AFFIDAVIT My name is Harold Weisberg.I reside at 7627 01d Receiver Road,Frederick, intelligence analyst.I am the author of six books on the assassination of President John F.Kennedy and one on the assassination of Dr.Martin Luther King, Jr.After publication ofmybook on Dr.King in early 197l Ibecame investigator for James Earl Ray,the convicted assassin who claimed his guilty plea had been coerced.I conducted the habeas corpus investigation and the subsequent investigation for the two weeks of evidentiary hearing infederaldistrict court inMemphis,Tennessee. 1.As the plaintiff in C.A.75-1996I attended all but twoof the many calendar callsand hearings that were heldprior to September 1980when I underwent arterial surgery thatwas followedby two serious complications and surgerieswhich have severely limitedwhatIam abletodo.Ihavenotbeen have and have readall pleadings filedby both sides and all transcripts.At the requestof the court I met and tried to cooperate with the FBI,undertaking to makemysubject-matterknowledgeavailable toitandprovidingitwithmany copies of records,mostly its own records disclosed to me.When the court asked did so in all the personal conferences itrequested,some rather lengthy,and in filing detailed anddocumentedappeals that take up two full file drawers.Most of these two file drawersare takenup byxeroxes of theFBI'sown records.A 1 --- PAGE BREAK ---ed,some rather lengthy,and in filing detailed anddocumentedappeals that take up two full file drawers.Most of these two file drawersare takenup byxeroxes of theFBI'sown records.A 1 --- PAGE BREAK --- privacy.When the director of appeals,Mr.Quinlan J.Shea,Jr.,appeared and testified for the government,he praised the help I provided,which included theprivacyclaims,andhetestifiedon cross-examination thatthere wasimproper withholding of informationthatshouldbe restored.Ineffect,he testified that the disclosed records required reprocessing.These are precisely the improper withholdings I called to the FBI's attention,withholdings relating to Firstamong thesewere the names of trial witnesses,whose names the FBI then and since nefused to restore.The FBI even withheld- ten times in a newspaper clipping-the name of its specialagentwho had addressed aprofessional group abouthis work intheKing assassinationinvestigation.Ievenprepared for the FBIaconsolidatedindextoall thepublishedbookson the subjectand itrefused touse itinprocessingtherecords. 2.In preparing thisaffidavitIlimit myself to whatI recallof the case record,includingwhat Irecall of my many affidavits,some quite lengthy, detailedand thoroughly documented.All of this informationisknown to and is in the possession of the defendant,as also is those two file drawers of appeals. 3.In addition,when Iwas virtually coerced by the district court to actas the defendant's consultant in my suit againstit,Iprepared a lengthy, also found it quite helpfuland informative.(Defendant's then counselinsisted tothedistrictcourt thatmyserviceswereindispenable tocompliancebecauseI haduniquesubject-matterknowledge.) 4.Ihave read and herein address defendant's supplementalbrief,filed May 18,1984.Beginning with its very first sentence it misrepresents and is not in accord with or in any substantivemanner supported by the case record. 2 --- PAGE BREAK ---'s supplementalbrief,filed May 18,1984.Beginning with its very first sentence it misrepresents and is not in accord with or in any substantivemanner supported by the case record. 2 --- PAGE BREAK --- The first sentence states that'"a showing of publicinterestinthe.information sought"is"absent."Throughout the litigation Ihave shown the public interest s basedonallegedprivacyconsiderationswereunjustifiedandthatall information relating to those he referred to as"players"should be disclosed, and the attorney general decided that this is an"historical case"requiring maximumpossible disclosure.Moreover,as I address below,even when Iprovided ignore them,it disclosed records reflecting the existence of still withheld records thatremain unsearched for to this very day.(My appeals also are ignored.)Atthesame time itdisclosedvoluntarilyawide rangeof extremely personaland entirely irrelevant records about those it didnot like or ofwhose views it disapproved.These range from the names of who was sleeping with whom, a fewillustrations of which are below,to its complete fabrication that I,a Jew,allegedlywas conspiring against itwithone of themostnotorious of anti-Semites,J.B.Stoner. 5.I am included in thepersons listed in the Items of the requestin question and tothisday the FBI has still refusedtosearch for andprocess the unquestionably relevant records the existence of which it disclosedunintentionally the FBI firstclaimed did not existand then claimed it couldnot find.That tickler was decimated by the FBI after my request was filed,but what remains of itdisclosesthatIand another person listed in these Itemsareincluded innot fewer than five "bank robbery"files.