clup THE SPY WHO LOVED HIM Before he died, twasSeptember1955.In thebackyard of117PrinceSt.in Michael Scott's Old Town Alexandria,a newborn baby boy, swaddled ina U.SDEPARTMENTOR blanket,was handed to the man whowould become his father. father wrote his 0 LWinstonMcKinleyScottwas46,handsome,self-assured,his memoirs. Now eyes as impenetrable as the secrets they protected.The new dad Michael wants proud.His wife,Paula,beautiful and doomed,hovered nearby.A to read them. KodakBrownie camera clicked. And so the moment stil lives,40 years later.Michael Scott ex- There's just one tracts the black-and-white photograph from one of many family al- problem. The CIA bums scattered on thefloor of the study in his Califormia home.In the picture,Michael is the baby.Today heis an easygoing middle has them and agedguy in jeans and abaseball capwho directs made-for-TVmov- won't cough them ies. His adoptive parents are both dead. Old pictures.Passports.Birth certifi- up. It seems cates.A slender volume of love poems Michael Scott'sfather hada more that his father once wrote.Michael Scott keeps them all in plastic boxes, interesting job than Michael ever knew. his connections to a childhood he is just now beginning to understand.Michael By Jefferson Morley Scott has been digging into his past. WashingtonPostStaffWriter What he has stumbled into are shad: owy catacombs of Cold War intrigue. --- PAGE BREAK --- Michael Scott has discovered that his adoptive father was not,as the son once believed, a State Department functionary. He was a spy, and not a minor one.Winston Scott was a master of American espionage, for more thana decade the CIA's chief operative in MexicoCity. In the 1960s,Mexico City was the UCasablanca of the Cold War,a sanctu SeeCIA SON,F5,Col.1 From far left,the adoption scene:Win and Paula Scott and baby Michael In their back yard on Prince Street;Michael today.. BYTODDBIGELOWFORTHEWASHINGTONPOST --- PAGE BREAK ---nctu SeeCIA SON,F5,Col.1 From far left,the adoption scene:Win and Paula Scott and baby Michael In their back yard on Prince Street;Michael today.. BYTODDBIGELOWFORTHEWASHINGTONPOST --- PAGE BREAK --- Winston McKinley Scott, loving father and master spy. His ID card,far right, described him as a Foreign Service officerretired from theState Department. --- PAGE BREAK ---CIA SON,FromF1 call:acompromised situation." ary fot-spies, revolutionaries, assassins and provoca- The:Paper Chase teursScott was,by all accounts,a brilliant proconsul, the confidant of three Mexican presidents,a personal fa- ByMichael Scott's first birthday in 1956, Win and voriteofLyndon Johnson's,the objectofleftistdeath PaulaScottwere livingin a grand house onPaseo de la threats,a puppet master of the counterintelligence craft. Reforina,themainboulevard ofMexicoCity.Therewasa He presided over hundreds if not thousands of covert palmfree inthemiddleof theopen-air livingroom,anda CIA operations during the time of dramaticdefections, intricate surveillanceprojects,treacherouscovertopera was rnostly devoted to Michael's food.The Scotts,wor- tions and,intriguingly,Lee Harvey Oswald’ssuspicious ried aboutthewaterinMexico City,bathed theboywith visitto Mexico City shortly before theKennedy assassi- bottlefl drinking water. nation. Michael's earliest childhood memories ofWin are fond “When you do something like this,says the son of his and rnagical.He recalls his father holding him up at an research,“the pathi you are walking along may lead to embassyfunctionin the summerof1962toshakehands something that‘s going to destroy the image of the per- with thepresident of theUnitedStates,JohnF.Kennedy. son who you want to think highly of. That's always a His recollections of Paula are minimal. risk." Twish I had more memories of her,he says squinting. You wouldnotbereading about any of thisifMichael The bnesIhave arevery vague.I've been told shewas Scott'Sresearch had remainedprivate.But it hasn't,be drinking a lot then." causesometimeagoScottfound outaboutsomethinghe InSeptember1962,one week afterMichael’s seventh desperately wanted to see,whatever it revealed:a221- birthday,Paula Scottdiedof undisclosed causesMorgan pagememoirhisfatherwrotein1970and1971,just be Scott,WinScottsbrother,nowapsychiatristinVirginia fore his,death.risk." Twish I had more memories of her,he says squinting. You wouldnotbereading about any of thisifMichael The bnesIhave