Testimony - Howard Leslie BRENNAN, Marxh 24, 196l, (3H140-61) 184-6; 211) Shaquou sat pue u ogsstuu, oua ssoua tm Jo pury oua uoeq ueuug peg gave represented him asbeing,the Commission would have had little or no pproblem with him. He was described by Cong. Ford as the most impor. tant witness toappear before the Commission in the article.the Cong. signed for LIFE Magazine 0ctober 2, 1964. Brennan is an important witness, but not at all in the sense'sug- gested by Cong.Ford. He is, as pepresented by the Comnission, the only actual eyewitness. He is the only one, acoording to the Commissionls report, able to give a description of the assassin. In the report the Commisaion is careful,aware of Brennan's weakness, to stipulate it does notdepend upon him alone.:The fact is, and the fact becomes clesr in Brennans testimony, that so far as the Commission is concerned and so far as Brennan is concerned, he is, in fact, the only eyewitness. The importance of Brennan as a witness is that he constitutes a witness about the Commission rather than as an eyewitness. I/doubt if by now Brennan actually knows what he did or did not see.He did not seewhat hetestified to andwhat the Commisaion quoted him as having seen。It was a physical impossibility.But the manner in which the Commissian handled Brennan and his testimony, and tspecially what the Commission excludes and ignores in its handling of Brennan,is ample witness to the Commission's approach, bias, methods and integrity.or lackofit。 Actually,Brennan was called tothe stand 3 times in a single day。 By comparison, Constable Weitzman who found the.gun in company with Deputy Booone wa s never called before the commission. Only a time- wasting and unessential examination oftherecords of appearances of all the witnesses will indicate whether this is so, but I doubt very much if the Commission found it necessary to call a single witness 3 times in thecourseofa singledayofhearings。 --- PAGE BREAK ---all the witnesses will indicate whether this is so, but I doubt very much if the Commission found it necessary to call a single witness 3 times in thecourseofa singledayofhearings。 --- PAGE BREAK --- 2-Brennan Toset Brennan'stestimonyin context,at approximately12:45or roughly lo minutes after the assassination,the police broadcast a de- scription of agsuspect。In its report tbe Commission never specifically states the source of thas eyewitness description.There is no evidence source of its eyewitness description。The Commission handledthis situ- was "most probably" the source of the. police broadcast。The importance ofspecific andirrefutableknowledgeofthesourceofthisdescription is hardly:subject to exaggeration。 To cite just one possibility, that of conspiracy。Could a conspirator have given a false description to tne police? Brennan had given astatement tha dayofthe assassination in the sheriff's office.It is in Vo. XIx.on p.47o and is about an half-page long. When he appeared before the Cormission, 4 members, incYuding the Chairman, were present, together with J.Lee Rankin, general counsel; Joseph A.Ball, David W.Belin, and Norman Redlich, assistant counsel, and Charles Murray, "observer". Mr. Belin conducted the examination. Brennan identifies himself as a 45-year-old married steamfitter. cafeteria He had lunch at noon in the saxakwxkaxxat the corner of Main and Record, left at 12:18 and walked to the corner of Houston and Elm,which he estimates took about 4minutes(p.lll).He observed aman having an epileptic seizure until the man was removed by an ambulance,and then "walked over to'this retainer wall of this litile park pool and jumped o sx o d d 0u o Depository Building taken from Dealey Plaza and fron the right of the center of the Depository Building as it is face。 It is Exhibit 477. He is then shown Exhibig478 which he identifies as "That is the retaining wall and myself sitting on it at Houston and Elm。" This picture was --- PAGE BREAK ---ding as it is face。 It is Exhibit 477. He is then shown Exhibig478 which he identifies as "That is the retaining wall and myself sitting on it at Houston and Elm。" This picture was --- PAGE BREAK --- 3-Brennan taken when "the photographer was standing on the front steps of the Texas School Book Depository .o. on the 20th of March." He is then handed "a negative which has been marked as Cmmmission Exhibit l79! and described by Belin as "a negative from a moving picture film. And I will hand you a magnifying glass - the negative has been enlarged. Tpisnegative appearstobeapicture ofthePresidentialmotorcadeon should be pertinent to ask why,especially when thenegativehad already the.negative was. Brennan's reply was, "yes.I am sitting at the same position as I was in the picture taken Friday, with the exception, I he. lieve, my hand is resting on the wall, and Friday mynhand, I believe, ur saat anof “Ttom, 'sfes uTrog 6osuodsor uI " got fu uo Sutaser sem this picture,Exhibit,479,I notice, are not dangling on the front side there,isthatcorrect?"(p.Ki42) Brennan's reply was an abrupt and unqualified denial.He said briefly, "No." He may have had something else in mind, but he actually said that Belin was not correct。Next Belin asked a description of the clothingBrennan was wearing. "Gray khaki work clothes, with a dark gray hard helmet." Belin then says (inaccurately),"Your head Ahere appears to be the highest in the group,a little bit left of center in the upper part of the picture, is that correct?! Beennan affirmed, and he ssid the scene was as he rememberadit。 It is not possible to identify Brennan as Brennan from Exhibit 479. It is not clear enough in the picture.None of the features can be --- PAGE BREAK ---and he ssid the scene was as he rememberadit。 It is not possible to identify Brennan as Brennan from Exhibit 479. It is not clear enough in the picture.None of the features can be --- PAGE BREAK --- 4Brennan distinguished,nor is it possible for me,with a magnifying glsss,to see any evidence that Brennan is, in fact, sitting. I am not saying that Brennan wasn't there; I do not know。