THE ASSASSINATIONOF JOHN FITZGERALD KENNEDY ANANNOTATEDBIBLIOGRAPHY By DAVID R. WRONE Oswald’s murderer,Jack Ruby,remains scan- XRITINGanhistorical accountofavio- lent andemotion-laden contemporary ty andmurky to thisday. In addition, much of the documentary evi- event presents a number of difficult problems, dence comes from faceless institutional some of which cannot be solved.The Novem- ber 22,1963,assassination of President John sources which arenoteasily accessible tomost F.Kennedy is such an event. Scholars of these scholars.Historians cannotpush into archives scattered evi- of busy agencies such nas theCentralIntelli- crisesmust gather the dence,analyzeit,andwritea lucid accountfor genceAgencyor theFederal Bureauof in both the scholarly community and thepublic. vestigation topoke around for material.Nor Theirrolein a social crisisis no different from can historians question the agents who typed their role at any other time.In fact,the emer- crucial documents.Both critics and support. ers of the Warren Commission report have gencyprovides an excellentopportunity to askedwhy federal security agents were not demonstrate the practical use of scholarship. Obtaininga solid basein the factsrequires covering the buildings overlooking the assas- sination site.According tomanyinformed carefulattention to the types ofevidentiary availableandanaware- persons this was a most unusual lapse in se. materialsinmediately arrangements. Historians 1prob- ness that many will fromfederal,state,and curity which always ablynever ppened precisely,be local governmental When there isa cause the answer mus be sought within the intrigue in the crisis, operatingproceduresandmethodsof com- possibility of foreig assassination,the plex-federalagencies.There may be alogical as in the John F.Kenne reason for this fatal error,but historians must pressure for knowledge of its basic outline in- creases.The emotional urge to proceed hasti- lywith the firstavailable documentsis often NoTE:The reviewer wishes to acknowledge the in. irresistible.The first picture of events is formationandencouragementgivenbyAttorney 1becausetheevidencebe James Lesar,Washington, D.C. usually distorted Information on Lec Harvey Oswald,including comes public in such an erratic manner that photographs in dress suitsmarriage detailshistory minor facts are emphasized while important ofhis trips to Russia and New Orleans,was known almost immediately.Therecently declassifiedCD ones remain obscure.In the investigation of 355(CommissionDocuments)in the National John F.Kennedy’s death,background from Archives reveals that one thousand persons were the federal files on the alleged assassin,Lee interviewed concerning their acquaintance with or knowledge of Jack Ruby.The letters Ruby wrote in H.Oswald,was known in great detail almost jail havenever been collected.Penn Jones,Jr.,Mid. immediately after the event.Information on lothian,Texas,owns one. 21of Jack Ruby.The letters Ruby wrote in H.Oswald,was known in great detail almost jail havenever been collected.Penn Jones,Jr.,Mid. immediately after the event.Information on lothian,Texas,owns one. 21 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY be cternal skeptics of evidence whose origin ments.These include the treason charge levied against Daniel Boone, the suspicion roused cannot be probed. against Alexander Hamilton's connections Theclamor for informationfrequently with Great Britain,and the charges that leadspublicandprivate sourcestosupply tappealtotheemotions Robert M. La Follette was pro-German during number of facts that but which cannot be used to build a clcar and World War I.In Boone's case the accusation distinct accountof theevent.Theveryexist- was apparently false,in Hamilton’s case the ence of these facts requiresperusalof them charges were true, and in La Follette’s case before they can be properly classified 1and theywere outrageously and deliberately false the main investigation resumed.For example, slurs.3 Students also confront the possibility that theFBI supplied theWarrenCommission staff therearefraudulentdocumentsamong the with Jack Ruby’smother’s dentalchart,Lee [attendance evidence theyhave touse. Complex analysis Harvey Oswald's gradeschool sheets,and other impressive irrelevancies,but must beperformed before some of the critical evidenceinanemotionally ychargedincident notthespectrograpl phicanalysesofthebullets which they were based.La Follette was pro-German during number of facts that but which cannot be used to build a clcar and World War I.In Boone's case the accusation distinct accountof theevent.Theveryexist- was apparently false,in Hamilton’s case the ence of these facts requiresperusalof them charges were true, and in La Follette’s case before they can be properly classified 1and theywere outrageously and deliberately false the main investigation resumed.For example, slurs.3 Students also confront the possibility that theFBI supplied theWarrenCommission staff therearefraudulentdocumentsamong the with Jack Ruby’smother’s dentalchart,Lee [attendance evidence theyhave touse. Complex analysis Harvey Oswald's gradeschool sheets,and other impressive irrelevancies,but must beperformed before some of the critical evidenceinanemotionally ychargedincident notthespectrograpl phicanalysesofthebullets which they were based. can be used.Forgeries are fairly common in andthedata upon history, and tend to appear ratmomentsof Further,as investigators assemble data they social crisis.Recent examples from European encounter possible contradictions of fact,but ehas beendestroyedthey history include the Czarist,French,and Nazi becauseevidence useoftheforgedProtocolsoftheEldersof havenoway to check authenticity.The alle- thata shot went through Zion against the Jews and Freemasons,and gationbycritics President Kennedy imousine windshield the British right-wing manufacture of the Zi- gaconspiracy, novievletter.4InAmerica theWhalenforge- from the front, thus since in the stress ries and the possibility of a counterfeited type- can never be checked the moment the car was flown immediately to writer in the Alger Hiss case stand out.Complex analysis Harvey Oswald's gradeschool sheets,and other impressive irrelevancies,but must beperformed before some of the critical evidenceinanemotionally ychargedincident notthespectrograpl phicanalysesofthebullets which they were based. can be used.Forgeries are fairly common in andthedata upon history, and tend to appear ratmomentsof Further,as investigators assemble data they social crisis.Recent examples from European encounter possible contradictions of fact,but ehas beendestroyedthey history include the Czarist,French,and Nazi becauseevidence useoftheforgedProtocolsoftheEldersof havenoway to check authenticity.The alle- thata shot went through Zion against the Jews and Freemasons,and gationbycritics President Kennedy imousine windshield the British right-wing manufacture of the Zi- gaconspiracy, novievletter.4InAmerica theWhalenforge- from the front, thus since in the stress ries and the possibility of a counterfeited type- can never be checked the moment the car was flown immediately to writer in the Alger Hiss case stand out. Cri- tics of theWarren Commission findings allege Detroit,cleaned,and renovated.2 A third problem is the handling of docu- the existence of several faked facts.These include thepossibility that the entire evidence mentary evidence thatoften isrelated torank linkingLeeHarvey Oswald to the actual shoot- charges and sensational revelations. Scholars have thedifficult jobofapproaching them ing is false, and that the third bullet,identi- with the detachment necessary to judge the fied as CommissionExhibit 399,of the three facts properly. Historians havelong been aware that federalinquiriesinto American Boone was triedfor the alleged betrayalof Ken- criseshavebeensubjected toemotional,truth tucky to the Shawnee Indians;he was acquitted. twisting pressures, and thedocuments sur- Reuben Gold Thwaites,Daniel Boone (New York, rounding the John F. Kennedy murder are 1902),166-169.--- PAGE BREAK --- twisting pressures, and thedocuments sur- Reuben Gold Thwaites,Daniel Boone (New York, rounding the John F. Kennedy murder are 1902),166-169. In the 1780's Boone did take gold of similar instances from Spain to repudiate the United States.Julian no exception.Examples P.Boyd,Number 7:Alexander Hamilton'sSecret include theprobeinto the assassination of Attempts to ControlAmericanForeignPolicywith AbrahamLincolnand therecentSenatehear- supporting documents (Princeton,1964);Belle Case and FolaLa Follette,Robert M.LaFollette,June 14, ings on theTonkin Gulf Resolution. 1855-June18,1925(NewYork,1953). Several investigators of the Dallas tragedy Norman Rufus Colin Cohn,Warrant for Geno cide:TheMythoftheJewishWorld-Conspiracy and have charged thathigh government figures the Protocols ofthe Elders of Zion (New York. wereindirectlylinkedto thePresident'sdeath. 1967);Lewis Chester et al.,The Zinoviev Letter Spectacular charges are hard to evaluate, al. (Philadelphia,1968). John L.Spivak,A Man in his Time (NewYork, most requiring inside knowledge.Scholars havebeen exposed to similar claims delivered visited, in The American Scholar,XLI:121-132 in the white heat of emotion,and know the (Winter,1971-1972). Each alleged fact usedby theWarren Commission necessityof calm examination of the docu- tolink Oswald to the actual shootingof thePresident isheld to be false,i.e.,that he carried a rifle into the building,that the recovered rifle functioned,that Oswaldwas on the sixth floor at the time of the Josiah Thompson,Six Seconds in Dallas: A shooting,that the shot fired from the building came from theeast windowof the bulding,and so Micro-Study oftheKennedy Assassination(New York,1967),113-114. forth. 