arevery vague.I've been told shewas Scott'Sresearch had remainedprivate.But it hasn't,be drinking a lot then." causesometimeagoScottfound outaboutsomethinghe InSeptember1962,one week afterMichael’s seventh desperately wanted to see,whatever it revealed:a221- birthday,Paula Scottdiedof undisclosed causesMorgan pagememoirhisfatherwrotein1970and1971,just be Scott,WinScottsbrother,nowapsychiatristinVirginia fore his,death. believeshissister-in-lawcommitted suicide.Michaelfinds WinstonScott had intended to have it published some. that plausible. day.Itmaycontain,Michael saysmportantinformatin about his adoption,his mother's death,and elements of Michaels early life.As Win Scott's heir,Michael Scott believes,it belongs to him. wasfrom averyCatholicfamily and suicidewas consid- Except the governmenthastSenior CIA oficialshad ered a shameful thing.”He believes his father's memoirs raced to Winston Scott's house in the hours after his mightshed light on whathappened. death and smooth-talked'it away from his widow,who WinScott,aromanticwho abhorred loneliness,remar- surrendered it unread.They've kept it ever since,and ried threemonthslater.HisPeruvian-born bridewas Jan- now won't cough it up.The Agency says it has no choice, etLeddy,amother of fivewho had just divorceda long that the father'sreminiscences are too volatile,too can- time Colleague of Scott's.Theirwedding was a sensation did about CIA sources and methods,toopotentially dam- intheMexican social scene.Whilefewpeopleknew that aging torelations with other countries. the groom was the CIA station chiefin the country,the And so it is that Michael Scott's understandable im- identityof the chiefwitnessto thecivil ceremony-the pulse.to learm about his father and himself has come into man who signed themarriage certificatewasno secret.death and smooth-talked'it away from his widow,who WinScott,aromanticwho abhorred loneliness,remar- surrendered it unread.They've kept it ever since,and ried threemonthslater.HisPeruvian-born bridewas Jan- now won't cough it up.The Agency says it has no choice, etLeddy,amother of fivewho had just divorceda long that the father'sreminiscences are too volatile,too can- time Colleague of Scott's.Theirwedding was a sensation did about CIA sources and methods,toopotentially dam- intheMexican social scene.Whilefewpeopleknew that aging torelations with other countries. the groom was the CIA station chiefin the country,the And so it is that Michael Scott's understandable im- identityof the chiefwitnessto thecivil ceremony-the pulse.to learm about his father and himself has come into man who signed themarriage certificatewasno secret. dramatic collision with the government's inevitable im- ItwasAdolfoLopezMateos,the president of Mexico. pulse to protect its secrets.The result is Scott uCentral WiScottwasaworkaholic,butonweekendshewould Intelligence Agency et al,and it is oneremarkable law- let Michael tag along to his office in the U.S.Embassy a suit fewblocks downPaseo delaReforma. Onthe onehand,the issuesitraises arenotunprece “T remember to get to his whole wing of the office you dented: We saw them with the Pentagon Papers case.Is had tostepthroughthisvaultdoor,likeabankvaulti thegovernmentreallyprotectinginformation thatmight chael-recalls.“As a kid I thought,This is kind of bi- prove harmful to theUnited States?Oris it just protect- zarre?" ing its.own dignity,sparing itself the embarrassment of having.to account publicly for past malfeasance? opth&film in the CIA darkroom in theembassy. Allthe while,Michael did not know his father worked tion ofinnocence and goodwill are longgone.At afeder for theCIA,thoughhe didrecognize thenames of some al court hearing in Washington early this month, a Jus- famous:visitors to their house.