'vp ■ m V. \. vfj: Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2011 with funding from University of Toronto http://www.archive.org/details/historyofnorman04free l^yKx /ll^wvC _j THE HISTORY OF THE NORMAN CONQUEST OF ENGLAND, ITS CAUSES AND ITS RESULTS. BY EDWARD A. FREEMAN, M.A., Hon. D.C.L. LATE FELLOW OP TRINITY COLLEGE. 9 VOLUME IV. TllK lihlGN OF WILLIAM THE CONQUEROR. ' Magna feres tacitas solatia mortis ad umbra.s, A tanto ceciilisse viro.' — Ovid. Melam. v. 191. Appendix ; but I beUeve that their substance will find a place as least as fitting among the more general disquisitions which I hope to give in the fifth volume. Besides the friends whom I have so often thanked in earHer volumes, I have now to acknowledge the great help which I have received from several friends at the various places which I had to examine in order to give a full account of William's Western and Northern campaigns. I have to thank them alike for help on the spot and for suggestions as to the local maps and plans. At Exeter I was accompanied by Mr. W. A. Sanford, whose eye for any physical point is much keener than mine. At Lincoln I had much help from the Precentor, the Rev. Edmimd Venables ; at York from Archdeacon Jones and the Kev. James Raine, Canon of York ; in the City and Bishoprick of Durham from the Eev. William Green- well and Mr. W. H. Longstafte of Gateshead ; and at vi rU KFACE. ChoBUT fn>rn the Doiin ami Mr. llu«^'lu's. And in speaking of my to[x>gnn>lucal n^ranlirM, tli<»ii;^Hi I do not tliink that in the prenont vohune 1 have had any dii\»ct hi^lp from Mr. J J\. (irt^cn, yet I have often felt the benefit of euriier incjuiries of the Kiime kind made in his company. 1 nuiy inily my that it wa« fmm him that I firnt learned t<> look on a towTi 08 a whole witli a kinil of personal history, instead of simply the })laee where such and such a church or ca«tle wjvs to be found. In the plans of towns, I have tried to show their extent as they must have stood in the days of William, and to mark such buildings as were then certainly or probably in being. But in such an attempt as this a good deal is necessarily left to conjecture. The map of the Fen country, illustratbig the campaigns of Hereward, is grounded on the map in Professor C. C. Babmgton's Ancient Cambridge- shire, and I have to thank the Professor for most valuable help boili in drawing the map and in per- sonally going over tlie ground. I have to say the same of the i)lan of the town of Cambridge, which is also founded on his work. The general map of England, 8ho\ving the gradual progress of William s conquest, is, as far as I know, a new attempt. Here again something must be left to conjecture. The Welsh boundary especially was very imcertain and fluc- tuating, and I cannot expect to have attained com- plete accuracy, but the map will at least show that all the shires on the March as they stand in Domes- day took in certain districts which now do not belong PREFACE. vii to them. With regard to the other sliires, I have not attempted to mark the small differences between their present and their Domesday boundaries, except in the extreme cases of the largest and smallest among them. Yorksliire was then far greater, and Rutkuid, whicli in truth was not a distinct shire, was still smaller than it is now. In making this map, T have to acknowledge many valuable hints from Mr. James Parker. The present volume has taken a longer time in its composition than any of those that have gone before it, partly because of the interruption caused by the revision of the first two volumes for the second edition, partly because of the greater extent and difficult v of the work itself. The fifth and last volume will, like the first, consist partly of nan'ative and partly of dissertation. In it I trust to go thoroughly into the effects of the Norman Conquest on the later condition and history of England, and to carry on the narrative in the form of a sketch to the point which I designed from the beginning, the reign of Edward the First. SOMERLEAZE, WeLLS, May 27, 187 I, DA 1 95 CONTENTS. CHAPTER XVn. A.D. IHl FIRST DAYS OF WILLIAM'S REIGN. December, 1066 — December, 1067. § I. Character of the Reign 0/ William. Position of William at the time of his coronation no armeert of Oily the younger founds Osency Priory Causes of lack of resistance to the confiHcation Confiscation familiar at the time Familiarity with the settlement of foreigners Ft-nuanent effects of the confiscation I^nil largely retained by it« actual posHCSsors Abbot Brand of Peterborough buys William's favour ..... William "s dealings with the New Minster 1069 Election of Abbot Wulfric Taxes and offerings .... Willixim's gifts to foreign churches Harold's standard sent to Rome Extent of Willuim'H occupation of England Analog}' l)ctween the position of William and llaroh Building of castles .... Con«lition of Norwich .... William's foreign auxiliaries Vicegerency of Odo and William Fitz-Osbern Their sfiecial Earldoms Earls appointed for single shires ; effects f>f th change ..... Holders of subordinate commands William's policy towards the North ; the Earls sum w>n(<\ in attend him to Normandy raoB '3 14 »5 15—16 >7 18 29 30 31— 3» 33-47 33 33—37 34 34 37 39—43 43—44 44 45 46 46 47 47—50 50—53 5^—53 54—55 56 56 57—59 59 59—60 61 — 62 61 63-65 65 66—68 67 68—69 69—73 70—71 73-74 74—77 CONTENTS. XI A.U. February 4, 1067 Osw ulf dupoeed ; Copsige apjKjintcU Earl PAGB 76 § 3. Willi am' 9 first Visit to Normatuly. March —December, 1087. March, 1067 William Mis nil for Nonnamly Hifl English attentlanU or hostages Supprertsion of piracy Hirt reception in Normandy HIb visits and grants to churches His pro])able consultations with Lanfranc Englisli and Gennan skill in gold-work and em broidery .... April 8, 1067 William keeps Easter at Frcamp 990 — 1082 Condition and history of the monastery 1062 Ralph of Montdidier; his marriage with King Henry's widow The Engli.sh visitors . Consecration of churches May I, 1067 Saint Mary-on-Dive . July I Jumit'ges .... August 9 Death of Archbishop Mauriliu.s Lanfranc refuses the primacy 1067 — 1069 Primacy of .John of I vry Flourishing state of Normandy 77 79 80 81 82 8a-83 8 84-85 86 87—90 92—94 93 93 94 95 96 — 98 98 CHAPTER XVIII. THE CONQUEST OF WESTERN AND NORTHERN ENGLAND. March, 1067 — April, io;o. Great part of England still unconquered . . 101 William's motives for leaving England . loi — 103 Called back by the prospect of foreign invasion 103 § I. The Administration of Odo and William Fitz-Oshcm. March — December, 1067. Oppressive government of the regents . . 103 — 106 March 11, Revolt against Copsige ; he \% killed by Oswidf at 1067. Newbum ; Nonnan praises of him . . 106 — loS Special oppression in Herefordshire and Kent . 108 — 109 I.'nion of Wolsh and English . . . 109 August 15 E.tdri(; the Wild Iwdds out ; his alliance with Bleddyn and Rhiwallon ; their ravages in Herefordshire . no — iii xU CONTENTS. A, D. PAOR Hm KwHib MtbrtAk : help aought from BwlMt of Boologno .1 11 — 114 UnaoocoMful aiUck on Dover: 4««mi>e of EturtAce Mi«iun*rk ..... 119 — laa 1066—1093 SUU of Nonrmy ; reign* of Magnus *&d OUif K>Trc ia« WiUiun's real d«ager from Denmark 133 ( a. Thf Cofi'^iuff 0/ thf W($(. Decemhfr, 1067 — March, 10/') 9. .gX^ * Matilda and RobeK regents in Normandy . 173 William seta aafl at Dieppe . 1 24 Deoenber 7 He landH nt Winchelsea 175 December 6 Chri>«t Church burnt . 125 No open revolt in the conqueretl shires, but the West and North threatening . 126 Deoenil>or 25, wmjaui keeps Christmaa at Westminster ; further 6 '1068 confiscation H and taxations 127 — 128 Eustace of Boulo^oie tried and condemned in absence 1 28 — 129 His later reconciliation ; his lands . . 139 — 130 Death of Wulfwig, Bishop of Dorchester . 1 30 Exclusion of Englislinien from ecclesiastical prefer- ment . . . . . 131 1067 — 1092 Remigius, Bishop of Dorchester, afterwards of Lin- coln ; he is consecrated by Stigand . . 132 — 133 Autumn, 1067 Oswulf slain by a robber .... 133 — 134 Christmas, Gospatric buys the Earldom of Northumberland of 1067— 1068 William . . . . . 134—135 William's negotiations with Swend and Adalbert of Bremen; mission of Abbot i£thelsige . 135 — 137 1070 Later history of .(Ethelsige ; his outlawry . . 137 His return . . . . . 138 State of the West ; zeal of the men of Exeter ; their alliance with the neighbouring shires and towns . 138 — 139 Connexion of the Western movement with the House of Godwine; their lands in the West . . 140 — 141 Gytha and her grandsons at Exeter; state of the family ...... 141 — 143 Volunteers from other districts; story of Blaecman of Berkshire ..... 143 — 144 The West unsupported by the North . 144 CONTENTS. ziu A. D, .f^g William demands the submission of Exeter . Attempt at a compromise ; republican Hchemes at Exeter ; royal rights over the city Position of the local Thegius and of the family of Harold ..... William's answer ; he marches against Exeter His employment of Englidh troi>p8 William's march ; Ina harryings in Dor.>er8e«, but a party >\'ithdraw to the North and occupy Durham . . 193 — 194 106S— 'I069 Eadgar, Gospatric, and others pass the winter in Scotland ...... 194 — 195 Question of the destruction of Leicester . . 196 — 197 William reaches Nottingham; history of the town 196—199 William I*everel ; his castles at Nottingham and in the Peakland ..... 200 — 201 York summits ; history of the city . . 201 — 203 Foundation of the first castle ; William Malet ap- pointed Sheriff ..... 203 — 204 Bobmiasion of Archill and ^Ethelwine . . 205 First submission of Malcolm . , ao6 Extent of William's dominion in 1068 . . 206 — 207 His return march ; he reaches Lincoln . 208 History of Lincoln ; effects of William's reign on the city ...... 2o8 — 215 Comparatively favourable treatment of Lincoln and Lincolnsliiro ..... 213 — 216 Treatment of Stamford and Torkesey . . 216 — 217 Foundation of Lincoln castle . . . 217 — 218 Migration to the lower town ; churches of Cole- swegen ...... 218 — 219 William reaches Cambridge; early history of the town 219 — 221 CONTENTS. A. D. Foundation of the castle and origin of the modem tovra ...... WillL-uu at Huntingdon ; hi.^tory of the town and foundation of the caatlo .... Hea\7^ confiscations in Cambridgeshire and Hunting- donrihire ; oppres-sions of the Sheriffs Picot and Eustace ...... Harold's sons return truni Ireland; they attack Bristol in vain ..... Tlieir drawn battle with Eadnoth the Staller ; death of EadflBtal»of Eadyar in Liiuleeey . 166 fkpttmtwrlQ The Daoet and Bngttdi march on York ; the city fir«d by Um NomuuM .... 366—267 Stfiltaiberil tli* Danea and EngUah take York : oxploitn of WnllhiN.f . . 368—169 Capture of William M.nl.t and Ciilbc-rt of Ghent if>9 Dontruction of the c;u«tleM 370 The army disptrwes 17^ MoremenUi in the Wt>at; siegCH of Montacute and Exeter ...... 171—173 MoTement* in Staffortlahiro and on the Welsh border; Shrewsbury beaieged by Eadric . 273 — 374 The revolts put e8iegeni of Exeter . 379 Ea. FHgkl oT JDUMUgv; BooUind •p|K^<«> Abbot of ayal Ai^wIIb«'« ... WttlitaB Jwnnilt iho UihI* ftll«tiAt««1 by RftMrrsI ; Um aooWoo j— ji WUlaimO«ai^AtWIiMbor; .'VI ofnoauMoTTork ABdof \\.,..u.. . I w. ■ r Majt M "^^ Lag»U EroMDftid hoUa a vynod : ilcprirAtiun of JBlhoMoi aiipdBlBMBt of SUgmmi of Solavy Ami H«fMlorilmhun . . . . Maj jo Walkrlin ooaaMraied bj Ennttnind . Laafrmoo Appoint««l to CAntorbury ; hut Hcruplcji oraroooM by H«rlwin .... Aogofl 15 Laofraoc rooetVM tho Arcbbbhoprick fnnn the King Aofw* t9 Hk oooMOfmtkm § a. T*h« Primacy 0/ Lanfranc. 1070 — 1089. RoUtioM botwoen William and Tjinfranc RdAtioni between the two Archhiahopricka ; Wil- liAm'i policy requires tho aubordination of York LAofrAOC reftuea consecration to Thomaa unlcHH he mAket profia«ion ; comprombo brought a1x>ut by William ..... 1071 I^-Kufnujc and ThoniAa go to Rome for their pallia I>.-\nfranc intcrccde« for Thomas and Remigiua April 8, 107 a EAster Gcmi^t at Wincheater ; settlement of the queation between tho ArchbiahcprickH EccleaiAHtical scheme of Lanfranc ; hiii worka at CAnterliury .... 1073 — 1079 Rebuilding of Chriat Church . 1084 Hia foundation of Saint Gregory's 107a EncroAchmcnta of Odo on the lands of the see ; Lan franc recovera them on Pcnenden Heath ; reten tion of Engliah Law 1075 — 1076 Hiatory of Itocheater; death of Siward and episco- pate of Emost .... 1077 — XI08 Epi«copatc of Gundulf ; hia reforms and buildings 1070^1100 H iatory of York ; primacy of Thomas 1093 lie conaecrates Anselra ; revival of the dispute be tween the Archbishopricks Worlw of Thoniaa at York 105 1 — 1075 Biahopa of London ; episcopate of William 1075 — 10S5 Epiacopatc of Hugh of Orival 1086 — 10S7 Epiacopate of Maurice ; he begina to rebuild Saint Paul's ...... PAQI 337 339—340 340—343 .U3— 344 344 345—347 347 347—349 349—350 350—351 353—354 355—357 357— 3.'^9 359—364 361 363 364—368 369 369—372 372—374 372—373 373—374 374 375 375 - CONTENTS. XIX A.D. 1070 — 1098 1046 — 1072 1072— II03 I 107 — 1 136 1079 1079— 1095 1075 1085 1084 1077 — I0S4 1077— 1095 io85-_io87 1072— 1 104 1089 — 1 100 1071 or 107a 1078 1082 — 1083 1089 — 1090 io66-io77(?) 1077— 1088 1072 (?) 1077 1070 — 1076 1088 History of Winchester ; epiMOpttta of Walkelin ; Hchemo for the substitution of canons for monkB Hutory of Exuter ; episcopate of Leofric Episcopate of Osbem ; his English tendencies Foundation of the present cathedral by William of Warolwaat .... History of Hereford ; death of Walter Episcopate of Koljert; he rebuilds the church History of Wulfstan ; his deposition desi^euncils held by Lanfranc ; distinction between ecclesiastical and temporal assemblies Deposition of Abbots ; Wulfric of New Minster sue ceeded by Rhiwallon Deposition of ^thelnoth of Glastonbury Tiiurstan Abbot of Glastonbiirj- ; his dispute with the monks and deposition by William He buys his restoration of William Rufus Fritliric Abbot of Saint Albau's ; legendary nature of his history .... Paul Abbot of St. Alban's ; his reforms and build ings ; he destroys the tombs of the English Abbots William's personal zeal in ecclesiastical matters appointment of Abbots of Westminster Eadwinc succeeded by Geoffrey Appointment of Vital ; correspondence of William with John of Fecamp William's vow to Saint Martin ; beginning of the foundation of Battle Abbey Story of the building of the Abbey ; the High Altar fixed on the site of the Standard . Succession of Abbots; consecration of the church Exemption of the Abbey from episcopal jurisiliction Lanfranc's opposition to monastic exemptions ; his dealings with Saint Eadniundsbury His dealings with Saint Augustine's; he forces Abbot Guy on the monks .... b 2 PAGE 375 — 376 378 378 379 379 379—383 3^3 384-385 385-387 387—391 387-388 388 388 388—389 3«9 391—393 393 394 394—397 398 398 398—400 401 401 401 — 402 402 — 404 404—409 406 — 407 409 — 410 410 — 412 412—414 IX CONTENTS. " A.O. TAQI 107s DwwfertUrMxmJaf IMAeyriok»;ooinpari»oi>of Bi^tfeb Aod ooQllimitel MM . 414-417 1075—1078 llaniuuui rMMortt th* •«• of 8h«rboro« to Haluilitirv 418 I III FooadfttioQ of D«w RalUbury 4'^^ 107S— 1079 B|4wo|iU of Owomid .... 418 BOgnad rmovva the fee of StUaoy to Chioheetor 4^9 1071—1085 Peler r«Bo?«e Ibo ■•« of Uohfield to ObeeUr 419 1086—1 117 Robert of LimMcy rvnuivMi the Me to Coventn' ; hb Ul«treftlment of tlie mooka and rebuke from I^n- ft«no : Uter hiirtory of the eee 4i(>— 421 1085 Remigiua ramovee the ace of Durchoiitor to Lincoln 441 1078 HeHk«t reiDOTee the eee of Elmbam to Tlntford 4^1 1091 — 1119 Herbert Loeinga remoree the vee U> Norwich 4?^ 1088 — 1 13 J John of Touni removee the aee of Wellit to lUith 43a April 1. 1076 Council at Winchc«tor : i' • ■ !,of the nmrrift^'o of the clergy; modificatic I .(•n>c«of Ilililebrand 422 — 426 1076 MI«don of Thomaa, Lanfranc. and Remigiua to Rome; prinlojjofi coiifinn«'iki |>nw- Ugwof tbo BAridoai .... 489 — 491 1073^1088 Robvrt of HhudJljui ; hi* wmn with the Wolnh . 490-h9> 1 101 BmI Uilglidiaf a monk ; hut friend*lii]> ri>r An»olm . 4y3 Roftr of Mtmtfommjt Karl of ShrowNhiirv ; privt- lofM of iho KMrldom ; iroAtmeDt of Shrowibtiry . 493 — 494 lo8a Moitlorof MaImI at Burat; good influence of Ili>t;t3r'a •aoood wif« AdaliA .... 4<;4— 495 Uktorjr of Odderiua ; bia MtUement aX Shrcynbury . 495 ' . ' Birth of Ordario ; hit BogUah educatioD 495 — 496 1085 Oideric MOi to Saint £\-roul ; hi« abiding EngliBh ftialinj ; lewam* ' ' v hiH liixtory . 496^498 10^7 — 1094 Bari Rogvr foaQd^ ' ury Abbuy at the MUggoa- Uon of OdelcHuJi ; hi« duath . 498 — 500 loSi Earl Roger introduoM Cluniac nionkn at Wmilock . 500 1071 — 1071 Roger's wara with tho Wcbih ; fuimdation of Mont- gomery Castlo ..... 503 — 503 1067 — 1071 Earldom of Hereford under William Fitz-08lH?rn . 502 — 504 1070 Hin warn with tho Weli*h ; hia allianco with Canidoc the 8«m of CJruffydd .... 503 1070 Maloohu ravages Northern England 505 He receives Eiidg.ir and hi.H nisterrt at Wearmouth . 505 — 506 Go8{>atric invades Cumberhmd ; iucrcawod cruelties of Malcolm ...... 506 — 508 Eadgar and his bi^iters remain in Sc-otland ; marriage of Malcolm and Margaret; ita lasting effects . 508 — 513 April 3. 1071 Walcher taketi possession of the aee of Durham . 513 August 15, William invaded .Scotland ; ho in accompanied by *°7^ Eadric ...... 514—515 Malc«»bu does homage at Abemetby . . . 515 — 518 November, Legentb* of William's return ; foundation of the caetle *o7i of Durham. ..... 518—522 November, Gospjitrio deprived of his Earldom ; his later history '°7* and {>artial restoration .... 532 — 524 1073 — 1075 Waltheert Regency of Richildls ; she asks help of William Fitz- Osljeni . . .... February 20, French and Norman intervention in Flanders ; battle ^07^ ^ of Caasel ; death of Count Aniulf and William Fitz-Oabem ; imprisonment of Gerbod of Chester Philip makes peace with Robert ; delay of Amulf's German allies ..... Division of the estates of William Fitz-Osbem Hostility between Normandy and Flanders ; William abets Baldwin of Hennegau against Robert May, 1074 William's alleged designs on Germany; alleged in- vitation from .tVrchbishop Hanno of Koln Other versions and estimate of the story 1072 William in Normandy ; Synod of Rouen 1069 — 1085 State of iNIaine ; episcopate of Amo Id 1066 — 1109 Fulk Rechin of Anjou ; his alleged intrigues 1073 Revolt of Maine ; invitation to Azo and Gersendis and their son Hugh ; action of Geoffrey of May- enne and Bishop Arnold .... Azo in Maine ; he leaves Gersendis and her son behind; relations of Geoffrey and Gersendis Municipal traditions in Gaul ; the Commune of Le Mans ...... War of the Commune with Hugh of Sill»5 ; treason of Geoff'rey ...... Gersendis betrays the castle to Geoffrey ; the citizens invite Fulk, who takes the castle . William sets forth to recover Maine ; his English troops ...... Harrying of Maine ; sieges of Fresnay and Sillt? ; sur- render of Le Mans and submi-ssion of the country Fulk attacks La Flbche ; he is joined by Howel and the Bretons ..... Peace of Blanchelande ; Robert does homage to Fulk for Maine ...... ■530 53» 531—532 532—533 533 534—535 535—53^^ 536—537 537 538 538—539 539—540 540—543 543—544 544—545 545—547 547—548 548—552 552—554 554—556 556—558 558—560 561 5M— 564 lULkW CONTENTS 107^—1076. A. D. 1071—1074 I07J 1074 J^)r8.io74 lor* December 19, ChnHtniag, 1075 — 1076 14*7 '5.1076 I s n. 8uu of Bufkad; Innwiii \ opprawioo: ipMial MMplafaili of Um BngHth womm . Jmkmtj UlwMo WlUUm and Phili] N^lUkm rttarea to BngUnd . !!• goo* back to Nonuandy . Badgw goot fmm FUaden to StxitlAod ; Fliillp oflcnt Montraail to him . bdgttr Mta mdl fur Fnuico, but in driven beck Hb reooocilUUian with Williiuu DMling* of WiUJAiD » ilh Walthcof . Bogvr KatI of Hereford lujipcctad of treMon; Lan franc'* Ictlem and exromi). m Ralph of NoKolk niarrics i -iw <.f Ito^'or oituipiracj at tho bride -ale QttostioD of tho complicity of Walthoof; hiu cuufcti noDB to Lanfranc and Williatn Revolt of Ralph and Roger; tho Bretons HupiMirt Ralph ; aid sought from Dciuuark Roger defeated and taken prinoner Ralph encamps at Cambridge ; ho flieH to Norwich Union of Normami and English ; mutilation of the pHBonors ..... Ilal]>h flies to Denmark and thence to Britanny Norwich defended by Emma ; its siege and capitula tion ..... WillL-un returns ; arrest of Waltheof The Danish fleet in the Humber ; plunder of York Minster ..... Death of Eadgyth ; her burial at Westminster Midwinter Gem6t at Westminster ; trial of the Earls and their folio wen* .... Ilolph condemned by default ; cruel punishment of the Bret^)n« ..... Trial and condemnation of Roger ; his imprisonment for life ...... Trial of Waltheof; enmity of his wife Judith ; he is remanded to prison at Winchester Confiscation of the lands of Ilalph and Roger ; grants to Roger the Bigod ; no new Earls appointed Continued imprisonment of Waltheof ; his penitence His final trial and condemnation to death; injustice of the sentence ..... Beheading of Waltheof ; he is looked upon as a martyr raoi 564-668 568 568 568—569 570— 57* 57a 573 574-578 578-579 579 5So_5H, 5H0-5H1 581 582-584 580-584 585 585-586 587-588 589 589 590—592 590—591 59» 593 593—594 594— 59^) CONTENTS. XXV A. D. PAGE ywvj — 715 Iliritory of Crowland ; story of Saint Guth lac 597 c. 877 Monastery deatroyc«l by tlie Danes . . 597 946—955 IlestoreJ by Thurc>'tol .... 597 1063 — 10S6 Ulfcytel Abbot of Crowland; gifts of Waltheof t«i the monastery ..... 598 ^^ ''' WaUheofs body tranalatod to Crowland 599 Q.^ '^V Deposition of Ulfcytel ; itn probable grounds . 599 1086 — 1 109 Ing:ulf Abbot of CrowLand, his real and legendary history ...... 600 — 601 1092 Second translation of Waltheof ; hli niinicles 601 — 602 1 109 — 1124 Geoffrey Abbot of Crowland .... 602 11:4 — 113S Waltheof Abbot of Crowland ; visit of Orderic . 603 Real and lej^^endary history of Judith; her founda- tion at Eldtow ..... 603 — 604 c. 1089 M«itilda, daughter of Waltheof, marries Simon of Senlis ; her second marriage with David of Scot- land ; it8 results ..... 604 — 605 Estimate of the execution of Waltheof . . 605 — 607 William's love of hunting ; nature of hunting in early times ..... 608 — 609 Beginning of Forest Laws ; legislation of William . 609 — 610 1070 — 1081 Making of the New Forest ; contemporary feeling . 611 — 613 Deaths of his children in the New Forest ; a curse deemed to rest on lus house . . . 613 — 615 CHAPTER XXL THE LATEB DAYS OF WILLIAM. IO76 — 1087. § I. Character of the Later Reign of William. Quiet of England ; William's unsuccessful warfare on the Continent ..... 616 — 617 Character of William's government ; his strict pro- se r\ation of the peace .... 617 — 619 His fiscal and other oppressions . 620—622 His revenue . . . . . . 623 He keeps up the meetings of the Witan . . 623 His legislation ; legal relations between French and English ...... 623 — ^)24 Laws against the slave-trade . . . 625 Capital punishment forbidden ; practice of mutilation 625 William's personal appearance; splendour of his court; his avarice ..... 625 — 626 Practical deHputism of his government . . 627 1XV1 CONTKNT8. A- II. A|«ili.io«i of Alriioc KotnDAiuw: Itubvrt Wiacanl ibe luMUni Empire : Kufluh roiufurov 1077 Juno Robert bMl>gw I>jrHuirhion Oclubtf AUxiot OOOMH Ui iU rvlivi ; hiit 1 a:u.\ OoCob«ri8 Bttlll* of Djrrhachiun ; vitluur an.l hl.iu^l.trr of tho BogUab Aloxioa boUda lub6to« ... 10S3 Tb« Baglkib dafnd KA«iert at CJerberoi William besieges Gerberoi ; he is defeated and wounded by Robert William reconciled to his son ; Gregory's letter to Robert ..... Robert's expedition to Scotland ; his final quarrel with his father .... 1086^1090 Constance raarrio.s Alan of Britanny ; her death and character ..... 1080 Marriage of Adela with Steplien of Chartres 1074 — 1082 Story of Simon of Valoia ; he refuses William' daughter and helps to reconcile Robert Betrothal of a daughter of W^illiam to Alfonso « ^' Death of Queen Matilda; her tomb and epitaph 1079 .Januarj-, 1080 May 8 Autumn TAQU 637—618 6a8 6J9 6J9 630—631 631 631—633 637 633 ^'33— ^»34 ^•35 r.36 637 638 638 — 642 642—643 643—644 644 — 646 646 6^7 — 648 649 — 650 650 650—^51 652—654 652—654 654—655 655—656 CONTENTS. xxvii A. D. PAGE 1083 Revolt of Hubert of Beaamont ; be defendfl Saints Susanne ...... 656 1083 — 1086 War of Sainte-Susanne ; ill success of William; death of liiclicr of L'Aiglo . 657 — 659 1086 Hubert reconciled to William (>S9 /^J'^ '~ Death of Bishop Hugh of Lisioux ; dispute as to bis 10 J- 7 ' burial ...... 659 — 660 1077 — 1 100 Gilbert Mamiiiot, Bishop of Lisieux ; his character . 660 — 661 1079 — 1100 Death of Archbishop Joliri ; the see of lloueu re- fused by Wimund ; Priiuacy of William ** Bona Anima" . . . . . . 661 1086 Council of Lillebouue; re-enactment of the Truce of God ...... 661—662 § 3. The Affairs of the Scottish and Welsh Marches. 1078— 108 1. 1078 Malcolm defeats Maelsljehta .... 663 Augu.st, 1079 Malcolm inva»^ i-lory of 8fth)i FooatUlioD of Canliff CmU« I iii.k ■■ t' PAOB (.79 1081 io8j CliiblinM. 1083—1084 107^ 1076— I oSo 1080—1086 1085 Julv 10, I0S6 ChrifiliDaA, xoSf— 1086 JanuAO* — July. 1086 May 14 Auguiit I f 4. Tk€ IjUtrLtgkkMm^fWiakm, io8j-io86. ChArmcirr of the joan 1 08 J - 1 086 TriUo and opprowion of Odu ; bo Mpirca to tlio I^I*<7 Wtlluun Accuaea And arretU him ; hi* imprbonmeni At Koueo ..... FAOiine in EngUnd .... Tax Uid on ih« land .... State of DenmArk ; deAth of Swend Ectrithaon Keign of HATiiId Iloin I<«i)ni of SAint Cnut ; he ])rop.arc« to inviido Eng Uud ; contingent of Obif Kyrro WiUiAm returns to EngUnd ; his mercenaries ; he Iajs wAste the coAst Discontent of the Danish fleet ; martyrdom of Cnut Gein6t At Gloucester ; the Great Survey ordered The Commiwion for the Survey ; popular discontent and disturbances ..... Whitsun Gemdt at Westminster; Henry dubbed knight ...... Gemot at Salisbur}' ; all landowners become the men of the Kinj.: ; effect on later Engliah history Another tax laid on ; William goes to Normandy Eadgar goes to Apulia ; Christina takes the veil 681 681— 68a 683—685 685 685—686 686 686 686—687 688—689 689 690 — 691 691 — 694 694 694 — 696 696 — 697 697 § 5. Tfu L(Ut Days of William. A xujujst — iScptemher, 1 08 7. Physical jiha-nomena of the years 1086 — 1087 miscellaneous events and deaths . 1087 Dispute about the French Vexin; incxirsions of the French commanders at Mantes William's sickness at Rouen; I'hilip's jest . Aogaat, 1087 William invades the Vexin August 15 William bums Mantes, and receives hi.s death- wound He is carried U) Saint Oer\'ai8 ; bin sickncHH . Angiist 14 Death of Gull>ert of Hugleville August 24 Death of Gunhild at Bruges . 697—699 699 — 700 700 — 701 701 701—703 704 705 705 CONTENTS. A. D. Details of William 'h sickiiesH ; hiii rei>cntance and dlspoflal of hi8 iloiniuioiiH .... HLs bequest to Henry .... He releAaes hb priisionere .... September 9 Death uf William ..... General confutiion at his death ; neglect of hiti Ixnly ; he is taken to Caen by Herlwin Reception of the bf T\^<■ AWogtd iVtuutov of WUlinm'a •oltliom NN. Fnihric Abbot of Saint A llian'ii GO. Th« Legend of Herowanl . PP. Biahopt ^-Ethclric nntl .Y^tholwino . QQ. Tb« Connexion of Wftlthoof with the ConHpimry of BAlph RR. The Siege of Dol and the Marriage r>f Conntanco SS. The Battle of Gerben.t TT. Tlie Betrothal of William's Daughter to Alfoniw UU. The Claim of Ascelln PAQI 78J 786 78H 790 794 7V« Koo Koo 800 800 801 801 804 8ia 813 816 818 810 8a I k -V f^ ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. p. 19, note, for " WilHnm of Poitiers who," rea«l " William of Poitiers, who." p. 34, 1. 20. The Words about Ralph of Norfolk should bo left out. See p. 737. p. 41,1. 3, for " Regemibald " read " Regenbald " or ♦' Reinbald." p. 64, 1. 10. For Eadric'8 title of "Child" see p. ill. p. 70, 1. 2 from bottom. Norfolk and Suffolk seem to have both been under the government of Ralph of Wader ; but the two divisions of East- Anglia were only just beginning to be looked on a.s distinct shires. p. 94, 1. 17, for " schimatically " read ** schismatically." p. 118, note 3, for "quietum" reatl "quietem." p. 124, note I. In connexion wnth this should be taken William of Malmes- bury's account (v. 407), in which Roger appears as almost equalling Gulbert of Hugleville in his own person, though not as carrying his scruples so far as to forbid the enrichment of his sons; "Homo antique simplicitatis et fidei, qui, crebni a Willehno primo invitatus ut Angliam veniret, largis ad voluntatem possessionibus munerandus, supersedit ; pronuncians, patrum suorum ha?re- ditatem se velle fovere, non transmarinas et indebitas possessiones vel appetere vel invadere." p. 130, 1. 5, for "other shires in those western lands" read "other shires and in those western lands." p. 143, 1. I. On the probability that Wulf had a twin brother, bearing the name of his father, see p. 756. p. 164, 1. 4 from bottom. No part of Eadnoth's lands seema to have passed to his son. See p. 759. J). 170, note 2, for "tone" read "tenet." p. 178, 1. II. Tiuit P>ri3tol Castle wiis built during William's reign, possibly at the very end of it, appears from its appearing in 1088 as one of the great centres of revolt. Sot; the Chronicle and Florence under that year, where the two Mowbrays " ferdou to Bricgstowe and hergodon and brohton to ham castele pa hergunge, and syCCon foron ut of \>&m castele and hergodon BatJon and eall pa-t land pair abutau and call Beorclea hyrnesse hi awajston." p. 193. note I, for "NN " road "00." p. '214, note a. TIjo "Turoldus" here spoken of is doubtless the Sheriff Thorold. See p. 472, note 3. p. 157, note 2. Compare the business spoken of in p. 21, note 5. xxxu ADDITIOKB AND CORRBCTIONa PIK «6;-i^9. noU V For **inAU oopH. Ebomcum " raad "mRla, crpii |v 17^ b>4« 9. For "l"-!i.>trN, ,lr...« tJuilUlit.uiii ■ ii.v*l "I'cJnitrh diu*, GoiUalaam," |k> A08. L 4 ttom botUon. fur " rvUin " mad " rvUicu.** p. Jil6, nc4« I, far " 1. ■ rvA*! " nuvxiiuui." .. . , 1 . ^ s, |U1| .. . i .-- ^X ScriptU 531. cf. R Wcndorer. il. 187) Mys c! oiind ill 1 158, " llrnricun lUx An({l«>runi, curimatuii Apud Wi^or- ptwt crlcl>nit4oneiu divim»niin comnnm huikt altArv iMnniit, noc ulU-thero were Howral Abbota — who Murvivod all thaa^m, and died in poaenion of hi* wee long aftialum fixcrit." p. 371, side-note, for "Cambridge" reml "Cambridgeshire." p- 373. 1. 3- The question was also raised by Thomas at the intended dedication of Remigius' church at Lincoln in 1092, when Thomas " illi con- traiiicendo rcsistcbat, affirmans cam in suA parocliid esse constructam." >Su •aya Florence, who goes on with a story which revives the old charge of si: ■ ^' * US, William Rufus " pro pccuniA quam ei Rcmigius d- ip« to dedicate the church, and Iteuiigius dies before the appointed day "occulto Dei judicio." p. 374, note I. Put a semicolon after "reppcrit." p. 382, note 3. Put a semicolon after ** retrado," p. 391, heading, for " Churches " read " Churchmen." p. 402, note 3, for " in-finibus " read " in fiuibuH." p. 420, L 4 from bottom. The wonls of William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 310, Gest. Reg. iv. 341) are remarkable. In the Gesta Regum he clearly wishes to imply that there was no lawful removal of the see to Coventry ; "Quinetiam moritunis, />arrf faciens scita canonum quihus edicitur jxmtifices M tuis tedCbiit sepdiri dibtrc, non apud Cestram, sed apud Coventreiam se tumulatum in pnecepit; auk opinione relinquens successuris non indebitum calumoiandi, Hcd quasi jus legitimum vindicandi." The words in Italics are left out in the Ge«ta Pontificum. p. 427, note I. William of Malmesbury seems here to be copying Florence, 1094 ; " Hereberhtus, qui ctignominabatur LoHinga, quod ei ars adulationia nui»cr egerat." The name without the explanation appears in the Chronicle of the same year, under the form of " Herbearde Losange." See his life and ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. ^^^^^^ writings discussed in the preface to his letters in the Herit-.s called Annalee Monastici in the sanie volume with the letters of Osbert of Clare. p. 433, note 3, del; comma after " atlds," p. 444, side-note, for " change " read "changed." p. 445, note 2. We have another witnesH to the same effect in the contrast drawn l>y William of Malmesburj' Utween the ecclesiastical rule of the Con- queror and that of bis successor (iv. 314); "Temiwre patris, post decesHum epi.scopi vel abbatis oinnes reditus integre custodiebantur. subrttituendo pantori resignaudi, eligebantunjue personK religionis inerit«J laudabileH ; at vero, pauculis annia intercedentibus, omnia immutata." p. 448, side-note, for "wealth of the country" reai.1 "wrath of the courtiers." p. 449, 1. II. Yet the question might have been raised whether the acceptance of the see of Aversa did not imply complicity in the Norman Conquest of Apulia, and whether the Norman Conquest of Apulia was not aa blameworthy aa that of England. Perhaps longer posses-sion and the specially Nonnan character of Aversa might be held to make a difference, p. 458, note 2, for " qui inter paludes " read " quia inter paludes." p. 470, side-note, for "settlement" read "settlements." p. 477, line 6, dele " with." p. 478, note 5, for " lb." read " Hi.st. Ab. u. a." pp. 482, 483, .side notes, for " 1076" read " 1073;" for " 1079" read " 1075;" for " 1086 " read " 1082 ;" for " 1089" read " 1082." See below, p. 824. p. 4QO, I. 10. Yet Roger of Poitou appears in the Chronicle (1093) under the form of " Rogger Peiteuin," and again in William of Malmesbury (v. 396) with the reason for his surname — "quod ex ea regione uxorem acceperat sic dictus." p. 502, 1. 9 from bottom. The castle of "Muntguniri" appears in the Chronicle, 1095, as taken by the Welsh. p. 502, 1. 2 from bottom. On the date of William Fitz-Osbem's appoint- ment art Earl, see above, p. 72. But I ought to have mentioned the grant of the Isle of Wight to him, at one date or the other. Orderic (521 D) couples it with the grant of the Earldom ; " Rex Guillelmus . . . Willelmo dapifero Normanniie, Osbemi filio, insulam V^ectatu et comitatum Herfordensem dedit." The large Crown lands in Wight which appear in Domesday had doubtless been his. The union of Wight and Hereford under William Fitz-Osbem is like the union of Arundel and Shrewsbury under Roger of Montgomery. It is quite in character with William's policy. P' 5^7. 1- 5 from bottom. This is the " Dunechaldus, Regis Scottonim Malcolini filius," whom we read of as being released — "a custodia laxatum" — on the death of William (see Florence, 1087, and below, p. 711). He is also the *' Dunecan Melcomes cynges sunu " of the Chronicle under 1097, who appears with the same description in Florence, with the addition that " Regi Willelmo [Rufo] tunc militavit." Donald is Dufenal or Dufenaldus the brother of Malcolm. William of Malmesbury (v. 399) calls Duncan " tilium Malcolmi nothuni," which is hard on Tngebiorg. C XXXIV ADDITIONS AND rOHHEtTlONS. p. fso. I. lo \Vc (imi Joul>(< M (•> tlir )>o4ly of Sidni Cuihborht rmiaad •f»in ill 1 104 hy '* i|u>kniiiiiliuu iiu-rr>|>c«ra iu iho Chronido (i 138) luid in Florence (1094) Ml ** IVuttrfljuntmnl." P- 5'4< I- 5- 1 «up|Ki«' tlukt thin iXilfin ia ibo Bame who appeara in the Cbrtmicl« untlrr 1091 ae hoUltng (."arliitlo or iU nitc, no doubt by tbe gnuit uf Maloolm. 1I« U drlren thence by Willtjun HufuK. p. 5 1 a. Dole a. See aboT«, p. 44 1 . p. 53a, Li. It b hard to believe tho statemont or William of Malme»> bury (t. 403) thill William paid a yearly fxMiHion of thruo lniM(lr»« 1* 5- ' need hardly except the Hinall and doubtful caac of the Priory of CariabrtHtkc in the IhK> of Wijrht. CariHbrooke in not mentioned by that naine in Domeeday. but William Fitz-Oabern gave Hevoral churcheH in the ialand, and amonf( them Bowcomb, by which is probably meant CariHbrooke (Domeeday, 5a. 53 b), to Win foundation at Lyra, f'arisbrooke before long («ee MonaaticoD, vii. 1090-109 1) became a cell to Lyra, but it is not ckar that it waa atrictly speaking a foundation of W^illiam Fitz-Osbem. p. 573, 1. I, deJf " the" l>efore " Huccesaor." p. 575, note 2, for " vcHtram " read *' vestrum." P- 59 >> 1- 7 from bottom. I do not feel quite satisfied about this life-long iiupriaunmeut of Koger. See p. 711. p. 600, last line, for *' in " read ** among." p. 604^ n<»te 4, for ** W^ade\i" read " Waldevi." p. 620, 1. 13, for " more i>ounds " read " more himdred pounds." p. 629, note I. I ought to have remarked that Albcric got his pun from William of Malme«bury, iv. .^87; "Quum oppidani fiducia mcenium jactitarent ideo urbem Durachium nominatum, quod contra omnes obsidiones imperterrita duraret, ' Et ego ' (inquitj ' vocor Durandus ; et eo usque in obsidione durabo quo civitati nomcn auferam, ut non Dunichium sed MoUiciumamodo dicatur.*" p. 638, note 3. William of Malmesbury (iv. 389) also puts the nickname into William's mouth; " Per resurrectionem Dei, probus erit Robelinus Curta Ocrea." His character of llobert is one degree better than that given by Orderic. After mentioning the nickname, he adds, " Hoc enim erat ejus cog- nomen, quod esset exiguus ; caeterum nihil habens quod succenseres, quia nee illepida: forma, nee infaceti eloquii, nee virtutis imbecillte, nee enervis erat conailii." He had just before said, "Natus in Nonnannia, spectatae jam Tirtutis habebatur adolescens quando pater Angliam venit ; fortitudinis pro- bata', quamquam exilis corporis et pinguis a^iualiculi." p. 644, I. 5. We find a man of the same name and office — very likely a son —in the Chronicle, 1 1 24 ; " \>ea kinges stiward of France Amalri." p. 651, note 3, for " zeal of" read " zeal for." p. 660, note 2, for " voluntate " reatl " voluntati." ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. ^xxv p. 662, note I. Fifteen yeare later, 1095, the Truce of God was confirmed by the higher authority of the Council of Clermont. Will. Malm. iv. 345 ; " Quod ab Adventu Domini usque ad octavas Epiphaniae, et a SeptuagesiiuA usque ad octavas Paschee, et a primd die Rogationum unque ad octava^ Pente> costes, et a (juarta ft*ria occidente sole oiuni tempore usque ad secundam feriam oriunte sole trevia Dei custodiatur." p. 670, 1. I. This Ealdgyth would be a niece of Ealdgjiih the daughter of Uhtred and mother of Gortpatric, See j). 134. I trust to go more fully into these pedigrees in my fifth volume. p. 676, 1. 2. Tlie New Castle and the castle at Tynemouth ("se castel set Tinemudan") appear in the Chronicle, 1095 ; " Feorde se eorl [Robert of Mowbray] aure nihte ut of Bebbaburh towardes TinemuCan ac \)V^ be innan ))ani niicun ciutde waeron his gewaer wurdon." p. 677, note 3. On the character of this Bishop see the remarkable entry in the Clironicle (1088) recording his revolt against William Rufus ; " Swa waell dyde se cyng be ^am biscope )>ddt eall Euglaland fierde tefter his nede and swa swa he wolde, and he l)ohte to donne be him eall swa Judas ScarioS dide be ure Drihtene." This is somewhat softened by Florence ; " Ea quoque tempestate Rex praedictus illius, ut veri consiliarii, fruebatur prudentia ; bene enim sapiebat, ejusque consiliis totius Angliae tractabatur respublica." p. 683, note I. If by these words we are to understand an " aula regia " in Wight itself, we can hardly place it anywhere but at Carisbrooke. There must have been some royal dwelling-place in Wight, as William stayed there some time in 1086 (see p. 697), and Carisbrooke is most likely intended by the entry in Domesday (52 h) about a castle at Alwinestone. See Ellis, i. 213. p. 710, last line, for "and .^fgar" read "the son of ^Ifgar." p. 711, note I, for " Donald" read " Duncan." p. 731, Note G. A better spelling of this name, according to its evident origin, would be Wiggod, and it is so spelled in the Worcester Chronicle, 1079. See p. 818. P- 735» 1- 3- ^" ^^6 works of Robert of Oily see Mr. James Parker's just published History of O.xford, pp. 38 et sec^q, p. 735, 1. 10 from bottom, for "Hugh Grantmesnil" read "Hugh of Grantmesnil." p. 745, Note N. In the Chronicle for 1088 we read of " Eustatius se iunga " as engaged in the revolt against William Rufiis. For this Florence has " Eustatius junior, Comes Bonmiice," which sounds as if he looked on the elder Eustace as having died before 1088. p. 768,1. 15, after "Norman writers" add "and Englishmen wTiting in Latin." p. 773, 1. 13 from bottom, for " would probably " read " probably would." p. 778, Note Z. For a full discussion of the rea<^ling and authority of the manuscripts see Mr. James Parker's Hi3tt>ry of Oxford, p. 36. p. 791, 1. 8 from bottom. I should have mentioned that it is here that William of Malmesbury (v. 390) quotes tiie proverb which elsewhere (see vol. ii. p. 274) has been put into the mouth of Fulk the Good of Anjou. Henry xxxn ADDITIONS AND OORRECTIONft. ').:•.. )ftt ; iuIiIikI*, putrr i|Uoq«<» midl- (i.io. I*. . 1^ V torntua. Mlnoa ooroDaiuN.' " p. 793. L 4. : lOf; Ihta mAttrr sfn^n. I think it i* nn open nt that th» Jfinglith King, whether iflifrrd Aval ..., ... , . . wliich ho and M. «le Itinjiufort (jive «lifforfntly, and wh •urM arbitrary. But in rithor caM*, if we Accept the reading IlcmrU. Uio i*lu^U»h fniucation of Henry the Fimt in c<|UAlly RMHertetl. On the ,..>., ».,., 1 \( .11 .1,.. ,, ^^^ i„ ^ tranjilntion from Latin into Kn^Unh, one Kin^ iiit<'ndo«i in taken away. But the know- Ctreck in almut an equal difficulty in either caao. J' 797, 1. a. for " sal u tens " r«ad "ialutem." p. 800, 1. I. For "plaTt" read "play." Florence aUo in the pi— g* rdvrrad to speaks of Stephen m *'fiIiuB amitn^ filius" [Willelmi Rufi, hc.], which would nutkc him the son of n biHter <>f Williani. }{ifl father appearH in the Chronicle (1096) as " Eoda e<»rl of Campaine )«i'8 cyny;eH ciOi/nj," a word which leaves the question open. p. 810, 1. 11 from bottom, for ** remarking " read " finding out." THE HISTORY OF THE NORMAN CONQUEST OF ENGLAND. VOL. IV. T CHAPTER XVII. THE FIRST DAYS OF WILLIAM's REIGN. ^ Decemljer 1066 — December 1067. § 1. Character of {he Reign of William. HE coronation rite was over, and the formal reign of Position of 1 • A f WilliAin at \Villiam over England was to begin. As far as out- the time of ward forms were concerned, he might be looked on as King ^^^^ over the whole land. He had indeed direct military pos- ' The chief thing to be noticed with regard to the authorities for these years is the los3 of some of the most important. The Biographer of Eadward failed us at the death of his own hero or, at the outside, at the Battle of Stainfordbridge. With the Battle of Stamfordbridge also the Abingdon Chronicle comes suddenly to an end. The Tapestry takes us only to the flight of the light-armed at 8enlac, and the poem of Guy of Amiens takes us only to the coronation of William, ^\''ace again ceases to be of any value just at present, as he cuts tlie history of William very short between his coronation and his burial. We miss also Mr. Kemble's great collection of Charters, which contains only a few documents later than the acces-sion of William. The documents of William's reign are numerous and important, but we have to seek them where we can find them, in the Foedera, in the Monasticon, in Hickes' Thesaurus, in the various local his- tories, anywhere in short where they may happen to be preserved. (A continuation, as well as a new recension, of the Codex Diplomaticus would be an unspeakable gain to historical scholarship.) And, while we lose so many of our old authorities, we are not reinforced by new ones of any importance. But several of our remaining authorities increase in value. Flo- rence now definitely becomes an independent and, as we go on, a contemporary writer of the first rank. Orderic, bom in 1075, does not reach that rank during our present period ; still he had good means of information, and his value gradually increases. So does that of William of Malmesbury as he gets nearer to his own time. Tho value of Henry of Huntingdon on the other hand lessens. His main value has always consisted in the early tra- ditions and fragments of early songs which he preserves, and his stock of B 2 TIIK FIROT DAYS OF WILLIAMS KEION. cBAr. xm. MMion only of ivrtniii of tlir Hi>utliorii uiul ciiHtcrn hliircH. •tied Rut it dotii not np]K*ar tlmt iiny part of tin- laiul was at . thid moment uctiially in arniK a;;:iiinHt him. Rival Kin^ ihcrp wiw none. Tho rival who had appoarod a^-ainsl him for a rooment liad suhmtttiHi to him and had I urn reci'iviMl to bis favour. Th»' rlnef mm of a larj^t* part of En^hiiul Forftioaorhad guhmittoil with him. h^idwine and Morkoro indocd mhI Mur- ***^^ hM out^* but they Koom to liave been simply, after k«r«. their manner, waitinj^ to wh' what eourse eventa would take. At all events they did not venture on any armed op|K)sition. Ami the eonsccration of William by tho Northumbrian Primate mi^ht be looked on as Bome sort of guaranty, however weak, for the obedience of his pro- vince. The two chiefs of the national Church, the repre- sentative of the national king-ship, the holiest Prelate in England, the chosen friend of the slain Harold, had all bowed to AVilliam and luid become his men. ^ He had possession of the miiifhtiest and of the most venerable of Enn-lish cities. The metropolis of yEthelberht, the royal city of .'Elfred, were alike his. He had been crowned in Eadward's church ; he dwelt in Eadward's palace; and if London had been slow to submit, a fortress was now rising- which would for ever fetter the hands of William's un- willinjj subjects. It mig-ht well seem that England was already William's in fact as well as in name. York, Gloucester, Exeter, had as yet not seen his face. But it might seem that all that was needed for their full posses- sion was for the King* to show himself before their gates in the friendly state of a peaceful progress. William, King them now grows inucli siualler. The subsidiary sources, the local writeru and the incidental notices in foreign authors, have to be attended to much M before. And the jiaramount importance of Domasday grows, I need hardly say, at every step as we draw near to the date of the Survey itself. The nuuis of personal and local detail which may be recovered from its incidental entries is utterly amazing. * See vol. iii. pj». 547, 767. '"' See vol. iii. pp. 529, 547. EFFECTS OF VVILLIAM's CORONATION. 6 of the Eng-lish, King" chosen, crowned, and anointetl, nii^ht chap. xvn. well grive himself out as already master of the whole realm. And yet we may be sure that there was none who knew England better than the Conqueror himself how far the land still conquured. was from bein<>' conijuerud. A\ illiam was Kin<»' ; but he knew well that in the g-reater part of his Kin*^dom his kintj-ship as yet hardly existed in name. But he knew also Advantage how much he had gained by becoming* a King. William ofhisCoro- knew, as well as Henry the Eighth himself, the inestimable "^^'•^"• advantage of having the letter of the law on his side. Since the homage at Berkhampstead, since the election and Fonnal coronation at Westminster, William was no longer a mere of'hu foreign invader, a mere candidate or pretender to the P<>»'^'o"- Crown. He was, as far as outward ceremonies could make him, the King", the choice of the English peoi)le, the con- 8ecrateortant staflfes of the Conquest which followed William's eoroniition seems to be thi«. Tlie opjxisition which William met with wjis in truth the stuhlKirn resistance of a land striving* to ^uard the last fira^mcnts of its freedom against the assaults of a forci;»-n in- vader who was ^vinning the land bit by bit. But in form it was resistance or rebellion against the lawful King and the eetablishetl government of the land. This twofold aspect of the struggle greatly aflected its character. The fall of Harold and liis brothers, the lack of any one else able or worthy to stand forth at the head of the nation, had left the English people without a leader. The corona- tion of William cut them off from all hope of finding a leader. It cut them off from all hope of united national action. Tlie coronation took place, as I have said, during a moment of apparent universal submission ; if all England had not acknowledged William, no part of England acknowledged any one else. The struggle which followed was a reaction after a panic ; it was the revolt of a people goaded to revolt by the oppression far less of William him- self than of William's unworthy lieutenants. In all those parts of the country which had already submitted to the new King, it was strictly rebellion, however justifiable re- bellion, against an established government. And even in those parts to which W^illiam's power had not yet reached, in those parts which he had to subdue by force after his coronation, the struggle bore a somewhat different character from that of simple national resistance to foreign invasion. AVhen the men of Exeter or Chester bade defiance to NATUKE OF THE RESISTANCE TO WILLIAM. 7 William, they were biddin*]^ defiance to the only de facto chap. xvn. Kinf'" and government in Enl«l was an usuri»ation, and llw luu Kiii^ wa** -^^^j^ the lawftd sncooKsor of his cousin Kin;^ luidsvard. lie was the •o **• herwlitan* Kinjf , a form of words which however must not f I»e preaiteolicy. Tlie orthodox way of KjK»akinp under \N illiam, at least in his milder moments, was to look on the fi^ht of Senlac as a sort of unhappy accident. The Kin"" had come to claim his Crown, and he was so unlucky as to be forced to overcome certain rebels and traitors before he could take possession of it. - Tn the ofiicial lanf»'uagc of William's reig'n, his entry is always spoken of as if it had l)een an entry as ]>eaceful as that of Charles the Second or FictionB of Georpif the First. Indeed the way in which the reign of Harold is ignored in the legal language of William's reign is an exact parallel to the way in which the Commonwealth and the rule of Cromwell arc ignored in the legal language of the reign of Charles the Second. ^ The delicate eu- phemism, so common in Domesday, " When King AVilliam came into England," is exactly of a piece with the legal fiction l>y which the year sixteen hundred and sixty is ' See vol. iii. p. 68a. ' In the somewhat suspiciouR (see Chapter xix.) foundation charter of Battle Abbey (Rynier, i. 4; Mon. Anj,'. iii. 244) William says, "Qmim in Angliam venisspni et in finibus Hasting' cum exercitu applicuissem contra hoHtes meofl qui mihi regnura Anglire injusto conabantur auferre." So in the WestminHter charter quote'! in Ellis, i. 312, and in the notes to Benoit, iii. 164 (see vol. iii. p. 684); "Angliam veniens, in ore gladii reg^um adeptus sura Anglorum, devicto Haroldo Rege cum suis compli- cibus, qui mihi regnum, providentia Dei destinatum, et beneficio concessionis domini et cognati mei gloriosi Regis Eut the legal fiction of the reign of William, like the legal fiction of the reign of Charles the Second, was in- tended to brand the acts of the alleged usurpation as null and void. And this system, fullv and consistently carried out, Practical had its effect. The legal fraud came admirably to the help ieiiu' into Kn^lnnd with any fixcil |)iir|H)8o , **" to pl«v tin* tvnint in Kn^^land. When ho 8\v«»n' hin I««Ht «n cxirunatioQ oath, he (louhtletiH niennt to keep it. William, aa I have oHen Miid, tJih lie ntuck at no crime that wouKl M.-TVV his purjK>»e, wna at no time one who rejoiccti in crime for its own gake. His soul wuh fur above the meaxiD(*«v of those ix»tty t^Tants wlio \>oii»t themwjjves that they can do miscliief. OF wanton oppression for oppres- sion's sake I do not believe that he wiis guilty at any time. Hum- And now. in the first moments of his rei^n, it was lii^ fwimlLtw policy as well jls his dis))ogition to make hit^ government as |r? "■** acceptable as he could to his new subjects of every class. His interest forbade lilm, and his temper certainly did not urge him, to do them any kind of wrong or damage which he knew how to avoid. His difficulties lay wholly in his I>o8ition. He had contrived to mount the English throne with every circumstance of formal legality. But he must liave known that he had not mounted it with the real good will of the English people. He must have known that the sort of artificial eagerness with which his accession had been welcometl was almost sure to be followed by a reaction 111 feeling against him. And the untoward accident which had turned thiwiirturb- the-UiHh ninhition, ntt;ick(Hl nnd huImIiuhI a ]hn>))Io that hnti novcr wn»n^\l him. And lliat kIh Ihkuiiu' i\m own np|in»|>rinto punishment hy drivinj*' him into sins of yet divjHT live. 0«»> fc*" And yet the beg^inninj^ of William were ; ;^ ' ' WUliMn; ^^ befjinninps of n foreign eonqueror could be. If we with Ummo «>in|iarc William with ('nut, the contrast hetwwn the firet ofCnai. days of i»ach is as favourahle to William as the contnust bctwet»n their last days is favourable to Cnut. The Danish concpieror be^n his reij^n with banishments and executions, some of which cxwutions seem to have taken the form of simple murders.' But, after the submission of licrkhamj»- stead, William docs not seem to have shed a drop of English blood. Even before the submission, he does not seem to liave been g'uilty of any slauf^hter except in what in his eyes would be held to be the lawful operations of war. '^ It. is certain that the cstiiblishmcnt of his power was not markeOHltlOIl. extreme theories in opposite directions which have been maintained by the two most eloquent and pojnilar writers on the subject. It is utterly unjust to look upon William Its true as a mere successful adventurer, a mere chief of a hostile ),'j'^ ^.^^^^[ army encamped in a conquered country. It is utterly 'l".^'!*^ unjust to speak of his claim of legal right and his show a mere o 1 ^ , A At • ^ triuinpli 01 legal government as mere pretences to cover the violence of force of a successful brik at anoUier pirturo, wo iiuiy l>e KhI (t» think timt all ri^ht and law were tmnipknl under foot, and that the Th«olil rule of William wan a ndc of nimple hrij^nida*^. NoitluT ,^j,^jjj,jj^ of these picturen represents the real truth <•! tlie case. ^'' Tlie lawH o( Knifland were not formallv <»r svsti^maticallv ihcir Aiiini- al»olisheil ; the rights of Knirlishmen were not formally ciumgvd. ^r »*}*stomatically disrepnrdrd. What l']n^lishmcn KulFcri'd frL>m was mainly that irregular, often undesigned, op- pression which must take plaec when the laws of a con- quertnl jKX^plc are administered hy their eoiujuerors. Another |>oint which has been the subject of much exag- •^•ration is the transfer of lands and offices from English- men to Normans and other foreigners. This has sometimes been spoken of as if William had systematically divided the lands of England among his followers, as Guthrum and Ilalfdene had divided the lands of East-Anglia and Northumberland.' Or rather it is spoken of as if the lands of England had been left open to a general scramble, in which every man in the invading army took whatever his right hand could seize upon.^ It is perfectly true that, in the course of William's reign, all the greatest estates and all the highest offices in England were trans- ferred from EnMish to foreig-n owners. The transfer of land was certainly not so great as has often been fancied. The notion that every Englishman was turned out of hearth and home is a mere dream. The actual occupants of the soil remained very generally undisturbed. Still the transfer of land was very great, great enough to ' See vol. i. p. 50. The words in the Chronicles (876) are, " py geare Halfdene NorShanhpnbra land gedadde : )>i£t bie 8y|)|^an ergende and heora tilgende waeron ; " and in 880, " her for se here of Cyrenceawtre on EaBtengle, and gesajt Jnet land, and hit gedalde." ' Take for instance the passage where Thierry (i. 269) begins to tell how "rimmense produit de cette spoliation universelle fut la solde des aventuriera de toua pays qui s'^taient enr6lds sous la bannifere du due de Normandie." CHANGES UNDER WILLIAM. 15 amount to the establishment in the hind of a territorial chap. x^-n. aristocracy of foreig-n birth. And this transfer may un- doubtedly be said to have been done systematically. 15ut it was not done at a blow ; it was done warily, gradually, and seemingly under the cover of legal form. There was no one moment of general confiscation or general plunder. In fact I have no doubt that William, at the time of Gooddia- .. - ^ 1 • position of his coronation, was thoroughly disposed to rule his new wiiuam Kintrdom as well as he had niled his paternal Duchy. '^i.,^!'''VV°^" t^ i •' oi his Loro- I have no doubt that he wished to do all that might be to nation, identify himself and his dynasty with the land which he claimed to be his by lawful right. We shall find that, in order better to discharge the duties of an English King, he himself strove to learn the English language, and that his English-bom son was brought up as an English iEtheling. But all these good intentions were thwarted by the in- His in- herent vice of his position. He could not maintain thwarted himself without the help of his Norman followers, and ^y !"^ ^ position. the presence of his Norman followers in England made it hopeless for him to try to reign in England as an English King. The example of Cnut, which so instinctively Misleading • • • innu^ncc presents itself to our minds, could not fail to present itself t,f the ex- to the mind of William himself.^ No example could be ^"^^j*^ °*^ more brilliant or more attractive. One foreign con- queror had already reigned in England as an English King, and had left behind him a name which lived in the memories of Englishmen side by side with the names of the noblest of their native princes. But the example was one that was altogether delusive. The position of William Differences was wholly diderent from the position of Cnut. Tlie dif- the^^osi- ference was both personal and national. Cnut must have J:^"" "^ , * Cnut and been really more at home in England than he was in tliat of Denmark. England was the prize of his first youthful warfare ; the Crown of England was the first of the many * See vol. ii. p. 299; iii. ]». 549. 16 THK KIIWT DAYS UK WILLIAMS liKKJN. our. ini. crtiwns which wm* pithcntl on hin bn>w, ' luul !u» was the •on of a jiriniv to wIkhii Kn^^-linhini'M had i^ivcii at K>ajt national dillerenees were still stronj^T. The Danes were oIUm the j>uj>ils and proselytes of the Kn^lish. They were a ^^ ^J^ kiudretl race, speaking a kindred ton^'-ue. They could xnmun in claim HO superiority over the English except the sujwriority of military success. And even in warlarc I lie arms and tactics of the two nations were much the same. Whenever Danes and Englishmen had met in open battle, there liad been no marked or lasting suix'riority on cither side, and the final victor^' of Cnut had not been owing to any hick of prowess on the part of his enemy. In every other respect, the English, with their purer faith and higher civiliziition, stood ready to be the masters of those who bad overcome them in mere warfare. With William's IvJor- mans the case was wholly ditferent. To decide whetlier the Normans or the English of that age had made the more real advances in civilization would require tliut we should first define in what real civilization consists. A fair comparison of the two nations might perhaps lead us to say that each had points of real superiority over the other. But at all events there were the widest differences between them. Their language, their habits, their mode of warfare, their social and political feelings, were widely different. Tlie native Normans, once the kinsmen of Danes ' See vol. i. j>. 404. CNUT AND WILLIAM COMPARED. 17 and Enq-lishmcn, had cxust aside all outward siorns of their <^"ap. xmi. kindred, and it must not be forg-otten that a lar^^ part of William's followers were not native Normans, but adven- turers gathered from every part of Gaul.* Tlie success of William's invasion was a distinct triumph of one lanj^uag-e, of one mode of warfare, of one social and political system, over another lang-uag-e, another mode of warfare, another social and political system. Under these circumstances it could not be that Normans and Eno^lishmen should blend toj'ether under William as Danes and Eniiflishmen had blended together under Cnut. Above all, it could not be that the Norman should, like the Dane, acce|)t the conquered Englishman as his intellectual master. The result was Cnut's rule that, while the rule of Cnut could daily become less Danish „ra«»lioy of Willinm hiinM'lf. WImu'vit ilwrit in i\\v land. Kn^li«»hmen, Normans, or any otluT, William woh their roaiitor and mouldctl thom to Iuh will. A lot^M dis- ceminp conqutTur mi^lit have made Himple havoc of all tiiat \\o fi»uiul o^tahliHlunl in the land which he conciucred. A man of moaner mould mi;,''lit have indulged in mere I>altry and wanton tyranny. Hut William neither chanpcd one whit nor tyranni/.ed one whit beyond what his }K>8ition and his purjioees demanded. 11 r knew how to use Nor- mans a^inst Engli.vihmen, but he knew also how to use Kni^flishmen ao^inst Norman.s, and he knew how to make the whole land his own and every man in it his subject. Tlie unity His jmsition as Coiujueror, combineil with that craft of the V ruler in which none could rival him, enableil him to ])ut XI the final seal to the work of Ec^berht, of P^adward, antl of LvWiiliam. iDthelstan, to make En«^land one united Kingdom, which, since his days, no man has ever dreamed of dividing. § 2. WiHianis jirst Bays in England. December 1066 — March 1067. Effecta of Tlie violence of William's followers had clianged the ■ ' • ' ■ ult r.,- day of his coronation from a day of formal, and perhaps more than formal,^ joy into a day of sorrow and wrath. The wrong done by the foreign soldiers who guarded the W^est Minster was not forgotten,^ though there seems to have been no open outbreak at the time. But it is a significant fact that, either at once upon his coronation or within a very short time after, William found it con- venient to leave London — and we may suj)pose West- ' See vol. iii. p. 550. ' See above, p. 10. WILLIAM AT BARKING. 19 minstor also — and to withdraw to Barkin<>' in Essex. <^'ap. xni. This was a point from which he couUl easily appear in witiuiraws London at any moment, thoung the of an English King were already changed into murmurs of "** "* distrust. The English people — William doubtless already knew it — were only biding their time. Still the formal investiture of William with the royal Effects of the coro- ofHce was already beginning to do its work upon men's niition ; minds. Men who had waited to see what might be the course or the destiny of the mere invader, the mere ' The arrangement of William of Poitiers who, at this point is our chief authority, is always very confused. In this case he begins with the passage which I have already quoted (see above, p. 13), describing the King's con- duct in London and his general designs and scheme of government, in- cluding umch which could hardly have been done in a day. Presently we read (147), " Egressus e Lundonifi, dies aliquot in propinquo loco morabatur Bercingis," and the reason is added, "dum firmamentaquaidam in urbecontra mobilitatem ingentis ac feri populi perficerentur. [On this beginning of Tower-building, see vol. iii. p. 553.] Vidit enim in primis necessarium magnopere Lundonienses coiirceri." With tliis as his motive, William would not stay very long in London or at Westminster. But how nmch of the various acts and designs which William of Poitiers seems vaguely to put between the coronation and the homage at Barking really belongs to William's first stay in London, how much to the stay at Barking, how much to the progress which followed, must be largely matter for con- jecture. One grant of lands recorded in Domesday (ii. 59) would seem to l)elotig to the very first days of William's reign. Lands in Essex which had belonged to a certain Lcofsuna appear as the property of Geoffrey of Mandeville, with the comment "Hoc manerium dcilit Ke.x G. .»n tlio Kinij ohoM'n. oskcs8C<1 Wiliuuu'« on hin mercy.* lie recviveii them ^nuMounly ; lu- iw- rx>^|.:j.n i^'pttHl their oaths of homo^ ; he ^-nuitiMl them their <• ti, i„w |,|,j^|jj niVegh, and held them in liiL^h honour.' At the saline time^ according to inveterate practice, ho rc<|uirtHl honta^'S f(»r their goml faith, :ind the royal favour was not won, })erhap8 the royal j)re8<»nee was not entered, without a fj^iXr^ This account of the surrender and rcg-rant of the lands of Englishmen who submitted to William is worthy of special attention. If it stood by itself, it might be taken as simply meaning; that commendation of the man and his land to the new lord which is implied in the act ul' homage. And, considering the circumstances under which that new lord had made his entry, it may well have been thought desirable to have every such act confirmed as solemnly as might be under the King's writ and seal. But when we take in the other evidence of different kinds, we shall perhaps be inclined to see in these almost casual words of the Norman panegyrist a deeper import even than this. The great confiscation of lands which is such a marked characteristic of William's reign was undoubtedly gradual. But when did it begin ? There is, I think, every reason to believe that it began in the very first .'^urTvn^^l. " Rex eorum sacramenta, ut postulaverunt, libens accepit, libe- raliter eis donavit gratiam suam, reddidit eis cuncta quae possederant, habebat eos magno honore." 1» ' Chron. Petrib. 1066. "And menn guidon liim gyld and gislas sealdon." Thifl comes directly after the coronation, and no doubt at least takes in those who submitted at Barking. CONFISCATIONS OP LAND. 23 days of William's En^^lish rei^n. He had to reward his chap. xvii. foreifj-n followers, and, in conformity with liis whole elia- ,^*'*^\'" I""'^" " ' ' ^ bahlu early racter and position, he had to reward them in some way bet^niming. which niipi-ht be, formally at least, different from simple plunder and brigiindaf»:e. His system of leg-al fictions easily Effect of supplied him with the means. He, King* William, the tioim. lawful successor of his kinsman King Eadward, had been for a while hindered from receiving his Crown and exer- cising* his royal authority. He had even been met, when he came to take possession of his Kingdom, not with the welcome which was his due, but with an obstinate resist- ance in arms, ^lany Englishmen had fought against him ; no Englishman, except an exile or two in his own train, had fought for him. Here was active treason in a large part of the nation, and at least passive complicity with treason in the remainder. The rights of the case, according to All the 1 I r William's reading of the Law, were plain. According to England its strict letter the lands of all such undutiful sulyects ^^^^^^ited. were forfeited. William would have been justified in re- storing Ralph of Norfolk ^ to his confiscated lands, and in seizing all the rest of the soil of England — save of course the lands of ecclesiastical corporations — for himself. But mercy and policy alike forbade such a course. Some Reasons favour was due to those who had not actually drawn fiJ^i'iy^^arn'- the sword against the lawful heir : some perhaps was ^"7 °"*^ even due to those survivors of the fight on Senlac or trine. the skirmish at Southwark who had atoned for their fault by a speedy submission. And besides this, the Its impos- lands of most of those who had fought against him lay f^\j'J,,e at his mercy, while the lands of many of those who now P^^'t /»^ came in to give their submission could not be reached without another campaign. William could at once seize on the lands of any Kentish or South-Saxon Tliegn or cliurl who had either died beneath the Standard or had • See vol. iii. p. 753. ti TIIK FIRST DAYS OP WIT.LIAIl's KKIQN. r. irti. lived to deal u l»Iow in thr J/«;//i>*.»r.' Hut the mon* port of tlio luiidn of Kailwine anil MorkcT»» inul Wultln'of and Co|»nij»t» lav in rojfituiH to wliicli NVilliiiin'H nrm luwl not yet rearlunl, and to wliich, if In* inBi8t4»htor of the former owner was constrained to y;'i\'c herself and her lands to a foreij'-n husband. In some cases Enj^lishmen of hi<^h rank contrived to win William's personal favour, and to keej) their lands and even their offices. A crowd of smaller Thegns and of well-to-do churls seem to have been left undisturbed. Either they had not been present in the battle, or they were looked on as victims whom William could afford to spare, or else they won his favour by timely submission or redeemed their lands by a pay- ment to the new King*. In some cases we distinctly C;iRe3 of read of men having- their lands granted back to them, ^^^^ ^^ or of their buying them of King William for money. Jt-*>"P^i«n- And yet we shall see that this process did not always secure them against the necessity of having in the phrase to "seek a lord" as a defender against illegal spoliation.^ But this last mentioned expression, of men buying their lands of the King, is most important, and is of much wider import than might seem at first sight. One of our national Chroniclers distinctly extends the phrase to all who did homage to William at or soon after his coronation. - And an entry in Domesday, which seems never to have received the attention which it deserves, distinctly speaks of a time when the English as a body redeemed their lands. -^ No General re- date is assigned in the Survey to this event; but the of lands two statements, taken tofifcther, can leave hardly any ^7 ^l^*^, ' t» 5 J J English. doubt that both refer to the same act, and that the general ' On all these casea see Appendix B. ' C'hron. Petrib. io66. "And menn guidon him gyld and gislas .sealdon, and stfSiian heora hind Ixthtan." ' This most important entry (Domesday, ii. 360) is quite incidental. Of some of the lands of Saint E:idmund.sbury we reaHHihle to recover the namcK of the Commissioners ^^IJ^j^ whom Willinm cmploycjuHdem liheralitatis dono accepcrant Angli com- plures quod a parentibus vel prioribus domini.s non acccperunt." * On all thcsu j)oiiitH .see Ai)pcndix A and B. W THE FIRST DAYS OF WII.MAMS UKION. c«Ar.zm. Northern hlnrU hiui tmiiul that then* was no olmnrc of William U'injf mtiHtictl with halfn Kin^tloin ; thov knew by thiff time that he liad made u]) hin mind to Ih* master of the whole land. If they did not Kuhmit, tliey would have to tijflit ; and tliey thoujfht it winer to suhmit on favonrahle terms, nit her than to nm the risk of a Htni^^^^^le whieh mi^ht end in their utter destruetion. To William, on the other hand, it wan elearly a j^iiu to reeeive even a nominal Fuhmi&sion. It quite fell in with his whole [wlicy of words and names and le«^»l fictions to ^-rant away lands of which he had never had a moment's iwssession. It was a l>old stroke to convert, without stirrinp from London or Barking", the Earls of the Northumhrians and the Mercians into his lieutenant.s, and their lands into fiefs held by his grant. The formal submission mi<^ht possibly prove to be a real one. And, if it did not, if Northumberland had after all to be conquered by force, the submission of its Earls, Prelates, and chief Theg-ns would put altogether a ditl'erent colour on the conquest. If William had still to go forth on a Northern camj^aign, he would now be going forth to recover what was, in every legal form, his own. He would be going to chastise men who were not only rel)cls and traitors in some vag-ue constructive sense, but who were actually men faithless to their lord, men who had rebelled agtiinst the sovereign to whom they had sworn oaths and from whom they acknowledged themselves to hold all that Northern they had. With this formal submission William seems for left*un- the present to have been content. Eadwine, Morkerc, and touched for ^jjgjj. companions had indeed to give gifts and hostages to the Conqueror, but they received all their lands and honours again, and were admitted to the full favour of the new King. Eadwine indeed seems really to have won William's personal regard, and he was further flattered by the promise, sincere or insincere, of the hand of one THE NORTH LEFT UNTOUCHED. 29 of the Kind's clau<'hters.' Tlie whole of Northern Enf,'lanJ chap. xvii. was simply left as it was before ; the old rulers, the old proprietors, were uiulistiirbed ; it does not seem that a single castle was built to keep Northumberland and Northern Mercia in chei'k, or that a sino:le soldier was sent to occupy or to spy out the land. All was trusted to the loyalty of William's new made vassals. The House of Leofric, the House of the old Northumbrian Earls, mi^^ht alike seem to have lost nothin<^ by the revolution wliich had enthroned a Norman instead of a West-Saxun in Winchester and London. Thus far did the Conqueror show himself mild and William's debonair to those parts of England which had not acted ^ith openly against him and which were as yet beyond his ^^^j immediate firrasp. Towards the districts which lay at his J$^\^"\ mercy, the districts whose men had followed Harold and his brothers, he began, if not to show himself beyond measure stark, at least to show that the forfeiture of the lands of the rebels was not to remain a dead letter. To the city His charter of London lie had, perhaps before he left Westminster for Barking, already granted a charter in the English tongue, that venerable parchment which may still be seen in the city archives with the cross traced by the Con- queror's own hand.- By that charter he confirmed to the city all its rights, possessions, and customs, as freely as ' Onl. Vit. 511 A. "Guillelinus Rex . . , filiam suam se in conjugem ei [Eduino Coiniti] daturum spoponderat." ' The original is given by Riley, Lib. Cust. ii. part ii. p. 504 ; Stuhhs, Select Chartera, 79. " Willelra Kyng gret Willelm Bisceop and GosfregS I'ortirefan and ealle \>a, burhwaru binnan Londone, Frencisce and Englisce, freondlice. And ic kyfie eow pu't ic wille |jit't get beon eallra |ra>ra lai,'a weorSe J)e gyt WKran on Eadwerdea dipge kynges. And ic wille \>«t kIc cyld beo hirt fiBth.-r }Tfnuiiie jcfler his fteder dtrge. And ic nelle ge}H)lian J»a.'t senig man eow a*nig wrang beode. God eow gehealde." One or two words here look a little suspicious, but this copy, if not absolutely the original, is at any rate much older tliau the verdions given by Mr. Riley, vol. ii. part ii. pp. 346, 247. so Tiir FrRsrr n\v?? of wimiam's kekjjt. cnxr. im. thov hml Uvn helil in tlu' tlnys of his proance of tlio ro^ular nnliT of tliinf^ which he found «itnMi» ^cw subjcctij from the insolence of his foreign followers. "!"^*^J7 The strict jwlice of his rei<:^n be«i^an already ; robbers, murderers, intruders on lands not legally granted, the spoilers of the traveller and the merchant, were kept in check, seemingly without reg:ird to their rank or nation. - The leaders of the host were exhorted to gentleness and motleration ; the inferior officers and common soldiers were kept in order by stringent proclamations.^ William's military code not only forbade slaughter, plunder, and rai)e, but dealt with all breaches of chastity and temper- ance as military offences.'* Courts martial were com- • A writ of E.vlward is addreHsed to them in Cod. Dipl. iv. 214. Another Portreeve, Ulf, appears as a benefuctor to Westminster in iv. 221 (nee vol. ii. pp. 510. 568). ' Will. Pict. 147. " Latrociniifl, invasionibus, maleSciis, locum omnem intra suoh terininos dene^vit. Portus et rjiuelibet itinera negotiatoribus patere, et nullani injuriam fieri, jussit." " liivasioneH," it should be remem- bered, is a kind of technical term for illegal occupations of land. The mention of the havens suggests the doings of the royal officers, who at all times needed careful keeping in check. • lb. 146. "Suis primatibus dign^ se et gravitate prsecepit, et dili- gentia suasit a?quitatem." Part of William's sermon has been already quoted (see above, p. 13). Tlie historian then goes on; " Milites vero mediK nobilitatis atr^ue gregarios aptlssimis edictis cotircuit." The distinc- tion reminds one of that drawn by Odysseus, II. ii. 188. • Will. Pict. 147. "Tutse erant a vi mulieres quam ssepe amatores inferunt. Etiam ilia delicta quse fierent consensu impudirarum infamise WILLIAMS FIRST PROGRESS. 31 missioncKl to visit all evil doers of every kind with severe chai*. xvn. punishment, and to show no favour to the native Normans above the auxiliaries from other parts of Gaul.' All these statements of the pane<^yrist we can, with the necessary deductions, fully accept. William, we need not doubt, honestly d'\d his best to preserve peace in liis Kini^dom and discipline in his army. It was the more needful to do so while the work of leg^al spoliation was going" on. The King now set forth on a progress, the William's \ ' £> \ • \ \ 11-111 •• proj,'res8 object ot which, there can be little doubt, was to visit ami ..ccu- and take possession of the forfeited lands.- In the course of [ji^'f,".' that progress he came across no opposition ; not a road was ^*-''^'^^ . . . hinds. shut against him ; not a man met him in arms. lie was met only by suppliants, who implored and obtained his Hisallej,'ed mercy, a mercy shown specially to those of low degree. ' ^ *^"'^"^> Mothers came forth with their children to work, and nut unsuccessfully, on his pity.^ This too we need not doubt. Its real at least in the sense which the great Survey enables us to put upon it. ^lany a man once rich and j)owerful doubtless met William at some stage of his progress, and won from his mercy, perhaps under the name of alms, some fragment of his old possessions which would at least keep him from want or servile work. Now too it doubt- less was that the crowd of smaller landowners, Thegns prohibendae gratiA vetabantur. Potare militem in tabemia non multum conceHsit, quoniam ebrietas litem, lis honiicidium Bolet generare. Seditiones interdixit, c«edem, et omnem rapinani, frsenana ut populos armis, ita legibua anna." * Will. Pict. 147. " Judices qui vulgo milituin essent tinuiri constituti sunt ; simul acerbee pcens in eos qui delincjuerent decretai sunt ; neque liberius Normanni quam Britanni vel Aquitani agere pennittebantur." ' lb. 148. *• Inde progrodieiiH diversa-s partes regni aceessit, ordinando ubique utilia sOn et incolia terra;." ' lb. " Iter nullum obstniitur, occurnint pasxim obaequentos aut expli- cantea. Omnes ille clementibus oculis respuxit, clementisaimia plebcm." * lb. '• Sa'pe vultu mi.serantem animum prodidit, jusait niultotieua miaericordiam, ([uuin aupplicea con.spiceret aut egenoa, matrea animadver- terot voce et jjeatibuH precari cum liberia." tt TIIK FIH8T DAYS OF WILMAM's RFJOX. our. im. of the lowett nuik or churln of the liifjluvt, whom we ■Mikb- ^'^^ retaining their hiiuU in the southern nliin'H, eamo ■'?•'•' and iH^jfjfttl the men\v of the new Kin^, niul wt-rc hy tiMlrlMKk. his merey ileenitHl too insi^nifiennt to Ik* ilisturhrd.' And we cnn better undorKtnnd the piettire of William's ch'iiH'ney -Alm«" to the suppliant widows and orphans, wlien wr turn to nuj iXutm* entries in the ^reat JMirvey which set hrlore us tlie uq>liaa, widows of mm of all hut the hi^^hest rank j^lad to lind »ome small part of the forfeiUnl wealth of their husbands and sons thrown haek to them, perhaps burthened with some ig-nominious tenure, by the contemptuous jiity of the Cunipieror. ETHkocc We shall j)erhaj)s better understand the process which UrdU- now went on throu«i^h a larypc ]>art ol Jvn;L,nand, if we fix our eyes more minutely on the fate of some particular individuals, families, and districts about which we are able to gather an unusual amount of detailed information. Kflfcu of Such a tyj)ical region is suj)})lied to us by a district of c*tion in which we may take Berkshire as the centre, but which "" * "** also takes in parts of most of the adjoining shires. This district is one of those in which the Commissioners em- ployed on William's Survey have been most bountiful in local and personal notices, while in some parts of England they give us little beyond dry lists of names. We are also able to draw a good deal of help from the detailed history of the great monastery of the district, the house of Saint Mary of Abingdon.'^ By these means we are able to call uj) a personal image of several men of the days of Eadward, Harold, and W illiam, of some of whom we have heard already. It may be simply because our local details are specially ' See Appendix D. ' The local History of Abingdon, " Cbronicon Monasterii de Abingdon," edite'land. Their shire had formed part of Harold's own ani..u^,' the ' foniaortt at Larldom, and we have already come across more than Stnhic. one instance in which his name is directly connected with the affairs of the shire. He appears on terms of friendship with the chief men of the district and, if not as himself a benefactor to the great local Abbey, yet as one who was ready to protect its rii^hts and to forward its interests.^ Tlie local officer second in rank, the Sheriff Godric, is (Jodric the one of the chosen few whom we know by name as liavin<^ ' given their lives for England in the great battle.^ And Great it is plain that the glorious end of the local chief had of the been laro-ely shared by the men of his shire. An inci- J^f ^"'^""^ dental expression in the local history shows that for a man to have been a Thcgn of Berkshire implied, almost as a matter of course, that he had died at Senlac.-^ Long Zeal of the after AVilliara's accession, the tenants of the Abbey are AbinL.l-jn mentioned as being specially zealous in every form of-^^^^^^- revolt and resistance against the foreign government.'* It is not wonderful then if the hand of William lay heavy on both the ecclesiastical and the temporal landowners of so stout-hearted a district. The vague laments of the local history ^ are fully borne out by the detailed evidence of ' See vol. ii. p. 42 ; and cf. vol. iii. p. 68. ' See vol. iii. pp. 426, 730. ' Hi«t. Mon. Ab. ii. 3. "Quae possessiones [the estates held by the tenants of the Abbey] ab eia habitse fuerant, quoa Tahinoa dicunt, et in bello Ha«tingis occubuerant." * lb. i. 486, 493, speaking of a much later time ; " Sed et homines abbatise Abbendonensis, dam regis parti favere Willehni debuerant, animo ft consxiltu inutati, anuati, quo hostes regi.s ipsius consi.sture acceperant, gre.Msani contendurunt." The WTitcr'.s position hIiouUI be noticed ; he ad- mires Harold and Godric, but he hohU that submission was due to King William. * lb. '* NulliuH sacrorum liminum jJro.spectCis revcrentin, nulla fratruin desolatfiFum compn.ssio. Extra [)er villas posthabito ciijunlibct resptctu, paHflim impensa vastatio." VOL. IV. U ;i THT. FiusT nA^s or wilijams hkkj.n. oiAr. XVII. Uu* Survoy. TluTr .n. not many purlw of Kn^laiid in which tho ixjufiM^tion m. ms to hnvo Ixvn more Hwwpinj^ ; tlwoo«i> noDe i)orhnpd of the hhin^s whiih fornicil Williain'H iirst Bwki^iivi. 00Dque«i, cxei*}>t the two whero he finit set foot| iinil whcro his hand foil henvictft of nil, the olil KontiKli mul South- BdUmof Saxon lands.* There, n» wtll as in some other nhires Vi^rViyf whieh were conquered later, not u siiij^^le Kn^lishman SuaMc. yg^^ allowtxl to kw\) his lands on their old tenure, and only two Enj^lish tenants-in-ehief appear in the Survey. The confiscation in Berkshire was not so extensive as in these extreme cases, hut nnion*^ the more ty ]>ieal shires, where Enj^iplish tenancy-in-cliief was not wholly furhidden, there are few where the number of Englishmen who retained their estates seems to have been smaller. Still, here as elsewhere, we find some instances of Englishmen who contrived to make their peace with the Conqueror, and we find the case of one man of hi«^h rank who seems to have risen to a special place in his favour. Lands of The lands held l»y Harold and his family in Berkshire hit tamily. Were iiot vcry extensive ; still Harold himselt, his mother Gytha, his sister Eadgyth, his V)rothers Tostig, Gyrth, and perhaps Leofwiue, are all found as land-owners in the shire.2 The lands of the Lady of course remained untouched till her death ; those of Tostig — of no great extent'* — no doubt fell in to the Crown at his outlawry in the days of Eadward. The estates of the fallen King and his loyal brothers were of course, in William's reading ' On the confiscations in Kent and Surrey, see Appendix E. ' The lands of Harold in Berkshire ^^^ll be found in Domesday, 57 h, 58,59 b, 60, 62 b, 63 6. In 58, 59, and 60 we find the names of his tenants and grantees, the last one perliaps being Eadncjth the Staller. Gytha and G}Tth occur together in 59 b, and Gyrth alone in 61. Tostig in 60. There is a Leofwine in 60 //, but he is not distinguinhed as " Comes." The estates of the Lady appear in 56 b, 57, 5H, 60, 63 b, wiiich last entry I shall have to mention again. ' Tostip's estate was reckoned at fourteen hides T. R. E., but at seven only at the time of the Survey. GREAT CONFISCATIONS IN HKRKSIIIKE. 35 of the Law, forfeited by the treas^m of tlicir owners, and chap. xvn. they were no doubt at onee seized into tlie Kin«^'s hands. The greater part of them remained in the Kin<;-'ti liands ciii»rty at the time of the Survey, but some portions had been Kinj^'a g-ranted out.' But a more speeial interest, in a view "^*^- of this particular district, is awakened by the fate of the Sheriff Godric and his family. His name is so I^-iiula of common that it is not always easy to distinguish his lands from those of less famous Godrics, but it is plain that his estates were large, both in his own shire and beyond its bounds, and that they were held by various tenures. Some of his lordships were hekl of the Crown, one at least by a grant from Eadward himself;^ others, as we have seen, were held of the Church of Abingdon, a happy accident to which we owe our l^etter knowledge of the man and his deeds. But he also held other lands by virtue of his office as Sheriff, an office which he seems also to have filled in Buckinghamshire as well as in Berkshire. And with regard to these various possessions, Personal the Survey has happily preserved a number of incidental Oodric. details, which throw light on the manners of the time, and which, like all details of the kind, help us better to understand the men and the age with which we are dealing. Two hides of land in Buckinghamshire were held in absolute property by a maiden whose English name appears in so coriiij)t a form that it can only be guessed at. But besides this, she occupied half a hide of royal domain, which was granted to her by Godric the Sheriff for the term of his Sherilldom, as her fee for teaching his daughter the special art of Englishwomen of those days, ' The greater estates of Harold in 57/^ and 58 are all in the King's liaiida ; some of the holders of .smaller portion.s will be mentioned pre- sently. ^ On the landx of Godric and ;dl |»ointn connected with tlieni, .nee Appendix F. n 2 36 THK FIRST DAYS OF WII.MAM S RKION. oijLr. xTii the art of cinhn^itK'ry in jr^'^J* Thij* jpll would, cvon in peaceful tinu^n, Imve rrvcrti'*! to the Crown nt the death of Godrio, but tho frtH«ht)l(l of the Knjjlihhwonian had c^jually imssed awny In'fore tlje time of the Survey.' In another entry wo find mention of a part of the royal domain in Hfrkshin* whith wiu* used for the feetlinj^ of the SherifT'g horses."' How far c^ither of these applications of the royal j)roperty was strielly le;;»iil, it mi^ht be hard to my ; at any rate they illustnite the liberties which ofTicers of every rank were in the habit of taking', whether by received custom or not, with the property of their masters. Ck.iTKv« Other entries however 8tH?m distinctly to char^ Godric witli J^\,f wronp^ful occupation of portions of the King's land.^ The «'»"ng*yJ lands of Godric himself were confiscatiHl, and were {^ranted occupatioa. ^ I^Aitdji of out to a follower of AVilliam named Henry of Ferrers, irrmni^ to '^^^ man, whose descendants held the Karldoms of Derby Henry of jm^ Nottingham, was the son of Walkelin of Ferrers, one reXTcra. I'll of the disturbers of the peace of Normandy in the days of William's childhood."' He had fought at Senlac,^ and was rewarded with high ofiices.and vast possessions in various parts of England, l^ut be could also stoop to despoil those whom the Conqueror himself bad spared. One obscure entry in tjjc Survey illustrates the account given l)y the panegyrist of William's clemency to sup- pliant wives and mothers. A single bide of land seems ' Domeedaj, 149. "De his tenuit Aluuid puella Ti. hklas quaa potuit dare et Yendere cui voluit, et de duininicil tirmu Regis E. liabuit ipsa dimidiam hidam, quara Godricus Vicecomes ei concessit quamdiu Vice- comes esset, ut iUa doceret fiiiam ejus aurifrisium operari." Wliat does ** Aluuid " stand for ? EaUiswith, Ealdgyth, or what ? Of the English enihroiderj' I shall have to speak again. ' Her land was held by a tenant of Roljert of Oily, of whom more anon. * Domesday, 57 h. "Henricus de Fereres tenet de hoc manerio XIJII. acfM teme quae fuerunt in fimm Regis T. R. E., sicut scira dicit. Dicuiit autem qurnl Godo." * See Appendix F. * Will. Gem. vii. 2; Ord. Vjt. 522 D. • Roman de Rou, 13498, GODRIC AND HIS FAMILY. 37 to have been left to the widow of the fallen SherifT, to he chap. xvn. held by the desradinff tenure of feedinj^r the Kin<^'8 doi^s. Jl'^\*'"( Even of this she was in the end defrauded ; even this widow, small frairnient of former wealth came into the hands of the rapacious stranger.^ The process of confiscation is well worth studying. Aiuilocry Almost every detail illustrates the way in which, in wiirunu's AVilliam's policy, wron''s name to others. Thus we find that the Sherilf Froger, ' Domesday, 57 h. " Henricus tenet ibi i. hidara, qute fuerat in fimiA Regis. Godricu.s tenuit. Aluricus de T.icehAm dlcit se vidis.se brevein Kegig quod earn dederit feminie Godrici in dono, eo quod uutriebat canea suos. Sed nemo cut in hundreds qui brevem viderit pni'ter Aliiricum." ' " AnteceMor" is the recjular technical term in Domesday, of which "ancestor," though now u.sed only in thr .senHC of" forefather," is simply a contraction. See Appendix A., and tiie Epi.stleHof Lunfranc, i. ,p, ed. (HIch It TUB FIR8T DATS OP WIKLIAM's RRION. OBAT. trn. wemini>'ly tJu* Normnn gucr(*«»or of CioH8 of the lamls hohl of tho Churi'h ])y (hnlrio and Thurkill/'* those wronj»s l>olonp ohiofly in tho times of disturbanco and op- pression somewhat hitor, and not to tho aots of AVilliain's first progress. Notfly In Kxikinj'^ over tho namos of smalUT ownoi*s in I^-rk- exUnction 8^*^, we are stniok, as I have already said, by the almost ofibe universal extent of the confiseation. Tho number of land- •nuuler Eniflish owners of tho middle olass, answering" to our smaller gentry ill Berk- ^^d rioher yeomanry, must in KiuL,'- Eadward's days have ^^'^ V>een verj' lar^^o. Lordship aftor lordship had been held by three brothers, by two or by three Thcg-ns, by one or two or three freemen/ the heritag^e of many such being* swept in * The unjust doings of Froger appear in Domesday, 57, 58. The Abingdon historian (i. 486, 494) speaks of him as a special enemy to the Ablnjy, and rejoices over hiw disgrace and loss of office, which is not recorded in Domesday, but which we might have guessed from his not ap- pearing there as a landowner. " Itaque tempuris illius rcrum abbatiic amissarum vel insinuatio vel computatio, non facile dictu. Quarum executioni Frogerus tunc Berchesiie >'icecomes pnt'cipuus efferebatur, sed ejiLSilem illo potentis hominis immoderatum super homines depressos pro- gressum moderantis universa postea Dei vindicta coercuit, ut et jus quo efferebtitur tNTannicum regi/l sibi justiii/l auftrretur, et in despectum omnium inopiA et stoliditate quoaecial provision made to meet any case ofibrfeiture ; "Quidquid tamen offensionis posseasoribu.s forte accideret, ecclesia inde jacturam nullara incur- reret.** Then follows, " It;tque ipso cum praedicto viro pariter in bello occiso, idem Henricus de Ferrariis banc \'illam cum alterA sua? ditioni adjecit." * In pp. 62 h, 63, we find " duo taini tenuerunt in paragio," *' tres liberi homines tenuenmt de rege Edwardo," " tres fratres tenuerunt de rege E. in alodio," " tres taini tenuenmt in alodjo de rege E." There are other entries of the same kind. NORMANS SETTLED IN BERKSHIRE. 39 a mass into the hands of some insatiable stranger. Among chap. xvii. those to whose crasp the lands and homes of Enijlishmen ^ "l'",*"^ were thus handed over we come across many names familiar Berkshire, to us in our Norman histor}', to some of whom we should not grudge any amount of wealth and honour in their own land. The men whose exploits we could follow with delight bt'hnv the steep of Arques or among the burning streets of Mortemer now meet us again in a less pleasing form as intruders in the shire which gave birth to yElfred. William of Eu,^ Ralph of Toesny^^and Ralph of Mortemer^ now had their reward in the spoils of the conquered land. With them we find the aged Walter Gifiard, who had re- fused to bear the standard at Senlac,'* and Toustain the son of Rolf, in whose hands the sacred banner had been so truly guarded.^ Other lands fell to the lot of kinsmen of the Conqueror himself, to his brother Robert of Mortain^ and to his cousin Richard of Evreux."^ Here we see the lands which Eudo of Rye, Eudo of Colchester, the worthy son of the faithful Hubert, received as the reward of his own and his father's loyalty.** Here we light on the names of ^liles Crispin, of the house of the defenders of Tillieres,^ and of Hugh of Avranches, more famous in another quarter of England as the first Count Palatine of Chester.^'^ The Lands foreign allies and mercenaries of the host are represented piemisii bvthe names of Gilbert of Ghent ^^ and Anuilf of Hosdin.^^ followers of AN illiam. * See Domesday, 6i, and for his fate Ord. Vit. 704 C. He was the Bon of Count Kobort. See vol. iii. p. 118. ' See Domesday, 62 6, Vol. iii. pp. 287, 465. ' lb. 62 b. * lb. 60. Vol. iii. pp. 129, 153, 465. * lb. 63. Vol. iii. p. 465. * Rr>bert of Mortain (^)o), wonderful to say, held only one lordship in Berkshire, and that was held of him by the Abbey of Preaux, the foundation of Humfrey de Vetulis. See Neu.stria Pia, p. 520. '' See Domesday, 60. Vol. ii. p. 2io. " lb. 6r b. Vt)l, ii. p. 249. * lb. 61 b. VoL ii. p. -204. '" lb. 60. Vol. ii. pp. 207, 291. •' lb. 67. Vol. iii. p. 312. " lb. 62 /'. Vol. iii. p. 714, whore T ought not to have confounded Arnulf of ilwdin with his much Biuallcr namesake of Ardres. 40 THE PinST DAYS OF WILLIAMS RKION. iTii. Xt»r \va*i the Nornuin ("huri'h likely to bo lor^Miini in the ^i^ to *1>^*'»'''^" ^^f ^1*** plumlor. An Kn^linhmnn nnmtHl Kudwanl >> rman aiui two nanii'lcsH allodial lioldorH witi* disiHissrssiMl in «...i favour of the \;rvi\i lioum? of Saint lVtlx*y whirli Ht)on hopin to riw* on J**** J** Kn^lish fj-n^untl i\» a monumont of Kng-lish overthrow Al>b*\. cnme in for the Hi>oilK alike of the 8])iritnnlty and of tho t<'m|»onilty of En;»'land. It ini«;ht in AVilliam's view 1k» fittinjj thot n lonl>hi|> whieh had passed from :i nameless Tlie^i to I'^iirl Harold Bhould pass from him to Saint Martin of the Place of Battle;* but we may ask, even on AVilliam's own prineijiles, why a monk from MarmoutierH should enjoy the spoils of a church and eij^ht hides of land belli in Kin^** Kadwanrs days by the Enj^'-lish Abbess Leofj^ifu.'* And amonfi^ ffj^ ^o ecclesiastical botlies wo also see g^fts to at least two churchmen in their personal ro«k?Mion8 character. One is no less a person than Geofl'rey of Groffrey of Mowbrav, the famous Bishop of Coutances, he who had Cuuunccs. exhorted the Norman host on the nig-ht before the battle, and had asked their assent to the crowning" of their Duke within the walls of the West Minster.'* His lands and lonl>hips reached into well nigh every corner of England, and probably among their firstfruits was a single Berkshire manor, the spoil of an Englishman whose name of Oda ' Donicsday, 59 6. ** Ahbas de Supertlivft tenet de Rege Peise. Duo alodiarii tenuerunt et |)otuerunt ire quo voluerunt. . . . Ipse Abbas tenet li. hidaa in Cot*erige. Eduuardu.s tenuit de Rcge E." * lb. 59 6. " Abbafl de Labatailge tenet de Rege Bristoldestone. HcralduH comes tenuit tunc pre X. Iiidis; quidam Tainus qui ante eum tenuit geldabat jiro xv. hidJH, niodo pro niliilo." ' lb. 60. "IpKe Abbas tenet in Keddinges ecclesiam cum viii. hidis ibi pertinentibufl ; Leveva abbatiHsa tenuit." This would Beem to be Leofgifu Abbess of Shaftesbury, of whom we hear in the Exon Domesday, 1 76, where we read of Combe in Somersetshire, "Abbatis.-a [Sancti Edwardi] habet i. mansionem qua* vocatur Comba, quam tenuit Leveva abbatissa." See Ellin, ii. 160. * See vol. iii. pp. 451, 559. LANDS GRANTED TO CHURCHMEN. 41 perhaps points to his being", like Thurkill of Kingston, of coap. xvii. the stock of the Dunes. ^ Keg-ennhuld too, the Norman Rc-inbald, , , . 1 • I • Chancellor Chancellor ot Lachvaru, was not only coutirmed in nis „f Ead- former huUlinir, hut received also the estate of a free ^"""^ ' Enirlishwoman named ^Elfy-ifu.-^ And with these we find Theo«l.»ric P ,,-,• ,111 theGold- the name of a man of unrecorded nationality, who doubtless Bmith. owed the favour of ^Villiam to his skill in an art specially adapted to enhance the splendour of a Kinj^'s court, an art for which both natives and sojourners in Enutth name in various parts of England, and it is not likely that they all belong to the name person. it THI PraBT DATS OP William's krion. MTii WillizuiiV puntees, grotxi niul umail, Ht<'|»iuHl each mnn into the place of ono or more Kn^lishnu'ii who bocaim* hin Ir^al amctMtora, A« in the cane of tho confiHCfltotl himlH of Gotlric and Tluirkill, cIiHputo8 Bonictimcm aroso an to (he exact extent of the anccntorn j>ro|HTty, and conHcliation eK)keed to two other Eng-lishmen, and he was even bold enou^-h to lay claim to property which was held by the powerful Robert of Oily.' Still more to be noticed, as illustrating- the boasted cle- English- mency of William, are the cases in which a string of receive«l women appear as keeping, under the title of alms from J^'^JJ" °^'" King William, the lands which they had held in full "alma." j)roperty under King Eadward.* Other entries let us into the fact that men who retained Cases of ... . commend- their land were sometimes driven to commend themselves, ation. to seek a lord, in order to win the protection of some powerful man.^ They thus sank, as far at least as those particular lands were concerned, from the rank of tenants- in-chief to the rank of mesne tenants. These commen- dations would doubtless not take place during the first stage of William's confiscations and renewed grants. Men * Domesday, 63 6. " Alwardus aurifaber tenet de Rege Sotesbroc ; pater ejus tenuit de reginil Eddid." This is Shottesbrook, famous for its graceful collegiate church of the fourteenth century. ' lb. " Alai de Ferendone tenet Lierecote de dono Regis W. ; Heraldua tenuit Isdem Alsi tenet de Rege dimidiam hidiuu quam Aluric quitlam liber homo tenuit T. R. E." ' Tlie lioldings of Cola come in p.age 63 h; but in 62 we read of two mills at Ardington, belonging to Robert of Oily, "Cola Anglicus calumniatur unum ex his niolinis, sed Aluuin ct Goduinus et Aluricus testificantur quod semper jacuit in Ardinttme." IJut it should be noticed that the antcccsi^or of Robert in this property was the same as one of the antecessors of Cola. * Domesday, 63 6. " Ibi haliet /Eldeva libera femina i. hidara do Rege in fclemosina, quam eadem tenuit T. R. E. et quo vellet ire potuisset." The same entry follows of " Eddid quzdam femina," and ** Eldit quredam femina," * See Appendix R. 44 Tin: nusT days op wiujams rkion. our. xrn. wouM U'jjin to fiml thoin nciHlful wlu-n opprnwion on the pttrt of the HtniiijjorH and ilistxiiittut on the part of the nativiv* \\iu\ U^pm to U\\io the nhajH' of ojkmi violence on In^th niih'**. Then dituhtlesH it wiw tluit ii Djunelestf En^lislmmn, who, in Kinj^ lunlwanra of the ditx'eso, the L<»tharin^ian Hermann. After Iler- ThortHl to main's (lays his son Thored, wliose name witnesses to the 1Wh1j«>|. l>nnish descent of the familv, renewed the commendation to Hermann's Norman successor Osmund J Such a case doubtless did not stand alone; indeed wc find one remarkable instance expressly recorded in the case of a Fno^l man of much hij^her rank. Azor, the sewer or dap'ifer li. n '.f * ^^ ^^"8" Kadward, held, among* various estates in various A? r to places, one hide of land at Ardin":t/)n. He met AVilliam i: rtof * ; *= , u.y. at Windsor, and received the restoration of his land, con firm eil by the royal writ. Yet at the time of the Survey Azof had been driven to hold this same land, no lon^T as a tenant-in-chief of the Crown, but as a tenant of Robert of Oily.- Here was a case of forced com- mendation without any claim of legal right. Robert had no writ of King AVilliani to show. Simply by the right of the stronger, he had at once defrauded the King of * Domesday, 58. " Isdem Episcopus tenet de Rege i. hidam et diini- diam, et Tori de eo. Pater Turi tt,'iniit T. R. E. et potuit ire quo voluit, Bed iiro 9x16, dejentiionc He comuiwit Heruianno Epihcopo, ct Tori Osmundo Episcopo similiter." ' lb. 62. " Iwiera Robertufi tenet unam liidara quam Azor dinpensator R. E. tenuit, et cum ca ire potuit quo voluit llanc terram tenet isdem Azor de Roberto, sed homines de hundredil testificantur eum de Rege debere tenere, quam Rex W. apud Windcsores ei reddidit ^t brevem 8uum inde ei dedit. Robertus vero tenet injuHte. Nemo enim eorum vidit brevem Kegia vel ex parte ejus hominem qui eum inde saiHiaset." We do not often get the historj- of a piece of land in such ftiU and clear detail. WIGOD OF WALLING FORD. 45 his rif^hts as Azof's immediate lord, and had further chxp. xvri. wTong-ed Azor himself hy reducing" him to a lower rank in the territorial hierarchy.' This mention of Robert of Oily leads us at once to the C&se of Wlj^od of most remarkable instance in this district of an Eng^lish- W;iiiiu^r- man of rank retainini;- his lands under William. Besides ""^ * Godric and Thurkill and the members of the house ot Godwine, there are not many Eng-lish names in the Berk- shire Survey to which we can attaeh a [)ersonal idea. The two Stallers, Bondig" and Eadnoth, both held lands in the shire. One certainly, the other possibly," passed into AVilliam's service, yet at the time of the Survey the lands of both of them were distributed among foreign holders. Of the fate of Bondig we know nothing for certain ; but it id strange that the lands of Eadnoth, who died fighting in AVilliam's cause, were not allowed to pass to his son.-^ A third Englishman of rank in the district knew better than all how to adapt himself to the new state of things. It is plain that Wigod of Wallingford, the kinsman and His favour cupbearer of Eadward,"* had made his submission to William Uam. and had been received into his full favour. There is Proba- ,,..,., bilityofhia therefore every reason to accept the tradition which re- receiving presents him as having made his submission when William j^j^' ^j'j^"^ "° appeared in Berkshire before his coronation, and which i"ai"^li- December, makes it owing to Wigod's help that William was peacefully 1066. received and enabled to cross the Thames without opposi- tion. Wigod seems to have retained so much inlluence in the new state of things that Englishmen of smaller account found it expedient to seek his protection by com- * See Appendix G. ' That is, if we can believe in the Wefltminster writ in the Monasticon, i. 310, where " \N ilieni Kin;^ gret Bundi stallere and Sawold sirefen and alle mine thegnen on Oxnefordesire freondlico." For the lauds of Bondig in Beritshire, see Domesday, 60 b, 72 b. ' On Eadnoth, see Domesday, 58 h, and Appendix S. • See vol. iii. p. 768. On Wigod and lloger of Oily, see Appendix G. 4^ THK PIK8T DAYS OF WILLIAM'8 UKKJN. i .vt. Kvii. menJation. Ho diinl iH'forc the time of tho Survey, but hit* landi), and much more than liis laudn, liad RoUrtof paatod to hin Nonuan K<>ns-iii-]a\v, UoIktI of Oilv ami XoH-ithUm. Miles Cmpin, othorwiw* Milrn of Wallin^-foni. This \va« of course the most honourahh* way whij'h ^Villian^ louUl find of providingf for hin favouriton. An llni^^linh h»'in'S8, the widow or dautjhtcr oi' a ImiuIowiht who had eithrr diixl in the battle or had inadr timely Kuhmission to AVilliam, was given in marriay^* to some foreig-n adven- turer, who thus, either at once or on the death of his father-in-law, was settled in an ICn^lish estate without any formal wronjip or confiscation. So now Robert of Oily and his bworn brother in arms, Roger of Ivry,* came, like other men, to make their fortunes, and received estab- lishments in the border shires of AVessex and Mercia. Tiio destiny of Robert, owing probably to his marriage with GfwUpo*- Wigod's daughter, was the more brilliant of the two. His Robert: possessions in Oxford and Oxfordshire were large, and six Oxfo^"^ years after AVilliam came into England, he reared, to Ca^ile. frown over the wasted and imiioverished town, that keep 1073. * _ * of Oxford which plays such a ])art in the wars of the next ag'e. One of its surrounding towers still stands, a relic of days when Oxford, unknown as a seat of learning, was famous as a border fortress. He and his English wife died childless, and his inheritance at Oxford passed to the son of his brother. Rut the younger Robert, like his uncle, married a wife whose English name of Ead- g^'th makes her English descent all but certain. Robert and Eadgyth left descendants, and we may thus believe that, in a strange and indirect way, some fragments of the lands and honours of England abode in the hands of men who, by the spindle side at least, were English. Some portions too of Engli.sh soil were still held by men whose descent from the ancient stock was yet more direct ' See Appendix G. ROBERT OF OILY. 47 than the descent of the sons of Norman fiithers and chap. xvn. JOn^lish mothers. The merits of Wi<^od pluadetl for his Wigod'g kinsfolk, and one at Ipast ot them deserved at Wiluam s ^,,,1 i.jg hands the hi^^hest rewards of I'aitliful and really honour- °«P^e^'*- able service. We shall see a son of Wigod, Tokij^ by name, die lit,'htiniiinst his rebellious son.^ His name therefore linds no place in the Survey, and his inheritance doubtless went to swell the wealth of his sisters' husbands. But two nephews of Wigod are found in Domesday,- and one of them appears in close and significant neil>t.rt of •11,- Oily the and his wife, their names live in local history as the younger founders of that great Abbey of Oseney which was for (y"J),ey a moment the cathedral church of the Bishoi)rick whose Priory. 1129. throne is now hidden in the elder minster of Saint Frithesuyth. Such is the witness of a single district to that process Causes of of confiscation and distribution of land which was now resistiuice carried on throu^-h a larg-e part of southern and eastern 1*^ ^''*: ^'^^' England. We are inclined to wonder at first sight that such wholesale robbery could be endured for a moment, that every inch of ground was not disputed in arms, that every hedge was not defended as a palisade, that every field did not become a local and unrecorded Place of Battle. Several causes may help to explain the fact. Some of them are obvious enough. The English were for the The sj.irit moment thoroughly cowed. Their moral force was utterly people broken, and in a large part of the country their physical l^'^*|^f" force was utterly broken also. They had no leader, and moment, in many districts, could Eadmund or Harold have come again, he could have gathered round him but a slender ' See Appendix G,, and Chron. Wig. 1079, ' See Api>endi,\ G. •18 THE FIRST DAYS Of WILLIAMS HKION. cMAf. iTiT. followin;^. TIjc land hml not vol rivovori'il from the .^y^l^ mere t^rnngv of tiie battle. Shiri»8 like Kent nntl Hfik- •^^•tl^tm 8hin», wha»it> men hiid been fonMiiost nt Senlft<\ were, lor that very reason, lens nl»le than oilier Hhires to olVer re- sistaneo after Senlao. If Wjj^kI liatl ha>' William, wrontc is in every case alike reported in the Survey as a wrong". AVe may be sure that no such illegid occupations were made by William's knowledg-e during* his firet pro- g-ress, however soon they may have begun when his back was turnetl and when Odo and William Fitz-Osbern reig-ncd in his stead. And there is no need to think that all the land. The actual 1 • 1 1 o" confirica- even m the southern shires, which the burvey shows to tion ami have passed from Englishmen to foreigners ])assed irom f,ution' them during the first months of William's rei<^n. The ^""^ trra- . . dually, confiscation beg-an now as the punishment of the great treason done on Senlac, but it was continued from time to time as excuses were given for it by the various local risings and disturbances of later years. William no doubt at once seized the lands of Harold and his family, of Godric, Thurkill, and others whose estates were large, and who had been foremost in what he called rebellion. But many a man who ai)pears in Domesday as holding under King Eadward, but whose lands had passed to another at the time of the Survey, must have had them granted back again by William in his first days and must have lost them on account of his share in some later in- surrection. And it must be remembered that, in taking- Berkshire as my type, I have purposely taken a strung' case, and that there were other shires in which the pro- portion of land finally retained by Englishmen was much greater. But, in any case, whatever was done was done Effects in a regular and legal way. And this must have done outw.inl something to raise men's spirits again, and to lead them ^^"jJi^"!"'^ to put some sort of trust in the new government. It wa.s plain that, though the rule of King Williiun was VOL. IV. E so TU^ FlBSr DAT8 OP WILLI. \m'8 RIION. cnxr xTii. likely to be lien) ami exact injf, yet it \\i\h not likely to be, at any rate l>y Kinj*" WillianrH own will, a reij^ii of mere lawleiiH violence. At all event**, not a drop of hlcKHl wa8 »1khI, and that was »om<»tliin^, when men hH)ked l»aortion was j»Tantctl out to forei;^n landowners, but PruUbUa that too was ^rantoil out in all lc«^il form. Fnr the rest, the 2SSb-** Enj^lishman who f^A hack his land under Kin^ William's "^ .•* writ juul seal, even if he had to i)ay a mark or two of gold for the favour, most likely went Ijack to his house re- joicing. He had been in the mouth of the lion, and he ha*l come forth unhurt. 1 1 is good success with one who might have harried his lands with fire and sword, who might have doomed himself to death or bondage, must have made him, at least in these earlier days of William's reign, disposed to be thankful that his lot was not far harder than it was. n^ttw But there were other and deeper causes at work which ^^J^^ *" made the change easier to work than it would be in ufthea^ our time, and which also made it seem less strange and wiUiBweep- ingoonfis- monstrous than it would seem in our time. Nothing is land. more repulsive to modern ideas than the confiscation of Difference private property under any circumstances. Exccjit in a of modem i p • i • ideas on fcw extreme cases, except under a lew special tyrannies, tieau jec . ^j^^ tcnurc of a private estate lives through both domestic revolution and foreign conquest. No conqueror of our days would dream of confiscating the lands of every man who had served in the army which he had overcome. And in the internal afTairs of civilized states there is a deep and growing feeling against confiscation in any shape, against punishing the children for the sins of the fathers, even against making the rights of the individual give way to the needs of the commonwealth. As for wrongs done by individuals to each other, it would be a thing unheard of in FAMILIARITY OF THE AOK WITH FORFEITURES. 51 Eng-land or in any other civilized country, for the lands chap. xvn. of a private o\\'ner or of an ecclesiastical corporation to be seized \vithoiit process of law by the steward of a neig-h- bouring- Duke or Earl. Now on all these points the circum- stances and the feelings of the men of the eleventh century were wholly diflerent from our own. Confiscation, a word which is so frightful a bugbear to most modern ears/ was ^ nothing strange or monstrous to them. The name might Confisca- be unknown; but they were familiar with the thing in i,^i,.J all manner of shapes, just and unjust, legal and illegal. I'"'"**''- Contiscation was the received punishment for all manner of crimes, moral as well as political ; it was the doom of the adulterer no less than the doom of the traitor.- Every and the revolution in the state, even every change analogous to result ..fa what we should call a change of ministry, was not indeed. I'**^^V^"^.^ ^ "^ ' revolution. as in the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries, ac- companied by the slaughter of the defeated party, but it was commonly accompanied by their banishment and for- feiture. All the lands of the House of Godwine which Case of William now seized on had been already seized and restored in the days of Eadward. Even women of the highest rank Cases of were no more secure than other folk. Eadgyth, who now EaU"-yth. sat at Winchester in queenly wealth and honour, had, in the days of her own husband, been driven thence despoiled of her lands and goods. Her predecessor Emma had twice undergone the same doom, once at the hands of an • ** Confiscation " of course strictly means forfeitxire to the royal Treasury, whether such forfeiture be just or unjust. In modern lan<,aiage the word always seems to be used in an odious sense, and it is even vulgarly used as a mere e,propriani religiose pactatam abominans, scortum diligeas, libidinose commisit. Quo reatu omni HuljHtantitk peculiali recte privatus est." The whole story is curious. E 2 59 TIIK PIIt»nft of land, mmlo nu»rt' (V)ni!nniily, it ooctiMtitA would K*vm, l»v Uu» nj^^ntn of iM)\viTful nu-n tlmii l»y tlu- jxiwerful men thcmm'lveH, wo linve nliundnnt iiiKtancrs nl such dttxln of wronj*", alike in the dnyn of Kadwurd and in the days of William. Mrn no douhi complained e looked fur. cirvtim- It mi«^ht be looked forward to with dread; it might be lookeil back upon with bitterness and with hopes of re- venge. Hut it eould not be lookwl on as anything strange or unnatural, when every man of mature years must have remembered the same process happening on a smaller scale at the outlawries of Osgod Clapa, of Swcgen, of Godwine, and of yElfgar. Special Nor was this aspect of the case essentially altered by the y. ■ . fact that William's confiscations were, to a great extent, ^' - confiscations of the lands of Englishmen for the behoof of era. " Sach foreigners. Even in this there was nothing new. Men Ij^m^^^jjj had been used to the establishment of foreigners in the thatage. land, evcr since the days when Hugh the French churl had shown himself so poor a defender of the walls of C»«e of tlie Exeter.^ Old men might remember those later days when of Cnut. Danish Earls and Danisli Thcgns were established in England, and when English nobles and even English iEthelings died by the hands either of the hangman or of the assassin. 2 With such memories as these in their minds, ' See voL i. p. 346. '■' S«.-e above, pp. 12, 17. Compare the worcLj of William of Poitiers, 145 ; EAKLlKlt SKTTLKMKXTS OF F(JUEl(;Nh:US. 58 they might be thankful that their present conqueror was ouA.r. xvn. satisfied with seizin*^ on hmcls, and did not go on to shed Mood.* Mtn whoso memories did not go so far baek as this could still remember to how great an extent English lands and honours had been parted out among the foreign favourites of Eadward. They could remember the evil deeds of the castle-builders in Herefordshire and the flight of the foreign Bishops through the eastern gate of London. -^ And of those foreign favourites some were still in the land, Favourites some still held English lands and honours. Robert the JontiuucHl* son of AVymarc, Staller and SherifT of the East-Saxons, is ""!)!:'" perhaps not to be reckoned as an enemy of England. His unlucky counsel to AVilliam on his landing was forgotten or forgiven. His estates were largely increased by grants from the Conqueror, and were handed on to his son Swegcn. ' Regenbald the Chancellor' kept at once his temporal estates and his ecclesiastical benefices. And, worse than all, the original sinners of the Herefordshire border, Richard and his son Osbern, were still lords ofOsbernof English soil and holders of English offices, ready to play ghire. * their part in the work of conquest which still had to go on. With such men as these already in the land, the establish- ment of William's foreign followers in England was simply a large addition made to a class whose presence English- men had already learned, if not to love, at least to endure. In all these various ways, the first confiscations of William " Nobilwsimos tuorura [he is ai)ostrophizing England] tilioruni, juveues ac senen, Chunutua Danus trucidavit niniia crudelitate, ut sibi ac liberia suis te Hubigeret. Hie [Willelmus] ne Heralduna vellet occubuisse." * See vol. ii. p. 266. ' See vol. ii. p. 331. ' On Robert and Svvegen see Appendix H. * For his Berk.shire holdingB, see above, p. 4 1 . He aj^peara as " Ilainbaldiis pre.nbyter" in Wiltslure,r)8?>, Btickinglianishiro, 146, CIloucestci"shire, 1^6 />. The iJuckinghanishire entatc he had himself heUl T.K.E., but the lands in Herefortlflhire, iSo h, which " Roinbaldus Canceler" hay that time the yoke of the stran^vr waa too tightly iixed upon their necks. of There ean he littK» doubt that it was to this creat catioooQ transfer of hinds fmm Kn^lislinien to stran^^ers that tho the par- Norman Comiuest of England owed its distini^uishinir of tho character. This >vas the cause, more llian anyone cause, ConquoRt. wliieli made the Norman Conquest so thorough and so lasting in one point of view, so transitory, if we look at it from another. It was the master-piece of William's policy of outward legality. He did not remain a mere conqueror at the head of a foreign army, liolding his new Kingdom by main force, and liable to be driven out whenever the whole nation should join together in one sudden and vigorous uprising. Himself, in his own read- ing of the Law, a lawful King, he would turn the followers by whose swords he had won his Crown into supporters of his throne, bearing a more lawful and peaceful character than that of mere foreign soldiers. The King by the edge of the sw^ord changed himself in all outward show into a King according to the laws of England, and by the same process his foreign knights and men-at-arms were changed into English landowners, holding the soil of England according to English Law. He had his garrison in every corner of the land, but his garrison was formed of the chief lords of the soil and of the chief tenants who held under Pwitionof them. Such a garrison was harder to drive out than any grantees in mere army. Each detachment of William's great array of tngiand. occupation was weak and isolated ; but in its very weak- I'ERMANENT EFFECTS OF THE CONFISCATION. 55 ness and isolation lay its stren«^tli. To have cut off every coap. xvii. Norman lord aiul liis Norman retainers throu<^hout the len^''tli and breadth of Ene in pn's^'^in^' what he profcRsed to look on as his rien to his wrath. We have seen how the Abbots J**^**^ , of Peterboroujrh and New Minster, Lcofric the nephew and New of Earl Lcofric and yElfwi<^ the brother of Earl Godwinc, had ji^iven their lives in the cause of Enf^land.' And the brotherhood of either house was in AVilliam's eyes as guilty as its chief. Twelve monks of the New Minster had been William's found among the slain at Senlac,- and the convent of the Uu* tlwtion Golden l^orough had done a deed of treason well nigh as ofijraud. J.JJ.J, jj^ William's eyes by sending the Ab]x)t chosen in Leofric's place to seek the royal confirmation at the hands of the English yEtheling.^ There seems to have been something specially galling to William in this quiet ignor- ing of his claims. The monks of Peterborough had not even waited to see what would be the final end of the strife. They had shut their eyes to the presence of the Conqueror in the land, and had dealt with the uncrowned Eadgar as alreadv Kin<^. What followed is best told in the words of Rcconcili- the local Chronicler. " W^hcn that King William heard twcen the ^^^^ ^J^i^g ^^ was vcry wroth, and said that the Abbot Kingftml i^jjj done despite to him. Then went crood men between the AbUt; ^ ° * See vol. iii. pp. 426, 501. ' See vol. iii. p. 426. ' See vol. iii. p. 530. WILLIAMS DEALINGS WITH ]»ETERBOK()UGH. 57 thorn and reconciled them, because that the Abbot was a cuap. xvn. good man. Then gtive he to the King forty marks of gold ^'^^r^ V^^^ for reconciliation." * William's Tlie wratli of William was thus turned away from ,...„. *, the Golden Borough by a discreet employment of the Jealin^Tj wealth of Saint Peter. On the great house of /Elfreil and New Eadward his hand fell more heavily. Winchester, it will " ^^ ^^' be borne in mind, boweone cyng xl. marc goldes to sahtnysse." That this Ls the right time (see vol. iii. p. 530) for this story is plain from what follows ; *' l>a lifede he [Brand] litle hwile ^lereefler, buton hry gear." r>ran. 89. * See the reference in vol. ii. p. 644, and Mon. Angl. ii. 428-431. THE riR8T DAYS OF WILIJAM's HKION. ouf.tttL A \MXfg9 part of the iiOMMsioiiH of tho m >>' were Mbed by the new Kinff — William the Tvnuit. ;i> tin* load historuui cmplmtimlly ailU him ' — iiiid ^niiitiHl out to hi* foUowem. A h»>»tMul, eonceivtHl in ihc tuuuv npirit of grim pleeMUitry 04* tk> many other tal«>s ahout the Coiiqucror, doicrilicfi him lut saying' tliat he puninhtHl the ohmc of the Ablwt hy the ronfi»*cation of a hnrony and the crime of the twelve monkn hy the confiscation of an cqiul number of manors.^ Nay more ; the two minstere of Wiocheeier, OKI ami New, stood in awkward neighbour- hood to each other, so much 8o that the niii^in^ of the wor- shipixTw in the one \» said to have difiturljcd the devotions of the worshippers in the other. The newer foundation was cabineil, criblKMl, and confinetl in a very narrow spaec between the cathedral church and tlie buil(linf:»'s of the WilliMn't city. William still further narrowed the dwelling-place J^^^^^i^of the monks of New Minster by seizing part of their precinct for the site of a palace for himself, the walls of which almost touched the west front of the church.-^ Such a royal dwell in<^-place was specially needed in a city which, under William, recovered some of the di^iity which it had lost under Eadward and Harold. The older j>alace of the West - Saxon Kings had become * T. Budbome, Uixt. M.ij. Wint. ap. Aug. Sacr. i. 249. " Wilhelmus Conqtmtor Ulud ah i|>HO rnonaMterio ra))uit injuKto et niilitibuH buIh tradidit. Conititnili modo se bAbuit Wilhflmtu Ti/ranniM alLis monasteriis et caeteris -Bobifiboa Angliae." • In the document called "Destnictio Monasterii de Hida " (Mon. Angl. ii. 437, see voL iL p. 644) we read, "Anno regni suo tertio mare tranjiiit, duccns aocum eoclesia) prajdictae thesauros, qui, in brevi rediens, dicii moiuuiterii, videlicet pro Abhate baroniam unam ct pro singulis monachiw qui cum Abbate contra dictum Regem in bellum processcrunt, ■ingqla feoda militum arripuit, militibus qui cum eo venerant conferendiB." The date at \easi is wrong. ' Sea tbe plan in Edwards* Liber de Hyda, p. xli. Of this palace no trace remains. A royal bouse, as distinguished from a castle, of William's reign would have been a precious addition to our knowledge of domestic aotiqiutiee. HIS SPOLIATION OP NEW MINSTKH. 59 the dwelling-pliicL' «>f the royal widows Emma and chap. xvii. Ead<^th, and nothin*^ could bo further from AVilliams purpose than in any way to disturb the relict of his reveretl predecessor and lord.^ But William's wrath against the olfending house seems g-radually to have relaxed. In the third year he allowed the election of Election of an AblK)t, whose name of Wulfric moreover proclaims 'wulfric. him to have been an Englishman, and whose deposition, ^°^9' three years later again, awakens an interest in his favour.* And it api>ears that some i)arts of the alienated lands Partial re- were in the course of William's reign restored to the to tlie Abbey, and other lands granted to it, some of them ^'^'^y- expressly in exchange for the ground alienated for the building of the palace.^ Besides these seizures of landed property, William also Taxes and possessed himself of great moveable wealth from various receive^d by sources. The native Chronicler simply tells us that he ^ ^^^^•'^"^• laid a very heavy tax upon all men. * But the expressions • In the Liber Winton (Domesday, iv. 535) we read, "domus Emmae Reginae fiiit quieta T. R. E. et mode est quieta." The palace kept the name of the first OKI Lady who held it. ' See Edwards, Liber de Hyd^, xli. ; Appendix to Winchester Chronicle, Tliorpe, i. 386. ' -Edwards, ib. ; Domesday, 43. Two of the new grants, Alton and Ciere, are expressly said to have belonged to Eadgyth, who had a house at Clere — ** ibi fuit aula." These grants therefore could not have been made till some years later, when the Lady was dead. But Clere is ex- pressly said to have been given as a recompense for the site of the palace ; " Hoc dedit ecclesiie W. Rex pro excambio terrtc in qu.l domua Regis est in civitate." Of another place, Laverstock, we find this curious notice ; ** Ulveva Dttedau tenuit de abbatiA usque ad obitum. Post mortem ejus reddidit Rex W. hoc manerium eidem ecclesiae pro sua aninia et uxoris ejus." The King therefore had some claim after the death of Wulfgifu. Was she one of the widows of men slain at iSotdac, who wore allowed to keep their lands as alms ? Of the mysterious and Slavonic-sounding name Beteslau, wliich seems also U) have puzzled Mr. Edwards, I can give no account. * Chron. Wig. 1066 (just after tiie account of the coronation oath), '* 8wa ^eah Icide gyld on mannum swiCe stiiJ." William of Poitiers, on the other hand, says (147), ** Tributis et cunctis ad regium fiscum reddendis •0 TIIR PIKST DAYH Of WILLIAMS KKION. csAr.iTii iif WTit4-rf» on til* oilur itidc mny Iciiil u^ to think that the lopil Hul.tK'ty of Williiim had forr*08uit." This however, whatever truth wc may cbooae to see in it, ia i»rol«:ibly meant to refer to regular and permanent taxation, while the worda of the Chronicler suggest a single extraordinary pajment. * WilLPict. 1 44. " Id munificentie studium adjuvit noB modicus cenBus. qaem undique civitates et locupletes quifjue obtulerant novitio domino." ' Ih. 155. " Abundantes ecclesiaj tranHmariii;e uli(jua ei libentes qujc in Galliam transfcrrct den* mrirhctl with tho holy s]H>ilM of con- qHS. qVMred Bnirlnnd. Tho ^Ak which William lH*HtowiHl on the •innlh*«t iiioiwwtiTy wen? pits which a mctro- l^oIiUn church would not have dc«pi«oeoome a Kin*;.'' He himself seems to have been ea^er pro munere cjiiBdcro ApOHtolici benignitate sibi iniw^o par redderet : simul et triumplaiin dc tymnno Koniti- ulteriuH<|Uc oj)t;ituiii j>ulcre jiidicaret." ' Will. I*ict. 1 44. ** iSpluudide mlomaret metropolitanain baailicam, quod minimum is his doniii coeniobolum aliquod betificavit." * lb. •* Alia cruce« aurtaH atlmoduni grandoH inKigniter gemmatas, pie- neque libnw auri vcl ex eodem mctallo vasa, nonnulhc pallia vol pretiosum aliud quid aooepere.** ThcHc tbingH were evidently among the pretended gift« of Uie English monaBteries whicli I liave mentioned just before. ' lb. " Mille eccleaiia Francia*, Aquitania?, Burgundia?, necnon Arvemia}, alianimque regionum i»erj)ctuo celebre erit Willelmi Regis memoriale." BenOtt (37882) oddly changes Auvergne into Saxony; •' N'out en France riche moster, Oil il n'enveiast ses presenz N'en Aquitaine n'en Borgoigne, Riches e precios e jenz." Ne par tot ci que vers Saisaoigne, * Will. Pict. 144. " Munera quidem gratisHima Normanniae advenerunt a truo duld nato, pio patre, festinante aflFectu misHa, quum 8a::vitia tem- poriii aUjue maris, intrante Januario, esset acerrinia." * lb. 1 45. " NulluH umquam illuxit ei [Normanniae] dies kctior, quam quum certo rescivit Principem suum, nuctorem sui fjuicti ntatus, Regem esse." He goes on with much more in the same strain, but the words which I have put in Italics form William's real title to honour. \ EXTENT OF HIS OCCUPATION OF ENGLAND. G3 to visit his native land in all the ^lory of conquest and chap. xvn. in all the splendour of his new rank. His tirst stay in *'*" ^'7" * •' pareH to En<,''land took up less than three months from the day vuit Nor- of his coronation, less tlian six months from the day ol his first landin<^ at Pevensey. But, before he ventured to leave his new Kin^^dom, William Ext<-nt of uad to take measures tor its g-ovemment and deience during* tion of his absence. We must here remember his position. He was ^"o ^ • King" over all England, inasmuch as there was no other King, inasmuch as the chief men of all England had out- wardly become his men. But he was in actual possession of only a small part of the country. It is not easy to trace the exact extent of the fully conquered territory. The south- eastern shires, Sussex and the Earldom of Leofwine, were, I need not say, hopelessly in the g-rasp of the Conqueror. Kent and Sussex, above all, had not only seen the flower of their inhabitants cut off in the great battle ; they had seen every inch of their territory, ecclesiastical estates alone excepted, portioned out among" foreign masters. Not a rood of g-round in those shires remained in the hands of an English tenant-in-chief of the King.^ West- wards we have traced William in person as far as Wall- iug"ford, and by his representatives as far as Winchester. There is therefore no doubt as to the submission of Hampshire, Berkshire, and part of Oxfordshire ; as to the town of Oxford itself the evidence is far from clear.- On the other hand Exeter, and with it Devonshire and Districts Cornwall, was still untouched. In Herefordshire and on pendent the Welsh border the state of things was very unsettled. The Norman colony, planted in that region by Eadward State of and so strangely tolerated by Harold, was still doing its shire. ' In Kent and SuHsex we find none of the claas of King's Thegna of whom I have already spoken in Berkahire. See above, p. 34, and ApiMindix E. ' See ApiK'ndix G., Z. Ci TiiR riHsr DAYB OF wimjam's keion. iii^r. iTii. work. OhIktu, it will Ih' nim ml) n «1, IckI Iktii ShorilF umlrr FUulu*nnl, vwn whru IIiunM was Karl of llu» nliiri',* and hiji fathrr Hichnnl, the oKl oirrndiT, btill lived. Their own Kiehnnrn (\ihtlo wnn n n-atly-inmh' outpoat of the NoniiAU Kill};. Aiul l»y w»me meaiiH, ilouhtlwH through Otbem*t oflioo of Sherilf, they were nlso in coniniand of the city of Hcrefonl, when*, jin^hahly under ()blx»ni's handn, B«*<*«ot a cmsile had now pprunj*" up.^ But tlie mont powerful Kn«^- lii^hman in tho}«o part*, Kudric the \\\U\, who hears the title of Child and is di'«cril>od as the son of /Klfric the brother of Eadrie Streona,* had refusitl to suhmit / and it is need- less to say that no honia^ ha.s been received from the Hninwut Welsh Princes. Of the remaining" shires of Harold's own IVmaCahirv Karldoni, Gloucester, Somerset, Dorset, mid \V ill si lire, ontoadMxJ. ^^jj. a(»^»(^untg are legs certain. AViltshire had i)robably suh- mitttnl along with Hampshire and lierkshire, but Somer- si'tiiihirc and Dorsetshire, there can be little doubt, still held out. In the central and northern part of England it does not seem that AVilliam had taken a single step to secure submission beyond receiving the homage of their &H' Earls and reinstating them in their offices. In the East occuiluxJ ^^ England "William's dominion w^as secured by the posses- sion of Norwich, the chief town of the Earldom of Gyrth/* In short the state of things seems roughly to have been • See vol. ii. p. 346, and above, p. 53. • Florence (1067) Hpeakw of the " Herefordenses castellani et Kichardus filiiM Scrob " as the opponents of Eadrie. I could almost have fancied that the wordH •' Herefordenses castellani " referred to " the castle '* in HerefunLihire, that is Kichard's Castle (see vol. ii. p. 138) ; hut the words of the Worcester Chronicler, •' p& castelmenn on Hereforda," seem to fix the meaning to the city itself. It is jiossible that Harold himself, during the Welsh war, may liave found it expedient to build a castle at Herefonl. But it is just .-iS likely to have been a work of Osbern himself during these first months of William's presence in England. ' Fl. Wig. 1067. " Eo tempore exstitit quidam pnepotens minister, EdricuH, cognomento Silvaticus, filius yKlfrici, fratris Edrici Streona;." •See above, p. 21, and Appendix I. • lb. " Se dedere Regi dedignabatur." '• See below, p. 67, ANALOGOUS POSITION OF WILLIAM AND HAROLD. Go on this wise. The battle of Senhic and his later cam- chap. xvn. j)ai«^ns and progresses had given William real possession [^^"* "^'^ of hy far the greater part of those regions of Kngland William 's . . ]M>8ition8 where the fortretw ^^PJP would aet, not as a eentre of oppretision against En^lish- fM«l. men« but as a defence ai^ninst invading enemies. lie had, as we have seen, built the famous c:istle at Dover ; ^ it is possible that he had built one at Hereford,-' and it seems likely that he had also built another at Arund«.*l. Domes- day at leai*t bears its witness to the existence of a castle there in the days of Kin«»' Kadward/ a solitary instance in the whole course of the Survey. But now the a^e »^^-' ' of castle-building fairly set in. It was William's jmlicy Wiiiiaju. to keep the conijuered land in cheek by commanding^ every town and every imj)ortant point by one of these fortresses, which became in truth the fetters of England.'' We have already seen him begin the work on the heights of Hastings,'' and go on with it in the greatest city of the land." And, as we follow his steps, we shall sec that, at every stag-e of the Conquest, the building of a castle in a con(iuered town was ever the first work of the Conqueror's foresight. Most of the castles whose foundation is dis- tinctly recorded naturally belong to places which came into William's hands in the course of later warfare. But * See vol. ii. p. 138. • See vol. iii. p. 536. ' See above, p. 64. * Domesday, 23. "Caatrum Harundol T. II. E. reddebat de quodain m<»lino XL. solidon." See Appendix K. ^ Ord. Vit. 51 1 C (speaking however of a somewhat later time) ; "Rex igitur KecesHUH regni provideiitius j)erluHtravit, et opportuna loca contra excursiones hoHtium conimunivit." So Will. Gem. vii. 42. "Rex autem monitus qiiidein prudentia, quA consulere in cunctis Regi novit, immunita re^Tii pro%-idiiwimtt dispoHitione perlu»travit, ac aerriraa stipendiorum copia munivit," * See vol. iii. p. 409. ' See above, p. 19. BUILDING OF CASTLES. 67 there were castles in Southern and Eastern En^hmd also, chap. xvii. and it is most Hkely that their foundation at h^ast, if not their completion, was amon^ the very first works of William's reij^n. In one ease indeerdaiii (jui propter pauperiem nuUam reddunt con- Huotudiiicni, et in illu terra ijuani ten< liant Stigandus T.R. E. njamiit niodo ex iliis HUj)eiioribiH xxxviiii. burgeuses . . . et in illu terra de 4011 Ileroldun habebat socaiu sunt XV. burgenses." F 2 68 TIIF. FIRST nAY8 <»K WIMJAM S RRION. OUmt OMiUaIn Booth- FhrtTII KngUml. c«Ar. ini. U» tliriiitoncd by a Siiiiuliiiavian rival.' A fortrt^Kfl was JJIJI^JM^ tlu»rvf<»n* built within tho wnlln of the city/' a fact which at onct' f»howM that tho city itm»lf wan aln*atly forti- fuHl, ami that tho now fortress wn« mainly intciuhMl ns a curb u|»on the oitizonn thomsolvos. \Vh('thrr William's jirt*s*«nt work wtuj roally tho bi»^inning of tho ;;roat fortross whose shell still surviveu, or whether all that waH now done waa to pro>n(lo in a ha^ty way for the needs of tho moment, is a question whieh may be left to local inquirers. In tho course of William's reign other castles arose within the limits of the territory which was already subduod, at Cantorbur}', Kochester, Brand)or, Lowes, Carisbroko, Waliiiii^'ford, and Windsor, the last being the most famous and abiding of all.' Of most of these it is probable that the beginnings at least belong to this early stage of William's reign, but all or most of them have cithor jwrished or survive only in tho form of representatives of lat^r date. The present keep of Rochester above all is tho noblest example of the Norman military architecturo of tho next generation. In all those castles wc are told that William placed trusty and valiant captains, who had come with him from Gaul, at tho head of large forces of The expression " from Gaul " is ro- t^*^hra»e- "i^irl^a^^^^'- It is a wituoss to the importance of the force iiuportanoj which William had drawn from lands beyond the bounds ofthe . of his own Duchy. The foreign, especially the Breton, Com- nuuiden 6x>ra •' GtM\ " placed in the canUta*. horso and foot.^ ' WilL Pict. 149. " Danos in auxilium citius recipere potest. A mari, quod Angloa a Danis separat, iiiillia j)a.ssuuin (|uatuordecim dlHtat." ' lb. "Hujua (juoque urbis intra rafiiuia muuitiouem conatruxit." So Ord. Vit. 506 B. " Intra moeiua Guentx opibus et munimine nobilJB urbi« et mari contigua*, validam arcem conatruxit." This almost looks as if the famous ca«tle of later times was now at least begun, though the words may merely refer to some temporary predecessor. • On these cawtles, see Appendix K. * Will. Pict. I48. •• Custodes in castellis strenuos viros collocavit, ex Gallic tnuluc-tos, quorum fidei pariter ac virtuti credebat, cum multitndine peditum et etiuitum." FOREIGN COMMANDERS OF THE CASTLES. 69 auxiliaries, must, at this stage of the Conquest, have heen chap. xvii. numerous and formithible, and wo shall see that, later in f*»reii,m his reign, William was well pleaseil to get rid of them. atthintiinc. To eneouraarl»arianH uh to fail to npprfciuto him. They nw thiit, whether m* Prelate or an tcmi>or&l ruler, lie was entitUil not only to their fear hut to their reverence dud BmUoom love' Theue two 8iHH:iully fnvounxl chiefs were invested wmtain ^*^*^* Kn^lis*h luirldoniH, and were entrusted with a general eomnmnd over the whole of the eon(|Ucred country. Hut, an«i iKio. even at this early time, William hcg^an that j)olicy of poUcy'wiUi ^>^'^'*^*'^" which \\Sk» allected the whole course of En«^li.sh '*R*^* *^ historj- since. In the Northern part of Eu'^-land, where his i)ower was purely nominal, he was constrained lor a season to leave the successors of Lcofric and Siward in possession of the vast governments held hy their pre- decessors. But, within that part of the land which was really his own, William was not g'oing to allow the growth of any power, even in the hands of those dearest to him, which had the faintest chance of hecoming" dan- EaHs gerous to his own. There was no longer to be an Earl lilr^nKlo ^^ *^^^ West-Saxons or an Earl of the East- Angles, wicld- Bhirca. ii^^ ^\^Q yogi powers and ruling over the vast territory which had heen held by the Earls of the Houses of God- wine and Leofric. Rcturninf^ in this to earlier English practice, the Earl under William was to have the rule of a single shire only, or if two shires were ever set under one Earl, they were at least not to be adjoininp^ Re«ulu of shires. The results of this change have been of the ** ' highest moment. This one resolution of the Conqueror Bciobat." He cnlargoH on William Fitz-Osbern's merits and on the frfendttbij) whicli had lasted between him and the Duko from tlu-ir oarlio.st d»yt. ' Will. Pict. 1 50. After a long pancgj-ric on Odo, lie windu up ; " LibentcK eidem obsequebantur, ut acceptisnimo domino, Nonnanni aUjue Britanni. Nee Angli a (Xlo to llu« ICarUiom of Kint ' niul of 1'^^^^ \V,lli:im Fit/.(W»orii to tho I'jirldom of lltTefonl.- The Ml 11.. !iato ami |HTmaiient iiulliority of lioth wiu* thua 1 within very narrow bounds; the wider com- .Mioh they uIko liohl wa« a mere temporary dele- ThHr Hnt f?ation of authority during the King's a1)6cncc. In this * Uftt clianietor they seem to have lx?en joined together aa co-regcnt*i, while each luul his own 8i>cciid province within HmSotUi the limit* common to both.' The South, which, we aro ib« Nortli ' aflBurtxl, wai!, through its neighbourhood and intercourse ™Jf with Gaul, somewhat less savage than the rest of the isknd, was put under the milder rule of the Bishop.* It was left to the new Earl of Hereford to keep watch against the still independent North, and Norwich, with its newly rising castle, was put under his 8j)ccial care.'^ These two extreme points of his province, Hereford on * Willuini of Poitierrt (149) inqdicH, witliout directly Htating, Odo'H ap- pointment an Earl ; ** Castruni Duverani Odmii fratri huo coinnuHit, cum .'vij.vxiitc or/l aufltrali, qua-, nomine vetusto Cantium dicta^ Galliam propius ii|toct.'it." The reterborough Clironiclcr ako calls him Earl (1087), though \*iihout naming his Earldom ; "He h:Lfde eorldom on Englelande." Hih Earldom is implied in the well-known story of hiw seizure by his brother's nrderw (Will. Malm. iii. 277 ; Ord. Vit. 647 C), and Williaui of Malmes- lairy, just lx.'fore telling it, says, " (Jdonem, quem ad episcopatum Baio- censcm provexit Conies, Comitcm Canti.e Hex instituit," an Orderic directly after the story spealu of his " comitatus Cantice." * Fn>m the language of Orderic (521 D) one might have thought that William Fitz-Ohbern did not receive the Earldom till 1 070, but Florcuco (1067) sjiys expressly, " Willelmum filium Osbemi, quern in Herefordensi provincii Comitcm constituerat. " * The joint commission of Odo and William appears faintly in the Worcester Chronicle, 1066; "and Oda Biscop and WyUelm Eorl l^elifen her acfter." It is more distinct in Florence, 1067 ; " Fratrem suum Odonem T'-ii conHom et Willelmum filium Osbemi Anpliie custoiles relinquens." So V\ il. Pict, 156. " Interea liaiocensis Pratsul Odo et Willelmus Osberni filius pm-fccturas in regno, uterque suam, laudabiliter admiuistrabant, interdura simul agitantes, mwlo diversi." * Will. Pict. 1 49. " Cantium . . . Cialliam projiius spectat, unde et a minus fcris hominibus incolitur. Consueverant enim merces cum Belgis mutare." * See above, p. 67. The words of William of Poitiers (149), " Ibidem REGENCY OF UDO AND WILLIAM FITZ-uSBEKN. 73 the West and Nonvieli on the East, show phiinly how I'ar vuw. xvii. the real duminion of WilUam reached towards the North. The two Earls were to be the royal lieutenants during Caption to William's absence, and they were specially bidtlen to be dilij^ent in the g-reat work of securing the obedience of the land by the buildinjT;' of castles.* Besides these two <»'reat Viceroys, we also know the SubonJi- names of some of the subordinate captains who held niantUhelJ commands under them. The few whose names appear ^ in the history were all of pure Norman birth. The Hugh of Castle of Dover, the chief fortress of the government ^t Dover, of Odo, was entrusted to the immediate care of IIu<^h of Montfort.- Of him we have heard in two widely dillerent characters on different sides of the sea. Dover, perhaps again arising from the ruin of the Norman fire, w^s given to the care of the man who had so well guarded the burning streets of Mortemer. Tlie fortress raised by the forethought of Harold was put under the rule, not of one who had met his axe face to face, but of one of the evil four who had WTOught the last brutalities upon his disabled body.-^ The fortress of Hastings had, Humfioy from the very day when it began to arise, been placed Hastin*^s, under the command of Ilumfrey the brother-in-law of the more famous Hugh of Grantmesuil.^ His son Robert, [Gucntii.*] Willclmum rcliquit Osbemi filiuiji pracipuum in exercitu suo, ut in vice Hua interim toti regno Aquilonem versus privesset," show tliat "Guenta" cannot be Winchester. ' Fl. Wig. 1067. "Castella per loca finnari praecepit." ' Will. Gem. vii, 39. " Milites Odonis Baioca.sirii Prrc.sulis atque Hu- goniH de Monteforti, quibua custodia Doroherniiu tredita crat." Will. Pict. 157. " Munitiones custodcs Prsesul Baiocensis attiuc Hugo de Montef«»rti." ^ On the doings of Hugo of Montfort at Mortuinor and Sonlac, seo vol. >"• PP- '55, 287, 499. • Ord. Vit. 513 B. "Sororius ejus [Ilugonis do GrantemaisnilJ Un- fridus do Telliolo, qui Uastingas a prima die constructionis ad custoiiien- duui suHceperat." Seo also 600 C. In 669 C wo read of his son Robert, " UmfriduH pater ejuH fuit filius Amfridi de progonio Dacorum. Adelizii 74 THE Pliurr DAYS OP WILLIAMS KKION. tiiAr &%ii. Iniowii AH^nmnlK lui U4)lK*rt of inuuldlaii. had Uv^n ono of tho Norman favotintoi of Koilwnnl ; \\c \\m\ riHvivi»d knight IkxxI at hii hundx, and hiul hold wlmt one would think muiit liavo Ikh'H the ttinccurc ofllco of nrniour-!)oarer lli^h of in the Saint.' To Ilti^h of (JranimcHnil himself was nil m ^'ii,. cntnwtcHl the pivornmont, or nt lca«t the militar}' com- ^^••'*'- mnnd. of the old Im|H'rial city ami t^^ a district which at \vasi tblcr mornin^-^^ifl af \N incheiitor placed under the rule of another Norman Hu^h <»f pjcater renown. V Of the state of thinf»>< in the Northern Earldoms wc , ,,'* unluckily hear nothin*^. It was William's policy to i.M N- rih. remove from the country durinp^ his absence all those whose presence in it at such a moment mi^ht have been dang-erous to his authority. An honourable pretext was not wanting". The chief men of England were called u]>on to accompany their new King on his visit to his dominions beyond the sea. Normans and Englishmen, now* under the rule of one common sovereign, were to feel, if not as fellow-countrymen, at least as fellow-subjects. They were to become accustomed to the presence and companionship of one another, and each was to look on the land f>f the other as a land not wholly foreign. vero inatcr ejuB utiror Hugonis dc- Grentcnuiisnil lain tliat )u> must ApfMTNii have given offence. If ho had fiiileil to ai>]>oar at ^Vw^ IWrkhainpstcAd or at Harkinf^*, to hrromo WillianrK man, and to nxx*ive his Karldoin apiin at WilliamH liandH, that was quite ^n)iind cnou^^h, ao(>onlin^ to the rodi* of the new itM^'n, to di^l with him as a traitor whoHo lands and honours wore forfoitinl without furtluT nentonce. Hut 08 yet William excrri»eeyond the T)'ne or the Ilumhor aa he exercised in tlu' Orkneys. Policy oT But it was politic to treat as his own the land which was one day to he his own. Tlic day had not yet ^" ":^"'^* come when he could try the exiH»riment of sending: a bumbcr> . * . . . Uod. foreifj'n Earl and foreign soldiers into that distant and dangiTous land. ]5ut it was prudont to make at least a show of authority even in the furthest corner of the hind over which he claimed to be Kinf*". Such a show of authority mi<^ht be made l)y granlin<^ the forfeited Karldom to an Eng-lishman, and leaving him to take jMtssession of it in William's name, if he could. Such an instrument was found in Copsige, the old lieutenant of Tostig. A partizan of Tostig* would naturally l>e at feud with Oswulf, as one whom the favour of Tostig's enemy Morkere had restored to some share of the possessions Copsige of his forefathers.' William acted ^vith speed. Early iJ^Jl^ in the month of February Copsige was invested with ^^^'^^P the Earldom, and he at once set forth to take possession. We shall see hereafter how he fared on his errand.^ position of Besides the Earls and Prelates who arc spoken of as iEthelwifi'^ accompanying William, there are one or two other leading *"<* churchmen of whom we hear later in the story, and age. of whom we should have been well pleased to learn some- thing at this particular moment. One of these is iEthel- wig, the prudent Abbot of Evesham. High as he had ' See vol. ii. p. 487. ' .See the ne.xt Chapter and Appendix L. COPSIGE APPOIXTEI) EAHL. 77 stootl in the favour of Eachvunl and Harold, he stood chap. xvii. equally hi;L^h in the favour of William. The annals of his house set him before us as one of the first of Knj^lish Prelates to submit to the new order of thin^^, and as l)ein^ at a somewhat later time invested witli large authority in several Mercian shires.^ Another Prelate also, whose church lay in the Earldom of Waltheof, iEthelsige of Ramsey, who had borne to Harold in his sickness the miraculous message of comfort from his saintly predecessor,''^ was also soon alter hi^h in William's favour. He therefore probably was so already. llie presence of Copsi^^e, /Ethelwig", and yEthelsio^e in the Earldoms of Morkere, Eadwine, and Waltheof respec- tively may possibly have been looked on as a g-uaranty for the preservation of order no less valuable than the absence of the Earls. But on all these points of detail we are left to conjecture. § 3. irUUa7n*s First Visit to Normandi/. March — December 1067. All was now ready for the royal voyage. Tlie place WilH.im'rt chosen for the embarcation was the same which had been tion at chosen for the landing* six months before. In the course ^®^^'^*^y- of the month of March the ships were ready at Pevensey, already most likely the lordship of William's brother, Robert of Mortain.-* Those ships, the Norman paneg-yrist tells us, should have been adorned, in ancient fashion, with white sails, as bearing" a conqueror to his triunijdi.' A ' Sec Appendix W. ' See vol. iii. p. 359. ' Seo Diiinestlay, 20 h. I know not on what autliority Thierry (i. 27.^) says, •• & Pevunsey, lieu de d<'])arquement de rarra^'C, lea soldats norraandH part iij,'t' rent i-ntre oiix les niairtuns doa vaincurt." TIo refers to Doniesday, i(), wh«-re there ia not, and could not well be, anything of the kind. ' Will. Pict. 150. "Stabant naveM ad trannniittendum paratissiinre, (juan T« THE riHS^ DAYS OF WILLIAM'h HKUJN. ruAr. XVII lar^' IhhIv o( Kn^^Ituhnu'n ol rank hail aHHomlilrd on the J'J' ^^' »<|H»t, citluT to nrroni|uiny tlu» Kin^ on his voya^jv or simply Miu ur to do him worhhip on hin dopartnro.* And of those who won* rh(»MMi for the former dan^^ToiiH honour the firnt was K*>1<^ luultjiir, the Kini^ of a moment, whom we are told tliat \N illuun had enriilutl with lary^» fP^^ *'^ \i\iu\ and enrolletl amon^ those who w»crc dearest to him.* Another wjw Stlgmad. Stipind the Primate, wliom he had already made up hin mind to remove from his office, hut witli whom he thought piK)d to bear for a while, till his dejiosition could be brought alx>ut by pro|XT Papal commission. Till this could be done, William di^enuHl it ]>rudcnt to show all honour to one whose authority stood so hig-h among his countrymen. ' The only iBib«lnoth other churchman of whom we hear by name is yEthelnoth, tur. Ablx)t of Glastonbury, whose obedience to William's sum- mons is the only sign which wc have yet come across of any authority being exercised by the new King in the Wcst<'rn shires. That yEthelnoth, who was alU-rwards dci)oscd from his Abbey, was already honoured by William's jealousy is a fact which may be set against the charges which are brought against him.* Among laymen the only one vcre decuerat albis velis more veterum odomatoH cbsc. Erant enim rcvec- tiini*, gloriofliMiinum triumphuin nuntiatura*, inaxinie optatum fjaudium" Tliierrj- (i. a8i) seems to think that the sails actually were white. ' Will. Pict. 150. "Convenit eodern multus Anglorum equitatus." ' Sec Appendix M. ' Will. Pict. 147. " Pontificiura Stij,'an(li, quod noverat non canonicuni, niininie probabat; sed AjxiHtolici sententiaiu exspectare melius quam pro- |x.Tantiu8 deix>nere cxistiinabat. 8uadel>ant et alise rationes, ut ad tempus pateretur at^iuc honorifice haberet ilium cujus inter Anglos auctoritaH erat Humma." William of Maliuesbury, Gest. Pont. 36 (I (juote henceforward from Mr. Hamilton's new edition), especially marks the unwillingness of Stigand to go on this journey ; " Nee niulto po8t in Normanniain navigans «ub velamine honoris renitentem sccum traxit, ne «juid pcrfidi.-L'. hc absente, per ejuB auctoritatem in Anglia pullularet." * On yEthelnoth, see vol. ii. p. 361. Thierry (i. 281) for /P^thelnoth sub- stitutes Frithric Ablx)t of Saint Alban's, fbr whose presence he quotes no authority. I suspect it to l)e as mythical as most other stories about that Prelate. William of Poitiers (150) mentions no Prelate but Stigand, but William's exolish companions. 79 mentioned besides the i'Etheling' and the three Earls, chap. xvn. is a The«^n of Kent, who bore the same name as the Abbot J^^'^;''"^"' of Ghistonbiiry.' Those however whose names are given ^^'i*li'«^* the hind wliich •ent forth Buch pHxlly nton^n wai< in winning. WIDkn'a 'Tlie voya^ wns proHjx'rous, and it Hirms to have had •"^ ^ the inckK'ntnl p>od eHi'ct of securing the wifety of sea- Vimcx farini'' folk of lower dejjree. A stop, we are told, was put ^SSj to all pir.iey for a lon^ time to come.'