Violent Drug Raids police officer says mistaken dressedmenbrokedown two raids occuronce ortwicea doors,handcuffed the Giglottos, Against the Innocent month.In Miami complaints of held them at gunpoint,emptied police harassment on drug drawers and closets,shattered Fqund, Widespread searchesareso frequentthat pottery,threw a television set theLegalServices ofGreater onthe floorandshoutedob- 25173 Miami can no longer handle scenities. the caseload. Ahalf-hourlater asimilar By'ANDREWH.MALCOLM Taken individually,the raids eventoccurredacross townat havebeenlittlenoticed nation- the Askews’modesthome. Special to The New York Times ally,apparently because they WASHINGTON,June 24-In- "CaveatVendor' werebelievedtobeisolated nocent Americans around the Inboth cases themen were aberrationsor unfortunatebut country havebeen subjected to agents of the Office for Drug understandable errors as hard- dozensofmistaken,violent and pressedpolice forces sought to Abuse Law Enforcement, an combat drug addiction,which umbrella agency established in often illegal police raids bylo- President January,i972,by President cal,state and Federal narcotics Nixonhas called “Public Enemy No.1." Nixon.Its mottois “Caveat agents in search of illicit drugs In addition,the raids oc- Vendor." and their dealers. curredinwidely scattered In both cases the men were An eight-week investigation areas.Often they involvedlow- at the wrong address. er-class familieswith little ac- In both cases they had no by The New York Times-con- cess to themedia or toadvice search or arrestwarrants. sisting of interviews with vic- onpossible legal recourse. Inboth cases they had no: tims of the raids,policemen Some believemany families authorityfromtheir superiors and narcotics agents-has kept quiet for fear of reprisals forthe raids.In bothcases shown that,contrary to pub- by the agents or perhaps be- they didnotidentify themselves lished reports and some Gov- cause in their hatred for drugs untilwell into the raid.sisting of interviews with vic- onpossible legal recourse. Inboth cases they had no: tims of the raids,policemen Some believemany families authorityfromtheir superiors and narcotics agents-has kept quiet for fear of reprisals forthe raids.In bothcases shown that,contrary to pub- by the agents or perhaps be- they didnotidentify themselves lished reports and some Gov- cause in their hatred for drugs untilwell into the raid. they_condoned the tactics but The agents, one ofwhom had ernment assertions, the recent not the locals. beeninvolved previouslyinin- illegal drug raids on two Col- cidents involving questionable linsville,Ill., families were not "No-Knock'Laws force, have beensuspended isolated incidents. But taken together the mis- with paybutcontinuetoper- In fact,during the last three taken raids paint a picture of formlimiteddutieswhilea strong-arm police tactics, shod- grand jury investigates and the years,mistaken raids have been dyor nonexistent pre-raid po- families sue. made by narcotics agents on lice investigation and the pres- Three days before the Col- allgovernment tlevels,often sures and brutalizingimpact on linsville raids, at 10:45 P.M. acting onuncorroborated tips the police of constantcontact Mrs.Laura Smith heard a tap- from informers. with what they call “society’s pingonawindow ofherhome scum, the drug pusher. on Chicago's tough South Side. Such incidents have resulted The incidents also underline Seconds later asledgehammer in at least four deaths,includ- what someviewas aninherent came through the back door, ingone policemanslainwhen danger in“no-knock”narcotics shesaid./Itwasfollowedby aterror-stricken innocent wo- raids,which were authorized fourarmedmenin civilian manshot:throughherbedroom for Federal agents by Congress clothes who ran through _the door as it burst open. In Cali- in1970.Somestates have house,she continued.They similar statutes. were Chicagopolicemen.In Cali- in1970.Somestates have house,she continued.They similar statutes. were Chicagopolicemen. forniaoneinnocentfather was Under these laws thepolice "They were looking for mari- shot throughtheheadas he may obtain a special no-knock juanaand 1somemannamed sat in a living room cradling search warrant authorizing Will,"recalls Mrs.Smith,who his infant son. them to break into homes un- noticedthatthesearch war- Details of each-raid,vary, announced if there isprobable rant was originally issued for generallythey cause to believe that the prop- 9763 South Oglesby,one block but involve