7) Son, hasil, “wer from 7/ Son, basal, ‘to devour" (cf Arab. hey; hausal, ‘‘crop” [of a bird]). (8) aaa. gobh, from obso- lete 1/ TUBA, gabhah (cf Arab. gil> jabt, “locust,” Be from f cle, jaba’, ‘to come out of a hole”). (9) Ay. 92bh, from same y/. (10) DYby, eetacal, trom 7/ boy, ¢alal (onomatopoetic), “to tinkle,”’ “to ring’ (cf Arab. he, sall, ‘‘to give a ringing sound” {used of a ww horse’s bit]; cf also Arab. urbe , fann, used of the sound of a drum or piece of metal, also of the humming of flies). (11) dxpis, akris (gen. axpidos, akridos; dim, axpidiov, ak- ridion, wheuce Acridium, a genus of locusts). (1), (2), (3) and (4) constitute the list of clean insects in Lev 11 21f, characterized as “winged creeping things that go upon all fours, 2. Identi- which have legs above their feet, fications wherewith to leap upon the earth.” This manifestly refers to jumping insects of the order Orthoptera, such as locusts, grass- hoppers and crickets, and is in contrast to the un- clean “winged creeping things that go upon all fours,’ which may be taken to denote running Orthoptera, such as cockroaches, mole-crickets and ear-wigs, as well as insects of other orders. ? Arbeh (1) is uniformly tr4 “locust” in RV. AV has usually “locust,” but “grasshopper” in Jgs 6 5; 7 12; Job 39 20; Jer 46 23. LXX has usually dxpls, akris, “locust”; but has potxos, brotichos, ‘‘wingless locust,” in Lev 11 22; 1 K 8 37 (akris in the || passage, 2 Ch 6 28); Nah 3 15; and arrédefos, aitélebos, ‘wingless locust,” in Nah Locust Lo-debar THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1908 . the tihiae of the front legs, and the females have long 317. ’Arbeh occurs (Ex 10 4-19) in the account of the plague of locusts; in the phrase “‘as locusts for multitude” (Jgs 6 5; 7 12); “more than the locusts . . . . innumerable” (Jer 46 23); “The locusts have no king, Yet go they forth all of them hy bands’ (Prov 30 27). ’Arbeh is referred to as a plague in Dt 28 38; 1 K 8 37; 2 Ch 6 28; Ps 78 46; in Joel and in Nah. These references, together with the fact that it is Locust: (1) rae (2) Acridium peregrinum; the most used word, occurring 24 t, warrant us in assuming it to be one of the swarming species, i.e. Pachtylus migratorius or Schistacerca peregrina, which from time to time devastate large regions in the countries bordering on the Mediterranean. Sal'am (2), EV “bald locust,” occurs only in Lev 1i 22. According to Tristram, NBH, the name “bald locust”? was given’ because it is said in the Talm to have a smooth head. It has been thought to be one of the genns Tryzalis (T. unguiculata or T. nasuta), in which the head is greatly elongated. Hargal (3), AV “beetle,” RV “cricket,” being one of the leaping insects, cannot be a beetle. It might be a cricket, but comparison with the Arab. (see supra) favors a locust of some sort. The word occurs only in Lev 11 22. See BEETLE. Haghabh (4) is one of the clean leaping insects of Lev 11 22 (EV “grasshopper”’). The word occurs in four other places, nowhere coupled with the name of another insect. In the report of the spies (Nu 18 33), we bave the expression, ‘‘We were in our own, sight as grasshoppers’; in Eccl 12 5, “The grasshopper shall be a burden”; in lsa 40 22, “It is he that sitteth above the circle of the earth, and the inhabitants thereof are as grasshoppers.” These three passages distinctly favor the rendering “grasshopper” of EV. In the remaining passage (2 Ch 7 13), “.... if I command the locust [EV] to devour the land,” the migratory locust seems to be referred to. Doubtless this as well as other words was loosely used. In Eng. there is no sharp distinction between the words “grasshopper” and “locust.” . The migratory locusts belong to the family Acridiidae, distinguished by short, thick antennae, and hy having the organs of hearing at the hase of the ahdomen. The insects of the family Locustidae are commonly called “grasshoppers,"’ but the same name is applied to thase Acridiidae which are not found In swarms. The Lo- custidae have long, thin antennae, organs of hearing on ovipositors. It may be noted that the insect known in America as the seventeen-year locust, which occasion- ally does extensive damage to trees by laying its eggs in the twigs, is a totally different insect, heing a Cicada of the order Rhynchota. Species of Cicada are found in Pal, but are not considered harmful. The Book of Joel is largely occupied with the description of a plague of locusts. Commentators differ as to whether it should be interpreted liter- ally or allegorically (see JonL). Four names ’arbeh (1), ga@zam (5), yelek (6) and hastl (7), are found in Joel 1 4 and again in 2 25. For the etymology of these names, see 1 above. ; 2 25) is in RV uniformly LXX has indifferently akris and brouchos. ‘' Palmer- worm”’ and ‘‘canker-worm"’ are hoth Old Eng. terms for caterpillars, which are strictly the larvae of lepidop- terous insects, i.e. butterflies and moths. While these four words occur in Joel 1 4 and 2 25, a consideration of the book as a whole does not show that the ravages of four different insect pests are referred to, but rather a single one, and that the locust. These words may therefore be regarded as different names of the locust, referring to different stages of development of the insect. It is true that the words do not occur in quite the same order in 1 4 and in 2 25, but while the former verse indicates a definite succession, the latter does not. If, therefore, all four words refer to the locust, ‘palmer-worm,” “canker-worm,” “caterpillar” and the LXX erusibé, “rust,” are obviously inappro- riate. 2 Gobh (8) is found in the difficult passage (Am 7 1), “. . . . He formed locusts [AV “grasshoppers,’”’ AVm “green worms,” LXX akris] in the beginning of the shooting up of the latter growth”; and (Nah 317) in“. ... thy marshals [are] as the swarms of grasshoppers [Heb gabh gabhay; AV “great grasshoppers’), which encamp in the hedges in the cold day, but when the sun ariseth they flee away, and their place is not known where they are.” The related gébh (9) occurs but once, in Isa 33 4, also a disputed passage, “And your spoil shall be gathered as the caterpillar {hds2l] gathereth: as locusts [gébhim] leap shall men leap upon it.” It is impossible to determine what species is meant, but some kind of locust or grasshopper fits any of these passages. In Dt 28 42, “All thy trees and the fruit of thy ground shall the locust [EV] possess,” we have (10) elagal (LXX erusibé). The same word is tr? in 28 65 and Ps 150 5 bis “cymbals,” in Job 41 7 “‘fish- spears,” and in Isa 18 1 “rustling.” As stated in 1, above, it is an ono- matopoetic word, and in Dt 28 42 Sticksof Dried may well refer to the noise of the the Sculp- wings of a flight of locusts. tures from In the NT we have (11) akris, Kouyunilk “locust,’’ the food of John the Bap- tist (Mt 3 4; Mk 1 6); the same word is used fig. in Rev 9 3.7; and_also in Apoc (Jth 2 20; Wisd 16 9; and see 2 Esd 4 24), _ The swarms of locusts are composed of countless individuals. The statements sometimes made that they darken the sky must not be taken too literally. 1909 They do not produce darkness; but their effect may be like that of a thick cloud. Their movements are largely determined by the wind, 3. Habits and while fields that are in their path may be laid waste, others at one side may not be affected. It is possible by vigorous waving to keep a given tract clear of them, but usually enough men cannot be found to protect the fields from their ravages. Large birds have been known to pass through a flight of locusts with open mouths,-filllng their crops with the insects. Tristram, NHB, relates how he saw the fishes in the Jordan enjoying a similar feast, as the locusts fell Into the stream. The female locust, by means of the ovipositor at the end of her abdomen, digs a hole in the ground, and deposits in it a mass of eggs, which are cemeuted together with a glandular secretion. An effective way of dealing with the locusts is to gather and destroy these egg-masses, and it Is customary for the local governments to offer a substantial reward for a measure of eggs. The young before they can fly are frequently event into pits or ditches dug for the purpose and are burned. _. The young are of the same general shape as the adult insects, differing in being small, black and wingless. The three distinct stages in the metamorphosis of butter- flies and others of the higher insects are not to be dis- tinguished in locusts. They molt about six times, emerging from each molt larger than before. At first there are no wings. After several molts, small and use- less wings are found, but it is only after the last molt that the insects are able to fly. In the early molts the tiny black nymphs are found in patches on the ground, hoppiug out of the way when disturbed. Later they run, until they are able to fly. In all stages they are destructive to vegetation. Some remarkable pictures of their ravages are found in Joel 1 6.7, “For a nation is come up upon my land, strong, and without number; his teeth are the teeth of a lion, and he hath the jaw-teeth of a lioness. He hath laid my vine waste, and barked my fig- tree: he hath made it clean bare, and cast it away; the branches thereof are made white” (see also 2 2-9.20). Locusts are instruments of the wrath of God (Ex 10 4-19; Dt 28 38.42; 2 Ch 713; Ps 78 46; 105 34; Nah 3 15-17; Wisd 4, Figura- 169; Rev 93); they typify an tive invading army (Jer 51 14.27); they are compared with horses (Joel 2 4; Rev 9 7); in Job 39 20, Jeh says of the horse: “Hast thou made him to leap as a locust?” AV “Canst thou make him afraid as a grasshopper?” Locusts are among the “four things which are little upon the earth, but... . are exceeding wise”’ (Prov 30 27). Like the stars and sands of the sea, locusts are a type of that which cannot be numbered (Jgs 65; 7 12; Jer 46 23; Jth 2 20). Grass- hoppers are a symbol of insignificance (Nu 13 33; Eccl 12 5; Isa 40 22; 2 Esd 4 24). The Arabs prepare for food the thorax of the locust, which contains the great wing muscles. They pull off the head, which as it comes away brings with it a mass of the viscera, and they remove the abdomen (or ‘‘tail’’), the legs and the wings. The thoraxes, if not at once eaten, are dried and put away as a store of food for a lean season. The idea of feeding upon locusts when prepared in this way should not be so repellent as the thought of eating the whole iusect. In the light of this it is not incredible that the food of John the Baptist should have been “locusts and wild honey (Mt 3 4). See Insects. a Aurrep E1y Day LOD, LYDDA (79, lédh; At88a, Lridda): Ono and Lod and the towns thereof are said to have been built by Shemed, a Benjamite 1. Scriptural (1 Ch 8 12). The children of Lod, Notices Hadid and Ono, to the number of 725, returned from Babylon with Zerub- babel (Ezr 2 33; Neh 7 37 [721]). The town lay in the Shephelah, perhaps in gé ha-hdrashim, “the valley of craftsmen” (Neh 11 35). In the NT it appears as Lydda. Here the apostle Peter visited the saints and healed the palsied Aeneas 6. Locusts as Food THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Locust Lo-debar (Acts 9 32). Hence he was summoned by mes- sengers from Joppa on the death of Dorcas. The three governments of Aphaerema, Lydda and Ramathaim were added to Judaea from the country of Samaria by King Deme- 2. History trius II (1 Macc 11 34). Lydda pre- from Mac-_ sided over one of the toparchies under cabean Jerus, into which Judaea was divided Times (BJ, TI, iii, 5). After the death of _ Julius Caesar the mhabitants of Lydda and certain other towns, having failed to pay the contributions Cassius demanded, were by him sold into slavery. They were freed by Antony (Ant, XIV, xi, 2; xii, 2). Lydda suffered severely under Cestius Gallus (BJ, U1, xix, 