22 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY theWarren Commission claims Oswald fired, when hunting a publisher and later whenread was planted in the hospital.7 ingreviews of their work.Therevisionist his- Thehandling of what appears tobe minor torians,whoexplained thatWorldWarIde pieces of evidence that stand contrary to the veloped partly out oftensionscreatedby overwhelming mass of facts is critical.A fact allied pressure upon theexpandingGerman nationandnotsolely in unprovoked German must fitwith therest of thefacts and cannot beignored when it does not.One fact can militarism,came under rheavycensurefrom be thekey to understanding an entire tragedy their colleagues until the late 1920's.11 The aswas thebordereau paperintheFrench publicationof German andRussiandocuments Dreyfus Affair.8 supported therevisionistsposition and helped dispel criticism. Later, historians divided Many documents first appear to be simple overt thebackground doftheAmericanentry statementsbutlater turnouttobecomplex. Thehistorical record abounds with instances intoWorld War II, some claiming there had of this type, such as Abraham Lincoln’s pur. beena conspiracybetween American civilian portedWadsworthletterespousingequality andmilitaryofficialstoprovoketheJapanese the races.In the documentarybase built dur- attack onPearlHarbor.Thelackofcomplete ing the inquiry into John F.Kennedy’s mur- documentary sources played a major role in der,numerous pieces of evidence appeared the swirling controversy.The anticonspiracy to be obvious and simple detail but laterproved school of historians ssilencedthe conspiracy tobe extremely complicated,requiring elab. school in a seldom-recalled, bitter struggle, These in frequently using shoddy methods that tdis- orate analysis before being used.beena conspiracybetween American civilian portedWadsworthletterespousingequality andmilitaryofficialstoprovoketheJapanese the races.In the documentarybase built dur- attack onPearlHarbor.Thelackofcomplete ing the inquiry into John F.Kennedy’s mur- documentary sources played a major role in der,numerous pieces of evidence appeared the swirling controversy.The anticonspiracy to be obvious and simple detail but laterproved school of historians ssilencedthe conspiracy tobe extremely complicated,requiring elab. school in a seldom-recalled, bitter struggle, These in frequently using shoddy methods that tdis- orate analysis before being used. clude accounts of the transitof Oswald from played a lapse in academic objectivity.12 Thequestion of conspiracy lurkingbe- the sixth to the firstfloor of theTexasSchool Book Depository.10 hindaneventofkey national importance is Another problem is thepresentation of con- commonly encountered Acrisis. Its con- stant appearance in the ewritingscriticalofthe clusionswhichrun counter tothepopular and officialversionsofwhathappened. Those Warren Commission findings is not an un- studying theKennedy murder areawareof usual 1historical phenomenon,but it is one thedifficulties scholarsfacedin 1previous thatis asdifficult toanswer as it is serious years with similar issues,andrealize they must in its implications. 1conspiracymeansthat beable tomaintain anobjectivecalmboth several persons planned, perpetrated,or at- temptedtoperpetrate unlawful act. Euro- pean,American,and Wisconsin history con- tain 1well-documented instances.1conspiracymeansthat beable tomaintain anobjectivecalmboth several persons planned, perpetrated,or at- temptedtoperpetrate unlawful act. Euro- pean,American,and Wisconsin history con- tain 1well-documented instances. European Raymond Marcus,TheBastard Bullet:A Search conspiracies are the Dreyfus Affair in France for Legitimacy forCommission Exhibit 399 (Los and the murderof LeonTrotsky in Mexico by Angeles,1966).'CE 399 is the bullet the Warren Commissionallegesentered thebackof thePresi- Soviet agents.13 In America conspiracies dent's neck,transited the neck,entered Connally's were part of theKu Klux Klan of the1860's, body,causing five wounds,smashing two bones,and mysteriously appeared in the hospital in pristine the night riders of Kentucky,1900-1910,the shape. American.Protective League during World Nicolas Halasz,Captain Dreyfus:TheStory of a War I,and the plundering and destruction of Mass Hysteria (NewYork,1955). The Authenticity of theWadsworth Letter,”in the JournalofSouthernHistory,XXXII:8387(Febru- ary,1966);Harold M.Hyman, “Lincoln and Equal Warren I. Cohen,The American Revisionists: Rights for Negroes: The Irrelevancy of theWads. TheLessonsof Intervention inWorldWar I (Chica- worth Letterin Civil War History,XII:258-266 (September,1966);Ludwell H.Johnson,“Lincoln go,1967);interviews with Professor Fred Albert andEqual Rights:A Reply,”in Civil War History, Shannon, Urbana, Illinois,196l;Bessie Louise Pierce,PublicOpinion andtheTeaching ofHistory XIII:66-73 (March,1967). iThreewitnesseswere onthe stairswhichOswald (NewYork,1926). Harry Elmer Barnes (ed.),Perpetual War for allegedly uscd to descend from the sixth floor.Two PerpetualPeuce:A Critical Examination of theFor. were not called to testify;Virginia Adams did give eignPolicyofFranklinDelano Rooseveltandits a statemcnt,but it was ignored.See Hcarings Before thePresident'sCominissionontheAssassinationof Aftermath(New York,1969edition).--- PAGE BREAK --- Harry Elmer Barnes (ed.),Perpetual War for allegedly uscd to descend from the sixth floor.Two PerpetualPeuce:A Critical Examination of theFor. were not called to testify;Virginia Adams did give eignPolicyofFranklinDelano Rooseveltandits a statemcnt,but it was ignored.See Hcarings Before thePresident'sCominissionontheAssassinationof Aftermath(New York,1969edition). Isaac Deutscher,Stalin:A Political Biography President John F.Kennedy(Washington,D.C, 1964),VI:392. (New York,1960). 23 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY The second reason why scholars hesitate de- theIndian tribes of Oklahoma.14InWiscon- rivesfrom Americanhistorians’strong accept- sin there was thebribing of almost all the ance of the theory of relativity,which holds members of the Wisconsin government by that an event ought not tobe examined until business interests in 1856 and the post-Civil forty years or more after its occurrence,when War scheme of timberinterests totake the its outline will havebecome distinct and clear. Stockbridge Indian reservation.15 numerous Only then will the manuscript sources be suit. Throughout tAmerican history ablystoredandproperly yarrangedforwork. claimsoftheexistence ofa conspiracyhave The event can thenbe seen through the critical beenproven false,though historianshave had eye ofabroadperspective and the inhibiting adifficult timerefuting someof them.There emotions of thepresentwill have faded suffi- were the false claims that Abraham Lincoln ciently topermit objective research.Such conspired to cause the outbreakof the Civil considerations help account for the failure of War,that the railroad workers who struck in against democratic professional historians,acting under scholarly 1894were in conspiracy conditions,to investigate the assassination of government,that radicals were conspiring in President John F.Kennedy.The difficulty in 1919totake over t the country,and that the using relativism is that the facts are never Cold War emerged outof aninternational Falseconspiracy all obtained; events one thousand years old communist conspiracy.16 are still unclear and still being researched. scares often appear during crisesin American The theory serves as a built-in,permanent life and sweep public opinion andfederaloffi- functional disability.It is undergoing very cialsinto reactionar stances so severe at effective criticism.17Like so many other theo- timesthatthenationallifeis twistedwith ten- ries, such as evolution, praginatism, and psy.claimsoftheexistence ofa conspiracyhave The event can thenbe seen through the critical beenproven false,though historianshave had eye ofabroadperspective and the inhibiting adifficult timerefuting someof them.There emotions of thepresentwill have faded suffi- were the false claims that Abraham Lincoln ciently topermit objective research.Such conspired to cause the outbreakof the Civil considerations help account for the failure of War,that the railroad workers who struck in against democratic professional historians,acting under scholarly 1894were in conspiracy conditions,to investigate the assassination of government,that radicals were conspiring in President John F.Kennedy.The difficulty in 1919totake over t the country,and that the using relativism is that the facts are never Cold War emerged outof aninternational Falseconspiracy all obtained; events one thousand years old communist conspiracy.16 are still unclear and still being researched. scares often appear during crisesin American The theory serves as a built-in,permanent life and sweep public opinion andfederaloffi- functional disability.It is undergoing very cialsinto reactionar stances so severe at effective criticism.17Like so many other theo- timesthatthenationallifeis twistedwith ten- ries, such as evolution, praginatism, and psy. sion, bitterness, and fear.scares often appear during crisesin American The theory serves as a built-in,permanent life and sweep public opinion andfederaloffi- functional disability.It is undergoing very cialsinto reactionar stances so severe at effective criticism.17Like so many other theo- timesthatthenationallifeis twistedwith ten- ries, such as evolution, praginatism, and psy. sion, bitterness, and fear. chic idealism,that have periodically emerged The impact of false conspiracy charges is todominatethe doctrinaire eapproachesto one of two principal reasons scholars are re- historical inquiry and have then fallen into luctanttotackle contemporary emotion- disuse,relativity also appearstobeon the charged andviolent events.This is especially decline.Its spresentsway is regretable, since true ofPresidentKennedy’sdeath since the the studyofthe assassinationprovides an op- murder has been proclaimed the work of a portunitytodemonstrate etherelevancetothe lone,psychologically disturbed,itinerant jani- publicgood of the scholarly abilities developed tor.It is,however, precisely in the realm of by thehistoricalprofession. controversial socialproblems thathistorical As a consequence of the dominance of these methods in the hands of scholars ought to twofactorsover historians,the nonofficial performbetter than any other method. investigation of the assassination has been left to citizen-scholars, opportunists, and deccen- trics who have given us a rather unique litera- Allen W.Trelease,White Terror:The KuKlux ture, as voluminous as its quality is mixed. Klan Conspiracy andSouthern Reconstruction (New Some haveproduced outright fiction,others York,197i);Harry Harrison Kroll, Riders in the have suffused 1 modest scholarly techniques Night (Philadelphia,1965);Joan M.Jensen,The Price of Vigilance (Chicago,1968);Arrell Gibson, with distorting emotions,and a few have The Kichapoos (Norman,Oklahoma,1968).