erty sought can be quicklyde- awayfrom theSmiths'home Continued on Page22,Column1 stroyedordisposedoforif at 9763 South Crandon.The givingnotice ofpolicepresence originaladdress was scratched Continued From Page 1, Col.4 couldendanger an officer or offandthatoftheSmiths other person. written in. heavily armed policemen,arriv- To some observers such mis- Circuit( Court Judge Irving ing at night,often unshaven taken raids are just that-mis- Kipnis,who signed the warrant, and in slovenly “undercover” takes caused by an understand- said such changes must be attire,bashing down the doors ablemountingpolice frustration made in a judge's presence, toa private homeor apart- withthegrowingdrugproblem. but he handles so many war- ment and holding the innocent They say that members of the rants these days that he could residents atgunpointwhile they more vocalmiddle class are notrecall if thatprocedure had ransack the house. now being subjected to rigor- been followed. A raid victim in Long Island ouspolice techniques that some The Chicago police offered has settled a damage suitwith allege some officers have long no explanation for theraid,nor theFederalGovernment for used inblack communities. didthey payfor the broken $160,000.Similar suits are To others,however,the mis- door. “Every time Ihear a pending. taken raids signaltheemer- noise at night now,”says Mrs.“Every time Ihear a pending. taken raids signaltheemer- noise at night now,”says Mrs. Sometimes the agents have gence of adangerousclimate Smith,“I live it all over again." warrantsandidentifythem- of repression. selves.Sometimes they do not. The drug raids on the homes Frequently,the raiding party ofHerbertGiglottoandDonald is rude,abusive and,as in Col- Askew in Collinsville, Ill., oc- linsville, shouts obscenities at curred the night of April 23. its terrified victims. Mr.Giglottowas asleep with InLosAngeles a veteran his wife in their apartment mentwhenmore thani5poorly --- PAGE BREAK ---, shouts obscenities at curred the night of April 23. its terrified victims. Mr.Giglottowas asleep with InLosAngeles a veteran his wife in their apartment mentwhenmore thani5poorly --- PAGE BREAK --- Her husband, James, is a Cook “Just don't move” came the County deputy sheriff. reply. OnJan.26 this year Mrs. Mr.Pine,a night worker, AnnaMajettewasasleepinawakenedupstairstoface sev- her apartment at1420Barbour eral gun barrels.The men Drive in Portsmouth,Va.She asked his name.“williamPine, heardanoiceasherdoorhereplied. crashed in. The men lookedateach Sherose from bed and, shelother and raced from thehouse. says, Frank Bonnewell, chief They werestateandFederal of Portsmouth detectives, narcotics agents,it waslearned steppedinfrontofherwithalater. And they gun.“We've heard a lot about wantedthe this house,”he said. green house at 30 Underhill Avenue, not the Pines’green The officerproduced a search house at 32Underhill. warrant.Hismen searched for didn'tknow policeoper- heroin. Then Mrs.Majette noticed ated like that in America, said Mrs.Pine. that the warrant wasissued for ApartmentAand hers At 6A.M. Sept. 20, 1972, Herman Apartment J. family “Sorry,” said the officer.And of Rochester, N. Y. was they left. awakening. Suddenly the door jamb splintered under the PhiladelphiaIncident weight of fourmen. They ordered Mrs. Herman got to talking. “Iwas on a raid thefamily'sbarkingdogs and onetime,” one policeman re- called,“and we got the wrong house.We broke in,went up- stairs toabedroom and found ahalf-deafandblindcouple that didn't evenknow we en- tered the house." On Jan.24 in Philadelphia threeoff-dutypatrolmen-John Chopak,James Haney and Har- ry Herr-were drinkingin a bar near 40th and Market Streets when, they say,a patron said theycould find narcotics in a nearby house. According to a police inves- tigation,the three men went tothe house on Wiota Street, ransacked thehouse andbeat three occupants.Not finding any drugs,they forced a passer- Sun Times Photo byintothehouseand beat James Smith,hiswife,Laura,and their children at back him too. door totheirhomeonChicago'sSouthSide,brokendown Then thepatron tookthe officers toanother houseon marijuana.Mr.Smith is a Cook County deputy sheriff. Baring Street where theybeat threeother occupants.They foundno drugs there either. The policemen were suspend- ed and arrested. On Jan.9 at 10 A.M.in Win- throp,1 Mass.,15 burly men armedwithshotguns broke down twodoors andburst into theWilliamPineresidence. Themendidnotidentify themselvesand wore nouni forms.They pushed the family The NewYork Times Mrs.Herbert Giglotto in us,please don't killus wreckage of her Collins- screamed 113-year-oldMelody ville,Ill.,apartment after Pine. Federal agents broke in.s.They pushed the family The NewYork Times Mrs.Herbert Giglotto in us,please don't killus wreckage of her Collins- screamed 113-year-oldMelody ville,Ill.,apartment after Pine. Federal agents broke in. --- PAGE BREAK ---searched the house.