Domestic Spying Abuses Said to Cover 40 Years Relentless Growth 1.29.76 By Laurence Stern HISTORY,FromA1 An eloquent warning of the dangers of Barry Goldwater (R-Ariz.),and used the runaway police powerinAmericawas operations against his 1964 challenger, Sen. sounded on May 10,1924 by the man who Barry Goldwater (R-Arz.),and used the three days later launched J.Edgar Hoover FBI to monitor the Democratic National Convention that same.year for purely 1976 theFBI. political reasons. "There is always the possibility,” "said With this rich legacy of precedents,Presi- Attorney General Harlan Fiske Stone,“that THE WASHINGTON POST wiretaps of government officialsand journal- free government and free institutions,be- ists at the midpoint of his tenure and em- cause it carrieswith it the possibility of barked upon the sweeping domestic counter- intelligence program outlined in the so quickly apprehended or understood" In the ensuing 52 years Stone's admoni- called Huston plan From administration to administration, tion would remain as a reproof to the according to the report,Hoover expanded relentless expansion of federal police power his bureaucraticwrit,carefully keeping tospyupon and conspire against ever memoranda for-the file to justify the ex- increasing numbers of Americans. Inthecomplicated historical mosaic criminal enforcement agency to its role,at portrayed by the Senate intelligence com- Hoover's height of power, as enforcer of mittee inits report released yesterday, the blame is passed in many directions the director's standardsof politicaland for the burgeoning of wiretapping, bug- moralorthodoxy. How did it happen? Who was respon- ging,political espionage, secret listing sible? and physical surveillance of many thou sands of American citizens. It portrays.successive chief executives installments- the prewar and World War period, the Cold War years and,finally, tional dissent and even the ambitions of the racial and antiwar ferment of the 1960s and early 1970s.and physical surveillance of many thou sands of American citizens. It portrays.successive chief executives installments- the prewar and World War period, the Cold War years and,finally, tional dissent and even the ambitions of the racial and antiwar ferment of the 1960s and early 1970s. paratus of secret power. The initial irony of Hoover's appoint- President Roosevelt ordered the FBI to ment as head of the Justice Department's compile lists of citizens whocabled the Bureauof Investigation, is underscored White House to protest his war policies in an exchange of correspondence between Attorney General Stone and civil liber- andorderedwiretappingof suspected "subversives." tarian Roger Baldwin,head of the Amer- ican Civil Liberties Union, in 1924. wiretapsofconversationsofahigh- Hoover had succeeded in persuading ranking executive official with Justice both Stone and Baldwin that he played an Felix Frankfurter and columnist Drew "unwilling part”in-the bureau's past ex- Pearson. cesses,which included the notorious Pal- President Eisenhower received reports mer raids on suspected subversives follow- on“purely political and social contacts” ing World WarI with foreign officials by Eleanor Roose- I think wewerewrongin our esti- mate of his [Hoover's] attitude,Baldwin liam O.Douglas. wrote Stone. In the Kennedy administration reporters Upon appointing Hoover as acting.di- and congressional staffers were wiretapped and civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. was placed under intensive electronic surveillance. See HISTORY,A14,Col.1 --- PAGE BREAK ---rector of the old Bureau of Intelligence, Stone gave him this mandate:“The activi- ties of the bureau are to be limited strictly to investigations of violations of Iaw,under my direction or under the di- rection of an assistant attorney general regularly conducting the work of the De- partment of Justice.". Ten monthslater Stone was out of office and Hoover had 48 years more to redefine that mandate. By the mid30s,under growing pressure from President Roosevelt,the FBI gradu- ally renewed the old post-World War Ii programs to gather intelligence on the of Hoover's relations with Congress on opinions and associations ofAmerican not only legislative but budgetary matters citizens, the report said over the remaining 32 years of his tenure. In August,1936, according to a Hoover He diedin 1972. In 1940, Congress was ready to aequiesce asked for more systematic gathering of to President Roosevelt's decision to con- intelligencelabout“subversive activities duct wiretapping against persons suspect- in the United States,particularly