1). Along with Jam- nia it surrendered to Vespasian (BJ, IV, vili, 1). After the fall of Jerus it was noted as a seat of rab- binical learning. The classical name of the city was Diospolis. In the 4th cent. it was connected with the trade in purple. It became the seat of a bishopric, and the bishop of Lydda was present at the Council of Nicaea. At Lydda, in 415 AD, took place the trial of Pelagius for heresy. Under the Moslems it became capital of the province of Filastin, but later it was superseded by er-Ramileh, founded by Khalif Suleiman, whither its inhabitants were removed (Ya'kabi,c 891 AD). Mukaddasi (c 985) says that in Lydda “there is a great mosque in which are wont to assemble large numbers of people from the capital [er-Ramleh] and from the villages around. In Lydda, too, is that wouderful church [of St. George] at the gate of which Christ will slay the antichrist’ (quoted by Guy le Strange, Pal under the Moslems, 493). It was rebuilt by the Crusaders; but was destroyed by Saladin after the battle of Hattin, 1191 AD. It was againrestored; but in 1271 it was sacked by the Mongols, and from this blow it has never recovered. The ancient Lod or Lydda is represented by the modern village of Ludd, on the road to Jerus, about 11 miles 8.E. of Yafa. Itis a station on the Jaffa- 3. Identifi- Jerus Railway. It occupies a picturesque ti a hollow in the plain of Sharon, and is sur- cauon 4nG founded by gardens and orchards, the Description beauty of ‘which intensifies by contrast the squalor of the village. It was the re- uted birthplace of St. George, and here he is said to have Been buried. The one ruin of importance in the place is that of the church which perpetuates his name. The town stood on the great caravan road be- tween Babylon and Egypt, near its intersection with that from Joppa tp Jerus and the East. Its position on these great arteries of commerce meant trade for the inhabitants. ‘‘The manufacture and repair of such requisites for the journey as sacks, saddles and strappings would create the skilled labor in cloth, leather, wood and metal that made the neighborhood once the valley of crafts- men’ (Mackie, HDB, s.v.). Like many other once prosperous cities on these and similar caravan routes, Lydda suffered from diversion of traffic to the sea; and it may be that for none of them is any great revival now possible. Ewine LODDEUS, lod-é’us (Ao8Sets, Loddetis; Swete reads Laadatos with Doldaios as variant in A; AV Daddeus, Saddeus): The captain, who was in the place of the treasury. Ezra sent to him for men who “might execute the priests’ office’ (1 Esd 8 46); called ‘Iddo” in Ezr 8 17. LO-DEBAR, ld’débar, 1é-dé’bar CDT 5, la dhebha@r'y: A place in Gilead where dwelt Machir, ‘son of Ammiel, who sheltered Mephibosheth, son of Saul, after that monarch’s death (2 8 9 4), until he was sent for by David. This same Machir met David with supplies when he fled to Gilead from Absalom (17 27f). Possibly it is the same place as Lidebir in Josh 13 26 (RVm). No cer- tain identification is possible; but Schumacher (Northern ‘Ajlan, 101) found a site with the name Ibdar about 64 miles E. of Umm Keis, N. of the great aqueduct, which may possibly represent the Lodge Logos THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1910 ancient city. Lidebir, at least, seems to be placed on the northern boundary of Gilead. The modern village stands on the southern shoulder of Wady Samar. There is a good spring to the E., a little lower down, while ancient remains are found in the neighborhood. W. Ewine LODGE, loj (77>, lin; xarackyvéw, kataskends, etc): To stay or dwell, temporarily, as for the night (Gen 32 13.21; Nu 228; Josh21AV; 43; Lk 13 19; Mt 21 17, aulizomai), or permanently (Ruth 1 16). In Isa 1 8, “a lodge {mlanah] in a garden of cucumbers,” the meaning is “hut,” ‘“‘cot- tage.” “Evil thoughts” are said to “lodge” in the wicked (Jer 4 14). LOFT: In 1 K 17 23, “chamber.” LOFTILY, lof’ti-li, LOFTINESS, _lof’ti-nes, LOFTY: The first form is only in Ps 73 8, where it means “haughtily,” as if from on high. The second is found only in Jer 48 29, where the loftiness of Moab also means his haughtiness, his groundless self-conceit. Lofty likewise means “haughty,” “lifted up’’ (cf Ps 131 1; Isa 2 11; Prov 30 13). In Isa 26 5 it refers to a self-secure and boastful city. In 57 15 it is used in a good sense of God who really is high and supreme. Isaiah uses the word more than all the other sacred writers put together. changed in RV to " LOG, log, 16g (19, légh, “deepened,” “hollowed out” [Lev 14 10-24]): The smallest liquid or dry measure of the Hebrews, equal to about 1 pint. See WEIGHTS AND M@ASURES. LOGIA, log’i-a, THE (Asya, Ldgia): The word ldgion, which is a dimin. of légos, was regu- larly used of Divine utterances. There 1. The are examples in the classics, the LXX, Word the writings of Josephus and Philo and “Logia” and in four passages in the NT (Acts 7 38; Its History Rom 32; He 612; 1 Pet 4 11) where it is uniformly rendered both in AV and RV “oracles.” It is not, therefore, sur- prising that early Christian writers, who thought of Christ as Divine, applied this term to His sayings also. We find this use, according to the usual inter- pretation, in the title of the lost work of Papias as preserved by Eusebins, Logidn kuriakén exégésis, “Exposition of the Lord’s Logia” (HE, ITI, 39), in that writer’s obscure reference to a Heb or Aram. writing by the apostle Matthew (ib), and in Poly- carp’s Ep. (§7), “the logia of the Lord.” The modern use of the word is twofold: (a) as the name of the document referred to by Papias which may or may not be the Q of recent inquirers; (b) as the name of recently discovered sayings ascribed to Jesus. For the former cf Gospets. The latter is the theme of this article. About 9% miles from the railway station of Beni Mazar, 121 miles from Cairo, a place now called Behnesa marks the site of an 2. The Dis- ancient city named by the Greeks covery of | Oxyrhynchus, from the name of a the Logia sacred fish, the modern binni, which had long been known as a great Chris- tian center in early times and was therefore selected by Messrs. Grenfell and Hunt for exploration in behalf of the Egyp Exploration Fund. They began work on the rnins of the town, January 11, 1897, and on the following day discovered a papyrus leaf inscribed with a number of sayings introduced by the formula légei Fésous, “saith Jesus,’’ some of which were at once seen to be quite new. When excavation was resumed in February, 1903, a second fragment was discovered, which must have belonged to the same or a similar collection, as the formula “saith Jesus’ is employed in exactly the same way, and the sayings exhibit the same mixed character. The first of these two fragments was named by the discoverers logia, but the short preface to the second fragment suggests that the word used in the original title may have been logoi, which is found in Acts 20 35 as the title perhaps of a col- lection of sayings of Jesus used by the apostle Paul. It is convenient, however, to retain logia, at any rate for the present. Other remains of early Chris- tian texts have been found on the same site (cf Aarapua) but none of precisely the same character. The first fragment, found and published in 1897, after- ward referred to as A, is a leaf from a papyrus book measuring in its present state 5} X3% . Descrip- inches and having 42 lines on the two z n Pike pages. As it is broken at the bottom it ion of the is impossible, in the absence of another Texts leaf, to ascertain or even conjecture how mouch has been lost. At the top right- hand corner of one page are the letters idia, dlpha, used as numerals, that is 11, and it has been suggested that this, with other characteristics, marks the page as the first of the two. The uncial writing is assigned to the 3d cent., perhaps to the early part of it. The text is fairly complete except at the end of the third logion, for the five following lines, and at the bottom. The second fragment, henceforth referred to as B, found in 1903 and published in 1904, has also 42 lines, or rather parts of lines, but on only one pase or column, the Christian text being written on the back of a roll the recto of which contained a survey list. The characters of this, too, are uncial, and the date, like that of A, seems to be also the 3d cent., but perhaps a little later. B_is unfortunately very defective, the bit of papyrus being broken vertically throughout, so that several letters are lost at the end of each line, and also horizontally for parts of several lines at the bottom. Seven of these sayings, or logia, inclusive of the preface of B, have or-contain canonical parallels, namely: (1) Al, which coincides with the usual text of Lk 6 42; (2) Ada (according to the editio princeps, 6a), which comes very close to Lk 4 24; (3) A6 (or 7), a 4. Logia variant of Mt § 14; (4) the saying cou- with Canoni- &ined_in the preface of B which resembles Jn 8 52; (5) B2, ll. 7t, ‘The kingdom of cal Parallels heaven ‘is within you,” which reminds us of Lk 17 21; (6) B3, ll. 4f, ‘Many that are first shall be last; and_ the last first," which corresponds to Mk 10 31; cf Mt 19 30; Lk 13 30; (7) B4, ll. 2-5, ‘‘ That which is hidden from thee shall be revealed to thee: for there is nothing hidden that shall not be made manjifest,’’ which is ike Mk 4 22 (cf Mt 10 26; Lk 12 2). These parallels or partial parallels— for some of them exhibit interesting variations—are, with one exception, of synoptic character. The other seven or eight logia, although not without possible echoes of the canonical Gospels in thought and diction, are all non-canonical and with one exception new. Three of them, namely B2 and 3 (apart from the canonical sayings given above) and 5, may be set aside as too uncertain to be of any value. What 5. New is preserved of the first (‘‘Who are they Savi that draw you [MS, us] to the kingdom ?” ayings etc) is indeed very tempting, but the J restoration of the lost matter is too pre- carious for any suggestion to be more than an ingenious conjecture. This is seen by comparing the restoration of this logion by the discoverers, Dr. Swete and Dr. C. Taylor, with that proposed by Deissmann (Licht vom Osten!, 329). While the Eng. scholars take hélké in the sense of ‘‘draw,”’ the German takes it in the sense which it has in the NT, “‘drag,”’ with the result of utter diver- ence as _to the meaning and even the subject of the logion. The logia which remain are undeniably of great interest, although the significance of at least one is ex- ceedingly obscure. The number of the sayings is not certaia. Dr. Taylor has shown that in A2f‘‘and” may couple two distinct utterances brought together by the compiler. If this suggestion is adopted, and if the words after A3 in the editio princeps are regarded as belonging to it and not as the remains of a separate logion, we get the following eight sayings: (1) “Except ye fast to the world [or “from the world”), ye shall in no wise find the kingdom of God” (A2a); (2) ‘Except ye keep the sabbath 1911 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Lodge Logos [Taylor “sabbatize the sabbath”, ye shall not see the Father” (A2b); (3) “I stood in the midst of the world, and in flesh was I seen of them, and I found all men drunken, and none found I athirst among them” (Aa); (4) “My soul grieveth over the sons of men, because they are blind in their heart and see not their wretchedness and their poverty” (the last clause restored by conjecture) (A3b); (5) ‘Wherever there are two they are not without God, and where there is one alone J say I am with him [after Blass]. Raise the stone and [there] thou shalt find me: cleave the wood [Taylor, ‘‘the tree”’] and there am I” (A4); (6) “A physician does not work cures on them that know him” (A5b); (7) ‘Thou hearest with one ear but the other thou hast closed” (largely conjectural but almost certain) (A6); (8) “[There is nothing] buried which shall not be raised” (or “‘known’’) (B4, 1. 