Unions Turn To AID After CIA Pullout L-f/Mn \ By Wiliam Greider Washington Post Staff Writer Blessed with new subsidies from the Government's for- eign-aid program, the AFL- CIO is putting extra muscle into its worldwide operations to create counter-revolution- ary labor movements in under- developed countries. The money— about $1,120,000 a year from the Agency for International Development — buys training seminars and field organizers, often hired locally, in Latin America, Africa and Asia. Their stated goal is “developing and strengthening free trade unions throughout the world.” In practice, this ranges fro-m prosaic matters like pension- fund squabbles to ambitious schemes for overpowering the dominant leftist labor organi- zations in some countries. See LABOR, A10, Col. 1 A 10 Monda y, April 21, 1969 THE WASHINGTON POST AID Replaces LABOR, From A1 This “union to union” diplo- macy, “uninhibited by a form- al Government relationship,’ as one AID official explained, is just the sort of thing which the Central Intelligence Agency used to pay for secret- ly — before the CIA’s cover was blown two years ago and it had to abandon its network of dummy foundations. Indeed, two of the U.S. Labor organizations which now share in the AID grants ar- ranged last June were identi- fied as beneficiaries of the CIA’s covert funding. Though their leaders denied the con- nection, the Retail Clerks In- ternational was linked to the Granary Fund of Boston and the International Federation of Petroleum and Chemical Workers received funds from the Andrew Hamilton Fund, both of which were CIA con- duits. After the sensational dis- closures of how the CIA had penetrated domestic institu- tions, the Government declared that the secret financing would be stopped and in a few cases replaced by public subsidy. One CIA orphan picked up by AID was the Asia Foundation. Called Sheer Nonsense According to the AFL-CIO’s Assistant Director of Interna- tional Affairs, Ernest S. Lee it is “just sheer nonsense” to' put the overseas labor activi- ties in the same category. American unions, he pointed out, have been carry- ing out international pro- grams for years, both with AID grants and with their own money. “W e have to give any support we can to free trade unions,” said Lee, “so that they will not be jeopar- dized from any position — gov- ernment, the Communists business.” However, AID Deputy Ad- ministrator Rutherford M Poats was m ore~equfvoc al ori the question of CIA financ-| ing. “I know they were not CIA-financed at the time we picked them up,” Poats said. “Whether they were at some time in the past I don’t know.” Poats said he was told that I the unions and their interna- tional affiliates had been pay- ing for the network of orga* fliers — with occasional suij> port from foundations — b u t that they could no longer af- ford to maintain them. “I don’t know,” Poats said, “whether, among the founda- tions they turned to for help in the past, any of those were CIA conduits. I just don’t! know.” Goes to 3 Institutes When AID agreed to pick up the costs formerly borne by the unions, the package was arranged by AFL-CIO’s Lee, who is assistant to^Iay Love- jStone, the Federation’s inter- national director, and is son- in-law to George Meany, the president. The AID money goes to three regional labor institutes which the AFL-CIO operates in Africa, Latin America and Asia, then is passed on by subcontracts to seven labor organizations, which are either U.S. unions or their international trade af- filiates. The arrangement was ap-| proved by the Labor Advisory Committee on Foreign Assist- ance, a labor-government group whose regular meetings are spiced with the spirit of international combat Presided over by Meany, the committee oversees the Federation’s housing, training and institu- tional programs in foreign countries, which receive about $8 million a year from AID. The main difference in the new AID spending, Lee said, is that Government financing now supports individual trade unions working with their counterparts within countries while the focus in the past has been on broader national labor confederations. The AID financ-J ■ .Tff-ttcw .---r .• CIA in ing is no secret, but the new union activities do not require formal approval from the “host country" as most foreign-aid projects do. Jay Lovestone, the elder eminence of American labor’s cold-war operations, told the AID officials “that U.S. em- bassy sponsorship or close identification with these pro- grams would be untendable and counter-productive.” Subsidy in Nigeria In Nigeria, the U.S. funds provide a modest direct subsidy to an infant union of oil work- ers whose dues will not support the union's activities “for quite some time to come.” In Colombia and Peru, the Retail Clerks International is concentrating on strengthening bank workers’ unions. The budget proposal for Colombia listed the secretary general of the bank workers union as the locally-hired representative. In Japan, the long-range ob- jective is welding together all of the diverse unions repre- senting oil and chemical work- ers into one national union, to be affiliated with the Den- ver-based International Fed- eration of Petroleum and Chemical Workers (IFPCW). While most of the U.S. or- ganisations submitted brief, bland descriptions last yeai of how they would spend the AID money, the IFPCW’* budget proposal detailed it* struggle with the other side ir 19 countries — how it some times battles dominant unions or