fascism ed of subversive activities despite the wire- andcommunism."lo tapping prohibition in the 1934 Federal In that conversation,according to the Communications Act. Hoover toid Congress that wiretapping ing Roosevelt that Communists were tak- ing control of the United Mine Workers, was“of considerable importance”because the American Newspaper Guild and the of the dangers to national security,and Hoover's memo also asserted that he the lawmakers agreed to leave the matter told the Presidentthe Communist Inter- entirely to the discretion of the executive, nationale had instructed its adherents to without statutory standards or require- vote for Roosevelt and against Alfred ment of a court warrant. Landon because of the fact that Gov.Hoover toid Congress that wiretapping ing Roosevelt that Communists were tak- ing control of the United Mine Workers, was“of considerable importance”because the American Newspaper Guild and the of the dangers to national security,and Hoover's memo also asserted that he the lawmakers agreed to leave the matter told the Presidentthe Communist Inter- entirely to the discretion of the executive, nationale had instructed its adherents to without statutory standards or require- vote for Roosevelt and against Alfred ment of a court warrant. Landon because of the fact that Gov. In 1941 Attorney General Francis Biddle approved a wiretap on the Los Angeles This was the underlying formula for Chamber of Commerce, with the caveat Hoover's communication with Presidents thatunless there were“some evidence from which,cumulatively,hiswrit of au- connecting the.Chamber of Commerce thority grew and his methods evolved.By with espionage, I think the surveillance evoking the threat of Communist penetra- should be discontinued. tion,whether real or imagined,Hoover The entire range of illegal government. acquiredevergreaterleewayunder al activity-wiretapping,bugging,illegal vaguely worded presidential mandates to entry and mail openings,which figured in enlarge the political intelligence role that the revelations of the Watergate scandal Had no basis in law, the report demon- was in full operation by the FBI during strated. the World War IIperiod Deliberately,Congress was kept out of With the end ofWorld War II there was the picture as the expanded domestic in- no corresponding reduction of the domes- telligence program was chartered within tic intelligence programsof the FBI and the executive branch.acquiredevergreaterleewayunder al activity-wiretapping,bugging,illegal vaguely worded presidential mandates to entry and mail openings,which figured in enlarge the political intelligence role that the revelations of the Watergate scandal Had no basis in law, the report demon- was in full operation by the FBI during strated. the World War IIperiod Deliberately,Congress was kept out of With the end ofWorld War II there was the picture as the expanded domestic in- no corresponding reduction of the domes- telligence program was chartered within tic intelligence programsof the FBI and the executive branch. Hoover insisted,in military intelligence agencies.Instead,as 1938, thatnoconcurring legislation be the Senate report noted, these programs "set the pattern for decades to come." jections which might be raised to such an As the Cold War era dawmed,the FBI's investigative scope andpowers,unchal- or individuals with some ulterior motive." lenged by a deferential Congress, floursh- Congress,for its part, showed no keen ed in the atmosphere of fervid anti-com- appetite to get involved,according to the munism.The admonition of Attorney Gen. report. eral Stone that the bureau “is not con- When′in November,1939,Hoover told cerned with political or other opinions of the House Appropriations Committee that individuals.[but] only with such con- visionunder presidential proclamation, United States” Seemed long forgotten. no questions were asked.Nor did any By the mid-1950's the Cointelpro opera- member of Congress challenge Hoover's tions were.launched to infiltrate, disrupt assertion the following year that he was ordiscreditnotonlytheCommunist empowered to investigate espionage, sab- Party but a wide range of domestic dissi- otage,neutrality violations and “any other dent organizations with no connection to subversive activities." -foreign powers.--- PAGE BREAK --- eral Stone that the bureau “is not con- When′in November,1939,Hoover told cerned with political or other opinions of the House Appropriations Committee that individuals.