5). _Attempts have been made to trace the collec- tion represented by these fragments (assuming that they belong to the same work) to 6. Origin some lost gospel—the Gospel accord- and Char- ing to the Egyptians (Harnack, Van acter of the Manen), the Gospel of the Ebionites Logia or the Gospel of the Twelve Apostles (Zahn), or the Gospel according to the Hebrews (Batiffol), but without decisive re- sult. That there is a connection of some kind with the last-mentioned apocryphal work is evi- dent from the fact that B1 (“Jesus saith, Let not him who seeks . . . . cease until he find Him; and having found Him, let him be amazed; and being amazed he shall reign, and reigning shall rest’) is ascribed by Clement of Alexandria to this writing, but that cannot have been the only source. It was probably one of a number drawn on by the compiler. The latter, so far as B is concerned, represents the sayings as spoken by Jesus to . . . . and Thomas.” In whatever way the gap is supplied—whether by “Philip,” or “Judas” or “‘the other disciples’’—one of the Twelve known as Thomas is clearly referred to as the me- dium or one of the media of transmission. It is possible that the short preface in which this state- ment is made belongs not to the whole collection but to a part of it. The whole work may, as Swete suggests (Expos T, XV, 494), have been entitled ‘Words of Jesus to the Twelve,” and this may have been the portion addressed to Thomas. The other fragment, A, might belong to a section associated with the name of another apostle. In any case the Logia must have formed part of a collection of considerable extent, as we know of material for 24 pages or columns of about 21 or 22 lines each. So far as can be judged the writing was not a gospel in the ordinary sense of that term, but a collection of sayings perhaps bearing considerable resemblance as to the form to the Logia of Matthew mentioned by Papias. The remains of B5, however, show that a saying might be prefaced with introductory matter. Perhaps a short narrative was sometimes appended. The relation to the canonical Gospels cannot he determined Rptenne evidence. The sayings preserved generally exhibit the synoptic type, perhaps more specifically the Lukan type, but Johannine echoes, that is, possible traces of the thought and diction ae prceon eed in the Fourth Gospel, are not absent (cf A, logia 2f, and preface to B). It seems not improhable that the compiler had our four Gospels before him, hut nothing can he proved. There is no distinct sign of heretical influence. The much- debated saying about the wood and the stone (A4b) nndoubtedly lends itself to pantheistic teaching, but can be otherwise understood. Under these circumstances the date of the com- pilation cannot at present be fixed except in a very general way. If our papyri which represent two copies were written, as the discoverers think, in the 8d cent., that fact and the induhitably archaic character of the sayings make it all hut certain that the text as arranged is not later than the 2d cent. To what part of the cent. it is to be assigned is at present undiscoverable. Sanday inclines to about 120 AD, the finders suggest about 140 AD as the terminus ad quem, Zahn dates 160-70 AD, and Dr. Taylor 150-200 AD. Further rescarch may solve these problems, but, with the resources now avail- able, all that can be said is that we have in the Logia of Oxyrhynchus a few glimpses of an early collection of sayings ascribed to Jesus which cir- culated in Egypt in the 3d cent. of great interest and possibly of considerable value, but of com- pletely unknown origin. Lirerators.—Of the extensive literature which has gathered round the Logia—as many as fifty publications relating to A only in the first few months—only a tew can be mentioned here. A was first published in 1897 as a pamphlet and afterward as No. 1 of Oxzyrhynchus Papyrt. aluable articles by Cross and Harnack ap- peared in Expos, ser. V, vol VI, 257 ff, 321 ff, 401 ff, an important lecture by Swete in Expos T, VIII, 544 ff, 568, and a very useful pamphlet by Sanday and Lock in the same year. B appeared In 1904 in pamphlet form and as No. 654 of the Ozyrhynchus Papyri, with a fwiler comm. Dr. OC. Taylor's pamphlets on A and B issued respectively in 1899 and 1905, and Swete's lecture on B, Expos T, XV, 488ff, are of exceptional significance for the study of the subject. Cf also Griffin- hoofe, The Unwritten Sayings of Christ (A only), 55-67; Kilecstermann, Kleine Texte, Nos. 8, pp. 11 f and 11, pp. 17 ff; Resch, Agrapha?, 68-73, 3531; HDB, art. ‘“‘Agrapha,”’ extra vol; also arts. on ‘‘ Unwritten Say- ings’’ in HDB, 1909, and DCG. Witiram Tayitor SmrrH LOGOS, log’os (Adyos, légos): I. Greex SpecoLtation - Heraclitus . Anaxagoras Plato . Aristotle Stoics EBREW ANTICIPATION OF DocTRINE . Word as Revelation of God . Suggestions of Personal Distlnctlons In Delty . Theophanies . Wisdom 5. Targums TIT. ALEXANDRIAN SYNTHESIS Philo IV. Curistian ReaizaTIon 1. Pauline Doctrine 2. Doctrine in Hebrews 3. Doctrine in Fourth Gospel (1) Content of Doctrine (a) Relation of Logos to God (b) Relation of Logos to World (2) Origin of Terminology {a) Hebrew Sonrce {b) Hellenic Source {c) Contrast hetween Philo and John V. Patristic DEVELOPMENT LireRaTURE The doctrine of the Logos has exerted a decisive and far-reaching influence upon speculative and Christian thought. The word has a long history, and the evolution of the idea it embodies is really the unfolding of man’s conception of God. To comprehend the relation of the Deity to the world has been the aim of all religious philosophy. While widely divergent views as to the Divine manifesta- tion have been conceived, from the dawn of West- ern speculation, the Gr word logos has been em- ployed with a certain degree of uniformity by a series of thinkers to express and define the nature and mode of God’s revelation. Logos signifies in classical Gr both ‘“‘reason” and “word.” Though in Bib. Gr the term is mostly employed in the sense of “‘word,”’ we cannot proper- ly dissociate the two significations. Every word implies a thought. It is impossible to imagine a time when God was without thought. Hence thought must be eternal as the Deity. The tr “thought” is probably the best equivalent for the Gr term, since it denotes, on the one hand, the faculty of reason, or the thought inwardly con- ceived in the mind; and, on the other hand, the thought outwardly expressed through the vehicle of language. The two ideas, thought and speech, mobo ms II. PWN Logos THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1912 are indubitably blended in the term logos; and in every employment of the word, in philosophy and Scripture, both notions of thought and its outward expression are intimately connected. In this art. it will be our aim to trace the evo- lution of the doctrine from its earliest appearance in Gr philosophy through its Heb and Alexandrian phases till it attained its richest expression in the writings of the NT, and esp. in the Fourth Gospel. The doctrine may be said to have two stages: a Hellenistic and a Heb; or, more correctly, a pre- Christian and a Christian. The theory of Philo and of the Alexandrian thinkers generally may be regarded as the connecting link between the Gr and the Christian forms of the doctrine. The Gr or pre-Christian speculation on the subject is marked by the names of Heraclitus, Plato and the Stoics. Philo paves the way for the Christian doctrine of Paul, Hebrews and the Johannine Gospel. I. Greek Speculation.—The earliest speculations of the Greeks were occupied with the world of Nature, and the first attempts at philosophy take the shape of a search for some unitary principle to explain the diversity of the universe. Heraclitus was practically the first who sought to account for the order which existed in a world of change . hy a law or ruling principle. This pro- 1.Heraclitus foundest of Gr philosophers saw every-~ thing in a condition of flux. Everything is forever pacing into something else and has an existence only in relation to this process. We cannot say things are: they come into being and pass away. To account for this state of perpetual becoming, Heraclitus was led to seek out a new and primary element from which all things take their rise. This substance he conceived to be, not water or air as previous thinkers had conjectured, but something more subtle, mysterious and potent— fire. This restless, all-consuming and yet all-transform- ing activity—now darting upward as a flame, now sink- ing to an ember and now vanishing as smoke—is for him at once the symbol and essence of life. But it is no arbitrary or lawlesselement. If there is flux everywhere, all change must take place according to ‘‘measure.”’ Reality is an ‘‘attunement’’ of opposites, a tension or harmony of conflicting elements. Heraclitus saw all the mutations of being governed by a rational and un- alterable law. This law he calls sometimes ‘‘Justice,”’ sometimes ‘‘Harmony’’; more frequently “Logos” or “Reason,” and in two passages at least, ‘'God.”’ | Fire, Logos, God are fundamentally the same. It is the eternal energy of the universe pervading all its substance and preserving in unity and harmony the perpetual drift and evolution of phenomenal existence. Though Heraclitus sometimes calls this rational principle God, it is not probable that he attached to it any definite idea of consciousness. The Logos is not above the world or even prior to it. It is im it, its inner pervasive energy sustaining, relating and harmonizing its endless variety. Little was done by the immediate successors of Her- aclitus to develop the doctrine of the Logos, and as the distinction between mind and matter 9. Anax- became more defined, the term nous ‘ superseded that of Logos as the rational agoras force of the world. Anaxagoras was the first thinker who introduced the idea of a supreme intellectual principle which, while independent of the world, governed it. His conception of the nous or ‘mind " is, however, vague and confused, hardly dis- tinguishable from corporeal matter. By the artificial introduction of a power acting externally upon the world, a dualism, which continued throughout Gr phi- losophy, was created. At the same time it is to the merit of Anaxagoras that he was the first to perceive some kind of distinction between mind and matter and to suggest a teleological explanation of the universe. In Plato the idea of a regulative principle reappears. But though the word is frequently used, it is nous and not Logos which determines his concep- 3. Plato tion of the relation of God and the world. : The special doctrine of the Logos does not find definite expression, except perhaps. in the Timaeus, where the word is employed as descrip- tive of the Divine force from which the world has arisen. But if the word does not frequently occur In the dialogues, there is not wanting a basis upon which a Logos-doctrine might be framed; and the conception of archetypal ideas affords a philosophical expression of the relation of God and the world. The idea of a dominating principle of reason was lifted to a higher plane by the distinction which Plato made between the world of sense and the world of thought, to the latter of which God belonged. According to Plato, true reality or absolute being con- sisted of the ‘‘Ideas’’ which he conceived as thoughts residing In the Divine mind before the creation of the world. To these abstract concepts was ascrihed the character of supersensible realities of which in some way the concrete visible things of the world were copies or images. Compared with the ‘‘Ideas,’’ the world of things was a world of shadows. This was the aspect of the Platonic doctrine of ideas which, as we shall see, Philo afterward seized upon, because it best fitted in with his general conception of the transcendence of God and_ His relation to the visible world. Three features of Plato's view ought to be remembered _as having a special significance for our subject: (1) While God is regarded by Plato as the intelligent power by which the world is formed, matter itself is conceived by him as in some sense eternal and partly, intractable. (2) While in the Philebus Plato employs the expression, ‘'the regal principle of intelligence in the nature of God” (vois Ba- gidicas ev TH Tov Atos voc, nous basilikés en té tort Diés phisei), it is doubtful if reason was endowed with personality or was anything more than an attribute of the Divine mind. (3) The ideas are merely models or archetypes after which creation is fashioned. The doctrine of the Logos cannot be said to occupy a distinctive place in the teaching of Aristotle, though the hae does Peer in a oy of * senses (6.2. adpfds Adyos, orthds légos, 4. Aristotle “right insight,”’ the faculty by which the will is trained to proper action). Aristotle sought to solve the fundamental problem of Gr phi- losophy as to how behind the changing multiplicity of appearances an abiding Being is to be thought by means of the concept of development. Plato had regarded the “ideas” as the causes of phenomena—causes different from the objects themselves. Aristotle endeavored to overcome the duality of Plato by representing reality as the essence which contains within itself potentially the phenomena, and unfolds into the particular mani- festations of the sensihle world. This conception has exerted a powerful influence upon subsequent thought, and particularly upon the monotheistic view of the world. At the same time in working it out, the ultimate ‘‘ prime- mover” of Aristotle was not materially different from the idea of ‘‘the Good" of Plato. And inasmuch as God was conceived as pure thought existing apart from the world in eternal blessedness, Aristotle did not suc- ceed in resolving the duality of God and the universe which exercised the Gr mind. It is to the Stoics we must look for thefirst system. atic exposition of the doctrine of the Logos. It is the key to their interpretation of life, 5. Stoics both in the realms of Nature and of f duty. Interested more in ethical than physical problems, they were compelled to seek a eneral metaphysical basis for a rational moral life. ome unitary idea must be found which will over- come the duality between God and the world and remove the opposition between the sensuous and supersensuous which Plato and Aristotle had failed to reconcile. For this end the Logos-doctrine of Heraclitus seemed to present itself as the most satisfactory solution of the problem. The funda- mental thought of the Stoics consequently is that the entire universe forms a single living connected whole and that. all particulars are the determinate forms assumed by the primitive power which they conceived as never-resting, all-pervading fire. This eternal activity or Divine world-power which contains within itself the conditions and processes of all things, they call Logos or God. More par- ticularly as the productive power, the Deity is named the éyos omepparikts, légos spermatrkés, the Seminal Logos or generative principle of the world. This vital energy not only pervades the universe, but unfolds itself into innumerable logot spermatikot or formative forces which energize the manifold phenomena of Nature and life. This subordination of all particulars to the Logos not only constitutes the rational order of the universe but supplies a norm of duty for the regulation of the activities of life. Hence in the moral sphere “to live according to Nature’ is the all-determining jaw of conduct. Il. Hebrew Anticipation of Doctrine.—So far we have traced the development of the Logos-doctrine in Gr philosophy. We have now to note a parallel movement in Heb thought. Though strictly speaking it is incorrect to separate the inner Reason from the outer expression in the term Logos, still in the Hellenistic usage the doctrine was sub- 1913 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Logos stantially a doctrine of Reason, while in Jewish lit. it was more esp. the outward expression or word that was emphasized. The sources of this conception are to be found in the OT and in the post-canonical literature. The God who is made known in Scripture 1. Word as is regarded as one who actively reveals Revelation Himself. He is exhibited therefore of God as making His will known in and by His spoken utterances. The “Word of God” is presented as the creative principle (Gen 13; Ps 33 6); as instrument of judgment (Hos 6 5); as agent of healing (Ps 107 20); and gen- erally as possessor of personal qualities (Isa 55 2; Ps 147 15). Revelation is frequently called the “Word of the Lord,” signifying the spoken as dis- tinct from the written word. _In particular, we may note certain adumbra- tions of distinction of oreens within the Being of God. It is contended that the 2. Sugges- phrase ‘‘Let us make” in Gen points tions of to a plurality of persons in the God- Personal head. This indefinite language of Distinctions Gen is more fully elaned by the in Deity _ priestly ritual in Nu (6 23-26) and in the Psalter. In Jer, Ezr and the vision of Isa (6 2-8) the same idea of Divine plurality is implied, showing that the OT presents a doctrine of God far removed from the sterile monotheism of the Koran (cf Liddon, Divinity of Our Lord, and Kénig). Passing from these indefinite intimations of personal distinction in the inner life of God, we may mention first that series of remarkable apparitions 3. Theopha- commonly known as the theophanies of nies the OT. These representations are de- scribed as the “ Angel of Jeh” or of ‘‘the Covenant”; or as the “Angel of his presence.'’ This angelic appearance is sometimes identified with Jeh (Gen 16 11.13; 32 29-31; Ex 3 2; 13 21), sometimes dis- tinguished from Him (Gen 22 15; 24 7; 28 12); some- times presented in both aspects (Ex 3 6; Zec I 11). We find God revealing Himself in this way to Abraham, Sarah, Lot, Hagar, Jacob, Moses, Joshua, Gideon, Manoah, Who was this angel? The earliest Fathers reply with general unanimity that He was the “ Word”’ or ‘‘Son of God.” But while the earlier church teachers distin- guished between the ‘Angel of the Lord” and the Father, the Arians sought to widen the distinction into a difference of natures, since an invisible Being must be higher than one cognizable by the senses. Augustine insists upon the Scriptural truth of the invisihility of God as God, the Son not less than the Father. He will not presume, however, to say which of the Divine persons manifested Himself in this or that instance; and his general doctrine, in which he has been followed by most of the later teachers of the church, is that the theophanies were not direct appearances of a Person of the Godhead, but self-manifestations of God through a created heing. A further development of the conception of a personal Medium of revelation is discernible in the description of Wisdom as given in some of the later 4, Wisdom books of the OT. The wisdom of Jewish Scripture is more than a buman endow- ment or even an attribute of God, and may he said to attain almost to a personal reflex of the Deity, remind- ing us of the archetypal ideas of Plato. In Job, wisdom is represented as existent in God and as communicated in its highest form to man. It is the eternal thought in which the Divine Architect ever heholds His future creation (Job 28 23-27). If in Job wisdom is revealed. only as underlying the laws of the_ universe and not as wholly personal, in the Book of Prov it is coeternal with Jeh and assists Him in creation (Prov 8 22-31). It may be doubtful whether this is the language of a real person or only of a poetic per eo ven: But some- thing more than a personified idea may he inferred from the contents of the sapiential hooks outside the Canon. Sir represents Wisdom as existing from all eternity with God. In Bar and still more in Wisd the Sophia is dis- tinctly personal—‘the very image of the goodness of God.” n this pseudo-Solomonic book, Supe to be the work ofan ‘Alexandrian writer before Philo, the influ- ence of Gr thoughtis traceable. The writer speaks ot God's Word (m2’mera’) as His agent in creation and judgment. Finally in the Tgs, which were popular interpretations or paraphrases of the OT Scripture, there was a tendency to avoid anthropomorphic terms or such 6. Targums expressions as involved a too internal con- ception of God's nature and manifestation. Here the three doctrines of the Word, the Angel, and Wisdom are Introduced as mediating factors between God_and the world. In particular the chasm between the Divine and human is bridged over by the use of such terms as mée'merd’ (‘‘word"’) and shekhindh (‘‘glory'’). The mé’merd’ proceeds from God, and is His messenger In Nature and history. Butit is significant that though the use of this expression implied the felt need of a Me- diator, the Word does not seem to have been actually identified wlth the Messiah. WW, Alexandrian Synthesis.—We have seen that according to Gr thought the Logos was conceived as a rational principle or impersonal energy by means of which the world was fashioned and ordered, while according to Heb thought the Logos was regarded rather as a mediating agent or personal organ of the Divine Being. The Hellenistic doc- trine, in other words, was chiefly a doctrine of the Logos as Reason; the Jewish, a doctrine of the Logos as Word. In the philosophy of Alexandria, of which Philo was an illustrious exponent, the two phases were combined, and Hellenistic speculation Philo was united with Heb tradition for the purpose of showing that the OT taught the true philosophy and embodied all that was highest in Gr reflection. In Philo the two streams meet and flow henceforth in a common bed. The all-pervading Energy of Heraclitus, the arche- typal Ideas of Plato, the purposive Reason of Aristotle, the immanent Order of the Stoics are taken up and fused with the Jewish conception of Jeh who, while transcending all finite existences, is revealed through His intermediatory Word. As the result of this Philonic synthesis, an entirely new idea of God is formulated. While Philo ad- mits the eternity of matter, he rejects the Gr view that the world is eternal, since it denies the creative activity and providence of God. At the same time he separates Divine energy from its manifestations in the world, and is therefore compelled to connect the one with the other by the interposition of sub- ordinate Powers. These Divine forces are the embodiment of the é5éa:, idéai, of Plato and the &yyedot, dggeloi, of the OT. The double meaning of Logos—thought and speech—is made use of by Philo to explain the relation subsisting between the ideal world existing only in the mind of God and the sensible universe which is its visible embodi- ment. He distinguishes, therefore, between_ the Logos inherent in God (Adyos évéideros, Légos endidthetos), corresponding to reason in man, and the Logos which emanates from God (Aéyos mpo- goptxds, légos prophorikés), corresponding to the spoken Word as the revelation of thought. Though in His inner essence God is incomprehensible by any but Himself, He has created the intelligible cosmos by His self-activity. The Word is therefore in Philo the rational order manifested in the visible world. Some special features of the Philonic Logos may be noted: (1) It is distinguished from God as the instrument from the Cause. (2) As instrument by which God makes the world, it isin its nature inter- mediate between