--- PAGE BREAK --- investigation of the assassination has been left to citizen-scholars, opportunists, and deccen- trics who have given us a rather unique litera- Allen W.Trelease,White Terror:The KuKlux ture, as voluminous as its quality is mixed. Klan Conspiracy andSouthern Reconstruction (New Some haveproduced outright fiction,others York,197i);Harry Harrison Kroll, Riders in the have suffused 1 modest scholarly techniques Night (Philadelphia,1965);Joan M.Jensen,The Price of Vigilance (Chicago,1968);Arrell Gibson, with distorting emotions,and a few have The Kichapoos (Norman,Oklahoma,1968). reached conclusions through such careful eval- Reportof theJoint Select Committee appointed toinvestigateintoallegedfraudsandcorruptionin uation of the evidence that theirwork should thedispositionofthelandgrantbytheLegislature berecommended to scholars everywhere. of1856,and for other purposes (Madison,1858); John C.Adams Papers,Archives-Manuscripts Divi- sion,State Historical Society of Wisconsin. Richard N.Current,Lincoln and the First Shot 1The criticism of relativity is voluminous and (Philadelphia,1963);Almont Lindsey,ThePullman can be approached from several systems ofthought, Strike:TheStory ofa Unique Experinent andofa (Chicago,1964 edition);; e.g,evolution,Christianity, determinism.These are GreatLaborUpheaval all unsatisfactory for various reasons: the philosophi- Robert K.Murray,Red Scare:A Study in National cal criticism is,perhaps,best.Its clearest statement Hysteria,1919-1920 (Minneapolis,1955);Gabriel isElijah Jordan'sForms ofIndividuality:AnIn Kolko,ThePolitics of War,1913-1945(NewYork, quiry intotheGroundsofOrderinHumanRelations 1969).Kolko's book is representative of many re. (Indianapolis,1927).One docs not embrace totali centvolumes on theColdWar both here in the tarianism or absolutism by rejectingrelativism. United States and in Europe. 24 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY IT IS CUSTOMARY in dealing with con- mentsand testimonywithoutevenasuspicion that many are complex and full of contradic- temporaryhistoryfor the scholar tomake his viewpoint explicit. This reviewer believes tions. that there was a conspiracy to murder Presi- Mark Lane isa NewYorkattorneywho dent Kennedy,and that it can be shown by early yquestionedtheofficialversionofthe the evidence in the following public docu- Kennedy assassination.With his legal back- ments: the physical evidence-especially bul- ground it is perhaps understandablewhy he would select ashis approach a criticism of controvertiblethattherewasmorethanone the Warren Commission,its evidence,and con- assassin;on the other hand,no evidence-the clusion.From his analysis of the witness testi- entire sequence of events,the curtain rod,the mony and some of thephysicalevidencehe sixth floor position,the transit to the first concludes that the Commission rendereda floor-links Oswald to the actual shooting. hasty and improper judgment.Having basi- Other considerationswhicharenotconclusive callyrestrictedhis study to theWarren Com- by themselvesdobolster theconspiracy theo. mission evidence and procedures and having ry.These include the evidence brought out reached the conclusion of its failure,Lane by Jim Garrison, as reported verbatim in the had two choices:either to find the.vast in- New Orleans press; eyewitnesses and 1photo- stitutionalframeworkof thelawafailureor to graphs of the scene in Dallas; and the Zapru- find a person in it who failed.He chose Chief dermoviefilm. JusticeEarl Warren asa whipping boy but This reviewerfound no evidence in thepub failed to support the accusation with evidence.mission evidence and procedures and having ry.These include the evidence brought out reached the conclusion of its failure,Lane by Jim Garrison, as reported verbatim in the had two choices:either to find the.vast in- New Orleans press; eyewitnesses and 1photo- stitutionalframeworkof thelawafailureor to graphs of the scene in Dallas; and the Zapru- find a person in it who failed.He chose Chief dermoviefilm. JusticeEarl Warren asa whipping boy but This reviewerfound no evidence in thepub failed to support the accusation with evidence. lishedmaterial thatwouldlink the conspiracy His concentration on the legal framework and R to the institutional acts of the military,busi procedures overlooked a third area for criti- intelligence bodiesof America, cism--the investigative federal agencies upon ness,ori France, or Russia.Nor is there evidence link whom the Commission had to rely andwhose ing the conspiracy to a left-wing group. slipshodmethods sandclumsyprocedures merited discussion. HISREVIEWexamines thearticlesand HaroldWeisberghadexperience asan in- books that reflectobjective procedures vestigative reporter in thei930's probingthe and attempts toprovide some rudimentary as- activities of American facist groups, and also sessment of their conclusions. In passing,a served as an intelligence officer duringWorld few works that have achieved popular success WarII.Althoughheisa tirelessworker who orshouldbemorewidely availablewillbe has done massive research on the Kennedy noted.Fiveauthorsstandouteitherfor their assassination, ,he has been ignored by the public acceptance or thorough work;a brief academic and general mediareviewers.Many sketchoftheirbackgroundfollows.HISREVIEWexamines thearticlesand HaroldWeisberghadexperience asan in- books that reflectobjective procedures vestigative reporter in thei930's probingthe and attempts toprovide some rudimentary as- activities of American facist groups, and also sessment of their conclusions. In passing,a served as an intelligence officer duringWorld few works that have achieved popular success WarII.Althoughheisa tirelessworker who orshouldbemorewidely availablewillbe has done massive research on the Kennedy noted.Fiveauthorsstandouteitherfor their assassination, ,he has been ignored by the public acceptance or thorough work;a brief academic and general mediareviewers.Many sketchoftheirbackgroundfollows. balkatreadingbooks thathavebeenprivately ColumnistJimBishophaslong specialized printed andwhose conclusions are forthright- in writing about popular subjects.His The ly used as titles.They have erred because his yWasShotisoneofthebest effortsare excellentexamplesof document DayKennedy sellers.on the assassination.It is also one of analysis and testimony scrutiny.With careful procedure a document is studied;he uncovers themosterror-ladenandmisinformedvol- Bishop approached his studyby clip flaws,errors,conflicts with other documents, umes.--- PAGE BREAK --- In passing,a served as an intelligence officer duringWorld few works that have achieved popular success WarII.Althoughheisa tirelessworker who orshouldbemorewidely availablewillbe has done massive research on the Kennedy noted.Fiveauthorsstandouteitherfor their assassination, ,he has been ignored by the public acceptance or thorough work;a brief academic and general mediareviewers.Many sketchoftheirbackgroundfollows. balkatreadingbooks thathavebeenprivately ColumnistJimBishophaslong specialized printed andwhose conclusions are forthright- in writing about popular subjects.His The ly used as titles.They have erred because his yWasShotisoneofthebest effortsare excellentexamplesof document DayKennedy sellers.on the assassination.It is also one of analysis and testimony scrutiny.With careful procedure a document is studied;he uncovers themosterror-ladenandmisinformedvol- Bishop approached his studyby clip flaws,errors,conflicts with other documents, umes. and sometimes deliberate misstatementsof ping andpastingall theevidencefound in the Warren Commission’s twenty-six volumes of facts.In no other source can one gain an un- testimony and exhibitsinto scrapbooks which derstandingof themethodbywhich the evi- were arranged chronologically.His book uses dence cmergedfor theWarren Commission staff to write theReport's conclusion.Weis- this material,supplemented by interviews of key witnesses such as severalwith President berg attributes motive to no one,for “the whitewashing was done on theworkinglevel, Lyndon Johnson.Havingblindly taken as his workingbase the official findings of theWar- not the level of policy.Policy was wrong and was inhibited.It was safer to be for sin and ren Commission,he uses history to defend against motherhood than to deny the successful them.His basicfallacy is the use of docu- 25 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY Penn Jones,Jr.,is the editor of a weekly Communist scare of the Dallas police.18 The newspaper in a small town near Dallas,Texas. majorityofpublicofficialshaddeclaredOs A decorated combatveteran andofficer of wald to be the lone,mad sniper before the in- WorldWar II,hehas published his newspaper vestigation got under way, and Weisberg pro- since 1948,often in the midst ofextremist at- vides scores ofinstanceswhere investigators for the Commission tended to restrict their tempts to stifle the paper.His