The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia, Vol. 2 Hosted text — Tower of Babel library. Source: Internet Archive . Public domain. e : = 2 oe oe : =} ERE ce g Sa eee ap ree ee eee ee ene ee Seen Renae. Sop ee ee ae CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY 3 403 uu nennn Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924063473403 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA JAMES ORR, M.A., D.D., Generat Epitor JOHN L. NUELSEN, D.D., LL.D. EDGAR Y. MULLINS, D.D., LL.D. ASSISTANT EDITORS MORRIS O. EVANS, D.D., Psa.D., Manacine Eprror VOLUME II CLEMENT— HERESH CHICAGO : THE HOWARD-SEVERANCE COMPAN 1915 S Printed by the Lakeside Pr Copyricut, 1915, By THE Howarb-SEVERANCE CoMP ANY All Rights of Translation and Reproduction Reserved International Copyright Secured The Publishers supply this Encyclopaedia only through authorized sales-agents. Booksellers cannot obtain it. ess Types cast and set by the University of Chicago Press Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A. 669 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cleanse Closet CLEMENT, klem’ent (KAfpys, Klémés, “mild’’): A fellow-worker with Paul at Philippi, mentioned with especial commendation in Phil 4 3. The name being common, no inference can be drawn from this statement as to any identity with the author of the Epistle to the Corinthians published under this name, who was also the third bishop of Rome. The truth of this supposition (‘it cannot be called a tradition,’ Donaldson, The A postolical Fathers, 120), although found in Origen, Eusebius, Epiphanius and Jerome, can neither be proved nor disproved. Even Roman Catholic authorities dispute it (art. “Clement,” Cath. Cyclopaedia, IV, 18). The remote- ness between the two in time and place is against it; “a wholly uncritical view” (Cruttwell, Literary His- tory of Early Christianity, 31). . H. E. Jacons CLEOPAS, klé’é-pas (KAcérwas, Kledpas, “re- nowned father’): One of the two disciples whom Jesus met on the way to Emmaus (Lk 24 18). The name is a contraction of Cleopatros, not identical with Clopas of Jn 19 25. See also ALPHArus; Cuopas. CLEOPATRA, klé-é-pa’tra (KAcorwdtpa, Kleo- patra, “from a famous father’): A daughter of Ptolemy VI (Philometor) and of Queen Cleopatra, who was married first to Alexander Balas 150 BC (1 Mace 10 58; Jos, Ant, XIII, iv, 1) and was afterward taken from him by her father and given to Demetrius Nicator on the invasion of Syria by the latter (1 Macc 11 12; Jos, Ant, XIII, iv, 7). Alexander was killed in battle against the joint forces of Ptolemy and Demetrius while Demetrius was in captivity in Parthia. Cleopatra married his brother Antiochus VII (Sidetes), who in the absence of Demetrius had gained possession of the Syrian throne (137 BC). She was probably privy (Appian, Syr., 68) to the murder of Demetrius on his return to Syria 125 BC, but Josephus (Ant, XIII, ix, 3) gives a different account of his death. She afterward murdered Seleucus, her eldest son by Nicator, who on his father’s death had taken possession of the government without her consent. She attempted unsuccessfully to poison her second son by Nicator Antiochus VIII (Grypus), for whom she had secured the succession, because he was unwilling to concede to her what she considered her due share of power. She was herself poisoned (120 BC) by the draught which she had prepared for their son (Justin 39). She had also a son by Antiochus VII (Sidetes An- tiochus Cyzicenus), who took his name from the place in which he was educated. He was killed in battle 95 BC. The name Cleopatra was borne by many Egyp princesses, the first of whom was daughter of Antiochus III and was married to Ptolemy V (Epiphanes) 193 BC. J. Hurcuison CLEOPHAS, klé’é-fas. See Ciopas. CLERK. See Town CLERK. CLIFF, CLIFT. See Cuzrr. CLOAK, klok, CLOKE own, mil, 72D, simlah, etc; tpdrvov, himdiion, «todh, siolé, etc): “Cloke” is retained in ERV, as in AV, instead of mod. “cloak” (ARV). In the OT, m*%l (cf NT himation) uniformly stands for the ordinary upper garment worn over the coat (k*théneth). In Mt 6 40 both “cloak” and “coat’’? are mentioned together; cf Lk 6 29. In size and material the “cloak” differed according to age and sex, class and occupation, but in shape it was like our mantle or shawl. It might be sewed up to have the sur- plice form of the robe of the Ephod (Ex 39 23), ‘or be worn loose and open like a Rom toga, the Arab. Abaa, or the Geneva gown. This is the “garment” referred to in Gen 39 12; Ex 22 26; Dt 24 13; “the robe” that Jonathan “stripped himself of” and gave to David (1 8 18 4); ‘“‘the robe” of Saul, “the robe” in which it is said the “old man” (Samuel) was “covered” (1 S 28 14); and in the NT “the best robe’ put on the return- ing prodigal (Lk 15 22). Paul’s ‘‘cloak” that he left _at Troas (2 Tim 4 18; phaindlés, Lat paenula, WH phelonés), it has been suggested, ‘may have been a light mantle like a cashmere dust-cloak, in which the books and parchment were wrapped” (HDB, s.v.). : Figuratively: The word lent itself easily and naturally to fig. uses. We find Paul (1 Thess 2 5) disclaiming using ‘a cloak of covetousness” (cf 1 Pet 2 16) and Jesus (Jn 16 22) saying, “Now they have no excuse [‘“cloak’’] for their sin.” Some such usage seems common to all languages; cf Eng. “pal- liate.” See Dress. Geo. B. Eacur CLOD: In Job 7 5 (WA, gish, WA, giish, “a mass of earth’), ‘‘clods of dust,” the crust of hig sores, formed by the dry, swollen skin—a symptom of leprosy, though not peculiar to it. In Job 21 33; 38 38 (A), reghebh, “a soft clod,” “lump of clay”), “The clods of the valley shall be swect unto him,” ‘The clods cleave fast together.” In Joel 1 17 (A772, meghraphah, “a furrow,’’ “‘some- thing thrown off” [by the spade]), “The seeds rot [m “shrivel’’] under their clods.”’ Figurative: “Jacob shall break his clods’” (Hos 10 11), ie. “must harrow for himself,” used fig. of spiritual discipline (cf Isa 28 24 AV). M. O. Evans CLOPAS, klo’pas (KAwrds, Klépds), CLEO- PHAS: The former in RV, the latter in AV, of Jn 19 25, for the name of the husband of one of the women who stood by the cross of Christ. Upon the philological ground of a variety in pronunci- ation of the Heb root,-sometimes identified with Alphaeus, the father of Jamies the Less. Said by tradition to have been the brother of Joseph, the husband of Mary; see BreTaReN oF THE Lorp. ae neebed from Cleopas, a Gr word, while Clopas is Aram. CLOSE, vb. kita; adj. and advb., klés (M3, kasah, "20, sdghar; Koppto, kammid): Other words are harah, “to burn”; “Shalt thou reign, because thou closest thyself in cedar?” (Jer 22 15 AV), RV ‘“‘strivest to excel in cedar,” m. “‘viest with the cedar”; ‘dcam, “to harden’; “Jeh hath closed your eyes” (Isa 29 10); gadhar, ‘‘to hedge” or “wall up” (Am 9 11); ‘agar, “to restrain’ (Gen 20 18). In Lk 4 20, pttissd, “to fold up.” RV has “was closed,’ m “is opened,” for ‘are open” (Nu 24 3.15), “closed” for ‘‘narrow” or “covered” (Ezk 40 16; 41 16.26): To ‘‘keep close,”’ sigdd (Lk 9 36), RV “held their peace.’’ We have also “kept close’ (RV Nu 6 13; Heb sdathar, “to hide’); also Job 28 21; ‘“‘kept himself close,” RVm “shut up” (1_Ch 12 1); ‘‘close places,” misgereth (2 8 22 46; Ps 18 45=“castles or holds shut in with high walls’’). W. L. Waker CLOSET, kloz’et: Is the rendering in AV of (1) MET, huppah, and (2) rapetov, tameton, also tami- eton. Huppah, derived from haphah, “to cover,” was probably originally the name of the tent specially set apart for the bride, and later (Joel 2 16) used for the bride’s chamber. The word tameton, originally storeroom (cf Lk 12 24, AV “storehouse”; RV “storechambor”’), but since for safety it was the inner rooms of the Heb house which were used for storage purposes, the word came to mean inner Cloth, Clothing THR INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 670 room, as in Mt 6 6; Lk 12 3, in both AV ‘“‘closet”’ (cf Mt 24 26, AV “secret chamber’’). In all cases RV uses “inner chamber.” See also Houss. Davin Foster Estes CLOTH, kloth, CLOTHING, klith’ing. See Dress. CLOTHED, kléthd, UPON (revise, ependis, “to put on over” another garment): Used only in 2 Cor 6 2.4. In ver 4 in contrast with unclothed, ef 1 Cor 15 53f, in which the idea of putting on, as a garment, is expressed of incorruption and im- mortality. The meaning here is very subtle and difficult of interpretation. In all probability Paul thinks of a certain enswathement of his physical mortal body even in this life (“in this we groan,” i.e. in this present body), hence the force of the pre- fixed preposition. The body itself was regarded by the philosophers of his day as a covering of the soul, and hence it was to be clothed upon and at the same time transformed by the superimposed heavenly body. Hpendiuiés, an outer garment, is used several times in LXX for m*‘ti, an upper gar- ment or robe (cf Jn 21 7). Waurer G. CLIPPINGER CLOTHES, klothz, RENDING OF (n2™“p D2, keri‘ath beghadhim): This term is used to describe an ordinary tear made in a garment. Samuel’s skirt was rent when Saul laid hold upon it (1 S 16 27). Jesus spoke about a rent being made in a garment (Mt 9 16). The term is also used to describe a Heb custom which indicated deep sor- row. Upon the death of a relative or important personage, or when there was a great calamity, it was customary for the Hebrews to tear their gar- ments. Reuben rent his clothes when he found that Joseph had been taken from the pit (Gen 37 29). The sons of Jacob rent their clothes when the cup was found in Benjamin’s sack (Gen 44 13). A messenger came to Eli with his clothes rent to tell of the taking of the ark of God and of the death of his two sons (1 8 4:12). David rent his gar- ments when he heard that Absalom had slain his brothers (2 8 18 31). See also 2 8 15 32; 2K 18 37; Isa 36 22; Jer 41 5. Rending of clothes was also an expression of indignation. The high priest rent his garment when Jesus spoke what he thought was blasphemy (Mt 26 65). See. also Mournina. A. W. Fortune CLOUD, Kloud (737, ‘adnan, AY, ‘dbh; veb&n, nephél2, vébos, néphos): I. Clouds in Palestine.—In the Bible few ref- erences are found of particular clouds or of clouds in connection with the phenomena of the weather conditions. The weather in Pal is more even and has less variety than that in other lands. It is a long, narrow country with sea on the W. and desert on the E. The wind coming from the W. is always moist and brings clouds withit. If the temperature over the land is low enough the clouds will be con- densed and rain will fall, but if the temperature is high, as in the five months of summer, there can be no rain even though clouds are seen. As a whole the winter is cloudy and the summer clear. In the autumn rain storms often arise suddenly from the sea, and what seems to be a mere haze, “as small as a man’s hand,” such as 1. Rain Gehazi saw (1 K 18 44) over the Clouds sea, within a few hours becomes the black storm cloud pouring down tor- rents of rain (1 K 18 45). Fog is almost unknown and there is very seldom an overcast, gloomy day. The west and southwest winds bring rain (Lk 12 54). In the months of April, May and September a hot east wind sometimes rises from the desert and brings with it a cloud of dust which fills the air and penetrates everything. In the summer after- noons, esp. in the month of August, on 2. Dis- the seacoast there is apt to blow up from agreeahle the S. a considerable number of low Clouds cirro-stratus clouds which seem to fill the air with dampness, making more oppressive the dead heat of summer. These are doubtless the detested ‘‘clouds without water’ men- tioned in Jude ver 12, and ‘heat by the shade of a cloud” (Isa 25 5). il. Figurative Uses.—The metaphoric and sym- bolic uses of clouds.are many, and furnish some of the most powerful figures of Scripture. 1. Jeho- In the OT, Jeh’s presence is made vah’s manifest and His glory shown forth Presence in a cloud. The cloud is usually and Glory spoken of as bright and shining, and it could not be fathomed by man: “Thou hast covered thyself with a cloud, so that no prayer can pass through” (Lam 3 44). Jeh Himself was present in the cloud (Ex 19 9; 24 16; 34 5) and His glory filled the places where the cloud was (Ex 16 10; 40 38; Nu 10 an “The cloud filled the house of Jeh” (1 K 8 10). In the NT we often have “the Son of man coming on” or ‘‘with clouds” (Mt 24 80; 26 64; Mk 13 26; 14 62; Lk 21 27) and received up by clouds (Acts 1 9). The glory of the second coming is indicated in Rev 1 7 for ‘he cometh with the clouds’ and ‘‘we that are alive... . shall together with them be caught up in the clouds, to meet the Lord” and dwell with Him (1 Thess 4 17). The pillar of cloud was a symbol of God’s guid- ance and presence to the children of Israel in their journeys to the promised land. The Lord appeared in a pillar of cloud and forsook them not (Neh 9 19). They followed the guidance of this cloud (Ex 40 36; Ps 78 14). The clouds are spoken of in the OT as the symbol of God’s presence and care over His 8. Bow in people; and so the “bow in the cloud” Cloud (Gen 9 13) is a sign of God’s pro- tection. As the black cloud covers the sky and blots out the sun from sight, so Jeh promises ‘‘to blot out : the sins’ of Israel (Isa 44 22); Egypt 4. Clouds also shall be conquered, ‘As for her, a Blot Out cloud shall cover her” (Ezk 30 18; ef Lam 2 1). There is usually a wide difference in temperature between day and night in Pal. The days are warm and clouds coming from the sea are 5. Transi- often completely dissolved in the warm tory atmosphere over the land. As the temperature falls, the moisture again condenses into dew and mist over the hills and valleys. As the sun rises the ‘morning cloud” (Hos 6 4) is quickly dispelled and disappears entirely. Job compares the passing of his pros- perity to the passing clouds (Job 30 15). God “‘bindeth up the waters in his thick clouds” (Job 26 8) and the “clouds are the dust of his feet’’ 2. Pillar of Cloud (Nah 1 8). Jeh ‘commands the clouds 6. God’s that they rain no rain” (Isa 6 6), but Omnipo- as for man, “who can number the tence and clouds?” (Job 38 37); “Can any un- Man’s derstand the spreadings of the clouds?” Ignorance (Job 36 29); ‘“‘Dost thou know the balancings of the clouds, the wondrous works of him who is perfect in knowledge?” (Job 37 16). See Batancines. “He that regardeth the clouds shall not reap” (Eccl 11 4), for it is God who controls the clouds and man cannot fathom His wisdom. ‘Thick clouds are a covering to him” (Job 22 14). 671 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Gleth, Clothing Clouds are the central figure in many visions. Ezekiel beheld ‘a stormy wind .... out of the north, a great cloud” (Ezk 1 4), and John saw “a white cloud; and on the cloud one sitting’? (Rev 14 14). See also Dnl 7 13; Rev 10 1; 11 12. The cloud is also the symbol of the terrible and of destruction. The day of Jeh’s reckoning is called the “day of clouds” (Ezk 30 7. Visions 8. The 3) and a day of “clouds and thick Terrible darkness” (Zeph 1 15). The invader and Un- is expected to “come up as clouds” (Jer pleasant 4 13). Joel (2 2) foretells the coming of locusts as ‘‘a day of clouds and thick darkness” which is both literal andfigurative. Mis- fortune and old age are compared to “the cloudy and dark day” (Ezk 34 12) and “the clouds return- ing after rain” (Eccl 12 2). Clouds are used in connection with various other figures. Rapidity of motion, ‘these that fly as a cloud” (Isa 60 8). As swaddling 9. Various clothes of the newborn earth (Job 38 Other 9); indicating great height (Job 20 6) Figures and fig. in Isa 14 14, “I will ascend above the heights of the clouds,” por- traying the self-esteem of Babylon. “A morning without clouds” is the symbol of righteousness and justice (2 S 23 4); partial knowledge and hidden glory (Lev 16 2; Acts 19; Rev 1 7). Aurrep H. Joy CLOUD, PILLAR OF. See Cuxovupn, II, 2; Piniar or CLoup. CLOUT, klout: As subst. (PMIAMOM, ha-shabhoth) a patch or piece of cloth, leather, or the like, a rag a shred, or fragment. Old ‘‘cast clouts and old rotten rags” (Jer 38 11.12 AV). As vb. (820, tala’) “to bandage,” “patch,” or mend with a clout. “Qld shoes and clouted [ARV “patched”] upon their feet’? (Josh 9 5; cf Shakespeare, Cym., IV, 2: “T thought he slept, And put my clouted brogues from off my feet’; Milton, Comus: ‘‘And the dull swain treads on it daily with his clouted shoon.” CLOVEN, klé’v’n: In the OT, represented by a participle from JOU, shdsa‘, “to split,” and applied to beasts that divide the hoof (Lev 11 3; Dt 14 7). Beasts with hoofs completely divided into two parts, that were also ruminant, were allowed the Israelites as food; see Cup; Hoor. In the NT, for diapepifbperar, diamerizémenai, in Acts 2 3 AV, RV “tongues parting asunder,” i.e. “bifurcated flames.” Another explanation found in RVm ap- plies the word, not to tongues, but to the multi- tude, “parting among them,” or “distributing them- selves among them,” settling upon the head of each disciple. H. E. Jacoss CLUB, klub. See Armor, III, 1; SuepHerp; Starr. CLUSTER, klus’tér: . (1) Douay, ’eshkol; cf proper name VaLs oF Esucou (q.v.), from root meaning “to bind to- gether.” A cluster or bunch of grapes (Gen 40 10; Nu 13 23; Isa 658; Cant 7 8; Mic 7 1, etc); a cluster of henna flowers (Cant 1 14); a cluster of dates (Cant 7 7). “Their grapes are grapes of gall, their clusters are bitter’? (Dt 32 32). (2) Bérpus, bétrus, “gather the clusters of the vine of the earth’ (Rev 14 18). The “cluster of raisins’ (cimmékim) of 1 8 26 18; 30 12, should rather be “raisin cakes” or ‘dried raisins.” E. W. G. Masterman CNIDUS, ni’dus, kni’dus (KviS0s, Knidos, “age’’): A city of Caria in the Rom province of Asia, past which, according to Acts 27 7, Paul sailed. At the S.W. corner of Asia Minor there projects for 90 miles into the sea a long, narrow peninsula, practically dividing the Aegean from the Mediterranean. It now bears the name of Cape Crio. Ships sailing along the southern coast of Asia Minor here turn northward as they round the point. Upon the very end of the peninsula, and also upon a small island off its point was the city of Cnidus. The island which in ancient times was connected with the mainland by a causeway is now joined to it by a sandy bar. Thus were formed two harbors, one of which could be closed by a chain. Though Cnidus was in Caria, it held the rank of a free city. There were Jews here as early as the 2d cent. BC. The ruins of Cnidus are the only objects of inter- est on the long peninsula, and as they may be reached by land only with great difficulty, few travelers have visited them; they may, however, be reached more easily by boat. The nearest modern village is Yazi Keui, 6 miles away. The ruins of Cnidus are unusually interesting, for the entire plan of the city may easily be traced. The sea-walls and piers remain. The acropolis was upon the hill in the western portion of the town; upon the terraces below stood the public buildings, among which were two theaters and the odeum still well preserved. The city was esp. noted for its shrine of Venus and for the statue of that god- dess by Praxiteles. Here in 1875-78 Sir C. New- ton discovered the statue of Demeter, now in the British Museum. See also the Aphrodite of Cnidus in the South Kensington Museum, one of the love- liest statues in the world. From here also came the huge Cnidian lion. The vast necropolis W. of the ruins contains tombs of every size and shape, and from various ages. E Banks COAL, kél (O05, peham, “charcoal”; cf Arab. fahm, “charcoal”; mbna, gaheleth, “burning coal’ or “hot ember”; cf Arab. jaham, “to kindle’; VWTW , shehor, “a black coal” [Lam 4 8]; cf Arab. shahhar, “soot” or “dark-colored sandstone”; DZ), regeph [1 K 19 6], and MBL, rigpah [ =Riz- pah] [Isa 6 6], m “a hot stone’; cf MW, resheph, “a flame” [Cant 8 6; Hab 3 5]; av@pak, dnihraz, “a live coal’? [Rom 12 20] [=gaheleth in Prov 25 22]; dvOpanud, anthrakid, “a live coal’’ [Jn 18 18; 21 9]): There is no reference to mineral coal in the Bible. Coal, or more properly lignite, of inferior quality, is found in thin beds (not exceeding 3 ft.) in the sandstone formation (see GEoLocy, Nubian Sandstone), but there is no evidence of its use in ancient times. Charcoal is manufactured in a primitive fashion which does not permit the con- servation of any by-products. A flat, circular place (Arab. beidar, same name as for a threshing- floor) 10 or 15 ft. in diameter is prepared in or con- veniently near to the forest. On this the wood to be converted into charcoal, is carefully stacked. in a dome-shaped structure, leaving an open space in the middle for fine kindlings. All except the center is first covered with leaves, and then with earth. The kindlings in the center are then fired and afterward covered in the same manner as the rest. While it is burning or smoldering it is care- fully watched, and earth is immediately placed upon any holes that may be formed in the cover- ing by the burning of the wood below. In several days, more or less, according to the size of the pile, the wood is converted into charcoal and the heap is opened. The charcoal floor is also called in Arab. mashharah, from shahhar, “soot”; ef Heb shehér. The characteristic odor of the mashharah clings for months to the spot. Coast Cold THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 672 In Ps 120 4, there is mention of “coals of juni- per,” RVm “broom,” réthem. This is doubtless the Arab. retem, Retama roetam, Forsk., a kind of broom which is abundant in Judaea and Moab. Charcoal from oak wood, especially Quercus coccifera, L., Arab. sindyan, is much preferred to other kinds, and fetches a higher price. In most of the passages where Eng. VSS have “coal,” the reference is not necessarily to charcoal, but may be to coals of burning wood. Peham in Prov 26 21, however, seems to stand for charcoal: ‘As coals are to hot embers, and wood to fire, So is a contentious man to inflame strife." The same may be true of peham in Isa 44 12 and 64 16; also of shehér in Lam 4 8. Aurrep Evy Day COAST, kést (5723, g*bhal, etc, “boundary”; of 23, gbhal, “mountain,” and Arab. jebel, “moun- tain”; 5am ) hebhel, lit. “a rope”; ef Arab. habl [Josh 19 29 AV; Zeph 2 5.6.7]; S4m, hoph, lit. “that which is washed”; cf Arab. hadffet(Josh 9 1 AV; Ezk 25 16]; wapddvos, pardlios, lit. “by the sea” [Lk 6 17]): “Coast” (fr Lat costa, “rib” or ‘“side”) in the sense of “seacoast,” occurs but a few times in the Bible. In nearly all the many passages where AV has “coast,” RV correctly has ‘‘border,’’ i.e. “bound- ary,’”’ translating g*bhal, etc; in Acts 27 2 ARV, “coast” is the tr of réros, tépos, lit. “place.” That the seacoast is but seldom mentioned arises naturally from the fact that, while the promised land ex- tended to the sea, the coast was never effectively occupied by the Israelites. RVm in a number of places renders 72, EV “‘sle’’ or “island” (q.v.), by “coastland,” e.g. Isa 11 11; 23 6; 24 15; 69 18; Jer 26 22: Ezk 396; Dni 11.18; Zeph 2 11. In Isa 20 6, AV has “‘isle,” AVim “country,” and RV “coast-land.”” In Jer 47 4, AV has “country,” AVm and RV ‘‘sle,” and RVm “sea-coast.” See Isiz. AtFreD Ey Day COAT, kat. See CLoax; Drgss, etc. COAT OF MAIL, mal. See Armor, ARMs; BRIGANDINE,’ COCK, kok (dAékrop, adléktér; Lat gallus): There is no reference in the OT to domesticated oultry, which was probably first introduced into Fada after the Rom conquest. See CHicKken. The cock is several times mentioned in the NT and always with reference to its habit of crowing in eastern countries with such regularity as to be almost clocklike. The first full salute comes almost to the minute at half-past eleven, the second at half-past one, and the third at dawn. So uni- formly do the cocks keep time and proclaim these three periods of night that we find cock-crowin mentioned as a regular division of time: ‘Wate therefore: for ye know not when the lord of the house cometh, whether at even, or at midnight, or at cockcrowing, or in the morning” (Mk 13 35). Jesus had these same periods of night in mind when he warned Peter that he would betray Him. Mt 26 34; Lk 22 34; Jn 13 38, give almost identical wording of the warning. But in all his writing Mark was more explicit, more given to exact detail. Remembering the divisions of night as the cocks kept them, his record reads: ‘‘And Jesus saith unto him, Verily I say into thee, that thou today, even this night, before the cock crow twice, shalt deny me thrice’ (Mk 14 30). See Cuicxen. It is hardly necessary to add that the cocks crow at irregular intervals as well as at the times indicated, according to the time of the year and the phase of the moon (being more liable to crow during the night if the moon is at the full), or if a storm threat- ens, or there is any disturbance in their neighbor- hood. Gene STRATTON-PORTER COCKATRICE, kok’a-tris, kok’a-tris (9D%, cepha'; "2I9D%, ciph'dni; LXX, BacwAloxos, basi- liskos, “basilisk” [q.v.], and dons, aspis, “asp” [see Apper; Asp; Serpent]): A fabulous, deadly, mon- ster. The name ‘‘cockatrice’ appears to be a cor- ruption of Lat calcatriz, from calcare, ‘“‘to tread,” calcatriz being in turn a tr of the Gr ¢yvetuwv, ich- neumon, from txvos, tchnos, “track” or “footstep.” Herpestes ichneumon, the ichnenmon, Pharaoh’s rat, or mongoose, a weasel-like animal, is a native of northern Africa and southern Spain. There are also other species, including the Indian mongoose. It preys on rats and snakes, and does not despise poultry and eggs. Pliny (see Ozford Dictionary, s.v. ‘‘Cockatrice'') relates that the ichneumon darts down the open mouth of the crocodile, and destroys it hy gnawing through its belly. In the course of time, as the story underwent changes, the animal was metamorphosed into a water snake, and was confused with the crocodile itself, and also with the hasilisk. According to the Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed, the cockatrice was helieved as late as the 17th cent. to he produced from a cock's egg and hatched hy a ser- pent, and “‘to possess the most deadly powers, plants withering at its touch, and men and animals being poi- soned hy itslook. It stood in awe however of the cock, the sound of whose crowing killed it. .... The weasel alone among animals was unaffected by the glance of its evil eye, and attacked it at all times successfully; for when wounded hy the monster's teeth it found a ready remedy in rue, the only plant which the cockatrice could not wither.” The real ichneumon does kill the most deadly snakes, and has been supposed to resort to a vegetable antidote when bitten. It actually dies however when hitten hy a deadly snake, and does not possess a knowledge of herbs, but its extraordinary agility enables it ordinarily to escape injury. It is interesting to see how the changing tale of this creature with its marvelous powers has made a hodge-podge of ichneumon, weasel, crocodile, and serpent. The Bib. references (AV Isa 11 8; 59 5; Jer 8 17) are doubtless to a serpent, the word “cocka- trice,” with its mediaeval implications, having been introduced by the translators of AV. See SERPENT, ALFRED ELy Day COCK-CROWING, kok’kré-ing (dAexropodwvia, alektorophonta): An indefinite hour of the night between midnight and morning (Mk 18 35), referred to by all the evangelists in their account of Peter’s denial (Mt 26 34.74; Mk 14 30; Lk 22 34; Jn 13 88). Itis derived from the habit of the cock to crow esp. toward morning. See Cock. COCKER, kok’ér (rOynvéw, tithénés, “to nurse,” “coddle,” ‘“‘pamper’’): Occurs only in Ecclus 30 9 with the meaning “to pamper”: “Cocker thy child, and he shall make thee afraid”; so Shakespeare, “a cockered silken wanton’; now seldom used; Jean Ingelow, “‘Poor folks cannot afford to cocker them- selves.” COCKLE, kok”l (AVm “stinking weeds,” RVm “noisome weeds”; TWN, bo’shah, from Heb root WRA, ba’ash, “to stink”; Badrtos, bdtos): “Let thistles grow instead of wheat, and cockle instead of barley” (Job 81 40). On account of the mean- ing of the Heb root we should expect that the reference was rather to repulsive, offensive weeds than to the pretty corn cockle, It is very possible that no particular plant is here intended, though the common Palestinian “stinking” arnms have been suggested by Hooker. CODE OF HAMMURABI. See Hammurasi, Cope oF. COELE-SYRIA, sé-lé-sir'i-a (AV Celosyria; Koihy Zvpla, Kotlé Surta, “hollow Syria”): So 673 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Coast Cold the Greeks after the time of Alexander the Great named the valley lying between the two mountain ranges, Lebanon and Anti-Lebanon. It is referred to in the OT as Bik‘ath ha-Lebhanon, “the valley of Lebanon” (Josh 11 17), a name the echo of which is still heard in el-Buka‘, the designation applied today to the southern part of the valley. This hollow, which extends about 100 miles in length, is the continuation northward of the Jordan valley. The main physical features are described under Lespanon (q.v.). The name, however, did not always indicate the same tract of territory. In Strabo (xvi.2) and Ptolemy (v.15), it covers the fertile land between Jebel esh-Sharky and the desert presided over by Damascus. In 1 Esd 2 17; 2 Macc 8 8, ete, it indicates the country 8. and E. of Mt. Lebanon, and along with Phoenicia it contributed the whole of the Seleucid dominions which lay 8. of the river Eleutherus. Jos includes in Coele-Syria the country E. of the Jordan, along with Scythopolis (Beisan) which lay on the W., sepa- rated by the river from the other members of the Decapolis (Ant, XIII, xiii, 2, etc). In XIV, iv, 5, he says that “Pompey committed Coele-Syria as far as the river Euphrates and Egypt to Scaurus.”’ The term is therefore one of some elasticity. W. Ewine COFFER, kof’ér (TI8, ’argaz): A small box such as that in which the Philis placed their golden mice and other offerings in returning the Ark (1 S 6 8.11.15). COFFIN, kof‘in. COGITATION, koj4-ta’shun, 7", ra‘ydn, “the act of thinking or reflecting,” as in Dnl 7 28, ‘my cogitations much troubled me” (RV “‘my thoughts”). COHORT, ko’hort: In RVm of Mt 27 27; Mk 16 16; Jn 18 3.12; Acts 10 1; 21 31; 27 1, the tr of spetra (AV and RV, “‘band”’); the tenth part of a legion; ordinarily about 600 men. In Jn 18 the word seems to be used loosely of a smaller body of soldiers, a detachment, detail. See Army; Bann. « See Curst; BURIAL. COINS, koinz: There were no coins in use in Pal until after the Captivity. It is not quite cer- tain whether gold and silver were before that time divided into pieces of a certain weight for use as money or not, but there can be no question of coin- age proper until the Pers period. Darius I is credited with introducing a coinage system into his empire, and his were the first coins that came into use among the Jews, though it seems probable that coins were struck in Lydia in the time of Croesus, the contemporary of Cyrus the Great, and these coins were doubtless the model upon which Darius based his system, and they may have circulated to some extent in Babylonia before the . return of the Jews. The only coins mentioned in the OT are the Darics (see Daric), and these only in the RV, the word “dram”’ being used in AV (Ezr 2 69; 8 27; Neh 7 70-72). The Jews had no native coins until the time of the Maccabees, who struck coins after gaining their independence about 143-141 BC. These kings struck silver and copper, or the latter, at least (see Monty), in de- nominations of shekels and fractions of the shekel, until the dynasty was overthrown by the Romans. Other coins were certainly in circulation during the same period, esp. those of Alexander and his suc- cessors, the Ptolemies of Egypt and the Seleucids of Syria, both of whom bore sway over Pal before the rise of the Maccabees. Besides these coins there were the issues of some of the Phoen towns, which were allowed to strike coins by the Persians and the Seleucids. The coins of Tyre and Sidon, both silver and copper, must have circulated largely in Pal on account of the intimate commercial rela- tions between the Jews and Phoenicians (for ex- amples, see under Money). After the advent of the Romans the local coinage was restricted chiefly to the series of copper coins, such as the mites mentioned in the NT, the silver denarii being struck mostly at Rome, but circulating wherever the Romans went. The coins of the Herods and the Procurators are abundant, but all of copper, since the Romans did not allow the Jewish rulers to strike either silver or gold coins. At the time of the first revolt (66-70 AD) the Jewish leader, Simon, struck shekels again, or, as some numis- matists think, he was the first to do so. But this series was a brief one, lasting between 3 and 4 years only, as Jerus was taken by Titus in 70 AD, and this put an end to the existence of the Jewish state. There was another short period of Jewish coinage during the second revolt, in the reign of Hadrian, when Simon Barcochba struck coins with Heb legends which indicate his independence of Rom rule. They were of both silver and copper, and constitute the last series of strictly Jewish coins (see Monry). After this the coins struck in Judaea were Rom, as Jerus was made a Rom colony. H. Porter COLA, ko’la. See CHoua. COLD, kold (AP, kor; buxpss, psuchrés [adj.], yroxos, pstichos [noun]): Pal is essentially a land of sunshine and warmth. The ex- 1. Temper- treme cold of northern latitudes is ature in unknown. January is the coldest Palestine month; but the degree of cold in a par- ticular place depends largely on the altitude above the sea. On the seacoast and plain the snow never falls; and the temperature reaches freezing-point, perhaps oncein thirty years. In Jerus at 2,500 ft. above the sea the mean temperature in January is about 45° F., but the minimum may be as low as 25° F. Snow occasionally falls, but lasts only a short time. On Mt. Hermon and on the Lebanons snow may be found the whole year, and the cold is most intense, even in the summer. In Jericho and around the Dead Sea, 1,292 ft. below sea-level, it is correspondingly hotter, and cold is. not known. ; Cold is of such short duration that no adequate provision is made by the people to protect them- selves against the cold. The sun is 2. Provi- always bright and warm, and nearly sion against always shines for part of the day, even Cold in winter. After sunset the people house. mountains almost hibernate. They wrap up their heads in shawls and coverings and only the most energetic venture out: ‘The sluggard will not plow by reason of the winter” (Prov 20 4, AV “cold’”). The peasants and more primitive people of the desert often make a fire in the open or in partial shelter, as in Melita where Paul was cast ashore after ship- wreck: “The barbarians ... . kindledafire... . because of the cold” (Acts 28 2). Col-hozeh Color, Colors The cold is greatly dreaded because it causes so much actual suffering: “Who can stand before his cold?” (Ps 147 17). The last degree 3. Dread of degradation is to have “no covering of Cold in the cold” (Job 24 7). In the heat of the long summer, the shadow of a rock or the cool of evening is most grate- ful, and the appreciation of a cup of cold water can easily be understood by anyone who 4. Cold has experienced the burning heat of the Grateful in Syrian sun: “‘Ascold waters to a thirsty Summer soul, so is good newsfrom a far country” (Prov 25 25); “cold of snow in the time of harvest” (Prov 25 13), probably with refer- ence to the use of snow (shaved ice) in the East to cool a beverage. Figurative uses: ‘The love of the many shall wax cold” (Mt 24 12); “I know thy works, that thou art neither cold nor hot” (Rev 3 15). _ ALFRED H. Joy COL-HOZEH, kol-hd’ze (MIM759, kol-hdzeh, “all seeing”; LXX omits): A man whose son Shallum rebuilt the fountain gate of Jerus in the days of Nehemiah (Neh 3 15). The C. of Neh 11 5 is probably another man. COLIUS, ké’li-us (Kédvs, Kélios, 1 Esd 9 23). See Cauitas, COLLAR, kol’ar, kol’ér: (1) (ABN, ntiphah, pl. TDD}, netiphath, lit. “drops,” from 5102, ndtaph, “to drop”). Jgs 8 26 includes n‘t7phdth among the spoils taken from the Midianites and Ishmaelites; RV ‘‘pendants,’’? AV “collars.” ”? per. (2) (1B, peh, lit. “mouth”). In Job 30 18 the word is used to indicate the collar band, or hole of a robe, through which the head was inserted. Job, in describing his suffering and writhing, mentions the disfiguring of his garment, and suggests that the whole thing feels as narrow or close-fitting as the neckband, or perhaps that in his fever and pains he feels as if the neckband itself is choking him. (3) (PINS, ¢indk, Jer 29 26, “stocks”; RV “shackles,” which see; RVm “collar”’). An instru- ment of torture or punishment. ; Naruan Isaacs COLLECTION, ké-lck’shun: (1) Inthe OT (ANW'A, mas’éth, “something taken up’’), used in 2 Ch 24 6.9 AV with reference to the tax prescribed in Ex 30 12.16; RV “tax.” (2) In the NT “collection” is the tr given to royla, logia, found only twice (classical, evAdoy%4, sullogé). It is used with reference to the collec- tion which Paul took up in the gentile churches for the poor Christians in Jerus, as, for some reason, perhaps more severe persecutions, that church was esp. needy (1 Cor 16 1.2; ver 2 AV “gatherings’’). Other words, such as bounty, contribution, blessing, alms, ministration, are used to indicate this same ministry. Paul seems to have ascribed to it great’ importance. Therefore, he planned it carefully long in advance; urged systematic, weekly savings for it; had delegates carefully chosen to take it to Jerus; and, in spite of dangers, determined himself to accompany them. Evidently he thought it the crowning act of his work in the provinces of Galatia, Asia, Macedonia and Achaia, for as soon as it was finished he purposed to go to Rome and the West (Acts 24 17; Rom 15 25.26; 2 Cor 8,9). See also ComMUnron. G. TREVER COLLEGE, kol’ej: This is the rendering of AV for Heb Mishneh (12W, mishneh, 2 K 22 14= 2 Ch 34 22; ef Zeph 1 10). It is found in the THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Kimhi ad loc. suggests ‘‘perfume-drop- 674 Tg of Jonathan on 2 K 22 14 and rests on a faulty combination with Mish, the well-known code of laws of the 2d cent. AD. RV renders ‘‘second quarter” (of the city); 2 Ch 34 22 AVm ‘‘the school.” COLLOP, kol’up (M2"B , pimah): A slice of meat or “fat,” AV in Job 15 27, ‘maketh collops of fat {thick folds of flesh] on his flanks,” said of the “wicked man.” ARV reads “[hath] gathered fat upon his loins.” COLONY, kol’é-ni (kodwvia, kolénia, Gr trans- literation of Lat colonia, from 7/ col, “cultivate’’): The word occurs but once (Acts 16 12) in refer- ence to Philippi in Macedonia. Rom colonies were of- three kinds and of three periods: (1) Those of the early republic, in which the colonists, estab- lished in conquered towns to serve the state as guardians of the frontier, were exempt from ordinary military service. They were distinguished as (a) c. cium Romanorum, wherein the colonists retained Rom citizenship, also called c. maritumae, because situated on the coast, and (b) c. Latinae, situated inland among the allies (soctt), wherein the colo- nists possessed the tus Latinum, entitling them to invoke the Rom law of property (commercium), but not that of the family (connubium), and re- ceived Rom citizenship only when elected to magis- tracies. (2) The colonies of the Gracchan period, established in pursuance of the scheme of agrarian reforms, to provide land for the poorer citizens. (3) After the time of Sulla colonies were founded in Italy by the Republic as a device for granting lands to retiring veterans, who of course retained citizenship. This privilege was appropriated by Caesar and the emperors, who employed it to es- tablish military colonies, chiefly in the provinces, with various rights and internal organizations. To this class belonged Philippi. Partly organized after the great battle of 42 BC, fought in the neighbor- ing plain by Brutus and Cassius, the champions of the fated Republic, and Antonius and Octavian, it was fully established as a colony by Octavian (afterward styled Augustus) after the battle of Actium (31 BC), under the name Colonia Aug. Iul. Philippi or Philippensis. It received the ius Italicum, whereby provincial cities acquired the same status as Italian cities, which possessed municipal self- government and exemption from poll and land taxes. See Civ1zENsHIP; PHInipr1; Roman. Winuiam ArtHur HEmpen COLOR, kul’ér, COLORS, kul’erz: The word tr@ “color” in AV is ‘ayin, which lit. means “eye” or “appearance,” and has been so triin RV. In the NT the Gr zpégacis, préphasis, has the meaning of pretense or show (Acts 27 30; cf Rev 17 4 AV). The references to Joseph’s coat of many colors (Gen 37 3.23.32) and ‘garments of divers colors” (2 § 13 18.19) probably do not mean the color of the garment at all, but the form, as suggested in ARVm, “a long garment with sleeves.” In Jgs 6 30 the word for “dip” or “dye’’ appears in the original and has been so tr? in ARV (see Dyn). In 1 Ch 29 2 OP, rikmah, meaning “varie- gated,” hence ‘“varicolored,” is found. In Isa 54 11, pukh is used. This name was applied to the sulphide of antimony (Arab. kohl) used for painting the eyes. Hence the ARVm rendering “antimony’ instead of “fair colors” (see Paint). In Ezk 16 16 N20 , tala’, is found, meaning “covered with pieces” or “‘spotted,”’ hence by implication “divers colors.” Although the ancient Hebrews had no specific words for “color,” “paint” or “painter,” still, as we know, they constantly met with displays of the art of coloring among the Babylonians (Ezk 23 14) and Egyptians and the inhabitants of Pal. Pottery, 675 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Col-hozeh Color, Colors glazed bricks, glassware, tomb walls, sarcophagi, wood and fabrics were submitted to the skill of the colorist. This skill probably consisted in bringing out striking effects by the use of a few primary colors, rather than in any attempt at the blending of shades which characterizes modern coloring. That the gaudy show of their heathen neighbors attracted the children of Israel is shown by such passages as Jgs 8 27; Ezk 23 12.16. Two reasons may be given for the indefiniteness of many of the Bib. referenees to color. (1) The origin of the Heb people: They had been wander- ing tribes or slaves with no occasion to develop a color language. (2) Their religious laws: These forbade expression in color or form (Ex 20 4). Yielding to the attractions of gorgeous display was discouraged by such prophets as Ezekiel, who had sickened of the abominations of the Chaldaeans. (Ezk 23 14.15.16); “And I said unto them, Cast ye away every man the abominations of his eyes” (Ezk 20 7). Indefiniteness of color language is common to oriental literature, ancient and modern. This does not indicate a want of appreciation of color but a failure to analyze and define color effects. The inhabitants of Syria and Pal today delight in bril- liant colors. Bright yellow, crimson, magenta and green are used for adornment with no evident sense of fitness, according to the foreigners’ eyes, other than their correspondence with the glaring brightness of the eastern skies. A soapmaker once told the writer that in order to make his wares attractive to the Arabs he colored them a brilliant crimson or yellow. A peasant chooses without hesitation a flaring magenta or yellow or green zun-nar (girdle), rather than one of somber hues. The oriental student in the chemical or physical laboratory often finds his inability to distinguish or classify color a real obstacle. His closest defi- nition of a color is usually “lightish” or ‘“darkish.” This is not due to color blindness but to a lack of education, and extends to lines other than color dis- tinctions. The colloquial language of Pal today is poor in words denoting color, and an attempt to secure from a native a satisfactory description of some simple color scheme is usually disappointing. The harmonious color effects which have come to us from the Orient have been, in the past, more the result of aceident (see Dye) than of deliberate purpose, ag witness the clashing of colors where modern artificial dyes have been introduced. This inability of the peoples of Bible lands to define colors is an inheritance from past ages, a consideration which helps us to appreciate the vagueness of many of the Bib. references. The following color words occur in the AV or RV: (1) bay, (2) black, (8) blue, (4) brown, (5) erimson, (6) green, (7) grey, (8) hoar, (9) purple, (10) red, (11) scarlet, (12) sorrel, (13) vermilion, (14) white, (15) yellow. In addition there are indefinite words indicating mixtures of light and dark: (a) grisled (grizzled), (b) ringstraked (ring- streaked), (c) speckled, (d) spotted. (1) Bay or red is more properly tr? “strong” i the RV. (2) Black (blackish): Eight different words have been tr? “black.”’ They indicate various meanings such as “dusky like the early dawn,” “ashen,” “swarthy,” “moved with passion.’ Black is ap- plied to hair (Lev 18 31; Cant 5 11; Mt 5 36); to marble or pavement (Est 1 6); to mourning (Job 30 28.30; Jer 14 2); to passion (Jer 8 21 AV; Lam 5 10); to horses (Zec 6 2.6; Rev 6 5); to the heavens (1 K 18 45; Job 3 5; Prov 7 9 AV; Jer 4 28; Mic 3 6); to the sun (Rev 6 12); to the skin (racial) (Cant 1 5.6); to flocks (Gen 30 32.33.35. 40); to brooks because of ice (Job 6 16). (3) Blue (ND2M, tkhéleth, a color from the eerulean mussel): This word was applied only to fabrics dyed with a special blue dye obtained from a shellfish. See Dyn. WW, shésh, in one passage of the AV is tr? “blue” (Est 16). It is properly tr? in RV “white cloth.” ‘Blueness of a wound” (Prov 20 30) is correctly rendered in RV “stripes that wound.” Blue is applied to the fringes, veil, vestments, embroideries, etc, in the description of the ark and tabernacle (Ex 25 ff; Nu 4 6f; 15 38); to workers in blue (2 Ch 2 7.14; 3 14); to palace adornments (Est 1 6); ay royal apparel ‘(Est 8 15; Jer 10 9; Ezk 28 6; 27 7.24). (4) Brown: The Heb word meaning “sunburnt” or “swarthy” is tr? “plack” in RV (Gen 30 32 ff), (5) Crimson (yn 72, karmil): This word is probably of Pers origin and applies to the brilliant dye obtained from a bug. A second word nybin, téla‘ath, is also found. Its meaning is the same. See Dyz. Crimson is applied to raiment (2 Ch 27.14; 314; Jer 4 30 AV); to sins (Isa 1 18). (6) Green (greenish): This word in the tr refers almost without exception to vegetation. The Heb P22, yards, lit. “pale,” is considered one of the three definite color words used in the OT (see Wu1TE; REp). The Gr equivalent, is chlérés; cf Eng. “chlorine.” This word occurs in the following vs: Gen 1 30; 9 3; Ex 10 15; Lev 2 14 (AV); 23 14 (AV); 2K 19 26; Ps 37 3: Isa 15 6; 37 27; Job 39 8; chla- ros, Mk 6 39; Rev 8 7;9 4. R27, ra‘dénan, closely allied in meaning to ydrak, is used to describe trees in the following passages: Dt 12 2; 1 K 14 23; 2K 16 4; 17 10; 19 26; 2 Ch 28 4; Job 16 32: Ps 87 35; 62 8; ‘Cant 1 16; Isa 57 5; Jer 2 20; 36; 11 16; 17 2.8: Ezk 6 13; Hos 14 8. Inthe remaining vs the Heb equivalents do not denote eolor, but the condition of being full of sap, fresh or unripe (cf similar uses in Eng.) (Gen 30 37 [AV]; Jgs 16 7.8; Ps 23 2; Cant 2 13; Job 8 16; Ezk 17 24; 20 47; Lk 28 31) In Est'1 6 the Heb word refers to a fiber, probably cotton, as is indicated by ARVm. Greenish is used to describe leprous spots in Lev 13 49; 14 37. The same word is tr! “yel- low” in Ps 68 13. (7) Gray: The Heb mDy, sébhah, means old age, hence refers also to the color of the aie in old age (Gen 42 38; 44 29; 44 31; Dt 32 25; Ps 71 18; Hos 7 9). See H. oar, next paragraph. (8) Hoar (hoary): ‘The same word which in other vs is tr? “gray” is rendered “hoar” or “hoary,” applying to the hair in 1 K 2 6.9; Isa 46 4; Lev 19 32; Job 41 32; Prov 16 31. Another Heb word is tr? “hoar” or “hoary,” describing ‘frost’? in Ex 16 14; Job 38 29; Ps 147 16. (9) ’ Purple: The Heb equivalent is 208, ’argaman; Gr wopptpa, porphira. The latter word refers to the source of the dye, namely, a shell- fish found on the shores of the Mediterranean. See Dye. This color, which varied widely according to the kind of shellfish used and the method of dye- ing, was utilized in connection with the adornment of the tabernacle (Ex 25, 26, 27, 28, 35, 36, 38, 39; Nu 4 13). There were workers in purple called to assist in beautifying the temple (2 Ch 2 7.14; 3 14). Purple was much used for royal raiment and furnishings (Jgs 8 26; Est 16; 8 15; Cant 3 10; Mk 15 17.20; Jn 19 "9. 5). Purple was typical of gorgeous apparel (Prov 31 22; Jer 10 9; Cant 7 5; Ezk 27 7.16; Lk 16 19; Acts 16 14; Rev 17 4; 418 12.16). (10) Red: The Heb OVS, ’ddhdm, is from Bt, dam, “blood,” hence, “bloodlike.” This is one of the three distinctive color words mentioned in the OT (see GREEN; WHITE), and is found in most of the references to red. Four other words are Color, Colors Colossians THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 676 used: (a) "2"2371, hakhlili, probably “darkened” or “clouded” (Gen 49 12; Prov 23 29); (6) Van, hdmar, “to ferment” (Ps 75 8m; Isa 27 2 AV); (c) OTD, bahat, probably “to glisten’” (Est 1 6); (d) ruppés, purrés, ‘“firelike’” (Mt 16 2.8; Rev 6 4; 12 3). Red is applied to dyed sking (Ex 25 5; 26 14; 85 7.23; 86 19; 39 34); to the color of animals (Nn 19 2; Zec 1 8; 6 2; Rev 6 4; 12 3); to the human skin (Gen 25 25; ruddy, 1 S 16 12; 17 42; Cant 5 10; Lam 47); to the eyes (Gen 49 12; Prov 28 29); to sores (Lev 13); to wine (Ps 75 8m; Prov 23 31; Isa 27 2 AV); to water (2 K 3 22); to pavement (Est 1 6); to pottage (Gen 25 30); to apparel (Isa 63 2); to the sky (Mt 16 2.3); to sing (Isa 1 18); to ashield (Nah 2 3). (11) Scarlet: Scarlet and crimson colors were probably from the same source (see CRIMSON; Dyz). my>iN, tala‘ath, or derivatives have been tr? by both “scarlet” and ‘‘crimson” (Gr kékkinos). A Chald word for purple has thrice been tr? ‘‘scar- let” in AV (Dnl 6 7.16.29). Scarlet is applied to fabrics or yarn used (a) in the equipment of the tabernacle (Ex 25 ff; Nu 4 8); (8) in rites in cleans- ing lepers (Lev 14); in ceremony of purification (Nu 19 6); to royal or gorgeous apparel (2 8 1 24; Prov 31 21; Lam 4 5; Dnl 5 7.16.29, “purple”; Nah 2 3; Mt 27 28; Rev 17 4; 18 12.16); to marking thread (Gen 38 28.30; Josh 2 18.21); to lips (Cant 4 3); to sins (Isa 1 18); to beasts (Rev 17 3); to wool (He 9 19). (12) Sorrel: This word occurs once in the RV (Zec 1 8). int (13) Vermilion: This word, WW, shdshar, occurs intwo passages (Jer 22 14; Ezk 23 14). Vermilion of modern arts is a sulphide of mercury. Itis not at all improbable that the paint referred to was an oxide of iron. This oxide ig still taken from the ground in Syria and Pal and used for decorative outlining. (14) White: The principal word for denoting whiteness in the Heb was y25 , tdbhan, a distinctive color word. Some of the objects to which it was applied show that it was used as we use the word ‘white’ (Gen 49 12). Mt. Lebanon was proba- bly named because of its snow-tipped peaks (Jer 18 14). White is applied to goats (Gen 30 35); to rods (Gen 30 37); to teeth (Gen 49 12); to leprous hairs and spots (Lev 13; Nu 12 10); to garments (Eccl 9 8; Dnl 7 9); assymbol of purity (Dnl 11 35; 12 10; Isa 1 18); to horses (Zee 1 8; 6 3.6); to tree branches (Joel 1 7); to coriander seed (Ex 16 31). The corresponding Gr word, Aevxés, leukés, isusedin NT. Itis applied to hair (Mt 5 36; Rev 1 14); to raiment (Mt 17 2; 28 3; Mk 9 3; 16 5; Lk 9 29; Jn 20 12: Acts 110; Rev 3 4.5.18; 6 11; 7 9.13.14; 19 14); to horses (Rev 6 2; 19 11.14); to a throne (Rev 20 11); to stone (Rev 2 17); toa cloud (Rev 14 14). Besides labhdn, four other Heb words have been tr? “white”: (a) "11, horz, or “AM, har, meaning “bleached,” applied to bread (Gen 40 16); to linen (Est 16; 8 15); (6) Mx, cah, or WWWX, ¢ahor, lit. “dazzling,” is applied to asses (Jgs 6 10); to human appearance (Cant 5 10); to wool (Ezk 27 18); (c) VI, dar, probably mother of pearl or alabaster (Est 1 6); (d) 17, rir, lit. “‘saliva,” and, from resemblance, ‘‘white of egg” (Job 6 6). (15) Yellow: This word occurs in Est 1 6 to de- scribe pavement; in Lev 13 to describe leprous hair; in Ps 68 13 to describe gold. Mixtures of colors: (a) grizzled (grisled), lit. “spotted as with hail,” applied to goats (Gen 31 10.12); to horses (Zec 6 3.6); (6) ringstreaked (ringstraked), lit. “striped with bands,” applied to animals (Gen 30 35ff; 31 8 ff); (c) speckled, lit. “dotted or spotted,” applied to cattle and goats (Gen 30 32ff; 31 8ff); to a bird (Jer 12 9); to horses (Zec 1 8 AV); (d) spotted, lit. “covered with patches,” applied to cattle and goats (Gen 30 32 ff). In Jude ver 23 “spotted” means “‘defiled.” Figurative: For fig. uses, see under separate colors. Literaturs.—Perrot and Chipiez, History of Art in Ancient Egypt, History of Art in Chaldaea and Assyria, History of Art in Phoenicia and its Dependencies; Wilkin- son, The Ancient Egyptians; Jew Enc; EB; Delitzsch, Tris. James A. PatTcH COLOSSAE, ké-los’é (Kodorral, Kolossat, “punishment”; AV Colosse): A city of Phrygia on the Lycus River, one of the branches of the Maeander, and 3 miles from Mt. Cadmus, 8,018 ft. high. It stood at the head of a gorge where the two streams unite, and on the great high- way traversing the country from Ephesus to the Euphrates valley, 13 miles from Hierapolis and 10 from Laodicea. Its history is chiefly associated with that of these two cities. Early, according to both Herodotus and Xenophon, it was a place of great importance. There Xerxes stopped 481 BC (Herod. vii.30) and Cyrus the Younger marched 401 BC (Xen. Anab. 1.2.6). From Col 2 1 it is not likely that Paul visited the place in person; but its Christianization was due to the efforts of Epa- phras and Timothy (Col 1 1.7), and it was the home of Philemon and Epaphras. That a church was established there early 1s evident from Col 4 12.13; Rev 1 11; 3 14. As the neighboring cities, Hier- apolis and Laodicea, increased in importance, Colossae declined. There were many Jews living there, and a chief article of commerce, for which the place was renowned, was the collossinus, a peculiar wool, probably of a purple color. In religion the people were specially lax, worshipping angels. Of them, Michael was the chief, and the protecting saint of the city. It is said that once he appeared to the people, saving the city in time of a flood. Tt was this belief in angels which called forth Paul’s epistle (Col 2 18). During the 7th and 8th cents. the place was overrun by the Saracens; in the 12th cent. the church was destroyed by the Turks and the city disappeared. Its site was explored by Mr. Hamilton. The ruins of the church, the stone foundation of a large theater, and a necropolis with stones of a peculiar shape are still to be seen. During the Middle Ages the place bore the name of Chonae; it is now called Chonas. E. J. Banxs COLOSSIANS, ké-losh’ans, ké-los‘i-anz, EPIS- TLE TO THE: This is one of the group of St. Paul’s epistles known as the Captivity Epistles (see PuILemMon, Epistie ro, for a discussion of these as a group). I. Authenticity.—The external evidence for the Epistle to the Colossians, prior to the middle of the 2d cent., is rather indeterminate. In 1. External Ignatius and in Polycarp we have here Evidence and.there phrases and terminology that suggest an acquaintance with Col but not much more (Ignat., Ephes., x.3, and Polyc. x.1; cf with Col 1 23). The phrase in Ep Barnabas, xii, “in him are all things and unto him are all things,” may be due to Col 1 16, but it ig quite as possibly a liturgical formula. The references in Justin Martyr’s Dialogue to Christ as the firstborn (pratétokos) are very probably suggested by Col 1 15, ‘the firstborn of all crea- tion” (Dial., 84, 85, 188). The first definite witness is Marcion, who included this epistle in hig collection of those written by St. Paul (Tert., Adv. Mare., v.19). A little later the Muratorian Fragment mentions Col among the Epistles of St. Paul (108, 1. 21, Colo- sensis). Irenaeus quotes it frequently and by name (Adv. haer., iii.14, 1). It is familiar to the writers 677 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Color, Colors Colossians of the following cents. (e.g. Tert., De praescrip., 7; Clem. Alex., Strom., I, 1; One. Contra Celsum, v.8). The authenticity was not questioned until the second quarter of the 19th cent. when Mayerhoff claimed on the ground of style, vo- 2. Internal cabulary, and thought that it was not Evidence by the apostle. The Tiibingen school claimed, on the basis of a supposed Gnosticism, that the epistle was the work of the 2d cent. and so not Pauline, This position has been thoroughly answered by showing that the teaching is essentially different from the Gnosticism of the 2d cent., esp. in the conception of Christ as prior to and greater than all things created (see V below). The attack in later years has been chiefly on the ground of vocabulary and style, the doctrinal position, esp. the Christology and the teaching about angels, and the relation to the Ephesian epistle. ‘The objection on the ground of vocabulary and style is based, as is so often the case, on the assumption that a man, no matter what he writes about, must use the same words and style. There are thirty-four words in Col which are not in any other NT book. When one removes those that are due to the difference in subject-matter, the total is no greater than that of some of the acknowledged epistles. The omission of familiar Pauline par- ticles, the use of genitives, of “all” (pds), and of synonyms, find parallels in other epistles, or are due to a difference of subject, or perhaps to the influence on the language of the apostle of his life in Rome (von Soden). The doctrinal position is not at heart contradictory to St- Paul’s earlier teaching (cf Godet, Intro NT; St. Paul’s Epistles, 440f). The Christology is in entire harmony with Phil (q.v.) which is generally admitted as Paulinc, and is only a development of the teaching in 1 Cor (8 6; 15 24-28), esp. in respect of the emphasis laid on ‘the cosmical activity of the preincarnate Christ.” Finally, the form in which St. Paul puts the Christology is that best calculated to meet the false teaching of the Colossian heretics (cf V below). In recent, years H. Holtzmann has advocated that this epistle is an interpolated form of an original Pauline epistle to the Colossians, and the work of the author of the Epistle to the Ephesians (q.v.). A modifi- cation of this theory of interpolation has recently been suggested by J. Weiss (TLZ, September 29, 1900). Both these theories are too complicated to “stand, and even von Soden, who at first followed Holtzmann, has abandoned the position (von Soden, Einl., 12); while Sanday (DB?) has shown how utterly untenable it is. Sober criticism today has come to realize that it is impossible to deny the Pauline authorship of this epistle. This position is strengthened by the close relationship between Col and Philem, of which Renan says: ‘Paul alone, so it would seem, could have written this little master- piece” (Abbott, /CC, lviii). If Philem (q.v.) stands as Pauline, as it must, then the authenticity of Col is established beyond controversy. Hf. Place and Date.—The Pauline authorship being established, it becomes evident at once that the apostle wrote Col along with the other Cap- tivity Epistles, and that itis best dated from Rome (see Puinemon, Epistu& To), and during the first captivity. This would be about 58 or, if the later chronology is preferred, 63 or 64. HL Destination.—The epistle was written, on the face of it, to the church at CoLossaz (q.v.), a town in the Lycus valley where the gospel had been preached most probably by Epaphras (Col 1 7; 4 12), and where St. Paul was, himself, unknown personally (1 4.8.9; 21.5). From the epistle it is evident that the Colossian Christians were Gen- tiles (1 27) for whom, as such, the apostle feels a responsibility (2 1 ff). He sends to them Tychicus (4 7), who is accompanied by Onesimus, onc of their own community (4 9), and urges them to be sure to read another letter which will reach them from Laodicea (4 16). IV. Relation to Other NT Writings.—Beyond the connection with Eph (q.v.) we need notice only the relation between Col and Rev. In the letter to Laodicea (Rev 3 14-21) we have two expressions: “the beginning of the creation of God,” and “TI will give to him to sit down with me in my throne,” in which we have an echo of Col which ‘suggests an acquaintance with and recognition of the earlier apostle’s teaching on the part of St. John” (Light- foot, Col, 42, n. 5). V. The Purpose.—The occasion of the epistle was, we may be sure, the information brought by Epaphras that the church in Colossae was subject to the assault of a body of Judaistic Christians who were seeking to overthrow the faith of the Colossians and weaken their regard for St. Paul (Zahn). This “heresy,’”’ as it is commonly called, has had many explanations. The Titbingen school taught that it was gnostic, and sought to find in the terms the apostle used evidence for the 2d cent. composi- tion of the epistle. Plérdma and gnésis (“fulness”’ and “knowledge’) not only do not require this interpretation, but will not admit it. The very heart of Gnosticism, i.e. the theory of emanation and the dualistic conception which regards matter as evil, finds no place in Col. The use of pléroma in this and the sister epistle, Eph, does not imply gnostic views, whether held by the apostle or by the readers of the letters. The significance in Col of this and the other words adopted by Gnosticism in later years is quite distinct from that later mean- ing. The underlying teaching is equally distinct. The Christ of the Colossians is not the aeon Christ of Gnosticism. In Essenism, on the other hand, Lightfoot and certain Germans seek the origin of this heresy. Essenism has certain affinities with Gnosticism on the one side and Judaism on the other. Two objections are raised against this explanation of the origin of the Colossian heresy. In the first place Essenism, as we know it, is found in the neighbor- hood of the Dead Sea, and there is no evidence for its establishment in the Lycus valley. In the second place, no references are found in Col to certain dis- tinct. Essene teachings, e.g. those about marriage, washings, commynism, Sabbath rules, etc. The Colossian heresy is due to Judaistic influ- ences on the one hand and to native beliefs and superstitions on the other. The Judaistic elements in this teaching are patent, circumcision (2 11), the Law (2 14.15), and special seasons (2 16). But there is more than Judaism in this false teach- ing. Its teachers look to intermediary spirits, angels whom they worship; and insist on a very strict asceticism. To seek the origin of angel wor- ship in Judaism, as is commonly done, is, as A. L. Williams has shown, to miss the real significance of the attitude of the Jews to angels and to mag- nify the bitter jeers of Celsus. Apart from phrascs used in exorcism and magic he shows us that there is no evidence that the Jew ever worshipped angels (JTS, X, 413). This element in the Colossian heresy was local, finding its antecedent in the wor- ship of the river spirits, and in later years the same tendency gave the impulse to the worship of St. Michael as the patron saint of Colossae (so too Ramsay, HDB, s.v. “Colossac’). The ‘danger of and the falsehood in this teaching were twofold. In the first place it brought the gospel under the bands of the Law once more, not now with the formality of the Galatian opponents, but none the less surely. But as the apostle’s readers are Gen- tiles (1 27) St. Paul is not terested in showing the preparatory aspect of the Law. He simply insists Colt Commandment THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 678 to them that they are quite free from all obligations of the Law because Christ, in whom they have been baptized (2 12), has blotted out all the Law (2 14). The second danger is that their belief in and worship of the heavenly powers, false ideas about Christ and the material world, would develop even further than it had. They, because of their union with Him, need fear no angelic being. Christ has triumphed over them all, leading them as it were captives in His train (2 15), as He conquered on the cross. The spiritual powers cease to have any authority over the Christians. It is to set Christ forward, in this way, as Head over all creation as very God, and out of His relation to the church and to the universe to develop the Christian life, that the apostle writes. VI. Argament.—The argument of the Epistle is as follows: 1 1.2: Salutation. 1 3-8: Thanksgiving for their faith in Christ, their love for the saints, their hope laid up in heaven, which they had in and through the gospel and of which he had heard from Epaphras. 1 9-13: Prayer that they might be filled with the full knowledge of God’s will so as to walk worthy of the Lord and to be fruitful in good works, thank- ful for their inheritance of the kingdom of His Son. 1 14-23: Statement of the Son’s position, from whom we have redemption. He is the very image of God, Creator, preéxistent, the Head of the church, preéminent over all, in whom all the ful- ness (pléroma) dwells, the Reconciler of all things, as also of the Colossians, through His death, pro- vided they are faithful to the hope of the gospel. 1 24—2 5: By his suffering he is filling up the sufferings of Christ, of whom he is a minister, even to reveal the great mystery of the ages, that Christ is in them, the Gentiles, the hope of glory, the object of the apostle’s preaching everywhere. This explains Paul’s interest in them, and his care for them, that their hearts may be strengthened in the love and knowledge of Christ. 2 6—3 4: He then passes to exhortation against those who are leading them astray, these false teachers of a vain, deceiving philosophy based on worldly wisdom, who ignore the truth of Christ’s position, as One in whom all the Divine plérama dwells, and their relation to Him, united by baptism; raised through the faith; quickened and forgiven; who teach the obligation of the observance of va- rious legal practices, strict asceticisms and angel worship. This exhortation is closed with the ap- peal that as Christ’s they will not submit to these regulations of men which are useless, esp. in com- parison with Christ’s power through the Resurrec- tion. 3 5-17: Practical exhortations follow to real mortification of the flesh with its characteristics, and the substitution of a new life of fellowship, love and eace. 3 18—4 1: Exhortation to fulfil social obligations, as wives, husbands, children, parents, slaves and masters. 4 2-6: Exhortation to devout and watchful prayer. 4 7-18: Salutations and greeting. LitERATURE.—Lightfoot, St. Paul's Epistles to the Colossians and Philemon; Abbott, Ephesians and Colos- sians, ICC; Peake, Colossians, Expositor’s Greek Testament; Maclaren, Colossians, Expositor’s Bible; Alexander, Colos- sians and Ephesians, Bible for Home and School; Moule, Colossians, Cambridge Bible; Haupt, Meyer's Krit. u. Exeg. Kom.; von Soden, Hand-Kom. zum NT. C. 8. Lewis COLT, kilt (FOAL) ("Y, ‘ayir, Ja, ben; wados, polos, vids, huids, with some word such as trofvylou, hupozugiou, understood; huios alone=“‘son’’): The Eng. words “‘colt”’ and “foal” are used in the Bible of the ass everywhere except in Gen 32 15, where the word “colt” is used of the camel in the list of animals destined by Jacob as presents for Esau. In most cases ‘ayir (ef Arab. ‘air, ‘‘ass’’) means ‘‘ass’s colt,” but it may be joined with ben, “son,” as in Zec 9 9, where we have: ‘al-hdmér w*‘al-‘ayir ben- "dthondth, lit. ‘‘on an ass, and on an ass’s colt, the son of the she-asses”; cf Mt 21 5: éwt dvov xai ért radov vidy Uro{vylov, epi énon kai epi pélon huién hupozu- giou, “upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass.” In Jn 12 15 we have émt wadov vou, epi pilon 6nou, and in the previous ver the diminutive, évdpuoy, ondrion. The commonest NT word for ‘‘colt’’ is polos, akin to which is Ger. Fohle and Eng. “foal” and “filly.” The Lat pullus signifies either “foal” or ‘‘chicken,”’ and in the latter sense gives rise to Fr. poulet and Eng. “pullet.”’ ’ In view of the fact that horses are but little men- tioned in the Bible, and that only in connection with royal equipages and armies, it is not surprising that ‘colt’? does not occur in its ordinary Eng. sense. Atrrep Exy Day COME, kum: The tr of many Heb and Gr words. In the phrase “The Spirit of Jeh came mightily upon him” (Jgs 14 6.19; 15 14; 1S 10 10; 11 6; 16 13), the word is ¢alé*h; Jgs 14 6; 15 14 “came mightily,” which is the uniform tr of RV (cf 13 25 “to move,” i.e. to disturb or stir up). In Jgs 6 34; 1 Ch 12 18; 2 Ch 24 20, it is labhesh, “‘to clothe”; RVm “The Spirit .... Clothed itself with Gideon” and... . ‘with Zechariah,” “The Spirit clothed Amasai.” Among its many changes, RV has ‘‘come forth” for “come” (Mt 26); “gone up” for (14 32, a different text); “come all the way” for “come” (Jn 4 15); “got out upon the’ for “come to” (219); “draw near’ for “come” (He 4 16); “eome” for “come and see’? (Rev 6 1); ‘‘secure”’ for “come by” (Acts 27 16); “attain unto” for “come in” (Eph 4 13); and ‘I come” for “I come again” (Jn 14 28). W. L. Wanker COMELINESS, kum’li-nes, COMELY, kum’li: Cognate with “becoming,” viz. what is suitable, graceful, handsome. The servant of Jeh in Isa 53 2 is without ‘‘comeliness” (hadhdér, “honor’’), i.e. there is in his appearance nothing attractive, while he is bowed beneath man’s sin. ‘‘Praise is comely” (na’wah, f. of n@weh; Ps 33 1; 147 1), ie. suitable or befitting “for the righteous,’’ and, there- fore, an honor and glory; “uncomely parts,” asché- mona (1 Cor 12 23), viz. less honorable. See also 1S 16 18, “a comely person”; Cant 6 4, ‘‘comely as Jerus,’’ etc. COMFORT, kum’fért (072, ndham; wapaxadto, parakaléd): The NT word is variously tr’, as “comfort,” “exhort,” “beseech,” the exact tr to be determined by the context. Etymologically, it is “to call alongside of,” i.e. to summon for assistance. To comfort is to cheer and encourage. It has a positive force wanting in its synonym “console,” as it indicates the dispelling of grief by the imparta- tion of strength. RV has correctly changed the tr of paramuthéomai from AV “comfort,” to “consola- tion.” Soin the OT, “Comfort ye my people” (Isa 40 1) is much stronger than ‘‘console,” which affords only the power of calm endurance of affliction, while the brightest hopes of the future and the highest incentives to present activity are the gifts of the Divine grace that is here bestowed. H. E. Jacoss COMFORTABLY, kum’fér-ta-bli (29759, ‘al labh, “to the heart’): “To speak to the heart,” i.e. to speak kindly, to console, to comfort, is the ordinary Heb expression for wooing: e.g. Boaz spake “‘to the 679 heart” of Ruth (Ruth 213m; AV “friendly,” RV “kindly”). The beauty of the Heb term is illus- trated in Gen 60 21 where Joseph “spake kindly” unto his brethren, winning them from fear to con- fidence. Rendered ‘‘comfortably” in five passages: thrice of human speaking, and twice of the tender- ness of God’s address to His people. David was urged to win back the hearts of the people by kind words: “speak comfortably” (2 8 19 7). Hezekiah in like manner comforted the Levites (2 Ch 30 22) and encouraged his captains (2 Ch 32 6). The term has exceptional wealth of meaning in connection with God’s message of grace and forgiveness to His redeemed people. The compassionate love that has atoned for their sins speaks to the heart (“‘comfort- ably’) of Jerus, saying “that her iniquity is par- doned” (Isa 40 2). Thesame promise of forgiveness is given to the penitent nation by the prophet Hosea (Hos 2 14); “comfortable words’ (Zec 1 13), i.e. words affording comfort. Dwicat M. Pratt COMFORTER, kum’fér-tér: This is a tr of the word rapdk\yros, pardklétes, in the Johannine writ- ings. In the Gospel it occurs in 14 16.26; 15 26; 16 7, and refers to the Holy Spirit. The word means lit. “called to one’s side” for help. The tr “Comforter” covers only a small part of the mean- ing as shown in the context. The word “Helper” would be a more adequate tr. The Spirit does a great deal for disciples besides comforting them, although to comfort was a part of His work for them. 'The Spirit guides into truth; indeed, He is called the Spirit of truth. He teaches and quickens the memory of disciples and glorifies Christ in them. He also has a work io do in the hearts of unbelievers, convicting the world of sin, of righteous- ness, and of judgment (Jn 14-16). The Comforter remains permanently with disciples after He comes in response to the prayers of Christ. The word paraklétos does not occur elsewhere in the Scriptures except in 1 Jn 21. In Job 16 2 the active form of the word (paraklétos is passive) is found in the pl., where Job calls his friends “miserable comforters.” The word ‘Comforter’ being an inadequate, and the word ‘Helper’ a too indefinite, tr of the word in the Gospel of John, it would probably be best to transfer the Gr word into Eng. in so far as it relates to the Holy Spirit (see PARACLETE). In 1 Jn 2 1 the word paraklétos refers to Christ: “If any man sin, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.” Here the tr Advocate is quite correct. As the next ver shows the writer has in mind the intercession of Christ for Christians on the basis of His mediatorial work: ‘And he is the propitiation for our sins; and not for ours only, but also for the whole world” (1 Jn 2 2). See ApvocaTE; Hoty Spirit; Parac.ere. E. Y. Mvoiins COMFORTLESS, kum’fért-les (oppavois, orpha- nots, orphans’): The Gr original is found but twice in the NT; rendered ‘“‘comfortless” in Jn 14 18,RV “desolate”; “fatherless” in Jas 1 27 (cf Ps 68 5). The term signifies bereft of a father, parents, guardian, teacher, guide, and indicates what must be the permanent ministry of the Holy Spirit to the disciples of Jesus, in comforting their hearts. In harmony with these parting words Jesus had called the chosen twelve “little children” (Jn 13 33); with- out. Him they would be “orphans,” comfortless desolate. The coming of the Holy Spirit would make Christ and the Father forever real to them, an abiding spiritual presence. Dwicat M. Pratr COMING OF CHRIST. See Apvent; PARov- SIA. ‘COMING, SECOND. See Parovusia. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Colt Commandment COMMANDMENT, ké-mand’ment, COM- MANDMENTS (112%, migwah; évroh4, entolé): The commandments are, first of all, prescriptions, or direc- tions of God, concerning particular matters, which He wanted observed with reference to circumstances as they arose, in a period when He spake immediately and with greater frequency than afterward. They were numerous, minute, and regarded as codrdinate and independent of each other. In the Ten Com- mandments, or, more properly, Ten Words, EVm (0°73, d*bharim), they are reduced to a few all- comprehensive precepts of permanent validity, upon which every duty required of man isbased. Certain prescriptions of temporary force, as those of the ceremonial and forensic laws, are applications of these ‘‘Words” to transient circumstances, and, for the time for which they were enacted, demanded perfect and unconditional obedience. The Pass, and esp. Ps 119, show that even under the OT, there was a deep spiritual appreciation of these commandments, and the extent to which obedience was deemed a privilege rather than a mere matter of constrained external compliance with duty. In the NT, Jesus shows in Mt 22 37.40; Mk 12 29. 81; Lk 10 27 (ef Rom 13 8.10) their organic unity. The “Ten” are reduced to two, and these two to one principle, that of love. In love, obe- dience begins, and works from within outward. Under the NT the commandments are kept when they are written upon the heart (He 10 16). While in the Synoptics they are referred to in a more abstract and distant way, in both the Gospel and the Epp. of Jn their relation to Jesus is most prominent. They are ‘my commandments” (Jn 14 15.21; 16 10.12); “my Father's’ (Jn 10 18; 15 10); or, many times throughout the epp., “his lie. Christ’s] commandments.” The new life in Christ enkindles love, and not ouly makes the com- mandments the rule of life, but the life itself the free expression of the commandments and of the nature of God, in which the commandments are grounded. Occasionally the word is used in the singular collect- ively (Ex 24 12; Ps 119 96; 1 Cor 14 37). See Ten ComMANnDMENTs, THE. H. E. Jacoss COMMANDMENT, THE NEW, ni (évroA\q Kaw, entolé kainé): The word ‘commandment’ is used in the Eng. VSS of the OT to translate several Heb words, more esp. those meaning ‘‘word” (dda- bhar) as the ten words of God (Ex 34 28) or king’s “command” (Est 1 12); “precept” (migwah) of God (Dt 4 2), of a king (2 K 18 36); “mouth” or “speech” (peh) of God (Ex 17 1), of Pharaoh (2 K 23 35). They express the theocratic idea of morality wherein the will or law of God is imposed upon men as their law of conduct (2 K 17 37). This idea is not repudiated in the NT, but sup- plemented or modified from within by making love the essence of the command. Jesus 1. Christ Christ, as reported in the Synoptics, and the Old came not “‘to destroy the law or the Command- prophets... . but to fulfil” (Mt 5 ment 17). He taught that ‘whosoever there- fore shall break one of these least com- mandments, and shall teach men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven” (Mt 5 19). He condemned the Pharisees for rejecting the command- ments of God as given by Moses (Mk 7 8-18). There ig a sense in which it is true that Christ pro- pounded no new commandment, but the new thing in His teaching was the emphasis laid on the old commandment of love, and the extent and intent of its application. The great commandment is “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God, . . . - [and] thy neighbor as thyself. On these two commandments the whole law hangeth, and the prophets” (Mt 22 34-40; Mk 12 28-34; ef Dt 6 5; Lev 19 18). Commandments Commentaries THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 680 When the law realizes itself as love for God and man in men’s hearts, it ceases to bear the aspect of a command. The force of authority 2. Principle and the active resistance or inertia of instead of the subject disappear; the law be- Law comes a principle, a motive, a joyous harmony of man’s will with the will of God; and in becoming internal, it becomes uni- versal and transcends all distinctions of race or class. Even this was not an altogether new idea (cf Jer 31 31-34; Ps 51); nor did Christ’s con- temporaries and disciples think it was. The revolutionary factor was the death of Christ wherein the love of God was exempli- 3. Christ’s fied and made manifest as the basis Love Ful- and principle of all spiritual life filled in (Jn 13 34). Paul therefore general- Death Be- izes all pre-Christian morality as a comes the system of law and commandments, Law of the standing in antithesis to the grace and Church love which are through Jesus Christ (Rom 5-7). Believers in Christ felt their experience and inward life to be so changed and new, that it needed a new term (agdpé= “‘love’’) to express their ideal of conduct (see CHARITY). Another change that grew upon the Christian con- sciousness, following from the resurrection and ascension of Christ, was the idea that He was the permanent source of the principle of life. ‘Jesus is Lord” (1 Cor 12 3). Hence in the Johannine writings the principle described by the new term agapé is associated with Christ’s lordship and sol- emnly described as His ‘new commandment.” “A new commandment I give unto you, that ye love one another; even as I have loved you, that ye also love one another” .(Jn 13 34). To the Christians of the end of the Ist cent. it was already an old commandment which they had from the beginning of the Christian teaching (1 Jn 2 7; 2 Jn 5); but it was also a new commandment which ever came with new force to men who were passing from the darkness of hatred to the 4. The New light of love (1 Jn 2 8-11). The term Revelation in the Gospel we may owe to the evangelist, but it brings into relief an element in the consciousness of Jesus which the author of the Fourth Gospel had appreciated more fully than the Synoptists. Jesus was aware that He was the bearer of a special message from the Father (Jn 12 49; Mt 11 27), that He fulfilled His mission in His death of love and self-sacrifice (Jn 10 18), and that the mission fulfilled gave Him authority over the lives of men, ‘“‘even as I have loved you, that ye also love one another.” The full meaning of Christ’s teaching was only real- ized when men had experienced and recognized the significance of His death as the cause and principle of right conduct. The Synoptists saw Christ’s teaching as the development of the prophetic teaching of the OT. Paul and John felt that the love of God in Christ was a new thing: (a) new as a revelation of God in Christ, (6) new as a principle of life in the church, and (c) new as a union of be- lievers with Christ. While it is love, it is also a commandment of Christ, calling forth the joyous obedience of believers. See also Broruerty Love. T. Regs COMMANDMENTS, THE TEN. See Com- MANDMENT; TEN COMMANDMENTS. COMMEND, ké-mend’: (1) For raparl@np., paratithémi (Lk 23 46), trans- lating the Heb pakadh (Ps 31 5), in the dying words of Jesus: “Into thy hands I commend my spirit.” AV in Ps has the more general word ‘‘commit.” The use of the Gr word in the sense of “deposit what belongs to one into the hands of another” is | not uacommon in the classics. So also the deriva- tives parathéké (2 Tim 1 12) and parakatathéké (1 Tim 6 20; 2 Tim 1 14). See Deposit. This sense of the Eng., while slightly archaic, corresponds to the first meaning of the Lat, whence it comes, “to com- mit for preservation,” esp. of the dying; to commend children, parents, etc, to the care of others (for examples, see Harper’s Latin Dictionary). (2) For cuviornut, suntstémi, “to stand together,” and then, by standing together, to establish, prove, exhibit, as “righteousness” and “love of God” (Rom 3 5; 5 8), and thus to attest (2 Cor 3 1; 4 2), and, finally, to certify or to recommend a stranger (Rom 16 1; 2 Cor 6 4). The use of paristémi in 1 Cor 8 8 is equivalent. i (3) “To praise,” éravéw, epainéd (Lk 16 8), and sunistemi in 2 Cor 10 12.18; for the OT, Heb hilié., in Gen 12 15 AV; Prov 12 8. H. E. Jacops COMMENTARIES, kom’en-ta-riz: Tre Worp—GENBRAL SCOPE DirFERENCES IN CHARACTER OF COMMENTARIES Rane or COMMENTARIES 1. Early Commentaries 1) Origen, etc 2) Chrysostom, etc 2. Schoiastic Period Nicolas de Lyra 3. Reformation and Post-Reformation Perlods (1) Luther and Calvin (2) Beza, Grotius, etc (3) Later Writers 4. 18th Century &) Calmet, M. Henry, etc II. Ii. 2) Patrick, Lowth, Scott 3) Gill, Doddridge (4) Bengel 5. The Modern Period—Its Characteristics (1) Germany (a) The Liberal School (b) Believing Tendency a) Conservative B cruel ediatin| is Confessional : (ec) Godet (Swiss) (2) Britain and America 3 Alford, Eadie | 6) Ellicott and Lightfoot c) Westcott ey Critical Influences—Broad Church Stanley and Jowett (e) Generai Commentaries (Series) 6. Recent Period (1) Germany (2) Britain and America LITERATURE I. The Word—General Scope—Etymologically, a commentary (from Lat commentor) denotes Jottings, annotations, memoranda, on a given subject, or perhaps on a series of events; hence its use in the pl. as a designation for a narrative or history, as the Commentaries of Caesar. In its application to Scripture, the word designates a work devoted to the explanation, elucidation, illustration, sometimes the homiletic expansion and edifying utilization, of the text of some book or portion of Scripture. The primary function of a good commentary is to furnish an exact interpretation of the meaning of the passage under consideration; it belongs to it also to show the connection of ideas, the steps of argu- ment, the scope and design of the whole, in the writing in question. This can only be successfully accomplished by the help of a knowledge of the original language of the writing, and of the histori- cal setting of the particular passage; by careful study of the context, and of the author’s general usages of thought and speech; and by comparison of parallel or related texts. Aid may also be ob- tained from external sources, as a knowledge of the history, archaeology, topography, chronology manners and customs, of the lands, peoples and times referred to; or, as in Deissmann’s recent dis- coveries, from the light thrown on peculiarities of language by papyri or other ancient remains (see his Light from the Ancient East). : 681 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Commandments Commentaries Il. Differences in Character.—It is obvious that commentaries will vary greatly in character and value according as they are more scholarly, techni- eal, and critical, entering, e.g. into philological dis- cussions, and tabulating and remarking upon the various views held as to the meaning; or again, more popular, aiming only at bringing out the general sense, and conveying it to the mind of the reader in attractive and edifying form. When the practical motive predominates, and the treatment is greatly enlarged by illustration, application, and the en- forcement of lessons, the work loses the character of commentary proper, and partakes more of the character of homily or discourse. Hl, Range of Commentaries.—No book in the world has been made the subject of so much com- menting and exposition as the Bible. Theological libraries are full of commentaries of all descriptions and all grades of worth. Some are commentaries on the original Heb or Gr texts; some on the Eng. or other VSS. Modern commentaries are usually accompanied with some measure of introduction to the books commented upon; the more learned works have commonly also some indication of the data for the determination of the textual readings (see Criticism, TexTuaL). Few writers are equal to the task of commenting with profit on the Bible as a whole, and, with the growth of knowledge, this task is now seldom attempted. Frequently, haw- ever, one writer contributes many valuable works, and sometimes, by codperation of like-minded scholars, commentaries on the whole Bible are pro- duced. It ig manifestly a very slight survey that can be taken in a brief art. of the work of comment- ing, and of the literature to which it has given rise; the attempt can only be made to follow the lines most helpful to those seeking aid from this class of books. On the use and abuse of commentaries by the preacher, C. H. Spurgeon’s racy remarks in his Commenting and Commentaries may be con- sulted. Rabbinical interpretations and paraphrases of the OT may here be left out of account (see next art.; also Tarcums; TaLmup; 1. Early Farrar’s History of Interpretation, Commen- Lect JI). Commentaries on the NT taries could not begin till the NT books themselves were written, and had ac- quired some degree of authority as sacred writings (see Brsue). The earliest commentaries we hear of are from the heretical circles of the Gnostics. Heracleon, a Valentinian (cir 175 AD), wrote a commentary on the Gospel of John (fragments in Origen), and on parts at least of the Gospel of Luke. Tatian, a disciple of Justin Martyr, about the same time, compiled his Diatessaron, or Harmony of the Four Gospels, on which, at a later time, commen- taries weré written. Ephraem Syrus (4th cent.) wrote such a commentary, of which an Armenian tr has now been recovered. The Church Father Hippolytus (beginning of 3d cent.), wrote several commentaries on the OT (Ex, Pss, Prov, Eccl, Dnl, Zec, etc), and on Mt, Lk and Rev. (1) Origen, etc—The strongest impulse, however, to the work of commenting and exposition of Holy Scripture undoubtedly proceeded from the school of Alexandria—esp. from Origen (203-54 AD). Clement, Origen’s predecessor, had written a trea- tise called Hupotupésets, or “Outlines,” a survey of the contents of Holy Scripture. Origen himself wrote commentaries on all the books of the OT, Ruth, Est and Eccl alone excepted, and on most of the books of the NT (Mk, 1 and 2 Cor, 1 and 2 Pet, 1, 2, and 3 Jn, Jas, Jude, Rev excepted). He furnished besides, scholia, or notes on difficult pas- sages, and delivered Homilies, or discourses, the records of which fill three folio volumes. ‘“‘By his | torical statements (Farrar, op. cit., 189 ff). Tetrapla and Herapla,” says Farrar, “he became the founder of all textual criticism; by his Homilies he fixed the type of a popular exposition; his scholia were the earliest specimens of marginal explanations; his commentaries furnished the church with her first continuous exegesis’ (op. cit., 188). Un- fortunately the Alexandrian school adopted a prin- ciple of allegorical interpretation which led it frequently into the most extravagant fancies. As- suming a threefold sense in Scripture—a literal, a moral, and a spiritual—it gave reins to caprice in foisting imaginary meanings on the simplest his- Some of Origen’s commentaries, however, are much freer from allegory than others, and all possess high value (cf Lightfoot, Galatians, 217). The later teachers of the Alexandrian school continued the exegeti- cal works of Origen. Pamphilus of Caesarea, the friend of Eusebius, is said to have written OT com- mentaries. (2) Chrysostom, etc—At the opposite pole from the allegorizing Alexandrian school of interpretation was the Antiochian, marked by a sober, literal and grammatical style of exegesis. Its reputed founder was Lucian (martyred 311 AD); but its real heads were Diodorus of Tarsus( 379-94 AD) and Theo- dore of Mopsuestia (893-428 AD); and its most distneuidhed. representative was John Chrysostom (847-407 AD). Chrysostom wrote continuous commentaries on Isa (only 1—8 10 remaining) and on Gal; but his chief contributions were his Homi- lies, covering almost the whole of the OT and NT. Of these over 600 remain, chiefly on the NT. They are unequal in character, those on Acts being re- puted the feeblest; others, as those on Mt, Rom and Cor, are splendid examples of expository teaching. Schaff speaks of Chrysostom as “‘the prince of com- mentators among the Fathers’’ ( Hist., Ante-Nicene Per., 816). Thomas Aquinas is reported to have said that he would rather possess Chrysostom’s homilies on Mt than be master of all Paris. In the West, Ambrose of Milan (340-97 AD) wrote exposi- tions of OT histories and of Lk (allegorical and typical), and Jerome (346-420 AD) wrote numerous commentaries on OT and NT books, largely, how- ever, compilations from others. The mediaeval and scholastic period offers little for our purpose. There was diligence in copying MSS, and producing catenae of the 2. Scholas- opinions of the Fathers; in the case tic Period of the schoolmen, in building up elaborate systems of theology; but the Scriptures were thrown into the background. Nicolas de Lyra.—The 14th cent., however, pro- duced one commentator of real eminence—Nicolas de Lyra (1270-1340). Nicolas was a Franciscan monk, well versed in Heb and rabbinical learning. While recognizing the usual distinctions of the various senses of Scripture, he practically builds on the literal, and exhibits great sobriety and skill in his interpretations. His work, which bears the name Postiliae Perpetuae in Universa Biblia, was much esteemed by Luther, who acknowledged his indebtedness to it. Hence the jest of his oppo- nents, St Lyra non lyrasset, Lutherus non saltasset (a notice of Lyra may be seen in Farrar, op. cit., 274-78). The Reformation brought men’s minds back to the Scriptures and opened a new era, in Bib. exposi- tion and commentary. It became 3. Refor- _ the custom to expound the Scriptures mation and on Sundays and week-days in all the Post-Refor- pulpits of the Protestant churches. mation “Luther’s custom was to expound Periods consecutively in a course of sermons the Old and New Testaments” (KXést- lin). The Reformation began at Ztrich with a Commentaries THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 682 series of discourses by Zwingli on the Gospel of Mt. The same was true of Calvin, Beza, Knox and all associated with them. The production of commen- taries or expository homilies was the necessary result. (1) Luther and Calvin.—As outstanding examples may be mentioned Luther’s Commentary on Gal, and the noble commentaries of Calvin. Not all by any means, but very many of the commentaries of Cal- vin were the fruit of pulpit prelections (e.g. the ex- positions of Job, the Minor Prophets, Jer, Dnl). Others, as the commentaries on Rom and the Pss (reputed his best), were prepared with great care. Calvin’s supreme excellence as a commentator is dis- puted by no one. From every school and shade of opinion in Christendom could be produced a chorus of testimony to the remarkable gifts of mind and heart displayed in his expositions of Scripture—to his breadth, moderation, fairness and modernness of spirit, in exhibiting the sense of inward genius of Holy Writ. The testimony of Arminius is as striking as any: “I exhort my pupils to peruse Calvin’s com- mentaries . . . . for I affirm that he excels beyond comparison in the interpretation of Scripture, and that his commentaries ought to be more highly valued than all that is handed down to us by the library of the Fathers.” (2) Beza, Grotius, etc.— Lutheranism had its distinguished exegetes (Brenz, d. 1572), who wrote able commentaries on the OT, and in both the Calvinistic and Arminian branches of the Reformed church the production of commentaries held a chief place. Beza, Calvin’s successor, is acknowl- edged to have possessed many of the best exegetical qualities which characterized his master. Grotius, in Holland (d. 1645), occupies the foremost place among the expositors in this cent. on the Arminian side. His exegetical works, if not marked by much spirituality, show sagacity and learning, and are enriched by parallels from classical literature. The school of Cocceius (d. 1669) developed the doctrine of the covenants, and revelled in typology. Coc- ceius wrote commentaries on nearly all the books of Scripture. His pupil Vitringa (d. 1716) gained re- nown by his expositions of Isa and the Apocalypse. (3) Later writers—Partly fostered by the habit of basing commentary on pulpit exposition, the tendency early set in to undue prolixity in the unfolding of the meaning of Scripture. “In the Lutheran church,” says Van Oosterzee, “they began to preach on whole books of the Bible; sometimes in a very prolix manner, as, e.g. in the case of the 220 sermons by one Striegnitz, a preacher at Meis- sen, on the history of Jonah, of which four are devoted to the consideration of the words ‘Unto Jonah’ ”’ (Practical Theol., 120). The habit spread. The commentaries of Peter Martyr (Swiss Reform- er, d. 1562) on Jgs and Rom occupy a folio each; N. Byfield (Puritan, d. 1622) on Col fills a folio; Caryl (Independent, d. 1673) on Job extends to 2 folios; Durham (d. 1658) on Isa 53 consists of 72 sermons; Venema (Holland, d. 1787) on Jer fills 2 quartos, and on the Pss no less than 6 quartos. These are only samples of a large class. H. Ham- mond’s A Paraphrase and Annotations on the NT. from an Arminian Standpoint belong to this period (1675). Another work which long took high rank is M. Poole’s elaborate Synopsis Criticorum Bibli- corum (5 vols, folio, 1669-76)—a summary of the opinions of 150 Bib. critics; with which must be taken his Eng. Annotations on the Holy Bible, only completed up to Isa 68 at the time of his death (1679). The work was continued by his friends. (1) Calmet, M. Henry, etc—The 18th cent. is marked by greater sobriety in exegesis. It is pro- lific in commentaries, but only a few attain to high distinction. Calmet (d. 1757), alearned Benedictine, on the Roman Catholic side, produced his Com- mentaire littéral sur tous les livres del’ Ancien et du Nouveau Testament, in 23 quarto vols 4, 18th —a work of immense erudition, though Century now necessarily superseded in its in- formation. On the Protestant side, Matthew Henry’s celebrated Exposition of the Old and New Testament (1708-10) easily holds the first place among devotional commentaries for its blending of good sense, quaintness, original and felicitous remark, and genuine insight into the meaning of the sacred writers. Itis, of course, not a critical work in the modern acceptation, and often is unduly diffuse. M. Henry’s work extends only to the end of Acts; the remaining books were done by various writers after his death (1714). Le Clere (d. 1736) may be named as precursor of the critical views now obtaining on the composition and authorship of the Pent. His commentaries began with Gen in 1693 and were not completed till 1731. Other commentators of note of Arminian views were Daniel Whitby (d. 1726; converted to Arianism), and, later, Adam Clarke, Wesleyan (1762-1832), whose work extends into the next cent. Clarke’s Commentary on the Holy Scriptures (1810-26), still held by many in high esteem, is marred to some extent by eccentricities of opinion. (2) Patrick, Lowth, Scott.—In the Anglican church the names of chief distinction in this cent. are Bishop Patrick, Bishop Lowth, and later Thomas Scott. Bishop Patrick, usually classed with the Cambridge Platonists (d. 1707), contributed paraphrases and commentaries on the OT from Gen to Cant, while Bishop Lowth (d. 1787) acquired last- ing fame by his Prelections on Heb Poetry, and A New Translation, with Notes on Isaiah. He was among the first to treat the poetical and prophetic writings really as literature. The commentaries of Patrick and Lowth were subsequently combined with those of Whitby and other divines (Arnold, etc) to form a complete Critical Commentary (1809), which went through many editions. The well-known commentary of Thomas Scott (1747-1821), repre- senting a moderate Calvinism, is a solid and ‘ju- dicious’” piece of work, inspired by an earnest, believing spirit, though not presenting any marked originality or brilliance. Brilliance is not the characteristic of many commentators of this age. (3) Gill, Doddridge.— Two -other Eng. writers deserving notice are Dr. John Gill (d. 1771; Cal- vinistic Baptist), who wrote Expositions on the OT and the NT and a separate Exposition of the Song of Solomon—learned, but ponderous and controver- sial; and Dr. Philip Doddridge (d. 1751), whose Family Expositor, embracing the entire NT, with a harmony of the Gospels, and paraphrases of the meaning, *is_ marked by excellent judgment, and obtained wide acceptance. (4) Bengel—Meanwhile a new period had been preluded in Germany by the appearance in 1742 of the Gnomon Novi Testamenti of J. A. Bengel (d. 1751), a work following upon his critical edition of the NT issued in 1734. “Though belonging to the 18th cent., Bengel’s critical and expository labors really herald and anticipate the best work in these departments of the 19th cent. His scholarship was exact, his Pa sound, his critical skill remark- able in a field in which he was a pioneer; his notes on the text, though brief, were pregnant with significance, and were informed by a spirit of warm and living piety. The modern period, to which Bengel in spirit, if not in date, belongs, is marked by great changes in the style and character of commentaries. The critical temper was now strong; great advances had been made in the textual criticism of both OT and NT (see Criticism, Textua.); the work 683 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Commentaries of the higher criticism had begun in the OT; in Germany, the spirit of humanism, inherited from Lessing, Herder and Goethe, had found 6. The its way into literature; knowledge of Modern the sciences, of oriental civilizations, Period—Its of other peoples and religions, was con- Character- stantly on the increase; scholarship was istics more precise and thorough; a higher - ideal of what commentary meant had taken possession of the mind. Learning, too, had en- larged its borders, and books on all subjects poured from the press in such numbers that.it was difficult to cope with them. This applies to commentaries as to other departments of theological study. Com- mentaries in the 19th cent., and in our own, are legion. Only the most prominent landmarks can be noted. (1) Germany (a) The liberal school—In Germany, as was to be anticipated, the rise of the critical spirit and the profound influence exercised by it are reflected in most of the commentaries produced in the first half of the cent. On the liberal side, the rationalistic temper is shown in the rejection of miracle, the denial of prediction in prophecy, and the lowering of the idea of inspiration generally. The scholarship, however, is frequently of a very high order. This temper is seen in De Wette (d. 1849), whose commentaries on the NT, written when his views had hecome more positive, show grace and feeling; in Gesenius (d. 1842), who pro- duced an epoch-making commentary on Isa; in Knobel (d. 1863), pronouncedly rationalistic, but with keen critical sense, as evinced in his com- mentaries on the Pent and Josh, Eeel, and Isa; in Hupfeld (d. 1866) in his Commentary on the Pss (4 vols); in Hitzig (d. 1875), acute but arbitrary, who wrote on the Pss and most of the Prophets; above all, in Ewald (d. 1875), a master in the interpretation of the poetical and prophetical books, but who commented also on the first three Gospels, on the writings of John, and on Paul’s epistles. Ewald’s influence is felt in the History of the Jewish Church by Dean Stanley, in England. The Evxegetical Handbook (Kurzgefasstes exegetisches Handbuch) embraced compendious annotations by Knobel, Hitzig, Bertheau (school of Ewald), etc, but also Olshausen (d. 1839; wrote likewise on the NT), on all the books of the OT. (b) Believing tendency—On the believing side, from a variety of standpoints, evangelical, eritical, mediating, confessional, a multitude of commentaries on the OT and NT were produced. The extremely conservative position in criticism was defended by Hengstenberg (d. 1869; on Pss, Eccl, Ezk, Jn, Rev), by Keil (d. 1888) in the well-known Keil and Delitzsch series (Gen to Est, Jer, Ezk, Dnl, Minor Prophets; also NT commentaries), and by Haver- nick (d. 1845; Dnl, Ezk). Delitzsch (d. 1890) wrote valued commentaries on Gen, Job, Pss, Prov, Cant, Eccl, Isa; also on He. After the rise of the Well- hausen school, he considerably modified his views in the newer critical direction. His New Comm. on Gen (1887) shows this change, but, with his other works, is still written in a strongly believing spirit. On the other hand, the critical position (older, not newer) is frankly represented by A. Dillmann (d. 1894) in his commentaries on the books of the Pent and Josh (ET of Genesis, 1897; many also of the above works are tr®). The mediating school, largely penetrated by the influence of Schleiermacher, had many distinguished representatives. Among the most conspicuous may be named Liicke (d. 1855), who wrote on John; Bleek, the OT and NT critical scholar (d. 1859), who has a work on the first three Gospels, and lec- tures on Eph, Col, Philem, He and Rev (his Comm. on He is the best known), and Tholuck (d. 1877), whose expositions and commentaries on Pss, Jn, Rom and He with his Comm. on the Sermon on the Mount, are fine pieces of exegetical work. A special place must be given to two names of high distinction in the present connection. One is J. P. Lange (d. 1884), the sg is and editor of the great Bibelwerk (theological and homiletical) in 22 vols, to which he himself contributed the com- mentaries on Gen to Nu, Hag, Zec, Mal, Mt, Mk, Jn, Rom, Rev, with introductions and homiletic hints. The otheris H. A. W. Meyer (d. 1873), whose Crit- ical and Exegetical Comm. on the N T’ from Mt to Phil (the remaining books being done by other scholars, Limemann, Huther, etc) is an essential part of every NT scholar’s equipment. With the more positive and confessional theo- logians may be ranked E. R. Stier (d. 1862), whose Words of the Lord Jesus (ET in 8 vols; Bib., mystical, tendency to prolixity), with commen- taries on 70 selected Pss, Prov, 2d Isa, Eph, He, Jas and Jude, found much acceptance. A. von Harless (d. 1879) wrote a Comm. on Eph, praised by Tholuck as one of the finest extant. Philippi (d. 1882), of Jewish extraction, best known by his Comm. on Rom, was.strictly Lutheran. One of the ablest of the Lutheran Confessionalists was Lu- thardt (d. 1892), whose works include a Comm. on St. John’s Gospel. Ebrard (d. 1887), as stoutly con- fessional on the Reformed side, has an esteemed Comm. on He. An eminent continental theologian who cannot be overlooked is the Swiss F. L. Godet (d. 1900), whose admirable Comm. on Si. John’s Gospel, and commentaries on Rom and Cor are highly appreciated. (2) Britain and America.—Meanwhile the Eng.- ppoaing countries were pursuing their own paths in the production of commentaries, either in continuing their old traditions, or in striking out on new lines, under the foreign influences which, from the begin- ning of the cent., had begun to play uponthem. In England Bishop Blomfield (d. 1857) published Lec- tures on Jn and Acts. In the United States there appeared from the pen of Dr. J. A. Alexander, of Princeton (d. 1860), a noteworthy Comm. on Isa, fully abreast of the modern learning, but staunchly con- servative: also a Comm. on Pss. From the same seminary proceeded the massive commentaries of Dr. Charles Hodge (Calvinistic) on Rom, Eph and Cor. Adapted for popular use and greatly in demand for Sunday-school purposes were the Notes, Critical, Explanatory and Practical of Albert Barnes (d. 1871; New School Presbyterian). These Notes, the fruit of the use of the early morning hours in a busy pastoral life, covered the whole of the NT, with several books of the OT (Job, Pss, Isa, Dnl). Sensible and informatory, rather than original or profound, they proved helpful to many. Over 1,000,000 copies are stated to have been sold. Of similar aim, though less widely known, were the Notes of Professor M. W. Jacobus (d. 1876; on the NT, Gen and Ex). A new era was opened in critical commentary in England by the publication of the Gr Testament (1849-61) of Dean Alford (d. 1871), followed by his NT for Eng. Readers (1868). Here was presented a thoroughly critical treatment of the texts, with a full display of the critical apparatus, and notes philological and exegetical, accompanied by learned and lucid introductions, on all the books of the NT. About the same time appeared the solid, if more theological and homiletical, commentaries of the Scottish scholar, J. Eadie (d. 1876), on Gal, Eph, Phil, 1 and 2 Thess. Anglican scholarship pro- duced its ripest fruits in this line in the classical Critical and Grammatical Comms. of Bishop Ellicott (d. 1905) on Gal, Eph, Phil, Col, Philem, Thess, Pastoral Epistles, and the yet more remarkable Commentaries Comm., Hebrew THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 684 series of commentaries of Bishop J. B. Lightfoot (d. 1889), massive in learning, and wider in outlook than Ellicott’s, on Gal, Phil, Col and Philem. A large part of the value of Lightfoot’s works consists in the special essays or dissertations on important subjects embodied in them (e.g. “St. Paul and the Three’, “The Christian Ministry,” ‘““The Colossian Heresy,” etc). With these names should be asso- ciated that of Bishop Westcott, Dr. Lightfoot’s successor in the see of Durham (d. 1901), whose commentaries on the Gospel and Epistles of St. John, and on He, take a place among the foremost. Bishop Moule, who, in turn, succeeded Dr. Westcott, has also written commentaries, simpler in character, on Rom, Eph, Phil and Col, in_ the Cambridge Bible Series, and on Rom in the Expositor’s Bible. In OT exposition mention should be made of Bishop Perowne’s valuable work on the Book of Psalms (2d ed, revised, 1870), with his contributions to the Cambridge Bible (see below). The critical and theological liberalism of Ger- many has made its influence felt in England in the rise of a Broad Church party, the best products of which in commentary were Dean Stanley’s (d. 1881) graphic and interesting Comm. on 1 and 2 Cor (1855) and Dr. B. Jowett’s Epistles of St. Paul to the Thess, Gal, and Rom, with Critical Notes and Disserta- tions (1855). The new spirit culminated in the appearance of the famous Essays and Reviews (1860) and in the works of Bishop Colenso on the Pent and Josh (1862-79). Bishop Colenso had already pub- lished a tr of Rom, with commentary (1861). Besides works by individual authors, there ap- peared during this period several general commen- taries, to the production of which many writers contributed. The following may be mentioned. The Speaker’s Comm. (10 vols, 1871-82), under the general editorship of Canon F. C. Cook (d. 1889), was called forth by the agitation over Bishop Colenso. Dr. Cook himself wrote introductions to Ex, Pss and Acts, and contributed the entire commentaries on Job, Hab, Mk, Luke, 1 Pet, with parts of commentaries on Ex, Pss and Mt. The work is of unequal value. A serviceable series is the Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges (1877 ff), edited by Bishop Perowne, with Smaller Cam- bridge Bible for Schools, and Cambridge Gr Test. for Schools and Colleges (still in process). Dr. Perowne (d. 1904) himself contributed to the first- named the commentaries on Ob, Jon, Hag, Zec, Mal and Gal. Many valuable contributions appear in this series, e.g. A. F. Kirkpatrick on 1 and 2 S and Pss, A. B. Davidson on Job and Ezk, Driver on Dnl, G. G. Findlay on Thess, etc. Next, under the editorship of Bishop Ellicott, were produced (1877-84) A NT Comm. for Eng. Readers (3 vols), and AnOT Comm. for Eng. Readers (5 vols), which contained some valuable work (Gen by R. Payne Smith, Ex by Canon G. Rawlinson, etc). Akin to this in character was the Popular Comm. on the NT (4 vols, 1879-83), edited by Dr. W. Schaff. This embraced, with other excellent matter, com- mentarics on Thess by Dr. Marcus Dods, and on 1 and 2 Pet by Dr. 8. D. F. Salmond. The Pulpit Comm. (49 vols, 1880 ff), edited by J. 8. Exell and Canon H. D. M. Spence, has expositions by good scholars, and an abundance of homiletical material by a great varicty of authors. The series of Handbooks for Bible Classes (T. & T. Clark, Edin- burgh) has a number of valuable commentaries, e.g. that of Dr. A. B. Davidson on He. In the most recent period the con- spicuous feature has been the produc- tion of commentaries in series or by individual writersembodying the results of an advanced OT criticism—in less degrce of a radical NT criticism. 6. Recent Period (1) Germany.—In Germany, in addition to the Kurzgefasstes exegetisches Handbuch, of older stand- ing (see above), to which Dillmann contributed, may be mentioned Marti’s Kurzer Hand-Commentar zum AT (1897 ff) and Nowack’s Handkommentar zum AT; also Strack and Zéckler’s Kurzgefasster Kommentar (OT and NT; critical, but moderate). Marti contributes to his Hand-Commentar the vols on Isa, Dnl and the Minor Prophets; Nowack con- tributes to his Handkommentar the vols on Jgs and Ruth, 1 and 28 and the Minor Prophets (of special importance in Nowack’s series are the vols on Gen by H. Gunkel, and on Dt and Josh by C. Steuer- nagel); Strack writes in his own work the vols on Gen to Nu (Oettli contributes Dt, Josh and Jgs). Much more conservative in spirit are the commen- taries of H. C. von Orelli (Basel) on Isa, Jer, Ezk and the Minor Prophets. Inthe NT, Meyer’s Com- mentary has been “revised” by later writers, many of them (J. Weiss, W. Bousset, etc) of much more advanced tendency than the original author. (2) Britain and America.—In Britain and Amer- ica like currents are observable. Professor T. K. Cheyne, who wrote a helpful commentary on the Prophecies of Isa (1880-81), and subsequently commentaries on Mic and Hos (Cambridge Bible), Jer (Pulpit Comm.), and on The Book of Psalms (1884), has become more and more extreme in his opinions. Of works in series the most important is The International Critical Commentary, edited by Drs. Driver and Plummer in England, and Dr. C. A. Briggs in the United States, of which 16 vols in the OT and the NT have already appeared. It need not be said that the commentaries in this series are always scholarly and able; those on the OT are, however, all built on the Wellhausen foundations (see CRITICISM OF THE Brsie, III). Dr. Driver himself writes on Dt; Dr. J. Skinner, on Gen; Dr. G.F. Moore, on Jgs; Dr. H. P. Smith, on 1 and 28; Dr. Briggs, on Pss; Dr. Toy, on Prov; Dr. W. R. Harper (d. 1906), on Am and Hos; while Mt in the NT is covered by W. C. Allen, Lk by Dr. Plummer, Rom by Drs. Sanday and Headlam, etc. A similar series is the Westminister Comm., recently com- menced, to which Dr. Driver contributes the vol on Gen (1904; 7th ed, 1909). Yet another recent opular series is’ The Century Bible, to which again leading critical scholars lend their aid (Dr. W. H. Bennett on Gen; also on ‘‘General Epistles’’; Dr. A.R.S. Kennedy on 1 and 28; Dr. Skinner on 1 and 2K; Dr. A. S. Peake on Job; also on He; Dr. Driver on a group of the Minor Prophets, etc). A well-planned one-vol Comm. on the Holy Bible, by various writers, has recently been edited by J. R. Dummelow (Cambridge). It is prefaced by a general Introduction, with a large number of arts. on the principal subjects with which a reader of the Bible will desire to be acquainted. It need only be added that very many of the for- eign. works mentioned above (not simply those specially noted) are now accessible in Eng. tr®. LrteRaTuRE.— Works and arts. specially devoted to commentaries are not numerous. Dr. 8. Davidson has an art. ‘‘Commentary”' in Kitto’s Bib. Ene, Vol I. See also F. W. Farrar’s Hist of Interpretation (Bampton Lects for 1885). C. H. Spurgeon’s popular talks on Commenting and Commentaries are accompanied by extensive lists of Commentaries on all parts of the Bible (severely exclusive of works deemed dangerous). Lists of commentaries on the Bible as a whole, on the OT and NT separately, and on the several books, may be seen in most good works on Introduction, or in prolegomena to commentaries on the different books; e.g. in the general Introduction prefixed to Lange’s Comm. on Genesis; also in the lengthy sections on Jewish, Gr, Lat and Protestant commentators, and again in the “ Index of the More Important Expository Works on the Bks of the OT."" In Bleek’s Introduction to the OT, very full information is given up to the author’s date. Full bibliographies of modern books, including commentaries on the.OT, are furnished in Dr. Driver's Introduction. Similar lists are given in other works regarding the NT. 685 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Commentaries Comm., Hebrew For the writers of the commeutaries on the speclal books in the ahove-noted German and Eng. series, lists may generally be seen attached to each vol of the serles. JAMES ORR COMMENTARIES, HEBREW, hé’broo: . Philo Judaeus Targum Midrash . Talmud . Karaites . Middle Ages ) Saadia ben Joseph Rashi (3) Joseph Kara (4) Abraham ibn Ezra Kimhi {8} Maithonides } OUR CON Maimunists Kabbalists The ' Zohar” (10) Isaac Arama 7. Modern Times Abarbanel 8. The Bi'urists (1) Mendelssohn 4 Zunz, etc 3) Malbim, ‘Ehrlich, etc 3 Halévy, Hoffmann, Mueller 5) Geiger, Graetz, Kohier L1rERATURE The following ouiline alludes to the leading Jewish commentators and their works in chronological order. However widely the principles which guided the various Jewish schools of exegesis, or the individual commentators, differ from those of the modern school, the latter will find a certain suggestiveness in the former’s interpretation which well merits attention. Philo Judaeus: A Hellenistic Jew of Alexandria, Egypt. Born about 20 BC; died after 40 AD. By his allegorical method of exegesis (a 1. Philo method he learned from the Stoics), Philo exercised a far-reaching influence not only on Jewish thought, but even more so on the Christian church. We have but to mention his influence on Origen and other Alexandrian Christian writers. His purpose in employing his allegorical method was, mainly, to reconcile Gr philosophy with the OT. See Puito Juparus. Josephus cannot be called a Bible commentator in the proper sense of the term. See JosEPHUS. Targim (pl. Targimim): _The Aram. tr of the OT. Lit. the word designates a tr in general; Its use, however, has been restricted to the Aram. version 2. Tar of the OT, as contrasted with the Heb » SaTEUM text which was called mikra’. The Teg includes all_ the books of the OT Dnt and Ezr-Neh, which are written in part in excepti ts inception dates back to the time of the Second Aram. Temple, and it is considered_a first approach to a com- mentary before the time of Jesus. or the Tg is not a mere tr, but rather a combination of a tr with a com- mentary, resulting in a paraphrase, or an interpretative tr —having its origin in exegesis. Thelanguage of this para- phrase is the vernacular tongue of Syria, which began to reassert itself throughout Pal as the eat of common Intercourse and trade, as soon as a fa: ar knowledge of the Heb tongue came to be lost. The Targimim are: TO THE PENTATEUCH (1) Targiim 'Onkelés or Bab Tg (the accepted and official) ; Aa Bs (2) Targiim yerashalmi or Palestinian Tg (" Pseudo- Jonathan"; aside from this [complete] Tg there are fragments of the Palestinian Tg termed ‘' Fragment Targiim’'). TO THE PROPHETS (1) Targiim Jonathau ben Uzziel (being the official one: originated In Pal aud was then adapted to the vernacular of Babylonia); S ‘ (2) A Palestinian Targum, called Targim ytrishalmi Sec rage in origin; ed. Lagarde, ‘ Prophetae Chal- daice"’). Other Targumim (not officially recognized): (1) To the Psalms and Job; (2) to Proverbs; (3) to_the Five Rolls; (4) to Chronicles—all Palestinian. See Taroum. Midhraésh: Apparently the practice of commenting upon and explaining the meaning of the Scriptures originated in the synagogues (in the 3. Midrash time of Ezra), from the necessity of ; an exposition of the Law to a congre- gation many of whom did not or might not under- stand the language in which it was read. Such commentaries, however, were oral and extempore; they were not until much later crystallized into a definite form. When they assumed a definite and, still later, written shape, the name Midhrdsh (mean- ing “investigation,” “interpretation,” from ddrash, “to investigate” a scriptural passage) was given. The word occurs in 2 Ch 13 22 where the RV trans- lates “commentary.” From this fact some have drawn the inference that such Midhraéshim were recognized and extant before the time of the Chroni- cler. They are: Midhrash Rabba’ on the Pent and the Five Rolls (the one on Gen occupies a first posi- tion among the various exegetical Midhrdshim, both on account of its age and importance). Next comes the oneon Lam. (Zunz pointed out that the Midh- rash Rabbd’ consists of ten entirely different Midh- rashim.) On the same ten books there is a similar collection, called ha-Midhrash ha-gadhél (the “Great Midrash’), being a collection of quotations from a good many works including the Midhrdsh Rabba’. Other Midhrashim are: The Midhrash Tanhimd’ on the Pentateuch; the Mekhilia’ on Exodus (this has been [Leipzig, 1909] tr? into German by Winter and Wuensche; the latter also published, under the main title Bibliotheca Rabbinica, a collection of the old Midhrashim in a German tr with introductions and notes). Further, Siphra’ on Lev; Siphréon Nu and Dt; p*stkta’, which comments on sections taken from the entire range of Scriptures for various festi- vals. There are also extant separate Midhrashim on the Pss, Prov, ete. ; In this connection we have yet to mention the Yalkut Shim‘6ni, a haggadie compilation attributed to the 11th or, according to Zunz, the 13th cent. The Yalkut extends over the whole of the OT and is arranged according to the sequence of those portions of the Bible to which reference is made. Further, the Yalkut ha-Makiri, a work similar in contents to the Yalkut Shim‘oni, ed. Greenup. See ComMEn- TARIES; MIpRAsH. Talmud (Talmidh): This term is used here to designate the entire body of literature exclusive of the Midhrash. mple exegetical material abounds in 4, Talmud the Talm as it does in the Midhrashim. » 1a The critical notes on the Bible by some Talmudists are very characteristic of thelr intellectual temper. Some of them were extremely radical, and expressed freely their opinions on important prehlems of Bible criticism, such as on the Integrity of the text, on doubtful authorship, etc. An Amora’ of the 3d cent. AD held the opinion that the story of Job is purely fictitious, both as to the name of the he and as to his fate. ‘The Talmudists also generalized, and set up_critical canons. The " Baraitha’, of the Thirty-two Rules" is the oldest work on Bib. her- meneutics (Philo’s hermeneutical rules heiug rather fantastic), and contains exegetical notices valid to this very day. Hermeneutics, of course, is not exegesis proper, but the theory of exegesis; oue results from the other, however. This Bdraitha’ calls attention, for instance, to the fact that words occur in the OT in an abbreviated form—a thing now generally accepted. See TALMUD. Karaites: ‘Followers of the Bible.” They are sometimes referred to as the ‘‘Protestants of the Jews,” professing to follow the OT 5. Karaites to the exclusion of the rabbinical tra- dition. The founder of this Jewish sect was a Bab Jew in the 8th cent., Anan ben David, by name; hence they were first called Ana- nites. The principal Karaite commentators of the 9th, 10th and 11th cents. are: Benjamin Al-Na- hawendi (he was the first to use the term ‘‘Karaites,” “Ba‘dlé Mikra’’’), Solomon ben Jeroham, Sahl ibn Mazliah, Yusuf al-Basir, Yafith ibn Ali (considered the greatest of this period), and Abu al-Faraij Harum. Of a later date we will mention Aaron ben Joseph and Aaron ben Elijah (14th cent.). The struggle between the Rabbinites and the Karaites undoubtedly gave the impetus to the great exegetical activity among the Jews in Arab.- Comm., Hebrew Commerce THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 686 speaking countries during the 10th and 11th cents. The extant fragments of Saadia’s commentary on the Pent (not less than his polemical writings proper) are full of polemics against the Karaite interpretation. And thesame circumstance aroused Karaites to like efforts. Middle Ages: In the old Midhradshim as well as elsewhere the consciousness of a simple meaning of a text was never entirely lost. The 6. Middle principal tendencies in exegesis were Ages four; these were afterward designated . by the acrostic “PaRDeS”: i.e. P*shat (or the simple philological explanation of words); Remez (or the allegorical); Derash (or the ethico- homiletical); and Sédh (or the mystical). Naturally enough this division could never be strictly carried out; hence variations and combinations are to be found. Saadia ben Joseph (892-942), the severest an- tagonist of the Karaites, tr’ the OT into Arab. with notes. The parts published are: Pent, Isa, Prov and Job. Moses ha-Darshan (the Preacher) of Narbonne, France, and Tobiah ben Eliezer in Castoria, Bul- garia (11th cent.), are the most prominent repre- sentatives of midrashic-symbolic Bible exegesis. The former’s work is known only by quotations, and _ contained Christian theological conceptions; the latter is the author of “Lekah Tabk” or “Psik- ta’ Zitarta’’’ on the Pent and the five M¢ghillath. Rashi (Solomon ben Isaac, of Troyes; born 1040, died 1105) wrote a very popular commentary, which extends over the whole of the OT, with the excep- tion of Ch, Ezr-Neh, and the last part of Job. He strives for the P¢shat, i.e. for a sober, natural and rational interpretation of the Bible. His is still a commentary both for the boy and the man among the Jews. Christian exegetes of the Middle Ages as well as of more modern times made use of his Bible commentary. Nicolas de Lyra (see Com- MENTARIES) followed Rashi closely; and it is a known fact that Luther’s tr of the Bible is depend- ent upon Nicolas de Lyra. Rashi’s commentary has called forth numerous supercommentaries. An independent and important exegete was Joseph Kara’ (about 1100). He edited and partly completed Rashi’s commentary, particularly the part on the Pent. Abraham ibn Ezra’s (1092-1168) commentary on the Pent, like Rashi’s commentaries, has pro- duced many supercommentaries. His is very scholarly. He was the first to maintain that Isa contains the work of two authors; and his doubts respecting the authenticity of the Pent were no- ticed by Spinoza. The grammarians and the lexicographers were not merely exegetical expounders of words, but many of them were likewise authors of actual commentaries. Such were the Kimhis, Joseph (father), Moses and David (his sons); esp. the latter. The Kimhis were the most brilliant con- tributors to Bible exegesis and Heb philology (like Ibn Ezra) in mediaeval times. Maimonides (1135-1204): Philo employed his allegorical method for the purpose of bringing about a reconciliation of Plato with the OT. Maimon- ides had something similar in view. To him Aris- totle was the representative of natural knowledge and the Bible of supernatural—and he sought for a reconciliation between the two in his religious philosophy. Exegesis proper was the one field, however, to which this great genius made no con- tribution of first-class importance. : The Maimunists, those exegetes of a philosophi- cal turn, are: Joseph ibn Aknin, Samuel ibn Tib- bon, his gon Moses, and his son-in-law, Jacob ben Abba Mari Anatolio, whose Malmadh ha-Talmidhim is the most important work of philosophical exe- gesis of the period. : Joseph ibn Kagpi, chiefly known as a philosopher of the Maimunist type, deserves attention. Ibn Kaspi is an exegete of the first quality. His ex- position of Isa 53 might be the work of the most modern scholar. He refers the prophecy to Israel, not to an individual, and in this his theory is far superior to that of some other famous Jewish ex- positors who interpret the chapter as referrmg to Hezekiah. : . Through the philosophical homily, which began to be used after the death of Maimonides, Aristotle was popularized. from the pulpit. The pulpit changed to a chair of philosophy. Aristotle’s con- cepts—as Matter and Form, the Four Causes, Possi- bility and Reality—were then something ordinary in the sermon, and were very popular. < The principal commentators with a Kabbalistic tendency are: Nahmanides (1194-1270?) whose great work is his commentary on the Pentateuch; Immanuel of Rome (1270?-13830?) who does, how- ever, not disregard the lit. meaning of the Scriptures; Bahya ben Asher (d. 1840) who formulated the four methods of exegesis of ““PaRDeS”’ referred to above; he took ‘Nahmanides as his model; many super- commentaries were written on his commentary on the Pent; and Gersonides (1288-1334), a maternal grandson of Nahmanides, who sees symbols in many Bib. passages; on account of some of his heretical ideas expressed in his philosophy, some rabbis for- bade the study of his commentaries. We must not fail to make mention of the Zohar (the “Bible of the Kabbalists’), the book of all others in the Middle Ages that dominated the thinking and feeling of the Jews for almost 500 years, and which was in favor with many Christian scholars. This work is pseudepigraphic, written partly in Aram. and partly in Heb. It first appeared in Spain‘ in the 13th cent., and was made known through Moses de Leon, to whom many historians attribute it. Mention must also be made of Isaac Arama (1430- 94), whose ’Akédhah, his commentary on the Pent (homiletical in style), was the standard book for the Jewish pulpit for cents., much esteemed by the Christian world, and is still much read by the Jews, esp. in Russia and Poland. Modern Times: Isaac Abravanel (or Abarbanel; 1437-1508): A statesman and scholar who came nearest to the modern idea of a Bible 7. Modern commentator by considering not only Times the literary elements of the Bible but __ the political and social life of the people aswell. Hewrote a general introduction to each book of the Bible, setting forth its character; and he was © the first to make use of Christian commentaries which he quotes without the least prejudice. Moses Alshech (second half of 16th cent.) wrote com- mentaries, all of which are of a homiletical character. . In the main the Jewish exegesis of the 16th and 17th cents. branched out into homiletics. We will pass over the critical annotatious con- nected with the various editions of the Heb Bible based upon the comparison of MSS, on grammatical and Massoretic studies, etc, such as those of Elijah Levita, Jacob ben Hayyim of Tunis (afterward a convert to Christianity), etc. The “Bi’urists” (“Commentators”): A school of exegetes which had its origin with Mendclssohn’s (1729-86) lit. German tr of the Bible, 8. The at a time when Christian Bib. studies “Biurists” of a modern nature had made some : progress, and under whose influence the Birurists wrote. They are: Dubno, Wessely, Jaroslav, H. Homberg, J. Euchel, etc. They laid a foundation for a critico-historical study of the . 687 Bible among modern Jews. It bore its fruit in the 19th cent. in the writings of Philippson, Munk, Fuerst, etc. Thesame cent. produced Zunz’s (1794— 1886) Gottesdienstlichen V ortraege der Juden, the book of “Jewish science.” It also produced three Jewish exegetes, Luzzatto in Italy, Malbim and Ehrlich in Russia (the latter since 1878 residing in New York); he published, in Heb, a commentary on the OT, entitled Mikra’ ki-Peshitah (Berlin, 1899-1901, 3 vols), and, in German, Randglossen z. hebr. Bibel, two scholarly works written from the conservative standpoint .(Leipzig, 1908-). Malbim was highly esteemed by the Christian commentators Franz Delitzsch and Muehlau, who studied under him. Others are Joseph Halévy, a French Jew, a most original Bible investigator, and D. Hoffmann (the last two named are adversaries of “higher criti- cism”) and D. H. Mueller. M. Heilprin wrote a collection of Bibelkritische Notizen (Baltimore, 1893), containing comparisons of various passages of the Bible, and The Historical Poetry of the Ancient He- brews (N.Y., 1879-80, 2 vols), and the American rabbi B. Szold, a Commentary on Job (Baltimore, 1886), written in classic Heb, and with accurate scholarship and in which full account is taken of the work of the Massorites. A new Heb commentary on the whole of the OT has been since 1903 in progress under the editorship of A. Kahana. This is the first attempt since Mendelssohn’s Bz’ur to approach the Bible from the Jewish side with the latest phil- ological and archaeological equipment. Among the authors are Kahana on Goness and Jonah, Krauss on Isaiah, Chajes on Psalms and Amos, Wynkoop on Hosea and Joel, and Lambert on Daniel. This attempt well deserves attention and commendation. There is still to be mentioned the work of M. M. Kalisch (1828-85), whose special object was to write a full and critical comm. on the OT. Of his His- torical and Critical Comm. on the OT, with a New Tr, only the following parts were published: Ezo- dus, 1855; Genesis, 1858; Leviticus (pts 1-2), 1867— 72. They contain a résumé of all that Jewish and Christian learning had accumulated on the subject up to the dates of their publication. In his Lev he anticipated Wellhausen to a large extent. We conclude with some names of the liberals: Geiger (whose Urschrift is extremely radical), Graetz, the great Jewish historian, and Kohler (president of the Hebrew Union College, Cincin- nati, O.) whose Der Segen Jacobs is one of the earliest essays of “higher criticism’’ written by a Jew. Litzerature.—Steinschneider, Jewish Literature, Lon- don, 1857; Zunz, Gottesdienstlichen Vortraege der Juden, 2d ed, Frankfurt a. M., 1892; Jew Ene (arts. by Bacher and Ginzberg): Catholic Ene (art. ‘‘Commentaries”); Rosenau, Jewish Biblical Commentators, Baltimore, 1906 oar te are Reg iegeperore thology of Jewish literature in a modern language; it con- tains very valuable introductions); Wogue, Histoire dela Bible et l’exegése biblique jusqu'd nos jours, Paris, 1881. ; Apoter S, Oxo COMMENTARY, kom’en-ta-ri (WYT2, midh- rash, ‘an investigation,” from WT, darash, ‘‘to search,” ‘inquire,’ ‘explore’; AV “story’’): “The c. of the prophet Iddo” (2 Ch 18 22), “the c. of the book of the kings” (24 27). In these passages the word is not used exactly in its modern sense. The Heb term means “an imaginative development of a thought or theme suggested by Scripture, esp. a didactic or homiletic exposition, or an edifying religious story” (Driver, LOT, 497). In the commentaries (Midhrashim) mentioned by the Chronicler as among his sources, the story of Abijah’s reign was presumably related and elabo- rated with a view to moral instruction rather than historic accuracy. See Curonicizs, Books oF; CoMMENTARIES, HEBREW. M. O. Evans THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 60™m., Hebrew Commerce COMMERCE, kom’érs (éuwopla, emporia): I. OT Times.—There were forces in early Heb life not favorable to the development of commerce. Intercourse with foreigners was not 1. Early encouraged by Israel’s social and Overland _ religious customs. From the days of Commerce the appearance of the Hebrews in Canaan, however, some commercial contact with the peoples around was inevitable. There were ancient trade routes between the East and the West, as well as between Egypt and the Mesopotamian valley. Pal lay as a bridge between these objective points. There were doubtless traveling merchants from very remote times, inter- changing commodities of other lands for those of Pal. Some of the Heb words for “trading” and “merchant” indicate this (cf WQ, sahar, “‘to travel,” 52%, rakhal, “to go about”). In the nomadic period, the people were necessarily dependent upon overland commerce for at least a part of their food supply, such as grain, and doubtless for articles of clothing, too. Frequent local famines would stimulate such trade. Companies or caravans carrying on this overland commerce are seen in Gen 37 25.28, “Ishmaelites” and “Midianites, mer- chantmen,” on their way to Egypt, with spices, balm and myrrh. Jacob caused his sons to take certain products to Egypt as a present with money to Joseph in return for grain: balsam, spices, honey, myrrh, nuts, almonds (Gen 43 11f). The presence of a “Bab mantle” among the spoils of Ai (Josh 7 21) indicates commerce between Canaan and the East. While there are slight indications of a possible sea trade as early as the days of the Judges (Jgs 5 17; cf Gen 49 13), we must wait 2. Sea till the days of the monarchy of Traffic David and esp. Solomon for the com- merce of ships. Land traffic was of course continued and expanded (1 K 10 15.28.29; 2 Ch 1 16). Sea trade at this time made large strides forward. The Philis were earlier in pos- session of the coast. Friendship with Hiram king of Tyre gave Solomon additional advantages sea- ward (1 K 5; 9 26; 10 19-29; 2 Ch 8 17; 9 14), since the Phoenicians were preéminently the Mediterranean traders among all the people of Pal. Later, commerce declined, but Jehoshaphat at- tempted to revive it (1 K 22 48; 2 Ch 20 36), but without success. Tyre and Sidon as great commercial centers, however, long impressed the life of Israel (Isa 23; Ezk 26-27). Later, in the Maccabean period, Simon acquired Joppa as a Jewish port (1 Macc 14 5), and so extended Mediterranean commerce. During the peaceful reign of Solomon, there came, with internal improvements and foreign friendships, a stimulus to traffic with Egypt and 3. Land the Far East over the ancient trade Traffic in routes as well as with Phoenicia on the Time of the northwest. He greatly added to the Kings his wealth through tariffs levied upon merchantmen (1 K 10 15). Trade with Syria in the days of Omri and Ahab is indicated by the permission Benhadad gave to Israelites to open streets, or trading quarters, in Damascus, as Syrians had in Samaria (1 K 20 34). The prophets disclose repeatedly the results of foreign commerce upon the people in the days of Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah, and of Jeroboam II, under whom great material prosperity was attained, followed by simple luxury (Isa 2 6.7.16; Hos 12 1.7.8; Am 6 3-6). The people in their greed of gain could not observe Sabbaths and feast days (Am 8 5); ef Sabbath trading and its punishment in the days of the restoration (Neh 13 15-22). ‘Canaanite’ became the nickname for traffickers (Zec 14 21; cf Isa 23 8). Commit Communion II. NT Times.—After the conquests of Alexan- der 3383 BC, trade between East and West was greatly stimulated. Colonies of Jews for trade purposes had been established in Egypt and else- where. The dispersion of the Jews throughout the Gr and Rom world added to their interest in com- merce. The Mediterranean Sea, as a great Rom lake, under Rom protection, became alive with commercial fleets. The Sea of Galilee with its enormous fish industry became the center of a large trading interest to all parts. The toll collected in Galilee must have been considerable. Matthew was called from his collectorship to discipleship (Mt 9 9); Zaccheus and other publicans became rich collecting taxes from large commercial inter- ests like that of balsam. Jesus frequently used the commerce of the day as illustration (Mt 13 45; 25 14-30). Along the Palestinian coast there were several ports where ships touched: Lydda, Joppa, Caesarea; and further north Ptolemais, Tyre, Sidon and Antioch (port Seleucia). The apostle Paul made use of ships touching at points on the coast of Asia Minor, and the islands along the coast, and also doing coast trade with Greece, Italy and Spain, to carry on his missionary enterprises (Acts 13 4-13; 16 11f; 1818; 20 13-16; 21 1-8; 27 1-44; 28 1-14). The rapid- ity with which the gospel spread throughout the Rom world in the 1st cent. was due no little to the use of the great Rom highways, built partly as trade routes; as well as to the constant going to and fro of tradesmen of all sorts; some of whom like Aquila and Priscilla (Acts 18 2.18.26), Lydia, (16 14.40) and Paul himself (who was a traveling tent-maker) were active in disseminating the new faith among the Gentiles. In Jas 4 13 we have a good representation of the life of a large number of Jews of this period, who would “go into such a city, and continue there a year, and buy and sell, and get gain” (AV). See also Traps. Enwarp Baaspy PoLiarp COMMIT, ké-mit’: Used in two senses: (1) “To give in charge” or “entrust’’: stm, “‘to put”? (Job 6 8); gdlal, “to roll” (Ps 37 5; Prov 16 3); pakadh, “to give in charge” (Ps 31 5 AV; ef Lk 28 46); tithémi, “committed to us [RVm “placed in us’’] the word of reconciliation” (2 Cor 5 19); parathéke, “that which I have committed unto him” (2 Tim 112; RVm “that which he hath committed unto me,” Gr “my deposit’); ‘that which is committed unto thee’ (1 Tim 6 20, Gr “the deposit”); “that good thing,” etc (2 Tim 1 14, Gr “the good deposit’) (2) “To do or practise [evil]”: prdssé, “commit such things” (Rom 1 32, RV “practice”; cf 2 2). In 1 Jn 3 4.8 ‘“doeth sin” (poié6, AV “committeth sin’) shows that it is not committing a single sin that is in view, but sinful practice. W.L. WALKER COMMODIOUS, ké-md’di-us (avetOeros, aneii- thetos, ‘not well placed’): The word occurs only in Acts 27 12. “As regards wintering, the place was certainly ‘not commodious,’ but as regards shelter from some winds (including N.W.), it was a good anchorage” (CH, XXIII, 639). COMMON, kom’un: kotvés, koinds, in the classics, and primarily in the NT, means what is public, general, universal, as contrasted with f:os, idios, what is peculiar, individual, not shared with others. Thus, “common faith” (Tit 1 4), “com- mon salvation” (Jude ver 3), refer to that in which the experience of all Christians unites and is identical: “common,” because there is but one faith and one salvation (Eph 4 4-6). From this comes the derived meaning of what is ordinary and, therefore, to be disesteemed, as contrasted with what pertains to a THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 688 class, and to be prized, because rare. This naturally coincides with OT exclusivism, particularity and separation. Its religion was that of a separated people, with a separated class as its ministers, and with minute directions as to distinctions of meat, drink, times, places, rites, vessels, etc. Whatever was common or ordinary, it avoided. The NT, on the other hand, withits universalism of scope, and its spirituality of sphere, rose above all such externals. The salvation which it brought was directed to the redemption of Nature, as well as of man, sanctify- ing the creature, and pervading all parts of man’s being and all relations of life. The antithesis is forcibly illustrated in Acts 10 14f, where Peter says: “I have never eaten anything that is c. and unclean,” and the reply is: ‘What God hath cleansed, make not thou c.” H. E. Jacozs COMMONWEALTH, kom’un-welth (aodvtela, politeia): Spoken of the theocracy (Eph 2 12). The same word is rendered “freedom,” AV; ‘“‘cit- izenship” RV. Also in the sense of common- wealth in the Apoc (2 Macc 4 11; 8 17; 13 14); in the sense of citizenship (3 Macc 3 21.23). See CiTizENsHIP. COMMUNE, ké-min’, COMMUNICATE, ko- min‘’i-kat, COMMUNICATION, ko-mi-ni-ka’shun: To commune is to converse confidentially and sym- pathetically. It is represented in both Heb and Gr by several words lit. signifying to speak (cf Lk 6 11, diadradéw, dialaléd; also Lk 22 4; Acts 24 26, dusréw, homilé6). To communicate is to impart something to another, so that it becomes common to giver and receiver. In 1 Tim 6 18, ‘willing to communicate” (RVm “sympathize’’), represents a single word ko:- vwvkol, koindnikot, and refers to the habit of sharing with others either sympathy or property. RV gives “companionships” for homiliat in 1 Cor 15 33 (AV “communications’). See also ComMMuNION. COMMUNION, ké-min’ynn (FELLOWSHIP): The terms “communion” and “fellowship” of the Eng. Bible are varying tr® of the words xowwria, koinénia, and xowwvréw, koindnéd, or their cognates. They ccsennte acts of fellowship observed among the early Christians or express the unique sense of unity and fellowship of which these acts were the outward expression. The several passages in which these terms are used fall into two groups: those in which they refer to acts of fellowship, and those in which they refer to fellowship as experienced. I. Acts of Fellowship.—The acts of fellowship mentioned in the NT are of four kinds. Our information concerning the nature of the fellowship involved in the observance of this sac- rament is confined to the single notice 1. The in 1 Cor 10 16.17, ‘The cup of bless- Lord’s ing which we bless, is it not a com- Supper munion of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not a communion of the body of Christ?” Owing to the presence of the material elements in the sacrament there is a temptation to limit the word for com- munion to the sense of partaking. This, however, does not entirely satisfy the requirements of the context. The full significance of the term is to be sought in the light of the argument of the whole section (vs 14-22). Paul is making a protest against Christians par- ticipating in idolatrous feasts on the ground that such feasts are really celebrated in honor of the demons associated with the idols, and that those who participate in them come into fellowship with demons. As a proof of this point the apostle cites the Lord’s Supper with which his readers are familiar. By partaking of the cup and the bread 689 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Commit Communion the communicants are linked together in unity: “We, who are many, are one bread, one body: for we ail partake of the one bread.” Thus the com- munion of the elements is a real communion of the worshippers one with another and with Christ. Unless the communion be understood in this spirit- ual sense Paul's illustration falls short of the mark. See Eucwarist. The term for fellowship as used in Acts 2 42 ig by some interpreted in this sense: “They continued stedfastly in the apostles’ teaching 2. Com- and fellowship, in the breaking of munism bread and the prayers.’ The fact that the four terms are used in pairs and that three of them refer to specific acts ob- served by the company of believers suggests that the term for fellowship also refers to some definite act similar to the others. It is very plausible to refer this to the community of goods described in the verses immediately following (see Community oF Goops). The author might, however, with equal propriety have regarded the interchange of spiritual experiences as an act of worship in the same class with “the breaking of bread and the prayers.” Christian fellowship found a natural mode of expression in almsgiving. Thisis enjoined asa duty in Rom 12 13; 1 Tim 6 18; He 13 16. An example of such giving is the great collection raised among the gentile con- verts for the poor saints of Jerus (Rom 15 26; 2 Cor 8 4; 913). To this collection St. Paul attached so much importance as a witness to the spirit of fellowship which the gospel inspires in all hearts alike, whether Jew or Gentile, that he desired even at the peril of his life to deliver it with his own hand. See CoLuEctron. A form of fellowship closely related to almsgiving was that of formal aid or coéperation in Christian work, such as the aid given to St. Paul by the Philippians (Phil 1 5). A unique form of this codperation is the formal endorsement by giving the right hand of fellowship as described in Gal 2 9. Il. Fellowship as Experienced.—¥rom the very beginning the early Christians experienced a peculiar sense of unity. Christ is at once the center of this unity and the origin of every expression of fellow- ship. Sometimes the fellowship is essentially an experience and as such it is scarcely susceptible of definition. It may rather be regarded as a mystical union in Christ. In other instances the fellowship approaches or includes the idea of intercourse. In some passages it is represented as a participa- tion or partnership. The terms occur most fre- quently in the writings of Paul with whom the idea of Christian unity was a controlling principle. ~ In its various relations, fellowship is represented: (1) As a communion between the Son and the Father. The gospel record represents Jesus as enjoying a unique sense of communion and inti- macy with the Father. Among many such ex- pressions those of Mt 11 25-27 (cf Lk 10 21.22) and Jn 14-15 are especially important. (2) As our communion with God, either with the Father or the Son or with the Father through the Son or the Holy Spirit. ‘Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ” (1 Jn 1 3; cf also Jn 14 6.23.26). (3) As our communion one with another. “If we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with: another” (1 Jn 17). Sometimes the idea of communion occurs in relation with abstract ideas or experiences: ‘‘Have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness”’ (Eph 6 11); “the fellowship of his sufferings” (Phil 3 10); “the fellowship of thy faith” (Philem ver 6). In three passages the relation of the fellowship is not entirely clear: the ‘fellowship of the Spirit’’ 3. Contri- butions 4, Codper- ation (Phil 2 1); ‘the communion of the Holy Spirit” (2 Cor 18 14); and “the fellowship of his Son Jesus Christ” (1 Cor 19). The fellowship is probably to be understood as that prevailing among Christians by virtue of the grace of Christ and the ministry of the Holy Spirit. It is not to be inferred that the idea of fellowship is limited to the passages in which the specific words for communion are used. Some of the clearest and richest expressions of unity and fellowship are found in the Gospels, though these words do not occur in them. In fact, perhaps, the most familiar and forcible expressions of the idea are those in which they are represented symbolically, as in the parable of the Vine and the Branches (Jn 16 1 ff) or in the figure of the Body and its Members (Mt 5 29 ff; Rom 12 5; 1 Cor 12). Russe_t Benjamin MILLER COMMUNION WITH DEMONS, dé’monz (DEVILS, dev’’1z): I, Use of Term.—The actual expression ‘“‘com- munion with demons” (kowwvol rdv Sauovlwy, koi- nonot tén daimonion) occurs but once in Scripture (1 Cor 10 20) where its fig. meaning is evident, but it is implied in the Eng. version of a number of pas- sages by the terms “one who has” or ‘‘those who have” “familiar spirits’ (Lev 19 31; 20 6.27; Dt 18 11; 1S 28 3.7.8.9; 2 K 21 6; 23 24; 1 Ch 10 13; 2 Ch 336; Isa 8 19; 19 3; 29 4). These passages seem to be somewhat incongruous with Paul’s statement, but are in reality so intimately related to it as to give and receive light through the connection. I, Teaching of Scriptare.—To begin with, we may safely say, in general, that there is no ground for asserting that the Bible admits the possibility of conscious and voluntary communion with spirits. This is an essential element of popular demonology in all ages, but it is absent from Scripture. Even in the passages mentioned above which refer to necromancers and wizards, while, as we shall see, the words indicate that such practitioners professed to rely upon spirits in their divinations, the Scriptures carefully refrain from sanctioning these claims, and a number of features in the vari- ous passages serve to indicate that the true scrip- tural view is quite the opposite. As this is not a prevalent opinion, we should do well to examine the passages with some little care. (1) We may first deal with the NT. In the Gospels the demoniacs are consistently looked upon and treated as unconscious and 1. The New helpless victims (see Demon, DkE- Testament mMonoLocy). The frequent use of this term ‘‘demonized” (daimonizémenoi) together with all that is told us of the methods of treating these cases adopted by Our Lord and His apostles (see Exorcism) indicates the belief of the NT writers that the control of demons over men is obtained outside of or below the region of con- scious volition and that the condition of the suffer- ers is pathological. The same must be said of the Lydian maiden whose cure by Paul is recorded in Acts 16 16. This is the one instance in the NT where divination is connected with spirits. ‘The account emphasizes the excitable neurosis of the patient; and the be- lief on the part of the apostles and of the writer of Acts that the girl was not the conscious accomplice of her masters, but their unfortunate victim through her mysterious malady, is clear. She was treated, as the other cases recorded in the NT, not as a conscious wrongdoer, but as a sick person to be healed. (1) Turning now to the OT, the instance which requires the most careful treatment, because it holds the key to all the rest, is the narrative of Saul’s Communion Comp. Religion THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 690 visit to the Witch of Endor in 1 S 28 3-25. The Heb word ’dbh which is usually tr? “‘one who has a familiar spirit’’ (see list of passages at 2. The Old beginning of art.) occurs in this nar- Testament rative four times (vs 3, 7 twice, 8). : According to the ordinary interpreta- tion it is used in three different senses, two of which occur here. These three senses are (a) a person who controls a spirit, (b) the spirit controlled, (c) the power to control such a spirit. This meaning appears to be altogether too broad. Omitting to translate the word we have: (ver 3) ‘Saul had put away dbhoth, and yidh‘dnim’’; (ver 7), a woman, a mistress of an ’dbh; (ver 8) “Divine untome.... by the ’obh.”’ It is extremely unlikely that the same word should be used in two senses go far apart as ‘person who has a spirit” and the “spirit itself” in the same context. In the last passage mentioned (ver 8) there is a double indication that the word ’6bh cannot have either signification mentioned. Saul says: ‘Divine unto me by the ’dbh and bring me up whomsoever J shall name unto thee.’ The expression ‘divine by” clearly points to some magi- cal object used in divination. Control of a spirit through some magical object is familiar enough. The rest of Saul’s statement confirms this view. The result of the divination is the calling up of a spirit. A spirit would hardly be used to call up another spirit. This conclusion is confirmed by the etymology. The word ’dbh is supposed to mean ‘‘one who has a familiar spirit,” from its root-significance of hollow and its primary meaning of wineskin. .According to this derivation the word is applied to a necromancer on the supposi- tion that the spirit inhabits his body and speaks from within. The transference to spirit is extremely unlikely and the explanation is not consistent with primitive ideas on spirit manifestation (see BDB, a8, end). (2) We, therefore, hold with H. P. Smith (UCC, “Samuel” in loc.), though partly on different grounds, that the word ’6bh has the same meaning in all the passages where it occurs, and that it refers to a sacred object or fetish by which spiritistic divination was carried on. The significance of this conclusion is that the misleading expression “familiar spirit’? disappears from the text, for Dr. Driver's interpretation of the companion word yidh‘énim (see ICC, Comm. Dt in loc.) will scarcely be maintained in the face of this new meaning for ’dbh. The prohibition contained in the law (Lev 20 27) against ’dbh6th, and those using them, places them in the same catalogue of offence and futility with idol-worship in general. (8) This opinion is confirmed by two separate items of evidence. (a) In the Witch of Endor story Samuel’s appearance, according to the idea of the narrator, was due to a miracle, not to the magic power of the feeble and cheating old woman to whom Saul had resorted. God speaks through the apparition a stern message of doom. No one was more startled than the woman herself, who for once had a real vision (ver 12). She not only gave a loud cry of astonishment and alarm but she described the figure which she saw as “a god coming up out of the earth.” The story is told with fidelity and clearly indicates the opinion that the actual appearance of a spirit is so violently exceptional as to indicate the immediate power and presence of God. (b) In Isa 8 19 the ’dbhkGth and yidh‘énim are spoken of as those who “‘chirp and mutter.” These terms refer to the necromancers themselves (LX X translates ’dbhith by eggastrémuthoi = ventriloquists) who practiced ventriloquism in conuection with their magicalrites. InIsa 29 4itis said ‘Thy voice shall beasan’dbh, out ofthe ground.” Here’dbhis usually interpreted as ‘‘ghost,” but it is far more probable (see BDB sub loc.) that it refers as in 8 19 to the ventriloquistic tricks of those who utter their oracles in voices intended to represent the spirits which they have evoked. They are stamped in these passages, as in the Witch of Endor narrative, as deceivers practising a fraudulent art. By implication their power to evoke spirits with whom they were in familiar intercourse is denied. : : This leaves the way clear for a brief consideration of the words of Paul in 1 Cor 10 20 in connection with cognate passages in the OT. 3. The (1) He argues that since idol-worship Meaning _is really demon-worship, the partaking of Idol- of heathen sacrifice is a communion Worship with demons and a separation from Christ. It is usually taken for granted that this characterization of heathen worship was simply a part of the Jewish-Christian elo against idolatry. Our fuller knowledge of the spiritism which conditious the use of images enables us to recognize the fact that from the viewpoint of hea- thenism itself Paul’s idea was strictly correct. The image is venerated because it is supposed to repre- sent or contain an invisible being or spirit, not necessarily a deity in the absolute sense, but a super- human living being capable of working good or ill to men. (2) In the AV the term devils is used in four OT passages (Lev 17 7; Dt 32 17; 2 Ch 11 15; Ps 106 37). In RV “devils” has disappeared from the text—the word he-goats appears in Lev 17 7 and 2 Ch 11 15, while “demons” appears in-Dt 32 17 and Ps 106 37. The tr of s*trim as “‘he-goats”’ is literally correct, but conveys an erroneous con- ception of the meaning. The practice reprobated is the worship of Satyrs (see Satyr) or wood- demons supposed to be like goats in appearance and to inhabit lonely places. The same word is used in Isa 13 21; 34 14. The word tr‘ “demons” in RV is shédhim, a term used only twice and both times in connection with the rites and abominations of heathen worship. It is interesting to note that the word shidu is applied to the beings represented by the bull-colossi of Assyria (Driver, Dt in loc.). BDB holds that the word shédhtm is an Assyr loan- word, while Briggs (ICC, Ps 106 37) holds that shédhim were ancient gods of Canaan. In either case the word belongs to heathenism and is used in Scripture to describe heathen worship in its own terminology. ‘The interpretation of these beings as evil is characteristic of Bib. demonism in general (see Demon, etc). The worship of idols was the worship of personal beings more than man and less than God, according to Jewish and Christian ideas (see Driver op. cit., 363). LXX translates both the above words by daiménia. The term ‘communion with demons” does not imply any power on the part of men to enter into voluntary relationship with beings of another world, but that, by sinful compliance in wrongdoing, such as idol- worship and magical rites, men may enter into a moral identification with evil powers against which it is their duty to fight. Literature.—The Dictionaries and Commentaries dealing with the passages quoted above contain discus- sions of the various aspects of the subject. Jewish superstitions are ably treated by Edersheim, LTJM (8th ed), II, 771, 773. 4. Conclu- sion Lovis Marruzws Sweer COMMUNITY, ké-mi’ni-ti, OF GOODS (drav- ra Kkowd elxov, hépanta koind etchon, lit. “They had all things [in] common”): In Acts 2 44, it is said that, in the infant church at Jerus, ‘all that believed were together, and had all things common,” and (4 34f) ‘as many as were possessors of lands or houses sold them, and brought the prices of the things that were sold, and laid them at the apostles’ 691 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Communion Comp. Religion feet.’”? The inference from this, that there was an absolute disposal of all the property of all the mem- bers of the church, and that its proceeds were con- tributed to a common fund, has been disputed upon the ground that the example of Barnabas in selling “a, field” for this purpose (4 37) would not have been mentioned, if this had been the universal rule. The thought conveyed is that all believers in that church held their Prcuseny as a trust from the Lord, for the benefit of the entire brotherhood, and, as there was need, did as Barnabas. No commandment, of which record has been preserved, prescribed any such course. It came from the spontaneous impulse of the sense of brotherhood in Christ, when the band of disciples was still small, making them in a sense one family, and under the external constraint of extreme want and persecution. So much there was, that they realized, under such conditions they had in com- mon, that they were ready to extend this to all things. It was, in a sense, a continuance of the practice of a common purse in the band of imme- diate followers of Our Lord during his ministry. The penalty inflicted on Ananias and Sapphira was not for any failure to comply fully with this custom, but because this freedom which they possessed (Acts 5 4) they falsely professed to have renounced, thus receiving in the estimation of their brethren a credit that was not their due. This custom did not last long. It was possible only within a limited circle, and under very peculiar circumstances. The NT recognizes the right of individual property and makes no effort to remove the differences that exist among believers them- selves. The community of goods which it renders possible is spiritual (1 Cor 3 211), and not one of visible and external things. With respect to the latter, it enjoins upon the Christian, as a steward of God, the possession and administration of prop- erty for the progress of the kingdom of God, and the highest interests of men. The spirit of Acts 4 34 is always to pervade the association of be- lievergs as a true Christian community. Meyer, on the above passage, has suggested that it is not unlikely that the well-known poverty of the church at Jerus, and its long dependence upon the alms of other churches, may be connected with this early communistic practice, which, however justifiable and commendable at the time, bore its inevitable fruits in a subsequent season of great scarcity and lack of employment. H. E. Jacozs COMPACT, kom-pakt’, COMPACTED, kom- pakt’ed ("2% , habhar, “to be joined”; cupBipdto, sumbibdzo, “to raise up together”): ‘‘Compact” appears as tr of habhar in Ps 122 3, ‘‘Jerus... . a city that is compact together’ (well built, its breaches restored, walls complete, and separate from all around it); and “compacted” (sumbibaz0) occurs in AV Eph 4 16, “fitly joined together and compacted,” RV “fitly framed and knit together.” In RV “compacted” is also the tr of curlernp, sunistemi, “to set together’’ (2 Pet 3 5), “an earth compacted out of water and amidst [m, through] water,” which suggests the idea of water as the pri- mary material (cf Gen 1 2). W. L. Walker (2) Military, g*dhadh, “troop,” hadmon, 2 Ch 20 12; rd’sh, “head,” “detachment”; Jgs 7 16.20: “three companies’; 9 34.37.43: “four companies.” (3) Band (hebher) or “gang,” as rendered by Keil and Delitzsch; a gang of murderous priests (Hos 6 9). (4) Camp or encampment (Gen 32 8.21; 60 9). (5) Religious body, “company of prophets” (1 8 19 20). ; (6) Assembly, congregation, “company of na- tions’ (Gen 35 11; Ezk 38 4.7.13.15). (7) A tumultuous crowd (2 K 9 17). (8) Associate, companion, often with reference to moral affinity (Job 34.8; Prov 29 3; Acts 10 28), kolléomaz, “to glue or cement together,” indicative of the binding power of moral affinity (RV “to join himself”); as a verb, to “company with” or “keep company” (Acts 1 21; 1 Cor 5 9.11; 2 Thess 3 14). In Apoc in the sense of “‘to co- habit” (Sus 1 54.57.58). (9) A host. “Great was the company,” ete (Ps 68 11 RV “The women... . are a great host’’). In the East it is the women who celebrate victories with song and dance (see 1 § 18 6.7). (10) A chorus, dance (m*halah). ‘The company of two armies’”’ (Cant 6 13 AV; RV ‘‘the dance of Mahanaim”’). (11) Meal party, «rola, klisia, ‘a reclining com- pany at meals.” “Make them sit down [Gr “recline’’ in companies” (Lk 9 14). Cf ‘‘companion,” from Lat com, ‘‘together,’”’ and panis, “bread.” (12) A myriad, a ten-thousand, an indefinite number (murias; He 12 22 [RV “‘hosts’’]). (13) Companions on a journey, sunodia, “a journeying together” (Lk 2 44). (14) Signifying kinship of spirit, idéos, “one’s own.” ‘They came to their own company” (Acts 4 23). (15) A mob (Acts 17 5 [RV ‘‘a crowd”]). Dwicut M. Pratt COMPARATIVE, kom-par’a-tiv, RELIGION: I. Tue Sussect 1n GENBRAL 1. Universality of Religion 2. Theories of Its Origin 3. Evolution II. Revation or CHRISTIANITY TO ETHNIC FalTHS AND THEIR TENETS . Karma God . The Summum Bonum . Self-Revelation of God . Incarnation . Salvation . Faith . Approach to God III. Generat CaaractTenristics or Eranic Farras . Tenets Common to All Religions . Tendency to Degradation . Mythology and Religion . Religion and Morality UPPOSED RESEMBLANCES TO REVEALED RELIGION . Rites . Dogmas . Asserted Parallels to Gospel History 4, Virgin Birth 5. Heathen Asplrations 6. Lessons Taught by Comparative Religion LITERATURE DON Gerd whe IV. ONE DRONE L The Subject in General.—The science of com- parative religion is perhaps the latest. born of all sciences. Largely in consequence of this fact, our knowledge of what it really proves is still far from definite, and men draw most contradictory conclu- sions on this point. Asin the case of all new sciences in the past, not a few people have endeavored under its shelter to attack Christianity and all revealed religion. These assaults already give signs of failure —ag in similar cases previously—and a new evidence of Christianity is emerging from the conflict. It is only “a little learning” that is proverbially danger- ous. The subject with which the science of com- parative religion deals is religion in general and all the facts which can be learnt about all religions, Comp. Religion THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 692 ancient and modern, whether professed by savages or prevalent among highly civilized communities, whether to be studied in sacred books or learnt orally from the people. In this way we learn first of all that religion is a universal phenomenon, found among all nations, in all conditions, though differing im- 1. Univer- mensely in its teachings, ceremonies sality of and effectsin different places. It is per- Religion baps the most powerful for good or evil of all the instincts (for it is an instinct) which influence mankind. To account for the origin and growth of religion various theories have been propounded: (1) ‘“Hu- manism,” which is the revival of the 2. Theories ancient view of Euhémeros (cir 400 BC) of Origin _ that all religion arose from fearof ghosts, and Growth and all the gods were but. men who of Religion had died; (2) ‘‘Animism,”’ which traces religion to early man’s fancy that every object in Nature had a personality like his own; (8) the Astral Theory, which supposes that religion originated from worship of the heavenly bodies. It is clear that there are facts to support each of these hypotheses, yet no one of them satisfies all the conditions of the case. To (1) it has been re- plied that most tribes from the earliest times clearly distinguished between those deities who had been men, and the gods proper, who had never been men and had never died. Regarding (2), it should be observed that it admits that man’s consciousness of his own personality and his fancy that it exists in other creatures also does not account for his worshipping them, unless we grant the existence of the sensus numinis within him: if so, then this explains, justifies, and necessitates religion. (3) The Astral Theory is in direct opposition to Eu- hémerism or Humanism. It ascribes personality to the heavenly bodies in man’s early fancy; but it, too, has to presuppose the sensus numinis, without which religion would be impossible, as would be the science of optics if man had not the sense of sight. It is often held that religion is due to evolution. If so, then its evolution, resulting ex hypothesi in Christianity as its acme, must be the 3. Evolution working out of a Divine “Eternal Purpose”’ (préthesis tin aidnén, Eph 3 11), just as has been the evolution of an amoeba into a man on the Evolutionary Theory. This would be an additional proof of the truth of Christianity. But, though doubtless there has been evolution—or gradual progress under Divine guidance—in religion, the fact of Christ is sufficient to show that there is a Divine self-revelation too. Hence the claim of Christianity to be the absolute religion. ‘‘The pre- Christian religions were the age-long prayer, the In- carnation was the answer” (Illingworth). Chris- tianity as revealed in Christ adds what none of the ethnic faiths could prove their claim to—autbority, holiness, revelation. Il. Relation of Christianity to Ethnic Faiths and Their Tenets.—It is very remarkable that Christianity—though clearly not a philosophy but a religion that has arisen under historical circum- stances which preclude the possibility of supposing it the product of Eclecticism—yet sums up in itself all that is good in all religions and_philosophies, without the bad, the fearful perversions and cor- ruptions of the moral sense, too often found in them. The more the study of comparative religion is carried on the more plainly evident does this be- come. It also supplements in a wonderful way the half-truths concealed rather than revealed in other systems, whether religious or philosophical. We subjoin a few instances of this. Karma is strongly insisted on in Hinditiism and Buddhism. These teach that every deed, good or bad, must have its result, that “its fruit must be eaten” here or hereafter. So does Christianity quite as forcibly (Gal 6 7.8). But neither Indian faith explains how sin can be forgiven, evil be overruled for good, nor how, by trampling under foot their vices, men may rise higher (Aug., Sermo iii, De Ascensione). They recognize, in some sense, the existence of evil, and illogically teach that rites and certain ascetic practices help to overcome it. They know of no Atonement, though modern Hinduism en- deavors to propitiate the deities by sacrifices, as indeed was done in Vedic times. Conscience they cannot explain. Christianity, while showing the heinousness of sin as no other system does, and so supplementing the others, supplements them still further by the Atonement, showing that God is just, and teaching how His very righteousness can be brought to ‘“justify’”’ the sinner (Rom 3 26). Mahayana Buddhism proclaims an_ immanent but not transcendent being (Dharma-kdya), who is “the ultimate reality that underlies 2. God all particular phenomena’ (Suzuki), who wills and reflects, though not fully personal. He is not the Creator of the world but a kind of Animus mundi. He is the sum total of all sentient beings, and they have no individual exist- ence, no “ego-soul.” The world of matter has no real existence but is his self-manifestation. Chris- tianity supplements and corrects this by teaching the transcendence as well as the immanence (Acts 17 28) of the Creator, who is at least personal, if not something higher, who is the Source of reality though not Himself the sole reality, and of our personality and life, and “who only hath immor- tality” (1 Tim 6 16). Vedantism and Sifiism proclaim that ultimate absorption in the impersonal “It” is the summum bonum, and the Chandogya Upanishad 1. Karma 3. The says, ‘‘There is just one thing, without “Summum a second” (Book VI, 21, 2). Of this Bonum” one thing everything is, so to speak, a part: there being no ultimate differ- ence between the human and the Divine. Thus sin is denied and unreality proclaimed (May4, illusion). The yearning for union with God underlying all this is satisfied in Christianity, which provides reconciliation with God and shows how by new spiritual birth men may become children of God (Jn 1 12.13) and “partakers of the divine nature”’ (2 Pet 14), without being swallowed up therein like a raindrop in the ocean: the union being spiritual and not material. Orthodox (Sunni) Muslim theology declares God to be separated from man by an impassable gulf and hence to be unknowable. 4. Self- Philosophically this leads to Agnos- Revelation ticism, though opposed to Polytheism. of God Among the Jews the philosophy of : Maimonides ends in the same failure to attain to a knowledge of the Divine or to describe God except by negations (Sépher Ha-madda‘,1 11). The Bible, on the other hand, while speaking of Him as invisible, and unknowable through merely human effort (Job 11 7.8; Jn 1 18), yet reveals Him in Christ, who is God and man. Jewish mysti- cism endeavored to solve the problem of creation by the invention of the ’Adham kadhmén (archetypal man), and earlier by Philo’s Logos doctrine and the Mémr@ of the Targums. But these abstractions have neither reality nor personality. The Christian Logos doctrine presents no theoretical but the actual his- torical, eternal Christ (cf Jn 1 1-3; He 1 2). Heathenism seeks to give some idea of the Invisible by means of idols; Vaish- navism has its doctrine of avatdras; Babtism and 5. Incar- nation 693 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Comp. Religion Bahdiism their dogma of ‘‘manifestations” (mazhar) in human beings; the ‘Alt-ilahis arc so called because they regard ‘Ali as God. Instead of these unworthy theories and deifications, Christianity supplies the holy, sinless, perfect Incarnation in Christ. Hindiiism offers mukti (médksha), ‘deliverance’ from a miserable existence; Christianity in Christ offers pardon, deliverance from sin, and 6. Salvation reconciliation with God. Krishnaism teaches unreasoning ‘‘de- votion” (bhakti) of “mind, body, property” to certain supposed incarnations of Krishna (Vishnu), quite regardless of their immoral conduct; 7. Faith Christianity inculcates a manly, reason- able “faith” in Christ, but only after “proving all things.”’ Pilgrimages in Islim and Hinditism indicate but do not satisfy a need for approach to God; Christianity teaches a growth in grace and in like- 8. Approach ness to Christ, and so a spiritual draw- to God ing near to God. HI. General Characteristics of Eth- nic Faiths.—In all religions we find, though in many various forms, certain common beliefs, such as: (1) the existence of some spiritual 1. Tenets power or powers, good or bad, superior Common to man and able to affect his present to All and future life; (2) that there is a Religions difference between right and wrong, even though not clearly defined; (3) that there is an after-life of some sort, with happiness or misery often regarded as in some measure dependent upon conduct or upon the ob- servance of certain rites here. In the main the fact of the all but universal agreement of religions upon these points proves that they are true in substance. Even such an agnostic philosophy as original Buddhism was, has been constrained by human need to evolve from itself or admit from without deistic or theistic elements, and thus Buddha himself has been deified by the Mahayana School. Yet no ethnic faith satisfies the “human soul naturally Christian,” as Tertullian calls it (Liber Apologeticus, cap. 17), for none of them reveals One God, personal, holy, loving, just, mer- ciful, omniscient and omnipotent. Even Islam fails here. Ethnic religions are either (1) poly- theistic, worshipping many gods, all imperfect and some evil, or (2) mystical, evaporating away, as it were, God’s Personality, thus rendering Him a mental] abstraction, as in the Hindi philosophical systems and in Mahayana Buddhism. Christianity as revealed in Christ does just what all other faiths fail to do, reconciling these two tendencies and cor- recting both. As a general rule, the nearer to their source we can trace religions, the purer we find them. In most cases a tendency to degradation 2. Ten- and not to progressive improvement dency to manifests itself as time goes on, and Degrada- this is sometimes carried to such an tion, not to extent that, as Lucretius found in Progress, in Rome and Greece, religion becomes a Ethnic curse and not a blessing. Thus, for Faiths example, regarding ancient Egypt, Professor Renouf says: “The sub- limer portions of the Egyp religion are not the com- paratively late result of a process of development. The sublimer portions are demonstrably ancient, and the last stage of the Egyp religion was by far the grossest and most corrupt” (Hibbert Lectures, 91). Modern Hinditiism, again, is incomparably lower in its religious conceptions than the religion of the Vedas. In Polynesia the same rule holds good, as is evident from the myths about Tangaroa. In Samoa he was said to be the son of two beings, the ‘“Cloudless Heaven” and the ‘“Outspread Heaven.” He originally existed in open space. He made the sky to dwell in. He then made the earth. Somewhat later he was supposed to be visible in the moon! But a lower depth was reached. In Hawaii, Tangaroa has sunk to an evil being, the leader of a rebellion against another god, Tane, and is now condemned to abide in the lowest depths of darkness and be the god of death. In South Africa, Australia and elsewhere, traditions still linger of a Creator of all things, but his worship has been entirely laid aside in favor of lower and more evil deities. Almost everywhere mythology has arisen and perverted religion into something very different from what it once was. The same 3. Mytholo- tendency has more than once mani- gy and fested itself in the Christian church, Religion thus rendering a return to Christ’s teachings necessary. As an instance, compare the modern popular religion of Italy with that of the NT. It is remarkable that no religion but the Christian, however, has shown its capability of reform. For the most part, in ethnic religions, there is no recognized connection between religion and moral- ity. The wide extension of phallic 4. Religion rites and the existence of hierédoulai and Moral- and hierddoulot in many lands show ity in that religion has often consecrated Ethnic gross immorality. Mythology aids in Faiths this degradation. Hence Seneca, after mentioning many evil myths related of Jupiter, etc., says: ‘By which nothing else was effected but the removal from men of their shame at sinning, if they deemed such beings gods” (L. A. Seneca, De beata vita cap. 26). With the possibly doubtful exception of the religion of cer- tain savage tribes, in no religion is the holiness of God taught except in Christianity and its initial stage, Judaism. Ethnic deities are mostly born of heaven and earth, if not identified with them in part, and are rarely regarded as creating them. It was otherwise, however, with Ahura Mazda in Zoroastrianism, and with certain Sumerian deities, and there are other exceptions, too. The “religions of Nature” have generally produced gross immor- ality, encouraged and even insisted upon as a part of their ritual; cf Mylitta-worship in Babylon and that of the “Mater detm,” Venus, Anahita, etc. IV. Supposed Resemblances to Revealed Re- ligion.—Much attention has been called to real or supposed community of rites and 1. Rites “myths,” esp. when any ethnic faith is compared with Christianity. Sac- rifice, for instance, is an essential part of every religion. In Christianity none are now offered, except the “living sacrifice’ of the believer, though that of Christ offered once for all is held to be the substance foreshadowed by Jewish sacrifices. Purifi- catory bathings are found almost everywhere, and that very naturally, because of the universality of conscience and of some sense of sin. Belief in the fiery end of the world existed among the Stoics, and is found in the Eddas of Scandi- - navia and the Purdnas of India. 2. Dogmas Traditions of an age before sin and death came upon mankind occur in many different lands. Many of these traditions may easily be accounted for. But in some cases the supposed resemblance to revealed religion does not exist, or is vastly exaggerated. The Yoga philosophy in India is popularly supposed to aim at union with God, as does Christianity; but (so understood) the Yéga system, as has already been said, implies loss of personality and absorption into the impersonal, unconscious “It” (Tat). The doctrine of a Trinity is nowhere found, only Triads Comp. Religion Comprehend THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 694 of separate deities. Belief in a resurrection is found in only very late parts of the Pers (Zoroastrian) scriptures, composed after cents. of communication with Jews and Christians. In the earlier Avesta ouly a “restoration” of the world is mentioned (cf Acts 3 21). Original (Hinayana) Buddhism teaches ‘immortality’? (amata), but by this is meant Nir- vdna (“extinction”). Mithraism has been said to teach the “resurrection of the body,’’ but, according to Eubilus and Porphyry, it taught rather the transmigration of the soul. The assertion is often made that many of the leading gospel incidents in the life of Our Lord are paralleled in other religions. It is 3. Asserted said, for instance, that the resurrec- Parallels to tion of Adonis, Osiris and Mithra Gospel was believed in by their followers. It History is true that, in some places, Adonis was said to have come to life the day after he had met his death by the tusk of a boar (the cold of winter); but everywhere it was recog- nized that he was not a man who had been killed, but the representative of the produce of the soil, slain or dying down in the cold weather and grow- ing again in spring. As to Osiris, his tomb was shown in more than one place in Egypt, and his body was never supposed to have come to life again, though his spirit was alive and was ruler of the underworld. Mithra was admitted to be the genius of the sun. He was said to have sprung from a rock (in old Pers and Sanskrit the same word means “sky,” “cloud” and “rock’’), but not to have been incarnated, nor to have died, much less to have risen from the dead. The modern erroneous fancy that Mithraists believed in his resurrection rests solely on one or at most two passages in Christian writers, which really refer to the burial of Osiris and the removal of his body from the tomb by his hostile brother Typhon (Set). The high morality attributed to Mithraism and even to the worship of Isis rests on no better foundation than the wrong rendering of a few passages and the deliberate ignoring of many which contradict the theory. Virgin birth, we have been told, is a doctrine of many religions. As a matter of fact, it is found in hardly one ethnic faith. Nothing of the kind was believed regarding Osiris, Adonis, Horus, Mithra, Krish- na, Zoroaster. Of Buddha it is denied entirely in all the books of the Southern Canon (Pali), and is found expressed only vaguely in one or two late unecanonical works of the Northern (Sanskrit) School. It was doubtless borrowed from Christianity. Supernatural birth of quite a dif- ferent (and very repulsive) kind is found in many mythologies, but that is quite another thing. Heathenism contains some vague aspirations and unconscious prophecies, the best example of which is to be found in Vergil’s Fourth 5. Heathen Eclogue, if that be not rather due to Aspirations Jewishinfluence. Any such foregleams and Un- of the coming light as are real and not conscious merely imaginary, such, for instance, Prophecies as the Indian doctrine of the avataras or “descents” of Vishnu, are to be accounted for as part of the Divine education of the human race. The “false dawn,” so well known in the East, is not a proof that the sun is not about to rise, nor can its existence justify anyone in shut- ting his eyes to and rejecting the day- 6. Lessons light when it comes. It is but a 4. Virgin Birth Taught by harbinger of the real dawn. Compara- Comparative religion teaches us that tive religion is essential to and distinctive Religion of humanity. The failures of the eth- nic faiths no less than their aspirations show how great is man’s need of Christ, and how utterly unable imagination has ever proved itself to be even to conceive of such an ideal character as He revealed to us in the full light of history and in the wonder-working effects of His character upon the lives and hearts of those who then and in all ages since have in Him received life and light. Literature.—Tylor, Anthropology; Jordan, Compara- tive Religion, Its Genesis and Growth; Falke, Zum Kampfe der drei Weltreligionen; Gould, Origin and Development of Religious Belief; Jevyons, Introduction to the History of Religion; Reville, Prolegomena to the History of Religions; Max Miiller, Introduction to the Science of Religion; Hard- wick, Christ and Other Masters; Kellogg, The Light of Asia and the Light of the World; Farrar, The Witness of History to Christ; A. Lang, Magic and Religion; The Making of Religion; Johnson, Oriental Religions and Their Relation to Universal Religion; Farnell, The Evolution of Religion; Howitt, The Native Tribes of S.E. Australia; Smith, Reli- gion of the Semites; Reinach, Cultes, mythes et religions; Dilger, Erldschen des Menschen nach Hinduismus und Christentum; Rhys Davids, Origin and Growth of Religion; Kuenen, National Religions and Universal Religion (Hib- bert Lectures, 1882); Déllinger, The Gentile and_the Jew in the Courts of the Temple of Christ (1862); Dodson, Evolution and Its Bearing on Religion; MacCulloch, Com- parative Theology; Baumann, Uber Religionen und Reli- gion; Waitz, Anthropologie der Naturvélker; Hastings, Encyclopaedia_of Religion and Ethics; Frazer, Adonis, Attis, Osiris; Dufourca, Hist. comparée des rel. paiennes et dela religion juive; Oesterley, Evolution of Religious Ideas; Martindale, Bearing of Comp. Study of Religions on Claims of Christianity; W. St. Clair Tisdall, Comparative Religion. W. St. Ciair Tispsu COMPARE, kom-par’ (797, damah, >, ma- shal, 71¥, ‘drakh; wapaBdddw, parabdlld, cvyxpive, sugkrind): “Compare” is the tr of 2%, damah, “to be like’ (Cant 1 9); of >on, mashal, “to liken,” “compare” (Isa 46 5); of J, ‘drakh, “‘to set in array,” “compare” (Ps 89 6; Isa 40 18); of MW, shdwah, “to be equal” (Prov 3 15; 8 11). _ Inthe NT sugkrino, “to judge” or “sift together,” is tr’ “comparing,” “comparing spiritual things with spiritual” (1 Cor 2 13 ERV), ARV “combining” (“adapting the discourse to the subject,’’ Thayer), RVm “interpreting spiritual things to spiritual [men].” . L. WaLker COMPASS, kum’pas, COMPASSES, kum’pas- iz: “Compass,” noun, is the tr of 457, high, “a circle,” “vault” or “arch” (‘when he set a compass upon the face of the depth” Prov 8 27 AV, RV, ARV “circle”; cf Job.26 10; and see Circus; Vauut or Harta); of 2373, karkdbh, “a margin,” “border” (Ex 27 5, “the compass of the altar,” RV “the ledge round,” so 38 4); the phrase “to fetch a compass” is the tr of 130, sabhabh, “to turn about,” “go round about” (Nu 34 5; Josh 15 3, RV “turn about,” 28 6 28; 2K 39, RV “make a circuit’); of periérchomat, “to go about’ (Acts 28 13, RV ‘made a circuit”; m “Some ancient authorities read cast loose’; see Crrcurt). “Compasses” is RV for “compass,” MIN, m¢htighdh, an instrument for describing a circle: “He marketh it out with the compasses” (isa 44 13) in making an idol. The vb. “to compass” occurs frequently in the senses of ‘‘to surround” and ‘‘to go round about,’ e.g. Gen 2 11, ‘which compasseth the whole land of Havilah,” Dt 2 1, “We compassed [went around] mount Seir many days’; in Jer 31 22 we have “A new thing on the earth: a woman shall compass a man,” RV “encompass”; possibly as a suitor; but more probably as a protector. In those happy days, the ape aaa of women (under God, ver 28) will be sufficient, while the men are at tbeir work; “to encompass” (“The cords of death compassed me,” Ps 18 4; ‘‘the waves of death,” 2S 22 5). “To gird” (Isa 50 11 RV); “to lie around,” “to be laid around’’ (He 5 2, “compassed with infirm- ity” [clothed with it]; 12 1, “compassed about with so great a cloud of witnesses’’). 695 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Comp. Religion Comprehend In Apoc we have ‘‘compassed about with yawning darkness’ (Wisd 19 17); ‘“‘compassed the circuit of heaven” (Ecclus 24 5); ‘‘compassed with pome- granates of gold” (45 9); “The rainbow compasseth the heaven’ (Ecclus 48 12); the course of the sun (1 Esd 4 34). W. L. WaLkKER COMPASSION, kom-pash’un: Compassion is the tr of BI, raham, “to love,” “pity,” “be merciful” (Dt 13 17; 30 3); of rahdmim, “mercies” (1 K 8 50); of San, hamal, ‘to pity,” ‘“‘spare”’ (Ex 2 6; 1S 23 21); DAMN, rahim (Ps 78 38; 86 15; 111 4; 112 4; 145 8), is rendered by ARV “merciful.” We have orhdayx vltouar, splagchnizomat, ‘to have the bowels yearning,” in Mt 9 36; 14 14, etc; sumpathés (He 10 34), “‘to suffer with [another]; sumpathés (1 Pet 3 8, RV ‘compassionate,’ m “Gr sympa- thetic’); metriopathéo (He 5 2, RV “who can bear ently with”); eleéd, “to show mildness,” “kindness” Mt 18 33; Mk 6 19; Jude ver 22, RV “mercy’’); oiktetrd, ‘to have pity” or ‘‘mercy’’ (Rom 9 15 dis). Both raham and splagchnizomai are examples of the physical origin of spiritual terms, the bowels being regarded as the seat of the warm, tender emotions or feelings. But, while raham applied to the lower viscera as well as the higher, spldgch- non denoted chiefly the higher viscera, the heart, lungs, liver. RV gives ‘‘compassion’’ for “mercy” (Isa 9 17; 14 1; 27 11; 49 13; Jer 13 14; 30 18; Dnl 19 AV “tender love with”; for “bowels of compassion,” 1 Jn 3 17); for “mercy” (He 10 28); ‘full of compassion” for “merciful” (ARV “merciful” in all cases) (Ex 34 6; Neh 9 17; Ps 103 8; Joel 2 13; Jon 4 2); “compassions” for “mercies” (Isa 63 15; Phil 2 1), for “repentings’”’ (Hos 11 8). Compassion, lit. a feeling with and for others, is a fundamental and distinctive quality of the Bib. - conception of God, and to its prominence the world owes more than words can express. (1) It lay at the foundation of Israel’s faith in Jeh. For it was out of His compassion that He, by a marvelous act of power, delivered them from Egyp bondage and called them to be His own people. Nothing, there- fore, is more prominent in the OT than the ascrip- tion of compassion, pity, mercy, etc, to God; the people may be said to have gloried in it. It is summed up in such sayings as that of the great declaration in Ex 34 6: ‘‘Jehovah—a God full of compassion [ARV merciful] and gracious” ¢ Ps 78 38: 8615; 111 4; 112 4; 145 8; Lath 3 22, “Hig compassions fail not’’). And, because this was the character of their God, the prophets de- clared that compassion was an essential require- ment on the part of members of the community (Hos 6 6; Mic 6 8; cf Prov 19 17). (2) In Jesus Christ, in whom God was ‘manifest in the flesh,” compassion was an outstanding feature (Mt 9 36; 14 14, etc) and He taught that it ought to be ex- tended, not to friends and neighbors only, but to all without exception, even to enemies (Mt 5 43-48; Lk 10 30-37). The God of the NT, the Father of men, is most clearly revealed as ‘a God full of compassion.” It extends to the whole human race, for which He effected not merely a temporal, but a spiritual and eternal, deliverance, giving up His own Son to the death of the cross in order to save us from the worst bondage of sin, with its consequences; seeking thereby to gain a new, wider people for Himself, still more devoted, more filled with and expressive of His own Spirit. Therefore all who know the God and Father of Christ, and who call themselves His children, must necessarily cultivate compas- sion and show mercy, “even as he is merciful.” Hence the many apostolic injunctions to that effect (Eph 4 32; Col 3 12; Jas 1 27; 1 Ju 3 17, etc). Christianity may be said to be distinctively the religion of Compassion. W. L. WALKER COMPEL, kom-pel’: Our Eng. word always has in it now the flavor of force, not always, however, physical. It may be strong moral urgency, though “constrain” better expresses this. There are several words indicative of such stron pressure: (1) O38, ’dnag, “to press’: “none coul compel” to drink (Est 1 8); (2) M73, 1. Inthe néddhah, ‘to drive,” ‘force’: “com- OT elled Judah thereto” (AV, RVm); “led Fade astray” RV (2 Ch 21 11). The same word rendered ‘force,’ as the adulteress by flattering words her victim (Prov 7 21); (3) 72%, ‘abhadh, “to serve”: not to compel him to serve as a bond servant (Lev 25 39 AV, RV “make him serve”); (4) JIB, pdrag, “to break forth upon,” “urge”: “his servants compelled him” (1 S 28 23 AV, RV “constrained”). In the NT two words are found: (1) dyyapedw, aggareio: The word is of Pers origin and means to employ a courier. The Aggaroi 2. Inthe | were public couriers stationed by ap- NT ointment of the kings of Persia, at xed localities, with horses ready for use, to transmit speedily from one to another the royal messages. These couriers had authority to press into their service, in case of need, horses, vessels, and even men, they might meet (Jos, Ant, XIII, ii, 3); “compel thee to go a mile” (Mt & 41 AV; RVm ‘impress’’); “compelled Simon to bear his cross” (Mt 27 32; Mk 15 21AV; RVm ‘Gmpressed’’). (2) dvayedgw, anagkdzd, ‘to con- strain,” whether by force, threats, entreaties, per- suasion, etc: ‘compel them to come in” (Lk 14 23 AV; RV “constrain’’). This has been a favorite text of religious persecutors. As Robertson says in his history of Charles V, “As they could not per- suade, they tried to compel men to believe.’ But it simply means that utmost zeal and moral urgency should be used by Christians to induce sinners to enter the Kingdom of God. Cf Acis 26 11. Grorce Henry TREVER COMPLAINING, kom-plan'‘ing (TX, ¢ewa- hah, “ery,” “outery,” SW, sth, “meditation,” “complaint”): ¢°wahah is tr? “complaining” (Ps 144 14, RV “outcry,” “no c. [outcry] in our streets,” i.e. “open places’’ where the people commonly assembled near the gate of the city (cf 2 Ch 32 6; Neh 8 1); a picture of peace in the city (cf Isa 24 11; Jer 14 2); some render “‘battlecry’; si*h (RV Prov 23 29, AV “babbling’’), of the drunkard. COMPLETE, kom-plét’: In AV for Anpéw, plér66, the vb. ordinarily used for the coming to pass of what had been predicted. AV translates this “complete” in Col 2 10; 4 12 to express the final and entire attainment of what is treated, leaving nothing beyond to be desired or hoped for; otherwise rendered in RV (“made full’). In RV, ¢. appears once for Gr drtios, from dré, “‘to join,” in 2 Tim 3 17, in sense of “‘accurately fitted for,” where AV has “perfect.”’ COMPOSITION, kom-pé-zish’un (M332, math- koneth, ‘‘measure”); COMPOUND, kom’pound (subst.) (TP7, rakah, ‘to make perfume,” Mp7, rékah, “perfume”): Used of the sacred anointing oil (Ex 30 25.32.33) and of the holy perfume (vs 37.38), which were not to be used for any profane purpose. COMPREHEND, kom-pré-hend’: Used in a twofold sense in both the OT and NT. This Conaniah Concourse THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 696 double meaning appears in two Heb and two Gr words which signify in turn (1) mental or spiritual perception, (2) capacity to hold or contain, as in a measure or in an all-inclusive principle, e.g.: (1) YT), yadha', “to see with the eyes or the mind,” hence “know,” “understand.” Job was urged by Elihu to accept as inscrutable the ways of God, inasmuch as His operations in the physical world are so mighty and mysterious that ‘we cannot comprehend”? them (Job 37 5). Modern science, in unveiling the secrets of Nature, is open- ing the way for a better understanding of God’s creative purpose and plan. KaTadauBdvw, katalambdnd, “to lay hold of,” hence mentally to apprehend: used of the spiritual capaci- ty of the Christian ‘‘to comprehend [RV ‘‘appre- hend”] with all saints’ (Eph 3 18) the measureless love of God; and of the inability of the unrenewed heart to know or perceive the revelation of God made in Christ: ‘the darkness comprehended it not” (Jn 15 RV “apprehended”; RVm ‘“‘overcame’’; ef 12 35). (2) bn, kal, “to measure” or “contain,” as grain in a bushel. So God’s immeasurable great- ness is seen in His being able to hold oceans in the hollow of His hand and “comprehend the dust of the earth in a measure” (Isa 40 12). dvaxepadaidw, anakephalaiéd, “to sum up under one head,” e.g. love includes every other moral principle and process. The entire law on_ its manward side, says Paul, “is comprehended [RV “summed up”’| in this saying, namely, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself” (Rom 13 9). Dwiest M. Pratrr CONANIAH, kon-a-ni’a (7179213, konanyaha, “Jah has founded or sustained”; AV Cononiah): (1) A Levite, appointed with his brother Shimei by Hezekiah, the king, and Azariah, the ruler of the house of God, to be overseer of the oblations and tithes and the dedicated things (2 Ch 31 12.18). (2) One of the chiefs of the Levites mentioned in connection with the passover celebration in Josiah’s reign (2 Ch 35 9). CONCEAL, kon-sél’ (wapaxadinro, parakalipts): Found but once in the NT (Lk 9 45). The primary meaning is to cover by hanging something in front of the object hidden. The purpose of the one con- cealing is made prominent. There is, therefore, a reserve and studied progress in regard to the state- ment of facts, that is not always a suppression of truth (Prov 12 16.23). God withholds more than He reveals (Prov 25 2; ef Ps 97 2; 1 Tim 6 16). CONCEIT, kon-sét’: An idiomatic rendering of a phrase, Pporvipor ev éavrois, phrénimoi en heautois, in Rom 11 25; 12 16; meaning lit. ‘“‘wise with one’s self,” ie. ‘4n one’s own opinion,” or, as in || OT passages (Prov 26 5.12 RVm), “in his own eyes” (Heb ‘ayin). CONCEPTION, kon-sep’shun, CONCEIVE, kon- sev’ (MN, harah, and derivatives; cvA\apBdvo, sullambdn6): Physically, the beginning of a new life in the womb of a mother, “‘to catch on,” used thus some forty times, as in Gen 3 16; 4 1; Ps 51 5. Metaphorically, applied to the start and growth within the heart, of thought, purpose, desire, e.g. “ce, mischief” (Job 15 35; Ps 7 14), ‘“‘c. chaff’ (Isa 33 11). This figure is carried out in details in Jas 115: ‘Lust, when it hath conceived, beareth sin.” CONCEPTION, IMMACULATE. See Immac- ULATE CONCEFTION. CONCERNING, kon-sfirn'‘ing: RV makes frequent changes, such as ‘‘for,” “as for,” “from,” “about,” for “concerning’”’; ‘‘concern- ing” instead of “for,” “of,’”’ “over,” “in,” “against.,”’ etc. Some of the other changes are, “unto that which is good” for “‘concerning’’ (Rom 16 19), “con- cerning” instead of “because of” (Jer 23 9), for ‘‘the miracle of” (Mk 6 52), for “with” (10 41), for “of the Lord” (Acts 18 25), “concerning Jesus’ (dif- erent text), “by way of disparagement” (2 Cor 11 21), instead of “concerning reproach”; “‘Why askest thou me concerning that which is good?” (Mt 19 17) instead of ‘‘Why callest thou me good?” (dif- ferent text; see RVm). W. L. Waker CONCISION, kon-sizh’un (xatatopy, katatomé, “mutilation,” “cutting”): A term by which St. Paul contemptuously designates the merely fleshly circumcision upon which the Judaizers insisted as being necessary for gentile converts (Phil 3 2), as distinguished from peritomé, the true circumcision (ver 3). Cf Gal 6 12 and Dt 28 1, and see Cir- CUMCISION. CONCLUDE, kon-klood’ (cupP.Patw, swmbibdzo): Used only in Acts 16 10, where AV has ‘‘assuredly gathering,” i.e. “inferring.” Where AV has “con- clude,” RV more accurately renders ‘‘reckon”’ (Rom 3 28); “giving judgment” (Acts 21 25); “shut up” (Rom 11 32; Gal 3 22). CONCLUSION, kon-kléo’zhun (FAD, soph): In Eccl 12 13 AV, where RV has “the end,” viz. a summary of the entire argument of the book. CONCORDANCE, kon-kér’dans: 1. Nature of Work 2. Classes of Concordances 3. Their Indispensableness 4, Concordances to Latin Vulgate 5. Concordances to the Heb OT 6. Concordances to the LXX 7. Concordances to the Greek NT 8. Concordances to the English Bible LItBRATURE The object of a concordance of Scripture is to guide the reader to any passage he is in search of by means of an alphabetical arrange- ment of the words found in Scripture, and the bringing together under each word of all the passages in which that word occurs. Thus, in the ver: “Cast thy burden upon Jeh” (Ps 55 22), the reader will look in the concordance under the words “cast” or “burden,” and there will find a reference to the text. The merit of a concordance is obviously exhaustiveness and clearness of arrangement. There are abridged concordances of the Bible which give only the most important words and passages. These are seldom satisfactory, and a fuller work has in the end fre- quently to be resorted to. The ordinary reader is naturally most familiar with concordances of the Eng. Bible, but it will be seen that, for scholarly purposes, 1. Nature of Work 2. Classes concordances are just as necessary of Con- for the Scriptures in their original cordances tongues, and for versions of the Scriptures other than Eng. There are required concordances of the OT in Heb, of the NT in Gr, of the LXX version (Gr) of the OT, of the Vulg version (Lat) of the NT, as well as of the tr® of the Scriptures into German, French and other living languages. There are now, further, required concordances of the RVV of the English OT and NT, as well as of the AV. There are needed, besides, good concordances to the Apoc, alike in its AV and RV forms. Textual criticism leads to modifications of the earlier concordances of the Heb and Gr texts. It is customary in con- cordances of the Eng. version to facilitate reference by giving not only single words, but also phrases 697 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Conaniah Concourse under which several passages are grouped, and to make the work more useful by furnishing lists of Scripture proper names, with their meanings, and, in the larger works, references to the Heb or Gr words for which the Eng. words stand. The indispensableness of a good concordance for the proper study of the Bible is so apparent that it is not surprising that, since 3. Their the idea was first conceived, much Indispensa- labor has been expended on the prep- bleness aration of such works. The wonder: rather is that the idea did not occur earlier than it did. No single scholar could ever hope to produce a perfect work of the kind by his own efforts. Modern concordances are based upon the labors of previous generations. The oldest concordances date from the 13th cent., and are based, as was then natural, upon the Latin Vulgate. A Concordantiae Mo- 4. Concord- rales is attributed to Antony of Padua ances to (d. 1231). The first concordance of Latin which we have actual knowledge is Vulgate that of Hugo of St. Caro, Dominican monk and cardinal (d. 1263). It was called Concordantiae S. Jacobi from the monastery in which it was compiled. 500 monks are said to have been engaged upon its preparation. Hugo’s Concordance became the basis of others into which successive improvements were introduced. The words of passages, at first wanting, were inserted; indeclinable particles were added; alphabetic arrangement was employed. Verse divisions were unknown till the time of Robert Stephens (1555). See Brsie. The earliest Heb concordance seems to have been that of Rabbi Mordecai ben Nathan (1438~- 48). It went through several editions 5. Concord- and was tr’ into Lat by Reuchlin ances to the (1556). Both original and tr con- Hebrew OT tained many errors. It was improved by Calasio, a Franciscan friar (1621), and more thoroughly by John Buxtorf, whose Concordance was published by his son (1632). This latter formed the basis of Dr. Julius First’s Libr. Sacrorum Vet. Test. Concordantive Heb atque Chald; 1840 (Eng. tr, Hebrew and Chaldean Con- cordance). A later Heb Concordance in Germany is that of Solomon Mandelkern (1896). In England, in 1754, appeared the valuable Heb Concordance, Adapted to the Eng. Bible, by Dr. Taylor, of Nor- wich. With it may be classed The Englishman’s Heb and Chald Concordance (18438; rev. ed, 1876). Though earlier attempts are heard of, the first printed concordance of the LXX (the Gr OT) was that of Trommius, published in 6. Concord- Amsterdam in 1718, in the author’s ances to 84th year. This important work the LXX remained the standard till quite lately. It is very complete, giving references not only to the LXX, but to other VSS (Aquila, Symmachus, Theodotion) in which the words occur, and showing by an index at the end the Heb or Chald words to which the Gr words correspond. In 1887 Bagster published A Handy Concordance of the Sept. Farlier works are superseded by the recent publication (1892, 1897, 1900) of Hatch and Redpath’s scholarly Concordance to the Sept, and Other Gr VSS of the OT. f, Concordances of the Gr NT began with that of Xystus Betulius (his real name was Birck) in 1554. The Concordance (Tameion) of Eras- 7. Concord- mus Schmid (1638) has often been ances to the reprinted and reédited. On it is Greek NT based the useful abridged Concord- ance published by Bagster. Recent works ate Bruder’s (1842; 4th ed, 1888; based on Schmid, with many improvements); in America, Hudson’s Critical Gr and Eng. Concordance, re- vised by Ezra Abbot (1870); in England, Moulton aud Geden’s Concordance to the Gr Test. according to the Texts of Westcott and Hort, Tischendorf, and the Eng. Revisers (1897). The list of concordances to the Eng. Bible is a long one; it is necessary here to particularize only a few of the chief.. The oldest is a 8. Concord- Concordance of the NT, brought out ances to the before 1540 by one Thomas Gybson, English though, as appears from the Preface, Bible it was principally the work of the printer John Day (the producer of Foxe’s Book of Martyrs). The first Concordance to the whole Bible was that of John Marbeck (1550). In the same year was published a tr by Walter Lynne of the Index Librorum of Bullinger, Conrad Pelican and others, under the title of A Briefe and a Compendious Table, in maner of a Concordance, openying the waye to the principall Histories of the whole Bible, etc. Alex. Cruden, whose own Concordance, the most adequate of all, was published in 1737, enumerates most of his predecessors in the intervening period. Cruden’s personal history is a pathetic one. A recurring mental malady overshadowed his caréer; but his indomitable perseverance and fixity of purpose, joined with a clear idea of what he wished to accom- plish, enabled him to overcome all obstacles, and produce a book for which the Christian world is grateful. The work is entitled A Complete Con- cordance to the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, etc; to which ts added, a Concordance to the Books called Apocrypha. Mr. Spurgeon said regarding it, ‘‘Be sure you buy a genuine unabridged Cruden, and none of the modern substitutes, good as they may be at the price... .. You need only one; have none but the best.” Many editions of this valuable book have been published. It no longer remains, however, the only authority, nor even the most complete and serviceable, though perhaps still the most convenient, for the purpose of the student. In 1873 was published the Analyti- cal Concordance to the Bibleby Robert Young, LL.D., to which an appendix has since been added. This bulky work contains “every word in alpha- betical order, arranged under its Heb or Gr original; with the literal meaning of each and its pronun- ciation.” It marks 30,000 various readings, and gives geographical and antiquarian notes. Yet more comprehensive is The Exhaustive Concord- ance of the Bible by James Strong, LL.D. This includes the new feature of a comparative concord- ance of the Authorized and Revised (English) VSS. It embraces also condensed Dictionaries of the Heb and Gr words, to which references are made from the Eng. words by figures. It thus differs in plan from Young’s, which gives the Heb and Gr words in the body of the concordance at the head of the passages coming under them. Lastly must be noticed the very valuable work published in the same year (1894) in America by J. B. R. Walker, Comprehensive Concordance, with an Introduction by Marshall Curtiss Hazard. It is stated to give 50,000 more passages than Cruden. LiteraturEe.—See arts. on ‘‘Concordance" in the various Dicts and Encys; arts. by Dr. Beard in Kitio's Enc (Vol I); and by Dr. OC. R. Gregory in the New Sch-Herz Ene (Vol IEE); Pref to Cruden’s complete Concordance, and Introduction by Hazard to Walker’s Compreh. Concordance. James ORR CONCOURSE, kon’kérs (MAM, hdmah, “to hum,” “to make a noise’; svarpoph, sustrophé, “a turning” or “twisting together’): Hdmdh, usually tr4 by some word signifying “sound’’ is rendered “eoncourse”’ in Prov 1 21 (perhaps from the noise made by people thronging and talking together; Concubinage Confession THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 698 ef 1 K 1 41, “uproar’), “She [wisdom] crieth in the chief place of concourse,” RVm ‘“‘Heb at the head of the noisy [streets]; sustrophé is tr4 ‘‘con- coe (Acts 19 40), a riotous crowd. Cf Jth 10 CONCUBINAGE, kon-kt’bi-naj. See Fammy. CONCUPISCENCE, kon-ki’pi-sens (ém@vpla, epithumia): Not used in RV, but in AV, Rom 78; Col 3 5; 1 Thess 4 5. The Gr noun, like the vb. from which it comes, meaning “‘to yearn,” “to long,” “to have the heart set upon a thing,”’ is determined in its moral quality by the source whence it springs or the object toward which it is directed. ‘Thus Our Lord uses it to express the intensest desire of His soul (Lk 22 15). Asa rule, when the object is not expressed, it refers to longing for that which God has forbidden, viz. lust. It is not limited to sexual desire, but includes all going forth of heart and will toward what God would not have us to have or be, as its use in the LXX of the Ten Commandments clearly shows, for ‘““Thou shalt not covet” (Ex 20 17). H. E. Jacozss CONDEMN, kon-dem’, kon-dem-n4’shun: : (1) The causative stem of JW, rdsha'‘, “to de- clare [or make] Ween “to eondemn,” whether in CONDEMNATION, civil, ethical or religious relations. 1. Inthe Taken in this sense the word needs no OT comment (Ex 22 9; Dt 25 1; Job 40 8); “Who then can condemn?” (Job 34 29, AV “make trouble”). (2) WIP, ‘dnash, “to fine.” ‘Condemned the land” (2 Ch 863 AV; AVm “mulcted’; RV “amereed”; ARV “‘fined’”); ‘wine of the con- demned”’ (Am 2 8; RV “fined” [unjustly]). (3) The active part. of DEW , shdphat, ‘to judge.” “From those that condemn his soul” (Ps 109 31 AV; RV “that judge his soul’). The NT usage is much more complicated, both because of the greater number of Gr words rendered “eondemn” and ‘‘condemnation,” and 2. Inthe because AV tr*the same word in several NT ; different ways, apparently with no rule whatever. (1) The most important word is xpivw, kriné, “to judge.” From it are a number of derivative vbs. and nouns. RV has rigidly excluded the harsh words “damn” and ‘damnation,’ substi- tuting “judge,” “condemn,” “judgment,” ‘“con- demnation.” This is proper, since the word damn (Lat damnare, ‘to inflict loss’ upon a person, “‘to condemn’’), and its derivatives has, in process of time, suffered degradation, so that in modern Eng. it usually refers to eternal punishment. This special application of the word for some cents. ran side by side with the original meaning, but even as late as Wycliffe’s version the word “damn” is usually employed in the sense of condemn, as in Job 9 20, “My mouth shall dampne me.” It is even applied to the condemnation of Jesus by the chief priests and scribes (Mk 10 33). This degeneration of the word is perhaps due, as Bishop Sanderson says, “not so much to good acts as to bad manners.”’ Kriné is rendered uniformly “judge” by RV, even where the context compels the thought of con- demnation (Jn 3 17.18; 12 47; Acts 7 7; “might be damned,” 2 Thess 2 12 AV; Rom 14 22; Jas 6 9). (2) The more specific sense of condemn, however, is found in xaraxptyw, katakrind, “to judge one down” (Mt 12 41.42; Mk 14 64): “is damned if he eat’? (Rom 14 28; 1 Cor 1132 AV; RV “eondemned”). See also Mk 16 16; 2 Pet 2 6. (3) For “condemnation” there is the noun «plza, krima, or xpiva, krima (for accent see Thayer’s Lexicon), in a forensic sense, “the sentence of the judge” (Lk 23 40; Mt 23 14, omittedin RV; “eon- demnation of the devil’ 1 Tim 3 6; 5 12; Jude ver 4). (4) Much stronger is xardxpywa, katdkerima, “con- demnation” (Rom 6 16.18; 8 1) with reference to the Divine judgment against sin. . ’ (5) xplows, krisis, “the process of judgment,’ “tribunal” (Jn 3 19; 5 24), with reference to ‘“‘the judgment brought by men upon themselves because of their rejection of Christ.’’ (6) A stronger word is the adj. avroxardxpiros, autokatékritos, “self-condemned” (Tit 3 11; cf'1 Jn 3 20.21). G. H. TREvVER CONDESCENSION, kon-dé-sen’shun, CHRIST. See Kenosis. CONDUCT, kon’dukt. CONDUIT, kon’dit. CONEY, ko’ni (JPW, shaphdn [Lev 115; Dt 14 7; Ps 104 18; Prov 30 26]): The word “coney” (formerly pronounced cooney) means ‘rabbit?’ (from Lat cuntculus). Sha@phdn is rendered in all four passages in the LXX xopoyptAdos, choiro- grillios, or “hedge-hog,’”’ but is now universally considered to refer to the Syrian hyrax, Procavia (or Hyrax) Syriaca, which in southern Pal and Sinai is called in Arab. wabar, in northern Pal and Syria tabstin, and in southern Arabia shufun, which is etymologically closely akin to shéphan. The word “hyrax’’ (tpat, hoirax) itself means ‘mouse’ or “shrew-mouse” (cf Lat sorex), so that it seems to OF See Erarcs. See CIsTERN. * a & - @ - JP.» Group of Conies. have been hard to find a name peculiar to this ani- mal. In Lev 11 5 RVm, we find “rock badger,” which is a tr of klip das, the rather inappropriate name given by the Boers to the Cape hyrax. The Syrian hyrax lives in Syria, Pal and Arabia. A number of other species, including several that are arboreal, live in Africa. They are not found in other parts of the world. In size, teeth and habits the Syrian hyrax somewhat resembles the rabbit though it is different in color, being reddish brown, and lacks the long hind legs of the rabbit. The similarity in dentition is confined to the large size of the front teeth and the presence of a large space between them and the back teeth. But whereas hares have a pair of front teeth on each jaw, the hyrax has one pair above and two below. These 699 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Concubinage Confession teeth differ also in structure from those of the hare and rabbit, not having the persistent pulp which enables the rabbit’s front teeth to grow continually as they are worn away. They do not hide among herbage like hares, nor burrow like rabbits, but live in holes or clefts of the rock, frequently in the faces of steep cliffs. Neither the hyrax nor the hare is a ruminant, as seems to be implied in Lev 11 5 and Dt 14 7, but their manner of chewing their food may readily have led them to be thought to chew the cud. The hyrax has four toes in front and three behind (the same number as in the tapir and in some fossil members of the horse family), all furnished with nails that are almost like hoofs, except the inner hind toes, which have claws. The hyraxes constitute a family of ungulates and, in spite of their small size, have points of resemblance *to elephants or rhinoceroses, but are not closely allied to these or to any other known animals. The camel, the coney and the hare are in the list of unclean animals because they ‘chew the cud but divide not the hoof,” but all three of these are eaten by the Arabs. ; The illustration is from a photograph of a group of conies in the Syrian Protestant College at Beirft, prepared by Mr. Douglas Carruthers, who collected these specimens in a cliff in the neighborhood of Tyre. Specimens from the Dead Sea are redder than those from Syria. ALFRED Exy Day CONFECTION, kon-fek’shun, CONFECTION- ARY, kon-fek’shun-a4-ri (MP7, rékah, “perfume,” “spice,” Tp), rakkahah, fem. “perfumer’): (1) ‘Confection’ is found in AV only, and but once ‘‘a c. after the art of the apothecary” (Ex 30 35; RV “perfume’’); but the RV renders 1 Ch 9 30, ‘‘the c. [AV ‘“ointment’’] of the spices.” It stands for something “made up,” a mixture of perfumes or medicines, but never sweetmeats, as c. means with us. (2) Likewise a “confectionary” is a perfumer. This word, too, is found but once (1S 8 13), “He will take your daughters to be perfumers [AV “confectionaries”], and to be cooks, and to be bakers.’’ See PERFUMES. Gro. B. Eacer CONFEDERATE, kon-fed’ér-it, CONFEDER- ACY, kon-fed’ér-a-si: ‘Confederate’ as an adj. in the sense of united or leagued is twice the tr of m3, berith, “covenant,” in several instances tr4 “league” (Gen 14 13, ba‘al berith, “lord or master of a covenant,” “‘an ally,’’ “these were c. with Abram”; cf Ps 83 5; once of M3, nih, ‘‘to rest,” ‘Syria is c. with Ephraim” (Isa 7 2, RVm ‘Testeth on Ephraim”; also 1 Macc 10 47). As a noun “‘confederate” occurs in 1 Mace 10 16, stimmachos, “confederates” (1 Mace 8 20.24.31; 14 40; 15 17). Confederacy, as a “league,” occurs as the tr of berith, “the men of thy c.”” (Ob ver 7); as a con- spiracy it occurs in Isa 8 12 bis, as tr of kesher from kadshar, “to bind’’: ‘‘Say yenot,ac.” Cf2 5 16 12; 2 K 12 20, ete. W. L. WaLKER CONFER, kon-fir’, CONFERENCE, kon’fér- eps: The equivalent of three Gr words of different shades of meaning. In Gal 1 16, mpocavarlonuu, prosanatithémi, had been used in classical writers for resorting to oracles (Lightfoot on Gal 2 6; Ellicott on Gal 1 16); hence, “to take counsel with,” “to consult.” In Acts 4 15, cvpBddd\qw, sumbdllé, “to compare views,” “‘discuss”; and in Acts 26 12, cva- raréw, sullaléd, “to talk together.’ Cf the single passage in the OT (1 K 1 7). _CONFESSION, kon-fesh’un (M7, yddhah; Gpodroyéw,. homologéd, and their derivatives): The radical meaning is ‘‘acknowledgment,” “‘avowal,”’ ” with the implication of a change of conviction or of course of conduct on the pari of the subject. In Eng. “profession” (AV 1 Tim 6 12; He 31; 4 14), besides absence of the thought just suggested, emphasizes the publicity of the act. C., like its Gr equivalent, connotes, as its etymology shows (Lat con, Gr homo), that the act places one in harmony with others. It is the uniting in a statement that has previously been made by someone else. Of the two Gr words from the same root in the NT, the compound with the Gr preposition ek found, among other places, in Mt 3 6; Acts 19 18; Rom 14 11; Phil 2 11, implies that it has come from an inner ‘impulse, i.e. it is the expression of a conviction of the heart. It is referred anthropopathically to God in Job 40 14, where Jeh says to the patriarch sar- castically: ‘Then will I also confess of [unto] thee’’; and in Rev 8 5, where it means “‘to recognize”’ or “acknowledge.” When man is said to confess or make confession, the contents of the confession are variously dis- tinguished. All, however, may be grouped under two heads, confession of faith and confession of sin. Confessions of faith are public acknowledgments of fidelity to God, and to the truth through which God is revealed, as 1 K 8 33. They are declara- tions of unqualified confidence in Christ, and of surrender to His service; Mt 10 32: ‘Every one . . .. who shall confess me before men.” In Phil 2 11, however, c. includes, alongside of willing, also unwilling, acknowledgment of the sovereignty of Jesus. The word c. stands also for everything con- tained in the Christian religion—‘‘the faith” used in the objective and widest sense, in He 3 1; 4 14. In both these passages, the allusion is to the NT. The “High Priest of our c.” (He 3 1) is the High Priest, of whom we learn and with whom we deal in that new revelation, which in that epistle is con- trasted with the old. Confessions of sins are also of various classes: (1) To God alone. Wherever there is true repent- ance for sin, the penitent freely confesses his guilt to Him, against whom he has sinned. This is described in Ps 32 3-6; cf 1 Jn 19; Prov 28 13. Such ¢. may be made either silently, or, as in Dnl 9 19, orally; it may be general, as in Ps 61, or particular, as when some special sin is recog- nized; it may even extend to what has not been discovered, but which is believed to exist because of recognized inner depravity (Ps 19 12), and thus include the state as well as the acts of sin (Rom 7 18). (2) To one’s neighbor, when be has been wronged (Lk 17 4): “If he sin against thee seven times in the day, and seven times turn again to thee, saying, I repent; thou shalt forgive him.” It_is to this form of c. that James refers (5 16): “Confess . . . . your sins one to another’; cf Mt 6 23f. (3) Toa spiritual adviser or minister of the word, such as the c. of David to Nathan (2 S 12 13), of the multitudes to John in the wilderness (Mt 3 6), of the Ephesians to Paul (Acts 19 18). This c. is a general acknowledgment of sinfulness, and enters into an enumeration of details only when the conscience is particularly burdened. (4) To the entire church, where some crime has created public scandal. As “secret sins are to be rebuked secretly, and public sins publicly,” in the apostolic age, where there was genuine penitence for a notorious offence, the acknowledgment was as public as the deed itself. An illustration of this is found in the well-known case at Corinth (cf 1 Cor 5 3 ff with 2 Cor 2 6f). For auricular c. in the sense of the mediaeval and Rom church, there is no authority in Holy Scripture. It is traceable to the practice of exam- ining those who were about to make a public c. of some notorious offence, and of giving advice con- cerning how far the circumstances of the sin were Confidence Conscience THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 700 to be announced; an expedient that was found ad- visable, since as much injury could be wrought by injudicious publishing of details in the c. as by the sin itself. The practice once introduced for par- ticular cases was in time extended to all cases; and the private c. of sin was demanded by the church as a condition of the absolution, and made an element of penitence, which was analyzed into contrition, confession and satisfaction. See the Examen Concilii Tridentinit (Ist ed, 1565) of Dr. Martin Chemnitz, superintendent of Brunswick, for a thorough exegetical and historical discussion of this entire subject. On the historical side, see also Henry Charles Lea, History of Auricular Con-" fession and Indulgences in the Latin Church (3 vols, Philadelphia, 1896). H. E. Jacoss CONFIDENCE, kon’fi-dens (TD3, bafah, and forms, 202, kegel; wappnola, parrhésia, weldw, pet- thé, wewolOnors, pepotthésis, tréotacis, hupdstasis): The chief Heb word tr4 “confidence” (bdfah, and its forms) means, perhaps, radically, ‘to be open,” showing thus what originated the idea of ‘‘confi- dence’; where there was nothing hidden a person felt safe; it is very frequently rendered ‘‘trust.”” In Ps 118 8.9 we have “It is better to take refuge in Jeh than to put confidence in princes,” and in 65 5, “QO God of our salvation, thou that art the confidence [mibhtah] of all the ends of the earth.” Muibhtah is tr? “confidence” in Job 18 14; 31 24; Prov 21 22, etc. Kesel (‘“firmness,” “stoutness”) is rendered ‘‘con- fidence” in Prov 3 26, and kislah in Job 4 6; peitho (“to persuade”) is tr? “confidence” in 2 Cor 2 3; Gal 5 10, etc; pepoithésis, in 2 Cor 1 15; 8 22, etc; hupostasis (“what stands under’’), in 2 Cor 11 17; He 3 14; 2 Cor 9 4; parrhésia (“‘out-spokenness,’ “boldness”) is invariably tr? in RV “boldness” (Acts 28 31; He 3 6; 416; 10 35; 1 Jn 2 28, 3 21; 6 14); tharsed or tharrhéo (“to have good courage’’) jis so tr’ in RV, “being therefore always of good courage” (2 Cor 5 6); “I am of good courage con- cerning you” (2 Cor 7 16), AV “confident” and “confidence.” RV has “confidence” for “hope” (Job 8 14); for “assurance” (Isa 32 17); for “trust” (2 Cor 3 4); for “same confident boasting” (2 Cor 9 4); “is con- fident” for “trusted”? (Job 40 23); ‘‘to have con- fidence” for “thinketh that he hath whereof he might trust” (Phil 3 4); “confidently” for “constantly” (Acts 12 15); “confidently affirm” for “affirm” (1 Tim 1 7); conversely, we bave for “his confi- dence” (Job 18 14), “‘wherein he trusteth,” for “with confidence” (Ezk 28 26) ‘securely therein.” The Bible teaches the value of confidence (Isa 30 15; He 10 35), but neither in “gold” (Job 81 24), nor in man, however great (Ps 118 8.9; Jer 17 5), nor in self (Prov 14 16; Phil 3 3), but in God (Ps 65 5; Prov 3 26; 14 26), as revealed in Christ (Eph 3 12; 1 Jn 6 13.14). W. L. WALKER CONFIRM, kon-firm, CONFIRMATION, kon- fér-ma’shun: In the OT represented by several Heb words, generally with reference to an increase of external strength, as “c. the feeble knees” (Isa 35 3); “c. the kingdom” (2 K 15 19); “c. in- heritance’” (Ps 68 9). In the NT, this external, objective sense is expressed by BeBaibw, bebaidd, as in Mk 16 20; Rom 15 8. The strengthening of mind, purpose, conviction, i.e. the inner or subjec- tive sense (Acts 14 22; 16 32.41) corresponds to émiornplte, epistérizd. Used also of ratifying or making valid (xvpdw, kurdo) a covenant (Gal 3 15). The noun is used in the second sense (He 6 16; Phil 1 7). Confirmation, the rite, in some denom- inations, of admission to the full communion of the church, which the Rom church has elevated to the place of a sacrament, has only ecclesiastical, but no Scriptural, authority. It is grounded, however, in the Scriptural precedent of the laying on of hands after baptism. See Hanps, ImposiTion OF. H. E. Jacozs CONFISCATION, kon-fis-ka’shun. See Pun- ISHMENTS. CONFLICT, kon’flikt (4y4v, agén, “contest,” “fight”): In Phil 1 30, “having the same c. which ye saw in me,” and Col 2 1 AV; 1 Thess 2 2 (AV “contention”); d@Ancs, dthlésis (lit. “combat in the public games”), in He 10 32 (AV “fight’’). See also Agony. CONFORM, kon-férm’, CONFORMABLE, kon- férm’a-b'l (cvppopdda, summorphds, “to become or be like,” or “of the same form”): Indicating an inner change of nature, working into the outward life (Rom 8 29; Phil 3 10.21); while cvexnuarl fw, suschématizé, “fashioned according to” (Rom 12 21 RV, AV “conformed”), refers to that which is external. CONFOUND, kon-found’: The physical origin of spiritual terms is well illustrated by the prin- cipal Heb words for “confounded” (rendered also “ashamed,” etc); WD, bdsh, is “to become pale” (2 K 19 26; Job 6 20; Ps 88 17; 1295 AV; Isa 19 9, etc); "PM, kaphér, “to become red”’ (Ps 36 4; Isa 1 29; 24 28, “the moon shall be confounded,” Mic 3 7); W232, ydbhash, “to be dried up” (Jer 46 24 AV; 48 120AV; 50 2 AV; Zec 10 5); D2D, kalam, “to blush” (Ps 69 6 AV; Isa 41 11, etc). In Gen 11 7.9, of the confusion of tongues, the word is boa, bdlal, “to mix,” “mingle.” In Jer 117 AV it is MNT, hathath, “to bring or put down.”’ In NT, kataischinéd, “to put to shame” (1 Cor 1 27 AV; 1 Pet 26 AV); and sugchind, “to pour together,” “bewilder’”’ (Acts 2 6; 9 22). RV fre- quently gives “ashamed” and ‘“‘put to shame’’ instead of “confounded.” W. L. WaLKER CONFUSION, kon-fi’zhun (MNW5, basheth, “shame, paleness,” M2, k‘limmah, “blushing,” WIM, tohd; axatacracta, akatastasia, rbyxvors, stig- chusis): In the OT bésheth (1 S 20 30; Ps 109 29 AV) and k‘limmah (Ps 44 15; Isa 30 3) are the words most frequently tr4 “confusion”; téhu, ‘“‘wastiness,”’ “emptiness” is so tr? (Isa 24 10; 34 11; 41 29), also kalén, “lightness,” “contempt” (Job 10 15= ignominy, ARV) and tebhel, ‘‘profanation”’ (Lev 18 23; 20 12); ra‘ash, “shaking,” “trembling,” rendered “confused” in Isa 9 5 AV; cf RV. Gr akatastasia, “instability” is tr? “confusion” (1 Cor 14 33; Jas 3 16); sugehusis, “a pouring out together” (Acts 19 29). In Wisd 14 26, “changing of kind” (AV) is rendered ‘confusion of sex.” W. L. WaLKER CONFUSION OF TONGUES. See Basen, Towrr oF; ToNGuEs, CONFUSION OF. CONGREGATION, kon-gré-ga’shun (Sp, ka hal, V2, ‘édhah): These two words rendered by “congregation” or ‘“‘assembly” are used apparently without any difference of sense. They appear to include an as- sembly of the whole people or any section that might be present on a given occasion. Indeed, sometimes the idea appears to correspond closely to that conveyed by “horde,” or even by “crowd.” ‘Hdhah is once used of bees (Jgs 14 8). It has been sought to distinguish the two words by means of Lev 4 18, “if the whole ‘édhah of Israel 1. Terms Employed 701 err, and the thing be hid from the eyes of the kaha.” The kahal would then be the smaller body repre- senting the whole ‘édhah, but the general usage is not favorable to this view (compare e.g. Ex 12 19, “cutting off from the ‘édhdh of Israel,” with Nu 19 20, “cutting off from the kahal’). The idea denoted by these words is said by Wellhausen to be ‘foreign to Heb antiquity,” though it “runs through the PC from beginning to end” (Pro- legomena, 78). Yet it is Dt that presents us with laws excluding certain classes from the kahal, and the word is also found in Gen 49 6; Nu 22 4 (RV “multitude”’); Dt 6 22; 9 10; 31 30; Josh 8 35; 18 17 47; 1 K 8 14; Mic 2 5, and other early passages, while ‘édkaéh occurs in 1 K 12 20 (see further, Eerdmans, Das Buch Exodus, 80f). On the other hand taste and euphony appear to be responsible for the choice of one or other of the words in many cases. Thus the Chronicler uses kahal frequently, but ‘édhah only once (2 Ch 5 6= 1 K 8 5). Moses provided for the summoning of the con- gregation by trumpets (Nu 10 2-8). For the sin offering to be brought if the whole 2. Legal congregation erred, see Lev 4 13-21. Provisions Dt 23 1-8 (in Heb 2-9) excludes bastards, Ammonites and Moabites from the assembly, even to the tenth generation, while Edomites and Egyptians were admitted in the third. Those who suffer from certain physical defects are also excluded. : One other word must be noted, 37’, mé‘édh. It occurs often in the phrase ’dhel mo‘édh (‘tent of meeting’; see TapeRNacLE). But 3. Other in Nu 16 2 we find it used of certain Terms princes who were “men of renown called to the assembly.” For M122, ‘dcereth, rendered by RV “solemn assembly,” see Feasts. On Sp, mikra’, see ConvocaTIon, Harotp M. WIENER CONGREGATION, MOUNT OF (W7720™0, har-mo‘édh, Isa 14 13): The prophet has depicted the excitement, caused in Sheol by the descent of the once mighty king of Babylon into the world of shades, and now himself points the contrast between the monarch’s former haughty boastings and his present weak and hopeless condition: ‘Thou saidst in thy heart, I will ascend into heaven, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God; and I will sit upon the mount of congregation, in the utter- most parts of the north.” Instead he is brought down ‘‘to the uttermost parts of the pit?’ (ver 15). By the ‘mount of congregation” (meeting or as- sembly) is evidently meant the fancied Olympus of the gods on some lofty northern height. The king vaunted that he would make his abode with the gods in heaven; now he is cast down to the depths of Sheol. JAMES ORR CONIAH, ké-ni’a (39793, konyahi, “Jab is creating’): A form of the name Jehoiachin, found in Jer 22 24.28; 37 1. See JEHOIACHIN. CONONIAH, kon-é-ni’a. CONQUEROR, kon’kér-ér: Known only in the compound vb. (imepukdpev, hupernikémen, Rom 8 37): A usual meaning of the preposition in com- position is ‘‘above all measure’; hence ‘‘more than conquerors,’ RV, AV. The comparison is to the completeness of the victory. Others may place their enemies in subjection; those here mentioned master not only their foes, but themselves. Others destroy their foes and their resources; while those who are ‘‘more than conquerors” convert foes into See ConaNnrag. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Confidence Conscience means of still farther promoting the interests for which they struggle (Rom 3 3-5). Nor is the victory external and transient, but internal and permanent. H. E. Jacogs CONSCIENCE, kon’shens () cuvelBnois, hé su- netdésis) : I. Ssquenr Conscience 1. Judicial 2. Punitive 3. Predictive 4. Social II. AntTEcEDENT ConsclIENCE III. Inruitionant ano AssociaTionan THEORIES IV. Tus Enucation or Conscience History AND LITERATURE 1. Earlier Views 2. Reformation and After I. Sequent Conscience.—The aspect of conscience earliest noticed in lit. and most frequently referred to at all times is what is called the 1, Judicial Sequent Conscience—that is to say, it follows action. This is (1) judicial. No sooner is a decision formed than there ensues a judgment favorable or adverse, a sentence of guilty or not guilty. Con- science has often been compared to a court of law, in which there are culprit, judge, witnesses and jury; but these are all in the subject’s own breast, and are in fact himself. It is (2) punitive. In the individual’s own breast are not only the figures of justice already mentioned, but the executioner as 2. Punitive well; for, on the back of a sentence of condemnation or acquittal, there im- mediately follows the pain of a wounded or the satisfaction of "an approving conscience; and of all human miseries or blisses this is the most poignant. Esp. has the remorse of an evil conscience impressed the human imagination, in such instances as Cain and Judas, Saul and Herod; and the poets, those knowers of human nature, have found their most moving themes in the delineation of this aspect of human experience. The ancient poets represented the terrors of conscience under the guise of the Erinyes or Furies, who, with swift, silent, unswerv- ing footstep, tracked the criminal and pulled him down, while Shakespeare, in such dramas as Macbeth and Richard the Third, has burned the same lessons into the imagination of all readers of his works. The satisfaction of a good conscience may stamp itself on the habitual serenity of one face, and the accusations of an evil conscience may impart a rate and sinister expression to another (ci Wisd 7 a It is (8) predictive. There is no instinct in the soul of man more august than the anticipation of something after death—of a tribunal 3. Predict- at which the whole of life will be re- ive vised and retribution awarded with perfect justice according to the deeds done in the body. It is this which imparts to death its solemnity; we instinctively know that we are going to our account. And such great natural instincts cannot be false. It is (4) social. Not only does a man’s own con- science pass sentence on his conduct, but the con- sciences of others pass sentence on it 4. Social too; and to this may be due a great intensification of the consequent sen- sations, Thus, a crime may lie hidden in the memory, and the pain of its guilt may be assuaged by the action of time, when suddenly and unex- pectedly it is found out and exposed to the knowl- edge of all; and, only when the force of the public conscience breaks forth on the culprit, driving him from society, does he feel his guilt in all its mag- nitude. The “Day of Judgment” (q.v.), as it is represented in Scripture, is an application of this Conscience Consecrate THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 702 principle on a vast scale; for there the character and conduct of everyone will be submitted to the conscience of all. On the other hand, a friend may be to a man a second conscience, by which his own conscience is kept alive and alert; and this approval from without may, in some cases, be, even more than the judgment within, an encouragement to everything that is good or a protection against temptation. If, Antecedent Conscience.—From the Sequent is distinguished the Antecedent Conscience, which designates a function of this faculty preceding moral decision or action. When the will stands at the parting of the ways, seeing clearly before it the right course and the wrong, conscience commands to strike into the one and forbids to choose the other. This is its imperative; and—to employ the language of Kant—it is a categorical impera- tive. What conscience commands may be ap- parently against our interests, and it may be com- pletely contrary to our inclinations; it may be opposed to the advice of friends or to the solicita- tions of companions; it may contradict the decrees of principalities and powers or the voices of the mul- titude; yet conscience in no way withdraws or modifies its claim. We may fail to obey, giving way to passion or being overborne by the allure- ments of temptation; but we know that we ought to obey; it is our duty; and this is a sublime and sacred word. The great, crises of life arise when conscience is issuing one command and self-inter- est or passion or authority another, and the ques- tion has to be decided which of the two is to be obeyed. The interpreters of human life have known how to make use of such moments, and many of the most memorable scenes in literature are of this nature; but the actual history of man- kind has also been dignified with numerous in- stances in which confessors and martyrs, standing on the same ground, have faced death rather than contravene the dictates of the authority within; and there never passes an hour in which the eye of the All-seeing does not behold someone on earth putting aside the bribes of self-interest or the menaces of authority and paying tribute to con- science by doing the right and taking the conse- quences. HI. Intuitional and Associational Theories.—Up to this point there is little difficulty or difference of opinion; but now we come to a point at which very differing views emerge. It was remarked above, that when anyone stands at the parting of the ways, seeing clearly the right course and the wrong, conscience imperatively commands him which to choose and which to avoid; but how does anyone know which of the two alternatives is the right and which the wrong? Does conscience still suffice here, or is he dependent on another faculty? Here the Intuitional and the Associational, or— speaking broadly—the Scotch and the English, the erman and the French schools of ethics diverge, those on the one side holding that conscience has still essential guidance to give, while those on the other maintain that the guidance must now be undertaken by other faculties. The Sensational or Experimental school holds that we are dependent on the authority of society or on our own estimate of the consequences of actions, while the opposite school teaches that in the conscience there is a clear revelation of certain moral laws, approving certain principles of action and disapproving others. The strong point of the former view is the diver- sity which has existed among human beings in different ages and in different latitudes as to what is right and what is wrong. What was virtuous in Athens might be sinful in Jerus; what is admired as heroism in Japan may be despised as fool- _ that inflicts the hardiness in Britain. To this it may be replied, first, that the diversity has been greatly exaggerat- ed; the unanimity of the human conscience under all skies being greater than is allowed by philoso- phers of this school. ‘Let any plain, honest man, says Butler, “before he engages in any course of action, ask himself, Is this I am going about right, or. is it wrong? Is it good, or is it evil? and I do not in the least doubt but that this question will be answered agreeably to truth and virtue by almost any fair man in almost any circumstances.” Then, there are many moral judgments supposed to be immediate verdicts of conscience which are really logical inferences from the utterances of this faculty and are lable to all the fallacies by which reason~ ing in any department of human affairs is beset. It is only for the major premise, not for the conclu- sion, that’ conscience is responsible. The strong point of the Intuitional school, on the other hand, is the power and right of the individual to break away from the habits of society, and, in defiance of the commands of authority or the voices of the multitude, to follow a course of his own. When he does 80, is it a logical conclusion as to the conse- quences of action he is obeying, or a higher intui- tion? When, for example, Christianity announced the sinfulness of fornication in opposition to the laxity of Greece and Rome, was it an argument about. consequences with which she operated suc- cessfully, or an instinct of purity which she divined at the back of the actions and opinions of heathen- dom? The lettering of the moral law may have to be picked out and cleansed from the accumulations of time, but the inscription is there all the same. IV. The Education of Conscience.—It may be, however, that a more exact analysis of the ante- cedent conscience is requisite. Between the cate- gorical imperative, which commands to choose the nght path and avoid the wrong, and the indicative, which declares that this is the right way and that the wrong, there ought perhaps to be assumed a certainty that one of the alternative ways is right and must be pursued at all hazards, while the other is wrong and must be abandoned at whatever cost. This perception, that moral distinctions exist, sepa- rate from each other as heaven and hell, is the pecul- jarity of conscience; but it does not exclude the necessity for taking time to ascertain, in every instance, which of the alternatives has the one character and which the other, or for employing a great variety of knowledge to make thissure. Those who would limit conscience to the faculty which utters the major premises of moral reasoning are wont to hold that it can never err and does not admit of being educated; but such a use of the term is too remote from common usage, and there must be room left for the conscience to enlighten itself by making acquaintance with such objective stand- ards as the character of God, the example of Christ, and the teaching of Scripture, as well as with the maxims of the wise and the experience of the good. Another question of great intcrest about the con- science is, whether it involves an intuition of God. When it 1s suffering the pain of remorse, who is it unishment? Is it only the con- science itself? Or is man, in such experiences, aware of the existence of a Being outside of and above himself? When the will is about to act, it receives the command to choose the right and refuse the wrong; but who issues this command? Is it only itself, or does the imperative come with a sanction and solemnity betokening a higher origin? Conscience is an intuition of moral law—the read- ing, so to speak, of a luminous writing, which hangs out there, on the bosom of Nature—but who penned that writing? It used to be thought that the word Conscience implied, in its very structure, a reference 703 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Conscience Consecrate to God, meaning lit. “knowledge along with an- other,” the other being God. Though this derivation be uncertain, many think that it exactly expresses the truth. ‘There are few people with an ethical experience of any depth who have not sometimes been overwhelmingly conscious of the approval or disapproval of an unseen Being; and, if there be any trustworthy argument for the existence of a Deity, prior to supernatural revelation, this is where it is to be found. V. History and Literature.—Only a few indica- tions of history can be given here. ‘The conscience, at least the sequent conscience, was identified in the ancient world, and the rise of a doctrine on the subject belongs : to the period when the human mind being shut out from public activity through political changes, was thrown back upon itself and began to watch closely its own symptoms. The word has a specially prominent place in the philosophical writ- ings of Cicero. Strange to say, it does not occur in the OT; but, though not the name, the thing ap- pears there frequently enough. On the very first page of revelation, the voice of God is heard calling among the trees of the garden (Gen 3 8); and, in the very next incident, the blood of Abel cries out to heaven from the ground (Gen 4 10). Inthe NT the word occurs with tolerable frequency, esp. in the speeches (Acts 24 16, etc) and writings of St. Paul (Rom 2 15; 9 1; 13 5; 1 Cor 6 7-12, etc); and this might have been expected to secure for it a prominent place in the doctrine of the church. But this did not immediately take effect, although Chrysostom already speaks of Conscience and Nature as two books in which the human mind can read of God, previous to supernatural revelation. In the Middle Ages the conscience received from two sources so much stimulation that both thing and name were certain to come into greater promi- nence in the speculations of the schools. The one of these influences was the rise of Monasticism, which, driving human beings into solitude, made the movements of their own: minds the objects of everlasting study to themselves; and the other was the practice of auricular confession, which became, especially to many of the inmates of the houses of religion, the most interesting business of life; because, in order to meet the confessor, they scanned every thought and weighed every scruple, becoming adepts at introspection and _ self-disci- line. Thus it came to pass that ethics took the ‘orm of Cases of Conscience, the priest having to train himself, or to be trained by professors and through books, to be able to answer every query submitted to him in the confessional. The ripest fruit of this method appears in the Summa of Aquinas, who discusses elaborately the doctrine of conscience, dividing it into two parts—synderesis (from curripyors, suntérésis) and conscientia—the one of which supplies the major premises and cannot err, while the other draws the inferences there- from and is liable to make mistakes. The Mystics identified the syndercsis as the point in the spirit of man at which it can be brought into contact and connection with the Spirit of God. At the Reformation the conscience was much in the mouths of men, both because the terrors of conscience formed a preparation for 1. Earlier Views 2. The comprehending justification by faith Reforma- and because, in appearing before tion and principalities and powers in vindica- After tion of their action, the Reformers took their stand on conscience, as Luther did so memorably at the Diet of Worms; and the assertion of the rights of conscience has ever since been a conspicuous testimony of Prot- estantism; whereas Romanists, especially as rep- resented by the Jesuits, have treatcd the conscience as a feeble and ignorant thing, requiring to be led by authority—that is, by themselves. The forms of mediaevalism long clung even to Protestant lit. on this subject. It may not be surprising to find a High Churchman like Jeremy Taylor, in his Ductor Dubitantium, discussing ethics as a system of cases of conscience, but it is curious to find a Puritan like Baxter (in his Christian Directory), and a Scottish Presbyterian like David Dickson (in his Therapeutica Sacra) doing the same. Deism in England and the Enlightenment in Germany mag- nified the conscience, to which they ascribed such a power of revealing God as made any further revelation unnecessary; but the practical effect was a secularization and vulgarization of the general mind; and it was against these rather than the system which had produced them that Butler in England and Kant in Germany had to raise the standard of a spiritual view of life. The former said of the conscience that, if it had power as it had right, it would absolutely govern the world; and Kant’s sublime saying is well known, at the close of his great work on Ethics: ‘Two things fill the soul with ever new and growing wonder and reverence, the oftener: and the longer reflection continues to occupy itself with them—the starry heavens above and the moral law within.” The rise of an Associational and Developmental Phi- losophy in England, represented by such powerful thinkers as the Mills, father and son, Professor Bain and Herbert Spencer, tended to dissipate the halo surrounding the conscience, by representing it as merely an emotional equivalent for the author- ity of law and the claims of custom, so stamped on the mind by the experience of generations that, its earthly source forgotten, it came to be attributed to supernatural powers. But this school was an- tagonized with success by such thinkers agy Mar- tineau and T. H. Green. R. Rothe regarded conscience as a term too popular and of too vari- able signification to be of much use in philosophical speculation; but most of the great succession of writers on Christian ethics who followed him have treated it seriously; Dorner esp. recognizing its importance, and Newman Smyth bestowing on it a thoroughly modern treatment. Among German works on the subject that of Gass, which contains an appendix on the history of the term synderesis, is deserving of special attention; that by Kahler is unfinished, as is also the work in Eng. by Robert- son; The Christian Conscience by Davison is slight and popular. Weighty discussions will be found in two books on Moral Philosophy—the Handbook of Calderwood, and the Ethics of Mezes. But there is abundance of room for a great monograph on the subject, which would treat conscience in a comprehensive manner as the subjective standard of conduct, formed by progressive familiarity with the objective standards as well as by practice in accordance with its own authority and with the will of God. JAMES STALKER CONSECRATE, kon’sé-krat, CONSECRATION, kon-sé-kra’shun: In the OT for several Heb words of different meanings: (1) DIM, haram: “I will consecrate [RV “de- vote’’] their gain unto the Lord,” i.e. the spoil of the nations shall be dedicated to the service of Jeh (Mic 4 13). See Ban; Curss. (2) “WW2, nazar, Wi, nézer (Nu 6 7. 9.12; RV “separate’). See Nazirive. (3) Wp, kadhésh: “to be set apart,” or “to be holy”: of Aaron and his sons (Ex 28 3; 30 30; RV “ganctify”). The silver and gold and brass and iron of the banned city of Jericho are ‘‘consecrated”’ Consent Contribution THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 704 things (RV “holy’’) unto the Lord (Josh 6 19); of the priests (2 Ch 26 18); of sacrifices (2 Ch 29 33; 31 6; Ezr 3 5). See Houiness. (4) TINA, mille yadh, lit. “to fill the hand”; and subst. pl. md, millwim, a peculiar idiom used frequently and generally for the installation of a priest into his office; and subst. for the installation offerings which were probably put into the priest’s hands to symbolize his admission into office; hence the phrase, ‘‘and thou shalt consecrate Aaron and his sons’ (Ex 29 9; so 28 41; 29 29.33.35; 32 29; Lev 8 33; 16 32; 21 10; Nu 3 3; Jgs 17 5.12; 2 Ch 29 31); of Jeroboam’s non-Levitical priest- hood (1 K 13 33; 2 Ch 13 9); of the altar (Ezk 43 26) and of those who contributed to build the temple (1 Ch 29 5). Subst. of an act of installa- tion (Lev 7 37; 8 33), and of installation offerings (Ex 29 22.26.27.31; Lev 8 22.28.29.31). In the NT redecda, teleidd, ‘to make perfect”? (He 7 28: RV “perfected’’); eyxavlfw, egkainizo, “to make new’’ (He 10 20; RV “‘dedicated’’). T. Ress CONSENT, kon-sent’: The vb. implies com- pliance with the guidance and direction of another, and, therefore, a secondary and subordinate rela- tion of approval, sympathy and concurrence on the part of the one who consents. He does not take the initiative, but yields to what the principal proposes. The phrase é« cvupdvov, ek sumphénou, “by consent,” means “by mutual agreement” (1 Cor 7 5), both parties concerned being placed on an equality. “With one consent” (Zeph 3 9, Heb ‘“vith one shoulder’; Lk 14 18) suggests, although it does not necessarily imply, the result of delibera- tion and consultation; it may have no other force than that of unanimity. H. E. Jacoss 2. In the NT CONSIDER, kon-sid’ér: In the NT the force of the word is brought out most vividly in Mt 6 26 (katapav0ave, kaiamanthénd), where it means to “examine closely,’ as though the observer had to bend down for this purpose, and in Lk 12 27; He 10 24 (katanoéd, to “observe well’), while in He 13 7 the anathedréd, ‘look up toward” or ‘‘look again at” is consistent with the reverential regard com- mended in the context. Used in the OT for a variety of Heb terms, signifying inspecting (Prov 31 16), examining (Lev 18 13), giving serious thoughts to (Ps 77 5; Isa 1 3), it often means little more than “see” or “behold” (Ps 8 3; 9 18). H. E. Jacoss CONSIST, kon-sist’ (cvvicrnp., sunistémi): To stand together, exist, subsist (Col 1 17, ‘in him all things consist,” i.e. the continuance of the universe is dependent upon His support and administration). In Lk 12 15, it tr® the vb. edut, eimi, ‘‘to be,” to express the thought that wealth is only an accident, not an essential to the highest ideal of life. CONSOLATION, kon-sé-la/shun (mwapékAnors, pardklésis): ‘Consolation of Israel’? (Lk 2 25), refers to the fulfilment of the promises in Isa 40 1 ff. See Comrort. “Son of consolation” (Acts 4 36 AV and ARVm); see BarnaBas. CONSORT, kon-sért’ (wporkAnpsa,; prosklérdd, “to allot,” Acts 17 4). The vb. may be either in the middle or passive voice. RV, AV, and Luther’s German tr regard it as middle, and render it: ‘“‘cast their lots with,” “associated,” “united with.” Inad- vocacy of the passive, see Alford’s Greek Testament, proposing: “were added,” as if by lot, the allotment being determined by God who gave them the Holy Spirit directing their choice. The Eng. has the Lat for “‘lot’’ as its base. CONSPIRACY, kon-spir’a-si. See ConFEDERACY. CONSTANT, kon’stant, CONSTANTLY, kon’- stant-li: In 1 Ch 28 (hdzak) meaning “firm,” “strong.” In Prov 21 28 the advb. (“constantly”) of AV is replaced in ARV by “shall speak so as to endure,” ERV “unchallenged.” RV gives ‘“‘con- auenuy: for AV “constantly” in Acts 12 15; Tit 8. CONSTELLATIONS, kon-ste-la/shuns (0"2"03, kesilim, lit. “Orions”). See Astronomy, IT, 11. CONSTRAIN, kon-stran’: Generally in the sense of pressing urgently (2 K 4 8; Lk 24 29; Acts 16 15), to impel or carry away (2 Cor 5 14); sometimes to be compelled of necessity (Job 32 18; Acts 28 19; cf Gal 6 12). See Compzt. CONSULT, kon-sult’ ox , sha@al, 7T., malakh, 721, ya'ag, DY [Aram.] yt; cvpPovActopar, sum- bouletiomat) : (1) “To ask,” “inquire,” ‘‘seek advice.” Ezekiel speaks of the king of Bab consulting the teraphim (zk 21 21), and the Israelites were admonished to have nothing to do with “a consulter with a familiar spirit’’ (Dt 18 11). See Astrotoay; Com- MUNION wiTH Demons; DiviNaTION. (2) “To take counsel,” “devise,” “plan.” The various officials of Babylon ‘‘consulted together to establish a royal statute’ (Dnl 6 7; cf Mt 26 4). (3) “To deliberate with one’s self,” ‘‘make up one’s mind.” Nehemiah consulted with himself as to what might be done for Jerus (Neh 5 7). Jesus spoke of a king ‘‘consulting’’ (AV) whether he be able to wage a war (Lk 14 31; RV ‘take counsel”’). A. W. Fortune CONSUME, kon-sim’ (028, ’akhal, M22, kalah, DAM, téamam; avadloxw, analiskd): In OT ’akhal (“to eat,” “devour”) occurs very frequently, and is tr’ “consumed” (Gen 31 40; Ex 15 7; Ps 78 63, etc); kalah (‘‘to finish’’) is also frequently tr? ‘‘con- sume,” ‘‘consumed”’ (Gen 41 30; Ex 32 10; Ps 59 13, etc); tamam, “‘to be perfect,” ‘finished’ (Nu 17 13; Dt 2 15; Ps 73 19, etc). There are many other words tr? “‘consume” and “consumed,” e.g. siiph, “to end” (Jer 8 138; Dnl 2 44; Zeph 1 2.3); balah, “to fade,” “wear away” (Job 13 28; Ps 49 14); gdzal, implying violence (Job 24 19); saphah, “to end” (Gen 19 15.17; Isa 7 20, etc); ‘ashesh, “to be old” (Ps 6 7; 31 9.10 AV); makak, “‘to be- come completed” (Ezk 4 17; Zec 14 12 bis); ‘dsah kalah is rendered “utterly consume” (Neh 9 31); analiské, ‘‘to use up,” occurs in Lk 9 54; Gal & 15; 2 Thess 2 8 (AV); dapanda, ‘to spend,”’ is tr® “‘con- sume” in Jas 4 3 (RV “‘spend”’); katanaliskd, “to consume utterly,” occurs only in He 12 29; “for our God is a consuming fire.”’ In RV “devour,” “devoured” are several times substituted for “consume,” “consumed,” e.g. Job 20 26; Jer 49 27; Nu 16 35; “boil well” (izk 24 10); for “be consumed with dying” (Nu 17 13), “perish all of us’; ‘consume’ is substituted for “corrupt” in Mt 6 19; “my spirit is consumed,” for “my breath is corrupt” (Job 17 1); instead of “the flame cousumeth the chaff’ (Isa 5 24) we have ‘‘as the dry grass sinketh down in the flame”; and for “whom the Lord shall consume’? (2 Thess 2 8), RV reads (after a different text) ‘“‘whom the Lord Jesus shall slay,” ‘“‘consume” in ARVm. W. L. WaLkER CONSUMMATION, kon-su-ma’shun (71792, kil- layon, fr m2 , kdlah): The word, meaning destruc- tion, completion, or failing (Isa 10 23; 28 22; Dnl 9 27) is tr’ interchangeably in the AV for another 4) 66, 705 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Consent Contribution Heb word referring to a physical disease, and best trd “consumption”; cf Lev 26 16; Dt 28 22. Not used in RV. The Heb variously but more accu- rately tr? “full end”; cf Dnl 9 27; Isa 10 23; and “destruction”; cf Isa 10 22; 28 22. There seems therefore to be an inconsistency on the part of both the Authorized and Revised tr’. Watter G. CLIPPINGER CONSUMPTION, kon-sump’shun (MENW, sha- hepheth, ‘‘wasting away’): One of the punishments which was to follow neglect or breach of the law. It may mean pulmonary consumption, which occurs frequently in Pal; but from its association with fever in the texts, Lev 26 16; Dt 28 22, itis more likely to be the much more common condition of wasting and emaciation from prolonged or often recurring attacks of malarial fever. CONTAIN, kon-tan’. CONTEND, kon-tend’, CONTENTION, kon- ten’shun: The meeting of effort by effort, striving against opposition; sometimes physically, asin battle (Dt 2 9), or with horses (Jer 12 5), sometimes orally (Neh 13 11), sometimes spiritually (Ilsa 57 16). In the NT dtaxpiver, diakrinein, for the hostile separa- tion of one from another, dispute (Jude ver 9), or érayuvtfounat, epagdnizomai (Jude ver 3), descriptive of the strain to which a contestant is put. The noun is almost universally used with an unfavorable meaning, and as worthy of condemnation, for an altercation arising from a quarrelsome disposition. “By pride cometh only contention” (Prov 13 10). The contentions at Corinth (1 Cor 1 11) called forth the rebukes of Paul. Where used in AV in a good sense (1 Thess 2 2) RV has “conflict.” In Acts 16 39, the noun has a peculiar force, where EV translates parozusmés (whence Eng. “paroxysm’’) by “sharp contention.”” The Gr word refers rather to the inner excitement and irritation than to its outward expression. H. E. Jacoss CONTENT, kon-tent’, CONTENTMENT, kon- tent’ment (O73, ya‘al; &pxéw, arkéd): To be free from care because of satisfaction with what is al- ready one’s own. The Heb means simply ‘to be -pleased.”” The Gr brings out the full force of the word in 1 Tim 68; He 13 5. Contentment (1 Tim 6 6) is more inward than satisfaction; the former is a hahit or permanent state of mind, the latter has to do with some particular occurrence or object. CONTINENCY, kon’'ti-nen-si (éyxparevopar, eg- krateiomai, ‘to have self-control” or ‘‘continency” RV, “to contain” AV): Paul, although he would that all men were like himself unmarried, yet advises that they should marry if they cannot control their sexual passions, and hold them in complete subjection to Christian motives (1 Cor 7 9). The same Gr vb. is used in 1 Cor 9 25, and tr‘ “is temperate” (AV and ERV) of the athlete who during the period of training abstains from all indulgence in food, drink, and sexual passion. For the general principle as expressed in subst. egkrdteia (Acta 24 25; Gal 5 23; 2 Pet 1 6) and adj. egkratés (Tit 1 8) see TEMPER- ANCE, TEMPERATE. T. REEs CONTINUAL, kon-tin’ti-al, CONTINUALLY, kon-tin’ti-a-li: Without cessation, although there may be intervals between its presence; that which regularly recurs throughout a period, as Lk 24 53: “(They] were continually in the temple”; “est .... by her continual coming” (Lk 18 5). In OT for Heb tadhir, “pursue,” as one drop of rain follows another in swift succession, but more frequently by tdmidh for offerings repeated at intervals, as See CoNnTINENCY. Ex 29 42; occasionally the Heb has the phrase lit. meaning “‘all the day” (kol ha-yém),asGen 6 5. In the NT most frequently for did pantés, “through all” (“always” Mt 18 10; He 13 15), ‘‘sometimes,” adialetptds, ‘incessantly’ (Rom 9 2 AV) and diéne- kés, “continuously” (He 7 3). H. E. Jacops CONTINUANCE, kon-tin’t-ans: Not in RV; in Ps 139 16 AV, as an interpretation of Heb yamim, “days,” treating of God’s prevision, where RV has: “They were all written, even the days that were or- dained for me,” 1.e. all my days were in view, before one of them actually existed. In Isa 64 5 AV, for ‘slam, “of long time,” RV; in Rom 2 7, for hupo- ae “natience,”’ RV, or still better, ‘‘stedfastness,” m. CONTRADICTION, kon-tra-dik’shun: AV for dvridoyla, antilogia (He 7 7; 12 3). In the former passage, RV has ‘‘without any dispute,” i.e. what has been said requires no argument; in the latter “gainsaying,” which is scarcely an improvement, the reference being to the oral attacks upon the words and character of Jesus. CONTRARY, kon’tra-ri (“W2, keri; évavrios, enantios): In the OT it has the sense of antago- nistic, as one person opposed or hostile to the other, esp. in Lev 26 21.23.24.27.28.40.41, where Jeh declares His attitude toward the people in such phrases as: “If ye will not for all this hearken unto me, but walk c. unto me; then I will walk c. unto you in wrath.” In the NT it has a more varied significance and is applied to both material and human relations as simply opposite, set over against an object or thing. Used of the wind as in Mt 14 24; Mk 6 48; Acts 27 4, where it is spoken of asc. Refers also to conflicting doctrines, customs or beliefs, as 1 Tim 1 10, ‘and if there be any other thing c. to the sound doctrine.” Several other Gr words are tr? with almost an identical meaning. Occasionally a prefix gives a slightly different shade of meaning. Water G. CLIPPINGER CONTRIBUTION, kon-tri-bi’shun (kotvevia, koinénia, “communion” or “fellowship,” Rom 15 26; 2 Cor 9 13): The meaning “contribution” is drawn from the context, rather than from the Gr word. The phrase in the passage cited, lit. rendered, would be “‘to exercise” or “put fellowship into activity.” The koinédnia subsisting among believers because of their inner communion with Christ places them and their gifts and posses- sions at the service of one another (see Com- MUNION). They are enjoined not to forget to com- municate (He 13 16). To be “communicative” (koinonikot) is to be a habit of their lives, the Christian principle being that of the holding of all property as a trust, to he distributed as there is need (Acts 2 44f; 2 Cor 8 14f). The first occa- sion for calling this fellowship into activity, by way of ‘contributions,’ was within the church at Jerus and for its needy members (see ComMuNITY oF Goons). The second occasion was repeatedly from the infant gentilé churches for the poor within the same church (Acts 11 29; Rom 15 26; 2 Cor 8 1-4; 9 2); the fellowship thus widening from intra-congregational to general church benevolence. These contributions were gathered weekly (1 Cor 16 2£), were proportioned to the means of the givers (Acts 11 29; 1 Cor 16 2), were not ex- acted or prescribed, in a legalistic manner, but were called forth as the free-will offerings of grateful hearts (2 Cor 8 7), springing from the community spirit, and were sent to their destination by ac- credited representatives of the congregations (I Cor 16 3; Acts 11 30). H. E. Jacozs Contrite Convict THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 706 CONTRITE, kon’trit, CONTRITION, kon- trish’'un (N3"1, dakka’, “bruise’): Only in OT (Ps 34 18; Ps 61 17; Isa 57 15); M22, nakheh, _ “smitten” (Isa 66 2). Contrite, “crushed,” is only the superlative of “broken”; ‘a contrite heart” is “a heart broken to pieces.” In Holy Scripture, the heart is the seat of all feeling, whether joy or sorrow. A contrite heart is one in which the natural pride and self-sufficiency have been completely humbled by the consciousness of guilt. The theological term “contrition” designates more than is found in these passages. It refers to the grief experienced as a consequence of the revela- tion of sin made by the preaching of the law (Jer 23 29). The analyzes repentance into two parts: ‘Contrition and faith,” the one the fruit of the preaching of the law, the other of the gospel. While c. has its de- grees, and is not equal in all persons, the promise of forgiveness is not dependent upon the degree of contrition, but solely upon the merit of Christ. It is not simply a precondition of faith, but, as hatred of sin, combined with the purpose, by God’s aid, to overcome it, grows with faith. H. E. Jacoss CONTROVERSY, kon‘tro-vér-si (2, ribh, “strife,” “contention”; époAoyoupéves, homologoumé- nés, “confessedly,” “without controversy’): Used frequently of disputes amoug men (as Dt 17 8) and then transferred to the justice of God as directed against the sins of men. Thus we read of Jeh's controversy with the nations (Jer 26 31); with the inhabitants of the land (Hos 4 1); with His people (Mic 6 2). ‘Without controversy” (1 Tim 3 16), a positive rather than a negative expression, “by common cousent,” or better, “as unanimously confessed,” introducing a quotation from a hymn or rhythmical confession of the early church. H. E. Jacoss CONVENIENT, kon-vén’yent: In RV limited to tr of xatpés, katrés, “suitable time,” “season,” and its compounds: ‘‘that which is seasonable” or “opportune” (Mk 6 21; Acts 24 25). AV is re- placed, in Prov 30 8 RV, by “needful” (Heb hak), “feed me with the food that is needful for me”; Jer 40 4, by “right”; Eph 5 4, by “befitting”; in Rom 1 28, by “fitting,” and in 1 Cor 16 12, by “op- portunity.” CONVENT, kon-vent’: Found in the AVm of Jer 49 19: ‘Who will convent me in judgment?” and in Jer 60 44: ‘Who will convent me to plead?” The Heb term which is rendered convent is y@‘adh, and it means to summon to a court, to call on to plead. Convent is obsolete, but it was formerly used, and meant to summon, or to call before a judge. Shakespeare used it several times. In King Henry VITI, Act V, he said, “The lords of the council hath commanded that the archbishop be convented to the council board.” CONVERSANT, kon-viar’sant (qm, hdalakh, “to go on,” “to walk’): This word is tr? “conver- sant” in Josh 8 35 AV (m ‘“‘walked”’), and 1 S 25 15 AV smeaning “going along with them;’? ARV went.”” CONVERSATION, kon-vér-sa’shun (avacrpoph, anastrophé, ép.dla, homilia): This word is another illustration of the changes which time makes in a living language. The modern sense of the term is mutual talk, colloquy, but in AV it never means that, but always behavior, conduct. This broader meaning, at a time not much later than the date of AV, began to yield to the special, limited one of Augsburg Confession (Art. XII) | today, perhaps, as has been suggested, because speech forms so large a part of conduct. The NT words for “converse” in the modern sense are homiléG (Lk 24 14.15; Acts 20 11) and sunomilé (Acts 10 27). (1) In the OT the word used to indicate conduct is J), derekh, “way,” the course one travels (AV Ps 37 14; m 50 23). It is the common Heb idea of conduct, possibly due, as Hatch thinks, to the fact that in Syria intercourse between village and village was so much on foot, with difficulty on stony tracks over the hills, and this is reflected in the metaphor. f (2) In the NT the idea of deportment is once rendered by trépos, ‘‘Let your c. be without covet- ousness” (He 18 5 AV; RV “be ye free from the love of money”; RVm “let your turn of mind be free”). But the usual Gr word is anastrophé, ‘“‘a turning up and down,” possibly due to the fact, as Hatch again avers, that life in the bustling streets of Athens and Rome gave rise to the conception of life as quick motion to and fro. ‘Ye have heard of my c.” (Gal 1 13 AV; RV “manner of life’). So also Eph 4 22; 1 Tim 4 12; He 13 7; ‘Let him show out of a good c.” (Jas 3 13 AV; RV “by his good life”); “vexed with the filthy c.” (2 Pet 27 AV; RV “lascivious life’); “holy ce.” (2 Pet 3 11 AV; RV “holy living’); ‘‘Our ec. is in heaven” (Phil 3 20 AV; RV “citizenship” [q.v.]). See also in the Apoc (Tob 4 14; 2 Macc 5 8). The tr* in the Revisions put a wholesome em- phasis upon conduct, and eliminate the danger of much misunderstanding. See further Hatch, Hssays in Biblical Greek. H. TREVER CONVERSION, kon-vir’shun: I. The Words “Conversion,’’ ‘‘Convert,’’ in Bib- lical Usage.—The noun “conversion” (éricrpogpt, epistrophé) occurs in only one passage 1. Inthe in the Bible, ‘“They passed through both English Phoenicia and Samaria, declaring the Bible conversion of the Gentiles’ (Acts 15 3). Derived forms of the vb. ‘‘con- vert” are used in the RV in Jas 5 19, “convert,” “converteth” (5 20), “converted” (Ps 51 13, m “return”), “converts” (Isa 1 27, m ‘“‘they that re- turn”). In other instances where the AV uses forms of the vb. “convert” the RV employs “‘turn again” (Isa 6 10; Lk 22 32; Acts 3 19), or “turn” (Isa 60 5; Mt 13 15; 18 3; Mk 4 12; Jn 12 40; Acts 28 27). In Ps 19 7 the reading of the AV, “The law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul,” has been changed by the revisers into “restoring the soul.” The words commonly used in the Eng. Bible as equivalent with the Heb and Gr terms are “turn,” “return,” “turn back,” ‘‘turn again” (ef Dt 4 30; Isa 65 7; Jer 3 12 ff; 26 5; 35 15; Ezk 18 21— 23; 33 11; Mal 37). Thus “convert” is synon- ymous with “turn,” and “conversion” with “turn- ing. : The principal Heb word is 33W, shabh; other words are M122, panah, JD, hdphakh, 329, $a- bhabh, in Hiphil. They are used (1) in 2. Inthe the lit. sense, for instance, Gen 14 7; OT Dt 17 16; Ps 669; Isa 38 8. (2) In the later prophetical writings the vb. shibh refers, both in the Qal and Hiphil forms, to the return from the captivity (Isa 1 27; Jer 29 14; 30 3; Ezk 16 53; Zeph 2 7). (3) In the fig., ethical or religious sense (a) from God (Nu 14 43; 1S 16 11; 1 K 9 6); (6) more frequently to turn back to God (1 S 7 3; 1 K 8 33; Isa 19 22; Joel 2 12; Am 46 ff; Hos 6 11; 7 10). The words used in the LXX and NT are orpé- gev, stréphein, and its compounds, é7o, apostr., dva, anasir., érava, epanastr., bro, hupostr., and esp. émirtpépevr, epistréphein. The latter word occurs 707 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Contrite Convict 39 times in the NT. It is used (1) in the lit. sense in Mt 9 22; 10 13; 24 18; Acts 9 40; 16 36, etc; (2) in the fig. sense, in tran-~ 3. Inthe sitive form (Lk 1 16f; Jas 5 19 f). NT In Gal 49 and 2 Pet 2 21 it de- notes to turn from the right way to the wrong. The opposite meaning, to turn from the wrong way to the right, we find in Lk 22 32; Acts 9 35; 11 21; 14 15; 16 19; 26 18; 2 Cor 3 16; 1 Thess 19; 1 Pet 2 25. In connection with metanoein, “repent,” it is used in Acts 3 19; 26 20. The root word strephein is used in the fig. sense in Mt 18 3; Jn 12 40. LXX and TR have here epistrephein. The Doctrine.—While the words “conversion” and “convert” do not occur frequently in our Eng. Bible the teaching contained therein is fundamental in Christian doctrine. From the words themselves it is not possible to derive a clearly defined doctrine of conversion; the materials for.the construction of the doctrine must be gathered from the tenor of Bib. teaching. There is a good deal of vagueness in the modern use of the term. By some writers it is used in ‘a very general way to stand for the whole 1. Vague series of manifestations just preced- Use of the ing, accompanying, and immediately Word following the apparent sudden changes of character involved” (E. D. Star- buck, The Psychology of Religion, 21). “‘To be converted,’ ‘to he regenerated,’ ‘to receive grace,’ ‘to experience religion,’ ‘to gain an assurance,’ are sO many phrases which denote the process, gradual or sudden, by which a self, hitherto di- vided and consciously wrong, inferior and unhappy hecomes unified and consciously right, superior and happy in consequence of its hold upon religious realities. This at least is what conversion signifies in general terms’ (William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience, 189). In this general, vague way the term is used not only by psychologists, hut also by theological writers and in common religious parlance. A converted manis a Christian, aheliever, a man who has religion, who has experienced re- generation. In its more restricted meaning the word denotes the action of man in the initial process of salvation as distinguished from the action of 2. Specific God. Justification and regeneration Meaning re purely Divine acts, repentance, faith, conversion are human acts although under the influence and by the power of the Divine agency. Thus conversion denotes the human volition and act hy which man in ohedience to the Divine summons determines to change the course of his life and turns to God. Arrested hy God’s call man stops to think, turns about and heads the opposite way. This presupposes that the previous course was not directed toward God but away from Him. The instances of conversion related in the Bible show that the objective point toward which man’s life was directed may be either the service of idols (1 Thess 1 9) or a life of reli- gious indifference, a self-centered life where material things engross the attention and deaden the sense of things spiritual (rich young ruler, Lk 18 22), or a life of sensuality, of open sin and shame (prodi- galson, Lk 15 13) oreven a mistaken way of serving God (Saul, Acts 26 9). Accordingly in conversion either the religious or the ethical element may pre- dominate. The moral man who turns from self to God or, as Saul did, from an erroneous notion concerning God’s will to a clear conception of his relation to God is more conscious of the religious factor. Conversion brings him into vital, conscious fellowship with God through Jesus Christ. The immoral man who is awakened to a realization of the holiness of God, of the demands of His law, and of his own sin and guilt is more conscious of the out- ward change in his manner of life. The ethical change is the more outstanding fact in his experi- ence, although it can never be separated from the religious experience of the changed relation to God. The mode of conversion varies greatly according to the former course of life. It may be a sudden crisis in the moral and intellectual 3. Mode life. This is very frequently the case in the experience of heathen who turn from the worship of idols to faith in Jesus Christ. A sudden crisis is frequently witnessed in the case of persons who, having lived a life of flagrant sin, renounce their former life. Conversion to them means a complete revolution in their thoughts, feelings and outward manner of life. In other instances conversion appears to he the climax of a prolonged conflict for supremacy of divergent mo- tives; and, again, it may be the goal of a gradual growth, the consummation of a process of discern- ing ever more clearly and yielding ever more defi- nitely and thus experiencing ever more vitally truths which have been implanted and nurtured by Christian training. This process results in the conscious acceptance of Jesus Christ as the personal Saviour and in the consecration of life to His service. Thus conversion may be an instantaneous act, or a process which is more or less prolonged. The latter is more frequently seen in the case of children and young people who have grown up in Christian families and have received the benefit of Christian training. No conversions of this kind are recorded in the NT. This may he explained hy the fact that most of our NT writings are addressed to the first generation of Christians, to men and women who were raised in Jewish legalism or heathen idolatry, and who turned to Christ after they had passed the age of adolescence. The religious life of their children as distinguished in its;mode and manifestations from that of the adults does not ap- pear to have been a matter of discussion or a source of perplexity so as to call forth specific instruction. Conversion comprises the characteristics both of repentance and of faith. Repentance is conversion viewed from its starting-point, the turning from the former life; faith indicates the ohjective point of conversion, the turning to God. Of late the psychology of conversion has been carefully studied and elaborately treated by psy- chologists. Much valuable material 4. Conver- has been gathered. It is shown that sion and certain periods of adolescent life are Psychology particularly susceptible to_ religious influences (cf G. Stanley Hall, Ado- lescence, II, ch xiv; E. D. Starbuck, Psychology of Religion, etc). Yet conversion cannot be explained as a natural process, conditioned by physiological changes in the adolescent, esp. hy approaching puberty. The laws of psychology are certainly God’s laws as much as all other laws of Nature, and His Spirit works in harmony with His own laws. But in genuine conversion there is always at work in a direct and immediate manner the Spirit of God to which man, be he adolescent or adult, consciously responds. Any attempt to explain conversion hy eliminating the direct working of the Divine Spirit falls short of the mark. See REGENERATION; Ra- PENTANCE. Lirenaturs.—See REGENERATION. . L. Nusisen CONVICT, kon-vikt’, CONVICTION, kon-vik’- shun (é\éyxw, elégchd, and compounds, “to prove guilty”): Usual tr of EV, where AV has “convince,” asin Jn 8 46; Tit 19; Jas 2 9; once also replacing AV “reprove”’ (Jn 16 8), while RV changes AV “convince” into “reprove’ in 1 Cor 14 24. It Convince Cord always implies the presentation of evidence. It is a decision presumed to be based upon a careful and discriminating consideration of all the proofs offered, and has a legal character, the verdict being rendered either in God’s judgment (Rom 3 19), or before men (Jn 8 46) by an appeal to their consciences in which God’s law is written (Rom 2 15). Since such conviction is addressed to the heart of the guilty, as well as concerning him exter- nally, the word ‘‘reprove’’ is sometimes substituted. To ‘convict . . . . in respect of righteousness, and of judgment” (Jn 16 8), refers to the conviction of the inadequacy and perversity of the ordinary, natural standards of righteousness and judgment, and the approval of those found in Christ, by the agency of the Holy Spirit, as the great interpreter and applier of the work of Christ. H JACOBS CONVINCE, kon-vins’ (é\éyxo, elégchd): An- other form etymologically of “convict,” means to bring to a decision concerning the truth or the false- hood of a proposition (Job 32 12). As usually applied to what is of a more individual and private character, and having reference to what is either good or bad, or what is in itself without moral quality, it has given way in RV to either “convict,” ‘‘reprove”’ or “‘confute.” See Convict. CONVOCATION, kon-vé-ka’shun: A rendering for 8p, mikra’, chiefly in the frequent “Holy Convocation’; but the word is sometimes used alone, e.g. Nu 10 2; Isa 113; 45. On a holy convocation no work could be done. The phrase differs from “solemn assembly,” which in the Pent is only applied to the concluding festivals at the end of Passover and Tabernacles, while ‘““Holy Con- vocation” is used of the Sabbath and all the great holy days of the Mosaic legislation. CONVULSING, kon-vuls‘ing (Mk 1 26m [AV torn]). See Unciean Spirit. COOKING, kodk’ing. See Foon. COOL, kool (77, rah, “wind”; katapixe, ka- tapsiich6, “to cool down’): “Cool of the day” (Gen 3 8, m “wind”), when the evening breeze has tempered the heat of the day, enabling Orientals to walk abroad. “Cool my tongue” (Lk 16 24), a phrase reflecting the Jewish notion that. Abraham had power to:rescue his descendants from the fires of Hades. COOS, ké’os. See Cos. COPING, ké’ping. See Hovusz. COPPER, kop’ér (MUM} , n*hdsheth): The word is trt “copper” in only one passage (Ezr 8 27 AV). In the ARV of this passage, “brass’”’ has been sub- stituted. Neither describes the actual alloy accord- ing to present definitions so well as the word “pronze.”’ Copper was one of the earliest metals to be known and utilized in alloy, but copper, as asingle metal, was probably little used. The remains of spears, balances, arms, vases, mirrors, statues, cooking utensils, implements of all kinds, etc, from Bible times are principally of an alloy of copper hardened with tin known today as bronze (see Brass). In such passages as Dt 8 9, where refer- ence is made to the native metal or ores, ‘‘copper” should be substituted for “brass” as in the ARV (cf Job 40 18). This is true also of coins as xarxés, chalkés, in Mt 10 9. Our modern Eng. word ‘copper’ is derived from an old name pertaining to the island of Cyprus. Copper was known to the ancients as Cyprian brass, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 708 probably because that island was one of the chief sources for this metal. The Sinai peninsula and the mountains of northern Syria also contributed to the ancient world’s supply (see Am Tab). No evidences of copper ore in any quantity are found in Pal proper. See Merat; Mine. James A. PaTcu COPPERSMITH, kop’é-smith (xaAkets, chal- kets): The word is found in NT once only, in 2 Tim 4 14: “Alexander the coppersmith did [m “showed”’] me much evil.” As the Bible word rendered ‘‘copper’” (see Ezr 8 27 AV) is tr? “brass” by RV, so the word here rendered ‘‘c.’’ should be rendered “brazier,”’ or ‘worker in brass.” See Copper. COPTIC VERSIONS, kop’tik var’shunz: I. LanevuaGe anp ALPHABET 1. Alphabet 2. Dialects Il. Versions INI. Caier Enirions LITERATURE I. Language and Alphabet.—The Coptic alpha- bet consists of the Gr uncial letters, plus seven characters taken from the Egyp de- 1. Alphabet motic to express sounds not represented intheGr. It can be traced back to the 4th cent., as the oldest Coptic MSS belong to the end of the 4th or beginning of the 5th cent. The language still prevailed in Egypt in the 9th cent., but was no longer understood in Middle Egypt in the 12th. Its last speaker died in 1633. There were at least five written dialects and sub- dialects of Coptic. Of these the most important from a literary point of view was 2. Dialects the (1) Buhairic, the dialect of Lower Egypt, often called Coptic par ezx- cellence, and also (wrongly) Memphitic. It is used as the ecclesiastical language in the services of the Coptic church. The other four dialects are some- what more closely allied to one another than to Buhairic, which shows greater traces of Gr influence. These dialects are, (2) the Sahidie (Sa‘td7, or dia- lect_of upper Egypt), also called Thebaic; (3) the Bashmiric—or rather Bushmtric—(for which Fayyimic has been suggested); (4) the Middle Egyp proper, (known from MSS found in the mon- astery of Jeremias near the Theban Serapeum), differing but little from (3); and (5) the Akhmimic (Akhmim=the ancient Chemmis). Akhmimic is more primitive and more closely related to ancient Egyp than any other. Only a few fragments in it (of Ex, Ecclus, 2 Macc, the Minor Prophets, and Catholic epp.) have yet been found. The last three dialects are often classed together as “Middle Egyp” and (4) is then called ‘Lower Sahidic.” Il. Versions.—In all 5 dialects more or less com- plete versions of the Bible once existed. They were the earliest made after the early Syr. At latest they began in the 3d cent., though some (e.g. Hyvernat) say as early as the 2d. It is thought that the Sahidic vergion was the earliest, then the Middle Egyp, and finally the Buhairic. The latter represents an early and comparatively pure Gr text, free from what are generally termed western additions, while the Sahidic, on the other hand, contains most of the peculiar western read- ings. It sometimes supports codex 8, sometimes codex B, sometimes both, but generally it closely agrees with codex D (Bezae), esp. in the Acts. A Coptic (Sahidic) MS, written considerably before 350 AD, and published by the British Museum in April, 1912, contains Dt, Jon, and Acts, and is older than any other Bib. MS (except a few frag- ments) yet known to exist. It proves that this Sa- hidic version was made about 200 AD. It in general supports the “Western” text of cod Bezae (D). 709 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Convince Cord Much of the NT esp. still exists in Sahidic, though not Rev. In Buhairic we have the Pent, Job, Pss, Prov, Isa, Jer, Ezk, Dnl, the 12 Minor Prophets, and fragments of the historical books of the OT, besides the whole NT, though the Book of Rev is later than the rest. In the other dialects much less had been preserved, as far as is known. In Bushmirrie we have fragments of Isa, Lam, Ep. Jer, and a good many fragments of the NT. In more than one dialect we have apoc gospels (see Texts and Studies, IV, no. 2, 1896) and Gnostic papyri, etc. The OT was tr? from the LXX. The Pss seem to have been tr? about 303 AD. Ill. Chief Editions.—The Buhairic Pss were first published in 1659. Wilkins published the Buhairic NT at London in 1716, and the Pent in 1731; Schwartze the Gospels in 1846-47; de Lagarde the Actsand Epp. in 1852. He also edited the Pss (trans- literated) in 1875, 151 in number, of which the last celebrates David’s victory over Goliath. He added fragments of the Sahidic Psalter and of the Buhairic Prov. Tattam published the MinorProphets in 1836 and the Major in 1852, an ed of the Gospels in London in 1847, and of the rest of the NT in 1852 (SPCK), with a literal Arab. version. Horner’s ed of the Buhairic NT (4 vols, 1898, etc, Clarendon Press) and of Sahidic Gospels (1910, 3 vols) is the standard ed. Ford published part of the Sahidic NT in 1799. Various edd of parts of OT and NT have since appeared: e.g. Ciasca published frag- ments of the Sahidic OT (aiecran Bibliorum Frag- menia Copto-Sahidica Musei Borgiani) at Rome, 1885-89. Literature.—Realencyclopddie fir prot. Theol. und Kirche, 111; Hyvernat, Etude sur les versions coptes; Revue biblique, 1896, 1897; Zeitschrift fur dgypt. Sprache; Journal of Theol. Studies, J, 3; Nestle, Text. Crit of Gr NT; Forbes Robinson, Tezts and Studies, IV; Oecesterley in Murray's New Bible Dict. : W. Sr. Cuair Tispatu COR, kor ((2, kor): A liquid and dry measure, same as the homer, of about 90 gals. capacity (Ezk 45 14). See Homer; WeicHTs anp Mzas- URES. CORAL, kor’al (MVANI, ra’math, UPI, peninim): The red coral or precious coral, Corallium rubrum, is confined to the Mediterranean and Adri- atic seas. It is the calcareous axis of a branching colony of polyps. It does not form reefs, but occurs in small masses from 40 to 100 fathoms below the surface. It differs totally in structure from the white corals which form coral reefs, belonging to the order of Octactinia or Eight-rayed Polyps, while the reef-building corals belong to the Hexactinia or Six-rayed Polyps. : Ra math, apparently from r. r@am, “to be high” (cf rim, ‘to be high”), occurs in three passages. In Prov 24 7, EVV have ‘“‘too high”: ‘Wisdom is too high for afool.” InJob 28 12-19, where various precious things are compared with wisdom, EV has “coral”? (AVm “Ramoth”). It is mentioned here along with s‘ghar, “gold” (RVm “treasure’’); kethem, “gold of Ophir’; shdham, “onyx” (RVm “beryl”); sappir, “sapphire”; zahabh, “gold”; ekhakhith, “crystal” (RV “glass’); paz, “gold”; gabhish, “pearls” (RV “‘crystal”); pentnim, “rubies” (RVm “red coral” or pearls’); pif*dhah, “topaz.” While the real meaning of some of these terms is doubtful (see Srongs, Precious), they all, includ- ing ra’math, appear to be precious stones or metals. In Ezk 27 16, r@’math occurs with ndphekh, ‘“‘emer- alds’ (RVm “carbuncles’”’); ’argaéman, “purple”; rikmah, “broidered work”; bug, “fine linen’; kadhkodh, ‘agate’ (AVm “‘chrysoprase,” RV “ru- bies”). Here the context does not require a pre- cious stone or metal, and Vulg has sericum, 1.e. “Chinese material” or “silk.” Notwithstanding, therefore, the traditional rendering, “coral,” the real meaning of r@’math must be admitted to be doubtful. Peninim (from r. pdnan, “to divide up,” “to separate’; cf Arab. fanan, “a branch of a tree’’) occurs in Job 28 18; Prov 315; 8 11; 20 15; 81 10; Lam 4 7. In all these passages EV has ‘“Tubies” (Job 28 18, RVm “red coral” or ‘“pearls’’; Lam 4 7, RVm “corals”). Everywhere a precious substance is indicated, but nowhere does the con- text give any light as to the nature of the sub- stance, except in Lam 4 7, where we have the state- ment that the nobles of Jerus ‘‘were more ruddy in body” than p*ninim. This and the etymology favor a branching red substance such as precious coral. The occurrence of p’ninim and ra’math together in Job 28 18 is, if we give the precedence to p‘ninim, a further argument against r@’moth meaning ‘‘coral.” Aurreo Evy Day COR-ASHAN, kér-ash’an, k6-ra’shan (ERV, AV Chor-ashan; JUY “iD, kor ‘dshdn, 1 § 30 30): The original reading was probably Bor-ashan, “well of Ashan.”’ See AsHAN. CORBAN, kér’ban (j27P,, korbdn; Sapov, déron; trd “a gift,” “a sacrificial offering,” lit. ‘that which is brought near,” viz. to the altar): An expression frequently used in the original text of the OT; in the Eng. Bible it occurs in Mk 7 11; cf also Mt 15 5. It is the most general term for a sacrifice of any kind. In the course of time it became asso- ciated with an objectionable practice. Anything dedicated to the temple by pronouncing the votive word “C.” forthwith belonged to the temple, but only ideally; actually it might remain in the posses- sion of him who made the vow. So a son might be justified in not supporting his old parents simply because he designated his property or a part of it as a gift to the temple, that is, as “C.”’? There was no necessity of fulfilling his vow, yet he was actually prohibited from ever using his property for the support of his parents. This shows clearly why Christ singled out this queer regulation in order to demonstrate the sophistry of tradition and to bring out the fact of its possible and actual hostility to the Scripture and its spirit. Wituiam Baur CORBE, kér’bé. See Cuorse. CORD, kérd (031, hebhel, "K), yether, 797, méthar, DAY , ‘dbhoth; cxowlov, schoinion): (1) The Arab. hab’! corresponds to the Heb hebhel and is still the common name for cord or rope throughout the East. Such ropes or cords are made of goat’s or camel’s hair, first spun into threads and then twisted or plaited into the larger and strongerform. Hebhelistr4rather inconsistently in RV by “cord” (Josh 2 15; Job 36 8, etc); by “line”? (28 8 2; Mic 25; Ps 166; 78 55; Am 717; Zec 2 1); by “ropes” (1 K 20 31), and by ‘tacklings” (Isa 83 23). (2) Yether corresponds to the Arab. wittar, which means catgut. With a kindred inconsistency it is tr? RV by ‘“withes” (Jgs 16 7 RVm “bowstring’’); by “cord” (Job 30 11), where some think it may mean “bowstring,” or possibly “rein” of a bridle, and by “bowstring” (Ps 11 2), doubtless the true meaning. (8) Méthar is considered the equivalent of Arab. atndb, which means tent ropes, being constantly so used by the Bedouin. They make the thing so called of goat’s or camel’s hair. It is used of the “eords” of the tabernacle (Jer 10 20), of the ‘‘cords”’ of the “hangings” and “‘pillars” of the courts of the tabernacle in Ex and Nu, and fig, by Isa (64 2), “Lengthen thy cords,”’ etc. (4) ‘Abhath is thought to have its equivalent in the Arab. ribiits, which means a band, or fastening. Cords, Small Cor, ist Ep. to THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA See Bann. Itistr4by “cords” in Ps 118 27; 129 4; by “bands” in Ezk 3 25; Job 39 10; Hos 11 4; by “ropes” in Jgs 15 13.14, and by “‘cart rope” in Isa 56 18. SeeCart. See also Nu 15 38 and Amv- ter. It seems to have the meaning of something twisted or interlaced. i (5) In the NT “cord” is found in Jn 2 15, trans- lating schoinion, but in Acts 27 32 the same Gr word is rendered “ropes.” Figurative: (1) of affliction (Job 36 8); (2) of God’s laws (Ps 2 3); (8) of the artifices of the wicked (Ps 129 4; 140 5); (4) of sinful habits (Prov 5 22); (5) of true friendship or compan- ionship (Eccl 4 12); (6) possibly of the spinal cord (Eccl 12 6); (7) of falsehood (Isa 5 18); (8) of the spirit of enterprise and devotion (Isa 54 2); (9) of od’s gentleness. Gro. B. Eacrr CORDS, kérdz, SMALL (cxouvlov, schointon, the diminutive of schotnos, ‘‘a rush,’’ hence “a rope of rushes’’): Tr4 ‘‘small cords” (Jn 2 15 AV; RV “cords’”’). The same word is tr4 “ropes” in Acts 27 32. See also Job 41 2m. CORE, ko’ré (Kopé, Koré): In AV, Jude ver 11, used as a variant for Korah. See Korag, 3. CORIANDER, kor-i-an’dé@r (74, gadh; Kédpvov, kérion): The fruit of the Coriandrum Sativum (N.O. Umbelliferae), a plant indigenous around the Medi- terranean and extensively cultivated. The fruits are aromatic and stomatic-carminative. They are of a grayish-yellow color, ribbed, ovate-globular and in size about twice that of a hemp-seed. ‘The manna was like coriander seed” (Nu 11 7; see also Ex 16 31). CORINTH, kor’inth (Képw6os, Kérinthos, “or- nament’’): A celebrated city of the Peloponnesus, capital of Corinthia, which lay N. of Argolis, and with the isthmus joined the peninsula to the main- land. Corinth had three good harbors (Lechaeum, on the Corinthian, and Cenchreae and Schoenus on the Saronic Gulf), and thus commanded the traffic of both the eastern and the western seas. The larger ships could not be hauled across the isthmus (Acts 27 6.37); smaller vessels were taken over by means of a ship tramway with wooden rails. The Phoenicians, who settled here very early, left many traces of their civilization in the industrial arts, such as dyeing and weaving, as well as in their religion and mythology. The Corin- thian cult of Aphrodite, of Melikertes (Melkart) and of Athene Phoenike are of Phoen origin. Poseidon, too, and other sea deities were held in high esteem in the commercial city. Various arts were cultivated and the Corinthians, even in the earliest times, were famous for their cleverness, inventiveness and artistic sense, and they prided themselves on surpassing the other Greeks in the embellishment of their city and in the adornment of their temples. There were many celebrated painters in Corinth, and the city became famous for the Corinthian order of architecture: an order, which, by the way, though held in high esteem by the Romans, was very little used by the Greeks them- selves. It was here, too, that the dithyramb (hymn to Dionysus) was first arranged artistically to be sung by a chorus; and the Isthmian games, held every two years, were celebrated just outside the city on the isthmus near the Saronic Gulf. But the commercial and materialistic spirit prevailed later. Not a single Corinthian distinguished himself in lit. Statesmen, however, there were in abundance: Peri- ander, Phidon, Timoleon. Harbors are few on the Corinthian Gulf. Hence no other city could wrest the commerce of these waters from Corinth. According to Thucydides, the first ships of war were built here in 664 BC. In those early days Corinth held a leading position among the Gr cities; but in consequence of her great material prosperity she would not risk all as Athens did, and win eternal supremacy over men: she had too much to lose to jeopardize her material interests for principle, and she soon sank into the second class. But when Athens, Thebes, Sparta and Argos fell away, Corinth came to the front again as the wealthiest and most important city in Greece; and when it was destroyed by Mum- mius in 146 BC, the treasures of art carried to Rome were as great as those of Athens. Delos became the commercial center for a time; but when Julius Ship-Canal at Corinth. Caesar restored Corinth a cent. later (46 BC), it grew so rapidly that the Rom colony soon became again one of the most prominent centers in Greece. When Paul visited Corinth, he found it the me- tropolis of the Peloponnesus. Jews flocked to this center of trade (Acts 18 1-18; Rom 16 21 ff; 1 Cor 9 20), the natural site for a great mart, and flourish- ing under the lavish hand of the Caesars; and this is one reason why Paul remained there so long (Acts 18 11) instead of sojourning in the old seats of aristocracy, such as Argos, Sparta and Athens. He found a strong Jewish nucleus to begin with; and it was in direct communication with Ephesus. But earthquake, malaria, and the harsh Turkish rule finally swept everything away except seven columns of one old Doric temple, the only object above ground left today to mark the site of the ancient city of wealth and luxury and immorality —the city of vice par excellence in the Rom world. Near the temple have been excavated the ruins of the famous fount of Peirene, so celebrated in Gr litera- ture. Directly S. of the city is the high rack (over 1,800 ft.) Acrocorinthus, which formed an impreg- nable fortress. Traces of the old ship-canal across the isthmus (attempted by Nero in 66-67 AD) were to be seen before excavations were begun for the present canal. At this time the city was thoroughly 710 . 711 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cords, Small Cor, 1st Ep. to Rom. Hence the many Lat names in the NT: | His first letter to the Corinthians was written from Lucius, Tertius, Gaius, Erastus, Quartus (Rom 16 21-23), Grispus, Titus Justus (Acts 18 7.8), For- tunatus, Achaicus (1 Cor 16 17). According to the testimony of Dio Chrysostomus, Corinth had hecome in the 2d cent. of our era the richest city in Greece. Its monuments and publie buildings and art treasures are descrihed in detail by Pausanias. The church in Corinth consisted principally of non-Jews (1 Cor 12 2). Paul had no intention at first of making the city a base of operations (Acts 18 1; 16 9.10); for he wished to return to Thessalonica (1 Thess 2 17.18). His plans were changed by a revelation (Acts 18 9.10). The Lord commanded him to speak boldly, and he did so, remaining in the city eighteen months. Find- ing strong opposition in the synagogue he left the Jews and went to the Gentiles (Acts 18 6). Never- theless, Crispus, the ruler of the synagogue and his household were believers and baptisms were nu- Ruins of Ancient Corinth with Acro-Corinthus in Background. merous (Acts 18 8); but no Corinthians were bap- tized by Paul himself except Crispus, Gaius and some of the household of Stephanas (1 Cor 1 14.16) ‘the firstfruits of Achaia’ (1 Cor 16 15). One of these, Gaius, was Paul’s host the next time he visited the city (Rom 16 23). Silas and Timothy, who had been left at Beroea, came on to Corinth ahout 45 days after Paul’s arrival. It was at this time that Paul wrote his first Epistle to the Thessa- lonians (3 6). During Gallio’s administration the Jews accused Paul, but the proconsul refused to allow the case to he brought to trial. This decision must have been looked upon with favor by a large majority of the Corinthians, who had a great dislike for the Jews (Acts 18 17). Paul became acquainted also with Priscilla and Aquila (18 18.26; Rom 16 8; 2 Tim 4 19), and later they accompanied him to Ephesus. Within a few years after Paul’s first visit to Corinth the Christians had increased so rapidly that they made quite a large congregation, but it was composed mainly of the lower classes: they were neither ‘learned, influential, nor of noble birth’ (1 Cor 1 26). Paul probably left Corinth to attend the cele- bration of the feast at Jerus (Acts 18 21), Little is known of the history of the church in Corinth after his departure. Apollos came from Ephesus with a letter of recommendation to the brethren in Achaia (Acts 18 27; 2 Cor 3 1); and he exer- cised a powerful influence (Acts 18 27.28; 1 Cor 1 12); and Paul came down later from Macedonia. Ephesus. Both Titus and Timothy were sent to Corinth from Ephesus (2 Cor 7 13.15; 1 Cor 4 17), and Timothy returned by land, meeting Paul in Macedonia (2 Cor 1 1), who visited Greece again in 56-57 or 57-58. Litzrratrurs.—Leake, Travels in the Morea, III, 229- 304; Peloponnesiaca, 392 ff; Curtlua, Peloponnesos, II, 514; Clark, Peloponnesus, 42-61; Conybeare and How- son, The Life and Epistles of St. Paul, ch xii; Ramsay, “Corlnth" (in HDB); Holm, History of Greece, I, 286 ff; II, 142, and 306-16; III, 31-44, and 283; IV, 221, 251, 347 and 410-12. J. E. Harry CORINTHIANS, ké-rin’thi-anz, FIRST EPISTLE TO THE: I. AvutHENTiIciIty or THE Two EpistLes 1. External Evidence cs 2. Internal Evidence 3. Consent of Criticism 4. Ultra-Radical Attack (Dutch School) II. Text of 1 anp 2Cor Integrity of 1 Cor_. III, Pavt's Previous Reiations wita Corintu 1. Corinth in 55 AD 2. Founding of the Church IV. Date or ruz Epistie V. Occasion oF tHE EpPIsTLE 1. A Previous Letter 2. Letter from Corinth VI. Convents 1. General Character 2. Order and Divislon 3. Outline (3) Chs 11-16 DistiNG@uisHiNG FraTuRzEs 1. Party Spirit 2. Christian Conscience 3. Power of the Cross LitzERATURS I. The Authenticity of the Two Epistles.—1 and 2 Cor, Gal and Rom, all belong to the period of Paul’s third missionary journey. They are the most remarkable of his writings, and are usually distinguished as the four great or principal epp.; a distinction which not only is a tribute to their high originality and intrinsic worth, but also indi- cates the extremely favorable opinion which critics of almost all schools have held regarding their authenticity. Throughout the cents. the tradition has remained practically unbroken, that they con- tain the very pectus Paulinum, the mind and heart of the great apostle of the Gentiles, and preserve to the church an impregnable defence of historical Christianity. What has to be said of their genuine- ness applies almost equally to both. The two epp. have a conspicuous place in the most ancient lists of Pauline writings. In the Mura- torian Fragment (cir 170) they stand 1. External at the head of the nine epp. addressed Evidence to churches, and are declared to have heen written to forbid heretical schism (primum omnium Corinthiis schisma hacresis in- tredicens); and in Marcion’s Apostolicon (cir 140) they stand second to Gal. They are also clearly attested in the most important writings of the suh- apostolic age, e.g. by Clement of Rome (cir 95), generally regarded as the friend of the apostle men- tioned in Phil 4 3; Ignatius (Ad Ephes., ch xviii, second decade of 2d cent.); Polycarp (chs ii, vi, xi, first half of 2d cent.), a disciple of John; and Justin Martyr (b. at close of 1st cent.); while the gnostic Ophites (2d cent.) were clearly familiar with both epp. (cf Westcott, Canon, passim, and Index II, also Charteris, Canonicity, 222-24, where most of the original passages are brought together). The witness of Clement is of the highest importance. Ere the close of the Ist cent. he himself wrote a letter to the Corinthians, in which (ch xlvii, Lightfoot’s ed, 144) he made a direct appeal to the authority of 1 Cor: “Take up the letter of Paul the blessed apostle; what did he write to you first in the beginning of the gospel? VII. Cor, 1st Ep. to THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 712 Verily he gave you spiritual direction regarding him- self, Cephas, and Apollos, for even then you were dividing yourselves into parties.” It would be im- possible to desire more explicit external testimony. Within themselves both epp. are replete with marks of genuineness. They are palpitating human documents, with the ring of reality 2. Internal from first to last. They admirably Evidence harmonize with the independent nar- rative of Acts; in the words of Schleier- macher (Finlig., 148), ‘“The whole fits together and completes itself perfectly, and yet each of the documents follows its own course, and the data contained in the one cannot be borrowed from those of the other.” Complex and difficult as the sub- jects and circumstances sometimes are, and varying as the moods of the writer are in dealing with them, there is a naturalness that compels assent to his good faith. The very difficulty created for a modern reader by the incomplete and _ allusive character of some of the references is itself a mark of genuineness rather than the opposite; just what would most likely be the case in a free and intimate correspondence between those who understood one another in the presence of immediate facts which needed no careful particularization; but what would almost as certainly have been avoided in a fictitious composition. Indeed a modicum of literary sense suffices to forbid classification among the pseudepigrapha. To take but a few instances from many, it is impossible to read such passages as those conveying the remonstrance in 1 Cor 9, the alternations of anxiety and relief in connection with the meeting of Titus in 2 Cor 2 and 7, or the ever-memorable passage which begins at 11 24 of the same ep.: “‘Of the Jews five times received I,” etc, without feeling that the hypothesis of fiction becomes an absurdity. No man ever wrote out of the heart if this writer did not. The truth is that the theory of pseudonymity leaves far more difficulties behind it than any it is supposed to solve. The unknown and unnamable literary prodigy of the 2d cent., who in the most daring and artistic manner gloried in the fanciful creation of those minute and life-like details which have imprinted themselves indelibly on the memory and imagina- tion of mankind, cannot be regarded as other than a chimera. No one knows where or when he lived, or in what shape or form. But if the writings are the undoubted rescripts of fact, to whose life and personality do they fit themselves more exquisitely than to those of the man whose name stands at their head, and whose compositions they claim to be? They suit beyond compare the apostle of the missionary journeys, the tender, eager, indomitable “prisoner of the Lord,’ and no other. No other that has even been suggested is more than the mere shadow of a name, and no two writers have as yet seriously agreed even as to the shadow. The perti- nent series of questions with which Godet (Intro to NT; Studies on the Epp., 305) concludes his remarks on the genuineness may well be repeated: “What use was it to explain at length in the 2d cent. a change in a plan of the journey, which, supposing it was real, had interest only for those whom the promised visit of the apostle personally concerned? When the author speaks of five hundred persons who had seen the risen Christ, of whom the most part were still alive at the time when he was writing is he telling his readers a mere story that would resemble a bad joke? What was the use of dis- cussing at length and giving detailed rules on the exercise of the glossolalia at a time when that gift no longer existed, so to say, in the church? Why make the apostle say: ‘We who shall be alive [at the moment of the Parousia]’ at a time when every- one knew that he was long dead? In fine, what church would have received without opposition into its archives, as an ep. of the apostle, half a cent. after his death, a letter unknown till then, and filled with reproaches most severe and humiliating to it? One is not surprised, therefore, that even the radical criticism of the 19th cent. cordially accepted the Corinthian epp. and their com- 8. Consent panions in the great group. The men of Criticism who founded that criticism were under no conceivable constraint in such a conclusion, save the constraint of obvious and incontrovertible fact. The Tubingen school, which doubted or denied the authenticity of all the rest of the epp., frankly acknowledged the genuineness of these. This also became the general verdict of the “critical” school which followed that of Ttibin- gen, and which, in many branches, has included the names of the leading German scholars to this day. F. C. Baur’s language (Paul, I, 246) was: “There has never been the slightest suspicion of unauthenticity cast on these four epp., and they bear so incontestably the character of Pauline originality, that there is no conceivable ground for the assertion of critical doubts in their case.” Renan (St. Paul, . Intro, V) was equally emphatic: ‘They are incon- testable, and uncontested.” Reference, however, must be made to the ultra- radical attack which has gathered some adherents, especially among Dutch scholars, 4. Ultra- during the last 25 years. As early Radical as 1792 Evanson, a_ retired Eng. Attack clergyman, rejected Rom on the ground that, according to Acts, no church existed in Rome in Paul’s day. Bruno Bauer (1850-51-52) made a more sweeping attack, relegating the whole of the four principal epp. to the close of the 2d cent. His views received little attention, until, in 1886 onward, they were taken up and extended by a series of writers in Holland, Pierson and Naber, and Loman, followed rapidly by Steck of Bern, Vélter of Amsterdam, and above all by Van Manen of Leyden. According to these writers, with slight modifications of view among themselves, it is very doubtful if Paul or Christ ever really existed; if they did, legend has long since made itself master of their personalities, and in every case what borders on the supernatural is to be taken as the criterion of the legendary. The epp. were written in the 1st quarter of the 2d cent., and as Paul, so far as he was known, was believed to be a reformer of anti-Judaic sympathies, he was chosen as the patron of the movement, and the writings were published in his name. The aim of the whole series was to further the interests of a supposed circle of clever and elevated men, who, partly imbued with Heb ideals, and partly with the speculations of Gr and Alexandrian philosophy, desired the spread of a universalistic Christianity and true Gnosis. For this end they perceived it necessary that Jewish legalism should be neutral- ized, and that the narrow national element should be expelled from the Messianic idea. Hence the epp. The principles on which the main conten- tions of the critics are based may be reduced to two: (1) that there are relations in the epp. so diff- cult, to understand that, since we cannot properly understand them, the epp. are not trustworthy; and (2) that the religious and ecclesiastical develop- ment is so great that not merely 20 or 30 years, but 70 or 80 more, are required, if we are to be able rationally to conceive it: to accept the situation at an earlier date is simply to accept what cannot possibly have been. It is manifest that on such principles it is possible to establish what one will, and that any historical lit. might be proved un- trustworthy, and reshaped according to the sub- jective idiosyncrasies of the critic. The under- 713 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cor, 1st Ep. to lying theory of intellectual development is too rigid, and is quite oblivious of the shocks it receives from actual facts, by the advent in history from time to time of powerful, compelling, and creative person- alities, who rather mould their age than are moulded by it. None have poured greater ridicule on this ‘“nseudo- Kritik’’ than the representatives of the advanced school in Germany whom it rather ex- pected to carry with it, and against whom it com- plains bitterly that they do not take it seriously. On the whole the vagaries of the Dutch school have rather confirmed than shaken belief in these epp.; and one may freely accept Ramsay’s view (HDB, I, 484) as expressing the modern mind regarding them, namely, that they are “the unimpeached and unassailable nucleus of admitted Pauline writings.” (Reference to the following will give a sufficiently adequate idea of the Dutch criticism and the replies that have been made to it: Van Manen, EB, art. “Paul,” and Expos T, IX, 205, 257, 314; Knowling, Witness of the Epp.; Clemen, Einhettlichkeit der p. B.; Sanday and Headlam, Romans, ICC; Godet Jiilicher and Zahn, in their Introductions; Schmiede and Lipsius in the Hand-Commentar.) HW. Text of 1 and 2 Cor.—The text of both epp. comes to us in the most ancient VSS, the Syr (Peshito), the Old Lat, and the Egyp, Integrity all of which were in very early use, of 1 Cor undoubtedly by the 3d cent. It is complete in the great Gr uncials: Sin. (X* and 4, 4th cent.), Vat. (B, 4th cent.), Alex. (A, 5th cent., minus two vs, 2 Cor 4 13; 12 7), and very nearly complete in Ephraemi (C, 5th cent.), and in the Gr-Lat Claromontanus (D, 6th cent.); as well as in numerous cursives. In both cases the original has been well preserved, and no exegetical difficulties of bigh importance are presented. (Reference should be made to the Intro in Sanday and Headlam’s Romans, [CC [1896], where §7 gives valuable information concerning the text, not only of Rom, but of the Pauline epp. generally; also to the recent ed [Oxford, 1910], NT Graecae, by Souter, where the various readings of the text used in RV [1881] are conveniently exhibited.) On the whole the text of 1 Cor flows on consistently, only at times, in a characteristic fashion, winding back upon itself, and few serious criticisms are made on its unity, although the case is different in this respect with its companion ep. Some writers, on insufficient grounds, believe that 1 Cor contains relics of a previous ep. (cf 5 9), e.g. in 7 17-24; 9 1—10 22; 16 1-55. HL Paul’s Previous Relations with Corinth.— When, in the course of his 2d missionary journey, Paul left Athens (Acts 18 1), he sailed 1. Corinth westward to Cenchreae, and entered in65AD Corinth “in weakness, and _ in fear, and in much trembling” (1 Cor 2 3). He was doubtless alone, although Silas and Timothy afterward joined him (Acts 18 5; 2 Cor 1 19). The ancient city of Corinth had been utterly laid in ruins when Rome subjugated Greece in the middle of the 2d cent. BC. But in the year 46 BC Caesar had caused it to be rebuilt and colonized in the Rom manner, and during the cent. that had elapsed it had prospered and grown enormously. Its population at this time has been estimated at between 600,00C and 700,000, by far the larger portion of whom were slaves. Its magnificent harbors, Cenchreae and Lechaeum, opening to the commerce of East and West, were crowded with ships, and its streets with travelers and merchants from almost every country under heaven. Even in that old pagan world the reputation of the city was bad; it has been compared (Baring-Gould, Study of St. Paul, 241) to an amalgam of New- market, Chicago and Paris, and probably it con- tained the worst features of each. At night it was made hideous by the brawls and lewd songs of drunken revelry. In the daytime its markets and squares swarmed with Jewish peddlers, foreign traders, sailors, soldiers, athletes in training, boxers, wrestlers, charioteers, racing-men, bettmg-men, courtesans, slaves, idlers and parasites of every description. The corrupting worship of Aphrodite, with its hordes of hieréddouloi, was dominant, and all over the Gr-Rom world, ‘‘to behave as a Corinthian” was a proverbial synonym for leading a low, shame- less and immoral life. Very naturally such a pol- luted and idolatrous environment accounts for much that has to be recorded of the semi-pagan and im- perfect life of many of the early converts. Paul was himself the founder of the church in Corinth (1 Cor 3 6.10). Entering the city with anxiety, and yet with almost auda- 2. Founding cious hopefulness, he determined to of the know nothing among its people save Church Jesus Christ and Him crucified (2 2). Undoubtedly be was conscious that the mission of the Cross here approached its crisis. If it could abide here, it could abide anywhere. At first he confined himself to working quietly at his trade, and cultivating the friendship of Aquila and Priscilla (Acts 18 Zf); then he opened his campaign in the synagogue where he persuaded both Jews and Greeks, and ultimately, when oppo- sition became violent, carried it on in the house of Titus Justus, a proselyte. He made deep impres- sions, and gradually gathered round him a number who were received into the faith (Acts 18 7.8; 1 Cor 1 14-16). The converts were drawn largely but not entirely from the lower or servile classes (1 26; 7 21); they included Crispus and Sosthenes, rulers of the synagogue, Gaius, and Stephanas with his household, ‘‘the firstfruits of Achaia’ (16 15). He regarded himself joyfully as the father of this community (4 14.15), every member of which seemed to him like bis own child. IV. Date of the Epistle.— After a sojourn of eighteen months (Acts 18 11) in this fruitful field, Paul departed, most probably in the year 52 (cf Turner, art. “Chron. NT,’ HDB, I, 422 ff), and, having visited Jerus and returned to Asia Minor (third journey), established himself for a period of between two and three years (érietia, Acts 20 31) in Ephesus (Acts 18 18 onward). It was during his stay there that his ep. was written, either in the spring (pre-Pentecost, 1 Cor 16 8) of the year in which he left, 55; or, if that does not give sufficient interval for a visit and a letter to Corinth, which there is considerable ground for believing inter- vened between 1 Cor and the departure from Ephesus, then in the spring of the preceding year, 54. This would give ample time for the conjectured events, and there is no insuperable reason against it. Pauline chronology is a subject by itself, but the suggested dates for the departure from Ephesus, and for the writing of 1 Cor, really fluctuate between the years 53 aud 57. Harnack (Gesch. der alt- christ. Litt., 11; Die Chron., I) and McGiffert (Apos Age) adopt the earlier date; Ramsay (St. Paul the Traveller), 56; Lightfoot (Bib. Essays) and Zahn (Hinl.), 57; Turner (ut supra), 55. Many regard 57 as too late, but Robertson (HDB, I, 485-86) still adheres to it. V. Occasion of the Epistle.—After Paul’s de- parture from Corinth, events moved rapidly, and far from satisfactorily. He was quite 1. APre- cognizant of them. The distance vious Letter from Ephesus was not great—about eight days’ journey by sea~and in the constant coming and going between the cities news of what was transpiring must frequently have come to his ears. Members of the household of Cor, ist Ep. to Chloe are distinctly mentioned (1 11) as having brought tidings of the contentions that prevailed, and there were no doubt other informants. Paul was so concerned by what he heard that he sent Timothy on a conciliatory mission with many commendations (417; 16 10f), although the present ep. probably reached Corinth first. He had also felt impelled, in a letter (5 9) which is now lost, to send earnest warning against companying with the immoral. Moreover, Apollos, after excellent work in Corinth, had come to Ephesus, and was received as a brother by the apostle (3 5.6; 16 12). Equally welcome was a deputa- tion consisting of Stephanas, Fortunatus and Achaicus (16 17), from whom the fullest informa- tion could be gained, and who were the probable bearers of a letter from the church of Corinth itself (7 1), appealing for advice and direc- 2. Letter tion on a number of points. This from letter has not been preserved, but it Corinth was evidently the immediate occasion of our ep., and its tenor is clearly mdi- cated by the nature of the apostle’s reply. (The letter, professing to be this letter to Paul, and its companion, professing to be Paul’s own lost letter just referred to, which deal with gnostic heresies, and were for long accepted by the Syrian and Ar- menian churches, are manifestly apocryphal. [Cf Stanley’s Corinthians, Appendix; Harnack’s Gesch. der altchrist. Litt., I, 37-39, and II, 506-8; Zahn, Hinl., 1, 183-249; Sanday, HB, I, 906-7.] If there be any relic in existence of Paul’s previous letter, it is possibly to be found in the passage 2 Cor 6 14— 7 1; at all events that passage may be regarded as reminiscent of its style and message.) So that 1 Cor is no bow drawn at a venture. It treats of a fully understood, and, on the whole, of a most unhappy situation. The church had broken into factions, and was distracted by party cries. Some of its members were living openly immoral lives, and dis- cipline was practically in abeyance. Others had quarrels over which they dragged one another into the heathen courts. Great differences of opinion had also arisen with regard to marriage and the social relations generally; with regard to banquets and the eating of food offered to idols; with regard to the behavior of women in the assemblies, to the Lord’s Supper and the love-feasts, to the use and value of spiritual gifts, and with regard to the hope of the resurrection. The apostle was filled with grief and indignation, which the too complacent tone of the Corinthians only intensified. They discussed questions in a lofty, intellectual way, without seem- ing to perceive their real drift, or the life and spirit which lay imperiled at their heart. Resisting the impulse to visit them “with a rod” (4 21), the apostle wrote the present ep., and dispatched it, if not by the hands of Stephanas and his comrades, most probably by the hands of Titus. VI. Contents of the Epistle.—In its general char- acter the ep. is a strenuous writing, masterly in its restraint in dealing with opposition 1. General firm in its grasp of ethical and spiritual Character principles, and wise and faithful in their application. Jt is calm, full of reasoning, clear and balanced in judgment; very varied in its lights and shadows, in its kindness, its gravity, its irony. It moves with firm tread among the commonest themes, but also rises easily into the loftiest spheres of thought and vision, breaking again and again into passages of glowing and rhythmical eloquence. It rebukes error, exposes and condemns sin, solves doubts, upholds and encourages faith, and all in a spirit of the utmost tenderness and love, full of grace and truth. It is broad in its outlook, penetrating in its insight, unending in its interest and application. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 714 It is also very orderly in its arrangement, so that - it is not difficult to follow the writer as he advances from point to point. Weizsacker 2. Order (Apos Age, J, 324-25) suggestively and distinguishes the matter into (1) sub- Division jects introduced by the letter from Corinth, and (2) those on which Paul had obtained information otherwise. He includes three main topics in the first class: marriage, meat offered to idols and spiritual gifts (there is a fourth —the logia or collection, 16 1); six in the second class: the factions, the case of incest, the lawsuits, the free customs of the women, the abuse connected with the Supper and the denial of the resurrection. It is useful, however, to adhere to the sequence of the ep. In broadly outlining the subject-matter we may make a threefold division: (1) chs 1-6; (2) chs 7-10; and (8) chs 11-end. . (1) Chs 1-6: After salutation, in which he asso- ciates Sosthenes with himself, and thanksgiving for the grace given to the Corinthians 3. Outline (1 1-9), Paul immediately begins (1 10-18) to refer to the internal divisions among them, and to the unworthy and misguided party cries that had arisen. (Many theories have been formed as to the exact signifi- cance of the so-called ‘‘Christus-party,” a party whose danger becomes more obvious in 2 Cor. Cf Meyer-Heinrici, Comm., 8th ed; Godet, Inéro, 250 ff; Stanley, Cor, 29-30; Farrar, St. Paul, ch xxxi; Pfleiderer, Paulinism, II, 28-31; _ Weiss, Intro, I, 259-65; Weizsacker, Apos Age, I, 325- 33, and 354 ff. Weizsacker holds that the name indicates exclusive relation to an authority, while Baur and Pfleiderer argue that it was a party watch- word [virtually Petrine] taken to bring out the apostolic inferiority of Paul. On the other hand a few scholars maintain that the name does not, strictly speaking, indicate a party at all but rather designates those who were disgusted at the display of all party spirit, and with whom Paul was in hearty sympathy. See McGiffert, Apos Age, 295-97.) After denouncing this petty partisan- ship, Paul offers an elaborate defence of his own ministry, declaring the power and wisdom of God in the gospel of the Cross (1 14—2 16), returning in ch 3 to the spirit of faction, showing its absurdity and narrowness in face of the fulness of the Chris- tian heritage in “all things” that belong to them as belonging to Christ; and once more defending his ministry in ch 4, making a touching appeal to his readers as his “‘beloved children,” whom he had begotten through the gospel. In ch 5 he deals with the case of a notorious offender, guilty of incest, whom they unworthily harbor in their midst and in the name of Christ demands that they should expel him from the church, pointing out at the same time that it is against the countenancing of immorality within the church membership that he specially warns, and had previously warned in his former ep. Ch 6 deals with the shamefulness of Christian brethren haling one another to the heathen courts, and not rather seeking the settle- ment of their differences within themselves; revert- ing once more in the closing vs to the subject of unchastity, which irrepressibly haunts him as he thinks of them. (2) Chs 7-10: In ch 7 he begins to reply to two of the matters on which the church had expressly consulted him in its ep., and which he usually in-~ duces by the phrase peri de, “now concerning.” | The first of these bears (ch 7) upon celibacy and marriage, including the case of “mixed” marriage. These questions he treats quite frankly, yet with delicacy and circumspection, always careful to dis- tinguish between what he has received as the direct word of the Lord, and what he only delivers as his 715 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cor, 1st Ep. to own opinion, the utterance of his own sanctified common-sense, yet to which the goad spirit within him gives weight. The second matter on which advice was solicited, questions regarding eidalé- thuta, meats offered to idols, he discusses in ch 8, recurring to it again in ch 10 toend. The scruples and casuistries involved he handles with excellent wisdom, and lays down a rule for the Christian conscience of a far-reaching kind, happily expressed: All things are lawful; but not all things are ex- pedient. All things are lawful; but not all things _edify. Let no man seck his own, but each his neigh- bor’s good” (10 23.24). By lifting their differences into the purer atmosphere of love and duty, he causes them to dissolve away. Ch 9 contains another notable defence of his apostleship, in which he asserts the principle that the Christian ministry has a claim for its support on those to whom it ministers, although in his own case he deliberately waived his right, that no challenge on such a matter should be possible among them. The earlier portion of ch 10 contains a reference to Jewish idolatry and sacramental abuse, in order that the evils that resulted might point a moral, and act as a solemn warning to Christians in relation to their own rites. (8) Chs 11-16: The third section deals with certain errors and defects that had crept into the inner life and observances of the church, also with further matters on which the Corinthians sought guidance, namely, spiritual gifts and the collection for the saints. Ch 11 1-16 has regard to the de- portment of women and their veiling in church, a matter which seems to have occasioned some diffi- culty, and which Paul deals with in a manner quite his own; passing thereafter to treat of graver and more disorderly affairs, gross abuses in the form of gluttony and drunkenness at the Lord’s Supper, which leads him, after severe censure, to make his classic reference to that sacred ordinance (vs 20 to end). Ch 12 sets forth the diversity, yet true unity, of spiritual gifts, and the confusion and jealousy to which a false conception of them inevi- tably leads, obscuring that “most excellent way,” the love which transcends them all, which never faileth, the greatest of the Christian graces, whose praise he chants in language of surpassing beauty (ch 13). He strives also, in the following chapter, to correct the disorder arising from the abuse of the gift of tongues, many desiring to speak at once, and many speaking only a vain babble which no one could understand, thinking themselves thereby highly gifted. It is not edifying: “I had rather,” he declares, ‘‘speak five words with my understand- ing, that I might instruct others also, than ten thousand words in a tongue” (14 19). Thereafter follows the immortal chapter on the resurrection, which he had learned that some denied (15 12). He anchors the faith to the resurrection of Christ as historic fact, abundantly attested (vs 3-8), shows how all-essential it is to the Christian hope (vs 13-19), and then proceeds by reasoning and analogy to brush aside certain naturalistic objec- tions to the great doctrine, “then they that are Christ’s, at his coming” (ver 23), when this mortal shall have put on immortality, and death be swal- lowed up in victory (ver 54). The closing chapter gives directions as to the collection for the saints in Jerus, on which his heart was deeply set, and in which he hoped the Corinthians would bear a worthy share. He promises to visit them, and even to tarry the winter with them. He then makes a series of tender personal references, and so brings the great ep. to a close. VII. Distinguishing Features.—It will be seen that there are passages in the ep. of great doctrinal and historical importance, esp. with reference to the Person of Christ, the Holy Spirit, the Euchar- ist and the Resurrection; also many that illuminate the nature of the religious meetings and services of the early church (ef particularly on thesc, Weiz- sacker, Apos Age, II, 246 ff). A lurid light is cast on many of the errors and evils that not unnaturally still clung to those who were just emerging from paganism, and much allowance has to be made for the Corinthian environment. The thoroughness with which the apostle pursues the difficulties raised into their relations and details, and the wide , scope of matters which he subjects to Christian | scrutiny and criterion, are also significant. Mani- festly he regarded the gospel as come to fill, not a part, but the whole, of life; to supply principles that follow the believers to their homes, to the most secluded sanctum there, out again to the world, to the market-place, the place of amusement, of temptation, of service, of trial, of worship and rayer; and all in harmony with knowing nothing ‘save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.” For Paul regards that not as a restriction, but as a large and expansive principle. He sets the cross on an emi- nence so high that its shadow covers the whole activities of human life. Three broad outstanding features of a practical kind may be recognized. The first is the earnest warning it conveys against a factious 1. The spirit as inimical to the Christian life. Party The Corinthians were imbued with Spirit the party spirit of Gr democracy, and were infected also by the sporting spirit of the great games that entered so largely into their existence. They transferred these things to the church. They listened to their teachers with itching ears, not as men who wished to learn, but as partisans who sought occasion either to applaud or to condemn. Paul recognizes that, though they are not dividing on deep things of the faith, they are giving way to “schisms” of a pettier and per- haps even more perilous kind, that appeal to the lowest elements in human nature, that cause scandal in the eyes of men and inflict grievous wounds on the Body of Christ. In combating this spirit he takes occasion to go below the surface, and to reveal the foundations of true Christian unity. That must simply be “in Christ.” And this is true even if the divergence should be on higher and graver things. Any unity in such a case, still possible to cherish, must be a unity in Christ. None can be unchurched who build on Him; none severed from the true and catholic faith, who confess with their lips and testify with their lives that He is Lord. The ep. also renders a high ethical service in the rules it lays down for the guidance of the Christian conscience. In matters where the 2. The issue is clearly one of the great im- Christian peratives, the conflict need never be Conscience protracted. An earnest man will sce his way. But beyond these, or not easily reducible to them, there are many matters that cause perplexity and doubt. Questions arise regarding things that do not seem to be wrong in themselves, yet whose abuse or the offence they give to others, may well canse debate. Meat offered to idols, and then bronght to table, was a stumbling-block to many Corinthian Christians. They said: “If we eat, it is consenting to idolatry; we dare not partake.’ But there were some who rose to a higher level. They perceived that this was a groundless scruple, for an idol is nothing at all, and the meat is not affected by the supersti- tion. Accordingly their higher and more rational view gave them liberty and left their conscience free. But was this really all that they had to con- sider? Some say: ‘Certainly’; and Paul ac- Cor, 1st Ep. to Cor, 2d Ep. to THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 716 knowledges that this is undoubtedly the law of individual freedom. But it is not the final answer. There has not entered into it a consideration of the mind of Christ. Christian liberty must be willing to subject itself to the law of love. Granted that a neighbor is often short-sighted and over-scrupulous, and that it would be good neither for him nor for others to suffer him to become a moral dictator; yet we are not quite relieved. The brother may be weak, but the very claim of his weakness may be strong. We may not ride over his scruples rough- shod. To do so would be to put ourselves wrong even more seriously. And if the matter is one that is manifestly fraught with peril to him, conscience may be roused to say, as the apostle says: ‘“‘Where- fore, if meat maketh my brother to stumble, I will eat no flesh for evermore.” A third notable feature of the ep. is its exalta- tion of the cross of Christ as the power and wisdom of God unto salvation. It was the 3. The force that began to move and unsettle, Power of _ to lift and change from its base, the the Cross __life of that old heathen world. It was neither Paul, nor Apollos, nor Cephas who accomplished that colossal task, but the preach- ing of the crucified Christ. The Christianity of Corinth and of Europe began with the gospel of Calvary and the open tomb. It can never with impunity draw away from these central facts. The river broadens and deepens as it flows, but it is never possible for it to sever itself from the living fountain from which it springs. Litsrature.—The following writers will be found most important and helpful: 1. On matters of introduction (both epp.): Holtzmann, Weiss, Hausrath, Harnack, Pfleiderer, Godet, Weizsicker, Jiilicher, Zahn, Salmon, Knowling, McGiffert, J. H. Kennedy, Ramsay, Sahatier, Farrar, Dohschiitz, Robert- son (HDB), Sanday (EB), Plummer (DB), Ropes (Ene Brit, 11th ed). 2. Commentaries and lectures (on 1 Cor or both): Meyer- Heinrici, Godet, T. C. Edwards, Hodge, Beet, Ellicott, Schmiedel (Hand-Comm.), Evans (Speakers’ Comm.), Farrar (Pulpit Comm.), Lightfoot (chs i-vii_in Bib. Ess.), Lias (Cambr. Gr Test.), McFadyen, F. W. Robertson, Findlay (Expos. Gr Test.); and on 2 Cor alone: Klépper, Waite (Sneakers Comm.), Denney (Expos. Bible), Bernard (Expos. 'r Test.). 3. For ancient writers and special articles, the list at close of Plummer’s art. in DB should be consulted. R. Dyxes Suaw CORINTHIANS, SECOND EPISTLE TO THE: I. Text, AUTHENTICITY AND Dats 1. Internal Evidence 2. External Evidence 3. Date II. Résumé or Events Ill. Tas New Situation 1. The Offender 2. The False Teachers 3. The Painful Visit 4. The Severe Letter IV. Hisroricat Reconstruction V. INTEGRITY OF THE EPisTLe 1. Ch 6 14— 2. Ch 10 1—13 10 VI. Contents or THe EpisTLe 1. Chs 1-7 2. Chs 8-9 3. Chs 10-13 VII. Vaxus or tas EpisTLe LITERATURE I. Text, Authenticity and Date.—Cf what has already been said in the preceding art. In the two important 5th-cent. uncials, A (Alex.) 1. Internal and C (Ephraemi), portions of the Evidence _text are lacking. As to the genuine- ness internal evidence very vividly attests it. The distinctive elements of Pauline theology and eschatology, expressed in familiar Pauline terms, are manifest throughout. Yet the ep. is not doctrinal or didactic, but an intensely personal document. Its absorbing intcrest is in events which were profoundly agitating Paul and the Corinthians at the time, straining their rela- tions to the point of rupture, and demanding strong action on Paul’s part. Our imperfect knowledge of the circumstances necessarily hinders a complete comprehension, but the references to these events and to others in the personal history of the apostle are so natural, and so manifestly made in good faith, that no doubt rises in the reader’s mind but that he is in the sphere of reality, and that the voice he hears is the voice of the man whose heart and nerves were being torn by the experiences through which he was passing. Tlowever scholars may differ as to the continuity and integrity of the text, there is no serious divergence among them in the opinion that all parts of the ep. are genuine writings of the apostle. y Externally, the testimony of the sub-apostolic age, though not so frequent or precise as in the case of 1 Cor, is still sufficiently clear 2. External to establish the existence and use of Evidence the ep. in the 2d cent. Clement of Rome is silent when he might rather have heen expected to use the ep. (cf Kennedy, Second and Third Cor, 142 ff); but it is quoted by Polycarp (Ad Phil., ii.4 and vi.1), and in the Epistle to Diognetus 5 12, while it is amply at- tested to by Irenaeus, Athenagoras, Theophilus, Tertullian and Clement of Alexandria. It was written from Macedonia (probably 3. Date from Philippi) either in the autumn of the same year as that in which 1 Cor was written, 54 or 55 AD, or in the autumn of the succeeding year. HT, Résumé of Events.—Great difficulty exists as to the circumstances in which the ep. was written, and as to the whole situation between 1 and 2 Cor. In 1 Cor Paul had intimated his intention of visiting the Corinthians and wintering with them, coming to them through Macedonia (16 5-7; cf also Acts 19 21). In 2 Cor 1 15.16 he refers to a somewhat different plan, Corinth-Macedonia—Corinth—Judaea; and describes this return from Macedonia to Cor- inth as a second or double benefit. But if this plan, on which he and his friends had counted, had not been entirely carried out, it had been for good reason (1 17), and not due to mere fickleness or light-hearted change to suit his own convenience. It was because he would ‘‘spare” them (1 23), and not come to them “again with sorrow” (2 1). That is, he had been with them, but there had been such a profound disturbance in their relations that he dared not risk a return meantime; instead, he had written a letter to probe and test them, “out of much affliction and anguish of heart ... . with many tears’ (2 4). Thank God, this severe letter had accomplished its mission. It had produced sorrow among them (2 2; 7 8.9), but it had brought their hearts back to him with the old allegiance, with great clearing of themselves, and fear: and longing and zeal (7 11). There was a period, however, of waiting for knowledge of this issue, which was to him a period of intense anxiety; he had even ner- vously regretted that he had written as he did (7 5-8). ‘Titus, who had gone as his representative to Corinth, was to return with a report of how this severe letter had been received, and when Titus failed to meet. him at Troas (2 13), he had “no relief for his spirit,” but pushed on eagerly to Mace- donia to encounter him the sooner. Then came the answer, and the lifting of the intolerable burden from his mind. “He that comforteth the lowly, even God, comforted” him (7 6). The Corinthians had been swayed by a godly sorrow and repentance (7 8), and thesky had clearcd again with almost un- hoped-for brightness. Oue who had offended (2 5 and 7 12)—but whose offence is not distinctly speci- fied—had been disciplined by the church; indeed, in the revulsion of feeling against him, and in sym- 717 pathy for the apostle, he had been punished so heavily that there was a danger of passing to an extreme, and plunging him into despair (2 7). Paul accordingly pleads for leniency and forgive- ness, lest further resentment should lead only to a further and sadder wrong (2 6-11). But in addi- tion to this offender there were others, probably following in his train, who had carried on a relent- less attack against the apostle both in his person and in his doctrine. He earnestly defends himself against their contemptuous charges of fleshliness and cowardice (ch 10), and crafty venality (12 16.17). Another Jesus is preached, a different spirit, a different gospel (11 4). They “commend themselves” (10 12), but are false apostles, deceit- ful workers, ministers of Satan, fashioning them- selves into ministers of Christ (11 13.14). Their attacks are vehemently repelled in an eloquent apologia (chs 11 and 12), and he declares that when he comes the third time they will not be spared (13 2). - Titus, accompanied by other well-known brethren, is again to be the representative of the apostle (8 6.17 ff). At no great interval Paul himself followed, thus making his third visit (12 14; 13 1), and so far fulfilled his original purpose that he spent the winter peacefully in Corinth (cf Acts 20 2.3; Rom 15 25-27 and 16 28). HI. The New Situation.—It is manifest that we are in the presence of a new and unexpected situ- ation, whose development is not clearly defined, and concerning which we have elsewhere no source of information. To elucidate it, the chief points requiring attention are: (1) The references to the offender in chs 2 and 7, and to the false teachers, particularly in the later chapters of the ep.; (2) the painful visit implicitly referred to in 2 1; and (8) the letter described as written in tears and for a time regretted (2 4; 7 8). The offender in 1 Cor 5 1-5 had been guilty of incest, and Paul was grieved that the church of Corinth did not regard with horror 1. The a crime which even the pagan world Offender would not have tolerated. His judg- ment on the case was uncompromising and the severest possible—that, in solemn assembly, in the name and with the power of the Lord Jesus, the church should deliver such a one to Satan for the destruction of the flesh. On the other hand, the offender in 2 Cor 2 5 ff is one who ob- viously has transgressed less heinously, and in a way more personal to the apostle. The church, roused by the apostle to show whether they indeed cared for him and stood by him (2 9; 13 7), had, by a majority, brought censure to bear on this man, and Paul now urged that matters should go no farther, lest an excess of discipline should really end in a triumph of Satan. It is not possible to regard such references as applying to the crime dealt with in 1 Cor. Purposely veiled as the state- ments are, it would yet appear that a personal attack had been made on the apostle; and the “many” in Corinth (2 6), having at length es- poused his cause, Paul then deals with the matter in the generous spirit he might have been expected to display. Even if the offender were the same person, which is most improbable, for he can scarce- ly have been retained in the membership, the lan- guage is not language that could have been applied to the earlier case. There has been a new offence in new circumstances. The apostle had been grievously wronged in the presence of the church, and the Corinthians had not spontaneously re- sented the wrong. That is what wounded the apostle most deeply, and it is to secure their change in this respect that is his gravest concern. Esp. in the later chs of 2 Cor there are, as we have seen, descriptions of an opposition by false THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cer Ist Ep. to Cor, 2d Ep. to teachers that is far beyond anything met with in 1 Cor. There indeed we have a spirit of fac- tion, associated with unworthy par- 2. The tiality toward individual preachers, False but nothing to lead us to suspect the Teachers _ presence of deep and radical differences undermining the gospel. The general consensus of opinion is that this opposition was of a Judaizing type, organized and fostered by implacable anti-Panline emissaries from Pal, who now followed the track of the apostle in Achaia as they did in Galatia. As they arrogated to them- selves a peculiar relation to Christ Himself (‘‘Christ’s men” and ‘ministers of Christ,” 10 7; 11 13), it is possible that the Christus-party of 1 Cor (and possibly the Cephas-party) may have persisted and formed the nucleus round which these new- comers built up their formidable opposition. One man seems to have been conspicuous as their ring- leader (10 7.11), and to have made himself specially obnoxious to the apostle. In all probability we may take it that he was the offender of chs 2 and 7. Under his influence the opposition audaciously endeavored to destroy the gospel of grace by per- sonal attacks upon its most distinguished exponent. Paul was denounced as an upstart and self-seeker, destitute of any apostolic authority, and derided for the contemptible appearance he made in person, in contrast with the swelling words and presump- tuous claims of his epp. It is clear, therefore, that a profound religious crisis had arisen among the Corinthians, and that there was a danger of their attachment to Paul and his doctrine being destroyed. 2 Cor 12 14 and 13 1.2 speak of a third visit in immediate prospect, and the latter passage also refers to a second visit that had been 3. The already accomplished; while 2 1 dis- Painful tinctly implies that a visit had taken Visit place of a character so painful that the apostle would never venture to endure a similar one. As this cannot possibly refer to the first visit when the church was founded, and cannot easily be regarded as indicating anything previous to 1 Cor which never alludes to such an experience, we must conclude that the reference points to the interval between 1 and 2 Cor. It was then beyond doubt that the visit “‘with sorrow,” which humbled him (12 21) and left such deep wounds, had actually taken place. “Any exegesis,” says Weizsacker justly, “that would avoid the con- clusion that Paul had already been twice in Corinth is capricious and artificial” (A postolie Age, 1, 343). Sabatier (Apostle Paul, 172 n.) records his revised opinion: “‘The reference here (2 1) is to a second and quite recent visit, of which he retained a very sorrowful recollection, including it among the most bitter trials of his apostolical career.” Paul not only speaks of a visit which had ended grievously, but also of a letter which he had written to deal with the painful circumstances, 4. The and as a kind of ultimatum to bring the Severe whole matter to an issue (2 4; 7 8). Letter This letter was written because he could not trust himself meantime to another visit. He was so distressed and agitated that he wrote it “with many tears’; after it was written he repented of it; and until he knew its effect he endured torture so keen that he hastened to Macedonia to meet his messenger, Titus, half- way. It is impossible by any stretch of interpre- tation to refer this language to 1 Cor, which on the whole is dominated by a spirit of didactic calm, and by a consciousness of friendly rapport with its recipients. Even though there be in it occasional indications of strong feeling, there is certainly nothing that we can conceive the apostle might have wished to recall. The alternative has gen- Cor, 2d Ep. to THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 718 erally been to regard this as another case of a lost ep. Just as the writer of Acts appears to have been willing that the deplorable visit itself should drop into oblivion, so doubtless neither Paul nor the Corinthians would be very anxious to preserve an ep. which echoed with the gusts and storms of such a visit. On the other hand a strong tendency has set in to regard this intermediate ep. as at least in part preserved in 2 Cor 10-13, whose tone, it is universally admitted, differs from that of the preceding chapters in a remarkable way, not easily accounted for. The majority of recent writers seem inclined to favor this view, which will naturally fall to be considered under the head of “Integrity.” IV. Historical Reconstruction.—In view of such an interpretation, we may with considerable proba- bility trace the course of events in the interval between 1 and 2 Cor as follows: After the dis- patch of 1 Cor, news reached the apostle of a disquieting character; probably both Titus and Timothy, on returning from Corinth, reported the growing menace of the opposition fostered by the Judaizing party. Paul felt impelled to pay an immediate visit, and found only too sadly that matters had not been overstated. The opposition was strong and full of effrontery, and the whole trend of things was against him. In face of the congregation he was baffled and flouted. He returned to Ephesus, and poured out his indigna- tion in a severe ep., which he sent on by the hands of Titus. Before Titus could return, events took a disastrous form in Ephesus, and Paul was forced to leave that city in peril of his life. He went to Troas, but, unable to wait patiently there for tidings of the issue in Corinth, he crossed to Mace- donia, and met Titus, possibly in Philippi. The report was happily reassuring; the majority of the congregation returned to their old attachment, and the heavy cloud of doubt and anxiety was dispelled from the apostle’s mind. He then wrote again— the present ep.—and forwarded it by Titus and other brethren, he himself following a little later, and finally wintering in Corinth as he had originally planned. If it be felt that the interval between spring and autumn of the same year is too brief for these events, the two epp. must be separated by a period of nearly 18 months, 1 Cor being referred to the spring of 54 or 55, and 2 Cor to the autumn of 55 or 56 AD. (Reference on the reconstruction should esp. be made to Weizsiacker’s Apostolic Age Eng. tr, I; to Sabatier’s Note to the Eng. ed 11893] of his Apostle Paul; and to Robertson’s art. in HDB.) V. Integrity of the Epistle.— Although the genu- ineness of the various parts of the ep. is scarcely disputed, the homogeneity is much debated. Sem- ler and some later writers, including Clemen (Einheitlichkeit), have thought that ch 9 should be eliminated as logically inconsistent with ch 8, and as evidently forming part of a letter to the con- verts of Achaia. But the connection with ch 8 is too close to permit of severance, and the logical objection, founded on the phraseology of 9 1, is generally regarded as hypercritical. There are two sections, however, whose right to remain integral parts of 2 Cor has been more forcibly challenged. The passage 6 14 to 7 1 deals with the incon- sistency and peril of intimate relations with the heathen, and is felt to be incongruous 1. Ch 6:14 with the context. No doubt it comes —7:1 strangely after an appeal to the Cor- inthians to show the apostle the same frankness and kindness that he is showing them; whereas 7 2 follows naturally and links itself closely to such an appeal. When we remember that the particular theme of the lost letter referred to in 1 Cor 5 9 was the relation of the converts to the immoral, it is by no means unlikely that we have here preserved a stray fragment of that ep. It is universally acknowledged that there is a remarkable change in the tone of the section 10 1— 13 10, as compared with that of the 2. Ch 10: previous chs. In the earlier chs there 1—138:10 is relief at the change which Titus has reported as having taken place in Corinth, and the spirit is one of gladness and con- tent; but from ch 10 onward the hostility to the apostle is unexpectedly represented as still raging, and as demanding the most strenuous treatment. The opening phrase, ‘(Now I Paul” (10 1), is re- garded as indicating a distinctive break from the previous section with which Timothy is associated (1 1), while the concluding vs, 13 11 to end, seem fittingly to close that section, but to be abruptly out of harmony with the polemic that ends at 13 10. Accordingly it is suggested that 13 11 should immediately follow 9 15, and that 10 1— 13 10 be regarded as a lengthy insertion from some other ep. Those who, while acknowledging the change of tone, yet maintain the integrity of the ep., do so on the ground that the apostle was a man of many moods, and that it is characteristic of him to make unexpected and even violent transitions; that new reports of a merely scotched antagonism may come in to ruffle and disturb his comparative contentment; and that in any case he might well deem it advisable finally to deliver his whole soul on a matter over which he had brooded and suffered deeply, so that there might be no mistake about the ground being cleared when he arrived in person. - The question is still a subject of keen discussion, and is not one on which it is easy to pronounce dogmatically. On the whole, however, it must be acknowledged that the preponderance of recent opinion is in favor of the theory of interpolation. Hausrath (Der Vier-Capitel-Brief des Paulus an die Korinther, 1870) gave an immense impetus to the view that this later section really represents the painful letter referred to in chs 2 and 7. As that earlier letter, however, must have contained references to the personal offender, the present section, which omits all such references, can be regarded as at most only a part of it. This theory is ably and minutely expounded by Schmiedel (Hand-Kommentar) ; and Pfleiderer, Lipsius, Clemen, Krenkel, von Soden, McGiffert, Cone, Plummer, Rendall, Moffatt, Adeney, Peake, and Massie are prominent among its adherents. J. H. Kennedy, (Second and Third Cor) presents perhaps the ablest and fullest argument for it that has yet appeared in English. On the other hand Sanday (#B) declares against it, and Robertson (HDB) regards it as decidedly not proven; while critics of such weight as Holtzmann, Beyschlag, Klépper, Weiz- sicker, Sabatier, Godet, Bernard, Denney, Weiss, and Zahn are all to be reckoned as advocates of the integrity of the ep. VI. Contents of the Epistle.— The order of matter in the ep. is quite clearly defined. There are three main divisions: (1) chs 1-7; (2) chs 8-9; and (3) chs 10-13. The first seven chapters as a whole are taken up with a retrospect of the events that have recently transpired, joyful references to the 1. Chs 1-7 fact that the clouds of grief in connec- tion with them have been dispelled, and that the evangelical ministry as a Divine trust and power is clearly manifested. After a cordial salutation, in which Timothy is associated, Paul starts at once to express his profound gratitude to God for the great comfort that had come to him by the good news from Corinth, rejoicing in it as a spiritual enrichment that will make his ministry 719 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cor, 2d Ep. to still more fruitful to the church (1 3-11). He professes his sincerity in all his relations with the Corinthians, and particularly vindicates it in con- nection with a change in the plan which had origi- nally promised a return (‘‘a second benefit’’) to Corinth; his sole reason for refraining, and for writing a painful letter instead, being his desire to spare them and to prove them (1 12; 2 4.9). Far from harboring any reséntment against the man who had caused so much trouble, he sincerely pleads that his punishment by the majority should Bo no farther, but that forgiveness should now reign, est the Adversary should gain an advantage over them (2 5-11). It was indeed an agonizing experi- ence until the moment he met Titus, but the relief was all the sweeter and more triumphant when God at length gave it, as he might have been sure He would give it to a faithful and soul-winnin servant of Christ (2 12-17). He does not indee wish to enter upon any further apologies or self- commendation. Some believe greatly in letters of commendation, but his living testimonial is in his converts. This he has, not of himself, but entirely through God, who alone has made him an efficient minister of the new and abiding covenant of the Spirit, whose glory naturally excels that of the old dispensation which fadeth because it really cannot bring life. Regarding this glorious ministry he must be bold and frank. It needs no veil as if to conceal its evanescence. Christ presents it unveiled to all who turn to Him, and they them- selves, reflecting His glory, are spiritually trans- formed (8 1-18). As for those who by God’s mercy have received such a gospel ministry, it is impossible for them to be faint-hearted in its exercise, although the eyes of some may be blinded to it, because the god of this world enslaves them (4 4). It is indeed wonderful that ministers of this grace should be creatures so frail, so subject to pressure and affliction, but it is not inexplicable. So much the more obvious is it that all the power and glory of salvation are from God alone (4 7.15). Yea, even if one be called to die in this ministry, that is but another light and momentary affliction. It is but passing from a frail earthly tent to abide forever in a heavenly home (6 1). Who would not long for it, that this mortal may be swallowed up in immortality? Courage, therefore, is ours to the end, for that end only means the cessation of our separation from Christ, whom it is a joy to serve absent or present. And present we shail all ultimately be before Him on the judgment throne (6 10). That itself unspeakably deepens the earnestness with which preachers of the gospel seek to persuade men. It is the love of Christ constrain- ing them (5 14) in the ministry of reconciliation, that they should entreat men as ambassadors on Christ’s behalf (6 20). So sacred and responsible a trust has subdued the apostle’s own life, and is indeed the key to its manifold endurance, and _to the earnestness with which he has striven to culti- vate every grace, and to submit himself to every discipline (6 1-10). Would God the Corinthians might open their hearts to him as he does to them! (Let them have no fellowship with iniquity, but perfect holiness in the fear of God [6 14—7 ]].) He has never wronged them; they are enshrined in his heart, living or dying; he glories in them, and is filled with comfort in all his affliction (6 11-13; 7 2-4). For what blessed comfort that was that Titus brought him in Macedonia to dispel his fears, and to show that the things he regretted and grieved to have written had done no harm after all, but had rather wrought in them the joyful change for which he longed! Now both they and he knew how dear he was to them. Titus, too, was overjoyed by the magnanimity of their reception of him. The apostle’s cup is full, and “in every- thing he is of good courage concerning them” (7 16). In the second section, chs 8-9, the apostle, now abundantly confident of their good-will, exhorts the Corinthians on the subject of the col- 2. Chs 8-9 lection for the poor saints at Jerus. He tells them of the extraordinary liberality of the Macedonian churches, and invites them to emulate it, and by the display of this addi- tional grace to make full proof of their love (8 1-8). Nay, they have a higher incentive than the liber- ality of Macedonia, even the self-sacrifice of Christ Himself (8 9). Wherefore let them go on with the good work they were so ready to initiate a year ago, giving out of a willing mind, as God hath enabled them (8 10-15). Further to encourage them he sends on Titus and other well-known and accredited brethren, whose intcrest in them is as great as his own, and he is hopeful that by their aid the matter will be completed, and all will rejoice when he comes, bringing with him probably some of those of Macedonia, to whom he has already been boasting of their zeal (8 16—-9 5). Above all, let them remember that important issues are bound up with this grace of Christian liberality. It is impos- sible to reap bountifully, if we sow sparingly. Grudging and compulsory benevolence is a contra- diction, but God loveth and rewardeth a cheerful giver. This grace blesseth him that gives and him that takes. Many great ends are served byit. The wants of the needy are supplied, men’s hearts are drawn affectionately to one another, thanksgivings abound, and God himself is glorified (9 6-15). The third section, chs 10-13, as has been pointed out, is a spirited and even passionate polemic, in the course of which the Judaizing 3. Chs 10— party in Corinth is vigorously assailed. 13 The enemies of the apostle have charged him with being very bold and courageous when he is absent, but humble enough when he is present. He hopes the Corinthians will not compel him to show his courage (10 2). It is true, being human, he walks in the flesh, but not in the selfish and cowardly way his opponents suggest. The weapons of his warfare are not car- nal, yet are they mighty before God to cast down such strongholds as theirs, such vain imaginations and disobedience. Some boast of being “‘Christ’s,” but that is no monopoly; he also is Christ’s. They think his letters are mere ‘“‘sound and fury, signify-~ ing nothing”; by and by they will discover their mistake. If he should glory in his authority, he is justified, for Corinth was verily part of his God- appointed province, and he at least did not there enter on other men’s labors. But it would be well if men who gloried confined themselves to glory- ing ‘in the Lord.” For after all it is His com- mendation alone that is of any permanent value (10 3-18). Will the Corinthians bear with him in a little of this foolish boasting? Truly he ven- tures on it out of concern for them (11 2). And as they are manifest adepts in toleration, abounding in patience toward those who have come with a different gospel, they may perhaps extend some of their indulgence to him, for though he cannot lay claim to a polished oratory comparable to that of these “super-eminent”’ apostles, yet at least he is not behind them in knowledge (11 4-6). Can it be that he really sinned in preaching the gospel to them without fee or reward? Was it a mark of fleshly cunning when he resolved not to be burden- some to them, while he accepted supplies from Macedonia? Ah! it was not because he did not love them, but because he decided to give no occasion to those who were too ready to blame him—those false apostles, who, like Satan himself, masquer- aded as angels of light and ministers of righteous- Cor, 2d Ep. ta Corner-stone THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 720 ness (11 7-15). Come, then, let him to this glorying, this poor folly, which they in their super- lative wisdom bear with so gladly in the case of those insolent creatures who now bully and degrade them (11 16-21). Hebrews! Israelites! So is he. Ministers of Christ! There he excels them— in labors, in perils, m persecutions; in burdens, anxieties, sympathies; in visions and revelations of the Lord; in infirmities and weaknesses that have made more manifest in him the strength of Christ (11 22—12 10). Certainly all this is folly, but they are most to blame for it who, through lack of loyalty, have forced him to it. Did he injure them by declining to be burdensome? Is it so sore a point? Let it be forgiven! Yet when he comes again he will take no other course (12 11-18). They must not imagine that in all this he is ex- cusing himself to them. He is sincerely and affectionately concerning himself for their edifying. He trembles lest when they meet again they should he disappointed in each other; lest they should he found in unworthy strife and tumults, and lest he should be humbled of God before them, having cause to mourn over some who are hardened and impenitent in their sins (12 19-21). For they must mect again—he is coming for the third time—and this time he will not spare. Let them prove them- selves whether they be in the faith; for surely they must know whether Christ beinthem. Heearnestly prays for their goodness and honor; not to the end that no display of his power may be called for, but simply that he will be glad to appear weak if they should appear strong. Could they but helieve it, their perfecting is the aim of all his labors (13 1-10). And so, with words of grace and tenderness, exhorting them to unity and peace, and pronouncing over them the threefold benediction, he bids them farewell (13 11-14). VII. Value of the Epistle.—The chief element of value in this ep. is the revelation it gives of the apostle himself. Through all its changing moods, Paul, in perfect abandon, shows us his very soul, suffering, rejoicing, enduring, overcoming. It has been truly said that ‘it enables us, as it were, to lay our hands upon his breast, and feel the very throbbings of his heart.” (1) In relation to his converts, it shows us how sensitive he was, how easy it was to touch him on the quick, and to wound his feelings. The apostle was very human, and nowhere are his kindred limitations more obvious than in these present incidents. He would prob- ably be the first to acquiesce, if it were said that even with him the creed was greater than the life. In the hastily written and nervously repented passages of that severe ep.; in the restless wander- ing, lke a perturbed spirit, from Troas to Mace- donia, to meet the news and know the issue of his acts, we see a man most lovable indeed, most like ourselves when issues hang in the balance, but a man not already perfect, not yet risen to the measure of the stature of Christ. Yet we see also the in- tensity with which Paul labored in his ministry— the tenacity with which he held to his mission, and the invincible courage with which he returned to the fight for his imperiled church. He loved those converts as only a great soul in Christ could love them. His keenest sorrow came in the disaster that threatened them, and he flew to their defence. He had not only won them for Christ, he was will- ing to die that he might keep them for Christ. (2) The ep. is charged with a magnificent conscious- ness on the apostle’s part of his high calling in Christ Jesus. He has heen called with a Divine calling to the most glorious work in which a man can eugage, to be to this estranged earth an am- bassador of heaven. Received as Divine, this voca- tion is accepted with supremedevotion. IJt has been a ministry of sorrow, of strain and suffering, of hair- breadth escapes with the bare life; with its thorn in the flesh, its buffeting of Satan. Yet through it all there rings the note of abounding consolation in Christ Jesus, and never was the ‘power of Christ, resting on frail humanity, more signally manifested. Lirrraturse.—See the references to both epp.. and to 2 Cor alone, under this heading in the preceding art. To the list there given should be added Moffatt's Introduction to the Literature of the NT, 1911; valuable for its critical resentation of recent views, and for its references to the iterature. CORINTHUS, ké-rin’thus: Kérinthos in the subscription to Rom (AV). Corinvu. CORMORANT, kér'mé-rant (920, shalakh; karapdkrns, katardkt@s; Lat Corvus marinus): A large sea-fowl helonging to the genus Phalac- rocoraz and well described by the Heb word used to designate it—which means a “plunging hird.” The hird appears as large as a goose when in full feather, but plucked, the body is much smaller. The adult birds are glossy black with bronze tints, touched with white on the cheeks and sides as a festal dress at mating season, and adorned with R. Dyrxes SHaw Lat form for Gr See Cormorant (Phalacrocoraz carbo). filamentary feathers on the head, and bright yellow gape. These birds if taken young and carefully trained can be sent into the water from boats aud bring to their masters large quantities of good- sized fish: commonly so used in China. The flesh is dark, tough and quite unfit to eat in the elders on account of their diet of fish. The nest. is built mostly of seaweed. The eggs are small for the size of the birds, having a rough, thick, but rather soft shell of a bluish white which soon be- comes soiled, as well as the nest and its immediate surroundings, from the habits of the birds. 'The young are leathery black, then covered with soft down of brownish black above and white beneath and taking on the full black of the grown bird at about three years. If taken in the squab state the young are said to be delicious food, resembling haked hare in flavor. The old birds are mentioned among the abominations for food (Lev 11 13-19; Dt 14 12-18). Gens Srratron-PorTEeR CORN, kérn (33%, daghan; olros, sttos): A word used for cereals generally (Gen 27 28.37, etc, AV) much as our Eng. word “corn.” ARV almost invariably substitutes “grain” for “corn.” The latter may be taken to include (1) barley, (2) wheat, (8) fitches (vetches), (4) lentils, (5) beans, (6) mil- let, (7) rye—the wrong tr for vetches, (8) pulse— for all these see separate articles. Rye and oats are not cultivated in Pal. For many references to corn see AGRICULTURE; Foop. “A corn [kéxxos, kék- bes RV “grain”] of wheat” is mentioned (Jn 12 721 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cor, 2d Ep. to Corner-stone CORNELIUS, kor-né'li-us (Kepvq\ves, Korné- lios, ‘of a horn’): The story of Cornelius is given ; in Acts 10 I—11 18. The name is 1. His Rom and belonged to distinguished Family and familics in the imperial city, such as Station the Scipios and Sulla. Thus he was : probably an Italian of Rom blood. Julian the Apostate reckons him as one of the few persons of distinction who became a Christian. He was evidently a man of importance in Caesarea and well known to the Jews (Acts 10 22). He was a centurion in the Italian cohort. To under- stand this we must note that the Rom army was divided into two broad divisions, the legions and the auxiliary forces. See Army, Roman. Legions were never permanently quartered in Pal until the great war which ended in the destruction of Jerus, 70 AD. From the year 6 AD, when Pal was made into a province of the second rank, until 66 AD, it was gar- risoned by auxiliary roo re recruited amongst the Samar- itans and Syrian Greeks. The headquarters were naturally at Caesarea, the residence of the procurator. But it would not have heen prudent for a garrison in Pal to be composed wholly of troops locally recruited. Therefore the Rom government mingled with the garrison 600 soldiers, free Italian volunteers. With this cohort Cor- nelius was connected as centurion. He is described as devout and God-fearing, i.e. at least, one of those men so numerous in that effete age of decadent heathenism who, dis- 2. His contented with polytheism, yearned Character for a better faith, embraced, there- fore, the monotheism of the Jews, read the Scriptures, and practised more or less of the Jewish rites. He was well reported of by the Jews, and his religion showed itself in prayer at the regular hours, and in alms to the people (of Israel). Even Jewish bigotry was dumb in pres- ence of so noble 2 man. Moreover, he seems to have made his house a sort of church, for his kins- folk and friends were in sympathy with him, and among the soldiers who closely attended him were some devout ones (Acts 10 1.27). The story of his conversion and admission into the Christian ehurch is told with some minuteness in Acts 10. Nothing further is known 3. His Ad- of Cornelius, though one tradition as- mission into serts that he founded the church in the Chris- Caesarea, and another legend that he tian Church became the bishop of Scamandros. The exact importance of the incident depends upon the position of Cornelius before it oc- curred. Certainly he was not a proselyte of the sanctuary, circumcised, under the law, 4. Signifi- a member of the Jewish communion. cance of the This is abundantly evident from Acts Incident 10 28.34.45; 11 3.18; 15 7.14. But was he not an inferior form of proselyte, later called ‘“proselytes of the gate”? This question has been much debated and is still under discussion. Ramsay (St. Paul the Traveller, 48) says that the expression, ‘‘God-fearing,”’ applied to him, is always used in Acts with reference to this kind of prose- lytes. Such were bound to observe certain regu- lations of purity, probably those, this author thinks, mentioned in Acts 15 29, and which stand in close relation to the principles laid down in Lev 17-18 for the conduct of strangers dwelling among Israel. Renan, on the other hand, denies that Cornelius was a proselyte at all, but simply a devout Gentile who adopted some of the Jewish ideas and religious customs which did not involve a special profession. The importance of the whole transaction to the development of the church seems to depend on the circumstance that Cornelius was probably not a proselyte at all. Thus we regard Cornelius as lit. the first-fruits of the Gentiles. The step here taken by Peter was therefore one of tremendous importance to the whole development of the church. The significance of the incident consists exactly in this, that under Divine direc- tion, the first Gentile, not at all belonging to the old theocracy, becomes a Spirit-filled Christian, enter- ing through the front door of the Christian church without first going through the narrow gate of Judaism. The incident settled forever the great, fundamental question as to the relations of Jew and Gentile in the church. The difficulties in the way of the complete triumph of Peter’s view of the equality of Jews and Gentiles in the Kingdom of Christ were enormous. It would have been indeed little short of miraculous if the multitude of Chris- tian Pharisees had not raised the question again and again. Did they not dog Paul’s steps after the Council? Certainly Ramsay is wrong in say- ing that the case of Cornelius was passed over or condoned as exceptional, for it was used as a prece- dent by both Peter and James (Acts 15 7.14). As for Peter’s subsequent conduct at Antioch, no one who knows Peter need be surprised at it. The very accusation that Paul hurled at him was that for the moment he was carried into incon- sistency with his principles (hupékrisis). Of course, this incident of Cornelius was only the first step in a long development; but the principle was forever settled. The rest in due time and proper order was sure to follow. By this tremendous innova- tion it was settled that Christianity was to be freed from the swaddling bands of Judaism and that the Christian church was not to be an appendix to the synagogue. The noble character of Cornelius was just fitted to abate, as far as possible, the preju- dices of the Jewish Christians against what must have seemed to them a dangerous, if not awful, innovation. G. H. Trever CORNER, kér’nér (PUEP'A, mikco™, TRB, pe’ ah TBD, pinnadh; apxt, arché, yevla, gonia, axpo- yoviatos, akrogoniatos): In Ex 26 24; Ezk 41 22; 46 21.22, miked, “angle” is tr? ‘corner’; pe'ah, “side,” “quarter,” and pinnah, “corner,” “front,” “chief,” are more frequently so tr, e.g. Ex 25 26; Lev 19 9; Jer 9 26; 26 23; and Ex 27 2; 1 K 7 34; Ps 118 22; Isa 28 16 (“corner- stone”); Jer 51 26. Other words are kéndaph, “wing” (Isa 11 12; Ezk 7 2); kathéph, “shoul- der” (2 K 11 11 AV bis); pa‘tam, “foot” (Ex 26 12 AV); zdwiydth, “corner-stones” (Ps 144 12; Zee 9 15 [tré “‘corners’’]). For “corner” RV has “side” (Ex 36 25), “cor- ner-stone’”’ (Zec 10 4), also for “stay” (Isa 19 13); instead of “teacher removed into a corner” (Isa 30 20), ‘be hidden,” ‘“‘hide themselves”; for ‘‘corners” we have “feet”? (Ex 26 12; 1 K 7 30); “ribs” (Ex 30 4; 87 27); for “‘divideinto corners’ (Neh 9 22), “allot after their portions’; for ‘‘into corners” (Dt 32 26), “afar’; the words to Israel (Isa 41 9) “galled thee from the chief men [dcilim] thereof” are rendered by RV “called thee from the corners thereof” (of the earth). In the NT we have génia (“angle,’”’ ‘‘corner”), ‘Gn the corners of the streets” (Mt 6 5), ‘‘the head of the corner” (21 42), “the four corners of the earth” (Rev 71; 20 8); arché (‘‘a beginning”) (Acts 10 11; 11 5); “chief cornerstone” (Eph 2 20; 1 Pet 2 6), is a tr of akrogéniatos (“at the extreme angle”’). W. L. WaLker CORNER GATE, kér'nér git. CORNERS OF THE EARTH. See Earrs, CorNERS OF. CORNER-STONE, kér’nér stin (735, pinnah, TINT, zdwith; axpoyevatos, akrogéniaios): Part of the public or imposing buildings to which impor- oo Ge See JERUSALEM. Cornet Countenance THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 722 tance has been attached in all ages and in many nations, both on account of its actual service and its figurative meaning. Ordinarily its use in the Bible is figurative, or symbolical. No doubt the original meaning was some important stone, which was laid at the foundation of a building. (1) With the Canaanites, who preceded Israel in the possession of Pal, corner-stone laying seems to have been a most sacred and impressive cere- monial. Under this important, stone of temples, or other great structures, bodies of children or older persons would be laid, consecrating the building by such human sacrifice (see Fortirication, II, 1). This was one of many hideous rites and prac- tices which Israel was to extirpate. It may throw light on the curse pronounced upon the rebuilding of Jericho (Josh 6 26; see PEFS, January, 1904, July, 1908). See Canaan. (2) OT references——The Heb word pinndh, “corner,” is found or implied in every occurrence of this idea. Derived from a root signifying “‘to turn,” it means “turning,’”’ and therefore ‘edge’ or “corner.” Ordinarily it is used with ’ebhen, “stone” (Ps 118 22); or it may occur alone, having acquired for itself through frequent use the whole technical phrase-idea (Zec 10 4 AV). While all the passages indicate the stone at the corner, there appear to be two conceptions: (a) the founda- tion-stone upon which the structure rested (Job 38 6; Isa 28 16; Jer 51 26); or (6) the topmost or cap-stone, which linked the last tier together (Ps 118 22; Zec 4 7); in both cases it is an im- portant or key-stone, and figurative of the Messiah, who is ‘‘the First and the Last.”’ In Job 38 6 it beautifully expresses in figures the stability of the earth, which Jeh created. In Zec 10 4 the leader or ruler in the Messianic age is repre- sented by the corner-stone. The ancient tradition of the one missing stone, when the temple was in building, is reflected in or has been suggested by Ps 118 22 (Midr quoted by Pusey under Zec 4 7). It is probable that we should read in Ps 144 12 not ‘“‘corner-stones,”’ but ‘‘corner-pillars,’’ or sup- ports (cf Gr Caryatides) from a different Heb word, zawith, BDB, s.v. (3) NT passages.—Ps 118 22 is quoted and interpreted as fulfilled in Jesus Christ in a number of passages: Mt 21 42; Mk 12 10; Lk 20 17; Acts 4 11 and 1 Pet 2 7; it is also the evident basis for Eph 2 20. Isa 28 16 is quoted twice in the NT: Rom 9 33, from LXX combined with the words of Isa 8 14, and in 1 Pet 2 6, which is quoted with some variation from LXX. The OT passages were understood by the rabbis to be Messianic, and were properly so applied by the NT writers. See also Hovusz. Epwarp Mack Figurative Uses CORNET, kér’net, kor’net. See Music. CORNFLOOR, kérn’flor (j3° 773, gdren daghan): “Thou hast loved a reward upon every cornfloor” (Hos 9 1 AV, RV “hire upon every grainfloor’”). Israel had deserted Jeh for supposed material bene- fits and regarded bounteous crops as the gift of the heathen gods which they worshipped. Jeh would therefore cause the corn (grain) and wine to fail (ver 2). See also THRESHING-FLOOR. CORONATION, kor-é-na’shun (apwrokAcla, protoklisia): Occurs in 2 Macc 4 21 (AV, RV “en- thronement’’) where Apollonius was sent into Egypt for the coronation of Ptolemy Philometor as king. The Gr word protoklisia occurs nowhere else, and its meaning is uncertain. The reading in Swete is pré- toklésia, and this means “‘the first call.” CORPSE, kirps: This word in the AV is the tr of two Heb words, "28, pegher, and 174, g°wtyah, while M22), nbhalah, and MDA, gaphah, which mean the same, are tr “body,” with which the Eng. word “corpse” (Lat corpus) was originally syno- nymical. Therefore we find the now apparently un- necessary addition of the adj. ‘‘dead” in 2 K 19 35 and Isa 37 36. The Gr equivalent is 77@ya, ptéma, lit. “a fallen body,” “a ruin” (from rérrw, piptd, “to fall”), in Mk 6 29; Rev 11 8.9. ; Corpses were considered as unclean and defiling in the OT, so that priests were not to touch dead bodies except those of near kinsfolk (Lev 21 1-3), the high priest and a Nazirite not even such (Lev 21 11; Nu 66-8). Nu 19 presents to us the ceremonial of purification from such defilement by the sprinkling with the ashes of a red heifer, cedar wood, hyssop and scarlet. It was considered a great calamity and disgrace to have one’s body left unburied, a “food unto all birds of the heavens, and unto the beasts of the earth” (Dt 28 26; 2S 2110; Ps 79 2; Isa 34 3; Jer 7 33, etc). Thence is explained the merit of Rizpah (2 S 21 10), and of the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead, who protected or recovered and buried the mutilated bodies of Saul and his sons (18 31 11-13; 268247; ef 1 Ch 10 11.12). See Burau. Even the corpses of persons executed by hanging were not to remain on the tree “‘all night,” “for he that is hanged is accursed of God; that thou defile not thy land which Jeh thy God giveth thee for an inheritance’ (Dt 21 23). H. L. E. Lusrine CORRECTION, ko-rek’shun (O71, misdr, usually rendered “instruction,” is tr4 “correction” in several passages): The vb. from which the noun is derived signifies “‘to instruct’? or ‘chastise.’ The idea of chastisement was very closely connected in the Heb mind with that of pedagogy. See CuasTIsEMENT. RV and ARV have changed “correction” of AV to “instruction” in Jer 7 28, reversing the order in the margins. DAW, shébhet, rendered “rod” in Job 219, is unnecessarily changed to “correction” in 37 13. In 2 Tim 3 16, éravipOwors, epanérthdsis, is tr’ “correction.” The difference between correction, discipline and instruction was not clearly drawn in the Heb mind. W. W. Davizs CORRUPTION, ké-rup’shun: The Heb words MYNW., mishhath, ONWA, mashhath, Mow, mashhith, and their Gr equivalents, p8op4, phthord, and SiadBopd, diaphthord, with numerous deriva- tives and cognate vbs., imply primarily physical degeneration and decay (Job 17 14; Acts 2 27, etc). The term NOW, shahath, which AV translates with “corruption” in Jon 2 6, ought to be rendered “pit,” as in Ps 30 9; 35 7 et passim, while sha- hath beli in Isa 88 17 means the “pit of nothing- ness,”’ i.e. of destruction. Figurative: At an early time we find the above- given words in a non-literal sense denoting moral depravity and corruption (Gen 6 11; Ex 82 7; Hos 9 9; Gal 6 8, etc), which ends in utter moral ruin and hopelessness, the second death. The question has been raised whether the meaning of these words might be extended so as to include the idea of final destruction and annihilation of the spirit. Upon careful examination, however, this question must be denied both from the standpoint of the OT and of the NT. Apart from other con- siderations we see this from the metaphors used in the Scriptures to illustrate the condition of “cor- ruption,” such as the ‘“‘unquenchable fire,” the “worm” which “dieth not” (Mk 9 43.48; cf Isa 723 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cornet Countenance 66 24), and “sleep” (Dnl 12 2), where a careful distinction is made between the blissful state after death of the righteous and the everlasting disgrace of the godless. The later Jewish theology is also fully agreed on this point. The meaning of the words cannot therefore extend beyond the idea of utter moral degradation and depravity. H. L. E. Luzrine CORRUPTION, MOUNT OF (Mnwvan—™7, har ha-mashhith; +d épos rot Mocod®, t6 6ros toti Mosodth): The hill on the right hand of which Solomon built high places for Ashtoreth, Chemosh and Milcom (2 K 23 13). The mountain re- ferred to is no doubt the Mount of Olives. The high places would, therefore, be on the southern height called in later Christian writings the ‘‘Mount of Offence,” and now, by the Arabs, Baten el- Hawa. Har ha-mashhith is probably only a perversion of har ha-mishhah, “Mount of Anointing,” a later name of the Mount of Olives. W. Ewine COS, kos (Kés, Kés, ‘‘summit”; AV Coos): An island off the coast of Caria, Asia Minor, one of the Sporades, mountainous in the southern half, with ridges extending to a height of 2,500 ft.; identified with themodernStanchio. It wasfamousin antiquity for excellent. wine, amphorae, wheat, ointments, silk and other clothing (Coae vestes). The capital was also called Cos. It possessed a famous hospital and medical school, and was the birthplace of Hippocrates (the father of medicine), of Ptolemy Philadelphus, and of the celebrated painter Apelles. The large plane tree in the center of the town (over 2,000 years old) is called “‘the tree of Hippocrates” to this day. The older capital, Astypalaea, was in the western part of the island, the later (since 366 BC) in the eastern part. From almost every point can be seen beautiful landscapes and picturesque views of sea and land and mountain. Cos was one of the six Dorian colonies. It soon became a flourishing place of commerce and in- dustry; later, like Corinth, it was one of the Jew- ish centers of the Aegaean, as well as one of the financial centers of the commercial world in the eastern Mediterranean. Among the _ benefactors of the people of Cos was Herod the Great. It is mentioned in connection with Paul’s third mission- ary journey in Acts 21 1, and in its relations with the Jews in 1 Macc 16 23; Ant, XIV, vii, 2; x, 15; BJ, I, xxi, 11. For a list of works on the island see Paton-Hicks, Inscriptions of Cos, ix. J. E. Harry COSAM, ki’sam (Kecdp, Kodsdém): An ancestor of Jesus in St. Luke’s genealogy in the 5th genera- tion before Zerubbabel (Lk 3 28). COSMOGONY, koz-mog’o-ni. See ANTHRO- POLOGY; CREATION; EarTH; EvoLutTion; WoRLD. COSMOLOGY, koz-mol’o-ji. See WorLp; PRovi- DENCE. COSTLINESS, kost’li-nes (tipidtys, timidtés, “‘preciousness,” ‘an abundance of costly things’’): Found only in Rev 18 19, ‘“‘made rich by reason of her costliness.”” COTES, kits. COTTAGE, kot’aj. COTTON, kot’’n (OB72, karpas, is the better tr, as in RVm, where AV and RV have “green” in Est 1 6): The Heb karpas is from the Pers kirpds and the Sanskrit karpdsa, “the cotton, plant.” The derived words originally meant ‘muslin’ or “calico,” but in classical times the use of words allied to See SHEEPCOTE. See Housz. karpas—in Gr and Lat—was extended to include linen. The probability is in favor of ‘‘cotton” in Est 16. This is the product of Gossypium her- baceum, a plant originally from India but now cultivated in many other lands. COUCH, kouch (subst.). See Bev. Couch (vb.): 727, rabhag, “to crouch,” “lurk,” as a beast in readiness to spring on its prey. “If thou doest not well, sin coucheth at the door” (Gen 4 7, AV “lieth’), waiting for it to open. Cain is warned to beware of the first temptations to evil, in his case esp. a sullen and jealous disposi- tion (cf Dante, Inferno, I, 30). See ABEL; Cain. The tribe of Judah is compared for its bravery to a recumbent lion or lioness (Gen 49 9; cf Nu 24 9f); and Issachar to “‘a strong ass, couching down be- tween the sheepfolds” (49 14, AV “between two burdens”; cf Jgs 6 16). ‘The deep that coucheth beneath’ (Dt 33 13), probably the springs of water, or possibly, as Driver suggests, ‘‘the subterranean deep, pictured as a gigantic monster.”’ See Apyss. M. O. Evans COUCHING-PLACE, kouch’ing-plas (Y270, marbéc; once in EV [Ezk 26 5]): The same Heb word, however, which means simply “place of lying down”’ of animals in repose, is used also in Zeph 2 15 where the tr is ‘a place... . to lie down in.” The figure, 2 common one in Scripture (see besides, Isa 17 2; 27 10), suggests desolation. COULTER, kol’tér. COUNCIL, koun’sil, COUNCILLOR, koun’si- lér (cupBotArov, sumboilion): An assembly of ad- visers (Acts 26 12); a body of those taking counsel (see Schitrer’s Jewish People in the Time of Christ, I (1), 60). Distinguished from cuvddpiov, sunédrion, the supreme court of the Jews, by being of a less formal character, i.e. less of an institution. For “council” in the latter sense, its most frequent use, see SANHEDRIN. A councillor (Gr bouleutés) was a member of the Sanhedrin. Applied to Joseph of Brieeavia (Mk 16 48; Lk 23 50). In AV “coun- sellor. See PLow. COUNSEL, koun’sel, COUNSELLOR, koun’se- lér (wvpBotALov, sumbotilion): Ordinarily found as object of vb. ‘to take” or ‘‘to give,” expressing, beside the idea of a practical end to be reached, that of consultation and deliberation among those united in a common cause (Mt 12 14; Mk36). A counsellor (stimboulos) is a confidential adviser (Rom 11 34); often in the OT (Isa 9 6; Prov 24 6, etc). Confounded in AV with “councillor” (see above), the latter being an official adviser, which the former does not necessarily mean. COUNT, kount ("29, sdphar, 12, mdnah; Wndlto, pséphizd): Used of arithmetical compu- tation ‘to number” (Ps 139 18; Nu_ 23 10); also for 20D, kathabh, ‘‘to reckon,”’ to indicate classifi- cation among or identification with, “c. for a stranger” (Job 19 15); “c. for his enemy” (Job 33 10). In the NT the arithmetical computation is less prominent, except in the sense of ‘‘calculate,” pséphizé, sumpséphizd, “to reckon with pebbles,” each pebble representing a unit (Lk 14 28; Acts 19 19); of moral estimate, hégéomai and logizomat (Phil 3 7.13). The noun, fr Heb kdsath, ‘‘a count of” (Ex 12 4), viz. in the arithmetical sense. H. E. Jacozs COUNTENANCE, koun’te-nans: (1) The noun (see also s.v. Face) is the tr of a variety of Heb and Gr expressions, D"33, pdnim; mpbcwrev, présdpon, being the most frequent. Be Counter-Charm Courts, Judicial THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 724 sides these there are found MN, mar’eh, “ap- pearance,” ‘“‘shape,” ‘‘comeliness,” ‘visage,’ 77Y, ‘ayin, “the eye,” INT, t6’ar, “appearance,” “figure,”’ etc, and Aram. VJ, zzw. To the Oriental the coun- tenance mirrors, even more than to us, the character and feelings of the heart. The countenance (mar’eh) is “fair” (1 8 17 42; 2 S 14 27; Dnl 115); in 15S 16 12, lit. “fair of eyes”; “comely” (Cant 2 14); “beautiful” (ta’ar, 1 S 26 3); “cheerful” (panim, Prov 15 18); “angry” (Prov 26 23); “fierce” (Dnl 8 23); “troubled” (Ezk 27 35); “sad” (1S 118; Neh 2 2.3; Eccl 7 3). The countenance is ‘‘sharp- ened,” i.e. made keen (Prov 27 17); it “falls,” ive. looks despondent, disappointed (Gen 4 5.6); is “cast down” (Job 29 24); “changed” (Job 14 20; cf “altered” into glory, Lk 9 29; Dnl 6 6.9.10; 7 28, Aram. ziw). To settle one’s countenance stedfastly upon a person (2 K 8 11) issynonymous with staring or gazing at a person. Not infre- quently we find compound expressions such as “‘light of countenance,” i.e. favor (Job 29 24; Ps 4 6; 44 3; 89 15; 90 8); “health of countenance” (Ps 42 11; 43 5); “help of countenance” (Ps 42 5); “rebuke of countenance” (Ps 80 16); “pride of countenance’ (Heb ’aph, lit. ‘‘haughty,” “lofty nose,” Ps 10 4). (2) As vb. (Heb VIM, hddhar, “to countenance’) we find the word in AV of Ex 23 3, where the Re- visers translate ‘Neither shalt thou favor [AV “countenance”’] a poor man in his cause.” Here the meaning seems to be that no distinction of persons shall be made by the judge. See Lev 19 15, where, however, a different word is used. There is therefore no need of the emendation proposed by Knobel! and accepted by Kautzsch, who would read oa , gadhol, “great,” for on, wdhal, “and the poor” of the text. The LXX has wévys, pénés, “poor.” H. L. E. Lusrine COUNTER-CHARM, koun’tér-charm. See Amu- LET; Car. COUNTERFEIT, koun’tér-fit (k(BdnAos, kibdélos, évatuTéw, anaiupdd, dpo1dw, homoidd): “‘C.” occurs as the tr of kibdélos, ‘‘mixed with dross,’ ‘‘not genuine’ (Wisd 15 9, ‘to make c. things,” RV “mouldeth counterfeits,’ spurious things, imita- tions”); 2 16 RV “‘base metal” (cf LXX Lev 19 19; Dt 22 11, “mingled garment,” and 2 Cor 13 5.6, adékimos, “reprobate” [silver]). “Counterfeit” in the older sense of a representation occurs in Wisd 14 17 (anatupod, ‘to make a likeness’’), “c. of his visage,” RV “imagining the likeness from afar,” and Ecclus 38 27 (homoiod, ‘to make like’’), ‘‘to c. imagery,’”’ RV ‘“‘to preserve likeness in his portrai- ture.” WALKER COUNTERVAIL, koun-tér-val’ (TW, shdwah, “equalize’”): To thwart or overcome by acting against with equal force; thus, “The enemy could not c. the king’s damage” or loss (Est 7 4 ARV reads “‘The adversary could not have compensated for the king’s damage’’). ‘Nothing doth c. [RV “can be taken in exchange for’’] a faithful friend” (Ecclus 6 15). COUNTRY, kun’tri (V8, ’erec, “land,” M7, sddheh, “field”; Gypés, agrés, “field,” x@pa, ché- ra, “region’”): The foregoing are the principal words rendered “country” in EV, though we find also ’ddhdmah, “earth” (Jon 4 2); 7%, “island” (Jer 47 4 AV); g*lilah, “circuit” (Ezk 47 8 AV); hebhel, “rope” (Dt 3 14); makém, “place” (Gen 29 26 AV); nepheth, “hill” or ‘‘height” (Josh 17 11 AV); génos, ‘race’ (Acts 4 86 AV); 1%, gé, “earth” (Mt 9 31 AV; Acts 7 3 AV); warps, patris, ‘native land” (Lk 4 23; Jn 4 44; He 11 14); weplxwpos, perichdros, “country [ARV “‘region’”’] round about” (Mt 14 35; Lk 3 3; 4 37; 8 37). InHe 11 14 fi, “heaven” is referred to as a country. Egypt and Assyria were ‘far countries” (Jer 8 19 AV; Zec 10 9). The hill country (cf the numerous Gibeahs [gibh'ah, “a hill’”’]) was the mountainous region to the N. or to the S. of Jerus. Thelow country, sh°phélah (see SHEPHELAH), consisted of the foothills to the west of the hill country. The south country or Nees (neghebh), q.v., was the dry, extreme southern part of Pal, ap- proximately hetween Beersheba and Kadesh-barnea. AuFrreD Ety Day COUNTRYMAN, kun’‘tri-man (cupbvdérys, sum- phulétés): “Of the same tribe” (1 Thess 2 14); also in idiomatic rendering (yévos, génos) for those of one’s own race or kin (2 Cor 11 26; Gal 1 14 AV, “one’s own nation”). Cf Mk 6 4; Rom 9 3; and see Cousin; Kinsmavy, etc. COUPLE, kup’: (1) Used as a noun, indicates two objects of the same kind that are considered together. Thus we read of a couple of cakes (2 8 13 6, used loosely), and a couple of asses (2 S 16 1, Heb cemedh). (2) Used as a vb., it means to join or fasten one thing to another. This term occurs most frequently in the description of the tabernacle (see Ex 26 6.9.11; 36 10.13.16). Couple is used in 1 Pet 3 2 to de- scribe the joining of fear to chaste behavior (Heb habhar). COUPLING, kup’ling: Is the EV rendering of MAM, mahbereth. This Heb word means join- ing, or the place where one thing is joined to an- other, as of the curtains of the tabernacle (Ex 26 4.5), and of the different parts of the ephod (Ex 28 27; 39 20). ; It is also the EV rendering of NMAMTA, m*hab- bréth, and this refers more to the thing that joins the two objects, as beams of wood (2 Ch 34 11), or hooks of iron (1 Ch 22 3). COURAGE, kur’4}: Heb hdzak, “to show one- self strong’ (Nu 13 20; 28 10 12; 1 Ch 19 18; 2Ch 158; Ezr 104; Ps 2714; 3124; Isa 41 6); rah, “spirit,” “animus” (Josh 2 11 AV); ’Gmag, “to be alert” (physically and mentally), “to be agile,” “quick,” ‘‘energetic” (Dt 31 6.7.23; Josh 1 6.9.18; 10 25; 1 Ch 22 13; 28 20); lébhabh, “the heart,” and fig.: “person,” “spirit’’ (Dnl 11 25); Gr thdrsos, “cheer” (Acts 28 15). A virtue highly esteemed among all nations, one of the four chief ‘natural” (cardinal) virtues (Wisd 8 7), while cowardice ranks as one of the mortal sins (Ecclus 212.18; Rev 21 8). COURSE, kors (from Lat cursus, “a running,” “race,” “voyage,” “way”): (1) ed@vdpopéw, euthudroméd, “forward or onward movement,” as of a ship: “We made a straight c¢.” (Acts 16 11; ef Acts 21 1); ‘We had finished our c.” (RV “voyage,” Acts 21 7). (2) A (prescribed or self-appointed) path, as of the sun: “Swift is the sun in his c.” (1 Esd 4 34); of the stars: “The stars in their courses fought against Sisera” (Jgs 6 20 AV) (see ASTRONOMY; AsTRoLoGy); of a river (or irrigating canal?): “as willows by the watercourses” (Isa 44 4); of a race (teéx, tréchd): “that the word of the Lord may have free c.” (RV “may run”) (2 Thess 3 1). (3) A career in such a course (Spsuos, drémos): “T have finished my [RV “‘the”] c.’ (2 Tim 4 7); “as John fulfilled [RV ‘‘was fulfilling”) his ¢.” (Acts 13 25); “that I might finish [RV ‘may accomplish”’] my c.” (Acts 20 24). (4) A way or manner, as of life: ‘Every one 725 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Counter-Charm Courts, Judicial turned to his c.” (Jer 8 6); “their c. is evil” (Jer 23 10); “‘walked according to the c. [aiw», aidn, RVm “‘‘age’’] of this world” (Eph 2 2). (5) Orderly succession: ‘‘sang together by c.” (ARV “sang one to another”) (Ezr 3 11); “by c.” (RV “in turn”) (1 Cor 14 27); the courses of the priests and Levites (I Ch 27 1-15; 1 Ch 28 1; 2 Ch 6 11; Lk 1 5.8). See Prizsts anp Levitss. (6) A row or layer, as of Masonry: “All the foundations of the earth are out of ¢.” (RV “are moved”; ARV “are shaken”) (Ps 82 5). (7) [The tongue] “setteth on fire the c. [RV “wheel’’] of nature” (Jas 3 6). The cycle of generation (tén trochén tés genéseds) here means the physical world as constituted by the round of origin and decay, and wpuied by the Orphic (legendary) cycle of births and eaths through which the soul passes in metempsy- See also GAMEs. Wiuuram Arraur Heme. COURSE OF PRIESTS AND LEVITES. See Priests AND LEVITEs. COURT, kaért. See Hovuss. COURT OF THE GENTILES. See Tempe (Heron’s). COURT OF THE SABBATH. See Coveren Way. COURT, kért, OF THE SANCTUARY, sank’ti- a-ri (TABERNACLE, TEMPLE): By “court” ("3M, haeér) is meant a clear space inclosed by curtains or walls, or surrounded by buildings. It was always an uncovered inclosure, but might have within its area one or more edifices. The first occurrence of the word is in Ex 27 9, where it is commanded to ‘make the court of the tabernacle.” The dimensions for this 1. The follow in the directions for the length Tabernacle of the linen curtains which were to inclose it. From these we learn that the perimeter of the court was 300 cubits, and that it consisted of two squares, each 75 ft., lying E. and W. of one another. In the westerly square stood the tabernacle, while in that to the E. was the altar of burnt offering. This was the worshipper’s square, and every Heb who passed through the entrance gate had immediate access to the altar (ef W. Roberteon Smith, note on Ex 20 26, OTJC. 435). The admission to this scene of the national solemnities was by the great east gate described in Ex 27 18-16 (see East Gate). The fundamental conception out of which grew the resolve to build a temple for the worship of Jeh was that the new structure was to be chosis. 2. Solo- an enlarged duplicate in stone of the mon’s tent of meeting (see TEMPLE). The Temple doubling in size of the holy chambers was accompanied by a doubling of the inclosed area upon which the holy house was to stand. Hitherto a rectangular oblong figure of 150 ft. in length and 75 ft. in breadth had sufficed for the needs of the people in their worship. Now an area of 300 ft. in length and 150 ft. in breadth was inclosed within heavy stone walls, making, as before, two squares, each of 150 ft. This was that “court. of the priests’ spoken of in 2 Ch 4 9, known to its builders as “the inner court” (1 K 6 36; ef Jer 36 10). Its walls consisted of “three courses of hewn stone, and a course of cedar beams” (I K 6 36), into which some read the meaning of colonnades. Its two divisions may have been marked by some fence. The innermost division, accessible only to the priests, was the site of the new temple. In the easterly division stood the altar of sacrifice; into this the Heb laity had access for worship at the altar. Later incidental allusions imply the existence of ‘chambers’ in the court, and also the accessibility of the laity (cf Jer 35 4; 36 10; Ezk 8 16). In distinction from this “inner” court a second or “outer” court was built by Solomon, spoken of by the Chronicler as “the great court” 3. The (2 Ch 4 9). Its doors were overlaid Great with brass (bronze). Wide differ- Court ence of opinion obtains as to the rela- tion of this outer court to the inner court just described, and to the rest of the Solo- monic buildings—particularly to “the great court’ of ‘‘the house of the forest of Lebanon” of 1 K 7 9.10. Some identify the two, others separate them. Did this court, with its brass-covered gates, ex- tend still farther to the E. than the temple “inner” court, with, however, the same breadth as the latter? Or was it, as Keil thinks, a much larger inclosure, surrounding the whole temple area, ex- tending perhaps 150 cubits eastward in front of the priests’ court (cf Keil, Bib. Archaeology, I, 171, ET) ? Yet more radical is the view, adopted by many modern authorities, which regards ‘the great court” as a vast inclosure surrounding the temple and the whole complex of buildings described in 1 K 7 I-12 (see the plan, after Stade, in G. A. Smith’s Jerusalem, II, 59). In the absence of con- clusive data the question must be left undetermined. In Ezekiel’s plan of the temple yet to be built, the lines of the temple courts as he had known them in Jerus are followed. Two squares 4, Ezekiel’s inclosed in stone walling, each of 150 Temple ft., lie N. and 8S. of one another, and bear the distinctive names, ‘‘the inner court” and “the outer court” (Ezk 8 16; 10 5). In the Herodian temple the old nomenclature gives place to a new set of terms. The extensive inclosure known later as “the court of the Gentiles’ does not appear under that name in the NT or in Jos. What we have in the tract Middéth of the Mishnah and in Jos is the mention of two courts, the ‘“‘court of the priests” and ‘“‘the court of Israel’ (Middéth, ii.6; v.1; Jos, BJ, V, v, 6). The data in regard to both are difficult and conflicting. In Middoth they appear as long narrow strips of 11 cubits in breadth extending at right angles to the temple and the altar across the inclosure—the “court of Israel’ being railed off from the “‘court of the priests’ on the E.; the latter extending back- ward as far as the altar, which has a distinct measurement. The design was to prevent the too near approach of the lay Israelite to the altar. Jos makes the 11 cubits of the “court of Israel” extend round the whole “‘court of the priests,” inclusive of altar and temple (see TEMPLE; and cf G. A. Smith, Jerusalem, II, 506-9, with the reconstruction of Waterhouse in Sacred Sites of the Gospels, 111 ff). For the ‘‘women’s court,’”’ see TREASURY. Many expressions in the Pss show how great was the attachment of the devout-minded Heb in all ages to those courts of the Lord’s house where he was accustomed to worship (e.g. Ps 65 4; 84 2; 92 13; 96 8; 100 4; 116 19). The courts were the scene of many historical events in the OT and NT, and of much of the earthly ministry of Jesus. There was enacted the scene described in the par- able of the Pharisee and Publican (Lk 18 10-14). W. Saaw CatpEcorr COURTS, JUDICIAL, joo-dish’al, ji-dish’al: At the advice of Jethro, Moses appointed judges (DOD, shéphetim, Ex 18). In Egypt 6. Temple of Herod 1. Their it appears that the Hebrews did not Organiza- have their own judges, which, of tion course, was a source of many wrongs. , Leaving Egypt, Moses took the judi- cial functions upon himself, but it was impossible Courts, Judicial THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 726 Covenant in OT that he should be equal to the task of administer- ing justice to two and one-half million people; hence he proceeded to organize a system of jurisprudence. He appointed judges over tens, fifties, hundreds, thousands—in all 78,600 judges. This system was adequate for the occasion, and these courts respec- tively corresponded practically to our Justices of the Peace, Mayor’s Court, District Court, Circuit Court. Finally, there was a Supreme Court under Moses and his successors. These courts, though graded, did not afford an opportunity of appeal. The lower courts turned their difficult cases over to the next higher. If the case was simple, the judge over tens would take it, but if the question was too intricate for him, he would refer it to the next higher court, and so on until it finally reached Moses. There were certain kinds of questions which the tens, fifties, and hundreds would not take at all, and the people understood it and would bring them to the higher courts for original jurisdiction. When any court decided it, that was the end of that case, for it could not be appealed (Ex 18 25. 26). On taking possession in Pal, the judges were to be appointed for every city and vicinity (Dt 16 18), thus giving to all Israel a speedy and cheap method of adjudication. Though not so _pre- scribed by the constitution, the judges at length were generally chosen from among the Levites, as the learned class. The office was elective. Jos states this plainly, and various passages of the Scriptures express it positively by inference (see Dt 118). Jephthah’s election by vote of the people is clearly set forth (Jgs 11 5-11). Among the Hebrews, the law was held very sacred; for God Himself had given it. Hence those who administered the law were 2. Character God’s special representatives, and of the their person was held correspond- Judges ingly sacred. These circumstances placed upon them the duty of admin- istering justice without respect to persons (Dt 1 17; 16 18). They were to be guided by the inalienable rights granted to every citizen by the Heb consti- tution: (1) No man was to be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law (Nu 35 9-34). (2) Two or three witnesses were required to convict anyone of crime (Dt 17 6; 19 2-13). (8) Punishment for crime was not to be transferred or entailed (Dt 24 16). (4) A man’s home was inviolate (Dt 24 10.11). (5) One held to bondage but having acquired lberty through his own effort should be protected (Dt 23 15.16). (6) One’s homestead was inalienable (Lev 25 23- 28.34). (7) Slavery could not be made perpetual without the person’s own consent (Ex 21 2-6). Gradually a legal profession developed among the Hebrews, the members of which were designated as ‘‘Lawyers” or ‘‘Scribes,” also known 3. Their as ‘Doctors of the Law” (Lk 2 46). Work Their business was threefold: (1) to study and interpret the law; (2) to instruct the Heb youth in the law; and (3) to decide questions of the law. The first two they did as scholars and teachers; the last cither as judges or as advisers in some court, as, for instance, the Senate of Jerus or some inferior tribunal. No code can go into such details as to eliminate the neces- sity of subsequent legislation, and this usually, to a great extent, takes the form of judicial decisions founded on the code, rather than of separate enact- ment; and so it was among the Hebrews. The provisions of their code were for the most part quite general, thus affording large scope for casuistic interpretation. Regarding the points not explicitly covered by the written law, a substitute must be found either in the form of established custom or in the form of an inference drawn from the statute. As a result of the industry with which this ine of legal development was pursued during the cents. immediately preceding our era, Hebrew law became ® most complicated science. For the disputed points, the judgments of the individual lawyers could not be taken as the standard; hence the several disciples of the law must frequently meet for a discussion, and the opinion of the majority then prevailed. These were the meetings of the “Doctors.” Whenever a case arose concerning which there had been no clear legal decision, the question was referred to the nearest lawyer; by him, to the nearest company of lawyers, perhaps the Sanhedrin, and the resultant decision was henceforth authority. Before the destruction of Jerus technical knowl- edge of the law was not a condition of eligibility to the office of judge. Anyone who could command the confidence of his fellow-citizens might be elected, and many of the rural courts undoubtedly were conducted, as among us, by men of sterling quality, but limited knowledge. Such men would avail themselves of the legal advice of any “doctor” who might be within reach; and in the more dignified courts of a large municipality it was a standing custom to have a company of lawyers present to discuss and decide any new law points that might arise. Of course, frequently these men were them- selves elected to the office of judge, so that prac- tically the entire system of jurisprudence was in their hands. Though Judaea at this time was a subject com- monwealth, yet the Sanhedrin, which was the body of supreme legislative and judicial 4. Limita- authority, exercised autonomous au- - tions under thority to such an extent that it not Roman only administered civil cases in accord- Rule ance with Jewish law—for without such a right a Jewish court would be impossible—but it also took part to a great extent in the punishment of crime. It exercised an inde- pendent police power, hence could send out its own officers to make arrests (Mt 26 47; Mk 14 43; Acts 43; 6 17.18). In cases that did not involve capital punishment, its judgments were final and untrammeled (Acts 4 2-23; 5 21-40). Only in capital punishment cases must the consent of the procurator be secured, which is not only clearly stated in Jn 18 31, but is also evident in the entire course of Christ’s trial, as reported by the Synoptic Gospels. In granting or withholding his consent in such cases, the procurator could follow his pleasure absolutely, applying either the Jewish or Rom law, as his guide. In one class of cases the right to inflict capital punishment even on Rom citizens was granted the Sanhedrin, namely, when a non-Jewish person overstepped the bounds and entered the interior holy place of the temple. Even in this case the consent of the procurator must be’ secured, but it appears that the Rom rulers were inclined to let the law take its course against such wanton outrage of the Jews’ feelings. Criminal cases not involving capital punishment need not be referred to the procurator. The city in which the Sanhedrin met was Jerus. To determine the particular building, and the spot on which the building stood, is inter- esting to the archaeologist, not to the student of law. The local courts usually held their sessions on the second and fifth day (Monday and Thursday) of the week, but we do not know whether the same custom was observed by the Great San- hedrin. On feast days no court was held, much less on the Sabbath. Since the death penalty was not to be pronounced until the day after the trial, such cases were avoided also on the day preceding 5. Time and Place of Sessions 727 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Courts, Judicial Covenant in OT a Sabbath or other sacred day. The emphasis placed on this observance may be seen from the edicts issued by Augustus, absolving the Jews from the duty of attending court on the Sabbath. See Doctor; Lawyer; SANHEDRIN; ScrIsE. Franx E, Hirscu COUSIN, kuz’n (@vefids, anepsids): Only in Col 4 10, where Mark is said to be “cousin” (RV) to Barnabas, and not as in AV, “sister's son.” The renderings “cousin” of AV for cvyyerjs, sug- genés, in Lk 1 36.58 were peobably understood at the time of the tr, in the wider, and not in the more restricted, sense of the term, now almost universally prevalent. In view of this the renderings “kins- woman,” “kinsfolk’’ in RV are preferable. As a title of honor and dignity, it occursin 1 Esd 4 42, etc. See Kinsman. COUTHA, kou’tha, koo’tha. See Curnan. COVENANT, kuv’e-nant (IN THE OT) (n™3, berith): I. Geweraun Meanine II. Amone Men 1. Harly Idea 2. Principal Elements 3. Different Varieties 4. Phraseology Used III, Between Gop anp Men 1. Essential Idea 2. Covenants Recorded in the OT 8. Phraseology Use 4, History of Covenant Idea LitsraTURE I. General Meaning.—The etymological force of the Heb brrith is not entirely certain. It is probable _ that the word is the same as the Assyr birttu, which has the common meaning ‘fetter,’ but also means “covenant.” The significance of the root from which this Assyr word is derived is uncertain. It is probable that it is “to bind,” but that is not definitely established. The meaning of biritu as covenant seems to come directly from the root, rather than as a derived meaning from fetter. If this root idea is to bind, the covenant is that which binds together the parties. This, at any rate, is in harmony with the general meaning of the word. In the OT the word has an ordinary use, when both parties are men, and a distinctly religious use, between God and men. There can be no doubt that the religious use has come from the ordinary, in harmony with the general custom in such cases, and not the reverse. There are also two shades of meaning, somewhat distinct, of the Heb word: one in which it is properly a covenant, i.e. a solemn mutual agreement, the other in which it is more a command, i.e. instead of an obligation voluntarily assumed, it is an obligation imposed by a superior upon an inferior. This latter meaning, however, has clearly been derived from the other. It is easy to see that an agreement, including as the contracting parties those of unequal position, might readily include those agreements which tended to partake of the nature of a command; but the pro- cess could not readily be reversed. Il, Among Men.—We consider first a covenant in which both contracting parties are men. In essence a covenant is an agreement, but an agreement of a solemn and binding force. The early Sem idea of a covenant was doubtless that which prevailed among the Arabs (see esp. W. Robertson Smith, Religion of the Semites, 2d ed, passim). This was primarily blood-brotherhood, in which two men became brothers by drinking each other’s blood. Ordinarily this meant that one was adopted into the clan of the other. Hence this act in- volved the clan of one of the contracting parties, and also brought the other party into relation with 1. Early Idea the god of this clan, by bringing him into the com- munity life of the clan, which included its god. In this early idea, then, ‘‘primarily the covenant is not a special engagement to this or that particular effect, but bond of troth and life-fellowship to all the effects for which kinsmen are permanently bound together” (W. Robertson Smith, op. cit., 315f). In this early ceremonial the religious idea was necessarily present, because the god was kindred to the clan; and the god had a special interest in the covenant, because he esp. protects the kindred blood, of which the stranger thus becomes a part. This religious side always persisted, although the original idea, was much modified. In later usage there were various substitutes for the drinking of each other’s blood, viz. drinking together the sac- rificial blood, sprinkling it upon the parties, eating together the sacrificial meal, ete; but the same idea found expression in all, the community of life result- ing from the covenant. The covenant in the OT shows considerable modification from the early idea. Yet it will doubtless help in understanding the 2. Principal OT covenant to keep in mind the early Elements idea and form. Combining state- ments made in different accounts, the following seem to be the principal elements in a covenant between men. Sorne of the details, it is to be noted, are not explicitly stated in reference to these covenants, but may be inferred from those between God and men. (1) A statement of the terms agreed upon (Gen 26 29; 31 50.52). This was a modification of the earlier idea, which has been noted, in which a covenant was all-inclusive. (2) An oath by each party to observe the terms, God being witness ae the oath (Gen 26 31; 31 48-53). ‘The oath was such a characteristic feature that sometimes the term “oath” is used as the equivalent of covenant (see Ezk 17 13). (3) A curse invoked by each one upon himself in case of disregard of the agreement. In a sense this may be considered a part of the oath, adding emphasis toit. This curse is not explicitly stated in the case of human covenants, but may be inferred from the covenant with God (Dt 27 15-26). (4) The formal ratification of the covenant by some solemn external act. The different ceremonies for this purpose, such as have already been mentioned, are to be regarded as the later equivalents of the early act of drinking each other’s blood. In the OT accounts it is not certain that such formal act is expressly mentioned in relation to covenants between men. It seems probable, however, that the sacrificial meal of Gen 31 54 included Laban, in which case it was a covenant sacrifice. In any case, both sacrificial meal and sprinkling of blood upon the two parties, the altar representing Jeh, are mentioned in Ex 24 4-8, with allusions else- where, in ratification of the covenant at Sinai between Jeh and Israel. In the covenant of God with Abraham is another ceremony, quite certainly with the same purpose. This is a peculiar observ- ance, viz. the cutting of animals into two parts and passing between the severed portions (Gen 15 9-18), a custom also referred to in Jer 34 18. Here it is to be noted that it is a smoking furnace and a flaming torch, representing God, not Abraham, which passed between the pieces. Such an act, it would seem, should be shared by both parties, but in this case it is doubtless to be explained by the fact that the covenant is principally a promise by Jeh. He is the one who binds Himself. Concerning the significance of this act there is difference of opinion. A common view is that it is in effect a formal ex- pression of the curse, imprecating upon oneself the same, i.e. cutting in pieces, if one breaks the terms of the covenant. But, as W. R. Smith has Covenant in OT Covenant, Bk of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 728 pointed out (op. cit., 481), this does not explain the passing between the pieces, which is the char- acteristic feature of the ceremony. It seems rather to be a symbol that the two parties ‘‘were taken within the mystical life of the victim.” (Cf the interpretation of He 9 15-17 in CovEeNnaNnT IN tue NT.) It would then be an inheritance from the early times, in which the victim was regarded as kindred with the tribe, and hence also an equiva~ lent of the drinking of each other’s blood. The immutability of a covenant is everywhere assumed, at least theoretically. Other features beyond those mentioned cannot be considered as fundamental. This is the case with the setting up of a stone, or raising a heap of stones (Gen 31 45.46). This is doubtless simply an ancient custom, which has no direct connection with the covenant, but comes from the ancient Sem idea of the sacredness of single stones or heaps of stones. Striking hands is a general expression of an agreement made (Ezr 10 19; Ezk 17 18, etc). In observing different varieties of agreements among men, we note that they may be either be- tween individuals or between larger 3. Different units, such as tribes and nations. In Varieties a great majority of cases, however, they are between the larger units. In some cases, also, when an individual acts it is in a representative capacity, as the head of a clan, or as a king. When the covenant is between tribes it is thus a treaty or alliance. The following pas- sages have this use of covenant: Gen 14 13; 21 27.32; 26 28; 31 44; Ex 23 32; 34 1215; Dt 72; Josh 9 6.7.11.15.16; Jgs22; 18111; 1K 6 12; 15 19[/2 Ch 16 3; 1 K 20 34; Ps 83 5; Isa 33 8; Ezk 16 61; 17 13-19; 305; Dnol 11 22; Am 19. In other cases it is between a king and his subjects, when it is more a command or ordinance, as 28 8 12.13.21; 5 3 || 1 Ch 113; Jer 34 8-18; Dnl 9 27. In other cases it is be- tween individuals, or between small groups, where it is an agreement or pledge (2 K 11 4/2 Ch 23 1; Job 311; 41 4; Hos 10 4). Between David and Jonathan it is more specifically an alliance of friendship (1 8 18 3; 20 8; 23 18), as also ap- parently in Ps 55 20. It means an alliance of marriage in Mal 2 14, but probably not in Prov 2 17, where it is better to understand the meaning as being “her covenant with God.” In all cases of covenants between men, except Jer 34 10 and Dnl 9 27, the technical phrase for making a covenant is karath berith, 4. Phrase- in which ka@rath meant originally “to ology Used cut.” Everything indicates that this vb. is used with reference to the formal ceremony of ratification above mentioned, of cutting animals in pieces. J, Between God and Men.—As already noted, the idea of covenants between God and men doubt- less arose from the idea of covenants 1. Essential between men. Hence the general Idea thought is similar, It cannot in this case, however, be an agreement be- tween contracting parties who stand on an equality, but God, the superior, always takes the initiative. To some extent, however, varying in different cases, it is regarded as a mutual agreement; God with His commands makes certain promises, and men agree to keep the commands, or, at any rate, the promises are conditioned on human obedience. Tn general, the covenant of God with men is a Divine ordinance, with signs and pledges on God’s part, and with promises for human obedience and penal- ties for disobedience, which ordinance is accepted by men. In one passage (Ps 25 14), it is used in a more general way of an alliance of friendship between God and man. A covenant of this general kind is said in the OT to have been made by God with Noah (Gen 9 9-17 and elsewhere). In this the promise 2. Cove- _is that there shall be no more deluge. nants Re- Cub Gobo new” covenant with His “blood.” disciples, that to speak of the covenant in this em- phatic way, referring manifestly to something other than the old Mosaic covenant, was in effect to call it a “new” covenant. The expression, in any case, looks back to the old and points the contrast; but in the contrast there are points of resemblance. It is most significant that Christ here connects the We at once think, as doubtless the disciples would 8. Relation think, of the transaction described in to Ex 24 Ex 24 7, when Moses “took the book of the covenant, and read in the audience of the people” those ‘words,’ indicating God’s undertaking on behalf of His people and what He required of them; “and they said, All that Jeh hath spoken will we do, and be obedient,” thus taking up their part of the contract. Then comes the ratification. ‘‘Moses took the blood [half of which had already been sprinkled on the altar], and sprinkled it on the people, and said, Behold the blood of the covenant, which Jeh hath made with you concerning all these words” (ver 8). The blood was sacrificial blood, the blood of the animals sacrificed as burnt offerings and peace offerings (Ex 24 5.6). The one half of the blood sprinkled on the altar tells of the sacrifice offered to God, the other half sprinkled on the people, of the virtue of the same sacrifice applied to the people, and so the covenant relation is fully brought about. Christ, by speaking of His blood in this connection, plainly indicates that His death was a sacrifice, and that through that sacrifice His people would be brought into a new covenant relationship with God. His sacrifice is acceptable to God and the virtue of it is to be applied to believers—so all the blessings of the new covenant are secured to them; the blood ‘“‘is poured ont for you” (Lk 22 20). He specifically mentions one great blessing of the new covenant, the forgiveness of sins—‘‘which is poured out for many unto remission of sins” (Mt 26 28). This great thought is taken up in He and fully expounded. The writer draws out fully the con- trast between the new covenant and iis 4. Usein the old by laying stress upon the per- Ep. to the fection of Christ’s atonement in con- Hebrews trast to the material and typical bk sacrifices (He 9 11-23). He was “a high priest of the good things to come,’’ connected with “the greater and more perfect tabernacle.” He entered the heavenly holy place “through his own blood,” not that of “goats and calves,” and by that perfect offering He has secured “eternal re- demption” in contrast to the temporal deliverance of the old dispensation. The blood of those typical offerings procured ceremonial cleansing; much more, therefore, shall the blood of Christ avail to cleanse the conscience “from dead works to serve the living God”’—that blood which is so superior in value to the hlood of the temporal sacrifices, yet resembles it in being sacrificial blood. It is the blood of Him “who, through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish unto God.” It is the fashion in certain quarters nowadays to say that it is not the blood of Christ, but His spirit of self-sacrifice for others, that invests the cross with its saving power, and this verse is sometimes cited to show that the virtue lies in the surrender of the perfect will, the shedding of the blood being a mere accident. But this is not the view of the NT writers. The blood- shedding is to them a necessity. Of course, it is not the natural, material blood, or the mere act of shedding it, that saves. The blood is the life. The blood is the symbol of life; the blood shed is the symbol of life outpoured—of the penalty borne; and while great emphasis must be laid, as in this verse it is laid, upon Christ’s perfect surrender of His holy will to God, yet the essence of the matter is found Covenant, New Covetousness ‘THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 732 in the fact that He willingly endured the dread con- sequences of sin, and as a veritable expiatory sacrifice shed His precious blood for the remission of sins. On the ground of that shed blood, as the writer goes on to assert, “He is the mediator of a new covenant, that a death having taken 5. The Me- place for the redemption of the trans- diator of gressions that were under the first the New covenant, they that have been called Covenant may receive the promise of the eternal inheritance’ (ver 15). Thus Christ fulfils the type in a twofold way: He-is the sacrifice upon which the covenant is based, whose blood ratifies it, and He is also, like Moses, the Mediator of the covenant. The death of Christ not only secures the forgiveness of those who are brought under the new covenant, but it was also for the redemption of the transgressions under the first cove- nant, implying that all the sacrifices gained their value by being types of Christ, and the forgiveness enjoyed by the people of God in former days was bestowed in virtue of the great Sacrifice to be offered in the fulness of time. Not only does the blessing of perfect forgiveness come through the new covenant, but also the prom- ise of the “eternal inheritance” in 6. “Inheri- contrast to the earthly inheritance tance” and which, under the old covenant, Israel “Testa- obtained. The mention of the inheri- ment” tance is held to justify the taking of the word in the next verse as “testa- ment,” the writer passing to the thought of a testamentary disposition, which is only of force after the death of the testator. Undoubtedly there is good ground for the analogy, and all the blessings of salvation which come to the believer may be considered as bequeathed by the Saviour in His death, and accruing to us because He has died. It has, in that sense, tacitly to be assumed that the testator lives again to be His own executor and to put usin possession of the blessings. Still, we think there is much to be said in favor of keeping to the sense of ‘‘covenant”’ even here, and taking the clause, which, rendered lit., is: ‘‘a covenant is of force [or firm] over the dead,” as meaning that the covenant is established on the ground of sacrifice, that sacri- fice representing the death of the maker of the covenant. The allusion may be further explained by areference to Gen 16 9.10.17, which has generally been considered as illustrating the ancient Sem method of making a covenant: the sacrificial animals being divided, and the parties passing between the pieces, implying that they deserved death if they broke the engagement. The technical Heb phrase for making a covenant is “to cut a covenant.” There is an interesting passage in Herodotus iii.8, concerning an Arabian custom which seems akin to the old Heb practice. ‘‘The Arabians observe pledges as religiously as any peeple; and they make them in the following manner; when any wish to pledge their faith, a third person standing between the two parties makes an incision with a sharp stene in the palm of the hand, nearest the longest fingers ef beth the contracters; then taking seme of the nap from the garments of each, he smears seven stones placed hetween him and the bleed; and as he dees this he invokes Bacchus and Urania. When this ceremeny is completed, the persen who pledges his faith binds his friends as sureties to the stranger, or the citizen, if the contract is made with a citizen, and the friends also hold themselves obliged to observe the engage- ment’-——Cary’s tr. Whatever the particular application of the word in ver 17, the central idea in the passage is that death, blood-shedding, is necessary to the estab- lishment of the covenant, and so he affirms that the first covenant was not dedicated without blood, and in proof quotes the passage already cited from Ex 24, and concludes that ‘apart from shedding of blood there is no remission”? (ver 22). See Covz- NANT IN NT. This new covenant established by Christ was fore- told by the prophet Jeremiah, who uses the very word ‘new covenant” in describing it, and 7. Relation verylikely Christ had that description in to Jer 31: mind when Heused the term, and meant 31-34 His disciples to understand that the prophetic interpretation would in Him be realized. There is no doubt that the author of He had the passage in mind, for he has led up to the previous statement by definitely quoting the whole statement of Jer 31 31-34. He hadin ch 7 spoken of the contrast between Christ’s priesthood ‘after the order of Melchizedek” (ver id) and the imper- fect Aaronic priesthood, and he designates Jesus as “the surety of a better covenant” (ver 22). Then in ch 8, emphasizing the thought of the superiority of Christ’s heavenly high-priesthood, he declares that Christ is the “mediator of a better covenant, which hath been enacted upon better promises” (ver 6). The first covenant, he says, was not fault- less, otherwise there would have been no need for a second; but the fault was not in the covenant but in the people who failed to keep it, though perhaps there is also the suggestion that the external imposi- tion of laws could not suffice to secure true obedience. “For finding fault with them he saith, Behold the days come, saith the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah.” The whole passage (chs 8-12) would repay careful study, but we need only note that not only is there prominence given to the great blessings of the covenant, perfect forgiveness and fulness of knowledge, but, as the very essence of the covenant—that which serves to distinguish it from the old covenant and at once to show its superiority and guarantee its permanence—there is this wonder- ful provision: ‘I will put my laws into their mind, and on their heart also will I write them: and I will be to them a’God, and they shall be to mea people.” This at once shows the spirituality of the new covenant. Its requirements are not simply given in the form of external rules, but the living Spirit possesses the heart; the law becomes an internal dominating principle, and so true obedience is secured. Ezekiel had spoken to the same effect, though the word ‘new covenant” is not used in the passage, ch 36 27: “T will put my Spirit within 8. To you, and cause you to walk in my Ezekiel statutes, and ye shall keep mine ordinances, and do them.” In ch 37 Ezekiel again speaks of the great blessings to be enjoyed by the people of God, including cleansing, walking in God’s statutes, recognition as God’s pe etc, and he distinctly says of this era of lessing: ‘I will make a covenant of peace with them j it shall be_an everlasting covenant with them” (ver 26). Other important foreshadowings of the new covenant are found in Isa 54 10; 55 3; 59 21; 61 8; Hos 2 18-28; Mal 3 1-4. We may well marvel at the spiritual insight of these prophets, and it is impossible to attribute their forecasts to natural genius; they can only be accounted for by Divine inspiration. The writer to the Hebrews recurs again and again to this theme of the ‘‘“New Covenant”; in 10 16.17 ‘he cites the words of Jeremiah already quoted about writing the law on their minds, and remembering their sins no more. In 12 24, he speaks of “Jesus the mediator of a new covenant,” and “the blood of sprinkling,” again connecting the “blood” with the “covenant,” and finally, in 18 20, he prays for the perfection of the saints through the “blood of an eternal covenant.” In 2 Cor 3 Paul has an interesting and instruct- ive contrast between the old covenant and the new. He begins it by saying that “our sufficiency is 733 from God; who also made us sufficient as ministers of a new covenant; not of the letter, but of the spirit: for the letter killeth, but the 9. Contrast Spirit giveth life’ (vs 5.6). The of Old and ‘letter’ is the letter of the law, of the Newin2 old covenant which could only bring Cor 3 condemnation, but the spirit which characterizes the new covenant gives life, writes the law upon the heart. He goes on to speak of the old as that “ministration of death” which nevertheless ‘‘came with glory” (ver 7), and he refers esp. to the law, but the new covenant is “the ministration of the spirit,’ the ‘ministration of righteousness” (vs 8.9), and has a far greater glory than the old. The message of this ‘‘new covenant”’ is “the gospel of Christ.’’ The glory of the new covenant is focused in Christ; rays forth from Him. The glory of the old dispensation was reflected upon the face of Moses, but that glory was transitory and so was the physical manifestation (ver 18). The sight of the shining face of Moses awed the people of Israel and they revered him as a leader specially favored of God (vs 7-13). When he had delivered his message he veiled his face and thus the people could not see that the glow did not last; every time that he went into the Divine presence he took off the veil and afresh his face was lit up with the glory, and coming out. with the traces of that glory lingering on his countenance he de- livered his message to the people and again veiled his face (cf Ex 34 29-85), and thus the transitori- ness and obscurity of the old dispensation were sym- bolized. In glorious contrast to that symbolical obscurity, the ministers of the gospel, of the new cove- nant, use great boldness of speech; the veil is done away in Christ (vs 12 ff). The glory which comes through Him is perpetual, and fears no vanishing away. ArcHIBALD M’Caic COVER, kuv’ér, COVERING, kuv’ér-ing: The tr of several Heb words. The covering of the ark (FADD, mikhseh, Gen 8 13) was possibly the lid of a hatchway (cf Mitchell, World before Abraham, 215). To the sons of Kohath was assigned the task of caring for the furniture of the Tabernacle whenever the camp was moved, a suitable covering (OD, kdsah) of sealskin being designated for each of the specially sacred objects, the temple curtains also being used (Nu 4 8.9.11.12 ff). Nu 19 15 (camidh) may refer to anything used as a lid or covering; Job 24 7; 31 19 (k¢suth) refer to clothing or bed-covering. ; Figurative: ‘Abaddon hath no covering” (k*sith) from God (Job 26 6); “He will destroy ... . the face of the covering [ha-lat] that covereth all peoples” (Isa 26 7). The removal of the veil, often worn as a token of mourning (cf 2 § 19 4), signified the destruction of death. W. TEARNS COVERED WAY, kuv’érd wa (70%, mésakh, “a covered walk’’): Mentioned in 2 K 16 18 (AV “covert’’) as a gallery belonging to the temple, con- cerning the purpose of which opinions differ. Some consider it to have been the place where the king stood or sat during the Sabbath services; others, a public place for teaching; others, the way by which ° the priest entered the sanctuary on the Sabbath. COVERING, kuv’ér-ing, FOR THE HEAD (repi- Bératov, peribélaion): Mentioned in the NT only in 1 Cor 11 15: “¥or her hair is given her for a cover- ing,” lit. “something cast round,” probably equiva- lent to “veil” (q.v.). Read in the light of the context: “Every woman praying or prophesying with her head unveiled dishonoreth her head’”’ (ver 5). The meaning would seem to be that Nature it- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Covenant, New Covetousness self, in providing women with a natural veil, has taught the lesson underlying the prevailing custom, that woman should not be unveiled in the public assemblies. Gro. B. Hacer COVERT, kuv’ért: Now seldom used, except for game, and then génerally spelt “cover.” “A covered way” (2 K 16 18 AV); also a shelter of any kind (Isa 4 6); “a hiding place,” “a lair,” “a hut” (Job 38 40); “a place of secrecy,” “‘a secret way” (1 S 25 20; Job 40 21; Ps 61 4; Isa 16 4; 32 2); “aden,” “a lair” (Jer 25 38). COVET, kuv’et (TIN, *dwah; tyrde, 22160, “to desire earnestly,” “‘to set the heart and mind upon anything”): Used in two senses: good, simply to desire earnestly but legitimately, e.g. AV 1 Cor 12 31; 14 39; bad, to desire unlawfully, or to secure il- legitimately (VE3, baa‘; ércduuéw, epithuméd, Rom 7 7; 13 9, etc); hence called “lust’’ (Mt 5 28; sor 10 6), “‘concupiscence’” (AV Rom 7 8; Col COVETOUSNESS, kuv’et-us-nes: Has a variety of shades of meaning determined largely by the nature of the particular word used, or the context, or both. Following are some of the uses: (1) To gain dishonestly (¥Z2, bdca‘), e.g. AV Ex 18 21; Ezk 38 31. (2) The wish to have more than one possesses, inordinately, of course (mAcovetla, pleo- nexta), e.g. Lk 12 15; 1 Thess 2 5. (3) An in- ordinate love of money (¢Adpyupos, phildrguros, AV Lk 16 14; 2 Tim 3 2; philarguria, 1 Tim 6 10); negative in He 13 5 AV. Covetousness is a very grave sin; indeed, so heinous is it that the Scriptures class it among the very gravest and grossest crimes (Eph 6 3). In Col 3 5 it is “idolatry,” while in 1 Cor 6 10 it is set. forth as excluding a man from heaven. Its heinousness, doubtless, is accounted for by its being in a very real sense the root of so many other forms of sin, e.g. departure from the faith (1 Tim 6 9.10); lying (2 K 6 22-25); theft (Josh 7 21); domestic trouble (Prov 15 27); murder (Ezk 22 12); in- deed, it leads to “many foolish and hurtful lusts” (1 Tim 6 9). Covetousness has always been a very serious menace to mankind, whether in the OT or NT period. It was one of the first sins that broke out after Israel had entered into the promised land (Achan, Josh 7); and also in the early Chris- tian church immediately after its founding (Ananias and Sapphira, Acts 5); hence so many warnings against it. A careful reading of the OT will reveal the fact that a very great part of the Jewish law— such as its enactments and regulations regarding duties toward the poor, toward servants; concern- ing gleaning, usury, pledges, gold and silver taken during war—was introduced and intended to counteract the spirit of covetousness. Eerdmans maintains (Expos, July, 1909) that the commandment, ‘Thou shalt not covet thy neigh- bor’s house” (Ex 20 17), meant to the Israelite that he should not take anything of his neighbor's poets that were momentarily unprotected y their owner. Cf Ex 34 23 ff. Thus, it refers to a category of acts that is not covered by the commandment, ‘Thou shalt not steal.” It is an oriental habit of mind from of old that when any- one sees abandoned goods which he thinks desirable, there is not the least objection to taking them, and Ex 20 170 is probably an explanation of what is to be understood by ‘“‘house” in ver 17a. Examples of covetousness: Achan (Josh 7); Saul (1 8 15 9.19); Judas (Mt 26 14.15); Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 6 1-11); Balaam (2 Pet 2 15 with Jude ver 11). Wiuiiam Evans Cow, Kine Crafts THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 734 COW, kou, KINE, kin (p3, bakar [cf Arab. bakar, “‘cow’’]; “pa rbay, ‘eghlath bakar [Isa 7 21]; TW , pdrah [cf Arab. furar, “young of a sheep, goat, or cow’y; niby MMS, paroth ‘dloth [1 8 6 7.10), “milch kine,” from D3, ‘al, “to suckle”; aDN, ’eleph): In Am 4 1, the term, “‘kine of Bashan,”’ is applied to the voluptuous women of Samaria. In Gen 41 1-36 is the narration of Pharaoh’s dream of the seven fat and seven lean kine. In Isaiah’s vision (Isa 11 7) we have: ‘And the cow and the hear shall feed; their young ones shall lie down together.” Cows do not seem to have been sacrificed. The sacrifice of the kine that brought the ark back from the Philis (1 S 6 14) was due to the exceptional circumstances. See CALF; CATTLE. : Atrrep ELy Day COZ, koz (Pp, kde, “thorn’”): A man of Judah (1 Ch 4 8). ARV has added the art., making the name Hakkoz without sufficient reason. The name occurs with the art. (Ha-kd¢) in Ezr 2 61; Neh 3 4.21; 7 63, and 1 Ch 24 10, but not with reference to the same person. Coz was of the tribe of Judah, while Hakkoz helonged to the family of Aaron. COZBI, koz’bi (STD, kozb?, “deceitful”): A Midianitish woman, distinguished as the daughter of Zur, “‘head of the people of a fathers’ house in Midian.” She was slain by Phinehas at Shittim in company with ‘‘Zimri, the son of Salu, a prince ot a ‘a house among the Simeonites” (Nu 25 18). COZEBA, ko-zé’ba (1 Ch 4 22). CRACKNEL, krak’nel: Occurs in 1 K 14 3, where Jeroboam hids his wife go to Abijah to in- quire concerning their son: ‘And take with thee ten loaves and cracknels’ (AVm “cakes,” ERV ‘“cracknels,” ARV ‘‘cakes’). The Heb word is See AcuziB. Dp), nikkuddim, from ndkadh, “to prick” or “mark”; most probably cakes with holes pricked in them like our biscuits. 3 CRAFT, kraft, CRAFTINESS, kraf’ti-nes (ravoup- yla, panourgia), CRAFTY, kraf’ti (mwavetpyos, pa- nourgos): The original meaning is that of “ability to do anything,” universally applied in a bad sense to unscrupulous wickedness, that stops short of no measure, however reprehensible, in order to attain its purposes; then, in a modified form, to resource- fulness in wrong, cunning (Dnl 8 25; 2 Macc 12 24; RVm “jugglery”). In Lk 20 23, Jesus per- ceives ‘‘the craftiness’’ of His adversaries, i.e. the complicated network which they have laid to en- snare Him. The art with which‘a plot is concealed, and its direction to the ruin of others, are elements that enter into the meaning. Heinrici on 1 Cor 3 19 illustrates from Plato the distinction between craftiness and wisdom. There is a touch of humor in 2 Cor 12 16, when Paul speaks of his conduct toward the Corinthians as having heen “crafty.” H. E. Jacoss CRAFTS: I. Sources or Our Know.LEDGE OF THE CRAFTS OF THE BIBLE 1. Written Records and Discoveries of Crafts- manship (1) Jewish (2) Canaanitish and Phoenician 3) Assyrian and Babylonian 4) Egyptian ost-Biblical Writings . Present Methods in Bible Lands RAFTS MENTIONED 1N THE BIBLE Brickmaking 4 Carpentering (Wood-Working) Carving (Engraving) Ceramics . Dyeing and Cleansing . Embroidering (Needlework) oN II. PMP LOMO 7. Glass-Making 8. Grinding 9. Mason Work me 10. Metal-Working (Mining) 11. Oil-Making 12. Painting 13. Paper-Making 14, Perfume-Making 15. Plastering : 16. Spinning and Weaving 17. Tanning 18. Tent-Making 19. Wine-Making III. Crarrsmen LiveRATURE I. Sources of Our Knowledge.—Our knowledge of the arts and crafts of Bible times has come to us through two principal ways. First, 1. Written from Bib., Assyr, Bab and Egyp Records written records. Of these the Egyp and Dis- are the most illuminating. Second, coveries of from examples of ancient handicraft Craftsman- which have heen buried and preserved ship through many cents. and brought to light again by modern discoveries. (1) Jewish craftsmanship—The chief written documents from which we may learn ahout Heb handicraft are the Bible records. A study of what few references there are leads us to believe that before the Israelites came in contact with the people of Canaan and Phoenicia they had not developed any considerable technical skill (1 K 5 6; 1 Ch 14.1; 2 Ch 27.14; Ezr 3 7). Some of the sim- pler operations, such as the spinning and weaving of the common fabrics and the shaping of domes- tic utensils, were performed in the household (Ex 35 25.26) but the weaving and dyeing of fine fabrics, carving, inlaying, metal-working, etc, was the work of foreigners, or was learned by the Jews after the Exodus, from the dwellers in Pal. The Jews, however, gradually developed skill in many of these crafts. It is helieved that as early as Nehemiah’s time, Jewish craftsmen had organ- ized into guilds (Neh 3 8.31.32). In post-Bib. times the Jews obtained monopolies in some of the industries, as for example, glass-making and dyeing. These trades remained the secrets of certain fami- lies for generations. It is hecause of this secrecy and the mystery that surrounded these trades, and is still maintained in many places, that we know so little as to how they were conducted. Until re- cently the principal indigo dyers in Damascus were Jews, and the Jews shared with Moslem crafts- men the right to make glass. In some of the Syrian cities Jewish craftsmen are now outnumbering other native workmen in certain trades. Few examples of Heb handicraft have been dis- covered by the archaeologists which shed much light upon early Heb work. Aside from the pottery of the Israelitish period, and a few seals and coins, no traces of Heb workmanship remain. It is even doubtful how many of the above objects are really the work of this people. (2) Canaanitish and Phoenician craftsmanship.— It is generally conceded that what technical skill the Hebrews acquired resulted from their contact with the Canaanites and Phoenicians. Frequent mention of the workmanship of these peoples is made in the Bible, but their own records are silent. Ezekiel’s account of the glories of Tyre (Ezk 27) gives some idea of the reputation of that city for craftsmanship: “Thy builders have perfected thy beauty” (ver 4); “Syria was thy merchant...” Damascus was thy merchant for the multitude of thy handiworks” (vs 16.18). Adad-nirari III (812- 783 BC), the Assyr king, enumerates the tribute which he exacted from the king of Damascus. “Variegated cloth, linen, an ivory bed, a seat of inlaid ivory, a table’ were among the captured arti- cles. These were probably Phoen work. 735 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cow, Kine Crafts Many examples of Phoen craftsmanship have been discovered. These are characterized, from the standpoint of art, by a crudeness which distin- guishes them from the more delicately and artis- tically wrought work of their teachers, the Baby- lonians and Egyptians. The credit remains, however, to the Phoenicians of introducing skilled workmanship into Pal. The Phoenicians, too, fur- nished the means of intercourse hetween the Baby- lonians and Egyptians. From the very earliest times there was an interchange of commodities and ideas hetween the people of the Nile and those of the Tigris and Euphrates. (3) Assyrian and Babylonian craftsmanship. The Babylonians and Assyrians made few refer- ences to their own handicraft in their records; but the explorers of recent years have revealed many examples of the remarkable workmanship of the early inhabitants of Mesopotamia. In referring to a silver vase found in that country (Telloh), dating from the 4th millennium BC, Clay (see “Literature’’) says “‘the whole is exceedingly well rendered and indicates remarkable skill, which in no respect is less striking than that of Egyp con- temporaries in this handicraft.” Jewelry, weapons, votive images, various utensils, tools of many kinds, statues in the hardest stones, delicately wrought, gems, dating from the times of Abraham and earher, lead us to ask when these people acquired their skill. (4) Egyptian craftsmanship.—The written records of Egypt are doubly important, because they not only refer to the various crafts, but 2.and3. —_ also illustrate the processes hy drawings Egyptian which can leave no doubt as to how and Post- the workmen accomplished their ends. Biblical The extensive explorations in Egypt Craftsman- have given to the world many priceless ship relics of craftsmanship, some of them dating from the very dawn of civiliza- tion. Among the ruins of early Syrian and Pales- tinian cities are found numerous objects witnessing to the skill of the Egyptians. These objects and the evidences of the influence of their work on the Phoen arts show the part that the Egyptians played in moulding the ideas of the workmen who were chosen to build the temple at Jerus. In the following brief summary of the crafts mentioned in the Bible, it will he noticeable how well they may be illustrated by the monuments of the Nile country. To confirm the knowledge derived from the above sources, post-Bih. writings and some of the present-day customs in Bible lands are valuable. These will be mentioned in discussing the various crafts. Il. Crafts Directly or Indirectly Mentioned in the Bible.—(For 2 more detailed treatment of the crafts see under separate arts.) This industry probably originated in Baby- lonia, but the knowledge of the process was early carried to Egypt, where later the Hebrews, along with other captives, were driven to making the bricks of the Egyp kings. The mak- ing of sun-dried bricks called for little skill, but the firing and glazing of bricks required trained work- men. See Brick. : Wood was extensively used by ancient builders. With the exception of the Egyp antiquities, little remains but the records to indicate 1. Brick- making 2. Carpen- this fact. Numerous references are tering made to the carpenter work in build- (Wood- ing the temple and subsequent repair- Working) ing of this structure (1 K 5 6; 2 Ch 23; 2K1211; 2 Ch 2412; 2K 22 6; Ezr 37; 41). David’s house and that of Solomon and his favorite wife were made partly of wood. In the story of the building of the tabernacle, wood-working is mentioned (Ex 25). The people of Tyre built ships of cypress, with masts of cedar wood and oars of oak (Ezk 27 5.6). Idols were carved from wood (Dt 29 17; 2 K 19 18; Isa 37 19; 45 20). The Philis built a wooden cart to carry the ark (1 S 6 7). Threshing instru- ments and yokes were made of wood (2 S 24 22). Ezra read the law from a pulpit of wood (Neh 8 4). Solomon’s chariots were made of wood (Cant 3 9). Inlaid work, still a favorite form of decoration in Syria, was used by the Phoenicians (Ezk 27 $4). How the ancient carpenters did their work can be assumed from the Egyp monuments. Some of the operations there pictured are still performed in the same ways. See Toous; CARPENTER. The terms “carving” and “engraving” are used interchangeably in translating OT passages. The first mention made of engraved objects 3. Carving is the signet of Judah (Gen 38 18). (Engraving) The art of engraving on various hard objects, such as clay, bone, ivory, metals and precious stones, probably came from Mesopotamia. The Hehrews learned engraving from the Canaanites. The nature of this engraving is shown by the Assyr cylinders and Egyp scarabs. It is doubtful how many of the signets found in Pal are Heb work, as the engraved devices are mostly Phoen or Egyp. From the earliest times it has been the custom in the Orient for men of affairs to carry constantly with them their signets. The seal was set in a ring, or, as was the case with Judah, and as the Arahs do today, it wag worn on a cord suspended about the neck. One of the present-day sights in a Syrian city street is the engraver of sig- nets, seated at his low hench ready to cut on one of his blank seals the buyer’s name or sign. The second form of carving is suggested by the Decalogue (Ex 20 4). The commandment explains why sculpturing remained undeveloped among the Jews, as it has to this day among the Moslems. In spite of the commandment, however, cherubim were carved on the wooden fittings of the temple interior (1 K 6 28). Among the peoples with whom the Jews came in contact, stone-cutting had reached a high degree of perfection. No stone proved too hard for their tools. In Egyp and Phoen tombs the carving was often done on plastered surfaces. See CaRvine. Both the Egyptians and Babylonians were skilled in molding and baking objects of clay. The early Bab records consist of burnt clay tab- 4. Ceramics lets. Glazed bricks formed an impor- tant decorative feature. In Egypt, idols, scarabs and amulets were often made of fired clay, glazed or unglazed. By far the most im- portant branch of ceramic art was the making of Jars for holding water’or other liquids. These jars have been used throughout the East from earliest times. The Jews learned what they knew about this art from the Phoenicians. See Potrery. Dyeing is one of the oldest of the crafts. The only references to the act of dyeing in the Bible are (a) in connection with the dyed skins of 6. Dyeing animals (Ex 25 5; 26 14), and (b) Jgs and Cleans- 6 30. That it was a highly developed ing trade is implied in the many other references to dyed stuffs both in the Bible and in profane lit. Cleansing was done by the fuller, who was probably a dyer also. See CoLor; Dye; FuLuer. Very little is known of the work of embroidering, further than that it was the working-in of color designs on cloth. In Ezk 27 7 we 6. Embroid- learn that it was one of the exports ering of Egypt. See EmBrorpERinG. (Needle- In Dt 33 19 “hidden treasures of work) the sand” is interpreted by some to mean the making of glass objects from the sand. There can be no question about the Crafts Crashing THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 736 Hebrews being acquainted with glass-making, as its history extends back to very early times. The Egyptians and Phoenicians made 7. Glass- bottles, glass beads, idols, etc. These Making objects are among those usually found in the tombs. Glass beads of very early manufacture were found in the mound at Gezer. Some of the pigments used for painting were made of powdered colored glass. In the NT we read of the “‘sea of glass like unto crystal” (Rev 4 6). See Guass. Grinding was a domestic task and can hardly be classed as one of the crafts. When flour was needed, the housewife, or more likely the serv- 8. Grinding ant, rubbed the wheat or barley between two millstones (see MILL- STONE) or, with a rounded river stone, crushed the wheat on a large flat stone. It is still a common custom in Syria and Pal for two women to work together as indicated in Mt 24 41 and Lk 17 35. Grinding of meal was a menial task, considered the employment of a concubine; hence setting Samson to grinding at the mill was intended as a disgrace. Therhythmic sound of the stone cutter at his work never. ceases in the prosperous oriental city. It is More common today, however, than in the earlier cents. when only high officials could afford stone houses. Frequently only the temple or shrines or tombs of a city were made of stone. As such buildings were very common, and much attention was paid to every detail of their construction, there was developed an efficient corps of masons, espe- cially in Egypt and Syria. When the Israelites abandoned their nomadic life, among the first things that they planned were permanent places of worship. As these developed into structures more pretentious than mere piles of stones, the builders naturally resorted +o the skill of the master builders of the country. A visitor to Jerus may still see the work of the ancient masons. The so- called Solomon’s quarries under the city, the great drafted stones of the temple area, belong to an early date. The very shape of the masons’ tools may be determined from the marks on the stones. See Mason. Among the oldest objects that have been pre- served are those of silver, gold and bronze. These are proof that the ancients understood 10. Metal- the various processes of mining, smelt- 9. Mason Work Working _ing, refining and working of metals. (Mining) See Minina; Metat-WorkIna. The oil referred to in the Bible is olive oil. Pliny mentions many other oils which were extracted in Egypt. The oils were usually ex- tracted by first crushing the fruit and 11. Oil- then pressing the crushed mass. At Making Gezer, Tell es Sdfi and other ancient ruins old oil presses have been discov- ered. See Orn. One who has visited the tombs and temples of Egypt will never forget the use which the ancient Egyp painters made of colors. The otherwise somber effect produced by expansive plain walls was overcome by sculpturing, either in relief or intaglio, ‘on a coating of stucco,.and then coloring these engravings in reds, yellows, greens and blues. Architectural details were also painted. The capi- tals of columns and the columns themselves received special attention from the painter. Colors were similarly used by the Greeks and Phoenicians. In the Sidon tombs, at Palmyra and similar ruins, traces of painting are still evident. See Painrinc. The word ‘‘paper’” occurs twice, once in the OT (Isa 19 7 AV) and once in NT (2 Jn ver 12). In Isa 19 7 the RV renders “paper reeds,” 12. Paint- ing “meadows.” Papyrus (q.v.) occurs in Isa 18 2 and RVm of Ex 23. The nearest approach to our paper which the ancients possessed was that made from a species of papy- rus. The process consisted in spreading out, side by side, long strips of the inner lining of the papyrus reed, then over these other strips at right angles to the first, afterward soaking with some adhesive material and finally pressing and drying. Sheets made in this way were fastened together with glue into a long scroll. The Gr for papyrus plant is “biblos,”’ from which the’ Eng. word ‘‘Bible”’ is derived. Parchment, leather and leaves were also used as paper. The natives of Syria and Pal still call a sheet of paper a “‘leaf” (Arab. waraket). The art of perfume-making dates back to the ancient Egyptians. In Ex 30 35 we have the first mention of scented anointing oils. 13. Paper- Making 14. Per- The perfumers’ (AV_ “confectioner” fume- or “apothecary”) products were used Making (a) for religious rites as offerings and to anoint the idols and (6) for per- sonal use on the body or clothes. Some perfumes were powders (incense); others were scented oils or fats (ointments). See PERFUME. The trade of plastering dates back to the begin- ning of the history of building. There were two x reasons for using plastering or stucco: 15. Plaster- (a) to render the buildings more re- ing (AV sisting to the weather and (b) to make “Plaister- the surfaces more suitable for decora- ing’’) tion by engraving or painting. See Paster. The arts of spinning and weaving were early practised in the household (Ex 35 25). Many different fibers were spun and woven 16. Spin- into cloth. Fabrics of wool, cotton, ning and flax, silk, wood fiber have been pre- Weaving served from Bible times. In the more progressive communities, the weaving of the fabrics was taken over by the weavers who made it their profession. In1 Ch 4 21 it is stated that many of the families of the house of Asbea were workers in fine linen. The modern invasion of European manufacturers has not yet driven out the weavers who toil at looms much like those described by the ancient Egyp drawings. See Sprn- NING; WEAVING. Although it is known that tanning was practised, the only reference to this trade mentioned in the Bible is to Simon the tanner (Acts 9 17. Tanning 48; 10 6.32). Leather girdles are men- tioned in 2K 18; Mt34. Relics taken from the tombs show that the ancients under- stood the various methods for preserving skins which are used in present-day practice. See TANNER. We think of Paul as the tent-maker. The tents which he made however were probably not like those so frequently referred to in the 18. Tent- OT. Tents in Paul’s time were made Making from Cilician eloth. Paul’s work was probably the sewing together of the proper lengths of cloth and the attaching of ropes and loops. In OT times the tents were made of strips of coarse goat’s hair cloth or of the skins of animals. See Tent. This art. is being written within sound of fes- tivities about the winepresses of Mt. Lebanon i where men and women are gathered 19. Wine- for the annual production of wine and Making molasses (Arab. dibs). Their process is so like that of Bible times that one is transported in thought to similar festivities that must have attended the wine-making even so far back as the early Egyp kings. That these workers understood the precautions necessary for procuring 737 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Crafts Crashing a desirable product is evidenced by early writings. The choice of proper soil for the vineyards, the adding of preservatives to keep the wine, boiling the juice to kill undesirable ferments, guarding against putting new wine‘ into old bottles, are ex- amples of their knowledge of wine-making. See Wine Press. HI, Craftsmen.—Craftsmen were early segre- gated into groups. A trade usually remained in a family. This is true to some extent in the East today. In such cities as Beirit, Damascus, or Aleppo the shops of the craftsmen of a given trade will be found grouped together. There is a silver and goldsmiths’ market (Arab. s#k), an iron market, a dyeing quarter, etc. Jewish craftsmen in early times sat separately in the synagogues. Some crafts were looked upon with disfavor, esp. those which brought men in contact with women, as for example, the trade of goldsmith, carder, weaver, fuller or tanner. There was a fellow-feeling among craftsmen referred to by Isaiah (Isa 41 6.7). This same feeling is observed among Syrian workmen today. The Arab has many phrases of encourage- ment for a man at his work, such as, ‘‘Peace to your hands,” ‘“‘May God give you strength.”’ A crowd of men pulling at a pulley rope, for example, shout or sing together as they pull. LiveRATURE.—Perrot and Chipiez, History of Art in Sardinia, Judaea, etc; History of Artin Ancient Egypt; History of Art in Phoenicia and Cyprus; Wilkinson, The Ancient Egyptians; Macalister, Bible Sitde-Lights fram the Mound of Gezer; Standard Dict. of the Bible; Bliss, Macalister and Wiinsch, Excavations in Pal; Hilprecht, Ex- plorations in Bible Lands during the 19th Cent.; Harper, The Bibleand Madern Discovertes; Delitzsch, Jewish Artisan Life, etc; Clay, Light on the OT from Babel; Jew Enc. : James A. Parco CRAG, krag (JU, shén[I S 7 12; 14 4; Job 39 28 AV and ERV]): Ina mountainous country composed of sedimentary rocks, like the cretaceous rocks of Pal, cliffs are formed on a slope where hard strata are underlaid by softer strata. The soft strata wear away more rapidly, undermining the hard strata above them, which for a time project, but finally break off by vertical joint planes, the fragments rolling down to form the talus slope at the foot of the cliff. As the breaking off of the undermined hard strata proceeds irregularly, there are left projecting crags, sometimes at the top of the cliff, and sometimes lower down. Two such crags (shén ha-sela‘, ‘sharp rock,” RV “rocky erag’’), which were given particular names, Bozez and Seneb, marked the scene of the exploit of Jonathan de- scribed in I § 14. Conder failed to identify the crags, and it has been proposed to alter the text rather extensively to make 1t read: ‘“‘wall of rock” instead of ‘‘crag” (EB s.v. “Michmash’). Such rocks form safe resting-places for birds of prey, as it is said of the eagle in Job 39 28 ERV: — “She dwelleth on the rock and hath her Jodaing there, Upon the crag of the rock, and the stronghold.” Aurrep Evy Day CRANE, kran (WW, ‘dghtir; yépavos, géranos; Lat Grus cinerea): A bird of the family gruidae. The crane is mentioned twice in the Bible: once on account of its voice (Isa 38 14: “Like a swallow or a crane, so did J chatter’); again because of the unforgettable picture these birds made in migra- tion (Jer 8 7): ‘Yea, the stork in the heavens knoweth her appointed times; and the turtle-dove and the swallow and the crane observe the time of their coming; but my people know not the law of Jeh.”” Some commentators have adduced reasons for dropping the crane from the ornithology of the Bible, but this never should be permitted. They were close relatives of stork, heron and ibis; almost as numerous as any of these, and residents of Pal, except in migration. The two quotations concern- ing them fit with their history, and point out the two features that made them as noticeable as any birds of Pal. Next to the ostrich and pelican they were the largest birds, having a wing sweep of 8 ft. from tip to tip and standing 4 ft.in height. In migra- tion such immense flocks passed over Pal as to darken the sky, and when they crossed the Red Sea they appeared to sweep from shore to shore, and so became the most noticeable migratory bird, for which reason, no doubt, they were included in Isaiah’s reference to spring migration with the ir ta b Bs Crane—Grus cinerea. beloved doves, used in sacrifice and for caged pets, and with the swallows that were held almost sacred because they homed in temples. Not so many of them settled in Pal as of the storks, but large flocks lived in the wilderness S. of Jerus, and a few pairs homed near water as far north as Merom, The grayish-brown cranes were the largest, and there were also a crested, and a whitecrane. They nested on the ground or in trees and laid two large eggs, Geos with species. The eggs of the brown bird were a light drab with brown speckles, and those of the white, rough, pale-blue with brown splotches. They were not so affectionate in pairs or to their young as storks, but were average parents. It is altogether probable that they were the birds intended by Isaiah, because they best suited his purpose, the crane and the swallow being almost incessant talkers among birds. The word “chat- ter,” used in the Bible, exactly suits the notes of a swallow, but is much too feeble to be used in de- scribing the vocalizing of the crane. They mi- grated in large wedge-shaped companies and cried constantly on wing. They talked incessantly while at the business of living, and even during the watches of the night they scarcely ceased passing along word that all was well, or sending abroad danger signals. The Arabs called the cry of the cranes “bellowing.” We usually express it by whooping or trumpeting. Any of these words is sufficiently expressive to denote an unusual voice, used in au unusual manner, so that it appealed to the prophet as suitable for use in a strong comparison. Genre STRATTON-PORTER CRASHING, krash’ing ((2W, shebher): This word, meaning “a, breach,” fig. “destruction,” is tr? “crashing” in Zeph 1 10: ‘a great crashing from the hills,” representing the doom to fall on evil-doers in Jerus, as the enemy advanced against the city from the north. Crates’ Creation THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 738 CRATES, kra’téz (Kparns, Krdtés), governor of the Cyprians, left as deputy of Sostratus when the latter, who was governor of Jerus, was summoned to Antioch by Antiochus Epiphanes, in consequence of a dispute with Menelaus (2 Macc 4 29). As Cyprus was not at the time in the possession of Antiochus, the words have been generally taken to mean Krates “who had formerly been, or after- ward was, governor of the Cypnians.”’ The Vulg translates the Gr into “Sostratus autem praelatus est Cypriis.” CREATION, kré-a’shun (S72, bara’, “to create”; krlovs, ktisis, ‘that which is created,” ‘“creature”): . Creation as Abiding 2. Mistaken Ideas 3. True Conception 4. The Genesis Cosmogony ee Matter not Eternal 7 8. rR . “Wisdom” in Creation . A Free, Personal Act . Creation and Evolution 9. Is Creation Eternal ? 10. Creation ex nihilo 11. From God’s Will 12. Error of Pantheism 13. First Cause a Necessary Presupposition 14. The End—the Divine Glory LirbratuRs Much negative ground has been cleared away for any modern discussion of the doctrine of creation. No idea of creation can now be taken 1. Creation as complete which does not include, as Abiding besides the world as at first consti- tuted, all that to this day is in and of creation. For God creates not being that can exist independently of Him, His preserving agency being inseparably connected with His creative power. We have long ceased to think of God’s creation as a machine left, completely made, to its own auto- matic working. With such a doctrine of creation, a theistic evolution would be quite incompatible. Just as little do we think of God’s creative agency, as merely that of a First Cause, linked to the universe from the outside by 2. Mistaken innumerable sequences of causes and Ideas ° effects. Nature in her entirety is as much His creation today as she ever was. The dynamic ubiquity of God, as efficient energy, is to be affirmed. God is still All and in All, but this in a way sharply distinguished from panthe- istic views, whether of the universe as God, or of God as the universe. Of His own freedom He creates, so that gnostic theories of natural and necessary emanation are left far behind. Not only have the “carpenter” and the ‘gardener’? theories—with, of course, the architect or world-builder theory of Plato—been dismissed; not only has the conception of evolution been proved harmonious with creative end, plan, purpose, ordering, guidance; but evo- lutionary science may itself be said to have given the thought of theistic evolution its best base or grounding. The theistic conception is, that the world—that all cosmic existences, substances, events —depend upon God. The doctrine of creation—of the origin and per- sistence, of all finite existences—as the work of God, is a necessary postulation of the re- 3. True ligious consciousness. Such conscious- Conception ness is marked by deeper insight than belongs to science. The underlying truth is the anti-patheistic one, that the energy and wisdom—by which that, which was not, became— were, in kind, other than its own. For science can but trace the continuity of sequences in all Nature, while in creation, in its primary sense, this law of continuity must be transcended, and the world viewed solely as product of Divine Intelligence, immanent in its evolution. For God is the Abso- lute Reason, always immanent in the developing universe. Apart from the cosmogonic attempts at the beginning of Genesis, which are clearly religious and ethical in scope and character, the OT furnishes no theoretic account of the manner and order in which creative process is earried on. The early chs of Genesis were, of course, not given to reveal the truths of physical science, but they recognize creation as marked by 4. The order, continuity, law, plastic power of Genesis productiveness in the different king- Cosmogony doms, unity of the world and progress- ive advance. The Genesis cosmogony teaches a process of becoming, as well as a creation (see EvotuTion). That cosmogony has been recog- nized by Haeckel as meritoriously marked by the two great ideas of separation or differentiation, and of progressive development or perfecting of the origi- nally simple matter. The OT presents the conception of time-worlds or successive ages, but its real em- phasis is on the energy of the Divine Word, bringing into being things that did not exist. The OT and the NT, in their doctrine of creation, recognize no eternal matter before creation. We cannot say that the origin of matter 5. Matter is excluded from the Genesis account not Eternal of creation, and this quite apart from the use of bara’, as admitting of ma- terial and means in creation. But it seems unwise to build upon Genesis passages that afford no more than a basis which has proved exegetically insecure. The NT seems to favor the derivation of matter from the non-existent—that is to say, the time- worlds were due to the effluent Divine Word or originative Will, rather than to being built out of God’s own invisible essence. So the best exegesis interprets He 11 3. In OT books, as the Pss, Prov, and Jer, the creation is expressly declared to be the work of ; Wisdom—a Wisdom not disjomed from 6. “Wis- , Goodness, as is yet more fully brought dom” in out in the Book of Job. The heavens Creation declare the glory of God, the world manifests or reveals Him to our ex- perience, as taken up and interpreted by the religious consciousness. The primary fact of the beginning of the time-worlds—the basal fact that the worlds came into being by the Word of God:—is something apprehensible only by the power of religious faith, as the only principle applicable to the case (He 11 3). Such intuitive faith is really an application of first principles in the highest—and a truly rational one (see Locos). In creation, God is but expressing or acting out the conscious Godhood that is in Him. In it the thought of His absolute Wisdom is realized by the action of His perfect Love. It is philosophi- cally necessary to maintain that God, as the Abso- lute Being, must find the end of creation in Himself. If the end were external to, and independent of, Him, then would He be conditioned thereby. What the religious consciousness is concerned to maintain is, the absolute freedom of God in the production of the universe, and the 7. AFree, fact that He is so much greater than Personal the universe that existence has been Act by Him bestowed on all things that do exist. The Scriptures are, from first to last, shot through with this truth. Neither Kant nor Spencer, from data of self-consciousness or sense- perception, can rise to the conception of creation, for they both fail to reach the idea of Divine Per- sonality. The inconceivability of creation has been pressed by Spencer, the idea of a self-existent Creator, through whose agency it has been made being to him unthinkable. As if it were not a transparent sophism, which Spencer’s own scien- tifie practice refuted, that a hypothesis may not have philosophical or scientific value, because it is 739 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Crates Creation what we call unthinkable or inconceivable. As if a true and sufficient cause were not enough, or a Divine act of will were not a vera causa. Depend- ent existence inevitably leads thought to demand existence that is not dependent. Creation is certainly not disproved by evolution, which does not explain the origin of the homogene- ous stuff itself, and does not account 8. Creation for the beginning of motion within it. and Evolu- Of the original creative action, lying tion beyond mortal ken or human observa- tiou, science—as concerned only with the manner of the process—is obviously in no posi- tion to speak. Creation may, in an important sense, be said not to have taken place in time, since time cannot be posited prior to the existence of the world. The difficulties of the ordinary hypothesis of a creation in time can never be surmounted, so long as we continue to make eternity mean simply indefinitely prolonged time. Augustine was, no doubt, right when, from the human standpoint, he declared that the world was not made in time, but with time. Time is itself a creation simultaneous with, and conditioned by, world-creation and move- ment. To say, in the ordinary fashion, that God created in time, is apt to make time appear inde- pendent of God, or God dependent upon time. Yet the time-forms enter into all our psychological ex- perience, and a concrete beginning is unthinkable to us. The time-conditions can be transcended only by some deeper intuition than mere logical insight can supply—by such intuitive endeav- 9. Is or, in fact, as is realized in the neces- Creation sary belief in the self-existent God. If Eternal? such an eternal Being acts or creates, He may be said to act or create in eternity; and it is legitimate enough, in such wise, to speak of His creative act as eternal. This seems preferable to the position of Origen, who specula- tively assumed an eternal or unbeginning activity for God as Creator, because the Divine Nature must be eternally self-determined to create in order to the manifestation of its perfections. Clearly did Aquinas perceive that we cannot affirm an eternal creation impossible, the creative act not falling within our categories of time and space. The question is purely one of God’s free volition, in which—and not in “nothing”’—the Source of the world is found. This brings us to notice the frequently pressed objection that creation cannot be out of nothing, since out of nothing comes nothing. 10. Creation This would mean that matter is eter- “ex nihilo” nal. But the eternity of matter, as something other than God, means its independence of God, and its power to limit or condition Him. We have, of course, no direct knowledge of the origin of matter, and the concep- tion of its necessary self-existence is fraught with hopeless difficulties and absurdities. The axiom, that out of nothing nothing comes, is not contra- dicted in the case of creation. The universe comes from God; it does not come from nothing. But the axiom does not really apply to the world’s creation, but only to the succession of its phenomena. Entity does not spring from non-entity. But there is an opposite and positive truth, that something presup- poses something, in this case rather some One— aliguis rather than aliquid. : it is enough to know that God has in Himself the powers and resources adequate for creating, without being able to define the ways 11. From in which creation is effected by Him. God’s Will It is a sheer necessity of rational faith or spiritual reason that the something which conditions the world is neither Ay, hiulé, nor elemental matter, but personal Spirit or originative Will. We have no right to suppose the world made out of nothing, and then to identify, as Erigena did, this “nothing” with God’s own essence. What we have a right to maintain is, that what God creates or calls into being owes its existence to nothing save His will alone, Ground of all actualities. Pre- existent Persouality is the ground and the condi- tion of the world’s beginning. In this sense, its beginning may be said to be relative rather than absolute. God is always antecedent to the universe—its prius, 12. Error of Cause and Creator. It remains an Pantheism effect, and sustains a relation of causal dependence upon Him. If we say, like Cousin, that God of necessity creates eternally, we run risk of falling into Spinozistic pantheism, identifying God, in excluding from Him absolute freedom in creation, with the impersonal and un- conscious substance of the universe. Or if, with Schelling, we posit in God something which is not God—a dark, irrational background, which original ground is also the ground of the Divine Existence —we may try to find a basis for the matter of the universe, but we are in danger of being merged—by conceptions tinged with corporeity—in that form of pantheism to which God is but the soul of the universe. The universe, we feel sure, has been caused; its existence must bave some ground; even if we held a philosophy so idealistic as to make the scheme of created things one grand illusion, an illusion so vast would still call for some explanatory Cause. Even if we are not content with the conception of a First Cause, acting on the world from without and antecedently in time, we are not yet freed from the necessity of asserting a Cause. An underlying and determining Cause of the universe would still need to be postulated as its Ground. Even a universe held to be eternal would need to be accounted for—we should still have to ask how such a universe came to be. Its 13. First | endless movement must have direc- Cause a tion and character imparted to it from Necessary some immanent ground or underly- Presupposi- ing cause. Such a self-existent and tion eternal World-Ground or First Cause is, by an inexorable law of thought, the necessary correlate of the finitude, or contingent character of the world. God and the world are not to be taken simply as cause and effect, for modern metaphysical thought is not content with such a mere ens extra-mundanum for the Ground of all possible experience. God, self-existent Cause of the ever-present world and its phenomena, is the ultimate Ground of the possibility of all that is. Such a Deity, as causa sui, creatively bringing forth the world out of His own potence, cannot be allowed to be an arbitrary resting- 14. The place, but a truly rational Ground, of End—the thought. Nor can His Creation be Divine allowed to be an aimless and mechani- Glory cal universe: it is shot through with end or purpose that tends to reflect the glory of the eternal and personal God, who is its Creator in a full and real sense. But the Divine action is not dramatic: of His working we can truly say, with Isa 45 15, “Verily thou art a God that hidest thyself.” As creation becomes progressively disclosed to us, its glory, as revealing God, ought to excite within us an always deeper sense of the senti- ment of Ps 8 1.9, “O Jeh our Lord, how excellent is thy name in all the earth!” See also ANTHRO- PoLoGy; EartH; WoRLD. Litprature.—James Orr, Christian View of God and the World, 1st ed, 1893: J. lverach, Christianity and Evo- lution, 1894; 8. Harris, God the Creator and Lord of All, 1897; A. L. Moore, Science and the Faith, 1889; B. P. Bowne, Studies in Theism, new ed, 1902; G. P. Fisher, Creator Creed, Creeds THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 740 SAGE) j Grounds of Theistic and Christian Belief, new ed, 1902; J. Lindsay, Recent Advances in Theistic Philosophy of Religion, 1897; A. Dorner, Religionsphilosophie, 1903; J. Lindsay, Studies in European Philosophy, 1909; O. Dykes, The Divine Worker in Creation and Providence, 1909; J. Lindsay, The Fundamental Problems of Meta- physics, 1910. James Linpsay CREATOR, kré-a’'tér (krioris, kiistés, 1 Pet 4 19): The distinctive characteristic of Deity, as the Creator, is that He is the Cause 1. God as of the existent universe—Cause of its Creator being, not merely of its evolution or present arrangements. ‘The doctrine of His being the Creator implies, that is to say, that He is the real and the exclusive Agent in the pro- duction of the world. For, as Herder remarked, the thought of the Creator is the most fruitful of all our ideas. As Creator, He is the Unconditioned, and the All-conditioning, Being. The universe is thus dependent upon Him, as its causative ante- cedent. He calls it, as Aquinas said, “according to its whole substance,” into being, without any pre- supposed basis. His power, as Creator, is different in kind from finite power. But the creative process is not a case of sheer almightiness, creating some- thing out of nothing, but an expression of God, as the Absolute Reason, under the forms of time and space, causality and finite personality. In-all His work, as Creator, there is no incitement from with- out, but it rather remains an eternal activity of self-manifestation on the part of a God whois Love. God’s free creative action is destined to realize archetypal ends and ideals, which are peculiar to Himself. For thought cannot be con- 2. Purpose tent with the causal category under in Creation which He called the world into being, but must run on to the teleological category, wherein He is assumed to have created with a purpose, which His directive agency will see at last fulfilled. As Creator, He is distinct from the universe, which is the product of the free action of His will. This theistic postulation of His freedom, as Creator, rules out all theories of necessary emanation. His creative action was in no way necessarily eternal—not even necessary to His own blessedness or perfection, which must be held as already complete in Himself. To speak, as Pro- fessor James does, of ‘‘the stagnant felicity of the Absolute’s own perfection” is to misconceive the infinite plenitude of His existence, and to place Him in a position of abject and unworthy depend- ence upon an eternal activity of world-making. God’s action, as Creator, does not lower our con- ception of His changelessness, for it ia a gratuitous assumption to suppose either that 3. Relation the will to create was a sudden or to Time accidental thing, or that He could not will a change, without, in any proper sense, changing His will. Again, grave difficulties cluster around the conception of His creative thought or purpose as externalized in time, the chief source of the trouble being, as is often imper- fectly realized, that, in attempting to view things as they were when time began, we are really trying to get out of, and beyond, experience, to the think- ing of which time is an indispensable condition. God’s work as Creator must have taken place in time, since the world must be held as no necessary element in the Absolute Life. The self-determined action of the Divine Will, then, is to be taken as the ultimate principle of the cosmos. Not to any causal or meta- 4, Christ in physical necessity, but to Divine or Creation Absolute Personality, must the created world be referred. “Of him, and through him, and unto him, are all things” (Rom 11 36). This creative action of God is mediated by Christ—by whom “were all things created, in the heavens and upon the earth, things visible and things invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers; all things have been created through him, and unto him” (Col 116). See CREATION. James Linpsay CREATURE, kré’tiir: The word “creature,” as it oceurs in the NT, is the tr and also the exact Eng. equivalent of the Gr «rics, ktisis, or xriopa, kitsma, from xrl{w, ktizd, “to create.” In the OT, on the other hand, it stands for words which have in the original no reference to creation, but which come from other roots. Nephesh, “living creature” (lit. “a breathing thing’’), occurs in the accounts of the Creation and the Flood and at the close of the lists of clean and unclean animals in Lev 11 46. Hay, “living creature” (lit. “a living thing’), occurs 13 times in Ezk 1, 3 and 10 (see Creature, Livina). Sherec, “moving creature” (lit. “a swarming thing,” generally rendered “‘creep- ing thing,” q.v.), occurs once in Gen 1 20. ’Ofim, “doleful creatures,” occurs once only in Isa 13 21. It appears to be an onomatopoetic word referring to the mournful sounds emitted by the animals in question. From the context it is fair to suppose that owls may be the animals referred to. See Ow1; CREATION. ALFRED Ey Day CREATURE, LIVING (0, hayyah; téov, zoon): “Living creature” (hayyah) is the designa- tion of each of the composite figures in Ezekiel’s visions (1 5.13 ff; 3 18; 10 15.17.20) and, RV, of the similar beings in the visions of the Apocalypse, instead of the extremely unfortunate tr of zoon in AV by “beasts” (Rev 4 6ff; 5 6ff; 6 1ff; 7 11; 14 3; 16 7; 19 4), which, however, went back to Wichif, in whose time the word had not the low meaning which “beast,” “beastly” have with us; hence he translates 1 Cor 15 44, “It is sowen a beestli body,” meaning simply animal (see Trench’s Select Glossary); in Rev ‘‘the beasts of the earth,” the “beasts” that came up, the notable “beast” that hoe worshipped, represent the Gr thérion, ‘a wild east.” The “living creatures” in Ezekiel’s vision (1 5 ff) were four in number, ‘‘with the general appearance of a man, but each with four faces and four wings, and straight legs with the feet of an ox. Under their wings are human hands, and these wings are so joined that they never require to turn. The front face is that of a man; right and left of this are the faces of a lion and [of] an ox, and behind, that of an eagle .. . . out of the midst of them gleam fire, torches, lightnings, and connected with them are four wheels that can turn in every direction, called whirling wheels (10 12.13). Like the crea- tures, these are alive, covered with eyes, the sign of intelligence; the spirit of the living creatures is in them. They are afterward discovered by the prophet to becherubim” (Schultz, OT Theology, 11,233). See Cuervsim. In Ezekiel’s vision they seem to be the bearers of the throne and glory of God; the bearers of His presence and of His revelation (9 3; 10 3). They also sound forth His praise (3 12; 10 2). (See Schultz as above.) The four living creatures in Rev (4 6) are not under the throne but “in the midst of the throne” (ARVm “before”; see 717; cf 5 6) and “round about the throne.” They are also cherubim, and seem to represent the four beings that stand at the head of the four divisions of the creation; among the untamed animals the lion; among cattle the calf or ox; among birds the eagle; among all created beings the man. It gives “a perfect picture of true service, which should be as brave as the lion, patient as the ox, aspiring as the eagle, intelligent as man” (Milligan in loc.). They repre- 741 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA sent the powers of Nature—of the creation, “full of eyes” as denoting its permeation with the Divine Reason, the wings signifying its constant, ready service, and the unceasing praise the constant doing of God’s will. The imagery is founded on Ezekiel as that had been modified in apocalyptic writings and as it was exalted in the mind of the Seer of Patmos. W. L. WaLKER CREDIT, kred’it (morevew, pistevein; 1 Macc 10 46 AV, RV “gave no credence”; Wisd 18 6 AV, RV “trusted”; 1 Mace 1 30 AV, RV “credence”’): In the modern commercial sense the noun “credit” don not occur in the canonical Scriptures or in the poe. : CREDITOR, kred’i-tér ([a] MW, nasheh, partici- ple of MW), nashah: Ex 22 24 [ET 25]; 2 K 4 1; wT? Isa 50 1; tr? “extortioner,” Ps 109 11; “‘taker of usury,” Isa 24 2 AV; [b] M199, malweh, participle of mie. lawah, Isa 24 2 RV, AV “lender”; [c] ‘ya ‘TT MBA , ba‘al mashshéh yadhs: “lord of the loan of his hand,” Dt 15 2; [d] Savors, danisiés: Lk 7 41, “ creditor’? AV, “lender” RV; cf further danisiés, Sir 29 28, “lender” AV, “money-lender”’ RV): In the ideal social system of the OT, debts are incurred only because of poverty, and the law protected the poor debtor from his creditor, who in Ex 22 25 is forbidden to demand interest, and in Dt 16 2 to exact payment in view of the nearness of the year of release. 2 K 4 1 shows that the actual practice was not so considerate, and in consequence the cred- itor fell into bad_ repute. In Ps 109 11 he is the extortioner; in Prov 29 13 the oppressor is evi- dently the creditor, though a different word is used; ef also Prov 22 7. In Sir 29 28 the importunity of the creditor is one of the hardships of the poor man of understanding. The actual practice of the Jews may be gathered from Neh 6 1 ff; Jer 34 8 ff; and Sir 29 1-11. See also Dzst. Water R. BEerreRipGe CREED, kréd, CREEDS: . Scripruray Basis 1. In the OT 2. In the NT—Gospels 3. In the Epistles (1) Paul 33 Later Writings (3) Hebrews II. Hisroricat Forms 1. The Apostles’ Creed 2. The Nicene Creed (i) Origin, Date, Character (2) * Filioque"’ Clause - 3. The Athanasian Creed (1) Authorship (2) Question of Imposture 3) Value and Features The Reformation Creeds 1) Lutheran i) Genevese 3) Dutch (4) Westminster Confession LIvERATURE By “creed” we understand the systematic state- ment of religious faith; and by the creeds of the Christian church we mean the formal expression of “the faith which was delivered unto the saints.” The word is derived from the first word of the Lat VSS of the Apostles’ Creed, and the name is usually applied to those formulae known as the Apostles’, the Nicene and the Athanasian creeds. In this art. we shall first indicate the Scriptural foundation and rudimentary Bib. statements upon which the distinctive dogmas of the church are based; and, secondly, briefly describe the origin and nature of the three most important symbols of belief which have dominated Christian thought. | I. Scriptural Basis.—There are three forms in which the religious instinct naturally expresses I Creator Creed, Creeds itseli—in a ritual, a creed and a life. Men first seek to propitiate the Deity by some outward act and express their devotion in some external ceremony. Next they endeavor to explain their worship and to find a rationale of it in certain facts which they formulate into a confession; and lastly, not content with the outward act or the verbal interpretation of it, they attempt to express their religion in life. Pagan religion first appears in the form of a rite. The worshipper was content with the proper per- formance of a ceremony and was not, in the earliest stage at least, concerned with an interpretation of his act. The myths, which to some extent were an attempt to rationalize ritual, may be regarded as the earliest approach to a formulated statement of belief. But inasmuch as the myths of early pagan religion are not obligatory upon the reason or the faith of the worshipper, they can scarcely be regarded as creeds. Pagan religion, strictly speaking, has no theology and having no real historical basis of facts does not possess the elements of acreed. In this respect it is distinguished from revealed reli- gion. This latter rests upon facts, the meaning and interpretation of which are felt to be necessary to give to revelation its values and authority. Even in the OT there are not wanting the germs of a creed. In the Decalogue we have the begin- nings of the formulation of belief, and 1. In the in the proclamation, ‘Hear, O Israel: OT Jeh our God is one Jeh”’ (Dt 6 4), we have what may be regarded as the symbol of the OT faith and the earliest attempt to enunciate a doctrine. It is to the NT, however, we must turn to find the real indications of such a statement of belief as may be designated a creed. We 2. In must remember that Christ lived and the NI— __ tanght for a time before any attempt Gospels was made to portray His life or to record His sayings. The earliest writ- ings are not the Gospels, but some of the Epistles, and it is to them we must look for any definite explanation of the facts which center in the appear- ance of Christ upon the earth. At the same time in the sequence of events the personality and teaching of Jesus come first, and in the relation to Him of His disciples and converts and in their personal confes- sions and utterances of faith we have the earliest suggestions of an expression of belief. The confession of Nathanael (Jn 1 49), “Rabbi, thou art the Son of God,” and still more the utterance of St. Peter (Mt 16 16), “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God,” and the exclamation of Thomas (Jn 20 28), contain the germ of a creed. It is to be noted that all these expressions of belief have Christ as their object and give utterance with more or less explicitness to a conviction of His Divine nature and authority. But while these sayings in the Gospels were no. doubt taken up and incorporated in later inter- pretations, it is to the Epistles that 3. Inthe we must first go, for an explanation of Epistles the facts of Christ’s person and His relation to God and man. Paul’s Epistles are really of the nature of a confession and manifesto of Christian belief. Communities of be- lievers already existed when the apostle directed to them his earliest letters. In their oral addresses the apostles must have been accustomed not only to state facts which were familiar to their hearers, but also to draw inferences from them as to the meaning of Christ and the great truths centering in His person—His incarnation, His death and resur- rection (as we may see from the recorded sermons of Peter and Paul in Acts). It is to these facts that the Epistles appeal. It was at once natural and necessary that some expression of the faith once Creed, Creeds Creeping Thing THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 742 delivered to the saints should be formulated for a body whose memhers were pledged to each other and united for common action, and whose hond of union was the acknowledgment of ‘‘one Lord, one faith.’ Paul recognizes it as vital to the very spirit of religion that some definite profession of belief in Christ should be made: “If thou shalt confess with thy mouth Jesus as Lord, and shalt believe in thy heart that God raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved” (Rom 10 9). These words would seem to imply that a confession of the Deity, the atoning death, and resurrection of Jesus was the earliest form of Christian creed. It must also be ohserved that from the very first the confession of faith seems to have been connected with the administration of baptism. Alrcady im the story of the Ethiopian eunuch (Acts 8 37 AV) (a passage indeed of doubtful genuineness but attested by Irenaeus and therefore of great antiq- uity) we find that as a condition of baptism the convert is asked to declare his belief in Jesus Christ as the Son of God. The passage in 1 Tim (6 12; ef He 10 23), “Lay hold on the life eternal, where- unto thou wast called, and didst confess the good confession in the sight of many witnesses,” may refer to a confession required only of those who were being ordained: but the context leads us to infer that it was a haptismal vow asked of members not less than of ministers of the church. The proha- hility is that the earliest form of creed reflected little more than Christ’s final command to baptize all men “into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Mt 28 19), or perhaps simply “into the name of the Lord Jesus’ (Acts 19 5). The ver in 8 37 AV, though disputed by some, is instructive in this connection. Faith in Jesus Christ was regarded as the cardinal point of the New Revelation and may have been taken to imply a relation to the Father as well as a promise of the Holy Spirit. It is evident that the creeds that have come down to us. are mainly an expression of the doctrine of the Trinity as embodied in the original baptismal formula derived from Our Lord’s commission. | Already indeed in some places of the OT this doc- trine is foreshadowed; but it is first clearly in- corporated in the Lord’s command just mentioned and in the benediction of St. Paul (2 Cor 13 14), and subsequently in the Christian doxologies. Some scholars have preferred to find traces in the later writings of the NT of a more definite summary of helief: asin the allusion to the form of sound words (2 Tim 1 13), the “deposit” or “good deposit” which was to be kept (1 Tim 6 20 RVm; 2 Tim 1 14 RVim); also in “‘the faithful words” enumer- ated in these epistles (1 Tim 115; 3.1; 4 8.9; 2 Tim 211); and in the remarkable passage in the beginning of He 6 in which the elementary doctrines of the Christian religion are enumerated; first on the subjective side, repentance and faith, and then objectively, the resurrection and the judg- ment. There are also brief summaries in several of the Pauline Epistles of what the apostle must have considered to he essential tenets. Thus for example we have the death, burial and resurrection of Christ mentioned in 1 Cor 15 3f; Rom 1 3f. Such summaries or confessions of personal faith as in 2 Thess 2 13f are frequent in Paul’s writings and may correspond to statements of truth which the apostle found serviceahle for catechetical purposes as he moved from one Christian community to another. See CaTEcuIsT. It is not indeed till a much later age—the age of Irenaeus and Tertullian (175-200)—that we meet with any definite summary of belief. But it cannot be doubted that these Scriptural passages to which we have referred not only served as the first forms of confession but also contributed the materials out of which the articles of the church’s faith were formu- lated. As soon as Christian preaching and teaching were exercised there would he a felt need for explicit statement of the truths revealed in and through Jesus Christ. It may be said that all the main facts which were subsequently embodied in the creeds have their roots in the NT Scripture and esp. in the Pauline Epistles. The only exception which might be made isin the case of the virgin birth. It does not lie within the scope of this art. to comment upon the silence of the epistles on this subject. This, however, we may say, that the omissions of Paul’s reference to it does not prove it untrue. It only proves at most .that it was not a part of the ground upon which the Christ was commended to the first acceptance of faith. But though no direct allusion to the virgin birth occurs in Paul’s writ- ings the truth which gives spiritual value to the fact of the virgin conception, viz., God’s new creation of humanity in Christ, is a vital and funda- mental element in the faith hoth of St. Paul and of the whole early church. The Christian life is essentially a new creation (2 Cor 5 17; Gal 6 15; Rom 6 4) in Jesus Christ, the second Adam (Rom 5 12-21), who is from heaven (1 Cor 15 47). Into this spiritual context the facts recorded by Matthew and Luke introduce no alien or incompatible element (cf W. Richmond, The Creed in the Episties of Paul; Orr, The Virgin Birth of Christ). And therefore the story of Christ’s birth as we have it in the Synoptics finds a natural place in the creed of those who accept the Pauline idea of a new creation in Christ. See Virain Breru. It is beyond the scope of this art. to discuss the evidences of development in the main doctrines of the gospel, but however the later ages may have elaborated them, the leading tenets of the subse- quent faith of the church—the doctrine of the Trinity; Our Lord’s divinity and real humanity; His atoning death and resurrection; the doctrine of the Holy Spirit and of the catholicity and unity of the church—stand clear and distinct in these earliest Scriptural sources. I. Historical Forms.—Faith implies a creed as a confession and testimony. Such a confession and testimony answers to a natural impulse of the soul. Hence a profession of faith is at once a personal, a social and a historical testimony. A formal creed witnesses to the universality of faith, binds be- lievers together, and unites the successive ages of the church. It is the spontaneous expression of the life and experience of the Christian society. As the purpose of this art. is chiefly to indicate the Scriptural sources of the creeds rather than to dis- cuss their origin and history, we can only briefly describe the main historical forms which have pre- vailed in the Christian church. The Apostles’ Creed, anciently called the Roman Creed, though popularly regarded as the earliest, was probably not the first in chronologi- 1. The cal order. Its origin and growth are Apostles’ involved in considerable obscurity Creed (see separate art., APosTLEs’ CREED; _ and cf Heurtley, Harmonia Symbolica). The Nicene Creed, called sometimes “the Creed of the 318” from the number of bishops reputed to have been present, was authorized 2. The at the Council of Nice in 325 AD, and Nicene completed by the Council of Constanti- Creed nople in 381, when the clauses which follow the mention of the Holy Ghost were added. The opinions of Arius at the begin- ning of the 4th cent. created such unrest as to call forth not only the admonition of bishops but also the intervention of the emperor Constantine, who as a professed Christian, had become the patron of . 743 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Creed, Creeds Creeping Thing the church. The efforts of the emperor, however, had no effect in allaying the dissensions of the church at Alexandria, which, upon the banishment of Arius, spread throughout eastern Christendom. It was decided, therefore, to convoke a general council of bishops in which the Catholic doctrine should be once and for all formally declared. This, the first cecumenical council, met at Nicaea in Bithynia in 325 AD. There is no detailed record of the pro- ceedings. ‘We do not know whether it lasted weeks or days’ (Stanley, Lects on East Ch.). Arius, being only a presbyter, had no seat in the conclave, but was allowed to express his opinions. His chief op- ponent was Athanasius. The controversy turned upon the nature of the Son and His relation to the Father. The word homootsios (“of one substance with’), used in the course of the argument with a view of controvert- ing the extreme orthodox position, became the battleground between the parties. The Arians violently condemned. The Sabellians or Semi- Arians to evade its full force contended for the term homoiotsios (‘‘of like substance’). But the majority finally adopted the former expression as the term best suited to discriminate their view of the relation of the Father and Son from the Arian view. The assent of the emperor was gained and the words ‘‘being of one substance with the Father” were incorporated into the creed. The clauses de- scriptive of the Holy Spirit were added or confirmed at a later council (882), and were designed to refute the Macedonian heresy which denied His equality with the Father and Son, and reduced the Holy Spirit to a level with the angels. The phrase “proceedeth from the Father and the Son” is also of historical importance. The last three words are a later addition to the creed by western churches, formally adopted by the Council of Toledo in 589. But when the matter was re- ferred in the 9th cent. to Leo III he pronounced against them as unauthorized. This interpolation known as the Filioque, marks the difference still between the Lat and Gr churches. From the 9th cent. no change has been made in the Nicene Creed. It has remained, without the Filioque clause, the cecumenical symbol of the Eastern Church; and with the addition of that word it has taken its place among the three great creeds of the Western Church. The Athanasian Creed, or the Symbolum Quicunque, as it is called, from its opening words, differs entirely in its origin and history from those we have 3. The just considered. It is not a gradual Athanasi growth like the Apostles’ Creed, nor is it anasia the outcome of synodical authority like Creed the Nicene Creed. ‘When the composi- tion appears for the first time as a document of authority it is ci in its completeness and as the work of the Father whose name it has since, in the most part, borne, although it was not brought to light for many cents. after his death" (Lumby, Hist of the Creeds). Without going into the full and intricate evidence which has heen brought forward by scholars to prove that it is incorrectly attributed to Athanasius, it is sufficient to ohserve that both authorship and date are uncertain, Dr. Swainson proves in the most conclusive manner that the existence of this creed cannot he traced before the age of Charlemagne, and that its origin may probably be ascribed to the then existing demand for a more detailed exposition of the faith than was to be found in the Apostles’ Creed. IJtis no- where mentioned at synods hefore the end of the 8th cent., whose special business it was to discuss the very matters which were afterward embodied within it in such detail. . ; The question of imposture has been raised with regard to this creed, and it has been maintained by some that lt was originally a forgery of the same nature as the “false decretals” and the equally famous ‘‘ Donation of Constantine’’ (Swainson). ut it may be said that the word ‘imposture” is incorrectly applied to ‘‘a natural and inevitable result of the working of the mind of the Western Church toward a more elahorate and detailed confession of its Trinitarian faith’ (Tulloch, Enc Brit). The a cure: if there was any, consisted not in the origin of the creed but in the ascription of it to_a name and a date with which it had no connection. This was done no doubt to secure for it credit and authority, and was supposed to be justified by its special doctrinal import. port. This symbol, though too compendlous and elahcrate to serve the purposes of a creed, itself standing in need of exposition and explanation, has lts value as repre- senting a further stage cf doctrinal development. If the apostles! Creed determined the nature of God and the lcene Creed defined the character and relation of the Son and the ney Spirit, the Athanasian Creed may he regarded as establishing the great doctrine of the Trinity. Its distinguishing features are the menitery clauses and its uncompromising statement of the value of the Chris- tlan falth. The other creeds set forth the mercles of Revelation; this adds the danger of rejecting them. The others declare the faith; this Insists also on its necesslty. This, also, alone insists upon the necessity of good works (Yonge, An Exposition of the Apostles’ Creed). The clos- ing warnlng is hased on Christ's own words: ‘ Depart from me,"' etc (Mt 25 41.46). If this creed is sclemn in its admonitions, we must remember that so also are the Gospels. On the whole itis a comprehensive summary of truth, laying down the rule of faith as a foundation, fol- lowing cut its issues of good or evil. True belief is closely connected with right action. With the adoption of the “Athanasian” symbol, the creed-making of the early and mediaeval church ceases. Of the three mentioned one only in the broadest sense, the Nicene, is Catholic. Neither the Apostles’ nor the Athanasian Creed is known to the Gr or oriental church which remained faith- ful to the faith settled by the holy Fathers at Nicaea. The two others adopted by the West are really gradual growths or consequences from it, without any definite parentage or synodic authority. But the faith as defined at Nicaea and ratified by sub- sequent councils is the only true Catholic symbol of the universal church. ; With the Reformation a new era of creed-formation began. It will not, however, be necessary to do more than mention some of the confes- 4. The sions of the Reformed churches which Reforma- consist mainly of elaborations of the tion Creeds original creeds with the addition of special arts. designed to emphasize and safeguard the distinctive doctrines and ecclesiastical positions of particular branches of the church. Of this nature are the Confessions of the Lutheran church—the Augsburg Confession of 1530; the Gene- vese or Calvinistic of 1549 consisting of 26 arts., defining particularly the nature of the Sacraments; confessions of the Dutch church confirmed at the Synod of Dort in 1619 and known as the ‘Decrees of Dort”; and the famous Heidelberg Catechism. To this series of Protestant confessions must be added the 39 Articles of the Church of England and the Westminster Confession of Faith, which is the doctrinal standard not only of the churches of Scotland, but of the principal Presbyterian churches of Britain and America. Literature.—Winer, Doctrines and Confessions of Christendom (tr Clark, 1873); Lumby, History of the Creeds; Swainson, The Nicene and astles’ Creeds (1875); Heurtley, Harmonia Symbolica (1858); Zahn, A post. Symb. (1892); Harnack, A post. Glaubensbekenntnis; Swete, Apostles' Creed; Hefele, Councils of the Church; Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom. For exposition, and of a more popular nature, may be mentioned the works of Hooker, Barrow, and Beveridge, and esp. Bishop Pearson; Westcott, Historic Faith; Norris, Rudiments of Theology; W. W. Harvey, The Three Creeds; J. Eyre Yonge, An Exposition of the Apostles’ Creed (1888); Wilfred Rich- mond, The Creed in the Epistles of Paul (1909). Arca. B. D. ALEXANDER CREEK, krék, collog. krik (kéAos, kélpos [Acts 27 39], RV “bay”): The spot has been identified as the traditional Bay of St. Paul about 8 miles N.W. of the town of Valetta in the island of Malta. See Meira. CREEPING, krép'ing, THING (U2), remes, VW , sherec; épwerdv, herpetén): Remes and shereg, with the root vbs. rdmas and shdrac, are used with- out any sharp distinction for insects and other small creatures. Rdadmas means clearly ‘‘to creep,” and is used even of the beasts of the forest (Ps 104 Cremation Crime, Crimes THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 744 20), while sh@rac¢ is rather ‘‘to swarm.” But in at least one passage (Lev 11 44), we have the noun, shereg, with the vb. rémas; “with any manner of creeping thing that moveth upon the earth.” The principal passages where these words occur are the accounts of the Creation and the Flood and the references to unclean animals in Lev and in the vision of Peter. In the last we have the word herpeton as the Gr equivalent of the Heb words (Acts 10 12). Winged creeping things (shere¢ ha—‘oph, Lev 11 20 ff), as well as the wingless, are unclean, but an exception is made in favor of the locusts, ‘which have legs above their feet, where- with to leap upon the earth.” See Insects; Lo- cusT. ALFrrep Exy Day CREMATION, kré-ma’shun (cf NW, sdraph, Josh 7 15, etc, “shall be burnt with fire’; kalo, kato, 1 Cor 13 3, “If I give my body to be burned,” etc): Cremation, while the customary practice of the ancient Greeks, and not unknown among the Romans, was certainly not the ordinary mode of disposing of the dead among the Hebrews or other oriental peoples. Even among the Greeks, bodies were often buried without being burned (Thue. i. 134.6; Plato. Phaedo 115 E; Plut. Lye. xxvii). Cicero thought that burial was the more ancient practice, though among the Romans both methods were in use in his day (De leg. it.22.56). Lucian (De luctu xxi) expressly says that, while the Greeks burned their dead, the Persians buried them (see Boriat, and cf 2 8 21 12-14). In the case sup- posed by Amos (6 10), when it is predicted that Jeh, in abhorrence of ‘“‘the excellency of Jacob,” shall ‘deliver up the city,” and, ‘if there remain ten men in one house, that they shall die,” and ‘‘a man’s kins- man [ARVy] shall take him up, even he that burneth him,” etc, thesuggestion seems to be that of pestilence with accompanying infection, and that this, or the special judgment of Jeh, is why burning is preferred. When Pau! (1 Cor 13 3) speaks of giving his body to be burned, he is simply accommodating his lan- guage to the customs of Corinth. (But see Plutarch on Zarmanochegas, and C. Beard, The Universal Christ.) How far religious, or sanitary, or practical reasons were influential in deciding between the different methods, it is impossible to say. That bodies were burned in times of pestilence in the Valley of Hinnom at Jerus is without support (see Ezk 39 11-16). The “very great burning” at the burial of Asa (2 Ch 16 14) is not a case of cremation, but of burning spices and furniture in the king’s honor (ef Jer 34 5). Nor is 1 K 13 2 a case in point; it is simply a prophecy of a king who shall take the bones of men previously buried, and the priests of the high places that burn incense in false worship, and cause them to be burned on the defiled altar to further pollute it and render it abominable. There is in the NT no instance of cremation, Jew- ish, heathen or Christian, and clearly the early Christians followed the Jewish practice of burying the dead (see Tert., Apol., xlii; Minuc. Felix, Octav., xxxix; Aug. De civ. Det, i.12,13). Indeed, cre- mation has never been popular among Christians, owing largely, doubtless, to the natural influence of the example of the Jews, the indisputable fact that Christ was buried, the vivid hope of the resur- rection and the more or less material views con- cerning it prevalent here and there at this time or that. While there is nothing anti-Christian in it, and much in sanitary considerations to call for it in an age of science, it is not likely that it will ever become the prevailing practice of Christendom. Gro. B. Eacur CRESCENS, kres’enz (Kpfoxns, Kréskés, “increas- ing”): An assistant of Paul, mentioned in 2 Tim 4 10 as having gone to Galatia. That he was one of the Seventy, and that he founded the church in Vienna in Gaul, are traditions without any trust- worthy basis. CRESCENTS, kres’ents ("WW , sahdranim): Moon-shaped necklaces (Jgs 8 21.26; Isa 3 18). CRETE, krat (Kprn, Krété, ethnic Kpires, Kré- tes, Acts 211; Tit 1.12): An island bounding the Aegean Sea on the S. It stretches from 34° 50’ to 35° 40’ N. lat. and from 23° 30’ to 26° 20’ E. long. With Cythera ou the N.W. and Carpathos and Rhodog on the N.E., it forms a continuous bridge between Greece and Asia Minor. The center of the island is formed by a mountain chain rising to a height of 8,193 ft. in Mt. Ida, and fringed with low valleys beside the coast. There are no considerable rivers; the largest, the Metropole, on the S., is a tiny stream, fordable anywhere. An island of considerable extent (156 miles long, and from 7 to 30 miles broad), in several districts very fertile and possessing one or two good harbors, it seems marked out by its position for an important réle in the history of the eastern Mediterranean. But never since an age which was already legendary when Gr history began has Crete occupied a dominat- ing position among the powers of the surrounding continents. Internal dissensions, due in ancient times to the diversity of races inhabiting its soil (Eteocretans—the original inhabitants—Pelasgians, Achaeans, Cydoniaus and Dorians), and in modern times to the fact that a large minority of the popu- lation has accepted the Ottoman religion along with Ottoman government, have kept Crete iu a position of political inferiority throughout the historical period. Mt. Ida in Crete was famous in Gr legend as the birthplace of Zeus. The half-legendary, half- historical King Minos was said to be 1. Early the son of Zeus, and to have derived History from his father the wisdom to which, by a type of myth common in Gr lands, the constitution of the Cretan cities was ascribed. Minos was accepted as a historical personage by Thucydides and Aristotle, who say that he was the first dynast in Greece to establish dominion on the sea. One of his exploits was the suppression of piracy in Cretan waters, a feat which had to be repeated by the Rom Pompeius at a later period. Aristotle compares the Cretan institutions with those of Sparta; the island was said to have been colonized by Dorians from Pelopomnesus (Politics ii.10). The most important cities in Crete were Knossos (whose palace has been excavated with fruitful results by Mr. Arthur Evans), Gortyna, near the Gulf of Messara, and Cydonia, with its river Iardanus. The excavations of Mr. Evans at Knossos and of the Italians at Phaestos (near Fair Havens) prove that Crete was a center of Mediter- ranean civilization in an early age. In the Homer- ic poems, Crete is said to have contained an hundred cities; at that period the Cretans were still famed as daring sailors. In the classical age of Gr history they never held a leading position. They are men- tioned chiefly as traders and mercenary soldiers, skilled esp. in archery. During the Hellenistic period Crete remained free. Demetrius Nicator made the island his base of operations before his defeat at Azotus in 148. In 141, the Cretan Jews were influential enough to secure the patronage of Rome. They were being oppressed by the people of Gortyna, 2. The and appealed to Rome, which granted Jews in them protection. In strengthening the Crete position of the Jews, the Romans were copying the Seleucid policy in Asia Minor; both the Seleucids and the Romans found 745 the Jews among their most devotedsupportersin their subject states. This interference of Rome in the interest of her future partisans paved the way for her annexation of the island in the following cent. From this date, there was a strong and prosperous body of Jews in Crete, and Cretans are mentioned among the strangers present at the Feast of Pente- cost in Acts 2 11. Its alliance with Mithradates the Great, and the help it gave to the Cilician pirates gave Rome the pretext she desired for making war on Crete, and the island was annexed by Metellus in 67 BC. With Cyrene on the N. coast of Africa, it was formed into a Rom province. When Augus- tus divided the Empire between the Senate and himself, Crete and Cyrene were sufficiently peace- ful to be given to the Senate. They formed one province till the time of Con- stantine, who made Crete a separate province. The Saracens annexed Crete in 823 AD, but it was recaptured for the Byzantine Empire by Nicephorus Pho- kas in the following cent. From the 13th till the 17th cent. it was held by the Venetian Republic: from this period dates its modern name “Kandia,” which the Venetians gave to the Saracen capital Khandax, and afterward to the whole island. After a desperate resistance, lasting from 1645 to 1669 AD, Crete fell into the hands of the Turks, who still exercise a nominal suzerainty over the island. In 1 § 30 14; Ezk 26 16, and Zeph 2 5, the Philis are described as Cherethites, which is usually taken to mean Cretans. The name is 4. Crete in connected with Caphtor and the the OT Caphtorim (Dt 2 23; Jer 47 4; Am 9 7). The similarity between the river- names Jordan and Iardanos (Homer Odyssey iii. 292) “about whose streams the Kydones dwelt,” has suggested that Caphtor is to be identified with Cydonia; or possibly it was the name of the whole island. Tacitus believed in an ancient connection between Crete and Pal; the Jews, he said, were fugitives from Crete, and derived their name Iudaei from Mt. Ida (Hist. v.2). Crete is mentioned in connection with the campaign of Demetrius Nicator, referred to above, in 1 Macc 10 67. See CapHtToR; CHERETHITES. Crete owes its connection with Pauline history to the accident of a gale which forced the ship carrying Paul to Rome to take shelter 6. Crete in on the 8. coast of the island. In the the NT harbor of Myra, on the coast of Lycia, the centurion in charge of Paul trans- ferred bim from the Adramyttian ship which had brought them from Caesarea, to a ship from Alex- andria in Egypt, bound for Ostia with a cargo of grain. The fact that the centurion was in virtual command of the ship (Acts 27 11) proves that it was one of the vessels in the imperial transport service. Leaving Myra they came opposite Cnidus with difficulty, against a head-wind. The ordinary course from Cnidus in good weather was to steer straight for Cythera, but on this occasion the W. or N.W. winds made this route impracticable, and they sailed under the lee of Crete, whose 8. coast would shelter them from a N.W. gale, and afford occasional protection from a W. gale. They passed Salmone, the N.E. corner of Crete, with difficulty, and worked round the coast to Fair Havens, a harbor somewhat to the E. of Cape Matala. The great Feast fell while they were at Fair Havens; in 59 AD it wag on October 5, in the middle of the season when the equinoxes made pee impossible. Paul advised the centurion to winter in Fair Havens, but the captain wished to reach Phoenix, a harbor farther to the W., where ships from Egypt were accustomed to put in during the stormy season. It was decided to follow the captain’s advice; but 3. Later History THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA remation rime, Crimes on its way to Phoenix the ship was struck by a N.E. wind called Euraquilo, which rushed down from Mt. Ida. The ship was carried out to sea; it managed to run under the lee of Cauda, an island 23 miles W. of Cape Matala, where the crew hauled in the boat, undergirded the ship, and slackened sail. On the fourteenth night they were driven on the coast of Malta, and wrecked. The narrative does not state that Paul landed in Crete, but as the ship lay for some time at Fair Havens (Acts 27 8.9) he had plenty of opportunity to land, but not to travel inland. The centurion gave him permission to land at Sidon. Paul left Titus in Crete (Tit 1 5); tradition made the latter its first bishop, and patron saint. Cretans were present, as noted above, at the Feast of Pentecost (Acts 2 11). Paul’s estimate of the Cretan character (Tit 1 10- 6. The 16) was the one current in antiquity. Cretans Paul quotes (1 12) a well-known line of the Cretan poet Epimenides (who lived about 600 BC) on the mendacity of the Cre- tans. The sentiment was repeated by Callimachus (Hymn to Zeus 8). Other ancient witnesses to the detestation in which the Cretan character was held are Livy xliv.45, and Plutarch Aemilius § 23. LiveratuRe.—Smith, Voyage and Shipwreck of St. Paul; Ramsay, St. Paulthe Traveller and Roman Citizen, 320-30. On Crete in Gr and Rom times, consult e.g. Grote, Holm, and Mommsen. A succinct account of the prehistoric archaeology of theisland is given in Burrows, fa a in Crete, and Baikie, The Sea Kings of W. M. Caper CRIB (C738, ’ébhiis): “Crib” translates the Heb word ’ébhigs exactly, as it denotes ‘‘a barred recepta- cle for fodder used in cowsheds and foldyards; also in fields, for beasts lying out in the winter.” The Heb is from a word meaning to feed (O38, ’abhas), and is used in the precise sense of the Eng. word in Job 39 9 of the “crib” of the wild ox, in Prov 14 4, “Where no oxen are, the crib is clean,” and in Isa 1 3, “The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master’s crib.” CRICKET, krik’et (93°, hargal): This occurs in Lev 11 22 (AV “beetle”), and doubtless refers to some kind of locust or grasshopper. See BEETLE; Locust; InsEcr. CRIER, kri’ér (NUP, kara’; cf Bodw, bods): (1) Neither is this exact word found in EV, nor a word exactly corresponding to it in the Heh Bible, but the character it stands for appears as ‘‘one who cries aloud,” i.e., proclaims mandates or gives public messages. In Prov 1 21 it is said, “She [Wisdom] crieth in the chief place of concourse.” John the Baptist calls himself “the voice of one cry- ing in the wilderness” (Jn 1 23)—like a herald going before the king. (2) In the East today every village even has its public crier, selected for his loud or penetrating voice, and appointed to give notice of the fresh orders or mandates of the mudir (“governor”) or other authorities. The muezzin of the Moslems, who at the five appointed times of prayer mounts the minaret and calls the faithful to prayer, is another striking example. Something like the ancient “heralds” of the king were the “heralds” of the Middle Ages in Europe who, preceded by trumpeters, made official proclamations. Gro. B. Eacrer CRIME, krim, CRIMES, krimz: This term is used in Eng. as the equivalent of the Heb DEW, mishpdt, “judgment,” ‘“‘verdiet” (Ezk 7 23); QT, zimmah, “a heinous crime’ (Job 31 11); OWN, 'asham= “a fault,” “sin” (Gen 26 10, EV ‘‘guiltiness’’); Crime, Crimes THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 746 and Gr alria, aitia, “‘case,’’ “cause” (Acts 25 27, RV “charges’). In AV Jn 18 38; 19 4.6, the rendition is “fault.” tykhnpa, égkléma, “indictment,” “charge” (Acts. 25 16 AV) is changed in RV to “matter.” popY, ‘dkalkal, FIMPY, ‘akallathon, romp, p*thaltol; okodwds, skolids): Primarily designates something that is bent, twisted or deformed (Isa 27 1; 45 2 AV). Figurative: (1) It designates a course of action that deviates from rectitude, esp. deceit, guile, hy- pocrisy (Dt 32 5; Prov 215; Eccl 115; Lk 3 5; ef Phil 2 15); (2) trials (sent by God, Eccl 7 13; ae 3 9); (3) difficulties (removed by God, Isa 42 See LrviIATHAN; CROOKED SERPENT, krook’ed sdr’pent. ASTRONOMY. CROP: (1) As noun the translation of TN, murah (Lev 1 16), which is the craw of a bird, esp. of doves and pigeons, which had to be removed by the priest before he offered the birds as a burnt sacri- See ce. (2) As a vb. it is (Ezk 17 4.22) the tr of DUP, kataph, which has the meaning of “cutting off,” “cutting down,” “plucking.” CROSS (cravpés, staurdés, “a cross,” “the cruci- fixion”; okdédowp, skélops, “a stake,” “a pole”): The name is not found in the OT. It is derived from the Lat word cruz. In the Gr language it is stauros, but sometimes we find the word skolops used as its Gr equivalent. The historical writers, who transferred the events of Romi history into the 761 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Criticism Cross Gr language, make use of these two words. No word in human language has become more univer- sally known than this word, and that because all of the history of the world since the death of Christ has been measured by the distance which separates events from it. The symbol and principal content of the Christian religion and of Christian civiliza- tion is found in this one word. The cross occurs in at least four different forms: (1) the form usually seen in pictures, the cruz immissa, in which the upright beam ‘1. Forms of projected above the shorter crosspiece; the Cross this is most likely the type of cross on which the Saviour died, as may be inferred from the inscription which was nailed above His head; (2) the crux commissa, or St. Anthony’s cross, which has the shape of the letter T; (3) the Gr cross of later date, in which the pieces are equally long; (4) the crux decussata, or St. Andrew’s cross, which has the shape of the letter x. The early church historians Socrates (1,17), Sozomen (2,1), Rufinus (1,7) and Theodoret (1,18) all make mention of this tradition. The 2. Discov- most significant thing is that Eusebius ery of the (Vit. Const., i11.26-28), who carries True Cross more weight than they all together, wholly omits it. According toit, Helena, the mother of Constantine the Great, in 325 AD, when she was 79 years old, discovered the true cross of Jesus by an excavation she caused to be made on the traditional spot of His grave. With the cross of the Saviour were found the two crosses of the malefactors who were cru- cified with Him. A miracle of healing, wrought by touching the true cross, revealed its identity. When found it was intact, even the holy nails of the cruci- fixion being discovered. The main part of the cross was deposited by Helena in a church erected over the spot. Of the remainder, a portion was inserted into the head of the statue of Constantine, and the balance was placed in a new church, specially erected for it at Rome and named after it SantaCroce. Small fragments of the wood of the true cross were sold, encrusted with gold and jewels, and since many among the wealthy believers were desirous of pos- sessing such priceless relics, the miracle of the ‘Multiplication of the cross’? was devised, so that the relic suffered no diminution ‘et quasi intacta maneret”’ (Paulinus ep 11 ad Sev). Fragments of the true cross are thus to be found in many Roman Catholic churches of many countries, all over Christendom. It is said that the East celebrated the siaurosimos hémera (Crucifixion Day) on Sep- tember 14, since the 4th cent. The evidence for this fact is late and untrustworthy. It is certain that the West celebrated the Invention of the Cross, on May 3, since the time of Gregory the Great in the 6th cent. The finding and publication of the apocryphal ‘‘Doctrina Addaci” has made it evi- dent that the entire legend of the discovery_of the cross by Helena is but a version of the old Edessa legend, which tells of an identical discovery of the cross, under the very same circumstances, by the wife of the emperor Claudius, who had been con- verted to Christianity by the preaching of Peter. (1) Extra-scriptural—The sign of the cross was well known in the symbolics of various ancient nations. Among the Egyptians it is 3. Symboli- said to have been the symbol of di- cal Uses of vinity and eternal life, and to have the Cross been found in the temple of Serapis. It is known either in the form of the Gr cross or in the form of the letter T. The Spaniards found it to be well known, as a symbol, by the Mexicans and Peruvians, perhaps signifying the four elements, or the four seasons, or the four points of the compass. (2) Scriptural—The suffering implied in cruci- fixion naturally made the cross a symbol! of pain, distress and burden-bearing. Thus Jesus used it Himself (Mt 10 38; 16 24). In Paulinic lit. the cross stands for the preaching of the doctrine of the Atonement (1 Cor 118; Gal 614; Phil 3 18; Col 1 20). It expresses the bond of.unity between the Jew and the Gentile (Eph 2 16), and between the believer and Christ, and also symbolizes sancti- fication (Gal 5 24). The cross is the center and circumference of the preaching of the apostles and of the life of the NT church. As an instrument of death the cross was detested by the’ Jews. ‘Cursed is everyone that hangeth on a tree’ (Gal 313; cf Dt 21 23), 4. Cruci- hence it became a stumbling-block to fixion them, for how could one accursed of God be their Messiah? Nor was the cross differently considered by the Romans. ‘Let the very name of the cross be far away not only from the body of a Roman citizen, but even from his thoughts, his eyes, his ears’’ (Cicero Pro Rabi- rio 5). The earliest mode of crucifixion seems to have been by impalation, the transfixion of the body lengthwise and crosswise by sharpened stakes, a mode of death-punishment still well known among the Mongol race. The usual mode of crucifixion was familiar to the Greeks, the Romans, the Egyp- tians, Persians and Babylonians (Thuc. 1, 110; Herod. iii.125, 159). Alexander the Great exe- cuted two thousand Tyrian captives in this way, after the fall of the city. The Jews received this form of punishment from the Syrians and Romans (Ant, XIL v, 4; XX, vi, 2; BJ, I, iv, 6). The Rom citizen wasexempt from this form of death, it being considered the death of a slave (Cicero In Verrem1. 5, 66; Quint. viii.4). The punishment was meted out for such crimes as treason, desertion in the face of the enemy, robbery, piracy, assassination, sedition, etc. It continued in vogue in the Rom empire till the day of Constantine, when it was abolished as an insult to Christianity. Among the Romans cruci- fixion was preceded by scourging, undoubtedly to hasten impending death. The victim then bore his own cross, or at least the upright beam, to the place of execution. This in itself proves that the structure was less ponderous than is commonly supposed. When he was tied to the cross nothing further was done and he was left to die from starva- tion. If he was nailed to the cross, at least in Judaea, a stupefying drink was given him to deaden the agony. The number of nails used seems to have been indeterminate. A tablet, on which the feet rested or on which the body was partly sup- poled seems to have been a part of the cross to eep the wounds from tearing through the trans- fixed members (Iren., Adv. haer., ii.42). The suffer- ing of death by crucifixion was intense, esp. in hot climates. Severe local inflammation, coupled with an insignificant bleeding of the jagged wounds, produced traumatic fever, which was aggravated y the exposure to the heat of the sun, the strained position of the body and insufferable thirst. The wounds swelled about the rough nails and the torn and lacerated tendons and nerves caused excruciat- ing agony. The arteries of the head and stomach were surcharged with blood and a terrific throbbing headache ensued. The mind was confused and filled with anxiety and dread foreboding. The victim of crucifixion literally died a thousand deaths. Tetanus not rarely supervened and the rigors of the attending convulsions would tear at the wounds and add to the burden of pain, till at last the bodily forces were exhausted and the victim sank to unconsciousness and death. The suffer- ings were so frightful that “even among the raging passions of war pity was sometimes excited” (BJ, Crossway Cruel THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 762 V, xi, 1). The length of this agony was wholly determined by the constitution of the victim, but death rarely ensued before thirty-six hours had elapsed. Instances are on record of victims of the cross who survived their terrible injuries when taken down from the cross after many hours of suspension (Jos, Vita, 75). Death was sometimes hastened by breaking the legs of the victims and by a hard blow delivered under the armpit before crucifixion. Crura fracta was a well-known Rom term (Cicero Phil. xiii.12). The sudden death of Christ evidently was a matter of astonishment (Mk 15 44). The peculiar symptoms mentioned by John (19 34) would seem to point to a rupture of the heart, of which the Saviour died, independent of the cross itself, or perhaps hastened by its agony. See BLoop anp WarTER. Henry E. Doser CROSSWAY, kros’wa (PIB, perek, lit. “divi- sion’): A forking or dividing of the way. Obadiah warns Edom, ‘‘And stand thou not in the crossway, to cut off those of his that escape’ (Ob ver 14). In LXX, ‘‘a mountain pass.” CROWN, kroun: The word crown in the OT is a tr of five different Heb words, and in the NT of two Gr words. These express the several mean- ings, and must be examined to ascertain the same. The five Heb words are as follows: (1) 7p 7p, kodhkodh, from TIP, kadhadh; (2) “1, zér, from 3, 2drar; (3) Wi, nezer, or Wi, 1. In nezer, both from V1}, nazar; (4) IOP, Hebrew + ‘didrah, from “OI, ‘atar; (5) WW, kether, from 9, kéathar. (1) Kodhkédh means “the crown of the head,” and is also rendered in AV “top of the head,” “scalp,” “pate.’ Jt comes from kdédhadh, meaning ‘to shrivel up,” “contract,” or bend the body or neck through courtesy. Both RV and ARV, in Dt 28 35 and 33 16, tr it ‘‘crown” instead of ‘‘top”’ as in AV. Jacob in his prophecy concerning his sons says: “The blessings of thy father .... shall be on the head of Joseph, and on the crown of the head of him that is prince among his brethren” (Gen 49 26 ARVm). Other references are: Dt 33 20; 2S 14 25; Job 27; Isa 317; Jer 2 16; 48 45. Tr “scalp” in Ps 68 21 and “pate” in Ps 7 16. (2) Zér means a “‘chaplet,’’ something spread around the top as a molding about the border, and because of its wreath-like appearance called a crown. “That which presses, binds” (BDB). Comes from zdrar, meaning “‘to diffuse” or “‘scatter.” It is used in Ex 26 11.24.25; 30 3.4; 37 2.11.12.26.27. (3) Nezer means something “‘set apart”; i.e. a dedication to the priesthood or the dedication of a Nazarite, hence a chaplet or fillet as a symbol of such consecration. The word in AV is rendered “crown,” “consecration,” “separation,” ‘“‘hair.” Comes from nazar, meaning ‘‘to hold aloof” from impurity, even from drink and food, more defi- nitely, “to set apart” for sacred purposes, ie. “to separate,” “devote,” “consecrate.” It is found in Ex 29 6; 39 30; Lev 8 9; 21 12;28 110; 2K 11 12; 2 Ch 23 11; Ps 89 39; 132 18; Prov 27 24; Zec 9 16. (4) ‘At@rah means a crown in the usual sense. Comes from ‘afar, meaning “‘to encircle,” as in war for offence or defence; also actually and fig- uratively ‘to crown.” Rendered sometimes ‘to compass.” It is used in 2S 12 30; 1 Ch 20 2; Est 8 15; Job 19 9; 31 36; Ps 21 3; Prov 4 9; 12 4; 14 24; 16 31; 17.6; Cant 311; Isa 28 1.3.5; 62 3; Jer 13 18; Lam 5 16; Ezk 16 12; 21 26; 23 42; Zee 6 11.14; “crowned,” Cant 8 11; ‘crownest,” Ps 65 11; “crowneth,” Ps 103 4. RV tr’ “crowned,” of Ps 8 5 “hast crowned.” ARV prefers to tr “‘crowning,” in Isa 23 8, “the bestower of crowns.” (5) Kether means a “circlet’’ or “a diadem.” From kdthar, meaning ‘‘to inclose”: as a friend, ‘‘to crown”; as an enemy, “‘to besiege.” Variously tré “beset round,” ‘“inclose round,” “‘suffer,’’ ‘compass about.” Found in Est 1 11; 2 17; 6 8; “crowned,” in Prov 14 18. Ancient Asiatic Crowns. The two Gr words of the NT tr‘ crown are: (1) orépavos, stéphanos, from stéph6, and (2) diddnua, diddéma, from diadéé, ‘to bind round.” 2. In Greek (1) Stephanos means a_chaplet (wreath) made of leaves or leaf-like gold, used for marriage and festive occasions, and expressing public recognition of victory in races, games and war; also figuratively as a reward for efficient Christian life and service (see GAmEs). This symbol was more noticeable and intricate than the plain fillet. Only in the Rev of John is stephanos called “golden.” The ‘crown of thorns” which Jesus wore was a stephanos (woven wreath) of thorns; the kind is not known (Mt 27 29; Mk 15 17; Jn 19 2.5). Lk makes no mention of it. Whether intended to represent royalty or victory, it was a caricature crown. Stephanos is found in 1 Cor 9 25; Phil 41; 1 Thess 2 19; 2 Tim 4 8; Jas 112; 1 Pet 6 4; Rev 2 10; 3 11; 6 2; 12 1; 14 14; plur. in Rev 4 4.10; 9 7; ‘‘crowned” in 2 Tim 2 5; He 2 9; ‘‘crownedst” in He 2 7. (2) Diadéma is the word for ‘“‘diadem,”’ from dia (about) and deé (bound), i.e. something bound about the head. In the three places where it occurs (Rev 12 3; 13 1 and 19 12) both RV and ARV trit not “crowns” but ‘‘diadems,” thus making the proper distinction between stephanos and diadéma, such as is not done either in AV or the LXX (see Trench, Synonyms of the NT). According to Thayer the distinction was not observed in Hellenic Gr. “Dia- dems” are on the dragon (Rev 12 3), the beast (Rev_13 1) and on the Rider of the White Horse, “the Faithful and True’ (Rev 19 12). In each case the “diadems”’ are symbolic of power to rule. There are five uses of the crown as seen in the Scripture references studied, viz. decoration, con- secration, coronation, exaltation, and 8. Use and remuneration. Significance (1) Decoration.—The zér of Ex, as _far_as it was a crown at all, was for ornamentation, its position not seeming to indicate 763 any utility purpose. These wavelet, gold moldings, used in the furnishings of the tabernacle of Moses, were placed about (a) the table of shewbread (Ex 25 24; 37 11); (6) the ark of the covenant oe 265 11; 37 2); (c) the altar of incense (Ex 30 3.4; 37 26.27). The position of these crowns is a de- bated question among archaeologists. Their pur- pose other than decoration is not known. The encircling gold might signify gratitude, purity and enduring worth. (2) Consecration —The nezer had a twofold use as the crown of consecration: (a) It was placed as a frontlet on the miter of the high priest, being tied with a blue lace (Ex 39 30). The priestly crown was a flat piece of pure gold, bearing the inscription, “Holy to Jeh,” signifying the consecration of the priest as the representative of the people (Ex 29 6; Lev 8 9). (b) Likewise the Heb king (2 K 11 12) was set apart by God in wearing on his head a royal nezer, whether of silk or gold we do not know. It was set with jewels (Zec 9 16) and was light enough to be taken into battle (2 S 1 10). (3) Coronation—The ordinary use of the crown. There were three kinds of kingly crowns used in coronation services: (a) The nezer or consecration crown, above referred to, was the only one used in crowning Heb kings. What seems to be an excep- tion is in the case of Joshua, who represented both priest and king (Zec 6 11 ARVm). (b) The dtarah, and (c) the kether were used in crowning foreign monarchs. No king but a Heb could wear a nezer—a “Holy to Jeh’” crown. It is recorded that David presumed to put on his own head the ‘dtarch of rane Malcam (28 12 30 ARVm). The kether or jeweled turban was the crown of the Pers king and queen (Est 1 11; 2 17; 6 8). (4) Exaltation.—The ‘at@rah, the stephanos and the diadéma were used as crowns of exaltation. Stephanos was the usual crown of exaltation for victors of games, achievement in war and places of honor at feasts. The ‘ééaérah was worn at ban- quets (Cant 3 11; Isa 28 1.3), probably taking the form of a wreath of flowers; also as a crown of honor and victory (Ezk 16 12; 21 26; 23 42). Stephanos is the crown of exaltation bestowed upon Christ (Rev 6 2; 14 14; He 29). “Exaltation was the logical result of Christ’s humiliation” (Vincent). The Apocalyptic woman and locusts receive this emblem of exaltation (Rev 12 1; 9 7). The symbolic dragon and beast are elevated, wear- ing diadéma (Rev 12 3; 13 1). The conquering Christ has “upon his head . . . . many diadems’”’ (Rev 19 12). See further Tertullian, De corona. (5) Remuneration —Paul, witnessing the races and games, caught the vision of wreath-crowned victors flush with the reward of earnest endeavor. See Games. He also saw the persistent, faithful Christian at the end of his hard-won race wearing the symbolic stephanos of rejoicing (1 Thess 2 19 AV), of righteousness (2 Tim 4 8), of glory (1 Pet 5 4), of life (Jas 1 12; Rev 2 10). Paul’s fellow- Christians were his joy and stephanos (Phil 4 1), “of which Paul might justly make his boast” (Ellicott). Long before Paul, his Heb ancestors saw the ‘dtdrah of glory (Prov 4 9) and the ‘dfdrah of a good wife, children’s children, riches and a peaceful old age (Prov 12 4; 14 24; 1631; 17 6). For Apoc references see 1 Mace 10 29; 11 35; 13 39. Wituiam Epwarp RaFFEeTy CROWN OF THORNS, thérnz (&xavéios orépa- vos, akdnthinos stéphanos): Three of the four evan- gelists mention the crown of thorns, wherewith the rude Rom soldiers derided the captive Christ. (Mt 27.29; Mk 1617; Jn 19 2). All speak of the akanthine (Acanthus) crown, but there is no cer- tainty about the peculiar plant, from the branches THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Crossway Cruel of which this crown of cruel mockery was plaited. The rabbinical books mention no less than twenty- two words in the Bible signifying thorny plants, and the word dkantha in the NT Gr is a generic and not a specific term. And this word or its adj. is used in the three Gospels, quoted above. It is therefore impossible definitely to determine what was the exact plant or tree, whose thorny branches were selected for this purpose. Tobler (Denkbi., 118, 179) inclines to the Spina Christi, as did Has- selquist. Its botanical name is Zizyphus Spina Christi. It is very common in the East. Its spines are small and sharp, its branches soft, round and pliable, and the leaves look like ivy, with a dark, shiny green color, making them therefore very adaptable to the purpose of the soldiers. Others have designated the Paliurus aculeatus or the Lycium herridum. Both Geikie (Life of Christ, 549) and Farrar (Life of Christ, note 625) point to the Nubk (Zizyphus lotus). Says the latter, ‘“‘The Nubk struck me, as it has all travelers in Pal, as being most suitable both for mockery and ain, since its leaves are bright and its thorns singu- arly strong. But though the Nubkis very common on the shores of Galilee, I saw none of it near Jerus.” The settlement of the question is manifestly im- possible. Henry E. Dosksr CRUCIFIXION, kr6o-si-fik’shun. See Cross; PUNISHMENTS. CRUEL, kroo’el, CRUELTY, kroo’el-ti (T38, akhzdr, “harsh,” “fierce,” ON, hdmds, “vio- lence’): There are various uses of the word ‘‘cruel’’ in the OT: (a) “the cruel [deadly] venom of asps”’ (Dt 32 33); (6) spoken of men of relentless hate: “They hate me with cruel hatred’ (Ps 25 19; cf Prov 59; 11 17; 12 10; Jer 6 23; 50 42); (c) Job speaks of God’s dealings with him as ‘‘crnel” and arbitrary: “Thou art turned to be cruel to me” (Job 30 21); conscious of his virtue, yet hold- ing God to be the author of his sufferings, Job is driven to the conclusion that God has become his enemy and is bent upon destroying him; (d) the “day of Jeh’’—a prophetic phrase to denote the - time of God’s manifestation in judgment—is de- scribed as coming, “cruel, with wrath and fierce anger” (Isa 13 9). The word “cruelty” has nearly disappeared from the Bible. In RV it occurs only in Ps 27 12. AV has it in Gen 49 5; Ps 74 20 (RV “violence”’); Ezk 34 4 (78, perekh, “crush- ing,” RV ‘rigor’’). The OT records many acts on the part of chosen individuals and the elect nation which are marked by gross cruelty, particularly when measured by the standards of our own age. Some of these acts are sanctioned by Scripture or even presented as com- manded by God, as, for example, the sacrifice of Isaac, the extermination of the Canaanites, the authorization of the avenger of blood and of human slavery, and of retaliation for evil. Some of the deeds performed by Divinely appointed leaders of Israel are characterized by inhumanity. Samuel “hewed Agag in pieces” (1 S 15 33). David mas- sacred the Ammonites with great barbarity (2 8 12 31). Elijah slew the prophets of Baal (1 K 18 40; cf 2 K 1 10; 10 25). Some of the utterances of the Psalmists breathe the spirit of hate and revenge, as in the so-called imprecatory psalms (Ps 187 8.9; 189 21f). This has often been a matter of great perplexity to the devout student of the Bible. He has found it difficult to reconcile such practices, which bear the stamp of Divine approval, with the highest standards of Christian morality. It is sometimes urged in justification that these deeds are permitted, but not commanded by God. But this answer hardly meets the facts of Crumb Cunning THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 764 the case. We shall arrive at a truer answer if we recognize the fact, which Jesus emphasizes, that the OT religion is a self-accommodation to the low moral standard of those whom it was designed to instruct. This He reiterates in the Sermon on the Mount (Mt 5 22.28.34), and affirms in His reference to the hardness of the ancestral Jewish heart (Mt 19 8). In the OT we are dealing with the childhood of the world, in which revelation is com- pelled to limit itself to the comprehension of its subjects. It must speak so that they can under- stand. It must start with them where it finds them. It must lead them along lines in which they of their own volition can walk, that character may grow step by step. A gradual development of spiritual and ethical ideals may clearly be traced in the sacred records. We must therefore read the OT narratives and interpret their teaching, not according to the standards of our own age, but in the light of the age to which these narratives belong. The spirit of Elijah may not be the spirit of Christ (Lk 9 55). While many of the acts of cruelty and barbarity recorded in the OT are indicative of an age of a low type of morality, yet we must at the same time recognize the fact, that Israel’s religion by emphasizing holy living and righteous conduct created an atmosphere favorable for the growth of high ethical ideals. Wherever this religion is seen at its best, as in the teachings of the prophets, it is the mark of the righteous man to treat human life as sacred and to refrain scrupulously from inflict- ing unnecessary pain. Even the Gentiles shall be brought to judgment for their barbarities and inhuman practices (Am 1 2f; 2 K 25 7). Among the blessings of the Messianic kingdom, predicted by the prophets, is the cessation of war with all of its attendant cruelties and horrors. The Law of Israel also reflected this tendency toward humanity, and many of its ordinances, while seemingly in- human, really tended to mitigate prevailing bar- barity. Instances of such ordinances are those referring to the maltreatment of slaves (Ex 21 20), to the Cities of Refuge (Nu 35 19 ff; cf Josh 20), to rules of warfare (Dt 20 10f), etc. The exter- mination of the Canaanites is represented as a Di- vine judgment upon a morally corrupt civilization (Gen 15 16; Dt 12 30). It is declared necessary in order to guard the Hebrews from contamination by the sins of the Canaanites (Ex 23 32). It is not so far back, that many of the practices that are condemned by the most enlightened Chris- tianity of our day, prevailed universally and were not thought incompatible with Christian civiliza- tion. Even our own time needs to secure a more widespread practical recognition of the principles of humanity, kindness and justice, which are pro- fessedly the law of the Christian life. L. Kaiszer CRUMB, krum ({ixlov, psichion, “a little bit’): Occurs only in the NT, of remnants of food, scraps. Lazarus desired ‘‘to be fed with the crumbs that fell from the rich man’s table’ (Lk 16 21). “Even the [little] dogs eat of the crumbs” (Mt 15 27; Mk 7 28), “possibly the fragments of bread on which the guests wiped their hands (after thrust- ing them into the common dish), and flung to the dogs” (Farrar, Life of Christ, I, 476). CRUSE, kréos: A small earthen vessel or flask, usually for holding liquids: MODY, cappahath; as water, 1 S 26 11.12.16;1 K 19 6; it being porous, the liquid is kept cool; also for holding oil, as in 1 K 17 12.14.16. In 1 K 143 (“a ecruse of honey’) the word Pp aP2, bakbuk, would be better rendered “bottle,” doubtless deriving its name from the gurgling sound of issuing liquids. In 2 K 2 20 PPT>%, c*lanith, is not a jar or flask, but a dish, or platter, for salt or other substances. In the NT a small jar or vial, dAdBacrpov, ald- bastron, “alabaster cruse”’ or flask, for holding oint- ment; not “box asin AV (Mt 26 7; Mk 143; Lk T 37; cf 18 101; 2 K 9 1.3, where “box” in AV is used for “‘vial’’ RV). Epwarp BacsBy PoLiarp CRY, CRYING, kri‘ing (P27, za‘ak, PIL, ca'ak [and forms], NUP, kara’, VW, shawa‘, 3, rin- nah; Bodw, bodd, kpatw, krdzd, pwvéw, phonéd): Various words are tr? “cry,” “crying,” etc, the chief of which are those above given; zd‘ak and ¢@ak denote esp. a cry for help, from pain or dis- tress, and are frequently used for crying to God, e.g. (ed'ak, Ex 2 23; Jgs 3 9.15; Ps 22 5; 107 13. 19; Mic 3 4); (catak, Ex 8 12; 15 25; Ps 34 17; 77 1; Isa 19 20; Lam 2 18); kGra@’ (a mimet- ic word) has the widest signification, but is often used of appealing to God (frequently tr+ “call,” “called,” etc, Gen 39 14.15.18; 41 43; Dt 16 9; 24.15;'1 K 18 27; Ps 3 4; 222; 277; Prov i 21; Isa 34 14; Jer 2 2, etc); sha@wa', ‘‘to cry aloud” (Job 29 12; 30 20.28; Ps 18 6.41; 88 13; Jon 2 2; Hab 1 2, etc); rinnah, “‘a shouting,” whether for Joy or grief (1 K 8 28; Ps 17 1; 61 1; 88 2; 119 169; 1426; Isa 43 14 RV ‘‘ejoicing,” etc). Other Heb words are ’@nak, ‘“‘to groan” (Ezk 9 4; 24 17 AV; 26 15 AV); hamah, “to make a noise’ (Ps 55 17 AV); ra‘, “to shout” (Jgs 7 21 AV; Job 30 5; Isa 42 13, etc); rdnan, “to cry aloud” (Ps 84 2; Lam 2 19); shde‘, ‘crying’ (Isa 22 5); tshw oth, “crying,” “noise” (Job 39 7 AV). In the NT we have boaé, “to cry,” “shout” (Mt 33; Mk 13; 15 34; Gal 4 27, etc); krazo (mimetic, the hoarse cry of the raven), ‘to cry out”’ (Mt 9 27; 14 30; 21 9; 27 50; Mk 5 5; Gal 4 6; Rev 6 10; 7 2, etc); phdned, “to give forth the voice,” “sound” (Lk 8 8, 16 24; 23 46; Acts 16 28; Rev 14 18 AV); anabodo, “to ery out’ (Mt 27 46; Lk 9 38); aphiemi, “to let go,” “to send away” (Mk 15 37 AV); epibodd, ‘to cry about’ (anything) (Acts 25 24); epiphdnéé, “to give forth the voice upon” (Lk 23 21 AV); kraugdzé, “to make a cry, or outcry, or clamor” (Mt 12 19; 15 22; Jn 11 43; 18 40; 19 6.15; Acts 22 23); ana- krdz6, ‘to cry out” (Mk 1 23; Lk 4 33, etc); kraugé, “a, crying out”? (Mt 25 6; Acts 23 9 AV; He 5 7; Rev 21 4). For “cry"’ RV has ‘sound"” because of these things’’ (Job 30 24 ERV) 'y y op Bt Beare 42 14); “call’’ (Ps 28 i 61 2; 141 1); e gr wae é Joel 1 20); “cry aloud” (Mt 12 19); ‘‘clamor" (Acts 3 9). Among the other changes are, ‘‘moan”’ for “ aloud" (Ps §5 17); ‘‘sound an alarm" (Hos § 8); ‘ your pleasure,’’ m ‘‘blind yourselves,"’ for ‘‘cry ye out” ‘sa 9 9); ‘sigh, but not aloud" for “forbear to cry” Ezk 24 17); “shoutings” for “crying’’ (Job 39 7); “destruction”’ for ‘‘crying’’ (Prov 19 18, where we have instead of ‘let not thy soul spare for his crying,” “‘set not thy heart on his destruction,” m, Heb ‘causing him to die” [math, ‘to put to death’); “went up" for “crying aloud"’ (Mk 1§ 8, different text); ‘“ery" for “voice"’ (Lik 1 42); for ‘had cried"* (Lk 23 46), ARV has ‘‘crying.’' fe W. L. Waker _ CRYSTAL, kris’tal: In EV the word is probably intended to signify rock-crystal, crystallized quartz. This the Greeks called kpvoraAhos, kriistallos, “ice,” pelievive it to have been formed from water by in- tense cold. Thus in Rev 4 6; 21 11; 22 1, either “erystal’’ (EV) or “ice” (Gr krustallos) suits the context. The word rendered “crystal” in Ezk 1 22 (TIP, kerah) js ambiguous in precisely the same way (RVm “ice”). In Job 28 17 the con- text favors AV “crystal,” rather than RV “glass” (FMDIDT, ekhukhith). Finally, in Job 28 18 RV reads “crystal” for AV “pearls” (Heb gabhish; the 765 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Crumb Cunning weight of evidence favors RV in spite of the paral- lelism suggested by AV). See also Sronus, Pre- cous. Farr CUB, kub (853, kabh; AV Chub): The word occurs only in Ezk 30 5. There it is almost cer- tainly a corruption, and we should read, as in LXX, “Lub,” i.e. Libya. Libya, in the earlier part of the same ver (AV), is a mistr of ‘“‘Put,’”’ thus cor- rectly rendered in RV. CUBIT, ki’bit (WARN, ’ammah; whxvs, péchus): The standard for measures of length among the Hebrews. They derived it from the Babylonians, but a similar measure was used in Egypt with which they must have been familiar. The length of the cubit is variously estimated, since there seems to have been a double standard in both countries, and because we have no undisputed example of the cubit remaining to the present time. The original cubit was the length of the forearm, from the elbow to the end of the middle finger, as is implied from the derivation of the word in Heb and in Lat (cubitum). It seems to be referred to also in Dt 3 11: “after the cubit of a man.” But this was too indefinite for a scientific standard, and the Babylonians early adopted a more accurate method of measurement which passed to the nations of the West. They bad a double standard, the so-called royal cubit and the ordinary one. From the remains of build- ings in Assyria and Babylonia, the former is made out to be about 20.6 in., and a cubit of similar length was used in Egypt and must have been known to the Hebrews. This was probably the cubit mentioned by Ezk 40 5 and perhaps that of Solomon’s temple, ‘cubits after the first measure” (2 Ch 3 3), ie. the ancient cubit. The ordinary cubit of commerce was shorter, and has been vari- ously estimated at between 16 and 18 or more ‘inches, but the evidence of the Siloam inscription and of the tombs in Pal seems to indicate 17.6 in. as the average length. See Wxzicuts anp Muas- urEs. This was the cubit of six palms, while the longer one was of seven (Ezk 40 5). The cubit mentioned in Jgs 3 16 is from a different word in Heb (794, gémedh) and was probably shorter, for Ehud girded it on his thigh under his clothing. The NT references are Mt 6 27; Lk 12 25, “Which of you... . canadd a c. unto the measure of his life?”; Jn 21 8, “about two hundred cubits off’; Rev 21 17, ‘the wall thereof, a hundred and forty and'four cubits.” H. Porter CUCKOW, kotk’oo, kuk’6o (MW, shahaph; Adpos, idros; Lat Cuculus canorus): The Heb root from which the word shdhaph is derived means “‘to belean” and “slender,” and in older VSS of the Bible was tr’ cuckow (cuckoo). It was mentioned twice in the Bible (Lev 11 16, and practically the same in Dt 14 15 AV “cuckoo”), in the list of unclean birds. The Lat term by which we designate the bird is very similar to the Arab., and all names for it in different countries are so nearly the same that they prove themselves based on its double cry, “cuck-oo,” or the single note “kowk” or “ gouk.” The bird is as old as history, and interesting because the European species placed its eggs in the nests of other birds, which gave rise to much fiction con- cerning its habits. The European bird is a brown- ish gray with white bars underneath, and larger than ours, which are a beautiful olive gray, with tail feathers of irregular length touched with white, knee tufts, black or yellow bill, according to species, and beautiful sleek head and shining eyes. Our birds build their own nests, attend their young with care and are much loved for their beauty. Their food is not repulsive in any species; there never was any reason why they should have been classed among the abominations, and for these reasons scientists in search of a “Jean, slender” bird of offensive diet and habit have selected the ‘‘sea-mew” (q.v.) which is substituted for cuckoo in the RV with good natural-history reason to sustain the change. Gene STRATTON-PoRTER CUCUMBER, ki’kum-bér (NUP, kishshu’tm; olxvos, sikuos): One of the articles of food for which Israel in the wilderness looked back with longing to Egypt (Nu 11 5). Cucumbers are great favorites with all the people of Pal. Two varieties occur, Cucumis sativus (Arab. Khydr), originally a product of N.W. India, which is smooth-skinned, whitish and of delicate flavor, and requires much water in its cultivation, and Cucumis chate (Arab. faqqis), which is long and slender but less juicy than the former. Probably the Bib. reference is to this latter as it is a plant much grown in Egypt where it is said to attain unusual excellence. A “garden of cucumbers,” or more literally a “place of cucumbers’ (mikshah), is mentioned in Isa 1 8; Bar 6 70. “A lodge in a garden of cucumbers” (Isa 1 8) is the rough wooden booth erected by the owner from which he keeps guard over his ripening vegetables. It is commonly raised upon poles and, when abandoned for the season, it falls into decay and presents a dreary spectacle of tottering poles and dead leaves. ; E. W. G. Masrsrman CUD. See CHew. CULTURE, kul’tir: Found only in 2 Esd 8 6 AV and RV, “give... . culture to our under- standing,” i.e. to nourish it as seed in the ground. CUMBER, kum’bér, CUMBERED (kxartapyéo, katargéd, “to make idle,” wepvomdopar, perispd- omat, “to be drawn about,” in mind “to be distracted”): Spoken of the barren fig tree in the parable: “Cut it down; why doth it also cum- ber (block up, make unproductive] the ground?” (Lk 13 7). Cumbered means to be over-occupied with cares or business, distracted: “But Martha was cumbered about much serving’ (Lk 10 40). The word cumbrance occurs only in Dt 1 12: “How can I myself alone bear your cumbrance?” (710, torah, “an encumbrance,” ‘a burden’’). Cf Isa 1 14, where RVm has ‘‘cumbrance,” RV “trouble.” CUMI, koo’mé, kti’mi. See Tanirua. CUMMIN, kum’in (73, kammén; tbpiwov, kii- minon): The seed of the herb Cuminum cyminum (N.O. Umbelliferae). It has carminative properties and is used for flavoring various dishes, esp. during fasts. In flavor and appearance it resembles cara- way, though it is less agreeable to western palates. As an illustration of Jeh’s wisdom it is said (Isa 28 25.27) that cummin is scattered in sowing and beaten out with a rod in threshing. These facts are true in Pal today. The Jews paid tithes of cummin (Mt 23 23) (see cut on following page). CUN, kun (j13, kin; A, ee t&v exdextdv Tédewv, ek ton eklekién poledn, “from the chosen cities’): One of the cities of Hadarezer, king of Syria, spoiled by David (1 Ch 18 8, AV “Chun”). In the || pas- sage (2 8 8 8) its place is taken by BEROTHAI, which see. CUNNING, kun’ing (03%, hakham, 20M, ha- shabh): In Bible-English ‘cunning” means always “wise” or ‘skilful’; the word does not occur in the bad sense, and it is found in the OT only. The Cup Cush THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 766 chief Heb words are hakhaém, ‘wise,’ “skilful” (2 Ch 2 7 AV “a man cunning to work in gold”; ver 13; Isa 3 3 AV, etc); kdskabh, “to think,’ “devise,” “desire” (Ex 26 1.31; 28 6.15 AV,etc). We have also da‘ath, “knowledge” (1 K 7 14 AV); bin, “to be intelligent” (1 Ch 26 7AV); ma- hdshebheth, “thought,” “device,” “design” (Ex 31 4; 36 33.35 AV); ’aman, “artificer’ (Cant 7 1 AV); yadha*, “to know,” once tr? “cunning” (Dnl 1 4 AV). For “cunning’ ARV gives “skilful” (Ex 31 4, etc; Isa 3 3 “expert”’); for “cunning work” the work of the “skilful workman” (Ex 26 1.31, etc, ERV “cunning workman’); for “curious,” “skil- fully woven,” ERV SEY OV (Ex 28 8, etc). . L. WALKER ES I | NR Si \ Te Lebo Ne oN A Ie ACS ae } WY BUA ao j Ne Cummin. CUP (most frequently, O13 , kos; four other words in one passage each; worfprov, polérion): A vessel for drinking from, of a variety of material (gold, silver, earthenware), patterns (Est 1 7) and elaboration. Figurative: By ordinary fig. of speech, put some- times for the contents of the cup, viz. for that which is drunk (Mt 26 39). In both OT and NT applied fig. to that which is portioned out, and of which one is to partake; most frequently used of what is sorrowful, as God’s judgments, His wrath, afflic- tions, etc (Ps 11 6; 76 8; Isa 51 17; Rev 14 10). In a similar sense, used by Christ concerning the sufferings endured by Him (Mt 26 39), and the calamities attending the confession of His name (Mt 20 23). In the OT applied also to the bless- edness and joy of the children of God, and the full provision made for their wants (Ps 16 5; 23 5; 116 13; of Jer 16 7; Prov 31 6). All these pas- sages refer not only to the experience of an allotted joy and sorrow, but to the fact that all others share in this experience. Within a community of those having the same interests or lot, each received his apportioned measure, just as at a feast, each cup is filled for the individual to drain at the same time that his fellow-guests are occupied in the same way. The Holy Supper is called “the cup of the Lord” (1 Cor 10 21), since it is the Lord who makes the feast, and tenders the cup, just as “the cup of demons” with which it is contrasted, refers to what they offer and communicate. In 1 Cor 11 25, the cup is called “the new covenant in my blood,” i.e. it is a pledge and seal and means of imparting the blessings of the new covenant (He 10 16 f)—a covenant established by the shedding of the blood of Christ. The use of the word “cup”’ for the sac- rament shows how prominent was the part which the cup had in the Lord’s Supper in apostolic times. Not only were all commanded to drink of the wine (Mt 26 27), but the very irregularities in the Cor- inthian church point to its universal use (1 Cor 11 27). Nor does the Rom church attempt to justify its withholding the cup from the laity (the communion in one form) upon conformity with apostolic practice, or upon direct Scriptural author- ity. This variation from the original institution is an outgrowth of the doctrines of transubstan- tiation and sacramental concomitance, of the at- tempt to transform the sacrament of the Eucharist into the sacrifice of the Mass, and of the wide separation between clergy and laity resulting from raising the ministry to the rank of a sacerdotal order. The practice was condemned by Popes Leo I (d. 461) and Gelasius (d. 496); but gained a firm hold in the 12th cent., and was enacted into a church regulation by the Council of Constance in 1415. See also Buessine, Cur or. As to the use of cups for divination (Gen 44 5), the reference is to superstitious practice derived from the Gentiles. For various modes of divining what is unknown by the pouring of water into bowls, and making observations accordingly, see Geikie, Hours with the Bible, I, 4921, and art. Divination. . H. E. Jacozs CUPBEARER, kup’bar-ér ("2WA, mashkeh, “one giving drink”’; oivoxéos, oinochdéos): An officer of high rank at ancient oriental courts, whose duty it was to serve the wine at the king’s table. On account of the constant fear of plots and intrigues, a person must be regarded as thoroughly trust- worthy to hold this position. He must guard against poison in the king’s cup, and was sometimes required to swallow some of the wine before serving it. His confidential relations with the king often endeared him to his sovereign and also gave him a position of great influence. This officer is first mentioned in Scripture in Gen 40 1 ff, where the Heb word elsewhere tr? “cupbearer’” is rendered - “butler.” The phrase “chief of the butlers” (ver 2) accords with the fact that there were often a number of such officials under one as chief (cf Xen. Hellen. vii.l, 38). Nehemiah (cf 1 11) was cup- bearer to Artaxerxes Longimanus, and was held in high esteem by him, as the record shows. His financial ability (Neh 6 8.10.14.17) would indicate that the office was a lucrative one. Cupbearers are mentioned further in 1 K 10 5; 2 Ch 9 4, where they, among other evidences of royal splendor, are stated to have impressed the queen of Sheba with Solomon’s glory. The title Rabshakeh (Isa 36 2), once thought to mean “chief of the cupbearers,” is now given a different derivation and explained as “chief of the officers,” or “princes” (BDB s.v.). See further on cupbearers Herod. iii.34; Xen. Cyrop. 1.3, 8,9; Jos, Ant, XVI, viii, 1; Tob 1 22. BENJAMIN Reno Downer CUPBOARD, kub’érd (kvAlkiov, kulikion, 1 Macc 15 32): A kind of sideboard in or on which Simon’s gold and silver vessels were displayed, and which, among other evidences of his glory, amazed the Syrian envoy Athenobius. Cf the Rom abacus, said to have been introduced into Rome from Asia. CURDLE, kir’d’l (RDP, kapha’, “to congeal,” “harden,” “curdle’): Occurs in Job 10 10, “Hast thou not. . . . curdled me like cheese?” i.e. made him take solid form. ‘‘The formation of the embryo is a mystery on which the Heb dwells with a deep and reverential awe: cf Ps 189 13-16." These similes are often met with in the Koran and oriental poetry. See Speaker's Comm. in loc. CURE, kar, CURES: Represents the words M74, gahah, SBA, marpé’, TD, raphah; Ceparedo, the- rapeu6, tacts, iasis. Gahah in Prov 17 22 tr 767 “medicine”? means properly the removal of a band- age from a healed wound, and is used figuratively in Hos 6 13; marpé’, ‘‘healing,” is used in the sense of deliverance of the city in Jer 33 6; with a nega- tive particle in 2 Ch 21 18 it is used to describe the bowel disease of Jehoram as incurable. The Gr words are used of physical cures (casts in Lk 13 32) as contradistinguished from the casting out of demons as Mt 17 16; Lk 7 21; Jn 610. Cure is only used in the NT in the sense of physical heal- ing; in the OT usually in the sense of spiritual or national deliverance from danger. ALpx. Maca.isTar CURIOUS, ki’ri-us (MAUNA, mahdshebheth; aeplepyos, periergos): The above Heb word, mean- ing “thought,” “device,” “design,” is tr4 “curious,” Ex 35 32 AV “curious works’; ERV ‘cunning’; ARV “skilful”; héshebh (‘‘device,” ‘devised work’), trd AV “curious girdle,”’ is tr4 by ERV “cunningly woven band,” ARV “skilfully” (Ex 28 8.27.28; 29 5; 39 5.20.21; Lev 8 7). In Ps 139 15 rakam, “embroidered,” “variegated” is used fig. of a child in the womb, tr? “curiously wrought’; ‘the body or the foetus is described as woven together of so many different-colored threads, like a cunning and beautiful network or tapestry’? (Perowne in loc.). See also Curp.e. Periergos, “working round about,” is used of the “curious arts” of some in Ephesus who brought their books to be burned (Acts 19 19 ARV “magical”’). See AsTRoLocy 14. W. L. WaLKER CURRENT MONEY. See Money, CURRENT. CURSE, kirs (TON, ’alah [Nu 5 21.23.27, etc], TIN, m’érah [Prov 3 33; Mal 2 2, etc], M22p, kelalah [Gen 27 12.13]; wardpa, katdra [Gal 3 10. 13]): This word as noun and vb. renders different Heb words, some of them being more or less synonymous, differing only in degree of strength. It is often used in contrast with “bless’’ or ‘“‘bless- ing” (Dt 11 29). When a curse is pronounced against any person, we are not to understand this as a mere wish, however violent, that disaster should overtake the person in question, any more than we are to understand that a corresponding “blessing” conveys simply a wish that prosperity should be the lot of the person on whom the bless- ing is invoked. A curse was considered to possess an inherent power of carrying itself into effect. Prayer has been defined as a wish referred to God. Curses (or blessings) were imprecations referred to supernatural beings in whose existence and power to do good or inflict harm primitive man believed. The use of magic and spells of all kinds is based on the belief that it is possible to enlist the support of the superhuman beings with whom the universe abounds, and to persuade them to carry out the suppliant’s wishes. It has been suggested that spells were written on pieces of parchment and cast to the winds in the belief that they would find their way to their proper destination—that some de- moniac being would act as postman and deliver them at the proper address. In Zec (6 1-3) the “flying roll,” with curses inscribed on it ‘“goeth forth over the face of the whole land.” It would find its way into the house of every thief and per- jurer. curses to writing, it was enough to utter them aloud. Generally the name of some deity would be coupled with such imprecations, as Goliath cursed David by his gods (1 S 17 48). Such curses once uttered possessed the power of self-realization. It was customary for heads of families in their declining years to bless their children, such a blessing being, not simply a paternal wish that their children should prosper in life, but a potent factor in determining THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA But it was not always possible to commit’ Cup Cush their welfare (Gen 9 25). In this case Jacob seeks his father’s blessing, which was more than_ his father’s good wishes for his future career. Such blessings and curses were independent of moral considerations. Before moral distinctions played any part in molding theological conceptions it was not necessary, before a spell could be effectual, that the individual against whom the spell was pro- nounced should be deserving, on moral grounds, of the fate which was invoked on him. It was suffi- cient that he should be the foe of the author of the curse. We may assume that such curses sig- nalized the commencement of a battle. But in process of time such indiscriminate imprecations would not satisfy enlightened moral judgment. In the dramatic situation depicted in Dt (11 29; 27 12f) the curse was placed on Mt. Ebal and the blessing on Mt. Gerizim. But the curse was the penalty for disobedience, as the blessing was the reward for obedience. The Book of Prov (26 2) summarily dismisses the traditional belief—‘‘the curse that is causeless alighteth not.’ ‘In the dis- courses of Jesus we find blessings and curses. They are however simply authoritative declarations of the eternal connection between right doing and happi- ness, wrong doing and misery” (Cheyne). Whereas curses by ordinary persons were con- sidered more or less efficacious—some god _ being always only too glad to speed them on their way to their destination—yet special persons—“holy” persons—in virtue of their special relation to Divine beings possessed special powers of pronouncing effectual curses on account of their powers of en- listing supernatural aid. Balaam, according to the narrative in Nu (22f),was an expert in the art. Balak was convinced that Balaam’s curse would bring about the defeat of the Israelites (see Gray, “Numbers,” ICC). The term—and the thing signified—plays an im- porant part in Paul’s interpretation of the cross. n the light of the law all men are guilty. There is no acquittal through appeal to a law that commands and never forgives—prchibits and never_ relents. The violator of the law is under a curse. His doom hag been pronounced. Escape is impossible. But on the cross Jesus Christ endured the curse—for “cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree’ (Gal 3 10.13)—and a curse that has overtaken its victim is a spent force. See PUNISHMENTS. Jesus commands His disciples, ‘“‘Bless them that curse you” (Lk 6 28; cf Rom 12 14). He Himself cursed the fruitless fig tree (Mk 11 21)—a symbol of the doom of a fruitless people. Curse as the rendering of DI, hérem, implies a totally different idea (see AccursED). T. Lewis CURTAIN, ktir’t’n, -ten, -tin: The word ordina- rily used for curtain is M7", y*rt‘ah. Thus in Ex 26 1ff; 36 8 ff of the curtains of the tabernacle (see TABERNACLE); in 28 7 2; Ps 104 2; Cant 1 5 Isa 64 2; Jer 420; 1020; 49 29: Hab Figurative: In Isa 40 22 (like Ps 104 2, of the heavens), the word used is Pt, dak, lit. “gauze.” CUSH, kush (W'3, kash): (1) The first of the sons of Ham, from whom sprang Seba, Havilah, Sabtah, Raamah and Sab- tecah. He was also the father of 1. The Nimrod, who founded Babel (Baby- Ancestor of lon) and the other great states of Many Shinar or Babylonia (Gen 10 6-8). Nations The meaning of the name is uncertain. (2) The name of the country around which the Gihon flowed (Gen 2 18), rendered “Ethiopia” in the AV, but in view of the distance Cush Cut, Cutting THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 768 of that country from the other rivers mentioned, this seems to be an unlikely identification. Fried. Delitzsch has suggested (Wo lag das 2. ADis- Paradies? 74 ff) that the watercourse in trict of the question is the canal Gu-handé or Garden of Arahtu, which, coming from the &., Eden entered Babylon a little to the E. of the Euphrates, and, flowing alongside the Festival-Street, entered the Euphrates to the N. of Nebuchadrezzar’s palace. Koldewey (Tempel von Babylon und Borsippa, 38) regards the Gu-handé as the section of the Euphrates itself at this point. There is no indication, however, that the district which it inclosed was ever called Kasu or Cush, and the suppression of the final syllable of Gu-handé would remain unexplained. Moreover, the identification of Cush with a possible Ca8, for Kasdu, ‘“Chaldea,”’ seems likewise improbable, esp. as that name could only have been applied, in early times, to the dis- trict bordering on the Persian Gulf (see CHALDEA). Another theory is, that the Cush of Gen 2 13 is the Kusu of certain Assyr letters, where it seems to designate a district in the neighbor- 3. Probably hood of Cappadocia. This identifi- notin Asia cation apparently leads us back to an Minor ancient tradition at one time current in the East, but later forgotten, which caused the Pyramus river to assume the name of Jihan (i.e. Gihon). This stream rises in the moun- tains N.E. of the Gulf of Alexandretta, and, taking a southwesterly course, flows into the Mediterranean near Karatash. Though nearer than the Ethiopian Cush, this is still too far W., and therefore unsatis- factory as an identification—all the streams or waterways of the Garden of Eden ought to flow through the same district. (3) The well-known country of Cush or Ethio- pia, from Syene (Ezk 29 10) southward—Egyp K68, Bab Katsu, Assyr Katsu. This 4, The name sometimes denotes the land Ethiopian (Isa 11 11; 181; Zeph 3 10; Ezk Cush 29 10; Job 28 19; Est 11; 8 9); sometimes the people (Isa 20 4; Jer 46 9; Ezk 88 5); but is in many passages uncer- tain. Notwithstanding that the descendants of Ham are always regarded as non-Semites, the Ethiopians, Ge'ez, as they called themselves, spoke a Sem lan- guage of special interest on account of its likeness to Himyaritic, and its illustration of certain forms in Assyro-Babylonian. These Cushites were in all probability migrants from another (more northerly) district, and akin to the Canaanites—like them, dark, but by no means black, and certainly not Negroes. W. Max Miller (Asien und Europa, 113 n.) states that it cannot be proved whether the Egyptians had quite black neighbors (on the 8.). In earlier times they are represented as brown, and later as brown mingled with black, implying that negroes only came to their knowledge as a distinct and extensive race in comparatively late times. Moses’ (first?) wife (Nu 12 1) was certainly there- fore not a Negress, but simply a Cushite woman, probably speaking a Sem language—prehistoric Ge‘ez or Ethiopian (see CusHirs Woman). In all probability Sem tribes were classed as Hamitic simply because they acknowledged the supremacy of the Hamitic Egyptians, just as the non-Sem Elamites were set down as Semites (Gen 10 22) on account of their acknowledging Bab supremacy. It is doubtful whether the Hebrews, in ancient times, knew of the Negro race—they probably became acquainted with them long after the Egyptians. In the opinion of W. Max Miller (A. und E., 112), the Egyptians, when they became acquainted with the Negroes, having no word to express this race, classed them with the nekesé, which there- after included the Negroes. If the Heb name Phine- has (Pi-nthds) be really Egyp, and mean “‘the black,” there is still no need to suppose that this meant “the Negro,” for no Israelite 5. Negroes would have borne a name with such a Probably signification. The treasurer of Candace not In- queen of Meroé (Acts 8 27-39)—the cluded Ethiopian eunuch—was an Abyssinian, not a Negro; and being an educated man, was able to read the Heb Scriptures in the Gr (Sept) version. Cush (mét Kusi, pr. Kusht) is frequently mentioned in the Assyr imscriptions in company with Melubha (Aferohha) to indicate Ethiopia and Meroé. See Even; Erniopia; TABLE or Nations. T. G. Pincues CUSH, kush (W1D, kash; LXX Xovoel, Chou- set, Ps 7 title): A Benjamite, perhaps he that “was without cause” the ‘‘adversary”’ of David (ef Ps 7 4). See CusuHi. CUSHAN, ki’shan: In the Ps of Habakkuk (Hab 3 7) “the tents of C.” are mentioned in an individualizing description of the effects of a the- ophany. Parallel is the phrase ‘the curtains of the land of Midian.” LXX renders C., {W1D, kiushan, by Al@brwv, Aithidpon, reading perhaps D°U"2, kaushim, or PWD, kushin (JWOD, kashin). The context indicates that the same land or people is intended as the OT elsewhere calls Cush, yet vaguely and not in any strict geographical usage that would limit it to Africa. CUSHAN-RISHATHAIM, kt’shan-rish-a-tha’im (DINYW TWD, kushan rish‘dthayim, tr, or rather interpreted, as ‘man from Cush, he of the twofold crime”: LXX Xoveapoaéduy, Chousarsathdim, AV Chushan-rishathaim): Mentioned in Jgs 3 8-10 as a king of Mesopotamia who was chosen by God as his tool to chastise the Israelites for their idolatry. After Joshua’s death the children of Israel soon began to affiliate themselves with the heathen peoples among whom they dwelt. This was the fertile source of all their troubles. God delivered (“sold”) them into the hands of the heathen. C.-r. is the first whose name is given in this connection. Barring this short passage in Jgs nothing is known of the man. Eight years the Israelites were under his dominion, when the Lord raised up a deliverer to them, Othniel, the son of Kenaz, Caleb’s younger brother—the first of the judges. Wituiam Baur CUSHI, kii’shi: This name represents "7D , kiishi, in the original (LXX Xoveel, Chousei, Xovet, Choust), either with or without the art. With the art. (so in 2 S 18 21-32 seven out of eight times, all readings supported by LXX) it simply indi- cates that the person so designated was of the Cush- ite people, as in Jer 38 7 ff. Its use without the art. has doubtless developed out of the foregoing according to a familiar process. For the Cush of Ps 7, title read “‘Cushi” with LXX. (1) The messenger (RV “the Cushite’”’) sent by Joab to acquaint David with the victory over Absalom. That this man was in fact a foreigner is indicated by his ignorance of a shorter path which Ahimaaz took, by his being unrecognized by the watchman who recognizes Ahimaaz, and by his ignorance, as compared with Ahimaaz, of the senti- ments of David, whom he knows only as a king and not as aman. 28 18 21 (twice, the second time without the art.), 22.23.31 (twice), 32 (twice). (2) The great-grandfather of Jehudi, a contem- porary of Jeremiah (Jer 36 14). The name Jehudi itself (“a man of Judah”) is sufficient refutation of the opinion that the usc of C. as or in lieu of a proper 769 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cush Cut, Cutting name “seems to show that there were but few Cush- ites among the Israelites.” (3) The father of Zephaniah the prophet (Zeph 1 1). J. ae Boyp CUSHION, kodésh’un (rpockepddarov, proske- phdlaion): In NT, only m Mk 4 38 RV. The word means lit. a cushion for the head (AV “‘pillow’’) but was also used of one for sitting or reclining upon, e.g. of a rower’s cushion. The art. used with it in this passage suggests that it was one of the cus- tomary furnishings of the boat, and it was probably similar to the cushion placed ‘for the comfort of passengers in the stern of modern boats on the Sea of Galilee. ‘Silken cushions” of Am 3 12 RV is a rendering of the Heb d¢meshek from its supposed connection with damask, These cushions formed the divan, often the only article of furniture in an oriental reception room. ‘Cushions’ occurs further in the somewhat doubtful RVm rendering of Prov 7 16; 31 22. BrensaMIn Reno DowNeR CUSHITE, kush’‘it: Whereas "W112 , kishi, is else- where rendered Ethiopian, in 2 § 18 21-32 it is rendered Cushite in the RV (see Cusui and cf Cusnitze Woman). Its pl., which occurs in Zeph, Dnl and 2 Ch, also in the form DW), kushtyim, in An, is uniformly tr’ Ethiopians, following LXX. The other OT books use simply O73, késh, for people as well as land. CUSHITE, kush’it (ETHIOPIAN) WOMAN: In Nu 12 1 Moses is condemned by his sister Miriam and his brother Aaron ‘‘because of the Cush- ite woman [NWS NWR, ha-’ishshah ha-kushith} whom he had married”; and the narrator imme- diately adds by way of needed explanation, ‘“‘for he had married a Cushite woman” (Mw TES, Yishshah Khushith). Views regarding this person have been of two general classes: (1) She is to be identified with Zipporah (Ex 2 21 and elsewhere), Moses’ Midianitish wife, who is here called “the Cushite,” either in scorn of her dark complexion (cof Jer 18 23) and foreign origin (so most older exegetes), or as a consequence of an erroneous notion of the late age when this apocryphal addi- tion, “because of the Cushite,” etc, was ruserted in the narrative (so Wellhausen). (2) She is a woman whom Moses took to wife after the death of Zip- porah, really a Cushite (Ethiopian) by race, whether the princess of Meroé of whom Jos (Ant, I, x, 2) romances (so Targum of Jonathan), or one of the ‘mixed multitude” (Ex 12 38; cf Nu 11 4) that accompanied the Hebrews on their wanderings (so Ewald and most). Dillmann suggests a compromise between the two classes of views, viz. that this woman is a mere “‘variation in the saga” from the wife elsewhere represented as Midianitish, yet because of this variation she was understood by the author as distinct from Zipporah. The imph- cation of the passage, in any case, is clearly that this connection of Moses tended to injure his prestige in the eyes of race-proud Hebrews, and, equally, that in the author’s opinion such a view of the matter was obnoxious to God. J. Oscar Boyp CUSTODY, kus’té-di (™, yadh, MIPS, pekud- dah): In Est 2 3.8 bis.14, yadh, “the hand,” is tr? “custody”; p’kuddah, “numbering,” “charge’’; occurs in Nu 3 36 RV “the appointed charge,” m, Heb, “the office of the charge.” CUSTOM, kus’tum (tax): (a) JPT, halakh, Ezr 4 13.20; 7 24AV; (6) WB, bd, Ear 4 13, ete; (c) tedwvov, telénion, Mt 9 9; Mk 2 14; Lk 5 27, “receipt of custom” AV, RV “place of toll, the collectors’ office; (d) rédos, télos, Mt_ 17 25 (RV “toll’); Rom 13 7; 1 Mace 11 35 (RV “tolls”; ef I Mace 10 31). The tax designated by halakh in Ezr 4 13, etc, is usually taken to mean a road tax, a toll, from root hdlakhk, but ef AOF, II, 463, which derives from root ku, a command, a decree, hence an imposed tax. Bld from root yabhal is supposed to be a tax on merchandise or produce (as distinguished from ‘“‘tribute,” or the tax on houses, lands and persons), usually paid in kind and levied for the support of the native or provincial government. See Ryle, Cambridge Bible, Ezr-Neh, loc. cit. Telos in NT and Macc is an indirect tax farmed out to the publicans. Watrer R. BeTreRIDGE CUSTOM, kus’tum (usage): In the OT, except Gen 31 35 where RV renders, better, “manner” (JVI, derekh, “way’’), the words tr? “custom” are hok, hukkah, “statute,” and mishpat, “judgment.” Such passages as Jgs 11 39; Jer 32 I1, and esp. Ezr 3 4 (AV “custom,” RV “ordinance’’), illus- trate the difficulty of deciding upon the proper tr in cases where “custom” might become “statute,” “usage” establish itself as “law.” In Lev 18 30; Jer 10 3 the reference is to heathen religious prac- tices. In the NT Lk 19; 2 42; Acts 614; 16 1 (AV “manner”’); 16 21; 21 21; 263; 2817 (€0s, éihos), and Lk 2 27 from the same Gr root, refer likewise to definitely established religious practices; in every case except Acts 16 21, those of the Jewish law. The RV makes the tr of ethos uniform, reading ‘‘custom” in Lk 22 39 (AV “‘wont”’) and in Jn 19 40; Acts 25 16; He 10 25 (AV ‘manner”). Gr elw6s, eidthdés, from the same root, is rendered ‘‘custom” in Lk 4 16 by EV, and by RV also in Acts 17 2, its only other occurrence in the NT. In Jn 18 39; 1 Cor 11 16 “custom” is the tr of Gr sunétheia, in the sense of “usage” rather than of “law.” F. K. Farr CUT, CUTTING (M13, karath, 974, gddha', “ID, kadhadh, TD), ndthah; awondartw, apokdplé, exxéarte, ekkoptd): Many Heb words are tré ‘‘cut.” Of these ka@rath, “‘to cut down, out, off,” is the most frequent. As “cut off” it is used in the sense of laying or destroying (Gen 9 11; Dt 12 29; I K 11 16; Ps 101 8, etc), also for cutting off transgressors from the community of Jeh, which meant probably separation, or exclusion, rather than death or destruction (Gen 17 14; Ex 12 15. 19). Other words are ddmam, “to be silent,” “cease” (Jer 25 37 AV; 48 2); cdmath, “to destroy” (Ps 64 5 AV; 94 23, ete); gadhadh, “to cut one’s self,”’ is used of the cutting of one’s flesh before heathen gods and in mourning for the dead, which was forbidden to the Israelites (Dt 14 1; 1K 18 28; Jer 16 6; 41 5; 47 5); seret, sdreteth, ‘an- cision,” are also used of those ‘“‘cuttings of the flesh”’ (Lev 19 28; cf 21 5). See Currincs 1N THE Fuesu. The cutting of the hair of head and beard in mourning for the dead is referred to in Isa 15 2; “Every beard is cut off” (gddha‘), and Jer 7 29, gazaz, “Cut off thy hair [RVm “thy crown’’], O Jeru- salem” (cf Isa 22 12; Jer 166; Ezk 7 18; Am 8 10). This early and widespread practice was also forbidden to the Israelites as being unworthy of them in their relation to Jeh (Lev 19 27; Dt 14 1). Hérésheth, “carving,” “engraving,” 1s used for the “cutting of stones” (Ex 31 5; 35 33). In the NT we have apokopto, “to cut away” (Mk 9 43.45; Gal 6 12 AV; see Cowncision); diaprté, “to saw through” (Acts 6 33, ‘they were cut to the heart’’); dichelomés, “to cut in two” (Mt 24 51); suntémné, “to eut together’ (Rom 9 28), ‘finishing it and cutting it short,” ie. “making it conclusive and brief.” Cuth, Cuthah Cyprus Among the changes of RV are “brought to si- lence” for “cut down” (Jer 26 37), also for “cut off”? (Jer 49 26; 60 30); “sore wounded” for ‘cut in pieces” (Zec 12 3); for “cut off,” “pass through” (Job 11 10), “gone” (Ps 90 10); ‘rolled up” (Isa 38 12); “cut off’ for “destroy” (Ps 18 40; 69 4; 118 10.11.12); for “cut them in the head” (Am 9 1), “break them in pieces on the head of’’; for “in the cutting off of my days” (Isa 38 10; Heb d'mi, “silence,” ‘‘rest’’), ‘“‘noontide,” m “Or, tranquillity” (Gesenius, Delitzsch, etc, ‘‘in the quiet of my days’’); instead of, “I would that they were even cut off which trouble you” (Gal 6 12), ERV has “cut themselves off,” m ‘mutilate themselves,” ARV “go beyond circumcision,” m “Gr mutilate themselves.” W. L. Watker CUTH, kuth, CUTHAH, ki’tha (M5, kuth, TINND, kithah; Xovd, Choud, Xovv0d, Chounthd): The longer writing is the better of the two, and gives the Heb form of the name of one of the cities from which Sargon of Assyria brought colonists to fill the places of the Israelites which he deported from Samaria in 772 BC (2 K 17 24.30). Probably in consequence of their predominating numbers, the inhabitants of Samaria in general were then called kathiyim, or Cutheans. . From contract-tablets found at Tel-Ibrahim by the late Hormuzd Rassam, on which the ancient name of the place is given as Gudua 1. The or Kutd@, it would seem that that is the Ruins of site which has to be identified with the Cuthah Bib. Cuthah. It lies to the N.E. of Babylon, and was one of the most important cities of the Bab empire. The explorer describes the ruins as being about 3,000 ft. in cir- cumference and 280 ft. high, and adjoining them on the W. lies a smaller mound, crowned with a sanc- tuary dedicated to Ibrahim (Abraham). From the nature of the ruins, Rassam came to the conclusion that. the city was much more densely populated after the fall of Babylon than in earlier times. A portion of the ruins were in a very perfect state, and suggested an unfinished building. The great temple of the city was called B-mes- lam, and was dedicated to Nergal (cf 2 K 17 30), one of whose names was Meslam-ta-éa. 2. The Both city and temple would seem to Temple have been old Sumerian foundations, as the name Gudua and its later Sem form, Kutt, imply. Lirerature.