God and man. (8) As the ex- pressed thought of God and the rational principle of the visible world, the Logos is “the Eldest or First- born Son of God.” It is the “bond’’ (deopuds, des- més) holding together all things (De Mundi, 1.592), the law which determines the order of the universe and guides the destinies of men and nations (ib). Sometimes Philo calls it the ““Man of God”: or the “Heavenly man,” the immortal father of all noble men; sometimes he calls it ‘‘the Second God,” “the Image of God.” (4) From this it follows that the Logos must be the Mediator between God and man, the “Intercessor” (ixérys, hikétés) or “High Priest,”” who is the ambassador from heaven and interprets God to man. Philo almost exhausts the vocabulary of Heb metaphor in describing the Logos THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1914 Logos. It is ‘manna,’ “bread from heaven,” “the living stream,” the “sword” of Paradise, the guiding “‘cloud,” the “rock” in the wilderness. These various expressions, closely resembling the NT descriptions of Christ, lead us to ask: Is Philo’s Logos a personal being or a pure abstrac- tion? Philo himself seems to waver in his answer, and the Greek and the Jew in him are hopelessly at issue. That he personifies the Logos is implied in the figures he uses; but to maintain its person- ality would have been inconsistent with Philo’s whole view of God and the world. His Jewish faith inclines him to speak of the Logos as personal, while his Gr culture disposes him to an impersonal interpretation. Confronted with this alternative, the Alexandrian wavers in indecision. After all has been said, his Logos really resolves itself into a group of Divine ideas, and is conceived, not as a distinct person, but as the thought of God which is expressed in the rational order of the visible uni- verse. In the speculations of Philo, whose thought is so frequently couched in Bib. language, we have the gropings of a sincere mind after a truth which was disclosed in its fulness only by the revelation of Pentecost. In Philo, Gr philosophy, as has been said, ‘‘stood almost at the door of the Christian church.” Butif the Alexandrian thinker could not create the Christian doctrine, he unconsciously prepared the soil for its acceptance. In this sense his Logos-doctrine has a real value in the evolution of Christian thought. Philo was not, indeed, the master of the apostles, but even if be did nothing more than call forth their antagonism, he helped indirectly to determine the doctrine of Christendom. IV. Christian Realization.—We pass now to consider the import of the term in the NT. Here it signifies usually “utterance,” ‘‘speech” or ‘nar- rative.”’ In reference to God it is used sometimes for a special utterance, or for revelation in general, and even for the medium of revelation—Holy Scripture. In the prologue of the Fourth Gospel it is identified with the personal Christ; and it is this employment of the term in the light of its past history which creates the interest of the problem of the NT doctrine. The author of the Fourth Gospel is not, however, the first NT writer who represents Jesus as the Logos. Though Paul does not actu- 1. Pauline ally use the word in this connection, Doctrine _he has anticipated the Johannine con- ception. Christ is represented by St. Paul as before His advent living a life with God in heaven (Gal 4 4; Rom 10 6). He is conceived as one in whose image earthly beings, and esp. men, were made (1 Cor 117; 15 45-49); and even as participating in the creation (1 Cor 8 6J. In virtue of His distinct being He is called God’s “own Son” (Rom 8 32). Whether Paul was actually conversant with the writings of Philo is disputed (cf Pfleiderer, Urchris- tentum), but already when he wrote to the Colos- sians and Ephesians the influence of Alexandrian speculation was being felt in the church. Incipient Gnosticism, which was an attempt to correlate Christianity with the order of the universe as a whole, was current. Most noticeable are the pointed allusions to gnostic watchwords in Eph 3 19 (“fulness of God’) and in Col 2 3 (‘‘Christ, in whom are all the treasures of wisdom and knowl- edge hidden’’), where Paul shows that everything gonght for in the doctrine of the Pleroma is really given in Christ. The chief object of these epp. 1s to assert the unique dignity and absolute power of the Person of Christ. He is not merely one of the Aeons which make up the Pleroma, as gnostic teachers affirm, but a real and personal Being in whom all the fulness of the Godhead dwells. He is not merely an inferior workman creating glory for a higher Master. He creates for Himself. He is the end as well as the source of all created things (Col 1 15-20). Though throughout this ep. the word “Logos” is never introduced, it is plain that the edxdév, eikén, of Paul is equivalent in rank and function to the Logos of John. Each exists prior to creation, each is equal to God, shares His life and codperates in His work. In the Ep. to the He we have an equally ex- plicit, if not fuller, declaration of the eternal Deity of Christ. Whatever may be said of 2. Doctrine Paul there can be little doubt that the in He- author of He was familiar with the brews Philonic writings. Who this writer was we do not know; but his Philon- ism suggests that he may have been an Alexandrian Jew, possibly even a disciple of Philo. In language seemingly adapted from that source (‘‘Son of God,” “Firstborn,” “above angels,’ “Image of God,” ‘Agent in Creation,” ‘Mediator,’ “Great High Priest,”’ ‘‘Melchizedek’’) the author of He speaks of Christ as a reflection of the majesty and imprint of the nature of God, just as in a seal the impression resembles the stamp. The dignity of His title indicates His essential rank. He is expressly ad- dressed as God; and the expression ‘‘the effulgence of his glory’ (RV dratyacua, apatigasma) implies that He is one with God (He 1 3). By Him the worlds have been made, and all things are upheld by the fiat of His word (ver 3). In the name He bears, in the honors ascribed to Him, in His superiority to angels, in His relationship as Creator both to heaven and earth (ver 10), we recognize (in language which in the letter of it strongly re- minds us of Philo, yet in its spirit is so different) the description of one who though clothed with human nature is no mere subordinate being, but the possessor of all Divine prerogatives and the sharer of the very nature of God Himself. . In the Fourth Gospel the teaching of Paul an the author of He finds its completest expression. “The letter to the He stands in a sense 3. Doctrine half-way between Pauline and Jo- in the hannine teaching’”’ (Weizsacker, A pos- Fourth tolic Age, V,11). It is, however, too Gospel much to say that these three writers represent the successive stages of a single line of development. While all agree in em- phasizing the fact of Christ’s Divine personality and eternal being, Paul represents rather the reli- gious interest, the Ep. to the He the philosophi- cal. In the Johannine Christology the two ele- ments are united. Tn discussing the Johannine doctrine of the Logos we shall speak first of its content and secondly of its terminology. (1) Content of doctrine—The evangelist uses “Logos” 6 t as a designation of the Divine preéxist- ent person of Christ (Jn 1 1.14; 1 Jn 11; Rev 19 13), but he never puts it into the mouth of Christ. The idea which John sought to convey by this term was not essentially different from the conception of Christ as presented by Paul. But the use of the word gave a precision and emphasis to the being of Christ which the writer must have felt was esp. needed by the class of readers for whom his Gospel was intended. The Logos with whom the Fourth Gospel starts isa Person. Read- ers of the Synoptics had long been familiar with the term “Word of God” as equivalent to the Gospel; but the essential purport of John’s Word is Jesus Himself, His Person. We have here an essential change of ening The two applications are indeed connected; but the conception of the per- fect revelation of God in the Gospel passes into 1915 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Logos that of the perfect revelation af the Divine nature He eer (cf Weizsiicker, Apostolic Age, V, ii, In the prologue (which, however, must not be regarded as independent of, or having no integral connection with, the rest of the book) there is stated: (a) the relation of the Logos to God; and (6) the relation of the Logos to the world. (a) Relation of Logos to God: Here the author makes three distinct affirmations: (i) “In the be- ginning was the Word.” The evangelist carries back his history of Our Lord to a point prior to all temporal things. Nothing is said of the origin of the world. As in Gen 1 1, so here there is only implied that the Logos was existent when the world began to be. When as yet nothing was, the Logos was. Though the eternal preéxistence of the Word is not actually stated, it isimplied. (ii) “The Word was with God.” Here His personal existence is more specifically defined. He stands distinct from, yet in eternal fellowship with, God. The preposi- tion prés (bei, Luther) expresses beyond the fact of coexistence that of perpetual intercommunion. John would guard against the idea of mere self- contemplation on the one hand, and entire inde- pendence on the other. It is union, not fusion. (iii) “The Word was God.’”’ He is not merely re- lated eternally, but actually identical in essence with God. The notion of inferiority is emphatically excluded and the true Deity of the Word affirmed. In these three propositions we ascend from His eternal existence to His distinct personality and thence to His substantial Godhead. All that God is the Logos is. Identity, difference, communion are the three phases of the Divine relationship. (b) Relation of Logos to the warld: The Logos is word as well as thought, and therefore there is sug- gested the further idea of communicativeness. Of this self-communication the evangelist_mentions two phases—creation and revelation. The Word unveils Himself through the mediation of objects of sense and also manifests Himself directly. Hence in this section of the prologue (vs 3-5) a threefold division also occurs. (i) He is the Creator of the visible universe. ‘All things were made through him”—a phrase which describes the Logos as the organ of the entire creative activity of God and ex- cludes the idea favored by Plato and Philo that God was only the architect who molded into cosmos previously existing matter. The term ¢yévero, egéneto (‘‘becomes,” werden), implies the successive evolution of the world, a statement not inconsistent with the modern theory of development. (Gi) The Logos is also the source of the intellectual, moral and spiritual fe of man. “In him was life; and the life was the light of men.” He is the light ag well as the life—the fountain of all the manifold forms of being and thought in and by whom all created things subsist, and from whom all derive illumination (cf 1 Jn 1 1-3; also Col 1.17). But inasmuch as the higher phases of intelligent life involve freedom, the Divine Light, though perfect and undiminished in itself, was not comprehended by a world which chose darkness rather than light (vs 5.11). (iii) The climax of Divine revelation is expressed in the statement, “The Word became flesh,” which implies on the one hand the reality of Christ’s humanity, and, on the other, the volun- tariness of His incarnation, but excludes the notion that in becoming man the Logos ceased to be God. Though clothed m flesh, the Logos continues to be the self-manifesting God, and retains, even in human form, the character of the Eternal One. In this third phase is embodied the highest manifestation of the Godhead. In physical creation the power of God is revealed. In