I am saying this picture as reproduced doesn!t prove it. I also believe it does not prove he was sittingon thewall。 Conveniently,.when asked what he did, Brennan recalas observing the crowd "and the people in different building windows";which he might, indeed,have done,but it is just.too convenient,just too unlikely。 in which he says, "In particular, I saw-this one man on the sixth floor which left the window to my knawledge a couple of times." When shown Exhibit 477 and asked to circle the "particular window", Breanan replied, "Well, I am confused here, the way this shows. But I believe this is the sixth floor,the way those windows are built there right at the present。 I am confusedwhether this is the same window."Belin who, it would witness that I will come to in a moment, said, "You mean a because some windows are open below it?" and Brennan said,"No.The way the building is built, it seems like this is more or less a long window with a divider in the midale."Belin covered up the blunder fast. What had happened was that,instead of showing a picture already in evidence, the Dillard pictures,with the men in the windows on the 5th floor and the B 6th window open at the right place and with the. boxes stacked up,the Commission had made a photograph which showed only 4 open windows in the entire south face of the building。 Three of these are where the men were,the 4th is at the extreme end of the same flpor. The window at which Brennan said he saw this man was left closed and blinds or curtains behind it seemed to be drawn. But note that Brennan --- PAGE BREAK ---is at the extreme end of the same flpor. The window at which Brennan said he saw this man was left closed and blinds or curtains behind it seemed to be drawn. But note that Brennan --- PAGE BREAK --- 5-Brennan was surprised that the windows Φ peared in pairs。Although it is not a major point,this would seem to bear heavily on his credibility as a witness.Here is tho man who looked and saw all of the things he said se9, but he never noticed that the entire building is built with the windowsinpaira。 Asked by Belin to mark the window in whieh the man was,Bfennan did and marked it with the letter "A".He then marked with a"B" the window below in which he said he saw the colored men. You guessed it, Larry. He was wrong. It was not easy to be as wrong as he was, which is completely wrong; but Brennan, this unimpeachable character,this "most important" witness to face the Commission, was more than egual to the task.In fact, he could completely upset the law of averages。 Shown below the 6th floor windows, on the 5th floor, are adjoining pairs of windows with 3 of the 4 open。Apparently the rehearsal of Brennan was sone thing beyond his intellectual capacity. The only one of the 4 windows that was completely and 1o0 percent wrong was the one he marked as the one at which the colored men were.Of them,Brennan down,which is the fifth floor,colored guys。In particular,I only y for him to have identified 2 of the 3 Negroes, presumably totally unknown to him (I dont suppose the pictures that were available helped in his identification at all), but in Dillard Exbibit C, in bhe report on p.66, clearly there are 2 open windows below the one from which Oswald is alleged to have fired the shot.There is one Negro in each of the two。 On the day of the assassination, in fact, moments only after the assas- sination, as is shown clearly in Dillard Exhibit D, on p.67 of the report, --- PAGE BREAK ---is one Negro in each of the two。 On the day of the assassination, in fact, moments only after the assas- sination, as is shown clearly in Dillard Exhibit D, on p.67 of the report, --- PAGE BREAK --- 6-Brennan 3 of these 4 windows were open,the same 3 that were open on Exhibit 477。 Only one was closed,the same one that was closed on Exhiibit 477; and the closed one,thatls the one Brennan picked。In the 4th open window there also was another Negro employee looking out. This is made clear in Exhibit 485 which appears in the report on p.69.It is part of the Commission'sreconstruction. When you have friends like Brennan, who needs enemies? Not that he doesn't want to be helpful.Note the next paragraph a distance of Eim and Main Street (a physical impossibility- they parallel each other), as it came on to Houston and turnedthe corner at Houston and Elm, going down the incline towards the railroad underpass. And after the President had passed my position, I really couldn't say how that I positively thought was a backrire." Whoever described abackfire as a"crack"and whyshould a witness abackfire? He thought it was a firecracker thrown from the Depository (p.l43)。 Naturally, this caused him to look up. "And this man that I saw pre vious was aiming for his μ last shot." Rax Perhaps a litlle apprehensively, Belin asked, "Would you describe just exactly what you saw when you saw him this last time?! Brennan to the rescue. Hels going to be the big hero and prove everything. He said, "well, as it appeared to me he wes standing up and resting against the left window sill with gun shouldered to his right shoulder, holding the gun with his left hand and taking positive ain and fired his last shot。 As I calculate a couple of seconds. He drew the --- PAGE BREAK ---sill with gun shouldered to his right shoulder, holding the gun with his left hand and taking positive ain and fired his last shot。 As I calculate a couple of seconds. He drew the --- PAGE BREAK --- 7-Brinnan 8.S gun back from the window xn though he was drawing it bacl bo his side and his mark, and then he disappeared。 