(FBI fileclassification 9l)Ihave never had any connection,direct or indirect,with any bank robbery and as this record, Exhibit5below,states,"nor arethere anycriminalreferences to"me. 3 --- PAGE BREAK ---fileclassification 9l)Ihave never had any connection,direct or indirect,with any bank robbery and as this record, Exhibit5below,states,"nor arethere anycriminalreferences to"me. 3 --- PAGE BREAK --- 6.Bernard Fensterwald,Jr.,who was Ray's chief counsel when I was his investigator,also is listed in those items.He provided a privacy waiver.In response the FBI disclosed records in which it ordered all field offices to suspendelectronicsurveillance ofhimandanother lawyer andrecordsreflecting physical surveillance ofhim.Despite hisprivacy waiver and my providing the FBIwith.thisinformationinitsowm records,it hasmade nofurther search and provided no additional records.At the same time it disclosed its own political reporting on his mother,angled to defame her as some kind of "red,"when andI are among those includedin the surveillances Item,No.1l (see supplemental brief,page 5).Disclosed FBIrecords reflect that hewas coveredby its"symbol informants,"informants who are carried in its records with an identification composedof lettersandnumbers.Only summary/paraphrases havebeen disclosed. The FBIrefuses to search for andprocess the other relevantrecords required to exist.Theseincludeatthe least theinformant"contact"reports,onaprinted FBI form and filedin accordancewiththe function of theinformer,i.e.,"134 **Security Informants,"or "137 Criminal Informants."("**Security-related Classification.") 7.Iaddressbelowotherprivacywaiversandother Item1finformation relating tome andothers thattheFBIsimply refuses tosearchfor and process. 8.In alleging relevance of Antonelli v.Departmentof Justice beginning on page 3,the supplemental brief entirely misrepresents my Items 7,8 and 14 and of Antonelli to its misrepresentation of my request,and thus Antonelli is relevant.Its language(brief,page 3)requires that "'the requester seeks s 4 --- PAGE BREAK ---resents my Items 7,8 and 14 and of Antonelli to its misrepresentation of my request,and thus Antonelli is relevant.Its language(brief,page 3)requires that "'the requester seeks s 4 --- PAGE BREAK --- s files"anddisclosureof therequestedinformation wouldnot and,indeed,could not"reveal" that any one "has been the subject of FBI investigations."Moreover, withregardto some,thefactis that theFBI itselfhad already disclosed that some were"the subject"of its investigations.The truth is that these three any"investigations." 9.In addition,before Ifiled these Items thedefendanthad disclosed the existenceof such correspondence to the press. 10.With regard to the surveillances Item,No.ll,it is not necessarily FBI itselfhas disclosed that a least six were.It is an FBI fiction persisted in throughout thislitigation that it has onlyelectronicsurveillances indices investigations."There are,and Item ll specifies,other forms of surveillance, like mail and physical surveillance,both relevant in this litigation,and these other forms ofsurveillanceare notincluded intheindices ofsubjectsof electronic.surveillance.(Thoseoverheard andthosementionedarenot"the indices of those mentioned and those overheard is undisputed and,in fact, outsidethislitigationtheFBIitselfhasdisclosedthis. ll.There also are,and specifically in this case there were,unauthorized electronic surveillances the existence ofwhich was first indicated,albeit involuntarily,in thedisclosure tomeofwhatremainedoftheallegedly 5 --- PAGE BREAK ---lly in this case there were,unauthorized electronic surveillances the existence ofwhich was first indicated,albeit involuntarily,in thedisclosure tomeofwhatremainedoftheallegedly 5 --- PAGE BREAK --- nonexistent Long tickler.These existed years after the request for permission wasnotgrantedandwaswithdrawnbythe FBI.Threeof the FBI's recordsin thecaserecordrelating to the requestand itswithdrawalareattached as exhibits.Exhibit 1 is the.Rosen toDeLoach memorandum of May 9,1968,written by R.E.L.,the initials of then supervisor (later assistant director) Richard E. Longof theLong tickler.Itrecommendsthat the FBI bugandwiretap Ray's relativesonthe theorythatitwouldhelpcatchhimand intheinterestof "national security."The"technical surveillance"itrefers to is the wiretapping, also referred to as TESUR."JUNE"added to thse records is the FBI code name for surveillances the recordsofwhich were keptoutside themain files.Whilethis recommendation was being considered by the FBIHQ hierarchy,the FBI's assistant director in charge of its Legal Counsel Division urged bugging Ray's sister and brother-in-law,Carol and Albert Pepper,on the theory that it could lead to his arrest.It admitsthat thisbuggingwould beunconstitutionalandwouldprovide the Peppers with basis for suing.If there were to be sucha suit,he concluded, "the governmentof the United States should surelybe willing topick up the tab for any judgmenthad against those whoinstalled the microphones."(Exhibit 2) Inthisproposalnobasis forbelieving thatRaywouldbeintouchwith those relatives is provided and in fact noneexisted.Ray had not seen his sister since shewasalittlegirlandhehadnoidea ofwhereshelived.(This alsowastrue ofhis brother John,whose place ofbusiness the FBI alsowanted to surveil electronicallyas itdidatleastphysically.) 12.The FBI's position is that it does not require the Attorney General's approval forbugging and inthis case it didnot seek it.On May18it requested permission to wiretap only.Attorney General Ramsey Clark did not grant it. After Ray's arrest,under date of June ll,Director Hooverwithdrew this request. 6case it didnot seek it.On May18it requested permission to wiretap only.Attorney General Ramsey Clark did not grant it. After Ray's arrest,under date of June ll,Director Hooverwithdrew this request. 6 --- PAGE BREAK --- frommeonthatbasis. 13.The"recorded"orindexed original ofExhibit3is not a MURKIN record.It is identified inthe margin as in 66-8160,where it is Serial 2987. The 66 file classification is officially "Administrative Matters." Actually; this particular"admat"file,66 (the FBI has several admats),is the one in which ithides electronicsurveillances records,including tapes.Thus,as the case record shows,when the Department asked the FBI to submitan inventory of all theholdings of the59 field offices relating to MURKINand their multitudinous actionsagainst Dr.Kingand 4o0pages of inventory were sentto FBIHQ, they do not inventory a single one of its countless tapes.The FBI merely omitted all citations of its 66 records.In this litigation,too, it has relevant information is included in the MURKIN file,about which more appears below.