* •V.' V:?v;- ?• v«. t 'V» J ,1 ». -•*- V * ’ « iy 0> ;-w. r- »«* r ’ «. I ; Wi.---Jr. MEMORANDUM FOR MR. TOLSCN MIU BGLMONT •> »i o - * • ./-I 4' * Yva R *e.M ':'• - O 'nM i. f-ca/o/J MR. MOHR MR. CONRAD MR. D£ LOACH MR. EVANS \ MR. ROSEN MR. SULLIVAN • *» t «*». I-- - . j» . •>« I f* i i • i. ' • eo^ian DC * u . * *tr. Leo hankln called fron bew York to check In with me on ^ >* K .,; tho msttor of tho Commission. Re wanted to work out An arrangement with v r\ o > j^o which he thought might be eatlefactory. He aald be onderetood y * iiit. Belmont bandlod the Investigation. / / 7 I told Mr. Kankln that Mr. Belmont, Mr. .Rosea end I handled 5 tho preparation ol tho report and will handle additional leads as they come 9 1^=; 5^1 •' ".v1 t hVV in. *«.r •. «v -f .*.. s » » v- Mr. iXanUn asked how ho ehoold handle anything that cornea op, § things tho Commleslon wlU want developed further, in regard to the 1 £X • ® whether thoy ahould bo handled directly with mo or eomebody X vould^ : § designate. I ?y,'i Hi U .cji oft.® (,2 -ICIO’IO X replied thf.t ^ vIII designate aomeone. I explained thttl aent -k l thtt 1 i e w • e.jiH K * .» I, iir. Malloy down to L«\llaa to handle all of our angles down there; that he was i n the ground there; and that X IMok he probably would be the man who would bo more familiar with things Mr. Rankin ehoutd furthor exploro. 1 etatod Mr. l.^Uey 18 In Dallas at the proeent time but will bo ordered back tomorrow; that ho will bo available; and that we WlU be glad to run .oatany-—» additional matters ho may wont. 3 • * ‘ B r,;;c 17 i333 1 • X c dviecd Mr. Rankin of the difficulty I have had about the -v ' fer. 'fe* \ % .fc-/ 'it 1^ vV s. ’ V ^apartment's dcclre to iaeue certain conclusions; that they wTThleS to tesuo f. . V . < 4 4. At AA..1 m i *r. "j—a euicment btforu tho report went to tho Commission reaching conclusion* ; . —i—Ocv/ald was tbo aeeasoln, no foreign or eubvorelvo element Involved, and — juaj j)ew'fld hod no connection; that X Ur.tly disagreed; thoy took I iv<- Uvtti *1 , net t. No Ml . *dy -CWf TELCVPE UMiT o *y 4* V‘Vs i jj^'XEIiOX 'r •* \7' DEC 18 X& ' *. — ..9 * ^ 4A..A*f» .Js..nnection; that X Ur.tly disagreed; thoy took I iv<- Uvtti *1 , net t. No Ml . *dy -CWf TELCVPE UMiT o *y 4* V‘Vs i / /• jj^'XEIiOX 'r •* \7' DEC 18 X& ' *. — ..9 * ^ 4A..A*f» .Js.. --- PAGE BREAK ---■V/‘- • .. u< /.•»,, . i * Memorandum for Messrs. Tolson, Bc-lmonl, Mohr,. December 12, 19£3 V Conrad, Do Loach, Evans, Rosen, fiulllvaa ,>4 >>V'*vY ■'*!' * 1’-' ;• V’V 'V*. Vl/r* • / ; Vi >*v/r; *: ‘ ;» ‘r&biJ V.v . V-*» * - •••' > *.“.!•'/ -V . */V;: '.•.?•/■ V. ;V „ ... _ ' * “>• -V r- i i ♦ .-i. ' It up with tho White House and tho President agreed with me that we should •• vv re^ch no conclusion; nevertheless tho report does reach two conclusions in :i *:• 6ubstance. - fV . ' l.‘ itv.-.t'. • \ * t '■# 1 said I personally believe Oswald was the assassin; that the V.'V second aspect as to whether ho was the only man gives me great concern; v c that wo have several letters, not In the report because we were not able to .