And, at the same moment, I was diving wall that is a little higher on the Houston side." If the man bad been standing up, dirty as those windows were, Brennan could have seen nothing much above his knees. If he was standing, he couldn!t possibly have fired the rifle except through the window. The Dillard photographs prove this window was open only half-way in the bot- tom half, or only a quarter at most of the entire window area was open. Tho windcw sill was perhaps a foot from the floor. How he could have been standing and resting against theleft window sill.asBrennan de scribed is beyond imagination.The onlynthing that is left possible to imagine is that, in rehearsing his testimony,he wam!t edited a little。 And in eddition to all of that,the Commission'sownreconstruction shows that, &t the very least, in the course of firing, the assassin would have bean blocked from view by the building.In fact, it is doubt- ful if, from the Commission's recm struction, Brennan could have seen even the assassin's hands.But ifphe could,it is notlikely that he saw any- thing past the wrist.(Exhibit 887, report p.99; and this picture was taken with theboxesremoved.) if it had a scope, he said, "I did not observe a scope." Obviously, the scope had to be visible, even if the face werenlt。 And if the face had been visible, then the scope had to be more visible for, of course, the face was behind the scope. Perhaps worried about Brennan's testimony of the man standing up, Belin asked, "what ao you believe was the position of the people on the fifth floor that you saw -M standing or sitting?" --- PAGE BREAK ---worried about Brennan's testimony of the man standing up, Belin asked, "what ao you believe was the position of the people on the fifth floor that you saw -M standing or sitting?" --- PAGE BREAK --- 8.Brennan windowsill leaning out." Belin then wanted to know, "At the time you Brennan to therencue. "well,Icould see-atonetimehecame tothe window and he sat sideways on the window siil. Thatwasprevious si to Prelsdent Kennedy getting there.And I could see practically his whole body, from his hips up.But at the time he was firing A the gun, a possibility from his belt up." the sizth floor. Entirely aside from the fact that it was bloclked aby boxes, it wouid not have been possible,because the window was halfway closed,for Brennan to have seen anything ir the man had sat in the window sill, which is a complete impossibility. Exemine, for example in the parallel windows at the extreme eastendofthe5th floor,oneof whom is airectly underneath the assassin's window. These men, as the Conmission's reconstruetion shows, were actually on their knees. Yet even on their knews, with the windows open almost as wide as they will go, their heads are well above the midline of the lower half of pthe window..They are not only on their mees,but as Exhibit 485 of p.69 ofthe report shows,at least one of themhashis bodyat a considerable anglewhich shortensthe distance it wouldoccupyon the vertical plane。 In the light of this,is it necessary to cormment on Brennan's"Icould see, practically his whole body, froin his hips up?"y It doesnit get any better when Belin asks how much of the gun 7G Brennan saw. "I calculate X& to 85 percent", Brennan replied, although a few questions above he had not seen the telescopic sight, which would have been visible with a lot less than 70 to 85 percentshowing. --- PAGE BREAK ---X& to 85 percent", Brennan replied, although a few questions above he had not seen the telescopic sight, which would have been visible with a lot less than 70 to 85 percentshowing. --- PAGE BREAK --- 9-Brennan IfBelin was tying to remind Brennan of somethirg Brennan had for- gotten, in the next exchange, he didn't succeed。 His que stion was "Now, ug to the time ofq the shots,did you observe anything else that you Brennan replied, "well, not of q any importance. I don't remembe? any- thing else except - ". Possibly by this time Belin was afraid for he interrupted to ask, "Let me ask you this. How many shots did you hear?" Brennan again was direct and to the point, "Positively two. I do not recall a second shot - ", at which point Belin kept it from getting out of hand by saying,"By a second shot, you mean a middle shot betwecn the time/you heard the first mise and the last noise?! Mr.Murray. the observer, was there; but if he was doing any ob- serving,he wasn't in Oswald's interest. If Brennan heard.2 shots,how could he talk about a shot between s right.I don't know what made mefthink that there was firecrackers throwed out of the Book Store unless I did hear the second shot,because Ipositively thought the first shot wasa backfire,and subconsciously I must have heard a second shot, but I do not recall it. I could not swear.toit。" Who can blame Belin for the hasty switch, "could you describe the man you saw in the window on the sixth floor?n "To my best description, a man in his early thirties, fair complexion, slender but neat, neat slender, possibly 5-foot 10," Brennan said. "About what weight?" Belin prompted, with only slightly more success, for Brennan replied, "oh, at - I calculated, I think, from l60 to 175 pounds。" Still pulling it out,Belin wanted to know,"A white man?"(p.l44) --- PAGE BREAK ---ted, with only slightly more success, for Brennan replied, "oh, at - I calculated, I think, from l60 to 175 pounds。" Still pulling it out,Belin wanted to know,"A white man?"(p.l44) --- PAGE BREAK --- 10-Brennan Brennan agreed. Nowletus corpare thiswith the description in the affidavit Brennan signed in the sherirf!s office on November 22 (19 H470); whereas above hehaddeclined tosayhowfar the Presidentiscarhad gone, in the affidavit he said "about 5o yards from the intersoction." the Presidentisback was in line dith the lastwindow I havepeviously described ...". The last window he had pre viously described was the in window on the very corner or the building,the window Rxau which the alleged assassin was, and a window that the Presidential car passed be- fore/it completed making its turn. His description was,"a white man in/his early thirties, slender,nice looking,slender,and.would weighy about 165 to 175pounds.He had on light colored clothing,but deti nitely not a suit." No height is given in the original affidavit. But Zhe description broadcast.by the police the Commission has found (report,p.l44) "most probably" was Brennan's.The Cormmission at this point in the report noted the discrepancy in weight between Brennan's 2versions,and adrits that the height was omitted。 