the bestowal of light to mankind His wisdom is chiefly manifested. But in the third esp. is His love unveiled. All the per- fections of the Deity are focused and made visible in Christ—the “glory as of the only begotten from the Father, full of grace and truth” (Jn 1 14). Thus the Word reveals the Divine essence. The incarnation makes the life, the light and the love which are eternally present in God manifest to men, As they meet in God, so they meet in Christ. This is the glory which the disciples beheld; the truth to which the Baptist bore witness (ver 7); the fulness whereof His apostles received (ver 16); the entire body of grace and truth by which the werd gives to men the power to become the sons of od. There is Implied throughout that the Word ¢s the Son. Each of these expressions taken separately have led and may lead to error. But combined they correct possible misuse. On the one hand, their union protects us from considering the Logos as a mere abstract imper- sonal quality; and, on the other, saves us from imparting to the Son a lower state or more recent origin than the Father, Each term supplements and protects the other. Taken together they present Christ before His incarnation as at once personally distinct from, yet equal with, the Father—as the eternal life which was with God and was manifested to us. (2) Origin of en TOO have now to ask whence the author of the Fourth Gospel derived the phraseology employed to set forth his Christology. It will be well, however, to distinguish hetween the source of the doctrine itself and the source of the language. For it is possible that Alexandrian philosophy might have suggested the linguistic medium, while the doctrine itself had another origin. Writers like Reuss, Keim, Holtzmann, Weizsicker, Schmiedel, etc, who contend for the Alexandrian derivation of the prologue, are apt to overlook two considerations regarding the Johannine doctrine: (1) There is no essential difference hetween the teaching of John and that of the other apostolic writers; and even when the word ‘‘Logos”’ is not used, as in Paul's case, the. view of Christ's person is virtually that which we find in the Fourth Gospel. (2) The writer himself affirms that his knowledge of Christ was not borrowed from others, hut was derived from personal fellowship with Jesus Himself. ‘‘We heheld his glory, glory as of the only begotten.” This is John's summary and witness upon which he proceeds to hase the vivid memories of Jesus which follow. 'The Johannine doc- trine is not to be regarded merely_as a philosophical account of the nature of God and His creation of the world, but rather as the statement of a helief which already existed in the Christian church and which re- ceived fresh testimony and assurance from the evangel- ist’s own personal experience, ms But the question may still be asked: Even if it was no novel doctrine which John declared, what led him to adopt the Jankuage of the Logos, a word which had not heen employed in this connection by previous Christian writers, but which was prevalent in the philosophical vocahulary of the age? It would he inconceivable that the apostle lighted upon this word by chance or that he selected it without any previous knowledge of its his- tory and value. It may he assumed that waen he speaks of the ‘‘ Word”’ in relation to God and the world, he em- ploys a mode of speech which was already familiar to hose for whom he wrote and of whose general import he himself was well aware. The truth that Jesus of Nazareth was the Christ was borne in upon St. John. The prohlem which confronted him was how he could make that truth reai to his con- temporaries. This he sought to do hy using the language of the highest religious thought of his day. We have seen that the term “Logos” had under- one a twofold and to some extent parallel evolution. On the one hand, it had a Heb and, on the other, a Hellenic history. In which direction are we to look for the immediate source of the Johannine terminology? (a) Hebrew source: As a Palestinian Jew familiar with current Jewish ideas and forms of devout expression, it would be natural for him to adopt a word, or its Gr equivalent, which played so important a part in shaping and expressing the religious beliefs of the OT people. Many scholars consider that we have here the probable source of Johannine language. In the OT, and particularly in the Targums or Jewish paraphrases, the ‘‘Word” . is constantly spoken of as the efficient instrument of Divine action; and the “Word of God” had come to be used in a personal way as almost identical Logos Longevity THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1916 with God Himself. In Rev 19 13, we have ob- viously an adoption of this Heb use of the phrase. Throughout the Gospel there is evinced a decided familiarity and sympathy with the OT teaching, and some expressions would seem to indicate the evangelist’s desire to show that Jesus is the fulfil- ment of Jewish expectation (e.g. 1 14.29.31; 2 19; 3 14; 6 32.48-50), and the living embodiment of Israelitish truth (1 16; 8 12; 11 25; 14 6). But as against this it has been pointed out by Weiz- sicker (Apostolisches Zeitalter) that the Word of God is not conceived in the OT as an independent Being, still less as equivalent for the Messiah, and that the rabbinical doctrine which identifies the memra with God is of much later date. At the same time the Heb cast of thought of the Johannine Gospel and its affinities with Jewish rather than Hellenic modes of expression can hardly be gainsaid. Though John’s knowledgeof andsympathy with Palestinian religion may not actually account for his use of the term ‘‘Logos,” it may have largely colored and directed his special application of it. For, as Neander observes, that name may have been put forward at Ephesus in order to lead those Jews, who were busying themselves with specula- tions on the Logos as the center of all theophanies, to recognize in Christ the Supreme Revelation of God and the fulfilment of their Messianic hopes. (b) Hellenic source: Other writers trace the Johannine ideas and terms to Hellenic philosophy and particularly to Alexandrian influence as represented in Philo. No one can compare the Fourth Gospel with the writings of Philo without noting a remark- able similarity In diction, esp. in the use of the word “Logos.” Jt would be hazardous, however, on this ground alone to impute conscious borrowing to the evangelist. It is more probable that both the Alexandrian thinker and the NT writer were sub- ject to common influences of thought and expression. Hellenism largely colors the views and diction of the early church. St. Paul takes over many words from Gr philosophy. “There is not a single NT writing,” says Harnack (Dogmen-Geschichte, I, 47, n.), ‘“‘which does not betray the influence of the mode of thought and general culture which resulted from the Hellenizing of the Fast.” But, while that is true, it must not be forgotten, as Harnack himself points out, ‘“‘that while the writers of the NT breathe an atmosphere created by Gr culture, the religious ideas in which they live and move come to them from the OT.” It is hardly probable that St. John was directly acquainted with the writings of Philo. But it is more than likely that he was cognizant of the general tenor of his teaching and may have discovered in the language which had floated over from Alexan- dria to Ephesus a suitable vehicle for the utterance of his own beliefs, esp. welcome and intelligible to those who were familiar with Alexandrian modes of thought. But whatever superficial resemblances there may be between Philo and St. John (and they are not few or vague), it must be at once evident that the whole spirit and view of life is fundamentally different. So far from the apostle being a disciple of the Alexandrian or a borrower of his ideas, it would be more correct to say that there is clearly a conscious rejection of the Philonic conception, and that the Logos of John is a deliberate protest against what he must have regarded as the inade- quate and misleading philosophy of Greece. (c) Contrast between Philo and John: The eon- trast between the two writers is much more striking than the resemblance. The distinction is not due merely to the acceptance by the Christian writer of Jesus as the Word, but extends to the whole con- ception of God and His relation to the world which has made Christianity a new power among men. The Logos of Philo is metaphysical, that of John, religious. Philo moves entirely in the region of abstract thought, his idea of God is pure being; John’s thought is concrete and active, moving in a region of life and history. Philo’s Logos is inter- mediate, the instrument which God employs in fashioning the world; John’s Logos is not subsidiary but is Himself God, and as such is not a mere instru- ment, but the prime Agent in creation. According to Philo the Deity is conceived as an architect who forms the world out of already existent matter. According to John the Logos is absolute Creator of all that is, the Source of all being, life and intelli- gence. In Philo the Logos hovers between person- ality and impersonality, and if it is sometimes per- sonified it can hardly be said to have the value of an actual person; in John the personality of the Logos is affirmed from the first and it is of the very essence of his doctrine, the ground of His entire creative energy. The idea of an incarnation is alien to the thought of Philo and impossible in his scheme of the universe; the “Word that has be- come flesh” is the pivot and crown of Johannine teaching. Philo affirms the absolute incompre- hensibility of God; but it is the prime object of the evangelist to declare that God is revealed in Christ and that the Logos is the unveiling through the flesh of man of the self-manifesting Deity. Not- withstanding the personal epithets employed by Philo, his Logos remains a pure abstraction or attribute of God, and it is never brought into rela- tion with human history. John’s Logos, on the other hand, is instinct with life and energy from the beginning, and it is the very heart of his Gospel to declare as the very center of life and history the great historical event of the incarnation which is to recreate the world and reunite God and man. From whatever point of view we compare them, we find that Philo and St. John, while using the same language, give an entirely different value to it. The essential purport of the Johannine Logos is Jesus Christ. The adoption of the term involves its complete transformation. It is baptized with a new spirit and henceforth stands for a new concep- tion. From whatsoever source it was originally derived—from Heb tradition or Hellenic specula- tion—on Christian soil it is a new product. It is neither Gr nor Jewish, it is Christian. The philo- sophical abstraction has become a religious con- ception. Hellenism and Hebrewism have been taken up and fused into a higher unity, and Christ as the emhodiment of the Logos has become the creative power and the world-wide possession of mankind. The most probable view is that Philo and John found the same term eurrent in Jewish and gentile circles and used it to set forth their respective ideas; Philo, following his predilections for Gr philosophy, to give a Hellenic complexion to his theory of the relation of Divine Reason to the universe; John, true to his Heb instincts, seeing in the Logos the climax of that revelation of God to man of which the earlier Jewish theophanies were but partial ex- pressions. There is nothing improbable in ¢ i teaching of Philo gave a reat irguise eto ation ie Logos as Divine Reason which was already shadowed forth in the Bib. doctrine of Wisdom (Westcott). Nor need we tako offence that such an important idea should have come to the Bib. author from an extra-Bib. writer (cf Schmiedel, Johannine Writings), remembering only that the author of the Johannine Gospel was no mechani- cal borrower, but an entirely independent and original thinker who gave to the Logos and the ideas associated Pea bee SAD quotation. ee tributory to the full unfolding of the Gospel’ eos V. Potristic, Development.