—See Rassam, Asshur and the Land of Nimrod, 396, 409, and, for details of the worship of Nergal, PSBA, December, 1906, 203-18. T. G. Prncues CUTHA, kii'tha (Kovd, Kouthd; 1 Esd 5 32, AV Coutha): Head of a family of temple servants who returned with Zerubbabel from Babylon; not men- tioned in the canonical lists. CUTHAH. See Corn, CurHag. CUTHEAN, kt-thé’an, CUTHITE, kuth’it. See Curu; SAMARITANS. CUTTING ASUNDER. See AsunpEeR; Pun- ISHMENTS. CUTTING OFF. See Concision; PUNISHMENTS. CUTTINGSIN THE FLESH (UW, seret, POW, sGreteth): For relatives or friends to cut or beat themselves even to free blood-fiowing, especially in the violence of grief in mourning for their dead (see Buriat; Mourning), was a widely prevalent custom among ancient peoples, and is well-nigh uni- versal among uncivilized races today (see Spencer, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 770 Prin. of Soc., 3d ed, I, 168 ff). The fact is abun- dantly attested for most of the nations of antiquity, but there are two notable exceptions, the Egyptians (Herod. ii.61, 85; Wilk., Anc. Egyp, Il, 374), and the Hebrews (Dt 14 1; Lev 21 5). According to Plutarch (Sol. 21) Solon forbade the women of Athens to beat them- selves to the effusion of blood, and the laws of the Twelve Tables, quoted by Cic. (De leg. 11.23) contained a like injunc- tion. Among the ancient Arabs the forbidden practice was as- sociated, as among the He- brews, with the cutting off of the hair (Wellhausen, Skizzen, III, 160f). That the prohibition among the Hebrews wasurgently called foris made clear by the way it is dealt with by the Law and the prophets. The Law of Holiness reads: ‘‘Ye are the children of Jeh your God: ye shall not cut . yourselves” (Dt 14 1), or “make any incision” (UW, seret; Lev 19 28, NOW, sdreteth; LXX évrouls, entomis) in the flesh “for the dead.” Prob- ably the earliest reference to the custom as actually prevalent among the Hebrewsisin Hos 7 14(ERVm). Itwaswidely prevalent in the time of Jeremiah among his countrymen, even as among the Philis (Jer 47 5) and the Moabites (48 37; cf Am 8 10; Isa 3 24; 15 2; 22 12: Mic 1 16; Ezk 7 18). In seeking for the reason or purpose underlying all such prohibitions, we may note, first, that the “cuttings” and “baldness” forbidden are alike said to be “for the dead.’ Not less explicitly are they said to be incompatible with Israel’s unique rela- tion to Jeh—a relation at once of sonship (Dt 14 1) and of consecration (14 2). Moreover such mutilations of the body are always dealt with as forming part of the religious rites of the heathen (as of the Canaanitish Baal [1 K 18 28] note “after their manner,” see art. in HDB, s.v.). Both such shedding of blood and the dedication of the hair are found in almost all countries of that day in intimate connection with the rituals of burial and the pre- vailing belief in the necessity of propitiating the spirit of the deceased. The conclusion, then, seems clearly warranted that such tokens of grief were pro- hibited because they carried with them inevitably ideas and associations distinctly heathen in char- acter aud so incompatible with the pure religion of Jeh, and unworthy of those who had attained to the dignity of the sons (“children”) of Jeh. See also Mark; Stiemara. LitzRatuRE.—Benzinger, Heb Arch., §23; Nowack, Heb Arch., I, 33 f; Tylor, Prim. Cult.; W. R. Smith, Rel Sem, Lect IX; and Comm., Knobel-Dillmann, #x-Lev on Lev 19 28; Driver, Dton 14 1; and Lightfoot, Gal on 6 17. Gro. B. Eacer CYAMON, si‘a-mon (Kvapdv, Kuamén, Jth 7 3): Probably identical with JoknEam (q.v.). CYMBAL, sim’bal. CYPRESS, si’pres. CYPRIANS, sip’ri-ans (Kimpwor, Kiipriot): Oc- curs in 2 Macc 4 29. Menelaus who was high priest at Jerus, and Sostratus who was governor of the citadel, were summoned by King Antiochus to appear before him. ‘Menelaus left his own brother Lysimachus for his deputy in the high- priesthood; and Sostratus left Crates, who was over the Cyprians.” The Cyprians were the inhabi- tants of the island of Cyprus. Barnabas, who was Paul’s associate on his first missionary journey, was p am. See Music. See Houm Tree. 771 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cuth, Cuthah Cyprus a Cyprian (Kuprios; see Acts 4 36). RV desig- nates him as a man of Cyprus. The governor of the island was called a Cypriarch (see 2 Macc 12 2, and cf As1aRcH). A. W. Fortune CYPRUS, si’prus (Kérpos, Kiipros): An island situated near the N.E. corner of the Levant, in an angle formed by the coasts of Cilicia 1. Name _ and Syria. In the OT it is called Kit- tim, after the name of its Phoen capital Kition. The identification is expressly made by Jos (Ant, I, vi, 1) and by the Cyprian bishop Epi- phanius (Haer., xxx.25). In the tablets from Tell el-Amarna it is referred to as Alashia (E. Meyer, Gesch. des Alterthums, I?, §499), in Egyp records as Asi, while in the Assyr cuneiform inscriptions it is named Yavnan. The island is the largest in the Mediterranean with the exception of Sardinia and Sicily, its area being ahout 3,584 sq. miles. It lies in 34° 30’-35° 41’ 2. Geog- N. latitude and _ 32° 15’-34° 36’ E. longi- 3 tude, only 46 miles distant from the near- raphy est point of the Cilician coast and 60 miles _ from the Syrian. Thus from the northern shore of the island the mainland of Asia Minor is clearly visible and Mt. Lebanon can be seen from Eastern Cy- prus. This close proximity to the Cilician and Syrian coasts, as well as its position on the route between Asla Minor and Egypt, proved of great-importance for the his- tory and civilization of the island. Its greatest length, including the N.E. promontory, is about 140 miles, Its greatest breadth 60 miles. The S.W. portion of Cyprus is formed by a mountain complex, culminating in the peaks of Troddos (6,406 ft.), Midhari (5,305 ft.), Papofitsa (5,124 ‘t.) and MAchaira (4,674ft.). Tothe N.E. of this lies the great plain of the Mesoréa, nearly 60 miles in length and 10 to 20 in breadth, in which lies the modern capital Nicosia (Lefkosia). It is watered chiefly by the Pediaeus (mod. Pedids), and is bounded on the N, by a mountain range, which is continued_to the E.N.E. in the long, narrow promontory of the Karpass, terminating in Cape Andrea, the ancient Dinaretum. Its highest peaks are Buffavénto (3,135 ft.) and Hagios Elias (3,106 ft.). The shore-plain to the N. of these hills is narrow, but remark- ably fertile. | Cyprus is richly endowed by nature. Its fruits and flowers were famousin antiquity. Strabo, writing under Pe pee speaks of it as producing wine 3. Products and oil in abundance and corn sufficient for the needs of its inhabitants (XIV, 684). The elder Pliny refers to Cyprian salt, alum, gypsum, mica, unguents, laudanum, storax, resin and recious stones, including agate, jasper, amethyst, lapis azuli and several species of rock-crystal. His list includes the diamond (xxxvii.58) and the emerald (xxxvii.6, 66), but there is reason to believe that under these names a variety of rock-crystal and the beryl are intended. The chief source of the island’s wealth, how- ever, lay in its mines and forests. Silver is mentioned by Strabo (loc. cit.) among its products; copper, which was called by the Greeks after the name of the island, was extensively mined there from the earliest period down to the Middle. Ages; iron too was found in considerable quantities from the 9th cent. until Rom times. Scarcely less important were the forests, which at an early date are said to have covered almost the whole island. _The cypress seems to have been the principal tree, but Pliny tells of a giant cedar, 130 Rom feet in height, felled in Cyprus (xvi.203), and the island supplied timber for shipbuilding to many successive powers. The original inhabitants of Cyprus appear to have been a race akin to the peoples of Asia Minor. Its vast resources in copper and timber gained for it a considerable importance and wide commercial relations at a very remote period. Its wealth at- tracted the attention of Babylonia and Egypt, and there is reason to believe that it was conquered by Sargon I, king of Accad, and about a millennium later by Thothmes III, of the XVIIIth Egyptian Dynasty (1501-1447 BC). But the influences which molded its civilization camé from other uarters also. Excavation has shown that in 'yprus were several seats of the Minoan culture, and there can be little doubt that it was deeply influenced by Crete. The Minoan writing may well be the source of the curious Cyprian syllabic script, which continued in use for the representation of the Gr language down to the 4th cent. BC (A. J. Evans, 4, Early History Scripta Minoa, I). But the Minoan origin of the Cyprian syllabary is still doubtful, for it may have been derived from the Hittite hieroglyphs. Phoen influences too were at work, and the Phoen settlements—Citium, Amathus, Paphos and others —dgo back to a very early date. The break-up of the Minoan civilization was followed by a ‘Dark Age,” but later the island received a number of Gr settlers from Arcadia and other Hellenic states, as we judge not only from Gr tradition but from the evidence of the Cyprian dialect, which is closely akin to the Arcadian. In 709 BC Sargon II of Assyria made himself master of Cyprus, and tribute was paid by its seven princes to him and to his grand- son, Esarhaddon (681-667 BC). The overthrow of the Assyr Empire probably brought with it the independence of Cyprus, but it was conquered afresh by Aahmes (Amasis) of Egypt (Herod. ii. 182) who retained it till his death in 526 BC; but in the following year the defeat of his son and suc- cessor Psamtek III (Psammenitus) by Cambyses brought the island under Pers dominion (Herod. iii.19, 91). In 501 the Gr inhabitants led by Onesilus, brother of the reigning prince of Salamis, rose in revolt against the Persians, but were decisive- 5. Cyprus ly beaten (Herod. v.104 ff), and in 480 and the we find 150 Cyprian ships in the navy Greeks with which Xerxes attacked Greece (Herod. vii.90). The attempts of Pausanias and of Cimon to win Cyprus for the Hellenic cause met with but poor success, and the withdrawal of the Athenian forces from the Levant after their great naval victory off Salamis in 449 was followed by a strong anti-Hellenic movement throughout the island led by Abdemon, prince of Citium. In 411 Euagoras ascended the throne of Salamis and set to work to assert Hellenic influence and to champion Hellenic civilization. He joined with Pharnabazus the Pers satrap and Conon the Athenian to overthrow the naval power of Sparta at the battle of Cnidus in 394, and in 387 revolted from the Persians. He was followed by his son Nicocles, to whom Isocrates addressed the famous panegyric of Euagoras and who formed the subject of an enthusiastic eulogy by the same writer. Cyprus seems later to have fallen once again under Pers rule, but after the battle of Issus (333 BC) it voluntarily gave in its submission to Alexander the Great and rendered him valuable aid at the siege of Tyre. On his death (828) it fell to the share of Ptolemy of Egypt. It was, however, seized by Demetrius Poliorcetes, who defeated Ptolemy in a hotly contested battle off Salamis in 306. But eleven years later it came into the hands of the Ptolemies and remained a province of Egypt or a separate but dependent kingdom until the inter- vehtion of Rome (cf 2 Mace 10 13). We hear of a body of Cyprians, under the command of a certain Crates, serving among the troops of An- tiochus Epiphanes of Syria and forming part of the garrison of Jerus about 172 BC (2 Macc 4 29). This interpretation of the passage seems preferable to that according to which Crates had been governor of Cyprus under the Ptolemies before entering the service of Antiochus. In 58 BC the Romans resolved to incorporate Cyprus in their empire and Marcus Porcius Cato was intrusted with the task of its 6. Cyprus annexation. The reigning prince, a and Rome brother of Ptolemy Auletes of Egypt, received the offer of an honorable retirement as high priest of Aphrodite at Paphos, but he preferred to end his life by poison, and treas- ures amounting to some 7,000 talents passed into Rom hands, together with the island, which was attached to the province of Cilicia. In the parti- Cyprus Cyrus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 772 tion of the Rom empire between Senate and Em- peror, Cyprus was at first (27-22 BC) an imperial province (Dio Cassius liii.12), administered by a legatus Augusti pro praetore or by the imperial legate of Cilicia. In 22 BC, however, it was handed over to the Senate together with southern Gaul in ex- change for Dalmatia (Dio Cassius 1ii.12; liv.4) and was subsequently governed by ex-praetors bearing the honorary title of proconsul and residing at Paphos. The names of about a score of these governors are known to us from ancient authors, inscriptions and coins and will be found in D. G. Hogarth, Devia Cypria, App. Among them is Ser- gius Paulus, who was proconsul at the time of Paul’s visit to Paphos in 46 or 47 AD, and we may notice that the title applicd to him by the writer of the Acts (13 7) is strictly accurate. Coin of Cyprus under Emperor Claudius. The proximity of Cyprus to the Syrian coast rendered it easy of access from Pal, and Jews had probably begun to settle there even 7. Cyprus before the time of Alexander the Great. and the Certainly the number of Jewish resi- Jews dents under the Ptolemies was con- siderable (1 Mace 15 23; 2 Macc 12 2) and it must have been increased later when the copper mines of the island were farmed to Herod the Great (Jos, Ant, XVI, iv, 5; XIX, xxvi, 28; ef CIG, 2628). We shall not be surprised, there- fore, to find that at Salamis there was more than one synagogue at the time of Paul’s visit (Acts 13 5). In 116 AD the Jews of Cyprus rose in revolt and massacred no fewer than 240,000 Gentiles. Hadrian crushed the rising with great severity and drove all the Jews from the island. Henceforth no Jew might set foot upon it, even under stress of shipwreck, on pain of death (Dio Cassius Ixviii.32). In the life of the early church Cyprus played an important part. Among the Christians who fled from Judaea in consequence of the 8. The persecution which followed Stephen’s Church death were some who “‘travelled as far in Cyprus as Phoenicia, and Cyprus” (Acts 11 19) preaching to the Jews only. Certain natives of Cyprus and Cyrene took a further momentous step in preaching at Antioch to the Greeks also (Acts 11 20). Even before this time Joseph Barnabas, a Levite born in Cyprus (Acts 4 36), was prominent in the early Christian community at Jerus, and it was in his native island that he and Paul, accompanied by Barnabas’ nephew, John Mark, began their first missionary journey (Acts 13 4). After landing at Salamis they passed “through the whole island” to Paphos (Acts 18 6), probably visiting the Jewish synagogues in its cities. The Peutinger Table tells us of two roads from Salamis to Paphos in Rom times, one of which ran inland by way of Tre- mithus, Tamassus and Soli, a journey of about 4 days, while the other and easier route, occupying some 8 days, ran along the south coast by way of Citium, Amathus and Curium. Whether the “early disciple,” Mnason of Cyprus, was one of the converts made at this time or had previously em- braced Christianity we cannot determine (Acts 21 16). Barnabas and Mark revisited Cyprus later (Acts 15 39), but Paul did not again land on the island, though he sighted it when, on his last journey to Jerus, he sailed south of it on his way from Patara in Lycia to Tyre (Acts 21 3), and again when on his journey to Rome he sailed “under the lee of Cyprus,” that is, along its northern coast, on the way from Sidon to Myra in Lycia (Acts 27 4). In 401 AD the Council of Cyprus was convened, chiefly in consequence of the efforts of Theophilus of Alexandria, the inveterate opponent of Ori- genism, and took measures to check the reading of Origen’s works. The island, which was divided into 13 bishoprics, was declared autonomous in the 5th cent., after the alleged discovery of Matthew’s Gospel in the tomb of Barnabas at Salamis. The bishop of Salamis was made metropolitan by the emperor Zeno with the title “archbishop of all Cyprus,” and his successor, who now occupies the see of Nicosia, still enjoys the privilege of signing his name in red ink and is primate over the three other bishops of the island, those of Paphos, Kition and Kyrenia, all of whom are of metropolitan rank. Cyprus remained in the possession of the Rom and then of the Byzantine emperors, though twice overrun and temporarily occupied by the Saracens, 9. Later until] 1184, when its ruler, Isaac Comne- Hi nus, broke away from Constantinople and istory declared himself an independent emperor. From him it was wrested in 1191 by the Crusaders under Richard I of England, who bestowed it on Guy de Lusignan, the titular king of Jerus, and his descendants. In 1489 it was ceded to the Venetians by Catherine Cornaro, widow of James II, the last of the Lusignan kings, and remained in their hands until it was captured by the Ottoman Turks under Sultan Selim II, who invaded and subjugated the island in 1570 and laid siege to Famagtsta, which, after a heroic defence, capitulated on August 1, 1571. Since that time Cyprus has formed part of the Turkish empire, in spite of serious revoltsin 1764 and 1823; since 1878, however, it has been occnpied and administered by the British gov- ernment, subject to an annual payment to the Sublime Porte of £92,800 and a large quantity of salt. The High Commissioner, who resides at Nicosia, is assisted by a Legislative Council of 18 members. The estimated population in 1907 was 249,250, of whom rather more than a fifth were Moslems and the remainder chiefly members of the Gr Orthodox church. Lirerature.—An exhaustive bibliography will be found in C. D. Cobham, An Attempt at a Bibliography of Cyprus, Nicosia, 4th ed, 1900. The following works may be specially mentioned: E. Oberhummer, Aus Cypern, Berlin, 1890-92; Studien zur alten Geographie von Kypros, Munich, 1891; A. Sakellarios, Ta Kuzpiaxd, Athens, 1890+ References in ancient sources are collected in J. Meursins, Cyprus, Amsterdam, 1675, and W. Engel, Kypros, Berlin, 1841. For Cyprian archae- ology see P. Gardner, New Chapters in_Gr History, ch vi, London, 1892; Myres and M. Ohnefalsch- Richter, Catalogue of the Cyprus Museum, Oxford, 1899; M. O. Richter, Kypros, die Bibel und Homer, Berlin, 1893; D. G. Hogarth, Devia Cypria, London, 1889; and J. L. Myres’ art. on ‘Cypriote Archaeology” in Enc Brit, llth ed, VII, 697 ff. For excavations, Journal of Hellenic Studies, IX, XI, XII, XVII, and Excavations in Cyprus, London (British Museum), 1900; for art, G. Per- rot and C. Chipiez, Art in Phoenicia and Cyprus, ET, London, 1885; for coins, B. V. Head, Historia Numorum, Oxford, 1911; for inscriptions, Sammlung der griech. Dialekt-Inschriften, I, Géttingen, 1883; for the Cyprian church, J. Hackett, History of the Orithedox Church of Cyprus, London, 1901; for authorities on mediaeval and puder history, C. D. Cobham, Ene Brit, 11th ed, VI, z } Marcus N. Top CYRAMA, si-r4’ma, sir’a-ma. See Kirama. CYRENE, si-ré’né (Kvpjvyn, Kuréné, ‘“wall”): Cyrene was a city of Libya in North Africa, lat. 32° 40’ N., long. 22° 15’ EB. It lay W. of 1. Location ancient Egypt, from which it was separated by a portion of the Libyan desert, and occupied the territory now belonging to Barca and Tripoli. It was situated upon an ele- vated plateau about 2,000 ft. above the sea, from which it was distant some 10 miles. A high range of mountains lies to the S., about 90 miles inland. This shelters the coast land from the scorching 773 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cyprus Cyrus heat of the Sahara. The range drops down toward the N. in a series of terrace-like elevations, thus giving to the region a great variety of climate and vegetation. The soil is fertile. Cyrene was originally a Gr eolony founded by Battus in 630 BC. Beeause of the fertility of the soil, the great variety in climate and 2. History vegetation, together with its commer- cial advantages in location, the eity soon rose to great wealth and importance. Greater fame, however, came to it through its distinguished eitizens. It was the home of Callimachus the poet, Carneacles the founder of the New Academy at Athens, and Eratosthenes the mathematician. To these must be added, from later times, the elegant ancient Christian writer Synesius. So important did this Gr eolony beeome that, in little more than half a century, Amasis II of Egypt formed an alliance with C ene, marrying a Gr lady of noble, erhaps royal, bith (Herod. 1.181). Ptolemy III Pevereets I), 231 BC, incorporated Cyrene with Egypt. The city continued, though with much restlessness, a part of the Egyp empire until Apion, the last of the Ptolemies, willed it to Rome. It henceforth belonged to a Rom province. In the middle of the 7th eent., the conquering Saracens took possession of Cyrene, and from that time to this it has been the habitation of wandering tribes of Arabs. Cyrene comes into importance in Bib. history through the dispersion of the Jews. Ptolemy I, son of Lagus, transported Jews to this 3. Biblical and other cities of Libya (Jos, CAp, Importance I], 4) and from this time on Jews were very numerous there. By the return of the Jews of the Dispersion to the feasts at Jerus, Cyrenians came to have a eonspicuous place in the NT history. ‘A man of Cyrene, Simon by name,” was caught by the Rom soldiers and compelled to bear the cross of Jesus (Mt 27 32; cf Mk 16 21; Lk 23 26). See Cyrenian. Jews from Cyrene were among those present on the day of Pentecost. Their city appears as one of the important points in the wide circle of the Dispersion described by Peter in his sermon on that oecasion (Aets 2 10). Cy- renian Jews were of sufficient importance in those days to have their name associated with a syna- gogue at Jerus (6 9). And when the persecution arose ahout Stephen, some of these Jews of Cyrene who had heen eonverted at Jerus, were seattered abroad and eame with others to Antioch and preached the word ‘“‘unto the Jews only’ (11 19. 20 AV), and one of them, Lucius, became a prophet in the early church there. In this case, as in so many others, the wise providence of God in the dis- persion of the Jews in preparation for the spread of the gospel of the Messiah is seen. Coin of Cyrene. In the ruins of Cyrene are to be seen the remains of some beautiful buildings, and a few sculptures have been removed. The most inter- 4. Archae- esting remains of the wondrous civil- ology ization of this Gr colony are in a great system of tombs, some built, but the finest cut in the solid rock of the cliff. Dorie archi- tecture and brilliant decorative painting adorn these tombs. Literature.—Herod. ii; Jos, CAp; Thrige, Res Cyre- nensium. M. G. Kyte CYRENIAN, si-ré’ni-an, CYRENIANS (Kvpn- vates, Kurénaios, “a native or inhabitant of Cyrene’’): Two Jews of Cyrene are mentioned in the NT, viz. Simon (Mk 15 21 and Lk 23 26 AV) who was impressed to bear the Lord’s cross (Mk 15 21 RVm), and Lucius, a Christian teacher at Antioch (Acts 18 1). See Cyrenn; Luctus; Simon. For Cyrenians see CYRENE. CYRENIUS, “of Cyrene’’). CYRIA, sir’i-a (Kvpla, Kuria): The word means “lady,” feminine of lord, and it is so tr4in AV and the text of RV (2 Jn ver 5 RVm). But it is possible that the word is a proper name, and this possibility is recognized by placing Cyria, the usual transliteration of the word, in the margin by RV. CYRUS, si’rus (W7ID, koresh; Old Pers Kurus; Bab Kur[rjas, Kur[rlasu; Gr Kipos, Kuros, 2 Ch 36 22, ete): 1. Genealogy of Cyrus 2. His Country, Ansan or Anzan 3. His Origin (Herodotus) yea (Xenophon) ' 5 “ 6. 7 8 9 si-ré/ni-us (Kvpfyos, Kurénios, See QuiRinius. (Nicolaus of Damascus) coos ** (Ctesias) . Babylonian Records of His Reign—the Cylinder of Nabonidus . The Babylonian Chronicle sea “6 —The Capture of Babylon 10. The Cylinder of Cyrus 11. Cyrus’ History from Greek Sources 12. The Massagetae 13. The Sacae, Berbices, etc 14. Doubt as to the Manner of His Death 15. Cyrus' Reputation 16. Why Did the Babylonians Accept Him? 17. Cyrus and the Jews 18. Cyrus in Persia—His Bas-relief The son of the earlier Cambyses, of the royal race of the Achemenians. His genealogy, as given by himself, is as follows: “I am Cyrus, 1. Gene- _ king of the host, the great king, the alogy of mighty king, king of Tindir [Babylon], Cyrus king of the land of Sumeru and Akkadiy, king of the four regions, son of Cam- byses, the great king, king of the city AnSan, grand- son of Cyrus, the great king, king of the eity AnSan, great-grandson of SiSpiS [Tetspes], the great king, king of the city Anan, the all-enduring royal seed whose sovereignty Bel and Nebo love,” etc (WAI, V, pl. 35, 20-22). As, in the Bab inscriptions, A&8San (AnSan, Anzan) is explained as Elam—the city was, in fact, the capital of that country—it is 2. His probable that Cyrus’ name was Elam- Country, ite; but the meaning is doubtful. The Angan or old Gr etymology connecting it with Anzan khor, “the sun,” in Persian, may there- fore he rejected. Aceording to Strabo, he was at first ealled Agradatés, the name by which he was universally known being taken from that of the river Cyrus. This, however, is more likely to have been the reason why his grandfather (after whom he was probably named) was called Cyrus. Several versions of his birth and rise to power are recorded. Herodotus (1.95) mentions three. In that which he quotes (1.107 ff), it is said 3. His that Mandane was the daughter of the Origin Median king Astyages, who, in eon- (Herodotus) sequence of a dream which he had had, foretelling the ultimate triumph of her son over his dynasty, gave her in marriage to a Persian named Cambyses, who was not one of his Cyrus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 774 peers. A second dream caused him to watch for her expected offspring, and when Cyrus came into the world Astyages delivered the child to his rela- tive, Harpagus, with orders to destroy it. Being unwilling +o do this, he handed the infant to a shepherd named Mitradates, who, his wife having brought forth a still-born child, consented to spare the life of the infant Cyrus. Later on, in conse- quence of his imperious acts, Cyrus was recognized hy Astyages, who came to learn the whole story, and spared him because, having once been made king by his companions in play, the Magians held the predictions concerning his ultimate royal state to have been fulfilled. The vengeance taken by Astyages upon Harpagus for his apparent dis- obedience to orders is well known: his son was slain, and a portion, disguised, given him to eat. Though filled with grief, Harpagus concealed his feelings, and departed with the remains of his son’s body; and Cyrus, in due course, was sent to stay with his parents, Cambyses and Mandane. Later on, Harpagus persuaded Cyrus to induce the Per- sians to revolt, and Astyages having blindly ap- pointed Harpagus commander-in-chief of the Median army, the last-named went over to the side of Cyrus. The result, was an easy victory for the latter, but Astyages took care to impale the Magians who had advised him to spare his grandson. Having gathered another, but smaller, army, he took the field in person, but was defeated and captured. Cyrus, however, who became king of Media as well as of Persia, treated him honorably and well. According to Xenophon, Cyropaedia i. §2, Cam- byses, the father of Cyrus, was king of Persia. Until his 12th year, Cyrus was educa- 4. His ted in Persia, when be was sent for, Origin with his mother, by Astyages, to whom (Xenophon) he at once manifested much affection. Astyages is said to have been succeeded by his son Cyaxares, and Cyrus then became his commander-in-chief, subduing, among others, the Lydians. He twice defeated the Assyrians (= Baby- lonians), his final conquest of the country being while the Median king wasstill alive. As, however, the Cyropaedia is a romance, the historical details are not of any great value. Nicolaus of Damascus describes Cyrus as the son of a Mardian handit named Atradates, his mother’s name being Argosté. While 5. Nicolaus in service in the palace of Astyages, of Damas- he was adopted by Artembarés, a cus cupbearer, and thus obtained promi- nence. Cyrus now made his bandit- father satrap of Persia, and, with base ingratitude, plotted against his king and benefactor. The preparations for a revolt having been made, he and his general Oibaras were victorious at Hyrba, but were defeated at Parsagadae, where his father: Atradates was captured and later on died. Cyrus now took refuge in his mountain home, but the taunts of the women sent him and his helpers forth again, this time to victory and dominion. Ctesias also states that there was no relation- ship between Cyrus and Astyages (Astyigas), who, when Cyrus conquered Media, fled to 6. His Ecbatana, and was there hidden by Origin his daughter Amytis, and Spitamas her (Ctesias) husband. Had not Astyages yielded, Cyrus, it is said, would have tortured them, with their children. Cyrus afterward libera- ted Astyages, and married his daughter Amytis, whose husband he had put to death for telling a falsehood. The Bactrians are said to have been so satisfied at the reconciliation of Cyrus with nae ages and his daughter, that thcy voluntarily sub- 1He may have added Persia to his dominion, but ac- cording to Cyrus himself, he was king of Ansan or Elam. | where it was seemingly expected that the mitted. Cyrus is said by Ctesias to have been taken prisoner by the Sacae, but he was ransomed. He died from a wound received in battle with the Derbices, assisted by the Indians. ‘ : In the midst of so much uncertainty, it is a relief to turn to the contemporary documents of the Baby- lonians, which, though they do not 7. Baby- speak of Cyrus’ youth in detail, and lonian refer only to other periods of his career Records of in which they were more immediately His Reign interested, may nevertheless, being —the Cyl- contemporary, be held to have an inder of altogether special authority. Accord- Nabonidus ing to the inscriptions, the conflict with Astyages took place in 549 BC. From the cylinder of Nabonidus we learn that the Medes had been very successful in their war- like operations, and had gone even as far afield as Haran, which they had besieged. The Baby- lonian King Nabonidus desired to carry out the instructions of Merodach, revealed in a dream, to restore the temple of Sin, the Mcoon-god, in that city. This, however, in consequence of the siege, he could not do, and it was revealed to him in a dream that the power of Astyages would he over- thrown at the end of three years, which happened as predicted. ‘They [the gods Sin and Merodach] then caused Cyrus, king of Anzan, his [Merodach’s| young servant, with his little army, to rise up against him [the Median]; he destroyed the wide-spreading Umman-manda [Medes], Ktuwegu [Astyages], king of the Medes, he captured, and took [him] prisoner to his [own] land.” The account of this engagement in the Babylonian Chronicle (which is, perhaps, Cy- rus’ own), is as follows: “({Astyages] gathered his army, and went against Cyrus, king of AnSan, to capture him, and [as for] Astyages, his 8. The army revolted against him and took Babylonian him, and gave him to Cyrus. Cyrus Chronicle went to the land of Ecbatana, his royal city. He carried off from Ecbatana silver, gold, furniture, merchandise, and took to the land of Ansan the furniture and merchandise which he had captured.” . The above is the entry for the 6th year of Na- bonidus, which corresponds with 549 BC; and it will be noticed that he is here called “king of AnSan.”’ The next reference to Cyrus in the Bab Chronicle is the entry for Nabonidus’ 9th year (546 BC), where it is stated that “Cyrus, king of the land of Parsu [Persia], gathered his army, and crossed the Tigris below Arbela,’’ and in the following month (Iyyar) entered the land of IS-. . . . , wheresomeone seems to have taken a brihe, garrisoned the place, and afterward a king ruled there. The passage, how- ever, is imperfect, and therefore obscure, but we may, perhaps, see therein some preparatory move on the part of Cyrus to obtain possession of the tract over which Nabonidus claimed dominion. The next year (545 BC) there seems to have been another move on the part of the Persians, for the Elamite governor (?) is referred to, and had appar- ently some dealings with the governor of Erech. All this time things seem to have been the same in Babylonia, thé king’s son (he is not named, but apparently Belshazzar is meant) and the soldiers remaining in Akkad (possibly used in the old sense of the word, to indicate the district around Sippar), main attack would _be delivered. The reference to the governor of Erech might imply that some con- spiracy was on foot more to the south—a movement of which the native authorities possibly remained in ignorance. After a gap which leaves four years unaccounted for, we have traces of four lines which mention the goddess Istar of Erech, and the gods of the land 775 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cyrus of Par... . (?Persia) are referred to. After this comes the long entry, which, though the date is broken away, must refer to the 17th 9. The year of Nahonidus. A royal visit to a Chronicle— temple is referred to, and there is men- the Capture tion of a revolt. Certain religious cere- of Babylon monies were then performed, and others omitted. Inthe month Tammuz, Cyrus seems to have fought a battle in Opis, and succeeded in attacking the army of Akkad situated on the Tigris. On the 14th of the month, Sippar was taken without fighting, and Nabonidus fled. On the 16th Ugbaru (Gobryas) governor of Media, entered Baby- lon, with the army of Cyrus, without fighting, and there Nabonidus was captured with his followers. At this time E-saggil and the temples of the land seem to have been closed, possibly to prevent the followers of Nabonidus from taking sanctuary there, or else to prevent plotters from coming forth; and on the 3d of Marcheswan (October), Cyrus entered Babylon. “Crowds collected before him, proposing peace for the city; Cyrus, command the peace of Babylon, all of it.” Gobryas, his vice- regent, then appoimted governors in Babylon, and the gods whom Nabonidus had taken down to Babylon, were returned to their shrines. On the night of the 11th of Marcheswan, Ugharu went against (some part of Babylon), and the son of the king died; and there was mourning for him from the 27th of Adar to the 3d of Nisan (six days). There is some doubt as to whether the text speaks of the king or the son of the king, but as there is a record that Nabonidus was exiled to Carmania, it would seem most likely that the death of Belshazzar ‘Gn the night” is here referred to. The day after the completion of the mourning (the 4th of Nisan), Cambyses, son of Cyrus, performed ceremonies in the temple E-nig-had-kalamma, probably in con- nection with the new year’s festival, for which Cyrus had probably timed his arrival at Babylon. Accord- ing to Herodotus (1.191), Babylon was taken dur- ing a festival, agreeing with Dn! 5 1 ff. The other inscription of Cyrus, discovered by Mr. H. Rassam at Babylon, is a kind of proclamation justifying his seizure of the crown. 10. The He states that the gods (of the various Cylinder cities of Babylonia) forsook their of Cyrus dwellings in anger that he (Nakonidus) had made them enter within Su-anna (Babylon). Merodach, the chief divinity of Baby- lon, sought also a just king, the desire of his heart, whose hand he might hold—Cyrus, king of Anan, he called his title—to all the kingdoms together (his) name was proclaimed. The glory of Cyrus’ conquests probably appealed to the Babylonians, for Cyrus next states that Mer- odach placed the whole of the troops of Quti (Media) under his feet, and the whole of the troops of the Manda (barbarians and mercenaries). He also caused his hands to hold the people of the dark head (Asiatics, including the Babylonians)—in righteous- ness and justice he cared for them. He commanded that he should go to his city Babylon, and walked by his side like a friend and a companion—without fighting and battle Merodach cansed him to enter Su-anna. By his high command, the kings of every region from the upper sea to the lower sea (the Mediterranean to the Persian Gulf), the kings of the Amorites, and the dwellers in tents, brought their valuable tribute and kissed his feet within Su-anna (Babylon). From Nineveh(?), the city ASéur, Susa, Agadé, the land of E’nunnak, Zamban, Mé-Turnu, and Déru, to the borders of Media, the gods inhabiting them were returned to their shrines, and all the people were collected and sent back to their dwellings. He finishes by soliciting the prayers of the gods to Bel and Nebo for length of days and happiness, asking them also to appeal to Merodach on behalf of Cyrus “his worshipper,” and his son Cambyses. It was probably between the defeat of Astyages and the capture of Babylon that Cyrus defeated Croesus and conquered Lydia. After 11. Cyrus’ preparing to attack the Gr _ cities of History from Asia Minor, he returned to Echatana, Greek taking Croesus with him. The states Sources which had formed the Lydian empire however, at once revolted, and ha again to be reduced to submission, this time by Harpagus, his faithful general, after a determined resistance. It was at this period that Cyrus sub- dued the nations of Upper Asia, his next objective being Babylonia (§9 and the two preceding para- graphs). In this connection it is noteworthy that, in the Bab official account, there is no mention of his engineering works preparatory to the taking of Babylon—the turning of the waters of the Gyndes into a number of channels in order to cross (Herod. i.189); the siege of Babylon, long and difficult, and the final capture of the city hy changing the course of the Euphrates, enabling his army to enter by the bed of the river (Herod. 1.190-91). There may be some foundation for this statement, but if so, the king did not boast of it—perhaps because it did not entail any real labor, for the irrigation works already in existence may have been nearly sufficient for the purpose. It seems likely that the conquest of Babylon opened the way for other military ex- ploits. Herodotus states that he next attacked the Massagetae, who were located 12. The beyond the Araxes. One-third of their Massagetae army was defeated, and the son of Tomyris, the queen, captured by a stratagem; but on being freed from his bonds, he committed suicide. In another exceedingly fierce battle which followed, the Pers army was destroyed, and Cyrus himself brought his life to an end there, after a reign of 29 years. (He had ruled over Media for 11, and over Babylonia [and Assyria] for 9 years.) According to the Bab contract-tablets, Cambyses, his son, was associated with him on the throne during the first portion of his 1st year of rule in Babylon. According to Ctesias, Cyrus made war with the Bactrians and the Sacae, but was taken prisoner by the latter, and was afterward 13. The ransomed. He died from a wound re- Sacae, Ber- ceived in battle with the Berbices. bices, ete Diodorus agrees, in the main, with Herodotus, but relates that Cyrus was captured by the Scythian queen (apparently Tomyris), who crucified or impaled him. It is strange that, in the case of such a celebrated ruler as Cyrus, nothing certain is known as to the manner of his death. The accounts 14. Doubt which have come down to us seem to astothe make it certain that he was killed in Manner of battle with some enemy, but the state- His Death ments concerning his end are con- flicting. This absence of any account of his death from a trustworthy source implies that Herodotus is right in indicating a terrible disaster to the Pers arms, and it is therefore probable that he fell on the field of battle—perhaps in conflict with the Massagetae, as Herodotus states. Sup- posing that only a few of the Pers army escaped, it may be that not one of those who saw him fall lived to tell the tale, and the world was dependent on the more or less trustworthy statements which the Massagetae made. That he was considered to be a personage of noble character is clear from all that has come down to us concerning him, the most noteworthy being Xeno- phon’s Cyrepaedia and Institution of Cyrus. The Cyrus Dalmatia THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 776 Bab inscriptions do not reproduce Bab opinion, but the fact that on the occasion of the siege of Babylon the people trusted to his 16. Cyrus’ honor and came forth asking peace for Reputation the city (apparently with every confi- dence that their request would be granted); and that the Babylonians, as a whole, were contented under his rule, may be regarded as tacit confirmation. Nabonidus, before the invasion of his territory by the Pers forces, was evidently well disposed toward him, and looked upon him, as we have seen, as ‘‘the young servant of Merodach,” the patron deity of Babylon. It is not altogether clear, however, why the Babylonians submitted to him with so little resistance—their inscriptions contain no indication that they had real reason to be dissatisfied with the rule of Nabonidus—he seems to have been simply regarded as 16. Why Did somewhat unorthodox in his worship the Baby- of the gods; but could they expect lonians an alien, of a different religion, to be Accept better in that respect? Dissatisfac- Him? tion on the part of the Babylonian priesthood was undoubtedly at the bottom of their discontent, however, and may be held to supply a sufficient reason, though it does not redound to the credit of Bab patriotism. It has been said that the success of Cyrus was in part due to the aid given him by the Jews, who, recog- nizing him as a monotheist like themselves, gave him more than mere sympathy; but it is probable that he could never have conquered Babylonia had not the priests, as indicated by their own records, spread discontent among the people. It is doubtful whether we may attribute a higher motive to the priesthood, though that is not altogether impossible. The inner teaching of the Bab polytheistic faith was, as is now well known, monotheistic, and there may have been, among the priests, a desire to have a ruler holding that to be the true faith, and also not so inclined as Nabonidus to run counter to the people’s (and the priests’) prejudices. Jewish Anfitence would, in some measure, account for this. If the Jews thought that they would be more sympathetically treated under Cyrus’ rule, they DABAREH, dab’a-re. See DaBerartu. DABBESHETH, dab’e-sheth, (WAI, dabbesheth; AaBac8al, Dabasthai; AV Dabbasheth, dab’a-sheth): A town on the western boundary of Zebulun (Josh 19 11). It is probably identical with the modern Dabsheh, a ruined site to the E. of Acre. DABERATH, dab’é-rath (R70, ha-dabh’rath, “pasture”; AaPetpa6, Dabeirdth): A city in the ter- ritory of Issachar, on the boundary between that tribe and Zebulun (Josh 19 12). It was assigned to the Gershonite Levites (Josh 21 28; 1 Ch 6 72). The most probable identification is with Dabiriyeh, a village on the lower western slopes of Tabor. DABRIA, da’bri-a: One of the five who wrote down the visions of Esdras, described (2 Esd 14 24) as “ready to write swiftly.” DACUBI, da-ki’bi, AV Dacobi, di-ko’bi: Head of a family of gate-keepers (1 Hsd 5 28). See Axkus; Daxvsi. DADDEUS, da-dé’us, RV LODDEUS (Ac8Saios, Loddaios), which see. were not disappointed. It was he who gave orders for the rebuilding of the Temple at Jerus (2 Ch 36 23; Ezr 1 2; 6 13; 6 3), restored 17. Cyrus the vessels of the House of the Lord and the which Nebuchadnezzar had taken away Jews (Ezr 1 7), and provided funds to bring cedar trees from Lebanon (3 7). But he also restored the temples of the Babylonians, and brought back the images of the gods to their shrines. Nevertheless the Jews evidently felt that the favors he granted them showed sympathy for them, and this it probably was which caused Isaiah (44 28) to see in him a “‘shepherd” of the Lord, and an anointed king (Messiah, r@ xpior@ pov, 16 Chrisié mou, Isa 45 1)—a title suggesting to later writers that he was a type of Christ (Hieron., Comm. on Isa 44 1). ; From Persia we do not get any help as to his character, nor as to the estimation in which he was held. His only inscription extant 18.Cyrus is ahove his idealized bas-relief at in Persia— Murghdb, where he simply writes: His Bas- ‘I am Cyrus, the Achemenian.” The relief stone shows Cyrus standing, looking to the right, draped in a fringed gar- ment resembling those worn by the ancient Baby- lonians, reaching to the feet. His hair is combed back in the Pers style, and upon his head is an elaborate Egyp crown, two horns extending to front and back, with a uraeus serpent rising from each end, and between the serpents three vase-like ob- jects, with discs at their bases and summits, and serrated leaves between. There is no doubt that this crown is symbolical of his dominion over Egypt, the three vase-like objects being modifi- cations of the triple helmet-crown of the Egyp deities. The king is represented as four-winged in the Assyro-Babylonian style, probably as a claim to divinity in their hierarchy as well as to dominion in the lands of Merodach’and ASSur. In his right hand, which is raised to the level of his shoulder, he holds a kind of scepter seemingly terminating in a bird’s head—in all probability also a symbol of Bab dominion, though the emblem of the Bab cities of the South was most commonly a bird with wings displayed. T. G. PincueEs DAGGER, dag’ér. See Armor, Arms. DAGON, da’gon (JJ, daghon; apparently de- rived from 4°], dagh, ‘“‘fish”): Name of the god of the Philis (according to Jerome on Isa 46 1 of the Philis generally); in the Bible Dagon is associated with Gaza (Jgs 16) but elsewhere with Ashdod (cf 18 6 and 1 Macc 10 83f; 11 4); in1 Ch 10 10 there is probably an error (cf the |! passage 1 S 31 10). The god had his temple (‘‘the houseof Dagon’’) and his priests. When the ark was captured by the Philis, it was con- ducted to Ashdod where it was placed in the house of Dagon by the side of the idol. But on the morrow it was found that the idol lay prostrate be- fore the ark of the Lord. It was restored to its place; but on the fol- lowing day Dagon again lay on the ground before the ark, this time with the head and both hands severed from the body and lying upon the miphidn (the word is commonly interpreted to mean ‘‘threshold”; according to Winckler, it means “pedestal”); the body alone Dagon. 777 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Cyrus Dalmatia remained intact. The Heb says: “Dagon alone | of gate-keepers (1 Esd 6 28) called “Akkub” in the remained.” Whether we resort to an emendation (43, daghd, “his fish-part’’) or not, commen- tators appear to be right in inferring that the idol was half man, half fish. Classic authors give this form to Derceto. The sacred writer adds that from that time on the priests of Dagon and all those that entered the house of Dagon refrained from stepping upon the miphian of Dagon. See 1 S 6 1-5. The prophet Zephaniah (1 9) speaks of an idolatrous practice which consisted in leaping over the miph- tan. The Septuagint in 1 S indeed adds the clause: “but they were wont to leap.’ Leaping over the threshold was probably a feature of the Phili ritual which the Hebrews explained in their way. A god Dagon seems to have been worshipped by the Ca- naanites; see BETH-DAGON. LiteRATURE.—Commentaries on Jgs and 1 8S; Winck- ler, Altoriental. Forschungen, III, 3838. Max L. Marconis DAILY, dali: This word, coming as it does from the Heb BT, yém, “day,” and the Gr 4pépa, ha- méra, suggests either day by day (Ex 5 13), that which is prepared for one daily (Nch 5 18), as e.g. our ‘daily bread,” meaning bread sufficient for that day (Mt 6 11); or day by day continuously, one day after another in succession, as ‘‘the daily burnt offering’ (Nu 29 6 AV), ‘daily ministra- tion” (Acts 6 1), and ‘‘daily in the temple” (Acts 5 42 AV). The meaning of the word “daily” as used in the Lord’s Prayer (Mt 6 11) seems to indi- cate sufficient for our need, whether we consider that need as a day at a time, or day after day as we are permitted to live. “Give us bread sufficient for our sustenance.” WituiamM Evans DAILY OFFERING, or SACRIFICE. See Sac- RIFICE. DAINTIES, dan’tiss DAINTY (MEATS) (NAPS, mat'ammoth, “things full of taste,” DAI, man‘ammim, TIVA, ma'tédhan; \wapés, liparés, “fat,’’ “shining’”’): Jacob is represented as predicting of Asher, ‘‘He shall yield royal d.’’ (Gen 49 20; cf || clause, ‘His bread shall be fat,” and Dt 33 24, “Let him dip his foot in oil’). David, praying to be delivered from the ways of “men that work inquity,” cries, “Let me not eat of their d.” (Ps 141 4). The man who sitteth “to eat with a ruler” (Prov 231-3) is counseled, “If thou be a man given to appetite, be not desirous of his d.; see- ing they are deceitful food” (cf John’s words in the woes upon Babylon [Rev 18 14], ‘All things that were d. and sumptuous are perished from thee,”’ and Homer’s Iliad [Pope], xviii.456). ‘‘Dainties,’’ then, are luxuries, costly, delicate and rare. This idea is common to all the words thus rendered; naturally associated with kings’ tables, and with the lives of those who are lovers of pleasure and luxury. By their associations and their softening effects they are to be abstained from or indulged in moderately as ‘deceitful food” by those who would live the simple and righteous life which wisdom sanc- tions. They are also “offered not from genuine hospitality, but with some by-ends.”’ He should also shun the dainties of the niggard (Prov 23 6) who counts the cost (ver 7 RVm) of every morsel that his‘guest eats. See Drexiicats; Foon, etc. Gro. B. EacEer DAISAN, da’san, da‘i-san (Aotodv, Daisdn): Head of a family of temple servants (1 Esd 5 31) called Rezin in Ezr 2 48; Neh 7 50, the inter- change of D and #in Heb being not uncommon. DAKUBI, da-kii’bi, da-koo’bi (AaxotB, Dakoub, AakovuBl, Dakoubi; AVY Dacobi): Head of a family canonical lists. DALAIAH, da-la’a, da-la-i’a. DALAN, da’/lan (Aaddv, Dalén; AV Ladan): Head of a family that returned to Jerus, but which “could shew neither their families, nor their stock, how they were of Israel” (1 Esd 5 37); corresponds to Delaiah (Ezr 2 60). Another reading is “Asan.” DALE, dal, KING’S (TAT POY, ‘emek ha- melekh) : (1) “Absalom in his lifetime had taken and reared up for himself the pillar, which is in the king’s dale” (2 8 18 18). According to Jos (Ant, VII, x, 3) this was a marble pillar, which he calls ‘“Absalom’s hand” and it was two furlongs from Jerus. Warren suggests that this dale was identical with the Kinc’s GarpeEn (q.v.), which he places at the open valley formed at the junction of the Tyropceon with the Kidron (see JERusaLEM). The so-called Absalom’s Pillar, which the Jews still pelt with stones in reprobation of Absalom’s disobedience, and which a comparatively recent tradition asso- ciates with 2 S 18 18, isa very much later structure, belonging to the Graeco-Rom period, but showing Egyp influence. (2) King’s Vale (Gen 14 17; AV dale). See E. W. G. Masterman Kine’s VALE; VALn. DALETH, da‘leth (7, 7): The 4th letter of the Heb alphabet, and as such used in Ps 119 to designate the 4th section; transliterated in this Encyclopaedia with the dagesh as d, and, without, as dh (=th in the). It came also to be used for the number four (4), and with the dieresis for 4,000. With the apostrophe it is sometimes used as abbre- viation for the tetragrammaton. For name, etc, see ALPHABET. DALLY, dal’i: Oceurs in Wisd 12 26: “But they that would not be reformed by that correction wherein he daillied with them” (ravyviots émiriyjoews, paigniots epitiméseds, “child play of correction’’), the reference being to the earlier and lighter plagues of Egypt; RV renders “by a mocking correction as of children,” “by a correction which was as children’s play,’ Gr (as above). He first tried them by those lighter inflictions before sending on them the heavier. In later usage ‘dally’’ implies delay. DALMANUTHA, dal-ma-nii’tha. pan. Ci Mk 8 10; Mt 15 39. See DELaran. See Maaca- DALMATIA, dal-ma’shi-a (AoAparia, Dalmatia, “deceitful’): A district of the Rom empire lying on the eastern shore of the Adriatic. Writing from Rome to Timothy during his second imprisonment (in 66 or 67 AD, according to Ramsay’s chronology), Paul records the departure of Titus to Dalmatia (2 Tim 4 10). No mention is made of his special mission, and we cannot tell whether his object was to traverse regions hitherto unevangelized or to visit churches already formed. Nor can we deter- mine with certainty the meaning of the word Dal- matia as here used. Originally it denoted the land of the barbarous Dalmatae or Delmatae, a warlike Illyrian tribe subjugated by the Romans after a long and stubborn resistance; it was then applied to the southern portion of the Rom _ province of Illyricum, lying between the river Titius (mod. Kerka) and the Macedonian frontier; later the name was extended to the entire province. On the whole it seems most probable that the apostle uses it in this last sense. Sce further s.v. ILLYRICUM. Marcus N. Top Dalphon Damascus THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 778 DALPHON, dal’fon (71D2%, dalphon, “crafty”): The second of the ten sons of Haman, slain by the Jews (Est 9 7). DAM (88, ’ém, ordinary Heb word for “‘mother’’): Heb law prohibited the destruction of the ‘‘dam” and the young of birds at the same time, command- ing that uf the young be taken from a nest the dam be allowed to escape (Dt 22 6.7). In the same spirit it enjoined the taking of an animal for slaughter before it had heen seven days with its ‘‘dam” (Ex 22 30; Lev 22 27; cf Ex 23 19). DAMAGE, dam’aj (ND20), hdbhala’): This word expresses any inflicted loss of value or permanent injury to persons or things. ‘‘Why should damage grow to the hurt of the kings?” (Ezr 4 22). In Prov 26 6 “damage” means “wrong,” “injury” (Heb 0°, hamas). The trof Est 7 4 is doubtful: “Although the adversary could not have compen- sated for the king’s damage” (RVm ‘For our afflic- tion is not to be compared with the king’s damage’”’; AV “could not countervail the king’s damage”); .but Heb pip, nézek (Est 7 4) and Aram. ‘Ors: nGzik (Dnl 6 2) have the meaning of ‘‘molestation” or “annoyance” (see Ges.-Buhl Dict. [15th ed] 489, 806, 908). We therefore ought to read ‘for that oppression would not have been worthy of the mo- lestation of the king’ (Est 7 4) and ‘that the king should have no molestation’ (Dnl 6 2). The Gr fnula, zémia, “loss” and tnutdw, 2émidd, “to cause loss’; RV therefore translates Acts 27 10 “will be with injury and much loss” (AV “‘damage”’), and 2 Cor7 9 “that ye might suffer loss by us in nothing” (AV “damage’’). A. L. Bresticu DAMARIS, dam/a-ris (Adpapis, Démaris, pos- sibly a corruption of Sdpoadts, ddmalis, ‘a heifer’’): The name of a female Christian of Athens, converted by Paul’s preaching (Acts 17 34). The fact that she is mentioned in this passage together with Dio- nysius the Areopagite has led some, most probably in error, to regard her as his wife. The singling out of her name with that of Dionysius may indicate some personal or social distinction. Cf Acts 17 12. DAMASCENES, dam-a-sénz’, dam’a-sénz (rhv wodvy Aapacknvay, én pélin Damaskénon, “the city of the Damascenes’’): The inhabitants of Damascus oe Aretas the Arabian are so called (2 Cor 11 32). DAMASCUS, da-mas’kus: Name Situation and Natural Features The City Itself Its History (1) The Early Period (to cir 950 BC) (2) The Aramaean Kingdom (cir 950-732 BC) (3) The Middle Period (732 BC-650 AD) (4) Under Islam The Eng. name is the same. as the Gr Aauackés, Damaskés. The Heb nameis PUET, Dammesek, but the Aram. form PWN 71, Darmesek, oc- curs in 1 Ch 18 5; 2 Ch 28 5. The name appears in Egyp inscriptions as Ti-mas-ku (16th cent. BC), and Sa-ra-mas-ki (13th cent. BC), which W. M. Miiller, Asten u. Europa, 227, regards as representing Ti-ra-mas-ki, conclud- ing from the ‘‘ra’’ in this form that Damascus had by that time passed under Aram. influence. In the Am Tab the forms Ti-ma-ai-gi and Di-mas-ka occur. The Arab. name is Dimashk esh-Sham (‘‘Damascus of Syria’) usually contrasted to Esh-Sham simply. The meaning of the name Damascus is unknown. Esh-Sham (Syria) means ‘‘the left,”’ in contrast to the Yemen (Arabia) =‘‘the right.” BONE 1. Name Damascus is situated (33° 30’ N. lat., 36° 18’ E. long.) in the N.W. corner of the Ghuta, a fertile plain about 2,300 ft. above sea level, 2. Situation W. of Mt. Hermon. The part of and Natural the Ghuta E. of the city is called el- Features _Merj, the “‘meadow-land” of Damascus. The river Barada (see ABANA) flows through Damascus and waters the plain, through which the Nahr el-Awaj (see PHarPar) also flows, a few miles S. of the city. Surrounded on three sides by bare hills, and bordered on the E., its open side, by the desert, its well-watered and fertile Ghuta, with its streams and fountains, its fields and orchards, makes a vivid impression on the Arab of the desert. Arab. lit. is rich in praises of Damas- cus, which is described as an earthly paradise. The European or American traveler is apt to feel that these praises are exaggerated, and it is perhaps only in early summer that the beauty of the in- numerable fruit trees—apricots, pomegranates, wal- nuts and many others—justifies enthusiasm. To see Damascus as the Arab sees it, we must approach it, as he does, from the desert. The Barada (Abana) is the life blood of Damascus. Confined in a narrow gorge until close to the city, where it spreads itself in many channels over the plain, only to lose itself a few miles away in the marshes that fringe the desert, its whole strength is expended in making a small area between the hills and the desert really fertile. That is why a city on this site is inevitable and permanent. Damascus, almost defenceless from a military point of view, is the natural mart and factory of inland Syria. In the course of its long history it has more than once enjoyed and lost political supremacy, but in all the vicissitudes of political fortune it has remained the natural harbor of the Syrian desert. Damascus lies along the main stream of the Bara- da, almost entirely on its south bank. The city is about a mile long (E. to W.) and about 3. The City half a mile broad (N. to S.). On the Itself south side a long suburb, consisting for the most part of a single street, called the Meidan, stretches for a mile beyond the line of the city wall, terminating at the Bawwabet Allah, the ‘‘Gate of God,” the starting-point of the Haj, the annual pilgrimage to Mecca. The city has thus roughly the shape of a broad-headed spoon, of which the Meidan is the handle. In the Gr period, a long, colonnaded street ran through the city, doubtless the “street which is called Straight” (Acts 9 11). This street, along the course of which remains of columns have been discovered, runs westward from the Babesh-Sherki, the ‘East Gate.” Part of it is still called Derb el-Mustakim (“Straight Street”), but it is not certain that it has borne the name through all the intervening cents. It runs between the Jewish and Christian quarters (on the left and right, respectively, going west), and ter- minates in the Suk el-Midhatiyeh. a bazaar built by Midhat Pasha, on the north of which is the main Moslem quarter, in which are the citadel and the Great Mosque. The houses are flat-roofed, and are usually built round a courtyard, in which is a foun- tain. The streets, with the exception of Straight Street, are mostly narrow and tortuous, but on the west side of the city there are some good covered bazaars. Damascus is not rich in antiquities. The Omayyad Mosque, or Great Mosque, replaced a Christian church, which in its time had taken the place of a pagan temple. The site was doubtless occupied from time immemorial by the chief reli- ious edifice of the city. A small part of the ancient hristian church is still extant. Part of the city wall has been preserved, with a foundation going back to Rom times, surmounted by Arab work. The traditional site of Paul’s escape (Acts 9 25; 779 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Daiphon Damascus 2 Cor 11 33) and of the House of Naaman (2 K 5) are pointed out to the traveler, but the traditions are valueless. The charm of Damascus lies in the life of the bazaars, in the variety of types which may be seen there—the Druse, the Kurd, the Bedouin and many others—and in its historical associations. It has always been a manufacturing city. Our word “damask” bears witness to the fame of its textile industry, and the ‘“Damascus blades” of the Crusading period were equally famous; and though Timur (Tamerlane) destroyed the trade in arms in 1899 by carrying away the armorers to Samarcand, Damascus is still a city of busy craftsmen in cloth and wood. Its antiquity casts a spell of romance upon it. After a traceable history of thirty-five cents. it is still a populous and flourishing city, and, in spite of the advent of the railway and even the electric street car, it still preserves the flavor of the East. : kingdom in Damascus. Rezon, son-of Eliada, an officer in the army of Hadadezer, king of Zobah, escaped in the hour of defeat, and became a captain of banditti. Later he established himself in Da- mascus, and became its king (1 K 11 23 ff). He cherished a not unnatural animosity against Israel, and the rise of a powerful and hostile kingdom in the Israelitish frontier was a constant source of anxiety to Solomon (1 K 11 25). (2) The Aramaean kingdom (cir 960-732 BC).— Whether Rezon was himself the founder of a dy- nasty is not clear. He has been identified with Hezion, father of Tab-rimmon, and grandfather of Ben-hadad (1 K 15 18), but the identification, though a natural one, is insecure. Ben-hadad (Bir- idri) is the first king of Damascus, after Rezon, of whom we have any detailed knowledge. The disruption of the Heb kingdom afforded the Ara- maeans an opportunity of playing off the rival Heb Azsana River. (1) The early period (to cir 950 BC).—The origin of Damascus is unknown. Mention has already been made (§1) of the references to the 4, Its city in Egyp inscriptions andin the Am History Tab. It appears once —possibly twice —in the history of Abraham. In Gen 14 15 we read that Abraham pursued the four kings as far as Hobah, ‘‘which is on the left hand [i.e. the north) of Damascus.” But this is simply a geo- graphical note which shows only that Damascus was well known at the time when Gen 14 was written. Greater interest attaches to Gen 15 2 where Abraham complains that he is childless and that his heir is ‘““‘Dammesek Eliezer’ (ERV), for which the Syr version reads “Eliezer the Damaschul.” The clause, however, is hopelessly obscure, and it is doubtful whether it contains any reference to Da- mascusatall. Inthe time of David Damascus was an Aramaean city, which assisted the neighboring Aramaean states in their unsuccessful wars against David (2S 8 5f). These campaigns resulted in- directly in the establishment of a powerful Aramaean states against each other, and of bestowing their favors now on one, and now on the other. Ben- hadad was induced by Asa of Judah to accept a large bribe, or tribute, from the Temple treasures, and relieve Asa by attacking the Northern Kingdom . (1 K 16 18 ff). Some years later (cir 880 BC) Ben-hadad (or his successor?) defeated Omri of Israel, annexed several Israelitish cities, and secured the right of having Syrian ‘‘streets” (i.e. probably a bazaar for Syrian merchants) in Samaria (1 K 20 34). Ben-hadad II (according to Winckler the two Ben-hadads are really identical, but this view, though just possible chronologically, conflicts with 1 K 20 34) was the great antagonist of Ahab. His campaigns against Israel are narrated in 1 IX 20 22. At first successful, he was subsequently twice de- feated by Ahab, and after the rout at Aphek was at the mercy of the conqueror, who treated him with generous leniency, claiming only the restora- tion of the lost Israelitish towns, and the right of establishing an Israclitish bazaar in Damascus. On the renewal of hostilities three years later Ahab Damascus Dan THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 780 fell before Ramoth-gilead, and his death relieved Ben-hadad of the only neighboring monarch who could ever challenge the superiority of Damascus. Further light is thrown upon the history of Damas- cus at this time by the Assyrian inscriptions. In 854 BC the Assyrians defeated a coalition of Syrian and Palestine states (including Israel) under the leadership of Ben-hadad at Karkar. In 849 and 846 BC renewed attacks were made upon Damascus by the Assyrians, who, however, did not effect any considerable conquest. From this date until the fall of the city in 732 BC the power of the Aramaean kingdom depended upon the activity or quiescence of Assyria. Hazacl, who murdered Ben-hadad and usurped his throne cir 844 BC, was attacked in 842 and 839, but during the next thirty years Assyria made no further advance westward. Hazael was able to devote all his energies to his western neighbors, and Israel suffered severely at his hands. In 803 Mari’ of Damascus, who is probably identical with the Ben-hadad of 2 K 13 3, Hazael’s son, was made tributary to Ramman-nirari III of Assyria. This blow weakened Aram, and afforded Jeroboam II of Israel an opportunity of avenging the defeats inflicted upon his country by Hazael. In 773 Assyria again invaded the territory of Damascus. Tiglath-pileser III (745-727 BC) pushed vigorously westward, and in 738 Rezin of Damascus paid trib- ute. A year or two later he revolted, and attempted in concert with Pekah of Israel, to coerce Judah into joining an anti-Assyrian league (2 K 15 37; 16 5; Isa 7). His punishment was swift and de- cisive. In 734 the Assyrians advanced and laid siege to Damascus, which fell in 732. Rezin was executed, his kingdom was overthrown, and the city suffered the fate which a few years later befell Samaria. (4) The middle period (cir 782 BC-650 AD).— Damascus had now lost its political importance, and for more than two cents. we have only one or two inconsiderable references to it. It is men- tioned in an inscription of Sargon (722-705 BC) as having taken part in an unsuccessful insurrecti-n along with Hamath and Arpad. There are inci- dental references to it in Jer 49 23 ff and Ezk 27 18; 47 16 ff. In the Pers period Damascus, if not politically of great, importance, was a prosperous city. The overthrow of the Pers empire by Alex- ander was soon followed (301 BC) by the estab- lishment of the Seleucid kingdom of Syria, with Antioch as its capital, and Damascus lost its posi- tion as the chief city of Syria. The center of gravity was moved toward the sea, and the maritime com- merce of the Levant became more important than the trade of Damascus with the interior. In 111 BC the Syrian kingdom was divided, and Antiochus Cyzicenus became king of Coele-Syria, with Da- mascus as his capital. His successors, Demetrius Eucaerus and Antiochus Dionysus, had troubled careers, being involved in domestic conflicts and in wars with the Parthians, with Alexander Jan- naeus of Judaea, and with Aretas the Nabataean, who obtained possession of Damascus in 85 BC. Tigranes, being of Armenia, held Syria for some years after this date, but was defeated by the Romans, and in 64 BC Pompcy finally annexed the country. The position of Damascus during the first cent. and a half of Rom rule in Syria is obscure. For a time it was in Rom hands, and from 31 BC- 33 AD its coins bear the names of Augustus or Ti- berius. Subsequently it was again in the hands of the Nabataeans, and was ruled by an ethnarch, or governor, appointed by Aretas, the Nabataean king. This cthnarch adopted a hostile attitude to Paul (2 Cor 11 32f). Later, in the time of Nero, it again became a Rom city. in the early history of Christianity Damascus, as compared with Antioch, played a very minor part. But it is memorable in Christian history on account of its associations with Paul’s conversion, and as the scene of his earliest Christian preaching (Acts 9 1-25). All the NT ref- erences to the city relate to this event (Acts 9 1- 25; 22 5-11; 26 12.20; 2 Cor 11 32f; Gal 1 17). a ts Traditional House of Ananias. Afterward, under the early Byzantine emperor, Damascus, though important as an outpost of civili- zation on the edge of the desert, continued to be second to Antioch both politically and ecclesiasti- cally. It was not until the Arabian conquest (634 AD when it passed out of Christian hands, and re- verted to the desert, that it once more became a true capital. _(4) Under Islam.~—Damascus has now been a Moslem city, or rather a city under Moslem rule, for nearly thir- teen centuries. For about a cent. after 650 AD it was the seat of the Omayyad caliphs, and enjoyed a position of preéminence in the Moslem world. Later it was sup- planted by Bagdad, and in the 10th cent. it came under the rule of the Fatimites of Egypt. Toward the close of the 11th cent. the Seljuk Turks entered Syria and cap- tured Damascus. In the period of the Crusades the city, thongh never of decisive importance, played a con- siderable part, and was for a time the headquarters of Saladin. In 13800 it was plundered by the Tartars, and in 1399 Timur exacted an enormous ransom from it, and carried off its famous armorers, thus robbing it of one of its most important industries. Finally, in 1516 AD, the Osmanli Turks under Sultan Selim con- quered Syria, and Damascus became, and still is, the capital of a province of the Ottoman Empire. C. H. Taomson DAMMESEK ELIEZER (Gen 15 2 ERV). See Eximzur (1). DAMN, dam, DAMNATION, dam-na’shun, DAMNABLE, dam’na-b’l: These words have under- gone a change of meaning since the AV was made. They are derived from Lat damnare=‘‘to inflict a loss,” “to condemn,’”’ and that was their original meaning in Eng. Now they denote exclusively the idea of everlasting punishment in hell. It is often difficult to determine which meaning was intended by the translatorsin AV. They have been excluded altogether from RV. The words for which they stand in AV are: (1) arddea, apdleia, “destruction,” tr? “damna- ble” and ‘‘damnation” only in 2 Pet 21 3 (RV “destructive,” “destruction”’). False prophets taught doctrines calculated to destroy others, and themselves incurred the sentence of destruction such as overtook the fallen angels, the world in the Deluge, and the cities of the Plain. Apéleia occurs otherwise 16 times in the NT, and is always tr? in AV and RV by either “perdition” or “destruction”’: twice of waste of treasure (Mt 26 8=Mk 14 4); twice of the beast that comes out of the abyss and gocs into perdition (Rev 17 8.11). In all other cases, it refers to men, and defines the destiny that befalls them as the result of sin: Judas is the “son of perdition” (Jn 17 12). Peter consigns Simon Magus and his money to perdition (Acts 8 20). 781 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Damascus D Some men are ‘‘vessels of wrath fitted unto de- struction” (Rom 9 22), and others, their “end is perdition”’ (Phil 3 19). It is the antithesis of sal- vation (He 10 39; Phil 1 28). Of the two ways of life, one leads to destruction (Mt 7 13). Whether it is utter, final and irretrievable destruction is not stated. (2) xplvw, krind, tr4 “damned” only in AV of 2 Thess 2 12 (RV “‘judged”’) means “to judge” in the widest sense, ‘‘to form an opinion” (Lk 7 43), and forensically “‘to test and try” an accused person. It can only acquire the sense of ‘judging guilty’ or “condemning”’ from the context. (83) xaraxpivw, katakriné, tr4 “damned” only in AV of Mk 16 16; Rom 14 23 (“condemned” in RV), means properly “to give judgment against” or “to condemn” and is so tr? 17 t in AV and always in RV. (4) xplows, krisis, tr? “damnation” in AV of Mt 23 33; Mk 3 29; Jn 5 29 (RV “judgment,” but in Mk 3 29, “sin” for dudprnua, hamartéma), means (a) judgment in general like krind, and is so used about 17 t, besides 14 ¢ in the phrase “day of judgment”’; (b) ‘condemnation,’ like katakrina, about 14 ¢. (5) «plua, krima, tr’in AV “damnation” 7 t (Mt 23 14=Mk 12 40=Lk 20 47; Rom 3 8; 13 2; 1 Cor 11 29; 1 Tim 5 12), “condemnation” 6t, “judg- ment” 13 t, ‘law’ and “avenged” once each; in RV “condemnation” 9 t (Mt 23 14 only inserted in m), “judgment” 17 +, and once in m, “lawsuit” and “sentence” once each. “Judgment”? may be neutral, an impartial act of the judge weighing the evidence (so in Mt 7 2; Acts 24 25; Rom 11 33; He 6 2; 1 Pet 417; Rev 20 4) and “lawsuit” (1 Cor 6 7); or it may be inferred from the context that judgment is unto condemnation (soin Rom 2 2.3; 5 16; Gal 6 10; 2 Pet 23; Rev 17 1; 18 20, and RV Rom 13 2; 1 Cor 11 29). In places where krima and krisis are rightly tr’ “condem- nation,” and where “judgment” regarded as an ac- complished fact involves a sentence of guilt, they together with katakrind define the relation of a per- son to the supreme authority, as that of a criminal, found and held guilty, and liable to punishment. So the Rom empire regarded Jesus Christ, and the thief on the cross (Lk 23 40; 24 20). But gener- ally these words refer to man as a sinner against God, judged guilty by Him, and liable to the just penalty of sin. They imply nothing further as to the nature of the penalty or the state of man under- going it, nor as to its duration. Nor does the word “eternal” (adv, aldvos, aidn, aidnios, often wrongly tr4 “everlasting” in AV) when added to them, deter- mine the question of duration. Condemnation is an act in the moral universe, which cannot be deter- mined under categories of time. ; These terms define the action of God in relation to man’s conduct, as that of the Supreme Judge, but they express only one aspect of that relation which is only fully conceived, when coérdinated with the more fundamental idea of God’s Fatherhood. See EscuaToLocy; JUDGMENT. LireraturRE.—Salmond, Christian Doctrine of Immor- tality; Charles, Eschatology. T. Rees DAMSEL, dam’zel: A young, unmarried woman; a girl (lass); maiden (cf Fr. demoiselle). RV in Mt 26 69; Jn 18 17; Acts 12 13; 16 16 gives “maid” for madloxyn, paidiské, “a girl,” ie. (spec.) a maid- servant or young female slave (AV ‘“damsel’’), and “child” for madlor, paidton, “a half-grown boy or girl,” in Mk 6 39.40 dis.41. DAN (74, dan, “judge”; Adv, Dan): The fifth of Jacob’s sons, the first borne to him by Bilhah, the maid of Rachel, to whom, as the child of her slave, he legally belonged. At his birth Rachel, whose barrenness had been a sore trial to her, exclaimed “‘God hath judgedme.... and hath given me ason,” so she called his name Dan, i.e. “judge” (Gen 30 6). He was full brother of Naphtali. In Jacob’s Blessing there is an echo of Rachel’s words, ‘‘Dan shall judge ‘his people’ (Gen 49 16). Of the pa- triarch Dan almost nothing is recorded. Of his sons at the settlement in Egypt only one, Hushim, is mentioned (Gen 46 23). The name in Nu 26 42 is Shuham. The tribe however stands second in point of numbers on leaving Egypt, furnishing 62,700 men of war (Nu 1 39); and 2. The at the second census they were 64,400 Tribe strong (26 43). The standard of the camp of Dan in the desert march, with which were Asher and Naphtali, was on the north side of the tabernacle (Nu 2 25; 10 25; cf Josh 6 9 AVm “gathering host’). The prince of the tribe was Ahiezer (Nu 1 12). Among the spies Dan was represented hy Ammiel the son of Gemalli (13 12). Of the tribe of Dan was Oholiab (AV “Aholiab’’) one of the wise-hearted artificers en- gaged in the construction of the tabernacle (Ex 31 6). One who was stoned for blasphemy was the son of a Danite woman (Lev 24 10f). At the ceremony of blessing and cursing, Dan and Naphtali stood on Mount Ebal, while the other Rachel tribes were on Gerizim (Dt 27 13). The prince of Dan at the division of the land was Bukki the son of Jogli (Nu 34 22). The portion assigned to Dan adjoined those of Ephraim, Benjamin and Judah, and lay on the west- ern slopes of the mountain. The 3. Territory reference in Jgs 5 17: “And Dan, why did he remain in ships?” seems to mean that on the W. Dan had reached the sea. But the passage is one of difficulty. We are told that the Amorites forced the children of Dan into the mountain (Jgs 1 34), so they did not enjoy the richest part of their ideal portion, the fertile plain between the mountain and thesea. The strong hand of the house of Joseph kept the Amorites tributary, but did not drive them out. Later we find Dan oppressed hy the Philis, against whom the heroic exploits of Samson were performed (Jgs 14 ff). The expedition of the Danites recorded in Jgs 18 is referred to in Josh 19 47 ff. The 4. The story affords a priceless glimpse of the Danite Raid conditions prevailing in those days. Desiring an extension of territory, the Danites sent out spies, who recommended an attack upon Laish, a city at the north end of the Jordan valley. The people, possibly a colony from Sidon, were careless in their fancied security. The land was large, and there was “no want of anything that was in theearth.” The expedition of the 600, their dealings with Micah and his priest, their capture of Laish, and their founding of an idol shrine with priestly attendant, illustrate the strange mingling of lawlessness and superstition which was charac- teristic of the time. The town rebuilt on the site of Laish they called Dan—see following art. Per- haps 2 Ch 2 14 may be taken to indicate that the Danites intermarried with the Phoenicians. Di- vided between its ancient seat in the S. and the new territory in the N. the tribe retained its place in Israel for a time (1 Ch 12 35; 27 22), but it played no part of importance in the subsequent history. The name disappears from the genealogical lists of Ch; and it is not mentioned among the tribes in Rev 7 5 ff. Samson was the one great man produced by Dan, and he seems to have embodied the leading charac- teristics of the tribe: unsteady, unscrupulous, vio- lent, possessed of a certain grim humor; stealthy 1. Name Dan Daniel, Bk of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 782. in tactics—‘“a serpent in the way, an adder in the path” (Gen 49 17)—but swift and strong in strik- ing—‘‘a lion’s whelp, that leapeth forth from Ba- shan” (Dt 33 22). Along with Abel, Dan ranked as a city in which the true customs of old Israel were preserved (2 S 20 18 LXX). W. Ewina DAN: A city familiar as marking the northern limit of the land of Israel in the common phrase ‘from Dan even to Beer-sheba”’ (Jgs 20 1; 18 3 20, etc). Its ancient name was Laish or Leshem (Jgs 18 7, etc). It was probably an outlying set- tlement of Tyre or Sidon. Its inhabitants, pursu- ing the ends of peaceful traders, were defenceless against the onset of the Danite raiders. Having captured the city the Danites gave it the name of their own tribal ancestor (Jgs 18). It lay in the valley near Beth-rehob (ver 28). Jos places it near Mt. Lebanon and the fountain of the lesser Jor- dan, a day’s journey from Sidon (Ant, V, iii, 1; VIII, viii, 4; BJ, IV, i, 1). Onem says it lay 4 Rom miles from Paneas on the way to Tyre, at the source of the Jordan. This points decisively to Tell el-Kady, in the plain W. of Banias. The mound of this name—K dy is the exact Arab. equivalent of the Heb Dan—rises from among the bushes and reeds to a height varying from 40 to 80 ft. The largest of all the springs of the Jordan rises on the west side. The waters join with those of a smaller spring on the other side to form Nahr el-Leddén which flows southward to meet the streams from Banias and Hasbetyeh. The mound, which is the crater of an extinct volcano, has certain ancient remains on the south side, while the tomb of Sheikh Marzuk is sheltered by two holy trees. The sanc- tuary and ritual established by the Danites per- sisted as long as the house of God was in Shiloh, and the priesthood in this idolatrous shrine remained in the family of Jonathan till the conquest of Tig- lath-pileser (Jgs 18 30; 2 K 16 29). Here Jero- boam I set up the golden calf. The ancient sanctity of the place would tend to promote the success of his scheme (1 K 12 28f, etc). The calf, according to a Jewish tradition, was taken away by Tiglath- pileser. Dan fell before Benhadad, king of Syria (1 K 15 20; 2 Ch 164). It was regained by Jeroboam Ii (2 K 14 25). It shared the country’s fate at the hands of Tiglath-pileser (2 K 15 29). It was to this district that Abraham pursued the army of Chedorlaomer (Gen 14 14). For Dr. G. A. Smith’s suggestion that Dan may have been at Banids see HGHL', 473, 480 f. W. Ewine DAN (Ezk 27 19 AV). See Vepan. DANCING, dan’sing. See Games. DANDLE, dan‘d’| (9WYW, sha‘dsha‘, a Pulpal form, from root JV, shd‘a‘, with sense of to “be caressed”). Occurs in Isa 66 12, “shall be dandled upon the knees.” DANGER, dan’jér: Danger does not express a state of reality but a possibility. In Mt 5 21f, however, and also AV Mk 3 29 (RV “but is guilty of an eternal sin’’) the expression “danger” refers to a certainty, for the danger spoken of is in one case judgment which one brings upon himself, and in the other the committing of an unpardonable sin. Both are the necessary consequences of a man’s conduct. The reason for translating the Gr %voxos, énochos (lit. “to be held in anything so one cannot escape”) by “is in danger,” instead of “guilty” or “liable,” may be due to the translat- or’s conception of these passages as a warning against such an act rather than as a statement of the judgment which stands pronounced over every man who commits the sin. A. L. Brustica DANIEL, dan’yel (ON*2J, dantyé’l, 287, dani’ él, “God is my judge”; Aaw#d, Daniél): (1) One of the sons of David (1 Ch 3 1). (2) A Levite of the family of Ithamar (Ear 8 2; Neh 10 6). (3) A prophet of the time of Nebuchadnezzar and Cyrus, the hero and author of the Book of Dal. We know nothing of the early life of Daniel, except what is recorded in the book bearing his name. Here it is said that he was one of the youths of royal or noble seed, who were carried captive by Nebuchadnezzar in the third year of Jehoiakim, king of Judah. These youths were without blem- ish, well-favored, skilful in all wisdom, endued with knowledge, and understanding science, and such as had ability to stand in the king’s palace. The king commanded to teach them the knowledge and tongue of the Chaldaeans; and appointed for them a daily portion of the king’s food and of the wine which be drank. After having been thus nourished for three years, they were to stand before the king. Ashpenaz, the master or chief of the eunuchs, into whose hands they had been intrusted, following a custom of the time, gave to each of these youths a new and Bab name. To Daniel, he gave the name Belteshazzar. In Bab this name was probably Belu-lita-sharri-usur, which means “O Bel, protect thou the hostage of the king,”’ a most appropriate name for one in the place which Daniel occupied as a hostage of Jehoiakim at the court of the king of Babylon. The youths were probably from 12 to 15 years of age at the time when they were carried captive. (For changes of names, cf Joseph changed to Zaphenath-paneah [Gen 41 45]; Elakim, to Jehoiakim [2 K 23 34]; Mattaniah, to Zedekiah (2 K 24 17]; and the two names of the high priest Johanan’s brother in the Sachau Papyri, i.e. Ostan and Anani.) Having purposed in his heart that he would not defile himself with the food and drink of the king, Daniel requested of Ashpenaz permission to eat vegetables and drink water. Through the favor of God, this request was granted, notwithstanding the fear of Ashpenaz that his head would be endangered to the king on account of the probably resulting oor appearance of the youths living upon this Blood duuane diet, in comparison with the expected healthy appearance of the others of their class. However, ten days’ trial having been first granted, and at the end of that time their countenances having been found fairer and their flesh fatter than the other youths’, the permission was made perma- nent; and God gave to Daniel and his companions knowledge and skill in all learning and wisdom, and to Daniel understanding in all visions and dreams; so that at the end of the three years when the king communed with them, he found them much superior to all the magicians and enchanters in every matter of wisdom and understanding. Daniel’s public activities were in harmony with his education. His first appearance was as an in- terpreter of the dream recorded in 2. Dream- Dnl 2. Nebuchadnezzar having seen Interpreter in his dream a vision of a great image, excellent in brightness and terrible in appearance, its head of fine gold, its breast and its arms of silver, its belly and its thighs of brass, its legs of iron, its feet part of iron and part of clay, beheld a stone cut out without hands smiting the image and breaking it in pieces, until it became like chaff and was carried away by the wind; while the stone that smote the image became a great mountain and filled the whole earth. When the king awoke from his troubled sleep, he forgot, or feigned that he had forgotten, the dream, and summoned the wise men of Babylon both to tell him the dream and 1. Early Life 1 Se ee SOURCES OF THE JORDAN AT DAN 783 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dan Daniel, Bk of to give the interpretation thereof. The wise men having said that they could not tell the dream, nor interpret it as long as it was untold, the king threat- ened them with death. Daniel, who seems not to have been present when the other wise men were before the king, when he was informed of the threat of the king, and that preparations were being made to slay all of the wise men of Babylon, himself and his three companions included, boldly went in to the king and requested that he would appoint a time for him to appear to show the interpretation. Then he went to his house, and he and his companions prayed, and the dream and its interpretation were made known unto Daniel. At the appointed time, the dream was explained and the four Hebrews were loaded with wealth and given high positions in the service of the king. In the 4th chapter, we have recorded Daniel’s interpretation of the dream of Nebuchadnezzar about the great tree that was hewn at the command of an angel, thus prefiguring the insanity of the king. Daniel’s third great appearance in the book is in ch 5, where he is called upon to explain the extraordinary writing upon the wall 3. Inter- of Belshazzar’s palace, which foretold preter of the end of the Bab empire and the in- Signs coming of the Medes and Persians. For this service Daniel was clothed with purple, a chain of gold put around his neck, and he was made the third ruler in the kingdom. Daniel, however, was not merely an interpreter of other men’s visions. In the last six chapters we have recorded four or five of his own’ 4. Seer of Visions visions, all of which are taken up with revelations concerning the future his- tory of the great world empires, esp. in their relation to the people of God, and predic- tions of the final triumph of the Messiah’s kingdom. In addition to his duties as seer and as inter- preter of signs and dreams, Daniel also stood high in the governmental service of Nebu- §. Official chadnezzar, Belshazzar, and Darius of the . the Mede, and panes also of Cyrus. Kings The Book of Dnl, our only reliable source of information on this subject, does not tell us much about his civil duties and per- formances. It does say, however, that he was chief of the wise men, that he was in the gate of the king, and that he was governor over the whole province of Babylon under Nebuchadnezzar; that Belshaz- zar made him the third ruler in his kingdom; and that Darius made him one of the three presidents to whom his hundred and twenty satraps were to give account; and that he even thought to set him over his whole kingdom. In all of these positions he geems to have conducted himself with faithfulness and judgment. While in the service of Darius the Mede, he aroused the antipathy of the other presi- dents and of the satraps. Unable to find any fault with his official acts, they induced the king to make a decree, apparently general in form and purpose, but really aimed at Daniel alone. They saw that they could find no valid accusation against him, unless they found it in connection with something concerning the law of his God. They therefore caused the king to make a decree that no one should make a request of anyone for the space of thirty days, save of the king. Daniel, having publicly prayed three times a day as he was in the habit of doing, was caught in the act, accused, and on account of the irrevocability of a law of the Medes and Persians, was condenined in accordance with the decree to be cast into a den of lions. The king was much troubled at this, but was unable to with- hold the punishment. However, he expressed to Daniel his belief that his God in whom he trusted continually would deliver him; and so indeed it | came to pass. For in the morning, when the king drew near to the mouth of the den, and called to him, Daniel said that God had sent His angel and shut the mouths of the lions. So Daniel was taken up unharmed, and at the command of the king his accusers, having been cast into the den, were de- stroyed before they reached the bottom. Literature.—Besides the commentaries and other works mentioned in the art. on the Book of Dni, valuable information may be found in Jos and in Payne Smith's Lectures on Daniel. R. Dick Wiitson DANIEL, dan’yel, BOOK OF: I. Name II. Puiace in tae Canon III. Divisions or tae Boox IV. Lanevaces V. Purpose or tHe Boor VI. Unity VII. GenvuiNeNnEss 1. The Predictions 2. The Miracles 3. The Text 4, The Language 5. The Historical Statements VIII. INTERPRETATION IX. Docrnrines Literature . ApocrRyPHAL ADDITIONS LireRatTurRe I. Name.—The Book of Dn is rightly so called, whether we consider Daniel as the author of it, or as the principal person mentioned in it. I. Place in the Canon.—In the Eng. Bible, Dn! is placed among the Major Prophets, immediately after Ezk, thus following the order of the Sept and of the Lat Vulg. In the Heb Bible, however, it is placed in the third division of the Canon, called the Kethuvim or writings, by the Hebrews, and the hagiographa, or holy writings, by the Seventy. It has been claimed, that Dnl was placed by the Jews in the third part of the Canon, either because they thought the inspiration of its author to be of a lower kind than was that of the other prophets, or because the book was written after the second or prophetical part of the Canon had been closed. Tt is more probable, that the book was placed in this part of the Heb Canon, because Daniel is not called a nabhi’ (“prophet”), but was rather a hézeh (“‘seer’’) and a haékham (‘wise man’). None but the works of the n°bhi’im were put in the second part of the Jewish Canon, the third being reserved for the heterogeneous works of seers, wise men, and priests, or for those that do not mention the name or work of a prophet, or that are poetical in form. A con- fusion has arisen, because the Gr word prophet is used to render the two Heb words nabhi’ and hézeh. In the Scriptures, God is said to speak to the former, whereas the latter see visions and dream dreams. Some have attempted to explain the position of Daniel by assuming that he had the prophetic gift without holding the prophetic office. It must be kept in mind that all reasons given to account for the order and place of many of the books in the Canon are purely conjectural, since we have no historical evidence bearing upon the subject earlier than the time of Jesus ben Sirach, who wrote prob- ably about 180 BC. HI. Divisions af the Book.—According to its sub- ject-matter, the book falls naturally into two great divisions, each consisting of six chapters, the first portion containing the historical sections, and the second the apocalyptic, or predictive, portions; though the former is not devoid of predictions, nor the latter of historical statements. More specifi- cally, the first chapter is introductory to the whole book; chs 2-6 describe some marvelous events in the history of Daniel and his three companions in their relations with the rulers of Babylon; and chs 7-12 narrate some visions of Daniel concerning the peat ord Dra esp. in relation to the kingdom of God. Daniel, Bk of THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 784 According to the languages in which the book is written, it may be divided into the Aram. portion, extending from 2 4b to the end of ch 7, and a Heb portion embracing the rest of the book. IV. Languages.—The language of the book is partly Heb and partly a dialect of Aram., which has been called Chaldee, or Bib. Aram. This Aram. is almost exactly the same as that which is found in portions of Ezr. On account of the large number of Bah and Pers words characteristic of this Aram. and of that of the papyri recently found in Egypt, as well as on account of the general similarity of the nominal, verbal and other forms, and of the syn- tactical construction, the Aram. of this period might properly be called the Bab-Pers Aram. With the exception of the sign used to denote the sound dh, and of the use of koph in a few cases where Dnl has ‘ayin, the spelling in the papyri is the same in gen- eral as that in the Bib. books. Whether the change of spelling was made at a later time in the MSS of Dnl, or whether it was a peculiarity of the Bab Aram. as distinguished from the Egyp, or whether it was due to the unifying, scientific genius of Daniel him- self, we have no means at present todetermine. In view of the fact that the Elephantine Papyri fre- quently employ the d sign to express the dh sound, and that it is always employed in Ezr to express it; in view further of the fact that the 2 sign is found as late as the earliest Nabatean inscription, that of 70 BC (see Buting, 349: 1, 2, 4) to express the dh sound, it seems fatuous to insist on the ground of the writing of these two sounds in the Book of Dnl, that it cannot have heen written in the Pers period. As to the use of képh and ‘ayin for the Aram. sound which corresponds to the Heb cadhé when equiva- lent to an Arab. dad, any hasty conclusion is de- barred by the fact that the Aram. papyri of the 5th cent. BC. the MSS of the Sam Tg and the Man- daic MSS written from 600 to 900 AD all employ the two letters to express the one sound. The writing of ’dleph and hé without any proper dis- crimination occurs in the papyri as well as in Dnl. The only serious objection to the early date of Dnl upon the ground of its spelling is that which is based upon the use of a final n in the pronominal suffix of the second and third persons masc. pl. instead of the m of the Aram. papyri and of the Zakir and Sendschirli inscriptions. It is possihle that Dnl was influenced in this hy the correspond- ing forms of the Bab language. The Syr and Man- daic dialects of the Aram. agree with the Bab in the formation of the pronominal suffixes of the second and third persons masc. pl., as against the Heb, Arab., Minaean, Sabaean and Ethiopic. It is possible that the occurrence of m in some west Aram. documents may have arisen through the influence of the Heb and Phoen, and that pure Aram. always bad n just as we find it in Assyr and Bab, and in all east Aram. documents thus far discovered. The supposition that the use of y in Dnl as a pre- formative of the third person masculine of the im- perfect proves a Palestinian provenience has been shown to be untenable by the discovery that the earliest east Syr also used y. (See M. Pognon, In- scriptions sémitiques, premiére partie, 17.) This inscription is dated 73 AD. This proof that in the earlier stages of its history the east Aram. was in this respect the same as that found in Dnl is confirmed by the fact that the forms of the 3d person of the imperfect found in the proper names on the Aram. dockets of the Assyr inscriptions also have the preformative y. (See CJS, II, 47.) V. Purpose of the Book.—The book is not in- tended to give an account of the life of Daniel. It gives neither his lineage, nor his age, and recounts but a few of the events of his long career. Nor isit meant to give a record of the history of Israel during the exile, nor even of the captivity in Babylon. Its purpose is to show how by His providential guid- ance, His miraculous interventions, His foreknowl- edge and almighty power, the God of heaven controls and directs the forces of Nature and the history of nations, the lives of Heh captives and of the might- iest of the kings of the earth, for the accomplish- ment of His Divine and beneficent plans for His servants and people. VI. Unity.—The unity of the book was first denied by Spinoza, who suggested that the first part was taken from the chronological works of the Chal- daeans, hasing his supposition upon the difference of language hetween the former and latter parts. Newton followed Spinoza in suggesting two parts, but began his second division with ch 7, where the narrative passes over from the 3d to the Ist person. Kohler follows Newton, claiming, however, that the visions were written by the Daniel of the exile, but that the first 6 chapters were composed by a later writer who also redacted the whole work. Von Orelli holds that certain prophecies of Daniel were enlarged and interpolated by a Jew living in the time of Antiochus Epiphanes, in order to show his con- temporaries the bearing of the predictions of the book upon those times of oppression. Zéckler and Lange hold to the unity of the book in general; but the former thought that 11 5-45 is an interpola- tion; and the latter, that 10 1—11 44 and 12 5-18 have been inserted in the original work. Meinhold holds that the Aram. portions existed as early as the times of Alexander the Great—a view to which Strack also inclines. Eichhorn held that the book consisted of ten different original sections, which are bound together merely by the circumstance that they are all concerned with Daniel and his three friends. Finally, De Lagarde, believing that the fourth kingdom was the Rom, held that ch 7 was written about 69 AD. (For the best discussion of the controversies about the unity of Dnl, see Eich- horn, Hinleitung, §§ 612-19, and Buhl in RE, IV, 449-51.) VI. Genuineness.—With the exception of the neo-Platonist Porphyry, a Gr non-Christian phi- losopher of the 3d cent. AD, the genuineness of the Book of Dnl was denied by no one until the rise of the deistic movement in the 17th cent. The attacks upon the genuineness of the book have been based upon (1) the predictions, (2) the miracles, (3) the text, (4) the language, (5) the historical statements. The assailants of the genuineness of Dnl on the ground of the predictions found therein, may be divided into two classes—those who 1. The Pre- deny prediction in general, and those dictions who claim that the apocalyptic char- acter of the predictions of Dnl is a sufficient proof of their lack of genuineness. The first of these two classes includes properly those only who deny not merely Christianity, but theism; and the answering of them may safely be left to those who defend the doctrines of theism, and par- ticularly of revelation. The second class of as- sailants is, however, of a different character, since it consists of those who are sincere believers in Christianity and predictive prophecy. They claim, however, that certain characteristics of definiteness and detail, distinguishing the predictive portions of the Book of Dnl from other predictions of the OT, bring the genuineness of Dnl into question. The kind of prediction found here, ordinarily called apocalyptic, is said to have arisen first in the 2d cent. BC, when parts of the Book of En and of the Sibylline Oracles were written; and a main characteristic of an apocalypse is said to be that it records past eventsasif they were still future, throw- ing the speaker back into some distant past time, 785 for the purpose of producive on the reader the im- pression that the book contains real predictions, thus gaining credence for the statements of the writer and giving consolation to those who are thus led to believe in the providential foresight of God for those who trust in Him. Since those who believe that God has spoken unto man by His Son and through the prophets will not be able to set limits to the extent and definiteness of the revelations which He may have seen fit to make through them, nor to prescribe the method, style, time and character of the revelations, this attack on the genuineness of Dnl may safely be left to the defenders of the possibility and the fact of a revelation. One who believes in these may logically believe in the genuineness of Dnl, as far as this ob- jection goes. That there are spurious apocalypses no more proves that all are spurious than that there are spurious gospels or epistles proves that there are no genuineones. The spurious epp. of Philaris do not prove that Cicero’s Letters are not genuine; nor do the false statements of 2 Macc, nor the many spurious Acts of the Apostles, prove that 1 Macc or Luke’s Acts of the Apostles is not genuine. Nor does the fact that the oldest portions of the spurious apocalypses which have been preserved to our time are thought to have been written in the 2d cent. BC, prove that no apocalypses, either genuine or spurious, were written before that time. There must have been a beginning, a first apocalypse, at some time, if ever. Besides, if we admit that the earliest parts of the Book of En and of the Sibyl- line Oracles were written about the middle of the 2d cent. BC, whereas the Book of Esd was written about 300 AD, 450 years later, we can see no good literary reason why Dnl may not have antedated En by 350 years. The period between 500 BC and 150 BC is so almost entirely devoid of all known Heb literary productions as to render it exceedingly precarious for anyone to express an opinion as to what works may have characterized that long space of time. Secondly, as to the objections made against the Book of Dnl on the ground of the number or char- acter of the miracles recorded, we shall only say that they affect the whole Christian system, which is full of the miraculous from beginning toend. If we begin to reject the books of the Bible because miraculous events are recorded in them, where in- deed shall we stop? Thirdly, a more serious objection, as far as Dnl itself is concerned, is the claim of Eichhorn that the original text of the Aram. portion 3. The Text has been so thoroughly tampered with and changed, that we can no longer get at the genuine original composition. We our- selves can see no objection to the belief that these Aram. portions were written first of all in Heb, or even, if you will, in Bab; nor to the supposition that some Gr translators modified the meaning in their version either intentionally, or through a misunder- standing of the original. We claim, however, that the composite Aram. of Dnl agrees in almost every particular of orthography, etymology and syntax, with the Aram. of the North Sem inscriptions of the 9th, 8th and 7th cents. BC and of the Egyp papyri of the 5th cent. BC, and that the vocabulary of Dnl has an admixture of Heb, Bab and Pers words simi- lar to that of the papyri of the 5th cent. BC; where- as, it differs in composition from the Aram. of the Nabateans, which is devoid of Pers, Heb, and Bab words, and is full of Arabisms, and also from that of the Palmyrenes, which is full of Gr words, while hav- ing but one or two Pers words, and no Heb or Bab. ‘As to different recensions, we meet with a similar difficulty in Jeremiah without anyone’s impugning 2. The Miracles THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA _ Daniel, Bk of on that account the genuineness of the work as a whole. As to interpolations of verses or sections, they are found in the Sam recension of the Heb text and in the Sam and other Tgs, as also in certain places in the text of the NT, Jos and many other ancient literary works, without causing us to dis- believe in the genuineness of the rest of their works, or of the works as a whole. Fourthly, the objections to the genuineness of Dnl based on the presence in it of three Gr names of musical instruments and of a number 4. The of Pers words do not seem nearly as Language weighty today as they did a hundred years ago. The Gr inscriptions at Abu Simbal in Upper Egypt dating from the time of Psamtek IJ in the early part of the 6th cent. BC, the discovery of the Minoan inscriptious and ruins in Crete, the revelations of the wide commercial relations of the Phoenicians in the early part of the 1st millennium BC, the lately published inscriptions of Sennacherib about his campaigns in Cilicia against the Gr seafarers to which Alexander Poly- histor and Abydenus had referred, telling about his having carried many Greeks captive to Nineveh about 700 BC, the confirmation of the wealth and expensive ceremonies of Nebuchadnezzar made by his own building and other inscriptions, all assure us of the possibility of the use of Gr musical instruments at Babylon in the 6th cent. BC. This, taken along with the well-known fact that names of articles of commerce and esp. of musical instru- ments go with the thing, leave no room to doubt that a writer of the 6th cent. BC may have known and used borrowed Gr terms. The Aramaeans being the great commercial middlemen between Egypt and Greece on the one hand and Babylon and the Orient on the other, and being in addition a subject people, would naturally adopt many for- eign words into their vocabulary. As to the presence of the so-called Pers words in Dnl, it must be remembered that many words which were formerly considered to be such have been found to be Bab. As to the others, perhaps all of them may be Median rather than Pers; and if so, the children of Israel who were carried captive to the cities of the Medes in the middle of the 8th cent. BC, and the Aramaeans, many of whom were sub- ject to the Medes, at least from the time of the fall of Nineveh about 607 BC, may well have adopted many words into their vocabulary from the lan- guage of their rulers. Daniel was not writing merely for the Jews who had been carried captive by Nebuchadnezzar, but for all Israelites through- out the world. Hence, he would properly use a language which his scattered readers would under- stand rather than the purer idiom of Judaea. Most of his foreign terms are names of officials, legal terms, and articles of clothing, for which there were no suitable terms existing in the earlier Heb or Aram. There was nothing for a writer to do but to invent new terms, or to transfer the current foreign words into his native language. The latter was the pref- erable method and the one which he adopted. Fifthly, objections to the genuineness of the Book of Dnl are made on the ground of the historical misstatements which are said to be 5. Histori- found in it. These may be classed as cal State- (1) chronological, (2) geographical, and ments (3) various. i (1) Chronological objections.—The first chronological objection is derived from Dnl 1 1, where it is said that Nebuchadnezzar made an expedition against Jerus in the 3d year of Jehoiakim, whereas Jeremiah seems to imply that the expedition was made in the 4th year of that king. As Daniel was writing primarily for the Jews of Babylon, he would naturally use the system of dating that was Daniel, Bk of Daphne employed there; and this system differed in its method of denoting the 1st year of a reign from that used by the Egyptians and by the Jews of Jerus for whom Jeremiah wrote. The second objection is derived from the fact that Daniel is said (Dnl 1 21) to have lived unto the 1st year of Cyrus the king, whereas in 10 1 he is said to have seen a vision in the 3d year of Cyrus, king of Persia. These statements are easily recon- ciled by supposing that in the former case it is the 1st year of Cyrus as king of Babylon, and in the second, the 3d year of Cyrus as king of Persia. The third chronological objection is based on 6 28, where it is said that Daniel prospered in the kingdom of Darius and in the kingdom of Cyrus the Persian. This statement is harmonized with the facts revealed by the monuments and with the statements of the book itself by supposing that Darius reigned synchronously with Cyrus, but as sub-king under him. The fourth objection is based on 8 1, where Daniel is said to have seen a vision in the third year of Belshazzar the king. If we suppose that Bel- shazzar was king of the Chaldaeans while his father was king of Babylon, just as Cambyses was king of Babylon while his father, Cyrus, was king of the lands, or as Nabonidus II seems to have been king of Harran while his father, Nabonidus I, was king of Babylon, this statement will harmonize with the other statements made with regard to Belshazzar. (2) Geographical objections —As to the geographi- cal objections, three only need be considered as im- portant. The first is, that Shushan seems to be spoken of in 7 2 as subject to Babylon, whereas it is supposed by some to have been at that time sub- ject to Media. Here we can safely rest upon the opinion of Winckler, that at the division of the Assyr dominions among the allied Medes and Baby- lonians, Elam became subject to Babylon rather than to Media. If, however, this opinion could be shown not to be true, we must remember that Daniel is said to have been at Shushan in a, vision. The second geographical objection is based on the supposition that Nebuchadnezzar would not have gone against Jerus, leaving an Egyp garrison at Carchemish in his rear, thus endangering his line of communication and a possible retreat to Babylon. This objection has no weight, now that the position of Carchemish has been shown to be, not at Cires- sium, as formerly conjectured, but at Jirabis, 150 miles farther up the Euphrates. Carchemish would have cut off a retreat to Nineveh, but was far re- moved from the direct line of communication with Babylon. The third geographical objection is derived from the statement that Darius placed 120 satraps in, or over, all his kingdom. The objection rests upon a false conception of the meaning of satrap and of the extent of a satrapy, there being no reason why a sub-king under Darius may not have had as many satraps under him as Sargon of Assyria had govern- ors and deputies under him; and the latter king mentions 117 peoples and countries over which he appointed his deputies to rule in his place. (3) Other objections—vVarious other objections to the genuineness of Dnl have been made, the prin- cipal being those derived from the supposed non-cx- istence of Kings Darius the Mede and Belshazzar the Chaldaean, from the use of the word Chaldaean to denote the wise mcn of Babylon, and from the silence of other historical sources as to many of the events recorded in Dnl. The discussion of the existence of Belshazzar and Darius the Mede will be found under BensHazzaR and Darrus. As to the argu- ment from silence in general, it may be said that it reduces itself in fact to the absence of all reference to Daniel on the monuments, in the Book of Ecclus, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 786 and in the post-exilic lit. As to the latter books it proves too much; for Hag, Zec, and Mal, as well as Ezr, Neh, and Est, refer to so few of the older canonical books and earlier historical persons and events, that it is not fair to expect them to refer to Daniel—at least, to use their not referring to him or his book as an argument against the existence of either before the time when they were written. As to Ecclus, we might have expected him to mention Daniel or the Three Children; but who knows what reasons Ben Sira may have had for not placing them in his list of Heb heroes? Perhaps, since he held the views which later characterized the Sadducees, he may have passed Daniel by because of his views on the resurrection and on angels. Perhaps he failed to mention any of the four companions be- cause none of their deeds had been wrought in Pal; or because their deeds exalted too highly the heathen monarchies to which the Jews were subject. Or, more likely, the book may have been unknown to him, since very few copies at best of the whole OT can have existed in his time, and the Book of Dnl may not have gained general currency in Pal before it was made so preéminent by the fulfilment of its predictions in the Maccabean times. ; : It is not satisfactory to say that Ben Sira did not mention Daniel and his companions, because the stories concerning them had not yet been im- bedded in a canonical book, inasmuch as he does place Simon, the high priest, among the greatest of Israel’s great men, although he is not mentioned in any canonical book. In conclusion, it may be said, that while it is impossible for us to determine why Ben Sira does not mention Daniel and his three companions among his worthies, if their deeds were known to him, it is even more impossible to under- stand how these stories concerning them cannot merely have arisen but have been accepted as true, between 180 BC, when Ecclus is thought to have been written, and 169 BC, when, according to 1 Macc, Matthias, the first of the Asmoneans, ex- horted his brethren to follow the example cf the fortitude of Ananias and his friends. As to the absence of all mention of Daniel on the contemporary historical documents of Babylon and Persia, such mention is not to be expected, inas- much as those documents give the names of none who occupied positions such as, or similar to, those which Daniel is said to have filled. VI. interpretation—Questions of the interpre- tation of particular passages may be looked for in the commentaries and special works. As to the general question of the kind of prophecy found in the Book of Dnl, it has already been discussed above under the caption of “Genuineness.” As to the interpretation of the world monarchies which pre- cede the monarchy of the Messiah Prince, it may be said, however, that the latest discoveries, ruling out as they do a separate Median empire that in- cluded Babylon, support the view that the four monarchies are the Bab, the Pers, the Gr, and the Rom. According to this view, Darius the Mede was only a sub-king under Cyrus the Pers. Other interpretations have been made by selecting the four empires from those of Assyria, Babylonia, Media, Persia, Medo-Persia, Alexander, the Seleucids, the Romans, and the Mohammedans. The first and the last of these have generally been excluded from serious consideration. The main dispute is as to whether the 4th empire was that of the Seleucids, or that of the Romans, the former view being held commonly by those who hold to the composition of Dnl in the 2d cent. BC, and the latter by those who hold to the traditional view that it was written in the 6th cent. BC. IX. Doctrines.—It is universally admitted that the teachings of Daniel with regard to angels and 787 the resurrection are more explicit than those found elsewhere in the OT. As to angels, Daniel attrib- utes to them names, ranks, and functions not men- tioned by others. It has become common in certain quarters to asscrt that these peculiarities of Daniel are due to Pers influences. The Bab monuments, however, have revealed the fact that the Babylo- niangs believed in both good and evil spirits with names, ranks, and different functions. These spirits correspond in several respects to the Heb angels, and may well have afforded Daniel the back- ground for his visions. Yet, in all such matters, it must be remembered that Daniel purports to give us a Vision, or revelation; and a revelation cannot be bound by the ordinary laws of time and human influence. As to the doctrine of the resurrection, it is gen- erally admitted that Daniel adds some new and distinct features to that which is taught in the other canonical books of the Old Testament. But it will be noted that he does not dwell upon this doctrine, since he mentions it only in 12 2. The materials for his doctrine are to be found in Isa 26 14.21 and 66 24: Ezk 37 1-14, and in Job 14 12; 19 25; Hos 6 2; 1K 17; 2 K 4, and 8 1-5, as well as in the use of the words for sleep and awakening from sleep, or from the dust, for everlasting life or ever- lasting contempt in Isa 26 19; Ps 76 6; 13 3; 127 2; Dt 3116; 287 12; 1K 121; Job7 21, and Jer 20 11; 23 40. The essential ideas and phraseology of Daniel’s teachings are found in Isa, Jer, and Ezk. The first two parts of the books of En and 2 Mace make much of the resurrection; but on the other hand, Eccl seems to believe not even in the immortality of the soul, and Wisd and 1 Mace do not mention a resurrection of the body. That the post-exilic prophets do not mention a resurrection does not prove that they knew nothing about Dnl any more than it proves that they knew nothing about Isa, Jer, and Ezk. There are resemblances, it is true, between the teachings of Daniel with regard to the resurrection and those of the Avesta. But so are there between his doctrines and the ideas of the Egyptians, which had existed for millenniums before his time. Besides there is no proof of any derivation of doctrines from the Persians by the writers of the canonical books of the Jews; and, as we have seen above, both the ideas and verbiage of Daniel are to be found in the acknowledgedly early Heb literature. And finally, this attempt to find a natural origin for all Bib. ideas leaves out of sight the fact that the Scriptures con- tain revelations from God, which transcend the ordinary course of human development. To a Christian, therefore, there can_be no reason for believing that the doctrines of Dnl may not have been promulgated in the 6th cent. BC. The hest commentaries on Dnl from a conservative point of view are those by Calvin, Moses Stuart, Keil, Zéckler, Strong in Lange’s Bibelwerk, Commen- Fuller in the Speaker's Commentary, taries and Zhomson in the Pulpit Commentary, and Wright, Daniel and His Critics. The Introduc- pest defences of Daniel’s authenticity and tions genuineness are Hengstenberg, Authen- ticity of the Book of Daniel, Tregelles, De- fense of the Authenticity, Auberlen, The Prophectes of Daniel, Fuller, Essay on the Authenticity of Daniel, Pusey, Daniel the Prophet (still the best of all), C. H. H. ‘Wright, Daniel and His Critics, Kennedy, The Book of Daniel from the Christian Standpoint, Joseph Wilson, Daniel, and Sir Robert Anderson, Daniel in the Critics’ Den. One should consult also Pinches, The Old Testament in the Light of the Historical Records of Assyria and Babylonia, Clay, Light on the Old Testament from Babel, and Orr, The Problem of the OT. For Eng. readers, the radical school is hest represented by Driver in his Lit. of the OT and in his Daniel; by Bevan, The Book of Daniel; by Prince, Commentary on Daniel, and by Cornill in his Intro to the X. Apocryphal Additions.—In the Gr translations of Dnl three or four pieces are added which are not THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Daniel, Bk of Daphne found in the original Heb or Aram. text as it has come down to us. These are The Prayer of Azarias, The Song of the Three Holy Children, Susanna, and Bel and the Dragon. These additions have all been rejected from the Canon by the Protestant churches because they are not contained in the Heb Canon. In the Church of England they are “read for example of life and instruction of manners.” The Three was “ordered in the rubric of the first Prayer Book of Edward VI (AD 1549) to be used in Lent as a responsory to the OT Lesson at the Morning Prayer.” It contains the Prayer of Azarias from the midst of the fiery furnace, and the song of praise by the three children for their deliverance; the latter being couched largely in phrases borrowed from Ps 148. Sus presents to us the story of a virtuous woman who resisted the seductive attempts of two judges of the elders of the people, whose machinations were exposed through the wisdom of Daniel who convicted them of false witness by the evidence of their own mouth, so that they were put to death according to the law of Moses; and from that day forth Daniel was held in great reputation in the sight of the people. Bel contains three stories. The first relates how Daniel destroyed the image of Bel which Nebuchadnezzar worshipped, by showing by means of ashes strewn on the floor of the temple that the offerings to Bel were devoured by the priests who came secretly into the temple by night. The second tells how Daniel killed the Dragon by throw- ing lumps of mingled pitch, fat and hair into his mouth, so causing the Dragon to burst asunder. The third gives a detailed account of the lions’ den, stating that there were seven lions and that Daniel lived in the den six days, being sustained by broken bread and pottage which a prophet named Habak- kuk brought to him through the air, an angel of the Lord having taken him by the arm and borne him by the hair of his head and through the vehemency of his spirit set him in Babylon over the den, into which he dropped the food for Daniel’s use. Litreraturz.—For commentaries on the additions to the Book of Dnl, see the works on Dnl cited above, and also The Apocrypha by Churton and others; the volume on the Apocrypha in Lange’s Commentary by Bissell; ““The Apocrypha" by Wace in the Speaker's Commentary, and Schtirer, History of the Jewish People. R. Dick WiLson DANITES, dan’its (J70, ha-danit): Occurs as describing those belonging to Dan in Jgs 13 2; 18 1.11; 1 Ch 12 35. DAN-JAAN, dan-ja’an (JZ? 7'J, dan ya‘an; B, Adv Eiédv kal Od8dv, Din Eiddn kai Ouddn): A place visited by Joab and his officers when taking the census (2 8 24 6). It is mentioned between Gilead and Sidon. Some would identify it with Khan Danian, a ruined site N. of Achzib. The text is probably corrupt. Klostermann would read “toward Dan and Ijon” (ef 1 K 16 20). DANNAH, dan’a (727, dannah): One of the cities in the hill country of Judah (Josh 15 49) between Socoh and Kiriath-sannah (Debir), prob- ably Idhna—the Iedna of the Onom—8 miles W. of Hebron. See PEF, III, 305, 330. DAPHNE, daf'né (Adbvy, Déphné, “‘bay-tree”): A suburb of Antioch on the Orontes, according to Strabo and the Jerus itinerary, about 40 furlongs, or 5 miles distant. It is identified with Bett el-Ma on the left bank of the river, to the 8.W. of the city. Here were the famous grove and sanctuary of Apollo. The grove and shrine owed their origin to Seleucus Nicator. It was a place of great natural beauty, and the Seleucid kings spared no outlay in adding to its attractions. The precincts enjoyed the right of asylum. Hither fied Onias the high pee THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 788 priest (171 BC) from the wrath of Menelaus whom he had offended by plain speech. To the disgust and indignation of Jew and Gentile alike, he was lured from the sanctuary by Andronicus and basely put to death (2 Macc 4 33-38). 1t sheltered fugi- tives dyed with villainy of every shade. It was the great pleasure resort of the citizens of Antioch; and it gained an evil repute for immorality, as witnessed by the proverbial Daphnici mores. In Tiberim defluxit Orontes, says Juvenal (iii.62), indi- cating one main source of the corruption that de- moralized the imperial city. The decline of Daphne dates from the days of Christian astendency in the reign of Julian. The place is still musical with fountains and luxuriant with wild vegetation; but nothing now remains to suggest its former splendor. See AntiocH; Gibbon, Decline and Fall, ch xxiii. : W. Ewine DARA, dar’a (91, dara‘). See Darpa. DARDA, dar’da (VIVI, darda‘, “pearl of wis- dom’’): One of the wise men to whom Solomon is compared (1 K 4 31). He was either a son of Mahol (ibid) or a son of Zerah, son of Judah (1 Ch 2 6, where the corresponding name in the same list is giveu as Dara). In rabbinic lore the name has been interpreted as dér dé‘, “the generation of knowledge’’—the generation of the wilderness. DARE, dar: The expression “to dare” in the Scriptures never has the meaning of ‘‘to defy,” “‘to challenge,” or ‘‘to terrify.” It is always found as the tr of rodzdw, tolmdd, “to manifest courage.” This is particularly evident from 2 Cor 10 12, “for we are not bold to number or compare ourselves” (AV “for we dare not make ourselves of the number’’). DARIC, dar'ik (J7AD%1, darkemén, and JIDVI8, ’adharkon; Saperxés, dareikéds): A Pers gold coin about a guinea or five dollars in value. The first form of the word occurs in 1 Ch 29 7; Ezr 2 69, and Neh 7 70-72; the second in Ezr 8 27 and is rendered “dram” in AV and “daric’’ in RV. Inthe passage in Ch, it must refer to a weight, since at the time of David there were no coins, but in the days of Ezra and Nehemiah the Pers darics were current. See Monezy. DARIUS, da-ri’us: The name of three or four kings mentioned in the OT. In the original Pers it is spelled ““Darayavaush”; in Bab, usually ‘Dari- amush”; in Susian(?), ‘““Tariyamaush”; in Egyp, “Antaryuash”’; on Aram. inscriptions, WPI or wWwwwnwst; in Heb, WN, dareydwesh; in Gr, Aapetos, Daretos; in Lat, “Darius.” In meaning it is probably connected with the new Pers word Dara, “king”? Herodotus says it means in Gr, ’Epéelys, Erxeiés, coercttor, ‘‘restrainer,” ‘“compeller,” ‘‘com- mander.” (1) Darius the Mede (Dnl 6 1; 11 1) was the son of Ahasuerus (Xerxes) of the seed of the Medes (Dn! 9 1). He received the government of Bel- shazzar the Chaldaean upon the death of that prince (Dnl 5 30.31; 6 1), and was made king over the kingdom of the Chaldaeans. From Dnl 6 28 we may infer that Darius was king contemporaneously with Cyrus. Outside of the Book of Dnl there is no mention of Darius the Mede by name, though there are good reasons for identifying him with Gubaru, or Ugbaru, the_gov- ernor of Gutium, who is said in the Nabunaid-Cyrus Chronicle to have been appointed by Cyrus as his governor of Babylon after its capture from the Chaldaeans. Somereasons for this identification are as follows: (a) Gubaru is possibly a tr of Darius. The same radical letters in Arab. mean “king,” “compeller,”’ “restrainer.’’? In Heb, derivations of the root mean “lord,” “mistress,” ‘queen’; in Aram., “mighty,” “almighty.” (6) Gutium was the designation of the country N. of Babylon and was in all possibility in the time of Cyrus a part of the province of Media. : (c) But even if Gutium were not a part of Media at that time, it was the custom of Pers kings to appoint Medes as well as Persians to satrapies and to the command of armies. Hence Darius-Gubaru may have been a Mede, even if Gutium were not a part of Media proper. dl (d) Since Daniel never calls Darius the Mede king of Media, or king of Persia, it is immaterial what his title or position may have been before he was made king over the realm of the Chaldaeans. Since the realm of the Chaldaeans never included either Media or Persia, there is absolutely no evi- dence in the Book of Dnl that its author ever meant to imply that Darius the Mede ever ruled over either Media or Persia. (e) That Gubaru is called governor (pthatu), and Darius the Mede, king, is no objection to this identi- fication; for in ancient as well as modern oriental empires the governors of provinces and cities were often called kings. Moreover, in the Aram. lan- guage, no more appropriate word than “king” can be found to designate the ruler of a sub-kingdom, or province of the empire. (f) That Darius is said to have had 120 satraps under him does not conflict with this; for the Pers word “satrap” is indefinite as to the extent of his rule, just like the Eng. word ‘‘governor.” Besides, Gubaru is said to have appointed pthatus under himself. If the kingdom of the Chaldaeans which he received was as large as that of Sargon he may easily have appointed 120 of these sub-rulers; for Sargon names 117 subject cities and countries over which he appointed his prefects and governors. (g) The peoples, nations and tongues of ch 6 are no objection to this identification; for Babylonia itself at this time was inhabited by Babylonians, Chaldacans, Arabians, Aramaeans and Jews, and the kingdom of the Chaldaeans embraced also Assyrians, Elamites, Phoenicians and others within its limits. (kh) This identification is supported further by the fact that there is no other person known to his- tory that can well be meant. Some, indeed, have thought that Darius the Mede was a reflection into the past of Darius Hystaspis; but this is rendered impossible inasmuch as the character, deeds and empire of Darius Hystaspis, which are well known to us from his own monuments and from the Gr historians, do not resemble what Daniel says of Darius the Mede. (2) Darius, the fourth king of Persia, called Hystaspes because he was the son of a Pers king named Hystaspis, is mentioned in Ear (4 5, et al.), Hag (11) and Zec (1 1). Upon the death of Cambyses, son and successor to Cyrus, Smerdis the Magian usurped the kingdom and was de- throned by seven Pers nobles from among whom Darius was selected to be king. After many rebel- lions and wars he succeeded in establishing himself firmly upon the throne (Ani, XI, i). He reorgan- ized and enlarged the Pers empire. He is best known to general history from his conflict with Greece culminating at Marathon, and for his re-dig- ging of the Suez Canal. In sacred history he stands forth as the king who enabled the Jews under Jeshua and Zerubbabel to rebuild the temple at Jerus. (8) Darius, called by the Grecks Nothus, was called Ochus before he became king. He reigned from 424 to 404 BC. In the Scriptures he is men- tioned only in Neh 12 22, where he is called Darius the Pers, probably to distinguish him from Darius the Mede. It is not necessary to suppose that 789 Darius Codomannus who reigned from 336 to 330 BC, is meant by the author of Neh 12, because he mentions Jaddua; for (a) Johanan, the father of this Jaddua, was high priest about 408 BC, as is clear from the Aram. papyrus from Elephantine lately published by Professor Sachau of Berlin, and Jaddua may well have succeeded him in those troublous times before the death of Darius Nothus in 404 BC. And (b) that a high priest named Jaddua met Alexander in 332 BC, is attested only by Jos (Ant, XI, vill, 5). It is not fair to take the testimony of Jos as to Jaddua without taking his testimony as to the meeting with Alexander and as to the appeal of Jaddua to the predictions of the Book of Dnl. But even if Jos be right, there may have been two Jadduas, one high priest in 404 BC, and the other in 332 BC; or the one who was alive and exercising his functions in 404 BC may still have been high priest in 832 BC. He need not have exceeded 90 years of age. According to the Eshki Harran inscription, which purports to have been written by himself, the priest of the temple in that city had served for 104 years. In our own time how many men have been vigorous in mind and body at the age of 90, or thereabouts; Bismarck and Gladstone, for example? R. Dick Witson DARK, dark, DARKNESS, dark’nes (JUM, hashekh; oxéros, skétos): The day and night, light and darkness, are notable antitheses 1. Dark- in Pal. There the day does not slowly ness and _ fade away into the night after a period Light in of twilight, but before sunset there is Palestine the brightness of day, and when the sun has disappeared everything has changed and night is at hand. From sunset until the darkness of night is less than an hour. In the Bible the main use of darkness is in con- trast to light. Light is the symbol of God’s purity, wisdom and glory. Darkness is the 2. Symbolic opposite. Miraculous occurrence of Uses darkness in the land of Egypt for three days is recorded in Ex 10 21.22, and at the death of Christ (Mt 27 45). See PLacuzs; EcuipseE. The fig. uses of darkness are many and various. Itis used as a symbol (a) of moral depravity and its punishment. The wicked walk and work in dark- ness (Ps 82 5; Prov 2 13; Jn 3 19; Rom 13 12), and their reward is to “sit in darkness” (Ps 107 10) or to be “cast forth into the outer darkness” (Mt 8 12); (b) of things mysterious or inexplicable (1 K 8 12; Ps 97 2); (c) of trouble and affliction (2 § 22 29; Job 5 14; Prov 20 20; Isa 9 2; cf Gen 15 12); (d) of punishment (Lam 3 2; Ezk 32 8; Zeph 1 15); (e) of death (1 S 2.9; Job 10 21f; Eccl 11 8); (f) of nothingness (Job 3 4-6); (g) of human ignorance (Job 19 8; 1 Jn 2 11). “A dark (RVm “squalid”] place” (2 Pet 1 19) refers esp. to the state of things described in ch 2. AtFreD H. Joy DARKLY, dark’li: The word occurs in 1 Cor 13 12, ‘For now we see in a mirror, darkly,” in tr of the words év aivlyyari, en ainigmati, RVm “in a riddle.” The contrast is with the “face to face” vision of Divine things in eternity. Earth’s best knowledge is partial, obscure, enigmatic, a broken reflection of the complete truth (“broken lights of Thee”). DARKON, dar’kon (PPT, darkon, “carrier’”): Ancestor of a subdivision of ‘‘Solomon’s servants,” so called, in post-exilic times (Ezr 2 56; Neh 7 58, Lozon, 1 Esd 5 33). DARK SAYINGS (Prov 1 6; Ps 78 2; sing., Ps 49 4[5]; MIT, hidhsth, sing. TIN, hidhah, else- where rendered “riddle,” “proverb”): In the head- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dara Dash ing to the canonical Book of Prov, the general term “proverbs” is made to include ‘a proverb (wr, mashdl], and a figure [or, an interpretation, my", m‘licah], the words [sing. \3°I, débhar] of the wise, and their dark sayings [or, riddles].”” The “prov- erb” is either a saying current among the people (ef 1 8 10 12; “the proverb of the ancients’ 24 13[14]), or a sentence of ethical wisdom composed by the order of wise men (D251), hdkhamim). Of the latter kind are the sententious maxims of the Wisdom lit. (chiefly Prov, but also Job, Ecel, and among the uncanonical writings Ecclus). They are characterized by a secular touch; wisdom, moreover, flourished among the neighbors of Israel as well; so in Edom and elsewhere. Whatever the date of the collection known as the “Proverbs of Solomon,” the wise men existed in Israel at a very early period; the prophets allude to them. But the Heb mashal is sometimes of a more elaborate character corre- sponding to our “parables”; frequently a vein of taunt runs through them, and they played an im- portant part in compositions directed against other nations (cf Nu 21 27). The prophets are fond of employing this genre of literary production; in their hands the ma@shal becomes a fig. or allegorical discourse (cf Ezk 21 5ff [8 ff}). The mdshal in the sense of a didactic poem occurs also in the Psalms (Pss 49 and 78). Hence it is that ‘“prov- erb” and “figure,” or ‘‘proverb” and “dark saying” are interchangeable terms. The “dark saying’ is the popular “riddle” (cf Jgs 14) raised to the dignity of elaborate production. It is in short an allegorical sentence requiring interpretation. Both prophets and psalmists avail themselves thereof. The word of God comes to the prophet in the form of a vision (cf the visions of Amos or Jeremiah), i.e. the truth presents itself to them in the form of a simile. To the perfect prophet of the type of Moses the revelation comes direct in the shape of the naked truth without the mediation of figures of speech or obscure utterances requiring elucidation (cf Nu 12). In the same way St. Paul (1 Cor 13) distinguishes between the childish manner of speaking of things spiritual and the manner of a man: “For now we see in a mirror, darkly [Gr “in a riddle’’]; but then face to face.” The rabbis say that, whereas all the other prophets saw God and things Divine in a dim mirror, Moses saw them in a polished, clear mirror. Both St. Paul and the rabbis feel the difference between mediate and immediate vision, the reve- lation which requires dark fig. language as a vehicle and the clear perception which is the direct truth. Max L. Marcouis DARLING, dir’ling (TT, yahidh, “only,” AVm “only one’; ARVm “dear life’): Used poetically for the life or soul (Ps 22 20; 35 17). DART, dart (7, héc; Bédos, bélos): A pointed missile weapon, as an arrow or light spear (2 S 18 14; Job 41 26). See Armor, Arms, III, 4; Ar- RoW. Figurative: (1) Of the penalty of sin (Prov 7 23 AV); (2) of strong suggestions and fierce tempta- tions to evil (Eph 6 16; cf 1 Mace 6 51). DART-SNAKE, dirt’snake (Isa 34 15). ARROWSNAKE. DASH: The idea of ‘to throw violently” or “to strike” with purpose of causing destruction is usually connected with the word “to dash.” There is per- haps but one exception to this: Ps 91 12 and the quotations of this passage in the NT (Mt 4 6; Lk 411, rpockérrw, prosképts), have the meaning “‘to strike against accidentally” and not intentionally. Nah 2 1, “he that dasheth in pieces” is doubtful. See Dates David “Be that scatters’ would be in better harmony with the Heb "22, méphig, and the following de- scription of destruction. In all other cases ‘‘to dash” is connected with the idea of destruction, esp. the infliction, of punishment which is usually ex- pressed by WO, ratash, ‘to dash to the ground” (2 K 8 12; Isa 18 16 ff, et al., ‘to dash in pieces,” AV simply “‘to dash”), but also by 722, ndphag, “to break to pieces” (Ps 2 9; 1879, et al.). See also PUNISHMENTS. A. L. Bresiicu DATES, dats (wa, d*bhash): Arab. dibbs (2 Ch a 5 AVm); EV Honey (q.v.). See also Paum REE. DATHAN, da'‘than (iJ, ddthan, meaning and derivation unknown, though the name is found in Assyr, in the records of Shalmanezer II): The son of Eliab the son of Pallu the son of Reuben (Nu 26 5 ff; Dt 11.6; Ps 106 17). He and his brother Abiram, with others, followed Korah the Levite in disputing the authority of Moses and Aaron in the wilderness (Nu 16-17, 26; Dt 11 6; Ps 106 17). Other followers of Korah perished by fire before the tent of meeting, but Dathan and Abiram were swallowed up by the earth, with their families and their goods, at their tents. See Koraug. Wiuis J. BEECHER DATHEMA, dath’éma (Ad@epa, Ddthema): A stronghold (1 Mace 5 29)-in Gilead to which the Jews fled for refuge from the heathen (ver9). They were delivered by Judas and Jonathan his brother. It was within a night’s march from Bosora. It may possibly be identical with ‘Athamdn which lies E. of el-Muzérib. DAUB, déb: ‘To daub” always has the meaning ‘to cover,” “to smear with’ in the Scriptures. Ezk compares the flatteries of the false prophets to a slight wall covered with whitewash (lit. “spittle’’). See Ezk 18 10 ff; 22 28. In Ex 2 3 “daubed it with slime and with pitch” (Heb TVAND1, wat- tahm*rah, denom. of 91), hémar, “bitumen” or “as- phalt’”’), ‘“‘to daub” has the same meaning as in the Ezk passage. DAUGHTER, dé‘tér (3, bath; Ovydrnp, thu- gdtér): Used in Scriptures in several more or less distinct senses: (a) for daughter in the ordinary, literal sense (Gen 46 25; Ex 1 16); (6) daughter- in-law (Ruth 2 2); (c) granddaughter or other female descendant (Ex 21; Lk 1 5; 13 16); (d) the women of a country, or of a place, taken collectively (Lk 23 28), of a particular religion (Mal 2 11); (e) all the population of a place, taken collectively, esp. in Prophets and poetic books (Ps 9 14; Isa 23 10; Jer 46 24; Mt 21 5); (f) used in familiar address, ‘‘Daughter, be of good comfort” (Mt 9 22 AV; Mk 6 34; Lk 8 48); (gy) women in general (Prov 31 29); (h) the personification of towns or cities, as of the female sex (Isa 47 1; Ezk 16 44.46; cf Nah 3 4.7), esp. of dependent towns and villages (Ps 48 11; Nu 21 25m; Jgs 1 27m); (<) in Heb idiom for person or thing belonging to or having the characteristics of that with which it is joined, as “daughter of ninety years,” of Sarah, ninety years old (Gen 17 17); “daughters of music,” singing birds, or singing women (Eccl 12 4); daughters of a tree, i.e. branches; daughter of the eye, ie. the pupil. Daughters were not so highly prized as sons, not being usually mentioned by name. A father might sometimes sell his daughter as bondwoman (Ex 21 7); though not to a foreigner (ver 8); daughters might sometimes inherit as did sons, but could not take the inheritance outside of the tribe (Nu 36 1-12). Epwarp Bacsy PoLiarp THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 790 DAUGHTER-IN-LAW. See RELATIONSHIPS, Famity. DAVID, da’vid (11, dawidh, or T7711, dawidh, “beloved’’; Aavel8, Daueid, also in NT, Dauid, Dabid; see Thayer’s Lex.): oe L Name and Genealogy.—This name, which is written “defectively” in the older books, such as those of 8, but plene with the yddh in Ch and the later books, is derived, like the similar name Jedi- diah (2 8 12 25), from a root meaning “to love.” The only person who bears this name in the Bible is the son of Jesse, the second king of Israel. His genealogy is given in the table appended to the Book of Ruth (4 18-22). Here the following points are to be noted: David belonged to the tmbe of Judah: his ancestor Nahshon was chieftain of the whole tribe (Nu 1 7; 2 3; 1 Ch 2 10) and brother- in-law of Aaron the high priest (Hx 6 23). As no other descendants of Nahshon are mentioned, his authority probably descended to Jesse by right of primogeniture. This supposition is countenanced by the fact that Salma (Salmon), the name of the son of Nahshon and father of Boaz, is also the name of a grandson of Caleb who became ‘father’ of Bethlehem, the home of Jesse (1 Ch 2 51). David was closely connected with the tribe of Moab, the mother of his grandfather Obed being Ruth the Moabitess. Of the wife or wives of Jesse we know nothing, and consequently are without information upon a most interesting point—the persouality of the mother of David; but that she too may have been of the tribe of Moab is rendered probable by the fact that, when hard pressed, David placed his parents under the protection of the king of that country (1 S 22 3.4). Hl, Early Years—The home of David when he comes upon the stage of history was the picturesque town of Bethlehem. ‘There his family 1. Shepherd had been settled for generations, in- deed ever since the Israelite nation had overrun the land of Canaan. His father was appar- ently not only the chief man of the place, but he seems to have been chieftain of the whole clan to which he belonged—the clan of Judah. Although the country round Bethlehem is more fertile than that in the neighborhood of Jerus, the inhabitants joined to the cultivation of the soil the breeding of cattle (Lk 2 8). David’s father, not only culti- vated his ancestral fields, but kept flocks of sheep and goats as well. The flocks were sent out every day to pasture in the neighboring valleys attended by the herdsmen armed so as to defend themselves and their charge, not only against marauders from the surrounding deserts, but also from the lions and bears with which the country was then infested. David seems to have been in the habit of accom- panying his father’s servants in their task (1 S 17 20.22), and on occasion would be left in full charge by himself. Nor was his post at such times a sine- cure. He had not only to keep a sharp lookout for thieves, but on more than one occasion had with no other weapon than his shepherd’s club or staff to rescue a lamb from the clutches of a lion or a bear (vs 34 ff). Such adventures, however, must have been rare, and David must often have watched eagerly the lengthening of the shadow which told of the approach of sunset, when he could drive his charge into the zariba for the night and return home. There is, indeed, no life more monotonous and en- ervating than that of an eastern shepherd, but David must have made good use of his idle time. He seems, in fact, to have made such good use of it as to have neglected his handful of sheep. The inci- dents of which he boasted to Saul would not have occurred, had his proper occupation taken up all his thoughts; but, like King Alfred, his head seems 791 to have been filled with ideas far removed from his | By sacred poetry we mean humble task. David, like Nelson, does not seem to have known what it was to be afraid, and it was not to be ex- pected that he could be satisfied with 2, Slinger the lot of the youngest of eight sons of the now aged chief (1S 17 12; 1 Ch 2 13 ff). In the East every man is a soldier, and David’s bent was in that direction. The tribes- men of Benjamin near whose border his home was situated were famed through all Israel as slingers, some of whom could sling at a hair and not miss (Jgs 20 16). Taught, perhaps, by one of these, but certainly by dint of constant practice, David acquired an accuracy of aim which reminds one of tales of William Tell or Robin Hood (1 8 17 49). Another of the pastimes in the pursuit of which David spent many an hour of his youthful days was music. The instrument which he 3. Harpist used was the “harp’’ (Heb kinnér). This instrument had many forms, which may be seen on the Assyr and Egyp monu- ments; but the kind used by David was probably like the modern Arab. rubdba, having only one or two strings, played not with a plectrum (An, VII, xii, 3) but by the hand (cf 1S 16 23, etc, which do not exclude a quill). Whatever the nature of the instrument was, D. acquired such proficiency in playing it that his fame as a musician soon spread throughout the countryside (ver 18). With the passing of time be becomes the Heb Orpheus, in me music birds and mountains joined (cf Koran, c ). To the accompaniment of his lyre David no doubt sang words, either of popular songs or of lyrics of his own composition, in that wailing 4. Poet eastern key which seems to be an imi- tation of the bleating of flocks. The verses he sang would recount his own adventures or the heroic prowess of the warrior of his clan, or celebrate the loveliness of some maiden of the tribe, or consist of elegies upon those slain in battle. That the name of D. was long connected with music the reverse of sacred appears from the fact that Amos denounces the people of luxury of his time for improvising to the sound of the viol, inventing in- struments of music, like D. (6 5). (Itis not clear to which clause “like D.” belongs, probably to both.) The only remains of the secular poetry of D. which have come down to us are his elegies on Saul and Jonathan and on Abner (2 S 1 19-27; 3 33.34), which show him to have been a true poet. Did D. also compose religious verses? Was he “the sweet psalmist of Israel’ (2 S 23 1)? In the ; oldest account which we have, con- 6. Psalmist tained in the. books of S, D. appears as a musician and as a secular poet only, for it is obvious the poetical passages, 2 8 22 1—23 7, do not belong to the original form of that book but are thrust in in the middle of a long list of names of D.’s soldiers. The position is the same in Am (6 5). Itis in the later books and passages that sacred music and psalms begin to be ascribed to him. Perhaps the earliest instance is the pas- sage just cited containing the “last words’ of D. (2S 23 1-7). The Chronicler (about 300 BC) seems to put parts of Pss 105, 96 and 106 into the mouth of D. dt Ch 16 7 ff), and Nehemiah (12 36) regards him apparently as the inventor of the instru- ments used in the Temple service (1 Ch 23 5), or as a player of sacred music. So too in the LXX psalter (151 2) we read, ‘“My hands made an organ, my fingers fashioned a psaltery”; and gradually the whole of the Psalms came to be ascribed to D. as author. In regard to this question it must be remembered that in the East at any rate there is no such distinction as that of sacred and secular. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dates David oetry which mentions the name of God or quotes Botires but the Heb or Arab poet will use the name of God as an accom- paniment to a dance, and will freely sprinkle even comic poetry with citations from his sacred book. D. must have composed sacred poems if he com- posed at all, and he would use his musical gift for the purposes of religion as readily as for those of amusement and pleasure (28 6 14.15). Whether any of our psalms was composed by D. is another question. The titles cannot be considered as con- clusive evidence, and internal proofs of his author- ship are wanting. Indeed the only psalm which claims to have been written by D. is the 18th (= 28 22). One cannot help wishing that the 23d were sung by the little herd lad as he watched his father’s flocks and guarded them from danger. There are sayings of Mohammed that the happiest life is that of the shepherd, and that no one became a prophet who had not at one time 6. Tribes- tended a flock of sheep. What Mo- man hammed meant was that the shepherd enjoys leisure and solitude for reflec- tion and for plunging into those day dreams out of which prophets are made. If D., like the Arab poet Tarafa, indulged in sport, in music and in poetry, even to the neglect of his charge, he must have sought out themes on which to exercise his muse; and it must have been with no little chagrin that he learnt that whereas the tribes of Ephraim, Benjamin, Naphtali, Manasseh, Issachar, Zebulun, Levi, Dan, and even the non-Israelite tribes of Kenaz and the debatable land of Gilead could boast of having held the hegemony of Israel and led the nation in battle, his own tribe of Judah had played a quite subor- dinate part, and was not even mentioned in the national war song of Deborah. As contrasted with the poets of these tribes he could boast in his verses only of Ibzan who belonged to his own town of Bethlehem (Jgs 12 8). The Jerahmeelites were no doubt a powerful clan, but neither they nor any other of the subdivisions of Judah had ever done anything for the common good. Indeed, when the twelve pathfinders had been sent in advance into Canaan, Judah had been represented by Caleb, a member of the Uitlander tribe of Kenaz (Nu 13 6). He became apparently the adopted son of Hezron and so D. might claim kinship with him, and through him with Othniel the first of the judges (Jgs 1 13). _D. thus belonged to the least efficient of all the Israclitish tribes except one, and one which, con- sidering its size and wealth, had till now failed to play a worthy part in the confederacy. It is diffi- cult to believe that the young D. never dreamed of a day when his own tribe should take its true place among its fellows, and when the deliverer of Israel from its oppressors should belong for once to the tribe of Judah. HL, In the Service of Saul—The earliest events in the career of D. are involved in some obscurity. This is due mainly to what appears to 1. David be an insoluble difficulty in chs 16 and First Meets 17 of 1 S. In ch 16, D. is engaged Saul to play before Saul in order to dispel his melancholy, and becomes his squire or armor-bearer (16 21), whereas in the following chapter he is unknown to Saul, who, after the death of Goliath, asks Abner who he is, and Abner replies that he does not know (17 55). This apparent contradiction may be accounted for by the following considerations: (a) 16 14-23 may be inserted out of its chronological order for the sake of the contrast with the section immediately preceding—“‘the spirit of JHVH came mightily upon D. from that day for- ward .... the spirit of JHVH departed from Saul” (16 13.14); (6) the fact of D. becoming Saul’s squire does not imply constant personal attendance David 792 upon him; the text says D. became an (not his) armor-bearer to Saul. The king would have many such squires: Joab, though only commander-in- chief, had, it seems, eighteen (2 S 23 37 reads “ar- mor-bearers’’); (c) D. would not play before Saul every day: his presence might not be required for a space of weeks or months; (d) Saul’s failure to recognize D. may have been a result of the ‘evil spirit from JHVH’ and Abner’s denial of knowl- edge may have been feigned out of jealousy. If we accept all the statements of the dramatis per- sonae in these narratives we shall not get very far. The facts seem to have been somewhat as follows: It had become evident that Saul was not equal to the task to which he had been set— 2. His First the task of breaking the Phili power, Exploit and it became the duty of Samuel, as the vicar of Jeh and as still holding very large powers, to look about for a successor. He turned to the tribe of Judah (the full brother of his own ancestor Levi), a tribe which was fast becoming the most powerful member of the federation. The headman of this clan was Jesse of Bethlehem. His name was well known in the country—Saul does not require to be told who heis(1 S 16 18; 17 58)—but he was by this time advanced in years (17 12). He had, however, many sons. Old men in the East often foretell a great future for a young boy (ef Lk 2 34). Samuel saw that D. was formed of other clay than his brothers, and he anointed him as he had done Saul (18 101). But whereas the anointing of Saul was done surreptitiously and for a definite purpose which was explained at the time (10 1), that of D. was performed before his whole family, but with what object he was not told (16 13). His brothers do not seem to have thought the matter of much consequence (cf 17 28), and all D. could conclude from it was that he was destined to some high office—perhaps that of Samuel’s succes- sor (ef 1 K 19 15.16). It would have the effect of nerving him for any adventure and raising his hopes high and steeling his courage. Whether by ac- cident or by contrivance he became attached to Saul as minstrel (cf 2 K 3 15) and subsequently as one of his armor-bearers. He would probably be at this time about twenty years of age. It must have been after an interval of some months that an event hap- peued which made it impossible for Saul ever again to forget the existence of D. This was the famous duel between D. and the Phili Goliath, which saved the situation for Saul for the time (ch 17). In regard to this narrative it must be noted that vs 12-31.41.50.55-58 and the first five verses of ch 18 are wanting in the best MS of the LXX, that is, the sending of D. from Bethlehem and his fresh introduction to Saul and Saul’s failure to recognize him are left out. With the omission of these verses all the difficulties of the narrative vanish. For the reason why D. could not wear the armor offered him was not because he was still a child, which is absurd in view of the fact that Saul was excep- tionally tall (1 S 9 2), but because he had had no practice with it (17 39). It is ridiculous to sup- pose that D. was not at this time full-grown, and that two armies stood by while a child advanced to engage a giant. The event gained for D. the repu- tation won in modern times at the cannon’s mouth, but also the devoted friendship of Jonathan and the enmity of Saul (1 8S 18 1-9). The next years of D.’s life were spent in the serv- ice of Saul in his wars with the Philis. D.’s suc- cess where Saul had failed, however, instead of gratifying only inflamed the jealousy of the latter, and he determined to put D. out of the way. More than once he attempted to do so with his own hand (18 11; 19 10), but he also employed stratagem. It came to his ears that his daughter Michal, as well THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA as his son Jonathan, loved D., and Saul undertook to give her to D. on condition of his killing a hundred Philis. The gruesome dowry was paid, 3. Envy of and D. became Saul’sson-in-law. The Saul and Heb text states that Saul first offered Flight of his elder daughter to _D., and then David failed to implement his promise (18 17-19.21b), but this passage is not found in the Gr. D.’s relation to Saul did not mitigate the hatred of the latter; indeed his enmity became so bitter that D. determined upon flight. With the help of stratagem on the part of Michal, this was effected and D. betook himself to Samuel at Ramah for counsel and advice (19 18). Thither Saul pursued him, but when he came into the pres- euce of the prophet his courage failed and he was overcome by the contagion of the prophetic ecstasy (19 24) as he had been on a previous occasion (10 11). D. returned to Gibeah, while the coast was clear, to meet Jonathan, but Saul also returned immediately, his hatred more intense than before. D. then continued his flight and came to Ahimelech, the priest at Nob (21 1). It is sometimes supposed that we have here two inconsistent accounts of D.’s flight, according to one of which he fled to Samuel at Ramah, and according to the other to Ahimelech at Nob; but there is no necessity for such a suppo- sition, and even if it were correct, it would not clear up all the difficulties of the narrative. There is evidently much in these narratives that is left untold and our business should be to fill up the gaps in a way consistent with what we are given. That Saul made sure that D. would not return is shown by the fact that he gave his daughter Michal to a man of the tribe of Benjamin as wife (25 44). The relation existing between Jonathan and David was one of pure friendship. There was no reason why it should not be so. A heredi- 4. Jonathan tary monarchy did not yet exist in and David Israel. The only previous attempt to establish such an institution—that of Gideon’s family (Jgs 9)—though not of Gideon himself (8 23)—had ended in failure. The prin- ciple followed hitherto had been that of election by the sheikhs or caids of the clans. To this Saul owed his position, for the lot was a kind of ballot. More- over, behind all national movements there lay the power of the prophets, the representatives of Jeh. Saul was indebted for his election to Samuel, just as Barak was to Deborah (Jgs 4 6). Like the judges who preceded him he had been put forward to meet a definite crisis in the national affairs—the rise of the Phili power (9 16). Had he succeeded in crushing these invaders, the newly established kingdom would in the abseuce of this bond of union have dissolved again into its elements, as had hap- pened on every similar occasion before. He was the only judge who had failed to accomplish the task for which be was appointed, and he was the only one who had been appointed on the under- standing that his son should succeed him, for this constitutes the distinction between king and judge. Moreover, not only was Saul aware that he had failed, but he saw before him the man who was read to step into his place and succeed. His rival had, besides, the backing of the mass of the people and of Samuel who was still virtual head of the state and last court of appeal. It is not to be wondered at_that Saul was hostile to D. Jonathan, on the other hand, acquiesced in the turn things had taken and bowed to what he believed to be the inevitable. Such was his love for D. that he asked only to be his wazeer (vizier) when D. came to the throne GS 23 17). D.’s position was perhaps the most difficult im- aginable. He had to fight the battles of a king whose one idea was to bring about his ruin. He was the bosom friend of a prince whom he proposed to sup- 793 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA David plant in his inheritance. His hope of salvation lay in the death of his king, the father of his wife and of his best friend. The situation would in ordinary circumstances be intolerable, and it wonld have becn impossible but for the fact that those concerned were obsessed by a profound belief in Fate. Jona- than bore no grudge against D. for aiming at the throne because to the throne he was destined by the will of Jeh. To D. it would never occur that he had the choice of declining the high destiny in storefor him. Had he had the power to refuse what he believed to be the decree of Fate, he would hardly escape censure for his ambition and disloyalty. IV. David in Exile—From the moment of his flight D. became an outlaw and remained so until the death of Saul. This period of his 1. David career is full of stirring adventures as Outlaw which remind us of Robert Bruce or Wiliam Wallace of Scotland. Like King Arthur and other heroes he carried a famous sword—the sword of Goliath (21 9). Having ob- tained it of Ahimelech, he for the first time left Is- raelite territory and betook himself to the Phili city of Gath (21 10). Not feeling safe here he left and took up his abode in the cave of Adullam (22 1) in the country of Judah, almost within sight of his native Bethlehem. This cave was admirably suited to the outlaw’s purpose and no doubt D. had many a time explored its recesses when a boy. Here he was joined by his parents and brothers, with their servants, as well as by all sorts of persons who were at war with the government, debtors, fugitives from justice, and discontented persons generally. D.thus became the chief of a band of ontlaws who num- bered about 400. Of such stuff some of his bravest soldiers were made (2 8 23 13ff). He had an augur, too, to direct his actions, and, after the mas- sacre of the priests at Nob, a priest, Abiathar, carry- ing an ephod with which to cast lots (1 8 22 5; 23 6). During this period he supported himself and his men by making raids on the Phili outposts and levying blackmail on his own countrymen (25 2ff) in return for giving them his protection from the Philis (23 1ff). Hard pressed both by Saul and the Philis (who had established themselves even in Bethlehem) he committed his parents to the keep- ing of the king of Moab, and began to rove as a free- booter through the country (23 5.15.25.29). On two occasions D. had Saul in his power, but refused to seize the opportunity of taking his life (24-26). Here again there are no adequate grounds for sup- posing we have two accounts of one and the same incident. During his wandering D.’s followers in- creased in numbers (cf 22 2; 23 13; 25 13). His chief lientenant was his nephew Abishai, the son of his sister Zeruiah, but his brothers Joab and Asahel do not seem to have joined D. yet. Another of his nephews, Jonathan the son of Shimei (Shammah), is mentioned (2 8 21 21; cf 18 16 9) and the Chronicler thinks many other knights joined him during this period (1 Ch 11 10ff). The position of D. at this time was very similar to that of the brigand Raisuli of late in Morocco. That there was some stability in it is shown by his taking two wives at this time—Ahinoam and Abigail (1 8 25 42.43). D. now, abandoning all hope of ever conciliating the king (1 S 27 1), made a move which shows at once his reckless daring and consum- 2. David mate genius. He offered’ the services Joins the of himself and his little army of 600 Philistines men to the enemies of his country. The town of Gath appears to have been an asylum for fugitive Israelites (1 K 2 39). D.’s first impulse on his flight from Saul had been to seek safety there (1 S 21 10-15). Then, however, he was the hero of Israel, whose assassination would be the highest gain to the Philis; now he was the embittered antagonist of Saul, and was welcomed accordingly. Achish placed at his disposal the fortified town of Ziklag in the territory of the now extinct tribe of Simeon, and there he and his follow- ers, each of whom had his family with him, took up their quarters for sixteen months (27 6.7). The advantages to D. were many. He was safe at last from the persecution of Saul (27 4); he could secure ample supplies by making raids upon the Ama- lekites and other tribes hostile to Israel toward the S. (27 8); and if the opportunity presented itself he could deal a serious blow at the Phili arms. The position was no doubt a precarious one. It could last just as long as D. could hoodwink Achish by per- suading him that his raids were directed against his own tribe (27 10). This he succeeded in doing so completely that Achish would have taken him with him on the campaign which ended in the decisive battle of Gilboa, but the other chiefs, fearing treach- ery, refused to allow him to do so. D. was forced to return with his followers to Ziklag, only to find that town razed to the ground and all the women and children carried off by his old enemies the Amalekites (80 1.2). By the time he had recovered the spoil and returned in triumph to Ziklag the battle of Gilboa had been fought and Saul was slain. The conduct of D. in his relations with the Philis was not more reprehensible than that of the Cid who allied himself with Al-Mun’taman of Saragossa, or of Coriolanus who went over to the Volsci. D. com- posed upon the death of Saul and Jonathan an elegy every sentence of which has become classic. V. David as King.—D. immediately removed from Ziklag and took up his quarters at Hebron, where he was at once anointed king 1. Civil over his own tribe of Judah. Thus War began the cleavage between Judah and Israel. Here he was joined, appar- ently for the first time, by his nephew Joab. Abner however, loyal to his former master, had Esh-baal (1 Ch 8 33), son of Saul, anointed king over the remaining tribes at Mahanaim, a fortified town E. of the Jordan. War continued between D. and Abner for several years, fortune always favoring D. Seeing things were going against him Abner forced Esh-baal into a personal quarrel with himself and then transferred his allegiance and persuaded his side to transfer theirs to D. (28 3 21). He did not reap the fruit of his defection, as he was imme- diately after assassinated by Joab in revenge for the death of Asahel whom Abner had killed in self- defence (3 27). Deprived of his chief support Esh-baal also fell a victim to assassination (4 2 ff). D. denounced both crimes with apparent sincerity. He composed an elegy and fasted for Abner (3 33 ff) and avenged the death of Esh-baal (4 9 ff). Yet these acts of violence laid the sovereignty of all Israel at his feet. Of the male heirs of Saul there remained only a son of Jonathan, Merib-baal (1 Ch 8 34) who was a crippled child of 7. D. was there- fore elected king over the nation (28 6 1ff). His sovereignty of Judah is said to have lasted 74 years and that over the undivided people 33, making a reign of 40 years, beginning from D.’s 30th year (5 5; 1 Ch 34; in25 2 10 the text is probably corrupt). These are round numbers. King of all the Israclitish tribes, D. found his hands free to expel the foreigners who had invaded the sacred territory. His first step 2. Con- was to move his headquarters from the quests Southern Hebron, which he had been Abroad compelled at first to make his capital, to the more. central Jerus. The fort here, which was still held by the aboriginal Jebusites, was stormed by Joab, D.’s nephew, who also super- intended the rebuilding for D. He was in conse- quence appointed commander-in-chief (1 Ch 11 David THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 794 6.8), a post which he held as long as D. lived. The materials and the skilled workmen for the erection of the palace were supplied by Hiram of Tyre (286 11). D. now turned his attention to the surrounding tribes and peoples. The most for- midable enemy, the Philis, were worsted in several campaigns, and their power crippled (2 8 6 17 ff; 8 1). In one of these D. so nearly came by his death, that his people would not afterward permit him to take part in the fighting (21 16.17). One of the first countries against which D. turned his arms was the land of Moab, which he treated with a severity which would suggest that the Moabite king had ill-treated D.’s father and mother, who had taken refuge with him (8 2). Yet his conduct toward the Bené ‘Ammon was even more cruel (12 31), and for a less cause (10 1ff). The king of Zobah (Chalkis) was defeated (8 3), and Israelite © garrisons were placed in Syria of Damascus (8 6) and Edom (8 14). The Bené ‘Ammén formed a league with the Syrian kingdoms to the N. and E. of Pal (10 6.16), but these also had no success. All these people became tributary to the kingdom of Israel under D. (10 18.19) except the Bené ‘Amman who were practically exterminated for the time being (12 31). Thus Israel became one of the “great powers” of the world during the reign of D. and his immediate successor. There is no doubt that the expansion of the bound- aries of Israel at this period almost to their ideal limits (Dt 11 24, etc) was largely due 8. Political to the fact that the two great empires Situation of Egypt and Assyria were at the mo- ment passing through a period of weakness and decay. The Assyr monarchy was in a decadent state from about the year 1050 BC, and the 22d Dynasty—to which Shishak belonged (1 K 14 25)—had not yet arisen. D., therefore, had a free hand when his time came and found no more formidable opposition than that of the petty states bordering upon Pal. Against the combined forces of all the Israelitish tribes these had never been able to effect much. It had been the custom of the Israelites on setting out upon expeditions in which the nation as a whole took part to carry with them the sacred 4, The Ark box or “ark” which contained the two stone tables (Josh 4 7, etc). When D. had secured the fortress of Jebus for his metropo- lis one of his first thoughts was to bring into it this emblem of victory. It was then lying at Kiriath- jearim, possibly Abu Gish about 8 miles N.W. of Jerus (cf Ps 132). Owing to the sudden death of one of the drivers, which he interpreted as indica- tive of anger on the part of Jeh, D. left the ark at the house of a Phili which happened to be near at hand. As no misfortune befell this person, but on the contrary much prosperity, D. took courage after three months to bring the sacred chest and its contents into his royal city. The ceremony was conducted with military honors (2 8 6 1) and with religious dancing and music (6 5.14) and festivity (6 18.19). A tent was pitched for it, in which it remained (7 2), except when it was sent with the army to the seat of war (11 11; 15 24). D., how- ever, had already built for himself a stone palace, and he wished now to add to it a chapel royal in the shape of a small temple, such as the neighboring kings had. He was the more anxious to so do as he had much of the material ready to hand in the pre- cious metals which formed the most valuable part of the spoil of the conquered races, such as bronze from Chalkis (8 8), gold and silver (8 11) and the vessels which he had received as a present from the king of Hamath (8 10). He was persuaded, how- ever, by the prophet Nathan to forego that task, on the ground of his having shed much human blood, and to leave it to his successor (1 Ch 22 8; 28 3). VI. Domestic Life.—In accordance with the practice of the kings of his time D. had several wives. His first wife was Michal, the 1. His younger daughter of Saul. When D. Wives and fled from Saul she was given to Phal- Children _tiel, but was restored to D. after Saul’s death. She does not appear to have borne any children. In 2.S 21 8 “Michal” should be Merab (1 S 18 19). During the period of sepa- ration from Michal, D. took to wife Ahinoam of Jezreel and Abigail the wife of Nabal (1 S 26 43.42), who accompanied him to Ziklag (27 3 ff), when they were among those captured by the Ama- lekites (30 5). A fourth wife was the daughter of Talmai of Geshur, Maacah, whom he had captured in war (27 8; 28 83). When he removed to Hebron Ahinoam bore him his eldest son Amnon, and Abigail his second son Chileab or Daniel (2 8 3 2.3; 1 Ch 8 1); his third son was Absalom, whose mother was Maacah, and his fourth Adonijah. His mother’s name was Haggith; nothing is known about her. Two other sons, Shephatiah and Ithream were also born in Hebron (2 S 3 2-5; 1 Ch 38 1-4). When D. added the kingdom of Israel to that of Judah, he, in accordance with custom, took more wives with a view to increase his state and dignity. One of these was Bathsheba, who became the mother of Solomon (258 6 13ff; 1 Ch 3 5ff; 14 3ff). D.’s sons discharged priestly functions (2 8 8 18; cf Nathan in Zec 12 12). It was perhaps inevitable that in so large a house- hold the usual dissensions and crimes of the harim should have sprung up in plenty. A 2. Domestic most unvarnished account of these is Troubles given in 28 11-20—it has been suggested by Abiathar the priest in order to avenge himself on Solomon for his disgrace (1 K 2 26.27), Solomon’s mother being Bathsheba (2 § 11, 12). Ch 13 recounts the wrong done to Tamar, the daughter of D. and Maacah, and sister of Absalom, and how the last named, having avenged his sister’s honor by killing Amnon, his eldest brother, fled for asylum to his mother’s father, the king of Geshur. Thence after two years he re- turned (ch 14), only to foment rebellion against his father (ch 15), leading to civil war between D. and Judah on the one side and Absalom and Israel on the other (chs 16, 17), and ending in the death of himself (ch 18) and of Amasa, D.’s nephew, -at the hands of his cousins Joab and Abishai (20 7 ff), as well as nearly precipitating the disruption of the newly founded kingdom (19 43). The rebellion of Absalom was probably due to the fact of Solomon having been designated D.’s successor (cf 12 24; 1 Ch 22 9), for Absalom had the best claim, Amnon being dead and Chileab apparently of no account. VII. His Officials—As D.’s circumstances im- proved he required assistance in the management. of his affairs. The beginning of his 1. Prophets good fortune had been the friendship of the prophet Samuel (1 S 16 13; 19 18). The prophet or seer was keeper of the king’s conscience and was not appointed by him, but claimed Divine authority (8 7 3.5 ff; 12 1 ff; 24 11 ff). Among the persons who discharged this duty for D. were Gad the seer (1 S 22 5) and Nathan the prophet (1 K 1 I1 ff). All these are said to have written memoirs of their times (1 Ch 29 29; 2 Ch 9 29). Next to the prophet came the priest. The ko- hén (priest) was, as the name indicates, a soothsayer or diviner. The duty of Abiathar, 2. Priests D.’s first priest (1 S 22 20 ff), was to carry the ephod—an object used for ; casting lots (23 6 ff), in order to decide what to do 795 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA David in cases where there was no other way of making up one’s mind (30.7). It is not to be confused with the dress of the same name (1 S 2 18). Later, at Hebron, Abiathar was given a colleague, Zadok (1 Ch 12 28), and it became their duty to carry the ark in erp on (2 8 15 24). Shortly after the death of D., Abiathar was deposed by Solomon for his part in Adonijah’s attempt to seize the throne (1 K 2 26.27), and Zadok remained sole priest to the king (2 35). D.’s sons also acted in the same capacity (2 8 8 18). An extra private priest is mentioned in 2 § 20 26 (cf 23 26.38). When still an outlaw D. required the services of a henchman to take command of his men in his absence. This post was held at first 3. Military hy different persons according to cir- Officers cumstances, but generally, it seems, hy his nephew Abishai (1 8S 26 6). It was only after the death of Saul that his brother Joab threw in his lot with D. His great military talents at once gave him a leading place, and asa re- ward for the capture of Jebus he was given the chief command, which he held against all rivals (2S 3 27; 20 10) during the whole reign. D.’s special body-guard of Phili troops—the Cherethites and Pelethites—were commanded by Benaiah, who in the following reign, succeeded Joab (1 K 2 35). The office of recorder or magister memoriae was held during this reign and in the following hy Je- hoshaphat (2 8 8 16); and that of 4. Other secretary by Seraiah (2 S 8 17), also Officials called Shavsha (1 Ch 18 16) or Shisha (1 K 4 3). There were also the coun- sellors, men noted for their great acumen and knowledge of human nature, such as Ahithophel and Hushai. It was natural that there should be much mutual jealousy and rivalry among these officials, and that some of them should attach them- 5. Mutual selves to one of D.’s many sons, others Rivalry to another. Thus Amnon is the spe- cial patron of D.’s nephew Jonadab (2 8 18 3; cf 21 21), and Absalom is backed by Amasa (17 25). The claim of Adonijah to the throne is supported by Joab and Abiathar (1 K 1 7), as against that of Solomon who is backed by Nathan, Benaiah, Zadok (ver 8) and Hushai (cf Ant, VII, xiv, 4). _ Ahithophel sides with Absa- lom; Hushai with D. (2 8 16 12.32). VIN. Personal Character of David.—We should obtain a very different idea of the personal character of D. according as we drew our con- 1. Chroni- clusions from the books of S and K or cles from the books of Ch. There is no doubt whatever that the former books are much truer to fact, and any estimate or appre- ciation of D. or of any of the other characters de- scribed must be based upon them. The Chronicler, on the other hand, is biased by the religious ideas of his own time and is prejudiced in favor of some of those whose biographies he writes and against others. He accordingly suppresses the dark passages of D.’s life, e.g. the murder of Uriah (1 Ch 20), or sets them in a favorable light, e.g. by laying the blame of the census upon Satan (1 Ch 21 1). D.’s success, esp. as against Saul’s misfortune, is greatly exaggerated (12 2.22). Ceremonial functions are greatly elaborated (ch 16; cf 2 8 6). The various orders of priests and singers in the second temple have their origin traced back to D. (16 4 ff.37 ff; chs 28-27), and the temple of Solomon itself is to all intents and purposes built by him (chs 22, 28). At the same time there may be much material in the shape of names and isolated statements not found in the older books, which so long as they are not tinged with the Chronicler’s pragmatism or “tendency,’”’ may possibly be authentic records pre- served within the circle of the priestly caste, e.g. we are told that Saul’s skull was fastened in the temple of Dagon (1 Ch 10 10). There is no doubt that the true names of Ish-bosheth, Mephibosheth and Eliada (2 8 2 8; 4 4; 6 16) were Ish-baal (Esh-baal), Merib- baal and Beeliada (1 Ch 8 33; 9 39; 8 34; 9 40; 14 7); that the old name of Jerusalem was Jebus (11 4.5; cf Jgs 19 10.11); perhaps a son of D. called Nogah has to be added to 2 8 5 15 from 1 Ch 3 7; 146; in 2 S 8 8 and 21 18, for Betah and Gob read Tebah (Tibhath) and Gezer (1 Ch 18 8; Gen 22 24: 1 Ch 204). The incident recounted in 2S 23 9 ff happened at Pasdammim (1 Ch 11 13). Shammah the Harodite was the son of Elika (2 8 23 25; cf 1 Ch 11 27), and other names in this list have to be corrected after the readings of the . Chronicler. Three (not seven) years of famine was the alternative offered to D. (2 8 24 13; of 1 Ch 21 12). If we could believe that the Book of Pss was in whole or In part the work of D., it would throw a flood of light upon the religious side of his nature. Indeed, we should know as much about his religious life as can well be known about Unfortunately the date and authorship of the 2. Psalms Pan are questions regarding which the most divergent opinions are held. In the early Christian centuries all the Pss were ascribed to D. and, where necessary, ex- plained as prophecies. The author of the Ep. to the He speaks of the Book of Pss simply as ‘‘ David" (4 7). The Gr text, however, of that book ascribes only some 87 of the poems to D., and the Heb only 73. Some of these are not D.’s, and in the whole book there is only one which professes from its contents to be his, namely, Ps 18 (=2 8 22). The occasion on which a psalm was composed is stated only in the case of 13 psalms, all of which are ascribed to D. Each of these is referred to some incident recorded in the books of S, although sometimes the cita- tion is erroneous (see Psatms). The LXX supplies occasions to two or three more psalms; but all such state- ments are merely the conjectures of readers and scribes and are of no historical value. To form a correct opinion of anyone is much more difficult than to state the facts of his life; to form an opinion which will be generally 3. Complex accepted is impossible. Of D.’s char- Character acter the most opposite estimates have been formed. On one hand he is ex- tolled as a saint, and yet few men have committed worse crimes. The character of D. must remain, like that of everyone, an insoluble enigma. A per- son is to be judged by his motives rather than by his actions, and one’s true motives are unknown even - to oneself (Jer 17 9). There are several sides of D.’s nature in regard to which there cannot be two opinions. . 4 Perhaps the feature of his character which stands out most prominently in his earlier years, at any rate, is his boundless physical courage. 4. Physical He never shirked danger (1 S 17 28. Courage 34 ff) and delighted in hairbreadth escapes (26 6). Like most Semites he was fond of gambling and liked to take risks (18 26; cf 28 9; 30 7), even when modesty would have led him to decline them (17 32; cf Jgs 8 20). A native indifference to the shedding of blood grew into a liking for it, giving rise to acts of gross cruelty (1S 279; 2882; 167, etc). He had need, indeed, to be a brave man, considering the charac- ter of the men whom he ruled (1 S 22 2). Yet he could rule them by gentleness as well as by force (30 23). All classes had unbounded confidence in his personal courage and soldierly qualities (2 S 18 3), and were themselves driven to restrain his mili- tary ardor (21 17). Whether D. possessed moral courage to an equal degree is another matter. Had he done so he would hardly have permitted the execution 5. Moral of seven sons of Saul (2 8 21 1 ff), Courage and that, too, at the cost of breaking his plighted word (1S 24 21); he would not have stood in awe of the sons of his sister David Day THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 796 Zeruiah (2 8 3 39), and would have punished Joab instead of weakly invoking an imprecation on his head (ver 29), however much he might have felt the loss of his services. But in many matters his natural sense of justice was blunted by the super- stitions of the age in which he lived. But D. was even more prudent than courageous. He is so described by the person who recommended him (somewhat eulogistically) to Saul 6. Prudence (1 8 16 18). Prudence or wisdom was indeed what his biographer most remarks in him (18 5.30), and situated as he was he could not have too much of it. It shows itself in the fact that he consistently made as many friends and as few enemies as was possible. His wonderful foresight is shown in such acts as his conciliating the Judaean chiefs with gifts taken from his spoil (30 26 ff), in his commendation of the men of Ja- besh-gilead (2 8 2 5-7), and in his reception of Abner (3 20). Yet it must be confessed that this constant looking forward to the future takes away from the spontaneity of his virtue. His gratitude is often a keen sense of favors to come. His kind- ness to Merib-baal did him no harm and some advantage (ch 9; 19 24 ff), and his clemency to Shimei helped to win him the tribe of Benjamin (19 16 ff). Even in his earliest youth he seems to have preferred to attain his ends by roundabout ways. The means by which he obtained introduc- tion or reintroduction to Saul (1 S 17 26 ff) afford some justification for the opinon which his eldest brother held of him (ver 28). Perhaps nothing proves the genius of D. better than his choice of Jebus as the capital of the country—which it still continues to be after a lapse of three thousand years. Yet it must be confessed that D.’s prudence often degenerates into cunning. With true oriental sub- tlety he believed firmly in keeping 7. Strategy one’s secret to oneself at all costs (1 8 21 2). The manner in which he got himself out of Gath after this first visit there (21 13) and the fact that he hoodwinked Achish during sixteen months (ch 27; 28 1; 29) may excite our admiration but not our respect. The Oriental, however, delights in a display of cunning and makes use of it without shame (2 S 15 34), just as the European does in secret. There is something curi- ously modern in the diplomacy which D. employed to ensure his own return in due state (19 11 ff). We must remember, however, that D. lived among persons hardly one of whom he could trust. Joab accuses Abner of deceit, while he himself was faith- ful to none except D. (2 8 3 25). Ziba accuses Merib-baal of treachery, and Merib-baal, Ziba of falsehood, and D. cannot tell which is speaking the truth (28 161ff; 19 24ff). D. himself is out- witted by Joab, though with a friendly purpose (28 14 1ff). The wonder, therefore, is, not that D. was guilty of occasional obliquity, but that he remained as straighforward and simple as he was. D. was, indeed, a man very much ahead of the times in which he lived. His fine elegies upon the death of Saul and Jonathan, Abner 8. Nobility and Absalom show that his nature was untainted with malice. It was no superstitious fear but a high sense of honor which kept him back from putting out of his way his arch- enemy when he had him in his power (1 § 24-26). He even attempts to find an excuse for him (26 19), while depreciating himself (24 14; 26 20) in phrases which are more than a mere oriental metonymy (28 98). It was the ambition of his life to be the founder of a permanent dynasty (2 8 7 29), yet | he was willing that his house should be sacrificed to save his nation from destruction (24 17). Like most Orientals he was endowed with a refinement of feeling unknown in the West. His refusal to drink of water obtained at the cost of bloodshed has be- come classic (2 S 23 17). And he seems to have been gifted with the saving sense of humor (1 8 26 15). That he was a religious person goes without saying (28 7; 8 11). He did not probably believe that outside the land of Israel Jeh ceased to rule: the expression used in 1 8 26 19 is not a term of dogmatic theology. Like other Hebrews D. had no theology. He believed in Jeh alone as the ruler, if not of the universe, at any rate of all the world known to him. He certainly did not believe in Chemosh or Milcom, whether in the lands of Moab and Ammon or out of them (2 § 12 30; for “their king” read Maleam [Milcom]). D. discharged, as most Orientals do, his duty toward his parents (1 S 22 3). To Michal his first wife his love was constant (2 8 9. Davidin 3 13), although she did not bear him Relation to any children. In accordance with the His Family custom of the times, as his estate im- proved, he took other wives and slave- girls. The favorite wifé of his latter days was Bathsheba. His court made some show of splendor as contrasted with the dwellings of the peasantry and the farmer class (19 28.35), but his palace was always small and plain, so that it could be left to the keeping of ten women when he removed from it (15 16). D. and Michal seem to have lived on terms of perfect equality (6 20 ff). In this he con- trasts somewhat with Ahab (1 K 21 5ff). D.’s chief weakness in regard to his family was his indul- gence of some of his sons and favoring some above others, and want of firmness in regard tothem. He could refuse them nothing (2 8 13 27). His first favorite was his eldest son Amnon (13 21 LXX). After the death of Amnon, Absalom became the favorite (18 33), and after the death of Absalom, Adonijah (1 K 16). Yet D. lived for two whole years in Jerus along with Absalom without seeing him (28 14 28), and he was succeeded not by Adonijah, but by Solomon, whose mother was the favorite wife of his later years. Not only did D. know the value of having many friends, but he was capable of sincere attachment. There is no reason to doubt the sin- 10. Davidin cerity of his love for Jonathan, al- Relation to though it is not so completely cut off His Friends from all suspicion of self-interest as is that of Jonathan for him. D., indeed, had the faculty of winning the confidence and love of all sorts and conditions of people, not only of Jona- than (1S 18 1 ff; 20; 23 16 ff), but of J.’s sister Michal (18 20), of the whole people (18 28 LXX; 2 8 19 14), and even of his people’s enemies (2 8 17 27 ff). His friendship lasted as long as the ob- ject of it lived (28 117 ff; 10 1f). In the case of his officers this was partly due to his faculty for choosing good men (28 8 16 ff), so that the same persons often held the same offices during D.’s life (20 23 ff). Yet the services of one of them at least were retained more by compulsion than by choice (2 8 3 39). He seems, indeed, to have continued Joab in his post because he felt he could not do with- out him. Joab was devoted to D. with the devotion of Caleb Balderstone to his master, and he was as utterly unscrupulous. He did not hesitate to com- mit any crime that would benefit D. The latter dared not perpetrate these atrocities himself, but he did not mind taking advantage of such a useful instrument, and never punished Joab for them, save with an impotent curse (3 29). He dealt otherwise with malefactors who could be better spared (25 1 14 ff; 4 9ff). Indeed, a suspicious juryman might find that D. put both Abner and Amasa in the way of Joab (3 23 ff; 19 13; 20 4 ff). It does not say much for D. that he fell so 797 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA David Day low as to fear losing the good opinion even of Joab, Even as early as Ezekiel D. became the ruler who this ready instrument of his worst crime (11 25). was to govern the restored people of Israel (34 23. One reason for the high position D. held in the popular estimation was no doubt his almost unin- terrupted success. He was regarded 11. His as the chosen of Heaven, by friend and Success foe alike (1 8 23 17). Fortune seemed to favor him. Nothing could have been more timely than the death of Saul and Jona- than, of Ishbaal and Abner, of Absalom and Amasa, and he did not raise his hand against one of them. As a guerilla chief with his 600 bandits he could keep at bay Saul with his 3,000 picked men (1 S 24 2; 26 2), but he was not a great general. Most of the old judges of Israel did in one pitched battle what D. effected in a campaign (1 S 18 30; 19 8; 23 1ff; 28 6 17ff; 21 15 ff). Most of his con- quests were won for him by Joab (1 Ch 11 6; 28S 11 1), who willingly accorded D. the credit of what he himself had done (2 8 12 27.28; cf 28 8 13; 1 Ch 18 11 with the title of Ps 60). And to crown all, when he came to turn his arms east and west, he found his two most formidable opponents in these directions crippled and harmless. That he ever survived Saul he owed to a timely incursion of the Philis (1 5 23 24 ff), and his whole career is largely to be explained by the fact that, at the moment, the tribe of Judah as a whole was passing from insig- nificance to supremacy. In the prosecution of his military achievements D. employed everyone who came to his hand as an instrument without any question of 12. His nationabty. This is not to impugn Foreign his patriotism. Eastern peoples are Friends united not by the ties of country but of religion. Still it does seem strange that two of D.’s best friends were two enemies of his nation—Nahash, king of the Bené ‘Ammén (1 § 11 1; 2 8 10 1 ff) and Achish, lord of Gath (1 S 21 10; 27; 28 1ff; 29). He appears to have found the Philis more reliable and trustworthy than the Hebrews. When he became king his personal body-guard was composed of mercenaries of that nation—the Cherethites and Pelethites—with whom he had become acquainted when at Ziklag (1 S 30 14; 2S 8 18; 20 23). It was to a native of Gath that he committed the care of the sacred ark on its passage from Kirjath-jearim to Jerus (2 8 6 10.11). When the rebellion broke out under Absalom, he com- mitted one-third of his forces to a banished soldier of the same town, who had come to him a little while before with a band of followers (2 S 15 19 ff; 18 2). Some of the soldiers in whom he placed the greatest confidence were Hittites (1S 266; 258 11 6), and his commissariat was furnished by persons outside of Israel (2 S 17 27; the Machir tribe were half Syrian; Gilead is the son of Machir, 1 Ch 7 14). The threshing-floor of a Jebusite became the site of the temple of Solomon (2 § 24 18 ff). ; D. was a strong believer in the power of Nemesis, and that daughter of Night played a considerable part in his hfe. He felt a peculiar 13. Neme- satisfaction in being undeservedly sis cursed by Shimei, from a conviction that poetic justice would in the end prevail (2 8 16 12). He must have felt that the same unseen power was at work when his own eldest son was guilty of a crime such as his father had com- mitted before him (2 S 13 and 11), and when the grandfather of the wife of Uriah the Hittite became the enemy whom he had most to fear (2 8 11 3; 23 34; cf Ps 41 9; 55 12f). And D.’s own last hours, instead of being spent in repose and peace following upon a strenuous and successful life, were passed in meting out vengeance to those who had incurred his displeasure as well as commending those who had done him service (1 K 2 5 ff). 24; 37 24). If there were to be a rul- 14. Refer- ing house it must be the Davidic ences in dynasty; it did not occur to the Jews the NT to think of any other solution (Am 911; Hos 3 5; Jer 30 9; Zec 12 8). That Jesus was descended from D. (Mt 9 27, etc) is proved by the fact that his enemies did not deny that he was so (22 41 ff). In the NT, D. is re- garded as the author of the Pss (Acts 4 25; Rom 46; He 47). He is also one of the OT saints (He 11 32) whose actions (unless otherwise stated) are to be imitated (Mt 12 3); but yet not to be compared with the Messiah (Acts 2 29 ff; 13 36) who has power over the life to come (Rev 3 7) and who is “the Root of David” (5 5; 22 16). LitERATURE.—See the commentaries on the books of S, K, Ch, and Pss, and histories of the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, esp. Wellhausen and Kittel. A sketch of the life and historical position of David from the modern Continental point of view will be found in G. oe Saul, David, Salomo, published by Mohr, Tiibingen, Tuomas Hunter WEIR DAVID, CITY OF. See Zion. DAVID, ROOT, réot, OF (4 pita Aaveld, he rhiza Dauvetd, Rev 5 5; 22 16): Root here means stock, family, descendant, hence ‘‘the Root of David” is that which descended from David, not that from which David descended. Jesus Christ in His human nature and family connections was a descendant of David, a member of his family. DAVID, TOWER, tou’ér, OF. See JERUSALEM. DAWN, dén, DAWNING: The word means the approach of the morning light, the breaking of the day. There are several words in the Bible that indi- cate this. 3, nesheph, “twilight” of the morn- ing (Job 7 4; Ps 119 147). The same word is used for evening twilight (1 S 30 17; 2 K 7 5.7); “pa MB, pendth ha-boker, ‘the turning” of the morning, the change from darkness to light, approach of the morning (Jgs 19 26); WWW "BIDI, ‘aph‘appé shahar, “the eyelids” of the morning (Job 3 9; 41 18 [10]); Ww miby , ‘doth ha-shahar, “the ascent” or ‘“‘rise’”’ of the morning (Josh 6 15); éripdonw, epi- phésko, ‘to grow light,” the approach of the dawn (Mt 28 1; Lk 23 54m j diavydsw, diaugdzd, “to grow bright,” “lustrous” (2 Pet 1 19), “until the day dawn”; fig. of the Second Coming of Christ (cf ver 16). H. Porter DAY, da (D1, yom; jpépa, héméra): This com- mon word has caused some trouble to plain readers, because they have not noticed that the word is used in several different senses in the Eng. Bible. When the different uses of the word are understood the difficulty of interpretation vanishes. We note several different uses of the word: (1) It sometimes means the time from daylight tilldark. This popular meaning is easily discovered by the context, eg. Gen 15; 8 22, etc. The marked periods of this daytime were morning, noon and night, as with us. See Ps 65 17. The early hours were sometimes called ‘the cool of the day” (Gen 3 8). After the exile the day or daytime was divided into twelve hours and the night into twelve (see Mt 20 1-12; Jn 119; Acts 23 23); 6 AM would correspond to the first hour, 9 AM to the third; 12 M to the sixth, etc. The hours were longer during the longer days and shorter during the shorter days, as they always counted 12 hours between sunrise and sunset. (2) Day also means a period of 24 hours, or the Day and Night Dayspring THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 798 time from sunset to sunset. In Bible usage the day begins with sunset (see Lev 23 32; Ex 12 15- 20; 2 Cor 11 25, where night is put before day). See Day anp NicHrT. (3) The word “day” is also used of an indefinite period, e.g. “the day” or “day that’ means in general “that time” (see Gen 2 4; Lev 14 2); “day of trouble’ (Ps 20 1); ‘‘day of his wrath” (Job 20 28); “day of Jehovah” (Isa 2 12); “day of the Lord” (1 Cor 6 5; 1 Thess 5 2; 2 Pet 3 10); ‘day of salvation” (2 Cor 6 2); “day of Jesus Christ” (Phil 1 6). (4) It is used figuratively also'in Jn 9 4, where ‘while it is day” means “while I have opportunity to work, as daytime is the time for work.” In 1 Thess 5 5.8, ‘sons of the day’ means spiritually enlightened ones. (5) We must also bear in mind that with God time .is not reckoned as with us (see Ps 90 4; 2 Pet 3 8). (6) The apocalyptic use of the word “day” in Dnl 12 11; Rev 2 10, ete, is difficult to define. It evi- dently does not mean a natural day. See Apoca- LYPSE. (7) On the meaning of “day” in the story of Creation we note (a) the word “‘day”’ is used of the whole period of creation (Gen 2 4); (b) these days are days of God, with whom one day is as a thousand years; the whole age or period of salvation is called “the day of salvation”; see above. So we believe that in harmony with Bible usage we may under- stand the creative days as creative periods. See also ASTRONOMY; CREATION; EvoLuTion. G. H. GerBeRpDING Figurative: The word “‘day”’ is used fig. in many senses, some of which are here given. (1) The span of human life—Gen 5 4: “And the days of Adam... . were eight hundred years.” “And if thou wilt walk ... . then I will lengthen thy days” (1 K 3 14; cf Ps 90 12; Isa 38 5). (2) An indefinite time.