Then how didthe police get'the height for their descriptions? Even inquoting Brennan in the report on p.llt,the Commission eeits his testimomy and puts it within quotation marks.The other editorial arrangements make it seem as though Brennan was a precise and accurate observer, and he was any- thing but that。 Brennan was closer to hic original version in testifying about the clothing which he described as "light colored clothes, more of a khaki color." Leave out the "khaki" and itls pretty close to his original affidavit which said, "He had on light colored clothing but definitely not a suit." --- PAGE BREAK ---red clothes, more of a khaki color." Leave out the "khaki" and itls pretty close to his original affidavit which said, "He had on light colored clothing but definitely not a suit." --- PAGE BREAK --- 1lBrennan The Cormissicn, which was careful in teh report not to quote the police broadcast,ignores another and important part of this broadcast. There are other minor differences, such as Brennan's "in his early thirties" as compared to the police broadcast of "approximatagy 3o". But the important thing the Commission has deliberately ignored was indicated by Bronnan himself in backing off from any description of the weapon.In restricting itself to Brennan's alleged description of the alleged assassin, the Commission was able to ignore this.However, the police broadcast on Channel l at ay time that cannot be precisely computed before 12:l46 also includes "armed with what is thought to be a3030 rif1e."(17H 397) Belin returned to Brernan!s longest speech thus far,at the top of p.ll4, which he concl uded by saying, "And, at the same moment, I was diving off of that firewall and tothe right for bullet protection.o to ask Brennan why he jumped. Brennan explained, "Well, it occurred to me that there might bemore than one person, that it was a plot which could mean several people.and.I knew beyond reasonable doubt that there were going to be bullets flying from every direction."What Brennan "knea beyond "reasonable doubt", as a matter of fact, never did happen. What Belin has succeeded in doing here is drawsing attention away fran a much more significant flaw in the earlier testimony of Brennan about diving off that wall.The "at the same moment" that Brennan was talking about, while he was diving off the wall, he was, according to the testimony,watching the witness and observing what he had testified to。 About Brennan, it is almost believable, but in order to have accom- plished this feat, he necessarily had to have eyes on both sides of his body.He could not at one and the sane time be observing an assassin to the north and hurling his body to the south.have accom- plished this feat, he necessarily had to have eyes on both sides of his body.He could not at one and the sane time be observing an assassin to the north and hurling his body to the south. --- PAGE BREAK --- 12-Bheanan Apparently Brennan was able to overcome this first of his fears officers running toward the west side of the building,he said,"I knew I had to get someone quick to tell them where the man was. So I ran or Iwalked-thero is.a possibilityI ran,because I have the habit of, when something has to be done in a hurry,I run.(what a picture this ofothers)And there was one officer standing at the corner of the Texas Book Store on the street.!Because "It didn't seem to me he was going in any direction,”Brennan asked him toget"someone in charge,a Sece t Service man or an FBI." No ordinary cop would do for Brennan.He had togoright to thetop。 Does this suggest a reason the Conmission has carefully avoided printing any of the numerous pictures available of the area Brennan described, inmnediately in front of the Depository, where he talked to this poaiceman?Is it possible a witness other than Brennan might be identified talking to a police official who might also be identified? But if Brennan is to be believed,the policeman did take him to the Secret Service,for he said that after the policeman "had to give some orders or something on the east side of the building on Houston Street (maybe it wasnit just an ordinary everydsy policeman). And then he had taken me to,I believe, Mr.Sorrels, an automobile sitting in front of the Texas Book Store..o..related my information and there was a few minutes of discussion, and Mr. Sorrels had taken me then across the street to the sheriffls building." Asked"Didyou describe theman that you saw in the window?",the very positive Mr.Brennan who has been so excessively definite about everything else, could say only, "Yess I be- lieve I did." Now we have the description that was "most probably" hadgivenit。ow?",the very positive Mr.Brennan who has been so excessively definite about everything else, could say only, "Yess I be- lieve I did." Now we have the description that was "most probably" hadgivenit。 --- PAGE BREAK --- 13-Brennan It will be interesting to check this against the ststements by SorrelZs. (p.l65) AsthetwoNegroe'shehadmentionedseeingin thewindowsdashed from the building,Brennan said he identified them and "Mr.Sorrels or the Secret Service man stopped them." There is no stopping Brennan. Whenasked "Is there anything else now up to the time you got down to the Dallas Police Station?" he said, "Well, nothing except that up until that time, through my entire life, I could never remember what a colored person looked Like if he got out ofmy sight.AndIalways thoughtthat-ifIhad toidentifyacolored person I could not. But by coincidence that one time I did recognize those two boys." However, he doesn't recall whether these two Negroes said in his presence that they had, in fact,been in the 5th loor windows He went to the lineup where he was introduced to "Captain Fritz.in Mr.Sorrels'office".Here Belin backtracked to ask/y if Brennan knew the name of the officer to whom he spoke outside the Book Depository. Brennan didntt.