—The Johannine Logos became the fruitful source of much speculation in gnostic 1917 4 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Logos Longevity circles and among the early Fathers regarding the nature of Christ. The positive truth presented by the Fourth Gospel was once more broken up, and the various elements of which it was the synthesis became the seeds of a number of partial and one-sided theories respecting the relation of the Father and the Son. Tho influence of Gr ideas, which had already begun in the aostone Age, became more pronounced and largely shaped the current of ante-Nicene theology (ses Hatch, Hibbert Lectures). Gnosticism in particular was an attempt to reconcile Christianity with philosophy; but in gnostic systems the term ‘‘Logos"’ ls only sparingly employed. According to Basilides the ‘‘Logos’' was an emanation from the nous as personified Wisdom, which again was directly derived from the Father. Valentinus, in whose teaching Gnos- ticism culminated, taught that Wisdom was the last of a series of Aeons which emanated from the Primal Being, and the Logos was an emanation of the first two princi- les which issued from God—Reason, Faith. ustin artyr, the first of the sub-apostolic Fathers, sought to unite the Scriptural idea of the Logos as Word with the Hellenic idea of Reason. According to him God pro- duced in His own nature a ratlonal power which was His agent in creation and took the form in history of the Divine Man. Christ is the organ of all revelatiuns, and as the Adyos oweppatixds, légos spermatikés, He sows the seeds of virtue and truth among the heathen. All that is true and beautiful in the pagau world ls to be traced to the activity of the Logos before His incarna- tion. Tatian and Theophilus taught essentially the same . doctrine; though m Tatian there is a marked leaning toward Gnosticism, and consequently a tendency to separate the ideal from the historical Christ. oras, who ascribes to the Logos the creation of all things, regarding it in the doubie sense of the Reason of God and the creative energy of the world, has a firm grasp of the Bib. doctrine, which was still mure clearly expressed b Irenaeus, who held that the Son was the essential Word, eternally begotten of the Father and at pnce the inter- preter of God and the Creator of the world. _ The Alexandrian school was shaped hy the threefold influence of Plato, Philo and the Johannine Gospel. Clement of Alexandria views the Son as the Logos of the Father, the Fountain of all intelligence, the Revealer of the Divine Being and the Creator and Mluminator of mankind. He repudiates the idea of the inferiority of the Son, and regards the Logos not as the spoken but as the creative word. Origen seeks to reconcile the two ideas of the eternity and the subordination of the Logos, and is in this sense a mediator between the Arian and more orthodox parties and was appealed to by hoth. According to him the Son is equal in substance with the Father, but there is a difference in essence. While the Father is ‘the Gud" (6 es, ho theés) and “God Him- self’ (avrd8eos, autétheos), the Logos_is “a second God” (Sevrepos Oeés, detiteros theds). In the Nicene Age, under the shaping influence of the powerful mind of Athanasius, and, to a lesser degree, of Basil and the two Gregories, the Logos-doctrine attained its final form in the TEP naDe statement of the Nicene Creed which declared the essential unity, but, at the same time, the rsonal distinction of the Father and Son. The Bouncit of Nicaea practically gathered up the divergent views of the past and established the teaching of the Fourth Gospel as the doctrine of the church. Lrreraturs.—(1) On Gr Logos: Schlelermacher, Herakleitos der Dunkle; Histories of Philosophy, Zeller, Ueberweg, Ritter; Heinze, Die Lehre vom Logos in der Gr Phil. s72); Aall, Gesch. d. Logosidee in d. Gr Phil. 1896). (2 m Jewish doctrine: Oehler, OT Theol. f ' Schiirer, Lehrbuch d. NT Zeitgesch; Schultz, OT Theol. (3) On Alexandrian doctrine: Gfrirer, Philo uw. die alez. Theosophie (1831); Dahne, Gesch, Darstell. der jad.-alez. Religions-Philosophie (1843); Keferstein, Philos Lehre von den géttlichen Mittelwesen (1846); Dor- ner, Entwicklungsgesch. der Lehre_v. d. Person Christi; Siegfried, Philo v, Alex. (1875); Drummond, Philo Ju- daeus (1888); Réville, La doctrine du Logos; Huber, Die Philosophie der Kirchenvdter; Grossmann, Questiones Philoneae (1841); Watson, Philos. Basis of Religion (1907). (4) On Johannine Gospel: Relative comms. of Meyer, Godet, Westcott, Luthardt, E. Scott (1907); Lid- don, Divinity of Our Lord (‘Bampton Lectures,’’ 1866); Watkins, Modern Criticism on_the Fourth Gospel (‘'Bamp- ton Lectures,’’ 1890); Gloag, Intro to Johannine Writings (1891); Stevens, Johannine Theol. (1894); Drummond, Gospel of St, John; Bertling, Der Johan. Logos (1907); Schmiedel, The Johannine Writings (1908); Weizsicker, Apostolic Age, V, ii; Beyschlag and Weiss, Bib. Theol. of NT; Drummond, Via, Veritas, Vita (1894); Hatch, Gr Ideas and Usages, Their Influence upon the Christian Church (Hibbert Lectures, 1888). (5) Patristic_period: Harnack, Dogmen-Gesch.; Baur, Kirchen-Gesch.; Dorner, System d. chr. Glaubenslehre; Lovfs, Lettfaden fir seine Vorlesungen wber Dogmengeschichte; Atzbergen, Die Logoslehre d. heiligen Athanasius (1880). Arcu. B. D. ALEXANDER LOINS, loinz (72%, hala, Aram. PV, harac, n'a, mothen, 20D, kegel, 172, yarékh; orbits, ospiuis): This variety of Heb synonyms seems to be used Athenag- | rather pesmigmously for the loins, though there is no little difference in the secondary meanings of these words. They represent various modes of expressing the loins as the seat of strength and vigor (Job 40 16, Heb méthen, here used of Behemoth), the center of procreative power, the portion of the body which is girded about, and is considered as specially needful of covering, even under primitive conditions of life (Job 31 20), and where painful disease most effectually unfits a man for work and warfare. Jacob receives the Divine promise that “kings shall come out of [his] loins” (hdldc, Gen 36 11), and we read of 66 souls “that came out of his loins’ (yG@rékh) which went into Egypt (46 26). The Ep. to the He speaks of the Levites as having come out. of the loins of Abraham (He 7 5). As the seat of strength (cf Lea; TuicH), the loins are girded with belts of leather (2 K 1 8; Mt 3 4), or cloth, often beautifully embroidered (Ex 28 39), or of costly material (89 29; Jer 13 1f). Girded loins are a sign of readiness for service or endeavor (Ex 1211; 1K 1846; 2 K 4 29; Job 38 3; Prov 3117; Lk 12 35; 1 Pet 1 13)” Of God it is said that. ‘“‘he looseth the bond of kings, and bindeth their Joins with a girdle,” i.e. strength- ens them (Job 12 18). On the loins the sword is worn (2 8 20 8). It is a sign of mourning to gird the loins with sackcloth (1 K 20 32; Isa 32 11; Jer 48 37; Am 8 10; see also the First Papyrus of Elephantine, 1.20). A man whose strength is in his attachment to truth, in other words is faithful, is spoken of as having his loins girt about with truth (Eph 6 14). Thus the Messiah is described: “Righteousness shall be the girdle of his waist, and faithfulness the girdle of his loins” (Isa 11 5). One of the most primitive modes of clothing con- sisted of a fleece tied around the loins (Job 31 20). The condition of unfitness for service is described in that the loins (kesel) are filled with a burning (Ps 38 7, AV “loathsome disease”), or that “a sore burden” is Jaid upon the “loins” (mdthen, 66 11). Thus the loins are made “continually to shake” (69 23), “the joints of [the] loins’ (Adrac) are loosed (Dnl 6 6), the “Joins are filled with anguish” (Isa 21 3). It is very likely that originally a disa- bling lumbago or the painful affections of the gall or the bladder (calculus, etc) are meant, but. very soon the expression becomes merely metaphorical to express personal helplessness, esp. that which can but rely upon assistance and help from God. ‘ H. L. E. Lusrine LOIS, ld’is (Awts, Lois [2 Tim 1 5]): The grand- mother of Timothy, and evidently the mother of Eunice, Timothy’s mother. The family lived at Lystra (Acts 16 1). It was on the occasion of Paul’s first missionary journey (Acts 14) that Eunice and Timothy were converted to Christ, and it was, in all likelihood, on the same occasion that Lois also became a Christian. Paul speaks of the unfeigned faith that there was in Timothy, and he adds that this faith dwelt at the first in ‘thy grand- mother Lois, and thy mother Eunice.” This is the only passage where Lois is mentioned; but by com- paring 2 Tim 1 5 with 2 Tim 3 15 (AV), where Paul refers to Timothy’s having “from a child known the holy scriptures,” it would appear that Lois was associated with Eunice, both in a reverent faith in God and in the careful instruction in the OT which was given to Timothy. See Eunice; TIMoTHY. Joun RuTHERFURD LONGEVITY, lon-jev’i-ti: In the part of Gen ascribed to P, the names and genealogies of the patriarchs are given (Gen 6,11). In the three V8S which are our chief sources, MT, LXX and Sam, the age-numbers given for these patriarchs are hope- Longsuffering Lord’s Day THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 1918 lessly at variance. It is in accord with what we find in the earliest legend of most races that in these chapters a great length of life is ascribed to these; thus Berosus attributes to the first 10 kings of Babylonia a span of 430,000 years, and Hesiod (Works and Days, 129) says that in the Silver Age childhood lasted 100 years, during which a boy was reared and grew up beside his mother. On the other hand the evidence of prehistoric archaeology shows that the rate of development of the individual in the early Stone Age differed very little from that of humanity at the present day. It is possible that, in the case of the Heb record, the names of certain pre-Abrahamic patriarchs were derived from an ancient tradition, and that in the desire to fill up the chronology of the period before the call of Abraham, these names were inserted and the time which was supposed to have elapsed was divided among them, on the basis of some such hypothesis as that which is said to have existed among the Jews, that the Messiah should come 4,000 years after Adam. ; We know from the archaeological evidence that the antiquity of primitive man extends to a date very much farther back than 4,000 years. Indeed, we can prove that before 4000 BC there were settled nationalities both in the valley of the Nile and that of the Euphrates, and that among these the duration of individual life was much the same as at the present day. The first three dynasties in Egypt, starting at or about 4400 BC, consisted of 25 consecutive kings, the average length of whose several reigns was about 30 years. The biographic sketches of Bib. persons other than those in Gen showed that their longevity did not exceed that of our con- temporaries. +o was at 98 blind and feeble. David at 70 was bedridden and frail. Manasseh, the king of Judah whose reign was longest, died at 67; Uzziah at 68. The statement in Ps 90 10 attributed to Moses is a correct esti- mate of what has been the expectation of life at all time. At the present day among Palestinian fellahin very old men are uncommon. I have never seen anyone among them who could prove that he was 80 years of age; the rate of infant mortality is appallingly high. Maturity is earlier, and signs of senility appear