(This 66 file classification isnot theonly oneIidentified asholding relevant information thatthe FBI refused to search.Others include 91 and 94, aboutwhichmore appearsbelow.(Seeparagraphs57.and 60ff.) 14.Despite this request for permission towiretap and its ostentatious withdrawal,there ispersuasivereason tobelieve that the FBIwas already engaged in these electronic surveillances and had pulled "black bag" jobs,which require breaking and entering,to seek and,if found,steal what itwanted.Exhibit4 is the May 2,1968,FBIHQ order to the St.Louis office to"provide ful1 coverage"of John Ray's tavern.The case recordalsoholdsother"fullcoverage" s fieldoffices provided information that included their phone numbers.The coverage couldnotbe"full"withoutelectronic surveillances,and when only 7 --- PAGE BREAK ---ecordalsoholdsother"fullcoverage" s fieldoffices provided information that included their phone numbers.The coverage couldnotbe"full"withoutelectronic surveillances,and when only 7 --- PAGE BREAK --- physical surveillance was directed and performed, it was referred to and reported as only physical surveillance.(Code name FIsuR)In this case St.Louis was ordered to obtain financialinformation(allelse is withheldunder claim to exemptionnotpostedon therecorditself)thatordinarilywouldrequirea subpoena.St.Louiswas toldthatif nosubpoenawas availableitwas toget the information without subpoena if that"can be accomplishedwith full security formulation for"ifyou can doitwithoutgetting caught." 15.Of the persons listed in Item ll the disclosed MURKIN records towhich the FBIhas information it has not disclosed tome.I provided this information andthe FBIhas neither searched forwhat iswithheld not deniedhaving it.One illustration,again alisted member of the Rayramily,relates to the FBI's mail,physical and even bed surveillance of Jerry Ray.When the FBI learned frommail surveillance that hewas going to go to Camden,New Jersey,to visita woman,it made her an informer of the Newark field office.She then took Jerry toher bed.In its deep concern for privacy, the FBI disclosed her name, Marjorie Fetters.The MURKIN file.holds only what the FBIwanted that file to include of what she reported.The underlying information remains withheld.I correctly identified her informer file number, 137-6826,but the FBI refuses to makeanysearch.Notwithstanding the factthat ithadalreadydisclosedthat informer,it makesa"privacy"claimand alleges that Ihave made no showing at all when all of this andmuch more is in the case record.(In thislitigation the FBI disclosed the names of a number of its symbol informers,as I recall,a total of five.This does not include Patterson and Geppert,referred tobelow. 8 --- PAGE BREAK ---ecord.(In thislitigation the FBI disclosed the names of a number of its symbol informers,as I recall,a total of five.This does not include Patterson and Geppert,referred tobelow. 8 --- PAGE BREAK --- AfterIinformedit theFBIdidnotaskmetoreturnthosepagesor askto replacethemwithpages fromwhich thenameswere withheld.Oneof these disclosed informers was a woman reporting on the mafia in Chicago.To the best ofmy knowledge,these informersare also identified by name in the copies 16.Jerry Ray,who with the other Rays is included in my Item ll,was underphysicalsurveillance inanumber of midwesterncities.This is disclosed in the MURKIN records.Other surveillances of him,not included in the MURKIN records,are inother records the FBIdidnotdisclose tome.Itwould have learned this,assuming that it didnot know,if ithad consulted its indices but itrefused and stillrefusesto dothat,notwithstanding allithas made public relating to Jerry and other Rays.Aside from reflecting the actualities involved intheFBI'srefusaltosearchanditsallegedreasonforrefusingtosearch, privacy,this also reflects the fact that the MURKIN file isnot all inclusive and the FBIknowsitisnot.Moreaboutthis misrepresentation of the inclusivenessof theMURKIN file appearsbelow. 17.The three nonsurveillance Items in question relate largely to the plea bargaining that was the causeof nationaleditorialoutrage,particularly in theNewYork Times andthe Washington Post;tothoseincludedin theprosecution and defense,someofwhom were involvedin it;and to the official leaking that greatlyinfluenced theoutcome.Italsoincludes thewriterwhobought the exclusiveliterary rights in return fora guiltyplea,ashe testified,of all places,to the grand jury that indictedRay in Memphis.Prior to theguiltyplea the governmentitself disclosedthatitwas innegotiation and the identifications and comments of some ofthose involvedin itsnegotiations.(Theprosecution was 6 --- PAGE BREAK ---s.Prior to theguiltyplea the governmentitself disclosedthatitwas innegotiation and the identifications and comments of some ofthose involvedin itsnegotiations.(Theprosecution was 6 --- PAGE BREAK --- bargainingwith theKing familyand associates..Item8 is limited to this. 18.Atno time did theFBI ever ask meto inform itof thepublic interest involvedin these Items,butwhen asked by the court and the appeals office I did provide such information,across the board.From the outset,until it was, clearly,a futility,I voluntarily provided the FBI with proof that it was claiming director'sown words.Some of this alsowas in open court,when the judge openly ridiculed the FBI's claims.In the very first records processed,the FBI withheld what itknew was disclosedin the Tennessee court and theextradition hearing andwas published from coast to coast.From then until nowithasrefused to restore such information,withheldunderprivacyclaim. 