(p.ll6) Then asked if hewas sure of the names of theSecret Service men he talked to, Brennan said, "I do not know the other man's name." Then Belin:"You believe one of them was Sorrels?" Brennan:"I believe one of them was Sorrels。" Brennan: "That is at the building/" Whatever Mr. Belin was about to say for the record, he didnt, for he said merely, "yes, sir." Another obvious lawyer's trick followed immediately when Mr.Belin said, "By the way, Mr. Brennan, I note that you have glasses with you heretoday. Were you wearing glasses at the time of bhe incident that you related here?"y --- PAGE BREAK ---diately when Mr.Belin said, "By the way, Mr. Brennan, I note that you have glasses with you heretoday. Were you wearing glasses at the time of bhe incident that you related here?"y --- PAGE BREAK --- 14-Brennan From the picture referred to ean ier,unless Brennan wore frame less glasses,it didn't seem as though he wore any.But it gave Brennan his platform. His reply was, "No. I only use glesses to see fine print and more especially the Bible and blueprint."Then Belin elicits the This left Brennan's vision not as good as it was。 There is no questioning about the nature of this acaident..It nay have just been an accident, but it shouid not have been an occupational one because Brennan is a steamfitter. Butadded tothe otherreports coming outor Dalaas about.some of the more important witnesses,the thrgets to the Euins' family,the shcoting orWarren Reynolds thrugh the head, and even in acity where one hospital has 4 or5 gunshots wounds a night,this seems like an unusually high attrition rate arong the CommissionIswitnesses。 After a page of aiversion,Mr。Belin goes back to Friday night at . lineup at which he said there were 7or possibly only 6.Asked what he said, he replied, "I told Mr. Sorrels and Captain Fritz at that time that Oswald.br the man in the lineup thetI identified locking more like a and he also admits that he had,in the meantime, seen Oswald's picture. (p。14.7) Pushed a little bit - it was necesssry for Belin to do so - and asked "Nof, is there anything else you told the officers ...", Brennan concedes, "vell, I told them I could not make a positive identification." Aue Tte4 cto4e1 roaa nof p1p “4eu4 woua pto4 nof uoumu 'sfes uoug u1tog officer or investigating person anything different?" to which Brennan --- PAGE BREAK ---d not make a positive identification." Aue Tte4 cto4e1 roaa nof p1p “4eu4 woua pto4 nof uoumu 'sfes uoug u1tog officer or investigating person anything different?" to which Brennan --- PAGE BREAK --- 15_Brennan replied he had. He doesn't recall when, he won!t swaar to the name of the person to whom he did it,but he thinks it was a Secret Sorvice man named Wiliiams from Houston.But "he could have been an FBI."This is Brennanls version ofowhatothe agmt told hin,"you said you coulan!t make a positive identification./ Did you do that for security reasons personally, or couldn't you?" Brennan's version here of Brennan's -x ue dog pnsy nJtosAu pue fttueg fu - suoseot fatanoes ctog ssot to planation, it was this°"I believe at that time, and I still believe it was a Conmunist activity, and I felt like there haanlt been more than one eyewitness, and if it got to be a known fact that I wasn an eyewitness, my family or I, , either one, might not be safe." Brennanadmitsheknew Oswald had alreadybeen arrestedfor the murder of officer Tippit and there was no prospect of his being released. Butwhat had happened to change his mind he isasked,and he replied, "After Oswald was killed, I was relieved quite a bit that as far as pres- sure on myseif of somebody not wanting me to identify anybody, there was no longer that immeaiate danger." Fe is not asked why, then, he aidnt immedig&ely go to the police and te11 them.(p.148) when asked how far he was foom the windcw, Brennan is not the man in to say he didn't know or that/his presence the Commission has measured 18 it; instead,he said,"well,εt that time,I calcuaated ll0-foot at an angle. But closer surveillance I believe it will run close to l22 to 126 feet at an angle." When Belin explained that they together had paced the distance the previous Friday, Brennan wouidnit let him finish the sentence.At the point where Belin gets to the approximate distance, Brennan interrupts to say, "93-foot。" --- PAGE BREAK ---aced the distance the previous Friday, Brennan wouidnit let him finish the sentence.At the point where Belin gets to the approximate distance, Brennan interrupts to say, "93-foot。" --- PAGE BREAK --- 16_Brcnnan Cong.Ford interrupts at this point to say that he thinks Brennan gives him Exhibit 36l and tells him that if he turns it upside dcwn 1t will work out fine。(Note to Larry:'This is not a joke;its literally true.X They just made it upside down.)Brennan does it, including the (6i7T°C) After he finished putting the marks on, including where he talked to the police, the Secret Service, otc., Belin asks, "Now, are these accurate or approximate locations, Mr.Brennan?"Brennan!s disappoint- ment, and perhaps a feeling of lese majeste, is clear in his statement, "Well, donlt you have photographs of ne talking to the SecrotService men right here?" Belin didn't. "You should have," Brennan informed him. Xk less xkaxa than helpful. He continued, explaining that while he didnt knou balieve Me. Lish who requested that he cut those films or get them cut of the FBI. I believeyou might know about then. Souebody cut those films, because a number of times later the same filns were shown, and that part was cut." Lish, he said, was with the FBI: Belin thanled him very much for his information and immediately changed the subject. But in any event, ie Brennanls to be belicved, not cnly