CDS ANGELES TIMES HOWARD ROSENBERG ‘Guilt or Innocence’: Trial or T he man who is serving a 99-year sentence for the murder of the most celebrat- ed civil rights leader of our time faces America, a silvery, spike - haired, passive figure with folded hpnds. His body, in prison grays, is relaxed. His gaze, through eye- glasses with dark frames, is flat. Except for a trace of a grimace, his face is clueless, expressionless, re- vealing nothing. !"0n the Fourth of April , 1968, at approximately 6.-01 in the afterrwon, did you fire, shoot at and murder Martin Luther King Jr?' \" No, l didn't." •At age 64, James Earl Ray is finally getting the public trial he’s been seeking for more than 24 y£ars. Real judge. Real lawyers. Real jury. Real courtroom. Real witnesses. Real testimony. | On television. | But the jury’s decision that will be announced at the conclusion of "Guilt or Innocence: The Trial of Jfcmes Earl Ray"— airing at 8 p.m. Sfinday on HBO— will be binding only on public opinion. A guilty verdict will speak for itself. Yet eyen if "acquitted” by these 12 hired -for -TV jurors, Ray would remain in Nashville’s Riverbend Maximum Security Institution. T ike Ross Perot and President Lj Clinton, though, Ray is using television to take his case directly tp the people. His conventional legal options apparently exhausted, Ray is hoping a favorable verdict here will win public support for the afctual jury trial that he’s been denied ever since withdrawing his original guilty plea in March, 1969. J This isn’t cable’s Court TV, \fhich beams actual criminal trials into America’s households. Nor is it "{The Judge," "Divorce Court” or ajiy other comically phony court- room series. Airing on the 25th anniversary of King’s murder, Sunday ’8 largely tedious three - hour special is a blending of the authentic and the artificial, further obscuring the line on TV separat- ing what’s real and what isn’t. ; Controversial figures, from Lee Harvey Oswald to Alger Hiss to Bernhard Goetz, have had their (Jays in TV’s mock courtrooms. And a tabloid series gave that media asteroid Amy Fisher a mock tfrial recently. Unlike these, how- ever, "The Trial of James Earl Ray” features no professional ac- tors. And unlike a similar HBO program on Kurt Waldheim's al- leged war crimes— produced by the ..same British documentary maker. Jack Saltman, who guides i The Trial of James Earl Ray”— the imprisoned subject of this event as real as its other participants, Appearing in an actual Memphis ’{courtroom through a satellite hookup to Riverbend. ! Presiding over the trial is Marvin J3. Frankel, former U.S. District i Court judge for New York. The jprosecutor is W. Hickman Ewing, iormer U.S. attorney for the West- ern District of Tennessee. Repre- senting Ray is his actual attorney, •William F. Pepper (who pitched Jthe idea for the trial to HBO). The jjurors, many of whom take notes ^during the trial, were selected from 'three states. J And everything on the screen, espite all these accouterments of reality, however, what you {see is not a real trial. For one thing, 1 there’s a voice-over commentary [from Chari ay ne Hunter-Gault of -"The MacNeil/Lehrer NewsHour” Ion PBS. For another, the three J hours that viewers will see are a [mere sliver of the actual testimony, ; which HBO says took 10 days to i tape. Ray alone was questioned and J cross -examined on camera for /more than five hours. The spe- cial— edited "in conjunction with” ) attorneys for both sides— grants ; him about a half hour. '• No matter how skilled or honest {the editing, it’s impossible to com- J press an event so severely without /dramatically altering its reality. iThus, the truncated Ray trial seen ; {by viewers is much narrower than * j the one observed by its jury. » One also has to wonder about the Entertainment? ! impact of makeup and micro- j, phones, and of TV’s presence in general. It’s almost a given that the * behavior of witnesses and the per- ceptions of jurors— to say nothing jof their concentration— would be •affected by the presence of camer- * as either in their faces or looking ; { over their shoulders. That’s in ri contrast to real televised trials in if which a single stationary camera is j nobtrusively deployed at the rear J of the courtroom. ^ What will the jurors decide? The bigger question is whether anyone * will be awake to hear. J If deformed in other areas, the •special does reek of the monotony /that typifies most trials. Smart {viewers will do their own editing {and skip the deadly first hour (it’s [only a show, after all> and tune in {for Ray’s testimony and the de- fense. Ray