19.Writers towhom the FBIleaked and whohadandused FBI recordsare included inItems 7of both theApril 15and December 23requests.With regard tothese writers,Ididnot request all the FBI's files on them or"the results of FBI investigations of them,"as the supplemental brief represents.What Idid equestiscopies of theinformationdisclosed tothemandrelated correspondence. Ofthesewriters: a)ClayBlair thanked the FBI for its help inhisbook and quoted FBI FBIrecordsverbatimin it; b)George McMillan has the content of FBI reports in his book and he claimed to have copies of Carol Pepper's financial records (see Exhibit4 above); c)Jeremiah O'Leary is disclosed by the FBI in this litigation to have agreed to submit his significantReaders Digest article for its editing prior to publication.When outside this litigation the FBI disclosed this and o'Learywas asked toexplainhis submissiontoprior censorship tohis 10 --- PAGE BREAK ---ders Digest article for its editing prior to publication.When outside this litigation the FBI disclosed this and o'Learywas asked toexplainhis submissiontoprior censorship tohis 10 --- PAGE BREAK --- peers,he stated,as without contradiction the case record reflects,that heused; d)Gerold Frankhad copies of FBI reports andused them verbatimin his book. e)William Bradford Huie,the writer who bought the exclusive rights to whatheexpectedwouldbeaconfessionofguiltwhilepresentinghimselfas Ray's defender,is disclosed in the FBIHQ MURKIN file tohavebeenbargaining with the FBI to sell Ray out.:The FBI knew it had other and extensive relevant Huie records not filed in MURKIN but it denied them to me.When my counsel made a separate request for them,many were provided to him. 20.In every instance, the relationship of all these writers to the FBI wasdisclosed by them,byitorbyboth thewriters andthe FBI. 21 With regard to Ray's counsel,the disclosed MURKIN records hold relating to legalmattersThese wereintercepted before entering themails despitetheorderofthetrialjudgethatitnotbedoneandassurancesthatit Iknow thisbecause prior toand outside this litigationIobtained copies not provided to me by theFBI from its MURKIN file.Raywrote the judge after publicationof the FBl/ReadersDigest/JeremiahO'Learyarticle thatifthejudge thejudgeandpleadguilty. theFBI'sleaking hadenormous influence on theabortingof thecriminalproceeding inwhich the FBI'sevidence wouldhavebeen subjectto cross-examination.AfterI 11 --- PAGE BREAK ---e thejudgeandpleadguilty. theFBI'sleaking hadenormous influence on theabortingof thecriminalproceeding inwhich the FBI'sevidence wouldhavebeen subjectto cross-examination.AfterI 11 --- PAGE BREAK --- examined the allegedevidence,Iwaswithoutdoubtabout this.I thusbelieve search,evenafterI provided itwith all the foregoing informationand muchmore. 23.In this supplemental brief(page 5,footnote 2) the FBI insists there isaprivacyquestion in-withholding frommewhat itadmits disclosing to another.At the same point it infers that when I filedprivacywaivers it searched and complied.It does not include all the privacywaivers Ifiledin thiscase and it does notrefute whatI provided showing that ithadrecords relating to its surveillancesof Mr.Fensterwald that ithas not searched for andhasnot provided.Ithasnot denied that ithasadditionalrelevantrecords relating to surveillances of me,proof of which I provided and is in the case record,but it file.My relevantappealsremain ignored. 24.Oliver Patterson was an FBI symbol informer.The FBI had him spy on the Ray family and defense counsel and this is within Item ll.Relevant as this is to MURKIN, no record suggesting it in any way is in the MURKIN files or was disclosedvoluntarily tome inanyother way.As Patterson later testified,the FBI hadhim alterone ofhis reportsinamanner thatmadeitprejudicial against Ray.It then askedhim to disclose himself as its informer and testify to this report before the House Select Committee on Assassinations.He objected,in writing,yet contrary toits claim that it never discloses an informer andwithholds only toprotectthem,overhiswritten objections itdisclosedhim to the committee -and not himalone among its informers.He thus was coerced intoworking for the 12 --- PAGE BREAK ---informer andwithholds only toprotectthem,overhiswritten objections itdisclosedhim to the committee -and not himalone among its informers.He thus was coerced intoworking for the 12 --- PAGE BREAK --- the committee as itsspy.In timeherebelled and wentpublic.Hecame to see me and he provided me with a privacywaiver.In response,when directed to,the FBI provided some records.Those records it provided refer to others neither provided nor claimed tobe withinanyFOIA exemption.Irequested them,Iappealed their denial,and I have had no response.These are unsearched-for."Top Echelon Informer"Patterson records and the Patterson records of an FBI committee of the samename,"TopEchelonInformer." 25.Patterson hada woman associate,Susan Wadsworth.She also came to acknowledgmentofreceipt ofher privacywaiver,Ihavenotreceived any FBI record relatingtoheror anydenialof the existence ofanyandmyappealremains ignored. 