resistance to censorship hasearned research to agree. Weisberg's weaknesses asan author are, awards.An indefatigable worker,he is well informed about thedetailsof themurder and first, he does not consistently organize his ma- terial along conventional lines.He analyses an excellent and willing guide of the Texas murder site. When analysing facts he places a docuiment to support anargumentin one chapter and then elsewherepresents additional theminaframeworkofamilitaryconspiracy criticism that adds even moreweight to the operatingin conjunctionwith right-wing ele. initial comment.This scatters the attention of ments.Many of his statements and assertions readers. Second,he tends to employ expres- of fact are not supported by reference to the evidentiary base;his conclusions are present- sive "censor, particularlywhen he strikes at the ed in theform of essays and editorials. arrogance of a witness.Second,he tends to employ expres- of fact are not supported by reference to the evidentiary base;his conclusions are present- sive "censor, particularlywhen he strikes at the ed in theform of essays and editorials. arrogance of a witness. Sylvia Meagher (pronounced Marr),a re- HEANNOTATEDBIBLIOGRAPHY which follows is arranged into five cate- search librarian for theUnited Nations,wrote gories.First, the bibliographical materials are AccessoriesAftertheFact,whichisthebest listed.At present there is no adequate bibliog book on the assassinationbutwhichis seldom found in public libraries.Her numerous arti- raphy for the study of the assassination.Sec- cles and constant research have established ond,some of themajor documentary sources her as one of the top authorities on the subject, arebriefly surveyed. 1.A comprehensiveguide would be book length.Third, ,afewselected but the learned journals have declined touse her excellentabilities for reviewingbooks on critical or controversial articles are included. Fourth-themainbodyof thereview-are the assassination. the books.Fifth, is a miscellaneous list that merely suggests the type of materials available, 1HaroldWeisberg,WhitewashII:TheFBI-Secret but touches on somekey items also. Service Cover-up (Hyattstown,Maryland,1966),234. Bibliographical Works Sable, Martin H.A Bio-Bibliography of the Crown,James Tracy.The Kennedy Litera- Kennedy Family.(The Scarecrow Press, ture:A Bibliographical Essay on John F. New York, 1969.) Kennedy.(NewYork UniversityPress,New York, 1968.) An excellent but incomplete guide to arti- cles and books on all facetsofthe assassina- An incomplete attemptto assemblebooks tion and its aftermath. thatismarredbya pro-Warren Commission bias.--- PAGE BREAK --- New York, 1969.) Kennedy.(NewYork UniversityPress,New York, 1968.) An excellent but incomplete guide to arti- cles and books on all facetsofthe assassina- An incomplete attemptto assemblebooks tion and its aftermath. thatismarredbya pro-Warren Commission bias. Thompson,William Clifton.A Bibliography ofLiteratureRelatingtotheAssassination [Fensterwald,Bernard, Jr.,et al.].“Selective ofPresident John F.Kennedy.(Carleton Bibliography on Assassination.”(The Com- Printing Company,San Antonio,1968.Re- mittee to Investigate Assassinations,927 visededitionwith1971supplementprinted Fifteenth Street,N.W.,Washington,1969.) byJiffyPress. Distributed by W.C. Thompson&Son,731 RiversideDrive,San An eight-page, mimeographed, double. Antonio, Texas 78223.) column listingofbooks on the deaths ofnu A listing of 283entries,excluding magazine merousAmerican andworldleaderscompiled and newspaper articles. An excellent source for committee members'use. 26 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHIN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY tion pictures and still photosby Abraham Za- compiled by a private citizen, listing distri pruder,O. O. Nix, and others. butors and prices of several indispensable mo- Basic Sources Prepared by a private citizen, this is an AMERICAN PUBLIC absolutely indispensable index issued in a [The Committee to InvestigateAssassina- limited edition. tions.][Cross List Reference for Commis- SubjectIndextotheWarrenReport sionExhibits and CommissionDocuments] andHearings&Exhibits.(University Mic- (The Committee to Investigate Assassina- rofilms, Ann Arbor, 1971.) tions,927Fifteenth Street,N.W.,Washing Updated and slightly expanded edition now ton.Typescript. 40 pages.) available permanently in cloth or paper covers. A privately prepared cross-reference to the NationalArchivesWarren Commissionhold. U.S. Congress, Senate. Authorizing the Com- ings, indispensable to their use. missionestablishedtoreportupontheas- eCon- sassinationofPresidentJohnF.Kennedy [Jaworski, Leon].Files of Evidence tocompeltheattendanceandtestimonyof nectedwith theInvestigation of theAssassi- witnessesandtheproductionofevidence. nation of President John F.Kennedy.(N.p., Public Law 88-202,88 Congress,1 Session, n.d.Twenty-one volumes,in two-reel micro- December 13,1963.Senate Joint Resolu- film edition. Washington, D. C.,Micro- tion 137. card Editions, 901 Twenty-sixth Street, N.W.,[1967].) U.S.[National Archives].Index of Basic Source Materials.... (National Archives The little-known files of the biased assassi- nationinvestigation compiledby the attorney and Records Service, General Services Ad- ministration, Washington,1970. 185 general of Texas thatruns to about 5,500 volumes.(National Archives The little-known files of the biased assassi- nationinvestigation compiledby the attorney and Records Service, General Services Ad- ministration, Washington,1970. 185 general of Texas thatruns to about 5,500 volumes. It contains pagesin twenty-one pages.) Dallaspolice radio transmissions,data on the The archives lists the 1,555 CD's and in- area,plans and photos of the scenes,and so dicates theagency which prepared the report, forth.The two-reelmicrofilmwasprepared the name of theinvestigating agent, the sub for the Library of Congress. jectmatter of thereport,andcity where the investigation originated.It fails to cross- Johnson,Marion M.(compiler).“Prelimi- reference toCE's(CommissionExhibits)and naryInventory of theRecords of thePresi- is of limited usefulness. dent's Commission on the Assassination of President Kennedy.”(National Archives U.S.President.Executive Order No.1l130, and Records Service,General Services Ad “Appointing a Commission to report upon ministration,Washington,1970.28 pages.) theAssassination of President John F.Ken- Lifton, David S. (compiler). Document Ad- nedy."Codeof Federal Regulation.Title3 dendumtotheWarrenReport.(Sightext ThePresident.1959-1963compilation.(0f- EI Segundo, California, Publications, fice of the Federal Register,Washington, 1968). 1964.) A necessary addition that contains the de- Executivefiatcreated theWarren Commis- classified transcriptsof theproceedings of the sion.The order is also printed in theWarren executive sessionsof theWarren Commission; Commission Report, p. 471.--- PAGE BREAK --- 1964.) A necessary addition that contains the de- Executivefiatcreated theWarren Commis- classified transcriptsof theproceedings of the sion.The order is also printed in theWarren executive sessionsof theWarren Commission; Commission Report, p. 471. CD(Commission Document)344,transcript [U.S.Warren Commission].Investigation of ofa taperecordingofthefirst interrogation theAssassination ofPresidentJohnF of Marina Oswald,November 24;and,the Kennedy:HearingsBeforethePresidents Liebeler Memorandum of September 6,1964, Commission ontheAssassination ofPresi- on“Galley proofs of Chapter IV of the Re dent Kennedy.(Government Printing Of- port." fice,Washington,1964, 26 vols.) Meagher, Sylvia. Subject I lex-to the Warren A 20,000-page, 10,400,000-word selection Report and Hearings & Exhibits.(Scare- from the unpublished evidence collected by crow Press,New York,1966.) 27 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY the substantial holdings assembled byinvesti- commission staff. Fifteen volumes contain gators such as Penn Jones,Jr.,Midlothian, testimonybywitnesses andelevenvolumes are Texas.The original Zapruder film is private- exhibits. Volume XV containsonelist of ly held;however, many good copies of the names and one of exhibits.There is no sub- or bootleg edition are available at modestprices. ject index.Nothing is in chronological Thefilm,Rush toJudgment,by MarkLane, subject order and thematerial appears tohave distributed by Rogosin of New York,is an been randomlyselected.Thevolumes con- excellent and’clear presentation of the critic's tain interesting informationif one has the en- view.It includes eyewitness testimony and a durance to read it all.For example,on pages visualperspective thatis notobtainable any 799-800ofVolumeXXVI theineptnessof the placeelse.There areotherfilms. investigationissuggestedbyaletterfrom the theFederalBureauofInvestigation to Georgetown University Archives. staffof the commissioninforming them that Containst thecompletefilesof theCom- they cannot identify one of the finger prints mittee to Investigate Assassinations,includ foundon thesixthfloorof theTexasSchool ing its collection of books. This unique re- BookDepository and that thefirmrentingthe search center is open to scholars. buildingrefused tohave all thepersonsin the done. building fingerprinted. Nothing was AMERICANSECRET Thousands of pages in the volumes are useless, trivial,or tangential, such as the reprinting Somematerialscollectedby the staffofthe of scores of fpages ofemotionalultra-right Warren Commissionareheld inthe archives wing articles from the public press,and func. under security classification and restrictions data. Eight thousand and will be unavailable for many years.Much tionasdiversionary of the classified material,however,should copies of the set were printed.under security classification and restrictions data. Eight thousand and will be unavailable for many years.Much tionasdiversionary of the classified material,however,should copies of the set were printed. never bemade public since it isirrelevant and [U.S.Warren Commission].Report of the contains personal information, such as the President’s Commissionon the Assassina- medical records of Marina Oswald’s preg tion of President John F.Kennedy.