--- PAGE BREAK --- opth&film in the CIA darkroom in theembassy. Allthe while,Michael did not know his father worked tion ofinnocence and goodwill are longgone.At afeder for theCIA,thoughhe didrecognize thenames of some al court hearing in Washington early this month, a Jus- famous:visitors to their house. ticeDepartment lawyergravely told U.SDistrict Judge “Allen Dulles came to visit one time and we allwent to Charles Richey that the documents Michael Scott is thesaltbaths.Iremember driving down there andnotic- seeking concerning hisfather are so sensitive thatthey ‘inghow gnarly Dulles'hands were.He had arthritis or can be described to thejudge onlyby a senior CIA off- cialbehind closeddoors.The courtseemed unmoved. that.": "Then bring him in here and we'll do it,Richey said, ButMichael is the firstto acknowledge that his memo glowering. riesofhisfather may be lovingly selective.He calls on his Scqtt's lawyer,MarkZaid,aWashington-based spe stepbrother,GeorgeLeddy,who isa guestlecturerin cialistinFreedom of Information Act litigation says that LatinAmerican studies at UCLA and who is the same age "TheCIA's attitude in this case illustrates that the Cold asMichael, to fill in the details. War secrecy mentality still exists." “InOctober1968,Mexico City was just about shut Fohisclient though,the caseisultimatelyless about downLeddy recalls.It was a time ofpolitical turmoil. statesecrets thanfamily secretsa simpleeffort atself- "There were tanks in thestreets and all the schoolswere discoveryby one man who happened,through nofaultof closed.In themidstof thiscrisis,AllenDulles andRichard his own,to be delivered at birth into what theCIA might --- PAGE BREAK ---sonwas amorbiderrandnotunfamiliar toJamesAngle ton.Sevenyears earlier,in October 1964,the counterin- Helms came to see WinScott,Iassume to consult with telligence chiefhad undertakena similar quest.Awoman him aboutwhat the U.S. should do.I remember because namedMaryMeyer,whohadbeenoneofPresidentKen- theyeouldn'tfindacateringservice thatthey could trust, nedy’s mistresses,was murdered mysteriously on the so when they had a party I had to pour the drinks. C&OCanal towpath.Afewdayslater,Angleton,whowas “Dilles came a second time,Michael says softly.Thad skilled at picking locks,broke into the dead woman's totallyforgotten that." housein search of a diary that she wasknown tohave InJune1969,WinScottretiredatage60.Thefollow- kept.Hewas discovered there by MaryMeyer's sister THEWASHINGTONPOST Michael Scott holding his father's Distinguished Intelligence Medal, the CiA's highest honor:The search for his father's story has led him into the shadowy world of Cold War intrigue. BYTOODBIGELOWFORTHEW ingyear,Michaeland George,both15,were dispatchd to Connecticut to enter the10th grade ata boarding Toni Bradlee and her then-husband,Ben Bradlee,later school.Michaeleceivedtypedletters,almostdaily,from executive editorof theWashingtonPost.When thediary his father in Mexico City.In them,Win Scott neyer men- finally turned upa few days later,theBradleeshandedit tioned thathewaswritinghismemoirs,actively seekinga over toAngleton. publisher,andmaking CIADirector RichardHelms very, By comparison,obtaining Win Scott's memoirs was verynervous. easy.Angleton didn't have to pick any locks.All he had to On April 26,1971,when Michael was working in the dowasgain the cooperationof Scott'swidow,Janet.publisher,andmaking CIADirector RichardHelms very, By comparison,obtaining Win Scott's memoirs was verynervous. easy.Angleton didn't have to pick any locks.All he had to On April 26,1971,when Michael was working in the dowasgain the cooperationof Scott'swidow,Janet. student cafe,he was summoned to the dean’soffice.His There aretwo accountsofwhathappenedin theScott stepbrother was already there.The two boys were told family home on the aftemoon of April 28,1971.One that theirfatherhaddied.They quicklyarranged tofly to comesfromarecently declassifiedCiA cablewrittenthe Mexico City. next day by John Horton,who was the CIA's Mexico.City “Tforget whathapened,Michae says,“but wemissed station chief at the time.This cable is based on what An- theplane." gleton toldHorton right after the visit.Horton isretired A Morbid Mission and livinginMaryland;he declined tobeinterviewed for this article.)Theother accountcomesfromMichael Scott James Jesus Angleton didn't miss his plane. andGeorge Leddy andisbased on what JanetScotthas Angleton,the chief of counterintelligence and one of Scott,a formerCIAemployeeherself,alsodeclinestotalk the most powerful figures in the CIA,had known Win to reporters. Scott since they were bothinLondon inthemid-40s.He Bothversions of theAngleton visit indicate the same had been asked to talktoScott about themanuscriptand thing:thatit was a tense,unpleasant meeting. wasplanning todo sowhen heheard thenews thatScott Angleton is now dead.At the time he was a tall,gaunt was dead.Angleton put aside his antipathy for all things man whose once-handsome featureshadbeenpinched Mexican (he was half Mexican himself and ashamed of it) down toasinisteraspectbyalcoholism and aprofession and flew toMexico City.Hehad butonegoal in mind:to thatrequiredacertain amountofparanoia.JanetScott securethememoirs.