Gid the police know that the shots bad come fron the 6th floor window, but also the FBI and the Secret Service, and irnediately. Yet there is no evidence that either of these agencies or any agents ever saw to it that an --- PAGE BREAK ---ome fron the 6th floor window, but also the FBI and the Secret Service, and irnediately. Yet there is no evidence that either of these agencies or any agents ever saw to it that an --- PAGE BREAK --- :7.Brennan immmediate systcmatic soarch was made or saw to itAthat the building was sealed.I doubt if any of the FBI, Secret Service or police people are anxious for the pictures to be found and for them to be identified asresponsible for nct causing an immediate search ofthe 6th floor arca and for not immediately quarantining the buiiding. (p.l50) Belin, who hadn't really wanted to go intoExhibit 36l to begin with, appears finished with it now, but I am not.I want.to point out that among the inaccuracies in this chart are the failure to locate the arcade and the wall'which are the objects of such extensive refer- ence in testimony,depositions and exhibits by so many vitnesses the Commlssion chose to ignore or disbelieve, who identified the area of these two stmuctures as the sourde of at least the initialbullat。 With a magnirying glass. Thore are 2 picturos showing large areas that are approximately 1 inch by l inch.obviously, they also show nothing。 mark Bwennan is then asked to mak his route insofar as it is possible upon Exhibit l78, which he does,and by the time all of this rlgemarole is over, 2 pages have been wasted. They contribute nothing. Rut here he alters his story about what he did to tale protection from the shots。He didnit go over the wall to the south, ho went around it to the east。He isithen asked to mark the spot he went arter tho ficer with the letter "r",but I don't see them on this exhibit, even witha megnifyincglass. Thenpe is askedto shot on the picture the spot "which is where you said you went to the car". He tten points out a place (p.l5l) which is the wrong place because it ia on the wrong street, and when Belin eorrects him, he says, "oh, is that right?" and then says that Belin is correct.When they finaily decide on the place,p.l5l) which is the wrong place because it ia on the wrong street, and when Belin eorrects him, he says, "oh, is that right?" and then says that Belin is correct.When they finaily decide on the place, --- PAGE BREAK --- 18-Brennan also Brennan is told to mark it with an "r" which xsay does not appear on Exhibit477. Belin next wants to know if, when Brennan sau the gun in the window, "did you see any objects of any kind in the window, or near the window?" Unhelprully yelpful, Brennan roplied, "Yes.Through the window, which boxes." Brennan's oyes certainly were good before he got sandblasted! and The picture shous the tip edge of a boz xa 8 cavern of blackness beyond it.Adlitionally, Brennan was looking up at a rather steep angle; nothing shous through any or the windows, and the window he's talking about, only the bottom half of the bottom half was open. Next Belin shows him Ezhibits l80 and l8l, pictures of the Deposl- tory!s south wall showing the windows in question. Lxhibit h82 isI an enlargement of l81. Belin begins by pushing his luck too far,.end asks Brennan, "tirst of all, on Exhibits h81 end 482, do you recognize any two persons pf these reagku in the fifth flonr window as people you saw tbere?" Brennan said, "No; I do not recognize 太hmeZux them. As positita identi fication I cannot recognize them."Then he corrects himself because it is obvious he muat heve known them, and says, "Now,I see where there is & possibility I did make a mistake.I believe these two colored boys was in this windou, end I believe I showed on that other oxhibit that they were in this window." Belin wants to drop it; he says, "A1l right.y I am going to hand you now - " That's as far as he got before ouc 9toa fou4 qou4 s1 pTus I quzua ftuo oui, *fes c4 po4dnrtoqur uauueng this about them, but he had incorrectly marked i an exhibit to this effect. Belin understood and helped him correct the first mistake by saying, "You --- PAGE BREAK ---i, *fes c4 po4dnrtoqur uauueng this about them, but he had incorrectly marked i an exhibit to this effect. Belin understood and helped him correct the first mistake by saying, "You --- PAGE BREAK --- 19Bonnan But evcn with the aetual photograph taken at the timo in front of hin, Bronnan is beyond help. He says, "rhat I am not positivo of. I just remember that they were over one window fron below him,which at that tine I might have thought this was one window over." Prom the reconrd, in the language, if you'il ezcuse the expression, it is not possiblo to untangle this.. It is nonetheless clear that the "most important" witness aidn't know. what he was talking about and couldn't even be led into rectifying his error when it was called to it when he had the incontrovertible rgk proof of his orror in his hands. By nou, Belin has ta help him. He says, "All right. Let me ask you this.On Ezhibit l81,does the condition o the'openirg of the windoas November 22?" Brennan replies, "yes,/Ehese do." Pelin said, "you are. pointing to the fifth.floor windows now?"