*:'! ' prove It, w ritten to him from Cuba referring to tho Job ha was going to do, *' his good marksmanship, and stating when it was all over he would be brought back to Cuba and presented to the chief; that wo do not know If tho chief wa« Castro and cannot mnko an Investigation because we have no intelligence operation In Cuba; that I did not put this in tho report because we did not have proof of It and didn’t want to put speculation in the report; that thi* was the reason I urged strongly that we not reach conclusion Oswald was tho only man. • % ik*' 1 >‘*1* . * + «■*. vN .'y ‘* s v " ■ As to Rubensteln, I said I did not want a statement about • V' Rubcnotcln and Oswald; that we have no proof they were ever.together. t > stated Kubcnstein is a shady character from the hoodlum element of Chicago, has a poor background, runs a nightclub In Dallas, and is what would be called a police buff; that tho police officers in that precinct have been ablt to get food and liquor from him at any tlrao they drop in; that while I think V there was no connection between him and Oswald, 1 did not want tho report to bo 100% sure on that. • : * • W «. • ft •- •ry<.--- PAGE BREAK --- • : * • W «. • ft •- •ry<. $L*Y>: * ~ * w • \ t v - V V ; « J * t $ * Fourth, I elated I did not bolleve any conclusions concerning Vv * Kubenzleln should be reached at tills time because he has not been tried; ; that was why I suggested to tho Attorney General of Texas - and understood tho Chief Justice did too - that his court of special inquiry bo held in abeyance until after tho Commission makes Its findings. I said I thought they would • go ahead with tho Rubensteln trial in February; that was why 1 felt our report should name mf rely tho facts we have establlohed. L'-; . 4 . r. ***** . ■ s • V * I further stated there may be some aspects Mr. Rankin will ' W'ant.lo liave ru.Vout further; that there may bo letters written to members of th<| Commission; that we have letters from people who claim to have seen .. Oswald; that up to tho time wo submitted tho report we had cleared up all. theoo angles except the Cuban thing which I discussed generally and explained thal Uio Inform* r recanted and blow that angle out of the window; that sort > ‘ of filing may bo popping up all the time. I advised Mr. Rankin if he wanted - ^ M ^ »» * any we \ fc r loads followed out or any Implementation of what wo have already done* * ’ will give him 100% cooperation. .vdv.r. . . • . ’ . *Jd' t ' •.* • ,*■*. ,* • a* ' 4 ■*' ■ ! V ' . *► v* * ‘ * * • . *♦ »■' . Mr. Rankin stated ho know wo would; that he just wanted to establish liaison; that ho does not want to bother ruo until properly.,: _ V-: ■ • v. k". ‘ it- ■;. / sp’v 7. vt r'-'- t. - •. r'i '■if i-tt i» i'?"* 'i '■ ff-YY » Hr ti'lt ,,V.» •c..,' •■'. ■?;: , '■ ,r v|*:'w>' ' 4a • v # 4 / r;,< k V V * .1 ► V •* 4*? ♦ '4 .7 ( v > V* *•**-'*, 4 V * * • ' . *Sr » «rV \l * r<-.% v . v,- ^i-;:;V 1 establishing it RS a matter I should know. 1 told him not to hesitate to call me; that 1 will designate Mr. Malley and he will advise me at once of :;.vv%^r\ anything. Mr. Rankin then said he would get in touch with me If he thinks i: V tliCre In anything which should be taken up on that level. .. . .. ., As ■ >*». <-» r,‘* I mentioned to him the actions of the Soviet Embassy, the Communist Party In New York, and Joh^^ot In making available to ui"'** 1L«l - i».. . vs t « . . . i . . jl . i w •• tholr Information on Oswald/ v s '? 7 '/*.*••• Vj Vj;4- •-• & P+ ' Q-Ut ■> ;fy ~ V... * > • • r . •• *ry : : (/** ^ ^ ^ " ' I also discussed the operations of theJDallasJ^^otlce Department In the case which led to tho murder of Oswald. A- _ . ' 1 told fc7. Rankin the Department held the report about five days and then began to leM^tcmfe from the Department on It, items such as the V- Shooting of Ckmorc^alkerJ things not known In Dallas; that 1 kept pressing 4 ' (hemTo get UurYeport to tho Commission; that a debate was going on between ,c the Department and me; that 1 did not want any conclusion drawn but 1 thought * a conclusion had been made in the letter of transmission to the Commission; that there would have been no purpose in appointing a Presidential Commission except to evaluate the facts; that It was the duty of the EDI to get the facta and let the Commission reach a conclusion. -V7V“ »V £ -f- r* r , ’•■**•* 4 * *4 L • *•; MV*.