--- PAGE BREAK --- Scott since they were bothinLondon inthemid-40s.He Bothversions of theAngleton visit indicate the same had been asked to talktoScott about themanuscriptand thing:thatit was a tense,unpleasant meeting. wasplanning todo sowhen heheard thenews thatScott Angleton is now dead.At the time he was a tall,gaunt was dead.Angleton put aside his antipathy for all things man whose once-handsome featureshadbeenpinched Mexican (he was half Mexican himself and ashamed of it) down toasinisteraspectbyalcoholism and aprofession and flew toMexico City.Hehad butonegoal in mind:to thatrequiredacertain amountofparanoia.JanetScott securethememoirs. wasaself-educatedwomanof diverseinterests,whojust Retrieving thememoirs of a well-connected dead per- 24hours earlierhad buriedherhusband in theAmerican- British cemetery in Mexico City.She knew Angleton --- PAGE BREAK ---through Win and didn't care forhum.Sne liked humeven lessas she listened to hiscordiallybrutal message. own identity.as Win Scott's son.The accidents of life, According to the recently declassified CIA cable,An- whichhadseemedgeneroustoateenager,becamea little gleton expressed regrets about herhusband's death, more frightening. quickly adding mention of “the benefits to which she was “Oneday,Ijustsaid tomyself,Youcomein,you talk somebodyfor threehoursfor aninterviewforadocumen- tentative.JanetScott'srecollection of thisominousintro- tary,andyou wind upknowingmore about them thanyou duction ismore specific.She has toldher family thatAn- do aboutyourself.'Irealized thatif Iput10 percent of the gleton threatened her,saying that theAgency wasplan- effortIputintotalkingtotheseotherpeople,Icouldfind ning to putup a plaque in honor ofWin Scott at CIA out somethingpretty interesting and important for my headquartersinLangley,but thatitmightnotproceed if kids.Mywife,Barbara,pushedme to doit,saying h she didn't cooperate. were things that anyperson shouldknow.abouthisfami- Angleton, according to the CIA's cable,went on to ly." warnJanetScott thatpublication of thememoirswouldvi- olate two secrecy agreements anddamageU.S.relations Sometimein the 1970s,Michael says,he figuredout withforeigngovermments.Hewarned hernot toreadit, hisfatherhadbeen associatedwithAmericanintelligence. He didn't think much of it at the time.ButinMarch1986 mate matters of previous marriage.”When Angleton said he wrote a letter to the CIA,seeking themanuscript his the Agency wanted all copies of the manuscript,Janet stepmotherhad toldhim about 15years before.Here Scott hastened to cooperate.She found themanuscript ceived afriendlynotebackinvitinghim tocome to CIA thenextdayandimmediatelyturmeditover tostation headquarters whenever he was in the Washington area. chief John Horton.He didn't think much of it at the time.ButinMarch1986 mate matters of previous marriage.”When Angleton said he wrote a letter to the CIA,seeking themanuscript his the Agency wanted all copies of the manuscript,Janet stepmotherhad toldhim about 15years before.Here Scott hastened to cooperate.She found themanuscript ceived afriendlynotebackinvitinghim tocome to CIA thenextdayandimmediatelyturmeditover tostation headquarters whenever he was in the Washington area. chief John Horton. That summer,he wasin WestVirginia shootinga docu- “We got two original drafts and two carbons of manu- mentary and took a day offto drive intoLangley.Two se script,Horton thenreported inhis.cableto CIADirector nior CIA public affairs officers ushered him through the Richard Helms.Horton also reported removing“three doors famously emblazonedwith the credo“The Truth large cartons andfourvaliseswithfilefolders,notesand Shall SetYou Free." memoranda of classified station files”from Win Scott's His hosts praised his father generously.They talked study. about his Distinguished Intelligence Medal, the Agency’'s Hortonclosedwith awordofcoolcandor tothenow dry-eyed widow.According to his report,he acknowl- inghim the manuscript,noting only that a few sensitive edged that Win Scott's friends“may feel Agency has things about LeeHarvey Oswald had tobe deleted.They handed him a sheaf of papersandMichael Scott left a hap- “was prepared toweather