(p.l52) Brennan entangles himself further. "But I'don't recallethis Window at the time or the shooting being that low." Hith the windows in which the colored boys being open in one case, as wide as possible,and in the othor case, almost that wide,poor Belin Rxzanar could do nothing but say,"Now, by this window you are pointing to the window on the sixth floor?n the letten "A" around this window.I Instead of dropping it thore,he asks Brennan, "how high do you belicve it was open?" and Brennan replies, "I believe that at the time he was firing, it was open just like this.", windowsonthe which Belin interprets in English as "just like the/firth floor inmedi- atelybelow?n "rhat is right," says Brennan. Belin shifts to another blunder ard asks, "I note in window "A" there appear to be some boxes --- PAGE BREAK ---lish as "just like the/firth floor inmedi- atelybelow?n "rhat is right," says Brennan. Belin shifts to another blunder ard asks, "I note in window "A" there appear to be some boxes --- PAGE BREAK --- 20Brennan in the window. To bhe bost of your recolleetion, whnt is ths faet as: ornot to whether/khusa thoso boaea as shown in this exhibit appear to be simi lar to the ones you saw on Jovenber 22?u He should have known bettar than totryto straightenthat one out. Bronnan's roply was, "No; I could see moro boxes." rIa the window or behind tho window? Belin wants to know, and Bren nan answezs, "Behind the window.Belin then says,"I em talking in che window itsele", and Bronnan says, "No, no.That is I donit remenber abox ia thewirdow,these boxes I remenbor are stacked up betind the window, and bhey wore zigzaggod,kind of step down,and thore wus a spacb it looked lire back of here." 8 on Sursugod oxn nof mon, "gfes xs pue 4pua sgotdroguT rrteg space which would bo on the cast slde,is thet right?ana Brennan says that is right. Belin then says, "whon you say you dontt roneuber . Ican seo those boxes there non.I dont know whether you can seo them or not. It seems like I can seo the boxes in thab picturo.An I rightg What coula Belln say?He replied,"I don't know,.sir.Ican'b soo them on Exhibit h71. Zhat could be the dirty window here." Brennan says, "Rere they are here. Thoso bozes thore." Belin, knowing full woll that Exhibit g482,to waich Brennan has pointod, is a very considerable on largonent and nonetheless the boxes in the baokground are oven there barely visible, says, "veil, here is Bxhibit h82. First cf all,1 se8 a box on Exhibit h62,right in the window."Brennan aatd, FYes; I don't renouber that box." How this is a box that was right in the sun right in the front of the bindow. fa surgoq ou uogegatas rnrssooons e uodn seyTaqs Arroury urtog asking. "Do you recall that it definitely was not there, or just you don't recall whether it was or was not there." Even the court reportersurgoq ou uogegatas rnrssooons e uodn seyTaqs Arroury urtog asking. "Do you recall that it definitely was not there, or just you don't recall whether it was or was not there." Even the court reporter --- PAGE BREAK ---rnrssooons e uodn seyTaqs Arroury urtog asking. "Do you recall that it definitely was not there, or just you don't recall whether it was or was not there." Even the court reporter --- PAGE BREAK --- 21-Brennan knew this wasnt kh question。Brennan sa_id,"I do not recall that being there. So, therefore, I could not say it definitely wasn't there." Belin sums it up, "You cannot say whether it was or was not?" and Brennan says, "No." Belin then asks him to yark Exhibit l82 with an arrow at the point where he saw, or thinks he saw, boxes. When that is done,he launches into an explanation of the source of exhibits 480,481 and l82,what his plans are with regard to the photographer, when he is going to Dallas and what he is going to do there, and explains also the antecedents of exhibit 479,one of the frames of the Zapruder film, end then switches Brennan entirely away from the disaster of the boxes,what he sawland what he didn't see。For Brennan has succeeded inswearing that the onlything he likely could have seen with any clarity in the window is the thing he didn't see。 He should have left the windows alone, too.But he didn't;.he asked if "from the time you first saw the Fresidential motorcade turning north on Houston from Main, did you observe the window from which you say you saw the last shot fired at any time prior to the time you saw the rifle in the window?" Brennan said he did. Belin then says,"well, what I am saying is this.You saw the motorcade turn?"(p.l53) Mr.Brennan, "No; not after I saw the motorcade,I aid not observe a man or rifle in the window/" of course, this constituted a denial of everything hehad said。.Belin then saidg "Did you observe the window atalluntilafteryou heard that first sound which was abackfire or firecracker,at least you thought it was?"Brennan, who had said heid seen a man in the window 2 or 3 times, replied,"No." Belin starts all over again. He says, "well, let the record be clear. The first sound motorcycle"。Belin asked,"And then you later said something Aabout aman in the window 2 or 3 times, replied,"No." Belin starts all over again. He says, "well, let the record be clear. The first sound motorcycle"。Belin asked,"And then you later said something Aabout a --- PAGE BREAK ---or 3 times, replied,"No." Belin starts all over again. He says, "well, let the record be clear. The first sound motorcycle"。Belin asked,"And then you later said something Aabout a --- PAGE BREAK --- 22_Brennan firecracker。Did that have reference to the first.shot, or sone thing in between the first and last?"Actually, in Brennan's earlier testi- mony (p.ll3) the "backfire" and the "firecracker" were both one. First, he thought it was a "backfire" and then a "firecracker"。 His reply to the question was, "I positively thought that the first shot was a back- fire of a motorcycle。And then something made me think that someone was throwing firecrackers from the Texas Book Store, and a possibility it was the second shot..But I glanced up or looked up and I saw this man taking aim for his last shot.The first shot and last shot is my only positive recolleetion of two shots." Obviously, if he heard three noises, kkaugbk the first one was a backfire or firecracker,the next one was the first shot and the next onewas not onlythesecond shot but it was alsothelastshot. At this point Mr. McCloy wants his own kind of clarification, and asks,"Did you see the flash of what was either the second or the third shot?" Brennan didn't. MeCloy persisted, "Could you see that he had discharged the fifle?" Brennans reply was not too simple. It was, "No. For some reason I did not get an echo at any time. The first shot was positive and clear and the last shot was positive and clear, with no echo on my part." I don?t know what this has to do with seeing, but MeCloy said, "Yes." And when Brennan says, "last shot," he means what to him you saw him aimn which Brennan said he did, and then McCloy said, "Did you see the rifle discharge, did you see the recoil or the flash?" Brennandidn!t。 