26.Another FBI symbol informerwho spied on the Ray family and defense (Item 1l) was Richard Geppert.Both he and Patterson spied on J.B.Stoner,who is included inmy request.Geppert appeared on St.Louis television and confessed s TV confession.Both then FBI counsel and theappeals office indicated that ifI provided this tape therelevant recordswould be disclosed.Iprovided the tape andI have notheardaword since,afterabout seven years. struggles extensively from New Orleans.He hada good rapportwith blacks and they reported what they saw and heard tohim.He toldme thathetookthis information to the FBI in Memphis,but there is no indication of this in any Memphis or FBIHQ records disclosed tome.There isaclear reflection of the FBI'seffort to refutewhathe reported.Iknowsome ofwhathe reportedbecausehe still had 13 --- PAGE BREAK ---ation of this in any Memphis or FBIHQ records disclosed tome.There isaclear reflection of the FBI'seffort to refutewhathe reported.Iknowsome ofwhathe reportedbecausehe still had 13 --- PAGE BREAK --- someof his notes and provided them tome.This informationincluded advance knowledge of the assassination,about which more appears below in connection with the FBI claim that all such information is in its MURKIN files.I have heard nothing atall since filing Herron'sprivacy waiver.Moreover,noAntonelli relating to the investigation of President Kennedy's assassination,has already disclosedinvestigatoryrecordsonhim. 28.With regard to what the FBI describes asa"laundry listof names," it represented to this Court that "it does not have to confirm or deny the has already done this in this litigation and elsewhere.Ido not recall that any one of the persons included in these items referred to asa"laundry list"is not included in the MURKIN records already disclosed.There thus is no genuine question of either confirmingor denyingbecause theFBIhasalreadyconfirmedand cannot deny"the existence of records pertaining to these individuals."Most of these recordsareavailablein the FBI'sownpublic reading room,where it deposits recordsprovidedtome. 29.Each of these persons is what Mr.Shea described as a “player,"a person with a sigmificant role,and thus,as he held and testified,"public interest" does exist.Were this not true,however,the allegation of this supplemental brief, thatI "failed to demonstrate sufficientpublic interest"(page 6)still would not be true.Whether or not this is required of an FoIA requester,I provided such informationunder oath to the district courtandto the defendant,with documentation that Ibelieve isextraordinarily extensive.Inmany meetingswith the FBI Ialso addressed"public interest"with regard to each person whosename came up.When these names came up in the consultancy intowhich I was virtually 14 --- PAGE BREAK ---ve.Inmany meetingswith the FBI Ialso addressed"public interest"with regard to each person whosename came up.When these names came up in the consultancy intowhich I was virtually 14 --- PAGE BREAK --- coercedbythe court atthedefendant'srequest,andthatreportisabout200 pages long,I provided exactly the kind of information the brief represents I didnotprovide. 30.The FBI has not refuted the accuracyof the information I provided. Itfilednocounter-affidavits. 3l.TheFBIhas a recordofwithholdingfrommewhat it discloses to others.To establish this I assisteda reporter friend in anotherpart of the assassination information.The FBI withheldhis already disclosed name and other information fromme.I then displayed several of the volumes ofrecords theFBI disclosed to my friend to the district court and thedefendant-withouta single additionalrecordbeingdisclosedoranyof the informationwithheldfromme althoughalreadydisclosedbeingrestoredtothe recordsthatwereprovided. (This man also was dead and the other requester hadprovided theFBI with proof ofhisdeath.) 32.Thereishalf-truth in theclaim(at the topofpage 6)that ithas "been theFBI'spositionbased on itsknowledge of its files that anyinformation about individuals relevant to the King assassinationand the ensuing FBI investigation is contained in the Bureau's MURKIN file."What is true is that this has been the FBI's position,persisted in despite the enormous amountof contrary evidence in the case record, those appeals and my consultancy report. files"because those very files disclosed to me establishbeyond question that it is not true.Moreover,my request is notlimited to individuals and it also is nottrue withregard toinformation other thanpertaining toindividuals.Italso is not true that all the information the FBIhas disclosed"is contained in the ·15 --- PAGE BREAK ---ividuals and it also is nottrue withregard toinformation other thanpertaining toindividuals.Italso is not true that all the information the FBIhas disclosed"is contained in the ·15 --- PAGE BREAK --- Headquarters.At the time of the King assassination FBIHQ also wasreferred to by FBIHQ and the field offices as "Seatof Government,"contracted on occasion to"SOG.") 33.The FBI took the same position before the district court,was proven tobewrong,andwascompelledtodisclosealargevolumeoffieldofficeMURKIN information thatwas notduplicatedatFBIHQ eventhough those recordswere the field officeMURKIN records. 34.Information relevant to the assassination andits investigation is in files other than MURKIN files thatwere disclosed to me.Included in these aretheFBIHQand Memphis filesona groupofyoung Memphisblackswho called themselves "the Invaders"and the files on the strike of theMemphis sanitation workers in support of which Dr.King was in Memphiswhen he was assassinated. (Seealsoparagraphs52ff.) 35.The FBI refused to disclose a file on the threat tokill Dr.King when he returned to Memphis,claiming itwas not relevantmerelybecause it was not classifiedby it asMURKIN.When the court compelledits disclosure,it revealed thatwhatwas threatened iswhat came topass andthattheFBI did not even bother tonotify the intendedvictim.(This is dealtwith at greater length in myreplybrief.) 36.The appeals director,inamemorandum the entire textof whichwas withheld from me butwas disclosed to another,informed the FBI that information is relevantby virtue of its content,not by how the FBI has it filed.It paid no attention to him and made no further searches. 