i? .' t^'f r. 7i-r^ . • ' «^7 Ttfr‘y,sr» Voi;'8 #5 July,' 1992 • '-. -'yir. A JOURNAL’ OF RESEARCH ON 'THE TEXAS. CONNECTION rA' secono;^Opinion ^ • .i;/ ; :. . ::.n ..;:;r:.?xs by Raymond Carroll " ^ ^ . gi&sl THE GREAtlsT kCRCT^ I EVER^L KENNEDY ASSASSINATION 26 by Roger Bruce /einman Jc-:: SOME EVIOtNCE TOIbACK ;UP TOM WILSON? /' . ':?' by Jpahoe Brauri .• . V'.;^ ^ '•' warren COMMISSION!^ :.•. • by Davl{l,B. Perry i . by Mark S. Zaid V LEHERS TO THE EDITOR' CORRECTION :v **♦ • -:V. .t • 30 ;'-.^v5vrcp| 35 ' ' :-i_ THE THIRD DECADE that' It tends tof; oversimplify a very complex body of evidence and presents Lyndon Johnson as being the only human being capable of engineering the assassination plot and getting 'away with it. However, the book is well written, easy to read, and' keeps the ; reader'.s interest throughout. The early section dealing with the Warren Commission manipitlation of the evidence is especially good. Unfortunately, there is no hard evidence.' But then would we really expect there to be .any? Craig Zirbel effectively convinced this reader that Lyndon Johnson did indee.d- have -the ipotive and the opportunity to murder President Kennedy. Whether he actually did it Is still a matter open to debate, but we should at least put him up thee?' among the • prime suspects. Even if Johnson didn't order the hit, I am convjiijced, after; reading this book, that at the least he used the Dallas police •department And the FBI to cover up the evidence after the fact. Lyndon Johnson certainly knew a lot more about the Kennedy assassination than he ever revealed to the :^erican publjic. *117': Parkview 0r4e Land! svi lie, PA 17538 THE TEXAS CONNECTION; A SECOND OPINION » . ' \ by I Raymond jCarroll* -.Ttie assassination of JFK will remain controversial long after the debate about who .kiilled him has been resolved. Historians wilKcontinue to argue the significance of Kennedy's Thousand Days and the extent to which the presidency of Lyndon Johnson marked *a watershed in American history, .one of the great divides in the evolution of its "foreign, and domestic policies." Craig Zirbel's bestselling book will undoubtedly anger, those historians- who see no special significance in the events of November 22^ 1963 beyond the "fact" that the President was shot by a disturbed Communist on his^.lunch break. In Zirbel's book LBJ masterminded this finar^step on his''pwn path; of ^wer with the help of a group of Texas oilmen, police chief/; Jesse Curr^-.and Jack Ruby. Minor assists were provided by D.A. Henry Wade and by Joe Brown’,.. the Judgelwho presided over the trial of Jack Ruby. The plotters also used Joh^' .'Connal ly and Lee Oswald as unwitting allies. The mechanics of the shooting apparently followed the script of Hugh McDonald's "Appointment in Dallas." (Oddly enough; ' while citing "Appointment" with approval, Zirbel does not even mention McDonald's other book, "LBJ and the JFK Conspiracy," which links Johnson with a faction In the Kreml ini ) •. -.I’f JFK', really was murdered by unknown conspirators then Johnson, as the Vice-President who succeeded him, is .a logical suspect. Assassination researchers have -tended to shy away from this obvious area of inquiry, although Zirbel is^by no meanS..the first to raise it. People began to whisper about LBJ even as the sound of gunfjre faded in;. Oealey Plaza. Rumors were especially prevalent in Texas, where Johnson had a mixed reputation. Johnson himself was painfully aware of the rumors. Earl). barren agreed to. head up a Commission of Inquiry only after Johnson told him abou t. •" rumors. ..aittributing the assassination to a faction within the government." Eveh).,the prqstige of Chief Justice Warren could not stop the rumors and sooii they wefe.no longer only whispers. In 1967 Barbara Garson's satirical play Macbird. began a successfuljrun at the Village Gate in New York. In that same year, Sylvia Meagher published "AcceS;Sories After the Fact," her monumental study of the Warren Cornniss ion's-, published evidence. Meagher cited Penn Jones' claim that a letter by -Jack Ruby and smuggled out of jail stated that "they alone planned the ^ by they jl mean Johnson and the. others."'’ In 1967 also, Joachim Joesten published “The Case Against Lyndon Johnson in the Assassination of President i&^-"'- :\tT^ iewS -s fi« t5« , jfeujfbas profit f™“,“'j”“|l“'irrefpaUT5V«^^^^^ 7 can"Tno“"tt,« hi Is U^inarily have .i)een the national media * 1 3 r/^r„r,|:en“r rrlson Livingstone, that ^ often ''„ j „„ j HhUe House aide, the jid^VorhCg" « d?';itV ?hi act .that ‘heyj still |t 1 ng^^gp^ uf too published -eest Evidence,' In which he l^sassinatio • ^ ‘ ^ jFlC's ^bodv was clandestinely removed from its coffin during d^fusion surrounding Johnson's^ gi^vSSSiisliSis j^ft ;l tt ^"IridFKf Johnson lin/ .ftea 1 t^frr^^^^^ h“ls f’irst election 1 " college aod I f 3 i Iiili^ Til THE THIRD DECADE his bwo' pockefts even dfter he became Vice-President. But Zirbel is on shakier ground when he accusVs LBd of complicity in the 1961 shooting of Henry Marshall, an agent of the Department of»,Agri culture who was murdered while investigating the affairs of Billie Sol Estes. Zirbel cites a March, 1984 report in the Milwaukee Journal as evidence that Est^s told.e Grand Jury that "Vice President Johnson was directly invoTved in 'the murder." Even if Estes actually said this (since Grand Jury testijjiony is secret, we can't necessarily trust a newspaper account), what reason is there to believe ^that It is true? As a convicted wrongdoer, Estes is hardly an unimpeachable witness and his allegation may have been entirely self-serving. Moreover, Zirbel offers no evidence that LBJ was Involved in anj^ of Billie ^ol s affairs., apert from a single letter LBJ wrote to the Department of Agriculture on behalf of his fellow Texan. ...... Lftt us for the sake of argument, that LBJ had a motive and that he was not the most ethical politician of the post-war era. If he organized the assas; 5 ihation, how did he accomplish it? Zirbel *s answer is the Texas connection. It was: John Connally. aa^ld Johnson crony, who insisted on the deadly choice of routft for tfie motorcade. LBJ wanted Yarborough in the death car instead of his buddy Connally Connally and Korth both had links to Oswald through their s^vice as sdpcessive Secretaries of the Navy whom Oswald had petitioned about jf^is Marine discharge. Korth' had once handled a legal matter for Oswald's mother. It was Connally who exclaimed, "My God! They are going to kill us all! Zirbel ^sks Is it possible that, at^the immediate instant when the bullet struck, Connally finally put together the pieces realizing that he had been duped by Johnson into supplying hini with information that LBJ now used for political destruction? The answer^is maybe— ?-or maybe his exclamation was prompted by concern for his wife s safety;* she was in the line of fire too. , The next link in the Texas connection is Jesse Curry. Zirbel says that Curry, as Chief of Dall^ police, had final responsibility for the trip's planning (Curry says otherwisel^'Tand for local security. Although Zirbel says police arrested the right man in the^ Tippit shooting, h& argues that Curry played the lead role in arranging for Ruby to shoot Oswald. Zirbel devotes a chapter (in fairness it shotrld.be sifd that some of Zirbel 's chapters would bare^ make a paragraph in The Third Decade)' to furry's supposed "personal relationship" with LBJ and his sinister decision to accompany LBJ to the airport rather than head up the investigation; But Zirbel- ts taking Curry's accountability as a public official and magically tran^uting ft into conspiratorial guilt. If Curry thought LBJ might be in danger, and .if he believed the crime scene was in the hands of competent assistants, then who is to*; say that he was wrong to make sure that Dallas did not produce two dead Presidents in one: day? Zirbel does not even produce any evidence that Curry and LBJ were, acquaintances prior to the assassination. ^ u- ‘Zirbel .conjures up a nice little sub-plot involving oilman Clint Murchison, District Attorney Henry Wade and Judge Joe Brown. It seems the deal was for Judge BroWh to refuse to move the Ruby trial out of Dallas, thereby guaranteeing that the conviction would be reversed on appeal. D.^ Wade would then arrange for Ruby to plead' guilty'^ to a* lesser charge and go free. This seems like a good idea 2 yntil we learn that the plotters were busy arranging to have Ruby bumped off anyway. Brown's reward?— ra contract with Holt, Rinehart, a publishing company controlled by the* Murchison fai&ily. Zirbel does not implicate Mark Lane in this plot, although logitatly he. should. Holt Rinehart published "Rush to Judgment" and "A Citizen s dissent." . , . ^7he final link in Zirbel 's Texas connection is billionaire H.L. Hunt. Hunt was as W^U known for his eccentric conservatism (in September 1963 he had lobbied the U.S.-.^ Senate :to reject the test ban treaty) as he was for his almost mystical ability to locate. oil. The evidence presented by Zirbel that Hunt was a murderer Is, however, a ’little short of compelling. In fact Zirbel 's attack on Hunt and his sons 13 THE THIRD DECADE LariiAr arid Bunicer-ds probably;, the shabbiest section of the book. The "evidence cited by Zirbel Includes the following; ^ ^ m, ■, u ^ ■ fa) Bunketv’Hunt admitted contributing towards the cost of the Welcome Mr. ' Kennedy'*' adverilsement which appeared In the Dallas Morning News on Novembw 22, 1363. 