——Existence in general: Gen 3 14: ‘All the days of thy life” (cf Gen 21 34; Nu 9 19; Josh 22 3; Lk 1 24; Acts 21 10). (83) A set time.—Gen 26 24: “And when her ays... . were fulfilled’; Dnl 12 13: ‘Thou shalt stand in thy lot, at the end of the days” (cf Lev 12 6; Dnl 2 44). (4) A historic period. —Gen 6 4: ‘The Nephilim were in the earth in those days”; Jgs 17 6: ‘In those days there was no king in Israel” (cf 1 S 3 1; 1 Ch 5 17; Hos 2 13). (5) Past time.—Ps 18 18: “the day of my ca- lamity”; Ps 77 5: ‘I have considered the days of old” (cf Mic 7 20; Mal 3 7; Mt 23 30). (6) Future time.—Dt 3114: “Thy days ap- proach that thou must die’; Ps 72 7: “In his days shall... .” (cf Ezk 22 14; Joel 2 29; Mt 2419; 2 Pet 3 3; Rev 9 6). (7) The eternal—In Dnl 7 9.13, where God is called ‘‘the ancient of days.” (8) A season of opportunity —Jn 9 4: “We must work the works of him that sent me, while it is day: the night cometh, when no man can work” (cf Rom 13 12.13; 1 Thess & 5-8). See Day (4), above. (9) Time of salvation—Specially referring to the hopes and prospects of the parousia (see Escua- ToLoGy oF NT). Rom 13 12: “The night is far spent, and the day is at hand.” Henry E. Dosker DAY AND NIGHT: “Day,” BM, ydm; ordi- narily, the Heb “day” lasted from dawn to the coming forth of the stars (Neh 4 21). The con- text usually makes it clear whether the term “day” refers to the period of twenty-four hours or to day- time; when there was a possibility of confusion, the term Teta laylah, “night,” was added (Gen 7 4.12; 31 39). The “day” is reckoned from evening to evening, in accordance with the order noted in the account of Creation, viz. “And there was even- ing and there was morning, one day” (Gen 1 5); Lev 23 32 and Dnl 8 14 reflect the same mode of reckoning the day. The phrase 72 377, ‘erebh boker, ‘“‘evening-morning,” used in this last passage, is simply a variation of ydm and laylah, “day” and ‘night?’ it is the equivalent of the Gr_vuxéquepor, nuchthémeron (2 Cor 11 25). That the custom of reckoning the day as beginning in the evening and lasting until the following evening was probably of late origin is shown by the phrase “tarry all night” (Jgs 19 6-9); the context shows that the day is regarded as beginning in the morning; in the even- ing the day “declined,” and until the new day (morning) arrived it was necessary to “‘tarry all night” (cf also Nu 11 32). The transition of day to night begins before sun- set and lasts till after sunset; the change of night to day begins before sunrise and continues until after sunrise. In both cases, neither ‘erebh, “even- ing,” nor béker, “morning,” indicate an exact space of time (cf Gen 8 11; Ex 10 13; Dt 16 6). The term TW}, nesheph, is used for both evening twilight and morning dawn (cf 1 S 30 17; 2 K 7 5.7; Job 7 4). As there were no definite measurements of the time of day, the various periods were indicated by the natural changes of the day; thus “midday” was the time of the day when the sun mounted its highest (DTIMY, ¢ohdrayim); afternoon was that part of the day when the sun declined (BVA M03, ntoth ha-yom) ; and evening was the time of the going down of the sun (379, ‘erebh). “Between the even- ings” (DID4IM Pa, bén ha-‘arbayim) was the inter- val between sunset and darkness. The day was not divided into hours until a late period. MU, sha@‘@h=Aram. (Dnl 3 6), is common in Syr and in later Heb; it denoted, originally, any short space of time, and only later came to be equivalent to our “hour” (Driver). The threefold division of the day into watches continued into post-exilic Rom times; but the Rom method of four divisions was also known (Mk 13 35), where all four divisions are referred to: “at even” (6¥é, opsé), “midnight” (uecovtxriovy, mesoniktion), ‘at cock crowing” (ddex- ropopwria, alektorophénia), ‘in the morning” (pw, prot). These last extended from six to six o’clock (cf also Mt 14 25; Mk 13 35). Acts 12 4 speaks of four parties of four Rom soldiers (quaternions), each of whom had to keep guard during one watch of the night. In Berakhoth 3b, Rabbi Nathan (2d cent.) knows of only three night-watches; but the patriarch, Rabbi Judah, knows four. See also Day. Horace J. Wour DAY BEFORE THE SABBATH (4 mapacxevt, hé paraskeué, “‘preparation’”’): Considered as a day of preparation, In accordance with Ex 16 23, both before the regular Sabbath and before a feast Sab- bath (Mt 27 62; Mk 15 42; Lk 23 54; Jn 19 14. 31.42). At 38 PM, the Hebrews began to prepare their food for the next day, and to perform all labors which were forbidden to be done on the Sab- bath and yet must be done. They bathed and puri- fied themselves, dressed in festive apparel, set their tables, and lighted their lamps. On the day before Easter, the Hebrews of the later period made it their chief business to remove all leaven from the house (1 Cor 5 7). This custom of converting at least a portion of the day before the Sabbath into a holy day was recognized by the Romans to such an extent that, according to a rescript of Augustus, Jews need not appear in court after 3 PM on such days. Criminal cases were not brought before court on this day, and journeys exceeding 12 Rom miles were prohibited. The signal for the prepa- 799 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Day and Night Dayspring rations was given by the priests by means of trum- pets blown six times at intervals. Frank E. Hirscu DAY, BREAK OF. See Break or Day. DAY, JOSHUA’S LONG. See Brtu-Horon, Battle oF. DAY, LAST (4 éoxdty jpépa, hé eschdté héméra): Repeatedly used by Jesus in Jn (6 39.40.44.54; 11 24; 12 48) for the day of resurrection and judgment (see Escoarotocy or THE NT). Cf the usage in the OT (Isa 2 2; Mic 4 1) and the NT (Acts 2 17; 2 Tim 3 1; 2 Pet 3 3; 1 Jn 2 18; Jude ver 18) of “last days” and “last time” to denote the Messianic age. See Larrer Days; Last Days; Last Time. In Jn 7 37, “the last day, the great day of the feast’’ refers to the eighth day of the feast of Taber- nacles. This closing day was observed as a Sab- bath (Lev 23 36). On it the libation of water made on other days was not made; hence the allu- sion of Jesus to Himself as the Giver of the living water. JAMES ORR DAY, LORD'S. See Lorp’s Day. DAY OF ATONEMENT. See ATonEMENT, Day OF. DAY OF CHRIST. See Day or THE Lorn. DAY OF JEHOVAH. See Day or TuE Lorn. DAY OF JUDGMENT. See JupGmMenrt, Last. DAY OF THE LORD (JEHOVAH) (7177 BD”, yom YHWH; 7 tpépa rot Kuplov, hé héméra tov Kurtou): The idea is a common OT one. It denotes the consummation of the kingdom of God and the absolute cessation of all attacks upon it (Isa 2 12; 138 6.9; 34 8; Ezk 13 5; 30 3; Joel 1 15; 2 11; Am 6 18; Zeph 1 14; Zec 141). Itisa “day of visitation” (Isa 10 3), a day “of the wrath of Jeh” (Ezk 7 19), a “great day of Jeh’’ (Zeph 1 14). ae entire conception in the OT is dark and fore- oding. On the other hand the NT idea is pervaded with the elements of hope and joy and victory. In the NT it is eminently the day of Christ, the day of His coming in the glory of His father. The very conception of Him as the “Son of Man’’ points to this day (E. Kuehl, Das Selbstbewusstsein Jesu, 68). Jn 6 27: “And he gave him authority to execute judgment, because he is a son of man” (cf Mt 24 27.30; Lk 12 8). It is true in the NT there is a dark background to the bright picture, for it still remains a “day of wrath” (Rom 2 5.6), a “great day” (Rev 6 17; Jude ver 6), a “day of God” (2 Pet 3 12), a “day of judgment” (Mt 10 15; 2 Pet 3 7; Rom 2 16). Sometimes it is calle “that day” (Mt 7 22; 1 Thess 6 4; 2 Tim 4 8), and again it is called “the day’? without any quali- fication whatever, as if it were the only day worth counting in all the history of the world and of the race (1 Cor 3 13). To the unbeliever, the NT depicts it as a day of terror; to the believer, as a day of joy. For on that day Christ will raise the dead, esp. His own dead, the bodies of those that believed in Him—“‘that of all that which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up at the last day” (Jn 6 39). In that day He comes to His own (Mt 16 27), and therefore it is called “the day of our Lord Jesus” (2 Cor 1 14),“‘the day of Jesus Christ’’ or “of Christ” (Phil 1 6.10), the day when there ‘shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven’ (Mt 24 30). All Paulinic lit. is esp. suf- fused with this longing for the “parousia,” the day of Christ’s glorious manifestation. The entire con- ception of that day centers therefore in Christ and points to the everlasting establishment of the king- dom of heaven, from which sin will be forever elim- inated, and in which the antithesis between Nature and grace will be changed into an everlasting synthesis. See also Escuatotocy (or OT anp NT). Henry E. Dosxer DAY'S JOURNEY, jtr’ni (01 F713, derekh yom, Gen 30 36; Nu 10 33; 11 31; tpépas 686s, héméras hodés, Lk 2 44): The common way of estimating distances in the East is by hours and days. This is natural in a country where roads are mere bridle paths or non-existent, as in the desert. The dis- tance traveled must of course differ largely accord- ing to the difficulties of the way, and it is more important to know where night will overtake the traveler than the actual distance accomplished. A day’s journey is now commonly reckoned at about 3 miles per hour, the distance usually covered by a loaded mule, the number of hours being about 8. Hence a day’s journey is about 24 miles, and this may be taken as a fair estimate for Bible times. H. Porter DAYS, LAST. See Last Days. DAYSMAN, diz’man (127, yakhah, ‘to argue, de- cide, convince,’ RV UMPIRE): The use of this word appears to have been more common in the 16th cent. than at the later date of the tr of AV, when its adoption was infrequent. The oldest instance of the term given in the Ozford English Dictionary is Plumpion Corresp. (1489), p. 82: “Sir, the dayes- men cannot agre us.” It appears also in the 1551 ed of the OT in 1 S 2 25, where the EV “judge” is trd “dayes-man.” Tindale’s tr has for Ex 21 22, ‘He shall paye as the dayesmen appoynte him” . (EV as the “‘judges determine’). See also Edmund Spenser’s Faerie Queene, ii, c. 8, published in 1590. As used in AV (Job 9 33) the word means an ar- bitrator, umpire, referee; one who stands in a judi- cial capacity between two parties, and decides upon the merits of their arguments or case at law. ‘“‘Nei- ther is there any daysman [RV “umpire’’] betwixt us, that might lay his hand upon us both” (ef Gen 31 37). It was the eastern custom for a judge to lay his hands upon the heads of the two parties in disagreement, thus emphasizing his adjudicatory capacity and his desire to render an unbiased ver- dict. Job might consider a human judge as capa- ble of acting as an umpire upon his own claims, but no man was worthy to question the purposes of Jeh, or metaphorically, to “lay his hands upon” Him. In the NT (1 Cor 4 3, dv@pwrtvy, anthripiné, twépa., héméra) “man’s judgment” is lit. ‘man’s day,” in the sense of a day fixed for the trial of a case. Both Tindale and Coverdale so translate. See also 1 Tim 2 5, where the Saviour is termed the “one mediator... . between God and men.” Here the word understands a pleader, an advocate before an umpire, rather than the adjudicator him- self (see Job 19 25-27). ARTHUR WaLwyn Evans DAYSPRING, da’spring: This beautiful Eng. word, in current use in the time of the AV, is found in the OT asthe trof WW, shahar, “Hastthou.... caused the dayspring to know his place?” (Job 38 12 AV). This is no doubt intended lit. for the dawn. The ‘‘place’”’ of the dayspring is the particular point of the horizon at which the sun comes up on any given day. This slowly changes day by day through the year, moving northward from midwinter till mid- summer, and back again southward from midsum- mer to midwinter. See Astronomy, I, 2. Also once in the NT for dvarodj, anatolé, “a rising.” Day-Star Dead Sea THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 800 “The dayspring from on high hath visited us” (AV; RV “shall visit us,’ Lk 1 78). Also in Apoc, “At the dayspring pray unto thee” (AV; RV “plead with thee at the dawning of the light,” Wisd 16 28). Both the Heb and Gr words, however, are of fre- quent occurrence, but variously rendered, “dawn,” “break of day,” “morning,” “sunrise,” “east.” Note esp. “the spring of the day” (1 S 9 26), “the day began to spring’ (Jgs 19 25). Used with héliou, “sun,” for nsing of the sun (Rev 7 2; 16 12). In LXX the same Gr word is used for Heb cemah, “branch,” to designate the Messiah (Jer 23 5; Zec 6 12). But this sense of the word is wholly unknown in profane Gr. The word is also employed in L-XX to express the rising of a heavenly body, as the moon (Isa 60 19). This is good Gr. See the kindred vb. anatéllé, “to rise’ (LXX, Isa 60 1; Mal 4 2). What is the meaning of anatolé in Lk 1 78? Certainly not branch; that does not fit any of the facts, unless it be rendered “‘branch of light” (see Reynolds, John the Baptist, 115). It occurs in Zacharias’ bymn over the birth of his son. The ode consists of two parts, ‘The glory and security of the Messiah’s kingdom,” and ‘The glory of the Forerunner.” The expression before us is in the latter part. It naturally refers, therefore, not to the Messiah himself, but to John. He is the dayspring from on high who hath visited the people who sat in darkness and the shadow of death. With Godet we believe that the picture is borrowed from the caravan which has missed its way in the desert. The unfortunate pilgrims, overtaken by the night, are sitting down expecting death, when suddenly a star brightly beams above them. They take cour- age at the sight. The whole caravan leaps to its feet. It is the herald of the coming day and soon they see the great orb himself filling the east with orient pearl and gold. Is not one tempted to go a little farther and see here the morning star, berald of the coming sun to be obliterated by his rising? ‘He must wax, but I must wane’ (Jn 3 30). What was John’s work but, by his own testimony, to guide the benighted pilgrims into the way of peace, that is, to Him who was the Prince of Peace? If, however, as by most commentators, it be taken to refer to the Messiah, it probably implies prophetic knowledge that the conception of Jesus had already taken place, and that the Messianic era was at hand, when the Jewish world should be filled with spiritual splendor. See Day-Srar. G. H. TREvVER DAY-STAR (ANW772 55°, Adel ben-shahar, Isa 14 12; dwoddpos, phdsphéros, 2 Pet 119): The OT passage 1s rendered in AV ‘Lucifer, son of the morning,” in AVm and RV “day-star,” i.e. the morning star. The reference is to the king of Baby- lon (ver 4). In 2 Pet 1 19, “Until ... . the day- star arise in your hearts,” the word is lit. “light- bringer.” It is applicable, therefore, not only to the planet Venus, seen as a morning star, herald of the dawn, but to the sun itself, and is used here as a title of Our Lord. See Astronomy, I, 6. ‘ DAY, THAT (THE). DEACON, 4dé‘k’n, See Day or THE Lorp. DEACONESS, dé’k’n-es: The term d:dxovos, didkonos, and its cognates occur. many times in the NT, as do its synonyms irnpérns, hupérétés, and dobdos, dowvilos, with their respective cognates. It may be said in general that the terms denote the service or ministration of the bondserv- ant (dowos), underling (hupéretés) or helper (dia- konos), in all shades and gradations of meaning both literal and metaphorical. It would serve no useful purpose to list and discuss all the passages in detail. Christianity has from the beginning stood for filial service to God and His kingdom and for brotherly helpfulness to man, and hence terms expressive of these functions abound in the NT. It behooves us to inquire whether and where they occur in a tech- nical sense sufficiently defined to denote the institu- tion of a special ecclesiastical office, from which the historical diaconate may confidently be said to be derived. ; Many have sought the origin of the diaconate in the institution of the Seven at Jerus (Acts 6), and this view was countenanced by many of the church Fathers. The Seven were appointed to “serve tables’ (diakonein trapézais), in order to permit the Twelve to “continue stedfastly in prayer, and in the ministry [diakonia] of the word.” They are not called deacons (diakonot), and the qualifica- tions required are not the same as those prescribed by Paul in 1 Tim 3 8-12; furthermore, Stephen appears in Acts preéminently as a preacher, and Dilip as an evangelist. Paul clearly recognizes women as deaconesses, but will not permit a woman to teach (1 Tim 2 12). The obvious conclusion is that the Seven may be called the first deacons only im the sense that they were the earliest recorded helpers of the Twelve as directors of the church, and that they served in the capacity, among others, of specially appointed ministrants to the poor. Paul says, “I commend unto you Phoebe our sister, who is a servant [RVm “or, deaconess’’] of the church that is at Cenchreae” (Rom 16 1). This is by many taken as referring to an officially appointed deaconess; but the fact that there is in the earlier group of Paul’s epistles no clear evidence of the institution of the diaconate, makes against this interpretation. Phoebe was clearly an honored helper in the church closely associated with that at Corinth, where likewise evidence of special eccle- siastical organization is wanting. In Phil 1 1 Paul and Timothy send greetings “to all the saints .... at Philippi, with the bishops and deacons.” Here then we find mention of “‘dea- cons” in a way to suggest a formal diaconate; but the want of definition as to their qualifications and duties renders it impossible to affirm with certainty the existence of the office. In 1 Tim 3 8-12, after prescribing the qualifi- cations and the method of appointment of a bishop or overseer, Paul continues: “Deacons in like man- ner must be grave, not double-tongued, not given to much wine, not greedy of filthy lucre; holding the mystery of the faith in a pure conscience. And let these also first be proved; then let them serve as deacons, if they be blameless. Women in like manner must be grave, not slanderers, temperate, faithful in all things. Let deacons be husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well.” Deacons and deaconesses are here provided for, and the character of their qualifications makes | it clear that they were to be appointed as dispensers of alms, who should come into close personal rela- tions with the poor. We conclude, therefore, that the Seven and Phoebe did not exercise the diaconate in a technical sense, which appears first certainly in 1 Tim 8, although it is not improbably recognized in Phil 1 1, and was foreshadowed in the various agencies for the dispensing of alms and the care of the poor of the church instituted in various churches at an earlier date. See also Bispop; Cuurcu; Caurca Gov- ERNMENT. WituiamM ArtHuR Heipen DEAD, ded (M2, math; vexpés, nekrés): Used in several senses: (1) as a substantive, denoting the body deprived of life, as when Abraham speaks of burying his dead (Gen 23); (2) as a collective noun including all those that have passed away from life (as Rev 20 12). In several passages dead in 801 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Day-Star Dead Sea this sense is used in contrast to the quick or living (as Nu 16 48). This collective mode of expression ig used when resurrection is described as “rising from the dead”; (3) as an adj., coupled with body, car- case or man, as Dt 14 8 AV; (4) most frequently it is used as a complement of the vb. “to be,” referring to the condition of being deceased or the period of death, e.g. 2S 12 19; Mk 6 35; (5) in the sense of being liable to death it occurs in Gen 20 3; Ex 12 33; 2 S 16 9; (6) as an intensive adj. it is used in the phrase ‘‘dead sleep,” to mean profound sleep simulating death (Ps 76 6); (7) figuratively “dead” is used to express the spiritual condition of those who are unable to attain to the life of faith. They are dead in trespasses, as in Eph 2 1, or con- versely, those who by the New Birth are delivered from sin, are said to be dead to the Law (as Col 2 20, etc). A faith which does not show its life in the practical virtues of Christianity is called dead (Jas 217); (8)in Rom 4 19; He 11 12, ‘‘dead”’ signifies the senile condition of loss of vigor and virility. The passage in Job (26 5), wherein in AV “dead things” seem to mean things that never had life, is more accurately train RV as “they that are de- ceased,”’ i.e. the shades of the dead. There are few references to the physical accom- paniments of the act of ne Deborah has a poet- ical account of the death of Sisera (Jgs 5 24 ff), and in Eccl 12, where the failure of the bodily faculties in old age culminates in death, it is pictorially com- pared to the breaking of a lamp extinguishing the flame (“golden” being probably used of “‘oil,”’ as it is in Zee 4 12), and the loosing of the silver hebhel or chain by which the lamp is suspended in the tent of the Arab. The dead body defiled those who touched it (Lev 11 31) and therefore sepulture took place speedily, as in the case of Lazarus (Jn 11 17-39) and Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 6 6-10). This practice is still followed by the fellahin. The uselessness of the dead is the subject of a proverb (Eccl 9 4) and the phrase “dead dog”’ is used as a contemptuous epithet as of a person utterly worthless (1 S 24 14; 28 9 8; 16 9). AtEx. MAcALiIsTER DEAD, BAPTISM FOR THE. See Baptism FOR THE Deap. DEAD BODY. See Corpse. DEADLY, ded’li: In the OT two words are used in the sense of a “mortal [Heb nephesh, “hateful,” “foul”] enemy” (Ps 17 9), and in the sense of ‘fatal disease,’ the destructiveness of which causes a general panic (Heb maweth, ‘‘death,’”’ 1S 6 11). In the NT we have in Rev 13 3.12 the expres- sion “deadly wound” (Gr thdnatos), better “death- stroke,” as in RV, and the phrases ‘deadly thing,” ie. poison (thandsimén ti, Mk 16 18), and “full of deadly poison” (mesté iow thanatéphérou, Jas 3 8), said of an unruly tongue. Both Gr words convey the idea of “causing or bringing death” and occur in classical lit. in a variety of uses in combination with the bite of venomous reptiles, deadly potions, mortal wounds and fatal contagion. DEAD SEA, THE: H. L. E. Luerine . Present AREA IJ, Former ENLARGEMENT III. Leveu or, 1s Earity Historic Times IV. CowstituTion oF THE WATER » CLIMATE VI. Roaps Misce,ianeovus Items The Plain of the Jordan . Ain Jidi (En-gedi) The Fortress of Masada Jebel Usdum (Mount of Sodom) . Vale of Siddim . El-Lisén VIII. History LITERATURE PoP oN The name given by Gr and Lat writers to the remarkable inland lake occupying the deepest part of the depression of the ARABAH (q.v.). In the Bible it is called the Salt Sea (Gen 14 3; Dt 3 17); the Sea of the Plain (‘Arabhah) (Josh 3 16); and the (East) Eastern Sea (Ezk 47 18; Jocl 2 20). Among the Arabs it is still called Bahr Lat (Sea of Lot). By Jos it was called Lake Asphaltites (Ant, I, ix) from the quantities of bitumen or asphalt occasion- ally washed upon its shores and found in some of the tributary wadies. I. Present Area.—The length of the lake from N. to S. is 47 miles; its greatest width 10 miles nar- rowing down to less than 2 miles opposite Point Molyneux on e-Lisén. Its area is approximately 300 sq. miles. From various levelings its surface is found to be 1,292 ft. below that of the Mediter- ranean, while its greatest depth, near the eastern shore 10 miles S. of the mouth of the Jordan is 1,278 ft. But the level varies from 10 to 15 ft. semiannually, and more at longer intervals; and we are not sure from which one of these levels the above figures have been derived. Throughout the northern half of the lake on the E. side the descent to the extreme depth is very rapid; while from the western side the depth increases more gradually, esp. at the extreme northern end, where the lake has been filled in by the delta of the Jordan. Jebel Usdum from the South, Looking over the Mud Flat (Vale of Siddim) Covered by the Sea in High Water. (Photo. by Libbey.) About two-thirds of the distance to the southern end, the peninsula, el-Lisdn (‘‘the Tongue’’), pro- jects from the E. more than half-way across the lake, being in the shape, however, of a boot rather than a tongue, with the toe to the N., forming a bay between it and the eastern mamland. The head of this bay has been largely filled in by the débris brought down by Wady Kerak, and Wady Ben Hamid, and shoals very gradually down to the greatest depths to the N. The toe of this penin- sula is named Point Costigan, and the heel, Point Molyneux, after two travelers who lost their lives about the middle of the 19th cent. in pioneer at- tempts to explore the lake. Over the entire area 8. of Point Molyneux, the water is shallow, being nowhere more than 15 ft. deep, and for the most part not over 10 ft., and in some places less than 6 ft. In high water the lake extends a mile or more beyond low-water mark, over the Mud Flat (Seb- kah) at the south end. From the history of the crossing of the Jordan by Joshua and the expedition of Chedorlaomer when Lot was captured, it is evident that the outlines of the sea were essentially the same 3,500 years ago as they are now, showing that there has been no radical change in climatic conditions since then. I. Former Enlargement.—But if we go back a few thousand years into prehistoric times the evi- dence is abundant that the valley has witnessed remarkable climatic changes (see ARABAH). At Ain Abu Weridech, about 40 miles beyond the south end of the lake, Hull in 1888 discovered deposits of an abandoned shore line 1,400 ft. above its level (see ARazBaH). A pronounced abandoned shore Dead Sea line at the 650 ft. level had been observed first by Tristram, and noted afterward by many trav- elers. But from the more detailed examination made by Professor Ellsworth Huntington in 1909 (see Pal and Its Transformation) five abandoned shore lines of marked size have been determined, Ree: Sen Fh Remnant of the 650-ft. Ahandoned Shore Line at 8S. W. Corner of Dead Sea, Surmounted by Cru- saders’ Castle and in Places Excavated to Furnish Places of Shelter. (Photo. by F. B. Wright.) surrounding the valley at the following approxi- mate heights above the present level of the lake: 1,480, 640, 430, 300 and 250 ft. He writes that “at its greatest extent the sea stretched at least 30 miles sonth of its present termination, while northward it probably covered the Sea of Galilee and the Waters of Merom, and sent an arm into the Vale of Jezreel..... Lacustrine deposits exist in the Jordan valley shortly south of the Sea of Gali- lee. A mile north of Jisr el-Mujamiyeh, as the modern railroad bridge is called, a tilted scries of clays, apparently lacustrine, lies under some untilted whitish clays, also apparently lacustrine. The ele- vation here is about 840 it. below that of the Mediterranean Sea, or 450 above the Dead Sea. . ... So far as can be detected by the aneroid the highest deposits [about the Dead Seal] lie at the same elevation on all sides of the lake.” There are also numerous minor strands below the 250 ft. major strand. These are estimated by Huntington as 210, 170, 145, 115, 90, 70, 56, 40, 30 and 12 ft. above the lake successively. It is noted, also, that the lower beaches all show less erosion than those above them. This certainly points to a gradual diminution of the water in the aan during the prehistoric period, while on the other hand there is much evidence that there has been a considerable rise in the water within the historic period. Date palms and tamarisks are seen standing out from the water in numerous places some little distance from the present shore where the water is several feet deep. These are of such size as to show that for many years the soil in which they grew was not subject to overflow. As long ago as 1876 Merrill noticed such trees standing in the water 40 ft. from the shore, near the N.E. corner of the lake (Hast of the Jordan, 224). Numerous trunks of date palms THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 802 and tamarisks can now be seen submerged to a similar extent along the western shore. In 1818 Irby and Mangles (Travels, 454) saw a company of Arabs ford the lake from Point Molyneux to the west side, and noted that the line of the ford was marked by branches of trees which had been stuck into the bottom. In 1838 Robinson found the water at such a stage that the ford was impracti- cable and so it has Sheen reported by all travelers since that time. But Mr. A. Forder, having re- cently examined the evidence for the Pal Explora- tion Fund, learns from the older Arabs that formerly there was a well-known causeway leading from et- Lisén opposite Wady Kerak to Wady Umm Baghek, across which sheep, goats and men could pass, while camels and mules could be driven across anywhere in the water. Moreover the Arab guide said that the channel “was so narrow that the people of his tribe used to sit on the edge of the Lisdn and parley with Arabs from the west as to the return of cattle that had been stolen by one or other of the parties.” (See PEFS [April, 1910], 112.) Ill, Level of, in Early Historic Times.—Numer- ous general considerations indicate that in the early historic period the level of the water was so much lower than now that much of the bay 8. of Point , Molyneux was dry land. In Josh 15 2.5f the south border of Judah is said to extend from “the bay [tongue, Lisdn] that looketh southward” ; while the “border of the north quarter was from the bay [tongue, Lisén] of the sea at the end of the Jor- dan; and the border went up to Beth-hoglah, and passed along by the north of Beth-arabah.” If the limits of the north end of the Dead Sea were the same then as now the boundary must have turned down to the mouth of the Jordan by a sharp angle. ' But according to the description it runs almost exactly E. and W. from beyond Jerus to Beth-hog- lah, and nothing is said about any change in direc- tion, while elsewhere, any such abrupt change in direction as is here supposed is carefully noted. Furthermore, in detailing the boundary of Benja- min (Josh 18 19) we are told that “the border passed along to the side of Beth-hoglah northward; and the goings out of the border were at the north bay [tongue, Lisdn] of the Salt Sea, at the south end of the Jordan: this was the south border.” This ean hardly have any other meaning than that the north end of the Dead Sea was at Beth-hoglah. From these data Mr. Clermont-Ganneau (see Recueil d’archéologie orientale, V [1902], 267-80) inferred that in the time of Joshua the level of the sea was Beach at Low Water at the North End of the Sea, Bordering the Plain of Jericho. (Photo. by Libhey.) Dead so much higher than now that a tongue-like exten- sion reached the vicinity of Beth-hoglah, while the underlying topography was essentially the same as now. On the contrary, our present knowledge of the geologic forces in operation would indicate that at that tume the Dead Sea was considerably lower than now, and that its rise to its present level has been partly caused by the silting up of a bay which formerly extended to Beth-hogiah. F nent eyes ee VIEW FROM MOUNT OF OLIVES, OVERLOOKING THE DEAD SEA 803 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dead Sea The geological evidence concerning this point is | the extent to which these encroachments have so interesting, and of so much importance in its | tended to narrow the limits of the original lake. bearing upon our interpretation of various historical | The sediment deposited by the Jordan, at the north statements concerning the region, that it is worth | end of the Dead Sea, is practically all derived from while to present it somewhat in detail. As already | the portion of the drainage basin between it and the stated (see Annan), the present level of the Dead | Sea of Galilee—the latter serving as a catch-basin Sea is determined by the equilibrium established | to retain the sediment brought down from the up- between the evaporation (estimated at 20,000,000 | per part of the valley. The Zér, or narrow channel cubic ft. per diem) over the area and the amount of | which the ‘Jordan has eroded in the sedimentary SCALE OF GEGCRAPHICAL MILES Se ‘ oe re f ere oe be eee Map anp Loneairupinay Section (rrom Norrx ro Sours) or THE Dean Sra, rrom THE OBSERVATIONS, SURVEYS AND Sounpinos oF Lyncu, Rosrnson, DE Sautcy, VAN DE VELDE AND OTHERS. 1, Jericho. 2. Ford of Jordan. 8. Wady Kumren. 4. Wady Zerke Ma'ain. 5. Ras Feshkah. 6, Ain Terabch. 7. Rag Mersed. 8, Wady Mojih, 9. Ain didy. 10, Birket el-Khulil, 11. Sebbeh. 12. Wady Zuweirah. 13. Um Zoghal. 14. Jebel Usdum. 15. Wady el-Fikri. 16. Wady el-Jeib. 17. Wady Tufileh. 18. Ghor es Safieh. 19. Plaines Sebkah. 20. Wadyed Dra’uh. 21, Tho Feninsula. 22. The Lagoon. 23, The Frank Mountain. 24, Bethlehem, 25. Hebron. (The dotted lines show the place of the transverse sectiona shown in the following illustration.) water brought into the valley by the tributary | plain through which it flows (see JorpAN, VALLEY streams. The present area of the sea is, in round | oF), is approximately half a mile wide, 100 feet deep, numbers, 300 sq. miles. The historical evidence | and 60 mileslong. All the sediment which formerly shows that this evaporating surface has not varied | filled this has been swept into the head of the sea, appreciably since the time of Abraham. But the | while the Jarmuk, the Jabbok, and a score of smaller encroachments of the delta of the Jordan upon this | tributaries descending rapidly from the bordering area, as well as of the deltas of several other streams, | heights of Gilead, three or four thousand ft. above must have been very great since that period. The | the valley, bring an abnormal amount of débris effect of this auld he to limit the evaporating sur- | into the river, as do a large number of shorter trib- face, which would cause the water to rise until it | utaries which descend an equal amount from the overflowed enough of the low land at the south end | mountains of Galilee, Samaria, and Judah. The to restore the equilibrium. entire area thus contributing to this part of the It is easy to make an approximate calculation of | Jordan is not less than 3,000 sq. mileg Dead Sea THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 804. All writers are impressed by the evidence of the torrential floods which fill these water courses after severe storms. The descent being so rapid, permits the water after each rainfall to run off without delay, and so intensifies its eroding power. The well-known figure of Our Lord (Mt 7 26 ff) in de- scribing the destruction of the house which is built upon the sand, when the rains descend and the winds beat upon it, is drawn from Nature. The delta terraces at the mouths of such mountain streams where they debouch on the lowlands are formed and re-formed with extreme rapidity, each succeed- ing storm tending to wash the previous delta down to lower levels and carry away whatever was built upon it. The storms which descend upon the plains of Gilead, as well as those upon the Judaean hills, are exceedingly destructive. For though the rainfall at Jerns, according to the observations of Chaplin (see J. Glaisher, ‘‘On the Fall of Rain at Jerus,” PHFS [Jannary, 1894], 39) averages but 20 inches annually, ranging from 32.21 inches in 1878 to 13.39 inches in 1870, nearly all occurs in the three winter months, and therefore in quantities to he most effective in erosive capacity. d this is effective upon hoth sides of the Jordan valley, in which the rainfall is very slight. *’ Day after day,” Tristram remarks, “‘we have seeu the clouds, after pouring their fatness on Samaria and Judaea, pass over the valley, and then descend in torrents on the hills of Gilead and Moab,” a phenomenon naturally resulting from the rising column of heated air coming up from the torrid conditions of the depressed Jordan valley. Tristram (The Land of Moab, 23, 24) gives a vivid description of the effect of a storm near Jerus. As his party was encamped during the night the whole slope upon which they pitched became a shallow stream, while “the deep ravines of the wilderness of Judah [were] covered with torrents, and tiny cas- cades rolling down from every rock..... So easily disintegrated is the soft limestone of these wadies, that the rain of a few hours . . . . did more to deepen and widen the channels than the storms of several years could effect on a Northumbrian hillside. No geologist could watch the effect of this storm without being convinced that in calculating the progress of denudation, other factors than that of time must be taken into account, and that denu- dation may proceed most rapidly where rains are most uncertain.” Lieutenant Lynch writes that while ascending the Kerak “‘there came a shout of thunder from the dense cloud which had gathered at the summit of the gorge, followed by a rain, compared to which the gentle showers of our more favoured clime are as dew drops to the overflowing cistern... .. The black and threatening cloud soon enveloped the mountain tops, the lightning playing across it in incessant flashes, while the loud thunder reverber- ated from side to side of the appalling chasm. Be- tween the peals we soon heard a roaring and con- tinuous sound. It was the torrent from the rain cloud, sweeping in a long line of foam down the steep declivity, bearing along huge fragments of rocks, which, striking against each other, sounded like mimic thunder.” I can bear similar testimony from observations when traveling in Turkestan where the annual rain- fall is only about 4 inches. At one time a storm was seen raging upon the mountains 20 miles away, where it spent its entire force without shedding a drop upon the plain. Upon skirting the base of the mountain the next day, however, the railroad track was covered for a long distance 2 or 3 ft. deep with débris which had been washed down by the cloudburst. No one can have any proper compre- hension of the erosive power of the showers of Pal without duly taking into account the extent and the steepness of the descent from the highlands on either side, and the irregularity of the rainfall, These form what in the Rocky Mountains would be called 1. From Ain Feshkhah to E. shore. East West 3, From Ain Teraheh to Wady Zerka. Souseccwuchsecestant [ ---------- 104.------ 3 o 5. From Ain Jidy to Wady Mojib, j-------- 939------} ------~ 876-------| woe ennnil2 8--- =e oe ” Ford near S. end of Peninsula, Transverse Section (from West to East) of th ea; Plotted from the shunaines Given: ee by Lynch, 1849, arroyos. Afier the débris has been brought into the Jordan by these torrents, and the rise of water 805 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dead Sea makes it “overflow all its banks,’’ the sediment is | extending 2 miles farther south with an average then swept on to the Dead Sea with great rapidity. All these considerations indicate that the deltas of the streams coming into the valley of the Jordan and the Dead Sea must be increasing at an unusually rapid rate. It will be profitable, therefore, to com- pare it with other deltas upon which direct obser- vations have been made. The Mississippi River is sweeping into the Gulf of Mexico sediment at a rate which represents one foot of surface soil over the whole drainage basin, extending from the Rocky Mountains to the Alleghenies, in a little less than 5,000 years. The Hoang-Ho is lowering its drain- age basin a foot in 1,464 years, while the river Po is reducing its level a foot in 729 years. So rapidly has the river Po filled up its valley that the city of Adria, which was a seaport 2,000 years ago, is now 14 miles from the mouth of the river. The Tigris and Euphrates rivers have silted up the head of the Persian Gulf nearly 100 miles. (See Croll, Climate and Time, 332, 333; Darwin, Formation of Vegetable Mould through the Action of Worms, 233.) From these considerations it is a conservative estimate that the tributaries of the Jordan valley between the Lake of Galilee and the Dead Sea bring down sediment enough to lower the basin one foot in 2,000 years, so that since the time of Abraham 167,- 270,400,000 cubic feet of solid matter have been added to its delta. This would cover 25 sq. miles 250 ft. deep. Taking into consideration the prob- able depth of water at the north end of the sea, it is, therefore, not an extravagant supposition that the Jordan delta has encroached upon the sea to the extent of 15 or 20 sq. miles, hmiting the evapo- rating surface to that extent and causing the level of the water to rise, and extend an equal amount over the low lands at the south end. ; ’ At the same time the other streams coming direct- ly into the lake have been contributing deltas to narrow its margin at various points. The Kerak, the Arnon and the Zerka Mo’ain bring in an im- mense amount of sediment from the E.; el- Hessi, el-Jeib and el-Fikri from the S.; and Wady el- Muhauwit, el- Areyeh and the Kedron, with numerous smaller intermediate streams, from the W. A de- tailed examination of these deposits will serve the double purpose of establishing the point in question and of giving a vivid conception of the sea and its surroundings. Throughout the lower part of its course the river Jordan flows as has heen already said, through a narrow gorge called the Zér, which the river has eroded in the soft sedimentary deposits which cover the hottom of the valley (or Ghér) from side to side. puposite Jericho the Ghér is ahout 15 miles wide. The Zér, however, does not average more than one-half mile in width and is about 100 ft. lower than the general level of the Ghér. But at “the Jews’ Castle,’’ about 8 miles from the mouth of the Jordan, the Zér begins to enlarge and merge into a true delta. The embankment of the Zér slopes away in a 8.W. direction till it reaches the Judaean mountains at Khurbet Kumran, 10 miles distant, leaving a triangle of low land between it and the Dead Sea averaging fully one mile in width and heing nearly 3 miles wide opposite the mouth of the Jordan. ‘The face of the embankment separating the Zér from the Ghér has in several places been deeply cut into by the small wadies which come down from the western mountains, and the wash from these wadies as well as that from more temporary streams after every shower has considerably raised the western border of the Zér throughout this distance. But it can safely be estimated that the original boundary of the Dead Sea has here been encroached upon to the extent of 10 or 15sq. miles. Again, upon the eastern side of the Jordan the other limb of the delta, though smaller, is equally in evidence. Merrill (Hast of the Jordan, 223, 224), in describing his survey of the region, says he was compelled to walk for some hours along the shore and then north to reach his horses, which evidently had been coming over the harder and more elevated surface of the Ghér. “The plain,” he says, ‘for many sq. miles north of the sea is like ashes in which we often sank over shoe. Returning to the N.W. corner of the lake we find the delta deposit which we left at Khurbet Kumran width of one-half mile to Ras Feshkah, which rises * abruptly from the water’s edge, and renders it iaiposeible for travelers to follow along the shore. But just beyond Ras Feshkah a delta half a mile or more in length and width is projected into the sea at the mouth of Wady en Nar, which comes down from Jerus and is known in its upper portions as Kedron. This is the wady which passes the con- vent of Mar Saba and is referred to in such a striking manner in Ezk 47. Like most of the other wadies coming into the Dead Sea, this courses the most of its way through inaccessible defiles and has built up a delta at its mouth covered with ‘‘fragments of rock or boulders swept along by the torrent in its periodical overflows” (De Saulcy, I, 137, 138). From Rds Feshkah to Rds Mersid, a distance of 15 miles, the shore is bordered with a deposit of sand and gravel averaging 2 half a mile in width, while opposite Wady ed Derajeh and Wady Hisdsa (which descend from Bethiehem and the wilderness of Tekoah) the width is fully one mile. At the mouth of one of the smaller gorges De Saulcy noted what geologists call a ‘‘cone of dejection’’ where ‘the gravel washed down from the reo was heaped up to the extent of nearly 250 yards”’ Rds Mersid, again, obstructs the passage along the shore almost as effectually as did Ras Feshkah, but farther south there is no other obstruction. The plain of En-gedi, connected in such an interest- ing manner with the history of David and with numerous other events of national importance, is described by the Pal Exploration Fund as “about half a mile broad and a mile in length.” This con- sists of material brought down for the most pArt by Wady el-’ Areijeh, which descends from the vicinity of Hebron with one branch passing through Tekoah. The principal path leading from the west side of the Dead Sea to the hills of Judaea follows the direction of this wady. Between En-gedi and Sebbeh (Masada), a distance of 10 miles, the limestone cliffs retreat till they are fully 2 miles from the shore. Across this space numerous wadies course their way bringing down an_ immense amount of débris and depositing it as deltas at the water's edge. These projecting deltas were noticed by Robin- son as he looked southward from the height above En- gedi, hut their significance was not understood. “One feature of the sea,’’ he says, “struck us imme- diately, which was unexpected to us, viz. the number of shoal-like points and peninsulas which run into its south- ern part, appearing at first sight like flat sand-banks or islands. Below us on the S: were two such projecting banks on the western shore, composed prohably of pebbles and gravel, extending out into the sea for a considerable distance. The larger and more important of these is on the 8. of the spot called Birket el- Khilil, a little bay or indentation in the western precipice, where the water, flowing into shallow hasins when it is high, evaporates, and deposits salt. This Bpoe is just S. of the mouth of Wady cl-Khibarah” (BR, 1,501). One of these deltas is described by De Saulcy as 500 yds. in breadth and another as indefinitely larger. Usdum the Western Cli of the Bowlders Rolled Along by the Torrent of Which eee on the Right, Masada and s on the Left. Water. (Photo. by Libbey.) Six miles 8. of Masada, probably at the mouth of Wady Umm Baghek, Lynch notes a delta extending “half a mile out into the sea.” Still farther 8. the Dead Sea THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 806 combined delta of the Wady Zuweirah and Wady ‘ Muhauwat covers an area of 2 or 3 sq. miles, and is dotted with bowlders and fragments of rock a foot or more in diameter, which have been washed over the area by the torrential floods. Beyond Jebel Usdum, Wady el-Fikreh, draining an area of 200 or 300 sq. miles, has deposited an immense amount of coarse sediment on the W. side of the Sebkah (a mud flat. which was formerly occupied, probably by a projection of the Dead Sea). Into theS. end of the depression, extending from the Sebkah to the Ascent of Akrabbim, deltas of Wady el-Jeib, Wady el-Khanzireh and Wady Tujfileh have in connection with Wady Fikreh encroached upon the valley to the extent of 12 or 15sq. miles. Altogether these wadies drain an area of more than 3,000 sq. miles, and the granitic formations over which they pass have been 80 disintegrated by atmospheric influences that an excessive amount of coarse sediment is carried along by them (see Hull, Mount Seir, etc, 104-6). In ascending them, one encounters every indication of occasional destructive floods. Following up the eastern shore, Wady el-Hess? com- ing down from the mountains of Edom has built up the plain of Safiekh which pushes out into the neck of the Sebkah and covers an area of 3 or 4 sq. miles. Farther N., Wady Kerak and Wady Beni Hamid have with their deltas encroached to the extent of 2 or 3 sq. miles upon the head of the hay, erp une into the Lisdn east of Point Costigan. Still farther N., Wady Mojib (the Arnon) and Wady Zerka Ma'ain (coming down from the hot springs of Callirrhoe) have built up less pronounced deltas because of the greater depth of the water on the E. side, but even so they are by no means inconsiderahle, in each case projecting a half-mile or more into the lake. Putting all these items together, there can be little doubt that the area of the Dead Sea has been encroached upon to the extent of 25 or 30 sq. miles since the time of Abraham and that this has resulted in a rise of the general level of the water sufficient. to overflow a considerable portion of the lagoon at the S. end, thus keeping the evaporating area con- stant. The only escape from this conclusion is the supposition that the rainfall of the region is less than it was at the dawn of history, and so the smaller evaporating area would be sufficient to maintain the former level. But of this we have no adequate evi- dence. On the contrary there is abundant evi- dence that the climatic conditions connected with the production of the Glacial Period had passed away long before the conquest of the Vale of Sid- dim by Amraphel and his confederates (Gen 14). The consequences of this rise of water are various and significant. It lends credibility to the persist-~ ent tradition that the sites of Sodom and Gomorrah are covered by the shallow water at the S. end of the sea, and also to the statement of Scripture that the region about these cities (on the suppositiou that they were at the S. end of the sea) was like the garden of the Lord; for that plain was then much larger than it is now, and was well watered, and possessed greater elements of fertility than are now apparent. Furthermore, this supposed lower level of the lake in early times may have greatly facili- tated the passage of armies and caravans from one end to the other, thus rendering it more easy to understand the historical statements relating to the earliest periods of occupation. Even now the road at the base of Jebel Usdum which is open at low water is impassable at high water. On the last of December, 1883, Professor Hull (Mount Seir, etc, 133) traversed the shore at the base of the salt cliffs along a gravel terrace 100 ft. wide, which “abruptly terminated in a descent of about 5 ft. to the line of driftwood which marked the upper limit of the waters.” On the Ist of January, 1901, the water along the base of the salt cliffs was so deep that it was impossible for my party to pass along the shore. It. is easy to believe that the level might have been lowered sufficiently to expose a margin of shore which could be traversed on the W. side from one end to the other. IV. Constitution of the Water. —As in the case of all inclosed basins, the waters of the Dead Sea are impregnated to an excessive degree with saline matter. ‘The salt whith they contain,” however, “4s not wholly or even principally common salt, but is mostly the chloride and bromide of magnesium and calcium, so that they are not merely a strong brine, but rather resemble the mother liquors of a salt- pau left after the common salt has crystallized out” (Dawson, Egypt and Syria, 123). The following analysis is given by Booth and Muckle of water brought by Commander Lynch and taken by him May 5 from 195 fathoms deep opposite the mouth of Wady Zerka Ma’ain. Other analyses vary from this more or less, owing doubtless to the different localities and depths from which the specimens had been obtained. Specific gravity at 60°............ . 22742 Chloride of magnesium........... 145.8971 Chloride of calcium..... .. 81.0746 Chloride of sodium..... 78.5537 Chloride of potassium... : 6.5860 Bromide of potassium............ 1.3741 Sulphate of lime................. 0.7012 264.1867 W)BbG ii seca 5s eee auacacee te etanens, Warde ghee 735.8133 1000 . 0000 Total amount of solid matter found by direct experiment........... 264.0000 What is here labeled bromide of potassium, how- ever, is called by most other analysts bromide of magnesium, it being difficult to separate and dis- tinguish these elements in composition. The large percentage of bromide, of which but a trace is found in the ocean, is supposed to have been derived from volcanic emanations. As compared with sea water, it is worthy of note that that of the Dead Sea yields 26 Ibs. of salts to 100 lbs. of water, whereas that of the Atlantic yields only 6 Ibs. in the same quan- tity. Lake Urumiah is as salt as the Dead Sea. As results of this salinity the water is excessively buoyant and is destructive of all forms of animal life. Lynch found that his metal boats sank an inch deeper in the Jordan when equally heavily laden than they did in the Dead Sea. All travelers who bathe in it relate that when they throw them- selves upon their backs their bodies will be half out of the water. Jos (BJ, IV, vii, 4) relates that the emperor Vespasian caused certain men who could Bathing at the North End of the Dead Sea, the Mountains of Moab in the Background. (Photo. by F. B. Wright.) not swim to be thrown into the water with their hands tied_behind them, and they floated on the surface. Dead fish and various shells are indeed often found upon the shore, but they have evi- dently been brought in by the tributary fresh-water streams, or belong to species which live in the brack- ish pools of the bordering lagoons, which are abun- dantly supplied with fresh water. The report ex- tensively circulated in earlier times that birds did 807 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dead Sea not fly over the lake has no foundation in fact, as some species of birds are known even to light upon the surface and sport upon the waters. The whole depression is subject to frequent storms of wind blowing through its length. These produce waves whose force is very destructive of boats encounter- ing them owing to the high specific gravity of the water; but for the same reason the waves rapidly subside after a storm, so that the general appear- ance of the lake is placid in the extreme. Salt Cliffs on the East Side of Jebel Usdum, Washed by the Waters of the Lake. Pillar of Salt Ready to Fall. (Photo. by F. B. Wright.) The source from which these saline matters have been derived has been a subject of much speculation —some having supposed that it was derived from the dissolution of the salt cliffs in Jebel Usdum. But this theory is disproved by the fact that com- mon salt forms but a small portion of the material held in solution by the water. It is more correct to regard this salt mountain as a deposit precipitated from the saturated brine which had accumulated, as we have supposed, during the Cretaceous age. Probably salt is now being deposited at the bottom of the lake from the present saturated solution to appear in some future age in the wreck of progress- ive geological changes. The salts of the Dead Sea, like those in all similarly inclosed basins, have been brought in by the streams of water from all over the drainage basin. Such streams always contain more or less solid matter in solution, which becomes concentrated through the evaporation which takes place over inclosed basins. The ocean is the great reservoir of such deposits, but is too large to be af- fected to the extent noticeable in smaller basins. The extreme salinity of the Dead Sea water shows both the long continuance of the isolation of the basin and the abundance of soluble matter con- tained in the rocks of the inscribed area. The great extent of recent voleanic rocks, esp. in the region E. of the Jordan, accounts for the large rela- tive proportion of some of the ingredients. , V. Climate.—Owing to the great depression below sea level, the climate is excessively warm, so that palms and other tropical trees flourish on the borders of the rivers wherever fresh water finds soil on which to spread itself. Snow never falls upon the lake, though it frequently covers the hills of Judaea and the plateau of Moab. As already ex- plained the rainfall in the Jordan valley is less than on the bordering mountains. During the winter season the Arab tribes go down to the valley with their flocks of sheep and goats and camp upon the surrounding plains. But the excessive heat of the summer, rising sometimes to 130° F., drives them back to the hills again. . OF THE Priarn). VI. Roads.—¥Except at the N. end the approaches to the Dead Sea are few and very difficult to travel. On the W. side the nearest approach is at En-gedi, and this down a winding descent of 2,000 ft. where a few men at the top of the cliff could hold an army at bay below. The path up Wady Zuweirah from the N. end of Jebel Usdum is scarcely better. Upon the 8. end the path leads up Wady Fikreh for a con- siderable distance on the W. side of the Mud Flat, and then crosses over to the Wady el-Jeib, up whose torrential bed during the dry season caravans can find their way through the Arabah to Akabah. More difficult paths lead up from the E. of the Mud Flat into the Arabah, and through the mountaims of Moab to Petra into the plains beyond and the Pil- grim route from Damascus to Mecca. From the Lisdn a difficult path leads up Wady Kerak to the fortress of the same name 20 miles distant and 5,000 ft. above the lake. Another path a little farther north leads up the Wady Beni Hamid to Ar of Moab. From the Arnon to the N. end of the Dead Sea the mountains are so precipitous that travel along the shore is now practically impossible. But there are, according to Tristram (The Land of Moab, 355), remnants of an “old and well-engineered road of ancient times’ extending as far S. at least as the Zerka Ma’ain. VII. Miscellaneous Items.—There are numerous points about the border of the lake of special inter- est. When Lot and Abraham looked 1. The down from the heights of Bethel (Gen Plain of the 13 10 ff) they are said to have beheld Jordan “all the Plain of the Jordan, that it wag well watered every where, before Jeh destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah, like the gar- den of Jeh, like the land of Egypt, as thou goest unto Zoar. So Lot chose him all the Plain of the Jordan; and Lot journeyed east: .... and Lot The word here tr? ‘Plain’ is kikka@r (Ciccar), meaning “circle,” and indicating the appearance from Bethel of the Jordan valley surrounding the N. end of the Dead Sea. From this fact, many recent writers have located Sodom and Gomorrah at that end of the sea (see Crrres But it is by no means certain that it is necessary thus to narrow down the meaning of the phrase. Though the S. end of the Dead Sea is not visible from the heights of Bethel, it is so con- nected with the general depression that it may well have been in the minds of Abraham and Lot as they were dividing the country between them, one choos- ing the plain, a part of which was visible, the other remaining on the bordering mountainous area, so dif- ferent in all its natural resources and conditions. The extent of the region chosen by Lot may there- fore be left to be determined by other considerations. Ain Jidi, “fountain of the kid” (?) (see En- GEDI) is an oasis at the base of the western cliffs about half-way between the N. and 2. Ain Jidi the 8. ends of the lake, fed by springs (En-gedi) of warm water which burst from be- neath the overhanging cliffs. The 650 ft. shore line composed of shingle and calcareous mar! is here prominent, and, as already remarked, there is an extensive gravel terrace at the present water level. Palms and vines formerly flourished here (Cant 1 14), but now only a few bushes of acacia and tamarisk are to be found. From time immemorial, however, it has been the terminus of the principal trail which zig-zags up the cliffs to the plateau, across which paths lead to Hebron and Bethlehem. The Fortress of Masada was the last stronghold held by the fanatical Jews (Zealots) after the de- struction of Jerus by the Romans, and offers a bird’s- eye view of the Dead Sea, which is as instructive as Dead Sea THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 808 it is interesting. It is situated half-way between Jebel Usdum and En-gedi, directly opposite the northern promontory of el-Lisén. Here 3. The on a precipitous height, 2,000 ft. above Fortress of the sea, is a plateau about 700 yds. Masada long, and 200 wide, adorned with ruins of dwellings, palaces and temples of the Herodian age. Standing upon this height one sees the outlines of the Rom camp, near the shore of the sea, and those of another camp in a depression several hundred yards to the W., from which the final attack of the besiegers was made over a pathway constructed along a sloping ridge. Jebel Usdum (Mount of Sodom) is a salt mountain extending 7 or 8 miles along the S.W. shore of the lake and on the W. side of the 4. Jebel Valley of Salt to its southern bound- Usdum ary. Its name is derived from the traditional belief that Sodom was lo- cated at the S. end of the sea; but, on the other hand, it is not unlikely that the name would become attached to it because of its seeming to contain the pillar of salt, which, according to the ordinary tr, marked the place where Lot’s wife was overwhelmed. The mountain rises 600 ft. above the lake, and has a general level surface except where streams have View rrom AIN Jipi, Looxina SoutH (From a drawing by W. Tipping, Esq-, 1842.) Here many miles away from their base of supplies the Romans slowly but irresistibly drew in their be- sieging lines to the final tragic consummation when the last remnant of the defenders committed suicide (BJ, VII, ix, 1). The view gives one a profound impression of the difficulties attending military cam- paigns in all that region. Upon lifting up one’s eyes to take in the broader view, he sees the Dead Sea in its whole length with the low ridge of Jebel Usdum, the Valley of Salt, the Ascent of Akrabbim, the depression of the Arabah, and Mt. Hor, to the S., while across the whole horizon to the E. is the long wall of Moab dissected by Wady Kerak and the river Arnon, leading up to the strongholds of Ker, Aroer and Dibon, of Moab; while immediately in the front are the white cliffs of el-Lisdn, and to the N., near by, the green oasis of En-gedi, and, dimmed by distance, the plains of Jericho, and the cluster of peaks surrounding Mt. Pisgah; while the sea itself sparkles like a gem of brilliant azure in the midst of its desolate surroundings, giving no token of the deadly elements which permeate its water. worn furrows and gullies in it. The eastern face presents a precipitous wall of rock salt, which, as said above, at the time of my visit (January, 1901), was washed by the waves of the lake making it im- possible to pass along its base. At other times when the water is low, travelers can pass along the whole length of the shore. This wall of salt pre- sents much the appearance of a glacier, the salt being as transparent as ice, while the action of the waves has hollowed ont extensive and picturesque caverns and left isolated towers and connected pin- nacles of salt often resembling a Gothic cathedral. These towers and pinnacles are, of course, being displaced from time to time, while others are formed to continue the illusion. Any pillar of salt known to the ancients must be entirely different from those which meet the eye of the modern traveler. It follows also as a matter of course that the gradual dissolution of this salt must partly account for the excessive salinity of the Dead Sea. It is uncertain how deep the deposit extends below the surface. It rises upward 200 or 300 ft., 809 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dead Sea where it is capped by eonsolidated strata of sedi- mentary material, consisting of sand and loam, which most geologists think was deposited at the time of the formation of the 650 ft. terrace already described, and whieh they connect with the climatie conditions of the Glacial period. This view is presented as follows by Professor B.K. Emerson: ‘'In the earlier portion of the post-glacial stadium, a final sinking of a fraction of the bottom of the trough, near the S. end of the lake, dissected the low salt platean, sinking its central parts beneath the salt waters, while fragments remain buttressed against the great walls of the trench forming the plains of Jebel Usdum and the peninsula el-Lisén with the swampy Sebkah between. .... It exposed the wonderful eastern wall of Jebel Usdum: 7 miles long, with 30-45 m. af clear 12; 2 Ch 25 11). This is in all probability the plain extending from the southern end of the Dead Sea to the “Ascent of Akrabbim” which 5. Vale of crosses the valley from side to side, Siddim and forms the southern margin of the Ghér. At present the area of the vale is about 50 sq. miles; but if our theory concerning the lower level of the Dead Sea in the time of Abra- ham is correct, it may then have included a eon- siderable portion of the lagoon S. of el-Lisén and so have been a third larger than now. In Gen 14 10 the vale is said to have been full of slime (that is, of bitumen or asphalt) pits. In modern times masses of asphalt are oceasionally found floating m the View FROM THE HeIGHts BEHIND Masapba, SHOWING THE WIDE BeEacu ON THE WESTERN SIDE oF THE Laka, AND THE TONGUE-SHAPED PENINSULA. (From a drawing by W. Tipping, Esq.) blue salt at the base, capped by 125-140 m. of gypsum- bearing marls impregnated with sulphur, and _conglom- erates at times cemented by bitumen’ (‘‘ Geological Myths,’’ Proc. Am. Assoc. for Adv. of Sci. [1896], 110, 111). If this was the case there has been a depression of the 8. end of the Dead Sea to the extent of several hundred feet within a comparatively few thousand years, in which case the traditional view that Sodom and Go- morrah were overwhelmed by Dead Sea water at the time of their destruction would refer to an occurrence exactly in line with movements that_have been prac- tically continuous during Tertiary, Glacial, and post- Glacial times. With more reason, Lartet contends that this salt is a Cretaceous or Tertiary deposit covered with late Tertiary strata, in which ease the sinking of the bloek between Jebel Usdum and el-Lisdn, for the most part, took place at a much earlier date than the formation of the 650 ft. terrace. A striking corollary of this supposition would be that the cli- matie eonditions have been practically the same during all of the post-Carboniferous times, there having been cyeles of moist and dry climate in that region succeeding each other during all these geo- logical periods. The Vale of Siddim (Gen 14 3.8.10) is probably the same as the Valley of Salt (2 K 14 7; 1 Ch 18 southern part of the Dead Sea. After the earth- quake of 1834 a large quantity was cast upon the shore near the §8.W. corner of the lake, 3 tons of which were brought to market by the Arab natives. After the earthquake of January, 1837, a mass of asphaltum was driven aground on the W. side not far from Jebel Usdum. The neighboring Arabs swam off to it, cut it up with axes and carried it to market. by the camel load, and sold it to the value of several thousand dollars. At earlier times such occur- rences seem to have been still more frequent. Jos affirms that “the sea in many places sends up black masses of asphaltum having the form and size of headless oxen”; while Diodorus Siculus relates that the bitumen (asphaltum) was thrown up in masses eovering sometimes two or three acres and having the appearance of islands (Jos, BJ, IV, viii, 4; Diod. Sic. ii.48; Pliny, NA, viil3; Tae. Hist. v.6; Dioseor., De re Med., i.99). : Since asphalt is a product of petroleum from which the volatile elements have been evaporated, the ultimate source of these masses is doubtless to be found in the extensive beds of bituminous limestone which appear in numerous places on both sides of the Dead Sea. An outcrop of it can be observed Dead Sea Death THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 810 at Neby Mousa, on the road from Jerus to Jericho, which Dawson describes as resembling dry chalk saturated with coal tar. When long weathered this becomes white and chalky at the surface, so that a mass of it, quite white externally, reveals an intense blackness when broken. It is this that the people of Bethlehem call ‘Dead Sea stone,” and which they carve into various ornamental articles and expose for sale. Some specimens of it are suffi- ciently bituminous to burn with flame like cannel- coal. These beds are still more abundant about the S. end of the lake and doubtless underlie the whole region, and for all time must have been ex- uding bituminous and gaseous matter, but much more abundantly in former times than now. : In these accumulations of bitumen at the S. end of the Ghér we probably have the incentive which led the Babylonians under Amraphel and Chedor- laomer to make such long expeditions -for the sake of conquering the region and holding it under their power. Bitumen was much in demand in Baby- lonia. El-Lisdn (the Tongue), which projects half-way across the lake from the mouth of Wady Kerak, is, like Jebel Usdum, a promontory of white calcareous 6. El-Lisan sediment containing beds of salt and gyp- . 21 sum, and breaking off on its western side in a Cliff 300 ft. high. Its upper surface rises in terraces to the 600 ft. level on the E., as Jebel Usdum does on the W. The length of the promontory from N. to S. is 9 miles. This corresponds so closely in general structure and appearance to Jebel Usdum on the opposite side of the lake that we find it difficult to doubt the theory of Professor Emerson, stated above, that the formation originally extended across and that a block of the original bottom of the lake has dropped down, leaving these remnants upon the sides. Te- quent occurrences similar to this are noted by the United States geologists in the Rocky Mountain region. VUI. History.— Difficulty of access has pre- vented the Dead Sea from playing any important part in history except as an obstruction both to commerce and to military movements. Boats have never been used upon it to any considerable extent. From earliest times salt has been gathered on its western shores and carried up to market over the difficult aths leading to Jerus. A similar commerce has bead carried on in bitumen; that from the Dead Sea being specially prized in Beypt, while as already remarked, it is te no means improbable that the its of bitumen which abounded in the “Vale of siddim’’ were the chief attraction leading the kings of Babylonia to undertake long expeditions for the conquest of the region. Productive as may have been the plain at the S. end of the sea, it was too far outside the caravan route leading through Petra to the S. end of the Arabah and the mines of the Sinaitic Peninsula to divert the course of travel. Still the settlements on the eastern border of the Vale of Siddim were of sufficient importance in mediaeval times to induce the Crusaders to visit the region and leave their marks upon it. The Arabian town of Zoghar, probably the Bib. Zoar, ap- pears at one time to have been a most important place, and was the center of considerable commer- cial activity. Indigo was grown there, and the oasis was noted for its fine species of dates. The country round about abounded in springs and there was much arable land (see Le Strange, Pal under the Moslems, 286 ff). The hot springs upon the eastern shore of the Dead Sea at Callirrhoe some distance up the Wady Zerka Ma’ain were much resorted to for their medicmal properties. Here Herod came as a last resort, to secure relief from his loathsome malady, but failed of help. The fortress of Machae- rus, where John the Baptist was imprisoned, is situated but a few miles S. of the Zerka Ma’ain, but access to this region is possible only through a difficult road leading over the mountains a few miles E. of the sea. On four occasions important military expeditions were conducted along the narrow defiles_which border the 8.W. end of the Dead Sea: (1) That of Amraphel and his confederates from Babylonia, who seem first to have opened the way past Petra to the mines of the Sinaitic Peninsula, and then to have swept northward through the land of the Amalekites and Amorites and come down to the Dead Sea at Hn-gedi, and then to have turned to subdue the Cities of the Plain, where Lot was dwelling. This accomplished, they probably re- treated along the west shore of the lake, which very likely: afforded at that time a complete passage- way to the valley of the Jordan. Or they may have gone on eastward to the line of the present pilgrim route from Damascus to Mecca and followed it northward. (2) In the early part of the reign of Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 20), the Moabites, Ammonites and some other tribes joined together, forming a large army, and, following around the S. end of the Dead Sea, marched along the W. shore to En-gedi, and having ascended the zigzag path leading up the precipitous heights to the wilderness of Tekoa, were there thrown into confusion and utterly anni- hilated. (3) Not many years later Jehoram and Jehoshaphat “fetched a compass [RV ‘“‘made a circuit”’] of seven days’ journey” (2 K 3 9) around the S. end of the Dead Sea and attacked the Moab- ites in their own country, but returned without completing the conquest. The particulars of this expedition are given in 2 K 3 and in the inscription on the Moabite Stone. (4) The Romans shortly after the destruction of Jerus conducted a long siege of the fortress of Masada, of which an account has already been given in a previous section (VII, 3). All their supplies must have come down the tor- tuous path to Hn-gedi and thence been brought along the western shore to the camp, the remains of which are still to be seen at the base of the fortress. For many cents., indeed for well-nigh 1,800 years, the Dead Sea remained a mystery, and its geology and physical characteristics were practically un- known. The first intimation of the depression of the lake below sea level was furnished in 1837 by Moore and Beke, who made some imperfect experi- ments with boiling water from which they inferred a depression of 500 ft. In 1841 Lieutenant Sim- mons of the British navy, by trigonometrical ob- servations, estimated the depression to be 1,312 ft. In 1835 Costigan, and again in 1847 Lieutenant Molyneux ventured upon the sea in boats; but the early death of both, consequent upon their ex- posures, prevented their making any full reports. Appropriately, however, their names have been at- tached to prominent points on the Lisdn. In 1848 Lieutenant Lynch, of the United States navy, was dispatched to explore the Jordan and the’ Dead Sea. The results of this expedition were most im- portant. Soundings of the depths were carefully and systematically conducted, and levels were run from the Dead Sea by Jerus to the Mediterranean, giving the depression at the surface of the Dead Sea as 1,316.7 ft., and its greatest depth 1,278 ft. More recently Sir C. W. Wilson in connection with the Ordinance Survey of Pal carried levels over the same route with the result of reducing the depression to 1,292 ft., which is now generally accepted to be correct. But as already stated the stage of water in the lake is not given, and that is known to vary at least 15 ft. annually, and still more at longer intervals. Lirerature.—Hull, Mou i nai Pal, 1889; Huntington, Pal ate Frid rae LH a Lartet, Voyage d'exploration dela Mer Morte, 1880; Lynch, Report of U.S. Expedition to the Jordan and Dead Sea, 1852; Robinson, BR, 1841; De Saulcy, Vo d i Syrie, 1853; Tristram, Land of Israel, 3d ed A872, The 811 Land of Moab, 1873; G. A. Smith, HGHL; Wright, Scientific Confirmations of OT Hist, 1906, and Journal of Bib. Lit., 1911. Grorce FrEepERicK WricHt DEAD, STATE OF THE. See Hanes. DEAF, def (WN, harésh; kodss, kaphds): Used either in the physical sense, or figuratively as ex- pressing unwillingness to hear the Divine message (Ps 68 4), or incapacity to understand it for want of spirituality (Ps 38 13). The prophetic utter- ances were sufficiently forcible to compel even such to hear (Isa 42 18; 43 8) and thereby to receive the Divine mercy (Isa 29 18; 36 5). The expression “deaf adder that stoppeth her ear” (Ps 68 4) alludes to a curious notion that the adder, to avoid hearing the voice of the charmer, laid its head with one ear on the ground and stopped the other with the tip of its tail (Diary of John Manninghan, 1602). The adder is called deaf by Shakespeare (2 Hen VI, iii, 2, 76; Troilus and Cres- sida, ti, 2, 172). The erroneous idea probably arose from the absence of external ears. Physical deafness was regarded as a judgment from God (Ex 4 11; Mic 7 16), and it was conse- quently impious to curse the deaf (Lev 19 14). In NT times deafness and kindred defects were attrib- uted to evil spirits (Mk 9 18 ff). See Dump. ALEx. MACcALIsTER DEAL, dé: The noun “deal” is not found in RV. The AV tr of JINZY, ‘issdrén, ‘the tenth deal’ (Ex 29 40; Lev 14 10, et al.) is rendered uniformly “the tenth part”? in RV (see WEicHTs anp Meras- uRES). The vb. “to deal” often means ‘‘to appor- OT, viz. Jer 31 20. RV correctly changes “dear Son” of AV (Col 1 18) into “the Sou of his love.” H. E. Jacozs DEARTH, dirth. See Faminz. DEATH (MA, maweth; @dvaros, thdnaios): PHYSIOLOGICAL AND FIGURATIVE VIEW The word ‘‘Death” is used in the sense of (1) the process of dying (Gen 21 16); (2) the period of de- cease (Gen 27 7); (3) as a possible synonym for poison (2 K 4 40); (4) as descriptive of person in danger of perishing (Jgs 16 18; “in deaths oft” 2, Cor 11 23). In this sense the shadow of death is a familiar expression in Job, the Psalms and the Prophets; (5) death is personified in 1 Cor 18 55 and Rev 20 14. Deliverance from this catastrophe is called the “issues from death” (Ps 68 20 AV; tr@ “escape” in RV). Judicial execution, “putting to death,” is mentioned 39 times in the Levitical Law. Figuratively: Death is the loss of spiritual life as THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA ee, Aa Sa ne ee ee ee a ae Dead Sea Death in Rom 8 6; and the final state of the unregener- ate is called the “second death” in Rev 20 14. ALEX. MAcALIsTER THEOLOGICAL VIEW _ According to Gen 2 17, God gave to man, created in His own image, the command not to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, and 1. Concep- added thereto the warning, “in the day tion of Sin that thou eatest thereof, thou shalt and Death surely die.” Though not exclusively, reference is certainly made here in the first place to bodily death. Yet because death by no Means came upon Adam and Eve on the day of their transgression, but took place hundreds of years later, the expression, “in the day that,” must be conceived in a wider sense, or the delay of death must be attributed to the entering-in of mercy (Gen 3 15). However this may be, Gen 2 17 places a close connection between man’s death and his trans- gression of God’s commandment, thereby attaching to death a religious and ethical significance, and on the other hand makes the life of man dependent on his obedience to God. This religious-ethical nature of life and death is not only decidedly and clearly expressed in Gen 2, but it is the fundamental thought of the whole of Scripture and forms an essential element in the revelations of salvation. The theologians of early and more recent times, who have denied the spiritual significance of death and have separated the connection between ethical and physical life, usually endeavor to trace back their - opinions to Scripture; and those passages which un- doubtedly see in death a punishment for sin (Gen 217; Jn 8 44; Rom 6 12; 6 23; 1 Cor 16 21), they take as individual opinions, which form no part of the organism of revelation. But this en- deavor shuts out the organic character of the reve- lation of salvation. It is true that death in Holy Scripture is often measured by the weakness and frailty of human nature (Gen 3 19; Job 14 1.12; Ps 39 5.6; 90 5; 103 14.15; Eccl 3 20, etc). Death is seldom connected with the transgression of the first man either in the OT or the NT, or mentioned as a specified punishment for sin (Jn 8 44; Rom 6 12; 6 23; 1 Cor 16 21; Jas 1 15); for the most part it is portrayed as something natural (Gen 6 5; 9 29; 15 15; 26 8, etc), a long life being presented as a blessing in contrast to death in the midst of days as a disaster and a judgment (Ps 102 23f; Isa 66 20). But all this is not contrary to the idea that death is a consequence of, and a punishment for, sin. Daily, everyone who agrees with Scripture that death is held out as a punishment for sin, speaks in the same way. Death, though come into the world through sin, is nevertheless at the same time a consequence of man’s physical and frail existence now; it could therefore be threatened as a punishment to man, because he was taken out of the ground and was made a living soul, of the earth earthy (Gen 2 7; 1 Cor 15 45.47). If he had remained obedient, he would not have returned to dust (Gen 3 19), but have pressed forward on the path of spiritual devel- opment (1 Cor 15 46.51); his return to dust was possible simply because he was made from dust (see ADAM IN THE NT). Thus, although death is in this way a consequence of sin, yet a long life is felt to be a blessing and death a disaster and a judg- ment, above all when man is taken away in the bloom of his youth or the strength of his years. There is nothing strange, therefore, in the manner in which Scripture speaks about death; we all ex- press ourselves daily in the same way, though we at the same time consider it as the wages of sin. Beneath the ordinary, everyday expressions about death lies the deep consciousness that it is unnatural and contrary to our innermost being. Death Deborah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 812 This is decidedly expressed in Scripture, much more so even than among ourselves. For we are influenced always more or less by the 2. The Greek, Platonic idea, that the body Meaning — dies, yet the soul isimmortal. Such au of Death idea is utterly contrary to the Israelite consciousness, and is nowhere found in the OT. The whole man dies, when in death the spirit (Ps 146 4; Eccl 12 7), or soul (Gen 35 18; 2819; 1K 17 21; Jon 4 3), goes out of a man. Not only his body, but his soul also returns to a state of death and belongs to the nether-world; therefore the OT can speak of a death of one’s soul (Gen 87 21 [Heb]; Nu 28 10m; Dt 22 21; Jgs 16 30; Job 36 14; Ps 78 50), and of defilement by coming in contact with a dead body (Lev 19 28; 21 11; 22 4; Nu 5 2;66; 96; 19 10 ff; Dt 14 1; Hag 2 13). This death of man is not annihila- tion, however, but a deprivation of all that makes for life on earth. The Sheol (sh’6l) is in contrast with the land of the living in every respect (Job 28 13; Prov 15 24; Ezk 26 20; 32 23); itisan abode of darkness and the shadow of death (Job 10 21. 22; Ps 88 12; 143 3), a place of destruction, yca destruction itself (Job 26 6; 28 22; 3112; Ps 88 11; Prov 27 20), without any order (Job 10 22), a land of rest, of silence, of oblivion (Job 3 13.17.18; Ps 94 17; 115 17), where God and man are no longer to be seen (Isa 38 11), God no longer praised or thanked (Ps 6 5; 115 17), His perfec- tions no more acknowledged (Ps 88 10-13; Isa 38 18.19), His wonders not contemplated (Ps 88 12), where the dead are unconscious, do no more work, take no account of anything, possess no knowledge nor wisdom, neither have any more a portion in anything that is done under the sun (Eccl 9 5.6.10). The dead (‘‘the Shades’ RVm; ef art. DecEasep) are asleep (Job 26 5; Prov 2.18; 918; 21 6; Ps 88 11; Isa 14 9), weakened (Isa 14 10) and without strength (Ps 88 4). The dread of death was felt much more deeply therefore by the Israelites than by ourselves. Death to them was separation from 3. Light all that they loved, from God, from in the His service, from His law, from His Darkness people, from His land, from all the rich companionship in which they lived. But now in this darkness appears the light of the revelation of salvation from on high. The God of Israel is the living God and the fountain of all life (Dt 6 26; Josh 310; Ps 369). He is the Creator of heaven and earth, whose power knows no bounds and whose dominion extends over life and death (Dt 32 39; 1826; Ps 90 3). He gave life to man (Gen 1 26; 2 7), and creates and sus- tains every man still (Job 32 8; 33 4; 34 14; Ps 104 29; Eccl 12 7). He connects life with the keeping of His law and appoints death for the trans- gression of it (Gen 2.17; Lev 18 5; Dt 30 20; 32 47). He lives in heaven, but is present also by His spirit in Sheol (Ps 139 7.8). Sheol and Abaddon are open to Him even as the hearts of the children of men (Job 26 6; 3817; Prov 16 11). He kills and makes alive, brings down into Sheol and raises from thence again (Dt 32 89; 1826; 2K 5 7). He lengthens life for those who keep His commandments (Ex 20 12; Job 5 26), gives escape from death, can deliver when death menaces (Ps 68 20; Isa 38 5; Jer 15 20; Dnl 3 26), can take Enoch and Elijah to Himself without dying (Gen 5 24; 2 K 2 11), can restore the dead to life (1 K 17 22; 2 K 4 34; 13 21). He can even bring death wholly to nothing and completcly triumph over its power by rising from the dead (Job 14 13-15; 19 25-27; Hos 6 2; 13 14; Isa 26 8; 26 19; Ezk 37 11.12; Dnl 12 2). This revelation by degrees rejects the old con- trast between life on earth and the disconsolate existence after death, in the dark place of Sheol, and puts another inits place. The physical 4. Spiritual contrast between life and death gradu- Significance ally makes way for the moral and spirit- ual difference between a life spent in the fear of the Lord, and a life in the service of sin. The man who serves God is alive (Gen 2 17); lifeis involved in the keeping of His commandments (Lev 18 5; Dt 30 20); His word is life (Dt 8 3; 32 47). Life is still for the most part understood to mean length of days (Prov 2 18; 3 16; 10 30; Isa 65 20). Nevertheless it is remarkable that Prov often mentions death and Sheol in connection with the godless (2 18; 5 5; 7 27; 9 18), and on the other hand only speaks of life in connection with the right- eous. Wisdom, righteousness, the fear of the Lord is the way of life (8 35.36; 11 19; 12 28; 13 14; 14 27; 19 23). The wicked is driven away in his wickedness, but the righteous hath hope in his death (14 32). Blessed is he who has the Lord for his God (Dt 33 29; Ps 1 1.2; 2 12; 32 1.2; 33 12; 34 9, etc); he is comforted in the greatest adver- sity (Ps 73 25-28; Hab 3 17-19), and sees a light arise for him behind physical death (Gen 49 18; Job 14 13-15; 16 16-21; 19 25-27; Ps 78 23- 26). The godless on the contrary, although enjoy- ing for a time much prosperity, perish and come to an of (Ps 1 4-6; 73 18-20; Isa 48 22; Mal 4 3, etc). The righteous of the OT truly are continually occupied with the problem that the lot of man on earth often corresponds so little to his spiritual worth, but he strengthens himself with the con- viction that for the righteous it will be well, and for the wicked, ill] (Eecl 8 12.18; Isa 3 10.11). If they do not realize it in the present, they look for- ward to the future and hope for the day in which God’s justice will extend salvation to the righteous, and His anger will be visited on the wicked in judg- ment. So in the OT the revelation of the new covenant is prepared wherein Christ by His appear- ance hath abolished death and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel (2 Tim 110). See AsonisH. This everlasting life is already here on earth presented to man by faith, and it is his portion also in the hour of death (Jn 3 86; 11 25.26). On the other hand, he who lives in sin and is disobedient to the Son of God, is in his living dead (Mt 8 22; Lk 15 32; Jn 3 36; 8 24: Eph 2 1; Col 2 13); he shall never see life, but shal] pass by bodily death into the second death (Rev 2 11; 20 6.14; 21 8). This view of Scripture upon death goes much deeper than that which is found in other religions, but it nevertheless receives support 5. Death in from the unanimous witness of humani- Non-Chris- ty with regard to its unnaturalness tian Reli- and dread. The so-called nature- gionsandin peoples even feel that death is much Science more of an enigma than life; Tiele (Inleiding tot de goddienst-artenschap, II [1900], 202, referring to Andrew Lang, Modern My- thology, ch xiii) says rightly, that all peoples have the conviction that man by nature is immortal, that immortality wants no proof, but that death is a mystery and must be explained. Touching com- plaints arise in the hearts of all men on the frailty and vanity of life, and the whole of mankind fears death as a mysterious power. Man finds comfort in death only when he hopes it will be an end toa still more miserable life. Seneca may be taken as interpreter of some philosophers when he says: Stultitia est timore mortis mori (“It is stupid to die through the fear of death’’) and some may be able, like a Socrates or a Cato, to face death calmly and courageously; what have these few to say to the 818 millions, who through fear of death are all their life- time subject to bondage (He 2 15)? Such a mys- tery has death remained up to the present day. It may be said with Kassowitz, Verworm and others that the “cell” is the beginning, and the old, gray man is the natural end of an uninterrupted life- development, or with Metschnikoff, that science will one day so lengthen life that it will fade away like a rose at last and death lose all its dread; death still is no less a riddle, and one which swallows up all the strength of life. When one considers, be- sides, that a number of creatures, plants, trees, ani- mals, reach a much higher age than man; that the larger half of mankind dies before or shortly after birth; that another large percentage dies in the bloom of youth or in the prime of life; that the law of the survival of the fittest is true only when the fact of the survival is taken as a proof of their fit- ness; that the graybeards, who, spent and decrepit, go down to the grave, form a very small number; then the enigma of death increases more and more in mysteriousness. The endeavors to bring death into connection with certain activities of the organ- ism and to explain it by increasing weight, by growth or by fertility, have all led to shipwreck. When Weismann took refuge in the immortality of the “einzellige Protozoén,” he raised a hypothesis which not only found many opponents, but which also left mortality of the “Kérperplasma” an insoluble mystery (Beth, ‘Ueber Ursache und Zweck des Todes, Glauben und Wissen [1909], 285-304, 335- 48). Thus science certainly does not compel us to review Scripture on this point, but rather fur- nishes a strong proof of the mysterious majesty of death. When Pelagius, Socinus, Schleiermacher, Ritschl and a number of other theologians and phi- losophers separate death from its connection with sin, they are not compelled to do so by science, but are led by a defective insight into the relation be- tween éthos and phisis. Misery and death are not absolutely always consequences and punishment of a great personal transgression (Lk 13 2; Jn 9 3); but that they are connected with sin, we learn from the experience of every day. Who can number the victims of mammonism, alcoholism and licentious- ness? Even spiritual sins exercise their influence on corporal life; envy is a rottenness of the bones (Prov 14 30). This connection is taught us in a great measure by Scripture, when it placed the not yet fallen man in a Paradise, where death had not yet entered, and eternal life was not yet possessed and enjoyed; when it sends fallen man, who, how- ever, is destined for redemption, into a world full of misery and death; and at last assigns to the wholly renewed man a new heaven and a new earth, where death, sorrow, crying or pain shall no longer exist (Rev 21 4). Finally, Scripture is not the book of death, but of life, of everlasting life through Jesus Christ Our Lord. It tells us, in oft-repeated and unmistakable terms, of the dreaded reality of death, but it pro- claims to us still more loudly the wonderful power of the life which is in Christ Jesus. See also Dr- CEASE. HERMAN Bavinck DEATH, BODY OF. Sce Bopy or Dzata. DEATH, SECOND (6 Setrepos Odvaros, ho deti- teros thdnatos): An expression, peculiar to the Book of Rev (2 11; 20 6.14; 21 8) in Scripture, denoting the final penalty of the unrighteous; parallel with another expression likewise peculiar, “the lake of fire,”’ in 20 14; 21 8. See Escuaronocy or THE NT. DEBATE, dé-bit’: This word is used only once in RV (Prov 25 9). It evidently refers to the set- tling of a difficulty with a neighbor, and anticipates THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Death Deborah Mt 18 15. It argues for and shows the advantage of private, peaceable settlement of difficulties. Cf Ecclus 28 9, and see MAKEBATES. DEBIR, dé’bér (WA, dbhir, or WAI, dbhir, “oracle”): King of Eglon, one of the five Amorite kings whose confederation against Israel was over- come and who were killed by Joshua (Josh 10 3). DEBIR, dé’bér (2, dbhir; AaPelp, Dabeir): “And Joshua returned, and all Israel with him, to Debir, and fought against it: and he took it, and the king thereof, and all the cities thereof; and they smote them with the edge of the sword... . he left none remaining” (Josh 10 38.39). In Josh 15 15-17 and Jgs 1 11-13 is an account of how Othniel captured Debir, which ‘“‘beforetime was Kiriath- sepher,” and won thereby the hand of Achsah, Ca- Jeb’s daughter. In Josh 15 49 Debir is called Kiriath-sannah. It had once been inhabited by the Anakim (Josh 11 21). It was a Levitical city (Josh 21 15; 1 Ch 6 58). (1) Debir is usually accepted as meaning “back,” but this is doubtful; the word d*bhir is used to de- note the “holy of holies” (1 K 6 5). 1. The According to Sayce (HDB), “the city Meaning of must have been a sacred one with a the Name well-known temple.” Kiriath-sepher is trd “town of books,” and Sayce and others consider that in all probability there was a great storehouse of clay tablets here; perhaps the name may have been kiryath sdpher, “town of scribes.” Kiriath-sannah (Josh 15 49) is prob- ably a corruption of Kiriath-sepher; the LXX has here as in references to the latter réAcs ypappdrwr, polis grammdion, “town of books.” Unfortunately this site, important even if the speculations about the books are doubtful, is still a matter of uncertainty. Hdh-Dhd- 2. The Site heriyeh, some 11 miles 8.W. of Hebron, has a good deal of support. It was unquestionably a site of importance in ancient times as the meeting-place of several roads; it is in the Negeb (cf Jgs 1 15), in the neighborhood of the probable site of Anab (Josh 11 21; 15 50); it is a dry site, but there are “upper” and “lower”’ springs about 6% miles to the N. A more thorough exam- ination of the site than has as yet been undertaken might produce added proofs in favor of this identi- fication. No other suggestion has any great prob- ability. See PEF, Ill, 402; PHFS, 1875. (2) Debir, on the border between Judah and Ben- jamin (Jash 15 7), must have been somewhere E. of Jerus not far from the modern Jericho road. Thogh- gret ed Debr, ‘‘the pass of the rear,” half a mile 8.W.. of the Tal‘at ed Dumm (see Apummin), close to the so-called, ‘Inn of the Good Samaritan,” may be an echo of the name which has lingered in the neigh- borhood. Many authorities consider that there is no place-name in this reference at all, the text being corrupt. (3) Debir RVm, Lidebir (Josh 18 26), a town on the border of Gad, near Mahanaim; Ibdar, 8. of the Yarmuk has been suggested. May be identical with Lo-debar (2 8 9 4). E. W. G. Masterman DEBORAH, deb’é-ra (M7131, d*bhdrah, signify- ing “‘bee’?): (1) Rebekah’s nurse, who died near Bethel and a buried under “the oak of weeping” (Gen 35 m). (2) A prophetess, fourth in the order of the ‘“udges.” In aftertimes a palm tree, known as the “palm tree of Deborah,” was shown between Ramah and Bethel, beneath which the prophetess was wont to administer justice. Like the rest of the “judges” she became a leader of her people in Debt, Debtor Deceit ti This time the oppressor imes of national distress. was Jabin, king of Hazor, whose general was Sisera. Deborah summoned Barak of Kedesh-naphtali and delivered to him the Divine message to meet Sisera in battle by the brook Kishon. Barak induced Deborah to accompany him; they were joined by 10,000 men of Zebulun and Naphtali. The battle took place by the brook Kishon, and Sisera’s army was thoroughly routed. While Barak pursued the fleeing army, Sisera escaped and sought refuge with Jael the wife of Heber the Kenite, near Kedesh. The brave woman, the prototype of Judith, put the Canaanite general to sleep by offering him a draft of milk sen then slew him by driving a peg into his temple. Thus runs the story in Jgs.4. It is on the whole substantiated by the ode in ch 5 which is ascribed jointly to Deborah and Barak. It is possible that the editor mistook the archaic form TP, kami2, in ver 7 which should be rendered “thou arosedst” instead of “I arose.’? Certainly the ode was composed by a person who, if not a contem- porary of the event, was very near it in point of time. The song is spoken of as one of the oldest. pieces of Heb lit. Great difficulties meet the exegete. Never- theless the general substance is clear. The Lord is described as having come from Sinai near the “field of Edom” to take part in the battle; ‘for from heaven they fought, the very stars from their courses fought against Sisera’ (ver 20). The nation was in a sad plight, oppressed by a mighty king, and the tribes loth to submerge their separatist tendencies. Some, like Reuben, Gilead, Dan and Asher re- mained away. A community by the name of Meroz is singled out for blame, ‘because they came not to the help of Jeh, to the help of Jeh among the mighty’ (ver 23; cf RVm). Ephraim, Issachar, Machir, Benjamin were among the followers of Barak; “Zebulun . . . . jeoparded their lives unto the death, and Naphtali, upon the high places of the field” (ver 18). According to the song, the batitle was fought at Taanach by the waters of Megiddo; Sisera’s host was swept away by “that ancient river, the river Kishon” (ver 21). Jael, the wife of Heber the Kenite, receives here due meed of praise for her heroic act. The paean vividly paints the waiting of Sisera’s mother for the home-coming of the gen- eral; the delay is ascribed to the great booty which the conqueror is distributing among his Canaanite host. ‘‘So let all thine enemies perish,’ concludes the song; “O Jeh: but let them that love him be as the sun when he goeth forth in his might.” It is a song in praise of the “righteous acts” of the Lord, His work of victory which Israel’s leaders, ‘the long-haired princes,’ wrought, giving their lives freely to the nation’s cause. And the nation was sore bestead because it had become faithless to the Lord and chosen new gods. Out of the conflict came, for the time being, victory and moral purifica- tion; and the inspiring genius of it all was a woman in Israel, the prophetess Deborah. (8) Tobit’s grandmother (AV ‘“Debora,’’ Tob 1 8). Max L. Marcouis DEBT, det, DEBTOR, det’ér: It is difficult now- adays to think of debt without associating with it the idea of interest, and even usury. Certain it is that this idea is associated with the OT idea of the word, at least in the later period of OT history. This is true of the NT entire. The Heb word ("0?, nsht) always carries with it the idea of “biting interest” (cf 2K 47). The Gr words ddveor, ddneion (Mt 18 27), and épedry, opheilé (Mt 18 32), may point only to the fact of indebtedness; the idea of interest, however, is clearly taught in the NT (cf Mt 25 27). Quite extensive legislation is provided in the OT governing the matter of debt and debtors. Indebt- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 814 edness and loaning had not, however, the commer- cial aspect among the Jews so characteristic of the nations surrounding Pal. Indeed the Mosaic leg- islation was seemingly intended to guard against just. such commercialism. It was looked upon as a misfortune to be in debt; it indicated poverty brought on probably by blighted harvests; conse- quently those in debt were to be looked upon with pity and dealt with in leniency. There must be no oppression of the poor under such circumstances (Ex 22 25; Dt 28 19.20; Ezk 18 18). Even where a pledge is given and received, certain restrictions are thrown around it, e.g. the creditor must not take a mill, nor a necessary garment, nor a widow’s ox, etc, in pledge (Ex 22 25-27; Dt 24 6.10-13; Job ; Am 2 8). And further, the pledge is to be restored in some instances “‘before the sun goeth down” (Ex 22 26.27), and in all cases full redemp- tion in the seventh and jubilee years (Neh 10 31, etc). The Jews were strictly exhorted to take no interest at all from their own nation (Ex 22 25; Dt 23 19.20). Strangers, however, might be charged interest (ibid). A devout Jew would not lend money to another Jew on interest. It would seem that as Israel came into contact with the surrounding nations, debt became increas- ingly a commercial matter. The Mosaic laws re- garding clemency toward the poor who were com- pelled for the time being to become debtors were utterly disregarded, and the poor were oppressed by the rich. An illustration of the severity with which debtors came to be dealt with is to be found in 2 K 4 1-7, in which, because of the inability of a widow to pay asmall debt contracted by her dead husband, the woman complains to the prophet that the creditors have come to sell her two children in order that the debt might be paid. Strangely the prophet, while helping the widow by miraculously multiplying the oil in order that the debt might be paid, says nothing by way of condemnation of such conduct on the part of the creditors. Are we to understand by this that commercialism had already so powerful a grip upon Israel that even to a prophet the practice had come to seem proper, or at least expected? The debtor himself or his family might be sold for debt, or the debtor might become a slave for a certain length of time until the debt was paid (Lev 25 39.47; Isa 50 1). So oppressive had the commercial system in Israel become that the debtor cursed the creditor and the creditor the debtor (Jer 15 10). Sometimes debtors were outlawed, asin the case of the men who came to David in the cave of Adullam (1 8 22 2). That the matter of borrow- ing and lending had assumed very grievous propor- tions is evident from the very sharp warnings con- cerning the matter in the Book of Prov (6 1; 11 15; 20 16, etc). The teaching of the NT on this subject is con- fined very largely to the parables of Our Lord. Some think that the expression, “Owe no man anything” (Rom 18 8), is an absolute warning against indebt- edness. Quite a noticeable advance in the matter of debts and debtors is noticed as we enter the time ofthe NT. Weread of bankers, exchangers, money- changers, interest, investments, usury (Mt 25 16— 27; Jn 2 13-17). The taking of interest does not seem to be explicitly condemned in the NT. The person of the debtor, as well as his family and lands, could be seized for non-payment of debt (Mt 18 21-26). Indeed, the debtor was often east into prison and tormented because of non-payment (Mt 18 30.34). That compassion and leniency should be exercised toward those in debt is the clear teach- ing of Christ in the parables of the Unmerciful Serv- ny a 18 23-35) and the Two Debtors (Lk 7 Figurative: Debt and debtor are used in a moral 815 sense also as indicating the obligation of a righteous life which we owe to God. To fall short in righteous living is to become a debtor. For this reason we pray, “Forgive us our debts’ (Mt 6 12). Those who are ministered to in spiritual things are said to be debtors to those who minister to them (Rom 15 27). Tomake a vow to God is to put one’s self in debt in a moral sense (Mt 23 16-18; RVm “bound by his oath’’). In a deeply spiritual sense the apostle Paul professed to be in debt to all men in that he Hes them the opportunity to do them good (Rom The parables of Jesus as above named are rich with comforting truth. How beautiful is the will- ingness of God, the great and Divine Creditor, to release us from our indebtedness! Just so ought we to be imitators of the Father in heaven who is merciful. Wiuuiam Evans DECALOGUE, dek’a-log. See Ten Commann- MENTS. ; DECAPOLIS, dé-kap’é-lis (Aexdodts, Deka polis): The name given to the region occupied by a league of ‘‘ten cities’ (Mt 4 25; Mk 6 20; 7 31), which Eusebius defines (Onom) as “lying in the Peraea, round Hippos, Pella and Gadara.”’ Such combina- tions of Gr cities arose as Rome assumed dominion in the East, to promote their common interests in trade and commerce, and for mutual protection against the peoples surrounding them. ‘This par- ticular league seems to have been constituted about the time of Pompey’s campaign in Syria, 65 BC, by which several cities in Decapolis dated their eras. They were independent of the local tetrarchy, and answerable directly to the governor of Syria. They enjoyed the rights of association and asylum; they struck their own coinage, paid imperial taxes and were liable to military service (Ant, XIV, iv, 4; BJ, I, vii, 7; IL, xviii, 3; III, ix, 7; Vita, 65, 74). Of the ten cities, Scythopolis, the ancient Bethshean, alone, the capital of the league, was on the W. side of Jordan. The names given by Pliny (NZ, v.18) are Scythopolis (Beisdn), Hippos (Sustyeh), Ga- dara (Umm Keis), Pella (Fahil), Philadelphia (‘Ammdn), Gerasa (Jerash), Dion (Adtin?), Ca- natha (Kanawdt), Damascus and Raphana. The last named is not identified, and Dion is uncertain. Other cities joined the league, and Ptolemy, who omits Raphana, gives a list of 18. The Gr inhabi- tants were never on good terms with the Jews; and the herd of swine (Mk 6 11 ff) indicates contempt for what was probably regarded as Jewish prejudice. The ruins still ween at Gadara, but esp. at Kanawdat (see KenatH) and Jerash, of temples, theaters and other public buildings, attest the splendor of these cities in their day. W. Ewina DECAY, dé-ka’: Although this wofd is still in good use in both its lit. sense, of the putrefaction of either animal or vegetable matter, and its de- rived sense, denoting any deterioration, decline or gradual failure, the RV has replaced it by other expressions in Lev 25 35; Eccl 10 18; Isa 44 26; He 8 13; in some of these cases with a gain in ac- curacy of tr. In Neh 4 10 (YD, kashal, “to_be feeble,” stumble”) RV retains “‘isdecayed”; m Job 14 11 (AQ, harébh, “‘to be dried up”) ARV substi- tutes “wasteth,” and in Jn 11 39 ARV has ‘‘the body decayeth” instead of the more literal tr offen- sive to modern ears (fe, dzet, “emits a smell’’). F. K. Farr DECEASE, dé-sés’, IN OT AND APOC (827, raphd’, pl. r°ph@im, “ghosts,” “shades,” is tr? by “dead,” “dead body,” and “deceased” in both AV and RV): The word seems to mean “‘soft,” “inert,” THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Debt, Debtor Deceit but its etymology is uncertain (see RepHAim). The various writers of the OT present, as is to be ex- pected on such a subject, different conceptions of the condition of the deceased. In the beginning prob- ably a vague idea of the continuation of existence was held, without the activities (isa 59 10) and the joys of the present life (Ps 49 17). They dwell in the ‘land of forgetfulness” (Job 14 21; Ps 88 5; cf Isa 26 14), they ‘‘tremble” of cold (Job 26 5), they totter and “stumble at noonday as in the twi- light” (Isa 59 10), their voice is described as low and muttering or chirping (Isa 8 19; 29 4), which may refer to the peculiar pitch of the voice of the spirit medium when a spirit speaks through him. (The calling up of the dead, which was strictly for- bidden to Israel [Lev 19 31; 20 27] is referred to in 1 § 28 13 and perhaps in Isa 14 9.) The de- ceased are separated from their friends; love and hatred have both ceased with them (Eccl 9 5.6); “There is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in Sheol’ (Eccl 9 10). The deceased are unable to praise Jeh (Ps 6 5; 88 10-12; Isa 38 18; Bar 217; Sir 17 27.28). Nor does there seem to have been at first an anticipation of reward or punishment after death (Ps 88 10; Sir 41 4), probably because the shades were supposed to be jacking the organs by which either reward or pun- ishment could be perceived; nevertheless they are still in the realm of God’s power (1 S 2 6; Ps 86 13; 189 8; Prov 15 11; Isa 7 11; Hos 13 14; Am 9 2; Tob 13 2). Gradually the possibility of a return of the de- parted was conceived (Gen 5 24; 2 K 13 21; Ps 49 15; 73 24; 86 13; Hos 13 14; Wisd 3 1-7; 4 13.14; 6 18.19; 10 14). Even here it is often more the idea of the immortality of the soul than that of the resurrection of the body, and some of these passages may be interpreted as allegorical expressions for a temporal rescue from great disas- ter (e.g. 1 8S 2 6); nevertheless this interpretation presupposes the existence of a deliverance from the shadows of Sheol to a better life in the presence of Jeh. Some passages refer clearly to such an escape at the end of the age (Dnl 12 2; Isa 26 19). Only very few of the OT believers reached the sublime faith of Job (19 25.26) and none the blessed expec- tation taught in the NT, for none but Christ has “brought life and immortality to light”? (2 Tim 1 10; Jn 5 28.29). ; The opinion that the dead or at least the newly buried could pattake of the food which was placed in graves, a custom which recent excavations have clearly shown to have been almost universal in Pal, and which is referred to in Dt 26 14 and Tob 4 17, was soon doubted (Sir 30 18), and food and drink prepared for the funeral was henceforth intended as the “bread of comfort” and the “cup of consola- tion” for the mourners (Jer 16 7; 28 3 35; Ezk 24 17). Similarly the offering and burning of in- cense, originally an homage to the deceased, became a relief for the mourner (2 Ch 16 14; 21 19; Jer 34 5). See also Wisd 3 2; 7 6; Sir 38 23, and arts. on Corpse; Dreatu; Hanes; SHEOL. H. L. E. Lurrine DECEASE, dé-sés’, IN NT (redcurdw, telewtdo, “to come to an end,” “married and deceased” [Mt 22 25]): With @avdry, thandio, “death,” “die the death” (Mt 15 4; Mk 7 10, RVm “surely die’). Elsewhere the word is tr‘ ‘die’ (Mt 2 19; 9 18; Mk 9 48 and often; He 11 22, RV “end wasnigh”). Also the subst., @£0d0s, éxedos, “exodus,” “exit,” “departure,” “his decease which he was about to accomplish” (Lk 9 31, RVm ‘‘departure”’); “after my decease” (2 Pet 1 15, RVm ‘‘departure’’). DECEIT, dé-sét’ (WAND, mirmah; 8édos, délos): The intentional misleading or beguiling of another; Deceivableness Deer THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 816 in Scripture represented as a companion of many other forms of wickedness, as cursing (Ps 10 7), hatred (Prov 26 24), theft, covetousness, adultery, murder (Mk 7 22; Rom 1 29). The RV intro- duces the word in Prov 14 25; 2 Thess 2 10; but in such passages as Ps 65 11; Prov 20 17; 26 26; 1 Thess 2 3, renders a variety of words, more ac- curately than the AV, by “oppression,” “falsehood,” “guile,” “error.” DECEIVABLENESS, = dé-sév’a-b’I-nes, DE- CEIVE, dé-sév’ (NW), nasha’, “to lead astray’’): “The pride of thy heart hath deceived thee” (Jer 49 16), i.e. “Thy stern mountain fastnesses have per- suaded thee that thou art impregnable.” In Jer 20 7, ‘“O Lord, thou hast deceived me, and I was deceived,” MDB, paihah, signifies ‘to be enticed,” “persuaded,” as in ARV and RVm. In the OT most often, and in the NT regularly, the various words rendered in AV “deceive” denote some deliberate misleading in the moral or spiritual realm. False prophets (Jer 29 8), false teachers (Eph 6 6) and Satan himself (Rev 12 9) are de- ceivers in this sense. In the gospels, AV ‘‘deceive” (wardw, plandd, 9t, Mt 24 4.5 || Mk 13 5.6 || Lk 21 8; Mt 24 11.24; Jn 7 12.47) becomes in RV “lead astray”; the same change is made in 1 Jn 2 26; 3 7; but elsewhere (13 t) both AV and RV render planad by “deceive.” “Deceivableness”’ (drdry, apdté), only in 2 Thess 2 10, signifies power to deceive, not liability to de- ception; RV “deceit.” F. K. Farr DECENTLY, dé’sent-li (eboxnpdvas, euschémé- nos): Only once is this word found in our Eng. Bible (1 Cor 14 40). It is in the last verse of that re- markable chapter on the proper use of spiritual gifts in the church and the proper conduct of public wor- ship. It does not refer here to absence of impurity or obscenity. It rather refers to good order in the conduct of public worship. All things that are done and said in public worship are to be in harmony with that becoming and reverent spirit and tone that befit the true worshippers of God. DECISION, dé-sizh’un: Has several different shades of meaning. It expresses the formation of a Judgment on a matter under consideration. It expresses the quality of being firm or positive in one’s actions. It expresses the termination of a contest or question in favor of one side or the other, as the decision of the battle, or the decision of the judge. Until recent times the decision of disputed points between nations was determined by force of arms. Thus the questions of dispute were 1. National decided between Israel and the sur- Decisions rounding tribes, between Israel and Assyria, between Israel and Egypt, and later between Judaea and Rome. In the earliest times the questions of dispute be- tween individuals were decided by the patriarch who was the head of the family. When 2. Judicial Israel became a nation men were ap- Decisions pointed to decide the difficnlties be- tween the people. At first this was one of the most important duties of Moses, but when the task became too great he appointed judges to assist him (see Ex 18 13-26). One important function of those who are called judges was to decide the difficulties between the people (see Jgs 4 4.5). The kings also decided questions of dispute between individuals (see 28 15 1-6; 1K 3 16-28). As the people developed in their national ideals the decisions in judicial matters were rendered by councils appointed for that purpose. Perplexing questions were many times decided by the casting of lots. The people believed that God would in this way direct them to the 3. Methods right decision (Prov 16 33; Josh 7 of Forming 10-21; 14 2; 18 10 20f). Casting Decisions lots must have been a common method of deciding perplexing questions (see 1 8 14 41.42; Jon 17). It was resorted to by the apostles to decide which of the two men they had selected should take the place of Judas (Acts 1 21— 26). The custom gradually lost in favor, and de- cisions, even of perplexing questions, were formed by considering all the facts. See Auaury IV, 3; Lots. A. W. Fortune DECISION, VALLEY OF. See JeEHosHAPHAT, VALLEY OF. DECLARATION, dek-la-ra’shun, DECLARE, dé- klar’: “Declare” is the tr of a variety of Heb and Gr words in the OT and NT, appearing to bear uni- formly the meaning ‘‘to make known,” “‘set forth,” rather than (the older meaning) “to explain” (Dt 15). Declaration (Est 10 2 AV, RV “full ac- count’; Job 13 17; Ecclus 43 6; Lk 1 1 AV, RV ‘narrative’; 2 Cor 8 19 AV, RV “to show’) has the like meaning. DECLINE, dé-klin’ (“0, sar, or MW, sar, WO, na@iah): In AV this word occurs 9 t in its original sense (now obsolete) of “turn aside.” RV substi- tutes “turn aside” in Ex 23 2; Dt 17 11; 2 Ch 342: Job 23 11. In Ps 102 11; 109 23, the lengthening shadows of afternoon are said to ‘‘de- cline,” and RV introduces the word in the same general sense in Jgs 19 8; 2 K 20 10; Jer 6 4. See AFTERNOON. DEDAN, dé’dan, DEDANITES, dé’dan-its (AV Dedanim, ded’a-nim; 771, ddhan, “low,” D277, d°dhénim): An Arabian people named in Gen 10 7 as descended from Cush; in Gen 26 3 as descended from Keturah. Evidently they were, like the related Sheba (Sabaeans), of mixed race (cf Gen 10 7.28). In Isa 21 18 allusion is made to the “caravans of Dedanites”’ in the wilds of Arabia, and Ezk mentions them as supplying Tyre with precious things (Ezk 27 20; in ver 15, ““Dedan” should probably be read as in LXX, ‘‘Rodan,” i.e. Rhodians). The name seems still to linger in the island of Dadan, on the border of the Pers Gulf. It is found also in Min. and Sab. inscriptions (Glazer, II, 392 ff). JaMEs ORR DEDICATE, ded’i-kat, DEDICATION, ded-i- ka’shun (1331), hdnukkah, “initiation,” “consecra- tion’; UIP, kadhésh, “to be clean,” “sanctify”; DN, hérem, “a thing devoted [to God]’”): Often used in Heb of the consecration of persons, but usually in the EV of the setting apart of things to a sacred use, as of the altar (Nu 7 10f.84.88; ef Dnl 3 2.3, “the d. of the image’), of silver and gold (28 8 11; 2 K 12 4), of the Temple (1 K 8 63; Ezr 6 16f; cf Ex 29 44), of the wall of Jerus (Neh 12 27), of private dwellings (Dt 20 5). RV substitutes “devoted” for “dedicated” in Ezk 44 29. See ConsEcRATION; SANCTIFICATION. DEDICATION, ded-i-ka’shun, FEAST OF (ra éykaina, id egkainia, Jn 10 22): A feast held by the Jews throughout the country for eight days, commencing on the 25th Kislev (December), in commemoration of the cleansing of the temple and dedication of the altar by Jndas Maccabaeus after their desecration by Antiochus Epiphanes (1 Mace 4 56.59). The feast was to be kept “with mirth and gladness.’’ 2 Macc 10 6.7 says it was kept 817 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA p&ceivableness like the Feast of the Tabernacles, with the carrying of palm and other branches, and the singing of psalms. Jos calls it ‘“Lights,’”’ from the joy which accompanied it (Ant, XII, vii, 7). At this winter feast Jesus delivered in the temple the discourse recorded in Jn 10 24 ff, at Jerus. JAMES ORR DEED, déd: Used in its ordinary modern sense in EV. In the OT it is used to tr five Heb words: gmiulah, lit. “recompense” (Isa 59 18); dabhar, lit. “word,” “thing” (2 Ch 36 27 AV, RV “acts”; Est 1 17.18; Jer 5 28); ma‘dseh (Gen 20 9; 44 15; Ezr 9 13); ‘dltlah (1 Ch 16 8 AV, RV “do- ings’; Ps 106 1 AV, RV “doings’); pd‘al (Ps 28 4 AV, RV “work”; Jer 26 14). In the NT “deed” very frequently translates épyor, érgon (same root as Eng. “work”; cf “energy’’), which is still more frequently (esp. in RV) rendered “work.” In Lk 23 51) Acts 19 18; Rom 8 13; Col 8 9 AV, RV “doings,” it stands for Gr rpéits, prdzis (lit. “a doing,” ‘‘transaction”’), each time in a bad sense, equivalent to wicked deed, crime, a meaning which is frequently associated with the pl. of praxis (cf Eng. “practices’’ in the sense of trickery; so often in Polybius; Deissmann maintains that praxis was a technical term in magic), although in Mt 16 27 (AV “works’’) and Rom 12 4 the same Gr word has a neutral meaning. In Jas 1 25 AV “deed” is the tr of Gr wolyo.s, polésis, more correctly ren- dered “doing” in RV. D. Mratt Epwarps DEEP (CNM, tthém; &Bvocos, dbussos, Lk 8 31 AV; Rom 10 7 AV; BdOos, bathos, Lk 6 4; Bv0és, buthéds, 2 Cor 11 25): The Heb word (‘‘water in commotion”) is used (1) of the primeval watery waste (Gen 1 2), where some suggest a connection with Bab Tiamat in the creation-epic; (2) of the sea (sa 51 10 and commonly); (3) of the subterranean reservoir of water (Gen 7 11; 8 2; 49 25; Dt 33 13; Ezk 31 4, etc). In the RV the Gr word first noted is rendered, lit., ‘“abyss.”’ See AByss; also Astronomy, III, 7. DEEP SLEEP. See Steep, Dezr. DEER, dér (PR, ’ayyal, fem. mx, ‘ayyalah, and mbox , ayyeleth [cf Arab.’ayyal and ’¢yal, “deer” and Sy, vaytl, “ram,’’ and Lat caper and capra, “goat,’’ caprea, capreolus, ‘wild goat,” “chamois,” or “roe deer”]; WOM), yakmér [cf Arab. yahmiur, “deer”]; MI, yatdlah, fem. of 5Y2, ya'él [cf Arab. wa'l, “Pers wild goat’’]; "2%, ¢°bh2, and fem. M232, ¢*bhtyah [cf Arab. gabt and fem. zabtyah, “gazelle’’]; "DY , ‘opher (cf Arab. ghafr and ghufr, “young of the mountain goat’’}): Ot the words in the preceding list, the writer helieves that only the first two, i.e. 'ayyal (with its fem. forms) and yahmaér should he trd ‘‘deer,”’ ’ayyai for the roe deer and yahmur for the fallow deer. Further, he believes that yda'él (incl. ya'dlah) should he trd “‘ibex,’’ and sebhi, ‘‘gazelle."’ ‘Opher is the young of a roe deer or of a gazelle. ’Ayyal and ita fem. forms are regularly in EV ren- dered “hart”? and “hind,” terms which are more commonly applied to the male and female of the red deer, Cervus elaphus, which inhabits Great Britain, the continent of Europe, the Caucasus and Asia Minor, but which has never been reported as far south as Syria or Pal. The roe deer, Capreolus caprea, however, which inhabits the British Isles, the greater part of Europe, the Caucasus and Per- sia, is certainly found in Pal. The museum of the Syrian Protestant College at Beirdt possesses the skeleton of a roe deer which was shot in the moun- tains near Tyre. As late as 1890 it was fairly com- mon in southern Lebanon and Carmel, but has now (1912) become very scarce. The fallow deer, Cervus dama, is a native of Northern Africa and countries about the Mediterranean. It is found in central Europe and Great Britain, where it has been intro- duced from its more southern habitat. A variety of the fallow deer, sometimes counted as a separate species under the name of Cervus Mesopotamicus, inhabits northeastern Mesopotamia and Persia. It may in former times have been found in Pal, and Tristram reports having seen the fallow deer in Galilee (Fauna and Flora of Pal), but while Tris- tram was a remarkably acute observer, he appears sometimes to have been too readily satisfied, and his observations, when unaccompanied, as in this case, by specimens, are to be accepted with caution. Now ’ayydl (and its fem. forms) occurs in the Bible 22 t, while yahm@ér occurs only twice, i.e. in the list of clean animals in Dt 14 5, and in 1 K 4 28, in the list of animals provided for Solomon’s table. In both places AV has ‘fallow deer” and RV “roc- buck.” In view of the fact that the roe deer has within recent years been common in Pal, while the occurrence of the fallow deer must be considered doubtful, it seems fair to render ’ayyal “roe deer” or “roebuck,” leaving yahm@r for fallow deer. The Arabs call the roe deer both ’ayydal and wa'l. Wa'‘l is the proper name of the Pers wild goat, Capra aegagrus, and is also often used for the Arab. or Sin ibex, Capra beden, though only by those who do not live within its range. Where the ibex is at home it is always called beden. This looseness of nomenclature must be taken into account, and we have no reason to suppose that the Hebrews were more exact than are the Arabs. There are many examples of this in Eng., e.g. panther, coney, rab- bit Gn America), locust, adder and many others. Ya‘él (incl. ya‘dlah) occurs 4 t. In Job 39 1; Ps 104 18; 18 24 2, EV renders ya‘él by “wild goat.” For ya‘didh in Prov 6 19, AV has “roe,” while RV has “‘doe,”’ which is non-committal, since the name, ‘‘doe,” may be applied to the female of a deer or of an ibex. Since the Arab. wa‘l, which is etymologically closely akin to ya‘él, means the Pers wild goat, it might be supposed that that ani- ma] was meant, were it not that it inhabits the plains of the Syrian desert, and not the mountains of Southern Pal, where the ibex lives. At least two of the passages clearly indicate the latter locality, i.e. Ps 104 18: “The high mountains are for the wild goats,” and 1S 24 2: ‘‘Saul.... went to seek David and his men upon the rocks of the wild goats.” The conclusion then seems _ irresistible that ya‘é, and consequently ya‘dlah, is the ibex. C¢bhi (incl. ¢¢bhiyah) is uniformly rendered ‘‘roe” or “roebuck”’ in AV, while RV, either in the text or in the margin, bas in most cases “gazelle.” In two places “roe” is retained in RV without comment, ie.2 5 2 18: ‘“Asahel was as light of foot as a wild roe,’ and 1 Ch 12 8: “were as swift as the roes upon the mountains.” ’Ayydl and ¢*bhi occur to- gether in Dt 12 15.22; 145; 15 22; 1 K 4 23; Cant 2 9.17, ic. in 7 of the 16 passages in which we find ¢°bh?. If therefore it Be accepted that ‘ayyal is the roe deer, it follows that ¢*bh7 must be something else. Now the gazelle is common in Pal and satisfies perfectly every passage in which we find ¢*bhi. Further, one of the Arab. names of the gazelle is zabi, a word which is etymologically much nearer to ¢’bhi than appears in this trans- literation. ‘Opher is akin to ‘aphdar, ‘“‘dust,”’ and has refer- ence to the color of the young of the deer or gazelle, to both of which it is applied. In Cant 2 9.17 and 8 14, we have ‘apher ha-’ayydlim, EV ‘‘young hart,” lit. ‘fawn of the roe deer.’ In Cant 4 5 and 7 3, we have ‘épharim t’omé ¢ebhiyah, AV ‘young roes that are twins,”’ RV “fawns that are twins of a roe,” Defame Delaiah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 818 RVm “gazelle” (for “roe’). For further reference to these questions, see ZodLoGy. With the exception of mere lists of animals, as in Dt 14 and 1 K 4, the treatment of these animals is highly poetical, and shows much appreciation of their grace and beauty. ALFRED Evy Day DEFAME, dé-fim’, DEFAMING, dé-fam’ing: These words occur bunt twice in AV, and are trans- lations of 12", dibbah, ‘‘slander,” from dabhath, “to slander,” or spread an evil report, and Pdac- gnuéw, blasphémés, ‘to speak injuriously”’ of anyone (Jer 20 10; 1 Cor 4 13). “To defame” differs from “‘to revile” in that the former refers to public slander, the latter to personal abuse. DEFECT, dé-fekt’, DEFECTIVE, dé-fekt'iv (itrypa, héiiéma, “loss,” ‘a defect’): Occurs in 1 Cor 6 7: “Nay, already it is altogether a defect in you [AV “there is utterly a fault among you”’], that ye have lawsuits one with another.” ‘Defect’”’ means “‘want or absence of something necessary for completeness” (RVm ‘‘a loss to you”). The mean- ing of the passage in RV is that when Christians have lawsuits one with another it produces a lack of something which brings them short of completeness, they suffer a spiritual loss or defeat, and perhaps defect is not quite strong enough fully to express that idea. Defective: Sir 49 4 AV, RV “committed tres- pass.” A. W. Fortunes DEFENCE, dé-fens’. See Courts, Jupicia. DEFENCED. See Fortification. DEFER, dé-far’ (WON, ’dhar [in Hiphil], 728, -arakh fin Hiphil], FWA, mashakh [in Niphal], “to postpone,’ more or less definitely; ‘‘delay’’): In OT passages such as Isa 48 9; Ezk 12 25.28; Dnl 9 19, the idea of indefinite postponement agrees with the Heb and with the context. In the only NT occurrence of the word (4va8éddw, anabdlld, in the middle voice, Acts 24 22) a definite postpone- ment is implied. DEFILE, dé-fil’, DEFILEMENT, dé-fil’ment (AS Gfijlau, etc; ME defoulen, ‘make foul,” “‘pollute,”’ render [AV] 9 Heb roots [RV six]: SYA, ga al, ‘“de- file’; bom , halal, “defile” [from ‘“untie, loosen, open,” i.e. “make common,”’ hence “‘profane’’]; 437, hanéph, “incline away” [from right or religion], hence “profane,” ‘defile’ [Jer 8 9, ARV ‘‘pollute’”]; N'QD , fame’, the principal root, over 250 t, tré “de- file” 74 +, “to become, or render, unclean’; P20, tanaph, “to soil” [Cant 5 3]; 529, ‘alal, “deal severely, or decidedly, with,” “roll” (Job 16 15, AV, ARVmn]; 37, ‘adndh, “humble” [Gen 34 2 AV, ARV “humble”]; Wp , kddhash, “separate,” “sanc- tify,” ‘devote to religious use,” hence “forfeit”? [Dt 22 9 AV, ARV “forfeit,’’ m “‘consecrated’’]. They also render 6 [AV] Gr roots [ARV, 4]: xocvds, koinds, etc, “common” or “unclean,” because appertaining to the outside world and not to the people of God, opposite of katharés, ‘‘clean,’’ ieee 13 t; wtalew miaind, wlacua, miasma, macpss, miasmés, ‘stain,’ “tinge,” ‘dye’: “In their dreamings d. the flesh,” Jude ver 8; wodtvw, moliind, “stain,” “contaminate”: ‘not d. their garments” [Rev 3 4]; orAdu, spildd, “spot,” “stain”: “d. the whole body” [Jas 3 6]; g~belpw, phtheird, “corrupt,” “destroy”: the temple of God [1 Cor 3 17 AV, ARV “destroyeth”]; ¢p- aevoxolrys, arscnokoités: “d. themselves with men” {1 Tim 1 10 AV, ARV “abusers of’’]): Defilement in the OT was physical, sexual, ethical, ceremonial, religious, the last four, esp., overlapping. (1) Physical: “I have washed my 1. Defile- feet; how shall Id. them?’ (Cant 5 ment in 3). (2) Sexual: which might be cere- the OT monial or moral; of individuals by illicit intercourse (Lev 18 20), or by intercourse at forbidden times (15 24; 1 S 21 5); of the land by adultery: “Shall not that land be greatly defiled?” (Jer 31 ARV “polluted,” usually substituted where the moral or religious predominates over the ceremonial). (3) Ethical: “Your hands are defiled with blood” (Isa 59 3); “Neither shall they d. themselves any more with .... any of their transgressions” (Ezk 37 23). (4) Ceremonial: to render ceremonially unclean, i.e. disqualified for religious service or worship, and capable of communicating the disqualification. (a) Persons were defiled by contact with carcases of unclean animals (Lev 11 24); or with any car- case (17 15); by eating a carcase (22 8); by contact with issues from the body, one’s own or another's, e.g. abnormal issues from the genitals, male or female (15 2.25); menstruation (Lev 15 19); by contact with anyone thus unclean (15 24); copu- lation (15 16-18); uncleanness after childbirth (12 2-5); by contact with unclean persons (6 3), or unclean things (22 6), or with leprosy (esp. defil- ing; 13 14), or with the dead (Nu 6 12), or with one unclean by such contact (19 22), or by funeral rites (Lev 21 1); by contact with creeping things (22 5), or with unclean animals (11 26). (6) Holy objects were ceremonially defiled by the contact, entrance or approach of the defiled (15 31; Nu 19 13); by the presence of dead bodies, or any remains of the dead (Ezk 9 7; 2 K 23 16: Josiah’s defilement of heathen altars by the ashes of the priests); by the entrance of foreigners (Ps 79 1; sce Acts 21 28); by forbidden treatment, as the altar by being tooled (Ex 20 25); objects in gen- eral by contact with the unclean. Ceremonial defilement, strictly considered, implied, not sin, but ritual unfitness. (5) Religious: not always easily distinguished or entirely distinguishable from the ceremonial, still less from the ethical, but in which the central attitude and relationship to Jeh as covenant God and God of righteousness, was more fully in question. The land might be defiled by bloodshed (Nu 365 33), esp. of the just or inno- cent; by adultery (Jer 3 1); by idolatry and idol- atrous practices, like sacrificing children to idols, etc (Lev 20 3; Ps 106 39); the temple or altar by disrespect (Mal 1 7.12); by offering the un- clean (Hag 2 14); by any sort of unrighteousness (Ezk 36 17); by the presence of idols or idolatrous paraphernalia (Jer 7 30). The scope of defilement in its various degrees (direct, or primary, as from the person or thing de- filed; indirect, or secondary, tertiary, 2. Defile- or even further, by contact with the ment in NT defiled) had been greatly widened by rabbinism into a complex and im- mensely burderisome system whose shadow falls over the whole NT life. Specific mentions are com- paratively few. Physical d. is not mentioned. Sexual d. appears, in a figurative sense: “These are they that were not defiled with women” (Rev 14 4). Ceremonial d. is found in, but not approved by, the NT. Examples are: by eating with un- washed, “common,” not ceremonially cleansed, hands (Mk 7 2); by eating unclean, “common,” food (Acts 10 14; Peter’s vision); by intimate association with Gentiles, such as eating with them (not expressly forbidden in Mosaic law; Acts 11 3), or entering into their houses (Jn 18 28; the Pharisees refusing to enter the Praetorium); b the presence of Gentiles in the Temple (Acts 21 819 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Petes 28). But with Christ’s decisive and revolutionary ; ‘man’ being Heb ’dédham (“common humanity”; cf dictum (Mk 719): “This he said, making ail meats clean,” ete, and with the command in Peter’s vision: ‘‘What God hath cleansed, make not thou common” (Acts 10 15), and with Paul’s bold and consistent teaching: “‘All things indeed are clean” (Rom 14 20, etc), the idea of ceremonial or ritual d., having accomplished its educative purpose, passed. Defilement in the NT teaching, therefore, is uniformly ethical or spiritual, the two constantly merging. The ethical is found more predominantly in: “The things which proceed out of the mouth eome forth out of the heart; and they defile the man” (Mt 16 18); “that did not defile their gar- ments” (Rev 3 4); ‘defileth the whole body” (Jas 3 6). The spiritual seems to predominate in: “defiled and unbelieving” (Tit 1 15); ‘‘conseience being weak is defiled” (by concession to idola- try) (1 Cor 8 7); “lest any root of bitterness springing up trouble you, and thereby the many be defiled” (He 12 15). For the supposed origins of the idea and details of defilement, as from hy- gienie or aesthetic causes, “natural aversions,”’ “taboo,” “totemism,” associations with ideas of death, or evil life, religious symbolism, etc, see Potiution; Purirication; UNcitEaN. Whatever use God may have made of ideas and feelings com- mon among many nations in some form, the Divine purpose was clearly to impress deeply and indelibly on the Israelites the ideas of holiness and saered- ness in pereral and of Jch’s holiness, and their own required holiness and separateness in particular, thus preparing for the deep NT teachings of sin, and of spiritual consecration and sanctification. Pair WENDELL CRANNELL DEFY, dé-fi (020, h@raph, OTT, 2d‘am): In1 8 17 10.25.26.36.45 (the story of David and Goliath) and kindred passages, this word is used in its most familiar sense—“‘to taunt,” “challenge to combat” (Heb haraph). In Nu 23 7.8 “denounce” would be a better tr than ‘‘defy”’ (Heb za‘am). DEGENERATE, dé-jen’ér-4t: Only in Jer 2 21, where Judah is eompared to a “noble vine” which it “turned into the degenerate branches of a foreign vine.” It represents Heb sarim=!‘stray” or “‘de- generate (shoots),” from sir=‘‘to turn aside,” esp. to turn aside from the right path (Gr pikria, lit. “bitterness”’). DEGREE, dé-gre’ (ress , masélah, “a going up” or “ascent,” henee a staircase or flight of steps; “rank”: ramewwés, tapeinds, “‘low’): By derivation it should mean “a step down” (Lat, de, down, gradus, step). It is used, however, of any step, up or down; then of grade or rank, whether high or low. (1) In its literal sense of step (as of a stair), it is used in the pl. to translate Heb ma‘dloih (“steps”), in the |} passages 2 K 20 9-11 AV (5 t); Isa 38 8 AV (3 t), where we read of the “degrees” (RV “steps”) on the “dial of Ahaz” (Heb “‘steps of Ahaz’”’). See Diau or Anaz. It seems to mean steps or progressive movements of the ba oad a. certain place in the phrase “‘A Song of Degrees” (RV “Ascents”), which forms the title of each of the Pss 120-34, probably because they were sung on the way up to the great feasts at Jerus. See Psatms. (2) The secondary (but now the more usual) sense of rank, order, grade is found in the following passages: (2) 1 Ch 16 18, “their brethren of the second (degree),” lit. “of the seconds’’ (Heb mishnim; ef 2 Ch 28 7, “Elkanah that was next to the king,” Heb, “the king’s second,” i.e. in rank); (b) 1 Ch 17 17, “a man of high degree” (Heb maélah, “step’); (c) Ps 629, “men of low de- gree . . men of high degree,” a paraphrase of Heb “sons of man... . sons of man,” the first Gr dnthrépos, Lat homo, Welsh dyn), and the second Heb ’ish ane in a superior sense; cf Gr anér, Lat vir, Welsh gwr); (d) ‘of low degree’ for Gr tapeinos in Sir 11 1; Lk 1 52; Jas 1 9; (ce) In1 Tim 3 13 AV “a good degree” (Gr bathmés kalés, RV ‘a good standing’’) is assured to those who have “‘served well as deacons.”’ Some take this to mean promotion to a higher official position in the church; but it prob- ably means simply a position of moral weight and influence in the church gained by faithfulness in service (so Hort). D. Miatt Evwarps DEGREES, SONGS OF inven WW, shir ha-ma‘dloth; LXX 8h trav avaBalpav, ddé ton ana- bathmén; Vulg canticum graduum, RV “a song of ascents’): The title prefixed to 15 psalms (Pss 120 -34) as to the significance of which there are four views: (1) The Jewish interpretation. According to the Mish, Middath 2 5, Sukkah 51b, there wasin the temple a semicircular flight of stairs with 15 steps which led from the court of the men of Israel down to the court of the women. Upon these stairs the Levites played on musical instruments on the even- ing of the first day of Tabernacles. Later Jewish writers say that the 15 psalms derived their title from the 16 steps. (2) Gesenius, Delitzsch and others affirm that these psalms derive their name from the step-like progressive rhythm of their thoughts. They are called Songs of Degrees be- cause they move forward climactically by means of the resumption of the immediately preceding word. But this characteristic is not found in several of the group. (3) Theodoret and other Fathers explain these 15 hymns as traveling songs of the returning exiles. In Ezr 7 9 the return from exile is called “the going up [ha-ma‘dlaA] from Babylon.” Several of the group suit this situation quite well, but others presuppose the temple and its stated services. (4) The most probable view is that the hymns were sung by pilgrim bands on their way to the three great festivals of the Jewish year. The journey to Jerus was called a “going up,’”’ whether the worshipper came from north or south, east or west. All of the songs are suitable for use on such occasions. Hence the title Pilgrim Psalms is pre- ferred by many scholars. See Daw or AHAZ. JOHN Ricwarn SaMPEY DEHAITES, dé-ha’téz (RWIT, dehawé’; AV De- havites): A people enumerated in Ezr 4 9 with Elamites, etc, as among those settled by the Assyr king Osnappar (Assurbanipal) in Samaria. The identification is uncertain. DEHORT, dé-hért’ (4moorpépw, aposiréphi; RV DISSUADE): Not found in the Eng. Bible; once only in Apoc (1 Mace 9 9). An obsolete Eng. word; the opposite of ‘‘exhort.’’ It means ‘“‘to dis- suade,” “to forbid,” ‘‘to restrain from.” DEKAR, dé’kir (WRT, deker, “lancer’’): Father of one of Solomon’s commissaries (1 K 4 9 AV). See BEN-DEKER. DELAIAH, déla’ya (75, délayah, “God has raised”’): (1) A descendant of David (1 Ch 3 24; AV “Dalaiah’’). (2) One of David's priests and leader of the 23d course (1 Ch 24 18). (3) One of the princes who pleaded with Jehoia- kim not to destroy the roll containing the prophecies of Jeremiah (Jer 36 12.25). (4) The ancestor of a post-exilic family whose genealogy was lost (Ezr 2 60; Neh 7 62; 1 Esd 5 37m). See Datan. (5) The father of timorous Shemaiah (Neh 6 10). Delve of Noah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 820 DELAY, dé-la’: The noun “delay” (Acts 25 17, | 14; Isa 66 3); sha‘a', “to stroke,” “caress,” “T made no delay”; AV ‘without any delay’’) means ‘procrastination.’ The vb. ‘‘to delay’ (Ex 22 29; “MS, ’dhar) involves the idea “‘to stop for a time,” the people being admonished not to discontinue a custom. The Pil. pf. of WD, bash (Ex 32 1), ‘Moses delayed to come,” expresses not only the fact that he tarried, but also the disappoint- ment on the part of the people, being under the impression that he possibly was put to shame and had failed in his mission, which also better explains the consequent action of the people. ‘To delay” (xpovl{e, chronizd) is used transitively in Mt 24 48 (RV ‘My lord tarrieth’) and in Lk 12 45. The meaning here is ‘‘to prolong,” ‘to defer.” A. L. Bresiica DELECTABLE, délek’ta-b’] (WM, hamadh, “to desire”): Found only in Isa 44 9 AV: ‘Their delectable things shall not profit,” AVm “desirable.” ARV translates: ‘‘the things that they delight in.” The reference is to idols or images. Delitzsch renders the phrase: “Their darlings are good for nothing.”” The word may be traced back to the Lat delectabilis, ‘‘pleasant,” or ‘‘delightful.” DELICACY, del’i-ka-si (r8 orpivos, 16 strénos): Found only in Rev 18 3 AV: “The merchants of the earth are waxed rich through the abundance of her delicacies.’”” RV has very properly changed delicacies to “wantonness,” and “luxury” in the margin, which is much nearer to the original. DELICATE, del’i-kat, DELICATELY, del’i-kat-li (T1Y, ‘édhen, 337, ‘anogh; év tpvpy, en truphé): “Delicate”? usually an adj., but once a subst. (Jer 61 34 AV), ‘He hath filled his belly [RV ‘“‘maw’’] with my delicates.”’ RV retains the word, but ARV very properly has replaced it with ‘‘delicacies.” In Sir 80 18, RV agathd, “good things.” The adj. seems to have two meanings, though not easily distinguished: (1) tenderly reared, and (2) wanton or voluptuous. In Dt 28 54.56; Isa 47.1; Jer 6 2, “luxurious” or “daintily bred” would certainly be nearer the original than ‘‘delicate.” ‘Delicate children” of Mic 1 16 AV is changed by RV to “children of thy delight,” i.e. beloved children, rather than children begotten in passion. The advb. “delicately”’ is employed in the same sense as the adj. (Lam 4 5; Lk 7 25). In the old Eng. writers “delicate” is often used for voluptuous: ‘‘Dives for his delicate life to the devil went’? (Piers Plowman). The meaning of “delicately”? (ma‘ddhdn) in 1 Sam 15 32 (AV) is a real puzzle. The AV reads, ‘‘And Agag came unto him delicately,” with a possible suggestion of weakness or fear. ARV and RVm substitute ‘‘cheerfully.”” Others, by metathesis or change of consonants in the Heb word, tr ‘Sn bonds” or ‘fetters.”’ W. W. Daviss DELICIOUSLY, dé-lish’us-li (etpnvidw, strénidd, “to live hard or wantonly”): ‘She[Babylon] ... . lived deliciously” (Rev 18 7.9 AV, RV “wantonly,” RVm “‘luxuriously”’). DELIGHT, dé-lit’ (vb., TEM, haphic, ME, racah, YYW, sha‘a‘; cvviSopar, sunédomai): ‘To delight”’ is most frequently expressed by haphéc, which means originally ‘‘to bend” (cf Job 40 17 “He moveth his tail’), hence, “to incline to,’ “take pleasure in.” Jt is used of God’s pleasure in His people (Nu 14 8; 2 5 22 20; Ps 18 19, etc), and in righteousness, etc (Isa 66 4; Jer 9 24; Mic 7 18, etc), also of man’s delight in God and His will (Ps 40 8; 73 25; AV and RV, ‘There is none upon earth that I desire besides thee’), and in other objects (Gen 34 19; 15 18 22; Est 2 “be fond of,” occurs in Ps 94 19, “Thy comforts delight my soul”; 119 16.47.70, “I will delight myself in thy statutes.” Similarly, St. Paul says (Rom 7 22), “I delight [sunédomai] in [m, RV “Gr with”] the law of God after the inward man.” This is the only occurrence of the word in the NT, “To delight one’s self” (in the Lord) is represented chiefly by ‘dnagh (Job 22 26; 27 10; Ps 37 4.11; Isa 68 14). Delight (noun), chiefly hépheg (1 S 15 22; Ps 12; 163), racdn (Prov 11 1.20; 12 22; 16 8), sha‘ishi'im (Ps 119 24.77.92.143.174; Prov 8 30. 31). RV has ‘delight’ for ‘desire’ (Neh 1 11; Ps 22 8; 61 16), for “observe,” different reading (Prov 23 26), “no delight in” for “smell ta” (Am 5 21), “delightest in me’’ for “favorest me” (Ps 41 11), “his delight shall be in” (m ‘Heb ‘scent’’’) for “of quick understanding” (Isa 11 3). ; The element of joy, of delight in God and His law and will, in the Heb religion is noteworthy as being something which we are apt to fall beneath even in the clearer light of Christianity. W. L. WALKER - DELIGHTSOME, dé-lit’sum: 2M, hépheg, is rendered “delightsome”’: Mal 8 12, ‘‘Ye shall be a delightsome land,” lit. ‘‘a land of delight.” DELILAH, dé-li‘la (""5'T, d-lilah, “dainty one,” perhaps; LXX AadaSd, Daleidé, Aadt8d, Dalida): The woman who betrayed Samson to the Philis (Jgs 16). She was presumably a Phili, though that is not expressly stated. She is not spoken of as Samson’s wife, though many have understood the account in that way. The Philis paid her a tremendously high price for her services. The account indicates that for beauty, personal charm, mental ability, self-command, nerve, she was quite a wonderful woman, a woman to be admired for some qualities which she exhibits, even while she is to be utterly disapproved. See Samson. Wi.us J. BEECHER DELIVER, déliv’er (%3, nacal, {02, nathan; fiopat, rhiiomat, wapadlSept, paradiddmi): Occurs very frequently in the OT and represents various Heb terms. The Eng. word is used in two senses, (1) “‘to set free,” etc, (2) ‘“‘to give up or over.” (1) The word most often tr4 ‘deliver’ in the first sense is ndcal, meaning originally, perhaps, ‘‘to draw out.” It is used of all kinds of deliverance (Gen 82 11; Ps 26 20; 143 9, etc; Jer 7 10; Ezk 3 19,etc; Zeph 1 18, etc). The Aram. n%¢al occurs in Dn] 3 29; 6 14; 8 4.7; yasha', “‘to save,” in Jgs 39.381 AV, etc; malat, “to let or cause to escape,” in Isa 46 2, ‘‘recover,”’ etc. In the NT rhuomai, ‘‘to rescue,”’ is most frequently tr4 “deliver” in this sense (Mt 6 13 AV, ‘Deliver us from evil’); katargéé, ‘‘to make useless” or ‘‘without effect”’ (Rom 7 6 RV, discharged”). In the NT “save” takes largely the place of ‘deliver’ in the OT, and the idea is raised to the spiritual and eternal. (2) For ‘‘deliver’ in the sense of “give over, up,” etc, the most frequent word is nathan, the common word for “to give’ (Gen 32 16; 40 18 AV; Ex 5 18). Other words are mdghan (Hos 11 8, AV and ERV ‘How shall I deliver thee Israel?” ie. “How shall I give thee up?” as in the first clause of the verse, with a different word [nathan], ARV “How shall I cast thee off ?’’), yhabh, Aram. (Ezr. B 14). In the NT paradidémi, ‘‘to give over to,’”’ is most frequent (Mt 6 25; 11 27, “All things have been delivered [given or made over] unto me of my Father”; Mk 713; Lk 12; 1 Tim 1 20, etc); charizomai, “to grant as a favor’ (Acts 26 11. 16 AY). 821 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Delay Deluge of Noah (8) Ydladh, “to bring forth,” is also rendered “deliver’’ in the sense of childbirth (Gen 25 24; Ex 1 19, etc). In the NT this sense is borne by rlerw, tikté (Lk 1 57; 2 6; Rev 12 2.4), and yevrde, genndo (Jn 16 21). In RV there are many changes, such as, for ‘“‘de- liver,” ‘restore’ (Gen 37 22; 40 13; Ex 22 26; Dt 24 13); for “delivered,” “defended” (1 Ch 11 14); for ‘“‘cannot deliver thee,” ‘‘neither .... turn thee aside’ (Job 36 18); for “betray,” “betrayed” we have ‘‘deliver,” “delivered up,’’ etc (Mt 104m; Mk 1312; 14 10f; Lk 21 16); for ‘delivered into chains,” “committed to pits” (2 Pet 24, m “some ancient authorities read chains”; ef Wisd 17 17); “Deliver us from evil,” omitted in Lk 11 4, m “Many ancient authorities add but deliver us from the evil one (or, from evil).” W. L. WaLkKrer DELOS, dé’los (Afjkes, Délos): An island, now deserted, one of the Cyclades in the Aegaean Sea, about 3 miles long and 1 mile broad, with a rocky mountain (Cynthus) several hundred feet high in the center. In antiquity Delos enjoyed great prosperity. According to Gr legend the island once floated on the surface of the water, until Poseidon fastened it on four diamond pillars for the wandering Leto, who, like Io, was pursued by the vengeful Hera. It was here that Apollo and Artemis were born; hence the island was sacred, and became one of the chief seats of worship of the two deities. Numerous temples embellished Delos. The most magnificent was that of Apollo, which contained a colossal statue of. the god, a dedicatory offering of the Naxians. This temple was a sanctuary visited by all the Greeks, who came from far and near to worship at the deity’s shrine. There was a Dorian peripteral temple in Delos from the beginning of the 4th cent. BC. To the N. was a remarkable altar composed entirely of ox-horns. The various Ionian cities sent sacred embassies (thedriat) with rich offerings. There was also a celebrated oracle in Delos which was accounted one of the most trustworthy in the world. Every five years the famous Delian festival was celebrated with prophecies, athletic contests and games of every kind. All the nations of Greece participated. : The earliest inhabitants of Delos were Carians; but about 1000 BC the island was occupied by Jonians. For a long time it enjoyed independence. In 478 Delos was chosen as the place for the con- vention of the representatives of the Gr states for deliberation about means for defence against Persia. The treasury of the Athenian Confederacy was kept here after 476. The island became independent of Athens in 454. During the 2d and Ist cents. BC it became one of the chief ports of the Aegaean. This was partly due to its location, and_partly to the fact that the Romans, after 190 BC, favored the island as a rival to the sea-power of Rhodes. In 166 Delos was given to Athens; the inhabitants fled to Achaea, and the island was colonized by Athenians, together with Romans. The ruins of the city of Delos, which became a flourishing commercial port, are to the N. of the temple. It became the center of trade between Alexandria and the Black Sea, and was for a long time one of the chief slave markets of the Gr world. But Delos received a severe blow, from which it never recovered, in the war between Rome and Mithridates. The latter’s general landed in 88 BC and massacred many, and sold the remainder of the defenceless people, and sacked and destroyed the city together with the temple and its countless treasures. At the conclusion of peace (84) Delos came into the possession of the Romans, who later gave it back to Athens. Undcr the Empire the island lost its importance entirely. Delos was one of the states to which Rome addressed letters in behalf of the Jews (138-137 BC; see 1 Macc 16 16-23). Among those who came to Delos from the East must have been many of this nation. Jos cites in full a decree passed in Delos which confirmed the Jewish exemption from military service (Ant, XIV, x, 4). The excavations of the French have laid bare 8 temples within the sacred inclosure (Apollo, Artemis, Dionysus). Numerous statues, dating from the earliest times of Gr art down to the latest, have been discovered; also 2,000 inscriptions, among which was an inventory of the temple treasure. By the side of Delos, across a very narrow strait, lies Rheneia, another island which was the burying- ground of Delos; for on the sacred isle neither births, deaths nor burials were permitted. In 426 BC Delos was ‘‘purified’”’ by the Athenians—by the removal of the bodies that had been interred there previously. LitERaATURE.—Lehégue, Recherches sur Délos (Paris, 1876); V.v. Scbéffer, De Deli Insulae rebus, Berliner Studien fir klass. Phil. (Berlin, 1889); Homolle, 8. Reinach and others, in the Bulletin de corresp. Hellén. (VI, 1-167; VII, 103-25, 329-73; VIII, 75-158; XIV, 389-511; XV,113-68); Homolle, Archives de Vintendance sacrée & Délos; Jebb, Journal of Hellenic Studies (1880), . J. E. Harry DELUGE, del’ij, OF NOAH, THE: . The Biblical Account ‘'Noah’s Log Book”’ The Egyptian Tradition The Indian = The Chinese The Greek ie The British us The American Indian Traditions The Babylonian Tradition Cuneiform Tablets . Was the Flood Universal? The means described in Gen 6-8 by which the Lord destroyed, on account of their wickedness, all the members of the human race except POOR Aor or ind 1. The Noah and his family. According to Biblical the account, Noah was warned of the Account event 120 years before (Gen 6 3; 1 Pet 3 20; 2 Pet 2 5). During all this time he is said to have been a ‘‘preacher of righteousness” ‘‘while the ark was a preparing,” when we may well suppose (according to the theory to be presently propounded) the physical events leading up to the final catastrophe may have given point to his preaching. When the catastrophe came, the physical means'employed were twofold, namely, the breaking up of the “fountains of the great deep” and the opening of ‘‘the windows of heaven” (Gen 7 11). But the rain is spoken of as continu- ing as a main cause only 40 days, while the waters continued to prevail for 150 days (ver 24), when (8 2.3) ‘the fountains also of the deep and the windows of heaven were stopped, and the rain from heaven was restrained; and the watcrs returned from off the earth continually,” so that after 10 months the ark rested upon ‘‘the mountains of Ararat’’ (not the peak of Mount Ararat, but the highlands of Armenia in the upper part of the valley of the Euphrates and Tigris; see ARARAT). Here it rested 40 days before the water subsided sufficiently to suggest disembarking, when a raven (which could easily find its food on the carcases of the animals which had been destroyed) was sent forth, and did not return (ver 7); but a dove sent out at the same time found no rest and returned empty to the ark (ver 9). After 7 days, however, it was sent out again and returned with a fresh olive leaf (ver 11). After 7 days more the dove was sent Deluge of Noah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 822 forth again and did not return. After 56 days more of waiting Noah and his family departed from the ark. The following are the leading 2. ‘*Noah’s points in the story which has been Log Book” appropriately styled by Sir William Dawson ‘‘Noah’s log book” (see S. E. Bishop’s art. in Bib. Sac. [1906], 510-17, and Rev. Joseph B. Davidson in the author's Scientific Con- firmations of OT History, 180-84). ““Noan’s Loe Book” Numbor of Days All enter the ark; God shuts the door. Rains fall. Floods pour in from sea. 40 Ark floats. Ark sails swittly. 27 Rainstops. Floods kecp pouring in and water rising 17 Ark touches bottom on top of high mountains and stays there. Waters stop rising. Water stationary...... 40 Waters begin to settle. Settle fifteen CUNT tS Deane ce seere Sena ee artes toate tacahes 34 Ark left on dry land. Waters continue to settle. oah waits..........005 40 Noah sends out a raven. It returns not. Waters settle. Noah waits.... Noah sends out a dove. It returns. Waters settle. Noah waits........ Noah sends out dove again. brings an olive Jeaf just grown. Wa- ters settle. Noah waits........... 7 Noah sends out dove again. It returns not. Waters settle. Noah waits... 29 Noahremoves covering, looks all around. No water can be seen. Ground dries up. Noah waits..............+.0.5 56 2 27 God opens the door, and says, “Go forth.’ Total time of flood 370 It will thus be seen that there is no need of sup- posing any duplication and overlapping of accounts in the Bib. story. There is continual progress in the account from beginning to end, with only such repetitions for literary effect. as we are familiar with in oriental writings. In Gen 6 5—7 18 the wicked- ness of the world is assigned as the reason which prevailed in the Divine counsels for bringing about the contemplated catastrophe. While emphasizing the righteousness of Noah which led to his preserva- tion, 6 13-21 contains the direction for the making of the ark and of the preparations to bring into it a certain number of animals. This preparation having been made, the order was given (7 1-4) for the embarkation which (ver 5) was duly accom- plished. We are then told that Noah and his family, and beasts both clean and unclean, were shut up in the ark during the prevalence of the water and its final subsidence. Altogether the account is most graphic and impressive (see W. H. Green, Unity of the Book of Genesis, 83 fi). Compared with other traditions of the Deluge, the Bib. account appears in a most favorable light, while the general prevalence of such traditions strongly confirms the reality of the Bib. story. An Egyp legend of the Deluge is referred to in Plato’s T'imacus, where the gods are said to have purified the earth by a great flood of Month Day 2 17 110 3. The water from which only a few shepherds Egyptian escaped by climbing to the summit of Tradition a high mountain. In the Egyp docu- ments themselves, however, we find only that Ra’ the creator, on account of the insolence of man, proceeded to exterminate him by a deluge of blood which flowed up to Heliopolis, the home of the gods; but the heinousness of the deed so affected him that he repented and swore never more to destroy mankind. In Indian mythology there is no reference to the Flood in the Rig Veda, but in the laws of Manu we are told that a fish said to Manu, 4. The “A deluge will sweep all creatures Indian away..... Build a vessel and wor- Tradition ship me. When the waters rise enter the vessel and I will save thee. .... When the Deluge came, he had entered the ves- 8élo 2.8.5.5 the North. The Deluge had carried away ail creatures, and Manu remained alone” (tr? by Max Miller). The Chinese tradition is embodied in sublime language in their book of Li-Ki: “And now the pillars of heaven were broken, the 5. The earth shook to its very foundation; Chinese the sun and the stars changed their. Tradition motions; the earth fell to pieces, and the waters enclosed within its bosom burst forth with violence, and overflowed. Man having rebelled against heaven, the system of the universe was totally disordered, and the grand har- mony of nature destroyed. All these evils arose from man’s despising the supreme power of the uni- verse. He fixed his looks upon terrestrial objects and loved them to excess, until gradually he became transformed into the objects which he loved, and celestial reason entirely abandoned him.” The Greeks, according to Plutarch, had five different traditions of the Deluge, that of Deucalion being the most important. Accord- 6. The ing to this, Prometheus warned his son Greek Deucalion of the flood which Zeus Tradition had resolved to bring upon the earth by reason of its wickedness. Accord- ingly Deucalion constructed an ark and took refuge in it, but with his vessel was stranded on Mount Parnassus in Thessaly, whereupon they disembarked and repeopled the earth by the fantastic process revealed to them by the goddess Themis of throwing stones about them, those which Deucalion threw becoming men and those which Pyrrha_ threw becoming women. Lucian’s form of the legend, however, is less fantastic and more nearly in line with Sem tradition. In the Gr legend as in the Sem, a dove is sent forth which returns both a first and a second time, its feet being tinged with mud the second time, intimating the abatement of the flood. But neither Homer nor Hesiod have this tradition. Probably it was borrowed from the Semites or the Hindus. In Britain there is a Druid legend that on account of the profligacy of mankind, the Supreme Being sent a flood upon the earth when ‘‘the 7. The waves of the sea lifted themselves on British high round the border of Britain. Tradition The rain poured down from heaven and the waters covered the earth.” But the patriarch, distinguished for his integrity, had been shut up with a select company in a strong ship which bore them safely upon the summit of the waters (Ed. Davies in his Mythology and Rites of British Druids). From these the world was again repeopled. There are various forms of this legend but they all agree in substance. Among the American Indians traditions of the Deluge were found by travelers to be widely dis- seminated. Mr. Catlin says, ‘Among 8. American the 120 different tribes which I visited Indian in North, South, and Central America, Traditions not a tribe exists that has not related to me distinct or vague traditions of such a calamity, in which one, or three, or eight persons were saved above the waters upon the top of a high mountain” (quoted by Wm. Restelle in Bib. Sac. [January, 1907], 157). While many, per- haps most, of these traditions bear the stamp of 823 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Deluge of Noah Christian influence through the early missionaries, the Mexican legend bears evident marks of original- ity. According to it the 4th age was one of water, when all men were turned into fishes except Tezpi and his wife Hochiquetzal and their children, who with many animals took refuge in a ship which sailed safely over the tumultuous waters which overwhelmed the earth. When the flood subsided the ship stranded on Mount Cohuacan, whereupon he sent forth a vulture which did not return, and then a humming bird which returned with some leaves in its beak. The Peruvian story differs from this in many particulars. According to it a single man and woman took refuge m a box and floated hundreds of miles from Cuzco to an unknown land where they made clay images of all races, and animated them. The Moravian missionary Cranz, in his History of Greenland, says that “the first missionaries among the Greenlanders found a tolerably distinct tra- dition of the Deluge” to the effect that ‘‘the earth was once tilted over and all men were drowned” except one “who smote afterward upon the ground with a stick and thence came out a woman with whom he peopled the earth again.” Moreover, the Greenlanders point to the remains of fishes and bones of a whale on high mountains where men never could have dwelt, as proof that the earth was once flooded. Among the North American Indians generally legends of the Deluge are so embellished that they become extremely fantastic, but in many of them there are peculiarities which point unques- tionably to a common origin of extreme antiquity. The unprejudiced reader cannot rise from the study of the subject without agreeing in general with Francois Lenormant, who writes: “As the case now stands, we do not hesitate to declare that, far from being a myth, the Bib. Deluge is a real and historical fact, having, to say the least, left its impress on the ancestors of three races—Aryan, or Indo-European, Sem, or Syrio-Arabian, Chamitic, or Kushite—that is to say on the three great civi- lized races of the ancient world, those which consti- tute the higher humanity—hefore the ancestors of these races had as yet separated, and in the part of Asia together inhabited” (Contemporary Review, November, 1879). The most instructive of these traditions are those which have come down to us from Babylonia, which until recently were known to us only 9. The through the Gr historian Berosus of Babylonian the 4th cent. BC, who narrates that a Tradition great deluge happened at some indefi- nite time in the past during the reign of Xisuthrus, son of Ardates. Xisuthrus was warned beforehand by the deity Cronos, and told to build a ship and take with him his friends and relations and all the different animals with all necessary food and trust himself fearlessly to the deep, whereupon he built ‘a vessel 5 stadia [3,000 ft.] long and 2 stadia [1,200 ft.] broad.” After the flood subsided Xisuthrus, like Noah, sent out birds which returned to him again. After waiting some days and sending them out a second time, they returned with their feet tinged with mud. Upon the third trial they returned no more, whereupon they disembarked and Xisuthrus with his wife, daughter and pilot offered sacrifice to the gods and were translated to live with the gods. It was found that the place where they were was ‘“‘the land of Armenia,” but they were told to return to Baby- lon. Berosus concluded his account by saying that “the vessel being thus stranded in Armenia, some part of it yet remains in the Corcyraean mountains.” By An earlier and far more important tradition was found inscribed on cuneiform tablets in Babylonia dating from 3000 BC. These were discovered by George Smith in 1870 and filled as many as 180 lines. The human hero of the account, 10. Cune- corresponding to Noah of the Bible iform and Xisuthrus of Berosus, is Gilga- Tablets mesh, who lived in Shurippak, a city full of violence, on the banks of the Euphrates. He was warned of an approaching flood and exhorted to pull down his house and build a ship and cause ‘‘seed of life of every sort to go up into it.” The ship, he says, was to be “exact in its dimensions, equal in its breadth and its length..... Its sides were 140 cubits high, the border of its top equaled 140 cubits..... I constructed it in 6 stories, dividing it into 7 com- partments. Its floors I divided into 9 cham- bersso.) 44, I chose a mast (or rudder pole), and supplied what was necessary. Six sars of bitumen I poured over the outside; three sars of bitumen over the inside.’ After embarking, the storm broke with fearful violence and the steering of the ship was handed over to Bezur-Bel, the ship man. But amidst the roll of thunder and the march of mountain waves the helm was wrenched from the pilot’s hands and the pouring rain and the lightning flashes dismayed all hearts. “Like a battle charge upon mankind” the water rushed so that the gods even were dismayed at the flood and cowered like dogs, taking refuge in the heaven of Anu while Ishtar screamed like a woman in travail, and repenting of her anger, resolved to save a few and ‘‘to give birth to my people” till like ‘‘the fry of fishes they fill the sea.””. The ship was therefore turned to the country of Nizir (Armenia). It is worthy of notice that the cuneiform tablet exhibits as much variety of style as does the Bib. account. Plain narrative and rhetorical prose are intermingled in both accounts, a fact which effectually disposes of the critical theory which regards the Bib. account as a clumsy combination made in later times by piecing together two or more independent traditions. Evidently the piecing to- gether, if there was any, had been accomplished early in Bab history. See BABYLONIA AND ASSYRIA. On comparing the Bib. account with that of the cuneiform tablets, the following similarities and contrasts are brought to light: (1) That the cuneiform inscription is from start to finish polytheistic (ll. 3-17), whereas the narra- tive in Gen is monotheistic. (2) The cuneiform agrees with the Bib. narra- tive in making the Deluge a Divine punishment for the wickedness of the world (ll. 5, 6). (8) The names differ to a degree that is irrecon- cilable with our present knowledge. (4) The dimensions of the ark as given in Gen (6 15) are reasonable, while those of Berosus and the cuneiform tablets are unreasonable. Accord- ing to Gen, the ark was 300 cuhits (5624 ft.) long, 50 cubits (932 ft.) wide, and 30 cubits (564 ft.) deep, which are the natural proportions for a ship of that size, being in fact very close to those of the great steamers which are now constructed to cross the Atlantic. The “Celtic” of the White Star line, built in 1901, is 700 ft. long, 75 ft. wide and 493 ft. deep. The dimensions of the ‘‘Great Eastern,” built in 1858 (692 ft. long, 83 ft. broad, and 58 ft. deep), are still closer to those of the ark. The cuneiform tablets represent the length, width and depth each as 140 cubits (262 ft.) (IL. 22, 23, 38-41), the dimen- sions of an entirely unseaworthy structure. Accord- ing to Berosus, it was 5 stadia (3,000 ft.) and 2 stadia (1,200 ft.) broad; while Origen (Against Cel- sus, 4.41), represented it to be 135,000 ft. (25 miles) long, and 3,750 ft. (2 mile) wide. (5) In the Bib. account, nothing is introduced conflicting with the sublime conception of holiness Deluge of Noah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA and the peculiar combination of justice and mercy ascribed to God throughout the Bible, and illus- trated in the general scheme of providential govern- ment manifest in the order of Nature and in history; while, in the cuneiform tablets, the Deluge is occasioned by a quarrel among the gods, and the few survivors escape, not by reason of a merciful plan, but by a mistake which aroused the anger of Bel (II.-146-50). (6) In all the accounts, the ark is represented as floating up stream. According to Gen, it was not, as is usually tr’, on “Mount Ararat’ (8 4), but in the “mountains of Ararat,” designating an indefinite region in Armenia upon which the ark rested; according to the inscriptions, it was in Nizir (Il. 115-20), a region which is watered by the Zab and the Tornadus; while, according to Berosus, it was on the Corcyraean Mountains, included in the same indefinite area. In all three cases, its resting-place is in the direction of the headwaters of the Euphrates valley, while the scene of the building is clearly laid in the lower part of the valley. (7) Again, in the Bib. narrative, the spread of the water floating the ark is represented to have been occasioned, not so much by the rain which fell, as by the breaking-up of ‘‘all the fountains of the great deep” (7 11), which very naturally describes phenomena connected with one of the extensive downward movements of the earth’s crust with which geology has made us familiar. The sinking of the land below the level of the ocean is equivalent, in its effects, to the rising of the water above it, and is accurately expressed by the phrases used in the sacred narrative. This appears, not only in the language concerning the breaking-up of the great deep which describes the coming-on of the Flood, but also in the description of its termination, in which it is said, that the ‘fountains also of the deep . . - . were stopped, .... and the waters returned from off the earth continually” (8 2.3). Nothing is said of this in the other accounts. (8) The cuneiform tablets agree in general with the two other accounts respecting the collecting of the animals for preservation, but differ from Gen in not mentioning the sevens of clean animals and in including others beside the family of the builder (Il. 66-69). (9) The cuneiform inscription is peculiar in providing the structure with a mast, and putting it in charge of a pilot (Il. 45, 70, 71). (10) The accounts differ decidedly in the dura- tion of the Flood. According to the ordinary inter- pretation of the Bib. account, the Deluge continued a year and 17 days; whereas, according to the cuneiform tablets, it lasted only 14 days (1. 103- 7, 117-22). (11) All accounts agree in sending out birds; but, according to Gen (8 8) a raven was first sent out, and then in succession two doves (8 8-12); while the cuneiform inscription mentions the dove and the raven in reverse order from Gen, and adds a swallow (ll. 121-80). (12) All accounts agree in the building of an altar and offering a sacrifice after leaving the ark. But the cuneiform inscription is overlaid with a poly- theistic coloring: ‘“The gods like flies swarmed about the sacrifices” (II. 182-43). (13) According to the Bib. account, Noah sur- vived the Flood for a long time; whereas Nth- napishtim and his wife were at once deified and taken to heaven (ll. 177-80). (14) Both accounts agree in saying that the human race is not again to be destroyed by a flood (Gen 9 11; ll. 162-69). Close inspection of these peculiarities makes it evident that the narrative in Gen carries upon its face an appearance of reality not found in the other 824 It is scarcely possible that the reason- able dimensions of the ark, its floating up stream, and the references to the breaking-up of the foun- tains of the great deep should have been hit upon accounts. by accident. It is in the highest degree improbable that correct statements of such unobvious facts should be due to the accident of legendary guess- work. At the same time, the duration of the Deluge, according to Gen, affords opportunity for a gradual progress of events which best accords with scientific conceptions of geological movements. If, as the most probable interpretation would imply, the water began to recede after 150 days from the beginning of the Flood and fell 15 cubits in 74 days, that would only be 32 inches per day—a rate which would be imperceptible to an ordinary observer. Nor is it necessary to suppose that the entire flooded area was uncovered when Noah disembarked. The emergence of the land may have continued for an indefinite period, permitting the prevailing water to modify the climate of all western and ceutral Asia for many cents. Evidence that this was the case will be found in a later paragraph. In considering the credibility of the Bib. story we encounter at the outset the question whether the narrative compels us to believe the 11. Was Flood to have been universal. In the Flood answer, it is sufficient to suggest that . Universal? since the purpose of the judgment was the destruction of the human race, all the universality which it is necessary to infer from the language would be only such as was sufficient to accomplish that object. If man was at that time limited to the Euphrates valley, the submergence of that area would meet all the necessary conditions. Such a limitation is more easily accepted from the fact that general phrases like ‘“Everybody knows,” “The whole country was aroused,” are never in literature literally interpreted. When it is said (Gen 41 54-57) that the famine was ‘‘in all lands,” and over “all the face of the earth,” and that “all countries came into Egypt .... to buy grain,” no one supposes that it is intended to imply that the irrigated plains of Babylonia, from which the patriarchs had emigrated, were suffering from drought like Pal. (For other examples of the familiar use of this hyperbole, see Dt 2 25; Job 37 3; Acts 2 25; Rom 1 8.) As to the extent to which the human race was spread over the earth at the time of the Flood, two suppositions are possible. First, that of Hugh Miller (Testimony of the Rocks) that, owing to the shortness of the antediluvian chronology, and the violence and moral corruption of the people, popula- tion had not spread beyond the boundary of western Asia. An insuperable. objection to this theory is that the later discoveries have brought to light remains of prehistoric man from all over the northern hemisphere, showing that long before the time of the Flood he had become widely scattered. _ Another theory, supported by much evidence, is that, in connection with the enormous physical changes in the earth’s surface during the closing scenes of the Glacial epoch, man had perished from off the face of the earth except in the valley of the Euphrates, and that the Noachian Deluge is the final catastrophe in that series of destructive events (see ANTEDILUVIANS). The facts concerning the Glacial epoch naturally lead up to this conclusion. For during the entire epoch, and esp. at its close, the conditions affecting the level of the land sur- faces of the northern hemisphere were extremely abnormal], and continued so until some time after man had appeared on the earth. The Glacial epoch followed upon, and probably was a consequence of, an extensive elevation of all the land surfaces of the northern hemisphere at 825 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Deluge of Noah the close of the Tertiary period. This elevation was certainly as much as 2,000 ft. over the northern art of the United States, and over Canada and orthern Europe. Snow accumulated over this high land until the ice formed by it was certainly a mile thick, and some of the best authorities say 2, or even 3 miles. The surface over which this was spread amounted to 2,000,000 sq. miles in Europe and 4,000,000 in North America. The total amount of the accumulation would therefore be 6,000,000 cubic miles at the lowest calculation, or twice or three times that amount if the largest estimates are accepted. (For detailed evidence see Wright, Ice Age in North America, 5th ed.) But in either case the transference of so much weight from the ocean beds to the land surfaces of the northern hemisphere brings into the problem a physical force sufficient to produce incalculable effects. The weight of 6,000,000 cubic miles of ice would be twenty-four thousand million million (24,000,000,000,000,000) tons, which is equal to that of the entire North American continent above sea level. Furthermore this weight was first re- moved from the ocean beds, thus disturbing still more the balance of forces which secure the stability of the land. The geological evidence is abundant that in connection with the overloading of the land surfaces in the Northern Hemisphere, and probably by reason of it, the glaciated area and a considerable margin outside of it sank down until it was depressed far below the present level. The post-Glacial depression in North America was certainly 600 ft. below sea level at Montreal, and several hundred feet lower farther north. In Sweden the post-Glacial sea beaches show a depres- sion of the land 1,000 ft. below the sea. The evidences of a long-continued post-Glacial subsidence of the Aral-Caspian basin and much of the surrounding area is equally conclusive. At Trebizond, on the Black Sea, there is an extensive recent sea beach clinging to the precipitous volcanic mountain back of the city 750 ft. above the present water level. The gravel in this beach is so fresh as to compel a belief in its recent origin, while it cer- tainly has been deposited by a body of water stand~ ing at that elevation after the rock erosion of the region had been almost entirely effected. The deposit is about 100 ft. thick, and extends along the precipitous face of the mountain for a half-mile or more. So extensive is it that it furnishes an attractive building place for a monastery. When the water was high enough to build up this shore line, it would cover all the plains of southern Russia, of Western Siberia and of the Aral-Caspian depres- sion in Turkestan. Similar terraces of correspond- ing height are reported by competent authorities on the south shore of the Crimea and at Baku, on the Caspian Sea. Further and most interesting evidence of this post-Glacial land depression is found in the exist- ence of Arctic seal 2,000 miles from the Arctic Ocean in bodies of water as widely separated as the Caspian Sea, the Aral Sea and Lake Baikal. Lake Baikal is now 1,500 ft. above sea level. It is evident, therefore, that there must have been a recent depres- sion of the whole area to admit the migration of this species to that distant locality. ‘There are also clear indications of a smaller depression around the eastern shores of the Mediterranean Sea, where there are abandoned sea beaches from 200 to 300 ft. above tide, which abound in species of shells identical with those now living nearby. These are found in Egypt, in the valley of the Red Sea, and in the vicinity of Joppa and Beirdt. During their formation Asia and Africa must have been separated by a wide stretch of water connect- ing the Mediterranean with the Red Sea. The effect of such lingering wide expanses of water upon the climate of Western Asia must have been pro- found, and would naturally provide those condi- tions which would favor the early development of the human race in Armenia (where even now at an elevation of 5,000 ft. the vine is indigenous), from which the second distribution of mankind is said to have taken place. Furthermore there is indubitable evidence that the rainfall in central Asia was, at a comparatively recent time, immensely greater than it has been in the historic period, indicating that gradual passage from the conditions connected with the Deluge to those of the present time, at which we have hinted above. At the present time the evapora~ tion over the Aral Sea is so great that two rivers (the ancient Oxus and the Jaxartes), coming down from the heights of central Asia, each with a volume as great as that of Niagara, do not suffice to cause an overflow into the Caspian Sea. But the exist- ence of such an overflow during the prehistoric period is so plain that it has been proposed to utilize its channel (which is a mile wide and as distinctly marked as that of any living stream) for a canal. Owing to the comparatively brief duration of the Noachian Deluge proper, we cannot expect to find many positive indications of its occurrence. Nevertheless, Professor Prestwich (than whom there has been no higher geological authority in England during the last cent.) adduces an array of facts relating to Western Europe and the Mediterranean basin which cannot be ignored (see Phil. Trans. of the Royal Soc. of Lond., CXXIV_ [1893], 903-84; SCOT, 238-82). Among these evidences one of the most convincing is to be found in the cave of San Ciro at the base of the mountains surrounding the plain of Palermo in Sicily. In this cave there was found an immense mass of the bones of hippo- potami of all ages down to the foetus, mingled with a few of the deer, ox and elephant. These were so fresh when discovered that they were cut into ornaments and polished and still retained a con- siderable amount of their nitrogenous matter. Twenty tons of these bones were shipped for com- mercial purposes in the first six months after their discovery. Evidently the animals furnishing these bones had taken refuge in this cave to escape the rising water which had driven them in from the surrounding plains and cooped them up in the amphitheater of mountains during a gradual depression of the land. Similar collections of bones are found in various ossiferous fissures, in England and Western Europe, notably in the Rock of Gibral- tar and at Santenay, a few miles 8. of Chalons in central France, where there is an accumulation of bones in fissures 1,000 ft. above the sea, similar in many respects to that in the cave described at San Ciro, though the bones of hippopotami did not appear in these places; but the ee of wolves, bears, horses and oxen, none of which had been gnawed by carnivora, were indiscriminately com- mingled as though swept in by all-pervading cur- rents of water. Still further evidence is adduced in the deposits connected with what is called the rubble drift on both sides of the English Channel and on the Jersey Islands. Here in various locali- ties, notably at Brighton, England, and near Calais, France, elephant bones and human implements occur beneath deep deposits of unassorted drift, which is not glacial nor the product of limited and local streams of water, but can be accounted for only by general waves of translation produced when the land was being rcélevated from beneath the water by a series of such sudden earthquake shocks as cause the tidal waves which are often so destructive. Thus, while we cannot appeal to geology for direct, proof of the Noachian Deluge, recent geologi- Delusion Demon THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 826 cal discoveries do show that such a catastrophe is perfectly credible from a scientific point of view; and the supposition that there was a universal destruction of the human race, in the northern hemisphere at least, in connection with the floods accompanying the melting off of the glacial ice is supported by a great amount of evidence. There was certainly an extensive destruction of animal species associated with man during that period. In Europe the great Irish elk, the machairodus, the cave lion, the rhinoceros, the hippopotamus and the elephant disappeared with prehistoric man, amid the floods at the close of the Glacial epoch. In North America equally large felines, together with horses, tapirs, llamas, great mastodons and ele- hants and the huge megalonyx went to destruction mM connection with the same floods that destroyed so large a part of the human race during the dra- matic closing scenes of the period. It is, therefore, by no means difficult for an all-round geologist to believe in a final catastrophe such as is described in Gen. If we disbelieve in the Bib. Deluge it is not because we know too much geology, but too little. Grorce Freperick WRIGHT DELUSION, dé-li’zhun: (1) Isa 66 4, “I also will choose their delusions’ (RVm ‘‘mockings’”), Heb ta‘dlulim, which occurs only here and Isa 3 4 (where it is trd “babes,” RVm “childishness’’). Its meaning is somewhat ambiguous. The best tr seems to be “wantonness,” ‘‘caprice.” ‘Their wanton dealing, i.e. that inflicted on them” (BDB). Other tr® suggested are “insults” (Skinner), ‘‘freaks of fortune” (Cheyne), ‘follies’ (Whitehouse). LXX has empaigmata, ‘“‘mockings,” Vulg illusiones. (2) 2 Thess 2 11 AV, ‘‘God shall send them strong delusion” (RV ‘God sendeth them a working of error’), wAdvy, pldné, “a wandering,” ‘a roaming about,” in the NT “error,” either of opinion or of conduct. D. Miat, Epwarps DEMAND, dé-mand’: The peremptory, impera- tive sense is absent from this word in its occurrences in AV, where it means no more than ‘ask,’ “in- quire” (cf Fr. demander) one or the other of which RV substitutes in 28 11 7; Mt 2 4; Lk 3 14; 17 20; Acts 21 33. RV retains “demand” in Ex 6 14; Job 38 3; 40 7; 42 4; Dnl 2 27; and inserts it (AV “‘require’’) in Neh 6 18. DEMAS, dé’mas (Anpas, Démds, ‘“popular”): According to Col 4 14; 2 Tim 4 10; Philem ver 24, one who was for a time a ‘‘fellow-worker” with Paul at Rome (Col, Philem), but at last, “having loved this present world,” forsook the apostle and betook himself to Thessalonica (2 Tim). No other particulars are given concerning him. See Apostasy; DEMETRIUS. DEMETRIUS, dé-métri-us (Anpiatpios, Démé- tries, ‘‘of”’ or “belonging to Demeter,” an ordinary name in Greece): (1) Demetrius I, surnamed Zwrijp, Sétér (“‘sav- jour’), was the son of Seleucus IV (Philopator). He was sent as a boy to Rome, by his father, to serve as a hostage, and remained there quietly dur- ing his father’s life. He was detained also during the reign of his uncle, ANTIOcHUS EpIpHanes (q.v.) from 175 to 164 BC; but when Antiochus died De- metrius, who was now a young man of 23 (Polyb. xxxi.12), chafed at a longer detention, particularly as his cousin, Antiochus Eupator, a boy of 9, suc- ceeded to the kingdom with Lysias as his guardian. The Rom Senate, however, refused to listen to his plea for the restoration to Syria, because, as Polyb- ius says, they felt surer of their power over Syria with a mere boy as king. In the meantime, a quarrel had arisen hetween Ptolemy Philometor and Euergetes Physkon (Livy Epit. 46; Diod. Sic. fr xi), and Gnaeus Octavius, who had been sent to quell the disorder, was assassinated in Syria, while plundering the country. Demetrius, taking advantage of the troubled condition of affairs, consulted with his friend Polybius as to the advis- ability of attempting to seize the throne of Syria (op. cit. xxxi.19). The historian advised him not to stumble twice on the same stone, but to venture something worthy of a king, so after a second un- successful appeal to the Senate, Demetrius escaped to Tripolis, and from there advanced to Antioch where he was proclaimed king (162 BC). His first act was to put to death young Antiochus, his cousin, and his minister Lysias (Appian, Syr., c. 47; Ant, XII, x, 1; 1 Mace 7 1-4; 2 Mace 14 1.2). As soon as he was established in power, Deme- trius made an attempt to placate the Romans by sending them valuable gifts as well as the assassin of Gn. Octavius (Polyb. xxi.23); and he then tried to secure the Hellenizing party by sending his friend Baccurpes (q.v.) to make the wicked Alcimus high priest. After a violent struggle and much treachery on the part of Bacchides (Ant, XII, x, 2), the latter left the country, having charged all the people to obey Alcimus, who was protected by an army. The Jews uuder Judas resented his presence, and Judas inflicted severe punishment on all who had gone over to Alcimus (1 Macc 7 24). Alcimus, in fear, sent a message for aid to Demetrius, who sent to his assistance Nicanor, the best disposed and most faithful of his friends, who had accompanied him in his flight from Rome (Ant, XII, x, 4). On his arrival in Judaea, he attempted to win by guile, but Judas saw through his treachery, and Nicanor was forced to fight openly, suffering two signal defeats, the first at Capharsalama (1 Macc 7 31.32), and the second (in which Nicanor himself was killed), at Adasa (7 39 ff; 2 Macc 15 26 ff). In a short while, however, Demetrius, hearing of the death of Nicanor, sent Bacchides and Alcimus into Judaea again (1 Macc 9 1). Judas arose against them with an army of 3,000 men, but when these saw that 20,000 opposed them, the greater part of them deserted, and Judas, with an army of 800, lost his life, like another Leonidas, on the field of battle (1 Macc 9 4.6.18). Then Bacchides took the wicked men and made them lords of the country (1 Mace 9 25); while Jonathan, who was appointed ee to Judas, fled with his friends (1 Mace 9 During the next seven years, Demetrius succeeded in alienating both the Romans (Polyb. xxxii.20) and his own people, and ALEXANDER Batas (q.v.) was put forward as a claimant to the throne, his supporters maintaining that he was the son of An- tiochus Epiphanes (1 Macc 10 1-21; Ant, XIII, ii, 1-3). Both Alexander and Demetrius made bids for the support of the Jews, the former offering the high-priesthood and the title of King’s Friend (1 Macc 10 20), and the latter freedom from taxes, tributes and customs (10 28 ff). Alexander’s bait proved more alluring, since the Jews “gave no credence” to the words of Demetrius, and with the aid of the Maccabees, he vied with Demetrius for the space of two years for the complete sovereignty of Syria. At the end of this time, a decisive battle took place, in which Demetrius was slain, and Alex- ander became king of Syria (150 BC) (10 48-50; Ant, XIII, ii, 4; Polyb. ii1.5; see also MaccaBmns). (2) Demetrius Tl, surnamed Nixdrwp, Nikdtor (“conqueror”), was the son of Demetrius Soter. When Balas was warring with Demetrius I, he sent his son to a place of safety in Crete. Three years after his father’s death (147 BC), the unpopularity of Alexander gave the young man an opportunity 827 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Delusion Demon to return and seize the government. He landed in Cilicia with Cretan mercenaries and secured the support of all Syria with the exception of Judaea (1 Mace 10 67 ff). Apollonius, his general, the governor of Coele-Syria, who essayed the conquest of the Jews, was defeated at Azotus with great loss. Ptolemy Philometor, whose daughter was the wife of Alexander Balas, now entered into the struggle, and taking Cleopatra, his daughter, from Alexander, he gave her to Demetrius (11 12). He then joined Demetrius’ army and the combined forces inflicted a defeat on Balas (145 BC), and from this Demetrius received his surname Nikator (Ant, XIII, iv, 8; 1 Macc 11 14ff). Jonathan now concluded a favorable treaty with Demetrius, whereby three Samaritan provinces were added to Judaea and the whole country was made exempt from tax (1 Mace 11 20-37; Ant, XIII, iv, 9). Demetrius then dismissed his army except the foreigners, thinking himself safe with the loyalty of the Jews assured. In the meantime, Tryphon, one of Balas’ generals, set up the son of Alexander, Antiochus, as a claimant to the throne, and secured the assistance of the discarded army of Demetrius. Jonathan’s aid was sought and he quelled the rebel- lion, on condition that the Syrian garrison be re- me from Jerus (1 Mace 11 41-52; Ant, XIII, v, 2-3). j The king, however, falsified all that he had said, and kept none of his promises, so the Jews, deserting him, took sides with Tryphon and supported the claims of the boy Antiochus (1 Macc 11 53-59; Ant, XIII, v, 5-11). Demetrius’ generals then entered Syria but were defeated by Jonathan at Hazor (1 Mace 11 63-74), and by skilful general- ship he made futile a second attempt at invasion (12 24 ff). Tryphon, who was now master of Syria, broke faith with Jonathan (12 40) and essayed the con- quest of Judaea. Jonathan was killed by treachery, and Simon, his successor, made proposals of peace to Demetrius, who agreed to let bygones be bygones (1 Mace 13 36-40; Ant, XIII, vi, 7). Demetrius then left Simon to carry on the war, and set out to Parthia, ostensibly to secure the assistance of the king, Mithridates, against Tryphon (1 Mace 14 1). Here he was captured and imprisoned (14 3; Ant, XIII, v, 11; Jos, however, puts this event in 140 rather than 138 BC). After an imprisonment of ten years, he was re- leased and resumed the sovereignty 128 BC, but becoming involved in a quarrel with Ptolemy Phy- kon, he was defeated in battle at Damascus. From this place, he fled to Tyre, where he was murdered in 125 BC, according to some, at the instigation of Cleopatra, his wife (Jos, Ant, XIII, ix, 3). (8) Demetrius III, Evxaipos, Hikairos (‘the fortunate”), was the son of Antiochus Grypus, and grandson of Demetrius Nikator. When his father died, civil war arose, in which his two elder brothers lost their lives, while Philip, the third_brother, secured part of Syria as his domain. Demetrius then took up his abode in Coele-Syria with Damas- cus as his capital (Ant, XIII, xiii, 4; BJ, I, iv, 4). War now broke out in Judaea between Alexander Jannaeus and his Pharisee subjects, who invited Demetrius to aid them. Thinking this a good opportunity to extend his realm, he joined the in- surgent Jews and together they defeated Jannaeus near Shechem (Ant, XIII, xiv,1; BJ, I, iv, 5). The Jews then deserted Demetrius, and he with- drew to Beroea, which was in the possession of his brother Philip. Demetrius besieged him, and Philip summoned the Parthians to his assistance. The tables were turned, and Demetrius, besieged in his camp and starved into submission, was taken prisoner and sent to Arsaces, who held him captive until his death (Ant, XIII, xiv, 3). The dates of his reign are not certain. ARTHUR J. KINSELLA DEMETRIUS, dé-m@’tri-us (AnpArpios, Démétrios, “belonging to Ceres’): The name of two persons: (1) A Christian disciple praised by St. John (3 Jn ver 12). (2) A silversmith of Ephesus who manufactured the little silver shrines of the goddess Diana to sell to the visiting pilgrims (Acts 19 23 ff). Because the teachings of Paul were injuring the trade of the silversmiths, there arose a riot of which Demetrius was the chief. Upon an inscription which Mr. Wood discovered among the ruins of the city, there appeared the name Demetrius, a warden of the Ephesian temple for the year 57 AD, and some authors believe the temple warden to be identical with the ringleader of the rebellion. The name, however, has been most common among the Greeks of every age. Because of its frequent use it cannot be supposed that Demetrius, the disciple of 3 Jn ver 12, was the silversmith of Ephesus, nor that Demas of 2 Tim 4 10, who bore the name in a contracted form, may be identified with him. E. J. Banxs DEMON, dé’mon, DEMONIAC, dé-md'ni-ak, DEMONOLOGY, dé-mon-ol’-8-ji (Aauévov, dai- ménion, earlier form Salpov, daimin=nvedpa axd- Baprov, wovypsv, pnetima akdtharton, ponérén, ‘“de- mon,” “unclean or evil spirit,’’ incorrectly rendered devil in AV): I. Definition.—The word daimén or daimonion seems originally to have had two closely related meanings; a deity, and a spirit, superhuman but not supernatural. In the former sense the term occurs in the LXX tr of Dt 3217; Ps 106 37; Acts 17 18. The second of these meanings, which involves a general reference to vaguely conceived personal beings akin to men and yet belonging to the unseen realm, leads to the application of the term to the peculiar and restricted class of beings designated ‘“‘demons”’ in the NT. il. The Origin of Biblical Demonology.