that one." pyman, Around this time,Michael andhis stepbrother arrived Only when he actuallygot around toreading thepages home.Akidwhosebiggest concermjusta few days earlier did hefeel abitfoolish.Thebulk of themanuscriptwas had been making the TaftSchoolgolf team,hadreached missing. The CIA had given him the first nine chapters, theendofhischildhood.In the daysfollowinghisfather's death,helearmedtwofamilysecrets.about his Distinguished Intelligence Medal, the Agency’'s Hortonclosedwith awordofcoolcandor tothenow dry-eyed widow.According to his report,he acknowl- inghim the manuscript,noting only that a few sensitive edged that Win Scott's friends“may feel Agency has things about LeeHarvey Oswald had tobe deleted.They handed him a sheaf of papersandMichael Scott left a hap- “was prepared toweather that one." pyman, Around this time,Michael andhis stepbrother arrived Only when he actuallygot around toreading thepages home.Akidwhosebiggest concermjusta few days earlier did hefeel abitfoolish.Thebulk of themanuscriptwas had been making the TaftSchoolgolf team,hadreached missing. The CIA had given him the first nine chapters, theendofhischildhood.In the daysfollowinghisfather's death,helearmedtwofamilysecrets. Michael'sstepmother tookhim aside and toldhimwhat he had previously suspected: that Win Scott was not his about90pages,coveringWinScottsboyhoodonafarm biologicalfather.Michaelhad actuallybeen adopted by in Jemison,Ala,his semipro baseball career,hisPhD n WinandPaula shortly afterhisbirth in1955. mathematics,hisbrief stintattheFBI,andhisenlistment “It wasn't a shock,Michael says with characteristic equanimity.“We didn’t look alike.He wasvery fair andI in theNavy and thebeginningofhiscareerintheOficeof Strategic Services in 1944. was darker.Hehad never told me about being adopted. Why not?I thinkbecause hewas.afraidImight love him Andright there,Michael had to stopreading.Thenext 115pagesofhisfather'sbookweremissing,deletedvir- less." His stepmother also toldhim somepeople from the government hadcome byfor hisfather'smemoirs. The CIA threwin one of the final chapters,which con She didn’'t saywho,orwhy. tained some general reflections about the intelligence Aweeklater,Michael Scottflewback to Connecticut. business.--- PAGE BREAK --- tained some general reflections about the intelligence Aweeklater,Michael Scottflewback to Connecticut. business. At the same time,hisfatherspaperswere being sentby Scott was angry.“Right when the story began to getin- diplomaticpouch to CIA headquarters.Michael restimed teresting,it stopped.In1945.I atleastwanted toget to his classes and quit the golf team.The paper legacy of 1955,whenIcame into the picture.” Win Scottloving dad,charismatic covertoperator,and The Secrets CIA loyalistwentintoa super-ecretarchive,erhapsin theCIA director'soffice. Whatexactly is so sensitive aboutWinScott'sunpub- Missing Chapters lished memoirs,a quarter of a century old? It'snotwhatScott knew aboutLee Oswald.His chap Thestorywouldendthere,exceptforMichael’schoice teron the accused assassinwasdeclassifiedinSeptember ofcareer:investigating otherpeople'slives.Hebecamea 1993along witha millionpages of CIA documents con- documentary flmmaker, then a producer forNBC's“Un- cerning the Kennedy assassination.His eight-page de solvedMysteries,and now a director.(His latestmovie, scription of the CIA's surveillance.ofOswald in Mexico “All She Ever Wanted,will air on ABC onApril 14.) City does not constitute any kind of“smoking gun”in the In1985Ispentalotoftimewithacouplewhose long-running debate about the Kennedy assassination. daughterhad been raped and murdered,he says softly. WinScott'spersonal conspiracy theory thatOswaldmight Their tragedy-therole of happenstance in the livesof havebeenaSoviet agentisnotsupportedbyrecentlyre goodpeoplecastaharshlighton thecontingency of his leasedKGBfilesonthesubject.About theonlythingthat Scott'sOswaldchapterprovessthat,after33yearsand fourofficialinvestigations,the CIA hasyet toprovidea --- PAGE BREAK ---coherent accountofwhatitsofficersknew about Uswala SUNDAY,MARCH17,1996F5 before the assassination. WinScottdidwrite thatOswaldwas“apersonofgreat livedon NebraskaAvenue and worked closelywith top interesttotheCIA duringhisvisit toMexicoCitybe CIA officials-—includingWinScott andJamesAngleton. tweenSept.27andOct.2,1963.That's arather different "Nobodyin the CIA