even the Government it- self. Its affiliate in Trinidad,. the IFPCW noted, had “come under the influence of the Communist leadership, if not under the direction of Com- munist leaders." It proposed to correct this by supporting a challenge by oil workers dedi- cated to the free trade union movement. In Colombia, the IFPCW in- tended to challenge “Fede- petrol,” a rival federation. “Fedepetrol,” it said, “is con- trolled by Communists and its leaders have recently in- creased their activities in at- tempting to organize chemi- cal and pharmaceutical work- ers.” The AID-financed program would “assist the free, demo- cratic trade unions currently in Fedepetrol to recapture their organization from its present Communist leadership control. We must continue to work with key persons em- ployed by Ecopetrol, Colpet and Intercol (the three oil companies where the rival union has its membership strength.)” At the same time, the U.S.- based labor group intended to beef up its own affiliate in Colombia “and assist H in de- veloping a closer relationship with the government of Colombia. Eventually, merge Fedepetrol into our affiliate.” Recruitment Set In Peru, the objective is signing up unorganized work, ers in chemical and pharmac- meutical plants. However, the IFPCW said, “a rival union exists which is oriented to- ward the Communist Party. Our program envisions a vig- orous attempt to win these Helping U.S. Unions employes to the democratic trade union forces.’* In Pakistan, the oil federa- tion complained, “politically, the government Is leaning to- ward the Communist orbit and constantly puts pressure upon our affiliate and the Pak- istan National Federation of Trade Unions to entertain vis- itors from China and the WFTU (the Communist-spon- sored international organiza- tion of unions). These organi- zations have been able to maintain their independence in spite of government pres- sure.** ' • The ICFTU and others have discovered that the helping hand of American labor is not universally welcomed. • r “Harassment” Reported In South Vietnam, where the AFL-CIO is pouring sup- port into a tenant farmers’ union, Lovestone complained to the State Department last year that the local labor lead- ers were continually harassed, even arrested, by South Viet- namese military leaders, whom the U.S. also supports. “This is a source of embarass- mesnt to the AFL-CIO which is steadfastly supporting the U.S. war effort in Vietnam,” * Lovestone reminded the gov- * ernmemt. * When three AFL-CIO vice * presidents landed in Nigeria 1 on an inspection tour last ’ spring, the airport officials at : Lagos submitted them to a * meticulous personal search, an embarassment which the labor leaders blamed on Com- munist rivals. In Brazil, a government de- cree ordered foreign labor organizers to apply for per- mission to 'operate in the country, but a year has passed and none of the applications have yet been approved. “It will be necessary that we work within the framework of the present Brazilian labor legislation,” the IFPCW con- ceded, “but we must also work for new labor legislation and the elimination of the repres- sive type.” Activities Defended AID officials defend these activities as a normal aspect of the foreign-aid program. The development of economic growth and stability . requires free and strong labor unions just as it requires new indus- try and commerce, they con- tend. 4 “Our general view is that technical assistance to labor unions is and should be a continuing part of develop- ment,” Poats said. An AID labor advisor who covers Latin America explain- ed: “Unions act as dividers of profits. The U.S. Government likes to see more purchasing power in the hands of these people rather than in Swiss banks.” Poats dismissed the domes- tic political overtones of the activities as an inevitable ele- ment “The whole orientation is that they’re out fighting the WFTU (the Communist federa- tion) around the world,” Poats said. “We are operating in host countries where the gov- ernment favors a moderate, nationalist union as opposed to a Communist union.” Another AID executive put it this way: “Now, nothing is more political than labor union training. But we treat it as developmental.” Stems From Cold War The AFL-CIO’s devotion to international operation stems primarily from Meany and Lovestone's commitment to help America fight the Cold War, an attitude which has drawn frequent attacks from V’alter Reuther and the United Auto Workers, among others. The critics suggest that the labor federation’s role in U.S. diplomacy inevit- ably affects its attitudes in U.S. politics such as the AFL- CIO’s hawkish defense of the American role in Vietnam. In any case, there is an ac- knowledged self-interest for the U.S. labor organizations that work overseas. Though they do not expect to benefit directly and immediately, they are in the business of gather- ing new members and affili- ates into the fold! One AID official dei-ribed “organizing aims” and the Government aims as compatible. “If we get what we want as a by- product of what the union wants, then it’s worthwhile,” he said. And Lee offered this expla- nation of how the AFL-CIO views global unionism: “It’s a selfish thing, too. After all, free trade unionism is our bread and butter. You get unions taken over by the Corns or even by the right-wing Fascists, what happens? It be- comes stagnant, a cheap labor market. That becomes a threat to us and the United States. Industry is concerned about it,