^ Tlie exj)reKsion is PJ'^T'J*"* remarkahle ; it mij^ht seem to imply that, since the great »om«oi. lUrt of Harold had disapju'ared from the Channel, ])iracy had been sjx»eially rife. The Danish havens in Ireland were no doubt always full of men in whom the old W'ikin^ spirit was stronq^, and who were ready to sail forth for fiji^hting or plunder wherever either ri<»^hting or j)lunder was to be had. And it is quite jwssible that disjwsseFsed Eng^lisli- men may have already begun, as we know that they did before long, to take service in any quarter which promised either a chance of restoration or a hope of vengeance on those who made restoration hopeless. For the present at least, it would seem that the southern coast of England, the coast which William's own fleet could immediately protect or coerce, remained unharried by either friends or enemies. William'a The haven at which AVilliam landed is not told us. But JJ*^^jj^ we have full, perhaps not exaggerated, accounts of the joy ™*'»nitentiae quadragesiinalia rigori vacant. Ceteruni ubique agebantur taniquam sumiuae fcstivi teniporis ferite : boI sestivft sercnitate lucidus videbatur, gratia dierura solitd longe major." Is this merely metaphor, or was William really favoured by tlio weather ? ' lb. *• Minonim aive remotiorum locorum incoIiB in urbes, aut alio ubi facultaa conapiciendi Ilegem daretur, confluebant." ' lb. *' Quum in metropolim suam Kotliomagum introiret, senes, paeri, matronn?, cunctique cives spectatum proces-serant ; conclaniabant salutantea reducem, adeo ut civitas ilia universa applaudere putaretur, Bicuti Roma (juondaiu Pouipeio suo applauden.s tripudiavit." * lb. 155. ''Oj)tinie (juidem egerat in gubcrnaculo domiua nostra Mntildie, jam nomine divulgato Regina, etsi nondum coronata." ' See vol. iii. p. 384. vor. IV, O •S TIIK KIKST HAYS oK WIIJ.IAMS HKIUN. iriL aiDOii? prinivly hi>ii)t^«. Mi]>]tlu>tl a iikkIcI fur lowlier homes lo t..il..\V. WiUiAm Hut )>«->i>l(-?> hiii own hoiitii>holil, IxniiileH Wm |HH)))le ut N(«mAA la>V^\ ^Vi^uln^ the champion of the Church, the Crunader Ckurrk. |^J||iI^gt the |R'rjuaHl bluiiphemer, the rciurmer of tlie corrupt maanerB of the Ix^ni^hteil iHlund, stood in a more din-ct and 8|K*cial relation to the eccle^iiuitii-al foundations uf his Duchy. lie haendert;nt." Mark the use of the word " moniisterium " (see vol. i. p. 472 ; ii. [»p. 249, 441) an applied to churches of both classes. ' lb. "NuUiuH umquam Regis aut Imperatoris largitatein in oblationi- buji majorem comjK'rimus." ' lb. " Item quas ecclesiaa non prsesenti^ suA, muneribus viaitavititerum." •*Itenini'' ina«t refer to the gifts sent now, as distinguished from those which bad l>c€n already sent from England in January. See above, p. 61. * See voL iii. p. 382. WILLIAM AND LANFRANC. 89 two men must have had other thou^-hts in their minds than chap. xvii. any that were likely to oecur to the minds of the mass of those who greeted the Conqueror on his return. To the shoutin)^ multitudes and to the rejoicing clerp^y the work no douht seemed to be done, when their Duke returned from his island warfare in the guise of a triumphant King". But both William and Lanfranc must have knouTi that the work was only be^^i-un, and that the real Conquest of Eng-land was still a thincf of the future. To Lanfranc the Conqueror might not scruple to reveal the secret that tlie seeming" King of the English was in truth King only over East-Anglia and part of Wessex. He had with him the Earls of the North and an Abbot of the West, but the West and the North were still wholly unsubdued. That York and Exeter would one day be his, no less than London autl Winchester, William could hardly doubt; but as to the way, the means, the time, of making his kingship a reality over the whole realm there was room for much of thought- ful consultation between the two subtle and daring minds which now again came together. And there was one point of still deeper personal moment to the Abbot of Saint Stephen's. William, we know, had, among the other objects of his undertaking, gone forth as a missionary to reform the corrupted Church of England. Tlie chief Prelate, in Presence of William and Lanfranc's eyes the intrusive Prelate, of that lanfranc corrupted Church, the Prelate already doomed in William's P^^'^^^y *■ '' nxed on as counsels, was now one of the most honoured among his succes- William's train, possibly a guest within the w\alls of Lanfranc's own Abbey. ^ Is it going too far to surmise ' Sec above, p. 78. William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 37) is emphatic on the honours pjiid to Stigand in Normandy ; " Inter qune difficile dictu est (juantis cum [Stigandum] exccperit officiis, dignanter ubicuinque loct)- runi assurgendo et contra eum in omnibus episcopatibus Nortnannia; et abbatiis long& serie pompse procedi faciendo." But ho adds pointedly, •* Sed quifbjuid his tegebntur involucris erupit in clanim, veniente Angliam Ermenfredo, Sedunense Episcopo, legato Alexandri Papa"." See Chapter xix. O 2 sor. 8« THK FIKST PAYS OF WIIJ.IAMS liKION. CMAT. ini. that, ilurini? Williuin'it U^ntni |ti)^riinii;^* to Cnon, it WM fully arrmn^Hl who nhouKl l>c tho next to fill the throne of Aii^utino, ami what Hhould Ikj thi» imlicy of the IVimuto who iihouKl utep into the phicc of tho ulrciuly coiuIoiiuuhI •thiiiinAtic? But of till this the writers of tho lime tositivc certainty lies on the surfa(x\ The unlinishcd minster, not to he hallowixl for another ten years,' was rising under the care MUluun't of it^ ^^reat Abbot. The jjifts of William to his own house at aunt were splendid. To all the churches which he visited he mapiMna. g^ye ctnitly vestments and ingots of gold ;'- would it be tx^o wild a flight of fancy to deem that for the church of Saint Stephen was reserved that mighty ingot of all which Harold Ilardradu had brought from the far East, and which had passetl from the hands of the victor of Stamfordbridge into the hands of the victor of Senlac ?^ However this may be, the choicest wealth of England was poured forth before the altar of the protomartyr. Men gazed with wonder upon Skill cf the the rich spoils of the conquered island. They might look in the art*, down on its inhabitants as barbarians ; they might scorn '^'la^ork ^^'^"^ ^ unskilled in the tactics of the horseman, as lagging Mid em- broiilefy. behind continental knds in the crafts of the scul])tor and the mason. But there were other arts, arts of skill and adornment, in which England and other Teutonic lands were allowed to outdo the nations of the Romance speech. The women of p]ngland were renowned for the art which had wrought the Raven on the banner of Ragnar and the Fighting-Man on the banner of Harold. And the same * See vol. iii. p, io8, ' Will. Pict. 154. " Qiiam pietatem ipse confestim lucro multiplici recom- pOBMTit, dotuinjt pallia, libraa auri, aliaque magna altaribua et famullB Chrirti." See above, p. 62. ' See vol. iii. p. 341. ENGLISH SKILL IN THK ARTS. 85 skill turned to more peaceful uses had adorned the gor- chap. xvii. geous vestments with which Ead<^yth had appeased the wrath of the saintly Albot of Saint Ili([uier.^ We have seen by what rich rewanls the knowle» « Htrikinff witni'sw, not only to the early do- ott n«i*t velo|)emcnt of the ornamental arlK in England and in the kindred laiuU, hut to the induoncc over men'n minds which woB i»till held hy the realms and eities which, fallen M they were from their ancient power, Btill kept up the unhroken traditions of elder days. Constantinople and BagtUd * — jx^rhap8 rather Constantinople and Cordova — were still looked up to as the special homes of all that was most nuigniticent u|K)n earth. The Greek and the Sanicen, the two nations which, if last in the race of political freedom, were foremost in the race of material civilization, were instinctively aj>pcaled to as the natural judges of all that was rich and splendid. High and strange in- deed was the calling of the Normans of those days. Tbo Nor- Tlie sovereign of Normandy was bringing the wealth |{^M«.i which Greeks and Saracens might wonder at from his conquered island in the Northern Ocean. Meanwhile other men of his own race were treading the path which was to had them to grasp the wealth of Greeks and Saracens in their own land. As AVilliam turned to his own ends the skill of the continental and the insular Teuton, so his countrymen were soon to turn the skill of Greek and Saracen to their ends, in that other island of hardly less renown which the Norman won as his home and kingdom in the southern sea. William Easter now drew nigh, and William had appointed E^^t^ ^ the festival to be kept in the ducal palace and monastery April 8 ^^ Fecamp.' This year no crowning feast, no national 1067. ' Will. Pict. 154, "Transirct iliac hoHpes Graccus aut Arabs, voluptate traheretur eAdem." * It Hbould ^»e remcmbcTcd that, in this age, Babylon means Bagdad. Two hundred years later it meant Cairo. ^ See vol. i. p. 380. ■ad in Skalj William's easter at fecamp. 87 Gemot, was held in the royal hall or in the QUI Min>tor chap. xvii. of Winehester. After his own Saint Stei)hen's, no ehureh in Normandy stood liicjlier in William's favour than the ^reat house of Uiehard the Fearless and Ilieliard the Good, lliat house was now flourishing^ under its second Abbot John, ^^'illiam's special friend and coun- sellor. * But of the mi<^hty pile which now com- Condition 11 r 1 1 ii r and hirttory mands the recamp valley, that huf]^e lenijth ot nave of the which almost rivals our own Saint Alban's, that central n^o^^sU-ry. tower so stately in its simple majesty, that Lady Chapel where the rich work of later days contrasts with the stem dig-nity of the thirteenth centur}', not a stone had yet arisen.- The monks of Fecamp stiil worshij)ped Secular in the elder church of Richard the Fearless. Tliat church founded by had been built for secular canons, who, under Richard the J{j^^'pe^*r- Good, the patron and father of monks,-* gave way to I^sh. recrulars from Saint Benifj-nus of Diion, that creat Bur- ,, , " ^^ J ' r> Monks pundian abbey which has become the cathedral church substituted of a modern diocese* Thence too came their first Abbot, ^^e Good. lOOI. * We shall see him in thi3 character in Chapter xix. ' Tl»e earliest part of the existiiij,' church is due to William of Ros, Abbot from 1087 to 1 107. See Ord. Vit. 832 A, who says of him, "Cancellum veteris ecclesise, quam Ricardus Dux construxerat, dejecit, et eximise pul- critudinis opere in melius renovavit, atquo in longitudine et latitudine decenter augmentavit. Navem quoque basilicce ubi oratorium Sancti Fffxlmundi habetur eleganter auxit, opusque tandem consunmiatum a Guillelmo Archiepiscopo aliisc|ue quatuor praesulibus xvii. Kal. Julii [1107] consecrari fecit." William, aumanied '• Bona-anima," was Archbishop of Rouen from 1079 to 11 10. Of the choir then consecrated one chapel re- mains in a very marked style of Romanesque, ' Add. ad Will, Gem., Duchbsne, 316 C, " Do Richanhi fdio priini Richardi dicitur, quod fuerat pater patriae et maximi monachorum," See vol, ii, p, 223, * When I spoke of Ft'camp in connexion with Richard the Fearlens (vol. i. p, 2R0) I did not accurately distinguish between his first foundation, for secular canons, and the change to regidars which was afterwards designed by him and carried out by Richard the Good. Tlie mistake was, I hope, a pardonable one, considering that William of Malnie.sbury (ii. 165), when Hp«.'aking of Richard the Fearle.ss, says, " Fiscannum cundcr8 of the church were buried, neither within nor without the pile which they had reared and en- riched.* There too its second founder loved to keep the highest of the Church's festivals, and to honour rather than to abase himself by jierforming menial services HiilMfliAl to the holy inmates.^ In later days the house of the two with the Richards became the special home of those among their P"*^ descendants who embraced the monastic life. There the boiMe. Abbatem DinonenRem innigniverat." See the whole history in Neustria PiA, 210 ft seqq. ; De Lincy, Essai Historique et Littt-raire 8ur I'Abhaye de Fi*camp (Rouen, 1840), pp. 7 et Heqq., 244 et seqq. Iinleed I ought to have found out the change from Wace, who first (5873), Hj^eaking of the foundation of Richard the Fearless, says, "Clers establi ki servireient, E provendes dunt il vivreient." But afterwards (5945 et seqq.) he goes on to tell about Abbot William and the monks coming from Dijon. ' For his history see the Chronicle of Saint Benignus in D'Achery, ii. 381, 386 ; of. Mabillon, Analecta, i. 229. ' So says the local Chronicle in De Lincy, p. 245, but was it according to Canon Law for a man and his wife to be sponsors to the same child ? ' Neustria Pia, p. 213. • The whole legend is treated at length by M. De Lincy, p, 79 et seqq. He connects it with the story of the Saint Graal. • See the story in Dudo, 156 D ; Palgrave, ii. 903. • See Add. ad Will. Gem., Duchesne, 317 A. HISTORY OF FECAMP. 89 unhappy Malp^er liad passed his youthlul years,' and there chap. xvii. too dwelt i>erhaps the only members of the ducal house whose names are never mentioned in connexion with political strife, William the son of Richard the Gootl,- and Nicolas, the son of the third Richard, who left his cell at Fecamp to receive the ahbatial staff of Saint Ouen.-^ There the youn^;' and pious Mar<>aret, the last scion of the house of Maine, had found her g-rave, when she had escaped from the fear of earthly wedlock to the presence of a heavenly Bridegroom.'* Tlie reigning Abbot Abbot John, of Jjombard birth like his predecessor, had now 1031-1082. presided over the house for six and thirty years. He had received the second profession of Maurilius, the Primate who still for a short time longer filled the metropolitan throne of Rouen. ^ He had crossed the sea to set what Gifts of pi , . he might at the hands of Eadward ; the bountiful King to Ftcamp. had granted to his house a prospective interest in the lord- j|'"ji«^'*ed ship of Steyning in the South-Saxon land, but Godwine, wine ; not coveting the presence of strangers in his own special shire, had managed to convert the estate to his own use. Harold had been less austere or less grasping ; he had not restored Ste}Tiing, but he had allowed the church of Fecamp to obtain other possessions in England. William, before he crossed the sea, had promised the confirmed restoration of the disputed lands, and the promise had been carried out in a charter granted by the new King, which most likely formed part of his oblations at the present Paschal feast.'^ In no part of William's dominions Zeal of the had he been more loyally served than within the monastic monks for walls of Fecamp. One monk of Fecamp, Hugh Margot, ^^^^^•'^"^• ' See vol. ii. p. a 10 ; iii. p. 93. ' Will. Gem. v. 13. ^ See vol. i. p. 518 ; iii. p. 380. * See vol. iii. p. 213. ' See vol. iii. p. 100. • On Steyning and the other English possessions of Ftcanij), see Cod. Dipl. iv. 329; Neustria Pia, 233. I have enlarged on the subject in an Appendix (Note C.) to the second edition of my second volume. so THE riHSrr DAYS OF WILLIAM 8 KKIQN. .MAI- trtt. had borna WillbmV ini^vKapni of^ramin^^ niul (K>rinnc*o to hii ri\*nl.' Anothor. the almoiuT lUmifjiiiH, hml ^vcn n wolU ji*.4jjmM nhip to »hnre in tho voyn^* fixmi Saint Valery to PrsMi-. \.- The liouH*» itwlf, luul ttiptviftlly this lat»U nnnunl /«..!.- iiuihUt of tlic Iioubo, were now U) reap their reward. The EoKter Feast at Fdeamp was attendetl by a pomimnv of variuUH nation8. Tlic knii^htK and Boldiers of William *H army followed him thither, and a vast crowd I N • of all orders came togt»ther to meet him. Tlie Bishops , , ' and Ahhots of Normandy were there, and a ]ar^» Ixxly of the noMes of France. Foremost amonp^ these last was one who had preatlv risen in renown and worldly rank p-i^.h „f since we last heanl of him. iluli)h of Montdidier, onc<» the lord and the captive of Rotifer of Mortcmer/* had risen to be a mi^-hty Count, lord of Valois and Amiens 1..* in;\r and of the French Vexin.' He had, five years before, K^n-*'' aLrainst the will of the young" Kin^ Philip and of his H.t.rvV o^imrilian the Marquess l^aldwin, married the Russian io6i. princess Anne or Adelaide or Agnes, the widowwl mother of the Kinp;*. Either on the p^round of kindred between Ralph and her former husband or on that of the existence of an earlier Countess, the marriani-c was loudly denounced, and Ralj)h underwent more than one excommunica- tion.* A princess broui>ht up in Eastern Orthodoxy may perhaps have felt but little dread of Western ana- themas, and William, with all his piety, may have felt some lurkin<^ symj)athy for those who had drawn on * Sec %ol. iii. p. 431. » See vol. iii. p. 380. * Sec vol. iii. j)p. 145, 157. * Will. Pict. 156. "Regis Frnncorum vitricus intererat hujus curiae, Rodolphtu prappotens ComeH, mult.V|ue nobilita-s Francise." * Chron. 8. Petri Vivi Scnon. 1060 (ap. D'Achery, ii. 476). "Rodulfus Comet conaangtiineus ejuiideTn Regis duxit uxorem in conjugio contra ju* et flu, unde fiiit excommunicatus." See Art de Verifier les Dates, ii 701. \ . .. M M- 1 i:. r THE ENGLISH VISITORS. 91 themselves the censures of the Cliiirch for thib particular chap. xvn. cause. At all eventtj the excommunicated Count was received with all honour at the festival at Fecamp, and, as we are told that \\'illiam exacted strict attendance at divine service from all his company,* we must infer that the assembled Prelates of Normandy did not shrink tVoni his spiritual society. But chief among" the giiests The Eng- of the Kinj^-Duke were the companions, the hostages, whom he had brought with him from his island realm. To Eadgar, the momentary King, brought as a child from Hungary to England, a visit to Normandy was but a small episode in a life of wanderings. Eadwine and Morkere may possibly have been visiting the native land of their own mother.- But Waltheof the son of Siward, whose not remote forefather was held to have been a bear in a Norwegian forest,^ was treading a land which his kindred had certainly never visited in any peaceful guise. Amid the splendours of the Easter feast the Abbot of Glas- tonbury might compare the church of Duke llichard with his ON\Ti church reared by the great Dunstan, and with that prima)val temple of wood which still lingered on from the days of the conquered Briton."* The older and wi-sur among the English visitors, the Primate above all, might see through the hollowness of the honours which were everywhere shown to themselves and their country- men. But outwardly at least all was joy and festivity. The English visitors were the objects of universal at- Norman tention, of universal admiration. The outward attrac- '^f 'Ji|[.'^ ^^^ tions of our countrymen IkkI not lessened since Gregory English, liad beheld the angelic children of Deira in the Roman slave-market. The beauty of the English youth, the ' Will. Pict. 155. '* Huinilitcr adstana ilK- clioris onlinum religiosorum, ludicra intcnuittcre, concurrero ad divina, militum pli'bi««jue turlias coegit." * See vol. ii. p. 629 ; iii. p. 699. ' See vol. i. p. 586. * See vol. i. p. 486. 91 TIIK FIRST DAYS OF WILLIAMS IlKinN. . ini. loog^luurtHi chiUlrrn of I In* North, rivet tiil tin* cyvn of tho okito ihorn Normnn*.* And the wealth of Kn^lnnd nji^iin cUzzM all pyw at KtVamp, as at every other Ht«j^» of \\ Iiaiii'h Noriimn |m>jfre««. Tlie rol>c« of state of the ^PM^^ Kinff and \m chief nobles, rich with the ernhnmlery of poll! wrought by Eni^flish handH, mad<» all that Fnincc and Normandy had U'lield of the name kind seem mean by comi»ariii<»n.^ At Wiiliam's Paschal feast the whole comimny, we are told, ilnink out of the siwils of En^-land, cupe of gold and silver, in miniber and ^oodliness such a^ no man had seen Wfore, cups too made of the horns of the %vild hull of the English woods, and tipped at either end with the same costly metals.' The fame of the King of the English and of the wealth and splendour of his Kingdom was soon spread abroad through every land/ As soon as the Easter Feast was over, a whole round of ecclesiastical ceremonies and ecclesiastical cares pressed upon the mind of AVilliam. As not uncommonly happened,'* several great monastic churches, which had probably been finished some while before, were still waiting for consecration. The piety of the Duke demanded that the ceremony should be no longer delayed. The feast of Saint Philip and Saint James was fixed by his bidding ' Will. Pict. 156. " Curiose hi cum Nonn.annis ccrnebant crinigeros alumnofi plage aquilonaliii, quorum pulcritudini Galliae Comatae furmo- UMuni juvenes inviderent. Nee enim puellari venustati codebant." The introfluction of Gallia Comata is happier than most of the Archdeacon's cUnical flourishes. ' lb. " Regiii autem regiorumque satellitum indumenta spectantes intexta atque cnistata auro, quseque antea viderant vilia aestimavere." * lb. •* Item vaaa argentea sive aurea aatherin«> of men of all ranks, to whom certain decrees which the Duke had made for the good of his whole people were announced by the voice of the herald.** Of this legislation, whatever was its nature and oljject, we should gladly learn some further details. A day two months Consecra- later was devoti'd to a still greater ceremony of the same jumi^fres. kind, the hallowing of a minster of still higher renown, "^^^ ^• one which still remains, though unhappily in ruins, to bear witness to the arts of those days and of days far earlier still.' Tlie church of Jumieges had been begun. The church seven and twenty years before, by that Abbot Robert 1040-1058. whom the blind favour of Eadward had successively thrust into the episcopal chairs of London and Canterbury, and ' OrJ. Vit. 507 A. " Celebratjl Paschae sollennitate, Rex detlicari haHilicam Sanctse Mariee super Divam preecepit." See Neustria Pia, p. 498. ' See vol. iii, pp. 1 1 7, 153. ' Ord. Vit. 507 A. " Utramque [Dives and Jiimitgea] nimirum ex prte- diifl dominii Hui larj,Mter dotavit, Hu.1<|ue priesonti.l, dum sanctum niysteriuui lelelmirctur, devote suhlimavit." ' Ih. " Ipse cum mogno ocetu optimatum et mediocrium Kal. Maii revtruntcT interfuit, et utillima totiua populi commoditati edicta 8ub voce prseconia promulgavit." * The exlMtence at work of Merowingian daya in the earlier and smaller church at Jumit-gen haa been satisfactorily proved by M. Bouet. u TUB FIRilT DAYS OF WILLIAMS KKKJN. DMlhof Arch- bubop Mauriliua AttgUkt 9. iTit. whom the indifnuiiit vo'xoc of the J-lnj^linli iH-oplo bml ciriven trom the otluv in which ho hntl uuu\v himself th<» nK)t of all cTil.* H4iU'rt was nowdrnd. niul ho hml U'cn hiiriiHl in the churt'h of hiii own n^nrinj*', hut the conwomtin)^ rit45 ha«l been dehiyi'tl thn>u^h tlie incumhoncios of two AhUita, (lotlfrcy, the imnu'olitan throne of Normandy was again vacant.^ In the search for a successor the claims of one • See vol. ii. pp. 70, 120, 331, 335, 341. * See Neustria Pia, 309. ' Onleric (507 A) a^^'ain uses the same expreBsion, " Kal. Julii ecclesiain Sanctte Mariae apud Gemineticum dedicari praecepit, et ipse sacro mysterio venentnter adfuit." So William of Jirniieges (vii. 38), " PauUo post in Normanniam regreRHus, cccleaiam Sanctse Mariee in Gemmetico cum honore magno dedicari juBftit." • Orderic (u. a.) sajT*, "Maurilius cum Huffraganeis epiHCopis banc dedi- OtJoPem humiliter et devote perpetravit." But William of Jumieges (a. a.) meDtiona only Maurilius himself and Baldwin, Bishop of Evreux (1067 to 107 1). See Bessin, Cone. Kot. Prov. 374, • Ortl. Vit. 507 A, B. " Paullo post, duodecimo episcopatus sui anno, LANPRANC REFUSES THE SEE OF ROUEN. 95 man stood forth beyond all comparison. Then* was one ciiai-. xvii. Prelate in Normandy who towered, as no Prelate had ever towered bel'ore, over the whole Church of the Duchy. Lanfranc, Abbot of Saint Stephen's, was called Unani- by every voice to fdl the hij^hest spiritual place in his eketion of adopted country. The process of his election reads as if ^"f'^°c- it were copied from our own side of the water in the days of Eadward. The church of Rouen chose Lanfranc as Archbishop by a canonical- election ; the Duke, the nobles, and the whole people of Normandy — we seem to be reading- the acts of EnmenHem, quani invitus susceperat, libentor dinussisset, si extra aniujie la-'sionem gravem facero valuisset." William of Jumi^gea mentions th«' ap)H>intment of John without mentioning the offer to Lanfratic. M TIIR FinST PAYS OP WILLIAM R RKIOK, GMAT. im. doubt Icfs f*irrn in p»

i)tirinntinn \\n» ^'iven only on tlio nndenttndin^ that tho IVinmcy of Rouen wouhl ho dcclimxl by the man who was aln»a(ly deni^ntHl for the Primacv of Cantorbiirv. On I>iinfranc'8 refusal, the Diftliop <»f Avranchet*, his favourito and ointment of Odo, and had proved himself a troublesome kinsman and subject to William's father Robert.^ In these two Prelates the male line of Asperlenpf and Sprota came to an end, but the stock was continued in females. Hug-h of Mont fort, who now held the command at Dover, was married to a niece of the new Primate,-^ and the more famous William Fitz-Osbern was the son of his sister.^ Archbishop John was a rigid asserter of eccle- Lanfmnc siastical discipline. In order to put his appointment R^mff to beyond all cavil, an embassy was at once despatched to pJuum fur ^™^ *^ obtain the pallium for the new Primate, a step John. which is spoken of as if it were at once praiseworthy ' Ord. Vit 507 C ; Will. Gem. vii. 38. The latter writer goes on to give the whole hixtory and pedigree of Rudolf and his descendants, including hi« killing a l>ear in the days of Richard the Fearless, The tale is trans* lat^l by lienoit (38071 et seqq). On Rudolf's suppression of the peasant rc-vult, »ee vol. i. p. 284. • See voL i. p. 518. Hugh must surely have been very much older than John. His episcopate and that of Odo fill up between them the almost un- pandleleth rcpiilnrH and Bocnhirrt n|fiiinst him. Ho WW HUcxtHHlwl in tho w»o of Avmnihtti hy nn Italian lUinKHl Mit'hnol, whoso Itariiiii^ and j>ioty aro hij^hly lfkhtt»l. ii|H>kon of.' Hon* wo have anothor inslAncM; of the AviMkelMa di»ot*rninj»' patronagt; which William wiw roady to extend io67*io8;. ^p IjqjIj gido« of the sea to worthy men of any 8i)eoch or any eountiy exoept the proscriluil nativ»«s of England/* TlioA* ecclesiastical cares and utlicr i>oacc'i'ul duties occu- ditionof picd William during the whole summer and autumn. ^' Normandy is, as usual, described — and probably described with truth — as rejoicincni J»>lmiinoin Kothoniagcnseiu Archiepiscopuin, inisHain cele- bnuitetu in frstivitate ejutwlem sancti, cum armata manu virorum. Undo judicntuni eBt in concilio in c^deni civitate congregate, |»ru'Hid<,'nto Kego Anglonim Willelmo, inonachos luijua criniiniH nos [»er abb.itiaH carceriljuii retnidi ad placitum Archiepiscopi." ' Ord. Vit, 507 D. " Michael, natione Italiciw, eruditione literarura imItutuH, Htudio religioniB venerandus/' ' Will. Malms. Gest. Reg. iii. 240. *' In locum illorum qui morcrentur, cujuHcumqae gentia industriam, praeter Angligenara, imposuit. Exigelmt hoc, ni fallor, indurata in Regem pervicacia ; quum Hint Normanui . . in conviventea advenaw naturali benignitate proclives." * OnL Vit. 509 B. ** WillelmuB Rex, dum moraretur in Normannifl, tran- quillitati ejus in longum prospiciebat BoUicitudiue maxim.l. Justas leges et rt-cta juriately when describing the gooU. ('IIapti:h wiif. TIIR CONQVEST OP WK9TERN AND NORTHERN ENGLAND.' March 1067— April 1070. A^'^E have now readied a stage in our history in which » ^ it is of uiKX-ial moment to bear in mind the peculiar nature of AVilliam*s position as I have already set it forth. William had taken seizin of his King-dom on the shore • In the course of thin Chapter wc lo«e the help of WilliAm of Poitiers, whose work, M we hftve it, suddenly breaks off soon after William's return lo Enis'lAnd. He seems however to liavu brought hifl »tory to a good epic finish at the point when William's power waa really eatabliahed throughout the country (nee Ord. Vit. 521 C). The substance of the latter part of his work is preserved to us by Orderic, whose own value aLio is constantly increasing. As the affairs of Northumberland are now of great moment, it is a great advantage to have the important insertions in the text of Florence which have been hitherto attributed to Simeon of Durham, but which have been lately subjected to a Hearching examination by a most cunij)etent Xorthumbri;in critic, with whone writings I am sorry that I did not become sooner acquainted. Mr. J. H. Hinde, in his History of North- humberland — a book which is a model of what local histories should Ixj, but what they very seldom are — and again in hia Preface to the edition of Simeon of Durham published by the Surtees Society, argues that these insertions are not the work of Simeon, but of some unknown monk of Hexham, writing after the Scottish inn>ad in the time of David. The chief argument is the occasional contradictions, real or apparent, between these insertions and the Hi.story of the Church of Durham i)rinted in the Decern Scriptores, which Mr. Hinde strongly maintains to be the work of Simeon, in opposition to the view which has aswigned it to Turgot. I con- fess that, whether the author be Simeon or any one else, and whether he wrote at Durham or at Hexham, I set great store by a work which in any case is Florence aossession of many shires of En«^land, and he held in his power such amonfj the chiefs of the rest of the land as seemed likely to en- dan«^er his dominion. lie had now to esta]>lish his power A large over those parts of En«^land where he was King only so ['^e ianlr for liiin to dwell exrlufttvoly in inthor, oiu! it wiu» iloubllfHH j^mhI |K)lit'y to vuit NomiAiitly at thin ]uirticulnr moment. His ]>o))U- Urity in hi« uativo Duoliy munt now have been at itn ven* hi^iMt, but anythin;^ which couUl bo conetnicil an ncf^ect of hin own hnul ami ]>e(>|)lc mi^ht have catted that |>»»pularity to cool an it had warnutl. The viHJt to Normaiiily, the Easter-FeoMt at FcVainj>, the ctTemoiiii'H at Jumi^ges and on the Dive, were all hj^^'Hs that the Kin^ (»f the En^'lish was not imfl'iil up by his new great- ue«8. but that he was tjtill the Duke of the Normans, loving his own land, labourin^jf for its welfare, showing Mil »h- honour to its holy men and its holy places. And as his presence in Normandy was certainly ])olitic, his absence from England may have been politic also. It was doubt- *^ less meant to be taken as a sign of confidence in his new in tb« EnglUh. subjects. King AVilliam, a righteous and merciful King, had dealt in all gentleness and tenderness with a people of whom well nigh every man was entangled in the guilt of treason. He had shown favour and honour to all who had not personally sinned against him ; the noblest men of England had been chosen as his companions in his voyage, and they were now the objects of wonder and admiration to his subjects beyond the sea. A Conqueror who had shed no blood except in battle,^ who had seized no man's lands or goods save with every legal formality, might affect to trust himself to the good will of his new subjects, and might profess to deem that his actual presence was not r ..'1;- needed to secure their obedience. In his own heart he , ^, may not have been sorry to put their obedience to the test, ^ * to see w^hat his chances really were of retaining the part of the land which he had already won, and of winning * UnlcM we except the probable executions at Romney (see vol. iii. p. 5 '4^, and these were, after all, a military operation while the war Htill Uated. King William had certainly not j»ut any man to death. MOTIVES OP WILLIAMS AB.SENCE FROM ENGLAND. 103 the rest to a more than nominal subjection. This policy chap.xvui. enabled him directly to prove the disposition of the peoj)le at large. The shires which had submitted were free from the terror of his own presence, and the presence in his train of the Earls of northern and centnil Kn<^land left the still independent districts to their own devices. I do not l>elieve for a moment that William purposely l)ut Kni^land into the hands of oi)pressive lieutenants, in order that the people might be goaded into revolt. But it is not unlikelv that he mav have wished to brinfj matters to an issue and to learn what the temper of the nation really was. It is possible that he was not sorry when an imperfect and unsatisfactory state of things was put an end to by the act of others, when he fuund that, ii' he meant to be King at all, he must go on with the work of conquest. The same kind of feeling may have Reasons for led him not to hurry back at once on the first news of hia^retiSn disaffection. Haste would have implied fear. It would rather suit his purpose to deal with the isolated movements which took place during his absence as trifles which his lieutenants could easily put down, even if they were not put down by the loyal English themselves. It was only William when he found that the disaffected were intri^^uin^ for f^^^,^/^ ^^^^ o => by the foreign help, that there was a chance of his having to prospect of forei^ struggle for his Crown against Swend of Denmark or invasiou. some other foreign King, that William thouglit that the time was come to return to England with all speed. § 1. The Administration of Odo and Jlitliam Fitz-Osbern. March — Bccemher, 1067. The new Earls of Kent and Hereford, Bishop Odo .T„int com- of Baycux and William Fitz-Osbern, had been left, as we "),'f"\^,^,i have seen, in a joint general command in England. The ^^ '!•'""» Bishop was charged with the si)ecial care of the South, the OHhcm. 1in NorthumlH^rlaml and the htill ui»sii!m1iio<1 \\tiriA of Morcin.' Of the charart«T of tlioir admiinstration the Norman pane- gyric, of William g-ivoe a jjlowin^ picture. Tliey were modclii of loyalty towardn their master, of harmony towards one another, and of just government towanls those over whom they were set. Their example in all these respects wa** carefully followed hy the subordinate conmianders of the castles, whose huildinp;', in conformity with William's partin^i; orders,* they were diligently pressing on.^ The native Chronicler has another tale to tell. From him we learn how Odo Bishop and William Earl staye^l in the land, and wrought castles wide among the people, and oppressed the poor folk, and how evil grew ever after.* Here is another si>eaking witness to the horror with which our fathers looked on the fortresses, the special badges of foreign rule, which were fast rising among them. And I think that we may see that a distinction is drawn between the nde of William himself and the rule of his oppres- sive lieutenants. At all events, the record, or rather the wail, of the native writer is more than borne out by the elaborate picture drawn l)y our one authority who is English, French, and Norman all at once. And in his * See above, p. 72. ^ See above, p. 73. ' Will, Pict. 157, ** Mutuo sese, Regem aequaliter, diligel^ant; affectu ardelHint pari ad continendum in pace gentem Christianam ; con«ilio alter altcriufl axjuanimiter aKsentieb.intur, /Eqiiit;ito utcbantur niaxinia, iiti Rex pnemonuerat, qua honiincH efferi et iniinici corrigerentur et benevoli ficrent. Item prsefecti minores, ubi quisque in munitionibus locatus fuerat, Btrenuo curabat." * (liron. Wi,'. 10O6. "Ami Oda Biscop and Wyllelin Eorl belifcn her Wther [alVr King William's departure for Normandy], and worhton caMclas vide geond \hu \>eodt, and earm folc exccncte, and a sylJOan bit yflade 8wi"5e. WurfJo god Be ende Iwnne God wylle.** The words in Italics are nearly the same as the Peterborough writer's description of William himself; "CantelaM he let wyrcean and earme men swiSe swencean." See vol. ii. pp. 138, 192. ODO AND WILLIAM FITZ-OSBEKN. 106 version also the distinction between William and his un- cnAP.xvm. worthy representiitives is plainly drawn. The two haii«>hty Oppreiwivo chiefs whom he had h-fl in command despised his orders, nient of and laid every kind of oppression on the people. The ^viUia" Eng-lish were insulted hy the pride of the Normans. Their ^'>^^- « , • 1 Oabem. property and the honour of their women lay open to the attacks of the followers of the two viceroys, and no redress could be had from Earl or Bishop for any wrong" that an Eng-lishman suffered ; if an injured man dared to bring* a complaint before them, he was driven from the judge- ment-seat with scorn.' We must remember that the excesses here complained of were not the momentary ex- cesses of soldiers whose blood is roused by the excitement of a battle or a storm. The land was now, at least nomi- nally, at peace, and the oppression here described is the wearing, grinding, daily oppression of unrig-hteous rulers in time of peace. And the evils spoken of were just the Amount evils which it was William's own great object, both in KinA Normandy and in Enfjland, to put down. Wlierever °^" ^.®* liis personal authority was peaceably established, he had bility. no mercy for the robber or the ravisher.^ We may fully acquit William of any personal share in the evil deeds ' Ord, Vit. 507 D. " Interea Normannico fastu Angli opprimuntur, et pnesjidibus superbis, qui Regis nionitus spernebant, admodum injuria- bantur Odo nimiruia Epi.scopus et Guilielinus Osberni filius nimiii cervicositate tuinebant, et clamores Anglorum rationabiliter audire, cisque squitatis lance suffragari despiciebant. Nam amiigeros suos immodica-s praedas et incestoa raptus facientes vi tuebantur, et super eos qui contu- nieliis affecti querimonias agebant, magis dubacchabantur." This account of Orderic is very remarkable, because in this part of his work he is, in hia main facts, following William of Poitiers. But he here deliberately leaves out William's patiegyric on the two Earls and puts this widely different description of tliem instead. The passage has the same kind of value as the controversial passages of Florence (see vol. ii. p. 607 ; iii. p. 578), or a.s the places where Matthew Piiris, following the narrative of Roger of Wendover, changes the political colouring. ' S«c the famous character in the Peterborough Chronicle, 1087, and vol. ii. p. 173. 100 cuNgt*K8T or wsartRK and nokthkkn knoland. ourjiYnt. of Odo and hui fellow- viceroy ; his Mlian; in tho hlaroe in tlwt of not Mvin^ how utterly unfit hin brother nnd his dearr»t friend were for the trunt which ho phiotnl in them. Yet |M»rhaps no fitter (h'puties could he fuuiul. As throujfhout tlie whoh» Htx)r}', wronp was it8 own punishment. The oripnal sin of an unjust enterpri»c drove WiUiani a^iinst his will tn become a tyrant and a favourer of les»f iq*,*!*^ ' "' the Tyne, the new Earl was feasting in a place called Newhurn. Then followed a scene to which we find several parallels in Northumbrian history. The partizans of Oswulf beset the house where Copsige was ; he contrived to slip out secretly and to seek refuge in a neighbouring church. Rut his lurking-place was soon betrayed ; the church was set on fire ; the Earl, to escape the flames, tried to make his way out by the door, and was cut down on the threshold by the hands of Oswulf himself.^ The victor in this struggle, a scuffle rather than a battle, again took possession of the Earldom, and held it for a few months. By the Norman writers Copsigc, or, as they call him, Norman Coxo '', is held up to honour as the martyr of his loyalty to cJpsige. the Norman King, and they are not sparing of the praises whicli, according to their views, were due to the one Englishman whom William found thoroughly faithful.^ In ' Sim. Dun. CJcst. Reg. 1072, p. 91, ed. Ilinde. "Pulsus a Copaio de comitatu Osulfua." ' lb. " 0:julfu8 in fame et egcstate silvis latitana et raontibus, tandem collect 8 quo.s cadem nece.sditas compulerat sociid, Copsium in Xywoburne convivantem concludit." * lb. (ji. "QuintA hcbdomada commisai sibi comitatAs iiii. Idus Martii." * lb. "Qui [Copsiua] inter tumultuantcn tiirbaa Inpsu.s dum lateret in occle?>ia proditiis, incendio eccleaia) compellitur usque atl ostium procedere, ubi ill ipso ostio manibus Osulfi dttruncatur." * See vol. ii. p. 484. * Will. Pict. 158. " Sed ubi mentcm finniter in tenoro boni fiiani talit-.T dinioverc ncqucunt, comprovincialea ad invidiam concitavere, quam 10$ CX)XgUE8T OF WK8TKHN AND NOKTIIKUN KNQLAND. cnAr.tvm. Kn^linh raw. whether tlion or in»\\ , Mich pmijM»mipfht iH>rha|)t CoMtft'a iound like u eharpi* of the divpt^Ht trciittnn. What (\))>Hi^t> {|iyj^ w*cm« to liavo th>no was to um* the name of the Norman Kinff at a mennn to enrry out n i>en»onal selu-me, most like to carry out a Northumbrian deadly feud. His act was an attempt *h1 U'trayal of the country into the hands of an invader who hnd ns yet not venture"land Otbam- which were caused by the oppressions of Odo and William Fitz-Osbern. Of the general discontent at their adminis- tration, and of the outbreaks to which that discontent giivc rise, we have accounts which enter a good deal into detail, but it is not easy to fix the exact order of events. But the g-eneral indignation of the people, and their readiness to seek for foreign help in any quarter, are plainly shown on Outbreaks all sidcs. And it is plain also that the two most formidable fordahire Outbreaks took place in the districts immediately subject to and Kent ^jjg ^^^ Earls, in Herefordshire and in Kent. Under the poMibij immediate eye of the two viceroys oppression ought to have S^*dil° ^° ^^^^ flagrant than in other places ; but with rulers tricu. who systematically refused to listen to the complaints of the oppressed, it is possible that the grievances in the near neighbourhood of head-quarters may have been even greater io placartt ah Rege deficiendo. Postremo augeecente in dies malevolentia ipsorum, quum ille popularium odia, omnemque injuriam perpeti, quam integritatem fidei temerare mallet, per insidias oppres.sum interfccerc. Ita eximius vir suo caau quod majeHtas domini sui stare deberet asseruit." OUTBREAK IX HFKEFORDSHIRE. 109 than elsewhere. A local commander, j)erhai>s of no p^reat chap.xviii. consideration in his own country, but who found his eervices at Senlac rewardeil with an I*]n<^lish estate and sometimes with an En^^lish wife, mi^ht, from the very beirinnin"-, be more inclined to identify himself with his new country than men of such hi<^h j)laee in their own land as the Bishop of Bayeux and the Seneschal of Nonnandy. Kent and Herefordshire were moreover the Foreign two ends of William's real dominion, and they were the ea«ily districts where foreiijn aid mi^-ht most easily be found, [y""*^ ^ '^ •' there. Kent lay open to help from any enemies of William who mig-ht be found beyond the sea, and on the Herefordshire Readineas border the Welsh were always ready to step in on any welsh to pretext which promised a chance of fighting* and plunder. J*^'"'"^*"^ We have seen that the old alliance between /Elfgar and quarrel. GrufTydd had caused Eadwine to be accompanied by Welsh followers on his march to Northampton.^ That alliance was doubtless still remembered. On the other hand, the reigning princes, Bleddyn and Rhiwallon^ had received their king-ship at the hands of Harold and had become his men.' They had therefore, if they chose, a fair right to give themselves out as his avengers or as assertors of the rights of his house. When English plunder was to be had, kinsmen and followers both of the Northern and of the Southern GrufTydd would be ready to answer either call, llie unhapi)y thing was that, in those times, a movement for the deliverance of any district too often took the form of a general harrying of that district by friends and enemies alike. So it now was in Herefordshire. Tlie land had not yet recovered, it had not fully recovered twenty years after, from the wasting warfare of Gruflydd the son of Llywelyn.'* It was now to be wasted again. The most ])owerful, at any rate the most enterprising, Englishman ' See vol. ii. p. 490. ' See vol. ii. j>. 476. ' See vol. ii. p. 388. no i^i'NgrtST <»K WK^'^TKKN AND NOUTIIRKN KXOLANI). cMArinti of th«»»c |v,irtj« wn^s Hiulrir, of whom wo Imve alrwiily £/waa ^**^'^^-* ''** ^»»''*J InmU \hA\\ in the north of llonford- maiaut— shirt* and in Shn>p»*hin'. and ho lind n'futkxl all suhiniKsion to the ntw Kin;;:. Horo thon, ri^ht in the tooth of the new luirl (»r Ilorofonl, ri^lit in tlio tooth of the old enemies, Uiohard tho Bon of Sor(»l> and hib son Oxboni, Uy «n outlvinj^ j>itHH? of indo|HMidont Kn*;land which still ni»ctU»d to bo oonre8on(ativo9 of Nornian nilo in tho district wore slow to a^*t in such a iajM». ""JJ"*" The gurrijjons of !>oth fortresses, of Richard's Castle and Wm. of the (^stlc of Hereford, niado constant inroads on the lands of the rofnu'torv l«jidric. Tho Kn^^lish Thof^n and his f(»ll<>wors. and whoever cls(» may have joined him, stood nmnfiilly on their dofonce, and every Norman incursion was He Wttf^MB beaten }»ack with loss on the ]iart of tho invaders.^ At last, civn anc! ^^ ^^^^* month of Au^^ust, the En£;"lish chief ventured on re- Hhi«*llon, pj.ijjjj]g u^. formed an alliance with the two Welsh KincB, and hxTTivm * ^ ' •jtfATM and their combine" of .... , , Hereford. years lonj^er. The impression which he made on the ., , . Xormans is 8ho>\ii by the surname of the AVild or Savag-e maini un- Winch he bore among- them.'- Among the hills and woods io6--io6y. of the border land, Eadric and his British allies could maintain themselves as easily against the Norman chivalry as Grutlydd had done against the Eng-lish Housecarls, till the g-enius of Harold found out the way to bring the rest- less enemy to submission. * This contest in Herefordshire was strictly a local war. Difference It was an attempt, and an unsuccessful attempt, on the ^1,^ H^.re. part of the invaders to subdue a district, however small, f'^^'^^jy^^ ' and Kent- wliich had never submitted to William's authority. The inl' ^'ut- outbreak in Kent, a shire where William's authority was fully established, was of course strictly a revolt. In the Herefordshire case, the strangers had simply to be kept out ; in the Kentish case, they had to be driven out. It may possibly be owing to this difference that the ex- })loits of Eadric are recorded by the English wTiters only, while the movement in Kent is narrated at some length by our Norman informants, but is wholly passed by in the national Chronicles. The attempt at deliverance in Kent was certainly planned with very little regard to its chance of success and with still less regard to the national honour. The Kentishmen sought for foreign help, but they sought it in a very different quarter from that in which it was sought by Eadric. However practically dangerous might be the presence of Bleddyn and Rhiwallon on * Chron. Wig. 1067. " And Ea N(»UTIIKI:N KN(JLAM). aur.STut. Kn^^liiih gruiind, no fi»riniil treason to\viinl« Kn^laiul ua** im- pliixi in an nllianct* with rnili*r-kin^ of tin* Kii^Iinh Knipiro agminit »tmn^*rK who thrt^nti'mnl Hriton and Ilii^'-lihhinan TWXMit- alike. Hut the Kentish insur^ntj^ Miti^ht for help at the li^of liauilrt of a fctraii^^T who haetter, when the men of Kent sent to a^k for the help of Eustace of IJoulog-ne in an attack on the castle of Dover. The man whose crime had been the be^-innin^ of evils, the man who had slaughtered the bur<^hers of Dover in their streets and in their houses/ the man whose one exploit in the great battle had been to wreak a coward's spite on the corpse of the dead Harold,'^ was now called on to help to rid Dover of its Norman lords and to join in the sieg-c of the fortress which Harold himself had reared. Perha})s, ii' we minutely study the story, we may see signs that the iu\ntation was not shared in by the men of Dover itself, but it is plain that the men of the shire in general clutched OLjecu of eagerly even at so feeble a chance of help as this. What yon. ^^'c object proposed by such an invitation could be is not clear ; it was probably an act done in the mere frenzy of despair, w^ithout any rational reckoning of what was likely to come of it. We are told that the English, unable to have a native ruler, preferred one who was at least their neighbour and known to them." It is possible that some vague sentimental feeling may have attached to the son-in- law of iEthelred ;■• otherwise one would have thought that ' See voL ii. pp. 131-133. ' See vol. iii. p. 499. ' Will. Pict. 157. "Si erat serviendum non compatriotee, note servire atque vicino gatiuH putabant." * See vol. ii. p. 131. THE KENTISIIMEN INVITE EUSTACE. 113 what was known of William was, even now, better than cuap.xviii. what was known of Eustace. M^n could hardly have dreamed that the Count of Boulo<»-ne could disix^ssess William of those parts of England which he had already conquered, or that the still unsubdued districts could be l>ersuaded or compelled to receive him as their Kin«^. They could hardly have seriously thou»jht that, if a foreig-n King* had to be endured, they were likely to find a better Kin*^ in a paltry coward and murderer than they already had in the ^reat Conqueror. Most likely the reckonings of the men of Kent did not go so far afield. Anything seemed better than the rule of Odo and Hugh of Montfort. Eustace was at that moment the enemy of William,^ and any enemy of William seemed for the moment to be the friend of England.- Eustace's own views were most likely Probable views of not much clearer than those of his Kentish allies. He Eustace, may, or he may not, have aspired to the Imperial Crown of Britain ; but our hints rather set him before us as one who looked \Wth jealousy on the Norman power, and who hoped, by obtaining possession of the strong fortress of Dover, to be better able to hold his powerful neighbour in check on both sides of the sea.^ But, whatever may have been the views on both sides, the men of Kent patched up an alliance with their bitterest enemy."* It ' Will. Pict. 157. •• Regi eH tempestate Eustacliiua Comes Boloniaa adverwabatur, qui filium de fide ante bellum in NormanniA obsidem de- derat." Cf. vol. iii. p. 748. I do not know the ^Toumls or circumstances of this quarrel between Eustace and William, or of the suspicion in which William seemingly held Eustace even before his expedition. '^ Ord. Vit. 508 B. '• Olim cum eodem inimicitias ingentes habuerant, sed nunc, quia simultates inter eum et Ilegem in.surrexerant .... pacem cum illo fecerunt." ' Will. Pict. 157. ** Equidem fore, si firmissimo loco hoc sit potitus cum portu marino, ut potcntia ejus latiius distendatur, sicque potentiam Nor- inannorum diminutum iri." These words are put into the mouths of the English messengers, but they express the reasons why Eustace should accept the invitation, not why the English nhould send it. ' lb. " Quia Nonnannos odere.cum Eustachio, pridem sibi iuimicissimo, concordavore." See Orderic in the passage hist quoted. VOL. IV. I \\i COXgrRST of WMTIRN AKD NORTIIEKN ENGLAND. au».iYnt. was o^jtved thai \\\o (\>unt of Houlo^nc hIiouUI nnW norom ^ with II fl««t AUil with n fitting himl i'onf, and that th(* Kcnti»hnicai ahouKi U* nnuly to do thoir U'ht to inakt* hitn nUMter of the castle of Dover.* rUa i/Um Ilowevor unwifie the M^hemc of Kuhtart> and i\w Kontinh- nien may aucni in a widrr a4(p<*ot of thin^, tho actual attack on tho ra*f Odo ^'^ g^li, a time when Bishop Odo, Vicemy and Karl, antJioe and bin Kn^linh iillicH mvid to liuvo It rp I - IihI for an ctt«y fUcccM. I)ut tho pirriiMm wiu found ^^ngfi. l*«'tf<«r |in*|Hii\Hl iiiui in hij^luT npirit for dofonoo tlmn they i huhI iKMwiblo.' And it in ])lain that tlio townHinen 1 tho aide of the g^irition. Wliutcvrr mi^ht bo tho livlinpi of tho re«t of the nhire, the nu-n of Dover ha^ed. He therefore ordered a retreat to the ships.'' The evil which he thought to avoid now came upon him ; tho Utter rout f^Xes were thrown open by the townsmen, and a general attack on the part of the besiegers changed the retreat into a flight. In the last scene of the great battle the thought of Eustace had been that a new English host was coming to snatch the victory from the conquerors ; so now the crj' of Eustace and of his whole host was that the Bishop ' At this point William of Poitiers BUtMenly drawH in his horns, so that hia story reads like an abridgement of Orderic'H, iasteaeing, as it must be, an enlargement of William's. Is it poAsible that Ordcric, who clearly had William's account before liim, ha^l it in Home form earlier and fuller than our present copies, from which William of Poitiers, like his narneKake of Malmeabury, aflerwarda cut out parts through prudence ? The H[>ecial mention of the t^jwn comes from Orderic (508 C) ; " Quum hotites vehementer impetum facere in oppidum molirentur ; custodes af Jumieges (vii, 39) tolls us how '' Eustachius ad mare devertens, cum paucis indecenter navigio aufugit." William of Jumil'gcs makes no mention of the townsfolk, and 8]>eukH 118 OONQinKT or WB8TRRN AND NORTHERN KNOLAND. oBATJinu. liia nrphvw, wbo had accximpAnicil him, wilh U*tccamo tht* rn |>tivi< (»!' the pomMKim.' Ai was natural, tlu* horrors of the flight and •laii^^htor fell mainly on the French followen of Kustaco. Hut Kn^^'libh allien knew tlie country, and, prot4x?t4Hl by thoir own numbera, they contrived to hajlle the smaller bandrt which attem|)t4»d to follow them. An enterj>rii*e which had been j)lannc(l in folly thus Mded in utter diKg-rarc. While the sons of the soil, Brititih and Knjjlish alike, could still hold their own on the Herefordshire march, the attempt to rescue Enj^land by an alliance with the basest foe of Englishmen had led, G«tMr«l as it desi'rved. only to si<»'nal discomfiture. Of the rest of in oUmt ^^^ \:ini\ which was already conquered we hear nothing- in EJ"^^ detail. Our stories of oppression and discontent are per- fectly general. But men were everywhere seeking either to shake off the yoke or to escape it in their own ])crsons. Even where no open outbreak took place, local conspiracies were everywhere rife.^ Many left England altogether ; eomc sought a lasting home in foreign lands ; others only of the " milites Odoni« Raiocasini Pi-a?8uli8 atque Hugonis rle Monte- forti," and h<»w they, " liberalibus aniniis accen«i, portaa patufaciunt," &c. From this, and fVom the accounts of men falling headlong from the rocks, we n' ' ' thouglit that the attack was made only on the castle. Hut from net mention of "oppidum" and "oppidani" in Orderic it would seem that it was the town which was immediately assaulted. The \ liave invested the town on all sides, from above as well as ii r footmen pursued by horse may have tried to escape by climbing the heights on each side of the town. ' Will. Pict. 158. •* Nobilissimu-s tiro, nepos ejus, comprehensus est." Of this nephew I can give no further account. I conceive him to have been the son of Eustace's brother Lambert, who is described as Lord of Sens, and who died in 1054. Eustace's other brother Godfrey was Bishop of Paris, and his sister Gerberga, the wife of Duke Frederick of Lotharingia, had only daughters. See Art de Verifier les Dates, ii, 761 . ' WilL Pict. 157. " Angli neque beneficio, neque formidine satis coerceri poterant, ut quietum Herenam quam res novas ac turbi'las mallent. Con- ■urgere palam in arma non confidunt, sed regionatim de pravis conspira- tionibns tractant, si quibus forte dolls prsevaleant ad nocendum." The word "regionatim" explains the cause of the real conquest of England. APPLICATIONS FOR FOREIGN HELP. 110 simply visited them to seek the meann of their own resto- cHAP.xvni. ration or of the deliveranee of their countrv.* Eni'lish- Move- mentM after men, charged with the bidding of some section or other foreign of their countrymen, were scattered over every corner of *^ ^' Europe where there was any chance of help being found. Some seem to have sought for allies in the old land of their fathers at the mouth of the Elbe and the Weser.- But the state of things during the sickly and licentious sute of youth of Henry the Fourth did not offer much prospect of ®'™^^" help from the Teutonic Kingdom, The King himself was, in the autumn of this very year, Ipng on a bed of sickness at Goslar,-' and the troubles of Saxony and Tliuringia, if they had not yet broken forth, were already festering in silence. Tliere was another quarter in which such attempts Denmark were far more likely to be crowned with success. There promising was one foreign potentate to whom Englishmen might look a^^*^'"- as all but their countr}Tnan. Tlie old West- Saxon dynasty had died out ; its only representative was the King of a moment who was now tarrying in William's Norman court. The new West-Saxon dynasty had been cut off in the cause of England ; besides the sons of the traitor Tostig, its only adult legitimate representative was the hostage Wulfnoth, who was tarrying either in William's court or in William's dung'eon.'* But the stock of the Northern Position of kinsmen and conquerors of England still flourished in a Eatrithson. prince who was united by the closest ties of blood alike * Will. Pict. 157. " Ultro in exsiliura aliqui profugiunt, quo extorres vel a potestate Normannorum sint liberi, vel aucti opibus alienis contra eos rcvertantur." ' I think we may infer thia from the words of William of Poitiers (u. s.). ** Ad Danos, vel alio, undo auxilium alicjuod Hporatur, legatos missitant," compared with the legend of Harold's German journey (see vol. iii. pp. 515, 761), and with tlie various indications which we shall come across of the intercourse between England and Germany at this time. ' I>ambcrt, 1067. Henry fell sick on November nth. His life had been despaired of in a former sickness in May, 1066. * See vol. iii. pp. 342, 674. I shall give, a little further on, some account of the state of the House of Godwine at this moment. 120 tXJ.\gli:.ST l»K WKsTHKX AND NOUTIIKUN ENOLAND. CTurjimt. with t!»o Iloiiiii* «»f (?nut ami with the Huuhc of Godwinc. Swoncl, tlu* mm of V\( and I'ltitrith, Uic nephrw of Cnut, the nt»|»hew of Gytlm, iho hrotluT of the nninliTiHl lhH>rn, the ooftdn of Uic fttllcn llnroKl, \vik», of all mt*n not nl>M>IutoIy HbdoM born of Kn^Iihh |mrfnt*< on Knj^lihh noil, the miin who wan Oiott callinl on to avon^ the Moarty in Kn«^lanerhap8 1047-104S. n^t»t with less of MnLrlish thankfiilnoss than his services de^erveil." lie had refuseil to ahet the schemes of Tosti^ or to clutch at the crown which Tosti^ oflcred liim.^ He had iHjually refused to abet the enterprise of William, and Norman W'riters believed, thoufi^h doubtless without foun- (bition, that sulyects of his had been among" their foes on Senlac* Hut now everything had changed since the day when Swend had refused to undertake at Tostig-'s biddinp;* an enterprise which might befit the greatness of Cnut, but which was beyond the power of his own littleness. It was not now a solitary Englishman, banished by English justice, who asked him to attack a King of his own blood whom the free choice of the English people had honoured with their t Crown. Englishmen were pressing to him from all quarters, tobwend. ^^ eravc help against a foreign conqueror at the hands of one who might give himself out either as the heir of Cnut or as the avenger of Harold.^ Things too had changed in another way. Since the day of Stamfordbridge Norway * See vol. ii. pp. 9, 523. ■' See vol. ii. pp. 91-93. ' .See vol. iii. p. 330, * See vol. iii. p. 746. • Onl. Vit. 508 A. "Ad Suenum Regem Danorum dirigunt, atque ut regnum Angliae, quod SuenuH at Chunutus avi ejus armis obtinuerunt, repoflcat expetunt." In the Legatio Helsini (of which more below) in Lange>>ek, iii. 253, we read, "Contigit ut Danorum Rex, audita morte Haraldi consanguinei, venire in Angliam diaponeret, ut et mortem ejus vindicaret et terram sibi subigeret quam dicebat suam esse." HOPES OP HELP FROM DENMARK. 121 was no longer threatening, and the prudenee of Swend chap.xvui. himself no lonfrer needed to shrink from the risks of an English eanijuiign. There is indeed no reason to believe the wild fable of a late writer that, immediately on William's coronation, Swend sent to recjuire the new King to hold the English Crown of him as its lawful Over-lord.* Such a piece of bravado would be quite out ef character with the prudence which had enabled the Danish King to hold his own among so many storms. But now that Englishmen were bidding him to come and deliver England from the invader, there was no doubt that their requests were favourably listened to. And among the Englishmen who sought refuge in his Kingdom there was one especially who could give him the best information as to the naval resources of England. Eadric, the captain of King Presence of Eadward's ship, who had perhaps met Norman ships in Norfolk in naval warfare before the day of Senlac, had been out- I^e^^^^f^^- lawed at the coming of William, and was now an exile in the Danish Kingdom. ^ While he and other Englishmen were pressing Swend to action, there could be no doul)t where the greatest hope for England, the greatest danger for William, now lay. The whole North lay open to a Northum- Danish invasion at any moment. No Norman soldier ready for had crossed the Humber ; the brother Earls were with P*'}""'" ' help. William in Normandy ; the Northumbrian people, as yet unchecked by Norman castles and garrisons, would doubt- less have welcomed the Danish King to put an end to what, as far as they were concerned, was a state of Inter- regnum. Even if Swend had hastened, even if the ex- Swend pedition which took j)lace two years later had taken place f-ivourahlo at once, it would perhaps be too much to deem that "i*'°i*^^<^- William could have been driven out of P]ng1and. But ' See the story in Knighton, 2343, and Appendix P. ^ On thirt Emlric from the Eaat of England, sec vol. iii. p. 717, and Appendix I. 13S '-^ OP WWnill AKD KOirrilRIlN RNOLAKD. CBATJiTni. thcrp can be little doubt that, il' Kiirh n roiirsc hncl Ixx^n taken, the fliud oonquMi muitt hnv«* Ixvn lon^ dolnycHl. If Sw<*nd had corae at once, William could novrr hnv«» ocoupifd Northeni Kng'land, except nt the price of n hanl Htniffjjle a^iiiHt the men of the land, nup|>ort4Hl by their kinvfulk from IVnmnrk. Via •ought R<«side«( the l)ane«, we hear YSf^icIy of what the Norman ^t^^^iiy ii* writeri call other barlmnnis nations, as likely to take n Korraj. ^^^ jj^ disturbing: William's posnewion of Enj^land.' The reference u doubt b»Hs to Norway, whither wc nhall see that William did, a little time later, find it worth his while to send an embassy,^ no doubt with the obj(»et of Sut«- of waniing: oW any danijer from that quarter. But under ^^ ' the sons of Harold Ilardrada, Ma'ii'nufl and Olaf sur- {J*^^**, named Kyrre or the Tranquil, Nonvay, instead of threat- [Mmus enin^^ either Denmark or P'n^land, had well nigh itself 1066-1067. fallen under the power of Swend. ^ The power of the ~J*2]J^ Kingdom, as well as its reputation, must have been greatly tofrether. lessened by the failure of the great expedition against ( . England, and even by the mere slaughter of Stamford- , "j bridge. Neither of the brother Kings inherited the enter- prising disposition of their father. Olaf especially, who soon became sole King by the death of his brother, Pemceful was much more occupied in maintaining peace and good !,*n^^^I order in his own Kingrdom, than in disturbincf the King- of ouf doms of others. Men who doubtless yearned for the days of his father called him in mockery Olaf the Bonds or Churl."* And whatever gratitude the sons of Harold • Ord. Vit. 509 C. ** Ex malevolentift Anglonim cum niau Danorum aliarumque barltararum gentium, magnam cladem Normannis orituram intimabant." ' Sim. Dun. 1074 (p. 95, Hinde). See Chapter xxi. ' See Laing, iii. 103. • Laing, iii. 108. "King Olaf Haraldsaon wa» called by some Olaf Kyrro, but bj many Olaf the Bonder, because he Bat in peace, without strife withjn or without the country, and gave no reasonable cause for others to plunder in his dominions." Yet in the poem which Laing translates in STATE OF NORWAY. 123 Hanlra 11 T 11 • to William no motive to aven«^e his fall, or to disturb the reipfn offromNor- his conqueror. From Norway then there was no real hope ^^^' for England, no real danf^^er for William. The real hope, but from the real danf^er, was to be looked for wholly from Den- mark. And it was evidently the news that En«^lish exiles were gathering at the Danish Court, and that King* Swend was lending* a favourable ear to their prayers, which made William suddenly break off his festive and devout sojourn in his native Duchy, to embark once more on the sea of troubles w^hich still awaited him in his half- conquered island Kingdom. § 2. TAe Conquest of the West. December 1067 — March 1068. When William had once determined on his return to Matilda England, he did not tarry long in carrying his purpose fe"ft Re- ^^ into effect. Tlie Lady Matilda, a Kino^'s wife but not yet ^f"^ '" . , , "^ Normandy. a crowned Queen, was again entrusted wnth the govern- ment of Normandy, but this time William's eldest son Kobert was nominally associated with his mother.-^ He was still a boy ; he could not have been above thirteen years old, and he w^as probably younger ; ^ but his capacity p. 1 13, and the original of which is given in Johnstone, p. 228, he appears as a triumphant ravager of England ; "Orr er Engla pvcrrir Olafr borinn solo." He certainly was so in intent at a later time. ' See vol. iii. p. 375. ' Ord. Vit. 509 C. "Rex igitur Mathildi conjugi suae, filioque suo Rodl)ert<^) a4l by a Council of Pn»latt«a and HarouH ; \ni{ it wouWl kh-iu tliat thry won* now deprived of tlie niun who had act^nl '*«f»«' aa their President durini^ AVillianiH firxt ahsciuo. 'Vhr trndHtm ohl and ex]H*rienc(Hl Ho^i>r of Ihaiimont wan rall<>ht in WiiiUm either countr}'. Having made these arran^'ements, Willi.nn iheppa, liattened to the luiven at the mouth of the I)iej)])e, which J~^ was then spoken of as lying near the town of Anjues.*' He passed by the scene of his exploits of fourteen years earlier,^ and once more took ship for England. The month was December ; the sea was stormy ; but we are told that the prayers of the Norman Church, then engaged in keeping the festival of Saint Nicolas, kept its Prince safe from all dangers.^ As in the September of the year 1056, but I know of no evidence for the exact date. It could not havo been before 1054. * Orderic (509 C) saya, " Rex in illA tranefretatione Rogerium de Monte- Goraerici (quein tutorein Norm.inniie, duni ad bellum trauHniarinum i)rofici8- ceretur, cum sud conjuge dimiserat) secum minavit." Here ia a plain, though verj' strange, c^tnfuHJon l>etween Roger of Montgomery and Roger of Beaumont. It was Roger of lieaumont who was left in charge in Nor- mandy (see vol. iii. p. 384), and Roger of Montgomery (see vol. iii. p. 460) comman*le«l the French contingent at Senl.ic. ' Ord. Vit. 509 C. " Sext& nocte Decembris ad ostium amnis Deppse ultra oppidum Archas accesfiit." On the name Deppa, see vol. iii. p. 123. * See vol. iii. pp. 123-140. * Ord. Vit. u. 8. " Prima vigiliA gelidae noctis austro vela dedit Jam aura hicmali.s mare ssevissimum efficiebat ; sed Bancti Nicolai Myrse- onun Pnesulls 8ollennitatem EccleKia Dei celebrabat, et in Normannid pro devoto princi{>e fideliter orabat. Omnipotentia ergo Dei . . . benevolum Regem inter hiemales tem{>e8tate8 ad portiun aalutlH cum gaudio dirigebat." WILLIAM RETURNS TO ENGLAND. 125 before, one ni«^ht was enou«^h for the i)ass;a«,'"e, thoiif»'h the chap.xviii. course taken, from Dieppe to Winchelsea, was long-er than an.l lan.Ia the course of the f^reat Heet from the mouth of the Dive chelnea, to Pevensey. On the inoriow of the festival, William ^^^^^^^ stood once more on Eng-lish ground.* He came on a day of evil omen for Eng-land. Tlie most Chriat 1 • /» -ii 1 1 I A I Church at venerated among the minsters ot Lnglaml, tlie mother Canwr- church of the whole land, the church of Christ at Canter- ,'"^ , ' burned, bury ,2 was on that Saint Nicolas' day burned to the L)eceniber ground. The church, which had been simply damaged, but not destroyed, by the fire of Thurkill's Danes,^ was now utterly wasted by the flames which liglited William back to complete his errand of conquest. That church, so men fondly deemed, was still the first building of Augustine and ^Ethelberht, which had been simply re- paired and heightened under the primacy of Oda.^ But the native fabric was now to be wholly swept away to make room for the work of the first of a line of foreign Primates. Men's minds must indeed have been impressed, when the return of the Conqueror was ushered in by the destruction of the ecclesiastical home of the nation at the very moment of his coming. At the time of William's return no part of those shires Tliia is plainly from William of Poitiers, but the date is confirmed by our ovsii Chroniclers. ' Ord, Vit. 509 C. " Mane portum oppositi litoris, quem Wicenesiuni vocitant, prosperrimo cursu arripuit." ' Chron. Wig. 1067, " Her com se kyng eft ongean to Englalando, on See Nicolaerf mtessed»ge, and pxs daeges forbarn Criste.s cyrce on Cant- ware by ri." ' Tliis is distinctly attinned by Eadmer in the " Epistola ad (Ihistimienses." Ang. Sac. ii, 225. "Ad ha;c considerandum quia Eccksia ipsa in passi«)no beatiHsimi martyris Elphegi nee igne consumpta nee tecto aut parietibus diruta fuit. Violatam (juippe fui.s8e et pluribua ornamentis spoliatam, ac Hupposito de forirf igne ut concremaretur adorsam, novimua quo vesana manua Pontificem intu.s hcbc tuenteni, queni mandaret exire, compelleret." * See all the pas-sagea bearing on this point collected by Willis, Archi- tectural ilitttory of Canterbury. 7, 8. 116 coxgrBST or wistkrn' akp xortiikhx f.nolaxd. our .inn. of Knf*)iinii whi^h hml «'Vi»r U»on roally huIhIiuhI wnu ^ actunlly in nmin apiinnt him. Kiidrio ntill \\vh\ o\\\ on IL0 oua* Koa^M| the nen'for\i»»!nn' ninri'li, hut h^idrir had ncvor HuhinitttHl ftt all. The Kentish revolt had met with the futo which it deterred. And if wo holieve the Norman writorn, a party of onh»r had btx'n formed anionj^ all claswMi of Knp- li^hmen, who stood finnly hy the Nonnan Kiiijj a^inst their ri'ln-llioiiB fellow-count rymcn. At itB head was JjiUireil the Northern Primate and several other Bi.shops, and they were support oil l>y many others, Thejji'ns, citizens, and churls, the wisest and most respected, we arc asfiureil, of their several ortlers, who had learned to practise the di\'ine prccejit which hids men fear (Jod and honour the King.* AVherever William had cither himself appeared or had secured the district hy the building of a castle, that is, generally throughout south-eastern England, his will, outwardly at least, was law.- lie was received on his return by the English inhabitants, clergy and laity alike, with ever}' formal sign of loyalty.-^ On the other hand there was the general, if hidden, feeling of discontent within the obedient districts; there was the imminent T*»«**fn- fear of an invasion from Denmark, and the threatening \ng atti- tude of the aspect of the still independent West and North."* William North*" ^^^ °^^ of all his arts of war and policy to triumph over the combination of so many enemies at once. • Ord. Vit. 509 B, " Tunc Adeldrediis Priinae Eboracensifl aliique Ponti- ficca quidam utilitati re^se intendebant, quia sapientis monitum scientcs Kquitati obtemperabant. ' Time,' inquit, ' Ueum, fili mi, et Kegem.' Tunc etiam aliquot sapientiftBimi civium urbanorum et nonnulli ex militibus ingenuiB, quorum nomen et opeH valebant, et multi ex plebeiin contra suos pro NormannJH magnopere inimrgebant." Tliis plainly comes from William of Poitiers. * lb. 509 D, " Cunctse urbes et regionea, quas ipse adierat vel prsesidiis occupaverat, ad nutum ei parebant." • lb. " Adventui Regis Angli occurrerunt, ipsumque tarn honorificentiA monaateriali quam secularibus oflBciis sublimaverunt." * lb. " Circa temiinos regni occidentem aut plagani septemtrionalem MIDWINTER GEM6t. - 127 Tliis new act of" the drama be^aii with the f^eat cere- cuap.xviii. mony, ecclesiastical and political, which liabitually marked j^\j.^^^^'" the Midwinter Festival. For the third successive year tliat Chrwiauu /• • 1 111- • 1 *^ Wcut- lestival was kept, not as it had been in past times and was minster. again to be in later times, at Gloucester, but in the new seat ^^^'^^f^, of royalty at Westminster.^ There, in the chosen dwellin<' January 6, of his revered predecessor, Kin^^ William wore his Crown ^^^^ ^.j_ and gathered the Witan of England around him for counsel winter Gemot : and for judgement. We hear much of the courtesy and William's honour with which he received the English Prelates and J^J^^rMs tlio Theg-ns, with what readiness they were admitted to the £"^''"*^ . . Thegna. royal kiss, how willingly their requests were granted and their counsels followed, and how b^^ these generous arts many of the disaffected were won over.^ After making the needful deductions, there is probably much of truth in this. Now, as ever, there were those to whom William found it prudent to be gentle, and those to whom he deemed it his wisdom to be harsh. It stands unmistake- Second ably on record that William's return was accompanied by tion and a confiscation and distribution of lands on so wide a scale l.'"**^" f^' tion of that it could he said with indignant sarcasm that he gave lands. away the land of every man.^ The revolts and conspiracies versus effrsenis adhuc ferocia auperbiebat, et Anglise Regi, nisi ad libitum Buum, famulari sub Kege Eduardo aliisque prioribus olim despexerat." This is largely true of the North, but hardly of the West. ' Ord. Vit. 509 D. "Ipse Lundonise Domiuicam nativitatem celebravit," See vol. iii. p. 66. ' lb. *• Pontificibus Anglis proceribusque multa calliditate favit. Ipse omnes officioso atfectu demulccbat, dulciter ad oacula invitabat, benigue, si quid orabant, concedebat, prompte, si nuntiabant aut suggerebant, auscultabat. Desertores hujusmodi arte aliquotie.s reducuntur." ' Chron. Petrib. 1067. " And he geaf eelcea mannes land |>a he ongean com." Tliomaa Rudborne (Ang. Sac. i. 248) give.s a rhetorical account of William's doingu at this time in which, among a good deal of exaggeration, some expresaions are worth notice ; *• Willelmus in Regem sublimatus pacificu tractabat nobiliorcd regni Angliae, post fidelitatis juramontuiu ab ipdit sibi prKstituni ({uamdiu fidcm ei servabant, scd postquam rel>ellare cf«[)erunt, homagiis iterum ab ipHis acceptis datioque obsidibuii, omnibus. 118 CONQUK8T OK WR8TRKN AXD KORTllEKN RNOLAND. CBAr.xrtii. whirh had linp|M*ncM*nro would f*\\c ainjilo Bmv^t ux oxrtitt* for h\\v\\ n m«ii4un\ And Uio confiwiition \vii« ooMUfy. fiirthiT nttondiil liy oiu* of thoKo lu*nvy im))OHtM in money which to the ft»elinp« of thosi* dnvfl were more hnt^'ful tlwin contii«>ation. "The Kinjj net micklo ^eld on llie |>iH>r folk." ' wikUaa't William wan thus Inisy in half caressinc', half coercing, iHtroo* ... . tiocutoihthis Knj^lish Huhjeel^. Meanwhile the men of French and Norman birth who were alK)ut him were carefully warned of the state of the country, and bidden to \)q ever on their puanl aj^ainst the plots of the disafTected English.* And it also suited William's policy to give his subjects of both nations the spi'ctacle of a great judicial pageant, to teach them that their King was no respecter of persons, and that no man of either race could safely revolt against him. This Midwinter Gemot of Westminster was ma<.le unusually imi)ressive by a trial of which the like had certainly never been seen in England. Sentence of ban- ishment and forfeiture had been over and over again pronounced against English Thegns, Earls, and even qui ad rrgnum aspiraverant factue est terrori. Civitatibus quoque depositis et cautelliiJ propriisque ministriH impositis, .id Norinanniam cum obsidibu.s Aoglis et theHauri^ imprctiabilibus na\ngavit. QuibuH incarceratis ct sub salvA custodiil deputati«, ad Angliani denuo remeavit, ubi commilitonibua Buis NunnanniB qui in bello Uastingensi patriam secum subjugaverant terras Anglornm et possessioncM, ipgis cxpuhii*, succesnire manu dixtrihuit qfimentt, et modicum illud quod ci« remantie rat, foetus jam de rege tyrannug, guh jugo dctrtmt perpetua eerfitutU. Et quum se viderat in sublimi elevatum et in fautu regni confirmatuin, in alium virum Hubito est mutatus, nobiles tcTTBc quoa antiquus Hanguis ex antiquo sublimavcrat, proh dolor, exhsere- dando." * Chron. Wig. 1067. "And her se kyng sette micel gyld on earm folc." • Ord. Vit. 509 D. " Pari sedulitate et sollertia Guallos nunc instruebat, none ut contra omnes dolos et insidias singulorum semper ubiqtie parati e«0ent clam Anglis admonebat." I tliink, with Maseres (209), that for "Gu&Uos" we must read "Gallos." It seems impossible that intrigues with the Eret-WelHh can be meant, and, in Orderic, we can hardly under- stand " Gualii " of Oal-Wehh. See vol. ii. p. 140. TRIAL AND SENTEN'CE OP EUSTACE. 129 -^thelings. Once, in the niiiLst ol" warfare, a '('enenil chap.xviii. decree had been passed declarin<»; every Danish Kiny; an outlaw.' But it was a new thin<^ for a fori'i«^n prince to be formally put on his trial befon* an ICnj^'lish court, and, as it would seem, to be condemned by dtf'ault. Eustace of Boulogne was, in his County of Boulogne, a Euntace of sovereig^n prince, o\\Tiin«»' no superior but his lord the triwl and Kinff of the French. But ]>v takini,^ service in William's ^-^n;'"""*^ army he had become the man of the Duke of the Nor- c;emorc postuiodum perfunctus est. Erat enim idem Comes mai^uK nobilitatis," &c. He goes on to speak of his pedi^ce and his children. VOL. IV. K ISO OONgiKST Of WK8TKRN AND NORTIIKKN RNOI.AND. c«Ar.xTtit. ohieilj in tlni«o f»iirtii of Kn^Innd whiili wm' not in any I aaih Iwld (Luiy num nrii^h)>ourlitHKl to Iuh foreign (lonunioUH. He by kh ... uhI himiu'lf \vaj» clrml at tlio time of tlu» Survey, but hiB widow iind Hon apiH^ar there an holderv of lonlnhipH, Inith in varioUM other nhirt^s in tho«e weetern hindn wliieh on the day of his wntemv won* still uneonciuered. Tlie names of Ida and X KuHtaee, the widow and the son of tlie eowanl of Houloji^ne, the mother and the lirother of the hero of JerusaUMn, are found as owners of En^lisli soil on 8|X)t« which would have a strange pn>priety if we could deem that they were ever honoiin»' It uas in this Christmas session of the Witan that the vacancy would regularly be filled, llie death of Wulfwig at such a time might seem of hardly less evil omen than the burning of Christ Church. He was a living memorial of what Englishmen had done and suffered in the cause of English fVeedom. He had, in *o53- the moment of deliverance from Xomnan influence, been ' On the estates of Eustace in Somerset and elsewhere, see Appendix N. * Chron. Wig. and Fl. Wig. 1067. PROMOTION OK KoKKIGX rRELATE«J. 131 niised to the seat wliich the Norman I'll" hatl disgraced chap.xv!ii. and forsaken.^ He was now taken away at the moment when such parts of his diocese as still retained their inde- ])enden(e were about to be addetl to the dominion of the strant>ers. He died at Winchester, but he was buried in Wuifwii; his own cliurch, the last of the lonj^" line of Prrlatcs who ^j,,, hiHi,oj,8 liad not desniscd that lowlv dwellinfr-place. *'l^^' The appointment of his successor marked the bc^innin*^ of a new aTa. Since the fliy;ht of Robert and Ulf no man of French speech had been raised to an episcoj)al tlirone in En<,''land. The few men not natives of the island whom the policy of Harold had called to such hi^h ofliees were men whom Eng'land could hardly look on as strang-ers, men from the kindred land of the Lower Lotharing-ia.- William of London alone, honoured Cipially by men ol'all races, had been allowed to hand on to the reign of William the worst tradition of the earlv reifirn of Eadward. What Eadward had done out of mere weakness and personal favouritism William was now to do out of systematic policy. The Prelacy of England was to be used as a means for rivetting the fetters of England. TliC rule which was strictly carried Long ex- out through the rest of the century and the first half of the Eni'li-sli- next now began. As the Bishopricks and Abbeys of J"^" ^'"'"" England became vacant by the death or deprivation ofs|)iritual « \ ««|^ yju V*. English Prelates, men of Norman or other foreign birth ment. were appointed in their room. For a long time to come the appointment of an Englishman to a Bishoprick is un- known, and even to a great Abbey it is extremely rare. In the case of the Primacy indeed the rule was so strict that the exclusion of Englishmen was extended even to men of Norman descent born in England, and lor a liuudred years after the Concpiest, till the days of Thomas of London, no native of the Isle of Britain sat in the chair of Augustine. \N e have now to see the first fruits ol' this system in tlie ' See Vol. ii, pp. 113, 117, 331. '' See vol. ii. pp. 80, 4jy. K 2 13a aiNQlRin' OF WRSTRUN AND NollTIIKUN KN(JLANI). cmAr.iru]. cfaoiop of a Buccewior for Wulfwi;;^. Tin* ^^n;it liiKhoprick KvmiiptM of MiilKn^hiiul, a lar^jpt* juirt of whoiw iliocrM* wnn not yrt •DpuinuJ' *** Williain'n innvor, uim ;»;ivrn to Komij^iu-* i\\v AlinoiuT of J~|I. F^mp, whoHo zeal aiul lil>onility in William'n cause Hbr tkmtur boon aln^ady rcconloil.' Tlio voice of K<*:inointed shij) which had been the con- tribution of the loyal almoner."^ As yet however llemi^ius tflish liishoprick received consecration at Mii^'aiul ^1^^. |^a,|jg qC Stif»-and. » Kcnii^ius himself, in his later pro- tifji,'!!..- fession to Lanfranc, declared that he did it unwittingly, that he went for the rite to the actual Metropolitan, without knowinfi; the uncanonical and schismatical character which attached to all his official acts."* Yet we cannot forget the notoriety of Stigand's position, and the formal utterances of the Roman See agninst him.'' We cannot forget that Englishmen, that Harold himself", had commonly avoided his ministrations, that English Bishops, Wulfwig among them,'' had commonly been consecrated by other hands, that Harold and William alike had chosen the other Primate to perform the rite of their own crowning. The expulsion of Robert and tlic allcj^cd usurpation of Stigand ' iSee above, p. 90. ' See the next Chapter. ' This fact appears from Remigius' own profession to Lanfranc, printed by Mr. Diraock, Gir. Camb. vii. 151. * Itemigius in his profession repeats the Norman stories about Robert and Stigand, and adds, " Ego vero hujus negotii nee ex toto ignarus, neo asque<{uaque gnarus, ordinandus a^l eum vcni, professionem sibi suisque miccessriribus feci, curamque episcopalem dc manu ipsius ine consecrantis aocepi." lb. p. 152. ' See vol. ii. p. .^66. • See vol. ii. pp. 344, 466. nuKx-. HEMIGIUS BISHOP OF DOKCHESTKK. 133 liad even been i)ut torward ainoii^ the •^rniiiuls lor William's chap-xvui. exj)cditi<)n a«^ainst En<^land.' It would be strauge if uotliin^ ol' all this ha;ir)ly due all strict churchmen must have deemed a gross breach of t" ^^ >1- ecclesiastical order. William was still temporizing- with j^licy. Stig-and ; the time tor his degradation was not yet come.^ It would be a great, perhaps an unlocked for, mark of his continued confidence for the King to direct the new Bishop of Dorchester to seek consecration from the still acknowledged Primate. When the day came, the friend of Lanfranc and Hildebrand could easily find means to set straight any past irregularity. At all events, Remigius was consecrated by Stigand, with the help of what assistant Bishops we are not told, and he made profession to the schismatic as his lawful Metropolitan. He took possession of his humble Remigius bishopstool, in a land where Wigod on one side and Robert buildings of Oily on the other were ready to jjfive him all needful '\^ '""" '^ - r> Chester. help. There, we are told, he planned and began great Tlie see works,^ which w^ere left unfinished when the further pro- Lii"coln gress of William's conquests allowed him to remove his throne to a more lordly seat of episcopal rule. At the same Gemot William had also most probably the opportunity of again, nominally at least, bestowing an J*^ng- lish Earldom, The second reign of Oswulf beyond theTyne Oswulf had not la.sted long. In the course of the autumn he was rollber^ * slain, not however, as it would seem, in any political broil Autumn. 1 00 J . or at the hand of any avenger of Copsig-e. lie died l>y the * See vol. iii. pp. jS:, 383. '•' See above, p. 78. ' Will, Malm. Gest. Pont. .^1.'. See the ne,xt Chapter. lU CU.Ngl tsr Ki¥ WJ„sTKKN AM) NnKTHKUN KMJhAM). cttAravuL fpou* of a cummon rohlx^r, one of tlu* hnNnl who hud eMSped tiic hi^vy hnndii of Siwunl niul Tonti^, and tho ftory rvatin an if ho won* killo*! in tho net uf tryinff per- tonmlly to lurretit tho wrong- door.' IIik (leal)) loit tho dangvmiu [Kmi o|>on to the ambition of anothor Kn^linh- FbMmoT man of tho hi^host rank. Thin was Gospatric the son of "* * MuKlrotl, wlm, by fomalo dcscont at least, sprang of the noblost bK>od of Northuniborhind and oven of thf kingly Hkooo- bhx)d of Wottsox. For hJH motiicr Knldgvth was the with Um daughter of Uhtred by his thinl wife, tho daiigiitcr of ^f^*** King .Ktholrod. And tho words of our chief North- humbrian guide soom to imj)ly that this dosront gave him Gttnrintf >i<»mo kind of right of proloronco to tho Karldom."^ Tliis baraditon* ^^ ^ oommont on the growing notion of horoditiiry right duaoenta»d with roganl to such oflicos, and it is further remarkable oeakin. as showing that tho notion of succession through females was already beginning to bo entertained. We cannot suppose that it would have come into any man's head to propose a woman as a candidate for an Earldom, but men wore clearly beginning to think that the son of an Earl's daughter had a bettor right to his grandfather's dignity than an utter stranger to his blood. Of the former life of Gos- |>atric we know nothing, unless, as seems most likely, this is the same Gospatric who so gallantly jeoj)ardod his life to save the life of Tostig on his return from his Roman pilgrimage.** Godpatric He now went to William, ])roba])ly at this Christmas Northum- ^^^^t at Westminster, and asked for the Earldom vacant by ^"*5*, the successive deaths of Copsige and Oswulf. His claim, ' Sim. Dun. Gest. Keg. 92. " Mox sequenti jiuctumno et ipse OhuIFus quum in obyii gibi latronis lanccam praeceps irrueret, illico confosaus interiit." ' n». "Nam ex matemo Hanguine attinebat atl euin lienor illiuH comitatuii. Erat enim ex inatre AlgithA, filia Uhtredi comiti«, quam }iabuit ex Algiv& filiA Agelredi regis. Hanc Algitham pater dedit in con- jugiuin Mal'Jredo filin Criiiaiii." ' See vol. ii. p. 457. OOSPATUIC EARL OF NORTHUMBERLAND. 135 ))ack»*(l hy a lartnH chI comitatum North}'nil)ren8iuin." - On the Earltioni of GoHpatric, see Appendix O. 136 OONQUBBTT OF WRSTBIlN AND NOHTHKRN KNni.ANP. CBAT^viii hill rptscopdl ronnccnition. nt xUv liniuln of Stij^ml.' l\c hud Uvn further rntnistinl l»y Kjuhvunl in hin lifftinu' with thn p»vi*minrnt of tht» jjrtMit houw of Snint H«»n«''t of HaniM'v,- anil h^j^'ntln wi»nt on to gay that he hn' fn^m luulwanl to his cho«»n Buocessor.' No choice on Willinm'H part could have \>evn hcttcr plaimtnl to make a moral impri'ssion on the minds of Danes an. 454. ^ lb. p. 455. > See vol. iii. p. 359. • See Appendix P. • Lectio aj), T^angebek. iii. 253. " Keverenter igitur a liege Danorum reoeptufl et habituH, non imnlico teinj>ore apud euTii man«it. Tandem, quum negotia pro quibua mi88UH fuerat ad placitum jjeregiaset, licenti^ redeundi * R^e data, iter jier mare cum aocilH aggresauH eat." • See vol. iii. p 307. EMBASSY OF .+:T!1ELSI0E TO DENMARK. 137 the peace of England.' The U'genilary pari of the story chap.xvui. now follows. \\ hen /l!]tholsi«^e set sail from Denmark on I>egeni outlnwrv w rrvordfld in the ^T«<«it Survey, but it in no U>hh plain that, when the Survey itiH'lf wn» ninde, hi' wuh nf^in Ahl>ot of Rjunicy. Atn\ to wind up nil, ns if ])ur]>os(>|y to iniike way for tt new utate of thin^, both .Kthelni^' nnil IiIh HUcci'H^or nt Saint Autrnntine'a ilietl in the wime year tm William himself.* sc*'. M esteni i^n eni Kn^land, had had no dealin<^s whatever with the new King.^ And it would seem tliat the attitude of the men of the West was now taking the form of something beyond a mere refusal to acknowledge the King who reigned in London and Winchester. Exeter was of course the centre of all patriotic action. The city had doubtless fully re- covered from the misfortunes which fell on it in the days Hatred of Swcnd,'' but it is quite possible that the memory of r f i • « Hugh the French churl ^ had helped, along with later . , events, to make its inhabitants specially hostile to all men. men of French blood or speech. That hatred they are said to have shown in cruel and insulting treatment towards certain Norman knights who had been sent by William himself, and whom stress of weather had driven into their haven." Tliis may or may not imply that a » See vol. ii. p. 455. ' See thetie points worked out in Appendix P. • See above, p. 78. * Ortl. Vit. 510 A. " Regero alienigenarn . . . cum r|uo antea de nullo negotio egerant." * See vol. i. \) 346. * See above, p. 52. ' Ord. Vit. 510 C. "Militibus crudeliter et contumeliose illuserant, quoe ipse de Normannii miserat et tempestas ad portum illorum appulerat." STATE OP KXETER. 139 force had been sent against tlie West while AVilliam was ch.vp.xviii. still in Normandy. At all events the city was at this Zeal and moment perfectly independent and full of zeal for the all rankn. national cause. The citizens of Exeter were rich, nu- merous, and valiant, and, at this stage at least of the story, all ranks joined in full purpose to withstand the stranjjer to the uttermost.^ Like their brethren at Win- Their re- Chester, they stood in a special relation to the widowetl Ea"b' ^ shires and towns. This incidental mention is just in the style of William of Poitiers (cf. his .i(;c«)unt of Koniney, vol. iii. pp. 410, 534); one would he well pleased to know the story more at lar^^'e. ' Ord. Vit. 510 A. "Cives earn tenebant furiosi, copiosse multitudinis, infestissinii niurtalibus Gallici generis, puberes ac Senatus." One is tempted to read eitlier " phbs et Senatus" or "puberes ac si'uiores." lUit the mention of "Senatus," it will be presently seen, is important. (In this suggestion I find myself forestalled in the excellent note of Maseres, p. aio.) '^ In Domesday (100) twelve houses in E\tter appear as " lil)t.ru; ad iiumenim in ministeriis Eddid Reginne." ' See vol. iii. p. 54I. * See vol. i. pp. 3 ^S, 346. * " Operose nmnita," sayg Orderic. ' Ord. \'it. 510 A. " Pinnas ac turres et qua.o- bant in munimentis addcbXgi i>r or >Ni^^r»:K.N a.m» .NoiiniKK.N h.Mii.AM). o«Ar.&viii. of the niM^liUmnn^ nhinti, aiul to mil on their t4>\vnii to pnter into n leui^iie with Kxeter uj^uiiist the titrei^n TV l^i">H'' Tliom* nhirvH, thoc^e towns, were now untlouhtedly 9ommJ»\y wholly Kii^^linh in ftvlin^ ; they wen* prohahly hy thin ■ogltok j-jj^^, mainly K^^Mi^h in LKmhI. The Thej^ns and the eitizenit at all events would he h> ; the townn, we may U» hurt*, like Kxeter it*»elt', had l>een from the hej^inninjf Kn^lish (H»lonie«5 in the (\'ltie land. The memory' of older dititinetions would simply tend, as in 8ome parts it tend)} to this day, to nuike local feelinp^ a little stronj^T than elsewhere. But the patriots of Kxeter were ready to welcome help from any (piarter, and, amon^ other tpiartei-s, they 8ou«;^ht it amon^ the strang-ers from distant lamls whom the commercial imi^jrlance of their city had hrouj^ht to sojourn within their gates. Foreign merchants, if they seenuHl likely to be of use in the camj>aign, were pressiHl into the service, to take their jiart on behalf of the land to which they owed a temporary allegiance.'* It was j)lain that to put down such a movement as this must be AVilliam's first work. The active hostility of the West was becoming more dangerous than the stubborn sullenness of the North or even than tiic chances of an invasion from Denmark. CoDiMzioa And there was another feature about the movement at of iIm moTooient Exeter which would make it specially hateful in William's 7**^1 -f ^y^- '^^ Benalagn might be ready to welcome Swend Gcdwine. or to scck for a Kinjr in the House of Leofric. The name of Eadgar might kindle a sentimental feeling in any part of the Kingdom over which he had been for a moment chosen King. But the voice which came up from Exeter ' Ord. Vit. 510 A. " Hi nimirum socioH e plngiu finitimis inquiete arcesse- bant .... alias quoque civitateH ad conHpirandum in eadem legatiunibus insiigalwDt, et contra Kegem alienigenani toto hImu se iira'{)arabant, cum quo antea de nullo negotio egerant." ' lb. " McTcatorwi advenajt hello habileis rctiucbant." OYTHA AT KXETKR. Ml was :i voice raised on belialf of tlie House of Gmlwine and chap. xviii. ilarold. Of that House we have heard nothing" since (jytha, the mother of heroes, craved tlie body of lier son on the morrow of the g-reat battU'J 15ut now the widow rr»-Menceof of Godwine was j)resent in the city whose holy places she Kxeu-r. had enriched with otierin<»'s for the soul of her husband.- Tliere was no part of Ens^land in which her own possessions Great po»- and those of her children were larger than in the shires of Harold and Devon and Somerset. And it is in those shires only that we |'" J*™"y 111 the can trace in the Survey the names of those younger mem- We-t. bers of the family of whom so little record is to l>e found elsewhere.^ The lands of the House of Godwine, at all events the lands of Harold, Gyrth, and Leofwine, had, wherever William's rule had reached, been forfeited to the behoof of the Conqueror and his followers. Here, in the free West, their revenues and the fighting power of their occupants were still ready to be used in the cause of England. The men of Somerset and Dorset had sent their contingents to Senlac ; the men of Devonshire and Cornwall are not mentioned;"* in the swift march of events between the two great battles the forces of such distant regions may easily, without any suspicion of back- wardness or disloyalty, have failed to find their way to Harold's muster. But for this very reason those shires were better able to resist now ; their noblest and bravest had not been cut off, like the noblest and bravest of Kent and Berkshire. The widow of the great Earl, the mother of the fallen King, was thus dwelling within the walls of a city where she was well knf (i(Ml\viin» wrn* ili'ttil. mvo only Wtiltnoth tlir h<>stai^>, who \\i\h in the ^*. / ,f, haiul« of WillinmJ Of liuniMH «>tlu>r roin])ninoti in his fatal voya;;f, llakon the hon of Sw«'^n. no certain account can bo j{ivcn. I have venturcnl, rather doubt in;^ly. to j«^ive H*Xoo «iu 1)11,) hi* place amon^ the warrion* of Senlac* lit- may liave dierial mornin«jf-f^ift. .Kllj^ifu, accordin*^ to one ven>ion, was dead;* at all events there is no furtlier aooount to give of her. Ciunhild, alive and unmarried, was doubtless in attendance on lur mother. In the third generation, )»e8ides the doubtful case of Ilakon, the sons of Tt>i!iti«^ were in Norway ; '' of any children of Oyrth and Tl»e LtK)fwine we hear nothing. JJut Harold had left behind H&rx*ld. h*"^ ^*^'6 children, who, as I have elsewhere suggested, were Three sons probably the ofrsjjring of Eadgyth Swanneshals." Of their anil tWM dAuehterri. mother we hear no more after her sad errand to Senlac. chilc*t-n of ^^ ^^^^ really was the rich and fair Kadgifu of Domesday, her tjuJ^'>th lands formed — most likely had already formed — a rich Swan- "^ -^ a. iMirvest for Norman spoilers. But her three sons, God wine, Eadmund, and Magnus, of whom Godwine was a holder of lands in Somerset," and her daughters Gytha and Gun- hild, will all call for momentary notice. Everything leads us to believe that the whole family were now gathered round their grandmother at Exeter. But there was an- other child of Harold who was most likely in a distant • See above, p. 119. ' See vol. iii. p. 476. » Thia w made by Lappenl>erg, Norman Kings, p. 168 (Eng. ed.), after Subm. • See vol, iii, pp. 262, 703. "" lb. p. 374. • lb. p. 764, and Appendix R. ' See Appendix Q. STATE OF THE HOUSE OF GODWIN E. 143 part of EntJ-land. There can be little doubt tiiat I If, the charxvuf. son of Harold and Eald^vth, was born after his father's '*^ "- ' Bon of death. It would follow that he was born at Chester, ^^^bTth; whither his mother had been sent for safety by her brothers.' As Chester was not yet in AVilliam's pos.session, the babe, whom the event of the g-reat battle had hindertd from bein;^ a born /Ethelin*;', was probably dwelling* with his mother within the Mereian Earldom. Sooner or later hw cap- indeed he till into William's elutehes and remained a prisoner till the end of William's reign.'- But we may believe that his captivity dated only from the fall of Chester rather than susi)ect that even Eadwine could stoop to the baseness of giving u}) his infant nephew as the ])rice of the Conqueror's favour to himself. The son of Ealdgyth united the blood of the two greatest HarolJ'H houses in England, and, had his father's reign been as long Exeter, as the heart of England had prayed for at his crowning, he might have l)een the second King of the House of Godwine. The sons of Harold who were within the walls of Exeter came of a lowlier and doubtful stock. But, as vig-orous youths fast approaching manhood, they were better fitted to become the rallying point of a patriotic movement, and the probable stain on their birth could hardly be thrown in their teeth in the days of William the liastard. Hie whole West was ready for defence, and Volunteers volunteers flocked in from other parts. One recorded aistricts. instance in such cases proves many unrecorded. Bkecman, Blaecnmn a wealthy secular priest of Berkshire, a tenant of the Abbey ghire. of Abingdon, and himself founder of a goodly church in its neighbourhood, risked all his possessions, temporal and spiritual, to share the fortunes of the widow of Godwine.'' ' See vol. iii. pp 511, 7^14. ' See Flor. Wi;,'. 1067. ' Blsecman, lUachenian, Blachcniannus, is Rpuken of in the UiHt,'»lon, i. 474, as " presbyttT pecunioHUH." By the leave of the convent he built a church, with buihlinj^ of a monastic pattern attachen of the Ml CONgl'R;5T of WESTEHN AND NoHTIIKUN RNOLANI). riTni. Such a man, wc may U» nun*, did not hiaml alont* ; KxcttT, the oiu' jfnmt city of Southern Kn^hiiul wliirh rnnaiiuHl frw*. n*a« douhth»HH a city <»f rcfu^fc to many a patriotic heart from all the nhirt^ over which tlie IIouhc of (Jod- wim* had ruhxl. At no moment Hinee the hattle had the TW Wart* ho|i08 of deliverance Ixvn higher. Hnt, an usnal, hn-al and It not intenial diKsenKionn H|>oilcerha|)s have driven William once more l)evond the sea. But while P^xeter was in arms, York did not stir, and w lim ^<)rk did stir, Exeter had no longtT the power of stirrinj^. The ^mndsons of Ijeofrie doubtless eared little for a movement on hehalf of the House of (lodwine. }\:u\ the son of Harold and Kaldifvth been a ^rown man, capable of leading armies, both the fi^reat divisions of England mi^ht possibly have g-athered round one who united tlic Mood of (iodwine and the blood of Leofric. lUit the babe at Chester could ^ive no strength to any cause, and Eadwiiie and Morkere cljurch to Suiiit Arnlrew, got the name of " Aiidresia" (Aiulrea«ege ?). Tlie buil'lingH were " luirifice coaptata, picturis ca-'Liturimjue infra et extra ubicjue locorum delectabile viau 8ul>ornata." He then " privatira ae monachia ingerendo, turn auri argentique oHtentu, turn facundi oris profusione," got a lease of three lordships from the Abbey. The writer Heems to record the grant with some displeasure, but it wa« merely one of the usual leases. Bhi-cman was, as he b described in the local history (i. 484), " ecclesise homo effectus," just like Sheriff G«>etere sese subducerent, Abbas Ealdredus, primorum sese sen- tentia dedens, Regi fidelitatis sacramenta persolvit. At in posteriorum numero quum multi diverterent, turn et pcrempti Regis mater, secum in comitatu suo, una cum plurimia aliia, presbyterum lilachemannuni habens, Angliam deseruit." If Bbecraan accompanied Gytha in her flight, we may be pretty sure that he was with her at Exeter. WILLIAM CALLS ON EXETER TO SUBMIT. 115 tarried in the Court uf William till William's rule was as chap.xvui. safe at Exeter as it was at Winehester and Loudon. In overcoming" the hostility of the West, William acted William 1 1 1- 1 . i» !• 1 1 1^-1 negotiate. as no always did act. iseiore he tried arms, he tned neoT)tiation. In the ^Teai ease of all, in his dealinipin* to l»c Consuls or nurj»'onm.st«'rH of tlu* Free ^°yy*"' IiiiivrinI City of Exrter. Ah fnr tlu» ordinnry Tlicffiis Pcwtinn f»f tho o)untr>*, we ran lianlly attributo to them such a fwiiilv of ^^' J^rw* ^^ p(»litionl forcHJ^ht as to understand the probable Harul.l ri'jiults of the entablishnient of an indejM'ndent common- wealth in the gn^at WenttTn city. Such a commonwealth, if it lived and ])rospcred. was not unlikely to j)lay the part. which was afterwards jdayed by Hern and Florence, which was. a few years later, played for a moment by Lc Mans, and to constrain the nei^hbourin<;' lords of the soil to become its citizens or its subjects. Exeter had already possessions beyond its own walls, which mi^ht easily form the f^orvn of a subject district.' But, without supposing" the Western Thegns to look so far afield as this, the scheme of establishing' a commonwealth of Exeter could have no charm or interest for them. If they were faint- hearted, they might seek their advantage in becoming AVilliam's men and l>uying back their lands of him.'"^ If they were stout-hearted and hopeful, they might look forward to keeping William out of the AVestern lands altog-ether. But no half-measure offered any chance. A commonwealth of Exeter promised them nothing, and they could have no hope of admitting William as Over-lord with- No chance out admitting him as immediate King. They could hardly a de- have cherished any dream so wild as that of establishing pendent ^|^^. Wealhcyii as a separate principality like the Northern polity »n Wales, paying tribute to William as Basileus of Britain, ' Pomewlay, loo. " Biirgenses Exoniae urbis habent extra civitatem iemt xii. carucatas qu» nullam consuetudinem reddunt, nisi ad ipaam civitatem." ' See above, p. 25. WILLIAM KEFl'SES ALL COMrKOMlSE. 119 but ruled by a prince of the House of Godwine, a prince chap.xviii. who mio-ht himself be the man of the Over-lord, but whose personal vasssalage should not be shared by his subjects. But of all princes of liis day William was the least William *• likely to be entanj^led into middle courses or to be be mime- satisfied with a half-submission. He mi<^ht be Duke of^**'*''^'^ ° evc-ry- the Xormans and Ciesar of the Eng-lish ; ' but in either where. character he would be the immediate lord of every one of his subjects. He might be satisfied with maintaining the external superiority of his predecessors over the out- lyin*,^ provinces of his Empire, but within the Kingdom which his kinsman had bequeathed to him he would put up with nothing short of unreserved allegiance. He would have nothing to do with terms and reservations. His answer to the Exeter deputation was terse and to Hia answer the purpose; '* It is not my custom to take subjects on Exeter such conditions." - War of course followed : William ^^^P"*^^" tlOIl. marched with an army into Devonshire, an army drawn jje partly from the English inhabitants of the conquered "i^^.^"^* districts. This was the first, but not the last, time in Exeter, which William learned to em])lov En^flish valour in his ^^"oM'*^' . ^ •' o men m his wars on both sides of the sea."^ The policy of so doing army. was obvious : it was not a foreijifn conciueror who was J/^V^y °' ' ° 1 their em- marching against an independent city ; it was the King ployment. of the English, at the head of his loyal Englishmen, marching against a city which refused him his lawful ' "Qui Dux Nonnannis, qui Ctesar praifuit Angli.s," anya Abbot Baldric in his verses on William. Duchfesne, Rer. Franc. Scriptt. iv. 257 A. ' Ord. Vit. 510 A. " E contra sic eis remandavit Rex dicens, Non est mihi nioris aenalties which had heen dcorccaet hi oferforon." This will at least include the Dorset harryings. RAVAGES IN DORSET. lol no doubt now that the towns of that shire, Dorchester, chap.xviii. Bndport, Wareham, and Shaftes])ury, underwent that ^Viiiiam'K mva^es* on fearful harrving: the result of which is recorded in Domes- his march ; day. J3rid])ort was utterly ruined ; not a house seems to Doniet have been able to pay taxes at the time of the Survey. ^'"™- At Dorchester, the old Konian settlement, the chief town of the shire, only a small remnant of the houses escaped destruction.^ These facts are signs that William followed the same policy a^inst Exeter which he had followed William's T A r 1 TIT mi I in pol'cy tho ai^inst Le Mans- and ag-ainst London.-* Ihe boroughs of game as in Dorset were doubtless among the towns which had joined quests *^^° in the civic league. Probably they stood sieges and were taken by storm. At any rate they were ruthlessly hurried, in order at once to isolate and to frighten the greater city which lay beyond them. This policy did its work. As Its effect : William drew near, the fear of him and his wrath fell on trates^ the ])atncians of the commonwealth of Exeter. At a^i^'^^*^'", '^ oritr sub- distance of four miles from the city a second deputation mission met him, whose language was ver}' different from that of hostages. the earlier message. Nothing was now said of conditions ; nothing was refused ; all was abject submission to William's will. The men of Exeter craved for peace ; their gates were open to receive the King; they would obey all his orders. In pledge of their good faith, hostages, as many as William demanded, were at once given up.** And it would seem Alleged that William now made some special promises of favour promise by which he afterwards failed to carry out."^ We cannot ^^ ^^'^'^™- * On the detiils, see Appendix K. ' See vol. iii. p. 203. ' lb. pp. 533, 543. * Oni. Vit. 510 V>. " Majores mox, ut Regem cum extrcitu appro- pinquare cognoscunt, obviam advenienti procedunt, pacem poscunt, p«)rtaa ei patere dicunt, iniperata qua-libet se facturo.s promittunt, et obsides illico, •juantos Rex jubet, adtlucuntur." This of course cannot mean that they went back to the city for hostages. * So it would seem from the short but weighty account in the Worcester Chronicle, which gives hints which we should be well pleased to see drawn 152 C0NQUK8T OF \V>:8TRKN AND NOUTHKUN RNGLANM). oupjirtn. wonder Uiat it wiu k>, for, tM fnxm an \\\o nicHHon^ni rvturiUHl to tlie tt)wn, it »jHH'l)aMy looked to see it, by his new subjects pourin;^ forth to welcome their sovereipn. One niig'ht almost Ikj UhI to think that acts of dirwt hostility l^anoi f(»llowed on the part of the citizens. At all events, ,...,,. ^Villiam saw that he was deceived, and we can hardly dr«w« near blame him for being: filled with wonder and wrath.- With to reoon* noitre. and five hundred horsemen he rode forth to see the city, to city pr«^ j"^g^ o^ ^^s ^^^^ ^"^ ^^s fortifications, and to find out what P*JJ^**'' the enemy were doing.-* out at greater length. The words are — after the harryings — " And ^ be ferde to Defena^cire, and bcsset ^a burh Exanccster xviii. dagas, and ))aer wearff niicel liiw heres forfarun, ac he hcom irel hchct, and yfde gthrstf, and big him J>a burh apeafon for^an t>a JK-'genas heoui geswicon ha;fdon." The account seems hardly to follow chronological order, and this seeniH the most likely time for promises. • Ord. Vit. 510 B. ** Keversi ad concives, qui Huppliciapro reatu nimis metuebant, nihilominus machinantur hostilia quo; coiperant, multisque pro cau8^is ad oppnyiianduni sl-sc incitabant." TlieHe words by tliemHelves nould rather imply that those who niade the capitulation were the same a« those who diso^iied it. But the mention in the Chronicle of the treason of the The^ns, anr tJtr I'/Ufqaifji of the Clarmdnri Press. DESCRIPTION OF EXETKR. 153 The city to which William now drew near did not indeed aiAP.xvni. rival the natural stren«^th of Le Mans or Domfront, but it I>«^i>- •^ ^ . . tion of came nearer than most En<^lish towns to recall in*^ some- Exet«r. what of the character of those memorable scenes of his earlier ex])luits. Exeter is described by the most detailed historian of this cami)ai«^n as standing* in a plain, ^ and to one who looks down upon the city from the hit^her g-round which surrounds it on nearly every side the description might not seem inappropriate. But the city really stands on a hill, and a hill, in some parts, of no inconsiderable steepness. The Exe flows to the south-west; at the north- east a sort of narrow isthmus connects the hill with a large extent of ground at nearly its own level. On either side of the isthmus a sort of ravine, stretching towards the river on each side, forms a kind of natural moat round the greater part of the city. On the isthmus, the most important point in the line of defence, stood the east gate of the city, one of the four which guarded the ends of the four main streets which still keep up the memory of the ground-})lan of Roman Isca. The wall which, with Tlie walla a little care, may be traced through nearly the whole of its extent,^ followed the crest of the hill, which is divided from the river by rich alluvial pastures, in those days most likely mere swamps. The defences were therefore ' Or«leric (510 A) calls the city " in piano sit.a," anemiA vel Britannia minore bruvissimo aditur spatio, distans milliaria circiter duo." " Litus marinum " may, by a favourable construction, be taken to mean the shore of the estuary of the Exe, but the whole geography is confused. ' The walls of Exeter are well shown in the plans in Izacke's " Remark- able Antiquities of the City of Exeter" (London, 1 724), and Jenkiu-s's •• History and Description of the City of Exeter " (Exeter, 1806). Tn April, 1870, I made the whole circuit of the defences in company with Mr. W. A. Panford, antl we were able to trace the wall nearly everywher©. It has been greatly patched at vanous times, and shows a most remarkable variety in its masonry. 1 do not feel at all certain that some portions of the foundation of iEthelstan's wall do not remain on the north side. All the gates have been destroyed. 151 COKQtJBST OP WESTERN AND NUKTIIKRN KNGLAND. >iy William. At the opposite end of S^ y^' ' the city, William'n line of approach would lie by the ***"." isthmu8 leadinjj to the East (Jatc which opened into the Hi^h-street. The ground is such that he and his horsemen would see but little of the town till they came into its near ncig-hbourliood. To tlic left of the East Ciate, just within the wall, stood the cathedral church of the newly translated Bishoprick, which has since given way to the building whose combined uncouthness of out- line and perftH'tion of detail makes it unique among English churches. To the right of the gate rose the high ground, which AVilliam's keen eye would at the first glance mark as the site of the future castle. The river, the main source of the importance of the city, flowed out of sight on the other side, but on the right, soaring over the city and the intervening valley, rose the height of Penhow, looi. where, sixty-seven years before, Swend of Denmark, driven back from the city, had found his revenge in a victory over He find* the mcn of Devonshire and Somerset.- The new invader prepared ^ou^d the city as well prepared for defence as ever it had for defence. ly^Q^ against the earlier enemy. The g-ates were shut, and the whole range of walls and towers was thick with defenders.^ According to one version, one of the besieged went so far as to offer to William and his followers an ' On the blocking of the river by the E^rls iind Countesses of Devon, see Oliver's " History of the City of Exeter," p. 249. ' See vol. i. p. 340. • Ord. Vit. 510 B. ** Port« oflBrmatae erant, densasque turbse in pro- pugnAcidifl et per totam muri ambitum prostabant." SIEGE OF EXETER. 155 insult as unseemly as it was senseless.* The wrath of chap.xviii. William was now kindlt'd to the uttermost. God, he said, J"""!^ '^'^ to have would never help men who dare •'^B ni»i>^*^ have In-en Inaten hack from Exeter as Swend had been, if the military art of Normandy in AVilliam's days had not boon many 8te]>8 in advance of the military art of Th* city ml Denmark in the days of Swentl. It was by underminings bv » mine, the walU that William at last gained possession of tin- city.' This was a moile of attack for which the men of Exeter were most likely not j)repared. They coidd luirl their javelins from the battlements; they could cleave tht; skull of any daring assailant who mounted a scaling-ladder ; but a countermine would probably have been a refinement beyond their skill. William's mine advanced so far that part of the wall crumbled to the ground, making a prac- ticable breach."* The hearts, not only of the magistrates The but of the mass of the citizens, now at last gave way. To aet4inninc avoid the horrors of a storm, it was determined to submit J^'^J^ unreservedly to the mercy of a prince who, to do him ' Ord. Vit. 510 B. " Pertinacia furentis populi nullo timore, nee ulU reliquorum obHidum flectitur miseratione, sed acuitur ad defenBandum se Buottque larea tola obKtinatione." ' Chron. Wig. 1067. " pxT was micel his heres forfaren." ' Ord. Vit. 510 B. '* R<;x autem fortiter urbem obsidione concludit, inilitari feritate invaellantem leviter (?) subegit, divine scilicet jutus auxilio, quod pars muralis ultro decidens ingressum illi patefecerit." TIiIh is of course on the supposition that " Exonia" is the right reading. It strikes me that William's story, allowin'^' for a little legendary improve- ment, fits so well into Orderic's as to form an argument in favour of Exeter. The expression of Horence " infregit " seems to fall in with this account. SURRENDER OF EXETER. 157 justice, bad never ordereil or allowed an indiscriminate chap.xviii. massacre of unarmed suppliants.^ But there were still those in Exeter who scorned or Gytha and feared to throw themselves upon the mercy of AVilliam. company The mother of Harold was within the walls, and, as I have [^**'f]J}:^\i,^ already conjectured, she was pru])ahly accompanied by all aurrender. those members of the House of Godwine who were still free and still on En^^-lish ground. Tiytha left the city, evi- dently before the gates were thrown open;- with her went the wives of many good men,^ and probably others of both sexes, for the presence of Blaecman the priest is distinctly recorded.* If her grandsons were with her, they no doubt accompanied her in her ilight, though they did not share her final place of refuge. The means of escape were easy. Easy William, superior to Swend in his other resources, had means of brought no ships to share in the attack on Exeter. The ^^® "^'®'"- besieged therefore must have retained their communica- tions with the river and the sea during the whole length of the siege. Tliere was therefore nothing to hinder any who were minded to escape by water from so doing. When the breach in the wall showed that resistance was now hopeless, perhaps even while William was marching in triumph throuo-h the East Gate, it was still easy for Escape of ^ ° -^ Gythaand Gytha, and those who chose to share her fortunes, to make her foUow- their way by the Quay Gate to the still friendly stream. ^^°' Tlie widow of Godwine, the mother of Harold, was able ' Ord. Vit. 510 C. " Tandem municipes ingenti hostium instanti.l utile consilium coacti capiunt, aK uhK* to find their way nerons a ' •'^» frirndlv loiintn* to the coa«t of SomerHtt. There they cooipMy aou^ht shelter on one of those* two ishiiuln in the Bristol qa iblir* ^^""'***^' the St4H?p and the Flat Holm, which form such FUiHolffl. pn^niinent ohjeots in the view from either roast, and which can l»e seen even from the dintant hills of Gloueest^^'rshiro. .^^7 , To one of them (iihlas, the one Hriti>h chronicler of the the Holm*, hn^nnh Conquest, had retired for solitude and meditation, i>fGildM ^*^' l>init<.'8 from the Orkneys, forerunncrH of the ^Vikinf»^ *^ ***• of a later day, drove him to seek for refut^c in the inland Ht.lm. isfle of Ynysvitrin.^ In the days of the Danish invasions, hiiiorv in ^ ^a", inwsti pro patris occisione suique propukione, confugerant ad Dirmetuin Regem Hibemiie." See vol. ii. pp. 154, 387. ' Florence cuts the story short ; " De civitate fugiens eva.sit etFlandriam petit." But her stay on the Flat Holm was not very short, a.s the Chronicle Adds, "And )wer wunode sume bwile and swa for ^anon ofer sit» to See Audoniare." Thi.s " Bonie while " may pos.sibly cover the space till the final discomfiture of her grand.sons in June, 1069. ' See vol. ii. p. 151. * The bones of Gunhild, and h«'r sepulchral inscription written on lead, were first found in the church of Saint Donatus at Bruges in 1786. The church waa destroyed in 1804, but the inscription and a single bone — like the one bone of William which escaped the Huguenot destroyers of Saint Stephen's — were preserved. I have given the inscription in Ap|H;ndix L. IGO ooxgrEST or westkkn and noutiikkn rnoland. i-WAririii. the blood of llurold found itu way into the veina of many of tho princvly houHCM of Nt»rtluTn KuropeJ But wc must hnntcn hack to the gat«« of Exfter. Gytha and her companion?* were jfone, ami tliosr who had Ie«8 personal reason to dread the wnith of William went forth to crave hig mercy. The pa^'eant whidi had gTet»ted his eyes as he entered !.<• ^Immh ^ grect4'd them a^Tiin as lie enterc Htrirt watch ovi-r tho city wliow con- qui*«t hnd roht WiUiain no dour. IIo wiu* to hni^ton on with the coniph'tion of the ai,*: of the castle iind the doHtruction Um tffibato ... orSsctar. which it invoIviHl, another iH'uulty was intlicted uyxm the city. Tho |>atricianH of the half- bom common wealth had offeretl to pay to William the tribute which had been paid to earlier Kinp?.^ The money payment was now raised from an cKJcasional half-mark of silver to eighteen |M)unds yearly. Tlie rijjhtii of the Old T^ady were not forgotten, and Eadj^yth received two-thinls of tlu' increased burthen laid upon her mornin<^-gift.* WiUiAm The amount of resistance which William met with in into Corn- ^^*^* West after the fall of Exeter is not clearly marked. w*Ji and Tliere were movements which he had to put down : overcomes all oppo- and the heavy destruction which fell on the town of Barnstaple in the north-western part of Devonshire, and the still heavier destruction which fell on the town of ' Onl. Vit. 510 C. " Ibi IJalduiuuin du Moli.s, filium Gisleberti Comitis, alioeque mihtcH pnccipuos reliquit, qui necciisurium opua conficerent praj- sidioque manercnt." On Baldwin, see Will. Gem. viii. 37 ; Ord. Vit. 687 C, 694 D, which latter pasHage gives some details of hia actions after death. The genealogj' in DuCange, 1085, gives him as his wife a daughter of an auntof Duke William, whom Dr. Oliver (181) calls "Albreda the Conqueror's niece ;" but Orderic (687 C) seems to 8i>eak of her only as *' bona uxor." ' Domesday, 100. " In hac civitate sunt vaHtatae xlviii. domus pontquam Rex venit in Angliam." We may asuume tiiat these houses were destroyed to make way for the castle, though it is not expressly said that they were, as in some other places. ' See above, p. 146. * Domesday, 100. " Heec reddit xviii, libras per annum. De his habet B[aldwinus] >'icecomes vi. libras ad pensum et arsuram et Coluinus xii. libras ad numerum in miiiisteriis Eddid Iteginje. . . . lltec civitas T. K. E. non geldabat nisi quando Londonia et Eboracum et Wintonia geldabat ; et hoc erat dimidia marka argenti ad ojius militum." But even the tribute imposed by William was not largo for so great a city, when we find that Tawton paid fifteen pounds and Brampton sixteen. •itlOQ. CONQUEST OF THK WEST. 163 Lidford,^ mif'-ht seem to show that those two boroug^hs CHAP.xvm. were special scenes of resisUmce. Lidfbrd lay on the road towards Cornwall, into which |)eninsula William now marched. Whatever may have heen the zeal of their English landlords, the Breticealas themselves had no spe- cial motive to stnipi'fi^le aijainst one master on behalf of another, and whatever resistance William met with in that quarter was casilv ovorcomo.'^ Tlie conquest of Western England was thus complete, Confii.a\- and the usual processes of confiscation and division of lands .livlgf "„ „f now began. I say began, for of course, neither here nor ^*"^*'*- in any other part of the country, is it necessary to suppose that it took place altogether at once. In some cases it is plain that it did not. And here, as elsewhere, a few English- Enfjlishmen of rank contrived to win William's favour "J^.^.^ ^1* f obtained and to keep their lands and offices. One of these perhaps ff^vour. was Aiulf, a man who appears as Sheriff of Dorset, Aiulf ? and who may be the same as a landowTier of the same name in the reign of Eadward."^ A more certain case is ' Domesday, lOo ; Exon Domeadjiy, 80. Dr. Oliver (iSo) remarks that " this record shows that Lidford did not submit to the Conqueror until forty houses of the burgesses were dumDlished, nor Barnstaple until twenty-three houses were laid waste ; a proof of the deadly hostility of the townsmen against the Norman invaders." Tlie nuniber of burges-ses in Barn.staple T. R, E. was forty within the borough and nine without. Lidford had twenty-eight within the borough and forty-one without. Lidford, once more populous than Barnstaple, is now a very inconsiderable place. No destruction of houses is spoken of in the other Devonshire to^^'n8. ' Ord. Vit. 510 C. '' Ipse postea in C'nrnu I'ritanuiie ulterius contende- bat. Composito ubique motu quern deprehendit, exercitum iliinisit." ' Tlie entries about Aiulf may lead to the belief that there were two persons of the name. We have in Berkshire (63^, Wiltshire (73^ and Dorset (83 h, 83), an Aiulf, de.scribed as " V^iceconies" and " camerarius," hohling lands all of which haar iu« hindowniTH at tlio time of t!»o Survov. Must of thoin retaini'tl tlir landn which thov hatl thomwivrt hehl in the time of Kiiij^ luuhvanl. (\»lwino ikviiw aIt»o to have hivn th»' representativi' of tlie liMfv Lady in the city of Exeter.' This hir;»'e nuniher of Hi^i^ Devonsliirt* Tliej^s wlio rotainetl their hmds seems to TJjJ"" show that the greater jtart of the shire suhraittod easily •bit*. after the fall of the capiUd.^ Hut the most remarkable man, and the official of highest rank, amonj^ those who liMinoih won William's favour in the Western shires was I'julnoth, the hull«r. a nian who seems to have risen by the favour of Harold, who had held the office of Staller under butli Kadward and Harold, and who held lar<^e estates in various parts of Eng-land, but especially in tlie WVst. He became a zealous adherent of William and, as we shall presently see, died in his service. It is therefore almost certain that 1. of his he must have retained his lands; still onlv a small i)art of «itat«8 by I them passed to his son Harding, who, there is every reason to believe, was the ancestor of the great house of the Lords of Berkeley. Some pretext must therefore have lands bad passed to Norman owners. In Wiltsliire (74) we find among the King's Tbegns an Eathnund won of Aiulf holdirig landw which liis father had held T. R. E. This last person can hardly fail to have lx;en an English- man, but, as he can hardly fail to have been deml at the time of the Sur- vey, he can not well have been the Sheriff. It remains a question whether the Sheriff and the holder T. II. E. can be the same person. It should be noted that the Sheriff's largest estate, that in Dorsetshire, was partly an official and not a personal holding. Afler one of the entries (83) follows the comment, " banc tenet Aiulf de Itege quan)ito8i»ionH of the mh; of WoIIh.* I^Hjfric, \vli«> wa*< nt leact of Kn^liKh or TbptbMn Britinh Itirth. wan Ickh luoky ; he never olitaiiKil t)io aioff«a u> mttitutioii of the hiiuls at Topulinm rif which HnroUl K* i^ ^^^ **"^ ^^ have tlepriveil hiin.'J Within the comiueriil vHwiatioB city it*k>If A Bnmll tmnufer of ecrlesia.stical property took !i» ./ pla08towed for the same cause on the Old Minster of Winchester, passed away altogether from the Church, and lxH?ame part of the spoil of William's insatiable brother of Mortain.'' As William could have no motive for desjwiling the chief church of his own capital, and as we can hardly suspect him of going so far as to try to do Godwine an ill turn in the other world, this last alienation is more likely to bo due to some usurpation on the part of Earl Robert llian to any legal HiBtory of grant on the part of the King. Lastly, the fate of the i;Uciuan.' ^'*^^^^ of the patriotic priest Bla3cman illustrates at once the confusion of tenure so common at the time and also ' Hwtoriula, ap. Hunter, i8. " Prseoccupante autem ilium [Haroldum] judicio divins ultionis Dux victoriA potituH, quum regni gubemacula post eum husccpiBset, et a me dc injuria milii illati'i querimoniam audiisset, Wynesham ecclesijje resignavit, privilegio confinnavit," &c. On Banwell, see vol. ii. p. 639. This means that Wineshara came into the King's handi) by the forfeiture of yElfsige. I Hhould like to know more of one " Jobanncfl Danua " (Domesday, 89 b) who was also dispoHaessed in favour of the Bishoprick. • See vol, ii. p. 549. ^ {^g^ y^i jj p ^52. • Domesday, 104. " Ipsa ecclesia [de Labatailge] habet in Execestre eoclesiam Sancti Olaf." • See vol. ii. p. 352. The entry on Crowcombe in Domesday (91 h) w, *' Ecclesi* Sancti Suuithuni Winton, tenuit T. R. E." CONFISCATIONS AND GRANTS. 167 M illiam's constant desire to do formal justice as he under- cnAP.xrm. stood it. Blajcman's llii^ht was, as usual, held to he equivalent to outlawry, and his estates were seized. But, just as Henry of Ferrers had seized, not only the freehold lands of Godric, hut the lands which should have reverteart of the 8i>oil of the House of (todwine.^ Oeofircy of Mowl)niy Voceivwl nn oiuHosh lint of h^nlnhips in Soinerst^t, together with Hmallor poHsessionH in the other WetJtem sliires.^ Fresh j^ssetisions foil, as we have seen, loComi to the lot of Kustace of Boulop^e whon he recovered the favour of William, ' and few of the Iradini'' followers of the Conqueror went without their share in the new distrihu- ui Baldwin tion.^ Haldwin, who had Ixhmi left in command at Kxeter, and who drew his name from the eonquerce found in the roll-call of the conquerors. Well ni<^h the whole shire was granted to him. The list of his possessions, lands of Earl Harold, of the Sheriff Mierle- swegen, and of a crowd of smaller victims, is simply endless. Hardly any other landowners appear in Cornwall, except the Crown and ecclesiastical bodies. And the lands retained by the Crown are small compared with those in the hands of the Earl, and in favour of the Conqueror's brother the Church itself was not spared. The two great His rob- Cornish foundations, the two churches which laid claim to ^j^g be looked on as the episcopal sees of the West- Welsh diocese, ^^"/"c^ea of *■ '■ Bodmin were both shorn of their wealth to glut the insatiable ami Saint appetite oi the new Earl. Ihese were the church ot baint German, which bore the name of the missionary who had won back Britain from the Pelagian heresy,- and the more renowned house of Saint Petroc at Bodmin, a church which had won the favour of the West-Saxon conquerors,-' and which had l)ut lately yielded its episcopal rights to the capital of the West. Both alike were despoiled of many of their lordships to swell the vast possessions of Earl Robert."* Thus arose that great Earldom, and afterwards Duchy, of Cornwall, which was deemed too powerful to ' See his S|»iirt»iit lo tlie Crown. Hut the lamln of H<)U*rt in tin* WvM wrrc not cHinfinot! Hh wiaiiB to hin o\m 1'JirltIom. Tin* lortl of the wntATfalls heai>ed iJiiivMid top»thor manor u|>on manor amonj^ tho dafihin^ KtrraniH ^*^"*** of Devonshin* ami annmj^ the liilln and inlaiuls of JSomersot. And one sjwt came to liim l»y an exchange with an ecolcgia^ticnl luKly, thi> ])osHes8ion of whicli, like the \x>8' ■nnon of Pevensey, seemed to mark him out as the very cmhodiment of the overthrow of Kn^'-land. The hill of ' ' Lut«;:;iresl)urv, whence came the holy relic which had piven r.. I'n'rland her war-cry and whicli li:ul Ikmh the ohject of the life's devotion of her King*/ now passed into the hands of one who was to wipe out its name and memory. Tlic heig-ht, one of the peaked hills which form so marked a feature in the scenery of Somerset, was now crowned hy a castle of the new Earl, which, under the French name of !Montacute, l)ecame at once a badf'-c of the presence of the stranger and an object of the bitterest hatred to the men of the Western lands. - Rarity of In tracing: out the distribution of lands in the shires penional whicli fell into AVilliam's power after the surrender of ihe'walt, Exeter, we are struck at every step by the all but uiUir absence, among the dispossessed landowners, of names suggestive of ]5ntish origin. In Somerset, and even in Devonshire, this is not wonderful. Though much of British blood must have remained in those sliires, and though their originally British character was not yet wholly * See vol. i. p. 590 ; ii. i>. 440 ; iii. pp. 428, 480. ' DomeBclay, 93. " Ipse comes tene in dominlo Biscopestone, et ibi est caatc'Ilum ejus quod vocatur Montagud. Hoc manerium geldabat T. R. E. pro ix. hidis, et erat de Abb.itiA de Adelingi, et pro eo dedit Comes eidem eoclesis manerium quod Candel vocatur." In 92 is another entry, •* duo portarii de Montagud tenent de Comite Esturt," STATE OP CORNWALL. 171 forf>otten,* they had no doubt hy tliis time become to all cnAP.xvni. outward aj)pea ranee thorou«^hly Eni^lish. Even in local nomenclature, the British names, thouj^h common as compared with their rarity in the purely Teutonic parts of England, are still decidedly exceptional. But Corn- wall, I need not say, retained its British speech for ag^es alter this time ; the local nomenclature is mainly Celtic, and the ln or of Aii^jfliti/itl Uritonn. The r>Tiv««ibj Normaii ('on(|iu»i«t may very woll have ^ivi-n \\\v native *Q^^, element a fn»t»h »tart. Nowhere \va*i the (li8)M)8t, Ii6). So also RualJus Ailobed in Devonshire (114 b) suggests the Ruallus, that is Rhiwallon, of William of Poitiers, 1 10. See vol. iii. p. 233. He may not unlikely be the same man. * See hi8 estates in Devonshire, Domesday, loS f)-\ 10, and Cornwjdl, I 35. We have met with the name in different fonns, as Io}>wel, one of the WeUh princes who sought Eadward the Elder to Lord (see vol. i. p. 129), Judwal, Juchil or Judethil, one of those who rowed Eadgar on the Dee (Fl. Wig. 973 ; Will. Malm. ii. 148, 155), Juhcl Berengar in Biitanny in William I^ongsword's time (see vol. i, p. 207), and wu find (J)iMccitl as the ii.irae of a slave in Cornwall in Cod. Dipl. iv. 313. * Domesday, 162. " Sedecim domus erant ubi sedet castellum qute niodo desunt, et in burgo civitatis sunt wastage xiiii. s(> Imnd Ahlini «'*'**wi« to have faWon honvily <»n i'IitIch and layint'u aliko. ftprl^tHft* ^1*^ *^*^^ ^^^^ iiiKatialilo Hihliup of Buyeiix, ap|H'arH at n acOdo. later timo ainoiijf the tJ|K)iKT8 of the ('hurrh in this dis- triet^ and as he did not H|mre men of his own calling, neither ilid he Hpan> nu-n of his own nation. Ainonj^ Kn^litihmen we come aeroiw the well-known names of Saint Wulfstan the Hishop of the dichalf of the ri«^htH of the church of Worcester he braved the terrible Sheriff himself. Urse of Abetot was only the chief of a whole band of Norman sjwilers, who seem to have fallen with sjjccial cag-erness on the lands of the Church in this ])articular shire. But the Sherill' was the greatest and most daring of- fender of all. He built his cai>tk' in the very jaws of the monks of Worcester, so that the fosse of the fortress encroached on the monastic burying-ground.- Church and castle must thus have stood side by side over- looking the Severn. Complaint was made to the Arch- bishop, who came to the spot, examined the ground, and rebuked the King's officer to his face. To a Latin or French speaker the name of Urse might have suggested an easy play upon words. To the English Prelate, who reljukea ami curses Vr»e. 1068-1069 • On E.ildrccl*H B[K»liation of the church of Worcester, see vol. ii, p. 467. Of Lb ^ardianHhip and benefactions I nhall speak in Ap- pendix W. ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 253. " Ursus erat vicecomes Wigomiaj a Rege constitutus, qui in ipHJs pene faucibus monachorum caxtellum con- struxit, adeo ut fossatum ca-metorii partem decideret." The cawtle of WorcesUr is utterly gone, but the site to the south of the church is still well known. From the story of Saint Wulfstan, to be told in the next Chapter, we may infer that Oswald's church, then standing, did not staad on exactly the same site as the church of Wulfstan ; so that the rantle may have been still nearer to the church than it« site is now. 8UII. EALDRRD AND URSE. 175 appears as addressino^ the Norman Sheriliiii English verse, cHAP.xvm. it seems rather to have suggested a happy rime. "Hightest thou Urse? Have thou (Jod's curse" is the vigorous bit of English whieh is preserved to us. The rest we have only in the Latin of the narrator, but he g(x*s on to add, " and mine and all hallu\veii i'rtf, have \>u Godts /curf, eleganter in his verbis st;d dure nominum euphoniie alludens ; • Vocaris, inquit, Ursus ; luiht'iM Dei maltdictioncm,' et (quod Ani,dice non aj)posui) meam et onmium consccnitorum capitura, nisi castellum hinc amoveris ; et sciaa profecto quod progenies tua non diu de terra Sanctse Maria? haereditabitur." The apologetic way in whicli William quotes a few words of English reminds one of his difficulty about the names of the English shires : see vol. i. p. 382. ' See vol. iii. p. 112. ' Will. Malm. u. s. " Dixit ille implenda i\\v.v nn.s videimis impleta. Siquidem non multis annis filius ejus Kogerius patcrnaruiu possessiunem coni)M>.s, gravi Henrici Regis indignatione pulsus est, (|uod <^uemdam ix miniMtris regiis pnucipiti furore jussit interimi." 176 CtlXQURST OF WKSTRItN AND NORTnKKX KNttLANM). iHAr iTiit without nn vxnci tiato. 'Hie mnition t»f l-jiKlntl liowcvor (•tmMi*« ui» to fix it to n time not Inter than the yciir rrn>|«.r»l followiuf^ the takings of Kxeter.' Nor ran we j^ive a date ti , : to the Mvular eommis8ion whuh, if we may trust the liH'al higlon* of Kve>hjnn, /KtlielwiLr rtveivitl at home \ i time or other from William'H handH. This eomminRion e!«ith*Hl him with lur«»'e authority in several Hhires, in some of whieh it is plain that, at the time of the fall of Exeter, AVilliam had no authority gave such as he derived fn>m the nominal yuhmission of I'^dwine. yKthelwig" is de8cril)ed as chief ruler, or at any rate as chief jud^^e, in no less than seven shin's, Worcester, Gloucester, Oxford, Warwick, Hereford. Statford, and Shropshire.'^ We naturally susjn'ct exa«,'<^eration, but there is no reason to (loul)t eitluT yKthelwiy^'s early submission to Williani or liis lastin;^ favour with him/' He appears as already trusted by the Conqueror in a story whieh not improbably belongs to the time which we have now rcadud, and which seems to preserve a record of the strug-gle which led to llie Norman occupation of the two Hwiccian shires.' We * Ealdred died in September, 1069. ' Hist. Eves. 89. " Et quoninm Rex sapiens cognovernt eum virum prudent.em, pene omneH Iuijuh gentis hoiiiineH Hneculari sapientift ])necellcn- tem, commiHit ei curam istarum partium terra, videlicet, WirecestreBcire, Glouecestrescire, OxenefordHcire, et Wareuuickescire, Herefordscire, Sta- fordscire, ^crobschire, ita ut omnium hujus patrise consilia .atque judicia fere in eo penderent. Et non solum in iwlis partibus, sed etiara jier totam Angliam ubicumque veniebat, tam Franci quam Angli pro juatiBsimd lege teneV>ant quidquid ipse legibus saecularibua dicebat." ' See above, p. 77, and Appendix W. * The doubtful language of the Winchcombe writer preserved in the Monasticon, ii. 302, preserves at least the tradition of a severe struggle in this district. " Si vero sint qui scribunt Winchecombensium et Peme- cborensium monasteria, tempore quo Wiliielmus Normannorum Dux sibi regnnm subjugaverat, longe majora atque plura quam modo habuisse poflieocriones et dominia, sed quia minus caute sibi de futuris prospicientes, elegerunt eidem Willielmo Duci pro viribus resistere aut eum forte debellare, ideo dicunt eumdem Willielmum Regem, vehementer in eos commotum, abstulisse plurima ex eorum possessiouibiis, et ea pro huSl voluntate aliis j»iis locis contulisse. Verum an ha?c aliquid veritatis STORY OP .'ETHKLWIO AND GODRIC. 177 get glimmerings of li^htin*^ oii the Lorders oi ihoai' bhires, chap.xvih. which ended in a GhiUcestci-shire Ahbut lM.'int: cntiuj^ttJ ^^'*';^*^ *^ on the to tht) safe kcH'piiig u4' hih brother in WOrct^bUTiihirt*. Hwiccuui Godne, Abbot of Winehcombt*, whone a|>])ointmeut to tliat monastery w as recordt^l iu an eurlioj Chapter/ is set bi'tore Ke»wUnc« UB as tlio leader oi patriotic movements in that qiuirter. j.riH.mment His opposition was thoucrht ot importance euoiitrh to ca.ll, !'. *, ? "V ' » r« I try ' (nKlrlc ui not nierely tor demivation or outlawry, but lor personal ^^ini^h- / . . . f'>Tiibe. restraint. The monastery was despoiled of many of its possessions; Godrie himst;lf was at lirbl put in ward at Gloucester, and was afterwards entrust«'d to the milder keej)ing of ^iilthelwi*^, to whom also the care of the Abbey itself was entrusted for three years, till a successor for Godrie was found in a Norman named (Jaland or Waland.* The exact date of these events is not to be fixed, and it must remain uncertain wliether they were connected with the movement in the AVest which I have just recorded or with the movement in the North which I shall presently have to record. But it seems plain that Gloucestershire was fully subdued at some 8taf>e of the h:i)>«aiit, necne, cum ea in nostris antiqiiitatibua nusqimnv legerim, non audiin scribert. Meniini tamen me, apud monayteriiun Eveshai^ipiensiuni, in eorum antifjuisriiniia historiis olim legisse, Willielniuni Ducem Nonuau- norum, tunc Angluruin Kegem, Gotlricuni Abbatem Winchelcumbensem \iolenter tenuiHse, *c in ca«tro Gloucestrioe juBsisse retriKli custodiendum, Wiuchelcumbenfitque cujnobium Abbatls p]vesliammen.siura mnilerationi coinniendis-se, et paulo post cuidani nionacho ex Nornianiiorum, ut credi- tur, genere, Galando nomine, illud idem Winchecumbense monasterium contuliree regxnduni. Quo reveril fieri umqtmm baud potuit nisi (ut com- njunis se babet fania) i'ieni Willitlimis lu.x in Al)batem hujus loci fui.sset vehementer ejiacerbatua." * See voL ii. p. 36a. ■^ The account of (iodricin the Kv«.shjuu liisU^ry (90) runs tliiw ; " Rex WillieUuug tollens Abbatom Wincelcund)enseni, Godricum nomine, fecit conutitui in captivitatu apud Ciloecentre, moxque huic Abbati, Agt'luuio Huam abbatiam commuit, quaiu fere per trea annos quasi propriam in cuncti.H gubeniando servavit. Deinde Rex donavit Ulam cuiilam Abl)»ti (ialando nomine, et eo post modicum tempun ex quo earn accepit defuncto, iterum isfci Abbati Ageluuio cunimittitur." In the next Chapter we shall come acrosfl a record of (iodric's sojourn at Kvetdiaju. VOL. IV. N 178 CONQUEST OF WB8TRRN AND NOUTIIKUN KX(JLANl). eaAfariti. y«ir which wo have now nsichtt!, wiul I \\i\\'v cHmms'ttnl it with tho Wrstoni movement Ihsuiim* (lir suhjuj^tion of Ghtmx'jitoruhire i< at leant connwtotl witli it in iilea. All Tho conquoft of (tlouccsU'rvhin* put into Williain'n ImnilM tho wholo of tho former Knrldoin of IlaroUl, c'xtv|»t tho », cK>rnor i»f Horofonli*hin» which was ntill drfciuletl l)y luidric tho WiUl. Ono thinj^ is tH;rt«in, that \\\r parent morcluint , . jj^j lioroujfh on tho Iwnlors of Mcrcia and Woswx was in NVillianrs powor, and was not disposed to revolt u^-ainst him. The castle of Bristol is famous in the wars of the next cen- tury, but then* is no reconl of its foundation in tho Survey.' WiUiAoi William, now concjueror of all southern and western KA«ur»t Knglaiid, returned to his southern eapitiil and kept the ui Marrh ^^^^ Feast, accordin**: to the custom of his predecessors, i3. 1068. in the royal city of Winchester.^ There mij^ht Eadj^yth, while her mother, sister, and niece were seekin;^ shelter in their lonely island, receive all the honours due to the widow of a King. Her lands in the West had been spared, and her royal home in her dower city was still hers. Hut she was not long to enjoy her position as the highest of her Matilda scx in England. William now deemed that his Kingdom cuineH to 1 f 1 • j 11 1 • •/» 1 Knglaiid. ^^*8s secure enough lor hmi to call on his wife to come and share liis honours. An honourable embassy was sent to the Duchess- Regent in Normandy to invite her presence in England.-' She came with a train of clerks and lords and noble ladies ; and among the churchmen in her company one is specially recorded, Bishop Guy of Amiens, ' Bristol ia simply mentioned in Domesday (163) under the bead " In Ber- tune apud Brihtoet of the f^eat battle.^ His work was alivady cHAP.xvm. written, perhaps as a hiiireate's otlerin*^ at the ^reat solem- nity whieh was presently to take plaee. For at Pente- William cost Kiu<^ AVilliam, again walkin**- in the steps of his iCntecoHt predecessor, wore his Crown at Westminster. And there *'.^^*^*^ * nunster. in the church which had beheld his own anointing", though >iatiiiia is doubtless in far other iniise than the wild tumult of the ^"r'.^i"*^ ^^ great Midwinter-day, the Lady Matilda was hidlowed to May n, Queen by Archbishop Eaklred. The law which had marked the crime of Eadburh by lessening the dignity of the wife of the West-Saxon King was now repealed or forgotten, and the consorts of English Kings have ever since shared equally with their husljands in all the lionorary dignities and j)riviK ges of royalty.^ § 3. The First Conquest of the North. Summer and Autumn, 1068. All for the moment now seemed quiet. William had IN.sitiim of assured his dominion over the West, and the chiefs of the j^,j^| ^^ North were still at his court in a character which did '"^'"^•l^^rf. not greatly differ from that of hostages. Eadwine and Morkeve were William's Earls ovei* Mercia and Deira, as \A illiam Fitz-Osbern was his Earl over Herefordshire and Bishop Odo over Kent.'- But it was his policy to * Ord. Vit. 510 C. " Protinus ilia mariti jussis libenter obedivit, et cum ingenti fTe«|uentiu virorurn ac nobilium feiiiinaruui transfrctavit. In clero qui ad diviiia ei miui-strabat, Celebris Guido Ambiauorum Pnesul eminebat, qui jam certamen Henildi et Guillelmi versifice descripserat." See vol. iii. pp. xxvi. 136, 377. ' Chron. W ig. 1067. " And sona after pam com Mathild seo hUtfdie hider to landu, and EaMred arceblsceop hig gehalgode to cirdiie on Westmynstre on Uwitan Sunnan dieg." Ord. Vit. 510 D. " Adclredus Eboracorum metropolitan U8, qui maritum inunxerat, Matildem aiml rt^iitl, uiid lie liiid tried to win him vvcr l»y u {trumiHe, whrthur Kincert^ (it dvmfifnedly A.Uu.ht*^ lUuAjrT* uf the hand of cnm ut* Uin thiu^^hterji. H»r iuliiM| I'f U iliuua it**.!, . Ill 1 1 (AT 4ui»«tl whether MaldiU t»r A^itlui, I tw not ]>n'tend to dotermin*, ** » ^ ^ there lieouiH every ri'uwon to l)elieve that, whatever miiy • »nr. but • •' U»c luAT. hnve biH»ii the ohjeets of William, a renl attiichment had UycJ. tipnmK' up l»etwt»en the Norman maiden unom|)li!4hment of hLs wiHho8. It is to bo noticed Uiut of Normaa ^® brea<.'h of fnith is distinctly attrihuted, not to William's prejodioe. q^.,j ^l^.j^ju-nj;^ l^ut to the had counsel of «omo of hi« Normaji advisers.' There is something <^r()tcs(|ue in the notion of William the Great bein^ led astray, like -^thelred or Eadward, by the arts or the advice of any man. But it is yuite possible that a feeling" of contempt towards the conquered nation, whiili William assuredly did not share, may have already grown up among" William^ Gorman followers. Eadwine^ wo are told, had won the Ipve of William's courtiers as well as of William himself.'^ Still they may have looketl on a marriage with the native Earl of now.or it may belong to the short time in 1070 -1071. botween the real con- quest of .Staffordshire and the la«t revolt of E;idwiue. The writ in followed by another addrtKHcd to Archbiwhop E:\ldred, Bishop Wulfstan. Earl Williani /Fitz Osbem), and all the ThegnH in GlouceHterfiiiire and WorcesterKhire. * Ord. Vit. 511 A. "Guillelmus Rex, quando Eduinus Comes cum eo ooncordiani fecerat [see above, p. 20] .... filiani suam ee in conjugem ei datuniin sixjpondemt ; wed po8tmo\nth rei,'ard to \Villiani'8 treatment of Morkere; '* Rex (!iiilltlriiiis, fonsilio jiravoruin Tn:il(! uhus, laudi ana? damnmn ingessit." • When Orderic (521 B) records the death of Eadwine, " fonnoHisHiraua juvfcnia EduinuH Comes," he add^, "audita per Angliam Eduini morte, iQctUfl ingenx non nolum Anglis sed etiam Xonnaimis et Francis ortus est; qui eum relut socium et amicum seu dognatum cum multis fletibun planienmt." POSITION (jK KADVS'INE. 181 the ^fon-ians as iinworthv <>f a daiv^'hU'r of the conqm»rin<>* cnxp.xvin. Kiiio^ of the Eni*-lish. And to a prejudice of tliis kind William may have fuoTid it netnlfnl to show some deference. But it is fjTiite as likely that it was Williamn own yiolicy which M him to fry to keep P^adunne still more depcTulent upon himself hy constantly promising- and never fulfillinj^'. However this mav he, the marriaijre was delayed, and the Indiana- atifij^r of Eadwine was further kindled aj^ainst William. Eadwine. The position of the two hrothers must have h^-en irksome and dci>'radino' enoug;h in any case, and the further wrong- done to Eadwine hrong-ht matters to a head. The sons of Revolt of /Klft^r, the Normans Bay, openly reK'lled.' The view of brothere. the people of their Earldoms would doubtless be that they at last came back to head them ag-ainst a l'oreio;'n invader to wliom, thou<,''h they had submitted, their people never had. At this moment then, when the AVest had jnst sub- Rising in mitted, the North rose. As yet no st«'p had been taken Summer, for its practical subjugation, and the men of Mercia and ^°^'^- Northumberland had now their natural chiefs to head them. There was little in the past career of Eadwine and Position ^forkere to prive any gr>od g-round of hope for any under- ,acter of takings >>cgun under their lead. But in Northumbrian ^^"^^"*^- eyes the acts by which they had undone England, their successive betrayals of Harold and Eadg-ar, and, still more, their earlier share in the revolt against Tostig, might seem praiseworthy assertions of the independence of Northern England. Absence too and di.stance would work their usual work. The forced presence of the Earls in William's court would look like imprisonment ; their visit to Normandy would look like banishment. They might thus seem entitled ' Onl. \ it. 511 A. ''Kodfiii anno egregii jviven(H Kiiuinus ct Mot- oaruH, filii Klfijari Coniitia, rebellaverunt, et cum fis jniilti alii fcrocitor inHurrexfrunt, quorum niotus Albionis regnuiu vehemouter turbftvorunt. .... Ffluinus . . . iratus cum fratn; auo ad rcbellionom incitntiH est." (h» the ditt'crent account-s of these events, in no way coiitnidictory to each other, but every one strangely imperfect, see Appendijc Y. 18S coxgrKST ok wbstkrn* and NOKTIIKUN knoland. iHAr xviii toclAim •omewhnt oftho honoiirH ofoonft^ssors in thr luitiMiial ctiUMN Add to this thnt, ]M>)iti(*n)ly wortiiloHH a» Kudwino doarly \vaj». Iio pliiiiily jhihsckhihI iiiaiiy of thow HUiu'rlicinl nttrartions wliioli ofton havo n 8tn>np'r indiuMico on inon than the )n^)u*st wit^lom and virtue. His hi^h hirtli and offiiH*, \m han«l8i>nio |>or«<)n and winning aoken of as a common movement of English and Welsh. "^ 1055- The league between ^Elfgar and Gnitlydd the son of Llywelyn * seems never to have been forgotten. Welsh allies had joined the revolted Northumbrians in their 1065. march to the Gemots of Northampton and Oxford.-^' It is not clear what amount of understanding may have existed between Eadric of Herefordshire and the Mercian Earls ; but we have seen Eadric ])owerfully supported by the Ci\Tl WW reigning Welsh Princes Bleddyn and Rhiwallon.'^ Bleddyn Winter*^ had now, by the result of a civil war, become sole sovereign 1067-1068. of at least all North Wales. Bleddyn and Rhiwallon, ' Ord. Vit. 511 A. ** Fervcns adfectus erat prajfatis fratribus erga Dei cultum et bonorum reverentiam hominum. Erat eis ingens pulcritudo, nobilia et ampla cognatio, late valens potentatua et nimia in coh popularium dilectio." So .it a later stage (521 B) ; " Idem [EduinuH], ut Hupra dictum est, fucrat ex rcligiosa parentel& natus, multimiue bonis dedituH, prout poterat inter tanta saecularium curarum inipedimenta poKitus. Corporis pulcritudine in multis millibus emincbat, et clericorum atcjue monacliorum paui>erunujue benignus amator erat." ' lb. 51 1 A. ** A cleria et monachis crebra pro illis fiebat oratio et a turbJH fiauperum quotidiana Bupplicatio." ' lb. " Eum magna pars Anglorum et Gualorum sequuta est." * See vol. ii. p. 387. ' See vol, ii. p. 490. • See above, p. 110. STATE OF WALES. 183 whom the Eiii^-lish make brotherii of (jrutF) dd,' apjH'ar chap.xvui. in the Welsh Chronicles as sons of Cenwyn,- and we liiid them about this time en;»Ti^ed in a war with two of their countrymen, described as Meredydd and Idwal, sons of Gruffydd.'^ A battle took place at Mechain in Powys, in Battle of 1 • 1 1 1 1 • • T 1 1 i> 11 • Mechain; which tlie brother princes were victorious. Idwal leli in death ..f battle, and Meredvdd, (Ivin^? from the i\M, .lied of the J'*'^;?"""' cold,' a description which seems to fix this campaign to the »«'« Under- same winter which beheld William's return from Nor- mandy. Jkit the victory was purchasetl by the death of Rhiwallon, and the struj^gle seems in some way to have led to a division of the g-reat dominion of GruHydd the son of Llywelyn. Bleddyn reigned alone in Gwynedd and Powys, but Deheubarth or South Wales is spoken of as being under the rule of another Aleredydd, the son of Owen the son of Etwin, one of a house of which we hoard in the days of ^^Cthelred. ' The language of the one writer who narrates these events Holding of in any detail seems to describe the holding of an assembly presence of which must have been designed as a general Gemot of the ^''*^ ^^yl=»l»- Empire, at which the chief men of Wales as well as of ' 8ee vol. ii. p. 476. Orderio, it may be remembered (see vol. ii. p. 630^, makes BluiMyn a .son of CIruffydd »T,nd Ealdgyth ; he now remembers tlie BUpposed kindred, and speaks of Eadwine and Morkere as Bleddyn's uncles (511 B); " BlidenuH Rex Guallorum ud aninculos suos suppetias venit." ^ They are so culled under 106S ])oth in the Annales Cambiiie and in the Brut y Tywysogion.but the Brut under 1073 ^*>ems to speak of BIcddyn as (JrufFydd'a brother." ' Idwal in the Annales, Ithel in the Brut. Here are further forms of the name spoken of in p. 1 73. * Ann. Camb. 1068. " Bellum Methein inter fdios Kenwin, scilicet Bledin et Kuallo et filios Grifini, scilicet Maredut et Idwal, in quo filii Grilini ceciderunt, Idwal bello, Maredut frigore, Ruallo etiam filius Kenwin, occisus est." So Brut y Tywysogion in anno. * Tlie Brut say.s, " Bledtlyn, son of C^Tivyn, held Gwynedd and Powys, and Maredudd, son of Owain, son of Edwin, held South Wales " [Deheubarth]. (On ICtwin see vol. i. p. 313.) The Annals say simply, ** Bledin in regnum succeHsit." It should be remembered that the Welsh writers do not mention the investiture of Bleddyn an»NQt*Birr or wkstrilk and nortiikun knqland. CBAFavm. KnirUiid AppMrnd.' The |frieTanc4« o( the \vhti)i> country w«f>t ftmni^y M't (ortii. mid it wan tlettrnnini'd to »c*ok iur ^^* h«lp in I'Vwr)' ciuartur. Mi^iwiMij^tTH wriv M'lii tn ever)' pari of Kll^-land to siir up tJte )xv)|»lu. Thoy of cotirae wont opi'uly tiO thi* {Mirt« which weru still inili'ptMulrnt, and thoy* j(cot «»oci\*tly to thu shires whidi were alrtitdy under the yoke." The rMoIution to di'fcnd or to rooover their aucicnt frtt^Iom vios widely B]»rpnd and iirmly fixed in the luiirtd of r«.».hl« Eo^flislimon.* Nor \va« the ohanco of fonMtrn aid ni^leoted. c«>nvort m>:!. ti»o It in not dear whether it was in concert with this Xort-hern HArt4ti raovonu«it Uiat the gons <»r Hanild and their Irinh allies pre«entJy attiinpted to return. The only dilliculty in the \Tay of sucJi a sup]>o«ition is the rivalry which liad ho lonj^ rei4>:nes«r«i4 gtjneml. Wc seena also to «:et glimpses of further a])plioa- njArk; tions to Swcud of Denmark,* and there can bo no doubt with Mai- tliat it wiw as a part of this same general movement that c«>ltn of 1 • 1 o 1 1 1 • 1 1 1 s*.x>tiAnd. Communications were opened with Scotland which led to a chain of events of the hif^hcst moment in the history of both Northern and Southern Hritiiin. Our history just at this time has to be put together in so piecemeal a way that it is not easy to arrange events in their exact order, or even always to assign their proper share in them to each of the actors. It is not, for instance, perfectly ' Ord. Vit. 511 B. " Blidenus . . . venit, seoumque multitutJincui Britnnum addujtit. Congrof^atis autem in unum multis Anglorum et Guallorutn optimatiburf, fit generaliH ({uerimonia^lo injuriiH et oppresiiionibus 4uibuH iutoicralniiter Angli affligebantur a Noniiaunis et eorum oon- tubernalibux " — tliat is, the foret^ meroenarlefl. ' lb. " LegationibuH quoHciinique poterant per omnes Albionw terralnos in hootefl cUm palamque Htiinulal^ant." ' Fit ex Gonseniiu omnium fro verulkandd libcrtate prUtina procax con- Bpiratio et obnixa oontnt, NormannoH crjnjuratio.'' * Hist. Ab. i. 493. " Tare gentem JJaiiorum ut Angliam appeteret illicere." GENERAL MOVEMENT AOAIXST WILLIAM. 