* * * 'r ys f. «?. n ‘ ■» •' Mr.--- PAGE BREAK --- «?. n ‘ ■» •' Mr. Rankin Inquired if anything had been dono about seeing '/ that the films would be preserved and available for the Commission I answered that we have them ourselves; that we have films taken by private Individuals; that the President was not being covered by a^car with television people as they do here in Washington; that there was not a'professlonal f ’ photographer whore this took place; that the Secret Service car immediately in bacx had already passed the building, which was at an anglo, with the . ‘ result they couldn’t tell where tho shots were coming from. I mentioned ' tho comment by formor Chief of Secret Service Baughman that ho could not f understand why tho Secret Service men did not open fire with machine guns * jjr at tho window. | said tho Secret Servlco men did not soo whero the shots . ... - came from and would havo killed a lot of Innocent people If thoy had done , * .*7" . \ . > .* -■ .• . * 7- '.■a #;*?£• *1 i*r - ^ • *.* . '’■•V** *V., # •* * - **...* *\.r^ ..r i * V- :7 - In connection with stories indicating Oswald could not have. ‘ < •* > dono this alone4 I elated ho was a marksman and it wasn’t anything ho k ’ - \$-i , C- - . v .• . . • * "’r '* . • ♦ ' JC' . 7 • T* • • * * . I told Mr. Rankin we would want to do anything we can here to '.. make his Job easier. He eaid he has always had complete confidence la A ‘ J" ’ that and in me.M;\. . u ’ * :X f. ir, * t. ; *’ ' H V • • fr* \ r/ . f-. *■77^; v' ■A ■ .'>£ fts i;: ■; - . mm III >: •*■-7 3&-v ■m r4 f,y n/)>; - V- t'V;',; -y f • 4** u.’ikiSr;^<• v•; ;v;»w’vf*4:W* •, >. i . t * « ■V. rr '-■V --- PAGE BREAK ---. f-. *■77^; v' ■A ■ .'>£ fts i;: ■; - . mm III >: •*■-7 3&-v ■m r4 f,y n/)>; - V- t'V;',; -y f • 4** u.’ikiSr;^<• v•; ;v;»w’vf*4:W* •, >. i . t * « ■V. rr '-■V --- PAGE BREAK --- r» n ■ o o O — Memorandum for Messrs. Tolson, Belmont, Mohr, December 12, 1963 . Conrad, DeLoach, Evans, Rosen, SulUvaa . ....• t . -f «.«w ,l *1 * % • - rat, . C7 •; v T* ,:»V could not do; that we have tested It on our rifle range and were able to get . sbote off even faster than he did; that there la DO question In my mind about It; that wc also found the fingerprints and the bulleta so conclusively • fired from the gun; that we have all this and we have all the photograph!. /* » .»■ • : ■ - • » * m *-» Mr. Rankin Inquired If we also have the television film run off of the ehootlng of Oswald, and I told him we have this* ^ - , Mr. Rankin said Mr. Malone delivered to him a copy of the .-*■ report and also offered to help in any way possible; this was very kind of Malone; but he will not deal with Malone in anything unless U Is some emergency and he has to handle It locally. I told Mr. Rankin this was all right ant\ If he should need to call upon Malone, Malone would be available. *> L'w • I also tord Mr. Rankin there Is a direct wire between the New York Office and here; that he can atwaji place any calls to here over our wire; and that I will arrange for this. •- 1 told Mr. Rankin to let us know U there is anything we can do. Very truly yours, . J. E f L John Edgar Hoover Director