Brennan always wanted to be perfect。 When Dulles asked if he could see "who or what he was aiming at?", Brennan replied, "Subconsciously I knew what he was firing at.But immediately I looked towards wherenan always wanted to be perfect。 When Dulles asked if he could see "who or what he was aiming at?", Brennan replied, "Subconsciously I knew what he was firing at.But immediately I looked towards where --- PAGE BREAK --- 23.-Brennan President Kennedy's car should be, and there was something obstructing my view. I could not see the President or his car at that time.% And that I should have been able to see it.I could not see it." This is office,he does not mention taking hisgeyes off the window from the time of the second shot, or as it was to him, the first shot, having ore looked up just befan that, thinking someone was throwing firecrackers, and hef certainly implies he never took his eyes off,concluding his affidavit in this respect by saying, "I was looking at the man in this window at.the time of the last explosion.He then described how the man let the gun down to his side,as he says he saw it, etc. Nor has he referred to looking in the direction of the President in his testi- mony up to this point.Belin asks Brennan if he remembered "on one of your interviews bith the FBI, they record a statement that you estimated the shots were fired ay appproximately 90 yards.", or approximately 3 times the distance it actually was. Belin continues, "At that time did you make that statement to the FBI - and this would be on 22 November. To the best ofyour recollection?" If it was on 22 November, it was not in the statement he made in the sheriffis office, unless he made more thanoneandonlyoneisused. Brennan cannot make a mistake. He says, "There was a mistake in the FBI recording there." He said that he was talking about the dis- tance from the gun to President Kennedy, the President Kennedy he couldn!t C see. This obvious error he explained as follows: "No; I dould not (see him)。 But I could see before and aater." Belin then re fers to another part of this interview quoting Brennan as having attended a lineup, "at --- PAGE BREAK ---ned as follows: "No; I dould not (see him)。 But I could see before and aater." Belin then re fers to another part of this interview quoting Brennan as having attended a lineup, "at --- PAGE BREAK --- 24Brennan He asked if that was an accurate recording. Brennan says,"Yes; I be- lieve - " and here Belin interrupts him, asking if that part of the FBI statement is correct, to which Brennan agrees. Belin then says, "What Belin immediately interrupts with a "No" which he follows this way: "what was the fact. Could you or could’ you not actually identify this person as the man you saw firing the rifle?" Brennan said, "I believed I could with all fairness and sincerity.As you asked me the question before, had I saw those pictures of Oswald prior, which naturally I don't though know whether it confused me or made me feel as kkwgkx I was taking unfair advantage or what。But with all fairness,I could have positively iden- tified the man." Belin then refers to a December 17 interview with the in a lineup you felt positive identification was not necessary, because it was your understanding that Oswald had already been charged with the you had observedhispicture ontelevisionprior tothe timeofidentifi- cation,and that that tended to cloud any identification/made of Oswald you at the police department.Now,does this December 17 interview accg- rately record whst you told the FBI with regard to that matter of identie fication?" Brennan said, "I believe it does." Note the conflict here, with his earlier teatimony about fearing he and his family might become. the victims of a Communist plot. Note also he said that as soon as Oswald --- PAGE BREAK ---it does." Note the conflict here, with his earlier teatimony about fearing he and his family might become. the victims of a Communist plot. Note also he said that as soon as Oswald --- PAGE BREAK --- 25-Brennan was killed, he no longer had that fear and the fear was the only thing that kept him from making positive identification. Brennan was also interviewed by the FBI on January 7.In para- phrasing it,Belin indicates how either he or the FBI helped Brennan along with the problem of Brennan's having seen Oswald's picture on not helppyou retain the original impression of the man in the.window With the rifle, but that upon seeing Lee Harvey Oswald in the police in the window.Now,is that what you told the man on January 7-that Oswald most resembled the man that you had seen in the window?"zxRaxkawka区 Does mkxzk Brennan agreed,foalowing which Belin wanted to know,"Sogas that mean you could notgive him apositive identification at that time,but could merely say he most resembled the man in the window?n Before continuing, I want to note that seeing Oswald on television, hel in the context of not htzping Brennan retain his original impression, did help him know who the police wanted identified。 What is the legal situationwith respecttoalineupin which themanknown tobewanted bythe police has his picture broadcast aswidely as possible and in which the peopleasked tomakethe identification in thelineuphave seen thispicture? Butforpersonal reasons I didn't feellike that at thatmomentit was compulsory and I did not want to give apositive identification at that time。 This is in reference to the Jauary 7 interview.At that time Brennan!s personal reasons, which he alleged to have been fear of Com- munist retaliation,no longer existed as he himselo had testified and