183 clear what was at this moment tin* position of Ka(l«»'ar, cuap.xviii. the yKtholiiUJ:, the monuMitary Kin^. But on tlie whole it I*'«'iti"" of seems most jjrobiible that he was the nominal head of the probably movement, and tliat whatever was done was done in his ^^^^ jj^.^^j name as the Kiny alrciuiv luwfullv chosen.^ Such a doc-"^^* " - * movement. trine raii^ht not be acoej)table to the sons of Harold ; it mii^ht not he acccj)table to Swend of Denmark ; it mi^ht not be acceptable in their heart of hearts to the two Earls by whom the iilthelin^' had already been once betrayed. But there was no one round whom so many varyin*^ interests and associations could <^ather as round the last representative of the House of Cerdic. Whatever Action of the brother Earls may have done, the Northumbrians in emThegna. <^eneral seem to have accepted Eado-ar in ^ood faith. They were ])erhaj>s not without a remembrance of that earlier Ead<:^r, who had. found his way to the West-Saxon throne by Northumbrian help, and whose name abode on North- humbrian tonj^ues as the embodiment of just and good g-oveniment, till his memory was overshadowed by the more recent memory of the Danish Cnut.^ At the head of the Gospatric. Northern movement stood Gospatric, who had, not many months before, been invested by William with the Bernician Earldi.m.'^ William's jealousy seems up to this time to have kept him idle in his court along with his fellow-Earls of the house of Leofric, while the province which he nominally held under the Norman King* still retained its perfect inde- pendence. Next in rank to Gospatric was the Sheriff Mfcrle- Maerle- swegen, whom Harold had left to command the North after *'^^^^^"* the great day of Stamfordbridge/ and who now jeoparded the distant possessions which he held in AVilliam's latest conquest of Cornwall.'" Hardly lower in local esteem than ArchilL these great chiefs was Archill, who is described as one of the ' On the order of events, see Ajipomlix \ . ' 8ee vol. i. pp. 67, 46 J. ' See above, p. i.^. * Sec vol. iii. p. 421. * 8ec above, p. 169. 186 CX>Xgl KST Of WKsreUN AND XORTHKUN KN(JLANI). 'Jnrm. iDOSt powerful Thef^ni of NortluinilMTlund,' uml whoti* vumI (vUtc^ti htn*tchcd, if not, like lhoM» of Mirrletiwefpen, from Yorkshirv into (\»nnvall, yvi fmm Vorki«liin' into tlie \Umikv of Si>uth-M(>nanitionH, or else HooUtfh tile whole movement liatl fallen throu^-li before hiu troopg rpg»»«n. yjj Ih? jfot topi'thcr. For we have to tell the same talc tbe more- which \vc have ever to toll in the Kuirlish historv of Hj^^j^j^j, these years, nave when a born Kinpf of Men, an Kadmmul the foil ure ^,r ji HaroKl, stands forth ati the leader of a peoiile worthy of ihc two . R\rU. of him. As in the days of yKthelred, as in the days of the Interrej^nnm, as at the sieg-e of Kxeter, the zeal and couraj^^ of A whole people were attain brouglit to nought by the cowardice and selfishness of incompetent leaders. Oeneml The blood of the nation was thoroughly roused. Every xeal of the i • i i i i i -vt r l*ople. town which was as yet unchecked by a Norman fortress or a Norman garrison looked well to its rami)arts and made York the rcjidy for resistance. The metropolis of Northern England set the example. What Exeter was in the West, York was rv>'U(tanLx-. in the North. It was the centre of every patriotic move- Vain meut/ where all the mild i)iety of Ealdrcd strove in vain to tMrxti keep down the burning zeal of its eager citizens.'* But it was ifwir^^ not the towns only ; every defensible spot, woods, marshes, ' Ortl. Vit. 511 C. ** Archillus potcntistiimus Nordanhimbroruin." ' See Ellin, ii. 41. ' Ord. Vit. 511 D. " Malcolmus licet ab Anglis requisitus fuerit, et validam expeditionem [fyrdj in e«»rum auxilium paraverit." * Tbe declamation of William of Mabncsbury (iii. 248) in in tnith a nctble panegjTic on tbe city ; " Eboracum, uuicuin rebellionum Kuffugium . . . ibi enim Rex Scotorum Malcolmus cum suis, ibi Edgarus et Marcherius ct Weldeofus cum Anglic et Danis, nidum tyrannidis stepe foveb.ant, sa^pe duces illius [Willebni] trucidabant." Mark tlie use of (yrannis. See vol, i. pp. 152, 269. • Ord. Vit. 511 B. " ElK)racen8i8 civitas ardentiasime furit, (|uam sanctitaa Pontificis aui sedare nequit." ZEAL OF THE NORTH. 187 mouths of rivers, were all seizwl upon and streni»lhened in cuAr.xvni. readiness for an attack.' Men thou«^ht it shame to dwell at such a time under the sljadow of a house. Tlie wild The men, the savages, as the mocking tongues of the Normans called them, dwelled of their own choice in tents and lurk- ing-places, lest their strength should grow rusty among the comforts uf their own roof-trees.^ All this is credible enough ; but it is hard to fix the chronology, and it is almost harder to believe the tale of a general conspiracy throughout England to massacre all the Normans during the penitential solemnities of Ash Wednesday. The plot, Legend of we are told, failed through the sudden return of the great conspiracy, warrior, who is thus conceived as being absent from England at the time when he was winning his great suc- cesses in the AVest. The malecontents, it is added, with- drew into the inaccessible North, and there for a while withstood the royal power.-* That such a tale as this is wholly legendary it is hardly needful to prove. Thus mutters stood in northern and central England not very long after William had brought over his Queen to enjoy the honours of royalty in the conquered land. News The news was presently brought to the King that the folk in the Wiiijam. North were gathered together, and that they would stand * Orel. Vit. 5 1 1 B. " Seditiosi silvas, paludes, aestuari.'i, et urbes aliquot in munimentis huhent," The " urbes aliquot " would doubtless take in all the walled towns of the indej)endent shires. ' lb. C. " Plures in tabemaculis morabantur ; in domibus, ne moUesce- rent, requiescere dedignabantur, unde quidam eorum a Normannis s'dvatici cogTiotiiinnl)antur." See above, p. 1 1 1, of Ea Iric of Herefordsliire. ' Will. Gem. vii. 40. " Ipse vero in regnuni remeans Anglicuin, iterato plurimos ejusdem gentis repperit, quorum levia corda ab ejus fidclitate pr.fvaricatrix conspiratio averterat. Conjuraverant enim latrunculi per totain patriam, (juatinns milites, quos ad tuendum rognum relitjuerat, in capite jejuni nudis vestigiia, quo solet usu poenitens Christianorum religio, a«i ecclesiam festinantea incautos ubique perimerent, et sic ipsum a Nor- mannis regredientera levius e regno proturbaront." He then goes on to speak of their taking up a position at Durham, which I shall have to H|>eak of presently. \M loNgrRnT or wrstkrn and ^ORTHKHN knoland. cwAr.xinii m»»ififft him if \\o »rtmo ' l*r»»*Hil»ly th<* |iri*H«'no«» nF I'.rtMnMl rtt York. HO jkwn jiOor tht» ^^ront ron'mrtny at WoHtminntor, nntl lu« jittint<» nnd to Htrrni'-thoii them with > mstW.* On«* vrrnion, a version n»stin^ more on infrw^not* ^.^ ^,, .\ than on dinvt authority, would lead uh to think that ftt t^uwiion t^hi.H time (Hford f»till hold out, that tho touii was tjtkcn ■A to iko l>v Htorm, and that the f^carfiil dovastntion nvorded in thi» OxfunJ- Snrver wa« the result.^ if suoh was tlic hof*innin^ <»f William'H tirst Nortlu'm rtimpniy-n, wo can woU underMjind the torror-strikinp: uHt'ct of Huch a Mow dealt nt nnch a moment. But the direet evidence for a sie<>e of Oxford is bo weak that the tale cannot he relied on with any certainty. WiUUm At Xlie first place where William's presence is distinctly re- corded is \> arwnck. That to\NTi was one of tho series of Fuunda- strong'holds Ity which the renowned Lady of the Mercians, to"wii\y ^ ^^'^ daughter of /Elfred, had sought to put a hridle in the j-U.belJia,-wt t>tet folc be norSan hatfdom beom gegaUerad tog:edere, and wpldon liim ongean standan, gif be come." ' Ord. Vit. 511 C. "Rex igitur HeceasuB regni providentius perlustra- vit, et oppc^tuna loca contra excunaones hostium coranaunivit.** . Itia now that Ordcric tankc» that remark on the lack of cagtles wliich I quote^l long ago. See voL ii. p. 140. ' On the date of the taking of Oxford, see Appendix Z. * Chron. Wig. 915. "Her on ^i^on geare wien Wtfrincwic getimbrod." Florence (in anno) addh that it was founded "in fine auctumju,";,^ i,, ,;*.-.;.j< WILLIAM AT WATUVICK. 189 appears iu the Survey us one of the very ffw Ki»w:li&luaen cH.vp.xvin. retaining or jK>s>o:?Hiii^ estates which put them at all on a level with William's ^reat Norman ^auteeH. He was Probable the tion oi -.hltwine, who seems to have heeii olierili at tiie ^^.:ifwine time of William's entry, and who evidently made his peace ^^'^ '"^I'^nff- with the Cuiujueror.' Thurkill kept his lauds, which Were largely increased hy royal grants out of the confis- cated estiites of less lacky Knj^lislunen. Kor amonp his Landa of jK)S3essions a sixudl part only had been held by his father xhurkill. in King- Kadward's days; tlje greater j)art had been the property of various English owners, amonj:^ whom we dis- cern Earl Eadwine, another Eadwine described as the Sheritr, and the greater name of Ilereward. It is i)ainful, Few Eng- on looking tlirou^h the Warwickshire Survey, to compare jj^ war- the vast estates of Thurkill with the two or three other ^vkkshire. Thegns of the shire who retained some small fragments of their property.- It is plain that here, as elsewhere, the men of the shire at large were patriotic, and paid the penalty iu the confiscation of their lands. The one loyal man, the one prudent man, the one traitor, as he would be called in the mouths of his more stout-hearted countrymen, reaped his reward, in retaining his wealth and honours, and in adding ta tbem alike at the cost of a less successful fellow-traitor and at the cost of men better than himself. William thus held Warwick, and we Ciui hardly doubt William's that he held it through the adherence, either now or at Mercia some earlier time, of the Sherilf /Elfwine and his son. ^^'fe^"**- ' On iElfwine and Thurkill, see Appendix AA. ' See Domesday, 344, 244ft. Two women hold land in "alms," Eatlgj'th who kept her o>^n estate, and Leofgrifu the nun, whose landft hrvd been held T. K. E. by God^pfu, widow of Ijeofric. /EUwi^'e, Ordric, and (jodwine had kept their land.M, thouj^di tliose «)f Ordric were waste. /Elfrie had landa which had been held by Wichig. The only one remaining holder is Leofwine, who holdH two very .small ostates. Of ono we read, " Hie Ticuuinua omit ab Aluuino fratre huo." He may have been the Sheriff'u brother. TIh,\so men are not given the title of Thej^n. They are the only Enj^lish tenants in rapite, though of course there are En>,'IiHh undertenants. 190 CONQUEST OP WB8TKRN AND KoUTHRRN ENGLAND. our^nii. IIo had now paused out of thoHo Inndx, Wi^t-Snxon. VjmU An^liAii, niul MiToian. whirh hiul hvvu for n lon^vr or •hortor timo tinilrr tlio rule i»f the H«»uho of (I<»(hvinr. IK* tuul euU'rtHl thone Htrictly Morfinn lands over which tlic House of Lcofric had, sine** their j^reat rise under (^nut, alwars retaineil at h»ast a superiority. Warwiekhhire had ]Hrha]>s Ikhmi hehl hh a 8ul>onlinate j^vernment hy Halph and Oihhi. hut t!u» Hwieeian landH had revertxd to the nde of Lcofric or his son.' and William was now 8<*ttin^ forth to estahlinh hin efltK'tivc supremaey over tho Karl- dom of Eadwine, the old realm of Olla and Cenwulf. He was in truth setting forth to conquer a new Kinj^lom. And, unless we accept the version which rejiresents Oxford as being- stormed durinsi^ the campaif^n of this year, War\N'ick was the firntfruits of his conc|uest. The new possession had to he g-uardcd in the usual way. Whatever bulwarks survived from the days of yEthelllad were deemtnl worthless in the recent advance of the defensive Founda- art. Warwick could bo safely guarded only by a castle Warwick ^^ the newest Norman pattern. Yet in this case at least Castle. ^jjp works of the defender of England have proved more lasting than the works of her Conqueror. The new town which arose at the bidding of the Lady of the Mercians, stood on a slightly rising ground at a small distance from the sluggish stream of the W^arwickshirc Avon. For the defence of her new creation, the Lady reared between the town and the river one of those vast artificial mounds which played so important a part in the early history of fortification. Whatever works, whether of stone or of timber, crowned or surrounded it in its first estate have utterly passed away, and the crest of the artificial hill is crowned by defences of a far later date tlian the days of either iEthelflad or William. But the mound itself still remains, a monument of the wisdom and energy of ' See vol. ii. jjp. 563-565, FOUNDATION OF WARWICK CASTLE. 191 the mit^hty daug-liter of /Eltred, while the keep of chap.xviii. William has so utterly perished that its van' site can only now be <,^uessed at. Most likely it stood in the void space between the mound, the ^-ateway, and the later eastle, whose picturesque turrets and battlements han<^ so j)roudly over the river at its feet. At all events, it was now that that famous fortress took its bejjinning. Either because the town passed peaceably into the hands of the Conqueror, or because the site of the fortress stood more than usually isolated from the town, the building of the castle seems to have involved a far smaller destruction of houses than was commonly the case elsewhere.^ Thus Its later arose the renowned castle of Warwick, famous alike in K'^iihI and in liistory, the seat of the mythical Guy and of the historical King-maker.- And, though the actual work of William himself has vanished, yet his foundation abides, one of the few fortresses of his day which have lived on through all changes and all rebuildings, and which still remain the dwelling-places of noble owners. With the guardianship of the new fortress no man of English birth, not even the loyal /Elfwine, might be trusted. He might retain the civil administration of the shire, but the military command of the castle could be safely entrusted only to Norman hands. The new castle was placed in the keeping of Henry, the younger son of Roger of Beaumont.-^ A great ' The only destruction in the town of Warwick recorded in Domesday i.s that of four liou-scs belong^injj to the Abbey of Coventry, which are en- tered in ]). 238 aH " vastie propter situm cuntelli." ■'' Tlie legend of Guy, which may be found at large in Knighton (X Scriptt. 2324), irt place«l in the day.s of vlCthelstan. Tliere is in the popular mind an invincible tendency to identify this mythical hero with Eiirl Richard Neville. The confusion is possibly helped by the existence of a real Guy Eiirl of Warwick in the days of Edward the Second. See the HO called Walsinghani, i. 130, ed. Riley. ^ Ord. Vit. 51 1 C. " Ivex itaquc castrum apud Guarevicum condidit, et Henrico Rogerii de Ikllomoute filio ad flervandum tradi. *i! i.; i .mi :j ..■ u: Tliis vi;;orous bo^'-inninj^T <^f tfhe cnmpaii;n difl 'its'workl Our accounts arc stnmpi'ely im]>erfect, hut, such as tln'y March <.f are, they lead us to think that Ka\nne and Morkere ^ud were actually marching at the head ol an army to meet Morkere. ^j^^. {j^yader, and that, as they drew near to Warwick and learned the occupation and defence of the town, they shrank from meeting;' the Con(pieror in arms, and, without Thi»y U» porf- choiee of I'liihlliun )vm\ nlaocnl the minster of Saint (^lth- tioo of I>uriiuii. berht * and the hunil»ler home of epipcopal rule wliioh precetlM the mi^-hty eantle of William of Saint Carih'f and Hugh of Pudsey. Tlie mound on which the later k(H?p of the episcopal fortress still stands may well have l)een called into play at this time, if not in times earlier still. Commanding: the neck of the |>eninsula, g-uarded on tlirce other sides by the rivir which flows by the foot of the well nig:h perpendicular hill, a fort on or near this ])oint would make the ecclesiastical precinct secure against all attack. At all events, Durham was put into a state of such vig-orous defence that its indc])endence was not threatened for the present. As for the rest of the land, William had only to march on and take possession. Fjidpirjimi Hut meanwhile a company of Englishmen of higher rank sought a shelter yet further to the North than that which had been chosen by the defenders of Durham. King Malcolm of Scotland had already promised his help to the patriots, but before his help was forthcoming, the whole scheme had broken down through the desertion of the brother Earls. JJut the Scottish King might still show his good will to the cause in another way. Two of the chief men of the North had chosen a different course from ' Will. Gem. vii. 40. " Repentinum ma^oii flebellatoriB fonnidnntea ad- ventum, furtim, ut festinum maj,'ni tern-ris consilium suasit, fugA lapsi in quamdam partem Cumberlondje cjomitatfls, aquis pariter et Hilvis inaccessi- bilem, 86 contulerunt ; et firmis«in)o vallo castrum erexerunt, quod propria lingua Dunelmum nuncuparunt." Thi.s follows the passage quoted in p. 18"; the geOg'rajiliy breaks down at once; on the chronology see Ap- pendix Y. * See vol. i. p. 321. { ScotUnd. FLinilT OP EADOAR TO SCOTLAND. 195 that followed by the sons of Leofric. One of them was a cHAp.xvni. man of birth even more lofty than their own and of e^jual nominal rank. AV'hen Eadwine and Morkere bowed to the Conqueror and returned to their luxurious ij>nominy in his court, Gospatrie, with a nobUr spirit, set forth to seek a shelter in Scotland till the day mij^'-ht come when he could a«^in serve his country. ^^ ith him went the Slieritf MaTlesweg-en and many others of the best men of the Xoilli. They took with tliem the nominal leader of the enterprise, Eadgar the yEthfling", with his mother Agiitha and his sisters ^Iar«>:aret and Christina.^ They set sail, at what haven we are not told, and reached the court of Dunferm- line in safety. 2 Malcolm received the exiles as favourably as he had, two years before, received Tostig*.^ The whole They paaa party abode under his protection throu^^'h the whole ^.-^j^ winter,"* planninsr no doubt new schemes for the deliver- ^Lalcolm , , ^ 1068- 1069. ance of the land which the sons of iElfj^ar had for- saken. Tlie shelter triven by Malcolm was valuable in itself, and in the end the sojourn of the English exiles at the Scottish court led to events memorable in the history of both countries. Not only did Scotland stand ready as a land where English exiles were ever welcome, but p^reater results still came when at a later time one of the company was prevailed on to acce])t the land of refuge as a permanent dwelling place.'^ We return to the progress of the Conqueror. The next ' On the movements of GoHpatric and Mserleswegen, see Appendix Y. ' The Chronicles simply wiy *' comon [foran, Petrib.] to Scotlande." But Florence anjf way from \Var\vi«'k ; ami, if no ^^ blow wii« htnu'k in nil the ri*j>:ion hftwtMMi thow two townx, there niuht at any nito have hiH»n many ])eaeefiil Hul)miB- S «ionK. Coventry, with ICjirl liCofrieV minster, and Ix'iccHter, T^-'Tv ^.r the capital of the intervening; nhire. an- not mentioneti; ^ but the submission of thns4« towns and of the neif;hl)our- in^ country must have hnpiH*nery of the FoiuKlation of Leicester Abhey in the Monaaticon, vi. 466, the narrative begins, " Robertus Comes Mellenti, veniens in An- gliam cum Willielmo Duce Nurmannia?, adeptus consulatum Leycestriae, ex done dicti Ducis et Conqua'storis Angliaj, dcstrudd priiis ciritate Lei- cettriie cum castello et eccle.si.l ixifra castelhnn, tempore pnedicti Con- qua*8toriH, rea.'dificavit ipsam ecclesiam Sanctie Mari;e infra ca.stellum." ' Tliere are many English under-tenant8, but of tenants in cnpite there Mem to be only three, Aschil, Raven, and Turchil — all seemingly of Danish descent — among the "servientes Regis" in p. 236 h. ' See Domesday, 292 6, 293. On 294 the list goes on with the Thegns of Rutland, HO strangely treated as an appendage to Nottinghamshire. One entry (293) shows William in a somewhat amiable light ; "In Wareshope tenet quidam caecus i. bovatam in eleemosynA de Rege." But he might have been blinded by the royal order. Cf. vol. iii. p. 107. 199 cxJNgrwT or wkmtkun asd south kkn knoland. tuAr iriii. 'l^li,} main im}H>r(uuoo ul Nultin^liam wiih clrnwn Iruin \\h •inC^vl I*"'"*'!"" "«»r tMi and f^tinrd tho iHiinmunioationH lx)th ways wa** the jrrwit |mhlir duty laid u|>on its Ijur^horM.' Tho rivor Hows at nomo distance from the ori;^nal town, whidi standn on a hill divided by a slipht dopression from a Htocj) rooky hoi;^ht to the west, at the foot of wliich runs the smaller stream of the Leen. Nottin^^ham, like Leicester, was a member of the Danish (%>nfodoracy, and its defonoo had been a special object of the care of Eadward tho Elder. Its acquisition indeed seems to have betMi the crown of liis concjuests in Fortififlft- central Enj^laiid. Ho visited Nottin«»:hain twice, and at KiilwMxl f^i^ch visit he secured his conquest by a fortress. His first thf EMer. occupation of Notlin«rliain wius followed by the final sub- mission of all Mercia, Enj^lish and Danish, and its incor- poration with the West-Saxon Kinf^lom. His second visit was followed within the same year by that prcat Commen- dation of the staU»s north of the Humbor which first made the West-Saxon Kin*^ to l^e Lord of all Britain. The position of Nottiu<^hani in truth made it in some sort the key of Northumberland, and the g-reat object of Eadward^s fortifications was to secure the river. On tbe former of his two visits he secured the borough ])y a f')rtress on the left bank of the Trent ;2 on the second he added another * Dome9rtance of the navigation of the Trent comes out also in the Charter of Henry the Second to Nottingham in Rym'^r, i. 4I, and Stubbs' Select Chartera, 159. The burgesses were en- titled to tolls from those who used the river, but it is also ordered, " Iter de Treiita liberum esse debet navigantibiis quantum pertica una obtirieblt ex utraque parte fili aqua;." ' Chron. Wint. 922. " I'a for he l)onaD to Snotingahara, and gefor >a burg, and bet hie gebetan and gesettan, jegber ge mid Engliscum SUBMISSION OF NOTTINGHAM. 199 fortress on the opposite bank, and joined the two toj^ether chap.xvui. by a bridge.^ All traces of Eadward's works have vanished. But their site is doubtless marked by the ])ictures(|ue iiiediiL'val bridg-e whieh is now gfiving" way to a modern successor. This imjmrtant post the men of Nottingham had to hold; no further military service is spoken of; yet, besides merchants, we hear of horsemen or knights as forming a chief element in the population of Nottingham.*^ Two churches are recordetl in the Survey, but Nottingham never became the seat of any great ecclesiastical founda- tion. Of the submission of this important post we get no Nottinij- details; but it was at the head of his army that AVilliam m its to appeared before the town,"^ and its possession was at once ' ^^^^' secured by the foundation of a castle."* The site which Founda- ^^ illiam chose lor the fortress which was to overawe the castle. umnnum ge niid Deniscuni, and him cierde e.ill J»aet fulc to f>e on Mercnahinde geseten wtes, 8egt>er ge Uenisc ge En^lisce." This entry follows immediately on the commendation of the Welsh princes. See vol. i. p. 60. * Chron. Wint. 9:4. "Her on t>ysum gere foran to middum suniera; for Eadweard cyning mid fierde to Snotir.gaham ; and het gewyrcan \>a, burg on 8u5 healfe J>iere eas ; ongean t>a obre and ^a brjcge ofer Treontan, betwix J>am twam burgum." Then follows the entry of the fortification of Bake- wt'll and the Peak land, and then that of the commendation of Northum- berhmd, Scotland, and Strathciyde. ' In Domesday we read of " domus mercatorum " and of '* douuis equitum," the latter being seemingly a numerous class. Were they the remains of an old Danish patriciate? fSee vol. i. p. 64. " Etjues," what- ever its meaning, is a most unusual word. Du Cange (in voc.) quotes a charter of Philip of France in 1050 (I do not understand tlie date), in which " duo equites " are granted along witli " duo rustici." But these Nottingham "ecjuites " rather sug'^est the cnihtenaijild of London. ' llor. Wig. 1068. "Rex WiUelnius cum exercitu suo Snotingaham venit." * Chron. Wig. 1067. "He for \>',\ to Snotingahani and worhte l> CXlNglEST Of WBSTKKN AM) NoUTIIKUN KNULANIi. cMAr.iTiu. boitmf^h \vmb one which would huvr Ih'cii K^iw oli^iltlr fur Eadwunrii olijeota of proU^ction. 'VUv nwlK» <»f Nottiii^huin WM now rt*anxl on the hi;fht»Ht |>oint (»f the f^reat rock ovcrhan^finj^ the town. A ni*w town spread itnt'lf over the lower ground lK'twiH»n the CAKth' and the ohli»r horon^-h.' SiAltor In such a case the huildinj^ of tho ca.stlr did not involve „„j^ mny destruction of houses ; hut the borouj^h Kudcretl under ^^ *"*• the foreign government. The nund)er of its ])urghcni dwindled, uliile the amount of royal revenue drawn from WQUmb the town was incri»a8etl.- The command of the new fortress / ^ ^ was placed in the safe hands of William Peverel, a Norman •*" adventurer of unknown orig-in, who beeamo one of the pn.'atest landowners in this and the adjoininp;' shire. -^ From Xottin^-ham his name has passed away ; a modern house, now itself a ruin, occui)ies the site of the Concpieror's fortress. But the name of Peverel is insej)arably bound to His caatle another of his possessions. In the wild Peakland of Dcrby- IVnk. shire, where the hu<^e mass of Mam Tor rises over the valley of the southern Derwent, a lieig-lit of less elevation than some of its fellows, but of sing-ular steepness of ascent, overhangs the hupi-e cavern which bears the name of the DeWl's Hole. On its hig-hcst point, standing- on the very edge of a perpendicular cliff, where the fosses of Arques and ' Doineiwlxiy, 280. " Hugo vicccoines, filiuH lialclnci .... in terra OomitiH in novo hurgo statuit xiii. doniuH (juse antca non fiierant, appouena ems in senBU veteris burgi." ' See EIUh, ii. 476; Domewlay, 280. "T. R.E. reddebat Snotinghara xviii. libras; modo reddit xxx. libraa et x. libroH de moneta." Another grievance was the interference with the burgesses' right to fish in the river; ** In aqua Trente soliti erant piscari, et modo querelam faciunt, eo quod piscari prohibentur." * William Peverel's estates in Derbyshire appear in Domesday, 276, and tho»e in XottinghaniKhire in 2*^7, 288. This is the AVilHain Peverel whom an utterly uncertified and almost imposHible scandal callH a natural son of the Conqueror. See vol. iii. p. 656, and Ellis, i. 466, 467. Ranulf Peverel is a real man, but he is far more likely to have been a brother of William than a reputed father. On Engelric, the allied maternal grandfather of Williaui Peverel, see alx)ve, p. 26. WILLIAM PKVKUKL 201 Old Sarum were neetlless and impussiljle, William IVveiel chai'.xvih. reared his castle of Peak Forest,' the true vulture's nest of a robber-knit^ht. It is the worthy fellow of those other fortresses which freedom has left as forsaken ruins on so many of the hei«»'hti5 where the youn^ Rhine runs throu<^h the huiil of the Three Leag-ues. The still existin<^ keep most likely belon<^s to a slightly later age, but, as in so many other cases, it fairly represents the position and general style of the first building. Romance unites with history to make the name of Peverel of the Peak cleave to a spot where the frowning fortress of the invader seems almost a natural finish for the wild height on which it is reared. William had thus passed, seemingly without a blow Effects of being struck, certainly without anything to be called a unintcT- battle, thiouf'-h the heart of Mercia. He was now so far ^V^^*^ , . . . . march, on Northumbrian ground that he was within the province and diocese of the Northumbrian Primate, perhaps even within the jurisdiction of the Noilhumbrian Earl.- His last conquest commanded the approach by land and by water to the still indei)endent North. The defection of the Earls, the actual approach of the Concjueror in person, did what all the preaching of Ealdred had I'ailed to do. The Northumbrian metropolis trembled, as the Kentish metropolis had trembled two years before.'^ At what York sub- stage of the march between Nottingham and York we know not, but seemingly before William api)eared beneath the wallsj certainly ])efore any hostile steps had been taken, an embassy from York drew near with the keys of the city, and with hostages for the good faith of the ' Donieaday, 376. " Terrain castelli in Pechefers Willehni Pevrel tenu- eruiit (}eme})ern et Hundiiic." On the date of the present castle, see Mr. Ilartshorno's paper in the Archaological Journal, v. a 14, where also may be seen some account of the doings which went on in it even as late M the reign of Henry the Fourth. ' .See vol. ii. p. 560. ' Sec vol. iii. p. 539. c.lv. iot cx>xgiiE8T or western and noktiikkn p.nqland. cjur ivtii. citizeiui.* The DiihmiKKinn wm acMvptoil ; hut Willium put little tnmt in tho prt)mi»et which were made to him, and he determimHl to take every meiins to Keeiiro the city which wna hin jfreiitot*t con(|ue«*t since the sub- KMr\j hi»> mitvion of I/ondon. Tlie old Khonicuin lay on the left Yclrk Umk of the ()usi\ at a ]>oint where the couree of the river is towanlx the 8{)Uth-ca8t. At a short distance Ix'low tlie Roman city it rcci'ives tlic waters of the Foss, a stream llowinj'' from the north-ca.«*t, and wlilcli therefore forms a 8ort of peninsula with the j^prcatcr river. Hut even in Uoman times a suhurh had arisen on the ripht hank of the Ouse, and the Anp^lian and Danish city, a city which in the tenth centur}- is said to have numbered more than thirty Exteosion thousand inhabitants,^ had spread itself far beyond the K'MiiMi Roman walls, both on the right bank and in the direction of the conlluence of the rivers. The minster of Saint Peter, the metropolitan church of Northumberland, stood within the ancient circuit, but the new foundation of Saint Olaf, the burving-place of Siward, ' lay beyond the walls, not far from their south-west corner, where a Roman multang-ular tower still remains. And in the newer parts of the city ' Ord, Vit. 511 C. " Hrec Eboracenses ut audierunt, extimentes matii- rati deditione >'ini declinaverunt, Regique cLives civitatia cum obsidibus dedt'ruiit." ' The inanuscriiit Life of ArchbiHhop Oswald, quoted by Mr. Rainu (Fasti Eboracenses, i. 123), says, " Eat civitas Eboraca metropolis totiuH gentiH Xorthaninibroruin, qujp quondam erat nobilit»^r a;dificata et firiniter muris constructa, qua- nunc diiniKaa vetustate; quie tanien gaudet de multitudine populorum, non minus virorum ac niulierum, exceptia parvulia et pubetinis, quam xxx. millia in eadem civitate numerati Hunt, quse inediciabiliter repleta et mercatorutn gazis locupleta qui undique adve- niunt, maxime ex Danorum gente." I need hardly Hay that very little trust is to be put in such statistics. In the time of King Eadward the city wa« di\ndeelr4^iUtJ <•'' ffif I hirrrulon /'n\>.<. SUBMISSION OF YOKK. 203 otlitT rhurches had sprung uj),* witnessing' to tlie growth chap.xviii. of population heyond the ancient precinct, a growth which may well have been one of the causes of that neglect of the older fortillcations which is said to have happened at u somewhat earlier tirae.*- The wealth and importance of the city Lirgely depended on its trade. This was chiefly carried on with the kindred people of Denmark, to whom the broad stream of the Ouse offered an easy access. To William control this great city William took the usual means of ^^^^ ciJile founding a castle, lie chose a site whore a high mound ^*" tJje left '^ " bank of the suggests that it had been used for purposes of defence in Ouae. earlier times, and which is not unlikely to have been the site of the old Danish tower of York, famous in the wars of ..Ethelstan.'^ It was on the peninsular ground between the Ouse and the Foss, on the mound which is now crowned by the later fortress known as Clif- lord's Tower, that William planted his new fortress. The position commands one main passage of the Ouse, and the waters of the Foss ma\', then as now, have washed the outworks of the castle. Thus the first castle of York arose, the castle on the left bank of the river, but which, dis^tant as it was from the elder walls of El)oracum, was, then as now, held to be within the bounds of the city."* Five hundred picked knights were set to guard ' The church of Saint Mary Bishophill Junior, on the ri«jlit hank of the river, has a tower which may possibly have been rebuilt in later times. But, if wo, it must have been rebuilt out of mnteiials not later than the time of William. Parts indeed of it seem to be fragments of Roman work, with which the neighbourhood — the Roman suburb — abounds. ' See note 2 on last page. ' Will. Malm. ii. 134. *' Ethelstanus castrum quod olim Dani in Eboraco obfirmaverimt atl solum diruit, ne esset quo se tutari perfidia posset." * Ord. V'it. 511 C " Ipse tamen, (juia fidem illorum suspectam habuit, in Ill-he ipsd munitionem firmavit, qviam delectis militibus cu-ttodiondam tra- didit." He afterwards, as we «h.ill see, mentions the buililing of the second castle. This minute statement seema to outweigh the words of the English writers, which in strictness would imply that l>otli of the Vork castles 204 OONglKST or W^lSTKHN AND NCUITIIKKN KNOLAND. cHAr.&vui. 9ff%, llOlMf'% KiuKicb- ol If boot, aoU Wil- lUm Mdrt. Laiidc anil offiom of WlUlMU PmVmhIe lions. Uio fortxvuK, ululor tiic iN>innmiul of at Ifu^t throo truKty captain*. One of tlu'in, ItiU'rt Fitz-Riclmnl, wo know only from hip fnt<» in the nrxt ycnr* Of (lu» otluTH om* WM the Flomish julvonturiT, (JilhtTt of (ilient ;^ the other wan u nitin wlioso nnnu* mii8t always awak(*n a certain sympathy in Kn^^linli hearts, William Malet. who had V»orne the Ixnly of Harold to it8 first ha*«ty hurial on the nnks of HaKtiiij'ii.'* He nceived tlie ofhce of Siieriir/ and he was at once rewarded with larj»-e ^-rants of lands in the hhirc. This is shown hy several jiassapes of the Snrvey, which speak of lands as having heen held hy NN'illiam ^falet before the revolt of the next year. This of course implies confiscations at this j)articular time. But among the names of those English owners whom we can certainly say were disj)08sessed at this moment, there are none to wliich we atta<'h any idea.^ It appears that AVilliam also at this time made gifts to were built At once. So Chrnn. Wig. " Ue for Bwa to Eoferwic and )»ifr worhte tuxgrn castdas." And Florence, " Eboracuru \ierTexit, ibique duo- bus cjuitclli^ finnatis, qitingentoH uiilites in eis posuit." ' See below, p. 238. ' See vol. iii. p. 3 la. For bis laudH, not large, in Yorkabire, see Domes- day, 326. • See vol. iii. pp. 466, 514. William and (JillxTt both appear in the history of the next year. • Sim. Dun. 1069, p. 85. " W^illiehno Malet qui tunc vicecomitatuni gerebat." So Domesday, 374. " Vivente Willelmo Malet et vicecomitatum tenente in Euruic." • In the Clamores de Evniioicire in DomcHday, 373-374, we find several entries speaking of lands as being held by W^illiam Malet " antequam cas- tellum captum fuiHset ;" "donee inva.sum est cistellum ;" "donee fractum est castellum ;" "quamdiu tcnuit castellum de Euruic ;" "usque iJani ceperunt ilium." The names of the f«trmer potwessors are given, including a long string of Danish names in Holdemess. But the only one (373) which awakens «ny |»erHonal interest or curiosity is a woman named Asa — it in hard to see what Engliwh name can be meant — who had been, on what ground we are not told, divorced or separated from her husband Beomwulf. All her ^ands which nhe held in her own right " ut domina," free from all control of her husband, were given to William Malet. Cf. p. 51. CONFISCATIONS IN YORK.^IIIRE. 205 the church of Saint John at Bevcih*y, and confirmed ^ifts ^"ap.xviii. of his predecessor Eadward to the same cliurch.' ^^^j,,^ j^^jj^^ The confiscations which are im])licd in the j^rants t() «•<" ii*^^»=r- W iUiam Malet are not hkely to have stood alone, hut in other cases there is not the same means of distinf^uishin^ between forfeitures made now and forfeitures made at a later time. We must however suppose that, as P^adwine I*«^«'tion and Morkere were now a^ain in the Kiiig-'s nominal wine and favour, their lands were spareil for the j)resent. And it * is certain that, while William was at York, he received the submission of some other men of importance, whose lands would, according* to his usual jxdicy, be restored to them either whollv or in part. Thus Archill, the Suhmisflion ' > 1 1-11 • '■•* Archill, great TSorthumbnan ihegn,- deemed it hopeless to resist, now that the Earls had forsaken the cause and the capital of the P]arldom was in the hands of the Conqueror. He came to York; he was received into the King's peace, and gave his son as a hoster donum Regis W. quod dedit Sancto Johanni tempore yEldredi Archiepiscopi." It is added, " de hoc habent cancmici Higillum Regis Kdwardi et Regis Willelmi." ' See above, p. 1S5. ' Ord. \'it. 511 ('. "Archillus . . . cum Hege concordiam fecit, eique filiuiii Huum obHideni tra«lidit." COXQIRST OF WB8TRRX AND NOUTIIKRN KNOLANI). aupxrm liiiliniitttHl, no -'Kthelwine, thr Hinhop <)f Dinliain,' came to WilluinrH court at York, ami \vn« n^ceiviil into \\\h fiivour.^ Hut ho did not conn* only in liin own nnino. IIo bore a commiHsion fn)in Kin^ Malrolin, \vhoN> Karldom of liothian forintxl )>nrt of hin diocrst*. and In* arran^-cd torms MaI- ^^ pi*acc lH't\vt«on tin* (\»n(jUt*ror and the Scottinh urincc.^ Wo kn<»\v not their rxact nature ; hut it is plain that thev impIitHl the recognition of WiUianis Huprcmacy, and tljat they did not involve the surrender or expulsion of the Flralmb* English exiles. The Bishop returned to Scotland, and thence m^^fHi of Maloohn. <^Ani<'cl, Exeter and York had come into his actual pos- si Salon; but there were still lands and cities which stood to him now as Exeter and York had stood to him in those days. Bernicia was now what all Northumberland had been th( n ; Durham was as independent now as York had been ; the homage of /Ethelwine had brought witli it as little })ractical submission on the i)art of his flock as the earlier homage of Ealdred. So too he had now received the nominal homage of Malcolm of Scotland ; but as yet it was purely nominal, and the two Kings had not even seen one another face to face. Now as before, William was satisfied for William a while with taking seizin as it were by these nominal Xorth and submissions, of which he would know how to make use ^^.^' ' west, when the time came. York was the most northern point at which he thought it expedient for the present to appear in person, and to confirm his dominion by fortresses and gamsons. Scotland, Bernicia, and the north - western shires of Mercia, were still left in their precarious inde- pendence. A large district, still unsubdued, lay between and the line of his late march northwards and the East-Anglian Jjn-o^i shires which he had won by the erreat wao-er of battle '^•'^''tem •^ . . Mercia, on Senlac. On that district he deemed it i)rudent firmly to fix his yoke before he risked any more enterprises in the extreme North. He therefore returned by a road lying to the east of that which had taken him by AVarwick and Nottingham. And on his southward, no less than on his northward, march, each important point on his progress was secured as it submitted by the building of a castle.^ ' The Worcester Chronicler, after mentioning the castles at Nottingham and York, addH vaguely, " and on IJncolna and gehwar on ban ende." S) is more definite ; " Hex posthojc in reversione sua Lincoli», Huntendonie, et Gruntebrugii* castra loravit, et tutelam e«)rum fortiHsimis viris cominendavit." to« roxgrRn. PriMla among their number. The firiit ntx»nli»«l jxiint nf his lioinewiinl innn'li wns Liiut^ln. That lM»rou^h, Hn t«) Ihh'oitio u city, wjw thfii one of thf prt»atoHt in Knjjiontl.' It hfuiMted ch'vrn hundnnl and fifty inhahitix! hon«»H.' A nuMnIxT, douhtlcHH tho forvmi»Kt nHMiil»or, of the I>aniKh civic Confi'ower ever fallen as low in Kn^land as it dill in (lennany and Italy, the nilin;^ l)nr«;herK of Lincoln mipht have stootl forth as an oli^rchy not Ichb proud, and even more narrow, than their hnthren of Hern and \'enicc. It is only the peculiar character of ICuf^lish history, the sti'ady advance of the whole realm, as ojiposed to the mon» hrilliant develo]>ement of ])arti('nlar cuties, which hindereil the descendants oC Swartinj^" the son of Grinj- hold and Swart brand the son of Tif from handinji;" on names as memoraldc in history as tlu* names of Krhu.'h and of Fogcari. The Lawmen ot" Lincoln enjoyed the rights of territorial lords. All twelve were clothed with the judicial powers of sac and soc, and one among them, whether hy seniority or by hereditary rig'ht, further enjoyed the profitable privileges of /oil and tenm.^ And it is to be noticed that three (tf these great officers were men in holy orders. Tlie list does not begin, like an ancient charter, but ends like a modern commission of the peace, ' William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 312) calln it " Lindocolinam civi- tatem, uaam ex populosioribuM Anglia,-, enijtorium honiinum terra inarique venientiura." See also vol. ii. p. 512. Henry of Huntingdon (M. H. B. 693 ^) quotes the line, " TeHtis Lincolia:' gena infinita decore." ' Domesday, 336. '* In civitate Lincolia erant tempore Regis Edwardi nov-ies centum et Ixx. mansiones hoKpitatse. Hie numerus Anglice com- putatur i. centum pro cxx." See Ellis, i. 148; ii. 466. ' Domesday, 336. " In i[)«a civitate erat xii, Lageman, id ewt, habentes Bacam et socam, Uardecnut, Suartin filius Grimboldi, Ulf filius Suertebrand, qui habuit thol et theim, Walraven, Aluuold, Britric, Guret, Ulbert, Godric filius Eddevae, Siwardns presbyter, Ix;uuine prcHbyter, Aldene preHbyter." I presume that Eafdhnv is the name intended by the corrupt form Aldene. CONSTITrTiMN OF I.INCOLK. 209 with the names of the clerical members of the body, the chap.xviii. priests Siward, Lcofwine, ami KaKlhun. It would seem that they did not sit by virtue of their ecclesiastical benefices, but that their ecclesiastical character was simj>ly incidental and jxirsonal. It is certain that one left a widow and that another was succeeded by his son.' 15esides its Lawmen, Lincoln also contained citizens who, in the country at lar<^e, were of yet hif^her di«^nity. Ma'rleswegen PtmieaMonii the Sheriff, Earl ^lorkere, Earl Harold himself, held and'^.them houses in the borou<^h, and within their precincts they held '" ^*'*^ ^*^y- the same rig-hts of jurisdiction as the civic aristocracy.^ Private burghers also had their halls, and many houses were held of them bv their fellow-citizens of lower decree.-* The rights both of burghership and of clanship were strictly enforced, and grants, even to religious houses, of pro- perty within the borough were denounced as illegal.^ ' Domestlay, 336. '* Ulnodus presbyter loco Siuuard presbyteri, Buruolt loco patria sui Leuuine, qui modo est monachus, Leduuinus filius Reveriae loco Aldene presbyteri." Of "' Ulnodu.s " we shall hear in a later note. It would seem that the son succeeded the father quite irrespective of his character, lay or clerical. Mark al^ that the priest who became a monk was civilly dead. ^ The " niansiones " of ^lairleswegen, Morkere, and Harold all appear in Domesday, 336. Tlie two Earls had sac and soc ; Ma;rleswegen, it would seem, had not. We then read ; " Rogerus de Busli habet i. man.sionem Suen filii Suave cum sac^ et soca ; Judita comitissa habet i. manaionem Stori sine sacA et soca." ' Domesday, 336. "Tochi filius Outi habuit in civitate xxx. mansiones praeter suam hallam, et ii. ecclesias et dimidiam, et suam hallam habuit quietam ab omni cunsuetudine ; et super alian xxx. mansiones habuit loca- tionem, et pneter hoc de unftquaque uuum denarium, id est landgable." Tokig's thirty houses had at the time of the Survey pa.sded to Bishop RemigiuH " in ecclesiA Sancta' Mariu,*." Tliey therefore probably stood on the site of the present prebendal houses. * Certain lands belonged to the church of All Saints. Of these the Survey (336) goes on to say, "Hanc ecclesiam et terram ecclesiie et (pud- quid ad earn pertinet habuit Godricus filius Gareuina;, sed, eo fticto nionaclio, Abbas de Burg obtinet. Burgenses vero omues Lincoliie dicunt quoil injusto hal>et, quia nee Gareuine nee Godricus filius ejus, nee uUus alius, dare putucrunt extra civitatem nee extra parcntes eorum nisi concessu R^pB. Ilanc ecclesiam et quic ibi pertinent clamat Emuin presbyter heroditate (f«Mlrici consanguinci nui." VOL. IV. !» .'iU COKQUBST or WBSTKHN AM) NOHTIIKKX KN(JLAM). . lur Aviit. The community, liko that of Kxctor, liatl Hm landit lyin^ « ,v,u»:. n >xii|iout the oitv wuUk, IuiiiIh which »»ofm to hftve hcvn a)t|H>rtiomHl amon^ tlio roa^nt rates aiul chief hur^hersJ Tlie Kii)^ had a mint in the borou^hi whieh hnm^ht him RIgliliof in Bi'veuty-five |M>und8 yearly.' Dut whether he wan ^^* aotitled to any forfeitures or other protitd witliin tht> widln •eenui to luive been matter of controvcrHy.' We hear nothing of military- Kcrviee ; it WiUild almost seem ns if a yearly tribute of tiiirty iH)unds, twenty as usual to the Kin^ and ten to the Earl of the shire, redeemed the borough from all claims on the part of any external authority.* Such a community as this, 8tren«^thenee is the mighty minster, which, almost like that (»f Laon,'' crowns the end of the ridge, rising, with a ' Domeaday, 336. "In canipis Liocolite extra civitatem aunt xii. caru- cats teme et dimidia." The Survey goes on to mention their present and former owners, several of whom were among the Lawmen. ' lb. 336 6. " Moneta veru reddit Ixxv, librae." • lb. 336. Of the thirty houBes which had belonged to Tokig we read, "Super has xxx.manaioneK habebat Rex thelonium et f(triHfacturam, ut bur- genses juraverunt. Sed his jurantibuH contradicit Vluitt presbyter, et offert se portatunim judicium quod non ita eat sicuti dicunt." • lb. 336 b. " T. K. E. reddebat civitaa Lincolia Regi xx. libraH et Comiti X. libraa. Modo reddit c. libras ad numerum inter Regem et Comitem." ' The ending coin, the same of course as Colonia Agrippina, KiJln, is, aA fiw a« I know, peculiar to Lincoln in English local nunienclature. • There is however this difference, that at Laon the hill runs east and west, while at Lincoln it runs north and south, so that the minster stands as it were against the grain. DESCRIPTION OK LINCOLN. 211 steepness well ni«^h unknown in the streets of English chxp.xvui. towns, above the lower city and the phiin at its feet. Next in importance to the minster is the castle, which, marred as it is by modern changes, still crowns the hein tho river to tho nuuth of it. Vale aiul r\i\^ alike iirv travenkni by those great nnuln whicli al»i« K*^c of the Konian city. Hut the R4)n)an wa8 not the rile hn«t to ooeupy the 8|x>t. His r«tail. after elimhinp the hill, eut^ throu^^h nn earlier town to the north of the present city, of whieh the dyke and foss are still easy to Ixj 8e<'n. The road itself, the Ermine Street, notwithstanding all the centuries whieh have passetl since it was lir^t tiaciil out and paved, is still distin^jfiiisluMl from a yet older tra<'k hy the name of the New Street. And the New Street leads to the New Port, the Roman areh of massive stones which still remains the entrance to the city from the north. The The Roman town, the Colony of Lindum, arose to the south Colony and *^^ this more ancient site, on the very hrow of the liill. iurcmwn*. Prag-ments of the wall still remain, and tlie site of tlie southern f^tc is still marked at a point Imt a little way down the steep descent. In th^uir "/\ LINCOLN mo I()()H >loa7. t i J-i'f f/it" /W/V/'///'." I'l thr ( liiniitii'n I'r^ss William's tkkatment of Lincoln. 213 then an important hi«^h\vay of merchandize, at its feet, chap.xviii, dwelled the rich and proud commonwealth, which, holdint^ such a position, nii«^ht have been expected to withstand the invader as manfuUv as Domfront, Le Mans, or Mayenne. But not one word has been preserved to us No dcUiU either of the neN lUiam. that the treatment which it received from him was on the whole favourable. The amount of tribute was largely raised,^ but the civic constitution remained untouched. The numbers and powers of the magistrates, and even their hereditary succession, remained under King William as they had stood under King Eadward. The son succeeded to his father's office, and one Norman only, Peter of Valognes, had found his way at the time of the Survey into the ranks of the Lincoln Lawmen.- One of the priestly members of the magistracy must in some way have given offence, as a payment of forty shillings had been laid upon biin as a fine, j)robably for the redemption of his land or office. But even he had a successor of his own nation and calling, who however stands charged with wrong-doing * See |). 1 lO, note 4. ^ l)(>nie.s«Uy, 336. " Pctnis do Valongcs loco Godric filii I*!!oth in tho pity nnil in the tih\rt\ who r('tnin<« qniw tenet rivit?t presbyter; nunc ha1>et Alfnod mem liujaH carucato) ot Nonuan filiuK Siuuarfl proHhytcri alienun mcve, p. 209, note 4), that of Earl Morkere, with the note, " Sic de Rege tenet sicut Morcar habuit, ut ipse dicit," ' lb. 370 ''-371 h. "Terra Sortebrand ct alioruin Tainorum." Most of the names are English or Danish, but among them we several times find " Emuinus pre.sb}'ter," doubtlesH tlic same who ha.356^357«'- • lb. 357 i-358 h. So in the city (336 b), " Aluredus nepos Turohli hal>et iii. tofles de terra Sybi quam Rex sibi dedit." See Mr. J. G. Nichols in the Lincrdn Volume of the Archaological Institute, 255. ' "Norman de Adreci" ajipears in 361 b, and "Normannus Crassus," a much smaller holder, in 362. ENGLISH AND NOILMAN LANDOWNERa 215 of the great Norman grantees. Among these last we have chap.xvih. the usual difficulty in finding out whetlier the confiscations which provided tor them were made now or at a hiter time. But, sooner or later, Karl Hugh/ Kalph of Mortemer,' Nomirtn William of Percy, ^ Walter of Kyneourt,-* Ilbert of Lacy,'' Henry of Ferrers/' Ivo Taillebois, famous in local history or legend,' and a crowd of other foreign adventurers, were estahlished at the exj>ense of the Danish ThegnhocKl of Lindesey, Kesteven, and Holland, as their forefathers had, in the days of Ingwar and Hubba, been established at the expense of earlier Anglian owners. A few names awaken curiosity without satisfying it. The element of foreign adventure in William's host was largely repre- sented in Lincolnshire. Besides the well-known names of Earl Alan ^ and Gilbert of Ghent/J we find Baldwin of Flanders,^^ Ralph of Saint A'aler}'/^ two Bretons, Oger ^- and Waldin,^ ' and three other men of uncertain race de- scribed as Walclin tlie engineer,^^ Hcppo the halistarluHy' and ' Domes innn* intt'llrcttiAl bnuicho« of \varfnn», wo hIiouKI !k» Iwlter jiIeaKt**! to Iwirn •omethins; in«»n» than of many <»f tlu*ir fellow-atlveniiironi of higher niiik ami fame. thifoohf On the \vhoK» then tho amount of hind and of authority pamiT«l7 which n*mnim.Hl in Kn^hnh or naninli hands in Lincoh)- ii^^j^ shin* and tiie Lincohisljiro iKirouj^lis is very remarkaldc It is plain that Lincolnhhirc submitted more jK'aceably, and was dealt with more tenderly, than most parts of the OondWon Kintrthmi. Stamfortl, the town next in account afler the of Sum- fortl ; loi-al capital, fareil only less well than Lincoln itself. Of its twelve Lawmen, nine were undisturbed,-' and Lawmen and burghers retained a lar<>c portion of their common land beyond the town walls. ' Stamford, like Lincoln, had been a member of the Danish Confederacy, and, like its allies, it fills a prominent place in the wars of Eadward the Klder and his son Kadmund. In William's days, as now, the town stood in two shires. Of its six wards, five were in Lincolnshire and one in Northamptonshire.* Tlie fort- ress of Eadward stood on the southern side of the river,' ' "Odo arbalixtarius." Domesday, 365 6. ' Domesday, 336 />. " In Stamford T. R. E. erant xii. Lagemanni, (lui habebant infra domoH huob sacani et socani et super homines suos, pneter geld et heriete et foris facturam corponim suorum de xl. oris argenti et pra-ter latroncm. Hoc idem raoaet folc eal fSo to ^'acre nor- |>erran byrig hienle him bcah to and sohtari liinc him to hlaforde." STAMFOHI) AND TOHKKSKV. 317 but now the town was overawed by a Norman eastle on chap.xviii. the Lincolnshire side, which however involved the destruc- tion of five houses only.' Torkesey, a place now utterly of Tor- insig^niticant, hut which then seems to have ranked next after Lincoln and Stamford, suffered far more severely than either, so as to su«^o:est the idea that William met with some serious resistance at this point. The position of the town on the Trent, where it still commands a ferry, made it a place of importance on the great Northern road, and its two hundred and thirteen burgesses liad the honourable duty of conducting the King's commissioners down the river on their wav to York.-' But at the time of the ft/ Survey the burgesses had sunk to one hundred and two, and a hundred and eleven houses stood waste.-* To return Sixcial to Lincoln itself, the Survey contains several entries which ahout have a special interest. One burerher of Lincoln, Llfkill or ^'"^o^" » i o ' story of Ulfcytel by name, received a grant of land without the city ^'Ifkill- as the price, or part of the price, of a ship which he sold to the King.^ Another grant of the same kind has had a higher and more lasting importance. A castle was of Building of course raised at Lincoln as well as elsewhere, and at Lincoln, unlike Nottingham, the strongest site was to be found within the city itself. The mound which now supports the polygonal keep of the next age may have supported some earlier fortress ; it doubtless supported the fortress * Domesday, 336 6. Of a hundred and forty-one houses in the five Lincolnshire wards we read, "Modo totidem sunt, pnvter v. (juie propter opus castri sunt waata;." " lb. 337. " Hoc autem eonim erat ut, si legati Regis illuc venirent, homines ejusiiem vici cum navihus suis et aliis instrumeiitis navigationis U8<^ue Eboracum cos conducerent." ' lb. " Modo haljet Rex in dominio, et sunt ibi cii. burgenses manentes. Wastaj sunt vero cxi. mansiones." * lb. 336. "Ex his [of the carucates spoken of in p. 210, note l] dedit unam Rex WillclmuH cuidani Vlchul pro un;l navi (luam ab eo emit. lUe vero qui navim vendidit mortuua est, et banc carucatam ternu nullus habet nisi Hegc conccdente." :IS CONQUB8T OP WESTERN AND KOIlTIIKnN P.NnLAND. cvAP.xna. which wnst now rpAnnl )>y William. 'V\\v huildin*^ of \\u* and \i» outuorku involvcHl \\\v dent met ion of a Diiiittu Um> numU^r of hou«w. One humln'tl and gixtv-inx lloa of . . kuuMB. dw'cllinpt ponHlicHl to make room for it.' and wo ran hardly douht that the huiUlin^- of the minster a frw yearK later muut have involveoriion of the hurj^hers of Lincoln, who had once held houses on the heip^ht, were driven from their former liomes and h.id to seek dwellinj^ where they could. For a small ])art of them a dwelling- place was foimd in a manner which forms one of the most interestr WiiiiAin'u inj^ pieces of local history in England. Without the city, 0^ ** at the foot of the liili, beyond the stream of the AVitham, Bwtgm. ]jjy jj ^vaste piece of land which had never been dwelled upon by man. This the King- granted to his Enf^lish Miin^ioD favourite Coleswecrcn. A new town })etr:ni to arise. At the toth« . .... lower time of the Survey thirty-six inha])it<'d houses, inhabited '"^'" doubtless by men who had lost their homes on the hei<^hl, ('..u-swe- formed part of the estate of Colcswen^'en. For the use of his ciii.rche-H. tcuauts lic built two churches, the most strikinfj^ portions of which still remain. They still bear witness, in their tall slender towers and windows of tlic more ancient fashion, that, even while the Norman castle and the Norman minster were rising above their heads, English- men could still build in earlier and more national forms of art. lieared as they were after King AVilliam came into England, the works of Coleswegen, the towers of Saint ' Domesday, 336 b. " De prsedictis wastis tnamionibua propter caHtellum destructee fuerunt clrvi." ' lb. " Reliquae hxiv. wastatie sunt extra metam castellam, non propter oppre«8ionem vicecomitum et ministrorum, sed propter infortunium et paupertat«m et ignium exuRtionem." COLESWEGEN S CHUHCHES. 210 Peter-at-Gowt-^ and Saint Mary-le-Wig-fonl still reproduce chap.xviii. that style of huiMinp^ which Wilfrith and his cont^'mpo- niries had broui^ht from Rome, and which so lonp re- mained the common herita^ of Western Christendom. I hardly know of any works of man which speak more strono-ly to the heart than these two stern and unadorned, yet stately, towers, reared, in the days of bondag-e, hy an Knfj-lishman who, hy whatever means, contrived to hold up his head amonj^ the conquerors of Eng-land, and to win no small share of the honours which hclonjif to the founders of new temples of God and of new dwelling'-places of man.* Of the places throut^h which William j)assed on his march southward from Lincoln two only are mentioned, Hunting- don and Cambridt^e. Cambridtje, not yet famous as the William at seat of a great University, was a borough of considerable '^"* '"'^fe'^- importance, though not attaining to the measure of lOxeter, Lincoln, or Norwich. The town of Cambridge, Orif,^!! of or, in the language oi" those days, Grantbridge — the riuun, Roman Camboritum — then stood wholly' on the left bank f"!*"^' •' bridge, of the river Cam or Grunt. The alternative name of the or Cam- river is still not wholly forgotten. The extent of the Roman town can be easily traced.'- It is something like * Domesday, 3,^6 h. " Colsuen habet in Lincoliii civitate iv. tHitivrly Hnuill, but in tliat tint n'^ion, ctintfidomlile, ritljfi* of hij^lu-r j^roiiml ovcrljKikinjf \\u* riviT at ittf feet. Like so mnny other Uonuin nites, Camborittim MH*mi» to have been uttrrly overthrown nml forsiikcn in Ili liaHilH- tho havoc of the Kny:li«h (\>n(MH'.st. In the wvrntli cm- tioaia Um . . awMtb tur}' tho town in BjHtkon of im lyin^* dcKohito ; it wnn thrrc, **" *^* amon^; the shattertnl remains of Kmnan skill, that a marble narcophai^us was nouj^ht to receive the remains of tlie virgin QutHMi and Ahhess .Kthelthrytli. Scxhurli, her sister and successor in the rule of the holy house of Kly, thought good to translate her body to a place of hi^^her honour in the ehureh which she had founded.' No stone fit for such a purposi» eould be found in tho land of flats and fens, but the ruins of the Koman town still remained as a quarry where all who would mi<^ht seek Iterartoim^ materials for their own buildingps. But in process of time, UurhiH- as civilization and the art of defence advanced, the Roman ^^' site, like so many other Roman sites, was ag^in occupied, and at the be^innin^ of the tenth century Grantbrid^e had once more grown up to enough of importance to give its name to a shire in the new nomenclature of Mercia.'- In the wars of Swend the town, like other t<^)wns, was burned.^ But to a wooden town— and in that part of Ancient Cainbridgefihire, publiKhed in the Transactionw of tlic Cambridge Antiquarian Sftciety, p. 3. * Baeda, iv. 19. " Quum Bedecim annis esset sepulta, placuit eidem ab- batissse levari <>8Ka ejuH, et in I(K:eIlo novo powita in ecclesiatn tranHferri ; juitsitque quoHdain fratribus quaTere lapidern, de quo locellura in hoc fivcere poHsent ; qui a8cenK& navi (ipsa enim regie Elge undiquc est afj[uia ac pahidibuH circumdatn, ne'■,//, - •n,itir: Ti- fitrf f'ltift' 2'S(' / (•AM1U)KI TIM ( 'ranthnclt;**. CAMBRIDGE. lOC.P. 1()«S7. S! BemftXh •» .MfU* / Furhfuj J-or/hr' IffJftfott'.'* of' t/ii- ( larrniL>n />kt.s BUILDIXO OF CAMnRIDOK CASTLE. 221 Kii<^lamJ towns must have been even more completely cuAPJtvm. w(Kxlen than elsewhere — :i destruetion of this sort was a mere passin*^ misfortune. In William's day (irant bridge It« con- was again a town of four hundred houses, divided into wuiiani'M twelve wards, and ruled by Lawmen after the manner of '""*^- LiiK'oln and Stamford.' No details of its siege or sub- mission are given. A eastle was of course built:- it nuiKling arose on a mound, partly natural, ])artly artificial, which cattle. still marks the site of the Norman fortress, as it doubt- less marked that of some earlier English predecessor. But all actual traces of either have utterly passed away. The building of the castle immediately involved the destruction of twenty-seven houses, and, either now or in the wars which followed in the neighbourhood, a large number of other dwellings became waste.-^ But this havoc seems to have led to even more important consequences at Cambridge than it led to at Lincoln. At Lincoln the Origin of driving out of the former inhabitants led only to the t^^.,[ ^*„^i ^ extension of the city by the formation of a suburb at the ^"iversity. foot of the hill. At Cambridge the river and the marshy ground beyond it had to be passed. On this new site a new town arose, the town first of monasteries and then of colleges, adorned by the minster of Saint Radegund and tlie minster of Barnwell, and far more famous as the dwelling-place of that renowned University which has so deeply stamped its mark on the intellect of England and ' Donit'Hflay, 1S9. •* In hoc burgo fuerunt et sunt decern custodiae." We preHcntly hear t)f the " harieta Lagemanorum." ' Ord. Vit. 511 D. •* Rex post haic in reversione sua LincoHa;, Hunten- dona;, et Gruntebru<,';i' castra h>cavit, et tutehim eorum fortissimis viris commendavit." Tlie Worcester Clironicle (1067) .simj)ly says, after men- tioning the castleH at York and Lincoln, "And gehwar on ban ende." S*> Florence, " In civitite Lindicolina aliisque locis castella finnari pnecepit." ' DomcHday, 189. " Pro caatro sunt destructiu xxvii. domus." The nuuihcr of waste houses in eacli of the ten wards is entered separatt-ly, amounting in the whole to fifty-three out of four hundred, besides thos«> tlfstroyed for the cafitlc. 222 iONgl'KST OV \VKSTKI:N AND NOUTIIKKN F.NUKANI). cturjiviii. the worUl, Hut, unliko tho aim* of Liiiroln, it would •ivin tliat tho oxilc« who won* drivoii from tho higher gtDUiiil of CumhrHi;^ had nithfr to enhir^ nn oarlirr •etth'iiuMit beyond tho rivor than a)>Hohitfly to found a new one. The unrient tower of Saint Ik?ne*t, tho mont ventTahlo monunu-nt in Canibridj^i', tU-arly pointD to an mgc earlier than that of the ehurehes of C'oleHwejfen at Lincoln, and sh«»ws that a site which was destiiu'd to beoome lo famous had alrtMidy btH'omc the dwelling-place of man. ^v ■ .1 'Hic town ut liiuilmL^don was, then a.s now, one of I i tK.u. much less account than ('anihridjq;'e, and one that would liariy hu- sccm to be of purely Kn^-lish ori<^in. As at Cambridge, no town. trace remains of the fortress reared by William beyond the mounds which no doubt mark the old Iluntersdvun which gave the town its name. They rise well above the stream of Ouse, and look forth on the old lU>man site of Duroli)>ons or Godmanchester on its opposite bank. Fortifica- Thev mark also, no doubt, the site of the fortress re- Ejulwanl stored by Eadward the Elder in the course of his Danish the Ela.'t gewcorc a.'t Ta,'me.seforda ; and hit Imdon and hytledon ; and furleton bat oj'cr at Huntanduue. . . . |>a for o^er lit ; and gefor \^ burg set Huntandune, and hie gebette and geedneo- wade ; Jwcr heo a-r tobrocen wais." There was therefore an older fortreHS. • Neither in Cambridgeshire nor in Uuntingdoii«hire do we find any Englushmen keeping large estaten like those of Colegrim and Coleswegen in Lincolnshire. In Cambridg' shire we do not even find any of that smaller class of King's Thegns of whom we have so often heard, and in Huntingdonshire we find only some four or five (207 h) who keep lands which themselves or their fathers had held T. R. E. STATE OF HUNTINODONSHIKE AND CAMBUIDCJESIIIKK. 223 important part iii later btru^gles a^inst William, and chap.xvui. it is impossible to sav to which date the main spolia- Heavycon- *■ * * (Lsc-aliuni* tion is to be referred. One thing is plain, that, eitlur in faiu- I 111- i • i ii bii.l^;«!iljire iKAv or at a later tmu*, both shires were put into tiie an.i Huu- lumds of most unseru])ulous Sheritl's. Picot bore rule in ^''1^^""- ('ambrid«^eshire and Eustace in IIiintin«^donshire, and the oppreu- amount of \vron«; wrouj'ht at their hands seems to have "[""tJ' f o the nhe- tar surpassed the ordinary measure ot havoc* Amon<^ "ff" i'"^**^* the otiier sins of Picot, the Survey char<^es him with Eustace, depriving; the burg-esses of Cambridge of their common land.- Yet he too appears as an ecclesiastical benefactor. A church and monastery of regular canons arose at his * The Sheriff' Picot appears in Domesday, 189, 190 b, 193 t, 197, ^oo, 70I h. In one of these placea (190) he in charged with an " invaaio super Kegeni," in 193 b he seems engaged in a very doubtful transaction with Earl Roger, and iu the entries of hijj own lands (201 b) we tinti a whole string of parcels of laud held by him which belonged to various churches. Picot alao appears in the HLstoria Eliensis (249, 251, Stewart), and in pp. 366, 267 we get the characters of the Sheriff himself and of one of his agents. Picot was ** genere Normannus, animo Gajtulus," and a vast number of hard names follow. In the next page the like measure is dealt to Gervase, " cui dominus ejus jam dictus Picotus, taniquam citteris fideliori, pro su& pravitate totius vice-comitatus negotia comniiserat." We shall also hear of him in Chapter xix. Eustace is charged in p. 202 with an *' occupatio " in Cambridgesliire, in 228 with another in Northamptonshire on the church of Ivamsey, and the entries in his own town and shire Jire full of complaints against him. In the town of Huntingdon in 203 tlu re are several, both from churches and from private English owners. The com- plaint from the representatives of a former English Sheriff is quite pathetic ; " Habuit Aluricus vicecomes T. R. E. unam mansionem quam W, Rex postea concessit uxori ejus et tiliis. Eustachius modo habet, quam pauper cum matre reclamat," In the entries of Eustace's own lands (206 b) we find English owners, and also the Countess Judith, com- plaining of hia seizures. Other c;vsea occur in 208, to one of which we get a date. A .small piece of land, " tertia pars dimidi.e hidie," belonging to the Abbey of Ely was seized by Eustace in 1071-1072, doubtless while the exploits of Hereward were going on ; " .Sio Abbas habuit T.R.E. et iHJ!rM£.N am» .nuHTHKKN KNULAND. oMAr.xviii. liulilin^ in honour of Saint iiWvs within the hoiimlH of P^\, thf old (.'nmhoritum,' iinil, Htninp'ly uh the liuihlin^ haH •tCbai- been dititiinin^d in later timc8, Homo Hmall rvVicn of tlio ^^^ work of thf rapariouH Shoritf ntill Hurvivf. Tin* evil (ItHHln of KiiHtaot* of Iluntinploii ntand otit still more eU»arly in the Survey. Hut of the town with which his name is eonnocted we should P|x»eially like to hear more. It lay within the Karldoni of Walllnntf, and Wm history is shroudcnl in the darkness which surrounds all the doinj^ of it*' Karl till he hreaks forth into full li/^ht Sut© of in the course of the next year. As to the other shire towhirr. which formed Walth(\)f's Karldoni, Northamjitonsliire, and as to its capital, history is eerto Gernon in maritagio feminie suie." The Priory of Saint GilcH was moved in 1 1 1 2 to Barnwell, outride the town, where it grew and flourished. ' At Northampton (Domenday, 219) sixty burgesses had shrunk up to forty-seven, the remaining houses being waste, but forty more had ap- jHrared in the new town (" in novo burgo "). All the freeholders mentioned in the town are strangers, and among all the large owners in the shire, even among the tenants of the church of Peterborough, very few English names are found. Two priests, (iodv^ine and Leofwine, api)ear in 222 h as •* eleemosynarii Regis," and in 229 we get a short list of Tliegns, among whom are two with the Danish names Olaf and Oslac. KKTURN ch ll.\i:nLlj> suNS. 22o father, Kin<^ Diarmici of DiiMin.' It was not hanl to tlnd chap.xvui. the means of raising and iiiannin<^ a fleet in the Danish towns on the east coast of Ireland, So, before the first year of their Lanishment was out, three sons of the fallen King, G(Klwine, Kadmund, and Magnus,- aj)j)carcd, exactly as their father had done sixttH?n years before,^ to attempt to win tlu'ir way hack into their native land by force. I low far this was done in concert with the leaders of the Northumbrian movement we can only guess. But things look as if all the enemies of William had agreed to do their best to shake his power, each in tho>e j)arts of the island where his influence was strongest. Harold's sons, just as their father had done, chose for their field of operations those shires of the West where the cause of their house had been defended longer than anywhere else. Their fleet, which is said to have numbered fifty-two ships,"* was manned no doubt partly by Danes from Ireland, partly by English exiles. At the head of this force they sailed up the Bristol They sail Channel. But either they had not taken warning by the j^rjgtl^i eiTor of their father, or they looked on a land under Channel, NoiTnan rule as an enemy's country, or else the natural love of plunder in the breasts of the Wikings from Ireland could not be overcome. The usual, but invariably fatal, mistake was made ; the deliverers began by ravaging the land far and wide.'' After thus harrying the coast as they and attack wrnt, they sailed up the Avon to Bristol, the port whence ' See above, \>. 159, and vol. ii. p. 154. ■^ On the 8on.s of Harold engaged in thi.s attempt, and on the authoritie.s for the stf)ry, see Appendix I)I>. ' See vol. ii. pp. 3i5-3»9. 596-59^- * So at least bay the Winchester Annals, Ann. Mon. ii, ■28. The Chronicler and Florence do not mention the number. * Chron. Wig. 1067. " Com an Haroldes Huna . . . mid scyphere into Afenan mufJan unwar, and hergoa burh abrecan woldon, ac seo burhwaru heom henrdlice wiS fuuht, and ]),\ hi ne militon of \fXTfi burh naht gewiniian ; hi foron )>a to Hcypan mid ^an )>e lii gehergod haefdon." ' lb. " And Hwa hi foron on Sumersieton and paer upp eodon." Here the narrative of Florence join.s in ; " de Hiberniu redeuntea in SumereetaniA applicuerunt." ♦ lb. " Ea*Jno5 .Staliere heom wiS gefcaht." Flor. Wig, " Ead- nothus, qui fuit Haroldi Regin iStallarius, occurrit cum exercitu." William of Malmesbury (iii. 254) in fuller on William's policy on thw head ; " Angligenam exercitum et ducem objecit, Xonnannos feriari penuittens, ingens sibi levamen providens, utrilibet vincerent," Yet it is clear that William'8 interest needed the repulse of Harold'H sons. * lb. " EadnofJ . . . wearS J-aer o&lagen and manege gode menn on segdre healfe." DEATH OF EADNOTIl. 227 rank of the persons spoken ol/ and it would swni to imply cuAr.xviii. that such English Thegns as were left in the shire did not scruple toolx?y the summons of Kadnoth. The result seems to have heen a drawn battle. Juidnoth fell in the lij»:ht, and ^'"j ••* I • o -1 1 • 1 • 1 • killcU in Ins son, jis we have sei»n, failed to retam the mhcritance battle. which might have seemetl the due reward of his father's services.- Godwine and his brothers sailed away, and, after further harryings in Devonshire and Cornwall, made their They way back to Ireland.^ All that King Harold's sons had Dtvonahire done towards the recovery of their father's Kingdom had ^I'-J^n^l^i^j )>een to be beaten back bv Enorlish buro-hers, to harry *^'^^ ^»^^ ^ . -^ to Ireland, three English shires, and to lose a large part of their own force in an indecisive battle ainiinst Eny-lishmen.* At some stage of this year, and seemingly not later than Birth of the month of September, an event took place which may pirgt. have had the effect of making the foreign dynasty seem ^^^^6?"^ one degree less foreign in the eyes of Englishmen. At some time after her coronation Queen Matilda gave birth to the fourth and youngest son of the Conqueror, most ^ C'f. Mr. Grotc'a remarks utx the aiialo|3'ou.i u.se of dyadot and 1ron." Compare the use of the same fonuula with regard to William's army after Senlac, vol. iii. p. 5.',.^. * Here may ctme in the curious comments of the Winchester Annalist (Ann. Mon. ii. 28) ; " Godwinus, Haruldi Regis filius, patrem vindicare cupiens, cum Iii. navibus Angliaui venit, et mult« mala Regi et regno intulit ; de regno tamen jK)slremo cxpulsus est. In hoc autem nm.xime ibi pn>fecit, i{\iiA intertmptis sodalibus de eonim victu et pollicito pnemio minus reddcbatur sollicitus." Compare the story of Antigouos aud Ddmd- trioH in Plutarch, Dcm. 40. Q 2 228 CONQITJ^T OF WE«TKKX AND SoHTHKIlN ENOI.AND. vaAMviit likolv tlu' yoiin;^*i«t of all \\'\h rliililrm. iJoru o\\ Muirlinb H»iinr irnmnil. the i»on of a rniwiunl Kini; aiul Uiuvn, tiu* haU* m\tm0 of f* ^ WiUUm'* %ak» n horn .'Kthrlin^'. and wan inarKid out from his hirth K&ffUUt »?* « future Kin^ of the Kn;jliHh.' Thore can he little .djMUn^. jj(^^|,j that, as tlu» chanoc*^ of dolivorance from the foreign yoke ^Tvw \vi«:iker anil weaker, Kn^i^linh fiM»linjj l>e^n to attach it«clf to that one amon^ the (/onijueror's children who alone could be lookecj»'inninj^ AiuU«.«^ that it should so attach it.H'lf. His policy with wan! the rci»-.inl to his Enj^lish-horn son was prohaldy much the •?.^^"'* '" same as that of P>lward the First with record to his Walt* ^ Uritish-horn son.- The very name of the young" iEthelin^- Tlie nitnie is worth notice. He was called Henry, a name strange to Enarland, almost equall}' strani^ to Normandy, hut a name of pcnuine Teutonic rin^^. ' If to Norman oars it nii^lit su^g-est the French Kin«^ who had hccn \Villiam's ally at Val-es-dunes and his enemy at Varaviilc, to Fnf^lisli ears it might rather suggest the reigning (ierman King and his father the renowned Emperor, close alliance with whom had ever heen the j)olicy of England. The choice of sucli a name, a name hitherto unknown in the ducal house, but which was to become one of the most famous among the royal names of England, may well have been a sort of com- promise Wtween the purely Norman and the purely English ' See Appendix EE. '-' Whatever we make of the familiar legen 1, there is no doubt that Edward the Second was bom at Caernarvon (though not in the tower of his own building), and it is not likely that he was bom there without a reason. See N. Trivet, 309; Lingard, ii. 522; Greatest of Plantagenets, 1 38; Williams' Hist, of Wales, 421. * There are very few Henries in Domesday, besides the well-known Henrj' of Ferrers. In English the name occurs as Heinric, Henric, Heanrig, Henrig, later as Henri and Heanri. In the first two forms it ifl looked on as a real Teutonic name ; the last two are attempts to represent the French sound ; the middle two may perhapn throw some light on the process of softening the final (/. HIKTH OV TIIK .f.THELIN(} HKNKY. 229 nomenclature, llenry then, the one royal-horn son of his chap.xviii. {)arent.s, the one who, hy En<»lish Law, would have a claim Careful to a distinct preierence at the next vacancy ot the tlironc, of Henry. was brought up with special care. He was tauj^ht all the learning ot* the aj^' ; his proficiency became wonderful am * See Appendix EE. * Sec vol. i. pp. 63. 35:, 479, 505. 2S0 COKQnST OF WKgTEKN AND NOIITIIKRN KNOLAND. inxr \Tui. kindnxl in hNxni niul ti|HHi'li willi Kn^lnnd. n v\otn' con- nexion with which, if it wan part of the |H)liry of Willi.nu. had l»c»'n (Hjunlly part of tlw |>olicy of (nHlwin* l.hu\> of hirth of a nriiuv who was to Ih» ho renownol ■h'm\ mnnot l»o lixctl with certainly. A l<>' al lni Kin^liun should l>c suInIuimI, had no erttfct on men \vhos*» hearthn were thuM thn'at4MMonnnand in Hanijishire ; - Ilunifrey of Tilleul left his ^guardianship of the fnrtreKs of Hastinj^,' to revisit the wives uhosi> importunate clainuurs thus calleil for them. They and many others crossed over into Nor- mandy, leaving" their Kin^ and their comrades to their fate, and leaving their ICnglish lands and honours to the King's mercy. > , , T\\iit this story is not true m ail its details is shown hy aod fid»«- ^^^^ ^"^^ ^^^^^ ^^'* i"^ormant, the monk of Saint Evroul, hood in the g^^^ on to siiy that those who now returned to Normandy rtory. forfeited for ever the lands and honours which they lell Htitrh of l>ehind in Eng"land.' Now in the case of Hugh of Grant- • t : .:ilmes- ..... • i • i tt i • i.i. rt^uiiw mesnil this is notoriously lalse. He apjx'ars, not only in w '%' '"o Dqi^ipj; Jay i^y^ ju ^]^Q historian's own pajifes, as retaining: his English possessions, including' his IShcrifrdom of Lei- cestershire, and as dying* in England long after the death of the Conqueror.^ And it is specially strange that the historian of Saint Evroul should, even l>y a momentary slip or a mere inaccuracy of expression, go so far wrong ' Ord. Vit. 512 A. " Rex inter Utt hellDruin motiones Kccuin niilites ■UOB retinere cupiebat, et terras cum reditibtw et inagiiia potuBtatibiiB eia smicabiliter offcrebat, et majora dum totum regnum ab adversariis undique liberatum esset promittebat." * See ab<»ve, p. 74. ' See above, p. 73. * Ord. Vit. 512 B. " Deinde fatnulari laHcivis dominabuH suis in Neu- Btriaui revenii sunt ; «ed honores quoa jam nactos hue de caua«// Amti Final Qmqy^»t nT tf,f Xnrfh. 1069-1070. Imports Wo havo now rcncluHl one of the most eventful years r*2 io6o* *^^ William's to\^\, tlie year whieh may ])c Faid to have finally maile him master of all Kn^land. His ]><)\vor wag wiiiamB already spread over tiie greater part of the Kinplom. lin* 1% .r" T^ie extreme north of Northumherland and some diKtrietu tAiiinh.^i jj^ ^Ij^j north-west of ^fereia alone remained ungubdued. But William's hold was as yet far from firm over a lar^'c part even of those phires where he had personally a])peared to reeeive submission and where he had planted eastles to \\ ' secure his conquests. And the state of the country every- ' where was wretohetl. The old powers had ])ecn broken down by William's con(|uest, and William's own power was not yet so firmly established as to ^ive his subjects of either race that protection which it certainly was his wish to "five to both alike. En<>lishmcn and Normans were preyiu'^- on one another, and, as so constantly happens, natural powers of destruction followed in the wake of the havoc which was wrought by man. What- ever escaped the sword fell into the jaws of hunc^er and pestilence.' Such is the picture given us in our most detailed narrative of these times. The prophecy of the dying Eadward had been fulfilled; fiends had indeed stalked through his land.^ Where William kept the Christmas Feast of this year wc are not told ; according to the practice of the more settled ' Ord. Vit. 512. " Multimodis desol.itionibuH Anglia nimiH attrita est, et tam ab indigenia quam ab alieiiigeniH vaMe aggrav.ita est. Jntcndia, rapinte. et quotidiame caedes miReram gentem invaserunt, percusserunt, dejecerunt, et conquaflsaverunt. Adverea fortuna miseros tam victoH quam victores muscipula sua irretivit ; nunc t-nse, nunc fame, nunc peste, irreverenter prsncipitavit, pmut omnipotens arbiter unicuique diHpensavit." ' 8ee vol. iii. p. 1 1. KORERT EAHL OF NORTH I'MBEKLAND. 235 years of his rei<>n it would he at Cilouecster. \\ lierever the cnAP.xviii. place was, it was no douht the result of tlie tleliljerations of Mi-lwintor ' Gc'in<5t at the Midwinter Gemot tliat an attempt was made to subdue (Jloa ccMtijr ? the extreme North, or rather to deal with it as with a land 106S-1069. already sulnlued. The Karldom of Northumberland in the narrower sense of the name was vacant by the fli«»'ht of Gospatric, and the ofTice, with the task of subduinp^ the country, was entrusted to one of William's own followers, seemingly one of the adventurers from Flanders. This was Robert of Comines, on whom all our authorities bestow the title of Earl, ^ and who now, in the course of January', set Tlie Earl- forth on the perilous task of taking possession of a dis- Xorthum- trict where William's own presence and William^s armies J'^^rl.m.l * beyoTnl tlie had not yet been seen. He commanded a body of troops Tyne which is variously reckoned at five, seven, and nine Robert of hundred. We have, as in some other cases, the further '""^"^*'- difhculty that it is not perfectly clear whether the numbers take in his whole force or only those among them who were of knightly rank.- Ilis course lay through Durham, Durham a city which had not as yet submitted, and which we jye,/'"''"''' have seen was a stronghold of the independent English.-^ We are told that the general feeling in the country was * Onl'ric (513 C) says, *• Ouillelinus Rex Dunelmensein comitatum Roclberto de Cuininis tradidit; " but Simeon (1069) says distinrtl}', "niisit Rcx WillielmuH XorthymlmH ad Aquilpnnlein plar/am Thuf Coiniteni Kod- berto coj^aioniento Cumin." The Chronicles (1068) simply .say, '* Willelm cyng geaf Rodberde Eorle J>one eorldom on NorCymbraland." On the new use of ** Xnrthumberl.ind " in the narrower sense, .see vol. i. p. 585 ; vdI. ii. pp. 483, 487. At any rate the expres.sion of Orderic need not imply that Robert was invested with a special Earldom of Durham, of the land be- tween the Tees and the Tyne, " Rove, p. 187. 1 iX»NgUKST OP WnSTRUN AND NOXTIIKUN KNUhAND. .iTiii. in favour ol li;^ia, but tliul the M*voniy ul ihr winter, hrif^trncd by a dtvp fnU nf Hnow, inmlo ni;^ht )io|)o- loM. The men of \\\v tliHtrict tlurt'fom (U'tcriniiinl to meet the in\*iierHon of the Bishop ^^" .Kt hoi wine. Tliat prelate, ns we have neon, had made his |»oace with William at York,^ and ho now camo, with more reason, to aot towards UolM-rt of Comincs the part which Robert the 8on of Wvmarc had aitrd towanL) William himself.' He mot the new Karl on his way, and warned him not to think of enterino^ the city.* Uohert made lif^ht of the warning; he marched on, dealiny with tin* land through which he marched as an enemy's country, and oven slayinj^ 8ome of the tenants or bondmen of the church of Saint Cutli- Rol^rt iK'rht. He entered Durham with his force, and we read I^uriuuii ^^ "" opixwition to his entrance. The Bishop perhaps prevailed thus far with his fellow-citizens, or j>erha[)s the site of his episcopal dwelling made him j)ractically master of the military position. Certain it is that liohert was admitted into the city, and that he and his immediate followers were lodged in the Bishop's own house, the doubtless far lowlier forerunner of the fortress which, side by side with the minster, looks down on the encircling- stream of the Wear. But it was soon shown that, if the prudence of yEthclwine led him to receive a visitor stained with such outrages a« those of which Robert had been ' Sim. Dun. Hiitt. Dun. iii. 15. " Quem illi ubi a. 414. ROBERT KILLED AT DrRHAM. 237 <^ilty, liis flock, ^\^thirl and without the city, were not cbap.xviii. like-niiiuled with him. Th»'y had no mind to receive a Norman Earl, an Karl whose approach to his intcmled capital had hecn marked by slau<^htcr and devastation. As RoluTt had In-'-nn, so lie went on : received as he Outrages was by the Bishop with all honour, hr allowed his nirn f„ii„wcp* to deal with the t )wn as with a \thice taken by storm. ^ Tlie sj)irit of the j)eople was now aroused. The news spread durinof the nii^ht, and towards morning* the <^ates of Durham were burst open by the assembled forces of Northumberland. A *^eneral massacre followed. In the Massacre houses, in the street.s, the Normans were everywhere Xonnarw. slaut^htercd.- No serious resistance seems to have been offered except in defence of the Bishop's liouse, where the RenisUnce Karl and his immediate companions withstood their as- Bishop's .sailants so manfully that they were driven to have recourse ^^*^' to fire. The palace was burned ; the Earl and his comrades Tl»e house ,,,.-., . lii 1 1 ^ /\ '^ burned all died, either by the ilames or by the sword. Une man and Robert alone contrived to escape with his life, and he was ^ , , . ^ ' party slain. wounded.' But, even amid the slaughter of their enemies, the men of Durham found time to think of their ])atron ' Sim. Dun. Hist. Regg. 84. " Dunehnum cum multa militum manu ingresaus permisit suos hostiliter ubique agere, Decisis etiam nonnuUis ecclesia; rusticis, susceptua est autem ab Episcopo cum orani humanitate et honore." So Hist. Dun. ii. 15; "Intravit Dunehnum cum scptingentis hominibus ubique per domo.s hostiliter agentibus." ' Sim. Dun. llwt. Regg. 94. " At Northymbri tota nocte festinantea Dunelmuin summu vi diluculo per porta.s irrumpunt et socios Comitis imparatoH ubique locorum interficiunt. Atrociter nimis ros geritur, j)ro- Btratis per domos et plateas miiitibus." So in the Durham History ; "Tanta denicjue fuit interfectorum multitudo ut omnes plateii- cruore atque cadaveribu.s replert-iitur." Compare Orderic, 512 C; *' Prima vero nocte cives coUecti sunt et ipsum cunctosque milites, pntter duos fuga illapsos, mactavtrunt. Fortinsimi viri nequiverunt defendere so, oppresai temjM)re, dolo, nndtitudine." ' Sim. Dun. Hint. Regg. io^)g. " Domum Episcopi, in qua Comes fuerat MUHceptus, aggrediuntur pugnantes, sed quum non ferrent jacuhi defenden- tium, domum cum iidiabitantibus cnn'^n'm'vverunt." Tho account in th«» 29$ it>XqUBST or WMTERN AND NOllTIIEKN KNGhAND. CTurjtmt. nint and of hit minntor. Tlic tluinot wliicli ilcMtruvinl the liuhup'tt i^ihiiv all hut ikizcU on the nei^hlKtiirin^ wcwtorii yjKmo0oi tower of the churt'h. tho huit fiiiibh uf the huiKhnj^, which Eadtiiund had uddinl to the work of the founder Kaldhun. But» owing, we ore told, to the pniyenj of the i)et)j)Ie, the wind ehaiig«il, the Haines turned away from the tower, aud the ehunh of Ealdhun and Kadnnind wiut sjiured to give way to the grander conceptions of Norman archi- tecti.' licToh At Tlie blow struck at Durham was at once followed by Her a blow struck at Vork.^ As Durham, which had never Kit*- '* submitted, n'fustnl to give up its freedom, York, which H»cU»rvl. jmj submitteil, was aroused to make an cHbrt to win its freedom back agnin. The citizens rose, and slew one of the Norman commanders, Robert the son of Richard, with many of his comi)anions/* That this was done with the distinct intention of throwinj^ off all alle*^iance to the Norman Kin;^ is shown by their immediately wel- EaJ***" »*- coming, most likely inviting", his English rival. The turiM from SooUaacI. descendant of the West-Saxon King's had small chance of winning back the Kingdom and the royal city of his fathers, but he was to have another momentary rcig-n in the Kingdom and city which had cost his fathers so much pains to win and to keep in hand. The i^theling- Eadg'ar ventured to leave his shelter in Scotland, and the whole force of Northumlicrland — the word being: here no doubt ■fa D'jfhaiu HiisU»ry i« to the Bame eflTect, except that it i.s not naid to be tlie Bishop'N liouse. One escaped, according to Simeon ; two, according to Ordcric. ' The eHcape of the tower, "turriH occidentalis quo,- juxta Htabat," ap- peals in the Durham History only. It wns seemingly a single western tower. See vol. i. pp. 496, 565. ' On the Kuccemion of events during this campaign, see Appendix Y. • OrtL Vit. 512 C. " Non multo post Rodbertus Ricardi filius, Ebora- eenns prmridii cuiitos, cum mult is peremptus est." No other writer roentioiM this outbreak, but it seems neeolicy, William. Hut it is plain that the chiefs and people of the North no lon«^er trusted them ; the career of the house of Leofric in those reg-ions was over. The new scheme was the restoration of the West-Saxon -Ethelin<»' by the mi»:;-ht of Northumberland and the kindred help of Den- mark. The policy of the scheme is obvious. Mierle- swegen, Gospatric, Archill, and the rest would never a^^ree to submit to any one of their own number ; they might all agree to yield a nominal submission to a prince who was inditferent to their local feuds, and in whose name each of them might hope to govern. But the choice of Eadgar as chief clearly points to at least a hope of driving AN'illiam wholly out of the island. The heir of Cerdic could never be satisfied with a Northumbrian Kingdom ; he could never sit down quietly to reign at York while Winchester was in the hands of the Norman Bastard. If left to themselves, Eadgar and his advisers would probabl}' have waited for the Danish succours which did come in the course of the year. But the i)resent moment could not be lost ; the advantage of the move- General ments at Durham and York was not to be thrown away. Xorthum- The spirit and confidence of the i)eoi)le was high, and **"^" ^ *^ X o people. ' Orderic (512 C) at thiti point waxes clasiiical, and talks of "Mariiis Swevus L^^^'rleswcg n], Gains Patricias [Gospatric; see vol. ii. p. 457], Edgaru.s AJeliuus, aiiiciuu potcntes et factiusi." The Chronicles (1068) say ttiinply, " Sena J>8er:i fter [after the movement at Durham] £ad<^ .i-ESeling com mid eallum NoriNhymbrum to Eoforwic, and ha burhmenn [" portnion " in the Peterborough Chronicle] wicV hinc gi'iiVedon." Hut Eadgar would never have got "all the Northumbrians" together witliout the guidance of ■ome of the great men of the country. UO a)NgrB8T op WWTRKN AND NDItTIIKKN KNUKAM). CM 4r I Tilt the opprvflrion!! ulucli rvcryuheiv wont on kindlni tlio natioiuil inilifirtiation inon* niul monv Men who hml «worn oatliH niul ^-ivm Iiostap'H to tho fon'i^n Kin^- rv«*ltHl little l»oth of their juith-* nnd of tho wifely c»f their min'ivinn^ frieiuln, nn ihry tlioii^ht of the lands fr%m\ whieh they hud Uhm) driven and of tiie kinniiien and eountr\men who had fulKn l»y tlie Imnds of the utranpiTs.' K«afr%r n» In jJiieh a frame of mind the a.«8einl>h'd forces of Norlli- htimhi^'rland, with the younj*" Eadjj;;ar at their head, drew near to the walls of York. The citizens at once welcometl the Enjflish Kinp, joined his forces, ami hco^in a general attack on the newly-huilt castle.- The command was now '^' -ijrt? of }|eld hy AVilliam Malet, who at once sent to King AVilliani, : to sayinjf that, unless helj) came with all sjxcd, he should lUiir ^*^ driven to surrendiT. • ^^'illiam was not likely to risk the loss of his northern capital; the need called for hi'j full force and his own j)rcsL'nce. He came with all " ' ' s|H»ed at the head of an overwhelming'' power;* his march \ :^ must, as a military exploit, have heen the fellow of the j^reat march which carried Harold from London to Stamfordbrid'^'e. lie came, and his vengeance was fearful. He defeMU He hurst upon the besiegers of the castle, slew, caj)tured, ibi- ioBur- n* 1 1 11 1*11 geuut. <'»r put to ilight the whole party, harried the town, and in some way or other did dishonour to the metropolitan ' Onl. Vit. f 13 ('. " Fiducia tleiiiceps Anglis crevit contra NorniannoH, a quibuH vidubant niinium vexari suos collegas et amicos. Fides, aacra- inentum, ct Halun obsidum vilia fuerunt iratis pro amissifl patnim suorum praediU et occisw ])arentibus et cotnp.itriotiH." ' lb. " Consociata manu civium Jic finitimorum, nmnitionem Regis in Eboraco impugnare ausi sunt." ' lb. " Willehnus cognoment^) Maletus, pnescH castrensis, Regi denun- cia\nt Be defecturum nisi maturum feHsi.s conferat auxilium." * Chron. Wig, io68. ** Wyllelm kyng corn suSan on unwaer on licoin mid geotendan here," or, as Peterborough ban it, " mid eallan his fyrde." Ord. Vit. 5 1 J. '* Rex ociuH advenit." WILLIAM KECOVEUS Yv)KK. 241 church of Saint Peter, most likely by showiii<^ small heed cuap.xvui. to its ri«4:hts of sanctuary.^ York was a second time subdued, and this time a second yoke was added. One and builJ« castle had not proved check enoug-h lor the turbulent city ; caatie at William therefore took the same steps to curl) York which ^'""^' Eadward the Elder had taken either to curb or to defend Nottingham. One castle already commanded the left bank of the Ouse ; another now arose on its right bank, on the mound which still bears the name of the Bail Tower, just within the later walls of the city. The navigation of the river and, with it, the direct communi- cation between the Danes of York and the Danes of Denmark, was thus brought altogether under Norman ca ofsloh pa be iBtfleon ne mihton, \ni:t Wiurun fela hund manna, and ))a burli forhergode, and See Putres myn.ster to bysmere macede, and ealle ba oSre eac forheri^ode and forhynde." So the Peterborough Clironicle more briefly, and without any mention of the minster. Ord. Vit. 513 C. "Rex . . in obsidentea ruit, nee uUi pepercit. Multi capti, pleriquo interfecti, ctetcri sunt fugati." ' Ord. Vit. 512 D. " Kex autem dies octo in urbe morans alterum pra'- Hidium condidit, et (Juillehnum C'omitem Osberni filium ad cusstodiciulum rcliquit." VOL. IV. K 2ia C0KQITE8T OP WK8TKRN AND NOUTHF.ItN RNOLANO. vmATjiriiL avrnfrr tho ciralh »»! IJirl II^iUtI.' Tlwy went as lar nn Alvorton, uin\, in the xt morning''. lUit a gvemi tlAfknetin came iii>on them, so tluit they could not •ee the way lH'fi»ro them.' IVewMitly one came among^ them who toKl them that the city a^inst which they were marching lind a Haint who dweUed in it, wlio waa ever it« defender, and who suircretl no man to harm it.' When the invaden* heanl thin, they ttirned hack a^^in, and the men of Durliam, who had hccn marked out for the slaughter, heard at tlic same time that a host had lHH?n sent against them, and that, hy \hr help of Saint Cutliberht, the host had been turned away.* The truth proba])ly is that William was satisfied for the present with the recovery of York, and thou<;'ht it wiser to leave Durham for a while untouched. lie went away in triumph to keep the P^east of Easter, according i:.-nfw.ly i'cll in witii two detmhments at different points, each of which sej»a- rately he found it easy to overcome. The slaughter wa.s terrible ; seventeen hundred men arc said to have been killed, and, as usual, the loss fell heaviest on the " best men/' whether by that name we are to understand English exiles of rank or chief men among the Dancb of Ireland.^ Nightfall alone, we are told, hindered the plunderers from being* utterly cut off. As it was, the ' On the Oleography of this ex]XKlition, see Appendix Y. • Ord. "NHt 513 A. " PnttinuH illiB Rriennud, Eudonis Comitis Britanni.'b Minorin filiiis, et GuillehuUH Guuldi cum ariiiis olnii fuerunt." " Bruou aorl," as the Worcester Chronicle calls him, was the son of Odo the brother of Howel and of the Alan who fought at Senlac, and cousin of the Ute Count Conan. See vol. ill. pp. 230, 231, 313. He appears in the Suffolk Domesday (ii. 391) as " Comes Brienus/' but he must have been deed befiwe Uie 8ur\'cy, as hi» lands are held by Earl Robert of Mortaiu. ' Cbron. Wig. 1068. " Breou eorl com on unwu.r heom togeinea mid unlytlAn weonxic and wilS gefeaht." • Will. Gem. vii. 41. " Briennus . . . cum eis sub die un& duobus prcbliij mammi conseruit." So Orderic, '• duobus uno die conflictibus." • lb. " Cassis vero mille et septingentis bellatorum cum nonnullis regni proceriboB reliqoi e certamine fugientes navium prsesidio necis excidium, ntcamqne evafBerunt." Are these " regni proceres " I'nglish exiles or men Mrring att8er ealle )>a bettttan menu )>e on Hun XyHe warron." L'TTEK DEFEAT OF HAKOLD's SONS. 245 two sons of Harold, with a Bmall remnant of their fol- chap.xvui. lowers, escaped in two ships to the friendly court of Kin^ Diarmid.^ This criishing" overthrow quenehed for ever the hopes No further of the House of Godwine. Of the sons of Harold we hear HaroM'H no more. The family which in two generations had risen ^^' from ohscurity to the hi<»'hest i)itch of greatness was in the third generation, so far as history is concerned, utterly wiped out. Of the band of sons who had gathered round Gmlwine in the march from Beverstone- and in the Gemot of London,^ the captive Wulfnoth alone remained. All the rest had been cut off. But of that generation we at least know the end. Of the next we know only that male descendants of Tostig, * that female descendants of Harold,^ lived on in Northern Europe. But in English history they No further have no longer a place. The Earl who delivered England the^Hoiise from the stranger, the Kinij who died as her champion ?^^t'^^V"® ^ ' ^ ^ in English against the stranger, have left behind them a name better history. than that of sons and daughters, but of their sons and daughters themselves no trace abides in the land which they loved and guarded. Godwine, Eadmund, and Magnus now vanish from our story. A time of confusion fol- lowed in Ireland, and their protector King Diarmid lost Death of his life in the very year of their second enterprise.^ jo^^o. Possibly they were cut off in these foreign broils ' Ord. \'it. 513 A. ** IJorrendam multitudincm in earn paucitiiteni redego- runt ut residui duabus 8canished Englishwoman, Frederick the son ««'3*»»35- of Reinhold, after a strange and discreditable career, ' See above, p. 158. ' See above, p. 157, • The Htory ia found in the Annalea Stadenaes, Pertz, xvi. 320; which I should not have been likely to explore save for the reference in Lappen- bcrg, Norman KingH, 11 4. • Pertz, u.g. " Praedictua Udo tenuit Stadenaem Coioitatum ab eccleaia Bremensi in beneticio." • See vol. iii. p. 232. • Pertz, u. 8. '* Friderici avia et mater de AngliA navigantes in comi- tata Btadcnsi naufragium passse sunt, et, secundum prisci juris rigorem, tarn homines «juani rea regix* ditioni sunt mancipati." ^ lb. " Fiiii favorabiliter a Dominis educati sunt, et adultia coUata adminifltratio et dispensatio quarumdam villarum." Autumn COMING OF THE DAXISII KLEKT. 247 diehind, Northern England at least, had heen looking* for help from the once hostile land of Denmark. All this while King Swend had been coming, perhaps to assert his own rights, at all events to avenge the blood of his kinsfolk who had died at Senlac. At once the nq)hew of Cnut and the nephew of Gytha, he might, for lack of more distinct representatives, pass as the champion of the house of the West-Saxon Earls no less than of the house of the Danish Kings.- And now at Swend ;it last, in the autumn of this present year, three years after help England had been for the last time invaded by a Scandi- ^^^^^ navian enemy, her shores were approached by a Scandina- vian fleet bearing men who at least gave themselves out as her friends. In August, less than two months after the final discomfiture of the sons of Harold in the West, two hundred and forty ships, commanded by men of their own blood, nephews and grand-nephews of Gytha, drew near to the ea.stern havens of England. The numbers in all these Descrip- statements are utterly uncertain ; we therefore have no f^^rce. trustworthy means of judging whether the efforts of Swend ' Frederick and his brother Ulric are said to have got rich by robbing and drowning in the Elbe three Danish Bishops who were passing through the country. Wlien the County passed to a minor heir, Henry, Frederick- acted M regent in his name, anfl afterwards bought his freedom and the possession of hia County from the Emperor Henry the Fifth. After many successes and reverses he wa.s finally, on the death of Henry — by poison as was alleged — in 1123, formally invested with the fief by Adalbert the Second, Archbishop from 1113 to 1148. ^ Ord. Vit. 513 B. "Multotiens enim pecuniis Anglorimi et obnixis precibus fuerat sollicitatus, et niinu suorum qui nujier in Heraldi conflictu occisi fuerant motus : quinetiam proximA cognominationo [cognatioue ?] &A regni cupiditatf-m incitatus, utpote nepos Eduardi Kegis, Hanlecunuti filiuH." A pedigree was seldom more utterly mistaken ; Swend, son of Ulf the son of Thorgils and of Kstrith the daiighter of the elder Swentl, was sister's stm U) Cnut, brother's sun to (iytlia, cousin alike to Harthacnut and to the sons of Gmlwino, but he hatl not a drop of blood in common with Eadward. U$ i -T or WWTERK AlfD NOBTIIKUN ENOLAND. i«4r %iMi to arKrw Bi^iuid wrrp or wtre not prmter than th.> rllorU of IIaaiM Htftlnida to wiIhIuo lior. Writrrn c.n tlio Nomuui tide »trmn all tJ»eir |>owrni of lanjr,m;;f to set fbfth how Swpna drainwl iho uholo iitn»nffth of hin nalm ami of nuiny •timiumlinfr niilmii. Tlio whole ini^lit of Wli ■■■<■! T^ '^' '"»* pithcrwl tojjcther; nuxiiiarirs in the cause JSJjf* of Kn;:Un«i mmo fn>m the kindml landH of FricKlaneorn, tiie ■on of rif and hlntrith, the brother of Kinp Swend and of '^M. •akOL ji^Md the murderetl Beoni, who liad himself once l)ecn an Earl in England, but who had been banisluHl nix and twenty vean* Ix^fore at the election of Eadward.'- AVith him came his nephews, Harold and Cnut, the sons ol' Kin^ Swcnd, » Onl. Vit 513 B.C. "Hie [Sumua] ingenti |K)tentiii polltb.it, univcnias ivgai toi TirM oontndichAt, quiltuii a vicinis regionibuH et amicis auxilia ■nfoa omoarralMt. A«)even et Thunim, FrHunque. aJioaqiM bhnm Deos, itumo cla.>inonc8, colebat. Hsec genu terr& ■uwiqiM pncluri periU erat, quam SuenuM cum Itege suo sscpe viccrat muufom diUooI lubegerat.** llj ■nail Rtock of Northern hwtory and geography here quite breaks down. A«(M«ric'« LeaiecU cannot well he Lutcti.i PnriKiorum, nor yet Leodium or Lflttieh, nor jet lAoaitz. I can find n<> name the leaHt like it nearer than Lithuania, llie Lithuanians undoubtedly remained heathens long after thin time, and we must remember that Scmbia or Sambia, seemingly in E««tcm PruMKta, wa« (see vol. i. p. 504) reckoned among the Kingdoms of Cnut. But I know of no conquettts of Swetid in tlioHC parts, and I cannot bcli«T« th*t Lithuanians worshipped our Teutonic Gods. Still it is baitfljr fiur to expect Orderic to be a comparative mytholoj^ist, and one voold b« Well pleaaed to numlxT the la>*t Kj)eaker8 of verbs in fn (see Lord SCrBBgferd'a Rnnaint, i. 6) among our helpern. It nuut have ban from the Polish contingent that some of Sir Walter SooU's cfaanctats leftrneme« " in the Winchester Aaiiak. 1069. wh^rr h. ;« further inaccurately made the son of Swcnd. OBJECTS OP SWKXI). 2-111 both of whom in tuni came to wear the Danish Crown, cn.vi'.xvni. while Cnut w.)n also the crown of martyrdom on those [j.^'^rolJ easy terms on which it was often adjutlg'ed to royal candi- -losi. dates. ^ We hear also of an Karl Thurkill and of two _io86.] Danish Bishops as havings a share, therefore donbtless a command, in the expc.tic royal name of Pen mark is already coming in. 6ons. tso c^»NgrBrr or wnTBtlf and xohtiikkn knoland. ot^iKitf. All h 1-- of joint action wen* »t an end; Swoml could no 1 .: r I* l«*okt"d on iij* bound to KU|>|)ort men who bad to xiUvrW failed to uupjwrt thenm»lvc«. His {Jhjfrt, DOW at leajjt, cannot fail to have Wen to reHtorc the in«. ' •" ^' t in one form or another. As far as wc cmti Miw itiio >u,'nd'n mind, one may Ih» inrliniHl to think tliat hi* caution and exiH»rience must hav»» tjiu|jht him that it waj» ho|H'le9i8 to alt^'mpt to phire the two crowns of Knf^and and l>enmark u|>on the same brow. Hut one of S«*end'ii many sons mi^ht well l>ecome the stock of a new dynasty, a dynasty which to Northern Mii^-land would be in every way welcome, whih' in Soutlicrn Kii«»'land it would be at least preferred to the rule of the Norman. We can however well U'lieve that the schemes of Swcnd, whatever they were, were not so distinctly chalked out, but that they were liable to change accortbng to the chances of war, and according" to the reception which they might meet with in Enjjland. We may jx'rhaps also infer that, whatever Swend's objects were, they were not very clearly made known, and that, at any rate, no purposes irreconcileably hostile to the claims of Eadgar were publicly announced. For we shall presently find the /Etheling acting in concert with the Danish invaders. And Eadgar at least must have hoped for the Crown for himself. If he had only to choose between two masters, he could liave no motive for pre- ferring Swend to William. But in any case it is plain that Swend's objects, what- ^iSwH ^^ t^^ were, took in the whole of England, and were not ffj*^' merely confined to its northern portion. And we may feel sure that it was generally known throughout England that Cctutniim a Danish invasion was preparing. The movements which Um ti»T». tocjk place m various parts of the country before the year cf Bwlgv. ^ was out, if not actually planned in concert with the Danish h» «*» King, were doubtless at least undertaken in the hope of being supported by Danish help. AVilliam had to struggle COURSE OF TUE FLEET. 251 against enemies in the West as well as in the North, and cnAP-ivin. this clanger from various points may account for the place where we next hear of him, one which othenvise seems somewhat strangely chosen. When the Danes actimlly drew WiiHam In near, William was engaged in hunting in the forest of ^f^'^^^j^ Dean, in the part of Gloucestershire west of Severn.* F'ond as William was of the craft of the woods, he was the least likely of all men to let his sport stand in the way of his interest. Strangely chosen as the place seems for a prince Probable who had to withstand the invasion of an enemy on his ^Im pre^ eastern coast, it was a good central point for watching the '^^^^^ t^ere, movements which soon broke forth on each side of him, and which had most likely already given signs of their coming. The Danish fleet did not at once make for that part of Course of England where it was most sure of a hearty welcome. It q^^^ ^^^ might have seemed the wisest as well as the most direct course if the deliverers had steered straight to the mouth of the Humber. Instead of so doing, whether by the orders of King Swend or by the discretion of their imme- diate commanders, they began their work by a series of attacks on various points in the south-east of England. In these, as it turned out, they simply lost time, strength, and credit.- Their first attack was on Dover, where rnsuccess- Harold's castle on the rock had been so vainly assaulted by ^^^ Dover Count Eustace.-^ W^e have not the same detailed account of this enterprise as we have of the former one, and we hear nothing of the feelings either of the men of Dover or of the men of Kent in general. But it seems that Odo, ' Ord. Vit. 513 C. *' Rex autum GuillelinuH tunc in Danu silva erat, iblfjue pro more veu;itui VHcibut." ' From the Chnmicles and I'lorunce we learn nothing; of the course of the Danish fleet till ita appearance in the Humber; the accounts of these unsuccc'Hsful attempts in other parts of England come from Orderic, who is probably following William of roitiun*. ' See above, p. 1 1 4. fSI "«T Of WR^RKN AM) NoRTHKHN KNOLAND. oufjimL (^r llu^li i*r Mt'iid.irt. or w)uH*vcr wan in inuuiiliatv (n>m- ouumI. wm ahlc to drive Iwck the invadeni with tho tr(H>|m which ho found at hin diKpomlJ A liko n'puU» followt'd ott an attempt which whm next mode on Sandwicli.^ The |>MM« now Hul«d northward for tlu* ontv Danish hmd of Ewt-Anglia. Aj* tlio HiH*t of the curlier Tlnirkill had dono fiftr-nine rmm before, they entonnl the estuary of the Stour and (Jippen, and lamltnl near Ipswich, not far from the soenc of Ulfeytcrs hattle of Hiiifjmero.^ Tliis time we are dintinetly tohi that tliey In-look theniBelves to phinder, and that they were driven hark witli the loss of liiirty men, not by a Norman ^rrison, hut hy the |HN»ple of the countr}'.* It is j)lain that we are here ri-adinp-, not of any serious attempt on the part of the whole fleet, but of an isolated rojndsc which fell on some - 'ated, |)erhap8 nnanthorized, band of plunderers. An Mlmmi aiiempt on Norwich which followed was a much more '. imjiortant enterprise, and one much more likely to have btvn delil>erately planned. One of the reasons which led William to j»laoe that K"reat city for a time under the command of his trustiest friend was the ease with which guecours from Denmark might be received there.'^ But W illiam Fitz-Osbcrn was no longer in command in the Ilai»t ; his services ha the *• Normanni " and " regii inilites" of the other *"*"*^ '^ See above, p. 67. THE FLEET IX THE HLMBEK. 253 with the East-Ang-lian I'arltlum, was the rene«^tle native chap.xviii. of the shire, Ilalph of Wachr.' AVe do not read that matters came so far as to an actual assault on the city ; it would rather seem that Ralph attacked the Danes while they were still in disorder, perhaps while they were scat- tered in search of plunder. Some were slain by the sword ; others perished in the waters of the river, of the Yare or the Wensum ; the remnant were driven in shameful flii^ht to their ships. - Tlie beg-innint^s of the expedition were thus very far from auspicious. But it should be borne in mind that, of all these Kentish and East-Anf^lian skirmishes, we have only Norman accounts. As the fleet drew near to what must have been all along the main object of the enterprise, we again get the help of our own writers.^ Early in Sep- The fleet tember the fleet entered the Humber."* Tlie day of its Humber. appearance was exactly the third anniversary of the day •^P^*^'"'^*^'" when King Harold of England had been driven to disband the troops with which he was guarding the southern coast ; ^ it must have been very near the third anniversary of the day when the Landwaster of Harold of Norway was first seen in the same waters.'^ But now the Raven of Denmark came on an errand of deliverance, and nK?n flocked from every side to welcome English exiles and Danish • See vol. iii. pp. 459, 751.- ^ Ord. Vit. 513 C ** Egresaos Nortliguici r\d siiuiloin discursioneni Radulfufl de Guader invasit, et raultis foiri>, iiiulti.s aqu.1, vitam ademit; et reliquoa tuq)iter navij,MUiu arripitiutes in pclagus abire conipulit." ^ The accouiitd in the Chronicles and in Florence give the same general factH, but P'loreuca attends much more strictly to chronological order. Tliat his account id copied by Simeon with only a few a(hlition8 is the beat proof of its trustworthine.ss. • " Betwyx |)am twani Sea Marian masaan," says the Peterborough Chronicle (1069). " Ante Nativitatem S. Mari;e " in Florence. ' See vol. iii. p. 338. • The battle of Fulford wa.s fought on Sejitember 30. See vol. iii. P- 350- fS4 rovnriwr n? ircnrny xjfn noktiikkx enoland. «Ar jTm. bIIm*. All NorthumU'rlaml mm* to mwt thorn, niul mon nnm ^^^^ OUUB ffrm fmiu JiKtant »hin*ii to join the nuiHter. Ah in '^ Umml to manr other c-om**, the Nonnan Survey preserves to ub the luiinc of a nn^U* man, who \va« douhtless only one man K*.; - f ain.'nj^ many. A former ilousecarl of Kinp Harold, attacb«il to him doubtless in the early days of his Kant- Anglian gorrrnment. whose name in French ears sounch^l M Scalpin, left the lands in Kssex which AVilliam had nllowdl him to keep and died at York as an outlaw.^ Men too of hif^-her rank and fame pressed to join the host llttMi of the delivererti. Wiiile the Danish fleet was still in the C^ eatuary, it was joined by a reinforcement of ships, sailing- no doubt mainly from the havens of Scotland, which oarrieii the exiles who had taken rcfupe at the court of Malcolm.^ They had been already joined by many of the chief men of the land, who cii(,''crly threw off their ' In I>oin«Kl*y, U. 59, nmong the lands of Geoffrey of Mandevillc in Emms, we find the following entry ; " iHtud qiioquc manerium T. R. PI dedit Ei^gmrua Ilaroldo, ct HcroKluH iterum dedit cuidam uuo himcarlo nomine Sealpioo, et \nU- S<-A]]iinuK dedit uxori siub in dote, videntibus iibus houii- ■oUioet I{<>gero MarettcaUx) et quoilam Anglico. Et hoc testatur liun- ,qaod*udierunt recognoscere Scalpino, et |>o8t<[iiam Rex venit in hunc torrmin t«nuit ifiAe, donee ivit ubi mortuus fuit in £broic& in utlagaria." " Rbrotca" ought to mean Evreux, but the name is often confounded with " Ebormcum," and Evreux would be a strange place of shelter for an EngUah esile. One can hardly doubt that Scalpin, or whatever his real Bame wa«, fought and died in this YorkBhire campaign. But the entry Hm an interest of another kind ; the grant of landn by Esegar to Harold wtmU Mem to connect itnelf with the transfer of Tofig'a Waltham estate to Harold. 8e« vol. ii. p. ^41. ' That the English leaders came by sea is distinctly implied by Florence, 1069; ** Hoani . . . filii ... in ostio Hunibni' fluininis apjilicuenint, ubi •it elite Eadg&rus, coines Waltheofus et Marleswein, multique alii, cum dacM quam ooogregaverant, occurrerunt." The chronology of Orderic (513 D) if Um dear, though he well describes the nature of the great Mtvary: "Jam Adelinus, Guallevus, Siguardus, aliifque praepotentes Aa^ ad Danos contiderant se. Perventum est ad Humbrae lati flomfaiia oetium." Wherever Waltheof and some of the others got their •hipa, tboM which brought Eadgar and his companions must have come from Scotland. THE NORTHUMBRIANS JOIN TUT. DANES. 255 allejriance to William. A band of men of the noblest cHAP.xvm. blood of Eng-land, the descendants of ancient Kings and ancient Earls, were gathered together on board the fleet of confederated Denmark and Northumberlaiul. Thither came the /Etheling Eadgar, once more to try the chances of the last representative of the House of Cerdic. Thither Go«patric. came Gospatric with the forces of his Northern Earldom, the men of the still independent England beyond the Tees, proud no doubt of the slaughter of their would be Norman Earl, prouder probably that the arm of Saint Cuthberht had been stretched forth to save them from the wrath of William himself.' Thither came the exiled Majrleswegen Ma»rle- to win back his own, and xVrchill, who thus jeoparded all Archill, that he had gained by his former submission to the stranger.^ Thither came Siward the son of ^Ethel^nr, SiwarJ the repenting of the homage which he had done to the newly ^Ethelgar. crowned Conqueror in his court at Barking.^ Tliither The four came the four sons of Carl, the treacherous slayer of Earl Carl. Ealdred in the lawless days of the sons of Cnut.** And Earl Wal- thither came the representative of the house most hostile to theirs, the grandson of the murdered Earl, cloaking his deadly feud while they marched together on their common enterprise. Waltheof the son of Siward, the Earl of Northampton and Huntingdon, came now to join the * Chron. Wig. 1069. " And heom com \>wr togenes Eadgar cilJ and WaldK'of eorl and Majrleswegen and Gospatric eorl mid NorShymbrum and ealle \>tk landleoden." On Gospatric, see above, pp. 134, 195. I conceive that " Nor^ymbrum" is here to be taken in the narrower sense, as it seems to be opposed to the " landleoden," that '\» doubtless the men of YorkHhire, and perhaps those of Linde.iej. To the list alrea noktiikkv rvni wn. . aar JiTtu. furcM which were lc«{^icd to deliver tlw laiui (if hin I MM I have mart' tluiu once inridontnlly noticiMl that a cortnin .yn^gi^y obararitv hang* over the nrtiong of Waltlufif up to thin i^^ moment. An oh«»urity of tho like kiiul lmnj»v over his UMbalttw whole character. Aa the victim of the Norinnn Kino>, Tn*mt**^ ■• *^**^ ^^ Enjjliahman who hchl a hijfh secular oHicc ■^•^ under hia goveniment, nx the one man whom, in the whole eourae of his reij^n, William scul to the scaH'old on a political charj»f,^ he won the abiding: love of Eufj- liahmen. And that love took the usual form ; in accord- ance with the invariable feeling of the agu, the j)utriot waa enrolled, by the popular voice at least, in the list of aainta and martyrs. Yet, when we look at the recorded acts of Waltheof, it is not very easy to see why he should have drawn to himself in so high a degree either the love of hia own people or the fear or hatred of the Norman. His ]x»litic»l conduct was lacking in steadfastness ; his reputation as a soldier rests wholly on a single display of personal strength and personal daring; his govern- ment of his Karldom was stained by at least one frightful crime, and the two or three acts of his private life which ooze out from incidental sources are, if not specially criminal, at leai^t not si)ecially honouniblc. His libe- rality to the Church is undoubted,'^ and the accounts • It U worth notice that the worda of the Peterborough Chronicler, " ];a fintle ae eori Wa])>eaf ut." are the same as those that are applied in 1067 to th« going out of Eadgar anoken of, Ryhall and Belmesthorp in \()\.. IV. S tSS CD1IQUB8T Of WB8TEKN AND NoUTHKHN KNOLANI). iiimany the force of the two shires over which he ruled, to join the men of his native Earldom ill welcoming the deliverers of England. It is not plain at what stage of its voyage the tidings The newa of the approach of the Danish fleet was brought to King d^j^^^- AVilliam in the forests of Gloucestershire. The only his- ^'^""b' •' broui^ht to torian who tells us anything in detail about his movements Willmm. makes him hear the news immediately after the unsuc- cessful attack on Norwich. But we can hardly doubt that earlier messengers must have told him of the appearance of the Danes off Dover, Sandwich, and Ipswich. But their repulse from Norwich, and no doubt other move- ments also, now made William see where the real danger from the invaders lay. The revolt of Waltheof, whether Import- he set forth fnjm William's own presence or from his revolt of own home at Northampton, was of itself the most marked "'"'^'''• sign of what was coming. It was York and all North- N(>rthiim- . -r^-.,,. T 1 bcrl.iml the humberland that was threatened. Still v\ lUiam did not jmrt of the leave his quarters in the West; he was doubtless carefully reaii'v "^"^ watching the movements which were soon to break out threntened. on each side of him. But he sent a messenger to York, ^Vill;aIu^s bidding his garrisons there stand firmly on their defence, t,, York, and call at once for his own ])reseuce if it should be needed. As we hear no more of ^^'illiam Fitz-Osbern, he had doubtless left what could have been meant only as a temporary' command.^ The Norman commanders in York were William Malet the Sheriff and the Fleming Gilbert of Ghent. Thcv either overrated the strentrth of their ' See above, p. 241. S 2 160 coKQunr or wi&rrr.RN and noutiikun rnoland. cvAf iTin. own w»IU »nd of their own troon«, or cls(» tliey Rrratly OmMmn urnkfimUtl the forcv %vhich \vni« ocimiii^: n^^iiiiKt tlu'in. «4 WUHmb Utit^mA Thrv went word U> Willinni thnt thoy cxiuKl hoKl out for .*^,,^ • whoie ytmr without calling on him for furtluT lirlp.' Thif iiMMiigv, it iip}Mnint, wns actually Hont after Wal- theof, Ead^r, and the n*«)t had joincMl the DnniHh iiect in the IIuml>er.' York wan neeminply a))out as well f;tiardi*d now hy iti« N(»nnan oppressors af^inst Scandi- nnvian deliven^rfj as it had been ;^mrded tln*ee years Wfore \,y ifK .li.ttten Earl airainst Seaiulinavian invaders. But the news which fell so li«,^htly (»n the ears of the Norman commanders in York told a very diirereni tal»* in the ears of the English Archbishop. Ealdrcd, the Primate who had crownetl both Harold and AViJliam, has a])peared in our history as one who had done his best to keep his 8iari«of province in the olxMlience of the foreign King."' lint his SlilZZt^ later days are surrounded by a crowd of stories, in some at least of which it is hard not to suspect the presence of a legendary element. One tale has already shown him, in his character of g-uardian of the church of Worcester, as witlistanding the terrible SherifT of that sliire, Urse of Abetot.* Another talc more directly concerns his later diocese, and, if it ever hap])cned at all, it could not have happened long" before the time which we have now reached. In this story l-^ldred appears clothed with a higher mission, as daring to rebuke, not a subordinate officer, however high in rank, but the mighty Conqueror himself. Ealdrcd, we are told, was present in his metropolitan city on one of the feasts of the Church, by which must be meant either • Ord. Vit. 515 C. "Illic [in Dan4 Hilv4] audito a(i praeAidiorum non indigeri Huhventu ejus ad annum." • Orderic addi, "Jam AdelinuH &c. ad Danon coniiderant se." • See »bore, p. 186. ♦ See above, p. 175. .STUlilK.S UK EALDKKl). 261 the Christmas of the last year, or the Easter or Pentecost cbaf.xviu. of the preseut.' A hirt^e stotk oi' all manner of g(X>d ^^j^*"^ thinipj was beiiii^ brought into the city from the episcopal lands in its neighbourhood. It chanced that the Sheriff — Ealdrcn! William Malet must be meant — was at that moment going l.^^vsiliiam out of York with a large company. At a short distance ^J*^*-*^- from the city he met the Archbishop's horses and waggons bringing in wheat and other meats for the feast. The Sheriff asked the drivers who they were, and for whom they were bringing those good things. They answered that they were the servants of the Archbishop, and were bring- ing in the things which were needful for his service. The SheriH', caring little for the Archbishop or his servants, bade his own followers seize on the whole of the stores and carry them to the King's storehouse in the castle. When the news was brought to Ealdred, he sent mes- sengers, clerks and citizens, to the Sheriff, and bade him restore the stolen property and make good the loss to Saint Peter and to himself as his \'icar. Otherwise he would at once go on to wield his spiritual weapons against him.- As no satisfaction was to be had, but as the William Archbishop's messengers were driven away with threats refuses and insults, the high-spirited Primate made up his mind restitution. to go at once and lay his complaints in person before the King. He went to London, where William then was. Ealwil of v\vTfry UkI !>' to lUivl him with nil duo honour. They Wfnt fir^i u» |.i»y in tho e|»iMH»|»al church of Suiut Paul, and then to tho Abbey of Saint Peter, hard by which William waidwtllin^f in Eadwanl*H ]>alacc of WcFtminster.* l>lAlilr\xl cntcrrd the n>yal prcwncc in bin i>oiitilical rol>e«, and with hin ttalV in hi» lumd. William rose to j^rcet him with the ki«» of |H«aee, but the Kn^lish Primate refused the prtvtinp; he stood still, and npoke to William in words hueh tm the Conqueror wa« not wont to hear. '* Hear me, Kteflro^ Kinjf William. When thou wast a strangt'r, and when God ^*** in his wrath a^inst the sins of our nation pranttnl to thee to win with much blood the Kingdom of all Britain,'- I hallowed thee to Kinj^, I gave thee my blessing, and set the cpown upon thy head. Now, because thy deeds call for it, I give thee my curse instead of my blessing, as to a persecutor of the Church of God, an oppressor of her ministers, as one who hast broken the promises and oaths which thou didst swear to me before the altar of Saint liaalU*- Peter." William, we are told, trembled, as he had once tkmnd ftiiMttoa before trembleil in the presence of the man who now stood before him.* He fell — can we believe the tale? — at the feet of I'laldred and afekcd what he had done that such a sentonco f-hould pass upon him. The great men who • T. Stobha, 1 703. " Moxque episcopuH illius civitatis cum multitudine cleri et populi ei, ut tanto delteat pontifici, obviam pergens orationiH gratia, priino •d eoclaaUm Sancti Pauli, delude ad ecclcfliam Sancti Petri WcHtmonasterii obi Rex eraty eum honorifice comitatuH est." The King's preHence at Westmincter Menu to point to Pentecost as the fea«t intended. If so, it muat lie the Pentecost of 1069. • lb. "Audi, inquit, Willielme Rex, (luum esses alienigena, et Deo pennittent« noKtrsHjue gentis superbiam puniente, regnum Britanniae, <|aAinTia multo cum sanguine, obtinuisseg, ego te in Regem consecravi et oorooam capiti tuo cum benedictione imposui." • lb. X704. "Ad h«c verba Roi tremefactus procidit ad [>edes ejus, humiliUr efflagiUuu ut in quo tam gravem sententiam meruisset aperiret." CX voL iii. p. 560. HIS REBUKE OF WILLIAM. 263 stood around bo<^ii to assail the Primate with threats, chap.xvui. and to ery out that the man who offered such an insult to the Kino^ should be at once banisheil from the realm.* They bade him at once raise the King* from the g-round ; but Ealdred answered, "Good men, let him lie there; he lies not at my feet, but at the feet of Saint Peter, who has done wrong* to Saint Peter's Vicar." ^ He then raised William from the ground, he told him his wrongs, and graciously acii in to aven^' ntit a private wronj: <»f hin own, but iIh» Kfnonil t»|»|>n'«iiion of liis |H?o|»le. It in hanl 1 . v-.vrr to fit in Uio talc with the known chronolo^^y of la » ■ c: \\ iiluunV rrijfn. An lonjf, wc are toUl, as tho new Kin^ r. ruled with any »how of mmlenition, so lonj? I'laldroil hHuwihI ' I * ' * towiinlii Inm the n»verencf duo to a Kinp.* But when ho sAia-i.i* jiyd nn unlH>aniMe t^ix on the |)ooph«, then luihlred went mciiflnflrm to rcnionstrnto. We nre not told whether this nfm to any of the jjenenil exaetions of which we have alrv«dy heard, but whieh eould hardly have touched KaUl- itti'i diocfso, or whether wc are to supjwse some special local burthen levietl after the conquest of York.- In either caae the mes^ngfrs of the Archbishop were driven away with ijcorn. Ealdred then put forth a solemn curse lUUi«d against the Kin^ and all his ofisprint^^. He had once, fcwMoa be said, blessiil him wrongfully; he would now curse }^J^ him rightfully.'*' The news of the anathema was brought U fa to William ; devotion or policy moved him ; he sent mes- wengers to ICiddred, craving that the curse might be Uiken off. But lx'f(»re they could reach the presence of the Kng'lish Primate, his soul had passed away from this world. There was no voice to speak the words of absolution, and ' Will. Malm. Gent. Pont. X 252. After mentioning the oath which WilliAm had nwoni to I'laldred at his coronation (see vol. iii. p. 560), tDcludiog a proraiDe " quod se modeste erga subjectoa ageret, et aequo jure Aoglos quo FrancoH tractaret," he goes on, '* itaque ilium quamdiu •rg» MUM teroperiem habuit, dilexit ut prolem, veneratus est ut Kegem." Ob* would like to know the number of months or weeks tliat this feeling UsUkI. • lb. " .Sc Ealdred'f own part of England, but it does not amount to absolute pitm. ' lb. " Xon nioratuB llle maledictionis telum in ilium in omnem ejus Tibrarit projjeniem, prsfatus posBe se maledictionem dare merito qui bene- dictiooeni Uediiiaet iramerito." l.NJl'UKT uF TilE .sTuKIKS. 205 we are left to suppose that the curse of Ealdred took its chap.xvui. etfec't in the misfortunes which cloutled the later days of William, and in the mysterious doom hy which all the male descendants of his house were swept from the earth within seventy years after Ealdred had placed the Crown of Eng-land on his brow.' Whatever may be the exact amount of truth and false- Value of hood in these talcs, their real value lies in their showing" ^ ^n. the streni^th of popular feelinfj", and not onlv the stren' « & popular but the permanence of local i)opular feeling". All the feeling, faults and doubtful actions of Ealdred were forgiven ; York and Worcester alike were ready then, and ages after, to canonize the Prelate who had dared to defy the stranger in the cause of his Church and country. And such tales Probable could hardly have gained popular belief, unless there had work of been something* in Ealdred^s real conduct to form a [[^J^^^ ^" groundwork for the story. We need not believe that William really crouched at the feet of Ealdred ; we need not even believe that Ealdred put forth a formal curse against William. But we can hardly doubt that some remonstrance against wrong", some expression of sorrow for his own hasty acknowledgement of the invader, was uttered by the English Primate in his last days. At all events, we know that his heart was smitten with fear and sorrow at the coming woes which the struggle which was about to begin was sure to bring upon his people. The man who had traversed well nigh the whole of the known world on errands of policy and devotion, the man who had stood before Pope and Ca\sar, and who ' In thirt version the death of E.ildred seems to be attributed to grief cauHc'd by these dealings with William ; *' Verumtamcn pnevenerat nun- tio« raorw antistis, qui ex a^gritudine auimi, ut plcrumque fit, contracto morbo decubucrat et obierat." On the difficulties arising from a liiahop dying or resigning before ho had withdrawn a malediction, see the Btory of the Emperor Andronikos Palaiologos and the I'atriarch Athariasios, Finlay, Byz. Emp. ii. 471. ouKQirnT OP wMmif and noutiirrn knoi.am) irm hjul ]iUct%\ the Cmwn on Uic head alike of I!nn»l(l nno ■MiiMlw Ukrn Away fn>m tho evil to cani}*h flcotn had nlnady met in the Humltor, but their banners had not yet been wen K'noath the walli of York, when a tomb within the minster of Saint Peter cloned on the hotly of the last Primate; of North- huniberland of the old stock.' >' -'Ahile the confederate fleets ucrc in the Hiiniber. t'alnekj Tl.* ■ ...; H'cordcil detail of what befel them there is a Sv«atnn7 «ngle anecdote, tellinij how the .Ethelinj^ Ead^r left •■'• the main body with a small company, the crew of a sin^^lc ship, to plunder on the coast of Lindcsey. They were attacked by the Norman <»tirrison at Lincoln ; the whole party, save the yKtheling and two comrades, were taken ; the ship, forsaken by those wlio were left to guard it, was seized and destroyed.* Such an adventure was an evil omen ; but it was nothinji; more. The fleet sailed on ; we are not told at what point of the Ouse the trooi)s dis- 1\» DuMi embarked,^ but it is plain that the most obvious approach Ikh iHM^ ^^ York from any convenient landing'-place would lead ■I*** ^**^ them along the left bank of the river, over the former faattie-gronnd of Fulford."* This road would bring" them • The Worcester Chronicle (1069) Bt-emH to put the death of Ealdred baCore the Danuh fleet entered the Huml>er, but it is plain, from the more cmrefnl order of Florence, th.-xt it liappened between their appearance in the Homber and their approach to York. ■ Ord. Vit. 513 D. "Adclinus ibi [in oatio Humbrae] eeorbuui ab •OCiA tnrbA cum quihusdam Huorum pnvdatum ierat. Quos insilienH familia Regit • Lincolnid cepit omntB, exceptis duobua cum Adeline elapfiis, et Oftrlin eonfregit quara cugto. A host that could not be numbered, pressing* on with one heart and one soul, came within sight of the warders of the Norman castles.' Their captains had boasted that they could dclend them- selves for a whole year without help from William ; but they soon found that such a boast was vain indeed. They l(X)ked for a siege, and their first thou<^ht was to hinder the besieg-ers from filling' up the ditches of the castle and so finding a more ready approach to the walls. Lest the houses near the castle should be used for this purpose, the Normans had recourse to their favourite element. They set fire to the houses in their own immediate neig*!!- The city . , , PI f^red by the bourhood. llie flames spread, the greater part of the Monnans. city was destroyed, and the fire even seized upon the j^^^^^^J^*^ metropolitan church in the opposite quarter.- Whether ' The deacription in the Worcester Chronicle (1069) is most graphic. Tho u-Etheling anfl the Earl.s an'l Thegii.s have come, ** and ealle l)a landieotien, ridende and gangi;ndu [compare Kolf's surname of (linujtrl, mit un- mstan here, swiSe fagengende, and swa ealle anraetllico to Eoferwic foron." ' The Worcester Chronicler would seem to imply a wilful ilesecnition of the minster ; ** And a-r^an \>e \>& scypmenn \>'u\eT conion, hiefdon J>a Fren- ciscan ba Wurli forkemed, and cac ^nt halie mynster Scus Petrus call forhcrgod and fi>rl>a'nied." But Florence Heems to make the burning of the minster accidental. " Nonnanni qui cantella custodicbant, timentes no domug quo; propc Cjuitulla crant adjumonta Danis ad implendaH fossas CAstel- lorum cHsent, igne oa>4 succendurc cn^pertint, <]ui nimis excrescens totam rivilatvm invsiHit, monusteriumque Sancti iVtri cum ipsA cunsuinpsit." w«iu»«>/ niVcjrrsT nv WBBTILHN A\n N(»UTIIKUN knuland. rwAfiviit. thu met .\B intentional or unwittinjf, it was Kp04»(li!y rw iHnrr AV«ig«d. Two dsvi Utor, while it would (toein that tho ^ybrElSi iJaw^ ^^^ '^^^ blttzinff. hut while tho city wiu* not yet ^'^ ^ wholly destroyed, tho host dn w ni^h which was to save it •I. from itj forvijfn mauton*.' Tlio VaitU Waltluof and (Jok- patrtc, and tho chief 'Hioj^ns who had joiiietl tho army, led the way ; the wholo forw* of Dm mark and North- nr.pirr4. hum)H*rland foUowod. Tho garrisons vent urod on a sally, ^'^^land a fight fi.llowoil within tho walls of the hurning eity.^ •.^flmm, j^j^j jjj^^y ji ^yjj^ {hi\t, tor one moment, Waltheof tho son iploitaof of Siwanl and -llthelfljed stood forth as the hero of deeds which handed down his name in tlw warlike son p? of the tong-ues of both his parents. We Ik ar a<^ain the old ring of the lays of Brunanhurh, of Maldon, and of Stam- fordbridgt*,'* as we liston to tlie tale which speaks of the g^iant form of the Northumbrian Karl, his mighty arms, his sinewy breast; how he stood by the g'atc as the enemy pressed forth, and hew, as each Norman drew nig-h, a head rolled on the earth beneath the unerrin^^ •weep of the Danish battle-axe.* Three thousand of the Hie Wincheiter Annaliiit (38) somewhat unfairly transfers the blame of tho barning to the Danes ; " Beornus Comes [see above, p. 348] . . . post alia qua regno intulit mala cepit, Eboracum et interfecit viros, et domoi oombujait.'* ' Flor. Wig. 1069. ">Sed hoc ultione divina citissime in eid vindicatum •at graviMimc. Nam priuwquam tota civitas esset combusta Danica claHsis aopcrvcoit ferii ii." ■ Ord. Vit. 513 D. " C'astellani obviam eis inconsultius exeunt, et intra arbis raa^nia infeliciter confligunt. Non valentea rcBistere multitudini omnaa ioterimuntur aut capiuntur." • The aoojunt in William of Malmesbury, iii. 253, which appears again in the Vit* et PaMio Waldevi Comitis (Chron. Angl. Norm. iii. in), an plainly oomea from a ballad an anything in Henry of Huntingdon. We hare alao the renee of Tliorkill Skallason wliich I sli.iil quote directly. • W ill. MalniH. u. s. " Siquidcm WeldeofuK in Eboracensi pugnA plures N"nnann'.runi hoIuh obtruncaverat, unoH et unoH i>er portas egredientes decapiunn, ner>v*uM laccrtifl, toroHus pectore, robuatuH et procerus toto coqxire, filius Siwardi magnificentissimi comitis, quern Digera Danico voeabalo, id eet fortero, cognominabant." EXPLOITS OF WALTHEOF. 269 strangers died that day.* A hundred of the chiefest in cnAP.xviii. rank were said to have falKMi amonj^ the flames by the hand of Waltheof liimself, and the scalds of the North 8an<^ how the son of Siward g^ave the corpses of the Frenchmen as a choice banquet for the wolves of North- humherland.^ The tale stirs the blood like the tale ofFmitlew- Q^Hfl OI tilC the last victory of Harold by the banks of Derwent. In victory. either case we mourn that the streng-th, and valour, and victory of Englishmen brought no lasting safety to their country. But Harold did all that mortal man could do, and yielded onlv to a destiny that was too stronjj: for him. Tlie men who smote the Nomians in the gate at York threw away the victory that they had gained by the inveterate habits of plunder and lack of discipline. But for the moment all seemed triumphant. The Norman gtirrison of York was utterly cut off. Of the men who had held city and shire in dread a few only were saved alive as prisoners. Among these were the GUbert of two commanders, Gilbert of Ghent and William Malet, winiam to":ether with William's wife and two children.^ The two ^^^^^\ '^ spared as prisoners. ' Flor. Wi^, 1069. "Plus tribus milibtis ex Norraannis tnicidatis." Tlie two Cliroiiiclers say only, "fela bund manna Frenci.scra jjjfir ofslogon." ' Tlie story in the Saga of Harold Hanlrada (Jobnston, 218 ; Laing, iii. 95) about \yaltheof burning a hundred Frenchmen in a wood after the battle of Senlac seems to me to be simply moved to this fight among the burning ruins at York. Anyhow the verses of Tborkill Skallason are Hpirited ; *' Hundrat let J heitom Frctt er at firdar kn.-ttto Hirdmenn iufurs brenna Flagd viggs und kl(» liggia Sokiiar yggr enn seggiom Imleitom fechz ata Svido kvelld var I'at elldi. 01s bl.ick vid line Fracka." This iKaTona heafodmen hjefdon on beandon." In Florence and Simeon (85. Hinde) wo get the names; "Willelmo Mul<-t [fjui tunc vicecomitatum gerobat, Sim.] cum sua conjuge et duobus liberie [et Gileberto de Gant, Sim.] aliiscpie i>er paucis vita; rescrvatis." The captivity of William Malet is also mentioned in Domesday (374^. It Tim rra roxgrerr or wrktrrn and n*»kthkhn kn(}Lani). oiArtTtn cmftlrt %iviv bmken down.' An c-nlij:ht4'noa cuRUd&B gewunnan." Chron. Wig. "And KoDc cMtel lohrxctm and towurj)an." TJie distinction <>{ the castlea iH flMDtiooed •e%-eral tiraeH in DomcHday ; (298), •' primo anno post destruc- tfa—n CMUilonim ; (373), "antefjuam castelluni captum fuisset," '• donee iBViaam ail OMteUum," " donc-c fractum est cawtellum." • Plut. TuDoleon, 22. " 'E»rrjp»/^« rwv 'ivpoMOvaiuv rhv $ov\6fJL«yoy irap(7vat **•▼■ vASpev Kou 1 ' - PI PI- niovemcnta slaughter of their garrisons, and of the capture of their in the commanders, was presently brought to King AVilliam in the West. He had work on his hands there also. It is plain that the tidings of the coming of the Danish 'fir 8« irdvjfs iLV(&t](rav, i.pxhv iktvdfpia^ iroiricrafXfyoi fif^aior6.rj]v tA K-ftpiryfia /col t^i/ jjfu'pav ^Ktii'rjy, ov ^6vov ri]v iiKpav, a.Wk koX toi oiKias Kol rh ^ivrtfJLaTa tuv rvpavvuv auirpf^av Kal KaTtaKa\l/ay/' * Flor, Wig. 1069. "Castellis eodtitn die fractis." ' Ord. Vit. 513 D. " Caatella dcsolata patent." I do nut know th.tt the wordn of the Engli.-^'o veil. i. p. 426. fTl rc>XOfi»T Of WESTKRX AND NOKTIIKKN KNCiLAND. i«Ariritt (k«i ) . ' 1 to rttungn in \-mnoini jinrt* of Kn^lantl, oven in thirty Ur away frtim the Uankn of i\\v lliimUor nnil tho •hon<« of tho (icnnan (X*can. \Vhilo William wan in the Forwt of Pfan. war iifipnin br.»ko out nortli and poutli of him. Devon^hin* and Somerset rose oiuh* ni«»rt», and thcro were hostile movements in StaiTordsliire and Slmi|»hbirt\ a district wliitli must Imve remained very im|H»rfivtly huUIuihI up t«> thin time The men of the \Vi>t had coiJtle« to fi;;ht a^inst as well as the men TlwcMiW of Yorkshire. I have already told how William's insati- uiutmi' ^y^ brother, RoU»rt of Mortain, now ICarl of (.'ornwall and lord of vast estates in all the Western shires, had niiiicd a fortress for the defence of his new possessions. He had raised it on the very heig^ht which had hcheld the fmdin^ of the Holy Rood of Waltham.^ From the peak which !iad now taken the name of Montaeutc, the fortress of the stranf^r Earl looked down like a vulture's nest on the 8urroundini> hills and on the rich valleys at its foot. Of the castle itself not a stone is left ; the present ornaments of the spot, the prar-eful tower of the parish church, the rich gateway of the fallen j)riorv, the mansion of the latest days of English art, are all things which as yet had no lx?ing. But the wooded height still covers the fosses which marked the spot which the men of Somerset and Dorset in those days looked on as, above all others, TbteMtle the house of bondage. In the further West the fortress which had grown up on the Red Mount of Exeter - held G^mtni the men of the once j)roud commonwealth in fetters. in t^ The men of all the Western shires rose by a common impulse. Tlieir zeal now, after so many defeats and hangings of their country, shows how deeply the sons of Harold had erred in trusting to tlic holj) of foreign plunderers, instead of boldly throwing themselves on the • .See almye, p. 170 2 See above, p. 1 61. W thiim. RISINO IN TIIK WEST. 273 patriotism of the people of the Wealhcpi. No names of chap.xvui. leaders are *^iven us; the movement seems to have been a thorouirhlv ])0|)ular one. We read how the West- Tlie men Saxons of Somerset, Dorset, ami the neighbouring dis- set an.! triets besieged the eastle of MontacuteJ Meanwhile the J^^^y^ men of Devonshire, strengthened by a large force of the Monta- Britons of Cornwall, the immediate victims of Robert ofHTin:KN KN(JLAM). MATJivtu. wboW countn- on l>oth iiiiltii of the river, iind thiK neck of Uml. rwinjf tUvp •Ijovc the Htn»aiii, luul dtmhtlcHH hwn chotrn in 4«rlior. mt well um in lator, tinunt iih tlu* site of the ftronxHoKl \\\\u\i wiw to kivp the honh'i- land in IW«M» mwt. At what time thin iniiK>rtant ]>oht liml iiillrn into "^" the hnntU of the Normann we an- n<»t (nld ; but it in •**'"*--•" plain that ShrewHburv waa now held by a Norman ^ar- ri«in, and a Norman ^^rrinon commonly im])lird at least the l»cj»innin>p« of a Norman rastle. It may be then tliat ShrfWhbury wa« already bridliil by some banty fore- runner of the fortress whieh was soon to become tlu* centn» of the jwwer of the united house of Montgomery and Ikdesnie. At all events, Shrewsbury was now in WillianiH olxnlienee, and a motley li<»st was gathered to Hki««»* aasault this new outpost of the strangers. Besiegers ^tftdhj gathered from all ))arts, and the J<]nglisb inhabitants of 2j{,",J>e ^^*-* ^<**^*" itsi'lf eagerly joined them in their attack on W«bh and the Norman fortress. Thither came Eadric the AVild, dMiUr. who had never Iwwed to the Normii!i King, with the foroee of his own still independent corner of Hereford- shire. Tliither came the men of still unconquered Chester, where the widow of Harold was perhaps still dwelling with her child, after the treason of her brothers and the overthrow of her stej>-sons. And from within the Cam- brian frontier the subjects of Bleddyn, now the sole King of Gwynedd and Powys, Hocked to the call of their old ally. The united forces of so many districts and races now laid siege to the fortress which had arisen on the bank of the great border stream.' Meanwhile York was falling, or had already fallen, and the Danish fleet was ' Opd. Vit. 514 A. "Gualli et CcHtrenses prsesidiurn Regis apud Scro- betbnriiin ob«erlerunt, quibus incolee civitfttis cum Edrico Guilda, potent! et hjBllhwo Tiro, aliiiif{ue ferrxribuH Anglirt auxilio fuerunt," Rhiwallon, it will be remembenxi, had died in the civil war (Kee above, p. 183), ho that BLeddjrn wm now sole King. THi: ENGLISFI ATTACK S1IKR\VSB!'RY. 275 still in the Xorthunibrian waters. The power of William chap.xvim. was threatened on every side, and one mi^-ht be tempted to think that it needed somethin<^ like his star to ^uide liiin to victory when so many foes were leag-ued against him. We should he glad of fuller details than we have of The revolt* 1_ 1 1 • 1 11 1 P"' ilowu the steps by which all these movements were i)ut down, piecemeal. The account in our single narrative is given with a good deal of confusion.* But we see that all were put down, and that they were put down without any great difficulty. The story of these campaigns is in many respects the storv of the rei^n of /Ethelred over ao^ain. There is far State of from being the same cowardice and treason. We meet feeling, with p]nglish leaders who are perhaps somewhat hasty in making their peace with the Norman, but we do not read Improve- either of armies forsaking their leaders or of leaders for- ^^sthelred's saking their armies. The rule of Cnut, of Godwine, and ^^^* of Harold had clearly raised the moral and military tone of the nation. But there is the same local isolation, the Local i sola- same incapacity to form any combined plan of operations, English in- the same general helplessness in the absence of any one "^'^e^^^- chief of the type of Eadmund and Harold. Whatever attachment men had to Waltheof, to Eadric, to the sons of Harold, was mainly local. Eadgar, the one man who might on sentimental grounds have become the centre of loyalty to the whole nation, was utterly unfit for com- mand. Add to this that, while the patriotic English had Their lack to struggle with enemies among whom the military science pHned of the age was carried to its highest pitch, their own niili- ^^^l^'^™- tary resources must have fallen back even below what the resources of the country had been in the days of .'Ethelred. ' Our only account of these Western cnm{>aign8 comes from Onleric (5 1 4), who doubtlcHH followH William of Poitiers. The English writers mention onlv the march against York. T 2 :7o c\i>gLt5T Uf ^^EiTTBRN AND NOllTIIKUN ENGLAND. .•ATJivui Ai in ihe tUrtfof .iCtlirlrttl, tluTP wan no nutionul Htandin^^ annv. In hi* J«v« the force of the lloiim'tarlM Imd not r9i come into U'ln^r. and now thot force had been Bwept airav frt»m the rarth. VmtU lik«' Walt heof and (ioH|>atric no doubt kept a ivrtain number of arnieil rnllowen* con- nim ttaotly in their pay. Hut that noble army which bad ^SammmiiB *»«*n called into lK»in^' by Cnut and broup^ht to iHirfection •**■*'" bv Harohl. the army which had overthrown Macbeth and Gnilfydd and Ilanlrada. had died, man by man, around the fallen KinR" on Senlac. There was no lon<^cr an Hn^litih foRv of which men paid in other lands that any one man therein wa** a match fur any two elsewhere. In thetc later enterpriscH everything had to be trusted U) such a force a« the towns and shires could supply of iVwipttn- themselves at a moment's ciill. There was also another wide ditference lx*tween the two cases. The opposition ^^ to the Danes was the work of a regular g-overnment, which, iiuimmmI weak and vicious as it was, was defending" territory which aomtotlMwas actually in its own ])Ossession. The opposition to . ormmos. ^^^ Xomians was driven to take the form of isolated revolts a^inst an established gx>vernment. It was at most the defence of isolated pieces of territory in which it could hardly l>e said that there was any regular g-overn- mcnt at all. The men of each district had to rise, how they could, af^inst those who were in the actual possession of power in their own districts, and they had little means of communication with their brethren who were eng-agcd AH Um in- in the same strug-gle in other ])arts of the country. They goTsrn- ^*"*^ ^^ strive against the forms of Law and against the 22^^ influence of property — Law which was now administered now on the by the officers of a foreign King", property which had Xocinui . . pftaBed away mlo the hands of foreign owners. It was no longer as in the two great campaigns of Harold, when the tried and disciplined soldiers of England were matched ugainst the tried and disciplined soldiers of other ISOLATION OK TIIK KNOLISII MOVEMENTS. 277 lands. It was not even as when the levies of each (listriot chap.xvtii. were ealleli('f of MontJM'uU' iintliT the cximinaiul of Hinhu)) (itotrrey of M«M CotitJUiotY, whoiM* va«t K-ranti* of hincl in tl»e Went were dirtily thivatoncil by tlie innurreetion. A^niinnt the nun of SouicrM't ami Dorst't he Utl the men <»f London, \Viuche»t4>r, and Snlihhnry.' Thetk» wonls would douht- \f*4 take in detacdinientn from the Normnn ^urriKonH of tiio«o eitie«. But when we consider the nature of the furw which JC4idn<»th KhI a^nst tlie yons of Harold,^ and of tliat wliieh William himself led to the first sie^ of Exeter,' it i-an hardly fail but that Geoffrey also com- manded the yjrr//, the legal English levy, of those towns and of the surrounding shires. Thr force thus raised waa, we are told, esi>ecially under the Divine j)ro- iection/ whether because they had a Bishop to their captain is not more fully explained. ^^ C have no details of the march or of the operations of the warlike Prelate. We are only told that the force under Geoli'rey attacked the li English who were besieging Montacute; that they slew some, took others prisoners, and put the rest to flight. The prisoners, according to the martial law of the eleventh Poimh- century, were punished by mutilation ; " in the more BfntnaivT ixjlished days of Elizabeth or James the Second these forerunners of the followers of !Mon mouth would hardly have escaped the gibbet or the quartering-block. The ffuppression of the other revolts is recorded with equal lack of detail, and withal with a good deal of confusion. Earl Brian, whom we have already heard of as defeating * Onl. Vit. 514 A. "GuentAtii, Lundonii, Salesberii, Gaufredo Coii- •lantieiud pnesole ductore, Hupervenerunt." " See above, p. 226. ' See above, p. I^9. * Ord. Vit. u. ». •* Divino nutu impediti Kunt." * lb. "Qaoedam peremeruDt, partim captou mutilaverunt, reliquos fngaTeruiit. " T' THE WESTERN INSUKOENTS DEFEATED. 279 the second attempt of Ilaroltl's sons/ a^in appeaiH <>ii chap.xvhi. the stag"e. AVith him is coupled an Ilarl William, whether {^^}-^°^ of '^ ' linan and the game who had been his companion in the former William Fitz- campai'ii'n or the more famous \\'illiain Fitz-OslH-rn «)f(j^j,^rn. Hereford is not so clear as we could wish. Our sin<»"le account seems to send the same pair of commanders at once to the relief of Exeter and to the relief of Shrews- bury.^ But we can at least see, what is perhaps the The most important fact in the whole history of the campaif^n, Exeter that the citizens of Exeter were no longrer on the patriotic J,S^.?,V^ . \NiIliaiu. side. With the Norman garrison of the Red Mount within their walls, the actual pressure brought upon them was not small ; in such a case they may well have been tired of enterprises which brought so little fruit, and they may have been well pleased to accept a season of peace even at the hands of the stranger. The spirit of the proud commonwealth was so changed that its burghers, so far from giving any help or comfort to the insurgents, seem to have actively joined in driving them back. The de- Defeat of fenders of Exeter, a name which most likely takes in both ^jegere of the foreign garrison and the English citizens, made a ^^^ter. vigorous sally, and drove away the besiegers from the walls. The flvinir insurtrents were met bv the forces of ' .See above, p. 244. ' Ord. Vit. 514 A, B. *• Exonije cives Ilegi favebant, non imiuemores pressurarum »juart olim passi fuerant. Protinus ubi Rex hrec accepit, Comitcs, duos Guillelnmm et Briennum, laborantibus subvenire pnecepit. Verum priurtqiiiim illi Scrobesburiam perveiiissent, urbe coiubustu hojjtcs discesserant, defensorcH quoque Exonite subito eruperuut et iinpetu in se obHidentoH abt'j^'tTunt. Fugientibu.s obvii Ouillelnuis et Brionnus p;randi ca'«le teineritatein puuieruiit." From this account, taken litcniily, we should certainly think that the same two commandera were sent both to Exeter an. our^Tiu the two KarU. and |wi(l, wr arr iM, iUv fortoit of their tmi^tk&m hv Itcin^ lanitton with a f^rcnt fdnu^^iitor. The hope* of the \Vit... The hopw of tho nhircH on tlu' Welsh l»(>rih'r were rrnsh«Ml BO law utterly, hut it iit not (N{iially eiiMV to follow the marrh of eventii. The IjoHio^in^" fon^i* of lOiulric, Kn^-lish and WcIhIi, diK]i|))K>Aml from Shrewshury, alter, it would nam, huminp the town." The movement at Stailord, that one of Uie three which \Villiam looked on an calling: for hia own prei^ence, still remainetl to he i>ut down. Hut as Avmkai yet he had not time to attend to it. The danger in thi> wM^tW North, where the Danes were actually in the laud, where ^ ' ' the castles of York had l>een hroken down, and the city itaelf was little more than a heap of Mackoncd ruins, was the gT^atest danp^r of all. William knew when to pause, and he knew als<^) when to act with speed and ener^^y. The over confidence of his commanders in York luul for once lecr, and the ships had been drawn chap.xviii. up on the coast of Lindesev.' W illiain and his horsemen ^'•; ""'■- j)riH«-M the followed them, llie crews were evidently scattered over Dan. h at the country, which ^^ illiam seems to have scoured with his horse. Some were overtaken and slain in the marshes of the district ; others were driven out of various lurkinpf- places, of which w(> have no distinct account, hut which would seem to have heen some kind of rou<>h and hasty fortresses, which William deemed it needful to level with the g^round.- But the mass of the invaders made their They re- way to their ships, and crossed over to the Yorkshire side Holder- of the estuarj'. There they were safe for the present. ^^^'*' William had no naval force in those waters; so the Danes were left for awhile to devise plans by which they might aveng^e both themselves and their comrades. ^ William had thus done all that could ])e done with the means immediately at his disposal. If he had not crushed the invading host, he had at least made them feel the force of his hand, and he had shown with what speed he could appear even in those parts of his Kingdom where his presence was least looked for. As he had no immediate means of reaching the Danes in Ilolderness, he himself went back to put dow^n the insurgents who still held their ground at Stafford. In Lindesey he left two trusty William captains to guard that coast against any attacks from the i^'^,}^,^.