[but] only with such con- visionunder presidential proclamation, United States” Seemed long forgotten. no questions were asked.Nor did any By the mid-1950's the Cointelpro opera- member of Congress challenge Hoover's tions were.launched to infiltrate, disrupt assertion the following year that he was ordiscreditnotonlytheCommunist empowered to investigate espionage, sab- Party but a wide range of domestic dissi- otage,neutrality violations and “any other dent organizations with no connection to subversive activities." -foreign powers. In the words of the Senate report, Congress was.simply choosing to avoid It was also during this period,in 1947, the issue of defining the FBl's intelli- that the Central Intelligence Agency was created by Congress and its operating gence jurisdiction turf-in deference to Hoover's strongly Even though these events took place in voiced insistence-was defined by statute the security-conscious atmosphere of im- as beyond the U.S.borders. pending war, they set the basic pattern However, the CIA,enjoying the same --- PAGE BREAK ---ced insistence-was defined by statute the security-conscious atmosphere of im- as beyond the U.S.borders. pending war, they set the basic pattern However, the CIA,enjoying the same --- PAGE BREAK --- climate of executive secreey in whieh the FBl'srole budgeoned,eventually initiated illegal programs of domestic surveillance. It also embarked on its own illegal mail- opeming operation. Although President Truman succumbed himself to the anti-Communist zealotry,of the time,thereport chronicled an attempt on his part to resist Hoover's pressure for control of investigations to monitor the Truman wanted to Ieave the authority loyalty ofall federal employees. in this area with the Civil Service Com- mission- Hoover's protests prompted Tru- man to serawl on a memorandum from his White House counsel,Clark Clifford:J Edgar will in all probability get this back he wants. It's dangerous. As the anti-Communist emotions of the Cold War deepened,Hoover compiled in behalf of the Truman and then Eisen the“enemies list” that acquired notoriety during the Watergate revelations. Itwas first called the Security Index- a target list for detention in the event of national crisis-and renamed the Reserve Index in1960. It comprised“professors,teachers,and educators;labor union organizers and leaders;writers,lecturers, newsmen and others in the mass media field One of those it named was novelist Norman Mailer,the report said. Hoover even kept his own secret lists of suspected membersof,the Communist undergroundwhichherefusedto turn over to the JusticeDepartment for fear internally that it did not have“evidence, whether admissible or otherwise,reflect- ing actual membership in the Communist Party. the national security complex emerged from the 1950s fortified by the Cold War consensus and unchallenged,both in do- mestic and foreign operations,by Con- gress,according to the report. The official line of the FBI was that the hardcore Communistunderground had been crushed by its zealous enforcement activities.The danger then perceived to come from other groups, such as the Socialist Workers Party,whose members Associated Press were supporters of Leon Trotsky in the political split of more than three decades earlies with Josef Stalin.The SWP be- came the target of an.ongoing Cointelpro operation that inundated its headquarters and membership over the years with FBI agents. But as the 1960s wore on,the bureau had richer targets -such as the Ku Klux Klan, the“New Left,” and the black na- tionalist movement for its weapon, Cointelpro. Early in the Kennedy administration the bureau was employed in one of its most blatant political roles by the White House. This was the bugging and wire tapping of principals in the campaign by the Dominican Republic for a larger share of the U.S. sugar quota. During theKennedy administrationFBIroles by the White House. This was the bugging and wire tapping of principals in the campaign by the Dominican Republic for a larger share of the U.S. sugar quota. During theKennedy administrationFBI --- PAGE BREAK ---House. This was the bugging and wire tapping of principals in the campaign by the Dominican Republic for a larger share of the U.S. sugar quota. During theKennedy administrationFBI --- PAGE BREAK --- agents bugged and wiretapped a number ofAmericansincludingformer-House Agricultural Committee Chairman Harold Cooley (D-N.C.),a Washingtonlaw_firm, two registered lobbyists,Capitol Hill staff- ers and foreign officials seeking the quota, the report said.Attorney General-Robert F.Kennedy specifically authorized a wire- tap of Cooley’ssecretary,it added. Electronic surveillance of the