“If I'd had him in the back as he fled. through the ceiling.It pierced a gun,” said Mr. Herman, “Id Mr.Dickenson died. It is a Mr.Dyer's skull,killing him havefired.Ithought they were violationofbureaurulestol instantly. burglars." shoot at fleeing suspects.No The shot came from an AR- They were not.They were “giant lab”was found. 15 military rifle,which one of state troopers,part of a force TheUnitedStates Attorney the agents upstairs,Sgt.Frank executing 22searchwarrants in San Francisco said there had Sweeney,was not authorized in Monroe County drug beenno civilrights violations a to carry.He said it had fired round-up.But they were at the and the killing had been justi- accidentally. wronghouse. fiable.homicide. No one that upstairs The police said they had On Feb.5,1973,Mr.Clifton apartment was arrested. wasindicted bya Humboldt A overheardatelephonenumber coroner'sjurydecided thatMr. duringawiretap andwhenthey County grand jury for second- Dyer died by cniminal means, had called theRochester Tele- degreemurderandinvoluntary but thedistrict attorney's office phone Corporation togetan manslaughter.TheFederal Gov- declined to prosecute. address forit,their service rep- ernmenthireda special defense SergeantSweeney, attorney for Mr.Clifton.The others,was later suspended among resentativegavethem3Audo- bon Street. lawyer,James McKittrick,seeks fromdutywithoutpay fora Itwas Herman's address tohave the charges dismissed. time. but not their telephone. The Mr.Clifton continues his Three weeksagoacourt police apparently never duties. awarded thefamily$ $900,000 checked the addressfurther. Second CaliforniaDeath damages.awarded thefamily$ $900,000 checked the addressfurther. Second CaliforniaDeath damages. Smashing into the wrong Mrs.Adelina Garcia has sued Complex Reasons house,added Capt.Richard Bo- Los Angelesand Riverside lan of the state police,was an The reasons behind these mis- “insignificant detail”in what Countyfor $750,000for the shooting deathof herhusband, taken raids arevaried and com- was“one hell of a raid." plex.Butthey are tied inti In Norfolk, Va., at 3 A.M. Francisco,by the police on a matelytotheveritableexplo- May. 24,1972, drugraidataranchnearIndio Mrs. Lillian sionof Government drugen- on May 12,1971. Davidson,a previous burglary forcementactivitiesinrecent The police said Mr. Garcia victim,heard someone break- hadignoredcommandstostop years. ingintoherhouseat812Lan- his truck.They shot him and At its formationin1968 the caster Street.Then someone be- Bureau of Narcoticsand Dan- gan tobatterdownherlocked wounded his wife.A substantial gerous Drugs, the main Federal cache of marijuana was dis- bedroom door. arm against drugs, had 615 covered on the ranch,but Mr. Shot Through Door agentsanda$14-millionbudget Garciawas never implicated in Now it has 1,586 the narcotics operation. domestic She grabbed a.32-caliber agents and a $74-millionbudget revolverandshotthroughthe Here in Washington on May On July 1,a new Drug En- door. 2,1970,seven policemen,only forcementAdministration will The bullet pierced the chest one in uniform,brokeinto Miss Lauretta Whitney's home oni absorbmostoftheFederal of Patrolman Lewis W.Hurst efforts,including the bureau. Jr.,the 22-year-old son of the Newton Street,knocked her These efforts cost about $245- headof theNorfolkPoliceDe- down and ransacked the apart- million a,year. partment's narcotics squad.He ment in search of illegalnar- Withits sudden growth,the died minuteslater. bureauhashad todosome Thepolice arrested Mrs. cotics.They found none.bureauhashad todosome Thepolice arrested Mrs. cotics.They found none. fast recruiting.