^^ ,,f Danes on the other side of the Ilumber. One of these ^l"rtain and Uohert was his brother Robert, Count of jMortain and now ofofEuto Cornwall, who was thus soon called away from his new Danes in estates in the West, and who must have been lighting ^'"^*^'^®y- in the flats of Lincolnshire at the very time that the ' Ord. Vit. 514 A. *' Illi vero nietu maj^oii hellatoris in Humbram au- fu^iunt, et ripie (jux* Line<»d, to put down the enemies t-o the south- wrtit whom he hati Ihhmi oMiped to bear with for a season. He ap|>cared at Stallonl, and there is none of his exploits of which we should be Wttcr pleased to have full details. WOHmb*! Oar one account, if vag>uc and l>ri(>t'. is still eniphatie. 4«#— I. By an easy success he wipearty.- Hut the eflects of the blow were lastin<^ ; many entries in the Survey show how deeply both the town and s»»«» the shire of Statford suflered, and how much lies hid under »itb U>c *^<^ ^'^^ »"*^ pithy words of our story. The wasted houses tfVBKoJ ^1* ij^g town, the wasted lands of the shire, the vast Miirc. scale on which the confiscation was earrieil out, show that Staffordshire must have been the scene of vigorous resistance, and that it was therefore marked out for special vengeance.'' ' See l>ome»Uy, i8. • OnL Vit. 514 B. " Rex interim apud E^Htafort quam plurimou factio- Mmm {iartium facili pruventu delevit." Here Orderic — can it be William of Poitiern T — sto|>8 to comment on the general state of things ; " In tot eeriaminibos sanj^is utrimque multus effuuditiir, et tam inermiH quam armata plebn divenii) infortuniia liinc indo miserabiliter concutitur. Lex Dei paMiro violatur et eccleHiasticuH rigor [>ene ab omnibus dissolvitur. Cvdat miaerorum multiplicantur, Hniin.-LMjuecupiditatiHet irce HtimiiliH Ktimu- kuttur ao aanciantar, et catervatim hinc inde ad inferna raptantur, Hiniiato Deo, cujus judicia e««e juHtiHeima comitrobantur," • Domesday, 346. "In burgo ot wum tliou;:l)t of. Tin* Oiinoii ^YvSt* ■***' "*** *loul»t thrir Kn^•liJ*h friemU iiIko, wore |)ur|K)«injf to kwp the Mitlwintvr I'Va*! at York.' This. a« Wfll oa vbat fi>Uow», gho^xi cither thnt Honio ronKitU»rahh« |Mirt of the city mtiKt hnve csrajKMl the ManieH, or else thnt, an »o ofU*n httm>enc In* repairef of houses which WIDttai were mainly of woocl.-' To hinder this enterprise, or a^in J. to ftirpriw his enemies in the moment of rejoiein^, William set forth from Nottiii;^ham. He marrlied as far Milr«MlMi M the banks of the Aire. That stream Hows from the hi^h UMnwr iumjg ^lijeh so lon^ divided tlie Northiimhrian Anj^les from the Northern Welsh, and finds its way into the Ouse below the hermitap^e which was perhaps already growing into the minster of Selby, hard hy the spot which was in after times to become the site of the palace and Ofipn of minster of Howden. Tlic spot itself where William reached '.r-^nrx ^^^ Ftream is marked out as lyinpf in the neifT-hbourhood '.* ui«r of one of the most famous castles reared bv those whom the event of that cam]>aigTi was to set as lords over Northern England. It was near the place where Ilbert of Lacy 1313. raisetion, as well as the evident distance of the ford from Pontefract, seems to show that, if the tale is to he trusted, the ford must he htoked for in the hilly country far uj) the river, and that the march to York must have been made by a roundabout course indeed. It is perfectly easy to understand that fords which were available in summer would be useless when the stream was swollen })V the ' See Tol. i. p. 300. * The only notice of tliu Lirfois wliich I can find in Donifsday is in ii. 49 b, where he appeani in posseHHion, but «eeniingly ille«jal posaefwion, of A oiuJl hohling in Essex. Half a hide waH held by " ii. franci honiineH," •* quam oocupavit LisoiHUH, (juia unuH illorum utlagavit." * Ord. Vit. 514 C. ** D«ili- was taken onlv bv storm with the slaug-hter of thousands ponitiou. of men.- But it seems i)lain that he entered the city or its ruins, and found no man to withstand him. The Northumbrians had gone each man to his home after their first great success/ and we hear nothing which show^s that their forces had been again brought together. Of the Danes we are expressly told that the news of their flight was brought to William before he had reached the city.-* His first object was once more to secure its possession. A force was left at York, with orders to begin at once with The ca-t!e.s the repair of the castles, which were once more to hold the repaired. * This ia the probable suggestion of Sir Francis Palgrave, iii. 455. ' This seems to be the meaning of Matthew of Westminster (1069), if that is the right name ; ** ElM)racum, ubi fuit Danonun receptaculum, potenter cum ibi inventi.s ex{)Ugnavit, et nmlta niillia honiinum ibidem interfecit." This is wrought up by Thierry into a picture of a dearly bought victory on tho part of the Nonnans after a long defence of which the " Roi Edgar " seems to be tho hero. ' See above, p. 271. * Ord. Vit. 514 ('. •* Eboraco ai>propin(|uatum est, sed Danos aufugisM nuntiatum est." !«- 2ii C0KQI*I8T of WtSTERN AND NoKTllKUN KNOLANM). .SAFJivtti tur(n>|>oli« of the North in Huhjfction.' And now vnuw ' "''•» that fi-arfiil tlixnl. hnlf of |>olicy, Imlf of vonjfiuincf, which \ t'. . u. luui i»tam|Htl thetuuneuf WiUiam with infiuny, and which foniii* a ch-arly nmrkc(»r wroi)*^. The aifi' wa-«< a ^te^n one, and hitherto William had certainly not tiiinned aj^iinst the ]>ub]i(' opinion of the n«^e. Hitherto lie had been on the whoh' a merciful concjueror. He had shown that he belonj^ed to another tyiK? of beings frtim the men who had wiiated his own Duchy in his child- h(xtd, and from the men on whom Siward and Tostij,^ liad striven to put some check within the land which he had now won.- Siward and Tostig* were both of them men of blood, stained witli tlic ^-nih oi' private murder, from which we may be sure that William would have shrunk at any time of his life. But we may be no less sure that Siwanl and Tostig, harsh as they were, would have shrunk from the horrors which William now proceeded deliberately - to intlict on Northern En<^land. The luirryinf^-s of which o Sussex and Kent had seen something on his first landing* ^ were now to be carried out, far more systematically, far more unHinchin;L,'"ly, throuc^h the whole of Yorkshire and several nei^hbourin<^ shires.' The Kinf»' took the work ' Ord. Vit. 5I4C. " Rex trilmnos et pnt'sidcH cum annatorum manu, (jui r««it*ur&n.Mit iu urbe caatclla, direxit, tt alion mhilumiiius in ripii Ilunibra.', qui Danifl reNUtcrent, reliquit." ■ .See vol. ii. i>. 381. 3 s^^je y^Jl jj; ^j, ^j, -^^ * The great harrying of the North iw mentioned briefly but emj)haticHlJy to the Chronicles, 1069 ; " |:'a hc kyng ^i« geaxode, ha for he norSward mid ealre hia fyrde ^e he gegadenan mihte, and ^a scire mid ealle forhergode and awente." So Florence ; " Quod ubi Ilegi innotuit Willelmo, exercitu moz congregato, in Northymbriam eiferato properavit auimo, eanique per toUm hiemem devMtare, homineJKjue trucidare, et multa mala non cessabat THK KAVACIINO OF NOUTlll MBERLAND. 289 oi' destruction as his personal share of the conquest of chap.xvui. Northuniberhuid. lie h'fl otliers to build his castles in ^Viiliam'* pi-nfonal York ; he left others to watch the Danish fleet in the Hhare in Til iii'in 111 1 1 ^^'*-' *i*-*va«- llumber; but he himself went through the length and tation. breadth of the land, through its wildest and most difticult regions, alike to punish the })ast revolts of its people and to cripple their power of engaging in such revolts for the time to come. That all who resisted were slain with the sword ^ was a matter of course ; Harold had done as much as that in his great campaign against Gruffydd.- But now William went to and fro over points a hundred miles from one another, * destroying, as far as in him lay, the life of the earth. It was not mere plunder, which may at least enrich the plunderer ; the work of William at this time was simple unmitigated havoc. Houses were ever}'- Utter de- where burned with all that was in them ; stores of corn, property of goods and jjroperty of every kind, were brought together l^'n*^^- and destroyed in the like sort; even living animals seem to have been driven to perish in the universal burning.^ The authentic records of the Conquest give no hint of any ex- ceptions being made or favour being shown in any part of the doomed region. But local legends as usual supply their Legend of tale of wonder. Beverley was saved by the interposition of vatiou of its heavenly patron, the canonized Archbishop John.^ Tlie ^6^'*^"®y- agere." Fuller details come from Orderic, the Evesham History, and other sources. ' Ord. Vit. 514 D. " PleroHque gladio vindice ferit, aliorum latebraa evertit, terras devastat, et domos cuui rebua omnibus concreniat." '' See vol. ii. p. 474. ' Ord. Vit. u. 8. " Spatio centum niilliariorum ca-stra ejus diffundun- tur." * Ih. " JuHHit \r& stimulante segetibus ct pecoribus cum vasis et omni genere alimentorum repleri, et igne injecto penitus omnia simul comburi, ct sic omnetn aliinoniani per totam regionem Trans- humbranam piiriter devjwtari." • On the hintory and legenda of Saint John of Beverley (Bishop of Hexham 687-705. of York 705-718, died 711), «ee Ba'da, v. 3-6. W.' VOL. IV. U ooHqruT or western and nokthkun knuland. cmApJitnL Kil^ )i««l pitob«x) hin camp •oven inilrn from the town, when 0«w« wa«bn>ii^'ht thut tho )kn>|i1(> of tho wl)ol(> lui^h- bourhood had Ukon »)ii>lter with nil thfir pn^ciouH thin^ in the inviitlahh* mincttinry which wdh aflonlcil hy the frith^tool of the saint.' On hearing; this, some plundcrcrH, ■rvniinfrly without the Toyn\ onlcrs,* wt forth t<> niiike n pnpv of the town and of thos*^ who had sou^fht shelter in it. Thejr entered Beverley without meetini'' with uny mwtanrr and made their way to the churchyard, where MimcukuM a vant crowd of jxHiple was ;»utherest )>u most sendan raffc beagHA wiff gebeorge," LEGEND OF nEVERLEY. 291 in hand, spurred his horse within the consecrated doors. ^ chap.xvih. But the venijeance of Saint John of Beverk»y did not slumber. The horse tell with its neck broken, and Toustaiu himsell", smitten in his «»wn person, his arms and legs all twisted behind his back, no long-er seemed a man but a monster.- His atlrij^hted comrades laid aside all their schemes ot* plunder and slaut^hter, and humbly implored the mercy of the saint.^ They made their way back to AVilliam and told him the tale of wonder. The William Kinof had already shown himself a friend to the church the righti of Saint John,^ and now, fearing* the wrath of the saint, I^ ,, ' ' '^ ' College. he summoned the chief members of the Chapter before him, and agiiin confirmed all their possessions by charters under the royal seal.^ He added new grants of land and precious gifts for the adornment of the minster,^ and, what was of * Al. Bev. 1 29. •' Extract© quo erat prsecinctus gladio, per medium plebla attonitie, super cniissarium fureua senem persequitur . . intra valvas ecclesie jam pene fugiendo exstinctum insequitur." ' lb. '* Ecce equus in quo sederat fracto collo corruit, et ipse, facie jam deformi post tergum versa mauibus pedil)usque reti)rtis, velut raonstrum informe omnium in se mirantium ora convertit." It is curious to see how Thierrj' (i. 319) waters down the miracle ; "son cheval, glissant sur le pave, s'abattit et le froissa duns sa chute." Of course this is likely enough to have been the kernel of truth in the legend, but no man luvs a ri^ht to tell the tale in this shape as if it were undoubted fact. On stories of this kind, see the profound remarks of Professor Stubbs in his Preface to De Inven- tione, xxvii-xxix. ' lb. ** StuiHifacti et exterriti socii ejus, projectis armis et deposit! ferocitate, ad impetrandam Sancti Johannis misericordiam convertuntur." * See above, p. 305. * lb. " Rex, audita virtute gloriosi confessoris, verensque similem ultionem de ceteris, accersitis ad se majoribus ecclesise, quajcunu^ue l)riorum Reguui vel principum libertate eidem ecclesiae fuerant coUata, regia auctoritate et sigiUi sui munimino confirmavit." The chief of these fonuer benefactors was yKthelstan, the second founder of the church in its secular sliape. See the legend in Bromton, X Scriptt. 838. I suspect that this present confiniiation is a legendary version of the earlier one in Ealdred's time. * lb. " Ne ipse i)ra;dece.ssorum suorum muniticentiis esset impar, pni^fatam ccclesiam pretiusis dunis decoravit, et ))<>ssessionibu8 am[)li- avit." L 2 ar4lM 39t LV>AfH«5i uK WESTERN AND NoUTHKIlN KN(iLANl). r«*rtnii moff» imtnrdUte value than all, that thon* mij^ht hv un M**^ further d«njri»r of tho pe»oe of Saint John InMnj^ broken, fl^^ hf at oDcc bnikc up bin ramp by wnind of trunipot, and rttnovcd bw bcad-erliai>8 outdone in si^'iiilleance by the i)assionle8H EHblMiB witncsB of the g-reat Survey, the entries of *' Waste," " Waste." " Waste," attached throu^li pa^c afltt. gftf). " Nee ttrra aliqiia erat culta, excepto solo temtorio bcati Johaniiw licverlaci; nam ibi quidain Regis niileH, collo etjui Mii fracio et fkcie pn^pria retortA, vindictam iucurrebat," ■ I Uke at a venture pp. 505, 305 b. After a long Htring of places we read, •* omcU waiita pntter Engelbi." After another such list, *' omnes ntnt waaUe except^) Wirueltun." The entry of " waata" occurs ahjo in twenty-four other placen in thoHe two page«. These are on landa belonging to the two great Earl« Robert and Hugh. Tlie dcKtruction however wan not cpread quiU- e«|ually over the whole land. In pp. 319, 319 b, the fatal word occum only nine times. Among the places which escaped we find the names of " Bameburg" and " Sproteburg." Sprotburgh has its frithatool a« well as Beverley, and it is hard that it has not also its WRETCH EDNE.SS OK THE CorXTIlV. 293 lurkinff-places tor ruhlHTs and wild locusts. ' Kven ;i chap.xviii. ireneration hiter the passinjj travelliT ))elu'ld with s<^)rrow 'f'."^ . . abiding the ruins of famous towns, with their lofty towers risin^^ tr;ic«rM of above the forsaken dwellinc^s, the fieUls lyin^^ uiitiUed and ravaj^ej*. tenantless, the rivers flowin*^ idly throu<>h the wilderness.'^ At tlie time the scene was so fearfid that the contemporary State of writers seem to lack words to set fortli its full horrors, r^^ t^^ ^Fon, women, and children died of hunus vel exstinctis gladio ct fame, vel propter famom pateruum solum relinquentibus." * Flor. Wig. 1069. " Nonnannis Angliam vastaiitibus, in Nortliynibria et (juibusdam aliis provinciin anno j)ra'cedenti, sed pnisenti et subsecpienti fere per totam Angliam, maxime per Northymbriam et per contigujw illi provinciaa. a^leo fames pr.'fvaluit, ut hominea ctpiinam, caninam, cattinam, et carnem comederent humanam." StI CONQt'BST or WEffTKRN AND NoKTMKUN KN(il.AM). c«Ar init thMA, toiDettliiat, whm Imppirr cIdvh hml (^otno, to lie iot fipM bj the churity of their iimi»(erH.' Ik'fore the etn\ of the year, Yorkiihire wm a wiKlfnu'sj*. Tin* h«Klies of tte inhAMtunt* were rotting: in the ntreetit, in the In^^h- wajt, or on their own hearthHtonrn ; an^. men )^c heonon heora lieafotl for hjra mote on ^jim yflum daguni." Mr. Kemhlc (SaxonH in Enghmd, I. 196), who mentions other examples of the practice, refers this deed to a time " afl late as the X«»rnian Con«jue.st." From the words wliich follow, in which Gospatric is mentioned, the document would seem to belotig tf) Um year 1070. Geatflied Bets free another party of slaves, who are deecrit>ed as " )>a men l>c heo Jiingede ait C'wiespatrike." All the names are Bngiieh or Danish. This example illustrates the general description of Hupeon of Durham (85), •• Alii in servitutem perpetuam sese venderent, dunuDodo (jualitercumcjiie miserabilem vitam sustentarent." • Ortt Vit. 514 D, 515 A. ** Nusquam tantA crudelitate usus est Goillelmus, hie turpiter vitio succubuit, dum iram suain n-gere contunipHit; 6l reoe innocuosque pari animadversione peremit. ... In multis Guillel- mam nostra libenter cxtulit relatio : sed in hoc ((uod una justum ot in- jnsfeatn rabide famis lanced a-quo transBxit, laudarc non audeo. Nam dum innocuos infantes juvenesque vernantes et floridos canitie senes fame peHclitari video ; mlHericordlA motuH miKerabilis populi mneroribus et anxietalibuM magis condoleo, quam frivolis adulationibus inutiliter studeo. Pr»t«rea indubitanter affero quod impune non remittetur tam feralis occisio. Summos enim et imos intuetur omnipotens Judex, et seque omnium facta discutict ac puniet districtisKimus vindex, ut palam omnibus enodat Dei perpetua lex." This passage is valuaVde, even if it be simi)ly the comment of Orderic, whose sense of right and wrong was keen enough. Bat it becomes of tenfold value, if we can believe that he copied it from William of Poitiers. It would show that there were bounds beyond widdl eren that abandoned flatterer refused to follow his hero. WILLIAMS CHIUSTMAS AT VOKK. 295 blood except in open fi<^htiii^. Me had spared the lives of cuap.xviu. rebels whom a less merciful prince miy-ht liave doomed to Pro''***l« ' e.Htimntc of the slaughter. His venf^eance fell only on the lands and William poods which were his own lawful forfeit, and if their former owners died of hunger through their loss, that was no guilt of his. All this, all that had gone before, all that was to come after, was to be done and sullered that William might win and wear the Crown which the choice of those whose gift it was had given to another. And, as if in mockery. Ho hold* W illiam decreed to show himself in all the pomp of king- (^hristma* ship in the midst of the land which he had wasted. He (^^J *^ * 1 ork. would remind men that all that he had done was not the 10^9-1070. act of a lawless invader overcoming his foreign enemies, but the act of a lawful King subduing the rebels who had again and again risen against him, who had slain his garrisons and broken down his castles. The Christmas Feast was this year to be kept, not in the new minster of Eadward at Westminster or of Ealdred at Gloucester,^ but amid the ruins of the houses and churches of the wasted metropolis of the North. The Crown which Ealdred had j)laced on William's head was to ]>e worn in his own city, when there was no Northumbrian Primate to do his duty to his King, and only the blackened walls of the minster to be the scene of the ceremony. Still the form was gone through, doubtless with such diminished splendour as the circumstances allowed. The Crown and all the other badges of royalty were brought from Winchester ; the army was left encamped without the city, and King William, not King Eadgar or King Swend, held the Christmas Feast in Vork.-^ It was doubtless at this grim * See vol. ii. p. 435. ' Ord. Vit. 515 A, 1>. " Inter l)ell.'i (Juillelinus ux civitato Guenta jubet adferri coronaiii, alituiuu oni.imt'nta regalia et vnsa, et diinisso exercitu in castriH Kboracinn pergit, ibique Natale Salvatoris noatri cmcelehrat." This is confinncd hy the Worcenter Chronicle, 1069 ; "And HG kyng wa-H \ntuo niidwintres daig on Eoferwic." 9M COXqriMT or WEHTERK AXU NoUTHKIIN P.N(JI.ANI). kinjf the ro<'ky hinl of the dark Swale, hr rranxl the eantle which, under itw French name of Kiehmond, bo lonp remaine in Yorkshire, aft<-T tlii' K.irls HtiL'h .-ind I<4>lx;rt, but his estate in the largeHt of the thre* • The de«c«at «*f Duchy ami Harldom may be Ktudied in Dng^lale's Baronage, 46, and in the Art de Virifier leH Dates, ii. 897 et seqq. See alao Gale, RegiHtrum Honoris de Richmond, the Preface and the Oeoealogioal TVee. It is enough to remember the regrant uf the Earldom to Dnke John in 1368, and the descent from him of the famouH Arthur, the Constable of France, in the fifteenth century, ' I cannot find any authentic dates for the different parts of the castle of Richmond, one of the fineHt Nomjan buildings in the kingdom. Gale attribute* the buiMing of the great tower to Couan, the fourth Earl, II 45-1 171. It would seem to be of late Norman date, but retaining an earlier entrance. Tlie hall overhanging the river struck me as possibly earlier than the keep, llie original cha{)el is very Hmall and plain. Both ball and chapel stand quite apart from the keep, showing how completely, at all eTent4 in castles of this palatial kind, the keep was merely an oocaaional place of defenc<<. • The name of " Kichmondshire " is familiar ; see Gale, and Whitaker'a Hiatory pnuim. Richmond also giveo itn name to an Archdeaconry. lilCHM(JNI) AND Pt)NTi:KKACT. 297 slope of the hill, and »i Benedictine Priory, a cell to Saint chap.xvmi. Mary of York, crowneil the opposite height beyond the river. At a short distance IVuni the town, amon^j the woods by the river side, arose in the next a^e the Pro*- monstratensian Abbey of Saint Agatha of Easby, and the tall slender tower of the still later F^ranciscan church mij^^ht almost seem in its gt^neral proportions to recall the archi- tecture of an earlier day.* Another Yorkshire borough arose on the estate of another of William's followers. Ilbert of Lacy became lord of the lands where William's Lane 1h of host had tarried on their Northern march, and, on the Lacy ; nearest convenient spot to the presumptuous river, the p^^'l^frLt incident of the campaif*'n was commemorated in the name of his castle of Pontefract or the Broken Bridge.- Another grantee was William of Percy, the founder of a great name, whose genuine bearers soon passed away, but which has been, like that of the Caesars, artificially handed on to later times.* The still more renowned name of Robert of Bruce also appears in the Survey, but his lands were a later ' The Priory of Saint Martin was founded about i lOO by WjTuar, dapifer to the second Alan, and a chief benefactor was ** Roahlus filius Roaldi, filii Alani, constabularii Hichniundia^." Earl Conan himself was also a benefactor. Mon. Angl. ill. 6oi, 6o3. Roaldus [Rliiwallon] was also the first founder of the Abbey of Easby. Mon. Angl. vii. 921. The Fran- ciscan Friary was founded in i^tS. Mon. An-^d. viii. 1545. The tall slender tower of the fifteenth orsixteentli century is, jis usual, inserted between the nave and choir of the elder church. Easby is well known for its noble refectory; of the church but little is left. " See above, p. 384. ' The Percies, who seem to have a mythical genealogy before they landed in Normandy, most likely came fnnn Percy in the C»^tentin. The genuine line became extinct in the third generation with William, the son of William's second son Richard. See Dugdale's IWonage, 370, and Hartshome, Feudal and Military Antiquities of Northumberland, 185. His daughter Agnes, in Hutiry the Stjcond's tirnt!, married .Irabant or I^>wer Lotharingia, a desct^ndant by female succession of Charles th<; Gri-at, iti whoso line, and afttTwarda in those of Seymour and Smithson, the artificial house of Percy has l)eon continued to our own time. 198 CliXQrEST or WBSTKRy AND NoUTlII^KN KNOLANI). rjiTiii. ifift fnnn i\w Coiiciuomr.' Tlicw nrv namw 8pi«ciaUy bclon^D^ to Northom hiHt«»rv ; l»ut Williani'H iinmtMliatr kinsfolk am! frioniln iliil not fail t<» oonu» in for tlu-ir shnre. Karl Iljupitlil'ii lanilii at Coninij-ibur^li |>uiwtojjo of Hrvrerr, whot*c lejfenilnry buton* I «hall iliiMniBH elsowluTc, ohtninod a ^rant of tho penin8ula of IloUlonioss.^ Still many lOn^lish Tho^na ^[ijjji^ retained their lands under the Crown,' while others had to •••■•^ hold them of Norman lords. This is speeially the case with the lands of lll)ert of Laey, which were larg-ely held by their former owners," while on the lands of Earl llol>ert thev aeem to have l)eeii almost wholly dispossessed in FaII in th» fiiTOur of his foreij^^n followers. But, after the frightful havoc of this winter, lands in Yorkshire could have been of little value to any man, native or strang-er. Throu<>;-li paf^ after page of the Survey the same frightful entry of *' Waste" constantly meets the eye, and a more attentive study will show many a lordship which had once kept uj) the hall of more than one English Thegn, but from which only the barest shadow of profit could now be wrung for if^ Xorman owner.*^ • DomeiKUy,332 h. •* Hie e«t feutlum Rotberti de Bruis, quod fuit datum pOstquAxn Liber de WintoniA Hcriptus fuit." • Domesday, 321. Conin'iijsburj^h and itn ajipurtenances Heem to have been the only po««e«BionH <»f William of Warren in Yorkshire. • Domesday, 305-308 fj. • See Appendix GG. • Domemlay, 330 h, 331 h. • In pp. 316 h, 317 fc, will be found a lon{j list of English tenants of libert, many of them holding lamls that had formerly been their own. To be mire, many of the lands arc waste. ' Thierry quotes the passage in Domesday, 315, where we read of a Yorkahire estate, " Duo Taini tenuerunt per ii. maneria. Ibi sunt ii. ▼fllsni cimi i. canicA. Valuit xl. solidos, mwlo iiii. solidos." In the same p^ge are other similar entries. Sacroft, which hat! been held by five Eaglkh poff QUI, and was worth four pounds, was now held of Ilbert by KLIGIIT OF .KTllKLWINi:. 299 Yorkshire was thus conquered. \N'iniam had made a cuAf.xvni. wilderness and he calhtl it peace. Nor can we douht ^V'l'''""* '■ .Miil\% iiit«r that order rei«^ntd in Veik while the Kinj^ wore his campaiifn. - . • 1 • -vi 1 1 January, Crown at the Al id winter reast in his r»orthern capital. 1070. As soon as the holy season was over, more warfare, more havoc, was to beg-in. With William the time when Kin^^ go forth to battle was not bounded by any limits of the seasons, and in tlie extreme North of Eng-land there were still foes to be overcome and lands to be wasted. In some Englinh remote corner, seemin»j^ly near the mouth 01 the lees, in ^]^,, ,„outh an inaccessible spot surrounded by marshes, a daring band ^f'^'^Tees. still defied his power. They held out in a fastness stored with rich i)lunder, and deemed that there at least they were safe from all attacks.* The lands of the future Palatinate of Durham were al-o unsubdued. Since the overthrow of Robert of Comines, no Norman had appeared within the franchises of Saint Cuthberht. ]3ut the land of the saint was already a wilderness. Bishop ^ilthelwine night of and his priests had already fled. Frightened at the horrors a„'(i i,,, which were croino: on south of the Tees, thev determined f ''^"""'^ =* ° » V from Dur- to leave the church and city on the height above the Wear, ham. and to seek safety once more lor themselves and tor the u, 1069. body of their patron in his own holy isle of Lindisfarn. No one was more eager in recommending this course than GospatHc the Earl Gospatrie. Whether out of zeal for their pre- their fli-ht. servation or from any less worthy m(jtive, he himself under- took the keeping of the more precious part of the moveable ornaments of the churrh durinir their absence.'- The tr> a certain R«»l>ert, wa.s entered jus waste ami vahied at twenty pence. The next phvcc, Tornevre, held hy four Knglishmen, liad ]>een worth four jH)und-<, and wa« now worth ten hhillinpi. ' Ord. Vit. 515 IJ. " Kurrtuni coinperit hostile collegium in angulo rpioilam regiuniH latitare, mari vel paludibuH undiquo munito." The position of thin place of Hhelter iH marked hy the course of Williiun's maivh, when he set forth to reduce it. ' Sim. Dun. Hiut. Dun. Eccl. iii. 16. " Hie enim Go8]tatricuM hoc maximo COKQUIBT UY WE8TKKN AM) NOKTHKHN KNOLANI). our.iTiu. Bishop Mid hiii vU'tVh then net fortli. I'oiir davR wore taken up with the inareh, the finit of wh'wU 1. <1 tlwm to the mouth of the Tyne, at the point where it«* waten* T^ f^mehuTf joinei! by thone of the northrni Don. There, <»n f!^^' the banks of the inlet hH*nlly known as the Slake of rs«|ikn Jt^rroxr, utill stood the venemhle chureh of the nionnstery where fifptla hainta to his Scottish birth or descent. He vexed them on their course in every way, hindering" their passag-e, plunderin|» the gpoods which they bore with them, and seeminp-ly doing personal despite to tlie holy men them- ThcT reach sclvcs.^ Notwithstanding- all these difTiculties, on Die fi[„j; fourth day, towards evening, they reached the coast of f7ihviT *^^ mainland opposite to the Holy Island. A miracle c«*n'»g- enabled them to reach the goal of their journey more daderat ooomlium, ut fufficnUn cccleHiain relinquerent^ et ipse maximam omajnentonim ejun partem Hocum alMlnxerat." ' On the Htate of Jamtw ami Monkwearmouth at thin time, see Afipendix HH. ' Sim. Dun. Hint. Dun. Eccl. iii. 15. *' Prima qiiidem nocte in ecclcHia Sancti Pauli in Ojrnum, necunflA in I^-tlilingtun, tt-rtiA in loco qui Tu^hala dicitur, nuuimt." • lb. 16. " In fugA memoratA quA cum Hancti patris corpore aeginning with Gil, see MiBs Tonga*! History of Chriatian Names, ii. 113. GOSPATKIC AND niLMKHAKL. 301 Speedily. The tide, which was lull when they reached cuap.xviii. the coast, ebl>ed at once to allow them to cross, as the waters by Mount Klimax made way for the passa^' of Alexander.' As soon as they were safe on the island, the waters came back, so that no pursuers mi<^ht overtake them.- A sin<^le ag^ed clerk was sent back to Durham to see how matters fared in the church and city. On Lej,'en.l of the way, m thr visions oi the ni«^lit, he beheld oaint and Gil- Cuthberht and the holy Kin^ Oswald, and he was warned ^^^■^'^■^• by them that the judi^ements of another world had already overtaken the wicked Gilmichael, whom he had so lately seen flourishing* and boasting" that he could do mischief. He was warned too that woes would fall on Gospatric also for his timid, perhaps sacrilegious, counsel.^ The priest sought the Earl and told him of the divine threat- enings. Gospatric hastened with naked feet to the Holy Island, and craved pardon for that in which he had ofl'ended. But on him vengeance came in this world ; the loss of his Earldom and all the troubles which befel him were his punishment."* ' See the story iu Arrian, i. 26. 2, 3 ; Plut. Alex. 17; and compare the comments of Josephus, Antiq. ii. 16. 5. * Sim. Dun. Ge.st. Kej/g. 86. '* Circa vesperom, quum plenum undique mare adveuientibus proliiberet ingreaaum, ecce, subito sui recessu liberum pne- stitit introituni, ita ut nee festinantes alitiuaiito tardius se([uerentur fluctus marini, nee tardantea aliquanto eitius pnecurrerent. Quum autem terram attigisflent, ecce, refluum mare, sicut ante, totas arenas operuerat." The story is told at greater length ami more dramatically in tlie Durham Historj', iii. 15. ' See the whole story in the Durham History, iii. 16. The words of Saint Cuthberht about Gospatric are, *' Vae tibi, Gospatrice, vae tibi, Gos- patriee, eccle.siam meam suis rebus evaeuAsti et in desortum convertisti.'* * Sim. Dun. Hist. Dun. Eeel. iii. 16. "Cujus [Gilloniiehaelis] tonnenta intolerabilia C'omiti Cospatrico, sed et ea quK de illo a pnedicto sancto audieram dum referrein, pavens illo intremuit ; moxcpie nudis pcdibus ac found.' None staywl in their dwellinjf* nave those who from any caune InektHl the mmnii of fli;;!it. Tlie ramp of refujje by the mouth of the Teee waa well stocked with provinionH, and was \\ fondly deemed to lx» impregnable.^ A<»iiiu8t this stronp- f^ h«»ld, at once the nt»arest and the most danperous of the *' ppots held hv those whom he callev i)roxv. They ajniin swore oaths to him and became tl^^o*" a»"^ .. -ii'-n- • •! LfOipatnc. his men, >> illiam even consentin<^ to rt»eeive tlie oath of Gosj)atric, as he had received the oath of Kin^ Malcolm,^ at tht' hands of his messeng^ers.^ IJoth ICarls were re- They are instated in their Earldoms, and no doubt in all their pos- ^^ ^\^^.lJ. sessions. Waltheol" indeed was more than restored to his J^^'rldoma. former place ; he was admitteKQU»*T OF WBJITKRN AN*I» NOUTIIKHN KNCJLAND. ouMirm. WM» not a11ow«hI to inmin* nafrty or panlnii for the liind ^*^'^'"T' OTfT which h«' niM. ^V^ must KunnoM* tluit tin* Huh- ifcgMnii musioii of CioKpntno wm not nr(>t>iii|mnHHl by any ^nonil •uhmiMiion of the rhicfn and jxH>|i|f of liis Knrldoni. \Vlint- c»T«»r mav have been thr can^ \vit)i tho lan«l ln-yond tin* T\nr, thf land Mwchmi tho Tynr :mi8hop Ealdliun. ' lie appears an a tenatit in capite in Dome8«lay, 331, 331 ^- All hiH estates had been held by himself T. R. E., but the amount in but small. * Simeon in his History (89) 8|>eaks ca-sually of " Eilaf huscarl apud r»gem pra'pollen.i honore," v/hom he classes among *' principales viri." NOI.. IV. X inf. COHQUBUT «»F \VKas4» that tlieir lands wore connnnitcU (k* yd, while they were still in the Kin«;'s Allcgiancv and in his apparent favour. Had Morkere to look on durinjf the o)n«iUest and desolation of the I'larl- ilom of whieh he dinv not seem to have heen formally deprived?' And where was Eadwine when William went forth to overcome the sjnvial home of his house, the last citadel of independent l']n«;land ? UllUam For we are now drawing near to the entl. One more \*^^ ^ march throuj^^h the wilds of Northumberland put William in complete possession of the land whose native rulers IHOeoaka had again howed to him. From the Tees he returned march by ^ ^ork by way of Ilelmsley,^ and the chronicler of his lltliiuA«y. mareJi ny^v becomes specially eloquent on the difficulties of the passaj^e. Some change in the weather may have made Uiosc difficulties even more frightful than they were on his march northwards. We now read how his course led him through hills and valleys, where the snow often by while neighbouring districts were rejoicing in the bloom of spring.'* Through that wild region William now ' We shall see, two years later, that Eaclwine and Morkere were then still courtiers of ^ViIliaID, and the Earldom of Gospatric took in only Kurtliutnberland in the narrower seiiHe, the Earldom of Oswulf. * In the text of Orderic (515 C) William is now carried to Hexham, an impossible piece of geography. See Appendix Y. I thankfully accept the correction of Mr. Hinde (Hifit. North, i. 178) ; "On this route be [Orderio] places Hexham (UagUHtald), doubtless in mistake for Uehn.sley (Hamelac), which is on the direct line from the lower valley of the Tees to York, and repones under the dreary summits of the Hambleton ranye, to which the above dcMcription unquestionably refers." I have for once been content to take Mr, Hinde's word for the character of the district. This Helmsley must be diMtinguished from Gate Uelmsley, which figures in the history of Stamfordbridge. See vol. iii. p. 356. • Ord. Vit. 515 C. " Mense Januario Hex Guillelmus Haugustaldarn rt-vertebatur a Te«iii, viA quae hactenus exercitui erat intentata; (lu;! WILLIAM KETURNS TO YORK. 307 matle his way aniiil the told ami ice iA' winter, ll needed cuAr.xvm. the hiddiuj; and the exanii)le of a leader who was ever *''^"*'* o I eULTifV of the foremost, and wh(j shrank IVoni no toil which he laid ^Viiiiam. upon others, to keep uj) the spirits of his followers.* The mareh was toilsome and dangerous; the horses died in crowds; each man pressed on as he could, thinking* oidy of his own safety, and reeking little of his lord or t)l" his comrade.- At one point AViliiani himself, with six horsemen only, lost his way, and had to spend a night in utter ignorance of the whereabouts of his main army. ♦ A chance attack from some band of wandering outlaws might i)Ossibly have delivered England. Tt might at least have nndone the work of the Conquest, and thrown the coni|uerors into utter anarchy and confusion. But the fortune of William once more carried him safe through all dangers. He reached York, and there he He returna finally settled the afiairs of the city and shire."* We m,j Hiially should be well pleased to know all that may possibly ^!i'!*'^ ^^i*^ lurk in so vague a phrase. Some confiscations, some the North, grants of land, are doubtless implied ; but we know that ^j^^ caatlea he restored the castles, and he most likely took other ^^ ^ ^^*'- measures for the restoration of the city, a large pai-t of which must still have been a ruin. William's work north of the Ilumber was now done. The land was thorou^hlv l''»"al con- quest ot conquered, but it was thoroughly conquered only because Northum- it was thoroughly wasted. The strength and the life of *^**" crt-bro ucutissinia ']w^ii, et vnlliuin Iminillinia; seiles, (|Uiim vicini.-i HorciiitHto vcriia gttUilet, niviburt conipluuiitur." * Ord. Vit. 515 C. "At ille in acerbistiimo liiemih gelu tranoivit, ani- moiM}ue niilituiu confirniavit huu alucritate." 'lb, " lllud iter difficulter peractum est, in «iuo sonipeduni ingeiia ruin.'i fucUi e^t. AnxiuH pro .suik quid([ue salute exstitit, duniinitiue paruni aut uniioi nieuiinit." ^ lb. ** In eA ditticultute Kex cum aeniM tantuni equitibua abcrruvit, ot noctem integrani ubinani eHHent (|Uoh ductabat igiiarua exegit." * lb. " Eboracuni reversuH coniplura illic caritcUa restauravit et urbi ac regioiii cmunK.dii ordinuvlt." X. 2 300 0>NgrKrtT OK \VK>ri.KN .\M> .Noinill.K.N l..Nt,l.AM». rtl xf iviii th« wlioli* tltntrict ami iU |>c«»|>lf !ia«l 1hi?ii liruken l»y hw mcmlcM jwlu*)'. W»« hliall hlill luar <»f one or two local oiitbr\tik« in NorthiimU'rland ; we hhall hear of inroails in irhich the Scut nto up the little that the Norman had NoriWfv rparvd. But we nhnll hear of no more luittles or sie^^es imSf i" which William had Ktill to strive to win or to krep the Northern jxirtion of hi« Kin^^d(»ni. AViiliain wiis now lord of NorthumlHTland ; hut, in hein^ lord of Northumher- Und. he was lonl only <»f a wilderness. One corner of England now alone remained to he eon- quen*d. Chester was still untou<'heH pretty well in the direct line for a march from York to Chester. ' Ord. Vit. 515 C " Deinde movit cxpcflitionem contra Cestronsos ct OuaIlo-4, qui, prwter alias offensjts, nupeniine S<'n»l)eslmriam obrtcdorunt. KxercituH autem, f|ui dura toleraverat, in hoc itinere multo (iuriora rentan! tinu-hat. ^'t,•rt•lKltur cnim locorum a.sperit.itt'm, hiemis intempe- riem, alimentorum inopiam, ct hostiiim tcrribilcm ferocitatem." * lb. C, D. ** Andegavi, BritoneH, et Cenomanni servitiis, ut diccbant, intolerabilibus oppido gravabantur, un«le pertinaciter a Hcgo mis-nioncm |»etcntcH conn«, who wore in jiomo sort hi« vntiKnln, wi»ro not reckonctl iimonjj' the meroennriot*. Hut it in hunl to schj how any troop* from the rival land of Anjou conld have l»een nerving* in Williani'H army in any character hut tluit of private adventurern.' Still we can understand that mere gtH>jj:mphical ncij^hluiurhnod nii«»^ht kee]) to^-othcr the forces of North-westeni Ciaul, after those from more distant rej^ons had 80uji;ht their dismissal. On the other hand, it is easy to hclicve that new swarms of strang'ers had (1o<"ked to AVilliam's hanners to take llwir chance of a 8han> in the spoils of Kiif^land. At all events, it was the men of Anjou, Maine, and liritanny who took the lead in the mutiny. Tliey demanded tlirir dismissal; they complaimnl of the hardship of followinpr a lord wlio was ever aiminn;- at some new cnterjirise of boundless anihition, and was ever laying" on his subjects orders too hard to be carried WDBuii** out.- AVilliani, we are told, kc])t the examide of his model with the Ca?sar before his eyes. lie did not stoop to entreat llie ■luUiiMn. mutineers or to win them over by j)romises.'' He set forth at once, bidding the faithful and valiant to follow him ; as for cowards and weaklimj-s, he recked little whether they followed him or not.^ This kind of dealing* told on the Difficult troops. They marched on, making their way among high Cbour ^*^'^ ^^^ deep valleys, across rivers swollen by the winter's rain, and bottoms which the same season had • See vol. iii. p. 314. • Onl. Vit. 515 D. " Sui niminim .id expurgationem depromebant non poHK domino semper nova et immoderata audcnti nimiaquc prsecipienti obtequi." ' lb. ** Rex autem constantiam Julii Csesaris in tali necesaitate sequutuH Ml, nee eo«i multo precatu ecu novin pronnnHiH retinere dignatus est." • lb. *• Audacter incef>tum iter iniit, fidaHque nibi cohortes se Hcqui pnecepit : desertores vero, velut inertes pavidowiue et invalidos, si disce- Hant, parvi pendit." - * — ^ h. T tJw JieJ^4*Ufj> t,l ih^ ( larmti/m J^js. HIS DEALINGS WITH THK MITINKKKS. 311 chanp^cd into well nijjh impenetnible marshes. Storms of chap.xviii. rain and hail troubk'd them on their march. Horsemen and footmen were brou^sima? valles, rivi et amnes periculosi, et voraginosa vallium ima. In hac viii gnuiientes ssepe niniio vexahantur imhre, mixta intenlum grandine. Aliquandu pnfsta- hant cunctis uxum equi in palxidibus evecti." - lb. "Ipse Rex multoties pedes cunctos agiliter praecedebat, et labo- rantos manibus impigre adjuvabat." ' H». " Tand»*m exereitum incolumeni usque Cestram perduxit." For Chester and Che-shire see the ent, qui jlitiores Hunt camibu.s vivunt, panem hordeit-iura tt siligi- nium pn) magno complectuntur. Transmittitur a CVstra Hilwniiam revehunturrjue civitati necefwaria, ut quod minuH natura soli habct lubt»r negotiantium apportct." Henry of Huntingdon also (M. U. B. 693 1>) speaks of " IHhemis Costtia propinqtians." ilf mvorrsT nr wKsrrnv wn noktiikun kn(jlani). .tnii. OUntonbury iin«i IVlorlM.n»u>fh, at Kxetor iiiul Lincoln. Hut ho w.iH not yet Kin^' nl (lu^stiT. Tlu« old City of the Ix»^otML, the river on which luul^'ar had U«cn rowinl by \niMnl Kin^>*. the minster where the Kn^lihh Hii> ileus had knelt with his vahmiI Kin^^^< n round liini, the walls frttm which men eotdd look out on the land which Ilnndd had nddcarely 8too|)ed to lu W*J own a nominal lord in the Teutonic Cirsar. By ancient ri^ht the men of the whole shire were bound to repair the walls and the hrid*^ of the local cajiital,' and we cannot doidit that, in the C(>urse of the three years during* which Chester had maintaintnl its independence of the invader, the lal>our of the surrounding lands had been willin<^ly given to strcn<:r^hcn the last national stronpi'hoid. There is no point in \Villiam's history at which we should more pladly welcome the minutest details than in this, the last »ck of stag^ of the real Conquest of En. 715 B, who calls ^'Ethelfrith'M victory " bellum bellorum ma.\inunn." ' See vol. iii. p. 403. * In 894 the Danish artny pureneil by the English took refuge within the mined site of Chester. The way in which the place i.s .spoken n( liy the Chronicler in remarkable ; ** pjet hy gedydon on anre wa^stre ceastre on Wirhealdm ; 8eo is Li;,'ecea.Mter haten." It is curious to find the future projier name of the city used as an appellative, " a waste chester." Flo- rence ia more distinct ; *' Civitateni Legionuni, tunc tenjporis de.sertani, quie Saxonice Legeceaster dicitur, prius<(uan» Regis yElfn'di et /Klhrredi Hubreguli exercitus, qui illos inse«|uutus est, ussetrant." The fugitives were able to defend the ** geweorc," as the Roman walls are called, very succe.sKfully. • Chron. 907. '* Her wa-s Ligcf-a-ster geedneowad." Florence (90S) is fuller; •' Civitas qua Karlegion I'.ritannico, et Legeceaster dicitur Sjixonice, juHtu ./Etheredi Ducis et .40gelfl«! of any othrr Kfij^linli city, nrn! tnu-fM of (heir Konuin forrninin^rH still n»iTmiii. enough to hhow Ihat, rxcrpt at thin |M>int, tlu* lino of tlio Romai) fort ifiurli, then n Fcn-ulnr. but soon to l>oronic .1 rir hou(iC, nnr( ad. It is jdeasant to learn that many of them found some measure of food and shelter at the <^ates of the Abbey of Evesham. The prudence of Abbot yEthelwig', Clinrity and the favour which he contrived to keep at the hands the Ruf- of three successive Kinjjs, had at least not quenched his ^f^'""/^ " ' 1 AI)l»ot will to help the distressed, while the yet untouched wealth .-Kti.elwig of his Abbey alloweil him the means as well as the will. ham. The houses, the streets, the churchyard, of Evesham were crowded with homeless wretches who, well ni<^h dyin<^ of hunf>'er before they reached the hospitable sjjot, had barely strengfth to swallow the food which the bounti- ful Prelate offered them.^ Every day, five, six, or more Mortality of the fugitives died and were buried by the pious care fuJitives. of the Prior /Elfric, to whose immediate guardianship the sufferers were entrusted.^ Nor was the bounty of .Ethel wig * Hist. Evesh. 90. " In priinis ttinporibus sui regni lIcx \\ illiflinus fecit tlovastari quoMdain 8cira8 istis in partibus, propter exRuIeu et latrones (|ui in HilviH hititahant ubitjue et maxima damna pliiribus hominihus faciebant, videlicet Eoveruuicscire, C'eaatrescire, Scrobscire, Stafonlscire, Deorbihcire." ' lb. " Maxima multitiido Renum, JMvenum, mulierum, cnm parvulis Hui.s, faniis miseriam fu^icntes, dolentissimc hue venirbat. quo.s omncs illo vir mi.seratua pro po.s.Me suo .ilcbat. I'lurts namiiue diu absorpti ilurissima fame, dum cibum avidiu8 sumerent, moriebantur. .lacebant mi.seri homineu per t'ltam villam, tam in domibus quam dufMris. necnon et in cilit<'r morifntcs a Pnore hujun loci Htpcliebantur." The hical hiMtorian l,' in the lioly houw» of Siiint KrH^winc' Hut little wnj* the help whieh all the Prelat<'H and Tlie^-ns of Kn^flancl, had every one Invn as openlmndeeople.*'' AlWfrd A hundred thonsand hmnan heiiips, no Rinall portion of the inhaliitants of Knjjland in tlir days, are siiid to ''y* have dieT Hublatu Kege Willielinc) jiiliente, factuHest refugiuin etadjutor piuMiinus in maiiinuH necettHJiatibuH." Tlie writer goes on to mention « *" ■ !•-• actH of . •Ethel wig, especially his custom when travelling of n . „ , 'Wers give up their cloakH — whicli however were restored two- fold— to any whom they met by the way in want of clothing Tliis remindii one of the Btr)rieH tfdd of KimAn by Plutarch (Kim. lo), and of the story told by William Fitz-Stephen (Gileg, S.T. C. 191) of Henry and Thomas. • Compare liurke's dcHcription of the suffering caused by Hyder Ali'a clerMtation of the Camatic ; " The alms of the settlement in this dreaility of the time may lead uh to accept the Uk'aI tni«lition which Hin'okn of an earlier cattle in the town itM'If. which from an entry in Dituiexhiy' wonUl srcin to ha\c Ihimi huilt and destroyed 1 cfon* the end <»f Willijiin's rvi^. Tlic castlcj* lK)th of Chcst^, imd where the Norman !!• trricw* minstcr was soon to rise. The great i)lain which is now covered by the modern city was well suited for a final gathering' and review of the victorious army. On that jja. ground, more than five hundred years before, had Cynric the Wcst-Saxon won one of those great fights, each of which marks a stage in the change of l^ritain into England.' And now William's host gathered on the siimc spot, to mark the last stage of the change by which England was not in- deed changed into Normandy, but was driven to accept the Norman as her master. The Conqueror now gave great gifts to the men who had shared his toils, gifts which, we are told, were reward enough even for all that they had ' In Domesday, 348 b, it is said of one of the lordships of Henry of FcTTcrs, " ad hf>c inancrium pcrtinuit terra de Stadford, in qu.1 Hex prui- ctj'it fieri caMteliuni, rjuod Miodo est dt Htructuui." Local Htaffordbhire wriUrn altto speak of a cattle in the town, distinct from that on the some- what diittant height. An unavoidable jiccident drives me to speak of ^itafford from much older and vaguer recollectiuiiH than those wliich 1 can bring to bear on most of the places mentioned in this Chapter. " Onl. Vit. 516 A. " In reversione suil apud Estafort alteram [muiii- tiooem] locavit; milites et alimonias abunde utrobique [at Chester and Hiaffunl] iniposuit." • See vol. i. p. 341;;. KEVIKW AT SALKSIUUV. 311) gone throiij^-li. Tln' coiKiutTurs of York and Stallord and chap xvm. Chester, the men who had hiid wa^te Enj^lish homes and Hi- re- tields, and who had forced their way throuj^h the frozen puniHi»- hills and valleys of Cleveland, received from the mouth "'*^"^ of tiieir sovereign the praises due to their deeds. They were at once dismissed with all thanks and honour. And those who had forsaken William's banners, or who had ijuaikxl under the toils of his marches, received no heavier }»unishment than to lose their share in the rewards of their comrades, and to he themselves kept under arms for forty days longer.' When AVilliam could thus send away the troops whom he could really trust, and could keep himself surrounded only by discontented mutineers, it was plain that England was conquered. It remained only to get rid of the Danish allies who had TliuDunisli promised so much, and had done so little, for the deliver- i„ai„.s in ance of En^rland. Osbeorn and his fleet stayed durin**" the !, , whole winter in the Ilumber, beyond the reach of William's 1069-1070. arms,-^ but not beyond the reach of his arts. Osbeorn was perhaps in his heart not over zealous 011 behalf of a land from which he had once been driven into banishment.-* At some stage of this memorable winter William contrived OsU-om to send a secret message to the Danish Earl, and to win ^villi..l,„; him over by the promise of a large sum of money. He was to siiil away when winter was over, and he was to be allowed in the meanwhile to plunder the English coast, on condition that he did not come to any actual engagement ' Urd. Vit. 516 A. " Pervenicii.s iiulc Sulesburiam pntiniji militihus ibi pro tantil tolerantiu lar^ns8itne distribuit, bene luoritos collauda\it, et cum ^'^ratiik multu diiiiUit. Deserturen auttin ml tlicH xl. ultra disccH-suni cuiniiiilitonuin per indii,'n.itioneni retinuit.euque pvL-na delictum quod pejus meruit cikitii^avit." ' Chroii. Wig. 1069. "And |iit liS heig calne winter innan llundire, Jwtr He kynj^ heom U> cum.iii lu- niilite." ' See vol. ii. p. 6{. 1 310 (XiXQfKOT •'»' wrsTri?\ wn v«»htIIKKN* Kvci AND. r«kr.anii. with tlir Kiii^*» furcH**.' Tlirv toniiK, (<» Uxh ilih-i.P . .nid tial niin, ho l^f^^HHl to. H ^ liowcvcr to have done* 1 his U'stt to rh(*at Uith iiitleti, Ntiniiaii ntid Kn^^^linh alike. Wo hhall mtr in the ixjurw of the next year that Williain'H lioMice to phinder waM Honiewhat lihenilly eonstnieil, and that the time diirin;*' whieli the Daninh fleet wan to l>e allo\ver*r». the doing* alike of Hnj^lish rcvolt^'rs and of their Danish ■ *^ ****■ allies. So, 8t)me\vhat later, we shall hear of the doings of I « Hri'ton, Cenomannian, and even Norman revoltc»rs. Still . v the Conquest was now really over. After the fall of Chester no int«'^ral ])art of the Eni^lish Kiii^lom remained iinsulxlued. William was full Kin*i^ over all lOnf^land. What remained still to ]»e done, as far as the whole island : concemwl, was for the new Kinji^ of the En<^lisli to estiihlish somewhat more than the external over-lordship of his prede<*e8sors over all the lands which had fornuKl j)art of their island Empire. Within En;{fland itself, what was still to be done was for the priest to follow in the track of the warrior, for the wiles of Lanfranc and Ilildeorand to huild up a power a«ifainst which William himself could liold his own, hut before which his weaker descendants had for a while to Ix-nd. ' Flor. Wig. 1069. " Iiiterea nuiitils atl Danicum comitem Esbemuiii niMcia ■{Ki{Hindtt He clanciilo daturum illi non modicse Hummani pecuuiw, et permtMurum licenter exercitui auo victum Hibi circa ripaw inariH ra])ere, eA tMaen inU-rp<>Mit& conditione, ut sine pugn/l discederet peracta hieine. Ille AuU^m, auri arguntique niinis aviduM, nun sine magno dedecore sui petaiis conoeant" Orderic (515 B) givcH uh (»nly a rhetorical account of the mfferingi of the Danes and of their return Uj Denmark ; not a word about the dealingM between William and Osbeom. Here at least Orderic ia Mlowtng William of Poitiers. CHAPTER XIX. THE ECCLESIASTICAL SETTLEMENT OF ENGLAND.^ A. D. 1070— 10S9. ITIX^GLAX^D was now fully conquered; the authority state of i L' ti-11- 1 111- England -i 01 VV illiam was now acknowledg'ca in every corner j,, ,070. of the realm. AVc shall hear almost immediately of fresh resistance ag-ainst William's authority ; but resistance now takes the form of the revolts of a subdued people ; it is no longer the defensive warfare of a people whose independence was attacked but was not yet overthrown. AVilliam had William in done his work of conquest, and his reign over the land of the which he had won was now to becrin. Thing's had greatly ^ '^ to rr> tD J country. changed since his crowning on the great Midwinter-Day. The realm of which he had then taken a formal possession was now truly his, but it had become his only by the sword. Tlie dream of a peaceful reign, under which England might flourish as Normandy had done, had passed away * For the ccclefliastical history of William'^ reijp, which I have endea- voured to deal with a.s a whole in the present Cliapter, several s^ources become of importance besides those to wliich we have trusted all along. The variouH l<»cal histories, beini^ mainly the histories i>f monasteries, are of course of .special value ft»r this j)urpose. Tlio Lives and Letters of Lanfranc are now of increased imi>ortance, and not least among them the short Latin Annals of his life which are attached to the Winchester Chronicle, Eadmer in his two Histories, Historia Novoruni and Vita Anselmi, is now of primary importance, and William of Malinesbury's Gesta Pontificum, which I can now quote in the new edition of Mr. Hamilton, becomes a hook of great value. VOL. IV. Y Iff Tlir. . MA.STlCAh >hrihKMKNT oK KNOLAND. MAT. XII. for c\.i William Imd !»con clrivon \o mnkr his nij^n thttf far ft roipn of terror, a reij^n of nlatij^^litor, oxilo, confinciition, ami ravnffi». A lar^i» part of the IuixIh of En^lanil ha*! l»c<'n laid waiil4»; a larpcr part Mill liaeace; comparative jx^acc indeed, if onlv the peace of utter subjection, set in from this time for the rc«t of AVilliam's rei^n. Revolts indeetl were to load. ^ go on, but they were all purely local revolts. There was never a^n^in a moment when any larj^e portion of the land was in arms at once, when, as durinf^ the last year, warfare was p^inpf on at once at Exeter, at Chester, at Durham, and at Norwich. For a moment the sword was sbeathetl ; no element of disturbance seemed to be left in the land except tlu- J)anish fleet in the Ilumber. Tlie coufjuerors and the conquered alike had a moment's breathin<^-time. I'ervoDal But in dealing with the acts of such a man as William, UaUam*' ^^^^ personal jwsition, the personal intentions, of the man himself are of hardly less moment than the condition linulual and the temper of armies and nations. We can hardly ■ ntr- nr j^^yi^^ ^l^jj^ William had chanofcd for the worse since the day of his crowning. Everything since that time had tended to draw out the worse features of his character and to throw the better ones into the shade. He had lxH?ome harder, more unscrupulous, more reckless of human sufFering. But the harshness of William's rule never sank into mere purposeless tyranny, into mere delight in oppres- sion. He never wholly lost the feeling that he owed a duty He sitll towards God and man. Even now he was capable of honest ral* well, endeavours to do his duty towards the realm which he had won at the cost of so much of crime and sorrow. It was alx)ut this time that he gave one most conspicuous instance of his wish, even now, to rule in England as an English King. It was his business as King to hearken to the WILLIAM TRIES TO LEARN EN'OLISII. 323 complaints of his subjects, to do ri<^ht and justice among chap. xix. tlam according to the laws of the Kings who had gone before him. It was his duty to go, like /Elfred and Cnut, through the shires and cities of his Kingtlom, and to see with his own eyes that those who nded in his name refused, sold, or delayed justice to no man.' 15ut this duty could not be thoroughly done by a King who knew not the tongue of his people, who had to hear their comi)laints and to pronounce his own judgements through the mouth of an interpreter. William then, at ^^ ^ri®*' r n ^ • . . '•' leam the age of forty-three, in all the pomp of kingship and Englwh. the renown of victory, again bowed his neck to the yoke of the schoolmaster. As Charles the Great had striven in his later years to learn the art of writing,- so now William the Great strove, we cannot doubt with all honesty of purpose, to master the tongue of his English subjects.^ In neither case were the efforts of the royal student crowned with any great measure of success. Tlie vague Probable X , • o • n -1 • extent of rhetoric ot our intormant leaves us with no very clear notion his studies. as to the real extent of William's English scholarship. We are told that he found his age an hindrance, and that, as we might have expected, other affairs called him away from his studies.'* We may feel sure that the Conqueror never learned to address an English Assembly like God- wine ; but we maybe allowed to believe that he learned English enough to understand the simple formula? of his ' I need hanlly quote the 29th chai)ter of the Great Cliartor; " Nulli ventleinus, iiuUi ncj,'abiinu.s, aut difrtTemus justiciam vul rectum." ' The deHcriptioti given by Kginhard (Yita K. 25) of Charles's attempts to write is well known ; " Paniin succesHit labor prwposterus ac sero inchoatuH." But I doul)t whetlur it is always remembered that his attempts to write prove that he could reatl. ' Ord. Vit. 520 D. " Anglicam locutionem plenmiquo sategit ediscens ut sine inter[>rete querelam Hul)jocta' Icgis posst-t intcllig»'ro, et scita recti- tiulinis unicuicpie, prout ratio dictaret, atfectuose di-proniere." * lb. " Ast a perceptionu hujusmtMli durior atas ilium comjHJSCobat, et tumultUH multiinodarum occupationum ad alia neceHsario adtrahebat." Y 2 S3I TWK ■0CLIBIA5ITICAL 8RTTI.KMP.NT OF KX(JLANI). OUF m. own chjui«*n(. Aiul tho fnrt tlint he nm«l»» evon an attonipt in hu own |»«'n»«»n to m^iuin' tho Kn^-liHli ton^iio wholly Wipes •way the Ir^'mlnry notion of hJH strivinj^ to abolinh its nm,^ and makcn it nil hut cortiiin that Kn^-iish fornuMl part of tho txliication of hin Knj;liH]i-lM)rn Bon.'*' It ia certain that this year, thf fourth year of William, h'ft iM'hind it a gintMal and a favounihle memory in pojmlar Si^inr k4 Udief. The traditions of a latrr ni4"«' told how KiM^^;- li.hin^' ibr William, in his fourth year, summonoil the Witan of the i^vanJ ^^^*^ ^*^ doi'laro what the anrient laws of England were. He had alremly, we are told, remembering his own Scan- dinavian descent and that of his Norman followers, decreed that the customs of tlic Denalaji^u should be observed thn»ughout his realm. Hut the jieople of Enji^land cried with one voice for the Laws of p^ood King Eadward and for none other. Twelve men therefore were, by the writ of King William, chosen in each shire, who declared on oath before the King what the Laws of King Eadward were. Those Laws were then i)ut int^j the shape of a code, and were pul>lishiHl by the order of King William as the only Law of his Kingdom. No one who fully takes in the history and the legal formula? of this age can accept this story as it stands. Remains of No one can believe that the large extant codes which bear IcgUftiaoo. ^^c names of Eadward and William were really put forth in their actual shape by either of those Kings.-^ On the other hand, there is little doubt that we have some genuine pieces of William's legislation surviving, though it would seem that ordinances put forth at various times and places have been put together a,s if they formed a continuous atatute.** And among these there are some enactments which we may, almost with certainty, refer to this par- » See the false Ingulf. 71, Gale. 2 See Appendix EE. • On the alleged Laws of William and Eadward, see Appendix KK. * The seemingly genuine Law8 of William have been last printed by Professor StnW»«. Select Charters, 80. See Appendix KK. KEXKWAL OF EADWAKiyS LAW. 32,: ticular period of ^Villillm's nii^ii. It iullowed almost as chap. xix. a matter of course tliat, in this passing- moment of peace, J?««^"n5il»*- when William was for the first time undisputed master En^'lwh of Ent'-hind, he should mark his new ix)sition by some xdaxib, and formal act of reconciliation between his old and his new rf"p*|^';*^ subjects. To " renew the Law " of some revered prince Law- after a time of war or disturbance was a process familiar both in En«^land and in Normandy. Harold Blaatand had renewed the Law of Rolf in Normandy,^ and Harold the son of Godwine had renewed the Law of Cnut in Northumberland. 2 But a still closer parallel is supplied by that great Gemot of Cnut's early reig-n in which Danes and Englishmen formally made up their dilferences, and united in the renewal of the Law of Eadgar.^ So it was quite in the order of things that William should, especially at this particular moment, ordain the formal reconciliation of his Norman and his English subjects, and decree the renewal of what was doubtless already beginning to be spoken of as the Law of Eadward. There Language is little doubt that we have the actual text of these ^|g^,j.ggg . two ordinances, ordinances most probably passed in the Easter Gemot of this year, and which not unlikely pre- serve to us, with the needful changes, the words of the borrowed earlier ordinances of Cnut. In the same language as ^j cnut!*** the first among the laws of the Danish conqueror, William now bids his subjects throughout his Kingdom to worship one God and to keep one true Christian faith; and if he does not venture, like his predecessor, to bid them love William King with right truthfulness, he ordains that there shall be peace and mutual security between English- men and Normans.' The Laws of Eadward are renewed ^ See vol. i. p. 144. * See vol. iL p. 499. ' See vol. i. p. 462. * Select Chartcrn, 80. " In priniis quod Huper omnia ununi vellut Deum ii6 TIIK ICOLIBlAflTlCAL 8ITTLKMKVT oK KNT.l.ANI). Normao iottowvn. Intar- Normaii Aod Eoff- Ikh William's ■trici poBoa. M toochin^ Uic hoUlin^ of Inndn aiui all otluT inAttcrs whatMievrr, l»ut a rwion-ation in made for such tluin|^'s M Xhv rvi^iiin^: Kin^f had nuwlo for tlu* j^xxl of tho piHtpIo of the Kii^:lihli.' TluH n»tiorvntion \va8 indeitl n (Lui^roiu om». Hut once ^nintinp: the jK)8ition of William in £ng>land, nome clmngvtj in, or additions to, tho ancirnt law» could hardly W avoido '" perduraverit. Ubi vero substantia defecerit, totus hundredus in quo oociiiio Cacta est communiter persolvat quod remanet." • See voL i. p, 493. HLKNDING oF KNGLISIIMKX AM) N«»1CMANS. 327 William's hands^ dealt out speedy justice on the roblx^T, chap. xix. the murderer, and the ravisher.' In the towns especially «P«cml blending the two races l)egan to dwell peaceably toj^ether ; French Becchet, patritk UotomAgensis . . . habuit uxorem Roesam, nationo Cado- nieiiHcm." Vet Thomas himself (Kp|). iii. 286) speaks of his parents aw "civcs Londouiunses " without a. hint of their foreign <>rii/in. nS THB BOCLESIAHTICAL 8KTTLKUKNT OF KNOLANI). cmAF in. not wholly ban' of militar)- cvcnU, was prol>ttbly not Iwire j^ of iin|)ortant |»«»lilUTil ovcntB. Still it is in it8 cHx;lesi- I iwortant as wifnrwn^ the lH';»:inninj^ of tin* syKt<*matic i>olicy of William and Laufraue in ooclosiastical matters. § 1. TAc CvunciU of the Year 1070. Tins sjH'cially cccleHiastical year, in which William was to 8ht»\v himself to the world mainly in the character of t rrformer of the Church, he^n, ntmngely yet character- istically, with an act which, in a less pious prince than William, might have been set do\NTi as a gross breach E«gii»b- of all ecclesiastical privilege. Many wealthy Englishmen, ifwt thair mainly, we may suppose, those who had suffered outlawry T**^ ^ or confiscation of lands, had 60U<^ht to save at least their •«»••• moveable wealth by placing large sums of money in the safe-keeping of various monastic bodies. But the thrcsh- oldfl of tlie English saints proved no safe-guard against Wiiiuun Hie Norman King. Early in the year, in the course of !»• m^aff- Lent, while he was still at Salisbury or before he reached **'5V'"1 Salisbury, William caused all the monasteries of England caiTIM On _ iho waoomy. to be searched, and all deposits of this kind to be carried Mxrch, to the royal treasury. It always has a grotesque sound 1°'^' when the deeds of William the Great, like those of smaller The dmign at- men, are either excysed or aggravated by throwing the WiUiMD hiame on evil counsellors; but we are told that of this J^ particular deed the Earl of Hereford, William J'itz-Osbern, was the chief adviser.^ It may have been deemed that ' Both Chronicles (1071 Wijf., 1070 Petrib.) record this searcli and Bpoli- •tion, but they give no hint as to its special motive ; " And t)aeB on Lengten ■e cyng let hergian ealle |ja mynstra l>e on Englalande waeron." Florence (i'^" ' - the caufH-, and mentionB William Fitz-Osbom a« the adviser ; ** ^ Herefordenids Comitis et quorumdam aliorum consilio, tempore Q inali, Rex Willelmus monasteria totius Angliae perscrutari, et PLUNDEK OF THE MONASTERIES. 329 the holy phiccs were rather purified than prufaned ))y chap. xix. easing them ot* the worldly wealth of rebels and traitors. The season of penitenee having been spent in this charitable work, William could better give his mind to the great schemes of ecclesiastical reform whose carrying out was to begin on the Eiister festival. At that festival the usual Gemot was held at Win- Ea«t«r Chester, and the King wore his Crown with the usual winchea- pomp. This public wearing of the Crown was in some sort ^'"'^jj a religious ceremony, a continuation, as it were, of the 1070- original rite of consecration, and the Crown itself was placed on the royal head by one of the chief Prelates of the land.^ In this case the rite received a special dignity and significance from the position of those by whom it was performed. Pope Alexander had sent three Legates Presence to the court of his obedient and victorious son. Ermenfrid, panai Bishop of Sitten, a man already well known both in Eng- ^*^g*^*^«- 1 1 1 • -VT 11 11 Ermenfrid land and m Normandy, whom we have already seen as the of Sitten. pecuniam, quam ditiores Aiigli, propter illiua austeritatem et depopula- tionem, in eis deposuerant, auferri et in ararium suumjusait deferri." William Thorn, the historian of Saint Augustine's, asserts that, not only money, but the charters to which William had sworn, and which he had now broken, were carried off(X Scriptt. 1787); " Williulmus . . . vndena se in sublimi positum et in regni solio confirmatum, subito ad alium virum rautatus, de Rege factus est tyrannus . . . Willielmua Cunquaistor dictud in multis promissa violavit, monasteria totius Anglia' perscrutari fecit, et pecuniam sinml et cl>artas, in quarum liburtatibus nobiles Angliaj confidebant et quaa Rex in arcto positus observaturura se juraverat, ab ecclesiis ubi insecurojacuerant auferri prtecepit, et in wrarium auum deferri." It must not be forgotten that this writer had his head full of the legendary confirmation of the franchises of Kent. * As the Winchester Annalist renaarks under the year 1073, " Sciendum e«t quod quolibet anno duin quietus fuerat ter coronari consueverat Rex ; Wigtymiie ad Natalo, Wintonite ad Pascha, Londoniae ad Pentecosten." This of courue comes from the Peterborough Clu-onicle, 1087 ; *' J>riwa he basr his cynohelm lulce geare." But we see that the ceremony was a sort of repeated coronation. So it is called by lienolt (39141), when deticribing the ChristmaH Feaat at York (sec above, p. 295), ** A Kvorwic fu coroni'*, A la saintc Nativit(5." 330 TIU aCCLKSlAHTlCAL hKTTLKMKAT t»K KNCLVVI) iVAT. iflL RipAl rrprravnUtivt* at the ixnirt^t lK)th ni' W illuiin and of >of5. EAtiwrnnl,* now (mme n thirtl time, lu^^oniiianitMl liy two oibor LagmUv, the C4irtlinal PricntH Jolin .ind P(*t4'r,''' at oooe to cciiifn*^tulAto thi* (A)nquoror on the* U*m)>4)ral niuHMnu* of hi* holy cut(^r|)nfH\ and to hrlp him in carrying out his wn hniiitinl schomi'ti for the sultju^ition and rcformntion of the beni^htt'd itihmdore. ' Thc>y came at William's own pimyer,* and one at leant of them tarriecrformed hy Ealdred in the West Minster.'* This ceremony done, a ceremony far from lacking signi- ficance or importance, King and Legates turned themselves to the more serious business which lay before them. This was no other than the beginning of W^illiam's great scheme for gradually remodelling the Church of England, as he had already gone far to remodel the State of England. It was the policy of which we have already seen the first-fruits in the appointment of Ileraigius of • 8co vol. ii. |», 461 ; iii. p. 96. ' Ordcric, 516 A, mentionu Ennenfrid only by name, adding, "et duos cannnicos cordinaleM." Florence adds their names, " presby teros Johanncni et Petnim, cardinales sedw apoHtolica;." ' See vol. iii. p. 284. * Ortl. Vit. 516 A. " Ex petitioue ipsiuB Alexander Papa tres idoneoa ei ut cUriwnmo [cariBtiimo ?] filio legaverat vicarios." * lb. " Apud se ferme annuo fenne Hpatio retinuit, audiens et honorans eog tAraquara angelo« Dei. In diverHib locis, in plurimis negotiiH, sic egere, ■icat iiidigaH canonicse ezaminationis et ordinationis regiones illas dinovere." Fmm Florence we learn that only Ermenfrid could have stayed so long tut A year. John and Peter went back before Pentecost. • lb. "GuUlelmus Rex Dominicam Resurrection is in urbe Guent4 oolebnMt, ubi Cardinales Romanae Ecclesia; coronam ei sollenniter im- poraenint." Vita Lanf. (Giles, i. 392). '* Eum in pasclia, coronam regni capiti ejug iniponentes, in Kegem Anglicum confimuiveruiit." ./ DEI'KIVATION Ob' KNGLISII I'KKLATES. 331 Fecamp to the see of Dorchester.* The ^eat places of cHiu*. xut. the Church of Eufrluiul were to be tilled by Normans or Knglinh " "^ prelacies other strangers whom William could trust. En«^lishmen ti» he were to be wholly shut out trom the rank ot Bishop and Htrangern. but sparin«^ly admitted to that of Abbot.- But William was no more inclined to act hastily in this matter than in any other. As ever, he was disposed to walk warily and was careful to have the letter of the law on his side. It would Thechan^je •II- 1111- '"**l^' Ji^a- not have suited his purpose to make a wholesale depri- dually, vation of the English Prelates. But as Bishopricks and Abbeys became vacant, fittin«> occupants of foreign birth were to be found for them,-^ and there was no objection to quicken the succession by depriving, one by one, those English Bishops or Abbots against whom any plausible accusation could be brought. These two processes were to The two be first of all applied to the two highest ecclesiastical posts bishon- in England. The metropolitan chair of York was regularly '"'^'^*'- vacant by the death of Ealdred ; that of Canterbury was to be made vacant by the deprivation of Stigand. We have already seen that the ecclesiastical position of Eccle- the Archbishop had been looked on as doubtful from the p<,.siti.)n <»f time of his nomination to the primacy by the voice of ^^'&'*"^^- liberated England in that Mickle Gemot which drove his foreign predecessor from his ill-gotten throne. * Ermenfrid, ' S«e above, j). 133. ^ Fl. Wig. 1070. '* OiHTam ilanto Rego ut quamplures ex Anglis auo honore privarentur, in quorum locum sua; gentis personas subrogavit, at! confirmationem Hcilicet sui fpuxl nnviter adquisierat regni." We shall fmd however that a diHtinction, and not an unnatural one, wa^ made between the case of Bishops and that of Abbots. An Abbot was not clothed with the Hamo high temporal powers aa a Bishop. From this time we shall see that no Englishman was appointed to a Bishoprick, and that the English Bishops, with the exception of Wulfstan, were grmlually de- privetl. In the case of AblKita the deprivations of Englishmen were many and appointments were few, but the rule was not absolutely inflexible. ' See above, p. 131. * See vol. ii. pp. 331, 335, 341 ; and on the ecclesustical position of Stigand, p. 605. 993 THE BCCLBBIA8TICAL ^KTThKMKNT UF KNOLAND. csAT. ftu. tho pr%«*nt I>e|^t4}, had, on his former v\»\t to Kn^lund, ' been the b«Arer of a Pkpol miitsivo ngninst him.' \vt WlDkM'a William had hitherto troaUHl him with ntuditHl honour;' he had ooDWcratcd the only Hit who hud Ikh^u np- fxiintiM since his acocwion,' uiul, if he had not l>een aIIouhxI to |»our the consecrating^ oil on Wdliam'H own head, he had fille*! the second place in the ceremony of his coronation.* Hut his hour was now come; he could now be de|)<>seti, not l»y the mere arhitrary will of tlu» King or by the sentence of a purely Kngliwh or Norman Assembly, but by the full authority of the Head of Western Christendom. As usual, all kinds of vague and improbable chai]ge8 were hrou^lit a^Minsl him;* but the QAKflCA. WtM»J- canonical grounds on which he was formally condemned 1070. ' were three. He had held the see of Winchester along with the Archhishoprick. ® He had taken the Arch- bishoprick during the life-time of Robert, and lie had UR-d at the mass the pallium wliich Robert had left Ix'hind.^ He had obtained his own pallium from the Hb usuqiing Pontiff Benedict the Tenth. ^ Stigand was heard in his own defence ; but liis defence seems to have con- sisted of arguments which would have more weight in the minds of Englishmen than in those of William and Ermen- frid. He aj)pealed to the faith of the King who had so long treated him as a friend ; he protested against the iniquity of his sentence, and apparently against the autho- • See vol. ii. p. 466. * See above, p. 78. ' See above, p. 133. * See vol. iii. p. 558. • Ord. Vit. 516 B. *' Stiganduin pridem reprobatuia anathemate depo- •Derunt. Perjiiriui enim et bomicidiis inquinatus erat, nee per OBtium in archipnnulatuni introierat." • See the cbarge« in full in vol. ii. p. 605. ' That Kol>ert left hiH pallium behind is a point inaiflted on with glee by the Peterborough Chronicler. See voL ii. j). 331. The consequences were not then foreseen. • See voL ii, p. 432. DEPOSITION OF STIGANI). 333 rity of his jiulg^es.^ Siuh a defence was of course in vain ; chap. xrx. he was deprived of both his Bishonricks, and, if not abso- Hw de- * * pnvation hitely imprisoned, he was at least kept under some measure ansis8imis divitiis quam Kcx in- venerat ecclesia) Wyntoniensi pro anima Sti^^andi solummodo tmnsnii.tit." JS4 THE BCn.RS!Ainewhnt mort» Iwith in foocl and in clothing. He anHwerrtl with the most Kolemn oathH that ho h«d not A penny or n j>onny*H worth to 8Uj»])ly hin wants. Whether either the Ohl Lady or any otlirr friend did any- thing to help him in his ii(M'<1 we are not told, l^ut tlic tale jjo«>8 on to nay that, after Stif^and's death, a mass of tri»aMure was found hidden underpround, and that round the depoRxl Primate's neok was a key, which was found to open m private writinp-case, in which were papers wherein the tale and weight of the whole hoard were accurately entereere nummum nee valenH, Huic sacramento solidi- tatem veri abfuiHHc proljavit in gens vis opum post mortem ejuH in sub- terranciM KpccubuH inventarum. Ad quarum indicium ut veniretur auxilio fuit clavicula collo examinati dependenH, qua? faniiliaris Bcrinii esset custos. Ea Rene immiHMa manife«tavit per cartas inventas et qualitatem metallonim et quantitatem ponderum." This became the stock passage for later writers to copy. Gervase however (Gest. Pont. Cant. X Scriptt. 1652) tellfl it in a form which seems to be original; " Siquidem eodem mortuo, clavig parvula in secretis reperta eat, quae serii cubicularis scrinii, appodta innumerabilimi thesaurorura dedit indicium. Cartaj quidem in- ▼enUe Hunt in quibus notata erat et metallorum qualitaH et ponderum qoantitaii quai per omnia pra;dia sua compilata defoderat." ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont, 150. " Stigandus evaluit, ut sibi Austnilium Saxonom cpiiicopatum restitueret, et Orientalium Anglonim fratri Ethel- mero adquireret." ^ See vol. ii. pp. 64, 65. OTHER DEPRIVATIONS. 335 the Survey, by which it appears that the East-Ani^lian chap. xix. Prehite hatl a wife.* We are told also that several Dopriva- Abbots were deposed;- but it is hard io identify iii<^re ^^'[Jj^^'^^ than one who was de|)osed at this particular Gemot. It is probable that our informant had in his mind the general system of deprivation of both Abbots and Bishops which went on from this time, rather than any special acts of this Easter Assembly. It is certain however that one great Abbey was at this moment vacant by death and another by forfeiture, and it would apjx'ar that the Norman successors of the English Prelates were appointed in this Council. Brand of Peterborough, Death of the Abbot who had been confirmed by the /Etheling i>et"r. * Eadgar,^ died while William was engajjed on his North- 5;><>rough. humbrian campaign.' The vacant ])ost was given to one 17, 1069. Turold, of whose exploits, militarv rather than ecclesias- [^"S^^^^'^fj * "... ">' Turold. tical, we shall presently hear.'' William's vengeance fell also on an inmate of the Golden Borough, who might have seemed likely to be perfectly harmless. This was yEthelric, Seizure of who had once been Bishop of Durham, but who had Jj^t^ BiX')p long ago given up his see and had retired to spend the ^^ Durliam. remnant of his days in the monastery.^ About this time, 1056.] * Domesday, ii. 195. " Hoc manerium accepit Almanis cum uxore sua antequam es-set Episcopus, et postea tenuit in episcopatu." /Etlielmfer, like most other people, French and English, i.s charged in Domesday with something in the way of invasiones. In the same page where his wife is mentioned we read, " Hemeshi tenuit Algarug Comes T. R. E. et Alwius emit. Stigamlus ahstulit et dedit Aliuaro fratri suo, sed hundred nescit quomodo ex illo fuit in episcopatu." Another entry in p. 200 in more curious. After the account of the outlawry and flii,dit <>f Ea in the Domesday sense. ' See a})ove, p. 333, note 2. * See v<»l. iii. p. 530. * Chron. Petrib. 1069. " And on pi.sum ilcan geare forAferde Brand Abl><>t of Burh on v. Kal. DeceMd»r." This is one of the earliest instince** of the m«j' away. Soon after their flight, wlien the Normans reachinl the city, it was thro^vn down by some of the invaders, and robbed of the ornaments with wliich it had been enriched l)y Tostig and Judith. William, on reaching Durham, whether moved by ])iety or by covetousness, cxpres.s<'d no small indignation, lie found out the onender.s, and sent them to the Bishop and Chapter, seemingly in their retreat at Lindisfarn, calling on them to sit in judgement on the sinners, and to visit them with ecclesiastical censures. No censure however followed ; yEthclwine may have doubted whether it would in the end be safe to excom- TW municate the soldiers of the Conqueror. In the course of (Jlmndi of Ihirhjun I-^nt the Bishop and his Canons returned to Durham, and, p--.ndl«l. jj^ ^Ijj. ypj.y \\vc\Q when the Council was sitting at Winchester, lojo. the church of Durham was solemnly reconciled after its desecration, and the body of Saint Cuthberht was set back again in his shrine with all honour.^ It must have been • On the dealings with these two brother Bisliops, see Appendix PP. * The iitory is told in the Durham History, iii. 15. " Inntante autein QuadrageHim&, tranquillitate reddita, Kacrura corpus Dunelmum reportave- runt, atque reconciliata solenniter eccleaia vii, Idus Aprilis, cum laudibus tntntntes eoclesiara suo in loco illud repoHuerunt. Invenerunt autem inuginem Cnicifixiin solum dejectam.et a suo ornatu quo aComite supra- dicto, Tidelioet Tosti, et ejus conjuge fuerat vestita, omnino spoliatara. Hum coim soUun ex omamentiii post se in ecclesia reliquerant, ob hoc OUTLAWRY OP .fITHELWINE. 337 just at this time that the sentence of outlawry was pro- cuai-. iix. nounced against /Ethel wine, and there is no other visible motive for it except his disobedience to the royal order. No charge could better fall in with ^Villiam's j)olicy ; the English Prelate had failed to show that zeal on behalf of his own church and its possessions which he, the Con- queror, had not forgotten, even in the midst of his North- humbrian warfare. If siicrilege was the crime of iEthel- wiue, he soon added to it, at least in the eyes of William. He saw that England was no longer a place for him; he ^-^^thelwine took a large part of the moveable treasures of his church K6in, but and set sail for Koln. Stress of weather however drove l*^ ^"^'^^ bac-k to him back to Scotland, where he passed the winter.* He *"><-•« tland. I 1111 1 '1 1 • April, 1070. was thus enabled to have a share in the ex})loits and videlicet quoU difficile in fuga portari poterat, siinul sperantes quod propter illam majorem loco reverentiam hostes exhibere vellent. Veruui quidam illorum supen'euientes, quidquid in ea auri et argenti vel gemmarum inve- nerant, penitua ab.strahentes abierunt. Quo facto Rex graviter indignatus jus8it eo8 pcrquisitos comprehendi, et comprehensos ad episcupuin et presby- teros, eorum judicio puniendos, perduci. At illi, nihil triate eis facientes, perniiserunt illeesos abire. " The same story is told by Roger of Howden (i. 1 20), some of whose expressions sound as if he had got the tale from some other quarter than Simeon ; " Imago Crucifixi, quae sola de omamentis ecclesise renianserat, quoniani non facile, pro sui niagnitudine, a festinantibus |)oterat asportari, auro suo et argento est spoliata, detrahentibus Normannis. Hex autem ([uum non longe esset, agnoscens ecclesice solitudinem et Crucifixi exspoliationem, graviter satis tulit, ipsosque qui hoc feccrant perquiri prte- cepit, nee multo post eosdcra ipsos sorte sibi obvios habuit, (juos, quuni pub- licam viara declinare conspicerat, illico intellexit homines mali alicujus esse conscios; qui protinus comprehensi aurum et argeutum, quod de Crucifixo tulerant, ostenderunt. Quos statim ad judicium episcopi et eorum qui cum illo erant, juiu dc fuga regredientium, transmisit, sed illi a rcatu absolutes impune dimittunt." ' Sim. Dun. Hist. Dun. iii. 17. " Reportato in Dunelmum, .siout jam dictum est, beatissimi confessoris corpora, Egelwinus xv. sui cpiscopatus anno, partem thesaurorum ecclesise secum asportans, Angliam] relicturus navem ascendit. Sed ([uum jam cupito itinere versus Coloniam navigaret, vento repulsus in Scotiam ibitlem hiemavit." This flight was evidently the consequence of the outlawry recorded in the Chronicles. Simeon records the events which happened in the North ; the Chronicler reconls, though imperfectly, tin; acts uf the Council. VOL. IV. L niB I00LI8IA8T1CAL SETTKKMKNT oV KNULAND. cttAT. in. iofl^nnic* of the next yt^. Aimthor Prolate who took nearly tbe mbm oourm* u*m8 in worldly fortum* more fMiar pnwprnnu. It wua now in all probability that /EtheUi^, the plurmlist Abbot of liamsoy and Saint Au^^iiMinc'H, who had Invn NVilliam'tf own ambassador at the court of Swrnd,' led Kng-land and apiin soujifht the shores of Dminark, this time in the charaeter of an exile.- His Kentish olHce at leuit was dealt with as forfeited, bein^ the other Abbey which was lilbnl aUmt this time, and most probably in this Council. A Norman monk of the name (»f Scotland was Abbot ol a.1^ A... forced on the unwilling brotherhood of Saint Augustine's.-' giirtiHit. jjg jj^j tioinething' however to retrieve the scandal of his 1070-1087. " appointment by greiit works in the way of buildin*^, and by recoverinij^ many of the lost estates of the church, some of them of William's own seizing-.' It must have been a striking* episode among the acts * See abore, p. 135. ' See Ap|>enclix P. ■ W, Thorn. X Scriptt. 1787. " Anno Domini quo supra, coinperto quod Egelsinus lie in Daciam fugemt, suamque eccIeHiam absque licenti^ R«giji |»etilA .lut obtentH dereliquerat, pnedictuH Kei nionHflttTium Sancti Augtistini cum omnibuH intenii^ et extemi.s appendiciii confiscavit, et eideni monaaterio quemdam monachum nomine Scotlandum, natione Normannum, in Abbatem pn^fecit, nionachiH AugUHtinienriibuH, tuin propter IlegiH tyran- nicUD potentiam, tuni propter Mui monaMterii ex onini perquisiN'it, quaudam abwcjue consensu conventCls •licBAvit." He had just before said that in the time of ^thelsige &i)me Normana bad seized (" violenter occupaverunt") lands belonging to the moBMtery, while .^thelaige had granted away othern through fear ("tlinore compuUus, invitis suis fratribus, concessit"). Plumwtede and Fordwicb art H[»ecially spoken of as places recovered from Bishop Odo, who claimed them ax having belonged to Godwine, hia predecessor in the Kentiab £ar]dom. Both places appear in Domesday (12) as possessions of tbe thhtj; and of Fordwicb we read, " Hujus burgi duas partes dedit Rex E. Hancto Augxutino, tertiam vero partem, quae fuerat Godwin! Comitis, EpiacopuK Baiooenais concessit eidem sancto annuente Rege W." But in 6 b among tbe posaeaaiona of Odo we find, ** Abbaw Sancti Augustini tenet de Epiacopo Baiocensi Plumestede." DEMANDS OF SATNT WULFSTAN. 339 of this As9cml>ly, in wliich so many Kn*^lish Prelates chap. xix. were deprived of tljeir dig^nities, wlien one of their number '^^"'.^ holdlv stood forth to assert the rights of his see. While "^'*"'''' ^^« others saw tin* Ivin<»''s purjwse and trembled lest the .i stroke mig-ht fall upon them, the holy Bishop of Worcester churcl/of arose and demanded the restitution of the estates of which ^^ orcwt*'''- Ealdred, on his translation from Worcester to York, had defrauded the church which he had left.^ Tlu* lands were now, during" the vacancy of the see of York, in the King's hands, and Wulfstan called both on the King" and on the other members of the Assembly to do justice to his church. - We may feel certain that, in this and in every other action of his life, Wulfstan acted with perfect sing-le-mindedness. But the man whom Harold had chosen as his fellow- worker when Northumberland was to be won over by ])ersuasion ^ could not have been absolutely wanting" in worldly wisdom. He could not have been the mere model of childish innocence and simplicity which his monastic admirers are inclined to make of him. Wulfstan was no His posi- doubt conscious that, even from William's point of view, reganl to no charere could be brou^jht aj^ainst him. He was also no ^^\^'^*"^ o C3 o and Ji.r- doubt equally ready to run any risk in maintaining* a right menfrid. whose maintenance was really the discharge of a trust.* ' See vol. ii. p. 467. ' Flor. Wig. 1070. "In hoc itaque concilio, dum cttttri trtpitli, utpotc RegiH agnoscentes animura, ne suis honoribus privarentur tinitrent, vener- andus vir WulstiinuH, W'igomenniB epiHcopiia, p<^«8e88iono« (juainplures sui episcopates nh Aldrtdo Arcbiepiscopo, duiu a Wigonicnsi ecclesiii ab Ebor- acensem transferrctur, sua }K>tcntiu rutc-ntaH, ({ua? eu tunc defuncto in regiam potcHtatem devenerant, constanter proclamabat, expetebat, justitianique inde fieri, tan» ab ip.-i.s qui concilio praerant quain a Rege Hagitabat." ' See vol. iii. p. f.2. * Wu are often unpleatiantly struck, in reading the hist^^ry of «Kx:le8iAfl- tical bodies, with the eagernchM, alniOHt greedines-s. shown by them in the asitcrtion and retention of every kind of temporal right. But it must in faimeHH be remembered that the right of the meniberx who fonn the cor- poration at any giv<;n time is not al>solute ; they are truateoH for their HuccesMorM and tlw foqxtration it«elf. We nmy be Htire that thi.s was th*- / 2 310 TOB B0CLKSIA8T1CAL 8BTTLKMENT oK KNOLAM). «-«Ar XII But ho prt^bahly know n\m thnt n olnim of ri^-lit on behalf of mn ccolociiuitioiil foundutioQ WM exactly tho kind of caum* in whioh lH)th c<>ni»cienco and policy wonld lead \N liani to do juutiiv. Nor would he forget that the ohirf of tho Pa)iAl Legato* wn« an old friond of his own. 1061. F.i;:ht years l»ock Ermenfrid had l)Oi»n his ^uost at Wor- oistor, and had niisR^l his voice on hin behalf in the ^" ' (toniot at Cilouot»ster.' Tho olaini was made and listened to; but the answer of William and Krnionfrid was dis- creet. Tliey oould not jud«^o without hearing both sides; they had heard the claim of Worcester; they had not heanl the defence of York ; the church of York was dumb, having no shephcnl to speak for her ; when tho Northern Arohhishoprick should again be full, both sides should be heard and the case decided. ^ lu.] The appointments to the two metropolitan sees were not formally made at the Easter Council. W^e cannot doubt that W^illiam had long ago settled in his own mind who should be the successor of Stignnd.'* Still it was seemly to wait, to take time for deliberation, and not to let it go forth to the world that Stigand had been con- demned, and his successor fixed upon, before he had been called on for his defence. The appointments to the vacant sees were therefore delayed till the next great Festival and ?o7o'^'^*' ^^*^ ^^^^ regular Gemot. This was the Feast of Pente- cost ; but the meeting usual at that season was held, not, WUtaiiii G«m6tat Wiod»or. feeling of "WulfHUn in hia pertinacious assertion of his right to temporal pOMwiom. Personal greediness could have no place in such a luind mUs. • See ▼oL ii. pp. 464, 465. • Flor. Wig. 1070. *' Quia Eboracenflia ecclesia, non habens pastorera qui pro e4 lo«^pieretur, muta erat, judicatum est ut ipsa querela sic remaneret quoujKjue, archjepijcopo ibi constituto qui ecclesiam dcfenderet, dum esset qui ejuN quf.r.,l«e responderet, ex objectis et responsis posset evidentius ac justiuj judicium fieri. Sicque tunc ea querela ad tempus reraansit." • See above, p. 84. GEm6t of WINDSOH. 311 according to nilc, at Westminster, hut at the royal seatoBAP. ux. of Windsor.^ This is a place of which we W<^in first to hear in the days of Eadward,- and which hecame of increased importance under William. Either now or later in his Windsor reij^-n, a castK', tlie germ of the present royal dwelling, arose tliere, and its defence seems to have heen a s[)ecial burthen laid upon the landowners of Berkshire.^ There, instead of close under the w^alls of London, the Assembly was held in which the thrones of Augustine and Paullinus were again filled by men of foreign blood and Roman speech. On the Pentecostal day itself, King William, William 111 11* -1 ^ 1 Ti 1 • -1 T" fsTanU the doubtless by his writ and seal like his predecessor King sec^ of Eadward, granted two of the vacant sees to Norman \viJ^t.i,e^'t,er priests.^ York, regularly void by the death of Ealdred, to Thcmas and NN al- was granted to Thomas, Treasurer of the church ofkulin. Bayeux and chaplain to the King. Winchester, void by ^ '^^ ^^' the deprivation of Stigand, was granted to Walkelin, another royal chaplain, who is also said, like so many ' Ord. Vit. 516 A, B. " Maxima vera ac utilliraa spiodua Windres^oris celebrata eat anno mlxx. ab incarnatione Domini." He however confounds the actfl of this Council with those of the Easter Council at Winchester. Florence carefully distinguishes them. ' Eadward's grant of Windsor to the church of Westminster is nien- tionetl in his writ. Cod. Dipl. iv. 227, and in the spurious charter, iv. 178 ; he also dates a charttr there in iv. 209. ' In Domestlay, 56 b, Windsor apj)ears as held by the Crown both T. R. E. and T. R. W. without any mention of the rights of the church of Westminstt-T. The place is also mentioned in 62, 62 b. The liuckinj^'ham- shire Thegn, Leofwine of Newham, had also (151 b) to find "ii. ioricatos in custodiam de Windessores ;" and in the Abingdon History, ii. 3, we reati how the same duty was laid upon that monastery; "Tunc Walingaforde et Oxenforde et Wildesore, cjtterisque locis castella pro regno sen'ando compacta. Unde huic abbatia* uiilitiim excubias apud ipsuin Wildesore oppidum habcndas regio imperio jussum." * Orderic, 516 l^, says only " constituti sunt nominandi pnisules N<>r- inanni duo regii cap«'llani. Ouasclifiinus [(Juakhelinus f] (luenUinonim et Thomaa Eboracorum, unus in loco depowiti, alter iscopatum, et Walcelino suo capcUano Wintonicnsis ooclcsiu) «H>pl(\ t<>int- ■MOli, did him honour, niul that of Thonian muy even have been pnnnptcd hy a wi»h to make some slight nmondH to a part of the Kin^om which had l>cen bo deeply («Ar*rt«f- wroogtxi. Thomas, n native of Hnveux, an well lui a ryrT-"? flanop of it« church, had Bou^'ht for learning beyond the •^f^ , boands of (Jaul and even l>evond the Inmnds of Christen- biibopal YoHi. dom. Like his Metropolitan Maurilius,'^ he harl studied * in the schools of Saxony and other Teutonic lands, and there he may possibly have learned enough of the kindred tongues to make him not wholly incapable of communi- cating with his EnjL^lish Ibx'k.' Hut his love of know- ledge had carried him into the South as well as the North ; he had crossed the Pyrenees, and had come l)ack to Bayeux full of all the learning* of the Spanish Saracens.^ His diocesan Odo, who made up somewhat for his own misdeeds by generous promotion of merit in others,'' placed Thomas in the Treasurer's stall in the church of his native city.® Tliis was an office for which one who had studied in the land of the goldsmith's craft "^ might be supposed to ' I do nut find the kindred of Walkelin to William anywhere except in Thonuu! RudlKjme, Ang. Sac, i. 255 ; *' WalcelinuH, vir magnae litteratune, doctor in thec s4hmi in the solemn <^"*''^*^'"- transepts of Saint Swithhun's, and even in some sort in the mio-hty nave of Edin<^ton and Wykeham.- AVilliam had thus on the Pentecostal Sunday exercised the ancient rig-ht of an English King to bestow the great benefices of the English Church. On the morrow an Ermenfrid ecclesiastical S}Tiod — such bodies are now beginning to gyT^od. be distinguished from the general Gemots of our fore- ^^*y '■♦• fathers — was held by Ermenfrid, who was now the only Legate in England, his two colleagues having already gone back to Rome. ^ Here we are told that several /Ethelric Abbots were deposeil, and also one Bishop, /Ethelric of jej>oiit!d. Selsey. Wc are not told what his offence was, but our English informant commits himself in this, as in other cases, to the assertion that the sentence was uncanonical.* Of ^Ethelric personally we know nothing, except that at a later time both \Villiam and Lanfranc did not scruple to make use of his knowledge of the ancient laws of ' See the account of his works in T. Stubbs, 1708. I shall hnve to mention them again. ' On the epiHCopate of Walkelin, see below, p. 375. ^ Flor. Wig. 1070. " Cujus [Regis] juw*u mox in cra.stino pra'dictus Seon of Thomo* deUjrtl. Kni;Unil.' For the prMont however the p of the South -Saxoiw vmn kept in wnnl at Marlhoroiij^h.^ Ilin iKM? WB* pmntiHl to one Sti^iind, whom it wiih hArtlly mxxiful for any writer to (liKtin^-uish from the ilo|M>Mxi Primate.^ Tlie name is Norman us well as Knp- hsh, and it ii» just |>ossible tliat the liishop of Selwy, s.M.ii to be of Chichester, is the same jHTson as the . lian of Marpirct of Maine.* The P^ast-Ang'lian Hishoprick, vacant hy the deprivation of .l]thelma?r, was ven to Horfast,the royal tliaphiin whose lack of learning had Ixvn lon^ before cxjiostHl by Ijanfranc in his cell at IJiH*.' One at least of the new liishops, Walkelin of Winchester, was at once consecrated by the Le^te/^ The consecration of the Northumbrian Primate was deiayeil. Tlic chronicler of his own cliurcli tells us that it was l>ecause, owing" to the flight of /Ethelwinc, there was no Bishop of his own province to perform the ceremony. 7 But it is hard to see how an Archbishop of York, whose nominal jurisdiction reached to the Orkneys,** but who ' In the fAmous cause on Pcnenden Heath, of which more in the next nction. • Flor. Wig, 1070. " Quem [Agelricuin] Rox sine culpa niox apud Maarlesbeorge in custodia posuit." • lb. •* Quibus o, ordinatus est Walcelitms." ' T. Stubbs (1706) records the flight of ^ii^thelwine, and adds, " Sic factum Art, ordinatio ipsius per tres fere menses delata est, eo quod Eboracensis fxilaiia illo temp<»re suflfraganeos a quibus ordiiiari poswit non liabebat." The position of the Scottish Bishops a.s suppoHcd suffragans of the see of York comes out more distinctly in the Appendix to the Winchester Chronicle under the year 1080. Archbishop Thomas consecrates William Bishop of Durham with the help of sufifragans of the see of Canterbury; ** Jubente Rege et Lanfranco consentiente . . . eo quod a Scottorum epi- toopb, qui sibi subjecti sunt, habere adjutorium non potuit." ' See Appendix LL. hANFHANC AlM'nINTKI) AKCIIBlSIlOl*. 315 had practically only a siiif^lc siifrnij^an at Durham, could cmai-. xix. ever have Ixjcn canonically consecratept'ars else- where (Will. Malm. iii. 298) as "sanctse Romance Ecclcsiw sulHliaconus" and "lector," and undur Ilildebran^l ho boconios the chief means of com- munication between Home and Nonnandy and England. ' lb, "Episcopos, abbatoH, ejusdemque patriie nobiles convenire fece- runt." So in the Life (i. 293), *' (^uuni iijitur StMlunen-^is epi.scopus invitaret cum ad regimen pontificalr, denuntianH in cnnsilio epiHcoporum et abbatum NonnanniK petiti«»n»m regi.>< simulque v«)luntatom siiam, et reliquorum scnlia aptstolica: h'gatorum." It must have been in this SynL S4« THK ECXrUtaiACTICAL 8ETTLKMKNT OP F.Vni.AVn cMAr. m. BaflM of the A|>oitolic See.' Lanfmnr of cmirM^ sot forth, '-•■***' ill the •trie lunml on »urh occasions, hiH own ^•nornl '^ji'otion§ uln.li w«»n' A pooil (It**! moro to tho i)iirpo8t», his i^fnornnro oi the Kng-linh tonjfiio ami of thr niannorH niid niHtoniB of tho liarhiutnis islmncioiv.^ Still to thin it woiiKl hnvo Won cmty to aniwor that tho scholar of Pa via hsul onoo Ihvh as pront a stninffor in Normandy a« ho would In- in Fivlaiiil and that, if ho wore out of (dace on an Enplish tt. , . al throno, ho muni ho oqually out of place in tho chief stall of a Norman al»l)o\ . Hut all ohjoctions were overmled. Queen Matilda and hor pon Robert urgrd his acceptance of tho post ; their ur^-ingij liowever took tho form of j)rayor6 ; what Lan franc scorns to have boon specially moved by was the interposition of one in whom Hm he still acknowlodgfosi of Chief Pontiff, l*iMh«>j.rick. Patriareli and Pope of the nations beyond the sea.' 1070. The ceremony was performed at Canterbury/ in the Hin • i metropolitan church. That church had been burned tanur nearly three years before.'* It had doubtless been patched **"'"-^- •^ •' * August 2y. up SO as to allow the monks to keep up their reg-ular services, but it could hardly have been in a Httinf^ state for so great a rite as the consecration of a Metroj)olitan, and that a Metropolitan who was, in some sort, the beginner of a new line. But in point of attendance of the higher ecclesiastics of the realm there was no lack. The Archbishop-elect was received with all honour by Reception both the convents of the city, by the monks of his own fnino at church, and by those of the rival house of Saint Aug-ustine.^ Canter- ' -^ ^ bury. ' Ep. Lanfr. (Giles, i. 30). He prays Alexanrds of Florence, " et in festi- vitate Sancti Johannis Baptistif die I)omiiiica, archiepiscopum consecrari fecit CantwariiE.'' The Feast of Saint .John inti'uded is that of the Decolla- tion, not of the Nativity. See also Vit. Lanfr. (Giles, i. 3CX>) ; and Will. Malm. (lost. Pont. 39. * See above, p. 125. * Chron. Wint. App. 1070. "C^uuni autem Cantuariiim venitfSMt, obviajn S48 THE ■OOLmiflTICAL 8ETTLKMKNT nF rvnr AND i-mur III. For the Actual rite of coniccration oijfht * Hiphops of his Uk rmMw provinco wrro aMcmbUxl. Four wore nlnu'ut, ninonj^ whom tho ttl»iviuv of the saintixl Hihhop of Wonvstor is the mixit irmarknlilo. Hut all who did not (i])|H'ur in pcnton hi^iifuxl their atiaent by mesfjcnprrs and lftteen restored to it by the pood will of Godwinc or Harold.^ His countryman, Walkelin of AVinchoster, bad just boon consecrated by the Papal Legate Ermenfrid, and 80, it is to be supjwsed, bad IIerfa.«t, the new Bishop of the East- Angles, and Stigand, the new Bishop of the South-Saxons. Gisa of Wells and Ilcrniaiin of Sher- lK>me were, like William, members of the Old-English hierarchy, though of foreign birth. But Gisa had been consecrated at Rome by Pope Nicolas ; Hermann alone had received his consecration from a Primate at once of English birth and of undoubted canonical position.'' Nor ei proceadt honorabiliter conventus ecclesiie Christi, conjuncto sibi toto oonventtt Sancti Augustini, cum electo ejuHdem ecclesise Abbatc Scotlando." * Chron. Wint. 1070. *' He waea gehaded .... fram eahte biscopuni hiu under^ioddum." So the lists in Vit. Lanfr. (Giles, i. 300) ; Will. Malm. (»e«t. Pont. 39 ; Gervase, Act. Pont. X Scriptt. 1653, reckon eight bishopH. Florence doeu not give a full list, but says, "Consecratus est ab epiecopis Gijione WyllenHi, et a Waltero Herefordensi, Herimannus etiam epi«copa« . . . cum quibusdam aliis ejus interfuit consecrationi." Walter's name w not found elsewhere. • ■ Chron. Wint. 1070. *' J^a o^re ^ser naron |>urh aerendrakean and burh gvwrite atiwdon hwi hi ffser beon ne mihton." Tliis is translated in the Life of Laafrmnc (Giles, i. 300) and William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 39), ** Ceteri qui abtentet fuerunt caussas suse absentise, tarn legatis quam litteriM, oHt^ndenint." ' See vol. ii. pp. 161, 345. * Hermann, appointed in 1045 (see vol. ii. p. 79), must have been conse- crated by Eadsige, or by some other English Bishop acting in his name. POSITION' OF WILLIAM AND LAXFRAXC. 319 was the line of the deprived Sti^and left unrepresented chap. xix. in the admission of the man whu supplanted him. Two of the ministerin*^ Prelates had received the episc()i)al order at his hands, Siward of Rochester in the days of King" Eadward ^ and llemi<^ius of Dorchester since King^ WiUiam came into England.- By the hands of these eight Lanfranc, the scholar of Pavia, the teacher of Avranehes, the monk of Bee, the Abbot of Caen, was received into the episcopal order and placed in the patriarchal see of Britain. § 2. The Primacy of Lanfranc. A.D. 1070 — 1089. Another stage of the Conquest was thus accomplished. Position of p-r«iT-iii 11 William Ihe Crowni 01 England had been won by the greatest of and Lau- living warriors and statesmen, and now tlie highest place ^"^' in the English Church was filled by the most renowned of living- scholars, the ablest — though not the most renowned — of living- ecclesiastical rulers. But at that moment the fame of Abbot Lanfranc was most likely equal to that of Archdeacon Hildebrand, and we may doubt whether the Primate who lived and died honoured by all men and successful in all his undertakings did not show a higher power of adapting means to ends than the Pope who loved righteousness and hated iniquity and for his reward died in exile."^ At that moment it might well seem that the two foremost men of the mainland of Western Christendom had crossed over together to rule as Pope and Caesar iu * See vol. ii. p. 433. ' See above, p. i^i. • Paul. Bemfried. ap. Murat. iii. 348. " Ubi in oxtremu |>08itufl erat, ultima verba ejus ha,'C fuerunt, ' Dilexi juatitiam et odivi iniquitatenj ; propterea morior in exwilio.' Quod contra nuidam venerabilia Episcopua reH|xjndiii4e n.trratur, ' Non {)otei, Domine, mori in exsilio, qui in vice Cbristi et Apostolorum ejuH divinitus accepiHti gentes hroreditatoni et poHtiettiiunem tenninoM terra'.'" SaO TliR I0CLISU8T1CAL 8ETTLF.MKNT oF KNOLAND. auf. sn. Um ialaml which men lcx>kiHl on aa nnothor world. And truly William and Lanfrnnc ruloil to^ethor iu their iHland Empire •• no Poim* ami Cift^Ar ovor niliHl to^'ther in the IinjHrial diy itiH'lf.* It in eertainlv to the honour of Willinm, it in |>erluip8 not altogether to tin* honour of Lanfrauo, that no wriouH diireren(< mt to have ariiten U'twtvn the two ilhistrioUH ...ii..imM^. Ldinfranc diK** not 8tand charj^od with direct comi»li('ity in any of Wilhom's particular acts of o|>j)rc'8Hion, but we never hear of hw protesting a^Diu8t them, and he may fairly be looked on AB sharing the responsibility ofWilliam'H general system of policy. Each had to keep down the conquered nation by his own special arms, and the hardness of the priest was ready to go hand in hand with the hardness of the warrior. llie great object of \Villiam was to bring the whole land into direct submission to his own power, a process in which he thoroughly succeeded, and which first made England that consolidated and indivisible Kingdom which it has Eocleai- ever since remained. The ecclesiastical shape of this pro- ddaoftbe ^*^ ^'^^ ^^ secure the more com])]cte submission of the P"*"*- Northern metropolis to the Soutlicrn. The position of the Fodtianof Archbishops of York was an anomalous one. There is no liuhopt of doubt that, in the original scheme of Gregory the Great, \ , the two Metropolitans of Britain were meant to hold an e<|ual rank and to have ecclesiastical jurisdiction over a tcTritor}' of nearly equal extent.'"^ The Province of York is smaller than the Province of Canterbury simply because political causes kej)t the Northumbrian Primate from exercising any effective authority north of the Tweed ' Brerifl Relatio (Giles, lo). " De liege vero Willelmo et Lanfranco Archiepbcopo dicebant uiulti qui tunc erant, quod tales duo hIuiuI in un& terri non invenirentur, quoles egaent Rex WillelinuH et LanfrancuH huu A rcb iff piacopuB." • Set; Appendix LL. EOfflUKl ander Wimun. RELATIONS OF CANTEKBUUY AND YORK. 3:il and the Solway. Scotland u-as im^ant to form part of chap. xix. the shcei>fohl whose centre was at York, iust as Wales ^"tland was meant to form i)art of the sheei)foUl whose centre t*) be unaor was at Canterbury. Wales was in the end ecclesiastically sulxlued ; Scotland never was subdued to any practical purpose, and the result was that the Archbishops of York were left with a vast region under their diocesan care, and with the sin<»:le sutrrag-an see of Durham under their metropolitan jurisdiction. But the diocese and Pi.Utit-al «• A' 1 ' 111 1 ii lx"n of provmce oi lork was, as events had shown, exactly the the Yurk part of En^Mand where the authority of William and l"^'^''"*-'*- the unity of the monarchy were most likely to be threatened. It was always possible that some insurrec- tion of the inhabitants, or some invasion from Denmark, mig-ht set up an opposition King in the Northumbrian capitid. It was a point of some moment to cut off such a pretender from the means of obtainino* any ecclesiastical sanction for his claims. An Archbishop of York who Danger of retained any claim to be independent of the see of^^"J"^./,^ Canterbury miffht consecrate a King* of the Northum- -"^'^^r^- r- . . politan in brians, and the King of the Northumbrians might grow Northum into a King of all England.' An Archbishop of Y'ork who had professed canonical obedience to the Church of Canterbury could not venture on such an act without drawing on himself the charge of ecclesiastical as well Tl»..ina.>< as civil rebellion. It was needful then for the joint pn)fts.sioi» schemes of William and Lanfranc that the first ccdesi- **^"''*^'^' astical act of the new epoch should be the full submis- Ljinfmnc. sion of the new Primate of York to the new Primate of ' T. Stubbs, X Scriptt. 1 706. " Porro utile eHHc ad regni integritateni ct firmitatcm ut Brittania uni quasi Primati aulxleretur, alio4]uiii cuntingert) posse ut de extcrin .'cntibus, qua- Ebonwuin navigiu venicntt* re^'iiuin iufc.stare mjlebant, ujuia ab EboracciiHi Arfhiepiier- auaait novo et credulo Kc^i." SAS THE I0CLE81A8TICAL ftBTTLRMENT OF KNCLANI). auf. 111. 11 -»•».• fK«i Lui« fnuir. LanfrftDC d«iuu»Jf bit |tro> fraM«.iO. TboniM aaddeparta a; crated Canterhiir)'. ThomM of Bayeux wia to m^eivc his conge- crmtion mt the handu of liiuifninr nnd to make profeiision of cmnonical olK^ditMioi* to him. It was uo doubt with thin ohject thni, wlicn the other newly npjwinttnl HiHho])H were constvrnteil l»y the Le^te Eniieiifrid, the elect of York n-niaiiied witliout eonse- • ration.* Tliomau now came to C'unterhury »nd sought cun«ecmtion at the liands of Lanfranc. All thing^a were ready f<»r the ceremony ; the Artlihishoj) and the assistant Bi8ho}>8 were in their places before the altar of Christ Church ; but, l>efore the actual ]x?rformance of the sacra- mental rite, Lanfranc demanded a profession of canonical obedience. In the eyes of writers in the interest of Caii- ti*rbury the Southern Primate was only assertinp;" the undoubted ri^ht of his church ; our solitary Northern infoniiant looks on him as the subtle deviser of new and unheard of pretensions.'^ Thomas refused the demand. The writers on the rival side are charitable enough to say that the refusal was not prompted by pride or perverseness. Tlie elect of York was a stranger in England and knew not the customs of the realm. He had also listened too much to the words of flatterers — j)ossibly of Northumbrian patriots.-* Lanfranc was inexorable ; he bade the assembled Bishops and monks take off their vestments ; the assembly broke up, and Thomas went away unconsecrated.'* Little * See above, p. 344. * T. Stubbs, X Scriptt. 1706. " Iste est Lanfrancua qui primus omnium •b BboraoenHi Archie])i»copu professiunem exegit, Huisque HucceHsoribuu hoc idem eiigendum exemplum dedit." ■ Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 39. '* Hoc autem ignorantia magis quam ■ptritAa elati jK^rtinantia faciebat. Novum enim homo et Anglica- consue- tudinu penitui) expere, verbis adulatorum plus aequo et bono fidem exhibebat." * I follow the zealous Canterbury writer, who tells the tale in our own tongue (CThron. Wint. 1070) ; "On l>am geare Thomas, se waes gecoran biaoop to Eferwic, com to Cantwareln-'rig l>aet man hine 6aer gehadede efker Htn ealdao gewunan. Da l>a Lanfranc crafede fo^'stnunge his gehcrsumnesse mid a^flwerunge, ^a forsoc be and SKde l>8et he hit nahte so donne. Da CONSECRATION HEKUSED TO THOMAS. 353 however as Thomiis mit*"ht have learned of Ent^Hsh Law, chap. xix. he had learned enough to know who was the Supreme Governor ul' the Chureh of England. His first appeal He appeal* was to the King.^ William, it is said, was at first in- KiniT dignant at the refusal of Liinfrani". He deemed that the WiilUm* claim of Canterbury was one not founded on ])lain truth f , tf^*^, and reason, but was somethiuc" devised by the subtle *^ Lan- learning of Lanfraiic.- But within a few days the Arch- demand, bishop of Canterbury came to the King's Court and set L*nfr»nc forth his own case. His hearers from beyond sea were right. convinced by his arguments ; those of English birth bore witness that all that he claimed was in accordance with the ancient laws of the land." The whole controversy illustrates William's position; it marks his strong spirit of technical legality, his freedom from any design of formal innovation on the laws and customs of England. WiUiam heard the disputants and gave judgement. The William abstract question he deemed too weighty to be decided auti^a all at once. Still it was absolutely necessary to come at co™pro- mwe. gewTaSede hine se arcebisceop Lanfranc, and bebead J>am biscopan Ce t>ar cumene wsran be San arcebisceop L. hsese ^a serfise to doiide, and eallan ^an niunecan ^a:t hi scoldau hi uuitcn'dan, and hi be his hK»e swa didan. .Swa Thoniaa to J>am tiraan ageau ferde buton bletijunga." ' Chron. Wint. App. 1070. "Thomas non sacratus abscessit, Regem adiit, et de Lanfrancu riuerimoniain fecit." ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 40. *' Rex audiena graviter accepit, exia- timans Lanfrancmn injusta petere et scientia magis litterarum quam ratione et veritate contidere." The York writer (X Scriptt. 1706) goea a Htep further ; ** Tliomas . . . exactionem Regi rettulit, qui primo moleste accipieus niandavit archiepiscopo ut absque profenijione eum cousecraret." This is a (terfectly natural Northumbrian view, but it seems quite incon- sirttent with the general relation-s between Willianj and Lanfranc, and it is strange to find it in one whtj, like William of Malmesbury, wrote within the Province of Canterbury. ' Will. Malm. u. s. ** Paucorura dierum spatio evoluto, Lanfrancus ad curiam veiiit, a Rege audientiam poutulavit, rcdditis rati«>nibus ejua animum mitigavit, tranxmarini.s ()ui aderant sua; parti juMtitiam >dewe Huaait et persuasit. Anj^li enini qui rem noveraut aasertioDibus ejus {>er onmia constantiHsime testimonium |>erhibebant." VOI-. IV. A a t54 THE E0CLB8IAOTICAL HKTTI.KMKNT «.K KVQLAND. TVmum cMMJt. US. ooc« to A icttlomrnt of some kind, and not to leafe the riiurt'h of York, at uueh a time, any lonjftT with- out a j>aj»tor. Tlu* prnrtical mind of William diH?riHHl a UMiiporary oompn^misi'. Tlu)ma« should mako a written profi*8«iion to Lsinfrano |H'rsomdly, ph'tl^-iiifj himself to full canonical o)>cdicncc. But he should not bo hound to do the like to any successor of I^mfranc, unless in the moan- while the matter had been thoroughly sifted, and the res|>eotive rijjhts of the two metropolitan churches for- mally defmtHl by a compj-tent tribunal.' Thus far Thomas was content to yield. With some unwilliiig'ness, he re- turned to Canterbury, made the rc(iuircd profession, and went away a consecrated Bishop. - Liuifrmnc Soon afler, seeming-ly before the year was out, Ijiinfranc lb* pro- reeeiveil professions of canonical obedience from those tkmor • Viu I*infr. ^(filen, i. 301); Will. Maliu. Gest. Pont. 40. " Itiujue regio edicto, comnmnique omnium decreto, Htatutuni chI ad pnixenH dcberi nKNDain ad matrem totius regni ecclesiam redire, profeiwionem scribere, vrriptAm legere, IcctAni inter exaniinundinn in pncHentiA epiHcoponim I^oiifranoo porrijifcre ; in qua pni'ceptis quidem ejus in omnibus quae ad ChrijitiAne religionia cultum pertinent se obtemperatunun absolute, null2L int4?rpo(>i et Lanfranco faceret professionem." T. Stubbs, on the other hand (X Scriptt. 1706), makes William threaten Thomas with banishment both from England and Normandy if he does not make at least a personal profeNtion, (" si non saltem personalem Lanfranco faceret professionem "). He yielded to the unreasonable wrath (" irrationabilis ira") of the King, but he took special care not to make a written profession (" cartam pro- feasionia neque ipse acripsit, neque scribi fecit, nee a Cantuariis scriptam legit vel I>anfrancand, had received consecration from various other f*;*"""" Archbishops or from the Pope.* Our informant, in men- Muffragnni*, tioning" these two classes, forgets to add a thinl, namely those, including" the Xorman Bishop of Dorchester, who had heon consecrated by Stigand himself.- It wa.s now that Remigius made that remarkable profession which I referred to at an earlier stage,' and Wulfstan that no less remarkable one which I referred to at an earlier stage still. ^ The next year both the newly consecrated Archbishops Lanfranc 1 T) - ■ went to Rome for their pallia. Lanfranc was received by ^^^ g^ ^^ Alexander with special honour. Contrary to all custom, ^f'"."® ^Vi*^ ' -^ ' their j)alljft, the Pope rose to meet him, and bestowed on him, not 107 1. one pallium only, but two, the second, it would seem, ^^•'*'"*^®<* being a special badge of personal favour.'' Yet some shown to incidents in the story might make us think that we by Pope were reading over again the stories of earlier days. ^'®^''^n"^''- Alexander dealt with Tliomas of York pretty much as Alexander Nicolas the Second had dealt with Ealdred when Earl depose Tostier went on pilg-rimafje.^ He dealt with Remi^-ius ^"'j''"'^ & V rs r^ >-• anil ue- pretty much as Leo the Ninth had dealt with an earlier "i'g»"^ of Dorchester. Norman Bishop of Dorchester, the unbishoply Ulf.^ The ' Chron, Wint. App. 1070. " Nee multo post Lanfrancus ah omnibus Anglici re^i episcopis professionem qiuesivit et accepit." William of Mahnesbury (Uest. Pont. 40) adds, "Qui diversis temporibus, diversis in lucin, ab aliiH archiepiscopis vel a Pap& tempore Stigandi .nacrati sunt." ' See above, p. 132. ' lb. * See vol. ii. p. (.O"] . * Chron. Wint. App. 1071. " Secundo anno ordinationia sute Romam ivit, quern Papa Alexander in taiitum honoravit ut ei contra raorem aKsurgeret, et duo pallia ob Hii^num pnecipui ainori.s tribuit, quorum unum Romano more ab altaru accepit, altenim vero ipse Papa, imde missan celebraro conHueverat, 8U& manu porrexit." So Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 40. The Life (diles, i. 30i) putH a Hj>ecial rea-^on into the P(»pe'rt mouth; " N, or hw gTMit adviser, wan miiuliHl to donrivo Utth Tlioiiias «ml KomigiUM of tlu-ir HishoprickH. Tliomiu* «Uk)i1 chnrgctl with no oirenco of Himony or plumlit y ; but h« wat the aon of n prioxt. This wtm nothin^^ won- derful or ilis^prncefu! either in Kn^lish or in Nointment of Heniii^ius lay open to cavil a^aiiu^ on stron^T grounds. The f^iWs which the loyalty of the ffmiffoa. ainioner of Fecamp had made to the Duke, when he was about to set forth on his j^jreat enterprise, were aOirmed to have amounted to a simoniacal bar^in of which the see of Dorchester was the price J The policy of these charges is plain. It was expedient to show that the acts even of so loyal a son of the Church as William were liable to l>e called in question, and thai breaches of ecclesiastical nile were not to be overlookeil even in him. But it was no less expetlient to deal tenderly with one who was at once so dutiful and so powerful. In William's case the Church was satisfied with asserting principles without rigorously TlKmaiur carr}'ing them into practice. Alexander showed himself l^^nfranc, ^^^ more inflexible than Nicolas and Leo. The matter wh.. rv. ^^.jjj, referred to the judfjement of Lanfranc, and by his them. (bnision both lliomas and Remigius were allowed to keep their liishopricks.'^ The rings and staves of which they ' Will. Malm. GcHt. Pont. 65. " Denique ainbon itineris Hui con)ite8, Thomam Archiepiucopum Elwracensem et Kemigium Epi8Co])um Lincoli- eoMin, bacalU et annulb exspoliatos, quud primus esset filius presb^rteri, Mcundufl pro auxiliis Willelmo venienti Angliam praebitis factus esset epiaoopufl, divinum rnuxiUM l^ellicoHis laLxmbus iiuiulinatus, precibua huIh restituit officio." On the gifts of Hetnigius to William, see above, p. 90, and voL iii. p. 380. ' lb. " Papa enira, pondus focti a se rejiciens, in eum considerationem transfudit, bene an secus fieret. Kedderet ipse investitura.s si vellet, sin LAXFRANC AND THOMAS AT ROME. 357 had het?n dcj)rived — nnga ami staves which they had chap. xix. received from the King of the English in an Assembly of his Witan — were restored to them again hy the hands of the Primate. We know not whether it was Wfore Thomaa or after this intercession «»n the piirt of his rival that ^-j^jj^ ^^f Thomas craved for a decision by Paj)al authority of the ^" •***» point in dispute between the Churches of York and Can- terbury. He pleaded that, by the ordinance of Gregory the Great, the two Primates were to be of e(pial authority, and that a simple personal precedence was to belong to him whose consecration was of older date.^ But Thomas and clainui claimed more than this. He asserted that three Bishoj)- iveT three" ricks of the province of Canterbury, Dorchester, Lichfield, ""ffrugan and Worcester, belonged of right to his own metroi)olitan Canter- jurisdiction.- Alexander declined to decide either question ; both should be heard and decided in England by a Council of the Bishops and Abbots of the realm. ^ AVith affiurs in this state the three Prelates returned to England. The cause was heard and decided in the course of the next year. It apj)ears to have been twice heard, in the regular Paschal and Pentecostal Gemots. The former was The Easter held, according to ancient use, at Winchester, while the wiiKiita- latter was held, like one of the meetings two years before,'^ \*^'"" ., „ . . ,. Apnl8, in the now favourite royal dwelling-place of Windsor. 1072. The two meetings are evidently confused in our several minus, faceret quod commodum Bciret. Ita illi de manu I.Anfninci Imculos et annulij.s recipifnte.^, hi-tum atl patriam cum codem moliti sunt ri'ditunj." It is ahnitrtt needlcHs t4i way that nothing of this sort is to he found iii the loyal YorkiHt Tliomatt Stuhhd. • See Appendix 1.1, ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 40. "In cujus [Ahxaiidri I'npji'] prascntia Thomas calumniam movit du primatu DorohcrnenHi.s ecclesia,* et de sub- jectione trium episcoporum, Dorcensia aive LincoIienslM, Wigomiensis, Licitfeldensi.s, qui nunc est Centrensis." So Vita Lanfr. 303. ' lb. 41. ** Do quA re et do trihus Episcupin multis hinc inde verbis prt)- latis.decrevit Alexander i'apa o[>ortere hanc caussum in Anglica terriL audiri, ut illic totiuH regni episcoporum et abbatum testimoniA et judicio diftiniri." ' See above, p. 340. 358 THE i;ai.»>»lASTlCAL m:TTI.KMKNT or KN(JLAM). CVAT. &II. accounti ; hut it would m^^m thnt the* inatttT wii^ (iiiit hmnl at \Vim'h«tcr Wfon* u pun»ly eccK«iiuotK nnd tlu« pntit inni of tlu* laity were nil aaM»inbled,* the Pajuil l^t^j^to lluhcrl was prosont,^ and the King- hinisolf, j>nt»idin^, like his predeceuHors mmon}^ his Witan, ndjtirwl all presiMit to hear nnd de- termine nooonlinjj to rig-ht Iwtween the two illustrious TrtAltVUie ditiputants.^ The cause wn« argued. From the side of iwwsjLsui tantorhurv Wf have a mmuto account ol the ])lcadmo^s, ^-{^^^ as detailcii l>y linnfranc lumsclf to the Pope. On the side of York no record is i)rescrved of the pleading's, except so ' Boiiidct the aooount iu the Gesta Pontificuin, wo havo Lanfranc's own kyiter to Pop« Alexander (Giles, i. 13), nnd the ftmnal decree i)f the Ah- •erobly with the nignaturea (Vit. Lanfr. Giles, i. 303 ; Will, Malm. Gent. Regg. iii. 298). In this document the two hearings are distinctly brought out. while Lanfranc's letter might have implied only a Kin;,'le hearing at Winchei«ter ; " Ventilata est hiec caiiHa priun apud Ventanam civitatem in Pa^chali Holemnitate, in cai>ella regia quic sita est in castello, {>ostea in Till4 regiA quae vocatur \Vinorum ordinum, qui congreguti »nint apud curiam in festi^ntate Pentecostes." ' Lanfranc himself, in his letter to the Po|ie (23), plainly bets foi-tli tlio mixed cliaracter of the Assembly ; " Quibus de rebus, vos, sicut sanctum pnidcntcmquc pastorem decuit et oportuit, i>er scriptum sententiam proimil- gftstis, quatenus conventus Anglicae terrse, episcoporum, abbatum, caetcra- rumque religiosi ortlinis personarum, utriusque partes rationed audiret, diiKTUteret, definiret ; factumque est ita. Convenerunt enim ad regalem curiam apud Wentanam civitatem in Paschali sollemnitate episcopi, ab- bates, oeterique ex sacro ac laicali ordine quos se de actione morumque probiiate par fuerat convenisse inprimis adunati sunt a nobis ex vestra auctoritate per sanctam obedientiam." Mark the mention of the laity, of whom there is no mention in the words attributed to Alexander. The Pope wijihed the matter to be judged by a Convocation, but it was judged bj a Parliament. • On Hubert, see above, p. 345. • £p. Lanfr. 24. " Deinde regia potestas per semetipsam contestata est m» per fidem et sacramentum quibus sibi colligati crant quatenus banc fiiMiin intentissime audirent, auditam ad certum rectumque finem sine partitun lavore perducerent. Utrumque omnes concorditer susceperunt, sese ita fiMrturo* sub prsefata obligatione 8points insi.sted on Ijy chap. xix. Thomas at the Roman Court. Tlie History of Bada was Ple*aing« put in as evidence; so were a long series of letters from of (^j^jt^.r. various Popes;* and the decision of the Assembly was '^"'y- given wholly in favour oi the Kentish metropolis. Ine favour of 1 1 umber was to be the boundary of the two provinces,'- i,*"!*'^ a boundary clear euoug-h as between Holderness and Lin- desey, less clear it' we go up to the hi«;her course of the Trent or the Ouse. Tliis sentence of course confirmed the right of Canterbury to archiepiscoj)al authority over the three disputed dioceses ; but the claim of York over them was even now not quite silenced.^ As to the church of \ork itself, the inherent precedence of Canterbury was acknowledged ; Thomas and his successors were to make pro- fession, not only to Lanfranc personally, but to him and his successoi*s. A zealous Canterbury writer adds, in a some- One Kuffra- wliat mocking strain, that, lest the Primate of York should York. be left altogether without suffragans, he was allowed to receive the profession of the Bishop of Durham.^ He was doubtless allowed to receive the profession of the Scottish Bishops also, if it were to be had. The undisputed ecclesiastical reign of Lanfranc now Eccleaiasti- began. His actions as the second man in tiic realm, as of Lan- franc ' See Ep. Lanfr. 24-26, and more fully Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 44-65, and Appendix LL. ' Will. ^L'ilm. (if»t. I'ont. 65. ** Succuhuit tantis raiionilms Thonja**, et placitum .'id modcrationeni transfcrrens, libcnter condition! concessit aniinuni, ut ulterior ripa Ilunibree fluminis esset principiuiu huo) diocccsiM, citerior esac-t limes j)arochiit' Cantu.iriensi.s." ^ iSee below, p, 372. * Gervase, Act. Pont. Cant. X Scriptt. 1653. ** Attjunen pro bono pacis l^nfrancus Hj)onte concessit Tlionuo ut DuncbncnHis cpi»*copuM dc ceterosibi protiterctur tt ut sutfragaticUH obe|M>li- of canonical discipline amon«^ them. As for the material tan church, fabric, whatever the fire had spared of the church which '°'^" °'^" Oda had re})aired and raised ' was now swept away to make room for the last improvements which the building-- art had received beyond the sea. Lanfranc took as his model the church which he had left at Caen,- and which still lacked somewhat of completion.^ Prudent, like his master, Lanfranc took care not to lay himself oj)en to the reproach which lii'-hts on those who begin to build and are not able to finish. The church of Canterbury, as desig-ned Changes in and carried out by him, was not one of those vast piles the Lw' " whose building" was necessarily spread over several g-enera- ^burch. tions. His whole work was done in the space of seven years, a space whose shortness amazed his own g-eneration.* The ancient church, with its two apsidal ends and its basilican ranges of pillars, now gave way to a minster of the received Norman type, with two towers, one of which was standing" within the present g"eneration. Hanking its western front, and with the central lantern rising, as usual, over the choir \vii\i its supporting ' See above, p. 125. See all the evidence in Willis's Cunterbury, 13, 14. ' See the comparison between the two churches in Willis, 65. ' See vol. iii. pp. 108, 38a. * EatJmer, Hist. Nov. 8 (Selden). " /Edificavit . . . ecclesi.-inj, quam .spatio septem annoruni a fundamentis fenne totam pcrfectam reury also (Gest. Pont. 69) remarks on the 8pee«l with which Lanfranc'H work waa done ; '* .^dificia ecclesiaj cui Redebat vorax flamma ante non multum consumpserat, cumulal)antquo ruitiatn aj(gere« parietuin, disjecta tectorum. Die, deturbatis veteribiis fundamentis, susciUavit in ampliorem Htatum omnia, ignorea majoro pulcritudino an velocitate." S4» Eahition of the choir umler tlie tower; " Turris in medio eodeaue mAximiM Rubnixa pilariu) poHita cut, nicut in medio circuiu- farwitjg ocntruu) . . . ab hac versus occidentem navis vel aula est eccleHise ■obniz* utriuique pilariis octo ; banc naveni vel aulam finiunt duK taiTM sublimes . . . pulpitum vero turreni pra^lictam a navi quodammodo wpMmbftt . . . pni-dicta magna turris crucem habebat ex utroque latere, MMtrmlon scilicet et aquilonalem.*' Thiu " pulpitum," it is plain from hitt description, wait the rood-Bcreen across the western arch of the lantern, but, when the choir was rebuilt by Prior Conrad, it would seem that the stAlht were placed in the eanteni limb, for Ger^ase says (1294), *• De turre in cborum per gradus plurimos aacenditur." ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 69. "Jam vero ex abundanti est dicere, quantum ibi omamentorum congesserit, vel in palliia et sacratis vestibus, in quibua, cedente materia, manus aurificum vincebat cxpensaruin pretium, vel in diversicoloribuH picturis, ubi lenocinante splendore fucorum an* spectabilix rapiebat animos, et pulcritudinis gratia soUicitabat oculos ad lAcniuuia.'* ' lb. 70. " Monachi Cantuarienses, sicut oumes tunc temporis in Anglic, •ecularibus liaud absimiles erant, nisi quod pudicitiam non facile pro- derent." * lb. " Canum cursibus avocari, avium pradam raptu aliarum volucrum per inane sequi, Hpumantis equi tergum premere, tesseras quatere, potibus indulgere, delicatiori victu et accuratiori cultu ; frugalitatem nescire, p*nimoniani abnuere, et cetera id genus, ut niagis illos conaules quan) iu« pro frequentiii famulantium diceres." LANFKANCS UEKOHMS. 3G3 chunired, but not suddenly. L.iiitVuuc knew better than chap. xix. at once to put new wine into old bottles, and the sinners were gradually led liy his mild rebukes to forsake the error of their ways.' He also largely increased the num- bers of the society. The monks of Christ Church were raised by him to a body of not less than a hundred and fifty, and they were placed under the more regular govern- ment of a Prior.-' He rebuilt the arvjhiepiscopal palace in the city, besides building houses on many of his rural lordshij)s.^ He built hospitals for the poor and sick of both His buiM- sexes, and founded the church of Saint Gregory the Ajwstle diHriublo of the English, served by a body of regular canons — the [o""<^*' first, it would seem, of that order who had been seen in s.iint England — whose duty it was to minister to the souls and ./t'^o'iJi'^.r. bodies of the brethren and sisters."* In all these good ''"''>', , ^ foundeu. 1084. • Will. Mahii. Geat. Pont. i. 70. *' Sciebat enim, artis artiuiu, id ent re^minis nnimariuii, peritissimus, consuetudiiiein i\ iiatum esse ^ecundain, a rt'pentiiKl moruiu convereione teneriores ex:icerb:iri aiiimos. Quaproptcr blandia monitiouibus per intcrvalla tem})«>ris, nunc ilia, nunc i.sta sul>- trahend, cote virtutum rudea exacuebat ad bonum mentea, eliniabatque ab eia vitiorum rubiginem." ' Gervase, Act. Pont. Cant. X Scrippt. 1654. ** Procesau temporia cen- tum mouachoa apposiiit, sic prudenter instituens ut in ecclesid Chriati inonachi eaaenl septies xx. vel centum et 1., quibua ordinem acripsit, Priorem instituit." ' Eadiner, Hist. Nov. 8. " .Edificavit et curiam aibi." Gervase, Act. Pont. Cant. 1655. *' In maneriia ad archiepiacopum pertinentibua ecolesiaa et domoa honeataa aedificavit." Of one of the.se buildings we find a aomewhat 8UH[iicious notice in Domeaday, 36;" Ad hue nijineriiun [Kstursete] jh-T- tinuerunt T. R. E. in civitate Hi. masurse, et modo non aunt niai xxv., quia alise Hunt deatructai in novA hoapitatione arohiepiscopi." • Will. Malm. (Jeat. Pont. 72. '* Extra urheni Cantuariam in aijuilo- nali parte lapideas domoa omnibus egenis, in occidental! parte regiA valo- tudine fluentibua ligneaa locavit, canonicia etiani apud Sanctum Gregorium regularibua inatitutia, (jui eia divina faccrunt officia ; diviaia pro varietate Boxuum habitaculis, sumptibua proviaia, miniatria delegatis." The din- tinction of the two clasaea of buildings in wood and in atone ahouldlns noted. Compare the buildinga of liiahop Aveagaud of Ia; Mana, vol. ii. p. 607, 2nd ed. ; Ger\ase, Act. Pont. Cant. 1655. " Eccleaiani Sancti Nicolai ad occidentem civitatia et ho.spitale fecit leproaonnn, in «|uil)UH ecclo- aiia clericoa instituit, ut pricdictia irgn)tis vivis ct defunctia apiritualia TIIK rrcl F-NlAsTIPAr Sr-TTIKMrNT OF KNrJl.AM). r. ui. works the Knif^ hrl)H^i iiiul favotinHl him, n» nlttn in his efforts for the npn^d and n^fDrm of niunaHticiHin in tlio Ukvnrmu countr}' ^frnornlly.* And lu'siilos Uioho |)u]»lic act**, wo J^^ hoar much also of \\'\h privalo ahnB,"* ahnn in whidi his aliumlant bounty did not alwayn wait till it wtm called u|x>n. I^anfranc freely otl'eri'd hrlp wherever it was neiMotl, and he strove that his left hand nhoiild not know what his ri^ht hand did.^ lU r»- Hut if lianfranc wm iMmntiful in H]»endin^, he was no ^uximof ^*^^ eareful in recovering; the ])roperty in regard to which biiM*. j^j, ^yjig trustee for his church and his 8UceeHSf)rs. One famous ease of his zeal in the recovery of the lost posses- sions of his sec has become familiar as an example of the E«»€»«o<^H- jurisprudence of the age.^ The Kind's brother, Bishop UMOit of Od©. Odo, had, in his temj)oral character of Earl of Kent, usurped divers possessions and rig-hts belon^ng to the Archbishop.* To these Lan franc made his claim, and the liiinigtnLrent. victualin quoquu eisdem «.'gT«tti« et reddituH aHHignavit." The Won! " clerici " om applied to regular canons Hhould be noted. ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 72. " Hujusmodi tempore Willelmi majori« injfistt-liat operibua, non multaK de his (juw ah eo |>etenda putiuiset repulHas {lOKiiUM. Nam ad ceteros minus civilis, illi erat affectuosuH et dulcis." ' Tlie writer of the Brevis Kelatio (Giles, 9) records a not very happy pUy upon Lanfranc's name ; " Propter largitatem itaque animi ejus dioebant quidam merito eum vocatum esse Lanfrancum, id est ferentem cor largum, eo qu(Kl largus et bonus erga onines hdniines fuit." ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 71. " Ultroneus juvenibus offerre denarios, quibuB neceasitudinum propriarum inopia,' occurrerent. Si datum fortuitu excideret, geminare, idciue clam aliis esse pnecipere." * The famous scene on Penenden Heath, " congregatio ilia famosa nf>bilium Anglia; et seniorum [J>a yldestan hegnas], quae ex praecepto liegis facU est apuompous o|>ening in which Ernulf records this feet is worth noticing; "Tempore magni Regis Willelmi, qui Anglicum re^nura armis conquisivit et suis ditionibus subjugavit, contigit Odonein Baiocensein £pi«copum et ejusdem Regii? fratrem njulto citius quam Lanfrancum Archiepi«copum in Angliam venire, atque in comitatu de Cant, cum magn& DISPUTE BE'nVEEN LANFRANC AM) oDO. 365 King commanded the mutter to be lieard, in ancient chap. xix. English form, bt»fore the Scimem6t of Kent. He further I-^J'f™"^'' o ' " HUit on bade that Ent'lisliraen known to be well versed in the Laws iVnenJen of Eng-land should be specially summoned.* Such a |»ru- i©;:. vision was not neeilless. When tlu- King's men, French and Knglish, wore gathered together, the result might be ditl'erent in a shire like Kent, which had been utterly given over as a prey to the spoiler,- and in a shire like Lincoln, where English Thegns and Lawmen still held their own in considerable numbers. ^ The Assembly met in the ancient meeting-place of the shire on Penenden Ileath,^ and the pleadings on the two sides occupied the whole shire for three days. ' Li this case the natural presidents of the Assembly, the Bishop and the Earl,° were themselves the litigants; the court was therefore held by Geoffrey of Mowbray, Bishop of Coutances, who appears on more than potentiA resulere, ibique potestatem non modicani exercere. Et quia illi-s diebuii in comitatu illo (juisquam non erat qui tantje fortitudini.s viro resiatere posset, propter ma^iam (juaiu habuit potestatem, terras complures de archiepiacopatu Cantuarberiie et consuetudines nonnuUas aibi arripuit, atque usurpan.s suae duminationi adscripsit." ' Anglia Sacra, i. 335. " Pntcepit ergo Rex comitatuiu totum absque mora considere, et homines comitatOs omnea Francigenas, et pnecipue Anglos in antiquLs legibua et consuetudinibua j)erito« in unum convenire." '* See aboA'e, p. 34. ^ See above, p, 214. * Domesday, i. "Si fuerint prsemoniti ut conveniant ad sciram, ibunt usque ad Pinnedennam, non longius." See Furley's Weald of Kent, 187, 237, 268. Compare the meetings of the Berkshire Soirgemut at Cwichelmeshliew, vol. i. p. 360. * Anglia Sacra, i, 335. " Et quoniain niulta placita de diratiocina- tionibuM terrarum et verba de consuotudinibus legum inter Archiepisco- pum et pnedictuin liaiocensom Episcopum ibi surrexcrunt, et etiam inter consuetudines regales et archiepiacopales quse prim& die expediri non jKjtuerunt, eil caus.s.1 totus coniitatus per tres dies ibi fuit detontus." ''' We find Lanfranc and (Jdo acting together in this character in Domes- day, 2. A reeve named Bruman had levied T. K. E. certain duc« belonging to the Abbey of Saint Augustine, " (jui postea T. R. W. ante Archiepisco- pum Lanfrancum et Episcopum Baioccnsem recognovit ae injuste accopissc, et aacramento facto juravit quod ipsa* ecclesixe suas consuctudincH ({uietaa habucrunt K. E. tempore, et ex inde utnt'(|Uo eccleaia* in sua terra habue» runt consuetudines Huas, judicio baronum Kegis cpii placitum tenut-runt." TUB BCCLBSIASnCAL BRTTI.F.MKNT (>P F.NOLAM). onAr. itm. one other occsnion in tlu» rimrnctor of JuHtiriftry.* A crowd Nai«r» of men of rank ami nuthoritv, FriMuh ami KntrliKh. ai*- AmtmUy. pfttml in that mixpil characU«r, nt onrr jud^os and wit- nri«. which niArko the jiirisprudenoe of the a^^*. \U\\ Wlt»««of «|K«cial woijfht was attAohinl to the witness of .Kthelric, SiiTlrii*. the de|io«xl Hiflhop of the Scmth-Saxons, an aj^ed man, f|)eoinlIy U»arniHl in the laws of the land. He wa«, by the Kind's Ppec'ial ortler, hroupht — perluips from his prison at MarllH)roujjh — in a oar or wap-i^on like a Merowin^ian Kini;. to declare to the Assembly what the ancient cnstoms '^J"%'*""^ of England were.- The Assembly heard and determined, LABftaoc on grounds, we are told, so strong* and clear that from that day no man ever dared to call in question one jot or one tittle of its decision.^^ Divers lands of the see were rc- THf coveretl from Odo and his followers and from other unjust Hu^'h of occupants. Among" them we specially mark Hugh of ]Mont- T r 1 i '^ ^'^^^' already known at Senlac and at Dover,' and Turold of M 1 KAij.h Rochester, whose dwarfish form still lives in the Tapestry Kjiiu-. of Bayeux.-^ A third was Ral])h, described, ix)ssibly from some physical defect of the same kind, as Curra-sjnna or Curbeitpine, who appears in the Survey as a special despoilcr ' Ang. Sac. i. 335. " Huic placito interfuerunt Goisfiridus EpiscopuB ConsUntieuMui, qui in loco RegJH fuit et justitiam illara tenuit." • lb. •* /Kj^elricuH EpiHCopu.s do Cicestra, vir antiquiH.sinius et legiim term «»pientisHimu8, qui ex pra-cepto Regiu advectuH fuit ad ipsas anti- qtUM legom oonsuetudines discutiendas et edocendaH in un& quadriga." No one would have ^esHcd from thin deRcription that -^'Ethelric had 00— ed to bo Dixhop of any see, and that, while he was Biwhop, his see WM at Selsey and not at Chichester. He is spoken of again in nearly the ■une way when his cause, of which we have already heard (see above, P* 343)» ^•^ finally settled in the Council of 1076; " Fratris nostri Ailrici, CiceitreiMUi quondam Epincopi, caussa canonice definita et ad finem per- ducU est." Wilkins* Concilia, i. 367. ' Ang. Sac. u. s. " In ilia die (juA ipsum placitum finitum fuit non ramanait homo in toto regno Angliie qui aliquid inde calumniaretur neque •oper ip«M ternM etiam parvum quidquid clamaret." • See above, p. 73. • "Tnroldus de Hrovecestria," as he appears in Ernulf. See vol. iii. p. 568. 80 in Domesday, 6 h, 7, we find " Ra t=> t^ l\^^. King narrowed to certain cases toiichintj the safety and ji^ood -%n.i the maintenance of the King's hi^^^hway.'- He established in bwhop. return divers rights of his own over the lands of the King and the Earl, such especially as touched the gootl morals and the souls' health of his flock. ^ The decree of the local Gemot was laid before the King, by whom it was approved and confirmed, and it was seemingly sanctioned with all solemnity by a general Council of the whole realm. ^ * ** RaUulfus deCurvA-spiuA" in Emulf. We find him in Domesday (a) m holding the houses in Canterbury which had belonged to Harold's mistreat, whether Eadiryth Swanneshal.s or any other (see vol. iii. pp. 763, 764) ; *' Radulfud do Curbespine habet iv. inansuras in civitate quas tenuit (^medam concubina Heraldi." He appears again in 9 6 ; " Kadulfua de Curbespine tenet de Epi.scopo [Odone] unum jugum in Berfrestone. Ibi una paui>ercula mulier reddit iii. denarios et ununi obolura." The name Curbejsinne may be hereditary, as in Orderic (550 D) wo find a " Robertus de Curva-spiiul, strenuu3 miles," father of Gilbert Maminot, Bishop of Lisieux, and perhaps of this Ralph. ' The royal rights are thus defined in the Winchester Appendix ; *' Lanfrancus diratiocinavit, se suamque ecclesiam omnes terras et consue- tudines sua.s ita liberas terra ni.iritpie habere, sicut Rex habet suas, exceptis tribus, N-idelicet, si regalis via fuerit efFosa ; si arbor incisa juxta super earn ceciderit ; si homicidium factum vel sanguis in ea fusus fuerit ; in iis (|ui deprehensus, et ab eo pignus acceptum fuerit ; Regi enim dabit ; alioquin liber a Regis exactoribus erit." They are given more fully by Ernulf, 3.^5, but to the same effect. Compare also the customs of Canterbury in Domes- day, 2 ; " Si quis infra has publicas vias intus civitatem vel extra fixlerit vel palum fixerit sequitur ilium pra.'positus Regis ubicumque abierit et emendam accipiet aOHt4|uam Rex audivit, laudavit, laudans cum consensu (muiiun- principum suonim confirmavit, et nt d«-inceps incornjptus iKJrsevenirei firiiiiter pni-cepit." 368 TUP. B0CLB81A8TICAL ABTTLEMKNT OF RNOLAM). tSAT. Ill T)iis if one of the inomontH in Win hintory wliich set I' ..!T^ U'fon* tiii the mixed character of William on it« brii^hteut \v t. i»i> • »itle. lie ciuiKl iit all timcK {tiny the tyrant when so ^ »••*.. rr .^ Huitetl his jx»licy. In course* of time he evt*n li-arncHl to ..*•.:. piuy jjjj» tyrant at the mere hidtlin^ of hin own pleasure. But when no 8uch motive led him ai^tniy, no prince was more ready than William to rei^ii as a just Kinp over his |H?ople. In this pn^wnt mattrr ylOlfn'd <»r Cnnt could have done no more than William did. \\c ai)i)ear8 tis not only willinj^. but anxi«»us, that juslioe should be done, even a^^innt his own brother. He stej)H in, not as a partizau of either disputant, but as a suj)remc j)ower, careful to provide that the lawfid judges should have the means of lUtflBtkm judging fairly between l>oth disjmtants. Above all, the l^w.^^ story shows that nothin<^ was further from his thoughts than to root out the Laws of England and to bring in some foreign code of his own devising in their stead. Tlie matter is judged by the lawful English Court, as- sembled in its ancient place of meeting. It is judged according to the ancient Laws of England, as set forth by the mouths of those who knew them best, those whose memories could go furthest back into the days of the holy Eadward and the righteous Cnut. If men of foreign birth were present, if they even ])resided in the Assembly, it was not as men of foreign birth that they were there. Geoffrey of Mowbray and his companions were present in the Gemot at Penenden as men who held English lands according to English Law. They were present as the officers of a King of the English who, on that day at least, fully carried out the oath which he had sworn, to rule his Kingdom as well as it had ever been ruled by any of the Kings of the English that were before him.^ Having thus sketched the state of the metropolitan ' See vol. iii. p. 560. BISHOPS OF ROCHESTER. 369 church, I will run briefly throuii^h the history of the chief chap. xix. Bishopricks and Abbeys of Enirland, as they were affected ^y^^}^ »' by this memorable primacy. A few events which had dumh.'s of a direct bearino- on ^:t'neral history will be kept for their uSr" proper place in chronolo<^ical order. Lanfranc Next to his own church of Canterbury, the chief object Rochenter. of Lanfranc's care was the little dependent Bishoprick of Rochester. Tlie nomination to this see lay in his own hands. ^ The Eng-lish Prelate Siward, who had a share in the conse- I>yath of cration of Lanfranc, was allowed to keep his see for life.- sivanl. He was followed in quick succession by two monks of Caen, ^°^^' hrnost and Gundulf, ' the latter of whom has left a g-reat RUhop. name behind him in the history of military architecture. He °' ' •^ , (Jundulf was the architect uf the i^reat work of the Concjueror, the Bishop, miyhty Tower of London;^ he built also his own tower '°'' *' ^ All our authoritieH emphaticaUy point to this peculiar position of the Rochester Bishoprick. Thus in the Appenili.x to the Winchester Chronicle we read, " Sexto anno dedit Hemosto raonacho, in capitulo ecclesiae Christi, ecclesiam Rofensem regendam, quern et Lundoniae sacravit Hemostus hoc ipso anno ab hAc vita migravit. Septimo anno, CJundulfo modo ecclesiam Rofen.sera tradidit, (luem etiam Cantuaria> sacravit." See also Gervase, Act. Pont, Cant. 1654. Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 136; " Has miserias corrigere volens, sapientissimus Lanfrancus Archiepiscopua Amostum nuemdani nionachuni jKHitificeni loco dedit. Sed eo veloci niorte pnerepto, CJundulfuiu leque monachuiu indu.xit." But the other side may be seen in the " Libellus " of the Rochester monks, Ang. Sac. i. 384. • Ann. Roff. Ang. Sac. i. 342. '* Anno mlxxv. Sywardu.** Roffensia Episcopus obiit, cui successit Arnostus, Beccensis monachus." Florence inadvertently puts this under 1070, seemingly wishing to clear off the his- tories of several Bishops at once. ' There is a Hj»ecial Life of Gundulf in Anglia Sacra, ii. 373. He wa.s a native of the Vexin, first a canon of Rouen, then a monk of Bee, who moved to Saint Stephen's with Lanfranc. * On the building of the Tower of London see Mr. (». T. Clark in Old London, 97, 98. As a direct authority for (Jundulf's share in the work he refers to the " Conventio inter Gundulfum Episcopum et Eladmerum An- hancle burgensem London iff'," in Hcarno's Textus Koffensis, 212 ; " Dum idem (Jundulfus, ex pni'cepto Regis Willielmi Miigni, pneosset open magnw turriit Londoniie, et bospitatus fuisset apud ipsum ..ICdmerum." The name Tower, and not CaMle, belonged to CJundulf's fortress from the first. See the Peterborough Chronicle, 1097, iioo, 11 01. VOL. IV. I» )) trO THE BOCLBBlAflTirAT. Rr.TTl.r.MKNT OK RNOLAND. OBAT. xii. at Mallinjf,* nJiil in the tiavH ot William UtifiiK ho huilt Awytw ^ ^yul cA»tU' in his own city, which in the m-xt n^c j^ve •fOvadttlt w»v to om» of j»Tt»rtlor enrichment, whieh n<»\v 0»rmH one of the nobh»«Jt ruins «>f Homanewiue defcnHive work.^ Hut HcrrhuiUU he iiliH\ no douht in jiiirtnonihip with liin patron, rebuilt itthJa)^'. his aithea.uu ministers. At the death of Siward, we are t«»ld, it was i».'t»w« for jn n wrt?toht*d utate. It was ntill served by secular canons, of whom only four were K-ft, and those living in the same |>overty in which we are told that their brethren at Wells li«m*4r« were found at the cominj^ of (iisa.* We R^ather from another ^^^.^^ source that they were commonly marrietl, that their wives and children were legally recoji^nizcd, and that moreover both husbands and wives remained on ^ood terms with the monks who supplanted them.'' These, under the care of Lanfranc * See Old I^»mlon, 97. * A diupute between the Bishop and William Rufu« about the manor of Hedenham in BuckinghamHhire was compromised by the Bishop, aa a skilful architect, undertaking to build the Kiuij a cantle ; " (juatenuH pro pccuniA, (juam pro concessione manerii exigebat, EpiHcopus Gundulfus, (juia in opere ca?mentarii plurimum sciens et efficax erat, castrum sibi Hrofense lapideum de buo construeret." (Ang. Sac. i. 338.) So presently we read, " Igitur hoc pacto coram Rege inito, fecit caHtrum Gundulfus Episcopua de ■uo ex integro totum, costamine, ut reor, Ix. librarum." The whole story is curious. * Emulf (Ang. Sac. i. 337) speaks only of Gundulf's share in the work; " xixi. annis inibi superstes exsistens, ecclesiam S. Andreae, pene vetuiitate dirutam, novam ex integro, ut hodie apparet, sedificavit, officinas quoque monachis necessariag, prout loci necessitas pati potuit, omnes c^»n»truxit." But Gervase, Act. Pont. Cant. 1665, diHtinctly attributes the work to Lanfranc ; " Ecclesiam Sancti Andrea; liofifensis, quam Rex olim f ' Tit Ethelbertus, renovavit, consummavit, quam etiam preciosis ir-f (t monachirt ditavit." * i. 339. " £t quum non ampliua in introitu episcopatus sui quaru quiu^ue invcnisset in ecclesiA S. Andrea? canonicos, die quA saeculo vrr^. iitl decessit plusquam sexaginta nionachos, bene legentes et optime -. in servitio Dei et apostoli sui Deum timentes et super omnia reliquit." William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 72) speaks of :. ,.{ y>,.,.iw.-ter, just like thrwe of Wells, as " ipsi quotidian! panis ' ThiH appears from a curious set of entries in Ang. Sac. i. 340, from WORKS OF GUXDrLF. 371 and Oundulf, grew to the number of fifty, and the nile chap. xix. of Saint Benedict flourished in tlie church of Saint Andrew of Rochester. Lanfranc also won back for his vassal Lanfmnc chunli a lordship in the distant shire of Cambridge, a tJie cMuu-n lordship which had Wlonged to Earl Harold, and whose "^'!'" "'^ grant is recorded in a writ of William in the Eng-lish bridgv?. tongfue.^ The story illustrates the state of thin^ in the days when Enf^lis^h Law had to be administered by foreign officers. The Bishop of Rochester claims the land of King AVilliam ; the King refers the matter to the lawful tribunal, the Scirgemot.^ But through fear Unjufrt of the Norman Sheriff Picot, of whom we have already th*JJ[,^j!iff heard, ^ the English witnesses gave a false verdict that ^*'^<'*- the land belonged to the Crown. Complaint was made The wrong to Bishop Odo, who had been present at the first hear- bv 0e ic fynnest fram ofer sap com [it in curious to see this familiar Domesday formulary in the English tongue and in the first person] and swa swa l^urbearn and fioti of Harolde hcolden." The land whicli Emulf (339) descril)es as " terra «nue erat de Fracenham et jacebat in Giselham " appears in Domesday (190 b) under the latter name. It is held by the Bish'»p of Rochester " sub Archiepiscopo I^anfranco." Tliere is no mention of Harold or of Goti, but besiiles " Wulwinus venator Regis E.," we read that *' xii. 80ci habuerunt i. hidam sub Turberto [doubtless the Thurbeani of the writ], ohtrtn mv of \oTk TliomaH of Bnycux of wt with all honour for thirty years, uutliviujr T>anfranc }^\ anil William and Willianr» Huceessor. The «>M disimte i070"iioo Ix^tween the two metro|M)litan sees was not fully IuuKhI. Ur (ooM- It fell to the lot of ThonuL** to consecrate tho succcsHor Aftwim. of Lanfranc, the holy Ansolm. It v/nn lu*ld at York 1093. that the profession which Thomas lunl niade to Lau- Rtnrd of fmnc i>er8onally was now utterly cancelletl an regarded '.imiMto his successor,^ a nolit£e in Britannia, alter super alterum esse non potest. 8i timore vel amore et juvenili consilio personaliter et indebite alicui me subjeci. liberatus sum ; in Primatem neminem consecrabo." WORKS OF THOMAS OF YORK. 373 the vag^uer title of Metropolitan.' The (juostion to<» al.out ciixv xix. the (lioeese of Dorchester or Lincoln also rose a^^in. On *'"^ ■"' ^'* the death of Remi^^ius, Thomas objected to the consecra- diction'of tion of his successor Robert Bloet as Bishop of Lincoln. ^'"'^***y- 1093. He mi«,'ht In* liishop of Dorchester, like his predecessors; but Lindesey, part of the spiritual conquest of Paullinus,* was of ancient ri<^ht subject to the metroi>olitan authority of York. ' This claim came to nothing, and Tliomas Work* of found better scope for his energ-ies in the reform of his at York own church. The minster of Saint Peter, like that of Re«t«.m- the southern metropolis, was found by Thomas a blackened n.'iJJ^ier^ ** ruin."* Yet it would seem that the ancient church was not utterly destroyed, and that the work of Thomas was rather to repair than actually to rebuild.^ But of the works either of Thomas or of his predecessors nothing remains beyond a few fmgments embedded in the crypts which support the vaster and more splendid fabric of later days. With regard to the constitution of his church, His re- his career was a memorable one in local and even in th™^m«ti- fjeneral history. It forms a Cfood illustration of the habits ^"t»on ^'f ... . . ^^^e Chap- and feelings of Englishmen with regard to the position ter. of the secular clergy. The church of York had been ' T. Stubbs, X Scriptt. 1707. We read first, "Scripta petitione et lecta ut eum in Primutern totiu.s Bnt.iTiiiiai consecraret. ct Thomas ilisct's«o«t.* ThoiDM i\ II* &r«i Dum)>cr of the hotly. Ho at first foUowod thi* oxainplo JJgJpi^j^ of OisM at WolU * and Iji»ofric nt Exotor,^ in introducing' the Lotharin^ian discipline. \lo huilt a dormitor}' and refectory, and made his canons live in common under the ini|>erintondence of a Provost.* He jin)])al)ly lived to find that this system did not suit the hahits of Kn^'lishmen at York any more than it did at Exeter. AViscr advisers * -it After- aftorwanls Kxl him to introduce the system which was witbdnva gradually introductnl into the secular cathedrals of En^^land. *^ He divided the e^jtatcs of his church into prebends, tlius allotting" to each canon his separate maintenance. He Hefoond* ftlso founded the dignities of Dean, Precentor, and Trca- nitiMMMl ^^^^' The office of Chancellor or Master of the Schools P'^***'***- he had already introduced while the church was under the Lotharin^ian discipline.'^ The work of Thomas in this respect still lives. The constitution of the church of York, as laid down by him, still remains nearly un- altered, and in no church in England have the original rights of the whole capitular body been so little encroached on by the growth of a residentiary oligarchy. WjUUm In the church of London no change was needed. Bishop Hiabop of ,. . . ly^n.lon. ^Villiam lived on, honoured by men of both races, and loji-io^f. j^.