knewKim Philby better than Win storyfrom the theoficial line(asarticulatedina1978 Scott,says Cleveland Cram,a retired CIA coumterintelli- for-the-recordmemo byone top official) that theAgency gence officer.Nobodyhadworked withhimso closely or “hadno real knowledge ofhis presence there” so long." Another possible explanationfor the CIA's skittishness Cram,a careerofficer who had worked inLondon for about the manuscript concerms other material that might many years,was calledoutofretirement in1978tocon- have been seizedwith it.Scott,for example,statedun- duct a top-secret internal review of JamesAngleton's ca equivocally thathis subordinatesin theMexico City sta- reer. The counterintelligence chief had.been forced to tion had photographedOswald duringhisvisit.TheAgen- quit amid the CIA scandals of the mid-1970s.At one cy deniesthat anypictureofOswaldwas ever takenin point,Cram says,hewas shown30 to40pages of the Mexico City. still-censored portion ofWinScott'smanuscriptand asked YetStanley Watson,who served asScottsdeputyin to comiment on it. Cram says that Scott wrote about his Mexico City,saidinsecretsworntestimonytocongres early suspicions of Philby. sional investigatorsin1978 that theMexicoCity station's "Win tells a story [in the manuscript], Cram recals, Oswald fle contained two surveillancephotos of Oswald. "about going to a cocktail party and meeting a redhaired In his testimony (whichwas declassified only in Decem- ber,Watsonvolunteered thatWinScottoftenkeptsensi- ism.And he found out shewasPhilby's sister andhewas tive files in his personal safe at home.--- PAGE BREAK --- sional investigatorsin1978 that theMexicoCity station's "Win tells a story [in the manuscript], Cram recals, Oswald fle contained two surveillancephotos of Oswald. "about going to a cocktail party and meeting a redhaired In his testimony (whichwas declassified only in Decem- ber,Watsonvolunteered thatWinScottoftenkeptsensi- ism.And he found out shewasPhilby's sister andhewas tive files in his personal safe at home. This safe was shocked that someone so close to a topBritish intelligence cleaned outand itscontents hauled away along with the official could besoopenly communist." manuscript afterAngleton's visit in April 1971. After Philbywas recalled by theBritish government Might there be a long-suppressed photo of Oswald under acloud of suspicioninJune1951,Scott andAngle among thepapers?Scott‘slawyer,MarkZaid,askedex tonboth contributed to an assessmenton whether hehad actlythatquestioninamotionfiledinsupportofScottu been a spy.According to Cram,WinScott concluded that CIA et al.The CIA replied in writing that there isno pho- Philby was almost certainlya Soviet spy;Angleton was toinitsWinScott archive. noncommittal. Yetanother possibility ofwhat the Agency fears is “I thinkJim was always worried about the other shoe what themanuscriptmightsay aboutKimPhilby,theleg dropping with Philby,”Cram speculates.“I think he must have been afraid thatsomethingworse could come out Britishintelligenceservices.From the summer of1949to about hisclosenesstoPhilby.WhatWinmight write about the summerof1951,PhilbywasstationedinWashington, Philbycouldhaverelectedvery,verybadlyonAngleton Thepossibilitiesforwhat else liesin themanuscript are From left: Win Scott,Michael Scott and Win's stepsons, George Leddy and Paul Leddy. 1970PHOTO --- PAGE BREAK ---vast.Scott‘s career did notbegin in Mexico City.Before hewas40,hewas the chiefofU.S.intelligenceoperations thekind ofespionage trick thatWinScott excelled at.In inpostwar London.Hehelped AllenDulles do a study of 1963,tofomentdissension,hisagentsplantedphonydoc theBritishintelligenceservices thatwasinfluential inthe uments ona Cuban government oficial indicating that creationoftheCIA,andhewentontosuperviseallcovert Castro'sviceministerofdefensewas a CIAagent.Securi- operations inEurope in the early 1950s. ty agents found the documents,and fourwholly innocent GeorgeLeddy thinks his stepfatherknew about and people were convictedof treason and throwninjailfor wrote about theCIA'seffortstokeep communistsandso- cialists outofpowerinItaly and France afterWorldWar years. I1.