(Gov. Washington, nancy. Other documents, such as the x-ray ernment Printing Office, data and the spectrographic analysis and data 1964.) it is based upon, which are vital to any ob- The study prepared by the clerks and staff jective investigation,are suppressed.They oftheWarren Commission belong to the people of the United States,and thevery existenceof suppressed documents on anofficially declarednonconspiracy is the AMERICAN PRIVATE negation of the principles of aconstitutional Severalprivate collectionsof documents democracy. exist thatare uncataloged.These include Articles Cook,Fred J. “Assassination Investigations: Belin, David. " Truth was my only goal. * TheIrregularsTake theField.TheNation TheTexas Observer (August 13,1971),13- (July 19, 1971),40-46. 15. A liberal journalist describes the composi- Areply toSylviaMeagher's articleof the tion,purpose,and activities of theCommittee same date and in the same newspaper by the toInvestigate Assassinations.The CTIA is a varyingnumber rofnon- Commission lawyerwhose questioning helped loosely grouped, witness Charles Givens to change his testi- academicmenwhocomefromdiversepolitical placed Oswald on backgrounds including right-wing,left-wing, mony.Givens’testimony Meagher demonstrates how center liberal,and nonalligned segments. the sixth floor. he originallyplaced Oswaldon the firstfloor Graham,Fred P. “Doctor Inspects Kennedy and then,under pressure, four months later X-Rays."New York Tiines,January placed Oswald on the sixth floor.Using an 1972.--- PAGE BREAK --- he originallyplaced Oswaldon the firstfloor Graham,Fred P. “Doctor Inspects Kennedy and then,under pressure, four months later X-Rays."New York Tiines,January placed Oswald on the sixth floor.Using an 1972. ancient ploy,Belinignores the specific charges In this widelyhailed report on a private levied against him by Mrs.Meagher and with viewing of federal secret documents,the New numerous errors of fact discusses side issues. 28 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY York urologist,Dr.John K. Lattimer,states as assassins of truth. Why this article would that Oswald alone shot thePresident.Latti- establishhim,asit did,asa national authority mer succumbs toone ofthemost alluringen- on theWarren Commissionisincomprehens- ticements that an emotional nationalevent pre- ible.ApparentlyKaplan workedin theJustice sentstothenonacademic researcher-at- Departmentfrom1957-1961. temptingtoevaluatetechnicalevidencebe- "The Assassins." Stanford Law yond one's professional expertise.He also Review,XIX: 1110-1151 (1967). failsto relate what he calls his findings to the multitude of other equally pertinent facts.As- The same article as above with a few errors suming Lattimer did in factexamine x-rays corrected. andalso assuming theywere in fact the x-rays Lattimer,John K.“Factors in the Death of of PresidentKennedy,the x-rays in themselves PresidentKennedy."Journal of the Ameri- donot tell who pulled the trigger.Perhaps can Medical Association,198:327-333 his reliance onadevil theoryof history dis- (October 24,1966). torts the alleged study since he haslong felt Oswald to be a“modern-day, traitorous guer- A urologist's opinion upholding theWar rilla...working with religious-type convic ren Commissionfindings while completely tion."All facts are trimmed to fit his distort. ignoringtestimonyandevidencecontraryto ing bed of assertions,which tends to preclude his desired argument.For example,he stipu- objectivity. latesthat thedefective scope on therifleal- legedlyused byOswald actuallyhelpedhimhit One of Lattimer’s errors relates to his de thePresident by compensatingfor poormarks- scription of theback wound.ignoringtestimonyandevidencecontraryto ing bed of assertions,which tends to preclude his desired argument.For example,he stipu- objectivity. latesthat thedefective scope on therifleal- legedlyused byOswald actuallyhelpedhimhit One of Lattimer’s errors relates to his de thePresident by compensatingfor poormarks- scription of theback wound. .Since thehole manship.He produces no unbiased figures in thePresident's shirt and coat is about six and calculations to prove this.He ignores inchesbelow thebackneckline,and Lattimer testimonyandevidenceofadefectivebolt, puts thebullet about twoinchesabove the a defective trigger,an apparent absence of an neckline,he must claim the Zapruder film ammunition clip,anda cartridge case with a shows the coat“bunched up”as the President denttoodeeptoholdabullet. waves tothecrowdinordertoaccountfor the eight-inch difference.This is absolutely “Similarities inFatalWoundings of contrarytothefact.Atthemomentofim John Wilkes Booth 1andLee Harvey pact thePresidentwasshieldedfromAbra- Oswald.NewYorkStateJournalofMedi- ham Zapruder's camera by a road sign and as cine (July 1,1966),1782-1794. Asensationalized dtreatmentofthetwo It is a physical impossibility for the well-tail. deathsthatlacks accurate and complete docu ored coat tobunch eight inches,though if it mentation.The author accepts the unfounded didtheoverlapwould producetwoholesin and outrageous view that the federal military- the fabric.Lattimer also maintains that the intelligence servicekilled Lincoln. bullet which entered PresidentKennedy's neck transited downwardat so steep an angle that "The Kennedy-Connally Single Bullet hadit been a frontal shotwhich caused the Theory:A Feasibility Study.International wound (as many critics have charged),the Surgery,50:524-532 2(December,1968).--- PAGE BREAK --- deathsthatlacks accurate and complete docu ored coat tobunch eight inches,though if it mentation.The author accepts the unfounded didtheoverlapwould producetwoholesin and outrageous view that the federal military- the fabric.Lattimer also maintains that the intelligence servicekilled Lincoln. bullet which entered PresidentKennedy's neck transited downwardat so steep an angle that "The Kennedy-Connally Single Bullet hadit been a frontal shotwhich caused the Theory:A Feasibility Study.International wound (as many critics have charged),the Surgery,50:524-532 2(December,1968). second assassinwouldhavehad tohavebeen Asimplisticeffort toshow thatbullet CE on the car floor.But this proves a conspiracy, 399did dowhat it was supposed to do:transit notthereverse,for theneckbullet(CE 399) PresidentKennedy’sneckinazig-yaw-and-zag couldnothavefollowedthepathLattimer path, wounding Governor Connally five suggests and still have hit Governor Connally. times,and smash twobones before emerging There would have tohave been a second as- unmarred.The author fails to substantiate sassin who shot Connally. his assertionswithreference tophotographs or The article is diversionary.It is curious to evidence.He claims to have obtained a that the two writers,Latimer and Belin,whose secretviewingof CE399in the publicar- articles are theleast competent,arethe New chives and found it to be flattened “severely” York Timesauthorities on the assassination. on the sideawayfrom the official photographs that show it to be round.‘This gives him a Kaplan, John.“The Assassins.”The Ameri- point from which to argue and marshal“facts” can Scholar,V111: 271-306 (July,1963). to sustain the single-bullet theory.However, Anerror-ridden andemotionally suffused the person who discovered thebullet on a attemptbyalawprofessortoattackcriticsof stretcher in theDallas hospital testified that theWarrenCommission findingswhohesees it“rolled out”from under the stretcher equip 29 --- PAGE BREAK ---WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY AUTUMN,1972 ment andpathologists and medical men who A long and scathing discussion of Renatus gaveitaminute andexhaustive study testified Hertogs and Lucy Freeman’s The Two As- that it was“without distortion.”CE 399 is sassins given by an informed critic.She is public;photographs ofall sides canbe readily too charitable. obtained.JosiahThompson,inSixSeconds in Dallas,offers a photograph of one side of the “Wheels with Deals:How the Ken- bullet on page 45,and one of the other side nedy “Investigation’was Organized.” The onpage 146,clearly distinguishedby a mark Minority of One,X:23-27(July-August, made during a federal examination.Thebut- 1968). let is inpristine condition.Lattimer notonly The'excellent, and the only,account of the must produce the“severely flattened”bullet Texas attorney_general’sinvestigation of the for public scrutiny,but also must prove that assassination.This article is essential reading it isin fact CE 399 beforehis amateur at- on thebackground to theWarren Commission. tempts canbe taken seriously. Rothchild,John.“Finding the Facts Bureau- Meagher,Sylvia.“After the Battle,the Book. crats Hide”TheWashingtonMonthly The Minority of One,IX:25-27 (June, (January,1972),15-27. 1967). The author summarizes the problems of An informed critic provides an excellent usingthe Freedom of Information Act and includes some material on the attempts of article-lengthreviewofWilliamManchester's The Death of a President. critics toobtain secret information. Sagatelyan, Mikhail. “Dallas: Who? How? "The curioustestimonyof Mr. Why?" SputnikMonthlyDigest.Trans- Givens.” The Texas Observer (August 13, lated by Monica Whyte.V11:111-130, 98 1971), 11-12. 