^yjj^g. Ijchind him a memory which was long cherished ' T. Stuhbs, X Scriptt, 1708. " De septera canonicis, non enim plures faenuit, tre« tantum repperit, ceteri vel mortui erant, vel metu vel desola- iione patrix exBulabant." " See vol. ii. p. 84. ' See vol. ii. p. 452. • T. Stubb«, u. 8. " Canonicos quos invenit, restituit, disperses revocavit, etaliqnoe addidit, refectorium et dormitorium refecit, prsepositura constituit, qui ceteris prseesoet, et eos procuraret." * lb. 1709, " Annifl plurimia canonicis comrauniter vescentibus, quo" runidam conBilio placuit archiepiacopo de terrSl Sancti Petri, quae a^Jhuc multam vaatata erat, singidaa prsebendas partiri. Tunc quidera statuit deca- num, tbe«aurarium, cantorem, nam magiHtrum scholarum ante atatuerat." BISHOPS OF mNDOX. 375 among' the burghers of his city.* Two Bishops succeeded cdap. xnt. him in the days of Lanfranc and Kinj; William. Ilui^h of '^"K** *»^ Orival is an obscure name enough,- but his successor Hinhop. Maurice was memorable for betjinnino: the mivc nil, hat! duties laid ujxin it >vliioh wen* i|uite ineoimiftcnt witii the monu^^tie proteKsion, and whieh could l»e In'tter diw^har^iHl l»y the more worldly rJLpcricnce of Uie 8tH?ular elerg-y.' MinhTU reaotituros certi exHtiterant, ut Wal- chelinus Episcopus adunatos penc quadraginta clericos, canonicoruni more tonsurd ac veste redimitos, haberet, quos, ejectis monachiH, Wentanae •cclesis cui pnBsidel^at mox intromitteret." So Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 71. *• Jam enim episcoporum livor increverat, volentium ab episco- palibus sedibus monachos, clericiH immissis, extrudere. Auctor hujus (actionis fuit Walkelinus Wentanus, ad ca-tera bonus, sed in hoc ad pravum conHiliis susurronum flexus, plus xl" canonicos cappis et super- pelliciiji omaverat." * Eadmer, u. s. " Sola mora hsec peragendi, nondum requisita ab Archi- episcopij Lanfranco licentia fuit," * lb. " Ut autem earn dicto (juoque citius impetraret, nulla menti ejus [Walkelini] dubitatio inerat, sed aliter ac sibi mens sua spoponderat exitus rei provenlt." SCHEMES OF WALKELIN oF WINCHESTEH. 377 franc, the liithcr aiul lover of monks, un consent to any chap. xix. such scheme was to l>e had.' Tlie Primate appealed to Pojmj Alexander. He obtained from him a hull censuring'' in the strongest terms the scheme for the humiliation of the monastic order,- and decreeing that the church of Canter- bury should remain served by monks, as the blessed Augustine had foundetl it.* Tlie design for the like change in the church of Winchester was equally brought to nought. There also all innovation was forbidden by Papal decree.* The canons whom Walkelin had gathered together had to go back to their homes without taking possession of their expected prebends,'' and the discipline which had been * *• Se arwurSa muneca feJer and frouer Lanilfranc arcebistn ip," sAyg the Peterborough Chronicler in recording his death in 1089. * The bull is given in Eadiner, lo, and Lanfranc's Letters, (iilea, i. 27. Itij language shows that the Papal gift of scolding was art vigorous then as it is now; " Accepinius a quihu^dam venientibus de partibus vestris ad limina sanctorum Apostolorum Petri et Pauli, quod quidam clerici, associato sibi terrenae potestatis, laicoruni videlicet, auxilio, diabolico spiritu repleti, nioliuntur de ecclesia S. Salvatoris in Dorobemiu, quje est metropolis totius Britanniae, monachos expellere et clericos inibi statuere ; cui nefario open molitionis suie hoc adjicere coiiantur, ut in orani sede episco- pali ordo monachuruin extirj)etur, quasi in eis non vigeat auctoritaa religionia." ' Tlie bull of Alexander professes simply to contiriu an earlier one of Boniface the Fifth, which orders, " ut vestra benignitad in monasterio Dorobemensi civitate constituto, quod sanctus doctor noster Augustiniw, beatse memorite Gregorii discipulus, Sancti Salvatoris nomini consecra- vit . . . licenter per omnia monaciiorum reguljiriter viventium habitationem statuat, a|)Ostolica auctoritate decementes, ut ipsi vestne salutis pne- dicat^jres monachi monachorum gregem sibi associent, et eorum vitam sanctitatuni moribus exoment." * Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 71. " Regem in sententiam traxerat [Walkelinus], et tantum mora in medio ut archiepiscopi consensum eliceret ; is quominus halK-Tetur, nihil dubitanduni. At ille auditum facinus exhorruit, et tot potentum excogitata.H machina.s, ut causes aranea. rum, solo intuitu dissolvit, quinotiam, ne idem audereut poeteri, egit ut Alexaniler Papa scriptis inhiberot." * Eadmcr, 10. ** Ergo ct clerici (|ui succedere nionachis fuerant j>er Walchelinum coUecti, et in sua dimissi sunt, et monachi qui ce«lere cleri- corum pr«judicio quixlam damnati erant, gratid Dei ut instuntiA l>oQi Lanfr.inci, priritiii.'f cotjversationix in hui\ ccclesiu comi>otcs offucti sunt." S7« TUB KIX'LK8IA8TICAL 8KTTLKMKNT OK KN(}I.ANI>. ctur. sii. brnuf^ht into tho OKI Minntrr l)y tho zeal of I'^d^r iiiui i£thrhvol(l rrmaiiUHl untouclu*il till the gt'iimil disHolution of mtmiiMtic Ixxlit's.' LmMo Ii*i»frio, tho fin*t Hisho]> of Exeter, the Pnlat*' who hiul 2J32r. broujjht in the Ivothnrinj^inn disripline,'* kept hin HiHhoprick 1046-1071. f^j. \[f^ \ Briton or Kiij^lishman whose fcelinjjH were mninly forei^-n, he was followed hy a stronper who had learned to f»fl as an Kni^lishman. Oshem, a non of the loM-noi. fiw^^if"^ puardian of \Villiain,* a brother of the famous Earl of Hen*ford, had, like others of his nation, crossed the sea to enjoy the favours and bounty of the ^.^ood King Eadwanl.^ Hut, unlike most of those who came on that errand, he adopted the manners and feelings of English- men. Amongst other signs of this tendency, he forbore to destroy the works of his j)reert l^'btTt by name, was the chosen friend of Saint Wulfstan, and, like Hereford, most other Norman Bishops, the rebuilder of his cathedral.- *®"^~'°95- The sainted Bishop of Worcester himself survived both P'^ition of Saint Kin^ and Metroix>litan, and remained for many years the Wulfsun. only Bishop of Eng-lish birth in J]n«^land.' We are told that, in one of the early Councils of William's reij^-n, the two Archbishops conspired together against the English- man, or at least attacked him at once from their several points of view. Thomas, as we have already seen,* claimed him as a sutfragan ; Laiifranc despiseil him as a simple * William of Malmesbury (Gest. Pont. 300) tells the story doubtingly (" nisi fama mentitur "), and adds that the King did all that might be to hinder the scandal from getting wind (" rumor criminis et ultionis totam j)er\agatus Angliam Regis quoijue aures attigit. Ille dignitate regia credulitatem dissimulans, ne vel cseteri disseminarent gravissimo coercuit edicto." The way in which Thierry deals with this I'relato is amu.sing. In ii. 21 the Lotharingian Bishop appointed by Eadward in 1062 becomea one of " une nuee d'avunturiers partis de la Gaule " under William. Of these adventurers he tells us " la plupart attichferent daus leur nouvel etat rimmoralite la plus dehontce " — an utter calumny as regards the Prelate* appointe par une femrae k qui il voulait faire violence," with a reference to the story of Walter, of all places in the world, in Knighton, X Scriptt. 7.^47. A few pages on (28) Walter comes to life again as an English patriot ; *' Flamand de naissance, le seul parmi les etrangers, evdques avant la conqutfte, qui so soit montr^ fidblo a la cause de sa patrie adoptive." See vol. ii. p. 81. ' Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. u. s. " Robertus Lotharingus ibi ecclcsiani tereti ajdificavit schemato, Aquensem basilicam pro modo imitatus suo." If so, all traces of his building have perished. The pre.nent Romanesque work at Hereford follows the common typo of English and Nonnan minsters, and has not the faintost likeness to the church of the Great Charles. ' Wulfstan (lied in 1095, twenty years aft<>r the li\ it wmiM sccin, to nponk any IWrvAT Uiijftiajjv hut hiu own.' Hin »h'p<»hition kimiium! hardly KUear an an enoniy of Wulfhtan. ' Vita Wlxt. 356. " Tandem JU8HU8 exire ut btrictiori conxilio rcBponHum poliret, cum paucis secnm egressiB horam nonain inctepit et jjercantavit. lliis porro referentibus ut alia magis quam psalmos curaret, et id propter quod venerat expediret, respondit ; * Stulti nescitis (juod Dominus dixit, Duni Hteteritifl ante Reges et pncHides, nolite cogitare quouiodo aut (juid Ictquamini. Dabitur enim vobis in ilia bora quid luquamini.' " ' Will. Malm. Ge^t. Pont. 285. " Ita data benedictione nionacho, mininifl? facundiae viro, sed Normannica; linguae sciolo, rem obtinuit, ut qui BUS dioecesis ante putabatur indignus regimine ab ArchiepiHCopo Eboraci suppliciter rogarctur ut 8ua« [sic] dignaretur lustrare, quo ipse pro timore hostium vel sermonis ignorantia cavebat accedere." The epithet "minimae facundis vir" Hounds odd, when we think of Wulfhtan 's journey to York in company with Harold, described by the same writer in hia Life of Wulfrtan. • Vita Wist. 256. " In eodem concilio apud Pedridan habito episco- patus ei Cestrensis a Lanfranco Archiepificopo vibitatio commissa est. Ea enim provincia, qua tres habet pagos, CeHtrensem, Crobemensem, Teforden- •em [I presume that Shropshire and Staifordshire lurk under these two strange names], erat adhuc propter longinquitatem Normannis inaccessa, et propter barbariem impacata." * The story finjt apjtears in ^Ethelred of Rievaulx (X Scriptt. 406 j, who \1» LEGEND OF SAINT WL'LKSTAN. 381 and Primate called on the En^-lish Bishop to ^'wo up his chap. xix. stair and rin«^''. lie was, they said, a simple and unleanu'd ^'j-'^^JjI^, man who knew not the French ton^ie, and who could 'l*^^l>ver- ance. be of no use m the counsels of the Kin^.' Wulfstan arose, statf in hand. IIo knew his own unworthint'ss ; he would willin«^ly give up his stafl", but he would not g-ive it up to Lanfranc, from whom he had not received it ; he would give it up to the holy Kadward who had given it to him. Wulfstan walked to tlu* tomb of Kadward and spoke to his dead master ; " Thou knowest, most holy King, how unwillingly I took this burthen upjn me, and how it was thou who didst constrain me thereto. The choice of the monks was not wanting, nor the petition of the people, nor the consent of the Bishops and nobles, but it was thv will which stood forth chief above all.- Lo, now there is a new King, a new Law, a new Primate, who puts forth new decrees. Tliey charge thee with error, who didst make me a Bishop ;' they charge me witli presumption is followeo- tentiie." ' S»e above, p. 174. ♦ Se«! the entry in Domesday, 173 f>, " Crescente congregationo T. K.W." ' Atm. Wig. 1085. "Major Malvoniia funduta •••*( jht Alwium SSI TIfl BCCLKSIA8TICAL 8BTTLBMENT OP BNOLAND. su WoUblan WMU At tliede- ■tmoCioo cflUold OOBTCb. \Vulfntaij'» j^»at*»nt work wim» in liin own city. Unlike the Norman-lH»m but Kn^linh-miniKHl Hishop of Exet<»r,* he yioKltxl to tl»c fa8hi<»n of t!u» day, and doHtroywl the church of hi« holy prtnlccciwor Oswald to make room for a Iniildinf^ on a p^vatcr scale, and more in accordance with the prevalent tanto of the times. ^ Of the work of Wulfstan in the minster of Worcester some portions still •I)ide oIkivc g^round, and his cryi>t remains untoiiche8St»ssion cf the new chunli, when the work of the blessetl Oswald began to be unroofed and pulled down, the holy AVulfstan stood and wept.-' The by- standers asked him why he did not rather rejoice at being the means of carrying so great and holy a work to its completion.* The Bishop forthwith made answer; " Our predecessors, whose monuments we deface, rather (I doubt) to set up the banners of our vain glory than to glorify God, they indeed (quoth he) were not acquainted monachum." A somewhat fuller account is given by William of Malmep- bur)', Gest. Pont, 286, 296. Elaldwine had a companicm named Ouy, another instance of Norman and Englishman working together. ' See above, p. 378. * Ann. Wig. 1084. "Inceptio operis Wigomiensis monxisterii per •anctum Wulstanum," Vita Wist. 263. "Tunc autem et novam ecclesiam perfecit; nee facile invenias omamentum, quod earn non decoraverit. Ita erat in fdngulia mirabilis et in omnibus singularis." * The story is told by William of Malmesbury in the Life of Wulfstan, 262, and in Gest. Pont. 283. The words in the latter place are, " Quum eoclesiae majoris opus, quod ipse a fundamentis inceperat, ad hoc increnienti procesHLBset ut jam monachi migrarent in illam, jussum est veterem eccle- siam, quam beatus Oswaldus fecerat, detegi et subrui. Ad hoc spectaculum •tanM Bub divo Wlstanus Lacrimal tenere nequivit." * Will Malm. Gest. Pont. 283. " Modesto a familiaribus redargutus, qui gaudere potius deberet, quod se superstite tantus ecclesiae honor acces- OMet ut ampliatuB monachorum numerus ampliora exigeret habitacula." at Bruitul. BUILDINGS OP WCLFSTAN. 385 with such stately biiildini^, but every place was a ehurch cii vp. xix. sufficient lor them to oiler themselves a reasonable, holy, and lively sacrifice unto God. We contrariwise are double dilig-ent in laying" heaps of stone, so to frame a material temple, but are too neg-lii'-ent in setting forward the building" of that lively temple the Church of God.'* * Yet there was no Prelate of his own or of any other day who had less need than Wulfstan to charge himself with neglecting the spiritual temple of God in order to build up heaps of stones. I pass by his zeal against the married clerg}' and other matters of purely ecclesiastical concern.^ I will raflier dwell on one side of his character which sets him before us as an unflinching assertor of the eternal principles of right. One act of Wulfstan's life, to which I He have already incidentally referred in an earlier volume,^ Rg»iiu«t the places him high among the apostles of humanity. Not- "l*^*"''"^'^* withstanding the repeated legislation of the days of -/Ethelred and Cnut, the Bristol slave-trade still went on. Indeed we may believe that, in the first years of the * I have given the speech of Wulfstan in the vigorous though somewhat free translation of Bishop Godwin in his Catalogue of Bishops. It ia curious to see bow, while he preserves the general sense, he translates some of the ideas as well as the words into those of the sixteenth century. But William of Malmesbury does not put exactly the same words into Wulfstan's mouth in his two works. In Gest, Pont. J83 they stand thus; " Ego longe aliter intelligo, quod nos miseri sanctorum opera dcstruimus, ut nobis laudem comparemus. Non noverat ilia felicium virorum setaa pompaticas ades construere, sed sub qualicunique tecto seipsos I)fo immolar« Hubjectosque ad exemplum attrahere. Nos e contra nitimur ut animarum negligentes accumulemu.s laj)i(le8." ' Vita Wist. 763. " Uxoratos presbyteros omnes uno convenit edicto, aut libidini aut ecclesiis renuntiandum pronuntiaiui." Wharton remarks on this that marriage was not forbidden to the parochial clergy till ili3, so that Wulfstan's severity in this respect must have applie«l Ut the canons only. But &» both the cathedral and the other great churches of the diocese were in the hands of the regulars, Wulfstan would have found no great ■cope for his energies in dealing with the canons only. ' See vol. i. p. 365 ; vol. ii. p. 153. The storj* is told by William of Malmesbury lH)th in the Life of Wulfstan, 358, and lees fully in the (iesta Rogum, tii. 269. VOL. IV. C C 386 THE BCCLE81A8TICAL BBTTLKMKNT OK KNCJLAM). cMAf. xii. Conquest, uhon mm Uowixl thoir noc\i» for nuftt in the evil djiVH,' Uio wiokinl tmflic in humnn i\vs\\ b4'(*anic more rife ihao eTer. Men, we are told, wont the length of uniting lutt, cruelty, And greed; they sold thoir fomule hIiivch when they were with ohild l»y thoniMolvos.-' Such n Ktate of tiling could in no way ^ivo strongth to William's throne or holp in any way to carry out the Hohomos of his policy. William thcri'fore wan as zealous apiinst the evil ])nictico as hi*« preilccitifionj. But the evil practice was too deeply rooted even for William's power.^ The saint of Worcester there- fore devoted himself to the pi-ood work of reclaiming' the men of the merchant horouj^h which then formed the furthest point of his diocese. llr ucnt repeatiHlly to Bristol ; he stayed there two or three months at a time, and preached every Sunday against the great sin of the place."* Tlie habit which had been too strong for Cnut and William gave way — at least for a season — to the exhortations of Rdanam- Wulfstan. The burghers of Bristol became convinced of b^tg^Mfft tlieginH thus; "On Drihtnes naman Hsflendis Cristes, is ^n^t Wulstan biscop on Drihtnes naman hw fS genidd wi6" his leofan geljnx^ra \>v him getreowu synd, for CmkIc and for worulile." Then follow the names of the AblK»ts, with the addition of " /Elf«tAn DccanuH on Wigraceautre," C C 2 SM THE ECCLEMAMUAL 8KTTLKMKNT nF KNOLAND. cBAT. in [mxt of tho Untlii of tho Al>lM'y from the rn]mciouH Unw*.* • On hin death, tho Ahl>cy won f^nint^Ml to n Nomian chnp- Waitor Uin of Lanfnuic, Walter, a monk tif Duko UoImtI'b houBo A b4»nl Kt( ,-^. •• •! jIMI' 'Alii Kv«Mh«m at Ccnty, who carrKHi on prcnt buihlinp* witli tin* money '®««"**'*^ which .l-'thehviji^ had patluTinl toj^»tlier,^ hut who IohI a larjjv part of the estates of his rhurs death late in William's rcif^n. He waa succeeded dM 1085. y^y ^jjp Norman Toustain or Tliurstan, a monk of Gloucester, 1085-1087. and was buried with all honour by the reig-ning" Norman ^•fl® , Abl>ot of that hou.sc.^' This was Scrlo, who succeeded to Abbot of ' OloaemUT. the Abbey on the death of his pre8tea fecit, et onines tres injuHte detinet." ' lb. 96. He was "literia tam liheralil)UH quara grammaticis undecum- que eruditiasimuH." On the Abbey of CeriHy, see vol. i. p. 529. ' lb. 97. " Maxime de pecunia quam Ageluuius abbas ad hoc opua reliquerat." ' II). * See above, p. 177. * Flor. Wig. 1085. "A venerabili Glawomensi abbate Serlone sepultus est honorifice.** ' Hiitt. Men, Glouc. i. 9. " Wilstanus Jerosolimam profectuB, obiit pere- grinuB anno Domini mille«imo septuageHimo Hccundo, {jraelationis suae decimo quarto, et anno regni Regis Edwardi filii Regis Egebredi, decimo septimo." Thin in a curious confusion of chronology. There can be no doubt that 107a is the right date, giving Wulfstan an incumbency of fourteen yean from his appointment in 1058, but the chronicler heedlessly lulded a regnal year which belongs to the pilgrimage of Ealdred in 1058- 1059. See vol. ii. pp. 436, 437. Serlo was at first a secular priest, a canon of Avrancbes ; he then became a monk of Saint Michael's Mount BOND BETWEEN WULFSTAN AND TlIK ABBcyTS. 389 Serlo fills a great [>\iu:e in the annals of his house, alike as ctiap. xix. the reformer of its discii)line and as the man who Wj>an HU the great miiistt-r which still remains. In the former^"™"' point, notwithstanding all the zeal of t^ldrtnl and the three \\ ulfstans/ Gloueester had sunk so slow that Serlo found in his monastery only two monks of full age and eight young noviees.- He is also described as recovering to his church some of the possessions of which it had heen de- frauded by Ealdred, and the local writer records with triumph the deep contrition with which Archbishop Thomas gave back the ill-gotten g:iins of his predecessor to their lawful owners. •' His architectural works rest on surer Uiu Kuil.l- evidcnce. After eleven years from its beginning, the GlouctMU-r. minster of Gloucester, or at least its eastern portions, the 'o^*/-"**- massive piers and arches now so strangely hidden by the net-work of a later age, stood ready for consecration in the last year of the eleventh century.^ Of the Abbots Death of beyond Wulfstan's diocese who signed the document, Abbot of Wulfwold of Chertsey is remarkable only for his ^*»ertoey. death being thought worthy of a record in the national ("monachua in ecclesiA Sancti Michaelis Monte TumbA;" see Max Miiller, Chips, iii. 351) ; then "quinto anno converaionis suae" he became Abbot of Gloucester. ' On the three Wulfstans who figure in Gloucester history during this centurj', see vol. ii. j). 669, ind ed. ' Hist. Mon. Gluuc. i. 10. " Ibi duos tantum perfectte tetaiis monachofl et circiter octavos juvenes parvoa inveniens." ' lb. II, 13. ** Ha,c acta sunt in prEeseiitiA douiini Serlonis Abbatis in capitido inonachoruin, niultis pnesentibus et gaudentibus." We hear how Thomas came, *' se ipsum ^Tavitc-r inculpando, pectus tundendo, genu flectendo, qui injuste eas [villas] tamdiu tenuerat." This is placoK KNCI.ANI). »«Ar iti. Chronicle*,' which however Icmvc lu to hml fnmi other •ourctw that he t4>o liiul n Nomian suoceasor, ()ot of that church before i\s union with the Biijhoprick of Somerset. •"* Frmillr Tlic iliKumcnt to which the names of these Pn-latcs are erf Vm^- Hubscrilxnl is chiefly intcrcHtin^" as showiny^ the friendly h»h an 1 it>lntions which existc-i. 209. * FI. Wig. 1088, " Normanni . . . diligebant eum [Wlstanum] valde," * It was to this Prelate, who reprovetet big willaS beon Gode gehyrsxime and heora bi8ce8Prfe." How does this apply to Chertsey ? Or doea it mean to the Bishop of the dioccHe, whoever he may be ? The passage seems to point to a tiuie when monasteries were just beginning to seek exemptions from epiHco|)aI jurisdiction. ^ lb. "And we willa^ urum woruld-hlafonle VVillehue cinincgo and Mahthilde J>a;re hla'fdian has vii. mynntnui syn an mynster, and beon swa hit her beforan awriten is ; (juasi cor unum et anima una." * lb. Besides smging masse.s, each Abl>ot was to wash, feed, and shoe one hundred poor men ; " And an C. [werfendra manna gobaJ5ige, and ^a fedan. and calk- J-a gescygean." Clothes are not spoken of, but shoe* are, a point to be noticed. * A list of these Councils is given in t\\v Latin Life of Lanfranc at- tached to the Winchester (now Canttrburj-) Chronicle. Thoy were held in the years 1071, 1074, 1075, 1076, 1078, 1081, 1086, at ditfervnt place*, Winchester, Gl(»uce«ter, and Lond«m. That is to say, thoy were hold at the same time as one of thu regular Gemots of the year. 99f THK IOOLB8IAflTICAL SBTTLKMENT oF KNni.AM). cmxt. &nu bc^nnnin^ roort« niul more to iMumo a purely (o nil dcoreos ha>palibuH amplius in hundret placita teneant ; nee caussam quae ad regimen animarum pertinet ad judicium ssecularium hominum adducant." * The writ ends, " quicumque secundum episcopales leges, de quacunque %'el cvljA interpellatus fuerit, ad locum quem ad hoc Episcopus ORIGIN OF ECCLESIASTICAL COUBTS. 393 prinning^ of those specially ecclesiastical tribunals whiclj, chap. xix. with lessened powers, have survived to our own day. The best that can be said for them is that, in the dark days of oppression, their claim to jud^» the causes, not only of ordained persons, but of all who bore any ecclesiastical character, and even of the poor, the fatherless, and the widow, did something" to place the most helpless part of the i>opulation under the rule of a milder jurisprudence than that of the courts of the Norman Kings and their officers. The ecclesiastical courts were thus one fVuit of the policy of William and Lanfranc. Another fruit was, not the Dintinction absolute beginning but the confirmation of the usag-e j^tical imd occasional in earlier times, of holdin^r a Convocation as ^"^l^^^J^f a distinct body from the Parliament. In one case we are Olouceaur. distinctly told that, after the King and his Witan had sat fost^'''^''* for five days, the Archbishop and his clergy sat for three days more.^ And it seems that, in this instance at least. Election of Bishops were chosen in the purely ecclesiastical assembly, ecclw^tT- thoug-h, as the choice in every case fell on the Kind's f*f a«»em- clerks, the King's will could not have been without its in- fluence. In several of these Councils one chief matter taken ivp^tion in hand was the deposition of English Abbots. In the very ^y ,. .^ first of these synods which is recorded, Wulfric, the newlv "f New chosen Abbot of the New Minster, was deposed to make 1071 or room for a successor whose name of Rhiwallon witnesses to °''' his birth in the lesser Britain. This assembly was held at Winchester. In another, held in London five years later,- ' cleRerit ot nominaverit, veniat, ibique de c&ubhA suk ivflpondeat ; et non Becunduni huiidret, sed secundum canoncs et t'i)iscopale« legea rectum Deo et EpiHcoj)o Huo fftciat." » Chron. Petrib. 1085. ' Apj». Cliron. Wint. " Octavo anno roniilium I»n c«'lcbr:ivit. in quo AiliKxIiim, CJhwHtiTigenHiH co»nohii Abl>at«n», de|>oHuit." Hut the din- cord between Tliuriitan and the monkH Ih plactnl in the PeterbortJUjrh Oironicle undrr 10S3, and Williiun of MahncHbury in hia Glaatoubury SM TIIR BCCLE8IAflTlCAL 8BTTLKMKNT oK RNOLAKI). cnkt. in. ifithcilnoth of (tlii»ton1>un', Willinm*H roin]innion on his v.s«lao(k f^j^ vovairv to Normnndy,' wan ttoi nuitlt* for n Norman • - ' 'I— lim ■ . itifT. tOOOeMor. In thin choice at leiutt Williiini and liunfrnnc * did not dinplay their uhuuI discn'tion. T\w new Ahhot, Aiipoiiii* Tluirutan hy name, mado himnelf menionil>le l>y ^-ivinjf IJT***^ ocoAsion to a Kx»al dlHturbancc, a minute account of which loSs. lum V)cen thoiij^lit worthy of a phice in the national Clironicles. His doinps ilhistrate the worst side, o^ tlic Leoj^ic of the Worcester Ahhnts ilhistrates the host side, of the etnini^Ts who were now set to rule over the Hicdb- churches of Kn^land. The monks, we are told, wen- in 5b« monk*, every way well disiK)seil towards him, and prayed liiin ^^* oft that he would deal j^ntly with them, as they were loyal and obedient to him."^ But the new Prelate, a monk of Lan franc's own house at Caen,^ despised the English brethren, and insisted on innovations in the service of the Church according^ to the newest fashions of Normandy. The monks of Glastonbury were called on to cast aside the immemorial Gregorian chants, and to adopt a new way of 6in«ifinpf which had been lately devised by one William of Fecamp.^ One day the monks were gathered Hwtory (330) pUce« the accession of Thurstan in 1082, without any men- tion of the (ieposition of ^thelnoth. It is hardly like the policy of Lanfranc to leave the Abbey vacant for five years. * See ftbove, p. 78. * Chron. Petrib. 10^3. " ^rest hit com of )>tes abbotes unwisdome, J>8et he miBbead his munecan on fela pingan, and ^a munecas hit msendon lufelice to him, and beadon hine }raet he sceolde healdan hi rihtlice and lufian hi, and hi woldon him beon holde and gehyrsume. Ac se abbot Dolde pet» naht, ac dyde heom yfele and beheot hcom wyrs." ' Will Malm. Ant. Glast. 330. ♦' Turstinus . . . quern Willelmus, ex Duce Normannia.' factus Rex Angliae, ex monacho Chadomensi Ab- baiem conslituit" So Florence, 1083. * lb. 331. •• Inter caetera etiam Gregorianuim cantum aspematus, mo- nachos compellere coepit ut, illo relicto, cujusdam \Vill6lmi Fiscanensis CMitum discerent et cantarent. Hoc aegre accipientcs, quippe qui jam tam in hoc quam in alio ecclesiastico oflBcio secundo [secundum?], Romanae •oclesift morem insenuerant, insuper mores ejusdem, tamquam alienigense TYRANNY OP TIirKSTAN OF OLASTONRURY. 895 toother in the chapter-house, ratluT, it woiiKl seem, to chap. xix. receive their Abbot's orders on this and other matters than for any purpose of fre*^ debate. Tlie monks were 8tublx>m ; the Abbot was fierce and threatening. At last he called for his Norman arehers, who presently entered the chapter- house all harnessed as if for battle.' What followed cannot The monka I nil -1 ^ I* i r \ -1 rm Willea niunecas full gewepnede." This story shows that they were archers, but in William of M.ilmesbury (Hist. Glast. 332) they become " milites et satellites sui phalerati." These are evidently the same persons of whom William sjHiaks in his very rhetorical account in Gest. Pont. 197, how the Abbot " terras et j>€cuni»fl m hcutontm suorum abusus consunipsit." " L«.'cator " = /crA^r, is j)lainly used as a mere Viigiie term of abuse, but it misled the writer of Hromton's Chronicle (973) into saying that Thurstan "res ecclesite hnocinaruio con- sumpit." Florence's description of Thurstan as hini.self anncd, and as doing much of the mischief with his own hands, is doubtless Ui be taken only in the sense that ** qui facit per alium facit |>er se." ' Chron. Petrib. 1083. " Ac reowlic hinp \nvr gelamp on dii«g." Com- pare the words in roH; jibout the death of William; "reowlic |»ing he dyde, and reowlicor him gelamp." ' Tb. " Sume «»f ham cnihtan." fsoi hni/jfitu in the H<^nH«^ of cheraliern, which, as we s»je under 10S6, would be " rider.xs," but moMt liki'ly the younger men of the party, jw Mr. Thorpe t4ikes it. * lb. " Upjmn hone uppflore," a most speaking doscriptiuii of a great S96 THE BCCLESIASTICAL SKTTLEMEXT OF ENOLANP. CHAT. sti. thot downwanln with iirnnvs towanlft tlio luilidom,' ho tliat on the rood that Htood above thr nltxir ntiirk <*n many arrows. And the wrt'tolxHl nionkn lay alM>ut the altar, and tome crept under it, and orietl with yi^minj^ to (i(>d, cmvinjf bin mildni*j«8,^ for that they rould ^1 no nnltliu'HH from men. What may we say, but that thry sh<»t sorrly, and that others brake down the doors there, and went in, and slew some of the monks to death, ond many wounded therein, so that the blood came from the altar ui>on thr grees and from the prees uj)on the floor.* Three wt're slain to death and eij^ht1^^ this formed no part of the schemes of ecclesiastical ^SSh^^ reformation desig-ned by AVilliam and Lanfranc. But the tUi«t«7. gtor}' shows how easily, in such a state of things?, a man of ungoverned temper placed in a position of authority Romiine8({Uu trif«»rium. William of MalmeHbury has "solaria inter colum- hm erecta," which would well describe the triforia at liomsey and Saint Frithswjth's, and in the far older church of Saint Martin at Angers. ' Chron. Petrih, 1083. " Toweanl ham haligdome ; " the sacrarium or prefcbvtery. * lb. ** Gyme cleopedon to Gode, hi» miltse biddende, ba ba hi ne mihton DAoe miltse act mannum ])egytan." Surely the Engliah tongue wan now »t the full height of iCk power. * lb. *' Swa J«t )>et blod com of ))am weofode uppon |)am gradan, and of b&m gradan on ham flore." For •' gmdan " I use the later fonn ** greeH," which BO oddly Hurvives in the " Orecian Stairs" at Lincoln. * William of Malmesbury (in the Glastonbury History) adds some mar- vellous details. One of the monks seized on the i^reat rood as a defence, and the bloody which in the Chronicle simply flows from the wounded monks, now flowi miraculously from the rood itself (" sed providente Deo, sagitta imaginem Dominicam in cruce defixatn subtus genua vulnerans, sanguinis ri^Tilum ex eadem produxit, qui de altari usque ad gradus de gralibus u»que ad terram descendens, ultionis divinae terrorem infaustis viris incutie- bat "). The actual sinner of course dies at once, and variouu degrees of pun- ishment light on hi." comnwles. None of these wonders are to be found in the Chronicles, or Florence, whom William to some extent copies, nor yet in William's own shorter accounts in the Gesta Kegum and Gesta Pon- tificum. Neither are they in the Winchester Annals, nor in Bromton, who follows Florence with some verbal changes, and who had the account in the Gesta Pontificum before him. HIS LATER CAREER. 397 could g-ive occasion to horrors which he himsolf perhaps chap. xix. as little really wislied for as his superiors. A forei«^ Prelate, with foreig-n soldiers at his command, might easily be hurried into deeds which could not have haj)i)ened either in the England iA' Kadward or in the Normandy of William. And if sucli measure was dealt out by churchmen to one another, we may g-uess what deeds were done in many a new-built donjon towards men who had not the jsame means as the monks of Glastonbury of handing- down their wail to posterity. As in most wars and revolutions, the greatest evils of the Norman Comjuest were not those which were done by the regular authority of the Con- ([ueror himself. The cruellest blows were those which were dealt by the more violent and base-minded among his followers, to whom a state of thing's for which he was responsible had given the {X)wer of working deeds of evil which even his mighty arm could not always redress. The upshot of this story is remarkable, as showing the difference between the Conqueror and his immediate suc- cessor. William heard the cause between the Abbot of Glastonbury and his monks. Neither side was pro- The Ab»>.>t nounced to be wholly guiltless, but the greater blame ftj^ijfj.^^. was declared to rest with the Abbot. Thurstan was \^}}*\*^ ^y removed from his office, and sent buck in disgrace to his cell at Caen. Of the monks, several were sent to other monasteries, to be kept under some degree of re- straint, the exact nature of which we are left to guess.' ' Will. Malm. Ant. filast. 331 (partly foUowirnf Florence). " Regi detnum Willelnn) primo (juerela super hoc clelatA, duiii niaxirna fiiisMo patuit AbbatiH culpa, ah eo un«le venerat redire coinpulsuH ent inj^lorius; de mnnachiH vero quaniplure« per epiMcopatu« et a])batiaH jusmu KegiH ciutiHlirmii diiiperLjuiitur." The WincheHter Annalist (10S3) uhch very ntronj? lan^'uagc ; "Ahhaa autoni, quasi in teHtiuioniuni inin»cuntiii« oxcuhwj caputio, quuiu diipiUH eiwet wl igno cremari vel nuftpendi patihulo, ad clauHtri Rui colutnnani C'adoini unde venerat, jutwu Rejipii reventUH ent." 398 TUB BCCLB8IA8TICAL SBTTLKMENT OF ENGLAND. nuir. kii. But M foon as the f^n^nt Kin^ \vni« dead, Thurntan, liy He UiT* |]|0 ii^lp of iiij kiiihfolk, nnd of tin* inoro im^vailinir HfueDoe of m l)nl>c of five humlriHl pouiuin of Kilvor, i: ' K ubtaintnl from AVillinm Hiifus hi« ri»8toration to tho olHco i»»y>i09a ^f ^vliieh ho had nliown himsi'lf so unworthy.* Another ^cat niona^itic house was also Fup]>liiHl hy Knnfmne with a ruliT in tlie y»'ar of the deposition of I Klholnoth. Frithric, who held tho AhWy of Saint Alhun . ... -it the time when King* William came into England, is a iU<. io-*r "^*** whoee history has become almost wholly mythical, lyrfrrmUry and the details of his story I shall therefore examine olse- hb h'irtorT ^^'^^"^•* ^^ ** certain that he still hold his Abbey at the io7i time of the Bettlement ol" tiu* disjiute between the two Archbishops.^ But five years later the Abbey had become vaK.-ant, and the way in which it was bestowed is every- TauI where spoken of as the Primate's own personal act. The AM-Tu P*"^*'*^ foundation of Offa was put under the rule of a Lunfrmnc. Xorman monk from Saint Stephen's, Paul by name, a near kinsman of his patron, and whom the scandal of the time • Will. Malm. Ant. Glaat. 332. ** Rege tAmeo mortuo, idem Turstinus, auxilio {)areDtum quorum, abbntiam GlaHtoniee a filio 8uo Willielmo dicto Rufo quingentiii libria argeuti dicitur redemisse, et monasterium aliquot annifl occupaiu et per ejusdem po88eK8ioneH pervagatus, longe ab ipso, ut dignuB erat, misere vitatn finivit." Thia in partly copied from Florence, who however says nothing ab<»ut the "auxilia parentuni." In the Gesta Pontificum (197) William adds the comment, "Impudens et infamis, qui, tanti sacrilegii consciuB, ausus sit it4,'ruin loco (juem violaverat intrudi." Notwithstanding all thia, in the Glastonbury HiHtory he windij up his ac- count by speaking ofThurstan's "fervor religionia, nonnulla pietas in Deo, multa providentia in 8%culo." The restoration of Thurstan must have been one of the first acta of William Rufiia, afl hia name in added to the (manuscript) grant of the town of Bath to IHhIiop John de Villula in 1090. Tlierc iH a letter from Lanfranc to ITiurHtan (Giles, i. 77). It is short and pithy, and chiefly consixts of advice to make his peace as fast as he can both with God and vvith the King. ' Set" Ap{>endix NN. • " Ego FridericuH Abbas Sancti AJbani consensi," occurs among the ngnatures. Will. Malm. iii. 298. 1077. PAUL ABBOT OP SAINT ALUAX^S. S99 afTirmed to be his tk»n.' IIo ruled as a great and ma^- chap. xix. niticent Prelate, reforming tlie discipline and increasing J*" |^*^ the revenues of his house,"- and raising that gigantic minster »>uii.ii: which, for size at least, if not for beauty, has remained the »o77-«o*^- wonder of all succeeding a^es. The ruins of ll^jman \'erulain had long formed a (juarry for the works of the neighbouring Abbey ; ^ and it was mainly out of bricks taken from that inexhaustible source that Paul, aided by the j)urse of Lanfrauc, reared the vastest and sternest temple of his age.^ His gifts to his house were bountiful,^ * Gest, Abb. S. Alb. i. 51. ** Paulu.s Abbas, natione Xeustor, c-oiiHan- guinitate ArchiepiHcopo Lanfranco propinquua (et, ut quidani autumant, filiu.s), monachurt fuit Cadomensis ecclediae. Hie ecclesiam Heati Albani suscepit regendani, procurante dicto Architpiscopo Lanfranco, qui eumdem Paulum filial! dilexit amore." Eadmer, Hiat. Nov. 8. " Quid refenun de abbatifi Sancti Albani, quam intu.s et extra ad nihihnn fere devolutam ipse, ut .suam, inatituto ei bonie memoriaj Paulo Abl)ute, a fundanientw readi- ficavit, et intua magiiA ruligione, foria multarum reruuj donatiune auxit, honeatavit, ditavit." Gervaae, Act. Pont. Cant. 1655. " Eccleaiani etiaiu Sancti ^Vlbani fjuani Rex Ine [Offa] fundaverat olim, reatauravit et ibidem monachoa in-stituit." So 1658. '* Priece{)it Rex ut .... abbatia Sancti Albani, quam Lanfrancua et anteceaaorea ejua babuerant, ad almlium Cantuarienais ecclesia' perpetuo jure traiLsiret." So tbe Worcester Annala under 1093 remark ; " Rex Willelmua concesait Anaelmo abbati;un .Sjincti Albani in alodium." On tbe po.s.silnlity of Lanfranc having been married before bis monaatic profeasion, aee Hook'a Arcbbi:>hop.s, ii. 80. Compare Lingard'a remarka on the wife and aon of Cardinal Campeggio, iv. 50S. ' See the detaibj in the Geata Abbatum, i. 53-60. ' The detaila of tbe atate of the ruina of Verulam in the Geata Abbatum, i. 24, 25, contain matter intereating to the getdogi.st and the comparative mythologiat. The pasaage with which we are concerned nma thus; " Tegulaa vero integraa, et lapidea (juoa invenit [Eiddrediia Abbaa] nptoa a, ri facultatea auppeterent, dirutd veteri eccleaii, novam conatrutre; propter (juod terrain in profunditate evcrtit ut lapifleaa structuraa inveniret." * Geat. Abb. i. 53. " Paulua Abbaa, t|uum jam Abbjia undecim annia exatitiaaet, infra eoadem annoa totam eccleaiam Sancti Albani, cum multiii aliia Ji-dificiia, opere conatruxit lateritio, Lanfranco efficacitor juvante ; qui, ut dicitur, millo marcaa ad fabricam contulit faciendam." ' The moat intereating among tluao gifts ia a collection of twenty-eight booka, all acfiningly eccloaiaatical (58). One wiahea to aeo tlu* " duo« textuH, aur<» et argento et gemmia f)matoa." 100 Tlir KCrT.eSIASTICAL SMTI.KMKNT OP KNOLAND. vMAf. til. ^rrt he diil not fiiil. nny mort' than Tlmrntan nt (ilaHtonlmry, to §how the insolonco of the I'ontjiHTinp rat*o tecially to rebuke him for omitting to translate the body of King OflQii to the new church. TTliifl is in direct contradiction to the legend of 0£Ek's burial in the Vita Offarum (Wats, ii. 32). • Ge«t. Abb. L 60. • lb. "Quidam de nobilibus Anglicis, hujus patrise partes inliabitans nemorosaa, Lyolf nuncupatus." 1 cannot find him in Domesday. * lb. 61. " Emit unam campanam, quam quum audlsHet suspensam in turn, tunc novam, sonare, jocose ait Anglico idiomate, ' Eja, quam dulce bUterant caprse meae et balant oves.' " * lb. " Uxor illico aliam adquisivit ; quae duae dulcissimam copulam reddiderunt. Quam quum audisset mulier, dixit, ' Non credo banc copu- ABBOTS OF WESTMINSTER. 401 In these cases the Primate was the chief mover, l>ut cii.vp. xix. instances are not lacking to show the personal, ami evi- f*«""n^ (lently conscientious, interest whicli William himself took NViiiiAiniu in ecclesiastical affairs. No church in the realm had tjcai hitrher claims on his reverence than the newly-reared '"*'**"*• minster of his lord and predecessor, where that lord and predecessor slei)t amid the reverence of both races, and where he himself had been chang-ed from a Duke into a King.' We have no record of the first avoidance of the Hintory of Abbey of Westminster, but we can hardly conceive that n,il^t«,r, Eadwine, the Abbot appointed lyy the sainted Kin«^ him- AbU)t self, was disturbed in his possession by his founder's kins- man anil successor. He probably died during* the first Geoffipey years ot \> illiam s reign, as the great award between the lo-j. two Primates bears the sig-nature of his Norman successor Geoffrey.- The next vacancy gave rise to a correspondence which does William honour. lie mused long as to the choice of a fit person to lill the office. At last, by the William advice of Lanfranc and the other chief men of his realm, vital, he pitched on Vital, a monk of Fecamp, who was the ^e'^JJ^j^' ° Abbot of his grandmother Judith's foundation of Bernay.^ '077 He liad raised that house from such lowly beginnings to so high an estate that the discerning eyes of the King and the Primate marked him out, notwithstanding his lurn favore cnrere divinu, qui me viro lueo legitiinn mntriumnio tt fuJen' Jilectionirt mutuie copulavit.' " ' William seta forth his own feelintc^ towanlH Wehtniin.stcr in \ns letter to Abbot John of F<5cftmp, of which I shall speak presently iu the passage (juote*! in vol. iii. p. 555. ' Will. Mahn. Gest. Regg. iii. 298. " Ego Gosfritlus Abbas coonobii Sancti Petri, ({uod non longe a LondoniA situm est, consensi." ' Chrun. Putrib. 1076. "On bifium geare . . . se cyng geaf West- mynster Vithele [Filwle, Wig, 1077] abbodo ; ho wrjh ir abbot on B«r- nege." He is spoken of byOrderic (491 D) a^ *' Berntticousium Abba«" iu the account of the endless disputes about his own monastery. See vol. ii. p. 234. On Vital's chronology, see Neustria Pia, 401 ; on Beruay, sec vol. i. p. 508. VOT,. IV. D d 401 TUB BCCLBSIA8TICAL 8ETTLKMENT OP ENGLAND. Abbot JobaoT '. sii. own unwillin^eM, a« the fitt4>«t nitin for the lii^hcr plnoe Hl»car> noir vacant in Kn^^land. On thin mnttor Iho Kin^: writes vitb to John, tho Italian Abbot of F<»(»anip/ tho civKniinHtical •U|icnor of the house of Bemfty, nnd tlu- nnswer of that Prelate, jfivinj'' his canonical Hamtion to thr wislios of the Kinjj, may paae as a model of a Htyle at once rcnjicctful and inde|>»Mident in adilressin^ a 8Ui>crior.'^ In wci^lun^ the mixixl character of William it would be utterly unfair not to let the ndation in which he stood to men like Lanfranc, John, aud Vital reckon for Komethinjj, even against those dark ])aftsap'8 of his history which I have already recorded and those darker passages still which I have yet to record. Willuuu'ii TOW to Saint MATttn. 1066. But besides acting the part of a nursing^father to tho churches which he found already existing* in the conquered land, the Conqueror had also to dischar^^e the vow which, in the ^reat crisis of his life, he had made on the height of Tclliam to the Apostle of the Gauls.^ If William was ' 8m voL iii. p. 100. • The connexion between Fecamp and Beniay apjtoars from the charter of Duke Richard the G<»od, io76. of luH promise by William Fa6er, the monk of Marmoutier, WiliiMn who, at the moment of his vow, ha»>. name of the Gaulish Apostle.^ The Fader accordin^^ly hastened to his home at Marmouticr, and thence brouofht four of his brethren to form the beginning's of the new society. Tliey looked at their new dwelliiig-place, but the site prescribed by the King's order ])leased them not. To men who had spent their days at Marmoutier, with the rocks above their heads and the mighty Loire at their feet, the hill of Senlac would offer but small attractions. The spot was high and bleak ; the hill was waterless ; ' Chron. de Bcllo, 6. " Per plurimum enira temporia ad municipiorum expugnationem atque ad rebellium subjugandam cervicoaitatem sollicitius aoimuin occupavit et virea." ' lb. 7, " Willelmo Fahro borum mentionern etudiosius inculcante." See Tol. iii. p. 458. ' rb. *• Eidem monacho, ut optaverat, Rex, quia ad manum habebatur, Ofwris fabricam committens, prspcei>it quatenus in antcfato coiigressumis loco, Accitii* secum sua; ecclesise aliquibua fratribiis, opjKjrtunum featinaret fundari monast^rium," FOUNDATION OF BATTLE ADHEY. 405 the nature of the grouml was iinsuitod to receive the vast chap. xix. and varied buildings of a great monastery.* They better likt'd a lower spot towards the western slope of the hill, a spot which, to men who had been themselves in the fig-ht, would be more sug-gestive of Norman mishap than of Norman victor)-.- There they actually be^n to build Th*y bojpn houses for their dwelling'-plaee, ' and they then sent to the anoihVr "" King, who had begun to take a lively interest in the ■*'**• work, prayings that tlio unfit site which he had chosen mig-ht be exchanged for one so far better suited for the puqiose.^ But the mind of the Conqueror, when once (ixed, was not easily turned. He was as little likely to William. I . f» 1 •! T 1 • • 1 Jiwwtn on g-ive up nis purpose ot building liis minster on the most the site of appropriate spot as to give up his struggle for his ^*' ^"'«- wife or for his Kingdom. The King was wroth at the request ; he again bade that his church should be built on no spot but that where he had won his crowning mercy. The high altar of the Abbey of Saint Martin Tla- high should stand nowhere but on the spot where the Standard site of the of the Fighting IVIan had been pitched on the day of ''^^'^'^''• Saint Calixtus.^ The monks, in their prosaic mood, pleaded * Chron. de liello, 7. " Qui memoratum belli locum considerantes, quum ad tarn insignem fabricam minus idoneum, ut videbatur, arbitrarentur." So soon after they complain " quod locus ille ubi ecclesiam fieri dccreverat, uti in colle situs, arenti gleba, siccus et aquarum foret indigus." ' lb, ** In huniiliori non procul loco, versus ejusdem coUis occidentalem pliigam, aptuni habitandi locum eligentes." This could not have been far from the spot where so many Nonuans were cut in pieces in an early stage of the battle. See vol. iii. p. 490. ' lb. " Ne nil (tperis agere viderentur, mansiuncula.s ([uasdam fabri- caverunt." * lb. We now hear of" Regis animus soUicitus de fabricic pmvectu." * lb. " Quod quum Rex percepisset, indignatus refugit, oi-iusque jusidt in efwlem loco cpio hostc pro.strato sibi eesserat tri»mq)huH biu«ilica: fund*- menta jaccre." So Will, Malm. Ge«t. Pont. 107. " Cu'nobium . . , Sancti Martini de Ik-llo, quoi, Angliam debellaverat, multa ibi et pretiosa (juum vivuH turn nu)ritunis delugans. Altare ecclesiie est in l«)CO ubi Haroldi pro patrin- caritato tH'cm cadaver oxanimc invuntum est." 406 TUB RCCLK8IAffriCAL 8ETTLKMKNT i»K KNcJLANl). CBAP. in. th» lack ofwrnto on tho hill. Willinin nnHwrrod niorrily that, if GotI gtivo him lonj; lifo enough, IIhto nhoiild be a rwidior flow of wine in his now house thau then* wm» of water in any othor nM>oy in Kn^^land.' Tlu'y pleaded the lock of huildinp-stone in the nri^-hbourhood. ^Villiam*0 answer wns prompt nnd practical ; whips were at once Bcni off to Caen to briii^ a.** much stone a« mifj^ht be needeat niynster wt |«ere Bataille." The fuller form, " Abbas Sancti Martini de loco lielli," appears in Domesday, 1 1 6, but it is commonly called in the Siu-vey "eccleum de Labatailge." Compare the church of Batalha in Portugal. Tlie verses of Rol)ert of Gloucester, ii. 368, must not be forgotten : — " Kyng Wyllam byjjojte hym ek of pe vole, \>Ai was verlore, And aslawe eke boru hym in batayle byuore. pere, as Jh; batayle was, an abbey he let rer© Of Seyn Martyn, vor her soules, J>at K*r aslawe were. And \>e monckes wel y nou feffede wy)H)uto fayle, f'at ys ycluped in Engelond, abbey of ))o batayle." * Chron. de Bello, 17. •'Homines ipsius villtu ob ejusdem loci par maxuuam excellentia; dignitatem, burgenses v(»cantur." The Chronicle goes on to dcHcrilie their customs. ' Six; vol. iii. p. 443. 408 THR KOCLKSIASTICAL HETThKMKVT nv KN(JL.SVn our iijL to the busy d^tt mtid mmiulii of the tomjMirn) and Hpiritunl life of the tkgt. We mii^ht winh that tho Hi>ot had for ever renuiintHl a wildemcHH, that no nijjn of man's hand, Mve 9omc moAsive stone, some Hini|)ly-Houl]>tun>ey that we find the *■••• most sjxaking witness that is left us of the ebb and flow of defeat and victory on the day of the great battle. The site of the Standard fixed the site of the high altar, and the site of the high altar fixed the site of the other buildings of the Abbey. Strangers from Marmoutier, to whom the place itself was a penance, would have no mind to fix their cloister and other buildings on the chilly northern side of the min.ster. And on the south, the nearness of the Standard to the slope of the hill gave but little room for the erection of the complicated group of buildings which surrounded the cloister of a great Benedictine house. The great dormitory, a building in its prt»sent state of a later age, was thus driven over the slope, and had to be borne aloft on the vastest and tallest of those underlying vaults with which the wisdom of ancient builders provided for health and safety.^ Those • Vaults of lhi« sort are couHtantly found under the main portions of moiUMtenM and other buildings, and they are constantly shown as cloisters, dormitorie«, an^'thing hxii what they are. One of the earliest and best that I know is tliat wiiich Hupp)ortH the hall of the episcopal palace at Angers, the prototype of that at Wells. SITE OF TIIK ABBEY. 409 vaults, gradually lesst'iiiii;^ in lu'i;,''lit with the ascent of chap. xix. the hill, mark a spot only le.»lrd<;e ,. ,, , of obedience to diocesan authority contained in the bond ofHuchex- • 11' ^l' Ti PI »i, I'll tinptiona. Samt \\ ultstau and the confederate Abbots was most likely not without a special meaning' at that particular time.- Iii the case of Battle, independence of the Bishoj) of the diocese was asserted from the very beginning.'^ In local belief, it had even formed part of the Duke's original vow upon the hill of Telham.* The warfare with the Bishops of Chichester forms a large part of the local history. It was the greatest of local triumphs when Stigand, the Prelate who moved the South-Saxon Bishoprick to its later site, had to forego his claim to summon the second Abbot ' See vol. iii. p. 485. * See above, p. 391. ' The story of the tlispute with the Bishop of Chichester is given in the Chronicon (\c Belle (25, a6). In the foundation charter the wonls run, " Sit li})era et quieta in perpetuuni de omni Hubjectione EpiscoiM>runi et quaninililx-'t personaruni tloniinatione, sicut eccleaia Chri.nti C'antuariie." In the other charter in the Monanticon, iii. 245, William is made to say, " Ita ut libera et quieta in perju'tuuni ub omni subjectione et domi- natione et querela Majori.s Monanterii et aliarum |)er»onaruni exiiotiono jiermaneat, sicut ecclesia Christi Cantuarienais, et sicut mea dominie* capella, et Hi^Tium Anj^dicai coron.e j»er (juam ego regno, et succeHsores mei lieges regnum Angliie debent obtinere." All this has a very suspicious sound, but the signatures are not im|)ossible, like those of the other charter. They are those of I»ot«'r Binhop of (.'h«\st oat)i(ilml churcli, **!5r** *'^^ hiniN-lf came to Battle and i>erfornuMl the ceremony befon* the hig'h altar of the prol»nl»ly t<'mj>nniry church of Jor^i M the monaster)'.* Hie hoiigc of Battle had also to defend ita inde|H»ndence a^inst another (*lniinant. The ehler hoiiw of Saint Martin aswrtinl the rij^htH of a parent (»vt»r oTBimW the youngt»r foundation. Btit William ]>rotccte(l his own iBPQi^, creation against the claims of the Abbot of Marmoutier, no less than against the claims of the Bishop of Chichester.* 'nie honw? whose in(lcj>endenee was thus carefully guarded agninst intruders from all quarters was richly endowed *^-''^"* - with lands and temporal rights, and the list of its early Um Abb«j. tenantfi and oflicers alfords a valuable study of the customs and nomenclature of the time. ' liMifnuic'i It would seem that Lanfranc by no means willingly ton»..nx^lic giivc m to a System by which episcopal authonty and the iKiiu!'^ common order of the Church were so thoroughly undcr- minctl, as when the Abbey of Battle was released from all onlinary jurisdiction on the part of the Bishop of Chichester. Charters of exemption were now constantly obtained by the monastic bodies. A few generations later the evil ' The story is told at length in the Chronicon dc Bello, 25, but the gist of it in found in the charter, Mon. Angl. iii. 245 ; " Primum Abbatem Ganiibertum in eodem mouasterio de Bello Stigaudus EpiHCopus Cices- treniiiii benedixit." ' .Sec Cbron. de Bello, 27, 28, where William in described aa waxing very fierce against the claims of Marmoutier; *' Quamobrem commotus Rex, omnes qui secom ademnt Majoris Mona«terii monxichos remittere prse- ccpit ; ipnique interminatus, * Per splendorem Dei * inquit (lioc enim as- Hueverat juramento), ' si hac de cjiuhh mare transieriH, aut illuc ulterius ierij<, in per{K:tuum Angliam, ad abbatise meee custodiara, non repedabis.' " * The liijt of names in given in Chronicon de Bello, 12-16. A few •re French, but far more are Engliah, Among the latter we may notice ".^EilricuB Child/' where Child can hardly be a title of honour. The names RuMellus and Herodes, in the same f>age, have an odd sound alongside of Goldwine, Eadwine, Siward, and other intelligible persons, " ^Ifuinus Abbat,** in p. 15, should also be noticed. EXEMPT MONASTERIES. 411 spread still further; the iiulependt'iice which had l)cen ob- chap. xix. taiiied by the reg-uhirs was envied and imitated by the seculars, and the authority of the Bishops be^^n to be specially set at nought in those churches which were specially their o\vn.* Each diocese was thus cut uj) into a group of distinct ecclesiastical jurisdictions, some of them subject to the authority of the Ordinary and others holding him at defiance. Ijanfranc, if a monk, was also a Bishop, and he seems to have done what he could to stop the innova- tion. He was severely taken to task by Pope Gregory for Dealingi abetting, or at least not restraining, Ilerfast, Bishop offrancj^^j Thetford, in certain acts which were looked on as breaches ^^.^'r^*^'. , with ^^alnt of the privileges of the house of Saint Eadmund.'- At a Eadmundji- * bury. later time we find him exhorting the same Prelate, among other precepts moral and ecclesiastical, to observe the privileges of that illustrious Abbey. ^^ But the tone of * Compare the disputes of Archbishops Baldwin and Hul^ert with the monks of Christ Church, so ^aphically told by Pn^fes-sor Stubba in the Preface to hid Epistobe Cantuarienses, and the long controversy between Robert Grosseteste and his refractory Chapter of Lincoln, which will be found in Dr. Shirley's edition of his Letters, ^ Epp. Lanfr. 23 (Giles, i. 44). " Non minima adniiratione dignum ducimus qud fronte, qu^ mente, Arfastum dictum Episcopum sanctse RomansB Ecclesiie illudere et beatie meniori;e ^Vlexamlrum pnedecesaorem nostrum, ejusque decreta contemnero j)atiamini . . . fratemitatem vestram confidenter d»;precamur, ut via nostr^ Arfaati nugas penitus com|)e8catis, et Sancti Edmundi Abbatem contra decretum decessons nostri inc^uietari nuUo modo sinatis." Still more curious is the way in which Gregory speaks of the King ; *' Guiliehnum Kegt- m, carissiniuni et unicum filium sanctaa Komanie Ecclesiie, precibus nostris et vi& nostrA super his adinonero dilectioncm vestram precaniur, et ne Arfa^iti vanis persu.'isiunibus acquiescat, in quo sua singulis prudeutia supra modum diminuta et contracta ab om- nibus cognoscitur." ' Ejt[). Lanfr. 26 (Giles, i. 47). " PostjKJsitis aleis, ut majora taccam, ludisque SiL'Cularibus, rjuibus per totam diem vacare diceris, divina^ littoras lege, docretisijue K«»manonmi I'outiticum sacrisque caiiunibus pnecipuo studium im|>ende." This letter is headed " Laufrancus lierol)erto," but an Herbert I^jsinga did not become Pisliop till 1091, I have no doubt, with Dean Hook (ii. 154), that tlu; letter wa^ really addressed to Hc'rfai«t. The letters of Lanfranc contain otiicr ruferencen to the affairs of the Abbey, and especially t*y Abbot Baldwin's skill in medicine. (See Epp. 10, ai, 2 J, ami 112 THE KOCLK^IASTKaL >UTTLKMRNT <»F KN(JLANI). itAr xtx. Laofninc is mnArkuMo ; ho dooti not at all tnko up the bil^ line of (»n»f»^)n'; he nimply exhortu Ilorfiist to con- form fttrictly to the existing Ijnw, and to ninkc no clniniH over the monantery which were not juHtifie- rity. The Abl)ey of Saint Augustine was one of those prent monai^teries in or close to episcopal cities which seem to liave l)cen desi^-ned as special thorns in the side of flw diocesan. Tlic writers of the house asscrtcnl that il had enjoyed the fullest exemption from all external jurisdiction Hi»alleg«l from the xory he^inninfi^ of thinj^s." They cliar<»"e Lanfraiic the pritj. with havinti; obtained from the Norman Abbot Scotland lo^oftbe |>once8sions which destroyed the ancient indcj)cndcncc of loss. the monaster}'.'^ On the death of Scotland, which did not hap}x;Q till afU'r the death of the Conqueror, the Primate vol. u. pp. 446, 585, 7nd ed.) We niuHt also remember that Herfast wan an old nccjiiaintance of Lanfranc (see vol. iii. p. 1 04). lialdwin, iJter all, Vas a Frenchman. 1 know not how I came to over- look the deceive paasage in Florence (1097), " Baldwinus, geiiere Gallm*, mrtiM medicina' bene jK-ritus." He ia there called ** eximijc vir religionis." ' Epj». Lanfr. 26 (Giles, i. 47). "Ad pnesens praecipio tibi ne in his rebus Sancti Edmundi aliquid appetas, nisi id ab antecessoribus tuis appetitum fuisse certis documentis ostendas." ' W. Thorn, X Scriptt. 1790. "A tempore enirn ])eati Papae Grcgorii ac sancti patris Auguutini .... ha;c illius Kummae matriH eccleMianim upecialis filla et spiritualis alumna regni Anglorum coenobiali dignitate et mooachili religione primaria gratiii omnipotcntis Dei, qui libertate vult fiUoa BUf*H frui et non ut fiat cum servis tributarii, ac sanctione sancti patru Gregorii ca;terorumque Romanorum pontiBcum necnon beati Augus- tini, omnique ecclesia^ticA pace honore ac libertate usa est, nee ullus unquam pnesulum sive alia persona earn inquictare ausa est." * lb. 1 791. " Lanfrancus . . . hanc eccle.siam apostolicam persequi incepit, et dominium quotl super earn juste habere non potuit, ut aliquo modo obtineret i>er se et suos complices machinari non destitit. Hie ergo postquani aliquot annis dignitate archiepiKcoj)ali fimctus est, Abbatera SootlaDdum quasi in magnee amicitis familiaritatem, sibi in dolo associavit, ut sub umbra hujus mutuie dilectionis quod ssepius optabat celerius adipijic«;reiur. Erant autem quapi comj>atriotap," &c. LANFRANC AT SAIXT AUGL'STIN'E S. 413 went still further. lie gtive the ahbatial Ixjiiediction to chap. xix. a certain Guv, who must liave been nominated either by }:" "ff".^ •' (tuyAbhol. himself <»r by the new Kin^.^ He then went to Saint io«.m. Au«^ustine"'s, stren«j;'thene(l by the seeuhir arm in the person of Odo, Bishop and Earl,*- and reave in and submitted to Guy as their Abbot. '' But on those who Punmh- resisted the hand of the Primate was heavy. /Klfuine the ivfracu>ry Prior and others were condemned to terms of imprisonment '"''"'"'• of different degrees of length and severity/^ and one, who * Chron. Wint. App. " Widonem ecclesiae Sancti Augustini Abbatem . . Cantuaria' in sede metroj)oli examiiiavit aUjue sacravit." ' lb. " Associate sibi Odoue Baiocensi Episjcopo, fratru Kegis, (jui tunc Cantuariam venerat." ' lb. " Venit itaque Lanfrancus, adduceas Abbatem, et quiun monachoa pertinaciter videret resi«tere, nee ei velle parere . . . Laufrancu.s cum 8ui« Abbatem honorifice introductum in seile Iwion of the F'fll<»wn of Magdalen Collegi' in 1687. Macaulay, ii. 299. It doen not appear whether the dinner-hour, whieh haa before now influenced parliamentary divisions, haot, wiw ])iil>li(*ly •ooarged and ex|>ollo(l fnmi the city. Thin mnn 1>on* tho Scott iiih name of Coliimlmn, ami the only other jiereon mentioneil hy namo, lH»Hiih»H the Prior il'ilfwino, in an En^ish ^Hfred.^ This certainly looks as if national as ilMak- ^<^I1 ** eoeleeiastical jealousies had something to do with lurttMMv. ^1^^ matter.* And it looks the more so as, when the di8|>iite bj^ *" went on after the death of Lanfninc, the monks in tlieir ^J*"^*' attacks on the Abbot were viLToruusly su])ported by the bofy. men of the oity.^ 1089. Tlic mention of the various monastic houseB, some of which were deeply interested in tho scries of Councils held by Lanfranc, has led me away from the succession Deorw of the Councils themselves. In one of them, held nine reooral years after William's first entry into En^rland, a measure "T?—''*' was taken which has had an important influence on the '075« later history of the English Church, and which is still more imjwrtant as an illustration of its earlier state. This was the decree by virtue of which several of the Bishopricks of Eng-land were removed from their former seats, which in some cases were small and insignificant places, to cities of greater importance. This was a decree which could hardly have been needed in Gaul, Spain, or oepit LanfrancuH, et per ecclesiaa Anglise diviait, constrinxit, donee eoa obedientiam pnjfiteri coegit." ' Chron. Wint. App. *' ^luredum, unum ex illis, vagantem fiigiendo oepit, et Cantuariae in Rc-de metropoli, cum quibundain sociis illius, qui Abbati nullum nioliti sunt, ferro compeditoH, multis dicbuH rigorem ordinis in cUustro di«C€re fecit." The affair of Coluraban hap}>ened the next year. His punifihineDt '\h ihxia dcncribed ; " Pnccepit ita^jue LanfrancuH ut ante portAS beati AugUKtini, spectante popido, ligaretur nudua, flagellia afficere- tur, deinde, prsfccino caj)itio, ab urbe pelleretur." ' Se« Ilfxjk, ArchbiijhopB, ii. 159. • The »itory is given at length in the Winchester Appendix. The Abbot wan nearly killed ; the refractory monks were scourged ; as for the citizens, "civea, qui Abbatia curiam armatA roanu intraverant, capti; et qui ae ab ejua impugnatione purgare non {K)terant oculos amiserunt." ENGLISH AND CONTINENTAL BISHOPRICKS. 415 Italy, and it points to a distinct iun hot ween the ecclesi- chap. xix. astical condition of En»rlanil and that of continental ^""^'■•<* countries which g-oes back to the earliest days of Chris- Knkriidh tianity in each. As usual, dillerences m ecclesiastical tinci.ui arrangements were owing to dillerences in social and ^V^^^^l'^y- political condition. When Christianity was first preached ints to the dif- ference in the condition of the Teutonic and the Roiuanizev ii luiui Itoyond the limits of * the Knipiro, iU prwioluTs ha the cities dominant, and in both the i>oclc8ia8tical arrangements adaiittHl them- selves to this fact.' The Bisho|> did not l)ec<)me, in the almost exclusive senne in which ht> did in the Ro- manized lands, the Bishop of the city; in some dioccKc>s lit tribal there was hardly anything to be called a city at all. The iurial duk- extent of the Bishop's jurisdiction was marked out by the ncicr. extent of the temporal jurisdiction of some King ur Kal- dorman, hut, like the King or Eiddorman, he was essen- tially the Bishop, not of a city, but of a district or rather Fffmrnptl of a tribe. Hence, both in England and in other parts frum tribe* of the British Islands, the titles of Bishops were for a long ordartrict*. Hjjqq more commonly territorial or tribal than local, and in the case of some of the Celtic Bishopricks the territorial style is kept on to this day.^ The Bishop had indeed his see, his Biahopstool^ his ordinary dwelling, in some par- ticular church of his diocese. This was his cathedral church, the church which was specially his own, where Ei^Uih he was surrounded by the monks or canons who were his 2^y« immediate companions and fellow-workers. But this his Pjjl^.i? special home was not always placed in the greatest town oonaiBied chiefly in their union. Several churches, as Toulouse, Alby, and PanH, have also been at different times raised from diocesan to metro- politan rank. ' Far be it from me to plunge into the mysteries of early Celtic ecclesi- •(Rtical biHtory, Coarbs, Lay Abbots, and what not. I speak of the Irihli and 8cf>ttuih Bishopricks as they appeared when they had assumed an intelligible territorial shape. ' It is so with the Bishopricks of Meath, Ossory, Galloway, Ross, Argyll, the lales, Caithness, and Sodor and Man. The Scandinavian Bishoprick of Ori^oey follows the same rule. See Appendix M. in the second edition of mj Moond volume. l:i:Mt>VAL OP BISIloriClCKS. 417 in his diocese. In some cast's, as at Saint David's and chap. xix. Lindisfarn, the seat of the Bishupriek seems to have been desi«^nedly placed in an inaccessible spot, us if it were ratlier meant to be the place of the past<3r*s occasional retreat from his more active duties than to be the constant centre of them. Tliis state of thin<^ went on at least till the end of the tenth century. Then it was that the see TmoHlA- of Saint Cuthberht was translated to what siH»edily Ixrame .n^f^ri, ^ the city and fortress of Durham.^ But Ealdlum created ^'"f''^^- 111 -1 1 , • t , , *>'>'5- churcli ana city by a smgle act, and ins probable motive was the greater safety of the site which he chose. The systematic removal of Bishopricks from smaller towns to greater belongs to a later time. This peculiar position of the English Bishops was no Rcjrinning doubt reckoned in foreign eyes among those errors of ^*,„,j,!r the barbarous islanders which it was the mission of William ^^**'^*- to reform. The beginning of change, in this respect as in most others, showed itself in the days of Eadward. The >>«*; of same feeling which shows itself in the decree of Lanfranc's 1050. Council shows itself also in Leofric's translation of the united sees of Devonshire and Cornwall to the great city of Exeter.- We can hardly doubt that this change, as Motive of well as the changes which Leofric made in the internal constitution of his church, was prompted by his Lothar- inirian education. Under William and his successor a long series of changes of the same kind were made. In Council of a Council held at Saint Paul's in London, =^ it was ordered, ,q-^ with tilt' King's sanction, that episcopal sees should be removed from vilhijres or small towns to cities."* Three t-> ' Rec vol. i. p. 321. • Stt; vi>l. ii. p. 83. ' Will, M;ilm. Gext. Pont. 66. All tho BiMhops of En^'hmd wciv pre- sent, save Walcher of Durham, who had a canonical excuse for absence. Rochester wjw vacant. * lb. 67. •* Ex (JccrutiH sunimonnn pontificuni Damnni et Leonis. necnon ex conciliia Sjinlicensi et LaodiccnHi, in (juiluiH prohilntur episcopales mdcH in villis exsistere, couccsmuui est rcgia muniftcentiii et synuihili auctorilat*' VOL. IV. K e 418 TflK Uiht^siAMi, Ai, HKTTI.KMKNT OK ENOLAND. niAr in Hi»h(>pnrkii wcn> nt once rpmovotl !»y virtiio of tluH dcvrco. II %. n i^j,» lii^thurini^nn HiTmnnn, who lm Sht'r)K>riu» aiul Hamfibun', now followed the example of {, , "' liei»frie, and reinovwl the sent of the united dioeese to 1074^078. ^jjj» hill-fortrewj of the elder Salisbury.' The choice of such a position wa* stnmfje, nnef»^n vifj'orously to build a 1078. church on the unpromisinpf spot wliirh he had chosen ; hut he only bejifan. and he left his work to be finished by Ownund his succt»s8or, the famous O-smund, a name renowned in S^Ubury. liturg^ical history. ^ At the same time Stig-and of Selsey 107s- 1099. rt»nioved the scat of the South-Saxon Bishoprick from rvmnrM thc sitc wliich yEthclwcalh liad LTanted to AVilfrith » febT^to ^^ ^^^ town, once the Roman Re^num, winch had taken C'hicbc«t«r. the name of one of the earliest Saxon conquerors in History Britain. Cissa the son of JEWc, one of the destroyers ^^^J*** of Anderida,* had g-iven his name to Cissanceaster or Chiche«ter. Chichester, a city which has retained its episcopal rank ever since the days of Stig-and. Here again the choice seems strange, at least if the central position of the city episcojiw de villifl transiro ad civitates, Herimanno de Sirabumd ad Seris- beriain, Stigando do Selengeo ad Cicestrum, Petro de Licitfelde ad Ces- trum." Florence rnuHt be miHtaken when (1070) he makes the removal of the 8ee to Salisbury happen before the consecration of Lanfranc. * See vol. i. p. 349 ; vol, ii. p. 406. ' Ann. Wav. 1217. " Ricardus . . . . cujiw consilio et auxilio nova eccle«ia Saresberia; novo in loco incepta est, ecclesiA veteri infra castelli ma'nia sitd priuB efl5^ct& aUjue subniotSL." Kicliard became Binhop of Salij^burv- in 1217. The actual building; of the church began in 1 231 ; see the TewkcHbury Annals in anno. ' Will. Malm. Oest. Pont. 183. lie goes on U> Kpcak of thc excellent state of the church of SaliHbury during the administration of Osmund. UennAnn's death is recorded in the Chronicles under the year 1078, with the description >^hich I quoted in vol. ii. p. 406. • Beda, Hi»t. Ecclea. iv. 13. ' See vol. iii. p. 402. SALISBURY, CHICIIESTKR, AND CHESTEH. 419 was to be at all thou<>ht of as well as its size.' The chap. xix. third see which was forsaken was that of Lichfield, the ??*.**/ . . Lachneld. seat of the holy Ccadda. To nKKlern eyes few episcopal sites in England are more attractive than that where, after all the havoc wrong-ht hy war and barbarism, the three spires still rise in all their grace above the silver pool at their feet. But few places were further removed than Lichfield from the continental ideal of an epi- scopal city. 2 Instead of the church crowning* the highest point of a great city like Bonrges or Le Mans, a small town had gjithered itself outside the episcopal precinct, as it had gathered itself outside the monastic precinct at Crowland and Evesham. Such a site was at once con- Pf^*" J 111- r»i 1 -r»T-i'i /» l^i^bop of demned, and by virtue of the new decree, Peter Bishop of Lichfield, Lichfield moved his dwelling-place to AVilliam's last con- removl^ ^ quest of Chester, and placed his throne in the minster of *'•*" **«*^ ^ . . . ^""t Saint John without the walls of the city.^ But this change ^<>hn'>^ at was not a lasting one ; the next Bishop, Robert of Limesey, * Will. Miilm. Gest. Pont. 205. " Sti«,'ano no doubt liowever that th<; churuh meant is that ttf Saint .John ; se«« above, p. 314. I gather from I^anfranc's letter to Pope Alexander (Giles, i. J 2) that Peter's English predccesj^or Lcofwine was excommunicated for being married and for refusing to appear at a Synod, and that ho then resigne*! his Hishoprick, But there is no distinct mention <>f this either in the Gesta Pontificum or in the local Historj'. E e 2 420 THE y lASTICAI. 8RTT1.KMF.NT OK KNOLANP. o«Ar III apiin n»iiiovi«ry Cbi«i.ir/. 1^ jjj^ High»»prirk.* We Irani, on tho evidence of tlic fib fmf^* dow dNiJ- Primate himsi'lf, that the way in wliieh Robert took pos- in|,*« »tth g^»^j^^„ partook htrongflv of the nature of a raitl or a «»' ' ht*rm. Lanfrane, wlio kept up u diligent correspondence Mo br«- ^"^^'* *"** sufTraj^ns nnd reljuked them sliarply on oeca- ».uk**l l.y gion^ rehukcB U<»hert with Hi>ecial sluirj)ne88, not only for his irn»verent treatment of his own metro|)olitan h-tterH,' hut also for his dealini^ with the monks of Coventry. He luid entered tlieir dormitory h}- force ; he had broken open their cl)e>t<, taken away their horses and otlier ]>roperty, j'uUed down their liouses and carried oiT the materials to his manors, and lastly, quartered himself and his following^ on the monastery for eight days.' CoTcntrr Restitution is ordered; yet Coventry remained the head charvh of chureh of the diocese,*^ and in the course of the next thediocrtc. ^ij^jjj.^. Chester seems to have been well niyh forgotten Coventry 88 an episcopal sec. The churches of Coventry and Lich- 6eld *^ ' ^^^^ ^'OTc now acknowledged as joint seats of the Bishop- ' Will. Malm. Ge«t. Pont. 309. "At vero succcBRor ejus llotbertus iterum bcdeni in Coventreiain migravit." bee vol. ii. pp. 414, 415. He ^oe« on to Bpc&k of the Hplendour and wealth of the monastery. • lb, 310. "Hoc Rotbertus inliians ex ip.sis eccleaiae gazis accepit, unde Begia occupationes falleret, unde Komanoruni aviditati irrcperet." • Epp. Lanfr. 31 (Giles, i. 51). "Littcraa ante paucos dies tibi transmiHi, et eau vix HUi4cepta.s legcre desprxisti, et cum magna indignatione, sicut mihi dictum est, super quoddam sedile eaa projecisti." • lb. •• Cl&morem fecerunt ad me tam abbas quaro monachi ejus, quod dormitorium eorum per vim introisti, areas eorum fre;;i8ti, et cquos et oronen prr>priet;iteB quaa habebant rapuisti. Insuper domos eorum destruxisti, et materia^ earum ad tuas villas asportari prsecepisti. In ipso quoque cuenobio cum famili4 tuS, consumen^ bona monachorum, octo dierum nioram fcci.Hti." Compare also the account of his doings given by William of MalmeHbury, Gest. Pont. .^lO. • See the letter of Bishop Rowland Lee to Lord Cromwell praying for the preservation of the church of Coventry, Mon. Angl. iii. 199. COVENTRY, LINCOLN, AND TIIETKOKD. 421 rick o( north-western MtiTia ' The dissohitiun of the ui\t. xix. monasteries swept away Coventry ; nuxlern arran«rcmfnt» '^"rp'^* have even removed the city into another diocese, and the <«»ventry. old home of Ccadda is now airain, as it was in the earliest ' times, the only S4.'at of his successors. But tliese three chang-es, made by the immediate orders 7s,6. of the Council of Ix)ndon, were not the only changes of the kind which were made durin<»; this reign and the following one. First of all, Uemigius, the monk of Fecamp, Remigiu* the Prelate of Dorchester, the man of small stature hut of .r*"****^ ' tnt' Hte of lofty soul,- removed the seat of his episcopal rule to the I >•'"•'«"*«'' ''...., ' * to Lincoln, lordliest spot within his diocese. He forsook the old home 10S5. of Birinus by the winding Thames, guarded by its Roman dykes and looking uj) at the mighty hill fort of Sinodun. He placed his church and throne among yet prouder relies of early times,^ side }>y side with the castle which was ah'eady rising to curb the haughty burghers of wealthy and famous Lincoln. Herfast of Elmham too translated the see H-rfast ♦ l*3\Il sill ^^11 of the East- Angles to Thetford, the town so famous and so the see of unlucky in the Danish wars.* His next successor but one, l:!'"*!:^'^ ^^ the famous Herbert, who has left behind him so mixed a 1078. * Lichfield was not wholly forgotten even under RoU-rt of Limcsey, who (Will. Malm. Gest. Pont. 311) " niagnanim apuil Licetfelil itiliticationum iiiclioator cx.stitit." So we rwul in the loc;il iri.>t(»ry (Ang. Siic. i. 443) of the great things done at Lichfield in the next ajje by Roger of Clinton, BIhIioji from 1 1 28 to 1148. Front the election of hi« succes-xor, Walter Durdent, the agreement or di.sagreeuient of the Canons of LichHehi and monks of Coventry in the election of the Bishop is carefully note*!, without any mention of the Canons of Chester. Nor mu.st wc forgot the momentary Hubstitution of Can(»n8 for mcnkti at Coventry by Bi.shop Hui,'h Nonant in 1 190, a subject on which Uichard of the Devizes ^65, 66) is very elo»|iient. See also Ang. Sac. i. 436. ' Will. Malm. Cicst. Pont 313. " C^uod «•<. j..< un.lius enit. (|viia ipse pro exiguiUite coqxtris peno |H)rtentum homiuis vi«lebatur. LucUkbatur excullere et foris eminerc animus, eniUjue Gnitior c.xiguo veniens e corpore virtus ; fjnem ideo natiira coiripegiMse putantnr. tit sciretur betttissimum ingr- niiini in miserrimo corixwi' h.il.iturc poH.ie." ' See aljove, p. an. ' Sie >,,!. i. pp. ^51, 380. lii THE BCCLK8IA8TICAL 8ETTLEMKNT OK RNULAND. CBAT. SIS. charaotor ami ho ninbi^uous a surnnnie,* rtMiiovod it yet tr*L acain. He rho»<» nn hit* ilwrllinj^ the E«Htorii rival of LoiSp KxotiT and Liiux)ln, aiul ntisinl tht* ridi and populous iiiyl'lKmi Non%*icli to tho rank of a city.^ I>ji8tly, but not (ill Jr^^Sj.*" ^*-* ^''^'**^ \N illiani was no more, another foreij^n IVelate HOI. was found to undo the work of Ciisn in tlie Hislioprick of Jaho of Sonien»ct. John, a K'arnotl pluKiciun from Tours,^ was tho [1088- 8Uccc88or of the reforniini; Lotliarin^^an. He, like Peter ''"i at Lichfield, despised his little city at the foot of Mendip. U»»»» He swept awav the works of his prcilecessor, and left the nfWvlUto ^ . . * . . . lUth. Canons of \\ ells in the poverty from which his predecessor had raised them. He then moved his throne to the Abbey of Saint Peter at Bath ; the line of independent Abbots was merged in that of the Bishops ; and John himself ruled alike as si)iritual and temporal lord in the old Roman town which had beheld the crowning of Eadgar the Peaceful. * CoQDcil at In another Council held at Winchester, in the year ler. April following that which decreed the translation of the Bishop- '■*» *°7 ricks, a variety of canons were passed, some of which must be taken in connexion with the great ecclesiastical move- ment which was going on throughout Europe. We must never forget that, while Lanfranc ruled at Canterbury, ' William of Malmesbury here uses nearly the same words in the GcHta ^^•8^*™ ('^'- 338) ft"tl in the Gesta Pont. (151) ; *' HerbertuH, cognoinento Losing quod ei ars adulationis inipegerat, ex abbate Ramebiensi emit epi- •oopatum TlietfordenBera ; patre quoque suo Roberto, ejusdem cognominis, in abbatiam Wintoniae intruHo." I do not see how this Robert can be tlie •ame as " Robertus Lotharingus " (Gest. Pont. 300), " venerandus vir Robertiu" (Fl. Wig. 1079), ^^*^ great friend of Saint Wulfatan, who became Bishop of Hereford in 1079. ^^^ above, p. 379. • After going to Rome, and getting his Htaff restored, " doraum reverHUH, •edem episcopalem transportavit ad insignem mercimoniis et populorum frcquentia vicum, nomine Norwic." (Gest. Reg. iv. 338; Gest. Pont. 151.) On Norwich, »ee above, p. 67. ' On John of Tours, see Gest. Pont. 194; Historiola, 22. I liave qwken more fully of Bath and Wells matters in my History of the Church of Wella, p. 35 et al. • See voL L p. 68. BEION OF IllLDKBKANI). 423 Ilildt'braiul ruled at Rome. We shall |iresfiitly kco that, chap. xix. in some most imTK)rtant i)oints, the Primate ot all Britain J^- ' »i>"nji liad fallen away from that ri<»'id standard of |)orfection in I^nfranc Roman eyes wliich had l)een reached hy the monk of BecJ brand/ Still the ecclesiastical lej^islation of Lanfranc is the lef^is- lation of Hildebrand, only slightly OKxlified and with a little of its overbearing'' harshness softened down. The two main Obj.»ct« of objects of the great Pope, two objects which in his idea hr»nJ. could hardly be kept asunder, were the subjection of the civil to the ecclesiastical iK)wer, and the establishment of the clergy as a distinct order, animatetl by one universal corporate spirit, and cut off from those ties of citizenship and kindred which bind men together in earthly bonds. The great means to this end was absolutely to forbid Iv.hibiUon , «)f the marriage to the clergy of every grade. An exaggerated nmmage reverence for virginity had been growing up in the Church ^.jjjl from the beginning, and it reached its full height when Eadward was deemed a saint for his real or supposetl breach of his first duty as a King. This feeling fell in with the politic views of Gregory. In a Council held at Rome two Decrees of years before the time which we have reached in our „, jj,,,,,^ En«:lish narrative, the marriage of the clergfy was forbidden ' ^'^'^*" 9. o ' » oj lo, 1074. more strongly than it had ever been forbidden before ; married priests were commanded to separate from their wives, and the laity were warned that the sacraments lost their effect when administered by the hands of men who trausirressed this new and stern commandment.^ T\\e "CJ* * See below, p. 434. ' So it would appear from the theolojjical argument of Sigel>erht (in anno, Pertz, iii. 362). He gives the decree of the Syu»>d thus; " (iregoriu* I'apa celebrata Hynodo HJuioiiiacoH anutheuiatizavit, et uxoratoM Racenlotca a divino officio reinovit, et laiciH miHsani e«>rura audire interdixit." He adds, that thin wafl *' novo oxemplo et, ut nndtis visum egt, inconHiderato prxjudicio contra Manctoruni patrum Hentenliam," ami goeu on to arj;ue tliat the unworthinoHH of uiiniHterM hinderoth not the effect of the Kacramonta. He in followed hy Roger of Wendover (ii. 13) luid l>y Matthew PariH 424 TUB BCVLKSlAJrrirAI. 8BTTLEMKNT OK ENGLAND. cMAf. Its. Bni^uih Council re-fiiaot*"*! the nrtH «>!' tlint nf Home in ft irtoumer coMidcniMy inililrr shniH'. In Kn^land and in other tmnimgm Trtitonic UnclH, no Iohk than in the Chtirchos of the East, taimftanil ji^^, hnhit of cleriejil marriaf»x» had taken far too deep root to l>o pot rid of ill a nicnunt. Lanfranc wt to w(»rk DMMlkM warily. lie drew u distinction which was nftorwanls |..pft.^ drawn a^in in a modified sliajie in tlie days of Queen !!^1!!a!ui EH7Jil»eth. The parochial and tlie coUeg-iatc clergy were •»<* not tronted exactly accordinij to the same measure. The dOTgy. Canons of cathedral and other capitular churches were firet dealt with. Of* the preyalence of marria^-e amonf^ this class we have already seen several instances.* The practice was of course the greatest of all obstacles in the way of those reformin"^ Bishops who soug'ht, sometimes to replace their Canons hy actual monks, sometimes to bring* Marrwir** them under the intermediate rule of Chrodegang. To the fbrbiddeii capitular clergy then marriage was absolutely forbidden, toGuiona. ^yithout reserve or exemption, and those who were already married were called on to separate from their wives. The decree of the Synod on this head is brief and pithy, Aulogj b " Let no Canon have a wife."^ So in the days of t^^gn^ Elizabeth, when the marriage of the clergy was neither allowed nor forbidden, but winked at, the parish clergy were let alone, but wives and children were not allowed to appear within either cathedral closes or academical in hia greater work (ed. Wats, 9), but in the Historia Minor (Ma(l«len, i 18) the theological argument is left out. See Milni.in, ill. 118. Lambert (1074, p. 163 of the leHser Pertz) tells ub how the decrees were received in Germany, and how " vehementer infremuit tota factio clerioorum, hominem plane ha^reticiim et vesani dogmatis esse clamitans." The chief argument was that Hildebrand's rule was fit only for angels and not for men, and that the German clergy were men and not aageU. * See evpecially the .account of the Canons of Rochester in p. 37; and on Walthara compare vol. ii. p. 444 • Wilkinu, Concilia, i. 367. " Decretum est ut nulluH canonicus uxorem habcat. MAKHIAOE OF I'KIESTS FUHBIDDEN. 425 c'ollep^'s.^ So now a mlKler rule was ai)])lit'tl to the paro- chap. xix. cliial cicrirv than that which wiis hrouerht to hear on their CM)lle<^iate brethren. Vested interests at least were re- spected. It was distinctly ordered that the married j>riest8 PaHuh 1 AA 1 "ill 1 prict* not who were scattered up and down the country m towns and t,, leave vilUi^^es should not be called on to leave their wives.^ ^ '"'*'' '*"^**- This relaxation of tlie edicts of Gre^ry showed the prac- tical j^ood sense of Lan franc and those who acteil with him, but it amounted to g^iving" up th«' point as a matter of principle. If, as Ilildebrand taug^ht, no saving" grace could be bestowed by the ministrations of a married priest, a larg-e part of the people of Eng-land were doomed to go without valid sacraments for years to come. The more Marri«g« distant future indeed was carefully provided for. Those f^r the priests who were not already married were strictly for- ^"^"'^*- bidden to marry, and the Bishops were no less strictly warned against ordaining married men."^ And other rules Sicui.-vr 1-11 -1 1 • P11- iiiarrij\j;je« were laid down with regard to the marriages oi the laity, furi.i.ldm which seem to show that the Danish custom,^ or some " '*'* ^^^•' kindred form of laxity, still prevailed. ^len were for- bidden to ffive their dauofhters or kinswomen in marriay-e OCT CT without the blessincr of the Church. Tliev were warned * See Queen Elizabeth's order prohibiting the residence of women in colleges, printed in Archbishop Parker's Correspondence (eendarie8, wtudents, &c. do keep particular household with their wives, chiMren and nurses, no small offence growrth to the intent of the founders and of the quiet and f)rdorly profession of study and learning." * Concilia, i. 367. " Decretum est ut . . . sacenlotos in castellis vel in Ticis habitantes habtntes uxon-s non cogantur ut diniittant." 'lb. ** Non habentes interdicantur ut hal)oant, et deincepa caveant episcopi ut sacerdotes vel diaconos non presurannt ordinaro nisi prius profiteantur ut uxores non habeant." * On this I have spoken more at length in an Appendix (Note X.) to the second edition of my Hrst v«»lume. In the next Chapter we shall como across something of the same kind in Ireland. 42G Tin: ULl.LMAMlCAL 8ETTLKMKNT <»F ENGLAND. caAT. xuL Xhtki fuch union* were not Inwful niarrin^\ but mcro foniii^tion.^ Othor provisionH liad ri'ftTonco to tho state of the tinuii iinJ to the new leg^JHlntion by wliich William TIm had N^|tanitoiI the eccletfiiUitiail ami temporal courts.''' It l^^l„m wms onhiinixl that no priest in town or country Khould am€%mnk Jmy© nny burthens laid on liis i'erlcsiji>tiail bcnefico MvtofliMi ••b* other than tho living luul been char^eil with in tho days of Kinj^ luulwanl.^ Such a provision mi^ht well be needed to pn)tei't tlnj^lish priests alike against Norman Bishops and a^iinst Norman patrons. Another ordinance denounced excommunication, with its attendant temporal jK'nalties, against all who should neglect any gimimons which citeil them to apj>car in the newly established courts of the Bishops.^ The cause of ^Ethelric, the dejK)sed Bishop of the South-Saxons, of which we have heard more than once without any very clear account of its nature, was now finally heard and decided.'' LuifrMc. It is worthy of special notice that, soon after this im- tkodHi^ portant Synod, within the course of the same year, Lanfranc, ^VJ»»8® again accompanied by Tliomas of York and Remigius of 1076. Dorchester, paid a visit to the threshold of the Apostles. * Concilia, i. 367. '* Pneterea statutum est ut nullua filiam suam vel oognatara tlet alicui absque benedictione sacerdotal! ; hi alitor fecerit, non ut legitimum conjugium sed ut foruicatoriuin judicabitur." ' See above, p. 392. ' Concilia, u. b. " Statutum est ne aliquiH clericus civilis vel rusticufl de beneficio ecclcHiae aliquod wervitium rediiat praeter illud quod fecit tempore Itegiii Edward].' * lb. " Laici vero, si de crimine huo accusati fuerint, et episcopo mo obedire noluerint, vocentur semel, et iterum, et tertio; si post ter- iuun vocationem emendare noluerint, excommunicentur ; si autem post exconununicationcm ad satisfactionem venerint, foriHfacturam Huam, quae Anglloe vocatur oferhyrncssc seu laJislUe, pro uniujuiwjue vocatione epi- •oopo guo reddant." On lah-slit and oferhynics see Schmid's Glossary. Good examples of the latter will be found in p. I46 of Schmid in the L*wa of .^theliitan. * See above, p. 3^-0. LANFRANC AT ROME. 4 27 Tliey would doubtless report to Pope Gre^ry the acts chap. tux. of the Synod at Winchester, how it had been found im- possible to carry out the Roman decrees in their fulness, and how the perverseness of the stiff-necked islanders had made some relaxation of their strictness unavoidable. But, at that particular moment, llildebrand himself mi»^ht well be willing" to j)urchase tlie alleg-iance of the Crown and Church of England by allowing the parish clergy of England to keep their wives for life. It was the great year of Synods and Diets, the year when the two swords 1076. clashed with all their might, the year when the sun and moon of the Christian firmament strove eagerly to eclipse each other, when the successor of Augustus took upon him to depose the successor of Peter, and when the successor of Peter took upon him more effectually to depose the suc- cessor of Augustus.^ At such a moment the presence of Imp«^rt of the three English Prelates was doubly welcome ; it was a i,i that sign that, whatever storms might vex the Church in ^^^' Italy and the Teutonic Kingdom, the island Emi)ire at least and its mighty sovereign remained firm in their allegiance to the mother and mistress of all Churches. Lanfranc, Thomas, and Remigius appeared at Rome, not Thtir mia- ,..,, ii'Aii'i •'**'^" from to pay a mere ecclesuistical homage, but in the lurther wiiihuu. character of ambassadors from the King of the Englis^h.- They were^ as they well might be, received with all * See vol. iii. p. 174. Tlie wonderful letters which passed between the Pope and the King, and the fonnula by which the German Bishops re- nounced the obedience of Hildebnind, are ^nven at len^^li in Hnmo de Bello Saxonico, pp. 57-79 of the smaller Pert/,. Whatever may bo thouj,'ht of the reasoning on either side — and the Pope's assertion that nIASTliAL SETTLEMENT UK t.Mil-AMi. nxr. sit. honour hy tho Pt»pi» niul the Sonnto (»f Home' My Vl'^. tHw liL-t name it may l>e safer to umlcrHtand tho eccle- •*•••• suutical ColK»ge of Cnnlinals, than tho Inidy which •till n*mninc(l an a nhadow of the earlier Knipire and of the «till earlier Commonwealth. Tlie wealth of Kn^'hmd wan, as ever, lavinlutl on the ^-reedy K4)maiis, and \\\v bounty of the thrcn? Prelates drew forth no lesH a^*at^» <^f . . Hrrlwin. dimittis of the man whose simple virtues stand in such Au;:u.st ^o, strange yet pleasing contrast with the intellectual giants who pressed into his spiritual household.* ' OrJ. Vit. 54S D. "Tunc hasilicnt pluros in N'onuftniUH cum inLjenti tri|»u atque Guillelmo [the English ^tbeling was perhaps left in hifl own iHland] et ingenti frtMiuentiA optiniatum et populurum affucrunt." Cf. above, p. 92, and vol. ii. p. ?I3. ' lb. On OiIo'h work at Kiyeux, sec vol. ii. p. 213. ' lb. See vol. iii. p. 109 382. * lb , and more fully Will. (lem. vi. 9, for both the dedication and the death of Htrlwin. See vol, ii. p. 222. Orderic (549 A) aA*\-*, " Vt-norabiliii llerluinuH Abbaw, dedicate Ik)cceiiMi cccleiti&, valde gavi^u-i eat, viMM|uv <|U)m| 490 TlfB BOOUnTARTICAL SBTTLF.MKNT OF EKOLAND. CTiAr. 111. Bnefa were tome of the most ntrikiiip Hoonofl, nuch were Itebi^Mitib ^^^ ^^ ^^^^ most iini>ortant ccolej*iaHtical tlinn^t's, which ^••■'•* markc^i tho uriranry of linnfranc. All liin rhanj^»s toiuK'cl TiiTMl to weaken tlmt thoroughly national rharnrtcr which had iMmtwae lK*long«d to the Knj^lish Clninh in earlier days. All NVldaMd tended to widen that dihtinetion In'twivn tlx* Hpiritual i^j, and tora|>oral powers which in the days of our insular ^ y^ freedom was hardly known. All tended to hrin^ the coanOTion English Church into closer dependence on the see of , , Rome. Rut while William wore the Crown which he ' ^^ >l- had won, there was no fear lest the most devout anion^ • per* K liAl ch»- tlie royal sons of the Roman Church should ever *^'*^* degfenerate into her ahject slave. Not a jot of the supremacy which had been handed on to him from his predecessors would the Conqueror witting^ly g-ive up. In 1075. the very year when Lanfranc, with the authority of William, was calmly decreeing that Lichfield should yield its episcopal rank to Chester, Gregory', without the au- thority of his sovereign, was decreeing that no Bishop or Abbot should receive his ring and staff from any I>emllng» of temporal lord.^ Such thunderbolts might hurl the lord with Wil- of Germany and Italy from his throne; against the lord iiAm- ^f Normandy and England they w^re harmless. Not a trace is seen of any attempt on Gregory's part to seek any change in the law of England by which the Prelates of England received the badges of their office from the royal hand. What King Eadward had freely done King William went on doing no less freely. William was vehemenUrr in hoc gaeculo desideravemt, ulterius inter mortalea commorari dcdi^natus eHt." See also Vit. Lanfr. (Giles, i. 276) ; Chron. Bee. (ih. 200). It it now that Lanfranc get« his magnificent title of " reverendus gentium tnuunnarinarum Bummus Pontifex." * See the words of the decree in Abbot Hugh's Verdun Chronicle (Pertz, ^•iii. 41a); "Si quia deinceps epiflcopatum aut abbatiam de manu alien jua laics penionse sudcepcrit, nuUatenun inter episcopos vel abbates habeatur," &c. Compare also the later decrees of 1078 in p. 423. GREGORY AND WILLIAM. 431 throughout his reign the favoured son of the Uoman chap. xix. Church. He did not absohitely reach perfection in the ^i'*''"**^ eyes of Gregory, but he came so much nearer to it than "''"^o to other princes that he deserved to be treated with Fi)ecial tenderness. Something was to be aUowed to a King who neither destroyed churches nor soKl them, wlio made hiy- men pay titlie antl made priests forsake their wives, and who refused all invitations to join in any schemes contrary to the interests of the Holy See.' One of Gregory's first acts on his accession was to profess his special affection for William, and at the same time to exhort him to a more punctual payment of the money due to the Church of Rome.*^ Later in his reign, Gregory thought it needful to expound to William, by help of the usual metaphors and comparisons, how far the power of Pontiffs stood above the power of Kings. ^ But no serious disi)ute ever arose * Ep. Greg. viL 5, ap. Lubbe, Concilia, x. 381. "Rex Anglorum, licet in quibiwdam non ita religiose sicut optamus ae habeat, taiaen in hoc quod ecclesias Dei non destruit [the New Forest was perhaps not heard of at Rome] neque vendit, et paceni justitiamque in Hubditin auis niodcrari pro- curat, et quia contra Apostolicam Sedem, rogatus a ([uibuadam ininiicis crucis Cliristi pactum inire, consentire noluit, j)rcsbyteros uxores, laicos decimaa quaa detitiebant, etiam juramento dimittere compulit, cieteria Regibua ae satia probabiliorem ac magia honorandum osti'udit. Unde uou indignum debet exi.stimari potestateni illius mitius eane tnictandam attjuo reapectu probitatLs ipsius, subditorum et conim quos diligit negligentias ex parte fore |)ortanda8." The letter is addresaed to Hugh Biahop of Die in the Province of Vienne in the Royal Burgundy, a Prelate employetl by Gregory on many of his missions. ' lb. 57. " Ha?c, cariasime, tibi inculcamus quia inter Reges te solum habemufl quera pne aliis diligere supra scripta credimua." He then mentions the Pet€r-|>ence ; '* Rebua Sancti Petri (|ua' in AngliA colliguntur sic te ut tuia invigilare adnionemus aic libfralitati tuie ut tua com- mittimus ut pium et pn>pitium dobitorem Potrum reperiaa et eum tibi ex d»'bito subvenire admoneas quern aibi mulla to tribuijwe non latebit." The liomtcot, liomescot, Jionijxtnuj, rccunia Jiomaua, Ihmiriu* Saudi Petri, the heor^-pn-nig, as it ia called in the Laws of Eaili;nr, ia men- tioned in a crowd of enactments from the Peace of Eadward and Guthniin onwards. ' lb. 246. "Credimua prudentinm ve^tram nt»n latere, omnibus aliin cxcellentiorea apoatolieam ct regiain digniUitca huic mundo ad rjua 4SS THE KtVLESlASTKAL 8KTTLKMKNT OF KNOLANU. cSAT. lu. U'luinn t\v«> mon wich of whom (m>iiIi1 n»H|K'c't xhv other, and etkvh i*f whom kiu'W that \\\v other rouUl ho utu'ftil for hif |>ur|>oM»«. Onct* only (ir»»^|^ory went t4»o fur, and ho then fouiul tliat the h»yal w)n of the Church wjih not pn«|uin.il to \h* its slave or its vassal. Kven then (ire^'ory did not ask that William should ^ive up the ri^ht of in- vestiture, thoujj^h he made a claim which was holder still. lUd*- At atmic time in William's reigTi of which we do not know tnacvfl^ the exact date, a Legate from llome, Hubert of whom we WiUiam. [nj^yc already hcanl, had come to Kn«;laud on two errands. He a«^iin demanded a more regular payment of the Peter- pence. And he made a far more darin^^ demand ; he a>jked that the Kini»- of the English should j)rofess himself the man of the Bishop of llome.' Some vague notion that such a profession wa.s due may well have floated in the minds of Popes and Cardinals ever since Alexander had sent the ring and banner to bless the invasion of England. - But whatever external claims Gregory ventured to assert over the Kingdom of England, they were wholly external claims. He claims a suzerainty over the realm, but he maki>8 no claim to control the lawful powers of King of and Witan in its internal government. Tlie aubwer of i*.'!^r^ni William was short and sim])le, and breathed in its fulness I.. Ki,^i;-ii ^^j^jj^ spirit of deference to precedent which has ever been re^mina omnipotentem Deum distribuisse. Sicut enim ad mundi pulcri- iudinem oculu cariteui diversis tem|X)ribu8 reprseBentandam solem et lunam omnibus aliw einincntiora dispoHuit luminaria ; sic ne creatura, quam •tti benignitaii ad imaginem buam in boc mundo creaverat, in erronea et mortift^rs traheretur [>ericula, providit ut apostolica et regia digiiitate per diversa rcgeretur officia. Qua tamcn mnjoritatiH et minoritati.s (ii^tantia religio sic se movet ChriHtiana, ut cura et diHpensatione apostolicai digni- tatis post Deum gutx^rnetur regia." * Ep. Lanfir. lo (Giles, i. 32). " Hubertus, legatus tuus, religiose pater, a' : f'X tua parte, me adinonuit, fjuateiiUB tibi et HUccesHoriliUS Iv ! faccrem, et de i>ecunia (juam antece.ssorLH iiiei i\A Roiuanam Ecclesiam mittere soleliant melius cogitarem." • See ToL iii. p. 321, WILLIAM KEFl'SES HOMAGE TO OUEOORY'. 433 the life and soul of English Law. The money he would chap. xix. \ydy ; liis priHleccssors had paid it. Owin^ to his ahscnce in Gaul, it had been for three years irre<^ularly <^ithered ; he tlierefore lx)mul himself to see that all arrears were faithfully paid in. But the claim of fealtv was another Ho refute* . ". fealty, matter; that he had never promised and his predecessors had never paid.^ But he craved the prayers of the Pon- tiff; he was ready to sliow to Gregor}' the same affection and obedience which he had ever paid to the Pontilfs who had gone before hira.- When we read this memorable letter, we are struck with Character the calm daring of the man who could thus at once brave Ham'b and refute the mighty Hildebrand without a word of^®^^"^' threatening or railing, without a word that the Pontiff himself could look on as undutiful or irreverent. The sim})le dignity, the crushing logic, of these few words of AVilliam the Great form a marked contrast to the foul calumnies and wild invectives which the partizans of Pope and Caesar were hurling at one another in other lands. But to Englishmen the letter has another and a deeper Its English interest. It shows how thoroughly William hold himself to have stepped into the position of the Kings of whom he professed himself to be the lawful successor. He claims all their rights, but not more than their rights. AVhat they paid he will ])ay ; what they never paid he will never pay. With the Crown of the island Empire William had, in the face of foreign powers, assumed the spirit ' Epp. Lanfr. lo. *' Unuin adrnisi, altenuu nun aondence, Laiifrane was LmAmm) rebuked bv Grej^^orv for laertum habemus, adventum tuum vel metus Regis, ejus scilicet quern inter cseteros illius dignitatis spccialius semper dileximus, vel maxime tua culpa nobis ntgavit. Et to quidcm. Hi vtl prisci anions niemoria 8U|)cresaet vel debita matri Romana* ecclosiee dilectio in mtntc rcmaneret, non dcbuit aliquis aut mundanae potestatis terror, aut cujusquam personie Huperstitiosus amor, a consptctu nostro retrahere. Ilium vero si contra apostolicam sedem novus arrogantiie tumor nunc erigit, sive contra nos ulla libido seu procacitas jactat, tanto gravius foremus, (juanto eum dilcctiono nostri indignum se fecisxe constituit." Lanfranc is bidden to rcfonn Williiim ; " ei dili^'mter aporiend*) et constantcr admonendo no contra niatretn omnium Kouumam ecclesiam <{ui«l inju.stum pntsumat novo quid a rcIigioH^ {K)testato alienum pctulanter audcat, et ncquc tuam nequo 1 r i IM THE ■CCLR8IA8TICAL SBTTKKMKNT OF KNOLANI). oiAr. xx\ IB vhtkr^^l with diiobtniM- irpcntiMl invitntion« to ni>|HMir l.^afrM>c ^ ^^ Il4»nu», ami ho in oven tlirrutonrd witli n'lnoval fnnu tlio lo Wwi by epuict^|tT» v««r.' It i« not howevor at all rlear that eitluT the rt*huke or the threat had the ellei't of hrin^^in^^ the Kn^,»'lish Primate to the thri»«hoKl ol^ the Apontles. And it in of even more inifwrtant to note that, when the ri^hl of ^ Opejpory to the Pajml throne was a^in calh'd in {jueHtion, 1080. when Kinp Henry had g-ivcn him a successor in the person of Wihert or Clement,^ and had received the Imivrial Crown from the Pontilf of his own making,' Cmimmm Lanfranc a^in uses the most cautious lanj^ua^^e, and ofLan?^ declines to commit himself either way. England, he tells ***** a correspondent, had neither rejected Gregory nor recog- nized Clement; the matter had still to he examined; Doth sides had still to be heard and a decision to be come alicujuB devotionein al) npoBtolicae sedis visitationeiii ulteriuH coorcere ut- tentet." Lastly he telU biin, " Decet fraternitatein tuam negligentin' sua- exoeasui sapienter corrigere atque ad apostolicam sedem quantociuH pro- perare." ' The letter, given in Labbe, Concilia, xii. 53, ia there a8signed to 1 081, but by JaifiS (Men. Greg. 494), though doubtfully, to 1083. After rejecting all excoaes about distance and the difficulty of the way, Hildebrand ^<*en on to oae some rather strong language ; " Quare apoHtolicA tibi auctoritato ptBM;ipimuA, ut, poHtposita occasione vel inani formidine, datis induciia quatuor nieni^iuui, post({uam haec nostra mandiita ad notitiain tuam per- Tencrint in praesentiH anni fest^j omnium sanctorum Romje adesse procures ei satagas, et inobedicntise tuoi reatum per tantum temporis supportatum emendare non ulterius negligas. Quod si nee adhuc te mandata apostolica movcrint, sed ea disaimulans in contt-mptu durare malueris, et periculum inobedientixe incurrere non orubueris, ort, 1079 (I'crtz, vi. 364), Otto of Freisingen (Annals, vi. 36), in reoonJing the appointment of Wibert, gives a general picture of tbo timM which ia well worth turning to. • For the coronation of Henry at Easter, 1084 or 1085, see the authorities ooDected by StruviuH, i. 38^. LANFRANC8 CONDUCT IN THE SCHISM. 437 to after hcarinj^ them.' Meanwhile he declines to join chap. xix. his correspondent in any disresjux'tfiil lanp^-uage towards Ctregory or in any extraordinary praises of Clement.^ On the other hand, he cannot helieve that the Emi)eror — he does not deny him the title — can have taken so weighty a step ^^^thout good reasons, or that he can have won so great a victory withont the manifest help of (iod.' It is plain that both the Caesar and the Pontiff of the island Empire had fully made nj) their minds to hold their own, and that all the obedience which Rome was likely to win from William, or from Lanfranc under William's rule, did not go beyond a decent ceremonial reverence. In fact there was no time when the royal supremacy Effectual in matters ecclesiastical was more fully carried out than theTovaT it was in the davs of the Conqueror. If William was 8"i»reiuAcy \ by Wil- pre-eminently Defender of the Faith, he was no less pre- liani. eminently Supreme Governor of the Church throughout his dominions. In all causes and over all persons was that supremacy asserted. Alongside of all that w^e hear of William's zeal and piety, we hear another voice comi)lain- Charge of ing of his aggressions on ecclesiastical privileges, and of ^j^,j^j ^^^^, the new customs which he brouq-ht over from Normandv ^"^'."'"^ ^ * against for the more complete subordination of the ecclesiastical him. .state to his will.^ On that will, we are told, all things * Epp. Lanfr. 65 (Gilefl, i. 80). " Nondum enim insula nostra priorem refutavit, nee utrum huic ohedire tlelwat sententiani promulgavit. Auditis utriniqtie cauHiH, hi ita c<»ntigerit, perspicacius quid fieri o|>ortoat provideri valuliit." ' lb. **Non probe quod Papam Gregorium vitu|)era«, quo«treH sui et \\m) 4M TIIK KiX-I.KSIAjrrU'AL 8BTTLE1IBNT OP ENOLAND. \ divino and hiiinnn wrro nmdo t<» ilriHMul.' Anion;; lli.->.' ' innovation!! wo ln«r thnt ho wouM have no Pope iukn«As- ' ^ Icdgtt! within hin dominion** witliout hin consmt, nnd 1 » .»j thnt no Papal k'ttom or hulls wrro nllowtnl to Iwivo any irpn>v»Hl }»y liimsi'lf.'' \Vhc'n tho Arfhl)iHhop summoned a national Council, its decrees had no force 1 Kini;'* until they were confirmed hy the Kin^; it might almost cm that no matters could ho even dehated without the ••»yal licence.^ Nor did William allow any of his Barons ■^*- or officers of state to be excommunicat<.Hl or suhjocted to iiy ecclesiastical censure without his consent.^ All these thinfjs are complaineremacy of P^adward, ])ut it was exercised in a difltrent iHc^c Wire ionovA- way. lender the native Enp;>Hsh Kind's the Church and fai NormAnni^ hal>ere solebant in ^Vnglia sen'are volens, dv huju.stnodi pcr- •onu epiiioopo8, abbatce, et alioH principes per totAin terram instituit, liuul hiul been absolutely the same thini^;' chap. xix. decrees in temporal and spiritual mattrrs were made bv ^^® ""* * ' •' premacy the same authority ; Kin^js, Karls, and IJishops were elected exercuted 11 11 1 111' II •r.iii'^ new and deposed ny the same all-rulinj^' assembly. under way by William all lhin<^ were tending" towards a separation ' "*'°* , , I • • 1 1 1 rni Ch»ngo« between the ecclesiastical and the temporal power. The consequent Archbishop now held his Synod as a body distinct from the ^" V'" great Gemot of the realm. It almost necessarily followed '. 1 1 T'-' • tiuaa. that the Kmg" should assert a distinct authority over ecclesiastical matters in a shape which gave him the aspect of an external, and even a hostile, power. In this sense it was a novelty for the King to control the action of a distinct ecclesiastical body, or distinctly to signify his personal will in ecclesiastical matters. The alleged changes Controver- of William became matters of fierce debate from the davs ^^1:!!?,'" of his son onward. But all of them became part and ^^f"'' *"»- parcel of the Law of Eng-land. The supremacy established ^ . - by William was essentially the same as the supremacy Ht^nry the which was contended for by Henry the Second, and finally 1164; established bv Henry the Eiffhth. But it is easy to see o^ Henry . .... . the Eighth, the weak point of his policy. AA illiam, like many other 1534. g-reat rulers, esta])lished a system which he himself could Weak work, but which smaller men could not work. I'nder William's weaker and baser King's evils showed themselves which ''y^*^^'"- under his rule had no place. Under a weak King the distinct ecclesiastical body could assume a degree of in- dependent i)ower which it could not a.«?sume in earlier days. UndiT a wicked King the ecclesiastical powers whieh William used, on the whole, for g-ood could be, far more easily than undrr the rider system, perverted into means of oppression and corruption. But the brighter side of the combined policy of William Darker and Lanfranc must not Mind us to the fad (hat tliey wiHiam ' Seo ?ol. i. i>, 406. franr. 410 THE SaM^RSlASTlCAL gBTTLXMBNT OP KNOLAND. our. in. werv, aAor all, rulcrh whom forct* iilono iiTH>o«Hl on nn Apfolm^ unwilling |>ct>pUv NVhilo \Villiain wiih aKHortiii^'- Xhv ri^htn of Uic En^liKh Cnnvn, hv was usin^;; xta poworn to fill all offioM of tnixt, ti'ni|H)nil and Hpiritiial, with men of other wnilMB*i landtf and othor tonj**!!**. From hin own |K)int of view Mwlioaai- noct of hij» up|>ointmont8 wore wisely and eonseientioiiHly ^"J5^ff*^ made ; hut every Norman Hishop and Abhot was none •^'^••- the less a bad^ to show that Kn«;land was a conquered land. And in some eiujes at least, either NVilliam ami lianfranc were mistaken in the men of their choiee, or else those men were corrupted by the temptations of their I>o8ition. Ag^iinst Tlionias of York and Osmund of Salis- bury we must set Prelates like liobert of Chester ' and Thurstan of Glastonbury,^ and we must not forget that Lanfranc himself did in some degree tread in their ways I'n-Eng- in the matter of Saint Aupfustine's.'' Lanfranc never be- ingtot camv a naturalized Englishman, like Osbcrn of Exeter; LAnfr*nc. j^^, jj^j ^^^^ advance so far in the same path as Thomas Rb comao' of York. Perhaps his cliaracter, hard if lofty, his devo- l-*iti..n. tion to interests spread over a field far wider than the Isle of Britain, hindered him from ever thoroughly throwing himself into any purely local or national posi- tion. His destiny made him first Norman and then English, but we may suspect that he never heartily assumed either character. In his eyes Normans and English alike were simply instruments for carrying out designs in which Normandy and England seemed but as small specks on the globe. An Italian born, a lawyer of the Empire, a devotee of the Papacy, he brought with him into England a contempt for the barbarous islanders. That contempt he never got over, even when his position drove him to throw aside his former devotion to Rome, and to appear in some sort as the champion of England. ^ See above, p. 418. * See ftlwve, p. 394. ' See above, p. 412. LANFKANX'S GENERAL POSITION'. Ill The man who could det'eiul the rip-hte of our island/ of chap. xix. its King" and of its Primate, himself 8howe'iMtii • • 1 • 1 1 /• 1 • 1 n " 1 En^'LtiKl. Visit the island of which fourteen years later he was to 1078-1079. • Mark tho words "insula nostra" in tho letter of Iwnfranc quoted in p. 437. Irj the next chapter we shall find him H|)eaking of " noa Angli." ' See above, p. 400. • See above, p|>. 351,412. * See vol. ii. p. Ji6. • See above, p. 429. * lb. ' Will. Gcni. vi. inc tho chiof i*liophonl.' I If liiul miuh diKcourHO with tho Pnmato, hiu old iVifinl ami l»rollirr, on the inimy niatt<*n( whirh were of common int4»rit»t to both. The con%*en**' of Kinfmnc and Anwim wt** !)ofore uh n remark- able and momonihlo pair. The lawyer, tho siTulnr wholnr, met the divine and the philoKopher ; tlic cceletfiasticnl ■totMinin stood face to face with the saint. The wisdom, oomcientious no doubt, but still hnrd and worldly, which oould gfoide Churt^hes and Kin^loms in troublous times, wu met by the boundless love which took in all (Jod's creatures of whatever race or species. Tlie talk of the two OoataBH friends fell on the ecclesiastical state of Enji^land. Ijanfranc, n<"rmSoM •* y*^^ unused to the habits and feeling* of his Hock, was ofl^Mi- bent on chang-inp many things, some, our P^nglish in- formant tells us, for good reasons, others simply of his flu doubu own arbitnirv will.- Amonjff«T<»nc»- bard city, usetl to fellow-citizens but not to fellow-country- «nd Eng- "^^'b familiar with the local strife of city and city but not Ikh feeling. ^([^ i]^q national struggles of a whole people, Lanfranc doubtless found it hard to understand the feeling which, in the minds of Englishmen, made religion and patriotism but two sides of the same thing, and which gave the honours of martyrdom to men who died in fijjfht ajjainst the ' Eaxhncr, Vita Ansclini, i. 5. 40. " Habebat praterea coenobium plures poMeasiones in Anglia, quafl }>ro communi fratrum utilitate necesae erat per Abhatis pncflentiam nonnumquam visitari. Ipso itaquesuae onlinationin anno AniielrauK in Angliain profectus est." He goes on to speak of his conferences with Lanfranc. • Ih. 42. "Erat Lanfrancus adhuc quasi rudis Anglus, necdumque ■edermnt animo ejus qusedam institutionea quas repererat in Anglia, qujipropter quum jilures de illis magni fretus ratione, turn quaadam niuta>'it soU aactoritatis Huee deliberatione." • lb. " Angli iuti inter quos degimuH inntituenint sibi quosdam quos eolereni sanctuH. De quibus qiium aliquando qui fuerint, «ecundum quod ipnmei refemnt, mente revolve, de sanctitatia eorum merito animum a dubietate Bectere nequeo." ANSELM3 DEFENCE OF iELFIIEAH. 44t heathen invader. Even the reverence paid to the holy chap. xix. yElHicah was unintelli<^ible to him. /Elfheah mif,'ht have been a saint; Lant'ranc eould not bring Inmsell* to look on him as a martyr. He had not died for the faitli of Christ ; he had only dieil rather than pay a sum of money which could not be raised save by doing* wrong to his people.^ In the eyes of Lanfranc, the lawyer and ad- ministrator, it was no martyrdom to die, not for faith but for charity, not for a theological dogma but for righteous- ness and mercy. He laid his doubts Wfore the father He con- of dogmatic theology, and from him he learned that gelm. dogma did not come before righteousness. If Christ was Aiyument , of Anselin truth, He was also righteousness ; it was as holy a thing on behalf to die for righteousness as to die for truth.- The Baptist died, not on behalf of a theological proposition, but on behalf of the eternal laws of right and wrong.^ So did ^Elflieah. He died for righteousness as John died for truth, for the truth which he spoke forth at his own peril.^ Tii the judgement of Ansclm, the English Primate was as true a martyr as the Forerunner of the Saviour."^ Lanfranc, Lanfranc With a noble frankness which redeems his earlier pre- by Ajwelm. judices, confessed his error, and declared himself convinced. ' Eatlmer, Vita Anselmi, i. 5. 43. " Hunc [Elfogum] non incxlo inter sanctofl verum et inter martyres numerant, licet eum, non pro confi'ssione nominis Cliristi, Hero C'hriHto moritur ; qui autem pro Christo moritur, ecclesia te«te, martyr habetur." ' rb. " Bcatus JohanncM Baptinta . . . non quia Chri.stum negare, 8eq>e««ione utnini- (\\u- dotinoat ] " Ill THE EtXTLRSlASTKAl. 8KTTLEMKNT OP ENOLANl). • HAT. in. Sainl .l.aiu-ah rrtaiiunl all hiH honotirnj ami \w Htill koopM ^^**r. hi* place in tin* Kn^lish Kal«'iulnr. The man wlw) thus (lefnided the cause of the Kn^lihh martyr \\i\n hiinHclf to fcHt^jlllu- *** *" ''*' 9cmt, and thence to n-lmke nin in Kin^ and 9natt mmI noble* in the true spirit of the Baptist.* Ijiinfranr, with all his preot qualities, livef tlie saints of England. Strangt»r a» he was, he has won his place amon^ the noblest worthies of our island. It was some- thing to be the model of all »'cclesiastical perfection ; it was something" to be the creator of the thcolof^y of Christ- endom; but it was something" higlier still to be the very emlKxliment of righteousness and mercy, to be handed down in the annals of humanity as the man who saved the hunted hare ^ and stood up for the holiness of iElfheah, TwoCold Looked at, not from a purely English )jut from a L^JJ^^iJ^^g., more general point of view, the primacy of Lanfranc, that ailmmU- jg ^}^p ecclesiastical administration of William, was cer- tnUion. PotnUof ^''*inly ^ time of advance and reform. The standard refonn. ^f ^]^q English Churcli, intellectual and moral, was, in a Dark nde cosmopolitan as]>cct, undoubtedly raised. In a strictly ciMiige. national point of \new, the case is quite different. The T].< foreign foreign Prelate miglit be, as a nile, a man of liiglier rreUl«. to » > ' Eadmer, Vita Anselmi, i. 5. 44. *' Firmji ratione tua edoctus beatnm Elieffum ut vere magnum et gloriosum inartyrem Christi deinceps me oolere et venerari ex corde, grati.1 Dei juvante, confido." He then goes on to speak of the honours retained by Saint yElfheah, at Lanfranc's order, in the church of Canterbury. ' An!*ehn, unlike some assertors of ecclesiastical rights, could denounce moral as well as ecclesiastical offences. See bis discourse with William Rufun in Eadmer, Hist. Nov. 24. • Tlic twf» hUiries which I quoted in my second volume (p. 25) from John of Salisbury's Life of Anselm are told also in the earlier Life by Eadmer, ii. 3. 27. THE FOREIGN PRELATES. 445 culture than his Enf^lish predecessor, but he could not have chap. xrx. the same sympathy with his tloek mid with their subor- dinate pastors. And the reforms ot* Lanfranc were pur- chased by mueh of wron^ and hardship in particular cases. \Ve are sig-niticantly told that the outraj^es of Thurstan at Glastonbury did not stand alone.* And, thouj^h William's Dupoeal of hands were undoubtedly clean from all stain of simony,'- tical oflBcea. yet even in his reign, and still more in the rei<^ns of his sons, Hishoprieks and Abbeys were turned into the rewards of purely temporal service.* This is an evil whieh will ever beset every Chureh whose offices carry with them enou<^h of temporal wealth and di«^nity to become objects of tem- poral ambition. And this evil would assume its worst form in days when services done to the King* would commonly mean services done agtiinst the people. Men complained UnjuHt 1 -r* 1 1 1 1 p 1 • 1 dejH)«itioii that r relates were hurled trom their seats at the royal of Engli.sh will, with small attention either to natural justice or to ^*^*^^^^''*- the forms of the Canon Law. The Englitih Abbot — it is the inmate of a Norman monastery who speaks — was j)ut aside to make wav for one who was not an Abbot but ' Old. Vit. 523 D. " Conventio et profectus fiebat inter conimissoa greges et archimandrita** Imjusmodi, qualLs inter 1ujm)3 et bidentes sine defensore solet fieri. Quud facile probari potest ab his (jui interfuenint in Turstino Cadomensi et conventu GleHtouien.si," ^ We may, I think, fairly accept the statement of William or Onleric in the death-bed speech (658 C) ; " Ecclesiasticas dignitates nunquam venum dedi, aimoniam detestatus semjHjr refutavi." He goes on to add, " In electione personarum vita,* meritum et sapientiiu doctrinam invejjtigavi, et, quantum in me fiiit, omnium dignissimo Ecclesiic regimen commendavi," and quotcM the oxanqde.H of Lanfranc and Anselm in proof. Compare the statement of Gregory (juoted in p. 431, and the words of the llyilo writer (^94^ " £piHco[HJH et Abbate^ . . . absque ulla connideratione pecunite aut nunnni Husceptione, sed solo divinitatis amore studiose cwpit ordinare." ' Ord. Vit. 523 C, D. ** NonnuUi ecclcsiastici viri, tjui sapientes et religiosi videbantur, regali curia; pro dignitatiltus cupitis t)bnixe famula- l>antur ; et divcrHJs tissentationum mooke out his mind before William and his lords. The learning* of Wimund was famous ; yet we need not believe that he gave the illustrious assembly a complete sketch of universal history, from Nabuchodonosor to Rolf, to prove that Kingdoms are not eternal, and that the power of this Uerebuke* world often passcs sju^edily away."* But we seem to hear •an^^ihe ^® g:enuine words when he says that God hates robbery ^**J^ for burnt-offering, and will not accept those who make i^v.oQ. oblations of the spoils of the poor.^ He asked by what ' Orel. Vit. 533 D. " Prij5ci Abbatew sajcularis comminatione potcKtatis ierrebantur, et Hine synodali discussione de sedibus suIh injuate fugabantur, pro quibus stipendiarii, non monachi, sed tyranni, contra sanctorum scita canonum intrudebantur." • lb. 524 A. On the hintory of this monastery, "Crux Heltonis," " Crux Sancti Leufredi vulgo La Croix Saint Leufn»y," in the diocese of Evreux, see Neustria Pia, 346. • lb, ** Regio juBHu accersitus, pontum transfretavit, et ol)latum sibi • Rege et proceribtis regni onus ecclesiastici regiminis omnino repudiavit." * The 8p)eech, whether hia own composition or Wimund's, is given at length by Onleric, 534-526. leaving out these parts, which are merely one of the usual displays of irrelevant learning, the speech is thoroughly worthy the occasion, and we may hope that it fairly represents the substance of what Wimund really said. * Onl. Vit. 524 C. "Dicit enim scriptura, ' Immolans ex iniquo, oblatio e«t macolata.' Et paulo post; 'Qui offert sacrificium ex substantial pauperum quui qui victimat filium in conspectu patris sui.' " WLML'ND REBUKES WILLIAM. 447 law he could be justifietl in h(jUlin<^ a place of authority chap. xu. amoii*^ men of whose tcutionem nescio." ^ lb. "Quorum patrcs carosque parcntes et amicus occidistis ^'lamo, K»»«t tho |>rot«|H'rity t)f thin worM nhouUl lead only to wivpin^ ami ^'nuhhiii^' of tooth in tho next. For hiuiJioir he wouM po hack to Normandy ; he would leave the fqwilfl of England t<> thone who lovcatieneej and let the man who dare y''"»""^ Beyond the bounds both of Normandy and Kn;rland, lie ^*'" **n- /. , ... luttcy and tound patrons who could a}>preciate his merit, and offers ^mk-h into of preferment which he could accept with ii good con- ^' science. Gret^i-or}' the Seventh raised him to the rank Wo»''°»***o of Cardinal ; Urban the Second bestowed on him the l.y(;rt^ory, Archbishoi)riek of Aversa. There, in a Norman city bilhop'^f founded on Italian st)il,- he at last found a i)lace where ;V.®™* \^ Lruau the he could undertake the care of tlu- souls of men without Socon.l. ..... 1 • 1 1088-1089. puttin*^ his own soul in jeopardy. While such men as Wimund were to be found amonir the priesthood of Normandy, it is with delii^ht that we also find at least one equally noble assertor of truth and ri<^hteousness among her gallant chivalry. Ilerlwin did not stand alone in practising the highest Christian virtues beneath the harness of the Norman warrior.' In English (Julljertof eyes the noblest of the men who followed William must ever refiisert be Gulbert of Ilugleville, the son of that valiant Kichanl \)'''^' "\ who had fought so well for his Duke in the ambush of Saint Aubin.^ A kinsman of William, he had married Beatrice of Valenciennes, who is described as a kinswoman of the Duchess Matilda.'"' The ties of loyalty and kindred had led him across the sea in the following of his cousin and] sovereign. He led his men to William's standard ; he fought by his side against the English axes ; he shared in all the toils by which England was brought under William's hand.'' And when the land was at peace, when ' Ord. Vit. 526 Ii. " lUe ah omni avaritiil purgari volens, et inter extenm paupcrtato premi quam inter suoa disHenHJuncH foverc nialuns." ^ Ih. •' Ha)c urbs t«Mi[M)re LooniH IX. Pape a Nurmannis (jui prinio Apuliani incohierunt const nu.L-i eat." ' See vol. ii. p. 218. ' See vol. iii. p. 13 J. * Onl. Vit. 606 I). " Miitliiliiirt Ilr^niw? consohrina irnt." She ia df»icriL»o«l tkH •* Beatrix, filia Chrirttiani «le V'alcnceniM iliustriM trilmni." * lb. " I'nefatUH liuroH consan^uincu.H DuciM semper ei fidelis fuit, VOL. IV. '• part of England. All land, whether it had been granted out to a stranger or was kept by its former owner, was lield by his grant. The tributes and other services due from the boroughs of England were paid to him, and in ' Our authorities for thifi period remain much the same as hcforo. We havt- the Worce.ster and l'utcTl»<»niui,'h Chronicles, Flon-nco ami hi.s North- huiiihrian interpoLitor, and Ordt^ric, boMidcH tlio usual HuhsMiary writern. And us much of this Chapter is concerned with the exploits of llervward and Walthoof, the mkimm of niytholo^ry which ha^ >,'ro\vn round tht-lr namuH in tlir ful.M«> luj^Milf and olsewhcrc has to he tcMt«'|>ointed whom he woidd in their btead. He vnka fully Kin^; Iw was jurhupH more truly King Uian any Kin^ who had ^^onc before him. No King- hod ever had the whole land, and those who bore rule in every corner of it, so thoron«,']>ly under bin control. Tlie process by which William had tn^ined his power was harsh and wrongful ; it had inflicted unutterable wretcluHlncss on the whole land ; parts of the land it had turned into a wilderness. The way in which his j>ower was used was systematically stern, occasionally cruel. Bui OooBoUd*- the Kin<^lom which he had won gained in the end from y;tigA>tii his winninj^ of it. It was William's concpiest and William's byWiniAm. j.^j|^, which fixetl for ever that Enci'land should remain a Kin«^lom one and indivisible. Change in From this time then whatever opposition William had ofopiMxii- still to face took the form ot" revolts or insurrections. \y^u^ • Those who now fought against him were no longer striving authority, to keep Something which they had, but striving to win J^*"**^<* back something which they had lost. Tlieir right so to form of do I should be the last to dispute. The right to resist Horml **" oppressive, above all a foreign, government is the mq>ectof g-roundwork of all freedom. It is undoubtedly a riffht Inaurreo- ^ . Uona. to l>e exercised with the greatest caution, and only in the extrcmest cases. A hopeless revolt, where success is im- possible and where failure only increases oppression, is undoubtedly a crime. But we must remember that many an enterprise which seems hopeless to men who look at it calmly from a distance does not seem hopeless to those Strength who are engaged in it. And we must also remember of locsl feelinga. ^^^^^ ^'^ t^^^' eleventh century men's local feelings were at ' Chnm. Petrib. 1087, " Bucopaa he saette of heora biscoprice and mbbodaa of beora abbodrice." (•H.\HA(TKK UF THi: KKVOLTS. 453 least as stron*^ as their national feelings. An enterprise chap. x». whieh was wholly hopeless as an attempt to drive William out of the land was not necessarily hopeless as an attempt to win back the independence of some particular district. From our point of view we should look on the lastin*^ dis- meml>erment of the Kin^lom as a <^reater evil than its mis- govemment at a particular time. We should arg-ue that to assert a precarious independence for a j)artieular district could lead only to makin<^ the honda^i^e of the whole land heavier. The men of the eleventh century did not look at matters in this licrht. Tliey would have been best pleased to shut out the stranger from every comer of the land. But failing this, it was in their eyes a worthy object to rescue any corner of the land from his grasp. From their own point of view then, the men who, in the cause of England, revolted against William were as worthy of English sympathy as those wIk^ at an earlier stage withstood him. But we must bear in mind the historical difference between their several positions. Tlie defence of Exeter w^as resistance to a foreign invader ; the defence of Ely was a revolt against a de facto King of the land. The time with which wx* have now^ to deal is marked by several revolts against William^s authority both in his insular aii> uliani s p<^wer lij^,,,'^ in Britain bevond the limits of the English Kinu^lom. J^.^:''.;*^.^'" ^ " '^ all nnUiin. \\v have now to see his assumption of the Imjx'rial as well as the royal authority. But during this j>eri<>d his strife is wholly with his own discontented subjects and vassals. Tliis character distinguishes it in a marked way Spt'ciM from a later period, in whieh he had to struggle at once <,f ti,pti,„^. against his own feudal lord anf tins time are olu-n iU THE RKV<»LTS AOAIKHT WILLIAM, cmAr. 1^ U0Tohot Um Tmrn- 1070-1071. tVoobU* taNoflli- l*n<1 Ah'l Rcrolt of Maine. 10:4- Km. -f io;5 1076. clo«'ly connected with ono nnothrr; still it is ewy to arranpt* them in »t»voral \v«'ll-(lt'fim»et EngliHce folc of e»Il l>a feonlandea comen to heom, and wendon l>8et hi sceoldon winnon enU t«!i land." HISTORY AND LEGENDS OF HEUEWAKD. 455 the story gives us is that the men of the fenland were chap. ix. ready to receive Swend as King*.* At this mf)ment we hear for the Hrst time of one whose mythieal fame outshines all the names of his generation, and of whom the few historical notices make us wish that details could be fdled in from some other source than legend. Suddenly, Apixwir- without preparation or introduction of any kind, we find Heke"- ourselves face t) face with the renowned but shadowy ^'^^^• form of Ilereward. With no name has fiction been more Legen.lary busy.- One tale, the wildest of all, hus made the famous u\^ i,irth outlaw a son of the great Earl Leofric. Romancers pro- *? j*;''" bably did not stop to think that this was to make him a brother of ^Ifgar, an uncle of Eadwine and Morkere, an uncle by marriage of King Grutlydd and of King Harold.'^ In truth, nothing whatever is known of his parentage; there is no more evidence for making him the son of an unknown Leofric of Bourne than there is for making him a son of the renowned Earl of the Mercians. Both the voice of legend and the witness of the great His j.ro- Survey agree in connecting Ilereward with Lincolnshire, Li„coin- but they differ as to the particular spot of the shire in "^^v/V^^k- which he is to be quartered. Legend also has forgotten '^•'ire. a fact which the document has preserved, namely, that the hero of the fenland did not belong wholly to Lincoln- * Yet, uncomfortable as it is to depart from the Chronicles, I confeaa tliat I know nut how to acctpt the statement of the Ptterl)<»rougli Chronicler (i070)that Sweijil came this year in person into the Humher; ** ^''a on [>nm ilcan geare com Swegn cyng of Denmarcan into Humbran." Nothing however in Haipeanince. We tlirectly after hear of the coming of Oaheoni and Christian to Ely. * Besides the account in the false Ingulf, we have the Oeata Here ward i Saxonis, published in M. Fnvnciscjue Michel's Chroniques Anglo-Nor- mandes, which is essentially the same which has been workeil into the Liber Eliensis puhlished by Mr. D. J. Stewart in 1848. There are also some notices in (ieoffrey (laimar. ' I shall exaiiiiiMi tlie chief statements of the mythical arroiints, as well as the few autiicntic notices of Herewurd which we have, chiefly in Domes- day and tlje Chronicles, in Ap|>endix ()0. 11$ TIIF. REY(»LTS AGAINST WILLIAM. cvAf. JUL •hin*. l>ut thnt he wnn hIho a landholder in tlir diHtnnt nhiri! HmcaiW. of Waruick. Hut ihr Survey luw pn»8orvceen »|iecially hiwy. Herewnnl, at Boine time it would seem U»fort» the jicriixl of his exploits, had 11er:u»d. distant monastery of Peterborough. The death of Brand, ^"^'"j'**"*" •^ ^ '27, 1069. the Abbot who had succeeded the patriot Leofric, has been xurold already recorded,^ as well as the appointment of his sue- T/r'?^*J^ cesser in the Easter Gemot of the past year. He was of I'tttr- course a stranger, but his Norman name, Turold,^ a form Aj.ril 4 ' of the Danish Tliorold, was a name still familiar in that ^°'°' part of England, one which had been borne by an English Sheriff who is recorded as a benefactor of the h«)use of Crowland.'' He is spoken of by the local Chronicler as a very stern man," and the known details of his earlier history fully bear out the character. He was a monk of ' " llercwanlus vir strumiiiiHimuM " says Florence (IO71), like "strfiuius Dux Ilaroldus." Seo vol, ii. pp. 393, 537. " The words in the Chronicles, 1071, '* buteat thoHe in 878, " butan l>am cyninge /Elfrede." ' See vol. iii. p. 69. * .Seo i»l>ove, p. 335. ' Chron. Petrih. 1070. " Se cyng hsfdo gifen \tait abbotrice an Froncisc© abljot ; Turolde wjch geluitfu." • Sec above, p. 214 and Domesday, 346. ' Chron. Petrib. 1070. " He wh'« Hwifte ntyrne man. " ,58 THK KF.V(»LTS AOAINST WILLIAM. m%r. II. F'^camp, wlio hiui \toen plnrtnl l»y William ovrr tlu' AMuy Mm AwvMw of Malmcsburv, it» Kn^lUh AbU»t Urihtrir having- hcfii Malmw trai»latetl harlcwnrdH to the less important Abbey of liurton.^ HiK niK* at .Malmohburv was tyrannical, and tlw storj runs that William pirktMl him out, an U»in^' more of a soldier tban a monk, as the (ittost man to rtilc the ^reat home of PeterlH)rou«j:h, now that it was tlircatenetl by Hercward and his fellow outlaws in tin* fens.^ In con- formity with his character, he is now described as cominp at the head (jf an armea munecas of Burh Kagen \>a:i heora ageue menn woldon hergon J)one mynstre . , . b^et w«r« forffan f>et hi herdon ssecgen J>et se cyng," &c. » See Apinndix OO. HKKEWAKI) PLUNDERS PETKKBoKOrGH. 439 for speaking of him as a nephew of the late En<^li8h Ahbot chap. xx. Brand. ^ The news came to the monks of Peterhorouph Htixward that a motley force, made up of outhiws, of their own men, „utiaw» and of the Danish allies, was cominij to harrv the monastery. *"** '**? . " • * men of the This, says the Chronicler, was Ilereward and his^nj**.- This nionaaUry. is the first mention of Hereward's name in authentic history, but it is a mention which shows th.it his name was already well known at IVtcrboroui^h. While the g'unj; was on its They march, a prudent churchward, Vware by name, acting by peter- the counsel of the monks, ' took out of the minster such '^^'■""g^. books and other moveable articles as he could, to preserve \^\^^^ them from robbery. He then before daybreak sent word ^*'® ^^^: '' ^ Hurc and to Turold, asking" for his peace and protection, and telling »♦ nis him that the outlaws were coming.^ This was not the Tur.jl.1. way either to stave off or to soften the comin«r attack. "J""*^ '• •/ '"' 1070. The outlaws had now fair ground for looking on the monks as traitors to the national cause, and for giving out tliat whatever they did was done as good service to the monas- tery itself, which was betrayed by its present inmates.^ Early in the morning the outlaws came with many ships, iirreward and the monks at first strove to keep them from entering [^^^ monas- the monastic precinct. Thus provoked, they took to the ^^^y- weapon so familiar to their Norman enemies; they set fire 1070. ' So the false Ingulf in Gale, p. 70; (Jcsta Horewarili, t'liron Ang.- Norm. ii. 39. ' Chron. Petrib. 1070. " |?a't wivs Herewanl and his gengc." These seem to be specially the rebellious tenants of the Abbey, " heora ageno menn," but we directly after hear of *• |)a utlaga " and of ** l>a Denesce menu " aa having a share in the work. ' lb. *' t'a wa'S ^xre an cyrcoward, Ywan- u.i -< L:atTe munece rwde." On the mean- ing of this passage and the force of the word })»f/, see Mr. Earle'g uoto, Parallel Chronicles, p. 348. * lb. •* And ferde Bona ir d»g to hone abbot Turolde, and Ba>gde him ha.'t he Hohte his griSe, and cydde him hu ha litlageH Hceolden cumen to IJurh." * lb. ** Sa.'gdon Jnet hi hit dydcn for Cch mynstreM holiUci|>e." leO THB RKV«»LT8 AGAINST WILMAM. r. XX. to the monki' hoiiup* niul to tho wholo town, and all \vm lmmi«t! khvo ono hoiite.* Hy tho Hiinu» moans ihvy mnde their way tJironjjIi tlu« Holhitho (into, tlu' notitlieni pnto of the monafterr, and tlie monkn now sought for their pcM^e and prt>ttvtion.^ But it wni« too hito. Thi» whole hand, out^ lawM, Danefi, and vnasals, wliothcr loyal or rchclliouR, hurst into tho niinstor. Thov clinihrd up to thr prcat rood and carriinl oil' its oniamonts of p^ld ; •* they cliniluil uy the steeple, and carrieil olf the p»ld and silver i>astr)nd staffs which was then* hidden.' Shrines, roods, Iwoks, vcRtments, roinetl money, ^ treasures of every kind, were carried away to the ships and were taken to Kly. Tlie monks were all Bcattered abroad — an act wlnCli seems to he specially attrihutod to the Danish allies — all save one sick brother in the infirmary." Tliis fact seems at once to s})eak well for the health of the brotherhood, and to mark tlie resi)ect which even the outlaws showed to buildin^^s and jxTsons Turt»id that mig-ht specially claim their forbearance. Presently reter- came Abbot Turold with a hundred and sixty armed boiTMjgh. Frenchmen. The enemy had already set sail, and he found only the one sick monk, and the empty church standing * Chron. Petrib. 1070. " J?a l^egdon hi fyr on and forbaemdon ealle J'a munece btues and eall )>a tun, buton ane huse." On the Norman paAHion for setting fire to everything, see vol. i. p. 224 ; vol. iii. pp. 155, 560. * lb. " |)a comen hi |>urh f) re in at Bolhit^e geate, and |a niunecaH oomen heom togeanes, beaden heom griiS."' ' lb. " Ac hi na rohten na bJng. geodon into ))e mynstre, cluniben upp to J>e hal^e rode, namcn J>a J>e kynehelm of ure Drilitnes hcafod, eall of •maate golde, namen \>& |>et fotspure J>e wajs undenueSen his fote, \>xt waes «ai of n$A golde." * 8e« voL ii. p. 437, for the hallowing of this 8teej)ie. * Chron. Petrib. u. 8. " J^at hiecce l>e J>aer wees behid, hit wa>8 eall of gold and of set/lfre." * The Chronicler specially mentionH " swa manega gersumas on sceat." Something ha^l perhapH eHcapea sacrseman in." " Secrae man," it %» written by Mr. Earle. DEPAKTL'KK OF THE DAXES. 4G1 in the midst of the hlackened ruins of the monaijten'. Hut chap. xx. the brotherhood (gradually assembled, and divine service ***^V'*' , , . iM-TVice was ai^in be;;un in the minstir after ceasintr for one rwttorttj. , , June g. week.' At this point the Chrunieler places a reconciliation be- AlK-gixl tween the two Kin*^, William and Swcnd.- But we niay ^j.^^^^f suspect that nothin"* reallv hai)peneil bevond some further ^^ '/'"*'" . neg^otiation between William and Osbeorn, and jR-rhaps a further bribe to the Danish Earl. At all events, soon Dej>arture after their exploit at Peterborou»^h the Danes sailed away i>ane!4. from Ely, and, after showing: themselves for two days in *^""° '"♦• " ' ' ^ J 1070. the Tliames, they sailed towards Denmark/' laden with the wealth which the faithless vassals of Saint Peter had hel})ed to carry away from his minster. But, as the tale evidently imj)lies, their sacrileg-e was not to go unpunished. While Fate i>f the , .,.■,«, .1 plunderers they were m the midst 01 the sea a mighty storm arose of Pet«r- and drove the ships hither and thither, some to Ireland, ^'^''""i* • some to Norway, some to their own shores of Denmark. These* last landed at a King-'s town whose name seems to have been unknown to our Chronicler. Tlie treasures of Peterborough, including the precious staff, were placed in the church of the town, but, through the drunkenness of its guardians, the church and all that was in it was burned in the night, and the relics of the wealth of the Golden Boroufjh were lost for ever.' OslxMirn. who had ' Chron. Petri!). 1070. " Ami hus so ah])ot Turoldo cum to liurli, jmd J>a inunecas coinen i>a ongean, and dydan C'hri.ste.s ^^udom in J>iL>re cyrce, jMut ier lia^fde Htanden fulle Hoofeniht fi)nitan a-lcea cynnes riht." ' lb. " J?a twegeu kynj^a.s Willclm an«l Swii'i^n wunNon wehtlcHl." • Tb. " Ta t>iL'.s sumere^ oiin jxt liS norft'an of Huinbran into Toemese, lagon J»a,'r twa niht, aii>l heoldan Hy.N«>t)n to Dienniercvn." The way in which thia is brought in shows plainly that the account of Hereward's doings is a local insertion in an earlier Chronicle, which must have l>een nearly the same aa tlie extant Worcester Chronicle. See Earle, Parallel Chronicles. * The name of the town is Kfl a blank. The .account then goes on ; " f'a BySflon \wx\\ heora |?eniele«t anri>u^)t hill ^^niit rx))0(litioi) to n\\v\\ n pitiful nul, met with wn nnjjrv n'(»o|>tion from his l»roth(»r Kinjf Odb«of« Swnul. Ho WM IjnninhiHl from Denmark on nccoimt of br Swaad. tl»<* hriljo whirh ho hni! tiikon from AVilliftm.' A spiritual BUkoD c(*n8urp also foil u|>on tho Enplinh oflondors. Bishop nnammu' i^^'tholric, Bccming'ly from his prison nt AVoatminHter, jiut 222^ forth an excommunication npiiinHt all who had any share cfFetw- in tlie plunder of Potorl)on)U^h.- It is hard to see on what principle of Canon Law a Bi^-lio]) without a diocese could claii]! to exercise any such jurisdiction. But tlir lonj^ sojourn of -.^^thelric at PeterlM^rouf»'h may have heen felt to fr\\Q him 8om(^ kind of control over the house and its l>elonpins^. 1 1 is censure of the ofTenders may even have been recjuired by AVilliam as an act of policy ; it cortaiidy would have a deeper effect on the minds of the men of the fenland than any censure jmt forth by Abbot Turold or Bishop Remig^ius. After this exploit, which the most zealous patriotism can hardly brin^ itself to look on as glorious, we hear nothing" of the doings of the revolted English during the remainder of the year or during the following winter. Our only notice belongs to quite another part of Eng- id and forhargod, i^Clmihtig God hit gemiltse hurh his ni} cele niild- b6ftneMe." ' Flor. Wig. 1070. " Imminente autem festivitate S. JohanniH Baptietee oomM £sl>emu8, cum claHse (jua* in Iluinbnii flumine hiemaverat, Dane- marciaro a^liit ; Bed frator huuh Rex Danorum Suanus, ilium, propter {)ecuniani, quara contra voluntatem Danorum a Rege Willelmo acceperat, eilegavit." ' Cbron. Petrib. 1070. " pa. herde i^gelric biscoj) }>et gcBecgon, \>a, amanxumcde he ealle J»a men J>a J>a;t yfel da;de baifden don." The Wor- ce*tcr version would seem to place the excommunication before the fjlundering, and to make it refer to some earlier wrong done to ^thelric himAelf personally ; " And man hergade )^t mynster ait Burh, J>a;t waron )« menn ]>e ae biscop vEgelric ar amanHumade, forpov ]>e hi namon \>(fr ran Yai he ahle." SUBMISSION OF EADHIC. 463 land. Eadric the Wild, the hero of the western march, chap. xx. now niaile his suhmission to the Kin^.' This event is \^i,7^J^° mentioned immediately after the retirement of the Danish "'»^"* ^" •^ . William. fleet, and in a way which might sug-n^st that the two . Fun.— thinn;^ were in some way conneeted. Perhaps Eadric *,o-o"* ' thou«^ht that, with the failure of Danish help, all hope for En<^land had passeil away, and that there was nothing to be done but to make what terms he could with the Conqueror. For the next year our accounts, though not Norman easy to reconcile, are comparatively full, and the Norman n^h ver- account is decidedly more discreditable to William than T"" "' •' the evcoU the English. And the renewed troubles of this year^^t''© seem to be spoken ot as the beginning ot a new and worse state of things, a state of greater wretchedness for the conquered.'^ The centre of the insurrectionary Revolt of or patriotic movement was the Isle of Ely. It is there- my. fore almost certain that the Isle had been held by the insurgents ever since the appearance of the Danish fleet in those waters in the summer of the year before. No Descrip- /•T»-i- 111 Mi/^ii T% n ^^^^ of the part ot Britain could he more easily deiended. iJetore country, the great works of drainage which have changed the course of the rivers and wliollv altered the face of the ' Flor. Wig. 1070. '* Vir strenuLssimus Edricus, coguoniento Silv.iticus, cujus HUpra mununiniua, cum Rege Willehuo pacificitur." Tlie subniifision of Eadric i« placed between the departure of Osbeom in June and the conaecration of I^anfranc in August. ^ Orderic'a account of the defence of Ely and the fate of Eadwine ami Morkere (521) foUows immediately on the description of the momentary reconciliation of English and Normans (see above, p. 327). A little way on (533), after describing the events of the year 107 1, he gives a .special picture of Norman (H)| di;^iity of a Itill.' Tlie only means of ii|>i)nMich were the rouds of liftman and earlier date, roads which, in such a country, necessarily tk the fomi of eauseways. The j^rcat Akeman Street led stnii^>ht to Ely from ^Villiam'8 newly huilt castle of Cam- hrid|^»/ while another road, of uncertain date, Kil from his other fortress of IIuntin«^lon, ' itself conncH'ted witli Cani- Aporottch bridjje by the K<»man ^'ia Dcvana. Hut the main ap- ai AldrvUt. pr^^ch was not by either of these ^rcat roads, but at a I>oint calietl Aldreth, a corruption of the name of the patron saint .Ethelthryth, where the ancient course of the Ouse. now shallow indeed, is crossed by a causeway and • On the geo.^TJipliy of this diHtrict see Profcawr C. C. Bal»iii;,'t<>ir8 Ancient CambritlgcHhire, unl lll'KI.NN \KI). \aU .• 1/,/ft, Hraiidon >^ 161 TIIK UKYOI.TS AOAINST WIM.lAM. cMAp II. cniintn*. till' Ihlo of VAy wim htritlly an ihlaiul. It iii a tract Hli^fhtly raimtl alM>ve the Ifvol of the Hurroumlin^ WHton», and at tlu» |>oint \vIuti» tin* ^^n-at niinHler still Htmnilrt it nniy \h* naid to risi> to tlir (li«^niity <•{' a liill.' The only nutans of approach \ven» tlu* roacU of Roman and i«arlior dato, roads which, in snch a country, necessarily took the form of causeways. The pnat Akcnnm Street led straig'ht to Ely fn>ni William's newly huilt castle of Cam- bridgv,* while another road, of uncertain date, le*l from his other fortress of Huntin^lon, ' itself connected with Cam- Aporoach hrid^' by the H<»man \*ia Devana. Hut tlir niaiii :ip- *t AldrvUi. proach was not by either of these ^reat roads, but at a point called Aldreth, a corrui)tion of the name of the patron sjiint .Ethelthryth, where the ancient course of the Ouse, now shallow indeed, is crossed by a causeway and * On the geography of this diHtrict see Professor C. C. Babing^ton's Ancient CambridgeHhirc, anci the map. I learned much from a perHonal exjuiiination of the ground between Cambridge and Ely in June, 1870, in company unth the Professor and with Mr. lionney of Saint John's College. A vivid dcHcription of the whole country, of which the Ely fenland is only a part, iii given by Orderic (537 D), but it is copied from the Life of Saint Ctuthlac by Felix of Crowland, wliom Orderic has oddly confounded with Felix Hishop of the East-AnglcH (537 A), who died in 647 (Ba;da, ii. 15; iii. 30) in the century before Guthlac lived. The extract is given in \Vri;;ht*K Bio^Taphia Britannica Litteraria, i. 248. ** Est in mediterraneorum Anglorum Britannia; partibus imuiensae magr>itudiriis acerrinia palus, »re cestre Sy ylcan naraa ys nemned Grante- cea«ter." The remarkable thing is that Camboritum, which in Bseda's day waa still "a waste che.ster" (see above, p. 3131, is spoken of as if it were an actual town. Felix and Bicda were c(>ntemporary, but P'eiix must have been the younger man, and it is just possible that the town may have been Mi up again before he wrote. * See above, p. 221. ^ See above, p. 222. frvrtrmn's Sfrmtui ContjitesL Vot 21 Tf tiuti paife46^ THE FENIAN!) IN THE ELEVENTH CENTURY. ILLUSTRATINC. THIi CAMPAIGN OK IIERKWARl). For the Bd&iaies of the Clarmdon JVess. THE ISLE OF ELY. 4G5 brid^.^ As the causeway cuts throu<^h what seems to chap. xx. be a British site, the camp which biars the strangti name of Belsar's Ilill, it cau hardly fail to be itself of Iloman work. 2 It was here that the Isle was most accessible to an enemy, and the course of the rivtT was further protected by a causeway furmin;^ an aiiy^le with that by which the bridge is approached.^ Within the Isle then, HerewanI in a position as strong in its way as if it had stood on the height of Laon or Lincoln, the revolted inhabitants of the fen district, probably with Ilcreward as their chief, had remained without interruption during the winter, lii the course of the next year an altogether new turn was given to atlairs when the force of the outlaws was strength- ened, if strengtheneil it was, by the accession of several men of higher rank and renown from other parts of Enirland. 'a' \Miile the conquest of Northern England was going Position of on, Eadwine and Morkere, whose treason had hliglited j^ ^J"^. the first attempt at resistance within their own Earldoms,* ^*^"- were dwelling in William's court in a character which we may call at pleasure that of guests, prisoners, or hostages. At last they felt dissatisfied with their condi- tion. Bad men, we are told, stirred up strife between them and the King.'' William, so runs another account. ' On Aklreth cau.seway, see Ancient Cambridgeshire, p. 4^. In th« GcHta Uerewartii (57) the place is called " Abrehcde .... ubi minus aquis ft paludu pni'cingitur [insula]," In the Ely Hintory, 339, it U '* Alrehethe, ubi alced very much as if it had been broken dou-n by Hereward and not mended hince. ' See Ancient Cambriiigcshire, 49. ' Uaddenham Causeway, called from a village in \Ui course, with a Urge and striking church, but containing notliiug of eariy date. * See above, p. 193. ^ Ord. Vit. 531 A. "Rex Guillelmus, consilio pravorum male usus, laudi 8U» damnum ingessit." VOL. IV. H h THE REVOLTS AOAINST WIM.IAM. r.UL. thougtit tn c)uin|ro their BtAtc of honoumMo roittniint into TWtImt* out of arttml ilun^mH nnd fottort*. l1ioy now loft his •owtuKi C€Hiri and o|HMily n»voltod.* Wc have no detjiilfl of their ^T^y. duinjjw, but they neeni to have cn^^n^^cd in vn^ue and i)ur- ■071. iMHk^U'ftB attemptit nt in8iirri*oiion, which could not fail to come to nothing". I1u»y wnndere) that E.x»]wine "bci mensihus a Scotia et Guallis vel Anglia auxilia Hibi quai- jiivit;" but he wrongly places the wanderings and death of Eadwine after the Burrender of his brother. The six monthH may possibly help us U) a date- for Eadwine's revolt — six months before the surrender of Ely in October. See Mow, p. 480. • Flor. Wig. 1071. • Chron. Petrib. 107 1. "Ea^Jwine eorl wearff ofslagen arhlice fram liis agenum mannum." The Worcester Chronicle and Florence leave out the adrerb. • Ord. Vit. 521 B. " Interea trcs fratres, qui ei familiares praecipuiquo Batellite8 erant, Normannis eum prodiderunt." • lb. *• Ad hoc facinus exastuatio marina Normannos adjuvit, quae ad rivulum quemdam Eduinum morari coegit, eique fugam penitus a^lemit." DEATH OF EADWINE. 467 his first, passage of arms may have happoncdJ At the chap. xx. head of twenty horsemen the Earl gallantly ^^ithstruKl JJ^ ^j^*^ the attacks of a party of Normans, till he was slain, as ''jH'l »'y it would seem, by the hands of the three traitors.^ lliey mcu. brought his head to William, hoping of course to win liis favour, but, as such traitors have usually Wen dealt with I'rom the days of David onward, their rewartl was outlawiy instead of honour/* Tluis died the Earl of the Mercians, the grandson ofHwch*- Leofrie and Godgifu, the brother-in-law of Harold. The historian who records his death waxes eloquent on his high birth, his personal beauty, his piety, his lx>unty to the clergy and the poor.^ Tlie news of his death, we are told, caused grief throughout all England, not among the English only, but among the Normans and French, who wept for him as for a comrade or a kinsman.^ Of the feelings of the royal maiden who, like so many other royal maidens, had been made the sport of her father's policy, we hear nothing. AVilliam himself — it is the last of his acts recorded by his panegyrist — shed tears over Eadwine*s lifeless head.^ All this may be ; Eadwine doubtless had many winning personal qualities, and knew how to make himself the ornament and darling of a court. But all this does not relieve him from the guilt of betraying every cause which he undertook, and breaking his faith to every lord to whom he plighted it. Those were days in which men both drew and sheathed their swords somewhat hastily; * On the question whether Eailwine ever entered the Isle of Ely, see Appendix 00. " Ord. Vit. 521 B. "Tres fratres .... ipsi eumdeni cum xx. c«jnitil>u.s toto nuju Bcsc defendentem occidenint." ' lb. C. " ProditoreH, <|ui jiro favorr illius v'x t.-ij^iit lioiiiiiu mu dtli n bant, severuH in exHiliuiii expulit," ' 8ee above, p. 182. * See above, p. 180. * Ord. Vit. 521 C. '• Kcx Guillulnius, coni{KTtu prmliiionc i[uk nepe IntUH Merciorum CoUiiul periorat, pietatc niotun flcvlt." II li 2 468 TIIK REVOLTS AOAINST WILMAM. our. UL thc%' wore day* in which cmtlm won* lightly t4ikcn and lightly hrnkon. But ovon in those diiyn it must liavc Ikhmi ft special pnvmincnce in ovil to have In'm faithlcwi alike to Eadward, U^ Ilaruld, to Eadgari and to William. Uaiki&n The surN-iving SOD of iEIfgar, ISfc^rkoro, still i^crhapt {UJJL^,, holding in name the Karldom to which ho had hccn called •* ^y- in Eadward 8 days by the Northumbrian rebels,' si'ems hitherto to have aotoil mainly under the influence of his brt»ther.' Now that Eadwine was dead, he showed, for a while at least, a hig^her spirit. U*' joined the outlaws in the Isle, which had now become the resort of the more Legeod of daring spirits from every part of England. Legend indeed otRdm. 1>*^ peopled the Camp of llefuge, as it has been romantically callwl, with a crowd of persons who unclou])tedly were not there. We hear of Earl Eadwine, notwithstanding his death, of Archbishoj) Stigand, notwithstanding his imprisonment at Winchester,^ of Abbot Frithric of Saint Alban's, whose name at once plunges us into an atmosphere of myth."* IViiMiBB But there is no doubt as to the presence of Morkere,^ of of Swartl Barn aad the Northumbrian Thegn Siward liarn," and of yEthelwine ^^J"P Bishop of Durliam, who left his shelter in Scotland to mine. share the dangers of his countrymen.'^ And there can be H^i^"^ little doubt that the life and soul of the defence was Hcre- ward himself. Though we cannot venture to accept a single * Sea Tol. ii. p. 485. ' See above, p. 20. " See above, p. 333. * See Appendix NN. * Chron. Wig. 107a ; Petrib. 107 1. " And Morkere mid scype gewende to Helig, and J>»r com .^Egelwine bisceop and Sig^varC Bam, and fcla hund manna mid heom." Plorence (1071) adds, " J/creivfirdiui vir gtrenuissimiu, com multi« aliia." Simeon (1071. 89, Hinde) add« of yEthelwine and Siward, " de Scottiu renavigantes illo advenerant." The account of Orderic (52! A) must be taken for what it in worth; " Rex Guillelmus . . . . fraudult-nter inclitum Comitcm Morcarum in Elienai insula conclusit, sibique confcederatum et nil mali machinantem vel Huspicantem ob- ■edit." * See above, p. 21. ^ See above, p. 337. HEIJEWARI) DEFENDS THE ISLE. 469 detail of his legendary history as matter of historical fact, chxf. ix. yet the mere abundance of such detxiils shows the impression which he made on the popular ima^ij-ination. His legendary prominence makes it pretty certain that, even if Ilercward was not the formal leader of the defenders of the Isle, it was on the strength of his heart and arm that the hopes of the defence mainly rested. And one of those incidental notices which in the history of these times often prove so murh, shows that the spirit which was kindled by the revolt of the Fenland spread itself into shires lar away from Peter- borough and Ely. A party of the valiant men of Berk- rnsucceai*. shire, tenants of Saint Mary of Abingdon, set forth to join of tllj^ the new champions of England. They were surprised on J^^kuhire their march by a b(xly of the King's troops, and underwent various punishments for their rebellion.