37.In expanding on its seriousmisrepresentation about the alleged all- inclusiveness of MURKIN,in footnote 4 thebrief actually states thatby not 16 --- PAGE BREAK ---im and made no further searches. 37.In expanding on its seriousmisrepresentation about the alleged all- inclusiveness of MURKIN,in footnote 4 thebrief actually states thatby not 16 --- PAGE BREAK --- plaintiff actuallybenefited from the Bureau'sreasonable interpretation(sic)·of his request,which resulted in the release to himofmore material on the King assassination thanwouldhave been released through apiecemealapproach."This isnot cited tone caserecord and it cannotbe because itis not true. 38.Ihavereadeverywordoftheconsiderablevolumeofpaperdisclosed tomeinthislitigation andmostof ithasnothingatall todowith theKing assassination orwith my request.For themostpart itisa large collection of the utterly irrelevant,mostly junk compiled under MURKIN to create impressive investigation.In addition,to make these artificial statistics appear to be mileage inpersonal cars andother such things,and to report those statistics to FBIHQonamonthlybasis.Even whenthe fieldoffices asked toberelievedof this burden,theywere directed to continue compiling and providing their statistics. WeA junk that isnotwithinmyrequestdIhad no regular income. 40.A large percentage of the MuRKIN file consists of letters praising Director Hoover and the FBI,not uncommonly from those who expressed extreme rightwingbelief andwhodescribed Dr.KingasaCommunist enemywhodeserved killing.The MURKIN file includes the careful check of FBI indices and records oneach:letterwriterbefore therewas any response.Italsoincludes the responses,none of which Iasked for,wantedorhas any relationship to the crime. 17 --- PAGE BREAK ---check of FBI indices and records oneach:letterwriterbefore therewas any response.Italsoincludes the responses,none of which Iasked for,wantedorhas any relationship to the crime. 17 --- PAGE BREAK --- 4l.It includes all the many dr eams,visions and theories thatwere 42.It includes,and I had to pay for, the many pages representing the considerableexpense the FBI wentto to read,analyzeandindexeverywordof Ayn Rand's writing on the theory that Ray adopted his aliases from her writings. This actually began with receiptof one of those nut letters.The FBI wasted all that time,effortand money after itknew there was nothing to this theory and that Rayused as aliases the names ofrealpeople.Itwas theKansasCityoffice which used theCanadianphonebookand made the discovery.Itreported thisto “GH the very day the FBI disclosed that theperson using thataliaswas in fact James Earl Ray.Itwas on Apri1 18,1968,exactly two weeks after the assassination. 43.It includes clippings of the newspapers that used this Ayn Rand concoctionafteritwasleaked. 44.It includesa great volume of racist diatribes sent to FBIHQ,andI certainly did not regard it as a"benefit" to have to pay for or read such stuff. 45.Ididnot requestbut itincludes a considerable volume ofpaper relating to the obviousfabrications of ayoung.drugoffendernamedByron Watson whocookedupafanciful taleinanunsuccessfulefforttoescapeconfinement. It includes a second volume of worthless paper relating to this after Mark Lane and Dick Gregory used the boy'sfabrication on coast-to-coastTV and to the White House.That triggered still another volume of paperI did not ask for,want to wastetimeonorwanttohavetopayforwhenIhadnoregularincome. 46.There is an astounding amount of similar paper.-volumes of it- reporting the FBI's wasted time in tracking down such reports,all compiled into those statistics,all used to support the claim thatit"leftno stone unturned." 18 --- PAGE BREAK ---per.-volumes of it- reporting the FBI's wasted time in tracking down such reports,all compiled into those statistics,all used to support the claim thatit"leftno stone unturned." 18 --- PAGE BREAK --- Andallhadnorelationshiptothecrime. 47.Itincludes all themanyrecords relating tothecollectionof soil samples from various parts of the country and fromRay's abandoned automobile andthereportsof thelaboratory'stestingofthosesamples,whichI didnot request,didnotwantand did not and do not,after reading theentire MuRKIN file,believe isrelevant toanything. 48.It does not,however,include such essential evidence as the results ofthecustomaryswabtesttodeterminewhethertherifletheFBIreferstoasthe "death"rifle had been fired after its lastcleaning and itdoes not include any proof that that rifle was used in the crime.In fact-and from the records provided,without test firingitalthoughrifles not allegedly used in the crime were test fired-the FBILabstated itcould notprove that the"death"bullet came from thatrifle. al! 49.Itdoesnot includetheFBI's records relating toits performanceof spectrographic andneutron-activation analyses.These are generally considered to be significant tests thatyield sigmificant results,important in criminal investigations andin the identification of bulletmaterial.Without question such records belong in MURKIN,the file on the"Murder of King." 50.Describing MURKIN as the FBI's file"on the King assassination" (brief,page 6) is misleading because the FBI did not investigate the crime itself. Itsstatement thatitdid not is in the MURKIN fileand the case record.When the FBI was subject to criticism, some of it unfair,like that of Mark Lane and Dick Gregory,itdefended itselfbysaying that itsinvestigationwas of a fugitive case,UFAC.