120,109-130 (June, July,August, 1971). A superb article by one of the most knowl- A Soviet journalist speculates on the mo- edgeableindividualsworkingon theKennedy tive behind the conspiracy to kill Kennedy.120,109-130 (June, July,August, 1971). A superb article by one of the most knowl- A Soviet journalist speculates on the mo- edgeableindividualsworkingon theKennedy tive behind the conspiracy to kill Kennedy. assassination.She gives a chronoiogical ac- Sagatelyan thinks that reactionary elements countofthe conflicting statements and testi- murdered the President tohalthismove mony of Charles Givens.The Warren Com- to stop the cold war.Lyndon B.Johnson al- mission used Givens as a key witness to Os- legedly participated in theassassination in wald’'s presence near the alleged sixth-floor order to squelch a Kennedyinvestigation of sniperwindowabout 1l:45A.M.Meagher. massive corruption in which the Vice Presi- however,shows that on November 22,1963 dent was involved.The author draws many Givens testified to theFBI thatOswaldwas on of the actual details from critical worksby the first floor playing dominoes at 1l:50. Americans.There is, however,no evidence Then Meagher traces the changes in his testi- to support his allegations.There is neither mony during questioningby the Commission factnor document of any kind that in any staff until onApril 8,1964,Givens placed way links President Johnson to the assassina- Oswald on the sixth floor. tion. “OnClosing Doors,Not Opening Sprague,Richard E.The Assassination of Them’or,The Limit of theWarren Investi- President John F.Kennedy:The Applica- gation.The Minority of One,VIIl:29-32 tionof Computerstothe Photographic (July-August,1966). Evidence." Computersand Automation, An article-lengthreview of Edward J.Ep XIX: 29-60 (May, 1970). stein’sInquest:TheWarren Commission and A computer specialist lists and assigns num- theEstablishmentofTruth. berstoall510known photographsofthe murder scene and immed "Post-assassination liateeventstakenby Credibility seventy-five photographers. Botha Chasm.” TheMinority of One,IX:21-22 single still photoandamoviesequence oftento (March, 1967).--- PAGE BREAK --- berstoall510known photographsofthe murder scene and immed "Post-assassination liateeventstakenby Credibility seventy-five photographers. Botha Chasm.” TheMinority of One,IX:21-22 single still photoandamoviesequence oftento (March, 1967). 500frames are counted as one each.A total A criticalanalysisof thepublic comments of 25,000frames exist.TheWarren Commis- ofmembersof theWarrenCommission staff. sion staff examined only twenty-six photo- graphs,about 5per cent of the 5i0,omitting, “A Psychiatrist's RetroactiveClair for example,the photographs ofa scopeless voyance"The Minority of One,VIII: 25- riflebeingexamined at theTexasSchoolBook 27 (June, 1966). Depository immediately after the murder,the 30 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY unarranged boxes of the alleged sniper's nest, minor factual errors (which have been cor- and of several men,probably common tramps, rected in subsequent issues of the magazine). Outside therealm of photographyandthe beingtakenintocustodybylawenforcement officials in the nearby railroad yards.This analysis of the photos,the author uses vague isanindispensable article in spite of the statements. Books Bishop, Jin.The Day Kennedy was Shot. Bringuier,Carlos.Red Friday:November (Funk &Wagnalls,NewYork,1968.) 22d,1963.(Chas.Hallberg & Company, Chicago, 1969.) The most error-laden andfactually distort- A disorganized and confusedattempt to ed book on the assassination.After locating analyse the assassination without using schol- one hundred instances of major factual error, acute distortion ofevidence,and omission of arly apparatus. facts contrary to the author's argument in Buchanan,Thomas.Who Killed Kennedy? three chapters, this reviewer stopped count- (G.P.Putnam’s Sons,New York,1964.) ing.For example,Bishop accepts the War- Ajournalist criticizes theWarren Commis- ren Commission conclusion that Oswald kill- sioninabookthatistoobriefandwhichis edKennedyfrom the sixth-floorbookdepos- largely speculative concerning the reasons be itory’s easternwindow and presents several hind themurder. eyewitnesses to sustain the assertion.Hecen- tershisnarrativeonHowardBrennanwho Chapman, Gil and Ann.Was Oswald Alone? stated that he saw Oswald shoot.Bishop (Publishers Export Company,Post Office omits entirely that Brennan hadpoor eye- Box 20127,San Diego,1967.) sight, did not wear his eyeglasses that day, The authors give abrief overviewby using contradicted his testimony,and testified to -thatthemanleaned other critical books,and make a major point aphysicalimpossibility- in locating Ruby’shome address--twoblocks against thewindowframe while shooting. Bishop also uses ArnoldRowland’s testimony from the scene ofofficer Tippit's murder.stated that he saw Oswald shoot.Bishop (Publishers Export Company,Post Office omits entirely that Brennan hadpoor eye- Box 20127,San Diego,1967.) sight, did not wear his eyeglasses that day, The authors give abrief overviewby using contradicted his testimony,and testified to -thatthemanleaned other critical books,and make a major point aphysicalimpossibility- in locating Ruby’shome address--twoblocks against thewindowframe while shooting. Bishop also uses ArnoldRowland’s testimony from the scene ofofficer Tippit's murder. but omits thatportionwhereRowland swore Curry, Jesse.Personal JFK File.(Limited toseeingtwomen in adjacentwindowson the Collectors, Dallas, 1969.) sixth floor,an unarmed Negro in the sniper TheDallasPoliceChief makes an attempt windowandthesniperinthewesternwin- Amos Euins’s “man”“with to present Dallas material,He prints the po dow.ToBishop, a bald spot" "Oswald in the window. licelogreportofNovember22withseveral is Bishopignores photographs which show that crucialomissions,adds three vitalminutes to the time of officer J. D. Tippit’s murder, thesixth-floor sniperwindowwasemptysec- ondsbeforethemurderanddoesnotinclude andprints apicture containingevidence re- comments from the report of Mr.Powell,the futing some police testimonybefore theWar- Armyintelligenceagent “trapped”in the de- ren Commission. pository when it wassealed bypolice.A Cutler,Robert.Bradley.The Flight of CE trained observer’sreport mighthaveadded 399:Evidence of Conspiracy.(Printed by considerablyto the credenceof thenarrative. Omni-Print,Beverly,Massachusetts,1969.) There are scores of similar difficulties. Cutler, an architect, gives an excellent anal. Brener,Milton E.The Garrison Case:A ysis of CE 399's course. Study in the Abuse of Power.(Clarkson N. TwoFlightpaths:Evidenceof Con- Potter, New York, 1969.) spiracy.--- PAGE BREAK --- Study in the Abuse of Power.(Clarkson N. TwoFlightpaths:Evidenceof Con- Potter, New York, 1969.) spiracy. (Mirror Press,Danvers,Massachu- An emotional criticism of Mr.Garrison setts,1971.Distributed by Cutler Designs, that centers on his-irregularities and eccen- 38Union Street,Manchester,Massachusetts tricities and his apparent abuse of office.It 01944.) ignores the evidence brought out in the trial Thisbriefvolume contains a summary of whichrelated totheautopsyofPresident Cutler’s TheFlightof CE 399and a studyof Kennedy,the release.of the Zapruder film, the “Traverse Thoracial".Charts and draw- and other material. 31 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY ings of the flightpaths and an analysis of himattimestoforce connectionsbetween thesixth-floor windowsare given. 'This is facts.The documentary _evidence,the testi- thebcst scholarly studyofafragmentof the mony of witnesses,and the analysis ofphys- Warren Commission findings and is amodel icalnaterial,at Teastasthey are presented, for any work of a similar nature. are not sufficient to carryhis argument ofa political conspiracyaidedandabettedbythe Epstein,Edward Jay.Counterplot.(TheVik- Central Intelligence Agency. ing Press, New York, 1969.) Gershenson,Alvin.Kennedy and Big Busi- Examining the ineptness of the investiga- ness.(Book Company of America,Beverly tionconductedby theNew Orleans’District Hills,California,1964.) Attorney, a professor adds his own misinfor- mation to construct a conspiracy in the D. Big business killed the President.Gershen- A.'s office to prove there is no such thing as son provides no evidence,just jumbled theory. a conspiracy. Goldberg,Arthur.ConspiracyInterpretations Inquest:TheWarren_Commission of theAssassinationofPresidentKennedy: andtheEstablishmentofTruth.(The InternationalandDomestic.(Universityof Viking Press, New York, 1966.) California Security StudiesProject,Secur- ity Studies Paper Number 16,Los Angeles, A good,concise criticism of the Warren University ofCalifornia,1968.) Commission's findings. .Epstein utilized the filesofonly one segmentof the Commission The author,an Air Force historian and a staff;therefore,his sargumentisdeflected member of the Commission staff,summarizes away from vital areas. hisstudyof thecriticalliteraturebutdoes not utilize footnotes or bibliography.In his Flammonde,Paris.TheKennedy Conspiracy: concluding remarkshe first employsFreud An Uncommissioned ReportontheJim toexorcisewhathe calls thedemonologists GarrisonInvestigation. (Meredith Press.hisstudyof thecriticalliteraturebutdoes not utilize footnotes or bibliography.In his Flammonde,Paris.TheKennedy Conspiracy: concluding remarkshe first employsFreud An Uncommissioned ReportontheJim toexorcisewhathe calls thedemonologists GarrisonInvestigation. (Meredith Press. whohave criticizedthe conclusionof the New York,1969.) Report and includes thefollowingdenial of a A free-lance writer provides a sympathetic conspiracy:“There is no evidence,there are appraisal of the New Orleans inquiry. no eyewitnesses,no one talked or betrayed the conspiracy. This reviewer feels Dr.Gold. Ford,Gerald R.,and Stiles,John R.Portrait berg's argument is not valid. of theAssassin. .