^ Tlie one instance of such zeal which happens to be recorded was doubtless not the only instance that took place ; brave or desperate men from various parts of England doubtless pressed to join in the defence of the spot which now alone was truly England. And if legend is allowed to count for anything, Alleged none of the warlike guests of Saint yEthclthryth showed ^i^^„|^ ^f^ greater zeal in the common cause than the monastic ^y- indwellers of her island. !Monks and warriors sat side by side in the refectory, the chief leaders being honoured with a place at the table of the Abbot, while weapons of war hung from the walls and the roof, that the comrades, lay and spiritual alike, might at once spring to their harness at any call of sudden need.- Everything bade fair f^r a long defence; men might deem that, though the rest of * See above, p. 33. The writer addn, " Circuraventi in itinerc captiqiie incarcerantur, et satis misere affliguntur." ' Gesta Horuwarili, 64. A Norman Kpy givtH the report i)f thf «li>ingH 'in the refectory, and addH ; " Hoc ntnipo niihi pni* cunctis ununi et valdo Diirificum est de illia omnibus quot tho Nonnun, yvi tin* IkIo of Kly mi^ht lonjf rtMiinin iiHlo|M»ndoi»t English ^nnimL With ho|H'* like this it is inipoH«il»lr not to gympnthizo; yet, from our calmer )x>ini of view, we cnn see tlmt tin- eau.ry of Ramsey, c. 86, to which 1 have alruaa sie healfe." Si) Flor. Wig. (1071); ">Sed hoc audito Rex cum butsecarlis in orientali plag& insulie onineni illin exitum obstruxit, et ponteni in occident-ili duoruni niilliari- oruni longuni fieri jussit." Tliu lai»t time wu heunl «)f the '* but^ccarli " was when they were so eager to fight for Eiulgar and again.Ht William. See vol. iii. pp. 525, 531. ' See Orderic, 522 C. It in true tliat in 680 C, HjHjaking of William KufuH, he sayH, "Guillelmua Kex Guillelmum de Guarenn& Comitom Huth- regia conBtituit," but this can hanlly bo the firnt grant. ' See voL iii. p. 647. Tlie incidental mention t>f Frederick's lamU at Truuipington in DomeMday (I9^>'') and in Norfolk (ii. 165 6, 1706) Moenm to show that he wan dead at the time of the Survey. Thin ftdb* in witlj the «tory of liirt being killed by Hereward, which in found in tlio (ieuta, 46, 54, 61, and iu the Homewhat lK;tter authority of the Liber de Hviltk, 295 ; " iiore- 173 TIIK KRVohTS A0AIN8T WILMAM. our. IX, who luifl become ono of the inoKt ]»roiniiu'nt ti^uroK in the Icgviulary history, and who npjH'urs in th»' Survey as the owner of Inr^ c^tatoH in the n(M^)i)M>urin;r land HI* ffvAl of Holland.* Homancv endows him with tlie nuirriapo a^^mrj •'^^^ heritage of the mythical Luey, the lon^^-liv»Ml and ■'•"^•'••' ofli'H- wedded daiig-hter of Karl yKlfjL^'^ar,* and therefore, according to one version, the niece of Ilrreward himwlf. History shows that there is so much of truth in the myth that Ivo really had n wife, certainly not a (lan«^h(cr of iElfgar, but still of Enpflish parcnta^ife, who on Nor- man lips was spoken of ae expected, the William*! royal head-quarters;^ but the energy of William carried ,juj^rten? at him to every point at which his presence could be needed. <-'anibridge. We find him in one tale directing his naval operations against the eastern part of the Isle from Ikandon,"^ a * See above, p. 369. ' The second volume of Domesday contains a crowd of references to the death of William Malet at some time before the date of the Survey; see PP- ^94, 334^. 373 ''» 380 6, 407, 440, 441, 442 h, 444. In tliree other entries things get more distinct. In I47 we read of land being held " die quo pater R. MaUt ivit in Jiorvitium Koi,ns." In 33a h wo read of land-s in Suffolk ** ex hf)c erat sesitud WillelnuH Malet (juando ivit in sorvitium Regis ubi mortuus est." Lastly, in 133 6 we find lands in Norfolk claimed by Robert Malet, who ** ell8, and how Hereward contrived to burn tower, pythoness, and all.'' Tales again are told of the various disguises in wliich he made his way into the King's camj) Regis coruun apud BranduDe." So in Hist. Eli. 239, " Rex ... ad Bmn- dunam reoeaait." The Great Ouse anciently ran into the sea at Wisbech ; it now Collowa Ihe course of the Little Ouse to Lynn. See Ancient Cam- bridgeshire, 69. » Gecta, 65 ; Hist. Eli. 233. ' Gesta, 57. •* I^atitudo ibi iiii. stadiorum extenditur, ubi adductis instnuncntis et structuris lignoruin et lapidum et ex onini ^encre Htruis, aggregationcm in palude viam, licet nimis sibi perinutilem et anguHtiin, straverunt ad magnum quippc flumen apud prsedictum locum, scilicet Abrehede, etiam in !U[uk maxim.is arbores et trabes conjimctas collocavo- nint, Hubterius connexis pcllibus bidentimn integre et versipelles excoriatis et aere plenis infusis, ut onus supereuntium melius sustentaretur et pondus." ' Hist. EIL 736. " Cotingelade " at least implies Cottcnham. * The tale is told at length in the Gesta, 58. * The storj- of the witch is given in the Gesta, 68-76 ; Hist. Eli. 234-337. In the former (75) she appears as "phithonissa mulier." EXI'LUITS UK HKKKNVAKl). 475 to spy out the hostile forces,* and of the way in which ciixf. xx. he harrieil tlie places which remaineil in the King-'s obetli- ence.2 WTiat amount of truth there may \>v in each particular story it is impa utlagan ha lallc on hand eodan, pant wxa Egelwino biaceop and Morkere corl, and t-allr t>a |h) nud heom weeron." So Florence, 107 1 ; ** Illi, ubi so videruut siuesse concluiMM, ropugnare dcsirftcbant." * Ord. Vit. 521 A. ** Versipellea inter eo« nuntil diacurrerunt, et dolosam conditionum nequiter pcpigorunt, scilicet ut se Comes Regi rodtlerei, eumque Uex pacifice ut fiduiii ainicuin su.sciporut. OltneiMug nein|K.< diu poterat acne ibidem inaccxMaibilitato ItK-i dofcudero uut, nimid vi occidunto. 476 THK «KV«U.T8 A0AIN8T WILLIAM. emxT. XX. wroD^ in hringin^ \hA\\ VjnUvinv and Morkrro into tlio I«lt», anil ftill more wn)np in ninkin^ both of Uiem CHcnpo,* A IB ynAiSihW rijjht in nttril)utinj; tlu» Hurrmdor of the IhIo to the tn»arhery of the Abbot and monkK, wlinso patriotiKm ■■■^ fnilixl them when William seized on all tlw landn (»! tin- monaster}' beyond the Iwrders of the Isle iti^elf.^ At all events it is certain that the greater part of the defenders of Ely came into William's hands. They were dealt with as he thoug-ht goen to the realm if Morkcrc were allowed to remain at large. In cither case, he was Punuth- incndix 00. ' The stor)- in U>\d in the Gesta (78), and more fully in the Ely History (240). In the former version Abbot Thurstan at first patriotically flees along with the Earls, and takes the treasures of the church witli him. As the e8ca{>c of the Earla is undoubtedly mythical, the escape of the Abbot is most likely no less so. ' Chron. Wig. 1072. "And se kyng nam heora scypa and waepna and manega sceattas, and l>a menn ealle he toe and dyde of heom ])(i:t he woldc." In Peterborough, 1071, " J?a men he ateah swa mca he tcolde." We may compare the wonls of William of Poitiers in describing the vengeance of William at Romney; see vol. iii. p. 534. * See above, p. 53. * Flor. Wig. 1 07 1. " Comitem caeterosque per Angliam divisos, partim custodia mancipavit, partim, manibus truncatia vel oculis erutis, abire penniait." SUBREXDER OF MnRKERE. 177 l)Ut into ward, but as hi> was entrusted to the keeping chaf. xx. of Roger of Beaumont, it may l>e that the dungeons and fetters of which we hear are only a figure of speech.' He remained a prisoner in Normandy all the rest of the HU mo- days of the Conqueror, and obtained but a single moment puIwukj of freedom at his death.- '^7- The like bondage, the like momentary glimpse of liu\>r\n- freedom, was the fate of Si ward Barn.' In the case siVarU of Bishop ^Ethelwiue earlier services may have been ^^"• allowed to count against his later enmity. lie was j^^JJ^ne simply committed to the care of Abbot Ealdred of >n '^ard at Abuiguun. Abingdon,"* and we have seen that this kind of custody did not involve any special hardship.'' lie reached the Abbey, it would almost seem, about the time when the tenants of the house were making their gallant but vain attempt to carry help to the defenders of Ely.*^ Their imprison- fault was visited on their lord the Abbot, who was first ^^i^^ imprisoned in the castle of Wallingford, and then, like E^^ilred- iEthelwine himself, transferred for the rest of his life to the milder custody of Bishop Walkelin at AVinchester."^ ' Ortl. Vit. 521 A, B. "Rex metuen.s iie Mi^rcarua injuriaa sibi et com- patriotis auiei neijuiter illatas ulcisctTetur, et jk-T cum aliijuae rteditionea in regno Albionis implacabiles orirentur, ilium sine manifesto reatu vinclis injecit, omnique vita sua in ergastulo coercuit ot cautche Rogerii oppiJani Belnionti:) mancipavit." ' See Yinr. Wig. 10S7. ' lb. * Both Chronicles mention the sending of /Etheli^'ine to Abingdon and his death flo«m after ; " poxm bisceop Egelwinc he sende t<> Abbandune and he J>a>r forSfcnie Hona hte« wintres." I'lorence, who gives a somewhat ilif- ferent account under the last year, here translates the Chronicles. See Appendix PP. So the local History of Abingdon (i. 485, 493) ; "Tulibus tentatis (juum diversi ordinis et dignitatis viri so comnuscuisaent, tum episcopus DunehuensLs (iuckjuo, yKgelwinus nomine, inter eiw cjui capti sunt inventus, et Abbendoniam missus, in captione ibi ad suic mortis dogeus diem nbiit." • See ab«)V«'. p. 388. " The passage quoted in p. ^ji follows immediately on the last extract. ' Hist. Mod. Ab. i. 486. " In illorum ctiam dominum, id est, Abba- tern Ealdredimi, qui et Brichwinug dictus est (binomius cnim emt\ Regis iniuiicitia est perhvta, adeo ut absque dilatiune, ejus pneccpto, apud i7$ THE nKVOLTS AOAINST WIM.IAM. c-HAf. 11. T\k9 Kinjf tlion prnnt«Ml tho AMh'V of Al»in^tl<>n to n aM^^U Gorman monk fri)m Juinii'pct*, who howt'vrr lK?ars the A'^f*'*- fin^iUrly KiipIihh-»oundinp nnmc of Adolohn or iKthel- helmJ His tank wait n (liilicult one, and one in which he 0eom8 to have had to tnist nlx>ut iHjually to Kn^linh SaftHafi tongues and to Norman swords. Tlu' Kin^-'s ofHcers were Ahbm^aa OODfltantly doin^ dama^^ to tlic h(>us(> liy exactions of T*riou8 kinds, in witlistnndin^ which the clo<|ucnce and lej^l knowUxlj^ of certain of his Kn<^lisl» monks stood MIlilMy him in pood stcad.^ On the other liand, the neccs- nicsiteof sities of the times, and tlie revolts and conspiracies which Um Abbot. ^^»pe g^jj] everywhere g^oing on — especially, we may be Bure, in so English - hearted a district as Berkshire — made it unsafe for even an Abbot to go about without a military guanl.^ He had also to send men to take a share in the defence of the newly-built castles of Oxford, Wallingford, and Windsor/ and moreover to provide for the defence of his own monastery.'* The arms of soldiers OMiellum WalingAfunlenae in eaptione poneretur. Ali(]uanio autem post tanpoTB A pnedicto loco oductuM, in manu WintuuienHL) Epmcopi Walchelini •ervandos oominittitur, n]tU(l qucin inanKit quoad Nixit." In the other version, in p. 493, Walkelin ia not mentioned, and we read more distinctly of Eally liired merce- naries;- afterwards, wlien thinps liad got rather more He ^fmnu quiet and u Inn military tenurt'S were being generally military introduced among the occupants of ecclesiastical propey by English Thegns on an English tenure were granted out to Norman knights on a tenure strictly military.^ This process, which went on at other places as well Illu«tra- as at Abingdon, marks a stage in that gradual advance ,,r!.wth of of feudal ideas in England which has been some- I'euJ*^'"- times mistaken for the formal enactment of a Feudal System. As for Abbot Adclelm, he continued to play a certain part in public affairs during the rest of AVilliam's reign. His prisoner, the deposed Bishop of Durham, died Death of ^'Kthel- in the year following his first imprisonment.'* His sue- ^ine. cessor was neither Norman nor English, but one of tliat ^°7** intermediate class whom both Harold and William found it convenient sometimes to favour. He was Walcher, a Lotharingian of Liittich,'' in whose appointment \vc may * Hist. Ab. ii. 3. " Tali in articulo bujus fortunie militeti trammiarini ID Angliain venientea favore colebantur pnecipuo." " lb. *• Primo quidein niercenariis in hoc utebatur." ' lb. "His sopitia incursibus, quum jam Kugia edicto in annalibua ann«>- taretur quot de episcopiis, quodve de abbatiis ad publicatn rem tuendam militea (si forte hinc quid cau8sa> prof)ellend£B contingeret) cxigcrcntur, eiiidem donativis prius retentis. Abbas raansiones posseMionuui eccIeHite |)crtinentibu8 inde delegavit, edicto cuique tenorc parendi de suie jwrtionis niansione." Tlien follows the passage about the Thegns whp died at Senlac, quoted in p. 33. Among these military tenants were doubtless the kinsfolk of whom the writer of the Appendix ci)nq)lains. * See above, p. 477. ' " Genere Ix)tharinj,ais," s.ay.«j Florence, 1072. Simeon (1071. 89, Hinde), more definitely, "de clero [mark the monk's view of things] LeiMliccnsiB ecclesia," and adds, " Invitatus namque ab i|«o Rege venerat ad ilium, pro- sapiu clani.H, honestus moribus, divin.T ac sa'cularis .icientin' gratia pm'r. 11 I. _# ^^^ ^'^ conaecrmted at Wiiuhcstor, Imt l>v thr haiuls of liis IhiHuMB. own Metropolitan.* Tlio I^ady Kiul^yth wan ])rcHent at * ' the cerpmony, and as tlu» Hihhoj>-oIect, n man of tall Htnturc, with white hair and a rosy count4'imnco, waa hrou^^ht Ix'foro his consecrators, the Lady, rominchtl j>orhapH of the outward s^jriaf of prvsenec of her dejwrted lord, exclaimed, '* Here we have i!^Xmn- • goodly martyr.'* Later events caused the words of the widow of the saint to be looked on as a proplu'cy.' ■ f tiu tuuulu of Waiiam cumes to vu i/. 1071. The monks of Ely — so runs the local history or leg-end — 11 were punisheil as they deserved for their treason. Tlic tale carries Thurstan and his companions as far as Warwick to make their suV»mis,sion to the King-."^ There can he no doubt that they did submit, and that their submission destroyed the hopes of the defenders of the Isle. A picturestjue tale describes William as coming to Ely, as entering the minster, but as not daring- to draw near to the shrine of the virgin patroness of the spot. He was too well aware of the wrongs which he and his had done to the patrimony of Saint ^thelthryth ; so, like the humble publican, he stood afar off, and offered a mark of gold on the altar,"* Strange to say, while the King ' This ftp|>cars from the statement of Archbishop Ralph in his letter to Pope Calixtus (X Scriptt. 1744), that Thomas consecrated three Bishops of Durham, but none of them at York, compared with what follows. ' Will, Malm. Gest. Pont. 272. " Pnedictum id ab Edgithu Reginft, relictA Regis Edwardi. Qua? quum vidisset Walkerium Wintoniai ad con«ccrandum duci, ceesario lacteolum, vultu roseum [compare the de- scription of Eadward in vol. ii. p. 27], statura praegrandem, 'Pulcrum,* tdif *hic martyrem habemus,* conjectura videlicet immoderatae gentis ad pnesagiendum inducta." William seems to have been as incredulous as to the prophetic powers of Eadgyth as Stigand was as to those of her husband. See vol. iii. p. 12. ' Hist. Eli. 741. * Ilist. Eli. 245. '*Ad monasterium denique veniens, longe a sancto corpore virginis stans, marcam auri super altare projecit, propius accedere non auflufl, verebatur sibi a Deo judicium inferri pro malis quae sui in loco patraverant." WILLIAM AT I:LY. 481 was in the church, the monks wore in the refectory, chap. xx. Their untimely meal was hroken in uj^n by Gill)ort of Clare, who asked whether they could not dine at some other time, when Kin^' William was actually present in the minster.* Iliey left the l>oard and rushed into the church; but the Kinj*" was jjune.- His work had l>een A cMtle done even in that short visit. He had marked out the Ely. site for a castle within the monastic jjrecinct, and he had already g-iven orders for its buililiii«^ by the work of men pressed from the three shires of Cambridg^e, Huntiuji^lon, and Bedford.^ Aldreth too, the key of the Island, was Al.lreth to receive a i^'arrison of forei'^niers faithful to the Kin;^.* *^*'^^*^° ' Meanwhile the monks followed AVilliam to \Vichford, a place at a short distance from Ely on the road to Aldreth. There, by the intercession of Gilbert, who had aroused Finen Uiil them in the refectory, they were admit teil to an audience. Abbey. \Vith some difliculty they were allowed to purchase the King's peace by a fine of seven hundrcil marks of silver — no bad interest for the one mark of gold which the King had offered to Saint iEthelthryth. On the ai)pointed day Spoliation the money, raised by the sacrifice of many of the orna- ehurch ments of the church, was brought to the Kin^-'s officers ^'■numentrt ' ° o U» j>»y the at Cambridge. But, alas, through some fraud of the fine, moneyers, the coins were found to be of light weight."^ ' Hist. Eli. 246. "O miseri et vecordes, num alii vice pnvndcre non liceret, dum Hex apud voh est et in eccle.sii consistit ■" On the iinport;inco of the dinner-hour in monastic revolutions, see above, p. 413. ' lb. "Quo dicto, rolictis mcnsis, nd ecclesiam omnes cucurrcre, sed Kegem non invenere." • lb. 245. " Ipso auteni, pnesidio intra septa inonachonim dolocat*), et qui id opu.s conficerent de Cantehrigiu", Iluntcdunin', ct IU'iuleri« examinata invenitur hiibuisse." " I)ra;,ni.a " seems to bo Miniply the (Jn-ek ip^yfia = mauipnltm. It wouhi soeui as if the omamenU were actually coined down in the monastery. VOL. IV. I i 481 TIIK KKV0LT8 AUAINST WILLIAM r. UL Willian) i«*ma wn>th ; hin )>eace nhould \tv ri'lusctl to tluin ftlt«^ift»tliiT. At la*it liis forlH*nmiu'o \\i\h |mrclmscHl l»y n lurlluT fine of thnv hundriHl nmrkH, the niinin^ of which in vol veil tlie lo«s of omunients "yet more holy and i»re- eioiu than thone which had Ikhmi ulrondy Micriiiccd.' The deposition of AbtK)t Thurstnn was nt h^aut ditiousscd in William's conncils;^ hut in the end he was allowed Dnih of to retain his oflice till his death six years later, when j^i * another raid was made on the jireciouK thin«j;^ of the Tlwoiiwinc monaster}'.^ The next AhlK)t, Theodwine, a Nonnan gl- monk from Jumiei^'s, )»rou*^ht ahout the restonitinn of 1076-1079. gQme of the lost j»^o(xl8. After a short incum])en(y of A ■ three years Theodwine dicnl, and the aii'airs of the monas- tery were prudently administereil for a time by a monk named Godfrey, who was afterwards removed to the He I Al»l>ey of Malmesbury.* In his day a linal settlement UntUufthc of the rij^htfi and projH^rty of the Abbey was made, and ^^'' the record of it gives us another of those glimpses of the jurisprudence of the age which seem to luring us sjKJcially ' The liat (Hwt. Eli. 247) is worth preserving ; "Totum quod in ccclesii ex auro et ai^^^ento residuum fuit, in8U])er imaginem aanctie Maris cum poerosuo sedentc-ru in throno, niinihilitcT fahrefactain, quain /ElfMJnua Al)ba.s [aeoond Ablxjt, from 981 to about 1016. See Hist. Eli. pp. 174, 178, 194, 197] fecerat de auro et argento, comminutum est; similiter imagines sanc- tarum virginum [yEtheltliryth and the other virgin saints of the place] niulto urnatu auri et argenti spoliatu.* sunt, ut pretium pecunia; cxsolvi (lueat." One is reminded of the reckoning of the ways and means of Athens in Thucydides, ii. 13, where we find the sacred offerings, public and private, counted aa a source of revenue, and specially the gold on the statue of Athene, "wtpiaiptrhv &.irav, like that of Saint /EtheltliryLh. Tl»e local writer addii mournfully that, after all the sacriBces made by the monks, " nihilo- minus Kj>enita,* (juietis fiduciil caruerunt." ' Hi.-ry of Saint Wulfstan in p. 379. ' lb. This happened both at Elly and at Wentworth. Some of the things seized and taken to the King's treasury at Winchester were the gifts of " bonorum executor Stigandus Archiepiscopus " (see vol. iii. p. 70), words pleasant to read in 1076. * On Theoenediction from Kemigius. C'ompju-e aU)ut liattle, aUive, p 409. I i 2 181 THE REVOLTS AOAINST WILLIAM. our. »A uj. xMlhin tho IhIo than thoso of Hinhop .Ktholwinc nntl Karl Morkcrv. All oW \uu\ yiclJiil ; thf Kiii^, wo arc U)K1, and all hi* host liatl cntiTtnl the Isle and had como as near llrfvwKnl to the Ahbcv as Wichford,* when Ilen-ward. with a Kmall JItS* '^ l»and of comnides liktMninde■ i i.is Liter uifol of Hereward endij, but le^^nd f^oes on to tell how he still UhI the life of an outlaw, how he still remained the terror of the Normans, and from the wood by his supiKjsi'd ances- tral home at Bourne harried at pleasure the lands of nine shin?s, as far as the distant town of Warwick.'' The Abbey of Peterboroug^h, under its Norman Aljbot, was an object ' G«tta, 79. ** SuhjungenB etiam Ivc;,'ciii esse npud Wycheford projH' uniuH stjujii cum omni huo cxercitu." ' lb. " Rci>entc hoc fecit cum suIh navibuH cjuaa habel)at bene armis muniUui ad cuHtodiendas aquaM in circuitu insula, in quoddam mare wide vocatum juxtA Welle ftecessit, magnum et spatioHum lateribuH a^juarum et liberon exitu^ habenK." " Marc wUU vocatum" in, I guppoBC, Hiinply the " great and wide »ea." Authentic history quite hears out the legend aH regards the escape of Hereward. All Hurrendered, say both the Chronicles, '* buton Herewardo ane, and ealle ^ K* ndd him woldon, and he hi ahtlice ut Uedde." So Florence ; " Omnes, excepto Herewardo viro strenuissimo, qui per paludes cum i>aucia evaKit, Regi »e dedebant." Neither authority gives any further account of him. ' According to the l^^nd (Gesta, 81) Hereward first " in BrunneHwald tnuisivit, et similiter in magnis silvis Northamtune crhabitavit, terram igne et ferr«> devastanx." Then we are told that the forces of nine shiros were brought again«t him, but seven only, even counting Lincoln and Holland as s^'parate shires, are mentioned. The others are Northampton, Cambridge, Leicester, Huntingdon, and Warwick. I prcsunie that tlie Hyde writer mixed together these more inbind exploits of Hereward with the defence of Ely, when he said (295) that " Herewardus tentans rebellare, conducta undique validu manu, meJiterranea Angliae loca, in (juorum paludibuH delitCHcebat, die et nocte ca*de et rapiiia complebat." The mention of Warwick also, which we should hardly have looked for, must be taken in connexion with the Domesday entries about Hereward in that shire. LATER STOKIES (»K IIKHEWAKD. 486 of his special hatred. Tiirold, it is saiil, was once inadf chap. xx. prisoner and was driven to redeem himself at an incretlihlc ^J"* J«^*l- lu^n with price;* and we hear of a second raid on tlie monastery Tumia of itself, unless indeed this is simply the earlier one moved by borough, the licence of legend out of its proper place. As to the end of the hero, reports differ. The two chief versions Hi* muT- agree in marrying liim to a rich hnglishwonian nanutl .«fthnih. iElfthryth, who had made her own peace with the King and obtained his peace also for her husband or lover.- In Hw rccnn- one tale, after some further exploits and the refutation of ^.^^\^ ii,o some slanderous charges, he wins William's favour, and ^^^ dies quietly in the King's peace.^ Another version gives his life a more tragic end. The French poet, who gives lie luxom- the fullest account of his later days, represents AVilliam Vvmhm to as practising towards him nearly the same policy which ^^•]^'"'^- earlier in his reign he had practised towards other English- men whose power and influence he dreaded. William on his first voyage to Normandy took with him the chief Earls and Prelates of England,^ and we shall presently see Eadric of Herefordshire, now reconciled with William, accompany the King in his expedition against Scotland.^ It was another instance of the same policy when William,' if 1 rightly understand a somewhat diflieult passage, took Ilereward with him among the Englishmen who hel^^cd to \ * Gcsta, 84. r>ut who cjin believe in a ransom of thirty thouiwind poundii ? ' The story, as tt)Ul in the Gesta, is clearly ma4le up of two (IJMtinct vxrHionM. The name .^fthryth, in the corrupt fonii " .^Vlfued," cornea from Gainiar. " This version is found in the Gesta, 89-98. The whole story thus winda up ; *' Herewardus igitur, miles inHi^iis et in multi« hx^is experttw et ciy- nituH, a Kege in jfratiani HUHcoptuH, cum torri.H ct pojweiwionibus |>atrirt nui multi.s i>ostmodum vixit annis, Kcgi Wilklmo tideliler Her\'ionji ac dovoto compatriotis placens et amicis; ac sic dcmum quievit in pace, cujus animw propitiotur Deus. Amen." * See above, pp. 75-78. ' Sw the next soction. 49S TIIR KK VOLTS AOAIXST WII,LIAM. legvnd of hUdMth. .IX. Win kick the revoltcHl County of ISluini*.* In this vorsion, tun in the other, it woiiM se**m thnt the Knn:li»h liero hail rt^ally won the favour of tlie Nommn Kiuy, imr is Willinm hinis«>H ehar|»^Hl with any dotiMo dralin;^ townrdn Ili-rowanl aft«T liiu suhniission. JJut the Kinpf's jH^aoe (H)uI(I not make him wife a^iiinst the violence anil treachery of Kmuller men. He still remaineil exposed to the hatnil of men of the comiuering' race, men j>erha]iR who had sufTered from his prowess, men at all event.s whose deeds were as law- less as any of his own durinpf hin days of outlawry. He had to keep watch within and without his house, and to plant [guards when he was at his meals. Once his chaplain /Kthelward, on whom this duty fell, slumherwl at his post. A hand of Normans now attacked Ilcreward. He armed himself in ha^te ; his spear was hroken, his sword was broken ; he was driven to use his shield as a weapon ; fifteen Frenchmen lay dead by his sinpi'le arm, when four of their party ^t behind him and smote him in the back.^ This stroke broug-ht him to bis knees. A Breton knin-bt, • This I take to be the mejininfj of the olwcure paasage in Geoffrey Gaimar, Chmn. Ang.-Ni>nn, i. 22-23 ; II i avoit ainceis este, Walter del Bois avoit matr, Et dan Oeffrci cil de Meino Tint en prison une Hinieine. Ereward, qui doit aler en pees, D'or et d'argent avoit meint fes." Si en fiert qe ij. Franceia occifit ; M?;8 iiij. vindrent ^ son doB Qui I'ont f<;ru par mi lu com, Od iiij. lancen I'ont ft^ru ; N'est merveille s'il est chou." We are again reminded of the fate of Harold (see vol. iii. p, 499), and of that of Patroklos, II. xvi. 806 ; " UttlQiV Si fJLfTOKppfVOV 6^(1 Sovpl £)fjuDU n((Taw." This version seems to bo followed by the Hyde writer (295); " Voni multas denique ctedcs atque seditiones, niulta pacis fu'dora cnm Koge fiicta et temerarie violata, «juudani n.* At York Thoma^j of Hayoux was beginning that canvr of ccclesia^ttioal reform whioh has won him an lionouraMc jdaco in K)cal histor)'.' But tho Karldom of which his melrojx)litan city was the head now came ovon nominally to an end hy tho revolt and imprison- No Eari of mont of Morkoro. No l!jirl of Southern NorthunilH'rland, Dm FA appointed ^^ Deira or Yorkshire, was ever a^^aiu appointee always needful. End of the The rebellion and death of Eadwine, like the rebellion EwSom ^"^ imprisonment of Morkere, brought the Earldom of Mercia to an end as w^ell as that of Deira. It was probably at this time that the great Earldoms on the north-western border towards Wales were finally settled.'* * See above, p. 303. * See above, p. 479. ' See above, p. 372. * I think we may infer this both from the probability of the case and from the exprcRsions of Onleric (521 D), the bej^'nnings of his perfectly independent narrative after the loss of William of Poitiers ; " Rex Guil- KAHLDOM <»F CHESTKK. 489 The Earldom of IIerefem, cukr. xx. had l>eon formal within the Earldom of Harold, hut Jf '■l'>"ni '.f llcrvfunl Itliulwine prohahly kept his nominal jurisdiction over umler Chester and Shrewshury till his last revolt.* These two pitz- important border districts were formed into Earldoms ,. ^'. which had more of the character of separate principalities than it was the usual policy of William to allow. Chest^T, EarlJom of the final conquest of the great Northern campaij^n, was, under as we have seen, first entrusted to the Kinjr's stci)-son, /*i^ **,;,., ' r» I » 1070-1071. the Fleming Gerbod.- But the new Earl was 8^)on tomptod to take a part in the wars of his own country, where he sutl'ered a long* imprisonment.^ By his de- parture his English Earldom seems to have been looked on as vacated. It was now crauted to IIuMi of Avranches, Hu^jh of the son of llichard, tlie grandson of the traitor Tluir- tiarl of stan.^ The dignity, as held })y him, was clothed with ,o'-T-noi. special privileges. All the land in the shire, with the state of exception of that held by the Bishop, belonged to the i>*^atine! ^ Earl in the first instance,' and its actual possessors held it of him as their lord. In Cheshire proper therefore there were no King's Thegns, nor any immetliate tenants- in-chief of the Crown of any kind, nor were any lands held by the King himself in demesne. But in certain lelmus, dejectis, ut diximus, Merciorum maxiinis Consulihus, Eduino Bcilicet interfecto et Morciro in vinculLs coustricto, authorn i>ortion, do«orihod in tho Survey ns tho I^nd between the Merw^v and the lli])|)le, ha\-anl. and was hrld under him by a crowd of ]>etty Thepfns, who, by the nature of their t<»nurcf», seemed to have been raiwxl but little above the rank of churls or even of serfs.* These lands had been gTant<*d by AVilliam to Roj>er of Poitou, but at the time of the Survey Robert of they were a«^in held by the Crown. Robert of Rliuddlan jj^jy, also, Kinpf Eadward's armour-bearer,^ held of tlie Kinuf a North district bearin«r the vamic but sounding: title of North Wales, the l>oundaries of which it was perhaps discreet not to define more exactly.^ AVitli these exceptions, the whole of the Cheshire of the Survey, a district much larger tlian the present shire, formed what may be fairly called a prin- PriTflegM cipality in the hands of the Palatine Earl. If the privilcf^^es PaUUne ^^ ^^^^ Earls of Chester had not been exceptional, if all the ^^•»^ Earldoms of Eng^land haertu8 de Roelent tenet de Rege Nortwales, ad firmam pro xl. libris, prater illam terram quam Rex ei dederat in feudo et prater terras episcopatus." Presently we read, " Onmis alia terra est in ailvis et moris, nee potest arari." ROBEHT OF KIIUDDLAN. 49I tlu' Kmpiro.' lUit it is plain that William allowed ihc9C chap. xx. exceptional i)rivile^e8 only on the exposed frontiers of his Kin«rdom, where it was specially neetlful to strenp^lhen the hands of the local ruler. Tlie Karl of Chester had to waj^^e Hugh'- a constant war with the \Velsh,2 and in this work ^^lrl ^*"j,^ Hii<;h found an able helper in llohert, who hears the title ^^'«'***>- of Marquess in its primitive sense, as one of the first Lonl J /. ^Farchers of the Welsh borders."* On the site of Kinfj **** V^^ Grutlydd's palace of Rhuddlan, the palace which was bumetl 1073-1088. by Harold as the earnest of his great Welsh campai^-n,* a "^^ C&stle of castle and town arose, "^ from which tlic ^fanjuess Robert KhmiaUn. carried on for fifteen years a constant warfare with liis British neii^hbours.** At last, in the year after the death * See vol. i. p. 322. ' Ortl. Vit. 522 A. ** Qui [Hugo] cum Rodberto de Kdl»erto do M.ilo-pai^su, aliiscpie proceribus fcri« luultuni (Jujdlorum sanguinem effutlit." The second of the two Roberts has left his naine to the town of M;dpa8. ? lb. 670 A, " Robertus princeps militiie ejus et totius provinciii* ^ibor- nator factus est." He is directly after called ** bellicosus Ararchio" and •* Robertus Marchisus," " Marchisus audax." * See vol. ii. p. 470. ' Ord. Vit. 670 A. " Decreto Regis oppidum contra Guallos [^Tjr«jxi renaii sunt baptismate." He goeti on to H|>cak of Rolnirt ■ " MU|)erbiA et cupiUitAH, •Oa THK KKVOI.TS A0AIN8T WI1J,IAM. (lur. &i oi mc I oni|iU'n>r, tlu" ioni of iilnuMlan wnn Ininwif rut iwhof ^ff i^ ., ^„^^^ ^^f „„othcr (millVd.l.' IliH cliii-f, Karl Ko)irn of ' IU>u.l«iUn. Ilujjli. -uiiiviHl h'xH vnlinnt lifutonant many vean*. Of iwi K*. *^"'^ clnrf authority ilrnwH n niont unfavouniMt* pictun*. rm4«r f>f He ri»5omMt^l the ^rt^at Kinir in who»o Htoad he rulinl only in his jxjnwmal cor]inK^nre ^ and in his love of war and hunting; in hin nohlor (jualitics h<' liad no share. Given up to excess of every kind, hv left la'hind him a large spurious oirK])rin^ of hoth sexes ;'^ and we arc told that he was at once p^eedy and lavish, hut never lihond.' In his devotion to the sports of tlic Held he laid waste his own lands, and he paid more rcjj^ard to liunters and falconers than to citluT the priest or the hushandnian.'' Against this assemhlanfc of vices it may he a small matter to set that he substituted monks for canons in the church of Saint Werburh," and rebuilt the minster, where he cjui rV. m mortAlium posHident pcctora." The brotherhood of N«!i. ii i \\ • i..iiian \\r\n doubtless better understood at Saint Evreux than it wa« at lihuddlan • His death ik deHcribcd at length Ity Onleric (670 C, D). It \va,s f«il- lowed we are told by " nimius luctus Angloruni et Normannorum." In common warfare wi\h the Briton the conquerors and the conquered seem to have forj^tten their differences. ■ Ord. Vit. 522 A. "Ventris ingluviei serviebat, unde nimiu) crassicici pondere pra-gravatus vix ire poterat." • lb. B. ** E pellicibus plurimara fiolxtlem utriusque sexus genuit, quai divendii infortuniia absoq>ta pene tota periit." • lb. A. *' Hie non dapKilis, sed prodigua erat ; non familiam secura^ scd exercitum semper ducebat. " • lb. " Ipse terrara suam quotidie dcvaatabat, et plus aucupibus ac venatoribus quam terrae cultoribus vel cccli oratoribus api)laudebat." This picture is curiously borne out by Domesday. In 263 h we read of the former small estate of a free Englishman, " Wasta fuit, et est niodo in foresta Comitis ;" in 269, " Hanc silvam habet Comes in forcHta sua positam ; " and, more emphatically than all, in 268 h, " Harum xx. hidanim omnes silvas habet Comes in foresta sua positas. Unde maneria sunt multnm pejoirita." The entrj' also " aira accipitris " seems to occur more commonly on Hugh's landfl than in other parts of the Survey, • See alx)ve, p. 314. Orderic (671 A) makes the curious remark that " Deo raonachorum gregem inter belluinos coetus nutriebat." CHARACTEU OF EAKL HUGH. 493 himself in his last days j)ut on the monastic gurh,* and cnxr. xx. where i)ortion8 of his work still remain. Yet one would **• **" * c«7tne« • think that there must, after all, have been some ^xhI »»"n'i »nJ thing in the man who, at least in his later days, ehose uoi. the holy Anselm as the physician and guardian of his Hu. friend- , , »liip for soul.- Aruclm. To the south of the Palatinate of Chester lay the other H.>g«rof great Earldom which was held by Roger of Montgomery. *,, "V ^Villiani's earlier conquests had given him his reward in ^^^^ **' the South, in the possession ot Chichester and of that bury. fortress of Arundel which, raised before King William ^^'^ *•***•• in Suflwz. came into England, is held to have kept to this day the ^^ j. si)ecial virtue of bestowing the rank of Earl uyH^n its <-'aaile. holder. ' Besides these southern estates, Roger, after the fall of Morkere, received as a further grant the Earldom He receives of Shropshire, with the peninsular town of Shrewsbury * ^^^'J^ ^,f as its capital. In that town and shire he held riirhts ''^^"-'^■•" bury. only less extensive than those which Earl Hugh held in Chester and Cheshire. In Shropshire there were no Crown I*rivUejfe« lands and no King's Thegns ; all the land, except. what was dom"^ ^^ held by ecclesiastical bodies and Ijy a very few Norman owners, was held by the Earl and his men.*^ Of Earl * Ord. Vit. 787 B. "Hugo Cestrensis Comes in Icctum decidit, et poet diutinum languorem inonachatum in ccL-nobio quod idem Ccstne ct)n8trux- erat su.scepit, atque liostriduuni, vi. Kal. Augiwti, obiit." ' Eladmcr, Vit. Ans. ii. i. "Adjuratus ab Hugone Cestrenjio Cumite niultisquu alii.s Anglorum regni j>rincii»ibu8, qui oum animaruni Muarum uiedicum et a4.lvocatuai elegeraiit." ' Ord. Vit. 52a B. " Rex Guillelmus Rogerio de Montc-Gomerid in prinds ca-struni Aruiidellum ut urbom Cicestram detlit." (>u Anindel Castle, see al>ove, j). 66. * lb. *• PoMtea coniitatum ScrobeMburia?, qua* in nionte f«u|»«r Kabrinnm fluvium sita etit, adjecit." " After the wnall list of tenantfl-in-chiof in D«>mf«day, j-.j, wo rv:u\, " ConieH KogcriuH quod ruli in p. 254 ; " Ipse Cumes liogeriuH tenet de Kvge civitatvni Scin>i>o«))vri« et totum comitatum et totiirn (loniiniuiii quiMl Ki-x K. ibi halMjbat." Karl Roger had no less » t«'iiaiit thriii Karl ilugb hiniHclf. Wv reiMi in tlie SAUie 194 TIIK Kl.Vul.TS AOAINBT WILMAM. MAI. IS. Kop*r a far In^ttor chtirnrtor is hnndiil down to uh (luiii of hi* bnitluT chicfH nt diopter nnd Ilcrfford, but it iuuhI be bonie in mind that the writer who ^wvh it to uh wum bound by an hereditary attaoliment to \\\h memory.' It lU ifi itliiin, on the other hand, that the Kn^lihh hur^^esseu f (flirw*-* "f Shrewsbury bitterly eom))hiinetl (»f the j^rievances which '•»»'7- they undenvent under his rule. The building' ol' the cattle, and that of tlie Abbey whieh we shall ])re8<.'ntly have to s]>eak of, the devastation of several houses from unknown causes, ond the establishment in the town of French bur^jessoe, who seem not to have l>een subject to the siime taxes as their English nei«^hbours, had greatly lessened the tax-paying power of the borough ; yet the same trilnite was exacted which had been paid in the days of King Eadward.* At the same time the burgesses of Shrewsbury might rejoice that they were in less evil case than their brethren in other towns whose tribute was influeooe actually raised.' And possibly the two pictures given us of his wic- , . " . , c«MiT« of Earl Ilogcr may in some degree be explamed by the * ^*^ influence for evil and for good of his two successive wives. For his first wife, it will l>e remembered, he had the Minder of heiress of Ik'lesme, the cruel Mabel. ^ She at last met i ^v , ' with the reward of her misdeeds. In her town of Bures by page, *' Hugo CoincH tenet Rogerio Comite in Walls terrara de Gal." It in «dded, "T. K. E. fuit wiuita, et qimndo Hugo recepit Hiiniliter." ' Ord. Vit. 52a 13. " Hie sapienn et moderatus et amator ssquitatis fuit^ et oomiUiteui Kapientum et uiodeKturum dilexit." He goes on to mention the good inHuc-ncc on the Eiirl'H luiud which was exercised by three clerks, his own father Odelerius, of whom more anon, and two others called Gode- \ta.\d and Hcr)>ert. ' iJoniesday, 252. " Dicunt Angligenie burgenses de Sciropesberie multum grave sibi esse quod ipsi reddunt totum gelduni sicuti reddebatur T. K. E.,ht, we Hm h, i. are told, for good upon the character of llog-er. Alnnidy oIuoim. a bountiful benefactor of monks in Normandy,* he became in England a still more renowned |iatron and founder. It is this last character of Earl Roger which indirectly connects him with one of our most valuable authorities for the histor\' of these times. Among his tbllowers was Hwtory of Odelerius the son of Constantius, a priest of Orleims f..i""* He was the Earl's chaplain and confessor, to whom HU Mcitlc- he gave a wooden church which stood in a suburb ofshrcw*- Shrewsbury beyond the Severn.^ The French clerk had ^"''>- married an iiinglish wite, and was the latlier ot at least of Or.kric. three English-born sons. One, sceminglv the eldest, re- ^^'r^^ ^^ 1 T. 1 • 1 r r^ . OrJeric. ceived the English name of Orderic ; ^ another bore the February 16, 1075. * The story of the death of Mabel ii> told at length by Orderic (578 li). Tlie chief murderer, with his brothers, " uoctu ad cameram C'oiuiti^iiue accesdit, ipsamcjue in municipio super Divam, quod Burin dicitur, in lecto jMDst balneum deliciantem, pro recompensatione patrimonii 8ui eiwe detrun- cavit." Her son Uugh tried in vain to overtake the slayer« of his mother, but they had warily broken down the bridgCH, and no escaped and m.vle their way to Apulia. ■' Ord. Vit. 578 B. ' lb. D. '* Adehaisam Ebrardi de Pusacio, qui de nobilissimis Francorum proceribus erat, filiam." He adds, " sequens a priori matroiia dij«p,tr woributi exstitit. Nam maturitate et religione viguit, virum(|uc 8uum aJ amorem monachorum et defensionem pau{»erum frequenter incitavit." " l*auj)ere8," iu the ca.se of Roger and Adeliza, nmy be traitslatotl EnylUh- men. * See Will. Gem. vH. a J. * Ord. Vit. 579 C, D. "Illic [beyond the eaut gate of Shrewsbury] nimirum lignea capella priscis temjKjribua aSiuuardo conMUigtiineo cundita fuerat." " The truer English fonn of the name would Ihj Oniric, like the Abl>ui of Abingdon mentioned in vol. iii. p. 731, and Ordricus in Uie form in hiji own text, but hi« editiv-- i fi>nn-< of tin- iuhml-.h Tboo«|iirir ami Fre*k*rick. 496 TlIK KKVOITS ACJAINST WILLIAM. aur.itx. ¥rcQc\\ immo of EvernrtI, wliilo tho vDunj^'Ht was rallctl after the mintly IWiHilift, tlie father of Wctjt^rn iiiouhh- II'm Kni^ ticiimi.* Tlu» younj^ Onlorio rocvivwl liin nnmo from tlio ^^^^ ' prietit who ImptizcHl him in tin* church of Kttinp^linm luiir the Severn.* At the n^r of five yearn hr IrariuMl tiie firet rmlimcntn of letters from the priest Siward, his ninternal kinsman, in tlic church by the f^ate of SlircWK- bur>* which was then or al\<'rwanls licld by his father.^ And, if we take his own words litenilly, his ethication was 80 strietly English tliat he did not understand the s-nt u» native ton^iio of his own father.* At the ag^* of ten years, K*vr!!ui ^^^*' younj^ Orderic, calUd in relig-ion Vital, ^ was sent as a '^*^5- tender exile, as he calls himself, from the furthest i)arts of Mercia, to 6cr\'e God in a monastery beyond the sea.'' This was that famous house of Ouche or Saint Evroul, • See below, p. 499. • Ord. Vit. 548 A. " Apud Ettin^eHham in ecclc«ia Sancti Kitta; Con- faMorU, quae sita est 8U]kt Sabrinam fluviuin, per luiniHteriuin Onlrici Moerdotifl wcro fontc rc-natus Hum." So again 924 A, where he tuhU, " iiiUii cjusdcm RacerdotiB, patrini scilicet mei, nomen indidisti." ' lb. 924 A. " Quum (juiiKiue esseni annoruni, apud iirbem ScrohcH- buriaoi scbolae tnulitUH sum, et prima tibi Kervitia clericatua obtuli in busilicii Banctonun Petri ct Pauli AfmRtolorum. Illic Siguardus injiignis presbjter per quinque annos C'armenti.s Nicostratie Uteris docuit me, ac pwltnin ct h^-mnifl aliiikjue nece»fiariiii in^tructionibuH mancipavit me." In 548 A it st&ndii thuB, " Siuua[r]do nobili prcsbjtero literis erudiendiit a genitore tnulituH sum." I presume that thin Siward is the same as " Siwardus consanguineus " Hj>oken of before. He muHt have been a kins- man lowanU tho mnrricHl cW^ and their wivi^ti, though ho IcU uk know that to * he the fon of a priest was looked on a^ a di8(|ualiiiration for ecclosiastical dimities,* yet he siicakB of hi8 own ))irth and his own )>arents without any ftvlin;^ of Hhamc. It is clear that Od(.'li>riu8 was a father of whom no son liad need to be ashamed, and it is etjiuilly clear, from the IKttiition which he held and the influence which ho exer- cised, that his nei^hljours, French and English, did not look on his married household as a matter of reproach. r Tie was the right hand man of Earl Render in his pious undertakii)i«fs, and it was at his suggestion that the great Ablx'v of Shrewsbury first arose. The town which formed the capital of lloger's luirldom wjis a very stronghold of the secular clergy. At the time of the Concjuest Shrews- bury contained no monastery, but several well-endowed foundations of secular canons stood within its walls.^ llie ordinary process would have been to drive the seculars out of one of these churches, as Earl Hugh did at Chester/-* and to call this process a new foundation. Instead of this, Odelerius offered his own church as the groundwork of the new foundation.^ The Earl made his vow before the altar ' See above, p. 448. ■ Tb« pussesuioDi) of the churches of Saint Mary, Saiut Michael, Saint Cha^l (Ceadda), Saiut Alkniuud (Ealhmuud), and Saiut Julian are all recorded in Domesday (252 b, 253). Of Saint Mary's, and the curious story alx>ut one of itu canonH, we have alreaolical cbaf. xi. ofIerin<^ of his gloves.^ The Abbey j^radually anjse in the 1087-1094. Foregate of Shrewsbury,"^ but the endowment which it received from its founder seems not to have been nia|^i- ficent.** Odekrius himself was, according to his means, ditu of a more bountiful benefactor than the Karl. lie com- "'""^ mended all that he luid to the new monastery,* and lx)th himself and one of his sons became monks within its priest. So in Domeeday (251 b) we reaU, " In Sciri>pc.-.l.cn'- civiUU; /licit L^^t-' predeut tense marka the work, as still going on] liogtriu* Comes abbatiam, et eidem dedit monasterium [mark the vague xuie of the word &A applied to a p.irwh church; see vol. i. p. 47a; vul. ii. p, 441] Saucti I'etri, ubi erat parochia civitatia." So iu the foundation charter (Mon. Angl. iii. 519) Roger speaks of his foundation as being made " in suburbio civitatls Salopesberiit', in ecclesia siinctoruni A{)Ostoloi-uui Petri et Pauli, quae antiquitua ibi fundata erat." The local history printed in the Monasticon ^iii. 51S) is to the same eii'ect, and it presently adils, "locus ille in quo supradicta ecclesia fundata est fuit de heereditatc cujusdam militis, cui nomen Siwardus," and it is added that Roger gave Siward other lands to procure his consent and participation in the foundation. If the de- scription of Siward as "miles" is correct, "Siwardus consanguineus " and "Siwardus presbyter" (3ee above, p. 495) must be two different people. The nave of the church now standing, which must be of the age of Rt)ger, or very little later, represents the wooden church of Oilelerius, in the same way in which what is called Saint Joseph's Chaj)el represents the '* lignea basilica" at Glastonbury. * Ord. Vit. 581 A. " Ad ecclesiam B. Petri Apostoli abiit, ibi«iue ae abbatiam constructurum i)alain testibus multis devovit, totumtjue »ul>- urbium, (juod extra j>ortam orientalem situm est, Sancto Pctro douavit ; et super anun per chiruthecas suas donationem posuit." ' Roger sjHiaka in his charter of " vicum ilium totum (jui dicitur liiforicavit ex Sagio, angusto prorsua victu et andctu, sed qui hjuj a-rumnas s|hj futuni) mercedis lu.tia animis parvipendant." * lb. 580 D. He first promises to spend fifteen {)ounds (" libnui steri- lensium") on the buildings of the monastery, antl then full»»wH one of those curious grants or commendations with a reservation, of which wo have mmxk so many. \W read that " (juoil prumiserat ex integro complevit," K k I 500 Tlir. UKVOLTft AGAINST WILLIAM. csAT. IX- walln.* Tlu* hous«» liouvvor was nlwnvH 8|>okcn c>f as the yyy work of the hjirl. Ho phietxl in it nn Ahhot and nionkri from hiu own monaatory of Saint Martin of Scvz,* and ■mmIu from S***. ... . .^ there, when he died §even years after the deatli of tho Hfad— lb M«i bwiaL Conqueror, he was buried with the lionourn of a foun(U»r.' ^^ ShppWiihunk' howcviT \\:is not the only plnee in his Earl- dom wliere Earl Ro;^r ni»i)eariMl as a benefactor of monastic tmrix Unlies. Wenloek in Shropshin* hager'« to ecclesiastical concerns. The position of his Earldom wam with . , , 1 1 • • 1 1 theWcLih. involved constant dealings with his Welsh neighbours. • Onl. Vit. 5S1 B. " Datis ducentiH lihris argenti Deo Benedictura filium guum il»idem oljtulit, et ipse |>oHt obituiu Ilogerii Comitirt monachile achema stucepit/* He was then Hixty years old. • See the charter, Mon. Angl. iii. 519. (See Will. Gem. vii. 22 ; Neustria Pia, 577.) ' Ord. Vit. 581 B. • Will, Malm. Gest. Pont. 306; Gesta Regum, i. 76, ii. 216, where we read of the wonderful discovery of her burying-place at the time of Earl Kogcr's foundation. • Flor. Wig. 1057; Will. Malm. Gest. Regum, ii, 196. It is plain from Domesday, 253 h, that Leofric's foundation, whatever its nature, went on till the changes made by Roger; *' EccleHiam Sanctai Milburga) fecit Rogerius Comes abbatiam. Ipna eccle.sia tenet Weuloch et teuuit T. R. E," And the same is said of all its other posseHKions, pave one, of which we read, " Ipsa eodena tenuit Grnlestoch, ComcH Rogerius dedit cajHillanis suis, sed ecclesia debet habere." (Did Odelerius profit Vjy this misappropriation ?) It is plain tliat Roger did nothing except change the foundation and rebuild the church. • Will, Malm. Gest. Pont. 306. On the Cluniac order, and its introduc- tion into England, see Mon. Angl. v. i, 72. EARL UOGEH'S WELSH WARS. 501 Under the later Earls of the House (ti' lA'ofric tlio re- cnxr.xx. latioiis between Wales and Mereia, whatever we say of J^*"^^"*** those between Wales and Kn":land, had commonlv been t*»« WrUh friendly.^ But tlu» new Earls of the Mereians of the Houjm; of House of Mimt^merj*'* deemed it their business, now '*^ "'^ that I^ng-land was con([urred, to complete their work by the further conquest of Wales. The Welsh princes were Fou.U ever fif^htin<> among* themselves, and the Norman Eiirls, tj,„ w^uh as Eng-lish Earls on the same border had done Ijcfore P""*^- them, not uncommonly found it answer their purj>oso to help one party in the divided land ag'ainst another. Earl Roger, with the aid of various valiant men whose names are duly recorded, was constantly at war with his dan- gerous neijjrh hours. Chief amonc: them was Warren the Invanion* f \v I Bald, the husband of his niece Aimeria, who commanded at Shrewsbury,^ and his own son Hu<^h, who, as the Welsh Chronicles witness, carried his wasting anns as far as the lands of Ceredigion and Dyfed.^ But the chief border possession of the House of ^lontgomery was that to which they transferred the name which they had them- selves borrowed from the ancestral hill in the land of * This ia shown in the marriage of Gruffydd and EAlilj,'yt'>. in tho help given by the Welsh to the Northumbrian revolt, and in more than one in-stance since the coniin;,' of William. See above, j>p. 109, 182. ' " Roij'erius Merciorum Comes" appears in Ordt-ric, ^)67 B, but in 7^8 A the two Hughs, he of Chester and Roger's son and successor, ap|>car more accnratidy as "duo Consules quibus Merciorum pnecipue rt-gio «ub- jacet." In tho same spirit (671 A) he calls the lUshop of Chester or Coventry " Merciorum Episcopus." ' Onl. Vit. 522 R " Warinus Calvua, corpore p.irvo sfd aninio magno.** Is this the "Warinus" tlie "antecessor" of the Sheritf Kainald who gave lands to Saint Peter for his soul ? (Domesday, a54.) * Ann. Camb. 1071. "Franci vastavenint KtTcdrgiaun." (>n tliis, to fill up the cuj) of misfortune, follows, " Menevia vawtata cHt a gcntilibus ct Uangor similiter." 1072. " De Muttgumeri Hugo vastavit Kereiligiaun." I'.rut y TywyMORion, 1071, ro72. "'ITun, a year after that, the Fn-mh ravaged C'eredi^^ion aneen held by three Enjjlishmen, free from all taxes, as a mere huntinp^-g-rounjl in the wildeniess.- But when Karl Kog-cr's fortress ha!»v>enj. ^y ^^^ great oppressor, William Fitz-Osbern, Earl of Ilerc- I*;*'' °^ , ford.^ His tenure of his Earldom was short, and, as regards H' r>T'inl. '-' J c/' 7-107 1. ' Domesday, 254, " Ipse Comes construxit castrum Muntgiimeri vo- catum." ' lb. " Adjacent lii. hidai et dimidia quas tenuenmt Seuuar, Oslac, Azor, cle Rej^ E. quietafl ah omni geldo ad venandum eaw liabuerunt." ' There ia something very striking in the tone, half of lamentation, half af triumph, in which Onleric (536 A) moralizes over the career of William Fitz-Oslxim ; " Vere gloria mundi ut flos fceni decidit et arescit, ac velut fdmus deBcit et transit. Ubi est Guillelmus Osbemi filius, Herfordensia Comes et R^s vicaritui, Normanniae dapifer, et magister militum belli- •osust Hie nimirum primus et maximus oppressor Anglorum fuit, et enormem causam per temeritatem suam enutrivit, per quam multis millibus niina miaerce mortis incubuit. Verum Justus Judex omnia videt, et uni- cuique prout raeretur digne redhibet. Proh dolor ! ecce Guillelmus corruit, WARS OF WILLIAM FITZ-OSHERN. 603 Enci'lislimon, liis conquests wore never complete, for the su)*- chap. xx. mission of Kadrio did not take place till the dominion and life of Earl William had come to an end. Hut on the Cymry his short rcijcn alloweil him to make some fearful inroads. Tlie Norman version makes him overthrow Welsh Hi* wan King^ by wholesale, Rhys, Cadwt^'^an, Meredydd, and others WcUh. who arc not named.' Tlie native chronicles of Wales make matters a little clearer. Tlie names of all three princes aj>pear in the Welsh history of the time, but it is the fate of Meredydd which we can most clearly connect with the arms of William Fitz-Osbom. We have seen Meredydd the son of Owen established in South Wales after the ci\'il war in which Rhiwallon fell, and which broke up the arranufcmcnts which had been made by Harold after the fall of Gruflydd the son of Llywel^Ti.^ But Caradoc Mere.ly«l«l the son of GruHydd the son of Rhydderch, the same who ^ntl xUin had destrovcd Harold's house at Portskewet,^ now leajrued ^y ^f-J^^l^ ' ^ and r^irl himself with the French, that is evidently with the F^arl ^Villi.-im. 1070. of Hereford, and their united forces overthrew ^leredydd on the banks of the Rumney.* We have here reached the bcoriuning', thouo^h only the bcfjinning", of that <>reat Norman settlement in South Wales which was a few years later to make Morf>'anwg', al)ove almost every other part of the Isle of Britain, a land of Norman kni«^hts and Norman castles. But this work was to be done by other hands than those of William Fitz-Osbcni. His career audax .ithleUi recei)it «|UO(l promcniit. Vt multofl cnse truci«ia\u. ip*«» quoque ferro repente interiit." ' Ord. Vit. 511 D. "Rex Guillelrau« . . euro cum Ciualt«rio de IjftC«io aliisque pro]).iti.s pngilihus contra Rritonos twllis inhianU'« oppowxiit. Honim audacia IJrachaniannoM jtriinitus invasit, ct Guallorum Regea Kiacn ot Caducan ac Mariadoth, aliDHcjuc plurea jjroatravit." ^ See above, p. 183. ' See vol. ii. p. 480. * Ann. Cainb. 1070, " Man-dut filiun Owini a Cnulauc filio CJriffld ot a Francin occiaiui est super ripam Rcmny." So Brut y Tywym>gion U^ the same effect. 604 TIIR nr.VOLTS aoainrt wilmam. ouF. 11. wTu the iihort«l of luiy anmn^ NVillinm'H cljiff followere; it i^TiH conHnod to the notual yviiTH <»f tlir (\)nit8, and that he do<>8 not, like his nei^hlwur' at Shrewslmry, n]>]>ear in Kn^land either an an ccclesiastieal founder or as n civil ruler. Wchear of his libe- rmlity, but it was a liberality shown towartlH soldiers only, and one of whieh the more disccmin*^ mind of his master K**"* , did not approve.* We hear of his legislation in his county miiiurr of Hereford, but his only reconh^l onlinanec is one which *-K *«'«• narro^vly limited the j)enalties for oH'cnees committed by members of the favoured class.- But, as he had l)een the ejirliest friend of William, he retained his confidence to the last. From his warfare on the Welsli border he was calbHl away to give the help of liis counsel to Queen Matilda in her regency of the Norman Duchy, ^ and from Hitdflslh thence he went to lose his life in that Flemish warfare 1071. of which it will be better to put off our notice until we have finished the survey of our own island. From the West w^e turn again to the North. Our Ijest authority for Northern affairs ^ describes King Malcolm as ' WilliAm of Malroeabury (Ge«t. Reg. iii. 256) ventures to say of him, "Siquidem . . . Willelmufl filiuH Oshemi, principibus optimis comparand us fuerit, haud scio an ctiani pnc'|)OiienduH." He goes on to say, " Erat in eo mentis animoHitas quam commendabat manus pene prodiga liheralitas ; onde factum c«t ut militum multitudine, quibus larga stipendia dabat, boetiuro aviditatcm arccret, civium seduh'tatem habcrct ; quare pro effusis ■omptibus a«i>errirnAni Regis ofTensam incurrit, quo and Durham, for another attack on a land which 8eemi*pulatione." ' lb. " De|x)pulatA Clyvelande ex parte, repentina depopulationo occupat Heortteniysse, imleque per terras Sancti Cuthherti ferociter discurrens, omnes omnibus rebus, nonnuUos etiani ipsis priv;it aiiinuil)U8." ' lb. * lb. "Quum circa ripaa fluminis equitaret, de«n(Iix HH. * lb. " Nuntiatuni eat illi clitoneni Eiwigaruni suastiue son>n», regiiw stirpis puellas decoras, plurcjKiuo alios pnedivites do suia sotlibua profugu« in ilium portum applicuisito naviijus." ^ At least wo have nowliere else to put tlxni during the winter of 1069. Most likely they stayotl with the fleet as long aa it kept in the Hunit>or, and parted company with the Danes as soon as they suilod towanls Ely. This is in f;w:t implied in the words of the next extnurt. :M THK RKV0LT8 AGAINST WILLIAM. c«Ar. XX. |»ui jt lh« \ li.i.l afmmiKinu'il ilu'iii in all thnr dnm^ alonj* the cajitrrn nMht, wt» HhoiiKl most likrly linvo lunnl <»f it. At nil rvontH, nhipx ade them dwell in his realm as long as it might ^1^ plea.«ie them.- They sailed on towards Scotland ; he went on with the harrjnng of Northumberland. For, while he was still at Wearmouth, another piece of tidings had been brought to him. AMiilo he was ravaging the land of Oc*pAtric Saint Cuthl>erht, Gospatric, William's Earl in North- Cumber- hfumberland, had burst into Malcolm's Cumbrian province, UncL * Sim. Dtm. 1070, p. 86. "Fuerant ibidem eo tempore et aliae naves nonnuUa?, quarum ductores erant clito Ea^lgarus cnni matre Agatha et cluabus Bororibus Margareta et ChnHtin^, Siward I3am, Marlessuein, Alf- winus filius Normanni, et alii quamplures, qwi post expu^ationem caa- tellorum Eboraci, DanU in giia rercrifniihiiB, quoniam ein auxilio fuerant, inrli|L,mationcm Regis iribi metuerant, Scotiam ire profugi parabant, ibifjue navigationem prosperam pnestolabantur." I can give no further accoimt of JEifwine the Hon of Northman. The "aliae naves" are opposed to that which carried Bishop ^thelwnne, • lb. p. 87. " Datis ergo dextris venientes ad se benigne alloquitiir, eiaqne cum suis omnibus regni sui habitationem quarodiu vellent cum pace doHAnt 6rmisnm&." HE WELCOMES EADGAH AM) HIS SISTRKS. 507 had harried the land with fire and sword, and had returntMl chap. xx. with great spoil to the old fortress of Northumhrian Kings and Earls at 15ainlK^rr)ugh.' That {>o8t he held as his hea(^l-(|uartcrs, strengthening himself against any attaek, and ever and anon making vigorous sallies against the invaders.- \Vhen the news of Gospatric's inroad into MaIooIoi*! Cumljerland was brought to Malcolm at Wearmouth, he crudtM* was filled with wrath, and issued orders, such as we may \ye sure that William never gave, and which remind us of the worst deeds of the apostate Swend ' and of the lieathen in- vaders before him. From that day forward none of English race were to be spared ; the remnant that the Norman had left were to pay for the exploit of their Earl by death or by hopeless slavery.^ Tlie word was given, and it was carried out to the letter by the ruthless marauders to whom it was addressed. The old men and women were slaughtered, as our local informant puts it, like swine for the banquet.^ Tlie Scots are even charged with re- newing one of the most fiendish cruelties of the heathen Danes, that of seeking their sport in tossing little children on the points of their spears.® Young men and maidens, ' Sim. Dun. 1070, p. 87. " Inter ha.s .Scottonuu vastationes ac mpinas Gospatricus Comes . . . accitis auxiliatoribus Htrcnuis atrwi ilepopulm- tione Cumbreland invadit. Peract& ctede et incemlio, cum ma^a pned4 revurtitur, aequo cum sociirt in munitionem Babbanburch finniairimMn conclusit." ' lb. *• Ex qu& g^epius prorumpens vire.H hostium debilitavit." ' See vol. i. p. 395. * Sim. Dun. 1070, p. 88. " Auditin illo (quum aetum Bcr\'itutin abducerent." " lb. " Senofl et vetulse, alii gla^liia obtruncantur, alii, ui porci ad (tum (lestinnti, lancoin confodiuntur." " lb. '• liapti ab ubtribuH matnim parvuli in altum acre pmjiciuntur, undo recidente« lancearum acuminibuH excipiuntur hantilibuN c»»nfertim 80I0 intixiM ; hAc crudelitato pro ludorum upectaculo delectabantur bewtiij* S08 TIIK KKVOLTS AOAINST WIM.IA^f. OBAP. XX. and all who were of agt) ami htniiLrth to l»o uhvCu] in '^■•J*^ »lavcn*, wore ilrivcn in fcttore to tlu* land of l>ond:iuf.* ariv«tt bio Many sank through fatiifuo, Bomp of tlicm novcr to nt*o again ; tln»»o in whom life wn« lefl found no j)ity, ])ut were driven on all the nion» unKparin^'ly hy the rnthleHH bidding of Malcolm * Thu8, we are told, was Scotland fdled with Knj^lish hlavt« of cither 8cx. There was not a villap?. there watj not even a house, so jK)or hut an En^^lish captive was there to bo seen in thraldom.** Thv While Malcolm was thus uKikinLT his fearful march vx\U-m homewartls, rich with the human spoil of En«;'land, the KcTIilnJ Eiiffli^b exiles had reached his land in safety hy sea. To some at least of the party it was only a momentary shelter. -4vUie1winc Siward Barn and Bishop .Kthelwinc soon left Scotland to lUni go share the fortunes of their countrymen amon^ the fens of ^ j^' Ely."* But the yEtheline^ and his family paid Malcolm a Eaa^nu* lonj^r visit, and one of the company was now at last per- ^j^^ siiadtxl to accept the land of rcfug-e as a jK?rmanent home. rttoMin in Margaret, the sister of Eadgar, had perhaps been betrothed ^^^**^^*'*"- -veil* to Malcolm m the days of King Eadward.'' He had per- haps begun to yearn after her from the time of her first cnjdelioreB Scotti." Of this particular form of cruelty we hear again in the iorasion of the Scota under David in 113S, when it in specially attributed to the Kava{,'e« of G.'illoway; see yEthelred of Kievaux, X Scrij)tt. 341; Hen. Hunt. Scriptt. p. liadiin, 312. Simeon adds the curious reflexion, "Sic innocens letas ccelum adMcensuras, inter coelum pendens et terram, emittit animas." ' Sim. Dun. 1070, p. 88. *' Juvenes et juvenculae, et quicumque operibua ac laboribua idonei \ndebantur, ante faciem hostium vincti compelluntur, at perpetuo exsilio in servos et ancillas redigantur." * lb, " Horum qujedam dum plusquam vires ferrent currendo ante ora compellentium fatigarentur, illico ruentes in terxani, eumdem locum casus et mortis halnjbant. Haec Malcolmus considerans, nullis misemnim lacrimis, nuUis gemitibus, flectebatur ad miseric^)nliam, sed potius jussit ut ainplius penirgerentur eundo." ' lb. " Rcpleta est ergo Scotia sen'is et ancillis Anglici generis, ita ut etiam us/jue hrnlie nulla, nnn dico yillula sed nee domuncula, sine his y»leat inveniri." • See above, p. 4^*8 . * See Appendix V>V>. MALCOLM SEEKS MARGARET IN MARRIAGE. 609 \nsit.* At all events, the marriage of the Soottwh King c»Ar. xx, with the sister of the English .Etheliiiif was now not lonir M^**»^ delayed. Malcolm's first wife, Ingehiorj^, the widow <.fMarK»r»t Thorfinn,- the mother of the two young Earls who had rU^fr. tarried with the Norwe^^ian fleet at Riccall,^ must have Quwtion M to hii been removed in some way, and for Mar<^ret'8 wake we btmar wifc may hope that she was removed by death rather than '"K"***** by divorce. ^ But the eagerness for the match was wholly on Malcolm's side. He indeed might wtll be bent on such an alliance. Margaret was indeed a banisheil wanderer; but both her jHirsonal merits and the splendour of her descent set her far above such wives as the Kings of Scots had hitherto taken to share their thrones. None of Mal- colm's predecessors had ever had the chance of wcx)ing a bride whose fathers were the whole line of West-Saxon Kings, and whose mother's kin went up to the Ciesars who bare rule over Rome.'' But both the sisters of Eadgar were MArgaref* inclined to a religious life. Christina we shall see again Aqj^ as the stem Abbess of a famous English monastery, and "»*'^""K Margaret's prayer at this time was to serve the mighty Lord through this short life in pure maidenhood.'' She herself, her brother, and all her companions at first utterly refused * Chron. Wig. 1067. " Da begann se cyngc Malcholm gjTnan hia [Eadgares] sweo.stor him to wife, Margaretan." ' Sec vol. iii. p. 344. ' Ih. pp. 357. 375. * Se€ Appendix BB. * Thu English Clirouicler (le.scaiits with evident pride on Margaivt'a doubly royal kindred ; " Of gelcaflullan and a-^clan cynno heo w;i •< aitprungon ; hire fsder wks Eadward affeling, Ea*IniundeM «unu kyngei«; Eadmund /EJh.1 reding, yEhelred Eiulgaring, Eadgar Emlrtdimj [it dhould be Eadniundintj], and Hwa forl^ on )'u;t cynecynu, and hire nunlor eynn ga;C to Heinrice canere, \>g ha;fde anwald <»fur Re thrown back on him. * Chron. Wig. 1067 ; " pnii heo on mwg<*Jhado On |>iHan life ncvortAn, Mihtigan Drihtn.' On chtrnrr forhKfcilnyHM Mid lichoman licro heortan Cweman mihtv." •M TIIR REVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. €1AP. XZ. ■Iiloontt. Bar iniloenoe on bar hosbuid, •ad on SooUMid g«DeraIIjr. Her eccle- ■JMtical f htngot tu lieurkeD to tho Kin^*« suit, litil the love of Malcolm WIS not to be witlittUxxl. lie dealt with her bn)ther till he fltiil Yea; for in truth liediirsl not wiy otherwino, seeinf^ they had come into his ]>ower.^ In fiict the marring- vow of Margmret to Maleolin sivms to have been pli^-htod as unwillinj^ly as \\\c h<)mai»'i*-vow of Ilartild to Willium. But the reBultiJ in the two cases were widely dill'erent. It was a good day indeed for Malcolm and for Scotland when Margaret was i>cr8uaded or const mined to exchange the easy self-di'dication of the cloister for the harder task of doin<» her duty in that state of life to which it had pleased Uod to call her. Marei^ret became the mirror of wives, mothers, and Queens, and none ever more worthily earned tlie honours of sainti«hip. Her g-entle influence reformed wliatever needed to be reformed in her husband,^ and none laboured more diligently for the advance of all temporal and spiritual enlightenment in her adopted country.' The wife of Malcolm played a part not wholly unlike the part played by the earlier wives of iEthelberht and Eadwine, an influence the opposite to the evil influence of the Norman Emma. There was indeed no need for Margaret to bring a new religion into Scotland, but she gave a new life to the religion which she found existing ' Chron. Wig. 1067. " And he [Eadgar] and his menn ealle lange wi^cwa*don and eac heo sylf wiiSwoc, and cweeS [then follows the poeui]. S« kyngc befealh georne hire brelSer, o5 )»aet he cwse^S ia wi^, and eac he elles ne dorste, forJ>an )>e hi on his anwald becuinene wseron," * lb. '* Se kyng hi pa underfeng, \>a, hit liire unt>ance8 wsere, and him gelicade hire |)eawa8, and J>ancode God i^e him Bwylce gemaeccean mihtiglice forgeaf, and wislice hine be|>ohte swa he full witter was, and awende hine Hylfne to Gode, and alee unsiuemysse oferhogode." So 8im. Dun. 88; " Cujus studio et industria Rex ipse, depositil morum barljarie, foetus est honestior atque civilior. ' lb. " De have been personally a far more unpromising subject than i^thelberht or Eadwine. In the Chronicles Malcolm is •' vir infidelis ; " Mar^faret is gent " Jxrne k^Tig gerihtan of |»am dweliande pa.'5e, and geln^gean hine to beteran wi>ge, and his leode samod, and alegcean ba uni>eawiw ha suo J>eoeawas," see Mr. E. W. Rolx;rt'«on, i. 149. Hw whole account of Malcolm and Margaret should be rejul. See aljii> Innes' Scotland in the Miildle Ages, 86 (though an unheard of exploit is there attributed to Margaret's father), and Burton's whole chapter ()eginning i- 378. * See the letter of Lanfranc to her, Giles, i. 59, ••ut it contains no historical information. He sends to her a certain Goldcwioui, who from his name njay be supposed to be an Englislnnan. ' 'Vhv Life of Margaret by Turg«>t, printed in Mr. Uinde's edition of Simeon, is one of the most interesting pieces that wo have m a pergonal and ecclesiastical biography, but it throws little light on the marriage sm a n»ero piece of history. * The dcttcent of the Conquen^r's sfjns from itlfrw! socmji l«» have boen forgotten. See vol. i. p. 33 ; ii. p. 304. ' 8«« vol. iii. pp. 1 1, 30. 5ia TBI REVOLTS AOAINST WILLIAM. XX. dominions. Mnloolm'H Hojourii in Kn^laixl, IiIh clofle it*Utions with Siwanl nnd Tohti;:, tloul»(li'hs Iu'IjhhI on the •lirpful of Kn^linh inthiences in Si^itlandJ And tho coming of Marpirot and the English i«xilt»H who followcMl in her train finally Si'ttled the matter. Lothian, and tlw nri^h- In^nrinj'' lands which, like Fife, soon l)eoame as Kn^lish ob lA>thian, Invame, ns I siiid near the l)ej»"ini)in^ of thin work,^ the historical Scotland. The Kinps of Scots who cbttracter . oTMar- Sprang;' from Malcolm ami Mar^^iret wen' Knf^lishnu'n, !t Britain became, like the Celtic portion of Southern Britain, hnj;..ui-i. ^ troublesome appendage whiyli it cost much pains to keep in even nominal allegiance. The Scotland so formed, the Kingdom of Dunfermline and Edinburgh, remained an English state, sjwaking the purest surviving form of the ^ English language, and whatever was other than English in it came from that irrepressible Norman influence which passed from the Southern England into the Northern. At 1503- last another marriage^ the marriage of another English ' See Palj,^rave, iv. 31 1. • See voL i. p. 140. Much on this head is to be found in the writers whom I have referred to in the last few notes, though I cannot say that Mr. Robertson's Appendix, " On the Theory of Di.splaceinent " (iL 484), is BO clear as the writings of his fellows. I presume that his object is to show that Lothian did not begin to become English at this time — a point on whicli there can be no doubt. Mr. Innes (88) quotes the signatures of two charters of Duncan the stepson, and Edgar the son of Margaret. All the names are English or Danish. Cf. Palgrave, iv, 334. • See the list in Palgrave, iv. 341, with his comments. Of eight children five have English names — Eadward, Eadmund, Eadgar, ^^thelred, and Eadgyth. The others are Alexander, David, and Mary. Not one is Scottish. Alexander reminds one of Constantine and Gregory at an earlier time. • See WilL Malm. v. 400 ; Hist. Nov. i. 3. WALCHKK BISHOP OF DURHAM. 518 Margtiret — widely different as was the sister of Henry the oiur. xx. Ei«^hth from the sister ot* Ead«^ir .Etheling" — c<»ni|)let*Hl the work which the earlier marria*^e bej^an. In three generations, aftor«, except ho far a« popular acquicHcence tn their >tuccfs«ion rni^ht Imj held to bo equivalent to a popular election. It wan by on Act of I'arliaiuent pas-sed in the reign of her laat elected King lh.1t the Crown of England waH firwt made hereditary. ' See above, p. 480. ' Sim. Dun. 1071 (S9 Ilintle). On F:glaf «)r '* Eilaf llunciirl," tee above, p. 305. * ^H-v IhjIow, § 4. VOL. IV. I. 1 5H TIIK KKVOITS AOAINST WILLIAM. c«Ar. Ki. nutumn Ins lai.i^ w.r. Ik., and in tlu» montli of Aiij»'U8t wuiUnj'i \x(, ,i^.t forlJi a^^'uiiiNl Sruilaml with a mij^^litv ft)rce l)oth by »,pua»t laml nnu j»t*a.' Ho wont at onro to avon^'o the special \ * .in wn»n;^ whioh his Kininlom liatl PiifUTctl at tho hands of MaK^>lni.'' and to ajwert in a practical shape his chiim to the urw ^ ImiHrial rights of hin pr. ore over the whole Isle of IJritain.^ Nothing eU< \\;i- now laokinpf to the perfection of William's Conquest. En«^land was his own; the sub- jupition of the restless Britons might be left to the Earls of the bonier ; but the sul)jugation of the greatest vassal of the Empire, the only vassal of undoubted kingly rank, was an enterprise which called for his own presence and for his Diriflonof full forcc. The fleet was sent to beset the whole coast/ Mid Mft while he himself set forth with the land army. Among his forcm. following came Eadric the Wild, the hero of Herefordshire, comMuue* who had been admitted to the King's peace about two years NVUlUm. i^forc.'* We are not told whether Eadric's presence was the result of his new-bom loyalty, or whether he was called on to follow William into Scotland as Hereward was perhaps called on to follow him into Maine.^ At all events, it is plain that the position which Eadric held in William's host was, outwardly at least, one of high Ajipcct of honourJ And the present warfare of William was one th^- evt« of ^^ which the most patriotic Englishman might serve him Kn^'ii,}i- w-ithout scruple. The Scot was more foreifjn than the ' Chron. Ab. 1073, Pctrib. 1072. " Her Willelin cyng la;dde scipfyrde and bindfjTde to Scotlande." So Florence, who givcH the date "post AsBumptionem S. Mariae." ' Sim. Dun. 1072 (89, Hinde). •' Graviter namque Rex Scottorum Mal- colmufi eum offenderat, quia, ut supradictum est, anno praeteriU) rcgni ■ui terminos atrociter depopulatua fuerat." ' Flor. Wig. 1072. " Ut earn suae ditioni subjugaret." * Chron. Ab. 1073, Petrib. 1072, "And )>a;t land on psk bss healfe mid ■cipum ymbe l«g." • See above, p. 463. * See above, p. 486. ' Flor, Wig. 1072. '• HabenH in comitatu huo Edricum cognomento SilTaticum." The valiant Englishman wa« received an the Conqueror's personal GegilS. WILLIAM INVADES SCOTL-VND. 615 Norman, and, whatever evils the Norman !md done, the chat. xi. Scot had done worse. Malcolm niii^ht give himself out as the champion — some day i)erhaj>s to be the heir — of the Old-Eng-lish kinr^ly liouse ; he mij^ht be the protector of Eadg^r, the husband of Margaret ; but jut«t at that time En^Mislimon would l>e far more likely to look on him simj)ly as the last and most brutal ravager of Northumberland, and they mi*^ht look on William as, for the nonce at least, the avenger of that great wrong. Never would Englishmen be so ready to acknowledge \Villiam as their lawful King as when he was about to lead them forth against the old enemy of England. Men to whom it was pain and grief that William should be King of the English would, now that he was King of the English, be ready to do him loyal service in assert- ing the rights of the English Crown over its foreign vassals. Men might for a moment forget Senlac and York and Ely, as they followed the standard of a King who might seem to be leading the hosts of England to another Brunanburli. But the Scottish campaign of William was not destined v n to be marked by any special feat of arms. Ilis march" might pass for a repetition of the march of Cnut thirty- five years before.^ Whatever resistance William met with he easilv overcame;* but there is nothing to show the No ann«a o|»p»>«itioii. Norman, any more than the Danish, Compieror had to assert his rights over Scotland at the expense' of a pitcheil battle. William marched through Lothian, the English Earldom held by the Scottish Kings ; he crossed the Forth,' ' See vol. i. p. 497. ' I presume, with Linganl (i. 466), that thin ix tlu- in.aum^' «'t ilt« difficult wordM (.f thu Chronicles, "aud he \>ivr ui\ht nc fund. |.i s J.c hooui \n: bc'tere ^bet. Petrib.) ware." But »eo Thorpe, ii. 1 79. ' Thia geeniH U> \h: Mr. Earlo'H explanation (Parallel C'hronicl. m. 348, 349) of the other diffic\ilt pa*MnKo which k'ik.-m junt before in the Chronicle*, "and hiit landfyrdo itt pieui K'wado inn hi'ddo." or iu \V4mHMitfr, '* hliunylf 1,1 2 5l6 THE REVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. 014P. II. Biul fouiul liiintk'lf in the j»ru|H»r Scotlaiul. Hi* pressed on through the CVltic londit over which, luuh'r the g«'nlh' inrtueneo of Margaret, civilization wan ju8t beginning to ipread it«elf. He came near to the broad entuary of the Tay, the stream flowing down from thai wihler nortliern land whose mountain nuiipart fringes tlie distant hmdscape at the furthest jwint to which William's mission as ('on- Ue r«Achat queror leil him. This wixs at Abernothy, the more southerly ^* spot of that name, a sj>ot said to have once been a dwelling- pla^'e of the Pictish Kings, but which is now a mean village, though still keeping the name of a burgh. Tlic town lies on the slope of a low range of hills looking down on the wide Tay and on the loftier hills beyond it, and its houses cluster round a structure which has but one fellow within TWBoandthe Isle of Britain. The round bell-tower, its shape, it may be, borrowed from distant Ravenna, but clothed with a distinctive character of its own, had been the favourite form of ecclesiastical tower in Ireland from the earliest times,^ and it remained so for a hundred years or more after the days of William. But this characteristic fashion of the Scots of Ireland seems never to have been prevalent among the Scots of Britain. Two examples alone remain in our island. One, the probable work of Kenneth, is mid hw landfyrde ferde inn ofer J>fet waeS." The words of the Waverley AnnaLs, referred to by Mr. Earle, and which, as usual, translate the Peter- borough Chronicle, are " exercitum suum per terram apud Scotvcade introduxit." " Inn la-dde;" "William was not " inn," he had not readied the genuine Scottish realm, till he crossed the Forth. So ^thelred of Rievaux, X Scriptt. 340 ; " Angliaj victor Willielraus per Laodonam, Calatriam, Scotiam, usque ad Abemith penetraret." What is " Calatria ?" ' The Irish round towers cannot be better described than they are by Giraldus, Top. Hib. ii. 9 (vol. ii. p. 92, ed. Dimock), " turres ecclesiasticse, qua more patrise arcta; sunt et altae, necnon ct rotundae." After the labours of Dr. Petrie, it is needless to prove to any rational being that the " ecclesi- asticse turres " are "ecclesiasticse turres." But it is as weil Ui remark that the usage, which was ancient in the time of Giraldus, still went on in his own day. Some of the round towers are as old as an "ecclesiastica turns'' is likely to be ; others date only from the twelfth, or even the thirteenth, century. MALCOLM DOES HOMAGE AT ABERNKTIIY. 517 attached to the cathedral church of Brechin ; ' the other chaf. xx. still stands, its upper portion seemingly rehuilt soon after William's day, but with the lower part of its primitive fabric still untouched, at the spot where ^Villiam ancl Malcolm met face to face. Tlie King of Scots came t<> Midcoim Aberncthv, and, under the shadow of the old Scottish Ir*""** r " ' ' the nuin of tower, he became the man of the Conqueror, now, like ^^UiUni. the Kings who had gone l>efore him, not only King of the Angles and Saxons, but Lord of the whole Empire of the Isle of Albion. As the elder Malcolm had l)Owed to Cnut, SO the younger Malcolm now bowed to AVilliam. The vassal was received into the peace of his lord, and he M*lcnlm gave hostages for his good faith, the young Donald, his son aon Donald by the dead or forsaken Inijebiorg:, beinsr among* them.- ** * **** No further details are given ; but we may suspect that among the terms of peace was a demand on AVil Ham's PoMihU side that Eadgar should be no longer sheltered in Scot- E»dg»r. ' I have to thank Mr. Stuart for the hint that the entry in the Pictinh Chronicles (Johnston, 143), ** Hie [Kenneth, Eadgar'a Kenneth] e«t qui tribuit magnam civitateni Brechne Domino," gives the date of the founda- tion of the church an#ks the matter in the face, but it is odd to make Florence l)orrow from ..^-Hhelrwi. But I have to thank Mr. RolH.'rtson for sending me t>ut in the I.Atin text in 0 Conor, iv. 343, it ap|H«ar» ihua; " Franci profecti sunt Albaniam, et ahstulcrunt Kegein Albania* srcum oUidem." 51t TlIK KKYOLT8 AGAINST WILLIAM. iMAf n laiul. We next hear of him iii Fhinih Kin^ and his BuhjiH'ts hy hin arniH and hy hin per- Th* hifh- sonal presence. The R'cnc at AluTnt'thy wan the crowning WlSm** ^^y ^^ William's fortune. lie wa«< frde." WILLIAM FOUNDS DURHAM CASTLE. 51f had Wen forg-otton, and the hoginnin^ of the Ntw Castle chaf. xx. did not arist? till a later stage of his rei^i. The place was known hy the less famous name of Monkchester.* Tlie Roman bridge too had vanished, and those wonderful worku of modem skill which carry one of the great highways of Britain over the broad stream of Tyne had as yet no later forerunner. Tlie stream was high, and crossing by any means was imi)ossible.- Tlie tale goes on to tell how William was obliged to tarry on the left bank of the river, and how his followers, used to live by rapine,^ Plunder of plundered the countr}- round, and especially sacked Tj-ne- ,^utL mouth, where such stock of food as was left after two harryings had been carefully stored up.* After this third Wiiiijun scourge had fallen on the unhappy land, AVilliam made i>urh*nj, his way to Durham. He there began the building of the ^^^^ famous castle, designed in this case^ not as the dwelling of King or Earl, but as a place where the foreign Bishop who had been sent as a shepherd over the turbulent land of Bernicia might be in safety against the probable attacks of his hostile tlock.^ Thus arose the huge fortified palace * This story cornea from a life of Saint Oswine publinbctl by the Surt«e« Society in their volume of Miscellanea Biographica, 1838, It betpna in p. 20 ; " Quotlam tempore quum Rex ille victoriortissimiw Willelmu**, •jui Normannis Angliam in manu forti nubjugavit, cum exercitu valiilo a Scx>tiil revertorctur, circa locum qui nunc Novum Castellum dicitur, quondam vero Monecestre dicebatur, fixit tentoria super Tynatn fluvium." ' Vita Oswini, 21. " t'outigerat enim tunc temjM»riH fluvium i|>«um a«lco esse derivatum ut transvadari nusquam |K)«set, nee |X)nti« qui mudo comi- tur adiiiiniculo pateret transitus. Hujus igitur neccaaitatta occaaiono, Rex inibi nunnuUam fecerat niuram." ' lb. *• Normanni de raping vivere a«8Ueti." * The legend of the " tribunua militum" Robert and hin hortf, lllufltmting the |K)wer of Saint Onwine, in worth reat-ling. * Sim. Dun. 1073, p. 93. *' EoH, in tho city of York ; •• Do unk man«ione Uctrc;enM« W. de Perci asportlace sibi in caat^jllum po§t«iuam do ScotiA rertiuM Sancti jKjpuluin Kf^n tributum solvere coiniwllerut." Ralph Flainbani apjHjarH by that name hi DomcjHlay in the Umn of Oxford (154). at Middleton in OxfordMhir© (157). where ha ap|>earH among a list of " clerici," and in three entries in tl»o New F.»re«t (5 1 ), from one of which it would Hccm that F:iulwanl ha«l the credit of brinjjing him into Enghintl. Two of the hohiin^'H Iwlongod U> En^linh owncm T. K. E., but of one we read, " Isdem Kanulfun tcnuit in i\mA villi I. hidani, ♦ t pro tnnto ho defendib.it T. K. K." I pre».unio that he U aluo the Ranulfuw I'lammo in IlampHhire (4«;) who holdi* lamU that had been hold of Earl GtMlwino by one Thored. MS THK UKVOLT8 AUA1N8T WILLIAM. c«Ar. XI. alive, he wi.uKl do no mon» \vn>n^ to Snint Cuthbt-rht or hia |)co|ilo. lit* implorod tin* haint's forg-ivoncm ami mndo a oocUy g\(\. ut hin nhrino. All wob in vain, oa lon^ ii» liu tarried within thi* forhidden hordiTs. llf wjik rarriod in a littor through the Hishoprick ; hut hin painH incTrnMt*erht and all the ancient customs of SK*^^ his i>eople, and made further offerings at his shrine and added to the possessions of his ministers.* Illu^tm. The value of this tale is that it sets before us the load strength of local feeling in those days, the strong at- leeling. tachment to all local customs and privileges, and the way in which William commonly respected them. So to do wiis an obvious part of his policy. A foreign prince who respected the privileges of Saint Cuthberht would be looked on with more kindly eyes than a native prince who disregarded them. On the other hand, we may perhaj>s see in both these stories signs that the frightful severities of William's rule in the North had gained him a worse name there than in other parts of the Kingdom, and that he was remembered as a sort of bugbear who might be made the subject of any tale of oppression or extortion. I turn from legend to history. Bishop Walcher now began his episcopal reign in his new fortress side by side with Eaklhun's minster, and it was William's pleasure to give him a new temporal yoke-fellow. Gospatric was deprived of his Earldom, on charges heavy enough in ' HiHt. Eccl. Dun. iii. 20. He restored Billingham, "quara violentia m&lignorum abetnlerat," and gave it, " pro sua suonunque filiorum salute, ad Tictum in ipsa ecclesi^ Sancto Cuthberto niiniHtrantium." It is abided, ** Leges qucKjue et consuetudines ipsius sancti, sicut antiqua Regum aucto- ritaii Rtabilierat, ipse quoque suo consenbu et auctoritate confirmavit, et illibatas ab omnibus servari prsecepit." WALTHEOF HAUL OP NoKTHL'MBEULAND. 523 William's eyes, but which William had fully for^ven chat. xx. three years bel'ore. lie had had a yhare in the Klaug^hter ^*'"P**'j* of the NorniaiiH at York, and, thou^'h not present in uf uU Bm4- person, he had been an accomplice in the earlier slaughter .\„rrmb«r of which Robert of Comines had been the victim.' What- '^"*' ever may have been the truth of tliis latter charj,t», there was no doubt about the former; but it was a chari^e which told equally afif:iinst the Earl whom William chose to suc- ceed him. William was not yet prepared a^in to try the experiment of sendin<^ a strani^^er to rule that distant and turbulent province. He bestowed the Earldom of North- humberland on an Englishman, and one who, like Gos- patric, came by female descent from the ancient Earls and Kings of the land. The government of NorthumWrlund WaiOMaf was g-iven to Walthcof the son of Siward and /Ethelllied, Xorthum- and it is clear that his descent was looked ui)on as £:ivin. 8y. " Uero CoH()atrico, WallbtHivun in o>niiUtum Huatollitur, ei ex patrin ac matriii proHapia dobilum. Fuorat enim SiwardI Cumitiu filiujH ex filiA quondam Comitiii Aldredi .Mfltdi." * See above, p. 303. * Sim. Dun. 1073, p. gi. " Fugiona iu\ Malcohnum nun multn |M«t Klandriain navigio petit. Cui |H)«t ali(|Uftntufu tontpu* Scottiam rrvor»o. donavit ei Rex Bupradiclu* Dunl)ar cum ailjacenlibiui t^ixi* in L«»di»nciii. 524 THE KKVOLTS AGAINST WILUAM. cHAf. IX. givm to have romo in the case of Gofr]intri(', ns they CAmc in tho ciiso «»f Al)Uil iEthrlsipc,^ during tho rvign of I'vUaI William hiinu<*lf. (tospfttric, tlum^h ralKn from hifl of hfa Uad* ancient wiralth and honourn, appears in the Survey as In V «^> ^^^ ' a conpiilerable landowner,^ and Iuh three Bonn, Dolfm, Waltlu»of, and Gospatrie, liave their j)laee in the local KHvocUhip histor}' of Northern Kngland.^ His successor Waltheol' tl»«f Durliani. AVhatever measures Walcher took for the souls' health of his flotk, Waltheof was ready to carry out with the stren^-th of the secular arm.* It is to be hopempoTO se Hiiofwiuo proctiraret." I really do not see the inconsiBtcncy which Mr. Hinde (p. 86) sees between this •Uktcment and the aooount of the former enmity between Malcolm and Godpatric. The enemy of an enemy h:in hiH own offences easily for^'iven, and the relatione between Malcolm and GosjKvlric do not greatly differ from those In-tween Malcolm and To«tig. Bc«ide8, the two stories which are aaid to be incnnKistent both come from the name authority, that of the Northern interpoUtor. • See alx>ve, p. 137. ' The landB of Gospatric in Yorkhhire api>ear in Domesday, 330, but to a large part i» arlded the fatal entry " waxta," and in one case ** non colit." He also held largely as a tenant of Earl Alan; see 309 6, 310 6, 311 h. In some caaes he held under Alan what he had himself held T. R. E. ; in others he held lands which had belonged to Archill, which was also the case with some of the lands which he held of the King. • • See Mr. Hinde's note, p. 92, and Dugdale's Baronage, 54. We also find in Orderic, 543 D, " Guallevus Angligena Crulandensis coenobii monachus frater Gonpatritii de magna nobilitate Anglorum," who became Abbot of Crowland in 1 1 24. " Walthef filius Gospatrici," " Gospatricius, filius eorumdero," and "Alanus filius Waldevi " all appear, along with nearly every one else in Yorkshire, French and English, among the benefactors of Saint Marj'a Abbey at York. Mon. Ang. iii. 550. Alan the son of Waltheof illustrates the law by which English names gave way to French. * Sim. Dun. 107a, p. 93. "Fuerunt autem amicissimi sibique mutuo acclines Walcherus Episcopus et Waltheo\Tis Comes. Unde una cum Episcojx) et in Byno<^lo presbj-terorum residens, humiliter et obedienter pro«equebatur quidquid pro corrigenda in suo comitatu Christianitate stataiojn ah Epijicopo fuisset." ML'KDEH OF THK SONS OP CAKL. 52^ brian government. With all hin piety and patriotism, tlie coap. ix. spirit of Northumbrian deadly feud was deeply rooted in '^a-'ly the heart of tlie new Earl. Lon^ bef«)re his own birtli, in twcen tbo the days of Ilarthacnut, his mother's father, Earl Ealdre "f^l*"" of '^ \ • Walth.-of of young men, sent across the border by the Earl of the 1073 Northumbrians, came upon them, as the Normans came on Hcreward, when they were thus unarmed and unsus- pecting. Tlie whole family, all the sons and grand.sons of Carl, were cut off, save one son, Sumorled, who chanced not to be present, and another, Cnut, whose character had won him such general love that the murderers them- selves could not brin*; themselves to slay him.- The > Soe vol. I. p. 586. ' Thu Htory in toM by Simeon of Durhftm in the onlarK'««l Floronco, 1073, p. 93, un in«ittt illi bonitate vitani permlHerunt. Sumerlede, qui usque hodie •uperest, ibi non aderat." The writer was evidently thinking of the sons of Job (.Job i. 18). Lan«Is held by Sumorled T. R. E. appear in Domesday, in Huntingdonshire, 206 h, Lincolnshire, 340 h (together with Archill, held by the Bishop of Durham), 351 h, 356 h (held by Colswegen), 371, Yorkshire, 300 ^>. Cnut ajtpears as a holder T. R. E. in many |)laces in Yorkshire and elsewhere, but there is nothing special about the entries. ' De 01>s. Dun. 157. " Deletis filiis et nepotibus Carli reversi sunt, raulta in variis speciebus spolia reportantes." ' Chron. Petrib. 1087. " Gif he moste \>& gyt twa gear libban, he hsefde Yrlande mid his icerscipe gewunnon, and wiSutan alcon waepnon." I follow the happy explanation of Mr. Earle (Parallel Clironicles, 353). ECCLESIASTICAL INTERCOURSE WITH IRELAND. 527 really been attributed to his great-graiuison.* Throughout chap. xi. William's reicTi, thini^ wtre toiKlini' towards a closer *^J'I"<*' o ' -^ " of Henry union between En«^;'land and Ireland, and towards the ^^^ -"^""n*!- establishment of at least one form of English supremacy. £^j^. Putting" aside the mythical claims of Eadi^ar and Cnut to Mti«l Irish victories and Irish dominion,*- we have hitherto had between to do with Ireland as a land whence Danish auxiliaries came ^^ to the help of their countrymen in En«;land, as the ^»at ^"r^"*^- market for English slaves, and as one of the lands where English exiles of every party were sure to find welcome. But now we see distinct sig-ns of a wish among at least one class of the inhabitants of Ireland to place themselves under the spiritual jurisdiction of the English Primate. Tliis movement began among the Danish settlers in the The Danish cities of the East coast, but it is plain that it spread from jra^ them to some at least among* the native Irish. Among: the ^,"*^'^, Danes such a movement was natural ; thoy were recent proselytes to Christianity, and they had of course embraced it in the form usual among* the Churches of the West. They stood in fact towards the native Celtic Church in Difference* much the same relation in which the English on their first thoKn^'lbh conversion had stood towards the native Celtic Churches ^."j^^^im in Britain. While strict diocesan episcopacy was the rule peculiar of all other Churches, in Ireland, besides the more regular "*^"'^' "'^ ' ' '^ Irish tribal episcopate, imaginary Bishops were endlessly multi- l-pi^c-o- plied without any effective jurisdiction. Such a practice would naturally seem somethin<> strange and heterodox in the eyes pf the Scandinavian converts. In such a case it was natural to strengthen the ties between themselves and the Church of the neighbouring island, whose Metro- politan claimed to be Patriarch of all the nations Wyond ' Tliere waa then, If wo may believe GiraMus (Exp. ITib. I. 34: rol, v. p. 780, Dimock), one peaceful mnraont in Irinh hiHt4»ry, " nilente insuIA in conHpectu Ili'js'iH, et traiujuiliri jam pace gautlente." ' See vol. i. p. 00 ; ii. p. 154. 518 THK HKVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. nur. IX. tin* *-« .1. A inoviMiu'iit ncconlinj^ly !K»j»iin, wliitli had the cIKh I fl' larply assimilating tlio Irinli Cliurrh to llic Kn^^litih iiKxlfl. rvon l>ofore the politiral coiuiucHt umlor AffUmr Henry the Stvoiul. It hri»iui )>v applications made to Iriili Lanfranc by several Kin^ and Hishops, lK)th Danish and i^jH^^ Irish ; and we cannot doubt that the spiritual connexion thus formwl was one of the chief means by whicli William hoped to briniif the island under his dominion without CoKf' slash or blow. The Primate's first correspondent was an of LiA^' An?hbishop of Dublin whose name is variously Latinized p^^^^ into Donatus and DomnaldusJ The answer of Lanfranc - of Dublin, r^datos wholK' to ecclesiastical matters. The death of his ob. 1074. ... corres|>ondent brou^lit Lanfranc into a closer connexion with the Church of Ireland. He was called on to consecrate the successor of Donatus. Patrick the l^ishop-elect came over to England with letters from the clergy and people of l^it4ini Dublin, ' and also from a potentate to whom Lanfranc gives Goditsd. the sounding title of King of Ireland."* In him we may recognise that Godred who played a part against England in the fight at StamfordV>ridge.^ The Bishop was con- * He i« addressed (Ep. Lanfr. i. 54) as " venerandus Hibcrniae Episcopus Domnaldus." I preiiumc that this is the Dunan or Donatus described oh Archbishop of the Galls, that is of the Danes, and as Archbishop of Dublin, both of Irish and Danes, whose death is recorded in all the Irish Annals under 1073 or 1074. See Four Masters, ii. 906, 907 ; Chronicon Scotorum, 290, 291 ; Tigemach, ap. O'Conor, ii. 309. ^ The letter is a^ldressed to the Bishop, " et iis qui sibi litteras trans- miserunt." The expression " nos Angli," used by Lanfranc, should be noticed. ' Ep. Lanfr i. 57. The superscription of the letter runs thus; " Veno- rando sanctae Cantuariensis Ecclesiae Metropolitano Lanfranco clerus et populus Eccle«ia» Dublinensis debitam subjectionem." They speak of ** Ecclesia Dublinensis, quse Hil>emiai insulxe metrf)i>olis est." The l^atricius of the Latin correspondence apfHjars in the Irish Annals as Gillaphadraig or Gil Patrick. * lb. 61. Lanfranc a^ldresses his letter " glorioso Hibernise Regi Gothrico ; " and hjieaks of Patrick, " quem, carii^sime fili, excellentia vestra ad noe consecrandum transmlsit." * See vol. iii. p, 346. This Godred or Gothric is therefore a different LANFRANC COXSKCKATKS IIUSII HlSlIors. 629 serrated in London, and the Kn<4*lish writors do not fail to chap. ix. ni'ortl that he made his profession to Ijanfranr.' The l^*»fr*«»*' ' cxjOMcrmto* Primate, in his letter to the Kin^, aeknowled^'s him as a l*»irick taithlul and orthodox son ot the Uoman Chureh, and ..r i>..t.itn earnestly exhorts him to correct various abuses in his *°""*' Kint^lom, esi)ecially the laxity which prevailed as to many to GodiwL points touching marriag-es and divorces.- Archbishop Patrick was drowned in the tenth year of I>«ih of ,. A 1 ^ \ ' IN iix 1 Patrick. his episcopate,^ and his successor — iJonach, Donnphus, or 10K4- Donatus — was also consecnited by I^nfranc* His sue- I^n*'«" CODM)- cessor Samuel was consecrated by Anselm,' and the con- crmuJ by secration of Irish Bishops to the sees of Dublin, Waterford, j^^s, and Limerick by the hands of the En«^lish Primate occurs Samuel at intervals up to the time of the conquest under Henry eraunl by the Second.^ Lanfranc had also another Irish corre- '^^*^*""- IOt;6. spondent in a Kin^ of native blood, who plays a great part Corr©- after the death of Diarmid," and whose name is cntur homine.s hcu do pro- pria, aeu de niortuaruni uxoruni parentelA conjuges ducere ; alii li"j;itime sibi copulata^ pro arbitrio ct voluntate relinquero ; nonnuUi suaM aliis dare, et aliorum infand& conuuutatione recipcre." ' Four MaMters, ii. 981 : Ann. Ult. 1084, ap. O'Conor, iv. 349. * W. StubbB, Keg. S.ier. Angl. 33. Hii* death by iK;Htilcncc is rcconlcU by the Four Masters (ii. 949) umler the year 1095, by the name of I)onnghu.s Piishop of Alh-C'liath. , • See Ea«lmer, 34. He wa*< however a monk of Saint All>an's. • After Samuel, we find (Kadmer, 36) Malchus o( Watc-rforrl. a monk of Winchester, in 1096, who was recommon«kMi to Anselm by King Mur- cha^lh anove, p. 345. VOL. IV. M in MO TIIK KBVOLTS A0AIM8T WIMJAM. our, u. the more mtily utt4*nHi Teivnco O'Hrion.' A iKrp atl'cction ndi««i townnln him 18 prufctukil by l\\v Kit^lihh rriiimto,'' )>iit he JJJfJJJJ^ in oxhurteil to iimko grt^at rcfoniw in his riahn. He '\h '^•■^ m*anieti to gvi rid of the practice of irregular inarria^*H, of simony, ami of (he evil cuHtomn hy which Hiahops were consecrateii by one Hishop only, and several Hihhops were oonsccrateil for the same placc.^ loiMBM This ccclesiafitienl intercourse with Ireland forms a oftiMM •TvnUao curious episode in the joint rci^^n of \N illiani and Ijimtnine. Jjjj' It should be noticetl that the name <»f tlw Kin;,^ of the English is never found in any of the Primate's letters to the Irish Kinr^s and Prelates. The wariness of William may have deemed it more discreet to keep for a while out of notice, till the habit of submission to the Pope of the island world mij^ht lead men's minds to sulnnit to its Ciesar ahjo. \\c may be tempted to wish that AVilliam had lived two years longer to undertake a work which he would most likely have done more thoroughly than it was done The IrUh by those who came after him. At any rate there can be iw^trto little doubt that the friendly intercourse of Lanfranc with thehn^rhiih Godrcd and Toirdhcall^ach was the first step towards the c«»iinexjon. ^ ^ _ II -I. submission of the Irish Princes to the English King at Dublin and towards the submission of the Irish Church to the English model at Cashel.' * See the various Irihli Annala collected iu the Notes t«j the Four Masters, 1073, where a strange legend is told of him. The intermediate form Terlagh seems Ui be recognized. Lanfranc addresses him as " magnificus Hilx-Tnise Rex Terdeluacus." ' Ep. Lanfr. i. 62. Patrick had spoken so highly of him " ut, qtuuuvis vofl numqu&m viderimus, tamquam visos tamen vos diligamus, et tamquam visis ac bene cognitis vobis salubriter consulere et sincerissime •ervire cuplamus." The flattery is at least well turned. ' lb. 63. " Quod episcopi ab uno episcopo consecrantur. Quod in villis vel dvitatibus plures ordinantur. Quod infantes bapti.suio sine chrisniate oonaecrato baptizantur. Quod sacri ordines per pecuniam ab episcopis djUQtur." * Sec Giraldus Cambreusis, Exp, Hib. i. 33-35; vol. v. j)p. 278-283, ed. Dimock. WILLIAM FITZ-()8BEILV IN NOKMANDY. 53I 5 4. The lievoU of Maine. cHAr. xx. We must now turn tor a while to William'b doiuinionb on the mainland, where we shall scxni see the strau^* sig-ht of Freneh-fcipeakiny; revulters against his authority brought baek to their allegianee by the axes of his English subjects. But, before things eanie to this stage, the man who, after AVilliani himself and Odo, had played the fore- most part in the cumjuest of England, lost his life beyond sea in a quarrel which was neither English nor Norman. \N illiam Fitz-Osbern had ever been the man whom William had most trusted, and whom he had ever chosen for those l)Osts which called for the highest displays of faithfulness, daring, and military skill. Some ilanger, domestic or William foreign, must have threatened the Norman Duchy when (j!,j^!nj A\ illiam took awav this trusted friend from his command '*'."' ^* NonuAijily. on the Welsh bi^rder, and sent him to help the Duchess (hri-Httn.-u*, Matilda in her gy one of his sonn, anothor Haldwiii. ^Uimm. ^^ ^"^^^ ^^**^ custom of the nilerx of Khinders never to divido 1067-1071.^^11. jjominions amonjjr their eliihlrrn. One son, at Ihc father's choice, succtHtletl to the \vhok» of liirt dominions, while the others mi«»'lit. if they choose, win settk'inents for themselves after the manner of tin* Wiking* of the further Ailvcn- North.-' Either in conformity with this custom or because n^Ann M.ii ^*^' ^^^*^ |>ersonally drawn on himself the disj)l»'asure of his V' |*'« '••i^r father, another son of IJaldwin, Kobert, had left his country liaJiIiriD. to seek for an establishment in forei'^'n lands. ^ He then went, like Harold Hardrada, llirou«^li various adventures in Southern Europe. The strang^cst tale of all is that which tells how the Warangian guards at Constantinople offered him the Empire of the East, and how the reigning Emj>eror, by putting guards along the rivers which gave access to his dominions, hindereert (107 1, p. 85 of the smaller Pertz) describes the cxistom at length, including the rule " ut unuH filioruin, qui patri potissimum placu- imet, nomcn jxitris acciperct." lie addw, " Hoc Hcilicet fiebat, ne, in plurcH diriiia provinciA, clanta.o, cujus AmiUe filiuM erat, et Willelino filio ()ftl>emi commendavcmt." But all the loral writerM make RichiMis act an n-gent. Orderic does not mention her, and Lambert oidy incidentally. Richildis waH ('ountenH of Mons «)r Hcnnegau in her own right, and her dominions paHHed to her M4.'con«l son by BaMwin, who Inire hi« father'n name ; Hce Ix-low, j>. 53M. She ha«l before \^^'X\ marriiil to Hermann. C'«>unt of Valenciennes. See C'hron. S. Andreir, I'ertXj.vii. 533 ; (.Jest. Ep. Cam. lb. 49a. 531 TIIR RKVOI.TS AOAINST WILLIAM. csat. XX. OWB Mid in othrr )nn<1s.' this Htory ona)>1«N uk to mid tlio 2JJ^""*][J namwi of Grrtnulo niui RiehiKliH. Hut the CountrKs- Wwrtldii, RefpPiit of Fliiiulors acnm not tlio whole country af^innt her by the tyn»nnical incnsuros of hor sliort n*^ncy.* Bobtrt KolnTt the Frisian i>n'scMitly invadrd Flaiidors, l)ut ho F!^n4rrt invadt^l it at the rtsjuost of a jK)\vrrful party in tho country, who were disj^^ust^'d with tin* inis^ovrriiniont. of the Countess, and who ahjuR'd all ulloi^-iancc to Iht and iKlin her sons.^ In this strait, Uidiildis soutrht for iiolitical h 1 > f^ I ofKinV' •'^"^^ military holj> at the hands of tho two over-lords of ry aiul ^|j^, ^roat Marchland, Kiufx Philip at l*aris and Kinijf Henry ii.jijp. at Liittich.* Ilt-rself and s<'eniinfifly a sort of crown- Shi- nffvm niatrimonial over Flanders and ITcnneiran, she offered to the ~na4:vto Karl of Hereford and RcjT;'ent of Normandy, already named tAz ^'y ^^«lK-ni. ^Villiam Fitz-Oshern felt his h(>art kindled at the prospect Wiiibun in ^^ j^romotion to princely rank and of warfare of a more hcrcaumr. hrilliant kind than an Earl of Hereford could wage at the ex|>ense of his British ncighhours. And, mature widower as he must have heen, we have hints that Richildis ' BiBin>, Matilda, the two Eald^ths (the wife of Eadmund Ironside and the wife of Han»ldl, Agties of Poitiern, and Anne of Russia. • See Ubbo, 95 ; OurieghcMut, 926; Art de V<'rifier les Dates, iii. 5. ' William of Malme«bury (iii. 356) says distinctly, " Ilia femineo fastu ampliora sexu Hpirans nova/jue a provincialibus tributa exigens, in perfidiam illoH cxcitavit ; misso quippe propter Ilobertum Frisonein nuntio ut sup- plicantix patriie habenas acciperet, omnem fidelitatem Amulfo, qui jam Comes dicebatur, abjurant." He adds however, " Nee vero defiiere qui pu[iilli partes fulcirent ; ita niultis diebus Flandria intestinis dissensionibus oriiui which Pliilii) wns niakini^ ready for the defence of his muiitrr cousin.- We know not whether we are to c«»uut amontr r^-K**" them an adventurer of cHjual hirtli and rank with Farl ^Villiani himself, over whose descent and actions a thick veil seems to l>e purposely thrown by all contemporary chroniclers. But it is certain that GerlxKl, Earl of Chester, Pn-»K-n«» of the son of Queen ^latilda, invited hy those am« nj^^ his ch^ttr. countrymen whom he had left as his representatives in his office of Advocate of Saint Bert in, obtained William's leave to take a pai-t in the Flemish war.' The Freneh army, strenf!;'thened hy the small Norman continruar>- King- Philip fled ; the Earl of Chester was taken captive '°' '°' • Will. Miilm. iii. 2i,^K " Totus in aniorein inuliorifl conccwcrat." Tliit-rry (ii. 59) luakcs wonilcrf\illy Hlmrt work of the Countoiw KiihiMifi and the revolution.^ of Fl.iiuK ts ; " (Juillauin*! \'\U irOsbert, le pn-niirr de« Bfigneum normands, p'rit de niort violeutc en Flandro, oh, |>our I'aniour d'une feninie, il sN'tiit enj^'ai,'*' dans d»-.M intri,'m>s iMilitiiiucs." ' Onl. Vit. 576 D. '* lUe cum deccni »oluinino«lo niilitibu.H Ke^,'" Ju .i.llit, et cum eo alacriter, qumi ofl hulum, in Flandriam accoMsit." • I conceive this to be the time referred to by Onlcric {t,2 2 \) wh.'U ho Hay.s that Oerbod, " lejjatione coactus Huorum qui« in Flandrik diinijtt'rat, it quibuH hertHlitariuni honon'm Huum conuniHcrat, cundi citoque n'dvundi licentiam a Rcge accejwrat." Thr Hyde writer (^96), of\<'n inaccurato but alwayH inilf|Knd«"nt, wemH to place tlio rx|Mdition of (Irrlmd aftrr the BUppreHHion (jf the revolt «)f Ralph of Norfolk. After rec«»rdinjj Uie bride- ale and it8 conHequonces, he titU\», " Quo tenifKire Comen CiwtreniiH decrjwit (;LTbfMio, fratcr Gondradn* C'omiti»*8«', Flandriamque venienn, iniinii-orunj pneventuM in»idii« miMjrabilittT |)eriit." TIIK UKVOLT9 AOAINST WILLIAM. CTUP. UL and endured a K>n^ impriMtnmont ; thr young Count of Ivmtlk c/ JTanderi and the blarl of Horrfonl wen* nlnin.* Umd After this docUivc defitit, the King of the French WM Ofebarn. gl^d to {^atoh u)> a pt^aoc with the ron(|ncror and to ^^^^^^ reoogniie his chum to the County of Flandere.'^ Meun- MMw viiL while a Ocminn nrmy was aetu.illy on tlie march to help . **" the young Amulf. Kin«; Henry had Itiddcn TluMnlwin tiMd«r> Bishop of Liittieh,' and (rodfrey Duke of Lotharin^ia, — of Anialf. son of the Godfrey of whom we have already licard^ and poooooeor of the doubtful privilege of heinj^ one of the husbands of the Great Countess,'' — to march with the forces of the Ijotharinj^ian Duchy to the support of Amulf. Perhaps they tarricert had made peace with Philip. Neither Duke nor Bishop had a mind to enter on a war with France ' Ord. Vit. 5j6 D; Will. Malm. (iii. 256), whose account is highly picturesque. LAmlK?rt, oiMly enouf^'h,
  • e.s not inuiition the battle at all. Orderic pUoes it " Doiuinico Scptuagesirane x. Kal. Martii," that is in 107 1, when Ciuiter fell on April 24. The short Chronicon Lyrense, the annuls of William'rt own foundation (Bouquet, xii. 776), placrs it on 8eptu]ige«ima Sunday, 1077. Both our Chroniclers record the fact, Wor- ceKter under 1071, Peterborough under 1070; "And BaMewine Eorl forfJferde, anrl his sunu Amulf feng to rice, and Willeliii Eorl sceolde ben hi* gehealcl, and Franca Cyng eac ; and com ha Rodhrilit Eorl and ofsloh hi* maeg Amulf, and hone Eorl and l>oiie Cyng aflymda and his men ofsloh fela ^senda." The fate of Ger^Kid coniCH from Onleric, 522 A; " Ibi [in Flandris] adversa iIla/{ucatuH forturiA in manus iniiuicorum inciderat, et in vinculis coercitus mun«lanaque felicitate privatus, longae miBeriae threnos depromere didiccrat." The Hyde writer is clearly wrong in killing him. The industry of Mr. Stapleton has found out documents of his dated long after, and which ■how that he was in the end reconcUed to Robert the Frisian. See Archaeo- logical Journal, iii. 18, 19. * Onl. \1t. 527 B. "Roome to his own home in Normandy. Thoui^h no ecclesiastical foundation Nomuui preserved his name in p]n;;Iand, two monasteries had aris^'U teric* at his hiddino' on his Norman estates. One was at Lvni, in I'i"!V.^'^* ^^ " • ' >> lIIlAIU the diocese of Evreux, where his wife Adeliza was already i"''^*- buried ; the other at Cormeille, in the diocese of Kouen, which was his own restint^-place.^ The policy of William Ili* emutm divided his inheritance. In rewardin*^ his own comrades, J^Vweon he had been obliged to make the same men great on both ^^ '*^"*- sides of the sea, but he did not wish that state of things to continue beyond the first generation. The Norman WiiiUm estates of William Fitz-Osbern passed to his eldest son ",,*^\,^^. William; the Earldom of Hereford and all that he held "^■^"Jy. in England was granted to his second son Roger, by EngUnd. whom, as we shall presently see, it was soon lost as the punishment of a reckless treason.^ The efTects of the wild enterprise of William Fitz- Wars Osbern long survived him. Ilis intermeddling in Flemish Nonimiuly affairs brou<^ht about a state of hostilitv between Nor- *" ■"*"' mandv and the countrv which, ever since William's marriage, had been its closest ally. Robert the Frisian ' LamlH,rt, 1071, p. 88. There in H^jniething not wholly H«tbifacU>ry in his whole Bt4jry ; kUU it at lea«t himlera us from accepting Onleric'a ntatc- nient (526 I)) that the Inipcri.-il troopH nctually fought on Robert's ddo in the battle of Ca>wel ; *' KodlHTtus Fn-.sio fxcrrituin II«'nriri Imperatoriii cuneifl suis Hociavit." ' See Orderic, 537 A. On Lyra, founiled alxnit 1045, and th«' K-gcnd of its foundation, see NeuHtria Pia. 534. On Conneille, nee p. 595. Knuna, the daughter of William Fitz-(JHl)enj, the lu-roino of the fainouM bride ale, is also Hj)oken of as it« founMre.HH. ' See Ord. Vit. 527 A; Will. Mahn. iii. 255. Onleric enlnrgen <>n the grief of the Nornian.s at Willijuu's death ; " NonnannMruni niatiinuni strenuitate baroneni vahte onines planxerunt f the slain Cojint Arnulf. in a 8orio« of nt thicks on his uncle in Flanders.' Latrr in 10B5. William's reij^^n \vc shall find Flnmh'rs and Denmark in enmity a^inst him.' For tlir present we are tem[)ted to ask, whether this warfare of William in the Mareh- Innd of (laul and (lermany had anythin/** to do with a Ftranj*t? and isolated report which meets us in the (iermaii WlUiMu'i history of the time. Tliree vtars after the death of William tU^ga on Fitz-Oshern, King" Henry was settings forth on an expe- \i*"^-' dition actiinst the Hunjjarians, and had advanced on his M«y, 1074. f^ >~> > Allej:«l march as far as Reo^enshur"'. He was there met by the o^^wnVum "^^"^ ^^^^ ^^^^ Archbishop of Koln, the famous Ilanno, by Hanno ),j,(| invited AVilliam the Bastard, King of the F^nglish, to binbop of invade the Eastern realm, and that he was already on his march with a vast army to take possession of the royal seat at Aachen.^ The news was thought serious enough to (^all the King away from his Hungarian cx- Dedine:* peditir»n. Hanno was with some difTiculty admitted to H fhar himself by oath, and was again received into the M»a K.i.^' Kin^'g friendshi]). If Hanno was to be believed, nothing ' OnL Vit. 52; B. " Porro inter Normannos et Flandrita^i recidiva (Hh- scnirio prodiit, et propter necem fratris Reginae aliorumque affinium et maxime pro caau Guillelmi Comitis diu perduravit." William of Malmes- bory (iii- 257) more fliHtinctly marks the action of Baldwin ; "Robertus nihil fjuod deploraret huo tempore vidit ; licet BaldwinuH frater Arnulfi, qui in Hanoe& provincii et caatello Valentiania comitatum habuit, Regis Willelmi auxilio plures assultUH faceret." ' See Cliron. Petrib. 1085. I shall speak of this in the next Chapter, • This i« the passage of Lambert (1074, P- '59) referred to in vol. ii. p. 582 ; " Quuni Ratisponam venisset [Rex Heinricus], insequuta est eum legatio familiarium ejus nuntiantium quod WilielielinuH cognomento Boxtar, Rex Anglonim, ab Archiepiscopo Coloniensi vana pollicitatione illectuH, cum roagno exercitu adventaret, regni sedem Aquisgrani occupare paratus." WILLIAM .S KKLATIONS WITH OEIOIANY. 539 liad ever passed botwoon him ami William ; } rt, even aHor mxr. xx. his reconciliation with the Archbishop, Ilenrv defnied the Henry (ianpi'er from En<>lan(l or Normandy ko formidahle that hf .\aiheo took up his quarters at Aachen, and devoted himself to ^^/i^ streng-theninc^ the defences of that (juarter of the Kingdom against the exj^ected harharic invasion.* Such is the story of William's relations with Ciemiany, ErttnuOe as told by the contemporary chronicler whom no meom- rtory. petent judg^e has placed at the heail of all the historians of the middle af^es.^ It is hard to say what amount of tnith there might have Wen in the rumour. While William was warring on the borders of the Empire, it is likely enough that Hanno may have tried to win his help for some of his own ambitious schemes. But we can hardly think that William, with England and Normandy on his hands, really dreameil of repeating in the elder minster of the Great Charh»8 the same crowning rite which he had already received in the minster of Eadward. And it will be well to comj^ire this v,'nii..n of version of the tale with that which ns (jiven bv the Saxon enemy — i)erhaps caUimniator — of TIenr}'. In this picture Hmrji^k* the King, in his despair and wrath agtiinst the Saxons, scvks ^,„j ,,^1,^^ for allies in every cpiarter. Besides nearer neighbours, he ^"^^ ^'"" craves help of Sw^end of Denmark,^ of his own uncle Duke AVilliam of Aciuitaine,^ and of the potentate to whom the ' Tlie whole st«>ry in I^.'viubert \a iimst curious. Tlio part.-* uJiich ino>*t con- cern UH are where Hanno (p 159^ pnitentH " ho non iU\ rationin ejcptTtcm vel communis commodi neglii^entcni oiw« ut in ultionem privata; injuria? patriam buam harharitt pHnlere velit," and where we rca«l, a little way on (p. 161), how Henry " hoc moo, AtpiaNf^-ani perretit, et adversuH ea, qu;i; de imiptione }HirlHiri>rum fama vulgavcnit onm n>>nii partem, quantum potemt. comniunivit." Aa barbaru* litorally tranjUnti"* Vfdhrh, we may ho|HJ that William's Norman subjocta are meant. ' Milman, iii. 16S. • Bruno, iJell. Sax. 36. " Rejjem I)an<»nmi pn)miiwionU juraim-nto oonfirmato* commemorat, hcmjuu illl daturum cuncta ijua» »it iMiUirttua afRnnat." 1 «lo not know wlietlio niiiter of the ruit^niiiij iJuko 640 TIIK RKVOLTS A0AIN8T WII.MAM. aiAf. XX. German writor, l<»ynl io \m (country, if not to itn Kin^. will give no higher title than that of Ktilor of Latin Framr.* Bnt he also prays NVilliam Kin^- of tlio Ku^^linh to comr to his help, promising that lie will pve him tin- like hrlp KoAimI of \Mck airain, sliouhl ho ever nted it.*= William in inanl and those whose evil cuAf. xx. consciences accused them trembh'd at the ai){)r<>ach of the avenger.^ IVacf, in the sense which the word bore in those days, was the great object of WiUiam's government; but peace meant one thing in Normandy and another in Kn«^land. (iuceii Matihhi travit." * lb. C, 529 B. The Bishops Hugh of Lisioux, Hobt«rt of iiecx, Michael of Avranches, and iJillHjrt of Evreux were aluo prvHont, lieaidM various Abbots, (ieoffruy of Coutancos iji not mentioned. It might not have bocn safe for William, Odo, aii-l (JeofTrey to leave England all at once, ' lb. 517 B. *• Epii*cojK)« ot ecclosiauticos viroii admouuit ut bene 541 TIIK KKVOLTS A0AIN8T WILLIAM. offiuth. >. II. went on to cnrry out tho iiiUuiions of thoir Bovcruign in tiio funu of a t»orii*H of minute* and htrict i^orli'siuHtii iil OMHWi of canons. As niii^ht be IcKikcil (nv unilcr tin* priinncv ol* John of Ivry, tho incmt rif^d hiws \v»ri' fiiact^Hl aj^in«t all Miart ibc niiirria^* and ixmcuhinagv on tlu" part ot the cUt^v,' with- fff iS^ ^"^ "">* ^^ ^^^"^ reluxatit»n of btrict discij)line which the ^*^»^» milder wisdom of Lanfranc found needful in JOn^land u few years later.* Still we do not luar that any inquiry N\a> made into the parenta^^i'e of that other John, who, if not the son of the IJishop of Uayeux, was at all events the son oo the of the Earl of Kent.* There are other proviHions touehin^ J^JJJ**** marriag^es among" the laity,' and about various minute ^^y- ecelesiastical i)oints. 15ut it is worth notice that the Norman Church found it needful to })ut on record a pro- fession of its orthodoxy in the profoundest mysteries of the faith,* and it passed one canon, the observance of which vivurent. ut legem l>ci jugiter revolvcrcnt, ut Eccleaite Dei communiter coDSulerent, ut sulxlitorum moreu secundum scita canonum currigerent, et omnn cnut« regcrcnt." ' Onl. Vit. 528 C. " De BacerdotjbuH et Levitia et subduuxjnilms (jui fcmimui Hibi ujiuri)averunt, Concilium Luxuvienne observetur, ue ecclcHiaa |)er •€ ne«{ue |)er Huffraganeos regaut, nee aliquid de beneficiis habeant." TTie Archdeacons are strictly to carry out the cation. It is plain that no distinction is made between the collegiate and the parochiiil clergy. The Council of Lisieux referred to is said (Bessin, 61) to be that of 1055, in which Malger was deposed (see vol. iii. p. 96). ■ See above, p. 424. " See vol. ii. p. 211. Possibly Odo drew the same distinction between his ecclesiastical and temporal functions which wa.s drawn by ArcljbiHlioj) Robert of liouen ; see vol. ii. p. 181. At all events William afterwards knew how to draw it for him. * No one was to marry within the seventh degree of kindred ; i)eople were to marry fasting ; a man whose wife entered religion could not marry during her lifetime (compare the story of Hereward); and there is a curious provision (Ord. Vit. 528 D) ; " Ne aliquis qui, vivente buSL uxore. de adulterio calumniatus fuerit, post mortem illius umquam de qud calum- niatus fuit accipiat. Multa ciiim mala inde evenerunt, nam jAurhni de cauua hoc $uae inter/ecerunt ." Did Archbishop John look forward as far aa the sixteenth century ? • They profess (Ord. Vit. 527 C) their faith in the mystery of the Trinity according to the first Four General Councils. STATE OF MA INK. 5^3 ini^lit be usel'ul, however dillicult, in any a«^e, namely, chap. xx. tliat i^reiit care should he taken as to the character and Apjx.int- . , . , ruenl of <|ualifications of those who were ap|)ointed Deaiw.' Such Deaaa. were the results of the archiepiscopal vi|»'our of the Primate John. Whether it was in this synod that his zeal pro- voked the party of laxity to put him in dan~' 5« had held the post of Chancellor under Vulgrin and under his predecessor Gervase.*" On the death of \ ulgrin he * Ord. Vit. 528 C. " Oportet eti&m ut Ulea I>*litw." I pruMUUio tli;it thU takcd in both urlw*n and rural Deau8. ' See A\jijve, p. 97. • See vol. iii. j.. ji i. * See vol. iii. p. .^79. ' Ax' vol. iii. p. 487. * See hia Life in Mahillou, Vetera Analecta, 3I]*. He wa« brought up by hid uuclu Kobert, " ^Taiumaticua aapionn ac rulij^iosuH," ami who hatl been diligent **j«u;roniiu libroruni inHtructione hou ilirutaruiu occleiiiaruni reutaurationo." On hid ileath hij* nephew MUtccedoil him in hin office, " et scholarum rej^men . . . prudentiitsime gubeniavit." 1 take the otlico to h.ivc been that of Chancellor of the church. Com|>aru the father and suu who held the name poHt at Walthaiu, vol. ii. pp. 443, 444. 514 THE REVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. citAr. XX. was chosen bv tho derp}' nntl |>oo|)lc t^ RurcttHl liim.' tfcM bf^ We hear notiiinj^ of tlio riphU of thf Kiiip of tlu* KnpliKh, aUr^ M>d who vn» now Count of tlu» Ccnonianiiiaiis, or of tlir more oiirs •., .iv« ^♦'P*^ rij^liU of the Kinp of the French.- Tlie only oppo- * ■ ' •• »ition to Arnold's npi>ointmeut came from some of his own rtiK-'k, who broiij^ht the Kame objection a<^ninst him which was brought a^inst Thomas of York, that he was iucoofir> tlie son of a priest. Hut on an anneal to llome the nuuion ... . hx Pope objection was set aside by Pope Alexander ; ' Arnold was . ^ ' consecratiHl Hishoi*. and larijely devoted himself to the lib bona- , . . ... in«*- great work ofbuildini^ Saint Julian's minster.' Hut more anxious secular cares soon pressed upon him. A Norman by birth, he was a loyal subject of William, and, soon after l)is election to the episcopate, the Cenomannian city and the whole Cenomannian land began to revolt against William's authority. Folk The beginning of mischief is by Norman writ^'rs attri- Rwrliin. Count of buted to the reigning Count of Anjou. This was the i^^jjog famous Fulk Ilcchin, one of the nephews and successors of Geoffrey Martel,'' who had, in the very year in which ' Vet. An. 313.* " CleruB et popiilus Cenomannensis ipsum in EpiHCopum elei^runt." ' See vol. iii. p. 194. The right of a^lvowson had clearly reverted to the King after the de.ith of Geoffrey. ' Vet. Aa. 313.* *' Papa apostolicA auctoritate rescnpsit, quod videlicet in Chrtsto fjU ritual iter renato generatio carmdis nihil ponset officere, quo- niinuM ad aacerdotium promoveri deberet, hi nullu.s eo luelior in eccleHia illl j^oterat reperiri." This answer is notable on two pounds; the prin- ciple on which it gf>e8 would Heem to remove all the disabilities of illegitimate birth in the pase of a baptized man, and it would also seem to narrow the choice of the electors of the Cenomannian Bishop to the members of the Cenomannian chapt". * See vol. iii. p. 205. On reading over again the accounts in the Ana- lecta, I am inclinefl to think that the sheH of the present nave is older than Vulipnn, and that the work both of Vulgrin and Arnold was confined to the choir and transepts. Vulgrin's work was badly built and fell down, BO that Arnold had to begin again. He finished the choir and laid the foundations of the transepts with their towers. • See vol. iii. p. 180. STATE OF THE HOUSE OF MAIHl. 515 A\ illiam came into Eng-land, overcome and imprisoned his cRxr. xx. brother Geoffrey the Beardt'd.* Fulk, we are told, mourned Hb alleged at seeing Maine, in the hands of William, altogether cut "*''*«*^ off from Angevin rule and Angevin influence.^ But it does not appear that any party in the Cenomannian state as yet cast its eyes towards Anjou in search of a ruler or a deliverer. The thoughts of the men of Maine went back to the line of their ancient princes. The male line < ' f Herbert Wake-dog was extinct ; no fruit had come of the ©f **^i^ empty bethrothal of Robert and Margaret ; ' but sons of the other daughters of Hugh, the other sisters of the younger Herbert, were still to be found both at their own gates and in distant lauds."* Tlie more distant and more ix)werful deliverer was first appealed to ; the claims of the house of La Heche were put aside till the next generation, and the patriots of Maine, chiefs and people alike, sought their Hugh, son defender against the Norman yoke in Hugh the son ofcei^ndia. Gersendis and the Marquess Azo.* It was perhaps the rejection of his more obvious claim which caused John John of of La Fleche, the husband of the third sister Paula, the takt-s the father of the famous Helias, to cleave sU'adily to the ^^'^"^* Norman side.^ A few among the Cenomannian nobles took the same course,^ but, as a rule, the whole County revolted. The city and its immediate neighbourhood * See vol. iii. p. 314. ^ Ord. Vit. 532 C. There ia a stmige sOenoe on Cenomannian $Ahu at this time in our Angevin authorities, not excepting Count Fulk him- self. ' See vol. iii. pp. 199, 113. * See voL iii. p. 197. * Vet. An. 314*. ** Ccnomannensium proceres una cum {M)pulo ab ipaius RegiH fidelitato unaniniiter defccerunt, ot mittenten in Italiani, Athonem quandam MarchiHium cum uxore et filio, (jui vocaloitur Hugv», indo venire feceniut." Ordcric luAkeii no mention of tho application to Azo. * Ord. Vit. 533 n. " Joluinucri do Fltcchil {Mttcnti.wlmus ^Vndogavorum . . . Nomiaimiri oilhiurubttt." ' lb. 53a D. VOL. IV. N n 616 TIIK KKVOLTH AGAINST WILLIAM. CSAP. zx. look tho Kail. JSkI ! . ! . ritizcns, ]>oasnntfi, jointU in one -■"J™!, patriotic impulse. The castle which held the city in iWOdsb^. bondAgo was stormwi,* and in the joy of recovered freo- TWNor* j()|Q n terrible venpcnncc \vr\s t:ikcn on the Normnns. driwooat Humfrey, the Kini^'s Seneschal, was killed in the Htorm of the castle; of the other Normans some shared his fat«, oUiere were put in bonds or driven out of iht; land.* Ilie city had, in the days of AVilliam's conquest, been well nigh the last part of the pro\'ince to be subdued ; it was now the first to assert its freedom. But presently the whole country rose. The Normans, looked on by all men as a common pest, were everywhere attiacked.* Import- Geoffrey of Mayenne, the man who had been the last to Aooe of , . 0«oa«7 of submit to William at the time of his first invasion,* was ^*"'*' not likely to be wanting at such a time. He was clearly the life and soul of the movement at its present stage.'' Bbhop Among the few who were faithful to William was naturally g^ia the Norman Bishop Arnold. As soon as the revolt broke ™*'*"'^J out, he at once left the city, and crossed the sea to his sovereign in England.*^ We may be led to think that it was from Arnold that William, now at the height of his power and glory in his island Empire, first heard that his noblest conquest on the mainland had fallen away from him. The Bishop was received with all honour, but his stay in England was not long. As soon as he was * Ord. Vit. 532 C. "Seditiosi civea et oppidani confines gregariique milites in eiteroH unanime conHilium ineunt, arcem urbis et alia munirnina [■ee ToL iii. pp. 206, 207] viriliter armati ambiunt, et Turgiaum de Traceio Guillelmumque de Firmitate aliosque Regis raunicipes expugiiant et ejiciunt." » Vet. An. 3i4»; Ord. Vit. u. s. ' Ord. Vit. 532 D. "Regio tota turbatur, et ibidem Normannica vis obfuBcatur ac pene ab omnibus, quasi generalis luee, passim imjjugnatur." * See voL iii. p. a 13. * OnL Vit. u. 8. The special importance of Geoffrey will be shown ynaeniij. « Vet. An. 31 4*. AZO IN MAINK. . 547 gt)ne, the revoltcrs beg-an to seize and plunder all the obap. zx. episeopal houses and possessions. It was an act of courajje, »nd n- and one which must have bi'en done as an act of duty, when Arnold alh-gt'd the sj)oiling of his g-oods as a reason for returning" to his flock, and obtained the King-'s licence to do so. He went back laden with royal gifts.^ But the men of Le Mans had at first no mind again to receive the partizan of their enemy within their walls. The Bishop was for a while driven to take up his abode in the monastery of Saint Vincent without the city, till his clergy found means to reconcile him with The BUhop the citizens, and he was again allowed to fill his throne citiJ^r^ in Saint Julian's.- cuncfled. Meanwhile the first revolution was accomplished. TheAiooom«« Marquess Azo had listened to the call of the Cenomannian ^ *• nobles and people. He appeared in the land, accom])anied by his wife Gersendis, the daughter of the ancient Counts, and by their son Hugh, who was called to reign over the province from which AVilliam had been driven. For a his first while he met with nothing but success. But little resistance ''"<^'«««*- was made to Azo's claims, and that little was overcome, partly by force, partly by gifts.^ But the Marquess and Dlwigre^ the citizens did not lonsf agfrce. His money, which he had I"*^"^ fT lavishly spent, began to fail him, and he therefore began, »n'j tl^o citiztftia. says the local writer, to taste the fickleness of the men of Le Mans, who gradually fell away from their attachment He ko«i to him.* Azo accordingly went back into Italy, leaving ^ ^^^^^' Gersendis and her son under the care of CJeofl'rey of f'"'*^ *od •^ Hugh. ' Vet. An. 314*. ' lb. 315*. " Quuin civea sui odio Rctju AnglM nequMiUMn ouin in civitatem paterentur intrare." Compare the deitcriplitm of Williant n* ** Angligena Rex " in Onl. Vit. 655 D. • II). " CunctA rej,Monu tain vi quatn niuneribun adquiititA." * II). *• Atho MarchirtiuM . . . cognitA levitate C'«?nt>mannenj«iun». «iuuin jam, (ieficiontc pccuni.1 (|uiini in cim initi<» copione ero^'averat, tidom qucxpiu ipHorum urga hc pariter deticcru perse n«iiw«t, ri'v«n«UM i «l in iL-xliain." N D 2 548 TlIK RKVOLTS AOAINST WILLIAM. «up. u. MlfSDncJ Tho choitx* of n Riinnlinn provcnl both por- •odaIIv and politimlly imlurky. (tc^tflrrv, ho the fvaiulal jjt dm nuj of tJie time wiiil, mmlc himwlf too nr(vj>taMi* to the UtMnnji. Marchiont^ss in the absence of hor hufihand,- and it is still more ct^rtain that he sliowed himself quite unfit to dt»al with a hi^h-spirited j^eople like the citizonH of Le Mans. FiaHkM of He could fi^-ht manfully for his own hand ; he could ™''^* loyally discharge a vassal's duty to his lord ; he could * strive — we need not doubt, with an honest zeal — to free hifl countr}' from the yoke of a stranger ; but a spirit was now ari^iniT^ which struck straig-ht at all the claims and all the prejudices of the lords and Prelates of those days, and, when tried by that harder test, he fell away. Mnnidpal The spirit of municii)al independence had never quite in Gmul. ^'^ ^"^ i^ the Roman municipalities of Gaul. In the South there can be little doubt that traditions of this kind were never extinct; and even in the North there may have l>een faintly abiding memories of the days when Position of the cities of the Empire, allies or colonics of the one ruling" BomAD commonwealth, knew no King but Ciesar and no master but the Law. The rule of Csesar and of his lieutenants may have been oppressive ; the Law which they administered may have been harsh and extortionate; still the rule of Rome was a rule of Law^, and the subject commonwealtlis of the Empire still proudly cherished the shadow of repub- lican freedom. And, if the traditions of civic independence thus lingered within the Roman towns, the traditions of a more equal, a more widely-spread, form of freedom * Vet. An. 315*. " In manu Gaufridi de Meduan&, viri nobilis et versuti admodum inyenii, uxorem cum filio derelinquena." William of Poitiers (see vol. iii. p. 20S) gives Geoffrey the same epithet. ' The hx^al writer at this point says scoffingly that Geoffrey was "hujus [Genif-ndis] tutor et quasi maritus effectus," and further on (285) he speaks of the ** illicita familiaritas quae jam inter eos male succreverat." It ■bould be remembered that Geraeudia had been put away by her first hiuband. See voL iii. p. 196. MUNICIPAL THADITIONS IN (iAUL, 549 lingered also beyond their walls. The j^reat peasant revolt chat. xx. in Normandy shows that the memorj' of the old Teutonic TrmditioM of the democracy, which lived on in Schwyz and in Friesland, Ttuumic had not wholly died away even within the bounds of J]^""*^ Gaul.* These twofold memories worked toj^ether within Rrj»ubliau» the next century or two to bring about that great birth in tb« of freedom which established alike the rural democracies of ^"^P**** Switzerland and the Free Imperial Cities of other parts of the Empire. Within the dominions of the French \tm me- King and his vassals the growth of civic freeilom was Prmnw. less perfect. No French or Norman or Aquitanian city ever reached the full rank of an independent common- wealth ; none attained that measure of freedom which Horence and Genoa kept for so many ages, which Bern and Ziirich have kept to our own day, which Massalia, the Defence of city which had once braved the might of Ca'sar, so nobly ai^nst defended agiiinst Charles of Aniou.^ But even in France y'^'** °' and its vassal states the growth of municipal life was i^^J- one of the most marked features of the next age,"* and the French towns, under the name of Communes, won for Growth of themselves a degree of local freedom which discerning muna. Kings found it their wisdom to fosten enemy.^ Orders were accordingly' sent through the whole country for a general G«nenJ march against his castle. Not a word is told us as to m^,»mt either the political or the military arrangements of the Ilepublic, but the army which set forth against Hugh was evidently a general levy of the population of the country.^ Tliis fact suggests matter for thought. In the first moment of recovered freedom, before disputes and differences had had time to arise, the people of the country at large gladly obeyed the orders which were sent forth to them from the capital. But the Ceno- mannian commonwealth would have displayed a wisdom shared with it by no other city-commonwealth save Rome and Athens, if it had found out any way of permanently • Vet. An. 316*. "Caatra vicina diebus sanctae Quadragesimae, immo Dominies pasaionis tempore, irrationaltiliter uuccendentes." ' We njAy add Towton, fought on Palm Sunday in 1461, and some less famous Easter fights before and after. • Vet. An. u. s. " Quibusdem injuriis adversum se conjuratorum animos trritAaset." Silliacxun or SuUiacum is Silld-le-Guillaume in the department ofSarthe. • lb. " Subito per totius regionis populos legatos miserunt, contra prae- £%tum Hugonem, qui Sanctis iriHtructionibuH obsistebat, tumultuosa; multi- tudinis agmina concitantes," Tlie sneering tone of the writer at this stage should be noticed, as, before long, he begins to talk patriotically about "nostrL" TREASON OF GEOFFREY OF MAYENN'E. 583 attaching" the country at lar<^» to the civic rule. To com- cba». j3l municate equal ri^^hts to whole provinces, to place their J^f*^***"* \'illage8 and smaller towns in some hi^-her i)osition tluin o^nimon- . Ill w*allh< to that of subject districts, is an honour which has been re- tb« tur- served for the commonwealths of modern Switzerland. But Country* for the moment all wa^ harmony. Tlie army of the Re- public, if it reeked little of holy seasons, at least put on the aspect of a religious procession. Bishop Arnold, IVewoet unwillingly no doubt, but probably in accordance with Amuld the terms of his late reconciliation, sanctified the host , with his presence and that of his clergy. The priests of the several churches marched at the head of their Hocks, carrying their crosses and banners. In this sacred array, the host, full of eager zeal, pressed on to the attack of Hugh's castle.^ But they had an enemy among them. Geotfrey had obeyed the summons to arms ; he had come Trts^jon of with his own following, probably from Mayenne on the ij^^^ opposite side of the besieged fortress, and he had pitched his camp hard by that of the civic army. But the Lord of ^layenne had not come with an honest heart to fight for burghers against a brother noble. He entered into a treasonable correspondence with Hugh, and a i)lan of action for the morrow was agreed on between them.' In the morning the garrison of the besieged castle made R^utofih* a sally ; the army of the Commonwealth was taken by *'^'' surprise, but they had time and courage left to make themselves ready for battle. But suddenly a false rumour was spread through the camp that the city itself had been betrayed to the enemy. T\\c countrymen who had tltckcd ^ Vet. An. 316*. "Congregate exercitu, Epincopo et mngtilaruin eoole- sianun presbytcrut pra;euutibiui, cum crucibus et vexilliii aariKho« at once threw down tWir arniH nntl fled. Tlio rc«t of th»» army, nobles and commouH aliko, Boon followed their example, and the local historian pWcn ii8 a g-rnphic dcjicription of the rout. The pursucrH do not Boem to have l>cen Pjxx'ially blood-thirnty, but crowds of the fiij^itiveR died by pressing" into the rivers or crushing one another to death in the narrow paths. Men of all ranks, scattered about the fields, were taken like fawns, not only by soldiorp but even by women, and it would seem that it ^v, female captor who made a prize of the chief shepherd Carture of the Cenomannian Church.^ Bishop Arnold was un- II? the doubtedly made a prisoner, and put into ward, but the Bubop. piety of Hugh of Sille presently released him and let him gt> home with all honour. Rflhcta of This g-reat blow may be said to have sealed the ruin of the new-born republic. A defeat after a stout resistance mig-ht have been a strenp^hening discipline, but such a defeat as this only discouraged the hearts of the men of Le Mans and made them ridiculous in the eyes of their enemies. The city, says the local writer, full of sorrow and fear, was tossed to and fro like a ship without a rudder.^ Hugh tent Geofifrey of Mayenne no longer dared to show himself at Italy. -^^ Mans; he sent the young Hugh back to his father in Italy, and betook himself to his castle of La Chart re on the Loir, close to the Angevin march. ^ Gersendis * Vet. An. 316*. "Quanti capti, quanti vulnerati, quanti a semetipsis in torrentibus et in Hcmitarum anj^stii^ oppressi atque exstincti sunt, non est opUHCuli pncHentis evolvere. Et, ut de caeteris taceam, tarn nobilibus quam ignobilibuH, quos non Holum militefl Bed et mulierculae passim per agroB Telut damulax pro arbitrio capiebant, ipse quoque episcopus, proh dolor, ab ipeis comprehenauH et ctistodiae niancipatuH est." ' rb. " Civitas nostra, in luctu et tremore posita, hue atque illuc, velut navis absque gubemaculo, ferebatur." ' lb. 285. *• Utpote sibi male conscius, cives suspectoa habens, Hugonem quidem puerum ad patrem in Italiam dimisit ; ipse vero ad castrum quod Career vocatur seceasit." INTERVENTTOy OF COUNT FL'LK. 555 remained in the city ; but the scandal of the time re- chap. xx. ported that she could not live without her lover, and that her whole mind was ji^iven to devising schemt^s for l)etraying' Le Mans to GeoHVey.* At last, on a Sunday, The omiU some traitors in the interest of the Countess admitted the ^ Cwua- Lord of Mavenne with ei'^-htv knijjhts into a fortress hard 1**^ . GeoJfroy. by the catheilral church, that is doubtless into the castle which had been built by William on his first entrance.'* Hostilities followed between the citizens and the new- comers.' Fire, the favourite means of destruction, wan freely used on both sides. The citizens called the neigh- The citi bouring- nobles to their help, and they called in one Count deliverer more dangerous than all in the j^erson of Count **^* Fulk of Anjou.^ Such a step amount*'d to giving up all hopes of maintaining their republican freedom; it must have l>een a mere measure of despair. Tlie Commonwealth was something to fight for; even the native dynasty was something to fight for ; but if Le Mans was to acknowleu> redire, quum . . . ejus abflentiam augtinere non pomet, ccepit machinari fjualiter ei traderet civitaU'rn." '^ The fortrosH Ih (loHcrihod as " quaMJam arx civitatiH, quie juxtA matram ecclesiam Hita erat ; " see vol. iii. p. ao6. Tho betrayal on Sunday, " qu&^lani (lie duniinictk," wan perhaps to punish the diareganl of tho citizoiui for the holy soaaonH of tho Church. ' Vet. An. 285. **Ca>pit [GaufriduH] hoMtilitcr agero, ft in pemicicra civiiim totis ni.sihua anhelare." * lb. " Tutiu3 rugiones proceron, ot pnrcipuo Fulconom .\ndej;avorxnn (oinitem, Mubito convoctknint." There in gi^muthing Mtrango in thiri mention of the Count of Anjou aa if ho were simply the chief among tho onlinary noblefl. ^ lb. "Telis et divoraurum generum machinis expugiuuit*)*." 566 TUP. UKV0LT8 A0AIN8T WILLIAM. r. XI. in the Blaii^htrr of the Normans nt Durhnin,' tlio minstor •—where we may conciMve that the works of nihho|) Arnold were for a wliih* at n stainlstill — narrowly cscniKMl thr (lames which were uaal to ilishnl^v the enemy from towers H««Mi|M*. and houses in it« iminediato nei^hhoiirhocxl.^ Geoirrey, hy connivance with a j>arty anionp the Ijcsiepers, escaped TImcmU* hy ni^^'ht.-'' His followers, deceived of the further succours to Polk. which he had ])rt)mis(Ml them, fnidinfr their provisions fail, and fiH^linj^ their walls quake heneath the strokes of the hat tori ng'-en^'ines, surrcndere' *!'^"*' wanl. liearted of living Englishmen, even Hereward himself.* As W^illiam took Eadric to witness and share in the sub- jugation of Scotland,* so he took Hereward to witness and share in the subjugation of Maine. We feel a kind of regret, a kind of shame, that valour which might have been used to free England from the yoke of William was used in quarrels in which England had no concern, to bring other nations under his yoke. But the same causes Motive* of which enabled William to employ English troops to bring j^iaiern. other Englishmen into bondage ^ would apply with tenfold force when they were summoned to serve the King in his wars beyond the sea. The mere love of adventure would stir up many to whom life in conqueretl England had become irksome. And many too, now that English prowess had been so discredited in the world, might rejoice in the opportunity of giving the men of the mainland a sample ' See vol. ii. p. 1 80. ' Chron. Wig. 1074, Petrih. 1073. *' ()n )wum gearw Willelm oyng l;L(Me Engluciie here and FrenciHcc ofer iw, and ^ewan ha*t land .Mann." I'^iiglLsh troops nerving out of England and not for any Knglish til)jcet land amyrdon, and hit eall abegdon Willelme [);an kyninge, Wig.] to handa, and hi syfJCon ham gewendon to Englalande." Roger of WcndoTer (ii. 13) adds, " Omnem provinciam debiliorera multo post tempore reddiderunt." We have no Cenomannian Domesday to mark the entries of •* wasta." WILLIAM REC0VKB8 MAINE. 559 infamous reno\vn, Robert the son of Karl Roger and of the nur. xx. cruel Mabelj who bore the name of Rob».*rt of Uelesme, and in whom, along* with the name of his mother's houije, the evil deeds of his mother and her kindred seemed to revive.* The fields and vineyards round the castle were wasted in Surraidir the usual sort, till Hubert its lord, fmding resistanee hoj)e- ^ B«aa. less, surrendered the fortress and his other fortress of"*^^- Beaumont, and received a royal garrison in each."^ Tlience the Conqueror moved south-westwards to Sille, the castle which had so lately borne the attack of the republican forces. Hugh of Sille, th'j enemy at once of King andsiejfrand Commonwealth, must hi;ve fought for Fulk or for Oer-ofsui^. sendis, or perhaps only for his own hand. But the terror of William's ravages and the example of his neighbour at Fresnay warned him against any obstinate resistance. He came forth; he craved for peace and obtained it.^ The inhabitants both of the towns and the country began to take the same course, the monks and clergy being fore- most in preaching submission."* At last the host of AVilliam drew near to the city itself. He encamped by WiiUjun the Sarthe, and sent a message, calling on the men of Le ^^^ ^ Mans, as he had called on the men of Exeter, to avoid ^*^^- the horrors of a storm, to escape bloodshed and fire-raising, by a timely and peaceful submission.'' The next day the magistrates of Le Mans made their way to the royal Tlio city presence. The Norman version simply tells how they * Ord. Vit, 53 J D. On gonio of his later Jointjs, hco 707. * lb. Hubert l>oro the title of Viscount (Ord. Vit. 648 C). whence hk two cawtlcH arc still called Freanay-le-Vicomte and Bcauuiont-lo-Vicomto. Tlie l^^ni^u■> r- li.^'i ■«i'< pacificum Marchioncm (Iccrcvcrunt di^'nit^T Husdpon? illin-iui .litiMni legitim.T! gratanter coUa submittero." It taken a little thought to rccogui/c the King and Conqueror in the garb of a peaceful Maniuuun. * II). See above, p. I45. 660 THB REVOLTS AQAIN.'sT WILLIAM. CTur. XI. brought tlic keys of the city, how they tlirow thcmaelTM on \Villuun*8 mercy nnil were gmciougly rcceiveort each man in peace under his own vine.** MoTo- During this whole campaign we have heard nothing T^Toi ^^ ^'"^^ ^^ Anjou. He and Geoffrey of Mayenne both Anjou. vanish from the scene after the taking of the castle by the combined forces of the Count and the citizens. But Maine was no sooner brought again under William's ' Ord. Vit. 533 A. • Vet. An. 786. " Proceres civitatis egressi cum Rege de pace colloquium habuerunt." Colloquium is the word conBtantly used by Lambert of Herz- feld for a Diet or Parliament. ' lb. " Acceptia ab eo sacramentiB, tam de impunitate perfidiae, fiuain de con»er\-andij8 antiquis ejusdem civitatis consuetudinibus atque justitiis, in ipgiuH ditionem at^iue imperium sese et sua omnia dedederunt." We see here that "dedere" in these times did not imply the fulness of a Roman " deditio," The •' justitise " are the rights of jurisdiction, " haute justice," and the like. See Du Cange in voc. * Ord. Vit. 533 B. " Exinde in domo sua et sub vite buA morari et ludere, si libet, quiets permissi sunt." The importance of the vines in Maine Appean throughout the story. WAK WITH FrLK. 661 power than we hear of him as srrkin«^ to diirturh an chaf. xi. nrdcr of thin<>s the establishment of which he BO<»ms to havo done nothing to hinder. His wrath was mainly He atuclu kindled a-ainst John of La Heche and the other Cenu- ^'* *"*'****•• mannian Harons who had stoml firm in their alle«,nanee to the King-.^ He marcheil a^inst I^a Fleche, a Ijorder l)ost about midway l>etween Ix* Mans and An^'rs, and drove its lord to ask help of William. The Kinp si-nt William a force under the command of two Barons of the land fore© to of Aug-e and Hiesmes, William of Moulins and Ro}>ert ofljjT^^ \'ieuxj>ont.- The war now took a more im|)ortant form. I'ulk o-ithered a greater host, and besieged John in La I'leche. His forces were presently swelletl by a large Fulk reinforcement of Bretons, under the reigning Count. {\*,eB,^ton« Conan, who died so opportunely on the eve of William's J*""**' great expedition,"^ had been succeeded by the husband Howel. of his sister Hadwisa, wlio bore the name of Howel, the renowned lawgiver of the insular Britons. Norman and Ange\nn had alike been enemies of Britanny, but the wrongs received at Norman hands were the more recent, and Howel and his subjects pressed eagerly to join in the attack on William's ally.* Again, as in Harold's march to Dol and Dinan, Norman and Eng- lishman went forth side by side against the Breiirealas of the mainland. For King William summoninl to his WiUkm standard his subjects of all races, Norman, English, and j,j^ f..^^;^^ others, and gathered so great a i>nwer that men siiid \^^^ liah. ' Ortl. Vit. 533 R. " Fulco Cum. h ti(.xi.> liv^r.- ii.-.juiter infoctun out, ot contrA quoHnitanniH fuvtiitis iiisurgi-rr (.-ouatUH est. Tunc ci JolianncH cho " cum frrratit) a^ininihuii." ' rb. Wo have hoard of Mouliim before in vol, iii. p. 137. S*j« StA|J»;lou, i. cxxxiii, cxxxiv, and on V'ieux Pont, i. clxxii, ii. ccUiv. ' See vol. iii. p. 316. ♦ Ord. Vit. 533 C. On hiit descent. ne« Art ile V«^rifier le« D*t*«, ii. 8^7. :\\v\ the |>etli^'roo in Mrs. Grcen'H Princemien, i. 25. VOT,. FV. 0 (» 66t TlIK HKVOLTfl AGAINST WILLIAM. ^ **« that sixty thousand iu>rm?nion rotle forth to the war.* But no war foUowiHl. llio IJrcton and Angevin host had, if we can at all trust Uic ^rtx>g:niphy of the story, JWksp- left the sii^gc of La Floche for j^jreater iindrrtakin^. It •k^M«— ««.. was on the older honler of Normandy and Msiinr, in the dehateahle land of Hniere, that tlic two armies met face to &oe.* But for once the Koman Church 8te])ped in Effi^Htf of to hinder and not to promote bloodsheil. A Cardinal (Hubert?) I'ri^^t whose name is not R-iven, but in whom we may for |>racf. |^, temptitl to scc the u])i(|uit<)us Hubert, was by some chance on the spot, cliarped proba])ly with some of the many letters which went to and fro between William and the Holy See. He and some well-disposed monks used their inHuence to bring" about peace between the contendiui,'- j)rinces and to hinder the shedding of Chris- tian blood. ^ They were helped in their praiseworthy un- dertaking by several of the Norman Counts and nobles, among whom we specially hear of Roger — I presume the ' OnL Vit. 533 C. "GuillelmuH Rex, ut tantam multituilinem giruHHe >uoa agnont, re^li edicto NoniiannoB et Anglos iterum excivit, aliaHijue sibi mibclitas gentes, ut fortis magiBter militum, conglobavit, ac, ut ferunt, ■exAginta millia equitum contra hoHtilcH cuneos secum adduxit." The number seems incredible, e8j>ecially as William was not likely to repeat the blunder of lialph, and to make the English as a body serve as " equites." ' The peace, according to Orderic (533 D), was made in "loco qui vulgo Bbutcalanda vel Brueria dicitur." Thiw (see Stapluton, i. Izxvii) is on the borders of Normandy and Maine, in the district added to Normandy by William's conquest of Domfront. This seems to show that the Angevin army had got so far north. But I do not understand Orderic's story when he says (533 C), " Andegavenses et Britones, comperto Ke;,'iH et agminum ejus adventu, non fugerunt, sed potius Ligerim fluvium audacter pertransi- erunt, et transvecti, ne timidiores spe fugiendi segnius pneliarentur, scafas suas destruxerunt." The burning of ships has a legendary sound, and fi^r Lifjtrim we should perhaps read Liderim, the Loir instead of the Loire. Only a very small part of an AngeWn and Breton host could need to cross the Loire for an invasion of Normandy. • The mediators are simply described as " quidam liomanse ecclesise Cardimdis presbyter et religiosi monachi." They were present "divino nutu." Cf. the mediation of the Cardinal of Perigord before the battle of Poitiers. Froisaart, c. 161. PEACE OP HLANCHELAXDB. 563 l]arl of Slirewsljun' — aiiert, Maine was to pass to William's eldest son Rol)ert, as the inheritance of his betrothed wife Marfniret. ' That scheme had passed away; but Robert was again chosi-n as the nominal ruler of Maine. He receivetl from Fulk a grant Robert of all the rights over the County which were claimed nukge to by the House of Anjou, and for this grant he performed ^ . '**' a formal act of homage to his new lord.^ Each prince, unlike some renowned princes in later times, honourably stipulated for his own adherents. John of La Fleche and all the subjects of the Count of Anjou wlio had taken the side of William were to be received to the full favour of Fulk, and the partizans of Fulk in the Cenomannian city and county were to be received to the full favour of William.'' Such was the Peace of IManchelande or liru^re. Its terms secured William in full immediate jK)ssession of Maine, but it opened a door to any amount of future (piestions and cavillings. The treaty however did ' Ord. Vit. 533 ('. " (Juilli.-limirt Kl>roiccn.ti.H ct Ko^'t-riuM nliitjue cumitm Htrenui(jue optimatoH." Williaui of Evroux had Hucccctlcd bin futiier Kichani ill the County; Heu vol. iii. p. 287. We are t<^»ld that thvHc noblen, "•icut erant prompt! vi audacoi ao« vol. iii. p. 199. * The h()mage soems to havi- \>rvu a merely formal one; " Kodbertus I'ulconi debitum homagium, ut minor majori, Icgaliter im|H?ndit." » Ord. Vit. 533 I). 002 8«4 TIIK IlKVOLTS AGAINST Wll.MAM. .XX. 0ocure peace Wtwcvn Nonnamly mul Anjou (lurini^ Iho nMiuiiniler of tlio dnys of ^Villia^l.' Hiit n«>lliin^ rouUl overcome the rooted dislike of the (Vnomimiiinii j>cople to the rule of the Norman. Even chirinj^ William's life- time partial revolt.s took pliRv,- and, wlun the j>Tcat Kintj was j;t)ue, the uncun(|ueraMe hatred >vhi(;h the stout- heartetl city and province hore to the sway of any foreign master showed itself under new leaders.^ 55. The Revolt of Ralph of Norfolk. 1075-1076. I»*«»»l We liavo hut slight notices of the internal state of ■iglAnd. Knj^land during" the years which were mainly taken up 1071-1074. ^^.j^jj ^jjg affairs of Scotland, Flanders, and Maine. But there is some reason to believe that the suppression of the revolt at Ely led to increased harshness, if not on the part of William himself, at least on that of the Normans esta- blished in England. It will be remembered that the time immediately following the completion of the Conquest is described as a time of unusual peace and harmony between the two races, a time when William himself, if not his followers, was trying to establish a state of things in which Norman and Englishman might sit down side by side as fellow-subjects."* In such pictures there is always some truth and some exaggeration. We must therefore look both for some truth and for some exaggeration in an opposite picture which is given us of the state of things immediately following the submission of Ely. We are ' Ord. Vit. 533 D. " llarc nimiruin pax . . . inter Regem et praefatum Comitem . . . omai vit4 Regis ad profectum utriusque provincise per- manait." ' See the next Chapter. ' The long struggle between Helias and William Rufua ia fully described by Orderic and by the local writer in the Lives of Bishops Howel and Hildebert * S«e above, p, 326. INCREASED OPPRESSION OF THE NORMANS. 565 tuld how the Normans, pulIWl u]) Ijy their p>o(J fortune, chap. \x. opT)rcsi>eil the En<^lish in all inanner of wavH, how thev ^"*^*^'* deemed that they might do whatever they would, how^'fi''" they forgot that it was not by their own merits, hut by the * hand of (iod, that they had overcome a nation greater and richer and more ancient than themselv« -. We hear too that the originally low estate of many of the strangers who were suddenly raised to rank and wealth in England was specially galling to the natives. We hear too, above all, of Special the complaints of the English women. AVe hear of the sad IJ "folSj^- estate of noble matrons who, having lost their husbands *^**^°"**"*- and all their friends, thought it better to die than to live. AVe hear of the sufferings of noble maidens who, handed over to be the sport of coarse and low-born ruffians, were left to weep for their shame and sorrow. In these last vague complaints we may perhaps venture to class together a variety of wTongs, ranging from unwilling marriages to actual \iolence. The whole picture is worthy of special study, especially when contrasteil with the earlier one.