1 Comment: not very clever on Bunker's part, to insult the President publicly if he was also planning an assassination. ; (b) H.L. Hunt had gambling contacts with Ruby la the 1950's. Comment: True. ; Ruby 'h^lped set up designed to fleece. Hunt and others out of large sums of money. ^ (c) Ruby stopped opts Ide the offices of Lamar Hunt on November 21. Comment: • i Truei! .Ruby was ev^ thoughtful enough to arrange for an Independent I witness.^ .* . .. . * ■ (d) Ruby had some -of Hifnt's conservative Lifeline literature In his apartment. Comneritr True •. Ruby had picked up the literature three weeks previously and praised to seiid It to the White House. "Nobody 2 |as any right to talk " like tills about ouri Government," he reportedly said. (e) In 197S a curious Tetter surfaced, apparently In Mexico. It was directed ' to a Mi** Hunti address unknown, and was purportedly written by Lee Harvey Oswald. •oh' November 8, 1963. Zirbel presents this latter, apparently expecting us to believe that.1t proves that one or another member of the family of H.L.. Hunt was Involved In an assassination plot with Oswald. . ; Curloitsly enough, the FBI Investigated the letter on the assumption that It >• was Intended for Bunker Hunt. The results of the FBI probe have not been released,^® hut Ziribel appears to have the distinction of being the first Warreri. .Commissi on Critic to be on the FBI's wave-length. “ (f) Zlrbet.cltes a disgruntled former Hunt employee as claiming tha^ghe saw , Marina Oswald In Hunt's office shortly after, the assassination; Comment: : Zirbel- neglects to;;ment1on that the Hunt family and Marina have repeatedly • denied, this allegation. Anyway Marina and old man Hunt could not have had a very , exciting conversation because Zirbel 's witness apparently forgot to *’ notlcp: whether there was a Russian translator present. One question for Zirbel: If Hunt really was as fanatical an LBJ supporter as Zirbel would have ris.'belleve, wl^y did he throw his support behind Barry Goldwater In 1964? •/. ■ ’-In the opening sectlotf of his book, Zirbel describes the strategy used by the Warren Conmlssibn to put across Its lone gunman theory. "It Is used every day across America by lawyers with tough cases... The strategy Is to deliberately confuse Issues and complIcate’-'inattersV before the jury, while at the same time offering a simple solution. It 'is hoped that the jury will believe that the actual Issues are too complicated to'*‘grasp, but If they were smart enough. to understand them, the solution would be the simple one that was offered." One suspects that Zirbel Is attempting something similar In The Texas Connection. Old H.L. %rit had- some i words which Zirbel might do well to ponder: "For the continued progress of the country he so courageously served, the ' ; assassination of President Kennedy should not be soon forgotten and should be openly and often reviewed, discussed and analysed. The tragic event and Its ( catastrophic results will be with us for years.: The better It Is understood, the less paralysing the tragedy will be; and John F. Kennedy i^guld be last ' to desire that blame be ascribed to anyone who Is blameless." *9 Bryan St., C6mmack,'.NY 11725. *' * ** ' Notes 1 ; ;-Robert Caro-, T|^ Years of Lyndon Johnson Volume One: The Path of Power ^ , ; I* ■ > “ THE THIRD DECADE i .-.;> ■■ i ' : .-. ••• . ;Z1rbe1.- Texas Connection , p. 215. 19.'Z1rbe1 .- Texas Connection , pp. 222-225, ; 20. . Zlrbel, Texas Connect"^ , pp. 244-248. 21 ."Zlrbel Texas Connect'fon , p. 247. i 22; Zirbel .‘" Texas Connect'jon . p. 250; Mark Lane Rush ^ Judgment , p. 237. 23'.-'iZ1rbe1 , Texas Connect'jon , p. 250; Lane, Rush to Judgment , p. 261. 24 . yZI rbel ‘ Texas Connect'fon , p. ?51; Warren Report (Bantam Ed.), p. 343. 25. ' ZTrbel. Texas Connectloli , pp. 234, 251; Henry Hurt, Reasonable Doubt ■■(Holt, Rinehart, Winston, 1986), p. 236. • ^ ; 26'l’;Z1rbe1 ; Texas Connection , pp. 234, 251; Harry Hurt III, Texas Rich ; v'Th’e Hunt, byna'sty From ~ tlie Early Oil Days Through the Silver '; Crash {Norton. 1981). p. 380. 27i'Hurt. Texas Rich , p. 234. 28 .-.Zlrbel .- Texas Connection , p. 32. 29. . ‘Hurt, T-exas Rich , p. 23?. ; ] \ • :•! V- vWET blankets II: NOSENKO AGAIN, THE' DANGER OF DROWNING IN PAPER, AND NPIC .'•f, ; ? by • Scott Van Wynsberghe* I .•«***.♦ i -••I- am surprised to find tr\yse1f becoming an argumentative windbag in the defense of KGB defector Yuri Nosenko. The overworked editor of this journal certainly has better things to' do than to fall Into such disputes. Still, a good squabble does wonders foi^ a constitution (both physiological • and political), and there, Is no deayihg the’energetlc level of our last exchange, 1n the May Issue. ; ;-..What helped Inspire this Installment was the publication of David* Wise's Mo'jehunt , the latest survey of the madness perpetrated by CIA counter-intelligence chleT' James; Angleton In the 1960s and 1970s. (New York; Random House, 1992.) - Wise, of ’course,' has i good claim to being the top U.S. writer on matters of Intelligence