“If he did, that information would still be politically ex- Michael'sreaction to thissideofhisfatherischaracter- plosive todayin those countries,Leddy says. isticallymorecharitable. “I don't agree with everything he did inhis life,he Likewise,what Scott wrote about his friendships with says,butI thinkofmy dadascommitted tocertaingoals topMexicanpoliticalfiguresinthe1960sandaboutthe which were the goals of the U.S.government in that peri- Mexican crisisof1968wouldbebignewsinMexicoto- od.Hebelieved in theU.S.and thepursuit of freedom.He day.Manyofthose officialsare still alive,andtheInstitu should be judged in the context of the times." tional RevolutionaryParty is facing the strongest chal lenge to itsrule since1968.isticallymorecharitable. “I don't agree with everything he did inhis life,he Likewise,what Scott wrote about his friendships with says,butI thinkofmy dadascommitted tocertaingoals topMexicanpoliticalfiguresinthe1960sandaboutthe which were the goals of the U.S.government in that peri- Mexican crisisof1968wouldbebignewsinMexicoto- od.Hebelieved in theU.S.and thepursuit of freedom.He day.Manyofthose officialsare still alive,andtheInstitu should be judged in the context of the times." tional RevolutionaryParty is facing the strongest chal lenge to itsrule since1968. AsJohnHorton,the CIA officerwho actuallyphysically "It Came to Little' removed themanuscript from theScott household,said "PracticallyanythingI toldyou aboutWinScottwould get After hours of talking about every conceivable as- into classified matters." pect of Win Scott's life and reaching no conclusions For Michaelandhisstepbrother,the darker,stillarg about themeaning.of it all,Michael Scottis aboutto ly unknown side ofWinScotts lifeis stilforbidding termi- give up.His own sons are now swarming around him tory.If they ever get themanuscript,Leddy expects to and so is the dog.Hiswife hasreturned from work. learn the worst about his stepfather.“He was my family Ancient espionage is givingway to the normality of and he was part of therepressive apparatus,Leddy says. family life.Dinnerwill be ready soon. Recently declassified CIA files,forexample,document Scottmakes one last stab at explainingwhy hisfa- ther wrotehis manuscript.Herefers to thelastthree chapters given to himby the CIA inFebruary1995.In these pages,arambling Win Scott explainedwhat he hopedwouldbethetitleof hisautobiography: "It CametoLittle." TheAgency,hewrote,hadfailed tostem thespread ofcommunism.And intelligence work,by its very na- ture,was dehumanizing,requiring clandestine officers tolead“schizoidal”lives.Perhapsreferring tohimself, he explained why clandestine officers should retire ear- ly.--- PAGE BREAK --- family life.Dinnerwill be ready soon. Recently declassified CIA files,forexample,document Scottmakes one last stab at explainingwhy hisfa- ther wrotehis manuscript.Herefers to thelastthree chapters given to himby the CIA inFebruary1995.In these pages,arambling Win Scott explainedwhat he hopedwouldbethetitleof hisautobiography: "It CametoLittle." TheAgency,hewrote,hadfailed tostem thespread ofcommunism.And intelligence work,by its very na- ture,was dehumanizing,requiring clandestine officers tolead“schizoidal”lives.Perhapsreferring tohimself, he explained why clandestine officers should retire ear- ly. "They arrive at a point in lifehaving met and dealt with so many dishonest people,and having,them- selves,in their demanding and dominating (false) selves,lived a liewhere they mistrust almost every- one,lookfor thehidden meaning andmotivesbehind even themostsincere statementsoffriends andloved ones." Scott confessed deepregret athaving sacrificed his personal life on the altar of intelligencework. "Trealize thatI devotedmyself far toocompletely to theworkandgavetoolittle time and attention torec- reationalandnormalfamily lifeandactivities,there tired spy wrote just months before his death.“And,I fully realize that in all those thousands of hours.ofwork as Ibeavered away,I looked formuch,and lo,it came to little'forme and my country." “I think what he really feared in the end, says Mi- chael quietly,“was that his true self·had become de- personalized and his false self had become dominant. The intrigue,the conspiracies,the betrayals and the secrets of hisfatherwillneverfail to interestMichael Scott,the filmmaker and the citizen. But toMichael Scott,theson,thereal struggleis o reconcilehisfather'stwolives.RetrievingIt Came to Little”from theCIA's archives-all of it-maybethe onlywaytorescuehisoldmanfrom thetwilightde spair of the clandestine life,and restore him,awhole man,to thefamily thatneverfullyknewhim.