^ And ^^^th regard to the complaints of the women, there is an independent witness from another quarter. We are told that, when the Great AVilliani first conquereil this land, many of his followers, proud of their success, and ' The picture j,aven by Orderic (533 B, C) of the sUte of things »t thin time i« worth tran.scrihing in full; " Atliptis itAcjue nimii-s opihun ^uiu* alii aggregarant, Nonnanni lurentcH inunoderate tuinclxaut, it imligona* »liviuo verbere pro roatibus suiH |>orcuj««i« impie mactabant. . . . Nohile* putsUjB dexpicabiliuni hulibrio anuigerorum pattbant, ct ab imniundis nehul'inibua opprt'SHif (IfdecUH huuiii dtplnrabant. Mationa- vlto cU:gantiA ft ingfiiuitalo g|>cctabiU>H doHolatK gtmebant : maritorum et omnium |>«nt; ainicorum Bolatio dfhtitutn' inagiH niori «|».im vivrro nptabant ludocilosi |»ar»jiiti airbii itlicickintur, undo nibi tiuita |)OtcHta8 einanAH«et, et putalxant (juod quidquid vcUcnt »ibi liccret. h>- mpieiitcH et nmligni cur cum t«>t,l cojjtritione conlis n<>n c«igiLabant, «iu.h1 non hu4 virtute, Bed Dei ^'ubcmantiM omnia nutu. h«>nttai victraut, et gentem iiiajorem et ditiorem et antiquiorem weiw uubrgtrant ; in qu4 piure« Hancti prudentew|ue viri liegenque jHitontwi micuerant, multi»«iu© niodiri domi militijifpiu nobiliter viguerant." 666 TIIF. REVOLTS AOAINST WILLIAM. r. IX. deeming (hnt tlu>y iiii^ht follow their own Itist^ in all thinpi, dealt nc<»onIin^: to their will, not only with tlie pootlfl of the oon<|uerepriA illam voluntate appeterent, violenter ingerendam." ^ I do not know that the word " primo" in the extract just given from Kadmer need bind us to place the injuries comjJained of in the very first days of the Conquest, or to fix the decision on the question to one of the earliest of Lanfranc's Councils. Any time in the first half of William's reipn would seem to answer Ea^lmer's description, and the passage which I have quoted from Orderic would seem to fix it to the time which we have now reached. COMPLAINTS OF TIIK ENGLISH WOMKN. $67 something of the strict discipline which WiUiani, in the chap. xx. first days of the Conquest, meted out against all otienders a«^ainst female chastity/ and we hear of it again in the portrait of his last years drawn by the native Chronicler.* At no time during William's reign is oppression of this and I»« of other kinds likely to have lu'en more rife than in the f..ilowiog days which immediately followed the recovery of Ely. y* The revolt, the first revolt after the actual conquest of the whole country, must have greatly kindled the wrath of William and his Normans, and must have strengthened the belief which they professed to hold, that no English- man could be trusted.-' And it was also just at this time that William's followers in England began to W more often relieved from the restraint of his i)ersonal presence. It was immediately af\er the fall of Ely that William began Effocta of that series of absences on the Continent of which we have aknonceon lust been describing some of the fruits. While William ^"»^ ^'o"'»- was holding synods in Normandy and waging war in Elaine, the state of things in England must have been pretty much the same as it was under the first regency of Odo and William Fitz-Osbern. It would indeed seem Alltye*! that at this time the chiet power during >> illiam s ab- ijuifnuic. sence was placed in the hands of Lanfranc, and Lanfranc at least cannot be suspected of abetting or winking at excesses which sinned agjiinst every rule alike of morality and of ecclesiastical law. But we may doubt whether the hand of the monk of Pavia, subtle as was his brain and sage as were his counsels, would always be strong enough to control the rude soldiers who had risen to we:ilth and power. We may well believe that these years, the central years of William's reign, were among the darkt'st times for » See alxive, p. 30. ' C hroii. IVtrih. 1087, ' Will. Malm. iii. 254. " Iii'l.- |.n)|»o«ituiu Ki^'in forta«u*iji m('nt4i excuHatur, ai aliiiunmlii ' hack, by m with gifts of all kinds, more especially furs, and among them storm, the precious spoils of the ermine.^ But their voyage was not prosperous ; the Chronicler gives us a graphic descrip- tion of the fierce storm which drove the ships ashore, seem- ingly on some part of the English coast. For we are told that some of the i)arty were seized by the Frenchmen, a name by which we must here assuredly understand Normans in England and not subjects of Philip of Paris.* Eadgar however and his chief comrades contrived to make their way back to Scotland, some on horseback and some on footj but both in very evil case.*^ Malcolm seems to have * Chnm. Wig. 1075. "On ^a-re ilcan tiile Bcndo so kyng of Francrico Filippui gewrit to him, and Imj.-kI liim |>wt he to liim come, and ho w«>hlo gcofan him J-one cartel a-t Muatru-l. ha-t ho mihto HvWan darghwamlico his linwinan unCaiicaH d(m." ' Se« vol. i. p. aa;. ' Various kinds of skins are m«'nti«>nrd. On tho cmiine 9ee Mr. £*rle'a note, p. 349. Hut tlirrc wtT« also " mycclagcofa and manegm gnrMina . . . on gyldenan faton and on 8eolfrt;nan." * Chron. Wij^. 1075. "Aiul his men eac wurdon «ume gola-hUt' t»f FrencyHcan nmnnan," » lb. " And hiH fercHUn menn fenh»n eft ongeftn to 8collandi\ •umo hreowlice on fotan gangt-njU} and Hiini© eannlice ridcnd"." erO TIIK REVOLTS AOAINST WILLIAM. CSAT. sx. taki-n llu» storm for an iiulioation of Proviilcnco that IUmwIb Willinm waa not to be withsttKxi. For he counsclloil Iuh lo )for> brother-in-law to send to the King in Normandy and ™"7J[m_ ••^ ^^^ ^^'** jx^ace. Eadgar obeywl ; lie sent messen^^^nj into Normandy ; they were favourably received by William, and an embassy was sent to liriiiq' the /Ktheling- to the Kings court to receive the King's peace in person.* roller of Tlie policy of this course was clear, l^adgar was be- ginning to show that he could be dangerous. His estiib- lishment at Montreuil as a tool in the hands of Philip and Robert was far more to be dreaded by William than any- thing that he could do in England. But it was not safe to leave him at large. Whether in England, Scotland, or Flanders, he might always be made use of by any enemy. The wisest thing from William's point of view was to keep him in that kind of honourable captivity in which no one knew better than William how to keep those whom he feared.2 A prison was not needed for Eadgar ; it was enough to bring him to William's court, and to watch him E»clg^.r'» carefully under the guise of honour. There is something Norauuidv ludicrous in the picture of his journey. Eadgar once more set out for the Continent, but this time not by sea, and this time as AVil Ham's friend and guest, not as the vassal and soldier of Philip. Malcolm and Margaret again loaded him with costly gifts — their former presents had been lost in the storm.^ He seems to have been looked on as remaining their * Chron. Wig. 1075. " Da gersedde Be kyngc Malcholom him pact li<; ■ende to Wyllelme cynge ofer hsb and liaede his grySes, and he eac swa dyde, and Be cyngc him Hea getifiade and a-fter him sende." ' See above, pp. 75, 193. So Will. Malm. iii. 251 ; " Ultro solitus erat quoscumque Anglos suspectos habehat, quasi honoris caussiL, Nor- manniam ducere, ne quidquam se absente in regno turbarent." ' Chron. Wig. 1075, " Anrl se kyngc eft Malcolm and his sweostor him and eallon his mannan unarimede gfersama geafon, and swiSe weorS- lice hine efl of heora gryffe sendon." These passages, together with the EADOAR RECONCILED TO WILLIAM. 57| truest till he reached Durham. Tliere he was met by Iluj^h cnxr. ii. the son of Baldric, who had stieceetletl William Malet in the Sheritrdom of Yorkshire, and whose name fijjures in the foundation le^i-end of Selhy Abbey. Ilui^h attendtnl him throuj^h the whole lenf»-th of England, and across the sea into Normandy. At every castle on the road the -Ktlioiinj'' was honourably received, and meat and fodder were pro- vided for him and his train. At last he found himself, as he had found himself six years lx*fore, a guest in William's Norman court. ^ He was received with mickle Eadgv worship, and ho became a permanent han^T-on of the toWiiiUm. Kini,'-. He received such ri<^hts a.s the King gave him/ HU granu including lands in England of no great extent,^ and a penaonn. })ension of a pound of silver daily. He lived in Normandy (piiet, contented, and despised,^ till just before the end of account of the vast spoils taken by Siwanl in his Scottish warfare [hvo voL ii. p. 365), contrast strangely with Liter descriptions ami proverbs about the jmverty of Scotland. * Chron. Wig. 1075. " And se scirgerefa of Eoferwic com him togfanes mi Dunholme, and ferde ealne wei^ mid him, and let him findan mete aiul finlder a-t a-lcan castellc H«-''* hi to conion, oft* \>;vt hig ofur wi* to jnim kynige coman." The retcrborough writer leaves out the details of the journey. ' lb. " And flc kyng Wyllelm mid micclan weorffscype J>a hine under- fengc, and he wa»H J>»r J»a on his hirude. ano«l by William of Malrnesbury, iii. 251. * Will. Malm. iii. 351. " Iteceptus erjjo Ecdftentim pro ignaviA et, nt ntitiuH dietutii sit, pro simpliiitnte contemptui habic dreaded only on account of his ^rcat name, and of the uw which others might make of him; his j)er- Bonal qualities could not give William one moment of DMliiig* of uneasiness. It was in a different way that he dealt with ^tli the man who was less directly his rival, but who, with all Waltbaoi. j^-g faults^ ^vas far more likely than Kadgar to he some day the leader of successful opposition to foreign rule. We have now reached what we may fairly call the turning- point of William's reign, the tragedy of the fate of Wi\\- T¥»oBa theof. For once in his reign, AVilliam was to stain his execu- hands with blood, blood not shed on the field of battle, but WTlLun* ^y ^ mockery of a judicial sentence, blood which, as far as riign. the cause for which it was shed was concerned, was inno- cent. Nothing but the keenest conviction of danger could have led William to this marked deviation from his usual policy, that policy which, in his own eyes and in the eyes of Pohjiion of his age, was a policy of mercy. Waltheof, at this moment, held as high a ])osition as any man in the realm after the King himself. He held a position which was shared by no other Englishman save one, and that one to whom one almost shrinks from giving the name of Englishman, the renegade and half-caste Ralph of Wader. And now, by a strange chain of events, by a strange tale of rashness and folly, Waltheof and Ralph alike were to fall from their high places, to leave England without an English Earl, and to have as the partner in their ruin the enim simplicitaa ut libram argenti, quam quotidie in etippenJio acci- piebat, Regi pro uno equo perdunaret." I do not know the story here alluded to. ROGER EARL OF nEREFORD. 578 son and the successor of tlie most cruel oppressor of chap xx. Eng'lishmen. We have seen that Ralph of Wador, the son of Ilalph R^ph of the Staller of Eadward's days by a Hrt'ton mother, had y^^i'j received the Earldom of Iuist-An<'lia as the reward of ^**^r. his treason to his country. We have seen him actin«^ vigoroiLsly in William's interest when the first Danish fleet which professed to come to deliver En«^land tried to efifect a landing- in his Earldom.^ At the other end of Rog«r, England, William Fitz-Osbern, after losing his life for the H^.f!lrj sake of Richildis or her dominions, had l>een succeeded in his Earldom of Hereford by his younger son Roger. The character of Roger is vaguely set before us in an unfavour- able light, though in the eyes of Englishmen it might not have been thought any special blame that he did not walk in the steps of his father.- But there is more distinct evidence against him than this. '^Tliree letters are extant, Lanfranc'n addressed to him by Lanfranc, in which he stands chargeil j*,,^" not only with acts of doubtful fidelity to the King, whieli are but vaguely hinted at, but with denials of justice and unlawful invasions of the property both of the King and of other men. The letters are conceived in a tone of great personal affection. Roger is conjured by the memory of his father to turn from the error of his ways ; he is implorcnl to come in person to the Primate and receive his fatherly counsel. But in the third letter, as he still remains obsti- Hin ox- nate, sentence of excommunication is pronounced against cation, him, an excommunication from whieh he is not to be re- leased till he has thrown himself on the King's mercy and made restitution l>oth to the King and to all others whom he iiad wront^cd.'* It is plain fVom these letters that the ' St'c above, |). 352. ' Ho watj, accunliiiff to WilliaiJi of Malmcjihury (iii. 155), " tlot«itju».lic pcrfidiaj juvonU, nuc iiioribux |Mitrij«ian«." ' Ep. I^anfr. 47. p. 66. " Ab hoc vinculo anathcmatui abcolvure Uj non 674 THE RKVin.TS AOAINHT WILLIAM. ouLP. UL loyalty of Roger townnl tlio Kin^- was not a littlo (loultirul for some time before the (inal outl>reak. A ninrriA^ contrart^nl, as it would seem, in express (ii'fiance of the royal ortlore, wn« tlu' immediate ocvasion of 'the r»»lH'llion. luirl William had left a dau^^htcr, Knima >.;_. by name,* who was sou^lit in marriag-e by the Karl of Norfolk. William, for whatever reason, forbade the mateh. But, taking a^lvanta^'e of his absence, the two Earls carried out their scheme, and lloger of Hereford ^vc his sister in marriage to her suitor.^ Tlic wedding-feast — the bridi^ale, as our forefathers called it — was kept with niiii miiiericordiatn domini iiui Ile|^8 requiraa, idbique et aliin quorum rcM injuHU' ]tra'ger. In the first letter (p. 64) we read, " Dominus noHter Angloruni Rex salutat vos ct nos oinnes, sicut fideles suus, in quibus magnam fiduciaiu habet, et mandat ut, ({uantum poKsumus, curam habeauius a;t wif to Norfiwic ; " but again I see a correction in the wonls of Florence (1074), "In flnvntebrjcgeniii provinciii, in li»co (jui Yxninga dicitur." * Chron. Petrib. 1075 ; " pa;T wefl hn't bryd eala Man mini to beala." Or, M WorccHter reada the second line, " f'let w»8 man'egra nianna K-alo." * See below, pp. 584, 589, * Chron. ^Vi^,^ 1076. " I):it wa'S Ko^'ror corl and W.-iljioof «H)rl, and bifiCop.i.s and ablxMl;u<, and ra*ddon ha-r ptct hi woUlon heora kynfhlaf«)r\l of his cynorice aorough xitwt the fonn, one degn'C Kmi lf)yal, " Hi woldon Jxme cyn:^ gonettan ut of Englelaudes cynedomo." * My narrative i.s put to^etlier fnnn the Chroniclen, Florence, and Orderic, of whom the last, writing nnleatfin^ to (icnl to ^»t rid of him.* Ho had FixtiK'il William of Mortiiin,-' ami jH)iHon(Hl Conan,' Walter, and Hiota.* He had unjustly seized the noMo Kin^lom of England, and lunl murdered or driven into exile its lawful heirs. ^ This at lea.'^t was a strange charge, when tlie .Ktheling" was livin;,'" in miekle worshij) in William's eourt. To the eompanions of his victf)rics he had j^aid no such honour as he ought ; some he had put to death like others ; to others, after their wounds, he had given nought ])ut barren lands — such as the pastures of Herefordshire and tlic eorn-lands of Norfolk — and those wasted by the ravages of the enemy. ^' All men hated him ; many would rejoice at his death. No time could be better tlian the present; W^illiam was beyond the sea; the greater part of his host was with him ; he was overwhelmed with cares and wars and rebellions and discords in his own family; no one believed that he would ever come back. The English were a peaceful race, fonder of feasts and ales than of dramatized by Tliierry (ii. 6i), who puts each charge into the mouth in which it Heems moat appropriate, * Ord. Vit. 534 A. " Dcgener, utpote nothus, est qui Rex nuncupatur, et in propatulo divinitus monstratur quod Deo displicet dum talis herus regno prsesidet." * lb. B. See vol. ii. p. 292. • lb. See vol. iii. p. 316. * lb. See vol. iii. p. 207. ' lb. " Xobile rpg^num Anglise temcre invasit, yenuinos haredes injicste trucidarit vel in ex«ilium crudcliter pepulit." • lb. The mention of death of course shows how purely fanciful the picture in, but one charge is curious ; " Vulneratis victoribus steriles fundos et hoetium depopulatione desolatos donavit, et eiwdem postmwlum re- stauratoH, avaritia cogente, abstulit seu minoravit." Does it mean that, when a grantee of William had brought the wasted land into tillage, the King took it away from him again ? The charge has a certain likeness to the charge brought by the Peterborough Chronicler (1087), that in letting his demesne lands he would take them away from the first tenant, if another oflereo(l of their kinsfolk.' Then the two F^arls, Ilalph !Ul|.h and and Uo'^'-iT, turn specially to Waltheof. The time was ^pj^.^! to come for him to win hack what he had lost, and to take ^^«>**'«*»^- veng-eance for the wron«^s which had heen done to him.^ The losses and wrong's of W'altheof are perhaps not very easily seen ; still even the Earl of three shires and hushand of the King-^s niece might l>e tempted by oilers which might possibly give him the Crown itself, and which would at all events enlargtj his Earldom to a third part of England. The land was to be brought back to the same state in Allegwl wliich it was in the days of <^ood King Eiidward. All ^l^^, con- power was to be in the hands of the three, Roger, Riilph, •i»»™'"'*- and Waltheof. One should be King, the other two should be Earls.' Here we probably get a glimpse of the real intentions of the consj)irators. Tlie centralizing system of lrk»K>me- AVilliam, the effective power which he had given to the y^j-u ..f Crown in every corner of the land, was likelv enoufjh to be ' "^» ■• J ' X o central - irksome to his Earls, French and English alike. Ralph, ization. Roger, and Waltheof, g'reat as they were, were far from .^ H)wtr- being" so great as Godwine, Leofric, and Siward had been, ful umler Their Earldoms were of smaller extent ; their authority than vuuler within thcni was far more carefully narrowed. England '^ liad, under Cnut, under Eadward, under William, made so many steps in the direction of unity. It was now proposed to make her take a step backwards. AN altheof was called on, in the name of English patriotism, to join in a scheme ' Ord. \ it. 534 C. " Angli Bua HolutnnuMlo rura colunt ; conviviia ot (HitationibuH, non pra;lii8, intendunt ; 8ununop«ro tamen pro Huoruni cxiiiu parentum ultioneni vidore concupiscunt." * Ih. I). They addrrns him, " O Htrpnue vir," which in Tldi-m- lK»ct>me« " hnnime do cceur ;" hin Kngliwh tranwlfttur tuniM it into " valiant So-rtm,' ft de8crii)tion hanlly juHtified by WaltheofH mixed dittcent, Danish, An^dian, and urHinu. ^ Ih. ('. " VohiinuH ut HtatuH n^j^ji Albioniu rodint«grotur ommnKxliji Hicut ulim fuit tcni|K)ro Eduardi piiitMimi Rrgiii. I'nufl ox nobU ait R«x. et Hint Duces, et sic nobiM tribuM oninoH Anglici Mubjiciontur hunuitM.'* VOU IV. 1' p 578 TIIK HKVOLTH AGAINST WILLIAM. muf. 11. which |mmiiMtl hiuh piins to hin »)\vn <»|>|>ro8fWHl nation.' IWoott- WalthiHjf muv liavo Invn tompUnl hv Buch oilers; it is ■|4r*cj ooi ^nmrwl certain that the Knijlish ])tH)]»Ie were not. They woulil SmIMi in P^***^'y h.ive exehan^^inl Kin^ William for Kinjj Kail^r or ••••'•*• f«»r Kin«^ Sweml. They luul no mind to exchange him for Kinj;" Ilalph or Kin^ ll«)[>er ; nor had they any mind to clothe Halpli, lloj^er, or even Wallheof, with any iwwer which mi^ht distiirh the good peace which King AVilliam made in thin land.- AOtfad The narrative which we have just been following- makes Waliboof. Waltheof answer in an edil'ying sermon, in which all the usual scriptural exami)les are hurled at the heads of his tempters. He is William's man, William's Earl, the husband of AVilliam's niece ; he will never break his faith and turn traitor.-' Moreover, by a somewhat doubtful statement of English Law, he tells them that by that Law the traitor is condemned to lose his head.'* Other QoOTtton accounts set him before us as unwillingly beguiled into nottotha ^ consent to the conspiracy, but as presently repenting.'* •^"■P"**y* It is certain that he had no share in the open rebellion * Onl. Vit. 534 D. " Eja nobilis heros, conHultus observa tibi generique tuo commodiiiflimos oiiinique genti tuae, quae prostrata est, salutiferos." ' »See vol. ii. p. 17a. ' Ord. Vit. 534 D. "Guillelmus Rex fidem meain, ut major a minori, jure reoepit ac, ut ei semper fidelis exsisterem, in matrimonium mibi neptem Buara cojiulavit. Locupletem quofjue comitatum mihi donavit et inter sues familiares convivas connumeravit." The words in which the homage is described are not such as we should have looked for in the case of a mere subject. See above, p. 563. * lb. 535 A. " Anglica lex capitis obtruncatione traditorem mulctat, omnemque progeniem ejus naturali ha^reditate omnino privat." ' The story as told by Florence (1074) runs thus ; " Magnam conjura- tionem, plurimis assentientibus, contra Regem Willelmum ibi feccrunt, Comitemque Waltheofum, suis inHidiis praeventum, secum conjurare com- pulerunt ; qui, mox ut potuit, Lanfrancum Dorubernensem Archiepi- ■oopum adiit, pcenitentiamque ab eo pro facto, licet non sponte, sacramento •ccepit, ejusfjue consilio Regem Willelmum in NormanniA degentem petiit, eique rem ex ordine geatara pandens, illius misericordiae ultro se dedit.*' WALTHEOFS CONFKSSION. 579 uliicli followeil. lie liastonetl to Arclil^isliop I^nfniiic, ciur. xx. doubtless as to a spiritual father, but perha|)s also as Wing '*" <^'"'«^ for the time a temporal su|)erior. He told him of the un- Lanfranc. lawful oath whieh he had taken a«^ainst his will. When The o*th the breakin*'' of a oonstniintHl oath would be to ^Vil Ham's |^„j ji,^ advantage, the guilt of perjury was a far slighter matter '^^ fj than when its breaking was to ^Villiam*s damage. Tlie oath of Harold was to be kept at all ha/ards ; its viola- tion could be atoned for only by his own overthrow and that of his Kingtlom. But in the case of Waltheof an unwilling oath might lawfully be broken ; all that Lanfrane re<|uired of his penitent was to go through certain ecclesiastical penances, and to go and confess the whole matter to the King against whom he had sinned. ^\ altheof crossed the sea and sought the presence of Waltheof ^Villiam. He did not come empty-handed ; when he Xonnaiuiy craved the Kintr's forgiveness he offered rich i^i^s as the f"^ ^^'"* n r> .-) fesHeH to price of his mercy. ^ It is not quite clear whether the the King, pardon was formally given, but it is certain that William William't made light of Waltheof's share in the matter, that the treatmtnt Earl abode in Normandy till the King's return, and that"^^""" till the King's return he suffered no punishment or re- st rain t.- Meanwhile the Earls of Herefonl and Norfolk — strangt^ Revolt of ])redecessors of nobler bearers of the same titles^ — were u^,l*J**' ill open revolt against the King. Kal])h made the most of his twofold descent. As a Breton, he called on the The Hrv- Bretons in England, perhaps on those beyond sea, to join KiiLrl-^'i'l in the enterprise. As an Englishman, born and ruling J'"" *^^** ' in ono of the Danish districts of l']nglanA" ha-t \w com to Enjjlalamle." * See vol. ii. p. 791 ; iii. 466. * Chron. Wii^'. 1076, IVtrih. 1075. " iUwulf Korl ami Ko^,'r.•r hx)rl wwron V p 2 MO TIIK RKVOI.TS AUAINST WILLIAM. .II. to hi« stAJuluril ; the DaoM GUnc, but camo too Into for Inn i»ur|H>!*c. Hoth the Karln wont to their ICiirliloitiH, and gathcreil toj^'tlier such foreeH um thi-y could mustiT, iLki).. a largt* j>ortion of the fon*e8 of Ualj»h Ikmh^ Breton **"/^"* or other mercenaries.^ \\v set out towards the point ,, where he wa.s to meet I lie I'arl of Hereford, aniMan unrsede, and hi Hpeonon heom to ^a Bryttaa, and sendoa eac to Denenmrcon aifler scyphere." * See below, p. 584. ' Ord. Vit. 535 A, li. " (iuillelmua de WarennA et Uicardua de Bene- £actA, filiuB Gwleberti Comitui, quos Hex pra;cipuo8 Anglise justitiarios coujitituerat in regni negotiis, rebellantes convocant ad curiam Regis. lUi vero praceptis eorum obsecundare conteinnunt, sed proterviam prosequi conantcs in regios satelliteH pru.-liari eligunt." ' The Chronicles say only, "Rogcer ferde west to his eorldome and gadenuie his folc J>an cyncge to unl^earfe he Ixjhte, ac hit wear^ heom ■eolfiin to mycclan heanne ;" or, as Peterborough putH it, " ac he wearcS gelet." Florence gives us the names of those by whom he was let ; " 8ed Herefordensi Comiti, ne, Sabrina tranavadato, Kaeaucoup de GalloU des frontiiTeH.'* Tliw seemingly comes from Ii. W'eiidover (ii. 15), " WulleuHilnis sibi conf»i*«leniti»," but tbin in Hiiuply a iiii.sunderHtanding of the "HryttaH" of the C'hronicb-«i. Thierry ha.H alxo Home details of the campaign for which 1 cannot find the autljority. * Flor. Wig. 1074. " I'ropc Grantebrycgiiun castnunetanti." ' Chron. Wig. 1076, Petrib. 1075, " Rawulf eac wolde mid bin eorldomo ff)rSgan, ac t>a castelracnn K' wwron on Englalande, and vnc Jm-t landfolo hrom togenes com«»n,and hi ealle gelett4m \>ai hi naht ne «Iy«lon." ' Ep. Lanfr. 37 (Giles, i. 56). " KcNlulpliux Comes, immo Ko«hdphu« tradit«s nuHtri. aut ipni [H-rjiiri do tcn-a veHtrA per mare fugient aut eos vivog vel mortucis haUbunt." * See alM>ve, p. J78. * V*^\n\ H. II. its TIIK RBVOLT8 AGAINST WILIJAM. MAT- IS ctit otl.' ilaiph tUnl to Nonvirh, tlu> (^ipital of Ihh Knrldoin. ***t^. TK<» rtwtic which William had lx*j^un to build at a vrry "' *^' fdHv flB^of hij« n'ijj'n * wnH in his |M>KscsHion. Its bniMiii^ KfM^ involvixl tho di*rehendere poterant vel interemerunt vel difwria modi* debilitaverunt." ' See above, p. 67. * Dotnaaday, iL 116 h. "In ill& terrft de qua HeroIduH habcbat socam ■OBt ZXT. boi^nsM, et xvii. mansurai vacuae quae sunt in occupatione fnatwlli. ei in bargo clxxx. manHurae vacurse in hoc quod erat in Bocil Regis «t Comitu, et Ixxxi. in occupatione castelli." • lb. 118. Under the head auxiliia Tia\igio a^liit." • I accept the flight \Ai Denmark, though resting on the authority of Oidehe only, aa it ao exactly falla in with what went before and what CoHowB. The Chronicles do not tell us whither he sailed ; Peterborough, SURRENDER OF NORWICH. 583 Meanwliile the woman whose marriage had heoii the chap. xx. immeiliate cause of all this disturbance was showiup' a ^'/^i*^*I " (lef fill led ni)hh*r spirit than either her brother or her husljand. *'y Emma. When the Earl of Norfolk took ship from Norwich, he left the castle in charge of his newly married Countess.^ Emma boldly stood a siege in which all the engineering ^»t?(?e and skill of the age was brought to bear for the space of tiou of three months u}x>n the still new fortress of Norwich.^ ^^^'^ ' And she held out till she obtained terms of capitulation from the besie<;ers which mi«rlit be looked on as com- paratively favourable.^ Lanfranc could announce to the King in his next despatch that the castle of Norwich had surrendered, and that, in the Primate's own energetic language, the Kingdom was cleansed from the fdth of the Bretons.* Rali)h, it is to be supi)osed, had some Norman and some English followers, but of their fate we hear Ttrms nothing, except from a statement in the Survey which to the shows that some of Ralph's partizans in the city had to ^'■®^^- seek dwellings elsewhere.'' This however, though it may to the passage before quoted, adds, that he " for to scipe a't Nor^wic." Florence (see the first note on the last page) mentions his flight to Britanny. He doubtless went there in the end. * See the pa.s8age in the Chronicles just quoted. So also Florence, "Castello suae conjugi niilitibu.'*(iue suis commendato." Orderic does not mention the Countess at this stage. ' Orderic (535 B) gives the full details of the siege; how the walls were attacked '* crebis aasultibus variisque niachinationibus," and that *' per tres menses." ' Chron. Petrib. 1075. " And his wif wn*8 innan J^am cantele, and hine heold swa lange pvct man hire grilS sealde." * p]p. Lanfr. 38 (fJiles, i. 57). "Gloria in txcclsis Deo, cujus misericordiA regnuin vestrum purgatum est spurcitia Britonum." ' It seems plain from Domesday (ii. 117 h) that some of the English citiz«'ns of Norwich were involved in Ralph's fall ; ** I>l' bursensibus qui manserunt in burgo de Norwic abienmt et niancnt in IWccKs villA Al^batis Sancti Edniundi xxii. et vi. in Uuniilgar, Ii. et dimisorunt burg\ini. Et in Torp Regis i. et in terr& Kogerii Bigot i. «!t sub W. de Noies i. et Kicardus do Scint-(.'ler i. Isti fugit-ntcH et alii runumcntes omnino sunt viistati, partini propter fnrirtfa<-tur:is Ii. rotnitiH, pnrtini propter arMuran), partim propter geltum Regis, partini propter Wuhr.iiiiiuiii." In connexion THE BKV0LT8 AGAINST WILLIAM. c«Ar I* harf h$Hk liio indirect rwmlt. wni» not lik«'ly to In- the forma] t4!rei of the terms of fa|)itulnti»»n. Amonp tlu* Brttoiw, who must luivc b«»on n ronsidcraMe IkkIv, thom» who had land* in Kn^land won* |»r()mistHl saffty in life and limb, and won? allowtil forty days to ^ai thorn out of tho Kinplom, to wliicli they were not to conic Imck without the KinjjV leave.* The mercenaries who liud no Und, but who had followeil I'^irl Iliilph for pay, were by dint of many entreaties admitt^Kl to the same terms, but the •horter time of a month was ^ivcn them to leave the King- dom.* The castle was occupied by two of the captains of the l>e8ieg«rs, Bishop GeofTrey and Earl William of Warren. With them was joined Robert Malet, a son of the famous William, who appears in the Survey as one of the great landowners of East-Anglia.*^ The garrison which they commanded consisted of three Inindred men-at-arms, and a body of balistarii and other engineers."* Norwich was thus held in safe keeping till the King's return. The ConntesB Emma, who had so valiantly defended the city, was received to the same terms as her followers. She made her way to Britanny, and was presently joined there by her husband.^ Tlius there was once more peace in the realm of King with ibis entry we m*y note the expreiwion of Orderic (535 C), " Vicarii Be^ GoiUelmiu et KicarduH municipM oppidi [though those words do not ahrmjabear » dric meaning] an." So Florence. Orderic (535 C), " RxpaUtu itaque cum uxore sua Britanuiam repetiit." This is Orderic's oolj mmtioo of the heroine. Lanfranc does not speak of her at all. THE DANES IN THE HUMBKK. 585 ^Villiam.^ But it was known that the dealing of Ralph chap. xx. with the Danish court luid not heen in vain, and that a Danish fleet was then on its voyaj^e. I^ntranc, as a watchful guardian of the realm, strictly charged Bishop Walcher to keep the new castle of Durham safe against their attacks. 2 Presently the King himself, whose presence \Viiiiam*M had been earnestly asked for by his lieutenants,^ came back to England. He brought with him Earl AValtheof, but not as yet as a prisoner. But soon after William's Arrest of landing, Waltheof was arrested.^ It is possible that this step may have been caused by the actual appearance ofTlieDanJMh a fleet of two hundred Danish shins in the Ilumber. Such tj.^, J" '*'' an invasion would naturally bring up again the memory of ^Valtheofs old exploits, and none the less that one of the leaders of the Danish fleet was Waltheof's old com- panion in arms. Swend had, as well nigh the last act of his life, once more sent his son Cnut, the future King and Its com- saint, together with an Earl named Ilakon, as the com- Cnut and manders of the fleet. "^ At such a moment it might well ^^'''*''^°- * Ep. Lanfr. 38 (Giles, i. 57). " Omnis strepitus bellonim, mLseranto Deo, in Anglic& terra quievit." So more emphatically in 21 (i, 49) ; " Nos expulsis Britonibus et sedatis omnibus bellis, in tanta tranquillitatc vivimus ut, poatquam Rex mare transiit, tranquillius nos vixisse nequa- quaiu meminerimus." ' lb. a8 (i. 49). " Dani, ut Rex vobis [Walchero] mandavit, revera veniunt : cajntrum itaque vestram hominibu.s et amiis et alimentis Nn^alanti curA muniri facite." ' Ord. Vit. 535 C * Chron. Petrib. 1075. "And se cing sySSan com to Englalaude, and genam Roger Eorl hi.s ma?g and gefe.stnodf hiiio, and WulJH'Df Eorl he genam eac." Worcester inserts hero the account of Waltheof'a voyage to Normandy, quoted in p. 579. Roger's captivity is described in Worcester by the wordn " ancl nette on prisun^ — foreign names being neero de NormanniA ren twii'gt-n hoafiMbnt-nn, C'nut Swicgnt'M Hunu fCyngi-n, Wi|,'.J and M.-u-un Eorl." This is the llakon whom Lappenberg (sue above, p. 142) identified with ilakon the son of 8ti THE REVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. CSAT. n. Mem tiiat i nut H kM fcllow-ftoliIitT, the man who liad clofftB to niAny Nornian HkulU iH'forc the pitr of York f^^rtlf wms not a man who couKl be Bofely lefl at hir^o ia BwUod. Waltheof was therefore put in ward as well ■• Rofrar, and the two Earla awaitinl tlicir public trial in the Midwinter (JemotJ TfcirMir Meanwhile the Danes were once more in the IlumWr. ** We hear nothing of their rweption by the people at lar^ ; we hear nothing of any resistance which thry may have met with fn.»m the King's commanders in Yorkshire. On the other hand, we hear of no exploits on their part, of no battles fought, of no Norman fortresses destroyed or taken. It is plain that the two castles of York did not hinder the Danes from sailing up the Ouse, but it is T^^t j'.un. ojiially clear that all that they did at York was an u.y.'oUT ns«l«-ss act of sacrilege, followed, so the story runs, by one of the usual judgements. " They dared not hold fight ^-ith William King, but they went to York, and brake Saint Peter's minster, and took therein mickle wealth, and so went away. And all died that were of that rede, that was Ilakon Karl's son and many others with him." ^ Thus the metropolitan church of the North, rising from its ruins under the care of Archbishop Thomas, raffered again, though doubtless far less severely than it had suffered in the last days of Ealdred.^ According to one version, the land to which the Danish fleet sailed SvagoB the aoii of Godwine. But couM Hakon, who must h.ive been bom •boot 1047, hare bad a son of the age which w implied directly after ? Tkiu Danish inroad i» mentioned only in the Chronicles. The DaniHh writen, ai ukuaI, give no help. * See note 4 last page. • Chron. Wig. 1076. "And ne dornton nan gefeoht healdan wiC Wil- UnM Cjog«, ac ferdon to Eoforwic, and bnecon See Petres mynster, and X6ecn ^erinne mycele shta, and foron Bwa aweg, ac ealle ]>& forferdon ►« Ki |>am nede WKron ; J>Kt wses Hacones sunu Eorlea, and manege o5re mid hini." Peterborough does not mention the sacrilege or its punish- • See abore, p. 267. DEATH OF EADGYTII. 587 after leavin<»' York was Flaiulers.^ Cnut was, now or coap. xx. later, the husband of Count Robert's dau«^hter ;^ both were enemies of William, and a meeting' of the two princes mi«^ht be sou ^o75- yet marks the severing of another tie between the older and the newer England. The Lady Eadgyth, the daughter of Godwine, the sister of Harold, the widow of Eadward, died in the month of December, in her palace at "Win- chester.^ Whih> all the rest of her family were either Her posi- slain or wandering to and fro in foreign lands, she had William, kt'pt all her lands and honours, and, as Queen ^fatilda was almost always in Normandy, she must have practically kept something more than the usual rank of the Old Lady. We have seen reason to think that her heart was Norman rather tlum English;"* still Englishmen must have felt that their land became somewhat less Eng-lish by the loss of one who, though of English birth, still sat in the highest place among the conquerors. The age of Eadgyth it would be hard to fix exactly. If she was, as seems not unlikely, the eldest child of Godwine and Gytha,' she must have now been about llfty-five years old. In that comparatively short space she had seen Changes mighty changes in England and in the world. Born iifytimo. ' Chron. Petrib. 1075. " Ac heoldon ofer sts to Flandran." ' Edia, Ethela, or Adela. See Knytlinga Saga, c. 30 ; .Mnoth. Hirtt. S. Canuti, Langebok, iii. 344 ; Will. Malm. iii. J57, and Chnm. IVtrih. 10S5. ** Cnut hfafde H<»(ilt«'ardi'H dohter." • Chron. Wig. 1076, I'rtrib. 1075; Flor. Wig. 1074. "And Eatlgyft' Beo hl.'L'fdie [hlaifdig, iVtril). ) for.Nfcrde, seo wie« EadwarduH cynges guresta, seofuQ niht a'r Xpes ma,'SH;kn, on Winco»tro.** * See vol. iii. p. 635. • See vol. ii. p. 555. THK BKVOLTft AGAINST WILLIAM. 11 in the f-arlv tlavi« of Cnut, she \uu\ m^'U the trou])l('f» of thr rt- ij^ii** of hi» mitih ; nho had nlinrt'*! in th»' rovmltv of the n^torwl Knirlish kin^^lv houw ; kIic had tharvd in one overthrow of her own family, and sho liad bciield anotiier more utter overthrow in wliidi nhe did not share. The sibtor nf Ilarohl hoKliii;^'- tin' hi^Hienl pUce among' her sex at the court of William must have been a stninge siffht in the eyes l)oth of Kn^^'-linhmen and of Normani. And the mention of Ead<^'th su'^pi'ests the momentar}* thought (tf other Kng-lishwomen who, like her- FM*«f telf, survived the lM»nda'»'e of their country. (Jodgifu, the ■^^ ' widow of Le8 ^a hono midwinter on WcHtmynatre, httr mon fordemdu eallo )>a Bryttan \>^ wicron n;t )>ani bryiilnpu X't Nurt'Svvie. Suiiie lii wurdon j^'cMlmuIc, and suine wrucon of lande, and Huniu getawod to Hcunde. pun wunion ^u.'» kyningcri bwiaiu gciiy- Oenule." v» THE HKVOLT8 AOAIXST WII.I.I AM. CTur. 11. Tixe other two YmtU, IU^t ami Walthoof, wore in mh ^'*rf ^_ k(vj»inj:. «nd api»enn'orwm In-Oire the AHScmbly. u^m •>/ H«^^r, Oil inav U* hup|)omh1, bad no drfonrc to make nf^inst **"**' thi* charpt' of trva»f>n. His sontoncc. nccordinp to Norman I^ir, was confiscation of lands and |)criH>tual im))ri8on- YVW«f mcntJ Tho ca»o of Walthoof was one of more dininilty ; on no Bhouinj'' had ho taken any active share in the rrln^llion ; whatever his oirenci* was, he had done what he oould to repair it hy a kixmmIv confession, and the Kin*^'H own tn^tment of him while in Normandy mif^ht liave been taken as an earnest that no very heavy punishment RMDi^of was in store for him. Hut Waltheof had his worst enemy J«litL on his own hearth ; the tie which hound liim most closely to William proved to be the very snare in wliicli he was entangled. His foreig^n wife, for what reason wo are not told, sought his destruction. It is plain that William bimself was not disposed to deal harshly with him, but Judith stood forth as the accuser of her husband in the of her uncle. The Earl was charged before the smbly with having been a favourer and accomplice WaltiMort of the late reWllion.^ His defence was that he had indeed heard the scheme of rebellion proposed, but that he had in no way consented to so wicked a design.^ Such at lea.st is the version of the historian who gives us the fullest narrative, but it is a version which overlooks the oath to the conspirators, which, willingly or unwillingly, there can l>e little doubt that Waltheof had taken. However this mav be, there can be little doubt that the Gemot * OrtL Vit. 535 D, "Secundum leges Normannorum judicatus est, et uniM4 omni hcreditaUj terren^ in carcere Regis perpetuo damnatus est." ' lb. 536 B. " Gallevus Comes a^l Regem accersitus est, et per cUlatioiMim Judith uzoHb susb accusatus est, quod prtedictse proditionis oooaehu et fautfir fiierit dominoque suo infidelis exstiterit." • lb. 535 B. "Ille intrejtidus palam recognovit quod proditorum nequis- ▼olontatem ab eu audierit, Bed eis in tarn nefanda re nullum oninino dederit.'* TIMAL AND DEFENCE OF WALTIIEOF. 591 came to no (.lefinite conclusion as to his sentence. He was '^"^»'- xx. remanded to prison at Winchester — a straiter prison, we manild* are told, than he had been in ])efore his trial.^ ^" l"''.''"" at N> in- The outlawry of the Earls of Norfolk and Ileret'ord chcHtcr. placed their estates and offices at the King-'s disposal, and ,,f*^^^\ the death of the Lady threw her lands also into his hands. ftn»l K«»i,'er m • 1 1 • /» 11 • confiscated. To enrich his followers was no lon«i^er so important an object with William as it had once been ; the needs of the royal exchequer were now the first object. Still portions of the forfeiteil lands were granted out.^ In East-Ang-lia Orants to p 1 1 T r» T-» 1 1 Koger the especially a large part ot the lands or lialph went to Bigod. enrich the founder of that great House of Bigod which some generations later was to succeed to his Earldom.^ But vast portions of the lands of the two Earls and of the Lady were kept in the King's own hands, » and no new No new r iris J\T'W Earls were appointed to the vacant Earldoms. The later p,)inted. history of the two chief rebels was strangely contrasted. Ilalph, banished from England, flourished in his mother's Later line of Ralph land of Britanny. He lived to take the Cross at the Waiier. preaching of Pope Urban, to set forth as a Crusader in the train of William's eldest son, and to die, along with his heroic wife, on their way to the Holy City.'' His son ' Ord. Vit. 535 B. " Super hac confessione judicium indagntum est et, cen.sorihuM inter se sentientibus, per plures imluciaa u.sque in annum pro- telatuin est." Florence (1074) says, "Comites Waltheofum et Rogerum, judiciali sententia damnatoM^ arctiori custodiiu mancipavit." I think we may accept the fuller version in Orderic, which does not suppose any inaccuracy in Florence, except in extending the words in Italics to Waltheof. ' Some lands which Ralph had given to Saint Benedict, seemingly of Ramsey, had come into the hands of William of Warren. See Domestlay, ii. 158, 158 b. ' For the lands of Roger the Bigod, see Domesday, ii. 173-190. Roger died in 1 107. Tlie first Earl was his younger son Hugh, creati-d K;irl of the East-Angles by Stephen in 1140 See R. Howdcn, i. i03 Stubbs, where ho appears as " Hugo consul de Est Anglo." See Dugdale's Baronage, 13a. * But we must not forget the remarkable application of one |>art of the Inntls of Eadgyth. See a])ovc, p. 167. • Or«l. Vit. 535 C. " In viil Dei pwnitenH et pcrogrinua cum uxoro suA obiit." TIIL UKVOLTB A0AIN8T WILLIAM. ^r. &S. ioccc>ctlc, ami hu ilaii^ht*T wa* n«Hlorctl to Kni^land by a inarria^o uith VjitI UoU'rt of LtMco«tor.' Wliilo Ualph was doin^ •onffthin^ in hin last dayn to wipe out tlir mcniorv of hit niAiiifold treasons, his Accomplice lio^r ])in(Hl out tf , .. . R4gv. the rciit of his days in prison. I^^^lllianl had any mind to rvlcoM* him, his own conduct ellW-tnally cut oti' all h« ' He is dcscrilKxl as constantly reviling" and nuir- nuinnu a^inst his sovcrci*^n, and in one case oflerinpf Mkta- him the most marked insult. One year at the Ea-ster lift . , . ahff Kiw. y^tuit, when the Kin«i^ made gifts to his lords, he sent a gift also to his imprisoned kinsman, a gift of goodly raiment, of silks and costly furs.' Roger piled np the King's pn»8ents in a heap luul at once set fire to them. The news was brought to AVilliam. "The man is too proud," said he, " who does such scorn to me ; but, by the sj)lendour of God, he shall never come out of my prison in my days." ' AVilliam kept his word, and his ilediflaia socoessor kept it after him; Roger the son of "WillLim ^^^^ Pitz-Osbern died in prison, and when our informant HiiMoa. wrote, his two sons, Reginald and Roger, were striving, by good s€r\'ice to Henry the First, to merit the resto- ration of some part of their father's possessions.^ ObaHmMd But a deeper interest attxichcs to the fate of the Earl ^myy* who was waiting his final sentence in his prison at Win- WaIiLmC Chester. Waltheof remained for months in his bonds, but » Ord. Vit. 535 C. • lb. 875 D ; WilL Gem. viii. 15. Orderic calls her Amicia, and the oootinuAtor of William, Itta. See Dugdale's Baronage, p. 68. ' Ord. Vit. 535 D. "Regalia omanienta, chlamydem, sericamque in- tomlam, et reDonem de prctioHis pellibus peregrinorum murium." Compare Uie gifta made by Malcolm and Margaret to Eadgar, p, 569. • lb. 536 A. " Multum superbuB eat, qui hoc mihi dedecuH fecit, sed, p« q>leiMloreni Dei, de carcere meo in omui vitA mea non exibit." Williajn'ii characteristic oath should be noticed. lb. He ae„teco8t This time sentence of death was pronounced. He had ^^^y '-^l- listeneil to the proposals of men who were plotting the King's life. lie had not at once opposed them, nor had he revealed to his sovereign the danger in which he stood.^ On these grounds, grounds which, according to any version He Ih con- of the story, were utterly frivolous, the English Earl was j^^^JJ^ doomed to die. Whatever may have been the letter of the ' See above, p. 535. ' See the deHcription of hia penitence given by Onleric (536 B) and Florence (1075), and see above, p. 256. ' Flor. Wig. 1075. "C'ujuH meinoriam voluenuit homines in terra (lelerc, sed creditur vure ilium cum sanctia in ctelo gaudere, pnedicto archi- pnesule pia: memoriae Landfranco, a quo, confes^^ione facta, pcL>nitentiam acce[jerat, fideliter attestante ; (jui et impositi crimiuia, supradicUe scilicet conjurationi.s, ilium immunem attinnabat cmhc, et tpia* in ctetcria commiHifiset, ut vcrum Chrintianum, puLnitontialibus lacrimiH de flcvisae ; 8e.st exitum vita* illius felici potiretur requie." * Ord. Vit. 5.^6 C. ** PnevalcnH concio ii'mult)rum ejus in curia regali coadunata u«t ;" and directly after, " Normanni qui . . . sibi pra-dia yju» et largos honoreH adipiHci cupiebant." * lb. " Euiu poHt multos tractatuH reum vnne mortiM definitum est, qui HodiilibuM do morto dondni Hui tractantibuH conseuHerit, nee eo.s pro herili exitio jHjfculerit, nee apert& delatione Heeluromun factionem dotexerit." VOL. IV. (^ (j TIIK REVOLTS AOAIXST WILLIAM. 11. law ID either count n*, muli an oxivution wuh without n pre- cwient (or vcam |uutt cithrr in Kn^rland or in Norinamly. It wmi ujMTiiilly un|m"Ceration8 of warfare. And strangest of all was the uneOHtlo Teter — comes, according to the Art de Verifier les DateH (i. 76 , on May 31. If bo, Orderic's date of April 30 must l)c a Hlip, and the sentence must have been puHrted at WcstminHtor at Pt^ntecost, not at Winchester at KaMter ^March 37). THK RKVlH.TH A0A1N8T WILLIAM. irmkT n to otter the woitLi '• lX?livir path, and his Ixnly wau at •>n«'^ meanly buninl u|>on tho jdaco of marly nlom. By Ofiafof - time the men of Winchester had risen from their l>cd8, and had heanl what a deoeiul(>nt liotine wu8 O^vImhL given to a monk of his own mono«tery, Ulfcytel by name.'' io6i-ioM. ji^ b4»^» a new ehureh, and in that work he waa much hel|MMl by his neighbour the Kar\ of Northampton aiiente Leofrico Ahbate suo, suscepit." * lb. Bftmack wa« given " vul hoc opus," for building the church. * lb. 537 A- •* Ibi in fofwa corpus ejus viliter projectum est, et viridi eaipite fe«tiDantcr coopertum e«t." * M. Paris, i. 20. •* Rex Willielmas prseoepit Weltheofum Comitem in Wintooii deoollari et extra civitatem in bivio Bej)eliri." (Compare the leg«nd of Godwine in voL ii, p. 612.) This writer Lad no notion of tho real Meoe of the execution. WALTIIEOFS BODY KEMOVED TO CROWLAND. 599 could bear that his body should lie in unhallowed ground caxF. xi. upon the rocks of Sussex.' And the monks of Crow- land had a more powerful intercessor with William than the canons of Waltham had. Judith, whether to save aj)pearances, or really smitten with remorse by the blow which had made her a widow, joined in the prayer of the convent, and AVilliam gave leave to Abbot Ulfcytel to remove the body of his benefactor. Fil'teen days The body therefore after the martyrdom of Waltheuf came his j^ cVow- first translation. The bodv, still fresh and bleeding" '*"^- " ' ° June 15, — so the tale ran — was borne to Crowland among the 1076. tears of many, and was there reverently buried in the chapter-house.'-^ But a subordinate part, however honourable, of the monastic buildings of Crowland, was soon deemed too mean a resting-place for the relics of the martyr of England. Abbot Ulfcytel kept his office for nearly ten years after the death of Waltheof. He was then deposed Deposition by Lanfranc in one of his Councils. We know not the Midwinter^ formal ground of his sentence, but we are given to under- 1085-6. stand that his real crime was the crime of being an Englishman. There is therefore nothing unlikely in the uncertified tale or tradition that the charge was one of superstition and idolatry, witnessed by the unauthorized miracles which the Abbot allowed to be wrought at the tomb of the English Earl. Ulfcytel, on this view, was a fellow-sufiferer with Sukrates ; he was punished for the introduction of strange saints whom King William did not find it convenient to acknowledire.^ However this '&' ' On tho analogy between tho buriaU of Harold and Waltheof, see vol. iii. p. 519. ^ Ord. Vit. 537 A, 54i C. The tranalation waa made " rogatu Judith et peniiiMflu Regi.M." The Ixnly was " adhuc integrum cum recvnti cruore, AC Hi tuni idem vir oblHset." • This in the wcUkiiowii story of tho falne Ingulf ^(ialf, 73), who niakeH Ulfcytel be depoBed on the accusation of Ivo Taillcl>oiH and othere in tho .'4^ Tlir. REVOLTS A0AIN8T WILLIAM. JLX of as nuiy l>c. it in cwt«in that tlu* womler-workinj^ powers of Walthcof bogmn to bo bln/.iMl al»ri>a]M>intment of an Engtiihiiuui to a hi^h office. The new Abbot wiih In^ilf, a name whieh has beoomo too well known through the forged History of Crowland wlueh bears his name, and which wa« so long mistaken for a genuine monument of the eleventh century J No genuine historical writinpfs of In;^ulf are extant ; but Inpulf himself must have been a remark- able man. An Englishman by birth, he had attached him- self to William's fortunes ; he had become his Secretary, 80 that we may very likely have some genuine pieces of his Oomi>osition in the English writs of William's reign.^ He fir«t aMsembly held in London after Waltlieof's translation. The date ia ut- toiij wrong, for it is certain that Ulfcytel was notdepoHed till the Gloucester Ammahtj of 1085-1086 (see App. Chnm. Wint.). Orderic also (543 C) MMM not to have known how many yearn parsed before the deposition ; •• Pbat Don multuin temporis pra-fatus Abbas, (juoniam Angligena erat et Komuumis ezo«ui, ab eemulis accuuatus est, et a Lanfranco ^Vrchiepiscopo depodttu et Glestonis claustro deputatus est." But here is no formal char]^, and it is not at all unlikely that the false In^'ulf may be reporting the genuine tnuljtion of the house when he says that the " debita reverentia nncto martyri habita " waa by his accusers turned into a charge of " idololatria." The story in short forestalls the later saying, " I>e par le roi ; defense h Dieu De faire miracle en ce lieu." ' I need hanlly, at this time of day, go about to disprove the genuineness of the ao-called Ingulf. A writer who misdates his own appointment by t«n J9tn, who finds Alexios Koriin«''noH reigning at Constantinople at some tfane before King William came into England, and who makes William raoatre hJs death-wound at Le Mans instead of at Mantes, must, if con- taoipormry, hAve been singularly careless. For a cloud of evidence of other kinds, SM Bir. Riley's paper in the Archaeological Journal, vol, xix. (1862), p. 32 • Ord. Vit, 543 C. " Ingulfus Fontinellensis raonachus Abbatiam CmUndis dono Guillelmi Regis recepit, et xxiv. annis per plurimas »dr9niX^ea rexit. Hie natione Anglicus erat; scriba Regis fuerat." There is nothing here to imply, as is asserted in the false histf»ry, that Ingulf attached himself to WilKam during his visit to England in 1 051. He is far more likely to have been one of the many Englishmen who SBt«red Williwm's service after his coronation. ABBOT IXOl'LF. 601 had afttTwards made the pilf^rimag^e to Jerusalem, and had ch.vp. xx. entered on relig-ion in a Norman monastery, the famous house of Saint Wandrille. There he had rist»n to the di<^- Inj^ulf nity of Prior, and thence, by William's j^-ift, he was pro- Cruwlan.1. moled to the abhatial stall of Crowland.* His first act was ^086-1109. to crave the Kiuf'-^s mercy for his predecessor. Ulfcytel had been committed to safe-keeping in the distant monastery of Glastonbury. At Ino-ulf's prayer, he was allowed to come back and end his days in the house of Peterborough where he had dwelled in his youth.- Ingulf, sickly in body but vigorous in mind, ruled the church of Crowland for twenty-four years.-* He repaired the damage done by Second a fire to the church and the other buildings of the monas- ti,,n of tery, and he gave a fresh attraction to the restored building ^^al^^^eo^- by removing into it the body of one who was beginning to be looked on as the local martyr. Waltheof was not a canonized saint, whose relics could be exalted in a shrine for a worship publicly recognized. But he might be laid in the founder's place of honour by the high altar. Thither the body was translated, a body which, so the legend told, was found, sixteen years after death, still whole, with the severed head joined again to the trunk, and with only a thin line of red to show where the headsman's sword had fallen. •» * Ord. Vit. 54a D. ** Hierusalcm porrexerat, unde rcversus FontinuUam expetiit, et a vin> eruditiiiMinio Gerberto ejusdem ccenobii Abbate mona- chilc-m habituin Hu.scopit, sub «|Ui) jam ii» ordine iustructus priorutum ailministravit. Hunc ab Abbatu suo Hex, (jui priuH oum novurat, rtMjui.sivit ct CrulandenHibus pnbposuit." We here boo where Inj^ulf really got his leamini,', nut at WcMtiainHter or at Oxford. Saint (Jerb«>rt, Abbot of S,iint Wandrille from 1062 to 1089, waa a (Jennan by birth and a great philoMopher. See Neuatria Pia, 169. ' lb. ** l*oHt<|uam CrulandijL* regimen habuit, pni'decefwori huo precibua benevoliH apud Ciuillelmum Kegem subvmiro Kat<'git." ' lb. •* (Jravi morbo pixhigrn' det«-nturt, diu ante mortem fiuam languit, ■ed vivaci animo RulHlitifl prodesse non «b-.siit." * lb. " C'orpuH Guallovi Comitis do capitulo jussit in c«-cle.si;iin tr.ins- fnrri, ft afpiani, iinde ogsa lavarentur, calefieri. S«»d p<*iit<|nani sHrt'opli.ii^i \\ •Ot TIIR RKVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM. iHAf. &JL Fttribcr mir»oloi». ininiclos of hvaViuf^, w»»ro of courHo wrou|ffat at tiio tomb of the trnnsliitod hero, ah in nftiT 1*65. davf thi'V won* wmng^ht by the relicH of Karl Simon of "*•'* Liciixvter and Earl Thomas of Lancaster.* And, Hei'minj»'ly Ome/Btwj tSier a hill, they began a^in in the reig^n of the next 10^ tii4 Abbot Geofrn»y, whose work in repairing; or rebuilding- the minster may have n«'«(l« d some Fuch special Banction.* Minwic* ..f In his day, more than a ^rncration after the Conquest, Kn^linhmen still rejoiced in the mighty works of the national hero.' An unl>elieving Nonnan monk, who maintained the martyr to be a traitor justly punished for his crimes/* was sternly rebuked by his Abbot, a Frenchman from Orleans, who was therefore less open to purely Norman prejudices.* opertorium revolutum est, corpus xvi. dormitionis huoq anno integrum, sicut in die qao sepultum fuerat, ct caput corpuri conjunctum, repertum att. Filum tantummodo, tjuasi pro signu decollatiunis, rubicunduni ihllilllit monachi et laici qu.'iiuplures qui adfueruut." • Ord. ViL 543 A. In th*e second volume of the Chroniques Anglo- Normandes (p. 131) there is a special tract, " Miracula Sancti Waldevi Glorioai Martj-ris." Most of them are wrought for the benefit of persons with Eoglish or Danish names, but among them (141) is " qusedam mater- familiaa religioHa, Athelis nomine, pa^ Normannico oriunda." Compare Um analogous tract, *' Miracula Simonis de Montfort," in Halliwell's RMbai^Mr, p. 67 ; and for Thomas of Lancaster see bis Office in Wright's Political Songv (Camden .Society), 268, and the document in Kymer, ii. 525, about hii alleged miracles, the counterpart of those of Waltheof. • It aoonda strange to read directly after the passage just quoted (Ord. Vit. 543 B) that under Geoffrey "ad tumbam Guallevi Comitis miracula domooatnri primiius capcrunt." These "more first miracles" of K'lrl Waltheof really renxind one of " more last words of Mr. Baxter." • Orti Vit. 543 B. " Auditis rumoribus Angli valde latati sunt, et AnglJCTW plebea ad tumulum sancti compatriotae, quem a Deo jam glori- ficari agnie multiplicibus audiunt, tam pro gaudio novae rei quam pro mis ncceeritatibua deprecaturi frequenter adcurrunt." • lb. " Quidem de Normannis monachus, nomine Audinus, vidit, vehe- meotcr Btom.^chatus advenientes derisit, et praefato Comiti cum irrisione deCrasit, dicens quod nequam traditor fucrit, et pro reatu suo capitis obtruncatione mulctari meruerit." • lb. C. " Dulciter eum, quia extraneus erat, redarguit." The French- man auioui to have been fjuite naturalized in England, though the Norman wae not. Geoffrey had been a monk of Saint Evroul, and was a personal friend of Orderic MIRACLES OF WALTIIEOF. 603 Nor was he merely rebuked by an earthly sui)erior; divine coap. xx. venf^eanee presently smote the scotler with sickness and death, while the taithful Abbot was rewarded with a vision in wliich he was assured that he who had been only an Earl on earth was now a King* in heaven.^ At last, the Waltheof old times mij^ht seem alto«^ether to have come back when, crowland. on the death of Geotlrey, the Ablx^y of Crowland received "^4-"38- as its ruler a man of the noblest Enyplish blood, and bearin<^ the martyr's name.- The hero had now to find his poet ; the monks of Crowhind needed an epitaph for the local saint, and Abbot Waltheof and his convent called in the aid of the monk of Saint Evroul, Orderic or Vital the Englishman, who had visited their house in the days of Abbot Geoffrey. * The historian undertook the task, and told in such hexameters as the age could produce, how Waltheof, the valiant and the devout, the son of the Danish Si ward, died by the sword at the bidding of Norman judges.^ The widow of Waltheof, Judith, appears in the Survey Esutoa as holding large estates, especially in Northamptonshire, juditk estates which had partly belonged to her husband, partly to other English owners.-^ She appears in monastic history ' See the story, and a wonderful hexameter or " mouadicon," in Orderic, 543 C. ' See above, p. 534. Abbot Waltheof, I am sorry to say, was deprived in I138. Mon. Ang. ii. loi. ' See Ord. Vit. 537 A. To this visit we owe Orderic's account of Crowland, which he wrote at the request of the Prior Wilainus [Wulfsige ?]. See above, p. 497. * Orderic gives the verses in pp. 543, 544. " Danigente Comitis 8[i]wardi filius audxix " has his virtues recorded, and then we read of liim M " (Icni'iue judicibus Nonuannis enso peremptus." There is quite another epitaph in C'hron. Ang.-Nonn. ii. i J3, where Judith is compared to iierodLiM an«l Job's wife ; " Ha'c accusavit ; Rex credidit, et tibi mortem Intulit, assignans cum ilamnatis tibi Hort<'m.*' ' Judith*! estates in Huntingdonshire are givon in DomeHiiay. J 17. thit»e •04 THE REVOLTS AGAINST WILLIAM \ an tho foundreM of « Ikmis,* rifnnns at IlrlfiiHtow or Klstow \- nttir IJ«««lf«»n!.* a platv uu^rv famouf* in lftt4T times as the I ... - lurth-placi' of John Hunyan. lie^-ond linn much more to toll of hrr. Liko Cn»it at tho tnin)) of I'^juliiuind,* nho otrerwi a splendid j»all at the tonil* of lier hushand, hut the pift was thrtnvn haek a«^»in hy unseen liands. ' Iler tf uncle the King wished to give her in second marriage to 1 valiant man ealliHl Simon of Senlis, who doi's not apj>ear in the Survey, but who in tlie story is already Earl of Northamj)ton. But Simon was lame, and Judith preferreeginning, but, as Simon is not to be found in DomeMlay, and ■« a " Syraon Comes " signs the grant of Bath to John de VtllalA in 1090 (see above, p. 398), it would seem that Simon came into CHILDKEN OF WALTHKOK. 605 Northampton, and of the neighbouring Priory of Saint chap. xi. Andrew,* and he died on his way back from a pilfjrima<»'e or crusade to Jerusalem.- Of the marriaf^e of Simon and ChiMren i^IatiKla came three children, a younger Simon, a younger ^,,,1 Matilda, and a younger Walt heof, who became Ablx)t of^^*'"^- Melrose.' But tlie daughter of the martyred Earl, after her first husband's death, consoled her widowhood with a loftier marriage. She became the wife of David of Scot- Second land, one of the sons of Malcolm and of the holy Margaret, MaiadTto and who himself became one of the most renowned princes I/"^^ of * Scotland, who ever wore the Scottish Crown. Through this marriage [King came the long connexion between the Earldom of Hunting- 1153.] don and the royal house of Scotland, and through it too Connexion the blood of AValtheof, and thereby of the long list of tj,^.s;cottiflh his forefathers, human and otherwise, passed into the veins Jf '"Jf j of the later Kings of England, and also, if genealogists dom of 1 • p r» 1 • 1 • Huuting- are to be trusted, into those 01 many 01 their subjects.^ don. The death of Waltheof is the turning-point in the Character history of William. As men generally look at the acts cution of of princes, it was the greatest crime of his life. In an ^^ abstract view of morality, to attack an unotfending nation in the assiTtion of an imaginary right, to lay waste whole provinces by fire and sword, to slay by the lingering death of cold and hunger thousands more than are slain in the short struggle of the battle-field, and to d(^ all England and married Waltheof'a daughttr in the very la.st years of William the Conqueror or in the Brat yeara of VV^illiam Kufus. Of \Valthe«)r« other daughterti, Judith married the younger llalph of TooHny, and the third, who i« namelesa, married Robert tlio Hon of Richard. Will. Gem. viii. 37. ' The date of 1084 is commonly given to this foundation (sec the first document in Mon. Angl. v. 190) ; but, as the Priory does not appear in Domert«lay, the date is more likely to be 1 108. ' Mon. Angl. v, 190. ' Chronifjue.s Anglo-NormandeM, ii. Ij6. * On the Hucceswion of the Karlili>m of Huntingdon, see Chrouiijuea Aiiglo- Normandes, ii. ia8 ; Dugdalo's Harunagc, 59. THK RBV0LT8 AGAINST WILLIAM. cmat 11. tiiit in ptirvnit of a pun'ly pcrBonal ambition, is a fi^ntcr KID a^inft humanity than to Hhcd tho blmxl of a gin^^K^ innocent man. And yet such are tlie inconsistenripg of our naturv that it nc*Hl8 a worse man to do tlu* losscr crime. An unjust war ond all that is involved in an unjust war, the harsh measures of repression which arc needed to keep a Crown once unjustly won, can all Im- more eMily cloakinl under fair pretences, their real cha- racter can Ik* more easily hidden from both doers and beholders, than can be done with the unri^^hteous slaughter of a sinfjle man. In this sense, the execution of Waltheof was a blacker deed than the invasion of En*;land and even woiiMB** than the devastation of Northunil)erland. Yet even now William's love of formal justice did not forsake him. Even now we may feel sure that he would have shnink from usinp^ the bowl or the dag-ger to get rid of the man whom he dreaded. AValthcof died in the sig-ht of the Sim, by the sword of the headsman, by the formal sentence of what was formally a competent court. William may even now have persuaded himself that he was but letting the law take its course, that he was but executing a righteous vengeance on a traitor righteously condemned. But so to persuade himself needed a yet stronger effort of the mighty power of self-delusion than to persuade Waitheof'i himself of the rifrhteousness of his former deeds. Never before had William sent an enemy to the scaffold. He had i»ardoncd men who had over and over again rebelled against him ; he had visited other traitors with outlawry, with lx)nds, with mutilation, never with death. And the man whom he chose for his one victim was innocent, or, even if in some measure guilty, he had redeemed his fault by a speedy penitence. Yet he had to die, while the life of his far more guilty comrade was spared. Never was legal execution more truly judicial murder ; never was innocent blood more ruthlessly shed to escape a possible ESTIMATE OF WALTIIEOF S EXECUTION. 607 political danger. Such a deed needed a worse man than was chap. xx. needed for any of William's earlier deeds. And William ^"^*"a^ •' clinnuo for now was a worse man than he had been when he set foot on the worne the Mora to attack a people who had never wrong-ed him. Crime, as ever, had punished itself by leadinfi;' to g-reater crime. And now the more open punishment followed. With the death of Waltheof the days of William's g'lory hjh i\\ buc- and pros{)erity came to an end. From that day the Con- tj^j^j^^J queror made no more conquests. His presence on the o*" ^^ '"^1- battle-field no longer carried with it the overthrow of his enemies; his presence beneath the walls of a Ijesieg'ed fortress no longer involved its speedy capture or surrender. William had to struggle against enemies at home and His domes- abroad ; and now he found foes in his own household. The blood of Waltheof was avenged by the bonds of Odo and by the parricidal thrust of the spear of Robert. Hie punishment of crime came in the best and purest relation of his life, when, after so many years of faithful partner- ship, strife at last arose between William and the wile of his lx>som. Eleven years of life and kingship were still 1076-1087. to be his, but they were to be years of toil and trouble, years of warfare without glory, years clouded over with every form of public and private sorrow.^ Closely connected in idea with the death of Waltheof, and most likely not far distant from it in date, was that other great crime of AVilliam which, in the eyes of the ' Tlio reflexion is that of Onleric, 544 A ; " Pro interfectionc CJualleW Coniitirt (Juillolinus Rex a niultin reprehensus eat, et inuItiM contra euiu inBurgentibuH, juste Dei judicio, multa adverna perpetutus e«t ; nee uniquam postea diuturnu pace potitiH cHt. Ipse ({iiideni contra omnen (quia ani- moflUH erat) viriliter restitit, sed proHporis evontibuM ad votuni, ut antoa, nori tripudiavit, nee crebrw victorianim titulia cxultavit. In trcdeciui anniM, quibu.s postinoduni vixit, annatorum acitMU df cainpo non fu^avit, nee oppidum ob.sidun.s bellicii virtuto cupit. Oninipotons arbiter omnia juato diaponit, nulluiiupie facinus inipuuitum relinquit, quia hie aut in futuro aeculo omnia punit." f «••» TIIK UKVOUTS AUAI.NST WILLIAM. our. IX. mm of hi< own ii^\ joinctl with tho Hlau^'htor of t)ii> Kn^liidi Karl io hrinjj down thr wnith of (Jml nj>on him WtOiMB's and upon hin hotim*. The love of the H{)ort« of tlic tiold, liMMbif. which niay \m} takon for granted in every man of tliat ■^ of whom the contrary is not expressly recorded, teemi to have reachiHl its height in William and liis KttUuvof toiit. We must rememher that in those days hunting jJ'JJJS had, in many part«} even of our own island, not yet '*""■ wholly lost it« ori^-inal character of defensive warfare with WOdbiMto the wild beaste. Scottish tniditions 8]>eak of the bear jJ^JJJJU^ as still lingering on in the eleventh century,^ and it is certain that, at all events in the less cultivated jiarts of Britain, the wolf still survived to prey on the flocks, and the wild boar to rava«^ the fields, of men who were striving to turn the wilderness into a fruitful field. '^ The stag and the roe, in northern Britain even the rein-deer,-^ were still untamed rangers of the wilderness, whose flesh was sought for as food, and whose haunts might be profit- ably cleared for the service of man. In such a state of things hunting might be a sport, as war might be a sport, but it was something more. It was always a ' I am Horry that I have nothing to quote on behalf of this statement bejond a vague Scottiiih traear is said to have been killed T. R. E. but no ori^nal authority is quoted. Is there any confusion with Otbeom the son of Siward and his ancestors — his forebears ? • The boar appean in the pa8«age of tlie Peterborough Chronicle which I ahall presently quote. That wolves remained in England long after, at all eventii in the shires bordering on Wales, is plain from a writ of Edward the Firnl in 1281 (Hynier, i. 591), in which Peter Corbet is commissioned to destroy wolven in the shires of Gloucester, Worcester, Hereford, Shropshire, and Stafford ; " Lupos cum hominibus, canibus, et ingeniis suis capiat et dectruat modiii omnibus quilms viderit expedire." This proves more by ft great d«al than the possibly poetical mention of wolves by Guy of Amiens (•ee vol. iii. p. 510) and by the Scandinavian poet who commemorates the •spkrits of Waltbeof (see above, p. 269). ■ Orkneyinga Saga, 384. " \>&t var si]^- Jarla naer hvert sumar at fara jttr a Kaianes oc >ar upp a merkr at veida rauddyri edr hrema." I have to thank Mr. Dawkins for this reference, and for other hints as to the Jwma of Britain. Tlie date of the story is about 1 159. William's hunting. 609 business ; it raif^ht often be a duty. The hunting- of /Elfred chap. xx. is recorded, not as a sport but as a serious employment, ^/'V^f'^'^ alon<> with the cares of war, "government, and study.' In the story of the tribute of wolves' heads imposed l>y anti t^i- |]adf^ar on the Welsh prinee Judwal, the original and hiwful o])je('t of hunting", the getting rid of noisome beasts, not their artificial preservation, is set forth with perfect clearness.- In the records of the great Survey we find constant mention of various services to be rendered in the royal huntings, huntings which were doubtless part of the King's pleasure, but which were also plainly looked upon as a serious business to be pursued for the public good.^ In the legislation of our later Kings we Beginning begin to find penalties for trespasses on the royal forests, i,^^,, but they are combined with an express acknowledgement Laws uf of the right of every man to slay the wild beasts of the field on his own ground."^ It was in William's age, and ' Atwer, M. H. B. 486 A. '* Interea taraen Rex, inter bella et pnesentis vit« frequf-ntia impedimenta, necnon Paganorum infestationed et quo- tiilianaa corporid iufirmitates, et regni gubernacula regere et omnem venandi artem agere ; aurifices et artiBces suos omiies, et falconarios et accipitrarios, canicularios quoque, docere ; et sdificia supra omnem aute- cessorum suorum consuetuflinem venemhiliora et pretiosiora nova sua machinatioiie facere ; et Saxonicoa libros recitare," and so on through the wliole string of iElfred's literary and pious employments. ' Will. Malm. ii. 155. "Qui etiam omnis generis feras sanguinis avidas ex regno exterminaro cogitaret, Judvalocjue Rcgi Walensium edictuin im- posuerit ut sibi (juotannis tributum treeontoruui luporum pcn.sitaret." The same distinction as to the motive of different forms of hunting is drawn out more at large in a remarkable letter of Peter of Blois, 56 (vol. i. p. 166, Giles), where hunting " gratiA voluptatis " is pronounced to bo "ex i\Mk inventione su& damnabilis." ' The stahilitio, so often Hpoken of in Domesday, is desrrilMMl by Kelham, 338 ; " One man went from every hou-ne to the stands or his station in the woon inHiotion of sudorin^- and iloath. It was thon too y*f|*:.^ thiit what hitherto, whftlicr sport or husinoHH, had Imth the H|xirt or tlie husincRS of every man, lurame the ex- clusive enjoyment of the Kinj; and of those whom he mi^ht allow to share it. It is plain that with William a new jx»rioaet hine man sceolde blendian ; he ffjrl>ead J>a heortAH Hwylce eac pa. baras ; swa HwiSe he lufode H^ be*h deor swilce he wsere heora fseder ; eac he seette be p^m haran ^set hi BKMten freo feran. HIh rice men hit maendon, and ^a eanne men hit bece- orodan, ac he w»8 Hwa sti^ Jraet he ne rohte heora eallra niS, ac hi moston Diid ealle )«• cynge» wille folgian, gif hi woldon libban, oS^e land habban, oOtSe eahta, o'X'Se wel his »ehta.*' The " mvcfl deor-fri^," a word which it iH hard to expre«8 in modern THE FOKK.^T LAWS. 611 makingr of the '* mickle deer-frith " which was the crown- chap. xx. in*^'- u rong" of all. It was not enou^li for William to seek the delights of slaughter in those spots where the uncleared land still harboured the beasts of the field. He William did not scruple to lay waste the land which was already th,. land brout'ht into man's ix)ssession, to unroot the dwellini^s ^^^ ^"* of man and the temples of God, in order to find a wider field for the gratification of his lust of bloodshed. Heavy was the guilt of the harrying of Northumberland ; but the harrying of Northumberland was at least done at the dictate of a cruel policy, and not in the mere wan- tonness of sport. Heavy as the guilt of that deed was, it was lighter than the guilt of the making of the New Forest. Each deed marks a new and a lower stag-e in the downward course. The exact date of this devastation of a large tract of ^^^•^ij^g ^* the New fertile country is not recorded, but it cannot have been Forest. very far from the time which we have now reached. It ' is not at all likely that William found leisure for such a business during the actual progress of the Conquest. On the other hand we not only find the Forest duly described in the Survey,' but we come across an incidental mention of it at an intermediate time which shows that the work had been fully done within a few years after the death of Waltheof.- Tlie favourite dwelling-place of William Wincheater when in England was W^inchestor. Under Eadwartl and caniuls. Harold the old West-Saxon capital had in some degree Englirth, doubtlesB means chiefly, but perhaps not exclusively, the New Vor(i»t. JJeor ia now gliding from its older and wider meaning of Thier, 07JP, /era, into its later special meaning of hart,-! ami hinds. The fatherly relationM between William and the high deer were perhaps measured by the relations between him and his eldest son. ' The New Forest entries take up pp. 51-51 b in Domesday. ' I refer to the deatli of William's son Richard, which seems (Ord. Vit. 573 (.') to have happened about 1081. Whenever it hapi>enetl, tho New I'orest must have then l)€en in full force. It r z eit THE BRYoLTH AGAINST WILLIAM. CBAf . &i. |(i«t its pneition.' WcntminKtcr liml Ixc^oine the chief homo of Kinpt, whilo Wiiu'hcHt4r wah liaiuK"*! over to thoir wiJown. The death of luul^yth, l»v which h»r rights over the city reverted to the Kin;;, wiih |)erliu|>s Dot without it« influence in making AVinchester a^niin more di«tinetly the royal dweUin^-phice. No other anioij^ the great cities of the King'doin wjw so \v«H suited to be the dwelling- place of a Kin^ who ruled in Normandy as well as in Kn^land. Hut in Hampshire, then no doubt the most civilized and lu'st cultivated j)art of the Kin^loni, it may well have been that either natural or artificial huntin^-Pfrounds were less extensive than in the wilder H« Uys regions in the North or on the Welsh border. To find room J[J^V^ therefore for William's sport, a fertile district, thirty miles atHMmp- in extent, was deliberately laid waste.-' In the days of •hire JCadward and the Kings before him it had been a flourish- ing land, full of the habitations of men, and thick set with churches where the worship of God was duly paid. ' At William's bidding men were driven from their homes; ' Se« vol. iii. p. 65. ' Will, Midm. iii. 275. "Nova Foresta . . . locus est quern WillelniUH pater, subrutiB eccleiiii«, desertix villia per triginta et eo ainplius milliaria, in saIius et lustra ferarum redegerat." Orel. Vit. 781 A. " Nunc Silva . . . ▼ide lector, cur Nova vocitata sit. Ab antiquis temporibuH ibi populosa ragio erat, et villiit huinanoi habitationi competentibuH abundabat. Copiosa Tero plebw Sutbamptunic pagum Bolerti cura obiiixe colebat ; unde australia pro\-iDciB Guentinxc urbi multi[)liciter campestri ubertate serviebat. Guillelmuii aut4.'tn priiiiuti, postquaut regnuin Albionis obtinuit, amator Deraorum. plus quain Ix. parochias ultro devantavit, ruricolag ad alia loca tnuumigrare compulit, et silvestrcH feraa pro horninibus, ut voluptatem veuuidi h&beret, ibidem constituit." See also M. Paris, i. 29, Madden. • Florence (iioo), after mentioning the death of William Rufus " in Novi ForcHt& quK linguA Anglorum Ytene nuncupatur," goes on to say, - Nee minim, ut populi rumor affirrnat, hanc proculdubio magnam Dei Tirtutem eue et vindictam. Antiquia enim temporibus, Eadwardi scilicet Kcgk et aliorum Anglise Regum prsedecessorum ejus, ea/lem regio incolia Dai culturibca et ecclesiii) nitebat uberrime, sed jussu Regis Willelmi Mttioru, hominibuB fugatis, domibuB semirutiu, ecclesiia destructis, terra fcramm tantum colebatur habitatione, et inde, ut creditur, causa erat infortoaii." Tin: NKW FOKE.ST. 613 their houses were pulled down, their ehurches were rooted chap. xx. up, and the fruitful land became a wildfrness. The his- Lan;juag« torians of both races raise their indi^-nant wail over the tempomry homes of man which were changed into the lairs of*"^"' wild beasts. Tlie ^reat Survey calmly gives us the „f j^o names of the Eng-lishmen who were driven forth from ' ^^^^7- their wasted homes, and show how a few of them were allowed to retain some small scraps of land beyond the limits of the sacred precincts of William's sport.' There, we are told, amid the desolation which he had wrought, the Conqueror would gladly have spent his life.- rejoicing in the slaughter of the lower animals during the short intervals of the slaughter of mankind. But we are The Sew told also that the scene of William's greatest crime was |,^,i,i ^^y ^^ the scene of the heaviest blows which were dealt upon 1**^.1'" '■ f:iinily. his house. A curse seemed to brood over the region from which man had been driven to make room for the wild beasts. The wilderness which William had made was fatal to his sons and to his sons' sons."^ His second son Richard, Death of a lad ot great promise, not yet girded with the belt ot Richard; knighthood, was cut off in the New Forest by a sudden and mysterious stroke, while the wearied stag was fleeing for its ' Tak»; one inHtance in Domejulay, 51 b ; " Filii (lodrici M;ilf habent de Kego Minte.stc-de. I'ater euruiii toiiuit de Kege E. Tunc 8u diffiidehut pro iii. hidis et diinidi&. MckIo non habent 61ii ejus nisi dimidiam hidani, (jua? geldavit pro una vir^cata. Alia terra est in fori'stA." Furetta, it must be remembered, Ih icildcrneiM rather than wood. So we fin«l more than once Huch entries as " Silvam ha)M;t Rex in forestA, ubi manebant vi. homines." ' Will. Malm. iii. 375. *' Ibi libcnter icvum exigcre, ibi plurimi.s omitto (juod diubus, certe mensibus, venatiitncs exercere gaudebat." ' William of Malmesbury goes on to say, " Ibi multa rcgio generi con- tigere infurtunia, qu;f habitatonim pncHcns audire volentibus sug^jerit memoria." He then mentioUH the death of Willium Kufus and the two Kichartls. Florence and Orderic speak to the same effect, and Orderic add.H (7K1 A), " MultiforniiH vi.sio criHhed — hv whose strtikc none knew— on the sito of one of the chuivhcs which his father had IcvcUctl witli the ground,* «-ill come iMjfore us at a later stag-e of our Htory. Our age shrinks, and is often wise in shrinking, from seeing the visible hand of God in the punishments which seem, even on eartbi to overtake the sinner. The age of William was ' Willuun of M&lmesbury (iii. 275) mys of him, " Ric&rduM magnanimo parenti iq>«m Inudin alobat, puer delicatufi, ut id aetatuls pusio, altum quid ■piraoi." Of hia death ho nays, " Tradunt cervos in NovJ^ ForestA tere- brantem tabidi neria nebulA morbum incurrisse." Orderic's account (573 C) ta more intelligible; '* Dutn prope Guentam in NovA Fore«t& venaretur, et quamdam feram caballo currente {x^rtinaciter insequeretur, ad HelUe ditellam valido corili ramo adniodum conxtrictus eat et letaliter lieitus." The Continuator of William t)f Jumibges (viii. 9) tells the story the same way, and adda, " Ferunt multi quod hi duo filii Willelmi Regis in ill& aihA judicio Dei pericrunt, quoniam niultas villas et ecclusias propter eamdem fcffOitiiii amplificandam in circuitu ipsius destruxerat." There ia a most remarkable story in Domesday, I4I, 14I h, of lands in Hertforrlshire restored by William to their ancient owner as an offering for Richard'i soul, but again, it would seem, brought wrongfully into depend- ence on a Norman lord ; " In Teuuinge tenet Aldene de Petro [" de Valongies," Bee above, p. 213] v. hidas ot dimidiam .... Hoc manerium tenuit Isdem Aldene Teignua R. E. et vendere potuit. Sed W. Rex dedit hoc manerium huic Aldene et miitri ejus pro atiinu't Iticardi filii sui, ut ipse dicit et per brevem suum oatendit. Modo dicit Petrus quod habet hoc meiieriam ex dono Regia." I do not understand the title of " Beomiae Dux " on Richard's tomb at Wmcbeater. ' Thin Richard was one of two aona whom Rol>ert had by a priest's daughter in the time of his wanderings. See the story in Orderic, 780 D. Of h'\M death Florence (iipn'HHtHl nation, but there i» not a word to hint tliat tliat opjjrcKHOil nati<»n wa« what it is now t)ie Hi^hion to call an o]>])n>sK(Hl nationality. We hear of the hanlnoHS of the Kiii^*, of the wn>npJoinjf« of the rich and of the sufferingii of the i)oor, but there is no reference to the one obvious cause of all these gne&, that the poor were the con(]Ucred nativ(>s of the soil, while the Kinj^ and the rich men were the stran^'re who hat! concjuered them. Kin^ William was "a very wise man and very rich, and more worshij>ful and strongvr than any of the King^ who had gone before him.''* But the obvious distinction which we should at once draw between King W^illiam and the Kin<»s who had gone before him is nowhere formally drawn. A man who drew his whole knowledge of William and William's acts from this memorable portrait would not learn from it, any more than he would learn from Domesday, that William was a foreign Conqueror.- It is i)lain that William and his acts had made the deepest impression on the man who had looked on him and had dwelled in his court. ^ Tliere was something about W^illiam that was awful and wonderful and unaccustomed ; but the man who describes him nowhere uses such language as a modem writer could not fail to use in speaking of a stranger who had won the Crown by the edge of the gword. We must not infer that the feeling of nation- ality was unknown to our forefathers of the eleventh eenturv'. Other passages of the Chronicles show plainly enough whar their feeling was towards Frenchmen, out- * Chron. Petrib. 1087. " Se cyng Willelm J>e we embe speca'S weea 8wi"5e win nuui, and Bwif^e rice, and wurCfulre and strengere J>onne aenig his fore- genggar waere." • The panage quoted in p. 406 would not imply more than that William luid won the Crown in battle, like Edward the Fourth or Henry the *^*nth. ' See vol. ii. p. 165. CHAHACTEK OF WILLIAMS CiOVKRNMKNT. 619 landish men, and the like.* But it is plain that the chap. xxi. feeling of nationality, though really felt, was in a manner latent, that it had not taken that definite and formal ahape whieh in truth in most countries it did not fully take till quite modern times. And we must again remember lu)w Foreign in everything Cnut had paved the way for William. The not^new. causes whieh made it possible for Cnut to reign in England as a national sovereign, and which made it impossible for William to do the like, were causes whieh the men of the eleventh century could not be cx])ected fully to understand. Three points in William's government stand out j)ro- Character- . 1 . 1 . ^ r ^ • i 11 /• i Wtic« of mmently in this wonderful picture, and all or them are William's fully borne out by the recorded acts of his life. He was ^^' ., ... ., •Ill ^^'^^^^ i""«j- etrict and merciless in preserving the peace ot the land, servatiunof He favoured the clergy and promoted ecclesiastical reform. ® P«*c«; He was guilty of great oppression, chiefly in the way of ex- t^e riergy ; tortion and fiscal demands, but oppression which was largely opi»re«sion cloked under the forms of law. On the first of these heads I f,,r„,s of have spoken several times already. It passed into a proverb '• that a man might go safely through William's Kingdom lif/a'mr with his bosom full of g-old.^ " No man durst slay other pr'M>''"ty man, had he never so mickle evil done to the other." ^ William. And if robbery and murder were thus vigorously put down, the third chief form of violence, outrages on female Punish- chastity, met with a speedy and fitting puni.shment.* ^^^rap". * all this there was much to William's real honour, much ' Se'.' the pasHAge qvii)tov he mid pleagode," The Chronicler clearly approvee of the mutilation. •so TIIK LATKK l>AY8 (>K WILLIAM. ' 111. which hindared him fn>in l>cin^ lonktHl on with unmixed ^ " »*• hatrtnl. The wconcl |>oint would nUo in tlioso tlnys jfo far to IniUmy the dnrker nith' of his nilc. Stark ns he won to those who withstood hin will, he wa.s mild to the ^ooivT |>aT hi wa-ll frrtlon." ' lb. The latter part in mont emphatic ; " So cyni^j . . . iie ruhlo na hu HwiKo Hynlice [>a ^erefan hit be^eatan uf oarmo mannon, no hu mani^e unlwja hi tlydon. Ac ntca man ticytior tfKre embe rihtf linjf, tint munn tlyde mare unlaya. Hi arordon unrihte tullad, and nianige oAre uiiriht hi dydan, ^e Mindon corfc^e to arcccciiiie." ^ Sve Apputidiz C. tit THB LATER DAYA OK WILLIAM. ottAT. sij. of its own hlootl wlio tako MTvice under the coiKiucrorH UiAn it nutlVm frrnn tho roiKjueronj thi'mwlvoH. Kn^lish rMvat •on'inp under \Villinm were not likely to be amon^^ the mo*t scni|)uIou8 or higli>niindeen violence, which it would have been altogether agninst AVilliam's j)rinciple and policy to encourage. wu.xn.u By these various means William wrung out of the un- retjue. ^^^PPX nation a revenue which made him richer and mightier than all his predecessors. One statement fixes his regular daily income at the incredible sum of more than a thousand and sixty pounds of silver.' The exaggeration is manifest ; it is not unlikely to be a proverbial exaggera- tion mistaken for a serious piece of arithmetic; but it shows the popular belief as to the boundless wealth which William gathered together. The vast tracts of land held by the Crow^n, which were let, as we have seen, to tenants who were made to pay the uttermost farthing, the tributes of the towns, and occasional taxes or bene- Hti out- volences, filled William's coffers, while his outgoings were aBuJL comparatively small. II is followers had been rewarded with grants of lands, and the feudal tenures of those lands, combined with the old English law of trinoda neces- titat, supplied him with an army almost without cost. Wfcv of Dependents of a lower class, old soldiers who had been ■D«Uerd«- less lucky than their comrades, Englishmen on whom utnAentt • Ord. Vit. 523 B. " Ipai Rtgi, ut fertur, mille et Bezagiota librse steri- l«iuui monetje, Holidique triginta et tre« oboli, ex justis redditibus Angliae par mgn\()* die« redduntur, exceptis muneribua regiis et reatuum redemp- tooibas, aliixque multiplicibus negotiis quse Regis aerarium quotidie ■daagcnt." The pbice of thiB Htatement in the narrative shows that it is P—Pi to Apply to William w well as to Henry. THE YEARLY ASSEMBLIES. 023 William liad looked with a more merciful eye than usual, chap. xxi. could be provided tor, without drawing* on the royal purse, by quartering" them on some monastery, or on some grantee who took their maintenance as part of his tenure.* William was doubtless the wealthiest prince of his time, and he kept up his roval state with fitting* dignity. The The reiju- 1 t 11- ' -111 f^ 1- I T larGein<5t« national Assemblies prescribeil by hnglisii Law were care- kept up by fully held at the aceustoraed places and seasons, and ' ^^^* doubtless with more than the accustomed splendour. " He was very worshipful ; thrice he bare his kingly helm each year, so oft as he was in England. At Easter he bare it at Winchester, at Pentecost at Westminster, at »' ^^i"- chestcT, ^Midwinter at Gloucester; and then were with him all Wc-.stmiu- the rich men over all England, Archbishops and suHragan ^toucJlter Bishops and Abbots and Earls and Thegns and Knights." - The bodv thus gathered toefether kept their old constitu- Name of tional name of the Witan,-* and pieces of their legislation gi,efl on. are preserved to us both in the records of the Chronicles and in the extant text of the documents themselves. Most of these statutes evidently belong to these later and more settled years of William's reign. '^The ordinance for taking Instances the Great Survey, and that other ordinance which decreed liHm'slegis- that every man in the land should be the man of the King, ''*''*'"" both appear in the national Annals.^ Others of William's * See the very carious story in Hist. Ah. ii. 6 of one Hermer, a knight of the Abbey (see al)ove, p. 47S), who wa.H takt-n by pinitPH and <«eemingly lost his hands. He hrui no landH, and he asked the King fi»r a nu'uns of maintenance ; *' C'ui Rex compatienH abbati mandavit debere »e hujusnu^li honiini tantuni tfmi- aliiiuorxurn providcre, qua quanidiu vixfrit j»o»wit sus- tentari." The Ablxit granted hiui an estjite which he htdd for the rest of hiii days. See also another story in Donieriday, 3186. A King's Reeve named Osgeat, doubtlc.««H an P^ngli.shnmn, held lands in IWdfonlshirf which " tenuit i. KocheniannuH T. R. E., (jucni Rex W. cum terra hac pra-dicto prtefect^^coramendavit, ut ({uamdiu viveret victum et vestitum ui praberet." ' Chron. Petrib. 1087. " Eiic he wa;s swyffc wurffful; hriwa he biir hio cynehelm fiilce geare, swa «)ft Hwa he wh'h on Englelande," (^c. See above, P- 339 ' See Chron. Petrib. 1085. 1086. ♦ lb THI LATBR DAYM OP WILLIAM. cMAt. III. ordiiumcrfl iTf'n*!^^*'^^ ^^^*^ rclutionH iK'twfon tlu> I'rcnch |j2J**/**** •a*! Englii»h inhuhitanU of the country. T\\v t\v{» rnrea appear on tonns of legal equality, but, a^ in the Si'ltW- mrat of the Teutonic tribes within the llomnn Kmpire, J** oach race waa, for some purjwses, allowed to ntain the Law. use of ita own I^aw. Frenchmen who had settled in B»l— Jtra Puglnn,] \j^ Kinp luidward's days, and wlio had Ix'come oamniaM naturaliz4Hl English suhjects, were counted as Enj^libh- men.' Other Frenchmen, William's own followers or those who had corae into the land during his reign, were allowed to keep some of their national customs with regard to the trial of judicial causes. In cases of appeal, at all events where there was no convincing evidence, the Law of each nation allowtni a refertnce to the direct judgement of God. RBglMh But in England this reference took the form of the ordeal '-r^n) of water or of hot iron,^ while in Normandy it took the NonnMi form of wager of" battle. William recognized both modes JJJI^pJ*^^' of trial. When a man of either race was appealed by b^Ue. 3 jjj^j^ ^1* jjjg Q^.jj Yuce, they no doubt followed their own R4sgTiU- Law. But special provisions are made for the case of a tioofl of , . ^^ptmlM nian of either race appealing a man of the other race. If pj^^gjj^j^a Frenchman appealed an Englishman, the Englishman ^'V**^ had the choice of either mode of trial. In the case of an Englishman appealing a Frenchman and declining both ordeal and battle, the Frenchman might purge himself by oath.^ Two other pieces of William's legislation are * W. StuhliA, Select Charters, 80. " OmniH Francigena qui tempore Ecfis Edwanii propinqui mei fuit in Anglia particeps consuetudinum Anglonim, quod ipsi dicunt onhlote et anscote, persolvatur secundum legem Anglorum. Hoc decretum aancitum eHt in civitate Claudia." As no Gloucester Gem6t wa« held in the earlier times of William, this statute most belong to the time which we have now reached. * See for instance the minute directions about the ordeal in the Laws of ^tbeUtan, ii. 23 (Thorpe, i. 210 ; Schmid, 144), and the legend of Emma, vol. ii. p. 568. * See the sUtute in W. Stubbs, Select Charters, 81. "Decretum «i ut, n Francii^ena appellaverit Anglum de perjurio aut murdro, furto, RELATIONS OF EN'OLISH AND FKENCH. 625 worthy of still mure sjH'ciiil notice. The hateful trade in chju*. xxi. human flesh, in its cruellest form of selling: men into ^^ ^ . foreiiJ^n lands, the sin ai^ainst which Saint Wulfstan hI»vc trade, preacheil to the buro^hers of Bristol,^ is forbidden by William, as it had been forbidden by earlier Kin«^. Con- fiscation of lands and j^oods is the punishment denounced against him who shall sell a man out of the land.-' In this enactment William acted as a just and merciful Kinj^, and he no doubt believed that he was acting* as a just and merciful King- in the enactment which follows it. Following" out his own general practice throughout life, The pun- William altogether forbade the j)unishment of death, ji^ath for- No man was to be hanfjed or otherwise put to death for ^»'l*^.^".>"t *=> ' mutilation any crime whatever. But instead of death William or- ordered. dained punishments which, according to modern notions, were worse than death. The man whose crimes deserved death, but whose life William's mercy spared, was doomed to the horrible penalties of l)linding — blinding in its most frightful form — and of fouler mutilation still. "^ Of the man himself our one personal i)ortrait clearly Wiliiam'ji belongs to his later years. William's height was tall, appear- but not excessive; he was neither a giant like Harold '^"*^' Hardrada nor a small man like Eadgar and (^nut. His countenance was stern ; the fore part of his head was homicidio, ran, (juoil Angli dicunt apert'im nipinam tjuiu nejjari non potest, AngluH »e defendat per ollaverit et pn>baro noluerit judicio aut duello, vulo tainen Franci^'enani purgare He sacramento non fracto." ' See above, p. 385. ' StubbB, Select Charters, 85. " Ego prohibeo ut nuUus vcndat hominem extra patrium Hiiper pirnain fonHfat-turain nifani." ' lb. *' liitonlico etiuiit ne (juis occidatur aut nu«|ienilfttur pro nliqu4 culpa, Hfd rruaiitur oculi et tcsticuli abscindantur. Et hoc prn'ceptum non Hit violatUMi nuprr forisfactunini nieain plfnani." Tliin wa-s tlio niOMt brutal way of tearing; out tho cytH, tliat intUiI^'iMl in by Kobt-rt of Belcmiie, and to which Henrj- the Second at leaat confr«H«d a tendency (nee !Ienry of Huntingdon's story in .Vnglia Sacra, it. 698, aiul William Fitz-Stcpheii, (files, i. 371); for other and milder ways, .hit Duoange in Abucinure. vol.. IV. S 8 tt6 THE LATEK DAYrt OP WILMAM. OBAf. Ill l»aM ; yrhcll»« r staiulin^ or nittinj* !»is look was wnrHliipful antl kindly. Suoh Uv npix'nrH in the Tu|K'stry; hihIi lit* it cl«»»tTiUxl hv onr who may liavo l(X)k('u- Kiiif^ with chiKlish woinh-r. Hut in liis lattor dayn hiH majcutic fi^-un* was clij-ti^-nrinl by exces»ivc corpulence J Still, unwit'hly a*< he ]>e<»anie, he never lost the j>ower of motion like Henry the Kiphth ; lie was ahlc to mount teksdoor a horse to the end of his days. At the times of the f^^f^g^ three gTeai yearly A8seml)lieH William a]>jM'aretl in all his plor)\ All the preat nun of his realm were gathered together, not only for counsel on tin* allairs of the King*- dom, but to join in their sovereign's royal feasts, when the ambaaetadors of forei«^ lands came to see his magni- ficence, and when AVilliam showed himself affable and M«« courteous and bountiful to all.- Yet perhaps it is not without sip^nificancc that the historian who gives us this splendid jiicture goes on immediately to speak of his avarice and extortions in words hardly differing from those of the native Chronicler.^ So too it is immiidiately aft4*r describing William's care in regularly summoning the constitutional Assemblies of the Kingdom that the native Chronicler himself goes on to tell us " how stark the King was, and how no man durst do anything against bis will ; how he had Earls in bonds that did against * WilL MaIiii. iii. 279. "Jiistaj fiiit Btaturae, immensae corpulentiae, fade feri, fronte caijiUi« nuda, roborin ingentis in lacertis . . . magnae dignitAtu aedeos ei stans, quamquam oheHitos ventria nliniH protensa corpus regium deformaret." So he appeai-H in Orderic (656 A) as " pinguissiinuH Rex Guillelmufi." ' lb. " Omnes eo cujuscumque professionis magnates regiuin edictuni aooenriebat, ut exU-ranim gentium legati speciem multitudinia apparatuui- qne delicianim mirarentur. Nee ullo tempore comior aut indulgenfli facilior erat, ut qui advenerunt largitatem ejus cum divitiis conquadrare obique gentium jactitarent." lb. 280. " Sola est de qua nonnihil culpetur pecuniae aggestio, quam nndecumque captatis occasionibua, honestas mode et regia dignitate non inferiores posset dicere, congregabat." He goes on to make some curious excQuefl for William's extortions. WILLIAMS PKKSUN AND HABITS. 627 his will, how Bishops he set of tlu'ir Hishopricks and chap, xxi. Abbots of their Ablx'ys, how he had Tlu'<,^ns in prison, and how at last he spared not his own brother." ^ In this last picture some of the best and some of the Strengtli worst acts of William's rei«^n are mingled tot^ether ; but tj^^jj j^.^. all join to set before us the i)icture of a t^jvernment far [**''""" °^ ** I o Jus govern- stronger, far more arbitrary, than anythin*^ that Eng'land mcut. had ever seen before. William strictly followed consti- tutional forms, Ixjcause he could atlbrd to do so, and yet could none the less wield a i>ower which in his hands amounted to a practical despotism. Kinj^ (jf the Eni^lish according" to the Law of England, he extended the royal power in its greatest fulness over all his subjects of either race; personal lord of every man in his Kingdom, feudal Buperior of his tenants-in-ehief, military commander alike of his feudal followers, of his hired soldiers, and of the old constitutional force of the Kingdom — in one or other of these various characters William contrived to w ield a power such as no other prince in Europe wielded, save only tlu' Caliph at Cordova and the Ctesar at l^yzantium. And, by a strange turning about of events, one of William's brother despots Ixjcame in some sort his rival. Among English- the Englishmen who at various tmies during William's aenice at reiern sought fresh homes in forei«^n lands, not a few made ^'^'"'*^n- their way to the New Rome, and there, in the service of the Eastern Emjjcrors, they not uncommonly had the satisfaction of meeting the kinsmen of their coniiuerors in oj)cn 1>attle. The movement towards the East probably began in the very first days of William's reign. No career was more attractive to a banished Englishman, especially to a native * In the Peterborough Clironiclo (1087) the (leuoriittion of the yearly AwemblieM in at once followed by the wohIh, " Swilce he wr« eac uwy^'o Btearc man and ra>6u swa >Rt man ne dontc nan |>ing ongcan hU willan don," Ac. S 8 2 r«.i f TIIR I.ATKR HAYS Of WILLIAM. . of tWSouHlinjivtiin pur!* of Knjflaiul. thnn tin' nirwr which WM o6Vim! bv tluit Wnranjfinn pmnl to winch tht» oxi)loi(« of lUmM Iliinlnip««.» Hut the ( hirf mij^mtion in tbi« difwtion plainly took \AacQ in th«» Intor days of William, when the rpvohition» of I'^iwt'Crn Knropo opt'n<«r]iaps to his ex])hjits, lias been far more widely spread throu«^h Western Kiirope than that of most of the Hyzantine Caesars. And he was the qiaeial (oc of the Normans. Alexios Komnenos hud barely been crowned in Saint Sophia^ when the Eastern Empire waa invaded hy the Normans of Apulia under the com- mand of their famous Duke Robert Wiscard, who by wntcri in distant lands has been strangely mistaken for an En|>-lish King*.^ But on the shores of Epeiros, no leaf than on the short's of Sussex, the Norman had to meet Englishmen in battle before he could lay any claim ^■••■'^ to the name of Conqueror. The danger of the Empire, and the prospect of fighting under its banners against Norman enemies, had clearly drawn a new reinforcement of English warriors to the side of Alexios.'' Robert • .S« »o|. ii. pp. 75 et Jieqq, » Hm his daughter Anna, Alex. iii. i ; Finlay, Byz. Emp. ii. 63. • Th« ttnt inYMion of RoU-rt Wiscard m described in the third and fawtb book* of Anna, in the fourth book of William of Apulia in Mura- tort, Tol. v.. aad in the third »>ook of Geoffrey Malateira in the same Toiaae. 8m aIm Willijun of MalmcHbury, iii. 262 ; Gibbon, c. Ivi. (x. a;*. Milaun) ; FinUy, ii. 88. It iH the Polish hJHtorian DlugoHS (i. 45) wW, oadOT the year 1056. Hpeaks of Henry the Fourth an "a Roberto Am^ur tUgt Romi pabus." •T^ Mwu to me quit* plain from the account of Orderic (508 A), taoiVk be hM placed it quite out of chronological order, at the very begin- THE ENGLISH WARANOIANS. 629 crossed the Hadriiitic and hesiegtHl Dyrrhachion, the city chap. xxi. whose later name had wiped out tlie memory of the more jJ^wj^h ancient Epidamnos.^ Alexios came to its relief at the th« Em- pire* ana head of one of those guthering^ of men of all races, besie^'en toni^ues, and creeds, which were wont in those days to ^jjion^ fi«4-ht side by side around the eaffles of the Eastern Rome. June.ioSi. \Vith Greeks disf^uised under the name of Romans and comes to Slaves distjuised under the name of Macedonians,"^ came '^® ^*^*'t^ '^ ' of Uyrrha- Mahometan Turks fighting- in Europe for the throne chion. , October, which they threatened in Asia,* Paulician heretics whom 1081.. persecution had changed from a religious sect into His motley a warlike tribe/ and Franks, men of Latin speech and faith, fighting against men of their own tongue in the cause of the rival Church and Empire.^ And ning of William's reign. The English exiles " militiaj Alexii Imperatoris Ckinstantinopolitani sese audacter obtulerunt, .... contra quera Rod- bertu.s Wi.scardus Aj)ulieaking peoplo are in Anna's style ^pdyyot, KiKroi, Aarivoi, just as in Ord»;ric and William of Ajiulia the By/Jintines are (ini'ci, .\chivi, Danai^ PeliiHgi, Tliraces. anything. When we read such a sentenoe as iiiojKoy ol Aarrvoj to 'PoufmiKoy arpArivfia, wo seem carried back to the days t>f the D«M'ii or of the Tarquiiis. Constantinc Humbertoy)OMZo« (Humborti(/f« or Humbert/»j/) is said THE LXTlAi i'AYS <»K WILLIAM. «p^ 111 ABMMiir tliw tUmnirs A«eml)lAg« were mon of whom we ^ rmJ with a thrill of minfflwl joy niul mrTow tlmt Oiey ^'.!-.l «,rf clwfiM>d the bravcut and most faithful of all who ^**'* w«rv ;,iithcmi umh-r the Unncre of Alienist us. > Hyzan- tinr mzid Norman accounta a^ree in setting' before us the Wanm^pana. tho Kn^hnh, the Barbarians of the Isle of Thoal^, as the force in which, amon^ all their varied TWIr MM. banda, the Eaatom Cnvars put their firmest trust.* Beneath th«» i»-alU of Dyrrhnchion, as on the heio^ht of Senlac, they bor* tho two-handed Danish axe, and at Dyrrhachion, no l«M than on Senlac, the Norman writers themselves Ix'ar witoeaa to the terrible effect with which the Danish axe g^Hl, «f waf wielded.^ The battle was lost ; the Cicsar of the East ^'^*^ fled before the Norman invader,* as his momentary ally, Oiaibvit. ^ CiBsar of the West, was to do before many years had Drfwti of I***^ away.* But England at least lost no honour on that fatal day. For a while the Normans gave way before the Waran^n charge. When a sudden flank attack threw the to hAW boen a diMxmUnteil nephew of Robert Wiscard. See Finlay, u.7a. SouMwhat later, about 1087, we find Flemish auxiliaries fighting for Ahtfaw S«e Anna, vii. 7. ' QmuL 31aJ. ilL 27 (Muratori, v. 584). " Waringi, in quibu.s Iniperatori ■Miim* apas rictons fuerat." • We a|ipcar in the actual description of the battle (Anna, iv. 6) as W w^j daii(a»rri$ >f. our oldest character in Prokopios, Bell. Goth, iv, 20] 0ifdmftt, oi wt\tKwf>6poi. Ebewiiere (ii. 9) we are ol «« ttjs QovKrji Bapayym, •i vflAMvfopoi 0af$afKH. The commander of this contingent was Nabitfis (viL 3, 4 4f X**" BafMi77t(u Na/iirerunt." Cf. vf)l. iii. p. 474. • Anna dawribea her father's flight in iv. 7. Even in flight however he ^•l ioo** pro iigien of valour. 8« Tol. L p. 171. On the dealings of Alexios with the /i^f 'Akafiavias ^^^X9*»9^ Aiioa, iii. 10; v. 3. BATTLE OF DVRKHACHION. 631 victorious and weaned Eng-lisli into confusion, the main chap. xxi. body of the axemen died, like Kincf Harold's Ilousecarls, yal""''and •^ ' o Hlaught<:r around their standard.^ The remnant retreated and made of the 1- 1 11 '11 • inci' English. a stand in and around the nei<^hbounng church of Samt Michael ; but the beloved Norman means of destruction was broug-ht ag"ainst them, and they died, as the Normans were said to have died at York,- crushed and scorched amid the ruins of the burning* temple.-^ For others who AJexios had not joined in the march to Dyrrhachion, or who Kibdtos entered the service after the battle, Alexios bei^an to ^"^ ^Jl®, ' o Euglish. build on the other side of the Propontis the city of Kibotos, their ark of refuge, whose name on French- speaking lips wa^ degraded into Chevetot.^ But as the They be- Normans, Robert himself and his son Bohemund, con- in'perial* tinueil to harass the Empire, Alexios recalled the Eng-lish ^^'b- guard. to the Imperial city, and made them the special guards of his person and palace.'' They served in later stages of the war. Kastoria, besieged by Bohemund, was, after Bohemund a gallant defence, surrendered to him by three huncbred gtoria. 1083. * Anna, iv. 6. Itnl St ol ■n(\(KVaiyoVTO. vinTd yovv T. 369. ' Anna, iv. 6. ol Aarivoi nvp Kar' aiiTujv ati'T«$, avv t<^ Ttfiivd irdyrat KaTtKavaav. The account in Geoffrey Malatcrra (iii. 37) is not quite the same; "Alii quantum capacita-s pcrmittcbat subintrabant, alii UintA multitudine tccta Hupencaudunt ut pondcrc ipsa tecta disboluta con- Hubiniantur, illos (^ui Hubintnivcrunt opprimentes, concluMi pjiriter suffo- carentur. " ' Uri. Vit. 50S 1>. '• Augu.sturt Alcxiu.s urbem ipuc Chtntot dicitur Anglia ultra Jiy/.antium ctepit conden." '■" lb. " Nimium infeHtantiini.s Nonnanni^ eott ad urbem regiam rcduxit, et uiadem principolu palatiiun cum rcgalibus thuttuuriM tradidit." iW Tlir I.VTKH I>AY8 OP WILLIAM. aSL WarmngMM nho >n»«"l«**i >* J* »"^^ ^® ^^"^ Imnlly (li»cm tb«l B^Uh wirrior* wrrv iil>m«nt wlion Bolu'nuind hini- wgU wan driven to rctrwit beyond tlio Had rial ir,'*' and •f wIm« Hrwin, the name Hrian of Hritanny who lial'>ai"''» ^ , . . hold un was never seriously threatened. These later years of his Er^laiKl life were years of comparative defeat and dis<>race ; but weakened, the ill successes of William were all undergone in other lands. The sinijle Northumbrian outbreak hardly amounted to a rebellion, and a Scottish inroad, fearful as the scourge must have been to those who had already sudered so much, in noway endangered the safety of William's throne. § 2. Wdlianis later Conlinenlal Wars. 1076 — 1086. The years immediately following the suppression of the Willianrs revolt at Ely were years in which William was con- between stantly passing to and fro between his insular and his England continental dominions. He was ever and anon called back Nonnandy. to England by some urgent political need, but at this time he made Normandy his chief dwelling-place, and Queen Matilda seems not to have left the country at all.^ But from this point the domestic events, and especially the domestic quarrels, in William^s family begin to form an important part of our narrative. Of William's many sons No grants and daughters not one obtained any grants of land in wiliuun Enirhind.2 Yet he made at least one grant to reward *^?.!"'' o o children. tinoplc. Compare the mention of Englwh as the tongue of Rolf Ganger. See vol. i. p. 191. ' On WilHam'H movemrnts in the yr.irs 1073-1076, .see above, pp. 513, 543, 568. There in no mention of Matilda aecomp.vnying him on any of hin viflitH to England. '* Thi.H remark i.s made by Sir II. Kllis, i. 331. It in also implied in Robert "h diHcourse with \\\a father in Orderic. lliis is a remarkable con- tnwit to the accumulation of lands in the family of Godwino. The difference in that between a King and an K.irl. ^$i THE LATBK DAYS l»K WILLI A.M. tu. Hrrkv done to one of hin dnii^htorH,* and his Hon William c^umMitcnKtioally cnoiiph, to have fotmd :i j)os- for him»elf l»y an act of wwriloj^ious Kp>liation.''' \\^!luun terniin^Iy fcartnl that his sons mi^^ht lu'comt^ hin nrmU. He thorrforo pivo tht-m no |)()lititttl apjjanaf^^cH, BOl evco any Undcd estates. He wished to ktvp tlicin in the state of dependent and, l)ccau8e do|u>i)d(M)t, dutiful childrvn. Tliry had no claim upon him for rewards; be had no ntn-d of them as instruments; he therefore fTitematirallv forhore to bestow on them any share of the wealth and |>ower and official dignity which he bestowed on his friends and his brothers. The first of the family of whom we now hear we hear of simply as vanishing from political and domestic life. The vow which William made at the consecration of his wife's charch, before he set forth on his great expedition,^ was now fulfdletl. In the year of the rebellion of the Earls William again kept the Easter Feast at Fecamp, and now his eldest daughter Cecily made her vows and received the habit of religion at the hands of her distant kinsman Archbishop John.* She passed her life in her mother's monaster}', a pattern of virtue and learning, and of sub- mifttion to the rule of her order. On the death of the first Abbess, Matilda, whose rule over the sisterhood was • Damt»dmy, 49. " GoiHfriilus Camerarius filiae RegiH . . . tenet de Rege |"W» •emtio quod fecit Mnthildi ejus filiae." • lb. 77, of UniU in Dorwet, " W. filius Regis tulit ab ecclesia sine coowasa Ep^aoopi et nionachorum," that ia the Bishop of Salisbury and Um monks of Sbcrbome. • 8m rul m. pp. 383. 395. • Ord. VH. 548 B. *• Anno ab Incamatione Domini mIxxv. indictione dU. GtiilJelmtu Rex Fiscanni sanctum Pascha celebravit, C^ieciliainque fUam mam permanum Johannis Archie7>i«copi Deo conHecrandam obtulit." In WUL G«m. vii. a6 we read, " Ibi [at Caen] Caecilia virgo filia ejus Deo ooonomta eit et in nen-itio Dei diu commorata est." TIhh jtrobably refers to th» otTHDony in 1066 ; it seems impossible to set aside so distinct a ' M that of OrHeric. SIEGE OF DOL. G35 prolong-ed tur turty-soveii years, Cecily succeedetl to her chap. xxi. office, and held it with honour till her own death Iburteen a!?^ years later.' 1113-1127. The next dau<,''hter of William of whom we hear was Constance, wife of destined to a widely different fate from that of her eldest Alim ..f sister. While Cecily studied and prayed, serveil and ruled, j^Jij.,)[hej' in her monastery, Constance earned a fame no less pure by ^^7^} . . * inarriud livings an useful and honourable life in the rank in which 1086, slie was born. Her first mention connects itself with the ' ^ ^ * very be«^inning' of William's later and darker days. After William the beheading' of Waltheof William nijriun crossed the sea d^K^ to Normandy, and we presently hear of him as besieg-iui^ '°""" the Breton city of Dol.- He had been seen under its walls in earlier times ; but then he had come as a deliverer, and Harold had come as his fellow-soldier. The warfare of William alone was less lucky than the warfare of William and Harold tog'ether. At the earlier time he came success- fully to relieve Dol when besieged by the Breton Count. It was now the Breton Count whose forces came success- fully to relieve Dol when besieg-ed by William. The motives of William for attacking- the city which Hia mo- now was visited by its almost only gleam of good luck are not very clear. Our chief informant makes it a simple aggression on the part of William. He wished to extend his power, and to win back the rights over Britanny which had belonged to the Dukes of the Normans who had reigned before him.'* It is possible that some of the rights which » Ord. Vit. 548 C. 8eo also Will. Gem. viii. 34; Will. ^falm. iii. 376. " Ceecilia, Caone c.i.Mtel let I)(»l." Ordoric (544 H) i.n fuller. ' Ord. Vit, 544 ]\. " (Juilji'lmurt R«!X, cupiens tines muos dilatare, sibique Britones.ut Hihi ohriecundarout, sicut olim Rolloni et Willermo aliisque Duci- bus Nonnannicis servierant, volens suhjugare, cum ingenti exercitu Dolense 6^ THE LATKR l».\YS OV WILLIAM. CSAF lit Willuun ikui^'h! to rrj^iin wore of an tvcloHiastical kind. Il ii certain that alMuit thin timo ho nvoivinl i\ \viU?r IWnii Pope Cfivgon-, char^Hnj; Inm to do nothing' on hchalf ^^^ of Juhcl, BUhop of Dol, who had Imvii (hj)OHiHl hy his authority. Another Bishop, Ivo, haoml wea]>ons. A still more obvious motive is trT?*^*^Wigge>te*l. if we could bclievi' the statement of one of our WmLrU own writers that Dol was at this time a possession or IM. fthelter of the fuj^itivc Earl Ralph.* Nothing would be more natural than a campai^^n undertaken in the Impr of seizing the fuj^itive, or at least of chastising" the city and the land where he had taken refuge. However this may be, William besiep'd Dol with a great host, and pitcheil his camp, full of all the splendours of his wealth, ki« tltfmu. beneath the walls of tlie city. The defenders of Dol trembled at his threats, and at the oath which he swore not to go away unless as a conqueror. ' But the conscience of William had now, like the consciences of Harold and Waltheof, to l>car the burthen of an unfulfilled oath, William went away from Dol, and he did not go away oppiduin obaedit.** William of M:ilineK))ury (iii. 258) confeHses his ignor- Mioe of the CMue; ^'Dum nwcio qu& simultate irritatus manum illuc mOttaram dazkwt." • 8— Qragw/'i Letter of September 27, 1076 (Jaffe, Mon. Greg. 541). Jobal hftd been d^poaed foritimony, marriage, and portioning bin daughters, like Kaldhun (nee vol. i. p. 358), with epiKCopal lands. William is exhorted •■ D« . . . tain toelecto bomini . . . ulterius auxiliura praebea-s neve scelerum ejw ie pMlidpem factJM ;" but wu are not told exactly what he had done. ■ 8m toL i. pp. 220, 230. ' Flor. Wig. 1075. " ''""^ '»®c miare transit© Rex in minorem Brytan- ■isB HMm roovit expeditionem, et raddlam Itcubdfi Comitis, quod Dol MMibwtar, obwdtt.*' But I know of nothing elsewhere to connect Dol wftb Ralph. Ord, Vii. 544 B. ** Nee ue inde diBoeflsurmn, nisi munitionera obtineret, ram janmenio aiwcniit.*' WILLIAMS FLIGHT FKoM DOL. G37 as a conqueror. Tt was there indeed that he met his first chap. xxi. defeat. Ahin Ferinint, son of the reig'niiif'' Count Howel,* Dol re- lieved by came to the relief of the besie^'d city, and with his forces Alaii anJ were joined the forces of the common overlord of William pj/^fp and Alan. King" Philip of France, now the firm ally of Robert of Flanders,- came to wag^e war on the island King" who, on Gaulish g^round, was still his man. The Bretons stood their ground manfully till the royal forces came.'' William was then driven to retreat, if not to William'i flig-ht, by the united forces of King* and Count. He left '^ behind him men and horses and countless treasures, tents with rich furniture, vessels, arms, spoils of all kinds, to the value, men said, of fifteen thousand pounds.^ At Crowland it was doubtless whispered with bated breath that the veng-eance for the blood of Waltheof had beg-un. But with William a new position had only the effect of enabling' him to show his genius on a new field. His first defeat g-ave him his first opportunity of improving* a defeat. Attacked on so many sides, it was his policy to disarm his Peace enemies, and he began by disarming the enemy who was \viui^^" least powerful and most isolated. Alan was won over by ^"^ , ' , , -^ HoweL the same arts which had been successfully practised on F^adwine. Peace was made ; by one of its terms the hand Constance of William's daughter Constance was promised to the son {^J^ian of the Breton Count ; but the actual marriage was not *°76' * Onleric (544 P.) dt'scrilu's the relief l)n>uj,'ht by Alan, calling liiin "Conies Britannia?," which he was not till 1083. See Appendix RK. ' See above, p. 538. ' Chron. Witr. 1077. IVtrib. io;6. " |^a Pryttius hine heoldon Jwvt se cyng conKif Francland " [" FVancrice," Wig.]. So Florence, 1075. Orderic and William of Malniesbury (iii. 258) do not bring Philip to Dol. * Chron. Wij^. 1077, I'l-'trib. 1076. "And Willelm })anon for, and |»aT fi>rlea« a^ifSer ge men ge hondont on liim wan a pnme vhich eiartly iuitcd \Villi«n)'8 poliry ; I'ut it wan u ipune which it n-aa not uSe for William InniKi-lf to carrj' too fur. w^ In the ooureo of the next year William also made ponce with the Kinp of the French ; hut the Enf,''li8lj Chronicler significantly remnrks that the ]>eaee held hut a littlr wliile.^ For altout tills time the fjood faith of Philij) was rx])nsed to a t«ni»tation wliirh seems to have been too j)OW('rful to U' \%ith»t4X>d. William was now heg'innin<> to find his foes Ckmrwn^ in hiu own household. The curse of his later years was K^<^ the diBobedience and open rebellion of his eldest son Robert. Tlie younfj- man liad some showy qualities which won him, if not friends, at least j)artizans. He was a daring soldier, a skilful archer, ojjcn of hand, bold and free of apeech. But the personal portrait of him is not attrac- tiYc. Short and fat, witli a luavy face, the eldest-born of the Conqueror was known by the nick-names of Gamharon and Curt-hote} Of the higher qualities of his father, of his f^enius for war and government, he had not a trace. In his first quarrel with his father Robert was not with- out a plausible grievance. At some time before the inva- sion of England, and again during an attack of sickness at some later time, William had declared Kobert his successor iM," in the Norman Duchy, and had made his chief vassals do ' Se« below, p. 650, and Appendix KR. • Cbroo. Pelrib. 1077. " Her on )n8am geare wurdon seehte Franca cyng and Willelm Knglalandea cyng, uc hit htold Utle huiUy ' Orti. Vit. 545 C. " Krat loquax et prodigus, audax et in armiB probiH- Minaa, fortls oortuiique sagittariuB, voce clarli et liberii, lingulL diftert^, facie ob«»4, oorpore pingui brtvique BtaturS, unde vulgo Gamharon cognominatuH «* et BreritKKTea." TJiii* laiit name was given him by his father (664 C). (Jmrnbartm b expUioed (Roquefort, GloHRaire de la Langue Romane), " Junbe ooart«, •obriquet doDn(^ a Robert, Due de Normandie, parce qu'il •Toll de gromes jambea sanx molletB. et toutes rondes." CHARACTER OF RoBKHT. 639 homage and swoar fealty to him. One or other of those two chap. xxr. settlements had been further confirmed by the Kin^ of the French as Overlord.* In lioth the settlements of Maine Maine also it was rather to Ilobert than to William himself that Mettled on the County was made over. At the conclusion of the last ^^'^• 1063,1073. treaty with Fulk of Anjoii, Ilobert had actually done homag-e for Maine, as for his own possession.- William however seems to have looked upon both these acts as mere securities for Robert's final succession, and he had not the faintest intention of <>ivin^ up any part of his dominions durinjj his life-time. He no doubt thoujjht that he had done quite enough for his son when he joined him with his mother in the regency of Normandy during his absence.^ We may further believe that William, though he might not be prepared to go the length of disinheriting his eldest son, did not wish so ill to his subjects as to give them Robert for their ruler before his time. Robert how- Robert de- ,,,.„,.. „ __ 1-1 luands an ever took a dinerent view 01 matters. He w^as stirred up immediate by his own ambition and by the suggestions of evil com- I*^*^^***^^"- panions to call on his father for an immediate provision."* * Ord. Vit. 545 C. " Guillelmus Princeps ante Seiilaicuni bellum, et post in quAdam sua sej^tudine, Robertum primogenitain sobolem suani fecorat Huum l»a;redem, et ju8sit onines optimates ei facere homagium et fidelitatem. At illi gratanter iniperantc adtjuieverunt." The sickness of William here spoken of took place at Lillebonne (573 B), but the date is not given. No one puts forth the grant so strongly as our own Worcester Chronicler in hi** very la.st entry (1079). from which we also get the con- firmation by King IMiilij*. Robert rev(»lted '* forl>an K' his fu-der ne wolde him letan waldan his eorldonies on Normandige, \>e lie sylf and eac se kyng Filip|)us mid his ge}»afunge him gogyfen hoefdon, and ^a |)o betst wa-ron on )jam lande hiefdon aft'as him gesworoTi aiul hine to Idafoixle genumen." He is abridged by Florence, 1077. '' See above, p. 561, an«l vol. iii. p. 199. "* See above, p. 123. • I have here to put together two accounts in different partM of Orderic, in the fourth book and in the fifth (pp. 545, 569). Ik)th evidently refer to the same time, but it serms hopeless to fix the exact date Our one land- mark is that the battle of (ierln-roi is fixeil by both Chronicles and Florence to the year 1079. Ordtric (570 C) talks of Robert wandering THE LATKK DAYH (»K WILLIAM. lEi yXe hcAT of the abject »Utc of (le|xnovcrty in «luoh hU father kept him, a refonn \n h ly suppoHO to ibtf Ukci which hji* Uvn already mcntionccl, that lio had rfCvtTcd no share \vhat(>ver in the 8]M)ils of Kn<;l:in(l.' His ooinnMlfla exhorted him to demand a share of tho Kin^^lnm of England, or at all events the possession of Normandy and Maine. Thev reniiiuli'*etl. Robert asks for Normandy, which he mv9 that his father had granted to him before the invasion of England. William answers that the request is incon- «iflt«nt ; Normandy is his hereditary possession, which he will not give up while he lives ; England he holds through the strength of Normandy.^ Robert has nothing to answer, except to ask what he is to do, and how he is to find the means to give anything to his followers.'' " Be to Tsrioaa purU of the world for about five years, which would seem to fix Um (IaU of his first r«l>cllion to about tho year 1074. ^"^ ^" ^^^ story of tke quarrel between the hrotherH at L'Aigle William and Henry are spoken ofM"miliiM.* But in 1074 Henry, the only one of William's children wboae birtli we can fix exactly, was only six years old, and he waH not "dabbed to rider* till 10S6. (See l^-low, p. 694.) Florence again dis- tinctlj pUcea the beginning of the rebellion in 1077, and this date has the force of a cfjrrection, for Florence is here foUowinfj the Worcester Chnmkle, which places the rebellion and the battle of Gerberoi in 1079. I think then that we may take 1077 as the probable date for the beginning ol the quarrel Ijetween Rol>ert and his father. • See Ord. Vit. 545 C, 569 C. " In ingenti pauperie degis," say Bobcrt's oonpanionH, and they go on at some length in the same strain. • Old. Vit 545 C. " Debitos honores, principatum videlicet Cseno- mannnnim at Neiutri»." 569 C. " Partem regni Albionis, aut saltern '^''"'Imii Nonnannue.** • lb. 569 D. " Incongruum est, fili, quod poscis. Per virtutem Nor- ■anniram obtinui Angliam. Hereditario jure possideo Normanniara, ipanque de manu me& dum advixero non ejiciam." • lb, " Quid roeis clientibus tribuam < " DISPUTE BETWEEN WILLIAM AND ROHEHT. 641 obedient to me in all thinofs,*' answers William, " and chap. xxi. share my dominions everywhere with me." Robert says that he will not be for ever his father's hireling*; he wants something" of his own that he may pay his own servants. To that end he asks for nothing shurt of the Duchy of Normandy. AViJliam reminds him of the duties of sons towards their fathers, and gives him a lecture on llehoboam and the evil of listening to young and foolish counsellors. He would do better to consult wise men, experienced nobles, or learned scholars like the two Archbishops, Lan- franc at Canterbury and William at Rouen.^ " My lord the King," says Robert, '' I did not come here to hear sermons, of which mv tutors g-ave me more than enough when I was learning grammar." - Will his father give him what he asks for, or not ? He has made up his mind that he will not stay any longer in Normandy as his servant. William William again answ^ers that he will not give up his native Duchy g^ve^up^ of Normandy, that he will not ffive up the Kin'j-dom of ^"y^^^"g ; ' . : . while he England which he has won with such toil. God had given Uvea, him the Kingdom and God might perhaps take it away from him, but he himself would give it up to no man. He seems even to have pleaded a religious scruple ; he had been crowned and anointed King, and he could not give up the Crown which the ministers of Christ had placed upon his head.'" His purpose was fixed; while he lived, he * Ord. Vit. 570 A. "A Guillelmo et Lanfranco Archiepiacopis, et aliia Bophistis niaturisque proceribus inquire consilium." The mention of Archbirthop William hIiows that the dialogue is HUj>j)08eJ to be held at some time after 1077; but if we are to admit a wandiring (tf five years, or even of one year, tluH date is im|>o.s8ible. ' lb. A, B. " Hue, Domine mi Kex, uon aceosdi pro sennonibus audieiidis, (juorum copia frequenter ustjue ad nau.seam imbutus sum a grammatici.s." ' lb. B. " Capiti men a vicariis Christi sacrum dia RobeK*s discontent into a Hame. William was now at war with Rotrou, Count of Mortxig^ne in Perche, that border land, the nursery of the house of Belesme,- which **^~- formed j»art of the Norman diocese of Seez, but which owDed the temporal 8U]x^riority of France.'' Rotrou ])ore a bad charnrter as a plunderer of the church of Chartres, QmmrtH and was divinely smitten for his crime.'* William, accom- H,ff»tTiMH panied by his three sons, Iiad marched as far as L'Aiglc iT^JUrll' *° ^^^ diocese of Evreux, not far from Ouche on the one hand and Verneuil on the other. This was the lordship of Richer, whose father E^inulf had died in the MalfoHse of Senlac/ The Kin^ and his two young-er and more dutiful tons,* William and Henry, were quartered in one house ; Robert lod|[^ in another. The two lads came to their elder brother's quarters, and began to play at dice in the solar or upper room, to make a great noise, and at last to throw water on Robert and his companions who were below. Robert, ■tirred up by two of the party, Ivo and Alberic of Grant- » OnL Vit. 570C. • Thi« Mcmt to follow from the words of Orderic (546 B), that William •cum Rotrooe MAuritanicnsi Comite pacem fecit" (see below, p. 644), whioh imply an earlier statt; of war. ' See vol. ii. p. 183. • OnL Vit. 5<6 B. " AnlmadverHioDe divinA obeurduit, et sic ad mortem tuque sardtu penmuunt." • See Tol. lii. p. 504. Ord. Vit. 545 D. "Guillelmus Rufus et Henricus patri favebant, VIIM41M nua frmt«mis viribus eequas arbitrantes, indignum ducebant quod ftat«r aonun aoloa habere palrium jus ambiebat, et agmine clientura sibi nlsMiiiuito |Nur patri «itimari peroptabat." Directly after, their playing •t dioa b Mid to be " gicut militibus raoris est." But see above, p. 640. KEBKLLION OF ROBERT. G43 mcsnil, the sons of the SherilF of Loiccstersliiro,^ rushed chap. xxi. upstairs to aven«^e the insult. The Kin^ smoothed down matters for the moment, but in the nig-ht Robert decamped with his comrades, and made an attemj)t to seize the ducal castle at Rouen. But he wais baflk'd by the faithfulness Robert's of its commander, the King-'s cup-bearer, Rog-er of Ivry, on Rouen whom we have already heard of in En*^land.- Robert was 'J^^*^*^*^ '^y J ^ Koger of now at the head of a band of exiles, numbering among them Ivry. several men of the noblest houses in Normandy. Among Roi>ert'8 them we find the sons of the two great Earls of the panbns. Welsh border, William of Breteuil, the son of the fallen Earl of Hereford, moved perhaps by wrath at the bonds of his brother, and Robert of Belesme, the son of Earl Roger of Shrewsbury and of the cruel Mabel, the man who was so faithfully to reproduce the crimes of his mother and his mother's house. With these we find the son of another famous man, Ralph of Conches or Toesny,-^ the son of the elder Ralph, renowned at Mortemer and at Senlac. These and others of the young nobles of Nor- mandy took up the cause of Robert, and forsook their solid possessions for the vain hopes he held out to them.^ William seized their lands, and with his usual grim plea- santry, employed their revenues in hiring mercenaries to fight against them.^ Robert and his companions soon found protectors. Hugh Robert of NeufcliAtel, lord of the border-castles of Neufchatel, Hugil of^ Sorel, and Raimalast, was the husband of the younger ^'^-'ufchatel, Mabel^ the sister of Robert of Belesme. He received the * See above, p. 132. • See above, p. 46. * On the younger Ralph, see above, p. 605. * Ord. Vit, 546 V>. " Op|)i(l,i (liviteHi|uo fundos ])ro inani npo ot pro- miaaiB flocci[)eiulen(lirt reli(iufnmt." A longer lirit of Robert's companions is given in 570 C. One is " Rodbertua de Molbraio," Hocniiugly the future Y^x\ of XorthunjlierK'ind. ' lb, " Kei ... do redditibua coruux utipeuilarius dimieantcs contra eotdflm remuneravit." T t a (II TIIR LATER DAY8 OP WIMJAM. c«»r »*.. ,iiW. ind hin ciutlcs Ikk^hu* their ho;ul-(|uart4TB (or •^ ^ rmraipnfr NormmntlyJ And it would lUM'm that KoIutI ^^- wwB almnlr lx»jfiiinin>f to peceivt* direct cnrourap?nirnt fnmi iht> common Overlord of all. Kin*,'* Philip at Parin. An officer of the Kind's court, his (hpifcr Aimerie, was aH pr««vnt in Hugh 'a castle of Kainialast. That castle was now besiegvd hy William in company with an uncxiHJcted allj. The tief of Itiimalast owned liotrou of Mortarrne as lit immean H ■■■ MMr Be wolde him Uetan waldan his eorldomea on Norraandige." QUARREL BETWEEN WILLIAM AND MATILDA. 645 but all that he got he st|iiancleretl on his worthless com- cuap. xxi. panions of hoth sexes. Hl* remained as poor as ever, and plung-ed into debt to sui)ply his needs. ^ Two sons how- ever were born to him in the course of his wanderings ; of one of them, Itithard, I have already spoken as one of those among William's otl'spring who met their doom amid the haunted shades of the New Forest.^ Robert however had still one friend in his own country Matilda and in his father's house. He was the darling son of j^f^^^^ his mother, and now the doom of sorrow which brooded over William's house took a new form, by stirring up the first strife between William and his Queen. Matilda, without her husband's knowledge, sent large sums of gold and silver and other precious things to her banished son. William heard of it, and sternly forbade her. But the tenderness of the mother prevailed over the duty of the wife, and Matilda again sent her gifts to Robert. William again rebuked her. She, his companion whom he loved Quarrel as his own soul, was spending his wealth on his enemies her and who sought his life, and was arming and strengthening ^ ^^*'"' them against him.'^ Matilda could only plead the love which she bore to one who is as usual mistaken for her first-bom son."* If Robert were dead and lying buried seven feet deep below the earth, she would gladly shed her blood to bring him to life again. How could she enjoy wealth while her son was lacking all things ? Such hard- ness was far from her heart, and she dared to add that her husband ought not to lay such commands upon her.'' The wrath of William was kindled,'' but the constant * See the graphic description in Orderic, 570 I). ' See above, p. 614. ' Ord. Vit. 571 A. *' Collateralirt niea, quain velut animam nieaiu diligo, quam omnibus gazis et potcstatibuH in toto pm'feci rt-gno meo." * lb. She in made to call him " prinujgenitam proguiiiem meam." * lb. B. " Nee vestra debet hoc niihi jubero potontia." The whoK* Kjteech, whethrr }.(«Tiuin»' nr not, is well conceivrd. " lb. ** Hi.s auditi.s K»;.\ furuM cxpalluit, et in tantum iia cju.s tlVt'r- buit/' \c. «. Till. LATKR DAYS OP WILLIAM. m*r lit. loT« of to many yi^n* pleaded for his diBolxHlitnt wife. But tofrmnU hor »^»iit he felt no st^niplcH. One Sninpon, a BMon. \\Md carried meanaffw and g'xfis from Matilda to brr ion. William gave orders to seize and blind him. Bat the Queen's friends warned him of his danger ; he (M to the house of Saint Evroul, where Abbot Mainer •helterxHl him, and where he put on the monastic garb for the salvation alike of soul and body.* The quarrel between William and his son was soon to come to a crisis. Robert now came, doubtless not for the first time, to the King* of the French, and craved I*"* for some eifoctual help. Philip accordingly quartered Gti^anL ^™ *" ^^^ cattle of Gerberoi ^ in tlie district of Beauvais, '•'•• Dear the borders of Normandy and France. The fortress was strong, both by its position and by its artiticial defences. Our historian adds that it was always held hy two lords of equal right, and that it was the custom of the place to welcome all exiles and fugitives, whence- •oever they might come. Robert was welcomed by the two commanders, one of them nameless, the other the Fidame Helias, a different person doubtless from the famous Helias of La Fleche.^ They acted zealously on Robert's behalf; mercenary soldiers crowded to Ger]>eroi from all quarters ; men of higher rank from various parts of Gaul were drawn by the vain promises of lk)bei*t ; even many men from Normandy itself, including some wlio ' OnL VK. 571 B. " MonAcbicum schema pro salvatione corporis et Aainur ■alubriter indotuB est." Thia Samson, " Reginee veredarius," can bftrdljbc Uie Mune penon m the SaniHon wlio in Onleric (531) recommends How«l Cor the see of Le Mans, which did not become vacant till 1085. • •• 0«fb6rTmcum " in Orderic, " Gibboracum*' in William of Malmesbury, •■ OwbonMO ** in the Peterborough Chronicle, " Gerbothret " in Florence. "OwlMioi** ifl the present name. Ord- Vit. 573. " Helias Vicedominus cum compari suo exsulem gra- taater raginm meoepit, illique suijvjue complicibus auxilium in omnibus "P**!*^^*^"*' Morie enim est illius cawtri ut ibidem duo pares domini sint, •• iwiiiiiH ibideiii fugitivi stucipiantur, undecumque advenerint," SIEGE OF GERBEROI. Gl7 had liithorto borne a pi-ood eliaraoter for loyalty, joined chap. xxi. their fortunes with those of the exiles. Such a state of things in a fortress so near his border called for AVilHam's personal energy to put an end to it.^ He accordingly William gathered his forces, garnsoned the border fortresses oi campaign. Normandy, and took means to keep the plunderers from Gerberoi in cheek. At last, when the Christmas Feast William 1-11 Ix^ieges was over, William, to whom all seasons were alike when Gerberoi. there was work to be done, set forth to besiege the castle ,08^*'^^' in person. His force, English, Norman, and mercenary, had many skirmishes with the defenders of the fortress. Among those defenders, Robert's French allies are especi- ally mentioned ;- yet there is an extant charter from which it would seem, if words have any meaning, that King Question^ T»i M' 1 • IP 1 1 • T» 1 1 of PJ'ilip's rhilip himseli, by whose authonty Robert was quartered presence. at Gerberoi, was personally present in the camp of the besiegers.'^ The policy of Philip was never very stead- fast, but such a sudden change as this almost passes the bounds of belief. It is more certain that in this siege one specially memorable personal encounter took place. William, who had passed unhurt through the nine William's hours' storm of the great battle,"* who, as far as we know, had never received a wound in any earlier or later fight, had now, for the first time, to turn his back on an eneiry ' Ord. Vit. 572 C. "Quod tarn prope limitem suum hostes sui Bctlem sibi elegerant indignum duxit, nee sine terribili calumnia diutiiis pertulit." ' lb. C, D. *' Hinc Normanni et Angli rogiique auxiliares dv fiiiitimis regionibus acriter insiHtubant ; illinc Galli et vicini hostes Roberto cohie- rentes fortiter resistebant." ^ Tlie d(»cument \» a charter of Saint Quentiu, printed in Bouquet, xii. 604 ; Gallia Christiana, x, Instrumenta, 247 ; see also Provost's edition of Orderic, ii. 3S7. It bears th«' .signaturi-.s of the King>4 Philip and William, and is dated, "Actum publico in obsidione pra-dictonim Hegum videlicet Philippi Regis Fraucorum et Willelmi Auglorum Regis, prope (ierl)err)dum, anno Incamati Verbi MLXXVIII. anno vero Philippi Regis Francorum .XIX." Compare the mention of Philip's aniba.H.sadors in p. 649. • See vol. iii. p. 50H. tM THE LATER DAYS Of WILLIAM. our. MM. in pcfflQIial conflict, and to retreat, defrnt^ul and wouiuIihI, in a ttftigfr^ l>cnr«th tlio walln of n jmltry bonier fortr«w. Ami WillianiV tir«t wound came from t]u» hand from wliich ■b»> Avoond i« moNt hitter. Kathir and son met face to face in the battle. The parricidal Hj>oar of Ilobert pierced the hand of hi* father; nn arrow at the same moment stnick the hor»e on which he rode, and William the Concjucror laj for a moment on the earth, rxpcctinjjf death at the handii of hiu own son. A loyal EnK-lishman sped to his reacue— A survivor of Scnlac or Ely mi^ht well have foo^t for William in such a quarrel. Toki^, the son Tt^^T* of Wigod of Wallin^onl, fi^htin^ on horseback in Nor- Sf "? man fashion, sprang down and offered his horse, like Eustace at Senlac, to the fallen Kint^. At that moment the shot of a crossbow gave the gallant Tliegn of Berkshire a mortal wound, and Tokig gave up his life for his sove- reign beneath the walls of Oerberoi, to the increase of the estates of his Norman brothers-in-law at Wallingford and Willk« Oxford. In this fierce exchanere of handstrokes the jotinger William, the dutiful son, the future tyrant, was also woundcil in the defence of his father. "With diffi- culty the King and his sons retreated — an English writer Tentures to say that they fled — before the face of the victorious reWl, leaving many of their followers dead on the field, and many prisoners in the hands of Robert.^ It is hard to conceive a blow more grievous than this. The King, the captain, the father, were all alike cut to the quick. Before Dol William had first learned what it was to flee before an enemy ; at Gerberoi he underwent the most humiliating personal overthrow, and that at the TTWjiitf* hands of his own subjects and his own son. It is plain that the siege of Gerberoi was raised, and that the defeat was a real and serious blow; for directly afterwards we • On the diflerent acoounU of this battle, see Appendix SS. On Tokig sad Us &mflj. tee above, p. 45, and Appendix G. WILLIAM WOUNDED BY KOBEUT. 649 find William back ai^-ain at Rouen, and the wisest heads of chap. xxi. Normandy are soon debating, not how they might carry on the war, but how they mit^ht make peace between the King" and his son.^ Robert himsiclf, in the moment of victory, went off ag-ain to Flanders.- He was not incapable of g-enerous feeling", and he may have been struck with remorse for his crime. Or perhaps the men who flockeil to Gerberoi on the faith of his empty promises may have begun to forsake him. At any rate we next find some of The nobles the chief men of Normandy, among them the old Roger mandy of Beaumont, Roger Earl of Shrewsbury, and Hugh of'^^^^^"'' Grantmesnil, whose sons had been the original authors of the mischief, pleading with William on behalf of his son. They admit his crime, but they set forth his youth and his penitence; they pray William not to thrust away the returning suppliant, and they venture also to plead for their own sons and other kinsmen who were involved in Robert's rebellion.^ William at first was stern ; he set forth his owti wrongs as prince and father, wrongs such as no Duke of the Normans had ever undergone before. He complained especially of Robert's crime in stirring up foreign enemies against him.'* At last however the con- William stant entreaties of his nobles, the exhortations of his to his son. Bishops and other pious men, the entreaties of the Queen, the mediation of the Ambassadors of the King of the French and of other neighbouring princes,'* at last moved • OnL Vit. 572 D. ' Chron. Wig. 1079. "And Robert eft gewende to Fleminga lande." This is the last entry in this Chronicle. A sentence following it, expressing indijj'Tiant weariness at Robert's conduct, is broken off; ** Ne wyllo we \>eh her na mare 8ca»5e awriUin Jhj he hin fiudcr gu. ..." The Peterborough writer is henceforward our only guide in our own tongue. ' Ord. Vit. 57a D, 573 A. Robert's penitence is strongly asserted. * lb. 573 A. •* Gallos et Antlegavenses cum A(|uit.'\nis et innumoris aliis in me tcmbiliter excivit. Onuie genus humaiium, si potuis-sot, contra me commovisset, et me vobiscum trucid&Hset." ' lb. R. ** Lcgati Rei^'is Fmiuorum nobilosquo viciiii ct ainiri." The lust can hardly mean William's own subjects. ja" Aata tola THB LATER DATS OP WILLIAM. Willuun* »UTn hmrt. He yirUh^l, and recciv(Hl his son and hi* i>«'n>i»nni<»nn. Tlic succossion to the Ducliy was meortd to RohoK on the same terms as before,' and a tbort time of |k*«cc folh>wed. During this interval Pope Oti^ry ■JJrwinI a K>tter to Ilol>ert, rejoicings that he had come to a better mind, and cnhirging' on his spocinl dutjT to a father who had won so much for his lieirs to inherit.' It must also liave been during tliis short time of roconriHati«)n that Robert was sent on an exjuHlition •gmiofi Maleolm of Seothind, of which we shall hear prpaentlj, and in which he did not, to say the k>ast, gain any special fi^lory.-* It was perhaps partly owiuf^ to William's disappointment at this further ill success that disputes ag-ain broke out between father and son. Robert refused to follow his father or to obey him in any- H«ifBbi thing. Fierce remonstrances and reproaches on William's %^i^„ part followed, and llobert again went away into France with a small body of comi)auions.* Maniac* From the rebellion of AVilliam's son we may turn to of Com* gfmpt Triih the marriages of his dauf^htcrs. Constance, betrothed to jjjy *[ AUn of Britanny soon after the flight of William from • OnL \*it. 573 B. Sec nbove, p. 638. • Epj>. Grc(;. VII. ap. Lnbbe, Cone. xii. 520; Jaff^, Mon. Greg. 420. ** Imniper moneoiiui ct pateme precamur ut menti tuse semper sit infixum quam furti maou, quam divulgaUL gloria, quidquid pater tuus posai- dcat ah ore inimicorum extraxerit [thin was true of Normandy, no lees than of EngLand], Hcienfl tamen hc non in perj»etuum vivere, wed ad hoc tun ririlitcr iiudiiere ut fueredi cUicui [a discreetly vague phrase] sua dimiUflni." Hubert wa« of course the letter-carrier between Gregory and • See Um next Section. • Ord- Vit. 573 B. " Denuo post aliquod tempus, paucis sodalibus fretus, • P**** reoeeait, nee poetea rediit ; drmec pater redicM Albericum Comitem, ut dncatum Neustric reciperet, in Galliam ad eum direxit." I do not vadentaad this laat allusion. I suppose the Earl Alberic siwken of is *•• »B»e whom wo nhall presently meet with in Northumberland, but I OBB make oat nothing of this mission to llobert. If for "rediens" we ■%h* read " moriens," the paw»ge would be intelligible. MAKKIAOE OP CONSTANCE. G51 Dol, appears several years later in attendance upon her chap. xxi. mother.^ In the end however she became Countess of the Bretons, thouf^h she did not lonj^ sur>'ive her mar- riage.- Some accounts make her a model of every virtue ; Her cha- others hint that she, or her husband under her influence, aeath. pushed a rif^id justice to such extremes that the ang-ry *°9o- people of Britanny conspired and took her otf by poison.^ She died childless, and Alan married Hermengnrde, the dau<»'hter of Fulk of Anjou and the divorced wife of William the Ninth of Aquitaine.^ Conan the son of Alan Deacen- and Hermcngarde renewed the connexion with AVilliam's ^y^n. house by a marriage with a natural daughter of Henry the First, and some generations later, through the chances of female succession, the County of Britanny became the heritage of the son of another Constance, that unhappy Arthur who has been so often mistaken for the lawful heir of England.'^ ' Orderic (603 A) mentions a visit of Queen Matilda, accompanied by ^jer daughter Constance, to the monastery of Saint Evroul. This wan ininietionem exacuit." This is really in no way inconsi.stent with the account of Orderic (544 C) ; ** Amatores sequitatis in Britannia multum exsultarent, si do fortunati progenie laudabiles sibi heredes inipetrarent ; qiy genuina bonitate indomitis Britonibus justitise libram insiiuiarent, eo.squo secundum normam divime legis et humana? rationis ire cogerent." An over strict justice like that of Tostig is (juite consistent with the piety, charity, antl zeal of the public good of which he goes on to speak. Benolt (421 ii) tells us, " Mult par ert sago e afait^e E proz 0 large e enseigniee." And directly after, " Kar trop ert bclo, sago 0 proz." The continuator of William «»f Jumi^ge8 (viii. 34) records her marriage an death without giving her any character. * Ord. Vit. 544 C; Benoit, 42121. ' Se« vol. i. p. 1 16. 45J THE LATKU DAT?? OP Wll.IJAM. our lu. AdoUmt cUtii^htor. AdoU, filli* a hi^Hitr ]>ln( <> in hiMory. *••'**•*• Sbr Iwtcminc* Um» wife of Stophen (^ount uf Hlois and (liArtrr*, the •on of the thinl TlioohaM. \h' him she 1^ wiu the mother of Stephen Kinp of the Enplisli. and of another mn of hig-her personal renown, Henry, tlie famous Huhop of Winchester, the friend of lliomas of London, the founder of the Hospital of Saint CrosB and of the Lady CTu|H?l at Glastonlmry.* As the wife of Count Stephen, \ '• la holdn |H>rluip8 the hig^hcst place amoner the ))rince88e8 ofcpfj o« el her generation.^ As the dauf»'ht«it." She died in 1 137, having lived to see her son a King. For a full picture of her life and character — in every wjvy adniir- ■M» and for her corTc«ix*ndence with Saint AnHclm and Hildebert Bishop •f L* Maos, I must refer to her Life by Mre. Green. ' See above, p. 90. • Hee Art de Verifier lea Dates, ii. 703. The death of Ralph and huccch- •on of Simon in 1074 is r«oonleorary Life of Simon in Mabillon, Act. Sanct. Ord. S. Ben. H«c. rL part 2 (vol. viii.) p. 374 ; Bouquet, xiv. 37, from which a frsat deal is borrowed by Alberic of Trois- Pun tain es, 1074-1082. There ia a ■bortar notice of him by Wibert Abbot of Nogent, in D'Achery's edHaoD of his works. 467, and Bouquet, xii. 236. Boaqnei, xiv. 39. " Hex Anglorum i>otentissimu8, Willelmus nomine, qai eoni natrierai." STOKY OF SIMON OF V A LOIS. 653 Die.^ One of the points on which he consultetl Gregory chap. xxi. was because his conscience was smitten on findin<»' that his fatlier had died excommunicate, and was buried at Montdidier, a |)hice to which he had no hiwf'ul right. At the Pontitl's bidding, Simon had the remains of his He re- 1- iii_r uiove« the father moved irom this unjust possession to the church oi Uxly of hi* Crepy, where he might at k'ast sleep in ground which was *' '*'"'^* hiwl'ully his own. In the process of the translation Simon looked upon the face of the corpse, and, horror-struck with the sight, he made up his mind to devote himself to God.- For a while he was satisfied with living a pious life in the world, and presently his chief vassals pressed him to marry. He was marrieert. See Bouquet's note, and Art de Verifier lea Dates, * William is made to say (Alberic, 1076), " Nutrimentuni nu>um quod in te, augmentari cupiens, negh-ctis mintiis Regis Hisp.iniaruuj Ktlunsi et Koberti Principia Apulio), tibi filiam nicam quam quterebani trndere in uxorem pnuelegi." The original Life is fuller, but to the same effect. Thi« TUB l.ATKH DAYS OV WILLIAM. lit. Iniwtta htiDMJr AUil Queen MutiKln, ami crnved Imto to (x>nMiIt the VoyH} about the ninttcr. He nt onco went aiu) niAilo hU monastic profession ; the Count became A Saint, ami the fame of his holiness was spread throughout loall Kuropo. He onco mon» appears in connexion with the history of William, when he came to join bin entreaties to those of the Norman nobles who strove to set Itobert and his father at one a^in.* I\vin^ at Rome a few years later, he received the unwonted honour t>r being buried among the Poj>eg, and his tomb was adorned with special gifts by the Queen whose daughter he had refused. - \Miatevcr faith we may put in this story, there is no doubt as to the marriage of Stephen and Adela. The proposals of the Count of Chart res are said to have been made through Geoffrey of Chaumont^ of whom we have already heard as one of the adventurers from other lands who liad followed AVilliam to the conquest of Eng- land.' The betrothal took place at Breteuil, and the ^Jry^g, marriage was celebrated at Chartres.'* But it should bo ADcfCKl noticed that one version of the story of Simon brings of WD. before us that daughter of AVilliam, whoever she was, who f . was bctrothetl, but never mamed, to Alfonso of Spain. This, I am inclined to think, was the same daughter who wooing on the piut of Robert Wbcard eeems rather apocryphal, but I bcliore it u joft pomible. * Boaqoet, xir. 40. " Anglorum Regem et Reginam, qui eum nutri- li, riaendi grati& Normanniam UHque properavit, illucque perveniens fiUmn, Bobertum nomine, Regem dimicantem invenit, qui utrique pftoe refonnat&, pestilentiae malum a regione fugavit." ' AH this b given in full in the Life, and is copied by Alberic, but it is ■ot ftrand in Wil)ert. ' 80 we are tf>ld in the Liber de Caatro Amba«i8e in D'Achery, iii. 277. He M «id to have brought Adela to Chartres, and to have afterwards OMunly dwelt at Stephen's court. On this Geoffrey, see vol. iii. p. 314. • Ord. Vit. 573 D. Stejthen sought for the marriage "cum Guillelrao Bege ftnnare Toleiu aroicitiam." See also Hugh of Floury (Pertz, ix. 391), but be doee not fix the date. DEATH OF MATILDA. G55 had been promisetl to EadwineJ I do not pretend to caap. xxi. fix her name ; it was forpj-otten wliile two of her sisters and the King her brother were still living.^ Tlie story runs that the memory of her En<:^lish lover still lived in her heart, that she prayed that she mi<^ht never be joined to the Spaniard, that her prayer was heard, that she died on the journey, that her body was brou<^ht back and buried at Bayeux, and that, as one story adds, her knees were found to have grown hard by the length and frequency of her prayers."^ The blows were now falling heavily on the house ofMisfor- "William. His eldest son was in open rebellion, and had William's barely escaped the guilt of parricide. A daughter had "*™'v- died, seeking death rather tlian a marriage which she hated. It was about the same time that his second son, the young Richard, met with his mysterious death in the New Forest, the first of the victims which the ruined homes and churches of Hampshire were to call for from the hearth of their destroyer.** And now a heavier stroke than all was to come upon the falHng Conqueror. His wife, for whom in his youth he had so long waited and struggled, w^ho had been for so many years the partner of his cares and counsels, but whose company he had of late so often had to sacrifice to the needs of his policy, had during these gloomy years for the first time withstood and disobeyed him, and now she was taken from him for ever. After a long sickness Queen Matilda died, and died, as was Dejith of to be expected, a i)ious and ediiymg death, blie was ot :viatiiiia. course buried in her own church at Caen, where her eldest N^^'«»"^'»' daughter was already a professed nun and was one day to * See vol. iii. p. 66 1, I have there adopted tlio suggcHtion of Mrs. Green that the hetrotlj.il of one dauj^hter to Eadwino has been confoumled with the betrothal of aiiothiT daughter to Harold. ' See Will. Malm. iii. 277. ' See Appendix TT. • See above, p. 613. TUB LATER DAYS OP WILLIAM. Ill be ft fWK>wwer gibi, divis egenis." • WUL Malm. IH. 273. •* I^.acrimis f»er inultos dies ubertim proaecutus, trndtam eaiitetem de«ideraverit. quin et ex eo tempore, ei credimus, ab oaurf TolupUte deadnt." • Ord. Vil. 648 B. " I'uht oJ^ituni gloriosae Mathildis Reginae Willelmus «•* peoe It. annLi quibiu Buper\ixit, multis procellis tribulatiouum contra •WB bMUfeniibui vehementer laboravit." • 8m aboT«, p. 558, O*^ ViL 648 B. " QuibuHdam parvifl occasionibus Regero prius tAodit, aed postmodDm in majua crescentibua," &c. ' lb. C. WAU OF SAINTE-SUSANNE. 657 The walled towns and the capital itself were liarassed/ and chap. xxi. those who were entrusted with tlu-ir defence sent urp^ent messages to their Kinf^, Duke, and Count to come to their rescue. But the days were gone when Domfront and Alen9on, when Dover and Lincoln, hud yielded to the dread of William's name. He came, and he saw that the work was too much for him. Sainte-Susanne was not to be taken.2 There were no means of besieging the castle ; The castle A> illiam confined his plans to doing something to check Mie^eJ, but the ravages of Hubert. For this purpose he built and t}j|!°„J,i'Jjj. garrisoned a counter- fortress in the neighbourhood.-^ The l>ourhood garrisoneebat." ' See vol. ii. p. 264 for the like at Brionne. Tlie tfirtr(reaeni.^ Hubert and his comrades were enriched by the rantroms of the chief men of Normandy and Enprland.* Not a few among" them lost their lives. The I>«Aol end of Richer of L'Aigle is worth the telling. On a i/Ay. Novemlx?r (Liy, a party of Normans were attacking the followers of Hul>ert. A beardless boy, hidden behind a thicket, struck Richer witli an arrow beneath the eye. The comrades of the baron seized him and were about to put him to death, but the dying Richer gathered such strength as he had left to bid them for God's sake to spare • In DomaiiUy, 158 b, it in said of Ludwell in Oxfordshire, " banc liadit Rex W. Roberto apud ohRidionem Sanctse Susannas." A much more ■yileHoos Domatday entry may abK> l>e connected with this war. Certain bods of Oiwald, » Tb^n of Surrey (36 h), were said by Bishop Odo to be Uikble to » yearly payment either of two marks of gold or of two bewk*— e sngular alternative. It in added, " £t hoc per concessionem Abbetia fratrli Omiuoldi, scilicet pro bello quod contra Gaufridum parvuni feeer* debait.** I can throw no light on tiiis forerunner of Sir Geoffrey HndeoB, onleM be hM anything to do with one " Machiellua de Guitot filtaa Godefridi parvi " (Ord. Vit. 649 C), who waa killed in this war. He WM tjghliBg on WUliam's aide, but biB father may have been among the • Old. Vit. 648 D. • lb. •• Re^ familia . . . divitiig, epulis, ac belHcia samptibus prae- itabet; aed ceetreuaif cuneus eia virtute ac multitudine sequiparari sata- gebei.** lb. Tlie but wonii of the description are emphatic ; " Tribua annis HnbOTtoa NomiMinifl restitit, et, inimicorum opibus locuples, invictua iL** DEATH OF RICHER OF L*AIGLE. 669 him, for that his own sins deserved death. The boy was chap. xxi. let go, and Richer liaving", for u-ant of a priest, confessed his sins to his comrades, died before he could be carried back to William's fortress.