—An in- teresting scheme of development has been suggested (by Baudissin and others) in which Bib. demonism is brought through polytheism into connection with primitive animism. A simple criticism of this theory, which is now in the ascendant, will serve fittingly to introduce what should be said specifically concerning 1. The Evo- Bib. demonology. (1) Animism, which lutionary _is one branch of that general primitive Theory view of things which is designated as spiritism, is the theory that all Nature is alive (see Ladd, Phil. Rel., 1, 891) and that all natural processes are due to the operation of living wills. (2) Polytheism is supposed to be the out- come of animism. The vaguely conceived spirits of the earlier conception are advanced to the posi- tion of deities with names, fixed characters and specific functions, organized into a pantheon. (8) Bib. demonology is supposed to be due to the solvent of monotheism upon contemporary polytheism. The Hebrews were brought into contact with sur- rounding nations, esp. during the Pers, Bab and Gr periods, and monotheism made room for heathen- ism by reducing its deities to the dimension of demons. They are not denied all objective reality, but are denied the dignity and prerogatives of deity. The objections to this ingenious theory are too many and too serious to be overcome. (1) The genetic connection between animism 2, Objec- and polytheism is not clear. In fact, tions to the the specific religious character of ani- Theory mism is altogether problematical. It belongs to the category of primitive philosophy rather than of religion. It is difficult Demon Den THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 828 to trace the process by which spirits unnamed and with characteristics of the vaguest become deities —esp. is it difficult to understand how certain spirits only are advanced to the standing of deities. More serious still, polytheism and animism have coexisted without close combination or real assimilation (see Sayce, Babylonia and Assyria, 232; Rogers, Religion of Babylonia and Assyria, 751) for a long course of history. It looks as if animism and polytheism had a different raison d’étre, origin and development. It is, at least, unsafe to construct a theory on the basis of so insecure a connection. (2) The inter- pretation of heathen deities as demons by no means indicates that polytheism is the source of Bib. demonology. On general principles, it seems far more likely that the category of demons was already familiar, and that connection with polytheism brought about an extension of its application. A glance at the OT will show how comparatively slight and unimportant has-been the bearing of heathen polytheism upon Bib. thought. The de- monology of the OT is confined to the following pas- sages: Lev 16 21.22; 177; Isa 13 21; 34 13; Dt 32 17; Ps 106 37 (elsewhere commented upon; see CoMMUNION witH Demons). Gesenius well says of Lev 16 21 that it is ‘vexed with the nu- merous conjectures of interpreters.”’ If the preva- lent modern view is accepted we find in it an actual meeting-point of popular superstition and the reli- gion of Jeh (see AzazgL). According to Driver (HDB, I, 207), this item in the Levitical ritual ‘was intended as a symbolical declaration that the land and the people are now purged from guilt, their sins being handed over to the evil spirit to whom they are held to belong, and whose home is in the desolate wilderness remote from human habitations (ver 22, into a land cut off)’ A more striking instance could scarcely be sought of the way in which the religion of Jeh kept the popular spiritism at a safe distance. Lev 17 7 (see ComMUNION witH Demons) refers to participation in the rites of heathen worship. The two passages—Isa 13 20.21; 34 13.14—are poetical and really imply nothing as to the writer’s own belief. Creatures both seen and unseen supposed to inhabit places deserted of man are’used, as any poet might use them, to furnish the details for a vivid word-picture of uninhabited solitude. There is no direct evidence that the narrative of the Fall (Gen 3 1-19) has any connection with demonology (see HDB, I, 590 n.), and the suggestion of Whitehouse that the mention of satyrs and night-monsters of current mythology with such creatures as jackals, etc, im- ples ‘that demons were held to reside more or less in all these animal denizens of the ruined solitude” is clearly fanciful. It is almost startling to find that all that can possibly be affirmed of demonology in the OT is confined to a small group of passages which are either legal or poetical and which all furnish examples of the inhibiting power of high religious conceptions upon the minds of a naturally super- stitious and imaginative people. Even if we add all the passages in which a real existence seems to be granted to heathen deities (e.g. Nu 21 29; Isa 19 1, etc) and interpret them in the extreme sense, we are still compelled to affirm that evidence is lacking to prove the influence of polytheism in the formation of the Bib. doctrine of demons. (3) This theory breaks down in another still more vital par- ticular. The demonology of the Bible is not of kin either with primitive animism or popular Sem de- monism. In what follows we shall address our- selves to NT demonology—that of the OT being a negligible quantity. : J. NT Demonology.—The most marked and significant fact of NT demonology is that it provides no materials for a discussion of the nature and char- acteristics of demons. Whitehouse says (HDB, I, 593) that NT demonology ‘‘is in all its broad char- acteristics the demonology of the contemporary Judaism stripped of its cruder and exaggerated features.” How much short of the whole truth this statement. comes will appear later, but as it stands it defines the specific direction of inquiry into the NT treatment of demons; namely, to ex- plain its freedom from the crude and exaggerated features of popular demonism. The presence among NT writers of an influence curbing curiosity and restraining the imagination is of all things the most important for us to discover and emphasize. In four of its most vital features the NT attitude on this subject differs from all popular conceptions: (a) in the absence of all imaginative details concern- ing demons; (b) in the emphasis placed upon the moral character of demons and their connection with the ethical disorders of the human race; (c) in the absence of confidence in magical methods of any kind in dealing with demons; (d) in its in- tense restrictions of the sphere of demoniacal opera- tions. A brief treatment under each of these heads will serve to present an ordered statement of the mosi important facts. (a) In the NT we are told practically nothing about the origin, nature, characteristics or habits of demons. In a highly figurative passage (Mt 12 43) Our Lord speaks of demons as passing through “waterless places,’’ and in the story of the Gadarene demoniac (Lk 8 31) the “abyss” is mentioned as the place of their ultimate detention. The method of their control over human beings is represented in two contrasted ways (cf Mk I 23 ff; Lk 4 33 ff), indicating that there was no fixed mode of regard- ing it. With these three scant items our direct information ceases. We are compelled to infer from the effects given in the limited number of specific instances narrated. And it is worthy of more than passing mention that no theoretical discussion of demons occurs. The center of interest in the Gospels is the person of Jesus, the sufferers and the cures. Interest in the demons as such is absent. Certain passages seem to indicate that the demons were able to speak (see Mk 1 24.26.34; Lk 4 41, etc), but comparing these statements with others (cf Mk 1 23; Lk 8 28) it is seen that no distinction is drawn between the cries of the tormented in the paroxysms of their complaint and the cries attrib- uted to the demons themselves. In other particu- lars the representation is consistent. The demons belong to the unseen world, they are incapable of manifestation except in the disorders which they cause—there are no materializations, no grotesque narratives of appearances and disappearances, no morbid dealing with repulsive details, no license of speculation in the narratives. In contrast with this reticence is not merely the demonology of primi- tive people, but also that of the non-canonical Jew- ish books. In the Book of En demons are said to be fallen angels, while Jos holds that they are the spirits of the wicked dead. In the rabbini- cal writings speculation has run riot in discussing the origin, nature and habits of demons. They are represented as the offspring of Adam and Eve in conjunction with male and female spirits, as being themselves sexed and capable of reproduction as well as performing all other physical functions. Details are given of their numbers, haunts and habits, of times and places where they are esp. dangerous, and of ways and methods of breaking their power (see Exorcism). Full sweep is also given to the imagination in descriptive narratives, oftentimes of the most morbid and unwholesome character, of their doings among men. After read- ing some of these narratives one can agree with 829 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Demon Den Edersheim when he says, “Greater contrast could scarcely be conceived than between what we read in the NT and the views and practices mentioned in Rabbinic writings’ (LTJM, II, 776). (b) It is also clearly to be noted that while in its original application the term daimonion is morally indifferent, in NT usage the demon is invariably an ethically evil being. This differentiates the NT treatment from extra-canonical Jewish writings. In the NT demons belong to the kingdom of Satan whose power it is the mission of Christ to destroy. It deepens and intensifies its representations of the earnestness of human life and its moral issues by extending the sphere of moral struggle to the invis- ible world. It clearly teaches that the power of Christ extends to the world of evil spirits and that faith in Him is adequate protection against any evils to which men may be exposed. (For significance of this point see Plummer, Si. Luke [ICC], 132-33.) (c) The NT demonology differs from all others by its negation of the power of magic rites to deliver from the affliction. agic which is clearly sep- arable from religion at that specific point (see Gwat- kin, Knowledge of God, I, 249) rests upon and is dependent upon spiritism. ‘The ancient Bab incan- tation texts, forming a surprisingly large proportion of the extant documents, are addressed Ginactly to the supposed activities and powers of demons. These beings, who are not trusted and prayed to in the sense in which deities are, command confidence and call forth prayer, are dealt with by magic rites and formulas (see Rogers, op. cit., 144). Even the Jew- ish non-canonical writings contain numerous forms of words and ceremonies for the expulsion of demons. In the NT there is no magic. The deliverance from a demon is a spiritual and ethical process (see Exorcism). (d) In the NT the range of activities attributed to demons is greatly restricted. According to Bab ideas: ‘These demons were everywhere; they lurked in every corner, watching for their prey. The city streets knew their malevolent presence, the rivers, the seas, the tops of mountains; they appeared sometimes as serpents gliding noiselessly upon their victims, as birds horrid of mien flying resistlessly to destroy or afflict, as begs in human forms, grotesque, malformed, awe-inspiring through their hideousness. To these demons all sorts of misfortune were ascribed—a toothache, a head- ache, a broken bone, a raging fever, an outburst of anger, of jealousy, of incomprehensible disease’ (Rogers, op. cit., 145). In the extra-canonical Jewish sources the same exuberance of fancy appears in attributing all kinds of ills of mind and body to innumerable, swarming hosts of demons lying in wait for men and besieging them with attacks and ills of all descriptions. Of this affluence of morbid fancy there is no hintinthe NT. A careful analysis of the instances will show the importance of this fact. There are, taking repetitions and all, about 80 references to demons in the NT. In 11 in- stances the distinction between demon-possession and diseases ordinarily caused is clearly made (Mt 424, 816; 108; Mk 1 32.34; 6 138; 16 17.18; Lk 4 40.41; 91; 13 32; Acts 19 12). The results of demon-possession are not exclusively mental or nervous (Mt 9 32.33; 12 22). They are distinctly and peculiarly mental in two instances only (Gada- rene maniac, Mt 8 28 and parallels, and Acts 19 13 f). Epilepsy is specified in one case only (Mt 17 15). There is distinction made between demonized and epileptic, and demonized and lunatic (Mt 4 24). There is distinction made between diseases caused by demons and the same disease not so caused (cf Mt 12 22;°16 30). In most of the instances no specific symptoms are mentioned. In an equally large proportion, however, there are occasional fits of mental excitement often due to the presence and teaching of Christ. A summary of the entire material leads to the conclusion that, in the NT cases of demon-possession, we have a specific type of disturbance, Conclusions physical or mental, distinguishable not so much by its symptoms which were often of the most general character, as by its accom- panimenis. ‘The aura, so to say, which surrounded the patient, served to distinguish his symptoms and to point out the special cause to which his suffering was attributed. Another unique feature of NT de- monology should be emphasized. While this group of disorders is attributed to demons, the victims are treated as sick folk and are healed. The whole atmosphere surrounding the narrative of these inci- dents is calm, lofty and pervaded with the spirit of Christ. When one remembers the manifold cruelties inspired by the unreasoning fear of demons, which make the annals of savage medicine a nightmare of -unimaginable horrors, we cannot but feel the world- wide difference between the Bib. narratives and all others, both of ancient and modern times, with which we are acquainted. Every feature of the NT narratives points to the conclusion that in them we have trustworthy reports of actual cures. This is more important for NT faith than any other con- clusion could possibly be. It is also evident that Jesus treated these cases of invaded personality, of bondage, of depression, of helpless fear, as due to a real superhuman cause, to meet and overcome which He addressed Himself. The most distinctive and important words we have upon this obscure and difficult subject, upon which we know far too little to speak with any assurance or authority, are these: ‘This kind can come out by nothing, save by prayer” (Mk 9 29). Literature.—(1) The most accessible statement of Baudissin's theory is in Whitehouse’s art. ‘’ Demons," ete, in HDB. (2) For extra-canonical Jewish ideas use Lange, Apocrypha, 118, 134; Edersheim, LT/ M, Appen- dices XIII, XVI. (3) For spirit-lore in general see Ladd, Phil. Rel., index s.v., and standard books on Anthropology and Philosophy of Religion under Spiritism. (4) For Bab demonology see summary in Rogers, Religion of Babylonia and Assyria, 144 ff. Louis Mattuews Sweet DEMOPHON, dem’é-fon (Anpodav, Démophén): A Syrian general in Pal under Antiochus V (Eupa- tor) who continued to harass the Jews after cove- nants had been made between Lysias and Judas Maccabaeus (2 Macc 12 2). DEN (3192, ma‘in, MW, m‘onah, “habita- tion’; W190, m“arah, and omfAaov, spélaion, “cave”; MIN, m’drah [Isa 11 8), “a light-hole,” fr VAS, dr, “light,” perhaps for m*‘arah; JO, sokh [Ps 10 9 AV], and 190, sukkah [Job 38 40], “a covert,” elséwhere “booth”; 27%, ’erebh[Job 37 8], “covert,” asin RV; Aa, gobh; cf Arab. jubb, ‘“pit” [Dul 6 7]; MII, minkaréth, “fissure” or “cleft” [Jgs 6 2]): In the limestone mountains of Pal, caves, large and small, are abundant, the calcium carbonate, of which the rock is mainly composed, being dis- solved by the water as it trickles over them or through their crevices. Even on the plains, by a similar process, pits or ‘lime sinks” are formed, which are sometimes used by the Arabs for storing straw or grain. Of this sort may have been the pit, bor, into which Joseph was cast by his brethren (Gen 37 20). Caves and crevices and sometimes spaces among piled-up bowlders at the foot of a cliff or ina stream bed are used as dens by jackals, wolves and other wild animals. Even the people, for longer or shorter periods, have lived as troglodytes. Cf Jgs 6 2: ‘Because of Midian the children of Israel made them the dens [minharoth] which are in the mountains, and the caves [m*‘arah], and the strong- Denarius Desert THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 830 holds [m*¢adh].” The precipitous sides of the valleys contain many caves converted by a little labor into human habitations. Notable instances are the val- ley of the Kidron near Méar-Saba, and Wadi-ul- Hamam near the Sea of Tiberias. See Cave. Aurrep Evy Day DENARIUS, dénd’ri-us (8yvdpuov, déndrion): A Rom silver coin, 25 of which went to the aureus, the standard gold coin of the empire in the time of Augustus, which was equal in value to about one guinea or $5.25; more exactly £1.0.6=$5.00, the £=$4.866. Hence the value of the denarius Denarius of Tiberius. would be about 20 cents and this was the ordinary wage of a soldier and a day laborer. The word is uniformly rendered “penny” in the AV and “shil- ling” in the ARV, except in Mt 22 19; Mk 12 15 and Lk 20 24, where the Lat word is used, since in these passsages it refers to the coin in which tribute was paid to the Rom government. See Money. H. Porter DENOUNCE, dé-nouns’: Occurs in Dt 30 18: “T denounce unto you this day, that ye shall surely perish.” It is used here in the obsolete sense of “to declare,’ to make known in a solemn manner. It is not found in the Bible with the regular meaning of “to censure,” “arraign,”’ etc. DENY, dé-ni’: This word is characteristic of the NT rather than the OT, although it translates three different Heb originals, viz. UND, kahash, ‘‘to lie,” “disown” (Gen 18 15; Josh 24 27; Job 8 18; 31 28; Prov 30 9); 23, mdna'‘, “to withhold,” “keep back” (1 K 20 7; Prov 30 7); AAW, shabh, “to turn back,” “say no” (1 K 2 16). In the NT, é»riéyw, antilégd, is once tr¢ deny,” in the case of the Sadducees who denied the resur- rection (Lk 20 27 AV), and where it carries the sense of speaking against the doctrine. But the word commonly is dpvéouat, arnéomai, with or without the prefix ap. In the absence of the pre- fix the sense 1s ‘‘to disown,”’ but when it is added it means “to disown totally” or to the fullest extent. In the milder sense it is found in Mt 10 33; 26 70. 72; of Simon Peter, Mk 14 68.70 (Acts 3 13.14; 2 Tim 212.18; 2 Pet 21; 1 Jn 2 22.23; Jude ver 4; Rev 2 13; 3 8). But it is significant that the sterner meaning is associated with Mt 16 24 and its parallels, where Christ calls upon him who would be His disciple to deny himself and take up his cross and follow Him. See also Peter, Sruon. : James M. Gray DEPOSIT, dé-poz’it (mwapadykyn, parathéke, 1 Tim 6 20; 2 Tim 1 12.14 RVm, paraphrased in both AV and RV into ‘that which is committed” [see CommEND]): The noun was used in the classical Gr, just as its Eng. equivalents, for “that which is placed with another for safe keeping,’ a charge committed to another’s hands, consisting often of money or property; cf Ex 22 7; Lev 6 2. This ractice was common in days when there were no anks. (1) In 1 Tim 6 20; also 2 Tim 1 14, the reference is to a deposit which God makes with man, and for which man is to give a reckoning. The context shows that this deposit is the Christian faith, “the pattern of sound words’ (2 Tim 1 18), that which is contrasted with the “oppositions of the knowledge which is falsely so called” (1 Tim 6 20). “Keep the talent of the Christian faith safe and undiminished” (Vincentius Lirenensis). (2) In2 Tim 1 12, the deposit is one which man makes with God. The key to the meaning of this expres- sion is found probably in Ps 31 5: “Into thy hand I commend my spirit: Thou hast redeemed me,” i.e. “All that I am, with all my interests, have been intrusted to Thy safe keeping, and, therefore, I have no anxieties with respect to the future. The day of reckoning, ‘that day,’ will show how faithful are the hands that hold this trust.” H. E. Jacozs DEPTH. See Apyss. DEPUTY, dep’ii-ti: This is the correct rendering of AX), niccdbh (1 K 22 47). In Est 8 9 and 9 3 the term improperly represents 730, sdghdn, in AV, and is corrected to ‘‘governor’” in RV. In the NT “deputy” represents dr@iraros, anthtipatos (Acts 13 7.8.12; 18 12; 19 38), which RV correctly renders ‘“‘proconsul’”’ (q.v.). The Rom proconsuls were officers invested with consular power over a district outside the city, usually for one year. Origi- nally they were retiring consuls, but after Augustus the title was given to governors of senatorial prov- inces, whether they had held the office of consul or not. The proconsul exercised judicial as well as military power in his province, and his authority was absolute, except as he might be held account- able at the expiration of his office. See GovErn- MENT. Wittuam Artour Heme. DERBE, dar’bé (AépBn, Dérbé, Acts 14 20.21; 16 1; AcpBatos, Derbaios, 20 4; AcpBarns, Derbétés, Strabo, Cicero): A city in the extreme 8.E. corner of the Lycaonian plain is mentioned twice as having been vistted by Paul (on his first and second mis- sionary journeys respectively), and it may now be regarded as highly probable that he passed through it on his third Journey (to the churches of Galatia). The view that these churches were in South Galatia is now accepted by the ma- jority of Eng. and Am. scholars, and a traveler pass- ing through the Cilician Gates to Southern Galatia must have traversed the territory of Derbe. Derbe is first mentioned as the seat of Antipater, who entertained Cicero, the Rom orator and gov- ernor of Cilicia. When the kingdom 1. History of Amyntas passed, at his death in 25 C, to the Romans, it was made into a province and called Galatia (see Gauatia). This province included Laranda as well as Derbe on the extreme S.E., and for a time Laranda was the frontier city looking toward Cappadocia and Cilicia and Syria via the Cilician Gates. But between 37 and 41 AD Laranda was transferred to the ‘‘pro- tected” kingdom of Antiochus, and Derbe became the frontier city. It was the last city on distinctively Rom territory, on the road leading from Southern Galatia to the E.; it was here that commerce enter- ing the province had to pay the customs dues. Strabo records this fact when he calls Derbe a limén or “customs station.’ It owed its importance (and consequently its visit from Paul on his first journey) to this fact, and to its position on a great Rom road leading from Antioch, the capital of Southern Gala- tia, to Iconium, Laranda, Heracleia-Cybistra, and the Cilician Gates. Rom milestones have been found along the line of this road, one at a point 15 miles N.W. of Derbe. It was one of those Lycao- nian cities honored with the title “Claudian” by the emperor Claudius; its coins bear the legend “Clau- dio-Derbe.”’ This implied considerable importance and prosperity as well as strong pro-Rom feeling; 831 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Denarius Desert yet we do not find Derbe standing aloof, like the Rom coloniae Iconium and Lystra, from the Com- mon Council of Lycaonian cities (Koinon Lyka- onias). Derbe remained in the provinco Galatia till about 135 AD, when it passed to the jurisdiction of the triple province Cilicia-Isauria-Lycaonia. It continued in this division till 295 AD, and was then included in the newly formed province Isauria. This arrangement lasted till about 372 AD, when Lycaonia, including Derbe, was formed into a separate province. The statement of Stephanus of Byzantium that Derbe was ‘‘a fortress of Isauria'' originated in the arrangement which existed from 295 to 372 AD. Coins of the city represent Hera- cles, Fortuna and a winged Victory writing on a shield (after the pattern of the Venus of Melos, in the Louvre, Paris). Derbe is mentioned several times in the records of the church councils. A bishop, Daphnus of Derbe, was present at the Council of Constantinople in 381. The site of Derbe was approximately fixed by the American explorer Sterrett, and more accurately by _ Sir W. M. Ramsay, who, after care- 2. Situation fully examining all the ruins in_ the neighborhood, placed it at Gudelisin. Up to 1911, certain epigraphic evidence fixing the site had not been found, but Ramsay’s identifica- tion meets all the conditions, and cannot be far wrong. On the E., Derbe was conterminous_ with Laranda, on the N.E. with Barata in the Kara Dagh. It bordered on the territory of Iconium on the N.W., and on Isauria on the W. Its territory touched the foothills of Taurus on the 8., and the site com- mands a fine view of the great mountain called Hadji Baba or the Pilgrim Father. The Greeks of the district say that the name is a reminiscence of St. Paul, “over whose travels” the mountain “stood as a silent witness.” The remains are mostly of the late Rom and Byzantine periods, but pottery of an earlier date has been found on the site. An inscription of a village on the territory of Derbe records the erection of a building by two archi- tects from Lystra. A line of boundary stones, separating the territory of Derbe from that of Barata, is still stand- ing. It probably belongs to an early delimitation of the territory of the frontier town of Galatia (Ramsay). In Acts 14 20.21, it is narrated that Paul and Barnabas, after being driven out of Lystra, de- parted to Derbe, where they “‘preached the gospel ....and made many disciples.” But they did not go farther. Paul’s mission included only the centers of Graeco-Rom civilization; it was no part of his plan to pass over the frontier of the prov- ince into non-Rom territory. This aspect of his purpose is illustrated by the reference to Derbe on his second journey (Acts 16 1). Paul started from Antioch and ‘“‘went through Syria and Cilicia, con- firming the churches” (16 41). ‘Then he came to Derbe and Lystra”’ (16 1AV). The unwarned reader might forget that in going from Cilicia to Derbe, Paul must have passed through a consider- able part of Antiochus’ territory, and visited the important cities of Heracleia-Cybistra and Laranda. But his work ends with the Rom Cilicia and begins again with the Rom Galatia; to him, the intervening country is a blank. Concentration of effort, and utilization only of the most fully prepared material were the characteristics of Paul’s missionary jour- neys in Asia Minor. That Paul was successful in Derbe may be gathered (as Ramsay points out) from the fact that he does not mention Derbe among the places where he had suffered persecution (2 Tim 3 11). Gaius of Derbe (among others) accom- panied Paul to Jerus, in charge of the donations of the churches to the poor in that city (Acts 20 4). LitERaTURE.—The only complete account of Derbe is that given in Sir W. M. Ramsay's Cities of St. Paul, 385— 404. On Paul's mission there, see the same author's St. Paul the Traveller and Rom Citizen, 119, 178. Many inscriptions of the later Rom period are collected in Sterrett, Wolfe Expedition to Asta Minor, Nos. 18-52. The principal ancient authorities, besides Acts, are Ci- 3. Paul at Derbe cero Ad Fam. xiii.73; Strabo xxx.569; Ptolemaeus, v.6, 17; Steph. Byz., Hierocl., 675; Notit. Episcop., 1, 404, and the Acta Conciliorum. W. M. Caper DERISION, dé-rizh’un: Three vbs. are so tr’: 72, lic, “scorn” (Ps 119 51); 332, la‘agh, “mock” (2 4; 59 8; Ezk 23 32); and pow, sakak, “laugh at” (Job 30 1; Ex 32 25m, ‘a whisper- ing’; cf Wisd 5 3). This word is found almost exclusively in the Psalms and Prophets; Jeremiah is fond of it. It is used both as a subst. and a vb., the latter in the phrase “‘to have in derision.” DESCEND, dé-send’ (177, ydradh; katoBalvo, katabaind, ‘go down’’); DESCENT, dé-sent’ (kard- Pacts, kaidbasis): Of Jeh (Ex 34 5); of the Spirit (Mt 3 16); of angels (Gen 28 12; Mt 28 2; Jn 1 51); of Christ (1 Thess 4 16; Eph 4 9). “He also descended into the lower parts of the earth” is variously interpreted, the two chief interpreta- tions being the one of the incarnation, and the other of the ‘‘descent into hell” (1 Pet 3 19). Theformer regards the clause ‘‘of the earth,” an appositive genitive, as when we speak of “the city of Rome,” viz., “the lower parts, ie. the earth.” The other regards the genitive as possessive, or, with Meyer, as governed by the comparative, ie. “parts lower than the earth.” For the former view, sce full discussion in Eadie; for the latter, Ellicott and esp. Meyer, in commentaries on Eph. H. E. Jacozs DESCENT, dé-sent’, OF JESUS. See Apocry- PHAL GOSPELS. DESCRIBE, dé-skrib’: This vb., now obsolete, in the sense used in Josh 18 4.6.8.9 and Jgs 8 14, is a tr of ADD, kathabh, usually rendered “to write” or “inscribe.” But in the above passages it has the OE meaning of dividing into parts or into lots, as for example: ‘Walk through the land, and de- scribe it according to their inheritance’ (Josh 18 4); that is, describe in writing the location and size of the several parcels of land thus portioned out. In Jgs 8 14 “described” should be tr* ‘‘wrote down a list of.”’ “Describe” occurs twice in the AV of the NT (Rom 4 6 and 10 5), where Aéyw, légs, and ypéow, grdphd, are both rendered ‘‘describeth.”’ RV corrects both, and substitutes “pronounceth” in the first and “‘writeth” in the second passage. Description =‘‘list”’ (1 Esd 5 39). W. W. Davies DESCRY, dé-skri’: This word like “describe” came into the Eng. through the Fr. descrire (Lat de- scribere); it occurs only in the AV of Jgs 1 23: “And the house of Joseph sent to descry Bethel.” “IM, tir, the vb. thus tr, signifies ‘to explore’ or “examine,” and RV correctly renders “sent to spy out. DESERT, dez’ért ("2T2, midhbar, M270, hor- bah, PAW), yshimon, DIY, ‘drabhah, WX, cryah, WIM, toh; tpypes, érémos, épypla erémia): Midh- bar, the commonest word for ‘desert,’ more often rendered ‘‘wilderness,” is perhaps from r. dabhar, in the sense of ‘‘to drive,” i.e. a place for driving or pasturing flocks. Y°shimén is from ya- sham, “to be empty”; horbah (cf Arab. kharib, “to lie waste”; khirbah, “a ruin”; khardb, “devasta- tion’’), from harabh, ‘to be dry”; ef also ‘drabh, ‘‘to be dry,” and ‘drabhah, “‘a desert” or “the Arabah” (see Cuamparan).. For ’ereg giydh (Ps 63.1; Isa 41 18), “a dry land,” cf ¢zy%m, “wild beasts of the desert” (Isa 13 21, etc). Tdh#, variously rendered “without form” (Gen 1 2 AV), “empty space,” AV “empty place” (Job 26 7), “waste,” AV “nothing” (Job 6 18), ‘confusion,’ RVm “wasteness’” (Isa 24 10 ERV), may be compared with Arab. éah, Desert Destroyer THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 832 “to go astray,” at-Tth, ‘the desert of the wander- ing.” In the NT we find erémos and erémia: “The child [John] . . . . was in the deserts till the day of his showing unto Israel” (Lk 1 80); “Our fathers did eat manna in the desert” (Jn 6 31 AV). In the Desert of Edom. The desert as known to the Israelites was not a waste of sand, as those are apt to imagine who have in mind the pictures of the Sahara. Great expanses of sand, it is true, are found in Arabia, but the near- est one, an- Nufud, was several days’ journey dis- tant from the farthest southeast reached by the Israelites in their wanderings. Most of the desert of Sinai and of Pal is Jand that needs only water to make it fruitful. E. of the Jordan, the line between “the desert”? and “the sown’’ lies about along the line of the Hijaz railway. To the W. there is barely enough water to support the crops of wheat; to the E. there is too little. Near the line of demarkation, the yield of wheat depends strictly upon the rain- fall. A few inches more or less of rain in the year determines whether the grain can reach maturity or not. The latent fertility of the desert lands is demonstrated by the season of scant rains, when they become carpeted with herbage and flowers. It 1s marvelous, too, how the camels, sheep and goats, even in the dry season, will find something to crop where the traveler sees nothing but absolute barren- ness. The long wandering of the Israelites in ‘‘the desert”? was made possible by the existence of food for their flocks and herds. Cf Ps 65 11.12: “Thou crownest the year with thy goodness; And thy paths drop fatness. They drop upon the pastures of the wilderness, And the hills are girded with joy’; and also Joel 2 22: ‘‘The pastures of the wilderness do spring.” “The desert” or “the wilderness” (ha-midhbar) usually signifies the desert of the wandering, or the northern part of the Sinaitic Peninsula. Cf Ex 38 1 AV: “Moses ... . led the flock [of Jethro] to the backside of the desert”; Ex 5 3 AV: “Let us go . ... three days’ journey into the desert”; Ex 19 2AV: “They .... were come to the desert of Sinai”; Ex 23 31 AV: “TI will set thy bounds from the Red Sea even unto the sea of the Philistines, and from the desert unto the river’ (Euphrates). Other uncultivated or pasture regions are known as Wilder- ness of Beersheba (Gen 21 14), W. of Judah (Jgs 1 16), W. of En-gedi (1 S 24 1), W. of Gibeon (2 8 2 24), W. of Maon (1 S 23 24), W. of Da- mascus; cf Arab. Badiyet-ush-Sham (1 K 19 15), etc. Midhber yam, “the wilderness of the sea” (Isa 21 1), may perhaps be that part of Arabia bordering upon the Pers Gulf. Aside from the towns and fields, practically all the land was midhbar or ‘‘desert,” for this term in- cluded mountain, plain and valley. The terms, “desert of En-gedi,” ‘desert of Maon,”’ etc, do not indicate circumscribed areas, but are applied in a general way to the lands about these places. To obtain water, the shepherds with their flocks traverse long distances to the wells, springs or streams, usu- ally arranging to reach the water about the middle of the day and rest about it for an hour or so, taking shelter from the sun in the shadows of the rocks, perhaps under some overhanging ledge. Autrrep Evy Day DESIRE, dé-zir’: The vb. “to desire” in the Scriptures usually means ‘‘to long for,” “to ask for,” “to demand,” and may be used in a good or bad sense (cf Dt 7 25 AV). RV frequently renders the more literal meaning of the Heb. Cf Job 20 20, “delight”; Prov 21 20, ‘“‘precious’”; Ps 40 6, “delight”; airéw, atté6 (except Col 1 9), and épwrdw, erdtdd (except Lk 7 36) are rendered ‘“‘to ask” and {yréw, zetéo, “to seek” (cf Lk 99 et al.). The Heb 502, kdsaph, lit. “to lose in value,” is trd (Zeph 2 1) by “hath no shame” (RVm “‘long- ing,” AV “not desired”). The literal tr ‘‘to lose in value,” “to degenerate,” would be more in har- mony with the context than the translations offered. The Heb 79M , hemdah (2 Ch 21 20, “without be- ing desired’), means according to the Arab. ‘‘to praise,” “to give thanks.”’ The context brings in contrast the burial of the king Jehoram with that of his fathers. In the latter case there was “burning,” i.e. recognition and praise, but when Jehoram died, there was no hemdah, i.e. there was no praise for his services rendered to the kingdom. For ‘“‘desire”’ in Eccl 12 5, see Caperserry. A. L. Bresiicu DESIRE OF ALL NATIONS: This phrase occurs only in Hag 27 (AV, ERV ‘desirable things,” ARVm ‘things desired’’), and is commonly applied to the Messiah. At the erection of the temple in Ezra’s time, the older men who had seen the more magnificent house of Solomon were disappointed and distressed at the comparison. The prophet, therefore, is directed to encourage them by the assurance that Jeh is with them nevertheless, and in a little while will shake the heavens, the earth, the sea, the dry land and the nations, and “‘the desire of all nations” shall come, and the house shall be filled with glory, so that ‘“‘the later glory of this house shall be greater than the former.” (1) Many expositors refer the prophecy to the first advent of Christ. The shaking of the heavens, the earth, the sea and the dry land is the figurative setting of the shaking of the nations, while this latter expression refers to those changes of earthly dominion coincident with the overthrow of the Per- sians by the Greeks, the Greeks by the Romans, and so on down to the beginning of our era. The house then in process of construction was filled with glory by the later presence of the Messiah, which glory was greater than the Shekinah of Solomon’s time. Objections are presented to this view as follows: First, there is the element of time. Five cents., more or less, elapsed between the building of Ezra’s temple and the first advent of Christ, and the men of Ezra’s time needed comfort for the present. Then there is the difficulty of associating the physical phenomena with any shaking of the nations occurring at the first advent. Furthermore, in what sense, it is asked, could Christ, when He came, be said to be the desire of all nations? And finally, what comfort would a Jew find in this mag- nifying of the Gentiles? (2) These difficulties, though not insuperable, lead others to apply the prophecy to the second advent of Christ. The Jews are to be restored to Jerus, and another temple is to be built (Ezk 40- 48). The shaking of the nations and the physical 833 henomena find their fulfilment in the ‘Great ribulation” so often spoken of in the OT and Rev, and which is followed by the coming of Christ in glory to set up His kingdom (Mal 3 1; Mt 24 29. 30 and other places). Some of the difficulties spoken of in the first instance apply here also, but not all of them, while others are common to both interpretations. One such common difficulty is that Ezra’s temple can hardly be identified with that of the time of Herod and Christ, and certainly not with that of Ezekiel; which is met, however, by saying that all the temples, including Sclomon’s, are treated as but one “‘house’—the house of the Lord, in the religious sense, at least, if not archi- tecturally. Another such difficulty touches the question of time, which, whether it includes five centuries or twenty, is met by the principle that to the prophets, “ascending in heart to God and the eternity of God, all times and all things of this world are only a mere point.’’ When the precise time of particular events is not revealed, they sometimes describe them as continuous, and sometimes blend two events together, having a near or partial, and also a remote or complete fulfilment. “They saw the future in space rather than in time, or the per- spective rather than the actual distance.” It is noted that the Lord Jesus so blends together the destruction of Jerus by Titus, AD 70, and the days of the anti-Christ at the end of this age, that it is difficult to separate them, and to say which belongs exclusively to either (Mt 24). That the words may have an ultimate fulfilment in the second advent of Christ receives strength from a compari- son of vs 21 and 22 of the same chapter (ch 2) of Hag with He 12 26.27. The writer of that epistle condenses the two passages in Hag 2 6.7 and 21. 22, implying that it was one and the same shaking, of which the former vs denote the beginning, and the latter the end. The shaking, in other words, began introductory to the first advent and will be finished at the second. Concerning the former, cf Mt 3 17; 27 51; 28 2; Acts 2 2; 4 31, and concerning the latter, Mt 24 7; Rev 16 20; 20 11 (Bengel, quoted by Canon Faussett). (3) Other expositors seek to cut the Gordian knot by altogether denying the application to the Mes- siah, and translating ‘‘the desire of all nations’ b ‘the beauty,” or “the desirable things of all nations,” ie. their precious gifts (see Isa 60 5.11; 61 6). This application is defended in the following way: (a) The Heb word means the quality and not the thing desired; (b) the Messiah was not desired by all the nations when He came; (c) the vb. ‘‘shall come” is pl., which requires the noun to be under- stood in the pl., whereas if the Messiah be in- tended, the noun is singular; (d) ‘The silver is mine,” ete (Hag 2 8) accords with the ir ‘“‘the de- sirable things of all nations’; (e) the agreement of the Sept and Syr VSS with such rendering. All these arguments, however, can be fairly met by counter-arguments, leaving the reader still in doubt. (a) An abstract noun is often put for the concrete; (b) the result shows that while the Jews rejected Christ, the Gentiles received and hence desired Him; (c) where two nouns stand together after the manner of “the desire’ and “nations,” the vb. agrees in number sometimes with the latter, even though the former be its nominative; (d) the 8th ver of the prophecy can be harmonized about as easily with one view as the other; (e) the AV is sustained by the Vulg and early Jewish rabbis. James M. Gray DESOLATE, des’é-lét (very frequently in the OT for DAW, shdmém, and its derivatives; less fre- quently, 27, harébh, and its derivatives, and other words. In the NT it stands for épnpos, érémos THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Desert Destroyer (Mt 23 38; Acis 1 20; Gal 4 27], eréméé [Rev 17 16], and monéé [1 Tim 6 5]): From Lat de, intens., solus, alone. Several shades of meaning can be distinguished: (1) Its primary sense is ‘‘left lonely,” “forlorn,” e.g. Ps 25 16, “Have mercy upon me; for I am desolate” (Heb yahidh, ‘‘alone’’); 1 Tim 5 5, “she that is a widow indeed, and deso- late’ (Gr memondméné, “left, alone”). (2) In the sense of “laid waste,’ “destitute of inhabitants,” e.g. Jer 4 7, “to make thy land desolate, that_thy cities be laid waste, without inhabitant.” (38) With the meaning ‘‘comfortless,” “afflicted,” e.g. Ps 143 4, “My heart within me is desolate.” (4) In the sense of “barren,” ‘childless,’ “unfruitful,” e.g. Job 15 34; Isa 49 21 (Heb galmaah). D. Mriatt Enwarps DESOLATION, ABOMINATION OF. See ABOMINATION OF DESOLATION. DESPAIR, dé-sp4r’: The subst. only in 2 Cor 4 8, “perplexed, but not in [RV “yet not unto’) despair,” lit. “being at a loss, but not utterly at a loss.” “Unto despair” here conveys the force of the Gr prefix ex (‘‘utterly,” “out and out’). Desperate, in Job 6 26; Isa 17 11. In the latter instance, the Heb adj. is derived from a vb.=‘“‘to be sick,’ and the lit. rendering would be “incurable” (cf Job 34 6, “my wound is incurable’). Desper- ately in Jer 17 9 AV, where the heart is said to be “desperately [i.e. incurably] wicked’ or “‘sick.”’ DESPITE, dé-spit’, DESPITEFUL, dé-spit’fool: “Despite” is from Lat despectus, ‘‘a looking down upon.” As a noun (=“contempt”) it is now gen- erally used in its shortened form, ‘‘spite,’’ while the longer form is used as a prep. (=“‘in spite of”). In EV it is always a noun. In the OT it translates Heb sh’ at, in Ezk 25 6, and in RV Ezk 26 15; 36 5 (“with despite of soul’). In He 10 29 (“hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace’’) it stands for Gr enubrizé, “to treat with contempt.” The adj. “despiteful” occurs in AV Ezk 26 15; 36 5; Sir 31 31 (‘despiteful words,’ RV “a word of re- proach”); Rom 1 30 (RV “insolent’’=Gr hubris- tés, fr hupér, “above”; ef Eng. ‘“uppish’’). D. Mratt Enwarps DESSAU, des’é, des’a-ii (Aecoaot, Dessaoi [2 Mace 14 16]): RV LESSAU (which see). DESTINY, des‘ti-ni (MENI): A god of Good eae possibly the Pleiades. See Astrotocy, 10; ENI. DESTROYER, dé-stroi’ér: In several passages the word designates a supernatural agent of de- struction, or destroying angel, executing Divine judgment. (1) In Ex 12 238, of the ‘destroyer’ who smote the first-born in Egypt, again referred to under the same title in He 11 28 RV (AV “he that destroyed”). (2) In Job 33 22, ‘the destroy- ers” (lit. “they that cause to die’’)=the angels of death that are ready to take away a man’s life during severe illness. No exact || to this is found in the OT. The nearest approach is ‘‘the angel that destroyed the people” by pestilence (2 S 24 16.17 || 1 Ch 21 15.16); the angel that smote the Assyrians (2 K 19 35=Isa $7 36 || 2 Ch 32 21); “angels of evil” (Ps 78 49). (3) In the Apoc, “the destroyer” is once referred to as “the minister of punishment” (RV; lit. “him who was punishing”), who brought death into the world (Wisd 18 22-25). (4) In 1 Cor 10 10, ‘‘the destroyer’’ is the angelic agent to whose instrumentality Paul attributes the plague of Nu 16 46-49. In later Jewish theology (the Tgs and Midr), the ‘destroyer’ or ‘angel of death"' appears under the name Sammael (l.e. the polson of God), who was once an arch- angel before the throne of God, and who caused the ser- Destruction Deuteronomy THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 834 pent to tempt Eve. According to Weher, he is not to be distinguished from Satan. The chief distinction between the ‘‘destroyer” of early thought and the Sam- mael of later Judaism is that the former was regarded as the emissary of Jeh, and subservient to His will, and sometimes was not clearly distinguished from Jeh Him- self, whereas the latter was regarded as a perfectly dis- tinct individuality, acting in independence or semi-inde- pendence, and from purely malicious and evil motives. The change was largely due to the influence of Pers dual- ism, which made good and evil to be independent powers. : D. Miati Enwarns DESTRUCTION, dé-struk’shun: In AV this word translates over 30 Heb words in the OT, and 4 words in the NT. Of these the most interesting, as having a technical sense, is ’ébhadd6n (from vb. *abhadh, “to be lost,” “to perish”). It is found 6 t in the Wisdom Literature, and nowhere else in the OT; cf Rev 911. See ABappon. DESTRUCTION, CITY OF (Isa 19 18; HELI- OPOLIS OR CITY OF THE SUN). See Astron- omy, I, 2; InR-Ha-HERES; ON. DETERMINATE, dé-itir’mi-nat (dprorpéevos, horis- ménos, ‘“‘determined,” “‘fixed”): Only in Acts 2 23, “by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God,” Gr hdrismenos, fr horizd, “to set bound- aries,’ “determine,” “‘settle’ (cf Eng. word “hori- zon”’—lit. “that which bounds’). It is remarkable that Peter in one and the same sentence speaks of the death of Christ from two quite distinct points of view. (1) From the historical standpoint, it was a crime perpetrated by men who were morally responsible for their deed (him... . ye by the hand of lawless men did crucify and slay’). (2) From the standpoint of Divine teleology, it was part of an eternal plan (“by the determinate,” etc). No effort is made to demonstrate the logical con- sistency of the two ideas. They represent two as- pects of the one fact. The same Gr word is used in Lk 22 22, where Christ speaks of His betrayal as taking place ‘‘as it was [RV “hath been” deter- mined” (katd t6 hdrisménon). Cf Lk 24 26. D. Mriatu Enwarps DETERMINE, dé-tir’min: (1) “To resolve,” ‘“decide.’’ This is the primary meaning of the word and it is also the one that is the most common. In the NT the Gr word xpivo, krin6, is tr “determine,” and it has the above mean- ing (Acts 20 16; 25 25; 1 Cor 2 2). The word occurs frequently in the OT with this meaning (see Ex 2122: 18 20 7.9.33). (2) “To decree,” “ordain,” ‘mark out.” The Gr word that is rendered ‘determine’ with this meaning is horizd6. See DETERMINATE. The Heb term héarag is tr’ “determine” with the above meaning; as “his days are determined” (Job 14 5); ‘‘a destruction is determined” (Isa 10 22); “desolations are ‘determined’ (Dnl 9 26). The Heb term mishpat, which means “judgment” or ‘“‘sentence,”’ is trd “determination” in Zeph 3 8. A. W. Fortune, DETESTABLE, dé-tes’ta-b'l, THINGS (73pV, shikkic; YRW, shekeg, synonymous with MAPIM, t6‘ébhah, “abomination,” “abominable thing”): The tr of shtkkuctm in Jer 16 18; Ezk 5 11; 7 20; 11 18.21; 87 23; a term always applied to idol-worship or to objects connected with idolatry; often also tr? “abomination,” as in 1 K 11 5.7 (bis); Jer 4 1; Ezk 20 7.8.30. Shekec, tr? “abomination,” is applied in the Scriptures to that which is ceremoni- ally unclean (Lev 7 21), creatures forbidden as food, as water animals without fins or scales (11 10- 12), birds of prey and the like (ver 18), winged creeping things (vs 20.23), creeping vermin (vs 41 f). Cf also Isa 66 17. By partaking of the food of the animals in question one makes himself detestable (Lev 11 43; 20 25). Similarly the idolatrous ap- purtenances are to be held in detestation; nothing of the kind should be appropriated for private use (Dt 7 26). See ABoMINATION. Max L. Mareoris DEUEL, diel, dé-t’el ONITT, d*w’él, “knowl edge of God’): A Gadite, the father of Eliasaph, the representative of the tribe of Gad in the census- taking (Nu 1 14), in making the offering of the tribe at the dedication of the altar (7 42.47), and as leader of the host of the tribe of the children of Gad in the wilderness (10 20). Called Reuel in Nu 2 14, 7 (d) being confused with "1 (7). DEUTERO-CANONICAL, di-tér-3-ka-non’i-kal, BOOKS: A term sometimes used to designate certain books, which by the Council of ‘Trent were inclnded in the OT, but which the Protestant churches designated as apocryphal (see APocrrY- PHA), and also certain books of the NT which for a long time were not accepted by the whole church as Scripture. Webster says the term pertains to “a, second Canon or ecclesiastical writing of inferior authority,” and the history of these books shows that they were all at times regarded by a part of the church as being inferior to the others and some of them are so regarded today. This second Canon includes Tob, Jth, Wisd, Ecclus, 2 Esd, 1 Macc and 2 Mace of the OT, and He, Jas, 2 Pet, 2 Jn, 3 Jn, Jude and Rev of the NT. : The OT books under consideration were not in the Heb Canon and they were originally designated as apocryphal. The LXX contained 1. The OT many of the apoc books, and among Books these were most of those which we have designated deutero-canonical. The LXX was perhaps the Gr Bible of NT times and it continued to be the OT of the early church, and hence these books were widely distributed. It seems, however, that they did not continue to hold their place along with the other books, for Athana- sius, bishop of Alex, in his Festal Epistle in 367 gave a list of the books of the Bible which were to be read, and at the close of this list he said: ‘There are also other books besides these, not canonized, yet set by the Fathers to be read to those who have just come up and who wish to be informed as to the word of godliness: Wisd, Sir, Est, Jth, Tob, the so-called Teaching of the Apos, and the Shepherd of Hermas.”’ Jerome also made a distinction between the apoc books and the others. In his Preface, after enu- merating the books contained in the Heb Canon, he adds: “This prologne I write as a preface to the books to be translated by us from the Heb into Lat, that we may know that all the books which are not of this number are apoc; therefore Wisd, which is commonly ascribed to Solomon as its author, and the book of Jesus the son of Sir, Jth, Tob and the Shep are not in the Canon.” Rufinus made the same distinction as did Jerome. He declared that ‘hese books are not canonical, but have been called by our forefathers ecclesiastical.” Augustine in- cluded these books in his list which he published in 397. He begins the list thus: ‘The entire canon of Scripture is comprised in these books.” Then fol- lows a list of the books which includes Tob, Jth, 1 Mace, 2 Mace, 2 Esd, Wisd and Ecclus, and it closes with these words: ‘In these 44 books is com- prised all the authority of the OT.” Inasmuch as these books were regarded by the church at large as ecclesiastical and helpful, and Augustine had given them canonical sanction, they rapidly gained in favor and most of them are found in the great MSS. See Canon or Tus OT. It is not probable that there was any general council of the church in those early centuries that set apart the various books of the NT and canon- ized them as Scripture for the whole church. There 835 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Destruction Deuteronomy was no single historical event which brought to- gether the NT books which were everywhere to be regarded as Scripture. These books 2. The NT did not make the same progress in the Books various provinces and churches. A careful study of conditions reveals the fact that there was no uniform NT canon in the church during at least the first 3 cents. The Ethi- opie church, for example, had 35 books in its NT, while the Syrian church had only 22 books. From an early date the churches were practi- cally agreed on those books which are sometimes designated as the protocanonical, and which Euse- bins designated as the homologoumena. They differed, however, in regard to the 7 disputed books which form a part of the so-called deutero-canon, and which Eusebius designated as the antilegomena. They also differed in regard to other ecclesiastical writings, for there was no fixed line between canoni- cal and non-canonical books. While there was perhaps no council of the church that had passed on the books and declared them eanonical, it is un- doubtedly true that before the close of the 2d cent. all the books that are in our NT, with the exception of those under consideration, had become recognized as Scripture in all orthodox churches. The history of these seven books reveals the fact that althongh some of them were early used by the Fathers, they afterward fell into disfavor. That is esp. true of He and Rev. Generally speaking, it can be said that at the close of the 2d cent. the 7 books under consider- ation had failed to receive any such general recognition as had the rest; however, all, with perhaps the exception of 2 Pet, had been used by some of the Fathers. He was freely attested by Clement of Rome and Justin Martyr; Jas by Hermas and probably by Clem of Rome; 2 Jn, 3 Jn and Jude by the Muratorian Fragment; Rev by Hermas and Justin Martyr who names John as its author. See Canon or THE NT. Jerome, who prepared the Vulg in the closing years of the 4th cent., accepted all 7 of the doubtful books, yet he held that 2 Jn and 3 Jn were written by the Presbyter, and he intimated that 2 Pet and Jude were still rejected by some, and he said the Latins did not receive He among the canonical Scriptures, neither did the Gr churches receive Rev. Augustine, who was one of the great leaders during the last part of the 4th cent. and the first part of the 5th, accepted without question the 7 disputed books. These books had gradually gained in favor and the position of Jerome and Augustine practically set- tled their canonicity for the orthodox churches. The Council of Carthage, held in 397, adopted the catalogue of Augustine. This catalogue contained all the disputed books both of the NT and the OT. Since the Reformation —The Canon of Augustine became the Canon of the majority of the churches and the OT books which he accepted were added to the Vulg, but there were some who still held to the Canon of Jerome. The awakening of the Reformation inevitably led to a reinvestigation of the Canon, since the Bible was made the source of authority, and some of the disputed books of the NT were again questioned by the Reformers. The position given the Bible by the Reformers led the Rom church to reaffirm its sanction and definitely to fix the books that should be accepted. Accordingly the Council of Trent, which convened in 1546, made the Canon of Augustine, which included the 7 apoc books of the OT, and the 7 disputed books of the NT, the Canon of the church, and it pronounced a curse upon those who did not receive these books. The Protestants at first followed the example of Rome and adopted these books which had long had the sanction of usage as their Bible. Gradually, however, the questioned books of the OT were sepa- rated from the others. That was true in Cover- dale’s tr, and in Matthew’s Bible they were not only separated from the others but they were prefaced with the words, “the volume of the book called Hagiographa.” In Cranmer’s Bible, Hagiographa was changed into Apoc, and this passed through the succeeding ed into the AV. A. W. Fortune DEUTERONOMY, di-tér-on’é-mi: 1. Name 2. What Dt Is 3. Analysis 4. Ruling Ideas 5. Unity 6. Authorship 7. Dt Spoken Twice 8. Dt’'s Influence in Israel’s History 9. The Critical Theory LITERATURE hi In Heb DMD MPN, 'aleh hd-debharim, “these are the words”; in Gr, Aevrepovbzu0v, Deuterondmion, “second law’; whence the Lat deutero- nomi, and the Eng. Deuteronomy. The Gr title is due to a mistrans- lation by the Sept of the clause in Dt 17 18 ren- dered, ‘“‘and he shall write for himself this repetition of the law.’”’ The Heb really means ‘‘and he shall write out for himself a copy of this law.” However, the error on which the Eng. title rests is not serious, as Dt is in a very true sense a repetition of the law. Dt is the last of the five books of the Pent, or ‘five-fifths of the Law.” It possesses an indi- viduality and impressiveness of its 2. What own. In Ex-Nu Jeh is represented Di Is as speaking unto Moses, whereas in Dt, Moses is represented as speaking at Jeh’s command to Israel (1 1-4; 5 1; 29 1). It is a hortatory recapitulation of various addresses delivered at various times and places in the desert wanderings—a sort of homily on the constitution, the essence or gist of Moses’ instructions to Israel during the forty years of their desert experience. It is “a Book of Reviews’; a tr of Israel’s redemp- tive history into living principles; not so much a history as a commentary. There is much of retro- spect in it, but its main outlook is forward. The rabbins speak of it as ‘the Book of Reproofs.” It is the text of all prophecy; a manual of evangelical oratory; possessing “all the warmth of a St. Ber- nard, the flaming zeal of a Savonarola, and the tender, gracious sympathy of a St. Francis of Assisi.” The author’s interest is entirely moral. His one supreme purpose is to arouse Israel’s loyalty to Jeh and to His revealed law. Taken as a whole the book is an exposition of the great commandment, “Thou shalt love Jeh thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy might.” It was from Dt Jesus summarized the whole of the Old Covenant in a single sentence (Mt 22 37; ef Dt 6 5), and from it He drew His weapons with which to vanquish the tempter (Mt 4 4.7.10; cf Dt 8 3; 6 16.18). Dt is composed of three discourses, followed by three short appendices: (1) 1 1—4 48, historical; a review of God’s dealings with Israel, 3. Analysis specifying in great detail where and when delivered (1 1-5), recounting in broad oratorical outlines the chief events in the nation’s experience from Horeb to Moab (1 6— 3 29), on which the author bases an earnest appeal to the people to be faithful and obedient, and in par- ticular to keep clear of all possible idolatry (4 1-40). Appended to this first discourse is a brief note (vs 41-43) concerning Moses’ appointment of three cities of refuge on the E. side of the Jordan. (2) 4 44—26 19, hortatory and legal; introduced by a superscription (4 44-49), and consisting of a résumé of Israel’s moral and civil statutes, testimonies and judgments. Analyzed in greater detail, this second discourse is composed of two main sections: (a) chs 6-11, an extended exposition of the Ten Com- mandments on which the theocracy was based; 1. Name Deuteronomy THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 836 (b) chs 12-26, a code of special statutes concerning worship, purity, tithes, the three annual feasts, the administration of justice, kings, priests, prophets, war, and the private and social life of the people. The spirit of this discourse is most ethical and reli- gious. The tone is that of a father no less than that of a legislator. A spirit of humanity pervades the entire discourse. Holiness is its ideal. (38) 27 1—81 30, predictive and minatory; the subject of this third discourse being “‘the blessings of obe- dience and the curses of disobedience.” This section begins with directions to inscribe these laws on plastered stones to be set up on Mt. Ebal (27 1-10), to be ratified by an antiphonal ritual of blessings and cursings from the two adjacent mountains, Gerizim and Ebal (vs 11-26). These are followed by solemn warnings against disobedience (28 1— 29 1), and fresh exhortations to accept the terms of the new covenant made in Moab, and to choose between life and death (29 2—30 20). Moses’ farewell charge to Israe] and his formal commission of Joshua close the discourse (ch 31). The section is filled with predictions, which were woefully veri- fied in Israel’s later history. The three appendices, spoken of above, close the book: (a) Moses’ Song (ch 82), which the great Lawgiver taught the peo- ple (the Law was given to the priests, 31 24-27); (b) Moses’ Blessing (ch 33), which forecast the future for the various tribes (Simeon only being omitted); (c) a brief account of Moses’ death and burial (ch 34) with a noble panegyric on him as the greatest prophet Israel. ever had. Thus closes this majestic and marvelously interesting and prac- tical book. Its keyword is ‘“‘possess’’; its central ere is “Jeh has chosen Israel, let Israel choose eh. The great central thought of Dt is the unique relation which Jeh as a unique God sustains to Israel as a unique people. ‘Hear O 4. Ruling Israel; Jeh our God is one Jeh.” The Ideas monotheism of Dt is very explicit. Following from this, as a necessary corollary almost, is the other great teaching of the book, the unity of the sanctuary. The motto of the book might be said to be, ‘One God, one sanctuary.” (1) Jehovah, a unique god.—Jeh is the only God, “There is none else besides him” (4 85.39; 6 4; 382 39), “He is God of gods, and Lord of lords’ (10 17), “the living God” (5 26), ‘the faithful God, who keepeth covenant and lovingkindness with them that love him and keep his commandments” (7 9), who abominates graven images and every species of idolatry (7 25.26; 12 31; 13 14; 18 12; 20 18; 27 15), to whom belong the heavens and the earth (10 14), who rules over all the nations (7 19), whose relation to Israel is near and personal (28 58), even that of a Father (32 6), whose being is spiritual (4 12.15), and whose name is ‘‘Rock” (82 4.15.18.30.31). Being such a God, He is jeal- ous of all rivals (7 4; 29 24-26; 31 16.17), and hence all temptations to idolatry must be utterly removed from the land, the Canaanites must be completely exterminated and all their altars, pillars, eee and images destroyed (7 1-5.16; 20 16-18; (2) Israel, a unique people.—The old Israel had become unique through the covenant which Jeh made with them at Horeb, creating out of them ‘a king- dom of priests, and a holy nation” (Ex 19 6). The new Israel who had been born in the desert were to inherit the blessings vouchsafed to their fathers, through the covenant just now being made in Moab (Dt 26 16-19; 27 9; 29 1; 5 2.3). By means of it they became the heirs of all the promises given unto their fathers the patriarchs (4 31; 7 12; 8 18; 29 13); they too became holy and peculiar, and especially beloved of Jeh (7 6; 14 2.21; 26 18.19; 28 9; 4 37), disciplined, indeed, but for their own good ‘(8 2.3.5.16), to be established as a people, as Jeh’s peculiar lot and inheritance (82 6.9; 4 7). (3) The relation between Jehovah and Israel a unique relation.—Other nations feared their deities; Israel was expected not only to fear Jeh but to love Him and cleave to Him (4 10; 6 29; 6 5; 10 12. 20; 11 1.13.22; 13 3.4; 17.19; 19.9; 28 58; 80 6.16.20; 31 12.13). The highest privileges are theirs because they are partakers of the covenant blessings; all others are strangers and foreigners, except they be admitted into Israel by special per- mission (23 1-8). The essential unity of the great kernel of Dt (chs 5-26) is recognized and freely allowed_by nearly everyone (e.g. Kautzsch, Kue- 5. Unity nen, Dillmann, Driver). Some would even defend the unity of the whole of chs 1-26 (Knobel, Graf, Kosters, Colenso, Kleinert). No other book of the OT, unless it be the prophecies of Ezekiel, bears such unmistakable signs of unity in aim, language and thought. ‘‘The literary style of Dt,” says Driver, “is very marked and indi- vidual; in his command of a chaste, yet warm and persuasive eloquence, the author of Dt stands unique among the writers of the OT” (Dt, Ixxvii, Ixxxviii). Many striking expressions characterize the style of this wonderful book of oratory: e.g. “cause to inherit’; ‘Hear O Israel’; the oft- repeated root, meaning in the Kal vb.-species “learn,” and in the Piel vb.-species “‘teach’’; “be willing”; ‘‘so shalt thou exterminate the evil from thy midst’”’; ‘as at this day”; ‘that it may be well with thee”; “the land whither thou goest in to possess it”; ‘“‘with all thy heart and with all thy soul’; and many others, all of which occur fre- quently in Dt and rarely elsewhere in the OT, thus binding, so far as style can, the different sections of the book into one solid unit. Barring various titles and editorial additions (11-5; 4 44-49; 29 1; 33 1.7.9.22; 34 1) and afew archaeological notes such as 2 10-12.20-23; 3 9.11.14; 10 6-9, and of course the last chapter, which gives an account of Moses’ death, there is every reason necessary for supposing that the book isa unit. Few writings in the entire field of literature have so clear a unity of purpose or so uniform a style of address. There is one passage bearing upon the authorship of Dt wherein it is stated most explicitly that Moses wrote “this law.” It reads, “And 6. Author- Moses wrote this law, and delivered ship it unto the priests the sons of Levi. .... And it came to pass, when Moses had made an end of writing the words of this law in a book, until they were finished [i.e. to the end], that Moses commanded the Levites, that bare the ark of the covenant of Jeh, saying, Take this book of the law, and put it by the side of the ark of the covenant of Jeh your God, that it may be there for a witness against thee” (Dt 31 9.24- 27). This passage is of more than traditional value, and should not be ignored as is so often done (e.g. by Ryle, art. “Dt,” HDB). It is not enough to say that Moses was the great fountain-head of Heb law, that he gave oral but not written statutes, or, that Moses was only the traditional source of these statutes. For it is distinctly and emphatically stated that ‘Moses wrote this law.” And it is further declared (31 22) that “Moses wrote this song,” contained in ch 32. Now, these statements are either true, or they are false. There is no es- cape. The authorship of no other book in the OT is so explicitly emphasized. The present writer believes that Moses actually wrote the great body of Dt, and for the following general reasons: (1) Di as a whole is eminently appropriate to what we know of Moses’ times.—It closes most fittingly 837 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Deuteronomy the formative period of Israel’s history. The his- torical situation from first to last is that of Moses. The references to foreign neighbors—Egypt, Canaan, Amalek, Ammon, Moab, Edom—are in every case to those who flourished in Moses’ own times. As a law book its teaching is based upon the Ten Com- mandments. If Moses gave the Ten Command- ments, then surely he may have written the Book of Dt also. Besides, the Code of Hammurabi, which antedates Moses by at least 700 years, makes it possible certainly that Moses also left laws in codified or written form. (2) Dt ts represented as emanating from Moses.— The language is language put into Moses’ mouth. Nearly forty times his name occurs, and in the ma- jority of instances as the authoritative author of the subject-matter. The first person is used pre- dominatingly throughout: “I commanded Joshua at that time” (3 21); and “I charged your judges at that time” (1 16); “And I commanded you at that time” (ver 18); “I have led you forty years in the wilderness’”’ (29 5). “The language surely purports to come from Moses; and if it was not actually used by him, it is a most remarkable case of impersonation, if not of literary forgery, for the writer represents himself as reproducing, not what Moses might have said, but the exact words of Moses” (Zerbe, The Antiquity of Heb Writing and Lit., 1911, 261). (8) Dt is a military law book, a code of conquest, a book of exhortation —It was intended primarily neither for Israel in the desert nor for Israel settled in Canaan, but for Israel on the borderland, eager for conquest. It is expressly stated that Moses taught Israel these statutes and judgments in order that they should obey them in the land which they were about to enter (4 5.14; 5 31). They must expel the aborigines (7 1; 9 1-3; 2017; 31 3), but in their warfare they must observe certain laws in keeping with the theocracy (20 1-20; 23 9-14; 21 10-14; 31 6.7), and, when they have finally dis- possessed their enemies, they must settle down to agricultural life and live no longer as nomads but as citizens of a civilized land (19 14; 22 8-10; 24 19-21). All these laws are regulations which should become binding in the future only (cf Kittel, His- iory of the Hebrews, I, 32). Coupled with them are prophetic exhortations which seem to be genuine, and to have had their birth in Moses’ soul. Indeed the great outstanding feature of Dt is its parenetic or hortatory character. Its exhortations have not only a military ring as though written on the eve of battle, but again and again warn Israel against allowing themselves to be conquered in religion through the seductions of idolatry. The book in short is the message of one who is interested in Israel’s political and religious future. There is a paternal vein running throughout it which marks it with a genuine Mosaic, not a merely fictitious or artificial, stamp. It is these general features, so characteristic of the entire book, which compel one to believe in its Mosaic authorship. . Certain literary features exist in Dt which lead the present writer to think that the bulk of the book was spoken twice; once, to the first 7. Dt generation between Horeb and Kadesh- Spoken barnea in the 2d year of the Exodus Twice wanderings, and a second time to the new generation, in the plains of Moab in the 40th year. Several considerations point in this direction: (1) The names of the widely separated geographical places mentioned in the title (1 1.2).—‘‘These are the words which Moses spake unto all Israel beyond the Jordan in the wilderness, in the Arabah over against Suph, between Paran, and Tophel, and Laban, and Hazeroth, and Di-zahab”; to which is added, ‘‘It is eleven days’ journey from Horeb by the way of Mount Seir unto Kadesh-barnea.”” If these state- ments have any relevancy whatever to the contents of the book which they introduce, they point to a wide area, from Horeb to Moab, as the historico- geographical background of the book. In other words, Dt, in part at least, seems to have been spoken first on the way between Horeb and Kadesh- barnea, and later again when Israel were encamped on the plains of Moab. And, indeed, what would be more natural than for Moses when marching northward from Horeb expecting to enter Canaan from the south, to exhort the Israel of that day in terms of chs 6-26? Being baffled, however, by the adverse report of the spies and the faithlessness of the people, and being forced to wait and wander for 38 years, what would be more natural than for Moses in Moab, when about to resign his position as leader, to repeat the exhortations of chs 5-26, adapting them to the needs of the new desert- trained generation and prefacing the whole by a Cae introduction such as that found in chs —4 (2) The double allusion to the cities of refuge (4 41-48; 19 1-13).—On the supposition that chs 5-26 were spoken first between Horeb and Kadesh- barnea, in the 2d year of the Exodus, it could not be expected that in this section the names of the three cities chosen E. of the Jordan should be given, and in fact they are not (19 1-13); the terri- tory of Sihon and Og had not yet been conquered and the cities of refuge, accordingly, had not yet been designated (ef Nu 35 214). But in 4 41-48, on the contrary, which forms a part of the historical introduction, which ex hypothest was delivered Just at the end of the 39 years’ wanderings, after Sihon and Og had been subdued and their territory di- vided, the three cities of refuge E. of the Jordan are aciually named, just as might be expected. (3) The section 4 44-49, which, in its original form, very probably introduced chs 6-26 before when chapters were adapted to the new situation in oab. (4) The phrase “began Moses to declare this law” (7 &), suggesting that the great lawgiver found it necessary to expound what he had delivered at some previous time. The Heb word tr? “to declare” is found elsewhere in the OT only in Dt 27 8 and in Hab 2 2, and signifies ‘to make plain.” (5) The author's evident attempt to identify the new generation in Moab with the patriarchs.—“Jeh made not this covenant with our fathers, but with us, even us, who are all of us here alive this day,”’ ie. with us who have survived the desert discipline (Dt 5 3). In view of these facts, we conclude that the book in its present form (barring the exceptions above mentioned) is the product of the whole 39 years of desert experience from Horeb on, adapted, however, to meet the exigencies of the Israelites as they stood between the victories already won on the E. of the Jordan and those anticipated on the W. The impression given throughout is that the aged lawgiver’s work is done, and that a new era in the people’s history is about to begin. The influence of Dt began to be felt from the very beginning of Israel’s career in Canaan. Though the references to Dt in Josh, Jgs, S and 8. Dt’s K are comparatively few, yet they are Influence sufficient to show that not only the in Israel’s principles of Dt were known and ob- History served but that they were known in written form as codified statutes. For example, when Jericho was taken, the city and its spoil were ‘‘devoted” (Josh 6 17.18) in keeping with Dt 13 15ff (ef Josh 10 40; 11 12.15 with Dt 7 2; 20 16.17). Achan trespassed and he and his household were stoned, and afterward burned Deuteronomy THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 838 with fire (Josh 7 25; cf Dt 13 10; 17 5). The fact that his sons and his daughters were put to death with him seems at first sight to contradict Dt 24 16, but there is no proof that they suffered for their father's sin (see AcHAN; AcHOR); besides the Hebrews recognized the unity of the house- hold, even that of Rahab the harlot (Josh 6 17). Again when Ai was taken, “only the cattle and the spoil” did Israel take for a prey unto themselves (Josh 8 27), in keeping with Dt 20 14; also, the body of the king of Ai was taken down before night- fallfrom the tree on which he had been hanged (Josh 8 29), which was in keeping with Dt 21 23 (ef Josh 10 26.27). As in warfare, so in worship. For instance, Joshua built an altar on Mt. Ebal (Josh 8 30.31), “as Moses the servant of Jeh commanded” (Dt 27 4-6), and he wrote on them a copy of the law (Josh 8 32), as Moses had also enjomed (Dt 27 3.8). Moreover, the elders and officers and judges stood on either side of the ark of the covenant between Ebal and Gerizim (Josh 8 33), as directed in Dt 11 29; 27 12.13, and Joshua read to all the congregation of Israel all the words of the law, the blessings and the cursings (Josh 8 34.35), in strict accord with Dt 31 11.12. But the passage of paramount importance is the story of the two and a half tribes who, on their return to their home on the E. side of the Jordan, erected a memorial at the Jordan, and, when ac- cused by their fellow-tribesmen of plurality of sanctuary, emphatically disavowed it (Josh 22 29; ef Dt 12 5). Obviously, therefore, Dt was known in the days of Joshua. A very few instances in the history of the Judges point in the same direc- tion: e.g. the utter destruction of Zephath (Jgs 1 17; cf Dt 7 2; 20 16f); Gideon’s elimination of the fearful and faint-hearted from his army (Jgs 7 1-7; ef Dt 20 1-9); the author’s studied con- cern to justify Gideon and Manoah for sacrificing at altars other than at Shiloh on the ground that they acted in obedience to Jeh’s direct commands (Jgs 6 25-27; 13 16); esp. the case of Micah, who congratulated himself that Jeh would do him good seeing he had a Levite for a priest, is clear evi- dence that Dt was known in the days of the Judges (Jgs 17 13; ef Dt 10 8; 18 1-8; 33 8-11). In 1 § 1 1-9.21.24 the pious Elkanah is pictured as going yearly to worship Jeh at Shiloh, the central sanctuary at that time. After the destruction of Shiloh, when the ark of the covenant had been cap- tured by the Philis, Samuel indeed sacrificed at Miz- pah, Ramah and Bethlehem (1 8 7 7-9.17; 16 5), but in doing so he only took advantage of the elas- ticity of the Deuteronomic law: ‘When... . he giveth you rest from all your enemies round about, so that ye dwell in safety; then it shall come to pass that to the place which Jeh your God shall choose, to cause his name to dwell there, thither shall ye bring all that Icommand you: your burnt-offerings, and your sacrifices” (Dt 12 10.11). It was not until Solomon’s time that Israel’s enemies were all sub- dued, and even then Solomon did not observe strictly the teachings of Dt; ‘His wives turned away his heart,” so that he did not faithfully keep Jeh’s “covenant” and “statutes” (1 K 11 3.11). Political disruption followed, and religion necessarily suffered. Yet Jehoiada the priest gave the youth- ful Joash “the crown” and ‘‘the testimony” (2 K 11 12; cf Dt 17 18). King Amaziah did not slay the children of the murderers who slew his father, in conscious obedience apparently to the law of Dt (2K 146; cf Dt 24 16). Later on, Hezekiah, the cultured king of Judah, reformed the cultus of his day by removing the high places, breaking down the pillars, cutting down the Asherahs, and even breaking in pieces the brazen serpent which Moses had made (2 K 18 4.22). Hezekiah’s reforms were unquestionably carried through under the influence of Dt. It is equally certain that the prophets of the 8th cent. were not ignorant of this book. For example, Hosea complains of Israel’s sacrificing upon the tops of the mountains and burning incense upon the hills, and warns Judah not to follow Israel’s exam- ple in coming up to worship at Gilgal and Beth-aven (Hos 4 18.15). He also alludes to striving with priests (Hos 4 4; cf Dt 17 12), removing land- marks (Hos 6 10; cf Dt 19 14), returmng to Egypt (Hos 8 13; 9 8; cf Dt 28 68), and of Jeh’s tender dealing with Ephraim (Hos 11 3; cf Dt 1 31; 32 10). The courage of Amos, the shepherd- prophet of Tekoa, can best be explained, also, on the basis of a written law such as that of Dt with which he and his hearers were already more or less familiar (Am 3 2; cf Dt 76; 47.8). He con- demns Israel’s inhumanity and adultery in the name of religion, and complains of their retaining over- night pledges wrested from the poor, which was dis- tinctly forbidden in Dt (Am 2 6-8; ef Dt 24 12- 15; 23 17). Likewise, in the prophecies of Isaiah there are conscious reflections of Dt’s thought and teaching. Zion is constantly pictured as the center of the nation’s religion and as Jeh’s secure dwelling- place (Isa 2 2-4; 8 18; 28 16; 29 1.2; cf Mic 4 1-4). Inshort, no one of the four great prophets of the 8th cent. BC—Isaiah, Micah, Amos, Hosea— ever recognized “high places” as legitimate centers of worship. Over against the Bib. view, certain modern critics since De Wette (1805) advocate a late origin of Dt, claiming that it was first published in 9. The 621 BC, when Hilkiah found ‘‘the Critical book of the law” in the temple in the Theory 18th year of King Josiah (2 K 22 8 ff). The kernel of Dt and “‘the book of the law’’ discovered by Hilkiah are said to be identical. Thus, Dr. G. A. Smith claims that ‘‘a code like the Book of Dt was not brought forth at a stroke, but was the expression of the gradual results of the age- long working of the Spirit of the Living God in the hearts of His people” (Jerusalem, II, 115). Accord- ing to Dr. Driver, ‘‘Dt may be described as the pro- phetic reformulation and adaptation to new needs, of an older legislation. It is probable that there was a tradition, if not a written record, of a final legislative address delivered by Moses in the steppes of Moab: the plan followed by the author would rest upon a more obvious motive, if he thus worked upon a traditional basis. But be that as it may, the bulk of the laws contained in Dt is undoubtedly far more ancient ‘than the author himself... .. What is essentially new in Dt is not the maiter, but the form. .... The new element in Dt is thus not the laws, but their parenetic setting’ (Dt, lxi, lvi). This refined presentation of the matter would not be so very objectionable, were Drs. Smith and Driver’s theory not linked up with certain other claims and allegations to the effect that Moses in the 15th cent. BC could not possibly have promul- gated such a lofty monotheism, that in theological teaching “the author of Dt is the spiritual heir of Hosea,” that there are discrepancies between it and other parts of the Pent, that in the early history of Israel down to the 8th cent. plurality of sanc- tuaries was legally permissible, that there are no traces of the influence of the principal teachings of a written Dt discoverable in Heb lit. until the time of Jeremiah, and that the book as we possess it was originally composed as a program of reform, not by Moses but in the name of Moses as a forgery or pseudepigraph. For example, F. H. Woods says, “Although not a necessary result of accepting the later date, the majority of critics believe this book of the law to have been the result of a pious fraud 839 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Deuteronomy promulgated by Hilkiah and Shaphan with the intention of deceiving Josiah into the belief that the reforms which they desired were the express com- mand of God revealed to Moses” (HDB, II, 368). Some are unwilling to go so far. But in any case, it is claimed that the law book discovered and pub- lished by Hilkiah, which brought about the reforma~ tion by Josiah in 621 BC, was no other than some portion of the Book of Dt, and of Dt alone. But there are several considerations which are opposed to this theory: (1) Dt emphasizes centralization of worship at one sanctuary (12 5); Josiah’s reformation was directed rather against idolatry in general (2 K 23 4ff). (2) In Dt 18 6-8, a Levite coming from the country to Jerus was allowed to minister and share in the priestly per- quisites; but in 2 K 23 9, ‘the priests of the high places came not up to the altar of Jeh in Jerus, but they did eat unleavened bread among their brethren.” And according to the critical theory, ‘‘Levites” and “priests” are interchange- able terms. (3) The following passages in Ex might almost equally with Dt account for Josiah’s reformation: 20 3; 22 18.20; 23 13.24.32.33; 34 13.14-17. (4) The law book discovered by Hilkiah was recognized at once as an ancient code which the fathers had disobeyed (2 K 22 13). Were they all deceived? Even Jeremiah (cf Jer 11 3.4)? “There were many persons in Judah who had power- ful motives for exposing this forgery if it was one” (Raven, OT Introduction, 112). _(5) One wonders why so many archaic and, in Josiah’s time, ap- parently obsolete laws should have been incorpo- rated in a code whose express motive was to reform an otherwise hopeless age: e.g. the command to ex- terminate the Canaanites, who had long since ceased to exist (Dt 7 18.22), and to blot out Amalek (Dt 265 17-19), the last remnants of whom were com- pletely destroyed in Hezekiah’s time (1 Ch 4 41- 43). Esp. is this true of the score and more of laws peculiar to Dt, concerning building battlements on the roofs of houses (Dt 22 8), robbing birds’ nests (vs 6.7), the sexes exchanging garments (ver 5), going out to war (20 1ff), etc. (6) Esp. remarkable is it that if Dt were written, as alleged, shortly before the reign of Josiah, there should be no anachronisms in it betraying a post-Mosaic origin. There are no allusions to the schism between Judah and Israel, no hint of Assyr oppres- sion through the exaction of tribute, nor any threats of Israel’s exile either to Assyria or Babylonia, but rather to Egypt (Dt 28 68). “Jerusalem” is never mentioned. From a literary point of view, it is psychologically and historically well-nigh im- possible for a writer to conceal all traces of his age and circumstances. On the other hand, no Egyp- tologist has ever discovered any anachronisms in Dt touching Egyp matters. From first to last the author depicts the actual situation of the times of Moses. It is consequently hard to believe, as is alleged, that a later writer is studying to give “an imaginative revivification of the past.” (7) The chief argument in favor of Dt’s late origin is its alleged teaching concerning the unity of the sanctuary. Wellhausen lays special emphasis upon this point. Prior to Josiah’s reformation, it is claimed, plurality of sanctuaries was allowed. But in opposition to this, it is possible to point victoriously to Hezekiah’s reformation (2 K 18 4. 22), as a movement in the direction of unity; and especially to Ex 20 24, which is so frequently mis- interpreted as allowing a multiplicity of sanctuaries. This classical passage when correctly interpreted | allows only that altars shall be erected in every place where Jeh records His name, ‘which pre- sumably during the wanderings and the time of the judges would mean wherever the Tabernacle was’’ (Mackay, Intro to OT, 110). This interpretation of this passage is confirmed and made practically certain, indeed, by the command in Ex 23 14-19 that Israel shall repair three times each year to the house of Jeh and there present their offering. On the other hand, Dt’s emphasis upon unity of sanc- tuary is often exaggerated. The Book of Dt requires unity only after Israel’s enemies are all overcome (Dt 12 10.11). “When” Jch giveth them rest, “then” they shall repair for worship to the place which “God shall choose.” As Davidson remarks: . “Tt is not a law that is to come into effect on their entry into Canaan; it is to be observed from the time that Jeh shall have given them rest from all their enemies round about; that is, from the times of David, or more particularly, Solomon; for only when the temple was built did that place become known which Jeh had chosen to place His name there” (OT Theology, 361). Besides, it should not be forgotten that in Dt itself the command is given to huild an altar in Mt. Ebal (27 5-7). Asa matter of fact, the unity of sanctuary follows as a neces- sary consequence of monotheism; and if Moses taught monotheism, he probably also enjoined unity of worship. If, on the other hand, monotheism was first evolved by the prophets of the 8th cent., then, of course, unity of sanctuary was of 8th-cent. origin also. (8) Another argument advanced in favor of the later origin of Dt is the contradiction between the laws of Dt and those of Lev-Nu concerning the priests and Levites. In Nu 16 10.35.40, a sharp distinction is drawn, it is alleged, between the priests and common Levites, whereas in Dt 18 1-8, all priests are Levites and all Levites are priests. But as a matter of fact, the passage in Dt does not invest a Levite with priestly but with Levitical functions (cf 18 7). “The point insisted upon is that all Levites shall receive full recognition at the sanctuary and be accorded their prerogatives. It goes without saying that if the Levite be a priest he shall serve and fare like his brethren the priests; if he be not a priest, he shall enjoy the privileges that belong to his brethren who are Levites, but not priests’ (J. D. Davis, art: “Dt,” in DB, 117). The Book of Dt teaches not that all the tribe, but only the tribe of Levi may exercise priestly functions, thus restricting the exercise of priestly prerogatives to one and only one tribe. This was in perfect harmony with Lev-Nu and also in keeping with the style of popular discourse. (9) Recently Professor Ed. Naville, the Egyptolo- gist, has propounded a theory of the origin of “the Book of the Law” discovered by Hilkiah, which is not without some value. On the analogy of the Egyp custom of burying texts of portions of “the Book of the Dead” at the foot of statues of gods and within foundations of temple walls, as at Hermopolis, be concludes that Solomon, when he constructed the Temple, probably deposited this “Book of the Law” in the foundations, and that when Josiah’s workmen were about their tasks of repairing the edifice, the long-forgotten docu- ment came to light and was given to Hilkiah the priest. Hilkiah, however, upon examination of the document found it difficult to read, and so, calling for Shaphan the scribe, who was more expert in deciphering antique letters than himself, he gave the sacred roll to him, and he in turn read it to both Hilkiah and the king. The MS may indeed have been written in cuneiform. Thus, according to Naville, ‘‘the Book of the Law,’ which he identifies with Dt, must be pushed back as far as the age of Solomon at the very latest. Geden shares a similar view as to its date: “some time during the pros- perous period of David and the United Monarchy” (Intro to the Heb Bible, 1909, 330). Device Dial of Ahaz But why not ascribe the book to the traditional author? Surely there ean be no_ philosophical objection to doing so, in view of the now-known Code of Hammurabi, which antedates Moses by so many hundreds of years! No other age accounts so well for its origin as that of the great lawgiver who claims to have written the bulk of it. And the history of the disintegration of the book only shows to what extremes a false method may lead; for ex- ample, Stenernagel separates the ‘‘Thou” and “Ye” sections from each other and assigns them to differ- ent authors of late date: Kennett, on the other hand, assigns the earliest strata to the period of the Exile (Jour. of Theol. Studies, 1904), On the whole, no theory is so satisfactory as that which, in keep- ing with Dt 31 22.24, ascribes to Moses the great bulk of the book. See also Criticism; PENTa- TEUCH. LitzratuRE.—On the conservative side: James Orr, The Problem of the OT, The Bross Prize, 1906; art. “‘Dt,” Illustrated Bible Dict., 1908; James Robertson, The Early Religion of Israel, 1892; art. ‘Dt,’ The Temple Bible Dict., 1910; John D. Davis, art. ‘‘ Dt," Davis' Dict. of the Bible, 1911; John H. Raven, OT Intro, 1906; A. S. Geden, Intro to the Heb Bible, 1909; W. Moller, Are the Critics Right? 1903: R. B. Girdle- stone, The Student's Dt, 1899; Hugh Pope, The Date of the Composition of Dt, 1911; A. S. Zerbe, The Antiquity of Heb Writing and Lit., 1911; Ed. Naville, The Discovery of the Book of the Law under King Josiah, 1911; E. ©. Bissell, The Pent: Its Origin and Structure, 1885; G. L. Robinson, The Expositor, ‘‘The Genesis of Dt,’ October and November, 1898, February, March, May, 1899; W.H. Green, Moses and the Prophets, 1891; The Higher Criticism of the Pent, 1895; A. M. Mackay, The Church- man's Intro to the OT, 1901; J. W. Beardslee, Outlines of an Intro to the OT, 1903; G. Vos, The Mosate Origin of the Pentateuchal Codes, 1886. On the other side: S. R. Driver, A Crit. and Ezeg. Comm. on Dt, 1895; The Hexateuch, by_J. Estlin_Car- enter and G. Harford-Battersby, I, II, 1900; G. A. mith, Jerus, II, 1908; W. Robertson Smith, The OT in the Jewish Church, 1895; A. Kuenen, The Hexateuch, 1886; H. E. Ryle, art. “Dt,” HDB, 1898; G. F. Moore, art. “Dt," Ene Bibl., 1899; J. A. Paterson, art. ‘“Dt,’’ Ene Brit, VIII, 1910. In German: De Wette, Drssert. crit-exeget., 1805; Kleinert, Das Dt wu. d. Deuteronomiker, 1872; Well- hausen, Die Comp. des Hez. u. d. hist. Biicher des AT, 1889; Gesch. Israels, 1895; Steuernagel, Der Rahmen des Di, 1894; Entsteh. des dt. Gesetzes, 1896. k Grorce L, Ropinson DEVICE, dé-vis’: “A scheme,” “invention,” “plot.” In the OT it stands for six Heb words, of which the most common is mahdshebheth (from hdshabh, ‘‘to think,” “contrive’”’). In the NT it occurs only twiee, once for Gr enthtimésis (Acts 17 29), and once for ndééma (2 Cor 2 11). Sometimes the word means simply that which is planned or invented, without any evil implication, as in 2 Ch 214; Acts 17 29 (of artistic work or invention), and Ecel 9 10 Gn the general sense of reasoning or contriving), But more frequently it is used in an evil sense, of a wicked purpose or plot, “Let_us devise devices against Jeremiah” (Jer 18 18); ‘‘For we are not ignorant of his [i.e. Satan’s] devices” (2 Cor 2 11), ete. D. Mratt Eywarps DEVIL, dev’. See Demon; Satan. DEVOTED, dé-vot‘ed, THINGS (071, herem). See Cursz; DerpicaTEr. DEVOTION, dé-vé’shun, DEVOTIONS (ceBde- para, sebdsmata): For AV ‘‘your devotions” (Acts 17 238), RV has ‘“‘the objects of your worship,” which is probably the intended meaning of AV. RV reads “devotion” for AV “prayer” in Job 15 4 (RVm “meditation,” Heb s7h). DEVOUT, dé-vout’ (ciAaBhs, culabés, eboeBhs, eusebés, v€Bopar, sébormai, “pious,” “dutiful,” “rever- ential’): The word is peculiar to St. Luke. Applied to Simeon (Lk 2 25), Cornelius (Acts 10 2.7), Ananias (22 12). ‘Devout proselytes’ (13 43, THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 840 AV “religious proselytes’’), with possible reference to the proselytes of righteousness as distinguished from the proselytes of the gate (see PRosELYTE). ‘Devout women of honorable estate” (13 50), proselytes to Judaism and wives of the men in bigh position among the heathen (see Jos, BJ, II, xx, 2). “Devout Greeks” (17 4), probably, though not necessarily, proselytes of the gate, heathen by birth, who attended the synagogue services and wor- shipped God. ‘Devout persons” (ver 17), prose- lytes of the gate. M. O. Evans DEW, di OD, tal; 8péc0s, drésos): Two things are necessary for the formation of dew, moisture and cold. In moist countries there is 1. Forma- less dew because the change in tem- tion of Dew perature between day and night is too small. Inthe deserts where the change in temperature between day and night is sometimes as much as 40° F., there is seldom dew because of lack of moisture in the atmosphere. Pal is fortu- nate in being near the sea, so that there is always a large percentage of water vapor in the air. The skies are clear, and hence there is rapid radiation beginning immediately after sunset, which cools the land and the air until the moisture is condensed and settles on cool objects. Air at a low tempera- ture is not capable of holding as much water vapor in suspension as warm air. ‘The ice pitcher fur- nishes an example of the formation of dew. Just as the drops of water form on the cool pitcher, so dew forms on rocks, grass and trees. In Pal it does not rain from April to October, and were it not for the dew in summer all vegetation would perish. Dew and rain are 2. Value of equally important. If there is no rain Dew in the winter grass and harvests fail; Palestine if no dew, the late crops dry up and there is no fruit. Failure of either of these gifts of Nature would cause great want and hardship, but the failure of both would cause famine and death. Even on the edge of the great Syrian desert in Anti-Lebanon, beyond Jordan and in Sinai, a considerable vegetation of a eertain kind flourishes in the summer, although there is not a drop of rain for six months. The dews are so heavy that the plants and trees are literally soaked with water at night, and they absorb sufficient moisture to more than supply the loss due to evaporation in the day. It is more surprising to one who has not seen it before to find a flourishing vineyard prac- tically in the desert itself. Some of the small ani- mals of the desert, such as the jerboa, seem to have no water supply except the dew. The dew forms most heavily on good conductors of heat, such as metals and stones, because they radiate their heat faster and cool the air around them. The wetting of Gideon’s fleeee (Jes 6 38) is an indication of the amount of dew formed, and the same phenomenon might be observed any elear night in summer in Pal. Dew was a present necessity to the people of Israel as it is today to the people of the same lands, so Jeh ae “TY will be as the dew unto 3. Impor- Israel” (Hos 14 5). Dew and rain tance to are of equal importance and are spoken Israel of together in 1 K 17 1. It was esp. valued by the children of Israel in the desert, for it supplied the manna for their suste- nance (Ex 16 13; Nu 11 9). Isaac in blessing Jacob asked that the “dew of heaven” (Gen 27 28) may be granted to him; that these things which make for fertility ' 4. Symbol and prosperity may be his portion. of Blessing “Lhe remnant of Jacob shall be in the _ midst of many peoples as dew from Jeh” (Mic 5 7), as a means of blessing to the na- tions. ‘Blessed of Jeh for. . . . dew” (Dt 33 13). 841 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Device Dial of Ahaz Dew is the means of refreshing and reinvigor- ating all vegetation. Many Scripture references carry out this idea. The song of 5. Symbol Moses says, ‘‘“My speech shall distil of Re- as the dew” (Dt 32 2). “A cloud of freshment dew’ (Isa 18 4) refreshes the har- vesters. ‘My head is filled with dew” (Cant 6 2). “Like the dew of Hermon” (Ps 133 3). “Thou hast the dew of thy youth” (Ps 110 3). “Thy dew is as the dew of herbs” (Isa 26 19). Job said of the time of his prosperity, ‘“The dew lieth all night upon my branch” (Job 29 19). Other figures use dew as the symbol of stealth, of that which comes up unawares (2 8 17 12), and of inconstaney (Hos 6 4; 13 3). God's knowl- edge covers the whole realm of the phenomena of Nature which are mysteries to man (Job 38 28; Prov 3 20). Autrren H. Joy DIADEM, di’a-dem: There are seven Bible ref- erences to the diadem, four in the OT and three in the NT. The Heb words do not mark any clear distinctions. : (1) O22, cdniph, M13X, cdndph, MD"2¥, caniphah (all from 03%, ¢énaph, primarily “to wrap,” ‘‘dress,”’ ‘Foll’”’) mean a headdress in the nature of a turban or piece of cloth wrapped or twisted about the head. The word is also rendered “hood,” “mitre.” Job 29 14: ‘‘My justice was as a robe and a diadem”’ (RVn, ‘‘turban’’); Isa 62 3: “a royal diadem in the hand of thy God.” (2) MVP DX, ¢¢phirdh, means “a crown,” “diadem,” Le. something round about the head; Isa 28 5° ‘9, diadem of beauty, unto the residue of his people.” (8) NDF, mignepheth, means an official turban or tiara of priest or king, tr‘ also “mitre.” Hzk 21 26: “Remove the mitre, and take off the crown.” (4) d:ddnua, diddéma, the Gr word in the NT for “diadem,” means ‘something bound about the head.” Found 3 t, all in Rev—12 3: “a great red dragon . . . . and upon his heads seven diadems” (AV “crowns’”’); 18 1: “a beast... . and on his horns ten diadems’”’; 19 11.12: “a white horse .... and upon his head are many diadems.”’ See Crown. Wituiam Enwarp RaFFetTy DIAL, di’al, OF AHAZ, &’haz, THE: . Hezekiah's Sickness and the Sign The Sign a Real Miracle The " Dial” a Staircase Time of Day of the Miracle . Hezekiah’s Choice of the Sign . Meaning of the Sign . The Fifteen ‘‘Songs of Degrees’’ One of the most striking instances recorded in Holy Scripture of the interruption, or rather rever- sal, of the working of a natural law is 1. Heze- the going back of the shadow on the kiah’s Sick- dial of Ahaz at the time of Hezekiah’s NoOoup toe ness and _recovery from his illness. The record the Sign of the incident is as follows. Isaiah was sent to Hezekiah in his sickness, to say: “Thus saith Jehovah, the God of David thy father, I have heard thy prayer, I have seen thy tears: behold, I will heal thee; on the third day thou shalt go up unto the house of Jehovah..... And Hezekiah said unto Isaiah, What shall he the sign that Jehovah will heal me, and that I shall go wp unto the house of Jehovah the third day ?_ And Isaiah said, This shall he the sign unto thee from Jehovah, that Jehovah will do the thing that he hath spoken: shall the shadow go forward ten steps, or go hack ten steps? And Hezekiah answered, It is a light thing for the shadow to decline ten steps: nay, but let the shadow return backward ten ae And Isaiah the prophet cried unto Jehovah; and he hrought the shadow ten steps backward, hy which it had gone down on the dial of Ahaz’”’ (2 K 20 5-11). And in Isa 38 8, it is said, ‘‘ Behold, I will cause the shadow on the steps, which is gone down on the dial of Ahaz with the sun, to return backward ten steps. Sothesun returned ten steps on the dial whereon it was gone down.” The first and essential point to be noted is that this was no ordinary astronomical phenomenon, nor was it the result of ordinary astro- 2. The Sign nomical laws then unknown. It was a Real peculiar to that particular place, and Miracle to that particular time; otherwise we should not read of ‘‘the ambassadors of the princes of Babylon, who sent .. .. to in- quire of the wonder that was done in the land” (2 Ch 32 31). It is impossible, therefore, to accept the suggestion that the dial of Ahaz may have been improperly constructed, so as to produce a reversal of the motion of the shadow at certain times. For such a maladjustment would have occasioned the repetition of the phenomenon every time the sun returned to the same position with respect to the dial. The narrative, in fact, informs us that the occurrence was not due to any natural Jaw, known or unknown, since Hezekiah was given the choice and exercised it of his own free will, as to whether a shadow should move in a particular direction or in the opposite. But there are no alternative results in the working of a natural law. ‘If astate of things is repeated in every detail, it must lead to exactly the same consequences.” The same natural law cannot indifferently produce one result, or its opposite. The movement of the shadow on the dial of Ahaz was, therefore, a miracle in the strict sense of the term. It cannot be explained by the working of any astronomical law, known or un- known. We have no information as to the as- tronomical conditions at the time; we can only inquire into the setting of the miracle. It is unfortunate that one important word in the narrative has been rendered in both AV and RV by a term which describes a recog- 3. The nized astronomical instrument. The “Dial”? a word “dial” (ma‘dléth) is usually tr4 Staircase “degrees,” ‘‘steps,”’ or “stairs,” and indeed is thus rendered in the same verse. There is no evidence that the structure referred to had been designed to serve as a dial or was anything other than a staircase, ‘‘the staircase of Ahaz.”’ It was probably connected with that “covered way for the sabbath that they had built in the house, and the king’s entry without,’ which Ahaz turned “round the house of Jeh, because of the king of Assyria” (2 K 16 18RVm). This staircase, called after Ahaz because the alteration was due to him, may have been substituted for David’s ‘‘causeway that goeth up,” which was ‘westward, by the gate of Shallecheth” (1 Ch 26 16), or more probably for Solomon’s “ascent by which he went up unto the house of Jehovah” which so impressed the queen of Sheba (2 Ch 9 4). At certain times of the day the shadow of some object fell upon this staircase, and we learn 4, Time of from both 2 K and Isa that this Day of the shadow had already gone down ten Miracle steps, while from Isa we learn in addi- tion that the sun also was going down. The miracle therefore took place in the afternoon, when the sun moves on its downward course, and when all shadows are thrown in an easterly direc- tion. We are not told what was the object that cast the shadow, but it must have stood to the west of the staircase, and the top of the staircase must have passed into the shadow first, and the foot of the staircase have remained longest in the light. The royal palace is understood to have been placed southeast of the Temple, and it is therefore probable that it was some part of the Temple buildings that had cast its shadow down the stairway in full view of the dying king, as he lay in his chamber. If the afternoon were well advanced the sun would be moving rapidly in altitude, and but little in azi- muth; or, in other words, the shadow would be ad- Dial of Ahaz Dictionaries THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 842 vancing down the steps at its quickest rate, but be moving only slowly toward the left of those who were mounting them. It may well have been the case, therefore, that the time had come when the priests from Ophel, and the officials and courtiers from the palace, were going up the ascent into the house of the Lord to be present at the evening sacrifice; pass- ing from the bright sunshine at the foot of the stairs into the shadow that had already fallen upon the upper steps. Thesnn would be going straight down behind the buildings and the steps already in shadow would sink into deeper shadow, not to emerge again into the light until a new day’s sun had arisen upon the earth. We can therefore understand the nature of the choice of the sign that was offered by the prophet to the dying king. Would he choose 5. Heze- ‘that ten more steps should be straight- kiah’s way engulfed in the shadow, or that Choice of | ten steps already shadowed should be the Sign brought back into the light? Either : might serve as a‘sign that he should arise on the third day and go up in renewed life to the house of the Lord; but the one sign would be in accordance with the natural progress of events, and the other would be directly opposed to it. It would be a light thing, as Hezekiah said, for the shadow to go forward ten steps; a bank of cloud rising behind the Temple would effect that change. But no disposition of cloud could bring the shadow back from that part of the staircase which had already passed into it, and restore it to the sunshine. The first. change was, in human estimation, easily possi- ble, ‘“‘a hght thing’; the second change seemed impossible. Hezekiah chose the seemingly impos- sible, and the Lord gave the sign and answered his prayer. We need not ask whether the king showed more or less faith in choosing thé ‘impossible’ rather than the “possible” sign. His father Ahaz had shown his want of faith by refusing to put the Lord to the test, by refusing to ask a sign, whether in the heaven above or in the earth beneath. The faith of Hezekiah was shown in asking a sign, which was at once in the heaven above and in the earth beneath, in accepting the choice offered to him, and so putting the Lord to the test. And the sign chosen was most fitting. Hezekiah lay dying, whether of plague or of cancer-we do not know, but his disease was mortal and beyond cure; he was already entering into the shadow of death. The word of the Lord was sure to him; on “the third day”’ he would rise and go up in new Hie to the house of God. But what of the sign? Should the shadow of death swallow him up; should his 6. Meaning life be swiftly cut off in darkness, and of the Sign be hidden until a new day should dawn, and the light of a new life, a life of resurrection, arise? (Cf Jn 11 24.) Or should the shadow be drawn back swiftly, and new years be added to his Life before death could come upon him? Swift death was in the natural progress of events; restoration to health was of the impossible. He chose the restoration to health, and the Lord answered his faith and his prayer. We are not able to go farther into particulars. The first temple, the royal palace, and the staircase of Ahaz were all destroyed in the destruction of Jerus by Nebuchadnezzar, and we have no means of ascertaining the exact position of the staircase with respect to Temple or palace, or the number of the steps that it contained, or the time of the day, or the season of the year when the sign was given. It is possible that if we knew any or all of these, a yet greater significance, both spiritual and astro- nomical, might attach to the narrative. Fifteen years were added to the life of Hezekiah. In the restoration of the second temple by Herod fifteen steps led from the Court of the Women to the Court of Israel, and on these steps the Levites during the Feast of Tabernacles were 7. The accustomed to stand in order to sing Fifteen the fifteen “songs of degrees’ (Pss “Songs of 120-34). At the head of these same Degrees” steps in the gateway, lepers who had been cleansed from their disease pre- sented themselves to the priests. It has been suggested that Hezekiah himself was the compiler of these fifteen “songs of the steps,” in thankfulness for his fifteen years of added life. Five of them are ascribed to David or as written for Solomon, but the remaining ten bear no author’s name. Their subjects are, howéver, most appropriate to the great crises and desires of Hezekiah’s life. His great Pass- over, to which all the tribes were invited, and so many Israelites came; the blasphemy of Rabshakeh and of Sennacherib’s threatening letter; the danger of the Assyr invasion and the deliverance from it; Hezekiah’s sickness unto death and his miraculous restoration to health; and the fact that at that time he would seem to have had no son to follow him on the throne—all these subjects seem to find fitting expression in the fifteen Psalms of the Steps. E. W. MaunpEeR DIAMOND, di’a-mund. See Sronzs, PReE- cIous. DIANA, di-an’a (ARTEMIS) ("Aprepts, Artemis, “prompt,” “safe’’): A deity of Asiatic origin, the mother goddess of the earth, whose seat of worship was the temple in Ephesns, the capital of the Rom province of Asia. Diana is but the Latinized form of the Gr word Artemis, yet the Artemis of Ephesus should not be confused with the Gr goddess of that name. She may, however, be identified with the Cyhele of the Phrygians whose name she also hore, and with several other deities who were worshipped under different names in various parts of the Orient. In Cappadocia she was known as Ma; to the Syrians as Atargatis or Mylitta; among the Phoenicians as Astarte, a name which appears among the Assyrians as Ishtar; the modern name Esther is derived from it. The same goddess seems to have been worshipped hy the Hittites, for a female deity is sculptured on the rocks at Yazili Kaya, near the Hittite city of Boghazkeui. It may be shown ultimately that the various goddesses of Syria and Asia Minor all owe their origin to the earlier Assyrian or Babylonian Ishtar, the goddess of love, whose chief attributes they possessed. The several forms and names under which she appears are due to the varying developments in different regions. Tradition says that Diana was born in the woods near Ephesus, where her temple was built, when her image of wood (possibly ebony; Pliny, NH, xvi. 40; Acts 19 35) fell from the sky (see also AsTRON- omy, I, 8 [2]). Also according to tradition the city which was later called Ephesus was founded by the Amazons, and Diana or Cybele was the deity of those half-mythical people. Later when Ephesus fell into the possession of the Greeks, Gr civiliza- tion partly supplanted the Asiatic, and in that city the two civilizations were blended together. The Gr name of Artemis was given to the Asiatic god- dess, and many of the Gr colonists represented her on their coins as Greek. Her images and forms of worship remained more Asiatic than Gr. Her ear- liest statues were figures crudely carved in wood. Later when she was represented in stone and metals, she bore upon her head a mural headdress, repre- senting a fortified city wall; from it, drapery hung upon each side of her face to her shoulders. The upper part of her body was completely covered with rows of breasts to signify that she was the mother of all life. The lower arms were extended. The lower part of the body resembled a rough block, as if her legs had been wrapped up in cloth like those of an Egyp mummy. In later times her Gr fol- lowers represented her with stags or lions standing 843 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dial of Ahaz Dictionaries at her sides. The most renowned of her statues stood on the platform before the entrance to her temple in Ephesus. As the statues indicate, she impersonated the reproductive powers of men and of animals and of all other life. Diana. At the head of her cult was a chief priest, originally a eunuch who bore the name and later the title Megabyzos. Under him were priests known as Hssenes, appointed. berhars from the city Officials, for but a single year; it was their duty to offer the sacrifices to the goddess in behalf of the city. Other subordinate classes of priests known as Kourétes, Krobatat and Hiirot performed duties which are now obscure. The priestesses were even more numerous, and, probably from their great numbers, they were called Melissai or bees; the Ephesian symbol there- fore which appears commonly upon the coins struck in the city, isa bee. The Melissai, which in the early times were all virgins, were of three classes; it is no longer known just what the special duties of each class were. The ritual of the temple services consisted of sacrifices and of ceremonial prostitution, a practice which was common to many of the religions of the ancient Orient, and which still exists among some of the obscure tribes of Asia Minor. The temple of Diana was not properly the home of the goddess; it was but a shrine, the chief one, devoted to her service. She lived in Nature; she was everywhere wherever there was life, the mother of all living things; all offerings of every possible nature were therefore acceptable to her; hence the vast wealth which poured into her temple. Not only was she worshipped in her temple, but in the minute shrines or naot which were sometimes mod- eled after the temple. More frequently the shrines were exceedingly crude objects, either of silver or stone or wood or clay. They were-made at Ephesus by dependents of the temple, and carried by the pilgrims throughout the world. Before them Diana might also be worshipped anywhere, just as now from the soil of the sacred Mesopotamian city of Kerbela, where the sons of Ali were martyred, little blocks are formed and are carried away by the Shiah Moslems that they may pray upon sacred ground wherever they may be. The makers of the shrines of Diana formed an exceedingly large class among whom, in Paul’s time, was Demetrius (Acts 19 24). None of the silver shrines have been dis- covered, but those of marble and of clay have ap- peared among the ruins of Ephesus. They are exceedingly crude; in a little shell-like bit of clay, a, crude clay female figure sits, sometimes with a tam- bourine in one hand and a cup in the other, or with a lion at her side or beneath her foot. Though the shrines were sold as sacred dwelling-places of the goddess, that the pilgrims who carried them to their distant homes, or buried them in the graves with their dead, might be assured of her constant pres- ence, their real purpose was to increase the temple revenues by their sale at a price which was many times their cost. With theshrines of Diana may be compared the household gods of clay found-in abundance among the ruins of the earlier Bab cities, esp. those cities in which temples to the goddess Ishtar stood. E. J. Banxs DIASPORA, di-as’pé-ra. DIBLAH, dib’la (M237, dibhlah, “circle”; AeB- Ad@a, Debldtha): The name occurs only in Ezk 6 14 (AV “Diblath”), and the place has not been iden- tified. If the reading is correct it may possibly be represented by Dzbl, a village in Upper Galilee, S. oF Seas But more likely it is a scribal error for DIBLAIM, dib’lé-im, dib-la’im (02927, dibh- layim, “two cakes’): A native of Northern Israel and father of Gomer, the wife of Hosea (Hos 1 3). DIBLATH, dib’lath. See Drsian. DIBLATHAIM, dib-la-tha’im. LATHAIM. DIBON, di’bon, DIBON-GAD (753°, dibhan, ‘“Gvashing”; AaBdév, Daibén): (1) A city of Moab captured by the Amorites (Nu 21 30), and held by them at the invasion by Israel. It was taken and given to the tribe of Gad, whence it is called Dibon-gad (Nu 32 34; 33 45). In Josh 13 17 it is reckoned to Reuben. Along with other cities in the territory N. of the Arnon, Dibon changed hands several times between Moab and Israel. Mesha claims it (MS), and in Jer 48 18.22 it is named among the cities of Moab. The form of the name, Dimon, in Isa 15 9, may have been given to make it resemble the Heb dam, “blood,’”’ to support the play upon words in the verse (HDB,s.v.)._ It is represented by the modern Dhiban, about 4 miles N. of Aroer (‘Ara‘ir), on the line of the old Rom road. The ruins that spread over two adjacent knolls are of no importance: walls, a tower, cistern, etc. Near Dibon the famous Moabite Stone was found. (2) A town in Judah, occupied after the exile (Neh 11 25). It may be the same as Dimonah (Josh 15 22); unidentified. W. Ewine DIBRI, dib’ri C737, dibhr7, “eloquent” [?]): A Danite, whose daughter Shelomith married an Egyptian. Their son was “cut off” (stoned) for blasphemy (Lev 24 11). DICE-PLAYING. Scc Gamus. DICTIONARIES, dik’shun-a-riz: A dictionary is a word-book or a list of words arranged in some fixed order, generally alphabetical, for ready refer- ence, and usually with definitions or longer treatises. The vocabulary or glossary is a mere list of words, often without definitions; the Lexicon or dictionary of language (words or concepts) has bare definitions, and the alphabetical encyclopaedia or dictionary of knowledge or information (objects, things, subjects, topics, etc) has longer treatises, but they are all See DisPERsION. See ALMoNn-pIB- Dictionaries THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 844 dictionaries: the alphabetical order being the main essential in modern use. There is, however, his- torically no good reason why the dictionary should not be logical or chronological. The earliest use of the word as quoted by Murray’s Dictionary (Joh. de Garlandia, cir 1225) was of a collection of words classified and not alphabetical. So, too, almost the earliest use in Eng. (J. Withal’s Dictionarie, 1556) was of a book of words classified by subjects. A book like Roget’s Thesaurus, which is a list of classi- fied words without definition, or a systematic en- cyclopaedia of treatises like Coleridge's unfortunate experiment, the Encyclopedia Metropolitana, is a dictionary in the historic sense. The earliest books usually quoted in the lists of Bib. dictionaries were also in fact classified or chronological, and not alphabetical (Eusebius’ Onomasticon; Jerome’s De viris illustribus). Classified word lists, sylla- baries, etc, of pre-alphabetic times, as well as in Chinese and other non-alphabetic languages of to- day, are of course also non-alphabetic, but strictly dictionaries. In pre-alphabetic times the dictionaries include, besides the syllabaries of which there were many examples in Assyria, Babylonia, Egypt, Cyprus, etc, and the word lists proper, chronological lists of kings and various classified lists of tribute, and of astronomical or other objects. They include, in short, all the many lists where the material is grouped round a series of catchwords. The alphabetical dictionary began with the alpha- bet itself, for this is a list of names of objects. The earlier alphabetical dictionaries were sometimes called alphabets. In a sense the alphabetical acrostics are dictionaries rather than acrostics, and Ps 119, where considerable material is grouped under each letter of the alphabet, comes rather close to the dictionary idea. So long as the quantity of literary material re- mained small, there was very little need for the development of the alphabetical dictionary, and the examples are rather few, the Lexicon of Suidas being perhaps the most noteworthy. With the im- mense increase in literary material there was a rapidly growing appreciation of the advantage of alphabetical arrangement, over the chronological or the systematic, in all cases where the object is to refer to a specific topic, rather than to read a book through or survey many topics with reference to their relation to one another. The number of alpha- betical dictionaries of knowledge increased rapidly with the growth of learning from the 13th cent.; now it has become legion and there are few subjects so narrow that they cannot boast their dictionary of information. The earliest Bible dictionary is usually counted the Onom of Eusebius, a geographical encyclopaedia; then came Jerome’s De nominibus 1. Bible hebraicis, and his De viris illustribus Dictionaries (chronological). The more noteworthy steps in the history of Bible diction- aries are represented by the names of Alsted, Cal- met, Winer, Kitto, William Smith, Fairbairn, Schenkel. The best recent dictionaries among the larger works are the Encyclopaedia Biblica, stand- ing for the extreme higher critical wing; Hastings, representing the slightly less radical; and this present International Standard Bible Encyclopaedia, which represents a growing distrust of the extreme positions of the 19th cent. higher critics. All of these are on a large scale and stand for the latest and best scholarship, and the same quality is re- flected in at least two of the recent single-volume dictionaries, A Standard Bible Dictionary (M. W. Jacobus), and the single-volume Hastings’ diction- ary. Both of these in tendency stand between Cheyne’s Encyclopaedia Biblica and this dictionary, Hastings facing rather toward Cheyne, and Jacobus toward this present work. - The John Crerar Library list of encyclopaedias forms an excellent guide to the lit. of general en- cyclopaedias within its scope, which 2. Bibli- includes chiefly technology and physi- ography cal and social sciences, but includes among its reference books very admir- ably chosen first-reference dictionaries to language, history, fine arts, and even philosophy and religion. Kroeger, Alice B. Guide to the Study and Use of Refer- ence Books, 2d ed, Boston, 1908, is an admirable intro- duction. Its select lists and bibliographical references supplemented hy the John Crerar and other reference lihrary lists will give complete orientation. Following is a list of previous dictionaries: BIBLICAL DICTIONARIES Ayre, J. Treasury of Bible Knowledge. London, 1866. Barnum, Samuel W. A Comprehensive Dictionary of the Bible. New York: Appleton, 1867. , ae Barr, John. A Complete Index and Concise Dictionary of the Holy Bible. New York: Methodist Book Con- cern, 1852. Bastow, J. A. Biblical Dictionary. 1848, 3 vols; condensed ed, London, 1859; 4th ed, 1877. London, Beck, Js C. Vollsténd. bibl. Worterbuch. Basel, 1770, 2 vols. Besser, H. Bibl. Worterbuch. Gotha, 1866. Bible Cyclopaedia, The. London: Parker, 1841. Bost, J. A. Dictionnaire dela Bible. Paris, 1865. Bourazan, F. A. Sacred Dictionary. London: Nishet, 0. Brown, John. A Dictionary of the Holy Bible. Edin- hurgh, 1768,4thed; London: Murray, 1797; American ea ror the 12th Edinhurgh ed, New York: Harper, Calmet, A. Dict. historique, critique, chronologique, géo- graphique et littéral de la Bible. Paris, 1719. Calmet, Augustine. Dictionary of the Holy Bible. 5th ed, revised and enlarged, 5 vols, London: Holdsworth, 1829; new ed, London: Bohn, 1847; abridged hy Buckley, new ed, London: Routledge, 1862. Cassell's Bible Dictionary. Ilustrated with nearly 600 engravings; London and New York, 2 vols: Cassell, 1866; new ed, 1869. Cheyne, T. K. and Black, J. 8S. Encyclopaedia Biblica. London, 1899-1903, 4 vols. Conder, F. R. and ©. R. A_ Handbook to the Bible. London: Longmans, 1879; 2d ed, 1880, New York: Randolph, n.d. [1880]. Dalmasius, J. A. Dictionarium manuale biblicum. Aug. Vind., 1776, 2 vols. Davis, J. . Dictionary of the Bible. Philadelphia, 1898; new ed, 1903. Eadie, John. A Biblical Cyclopaedia, London: Rel. Tr. Soc., 1848; 14th ed, London: Griffin, 1873. Easton, Illustrated Bible Dictionary. London: Nelson; New York: Methodist Book Concern, 1893. Fairbairn, Patrick. The Imperial Bible Dictionary. London: Blackie, 1866, 2 vols. Farrar, John. m, halah, “on , A6li; véeos, nésos): Palestine, from its position and physical conditions, ought to be a healthy country. That it is not so depends on the unsanitary conditions in which the people live and - the absence of any attempts to check the intro- duction or development of zymotic diseases. The number of marshes or pools is fairly small, and the use of active measures to destroy the larvae of mos- quitos might easily diminish or abolish the malarial fevers which now prevail all over the country. The freeing of Ismdilieh and Port Said from these pests is an object-lesson in sanitation. When one ex- amines the conditions of life in towns and villages all over the country, the evidences of the ravages of these fevers and their sequelae appear on every hand as they affect all ages from infancy to middle age, and one meets but few individuals of extreme old age. The absence of any adequate system of drainage and the pollution of the water supplies are also factors of great importance in preserving this unhealthiness. In ancient times it was regarded as healthier than Egypt, as it well might be, hence the diseases of Egypt are referred to as being worse than those of Pal (Dt 7 15; 28 60; Am 410). The sanitary regulations and restrictions of the PC would doubt- less have raised the standard of public health, but it is unlikely that these were ever observed over any large area. ; The types of disease which are referred to in the Bible are those that still prevail. Fevers of several kinds, dysentery, leprosy, intestinal worms, plague, nervous diseases such as paralysis and epilepsy, insanity, ophthalmia and skin diseases are among the commonest and will be described under their several names. Methods of treatment are described under Mepicine; Puysician. The word “disease” or “diseases” in AV is changed to “sickness” in RV The Scrip-. in 2K 12; 8 8; Mt 9 35, and left out in Jn 5 4; while in Mt 8 17 ‘‘sicknesses”’ is replaced by “diseases.”’ RV also changes ‘infirmity’ in Lk 7 21 to “diseases,”’ and in Ps 38 7 ‘‘a loathsome dis- ease”’ is changed to “burning.” ALEX. MACALISTER DISEASES OF THE EYE. See Evzs, Diszasrs OF. DISH: The rendering in EV in some connections of three Heb and one Gr word. The k*‘érdéh of Ex 25 29; 37 16; Nu 4 7 was apparently a kind of salver, in this case of gold, for holding the loaves of the “presence bread.’ The same word represents Slave Bearing Covered Dishes. the silver “platters” (Nu 7 13 ff) brought by the princes as a dedication gift. The séphel of Jgs 5 25 was a large bow], so tr? in Jgs 6 38. ‘‘Lordly dish” is lit. ‘‘bowl of [fit for] nobles.’ The ¢allahath of 2 K 21 13; Prov 19 24; 26 15 (last two AV “bosom” after LX X) refers probably to the wide, deep dish in which the principal part of the meal was served. Of somewhat similar form may have been the triéblion (LXX for ke‘drah) mentioned in connection with the Passover meal (Mt 26 23; Mk 14 20). BensaMin Reno Downer DISHAN, di’shan, DISHON, di’shon (71, di- shan, TU", dishén, “antelope,” “pygarg”’): A Horite clan, mentioned as the youngest ‘‘son” and else- where as the ‘‘grandson” of Seir. The form Dishon occurs several times in the list of Horite clans, to- gether with many other totem names (Gen 36 passim; 1 Ch 1 38.41). See Gray, HPN, 89. DISHONESTY, dis-on’es-ti: Only in 2 Cor 4 2, the AV rendering of Gr aischtiné; AV elsewhere and RV uniformly, ‘‘shame.” DISOBEDIENCE, dis-d-bé’di-ens, DISOBE- DIENT (11, mardh; awedéo, apeithéd, wapa- kotw, parakouod): The word used chiefly in the NT has the general meaning of a lack of regard for authority or rulership. The stronger meaning of actual stubbornness or violence is perhaps conveyed in the OT (1 K 13 26; Neh 9 26; cf1 K 18 21). In the NT there seem to be two rather clearly defined uses of the word, one objective and practi- cal, the other ethical and psychological. The first refers more to conduct, the second to belief and one’s mental attitude toward the object of disobedience. To the first belong such passages as refer to the overt act of disobedience to one’s parents (Rom 1 30; 2 Tim 3 2). Illustrating this more fully, the tr according to the AV of 1 Tim 1 9 is given as “uuruly” in the RV. By far the greater emphasis, however, is placed upon the distinctly ethical quality in which disobedience is really an attitude of the mind and finds its essence in a heart of unbelief and unfaithfulness (1 Pet 2 7.8; Eph 2 2; 5 6; Col 8 6). In the latter three references ‘children [sons] of disobedience” are mentioned, as if one should 855 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Discus Dispersion, The become the very offspring of such an unhappy and unholy state of mind. The classic phrase of NT lit. (Acts 26 19) contains both the practical and the ethical aspects. Paul’s convictions were changed by the vision and his conduct was made to conform immediately to it. Water G. CLippincer DISORDERLY, dis-ér’dér-li (Graxtos, dlaktos): The word is found four times in the Epp. to the Thess (1 Thess 5 14; 2 Thess 3 6.7.11), ‘““With- draw yourselves from every brother that walketh d.’’s “We behaved not ourselves d.”; “We hear of some that walk among you d.” The word is a military term and has reference to the soldier who does not keep the ranks (inordinatus, Liv). Then it refers to people who refuse to obey the civil laws, and thus it gets its meaning, ‘‘disorderly.” It points to members in the early church, who, by their lives, became a reproach to the gospel of Christ (cf 1 Thess 4 11.12). Henry E. Dosker DISPATCH, dis-pach’: Occurs Tob 7 8 in the sense of dispatch of business, “Let this business be dispatched” (RV ‘‘finished”); 2 Macc 12 18, “‘be- fore he had dispatched anything’ (RV “without accomplishing”); Wisd 11 19 [20]'in the sense of finishing, destroying, “dispatch them at once” (RV “eonsume”); 2 Macc 9 4 ‘dispatch the journey” (kataniein), which may mean “finish it quickly.” RV spells “despatch.” DISPENSATION, dis-pen-sa’shun: The Gr word (oikonomia) so tr4 signifies primarily, a stewardship, the management or disposition of affairs intrusted to one. Thus 1 Cor 9 17, AV “A dispensation of the gospel is committed unto me,” RV “TI have a stewardship intrusted to me.” The idea is similar in Eph 3 2 || Col 1 25 (RVm “stewardship”). In Eph 1 10 God’s own working is spoken of as a “dispensation.” DISPERSION, dis-pdr’shun, THE (Sac7opd, diaspora) : 1. Golah and Dispersion 19. Among Greeks Proper 2. Purpose of cs 20. The Roman Dispersion 3. Causes of a 21. Jews and Pompey 4. Extent of 22. Jews and the First Cae- 5. The Eastern a sars 6. The Egyptian“ 23. Influence of Jews in the 7. Testimony of Aramaic Early Roman Empire Papyri 24 Jews in Italy, Gaul, 8. Towle Temple at Syene Spain and N. Africa. 9. Theories of the Syene 25. The. Numbers of the Settlement Dispersion 10. Impertance of the Dis- 26. Jewish Proselytism covery 27. Internal Organization 11. A New Chapter of OT 28. Unity of the Jewish History People 12. Alexandrian Judaism 29. Dispersion Influenced 13. The Jews and Hellenism by_Greek Thought 14, The Septuagint 30. The Dispersion a Prep- 15. Early vidence of a aration for the Ad- Jewish Community vent of Christ 16. The Dispersion in Syria 31. The Dispersion au Aux- 17. In Arabia jliary to the Spread 18. In Asia Minor of the Gospel The Dispersion is the comprehensive designation applied to Jews living outside of Pal and maintaining their religious observances and cus- 1. Golah toms among the Gentiles. They were and known as the Galah (Arant. Galitha’), Diaspora _ the captivityy—an expression describing them in relation to their own land; and the Diaspora, the Dispersion, an, expression describing them in relation to the nations among whom they were scattered. On a notable occasion Jesus said, ‘Ye shall seek me, and shall not find me: and where I am, ye cannot come. The Jews there- fore said among themselves, Whither will this man go that we shall not find him? Will he go unto the Dispersion among the Greeks, and teach the Greeks?” (Jn 7 34.35). In 2 Macc certain priests of Jerus are represented as praying to God: “Gather together our Disper- sion, set at liberty them that are in 2. Purpose bondage among the heathen” (2 Mace of the 1 27; ef 2 Esd 2 7; Jas 11; 1 Pet Dispersion 11). The thought of such a Disper- sion as a punishment for the discbe- dience of the people finds frequent expression in the Prophets: Hosea (9 3), Jeremiah (8 3; 16 15, etc), Ezekiel (4 13), and Zechariah (10 9). And it ap- pears also in the Deuteronomic Law (Dt 28 25; 30 1). That the Dispersion of the Jews was for the benefit of the Gentiles is a conception to which expression is given in utterances of psalmists and prophets (Ps 67; Mic 6 7, etc). It is found also in the Apoc Bar, a work belonging to the Ist cent. AD: “I will scatter this people among the hee that they may do good to the Gentiles” The causes of the Dispersion most obvious to the student of OT history were the Assyr and Bab captivities, when the king of Assyria 3. Causes carried Israel away into his own land of the and placed them in Halah, and in Dispersion Habor by the river of Gozan, and in the cities of the Medes (2 K 17 5 ff); and when in the reign of Nebuchadrezzar, king of Babylon, Judah was carried away into Babylonia (2 K 24 14). See Capriviry. But there were other captivities which helped to scatter the chil- dren of Abraham. Ptolemy I of Egypt (322-285 BC) by his expeditions to Pal and his capture of Jerus added largely to the Jewish population of Alexandria. Antiochus the Great of Syria (223- 187 BC) removed from the Jewish communities in Mesopotamia and Babylon 2,000 families and settled them in Phrygia and Lydia (Jos, Ant, XII, iii, 4). Pompey after his capture of Jerus in 63 BC carried off hundreds of Jews to Rome, where they were sold as slaves, but, afterward, many of them obtained their freedom and civic rights. There was, besides, a voluntary emigration of Jewish settlers for purposes of trade and commerce into the neighboring countries, and 4. Extent esp. into the chief cities of the civilized of the world. The successors of Alexander Dispersion and their successors in turn, encouraged immigration into their territories and the mingling of nationalities. They needed colo- nists for the settlements and cities which they estab- lished, and with the offer of citizenship and facilities for trade and commerce they attracted many of the Jewish people. “In this way,’’ says Philo, ‘‘Jerus became the capital, not only of Judaea, hut of many other lands, en account of the colonies which it sent out from time to time into the bordering districts of Egypt, Phoenicia, Syria, Coele- Syria, and into the more distant regions of Pam hylia, Cilicia, the greater part of Asia Minor as far as Bithynia, and the remotest corners of Pontus. And in like manner into Europe: into Thessaly, and Boeotia, and Macedonia, and Aetolia, and Attica and Argos, and Corinth, and into the most fertile and fairest parts of the Peloponnesus. And not only is the continent full of Jewish colonists, hut also the most important islands, such as Euboea, Cyprus, and Crete. I say nothing of the countries beyond the Euphrates. All of them except a very small portion, and. Babylon, and all the satrapies which contain fruit- ful land, have Jewish inhabitants" (Philo, Leg ad Caium, About the middle of the 2d cent. BC the Sibylline Oracles could say of the Jewish people: “Every land and every sea is full of thee” (3 271). About the same period the Rom Senate, being anxious to extend protection to the Jews, had a circular letter written in their favor to the kings of Egypt, Syria, Pergamum, Cappadocia and Parthia, and to a great number of provinces, cities and islands of the Medi- terranean, where presumably there was a larger or smaller number of Jews (1 Macc 15 15 ff). It Dispersion, The THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 856 is no surprise, therefore, to read that for the Feast of Pentecost at Jerus, there were present after the ascen- sion of Jesus: “Parthians and Medes and Elamites, and the dwellers in Mesopotamia, in Judaea and Cappadocia, in Pontus and Asia, in Phrygia and Pamphylia, in Egypt and the parts of Libya about Cyrene, and sojourners from Rome, both Jews and proselytes, Cretans and Arabians” (Acts 2 9-12). The Eastern Dispersion, caused by the Assyrian and Babylonian captivities, seems to have increased aud multiplied, and to have enjoyed a 5. The considerable measure of liberty, and Eastern of prosperity. When the return from Dispersion the captivity took place under Zerub- babel, it was only a small proportion of the exiles who sought a home again in the land of their fathers. Nor did the numbers who accom- panied Ezra from Babylon greatly diminish the exiles who remained behind. In the time of Christ, Jos could speak of the Jews in Babylonia by ‘‘in- numerable myriads” (Ant, XI, v, 2). He also tells us of the 2,000 Jewish families whom Antiochus transferred from Babylon and Mesopotamia to Phrygia and Syria. Of the peculiarities of the Jews as a people living apart and observing their own customs and arousing the ill-will of the neighbors, we have a glimpse in the Pers period in the Book of Est (3 8). Babylonia remained a focus of eastern Judaism for centuries, and from the discussions in rabbinical schools there were elaborated the Talm of Jerus in the 5th cent. of our era, and the Talm of Babylon a cent. later. The two chief centers of Mesopotamian Judaism were Nehardea, a town on the Euphrates, and Nisibis on the Mygdonius, an affluent of the Chaboras, which were also centers of Syrian Christianity. The Egyp Dispersion is of special interest and importance, and reeent diseoveries have thrown unexpected light upon it. As far 6. The baek as the days of Sheshenqg, the Egyptian founder of the 22d Dynasty, the Shi- Dispersion shak of 1K 14 25f; 2 Ch 12 2 , who invaded Pal in the 10th cent. BC, and engraved on the 8. wall of the great Temple of Karnak the names of many districts and cities he had captured, prisoners of war and hostages may have been earried off to Egypt by the conqueror. At a later time Jewish mercenaries are said to have fought in the expedition of Psammetichus II against Ethiopia, to which expedition belong the famous inseriptions of Abu Simbel (594-589 BC). So we learn from the well-known Letter of Aristeas. But the clearest and best-known example of a settle- ment of Jews in Egypt is that connected with the prophet Jeremiah. When Gedaliah, the governor of Judaea, after the destruction of Jerus in 586 BC, had been treacherously murdered, the depressed and dispirited remnant under Johanan, the son of Kareah, resolved to take flight into Egypt, against the counsel of Jeremiah. A host of fugitives, in- cluding Jeremiah and his friend Baruch, accordingly set out thither, and scttled at Migdol and Tah- panhes and Noph (Memphis), and in the country of Pathros in upper Egypt (Jer 43, 44). It was in Egypt with those fugitives that Jeremiah ended his life. Many of the fugitives were taken prisoners by Nebuchadrezzar on one of his latest expeditions to the west, and were transported to Babylon (Jos, Ant, X, ix, 7; ef Jer 43 8f). Ot this colony of Jews it is natural to see a strong con- firmation in the recent discovery of Aram. papyri_ at Assouan, the Syene of the ancients. The %. Testi- papyri were the contents of a deed box of a mony of member of a Jewish colony in upper Egypt, = and the deeds refer to house property in Aramaic which Jews are concerned. ere then at Papyri Assouan, about 470 BC is a colony of Jews who have acquired houses and other proper” ty, and have become bankers and money lenders, wit a cent. of the death of Jeremiah. In the papyri there is evi- dence of the existence of a tribunal of the Hebrews, a court where cases could be decided, as fully recognized hy law as any of the other courts, Egyp or Pers, for Egypt, the hasest of kingdoms," was then subject to a Pers suzerain. Most significant of all, Jeh is acknowledged as the God of the Jews, and the existence of a chapel and even of an altar of sacrifice is heyond all donbt. Evidently these Jews in Egypt did not consider that an altar of Jeh could not stand anywhere else than at Jerus, or that outside Jerus the worship of the synagogue was the only worshi of the God of their fathers. These facts are rendere still more striking when we regard them as a fulfilment of Isaiah's prophecy: ‘‘In that day there shall be five cities in the land of Egypt that speak the language of Canaan, and swear to Jehovah of hosts; one shall becalled the city of destruction. In that day there shall be an altar to Jehovah in the midst of the land of Egypt, and a pillar at the border thereof to Jehovah" (Isa 19 18.19).| These papyri give information similar to that which the clay tablets discovered at Nippur give regarding the house of Murashu Sons (see Captivity) about the same time— the time when Ezra was setting out from Babylon to restore at Jerus the worship of the temple which Zerub- habel had rebuilt. It was just about a cent. from the time that Jeremiah had gone down to Egypt that we have the first of these deeds, and it was the grandfathers, or great-grandfathers, of the persons concerned whom he had accompanied thither so much against his will. These papyri were discovered in 1904, and a year or two later, auditional papyri were discovered in a mound which stands on the site of the ancient 8. Jewish Elephantiné or Yeh, an island in the Nile, Temple on the frontier also. One of these papyri p contains a petition from the Jewish at Syene colony in Elephantiné addressed to Bagohi (called Bagoas by Jos, Ant, XI, vii, 7), the Pers governor of Judah, ahout 408 BC. They ask for assistance to enable them to rebuild the temple of Jeh in Elephantiné, which had been destroyed at the instigation of the priests of the ram-headed Egyp god Khnuh, who had a temple in the fortress of Yeh or Elephantiné. This Jewish temple had been erected to Jeh at least 125 years before and had been spared by Cambysesin 525 BC when he destroyed all the temples erected to the gods of Egypt. The destruction of the temple at Yeh occurred in the 14th year of Darius, 411 BC. It contained an altar for burnt sacrifice, and there were gold and silver vessels in which the blood of sacrifice was collected. The head of the college of priests presenting this petition is Jedoniah, a@ name found in an abbreviated form in Jadon (Neh 3 7). . An attempt has been made to show that the bearers of these Heb names were descended from the captivity of the Northern Kingdom. It is suggested 9. Theories that they had come into Egypt with the of the Pers army under Cambyses from their adopted homes in Assyria and the citles Syene of the Medes and had obtained possessions Settlement onthe sonthern frontier of Egypt. Names helieved to point to the Northern King- dom, like Hosea and Menahem, occur very frequently, hut this is too narrow a foundation for such a theory, and the Israelitish origin of the Syene colonists is not established (/QR) [1907], 441 ff). There is more to be said in favor of the view that they were the descendants of a Jewish military colony. That Jewish mercenaries fought in the campaigns of the Pharaohs we have already seen. And that Elephantiné was an important garri- son town on the frontier is also certain. Jos (Ani, XIV, vi, 2) mentions a Jewish military colony holding a post at Pelusium in the cent. before Christ, and this might be a similar garrison stationed at the opposite extremity of the land in the 5th cent. Such a garrison would attract Jews engaged in business and in the occupations of civil life, and so a distinct Jewish community would be formed. It has even been suggested that the tidings of the de- struction of the temple at Jerus furnished the motive to these Egyp Jews to build the temple and rear the altar of burnt offering which the heathen priests of _Khnub had destroyed. While the petition to the religious authorities at Jerus indicates that the priests of Elephantiné regarded their temple as dependent upon the temple 10. Im- at Jerus, it is significant that they were portance also, as is shown iu their letter, in com- f th munication with Delaiah and Shelemiah of the the sons of Sanballat, the governor of Discovery Samaria. That this was Nehemiah's A enemy (Neh 4 1; 6 1, etc) is impossible, for he lived nearly a cent. earlier. But the association with descendants of his, themselves Samaritans, gives a schismatical appearance to the position of the Elephan- tiné temple. he existence of this temple with its priest- hood, its altar of sacrifice, and its offerings, from 500 years BC, is an important fact in the history of the Dis- persion. It was meant to keep those Jewish exiles true to the religion of thelr fathers and in religious fellowship with their brethren in Pal. For a like purpose the Temple of Onias at Leontopolis was eroctaatt In the early years of the Maccabean struggle. Onias had to fiee from Jerus with a number of priests and Levites, and for the aid he rendered to Ptolemy Philometor, the king of Egypt, he received a gift of iand upon which he built a 857 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dispersion, The temple like to the Temple at Jerus. Professor Flinders Petrie _helieves he has discovered this temple of Onias IV at Tel el-Yehudiyeh (Hyksos and Israelite Cities, ee The discovery confirms the account given of the temple by Jos, who is our only authorlty for its erection (Ant, XIII, iii, 2; XIV, viii, 2). The Elephantiné-Syene papyri have added a new and valuable chapter to OT history. We know now of a Jewish temple in Egypt which 11. A New certainly reaches 400 years farther Chapter of into antiquity than the temple of OT Onias IV at Leontopolis, and we obtain important information as to the rela- tions of its priesthood with the leaders of the Jerus Jews and the Samaritans. We know now from unbiased authorities that the Jewish settlements in the Valley of the Nile are much older than has hitherto been believed. We have valuahle confirmation not only of the notices in the Book of Jer, but also of the statements in the later Helle- nistic lit. Moreover, it is now shown that the skep- ticism which has prevailed in some quarters as to the very existence of any considerable Egyp Dis- persion before the time of Alexander the Great is unwarranted (Peters, Die jridische Gemeinde von Elephantiné-Syene, 50{; Schiirer, GJV*, III, 19 f). What exactly were the fortunes of this Jewish community at a later time, no record has yet heen found to tell. Possibly it decayed in History 42. Alex- course of time, for Herodotus who andrian visited Egypt about 450 BC makes no Judaism mention of it and found no Jews in sufficient numbers to attract his atten- tion. It was undoubtedly with the founding of Alexandria in 332 BC that the flourishing period of Judaism in Egypt commenced. Alexander the Great had hastened from the field of victory at Issus 333 BC, through Syria hy way of Tyre, the siege of which occupied him some months, showing clemency to the inhabitants of Jerus and severity to the recalcitrant inhabitants of Gaza till by its eastern gate he entered Egypt and took possession of the land of the Pharaohs. The Jews appear to have been friendly to Macedonian conquest, and in Alexander’s new city they received the rights of citizenship and two quartersall tothemselves. That they were restricted to their own quarters does not appear, and in the time of Philo, at the commence- ment of the Christian era, they had synagogues and places of prayer in all parts of the city. Alexander died in 323 BC but the favor which he had accorded to the Jews was continued by the Ptolemies who succeeded to his Egyp empire. The first Ptolemy, Lagi or Soter (822-285 BC), increased the Jewish population of Alexandria by raids into Pal on which he brought back a large number of captives, both Jews and Samaritans. Other Jews, hearing of his liberality and of the prosperity of their coreligion- isis, were attracted to Egypt and settled in Alex- andria of their own accord (Jos, Ant, XII, i, 1). Under their own ethnarch they enjoyed great pros- perity and had full religious liberty. The principal synagogue of the city was on a scale of great mag- nificence. Inthe reign of Ptolemy Philometor (182- 146 BC) they were allowed to set up the temple at Leontopolis, as we have already noticed. In the time of Philo the Jewish colony in Egypt was con- sidered to number a million. It was in Alexandria that the Jews first came so powerfully under the influence of Hellenism, and here that the peculiar Graeco-Jewish 13. The philosophy sprang up of which Philo Jews and was the most notable representative. Hellenism Thesame soil was eminently favorahle to early Christianity which had from the end of the 2d cent. onward its greatest teachers and their learned catechetical school. See ALEX- ANDRIA. ‘ginning of the Christian era. The great monument of Hellenistic Judaism, which had its chief seat in Alexandria, is the LXX tr of the OT, which hecame such a powerful prae- 14. The pee graupelveg and wae abe Bihle of i ie Apostles an e firs istians, even SeHIMAgINU. Creiha sLoniedesie: Curses Himes Tt is ascribed in the Letter of Aristeas to the interest of Ptolemy II Philadelphus (285-247 BC) in a proposal to secure a copy of the Jawish Law in an accessible tr for the famous Royal Library. It is more likely that as familiarity with their Heh tongue diminished in_ their new surroundings, the need of an intelligihle version of the Law to hegin with was felt, and Jewish hands were set to work to produce it. In course of time the rest followed, hut from the tradition of its being the work of 70 or 72 translators it is known as the LXX. See Sup- TUAGINT. The question has been raised whether too much has not been made of a Jewish community in Alex- andriaso early, and it has heen asserted 15. Early that we can scarcely speak of a Jewish Evidence of Dispersion anywhere hefore the Macca- a Jewish bean period in the second half of the Community 2d cent. BC. The evidence as we have _, Seen points to the existence of Jewish communities continuously from the days of Jere- miah. Papyri prove the presence of Jews in Egypt, not only in the towns hut in country districts from a comparatively early period. A remarkable in- scription has recently come to light showing that at Schedia, some 20 miles from Alexandria, there existed a Jewish community which had huilt a syna- gogue and dedicated it to the honor of Ptolemy IIT Euergetes (247-222 BC) and his queen Berenice. If such a community was organized in the little town of Schedia at that date, we can well believe the cosmopolitan city of Alexandria to have had a considerable Jewish community at a still carlier date. When we turn to Syria, we find large numbers of Jews, notwithstanding the hatred of Greeks and Syrians. Jos (BJ, VII, iii, 3) says 16. Disper- that it is the country which has the sion in Syria largest percentage of Jewish inhabit- . ants, and Antioch among the towns of Syria had the preéminence. In Damascus, which seems to have had a Jewish quarter or Jewish ha- zaars in the days of Ahab (1 K 20 34 and Burney’s note ad loc.), the Jewish population was numbered by thousands. From Galilee and Gilead and the region of the Hauran, Judas Maccabaeus and his brother Jonathan brought hodies of Jews, who were settlers among a pagan population, for safety to Judaea (1 Mace 6). Even in Arahia Judaism had considerable footing. Edward Glaser, who prosecuted valuable archaeological researches in Arahia (see Hilprecht, Recent 17. In Researches in Bible Lands, 131 ff), professes A 4 bi to have féund Himyaritic inscriptions of rabia the 4th and 5th cents. of our era which are monotheistic and therefore Jewish, but there is still uncertainty as to this. In the heginning of the 6th cent. a Jewish king actually reigned in Arahia, and hecause of his persecution of the Christians he was attacked and overthrown by the Christian king of Ahys- sinia. Of the widespread distribution of the Dispersion in Asia Minor there is abundant testimony, not only in the texts of the apostles, but in clas- 18. In Asia sical and early Christian lit. and in the Minor epigraphic lit. which has been accumu- lating for the last 30 years. At Per- gamum, in Lydia, in Karia, at Magnesia, at Tralles, at Miletum, in Cappadocia, Bithynia, and Pontus, considerahle Jewish communities existed at the he- At Smyrna the Jews played a prominent part in the death of Polycarp 155 AD, being esp. zealous in heaping up fagots upon the fire that consumed the martyr. In his Cities and Bishoprics of Phrygia Sir William Ram- say mentions numerous indications found on inscrip- tions of Jewish settlers, and his chapter on ‘‘The Jews in Phrygia” focuses the results of his inquiries Dispersion, The Divers, Diverse THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 858 (op. cit., 667 ff; cf 649 ff). He has also made it extremely probable that long before St. Paul’s day there was a strong body of Jews in Tarsus of Cilicia, and he holds that a Jewish colony was settled there as early as 171 BC. ‘The Seleucid kings,”’ he says, like the Ptolemies, “used the Jews as an element of the colonies which they founded to strengthen their hold on Phrygia and other countries.” But it is difficult to trace out the profound influence they exerted in the development of their country from the fact that they adopted to such an extent Gr and Rom names and manners, and were thus almost indistinguishable. At Laodicea and Hierapolis there have been found many evidences of their presence: for example, at the latter place an in- scription on a gravestone tells how the deceased Publius Aeclins Glycon mortified a sum of money to provide for the decoration of his tomb every year at the Feast of Unleavened Bread. The Dispersion among the Greeks proper had attained to considerable dimensions in the time of Christ. Philo, as noticed above, men- 19. Among tions Thessaly, Boeotia, Macedonia, Greeks Aetolia, Attica, Argos, Corinth and the Proper fairest and most fertile parts of the Peloponnesus as having Jewish in- habitants. Inscriptions recovered from Delphi and elsewhere relating to the manumission of slaves in the 2d cent. BC contain the names of Jews (Deiss- mann, Light from the Ancient East, 325f). In Sparta and Sicyon, Jews lived in the days of the Maccabees (1 Macc 16 23). At Philippi we know from Acts 16 16 there was a proseuché, or place of of prayer, and at Thessalonica, Berea, Athens, Cor- inth there were synagogues in St. Paul’s time. On the islands of the Greek archipelago and the Mediter- ranean there were Jews. Cyprus, the home of Bar- nabas, had a large Jewish population; and Euboea and Crete are named by Philo as Jewish centers. Rhodes has the distinction of having produced two opponents of Judaism in the first half of the 1st cent. BC. Clearchus of Soli, a disciple of Aristotle, introduces in one of his dialogues a Jew from Coele- Syria, Hellenic not in speech only but in mind, rep- resenting him as having come in his travels to Asia Minor and there conversed with Aristotle. Such an experience may have been rare so early; the incident may not be fact, but fiction; yet such as it is it tells a tale of the spread of Judaism. The relations of Rome with the Jewish people lend special interest to the Dispersion there. Jews do not appear to have been settled in 20. The Rome before the Maccabean period. Roman There is a certain pathos in the appeal Dispersion made to the Rom state by Judas Mac- cabaeus, amid the difficulties that were gathering round his position, for ‘‘a league of amity and confederacy” with the Rom people (1 Macc 8 17-82). His brother and successor, Jonathan, fol- lowed this up later (12 1-4.16). And in 140 BC Simon sent a delegation which concluded a treaty, offensive and defensive, with Rome, which was duly intimated by the Senate to their allies in various countries, esp. of the East. During the stay of the mission at Rome its members seem to have made attempts at religious propagandism, and the praetor Hispalus compelled them to return to their homes for attempting to corrupt Rom morals by introduc- ing the worship of Jupiter Sabazius which is no doubt the Rom interpretation of the Lord of Hosts (Jehovah Sabaoth). But ere long in Rome, as in Alexandria, they formed a colony by themselves, occupying Trastevere, the Transtiberine portion of the city, together with an island in the Tiber. Their prosperity grew with their numbers. When Cicero in 59 BC was defending Flaccus he speaks of gold being sent out of Italy, and all the provinces, to Jerus, and there was present among his listeners a large body of Jews interested in the case. When Pompey had captured Jerus in 63 BC, 21. Jews he brought back with him to Rome and a number of Jewish captives. They Pompey were sold as slaves, but many of them received their freedom and rights to citizenship. When Julius Caesar, who was a great patron and protector of the Jews, was assassinated, they wept over him for nights on end. 22. Jews Augustus protected and encouraged and the them. Tiberius, however, adopted re- First pressive measures toward them, and Caesars 4,000 Jews were deported by him to Sardinia while others were driven out of the city. With the downfall of Sejanus, the unworthy favorite of Tiberius, this repressive policy was reversed and they were allowed to return to Rome. Claudius again devised measures against them (c 50 AD), and they were banished from the city. They had, however, so multiplied and they had attained such influence that it was 23. Influ- impossible to get rid of them alto- ence of gether. Their customs and religious Jews in the observances brought down upon them Early Ro- the scorn of Juvenal and others, while man Empire their faith and worship had attractions for the thoughtful and the superstitious. “The Jews from the time of the first Caesar,’’ says Slr Samuel Dill, ‘‘ have worked their way into every class of society. A Jewish prince had inspired Caligula with an oriental ideal of monarchy. There were adherents of Judaism in the household of the great freedmen of Claudi- us, and their growing influence and turbulence compelled that emperor to expel the race from his capital. The worldly, pleasure-loving Poppaea had, perhaps, yielded to the mysterious charms of the religion of Moses. Butit was under the Flavians, who had such close associations with Judaea, that Jewish influences made themselves most felt. And in the reign of Domitian, two memhers of the imperial house, along with many others, suffered for following the Jewish mode of life" (Roman Society from Neroto Marcus Aurelius, 84). . In recent excavatious, which have laid bare much of subterranean Rome, many Jewish tombs have been examined and have yielded much additional knowledge of the conditions of Jewish life in the capital of the Caesars. Probably Jews gracing Pompey’s triumph after his Syrian campaign, 61 BC, made the first Rom catacombs similar to those on Jewish hillsides and esp. round Jerus; and in these Jewish catacombs pagans and Christians were never laid. In Italy, apart from Rom and Southern Italy, where they were widely spread, the number of Jews at the beginning of our era was not large. In Southern Gaul they were numerous and in Spain they were nu- merous and powerful. In North Africa there were Jewish communities in many centers, and Cyrene was the home of a large and flourishing Jewish 24. Jews in Italy, Gaul, Spain and North Africa population. It is not easy to form a trustworthy estimate of the Jewish Population of the world in the times of hrist. Harnack reckons up four or 25. Num- four and a half millions (Expansion of bers of the Christianity, I, 10) within the Rom Dispersion Empire: The Judaism of the Disper- sion would at least be several times more numerous than the Judaism of Pal. The question has been discussed how far the Jews of the Dispersion recruited their ranks by proselyt- : ism. That they should maintain a 26. Jewish propaganda on behalf of their ancestral Proselytism faith would only be in keeping with e the character of their religion as a religion of revelation. Although they had to live within “the hedge of the Law” to protect them against the corruptions and idolatries of the Gentiles, 859 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dispersion, The Divers, Diverse there was nevertheless at the heart of Judaism a missionary purpose, as we see from the universalism of the Pss and the Prophets. Judaism was bur- dened with a message which concerned all men, to the effect that there was one God, holy and spiritual, Creator of heaven and earth, who had committed to the family of Abraham in trust for the world His Law. To witness for the Living God, and to pro- claim His Law, was the chief element of the Jewish propaganda in the Rom empire, and their system of proselytism enabled them to gain adherents in numbers. In this the OT Scriptures and the ob- servance of the Sabbath were important factors, and enabled them to win the adherence of intelligent and educated people. That the Jews of the Dispersion had an internal organization with courts of their own, having con- siderable jurisdiction, not only in spirit- 27. Internal ual but in civil affairs, there is no Organiza- doubt. This would only be in accord- tion ance with the analogy of their consti- tution as seen in the NT, and of their commercial organization in many lands to this day. Tn all the lands of their Dispersion the Jews never lost touch with the land of their fathers, or Jerus, the city of the Great King. The bond 28. Unity of unity was maintained by the pilgrim- of the Jew- ages they made from all the countries ish People where they were scattered to their three great national feasts; by the payment of the half-shekel toward the services of the Temple as long as it stood; and by their volun- tary submission, so long as they had a national polity, to the decrees of the great Sanhedrin. That Judaism was influenced in its Dispersion by contact of the larger world of life and thought in which the Jews had their place outside 29. Disper- of Pal we can see by the example of sion Influ- Alexandria. It was there that it felt enced by most powerfully the penetrating and Greek pervasive influence of Gr thought, and Thought the large apocryphal and apocalyptic lit. which sprang up there is one of the most notable results. “The Alexandrian Jew was in reality both a Jew and a Greek; he held the faith of Jeh and sincerely worshipped the God of his fathers, but he spoke the Gr language, had received a Gr education, and had contracted many Gr ideas and habits. Still those in his position were Jews first, and Greeks afterward, and on all ‘the funda- mentals’ were in thorough sympathy with their Palestinian brethren” (Fairweather, From the Exile to the Advent, 109 f). : The Jewish people thus widely distributed over the Rom world with their monotheism, with their Scriptures, and with their Messianic 30. The hopes, did much to prepare the way Dispersion for the advent of the Redeemer who a Prepara- was to be the fulfilment of Jewish ex- tion for the pectation and hope. It was due to Advent of the strange and unique influence of Christ Judaism and to the circulation of the glowing visions of Israel’s prophets among the nations, that there was so widespread an expectation, mentioned by Tacitus, by Sue- tonius and by Jos, that from Judaea would arise a Ruler whose dominion would be over all. It is now believed that Virgil’s conception of the Better Age which was to be inaugurated by the birth of a child was derived from Isaiah’s prophecies. And not only did the Jewish Dispersion thus prepare the way for the world’s Redeemer in the fulness of the time, but when He had come and suffered and died and risen and ascended, it furnished a valuable auxil- iary to the proclamation of the gospel. Wherever the apostles and the first preachers traveled with the good news, they found Jewish communities to whom they offered first the great salvation. The synagogue services lent themselves most effect- ively to the ministry of St. Paul and 31, An his colleagues, and it was to the syna- Auxiliary _ gogue that they first repaired in every to the city they visited. Even to this day this Spread of preservation of “the dispersed of Israel” the Gospel is one of the marvels of the Divine government of the world, proving the truth of the word of God by one of the earliest prophets: “TI will sift the house of Israel among all the nations, like as grain is sifted in a sieve, yet shall not the least kernel fall upon the earth” (Am 9 9). Literature.—Schiirer,GJV4, IIT, 1 ff; Hacnack, Bxpan- sion of Christianity, I, 1-40; Fairweather, Background of the Gospel and From the Exile to the Advent; Jew Enc, att. ‘Diaspora’; Sayce and Cowley, Aram. Papyrt Discovered at Assuan; Oesterley and Box, Religion and Worship of the Synagogue. T. Nicou DISPERSION OF NATIONS. See Base; Dispersion; TaBLe or Nations. DISPOSITION, dis-pé-zish’un (Sarayal, dia- tagat): Only in Acts 7 53, “‘received the law by the disposition of angels,’’ where it bears the meaning of “administration”; RV ‘‘as it was ordained by angels.” DISPUTATION, dis-pt-ta’shun: In Acts 165 2, RV reads ‘‘questioning”’ for AV ‘‘disputation” (Gr suzétésis). In Rom 14 1, AV “doubtful disputa- tions” becomes in RV ‘“‘decision of scruples’ (Gr diakriseis dialogismén, lit. “discussions of doubts’’). The Gr in neither case implies what the word ‘‘dis- pute” has come to mean in modern Eng., but rather “to discuss’’ or “argue.” DISTAFF, dis'taf (TER, pelekh): This word oc- curs once in Prov 31 19; “spindle” is found in the same passage. In RV the meanings of the two words have been exchanged. See SpPinnina. DISTHL, dis-til’: Only found twice in the Eng. Bible (Dt 32 2; Job 36 27), in both cases in its original meaning of ‘‘to fall in drops,” as dew or rain (derived through Fr. from Lat de, ‘‘down,” stillo, “to drop’”’). It does not occur in its later tech- nical sense, for the process we call distillation was not known in ancient times. DISTINCTLY, dis-tinkt’li: Only Neh 8 8, “They read in the book, in the law of God, distinctly.” Probably the better rendering is RVm “with an interpretation,” i.e. translating into Aram. The Heb word is a part. of vb. pdrash=‘‘to make distinct.” The corresponding Aram. word occurs in Ezr 4 18 =“plainly” AV and RV, better ‘‘translated” RVm. _ DITCH, dich: The word is used indiscriminately in AV to represent at least three different ideas: a conduit or trench (2 K 3 16); a reservoir or cis- tern; or simply a pit or hole in the ground. In RV this distinction is observed more carefully. Cf Job 9 31; Ps 7 15 (“pit”), and Isa 22 11 (“reser- voir’), the former meaning a pit or any similar place of destruction or corruption; the latter a reser- voir or cistern of water. The NT usage (Mt 15 14 AV) corresponds somewhat with the former. See also 2 K 3 16 (‘‘trenches’’). DIVERS, di’vérz, DIVERSE, di-viirs’, DIVER- SITIES, di-vir’si-tiz: ‘‘Divers” meaning ‘‘vari- ous,” “different in kind,” is now obsolete and used only as a synonym of “several,’’ i.e. more than one. The distinction between “divers’’ and ‘‘di- verse’ in AV seems to be that the former is the Dives Divination THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 860 wider term, the latter being restricted to the mean- ing of ‘different in kind,” while ‘‘divers’’ is also used to express difference of number. RV retains “diverse” in all instances but changes ‘divers’ nearly everywhere, except where it has the meaning “several.” Cf Mt 247; Lk 2111; He 9 10, et al. It is hard to understand why RV retains “divers” as a tr of wotxldos, potkilos, in Mt 4 24; Mk 1 34, et al., because potkilos certainly cannot have the meaning ‘“‘several” but ‘‘different in kind,” and the idea expressed in these passages is not that some of the people had several diseases but that different people had different kinds of diseases. The same is true in He 18 9 where “divers” does not refer to number but to various kinds of teach- ing. He 2 4 and Jas 1 2 rightly change the read- ing of AV “divers” to ‘‘manifold.” In other passages RV changes “‘divers’’ to ‘‘di- verse,” and thus renders the idea of the original text “different in kind.” Cf Dt 26 13f; Prov 20 10.23. Other passages are changed the better to * render the original text: Dt 22 9, “two kinds of seed”; Jgs 5 30, “dyed”; 2 Ch 30 11, ‘certain men”; Mk 8 3 and Acts 19 9, “some.” AV reads in all these passages ‘‘divers.” RV changes AV He 1 1 ‘at sundry times and in divers manners,” an expression often found in Old Eng., to “by divers portions and in divers manners.” “Diversities” is found twice as tr of dralpeccs, diairesis, lit. ‘‘distribution’” (1 Cor 12 4ff), but RV changes AV, 1 Cor 12 28, ‘diversities’ to “divers kinds,” as tr of yvévy, géné, “kinds.” A. L. BREsLIcH DIVES, di’véz. See Lazarus. DIVIDE, di-vid’: It is difficult to decide whether 31, rdgha‘ (Job 26 12; Isa 51 15; Jer 31 35) should be rendered ‘‘to stir up” or ‘‘to still.” The Heb has both meanings. Some render ‘‘He causes the sea to tremble.” RY reads ‘‘to stir’ in text and “¢o still” in margin, while AV has ‘‘to divide’ in all three cases. 2 Ch 36 18, ‘carried them quickly” (AV “divided them speedily’’). Since pon , halak, may mean either ‘‘to distribute” or ‘‘to be smooth,” Hos 10 2 reads “their heart is divided”’ in the text, but offers “smooth” in margin (AV “divided’’). The Gr épéoropéw, orthotoméd, means “to cut straight,” hence the more lit. tr of 2 Tim 2 15, “handling aright the word of truth” (note “holding a straight course in the way of truth” or “rightly dividing the word of truth”; AV “rightly divid- ing’’). A. L. Bresuicu DIVINATION, div-i-na’shun: 1. Definition 2. Kinds of Divination 3. Fundamental Assumption in Divination 4, Legitimate and Illegitimate Divination 5. The Bible and Divination : 6. Modes of Divination Mentioned in the Bibie: Thos Approved and Those Condemned 7. Terms Used in the OT 8. Divination and Prophecy LirERATURE Divination is the act of obtaining secret knowl- edge, esp. that which relates to the future, by means within the reach almost exclusively of 1. Defini- special classes of men. tion Of this there are two main species: (1) artificial, (2) inspirational, or, as it was called in ancient times (Cicero, Lord Bacon, etc), natural divination. Artificial divination de- pends on the skill of the agent in read- 2. Kinds of ing and in interpreting certain signs Divination called omens. See Aucury. In in- spirational or natural divination the agent is professedly under the immediate influence of some spirit or god who enables the diviner to see the future, etc, and to utter oracles embodying what he sees. Among the Romans artificial divination prevailed almost exclusively, the other having vogue largely among the Greeks, a proof surely of the more spiritual trend of the Gr mind. Yet that great Roman, Cicero, in his memorable treatise on Divina- tion, says he agrees with those who take cognizance of these two distinct kinds of divination. As ex~- amples of inspirational divination he instances men dreaming or in a state of ecstasy (De Divinatione, 1.18). But though Cicero arranges diviners accord- ing to their pretentions, he does not believe in any superhuman communication. Thus he explains dreams on psychological principles much as modern psychologists would (op. cit. 11.63 ff). As a matter of fact Cicero was an atheist, or at least an agnostic. The Lat word divinatio was confined almost ex- clusively to divination by outward signs, though its etymology (deus, ‘“‘god’’) suggests that it denoted originally the other kind—that due to the inspira- tion of superhuman beings. Chrysippus (d. at Athens 207 BC), though himself a Gr philosopher, defines the word in a way which would have com- manded the approval of nearly every Rom, includ- ing Cicero himself who gives it. ‘‘Divination,” Cicero makes him say (op. cit. 11.63), is ‘‘a power in man which foresees and explains those signs which the gods throw in his way.”” The Greeks were, on the other hand, a more imaginative and emotional people, and with them inspirational divination held much the larger place. The Gr médntis (uévris) bears a close resemblance to the OT prophet, for both claimed to be inspired from without and to be superhumanly informed. The Gr term for divina- tion (hé) mantiké (=hé mantiké téchné) has refer- ence to the work of the mantis, and it hardly ever means divination of the lower sort—that by means of signs. Underlying all methods of divination there lay the belief that certain superhuman spiritual beings (gods, spirits) possess the secret 3. Funda- knowledge desired by men, and that, mental As- on certain conditions, they are willing sumption in to impart it. Divination (1) The word ‘divination’ itself, from deus, ‘‘god,”’ or divus, ‘‘pertaining to god,”’ carries with it the notion that the informa- tion obtained came from deity. Similarly the Gr mantiké implies that the message comes to the mantis from gods or spirits by way of inspiration. (2) Astrology, or astromancy, is but one form of divination and it rests upon the ultimate belief that the heavenly bodies are deities controlling the des- tinies of men and revealing the future to those who have eyes to see. According to the Weltanschau- ung or conception of the universe advocated by Hugo Winckler, Alfred Jeremias (see The OT in the Light of the East) and others, terrestrial events are but shadows of the celestial realities (cf Plato’s doc- trine of ideas), These latter represented the mind of the gods (see AsTRoLoGy secs. 1,2). (3) On hepatoscopy, or divining from the liver, see below, 6, (2), (c). : (4) It can be proved that among the ancient peoples (Babylonians, Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, etc) the view prevailed that not only oracles but also omens of all kinds are given to men by the gods and express the minds of these gods. Among the ancient Babylonians, Egyptians, Greeks and Romans the diviner stood in the service of the state and was officially consulted 4. Legiti- before wars and other great enterprises mate and were undertaken. But among these Illegitimate and other ancient peoples certain Divination classes of diviners were prohibited by : the government from exercising their calling, probably because they were supposed to be 861 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dives Divination in league with the gods of other and hostile nations. The gods of a people were in the beliefs of the time the protectors of their people and therefore the foes of the foes of their protégés. It is on this account that witchcraft has been so largely condemned and punished (see Wircucrarr). Necromancy is uni- forraly forbidden in the OT (see Lev 19 31; Dt 18 11; Isa 8 19; 19 3), probably on account of its con- nection with ancestor worship. But among other ancient peoples it was allowed and largely practised. Note that the Heb words tr? (Dt 18 11) “consulter with a familiar spirit” and “wizards” denote alike such persons as seek oracles from the spirits of the dead (see the present writer’s Magic, Divination, and Demonology among the Hebrews, 85 ff). The early Fathers believed that in the divination of heathenism we have the work of Satan who wished to discredit the true religion by producing phe- nomena among pagan races very similar to the prophetical marvels of the chosen people. This of course rests on a view of the OT prophet which makes him a ‘“‘predicter’” and little if anything more. See PRopHEcy. The attitude of the Bible toward divination is on the whole distinctly hostile and is fairly represented by Dt 18 10f, where the prophet of 5. The Yahweh is contrasted with diviners of Bible and all kinds as the only authorized medium Divination of supernatural revelation. Yet note the following: (1) Balaam (Nu 22-24) was a heathen diviner whose words of blessing and of cursing were believed to have magical force, and when his services are en- listed in the cause of Yahwism, so that, instead of cursing he blessed Israel, there is not a syllable of disapproval in the narrative. (2) In Isa 3 2 diviners are ranked with judges, warriors and prophets as pillars of the state. Thev are associated with prophets and seers in Jer 27 9; 29 8; Ezk 22 28 (ef 13 6-9; 12 24). It is true that the prophets and diviners mentioned in these passages use utter falsehoods, saying peace where there is none; all the same the men called prophets and diviners are classed together as similar func- tionaries. Pure Yahwism in its very basal principle is and must ever have been antagonistic to divination of every kind, though inspirational divination has resemblances to prophetism and even affinities with it. Why then does the Bible appear to speak with two voices, generally prohibiting but at times countenancing various forms of divination? In the actual religion of the OT we have a syncretism in which, though Yahwism forms the substructure, there are constituents from the religions of the native aborigines and the nations around. The underlying thought in all forms of divination is that by em- ploying certain means men are able to obtain knowl- edge otherwise beyond their reach. The religion of [srael made Yahweh the source of that knowledge and the prophet the medium through which it came to men. We have an analogous example of syncre- tism resulting in the union of opposite elements in ancient Zarathustraism (Zoroastrianism) which, though in its central principle inconsistent with divination by omens, yet took on from the native Turanian cults of Persia certain forms of divination, esp. that by lot (see Lenormant, La Divination, 22 ff). Nor should it be forgotten that the Bible isa library and not a book, and where so many writers, living at widely separated times, have been at work it is natural to look for diversity of teaching, though no one can deny that in fundamental matters Bible authors are wonderfully consistent. For modes of divination in vogue among the an- cient Babylonians, Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, ete, see the relevant works and dictionary articles. The species of divination spoken of in the Bible may be arranged under two heads: (1) those ap- parently sanctioned, and (2) those 6. Modes condemned in the Bible. of Divina- (1) Methods of divination tacitly or tion Men- expressly sanctioned in the Bible.—(a) tioned in The following are instances of inspira- the Bible _—_ tional divination: (a) The case of Balaam has already been cited. He was a Moabite and therefore a heathen soothsayer. His word of blessing or of curse is so potent that whether he blesses or curses his word secures its own realization. So far is his vocation from being censured that it is actually called into the service of Yahweh (see Nu 22-24). (8) To dreams the Bible assigns an important place as a legitimate means of revealing the future. Such dreams are of two kinds: (i) Involuntary or such as come unsought. Even these are regarded as sent for guidance in human affairs. The bulk of the dreams spoken of in the Bible belong to this class: see Gen 20 3.6 (Abimelech); 28 2f; 3110-14 (Jacob); 37 5-9 (Joseph; see Astronomy, II, 6); 40 5~21 (Pha- raoh’s butler and baker); 41 1-35 (Pharaoh); Jgs 7 9-14 (Gideon and an unnamed man); Dn! 1 17 (Daniel had understanding of dreams); Dn] 2 1- 49 (Nebuchadnezzar’s dream and its interpretation by Daniel); Mt 120; 2 13f.19f (Joseph, hus- band of Mary the virgin); 27 19; see also Jer 23 25 ff, where the lawfulness of prophetic dreams is assumed (cf ver 82, where “lying dreams’ imply genuine ones). In the document usually ascribed by modern critics to the Elohist (E), dreams bulk largely as the above examples serve to show. Among the Babylonians belief in the significance of dreams gave rise to a science (oneiromancy) so elaborate that only special interpreters called seers (sing. baru) were considered able to explain them (see Lenormant, op. cit., 143, for examples). (ii) The other species of dreams consists of such as are induced by what is called “incubation,” i.e. by sleeping in a sacred place where the god of the place is believed to reveal his secrets to the sleeper. Herodotus (iv.172) says that the Nasa- monians, an Egyp tribe, used to practise divination by sleeping in the graves of their ancestors. The dreams which then came to them were understood to be revelations of their deified ancestors. See Herod. 1.181 for another instance of incubation in Nineveh. We have a reference to this custom in Isa 65 4 (‘that sit among the graves’), where Yahweh enters into judgment with the Jews for their sin in yielding to this superstition. Solomon’s dream (1 K 3 5-15) came to him at the high place of Gibeon. See also Dream, Dreamer. (6) But the Bible appears in some places to give its approval to some kinds of artificial or (as it may be called) ominal divination. (a) Sortilege or divination by lot. The use of the lot as a means of ascertaining the will of Deity is referred to at least without expressed censure, and, as the present writer thinks, with tacit approval, in many parts of the Bible. It was by lot that Aaron decided which of the two goats was to be for Yahweh and which for Azazel (Lev 16 7-10). It was by lot that the land of Canaan was divided after the conquest (Nu 26 56 ff; Josh 18, 19). For other Bib. instances see Josh 7 14 (Achan found out by lot); 1 Ch 6 54ff; 24 5ff; 26 8f; 26 13f; Est 3 7 (“They cast Pur, that is, the lot’; see Century Bible in loc.); Neh 10 34; 11 1; Jon 1 7 (“The lot fell upon Jonah”); Mt 27 35; Acts 1 26. In the Urnim anp THummim (q.v.), as ex- plained by modern scholars, the same principle is applied, for these two words, though etymologically still obscure, stand for two objects (pebbles’), one Divination Divorce in O 7 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 862 denoting yes or its equivalent, and the other no. Whichever the high priest took from his ephod was believed to be the answer to the question asked. In all cases it is taken for granted that the lot cast was an expression and indication of the Divine will. See Aucury, IV, 3. (8) Hydromancy, or divination by water. In Gen 44 5 Joseph is represented as practising this kind of divination and not a word of disapproval is expressed. See Aucury, IV, 2. (vy) We read in the OT of other signs or omens which are implicitly approved of, thus Jgs 6 36- 40 (Gideon’s fleece); 1S 14 8-13 (Jonathan de- cides whether or not he is to attack the Philis by the words which he may happen to hear them speak). (2) Modes of divination condemned.—tThe follow- ing methods of divination are explicitly or implicitly condemned in the OT: (a) Astromancy (=Astrology). See AsTRoLoey. (6) Rhabdomancy, or the use of the divining rod, referred to apparently in Hos 4 12 (which may be paraphrased: “My people ask counsel of a bit of wood, and the rod made thereof answers their ques- tions”); Ezk 8 17 (“They put a rod [EV ‘“‘the branch”’} to their nose’). : (c) By an examination of the liver of animals; see Ezk 21 21. This mode of divining, hepatos- copy, as it is has been called, was very widespread among the Babylonians, Greeks, Romans, etc, of the ancient world, and it is still in vogue in Borneo, Burmah and Uganda. We have no evidence that it was practised among the Israelites, for in the above passage it is the king of Babylon (Nebuchad- nezzar) who is said to have “looked in the liver.” Opinions differ as to how the state of the liver could act as an omen. Jastrow says the liver was considered to he the seat of life, and that where the liver of the ani- mal sacrificed (generally a sheep) was accepted, it took on the character of the deity to whom it was offered. The soul of the animal as seen in the liver hecame then a reflector of the soul of the god (see HB, XX On the other hand, Alfred Jeremias says that in the view of the ancient Babylonians the lines and forms of the sheep's liver were regarded as reflecting the universe and its history (The OT in the Light of the Ancient East, I, 61). Neither of these explanations is made probahle hy its advocates. (d) By teraphim (cf TerapHim); see 1 8 16 23; Ezk 21 21; Zec 10 2. (e) Necromancy, or consulting the dead; see Lev 19 31; 206; Dt 1811; Isa 819; 193; see above. (f) Divination through the sacrifice of children by burning (see Dt 18 10). The context makes it almost certain that the words tr? “that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire’ (EV; but read and render “that burns his son or his daughter in the fire”) refer to a mode of obtaining an oracle (cf 2 K 3 27). The Phoenicians and Carthaginians sacrificed their children to Kronos in times of grave national danger or calamity (Por- Le Apud Euseb. Praep. Hv. iv.64,4; Diod. Sic. xx.14). These are examined in detail in T. Witton Davies’ Magic, Divination, and Demonology among the He- brews and Their Neighbors. See also 7. Terms the art. “Divination” in EB by the Used in same writer. The following brief notes the OTin must suffice here. Connection (1) DOP, kesem, generally rendered with “divination,” is a general term for div- Divination ination of all kinds. In Ezk 21 21 [26] it stands for divination by arrows while in 1 S 28 8 it is used of divination through the medium of an ’6bh (“familiar spirit”). On the derivation of the word see #'B, art. “Magic,” § 3. (2) 7, m*onen, ‘probably from a Sem root (ef Arab. ‘anna) which denotes to emit a hoarse nasal sound such as was customary in reciting the , 102 f). | prescribed formula (see CHARM). For ‘oak of the monim’ see AUGUR’s Oak. Some say the word means one who divines from the clouds, deriving from 7}?7, ‘anan, ‘‘a cloud,” though nothing in the context suggests this sense, and the same remark applies to the meaning ‘‘one who smites with the evil eye,’ making the term a denominative from ‘ayin, “eye.” The usual rendering in AV is pl. “observers of times’ and in RV “them that prac- tise augury” (Dt 18 10.14). ; (3) The vb. WM2, nihésh, of which WMD, lihesh, is but a variant, is probably a denominative from WM}, nahdsh, ‘a serpent” (J and n interchange in Heb), denoting “‘to hiss,” “to whisper” (like a ser- pent), then “to utter divinatory formulae.” As it is used for so many kinds of divination, W. R. Smith concludes that it came to be a general term for divine. The part. of this vb. is tr? ‘“enchanter”’ in Dt 18 10, the cognate vb., ‘‘to use enchantments” in Lev 19 26; 2 K 21 6; 2 Ch 33 6, and the corresponding noun “enchantment” in Nu 23 23; 24 1. (4) PW, gazertn, lit. “cutters,” i.e. such as kill (in Arab. the cognate vb.=‘“‘to slaughter’) for the purpose of examining the liver or entrails as omens. Perhaps the etymology implies “‘sacrifice,”’ animals being sacrificed as an appeal to deity. The word occurs only in Dnl (2 27; 4 7 [4]; 5 7.11), and is tr? “soothsayers.”” Some think they were ‘“‘astrolo- gers,’ the etymology in that case referring to the dividing of the heavens with a view, by casting the horoscope, to forecasting the future. (5) TON , ‘ashshaph (AV “astrologer,’”’ RV “en- chanter’’), occurs only in Dnl in the Heb (1 20; 2 2) and in the Aram. (2 10; 4 4 [7], etc) parts of | the book. The term is probably taken from the Bab and denotes a magician and esp. an exorcist rather than a diviner. (6) S°NTWD, kasda’im, the same word as the Gr Chaldatoi (Ka\daio.) (EV Chaldeans”), denotes in Dnl (1 4, etc) where alone it occurs, not the people so designated but a class of astrologers. This usage (common in classical writers) arose after the fall of the Bab empire, when the only Chaldaeans known were astrologers and soothsayers. See further, Maerc. For “spirit of divination” (Acts 16 16) see PYTHON; PHILIPPI. Inspirational divination and OT prophecy have much in common. Both imply the following con- ditions: (1) the primitive instinct that 8. Divina- craves for secret knowledge, esp. that tion and relating to the future; (2) the belief Prophecy that such knowledge is possessed by certain spiritual beings who are willing on certain terms toimpartit; (3) such secret knowl- edge is imparted generally to special classes of men (rarely women) called diviners or (Bab) seers and prophets. Many anthropologists (Tylor, Frazer, etc) and OT scholars (Wellhausen, W. Robertson Smith, etc) consider prophecy to be but an outgrowth and higher form of divination. The older theologians almost to a man, and a goodly number of moderns, take precisely the opposite view, that divination is a corruption of prophecy. Probably neither view is strictly true. Sometimes in human life we find evidences of progress from lower to higher. Some- times the process is the very reverse. It is impor- tant to take notice of the differences as well as the resemblances between the diviner and the prophet. (1) The OT prophet believes in a personal God whose spokesman he considers himself to be. When he spoke or wrote it was because he was, at least professedly, inspired and informed by Yahweh. “Thus says Yahweh,” was the usual formula with 863 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA _ Divination Divorce in OT which he introduced his oracles. The Gr and Rom mantis, on the other hand, worked himself up to the necessary ecstatic state by music, drugs (intoxi- cants, etc), sacrificial smoke and the like. Some- times it has been thought a sufficient means of divination to swallow the vital portions of birds and beasts of omen. It was believed that by eat- ing the hearts of crows, or moles, or of hawks, men took into their bodies the presaging soul of the creature (Frazer, Golden Bough?, Il, 355). (2) The mantis practised his art as a remuner- ative occupation, charging high fees and refusing in most cases to ply his calling without adequate remuneration. The local oracle shrines (Delphi Clavis, etc) were worked for personal and politica’ ends. The OT prophet, on the other hand, claimed to speak as he was bidden by his God. It was with him a matter of conviction as to what lives men ought to live, what state of heart they should cul- tivate. So far from furthering his own material interests, as he could by saying what kings and other dignitaries wished to hear, he boldly de- nounced the sins of the time, even when, as often, he had to condemn the conduct of kings and the policy of governments. Look, for example, at Isaiah’s fearless condemnation of the conduct of Ahaz in summoning the aid of Assyria (Isa 7 ff), and at the scathing words with which Jeremiah censured the doings of the nation’s leaders in his day (Jer 2 36, etc), though both these noble proph- ets suffered severely for their courage, esp. Jere- miah, who stands out as perhaps the finest recorded example of what, in the face of formidable opposi- tion, the religious teacher ought ever to be. Of Micaiah ben Imlah, King Ahab of Israel said, ‘‘I hate him; for he doth not prophesy good concern- ing me, but evil.” What reward did this prophet have for his fidelity to his conscience and his God? Imprisonment (1 K 22 1-35). Had he pleased the king by predicting a happy, prosperous future that was never to be, he would have been clothed in gor- geous robes and lodged in a very palace. Lirsratrcors.—lIn addition to the references above and the full bibliography prefixed to the present writer's book named above (Magic, etc), note the following: Bouché- Leclercq, Histoire de la divination dans l'antiquité; BE. B. Tylor, Primitive Culture®, I, 78-81; 117-33; IT, 155; J. G. Frazer, Golden Bough?, I, 346; II, 355; ITI, 342, et passim, and the arts. in the principal Bible dictionaries. T. Wirton Davies DIVINE, di-vin’, DIVINER, di-vin’ér. See Avucury; AstroLocy; Divination. DIVINE NAMES. See Gon, NamEs oF. DIVINE VISITATION. See PunisHMENTs. DIVISION, di-vizh’un: Used in EV in the follow- ing senses: : (1) A separate body of people (a) of the tribal divisions of Israel (Josh 11 23; 12 7; 18 10); (6) of sections of a tribe, ‘‘the divisions of Reuben” (Jgs 6 15.16 AV; but RVrightly substitutes “the water- courses of Reuben”; in Job 20 17 the same word is rendered ‘‘rivers’”’); (c) of the (late) organization of priests and Levites into classes or families who ministered in the temple in rotation; tr? ‘‘courses’’ generally in AV, and always in RV (1 Ch 24 1; 26 1.12.19; Neh 11 36; cf 2 Ch 85 5). Much prominence is given by the Chronicler to the 24 classes of priests, singers, and doorkeepers, who served in turns in the temple (cf Lk 1 5.8). (2) Separation, distinction: ‘‘I will put a division {[RVm “sien of deliverance''] between my people and thy people’’ (Ex 8 23). The Heb word here is pedhith=“ransom, “pedemption"' (ce Ps 111 9), but the reading is doubtful. AV and RV follow LXX, Syr and Vulg, which render “‘set a distinction,"’ perhaps on the basis of a different reading from that of our Heb text. (3) Inthe NT, dissension, dlsunion, schism (Lk 12 51; Rom 16 17; 1 Cor § 3 AV, omittedin RV; 1 Cor 1 10; 11 18; Gal 5 20). D. Miatu Epwarps DIVORCE, di-virs’, IN OT: Woman, among the Hebrews, as among most nations of antiquity, oc- cupied a subordinate position. Though 1. Subor- the Heb wife and mother was treated dinate Posi- with more consideration than her sister tion of in other lands, even in other Sem Woman countries, her position nevertheless was one of inferiority and subjection. The marriage relation from the standpoint of Heb legislation was looked upon very largely as a business affair, a mere question of property. A wife, never- theless, was, indeed, in most homes in Israel, the husband’s “most valued possession.” And yet while this is true, the husband was unconditionally and unreservedly the head of the family in all do- mestic relations. His rights and prerogatives were manifest on every side. Nowhere is this more evi- dent than in the matter of divorce. According to the laws of Moses a husband, under certain circum- stances, might divorce his wife; on the other hand, if at all possible, it was certainly very difficult for a wife to put away her husband. nfortunately a double standard of morality in matters pertaining e a sexes is, at least, as old as Moses (see Ex 21 —11). The OT law concerning divorce, apparently quite clear, is recorded most fully in Dt 24 1ff. perusal of the commentaries will, 2. Law of nevertheless, convince anyone that Divorce: there are difficulties of interpretation. Dt 24:1-4 The careful reader will notice that the renderings of the AV and RV differ materially. AV reads in the second part of ver 1: “then let him write a bill,” etc, RV has “‘that he shall write,’ etc, while the Heb original has neither “then” nor ‘‘that,’’ but the simple conjunction “and.” There is certainly no command in the words of Moses, but, on the other hand, a clear purpose to render the proceeding more difficult in the case of the husband. Moses’ aim was “‘to regulate and thus to mitigate an evil which he could not extir- pate.’ The evident purpose was, as far as possible, to favor the wife, and to protect her against an un- ceremonious expulsion from her home and children. As already suggested, marriage among the He- brews, as among most Orientals, was more a legal contract than the result of love or 8. Marriage affection. It would be, however, a a Legal great mistake to assume that deep love Contract was not often present, for at all times the domestic relations of the Heb married couple have compared most favorably with those of any other people, ancient or modern. In its last analysis it was, nevertheless, a business transaction. The husband or his family had, as a rule, to pay a certain dowry to the parents or guard- ians of the betrothed before the marriage was con- summated. A wife thus acquired could easily be regardcd as a piece of property, which, without great difficulty, could be disposed of in case the husband, for any reason, were disposed to rid himself of an uncongenial companion and willing to forfeit the mohar which he had paid for his wife. The advan- tage was always with the husband, and yet a wife was not utterly helpless, for she, too, though prac- tically without legal rights, could make herself so intolerably burdensome and hateful in the home that almost any husband would gladly avail him- self of his prerogatives and write her a bill of divorcement. Thus, though a wife could not di- vorce her husband, she could force him to divorce r. The following words of Professor Israel Abrahams, Cambridge, England, before ‘the Divorce Com- Divorce in OT Divorce in NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 864 mission” (London, November’ 21, 1910), are to the point: “In all such cases where the wife was concerned as the moving party she 4. Divorce could only demand that her husband Applicable should divorce her. The divorce was Only to always from first to last, in Jewish Wives law, the husband’s act.” Thecommon : , , term used in the Bible for divorce is TWN TWADW , shillath ’ishshah, “the sending away of a wife” (Dt 22 19.29). We never read of ‘“‘the send- ing away of a husband.” The fem. part., MW7A, grushah, “the woman thrust out,” is the term ap- plied to a divorced woman. The masc. form is not found. The Mosaic law apparently, on the side of the husband, made it as difficult as possible for him to secure a divorce. No man could un- 5. Process ceremoniously and capriciously dismiss and Ex- his wife without the semblance of a ceptions trial. In case one became dissatisfied with his wife, (1) he had to write her a Brut or Divorce (q.v.) drawn up by some con- stituted legal authority and in due legal form. In the very nature of the case, such a tribunal would use moral suasion to induce an adjustment; and, failing in this, would see to it that the law in the case, whatever it might be, would be upheld. (2) Such a bill or decree must be placed in the hand of the divorced wife. (3) She must be forced to leave the premises of her former husband. Divorce was denied two classes of husbands: (1) The man who had falsely accused his wife of antenuptial infidelity (Dt 22 13 ff), and (2) a person who had seduced a virgin (Dt 22 28f). Inaddition, a heavy penalty had to be paid to the father of such damsels. It is probable that a divorced wife who had not contracted a second marriage or had been guilty of adultery might be reunited to her husband. But in case she had married the second time she was forever barred from returning to her first husband, even if the second husband had divorced her or had died (Dt 24 3f). Such a law would serve as an obstacle to hasty divorces. Divorces from the earliest times were common among the Hebrews. All rabbis agree that a sepa- ration, though not desirable, was quite lawful. The only source of dispute among them was as to what constituted a valid reason or just cause. The language in Dt 24 1 ff has always been in dispute. The Heb words, 127 MI, ‘erwath da- bhar, on which a correct interpretation 6. Grounds depends, are not easy of solution, of Divoree though many exegetes, influenced (Doubtful possibly by some preconceived notion, Meaning of pass over them quite flippantly. The Dt 24:1) phrase troubled the Jewish rabbis of olden times, as it does Jewish and Christian commentators and translators in our day. AV renders the two words, “‘some uncleanness,” and in the margin, ‘matter of nakedness.” The latter, though a literal tr of the Heb, is quite unin- telligible. RV and ARV both have: “some un- seemly thing.’ Professor Driver translates the same words “some indecency.” The Ger. RV (Kautzsch) has ‘etwas Widerwdrtiges” (“something repulsive”). We know of no modern version which makes ‘erwath dabhar the equivalent of fornication or adultery. And, indeed, in the very nature of the case, we are forced to make the words apply to a minor fault or crime, for, by the Mosaic law, the penalty for adultery was death (Dt 22 20 ff). Itis, however, a question whether the extreme penalty was ever enforced. It is well known that at, and some time before, the time of our Saviour, there were two schools among the Jewish rabbis, that of Sham- mai and that of Hillel. Shammaiand his followers maintained that ‘erwath dabhar signified nothing less than unchastity or adultery, and argued that only this crime justified a man in divorcing his wife. Hillel and his disciples went to the other extreme. They placed great stress upon the words, “if she find no favor in his eyes” immediately preceding ‘erwath dabhar (Dt 24 1), and contended that di- vorce should be granted for the flimsiest reason: such as the spoiling of a dish either by burning or careless seasoning. Some of the rabbis boldly taught that aman had a perfect right to dismiss his wife, if he found another woman whom he lked better, or who was more beautiful (Mish, Gitfin, 14 10). Here are some other specifications taken from the same hook: ‘The following women may be divorced: She who violates the Law of Moses, e.g. causes her husband to eat food which has not been tithed..... She who vows, but does not keep her vows. .... She who goes out on the street with her hair loose, or spins in the street, or converses [flirts] with any man, or isa noisy woman. What is a noisy woman? It is one who speaks in her own house so loud that the neighbors may hear her.” It would be easy to extend the list, for the Mish and rabbinic writings are full of such laws. From what has been said, it is clear that adultery was not the only valid reason for divorce. Besides, the word adultery had a peculiar significance in Jewish law, which recognized polygamy and con- cubinage as legitimate. Thus a Hebrew might have two or more wives or concubines, and might have intercourse with a slave or bondwoman, even if married, without being guilty of the crime of adul- tery (Lev 19 20), for adultery, according to Jewish law, was possible only when a man dishonored the ‘free wife” of a Hehrew (20 10 ff). Divorcement, Bill of: This expression, found in Dt 24 1.3; Isa 50 1; Jer 3 8is the tr of the Heb nn) ADO. sépher kerithuth. The two words, lit. rendered, signify a document or hook of cutting off, ie. a certificate of divorce given by a husband to a wife, so as to afford her the opportunity or privilege of marrying another man. The Heb term is rendered hy the L. BiBAtop amo- gragiov, biblion apostasion. This is also found in the NT (Mk 10 4). t § 31 has ‘‘writing of divorce- ment” in EV, but Mt 19 7 AV has “writing,” while RV and ARV have “bill.” The certificate of divorce is called GA, get, pl. "a, oittin, in the Talm. Thereis an entire chapter devoted to the subjects in the Mish. It is not positively known when the custom of writing bills of divorcement commenced, but there are references to such documents in the earliest Heb legislation. The fact that Joseph had in mind the putting away of his espoused wife, Mary, without the formality of a bill or at least of a public procedure proves that a decree was not regarded as absolutely necessary (Mt 119). The following was the usual form of a decree: __ ‘On the day of the week in the month —— in the year—— from the heginning of the world, accord- ing to the common computation in the province of —— I the son of hy whatever name I may be known, of the town of with entire consent of mind, and with- out any constraint, have divorced, dismissed and ex- pelled thee daughter of by whatever name thou art called, of the town who hast been my wife hitherto; But now I have dismissed thee the daugh- ter of by whatever name thou art called, of the town of ——so as to be free at thy own disposal, to marry whomsoever thou pleasest, without hindrance from any- one, from this day for ever. Thou art thereforo free for anyone [who would marry thee}. Let this be thy bill of divorce from me, a writing of separation and ex- pulsion, according to the law of Moses and Israel. , the son of , witness ——,, the son of ——,, witness Spiritual application —The Heb prophets regard- ed Jeh not only as the father and king of the chosen people, and thus entitled to perfect obedience and loyalty on their part, but they conceived of Him as a husband married to Israel: Isaiah, speaking to his nation, says: ‘‘For thy Maker is thy husband; Jehovah of hosts is his name” (64 5). Jeremiah too makes use of similar language in the following: ‘Return, O backsliding children, saith Jehovah; for J am a husband unto you” (8 14). It is per- 865 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Divorce in OT Divorce in NT fectly natural that NT writers should have regarded Christ’s relation to His church under the same figure. Paulin 2 Cor says: ‘I am jealous over you with a godly jealousy: for I espoused you to one husband, that I might present you asa pure virgin to Christ” (11 2); see also Mt 9 15; Jn 3 29; Rev 19 7. Any unfaithfulness or sin on the part of Israel was regarded as spiritual adultery, which necessarily broke off the spiritual ties, and divorced the nation from God (Isa 1 21; Ezk 16 22; Rev 2 22). See also Marriace. Litsraturs.—Amram, Jewish Law of Divorce accord- tng to the Bible and Talmud, London, 1897; Abrahams, Jewish Life in the Middle Ages, London, 1896; Mackie, Bible Manners and Customs, London, 1898, The Mishna, Tra into Eng., De Sola and Raphall, London, 1843; Ben- zinger, Hebrdische Archdologie, Freiburg, 1894; Nowack, Lehrbuch der hebrdischen Archdologie, 1894. W. W. Daviss DIVORCE IN NT (76 drorrécvov, 6 apostdsiou): The Scripture doctrine of divorce is very simple. It is contained in Mt 19 3-12. ; We are not called upon to treat of divorce in the Mosaic legislation (Dt 24 1-4). That was passed upon by Jesus-in the above discussion and by Him ruled out of existence in His system of religion. After Jesus had spoken as above, the Mosaic per- mission of divorce became a dead letter. There could not be practice under it among His disciples. So such OT divorce is now a mere matter of anti- quarian curiosity. : : It may be of interest in passing to note that the drift of the Mosaic legislation was restrictive of a freedom of divorce that, had been practised before its enactment. It put in legal proceedings to bar the personal will of one of the parties. It recog- nized marriage as a social institution which should not be disrupted without reference to the rights of society init. In this restrictive character “the law is become our tutor to bring us unto Christ” (Gal 3 24). But here, as in numerous other instances, Christ went behind the enactments to primitive original principles whose recognition would make the law of none effect, because no practice was to be permitted under it. Thus the OT is disposed of. Of course what Jesus said will dominate the New. In fact, Jesus is the only author in the NT who has treated of divorce. It has been thought that Paul had the subject in hand. But we shall find on ex- amination, farther along, that he did not. We need then look nowhere but to this 19th ch of Mt for the Scripture doctrine of divorce. True, we have other reports of what Jesus sald (Mk 10 2-12; Lk 16 18). Butin Mt 19 we have the fullest report, containing everything that is reported elsewhere and one or two important observations that the other writers have not included. Lk has but one ver where Mt has ten. Lk’s ver is in no necessary connection with context. It seems to be a mere memorandum among others of the spiritual or ethical teachings of Christ. Luke however caught the gist of the whole teaching about divorce in recording the prohibition to put away one wife and marry another. The records in Mt 19 and Mk 10 cover one and the same occasion. But there is nothing in Mk that is not in Mt; and the latter contains nearly a third more of text than the former. There Is nothing, however, essential in Mt that is not in Mk, save the clause “exeept for fornication."’ That exception will be treated farther along. We seem to be justified then in saying that the total doctrine of the Scripture pertaining to divorce is contained in Mt 19. Attention must be called to the fact that, in the Sermon on the Mount (Mt 5 27-32), Jesus treated of divorce, and that in every essential particular it agrees with the elaboration in ch 19. Jesus there as plainly as in the argument with the Pharisees put Moses’ permission of divorce under ban; as plainly there declared the putting away of one partner to marry another person to be adul- tery. This may also be noticed, that the exception to the absolute prohibition is in the text of the Sermon on the Mount. We have then a summary of the NT doctrine of divorce stated by Christ Himself as follows: ‘Who- soever shall put away his wife, except for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery” (Mt 19 9). This puts Him in line with the ideal of the monogamic, indissoluble family which pervades the whole of the OT. It may be well here to treat of the exception which Christ made in His rule to the indissolubility of marriage. It is very widely main- 1. The tained in the Christian church that Family there should be no divorce for any cause whatever. This position is in plain contradiction to Christ’s teaching in Mt 5 and 19. One of the grounds adduced for this denial of divorce in case a partner is guilty of adultery is that Lk and Mk do not record the exception. It is a difficult matter to invade the psychology of writers who lived nearly two thousand years ago and tell why they did not include something in their text which someone else did in his. Neither Luke nor Mark were personal disciples of the Lord. They wrote at second hand. Matthew was a personal disciple of Christ and has twice recorded the excep- tion. It will be a new position in regard to judg- ment on human evidence when we put the silence of absentees in rank above the twice expressed report of one in all probability present—one known to be a close personal attendant. This may be said: Matthew’s record stands in ancient MS authority, Greek and also the Versions. And on this point let it be noted that the testimony of the MSS was up before the English and American Revisers, and they have deliberately reaffirmed the text of 1611 and given us the exception in Christ’s rule in each place (Mt 6 32; 19 9). This makes the matter as nearly rés adjudicata as can be done by human wisdom. Let us consider the rationality of the exception. That feature has had scant attention from theolo- gians and publicists, yet it will bear the closest scrutiny. In fact it is a key to much that is ex- planatory of the basic principle of the family. To begin with, the exception is not on its face an after- thought of some transcriber, but was called out by the very terms of the question of the Pharisees: ‘Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause?” This plainly called for a specification from Jesus of exceptions which he would allow to the rule against divorce. It is fortunate that the Phari- sees asked the question in the form they did, for that put on Jesus the necessity of enumerating such exceptions as he would allow. He mentioned one, and but one in reply. That puts the matter of ex- ceptions under the rule in logic: Expressio unius exclusio altertus. All other pretences for divorce were deliberately swept aside by Christ—a fact that should be remembered when other causes are sought to be foisted in alongside this one allowed by Christ. The question may come up, Whose insight is likely to be truest? Why, then, will reason stand by this exception? Because adultery is per se destructive of monogamic family life. Whoever, married, is guilty of adultery has taken another person into family relation. Children may be born to that relation—are born to it. Not to allow divorce in such case is to force an innocent party in marriage to live in a polygamous state. There is the issue stated so plainly that “the wayfaring man need not err therein,” and ‘he who runs may read,” and ‘“‘he who reads may run.” It is the hand of an unerring Master that has made fornication a ground for divorce from the bond of matrimony and limited divorce to that single cause. Whichever way we depart from strict practice under the Savicur’s direction we land in polygamy. The society that allows by its statutes divorce for any other cause than the one that breaks the monogamic bond, is simply acting in aid of polygamy, consecu- tive if not contemporaneous. Advocates of the freedom of divorce speak of the Divorcein NT THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 4 866 above view as ‘‘the ecclesiastical.” That is an attempt to use the argument ad invidiam. The church of Christ held and holds its views, not be- cause ecclesiastics taught it, but because Christ taught it, and that in His teaching we have a state- ment out from the righteousness, wisdom, insight and rationality of the all-wise God. Paul is the only other NT author besides Christ who has been supposed to treat of divorce. But a careful examination of Paul’s writing 2. Paul will disclose the fact that he has no- where discussed the question—for what cause or causes a man might put away his wife, or a woman her husband, with liberty of mar- riage to another person. If Paul has treated of divorce at allit isin 1 Cor 7. But even a careless reading of that chapter will disclose the fact that. Paul is not discussing the question for what causes marriage might be disrupted, but the question of manners and morals in the relation. Paul has not modified Christ in any respect. It has been sup- posed that in ver 15 Paul has allowed divorce to a believing partner who has been deserted by one unbelieving, and so he has been sometimes under- stood as adding desertion to the exception Christ made as cause for divorce. But Paul has not said in that verse or anywhere else that a Christian partner deserted by a heathen may be married to someone else. All he said is: “If the unbelieving departeth, let him depart: the brother or the sister is not under bondage [dedotilotat] in such cases: but God hath called us in peace.” To say that a deserted partner ‘‘hath not been enslaved” is not to say that he or she may be re- married. What is meant is easily inferred from the spirit that dominates the whole chapter, and that is that everyone shall accept the situation in which God has called him just as he is. ‘Be quiet” is a direction that hovers over every situation. If you are married, so remain. If unmarried, so remain. If an unbelieving partner deserts, let him or her desert. So remain. ‘‘God hath called us in peace.”’ Nothing can be more beautiful in the morals of the marriage relation than the direction given by Paul in this chapter for the conduct of all parties in marriage in all trials. Many reasons might be given why Paul could not have given liberty of remarriage, besides the one that he did not in his text; but attention should be called to the fact that such an assumption of authority in divorce would soon have brought him into conflict with the Rom government. Paul’s claim that he was a Rom citizen was of some value to himself. Would not some Rom citizen have claimed to scrutinize pretty closely Paul’s right to issue a decree of divorce against him because he had “departed” from a wife who had become a Chris- tian? There would be two sides to such divorces. Would not Paul, careful, shrewd, politic as he was, have known that, and have avoided an open rup- ture with a government that did not tolerate much interference with its laws? That neither Paul nor anyone else ever put such construction upon his | language, is evidenced by the fact that there is no record in history of a single case where it was at- tempted for 400 years after Paul was in his grave, and the Rom Empire had for a century been Chris- tian. Then we wait 400 years more before we find the suggestion repeated. That no use was ever made of such construction of Paul in the whole era of the adjustment of Christianity with heathenism is good evidence that it was never there to begin with. So we shall pass Paul as having in no respect modified the doctrine of divorce laid down by Christ in Mt 19. In all civilized countries the machinery of legisla- tion and law can always be open for removal or relief of troubles in marriage without proceeding to its annulment. If a father is cruel to his children, we do not abolish the parental 8. Reme- relation, but punish the father for his dies for cruelty. If he deserts his children, we Marriage need not assist him to rear other chil- Ils dren whom he can desert in turn, but we can punish him for his desertion. What can be done by law in case of parent and child can be done in case of husband and wife. By put- ting in absolute divorce (frequently for guilty and innocent alike) we invite the very evils we seek to cure. We make it the interest of a dissatisfied party to create a situation that a court will regard as intolerable, and so he or she may go free. Then by affording an easy way out of the troubles of married life we are inviting carelessness about entering marriage. We say by divorce statutes to a@ young woman: “If your husband deserts you, you may have another. Ifhe is cruel, you may have another. If he fails to support you, you may have another. If he is drunken, you may have another. If he is incompatible or makes you unhappy, you may have another’—and yet others beyond these. When an easy road is thus made out of marriage, will there be proper caution about entering into marriage? By just as much as a crevice for relief of the miseries of married life is opened by divorce, by so much the flood gates are opened into those miseries. The more solemnly society is impressed that the door of marriage does not swing outward as well as inward the more of happiness and blessing will it find in the institution. See Famizy. C. CavERNO DI-ZAHAB, di’za-hab, diz’a-hab (271771, @i-zd- habh; LXX Karaxptcoea, Katachrisea, lit. ‘“abound- ing in gold’): The name occurs in a hst apparently intended to fix definitely the situation of the camp of Israel in the plains of Moab (Dt 1 1). No place in the region has been found with a name suggest- ing this; and there is no other clue to its identifica- tion. Some names in the list are like those of stations earlier in the wanderings. Thinking that one of these may be intended Burckhardt suggested Mina edh-Dhahab, a boat harbor between Ras Mohammad and ‘Agaba. Cheyne gets over the difficulty by accepting a suggestion of Sayce that Di-zahab corresponds to Me-zahab (Gen 36 39); this latter he then transforms into Mitzraim, and identifies it with the North Arabian Musri (EB s.v.). The changes, however, seem greater than can be justified. Ewine DOCTOR, dok’tér: In Lk 2 46 (88doKados, diddskalos) “doctor” is equivalent to “teacher,” which latter is the tr of RV. Soin Lk 6 17; Acts 5 34, AV and RV “doctors,” “doctor,” of the law (nomediddskales). See Epucation; RABBI; SCRIBE. DOCTRINE, dok’trin: Lat doctrina, from doceo, “to teach,” denotes both the act of teaching and that which is taught; now used exclusively in the latter sense. (1) In the OT for (a) lekah “what is received,” hence “the matter taught” (Dt 32 2; Job 11 4; Prov 4 2; Isa 29 24, ARV “instruction”); (b) she- muah, “what is heard” (Isa 28 9, RV “message,” RVm ‘Teport’’); (c) musar, “discipline” (Jer 10 8 m, “The stock is a doctrine [RV “instruction” of vanities,” i.e. “The discipline of unreal gods is wood (is like themselves, destitute of true moral force)” (BDB). (2) In the NT for (i) didaskalia=(a) “the act of teaching” (1 Tim 4 13.16; 6 17; 2 Tim 3 10. 16), all in RV “teaching”; (b) “what is taught” (Mt 15 9; 2 Tim 43). In some passages the meaning is ambiguous as between (a) and (6). (ti) 867 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA ivoree in NT didaché, always tr‘ “teaching” in RV, except in Rom 16 17, where “doctrine” is retained in the text and “teaching’”’ inserted in m= (a) the act 1. Meaning of teaching (Mk 4 2; Acts 2 42, AV of Terms ‘‘doctrine’’); (6) what is taught (Jn 7 ‘ 16.17; Rev 2 14.15.24, AV “doe- trine’”’). In some places the meaning is ambiguous as between (a) and (b) and in Mt 7 28; Mk 1 22; Acts 13 12, the manner, rather than the act or matter of teaching is denoted, namely, with author- ity and power. The meaning of these words in the NT varied as the church developed the content of its experience into a system of thought, and came to 2. Christ’s regard such a system as an integral Teaching _ part of saving faith (cf the development Informal of the meaning of the term “faith”): (1) The doctrines of the Pharisees were a fairly compact and definite body of teaching, a fixed tradition handed down from one generation of teachers to another (Mt 16 12, AV “doctrine”; cf Mt 16 9; Mk 7 7). (2) In contrast with the Pharisaic system, the teaching of Jesus was uncon- ventional and occasional, discursive and unsystem- atic; it derived its power from His personality, character and works, more than from His words, so that His contemporaries were astonished at it and recognized it as a new teaching (Mt 7 28; 22 33; Mk 1 22.27; Lk 4 32). So we find itin the Synoptic Gospels, and the more systematic form given to it in the Johannine discourses is undoubtedly the work of the evangelist, who wrote rather to interpret Christ than to record His ¢psissima verba (Jn 20 31). The earliest teaching of the apostles consisted essentially of three propositions: (a) that Jesus was the Christ (Acts 3 18); (8) that He 3. Apostolic was risen from the dead (Acts 1 22; Doctrines 2 24.32); and (c) that salvation was by faith in His name (Acts 2 38; 3 16). While proclaiming these truths, it was neces- sary to coérdinate them with Heb faith, as based upon OT revelation. The method of the earliest reconstruction may be gathered from the speeches of Peter and Stephen (Acts 2 14-36; 5 29-32; 7 2-53). A more thorough reconstruction of the coordination of the Christian facts, not only with Heb history, but with universal history, and with a view of the world as a whole, was undertaken by Paul. Both types of doctrine are found in his speeches in Acts, the former type in that delivered at Antioch (13 16-41), and the latter in the speeches delivered at Lystra (14 15-17) and at Athens (17 22-31). The ideas given in outline in these speeches are more fully developed into a doctrinal system, with its center removed from the resurrection to the death of Christ, in the epistles, esp. in Gal, Rom, Eph, Phil and Col. But as yet it is the theological system of one teacher, and there is no sign of any attempt to impose it by authority on the church as a whole. As a matter of fact the Pauline system never was generally accepted by the church. Cf James and the Apostolic Fathers. In the Pastoral and General Epistles a new state of things appears. The repeated emphasis on “sound” or “healthy doctrine” (1_Tim 4, Begin- 110; 6 3; 2 Tim 1 13; 43; Tit 1 nings of 9; 2 1), “good doctrine” (1 Tim 4 6) Dogma implies that a body of teaching had _ now emerged which was generally ac- cepted, and which should serve as a standard of orthodoxy. The faith has become a body of truth “once for all delivered unto the saints” (Jude ver 3). The content of this “sound doctrine” is nowhere formally given, but it is a probable inference that it corresponded very nearly to the Rom formula that became known as the Apostles’ Creed. oe Deen . REES DOCUS, dé’kus. See Dox. DODAI, dé’di, do’da-i (1 Ch 27 4). DODANIM, do’da-nim (2°37 , dédhanim, “lead- ers’): In Gen 10 4, the son of Javan, the son of Japheth. This would place the Dodanim among the Ionians. The || passage 1 Ch 1 7, with the LXX and §, has, however, ‘““Rodanim,” which is probably the true reading. This identifies the people with the Rhodians (cf on Ezk 27 15 under Denay). DODAVAHU, dé-dav’a-hi (N79, dadhawaha, “loved of God’; AV Dodavah): Father of Eliezer of Mareshah, a prophet in the days of Jehoshaphat (2 Ch 20 37). DODO, do’dé, DODAI (71%, dadha, "TT, dodhay, “‘beloved’’): (1) The grandfather of Tola of the tribe of Is- sachar, one of the judges (Jgs 10 1). (2) “The Ahchite,”’ father of Eleazar, one of David’s heroes, and (2 S 23 9; 1 Ch 11 12) him- self the commander of one of the divisions of the army (1 Ch 27 4). (3) The Bethlehemite, father of Elhanan, one of David’s mighty men (2 § 23 24; 1 Ch 11 26). DOE, do. DOEG, do’eg (ANTT, AIN'T, dd’'égh, “anxious,” “cared for’): “The Edomite,” a servant of Saul, who watched David's intercourse with the priest Ahimelech, then denounced the priest to the king, and later executed his command to slay the priests at Nob. The position he held is described as that of “the mightiest” of S.’s herdsmen (1 § 21 7 m). LXX reads: “tending the mules.” Rabbinical legends speak of him as the greatest scholar of his time. The traditional title of Ps 52 associates the composition of that Ps with the events that led to the slaying of the priests (1 S 21 7; 22 9.18.22). Natuan Isaacs DOG (299, kelebh; [ef Arab. kelb, “dog”’]; Kooy, kdién; and dimin. kvvdpvov, kundrion): References to the dog, both in the OT and in the NT, are usually of a contemptuous character. A dog, and esp. a dead dog, is used as a figure of insignificance. Go- liath says to David (1 8 17 43): “Am Ia dog, that See Dono. See DrzrR. Pariah Dog at Beirat. thou comest to me with staves?” David says to Saul (1 § 24 14): “After whom dost thou pursue? after a dead dog, after a flea.” Mephibosheth says to David (28 9 8): “What is thy servant, that thou shouldest look upon such a dead dog as J am?” The same figure is found in the words of Hazael to Elisha (2 K 8 13). The meaning, which is ob- scure in AV, is brought out well in RV: “But what is thy servant, who is but a dog, that he should do Dogma Dor, Dora THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 868 this great thing?” The characteristically oriental interrogative form of these expressions should be noted. Other passages express by inference the low es- teem in which dogs are held. Nothing worse could happen to a person than that his body should be devoured by dogs (1 K 14 11; 16 4; 21 19.23, etc). Job 30 1 says of the youth who deride him that he disdained to set their fathers with the dogs of his flock. In Phil 3 2 and Rev 22 15, dogs are coupled with evil-workers, sorcerers, etc. In Mt 7 6 weread: “Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast your pearls before the swine.” Job 30 1 (cited above) refers to the use of dogs to guard flocks; and the comparison of inefficient watchmen with dumb dogs (Isa 56 10) implies that at least some dogs are useful. In the apocryphal Book of Tob, Tobias’ dog is his companion on his travels (Tob 5 16; 11 4; on thissee Expos T, XI, 258; HDB, IV, 989; Geiger, Civilization of E. Tranians, I, 85 ff). There is further the reference to the greyhound (Prov 30 31 EV) as one of the four things which are ‘‘stately in their going.’ But the rendering, ‘‘greyhound,’’ rests solely upen inference, and is contrary to the LXX and Vulg, which have respectively aléktér and gallus, i.e. “cock,’’ AVm ‘“horse."". The Heb has zarzir mothnayim, which AVm renders ‘‘girt in the loins.”". RVm has *‘war- horse,’’ Heb ‘‘ well girt (or, well knit] in the loins.” In support of the meaning, “‘girt,’’ for zarzir, there is the word zér, which, with zarzir, is assigned to the obs root zarar and the Arab. zirr, ‘‘button,”’ from zarr, ‘to but- ton,” ‘to compress.’’ Further, to render zarzir by ‘‘cock” logically requires a change in the text, for moth- nayim, ‘loins,’ becomes superlative and inappropriate (see EB, s.v. ‘‘Cock’’). On the other hand, the Arab. zarzair is a starling (cf Arab. zarzar, ‘“‘to utter cries,’’ said of birds; sarsar, ‘to cry out’; sarsir, ‘‘ cockroach,” or ‘‘cricket’). Also, according to #B (s.v. Cock”), “the Talmudic zarzir. .. . means some bird (a kind of raven).’’ If the text stands, there appears to be no better rendering than ‘‘girt in the loins,’ which might fairly be taken to refer to a war horse or to a greyhound. The Pers greyhound would in that case be understood, a hairy race, which, according to the Royal Natural His- tory, is less fleet than the Eng. breed and is used in cours- ing gazelles and in hunting the wild ass, and which accord- ing to Doughty (Arabia Deserta) is kept by the Bedawin. “These dogs are said to be sometimes girdled by their owners to prevent them from over-eating and becoming fat’’ (L. Fletcher, British Museum [Natural History]). Domestic dogs have probably been derived from various species of wolves and jackals. In this con- nection, it is noteworthy that the dogs of certain regions greatly resemble the wolves of those regions. The pariah dogs of Syria and Pal resemble the jack- als, esp. in color and in the tail, differing in their greater size and in the shape of muzzle and ears. It is fair to assume that they are much the same as existed in Bible times. and harmless creatures, and are valuable as scav- engers, but disturb the night with their barking. Each quarter of the city has its own pack of dogs, which vigorously resents any invasion of its terri- tory. A dog which for any reason finds itself in foreign territory gets home as quickly as possible, and is lucky if it does not have to run the gauntlet of a pack of vicious foes. The pariah dog is some- times brought up to be a sheep dog, but the best shepherd dogs are great wolfish creatures, which are usually obtained from Kurdistan. ALFRED Ey Day DOGMA, dog’ma (8dypa, dégma, from doxéw, dokéd, “that which seems,” “an opinion,” partic- ularly the opinion of a philosopher): In 1. AsLaw_ the decadent period of Gr philosophy, and the opinion, or ipse dizit, of the master Ordinance of a philosophical school came to be quoted as authoritative truth; also, the opinion of a sovereign imposed as law upon his subjects: a decree or ordinance of the civil author- ity. The word never appears in EV, although it is used 5 t in the Gr NT, but with the one exception They are in general meek . of Acts 16 4, in a sense widely different from that which ecclesiastical usage has given to it from the 2d cent. downward. ‘‘Dogma” is used in the NT, (1) of Rom laws: ‘‘a decree (Gr dogma] from Caesar Augustus” (Lk 2 1); “the decrees of Caesar” (Acts 17 7)=the whole body of Rom law; (2) of ordi- nances of religious law: ‘‘the law of commandments contained in ordinances” (Eph 2 15); “the bond written in ordinances” (Col 2 14) =the Mosaic ordi- nances as expressing the morallaw which condemned the sinner, and whose enmity Christ abolished by His death. It is a significant revelation of the spirit of Gr theology that all the Gr commentators under- stood by ordinances in these two places, the gospel as a body of dogmas which had removed the com- mandment or bond that was against us (see Light- foot, Col, ad loc.); (3) of the decrees of the Council of Jerus (Acts 15 20), which Paul and his com- panions delivered to the gentile churches (Acts 16 4). Here we have one element that entered into the later ecclesiastical meaning of the word. These dogmas were decisions on religious matters, imposed by a more or less authoritative council of the church as a condition of admission to its membership. There is however one important difference. These decrees relate to moral and ceremonial matters, but from the 2d cent. downward, dog- 2. As ma means esp. a theological doctrine. Formulated In Gr theology “doctrine” and ‘dog- Teaching ma’ meant thesame thing. Each had its origin in the opinion of some great teacher; each rested upon revelation and claimed its authority; each meant an exposition of a par- ticular truth of the gospel, and of the whole Chris- tian truth, which the church adopted as the only right exposition. Each word might be used for the teaching of a philosopher, or of a heretic, although for the latter, “‘heresy”’ became the regular term. On the one side stood the doctrines or dogmas of the majority or the ‘Catholic’ church, and on the other side, those of the heretics. So long as the “Catholic” ideal of orthodoxy and uniformity of belief held the field, there was no room for the distinction now made between “doctrine,” as a scientific and systematic expression of the truth of the Christian religion, and “dogma,” as those truths “authoritatively ratified as expressing the belief of the church.” This distinction could only arise when men began to think that various expressions of Christian truth could coexist in the church, and is therefore quite modern and even recent. Dogma in this sense denotes the ancient conception of theology as an authoritative system of orthodoxy, and doctrine, the modern conception, outside the dogmatic churches, where theology is regarded as a scientific exposition of truth. LirerRatuRse.—Harnack, t . Drummond, Studies Gn CLtan eee ane T. Rees DOK, dok (Aéx, Dok, Aaydv, Dagon): A small for- tress, ‘little stronghold” near Jericho (1 Mace 16 15), built by Ptolemy, son of Abubus, where he entertained and murdered his father-in-law Simon Maccabaeus and his two sons. Jos (Ané, XIII, vii, 1; BJ, I, ii, 3) calls the place Dagon and places it above Jericho. The name persists in Ain Duk with its copious springs of excellent water about 4 miles N.W. of Jericho. Some ancient foundations in the neighborhood are possibly those of Ptolemy’s fortress, but more probably of a Templars’ station which is known to have stood there as late as the end of the 13th cent. For its importance in earlier Jewish history, see Smith, HGHL, 250, 251, ; J. Hutcaison DOLEFUL, dol’f56l (GN, ’0%h, “howling’”’): The “doleful creatures” referred to in Isa 13 21 are probably “jackals,” although some have suggested 869 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dogma Dor, Dora “leopard,” or “‘hyaena.”’ The older EV gives “great owls.”” The word rendered ‘‘doleful lamen- tation” in Mic 2 4 (nth*yah) is simply a form of the word ordinarily tr? ‘‘wailing” (n*ht). Cf AVm. DOLPHIN, dol’fin. DOMINION, dé-min’yun: In Eph 1 21; Col 1 16 the word so tr? (kupiétys, kuridtés) appears to denote a rank or order of angels. The same word is probably to be so interpreted in Jude ver 8 (AV and RV ‘dominion”’), and in 2 Pet 210 (AV “government,”’ RV ‘“dominion”). See ANGEL. DOOM, doom: Occurs only once in AV (2 Esd 7 43), ‘‘The day of doom shall be the end of this time” (RV “‘the day of judgement”’); but RV gives it as the rendering of MDX, ¢¢phiradh, in Ezk 7 7. 10 (AV “the morning,” RVm “the turn” or “the crowning time’; but the meaning is not yet quite certain); and in 1 Cor 49 (éwiOavdriws, epi- ' thandtios, ‘‘as men doomed to death,” AV ‘‘ap- pointed [originally ‘“approved’’] unto death’). Our word ‘‘doom”’ is connected with the word “deem,” and signifies either the act of judging or (far more often) the sentence itself or the condition resulting therefrom (cf ‘‘Deemster” of Isle of Man and Jer- sey). Generally, but not always, an unfavorable judgment is implied. Cf Dryden, Coronation of Charles II, i, 127: “Two kingdoms wait your doom, and, as you choose, This must receive a crown, or that must lose.”’ J. R. Van Per DOOR, dir: Most commonly the rendering of Heb pethah, “doorway,” deleih, “door” proper (the two distinguished in Gen 19 6), or of Gr 6vpa, théra, which represents both meanings. The door proper was usually of wood, frequently sheeted with metal, sometimes of one slab of stone, as shown in excavations in the Hauran. It turned on pivots (the “hinges’’ of Prov 26 14) working in sockets above and below, and was provided with a bolt (2 8 13 17) or with lock and key (Jgs 3 23). The doorway was inclosed by the stone threshold (1 K 14 17), the two doorposts on either side, and the lintel above (Ex 12 7). Doors were frequently two-leaved, and folding ones are mentioned in con- nection with the temple (1 K 6 34). Where “‘door”’ is used in connection with city gates (Neh 3 1 ff) it refers to the door proper which swings on its hinges as distinguished from the whole structure. The custom of fastening to the doorposts small cases containing a parchment inscribed with the words of Dt 6 4-9; 11 13-21 had its origin in the command there given. See also Gate; House. Figuratiye: (1) Christ is ‘‘the door’ into the gos- pel ministry (Jn 10 1.2.7); ministers must receive their authority from Him, and exercise it in His spirit. (2) ‘Through faith in Him also both shep- herds and sheep enter into the kingdom of God (ver 9), and find all their spiritual needs supplied.’ (3) The fig. in Rev 3 20 is expressive of Christ’s patient, persistent and affectionate appeal to men. (4) Elsewhere also of opportunity (Mt 26 10; Acts 14 27; 1 Cor 16 9; 2 Cor 2 12; Rev 3 8). (5) Of freedom and power (Col 4 3). See also Acuor; SHEPHERD. BrNnJAMIN RENO DowNER DOORKEEPER, dor’kép-ér (PW, sho‘ér): The gates of an oriental city and of the temple courts so closely resembled the door of a house that the same Heb word was used for doorkeeper and gate- keeper. It is often tr? by the less definite word “porter” (q.V.)._, a In the preéxilic writings (2 S 18 26; 2 K 7 10. 11) reference is made to porters at the gates of the cities Mahanaim and Samaria. In these early See Bancrr. writings there is also mention of a small number of “keepers of the threshold” of the temple, whose duties included the gathering of money from the people for temple purposes, and the care of the sacred vessels (2 K 129; 22 4; 23 4). They held an honorable position (2 K 26 18), and occu- pied chambers in the temple (Jer 36 4). The same term is used to describe officers in the household of the king of Persia (Est 2 21; 6 2). Differing from these ‘keepers of the threshold” in some respects are the doorkeepers or porters mentioned in Ch, Ezr and Neh. These formed a numerous sacred order (1 Ch 9 22; 23 5) from the time of David. Their duties and the words describ- ing them in two passages, ‘‘keepers of the thresh- olds” (1 Ch 9 19) and “porters of the thresholds” (2 Ch 23 4), connect them in some measure with the ‘‘keeper of the threshold” referred to above. They guarded the gates of the house of Jeh (1 Ch 9 23), closing and opening them at the proper times (ver 27) and preventing the unclean from entering the sacred inclosure (2 Ch 23 19); they had charge of the sacred vessels and of the free-will offerings (2 Ch 81 14), and dwelt in the chambers about the temple (1 Ch 9 27). They were Levites, and came in from the Levitical villages every seventh day for service in their turn (1 Ch 9 25). Their office was honorable, ranking with the singers, after the priests and Levites (Ezr 2 42; 1 Ch 16 18). In Ps 84 10, “I had rather be a d. in the house of my God,” the word is not used in its technical sense. RVm gives “stand [AVm “sit’’] at the threshold,” to an eastern mind a situation of deep humility (cf title of the Ps and 1 Ch 9 19). In the NT the order of temple doorkeepers is not referred to. But a doorkeeper (6vpwpés, thurdrés) is mentioned in connection with a private house (Mk 13 34), with the high priest’s house (Jn 18 16.17), and with sheep-folds (Jn 10 3), a maid serving as doorkeeper in some cases (Acts 12 13). Grorce Rice Hovey DOORPOST, dér’pist. See Hovse. DOPHKAH, dof’ka (NPLT, dophkah, “drover’’): A desert camp of the Israelites, the first after leaving the wilderness of Sin (Nu 33 12.13). See Wan- DERINGS OF ISRAEL. DOR, dér, DORA, di’ra (ANT, da’r, “1, dér, “habitation,” “circle”; Adp, Dér; Jos, Adépa, Déra; mod. Tanturah): A town of the coast of Pal, S. of Carmel (CAp, II, 10; Viia, 8), about 8 miles N. of Caesarea. It was occupied in the earliest times by the Canaanites and probably belonged to Phoenicia, tradition saying that it was a Sidonian colony. It furnished an abundance of the shell-fish so valuable for the manufacture of the Tyrian purple, and this would have led the Phoenicians to occupy the site. In the 12th cent. BC, the region was occupied by the northern people who raided the whole Syrian coast and Egypt. They were driven back by the Egyp- tians, but renewed the attack, and the weakness of Egypt in the middle of the cent. enabled them to settle in the coast region 8. of Carmel; a tribe of them occupied Dor, and others the territory to the limits of the desert of Sinai, and became the Phili people so well known by their contests with the Hebrews. Naphoth-dor, ‘‘the heights of Dor,” may be the slopes of Carmel inland from Tantdérah. Dor fell within the territory assigned to Manasseh (Josh 17 11; cf Ant, V, i, 22). It was the seat of a king who possessed other towns on the heights back of the coast. He was one of the allies of Jabin of Hazor in the conflict with Joshua (Josh 11 2) and was conquered by him (12 23), but Dor was not occupied by the Israelites (17 11; Jgs 1 27). The inhabitants of Dor were at enmity with the Dorcas Dove THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 870 Phoen towns and it would seem that the Sidonians seized it to obtain its rich supplies of shell-fish, and this probably caused the war of retaliation waged by the Philis, under the lead of Ashkelon, against Sidon in the middle of the 11th cent. Sidon was besieged by land, and the inhabitants were compelled to flee to Tyre. Dor seems to have been occupied by Solomon since he placed one of his purveyors in the town (1 K 4 11), and Tiglath-pileser III re- duced it and set a governor over it (Rawl., Phoen., 84). Here Tryphon was besieged by Antiochus, but escaped to Apamea (I Macc 16 11.13.25; Ant, XIII, vii, 2). It was made free by Pompey, and joined to the province of Syria (XIV, iv, 4). The youths of the place set up a statue of Tiberius in the Jewish synagogue, an outrage that was reported to Publius Petronius by Agrippa, and reparation was made (XIX, vi, 3). It does not seem to have been of much importance in later times, though the forti- fications still remaining on the ruined site, from the period of the Middle Ages, show that it was then occupied. Itis now only a miserable village nestled in the ruins. H. Porter DORCAS, dér’kas (Aopxas, Dorkds, the Gr equivalent of Aram. tabitha, ‘‘a gazelle”): The name was borne by a Christian woman of Joppa. She is called a disciple (mathétria: Acts 9 36, the only place in the NT where the fem. form is used). She seems to have had some means and also to have been a leader in the Christian community. Dorcas was beloved for the manner in which she used her position and means, for she “was full of good works, and almsdeeds which shedid.”” Among her charities was the clothing of the poor with garments she her- self made (ver 39), and by following her example, numerous ‘Dorcas societies’ in the Christian church perpetuate her memory. There is a local memorial in the “Tabitha School” in Jaffa devoted to the care and education of poor girls. Her restoration to life by Peter is recorded. At the time of her death Peter was in Lydda where he had healed Aeneas. Being sent for, he went to Joppa, and, by the exercise of the supernatural powers granted to him, ‘“‘he presented her alive” to the mourning community. In consequence of this miracle “many believed on the Lord” (ver 42). S. F. Hunter DORYMENES, dé-rim‘’e-néz (Aopupévns, Do- ruménés): Father of Ptolemy Macron (1 Mace 3 388; 2 Macc 4 45); probably the same man who fought against Antiochus the Great (Polyb. v.61). DOSITHEUS, dé-sith’é-us (Aot@eos, Dostiheos): (1) A captain of Judas Maccabaens (2 Macc 12 19-25); along with Sosipater he captured Timo- theus after the battle of Carnion, but granted him his life and freedom on the representation that “he had in his power the parents of many of them and the brethren of some,” who, if they put him to death, should “‘be disregarded.” (2) A soldier in the army of Judas Maccabaeus (2 Mace 12 35); he made a special attack upon Gorgias, governor of Idumaea, the opposing general, and would have taken the “accursed man’ prisoner but for the interference of a Thracian horseman. (3) A Jew, son of Drimylus (8 Mace 1 3) who rescued Ptolemy Philopator from a plot of The- odotus. He afterward proved an apostate from Judaism. (4) A Levite priest who “in the 4th year of the reign of Ptolemy and Cleopatra”’ carried the tr of the Book of Est to Alexandria (Ad Est 11 I). J. Hurcuison DOTAEA, dé-té’a (AV, incorrectly, Judea; Aw- tala, Dataia): Another form of the name DoTHaNn (q.v.). DOTE, dot: “To dote’ means either “to be weakminded” or “to be foolishly fond.’” In the latter sense it is employed in Ezk 23 5 ff; in the former, in Jer 50 36 AV (RV “shal! become fools”); AV Sir 25 2 (RV “lacking understanding”), and AVI Tim 6 4 (RVm “‘to be sick”; AVm “a fool’’). DOTHAIM, do’théi-im: Mentioned in Jth 4 6 and frequently in connection with the invasion of Holofernes. See next art. DOTHAN, do’than (7207, déthayin, |], dothan, “two wells,” “double feast’; Aw@deap, Dothdeim): A place to the N. of Shechem whither Jacob’s sons went for pasture for the flocks; where Joseph who followed them was sold to the Ishmaelites, after having been imprisoned in a “pit” (Gen 37 17 ff). Dothan. Here in later days the eyes of Elisha’s servant were opened to see the mountain “full of horses and chariots of fire,’ guarding his master from the en- circling Syrians (2 K 6 13 ff). This is certainly to be identified with Tell Dothan, which lies on the E. of the ancient road leading from Gilead across Esdraelon to the seacoast, and thence to Egypt. It is about 5 miles to the S.W. of Jenin. There are some traces of old buildings, two cisterns—Déthayin or Dathayim=‘‘two cisterns’ or ‘‘pits’—and one copious spring. Excellent pasture is found in the surrounding plain, and on the adjoining slopes. ‘ . EWING DOUBLE, dub” (712 , shandah, “‘to repeat,” asin counting; opp , kaphal, “to fold over,” or “double,” as a cloth): A word used quite frequently in the OT. Jacob ordered his sons to take double money in their hands, i.e. twice the necessary amount (Gen 43 12.15). Ita thief be caught with a living ani- mal he was to restore double (Ex 22 4); if property be stolen out of the house of one to whom it 1s in- trusted he was to restore double (Ex 22 7.9). The firstborn was to receive a double portion of the in- heritance (Dt 21 17). Likewise also by a beauti- ful symbol Elisha asked for a double portion of Elijah’s spirit to fall upon him (2 K 2 9). De- grees of punishment or sufferings were alsg expressed by the idea of a doubling (Isa 61 7; ner 16 18; 17 18; Zec 9 12). The use of the second Heb form in Job 11 6 and 41 13 seems quite confusing initstr. AY translates it simply “double,” but RV gives it its expanded and derived meaning, ‘‘mani- fold in understanding,” and ‘‘who shall come within his jaws,’ respectively, ‘manifold’? in the first instance meaning multiplied, and “jaws’’ doubt- less meaning the double row of teeth. The classic phrases in the NT are those used by James to repre- sent instability and a wavering disposition, S&puxos, dipsuchos, lit. “doubleminded”’ (Jas 1 8; 4 8). WaLtTerR G. CLIPPINGER _ DOUBT, dout: This word, found only a score of times in the Bible, translates nevertheless about half as many different Heb and Gr originals with a corresponding variety of meanings. In Gen 37 33 “without doubt” is to be taken in the common sense of “certainly”; ‘in Job 12 2 in the sarcastic sense of “indeed! In Dnl 6 12.16, it is used as a difficult problem or mystery to be 871 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dorcas Dove explained, and these are the only cases of its em- ployment in the OT. In the NT it is about equally used to translate diarropéw, diaporéd, and draxplyw, diakrind, and their cognates. The first means “‘to be without resource,’ “utterly at a loss,’ “nonplussed”; and the second, “‘to judge diversely.” For the first, see Jn 13 22; Acts 2 12 AV; 6 24 AV; 10 17 AV; 25 20 AV; and Gal 4 20 AV. For the second see Mt 21 21; Mk 11 23; Acts 10 20; Rom 14 23. The last-named is deserving of particular attention. ‘‘He that doubteth is condemned [AV “damned”’] if he eat,’’ means that in a case of uncertainty as to one’s Christian liberty, it were better to err on the side of restraint. In Lk 12 29 “to be of doubtful mind” (uerewpiiw, metedrizo, lit. ‘‘to suspend” } vide Thayer, s.v.), means “to be driven by gusts,” or “to fluctuate in mid-air.” Here, as in Mt 14 31, ‘“douht’’ does not indicate alack of faith, but rather ‘‘a state of qualified faith’: its weakness, but not its absence. In Jn 10 24 “doubt” translates alpw puyjv, atrd psuchén, which lit. means “to lift up the soul,” or ‘“‘to keep one in suspense’; so RV. See also DispuTaTION. James M. Gray DOUGH, dé. DOVE, duv (WW, tar, TI, yonah; weprorrepa., peristerd; Lat Zenaedura carolinensis): A bird of the family Columbidae. Doves and pigeons are so closely related as to be spoken and written of as synonymous, yet there is a distinction recognized from the heginning of time. It was esp. marked in Pal, becanse doves migrated, but pigeons remained jn their chosen haunts all the year. Yet doves were the wild birds and were only confined singly or in pairs as caged pets, or in order to be available for sacrifice. Pigeons, without question, were the first domesticated birds, the record of their conquest by man extending if anything farther back than ducks, geese and swans. These two were the best known and the most loved of all the myriads of birds of Pal. Doves were given preference because they remained wild and were more elusive. The thing that escapes us is usually a little more attract- ive than the thing we have. Their loving natures had been noted, their sleek beautiful plumage, their plump bodies. They were the most precious of any- thing offered for sacrifice. Their use is always speci- fied in preference to pigeons if only one bird was used; if both, the dove is frequently mentioned first. Because of their docility when caged, their use in sacrifice, and the religious superstition con- cerning them, they were allowed to nest unmolested and, according to species, flocked all over Pal. The turtle-dove nested in gardens and vineyards, and was almost as tame as the pigeons. The palm turtle-dove took its name from its love of, homing in palm trees, and sought these afield, and in cities, even building near the temple in Jerus. It also selected thorn and other trees. It has a small body, about ten inches in length, covered with bright chestnut-colored feathers, the neck dappled with dark, lustrous feathers. The rock dove swarmed over, through, and among the cliffs of mountains and the fissures of caves and ravines. The collared turtle-dove was the largest of the species. It re- mained permanently and homed in the forests of Tabor and Gilead, around the Dead Sea, and along the Jordan valley. This bird was darker than the others and took its name from a clearly outlined collar of dark feathers encircling the neck, and was esp. sought for caged pets on account of its size and eauty. : i In all, the dove is mentioned about fifty times in the Bible. Many of these references are concernmg See Breap. its use in sacrifice and need not all be mentioned. The others are quoted and explained from a scien- tific standpoint and in accordance with the charac- teristics and habits of the birds. The first reference to the dove occurs in Gen 8 8-12, in the history of the flood; then follows its specified use in sac- rifice; note of its migratory habits is made, and then in poetry, prophecy, comparison, simile and song, it appears over and over throughout the Bible. n Gen 8 8-12, we read, “And he sent forth a dove from him, to see if the waters were abated.” Noah first sent out a raven, because it was a strong, aggressive bird and would return to its mate. But the raven only flew over the water and returned to perch on the ark. This was not satisfactory, so Noah in looking for a hird better suited to his pur- poses bethought him of the most loving and tender ird he knew—the dove. It not only would return to the ark, but would enter and go to the cage of its mate, and if it found green food it would regurgitate a portion for her or its young, or if not nesting he could tell by its droppings if greenery had been eaten and so decide if the waters were going down. And this is precisely what happened. The dove came back, and the watching Noah saw it feed its mate little green olive leaves, for the dove never carries food in the beak, but swallows and then regurgitates it to mate and young. This first reference to birds was made on account of the loving, tender characteristics of the species; the next, because they were the most loved by the people, and therefore chosen as most suitable to offer as sacrifice (Gen 15 9). In Lev 1 14f, doves are men- tioned as sacrifice: “And the priest shall bring it unto the altar, and wring off its head, and burn it on the altar; and the blood thereof shall be drained out on the side of the altar.” In Lev 6 7 the proper preparation of the sacrifice is prescribed. For method of handling sacrifice see vs 8.9.10. In Lev 12 6 the law for a sacrifice for a mother is given, and ver 8 of same ch provides that if she be too poor to offer a lamb, doves or pigeons will suffice. In Lev 14 4-8 the reference for the sacrifice of a leper is merely to “birds,” because it is understood that they are pigeons and doves, and it contains the specification that if the victim is too poor to afford so elahorate a sacrifice, a smaller one will suffice. The birds are named in ver 22: “Two turtle-doves, or two young pigeons, such as he is able to get; and the one shall be a sin-offering, and the other a burnt-offering” (cf Lev 15 14.29; Nu 6 10). When David prayed for the destruction of the treacherous, he used the dove in comparison, and because he says he would “lodge in the wilder- nee he indicates that he was thinking of the palm turtle. “And I said, Oh that I had wings like a dove! Then would I fly away, and be at rest’’ (Ps 55 6). In chanting a song of triumph, David used an ex- quisite thought. ‘““When ye lie among the sheepfolds, It is as the wings of a dove covered with silver, And her pinions wlth yellow gold"’ (Ps 68 13). He referred to the rock dove because the metallic luster on its neck would gleam like gold in sunshine, and the soft grayish-white feathers beneath the wings as he would see the bird above him in flight would appear silver-like. By this quotation David meant that in times of peace, when men slept con- tentedly at home among their folds, their life waa as rich with love and as free in peace as the silver wing of the dove that had the gold feathers and was unmolested among the inaccessible caves and cliffs. In Ps 74 19 the term “turtle-dove” is used to indi- cate people whom the Almighty is implored to pro- tect: “Ob deliver not the soul of thy turtle-dove Dove Drawer of Water JHE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 872 unto the wild beast: forget not the life of thy poor for ever.” Solomon uses the dove repeatedly in comparison or as a term of endearment. In Cant 1 15; 4 1; 5 12, he compares the eyes of his bride full, tender, beautiful, with those of a dove. In 2 12 he uses Turtle-Dove (Turtur auritus). the voice of the dove as an indication of spring. In 2 14 he addresses the bride as arock dove. In5 2 is another term of endearment, this time used in the dream of the bride (cf 6 9). Isa 38 14 has reference to the wailing, mournful dove note from which the commonest species take the name “mourning dove.” The reference in Isa 60 8 proves that the prophet was not so good an observer, or so correct in his natural history as David, who may have learned from the open. As a boy, David guarded the flocks of his father and watched the creatures around him. When exulting over the glory of the church in the numerous accessions of Gentiles, Isaiah cried, “Who are these that fly as a cloud, and as the doves to their windows?” This proves that he confounded pigeons and doves. Doves were wild, mostly mi- gratory, and had no ‘windows.’ But the clay cotes of pigeons molded in squares so that one large cote sheltered many pairs in separate homes had the appearance of latticed windows and were used asa basis in estimating a man’s wealth. This refer- ence should be changed to read, ‘‘and as pigeons to their windows.” In Jer 8 7 the fact is pointed out that doves were migratory; and in 48 28 people are advised to go live in solitary places and be peaceable, loving and faithful, like the rock doves. See also Ezk 7 16: ‘‘But those of them that escape shall escape, and shall be on the mountains lke doves of the valleys, all of them moaning, every one in his iniquity.” This merely means that people should be driven to hide among the caves and valleys where the rock doves lived, and that the sound of their mourning would resemble the cry of the birds. It does not mean, however, that the doves were mourning, for when doves coo and moan and to our ears grow most pitiful in their cries, they are the happiest in the mating season. The veneration cherished for doves in these days is inborn, and no bird is so loved and protected as the dove—hence it is unusually secure and happy and its mournful cry is the product of our imagination only. The dove is the happiest of birds. Hos 7 11 and 11 11 each compares people with doves; the first, because the birds at times appear foolishly trusting; the second, because, while no bird is more confiding, none is more easily frightened. ‘And Ephraim is like a silly dove, without understanding: they call unto Egypt, they go to Assyria” (7 11). “They shall come trembling as a bird out of Egypt, and as a dove out of the land of Assyria; and I will make them to dwell in their houses, saith Jeh” (11 11). The referencein Nah 2 7 is to the voice of the birds. NT references will be found in a description of the baptism of Jesus (Mt 3 16). People are ad- monished to be “‘harmless as doves” (10 16). “And Jesus entered into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the money-changers, and the seats of them that sold the doves” (Mt 21 12). This proves that these birds were a common article of commerce, probably the most used for caged pets, and those customarily employed for sacrifice. Dove’s Dung (2°31 "WD, hart yonim, Kethibh for DPS, dibhyénim): 2 K 6 25: “And there was a great famine in Samaria: and, behold, they be- sieged it, until an ass’s head was sold for fourscore pieces of silver, and the fourth part of a kab of dove’s dung for five pieces of silver.” This seems so re- pulsive that some commentators have tried to prove the name applied to the edible root of a plant, but the history of sieges records other cases where matter quite as offensive was used to sustain life. The text is probably correct as it stands. ; GENE STRATTON-PORTER DOWRY, dou’ri: In all Heb marriages, the dowry held an important place. The dowry sealed the betrothal. It took several forms. The bride- groom presented gifts to the bride. There was the “10, modhar, “dowry” as distinguished from ]MA, mattan, ‘‘gifts to the members of the family” (cf Gen 24 22.53; Gen $4 12). The price paid to the father or brothers of the bride was probably a survival of the early custom of purchasing wives (Gen 34 12; Ex 22 17; 1 8 18 25; cf Ruth 4 10; Hos 8 2). There was frequently much negotia- tion and bargaining as to size of dowry (Gen 34 12). The dowry would generally be according to the wealth and standing of the bride (cf 1 8 18 23). It might consist of money, jewelry or other valu- able effects; sometimes, of service rendered, as in the caseof Jacob (Gen 29 18); deeds of valor might be accepted in place of dowry (Josh 15 16; 15 18 25; Jgs 112). Occasionally a bride received a dowry from her father; sometimes in the shape of land (Jgs 1 15), and of cities (1 IX 9 16). In later Jewish history a written marriage contract definitely arranged for the nature and size of the dowry. Epwarp Bacay PoLLarp DOXOLOGY, dok-sol’5-ji (SofoAoyla, dozxologia, “a praising,” ‘‘giving glory”): A hymn or liturgical formula expressive of praise to God, as the Gloria in Excelsis (an expansion of Lk 2 14), sometimes called the Greater Doxology, and the Gloria Patri (‘Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost, world without end, Amen’’) also known as the Lesser Doxology. The clause, ‘‘as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be,’’ was probably added to the original simple formula to emphasize the church's dissent from the Arian conception of Christ. The term is applied in particular to the conclud- ing paragraph of the Lord’s Prayer (Mt 6 13m, “For thine is the kingdom,” etc; cf 1 Ch 29 11, and see Lorp’s PRAYER). To the same general class belong Ps 41 13; 72 18f; 89 52; Rom 16 27; Eph 2 20; 1 Tim 1 17; Jude ver 25; Rev 6 13f; 19 1-3, and the modern stanza beginning ‘‘Praise God, from whom all blessings flow.” M. O. Evans DRACHMA, drak’ma, DRAM (8paxp4, drachmé): The word is used in the LXX as the rendering of 873 Drawer of Water THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dove pa, beka', “half-shekel,” which must refer to the light standard for the shekel, as its weight was about 62 grains. In the NT the word occurs only in Lk 15 8.9, where it is rendered ‘‘a piece of silver’? (m “drachma”’). Jt was commonly taken as equivalent to the Rom denarius, though not strictly so. DRAGON, drag’un (PSE, tannin, pl. OST, tan- nim, NIT, tanndth; Spaxwv, drdkén): Tannin and the pl. tanninim occur 14 t, and in EV are variously rendered ‘‘dragon,"’ ‘‘whale,"’ ‘‘serpent"’ or ‘“‘sea-monster"'; but Lam 4 3, AV ‘'sea-monster,” AVm ‘‘sea calves,’’ RV ‘‘jackals.'’ Tannim occurs 12 t, and is rendered ‘‘dragons,"’ RV ‘“‘jackals,"" except in Ezk 29 3, where AV has ‘‘dragon"’ (ARV ‘‘monster"’), and in Ezk 32 2, where AV has ‘'whale"’ and ERV and AVm “dragon” (ARV ‘'monster"’). Tannéth occurs ance, in Mal 1 3, where it is rendered ‘“‘dragons,"’ RV “ jackals." Drakén occurs 12 t in Rev 12, 18, 16, and 20, where it is uniformly rendered ‘dragon.’ (Cf Arab. tinnin, the constellation, Draco.) Tannéth (ILXX dwpara démata, ‘‘dwellings'') is a fem. pl. form as if from tannaéh, but it suits the context to give it the same meaning as tannim. Iu Ex 7 9.10.12, tannin is used of the serpents which were produced from Aaron's rod and the rods of the Egyp magicians, whereas in Ex 4 3 and 7 15, for the serpeut produced from Aaron's rod, we find nahash, the ordinary word for serpent. In two passages’ we find ‘‘whale,"” RV ‘sea-monster’’; Gen ] 21: “‘And God created the great sea-monsters, and every living creature that moveth"’; Job 7 12: ‘‘'AmIasea, or a sea-monster, that thou settest a watch over me?"’ Other passages (ERV and AV) are Dt 32 33: ‘‘ Their wine is the poison of dragons [ARV ‘'serpents"'], and the cruel venom of asps'"’; Neh 2 13: ‘‘And I went out by night by the valley gate, even toward the dragon's [ARV ‘‘jackal's'’] well" (AV “dragon well"); Ps 91 13: '' Thou shalt tread upon the lion and adder: the young lion and the serpent [AV ‘‘dragon’’] shalt thou trample under foot"; Ps 148 7: ‘‘ Praise Jeh from the earth, ye sea-monsters [AV ‘*dragons"'], and all deeps’’; Jer §1 34: ‘‘ Nebuchad- rezzar the king of Bahylon hath devoured me,.... like a monster’ (AV ‘‘dragon''). Here also two tannim pasenes: Hzk 29 3: ‘Thus saith the Lord Jeh: Be- old, I am against thee, Pharaoh king of Egypt, the great monster [AV ‘‘dragon’’] that lieth in the midst -of his rivers, that hath said, My river is mine own, and I have madeit for myself’; and Ezk 32 2: ‘‘Son of man, take up a lamentation over Pharaoh king of Egynt, and say unto him, Thou wast likened unto a young lion of the nations: yet art thou as a monster (ERV “dragon, ’AV “whale” ] in the seas; and thou didst hreak forth with thy rivers. and troubledst the waters with thy feet, and fouledst their rivers.” The foregoing passages offer no especial difficul- ties in the interpretation of the word tannin. All may fairly be understood to refer to a serpent or sea-monster or some imaginary creature, without invoking any ancient myths for their elucidation. The same may be said of the passages in Rev. A dragon is taken as the personification of Satan, as of Pharaoh in the passages in Ezk. It is of course true that ancient myths may more or less distantly underlie some of these dragon and serpent refer- ences, and such myths may be demonstrated to throw additional light in certain cases, but at least the passages in question are intelligible without recourse to the myths. This however is not equally true of all the tannin passages. In Ps 74 12 we read: ‘Yet God is my King of old, working salva- tion in the midst of the earth. Thou didst divide the sea by thy strength: thou brakest the heads of the sea-monsters [AV “dragons’’] in the waters.” Cf Isa 27 1; 61 OF. The three passages just cited seem to denote each some particular act, and are referred by Canon Cheyne (EB s.v. “Dragon’’) to the old Bab myth of the conflict of Marduk and Tiamat in the Assyr creation-legend (thus Gunkel, etc). Indeed he refers to that myth not only these passages, but also Jer 61 34; Ezk 29 3-6; 32 2-8 and Job 7 12, which have been cited above. In translating the last two passages, Canon Cheyne uses the definite article, “the dragon,” instead of “a” as in RV, which makes a great difference in the meaning. In Ps 87 4, it is clear that Rahab is a country, i.e. Egypt. Isa 30 7 is to the same point. In Isa 61 9.10, “that didst cut Rahab in pieces” and “that didst pierce the monster” (AV “dragon’’), are two codrdinate ex- pressions of one idea, which is apparently the de- feat of the Egyptians, as appears in the reference to the passage of the Red Sea. In Isa 27 1, ‘‘levia- than the swift serpent” and “leviathan the crooked serpent” and ‘‘the monster [AV and ERV “‘dragon’”’] that isin the sea” have been identified with Baby- lon, Persia and Egypt (#B s.v. ‘‘Dragon,” 4). It is more probable that the first two expressions are coérdinate, and amount to “leviathan the swift and crooked serpent,” and that the verse may therefore refer to Babylonia and Egypt. Ps 74 12-15 is more in line with the idea of the art. in #B, but it is nevertheless susceptible of an explanation similar to that of the other two passages. Tannim, “dragons” (RV “jackals’’) occurs in Job 30 29; Ps 44 19; Isa 18 22; 3413; 357; 48 20; Jer 911; 10 22; 14 6; 49 33; 51 37; ¢tan- noth, “dragons” (RV “‘jackals”’) isfound in Mal 1 3. In all these passages, “jackal” suits the context better than “dragon,” “sea-monster” or ‘‘serpent.”’ An exception to the rendering of “dragon” or ‘“‘ser- pent” or “‘sea-monster” for tannin is found in Lam 43: “Even the Jackals draw out the breast, they give snuck to their young ones.” AV has ‘‘sea- monster,’ AVm “sea calves.” A mammal is indi- cated, and RV apparently assumes that tannin is an error for tanntm. Two other exceptions are in Ezk 29 3 and 32 2, where EV renders tannim by “dragon,” since in these two passages “jackal” ob- viously will not suit. See JACKAL. On the constellational dragons or snakes, see Astronomy, II, 1-5. Atrrep Exiy Day DRAGON, BEL AND THE. See BEL anv THE Dracon, DRAGON, RED. See Revetation, Boox or. DRAGON WELL (Neh 2 13 AV). AL’s WELL. DRAM. See Dracuma; Money. See Jack- DRAMA MIMIC, dra’ma mim‘ik. See Gamrs. . DRAUGHT, draft (ddeSpdv, aphedrén; Mt 15 17; Mk 719): “Closet,” “sink” or “privy” (Rheims), lit. “place for sitting apart’? (cf 2 K 10 27, “draught-house,” and Mish “water-honse’”’). According to the Mish Jehu turned the temple of Baal in Samaria into public latrines, ‘‘water- houses.” Mk adds here (7 19) that by this saying Jesus cleansed all articles of food, i.e., declared them to be clean. DRAWER, dré’ér, OF WATER (279 NW, shd’ebh mayim, from ANW, shd’abh, “to bale up” water): In Syria and Pal, outside of Mt. Lebanon and the Anti-Lebanon, the springs of water are scarce and the inhabitants of these less favored places have always depended upon wells and cisterns for their water supply. This necessitates some device for drawing the water. In the case of a cistern or shallow well, an earthenware water jar or a bucket made of tanned goats’ skin is lowered into the water by a rope and then raised by pulling up the rope hand over hand (probably the ancient method), or by running the rope over a crude pulley fixed di- rectly over the cistern or well. In the case of deep wells, the rope, attached to a larger bucket, is run over a pulley so that the water may be raised by the drawers walking away from the well as they pull the rope. Frequently animals are hitched to the rope to do the pulling. Dream, Dreamer tHe INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dress 874 In some districts where the water level is not too deep, a flight of steps leading down to the water’s edge is constructed in addition to the opening ver- tically above the water. Such a well is pointed out near Haran in Mesopotamia as the one from which Rebekah drew water for Abraham’s servant. In Gen 24 16 we read that Rebekah “went down to the fountain, and filled her pitcher, and came up.” The deep grooves in their curbs, worn by the ropes as the water was being raised, attest to the antiquity of many of the wells of Pal and Syria. Any one of the hundreds of grooves around a single well was many years in being formed. The fact that the present method of drawing water from these wells is not making these grooves, shows that they are the work of former times. St. Mary’s Well at Nazareth. The drawing of water was considered the work of women or of men unfit for other service (Gen 24 11.13.43; 18 911; In 47). In Syria, today, a girl servant willingly goes to draw the daily supply of water, but seldom is it possible to persuade a boy or man to perform this service. When the well or fountain is at a distance, or much water is needed, tanned skins or earthen Jars are filled and trans- ported on the backs of men or donkeys. Water drawing was usually done at evening time (Gen 24 11), and this custom has remained un- changed. There is no sight more interesting than the daily concourse at a Syrian water source. It is bound to remind one of the Bible stories where the setting is a wellside (Gen 24; Jn 4). The service of water drawing was associated, in early times, with that of hewer of wood (Dt 29 11). Joshua made the Gibeonites hewers of wood and drawers of water in exchange for their lives (Josh 9 21.23.27). The inhabitants of Nineveh were exhorted to draw water and fill the cisterns of their fortresses in preparation for a siege (Nah 3 14). Figurative: Water drawing is mentioned in the metaphor of Isa 12 3, “Ye draw water out of the wells of salvation.” Jamies A. Patcu DREAM, drém, DREAMER, drém’ér (otbn ; hdlom, Don , hélem; dvap, 6nar): In all time dreams and their interpretation have been the occasion of much curious and speculative inquiry. Because of the mystery by which they have been enshrouded, and growing out of a natural curiosity to know the future, much significance has been attached to them by people esp. of the lower stages of culture. Even the cultured are not without a superstitious awe and dread of dreams, attaching to them different interpretations according to local color and custom. Naturally enough, as with all other normal and natural phenomena for which men could assign no scientific and rational explanation, they would be. looked upon with a certain degree of superstitious fear. “Dreams, Which are the children of an idle brain, Begot of nothing but vain fantasy, _ Which is as thin of substance as the air And more inconstant than the wind. —Shakespeare. While a fully satisfactory theory of dreams has not yet been established and while it is hardly pos- sible that there will ever be a satis- 1. Physio- factory explanation for each individual logical and dream, yet through the rapid discov- Psychologi- eries of physiological psychology in the cal Ground recent decade or more, much new light is thrown on the subject. With the contribution modern psychology has made to our knowledge of the association of ideas through the . connected relation of certain cortical centers and areas, it has come to be pretty well established that the excitation of certain bodily organs or surfaces will stimulate certain brain areas. Conversely the stimulation of certain cortical areas will produce a response in certain bodily regions over which these centers or areas preside. Connecting thought pro- cesses are therefore dependent upon the proper corre- lation of ideas through what are known physio- logically as the association centers. If then it comes to pass that, as occurs in dreams, only fragmentary ideas or loosely connected trains of thought occur, and if, as frequently happens, there is momentary connection, but little connection with normal waking experience, it will easily be seen that the excitation of certain centers will awaken certain trains of thought which are but poorly related to the balance of one’s thinking processes. Much is being said about the dissociation of ideas and the disturbance of personality of which dreams are one of several forms. Others are hallucinations, trances, visions, etc. Dreams are abnormal and sometimes patho- logical. Sleep isa normal experience. Perfect and natural sleep should be without dreams of any con- scious occurrence. Perhaps psychologically there can be no such thing as perfectly dreamless sleep. Such a condition would probably be death itself. Nature doubtless has her silent vigils, keeping watch in the chambers of the soul during the deepest sleep. The only difference is that they do not come to the threshold of consciousness. Thus, dreams are to the sleeping state what visions and hallucinations are to the waking state, and like them have their ground in a distorted image-making function. While thesource of the materials and the excitant may not be the same in each case, yet functionally they are the same. The stimuli of dreams may be of two kinds. First, they may be physical and objective, or they may be due to suggestions and the association of ideas. They may be due to some physica] disorder, such as imperfect digestion or circulation, improper ventilation or heating, or an uncomfortable position. Since by the very nature of the case dreams do not occur in a conscious state, the real cause cannot easily be discoverable and then only after the sub- ject 1s entirely awakencd through the effects of it. They may also be due to the association of ideas. Suggestion plays a large part. The vividness and recency of a conscious impression during the waking state may be thrown up from the subconscious region during the sleeping hours. The usual dis- torted aspect of dreams is doubtless due to the un- coupling of groups of ideas through the uncoupling of the cortical association areas, some of them being less susceptible than others to the existing stimulus. The materials of dreams need not be recent; they may have been furnished by the conscious pro- cesses a long time before, but are brought to the threshold only by means of some train of ideas dur- ing a semi-conscious state. It is interesting to note 875 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Bream, Dreamer that while time and space seem quite real in dreams, the amount covered in a single dream may occupy but a moment of time for the dreamer. Dreams have always played an important part in the lit. and religion of all peoples. They have furnished eoiielocre: they have 2. History been the sources of systems of necro- of Belief mancy; they have become both the in Dreams source and the explanation of other- wise inexplicable acts of Providence. Growing out of them we have a theory of night- mares and demonology. They have become the working material of the prophet both Bib. and pagan. Mediaeval civilization is not without its lasting effects of dreams, and modern civilization still clings with something of reverence to the unsolved mys- tery of certain dreams. While we have almost emerged from anything like a slavish adherence to a superstitious belief in dreams, we must still admit the possibility of the profound significance of dreams in the impressions they make upon the sub- ject. The Bible, contrary to a notion perhaps too commonly held, attaches relatively little religious significance to dreams. Occasionally, 3. Dreams however, reference is made to commu- inthe OT nications from God through dreams (Gen 206; 1K 35; Mt1 20; 2 12.13.19.22). It recognizes their human relations more frequently. In the OT lit. dreams play but little part except in the books of Gen and Dnl, in which there are abundant references to them. For their moral bearings the most important ones per- haps are those referred to in Gen 37 5-10. An uncritical attitude will give to them a lifeless and mechanical interpretation. A sympathetic and rational explanation gives them beauty, naturalness and significance. Joseph was the youngest and most beloved son of Jacob. He was just in the prime of adolescence, the very period of day dream- ing. He was perhaps inordinately ambitious. This was doubtless heightened by the attentions of a doting father. The most natural dream would be that suggested by his usual waking state, which was one of ambition and perhaps unhealthy rivalry (see Astronomy, II, 6). The source of Pharaoh’s dreams and his solicitude are likewise capable of interpretation on somewhat natural grounds (Gen 41 7-82). The significance of them was given by Joseph. i : Another illustration of the psychological exposi- tion preceding is the dream of Solomon (1 K 3 5. 11-15). In this narrative, after Solomon had done what pleased Jeh and had offered a most humble prayer on an occasion which to him was a great crisis and at the same time a moment of great ecstasy in his life, he doubtless experiences a feeling of sweet peace in consequence of it. His sleep would natur- ally be somewhat disturbed by the excitement of the day. The dream was suggested by the associ- ations and naturally enough was the approving voice of Jeh. Dreaming and the prophetic function seem to have been closely associated (Dt 13 1.3.5). _ Wheth- er from a coldly mechanical and superstitious, a miraculous, or a perfectly natural point of view, this relation is consistent. The prophet must be a seer, a man of visions and ideals. As such he would be subject, as in his waking states, so in his sleeping states, to extraordinary experiences. The remarkable dreams of Nebuchadnezzar, who stands out as an exceptional example, afford an illustra- tion of what. may be styled a disturbed personality (Dnl 2 3-45; 4 5-19). The effort made by the magicians, the enchanters, the Chaldaeans, and the soothsayers, according to the best skill of the Ori- entals, was unavailing. Daniel, whether by ex- traordinary intellectual insight or by Divine com- munication, was able by his interpretation and its moral to set before the king a powerful! lesson. The NT gives still less place and importance to dreams than the OT. There are only six references and one citation to dreams or dreamers. It is sig- nificant that all these references are by Mt, and still more significant that Jesus nowhere refers to dreams, evidently attaching little if any importance tothem. The references in Mt are confined entirely to warnings and announcements (Mt 1 20; 2 12. 13.19.22; 27 19). Once a citation (Acts 2 17) is used for illustrative purposes (cf Joel 2 28). See also Auacury, IV, 5; Divinamion, VI, 1, 1(6); Magic; REVELATION. Whether God communicates directly or indirectly by dreams is still unsettled. With our present knowledge of spirit communication it would not seem unreasonable to assume that He may reveal Himself directly; and yet on the other hand the safest and perhaps surest explanation for our own day and experience is that in dream states the mind is more impressionable and responsive to natural causes through which God speaks and operates. That dreams have been and are valuable means of shaping men’s thoughts and careers cannot be de- nied, and as such, have played an important part in the social and moral life of individuals and of society. A valuable modern illustration of this is the dream of Adoniram Judson Gordon (see How Christ Came to Church), through the influence of which his entire religious life and that of his church were completely transformed. Lrverature.—Judd, Psychology; Cutten, The Psy- chological Phenomena of Christianity; Ladd, Philosophy of Knowledge; Baldwin, Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology; Ellis, The World of Dreams (Houghton, Mifflin Co.). : Waiter G. CLIPPINGER DREDGE, drej: A mixture of oats and barley (Job 24 6 AVm; AV “corn”; RV ‘“provender”). The Heb word is Syba, bela, usually ‘“‘mixed grain,” ZDMG, XLVIII, 236: grain not ground and boiled in water. Cf Job 6 5; Isa 30 24. DREGS, dregs: The “sediments,” “lees,” “grounds of liquor’; only in pl. In AV it stands for: (1) Heb kubba‘ath, “bowl,” “chalice,” found only in Iga 61 17.22: ‘‘the dregs of the cup of trembling”; “the dregs of the cup of my fury.” RV correctly changes ‘dregs’ into “bowl.” (2) Heb sh’marim, “sediments” or “‘dregs,”’ esp. lees of wine. “The dregs thereof, all the wicked of the earth shall wring [ARV ‘‘drain’] them out and drink them” (Ps 76 8), ic. God gives to the wicked the cup of wrathful judgment, which they must drink to the last drop. DRESS: In the Heb and Gr there is a wonderful wealth of terminology having to do with the general subject of dress among the ancient Orientals. This is reflected in the numerous synonyms for ‘dress”’ to be found in EV, “apparel,” ‘‘attire,” ‘‘clothes,” “raiment,”’ “garments,” etc. But the words used in the originals are often greatly obscured through the inconsistent variations of the translators. Be- sides there are few indications even in the original Heb or Gr of the exact shape or specific materials of the various articles of dress named, and so their identification is made doubly difficult. In dealing with the subject, therefore, the most reliable sources of information, apart from the meaning of the terms used in characterization, are certain well-known facts about the costumes and dress-customs of the orthodox Jews, and others about the forms of dress worn today by the people of simple life and primi- tive habits in modern Pal. Thanks to the ultra- conservatism and unchanging usages of the nearer Dress THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 876 East, this is no mean help. In the endeavor to dis- cover, distinguish and deal with the various oriental garments, then, we will consider: 1. The Meaning A Native of Jericho. of Terms; 2. The Materials; 3. The Outer Gar- ments; 4. The Inner Garments; 5. The Headdress; 6. The Foot-gear;'7. The Dress of Jesus and His Disciples. There was originally a sharp distinction between classical and oriental costume, but this was palpably lessened under the cosmopolitanism 1. Meaning of the Rom Empire. This of course of Terms had its effect both in the modification of the fashions of the day and upon the words used for articles of clothing in the NT. (1) The terms most used for clothes in general were, in the OT, saédhin, simlah, salmah, and in the NT himdtion (Mt 21 7; 24 18; 26 65; Lk 8 27) and énduma (Mt 22 111; cf 7 15), ‘pl., though the oldest and most widely distributed article of hnman apparel was probably the “‘loin-cloth” (Heb ’ézar), entirely different from “girdle” (Gr z6né). Bib. references for clothes are nearly all to the costume of the males, owing doubtless to the fact that the garments ordinarily used indoors were worn alike by men and women. (2) The three normal body garments, the ones most mentioned in the Scriptures, are sddhin, a rather long ‘‘under garment”’ provided with sleeves; kethoneth (Gr chitén), a long-sleeved tunic worn over the sédhin, likewise a shirt with sleeves (see Master- man, DCG, art. “Dress’); and simlaéh (Gr hima- tion), the cloak of AV and RV, used in the pl. for “garments” in general; and the “girdle” (Gr zdné; Arab, zunnar). The “headdress’’ (two types are now in use, the “turban” and the “kufiyeh’’) is never definitely named in the Bible, though we know it was the universal custom among ancient Orientals to cover the head. (3) The simlah (Gr himation) signifies an ‘‘outer garment” (see below), a ‘‘mantle,” or “‘cloak’’ (see lexicons). A kindred word in the Gr himatismés, (tr? “raiment” in Lk 9 29, “garments” in Mt 27 35, and “‘vesture” in Jn 19 24) stands in antithesis tohimation. The Gr chiton, Heb k*thoneth, the “un- der garment,” is tr? “‘coat”’in Mt 5 40, “‘clothes’’ in Mk 14 63. The Heb word m*‘il, Gr stolé, Lat stola, stands for a variety of garment used only by men of rank or of the priestly order, rendered RV “robe.” It stands for the long garments of the scribes ren- dered “long robes” (Mk 12 38; Lk 20 46) and “best robe’ in the story of the Prodigal Son (Lk 15 22). (For difference between m*‘tl and simlah, see Kennedy, one-vol HDB, 197.) Oriental infiu- ences led to the adoption of the long tunic in Rome, and in Cicero’s time it was a mark of effeminacy. It came to be known in its white form as tunica alba, or ‘‘white tunic,” afterward in English “alb.” Other NT terms are wop¢ipar, porphiran, the “purple’ (Lk 16 19); the purple robe of Jesus is called himation in Jn 19 2; léntion, ‘‘the towel” with which Jesus girded himself (13 4.5); then othénion, “linen cloth’ (Lk 24 12; Jn 19 40); sindén, “linen cloth” (Mt 27 59); and bussos, “fine linen” (Lk 16 19). The primitive ‘‘aprons” of Gen 3 7, made of “sewed fig-leaves,”’ were quite different from the “aprons” brought to the apostles in Acts 19 12. The latter were of a species known among the Ro- mans as semicinctium, a short ‘‘waist-cloth” worn esp. by slaves (Rich, Dict. of Rom and Gr Antiq.). Anthropology, Scripture and archaeology all wit- ness to the use by primitive man of skins of animals as dress material (Gen 3 21, “coats of skin’; cf He 11 37, ‘“‘went about in sheepskins, in goatskins’’). Even today the traveler will occa- sionally see in Pal a shepherd clad in ‘a coat of skin.” Then, as now, goat’s hair and camel’s hair supplied the materials for the coarser fabrics of the poor. Jobn the Baptist had his raiment, enduma, of camel’s hair (lit. “of camel’s hairs,” Mt 3 4). This was a coarse cloth made by weaving camel’s hairs. There is no evidence that coats of camel’s skin, like those made of goat’s skin or sheep’s skin have ever been worn in the East, as imagined by 2. The Materials A Shepherd of Bethany (with Sheepskin Coat). painters (see Meyer, Bleek, Weiss and Broadus; but cf HDB, art. Camel”). The favorite materi- als, however, in Pal, as throughout the Orient, in ancient times, were wool (see Prov 27 26, “The lambs are for thy clothing’) and flaz (see Prov 31 877 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dress 18, where it is said of the ideal woman of King Lem- uel, “She seeketh wool and flax, and worketh will- ingly with her hands’’). The finest quality of an- cient “linen”? seems to have been the product of Egypt (see Linen). The “silk” of Prov 31 22 AV is really “fine linen,” as in RV. The first certain mention of “silk” in the Bible, it is now conceded, is in Rev 18 12, as the word rendered “silk” in Ezk 16 10.18 is of doubtful meaning. (1) We may well begin here with the familiar saying of Jesus for a basal distinction: “If any man would go to law with thee, and take 3. The away thy coat [Gr chitin), let him have Outer thy cloak [himation] also” (Mt 5 40). Garments Here the “coat” (Heb kihdneth) was the ordinary “inner garment’? worn by the Jew of the day, in which he did the work of the day (see Mt 24 18; Mk 13 16). It resem- bled the Roman ‘‘tunic,” corresponding most nearly to our “‘long shirt,” reaching below the knees always, and, in case it was designed for dress occasions, reaching almost to the ground. Sometimes “two coats’ were worn (Lk $ 11; cf Mt 10 10; Mk 6 9), but in general only one. It was this garment of Jesus that is said by John (19 23) to have been “without seam, woven from the top throughout.” (2) The word himation, here rendered ‘‘cloak,”’ de- notes the well-known ‘‘outer garment” of the Jews (see Mt 9 20.21; 14 36; 21 7.8; but cf also 9 16; 17 2; 24 18; 26 65; 27 31.35). It appears insome cases to have been a loose robe, but in most others, certainly, it was a large square piece of eloth, like a modern shawl, which could be wrapped around the person, with more or less taste and comfort. Now these two, with the “girdle” (a necessary and almost universal article of oriental dress), were commonly all the garments worn by the ordinary man of the Orient. The “outer garment’ was frequently used by the poor and by the traveler as his only covering at night, just as shawls are used among us now. (3) The common Heb name for this ‘‘outer gar- ment” in the OT is as above, simladh or salmah. In most cases it was of “wool,” though sometimes of “linen,” and was as a rule certainly the counterpart of the himation of the Gr (this is its name through- out the NT). It answered, too, to the pallzum of the Romans. It belonged, like them, not to the —_, ZA Fee een CY FOSS LLLP LLL ELLE, etihild SHS ams Painting at Beni Hassan. 1. Fringed Skirt; 2 and 3. Tunics. endiimaia, or garments “put on,” but to the peri- blémata, or garments ‘“‘wrapped around” the body. It wag concerning this ‘cloak’ that the Law of Moses provided that, if it were taken in pawn, it should be returned before sunset—‘for that is his only covering, it is his raiment for his skin: wherein shall he sleep? ... . for I am gracions” (Ex 22 27). The Jewish tribunals would naturally, there- fore, allow the “inner garment” to be taken by legal process, rather than the outer one (Mt 6 40; Lk 6 29); but Jesus virtually teaches that rather than have difficulty or indulge animosity one would better yield one’s rights in this, as in other matters; cf 1 Cor 6 7. Some identify the stmiah of the ancient Hebrews with modern aba, the coarse blouse or overcoat worn today by the Syrian peasant (Nowack, Ben- zinger, Mackie in HDB); but the distinction be- tween these two garments of the Jews, so clearly made in the NT, seems to confirm the conclusion otherwise reached, that this Jewish “outer garment” closely resembled, if it was not identical with, the himation of the Greeks (see Jew Enc, art. “Cloke” Woman's Headdress and Veil (Modern). and 1-vol HDB, “Dress,” 197; but cf Masterman, DCG, art. “Dress,’’ 499, and Dearmer, DCG, art. “Cloke’’). In no respect has the variety of render- ings in our EV done more to conceal from Eng. readers the meaning of the original than in the case of this word simlah. For instance it is the ‘“gar- ment’? with which Noah’s nakedness was covered (Gen 9 23); the “clothes” in which the Hebrews bound up their kneading-troughs (Ex 12 34); the “garment” of Gideon in Jgs 8 25; the ‘raiment’ of Ruth (3 3); just as the himation of the NT is the “cloak” of Mt 6 40, the “clothes” of Mt 24 18 AV (RV “cloak’’), the “garment” (Mk 13 16 AV, RV “cloak”). (1) In considering the under garments, contrary to the impression made by EV, we must begin with the “loin-cloth’” (Heb ’ézdr), which 4. The unlike the “girdle” (see GiRDLE), was Under always worn next to the skin. The Garments figurative use made of it in Isa 11 5, ‘ and Jer 13 11, e.g. will be lost unless this is remembered. Often it was the only “under- garment,” as with certain of the prophets (Elijah, 2K 18; cf John the Baptist, Mt 3 4; Isaiah, 20 2, and Jeremiah, 13 1 ff). In later times it was displaced among the Hebrews by the “shirt” or Dress Drink, Strong THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 878 “tunic”? (see Tunic). The universal “sign of mourning” was the girding of the waist with an *ez6r or “hair-cloth” (EV “sack-cloth”). A “loin- cloth” of “‘linen’’? was worn by the priests of early times and bore the special name of ’@phédh (1 8 2 18; cf 29 6 14 ff). (2) The ordinary “under garment,’ later worn by all classes—certain special occasions and indi- viduals being exceptions—was the ‘“‘shirt’? (Heb kethoneth) which, as we have seen, reappears as chiton in Gr, and tunica in Lat. It is uniformly rendered ‘‘coat” in EV, except that RVm has “tunic” in Jn 19 23. The well-known piece of Assyr sculpture, representing the siege and capture of Lachish by Sennacherib, shows the Jewish captives, male and female, dressed in a moderately tight gar- ment, fitting close to the neck (cf Job 30 18) and reaching almost to the ankles; which must repre- sent the k°thdneth, or kutt6neth of the period, as worn in towns at least. Probably the kutidneth of the peasantry was both looser and shorter, resembling more the modern kamis of the Syrian fellah (cf Lat camisa, and Eng. ‘‘chemise’’). (3) As regards sleeves, they are not expressly mentioned in the OT, but the Lachish tunics men- tioned above have short sleeves, reaching half-way to the elbows. This probably represents the pre- vailing type of sleeve among the Hebrews of the earlier period. An early Egyp picture of a group of Sem traders (c 2000 BC) shows a colored tunic without sleeves, which, fastened on the left shoulder, left the right bare. Another variety of sleeves, re- stricted to the upper and wealthy classes, had long and wide sleeves reaching to the ground. This was the tunic worn by Tamar, the royal princess (2 8 18 18, “A garment of divers colors upon her; for with such robes were the king’s daughters that were virgins apparelled’’), ‘‘the tunic of [i.e. reaching to] palms and soles” worn by Joseph, familiarly known as the ‘‘coat of many colors’ (Gen 37 3), a render- ing which represents now an abandoned tradition (cf Kennedy, HDB). The long white linen tunic, which was the chief garment of the ordinary Jewish priest of the later period, had sleeves, which, for special reasons, were tied to the arms (cf Jos, Ani, II, vii, 2). (4) Ultimately it became usual, even with the people of the lower ranks, to wear an under ‘‘tunic,” or “real shirt”’ (Jos, Ant, XVII, vi, 7; Mish, passim, where it is called halwk). In this case the upper tunic, the kuittoneth Proper, would be removed at night (cf Cant 5 3, “I have put off my garment”). The material for the tunic might be either (1) woven on the loom in two pieces, and afterward put together without cutting (cf Dict. of Rom and Gr Antigq., art. ““Tunica’’), or (2) the garment might be woven whole on a special loom, “without seam,” i.e. so as to require no sewing, as we know from the description given in Jn 19 23, and from other sources, was the chitén worn by Our Lord just be- fore His crucifixion. The garments intended by the Heb (Dnl 3 21-27), rendered “coats” AV, have not been certainly made out. The AVm has “mantles,’’ the ERV ‘“‘hosen,” ARV “breeches” (see Hosen). For “‘coat of mail” (1 S 17 5) see Armor. When the Hebrews first emerged into view, they seem to have had no covering for the head except on special demand, as in case of war, 5. The when a leather-helmet was worn (see Headdress Armor). Ordinarily, as with the fellah of Pal today, a rope or cord served as a fillet (cf 1 K 20 32, and Virgil, Aeneid [Dryden], iv.213: ‘‘A golden fillet binds his awful brows’’). Such “fillets” may be seen surviving in the representation of Syrians on the monuments of Egypt. Naturally, in the course of time, exposure to the Syrian sun in the tropical summer time would “wind round”). compel recourse to some such covering as the modern kufiyeh, which lets in the breeze, but protects in a graceful, easy way, the head, the neck and the shoulders. The head-gear of Ben-hadad’s tribute- carriers (see above) resembles the Phrygian cap. es | Modern Druse Headdress. The head covering, however, which is best at- tested, at least for the upper ranks of both sexes, is the turban (Heb ¢aniph, from a root meaning to It is the ladies’ “hood” of Isa 3 28, RV ‘‘turban”; the “royal diadem” of Isa 62 3, and the “mitre” of Zec 3 5, RVm “turban” or “diadem.” Ezekiel’s description of a lady’s head- dress: ‘I bound thee with attire of fine linen” (Ezk 16 10 m), points to a turban. For the egg-shaped turban of the priests see BonNET (RV “‘head-tires’’). The hats of Dn] 3 21 (RV “mantles’’) are thought by some to have been the conical Bab headdress seen on the monuments. According to 2 Macc 4 12 RV the young Jewish nobles were compelled by Antiochus Epiphanes to wear the pétasos, the low, broad-brimmed hat associated with Hermes. Other forms of headdress were in use in NT times, as we learn from the Mish, as well as from the NT, e.g. the suddar (covidpiov, souddrion) from Lat suda- rium (a cloth for wiping off perspiration, sudor) which is probably the “napkin” of Jn 11 44; 20 7, although there it appears as a kerchief, or covering, for the head. The female captives from Lachish (see above) wear over their tunics an upper garment, which covers the forehead and falls down over the shoulders to the ankles. Whether this is the gar- ment intended by the Heb in Ruth 3 15, rendered “vail” by AV and “mantle” by RV, and “kerchiefs for the head” (Ezk 13 18 RY), we cannot say. The ‘‘veil” with which Rebekah and Tamar ‘“‘cov- ered themselves” (Gen 24 65; 38 14) was most 879 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dress Drink, Strong likely a large “mantle” in which the whole body could be wrapped, like the sddhin (see above). But is seems impossible to draw a clear distinction be- tween “mantle” and “veil” in the OT (Kennedy). The case of Moses (Ex 34 33) gives us the only express mention of a ‘‘face-veil.” The ancient Hebrews, like Orientals in general, went barefoot within doors. Out of doors they usually wore sandals, less frequently 6. Footgear shoes. The simplest form of sandal then, as now, consisted of a sole of untanned Jeather, bound to the foot by a leather thong, the shoe-latchet of Gen 14 23 and the Sandals. latchet of Mk 1 7, etc. In the obelisk of Shal- manezer, however, Jehu’s attendants are distin- guished by shoes completely covering the feet, from the Assyrians, who are represented as wearing sandals fitted with a heel-cap. Ladies of Ezekiel’s day wore shoes of “sealskin” (Ezk 16 10 RY). The soldiers’ “laced boot”” may be intended in Isa 95 (RVm). Then, as now, on entering the house of a friend, or asacred precinct (Ex 3 5; Josh 6 15), or in case of mourning (2 8 15 30), the sandals, or shoes, were removed. The priests performed their offices in the Temple in bare feet (cf the modern re- quirement on entering a mosque). In general we may say that the clothes worn by Christ and His disciples were of the simplest and least sumptuous kinds. A special 7. The interest must attach even to the clothes Dress of that Jesus wore. These consisted, Jesusand it seems quite certain, not of just His five separate articles (see Edersheim, Disciples LTJM, I, 625), but of six. In His day it had become customary to wear a linen shirt (halk) beneath the tunic (see above). That Our Lord wore such a “shirt” seems clear from the mention of the laying aside of the upper gar- ments (himdlia, pl.), ie. the “mantle” and the “tunic,” before washing His disciples’ feet (Jn 13 4). The tunic proper worn by Him, as we have seen, was “woven without seam” throughout, and was of the kind, therefore, that fitted closely about the neck, and had short sleeves. Above the tunic would naturally be the linen girdle, wound several times about the waist. On His feet were leather sandals (Mt 3 11). His upper garment was of the customary sort and shape, probably of white woolen cloth, as is suggested by the details of the account of the Transfiguration (Mk 9 3), with the four pre- scribed “tassels” at the corners. dress, we have no description of it, but we may set it down as certain that no Jewish teacher of that day would appear in public with the head uncovered. He probably wore the customary white linen ‘‘nap- kin” (sudarium), wound round the head as a turban, As to His head-. with the ends of it falling down over the neck. The dress of His disciples was, probably, not materially different. In conclusion it may be said that, although the dress of even orthodox Jews today is as various as their lands of residence and their languages, yet there are two garments worn by them the world over, the tallith and the ’arba‘ kan*photh (see DCG, art. ‘“Dress,’”’ col. 1). Jews who affect special sanctity, esp. those living in the Holy Land, still wear the tallith all day, as was the common custom in Christ’s time. As the earliest mention of the ’arba‘ kan?photh is in 1350 AD, it is clear that it can- not have existed in NT times. Lirzrature.—Nowack’s and Benzlnger’s Heb Archd- ologie; Tristram, Eastern Customs in Bible Lands; Rich, Dict. of Rom and Gr Antig.; Edersheim, Life and_Times of Jesus the Messiah, 625, and elsewhere; arts. on “ Dress," “ Clothing,"' ‘'Costumes,"' etc, HDB, DCG, Jew Enc (by Néldeke) in EB (by Abrahams and Cook); Masterman, We pan persone! Adornment in Mod. Pal,’’ in Bib. World: 190zneu: Geo. B. Eaczr DRINK. See Foop; Drinx, Strona. ZDRINE OFFERING. See Sacririce In OT anp DRINK, STRONG ("3W, shékhdr; olxepo, si- kera; from "DW, shakhar, “to be or become drunk”; probenly from the same root as sugar, saccharine): ith the exception of Nu 28 7, “strong drink’ is always coupled with “wine.” The two terms are commonly used as mutually exclusive, and as to- gether exhaustive of all kinds of intoxicants. Originally shékhaér seems to have been a general term for intoxicating drinks of all kinds, without reference to the material out of which they were made; and in that sense, it would include wine. Reminiscences of this older usage may be found in Nu 28 7 (where shékhar is clearly equivalent to wine, as may beseen by comparing it wi ver 14, and with Ex 29 40, where the material of the drink offering is expressly designated ‘' wine’). When the Hebrews were living a nomadic life, before their settlement in Canaan, the grape-wine was practically unknown to them, and there would be no need of a special term to describe it. But when they settled down to an agricultural life, and came to cultivate the vine, it would become neces- sary to distinguish it from the older kinds of intoxi- cants; hence the borrowed word yayin (‘‘wine’’) was applied to the former, while the latter would be classed together under the old term shékhar, which would then come to mean all intoxicating beverages other than wine (Lev 10 9; Nu 6 3; Dt 14 26; Prov 20 1; Isa 24 9). The exact nature of these drinks is not clearly indicated in the Bible itself. The only fermented beverage other than grape-wine specifically named is pomegranate-wine (Cant 8 2: ‘the juice of my pomegranate,” RVm ‘‘sweet wine of my pomegranate’’); but we may infer that other kinds of shékhdar besides that obtained from pome- granates were in use, such as drinks made from dates, honey, raisins, barley, apples, etc. Probably Jerome (c 400 AD) was near the mark when he wrote, “Sikera in the Heb tongue means every kind of drink which can intoxicate, whether made from grain or from the juice of apples, or when honey- combs are boiled down into a sweet and strange drink, or the fruit of palm oppressed into liquor, and when water is coloured and thickened from boiled herbs” (Ep. ad Nepotianum). Thus shékhar is a comprehensive term for all kinds of fermented drinks, excluding wine. Probably the most common sort of shzkhdr used jn Bib. times was palm- or date-wine. This is not actual y mentioned in the Bible, and we do not meet with its He name yen temarim (‘‘wine of dates’’) until the Talmudic poriod: But it is frequently referred to in the Assyr- ab contract tablets (ouneiform), and from this and other evidence we infer that it was very well known among the anclent Sem peoples. Moreover, lt is known ° Dromedary Dualism THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 380 that the palm tree flourished abundantly in Bib. lands, and the presumption is therefore very strong that wine made of the juice of dates was a common beverage. It must not be supposed, however, that the term shékhar refers exclusively to date-wine. It rather designates all intoxicating liquors other than grape-wine, while in a few cases it probably includes even wine. There can be no doubt that shékhGr was intoxi- cating. This is proved (1) from the etymology of the word, it being derived from shakhar, ‘“‘to be or become drunk” (Gen 9 21; Isa 29 9; Jer 25 27, etc); cf the word for drunkard (shikkar), and for drunkenness (shikkaérén) from the same root; (2) from descriptions of its effects: e.g. Isaiah graphic- ally describes the stupefying effect of shékhar on those who drink it excessively (28 7.8). Hannah defended herself against the charge of being drunk by saying, “I have drunk neither wine nor strong drink,” i.e. neither wine nor any other intoxicating liquor (15 115). The attempt made to prove that it was simply the unfermented juice of certain fruits is quite without foundation. Its immoderate use is strongly condemned (Isa 5 11.12; Prov 20 1; see DrRUNKENNEsS). It was forbidden to min- istering priests (Lev 10 9), and to Nazirites (Nu 6 3; Jgs 13 4.7.14; cf Lk 1 15), but was used in the sacrificial meal as drink offering (Nu 28 7), and could be bought with the tithe-money and con- sumed by the worshipper in the temple (Dt 14 26). It is commended to the weak and perishing as a means of deadening their pain; but not to princes, lest it might lead them to pervert justice (Prov 31 4-7). D. Mtatt Enwarps DROMEDARY, drum’é-da-ri, drom’é-d4-ri. See CaMEL. DROP, DROPPING: “To drop” expresses a “distilling” or ‘‘dripping” of a fluid (Jgs 5 4; Prov 3 20; Cant 5 5.13; Joel 3 18; Am 9 13; cf158 14 26, ‘the boney dropped” [m “a stream of honey”]); Job 29 22 and Isa 45 8 read ‘‘distil” (AV “drop’). The continuous “droppings” of rain through a leaking roof (roofs were usually made of clay in Pal, and always liable to cracks and leak- age) on a “very rainy day” is compared to a con- tentious wife (Prov 19 13; 27 15); ‘What is de- scribed is the irritating, unceasing, sound of the fall, drop after drop, of water through the chinks in the roof” (Plumptre loc. cit.); cf also AV Eccl 10 18 (RV “leaketh”). DROPSY, drop’si (b5pwmuds, hudrdpikds, “a man afflicted with hudroéps or dropsy’”’): Both forms of this disease occur in Pal, that in which the limbs and body are distended with water called anasarca, depending generally on cardiac or renal disease, and the form confined to the abdomen, usually the result of liver affection. The latter is the com- moner, as liver disease is a frequent result of recur- rent attacks of malarial fever. The man was evi- dently able to move about, as he had entered into the Pharisee’s house (Lk 14 2). DROSS, dros (490 , sigh): The refuse of smelting of precious metal (Prov 25 4; 26 23); used fig- uratively of what is base or worthless (Isa 1 22.25; Ezk 22 18.19; Ps 119 119). DROUGHT, drout. DROVE, driv. DROWNING, droun’ing. Sec PuNnIsHMENTS. See Famine. See CaTrTLe. DRUM, drum (tipravov, tiimpanon): This was the Heb toph, ‘‘tabret” or ‘‘timbrel,” a hand-drum, consisting of a ring of wood or metal covered with a , tightly drawn skin, with small pieces of metal hung ‘to the evil of immoderate drinking. around the rim, like a tambourine. It was raised in the one hand and struck with the other, usually by women, but sometimes also by men, at festivities and on occasions of rejoicing. See 1 Macc 9 39, RV “timbrels.”’ _DRUNKENNESS, drunk’n-nes (“}), raweh, JDW, shikkardn, NW, shethi; pen, méth2): I. Its Prevalence.—The Bible affords ample proof that excessive drinking of intoxicants was a common vice among the Hebrews, as among other ancicnt peoples. This is evident not only from individual cases of intoxication, as Noah (Gen 9 21), Lot (Gen 19 33.35), Nabal (1 S 25 36), Uriah made drunk by David (2 5 11 13), Amnon (2 § 13 28), Elah, king of Israel (1 K 16 9), Benhadad, king of Syria, and his confederates (1 K 20 16), Holo- fernes (Jth 13 2), ete, but also from frequent ref- erences to drunkenness as a great socialevil. Thus, Amos proclaims judgment on the voluptuous and dissolute rulers of Samaria ‘‘that drink winein [large] bowls” (Am 6 6), and the wealthy ladies who press their husbands to join them in a carousal (4 1); he also complains that this form of self-indulgence was practised even at the expense of the poor and under the guise of religion, at the sacrificial meals (2 8; see also Isa 5 11.12.22; 28 1-8; 56 11f). Its prev- alence is also reflected in many passages in the NT (eg. Mt 24 49; Lk 21 34; Acts 2 13.15; Eph 5 18; 1 Thess 6 7). Paul complains that at Corinth even the love-feast of the Christian church which immediately preceded the celebration of the Eucharist, was sometimes the scene of excessive drinking (1 Cor 11 21). It must, however, be noted that it is almost invariably the well-to-do who are charged with this vice in the Bible. There is no evidence to prove that it prevailed to any considerable extent among the common people. Intoxicants were then an expensive luxury, be- yond the reach of the poorer classes. See Drinx, STRONG. I, Its Symptoms and Effects.—These are most vividly portrayed: (1) some of its physical symptoms (Job 12 5; Ps 107 27; Prov 23 29; Isa 19 14; 288; 299: Jer 25 16); (2) its mental effects: exhilaration (Gen 43 34), jollity and mirth (1 Esd 8 20), forgetfulness (1 Esd 3 20), loss of understanding and balance of judgment (Isa 28 7; Hos 4 11); (3) its effects on man’s happiness and prosperity: its immediate effect is to make one oblivious of his misery; but ultimately it ‘‘ biteth like a serpent, and stingeth like an adder,’’ and leads to woe and sorrow (Prov 23 29-32) and to poverty (Prov 28 21; cf 21 17; Ecclus 19 1); hence wine is called a ‘“‘mocker’’ deceiving the unwise (Prov 201); (4) its moral and spiritual effects: it leads to a maladministra- tion of justice (Prov 31.5; Isa 5 23), provokes anger and a contentious, brawling spirit (Prov 20 1; 23 29; 1 Esd 3 22; Ecclus 31 26.29 f), and conduces to a profli- gate life (Eph § 18; ‘riot,’ lit. profligacy). It is allied with gambling and licentiousness (Joel 3 3), and inde- cency (Gen 9 211). Above all, it deadens the spiritual sensibilities, produces a callous indifference to religious influences and destroys all serious thought (lsa 5 12). Ill, Attitude of the Bible to the Drink Question. —Intemperance is condemned in uncompromising terms by the OT and the NT, as well as by the semi-canonical writings. While total abstinence is not prescribed as a formal and universal rule, broad principles are laid down, esp. in the NT, which point in that direction. In the OT, intemperance is most repugnant to the stern ethical rigorism of the prophets, as well as to the more utilitarian sense of pro- 1. Inthe priety of the “wisdom” writers. As OT might be expected, the national con- science was but gradually quickened ( | of 1 ) In the narra- tives of primitive times, excessive indulgence, or at least indulgence to the point of exhilaration, is men- tioned without censure as a natural thing, esp. on festive occasions (as in Gen 43 34 RVm), But a 881 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dromedary Dualism conscience more sensitive to the sinfulness of over- indulgence was gradually developed, and is reflected in the denunciations of the prophets and the warn- ing of the wise men (cf references under J and II, esp. Isa 6 11f.22; 281-8; Prov 23 29-33). Nowhere is the principle of total abstinence incul- cated as a rule applicable to all. In particular cases it was recognized as a duty. Priests while on duty in the sanctuary were to abstain from wine and strong drink (Lev 10 9; cf Ezk 44 21). Nazirites were to abstain from all intoxicants during the period of their vows (Nu 6 3f; cf Amos 2 12), yet not on account of the intoxicating qualities of wine, but because they represented the simplicity of the older pastoral life, as against the Canaanite civilization which the vine symbolized (W.R. Smith, Prophets of Israel, 841). So also the Rechabites abstained from wine (Jer 35 6.8.14) and social con- veniences, because they regarded the nomadic life as more conducive to Jeh-worship than agricultural and town life, with its temptations to Baal-worship. In Daniel and his comrades we have another instance of voluntary abstinence (Dnl 1 8-16). These, how- ever, are isolated instances. Throughout the OT the use of wine appears as practically universal, and its value is recognized as a cheering beverage (Jgs 9 13; Ps 104 15; Prov 31 7), which enables the sick to forget their pains (Prov 31 6). Moder- ation, however, is strongly inculeated and there are frequent warnings against the temptation and perils of the cup. In Apoc, we have the attitude of prudence and common seuse, but the prophetic note of stern de- nunciation is wanting. The path of 2. Deutero- wisdom is the golden mean. ‘Wine and Extra- is as good as life to men, if thou drink Canonical it in its measure; ... . wine drunk Writings in season and to satisfy is joy of heart, and gladness of soul: wine drunk largely is bitterness of soul, with provocation and conflict?’ (Ecclus 31 27-30 RV). A vivid picture of the effects of wine-drinking is given in 1 Esd 3 18-24. Stronger teaching on the subject is given in the Testament of the Twelve Pctriarchs. The use of wine is permitted to him who can use it tem- perately, but abstinence is enjoined as the wiser course (XII P, Jud 16 3). In the NT, intemperance is treated as a gravesin. Only once, indeed, does Our Lord explicitly con- demn drunkenness (Lk 21 34), though it is implicitly condemned in other passages (Mt 24 49=Lk 12 45). The meagerness of the references in Our Lord’s teaching is probably due to the fact already mentioned, that it was chiefly prevalent among the wealthy, and not among the poorer classes to whom Our Lord mainly ministered. The references in Paul’s writings are very numerous (Gal 6 21; Eph 6 18, etal.). Temperance and sobriety in all things are everywhere insisted on (e.g. Acts 24 25; Gal 5 23; 2 Pet 16). A bishop and those holding honorable position in the church should not be addicted to wine (1 Tim 3 2f; Tit 1 7f; 2 2f). Yet Jesus and His apostles were not ascetics, and the NT gives no rough-and-ready prohibition of strong drink on principle. In contrast with John the Baptist, who was a Nazirite from birth (Lk 1 15), Jesus was called by His enemies a ‘‘wine-bibber”’ (Mt 11 19). He took part in festivities in which wine was drunk (Jn 2 10). There are indications that He regarded wine as a source of innocent en- joyment (Lk 5 38f; 17 8). To insist on a dis- tinction between intoxicating and unfermented wine is a case of unjustifiable special pleading. It noust be borne in mind that. the drink question is far more complex and acute in modern than in Bib. times, and that the conditions of the modern world 3. In the NT have given rise to problems which were not within the horizon of NT writers. The habit of excessive drinking has spread enormously among the common people, owing largely to the cheapening of alcoholic drinks. The fact that the evil exists today in greater proportions may call for a drastic remedy and a special crusade. But rather than defend total abstinence by a false or forced exegesis, it were better to admit that the principle is not formally laid down in the NT, while maintaining that there are broad principles enunciated, which in view of modern conditions should lead to voluntary ab- stinence from all intoxicants. Such principles may be found, e.g. in Our Lord’s teaching in Mt 16 24 f; Mk 9 42f, and in the great Pauline passages— Rom 14 13-21; 1 Cor 8 8-13. IV. Drunkenness in Metaphor.—Drunkenness very frequently supplies Bib. writers with striking metaphors and similes. Thus, it symbolizes intel- lectual or spiritual perplexity (Job 12 25; Isa 19 14; Jer 23 9), bewilderment and helplessness under calamity (Jer 13 13; Ezk 23 33). It furnishes a figure for the movements of sailors on board ship in a storm (Ps 107 27), and for the convulsions of the earth on the day of Jeh (Isa 24 20). Jeh’s “cup of staggering’ is a symbol of affliction, the fury of the Lord causing stupor and confusion (Isa 61 17-23; cf Isa 63 6; Jer 26 15 ff; Ezk 23 33; Ps 75 8). The sword and the arrow are said to be sodden with drink like a. drunkard with wine (Dt 32 42; Jer 46 10). In the Apocalypse, Babylon (i.e. Rome) is portrayed under the figure of a ‘‘great harlot”? who makes kings ‘‘drunken with the wine of her fornication’; and who is herself “drunken with the blood of the saints, and .. . . of the mar- tyrs of Jesus” (Rev 17 2.6). D. Miatt Epwarps DRUSILLA, droo-sil’a (ApotovddAa, Drotisilia, or ApovothAa, Drousilia): Wife of Felix, a Jewess, who along with her husband “heard [Paul] concerning the faith in Christ Jesus’ during Paul’s deten- tion in Caesarea (Acts 24 24). B text gives the rendering ‘Drusilla the wife of Felix, a Jewess, asked to see Paul and to hear the word.” The fact that Drusilla was a Jewess explains her curiosity, but Paul, who was probably acquainted with the past history of her and Felix, refused to satisfy their request in the way they desired, and preached to them instead concerning righteousness and self- restraint and the final judgment. At this ‘Felix was terrified” (Acts 24 25). 6 text states that Paul’s being left in bonds on the retirement of Felix was due to the desire of the latter to please Drusilla (cf Acts 24 27). Probably this explanation, besides that of the accepted text, was true also, as Drusilla, who was a member of the ruling house, saw in Paul an enemy of its power, and hated him for his con- demnation of her own private sins. The chief other source of information regarding Drusilla is Jos. Drusilla was the youngest of the three daughters of Agrippa I, her sisters being Ber- nice and Mariamne. She was born about 36 AD and was married when 14 years old to Azizus, king of Emeza. Shortly afterward she was induced to desert her husband by Felix, who employed a Cyprian sorcerer, Simon by name, to carry out his purpose. She was also influenced to take this step by the cruelty of Azizus and the hatred of Bernice who was jealous of her beauty. Her marriage with Felix took place about 54 AD and by him she had one son, Agrippa, who perished under Titus in an eruption of Mt. Vesuvius. The mention by Jos of “the woman’ who perished along with Agrippa (Ant, XX, vii, 2) refers probably not to his mother Drusilla but to his wife. C. M. Kerr DUALISM, di’al-iz’m. See PHrtosopHy. Due Dye, Dyeing THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 882 DUE, di. See Dury. DUKE, dtk: The rendering in AV in Gen 36 15 ff; Ex 15 15, and 1 Ch 1 51 ff of B58, ’al- luph (ARV and ERVm “chief’’), and in Josh 13 21 of n*sikhim (‘‘dukes,” RV ‘“‘princes”’). It occurs also, as the rendering of stratégés,in 1 Macc 10 65 (RV “captain’”’). Elsewhere n‘stkhim is tr? ‘princes’ or “principal men.” ‘The fact that with two exceptions the term is applied in EV only to the chiefs of Edom has led to the impression that in the family of Esau the chiefs bore a special and hereditary title. But *allaiph was a general term for tribal chief or prince (cf Zee 9 7; 12 5.6; RV “chieftains,” AV “govern- ors’’). _ Moreover, at the time the AV was made the word “duke"’ was not used as a title in England: the term had the same general force as duzx, the word employed in the Vulg. So Sir T. Elyot (d. 1546) speaks of ‘‘ Hannibal, duke of Carthage” (The Governour, II, 233); Shakespeare, Henry V, III, 2, 20, *‘ Be merciful, great duke, to men of mould”’ (cl Midsummer Night's Dream, I, 1, 21); Sylvester (1591) Du Barias, ‘‘The great Duke, that (in dreadful aw) | Upon Mt. Horeb learn'd th’ eternall law."’ In a still earlier age Wiclif uses the word of the Messiah (Mt 2 6); and in Select Works, III, 137, ‘‘ Jesus Christ, duke of oure hatel.”’ Yet in all probability the Heb word was more specific than “chief” or ‘duke’ in the broad sense. For if ’alléph is derived from ’eleph, ‘‘thousand,” “tribe,’”’ the term would mean the leader of a clan, a “chiliarch” (cf LXX, Zec 9 7; 12 5.6). ARV has eliminated the word ‘‘duke.” See Cur=r. J. R. Van Pevr DULCIMER, dul’si-mér. See Music under Neb- hel and Sumphonia. DUMAH, di’ma (WAT, damah, “‘silence”): This word occurs in the OT with the following significa- tions: (1) the land of silence or death, the grave (Ps 94 17; 115 17); (2) a town in the highlands of Judah between Hebron and Beersheba, now ed- Daume (Josh 15 52); (3) an emblematical designa- tion of Edom in the obscure oracle (Isa 21 11.12); (4) an Ishmaelite tribe in Arabia (Gen 25 14; 1 Ch 1 30). According to the Arab. geographies this son of Ishmael founded the town of Dimat-el- Jandal, the stone-built Ditmah, so called to distin- guish it from another D. near the Euphrates. The former now bears the name of the Jauf (“‘belly’’), being a depression situated half-way between the head of the Persian Gulf and the head of the gulf of Akaba. Its people in the time of Mohammed were Christians of the tribe of Kelb. It contained a great well from which the palms and crops were irrigated. It has often been visited by European travelers in recent times. See Jour. Royal Geog. Soc., XXIV (1854), 188-58; W. G. Palgrave, Cen- tral and Eastern Arabia, ch ii. It is possible that the oracle in Isa (no. 3 above) concerns this place. ‘ Tuomas Hunter WEIR DUMB, dum (08, alam, ODN, “illam, lit. “tied in the tongue’; kwdds, kdphés): Used either as expressing the physical condition of speechlessness, generally associated with deafness, or figuratively as meaning the silence produced by the weight of God’e judgments (Ps 39 2-9; Dnl 10 15) or the oppression of external calamity (Ps 38 13). . As an adj. it is used to characterize inefficient teachers destitute of spirituality (“dumb dogs,” Isa 56 10). The speechlessness of Saul’s companions (Acts 9 7) was due to fright; that of the man without the wedding garment was because he had no excuse to give (Mt 22 12). Idols are called dumb, because helpless and voiceless (Hab 2 18.19; 1 Cor 12 2). The dumbness of the sheep before the shearer is a token of submission (Isa 58 7; Acts 8 32). Temporary dumbness was inflicted as a sign upon Ezekiel (8 26; 24 27; 33 22) and as a punishment for unbelief upon Zacharias (Lk 1 22). There are several cases recorded of Our Lord’s healing the dumb (Mt 15 30; Mk 7 37; Lk 11 14, etc). Dumb- ness is often associated with imbecility and was therefore regarded as due to demoniac possession (Mt 9 32; 12 22). The evangelists therefore de- scribe the healing of these as effected by the cast- ing out of demons. This is esp. noted in the case of the epileptic boy (Mk 9 17). The deaf man with the impediment in his speech (Mk 7 32) is said to have been cured by loosening the string of his tongue. This does not necessarily mean that he was tongue-tied, which is a condition causing lisping, not stammering; he was probably one of those deaf persons who produce babbling, incoherent and meaningless sounds. I saw in the asylum in Jerus a child born blind and deaf, who though dumb, produced inarticulate noises. In an old 14th-cent. psalter “dumb” is used as a vb. in Ps 39: ‘‘I doumbed and meked and was ful stille.” ALEX. MacatisTER DUNG, dung, DUNG GATE (MSDN, ’ashpath, TO, domen, WD, peresh; cxbParov, skiibalon, etc): Nine different words occurring in the Heb have been tr? “dung” in the OT. The word used to designate one of the gates of Jerus (‘ashpdth, Neh 2 13; 8 14) is more general than the others and may mean any kind of refuse. The gate was probably so named because ontside it was the general dump heap of the city. Visitors in recent years riding outside the city walls of Jerus, on their way to the Mt. of Olives or Jericho, may have witnessed such a dump against the wall, which has existed for generations. The first mention made of dung is in connection with sacrificial rites. The sacred law required that the dung, along with what parts of the animal were not burned on the altar, should be burned outside the camp (Ex 29 14; Lev 4 11; 8 17; 16 27; Nu 19 5). The fertilizing value of dung was appreciated by . the cultivator, as is indicated by Lk 18 8 and possi- bly Ps 83 10 and Isa 25 10. Dung was also used as a fuel. Ezk 4 12.15 will be understood when it is known that the dung of animals is a common fuel throughout Pal and Syria, where other fuel is scarce. During the summer, villagers gather the manure of their cattle, horses or camels, mix it with straw, make it into cakes and dry it for use as fuel for cooking, esp. in the winter when wood or charcoal or straw are not procurable. It burns slowly like peat and meets the needs of the kitchen. In Mesopotamia the writer saw it heing used with forced draft to fire a steam boiler. There was no idea of uncleanuess.in Ezekiel’s mind, as- rae with the use of animal dung as fuel (Ezk 15). Figuratively: Dung was frequently used figur- atively to express the idea (a) of worthlessness, esp. a perishable article for which no one cares (1 K 14 10; 2 K 6 25; 9 37; Job 20 7; Ps 88 10; Jer 8 2; 922; 164; 25 33: Zeph 117; Phil 3 8 [ARV “‘tefuse”]). Dunghill was used in the same way (18 28; Ezr 6 11; Ps 118 7; Isa 25 10; Dnl 2 5; 3 29; Lk 14 35; Lam 4 5); (6) as an expression of disgust (2 K 18 27; Isa 36 12); () of rebuke (Mal 2 3). JAMES A. PatcH DUNGEON, dun’jun. See Prison. DUNGHILL, dung’hil (NEW, ’ashpoth, 1 8 2 8, MATA, madhménah, etc, with other words; kowpta, kopria, Lk 14 35): Dung heap, or place of refuse. To sit upon a dunghill (1 S 2 8; Ps 113 7; Lam 4 5) is significant of the lowest aud most wretched condition. To turn a house into a dunghill (Dnl 883 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Due Dye, Dyeing 2 5; 3 29), or be flung upon a dunghill (Lk 14 35), marks the extreme of ignominy. Sce also Duna. DURA, di’'ra (N51, dura’): The name of the plain on which Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, set up the great golden image which all his subjects were ordered to worship (Dnl 3 1). Oppert placed it to the S.E. of Babylon, near a small river and mounds bearing the name of Douair or Daéair, where, also, was what seemed to be the base of a great statue (Hxpéd. scientifique en Mésopotamie, I, 238 f). Others have believed that name to indicate a portion of the actual site of Babylon within the great wall (d@ru) of the city—perhaps the rampart desig- nated dar Su-anna, “the rampart [of the city] Lofty-defense,” a name of Babylon. The fact that the plain was within the city of Babylon precludes an identification with the city Déru, which seems to have lain in the neighborhood of Erech (Hommel, Grundriss, 264, n. 5). It is noteworthy that the LXX substitutes Aceipd, Deeird, for Dura, suggest- ing that the Gr translators identified it with the Bab Déru, a city which apparently lay toward the Elamite border. It seems to have been called also Dér-ili, “god’s rampart.” That it was at some dis- tance is supported by the list WAJ, IV, 36 [88], where Déru, Tutul and Gudua (Cuthah), intervene between Déru or Dér-ili and Tindir (Babylon). “The plain of the dér” or “rampart” within Baby- lon would therefore seem to be the best rendering. T. G. Pincues DURE, dir (apéoKaipos, préskairos): Used for “endure” (q.v.), AV Mt 13 21 (RV “endureth’’). DUST, dust ((2Y, ‘phar; Kovoprés, koniortés, ots, chotis): Small particles of earth. The word has several figurative and symbolic meanings: (1) Dust being the material out of which God is said to have formed man (Gen 2 7), it became a symbol of man’s frailty (Ps 103 14, “For he knoweth our frame; he remembereth that we are dust”; cf Gen 18 27; Job 4 19, etc), and of his mortality (Gen 3 19, ‘Dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return’; cf Job 34 15; Ps 104 29; Ecel 3 20; 12 7, etc) Hence it is used figuratively for the grave (Ps 22 15.29; 30 9; Dnl 12 2). (2) Such actions as to lie in the dust, to lick the dust, to sprinkle dust on the head, are symbols expressive of deep humiliation, abasement or lamentation (e.g. Job 2 12; 42 6, Ps 72 9; Isa 2 10; 47 1; 49 23; Lam 210; 3 29; Ezk 27 30; Mic 7 17; Rev 18 19). Hence such expressions as ‘‘He raiseth up the poor out of the dust,” i.e. out of their state of lowliness (1828; Ps 113 7). (3) Throwing dust was an act expressive of execration. Thus Shimei “cursed” David and “threw stones at him, and cast dust,” lit. “dusted [him] with dust” (2 § 16 13). So the crowd which Paul addressed at Jerus manifested their wrath against him by tossing about their gar- ments and casting dust into the air (Acts 22 23). (4) Shaking the dust off one’s feet against anyone (Mt 10 14; Mk 6 11; Lk 95; 1011; Acts 13 51) is symbolic of renunciation, as we would say “washing one’s hands of him,” an intimation that all further intercourse was at anend. It was prac- tised by the Pharisees on passing from gentile to Jewish soil, it being a rabbinical doctrine that the dust of a heathen land defiles. (5) It is also used fig. for an innumerable multitude (e.g. Gen 13 16; 28 14; Job 27 16; Ps 78 27). (6) The expression “Jeh will make the rain of thy land powder and dust’” (Dt 28 24) means the dust in consequence of the drought shall fall down instead of rain on the dry ground. In Judaea and vicinity during a sirocco, the air becomes filled with sand and dust, which are blown down by the wind with great vio- lence. D. Mrati Epwarps DUTY, di’ti (UBT, dabhar; opera, ophetia): The word d. occurs only three times in the OT and twice in the NT. In the OT it is the tr of dabhar, which, meaning originally “speech,” or ‘‘word,” came to denote any particular “matter” that had to be attended to. In the two places where it is rendered “duty” (2 Ch 8 14; Ezr 3 4) the refer- ence is to the performance of the Temple services— praise and sacrifice—and it is probably from these passages that the phrase “taking duty” in church services is derived. In other passages we have different words employed to denote the priests’ dues: AV Lev 10 13.14, hék (‘statutory portion’); Dt 18 3, mishpat (“judgment”). In Prov 3 27, we have a reference to d. in the moral sense, ‘‘With- hold not good from them to whom it is due,” ba‘al (i.e. asin AVm, “from the owners thereof”). In Ex 21 10 we have the “duty of marriage” (‘dnah), that which was due to the wife. In the NT “duty”. is expressed by opheild, “to owe,” “to be due.” In Lk 17 10, we have “Say, . -..» we have done that which it was our duty to do,” and in Rom 165 27 AV, it is said of the Gen- tiles with reference to the Jewish Christians, “Their duty is also to minister unto them in carnal things,” ARV “they oweit.”” In Mt 18 34 we have “‘till he should pay all that was due” (opheild, owing”), and in 1 Cor 7 3 AV, “Render unto the wife due [ophetlé] benevolence,” ARV ‘“‘her due.” See also - Eraics. W. L. Waker DWARF, dwérf: The rendering in EV of Heb P12, dak, “thin,” “small,” in Lev 21 20, where a list is given of physical failings which forbade a man of the seed of Aaron to officiate at the altar, though he might partake of the sacrificial gifts. The precise meaning of the Heb word here is uncertain; elsewhere it is used of the lean kine (Gen 41 3) and blasted ears (ver 23) of Pharaoh’s dream; of the grains of manna (Ex 16 14), of the still, small voice (1 K 19 12), of dust (Isa 29 5), etc. LXX and Vulg suggest defective eyes; but ‘‘withered” would perhaps best express the meaning. See Prizsts AND LEvITEs. F. K. Farr DWELL, dwel: (1) In the OT ‘‘dwell’’ tr? 9 words, of which by far the most frequent is 2W?, yadshabh, “‘to sit down,” tr? “dwell” over 400 times (Gen 4 20; Josh 20 4; 1 Ch 17 1.4.5, etc); also very frequently “sit, 3 and sometimes “abide,” “inhabit,” ‘remain.” Another word often rendered ‘dwell” is J2W or J2U, shdkhan or shdkhén (‘to settle down’’), from which is derived the rabbinic word 1)", shekhinah (lit. “that which dwells’), the light on the mercy- seat which symbolized the Divine presence (Ex 25 8, etc). In order to avoid appearing to localize the Divine Being, wherever God is said to ‘‘dwell” in a place, the Tg renders that He ‘‘causes His She- kinah to dwell” there. (2) In the NT ‘dwell’ most frequently stands for olxéw, otkéd, or one of its compounds; also oxyvéw, skén66, and (chiefly in the Johannine writ- ings) wévw, ménd, which, however, is always tr “abide” in RV, and generally in AV. Mention may be made of the mystical significance of the word in some NT passages, of the mdwelling of the Father or of the Godhead in Christ (Jn 14 10; Col 1 19; 2 9), of the believer in Christ (Jn 6 56 AV; Eph 3 17), and in God (1 Jn 4 15 AV; cf Ps 90 1; 91 1), and of the Holy Spirit or God in the believer (Jn 14 17; AV1 Jn 3 24; 4 15f). D. Miatt Epwarps DYE, di, DYEING, di/ing (DUN, m’oddam, YI, hamag, SAY, ebhal, VAX, cebha‘): Four different Heb words have been tr4 “dyed’’: AV (a) Dye, Dyeing Eagle THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 884 m°oddaém, found in Ex 25 5; 26 14; 35 7; 36 19; 39 34; (6) hamiacg (RVm “‘crimsoned”’) (Isa 63 1); (c) tbhal (Ezk 23 15). Tebhal is probably more correctly rendered ‘‘flowing turban”’ as in the RV of the above vs (BDB); (d) cebha‘, ‘‘dyed” is so tr? in ARV of Jgs 5 30 (BDB); cf Arab. sabagh. The above references and other color words mentioned elsewhere (see CoLor) indicate that the Israelites were acquainted with dyed stuffs, even if they them- selves did not do the dyeing. An analysis of the various Bib. references shows but four colors which were produced on cloth by dyeing, namely, purple, blue (violet), crimson and scarlet. Of these, purple is the one best known because of the many historical references to it. It was the symbol of royalty and luxury. Because of its high price, due to the ex- pensive method of obtaining it, only royalty and the rich could afford purple attire. One writer tells us that the dyestuff was worth its weight in silver. Probably it was because of its scarcity, and because it was one of the very limited number of dyes known, rather than for any remarkable beauty of color, that the purple was so much sought after. If Pliny’s estimate is to be accredited, then “in the dye the smell of it was offensive and the color itself was harsh, of a greenish hue and strongly resembling that of the sea when in a tempestuous state.” The purple and blue dyes were extracted from shellfish. The exact process used by the ancients is still a question in spite of the attempts 1. Purple of early writers to describe it. Tyre and Blue and Sidon were noted as the suppliers of these colors, hence the name ‘‘Tyrian purple.” The inhabitants of these cities were at first simply dealers in the purple (Ezk 27 7.24), but they afterward became the manufacturers, as the heaps of the emptied shells of the Murex trun- culus, which still exist in the vicinity of these cities, testify. The pigment was secreted by a gland in the lining of the stomach. The shell was punctured and the fish removed in order to secure the dye. The juice, at first whitish, changed on exposure to yellowish or greenish and finally to red, amethyst or purple, according to the treatment. A modified color was obtained by first dipping the textile in a cochineal bath and then in the purple. Tyrian purple was considered most valuable when it was “exactly the color of clotted blood and of a blackish hue” (Pliny). See also Lyp1a; Tuyatira. Besides the shellfish above mentioned, several other species are noted by different writers, namely, Murex branderis, Murex ertnaceus, Murex buceinum (pur- pura haemastoma). This latter species is still used by the dwellers on the shores where it is found. Various species of the murex are found today at Haifa (Syria), about the Gr isles and on the N. coast of Africa. The purple color has been pro- duced from them by modern chemists, but it is of historical interest only, in the light of the discovery of modern artificial dyes with which it could not compete commercially. Two words have been used in the Heb Bible to describe the colors from shellfish: (a) ‘argéman (Gr porphira). This has been tr? “purple”; (6) tekhéleth which was probably a shade of violet, but has been tr? “blue” in both AV and RV. As indicated elsewhere (see Co.ors), three Heb words have been rendered crimson or scarlet: (a) karmil (cf Arab. kirmiz and Eng. ‘“car- 2. Crimson mine”), (b) téla’, and (c) shani. and Scarlet know nothing further about the method of producing these colors than that they were both obtained from the kermes in- sect which feeds on a species of live oak growing in Southern Europe and Turkey in Asia. The modern dyer can obtain several shades from the cochincal insect by varying the mordants or assistants used with the dye. Pliny mentions the same fact as being known by the ancient Egyptians. Some of the Syrian dyers still use the kermes, commonly called déd (““worms’’), although most of them have resorted to the artificial European dyes which they indiscriminately call ddd frangy (‘foreign worms’’). The “rams’ skins dyed red”’ mentioned in Ex 25 are still made in Syria. After the ram’s skin has been tanned in sumac, it islaid out on a table and a solution of the dye, made by boiling déd in water, is rubbed on. After the dye is dry, the skin is rubbed with oil and finally polished. No native product is more characteristic of the country than the slippers, Beduin shoes, and other leather articles made from “rams’ skins dyed red” (see TANNER). Other dyes probably known were: (1) Madder—In Jgs 10 1, we read that “after Abimelech there arose to save Israel Tola the son of Puah.”’ These were probably names 3. Other of clans. In the Heb they are also Dyes Prob- color words. Tala‘ is the scarlet dye ably Known and pw’ah, if, as is probable, it is the same as the Arab. fawah, means “madder.” This would add another dyestuff. Until the discovery of alizarin, which is artificial madder, the growing of fwah was one of the indus- tries of Cyprus and Syria. It was exported to Europe and was also used locally for producing “Turkey red” on cotton and for dyeing dull reds on wools for rug making (see TuyaTrra). It was the custom near Damascus for a father to plant a new madder field for each son that was born. The field began to yield in time to support the boy and later become his inheritance. Madder is mentioned in the Talm and by early Lat writers. A Saracenic helmet and a shield of similar origin, in the posses- sion of the writer, are lined with madder-dyed cotton. (2) Indigo—Another dye has been discovered among the Egyp mummy cloths, namely, indigo. Indigo blue was used in weaving to form the borders of the cloths. This pigment was probably imported from India. (8) Yellows and browns of doubtful origin have also been found in the Egyp tombs. The Jews acquired from the Phoenicians the secret of dyeing, and later held the monopoly in this trade in some districts. A Jewish guild of purple dyers is mentioned on a tombstone in Hieropolis. In the 12th cent. AD Jews were still dyers and glass work- ers at Tyre. Akhissar, a Jewish stronghold in Asia Minor, was famous as a dyeing city. See also ArtirE, DyEp. LireraturRE.—See ‘' Crafts’’ esp. in Wilkinson, Perrot and Chipiez, Jew Enc, and HDB. James A. Parc DYSENTERY, dis’en-ter-i (Svoevtepla, dusen- teria): In Acts 28 8 RV uses this word in place of the phrase ‘‘bloody flux’ of AV to describe the dis~ ease by which the father of Publius was affected in Malta at the time of St. Paul’s shipwreck. The acute form of this disease is often attended with a high temperature, hence Luke speaks of it as ‘fever and dysentery” (puretois kat dusenterta). The dis- ease is still occasionally epidemic in Malta where there have been several bad outbreaks among the garrison in the last cent., and it has proved to be an intractable and fatal disease there. [t is due toa parasitic microbe, the Bacillus dysenteriae. In 2 Ch 21 19 there is reference to an epidemic of a similar nature in the days of Jehoram. The malady, as predicted by Elisha, attacked the king and assumed a chronic form in the course of which portions of the intestine sloughed. This condition sometimes occura in the amoebic form of dysentery, cases of which sometimes last over two years. 5 ALEX. MAcALIsTER 885 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Dye, Dyeing Eagle EAGLE, @’g’1 ("W}, nesher; detés, aelés; Lat aquila): A bird of the genus aquila of the family falconidae. The Heb nesher, meaning ‘‘to tear with the beak,”’ is almost invariably tr¢ “eagle,” through- out the Bible; yet many of the most important references compel the admission that the bird to which they applied was a vulture. There were many large birds and carrion eaters flocking over Pal, attracted by the offal from animals slaugh- tered for tribal feasts and continuous sacrifice. The eagle family could not be separated from the vul- tures by their habit of feeding, for they ate the offal Short-toed Eagle (Circaétus gallicua). from slaughter as well as the vultures. One dis- tinction always holds good. Eagles never flock. They select the tallest trees of the forest, the top- most crag of the mountain, and pairs live in soli- tude, hunting and feeding singly, whenever possible carrying their prey to the nest so that the young may gain strength and experience by tearing at it and feeding themselves. The vultures are friendly, and collect. and feed in flocks. So where- ever it is recorded that a “flock came down on a carcase,”’ there may have been an eagle or two in it, but the body of it were vultures. Because they came in such close contact with birds of prey, the natives came nearer dividing them into families than any birds. Of perhaps a half-dozen, they recognized three eagles, they knew three vultures, four or five falcons, and several kites; but almost every Bib. reference is tr? ‘eagle,’ no matter how evident the text makes it that the bird was a vulture. For example, Mic 1 16: “Make thee bald, and cut off thy hair for the children of thy delight: enlarge thy baldness as the eagle[m “‘vulture”]; for they are gone into captivity from thee.” This is a reference to the custom of shaving the head when in mourn- ing, but as Pal knew no bald eagle, the text could refer only to the bare head and neck of the griffon vulture. The eagles were, when hunger-driven, birds of prey; the vultures, carrion feeders only. There was a golden eagle (the osprey of AV), not E very common, distinguished by its tan-colored head; the imperial eagle, more numcrous and easily iden- tified by a dark head and white shoulders; a spotted eagle; a tawny eagle, much more common and readily distinguished by its plumage; and the short- toed eagle, most common of all and especially a bird of prey, as also a small hooded eagle so similar to a vulture that it was easily mistaken for one, save that it was very bold about taking its own food. The first Bib. reference to the eagle referred to the right bird. Ex 19 4: “Ye have seen what I did unto the Egyptians, and how I bare you on eagles’ wings, and brought you unto myself.” This “bare you on eagles’ wings” must not be interpreted to mean that an eagle ever carried anything on its back. It merely means that by strength of power- ful wing it could carry quite a load with its feet and frequently was seen doing this. Vultures never carried anything; they feasted and regurgitated what they had eaten to their young. The second reference is found in Lev 11 13 and repeated in Dt 14 12, the lists of abominations. It would seem peculiar that Moses would find it necessary to include eagles in this list until it ig known that Arab mountaineers were eating these birds at that time. The next falls in Dt 28 49: “Jeh will bring a nation against thee from far, from the end of the earth, as the eagle flieth; a nation whose tongue thou shalt not understand.” This also refers to the true eagle and points out that its power of sus- tained flight, and the speed it could attain when hastening to its hunger-clamoring young, had been observed. The next reference is in Dt 32 11: “As an eagle that stirreth up her nest, That fluttereth over her young, He spread abroad his wings, he took them, He bare them on his pinions.” This is good natural history at last. Former VSS made these lines read as if the eagle carried its young on its wings, a thing wholly incompatible with flight in any bird. Samuel’s record of the lamentation of David over Saul and Jonathan is a wonderful poetic outburst and contains reference to this homing flight of the eagle 2 S 1 23). In Job 9 26 the arrow-like downward plunge of the hunger-driven eagle is used in comparison with the flight of time. In Job 39, which contains more good natural history than any other chapter of the Bible, will be found everything concerning the eagle anyone need know: “Isit at thy command that the eagle mounteth up, And maketh her nest on high ? On the cliff she dwelleth, and maketh her home, Upon the point of the cliff, and the stronghold. From thence she spieth out the prey; Her eyes behold it afar off. Her young ones also suck up blood: And where the slain are, there is she" (vs 27-30). Ps 103 5 is a reference to the long life of the eagle. The bird has been known to live to an astonishing age in captivity; under natural conditions, the age it attains can only be guessed. “Who satisfleth thy desire with good things, So that thy youth is renewed like the eagle.” Prov 23 5 compares the flight of wealth with that of an eagle; 30 17 touches on the fact that the eye of prey is the first place attacked in eating, prob- ably because it is the most vulnerable point and so is frequently fed to the young. Ver 19: “The way of an eagle in the air; The way of a serpent upon a rock; The way of a ship in the midst of the sea; And the way of a man with a maiden.” Eanes Earthly THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 886 This reference to the eagle is to that wonderful power of flight that enables a bird to hang as if frozen in the sky, for long periods appearing to our sight immovable, or to sail and soar directly into the eye of the sun, seeming to rejoice in its strength of flight and to exult in the security and freedom of the upper air. The word ‘“‘way" is here improperly . translated. To the average mind it always means a road, a path. In this instance it should he translated: The characteristics of an eagle in the air; The habit of a serpent upon the rock; The path of a ship in the midst of the sea; And the manner of a man with a maid. Each of these lines stood a separate marvel to Agur, and had no connection with the others (but cf Wisd 5 10.11, and see Way). Isa 40 31 is another flight reference. Jer 49 16 refers to the inaccessible heights at which the eagle loves to build and rear its young. Ver 22 refers to the eagle’s power of flight. Ezk 1 10 recounts a vision of the prophet in which strange living crea- tures had faces resembling eagles. The same book (17 3) contains the parable of the eagle: ‘Thus saith the Lord Jeh: A great eagle with great wings and long pinions, full of feathers, which had divers colors, came unto Lebanon, and took the top of the cedar.” Hos 8 1 is another flight reference. Ob ver 4 is almost identical with Jer 49 16. The next reference is that of Micah, and really refers to the griffon vulture (Mic 1 16). In Hab 1 8 the reference is to swift flight. Mt 24 28 undoubtedly refers to vultures. In Rev 4 7 the eagle is used as a symbol of strength. In Rev 8 13 the bird is represented as speaking: ‘‘And I saw, and I heard an eagle [AV “‘angel’’], flying in mid heaven, saying with a great voice, Woe, woe, woe, for them that dwell on the earth, by reason of the other voices of the trumpet of the three angels, who are yet to sound.”” The eagle makes its last appearance in the vision of the woman and the dragon (Rev 12 14). GENE STRATTON-PORTER EANES, @’a-néz (1 Esd 9 21): RV MANES (q.v.), RVm ‘‘Harim.” EAR, ér (JIN, ’dzen; ots, ovis, drlov, dtion, the latter word [lit. ‘‘earlet’’] in all the Gospels only used of the ear of the high priest’s servant, which was cut off by St. Peter: Mt 26 51; Mk 14 47; Lk 22 51 [not 22 50]; Jn 18 10.26): (1) The physical organ of hearing which was con- sidered of peculiar importance as the chief instru- ment by which man receives information and com- mandments. For this reason the ear of the priest had to be specially sanctified, the tip of the right ear being touched with sacrificial blood at the con- secration (Lev 8 23). Similarly the ear of the cleansed leper had to be rededicated to the service of God by blood and oil (Lev 14 14.17.25.28). The ear-lobe of a servant, who preferred to remain with the family of his master rather than become free in the seventh year, was to be publicly bored or pierced with an awl in token of perpetual servitude (Ex 21 6). It has been suggested that Ps 40 6 should be interpreted in this sense, but this is not probable (see below). The cutting off of the ears and noses of captives was an atrocious custom of war frequently alluded to in oriental lit. (Ezk 23 25). The phrase ‘to open the ear,” which origi- nally means the uncovering of the ear by partially removing the turban, so as to permit a clearer hear- ing, is used in the sense of revealing a secret or of giving important (private) information (1 S 9 15; 20 2.12.13; 28 7 27; 1 Ch 17 25; also Ps 40 6), and the NT promises similarly that ‘things which eye saw not, and ear heard not” are to be revealed by the reconciled God to the heart that in gladsome surrender has come to Him to be taught by His spirit (1 Cor 29). (2) The inner ear, the organ of spiritual percep- tion. If the ear listens, the heart willingly submits, but often the spiritual ear is “hardened” (Isa 6 10; Zec 711; Mt 18 15; Acts 28 27), or “heavy” (Isa 6 10; also Dt 29 4), either by self-seeking obstinacy or by the judgment of an insulted God. Such unwilling hearers are compared to the ‘deaf adder... . which hearkeneth not to the voice of charmers, charming never so wisely” (Ps 58 4.5; ef also Prov 21 13; 28 9; Acts 7 57). The ex- pression “He that hath ears to hear let him hear” is frequent in the Synoptic Gospels, occurring 7 or 8 times: Mt 11 15; 13 9.48; Mk 4 9.23 (7 16 RV omits); Lk 8 8; 14 35, and while not found in the Fourth Gospel, it occurs seven times in Rev 2 and 3. “Itching ears,” on the other hand, are those that have become tired of the sound of oft-repeated truth and that long for new though deceitful teach- ing (2 Tim 4 3). Ears may “tingle” at startling any esp. of disaster (1 S 3 11; 2 K 21 12; Jer (3) God’s ears are often mentioned in the anthro- popathic style of Scripture, signifying the ability of God to receive the petitions of His people, for “He that planted the ear, shall he not hear?” (Ps 949; also Ps 1017; 3415; 130 2; Isa 59 1; 1 Pet 3 12). But God also hears the murmurings of the wicked against Him (Nu 11 1; 2 K 19 28; Wisd 110; Jas 6 4); still it lies in His power to refuse to hear (Ezk 8 18; Lam 3 8; cf also ver 56). H. L. E. Luerrme EARING, ér'ing ("0 harish): The Heb word is twice tr? “earing” in AV (Gen 46 6; Ex 34 21). The RV rendering is “plowing”: ‘There shall be neither plowing nor harvest.’”” See also Dt 21 4; 18 8 12; Isa 30 24. EARLY, dr’li (8p0pos, érihros, and related words; wpot, proi): The word generally refers to the day, and means the hour of dawn or soon after (Gen 19 2; 2 Ch 36 15; Hos 6 4; Lk 24 22). Some- times it refers to the beginning of the season, e.g. the early rain (Ps 84 6; Jas 5 7; see Rain). It may also have the sense of “speedily” (Ps 46 5). The early morning is frequently commended as the hour for prayer. See examples of Jesus (Mk 1 35; Lk 21 38; Jn 8 2); also Abraham (Gen 19 27), Jacob (Gen 28 18), Gideon (Jgs 6 38), Samuel (1 8 16 12), David (1 S 17 20). G. H. GERBERDING EARNEST, fr’nest (appaBev,, arrhabén): Found three times in the NT: The “earnest of our inheri- tance” (Eph 1 14); “the earnest of the Spirit” (2 Cor 1 22; 6 5). It has an equivalent in Heb ‘erabhon (found in Gen 38 17.18.20), in Lat ar- rabo, Fr. arrhes and the OE arles. The termis mer- cantile and comes originally from the Phoenicians. Its general meaning is that of a pledge or token given as the assurance of the fulfilment of a bargain or promise. It also carries with it the idea of for- feit, such as is now common in land deals, only from the obverse side. In other words, the one promis- ing to convey property, wages or blessing binds the promise with an advance gift or pledge partaking of the quality of the benefit to be bestowed. If the agreement be about wages, then a part of the wages is advanced; if it be about land, then a clod given to the purchaser or beneficiary may stand as the pledge of final and complete conveyance of the prop- erty. Figurative: In the spiritual sense, as used in the passages above named, the reference is to the work of the Spirit of God in our hearts being a token and 887 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Eanes Earthly pledge of a perfect redemption and a heavenly inheritance. There is more than the idea of security in the word as used, for it clearly implies the con- tinuity and identity of the blessing. C. E. Scuenx EARRING, ér’ring: An ornamental pendant of some kind hanging from the ears has been worn by both sexes in oriental lands from the earliest times. Among the Greeks and Romans, as with western peoples in general, its use was confined to females. The ears in the statue of the Medicean Venus are pierced and probably were originally ornamented with earrings. It is clear, however, that among the Hebrews and related oriental peo- ples earrings were worn by both sexes. Abraham’s servant “put the earring upon |Rebekah’s] face, and the bracelets upon her hands” (Gen 24 47 AV), in accordance with custom, evidently, but it is im- plied that it was customary for men also to wear earrings, in that the relatives and friends of Job “every one [gave him] an earring of gold’ (Job 42 11 AV). Such ornaments were usually made of gold, finely wrought, and often set with precious stones, as archaeology has shown. Such jewels were worn in ancient times for protective as well as for decorative purposes. RV renders “amulets” for AV “earrings” in Isa 3 20, the Heb word (l*hashim) being elsewhere associated with serpent- charming; but the earrings of Gen 35 4, also, were more than mere ornaments, so the AV and RV may both be right in their renderings here (Kennedy). The influence of Egypt, where amulets of various kinds were worn by men and gods, by the living and the dead, is shown by recent excavations at Gezer, Taanach and Megiddo. See AmMuLET; OrNaMENT. Gro. B. Eager EARTH, firth (WAIN, ’ddhamah, TIS, ’erec, "DY, ‘aphar; yi, gé, olxovpévy, oikouméné): In a hilly limestone country like Pal, the small amount of iron oxide in the rocks tends to be oxidized, and thereby to give a prevailing reddish color to the soil. This is esp. the case on relatively barren hills where there is little organic matter present to prevent reddening and give a more blackish tinge. *Adhamah (cf ’adham, “a man,” and Adam) is from ’adham, “‘to be red,” and is used in the senses: “earth” (Ex 20 24), “land” (Ps 105 35), a “land” or country (Isa 14 2), “ground” (Gen 4 11), “the earth” (Gen 7 4). The word most in use is ’ere¢, undoubtedly from a most ancient root occurring in many languages, as Eng. “earth,”’ Ger. Erde, Arab. ’ard. It is used in most of the senses of ’édhamah, but less as ‘‘soil’”’ and more as “the earth” as a part of the universe; fre- quently with skdmayim, “heavens,” asin Gen 1 1: “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.” ‘Aphar and its root word and derivatives are closely paralleled in the Arab., and refer mainly to “dust” or “dry earth” (cf Arab. ‘afir, “to be of the color of dust”; ‘afar, “dust”; ya‘fur, “‘a gazelle’; Heb ‘opher, “‘a gazelle”). Ci Gen 2 7: “Jehovah God formed man of the dust of the ground’’; Job 212: “. ... sprinkled dust upon their heads”; Ps 104 29: “. . . . they die, and return to their dust”; Gen 18 27: “dust and ashes.” In the LXX and NT, g2 is used in nearly all cases, oikoumené being used a few times for the “habit- able earth,” as in Lk 21 26AV. See further AN- THROPOLOGY; ASTRONOMY; EvvoLUTION; WorRLD. AurreD Evy Day EARTH, CIRCLE OF THE. See Astronomy, Ill, 1, 3. EARTH, CORNERS OF THE: The ‘‘corners’’ or “ends” of the earth are its ‘‘wings” (kan*photh ha-’Greg), i.e. its borders or extremities. The word in general means a wing, because the wing of a bird is used as a covering for its young, and from this meaning it acquires that of the extremity of any- thing stretched out. It is thus used in Dt 22 12: ‘Thou shalt make thee fringes upon the four borders [wings] of thy vesture, wherewith thou coverest thy- self.” It thus also means the coasts or boundaries of the land surface of the earth; its extremities. It is tr4 “corners” in Isa 11 12; “ends” in Job 87 3 and 38 13. The “four corners” of the earth (Isa 11 12) or “land” (Ezk 7 2) are therefore simply the extremities of the land in the four cardinal direc- tions. See also Astronomy, III, 3. E. W. Maunprr EARTH, ENDS OF THE. See Earru, Cor- NERS OF THE. EARTH, PILLARS OF THE. Sce Astronomy, 2. ? EARTH, THE NEW. See EscHATOLOGY oF THE NT, LX; Hzavens (New). EARTH, VAULT, vélt, OF THE: In one passage God is said to have ‘founded his vault [’dghuddah] upon the earth” (Am 9 6). It is not quite certain whether this dome or vault refers to the earth itself, or to the heavens arched above it. The latter is the usual interpretation, but in either case the reference is rather to the strength of the structure than to its form; the word implying something that is firmly bound together and hence an arch or dome because of its stability. See also Astronomy, III, 2. EARTHEN, drth’n, VESSELS (W7, heres, "27, yecer; brrpdkives, osirdkinos): These vessels were heat-resisting and were used for cooking and for boiling clothes (Lev 6 28; 11 33; 14 5.50). They were probably non-porous and took the place of the kidri or ma’ajin used in Syria today. A traveler in the interior of Pal may still meet with the hos- pitality showed to David (2 $ 17 28). The gen- erous natives brought not only gifts of food but the necessary vessels in which to cook it. An earthen vessel was used to preserve a land deed (Jer 32 14). Figurative: In Jer 19 1 breaking of an earthen vessel was symbolical of the destruction of Jerus. These vessels were also used to symbolize the commonness (Lam 4 2) and frailness of our bodies (2 Cor 47). See Potrmery. James A. Patca EARTHLY, arth’li (émlyeos, epigeios, “existing upon the earth,” “terrestrial,” from én, epi, “upon’ and yf, gé, “earth”; Vulg terrenus): Of or pertain- ing to the earth, or to the present state of existence. The word epigeios is not found in LXX, but occurs in classical Gr from Plato down. In Plutarch Mor. 566 D, it occurs in the remarkable phrase, “that which is earthly of the soul.” Its meaning is pri- marily merely local (“being on the earth’). ‘The word gé (“earth”) has not in itself an ethical sig- nificance, and does not carry a suggestion of moral taint, such as the word késmos (‘“world”’) has, esp. in the Johannine writings, and sdrz (‘flesh’’), esp. in Paul. It does, however, suggest a certain limi- tation or frailty; and in some passages, the context gives the adj. epigetos an ethical color, though in the NT the purely local meaning is never lost sight of. It is tr4 “earthly” in the following passages: (1) Jn 3 12, ‘af I told you earthly things,” i.c. things which are realized on earth, things within the circle of human observation, truths of subjective experience (e.g. the new birth); in contrast to “heavenly things,” the objective truths which, as not directly realizable in human experience, must be revealed from above (the mysteries of the Divine purpose Earthquake Ebal, Mount THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 888 and plans). Clearly “earthly”? here implies no moral contrast to the heavenly or spiritual. (2) 2 Cor 5 1, “the earthly house of our tabernacle,” i.e. the body with which we are clothed on earth, in contrast to the spiritual resurrection-body, ‘“‘which is from heaven” (ver 2). Here again the word has a merely local, not an ethical, significance. (38) Phil 3 19, “‘whose glory is in their shame, who mind earthly things,” i.e. whose thoughts rest on earth, on the pleasures of life here below. (4) Jas 3 15, “This wisdom is not a wisdom that cometh down from above, but is earthly,” i.e. it is on the plane of life on earth, merely human, incapable of ascending to the level of Divine wisdom. In the . last two passages, the literal local meaning is still evident, but the word shades off into the moral and suggests that which is opposed to the spiritual in character. The same word is tr? “terrestrial” in 1 Cor 15 40, and “things in [RV ‘“on’’] earth” in Phil 2 10. AV has “earthly” in Jn 3 31, where it translates ek tés gés=lit. ‘‘out of the earth,” the reference being to the character and mission of the Baptist as partaking of the limitations of his earthly (human) origin, in contrast to the Messiah “that cometh from heaven.”’ The AV rendering is some- what misleading, for it introduces a confusion with the “earthly” of ver 12 (vide Westcott in loc.). RV rightly renders ‘‘of the earth.” “Earthly” is to be distinguished from ‘‘earthy”’ =made of earth or clay (chotkés, from choits, ‘“‘earth dug out,” 1 Cor 16 47 ff). D. Mratu Epwarps EARTHQUAKE, arth’kwak (OY7 » ra‘ash; oe pés, seismés): The last earthquake which worked any damage in Pal and Syria occurred 1. Earth- in 1837, and destroyed the village of quakes in Safed, near Mt. Hermon, and was felt Palestine even to Hebron. Since that time a few feehle shocks have been felt but no damage was done. The region is just on the edge of the great earthquake circle whose center is in Armenia, and is hable to earthquakes. The large number of references in the Bible to earthquakes, and the evident fear in the minds of the people of those times, would seem to indicate that they were more frequent in Bible times than recently. There are three main causes of earthquakes: (1) Harthslips.—In the slow process of cooling, the crust of the earth tends to wrinkle and fold as it con- tracts. This causes a stress to be set up 2. Causes im the strata composing the crust. If the of Earth- strata are too rigid to bend there must come after a time a break or fault. The quakes shock caused hy the break, which is usually several miles below the surface of the earth, is an earthquake, and it spreads in the form of earth waves from the break as center. Seismographs in all parts of the world are now adjusted to receive the waves even though the origin is on the opposite side of the earth. (2) Explosion of steam or gases under the surface. Some earthquakes, especialiy those underneath the sea, are thought to he caused hy water seeping through the soil and rocks and finding its way to the heated masses below. Steam is formed and if there is no escape for it, an explosion takes place whose force is felt on the surface. (3) Voleanic.—As earthquakes are of common occur- rence in volcanic regions it seems likely that there is some connection between the two, but the relation has not been fully traced. is the origin of both the volcano and earthquake. See further, Deuce or Noag. : Many destructive earthquakes have been re- corded in the history of Syria, but they have been mostly in the north, in the region of 3. Earth- Aleppo. Jerus itself has seldom been quakes in affected by earthquakes. The Hauran Jerusalem beyond the Jordan is covered with voleanic remains and signs of violent shocks, and the cities on the coast have suffered much, but Jerus on the higher ground between has usually escaped with little destruction. It may be that the second cause- A number of earthquakes are mentioned in the Scriptures: (1) At Mount Sinai (Ex 19 18); (2) Korah and companions destroyed in 4. Earth- fissure and sinking ground (Nu 16 31; quakesin Ant, IV, iii, 3); (3) in the Phili camp Scripture in the days of Saul (1 § 14 15); (4) after Elijah’s flight (1 K 19 11); (5) in the reign of Uzziah, between 790 and 740 BC (Am 11); Zec 14 5 probably refers to the same (Ant, IX, x, 4); (6) at Christ’s death (Mt 27 51— 54); (7) at Christ’s resurrection (Mt 28 2); (8) at Philippi when Paul and Silas were freed from prison (Acts 16 26). Most of these shocks seem _to have been slight and caused little loss of life. Jos men- tions one in the reign of Herod, ‘‘such as had not happened at any other time, which was very destructive to men and cattle’ (Ant, XV, v, 2). Professor G. A. Smith in his recent work on Jerusa- lem is of the opinion that earthquakes were suffi- ciently frequent and strong to account for the ap- pearance and disappearance of Nehemiah’s Foun- tain (Jerus, I, 74). The Heb ra‘ash is commonly used to mean a great noise. Large earthquakes are sometimes accompanied by a rumbling noise, but ag arule they come silently and without warning. In the Scriptures earthquakes are mentioned as tokens of God’s power (Job 9 6) and of His presence and anger (Ps 68 8; 18°7; Isa 13 5. Symbolic 13): “She shall be visited of Jeh of Use hosts... . with earthquake, and great noise” (Isa 29 6); also as a sign of Christ’s “coming, and of the end of the world” (Mt 24 3-7). See also Rev 11 13.19; 16 18. . LirERATURE.—Milne, Earthquakes (Inter. Scient. ser.); Plumptre, Bib. Studies, 136; Dutton, Harthquakes. : Aurrep H. Joy EASE, é2 (]28U, sha’dnan, J2NPW, shal’anan, chiefly, ‘‘at ease’): Used 19 t in the OT and once in the NT, most frequently meaning tranquillity, security or comfort of mind; in an ethical sense, indicating carelessness or indifference with reference to one’s moral or religious interests. The prophet Jeremiah used the phrase as an indication of national or tribal indifference: ‘‘Moab hath been at e. from his youth” (Jer 48 11); “I am very sore displeased with the nations that are at e.” (Zec 115). Fre- quent allusions are made also by various prophets to individuals or groups of individuals, as ‘“Woe to them that are at e. in Zion” (Am 6 1); “Rise up, ye women that are at e.”’ (Isa 32 9), and ‘Tremble, ye women that are at e.” (ver 11). The word in another form is used also in a verbal sense and to apply to physical ease and comfort, as “My couch shall e. my complaint” (Job 7 13; cf esp. 2 Ch 10 4.9). Simple mental tranquillity or peace of mind is also expressed by it (Jer 46 27). The single instance of its use in the NT is illus- trative of its figurative but most common usage in the OT, where it refers to moral indifference in the parable of the Rich Fool: “Soul... . take thine e., eat, drink, be merry” (Lk 12 19). Wa.LTEeR G. CLIPPINGER , EAST, ist, CHILDREN OF THE (TA, miz- rah, OTP, kedhem, OTP, kédhem, and other deriva- tives of the same root; dvaroA}, anatolé): Mizrah ig the equivalent of the Arab. meshrik, ‘the orient” or “place of sunrise.”” In the same way ma‘drabh, ‘west,’’ corresponds to the Arab. maghrib, and both mizrah and ma‘drabh occur in Ps 108 12: ‘‘As far as the east is from the west, so far hath he removed our transgressions from us.” Kéddham, ‘‘to pre- cede” (whence kedhem, ‘‘east’’), and its derivatives correspond closely to the Arab. kadham, except that the Arab. derivatives do not include the significa- tion “east.” In the majority of cases “east” and other words of direction require no explanation, but the expressions “the children of the east” (b¢né 889 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Earthquake Ebal, Mount kedhem), ‘‘the land of the children of the east” (ere¢ bend kedhem), and “‘the east country’’ (ereg kedhem), belong to a different category. In the story of Gideon (Jgs 6 3.33; 7 12; 8 10), we find several times the expression “the Midianites and the Amalekites and the children of the east.” In Jgs 8 24 it is said of the same host: “For they had golden earrings, because they _were Ishmaelites.” In Jer 49 28.29: “Go up to Kedar, and destroy the children of the east. Their tents and their flocks shall they take.” In Gen 25 6: “But unto the sons of the concubines, that Abraham had, Abraham gave gifts; and he sent them away from Isaac his son, while he yet lived, eastward, unto the east country.” Now Ishmael is the son of Abraham and Hagar, Midian of Abraham and Keturah, Kedar the son of Ishmael, and Amalek the grand- son of Esau, dwelling in Edom. It is evident that we have to do with the Syrian desert and in a general way with Arabia, esp. its northern part, and with peoples like the modern Bedawin who kept camels and dwelt in tents, “houses of hair’ (buyat sha‘r), as they are called by the Arabs of today. A striking passage is Gen 29 1: “Then Jacob went on his journey, and came to the land of the children of the east.” As one journeys eastward through the country E. of the Jordan he traverses first a region of towns and villages with fields of grain, and then the wide desert where the Bedawin wander with their herds. The line is a sharp one. Within a very few hours he passes from the settled art where the rain, though scanty, is sufficient to Brite the grain to maturity, to the bare desert. Job was ‘‘the greatest of all the children of the east” (Job 13). These desert people had a name for wisdom as we see from 1 K 4 30, “‘Solomon’s wisdom excelled the wisdom of all the children of the east, and all the wisdom of Egypt”; and from Mt 2 1: ‘Now when Jesus was born... . Wise- men from the east came.” Atrrep Evy Day EAST COUNTRY, kun’tri (7712 PRS, ’eree miz- rah): Lit. “country of the sunrise” over against the “country of the sunset” (Zec 8 7). The two to- gether form a poetical expression indicating the whole earth. EAST GATE. See Gats, Tue East. EAST (EASTERN, és’térn) SEA (Zee 14 8). See Deap Sra. EAST WIND. See WIN». EASTER, és’tér (waerxa, pdscha, fr Aram. NOB, pasha’, and Heb NOB, pesah, the Passover festival): The Eng. word comes from the AS Easire or Estera, a Teutonie goddess to whom sacrifice was offered in April, so the name was transferred to the paschal feast. ‘The word does not properly occur in Scrip- ture, although AV has it in Acts 12 4 where it stands for Passover, as it is rightly rendered in RV. There is no trace of Easter celebration in the NT, though some would see an intimation of it in 1 Cor 67. The Jewish Christians in the early church continued to celebrate the Passover, regarding Christ as the true paschal lamb, and this naturally passed over into a commemoration of the death and resurrection of Our Lord, or an Easter feast. This was preceded by a fast, which was considered by one party as ending at the hour of the crucifixion, ie. at 3 o’clock on Friday, by another as continuing until the hour of the resurrection before dawn on Easter morning. Differences arose as to the time of the Easter celebration, the Jewish Christians naturally fixing it at the time of the Passover feast which was regulated by the paschal moon. Accord- ing to this reckoning it began on the evening of the 14th day of the moon of the month of Nisan without regard to the day of the week, while the gentile Christians identified it with the first day of the week, i.e. the Sunday of the resurrection, irrespective of the day of the month. This latter practice finally prevailed in the church, and those who followed the other reckoning were stigmatized as heretics. But differences.arose as to the proper Sunday for the Easter celebration which led to long and_bitter controversies. The Council of Nice, 325 AD, de- creed that it should be on Sunday, but did not fix the particular Sunday. It was left to the bishop of Alexandria to determine, since that city was re- garded as the authority in astronomical matters and he was to communicate the result of his deter- mination to the other bishops. But this was not satisfactory, esp. to the western churches, and a definite rule for the determination of Easter was needed. By some it was kept as early as March 21, and by others as late as April 25, and others followed dates between. The rule was finally adopted, in the 7th cent., to celebrate Easter on the Sunday following the 14th day of the calendar moon which comes on, or after, the vernal equinox which was fixed for March 21. This is not always the astronomical moon, but near enough for practical purposes, and is determined without astronomical calculation by certain intricate rules adopted by ecclesiastical authority. These rules involve the Dominical Letters, or the first. seven of the alpha- bet, representing the days of the week, A standing for the first day of the year and the one on which Sunday falls being called the Dominical for that year. There are also involved the Golden Numbers and the Epacts, the first being the numbers from 1 to 19, the cycle of the moon when its phases recur on the same days of the year, the first of the cycle being that in which the new moon falls on January 1, The Epacts indicate the moon’s age at the be- ginning of each year. Easter was thus fixed by these rules, but another difficulty arose when the Gregorian calendar was adopted in 1582, the differ- ence between it and the Julian being then 10 days. This of course affected the determination of Easter, and its celebration by the Gr church, which has never admitted the Gregorian calendar, occurs usually at a different time from that followed by the western churches. This difference may be as much as five weeks and it may occur as late as April 30, while in the West it cannot occur later than April 25 nor earlier than March 22. Occa- sionally the two come together but this is rare, since the difference between the two calendars is now 13 days. The Easter feast has been and still is regarded as the greatest in the Christian church, since it commemorates the most important event in the life of its Founder. PorTER EBAL, é’bal (23°2, ‘zbhal, “bare”) or OBAL Q2iD, ‘abhal): (1) A people and region of Joktanite, Arabia. See Dillmann, Gen, and Glaser, Skizze, II, 426. The latter form of the name is that given in Gen 10 28, the former in 1 Ch 1 22 and in the Sam text of Gen 10 28. (2) A son of Shobal, son of Seir, the Horite (Gen 36 23; 1 Ch 1 40). EBAL, é’bal, MOUNT (22°97 14, har ‘ébhal; Ta:Béd, Gaibdl): Rises N. of the vale of Shechem, over against Mt. Gerizim on the S. The mountain (Arab. el-Islamiyeh) reaches a height of 1,402 ft. above the floor of the valley, and 3,077 ft. above the level of the Mediterranean. The Samaritans feign that Gerizim is the higher; but it is more than 200 Ebal, Mount Ebionism THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 890 ft. lower than Ebal. These two mountains over- hang the pass through which runs the main artery of intercourse between E. and W., the city of Na- blus lying in the throat of the valley to the W. The ancient Shechem probably stood farther to the E. The lower slopes of Ebal as one ascends from Nablus are covered with gardens and orchards, the copious streams from the fountains under Gerizim washing its foot, and spreading fertility and beauty. The vine, the fig and the olive grow luxuriantly. Higher up we scramble over rough rocky terraces, where grow only the ubiquitous thistles and prickly shrubs. Mount Ebal. From the broad summit a view of surpassing inter- est and beauty rewards the climber’s toil. West- ward beyond the hills and the plain of Sharon with its coast line of yellow sand running from Jaffa to Carmel, stretch the blue waters of the Mediter- ranean. From Carmel to Gilboa, Little Hermon and Tabor, roll the fruitful breadths of Esdraelon: the uplands of Galilee, with Nazareth showing on the brow above the plain, rise away to the but- tresses of Lebanon in the N. From the snowy peak of Hermon the eye ranges over the Jaulain and Mount Gilead to the Mountain of Bashan in the E., with the steep eastern wall of the Jordan valley in the foreground. The land of Moab is visible be- yond the Dead Sea; and the heights around Jerus close the view on the S. Round this splendid mountain, seen from afar on all sides, religious associations have gathered from old time. The Moslem Weley on the top— the usual white-domed sanctuary—where it is said the head of the Baptist is buried, is doubtless the modern representative of some ancient seat of wor- ship. The ruins of a church show that Christians also came under the spell of the hill. The slopes of Ebal toward Gerizim played their part in that memorable scene, when, having con- quered the central region of Pal, Joshua led the people hither, erected an altar of unhewn stones, wrote upon the stones—either engraving on the stone itself, or impressing on plaster placed there for the purpose—a copy of the law, and then, as Moses the servant of the Lord had commanded, placed half the tribes on the slope of Gerizim, and half on those of Ebal, and the ark with the priests and Levites in the center. Then with dramatic responses from the two divisions of the people, the blessings and the cursings of the Jaw were read (Josh 8 30 ff; ef Dt 27 11 ff). In all the future, therefore, this mountain, towering aloft in the very heart of the land, would remind beholders far and near of their people’s covenant with God. It has sometimes been questioned if the reading of the law could be heard by the people in the way described. The formation of the sides of the valley at the nar- towest part, and the acoustics, which have been tested more than once, leave no reasonable doubt as to the possibility. The importance of the mountain from a military point of view is illustrated by the ruins of a massive fortress found on the summit. W. Ewina EBED, é’bed (732, ‘ebhedh, “servant’’): (1) Father of -Gaal, who rebelled against Abim- elech (Jgs 9 26-35). ’ (2) A companion of Ezra in his return (Ezr 8 6) =Obeth (1 Esd 8 32). EBED-MELECH, @-bed-mé’lek, eb-ed-mé/lek (F227, ‘ebhedh-melekh, “servant of the king” or “of [god] Melek’’): An Ethiopian eunuch in the service of King Zedekiah, who interceded with the king for the prophet Jeremiah and rescued him from the dungeon into which he had been cast to die (Jer 38 7-13). For this, the word of Jeh through Jeremiah promised Ebed-melech that his life should be spared in the fall of Jerus Jer 39 15-18). EBEN-BOHAN. See Bowan. EBEN-EZEL. See EzeEt. EBEN-EZER, eb-en-@zér (720 JAN, ’ebhen hd-‘ezer, ‘‘stone of the help”; ’Apevétep, Abenézer): (1) Here Israel was defeated by the Philis, 4,000 men falling in the battle (1S 4 1ff). It appears also to have been the scene of the disaster when the ark of God was captured (vs 3 ff). The place is not identified. It was over against Aphek; but this site is also unknown (cf Josh 12 18). Onom pisces it between Jerus and Ascalon, in the neigh- orhood of Beth-shemesh. Conder suggests Deir Abéan, fully 2 miles E. of ‘Ain Shems (PEF, III, 24). (2) A stone set up by Samuel to perpetuate the memory of the signal victory granted to Israel over the Philis in answer to his prayer (1 S 7 12). It stood between Mizpeh and Shen. The latter is probably identical with ‘Ain Sinta, N. of Bethel. This defines the district in which it may be found; but no identification is yet possible. W. Ewina EBER, é’bér (13%, ‘ebher; "EBep, ber, in Gen; '0B4S, Obéd, in Ch): (1) Occurs in the genealogies (Gen 10 21.25; 11 14 ff) as the great-grandson of Shem and father of Peleg and Joktan. The word means “the other side,” “across,” and the form ‘Hebrew,”’ which is derived from it, is intended to denote the people or tribe who came “from the other side of the river” @.e. the Euphrates), from Haran (Gen 11 31), whence Abraham and his dependents migrated to Canaan. (2) A Gadite (1 Ch 5 13). (3) (4) Two Benjamites (1 Ch 8 12.22). (5) The head of a priestly family (Neh 12 20). : GRANT EBEZ, G'bez (PAN, 'ebhec, meaning unknown; ‘PéBes, Rhébes; AV Abez): One of the 16 cities in Issachar (Josh 19 20). The name seems to be cognate to that of the judge Ibzan (Jgs 12 8-10). All else concerning it is conjecture. EBIASAPH, é-bi’a-saf: A descendant of Kohath the son of Levi (1 Ch 6 37). See ABIASAPH. EBIONISM, @’bi-é-niz’m, EBIONITES, @'bi- S-nits (EBievato,, Ebidnatoi, from OMAN, 'ebhys- nim, “poor people’): Generai Statement ORIGIN OF THE Namn 1. The Poor Ones 2. Origin of the Name 891 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Ebal, Mount Ebionism II. Avrsorities ror THE OPINIONS OF THE ERIONITES 1. Ireuaeus, Tertullian and Hippolytus 2. Origen and Jerome 3. Epiphanius’ Description 4, Justin Martyr III. Literature or tee Esionites 1. The Gospel According to the Hebrews 2. The Clementines 3. Apocalypilc Literature IV. History or Esionism 1. Ebijonites and Essenes 2. Organization of Ebionites V. Evipence From EBIONISM FOR TRE DocTRINE oF THE Primitive CuurcnH — 1, Christology of the Early Church 2. Paulinism of the Karly Church LITERATURE The Ebionites were a sect of heretics frequently mentioned by the early Fathers. In regard to their opinions, as in regard to those of most General early heretical sects, there is the dif- Statement ficulty that to a large extent we are dependent for our information on their opponents. These opponents were not generally very careful to apprehend exactly the views of those whose opinions they undertook to refute. It adds to the difficulty in the present case that there is a dubiety as to the persons designated by the title. Sometimes, it is admitted, the name was uscd to designate all Jewish Christians irrespective of their opinions; at other times it denotes a sect akin to the Gnostics, who ascribed a purely human origin to Our Lord. There are, however, certain works, the Clementine writings, which from statements of the Fathers may be assumed to represent the views of this sect, but as these represent views to some extent divergent, it is difficult to decide which is the truly Ebionitic. There are also certain apocalyptic books which present affinities with Ebionism. The quota- tions from the Gospel according to the Hebrews— the only gospel the Ebionites received-—likewise afford means of appreciating their views. This gospel has come down to us only in isolated quota- tions, for the accuracy of which we have no guaran- tee. Finally, it has to be borne in mind that no sect can persist through centuries of changing cir- cumstances, and not in turn undergo change. I. Origin of the Name.—Tertullian and Epipha- nius assume the sect to have received its name from a certain Ebion or Hebion. Others 1. The of the Fathers, without affirming it, Poor Ones _ use language which seems to imply the belief in a person called Ebion. This, however, is generally now regarded as a mistake. No trace of the existence of such a person is to be found. The sect in question seems to have assumed the name Ebionites, ‘‘the poor ones,” from the first Beatitude (Mt 6 3), claiming to be the contin- uation into the new dispensation of the “poor and necdy”’ of the Pss, e.g. 69 33; 70 5; 74 21. It has been mooted that the sect may have had a leader who assumed the title ‘the poor man."’ Besides that we have no trace of his existence, the name would almost certainly have been treated as an Aram. word and put in the status emphaticua as Ebiona, whichin Gr would have become Ebionaa. The ordinary view of the origin of the name has the advantage of analogy in its favor. The pre- Reformation Protestants of the 12th 2. Origin and 138th cents. in France called them- of the selves “the poor men” (of Lyons). Name The fact that the apostle James in his Epistle implies a natural union be- tween poverty and piety (2 5), “Did not God choose them that are poor as to the world to be rich in faith .... 7’ would confirm the Jewish Chris- tians in their use of the name. Some have heen inclined to pies unduly a play ou the fame in which some of the Fathers indulge, as if the poor views of this sect as to the person of Christ had led to their receiving this name from without. Hl. Authorities for the Opinions of the Ebio- nites.—As indicated above, the main authorities for these are Irenaeus, Tertullian and 1. Irenaeus, Hippolytus. : Tertullian The characteristics of the Ebionites and noted by them were, first, the negative Hippolytus one that they did not, like the other Gnostics, distinguish between the Su- preme God and the Creator of the world—the demiurge—who was identified with the God of the Jews. With them Jeh was the Supreme God—the God of Israel and the Creator of the heavens and theearth. The second characteristic, also negative, was that they denied the supernatural birth of Our Lord. He was the son of Joseph and Mary in the ordinary sense of the word. The third was that they, along with the Cerinthians and Carpocratians, affirmed that a Divine power came down on Jesus at His’ baptism—the reward of His perfect holiness. According to one form of the theory, the Holy Ghost was the eternal Son of God. Another view was that the power which descended upon Him was the Divine wisdom, the Logos. By the influ- ence of this Divine power He performed miracles and taught with superhuman wisdom. But this Di- vine influence deserted Jesus on the Cross, hence the ery of being forsaken (Mt 27 46). The Divine power, however, raised Him from the dead and caused Him to ascend on high. Hippolytus brings the Ebionites into close connection with the Elka- saites and with a certain Alcibiades, whose views he had to combat in Rome. The last claimed to found his views on a work of Elkasai. From two other sources we derive further infor- mation: Origen and Jerome both notify the fact that the Ebionites tr? ‘almaéh “young 2. Origen woman” (it is rendered ‘virgin’ in and Jerome our AV and RV). This tr, so far as the mere word is concerned, is indubi- tably correct. There is another point in which both afford us information. The first says (Contra Celsum, v.61) that there are two classes of Ebio- nites, one of which denies the miraculous conception and birth of Our Lord, the other of which affirms it. Jerome, in his letter to Augustine, not only asserts the same thing but calls the one class, those affirm- ing the miraculous birth, Nazareans, and the other Ebionites. Origen in his second book against Cel- sus speaks as if the only distinction between the Ebionites and other Christians was their obedience to the Mosaic law, and by their example rebuts the assertion that the Jews in becoming Christians deserted the law of their fathers. Another feature of Ebionism presented to us by Jerome (Jn Jesa- tam, Ixvi.24) is their chiliastic view—the personal reign of Our Lord for 1,000 years as the Jewish Messiah. The writer who gives the most voluminous account of the Ehionites—‘‘Ebionaeans" as he calls them—is Epi- hanius. With him it is at once heresy 3. Epi- o. X and heresy No. XXX. Before discuss- hanius’ ing the Ehionites he takes up the closely PD re related_sect of the Nazarcans as heresy Description No, XXIX. .He had already in a more compendious way considered a similarly named sect, numbering it No. XVIII. It, however, is Jewish while this is Christian, The Jewish sect is dis- tinguished by eating no animal food and offering no sac- rifices. They have thus an affinity with the Essenes. They have a peculiarity that, while they honored the yp einlenche: they rejected the Pent which related their istory. These Nazareans dwelt @. of the Jordan in Gilead and Bashan. Heresy No. X XIX is the Christian Nazareans, This name had been at first applied to all Christians. Epiphanius identifies them with the Essenes and declares their distinguishing peculiarity to be the re- tention of circumcision and the ceremonial law. They use the Gospel of Mt but without the genealogies. As Heresy No, XXX he proceeds to consider the Ebionites. Eblon, Epiphanius assumes to have been a man, and calis him a ‘polymorphic portent,'’ and asserts that he was connected with the Samaritans, the Essenes, the Cerinthians and Carpocratians, yet desired to be regarded Ebionism THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 892 a Christian. 'The heresy originated after the flight of the church to Pella. They denied the miraculous birth of Our Lord, but maintained that a Divine influence came down upon Him at His baptism. This Divine wisdom had inspired, and in a sense dwelt, in all the patriarchs. In some sense the body of Jesus was re- garded as that of Adam revived. This body was cruci- fied and rose again. They receive only the Gospel of Mt in the form the Cerinthians use it, i.e. the Gospel accord- ing to the Hebrews. Epiphantus gives some account of this gospel and its defects. They use also other books; one which he esp. descrihes, The Journeyings of Peter, appears to be in the main identical with the Clementine omilies. He connects the Ehionites, as does Hippoly- tus, with Elkasai; from him they learned that the heavenly Christ was 96 miles high and 24 broad, and that the Holy Ghost had a female form of similar di- mensions, only invisible. Although he connects the Ebionites with the Essenes he mentions that, unlike the Essenes of Jos and Philo, the Ebionites not only permitted but enjoined matrimony on young men, LEpiphaninus ds as an especial enormity that the Ebionites permit second, third and even seventh marriages. Although they enjoin marriage they have a low opinion of women, crediting Eve with originating heathenism, in this agree- ing with the Essenian opinion of the sex. Mysteriously Epiphanius represents the Ebionites as not only rejecting the prophets in a body but deriding them. He also mentions the rejection of St. Paul by the Ebionites. It is exceedingly difficult to form a clear, self-consistent view of the doctrines of the Ebionites from the state- ments of Epiphanius, yet there are points in which his information is of value. Though Justin Martyr does not name the Ebio- nites in his dialogue with Trypho the Jew (47), he mentions two classes of Jewish Chris- tians: (a) those who not only them- selves observe the law but would compel the gentile believers also to be circumcised and keep the whole law, and will hold no communion with those who refuse to become Jews; (b) those who, observing the Mosaic law themselves, enter into communion with uncircum- cised gentile believers. The former appcar to be an early form of Ebionites. It is to be noted that Justin does not ascribe to them any doctrinal di- vergence from the orthodox views. In the follow- ing ch he mentions some that denied the divinity of Our Lord, but these were Gentiles (hémetérou génous) “of our race.” Il, Literature of the Ebionites.—-One thing of importance we do owe to Epiphanius—the indica- tion of the lit. produced by the Ebionites, from which we may get their views at first hand. This includes the Gospel according to the Hebrews, the Clemen- tines (Homilies and Recognitions); to which we would add the Ascension of Isaiah and the Odes of Solomon. It may be remarked that this lit. appears to represent the opinion of different classes of the Ebionites. We shall merely consider here the bear- ing these works have on the Ebionites. The Gospel according to the Hebrows we know only through quotations. We can have no certainty that these quotations are accurate. The quo- 4. Justin Martyr 1. The tations may have heen interpolated, and Gospel further the hook from which the quotations Accordin have been made has prohahly passed g through several recensions. The discus- to the sion of the question of the relation of this Hebrews book to the canonical Gospel of Mt is con- sidered elsewhere (see ApocRYPHAL Gos- PELs). One thing is clear, there were at least two recensions of this gospel, onenearer and the other farther from the canonical Gospel; the former, the Nazarean, differed only by omitting the genealogy from the First Gospel of the Canon. The other was more strictly Ehionite and omitted all mention of the miraculous birth. The Ehionite recension began, as Epiphanius tells us, ahruptly with the calling of the Apostles. The assertion of Epiphanius that the Ehionites rejected the prophets is supported by a quotation from _the Gospel according to the Hebrews in Jerome (Adv. Pelag., iii.2): ‘‘In the prophets, after they were anointed by the Spirit, sin was found.'' The change from céridas (‘‘locusts"') to egkridas (lit. ‘‘cakes of honey and oil’’; cf Ex 16 31; Nu 11 8) in the account of the food of John may be due to the avoidance of animal food attributed to this sect. One passage, which appears to be a denunciation of wealth in itself, is an addition of a second rich man to the story of the young ruler of the pynasorus. A singu- lar verse, quoted from this gospel both by Origen and Jerome, deserves special notice for several reasons: ‘‘My mother, the Holy Ghost, took me by one of my hairs and bore me to the great mountain Tabor.’’ The designa- tion of the Holy Ghost as ‘‘my mother” is unexampled. It implies a materialistic view of the doctrine of the Trinity after the form of a human family. It is a note of geographical ignorance to call Tahor a “‘great’’ mountain. It is only some 2,000 ft. high and behind It are the mountains of the hili country of Galilee rising up to 4,000 ft. in Jebel Jermuk, and hehind that the white top of Hermon, 10,000 ft. It is difficult to understand anyone resident in Pal calling Tabor a ‘great’ moun- tain. Rising from tne plain of Esdraelon itis prominent, but with the higher mountains behind it, it could not even seem great. In a quotation hy Jerome (Ad». Pelag., iii.2) Our Lord declares Himself unwilling to be baptized by John as unconscious of sin. This suits the representation of Ehionite views which we find in Ire- naeus that it was His sinlessness that made Jesus capable of receiving the Holy Ghost. The Clementine lit. attributed by Epiphanius to the Ebionites is a more important source of in- formation for their opinions. It has 2. The come down to us complete in three or Clementines four forms, the Homilies, the Recog- nitions, and two Epitomes which, however, differ less than the two larger works. They all seem to be recensions of an earlier work which has disappeared. The foundation of all of these is a species of religious novel on which are grafted sermons of Peter and his discussions with Simon Magus. Clement, a young Roman orphan of rank in search of a religion, meets Barnabas, who tells him of Christ, describing Him as the ‘‘Son of God,” and says that He had appeared in Judaea. To learn more about Jesus, Clement proceeds to Caesarea, where he meets Peter. He thereafter accompanies Peter to the various places whither the apostle pursues Simon Magus, and in course of his journeyings he meets and recognizes his father, his brother and his mother; hence the title Recog- nitions. It is in the discourses of Peter that the Ebionism appears. Its theology is fundamentally Jewish and Essenian. That it is Judaizing is evi- denced by the covert hostility to the apostle Paul. There are elements that are not those of orthodox Judaism. The Messiah is coequal, or nearly so, with the devil; in other words, the position is a modi- fication of Parseeism (Hom., III, 5). If the dis- course of Barnabas is excluded, Our Lord is always called the “prophet” (Hom.), the ‘Teacher” (Recog.). He is never asserted nor assumed to be Divine. Nothing is said of His miraculous birth. At the same time in the Recognitions He is regarded as not merely man. _ It is said He “assumed a Jew- ish body’ (Recog., I, 60). This agrees with what Epiphanius says of the Ebionite idea that it was as the body of Adam that the Christ appeared. The apostle Peter, who is represented as the model Christian, eats only herbs and practises frequent ablutions, quite in the manner of the Essenes. In his discourses Peter declares that the true prophet “quenches the fire of altars and represses war.” These are Essenian peculiarities, but he “sanctions marriage,” against Essenism as we find it in Philo and Jos. The phrase implies an opposition to some who not only did not sanction, but forbade, marriage (Hom., III, 26). If the ignoring of the work and apostleship of St. Paul be regarded as the criterion of the Judaizers, that is to say, the Ebionites, then in 3. Apoca- apocalyptic lit. we find works from lyptic which we can draw information as to Literature views. The Ascension of Isaiah was one of the earliest of these books to be recovered in modern times. The writer refers to the martyrdom of Peter in Rome, but makes no men- tion of Paul (IV, 3). The description of elders and shepherds hating one another (III, 29), “lawless elders and unjust shepherds who will ravage their sheep” (III, 24), seems a view of the church’s state as it appeared to a Judaizer when the Pauline view THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Ebionism 893 was prevailing. Notwithstanding this not only is the Divine dignity maintained, but the doctrine of the Trinity, “They all glorified the Father of all and His beloved Son and the Holy Spirit’? (VIII, 18), is affirmed. As to the person of Christ, He descended through the successive heavens to the earth to be born (IX, 18; X, 8-31). The virginity of Mary is affirmed (X, 12), and the child is born without pain, miraculously (XI, 8-14). A similar view of the birth of Christ is to be found in the Odes of Solomon (XIX, 7). IV. History of Ebionism.