is hardly electrifying. J But at least his presence resonates { history, and you can’t help angrily * measuring him against King, ! whom he is said to have shot with a J high-powered rifle from the win- J dow of a flophouse as the great i black leader stood with associates ! on the balcony of the Lorraine '“Motel in Memphis. TV REVIEW ‘River’ Shows Drama of King, Memphis Strike T he 25th anniversary of Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination Sunday will inspire various sentiments, spurts of memory and more than a few TV specials, but “At the River I Stand” (at 11 p.m. Sun- day on KCET-TV Channel 28) puts King’s cruel felling in Memphis on April 4, 1968, into a profound context. What brought King to Mem- phis was a spiral of events that had the superhuman momentum of a revolution. Memphis sanitation workers, suffering under brutal condi- tions and earning wages low enough to qualify them for wel- fare, staged a Febfuary, 1968, walkout when two workers were accidentally killed in a truck's trash compactor. It had been six years since T. 0. Jones had tried to organize his fellow workers into a union, and now, it seemed possible. Filmmakers David Appleby, Dr. Allison Graham and Steven John Ross intercut a raft of Ray repeats his off -stated story that the murder weapon traced to him was one he bought at the behest of a mystery man named Raoul, and that he wasn’t told what it would be used for. He maintains, again, that he never stalked King across the country and that his original, later- recanted confession was coerced. Ewing’s edited cross- examination is brisk, but not pene- trating. period news footage with fresh interviews with many of the witnesses to the Memphis sea- change, and despite Paul Win- field’s subdued narration, you can feel the waves of this sea- change coming at you. Remarkably, considering that the civil rights movement had long before established itself and won major social victories, it wasn’t quite the force to move its opponents— personified here by Memphis Mayor Henry Loeb— who remained arrogantly intransigent. L oeb, a colleague says, had “a plantation mentality,” but the benign dictatorship this im- plies turned crude and bloody as support grew for the sanitation workers. The film shows that, had Loeb agreed to the workers’ demands to organize, King would never have needed to come to Memphis to lead a mass march. When that march turned violent and beyond King’s con- trol, Memphis became a national battleground: Would established Amid an onslaught of forensic reports and other arid testimony, some other moments stand out: Journalist Earl Caldwell testifies that he saw a man crouching in the bushes near the Lorraine Motel about the time King was shot. That account generally matches those of other witnesses to the shooting who have said their stories were never checked out by the FBI. Former FBI agent Arthur Mur- white power create a kind of police state, and would King’s nonviolent dream turn into a nightmare? The famous “I’ve been to the mountaintop” speech becomes something much more than a sample of flowing King oration in “At the River I Stand.” It is arguably an even greater speech (shown here at great length) than his “I have a dream” mas- terpiece because, in Memphis, King was responding to a spon- taneous movement of poor peo- ple, and connecting with previ- ously untapped levels of passion. It was the unorganized nature of events that saw King rise to one of his greatest hours, and prob- ably led to his death. The combination of the Rev. Harold Middlebrook’s superbly reflective comments, King's fu- neral and the workers’ rapid victory ends the film on a note of sad triumph, of exuberant loss, the complex emotions of a nation finding its way. -ROBERT KOEHLER tagh breaks down briefly and cries while testifying that the bureau had been systematically fabricat- ing stories to “denigrate King’s character” before his death. The implication, one voiced in the past by Murtagh and others, is that the J. Edgar Hoover- led FBI conspired to assassinate King. In the trial, Murtagh claims to have evidence that the FBI was part of a “plot” to kill King, even though it didn’t FRIDAY, APRIL 2, 1993 actually pull the trigger. He is not asked to state his evidence. Meanwhile, some other ques- tions remain unanswered. Is this, as its backers claim, really the most thorough probe of the King F29*: murder to date? Or, as skeptic? might argue, is it impossible f6f~ something as inherently synthetic as a tailored -for -TV trial to evef mount a serious investigation thpt^ elevates truth over entertainment? *