New York hotel room in which Cooley met with for- eign oficials produced a flow of extra- neous political information that Hoover passed on to Attorney General Kennedy. One example: A foreign official was reported to be inccntact with two congressmen's secre- taries for reasons other than business.” The report said the FBI's own evalua- tion of these wiretaps indicates that they "undoubtedly. contributed heavily-to the administration's success"in passing its sugar bill. As the struggle for racial equality,first in the South and then in the black ghet- toese of the Northern cities, reached heavier levels of confrontation,the FBI found a new role.Under the direction of RRobert Kennedy and his Civil Rights Cointelpro operations against the Ku Klux Klan. Klansmen,like the Black Panthers and the antiwar dissidents,found themselves the targets of clandestine governmental activity designed not only to thwart racist activities but also to disrupt their organi- zations and, in some cases, jeopardize their marriages and home life. In its offensive against the New Left the FBI expanded its arsenal of acronymic operations There was VIDEM (Vietnam Demonstra- tion) and STAG (Student Agitation) pro- grams under which thre FBI gathered in- formation against young radicals. The FBl's operating defimition of the New Left,as voiced by the head of its New Left intelligence unit,was defined asfollows: Iknow.It's more or less an attitude,I would think." One bureau memorandum remarked that "the new Left has on many occasions vici- ously and scurrilously attacked the Direc- per our investigations and drive us off the college campuses. This was the history from which the re- cently publicized excesses of the Nixon ad- ministration flowed But much of the history of those abuses came to light for the first time in the in- vestigation of executiveactions forced into the open by the Watergate scandal The Senate report concludes there is enough blame to go around.those abuses came to light for the first time in the in- vestigation of executiveactions forced into the open by the Watergate scandal The Senate report concludes there is enough blame to go around. --- PAGE BREAK ---Detailed Report evidence was ever uncovered to contradict an initial 1941 finding that the civil rights "organization had a“strong tendency”to "steer clear of Communist activities." By'George Lardner Jr. OTheKennedy administration initiated Washington Post Stafr Writer. an FBL investigation of lobbying over. The Senate intelligence committee pending sugar legislation in196i which charged yesterday that overzealous efforts led to Attorney General RobertF.Ken- to protect the national security have con- nedy's approval of wiretapson the home phones of the clerk of the House Agricul- years under both Democratic and Repub- ture Committee,three AgricultureDepart- licanPresidents. ment officials,and the home and bisiness phones of a registered foreign agent. The FBI and other government agencies,the investigation also involved the bugging of committee disclosed a steadily expanding a New York hotel room occupied by House pattern of unwarranted invasions of pri- Agriculture-Chairman Harold Cooley (D- vacy,manipulation of the press,and viola N.C.). tions of constitutional and statutory rights, An FBI document boasted that a“pre- : ali in the name of countering supposedly text”phone call to the,mother of “black "subversive'activities. power”advocate Stokley Carmichael telling her that members of the Black, improprieties at every level-sometimes Panther Party intended to kill her son- commanded·by the White House, some- timescondoned byAttorneysGeneral, memo, the FBI felt that it had been re sometimes simply conceivedby under- sponsible for Carmichael's flight toAfrica the next day. their superiors.power”advocate Stokley Carmichael telling her that members of the Black, improprieties at every level-sometimes Panther Party intended to kill her son- commanded·by the White House, some- timescondoned byAttorneysGeneral, memo, the FBI felt that it had been re sometimes simply conceivedby under- sponsible for Carmichael's flight toAfrica the next day. their superiors. an"Unsavory and vicious tactics have been ularly received tidbits of political intelli- employed-including anonymous attempts gence labeled“Personal and Confidential" to break up marriages,disrupt_meetings, from-FBI Direetor J:Edgar-Hoover,.in- ostracize persons from their professions cluding inside information gleaned from and provoke target groups into rivalries wiretaps on individuals such as a former that might result in deaths,” the commit- Roosevelt White House aide who was try- tee said. ing to influence the Truman administra- Intelligence agencies,” the report add tion's appointments.The target of the tap, sonal objectives of Presidents and other security,was not named in the report but high officials. While the agencies often was reliably reported to be Washington (lawyer Thomas G.