(Simon & Schuster,New York,1965.) Hepburn,James [Pseudonym?].Farewell This volume is misnamed.It is really a por- America. (Frontiers Company,Vaduz, Liechtenstein,1968.) trait of Representative Ford,a Commission This is the most curious work on the as- member. sassination.Published in Liechtenstein,print- Fox,Sylvan.The Unanswered Questions edin Belgium,and distributed in Canada,the aboutPresidentKennedy’sAssassination. book is rare in theUnited States but avail- (Award Books, New York,1965.) able in Europe,apparently in several langu- A reporter gives an informed and brief ages.The bulk of its387pages develops the alleged motives for the assassination of the critical'statement. President by ultra-right-wing elements in the Garrison,Jim.A Heritage of Stone. (G.P United States.According to the author or Putnam’s Sons,New York,1970.) authors,mostmajor rreactionary American The New Orleans district attorney focuses forces were involved,but the principal one on the Dallas assassination,excluding discus- was the Texas oil interests.About three pages sion of his controversial trial.Profoundly in- touch on the murder itselfwithamap show. formed and based on extensive investigation.--- PAGE BREAK --- (G.P United States.According to the author or Putnam’s Sons,New York,1970.) authors,mostmajor rreactionary American The New Orleans district attorney focuses forces were involved,but the principal one on the Dallas assassination,excluding discus- was the Texas oil interests.About three pages sion of his controversial trial.Profoundly in- touch on the murder itselfwithamap show. formed and based on extensive investigation. ing thelocationofthe allegedassassinsand theattorney'sbookprovides strong butnot the trajectories of the severalbullets.Many conclusive evidence of a conspiracy.He pre- statements arenotsupported byknown facts; sentshisexplanationwithinapoliticalframe- the map is even contrary in some spots to work of military-business efforts to silence known and established fact.Linking themur- a critic of the cold war expansion intoSouth- der to Texas oil interests and charging that east Asia.This requires him to argue that theDallaspolicewereimplicatedareabso. President Kennedy wasa antiexpansion and lutely without anybase in fact.The sources radical. The framework,also,distorts Garri- used are allegedly taken from foreign intelli son’s insight into the documents,requiring gence files that are impossible to locate. This 32 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATION BIBLIOGRAPHY should more properly be classified as fic- James,Rosemary,and Wardlaw,Jack. Plot tion. orPolitics?TheGarrisonCase andIts Cast. (Pelican Publishing House, New Orleans, Hertogs, Renatus, and Freeman,Lucy. The 1967.) Two Assassins. (Thomas Y. Crowell, New The authors assemble factual background York, 1965.) material. Apsychological analysis of Ruby and Os wald by twoprofessors thatbelongs in a fic- Jones,Penn,Jr.Forgive My Grief.(Midlo- tion category of assassination literature. thian Mirror, Midlothian, Texas, 1966- 1969, 3 vols.) Kirkwood, James. American Grotesque: An Three slim volumes of essays and analysis AccountoftheClayShaw-JinGarrison ofWarren Commission witness testimony AffairintheCityofNewOrleans. (Simon drawn from intensive research.Steeped in and Schuster,New York,1970.) the political climate of his Texas homeland, An emotional,journalistic critique of Gar- Jonesprovides illuminatingin insights, e.g., the rison that contains muchinterestinginforma- nightof the murder some wealthyTexans tion,but does not relate the Garrison evidence held partiestocelebrate thedeathof the to theDallas tragedy. President.He also delves extensivelyinto President Johnson's Joesten,Joachim.The Case Against Lyndon economicandpolitical B.Johnson in the Assassination ofPresi- background,establishing myriadrelationships Munich, betweenKennedy successor and Texas re- dent Kennedy.(Selbstverlag, actionaries. The basic weakness is the au 1968-1969,2 vols.) thor's tendency, when reaching conclusions Ajournalist speculates about the role of upon the national bac groundtothemurder, President Johnson. toomit references to evidence thatwould The CaseAgainst theKennedyClan. provide a wider acceptance of his argument. (Selbstverlag,Munich,1967.) Lane,Mark.A Citizen’s Dissent:Mark Lane This is a poor book based on idle rumors.provide a wider acceptance of his argument. (Selbstverlag,Munich,1967.) Lane,Mark.A Citizen’s Dissent:Mark Lane This is a poor book based on idle rumors. Replies.(Holt,Rinehart and Winston,New York, 1968.) TheDarkSideofLyndonBaines Johnson.(Dawnay Ltd., London,1968.) An attorney replies to those who criticized his book,Rush to Judgment.The first por- Joesten popularizes information on John- tion,containing several pagesontheproblems son's Texas background and spices it‘with ofpresenting studies on theKennedy assassi- speculation, nation to the public,is awkward to use and detractsfrom theremainder of thework.Lane .TheGarrisonInquiry:Truth&Con fails to document some facts presented in this sequences.(Dawnay,London,1967.) segment, such as the British Broadcasting Ajournalist speculates on the background Company’s position during his London tour, of the inquiry. andthus they cannot be considered in the HowKennedy wasKilled:TheFull same category as the information in the ex- cellent last three-quarters of thebook. One Appalling Story.(Dawnay,London,1968.) substantial segmentexaminestheroleplayed This is a summary of other works and does byWalter Cronkiteand theColumbiaBroad not provide the answer it claims. casting System during.a.four-hour television. Marina Oswald.(Dawnay,London, review of theWarren Commission’s conclu- 1967.) sions.Bysuperbuseofdocumentaryevidence Lane shows that Cronkite and CBSpresented This is heavily speculative. views considerably atvariance with known .Oswald:Assassin or Fall Guy?(Mar- facts and proves that one must be fully_con- versantwith the factual basefor the studyof zani & Munsell,New York,1964.) theassassinationbeforeventuringtobecome Joesten’s first andbest book is full of in- a public authority on the validityof the one. formation,all twisted by an assumption of a sniper theory. right-wing plot.--- PAGE BREAK --- formation,all twisted by an assumption of a sniper theory. right-wing plot. Rush toJudgment:A Critiqueof .Oswald:The Truth.(Dawnay,Lon- theWarrenCommission'sInquiryintothe don,1967.) MurdersofPresident JohnF.Kennedy, A summary of rumors about Oswald. Officer J.D.Tippit and Lee Harvey Os- 33 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY wald.With an introduction by Professor This unfathomable book belongs in a fic- Hugh Trevor-Roper. (Holt,Rinehart and tion category of assassination literature. Winston,New York,1966.) Meagher,Sylvia.Accessories After theFact: The first major study to receive widespread TheWarren Commission,the Authorities, publicity,it establishes a basis in the evidence andtheReport.With an introduction by for refusing to accept the conclusion of the Leo Sauvage.(Bobbs-Merrill,Indianapo- Warren Commission. Unfortunately, ,Lane lis, 1967.) places a second thesis alongside thefirst and This is the most scholarly investigation of findsChiefJusticeEarlWarren toberespon- sible for the inquiry’s failurc.The first the the assassination and theonly volume that sis is sustained by excellent scholarly analysis; fulfills the demands ofobjectivity in every de- the second is.not supported from.the evi- tail.Meagher’s method is her strength.Each dence.In addition to the repugnancy of the topicistreated separately. Typically,she givesthe conclusionfrom theReport,followed preposterous accusation against Warren,it shifts the reader's focus away from themon- by theevidenceand testimonyofallwit- umental ineptness of the federalinvestiga- nesseswithreferencetoeach haspectofthe problem.Finally, she appraises the facts on tiveagencies toadefenseof theChiefJustice. thebasis of thedocumentaryevidence as Lawrence,Lincoln [Pseudonym].WereWe givenby the Commission.Sheconcludes that Controlled? (University Books,New Hyde the Commission did not prove Oswald killed Park,NewYork,1967.) John F.Kennedy and that the assassins are In a strictly speculative book the author still free.She states that a new investigation argues that the stock marketwas manipulated byresearchersindependentof the government heavilybefore andafter theassassination. is required.(University Books,New Hyde the Commission did not prove Oswald killed Park,NewYork,1967.) John F.Kennedy and that the assassins are In a strictly speculative book the author still free.She states that a new investigation argues that the stock marketwas manipulated byresearchersindependentof the government heavilybefore andafter theassassination. is required. No figures and statistics are given, but a Morin,Relman.Assassination:The Death of bizarre element of RHIC (Radio-Hypnotic President JohnF.Kennedy.(The New Intracerebral Control)is added. American Library,New York,1968.) Lewis,Richard Warren,and Schiller, Law- This volume lacks even the rudimentary rence.The Scavengers and Critics ofthe framework fora scholarlybook. WarrenReport: TheEndlessParadox. (Dell Publishing Company,New York, Newman,Albert H.The Assassination of John 1967.) F.Kennedy:The Reasons Why.(Clarkson Two journalists make a superficial and N.Potter,New York,1970.) fancifuleffort touphold the effortsofthe A strong supporter of the Warren Commis. WarrenCommissionbyattacking thosewho sion findings, Newman expendshis energies criticized its findings. Much of this thin, describing the mental states of thedeadOs ramblingvolume lacksdocumentation or even wald by inferences from conveniently kept a grasp of the subject. olddiaries,stray snapshots,used orderblanks, Manchester,William.The Death of a Presi- and speeches ofFidel Castro printed in vari- dent.(Harper &Row,New York,1967.) ous leftist journals.He then imposes motives on Oswald’s actions.It is an impressive ef A book thatrepresentsa commercialpoint fortbutfallsonthesamelogicalgroundsas ofview,not the evidence. did theMedieval scholastic argument on how Marcus,Raymond.The Bastard Bullet: to count angels on the head of a pin.New- SearchforLegitimacyforCommissionEx- man assumes thathis device of mental states hibit399.WithanintroductionbyMark is valid and that it gives expression to reality.