Court Rejects FBI Blanket Secrecy Rule Source Confidentiality Must Go Cqse-by-Case < f • • Neuter ^ ' A unanimous Supreme Court yes- terday rejected a government re- quest for an across-the-board rule that the FBI can keep secret the identities of all sources in criminal investigations. In a case dealing with disclosure under the federal Freedom of In- formation Act, the high court ruled that a source cannot automatically be considered confidential whenev- er the FBI gets information during a criminal investigation. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said in the court’s 15-page opinion that the narrowly defined circum- stances of the case must provide the basis for determining whether a source was deemed confidential and thus exempt from disclosure. Tor example, it is reasonable to infer that paid informants normally expect their cooperation with the FBI to be kept confidential,” she said. “Similarly, the character of the crime at issue and the source’s re- lation to the crime may be relevant to determining whether a source cooperated with the FBI with an implied assurance of confidential- ity,” O'Connor said. The case before the high court stemmed from a request for infor- mation from the FBI by Vincent Landano, who had been convicted of killing a New Jersey policeman dur- ing a 1976 robbery. He had filed the request with the FBI, which had helped investigate the killing, for its files in the case in the hope of finding evidence that would support his claims of inno- cence. In the several hundred pages that the FBI turned over to Landano, much of it was blacked out while the law enforcement agency withheld altogether several hundred other pages— apparently to “protect” its sources. In other action yesterday, the Supreme Court denied an appeal by E. Robert Wailach, a close friend and adviser to former attorney gen- eral Edwin Meese III, seeking the dismissal of all charges against him l in the Wedtech scandal. The justices let stand a ruling by a .U.S. Court of Appeals in New York rejecting Wallach's arguments that the theft and conspiracy charges must be thrown out on dou- ble-jeopardy grounds. The high court’s action cleared the way for a retriaL Wailach, 56, a San Francisco law- yer, was convicted in 1989 of ac- cepting more than $400,000 in il- legal payments from Wedtech, a now-defunct Bronx defense con- tractor, to influence Meese on gov- ernment contracts. Meese, the attorney general un- der President Ronald Reagan, was never charged with any criminal wrongdoing in his extensive deal- ings with Wailach.