among them sooner than among the same class in Great Britain. Atex. MAcALIsTER LONGSUFFERING, long-suf’ér-ing (D7BN JUN, erekh ’appayim; poxpobvpla, makrothumia): The words ’erekh ’appayim, tr? longsuffermg, mean lit. “long of nose” (or ‘‘breathing’’), and, as anger was indicated by rapid, violent breathing through the nostrils, ‘long of anger,” or “slow to wrath.” The adj. is applied to God (Ex 34 6 AV, in the name of Jeh as proclaimed to Moses; Nu 14 18 AV; Ps 86 15 AV; RV “slow to anger,” which is also the tr in other places; AV and RV Neh 9 17; Ps 103 8; 145 8; Prov 16 18; 16 32; Joel 2 13; Jon 4 2; Nah 1 3); it is associated with “great kindness” and ‘‘plenteous in mercy.”” The subst. occurs in Jer 16 15: “Take me not away in thy longsuffering.” In Eccl 7 8, we have ’erekh riith, AV and RV “patient in spirit.” The word in the NT rendered “longsuffering,” makrothumia (once makrothumés, “to be long- suffering’’), which is therendering of ’erekh 'appayim in the LXX, is lit. “long of mind or soul’ (regarded as the seat of the emotions), opposed to shortness of mind or soul, irascibility, impatience, intolerance. It is attributed to God (Rom 2 4; 9 22; 2 Pet 3 9), of His bearing long with sinners and slowness to execute judgment on them. It is, therefore, one of “the fruits of the Spirit”’ in man (Gal 5 22) which Christians are frequently exhorted to cherish | and show one toward the other (Eph 4 2; Col 1 11; 3 12, etc); it belongs, Paul says, to the love, without which all else is nothing: ‘Love suffereth long [makrothumef], and is kind’ (1 Cor 13 4). The vb. makrothumed is sometimes tr¢ by “patience” (Mt 18 26.29, ‘Have patience with me”). Lk 18 7 has been variously rendered; AV has “And shall not God avenge his own elect . . . . though he bear long with them’; RV “and yet he is longsuffering over them,”? ARVm “and is he slow to punish on their behalf?” Weymouth (NT in Modern Speech) has “although he seems slow in taking action on their behalf,” which most probably gives the sense of the passage; in Jas 5 7.8 the vb. occurs thrice, AV “be patient,” “hath long patience”; RV also tr® by ‘‘patient’’; this, however, as in Mt 18 26.29, seems to lose the full force of the Gr word. Ac- cording to Trench (Synonyms of the NT, 189), the difference between hupomoné (“patience”) and makrothumia is that the latter word expresses pa- tience in respect to persons, and the former in re- spect to things; hence hupomoné is never ascribed to God; where He is called ‘‘the God of patience,” itis as He gives it to His servants and saints. But cin Jas & 7 it is used with reference to things, and in Col 1 11 it ig associated with patience (cf He 6 12.15), suggesting patient endurance of trials and sufferings. In Col 1 11 it is also associated with ‘Foy,’ indicating that it is not a mere submissive- ness, but a joyful acceptance of the will of God, whatever it may be. In Wisd 15 1; Ecclus 5 4, we have “longsuffering” (makréthumos) ascribed to God; also in Ecclus 2 11, RV “mercy.” W. L. WALKER LOOK, Id6k: (1) The uses of the simple vb. in EV are nearly all good modern Eng. In Isa 5 2, however, ‘‘He looked that it should bring forth grapes’’—‘look’”’ is used in the sense of “expect.” Cf AV of Sir 20 14; Acts 28 6, “They looked when he should have swollen” (RV ‘‘They expected that he would have swollen’). In 1 Macc 4 54, AV has inserted “look” (omitted in RV) as a simple interjection, without a corresponding word in the Gr. (2) “Look upon” means “‘fix one’s attention on,” and is often so used in EV without further significance (Eccl 2 11; Lk 22 56, etc); but in 2 Ch 24 22 AV and RV, ‘“Jeh look upon it’? means “remember.” However, continual attention given to an object usually denotes that pleasure is found in it, and from this fact such uses as those of Prov 23 31, “Look not thou upon the wine when it is red,” are derived. In particular, God’s ‘looking upon” a person becomes a synonym for “showing favor unto,” asin Dt 26 7 AV; Ps 84 9 AV and RV; 119 132 AV; Lk 1 48 RV only, ete (RV usually re-words in such passages). On the other hand, “look on” may be weakened, as in such phrases as “fair to look upon” (Gen 12 11, etc), where it means only “fair to the sight.” Or, asin modern Eng., “look on” may describe the attitude of the passive spectator, even when applied to God. So Ps 36 17, ‘Lord, how long wiltthoulookon?” (3) “Look to” usually means “‘pay attention to,” asin Prov 14 15; Jer 39 12; 2 Jn ver 8, etc, and RV occasionally uses this phrase in place of AV’s “look upon” (Phil 2 4). The reverse change is made in AV’s 1 8 16 12, “goodly to look to”; Ezk 23 15, “all of them princes to look to,” but in the latter verse a more drastic revision was needed, for the meaning is “all of them in appearance as princes.” ‘Look out” may mean “‘search for’ (Gen 41 33; Acts 6 3), but may also be used lit. (Gen 26 8, etc). AV’s ‘looking after those things’ in Lk 21 26 has been changed by RV into “expectation of the things.” “Look one another in the face’ in 2 K 14 8.11 means ‘meet in battle.” Burron Scorr Easton 1919 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Longsuffering Lord’s Day LOOKING-GLASS, 106k’ing-glas (Ex 38 8 AV, m “brasen glasses”). See Guass; Mirror. LOOM, loom. See Weavina. LOOP, loop (in pl. MDS, lula’oth [Ex 26 41. 10f; 36 11f.17]): A ring or fold made of blue thread to fasten into the corresponding golden clasps, or taches upon the curtains of the tabernacle, joining them in sets, or pairs. See TABERNACLE. LORD, lérd, THE LORD: This Eng. word in our Bible represents one Aram.,3 Gr and 9 Heb words, two of them in two forms. It thus expresses all grades of dignity, honor, and majesty. It is not always possible to be sure of the sense in which the term is to be taken. In Gen 18 3; 19 18, the translators waver between interpreting of the Di- vine Person and a finite angel (cf marginal readings). It represents the most sacred Heb name for God, as their covenant God, Yah, Yahweh, and the more usual designation of Deity, "Adhdndy, ’Adhan, a term which they adopted to avoid pronouncing the most holy designation. They had placed on Lev 24 16 an interpretation that aroused such a dread that they seldom dared use the name at all. When two of the words usually tr? ‘‘Lord,” both referring to God, occur together, AV renders ‘‘Lord God,’ and ARV “Lord Jehovah.” ARV has adopted the rule of using the covenant name transliter- ated, instead of the term ‘Lord,” in which AV adopts the rule of the Hebrews to avoid the holy name. The Aram. designation, Mdr@, occurs only in Dnl (e.g. 2 47; 6 23), and the same word refers to aman (4 24), Of the Gr words, Kiirios is freely used of both the Deity and men. Despétes, of men in classic usage, occurs only of God, including the ascended Jesus, and is employed only 5 t. Megistdnes (pl.) is found once, of men (Mk 6 21). Rabboni (Heb in Gr letters) is applied only to the Christ, and is simply transliterated in RV, but rendered “Lord” in AV (cf Mk 10 51). Our Eng. VSS distinguish the 3 main uses of the term thus: (1) ‘“‘Lorp”’ represents the Heb Yahweh, LXX Kurios, except where ’Adhdndy or ’Adhon is combined with Yahweh (=‘Lord God’); ARV. has in these examples employed the name as it is found in the Heb, simply transliterated. (2) ‘“Lord”’ cor- responds to ’Adhénay, ’Adhén, Maré’, also Gr Kurios (see [1]), and Despotés, for which ARV has always “Master” in either the text or the margin. (8) “Lord” (“lord’’) translates all the remaining 8 Heb words and the Gr words except Despotés. Itis thus seen that Kurios corresponds to all three forms of writing the Eng. term. See JEHOVAH. WittiaM Owen CarvER LORD OF HOSTS: A name or title of God fre- quently used in the OT, always tra “Jeh of Hosts” (MANZE MT, YVehdwah gebha’sth) in ARV, since Yehdwah, never ’Adhdndy, is used in this phrase. Evidently the meaning of the title is that all created agencies and forces are under the leadership or dominion of Jeh, who made and maintains them (Gen 2 1; Isa 45 12). It is used to express Jeh’s great power. See Gop, Names or, II, 8. LORD’S DAY (h xvptaxh hepa, he Ituriaké himéra): Formerly it was supposed that the adj. kuriakos (tr4 “the Lord’s’”) was & 1. Linguis- purely Christian word, but recent dis- tic coveries have proved that it was in fairly common use in the Rom Empire before Christian influence had been felt. In secular use it signified “imperial,” “belonging to the lord” — the emperor—and so its adoption by Christianity in the sense “belonging to the Lord’’—to Christ— was perfectly easy. Indeed, there is reason to suppose that in the days of Domitian, when the issue had been sharply defined as “Who is Lord? Caesar or Christ?” the use of the adj. by the church was a part of the protest against Caesar-worship (see Lorp). And it is even possible that the full phrase, ‘‘the Lord’s day,” was coined as a contrast to the phrase, “the Augustean day” (4 ceBaor} tyuépa, hé sebasté héméra), a term that seems to have been used in some parts of the Empire to denote days esp. dedicated in honor of Caesar-worship. “Lord’s day’’ in the NT occurs only in Rev 1 10, but in the post-apostolic literature we have the following references: Ignatius, Ad 2. Post- Mag., ix.1, “No longer keeping the Apostolic Sabbath but living according to the Lord’s day, on which also our Light arose”; Hv. Pet., ver 35, ‘‘The Lord’s day began to dawn” (ef M¢ 28 1); ver 50, “early on the Lord’s day’’ (cf Lk 24 1); Barn 15 9, “We keep the eighth day with gladness,’’ on which Jesus arose from the dead.” I.e. Sunday, as the day of Christ’s resurrection, was kept as a Christian feast and called “the Lord’s day,” @ title fixed so definitely as to be introduced by the author of Ev. Pet. into phrases from the canonical Gospels. Its appropriateness in Rev 1 10 is obvious, as St. John received his vision of the exalted Lord when all Christians had their minds directed toward His entrance into glory through the resurrection. This “first day of the week” appears again in Acts 20 7 as the day on which the worship of the “breaking of bread” took place, and 8. Inthe the impression given by the context NT is that St. Paul and his companions prolonged their visit to Troas so as to join in the service. Again, 1 Cor 16 2 contains the command, “Upon the first day of the week let each one of you lay by him in store,’’ where the force of the form of the imperative used (the present for repeated action) would be better represented in Eng. by “lay by on the successive Sundays.” Worship is here not explicitly mentioned (the Gr of “by him’’ is the usual phrase for ‘‘at, home’’), but that the appropriateness of the day for Christian acts involves an appropriateness for Christian wor- ship is not to be doubted. Indeed, since the seven- day week was unknown to Gr thought, some regu- lar observance of a hebdomadal cycle must have been settled at Corinth before St. Paul could write his command. Finally, the phrase, ‘first day in the week” is found elsewhere in the NT only in Mt 28 1; Mk 162; Lk 24 1; Jn 20 1.19. The word in all passages for “first’’ is poor Gr (ula, mia, ‘‘one,” for rodéry, prété, a Hebraism), and the coincidence of the form of the phrase in Acts 20 7 and 1 Cor 16 2 with the form used by all four evangelists for the Resurrection Day is certainly not accidental; it was the fixed Christian base, just as ‘“‘Lord’s day” was to the writer of Hv. Pet. The hebdomadal observance of Sunday points back of Corinth to Jewish-Christian soil, but it is impossible to say when the custom 4. Origin first began. Not, apparently, in the earliest days, for Acts 2 46 represents the special worship as daily. But this could not have continued very long, for waning of the first enthusiasm, necessity of pursuing ordinary avoca- tions, and increasing numbers of converts must soon have made general daily gatherings impracti- cable.