“A majority of Davidson.They were looking The address on the warrant our people come to us right for2,400 parcels of fheroin came from atrusted informant, outof college,” said Richard thatan informer, aformer the city police said,but now Ulrich,administrative officer drug addict,had said were that Miss Whitney is suingfor for theiNational Training In- there.They were not. $100,000 damages,officials say stitute,the bureau's training The police said it had been they havenoideawherethe arm,“and some of them have anerrorbytheyounginformer informer is. lawenforcementexperience. and released Mrs.Davidson. "We're aiso consideringa The institute runs a 10-week The agents acted on an “im- class action suit, said Mrs. schoolfornewagentsand mediate entry”clause added to Florence Isbell of the local hundreds of localpolicemen, the search warrant.The clause, American CivilLiberties Union with 600 hours of instruction, said Lawrence Wallace,assist- as sheleafed throughfileswith including26hours on due pro- ant commonwealth attorney,is more than 20 similar cases. cessand theConstitution's unwrittencommonlawthat On Oct.3,1969,a number Fourth Amendment,which pro- dates backto Virginia's ofstateandlocal 1narcotics hibits “unreasonable searches founding. agents in Whittier,Calif.,drank and seizures.”Butapparently On April 24, 1972,local po- beerandhighballsfortwo licemen andagentsoftheBu- hours in a local bar as they awaitedcompletionofsearch attendanceisnotrequired; reauof Narcotics and Danger- warrants foradrugraidon some agents involvedin mis- ous Drugs moved on the moun- Apartments B andDat 8033 taken raidshad not taken the tainretreatof24-year-oldDirk South Comstock. course. Dickenson near Eureka,Calif., However,they initially en- Theraids are frightening for to seize a“giant lab”producing drugs. teredtheapartmentofMrs.--- PAGE BREAK --- Dickenson near Eureka,Calif., However,they initially en- Theraids are frightening for to seize a“giant lab”producing drugs. teredtheapartmentofMrs. bothraidedandraider.The FlorenceMehanat8031South tactics are based in part on Arriving onfoot withdogs Comstock.Realizing their mis- the theory that a sudden,over- andina borrowedhelicopter, take, the agents went upstairs whelming displayofpolice the agents, who were not in to the correct address. forcewillquashany thoughtof uniformanddid notidentify Drawn by the commotion, resistance and secure evidence themselves,assaulted the cabin Mrs.Mehan’s son-in-law,Hey- before it can be disposed of. with rifles and hand guns.Ap- ward Henry Dyer,22,and his "You have to go in with the parentlyfrightenedandbaffled, 22-month-oid son,Francis,went idea that this guy is going to Mr.Dickenson ran toward the to theMehan apartment. fight,, said Clyde Charles,an woods. An agent,Lloyd Clifton, shot Suddenly,abullet crashed agent who asked that his real name not be used.“He's al- --- PAGE BREAK ---oward the to theMehan apartment. fight,, said Clyde Charles,an woods. An agent,Lloyd Clifton, shot Suddenly,abullet crashed agent who asked that his real name not be used.“He's al- --- PAGE BREAK --- ways being shaken down by other pushers.So you figure you'll bestaringdownagun barrel." "I've been on 200 or so raids,”he continued,“and the no-knock is the scariest. You askyourselfwhatwouldyou doifyour door came crashing down at 3 A.M.andyou had a gun.You'd let go, right? Per- sonally,It think thedanger might outweigh the value." Officials of the bureau, which works against big-time pushers,say they have execu- ted “two or three”no-knock raids;officials for the Office of Drug Abuse Law Enforce- ment,which concentrates on smaller drug dealers, say they lave done “above 100" But the agents themselves admit to some “funny busi- ess'regardingtherequirement to announcethemselves on oth- er than no-knock raids.“You might whisper,‘Open up!Po- lice!”one said,“or you could yellit theinstant before yoi hit the door." Another drugofficialadded "It's hard for outsiders to set anormal standardofbehavior. Youcan't ask an agent to spendthreemonthsonacase and thenexpect himto an- nounce himseifpolitelyand lis- ten to every toilet onthefloor. flush away theevidence.You have to be a saint todo that. Eureka Times-Standard/Richard Harris Another agent said,“If you DirkDickenson dying near his mountain cabin atEureka,Calif.,after being shot in the spendweeksundercover,living back by narcotics agent,Lloyd Clifton, left.A “giant” lab being sought was not found. inaholeanddealingwithdrug people,your whole life-style changesandperhapsyour mo- rals too.Sometimes there's a thinlinebetween thehunted and thehunter." “This is dirty scummy work, said Myles J. Ambrose,head oftheOfficeofDrugAbuse Law Enforcement.You see these vermin selling drugs and what they dotopeople andour cities and you get sickened and angry and perhaps youtake your hostilities and frustrations outon some guy’s bookcase. It's not right.But how areyou going toprevent it?