--- PAGE BREAK --- olddiaries,stray snapshots,used orderblanks, Manchester,William.The Death of a Presi- and speeches ofFidel Castro printed in vari- dent.(Harper &Row,New York,1967.) ous leftist journals.He then imposes motives on Oswald’s actions.It is an impressive ef A book thatrepresentsa commercialpoint fortbutfallsonthesamelogicalgroundsas ofview,not the evidence. did theMedieval scholastic argument on how Marcus,Raymond.The Bastard Bullet: to count angels on the head of a pin.New- SearchforLegitimacyforCommissionEx- man assumes thathis device of mental states hibit399.WithanintroductionbyMark is valid and that it gives expression to reality. Lane.(Rendell Publications,Los Angeles, In addition,he assumes Oswald was a Marx- 1966.Distributed by Rendell Publications, ist,albeit slightly mad.All facts subsequently Post Office Box 35363 Preuss Station,Los encountered in hisinvestigations are placed Angeles,California 90035.) upon this Procrustean bed of assumptions and brushed aside if they do not fit.He thus A thin volume which is an excellent schol. ignoresall 1physical facts,logical problems arly study of a single aspect of the investiga- ofphotographic analysis,and the entire body tionbytheWarren Commission. of critical literature. Matteo,Pat.This Captive Land.(Privately printed,44 Elinor Place,Yonkers,New Oswald,Robert.Lee:A Portrait ofLeeHarv- York, 1968.) ey Oswald.(Coward, New York,1967.) 34 --- PAGE BREAK ---WRONE:JOHN F.KENNEDY ASSASSINATIONBIBLIOGRAPHY A book by Lee Oswald’s brother,whose Thompson, Josiah. Six Seconds in Dallas:A printedremarks differ considerably from his Micro-Study_oftheKennedyAssassination. initial comments published in the public press. (Bernard Geis Associates, New York, 1967.) Popkin,Richard H.The Second Oswald.With A studyof thewitnesses andphysicalevi anintroductionby Murray Kempton. dence the shots, shell casings,bullet frag (Avon Library-New York Review Book, ments,and so forth-used by the Warren New York,1966.) Commission.Thompson concludes that at least This is a good presentation of the probabil. three gunmen participated in the murder.The ity thatafake Oswald functioned todivert argument is carefully reasoned, the evidence investigators. However, it is too brief. is assessed with all the detachment of a first- rate scholar,and the conclusion closely fol- Roberts,Charles.The Truth About the As- lows the facts as he presents them.Perhaps sassination.WithaforewordbyPierre the book's most important point for future Salinger.(Grosset & Dunlap, New York, research is the “Dealey Plaza Chart:Loca- 1967.) tion of Witnesses”wherein the author num- A 1l8-page effort to uphold the findings of bers,names,locates,and gives information on the individual testimonies.Further ref- theWarrenCommissionby attackingthechar- acterandmotivesof thosewhowroteagainst erenceswhen applicableareprovidedon the 268 witnesses. the official conclusion.It is full of errors, lacks documentation,uses emotional langu- Thomson,George C.The Quest for Truth:A age,and completely failstofulfill the promise QuizzicalLook at theWarrenReport;or, given in its title.Why Salinger would be in- HowPresidentKennedyReallyWasAssas- formed about the assassination evidence is sinated.(G.C.Thomson Engineering Com- not revealed. pany,Glendale,California,1964.) Thisbriefcritical examination of thephys.the official conclusion.It is full of errors, lacks documentation,uses emotional langu- Thomson,George C.The Quest for Truth:A age,and completely failstofulfill the promise QuizzicalLook at theWarrenReport;or, given in its title.Why Salinger would be in- HowPresidentKennedyReallyWasAssas- formed about the assassination evidence is sinated.(G.C.Thomson Engineering Com- not revealed. pany,Glendale,California,1964.) Thisbriefcritical examination of thephys. Smith,Bill [William R.].Assassination by ical evidence is a good early effort,marred Consensus:TheStoryBehind theKennedy by a political bias. Assassination.. (L'Avant Garde Books, Washington, D.C., 1966.) Weisberg, Harold.Oswald in New Orleans: A rambling,footnote-free volume on “be- Caseof Conspiracywith theC.I.A.Fore- havior engineering” that makes no contribu- word byJim Garrison.(CanyonBooks,New tion whatsoever. York,1967.) An informative and exhaustive treatment of AHogStoryfromtheAftermireof the background of the New Orleans investiga- theKennedy Assassination. (L'Avant tion,told from the perspective of its rela- Garde Books,Washington,1968.) tionship to theWarren Commission'sinvesti Apparently Smith argues that insiders on gation. the allegedright-wing conspiracyplayed the Whitewash:TheReport on theWar- stock andhogmarkets andby selling short ren Report.(Harold Weisberg,Route 7, made a fortune.The thesis is impossible to Hyattstown,Maryland,1965.) follow. This was the first book which established a basis in fact for rejecting the conclusions Sauvage,Léo.TheOswald Affair:An Exam- of theWarren Commission.It'wasnotpub inationoftheContradictionsandOmissions oftheWarrenReport.(World Publishing licized. Company, Cleveland,1966.) WhitewashII:TheFBI-SecretSer- A journalist disputes theWarren Commis- vice Cover-up.(Harold Weisberg,Route 7, sionfindings anddoes what the title states, Hyattstown,Maryland,1966.) but in a rather superficial way.--- PAGE BREAK --- This was the first book which established a basis in fact for rejecting the conclusions Sauvage,Léo.TheOswald Affair:An Exam- of theWarren Commission.It'wasnotpub inationoftheContradictionsandOmissions oftheWarrenReport.(World Publishing licized. Company, Cleveland,1966.) WhitewashII:TheFBI-SecretSer- A journalist disputes theWarren Commis- vice Cover-up.(Harold Weisberg,Route 7, sionfindings anddoes what the title states, Hyattstown,Maryland,1966.) but in a rather superficial way. Weisbergexamines themethodsusedby thefederal investigative agencies toassemble, Sparrow,John.After the Assassination: analyze,and present the evidence they were PositiveAppraisaloftheWarrenReport. charged with procuring. He demonstrates (Chilmark Press,New York,1967.) with exhaustive detail 1theproceduresused to Thivofume-byarenwned professor clip photographs, misprint documents,and proves that academic qualifications are no omit key portions of the evidence to provide substituteforknowledgeof thedocuments. the conclusion sought-alone assassin.The 35 --- PAGE BREAK ---AUTUMN,1972 WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY graphicallyreproduced aloncmake thevolume reproduction ofmany unpublished documents a necessary addition to the critical literature. is an addedfeature. White,Stephen.ShouldWeNowBelieve the PhotographicWhitewash:Sup WarrenReport?PrefacebyWalterCron- pressed Kennedy Assassination Pictures. kite.(Macmillan Company, New York, (Harold Weisberg,Route 7, Hyattstown, 1968.) Maryland,1967.) White proves the answer is no. This book The photographs used to support the charge contains the error-laced textof the CBSdocu- of a lone assassin are examined and shown to mentary (which is commented upon above havebeen handledwithalackofobjective under Mark Lane’s Citizen’s Dissent). standards. The 140 pages of documents photo- Miscellaneous tions since then for his evaluation of new evi- CHARTS AND MAPS dence.He is extremely well informed. SpatialChartoftheNorthernHalfofDealey Truth Letter.(Bi-weekly.) Plaza.(Cutler Designs, Manchester,Mas- This is, apparently,published by Joachim sachusetts,38 Union Street,1970.) Joesten from his home,P.0.7890, Gutenburg, A superb architectural drawing of the as- Germany.The reviewer has only seen one sassination site,it is absolutely necessary for issue and cannot judge it. checking,measuring,and evaluating informa- tion concerning the physical evidence.The maps and charts of the'Warren Commission LEGAL CASES study are too inaccurate for good research. BriefforPlaintiff-Appellant andJointAppen- dix.In theUnitedStates CourtofAppeals NEWSLETTERSANDNEWSPAPERS fortheDistrictofColumbiaCircuit.No. 71-1026.HaroldWeisbergv.U.S.Depart- Computers and Automation.(Monthly.) ment of Justice. (Byron S. Adams Printing, Beginning in 1970, almost every issue has Washington,1971.) carried a critical article on the assassination. No.71-1026,Brief for the Appellee.Type While some of them are not of the best qual- script. ity, many are excellent and a few are among Reply Brief forPlaintiff-Appellant.Type- the best available.--- PAGE BREAK --- No.71-1026,Brief for the Appellee.Type While some of them are not of the best qual- script. ity, many are excellent and a few are among Reply Brief forPlaintiff-Appellant.Type- the best available. script. These three relateddocuments involve the CTIA Newsletter.(Quarterly.) question of freedom of information.Weisberg The Committee to Investigate Assassina- asked to examine the spectrographic analyses tions,92715th Street,N.W.,Washington,D. eraw data- -bullets, frag reportsandthe C.,issues this information sheet to all mem- ments of bullets,andobjects such as garments bers and interested parties.It summarizes andcurbstones said tohavebeen struck by their legal cases,provides a progress report on bullets-upon which the reports were based. theirfight tohavepertinentevidence released, His request was denied in court on the curious andgives noticesof books and other items grounds of national interest.The written re. ofgeneral information. fusals which were given toWeisberg state that the evidence is part of an “investigative file Midlothian Mirror.(Weekly.) compiledfor law Penn Jones, Jr., the editor of this Texas Since all persons involved are dead, this weekly,began printing critical information groundis equally curious.If theWarren Com- immediately after the assassination.Mluch of mission findings are valid and if the spectro- his work is published in the three volumes of graphictestswerecompletelyandproperly Forgive My Grief.TheMidlothian Mirror performed,such texts should substantiate the of August13,1970,reprints all his work since Commission findings. volume IIl;one must consult his weekly edi- 36