(Tommy) Corcoran. Aspartofthe FBIs Cointelpro sure from high officials in the executive branch and Congress, they also occasion- (counterintelligence program),an anony- ally initiated improper activities and then mous.letter was sent to the wife of a Ku concealed them from officials whom they Klux Klansman informing her that her had a'duty to inform” husband had"taken the:flesh of another The report said: unto himself,” and identifying the other Officials in the White House and the as a woman named Ruby,with her “Iust Justice Department,including then Presi- filled eyes and smart aleck figure.While the agencies often was reliably reported to be Washington (lawyer Thomas G.(Tommy) Corcoran. Aspartofthe FBIs Cointelpro sure from high officials in the executive branch and Congress, they also occasion- (counterintelligence program),an anony- ally initiated improper activities and then mous.letter was sent to the wife of a Ku concealed them from officials whom they Klux Klansman informing her that her had a'duty to inform” husband had"taken the:flesh of another The report said: unto himself,” and identifying the other Officials in the White House and the as a woman named Ruby,with her “Iust Justice Department,including then Presi- filled eyes and smart aleck figure. dent Lyndon Johnson and Attorney Gen- Although many of the excesses in the report dealt with wiretaps, bugs and im- aware of some of the FBI's persistent proper use of the mail the committee efforts to discredit the Rev.Dr.Martin also said the more widespread use of in- Luther King Jr.but made only tepid, formants was badly in need of legislative ocontrolsandrestrictions. strong indications of FBI wrongdoing that TheFBl's current budget,thereport they received. disclosed,includes.more than $7.4 million The FBI continued to investigate the for its“domestie security informants,”more NAACP for at least 25 years for signs than twice what it spends on informants ofCommunist subversion although no against organized crime. Confidential do- mestic-security spies cost even more in the SeeINTELLIGENCE,A15,Col.1 late 1960s and early 1970s when the CIA, military intelligence agences and even the electronically mindedNational Security Agency were working with the FBI to com- pile information about the vaguely defined "New Left”andblack activists. The paid anddirected informant has been the most exteunsively used technique in FBI domestic intelligence investigations, the committee found.According to a recent General Accounting Office study, they were used in 83 per cent of the cases sampled.--- PAGE BREAK --- Confidential do- mestic-security spies cost even more in the SeeINTELLIGENCE,A15,Col.1 late 1960s and early 1970s when the CIA, military intelligence agences and even the electronically mindedNational Security Agency were working with the FBI to com- pile information about the vaguely defined "New Left”andblack activists. The paid anddirected informant has been the most exteunsively used technique in FBI domestic intelligence investigations, the committee found.According to a recent General Accounting Office study, they were used in 83 per cent of the cases sampled. As of last June,the report continued the FBI had 1,500 domestic intelligence inormants.In 1972,the bureau had more ant” program alone. --- PAGE BREAK ---regulationsgoverning the use of inform- "ants,” and the FBI can use them guided ing for everybody-the general atmos- only by the bureau's own internal direc phere isone of amorality "tivesthereport saidraewo The prolonged committee inquiry was In the absence of clear andprecise written provisions directlyapplicableto reports and disclosures concerning both informants,”the committee added,“FBI the FBI and the Central Intelligence intelligence informants have engaged in Agency. violent and other inegal activity. Itwas supposed tobe completed last JfOne who penetrated the Klan occa- September but deadlines kept slipping as sionally joined his colleagues in kicking the senators and their 120-member staff pored over thousands of pages af testi bats,clubs,chainsand pistols on Freedom Riders in Alabama. of thousands o even more secret docu- Another informant assigned to a right- ments and,mernoranda reluctantly sup- plied by the