(UFAC means unauthorized flight to escape confinement.Ray had escaped from.the Missouri State Penitentiary.)This self-defense is not entirely true.The file does hold the results of theconsiderable FBI effort tomake it 19ized flight to escape confinement.Ray had escaped from.the Missouri State Penitentiary.)This self-defense is not entirely true.The file does hold the results of theconsiderable FBI effort tomake it 19 --- PAGE BREAK --- appear that Ray was guilty of the assassination but it does not reflect any exculpatory and potentially exculpatory evidence the FBI could notavoid,and it avoids entirely all its substantial indications of a conspiracywhile conducting exhaustive investigations of all the clearly insubstantial and downright silly reportsofaconspiracy. 5l.In describing not "treating the specificitems of plaintiff's request"(page 6)as benefiting me,thebriefdoes not cite the case record. There isno such evidence in the case record but the exact opposite abounds in it.Beginningthemomentthe FBIdisclosed that itwasgoing to giveme the MURKIN file instead of searching to comply with my request,the case record holds myuncontradictedcomplaints that a)Ihadnot requested theMURKIN file andb) thatentirefilecouldnotbegintocomplywithmyrequest. 52.In carrying forward the falsepretense that the FBI was doing mea big favor and givingme all Irequestedand more,there isanother footnote at thispoint.Itidentifies other alleged FBI generosities as "on several groups and subjects (e.g.,the Invaders and the Memphis Sanita tion Workers strike)." requests."This statement provides a means of evaluating the FBI's response to my request and the dependability of its brief because the FBI's recordsrelating areItem27。 53.Partof the FBI's self-described"reasonable"approach was to refuse toprovide these files originallyand in compliance withmyrequest.Whatever explains the FBIposition that two specific Items of itmake those Items "not within the scope of"the request,it isa fact that those fileshold seriously embarrassinginformation and information that,without question,is relevantto both the assassination anditsinvestigation yet is not inMURKIN.Theyhold the 20 --- PAGE BREAK ---those fileshold seriously embarrassinginformation and information that,without question,is relevantto both the assassination anditsinvestigation yet is not inMURKIN.Theyhold the 20 --- PAGE BREAK --- background to the assassination as well as facts relating to it.They disclose new FBI dirty tricks against Dr.King,like planting stories thathe was an (anti-black) racistby refusing to stay at the black motel atwhich its own took him elsewhere.They disclose spying on Dr.King and his associates.They hold significant and detailed information about the extensive domestic intelligence operations carried on jointlyby the FBI and thelocal police and the FBI's extensive distribution of such information-evenits attempts toharm thefamilies.of theyoungerpeopleitdid notlike.(Wheretheyoungpeopleand preachers were white the FBI slandered them,attempted toportray them as Communists.It pretended that white women were seeking black sex.It pursued ayoung unmarriedpregnantblackwoman student relentlessly,investigated to identifythe father ofher childandspreaddetailedreports ofwhereherrelatives had public employment in its effort to attract retribution against them.)When theFBI's.investigation disclosedthemurder ofablackyouthbyMemphispolice, rights"matter althouth it ostensibly was conductinga civilrights investigation (The FBIHQ MURKIN file is 44-3886i,the classification 44 representing civil rights.)These two files disclose that FBI special agents referred tomature black males as "boys"and even as“monkey faced."They disclose that this domestic political matters. They disclose that three it named of the top leaders of the Memphis NAACPwere symbol FBI informers.(These three are not included in its five informeridentificationsofwhichIinformed theFBIbecausebythetime these filesweredisclosed it was apparent that the FBIdisclosedthese identifications purposely or did not care about such disclosuresbecause it never onceresponded.) 21 --- PAGE BREAK ---usebythetime these filesweredisclosed it was apparent that the FBIdisclosedthese identifications purposely or did not care about such disclosuresbecause it never onceresponded.) 21 --- PAGE BREAK --- 54.The first person to reach the body of the fallen Dr.King was a moreeffectively. 55.These two sets of files in which,according to the brief,Ihad merely expressed later andcasual interest·butin fact specifically included in my request,by name,are not insignificant in ways not related to the assassination. They areof considerable public interest.After Imade themavailable toothers they were the subject of two collegiate"honors papers."The strike file is the subject ofaprofessor's scholarlypaper in thecurrent issue of The South Atlantic Quarterly, published by Duke University,as"A Case Study in Urban Surveillance"bytheFBI. 56.Despite the inclusion of these Items in my request,despite the fact that anyexamination ofthespecific Items oftherequest discloses that mostare notappropriate for filing under"themurderof King"caption,and despite the fact that the FBI never claimed or even represented that itclaimed tohave examinedits own indices,the brief alsostates at thispoint thatmy request 57.Another of the relevant FBI files correctly identified in the case record,without contradiction by the FBI,is its 94 classification.Although the FBI describes this classification as for "Research Matters,"it in fact is where the FBI hides.andby thisclassificationalone avoidson search its records pertaining to its own leaking,the press,publishers andwriters,the electronic media andits lobbying,all ofwhich,at the time of the King assassination,were handled by thedivision titled"Crime Records."When on depositionI established 22 --- PAGE BREAK ---dwriters,the electronic media andits lobbying,all ofwhich,at the time of the King assassination,were handled by thedivision titled"Crime Records."When on depositionI established 22 --- PAGE BREAK --- that the FBI's own search slips listed withheld 94 records for which no claim to exemption wasmade,then FBI counsel refused to even ask it to search its 94 files.My appeal remains ignored and the correctly identified and relevant files remainunsearched.I identifieda number of these 94 files as havingpossibly relevant information.Some examplesare:94-3-4-221 holds information relating to 0'Leary,the Readers Digest and the very article in question;94-8 fileholds information about0'Leary and theWashington Star andanother 94-3 file relates Frank.These relate to specific Items and persons in my request. 