—All authorities com- bine i asserting a close connection between the Ebionites and the Essenes. At first 1. Ebionites sight there are serious points of differ- and ence, principally these, the Ebionites Essenes enjoined marriage, while the Essenes, if we may believe Philo and Jos, for- bade it. This forbiddal, however, appears to have been true only of the coenobites of Engedi. More- over, some of the Judaizers, that is Ebionites, are charged with forbidding to marry (1 Tim 4 3). The Essenes in all their varieties seem to have come over to Christianity on the fall of the Jewish state and the retreat of the church to Pella. When they joined the believers in their exile the Parsee elements began a ferment in the church and Ebionism was one of the products. This probably is the meaning of the statement that Ebion began to teach his doc- trines at Pella. If we may judge from the state- ments of Scripture and from the earliest of the non- canonical apocalypses, the Ebionites were not at first heretical in their Christology. Only they maintained the universal obligation of the cere- monial law, holding that believers of gentile descent could be received into the church only if they were first circumcised. The keen dialectic of Paul forced them from this position. The abrogation of the Law was closely connected in Paul’s reasonings with the Divinity of Our Lord; consequently some of them may have felt that they could maintain their views more easily by denying His supreme Divinity and the reality of the incarnation. - The phenomena of His life rendered it impossible for anyone to declare Him to be merely man. Hence the complex notion of a Divine influence—an aeon, coming down upon Him. If, however, His birth were miraculous, then the supreme greatness of Moses would be impugned, consequently they were led to deny the virgin birth. Not till Theodotus appeared was the purely humani- tarian view of Our Lord’s person maintained. All the Heb Christians, however, did not pursue the above course. A large section remained at each general stage, and to the end one portion, the Nazareans, maintained their orthodox doctrinal position, and at the same time obeyed the requirements of the Law. The dualism which is found in the Clementines is an endeavor to explain the ower of evil in the world and the function of Satan. The Clementines confirm the statement of. the Fathers that the Ebionites used only the Gospel of Mt, for there are more quotations from Mt than from all the other books of the NT put together: These quotations are, however, all from chapters after the 3d. There are, it is to be noted, several unmistakable quotations from the Fourth Gospel. In the Clementines as noticed above there is_an avoidance of attributing Divinity to Our Lord. He is the Teacher, the Prophet; oniy in the dis- course ascribed to Barnabas is He called the Son of God. This, we are aware, is the reverse of the ordinarily received idea of the historic succession of beliefs. It is thought that, poser ee the belief in the purely ordinary nature of Our Lord’s birth, these Jewish believers grad- ually added feature after feature until He was regarded as a Divine person, the Divine Logos made flesh by miraculous conception and birth, The abstract possi- bility of such being the course of events is not denied, but we do say that what evidence we have tends in the direction we have taken. There are elements kindred to Ebionism in the Epistle of Jas, the prominence given to the poor, the little prominence given to the Divinity of Our Lord_or to the doctrines of grace all tend in that direction. Yet there is no developed Ebionism; the Divinity of Christ, if not stated in terms, is implied. Schwegler, followed in more recent times by Dr. Camp- bell of Dundee, finds a strong Ebionite bias in the Gospel of Lk, in which certainly there is no lessening of Our Lord's supreme Divinity. All that it amounts to is a prominence given to the poor. The identification of the poor with the righteous has not come down to us as a tenct of the Ebionites; it has been ascribed to them from their name. As ae stated in the Ascension of Isaiah, the Divinity of the Messiah is strongly asserted. The farther down the stream of history we go more and more clearly do the Ebionite features ap ear, till by the time when Alcibiades, the follower of asai, appeared in Rome, we have something widely removed from the Ebionism of the Clementines, far as that is from the simple position occupied by the Nazareans. The Jewish Christians appear to have formed an organization of their own, separate from the church Catholic. The places where they 2. Organ- assembled they did not call ekkléstat, ization of | “churches,” but sunagdgat, ‘“syna- Ebionites gogues.” If we may believe the Clem- entine Homilies they had evolved a complete episcopal system for themselves. We, however, must not think that every variation of faith had a separate organization for itself. Strict Jewish ceremonial allowed no Jew to eat with any other not a Jew. The “love-feasts” of the early church implied this eating in common. If gentile Christians were present the Ebionites could not join, hence the need of a separate church. All Jewish Christians who reverenced the law could meet together and partake of the “love-feast,” whatever their belief as to the person of Christ. In short, Ebionism was a thing of individuals, whose opinion ran through the whole gamut of faith, from the Nazareans, who differed from the orthodox simply in remaining Jews, to those whose Judaism alone prevented them from becoming followers of Theodotus of Byzantium, and who therefore sank back into pure Judaism. V. Evidence from Ebionism for the Doctrine of the Primitive Church.—In dealing with this branch of our subject we have to consider that 1. Chris- the tendency of those who in the early tology of days wrote against heresy was to ex- the Early aggerate the difference between the Church heretics and the orthodox. On the other hand we have to consider the psychological difficulty involved in a person recog- nizing that anyone whom he daily met, whom he saw eating and sleeping like other men, was more than man, was Divine. This difficulty, great to all, was doubly so to the Jew. Yet again we have to consider what the origin of Christian theology was. It was an attempt to give a reasoned and systematic explanation of the phenomenon of Jesus Christ. Christ’s character, His deeds and His claims had to be explained. The orthodox explanation which gradually became more definite as time rolled on was that He was the second person of the Trinity become incarnate, and the purpose of this incarna- tion that He might save many from their sins. This purpose He accomplished by dying on the cross and rising again. The primitive church owed its theology to Paul and John. Repugnant as much of this was to the Jews, yet the Ebionites, earnest, prejudiced Jews as they were, could not affirm in the presence of the facts of His career that Jesus was merely aman. They had to imagine a Divine influence coming down upon Him at His baptism, setting Him apart from all others. We have no trace of this at first: it stands at the end of a process of degradation of the ideal concerning the person of Christ. It was only when the effect of His person- ality had somewhat faded that men began to doubt His Divinity. The division of the personality seems to emerge at the same time. The earlier Ebionites, like the rest of the ist-cent. believers, regarded Christ as one person; only later do they reach the notion of a heavenly aeon separate from Jesus. The Ebionites seem to have held under varying forms a Ebionites Ecclesiastes THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 894 doctrine of the Trinity, and their holding it is an evidence that the church at large held it, not of course in that definiteness it assumed later, but essentially. - To some extent the same may be said in regard to the Pauline doctrine of redemption. It is to be observed that both writers, he of the 2. Paulin- Homilies as well as the writer of the ism of the Recognitions, dislike and ignore Paul, Early even if they do not attempt to pillory Church him under the image of Simon Magus, as many have thought that they do. What, however, is also to be observed, is that they do not venture to denounce him by name. Paul and his teachings must have been, in the early part of the 2d cent., held in such deep reverence that no one could hope to destroy them by direct assault; the only hope was a flank attack. This reverence for Paul implies the reception of all he taught. All the specially Pauline doctrines of original sin, of redemption through the sacrificial death of Christ, and all the cognate ideas must have been held strongly by the early church or the Ebionites would have denounced Paul in the Clementines by name. Schwegler would argue that Justin Martyr was an Ebionite because he neither mentions nor quotes Paul. To this it may be answered that as the em- perors to whom he addressed his apologies were heathens, and Trypho, with whom he had his dia- logue, was a Jew, he naturally did not name one whose authority would be valueless to those he was addressing. He is equally silent as to Peter, James and John. If he doesnot quote Paul there are several indubitable echoes of his phrases and his thoughts. In the face of the recent discoveries made in Egypt one cannot despair of MSS turning up which may throw needed light on this heresy. Were the Gospel according to the Hebrews to be found, or a MS of Hegesippus, we should be in a better position to decide a number of questions. LirERATURE.—Contemporary writers on Ebionites: Irenaeus; Tertullian; Hippolytus; Origen; Eusebius, III, 27; Epiphanius; Jerome; Justin Martyr (Trypho, 47, 48) refers to the Ebionites without naming them. Ebionite writings: Clementine Homilies; Clementine Recognitions: Clementine Epitomes; Asc Isa; Odes of Solomon. Modern church historians: Neander, General History of the Christian Religion and Church; Schréck, Kirchen- geschichte; Walch, Historie der Ketzereien, I, 95-124; Baur, Kirchengeschichte, 1, 172-74, and Dogmengeschichte, 140-61, and Christliche Gnosis; Schwegler, Nachapostoli- sches Zeitalter, 17-198; Ritschl, Altkatholische Kirche, 107-271; Matter, Gnosticisme, III, 11-28; Harnack, History of Dogma, 1-89 ff; Reuss, Hist. de la Théologie, I, 115-25; Donaldson, Christian Literature and Doctrine ve the Death of the Aposiles to the Nicene Council, : 39ff; Mansel, Gnostic Heresies, 123-26; Helgenfeld, Ketzergeschichte, 421-46, and Clementines. Articles in theological dictionaries: Smith and Wace; RE, 1st, 2d and 3d eds; Jew Enc; Holtzman u. Zopf- fel; Lightfoot, Galatians, Disc. III; Colin Campbeli, Studies in St. Luke. J. E. H. Tomson EBIONITES, GOSPEL OF THE. See Apoc- RYPHAL GosPELs; EBIONISM. EBONY, eb’o-ni (0°32, hobhnim [pl. only], vocalization uncertain; cf Arab. dbniis): Mentioned (Ezk 27 15) along with ivory as merchandise of Tyre brought by the men of Dedan. This is the heavy, black, heart-wood of various species of Diospyros, natives of Southern India and Ceylon; the bat kind is obtained from D. ebenum. The sap-wood, being white and valueless, is cut away, but the trunks are sufficiently large to leave blocks of heart-wood 2 ft. in diameter and 10 or more ft. long. Ebony was used by the ancient Egyptians, Greeks and Romans, as well as the Phoenicians, for various purposes; lt was frequently inlaid with ivory. In Europe it has been a favorite for cabinet- making down to recent times. E. W. G. Masterman EBRON, @bruu (j132, ‘ebhkron; AV wrongly, Hebron): A town in the territory of Asher (Josh 19 28). Probably we should read here Abdon, as in Josh 21 30; I Ch 6 74, the substitution of ° for ‘t being a common copyist’s error. See ABDON. EBRONAH, é-bro’na: In AV (Nu 33 34.35) for ABRONAH, which see. ECANUS, é-ka’nus: RV Erxants (q.v). ECBATANA, ek-bat’a-na (Ezr 6 2m). See AcH- METHA. ’ ECCE HOMO, ek’sé hd’mé (I80d 6 avOpwros, idowt ho dnthrépos, ‘Behold, the man!’ Jn 19 5): Pilate’s statement regarding Jesus during His trial. While the significance of this statement is somewhat debatable, yet there is little doubt, as judged from his attitude and statement immediately following, that Pilate was endeavoring to appeal to the ac- cusers’ sympathies and to point out to them the manly qualities of Jesus. The ordinary punc- tuation which places an exclamation point after “Behold” and a period after “the man” is evidently incorrect if the grammatical structure in the Gr is to be observed, which gives to the second and third words the nominative form, and which therefore admits of a mild exclamation, and therefore of the emphasis upon “the man.” Some, however, hold the contrary view and maintain that the utterance - was made in a spirit of contempt and ridicule, as much as to say, “Behold here a mere man.’ See esp. on this view Marcus Dods in Exzpostter’s Gr Test. It would seem, however, that the former of the two views would be sustained by the chief facts in the case. Water G. CLipPpINGcER ECCLESIASTES, e-klé-zi-as'téz, or THE PREACHER (M20P, koheleth; 'Ex«dyovcr§s, Ekklésiastés, perhaps “member of assembly”; see below): Structure of the Book The Contents . Composite Authorship ? . Koheleth “King in Jerusalom”’ Date and Authorship . Linguistic Peculiarities ‘ . Certain Inconclusive Arguments . Canonicity LITERATURE ORNS PONE 895 Reading this book one soon becomes aware that it is a discussion of certain difficult problems of human life. It begins with a title 1. Structure (1 1), followed by a preface (vs 2-11). of the Book lt bas a formal conclusion (12 8~13). Between the preface and the conclu- sion the body of the book is made up of materials of two kinds—first a series of ‘I’ sections, sections uttered in the 1st per. sing., a record of a personal experience; and second, an alternating series of gnomic sections, sections made up of proverbs (say 4 5.6.9-12; 5 1-12; 7 1-14.16-22; 8 1-8; 9 7-10; 10 1-4; 10 8—12 7). These may be called the “thou” sections, as most of them have the pronoun of the 2d per. sing. The idea of the vanity of all things characterizes the record of experience, but it also appears in the ‘‘thou”’ sections (e.g. 99). On the other hand the proverb element is not wholly lacking in the “‘T’’ sections (e.g. 4 1-8). In the preface the speaker lays down the propo- sition that all things are unreal, and that the results of human effort are illusive (1 2.3). 2. The Human generations, day and night, Contents the wind, the streams, are alike the re- petition of an unending round (vs 4-7). The same holds in regard to all human study and thinking (vs 8-11). The speaker shows familiarity with the phenomena which we think of as those of natural law, of the persistence of force, but he thinks of them in the main as monotonously limiting human experience. Nothing is new. All effort of Nature or of man is the doing again of something which has already been done. After the preface the speaker introduces himself, and recounts his experiences. At the outset he had a noble ambition for wisdom and discipline, but all he attained to was unreality and perplexity of mind (vs 12-18). Thisis equally the meaning of the text, whether we translate ‘‘vanity and vexation of spirit” or “vanity and a striving after wind,” (“emptiness, and struggling for breath”), though the first of these two tr*is the better grounded. Finding no adequate satisfaction in the pursuits of the scholar and thinker, taken by themselves, he seeks to combine these with the pursuit of agree- able sensations—alike those which come from luxury and those which come from activity and enterprise and achievement (2 1-12). No one could be in better shape than he for making this experiment, but again he only attains to unreality and perplexity of spirit. He says to himself that at least it is in itself profitable to be a wise man rather than a fool, but his comfort is impaired by the fact that both alike are mortal (vs 138-17). He finds little reassurance in the idea of laboring for the benefit of posterity; posterity is often not worthy (vs 18-21). One may toil unremittingly, but what is the use (vs 22.23)? He does not find himself helped by bringing God into the problem. ‘It is no good for a man that he should eat and drink and make his soul see good in his toil’ (vs 24-26, as most naturally translated), even if he thinks of it as the gift of God; for how can one be sure that the gift of God is anything but luck? He sees, however, that it is not just to dis- miss thus lightly the idea of God as a factor in the problem. It is true that there is a time for every- thing, and that everything is ‘‘beautiful in its time.” It is also true that ideas of infinity are in men’s minds, ideas which they can ncither get rid of nor fully comprehend (3 1-18). Here are tokens of God, who has established an infinite order. If we understood His ways better, that might unravel our perplexities. And if God is, immortality may be, and the solution of our problems may lie in that direction. For a moment it looks as if the speaker were coming out into the light, but doubt resumes its THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Ebionites Ecclesiastes hold upon him. He asks himself, ‘‘Who knoweth?” and he settles back into the darkness. He has previously decided that for a man to “eat and drink, and make his soul enjoy good” is not worth while; and now he reaches the conclusion that, unsatisfactory as this is, there is nothing better (vs 19-22). And so the record of experiences continues, hope- ful passages alternating with pessimistic passages. After a while the agnosticism and pessimism recede somewhat, and the hopeful passages become more positive. Even though “the poor man’s wisdom is despised,” the speaker says, ‘‘the words of the wise heard in quiet are better than the cry of him that ruleth among fools” (9 17). He says ‘‘Surely I know that it shall be well with them that fear God” (8 12), no matter how strongly appearances may indicate the contrary. The gnomic sections are mostly free from agnos- ticism and pessimism. The book as a whole sums itself up in the conclusion, ‘‘Fear God, and keep his commandments” (12 13). Of course the agnostic and pessimistic utterances in Eccl are to be regarded as the presentation of one side of an argument. Disconnect them and they are no part of the moral and religious teaching of the book, except in an indirect way. At no point should we be justified in thinking of the author as really doubting in regard to God or moral obligation. He delineates for us a soul in the toils of mental and spiritual conflict. It is a delineation which may serve for warning, and which is in other ways wholesomely instructive; and in the outcome of it, itis full of encouragement. In some passages the speaker in Eccl has in mind the solution of the problems of life which we are accustomed to call Epicurean (e.g. 5 18-20; 7 16. 17; 8 15; but not 2 24)—the solution which con- sists in avoiding extremes, and in getting from life as many agreeable sensations as possible; but it is not correct to say that he advocates this philosophy. He rather presents it as an alternative. His conclusion is the important part of his reason- ing. All things are vanity. Everything passes away. Yet (he says) it is better to read and use good words than bad words. Therefore because the Great, Teacher is wise, he ever teaches the people knowledge, and in so doing he ever seeks good words, acceptable words, upright words, words of truth. “The words of the wise are as goads; and as nails well fastened” (‘‘clinched at the back’’) (12 11). Such are the words of all the great masters. So (he ends) my son, be warned! There are many books in this world. Choose good ones. And his conclusion is: Reverence the Mighty Spirit. Keep to good principles. That is the whole duty of man. For everything at last becomes clear; and “good” stands out clearly from “‘evil.”” We have noticed that our book has “I” sections and “thou” sections. Certainly these are structural ’ marks, but as such they are capable of 3. Com- being interpreted in various ways. posite Au- Partitional hypotheses can easily be thorship? formed, and perhaps there is no great objection to them; but there are no phenomena which cannot be accounted for by the hypothesis that we have here just the work of one author, who sometimes quotes proverbial utter- ances, either his own or those of other men. As proving the integrity of the book three points present themselves. First, in some cases (e.g. 7 14b-16) the experience matter and the gnomic matter are closely combined in sense and in gram- matical construction. Second, it is possible to inter- pret all the gnomic sections as a part of the contin- uous argument. Third, if we so interpret them the book is a unit, the argument moving forward con- Ecclesiastes Eden THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 896 tinuously out of the speculative into the practical, and out of the darkness into the light. The speaker in Eccl calls himself Kéheleth (1 1. 2.12 and other places), rendered ‘‘the Preacher” in the EV. The word does not occur 4. Koheleth elsewhere, although it is from a stem that is in common use. Apparently it has been coined for a purpose by the author of Eccl. In form it is a fem. participle, though it denotes a man. This is best explained as a case of the using of an abstract expression for a concrete, as when in Eng. we say “Your Honor,” “Your Majesty.” The other words of the stem are used of people gathering in assemblies, and the current explanation is to the effect that Koheleth is a person who draws an audience whom he may address. ‘To this there are two objections: First, the participle is intransitive; its natural implication is that of a person who participates in an assembly, not of one who causes the participants to assemble. Second, the assembly distinctively indicated by the words of this stem is the official assembly for the tran- saction of public business. Worked out on this basis Koheleth seems to mean citizenship, or concretely, a citizen—a citizen of such respectability that he is entitled to participate in public assemblies. It is in the character of citizen-king that the speaker a Eccl relates his experiences and presents his ideas. This word for “assembly” and its cognates are in the Gr often tr? by ekklésia and its cognates (e.g. Dt 410; 9 10; Jgs 20 2; 215.8). So we are not surprised to find Kéheleth rendered by the Gr Ekklésiastés, and this Latinized into Ecclesiastes. The speaker in Eccl speaks not only in the character of Koheleth, but in that of “the son of David, king in Jerus” (1 1). So far as 5. ‘King in this clause is concerned the king in Jerusalem” question might be either Solomon or any other king of the dynasty, or might be a composite or an ideal king. He is repre- sented (1 12—2 11) as ‘‘king over Israel,” and as distinguished for wisdom, for his luxuries, for his great enterprises in building and in business. These marks fit Solomon better than any other king of the dynasty, unless possibly Uzziah. Possibly it is not absurd to apply to Solomon even the phrase “all that were before me over Jerus,” or ‘in Jerus” (1 16; 27.9; cf 1 Ch 2925; 1K 312; 2Ch 1 12). It is safer, however, to use an alternative statement. The speaker in Eccl is either Solomon or some other actual or composite or ideal king of the dynasty of David. If it were agreed that Solomon is the citizen king who, in Eccl, is represented as speaking, that would not be the same thing as agreeing that 6. Date and Solomon is the author of the book. Authorship No one thinks that Sir Galahad is the author of Tennyson’s poem of that name. Koheleth the king is the character into whose mouth the author of Ecclesiastes puts the utterances which he wishes to present, but it does not follow that the author is himself Koheleth. The statement is often made that Jewish tradi- tion attributes the writing of Eccl to Solomon; but can anyone cite any relatively early tradition to this effect? Is this alleged tradition anything else than the confusing of the author with the character whom he has sketched? The well-known classic tradition in Babha’ Bathra’ attributes Eccl to ‘Hezekiah and his company,’’ not to Solomon. And the tra- dition which 1s represented by the order in which the books occur in the Heb Bibles secms to place it still later. Concerning this tradition two facts are to be noted: First, it classes Eccl with the 5 miscel- laneous books (Cant, Ruth, Lam, Eccl, Est) known as the five m¢ghilldth, the five Rolls. Second, in the count of books which makes the number 22 or 24 it classes Eccl as one of the last 5 books (Eccl, Est, Dan, Ezr-Neh, 1 and 2 Ch). That the men who made this arrangement regarded the books of this group as the latest in the Bible is a natural inference. ; This agrees with the internal marks which con- stitute the principal evidence we have on this point. The grammatical character and the 7. Linguis- vocabulary of Eccl are exceptionally tic Pecul- peculiar, and they strongly indicate iarities that the book was written in the same literary period with these other latest books of the OT. ‘The true date is not much earlier or later than 400 BC (see Curonicies), though many place it a cent. or a cent. and a half later. Details concerning these phenomena may be found in Driver’s Introduction or other Introductions, or in commentaries. Only a few of the points will be given here, with barely enough illustrative instances to render the poinis intelligible. In Eccl the syntax of the vb. is peculiar. The imperfect with waw consecutive, the ordinary Heb narrative tense, occurs—for example, ‘‘And I applied my heart” (1 17)—but it is rare. The narrator habitually uses the perfect with waw (eg. 113; 2 11.12.14.15b¢s.17). In any Eng. book we should find it very noticeable if the author were in the habit of using the progressive form of the vb. instead of the ordinary form—if instead of saying “And I applied my heart” he should say “And I was applying my heart,’ “And I was look- ing on all the works,” ‘‘And I was turning” (1 13; 2 11.12), and so on. Another marked peculiarity is the frequent repeating of the pronoun along with the vb.: ‘I said in my heart, even I’; ‘And I was hating, even I, all my labor’ (2 1.18 and contin- ually). The use of the pronoun as copula is abnor- mally common in Eccl as compared with other parts of the Heb Bible (e.g. 4 2). The abbreviated form of the relative pronoun is much used instead of the full form, and in both forms the pronoun is used disproportionately often asa conjunction. In these and many similar phenomena the Heb of Eccl is affiliated with that of the later times. The vocabulary presents phenomena that have the same bearing. Words of the stem tékan appear in Eccl (1 15; 7 13; 12 9) and in the Aram. of Dnl (4 36), and not elsewhere in the Bible; they are frequent in the Talm. Words of the stem zaman (3 1) are used only in Eccl, Ezr, Neh, Dnl, Est. Words of the stem sh@lat, the stem whence comes our word “sultan,” are frequent in Eccl—words which are used elsewhere only in the avowedly post- exilian books and in Gen 42 6, though a different word of this stem appears in the history of the time of David. Only in Eccl and Est are found the vb. kdshér, “to be correct” (whence the modern Jewish kosher) and its derivative kishrén. The Pers word pardés, “park” (2 5), octurs elsewhere only in Neh and Cant, and the Pers word pithgdm, “official decision” or “record” (8 11), only in Est 1 20, and in the Aram. parts of Ezr and Dnl. Eccl also abounds in late words formed from earlier stems— for example, sekhel and sikh*lith, “folly” (10 6; 2 3, et al.); or m*dhingh, “province” (5 8), frequent in the latest books, but elsewhere found only in one passagein 1 K (20 14.15.17.19). Esp. common are new derivatives that end in n, for example, yith- ron, “profit”; ‘inydn, “travail”; hesron, “that which is missing”; ra‘ydn, ‘“vexation” (1 3.13.15.17 and often). To these add instances of old words used in new meanings, and the various other groups of phenomena that are usual in such cases. No parts of the book are free from them. The arguments for a later date than that which has been assigned are inconclusive. The Heb of 897 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Ecclesiastes Eden Eccl is more like the language of the Talmuds than is that of the Chronicler or Dnl or even Est; but if one infer that Eccl is therefore later 8. Certain than the others the inference will prove Inconclusive to be in various ways embarrassing. Arguments The differences are better accounted for by the fact that Eccl belongs to a different type of lit. from the others. Various passages have local color (e.g. 11 1), or make the impression of being allusions to specific events (e.g. 4 13-16; 6 2.38; 9 13-18), but the difficulty lies in locating the events. Dr. Kleinert argues plausibly for the writing of the book in Egypt in the time of the Ptolemies, but other equally probable hypotheses might be devised. It is alleged that Eccl copies from Ecclus, but it is more probable that the latter copied from the former. It is alleged that the Wisd controverts Eccl; if it does, that does not prove that the two are contemporary. It is alleged that the writer is familiar with the philosophy of Epicurus, and there- fore must have lived later than Epicurus, who died 270 BC, or even later than Lucretius of the 1st cent. BC. If there were proof that this was a case of borrowing, Epicurus or Lucretius might have been the borrowers; but there is no such proof; the selfishness which constitutes the nucleus of Epicu- reanism has exhibited itself in human lit. from the beginning. The strong resemblances hetween Eccl and Omar Khayy4m have no weight to prove that the Heb author was later than the Pers. Eccl pre- sents a perfectly distinct doctrine of immortality, whether it affirms the doctrine or not; but that proves a relatively early date for the doctrine, rather than a late date for Eccl. At every point the marks of Eccl are those of the Pers period, not of the Gr. In the early Christian cents., as in all the cents. since, there have been disputes concerning the canonicity of Eccl. It was not ques- 9. Canon- tioned that Eccl belonged to the canon icity as traditionally handed down. No question of admitting it to the canon was raised. But it was challenged because of the agnostic quality of some of its contents, and, every time, on close examination, the challenge was de- cided in its favor. Lizeraturs.—There are volumes on Eccl in all the great commentaries, and treatments of it in the volumes on Introduction. A few of the many separate com- mentaries are those of Moses Stuart, Andover, 1864; H. Gratz, Leipzig, 1871; G. Wildeboer, Ttibingen, 1898; E. H. Plumptre, Cambridge, 1881. Other works are those of J. F. Genung, Eccl, and Omar Khayydm, 1901, Words of Koheleth, 1904, and The Hebrew Lit. of Wisdom in the Light of Today, 1906; ©. H. H. Wright, Book of Koheleth, 1883; 8. Schiffer, Das_Buch Coheleth nach Talmud und Midrasch, 1885; A. H. McNeile, Intro to Eecl, New York, 1904. Wiuus J. BEECHER ECCLESIASTICUS, e-klézi-as’ti-kus. See Srracu. ECLIPSE, é-klips’. ED (7%, ‘adh, “witness”): The name of the altar erected by the trans-Jordanic tribes upon finally taking possession of Gilead (Josh 22 10.11.34); probably E. of the Jordan opposite Jericho. But neither the MT nor the LXX contained the word. Both the AV and RV, however, insert the word on the authority of afew MSS. It has been suggested that it is the final ‘édh in Gal‘édh, the name given hy Laban and Jacob to the memorial heap of stones erected by them in the vicinity (Gen 31 47.48). According to the MT, the name of the altar is the entire sentence: “It is a witness between us that Jeh isGod.”’ The opposition of the ten tribes to the erec- tion of this altar was on the score that it was built after the pattern of the great altar of burnt offering (Josh 22 11.29), which was a horned altar forbidden See ASTRONOMY. in ordinary lay.sacrifice. There is init, therefore, no indication of a general opposition to lay sacrifices on altars of earth or unhewn stone (see Wiener, EPC, 198). Grorce Freperick WRIGHT EDAR, &'dir. EDDIAS, ed-i’as. EDDINUS, ed’i-nus (B, ’H88ewvods, Eddeinois, A, 'E88ivois, Eddinowis): One of the “holy singers’ at Josiah’s Passover (1 Esd 1 15). AV reads here Jeduthun, the corresponding name in the || passage (2 Ch 86 15). EDEN, @d’n (J12, ‘édhen, “delight”; "H8ep, Edem): ; (1) The land in which ‘“Jeh God planted a garden,” where upon his creation “he put the man whom he had formed” (Gen 2 8). In the Assyr inscriptions idinu (Accadian édin) means “plain” and it is from this that the Bib. word is probahly derived. Follow- ing are the references to Eden in the Bible, aside from those in Gen 2 and 8: Gen 4 16; Isa 51 3; Ezk 28 18; 31 9.16.18; 36 35; Jocl 2 3. The Garden of Eden is said to be “eastward, in Eden” (Gen 2 8); where the vegetation was luxurious (2 9) and the fig tree indigenous (3 7), and where it was watered hy irrigation. All ki See Evsr. See Ieppias. inds of animals, including cattle, beasts of the field and birds, were found there (2 19.20). Moreover the climate was such that clothing was not needed for warmth. It is not surprising, therefore, that the pl. of the word has the meaning “delights,” and that Eden has been supposed to mean the land of delights, and that the word became a synonym for Paradise. The location of Eden is in part to be determined from the description already given. It must he where there is a climate adapted to the production of fruit trees and of animals capable of domestica- tion, and in general to the existence of man in his primitive condition. In particular, its location is supposed to be determined by the statements regarding the rivers coursing through it and sur- rounding it. There is a river (na@har) (Gen 2 10) which was parted and became four heads (ro’shim), a word which (Jgs 8 16; Job 117) designates main detachments into which an army is divided, and therefore would more properly signify branches than heads, permitting Jos and others to interpret the river as referring to the ocean, which by the Greeks was spoken of as the river (6keanés) surround~ ing the world. According to Jos, the Ganges, the Tigris, the Euphrates and the Nile are the four rivers, being but branches of this one river. More- over it is contended hy some, with much show of reason, that the word p*rath tr‘ Euphrates is a more general term, signifying “the broad” or “deep” river, and so may here refer to some other stream than the Euphrates, possibly to a river in some other region whose name is perpetuated in_the present Euphrates, as “the Thames” of New Eng- land perpetuates the memory of the Thames of Old England. In ancient times there was a river Phrath in Persia, and perhaps two._ It is doubtful whether the phrase ‘eastward, in Eden” refers to the position with reference to the writer or simply with reference to Eden itself. So far as that phrase is concerned, therefore, speculation is left free to range over the whole earth, and this it has done. Columbus when passing the mouth of the Orinoco surmised that its waters came down from the Garden of Eden. It is fair to say, however, that he supposed himself to be upon the E. coast of Asia. The traditions of its location somewhere in Central Asia are numerous and persistent. Natur- alists have, with Quatrefages, pretty generally fixed 1. Central Asia Eden Edom, Edomites THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 898 - upon the portion of Central Asia stretching E. from the Pamir, often referred to as the roof of the world, and from which flow four great rivers—the Indus, the Tarim, the Sur Daria (Jaxartes), and the Amu Daria (Oxus)—as the original cradle of man- kind. This conclusion has been arrived at from the fact that at the present time the three fundamental types of the races of mankind are grouped about this region. The Negro races are, indeed, in gen- eral far removed from the location, but still frag- ments of them both pure and mixed are found in various localities both in the interior and on the sea- shore and adjacent islands where they would nat- urally radiate from this center, while the yellow and the white races here meet at the present time in close contact. In the words of Quatrefages, ‘“‘No other region of the globe presents a similar union of extreme human types distributed round a common center” (The Human Species, 176). Philology, also, points to this same conclusion. On the E. are the monosyllabic languages, on the N. the polysyllabic or agglutinative languages, and on the W. and 8S. the inflectional or Aryan languages, of which the Sanskrit is an example, being closely allied to nearly all the languages of Europe. More- over, it is to this center that we trace the origin of nearly all our domesticated plants and animals. Naturally, therefore, the same high authority writes, “There we are inclined to say the first human beings appeared and multiplied till the populations over- flowed as from a bowl and spread themselves in waves in every direction” (ib, 177). With this conclusion, as already said, a large number of most eminent authorities agree. But it should be noted that if, as we believe, there was a universal destruc- tion of antediluvian man, the center of dispersion had in view by these naturalists and archaeologists would be that from the time of Noah, and so would not refer to the Eden from which Adam and Eve were driven. The same may be said of Haeckel’s theory that man originated in a submerged conti- nent within the area of the Indian Ocean. Dr. William F. Warren has with prodigious learn- ing attempted to show that the original Eden was at the North Pole, a theory which has 2. The too many considerations in its support North Pole tq be cast aside unceremoniously, for it certainly is true that in preglacial times a warm climate surrounded the North Pole in all the lands which have been explored. In Northern Greenland and in Spitzbergen abundant remains of fossil plants show that during the middle of the Tertiary period the whole circumpolar region was characterized by a climate similar to that pre- vailing at the present time in Southern Europe, Japan, and the southern United States (see Asa Gray’s lectures on ‘Forest Geography and Archae- ology” in the American Journal of Science, CXVI, 85-94, 183-96, and Wright, [ce Age in North Amer- ica, 5th ed, ch xvii). But as the latest discoveries have shown that there is no land within several hundred miles of the North Pole, Dr. Warren’s theory, if maintained at all, will have to be modified so as to place Eden at a considerable distance from the actual pole. Furthermore, his theory would involve the existence of ‘‘Tertiary man,” and thus extend his chronology to an incredible extent, even though with Professor Green (see ANTEDILUVIANS) we are permitted to consider the genealogical table of Gen 6 as sufficiently elastic to accommodate itself to any facts which may be discovered. Much also can be said in favor of identifying Eden with Armenia, for it is here that the Tigris and Euphrates have their origin, while 8. Armenia two others, the Aras (Araxes) emptying into the Caspian Sea and the Choruk (thought by some to be the Phasis) emptying into the Black Sea, would represent the Gihon and the Pishon. Havilah would then be identified with | Colchis, famous for its golden sands. But Cush is difficult to find in that region; while these four rivers could by no possibility be regarded as branches of one parent stream. Two theories locate Eden in the Euphrates valley. Of these the first would place it near the head of the Pers Gulf where the Tigris and Eu- 4. Baby- _phrates after their junction form the lonia Shaitt el-’ Arab which bifurcates into the eastern and the western arm before reaching the Gulf. Calvin considered the Pishon to be the eastern arm and the Gihon the western arm. Other more recent authorities modify the theory by supposing that Gihon and Pishon are represented by the Karum and the Kerkhah rivers which come into the Shatt el-’ Arab from the east. The most plausible objection to this theory is that the Bib. account represents all these branches as down stream from the main river, whereas this theory supposes that two of them at least are up stream. This objection has been ingeniously met by calling attention to the fact that 2,000 years before Christ the Pers Gulf extended up as far as Eridu, 100 miles above the present mouth of the river, and that the Tigris and the Euphrates then entered the head of the Gulf through separate channels, the enormous amount of silt brought down by the streams having converted so much of the valley into dry land. In consequence of the tides which extend up to the head of the Gulf, the current of all these streams would be turned up stream periodically, and so account for the Bib. statement. In this case the river (n@hdr) would be represented by the Pers Gulf itself, which was indeed called by the Babylonians nar marratum, “the bitter river.’ This theory is further sup- ported by the fact that according to the cuneiform inscriptions Eridu was reputed to have in its neigh- borhood a garden, “‘a holy place,” in which there grewasacred palm tree. This “‘tree of life’ appears frequently upon the inscriptions with two guardian spirits standing on either side. The other theory, advocated with great ability by Friedrich Delitzsch, places Eden just above the site of ancient Babylon, where the Tigris and Euphrates approach to within a short distance of one another and where the country is intersected by numerous irrigating streams which put off from the Euphrates and flow into the Tigris, whose level is here considerably lower than that of the Euphrates —the situation bemg somewhat such as it is at New Orleans where the Mississippi River puts off nu- merous streams which empty into Lake Pontchar- train. Delitzsch supposes the Shatt el- Nil, which flows eastward into the Tigris, to be the Gihon, and the Pallacopas, flowing on the W. side of the Euphrates through a region producing gold, to be the Pishon. The chief difficulties attending this theory pertain to the identification of the Pishon with the Pallacopas, and the location of Havilah on its banks. There is difficulty, also, in all these theories in the identification of Cush (Ethiopia), later associated with the country from which the Nile emerges, thus giving countenance to the belief of Jos and many others that that river represented the Gihon. If we are compelled to choose between these theories it would seem that the one which lo- cates Eden near the head of the Pers Gulf combines the greater number of probabilities of every kind. (2) A Levite of the time of Hezekiah (2 Ch 29 12; 31 15). Literature,Dawson, Modern Science in Bible Lands; Friedrich Delitasch, Wo lag das Paradies? (1881); Sayce, HCM, 95 ff; Hommel, Anc. Heb Tradition, 314; William F. Warren, Paradise Found, 1885. Georce FREDERICK WRIGHT 899 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA E4e8 Edom, Edomites EDEN, CHILDREN OF. See CuwILpREeNn or Eben. EDEN, HOUSE OF. See Aven; BETH-EDEN; CHILDREN oF Even. EDER, é’dér (3Y , ‘édher, “flock’’): (1) One of the “uttermost cities’ of Judah in the Negeb (‘South’) near the border of Edom (Josh 15 21), possibly Kh. el ‘Adar, 5 miles S. of Gaza, but probably this is too far west. (2) Eder (AV Edar) or better Migdal Eder, wT, mighdal ‘édher, “the tower of the flock”; T'déep, Gdder. After Rachel died and was buried ‘in the way to Ephrath (the same is Beth- lehem) . . . . Israel journeyed, and spread his tent beyond the tower of Eder’ (Gen 35 19.21). In ver 27 he is described as proceeding to Hebron. This ‘‘tower of the flock,’ which may have been only a tower and no town, must therefore be looked for between Bethlehem and Hebron. Jerome says that it was one Rom mile from Bethlehem. In the LXX, however, vs 16 and 21 are transposed, which suggests that there may have been a tradition that Migdal Eder was between Bethel and Bethlehem. There must have been many such towers for guard- ing flocks against robbers. Cf ‘‘tower of the watch- man” (2 K 18 8, etc). The phrase “‘Migdal Eder” occurs in Mic 4 8 where Jerus is compared to such a tower. E. W. G. MasterMan EDER, é'dér ("IY ‘édher, “flock’’). (1) A Merarite Levite in the days of David (1 Ch 23 23; 24 30); son of Mushi. (2) A Benjamite (1 Ch 8 15, AV ‘“‘Ader”). EDES, é’déz: RV Epos (q.v.). EDGE, ej: Very frequently occurs in the phrase “the edge of the sword” (Josh 10 28, et al.) from the Heb M8, peh, “lip,” or MW, saphah, “lip.” Ex 28 7 and 39 4read “ends,” from MEP, kaeah, “end” (AV “edge”), and Josh 13 27 has “uttermost part”’ for the same Heb word (AV “edge’’). In Jer 31 29 and Ezk 18 2, ‘‘The children’s teeth are set on edge” (UIP , kahah, “to be blunt”), i.e. set hard one against another. EDIFICATION, ed-i-fi-ka’shun, EDIFY, ed’i-fi: The Gr words olxedouéw, oikodoméés, “to build,” olxodouy, oikodomé, ‘the act of building,” are used both lit. and fig. in the NT; “edify,” “edifying,” “edification,” are the tr of AV in some 20 passages, all in the fig. sense of the promotion of growth in Christian character. RV in 2 Cor 10 8; 13 10; Eph 4 12.16; 1 Thess 5 11 renders “build up,” “building up,”’ making the force of the figure clearer to the Eng. reader. In 1 Tim 1 4 the Gr text followed by RV has olxovoula, oikonomta, ‘“dispen- sation,” instead of olxodoule, oikodomia, “edifying” F. K. Farr EDNA, ed’na ('E6va, Hdna): Wife of Raguel and mother of Sarah who married Tobias (Tob 7 2, etc; 10 12; 11 1). E. in Heb means “pleasure’’ and corresponds to Lat Anna. EDOM, é‘dum, EDOMITES, é’dum-its (O78, ’édhom, “red”; 'E8ép, Edém): The boundaries of Edom may be traced with some ap- proach to accuracy. On the E. of the ‘Arabah the northern border ran from the Dead Sea, and was marked by Wady el-Kurahi, or Wddy el-Hasé. On the EH. it marched with the desert. The southern border ran by Elath and Ezion-geber (Dt 2 8). On the W. of 1. Bound- aries the ‘Arabah the north boundary of Edom is deter- mined by the south border of Israel, as indicated in Nu 34 3f: a line running from the Salt Sea south- ward of the Ascent of Akrabbim to Zin and Kadesh- barnea. This last, we are told, lay in the “utter- most” of the border of Edom (Nu 20 16). The line may be generally indicated by the course of Waddy el-Fikrah. How much of the uplands W. of the ‘Arabah southward to the Gulf of ‘Akaba was included in Edom it is impossible to say. The land thus indicated varies greatly in char- acter and features. S. of the Dead Sea in the bottom of the valley we have first the 2. Charac- stretch of salt marsh land called es- ter and Sebkha; then, beyond the line of white Features cliffs that crosses the valley diagonally from N.W. to S.E., a broad depression strewn with stones and sandhills, the débris of an old sea bottom, rises gradually, and 60 miles to the 8. reaches a height of about 700 ft. above the level of the Red Sea, 2,000 ft. above that of the Dead Sea. From this point it sinks until it reaches the shore of the Gulf of ‘Akaba, 45 milesfartherS. The whole depression is known today as Wddy el-‘ Arabah (cf Heb ha-‘drabhadh, Dt 2 8 RV, etc). On either side the mountains rise steeply from the valley, their edges carved into many fantastic shapes by the deep wadys that break down from the interior (see AraBan). The northern part of the plateau on the W. forms the spacious grazing ground of the ‘Azd- zimeh Arabs. The mountains rise to a height of from about 1,500 ft. to a little over 2,000 ft. This district was traversed by the ancient caravan road to South Pal; and along the eastern side traces of the former civilization are still to be seen. The desert region to the S. is higher, reaching to as much as 2,600 it. The mountain range E. of the ‘Arabah is generally higher in the S. than in the N. Jebel Hartin, beside Petra, is 4,780 ft. above sea-level; while E. of ‘Akaba, Jebel el-Hisma& may be as much as 5,900 ft. in height. Limestone, porphyry and Nubian sandstone are the prevailing formation; but voleanic rocks are also found. The range consists mainly of rough rocky heights with many almost inaccessible peaks separated by deep gorges. But there are also breadths of fertile land where wheat, grapes, figs, pomegranates and olives are grown to advantage. The northern district is known today by the name el-Jebdl, corresponding to the ancient Gebal. Seir is the name applied to the eastern range in Gen 36 8; Dt 2 1.5; 2 Ch 20 23. It is also called Edom, and the Mount of Esau (Ob vs 81). Seir, however, is used for the western high- lands in Dt 33 2. This seems to be its meaning also in Jgs 5 4, where it appears as the equivalent of “the field of Edom.” With this same phrase, however, in Gen 82 3 it may more fitly apply to the eastern range. See illustration under DrsErt. The name Edom, “red,” may have been derived from the red sandstone cliffs characteristic of the country. It was applied to Esau 3. Origin because of the color of his skin (Gen of Name 26 25), or from the color of the pottage for which he sold his birthright (ver 30). In Gen 36 8 Esau is equated with Edom as dwelling in Mt. Seir; and he is described as the father of Edom (ver 9, Heb). The name however is probably much older. It may be traced in the records of the Twelfth Dynasty in Egypt. In the Am Tab (Brit Mus No. 64) Udumu, or Edom, is named; and in Assyr inscriptions the name Udumu occurs of a city and of a country. The latter may have been named from the former: this again may have been derived from a deity, Edom, who may be traced in such a name as Obed-edom (2 S 6 10). The children of Esau are said to have ‘‘destroyed” the Horites who dwelt in Seir before them (Gen 14 Edom, Edomites Education THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 900 6; Dt 2 22). This only means that the Horites were subdued. Esau married the daughter of Anah, a Horite (Gen 36 20—in ver 2 he is called a Hivite); and the lists in this chapter show that the races inter- mingled. The Horite government was in the hands of “dukes” (Gen 36 29f, RV ‘‘chiefs”). They were succeeded by dukes of the house of Esau (vs 40 ff). This form of government gave way to that of an elective monarchy (vs 31 ff); and this had existed some time before Israel left the wilderness. The then reigning king would not permit Israel to pass through the land (Nu 20 14ff; 21 4). Israel was forbidden to “abhor an Edomite,” on the ground that he was a brother; and children of the third generation might enter the assembly of the Lord (Dt 23 7f). War with Edom was out of the question. Some thirty years after the Exodus, Ramses III “smote the people of Seir.”’ The Israelites could not have been far off. We first hear of war between Israel and Edom under Saul (1 S 14 47). David prosecuted the war with terrific energy, slaying 18,000 Edomites (so read instead of ‘“Syrians’’) in the Valley of Salt (2 8 8 13f); Joab remaining for six months in the country, which was garrisoned by Israelites, “until he had cut off every male in Edom” (1 K 11 15f). Hadad of the blood royal of Edom escaped to Egypt, and later became a source of trouble to Solomon (vs 141.25). The conquest of Edom opened to Israel the ports of the Red Sea, whence the expeditions of Solomon and Jehoshaphat set out. In Jehoshaphat’s time the king is called a “deputy” (22 47). Its king acknowledged the supremacy of Judah (2 K 3 9, etc). Under Je- horam son of Jehoshaphat, Edom revolted. Jeho- ram defeated them at Zair, but was unable to quell the rebellion (8 20ff). Amaziah invaded the country, slew 10,000 in the Valley of Salt, and took Sela which he named Joktheel (14 7). Uzziah restored the Edomite port of Elath (14 22). In the Syrian war Rezin regained Elath for Syria, and cast out the Jews. It was then permanently occu- ied by Syrians—here also probably we should read domites (16 6). From the cuneiform iscrip- tions we learn that when Tiglath-pileser subdued Rezin, among the kings from whom he received homage at Damascus was Qaus-malaka of Edom (736 BC). Later Malik-ram paid homage to Sen- nacherib. To Ezarhaddon also they were com- pelled to render service. They gave what help they could to Nebuchadnezzar, and exulted in the destruction of Jerus, stirring the bitterest indigna- tion in the hearts of the Jews (Lam 4 21; Ezk 26 12; 36 3ff; Ob vs 10ff). The Edomites pressed into the now empty lands in the S. of Judah. In 300 BC Mt. Seir with its capital Petra fell into the hands of the Nabataeans. West of the ‘Arabah the country they eccupied came to be known by the Gr name Idumaea, and the people 5. Idumaea as Idumaeans. Hebron, their chief and the city, was taken by Judas Maccabaeus Idumaeans in 165 BC (1 Macc 4 29.61; 5 65). In 126 BC the country was subdued by John Hyrcanus, who compelled the people to become Jews and to submit to circumcision. Anti- pater, governor of Idumaea, was made procurator of Judaea, Samaria and Galilee by Julius Caesar. He paved the way to the throne for his son Herod the Great. With the fall of Judah under the Romans, Idumaea disappears from history. The names of several Edomite deities are known: Hadad, Qaus, Kozé, and, possibly, Edom; but of the religion of Edom we are without information. The language differed little from Heb. W. Ewina 4. History EDOS, @’dos (H8ats, Edais; AV Edes): One who agreed to put away his foreign wife (1 Esd 9 35); called Iddo, AV “Jadan,” in Ezr 10 48. EDREI, ed’ré-i CITTS, ’edhre't; "Hipdev, Edrd- ein): (1) One of the cities of Og, not far from Ashtaroth, where the power of his kingdom received its death- blow from the invading Israelites (Josh 12 4; Nu 21 33 ff, etc). It seems to mark the western limit of Bashan as against Salecah on the E. (Dt 3 10). It was given to Machir, son of Manasseh (Josh 13 31). Onom places it 24 Rom miles from_Bostra. The most probable identification is with Der‘ah, a town of between 4,000 and 5,000 inhabitants, on the southern lip of Wady Zeidch, about 29 miles as the crow flies E. of the Sea of Galilee. It is the center of an exceedingly fruitful district. The accumu- lated rubbish in the town covers many remains of antiquity. It is, however, chiefly remarkable for the extraordinary subterranean city, as yet only partially explored, cut in the rock under the town. This is certainly very ancient, and was doubtless used by the inhabitants as a refuge in times of stress and peril. For a description see Schumacher, Across the Jordan, 121 ff. (2) A place not identified, between Kedesh and En-hazor (Josh 19 37). W. Ewrye EDUCATION, ed-t-ka’shun: I. Epucation Derinep II. Epucarion 1n Earty I[sraEu 1. Nomadic aud Agricultural Periods . The Monarchical Period . Deuteronomic Legislation . Reading and Writing DUCATION IN LaTER [sRaBL . Educational Significance of the Prophets - The Book of the Law . Wise Men or Sages . The Book of Proverbs . Scribes and _Levites . Greek and Roman Influences POb ITI. re Anhwn IV. cI DUCATION IN New TEsTaAMENT TIMES . Subject Matter of Instruction - Method and Aims . Valuable Results of Jewish Education 4, The Preéminence of Jesus as a Teacher 5. Educational Work of the Early Disciples LitERATURE Ne I. Education Defined.—By education we under- stand the sum total of those processes whereby society transmits from one generation to the next its accumulated social, intellectual and religious experience and heritage. In part these processes are informal and incidental, arising from partici- pation in certain forms of social life and activity which exist on their own account and not for the sake of their educative influence upon the rising generation. The more formal educative processes are designed (1) to give the immature members of society a mastery over the symbols and technique of civilization, including language (reading and writing), the arts, the sciences, and religion, and (2) to enlarge the fund of individual and community knowledge beyond the measure furnished by the direct activities of the immediate environment (ef Dewey, art. on “Education” in Monroe’s CE; ef Butler, ME). Religious education among ancient and modern peoples alike reveals clearly this twofold aspect of all education. On its informal side it consists in the transmission of religious ideas and experience by means of the reciprocal processes of imitation and example; each generation, by actually par- ticipating in the religious activities and ceremonies of the social group, imbibing as it were the spirit and ideals of the preceding generation as these are modified by the particular economic and industrial conditions under which the entire process takes place. Formal religious education begins with the 901 conscious and systematic effort on the part of the mature members of a social group (tribe, nation, or religious fellowship) to initiate the immature mem- bers by means of solemn rites and ceremonies, or patient training, or both, into the mysteries and high privileges of their own religious fellowship and experience. As regards both the content and form of this instruction, these will in every case be deter- mined by the type and stage of civilization reflected in the life, occupations, habits and customs of the people. Among primitive races educational method is simpler and the content of formal instruction less differentiated than on higher culture levels (Ames, PRE). All education is at first religious in the sense that religious motives and ideas predominate in the educational efforts of all primitive peoples. The degree to which religion continues preéminent in the educational system of a progressive nation depends upon the vitality of its religion and upon the measure of efficiency and success with which from the first that religion is instilled into the very bone and sinew of each succeeding generation. Here lies the explanation of the religious-educational character of Heb national life, and here, too, the secret of Israel’s incomparable influence upon the religious and educational development of the world. The religion of Israel was a vital religion and it was a teaching religion (Kent, GT JC). il, Education in Early Israel (from Patriarchal Times to the Exile).—In their social and national development the Hebrews passed through several clearly marked cultural stages which it is important to note in connection with their educational history. At the earliest point at which the OT gives us any knowledge of them, they, like their ancestors, were nomads and shepherds. Their chief interest cen- tered in the flocks and herds from which they gained a livelihood, and in the simple, useful arts that seem gradually to have become hereditary in certain families. With the settlement of the Heb tribes in Pal and their closer contact with Canaanitish cul- ture, a more established agricultural life with result- ing changes in social and religious institutions gradu- ally superseded the nomadic stage of culture. A permanent dwelling-place made possible, as the con- tinual warfare of gradual conquest made necessary, a closer federation of the tribes, which ultimately resulted in the establishment of the monarchy under David (W. R. Smith, RS; Davidson, HE). In these earliest cultural periods, both the no- madic and the agricultural, there was no distinct separation between the spheres of 1. Nomadic religion and ordinary life. The rela- and Agri- tion of the people to Yahweh was con- cultural ceived by them in simple fashion as Periods involving on their part the obligation of filial obedience and loyalty, and on Yahweh's part reciprocal parental care over them as His people. The family was the social unit and its head the person in whom centered also religious authority and leadership. The tribal head or pa- triarch in turn combined in himself the functions which later were differentiated into those of priest and prophet and king. Education was a matter of purely domestic interest and concern. The home was the only school and the parents the only teach- ers. But there was real instruction, all of which, moreover, was given in a spirit of devout religious earnestness and of reverence for the common reli- gious ceremonies and beliefs, no matter whether the subject of instruction was the simple task of hus- bandry or of some useful art, or whether it was the sacred history and traditions of the tribe, or the actual performance of its religious rites. Accord- ing to Jos (Ant, IV, viii, 12) Moses himself had commanded, “‘All boys shail learn the most important parts of the law since such knowledge is most val- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA E40, Edomites Education uable and the source of happiness”; and again he commanded (Apion, II, 25) to teach them the rudi- ments of learning (reading and writing) together with the laws and deeds of the ancestors, in order that they might not transgress or seem ignorant of the laws of their ancestors, but rather emulate their example. Certain it is that the earliest legis- lation, including the Decalogue, emphasized paren- tal authority and their claim on the reverence of their children: ‘‘Honor thy father and thy mother, that thy days may be long in the land which Jeh thy God giveth thee” (Ex 20 12); ‘“‘And he that smiteth his father, or his mother, shall be surely put to death. And he that curseth his father or his mother, shall surely be put to death’ (Ex 21 15.17); while every father was exhorted to explain to his son the origin and significance of the great Passover ceremony with its feast of unleavened bread: ‘‘And thou shalt tell thy son in that day, saying, It is because of that which Jeh did for me when I came forth out of Egypt” (Ex 13 8). The period of conquest and settlement developed leaders who not only led the allied tribes in battle, but served as judges between their 2. The people, and were active in the main- Monarchical tenance of the ancestral religion. In Period time, sufficient codperation was ob- tained to make possible the organiza- tion of strong intertribal leagues and, finally, the kingship. ‘‘This increasing political unification,” says Ames, ‘‘was accompanied by a religious con- sciousness which became ultimately the most re- markable product of the national development” (Ames, PRE, 174f). The establishment of the kingdom and the beginnings of city and commercial life were accompanied by more radical cultural changes, including the differentiation of religious from other social institutions, the organization of the pricsthood, and the rise and devclopment of prophecy. Elijah, the Tishbite, Amos, the herds- man from Tekoa, Isaiah, the son of Amoz, were all champions of a simple faith and ancient religious ideals as over against the worldly-wise diplomacy and sensuous idolatry of the surrounding nations. Under the monarchy also a new religious symbol- ism developed. Yahweh was thought of as a king in whose hands actually lay the supreme guidance of the state: ‘Accordingly the organization of the state included provision for consulting His will and obtaining His direction in all weighty matters” (W. R. Smith, 2S, 30). Under the teaching of the prophets the ideal of personal and civic righteousness was moved to the very forefront of Heb religious thought, while the prophetic ideal of the future was that of a time when ‘the earth shall be full of the knowledge of Jch, as the waters cover the sea” (Isa 11 9), when all “from the least of them unto the greatest of them” shail know him (Jer 31 34). Concerning the so-called “schools of the prophets” which, in the days of Elijah, existed at Bethel, Jericho and Gilgal (2 K 2 3.5; 4 38f), and prob- ably in other places, it should be noted that these were associations or brotherhoods established for the purpose of mutual edification rather than edu- cation. The Bible does not use the word “schools” to designate these fraternities. Nevertheless we cannot conceive of the element of religious training as being entirely absent. Shortly before the Bab captivity King Josiah gave official recognition and sanction to the teach- ings of the prophets, while the Deuter- 3. Deutero- onomic legislation of the same period nomic strongly emphasized the responsibility Legislation of parents for the religious and moral instruction and training of their children, Concerning the words of the law Israel is admonished: ‘Thou shalt teach them diligently Education THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 902 unto thy children, and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thy house, and when thou walkest by the way, and when thou liest down, and when thou risest up” (Dt 6 7; 1119). For the benefit of children as well as adults the law was to be written “upon the door-posts” and “gates” (6 9; 11 20), and “very plainly” upon “great stones” set up for this purpose upon the hilltops and beside the altars (Dt 27 1-8). From the Deuteronomic period forward, religious training to the Jew became the synonym of education, while the word Térah, which originally denoted simply ‘‘Law” (Ex 24 12; Lev 7 1; 26 46), came to mean “Teligious instruction or teaching,” in which sense it is used in Dt 4 44; 6 1, “This is the law which Moses set before the Hear, O Israel, the stat- utes and the ordinances which I speak in your ears this day, that ye may learn them, and observe to do them”; and in Prov 6 23, “'For the commandment is a lamp; and the law is light; And reproofs of instruction are the way of life.’ (Cf Ps 19 8; Prov 31; 4 2.) With the development and reorganization of the ritual, priests and Levites, as the guardians of the law, were the principal instructors of 4. Reading the people, while parents remained in and charge of the training of the children. Writing In families of the aristocracy the place of the parents was sometimes taken by tutors, as appears from the case of the infant Solo- mon, whose training seems to have been intrusted to the prophet Nathan (2 § 12 25). There is no way of determining to what extent the common people were able to read and write. Our judgment. that these rudiments of formal education in the modern sense were not restricted to the higher classes is based upon such passages as Isa 29 11.12, which distinguishes between the man who “‘is learned”’ (lit. “knoweth letters’) and the one who is “not learned,” and Isa 10 19, referring to the ability of a child “to write,” taken together with such facts as that the literary prophets Amos and Micah sprang from the ranks of the common people, and that “the workman who excavated the tunnel from the Virgin’s Spring to the Pool of Siloam carved in the rock the manner of their work” (Ken- nedy in HDB). It should be added that the later Jewish tradition reflected in the Talm, Tg and Midr, and which represents both public, elementary and college education as highly developed even in pa- triarchal times, is generally regarded as altogether untrustworthy. If, Education in Later Israel (from the Exile to the Birth of Christ)—The national disaster that befell the Heb people in the downfall of Jerus and the Bab captivity was not without its compensating, purifying and stimulating influence upon the reli- gious and educational development of the nation. Under the pressure of adverse external circum- stances the only source of comfort for the exiled people was in the law and covenant of Yahweh, while the shattering of all hope of immediate na- tional greatness turned the thought and attention of the religious leaders away from the present toward the future. Two types of Messianic expec- tation characterized the religious development of the exilic period. The first is the priestly, material hope of return and restoration reficcted in the prophecies of Ezekiel. The exiled tribes are to return again to Jerus; the temple is to be restored, its ritual and worship purified and exalted, the priestly ordinance and service elaborated. The second is the spiritualized and idealized Messianic expectation of the Second Isaiah, based on teach- ings of the earlier prophets. For the greatest of Heb prophets Yahweh is the only God, and the God of all nations as well as of Israel. For him Israel is Yahweh’s servant, His instrument for revealing Himself to other nations, who, when they witness the redemption of Yahweh's suffering Servant, will bow down to Yahweh and acknowledge His rule. “Thus the trials of the nation lead to a compre- hensive universalism within which the suffering Israel gains an elevated and ennobling explanation” (Ames, PRE, 185). In the prophetic vision of Ezekiel we must seek the inspiration for the later development of Jewish ritual, as well as the basis of those eschatological hopes and expectations which find their fuller expression in the apocalypse of Dal and the kindred lit. of the later cents. The prophecies of the Isaiahs and the Messianic hope which these kindled in the hearts of the faithful prepared the way for the teachings of Jesus con- cerning a Divine spiritual kingdom, based upon the personal, ethical character of the individual and the mutual, spiritual fellowship of believers. The educational significance of the prophetic writings of this as of the preceding periods is that the prophets themselves were the real 1. Educa- religious leaders and representative tional Sig- men (Kulturtrdéger) of the nation. In nificance advance of their age they were the of the heralds of Divine truth; the watch- Prophets men on the mountain tops whose clear insight into the future detected the significant elements in the social and religious con- ditions and tendencies about them, and whose keen intellect and lofty faith grasped the eternal prin- ciples which are the basis of all individual and national integrity and worth. These truths and principles they impressed upon the consciousness of their own and succeeding generations, thereby giving to future teachers of their race the essence of their message, and preparing the way for the larger and fuller interpretation of religion and life contained in the teachings of Jesus. The immedi- ate influence of their teaching is explained in part by the variety and effectiveness of their teaching method, their marvelous simplicity and directness of speech, their dramatic emphasis upon essentials and their intelligent appreciation of social conditions and problems about them. The immediate bond of union, as well as the text- book and program of religious instruction, during the period of the captivity and sub- 2. The sequently, was the Book of the Law, Book of which the exiles carried with them to the Law Babylon. When in 458 BC a com- pany of exiles returned to Pal, they, along with their poorer brethren who had not been carried away, restored the Jewish community at Jerus, and under the suzerainty of Persia, founded a new nationalism, based, even more than had been the earlier monarchy, upon the theocratic concep- tion of Israel’s relation to Yahweh. During this period it was that writings of poets, lawgivers, prophets and sages were brought together into one sacred collection of scrolls, known later as the OT canon, of which the Torah (the law) was education- ally the most significant. ‘The recognized teachers of this period included, in addition to the priests and Levites, the “wise men,” or “sages’’ and the “scribes”? or sdphtrim (lit. “those learned in Scrip- tures’). Whether or not the sages and scribes of the later post-exilic times are to be regarded as one and the same class, as an-increasing number 3. Wise of scholars are inclined to believe, or Men or thought of as distinct classes, the wise Sages men clearly antedate, not only the soph*rim, but in all probability all forms of book learning as well. Suggestions of their existence and function are met with in earliest times 903 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Education both in Israel and among other nations of the East. As illustrations of their appearance in preéxilic OT history may be cited the references in 2 8 14 1-20; 1 K 4 32; Isa 29 10. It is no lesser per- sonage than King Solomon who, both by his contemporaries and later generations as well, was regarded as the greatest representative of this earlier group of teachers who uttered their wisdom in the form of clever, epigrammatic proverbs and shrewd sayings. The climax of Wisdom-teaching belongs, however, to the later post-exilic period. Of the wise men of this later day an excellent description is preserved for usin the Book of Ecclus (89 3.4.8.10; cf 1 1-11): “Fle seeks out the hidden meaning of proverbs, And is conversant with the suhtilties of parahles, He serves among great men, And appears before him who rules; He travels through the land of strange nations; For he hath tried good things and evil among men. ae rrttet forth the instruction which he has been aught, And glories in the law of the covenant of the Lord. Nations shall declare his wisdom, And the congregation shall tell out his praise." Of the pedagogic experience, wisdom and learn- ing of these sages, the Book of Prov forms the Bib. repository. Aside from the Torah it 4. The is thus the oldest handbook of edu- Book of cation. The wise men conceive of Proverbs _ life itself as a discipline. Parents are 4 the natural instructors of their chil- ren: ‘*My son, hear the instruction of thy father, And forsake not the law of thy mower us —Prov (Cf 4 1-4 ff; 6 20; 13 1.) The substance of such parental teaching is to he the ‘fear of Yahweh’ which ‘Gg the beginning of wisdom’; and fidelity in the performance of this parental obligation has the promise of success: ‘Train up a child in the way he should go, And even when he is oid he will not depart from it.” —Prov 22 6. In their training of children, parents are to observe sternness, not hesitating to apply the rod of correc~ tion, when needed (cf 23 13.14), yet doing so with discretion, since wise reproof is better than “a hundred stripes” (17 10). Following the home training there is provision for further instruction at the hands of professional teachers for all who would really obtain unto ‘‘wisdom” and who can afford the time and expense of such special training. The teachers are none other than the wise men or sages whose words “heard in quiet’’ (Eccl 9 17) are “‘as goads, and as nails well fastened” (12 11). Their precepts teach diligence (Prov 6 6-11), chastity (7 5), charity (14 21), truthfulness (17 7) and temperance (21 17; 28 20.21.29-35); for the aim of all Wisdom-teaching is none other than “To give prudence to the simple, To the young man knowledge and discretion: That the wise man may hear, and increase in learning; And that the man of understanding may attain unto sound counsels.’’—-Prov ] 4.5. The sdph*rim or ‘men of book learning” were editors and interpreters as well as scribes or copyists of ancient and current writings. As 5. Scribes a class they did not become prominent and Levites until the wise men, as such, stepped into the background, nor until the exigencies of the situation demanded more teachers and teaching than the ranks of priests and Levites, charged with increasing ritualistic duties, could supply. Ezra was both a priest and a séphér (Ear 7 11; Neh 8 1f), concerning whom we read that he “get his heart to seck the law of Jeh, and to do it, and to teach in Israel statutes and ordinances” (Ezr 7 10). Likewise the Levites often appear as teachers of the law, and we must think of the development of sopherism (scribism) as a distinct rofession as proceeding very gradually. The same is true of the characteristic Jewish religious-edu- cational institution, the synagogue, the origin and development of which fell within this same general period (ef Synacocur). The pupils of the sdph*- rim were the Pharisees (p’rishim or “‘separatists’”’) who during the Maccabean period came to be dis- tinguished from the priestly party or Sadducees. The conquest of Persia by Alexander (332 BC) marks the rise of Gr influence in Pal. Alexander ; himself visited Pal and perbaps Jerus 6. Greek (Jos, Ant, X, i, 8), befriended the and Roman Jews and granted to them the privilege Influences of self-government, and the main- tenance of their own social and reli- gious customs, both at home and in Alexandria, the new center of Gr learning, in the founding of which many Jews participated (see ALEXANDRIA). During the succeeding dynasty of the Ptolemies, Gr ideas and Gr culture penetrated to the very heart of Judaism at Jerus, and threatened the overthrow of Jewish social and religious institutions. The Mac- cabean revolt under Antiochus Epipbanes (174-— 164 BC) and the reéstablishment of a purified temple ritual during the early part of the Macca- bean period (161-63 BC) were the natural reaction against the attempt of the Seleucidae forcibly to substitute the Gr gymnasium and theater for the Jewish synagogue and soup le (Felten, NZ, I, 83 f; cf 1 Macc 1, 3, 9, 13 and 2 Macc 4-10). The end of the Maccabean period found Phariseeism and strict Jewish orthodoxy in the ascendency with such Hellenic tendencies as had found permanent lodgment in Judaism reflected in the agnosticism of the aristocratic Sadducees. The establishment of Rom authority in Pal (63 BC) introduced a new determining element into the environmental con- ditions under which Judaism was to attain its final distinguishing characteristics. The genius of the Romans was practical, legalistic and institutional. As organizers and administrators they were pre- eminent. But their religion never inspired to any exalted view of life, and education to them meant always merely a preparation for life’s practical duties. Hence the influence of Rom authority upon Judaism was favorable to the development of a narrow individualistic Phariseeism, rather than to the fostering of Gr idealism and universalism. With the destruction of Jerus by the Romans a little more than a cent. later (70 AD) and the cessation of the temple worship, the Sadducees as a class disappeared from Judaism, which has ever since been represented by the Pharisees devoted to the study of the law. Outside of Jerus and Pal, mean- while, the Jewish communities at Alexandria and elsewhere were much more hospitable to Gr culture and learning, at the same time exerting a reciprocal, modifying influence upon Gr thought. It was, how- ever, through its influence upon early Christian theology and education that the Hellenistic phi- losophy of the Alexandrian school left its deeper impress upon the substance and method of later Christian education. IV. Education in New Testament Times (from the birth of Christ to the end of the 1st cent.).— Elementary schools: Jewish education in the time of Christ was of the orthodox traditional type and in the hands of scribes, Pharisees and learned rabbis. The home was still the chief institution for the dis- pensation of elementary instruction, although synagogues, with attached schools for the young, were to be found in every important Jewish com- munity. Public elementary schools, other than Education Eglon THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 904 those connected with the synagogues, were of slower growth and do not seem to have been common until, some time after Joshua ben Gamala, high priest from 63-65 AD, ordered that teachers be appointed im every province and city to instruct children having attained the age of 6-7 years. In the synagogue schools the hazzdn, or attendant, not infrequently served as schoolmaster (cf ScHoon; ScHOOLMASTER). As in earlier times the Torah, connoting now the sacred OT writings as a whole, though with empha- sis still upon the law, furnished the 1. Subject- subject-matter of instruction. To this Matter of were added, in the secondary schools Instruction (colleges) of the rabbis, the illustra- tive and paraholical rabbinical inter- pretation of the law (the haggadhah) and its appli- cation to daily life in the form of concise precept or rule of conduct (the halakhah). Together the haggadhah and halakhah furnish the content of the Talm (or Talmuds), as the voluminous collections of orthodox Jewish teachings of later cents. came to be known. As regards teaching method the scribes and rabbis of NT times did not improve much upon the prac- tice of the séph*rim and sages of ear- 2. Method her cents. Memorization, the exact and Aims reproduction by the pupil of the mas- ter’s teaching, rather than general knowledge or culture, was the main objective. Since the voice of prophecy had become silent and the canon of revealed truth was considered closed, the intellectual mastery and interpretation of this sacred revelation of the past was the only aim that education on its intellectual side could have. On its practical side it sought, as formerly, the incul- cation of hahits of strict ritualistic observance, obedience to the letter of the law as a condition of association and fellowship with the selected com- pany of true Israelites to which scribes and Pharisecs considered themselves to helong. The success with which the teachings of the scribes and rabbis were accompanied is an evidence of their devotion to their work, and more still of the psychological insight manifested by them in utilizing every subtle means and method for securing and holding the attention of their pupils, and making their mem- ories the trained and obedient servants of an edu- cational ideal. The defects in their work were largely the defects in that ideal. Their theory and philosophy of education were narrow. ‘Their eyes were turned too much to the past rather than the present and future.” They failed to distinguish clearly the gold from the dross in their inherited teachings, or to adapt these to the vital urgent needs of the common people. In its struggle against foreign cults and foreign culture, Judaism had in- cased itself in a shell of stereotyped orthodoxy, the attempt to adapt which to new conditions and to a constantly changing social order resulted in an insincere and shallow casuistry of which the fan- tastic conglomerate mass of Talmudic wisdom of the 4th and 6th cents. is the lasting memorial. Nevertheless, “Jewish education, though defect- ive hoth in matter and in method, and tending to fetter rather than to free the mind, 3. Valuable achieved four valuable results: (1) it Results of developed a taste for close, critical Jewish study; (2) it sharpened the wits, even Education to the point of perversity; (3) it en- couraged a reverence for law and pro- duced desirable social conduct; and (4) it formed a owerful bond of union among the Jewish people.” To these four points of excellence enumerated by Davidson (HE, 80) must be added a, fifth which, briefly stated, is this: (5) Jewish education hy its consistent teaching of lofty monotheism, and its emphasis, sometimes incidental and sometimes outstanding, upon righteousness and holiness of life as a condition of participation in a future Mes- sianic kingdom, prepared the way for the Christian view of God and the world, set forth in its original distinctness of outline and incomparable simplicity in the teachings of Jesus. Jesus was more than a teacher; but He was a teacher first. To His contemporaries he appeared as a Jewish rabbi of exceptional in- 4. The Pre- fluence and popularity. He used the eminence of teaching methods of the rahbis; Jesus asa gathered about Him, as did they, a Teacher group of chosen disciples (learners) whom He trained and taught more explicitly with a view to perpetuating through them His own influence and work. His followers called Him Rabbi and Master, and the scribes and Phari- sees conceded His popularity and power. He taught, as did the rabbis of His time, in the temple courts, in the synagogue, in private, and on the public highway as the exigencies of the case de- manded. His textbook, so far as He used any, was the same as theirs; His form of speech (parable and connected discourse), manner of life and methods of instruction were theirs. Yet into His message and method He put a new note of authority that challenged attention and inspired confidence. Breaking with the traditions of the past He sub- stituted for devotion to the letter of the law an interest in men, with houndless sympathy for their misfortune, abiding faith in their worth and high destiny and earnest solicitude for their regeneration and perfection. To say that Jesus was the world’s greatest and foremost example as a teacher is to state a fact borne out by every inquiry, test and comparison that modern educational science can apply to the work and influence of its great creative geniuses of the past. Where His contemporaries and even His own followers saw only ‘‘as in a glass, darkly,” He saw clearly; and His view of God and the world, of human life and human destiny, has come down through the ages as a Divine revelation vouchsafed the world in Him. Viewed from the intellectual side, it was the life philosophy of Jesus that made His teachings imperishable; esthetically it was the compassionate tenderness and solicitude of His message that drew the multitudes to Him; judged from the standpoint of will, it was the example of His life, its purpose, its purity, its help- fulness, that caused men to follow Him; and tested hy its immediate and lasting social influence, it was the doctrine, the ideal and example of the human brotherliness and Divine sonship, that made Jesus the pattern of the great teachers of mankind in every age and generation. With a keen, penetrating insight into the ultimate meaning of life, He reached out, as it were, over the conflicting opinions of men and the mingling social and cultural currents of His time backward to the fundamental truths uttered by the ancient prophets of His race and forward to the ultimate goal of the race. Then with simple directness of speech He addressed Him- self to the consciences and wills of men, setting before them the ideal of the higher life, and with infinite patience sought to lift them to the plane of fellowship with Himself in thought and action. It remained for the disciples of Jesus to perpetuate His teaching ministry and to organize the new forces making for human betterment. 5. Educa- In this work, which was distinctly tional Work religious-educational in character, some of the found a field of labor among their Early own Jewish kinsmen, and others, like Disciples Paul, among the needy Gentiles (Gal 7? 116; 27; 1 Tim 27). As regards a division of labor in the apostolic church, we read 905 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Education Egion of apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers (1 Cor 12 28; Eph 4 11). The apostles were the itinerant leaders and missionaries of the entire church. Their work was largely that of teaching, Paul insisting on calling himself a teacher as well as an apostle (2 Tim 111; 1 Cor 4 17). The prophets were men with a special message like that of Agabus (Acts 21 10.11). The evangelists were itinerant preachers, as was Philip (8 40), while the pastors, also called bishops, had per- manent charge of individual churches. The pro- fessional teachers included both laymen and those ordained by the laying on of hands. Their work was regarded with highest honor in the chureh and community. In contrast with the itinerant ehureh officers, apostles and evangelists, they, like the pastors, resided permanently in loeal communities. With this class the author of the Epistle of Jas identifies himself, and there can be little doubt that the epistle which he wrote refleets both the eontent and form of the instruction which these earliest Christian teachers gave to their pupils. Before the close of the Ist cent. the religious educational work of the church had been organized into a more systematic form, out of which there developed gradually the catechumenate of the early post- apostolic period (see CatTecuist). In the Did, or Teachings of the Apostles, there has been reserved for_us a textbook of religious instruction from this earlier period (Kent, GTJC). Necessarily, the entire missionary and evangelistic work of the apos- tolic church was educational in character, and throughout this earliest period of ehureh history we must think of the work of apostles, evangelists and pastors, as well as that of professional teachers, as ineluding a certain amount of systematic religious instruction. See further Prpacogy; ScHoo.; Treacuer; TUTOR. Lirerature.—Ames, Psychology of Religious Experi- ence, coh x: Box, art. ‘‘Education,” in EB; Butler, The Meaning of Education; Davidson, History of Education; Dewey, art. ‘“‘Education,"’ in. Monroe’s Cyclopedia of Educatton; Edersheim, ‘‘The Uphringing of Jewish Chil- dren,” in SJSL, and Life and Times of Jesus, I, 225f; Fairweather, Background of the Gospels; Felten, ‘‘ Schrift- gelehrten, Synagogen u. Schulen,”’ in Neutestamentliche Zettgeschichte, 1; Ginsburg, art. ‘‘Education,’’ in Kitto’s Biblical Cyclopedia; Hiegemoser u. Bock, Quellenbuch u. Uberblick d. Geschichte d. Pddagogik; Katzer, arts. ‘‘ Jesus als Lehrer"’ and ‘‘ Judenchristentum," in Rein’s Encyklo- pddisches Handbuch d. Pddagogik; Kennedy, art. ‘‘ Educa- tion,” in HDB, 1; Kobler and Gudemann, art. ‘“ Educa- tion’ in Jew Enc, V; Kent, Great Teachers of Judaism and Christianity and Makers and Teachers of Judaism; Laurie, Historical Survey of Pre-Christian Education; Lewit, Darstellung d. theoreitschen u. praktischen Pddagogik im jid. Altertume; Oehler, art. ‘‘Padagogik d. Alten Testaments,’ in Schmid's Encyclopddie d. Gesammten Erziehungs- u.. Unterrichtswesen; Schtirer, ‘“ Schriftgelehr- samkeit, Schule u. Synagoge,"’ in Geschichte d. jiid. Volkes (ed 1907); W. R. Smith, Keligion of the Semites; Strauss- burger, Geschichte d. Unterrichts bei_d, Israeliten; von Rohden, art. ‘‘Katechetik"' in Rein’s EHP. H. H. Meyer EDUTH, é@’duth (NY , ‘édhuih, “testimony,” a technical term for the Ten Commandments or for the Law): In Ps 60 title, “set to Shushan Eduth”’ (lit. “a lily [is] the testimony’) ; 80 title, “set to Shoshannim Eduth”’ (lit. “lilies [is] the testimony’). The Heb words appear to be intended to designate a melody by the first few words ordinarily asso- ciated with it. See Psaums. EFFECT, é-fekt’, EFFECTUAL, é-fek’tii-al: In the OT, RV renders ‘‘fulfilment’” for “effeet” in Ezk 12 23 (Heb dabhdr, ‘‘matter’’); and in Jer 48 30 “His boastings have wrought nothing” for the vaguer “His lies shall not so effeet” of AV. In AV of the NT, ‘make of none effect”’ occurs repeat- edly: as the tr of Gr akuréé, ‘render void” (Mt 15 6; Mk 7 13); of katargéd, “annul” (Rom 3 3 [AV “make without effect”]; 4 14; Gal 3 17); and of kenéd, ‘make empty” (1 Gor 1 17). RV renders “make of none effect’? in Rom 3 3; Gal 3 17; “make void” in the other cases, with no apparent reason for the lack of uniformity. Gr energééis the opposite in meaning of katarged above. Its deriv- ative enérgés, ‘effective,’ is rendered “effectual” by EV in 1 Cor 16 9; Philem ver 6. RV dis- penses with ‘‘effeetual,” “effectually,” in the other cases where AV has used these words as auxiliary in the tr of energed or of enérgeia, ‘working’ (2 Cor 16; Gal 28; Eph 37; 4 16; 1 Thess 2 13; Jas 5 16). F. K. Farr EGG (ME"R, beech; ov, G6n; Lat ovum): An oval or spheroid body produced by birds, fishes and reptiles, from which their young emerge when in- cubated or naturally developed. The fertile egg of a bird consists of the yolk, a small disk from which the embryo develops, the albuminous white, and a ealcarcous shell. The most ancient records prove that eggs have been used as an artiele of diet ever since the use of the flesh of fowl] began. Chiekens were unknown in Pal in the days of Job, so that his query concerning the taste of the white of an egg might have referred to those of pigeons, ducks, eggs taken from the nests of geese or swans, game birds or ostriches. “Can that which hath no savor be eaten without salt? Or is there any taste in the white of an egg?” (Job 6 6, RVm “the juice of purslain”). In Lk 11 12 there is every possibility that the egg of our common domestic fow] is referred to, as “chickens” (q.v.) had been imported and were numerous in Pal at that time. “Or if he shall ask an egg, willhe give himascorpion?” The reference in Isa 59 5 is to the egg of a serpent, and is figura~ tive of the schemes of evil men: ‘“They hatch adders’ eggs, and weave the spider’s web: he that eateth of their eggs dieth; and that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper.” Gene StTratron-PorRTER EGLAH, eg'la (MD39, ‘eghlah, “heifer”): Wite of Pais and mother of Ithream (2 8 3 5] 1 Ch EGLAIM, eg’li-im (O"238, ’eghlayim; ’Ayahelp, Agaleim): A place named in Isa 15 8, possibly in the 8. of Moab. Onom identifies it with Agallim, a village 8 Rom miles 8. of Areopolis. It cannot now be ideutified. EGLATH-SHELISHIYAH, eg’lath-shel-i-shi’ya aww nbay , ‘eghlath sh*lishiydh) : Found in Isa 15 5; Jer 48 34 (Heb) in oracles against Moab. AV tr® ‘an heifer of three years old”; RV takes it as the name of a place, but ARVm has “a heifer three years old,” aee. to LXX. In the former case strong and unconquered cities, Zoar and Horonaim, are compared to the heifer not yet broken to the yoke. Such use of “heifer” is not infrequent (cf Jer 46 20; Hos 10 11, etc). The majority of scholars, however, take it asa place-name. Some would read “the third Eglath,” as if there were three towns of that name. No probable identification has been suggested. EwIne EGLON, eg’lon (Fbay, ‘eghlon, “circle”): A king of Moab in the period of the Judges who, in alliance with Ammon and Amalek, overeame Israel and made Jericho his capital, presumably driven aeross the Jordan by the turmoil in his own kingdom whieh at that time was probably being used as a battle ground by Edom and the desert tribes (cf Gen 36 35). After 18 years of servitude the children of Israel were delivered by Ehud the Benjamite, who like so many other Benjamites (cf Jgs 20 16) was left-handed. Under the pretext of carrying a present to the tyrant, he secured a private interview Eglon Egypt THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 906 and assassinated him with a two-edged sword which he had carried concealed on his right side (Jgs 3 19-22). Ehud made his escape, rallied the children of Israel about him and returned to conquer the Moabites (Jgs 3 30). Evia Davis Isaacs EGLON, eg’lon (J1932, ‘eghlan; ’O8oddp, Odol- lém): A royal Canaanite city whose king joined the league headed by Adonizedek of Jerus against the Gibeonites, which suffered overwhelming defeat at the hands of Joshua (Josh 10). Joshua passed from Libnah to Lachish, and from Lachish to Eglon on his way to Hebron (vs 31ff). It was in the Shephelah of Judah (15 39). The name seems to be preserved in that of Khirbet ‘Ajldn, about 10 miles W. of Beit Jibrin. Professor Petrie, however, thinks that the site of Tell Nejtleh better suits the requirements. While Khirbet ‘Ajldén is a compara- tively modern site, the city at Tell Nejtleh must have been contemporary with that at Tell el-Hesy (Lachish). It lies fully three miles S.E. of Tell el-Hesy. Ewine EGYPT, @'jipt: I. Tue Country . The Basis of the Land 2. The Nile Valley . Earliest Human Remains Climate Conditions of Life The Nile The Fauna The Flora The Prehistoric Races HE History 1st and 2d Ages: Prehistoric 3d Age: Ist and IId Dynasties 4th Age: IlId-—Vith Dynasties 5th Age: VIIth-XIVth Dynasties 6th Age: XVth—-XXIVth Dynasties 7th Age: XXVth Dynasty to Roman Times 8th Age: Arahic Early Foreign Connections gE OT ConwneEcTIONS Semitic Connections Abramic Times Circumcision Joseph Descent into Egypt The Oppression The Historic Position . The Plagues . Date of the Exodus 10. Route of the Exodus 11. Numbers of the Exodus 12. Israel in Canaan 13. Hadad 14. Pharaoh’s Daughter 15. Shishak 16. Zerakh 17. The Ethiopians 18. Tahpanhes 20. The Jews of Syene 21. The New Jerusalem of Oniah 22. The Egyptian Jew 23. Cities and Places Alphabetically IV. Tse Crvivization . Language . Writing Literature Four Views of Future Life Four Groups of Gods . Foreign Gods Laws . Character LiteRATURE Egypt (OMA, micrayim; 4 Atyurros, he Al- guptos): Usually supposed to represent the dual of _ Misr, referring to “the two lands,” as the Egyptians called their country. This dualism, however, has been denied by some. I. The Country.—Though Egypt is one of the earliest countries in recorded history, and as regards its continuous civilization, yet it is a a Il. IIT. 01.7 WS 9 NO 2 9 00 > UF G0 I ee 9 S00. DN HINB Gobo 1. The late country in its geological history Basis of and in its occupation by a settled pop- the Land ulation. The whole land up to Sil- sileh is a thick mass of Eocene hme- stone, with later marls over that in the lower districts. It has been elevated on the E., up to the mountains of igneous rocks many thousand ft. high toward the Red Sea. It has been depressed on the W., down to the Fayum and the oases below sea- level. This strain resulted in a deep fault from N. to S. for some hundreds of miles up from the Medi- terranean. This fault left its eastern side about 200 ft. above its western, and into it the drainage of the plateau poured, widening it out so as to form the Nile valley, as the permanent drain of Northeast Africa. The access of water to the rift seems to have caused the basalt outflows, which are seen as black columnar basalt S. of the Fayum, and brown massive basalt at Khankah, N. of Cairo. The gouging out of the Nile valley by rainfall must have continued when the land was 300 ft. higher than at present, as is shown by 2. The Nile the immense falls of strata into col- Valley lapsed caverns which were far below the present Nile level. Then, after the excavations of the valley, it has been submerged to 500 ft. lower than at present, as is shown by the rolled gravel beds and deposits on the tops of the water-worn cliffs, and the filling up of the tributary valleys—as at Thebes—by deep deposits, through which the subsequent stream beds have been scoured out. The land still had the Nile source 30 ft. higher than it is now within the human period, as seen by the worked flints in high gravel beds above the Nile plain. The distribution of land and water was very different from that at present when the land was only 100 ft. lower than now. Sucha change would make the valley an estuary up to S. of the Fayum, would submerge much of the western desert, and would unite the Gulf of Suez and the Mediterranean. Such differences would entirely alter the conditions of animal life by sea and land. And as the human period began when the water was considerably higher, the conditions of climate and of life must have greatly changed in the earlier ages of man’s occupation. The earliest human remains belonging to the present condition of the country are large palaeo- lithic flints found in the side valleys 3. Earliest at the present level of the Nile. As ‘uman these are perfectly fresh, and not rolled Remains or altered, they show that palaeolithic NI man lived in Egypt under the present conditions. The close of this palaeolithic age of hunters, and the beginning of a settled population of cultivators, cannot have been before the drying up of the climate, which by depriving the Nile of tributary streams enfeebled it so that its mud was deposited and formed a basis for agriculture. From the known rate of deposit, and depth of mud soil, this change took place about 10,000 years ago. As the recorded history of the country extends 7,500 years, and we know of two prehistoric ages before that, it is pretty well fixed that the disappearance of palaeolithic man, and the beginning of the con- tinuous civilization must have been about 9,000 to 10,000 years ago. For the continuation of this subject see the section on “History” below. The climate of Egypt is unique in the world. So far as solar heat determines it, the condition is tropical; for, though just N. of the 4, The tropic which lies at the boundary of Climate Egypt and Nubia, the cloudless con- ; dition fully compensates for higher latitude. So far as temperature of the air is con- cerned, the climate is temperate, the mean heat of the winter months being 52° and of the summer about 80°, much the same as Italy. This is due to | the steady prevalence of north winds, which main- tain fit conditions for active, strenuous work. The rainlessness and dry air give the same facility of living that is found in deserts, where shelter is only 907 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Egion Egypt needed for temperature and not for wet; while the inundation provides abundant moisture for the richest crops. The primitive condition—only recently changed —of the crops being all raised during five cool months from November to April, and 5. Condi- the inundation covering the land dur- tions of ing all the hot weather, left the popu- Life lation free from labor during the enervating season, and only required their energies when work was possible under favor- able conditions. At the same time it gave a great opportunity for monumental work, as any amount of labor could be drawn upon without the smallest reduction in the produce of the country. The great structures which covered the land gave train- Ing and organization to the people, without being any drain upon the welfare of the country. The inundation covering the plain also provided the easiest transport for great masses from the quarries at the time when labor was abundant. Thus-the climatic conditions were all in favor of a great civilization, and aided its production of monuments. The whole mass of the country being of limestone, and much of it of the finest quality, provided ma- terial for construction at every point. In the south, sandstone and granite were also at hand upon the great waterway. The Nile is the great factor which makes life possible in Northeast Africa, and without it Egypt would only be a desolate corner of the 6. The Nile Sahara. The union of two essentially different streams takes place at Khar- tum. The White or ight Nile comes from the great plains of the Sudan, while the Blue or dark Nile descends from the mountains of Abyssinia. The Sudan Nile from Gondokoro is filtered by the lakes and the sudd vegetation, so that it carries little mud; the Abyssinian Nile, by its rapid course, brings down all the soil which is deposited in Egypt, and which forms the basis for cultivation. The Sudan First Cataract of the Nile. Nile rises only 6 ft. from April to November; while the Abyssinian Nile rises 26 ft. from April to August. The latter makes the rise of the inundation, while the Sudan Nile maintains the level into the winter. In Egypt itself the unchecked Nile at Aswan rises 25 ft. from the end of May to the beginning of Sep- tember; while at Cairo, where modified by the irrigation system, it rises 16 ft. from May to the end of September. It was usually drained off the land by the beginning of November, and cultivation was begun. The whole cultivable land of Egypt ig but the dried-up bed of the great river, which fills its ancient limits during a third of the year. The time taken by a flush of water to come down the Nile is about 15 days from 400 miles above Khartum to Aswan, and about 6 days from Aswan to Cairo, or 80 to 90 miles a day, which shows a flow of 3 to 34 miles an hour when in flood. The fauna has undergone great changes during the human period. At the close of the prehistoric age there are represented the giraffe, 7. The elephant, wild ox, lion, leopard, stag, Fauna long-necked gazelle and great dogs, none of which are found in the historic period. During historic times various kinds of ante- lopes have been extcrminated, the hippopotamus was driven out of the Delta during Rom times, and the crocodile was cleared out of Upper Egypt and Nubia in the last century. Cranes and other birds shown on early sculptures are now unknown in the country. The animals still surviving are the wolf, jackal, hyaena, dogs, ichneumon, jerboa, rats, mice, lizards (up to 4 ft. long) and snakes, besides a great variety of birds, admirably figured by Whymper, Birds of Egypt. Of tamed animals, the ox, sheep, goat and donkey are ancient; the cat and horse were brought in about 2000 BC, the camel was not commonly known till 200 AD, and the buffalo was brought to Egypt and Italy in the Middle Ages. The cultivated plants of Egypt were numerous. In ancient times we find the maize (durrah), wheat, barley and lentil; the vine, currant, date 8. The palm, dum palm, fig, olive and pome- Flora granate; the onion, garlic, cucumber, melon and radish; the sont acacia, syca- more and tamarisk; the flax, henna and clover; and for ornament, the lotus, convolvulus and many others. The extension of commerce brought in by the Gr period, the bean, pea, sesame, lupin, helbeh, colocasia and sugar-cane; also the peach, walnut, castor-oil and pear. In the Rom and Arab. ages came in the chick pea, oats, rice, cotton, orange and lemon. In recent times have come the cactus, aloe, tomato, Indian corn, lebbek acacia and beetroot. Many European flowering and ornamental plants were also used in Egypt by the Greeks, and brought in later by the Arabs. The original race in Egypt seems to have been of the steatopygous type now only found in South frica. Figures of this race are known 9. The in the caves of France, in Malta, and Prehistoric later in Somaliland. As this race was Races still known in Egypt at the beginning of the neolithic civilization, and is there represented only by female figures in the graves, it seems that it was being exterminated by the new- comers and only the women were kept as slaves. The neolithic race of Egypt was apparently of the Libyan stock. There seems to have been a single type of the Amorites in Syria, the prehistoric Egyp- tians and the Libyans; this race had a high, well- filled head, long nose slightly aquiline, and short beard; the profile was upright and not progna- thous, the hair was wavy brown. It was a better type than the present south Europeans, of a very capable and intelligent appearance. From the objects found, and the religious legends, it seems that this race was subdued by an eastern, and prob- ably Arabian race, in the prehistoric age. Il. The History.—The founders of the dynastic history were very different, having a profile with nose and forehead in one straight line, and rather thick, but well-formed lips. Historically the indi- cations point to their coming from about Somali- land by water, and crossing into Egypt by the Kop- tos road from the Red Sea. The IId Dynasty gave place to some new blood, probably of Sudany origin. In the VIth and VIIth Dynasties foreigners poured in apparently from the N., perhaps from Crete, judging by their foreign products. The XVth and XVIth Dynasties were Hyksos, or Sem “princes of ' the desert” fromthe E. The XVIIth and XVIIIth THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 908 Egypt Dynasties were Berber in origin. The XIXth Dynasty was largely Sem from Syria. The XXIId Dynasty was headed by an eastern adventurer Shesheng, or Shusinak, “the man of Susa.” The XXVth Dynasty was Ethiopian. The XXVIth Dynasty was Libyan. The Greeks then poured into the Delta and the Fayum, and Hellenized Egypt. The Roman made but little change in the popula- tion; but during his rule the Arab began to enter the eastern side, and by 641 AD the Arab conquest swept the land, and brought in a large part—per- haps the majority—of the ancestors of the present inhabitants. After 3 cents. the Tunisians—the old Libyans—conquered Egypt again. The later ad- ministrations by Syrians, Circassians, Turks and others probably made no change in the general population. The economic changes of the past cent. have brought in Greeks, Italians and other foreigners to the large towns; but all these only amount to an eightieth of the population. The Copts are the descendants of the very mixed Egyp- tians of Rom age, kept separate from the Arab in- vaders by their Christianity. They are mainly in Upper Egypt, where some villages are entirely Cop- tic, and are distinguished by their superior clean- liness, regularity, and the freedom of the women from unwholesome seclusion. The Copts, though only a fifteenth of the population, have always had a large share of official posts, owing to their intel- ligence and ability being above that of the Muslim. In dealing with the history, we here follow the dating which was believed and followed by the Egyptians themselves. All the monu- 1. 1st and mental remains agree with this, so far 2d Ages: as they can check it; and the various Prehistoric arbitrary reductions that have been madé on some periods are solely due to some critics preferring their internal sense to all the external facts. For the details involved in the chronology, see Historical Studies, II (British School of Archaeology in Egypt). The general outline of the periods is given here, and the detailed view of the connection with OT history is treated in later sections. 1st Age.—The prehistoric age begins probably about 8000 BC, as soon as there was a sufficient amount of Nile deposit to attract a settled popu- lation. The desert river valley of Egypt was prob- ably one of the latest haunts of steatopygous palaeo- lithic man of the Bushman type. So soon as there was an opening for a pastoral or agricultural people, he was forced away by settlers from Libya. These settlers were clad in goatskins, and made a small amount of pottery by hand; they knew also of small quantities of copper, but mainly used flint, of which they gradually developed the finest working known in any age. They rapidly advanced in civilization. Their pottery of red polished ware was decorated with white clay patterns, exactly like the pottery still made in the mountains of Algeria. The forms of it were very varied and exquisitely regular, although made without the wheel. Their hard- stone vases are finer than any of those of the historic ages. They adopted spinning, weaving and wood- work. 2d Age.—Upon these people came in others prob- ably from the E., who brought in the use of the Arab face-veil, the belief in amulets, and the Pers lapis lazuli. Most of the previous forms of pottery disappear, and nearly all the productions are greatly altered. Copper became common, while gold, silver and lead were also known. Heliopolis was probably a center of rule. 83d Age.—About 5900 BC a new people came in with the elements of the art of writing, and a strong political ability of organization. Before 5800 BC they had established kings at Abydos in Upper Egypt, and for 3 cents. they gradually increased their power. On the carved slates which they have left, the standards of the allied tribes 2. 3d Age: are represented; the earliest in style Ist and Id _ shows the standard of Koptos, the next Dynasties has a standard as far N. as Hermopolis, and the latest bears the standard of Letopolis, and shows the conquest of the Fayum, or perhaps one of the coast lakes. This last is of the first king of the Ist Dynasty, Mena. The conquest of all Egypt is marked by the be- ginning of the series of numbered dynasties begin- ning with Mena, at about 5550 BC. The civilza- tion rapidly advanced. The art was at its best under the third king, Zer, and thence steadily de- clined. Writing was still ideographic under Mena, but became more syllabic and phonetic toward the end of the dynasty. The work in hardstone was at its height in the vases of the early part of the Ist Dynasty, when an immense variety of beautiful stones appear. It greatly fell off on reaching the IId Dynasty. The tombs were all of timber, built in large pits in the ground. 4th Age—The Ild Dynasty fell about 5000 BC, and a new power rapidly raised the art from an . almost barbarous state to its highest 3. 4th Age: triumphs by about 4750 BC, when the IId-VIth pyramid building wasstarted. Khufu, Dynasties thebuilder of the Great Pyramid in the IVth Dynasty, was one of the greatest rulers of Egypt. He organized the administration on lines which lasted for ages. He reformed the religious system, abolishing the endowments, and substituting models for the sacrifice of animals. He trained the largest body of skilled labor that ever appeared, for the building of his pyramid, the greatest and most accurate structure that the world has ever seen. The statuary of this age is more lifelike than that of any later age. The later reigns show steady decay in the character of work, with less dignity and more superficiality in the art. Great Pyramid of Khufu. bth Age.—By about 4050 BC, the decline of Egypt allowed of fresh people pressing in from the N., prob- ably connected with Crete. There are 4. 5th Age: few traces of these invaders; a curious VIIth— class of barbaric buttons used as seals XIVth are their commonest remains. Prob- Dynasties ably the so-called ‘“Hyksos sphinxes” and statues are of these people, and belong to the time of their attaining power in Egypt. By 3600 BC, the art developed into the great ages of the XIth to the XIIth Dynasties which lasted about 2 cents. The work is more scholastic and less nat- ural than before; but it is very beautiful and of splendid accuracy. The exquisite jewelry of Dah- shur is of this age. After some centuries of decay this civilization passed away. _ 6th Age.—The Sem tribes had long been filtering into Egypt, and Bab Semites even ruled the land 909 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Egypt until the great migration of the Hyksos took place about 2700 BC. These tribes were ruled by kings entitled ‘‘princes of the desert,” like 5. 6th Age: the Sem Absha, or Abishai, shown in XVth— the tomb of Beni-hasan, as coming to XXIVth settle in Egypt. By 1700 BC the Ber- Dynasties bers who had adopted the Egyp civil- ization pressed down from the 8., and ejected the Hyksos rule. This opened the most flourishing period of Egyp history, the XVIIIth Dynasty, 1587-13828 BC. The profusion of painted tombs at Thebes, which were copied and popular- ized by Gardner Wilkinson, has made the life of this period very familiar to us. The immense temples of Karnak and of Luqsor, and the finest of the Tombs of the Kings have impressed us with the royal magnificence of this age. The names of Sheshenq I (Shishak) in 952 BC, the founder of the XXIId Dynasty. His successors gradually decayed till the fall of the XXIIId Dynasty in 721 BC. The Ethiopian XXVIth Dynasty then held Egypt as a province of Ethiopia, down to 664 BC. 7th Age—Iit is hard to say when the next age began—perhaps with the Ethiopians; but it rose to importance with the XX VIth Dynasty 6. 7th Age: under Psamtek (Psammitichos I), 664- XXVth 610 BC, and continued under the well- Dynasty- known names of Necoh, Hophra and Roman Amasis until overthrown by the Per- Times sians in 525 BC. From 405 to 342 the Egyptians were independent; then the Persians again crushed them, and in 382 they fell into the hands of the Macedonians by the conquest of Alexander. Thothmes IJ and III, of the great queen Hatshepsut, of the magnificent Amenhotep III, and of the mono- theist reformer Akhenaton are among those best, known in the history. Their foreign connections we shall notice later. : The XIXth and XXth Dynasties were a period of continual degradation from the XVIIIth. Even in the best work of the 6th Age there is hardly ever the real solidity and perfection which is seen in that of the 4th or 5th Ages. But under the Ramessides cheap effects and showy imitations were the regu- lar system. The great Rameses II was a great advertiser, but inferior in power to half a dozen kings of the previous dynasty. In the XXth Dynasty one of the royal daughters married the high priest of Amen at Thebes; and on the unex- pected death of the young Rameses V, the throne reverted to his uncle Rameses VI, whose daughter then became the heiress, and her descendants, the high priests of Amen, became the rightful rulers. This priestly rule at Thebes, beginning in 1102 BC, was balanced by a purely secular rule of the north at Tanis (Zoan). These lasted until the rise of Osevisk or Tuotrumes I. The Macedonian Age of the Ptolemies was one of the richest and most brilliant at its start, but soon faded under bad rulers till it fell hopelessly to pieces and succumbed to the Rom subjection in 30 BC. From that time Egypt was ground by taxation, and steadily impoverished. By 300 AD it was too poor to keep even a copper currency in circulation, and barter became general. Public monuments entirely ceased to be erected, and Decius in 250 AD is the last ruler whose name was written in the old hiero- glyphs, which were thenceforward totally forgotten. After three more cents. of increasing degradation and misery, the Arab invasion burst upon the land, and a few thousand men rode through it and cleared out the remaining effete garrisons of the empire in 641 AD. 8th Age.—The Arab invasion found the country exhausted and helpless; repeated waves of tribes poured in, and for a generation or two 7. 8th Age: there was no chance of a settlement. Arabic Gradually the majority of the inhabi- tants were pressed into Islam, and by about 800 AD a strong government was established Egypt from Bagdad, and Egypt rapidly advanced. In place of being the most impoverished country it be- came the richest land of the Mediterranean. The great period of mediaeval Egypt was under the guid- ance of the Mesopotamian civilization, 800-969 AD. The Tunisian dominion of the Fatimites, 969-1171, was less successful. Occasionally strong rulers arose, such as Salah-ed-Din (Saladin), but the age of the Mamalukes, 1250-1577, was one of steady decline. Under the Turkish dominion, 1517, Egypt was split up into many half-independent counties, whose rulers began by yielding tribute, but relapsed into ignoring the Caliphate and living in continual internal feuds. In 1771 Aly Bey, a slave, succeeded in conquering Syria. The French and British quarrel left Muhamed Aly to rise su- preme, and to guide Egypt for over 40 years. Again Egypt conquered Syria, 1831-39, but was compelled by Europe to retreat. The opening of the Suez Canal (1869) necessarily led to the subjection of Egypt to European direction. The foreign connections of Egypt have been brought to light only during the last 20 years. In place of supposing that Egypt was’ 8. Early isolated until the Gr conquest, we now Foreign see that it was in the closest commer- Connections cial relation with the rest of the world throughout its history. We have al- ready noted the influences which entered by con- quest. During the periods of high civilization in Egypt, foreign connections came into notice by exploration and by trade. The lazuli of Persia was imported in the prehistoric age, as well as the emery of Smyrna. In the Ist Dynasty, Egypt conquered and held Sinai for the sake of the turquoise mines. In the ITId Dynasty, large fleets of ships were built, some as much as 160 ft. long; and the presence of much pottery imported from Crete and the north, even before this, points to a Mediterranean trade. In the Vth Dynasty, King Unas had relations with Syria. From the XIUth Dynasty comes the de- tailed account of the life of an Egyptian in Pal (Sanehat); and Cretan pottery of this age is found traded into Egypt. HI. Old Testament Connections.—The Hyksos invasion unified the rule of Syria and Egypt, and Syrian pottery is often found in Egypt 1. Semitic of this age. The return of the wave, Connections when Egypt drove out the Hyksos, and conquered Syria out to the Euphrates, was the greatest expansion of Egypt. Tahutmes I set.up his statue on the Euphrates, and all Syria was in his hands. Tahutmes III repeatedly raided Syria, bringing back plunder and captives year by year throughout most of his reign. The number of Syrian artists and of Syrian women brought into Egypt largely changed the style of art and the stand- ard of beauty. Amenhotep IIT held all Syria in peace, and recorded his triumphs at the Euphrates on the walls of the temple of Soleb far up in Nubia. His monotheist son, Amenhotep IV, took the name of Akhenaton, ‘the glory of the sun’s disc,” and established the worship of the radiant sun as the Aton, or Adon of Syria. The cuneiform letters from Tell el-Amarna place all this age before us in detail. There are some from the kings of the Amor- ites and Hittites, from Naharain and even Baby- lonia, to the great suzerain Amenhotep III. There is also the long series describing the gradual loss of Syria under Akhenaton, as written by the governors and chiefs, of the various towns. The main letters are summarized in the Students’ History of Egypt, TI, and full abstracts of all the letters are in Syria and Egypt, arranged in historical order. Pal was reconquered by Seti I and his son Rameses II, but they only held about a third of the extent which formerly belonged to Amenhotep III. Mer- THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 910 enptah, son of Rameses, also raided Southern Pal. After that, it was left alone till the raid of Sheshenq in 933 BC. The only considerable assertion of Egyp power was in Necoh’s two raids up to the Euphrates, in 609 and 605 BC. But Egypt generally held the desert and a few minor points along the south border of Pal. The Ptolemies seldom possessed more than that, their aspirations in Syria not lasting as per- manent conquests. They were more successful in holding Cyprus. We now come to the specific connections of Egypt with the OT. The movement of the family of Abram from Ur in the south of Meso- 2. Abramic potamia up to Haran in the north (Gen Times 11 31) and thence down Syria into Egypt (Gen 12 5.10) was like that of the earlier Sem ‘‘princes of the desert,’’ when they entered Egypt as the Hyksos kings about 2600 BC. Their earlier dominion was the XVth Dynasty of Egypt, and that was followed by another movement, the XVIth Dynasty, about 2250 BC, which was the date of the migration of Terah from Ur. Thus the Abramic family took part in the second Hyksos movement. The cause of these tribal movements has been partly explained by Mr. Huntington’s re- searches on the recurrence of dry periods in Asia (Royal Geogr. Soc., May 26, 1910: The Pulse of Asia). Such lack of rain forces the desert peoples on to the cultivated lands, and then later famines are recorded. The dry age which pushed the Arab tribes on to the Mediterranean in 640 AD was suc- ceeded by famines in Egypt during 6 cents. So as soon as Abram moved into Syria a famine pushed him on to Egypt (Gen 12 10). To this succeeded other famines in Canaan (Gen 26 1), and later in both Canaan and Egypt (Gen 41 56; 48 1; 47 18). The migration of Abram was thus conditioned by the general dry period, which forced the second Hyksos movement of which it was a part. The culture of the Hyksos was entirely nomadic, and agrees in all that we can trace with the patriarchal culture pictured in Gen. Circumcision was a very ancient mutilation in Egypt, and is still kept up there by both Muslim and Christian. It was first adopted 3. Circum- by Abram for Ishmael, the son of the cision Egyp Hagar (Gen 16 3; 17 23), be- fore Isaac was promised. Hagar mar- ried Ishmael to an Egyptian (Gen 21 21), so that the Ishmaelites, or Hagarenes, of Gilead and Moab were three-quarters Egyptian. At Gerar, in the south of Pal, Egyptian was the prevailing race and language, as the general of 911 Abimelech was Phichol, the Egyp name Pa-khal, “the Syrian,’”’ showing that the Gerarites were not Syrians. The Tekan of Joseph rising to Importance as a capable slave is perfectly natural in Egypt at that time, and equally so in later periods down to our 4. Joseph own days. That this occurred during the Hyksos period is shown by the title given to Joseph—Abrekh, Cabhrékh) (Gen 41 43) which is Abarakhu, the high Bab title. ‘he names Zaphnath- paaneah, Asenath, and Potipherah have been yariousl equated in Egyptian, Naville seeing forms of the XVIIIt Er iaaee in. them, but Spiegelherg, with more proba- bility, seelng types of names of the XXIId Dynasty or later. The names are most likely an expansion of the original document; but there is not a single feature or incident in the relations of Joseph to the Egyptians which is at all improhahle trom the history and civiliza- tion that we know. See Josrrx. The descent into Egypt and sojourn there are what might be expected of any Sem tribe at this time. The allocation in Goshen (Gen 47 27) 6. Descent was the most suitable, as that was on into Egypt the eastern border of the Delta, at the mouth of the Wady Tumilat, and was a district isolated from the general Egyp population. The whole of Goshen is not more than 100 sq. miles, being bounded by the deserts, and by the large Egyp city of Budastis on the W. The accounts of the embalming for 40 days and mourning for 70 days (Gen 50 3), and putting in a coffin (Gen 50 26) are exact. The 70 days’ mourning existed both in the Ist Dynasty and in the XXth. The oppression in Egypt began with a new king that knew not Joseph. This can hardly be other than the rise of the Berber conquerors 6. The Op- who took the Delta from the Hyksos pression at the beginning of the XVIIIth Dy- nasty, 1582 BC, and expelled the Hyksos into Syria. It could not be later than this, as the period of oppression. in Egypt is stated at 4 cents. (Gen 16 13; Acts 7 6), and the Exodus cannot be later than about 1220 BC, which leaves 360 years for the oppression. Also this length of oppression bars any much earlier date for the Exo- dus. The 360 years of oppression from 430 of the Sg > Statue of Rameses II at Luqsor. total sojourn in Egypt, leaves 70 years of freedom there. As Joseph died at 110 (Gen 50 26), this implies that he was over 40 when his family came into Egypt, which would be quite consistent with the history. THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Egypt The store cities Pithom and Raamses are the sites Tell el-Maskhuta and Tell Rotab in the Wady Tumilat, both built by Rameses II as 7. The frontier defences. It is evident then Historic that the serving with rigor was under Position that king, probably in the earlier part of his long reign of 67 years (1300- 1234 BC), when he was actively campaigning in Pal. This is shown in the narrative, for Moses was not yet born when the rigor began (Ex 1; 2 2), and he grew up, slew an Egyptian, and then lived long in Midian before the king of Egypt died (Ex 2 23), erhaps 40 or 50 years after the rigorous servitude besaae for he is represented as being 80 at the time of the Exodus (Dt 34 7). These numbers are probably not precise, but as a whole they agree well enough with Egyp history. After the king died, Moses returned to Egypt, and began moving to get his kin away to the eastern deserts, with which he had been well acquainted in his exile from Egypt. A harsher servitude ensues, which might be expected from the more vigorous reign of Merenptah, after the slackness of the old age of Rameses. The cam- paign of Merenptah against Israel and other people in Pal would not make him any less severe in hi treatment of Semites in Egypt. The plagues are in the order of usual seasonal troubles in Egypt, from the red un- wholesome Nile in June, through the frogs, insects, hail and rain, locusts, and sandstorms in March. The death of the firstborn was in April at the Passover. The date of the Exodus is indicated as being about 1200 BC, by the 4 cents. of oppression, and by the names of the land and the city 9. Date of of Rameses (Gen 47 4; cf Ex 1 11). the Exodus Thehistorical limit is that the Egyptians were incessantly raiding Pal down to 1194 BC, and then abandoned it till the invasion of Shishak. As there is no trace of these Egyp invasions during all the ups and downs of the age of the Judges, it seems impossible to suppose the Israelites entered Canaan till after 1194 BC. The setting back of the Exodus much earlier has arisen from taking three simultaneous histories of the Judges as consecutive, as we shall notice farther on. The facts stated above, and the length of all three lines of the priestly gene- alogies, agree completely with the Egyp history in putting the Exodus at about 1220 BC, and the entry into Canaan about 1180 BC. The route of the Exodus was first a concentration at Raamses or Tell Rotdb, in the Wady Tumilat, followed hy a march to Succoth, a general name for 8. The Plagues 10. Route the region of Bedawy hooths; from there of the to Etham in the edge of the wilderness, ahout the modern Nefisheh. Thence they Exodus turned and encamped hefore Pi-hahiroth, the HeyP Pa-qaheret, a Serapeum. Thus turning S. to the W. of the Red Sea (which then ex- tended up to Tell el-Maskhuta), they had a Migdol tower behind them and Baal-zephon opposite to them. They were thus ‘entangled in the land.’’ Then the strong east wind bared the shallows, and made it possible to cross the gulf and reach the opposite shore. They then went ‘‘ three days in the wilderness,’’ the three days’ route without water to Marah, the bitter spring of Hawara, and immediately beyond reached Elim, which accords entirely with the Wady Gharandel. Thence they encamped by the Red Sea. All of this account exactly agrees with the traditional route down the W. of the Sinaitic peninsula; it will not agree with any other route, and there Is no reason to look for any different location of the march. See Exonvs, I. E The numbers of the Israelites have long been a diffi- culty. On the one hand are the census lists (Nu 1, 2and 26), with their summaries of 600,000 men 11. Num-__ besides children and a mixed multitude bers of the Ex 12 37.38; 38 26; Nu 1 46; 11 21). m the other hand there are the exact Exodus statements of there heing 22,273 firsthorn, that is, fathers of families (Nu 3 43), and that 40,000 armed men entered Canaan with Joshua (Josh 4 13), also the 35,000 who fought at Ai (Josh 8 3.12), and the 32,000 who fought against Midian (Jgs 3). Besides these, there are the genera] considerations Egypt THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 912 that only 5,000 to 10,000 people could live in Goshen, that the Amalekites with whom the Israelites were equally matched (Ex 17 11) could not have exceeded about 5,000 in Sinai, that Moses judged all disputes, and that two midwives attended all the Israelite births, which would be 140 a day on a population of 600,000. Evi- dently the statements of numbers are contradictory, and the external evidence is allin accord with lesser numbers. Proposals to reduce arbitrarily the larger numbers have been frequent; but there is one likely line of misunder- standing that may have originated the increase. In the census lists of the trihes, most of the hundreds in_ the numbers are 400 or 500, others are near those, and there are none whatever on 000, 100, 800 or 900. Evidently the hundreds are independent of the thousands. Nowin writing the statements, such as ‘‘ Reuben, 46,500,’ the original list would be 46 ’eleph, 5 hundred people, and . ‘eleph_ means either ‘‘thousands” or else “groups"’ or “families.” Hence a census of 46 teuts, 500 people, would be ambiguous, and a later compiler might well take it as 46,500. tents, 5,550 people, would be misread as 603,550 people. The checks on this are, that the number per tent should be reasonable in all cases, that the hundreds should not fluctuate more than the tents between the first and last census, and that the total should correspond to the known populations of Goshen and of Sinai; these requirements all agree with this reading of the lists. The ulterior details beyond the Peay plan period are dealt with in Egypt and Israel, 45,55. See Exonus, IV. Two points need notice here as incidentally bear- ing on the Egyp connections: (1) the Israelites in Pal before the Exodus, indicated by 12. Israel Merenptah triumphing over them there in Canaan before 1230 BC, and the raids during the Egyp residence (1 Ch 7 21); (2) the triple history of the Judges, west, north, and east, each totaling to 120 years, in accord with the In this way the whole census of 598 | length of the four priestly genealogies (1 Ch 6 4. 8.22-28 .33-35.39-43.44-47), and showing that the . dates are about 1220 BC the Exodus,‘1180 BC the ' entry to Canaan, 1150 BC the beginning of Judges, 1030 BC Saul (Egypt and Israel, 52-58). The connections with the monarchy soon begin. David and Joab attacked Edom (2 8 8 14), and Hadad, the young king, was carried 13. Hadad off by his servants to Egypt for safety. The Pharaoh who received and sup- ported him must have been Siamen, the king of Zoan, which city was then an independent capital apart from the priest kings of Thebes (1 K 11 15- { 22), Hadad was married to the Egyp queen’s sis- ter when he grew up, probably in the reign of Pa- sebkhanu IT. : The Pharaoh whose daughter was married to Solomon must have been the same Pasebkhanu; he reigned from 987-952 BC, and the 14. Pha~ marriage was about 970 in the middle raoh’s of the reign. Another daughter of Daughter Pasebkhanu was Karamat, who was the wife of Shishak. Thus Solomon and Shishak married two sisters, and their aunt was queen of Edom. This throws light on the politics of the kingdoms. Probably Solomon had some child by Pharaoh’s daughter, and the Egyptians would expect that to be the heir. Shishak’s inva- sion, on the death of Solomon, was perhaps based upon the right of a nephew to the throne of Judah. The invasion of Shishak (Egyp, Sheshenq) took place probably at the end of his reign. His troops were Lubim (Libyans), Sukkim (men 15. Shishak of Succoth, the east border) and Kush- im (Ethiopians). The account of the war is on the side of the great fore-court at Karnak, which shows long lists of places in Judah, agreeing with the subjugation recorded in 1 K 14 25.26, and 2 Ch 12 2-4. Zerakh, or Usarkon, was the next king of Egypt, the son of Karamat, Solomon’s sister-in-law. He invaded Judah unsuccessfully in 903 16. Zerakh BC (2 Ch 149) with an army of Libyans and Sudanis (2 Ch 16 8). A statue of the Nile, dedicated by him, and naming his descent from Karamat and Pasebkhanu, is in the British Museum. After a couple of cents. the Ethiopian kings inter- vened. Shabaka was appointed viceroy of Egypt by his father Piankhy, and is described 17. The by the Assyrians as Sibe, commander- Ethiopians in-chief of Muzri, and by the Hebrews as Sua or So, king of Egypt (2 K 17 4). Tirhakah next appears as a viceroy, and Heze- kiah was warned against trusting to him (2 K 19 9). These two kings touch on Jewish history during their viceroyalties, before their full reigns began. Necoh next touches on Judah in his raid to Car- chemish in 609 BC, when he slew Josiah for oppos- ing him (2 K 23 29.30; 2 Ch 35 20-24). After the taking of Jerus, for fear of vengeance for the insurrection of Ishmael (2 K 25 25.26; Jer 40, 41, 42), the remnant of the Jews 18. Tah- fled to the frontier fortress of Egypt, panhes Tahpanhes, Tehaphnehes, Gr Daphnae, mod. Defenneh, about 10 miles W. of the present Suez Canal (Jer 43 7-13). The brick pavement in front of the entrance to the fortress there, in which Jeremiah hid the stones, has been uncovered and the fortress completely planned. It was occupied by Greeks, who there brought Gr words and things into contact with the traveling Jews for a couple of generations before the fall of Jerus. The prophecy that Hophra would be delivered to them that sought his life (Jer 44 30) was fulfilled, i as he was kept captive by his successor, 19. Hophra Amasis, for 3 years, and after a brief attempt at liberty, he was strangled. The account of the Jews settled in Egypt (Jer 44) is singularly illustrated by the Aram. Jewish papyri found at Syene (Aswan). These show 20. The the use of Aram. and of oaths by Yahu, Jews at as stated of 5 cities.in Egypt (Isa 19 Syene 18). The colony at Syene was well-to- do, though not rich; they were house- holders who possessed all their property by regular title-deeds, who executed marriage settlements, and were fully used to litigation, having in deeds of sale a clause that no other deed could be valid. The temple of Yahu filled the space between two roads, 913 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Egypt and faced upon 3 houses, implying a building about 60 or 70 ft. wide. It was built of hewn stone, with stone columns, 7 gates, and a cedar roof. It was destroyed in 410, after lasting from before Cam- byses in 525 BC, and a petition for rebuilding it was granted in 407. The most flourishing period of the Jews in Egypt was when Oniah IV, the son of the rightful high priest Oniah, was driven from Jerus by the 21. The abolition of Jewish worship and ordi- New Jeru- nances under Antiochus. In 170 BC salem of he fled to Egypt, and there established Oniah a new Jerus with a temple and sacrifices as being the only way to maintain the Jewish worship. Oniah IV was a valiant man, gen- eral to queen Cleopatra I; and he offered to form the Jewish community into a frontier guard on the E. of Egypt, hating the Syrians to the uttermost, if the Jews might form their own community. They so dominated the eastern Delta that troops of Caesar could not pass from Syria to Alexandria without their assent. The new Jerus was 20 miles N. of Cairo, a site now known as Tell el-Yehudiyeh. The great mound of the temple still remains there, with the Passover ovens beneath it, and part of the mas- sive stone fortifications on the front of it. This remained a stronghold of free Judaism until after Titus took Jerus; and it was only when the Zealots tried to make it a center of insurrection, that at last it was closed and fell into decay. Jos is the original authority for this history (see Egypt and Israel, 97-110). The Jew in Egypt followed a very different de- velopment from the Bab Jew, and this Egyp type largely influenced Christianity. Inthe 22. The colony at Syene a woman named “Trust Egyptian Yahveh”’ had no objection to swearing Jew by the Egyp goddess Seti when making an Egyp contract; and in Jer 44 15- 19, the Jews boasted of their heathen worship in Egypt. Oniah had no scruple in establishing a temple and sacrifices apart from Jerus, without any of the particularism of the Maccabean zealots. Philo at Alexandria labored all his life for the union of Jewish thought with Gr philosophy. The Her- metic books show how, from 500 to 200 BC, religious thought was developing under eclectic influence of Egyp, Jewish, Pers, Indian and Gr beliefs, and producing the tenets about the second God, the Eternal Son, who was the Logos, and the types of Conversion, as the Divine Ray, the New Birth, and the Baptism. Later the Wisdom lit. of Alexandria, 200-100 BC, provided the basis of thought and simile on which the Pauline Epp. were built. The great wrench in the history of the church came when it escaped from the Bab-Jewish formalism of the Captivity, which ruled at Jerus, and grew into the wider range of ideas of the Alexandrian: Jews. These ideas had been preserved in Egypt from the days of the monarchy, and had developed a great body of religious thought and phraseology from their eclectic connections. The relations of Chris- tianity with Egypt are outside our scope, but some of them will be found in Egypt and Israel, 124-41. The Egyp cities, places and peoples named in the OT may briefly be noted. Aven (Ezk 30 17) or On (Gen 41 45) is the ’An-of Egyptian, 23. Cities the Gr Heliopolis, now Matarieh, 7 and Places miles N. of Cairo. It was the seat Alphabeti- of prehistoric government, the royal cally ciiblese were kept there as the sacred relics of the temple, and its high priest was “the great seer,’’ one of the greatest of the religious officials. The schools of Heliopolis were celebrated, and it seems to have always been a cen- ter of learning. The site is now marked by the great inclosure of the temple, and one obelisk of Senusert (XIIth Dynasty). It was here that the Egyp kings had at their installation to come and bathe in the lake in which the sun bathes daily, the ’ Ainesh-Shems, or ‘Lake of the Sun” of the Arabs, connected with the fresh spring here which Chris- tian tradition attributes to the visit of the Virgin and Child. The great sycamore tree here is the successor of that under which the Virgin is said to have rested. BAAL-ZEPHON was a shrine on the eastern site of the head of the Red Sea, a few miles 8. of Ismaili- yeh; no trace is now known of it (Ex 14 2). Cusuim or Ethiopians were a part of the Egyp army of Shishak and of Usarkon (2 Ch 12 3; 16 8). The army was in 4 brigades, that of Ptah of Memphis, central Egypt; that of Amen of Thebes, Southern Egypt and Ethiopia; that of Set of the eastern frontier (Sukkim); and that of Ra, Heliop- olis and the Delta. GosHEN was a fertile district at the west end of the Wady Tumilat, 40 to 50 miles N.E. of Cairo. It was bounded by the deserts on the N. and 8.E., and by the Egyp city of Bubastis on the W. Its area was not over 100 sq. miles; it formerly sup- ported 4,000 Bedawin and now about 12,000 cul- tivators. Lusim, the Libyans who formed part of the Egyp army as light-armed archers, from very early times. Miapo is the name of any tower, familiar also as Magdala. It was applied to some watchtower on the W. of the Red Sea, probably on the high land above the Serapeum. No is Thebes, in Assyr Nia, from the Egyp Nu, “the city.” This was the capital of the XIIth Dynasty, and of the XVIIth-XXIst Dynasties. Owing to the buildings being of sandstone, which is not of much use for reworking, they have largely remained since the desolation of the city under Ptolemy X. The principal divisions of the site are: (1) Karnak, with the temple of the XIIth Dynasty, built over by all the successive kings of the XVIIIth Dynasty, and enlarged by Seti I and Rameses II, and by Shishak, Tirhakah, and the Ptolemies. The whole temple of Amon and its subsidiary temples form the largest mass of ruins that is known. (2) Luqsor, the temple to commemorate the divine birth of Amenhotep III (1440 BC), added to by Rameseg II. (3) The funerary temples, bordering the western shore, of the kings of the XVIIIth to XXth Dynasties. These have mostly been de- stroyed, by the unscrupulous quarrying done by each king on the work of his predecessors; the only temple in fair condition is that of Rameses III, which is left because no later king required its material for building. (4) The great cemetery, rang- ing from the splendid rock halls of the Tombs of the Kings, covered with paintings, down to the humblest graves. For any detailed account see either Bae- deker’s or Murray’s Guides, or Weigall’s Guide to Antiquities. Norn, the Egyp Men-nofer, Gr Memphis, now Mitraheny, 12 miles S. of Cairo. This was the capi- tal from the foundation at the beginning of the dynasties. Thebes and Alexandria shared its im- portance, but it was the seat of government down to the Arab invasion. In Rom times it was as large as London N. of the Thames. The outlying parts are now all buried by the rise of the soil, but more than a mile length of ruins yet remains, which are now being regularly worked over by the British School. The heart of the city is the great metro- politan temple of Ptah, nearly all of which is now under 10 feet of soil, and under water most of the year. This is being excavated in sections, as it is all private property. At the north end of the ruins is the palace mound, on which has been cleared the palace of Apries (Hophra). Other temples have Egypt THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 914 been located, as well as the foreign quarter con- taining early Gr pottery and the temple of Proteus named by Herodotus (see Memphis, I, II, II). Paruros is the usual name for Upper Egypt in the prophets. It isthe Egyp Pa-ta-res, ‘“‘the south land.” PiseseTH is the Egyp Pa-Bast, Gr Bubastis, at the eastern side of the Delta, the city of the cat-headed goddess Bast. The ruins are still large, and the temple site has been excavated, producing sculptures from the IVth Dynasty onward. Pitxom is the Egyp Pa-Tum, the city of the Sun- god Tum or Atmu, who was worshipped on the E. of the Delta. The site has remains of the fortress of Rameses II, built by the Israelites, and is now known as Tell el-Maskhuta, 11 miles W. of Ismailia. RaamssEs is the other city built by the Israelites, now Tell Rotéb, 20 miles W. of Ismailia. A walled camp existed here from early times, and the temple of Rameses was built on the top of the older ruins. A large part of the temple front is now at Philadel- phia, excavated by the British School. Sin is the Gr Pelusium, Assyr Siinu, Arab. Tineh, now some desolate mounds at the extreme E. coast of Egypt. SuccotsH was the district of “booths,” the eastern part of the Wady Tumilat. It was written in Egyp Thuku and abbreviated to Thu in which form it appears as a Rom name. The people of Succoth oe named in the army of Shishak (2 Ch SyeNE, Heb Sewénéh, mod. Aswan, the southern border town of Egypt at the Cataract. The greater part of the old town was on the island of Elephan- tine. There the Jewish papyri were found, and that, was probably the Jewish settlement with the temple of Yahu. The town on the eastern bank—the pres- ent. Aswan—was of less importance. TaHPANHES, TEHAPHNEHES, Gr Daphnae, Arab. Tell Defeneh. This was the first station on the Syrian road which touched the Nile canals, about 10 miles W. of Kantara on the Suez Canal. It seems to have been founded by Psammetichus about 664 BC, to hold his Gr mercenaries. The fort, built by him, abounded in Gr pottery, and was finally desolated about 566 BC, as described by Herodotus. The fort and camp have been excavated; and the pavement described by Jeremiah (ch 43), as op- posite to the entrance, has been identified. Zoan, Gr Tanis, Arab. San, is about 26 miles from the Suez Canal, and slightly more from the coast. The ruins of the temple are surrounded by the wall of Pasebkhanu, 80 it. thick of brickwork, and a ring of town ruins rises high around it. The temple was built in the VIth Dynasty, adorned with many statues in the XlIth and XIlIth Dynasties, and under Rameses II had many large granite obelisks and statues, esp. one colossus of the king in red granite about 90 ft. high. It is probable that the Pharaoh lived here at the time of the Exodus. IV. The Cwilization.—We now turn to some out- line of the civilization of the Egyptians. The lan- guage had primitive relations with the 1. Lan- Sem and the Libyan. Perhaps one guage common stock has separated into three languages—Sem, Egyp and Libyan. But though some basal words and grammar are in common, all the bulk of the words of daily life were entirely different in the three, and no one could be said to be derived from the other. Egyp, so far as We Can see, is a separate language without any connection as close as that between the Indo-Euro- pean group. From its proximity to Syria, Sem loan words were often introduced, and became common in the XVIIIth Dynasty and fashionable in the XIXtb. The language continually altered, and decayed in the later periods until Coptic is as different from it as Italian is from Latin. The writing was at first ideographic, using a sym- bol for each word. Gradually, signs were used phonetically; but the symbol, or some 2. Writing emblem of the idea of the word, con- tinued to be added to it, now called a determinative. From syllabic signs purely alpha- betic signs were produced by clipping and decay, sc that by 1000 to 500 BC the writing was almost alphabetic. After that it became modified by the influence of the short Gr alphabet, until by 200 AD it was expressed in Gr letters with a few extra signs. The actual signs used were elaborate pictures of the objects in the early times, and even down to the later periods very detailed signs were carved for monumental purposes. But as early as the Ist Dynasty a very much simplified current hand had been started, and during the pyramid period this became hardly recognizable from the original forms. Later on this current hand, or hieratic, is a study by itself and was written much more fully than the hieroglyphs on monuments, as its forms were so corrupt that an ample spelling was needed to iden- tify the word. By about 800 BC begins a much shortened set of signs, stil] more remote from their origins, known as demotic, which continued as the popular writing till Rom times. On public decrees the hieroglyphic and demotic are both given, showing that a knowledge of one was useless for reading the other, and that they were separate studies. The literature begins during the pyramid period, before 4000 BC, with biographies and collections of maxims for conduct; these show well- 8. Liter- regulated society, and would henefit ature any modern community in which they were followed. In the XIIth Dynasty tales appear, occupied with magic and foreign travel and wonders. A Jong poem in praise of the king shows very regular versification and system, of the type of Ps 136, the refrain differing in each stanza and being probably repeated in chorus, while the independent lines were sung by the leader. In the XVIlIth Dynasty, tales of character begin to de- velop and show much skill, long annals were recorded, and in the XIXth Dynasty there is an elaborate battle poem describing the valor of Rameses II. At about 700 BC there is a considerable tale which descrihes the quarrels of the rival chiefs, and the great fight regulated like a tournament by which the differences were settled. Such are the principal literary works apart from business documents. The religion of Egypt is an enormous subject, and that by which Egypt is perhaps most known. Here we can only give an outline of the 4, Four growth and subdivisions of it. There Views of never was any one religion in Egypt Future Life during historic times. There were at least four religions, all incompatible, and all believed in at once in varying degrees. The different religions can hest be seen apart by their incongruity regarding the future life. (1) The dead wandered about the cemetery seek- ing food, and were partly fed by the goddess in the sycamore tree. They therefore needed to have plates of food and jars of water in the tomb, and provided perpetually by their descendants in front of the doorway to the grave. The deceased is rep- resented as looking out over this doorway in one case. Here came in the great principle of substi- tution. For the food, substitute its image which cannot decay, and the carved table of offerings results. For the farmstead of animals, substitute its carved image on the walls and the animal sculp- tures result. For the life of the family, substitute their carved figures doing all that was wanted, sac- rificing and serving, and the family sculptures result. For the house, substitute a model upon the grave, and the pottery soul-bouses appear with their aes ANCIENT EGYPTIAN PAINTINGS ON CLOTH 915 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Egypt furniture and provisions. For the servants, put their figures doing household work, and their service is eternal. For the master himself, put thé most lifelike image that can be made, and his soul will occupy that as a restful home fitted for it. This principle is still believed in. Funeral offerings of food are still put even in Muslim graves, and a woman will visit a grave, and, removing a tile, will talk through a hole to her dead hushand. (2) The dead went to the kingdom of Osiris, to which only the good were admitted, while the evil were rejected, and consumed either by monsters or by fire. This heavenly kingdom was a complete duplicate of the earthly life. They planted and reaped, sported and played. And as the Egyp felicity consisted in making others work for them, so each man was provided with a retinue of serfs to cultivate the land for him. These ushabti figures in later times usually number 400, and often 1 in 10 of them is clad as an overseer. &, ’eldadh, ‘God has loved”): One of the 70 elders chosen by Moses at the com- mand of Jeh to share “the burden of the people” (Nu 11 16-25). Eldad and his companion Medad were not present with the rest at the tent of meeting, yet the Spirit rested also upon them and they prophesied in the camp (vs 26-29). ELDAD, el’dad, AND MODAD, mo’dad, BOOK OF: In the LXX they are called Eldad and Modad. In the AV the names are given as Eldad and Me- dad; meaning ‘‘God has loved” (‘God loves”) and “object of love’ (?). They were two of the seventy elders chosen by Moses (Nu 11 26), and while the others obeyed the summons and went to the taber- nacle, these two remained in the camp and prophe- sied (Nu 11 26). The nature of their prophecy is not recorded, and this naturally became a good subject for the play of the imagination. It fur- nished the basis for a lost work which was quoted by Hermas (Vis 2 8): “The Lord is near to them who return unto him, as it is written in Eldad and Mo- dad, who prophesied to the people in the wilderness.” The Pal Tgs also filled in the subject of the prophecy of Eldad and Modad, and, as they have it, it related to the coming of Gog and Magog against Israel at the end of the days. One of the Tgs has the ex- pression, ‘““The Lord is near to them that are in the hour of tribulation.’”” The authors of the Tgs were either dependent upon that work or upon a similar tradition; and the former of these views is the more probable. Lightfoot and Holtzman think the lengthy quotation in 1 Clem 23 and 2 Clem 11 is from the Book of Eldad and Modad. The work is found in the Stichometry of Nicephorus and consists of 400 stichoi, which would make it about twice the length of the Cant. A. W. Fortunes ELDER, el/-dér, IN THE OT (jpl, z2akén): Among primitive peoples authority seems naturally to be invested in those who by virtue of greater age Elder in the NT Election THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 924 and, consequently, experience are best fitted to govern: thus Iliad ii1.149. Later the idea of age became merged in that of dignity (1. 11.404, 1.570; Odyssey 11.14). In like manner the word patres came to be used among the Romans (Cic. Rep. 2.8. 14). So also among the Germans authority was intrusted to those who were older; cf Tacitus Agricola. The same is true among the Arabians to the present day, the sheik being always a man of age as well as of authority. From the first the Hebrews held this view of gov- ernment, although the term “elder’’ came later to be used of the idea of the authority for which, at first, age was regarded necessary. Thus the office appears in both J (9th cent. BC) (Ex 3 16; 12 21; 24 1, of the elders of the Hebrews; and of the Egyptians, Gen 50 7); and E (8th cent. BC) (Fx 175; 18 12; 19 7 [D.J; Josh 24 31, elders of Israel, or of the people. Cf the principle of selec- tion of heads of tens, fifties, etc, Ex 18 13 ff, seventy being selected from a previous body of elders); cf JE (Nu 11 16.24). Seventy are also mentioned in Ex 24 1, while in Jgs 8 14 seventy-seven are mentioned, although this might be taken to include seven princes. Probably the number was not uni- form. Elder as a title continues to have place down through the times of the Judges (Jgs 8 16; 2 7[D]; ef Ruth 4 2 ff) into the kingdom. Saul asked to be honored before the elders (1 S 15 30); the elders of Bethlehem appeared before Samuel (16 4); the elders appeared before David in Hebron (2 8 17 15; 1 Ch 11 3); elders took part in the temple procession of Solomon (1 K 8 3; 2 Ch 6 4). They continued through the Pers period (Ear 5 5.9; 6 7.14; 10 8.14; Joel 1 14m) and the Maccabean period (Jth 6 16; 7 23; 810; 106; 13 12; 1 Mace 12 35), while the NT (apeoBtrepos, presbi- teros, Mt 16 21; 26 47.57; Mk 8 31; Lk 9 22; Acts 4 5.23) makes frequent mention of the office. The elders served as local magistrates, in bringing murderers to trial (Dt 19 12; 21 1ff; Josh 20 4), punishing a disobedient son (Dt 21 19), inflicting penalty for slander (22 15), for noncompliance with the Levirate marriage law (25 7 ff), enforcing the Law (27 1), conducting the service in expiation of unwitting violation of the Law (Lev 4 13 ff). In certain passages different classes of officers are mentioned as ‘judges and officers” (Dt 16 18), “elders” and “officers” (81 28), ‘heads, tribes, elders, officers” (29 10 [Heb 9]). It is probable that both classes were selected from among the elders, and that to one class was assigned the work of judging, and that the ‘‘officers” exercised execu- tive functions (Schiirer). In entirely Jewish com- munities He same men would be both officers of the community and elders of the synagogue. In this case the same men would have jurisdiction over civil and religious matters. Litenaturn.—Schiirer, GJV3, § 23, esp. 175 ff (Eng. ed, II, i, 149 ff; Benzinger, H A2, 51; Deissmann, Brbel- studien, 153 ff (s.v. mpeoBirepos); BDB, 278 GRD: Preuschen, Griechisch-Deutsches Handwérterbuch, 8.V., 958 f. W. N. Srearns ELDER IN THE NT (wpecBirepos, presbiteros): (1) The word is used adjectivally to denote sen- jority (Lk 15 25; 1 Tim 5 2). (2) Referring to the Jewish elders of the syna- gogue, usually associated with the scribes and Pharisees, and NT passages cited in the previous article. (3) It denotes certain persons appointed to hold office in the Christian church, and to exercise spirit- ual oversight over the flock intrusted to them. From the references in Acts (14 23; 20 17) it may be inferred that the churches generally had elders appointed over them. That “elders” and ‘‘bishops”’ were in apostolic and sub-apostolic times the same, is now almost universally admitted; in all NT references their functions are identical. The most probable explanation of the difference of names is that “elder” refers mainly to the person, and “bishop” to the office; the name ‘elder’? empha- sizes what he is, while “bishop,” that is ‘‘overseer,”’ emphasizes what the elder or presbyter does. See BisHor; CourcH GovERNMENT; Ministry. A. C. GRANT ELEAD, el’é-ad (AION, *el‘ddh, “God has tes- tified”): An Ephraimite, slain while making a raid, by the men of Gath (1 Ch 7 21). ELEADAH, el-é-a'da, ELADAH (AV) (TI9>8, *el‘ddhah, “God has adorned’): An Ephraimite (i Ch 7 20). ~ ELEALEH, 6-lé-3/le (Mb9DN, ’el'alzh, “God has ascended”): Lay in the country taken from Sihon and within the lot given to Reuben (Nu 382 3.37 f). “Their names being changed’’ seems to apply to all the towns mentioned. There is no indication of the other names. Elealeh is noticed with Heshbon in the oracles against Moab in Isa 15 4; 16 9; Jer 48 34. Onom locates it one Rom mile from Hesh- bon. It is represented today by el‘Al, a mound crowned with ruins, about a mile N. of Hesban. ELEASA, el-é-a’sa. ELEASAH, el-é-a’sa (in Heb identical with Exasau, which see): (1) A descendant of Judah (1 Ch 2 39.40). (2) A Benjamite, a descendant of Saul (1 Ch 8 37; 9 43). ELEAZAR, el-é-a’zar, 6-lé-a’zar (VTD2N, ’el- ‘dzdr; "Eded{ap, Eledzar, ‘God is helper’): (1) The 3d son of Aaron by Elisheba (Ex 6 23; Nu 3 2). He married one of the daughters of Putiel, who bore him Phinehas (Ex 6 25). With his father and 3 brothers he was consecrated to the priest’s office (Ex 28 1). After the destruction of Nadab and Abihu, he occupied a more important position, and he and Ithamar “ministered in the priest’s office in the presenve of Aaron their father’’ (Lev 106f; Nu3 4; 1 Ch 24 2 ff). He was given the oversight of the Levites and had charge of the tabernacle and all within it (Nu 3 32; 4 16). To Eleazar fell the duty of beating out for an altar covering the censers of Korah and his fellow- conspirators who had attempted to seize the priest- hood (Nu 16 37.39). On the death of Aaron, Eleazar succeeded him (Nu 20 25 ff). He assisted Moses with the census after the plague in the plains of Moab (Nu 26 1 ff), and with Moses and the elders heard the petition of the daughters of Zelo- phehad who wished to be served as heirs to their father (Nu 27 1ff). After the entrance into Canaan, Eleazar and Joshua gave effect to the de- cision arrived at by giving the daughters of Zelo- phehad a share in the land of Manasseh (Josh 17 4). He was priest and adviser to Joshua, the suc- cessor of Moses (Nu 27 19; 31 12 ff), whom he also assisted in partitioning Canaan among the tribes (Nu 3417; Josh 14 1; 19 51; 211). He was buried in the hill (RVm ‘“Gibeah”) of Phinehas his son in the hill country of Ephraim (Josh 24 33). For some reason unknown the descendants of Itha- mar seem to have held the chief position among the priests from Eli till the accession of Solomon, when Abiathar was sent into retirement, and Zadok, the descendant of Eleazar, was appointed in his place (1 K 2 26 ff). Ezra was a descendant of Zadok See Exasa. 925 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Elder in the NT Election (Ezr 7 1 ff); and the high priest’s office was in the family of Zadok till the time of the Maccabees. (2) The gon of Abinadab, sanctified to keep the ark of Jeh, when it was brought from Beth-shemesh to Kiriath-jearim after being sent back by the Philis (1 S 7 1). (8) The son of Dodai, one of David’s three mighty men. A famous feat of arms with David at Ephes-dammim is recorded (2 8 28 9f; 1 Ch 11 12 f where he is named the son of Dodo). (4) A Levite, a son of Mahli, a Merarite. It is recorded that he had no sons, but daughters only, wae eh married to their cousins (1 Ch 23 21.22; 8). (5) A priest who accompanied Ezra from Baby- lon (Ezr 8 33); the son of Phinehas. (5) and (6) may be identical. (6) A priest who took part in the dedication of the wall of Jerus (Neh 12 42). (7) A son of Mattathias and brother of Judas Maccabaeus (1 Macc 2 5; 6 48f; 2 Macc 8 23). See ASMonEANS; MaccaBEEs. (8, 9) Two others are mentioned in 1 Macc 8 17; 2 Macc 6 18 ff. (10) An ancestor of Jesus, 3 generations before Joseph (Mt 1 15). S. F. Hunter ELEAZURUS, (q.v.). ELECT, élIekt’: That is, “chosen,” “selected.” In the OT the word represents derivatives of "Ji, bahar, elegit; in the NT éxAexrés, eklekids. It means properly an object or objects of selection. This primary meaning sometimes passes into that of “eminent,” “valuable,” ‘‘choice”; often thus as a fact, in places where AV uses ‘‘chosen”’ (or “‘elect’’) to translate the original (e.g. Isa 42 1; 1 Pet 2 6). In AV “elect” (or ‘‘chosen”’) is used of Israel as the race selected for special favor and to be the special vehicle of Divine purposes (so 4t in Apoc, Tob and Ecclus); of the great Servant of Jeh (cf Lk 23 35; the “Christ of God, his chosen’’); cf eminent saints as Jacob, Moses, Rufus (Rom 16 13); ‘‘the lady,” and her “sister” of 2 Jn; of the holy angels (1 Tim 6 21), with a possible suggestion of the lapse of other angels. Otherwise, and prevalently in the NT, it denotes a human community, also described as believers, saints, the Israel of God; regarded as in some sense selected by Him from among men, objects of His special favor, and correspondingly called to special holiness and service. See further under Exection. In the Eng. VSS “elect” is not used as a vb.: “to choose” is preferred; e.g. Mk 13 20; Eph 1 4. Hanpiey DuNELM RV ELIASIBUS el-é-a-zti'rus, ELECT LADY, é-lekt’ 1a’di (ékAexrqg kvpla, eklekté kuria; 2 Jn ver 1): In accordance with strict grammatical usage these words of address may be tr? in three ways: ‘‘to an elect lady” (which as an address is too indefinite); or, both words being taken as proper names, “to Hklekté Kuria’” (an improbable combination of two very rare names); or “to Eklekte, lady” =anglice, ‘to the lady [or ‘Madam’) Hklekté.” The other translations which have been given—‘‘to the elect lady” or “to the elect Kuria”—are open to objection on account of the omission of the article; but this violation of rule is perhaps not without parallel (cf 1 Pet 1 1). The translation adopted will partly depend upon whether we regard the epistle as addressed to an individual or to a community. Dr. Rendel Harris believes this question to be settled by the discovery in the papyri of numerous instances which prove that kurios and kurta were used by ancient letter- writers as terms of familiar endearment, applicable to brother, sister, son, wife, or intimate friend of either sex (Hzposttor, March, 1901; see also Find- lay, Fellowship in the Life Eternal, ch iii). In the light of this suggestion we should naturally translate, “to my [dear] lady Eklekté.”” Grammatically, this is strongly supported by 1 Tim 1 2and2 Tim 1 2 (Tisodép yrncig ... . dyarnr@ ... . Téxvy, Tim- othéS gnésid .... agapétd... . téknd=“‘to Tim- othy my true... . beloved .... child’); and the fact that the name Eklekté has not yet been discovered, though Eklektés has, offers no grave ob- jection. This is the tr favored by Clement of Alex- andria, who says of the epistle: scripta vero est ad quandam Babyloniam nomine Electam, stgnificat autem electionem ecclesiae sanctae (“It is written to a certain Babylonian, Electa by name; but it signi- fies thefurther election of the holy church’’). Itseems doubtful whether he means by the last clause that Electa is simply a personification of the church, or a real person whose name was derived from the Christian idea of election. Either way the render- ing, “‘to the lady Electa,” is suitable, and upon the whole it seems the best. Hklekt@ is not an adj. but a noun. If a person is intended, it is “the lady Electa’”’; if a church, it is designated, not “the elect Lady,” but “the lady Elect.” The mention of “thy elect sister” in 2 Jn ver 13 does not hinder either supposition. See further Crria; Joun, THE EPISTLes OF. Rosert Law ELECTION, é-lek’shun (ékAoy4, eklogé, “choice,” “selection’’): . Tse Worp 1n ScrRiPpTuRE Il, Tae Mysterncous ELEMENT Ill. Incipence vrpon CoMMUNITY AND INDIVIDUAL IV. Coonate anv Iuiustrative Bisticat Lanevaen V. Lamitatrons or Inquiry Herz. Score or Exvze- VI. Passeveuance VII. ConsipERations In RELIEF or THOUGHT I. Antinomies 2. Fatalism Another Thing 3. The Moral Aspects 4. ‘We know in Part’’ 5. The Unknown Future I. The Word in Scripture.—The word is absent from the OT, where the related Heb vb. (173, bahar) is frequent. In the NT it occurs 6t (Rom 911; 11 5.7.28; 1 Thess 14; 2 Pet 110). In all these places it appears to denote an act of Divine selection taking effect upon human objects so as to bring them into special and saving relations with God: a selection such as to be at once a mysterious thing, transcending human analysis of its motives (so eminently in Rom 9 11), and such as to be knowable by its objects, who are (2 Pet) exhorted to “make it sure,” certain, a fact to consciousness. It is always (with one exception, Rom 9 11; see below) related to a community, and thus has close affinity with the OT teachings upon the privileged position of Israel as the chosen, selected race (see under Exect). The objects of election in the NT are, in effect, the Israel of God, the new, regenerate race called to special privilege and special service. From one point of view, that of the external marks of Christianity, they may thus be described as the Christian community in its widest sense, the sense in which the sacramental position and the real are prima facie assumed to coincide. But from 2 Pet it is manifest that much more than this has to be said if the incidence of the word present to the writer’s mind is to be rightly felt. It is assumed there that the Christian, baptized and a worshipper, may yet need to make “sure” his “calling and elec- tion” as a fact to his consciousness. This implies conditions in the “election”? which far transcend the tests of sacred rite and external fellowship. Il. The Mysterious Element.—Such impressions of depth and mystery in the word are confirmed by Election Eleph THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 926 the other passages. In Rom 9 11 the context is charged with the most urgent and even staggering challenges to submission and silence in the presence of the inscrutable. To illustrate large assertions as to the liberty and sovereignty of the Divine deal- ings with man, the apostle brings in Esau and Jacob, individuals, twins as yet unborn, and points to the inscrutable difference of the Divine action toward them as such. Somehow, as a matter of fact, the Eternal appears as appointing to unborn Esau a future of comparative disfavor and to Jacob of favor; a future announced to the still pregnant mother. Such discrimination was made and an- nounced, says the apostle, ‘that the purpose of God - according to election might stand.” In the whole passage the gravest stress is laid upon the isolation of the “election” from the merit or demerit of its objects. : If, Incidence upon Community and Individual. —lIt is observable that the same characteristic, the inscrutable, the sovereign, is attached in the OT to the “election” of a favored and privileged nation. Israel is repeatedly reminded (see e.g. Dt 7) that the Divine call and choice of them to be the people of God has no relation to their virtues, or to their strength. The reason lies out of sight, in the Di- vine mind. So too “the Israel of God” (Gal 6 16) in the NT, the Christian community, “the new, peculiar race,”’ holds its great privileges by quite unmerited favor (e.g. Tit 3 5). And the nature of the case here leads, as it does not in the case of the natural Israel, to the thought of a Divine election of the individual, similarly inscrutable and sover- eign. For the idea of the New Israel involves the thought that in every genuine member of it the provisions of the New Covenant (Jer 31 31f) are being fulfilled: the sins are remembered no more and the law is written in the heart. The bearer of the Christian name, but not of the Christian spirit- ual standing and character, having ‘‘not the Spirit of Christ, is none of his’ (Rom 8 9). The chosen community accordingly, not as it seems ab ezira, but as it is in its essence, is a fellowship of individuals each of whom is an object of unmerited Divine favor, taking effect in the new life. And this in- volves the exercise of electing mercy. Cfe.g.1 Pet 13. And consider Rom 11 4-7 (where observe the exceptional use of “the election,’ meaning “the company of the elect”). IV. Cognate and Illustrative Biblical Language. —It is obvious that the aspects of mystery which gather round the word “election” are not confined to it alone. An important class of words, such as “calling,” “predestination,” “foreknowledge,” ‘purpose,’ “gift,” bears this same character; assert- ing or connoting, in appropriate contexts, the ele- ment of the inscrutable and sovereign in the action of the Divine will upon man, and particularly upon man’s will and affection toward God. And it will be felt by careful students of the Bible in its larger and more general teachings that one deep characteristic of the Book, which with all its boundless multi- plicity is yet one, is to emphasize on the side of man everything that can humble, convict, reduce to worshipping silence (see for typical passages Job 40 3.4; Rom 3 19), and on the side of God every- thing which can bring home to man the tran- scendence and sovereign claims of his almighty Maker. Not as unrelated utterances, but as part of a vast whole of view and teaching, occur such pas- sages as Eph 2 8.9 and Rom 11 33-36, and even the stern, or rather awestruck, phrases of Rom 9 20.21, where the potter and the clay are used in illustration. V. Limitations of Inquiry Here. Scope of Election.—We have sought thus in the simplest outline to note first the word “election” and then some related Scriptural words and_ principles, weighing the witness they bear to a profound mys- tery in the action of the Divine will upon man, in the spiritual sphere. What we have thus seen leaves still unstated what, according to Scripture, is the goal and issue of the elective act. In this art., remembering that it is part of a Bible Ency- clopaedia, we attempt no account of the history of thought upon election, in the successive Christian cents., nor again any discussion of the relation of election in Scripture to extra-Scriptural philosophies, to theories of necessity, determination, fatalism. We attempt only to see the matter as it les before us in the Bible. Studying it so, we find that this mysterious action of God on man has relation, in the Christian revelation, to nothing short of the salvation of the individual (and of the community of such individuals) from sin and condemnation, and the preservation of the saved to life eternal. We find this not so much in any single passage as in the main stream of Bib. language and tone on the subject of the Divine selective action. But it is remarkable that in the recorded thought of Our Lord Himself we find assertions in this direction which could hardly be more explicit. See Jn 6 37. 44.45; 10 27-29. To the writer the best summary of the Scriptural evidence, at once definite and re- strained, is the language of the 17th Anglican art.: “They which be endued with so excellent a benefit of Ged be called according to God’s purpose by His Spirit working in due season; they through grace obey the calling; they be justified freely; they be made sons of God by adoption; they be made like the image of His only begotten Son Jesus Christ; they walk religiously in good works, and at length, by God’s mercy, they attain to everlasting felicity.” VI. Perseverance.—The anxious problem of PERSEVERANCE will be treated under that word. It may be enough here to say that alike what we are permitted to read as revealed, and what we may humbly apprehend as the reason of the case, tend to the reverent belief that a perseverance (rather of the Lord than of the saints) is both taught and im- plied. But when we ponder the nature of the sub- ject we are amply prepared for the large range of Scriptures which on the other hand condemn and Brecuie? for the humble disciple, so gross a misuse of the doctrine as would let it justify one moment’s presumption upon Divine mercy in the heart which is at the same time sinning against the Divine love and holiness. VII. Considerations in Relief of Thought.—We close, in view of this last remark, with some de- tached notes in relief, well remembering the un- speakable trial which to many devout minds the word before us has always brought. First in place and importance is the thought that a spiritual fact like election, which belongs to the innermost purpose and work of the 1. Antin- Eternal, necessarily leads us to a region omies where comprehension is impossible, and where we can only reverently apprehend. The doctrine passes upward to the sphere where antinomies live and move, where we must be content to hear what sound to us contra- dictions, but which are really various aspects of infi- nite truth. Let us be content to know that the Divine choice is sovereign; and also that “his tender mercies are over all his works,” that ‘He willeth not the death of a sinner,’ that ‘God is love.” Let us relieve the tension of such submissive reliance by reverently noting how the supreme antinomy meets one type of human need with its one side, and with its other another. To the “fearful saint’? the Di- vine sovereignty of love is a sacred cordial. To the seeking penitent the Divine comprehensiveness of love opens the door of peace. To the deluded 927 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Election Eleph theorist who does not love and obey, the warnings of a fall and ruin which are possible, humanly, from any spiritual height, are a merciful beacon on the rocks. Further, we remember that election, in Scripture, is as different as possible from the fatal necessity of, e.g. the Stoics. It never appears 2. Fatalism as mechanical, or as a blind destiny. Another It has to do with the will of a God who Thing has given us otherwise supreme proofs that He is all-good and all-kind. And it is related to man not as a helpless and innocent being but as a sinner. It is never presented as an arbitrary force majeure. Even in Rom 9 the ‘si- lence” called for is not as if to say, “You are hope- lessly passive in the grasp of infinite power,” but, “You, the creature, cannot judge your Maker, who must know infinitely more of cause and reason than his handiwork can know.” The mystery, we may be sure, had behind it supreme right and reason, but in a region which at present at least we cannot pene- trate. Again, election never appears as a violation of buman will. For never in the Bible is man treated as irresponsible. In the Bible the relation of the buman and Divine wills is inscrutable; the reality of both is assured. Never is the doctrine presented apart from a moral context. It is intended manifestly to deepen man’s submission to—not force, but— 3. The mystery, where such submission means Moral faith. In the practical experience of Aspects the soul its designed effect is to em- phasize in the believer the conscious- ness (itself native to the true state of grace) that the whole of his salvation is due to the Divine mercy, no part of it to his merit, to his virtue, to his wis- dom. In the sanctified soul, which alone, assuredly, can make full use of the mysterious truth, is it designed to generate, together and in harmony, awe, thanksgiving and repose. A necessary caution in view of the whole subject is that bere, if anywhere in the regions of spiritual study, we inevitably “know in part,” 4, “We and in a very limited part. The treat- Know in ment of election has at times in Chris- Part” tian history been carried on as if, less by the light of revelation than by logical processes, we could tabulate or map the whole subject. Where this has been done, and where at the same time, under a sort of mental rather than spiritual fascination, election has been placed in the foreground of the system of religious thought, and allowed to dominate the rest, the truth has (to say the least) too often been distorted into an error. The Divine character has been beclouded in its beauty. Sovereignty has been divorced from love, and so defaced into an arbitrary fiat, which has for its only reason the assertion of omnipotence. - Thus the grievous wrong has been done of aloxpév rt héyeww rrept Tod Oelov, “defamation of God.” For example, the revelation of a posi- tive Divine selection has been made by inference to teach a corresponding rejection ruthless and terrible, as if the Eternal Love could ever by any possibility reject or crush even the faintest as- piration of the created spirit toward God. For such a thought not even the dark words of Rom 9 18 give Scriptural excuse. The case there in hand, Pharaoh’s, is anything but one of arbitrary power trampling on a human will looking toward God and right. Once more, the subject is one as to which we must on principle be content with knowledge so fragmentary that its parts may seem contradictory in our present imperfect light. The one thing we may be sure of behind the veil is, that nothing can be hidden there which will really contradict the supreme and ruling truth that God is love. Finally, let us from another side remember that here, as always in the things of the Spirit, ‘‘we know in part.”” The chosen multitude are 5. The sovereignly ‘“‘called, .. . . justified, Unknown .... glorified’ (Rom 8 29.30). But Future for what purposes? - Certainly not for an end terminating in themselves. They are saved, and kept, and raised to the perfect state, for the service of their Lord. And not till the cloud is lifted from the unseen life can we possibly know what that service under eternal conditions will include, what ministries of love and good in the . whole universe of being. HanoLtey DuneELM ELECTRUM, é-lek’trum: The RVm rendering of SAWN, hashmal, of Esk 14.27; 8 2 (LXX HAexrpov, élektren, Vulg electrum). Both AV and ERV have ‘“‘amber’’ while the ARV has “glowing metal.”’ Gesenius says electrum must not be under- stood as being here used for amber, but for a kind of metal remarkable for brightness, compounded of gold and silver. ‘Amber’ is undoubtedly a poor rendering, as the Heb term means ‘“‘polished brass.” ARV has the more correct rendering. Amber, however, may well have been known to Ezekiel (EB s.v.). See also Srongs, Precious; Buyxuve, IV. A. W. Fortune EL-ELOHE-ISRAEL, el-é-l6’hé-iz’r-el, el-el’6- he-iz/ré-el (ONTW? "TSN ON, al *elohe yisra’al, tr4 “God, the God of Israel” in AR Vm and AVm): Found only in Gen 33 20 as the name given to the altar erected at Shechem by Jacob, henceforth known as Israel, on the parcel of ground purchased by him from the inhabitants of Shechem, his first encamp- ment of length and importance since the return to Pal from Paddan-aram and the eventful night at Peniel (Gen 32 30). This unusual combination of names has given occasion for much speculation and for various text emendations. Already the LXX sought to meet the difficulty by reading wa-yikra’ ’el *élohé yisra’ él, “and he called upon the God of Israel,’ instead of the wa-yikra@ 16 ’él of MT, ‘‘and he called it El” etc. Wellhausen, followed by Dillmann, Driver and others, changes “altar” to “pillar,’ because the Heb verb, hicgibh, is used with mag- cébhah, “pillar,” in Gen 35 14.20, so making this religious act a parallel to that at Bethel. But De- litzsch, New Comm. on Gen, properly rejects this purely fanciful change, and understands the com- pound name as the altar’s inscription. Dillmann well suggests that “altar” (or ‘“‘pillar’’) be supplied, reading thus: “‘called it the altar of El, the God of Israel.” The peculiar phrase is best and most readily understood in its close connection with the struggle at Peniel, recorded in Gen 32. Being vic- torious in that struggle, Jacob received the new name “Israel”; and to his first altar in Pal he gave that name of God which appeared in his own new name, further explaining it by the appositive phrase ‘Elohe- Israel.”” Thus his altar was called, or dedicated to, “El, the God of Israel.” Enwarp Mack EL ELYON, el é-li’on. See Gon, NaMEs oF. ELEMENT, el’é-ment, ELEMENTS (ra orov- xeta, id stoicheia, “the letters of the alphabet,” “the elements out of which all things are formed,” “the heavenly bodies,” “the fundamental .princi- ples of any art or science’’): (1) In 2 Pet 3 10, the constituent parts of the physical universe (‘elements shall be dissolved with fervent heat,” ARVm “the heavenly bodies’’). (2) In Gal 4 3.9, RV has “rudiments,” as in AVm, and in Col 2 8.20, where the reference is to imperfect Jewish ordinances. See RUDIMENTS. ELEPH @'lef ((2871, ha~eleph, ‘the ox’): A place Elephant Eliezer THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 928 in the lot of Benjamin not far from Jerus (Josh 18 28). Thename is omitted by LXX, unless, indeed, it is combined with that of Zelah. It may be identi- cal with Lifta, a village W. of Jerus (Conder, HDB, s.v.). Others identify Lifta with Nephtoah. ELEPHANT, cl’é-fant (Job 40 15 AVm [ARVm “hippopotamus,” RV ‘ivory”’]; 1 K 10 22 AVm; 2Ch 921 AVm; 1 Mace 3 34; 6 28 ff; 8 6): Possibly in Job it is the extinct mammoth. See BEHEmoTH; Ivory. ELEPHANTINE, el-é-fan-ti’né. ELEUTHERUS, é-li’'thér-us ("Edcd@epos, Elevi~ theros; | Macc 11 7; 12 30): A river separating Syria and Phoenicia. ELEVEN, élev’’n, STARS. See Astronomy. See SEVENEH. ELEVEN, &lev’’n, THE (ot @véexa, hoi héndeka): The eleven apostles remaining after the death of Judas. The definite art. used serves to designate them as a distinct and definite group whose integ- rity was not destroyed by the loss of one of the twelve. The college of “the Twelve” had come to be so well recognized that the gospel writers all used on occasions the word with the definite art. to rep- resent the Twelve Apostles chosen by Jesus. This custom still remained and the numeral merely changed, as, “Afterward he was manifested unto the eleven” (Mk 16 14; cf Lk 24 9.33; Acts 2 14). On the other hand, however, the subst. is also some- times used, as “The eleven disciples went into Galilee’ (Mt 28 16; cf also Acts 1 26). As an il- lustration of the fixedness of usage, Paul refers to the eleven as “‘the twelve” when he recounts the appearances of Jesus after His resurrection: “And that he appeared to Cephas; then to the twelve” (1 Cor 16 5). WaLtTer G. CLIPPINGER ELHANAN, cl-ha’/nan (J209%, ’elh@nan, “whom God gave’): (1) A great warrior in the army of David who slew a Phili giant. There is a discrepancy between 25 21 19 and 1 Ch 20 5. In the former passage we read, ‘“‘And there was again war with the Philis at Gob; and Elhanan, the son of Jaare-oregim the Beth-lehemite, slew Goliath the Gittite, the staff of whose spear was like a weaver’s beam”; while in the latter we are told, “And there was again war with the Philis; and Elhanan the son of Jair slew Lahmi the brother of Goliath the Gittite, the staff of whose spear was like a weaver’s beam.” Most modern critics prefer as the original text of the latter part of the two discrepant statements the following: “and Elhanan the son of Jair the Beth-lehemite slew Goliath the Gittite, the staff of whose spear was like a weaver’sbeam.”’ Itis contended that the Chronicler slightly modified the text before him, in order to bring it into harmouy with 1 8 17, where David is said to have slain a Phili giant Goliath. There is almost unanimous agreement that ‘“Jaare-oregim”’ is a corrupt reading, and the ‘‘Jair” in 1 Ch is to be preferred. From Jerome to the present some schol- ars identify Elhanan with David, and thus remove the discrepancy. Ewald ( Hist, III, 70) argued that the name “Goliath” was iuserted in 1 S 17 and 21 by the narrators whose compositions are embodied in Samuel, Elhanan being the real victor over Goliath, while David’s antagonist was simply called ‘“‘the Philistine.” (2) The son of Dodo of Bethlehem, one of David’s mighty men (2 S 23 24; 1 Ch 11 26). Some moderns think that there was only one Elhanan, and that he was the son of Dodo of the clan of Jair. Joon Ricoarp SaMPEY ELI, #li C32 , elt): A descendant of Ithamar, the fourth son of Aaron, who exercised the office of high priest in Shiloh at the time of the birth of Sam- uel. For the first time in Israel, Eli combined in his own person the functions of high priest and judge, judging Israel for 40 years (1 S 4 18). The inci- dents in Eli’s life are few; indeed, the main interest of the narrative is in the other characters who are associated with him. The chief interest centers in Samuel. In Eli’s first interview with Hannah (1 § 1 12 ff), she is the central figure; in the second inter- view (1 S 1 24 ff), it is the child Samuel. When El next appears, it is as the father of Hophni and Phinehas, whose worthless and licentious lives had profaned their priestly office, and earned for them the title “‘men of Belial’’ (or ‘‘worthlessness’’). Eli administered no stern rebuke to his sons, but only a gentle chiding of their greed and immorality. Thereafter he was warned by a nameless prophet of the downfall of his house, and of the death of his two sons in one day (1 8 2 27-36), a message later confirmed by Samuel, who had received this word directly from Jeh Himself (1 8 3 11 ff). The prophecy was not long in fulfilment. During the next invasion by the Philis, the Israelites were utter- ly routed, the ark of God was captured, and Hophni and Phinehas were both slain. When the news reached Eli, he was so overcome that he “fell from off his seat backward by the side of the gate; and his neck brake, and he died” (1 S 4 18). The character of Eli, while sincere and devout, seems to have been entirely lacking in firmness. He appears from the history to have been a good man, full of humility and gentleness, but weak and indulgent. Hisis not a strong personality; he is always overshadowed by some more commanding or interesting figure. A. C. GRANT ELI, @'li or 4’lé, ELI, LAMA, la’mi, SABACH- THANTI, sa-bak’tha-ni. See Exo1, Exo, etc. ELIAB, é-li’ab (andy, *8li'abh, “God is father’): (1) Prince of the tribe of Zebulun in the Exodus (Nu 1 9; 2 7; 7 24.29; 10 16). (2) A Reubenite, father of Dathan and Abiram (Nu 16 11.12; 26 8f; Dt 11 6). (3) Eldest son of Jesse and brother of David (1 S 16 6), once called Elihu (1 Ch 27 18). He was of commanding appearance (1 S 16 6), and when serving with Saul’s army at the time when it was confronting the Philis and Goliath, was inclined to lord it over his brother David (17 28f). His re Abihail became a wife of Rehoboam (2 Ch 11 18). (4) An Ephraimite, an ancestor of Samuel (1 Ch 6 27); called Eliel in ver 34, and Elihuin1 § 1 1. (5) A Gadite warrior with David (1 Ch 12 9), one of 11 mighty men (vs 8.14). (6) A Levite musician (1 Ch 16 18.20; 16 5). (7) An ancestor of Judith (Jth 8 1; cf 9 2). F, Kk. Farr ELIADA, é-li’a-da, ELIADAH OPN, elyadha', “God isknowing.” Cf HPN, 219, 266,301; ’Embdaé Epidaé, or "Eddaé, Elidaé): (1) One of the sous of David (2 8 5 16; 1 Ch 3 8; called BrELtapa, 1 Ch 14 7 [q.v.]). (2) A descendant of Benjamin and a captain in the army of Jehoshaphat, commander of 200,000 men (2 Ch 17 17). (3) Father of Rezon, an ‘‘adversary’”’ of Solomon (1 K 11 23, AV “Eliadah”). ELIADAS, @li’a-das ’EdvaSds, Eliadds): A son of Zamoth who had married a strange wife (1 Esd 9 28); called Elioenal in Ezr 10 27. ELIADON, é-li’a-duu, RV ILIADUN (q.v.). 929 THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA Elephant Eliezer ELIAH, €é-li’a. ELIAHBA, é-li’a-ba, é--d’ba (NBM, ’elyah- ba’, “God hides’): One of David’s 30 mighty men (2 8 23 32; 1 Ch 11 38). ELIAKIM, é-li'a-kim (D°P728, ’elyakim; ’EAL- akelp, Hliakeim, “God sets up’’): (1) The son of Hilkiah who succeeded Shebna as governor of the palace and “grand vizier’ under Hezekiah (Isa 22 20). The functions of his office are seen from the oracle of Isaiah in which Shebna is deposed and Eliakim set in his place (Isa 22 15 ff). He is the “treasurer” (RVm “steward”), and is “over the house” (ver 15). At his installation he is clothed with a robe and girdle, the insignia of his office, and, having the government committed into his hand, is the “father to the inhabitants of Jerus, and to the house of Judah” (ver 21). The key of the house of David is laid on his shoulder, and he alone has power to open and shut, this being symbolic of his absolute authority as the king’s representative (ver 22). One of Solomon’s officials is the first mentioned as occupying this position (1 K 4 6), and this office was continued in both the Northern and South- ern Kingdom (1 K 16 9; 18 3; 2 K 10 5; 15 5). Its importance is seen from the fact that after Azariah was smitten with leprosy, Jotham his heir “was over the household, judging the people of the land” (2 K 16 5). When Sennacherib sent an army against Jerus in 701, Eliakim was one of these Jewish princes who held on behalf of Hezekiah a parley with the Assyr officers (2 K 18 18.26.37; Isa 36 3.11.22). As a result of the invader’s threats, he was sent by Hezekiah in sackcloth to Isaiah, entreating his pray to Jeh on behalf of Jerus (2 K 19 2; Isa 3 é (2) The original name of Jehoiakim, the son of Josiah, whom Pharaoh-necoh made king of Judah (2 K 23 34; 2 Ch 36 4). (8) A priest who assisted at the dedication of the wall of Jerus, rebuilt after his return from Babylon (Neh 12 41). (4) A grandson of Zerubbabel and ancestor of Jesus (Mt 1 18). (5) An ancestor of Jesus (Lk 3 30). 8S. F. Hunter ELIALI, é-li’a-li ’?EAvadcl, Elialet): 1 Esd 9 34; possibly corresponds to “Binnui” in Ezr 10 38. ELIAM, é-li’am (oy"eN , 7étam, “people’s God”’?): (1) Father of Bathsheba (2 § 11 3); in 1 Ch 3 5 called Ammiel. (2) One of David’s “thirty,” son of Ahithophel the Gilonite (2 S 23 34). ELIAONIAS, é-li-a-d-ni/as (’BAtadwvlas, Elia- léntas): A descendant of Phaath Moab (1 Esd 8 31); called “Eliehoenai” in Ezr 8 4. ELIAS, é-li’as. See Enisag. ELIASAPH, é&li’a-saf (FOTN, ’elydsaph, “God has added’): (1) Son of Deuel; prince of the tribe of Gad in the Exodus (Nu 1 14; 2 14; 7 42.47; 10 20). (2) Son of Lael; prince of the Gershonites (Nu 3 24). ELIASHIB, é-li’a-shib (asr dy, *elyadshibh, “God restores’’) : (1) A descendant of David (1 Ch 3 24). (2) Head of the eleventh course of priests (1 Ch 24 12). See Evisau. (8) The high priest in the time of Nehemiah. He, with his Pectiee the priests, helped in the re- building of the wall (Neh 3 1). But later he was “allied unto Tobiah’” the Ammonite (13 4) and allowed that enemy of Nehemiah the use of a great chamber in the temple (ver 5); and one of his grandsons, a son of Joiada, married a daughter of Sanballat the Horonite and was for this expelled from the community by Nehemiah (ver 28). See SANBALLAT. (4, 5, 6) Three Israelites, one a “singer,” who had married foreign wives (Ezr 10 24.27.36). (7) Father of Jehohanan_(Ezr 10 6); probably identical with (3) above. Called Eliasib nm 1 Esd 91, F, K. Farr ELIASIB, é-li’a-sib. See Exiasuip. ELIASIBUS, é-li-as’i-bus (EAvéovBos, Elidsibos, AV Eleazurus): One of the holy singers who had married a foreign wife (1 Esd 9 24); called ‘Elia- shib” in Ezr 10 27. ELIASIMUS, €-li-as’i-mus (’BAvdowpos, Elidsimos; AV Elisimus): One who had married a foreign wife (1 Esd 9 28). ELIASIS, é-li’a-sis (HAtéots, Elidsis): One who had married a foreign wife (1 Esd 9 34); corre- sponds to ‘Jaasu” in Ezr 10 37. ELIATHAH, é-li’a-tha (MANN , él? athah, “God has come”): A Hemanite, head of the twentieth division of the temple musicians (1 Ch 25 4.27). ELIDAD, 6-li’dad (TPN, *élidhadh, “God has loved’’): Prince of Benjamin in the division of the land (Nu 34 21); perhaps the same as Expap (q.v.). ELIEHOENAI, é-i-é-ho’é-ni OPVWTON, ’ely- ho‘énay, “to Jeh are mine eyes’’): (1) (AV Elioenai) a Korahite doorkeeper (1 Ch 26 3 (2) (AV. Elihoenai) Head of a family in the Re- turn (Ezr 8 4). ELIEL, é-I’el, el’i-el (ON"2N, *87’2l, “El is God,” or “my God is God”): (1, 2,3) Mighty men of David (1 Ch 11 46.47; 11 ; wo A chief of Manasseh, east of the Jordan (1 Ch (5, 6) Two chiefs of Benjamin (1 Ch 8 20.22). (7) A chief Levite from Hebron (1 Ch 16 9.11). (8) A Kohathite in the line of Elkanah, Samuel and Heman (1 Ch 6 34); see Enis (4). ia A Levite of the time of Hezekiah (2 Ch 31 ELIENAIL, el-i-6’nd-i (DON, 'ei'enay): A Benjamite chief (1 Ch 8 20). ELIEZER, el-i-8’zér, 6-li-8/zor (“IZ"DN, *elt'ezer; *EAuétep,’ Hliézer, “God is help’’): (1) The chief servant of Abram (Gen 16 2); ARV “Eliezer of Damascus,” ERV ‘“Dammesek Eliezer.” The Heb is peculiar: lit. “And the son of the possession [meshek] of my house is Dammasek [of] Ehezer.” A possible but-unlikely meaning is that his property would become the possession of Damascus, the city of Eliezer. Tg Syr (RVm) read “Eliezer the Damascene’”’: this supposes a reading, ‘Eliezer ha-dammaskz”’ or ‘“‘mid-dammesek.” The text may be corrupt: the assonance between meshek and Dammesek is suspicious. Abram calls Eliezer ‘‘one born in my house,” i.e. a dependant, a member of his household, and so regards him as his Elihaba Elijah THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BIBLE ENCYCLOPAEDIA 930 heir, Lot having gone from him (Gen 13). iiieser | cated his integrity and stands ready to present his is probably the servant, ‘‘the elder of his house, that ruled over all that he had,” of Gen 24. (2) The 2d son of Moses and Zipporah, called thus for “the God of my father was my help, and de- livered me from the sword of Pharaoh” (Ex 18 4; 1 Ch 23 15 ff). (3) A son of Becher, one of the sons of Benjamin (1 Ch 7 8). (4) A priest who assisted in bringing up the ark from the house of Obed-edom to Jerus (1 Ch 16 24). (5) The son of Zichri, ruler over the Reubenites in the time of David (1 Ch 27 16). (6) The son of Dodavahu of Mareshah who prophesied the destruction of the ships which Je- hoshaphat, king of Judah, built, because he had done so in co6peration with Ahaziah, king of Israel (2 Ch 20 36 ff). (7) One of the messengers whom Ezra sent to Iddo, the chief at Casiphia, with the request for ministers for the Temple (Ezr 8 16 ff). (8, 9, 10) A priest, a Levite, and one of the sons of Harim who had married non-Israelitish women (Ezr 10 18.23.31). (11) An ancestor of Jesus in the genealogy given by St. Luke (Lk 3 29). HunTER ELIHABA, &li/ha-ba. ELIHOENAI, el-i-hé-é’n4-i. ELIHOREPH, el-i-ho’ref (AON, “elthareph, “God of autumn”?):