executive branch wing paramilitary group in California called the Secret Army Organization “be- Ironically,thefindings come.at a time came an innovator of various harassment be only a shadow of what itwas last.year. actions." Mondale and others among the 1lmem- He took part in the firebomoing of an automobile and conducted “surveillance” ber committee spent much of their time at yesterday's briefing acknowledging the of a San Diego State University professor during which an SAO subordinate who was with him took out a gun and fired establishment of a permanent oversight committee with exclusive legislative and budget-making authority. young woman. Without such a new committee, said Warning that its findings cannot be Sen.Howard H.Baker Jr.(R-Tenn.),“all dismissed as isolated acts limited in time this is for naught.young woman. Without such a new committee, said Warning that its findings cannot be Sen.Howard H.Baker Jr.(R-Tenn.),“all dismissed as isolated acts limited in time this is for naught. and confined to a few willful men, the Absent from the session were Chairman Frank Church (D-Idaho),who is campaign- thatwouldfrthfisttmeutstatury limits and bounds on the government's ing for the Democratic presidential nom- ination,and Sens:John G.Tower (R-Tex) assertedrighttoconduct investigations and BarryGoldwater(R-Ariz.)who re- in areas where.there is no crime. fused to sign the report. Speaking of the abuses uncovered dur- ing the prolonged and highly seeretive 15-month committee investigation, Sen. treatise which pillories the nation's do- Walter Mondale(D-Minn.),chairman of mestic inteHigence agencies,fixes indivi- the panel's domestic intelligence subcom- dual culpability,ignores agency efforts atreform,and urges theadoption of of our domestic intelligence system-laws to replace vague executive orders; strong- er lines of accountability and control; The report was far more revealing and supervision of the courts where the priv- acy of Americans is threatened by wire- what ponderous volume on foreignin- taps,bugs, mail openings and break-ins; telligence activities that the committee and effective remedies for citizens whose issued Monday.Staff members said this rightsare violated.” “All this happenedMondale told re wasdue inpart to the committee'sin sistence on disclosures of abuses directly porters at a news briefing yesterday,“be- affecting American-eitizens in contrast to cause intelligence agencies were ordered clandestine U.S.activities abroad. tobreak the law,felt they had a right to Otherhighlightsof thereport dealt break the law,and even felt they had a duty under some higher claim of so-called ‘national security’to break the law.treatise which pillories the nation's do- Walter Mondale(D-Minn.),chairman of mestic inteHigence agencies,fixes indivi- the panel's domestic intelligence subcom- dual culpability,ignores agency efforts atreform,and urges theadoption of of our domestic intelligence system-laws to replace vague executive orders; strong- er lines of accountability and control; The report was far more revealing and supervision of the courts where the priv- acy of Americans is threatened by wire- what ponderous volume on foreignin- taps,bugs, mail openings and break-ins; telligence activities that the committee and effective remedies for citizens whose issued Monday.Staff members said this rightsare violated.” “All this happenedMondale told re wasdue inpart to the committee'sin sistence on disclosures of abuses directly porters at a news briefing yesterday,“be- affecting American-eitizens in contrast to cause intelligence agencies were ordered clandestine U.S.activities abroad. tobreak the law,felt they had a right to Otherhighlightsof thereport dealt break the law,and even felt they had a duty under some higher claim of so-called ‘national security’to break the law. THEKINGINVESTIGATION The committee blamed the abuses on AttheAugust1963MarchonWash that someday "all of God’s children,black what seems to have been a complete menand whitemen,Jewsand Gentiles, breakdown of the traditional system of Protestantsand Catholies,will be able to checks and palances.