58.Refusing to search to comply with the Items of my requests is not abnormal for the FBI.It is normal.InC.A.78-0322/0420 combined the FBIalso substituted files of its selection,without search being made,as'it actually admitted in that litigation.(By this means that litigation is stonewalled, nowintoitssixthyear.) 59.Anothermatter in the case record reflectingthe FBI's certain knowledge that.is directly opposite to what it now represents to this Court is the content of its ticklers.The MURKIN records themselves refer to several King assassination ticklers maintained by different supervisorsbywhosenames they are identified.Then supervisor,later assistant director,Richard E.Long had a large one,as supervisor Jack Lawn also did.After the FBI made several untruthful representations,that these did not exist,then that they could not be located (without ever asking either supervisor),I told the appeals office how itcould locate theLong tickler and it did.It then turnedoutthat thistickler had been gutted after thislitigationwas filed.After gutting it still held King assassinationrecords that are not from the MURKIN file. 60.The FBI's conspiracy theory of the King assassination,and contrary 23n gutted after thislitigationwas filed.After gutting it still held King assassinationrecords that are not from the MURKIN file. 60.The FBI's conspiracy theory of the King assassination,and contrary 23 --- PAGE BREAK --- to itspublicstatements itdid theorize that the crime was the result ofa conspiracy,in in its 91 or bank robbery files.One record thatescaped the Longmemory hole(attached as Exhibit 5)apparently because it holds statements aboutmethat appear tobeprejudicial and suitable for leaking,identifies three of the relevant 9/files in which Iam mentioned.After discovering this in the Long tickler,Iobtained access to additional disclosed and relevant 91 files and provided copies for the case record identifying a total of five such files by their number,with indications that others must exist inother field offices. (The Springfield office,where all of this originated,responded tomy request for all records on or about me by stating that it had none at all,an obvious untruth.)What this record saysaboutme is carefully.angledtobe prejudicial It does disclose,however,that the FBI received and refused to respond to my 1969 King assassination requests because itdoes not like me. 6l.While as Exhibit5states it is true thatI havebeen criticalof the FBI,it also is true thatonnumerous occasionsI have defended it against unfair charges such as those referred to above.OneIrecall very well ismaking useof an appearance on GoodMorning America,for which·I flewfromDallastoNew York whenI was ill,to defend the FBI against Mark Lane's and Dick Gregory's fabrications. 62.I knew of the FBI's bank robbery conspiracy theory,which is based on the fiction that Ray's brothers robbeda series of banks to finance him after supposed heists.I therefore knew that the onlywayI could be associated with becausehethenwastheonlyRaywithwhomI'dhadanycontactandmycontactwith 24 --- PAGE BREAK ---ries of banks to finance him after supposed heists.I therefore knew that the onlywayI could be associated with becausehethenwastheonlyRaywithwhomI'dhadanycontactandmycontactwith 24 --- PAGE BREAK --- him had been exclusively when he phoned me.We are both,I note,included in my Itemllonsurveillances. 63.Theseother disclosed 9l fire records that remain withheld fromme despitemyappealafterprovidingthemforthecaserecorddoestablishthatthe FBI's source was telephonic.They also disclose physical surveillance of Jerry Ray,which also is within Item ll.Having disclosed physical surveillance of all the Rays in St.Louis in the MURKIN files, physical surveillance of Jerry Ray outside of St.Louis and in other than the MURKIN files,and of telephone surveillance of Jerry Ray and me,the FBI now takes the position that it cannot disclosewhat ithasnot searched for in this litigation,allegedly on grounds of life and thatof thewomen in his life.(The FBI also disclosed MURKIN records reporting thatunmarried John Ray sleptwitha woman he took toa cheaphotel and 11of its own records that Iprovided.Itmerelyignored this evidence,as the appealsalsowereignored. 64.Even a key element in the official solution to the King assassination The only alleged eyewitness was an alcoholic with a record of violence,Charles Quitman Stephens.He lived in the flophouse,next to the bathroom from which the FBI claims the fatal shot was fired.A disclosed MURKIN Memphis record reports in summary-paraphrase what is not faithful to fact,that when Stephens was shown aphotograph of Ray he wasuncertainof identification.Thereafter the FBI and Civil Rights Division gothim to sign three different affidavits,all identifying Ray.One was used in the extraditionproceeding and was disclosed to me in the FOIA lawsuit referredtoin Exhibit5.But the recordsofinterviewon which the 25