--- PAGE BREAK --- tobreak the law,felt they had a right to Otherhighlightsof thereport dealt break the law,and even felt they had a duty under some higher claim of so-called ‘national security’to break the law. THEKINGINVESTIGATION The committee blamed the abuses on AttheAugust1963MarchonWash that someday "all of God’s children,black what seems to have been a complete menand whitemen,Jewsand Gentiles, breakdown of the traditional system of Protestantsand Catholies,will be able to checks and palances. joinhands andsingin thewordsof the Not only did the executive branch fail old Negro-spiritual,Free atlast,free at to supervise its own intelligence agencies, last,thank God Almighty, Im free at last.” the report said,but Congress seldom The FBI's Domestie Intelligence Division questioned the use to which its appropria- rated the performance as"demogogicand tions were being put,and the courts have concluded that it had made King the“most proven themselves"reluctant to grapple” with the few-domesticintelligence issues that have come before them. country." Shortly afterwards,in a campaign that Instead, the committee suggested,the continued until after King's assassination, main brake guarding against worse ex- theFBIdecided to“take himoff his cesses was simply the "flap potential," pedestal and rated him as a threat because the fear that illegal activities would be- comepublic knowledge. As faras legality isconcernedmorals, or ethics,(it) was never raised by myself Following a nine-hour meeting atFBI. or anyone else the FBI's former assis- headquarters in December of 1963,FBI tant director of intelligence, William C agentsplanted a microphone in King's Sulivan, told the committee.T think this bedroom at the Willard Hotel here and suggests really in government that we are during the next two years installed at 5 least 14more“bugs”in hotel rooms King --- PAGE BREAK ---occupied across the.country. Attorney General Kennedy,who had au- thofized taps on King's telephones earlier been “shocked”and that he and Marshall in1963,was apparentlynever explicitly informed President Johnson who “"took the toldof the microphone surveillances,the committee said,butKennedydid receive contact Hoover. reportscontaining.unattributed informa- Alluding to Bradlee without naming him tionfrom that surveillanee fromwhich he in thereport,the committee said the only might have concluded that microphones record of thisepisode in FBI files isa memo byctop-ranking Hoover deputy Car- Another ostensible excuse for the in- Teyestigations swirling about King was the In it,the report stated.DeLoach quoted suspicion that one of his key advisers Johnson's press secretary,Bill Moyers,as might be a Communist“sympathizer.”" When the FBI's New York field office concluded that the adviser was not, FBI Moyersitold the Senate committee he headquarters responded with what the couldn't remember the incident but said committee described asa theory of“guilty "itwould be fair toconclude that the until proven innocent." TheFBI headquartersreplymemo [Bradlee] revealed the-bureau's conduct rather than the bureau's conduct itself.Attorney General Kennedy,who had au- thofized taps on King's telephones earlier been “shocked”and that he and Marshall in1963,was apparentlynever explicitly informed President Johnson who “"took the toldof the microphone surveillances,the committee said,butKennedydid receive contact Hoover. reportscontaining.unattributed informa- Alluding to Bradlee without naming him tionfrom that surveillanee fromwhich he in thereport,the committee said the only might have concluded that microphones record of thisepisode in FBI files isa memo byctop-ranking Hoover deputy Car- Another ostensible excuse for the in- Teyestigations swirling about King was the In it,the report stated.DeLoach quoted suspicion that one of his key advisers Johnson's press secretary,Bill Moyers,as might be a Communist“sympathizer.”" When the FBI's New York field office concluded that the adviser was not, FBI Moyersitold the Senate committee he headquarters responded with what the couldn't remember the incident but said committee described asa theory of“guilty "itwould be fair toconclude that the until proven innocent." TheFBI headquartersreplymemo [Bradlee] revealed the-bureau's conduct rather than the bureau's conduct itself. The bureau doesnot-agree with the On another occasion, the committee re expressed belief of the field office that ported,the FBI gave Johnson White House (deleted),is not sympathetic to the party aide Walter Jenkins a bureau report “un- cause,While there may not be any evi favorable toDr.King." dence that(deleted)isa Communist, According to aJan.14,1964,memo to neither is there any substantial evidence Hoover, Jenkins stated that he“was of the that he is anti-Communist opinion that the FBI could perform a good In1964,a“sterilized”tape,apparently service to the country if this matter could containingcompromising,sexuallyex- somehow be confidentially given to mem- plicit,excerpts fromKing's hotel rooms, bers of the press.(In an interview with the Senate committeestaff,Jenkins denied having made such a suggestion;the report said Jenkins pleaded illness when asked totestify formally and has failed to took as a suicide suggestion.reportscontaining.unattributed informa- Alluding to Bradlee without naming him tionfrom that surveillanee fromwhich he in thereport,the committee said the only might have concluded that microphones record of thisepisode in FBI files isa memo byctop-ranking Hoover deputy Car- Another ostensible excuse for the in- Teyestigations swirling about King was the In it,the report stated.DeLoach quoted suspicion that one of his key advisers Johnson's press secretary,Bill Moyers,as might be a Communist“sympathizer.”" When the FBI's New York field office concluded that the adviser was not, FBI Moyersitold the Senate committee he headquarters responded with what the couldn't remember the incident but said committee described asa theory of“guilty "itwould be fair toconclude that the until proven innocent." TheFBI headquartersreplymemo [Bradlee] revealed the-bureau's conduct rather than the bureau's conduct itself. The bureau doesnot-agree with the On another occasion, the committee re expressed belief of the field office that ported,the FBI gave Johnson White House (deleted),is not sympathetic to the party aide Walter Jenkins a bureau report “un- cause,While there may not be any evi favorable toDr.King." dence that(deleted)isa Communist, According to aJan.14,1964,memo to neither is there any substantial evidence Hoover, Jenkins stated that he“was of the that he is anti-Communist opinion that the FBI could perform a good In1964,a“sterilized”tape,apparently service to the country if this matter could containingcompromising,sexuallyex- somehow be confidentially given to mem- plicit,excerpts fromKing's hotel rooms, bers of the press.(In an interview with the Senate committeestaff,Jenkins denied having made such a suggestion;the report said Jenkins pleaded illness when asked totestify formally and has failed to took as a suicide suggestion. answer written interrogatories submitted According to former FBI Assistant Di- rector Sullivan,thepurpose of the mailing to diminish his stature.Inother words,if it caused a break between Coretta and Martin Luther King,that would diminish Ieader,"” thereport said.--- PAGE BREAK --- The bureau doesnot-agree with the On another occasion, the committee re expressed belief of the field office that ported,the FBI gave Johnson White House (deleted),is not sympathetic to the party aide Walter Jenkins a bureau report “un- cause,While there may not be any evi favorable toDr.King." dence that(deleted)isa Communist, According to aJan.14,1964,memo to neither is there any substantial evidence Hoover, Jenkins stated that he“was of the that he is anti-Communist opinion that the FBI could perform a good In1964,a“sterilized”tape,apparently service to the country if this matter could containingcompromising,sexuallyex- somehow be confidentially given to mem- plicit,excerpts fromKing's hotel rooms, bers of the press.(In an interview with the Senate committeestaff,Jenkins denied having made such a suggestion;the report said Jenkins pleaded illness when asked totestify formally and has failed to took as a suicide suggestion. answer written interrogatories submitted According to former FBI Assistant Di- rector Sullivan,thepurpose of the mailing to diminish his stature.Inother words,if it caused a break between Coretta and Martin Luther King,that would diminish Ieader,"” thereport said. ROBERT F.KENNEDY SEENO EVIL The,campaign to discredit King was also offered by the committee as an ex ample of the neglect that Presidents,At- torneys General and other Cabinet officers have,until recently,accorded to clear evidence of improper domestic activities by intelligence agencies. The Senate report alluded,for instance, to November of 1964 when Washington Post executite editor Benjamin C.Brad lee,then Washington bureau chief of Newsweek magazine, told Attorney Gen- eral Katzenbach and Assistant Attorney General Burke Marshall that the FBI had approached one of his reporters and of MARTIN fered an opportunity to hear some “in- teresting" tapes involving King. Katzenbach told the committee he had 132 LUTHER --- PAGE BREAK ---at the FBI had approached one of his reporters and of MARTIN fered an opportunity to hear some “in- teresting" tapes involving King. Katzenbach told the committee he had 132 LUTHER --- PAGE BREAK --- llustrating CIA growth,top photo shows At bottom,a view of one of agency's Washington headquarters bulding in 1960.drnew:buildings at Langley, Va., in1976.