^ A tale of generosity like this does something to relieve the weariness of this wretched lx)rder warfare. The struggle went on, but wholly to the advantage of Hubert ; Earl William of Warren, Gilbert the brother of Richer, and others who were seeking to avenge his death, got only wounds for their pains. Count William of Evreux was taken prisoner. At last the Normans, finding that all their attempts were vain and that their forces were daily lessening, laid the plain state of the case before King William in England. Hubert was not to be con- quered ; valour and luck were alike on his side. They Hubert 1-11 T^- 1 1 It reconciled exhorted the King to make peace, and peace was granted to William. on the fullest terms. Hubert crossed over to England, he ' received the pardon of William for his past offences, he was confirmed in all his possessions and rights, and remained ever after his faithful subject.- The war of Sainte-Susanne brings us very near to the last stage of William's life. But before we survey the great legislative acts of his latest years in England, one or two ecclesiastical events in Normandy may well be men- tioned. Tlie famous Bishop Hugh of Lisieux had died in I>eath of the year which had been marked by the dedication of so Bishop of many Norman churches.^ A strange warfare was waged july "'^'^ 1077. * I have pretty well traniJAtcd the story in Orderic, 649 A. He adds a panej,'yric on fiicher which, from tliis hia one recorded act, we can believe to be fully deserved. The ** njunicipiuni " of a former extract has now become '* urlw." ' The date Heems to be marked by the war occupying the time between the death of Matilda in 1083 and the Survey in 1086. Tn Onleric, 649 D, the latter ft>llow8 at once, intr«xluced with " his totnporibu8." ' Se« above, p. 479, and on Bishop Hugh, \u\. iii. j). 1 18. U U 2 TUB LATRR DAVS oK WILLIAM. wn.9fm h»B hoAy l»ct%vivn hin ranonn and t))t> nuns (if .'i inimartiity of hi< n*arin;:,' wliilr IjIh m(»troj>()litan. tho ftOitorv IVimAto John, was gniittoii.with a divine judf^ment for Tcfoaing befitting honours to his deroascd suiVra^^n.- Hut the point of n*al imiK>rtan»ecratcd by Michael Biuhop of Avranches. • See the long picture of him given by Orderic, 550 B, 551 A. It is eU MmuDcd up in one sentence ; " ScientiA litterarum et facundiA diritiie ei delidiii indesinenter affluebat, propriae voluntate et HI* nirnis ierviebat." A liiit is given of the eminent men in the of Licieux at this time, including our old friend the Archdeacon >\ illiam of Poitien. On the parentage of Gilbert see above, p. 367. OILBEHT BISHOP OF LISIEUX. 661 Bishop; but in an a<^e when the Church monopolized learn- chap. xxi. inq" and science of all kinds, there was no way of promoting such a man except by making" him a Bishop. The ap- pointment was quite unlike those appointments in the days of William's minority, when ecclesiastical preferments were turned into mere provisions for younger or illegitimate members of the reifirning" house. It had more in common with those appointments of a somewhat later day, when Bishopricks and other ecclesiastical oflices were made the rewards of statesmen and diplomatists. But whatever we say of this appointment to the see of Lisieux, in the next great ecclesiastical office which William bestowed he con- sulted the strictest ecclesiastical propriety. Two years Death of after the death of Hugh of Lisieux the Primate died,^ and bishop William, as I have already mentioned,- at once offered '^*^^"* the vacant post, the greatest spiritual preferment in his winiam continental dominions, to Wimund of Saint Leutfred, the ''^*^?* '^'^ daring monk who had denounced his conquest and refused Mshoprick his offers in England. Wlien Wimund, from the noblest motives, refused the offered promotion, William again sought for a man of real ecclesiastical merit. The sue- William _ _ , • n 1 i 1 11 " Bona cessor 01 John, canonically elected, as we are told, was Anima," William, called the Good Soul, who had succeeded Lanfranc ^j^'^^tg.^ in the Abbey of Saint Stephen, and who now ruled the p^'f"'-' 1070 1079. church of llouen for thirty-one years. ^ His chief act was Archbishop the holding of a council at Lillebonne in the second year ,o-g-iiio. of his primacy, in which, besides a great number of enact- Couiuil of ments of the usual kind, the Truce of God was once more jqSo solemnly ordained.^ Ecclesiastical censures are denounced against all violators of the truce, and the secular power is ' Ord. Vit. 551 B. Him epitaph is given, which docs not mention hi.s loM) of Hpcech, but Jouh Hpcak of his " lingua diserta." " See above, p. 44H. " Ord. Vit. 551 C; Chron. 8. Stcph. in anno. * See vol. ii. p. 741. t ' ' THE LATKR DAYS OF WILLIAM. tL cmlUd in to «if«ogihcii the IihiuIh of tho Disliop.* llio tM««l ibr the r»-eiiaetioont of thin oniiniiiico, which in Miid to luiT« bwn cmrefully olwervetl in the more prospcroiw jCATi of William • reigTi,^ waa probably owing- to the con- hich had U^giin to arise now that William's defied by hiB own subjects. } 3. Tht Affairs of the Scottish and U'eUh Marches. 1087-1081. While the affairs of Normandy were in this confused ftate, and while the arms of William met with little but defeat, England remained comparatively quiet. For •ererml yesrs we hear nothing of the greater part of the country. In some years the Chronicles are an abaolutc blank. Quite towards the end of William's reign we shall come to a time of great legislative activity ; but, for about six years after the death of W^altheof, the internal history of England consists of a single outbreak, for it liardly amounted to an insurrection, in the most northern Earldom of England. J5ut along the Marches, Scfjttish and Welsh, the usual warfare went on. W'e have heard nothing of Malcolm since he coun- ■elled his brother-in-law Eadgar to make his peace with William.^ We now first come across his name in a mutilated passage of our Chronicles which records a •nccew which he gained over a competitor within his own Kingdom. Miclsla^hta or Malsnechtan, a son of • OnL Vit. 55a A. " Pax Dei, quae vulgo Trevia dicitur, sicut ipse PriaeefM Guillclmui earn in initio conHtituerat, finniter teneatur, et per rfagvlM parochi&B dictis excommunicationibus renovetur." The respective wwctiom of ibe Bishop and the Viwcount (Ilegis Vicecomes) are then MnrilMd. By another clauw: (553 D) penalties are denounced againat priciAs who ■hall excommunicate any one without the licence of the Biihop, " pnet«r Trcviae Dei infractores et latrones." ■ 8m toL ii. p. 141. 3 See above, p. 570. MALCOLM INVADES NORTIIUMBEULAND. 6G3 Lulach, and therefore a representative of the chiims of cii.vr. \xi. Macbeth or of Gruaoh, had been a^iii in re)x?llion, but Malc4)lm he was now overthrown by Malcolm. The King* took Mjelhla-hta. Madshehta's mother, and all his Ix'st men, and all his ' cattle, and he himself hardly escaped.^ This victory doubtless raised the strength and spirit of Malcolm, and two years later he ventured on another inroad into Eng- land. He crossed the border in the August of the year in which William and Robert were fighting* before Ger- beroi. He harried all Northumberland as far as the Tyne, Invwion of and went back after slaying many hundreds of men and bedaiul by carrying off great spoil in captives, money, and treasures ^^y',^" "** of every kind.- The gentle influence of Margaret may io;9- have reformed the personal conduct and the internal government of Malcolm, but his neighbours of England reaped but little benefit from the change. This new blow, like Malcolm's former inroad into England, was not at once avenged. AVilliam took no measures against the Scottish King until he was called on to chastise a domestic disturbance as well as a foreign invasion. The episcopate of AValcher of Durham Episcopate is known to us in some detail. We have seen that of Durham. 1071-10S0. * Chron. Wig. 1078. "And her Malcholom kyngc gewann Mwlalrehtan modor [a blank follows in the manuscript] and ealle his betstan menn and ealne his garsunian and his orf, and he sylf uneaSe a-tba-rst." The parent- age of this pretender comes from the Annals of Ulster (O'Conor, iv. 350), which record his death under 1085, with the title of King of Moray; " Maelsncctai mac Lulaigh ri Muire))." See Mr. E. W. l{«>bert*isum goare com Melcolm cyng of Scot- lande into Englelande betwyx J>am twam Marian nmssan mid mycclum fyrde, and gehergode NnrMiymbraland o5 hit com to Tine, and i>f: uK WILLIAM. r. ftit a fliftw ftieodship cxii«t|).- Ilig govcniment waH ^^JJ^JI^ hArdlr fuch mm wo nhouKl have lookcenitu8 deficiente, monachorum nomen pnrriDcialibuj inauditunx. in Htuporem vertebantur, quum quemlibet kabitfia ft vitae forte conspicerent." So to the same effect, but briefly, in the Durham Uiatory, iii. 2 1 . REVIVAL OF MONASTICISM IN THE NORTH. 665 already heard.' l^it it now came into the hearts of chap. xxi. certain monks in a di.stant shire, who had read in Bieda Tl'^eti inonkii how full Northumberland once was of holy places, to set ome from forth on a missionary enter})rize to the benighted land. corui>e anernnt. Factaqno ■ub ipHiH paric'tibus casultk ubi duriiiirent et manducaront, religio8urum eleemosynis paujK.Tem vitam sustcntirunt." ' lb. "Pauci do ipsa Northanhymbrorum provinci&f pluros vcro tie australibuB Anglorum partibuu." TIIR LATEK DAYS (»K WIM.IAM. r, giTc thorn the lunlHliip of Jarrow aiul other tiio rvTcnucii of which cmibloil thorn to build the tower and mooAstic buihlin^ which still remain.' It 10 to the Ibrtuiuittf |>overty of the house of Jnrrow that we owe that DmhU's choir is still left to us. But the flaroCi when once kiiHlKnl, spread far more widely. The reetored house of Jarrow l>i'caine the cmdle end centre of a whole crowd of monastic foundationR. .iClfwine remmined in the d\V('llin«^-I)lac(' of ]3a'da as Prior of the re>nved monastery. liut lU'gtjn frith, now, we may pragmne, no longjugata Nonnannis Anglid, obaides pro tota LindeHcia in Lindicolono castro custodiebatur." Thia must, I HuppoHo, bo i>laced soon after the taking of Lincoln in 1068. The rest of the »tory conies from the inter|)olatt«d Florenco. ' See alKjVf, p. laa. The ambasHadoni go in a merchant-ship; " navem mercatoriM videbatur, cum ad dittccndus psalmoa (juatti magin- trura sibi exhibuit." TUB LATKR DAYS oK WILLIAM. r.&u. at Jarrow.* mmi prcacnlly Fjililwino ami Tur^^)t net forth ttod tl«rrllc«l at MolrotM*, within tho dominions of Malcolm. Ilrfv thrv ftiirorwl |>crHtHMition at tho hands of the Scottish K;n^, who is ovon said to have threatened them witli TW^iv* death, hrcmuse they refused to swear ftalty to him.^ At \i the Itiddin^ of HiKhop Walchrr they came buck, and were "^ pUccd br him at ^^ < ujiiouth, where, under their care, the old ohurrh of lienedict RIhcoj), ruined in the wars of Malcolm, became a^in a place of Christian and monastic deYotion. That the relipious life once more took root and flourished in the most northern parts of England. Bishop \N alcher ^^^ himsidf thought of makings the monastic profession in his •^''* own person, and of setting monks instead of seculars to be the immetliate ministers of Saint Cuthberht. He even began to raise monastic buildings around the cathedral church, from which the canons were not as yet driven.^ We Hb h robbed, chap. xxi. it is said, of part of its moveable wealth,* and thouf^h the Bishop of Durham himself is charged with taking possession of a portion of its lands.- But the ecclesiastical schemes of Walchcr were all cut short by the fate which was brought upon him by the errors of his temporal government. Chief among his Walcher's imworthy favourites were one Gilbert, a kinsman, and (jiibert. therefore doubtless a countryman, of his own, and his LpiD(iuus exstitit, comitatum Northymbrensium Hubregendum cnmmiserat." ^ lb. " In tantum ixaltavtrat ut et in cpiscopatu et in comitatu fere nil sine illius arbitrio agitarotur." TUB LATRR DAYS OF WILMAM. . tit. NorihumhrrUnd, who had marrH^l I jiUl^yth, n dao|^hter of Karl KaKlnxl aiul «iftert, and prayed his colleague to Ugitf avenge him by speedily putting Ligulf to death. Gilbert hfOOhmt cootented, and, at the bead of a band of soldiers in the ** \f Biahop'g service, slew Ligidf in the night in his own house, together ^-ith most of his household.* Walcher heard the • TTi« fiMJljr deUili come from Simeon ; in Florence, " Liulfus " — a ■oftv fani than Simeon'it "Ligulfua" — i.s only " nobilia generosusque • Sm. I>an. 1080 (p. 99, Hinde). See Waltheofs charter in Mon. Angl. L 236. * nor. Wig. 1080. " Quia ubique loconim Normatini incessanter ei tcmpesUte op«nun dahant sua; feritati, cum suis omnibus ad Dunholme •e oontofit, qaiA Sanctum Cuthbcrtum corde sincere dilexit." This is c»^»«ed by Simeon, but it is curioux that he leaves out the account of certain rwirju wHh which, according U> the monk of Worcester, Saint Cuthberht faroared hit T0U17. S® *^ William of Malmesbury in both accounts. lignlfa boQM Memt now to be conceived as not being in the town. MURDER OF LIGL'LF. 071 tale; he expressed his sorrow by his words and postures, chap. xxi. and warned Leobwine that he had ruined him.' The ^^'»'^^»*''' protojiti* hu Bishop took shelter in the castle, and sent forth mes- iimc»ceuce. eeng-ers to announce that he was himself guiltless of the blood of Lij^ulf, and that he was ready to make solemn oath to that efi'oct.'' On this assurance the kinsfolk of the A Gem6t - „.,,tobt; held. murdered man exchan^fed promises of peace ^ \iitn the Bishop, and it was agreed that the whole matter should be brou«:ht before a jjeneral Gemot of the Earldom to be held at Gateshead,* a place on the south side of the T}'ne, which the works of modern skill have well nigh joined on to the town of Newcastle on the opposite bank. But before the assembly met, men learned that the acts of the Bishop were not strictly in agreement to his words. He Walcher'* had received both Gilbert and Leobwine to their former to the favour and former i)laee in his household.'' Men now fully '"^"^*''^"- believed that it was really by the Bishop's own orders that Ligulf had been elain. The assembly met, a gathering of the whole people of OenvUat ■VT 1 11 1 '111 T i*p /•! 1 1 OatesheaJ, Northumberland, with the hereditary chiefs of the land at May 14, its head.^ One of them bore the name of Waltheof, a name *° °* which speaks his kindred with the ancient Earls. Another Gilbert goes, "etepweopi et ejusdera Leobwini militibas in unura coadu- natis, ad villain uhi tunc Liulfus morabatur." Mark that the chaplain had ** milites " of his owe. * Flor. Wig. 1080. "Me et te omnemque familiaiu meam tuae linguae peremisti gladio." ' lb. **So necin Liulfi coiisciua non fuinse, (luiii potiiw ejus occisorera Gilebertuis omne«^ue Hocioa ipwiua de Northyinl)ria penitus exlegtt.s,se, ac {>aratum fore »emetipsum purgare secundum judicium {)ontificale.'' That is, by oath, neither l)y battle nor by ordeal. ' lb. " Pace ad inviceni datA et acccptA." * lb. " In loco qui dicitur ad Caput Capne." So the Durham History. ' lb. " Ut priu«, in suain gratiniu faniilianujue rccepit." * At this point the Durham History joinn us. The account there (iiL 33, 34) in writUn (:\x more strongly in Walcher's interest than that of Florence, The Assembly is described ah "qui ultra Tinam hiibitnverant universi natu majores [|»a yldcsUin K'j^nas] cum iutinitil totius populi multi- tudino in pesaimum aduuati consilium." trt THE LATER I)AY8 OF WILLIAM. WM Eadwuir. vtirimnuHl Kiih, the son of Uhtnd, tlio son of Oo«|Mitnc, the son of that Earl Thtml who. seventy- four T«u« before, had tlolivcrotl Durluim from tho ScotaJ The 0«ai6l was held, acconlinj? to ancient Kn^'lisli custom, in the ojicn air. But tho Bisliop, fearing: the vast and excited crowd, took his place in the church alon^ with his chosen followers, the guilty men l>ein^ among them. Between him and the people outi^ide messengers went to and fro.* This refusiil to meet his flock face to face would no douht do much to stir up their minds still more fiercely against him. Men had no mind for the usual formalities and discussions. A cry was raised in the English tongue, seemingly from the mouth of Eadwulf, '• Short rede, good rede, slay ye the Bishop."^ The tUoghtor began. All those outside the church who were known to be the Bishop's friends were cut down, a few mkme escaping by flight. Walclicr then bade his kins- man Gilbert, who, as the actual murderer, was the most hateful of all, to go forth and by his death turn away the wrath of the people. lie went forth, a body of knights following in the hope of defending him, but all fell beneath the swords and javelins of the armed * The DAnic of Waltheof comes from the Durham History, that of Ead- wulf from Simeon. 1073. • Hot. Wig. 1080. " Semel et iterum de buIh quos voluit pro pace facienda foTM ad ao« midt." Thiit in Homewhat differently told in the Durham Hblory; "DeclinMui episcopus tumultum, eccleoiolam ipsius loci intravit, •bi ooQTocaiis ad ae populi primatibun, do utriuHque partis utilitate ac irtai amicitiA tractavit. Quo facto. epiHOopo cum pauciasimiH Huonim in wriffrit remaoente, omnes qui advocati fuerant quasi consilio loquuturi, agiwiiiuitnr.* Roger of Wendover (ii. 17) gives the whole account in a i|iirft BOii boatfle to Walcher, and paints him as a mere fiscal oppressor wbo bought the Earldom of William. He now says, " Epiacopus nimis f«mtT raapondit, quod de nulla injuria vel calumni^ ipsis justitiam aatequam aibi libras quadringentas monetae optimse numer&s- oTiW • I do not KTUple to borrow this from R. Wendover; "Unus ex illis, CQJiM aHiitriam omnes exs{>ectabant [this must be Eadwulf], praecipitanter patrU linguA dixit, 'Schort red, god red, slea ye the bischop.'" MURDER OP WALCHKK. 673 Gomot, except two En^'-lish Tlie^i-ns whose kindrt'd hUxHl cir.vp. xxi. pleaded for them.' The Dean Leofwine and other eh'rks also went forth. But they were slaughtered as well as their lay comrades, the evil deeds of Leofwine out- weighing- any respect for his English Mood.- At last the Bishop bade the first author of the whole evil, Leobwine himself, to go forth ;•* but he refused. The Bishop then him- self went forth to the door of the church and j)leaded for his life. Tlie raging people refused to listen. The Bishop, Walcher like Cajsar, wi"ai)ped his face in his mantle and fell beneath the swords of his enemies, the actual death-blow, it is said, being dealt by the hand of Eadwulf.** A fierce cry was now raised for Leobwine; but the guilty man still tarried. The church was now set on fire, and presently Tlie church Leobwine, already scorched by the flames, came forth. Leobwiue A thousand spears were ready to meet him, and the man ''"'^^• who had plotted the death of Ligulf fell hewn in pieces by the countrymen of his victim. The slayers of the Bishop now hastened to Durham, in the hopes of slaying also those of his men whom he had left in the castle. But Vain the works of Norman engineers were too strong for them ; Durham after a siege of four days they grew weary of the attempt, t}j^^„^ur^ and were scattered abroad every man to his own home.^ derera. ' William of Malmesbury (iii. 271) makes Gilbert go out " ultro, ut suo periculo vitam domini niercaretur." '■' I follow the details in Florence; the account in the Durham History m.-ikes no one come out till the church is on fire. Tlie l^ishop's coiu- l>anioiiH then come forth " humiliter, peccata sua confeasi |)ercept& bene- dictione." Wah-hor liinist-lf dies hwt, " pne januis pacem pni-tfuto ramo offerens," Hays William of MalmeMbury. The Winchester Annalist (^loSo) coinmenUi ; *' Ne solus deC'AY8 oK WILLIAM. ^^r tJU. Vd^caoot did not fuil to lif^ht on tlinn in tliis world •'■•••' and in the next. Koil%uilf wm kilKnl hy n woman, iKThapn M»J ba. his own wife;* Waltht^f wax killttl l>y his wife's brother; ' but befora ho du-d, one had been raitkHl frum the dead to announce that a place in the lowest pit of hell was gfanding ready for him.* Hie murder of Walcher is one of thow aets which it is alike impo«»ihlc to wonder at and to juHtify. The Bishop, himaelf most likely gfuilty of nothinp^ worse than culpable weakneai, had stirred up the ]>a^sions of the whole country affainst him, and his life was the forfeit. But the blood of a Bishop, in whatever cause it mi^ht be shed, was alwajs sacred, and Walcher, without bein^ canonized, was RvkloC looked U]Kin as a kind of martyr. His body was carried to Durham by the pious care of the monks of Jarrow, and was hurritnlly burietl in the chai)t4?r-house.^ But it was not enough that the memory of Walcher should be reverenced ; his blood had to be avenged. His death was an act which no government could pass over, but it was eminently a case w oA»aat for smiting the leaders and sparing* the commons. But William entrusted the j)unishment of the rebellious district to his brother Odo, and the Bishop took, if not a heavier, at least a meaner vengeance than the King himself would have taken. The land, already so often harried, was harried yet again as a punishment for the slaughter HbonMl* of liB pastor. Men who had had no share in the dis- tarbancc were mutilated, and even, contrary to William's own invariable rule, beheaded. Others redeemed their lives from false charges by the payment of money.'* These ' Sin, Dun. 1072, p. 91. " Mox ipse a femin& occisus." See the whole nttiry of thih Waltheof in this worM and in the next, •ad of U»« ming again of Kadwulf of lUvenxworth, in the Durliani Hi.story, ^ '3- 3 Hist. Eccl. Dun. iii. 24. Hirt. Eccl. Dun. iii. 24. " Dum mortem epJHcopi ulciscerentur, terrara ptoc toUm in Holitudinem redegerunt." Florence and after him the latorpoUtor speak to the name effect. The Durham Hiatory calk the ROBERT IN SCOTLAND. 675 were doubtless the deeds of the Earl of Kent, wlio went chap. xxi. away after leavin«^ a •'•iiard iii the castle, liut meanwhile the Bishop of Bayeux had cast a lon^nj* eye on the treasures of Saint Cuthberht, and he carried ofi" a pastoral staff of rare workmanship and material, for it was wroui^ht of sapphire.* Havin';' thus chastised the Northumbrians, William deemed it time to chastise Malcolm of Scotland also. In Robert the autumn the King's eldest son Robert, now for a atjain-st moment reconciled to his father,- was sent agrainst Scotland ^^^f^^o^"*- ' " Autumn, with an army, in which were many of the great men of the »o8o. realm, and among* others Abbot Adelelm of Abingdon. No battle was fought, but, according to one account, Malcolm met Robert somewhere in Lothian, renewed his liomage, and again gave hostages.'^ This story may per- haps be a confused repetition of the scene between Mal- colm and William at Abernethy. It seems certain that Robert reaped no special glory in his Scottish expedition. His march was chiefly memorable from the fact that on his way back he stopped at the place which had hitherto been Monkchester, and there, opposite to the scene of Walcher's murder, laid the foundation of a fortress to guard the stream and curb the turbulent people. From that fortress, Founda- rebuilt in the next age with all the improvements of the Newcastle, later days of Norman art, the momentary dwelling-place |>er8oius killen the death of Wahlier tlio spirit iml ami temporal •dminijitrmtion of NorthumlH»rlaiul wore n^iin mi)arate(l. The Enrldom yvw» first pivcn to a certain AllMTic or Aubrpv. of whom little 18 known. Hr was found unfit for •0 diffictdt a |>08t ; he eitlier reni/^^niHl it or was removed from it, and went back into Normandy.'-* His name appears in the Survey as a past but not a present owner, which however neeil not imply more than the necessary kMtf of the lands attached to the Earldom.'' It would seem that \Villiam then once more tried the temporal g-overn- ment of a Bishop, but a liishop of a very different class Gtatbwj from the feeble Walcher. The liisliop of Coutances, Camamom\ Ocoffrey of Mowbniv, who had smitten the men of Somer- set and Dorset before Mont acute, was sent to curb the RobartoC men of NorthumlK'rland.^ lie, after a while, resigned his thankless office to his nephew Robert of Mowbray, a proud, stem, and gloomy man, who inherited the temporal pos- • .Sim. Dun. io.*'o, p. loo. " Rex Willelnuis auctumnali tempore Kodbertum filium auuin ScotiAm contra Malcolmum inieit. Sed qiium pMTMumi ad ^gglesbreth, nullo confecto negotio reversus, CaHtellum NonuB toper flamen Tyno omdidit." TIiIh may simply mean that there wm BO ImUUa, but the Aliingdon verwion in iuohI likely exaggerated. • lb. 1071, p. 92. *' R«x dedit ilium honorem Albrio. Quo in rebus dlflcflibat paruui v&Iente patrianirjue revereo, idem Rex Rodberto de Mulbroio dedit oomitatum Northymbreiisem." A strange legend about tlds Alberic will be found in Broraton (X Scriptt. 1255), which illustrates tW wmj tn which Eaxl^m Europe was ever present to the minds of the •eo of the elereoth century. We have heard of Alberic in the .story of Bobert, we abore, p. 650. He becomes "Aluredus" in Ann. Wint. 1080. WheivTer Alberic'a name rxxurs in Domesday, it is always "tenuit," Mi "teoei.'* See especially Oxfonlshire. 157 b, and Warwick.shire, 239 h. • 80 Dagdale (BeroiMge, 56) infers from the account of the foundation of 8eJnt Mary's at York. Mon. Angl. iii. 546, where we rea'AH favourable. He wajs ** potens in sajculo et oris volubilitate promptus, maxime nub Willehiio Kege juniore." * Of the importance of Durham in this point of view I shall have to speak in my fifth volutno. On William's works, see Hist. Keel. Dun. iv. 8, and the following tract on the Jiishops of Durham, X Scriptt. 61. * They were, according to the local historian (iv. 3), " nomen tantum cannnicorum habentes, sed in mdlo canonicorum rogulam He*iuenteH ; " that is, of course, the rule of ('linxlegang. Thi-ir Dean seems to have In'en married. '' Hist. Eccl. Dun. iv. i. " C^uia episcopatus parvitas ad triam<>nachorum cocnobia non sufhceret." There is 8on^othiIl^' o«ld iu the complaint of THB LATKR PAYS OF WILLIAM. EXLOUt; tKe monk* of tho two monut^t^rirs wore removed to DurhAni, mul Jarn)W luul NVoarnumth Hank into Ihiitabi l()yin^ PJjJ^*'*^ KnMiiVimim in the hiffhest ccclcHijistical oflices in his ^^ift. Kt )Mx:aine the first Prior of the new monastery, and he mw ffoeoeeded in his offiee by Turcot. Another E»)LjfliHh- tn^n of the name of Leofwine was the Bishop's secretary. -^ TTir land* of the monks were now 8C])anitcd from those of the Bishop,* and the great Priory of Durham he«,'-.in and flouriiihwl.* The eanons hiul the choice of resig-nation or making the monastic profession. All departed save the Dean, who was hardly persuaded by his son, already a monk, to become one of the new body.^ Everything shows how stoutly the English clergy, colleg^iate as well as parochial, clave to their separate married households. Afluaol Lastly, we must turn our eyes to the Welsh border. It would be vain to try to describe the endless civil wars within Wales itself, or to reckon up all the momentary Kings of the various rival dynasties. Some of them, as we have seen, did not scruple to call in Norman or Eng-lish allies against each other, but such alliances were commonly short lived. Canuloc the son of (iruffydd had been allied with William Fitz-Osbem against MereT ooal mines nor tcm|)oral principality. • 8m Moil Axi^L i. 50a. • Hki. BooL Dun. iv. 3. EaMwine (iv. 7) diefl April i 2, 1087, when the Bbbop appoiDted Turjjot " ojinmuni fratnirn conHilio." lb. Tlie monkii' Undji were to be "omnino ab epiucopi servitio et ab ovai ooMoatodine libcne et quietse ad Huum victum et veHtitum." This la slkgad to have been the ancient privilege of those " qui Deo coram SuMti Catbberti oorpore miniijtrant." See the Bishop's charter in Mon. Aagi L 1^6. if it be not made up out of the Durham History. 8ae King William'H charter confirming all the arrangements, Mon. Aa^ L a37, and that of Archbishop ThoniaH in R. Howden, i. 137, Stubbs. • Hiat Eccl. Diin. iv. 3. Wo read of the Canons, ♦* lUi de ecclesia , qoMD taliter ingredi maluerunt." WILLIAM IN WALES. 679 Mereilycld too enjoyctl the favour of both Williams, King* chap. ixi. and Earl, and received laiuLs in Herefordshire which had I>:in !« ht-M belonged to Earl Harold and other Enj^lislimen. And at j'vMN.mof the time of the Survev those land.s were held, not indeed by **'*:*^^.>'" ' -^ aiKl his son Meredydd himself, but by his son OruH'ydd.^ The most Grutfydil. powerful prince in Wales during* these years seems to have ^^^ of*"^"' been Trahaem the son of Caradoc — not the Caradoc of ^-'araUoc. whom we have so often heard — who is said to have avenged the blood of Bleddyn on Rhys of South Wales. Trahaern His death. was himself killed in a battle with Rhys the son of °'^* Tewdwr the son of the slain Rhys.- And we might almost infer from the Welsh writers that it was this event which iu some way led to the presence of William himself in Wales. They tell us that in the same year William the Bastard, WiiHam in King of the Saxons, French, and Britons, made his way ,o8i. to the shrine of Saint David, as they would have us believe, as a peaceful pilgrim.-^ The date must be wrong, for in the year of Gerberoi William was otherwise employed. But the English Chroniclers place two years later a great His con- exj)edition of William himself into Whales, in which he * freed many hundred men — captives no doubt carried off in the inroads of the Britons — and other writers speak of his subduing the countiy."* Something no (lou])t was * See the lands of ** Grifin filius Mariadoc " in Domesday, 187 6. In one entry we read, '* Comes W. dedit Mariadoc llegi," and in another, " Rex W. condonavit geldiim Hegi MariadDC et po.stea filio ejus." I conceive that this is Meredydd the son of Ble«idyn, who is mentioned in the Brut y Tywysogiou, rioo, and his Bon CJruffydd in 1113, p. 140. But, if bo, Meredydd wa.s not «ieati at the time of the Survey ; he must therefore have given some offence and lost his lands, though they were kept by hia son. Another (JrutFydd, or the same, appears in 180 6 as "Gritin pucr," and a Manioc in 187 h. ' See Aim. C'amb. 1073, 1076, 1079; Brut y Tywysogion, under the name year; Williamn, Hint, of Wales, 185, 186. It should bo noticcil that Trahaem had Seotti.sh, or more likely Irish, allien. ' In the Brut ( 1079) Wiljiarn fip|)i-ar« aM ** Ciwilim vaatard, vrenhin y Sao«on ar I'Veinc ar Hrytanyeit," liut in the Annaln we simply reail, " Willrni Kex An^lia; raujul oratiotiiK Sanctum Daviil adiit." * Chrun. Petril). loHi. "Ou j'isum ;^'earo so eyiitf heddi' fyrde into ll TUB LATER DAYS OK WILLIAM. . uu. done towmnli that cmi \*\ t)u> fouiuiation of the otitic of OMxlifT, m foumlatioD through whii-h tlir iminrk to the Tuff, and the boj^nniiifj^ wore miulo of tliat prciit occu- mtioo of South Wah»*i which went on s<» vi^-oroufily *• durinf^ the next nM^-n.' Yet thon«,'li a ]»il|^rimage to Saint David's was certainly not William's only motive in JjUJJjJ^^ entering Wales, we can well believe that both policy ami '*■*■• devotion led him to make his way to the distimt home of the lot I British haint and to make his offering' at his shrine. The B*v^«a o( church of Saint David's has not come under our notice since JJS" it was waited by Eadric seventy years before the visit of William.* Since then it had suffered a series of misfortunes; it had been more than once sacked by heathen invaders, one invasion, in which the Bishop Abraham was killed, having hapjHjned only a short time before William's own coming.^ In the next generation, the Norman conquest of South Wales at Icajit secured Saint David's from enemies WeaLui and Hrrgvfroodefida bund manna." William's visit to Wales is also m.nnA^ to in Dt^meodAy, 31 6. A King's Reeve is said to h.ive held lands ** qoMido fuit lU-z in Walcx, et |>o8tea. donee Episcopus Baiocensis in Ghent pcrrezH.** It wim therefore before Odo's arrest in 1082. R. Wendover (ii. 10) •• Kex Anglorum WillclmuH in Walliani duxit exercitum copioKum, et •ibi fuhjugant, et a re^^lis illiu homagia et fidelitates accepit." He it in 1079, ^"' *^'^ *^ ^h*^ same year as ThurHtan's disturbance at Ohatonbory, that is 1083; *o does Henry of Huntingdon (Script, p. Bed. SIS), bat be pUoea both in 1081 ; " Wiilielmus Kex anno decimo quinto duxit exercitum in Walliam, et earn sibi Hubdidit." So the Waverley Annal*, but under 1080, adding, " multi ex utraque parte perierunt." Ho Wincbest^rr, 1081 ; " Rex Walliam Hil>i subjugavit, et de Walensibus, boet ceUsres sint cuntoren et labi solcant de imniicorum manibus, multi- tndo inoumerabilifl capta et in modum porcorum [see above, pp. 507, 644] oocM» eat. Ex hoc nunc, lic«t inviti, fatt-ntur Anglos se in omnibus esse pHHteaitoree." See Lap|>enberg, 182. This seems borne out by the lan- of tbe Chronicler, 1087; " Brytland him waes on gewealde, and he <•— **^<* ^ewmhte, and )*t manncynn mid ealle gewealde." Coapara Wni, Malm. iii. 258, and Hist. Ab. ii. 10. • Brut J Tywyiogion. 1080. 2 .See vol. i. p. 384. Aaa. Camb. 1078, •• Menevia a gentilibus vastata est, et Abraham a gwtflibui occidJtur." ODO ASPIRES TO THE POPEDOM. 681 of this kind, but the British Cliurch now lost its last chap. xxi. trace of indewndence, and the succession of Norman ;.^'"'*5^' * nmt Nor- Bishops of Saint David's hc<^ins. nian Bishop. III5- § 4. The later Legislation of Jniliam. 1082-1086. We are now drawing near to the end of William's reign. ChAr»ct«r In its latest 3'ears En<^lish affairs agnin received that io«2-io86. share of attention at his hands which they had in some measure lost since the death of Walthoof. The continuous history of Eng-land during" these years begins with a great act of justice on the part of the King. The pride and Pride and oppression of Odo, Bishop and Earl, had grown to such of odo. ° a height that William's policy and his better nature both led him to put a stop to them. The special atrocities which had distincniished Odo's chastisement of Northum- berland, the extortion of bribes from innocent men, the wholesale execution of men whether innocent or guilty, were deeds such as William in his worst moments had never yet either done or approved. And now a fit of ambition of He aspires a still wilder kind seized on the mind of Odo. It was a papacy. small matter to rule England and Normandy, when, at least in his dreams, the lordship of the whole world offered itself to him.^ A soothsayer had prophesied that the successor of Hildebrand on the Papal throne should bear the name of Odo or Otto.- So, some ages later, a pre- diction of the same kind foretold that the successor of Leo the Tenth should bear the name ol' Hadrian. In both cases a vain ambition was roused in the breast of a prelate who had in one way or another a footing in England, and in both cases the prediction was fulfilled ' Onl. Vit. 646 D. "Odo . . . «[ui cum fratre buo Guilleliuo Rojje Nonnannifl dominahatur et Aii^Um, parvi pcndoiiM poU'statcn et divitiaM regni occidcntalis, niiii jure PaputUD duminarutur latiuM ct omnibus torn- gcuis." * lb. THE LATKR DAYft OP WILLIAM. r til in tiio ixr-'n of anotluT. Iladrinn do Cast4llo Boiiirht lUilnMitW tk^ iivmXU of Poix* I^n) in onliT to varato \]\v throno which, 4»yjiii«1 14 when it wa-* va.^t***!, wan fiUrd hy Hadrian of Utrecht. y!T^|*f *^ \Vr do not find that Odo of Hayoux cons])irod the death ^•i*- ttfOrv^ry the St»ventii, but it seems certain that lie took \Tt% durinj* Grcjjory's life to stH'iire his own succession to the Pontificate which in the end fell to the h.t (A' ifM-t|il. Otto of Ostia, tlic famous Trhan the Second.' He sent P*^— .*^ to Rome ; he bought himself a palace there, he filled it •W» with goodly furniture, and hjMMit lar^e sums in winning ^^. . fivour on the 8jx)t.'- He even designed to cross the Alps at the head of somcthiug" very like an array. Many of iulj. the Normans both in Kngland and in Normandy, among ' them the Earl of Chester himself, were ready to ijlij^ht CoAplidty ... . / I »-> 9ilSmt\ their faith to him and to follow his fortunes.*' Odo was ""'^ just on the point of setting sail for Normandy with a gfreat array, with a view to his further journey southwards. But his schemes by no moans fell in with the views of wnSam hiB King and brother. AVilliam, who w^as in Normandy fai WIgbL "^ ^^^ time, at once set sail for England, and suddenly met Odo in the Isle of AVight."* He there gathered together a meeting of the great men of the realm, so * Odo, Oddo, orOtto. See the Lives of Gregory and Urban in Muratori, ai- 34 7. 351.355- * OrcL Vit, 646 I). *' Romam misit, palatium Hibi emit, senatores Quiriitun magnifl muneribus datia sibi amicitiA copulavit," &c. So Will. MaIid. iii. 377 ; ** Pene jiapatum liomanum absent! a civibus inercatuR perM peregrinorum epi«toliB et nummis infarciens." Both these lU, whAtever we make of the " Kenatores Quirituin," seem to point to dedingn with Uymen rather than clergy. The Hyde writer (296) is •loqnent on the •plendour of Odo's palace. "NVace (14310-14321) Keems to hftTe fiuided that Odo's object was to secure the crown of England after William. * Ih. 646 D. " I Hi, quia Xormanni levcH et extcra videre cupidi Hunt, pn4iBiM pnwomptori Episcopo, cui principatus Albionis et Neuatriae Bon mffioeUU, Mwnsenuit. lagentes quoque fundos quos in occiduis rltanlibui powidebiit deaerere decreverunt, ac ut praefato praBsuIi trans Pa4am eomHarentar per 6dem spoponderunt." * lb. 647 A. WILLIAM ACCL'SES ODu. 683 many, we may suppose, as could be p^ot tog^ether at a chap, xxi, moment's notice.' Before lluiu William made his com- He plaint a«^ainst liis brother. Before he crossed the sea, he ^},g ^^J^j^. had entrusted the crovernment of Enj^land to the care ''^y- of Odo." The troubles of his continental dominions, the revolt of Maine, the revolt of his son, had occupied his own attention, while Odo ruleil in his name in Enj^pland. That rule had been a rule of oppression to all ; Odo had shown himself a tyrant to the whole realm. He had oppressed the poor, he had spoiled the Church, a thing which specially grieved William's heart when he thought of all the good and pious Kings who had gone before him, and who had enriched the churches of England for purposes far other than those to which their wealth was applied by Odo. ' Lastly, he had persuaded the King's knights, who were needed at home for the defence of the realm against the Danes and the Irish, to leave their duty and follow him beyond the Alps on vain schemes of winning dominion for himself.^ How, William asked * Ord. Vit. 647 A. " Congregatis in aula regali primoribus regni." '^ lb. " Antequam transfretAiwein in Nonnanniain reginien Angliaj fratri meo liaiocensi Episcopo corumendaveram." The Chronicler (1087) flay.s to the same effect, " He hit-filo eorlJom on Eiiglelande, and honne se cyng wsea on Normandige, bonne waes he mjegeste on ))isuni lande." This, I HUppose, refers to a conuniiwion later than that held by Lanfranc at the time of Ralph's rebellion, though William of Maliucsbury (iii. 277) says, " Hie totiuH Angliae vicedominua sub Rege fuit post necem Willelmi filii 0«bemi." ' lb. 647 B. " Fratcr meua Angliam vehenientcr opprosait . . . violcntor opes diri])uit, crudeliter paui>ere8 opprcHsit ; frivol^ ape militea mibi aurripuit, t^jtiimque regnuni injuatis exactionibus concutiena exaptavit." It is curious to see how Thierry ^ii. 86) colours all this. Odo is accuaed " d'avoir nialtraite leM Scufowi outre inesure, an grand damjer de Ui cause commune." So he translatea ** niilitos . . . »jui Angliam tutari debuerant " by " IcH guorriem sur la foi desipiels rejH>sait le saint enicnseH ut alioa hoitcs nuhi niniis infestoa." The mention of the Irish should be taken in Connexion with the rumour s|>okun uf at an earlier stage. (;$4 THE LATER DAYS OP WII.MAM. emAf 111 vi i\i» 1^ -rl»t he to ilt'al willi hinli :i lir<»tlier Th« A«embly remain«Ml siltMit. None dared to i>n)- DOttDoe tenienoe on such a rriminal. Then the Kin^ himielf ipokc af^in. Wlu-n one man, ho naid, diHtnr])8 the common weal of the whole land, he bliould not he •pAivd out of any personal favour. Ho hade his Uaions wmn Odo and put him in ward. IJut there was no man >riiliMi there who dared to lay hands on a Hisliop. Then AVilliam H^ -# teiicd his brother with his own liands. *' 1 am a clerk/' '^^^^ cried Odo, "and a minister of the Lord. It is not lawful iVibopof to condemn a Hishoj) without the Bentence of the Pope." Then answered William — the subtle mind of Lanfranc having, it is said, su^^ested the distinction — " I meddle not with clerks and Prelates. I do not seize the Bishop of Bayeux, but 1 do seize the Earl of Kent. I seize my Earl whom I set over my Kin«^dom, and I demand of him an account of the stewardship which I committed to him." * While the comi)laints of the Bishop of Bayeux ojo un- were thtis unheeded, the Earl of Kent was carried off to Knlll* ** Normandy and was kept in ward in the castle of Rouen.^ His imprisonment was heard of with great indignation by Vain Inur- the Pontiff whom he had hoped to succeed. Gre<^ory, in his Gra^orr. private correspondence with IIu<^]i Archbishop of Lyons, used very strong* language indeed as to the insolence ' I tnuuUt« Orderic. The same HUtry is told by William of Malmesbury (HL a77).aod in another jilace (iv, 306) he attributes the distinction to tlie pronpUng of Lanfranc. The utne dintinction wm drawn when the Chancellor Bishop of Ely ■Mad the Bi*hop of Durham in 1 190. See Ricliard of the Devizes, p. 13. ■ Ord. Vii, 647 C ; Ann. Wint. 1082. " Fiscatis omnibus quae habuerat, is evcercm tnudt, ubi, ri voluit, delicta sua deflevit." Cf. Domesday, 375. • Ipn [Odo] h*bebat ea die qua fuit ciptus, et postea fuit disaaisitus." Thk docs not imply any general conBscation. See Ellis, i. 5. William d Matiwbury (iii. 377) haa a wonderful story abuut the treasures of Odo ludden in bag* at the bottom of rivers, which seems to come from the MM* miat a« the kindred legends about Stigand. WILLIAM AKKESTS TIIK KMU. OF KKN'T. 685 which the Kiiif'' of the En«^lish showeil — certainly not chap. xii. for the first time — in puttinp;' a priest in prison. To William himself he used milder lani^uaf^-e, hut he had nothino;' to urf^^e in Odo's favour heyond the stock passages of Scripture which were held to forhid the laying* of pro- fane hands upon the Lord's anointed.' But Wilh'ani was not to he moved, and Odo remained in prison till William's general release of his prisoners on his dcath-hed. The year of Odo's arrest is marked in the English Famine o( Chronicles as a vear of mickle hun<;er.- Next vear * 10S3. came the disturhance hetween Thurstan and his monks at Glastonhury, and the death of Queen Matilda. But the Lej^isla- same year or the next saw the beginning of a series of acts 1083-1086. touching the internal government of England, acts which were of the highest moment both then and aft4,'rwards. These I shall here record simply as events, reserving the discussion of their working and their lasting consequences till we come to consider the last portion of our subject, the results of the Norman Conquest. We first hear of one of Tax laid those heavy direct impositions in money which were so Midwinter specially irksome to the minds of our forefathers. The 1083-1084. King laid a tax of seventy-two pennies on every hide of land in the Kingdom.'* The consequences of this taxation * Ep. Greg., Jaffi*, 570. " Ad notitiam tuam pervenisse non dubitaraua qu&liter Anglorum Rex in fratrem et coepiscopum nostrum Baiocensem contra fa.s et hone.stuni ausus e.st mariuni mittere, eunique contra ro^'iam zuudeiitiam reverentianu^ue Hocerdotalem inipudentc-r cuptuni et intpudcn- tiuH aa8t the occAHJon, an iminwIuiU* militur}' ncH'ttwity. ^Villin^^H hold mi Ungjfttwl ffM DOW AgMn threatened by tlir rival ]K)W(>r of «f Dwunark. The wise Kin^ Swend had now been dead for ftglii vcam. His immediate HUceesBor was bin son Harold, of whom we have already heard as the fellow-soldier of ^ W«lth«»f when York and Northumberland were for a Rdf* oT moment rwt^ued from William'H sway. Of this prince the Sj^ characters g-iven by Danish writers are somewhat con- io;6-io8a tradictorv. In some accounts he appears as slothful and contemptible, while in others he bears the name of a wiae and l)eneficent lawgiver.' lUit whatever was the character of his reipn in Denmark, it had no importance as Wdf^ regards Kn^land. The reig^n of his brother and successor, ^oiy>-'i"'w6 ^ ""^ ^^^^ saint and martyr, was of quite another kind. The conquest or deliverance of J]ngland was one of his Hiifa»cr jn^eat objects. He had himself taken part in two English "KTllnf!' editions. Besides that in which he shared with his ■•^ "*75- brother Harold, he had also borne his part in that vain raid on York which liad been stirred up by Ralph of Norfolk in the year of his revolt.*^ His ill success on those oocaaions rankled in his mind ; -^ his marriag-e with Adela of Flanders * broug-ht him into close alliance with the bitterest continental enemy of William, and he was further 1084. It WM no doubt voted at the Midwinter Gemot of 1083-1084 and levied in the courneof 1084. Matthew Paris (i. 27) s«1(1h, "undediatim portea coBpit, malcdictionibuij super caput huuid congestis, corpore manifeHte drteriofwi.'* On thia tax see voL ii. p. 574. * On Baint Cnot and all that belongB to him the fullest account is to be favod in his Life by >Kthelnoth, Langebek, iii. 375. On Harold's legis- *• *^- P- 34'i and Saxo, 214. See also Swend Aggesson, i. 56, who HuniH up hia character; " Haraldus^ quern ob benig- aoUitiem Cotem [Hein] cognominabant, BucceHeit in regno. Hie primus leges Danis in regia? electionis loco jam dicto praescripsit atque "*f»^*-** * See above, p. 586. Will. Malm. iiL 261. " Veteris repulssp memor." • See above, p. 587. PLANS OF CNUT. 687 calk'd uii t«^ undertake the enterprise by Englishmen who chap. xxi. soui^ht his court, and prayeil him to come and deliver a ^.^JJ'^j^^ kindred people from tlie bondaije in which they were held ^^ ^' . . . , , Englwh by men of Roman speech.^ At last his mind was made up ; exile*. he would go forth with all the might of Denmark, at once to avenge the blood of his kinsmen who had died on Senlac and to assert his own riglits as the successor of his great namesake. The undertaking was planned on a great scale ; Cnut'a a thousand Danish ships are said to have been gathered together in the Limfiord, the inlet which in late times has become a strait, and has thus made the northern part of Jutland an island. Six hundred ships were sent or pro- mised by Cnut's father-in-law, the Count of Flanders.^ Olaf Kyrre too, the pious and peaceful King of Norway, Contingent was stirred up to bear his part in a work tor which a son Kym.-. of Harold Ilardrada might seem to have a special call. Olaf however declined to go in person. He had not Cnut's skill or experience in warfare, nor had the princes of his house found the same luck in their English expeditions as the princes of the house of Cnut. But though he would not go himself, he gladly sent sixty ships to take a share in the enterprise under the command of the Danish King."^ ' The language of .^i^thelnoth, c. xi. (iil. 346), is very remarkable ; " Anglorum gens nohilin.siina . . . Haroldo Rege fortis-simo a Willelmo, Aiutralium Normannonnn Duce, belli insidiirt iiiterempto, ip9«Mjue Willelmo ita demum Anglorum im{>erium vi arripiente, eorumdem, quos supra com- nienioraviTnu.H, Romauorum ren Franrit/etKinim [he had just l)cforo wpoken of** Francigunif ere, si insignissimuni {)rincipeiii Kanutum. cum hui exerritft.i viris, ad ulcisct-udam consanguiuei uccciii. Haruldi ncilicct quondam Kegin, ab eisdem Romania interempti, Brittaniiio: littoribuH agnoviiwut applicaro." ' See the account of the flout in /Ethehudh, c. xiii. ; Onl. Vit. 649 D ; Will. Malm. iii. 361. " ChiXHum, ut acce{iimuH, millu ct uo amplius navium in Angliam parat ; auxilio ei urat socer Kobertus Fritio ttcxcenUirum ratium dominus." Our own Chronicle (1085) alMo btarM witiuHx that Cnut " fundat'arderi ei>rles fultumu of Fhiixlran." * Sec the Saga of Olaf Kyrr<', I>?iing, iii. 1 10. THK LATKtt PAVft OF WILLIAM. tst SmgliDd, or at IcAJft her Kin^-, wn« ihiin t)tn>nt4M)o^l and energ-y best served his purposes. He crowwd over to En«;land at the head of a vast host of soldiers of all kindg of arms, but amon^ whom native Normans HMa«h teem to have formea.-t menn wundredon hu ^'\h land niihte eall |>one hm9 atmlMnJ" Cf. Hurt. Ab. ij, 1 1. ^thelnoth abjo (c. xii., iii. 349) mentions thm mMiKiiinM nith other detaiLi of William's preparations ; " Willelmus, ■fftotaitioiib.ntpotebellicoHUH herrw, non iinperitus, cistra etoppida munire, mur» «i foMi cum propugnaculis castella circumcingere, urbium muros re- 9ann «* one here t,'cond all )>i.s land to hi.s mannon, and hi fieddon bone here »lc be hia land efrie." ' lb. " And men ha-fdon mycel geswinc \>«s geareti, and se cyng lett awcHtan Jwet land abutin \>a mp, het gif hia feond comen upp, \-xt hi na-fdun na on hwam hi fengon awa nedlice.*' ' See vol. iii. p. 435. • See /Kthelnoth, c. xiii. ; Sa.tco, 318. • See the jiccountw of Cnut's death or nuirtyrdoni in ^'Kthelnoth, c. xxvi.- xxviii. ; Sweud Aggcfwon, c. vi.; Saxo, 320. Our Chronicle mentions it under a wrong year, 1087 ; " l^a Dn-neHcnn |io wojm iiTtir gcteald eallra folcra getreowuHt, wurdon aweiido to |>»re meste untriw'Se and to J>am nuraten Bwicdome \>e wfre inihte gewurffan. Hi gecuron and abu^'an to Cnute cynge and him aMan sworon, and Hyfh'f(an hino earhlice ofslogon innan Hnr<< cyrcean." See alao Will. Malm. iii. 3^»i. • See vol. i. p. 44 j. VOL. IV. Y V Tilt LATKK DAYS OP WILLIAM. the nuun (UngtT hntl |uiks4h1 away. I\irt of hin incr- hc kept in Knjflaiul t]jn»u«^^h the winter, l»ut l«ft«f ili» part he let go to their own honu's, ami he kept the Mi»l- •MtaL wiotrr Fea«t at Ctlouee«ter in ]M>aee.* iol|-iot6. Tlie Midwiiit4?r Aasembly of that year was one of the most memorable in our history, ami wr liave a more •••l"''*^ minute record of itu acts tlian we can often recover of the Ada of these ancient Parliaments. The King first held his court for five days with his Witan, discliarging no doubt :*• the formal and the judicial business of the occasion. Then, according^ to the new custom of separatina se cyng geaxode to so'San )>aBt his feond l*!**** w»ron, and ne mihtcn na geforSian heora fare, |>a lett he sum Jwue Mfftt &ren to heora ageoe iande, and sum he heold on J>i8um lande ofer winter." lb. "Da U) J»am midwintre waes se cyag on Gleaweceastre mid his wHan, and beold pter hijj hired v. dagas and siSSan \>e arcebisceop and ftoadode men h«fiien ainod Jreo dagas.*' .See above, p. 393. ' See abore, p. 600. Seeabore, p. 393, The Chronicler gives their names and sees, and "hi «r»ron ealle J»«8 cyngen clerecaH." On these Prelates, see above, PP-375.4»9i4»i- THE GKEAT SLKVEY OUDEHED. 091 land, how it was set and by what men." * Many things chap. xxi. would join together at this time to make ^Villiam seek J^'^.^*^**' for a more full and accurate rejwrt of the state of his ordered. Kingdom than either he or any other prince of his time had ever before thought of asking for. It had perhaps been found no easy matter to levy fairly and accurately the tax of seventy-two pennies on each hide of land. And the threatentnl invasion from Denmark, the immediate fear of which liad passed away but which might easily come again, might well make William anxious fully to know what were the real resources, military and material, of his Kingdom. It was to this end that the thought and speech of William and his counsellors were directed, and the result was Domesday. The great record, the work of our foreign King, stands Domzsdat. as a national possession side by side with the contemporary Chronicle in our native tongue. Each is unique in its Its unique 1 • 1 X'- 1 -1 -1 1 cbanicter own kind, ^o other nation has such materials to draw aud value. upon for its history. Of the nature of the record itself, of the light which it throws upon the laws and manners of the time, I shall speak fully elsewhere. I have now only to speak of its formation as one of the great events of these memorable legislative years. Commissioners went The Com- forth into every- shire in England to make the inquiries theSurvey. which the decree of the Assembly had prescribed. The >°^5-6. whole work was done in the space of a single year,^ and ' Chron. Petrib. 1085. "After JjiMuiu lutf»le He cyiig raycel geOeaht and Hwiffe deope npsce wiiS bis witan ymbe bis land hu hit waTe getett, o06e mid hwilcuu xnannon." The "deep Mpeech," the colio- quium, of our forufathera simply need« translation to become a French J'arlenitnt. ' The Chronicle showa that the order for taking the Survey was made at tlie Midwinter Sesttion of 1085-6. Tlie Colophim of the second volume of Domei*# M s- dilTcrvnt Commisiiioncre wore R'nt to encli. In t)ie case MMMMm. of tome of the midland tthires the names of the Com- miflionerv have Ixvn ])rt«8erved. Those who tk tlie Sunrev in Worcestershire were four in nuniher, and thret' of them are already well known to us. ^^'(• no longer find amon^ them the names of even renegade En^lish- roen, aa in the earlier commission for the redemj)tion of lands.* The four were Romi^ Earl of Buckingham, llcnry of Ferrenj, lord of Tuthury and of Fifhide, and Adam, one **•«'•"' of the sons of Iluljert of Rye and brother of the Dapifer tM9 Ml* be rei'lvcnied *' tripliciter, scilicet tempore Rej^s i^duanli, et quando Rex Willelinus dedit, et (pio- hkkIo nit mwlo, et si potest plu.s habcri qu.ini habeatur." Tlie nanifs «>f the jurors are a good study of nomenclature. One of the first is *' Rod- bertUM Anglicu.'j." * I translate the well-known pojwaj^e under the year 1085. Tlie latter part is wonderfully vigorous ; " Hit is sccame to tellanno, ac hit ne jiuhte him nan Hceame to doiine, an oxe ne an cii ne an nwin un-n belyfon, \>:vt Dses geiuct on his gewrite. And rallr |>a gewrita wwrt^n gebroht to him sy/^iSan." Tlie Survey, I need hardly say, i^ recorded by all writers, giKxl and bad. One of the most curious account.-^ is in T. Ituill»(>nu\ Angl. .Sacr. ' Flor. Wig. 1086. •* Vexata est terra multis cbulibus inde pro<>}- dentibuii." THB LATKR DAYS OK WIM.IAM, cmw iM wpreAowTk in the next year. While the proat inquiHition wrnn piinjf on Wilhain nlxxle in Kii^liind. lli In Id Iuh \vv UMfl Maiitrr Ft^nt II* uuuttl at Winrhrhter, and Ins Pi'iit^voHtal Fea»t nt \Votiiiin»ter ; and at the last nieetinj,'' he (hihhed IO0&. «e r^#c jjjj vounirt'ut Hon, the -^^thelinc: Menn', to rider or kni^rht.' loi* But the f^ateit Assembly of this year was held at an l|««fT unimual time and in an iinnsual idacc. lU' Lamniastido kat^ki. the Great Survey wa.s made. AVilliam now knew how JVf^r^ this land was set and by what men. It would seem Hint .'oJj io(»6. the summer months had been passed by liim in g'oin;,'' to and fro;^ the process of taking* tlic Survey, and the disturbances to which the incjuirics g-ave rise, may well have called here and there for his personal presence. rum^tt oT And now a Mickle Gemot indeed was held, not within \»««.i t, or without the walls of any city, but on the great plain where William had once before reviewed his victorious army after the Conquest of England was over. * All the Witan, and all the landowners of England who were worth summoning, were gathered together at Salisbury. The royal quarters were doubtless fixed in the castle on the hill where Osmund's minster was rising/ while tlie plain itself was well fitted for the encampment and assembling of a body whose numbers were handed down by tradition as no less than sixty thousand.'' In this great meeting" • f'hron. retrib. ioS6. "He ilubliade his Bunu Ilenric to ridere bacr." We Havc lo«t the word rider = Hitter, chevalier, in thiH sense, one which was ■ot yet taken by hnifjht. The religious part of the ceremony was per- fonned by Lanfranc. Ord. Vit. 665 D; " Hunc Lanfrancus, dum juvenile TtHWr attiogere vidit, ad arma pro defensione regni sustuiit, eumque loric^ ifuluit ct galeam capiti ejus imposuit, eique ut Jiegis Jilio et in regali stein- matt naUt militia} cinj^lum in nomine Dfimini cinxit." ' lb. "SyfifJan he ferde abutan swa t»aet he com to Lammaessan to • 8m abore. p. 318. ♦ See above, p. 418. Clmm. Petrib. 1086. " J?.»?r him comon to his witan and ealle )?a MMiittcnd« men \>e ahtes waeron ofer eall Engleland, waeron ^aes mannes ■•O K hi weron." The " witan" and the ordinary " landsittende men" •!» b^gianing to be di«tingtiiahed, the germ of Lords and Commons. The GEMOT OF SALISBURY. 095 a decree was j)a.ssed which is one of the most memoral)h* chap. xxi. pieces of leg-ishition in the whole history of Eng-land. ^^a^ute to In other lands where military tenures existed it was mtn the beg-innini^ to be held that he who had j)lig'hted his faith King, to a lord who was the man of the Kino; was the man of that lord only, and did not become the man of the Kin^ himself.' It was beg-inninfj to be ludd that, if No duty such a man followed his immediate lord to battle a^inst countries the common sovereis-n, the lord mie faithful to him a^inst all other mm."* The great work of William's roi^n was to make Bngbuid for ever after an undivided Kingdom. It was on that day that thin great work was put into the formal •hape of a written law. William had thus l>oth rompleted and Rocured his con- quest. He had not oidy conquered the land, hut he luid conquered the tendencies to anarchy and division wliicli lurked Iwth in the old institutions of the land and in the new institutions which he had himself brought in mod fostered. His work in England was now done, and he left his island Kingdom never to come back to it. But, before he went, he haeah he dyde aerest aefter his gewunan, •wiUe mjcelne soeatt of bis man nan, J)aer lie mihte aenige teale to e(We mid nhte otSiSe ellea." • fim rc\. i. p. 480. William's last tax. 697 in g'athering', William aboilo in the li-le of Wig'ht ; he then chap. xxi. crossed over into Normandy with his newly extorted treasure. It was perhaps a sig-n of the times that the Eaore, cHto Eadj^'nruH, lic" ntiA a IXr^v irnpctrat/l cum cc. militihua man' tranwiit, et Apuliam aAYS oK WII.LIAM. of; »iieb mighty tiuindrrin^ nnd li^^htonin^ wnn thorn UiAt il »lcw many mon, and over it prrw worst' with mm morr and more."' Of tho last yoar itK^lf the |)irturo is yet inorp fwirful. It nootlx nil tho stn'n^-th of our nncirnt tOBfftie to aot forth tho full horrors of such n tiin(>. " It WM ft ^f^TV hoa\*>* yonr and a year of iiii;»'lity picknoBs in *lhi« land. Such disease came upon men tliat wrll ni^li fTTiT other man waa in tho worst ovil, and (hat so stronj^ly that manv mon dioil of tho e^^l. Thon camo thoro throuLcli the mickle tdorms of which wo have before told such mirkle hunger over all Kng-land that many mon died Mdlvthrouf^h tho hunj^r. Alas, how sad and rueful a tide was that ! Tlien the wretched mon lay driven full ni^h to death, and thon camo tho shai*]i huno^or and quite slew them. Who is there that may not feel sad for such a tide? or who is so hanl of heart that he would not weep F%«ifai over such evil luck?"- Il was a yoar too of public mis- fortunes of other kinds. London and other towns had been humod not many years before,^ and now Saint Paul's minbter was again burned with the most and best part of the city, and many other minsters were burned and well nig-h all the head towns in England.* But the horrors of storm, fire, pestilence, and hunger w^ere not all ; it was a year marked by wars and fightings, by the crimes of men • C*hron. Petrib. 1086. The Chronicler a8e8 }>e WQlcUn weolde an€rendlic gear on Jjissum lande." Then foUowH the d«aerip(lon which I bare tried to modernize in the text. But our modem ■p>th Cub utterly l>c«ide that of our fathers. • CVoa. Wig. 1078, Petrib. 1077. Chmn. Petrib. 1087. The fire in I>ondon, besides the minster, burned "hrt iDKst« d»l and hset rottexte call \>sfTe burh." Besides London, - foHmm ftilliiMh ailc beafod port on eallon Englelande." WONDERS OF WILLI AM's LAST YKAlt. 699 and by the deaths of men of renown. The wondtTs of chap. xxi. the year seem to have so deeply stampetl themselves on men's -"^"Fipo*©*! . , . . cove, p. 689, for tlie real date of Ciiut'.s death in 10^6. ' On this, the only reference to Spanish affairs in our Chronicles, see Mr. Earle's note, p. 354. The Chronicler seems t<> have confounded the con- quest of Toledo by Alfonso in 1085 with his defeat in 1086 or 1087. ' Chron. I*etrib. 1087. " Eac on ^isan ilcan lande on ^ani ilcan gearo forOferdon manega rice men." He then counts up the Prelates mentioned in the text. On Stigand, see above, pp. 409, 418 ; on Scotland, p. 41 3 ; on Thurstan, p. 388 ; on /Klfsige, p. 39O. F(>r the like remarkable deaths in Nonnandy, see below, p. 705. ' lb. "And ^a heora eallra hlaford, Willelm Englwlandes cyng. he wo Kr beforan enibe spwcon." I think this is tht; earliest use of the strictly territorial style in Knglish. See vol. i. p. 84. ' See Ord. Vit. ^>55 H. The homage of the reigning Count Drogo, the »onin law of /Ethelreour. The King of the P^nglish, he said, lay in at Rouen, and there would doubtless be a grand display • OnL Vit. 655 D. " Majoribufl Hibi curia in Cjenomannenses vel Anglos erwcMiUbus oonticuit, et contra Henricum dominum suum seu Philij)j)uin flhun ejtu pro Vulcawino pago arroa levare iliHtuliu" • Ord. Vit 655 A. • lb. ** Nwi juj Ruum sibi reddatur, terribilibiis minif) in hostes WilL Malm. iii. 281. " Ventrem potione alleviarat." Wace, 14181 ; •• A Roem etteii k s^jor Ne sai dire combien le tint, U 11 ardt esM maint jor ; Ne pout monter sor son destrier, Um aaCnttf U 11 avint. Armes porter ne guerreier." WILLIAM INVADES THE VEXIN. 701 of candles at his churching'. The wrath of William was chap. xxi. kindled, and he swore one of those fearful oaths by which, ^Villiam'a auHwcr. and by his very look, he was wont to strike terror into men. By the resurrection and sjilendour of God, he would, when he rose up again and went to mass, light a hundred thousand candles at the expense of King Philip.^ He kept William .. ., , •iiinA 1 1 enters tho his word ; aljout tlie middle ot August, when the corn was Vexin. in the fields, and the grapes in the vineyards, and the , yl""'' apples in the orchards,^ he led forth his troops to gather in the rich spoil of the fruitful season. All was laid waste; His all was overthrown ; the thought of mercy passed utterly away from William's mind ; the ruin and deaths of multi- tudes were to pay for the insult offered to him by their King.'^ At last he reached Mantes itself. The defenders William of the town had come forth to see at least, if they could Man7ea. not hinder, the harrying of their fields ; friends and foes August 15, io8: ' Philip's jest, such as it is, is given in two or three forms in William of Malmesburj- (iii. 281), Wace (14187), R. Wendover (ii. a8), M. Paris (i. 33). William preserves one very characteristic feature of William's answer; " Taliu per resuiTectionem et splendurem Dei pronuntians, quod Boleret ex industria talia sacramenta facere, quae ipso liiatu oris terrificum quiddam auditorum mentibu.s insonarent." Wact- Ci4'97) niake.s the answer run ; " Quant jo, distil, releverai, Mille chandeles li oferai, Dedenz sa terre k mease irai, Lumeigiions de fust i ai-a, Riche offrende li porterai, E fer pot feu en som luira." ' Will. Malm. iii. 282. ** Quando et segetes in agris, et botri in vineis, et poma in viridariis." Tliifi surely comes from a balhul. Orderic, 655 D, gives us the fact in prose, when ho speaks of the " conculcatio segetum et exstirpatio vincunmi." But, comparing William of Malmesbury and the Chronicles, it wouUl seem that Orderic i.s wrong in placing the beginning of the exjH-'dition in the hmt week of July. ' The reflexion is from William ui Malmesbury, iii. 282 ; "Omnia pro- terit, cuncta jwipulatur ; nihil trat quo «•> wu.liam. m^t 111. [mi— 11 thrtMi^h the ^tcs to^'thcr,' nnd now tho candles of William'* churvhinjf wcn^ lij*'htotl in all their bri^'htness. He bad rfarluxl n H|K)t wliich hnd lM>on niem()rat)l(* on two oooaakms in his earlier life. Mantes had Imcm the town where the hosU of Km nee were j^iiithered (or that grcmi invasion of Normandy whieh had heen brought to Doagfat on the day of Mortenier.' It was the town whose princcfl he had bwn long" Ix'fore suspectcHl of having made •wav with by the help of the poisoner's bowl.'' The city of Waltrr and Biota wa« now tlie border fortress of France, and the helpless burghers paid the penalty for the silly Vum jmis of their Kin^. To the utter ruin which William's ^Uarnhm. hand wrou^jht that day it is owin^that not a trace survives which can be assigned to his a^e or to the ages before him. The noble church whose two lofty towers of open work attract the eyes of every passer by may have risen •lowly from the ground l»y the help of the posthumous bounty of the rejx'ntant destroyer.* But there is not a •tone in its soaring arcades which can lay claim to a date within a centur}' after William's fatal visit. The other orna- ments of the town, the civic palace, the tower of another church whieh has wholly perished, belong to days later •till. On that day all was destroyed ; the candles blazed merrily ; the houses and goods of the citizens perished ; the churches were burned, and holy recluses, who deemed it a crime to leave their cells even at such a moment, were burned with them.'^ William's heart was gladdened by * Ord. Vit. 655 D. " Cum exercitu suo Mandantum ex improviMO venit, •t cum CMtremihuj raixtim intravit ; militeH enim occulte exierant, ut vide- rwt ooocnicationem segetuni suarum et ex8tir])ationem vinearum, quas Asedhraa Goelluji pridtc quam Rex advenisset cum Nonuannoruin viribus <*•''■■••*«»*. Imiens itaque exercitus Regis cum oppidanis portas partnuMdrii." ■ 8m toI. iii. p. I48. » lb. 207. ♦ See below, p. 707. • Ord«ric (655 D) Menu to wwh to clear William from the guilt of the bomiiig; " Exercitiu . . . per rabiein armigerorum immisso igne caatrum cum Mrleviin el skHIiuk cofnbuHgit ; " but tlie Chronicle and William of WILLIAMS DEATIl-WOL'NU. 703 the sig^ht ; he rude on, and bade his men heap on fuel to chap. xxi. make the flames burn yet more bravelv. Rut at that Wiiiiain* moment his horse stumbled, some say on the brink ot" a diteh, some say on the burnin*^ embers ; the body of the bulky King was thrown forward against the tall iron pummel of his saddle ; he kept his seat, but the pain of the blow was such that his eagerness was (pienched, and he ordered a retreat to be sounded.' The Conqueror had now received his death- wound. It was an unworthy fate indeed for one who had so often braved death in so many nobler and more awful shapes to fall at last by such an ignoble chance as the stumble of his horse among the burning embers of Mantes. And yet poetical justice itself might well be satisfied when the mighty warrior and ruler, who, with all his crimes, had never before stooped to mere useless and brutal havoc, Malniesbury seem to make it his own work. The Chronicle, followed by Florence, speaka of two male reclused tis burne«l ; " Ami forbeamde )>a burli Mahante, and ealle pa halige niynstres )>e wseron iunon piere burh, and twegen halige menn \>e hyi-sumedon Code on ancer settle wuuiende peer wajron forbeamde." In William they become " reclusa una, qua; spehieum Buum ncc in tali nccensitate de:>ercndum putavit." ' Will. Malm. iii. 232. " Quo 8ucces»u exhilaratus, dum suos audaciu^ incitat ut igni adjiciant pabula, propius flammiis succedens foci calore et auctumnalis a)8tQi4 inaMjualitate morbum nactus est. Dicunt quiilam quod pr»;ruptam fori.sam rionq>e.s tran.silien^i interauca setMorid ruperit, quod in auteriori parte sellae venter protuberabat." The other version comeH from Wace, 142 13 ; " I'armi la vile tre«pa«aout Par gnint air avant sailli, Sor un cheval ke mult amout, Li Heia ne tint k'il ne chai. En un ansiz uiLtt hcs dous piez, Kt il |Kir co mult He bleca Maist tost Ics out h aei Hachiez ; A Hon arfon u il hurta." Tliu tall rta«ldle-lxjW8 bhown in the TaiKJutry will be remembereoru chunorlH (juo suoh exhortjiliatur, ut fortur, arvin& intestinonmi ejus liquefactu, inhnnari nun nxKlice rd-pit." Orderic (656 A) in vaguer still, but the t-pithct which ho uses is n<>t without meaning; "Tunc ex nimiu ;i •>tu at ly^borc pinyuumimiM Hex GuilUlmus iufirmatuH «-st." •01 TUB LATKK DAYS OF WIKMAM. .mjkr 111. bad to par hi« life m tlie iH*nalty for thiiH lowering liimHclf lU H to ihr lovi'l of mcanrr inrn.' Faint and HuflVrinf,' from the •lux'k «mi fn>m the intornal woinul, AVilliiini tum«Ml •wjiv from his M'homw* of venpoanco, and, instrad ^A'' carninff hi« wujitinjf arms any furtlu-r witlnn tlir ilo- tninionii of his overlord, he was himself borne, a bick or nther a dyinj»' man, to Rouen. There he first took up hit quarters in the jwlaoc, hut presently, finding; the noise mild bustle of the eapital too much for his sinking- frame, bo caused himsidf to be moved out of the city to thr Priory of Saint Gervase. which stands on the hill overlooking' Rouen from ihe west. There a crypt, the oldest ecclesiastical work to be seen north of the Alps, a crj'pt already ancient in ^Villiam's days, covers the remains of some of the earliest apostles of northern Gaul. There was the tomb of the British Mellon, the first Hishop of the metropolitan see of Normandy, and there the Norman lord of all Britain, who had so lately received the submission of Mellon's native land, came to spend the short span of life which was still left to him on earth. '^ There William lay for several weeks of sickness and pain ; but he never to the hour of his death lost either the pos- rion of his senses or his full command of speech.^ We * Cliron. Petrib, 1087. " Reowlic J^ing he dyde, and reowlicor liim friaiDp. Hu reowlicor! Him geyfelade, and J>8Bt him stranglice eglade. Hw«-t mvg ic totiUan ? Se Kcearpa deafl |>e ne forlet ne rice menn ne bcane, teo bine gcnam." Men seem almost to have doubted whether the Concjucrrir waji Mubject to HicknesH and death like <»ther men. * Ord. Vit. 656 A. "Quia strepitUA Rothoinagi, quae populoBa civitas «i4) iaUAenJbih* erat sgnitanti, extra urbem ipHe Rex praecepit He efferri ad •oei6iiun SAOCti Gervaaii in coUe sitam occidentali." I know of no reason to doabi the rant antiquity of the cryjit. On Saint Mellon or Melan, eee ^^"'••^ 557* .*5^» ^'"t he fteems U) make him a Roman. The common tradUioo nuikes him a Briton, and he has a church dedicated to him in Moomoothahire. lb. " In acgritudine suA u.ortui .sunt, (jui lerumniw dcsolatu' regionis ac defensoro carcntifl non viderunt." * See alxivo, p. 159, and Appendix R. vol.. IV. /. z fOC TIIK I.ATRIl DAYS OP Will. I AM. iti MMUlwhilc Ri»ho|i« ami Ahhotn mid other )irrii itt«. towmfftln others, he had ever \>vv\\ meek and lowly.- Of all the Pn»latr8 of Normandy, the one to whom William's UMWjfhtK first turna godan men niman »flor heora g(xlne*we and fortleone w«^ he ub lett to heofonan rice." ' Qpd. V'it. 656 B. ** Sapiens heroa in futurum sibi multiAcjue commoiii in the pntli of onlrr.' N vi TTimiiij thr rule OTfT them niuHt l>y nil Inw {mHit to Robert. Ilobort wmM hi« cidett bom; he hiul {Yniinim'd Itiin (ho Norman purccmon bofon* he won the Crown of Kii^'lanil, and he had rtr»MV«l the homa^ of tlie Harons of the Duchy. Normandy and Maine niunt therefore pass to Koln^rt, and for them he must l)0 the man of the French Kiii^. Vet he well knew how Bad would be the fate of the land which had to be ruled by one so proud iitid foolish, and for whom a career of shame and sorrow wiu^i surely doomed.^ But what was to be done with England ? Now at last the heart of ^Villiam smote him. To Kn«^land he dared ' not appoint a successor ; he could only leave the disposal of the Island realm to the Almighty Ruler of the world. The evil deeds of his past life crowded upon his soul. H« oa». Now at last his heart confessed that he had won England fans kk iiMto- ^y ^^ riff^** ^y ^^ claim of birth; that he had won the J^^^Baf- Eiigligh Crown by wron^, and that what he had won hj wron^ he had no right to give to another.^ He had won his realm by warfare and bloodshed ; he had treated the sons of the English soil with needless harsh - neaa; he had cruelly wronged nobles and commons; he had spoiled many men wrongfully of their inheritance; * Ord- Vit. 656 D. " Normanni. bi bono riyidoque dominatu reguntur, ■IraBiiiMuni aunt," Ac. The passage Ih verKified by ^V.1ce, 14239. * What Onlcric (659 B) gives more fully is Bummed up in the expressive wonU of William of Malmesbury (iii. 282), " Normanniam invitun et ttmetoB Kolxdlo delc-gavit." * The whole pasitage in Orderic Hhould be read. The particular expres- iiaiw— which Wace versifies and ahridgeH — are doubtleHS his own, but we ■•ad BOt doabt that he expresses a genuine tradition as to William's djing ctaie of mind. The words " Non enim tantum decus hsereditario jure i" are specially emphatic. But the words of Wace (14267) are ■tOl: Eag^cierre cosqaia h tort, E 90 ke j'ai a tort toleit, A tort i out maint hoem mort, Oh jo n'en aveie nul dreit L«i mn en ai k tort ods, Ne dei mie k men filz doner, E k tort ai U regno pri« ; Ne "k tort nel' deit Writer." HIS DISPOSAL OF HIS DOMINIONS. 709 he hail shiiii countless multitudes by hunger or by the chap. xxi. sword. The harrying of Northumberland now rose up before his eyes in all its blackness. The dying man now told how cruelly he had burned and i)lundered the land, what thousands of every age and sex among the noble nation which he had conquered had been done to death at his bidding.* The sceptre of the realm which he had won by so many crimes he dared not hand over to any but to God alone. Yet he would not hide his wish He wiahea that his son William, who had been ever dutiful to him, ji^j,, , ' miffht reign in Enj^land after him. He would send him f';'^*^*-'^^ beyond the sea, and he would pray Lanfranc to place the cro\vn upon his head, if the Primate in his wisdom deemed that such an act could be rightly done.'- Of the two sons of whom he spoke, Robert was far His be- away, a banished rebel ; William was by his bedside. By money to his bedside also stood his youngest son, the English ^^^''y- ^theling, Henry the Clerk. "And what dost thou give to me, my father ?'' said the youth. "Five thousand pounds of silver from my hoard/' was the Con(|ueror's answer. " But of what use is a hoard to me," said Henry, " if I have no place to dwell in? " " Be patient, my son, and trust in the Lord, and let thine elders go before thee." ' He winds up his confesxiou witii the words (659 C), "Sic multa millia pulcerrirase gentis senum juvenumque, proh dolor, funestus trucidavi." ' Onl. Vit. U.S. " Guillfhmiin tilium nieiiin, qui niihi a prinuH anni« 8emiH.T udhicsit et inilii pro posse suo per omnia libeutcr ohedivit, opto iu Spiritu Dei diu valere, et in regni solio, si Dei voluuta« est, feiiciter fulgere." Wace (14375) adds, " Maiz ultro nicr ri-uverrai, Si il le pot fere par raison, A rArclic've«ito pr^irai Jo preie k" il en face le don." Ke la corone li otreit ; I do not see that such an expression as that of Florence (1087), " filio suo Willelnio regnum tradiy the false Ingulf. See the note in Taylor's Wacc, 274. •10 TMI LATRK DAY8 O? WII.MAM. c«Ar nt. It u |*»»rlK»p>i l»y tin* li^-ht of Intor ovi-nts that our )U fM«» ekninicltT p>«'»* on to make Willinm toll hin youn^ost son Uwmn\ tlwit the lUv would (N»nio when ho would Hucceed both grtmu^cmt, 1^1^ bn»tlicni in thoir dominions, and would bo richor and mifHiti*^ ^^**" either of thorn.* Tho Kin^- tlu'u di(tat«Ml A Icdl^r to Lnnfranc, settini; forth IiIh wishes with rogiird to the Kin^Iom. lie Kcalod it and ^j^dw it to his son H< »rr i. WilliAm, and baote8tate pra'6tH]>iM." This, I eoofm, luM a legendary nound, and Wace (142N2) suljMtituteH Homething quite diflcrvnt, njunely a recommeudation of Henry to his brothers ; *' Kt A Guillalme ci comant Igui come il n'a en chierte, Kt k Ilribort I'altre filz mant, Face Henria riche h manant K»- cheftcun en Ha poe«U5, Plus ke home de li tenant." Baiott 095^0 vemificH Orderic. The bequest of money to Henry standH 0«t pUtnly in the Chronicle ; " 8e hridda het Heanric, \>ntn He fijeder becwa^ gOTHUuan unateallendlice." William of MalmeHbury (iii. 282) ways, "pos- atminmm uuLU-nvm Henrico delegavit," Thiw agrees with what Orderic said lr» Ord. \ it. 659 D. " Henricus festinavit . . . munitura gazophylacium •ibi procurar«." Ill: JIKLEASES HIS PRISONERS. 711 captives of Ely, Roger the rebel Earl of Hereford, and chap. xxi. lastly, William's own brother Odo, once Earl of Kent and still IJishop of Bayeiix.' He granted the prayer. Let the Hew will- captives only swear that they would not disturb the peace leaaeallex- either of England or Normandy,- and all should come *^®^'' ^^"" forth, save one alone. Odo he would not nlease. The man whom he had imprisoned for the common weal of his Kingdom, the oppressor of the people, the plunderer of the Church, the man of pride and lust and cruelty, should not be set free by him. He spoke as the father of his people, knowing that, if Odo were once more let loose to trouble the world, tlic ruin of thousands would follow.-^ Yet once more the men who stood around Wil- liam^s bed, first among them Odo's own brother, Robert of Mortain, prayed for the pardon of his brother. They He is per- daringly pledged themselves for Odo's reformation, and release William gave orders that Odo should be set free, again protesting that the death and ruin of many would follow.' The last earthly acts of the Conqueror were now done. Death of He had striven to make his peace with God and man, septemher and to make such provision as he could for the children 9' 'o^?- ' Florence (1087) gives the list, Odo, Morkere, Roger, Si ward B.ini, ami Wulfnoth, with the addition, " oinnes quos vel in Angliil vel in Nonuanni;l custwliaE nianciparat." He afterwards mentions Wulf, and the hostage Donald the 8<>n of Malcolm. Orderic strangely fancied that llalph of Wader was in prisun lus well as Roger. Tlie only way to reconcile his story hero (660 A) with his account of the lifelong imprisMnnient of Roger (see above, p. 592) is t«j snppoHo that he was formally relea.sed and im- prittoned again, as waA certainly the ca^e with Wulfnoth and Morkere. ' Onl. Vit. 660 A. "Nexi tali tenoro de aircere proce "K WILLIAM. uu. and the ■ubjecit \vhom he loft hrhiml liiin. And now his Ijut hour was come. On n Thursday morning in Sop- lnnl»rr. when the win had alrmdy rison ui>on the earth, the finind of the grmt l^oH of the metr(>i>ohtan ininHt4'r •truck on the caw of the dyin^ Kinp.^ He m^n^l why H •ounded. He waa told that it ran^ for prime in the church of Our Lady. ^Villia^l lift^nl his eyes to heaven, be ftretched forth his hands, and spake his last words ; "To my Lady Mary, the holy Mother of God, I eom- mend mjself, that by her holy j)rayerH she may reconcile me to her deer Son our Lord Jesus Christ." He ])raycd, and hiB eoul peased away. William, King* of the Eng-lish and Duke of the Normans, the man whose fame has filled the world in his own and in every following age, had gone the way of all flesh. No Kingdom was left him now but hif seven feet of ground,^ and even to that his claim was not to be undisputed.^ The death of a King in those days came near to a break-up of all civil society. Till a new King was chosen and crowned, there was no longer a power in the land to protect or to chastise. All bonds were loosed; all public authority was in abeyance ; each man had to look to his own as he best might. No sooner was the breath • I tnuuUie Ordnic. He fixes the time (660 D) ; " Quinto idua Septem. fcri4 T. jiun Phcebo per orbem spargente clara radionim Hpicula, excitus Rex MMmm majorb si^^ audivit in metropolitanu basilica." So the Chronicle ; **He0W«ftltoD Nonnandige on t>one nextan dieg sefter Nativitaa See Marie." WUUjud of Jumi^gM (vii. 44) placcH it a day earlier. • Chron. Petrib. 1087. " Eala hu leas and hu unwrest is {jyases middan- mr^t» weU. Se ►• wwi aerur rice cyng and maniges landes hlaford, he ma/dt ^ eaUm ltmde$ hmUm Hofon fot mini [see voL iii. p. 365], and se \>g hwilon gMcrid mid golde and mid gemmum he laeg }>a oferwrogen ■Mtidao." Orderic (661 6) has a lamentation to the same general but fw lea term. • Will. Malm, ili, 183. •• Varietatis humanae tunc fuit videre miseriam, good bono Ule, totiiii olim Europae honor, antecessorumque suonim omnium r, ■edem eiem;*? requiescionis sine calurania impetrare non potuit.'' DEATH UF WILLIAM. 713 out of William'd body than the great company which liad chap. xxi. patiently watched around him during the ni«^ht was scattered hither and thitlier. The great men mounted ConfuMion their horses and rode with all speed to their own homes, dtiith of to guard their houses and goods against the outburst of ^^ »l^'*i"- lawlessness which was sure to break forth now that the land had no longer a ruler. Their servants and followers, seeing their lords gone, and deeming that there was no longer any fear of punishment, begun to make spoil of the royal chamber. Weapons, clothes, vessels, the royal Plunder bed and its furniture, were carried off, and for a ^vhole ^f hiaat- day the body of the Conqueror lay well nigh bare on the ^"^^»^- floor of the room in which he died.^ The men of Rouen Fear of th© were struck with fear and amazement, as though a hostile Koueu. army were coming against their city.^ Men took counsel of their wives and their friends what they should do or whither they should flee. They hid their goods or carried them into places of safety. The news of William's death was borne, we are gravely told, the self-same day to banished men in Rome and Calabria. For, so men then deemed, the evil spirit rejoiced, now that the death of the man who had kept the land in peace guve his servants full scope to work their wicked wills. ^ Leg'cnds like these, which set William before us as the Witness one guardian of law and order in his dominions, are in to Wii- truth the noblest tribute to his memorv. Men who had ''^'"'' govern- perhaps cursed his rule while living-, now knew what they nient. happido tripiidiavit, ody of the ?• Jj^** Kinif shoidd Im? borne to (\ien, there to be buried in tlie minster of Saint St*»phen whicli hr ]iims«']f had l)uilt. But how wai* the command to be obeyed':' The Kinj^'s •on* and kinsfolk had p)ne, each man to look after his N«»« uC own. His B4T>'ant8 and otheers had fled away with tiieir •polls. Not a man of his household was ready to do tlie last duty to his master. At last the lionest heart of a plain Nonnan gpentlenian was moved by natural piety. HrHwin A rustic knight, Herlwin by name, a name which is not ^ ^j^^ ** found in the roll-call of the despoilers of England, stood V*" ^ forth to do the work which princes and no])les failed to do. For the love of God and for llic honour of the Norman name, ho was ready to do the last corj)oral work of mercy to his dejMirted sovereign.^ His offer was accepted, and the foremost man of all the world, forsaken by his children and ser>'ants, was borne to his last home by the volun- tary' loyalty of a vassal faithful to his lord in life and death. Zeal ftad 'The funeral pomp, such as could be provided at such Heriwia. • moment, now set forth. It was at the cost of Herlwin that men were hired to wash and tend, to anoint and to embalm, the royal corpse.'^ It was at his cost that * " Geriixium " in Orderic, 66 1 C. I correct " Gervasium " from Camden, BiUiothcca, 34. • Ord. Vit. 661 C. '* Herluinua pa;;'enHiH eques, naturali bonitate coni- ["""xtm est, et curam excequiarum j»ro amore Dei et h(»nore gentiH sua^ ▼inlit«r amplexatuii ert." Herlwin ia mentioned by name by no one else, •loepi Ber .0), who here translateH Orderic. ***• " - ;->re« itaque tt vespilionea ac vehiculum mercede de propnii •omptibuii cunduxit. cadaver Regi« ad portum Sequan* devcxit. HIS BODY TAKEN TO CAEN. 716 a carriage was found to boar the corpse to the haven of chap. xxr. Rouen, whence, i)artlv hv wiiter, partly bv land, his i)iou8 deception «>f the Ixxly care watched over the doad Conqueror, till he reached the at ( aeo. haven of Caen, where his faithful bedesmen were ready to receive him. Abl>()t Gilbert stood at the head of his con- The vent, accompanied by a crowd of eler«»-y and a smaller body pnKjeasion. of laymen.^ They met the bier of the great King with all reverence, and beff:in the funeral procession towards the Abbey of Saint Stephen. But the luneral rites of William were to be gone through with as little of order and quiet as his crowning rites. At Westminster his crowning rites had been disturbed by a fire wantonly kindled. At Caen Fire at a like misfortune, but seemingly accidental in its origin, disturbed the rites of his burial. As the procession was on its way, flames were seen to burst from a house, and the fire soon spread itself through a large part of the town. The crowd that followed the bier, clergy and laity alike, impositumque navi usque Cadomum per aquam et aridam perduxit." Benolt (39746) translates Orderic, but Wace's account (14374) is different, wliich is the more to be noticed, because he so often follows Orderic ; " Dune fu la novele espandue Li con* unt niul bel conrte, E la gent fu grant acorue, Overt est, oint, et embasme. E li Eve-ske h 11 Riron A Caem unt li corn j)ort«'', Vinrent o grant proceH«ion; Si com il aveit comaud«5." William of Jumi^gea (vii. 44) simply says, " Translatum est corpus ejus, sicuti ordinaverat, CaA Cadomum est delatum." It is certainly strange if neither the Archbishop nor the Ablwt of Saint Ouen's could find tlie means of doing all that Herlwin is said to have done, yet I cannot bring myself to give up the story of the worthy knight. It is hard to think that any one can have inverjted it, and something to the same effect had plainly reached P^dmer, when he s.iys (Hist. Nov. 13, Selden), " Ab omni homine, sicut acce- pimuH, derelictum cadaver ejus sine omni pompd per Se({uanain naucelhl delatum." ' Ord. Vit. (>^>i I). " Miillitudo clericonim et laiconim adhirsit." William of Malmesbury speaks of " magna fre(|uentia ordiiiatorum, laicorum pauca." ;i^ TUB LATKR DAYS OF WILLIAM. sM^r \U. t/waiiMD. wfn ioon KAtttinxl altnmd to put out t\\o flamcB and (o MTV their hottiet and (^ooegan. A crowd of Norman Prelates had already made their way to Caen to do the last office to their aovereign. They had doubtless hastened, while the humble procesaion of llerlwin had been slowly making* its way by land and water. The holy Primate was there, and the warrior ]5ishops, Geoffrey of Coutances and Odo of Bayeux, already set free from his prison.'- There were the two Gilberts, the learned physician of Lisieux and the eloquent preacher of Evreux.^ There were a crowd of Abbots, some of whose namc^s are well known to us. Nicolas of Saint Oucn's, the son of the last Duke Richard, was there to do his duty to the kinsman who had in some sort supplanted him.* Tliere was Maincr of Saint Evroul, who had received his staff as William was setting forth from England,^ Gerbert, the learned stranger who had taught Ingulf at Saint Wandrille,^ William of Ros, whose works ' Orderic's •ocount of the fire is followed both by Wace and by Benolt. Ordarie hinitilf (661 D) deems the occasion worthy of a piece of Greek, aad telb xu bow the monkii "soma Regis ad coenobialem basilicam psallentes pwdoxaniiit.'' Cf. above, p. 6O0, • Ordefic gives the Ii«t, 661 D. On Gilbert Mjtniinot, see above, pp. 367, 660. Gilbert of Evreux we dtaU cit under directly. • 8ee vol. i. p. 518 ; ii. p. 181 ; iii. p. 380. • 8oe vol. iii. p. 382. « See above, p. 601. HIS BURIAL. 717 may still be seen in the minster of Fecamp,^ and, best and cwap. xxi, most rig"hteous of all that great assembly, already recovered from his sickness, stood the Abbot of Bee, the holy Anselm.2 Of William's children one only was present, Henry the .1 T^ii- TT 11 1-- 1 only son of the ^ritht'hn^ llonry, who by this time, we may deem, Wiiiiam had safely secured his treasure. Robert was still an exile I"^*^"'- in France, and William was looking after his own interests in England.^ By Henry then, his youngest and greatest son, and by the g-reat body of the Norman Prelacy, the body of William was received into liis own church, to seek the last home which, even now, he was not to win without a struggle. In the eastern limb of Saint Stephen's minster, not The tomb, yet the vaster and lighter choir of later days, but the single stern apse of Cerisy or Saint Gabriel, a tomb, between the high altar and the choir, had been made ready to receive the Conqueror's body.* The procession The office enteretl the church ; the bier on which all that was left of William lay was borne along* the nave, between the stern arches and massive pillars which he himself had reared. Tliey reached the choir, then doubtless filling np ' See above, p. 87. ' At the head of the list of Abbots comes " Anselmus Beccensis." Eailiner (Hist. Nov. 13) tells us, " Et quidein Willielmus ita mortuus eat : non tainen, nt dicitur, inconfessus : at«jue Anselmus evestijjfio est ab infir- mitate relevatus, pristiua^que saluti jMist modicum rudonatud." ' Will. Gem. vii. 44. " Solu.s filiorum suorum Ilemncus exsequiaa patris persefiuutUH est, diguu.s qui pattTiiam Iwrreditatem alicjuando solus obti- neret, »Touml, hut tho Inxly still hiy on the hier T> ritti I brfrrr tiic alUr.' Tlio moHs nf thr (load \vn» Htin^, and ■■■■r^* tk^n the Binhop of Kvr.ux in<»unt4'ound8 of the Norman Puchv, and had raisoil his native land to a height of jwwer and plorv Ix'yond all the deeds of his fathers who had jjone bef(»re him. And he t<»ld also of those deeds of the departoht have been said on William's side, as mere naked wrong, mere i>l under, mere robber}' for burnt - offering, is not in accordance with William's usual cha- racter. At such a moment the facts of the case would not be very accurately looked into. Men wIkj had come together to make prayers and oHerings for William's soul wniiM l)e more ready to admit even a false charge against him than to leave any possible sin of his unatoucd for. The yEtheling and the Bishops called Ascelin to them; they spoke friendly to him, and made a bargain with him on the spot. Beneath the roof of Saint Stephen's Theground 1 i 1 1 • 1 r* i 1 • Ml lH)UL'ht of the covenant was made winch first made its sou the Ascelin. lawful property of him who had founded the church and * On the appeal of Ascelin see Appendix UU. The most vivid account in given by Wace, from whom I get tho detail of Ascelin mounting the stone ( 14412); "Sor une pierre en haut monta, De vers la biere se toma." ' Ord. Vit. 662 R. " H.ino igitiir terram cahimninr et palam reclamo, et ne coq)U8 raptorirt ojHjriatur ccHpitc meo nee in hereditate mea Ke|>eliatur ex parte Dei prohibio." Tlie adjuration in Wace (144 18) takes a singular fonn ; •* .re par JhcHU omnipotent Nel' pois vt'er par plus haut home." ' lb. " Episcopi et Proceres alii audierunt, et vicinos ejus, cpii oumilrm vera dixisse contestabantur, intellexcrunt." rfO TIIK LATER DAYS (»K WILLIAM. ctuf. ftxi. of thoM to whom he had grmnttHl it. With the u8M>nt of Honn-, wxty shilling;* were nt once pivon to Awt'lin at the purcha«o-money of the seven feet of ground which were to be \Villiam'» own. Thr full pritv of the whole c«UU« whieh ht* Imd lost wns promiBinl to liiin, n promiso which WMB eoon nftor fnitlifully fulfilled.* A.»^elin then withdrew his protest ; "William mi«,'"ht now be buried in the gmund which had lawfully become his own, and the funeral rites went on. A poethumous atonement was tlius made for one of the ImtiaL w*^* whieh weighed down William's soul; ])ut one mis- fortune more was still in store for his body. The royal oorpec had now to be moved from the bier to the stone coffin which was to be its last restinp;'-placc. But by the unskilfulness of the workmen the coffin had been made too TW» body small to receive the unwieldy carcase of William. In the efforts which were made to force it into its narrow- room, the body burst ; a fearful stench filled the church, which the burning" of incense and of all sweet savours could not overcome.^ The remainder of the office was hurried over ; the officiating" clergy went back with all speed to their own quarters, and the course of William on earth was brought to an end. He had gone to his ' Onl. Vit. 66a C. " Nam pro k>culo soliuB sepultune sexa^nta soHdoB •o protinuji adhihuerunt, pro reliqua vero tellure quam calumniabatur •quipoUeiu mutuum eidem promiaerunt : et post non multum temporis, pro Mlute specialia heri quem diligebant, pactum compleverunt." William of MftliDesbury (iii. 283) saya, " Volente Hem-ico filio . . . centum librae M)geDti litigatori perHoIuta; audacem calumniam compescuere. " The koBdred poundii must be the price of the wliole estate. • Ord. Vit. u. 8. " Dum corpus in sarcofa^nim mitteretur, et violenter, qoU TM per imprudentiam camentariorum breve Btructum erat, com- pUoaniur, plii^inimufl venter crepuit, et intolerabilis foetor circura- ^^tktttm penoiUM et reliquuro vulgus implevit. Fumus turis aliorumque •Wfnalnm do turibuliit copiose ascendebat, sed teterrimum putorem idiidoie non prvvalebat. Sacerdotea itaque festinabant exsequias per- Btten et actutum Hua cum pavore mapalla repetere." This story seems peculiar to Orderic. William's mo>'ument. 721 grave amid scenes as stormy ami as wonderful as augfht chap. xxi. that liad marked his course from the day when he g-riksped the straw upon the floor at Falaise to the day when he received his death-wound in the burning" streets of Mantes. Tlie Conqueror had thus at last found his hardly won resting-place. When the first feelings of fear and wonder had passed away, mun began to think of doing those honours to his memory which he had failed to receive at the moment of his death and burial. His son William, William '« now crowned King of the English, undertook the duty of j^.^j^. \,y raising a fitting monument to the memory of his father. ^'^^^® A mass of gold and silver and precious stones was handed over to Otto the goldsmith, a man whose skill in the Teutonic craft had been rewarded by AVilliam, when living, with fair estates on English soil.^ The coffin itself, wrought of a single stone, and supported by three small columns of white marble,^ was surmounted by a shrine of splendid workmanship, blazing with all the precious materials which had been entrusted to the cunning hands of Otto.^ On that shrine the epitaph of William was graven in letters of gold. Many poets had striven for the honour of thus Epitaph 1 • ^ A A^ ^ ' 1 ^^' Ai\ll- commemorating their master; but the verses which were bishop rrii chosen to be placed on William's tomb were the work of ^"*^"''"*' Archbishop Thomas of York. * The Northumbrian Primate ' See above, p. 85. ' The toml), at its destruction in 1562 (see Hippeau, 181), wa.s described a.s a " locullo de pierre oil estoyent les osseniens du roy due, huuh son sopulchre ; lequel loculle estoit d'une forte pierre de Voideryl, couvert de lueHTue pierre, et soutenu sur trois petits pila«tre« de pierre blanche." ' Ord. Vit. 663 D. " Hie [VVillelmus Rufut*] uuri et argtiiti gem- niaruuMjue copiarn Othoni aurifabro erogavit, et Huper patriw Mui mausoleum fieri niirificum memoriale prajcepit. Ille vero, regiis jussis parens, iiuiigue opuH condidit, (juod ex auro et urgento et genuui.s UHondage led to her new birth of freedom. We liave to pass, however lightly, over those times of silent growth and revolution, those times, as it proved, of salutary chastisement, which part off the earlier freedom of Eng- land from the later. Our task will be done when the foreign nobles and the foreign King have in truth become our countrj-men, when the wergild of the heroes of Senlac has been paid in full on the battle-field of Lewes, and when the great Assembly which welcomed the return of Godwine rises again to life in the Parliaments of Earl Simon and King Edward. A P r E N D I X. NOTES A, B. pp. 8, 24. TiiK Lkgal Fictions and Confiscations of ^Villiam's- Reign. The text of this volume having swelled to uii unexpected extent, I reserve the substance of these notes, which are mainly founded on Domesday, for the general examination of Domesday in the fifth volume. NOTE C. p. 26. The Thbee Commissioners for Redemption of Lands. I think that, if we put together the passages from the Chronicle and from Domesday quoted in pp. 25, 26, we can hardly avoid the conclusion that they all refer to the same transaction, and that Bishop William, Engelric, and Ralph the Staller were joined in such a commission as I have spoken of in the text. Bishop William we already know ; a short notice of the other Commissioners may not be out of place. The mention of Engelric shows that the notices must refer to a transaction not very late in William's reign, and that the Bishop intended must be William of London. At first sight, in an entiy in East-Anglia, one might have thought that the person meant was William, Bishop of Thetford, who appears in the Survey as the Bishop in possession. But he was not consecrated till 1086, and he could only have just taken j)ossession when the Sur\*ey was made. But by that time the lands of Engelric had passed, either by death or confiscation, to Count Eustace. The Bishop must therefore be the London William, and the matter referred to must be iHjfore his death in 1075. And the comparison of the several passages seems to fix it to this date in 1068. rfi AprKNDix. Tbftl Hu|{rlru wan nn i.nj^lislmuin nevtut* plain. Il» iipjMjirB ■■ |»; ' ■ ■ '^' '■ K. in it. j6 ft, 37 ft, .^a '». timln Harold, umlcr the BUk^i : , uml umlrr the Chunli «»f Kiint Piuil. 11132,326, 33. wt find him holdinff, icominply !»y rrpilar f^mutH from Williniii, lanll which had U*«>n hcM by Han>leen tUnu' in tlic days of King William. Soo i. 137, ii. 5^6&, 26, 286, 296, 30, 31, 316, 34, 556, 102 ft, 106 ft. One eutry (ii. 5) is c«i>able of misconsti-uction ; " Ingclricus ahstulit nnaxn fcminani Brictevain t«neutoni xviii. acras." This docs not im- ply any pen^mal carryin*; off of Rrilitpifii, but niinply that Engelrio took iiiiiMCwiiin of her laud or of her lord's rights over it. Engelric boweirer wm a benefactor of the Church. A gift of his to the church of Saint Martin — that is Saint Martin-le-Grand in London — ii reoofded in ii. 14. But even his gooect that the whole tale, especially that part of it which makes Engelric to have been the first Dean of his own foundation, comes from the same mint as the talc (see vol. iii. p. 656) which makes his daughter the mother of William Peverel. llie charter is said to have been granted at the Christmas Eeast of 1068 (evidently mean- ing 1067), and to have been confirmed at the coronation of the Queen at the following Pentecost. It is signed by a crowd of names Boi^ish and Norman, among whom I doubt about Hugh Bishop of Liaieiix, of whose prewnce in England there is no other mention. And I doubt also about the Cardinal Presbyters John and Peter, who in authentic history do not appear in England till the year 1070. Of the third Commissioner joined with Engelric and Bishop TilK TllKKK C(JMMlS.SluNKIiS. 727 William I hoped that I had reached the true account in vol. iii. p. 752. I find however by further searching in Domesday that, though the rest of the account there given of tlie two Ralphs, father and son, will stand, yet I was wrong in inferring that the elder Ralph died before the coming of William. Several passages in the second volume of Domesday, besiiles the one with which we are now dealing, show that he was alive in William's reign. Thus in ii. 2176, 218, "In Estuna tenuit Ruilulfus Stalra T. R. E. i. carucatam ten-ie, et dedit cam T. R. Willclmi cum uxore su^ ad abbatiam concessione Regis." In ii. S7 again, " Benetleiam tenuit Comes Guert T. R. E. ; post eam adjunxit Comes Radulfus Stiilra huic manerio pro berewita T. R. Willelmi." Ralph was therefore alive at William's coming, and he acted under him on this important commission. Here too we get the explanation of his otherwise puzzling title of " Comes." He doubtless held the Earldom for a season after William's coming, and was succeeded by his son. As to the causes which led his son to identify himself with his mother's country, and to serve under William in his in- Tasion of England, we are still left in the dark ; but we must suppose some outlawry under either Eadward or Harold, which banished the son without touching the father. There is therefore no reason to supi)ose that grant of lands to the East - Anglian Bishoprick which I doubtingly inferred in vol. iii. p. 753. We presently read, " Hanc ten-am haljuit A[rfastus] episcopus in tempore utrorumque [Radulforum sc], et hundret nescit quo- modo, et numquam fuit de epi.scopatu teste hundret." It would seem that /Ethelniar and Erfast wore tenants successively of the two Ralphs, but that the next Bishop William kept the Itmd as part of the possessions of the see to the prejudice of the Crown. It follows therefore that the elder Ralpli was living as late as 1070, in which year the episcopate of Erfast begins. NOTES D, E. pp. ^2, 36. Thp: King's Tiieons and the Condition of Kent, Slkrev, and surse.v, The substance of these Notes also will be given in the examina- tion of Domesday. rit ArrKNDix. NOTE F. p. 35. The Lakos and Family of Cf«>i)Ri( . I OAT* toine Moount of Otxlric aiuI his chief pohkohhIoiis in n note in ihe Appemlix to my thinl volumo. p. 731. Tlio nuinl^cr of d«uUs »)»oot him wliich ore prcHcrved in Domestlfty '\n very noMrkable. It is plain thnt he waii, )>oth by office and by extent of proprrty, one of the first men in RorkHhire, but it also strikes ■M thnt then* are other reaaons for the prominence given to him ta ibe Surrey. Hia memor}* seems to ])e dealt with in somcwlmt IIm moe way an tlie memor}- of Harold. Tlic entries seem to iVfMl a certain anxiety to represent him as a wrong-doer. I hare already (vol. iii. p. 731) statetl the e>'idence for Goears from the entry which I have quoted in p. 36. In the same shire (ir>2) we read of '' Aluric liomo Godric Tioeoomitifi," and he again appears (144) as a landowner in close QQOliexion with various meml>ers of the house of Godwiuc. Of Weaton, a manor then held by Bishop Odo, we read ; " De terrd hujus manerii tcnuit Leuuinus comes ix. hidas et dimidiam, et Uodric vicecomes iii. hidas et dimidiam pro uno manerio, et ii. hominea ejuFotuerunt." Godric's estates in Bockinghamshire were therefore not large, and there are one or two other persons of the same name from whom he seems to be puq^osely dittinguishecgar the Staller (151). In thcBC latter pawaf^ea the title of "Vicecomes" might siinply be added for distinc- tion, but the grant to the embroideress was clearly an official act, and makes it plain that lio was Sherifl' of Buckinghamshire. Whether he was not also Sheriff of Bedfordshire is less plain, but a landowner in that nhire (213) is described as the man of Godric tbe ShcHff. In Buckinghamshire Godric was succeeded in his office by the Norman Ansculf, who waa dead at the time of the Survey, but whose ion William held large estates. He seems to have acted aftorthe jutul manner of Sheriffs, as we find him (148 b) wrong- THK LANIJS AM) FAMILY oK (JODIUC. 729 fully ilispoBsessing a Nominn hoMrr. As to tlie succt'ssion to the office in Tkrkshire, the entries bearing on it in Domesday are not very clear. At one of the phices calleil Sparsholt (57 h) lands were held by Henry of FeiTers " «[ua^, sicut scira testatur, remausenint in firnui Regis quando Goilricus vicecomitatuni |>or- didit." Of tlie other Sparsholt we read (60 6) that it was then held hy Henr)' of Ferrers, and that it had been held by *' Godricus unus liber homo." But of some of the lands in the same lord- ship we read, " Hanc ten-am dicit Henricus fuisse CJodrici ante- cessoris sui, sed, sicut hundreda testatur, Godricus earn occupavit super W. Regem post bellum do Hastinges, nee unnpiam tenuit T. E. Regis." These passages are difficult. The former of them would certainly at first sight imply that Godric had lived to be deprived of his office by William. But it seems impossible to set aside the distinct statement of the local history that he wius killed in the battle. Pos.sibly however " (juando vicecomitatuni j)enlidit ' may mean " when he was killed," the oj^ce being ip^io farto forfeited by Godric's treason in joining Harold. The death of a man already attainted would, on this view, be a sort of accident accruing to the forfeiture. The entries in the Yorkshire " clamores " with regard to the lands of William Malct sup])ly a parallel. We hear (373) of lands which William held '* quamdiu in Euruicscire terram tenuit,'* and which are claimed by his son. Forfeiture or legal alienation are therefore shut out, and the words '* quamdiu ter- ram tenuit " can only mean " as long as he lived." But " Godricus unus liber homo" must be a different man from the Sheriff, from whom he seems to be j)ointedly distinguished. Henry of Fcn*ei*s affirmed that the land had belonged to his *' antecessor," that is seemingly to the Sheriff. The Hundred witnessed that the other Godric, " unus liber homo," had taken jjossession of it since the battle, not having held it in King Ea«l\vard*s days. But, in Domesday law, the holding, first of Godric and then of Henry of P'errei-s, was an '' occupatio sujier Regem W.," and the land ought to have gone to the Crown. What then is meant by this "occupatio post bellum de Hastingcs ? ' It may be that, as we have so many euphemisms and circumlocutions to point out the reign of Harold, we have here, in the wonls "post bellum de Ha.stinge.s," an euj)hemism or eircundocution to point out the 7»/a«i-reign of I'^iulgar. The yEtheling, who, though not crownelM>t uf IV-torlKirou^li (fiee v«L iU. n '\o), may alto hftve ii]t]Munt<>4i n SlurifT of IWrkHhire. It it |- 'h«» tJ»*t t^»<> OiHlric who " vicocoinitntuni junliilit" WM ** Godricuii unu« lilicr homo." and woh nppointoti Slieriff by bdgM'. If w>. he nmy |>rol>A)t)y hnvo l>ccn the son of the SherifT vbo died at ScnUc. Hut whttlier Sheriff or not, whether 8on or aoi, if EaHj^t gmntcHl him nny hinds, if he entered on any hmdH frlttch, in WilliHUi'* reading of the h»w, were already forfeited, the mA would be held to be null and void, and it woidd W, in the lH^«ig« of Domesday, an *' oeeu]>atio super KeK WALLINGFORD AND KuBKKT UF uiLV. 731 ejus Iioinines de comitatu. Pi*a'tcr isUw bidas accepit istc Godricus de firma Regis unam virgatain terrce de quS non videruiit sigilluin Regis." These remarkable comments seem to Ikj confined to those lands of Goilric whicli at the time of the Survey were in possession of Henry of Ferrers. The name Godric is so common tliat it is almost in vain to seek for the Sherift*'8 possessions in other shires, or even in Berkshire when he is not in some way marked out from his namesakes, but he can hardly fail to be the same Godric who appears in Wiltshire (72) as holding lunds which at the Survey were lield by Henry of Ferrers. NOTE G. p. 45. WiGOD OF WaU^INGFORD AND ROBEUT OF OiLV. I MADE some mention of Wigod of Wallingford in the Appendix to my third volume. I have since worked out such notices as I could find in Domesday and elsewhere, and they quite confirm the story there quoted, though it is certainly not to be found in William of Poitiers. Wigod's case is the o})posite to that of his neighbour Godric. An Euglishnum of high rank contrives to make his peace with the Conqueror, to retain wealtli and infiueuce, and to hand them on to his descendants in the female line. The notices of Wigod in the charters I have already spoken of in vol. iii. p. 768. He was, by blood or by courtesy, a kinsman of Eadward ; he was his cup-bearer and, as would seem from the charter in Cod. Dipl. iv. 215, Sheritl* of Oxfordshire. He is also spoken of in a curious passage in the History of Abingdon (i. 477), where he is described as becoming possessed of the lordship of Whitchurch, belonging to a monk of the Abbey ; " Wigodus oppi- danorum Walingfordensium dominus possedit, velle monachorum pra'dictorum hinc et inde de eisdem terris sic se referente." As Wigod does not appear in Domesday as an actual lamlowner, he was pn)bably dead before the taking of the Survey. His son also, '* Tokig Wiggodes sunu," hud died by William's side at Ger- bcroi (s«'»! p. 64S). All this falls in with the tradition that his estates pa.s.sed to his daughter or daughters. One daughter is said to have been married to Robert of Oily, probably Ouilly-le-Vicomte, Jlf APPEXDIX. Mar lititm Now of the Un^ r4itJitof« of HolHTt in OxftmUhirc H b mmlionnl in ievrrml ciuioa h<»w he canio by thoni. TIuih in 158 il ta p*itl I hut one wiUtc wa« got by cxclinngc with WiilUr Qlflkni. Of two pUcet (158 6) wo read, " Hanc wlomit IU)lHrtU8 3« R^v,** while another (»eo |). 658) was granted by Williiun btHuo 8aililck-Sita»noe. In unc place only is the owner T. H. K. nuntioned, ami thcf» we read •* Wigod tenuit" (158). So of Htdn'rt'H IWlcHhiro kadf (6a), part IumI l>ecn held by Wigod of Kini; Eiulward. This <«rUanIv looks aa if Itoltert had Hucceee assumed ns the natural succcBsor of Wigod ; •* Hoc nmnerium tenuerunt v. sochi. Horum duo homines Bric- tiei Doam hidam et dimidiam habuerunt, et alii ii. homines Opulfi (ilii Fran unam hidam et dimidiam, et quintus homo Edmer Atule i. hidam tenuit. Nullus eorum ad antecessorem Wigot pertinuit, §ed unuMjuiw|ue terram suam veudere potuit. Horum lunia terram auBm emit a W. Rege novcm uneiis auri, ut homines de hundreot xviii. hidas de terra Wigoti, Milo vi. hidas." Miles however held many lordships in O.xfordshire which had been held by other o\niers T. 11. E., and in one case at least he seems to have been guilty of an irregular usurpation over the English owner. Of two lordships held under him by Ordgar we read (159 b), "Has ii. terras quas tenet Orgar de Milone de Rege deberet tenere. Ipse enim et pater suus et avunculus tenuerunt libere T. R. E." In three other very remarkable entries we find the names of Wigod and Miles connected in much the same way as those of Wigod and Robert, Miles being taken for granted as Wigod's successor. In SuiTey (36 b) we read, " Ipse Milo tenet Cisedune. Maguo Suert tenuit T. R. E. . . . Quando Rex W. veuit in Angliam Wigot non habebat." Here it is plain that Magno (Magnus ?) had either commended himself to Wigod or had been dispossessed by him. 80 in Berkshire (61 6), "In Radinges tenet Leuuard in Lonchelei i. hidam de Milone, et non potuit ire quo- libet absque licentia Wigoti." In Hampshire again (50 6), " Alwinus Wit tenet ii. hidas. Ipse tenuit T. R. E. . . . Hie Alwinus tenuit banc terram T. R. E. sub Wigoto pro tuitione. Modo tenet eamdem sub Milone, et fuit deliberatus per Hunfridum visde lupo ['* visde lupo, visde leuu. Wol/^s/acey Kelham, 363 ; see Domesday, 56] in excambio de Eradeuuatre, sieut ipse dicit. Sed Hundreda inde nichil scit." This seems to be Broadwater in Sussex, of which we read in 28 b, " Rotbertus tenet de Willelmo [de Braiose] Bradewatre. Wigot tenuit de Rege E." Our Wigod is also most likely the same as the Wigod who appears four times in Middlesex (129) in the account of lauds which at the time of the Survey belonged to Earl Roger, in two of which we get the names of Wigod's men, " Hanc tenuit Aluuinus homo Wigot, et potuit de ea facere clievc thnt Hobcit of Oily Mid Miki CMpia •uoocrdr.! Wj^mhI in nn onlrrly way, witlmut Miy violittM or oooBaoiti'M riH> only ditTirulty \h an to those ^■^ of Wigud in Uic WtMrt which had paMiod to the Crown. Bat ibe whot« erideooe falls in with the traditiun that Uol)ort aod Milc« tutXTcded by mnrria^o. Tlic wife of Kol>crt undouht- rdly U»rr the Knglish name of Fj»ldj;vth. " Alditha uxor me« " (Moci. Aogl. viii. 146a) connenUj to his gifts to the college of Saint Qtorgt in the castle of Oxford. That this P2aldgyth was • daogtiter of Wi^^ud is the received tradition (see vol. iii. p. 768). With rvgard to Miles the case is not so clear. Genealogists do not ■fffre as to his wife. ** He marritnl the heiress of Wallingford," Mrs Kelham (36). which does n(jt rule whether she was Wigod's daughter or grand -daughter. Sir licnry Kllis (i. 402), after I>ug- dalc (Baroiuge, i. 4 1 3), marries him to "Maud, daughter and heir of Robert de Oilgi, through him he became possessed of the honour and castle of Wallingfonl." But Robert of Oily never held Wallingford castle (cf. Domesday, -,6, 56 b), and it appears (MffP. A»gl ^*i- 251) that he died without issue. It is therefore almott certain that Miles as well as Robert married a daughter of Wigod. Miles' wife, Matilda ))y name, is mentioned in the Abingdon Histor}-, ii. 106, no. Most likely, like Eadgyth the daughter of Malcolm, she changed her name. Miles' connexion with Wallingfortl appears also in Domesday, 56, and in the History of Abingdon (ii. 12) he is expressly called " Milo de Waliiigaford, cognomento Crispin." Robert of Oily is a more important person on account of his con- BeiioD with Oxford. He figures at great length in the local History of Abingtlon, where he is described (ii, 7) as "ipse praedives, castelli Tero Oxenefordensis oppitianuK," and (ii. 12) as " constabularius Oxoniip, in cujus custodia erat illo tempore provincia ilia in prseceptis el in factis, adeo ut de ore ejus proferretur illi actio." The character goes on ; ** Dives enim valde erat ; diviti nee pauperi parcebat exigere ab eb pecunias, sibique gazas multij)licari." This may possibly ac- oooot for the state of the town of Oxford. Robert was for a while an enemy to the monks of Abingdon, and seized on some of their pnawHii'ini. But by dint of prayers, sickness, and visions, he was brangfat to refientance; he was forced by his wife {''cogente eum WIGOD OF WALLINGKUUD AND HUBERT OF UlLV. 735 uxore sua," ii. 14) to restore the lands of Saint Mary, and he became ulto^'ether another man. He not only helped to rebuild the minster of Abint^don, but he restored various mined parish churches within and without the walls of Oxford ('alius parochianas ecclesias dirutas, videlicet infra muros Oxenfordice et extra, ex Buniptu suo reparavit"). Of his work in this way tliere is little doubt that we have a specimen in the existing tower of Stiint Michael's at Oxford. He was also bountiful to the poor and full of good works of all kinds. Among other things we read (ii. 15, cf. 284) that "pons inagnus ad eep- temtrionaleni plagani Oxonian per eum fact us est." He was burieeon n iniHtress of Henry tlio Kir>t- Hti ? ani. iniikiH rt nil hut certain tluit she waa of Ku^IIkIi (k«mU I do not wiy ii!n»ohiteIy oertAin, iKvuiwe William of Warren •imI llundriiU had a daughter bo named (Will. Gem. viii. 8), who BMT protMihly liave licen a ^o' nnd Gilbert, %rho therefore, an well as the deKcendunt» of Miles Cru|iin, were |»rol>ohly of English deHcent by the mother's side. Eogliah namc« also sun'ived in their foundation of Oseney. The second Prior and the first Ahl)ot ( 1 138- 1 168) bore the name of Wigod, and must surely have been of the family of Wigod of WAllingford. His successor (1168-1183) bore the less distinctive BAme of Eadwmrd. Sec the Oseney Annals under those yearb. itlfred the nephew of Wigod and Wido of Oily ajjpeur near togrlher in Domesday, 1 60. NOTE H. p. 53. Robert and Sweoen of Essex. Of Robert the sou of W^^-marc, Eadward's Staller and favourite, we hvn already often heard (see vol. iii. pp. 9, 413). He appears as a )»rgf landowner in various parts of England under Eadward. He died before the time of the Survey (Domesday, ii. 47 b), and was succeeded by his Hon, who (cf vol. ii. j>j). 417, 663) was Englishman or Dane eooogb to bear the name of Swegen ; " Postcjuam Rex advenit, douo BcgU teuuit Rol>ertu8 i. hidam, et Sucnus filius ejus adjunxit iv. hidaa cum isti j>ost mortem ])atris sui," But nearly the whole of the Citates of RoU-rt in other parts of England had before the SnnrejpMBed to other owners, while his great cbtate in the Eastern tbires was largely increased. Thus liis lands in Somerset (92 h), Hertfordshire (134, 137 b), Herefordshire (186 b, 187), Cam- bridgeshire (193 6, 200 6, 201) had all passed away from the family. So bad i»art of his estate in Huntingdonshire (207), but another part (205 h) wa« still held by Swegen, as well as lands in Oxford- aliire (160) whose owner T. Ii. E. is not mentioned. Some parts ROBKRT AND SWEOEN OF ESSEX. 737 of his Suffolk aiul Essex estates (ii. 395, 106, 287//, 2956) had also passed from him, luit, 011 the other huiul, he had receivey a freeman T. R. E., " et illse vii. acree sunt additse post adventuni Regis Willelmi, quoB fuenmt cujusdam alius liberi hominis." But the most curious entry is in ii. 47 6, where, out of the lands of a certain Godric, most of which seem to have been granted to Robert, one lordship was granted to Swegen, who gave it to his father ; "S. tenet hoc manerium de dono Regis Willelmi, quod dedit patri suo Roberto." That Robert was Sheriff of Essex under Eadward we have seen in vol. ii. j). 347. Of his tenure of the office under William we get an incidental notice in the Survey (ii. 98). Grim the iieeve holds lands of which is noted ; " Hida est una de hominibus forisfactis erga Regem, nn IWmb t h (**8ilMi imle aUtulit po«U|Uttm p^-nliilit vicccomitatum ") UmI be bati lout tbe office l»cforr the Survey wan taken. One cvrioot ftorjr of Robert 'n officiul life* iH found in ii. 401 6. TVtv wmii ft crrtftin Bninijftr, ft freeman in Suflolk, who wfts coni- atniicil to iU»l>ort> but over whom* landM Haint Kndnuind had tlio riKbtft of aac aikI hoc : " Ktxlem teni|>orc fuorunt furati equi inventi io (bwio iatittf Hrunpiri. ita quod Abhaii, cujuh fuit Hoca ct saca, ct RodliciiuA, qui hfthait coniniendationoTn KUi>cr iNtum, vcuerunt de boe furto m*\ placitum rt. nirut huiulret testatur. discc-goruut imi. -.Mlit. r hIiw judicio qutnl vidissct hundrct." frr>m ii. 401 and other places, to have taken the ! t of surname, and he waA father or p^uid- fftther of Henry of Kssex, whose cowardice in the Welsh war in 1159 ia reconled hy Ger^'ftse (X Reriptt. 1380), and his pnnislnnent hv llojjer of Wendover (ii. 296. See also Dn^'daic's Barona^'e, 463 ; Ufttlox. History of the Exchequer, 28,42; Ellis, i. 489). The Ead- wftrd fton of Swegen in ii. 98 b (" tenuit Eduuardus filius Suani dimidiftm hidam ; moet Suenus." Swegen's invasions of ecclesiastical ftnd other iirojH'rty are recorded in 2, 42 b, 59 6, loi ; another of bis Tirtim«< (42 A) was "Biicteva libera femina" — doubtless the Mine Hrihtgifu of whose wrongs at another hand we have already beard (tee above, p. 726) — " quam Suenus addidit pra?dicta3 terrse." NOTH 1. p. 64. Eadric thp: Wild. OfJB earliest notice of Eadric is in Ordcric, 506 B, where he is mid to have been one of those who submitted to William at Barking: (aee p. 21). We there get bis surname of " Wild," and we are told Ihai be wa§ tbe nephew or grandson of Eadric Streona ; " Edricus EADRIC TIIK WILD. 739 quoque co^ioinento Oui/da, iil vat Silvaticus, nopos Edrici pcstiftTi Ducis cognomen to Streone, id est acc Bhown to )>i> In Uio account of the foundation of Wi^iorc Prior)- in tlie (Yi. 348). Kjidric i« rrprcdcntcd m dpfcntlinff Wi^oro OmIIc Mlr|H'tunl impriHon- BWtit ; " Ka^lulphua. tamqunm HtrcnuinHimuH pugil, in Mtircliiam, ot m— liitim contm Fxlrichum, Stdopiip ConHtemot\VvgemonaE> ocMelc- OTthiJP cum perlinrntiis dominum, con(pu>fitui ndhiir non pnrentein, directua, post longam lalNiris o))?idionem ipnuni in eodem cnntru obCentum, dictafi<]ue terras et ])luro8 alias in Marchiil, vi ^ladii ot fortunl, auo (]uam ^loriose manci])avit dominio, ciuoni vt por}»etiii« carctrrihun manci|mndum ad dominum suum Rogem adduxit vinctum, dictamque mancipationem castri de DyneythS in Melenyth, per cum eomtnicti, tuitione quam bellicose munivit." That this story is wrong may be easily shown from Domesday. Neither Wijrmore Castle nor its site ever belongeeen a sharer in his exploits. Eadric the Wild of Herefordshire must not be confounded with the East -Anglian Eadric mentioned in p. 121 and in vol. ill. p. 717. On his outlawry Bishop yEthelmar took possession of his Und« ; " Episcopus Almarus invasit terram " (Domesday, ii. 200). Mc^t likely the land was held by one of the common leases, and, when Eadric's right in it was ended by his outlawry, it legally reverted Ut the P*ishop. But as the Crown was sure to put in some claim, rightful or wrongful, to the lands of an outlaw, the Bishop's occupation was called an " invasio." THE EARLDOM AND DEATH OF COPSIGE. 711 NOTE K. I.. 66. Castles and Dkstrlction in Towns. The substance of this note also is removed to the examination of Doniesclay in the fifth volume. NOTE L. p. 76. The Earldom and Death ok Copsioe. I HAVE already (see vol. ii. p. 484) said somewhat about Copsige, theCoxo of the Nonnans, and his relations toTostig and to William. There is at first sight a chronological difficulty as to the date of his appointment to his Earldom and of the death which so soon fol- lowed it. William of Poitiers (148 ; so Orderic, 506 A) distinctly mentions him among the English leaders who submitted to William at Barking (see p. 24) ; " In his erat Comes Coxo, quem singulari et fortitudine et i)robitate Regi, post et optinio cuicjue Normanno, placuisse audivimus." Ijiiter in his story he tells us of his death, which he evidently puts during William's absence in Normandy in 1067. After telling the story of Eustace and the Kentishmen he adds (158); *' Eodem fere tempore Coxo Comes, quem placuisse Nor- mannis diximus, morte occidit immerita, et <|uam deceat propagari.' He then goes on with a panegyric on the viiiues and loyalty of Copsige; "Hie Regis causam et ipsuni favore multo pro])abat." He then tells us of the many temptations and exhortations by which Copsige's followers and the rest of his countrymen tried to move him from his constancy tp William ; '* Sui vero satellites ab ipso dissidcbant, factionum deterrimi fautores ac socii. l*roinde eum ab officio transvcrtere tentabant, 88ppe monentes, cjuasi per amicitiam, de private honore, ut liber- tatem a proavis traditam defenderet ; nunc obsecrantes at([Uo obtes- tantes, tam([uam gi*atia rerum publicai-um, ut, extraneos deserens, oi)timorum hominum suae nationis et consanguinitatia voluntatem Beiiucrctur. Sane diutiiui variacjuc calliditate ha'o suggerebant, et hujuHHiodi alia," XII APrEXDIX. CVirata birr - - '' tantUall tnuiitAtioufi, and diox a niurtyr to hi* failli lowai . i(M>op. 107). Wo turn from tiic rlirtoric of the ArcIuKacon of LiHieux to tho plaiacr niu-nitive of uur own Simeon, who at least gives ub datets tbooKh it ifl the iUto« themnelveH which at finit siglit raise the diAc«lty. Tlie utory comea in one of Simeon'K inBcrtions in the Clirooicio of Florence, and. a* ha|>|»on8 with several of tht»fcc inser- tioiu, it is put out of its itlnce, in that lu^count of tho Hucces&ion of Um Northumhrian Earls (see vol. i. p. 585) which comes in inci- deotAllj under the year 1072 (p. 91). He had just mentioned the •ppotDtraent of Oswiilf to the Bcniician Karldom by Morkere in 1065 (tee vol. ii. p. 487), He then adds ; " C'nj)to postnioduni it fnitffiil* mancipato Morkaro, Kcx Willclmus coniitatuni Osulti oommiait Copeio, qui erat partis Tostii Comitis, viro consiliario et pnidenti/* He then goes on to tell the tale of Copsige's death, of which he gives an exact date, fixing it to March 12, five weeks after his ap|>ointment to the Eiirldom, but without mentioning the year. I have quuttxi the passage in p. 107. Tlie diffic-ulty lies in the words " capto })08tmodum et custodise ■lancipato Morkaro.** It is certain that Morkere was not actually put in boudi< till after his revolt in 107 i (see p. 476). I was there- fore once inclined to think that the whole of these events were to be placed after William's reconfjuest of Ely in that year. But there arc •everal reasons against this date. First tlierc is the Xorman version, which speaks of Copsige as Ejirl in 1067 and as being killed in the OOUTM of that year. Then Simeon goes on to tell us, in the passages following those which I liave just quoted, how Oswulf was himself killed not long after the death of Copsige, and how Gospatric then l>eggod, or rather bought, the Bernician Earldom of William (sec p. 1 34). But Gospatric is called P^arl in the W^orcester Chronicle under the year 1068, and the account which Simeon gives (sec P-5'3) of the events of the year 1072 implies that it was in that year that Oo«patric finally lost his Earldom. I therefore place this account of Cojwjige, his appointment to his Earldom and his death, in the year 1067. We must therefore suppose a certain laxity of ffpeech on the part of Simeon in the woids which speak of an imprisonment of Morkere. In 1067 Morkere was outwardly in the highest favour with William. But the character in which he accompanied William to Normandy was practically THK EAULDOM AKD DEATH OK CUPSlGE. 743 tlmt of a hostage (see p. 75;. It was a ])ariltnmble exaggeration or confusion to apply to such a state of things hinguage which strictly a])pliecl only to hiu actual iniprisonuient at a later time. The account in the Durham Chronicle printed in the Monasticon, i. 235, is clearly made up from the narrative of Simeon, from which it diffti-s only in putting the death of Oswulf in the year following the dcatli of Coptjige, whereas in Simeon it happens in the same year *' sequenti auctumno." But this is no real ditlerence. Copsige was killed on March 12 in the year 1067. Easter fell on April 8. By any one thei*efore who followed the reckoning which begins the year at Etister, the death of Oswulf would l)e said to happen in the year following the death of Copsige. It is curious to see how this story is treated by Thierry. Copsige is killed twice over. The first time he dies by his Norman name, or rather by Thieriy's wonderful transformation of it (see vol. ii. 484), during William's absence in 1067. He is killed the second time by his own name, or something like it, after William's caj»turo of York in 1069. That is to say, Thierry read the account in William of Poitiers, and also the account in Simeon of Durham, or rather in the Chronicle in the Monasticon founded on it. Hut he did not find out that they both referred to the same person, and tliat his Kox and his Kopsi (which his English translator brings a degree nearer in the form of Kopsig) were the same man. The history of Kox is told at i. 286, without any hint as to tiie i)ai't of England to which the story belongs ; " Un chef saxon, nomm(^' Kox, re^ut de send)lables messages, au nom de la vieille libertd anglaise, et n'en tint aucun compte ; irrit^s de son refus, les conjurds lui envoybrent des ordres, puis des menaces; et, comme il i)ei*sistait toujoui-s dans .son amitid pour les vaincpiours, les menaces furent cxt^'cutces, et il pcrit dans une emeute, malgrd la protection dtrangcre. Les liistoriens normands le c<5lebrent comme un martyr de la foi jurde, digne d'etre cite partout comme exemj)le, et dont la gloire doit vivre d'age en age." The history of Kopsi (i. 326) is more romantic. It is placeil in the last days of 1069 or in the first days of 1070, while William is following up his concjuests beyond the Tyne. I do not know how Thierry got over the dilliculty id)out the imprisonment of 741 AriT.VDIX. lloHiCffV ta SilMon't Accounts Itornufto in hiit own vcmion AlurkcfV i* at litis BOOMOt in iinnfi Af^inHt Willinm ; "Qoukd let Korlliumbrirnt. Aprt^it avoir chiUMX^ TnRti^, frdro do HatdU, duu unc innurrcotion nntionalo, curcnt rhoiKi ]>ur oil Ich Nonniiiids ournit pmm6 U TjTke ; aJora il fut contraint do fuir comme Ics aiitrrs danH let forMt ct 1m montAgnes. On mit ^ sa place un certain Saxon •pprl^ Kopct. hommc que \ch habitants do la Northumhric avaient diAM^ arec Tottig, qui avait h so vcn^'cr d'eux, et quo, ]>our rctte imUoD m^e, le nouveao roi lour inipona pour chef. Kopsi s'in- ■UdU dans ton poste sous la protection dos ctrangcrs ; niais, apr^g •Toir exero^ quelque tomps son office, il fut asBaiili dans sa maiwon par une troujxj de d<5sh<^rit<5s conduite par ce m(^me Osulf dont il mtmit re^u U dni]>brciit Fur lui, Ic tu^rent, ci te dispcrBOreut auBsit<)t" With reganl to Copsige's earlier life, Geoffrey Gaimar, without much prol«bility, represents him as joining in the first incursions of T«»«tig in 1066 (see vol. iii. p. 304), and therefore as having shared hilf ii|ii>c«ri «• a liimlowiur in DMnndsT. though it tloo^ not of iim.'U provr that her IiuhImuuI wna «k«d, fall* in with that U^licf. Hut it wuh (hnihtU'RH the eUlrr EailACtf who WM tl)c ori^nnl ^n^iitet' of (ho huulH hold hy hin M)n» mhI the rntric* with regaril to him throw some light on hin history •ft I htkvr told it in the text. The firr»l wife t»f Kustiiee, OcKlgifu, the Cioila of the Nonnanii, tlie own BXMtcT of Kin^ Eadwnrtl, up|>eiu*i> an u landowner T. II. E. IB Buf 1 (17, 19, 196, 25), Surrey (34, where bIic is diHtin- gutabed m "Ooda Comitisiia, Boror R.E./' 36 b), Dorset (75 6, 76), Middlcm (130), Huekinghanishire (151 h), (iloueestershire (166 A, 170), Nottinghamshire (280, where she is distinj^uislied from lier iMinnwkf "GtKleva Comitissa/' the wife of Ix.>ofric, 287). Not a ■crap of these large possetusiouB was kept ])y Eustace after the death of his wife. Some of the estates of Qodgifu were at the time of the Survey in the King's hands ; the rest liad been granted out to various ecclesiastical and ]»rivate owners. The date of tlie death of Cfodgifu is not exactly known, hut it appeal's to have happened before 1056. (See Art de AY-rifur les Dates, ii. 762.) She there- fore ctiuld not liave been a liolder " ca die qua Rex E. vivus fuit et mortuus." Her api)eai*ance in Domesday is therefore a parallel Gftfte to those entries where Earl Godwine appears as the owner T. R. E. But her appearance seems to show that her lands ])assed to her husband, if the lands of Godgif'u had from 1056 to 1066 been in the liands of King Eadward or any grantee of his, we should hardly find her name in the Survey. It is a natural con- jecture that Eustace succeeded to the lands of his wife, that they were confiscated by William after his treason in 1067, and that the estates which Eustace afterwards held were later gi-ants after hii reconciliation. It strengthens this view that three lordsl)ij>s in Dortiet (85) were held at the time of the Survey by Ida the ■econd wife of Eustace, which she is also said to have hold T. R. E. This looks as if ICadward had made grants to the second wife of bis friend, which were not confiscated by William along with the laods of her husliand. At the time of Eustace's trial in 1067 the power of William had not yet reached into Dorset. Tlic Domesday holdings of Eustace were therefore grants later than his reconciliation with William, yet one is tempted to think that some of the lands held by Eustace in the Southern shires THE POSSESSIONS OP COUNT EUSTACE. 717 iiiiist Iiave been earlier grants wliich were restored. Tlie great bulk of his estates lie in the Eadtorn shires, especially in Essex (ii. 26-34), aud a large part of them could not have lx*en given him in William's fii-st days, as they consist of estates which had been held by Encfolric (see alx)ve, p. 725), and in one case (ii. 27) hatl belonged to the Lady Eadgyth. But other entries of land which had been held by Harold were most likely earlier grants which were restored. HLs estates in Kent (14), Surrey (34), Hampshire (34 b), had Ijeen mainly held by Crodwint', Oytha, and Harold, which looks as if they were early grants of William. And the estates in Somerset, it is plain, could not have been giiinted till after the conquest of the AVcst in 1068. One lordship in Somerset and one in Surrey (34) are entered in tlie Survey as belonging to the Countess. That in Somerset is Kenward.ston, now corruptly Kingweston, wliich (91 b), as well as Loxton, had been held T. 11. E. by Wulfgifn, who was also Ida's predecessor in some of her Dorset lands. Other possessions of Eustace are found in Hertfordshire (137), Oxfordshire (157 6), Cambridgeshire (196), Huntingdonshire (205), Bedford (211), Norfolk (ii. 151), and Suffolk (ii. 303), where, as also in Hertfordshire, Engclric again ap})ears. Several of the possessions of Eustace in Cambrldgesliire and Bed- fordshire were held under him by his follower Arnold or Arnulf of Ardres (see vol. iii. p. 714), whom I should not have confounded, even for a moment, witli u man of far larger possessions, Arnulf of Hesdin. Kenwardston was afterwards given by the Countess Mary, daughter of Malcolm and Margaret, to Bermondsey Abbey. See the Bermondsey Annals, 1114, 111.3, 1127; Ann. ^^on. iii. 432, 435. I ought to have mentioned the foundation of that monastery in my ecclesiastical chapter, as its founder was plainly an English- man in favour with William. It was founded in 1082 by one described as "Alwinus [^Ifwine] ('hild civis Londonia*" (Ann. Berm. in anno) for Cluniac monks who came from Jax Charit«5 on the Loire, and found a lienefactor in William Utifus. But in his charter (Mon. Ang. v. 100) /Elfwinc is not mentioned. 74a Ai*rKNi)ix. NOTE O. p. 135 The Earldom or (4ospatric. Tm ounear of Oonpiitnr woniil have l>eon imuli clearer, if Simeon of DnHMm, or whoever in tho Northern intorpolator of Florenee, had girefi ub the evenU of his life under their pmper yeani, inutcud of throwing them into a kind of Appendix under the year 1073 (p. 92. Hinde), the ihite of his deposition (see p. 135). He there my* dijitinctly that it waa on tlie deatl» of Oswulf, in the nntiinin of 1067. that (ttmpatric begged or bouglit tlje Earldom. This fixes the appointment to the first jwBsilde moment after the deatli of Ofwulf. that i^ to the Midwinter Genidt of 1067-1068 ; and the next time we hear of him is soon after Pentecost in 1068, when he Imtm William's court for Scotland (pce p. 185). The difficulty arises from Simeon's incidental way of tcllin«( the story. Having mcn- taooed Goipatric's npjK>intmcnt at Christmiis, 1067, he goes on to Mj, **Tenuit eomitatum donee Rex caupis ex supradictis ei aufeiTet; fagifftf ergo ad Malcolmum non multo post Flandriam navigio petit** (lee p. 523). This of course refers, not to his first flight in 1068, hut to his final flight in 1072. Simeon himself mentions the flight of 1068 under its proper year, and in descri])ing Gosi)atric'8 appemrancie at York in 1069 (p. 84) he gives him the title of Earl, which he bears also in the Worcester Chronicle (see p. 255); and this is to Ix^ noted, because the mention of Gospatric in 1069 is one of Smeon's additions to the text of Florence. Between these two events, in the l>eginning of 1069, the Worcester Chronicle and 8imeon place the grant of the Bcrnician Earldom to Robert of Comines (see p. 235), which is not mentioned by Florence. It would seem then that William treated Gospatric's Earldom as ▼acant through his flight to Scotland ; Robert was bis successor, and William (see p. 523), afterwards at least, looked on Gospatric IS having been an accomplice in the rising in which Robert lost his life. Qospatric's reconciliation with William and his restora- tion to his Earldom in the winter of 1069 are mentioned by Orderic only. Simeon, in recording his acts in the next year, 1070, treats him as if he had been Earl all along. He speaks, as we hare seen, of his share in the attack on York, and he does not .+:TIIELSlCiE ABBOT OF RAMSEY. 719 mention him again till \\v records his attack on CumU'rlantl in 1070 (p. 87; see p. 506), when he introduces him afresh, with a reference to his first appointment in 1067; "Oospatricus Comes qui, ut supra dictum est, a Rege Willehno comitatum Northaiihyni- hroruni pretio assecutus fuerat." He acts again as Earl when lie receives Bishop Wulch»'r at Durham in 1071 (see p. 513); he is finally dejwpeil in 1072, but he hacinf; furtlicr invc«to(l by Kmlwnnl witli the gorrmmrnt of HAmM»y. Tlio writer (o. 119) (loArn)>ofl Um AokncM of AMmi! .V.Ifwinr. nml mhU wonln which art^ c((uiv»l(>nt to % naiipiatii'ii ; ** Cn^ik^'utc iiulirn lan^ioro. ct H]>oin ri ointuMu rtilitunp ■anitatU penitua atliinonto. forinHcon* iiiiiiiiiiiHtrationis nr: ' officio, omne perfunctoriaB |H»trHt4»tiH <»nuH, ut hocuiii qii ihitarct, ahjccit," He jfoos on to Bay that the brethren took guwl care of him for the rest of Win da}!*, and then a)>atiH jure prapsidehat, doniOs RamesicnKM curam commisit." (The fomi Ail/sins in this extract mii^t •eetn to imply the name ^f^V/si^c rather than jfJlhelni^c, but it cloarly ^houM be /IrVsius, Ail hv'iu^ the usual Latin abbreviation of -£>«/.) It i^eems plain then that /Kthelsi^e held the two Abbeys in plurality before the death of Eadward, and that he was api>ointed Abbot of Ramsey during the lifetime of /Klfwine. But in the Act of 1073 touching the submission of the sec of York to Canterbur}' (Will. Malm. iii. 298 ; see p. 358) we read among the aignatures, "Ego Elf\^inuR, Abbas coenobii quod Ramosege dicitiir, conaensi." There is also a charter printed in the Monas- ticoo, ii 559, and in Ceak of ^Ethelsige and ^Elfwine ai l»oth Ablx>t« at once. First among the Abbots signs " iElsius Abbaa," as the Abbot concerned, and last among them we read, " Ego Alwinus Abbas hoc mcum dcsidcrium ad perfectum addaxi ct a Rege hilariter susce])i." On the other hand, it is dear that ^Ethelsige was Abbot of Ramsey at the time of the Sun-ey, for we read (436) of lands in Hampshire, "Hoc sic attcsUtur ElHi Abbaa de Ramesy et totum huudret." From the ■amc nourcc we also learn that he was at one time outlawed, and that he waa at the same time or another in Denmark. In 62 6 wo read of lands in IVrkshire ; " Elsi Abbas tenuit de veteri monas- t«rio Wintonensis ecclesise testimonio seine T. R. E. et postea, donee ullage fuit" And again in 208, of lands in Huntingdon- ■hire; " De altera hida dicunt qufnl Godricus tenuit cam de Abbate. Sed quum Abbas esset in Dancmarka, Osmundus pater Radulfi rapuit earn a Sawino aecipitrario, cui Abbas cam dedcrat ob amorem TTHELSIOE ABBOT OF RAM??EV. 7ol Rogis." Here we plainly see /Ktlielsige iu po8se5Kutoin Hrlhinutn. viniin pru- AT IVo me htmttt Virxiui dcvotinhimuin. in Dacinin iiiiHit, at H prop(i«iitum Rfgu af^oscrrrt v\ pro pare ol)tiiHiul1 a liege DttDonun, uUAiituin €Moi tibi poe»il>ilo, lalHtnuvt. **NaWff«ns iffHar rtatnlnViB AbbiiH, in Dariani pniHi>en> veiiit, Bigiqur M* pnMrnUus, niunera ac senitiu ex park Willielmi novi Rcgtt AngliiP olitulit, ac proccrc« temp niuneriltus honomvit. Rcrereotar igitur a Uegv Danonim receptus et habitun, non inudico laaipore Apod euni mansit. Tandem (pinm ne^otia ]>ro cjuibna ■liwm fiient ad plaeitum i>eregiH>set. licentid redcundi u iUge dati, it«r per mare cum Hoeiin aggrensus est." (iii. 253.) Tlie atory will alao be found at greater length in an English poem of the fourteenth eentur}-, quotetl by Sir Henry Ellis, ii. 99. It u of c*>un«o o|)en to any one to accept the facts that /Kthel- tigd took refuge in Denmark during his outlawry and that he ftllcnrards retunieil, Imt to look on the story of the embassy as a Icgoid gniwing out of these facts, devised to explain his presence in Denmark. But the three lessons given by Langebek, though they run off iiito an ecclesiastical legend, are yet perfectly probable and ooDsistent in their description of the political state of things. Tliere U nothing unlikely, but quite the contrary, in William's wnding an endjassy to Sweud. Indeed the singular failure of Swend to send help at the time when it would have been most I, hiB not coming in person at all, might of themsclveg that William's power of intrigue had been at work. To employ an Englishman and a friend of Harold for such an office wonld be a matter of obvious policy. On the whole the balance of probabilitj seems decidedly in favour of the embassy. Sir Henry Ellis (ii. 105) seems to have confounded iEthelsige with his predeceasor iElfwine. See vol. ii. pp. 372, 621. NOTE il p. 141. The Lands of Ovtha and her Family in the West. The Exeter Domesday is full of entries as to the possessions of the houae of Gf»dwine in the Western shires. They were almost wholly held by the King at the time of the Survey. The greater part of them are entered together in great masses under different LANDS OF OYTHA AND HEK FAMILY IN THE WEST. 753 titles, whidi van- somewhat iu different shires. Of the ffrcat heads of Grown lands, the first (75), headeeen held hy King Eadward himself. The like is the case with the next head (80), " Doniinicatus Regis in Sumer- 8€ta," But the next head, " Doininicatus Regis in Devenescim" (84), Consists, with the exception of a f^ingle iordshij), wholly of lands which had belonged to Gjtha and her sons. The members of the family who appear under this heading are Gj-tha hei-self, Eadgj-th, Harold, and Leofwiue. The names are spelled in various ways, and iu one place (90) Gytha appears simply as " mater llaraldi Comitis." In 90 is the entry, " Terne liegis dominicie iu Comu Galliie," consisting of twelve lordships which had been held by Harold, answering to the entry iu the Exchequer Domes- day, 120, which has the note at the end, "Has prcescriptas xii. terras teuuit Heraldiis Comes T. R. E." Then (94) follows the heading, " Terra? Regis quas tenuit Godwiiius Comes et filii ejus in Sumersetd." The lands under this head had belonged to Gytha, Harold, Tostig, " Godwinus filius Maroldi Comitis" (96), " Gunnilla hlia Comitis Goduiui " (96, 99), and Eddeva (97), of whom more anon. In 104 is a distinct entry of " Terra Editdae Regime in Sumerseta." Also iu 26 is the entry, " Doniinicatus Regis iu Dorseta," consisting of seven lordships which htul been hehl by Harold, six which had been held by King Eadward, one by Gytha under the name of " mater Ihiruldi Comitis," and two churches at Dorchester and elsewhere held by Brihtweard the priest. It is thus plain that the lauds of the lu)use of Godwine formed a large part of the Crown lands kept by William iu the Western shires. Only very small portions of them were allowed to pass into any other hands, and those chiefly into the hands of Wiliiaurs brother Earl Robert. The conquest of the West was, alone among William's later successes, a distinct triumj)li over the house of Godwine. He seems to have purposely kept their lauds iu his own hands as a sort of trophy. Among the members of the house of CJodwiuc who appear iu this list, the largest holdings are those of (Jytha, Eadgyth, and Harold. Leofwiue has several lordships in Devonshire ; iu Somei*set only one for certain, namely, Combe (Exon, 142 ; Exchequer, 87 6), VOL. IV. 3 c Xil APPRNDIX. vllkb ImmI pMwd to Riflhop Odu. The Lcstfwino wlio npiMMirn in ITifltwUMr. 91 6. 9a; Exdn, 3<;a, caii luinily l»e tiio Kurl. Tunti^ ■nwTi M thr owner of a aiii^lc lonlxhip only, tliat of WiiiHfunl in PlimwwL Gviih huMfl nothing in tlu> Went. Wiilfnotli ih*vn not •pfv«r among iiif* brutlupi. hut hoiuo of l\\v IuikIm wliidi H]>]>cHr in the Wiileni •liirt*M m held T. R. K. hy men nanuHl Wulfnoth may Imtv bf«D hi» prt>|nTty (sec Dorwt, 83 6; fcJomorBot, 91 6, 95; DevtMnhire, 103. 106, 109 6, no 6, in, 11 1 l>, ii.t f>, 114 f>* 116, 117 ; Cornwall, 122 b, 123. 123 h). Hut it in |KTimi)H more Ukelj that, likr HaroUrM houm Kiulminul and Mat^niis, he had not reeeiTed any Undi* on account of his youth. Amonj; the hsH known Bembcn of the family, two Somerset lordships are held hy Gunhild the daaghter of (todwine, and two hy God wine the 8(m of Harold. There remaiiiH only the entry of Kddeva in Exon, 97. She can hardly Ik? the Lady, whose lands in Somerset are entered under a •eparate head. Ib it possihlc that wc have here another trace uf Eadgyth Swanneshala 1 NOTE R. p. 141. Thk Children of Harold. Or the ions of Harold, Oodwine is recorded in Domesday (see above, p. 225), and he and his two hrothers Eadmund and Magnus are mentioned in the nairative of Florence (see p. 225, and below, Note DD). Two daughters, Guidiild and Gytha, are known to us from other Rources. Sir Henry Ellis (ii. 127) quotes Capgrave for a story of Guidiild, who is said to have been cured by Saint Wulffrtan. This may be the Gunhild who held seven hides of land at Kingston in Sussex of Harold. (Domesday, 28 6, "Gunnild tenuit de Hcraldo.") Of (iytha we hear more. According to Snorro (Johnston, 220; \ji\i\^, iii. 97), " Gyda Harallds-ddttir " married Valdimar King of H(»lmgard, the son of King .Jaroslaf and of Ingigerd the daughter of King Olaf of Sweden. By him she had a son Harold, from whose daughters Malfrid and Ingibiorg most of the Kings of the North seem to have sprung. Saxo (207) tells us how two sons of Harold took shelter along with their sister at the court of their kinfrman King Swend, by whom the sister, whose name is not THE CHILDREN OF HAHOLI). 755 mentioned, wus j^'ivon in niarria^'c to Kini; \N aldomar, niul a vaf,aio account is Ljivcn of tluir descendants ; " C'ujua fdii duo confestim in Daniam cum Horore ini^-'irunt. Quos Sucno, patemi eoruni merit i oblitus, consanf^uinese pietatis more excepit, pucllamque Ivutenorum Rej^i Waldemaro, qui et ipse Jarizlavus a suis est appellatus, uuptum dedit. Eidem postmmlum nostri temporis dux, ut sani^uinis ita et nominis hwrcs, ex fdia nepos obvenit." Hy Holnij^ard is meant Novgorod and Northern Hussia generally (nee Karamsin, Histoire de Russie, ii. 411). I cannot pretend to any minute knowledge of Russian history, hut, from such light as I can find in Karamsin and the Art de Verifier leg Dates (ii. 112), I cannot identify these princes. Jaroslaf, who reigned from 1019 to 1055, had both a son and a grandson of the name of Vladimir, one of whom is doubtless intended. Ikit the son died in 1052 (Karamsin, ii. 40), and whether the gi-andson, Vladimir son of Usevolod, who reigned from 1 1 1 3 to 1 1 25, married a daughter of our Harold I cannot say. Karamsin (ii. 39, 211, 417) accepts the man'iaj^e, but seemingly not from any Russian authorities, and he certainly knows of no Russian prince named Harold. Vladimir's son and successor was Mstislaf, who reigned at Kief from 112.-, to 1 132. Lappeuberg (557) says, " Die Sohne flohen nacli Irland, Gjihe zu ihres Vaters Vetter Svend von Danemark und wurde mit Waldemar, Czar von Russland, des Wsewold Sohn, vermahlt, dem sie den Sohn Mistislav-Harold und durch diesen eine fernere erlauchte Nachkommenschaft gab." But I do not know Lappen- berg's authority for giving any Russian Prince the double name of Mistislav-Harold. I have already hinted (see p. 142 and vol. iii. p. 764) that these three sons and two daughters of Harold were most likely the children of Eadgyth Swanneshals. None of the three sons who were grown men in 1068 could have been children of Ealdg^•th. Nor is it likely that either of the daughters was hers. Sir Heuiy Ellis (ii. 80) and La])penberg (557) assume a former marriage of Harold, of which they make these children the otfspring, but they quote no authority for such a marriage, and on the whole it seems easier to make them children of I'^dgyth. And their position and that of tlieir mother may have been a.s good as that of Sprota and **the other yKlfgifu " and their sons. As to children of HaroUl and Ealdg\'th, it is certain (see Florence, 3c 2 7A6 ArrKNiMX. 1087) *>*•* HaniKl had « ^••» Wulf wIid wiut iinpriKoiuHl in KurnuuHh*. ami waa rclcancMi liy Williftiii «u Ihh tlnith-InHl. On IIm oUmt hantl. tiic gvn(*ali»^y in I'Morcncc (i. 276) givcK Hurohl a too bj Ealtltfi'»» '" |\ i«ur)*H (iv. 32<;) aocount of tlic invasion of A: in 1098, wc read h(»w Ma^niuH of Norwfty cAmc " cum llaroMo fili»» HHroldi Hogis quondam An«;lia'." The Htatemcnt about Wulf i» no distinct that wo ninnot iijcct it, and a Bon of IInhiM who had no share in tlio warfaiv of his lnothcrs in tlie WvfX, hut who wat a captive in tlie luinds of William, can hardly fail tA» have been a son of tliddgyth, moHt likely ttiken ut Chester. Boi the itftteinent which gives Harold a Kon of iiin own name is not inoomistcut witii the other. iVny child of Harold and Eahlg>-th niugt have Ixfcn born after his father's death ; but Wulf and Harohl may have been posthumous twins, like the two pons — twiua certainly, though most likely not postliumous — of Eadnnind Ironside and the other EaUlgyth. In this case we must suppose that Harold was saved like Lewis from-beyond-Sea (see vol. i. p. 208), while Wulf was taken. Gunhild the daughter of Harold must not be confounded with ber aunt of the same name, the daughter of Godwinc. The latter 11 recordearentibus, genere Angla, i)atrc Oudwino Comite, sub cujus dominio maxima pars militabat Angliai, matre Githa, illustri jirosapia Dacorum oriunda. Hajc dum voveret •dhuc puella virginalem castitatem, de.sideraus spirituale conjugium, •previt oonnubia nonnuUorum nobilium principum. Hajcque dum jam ad nubilem setatcm pervenisset, Anglia devicta a Willelmo Normannonim Comite et ab eodem intcrfecto fratre suo Rege Anglo- rum Haroldo, relicta patria, apud sanctum Audomarum aliquot aancia exulans in Flandria, Xp'm quern pie amabat, in pectore KADNOTH THE STAIJ.KH. 757 scilicet semper colebat in operc circa siln famiilantcs hilariH et mcxlesta, erga extraiieos U'liivola et justa, pauperilms larpa, kuo coq)ori admcxluni parca ; (juitl tlicam, adeo ut omnibus illece}>ri» 8C abstincndo, per multos annos ante siii diem oliitus non vexeretur carnihus, ncquc quidqiuim quod sibi dulce visum est gustando, sed vix necessaria vita? capiendo, cilicio induta, ut nee etiam quibusdam pateret familiaribus, eonflictando cum viciis vicit in virtutibus. Dehinc transiens Bruggas, et ibi transvolutis quibusbey, and it is adde*! in a significant way, "non crat tunc in Abbatia"). The name Eadnoth is a com- mon one, and it is not easy to say which of the various entries under it in Domesday behmg to our P^adnoth. lie nn)st likely is the *' Ednod dapifer " of p. 69, but he cannot be tlie Ednod (nor yet tlie Alnod) of p. I 24 h. Moreover, there can be little doubt that Eadn(»th is tin- person intended by some of tin' entries of Abioator Ilerdin^i qui adhiic HuporcHt, mu^iH eoiMOeCus lin^inm in litcK acui'rc (|Uiini arnia in hello concutere." Wc lia%*c thuji a Ilanlin^' m)U of Kashani in Devonshire ; " Wulward bohtc Leoueile a»t Hierdinjj^ P^adno^s sune wi¥ v. scill. to cepe and to toUc" (Thorpe Dipl. Anjjl. 648). Among the witnesses to the deed we 6nd another " Hiertling " not further described. Harding the •on of Eadnoth can therefore liardly fail to be tlic same person as " Harding filius Alnod," who appears as a King's Thegn in Sonior- wi in Domestlay, 98 6, and who is doubtless the same as the Harding who ia mentioned in several following entries. Besides this, there it • string of entries in Dorset (80) which look very much as if Alumlua, Elnod, Ednod, were used indiscriminately. Of one of these, in which ElmMl apf>ear8 as an officer of Harold and an agent in one of his allege) Harding holds lands in pledge ("in vadimonio") of a cei-tain Brihtric, which lirilitric had held T. R. E., and the lands held by him in Bucking- hamshire (153) had been held T. R. E. by Wulfred and others. There were other lands of which a Harding, whether the same or another, ha) and to Count Alberic (69), and thence to the Crown (see p. 676. This looks like more than an official loss). Othei-s in WarwickshiiT (239 ?>») and Leicestei-shire (231 b) had also gone to Count Alan and to tlic Crown, and others in Dorsetshire (82 b) to Berenger Criffard. Nowhere does anything of Eadnoth's appear in the hands of Harding. This ai>])arent confiscation of the estate of a man who died in William's service suggests that Harding had given some personal offence which was visiter! by partial loss of lands. If he be, as is most likely, the " Hanlingus Uegina' pincenia" who signs the Waltham charter (Cod. Dipl. iv. 159), he probably had a friend ait court to plead for him. As to the d(>seeiidants of Harding, it seems in the highest th-gree Tao APPRNDIX. polAUoUuit tht« lliknling wiw the fnthorof Kol)ort FiU-Hanlin^ of Brktot tbr forvOithor «>f tlio second lino of the Lonln of Ikrkeley. Locml antiqiMritt c«ll Iliinlin^ of Hri^tol a son of "the King of DtBOurk,** a follower of Williiun the Conqueror, Mnyor of liristol, and what not. The unlikeliluxMl of a 8on of Swoml KKtritliH«)n Iwin^j in iKc »roicc of Willuim never strikes them. On the otluT hand, DothinK it nwrr likely than tluit a Tlu'^ni hol«ling li»nfaln)esl)ury, should throw in bin lot with the burghers of the j^roat city which lay on the march of the two shires, and should rise to eminence among them. Another question remains. I was once inclined to identify Rvd- DOth, under the form of Elnod or Alnod, with another " Al nod" whom wc find in other parts of the Kingdom, and who, curiously eooogh, ia charged with deeds of wronf^ of exactly the same kind aa thoae of the Weatcni Eudnoth. This is an Ahiod who seems to be ipecially distinguished as " the Kentishman," and whom I am therefore inclined to identify with the Kentish ^thelnoth whom AVilliani took with him on his first voyage to Normandy (see p. 79). In I)ome«day (at) we read of Middleton in Kent, " Dc silva Regis hal>et Wadanlus [our old friend of the Tapesti*y] tantum quod reddit xvi. denarios per annum et dimidiam, dcnam tenet ; qtum T. R. EL quidam villanus tenuit, et Alnod Cild duas partes cuidam villano \)er Wm abstulit." Next we find in Buckingham- ahire (144 ^, I45), " Alnodus teignus R. E.," " Alnodus Cilt teignus R. E.," and " AIuckI Chentiscus teignus R. E. ;" and in Northamp- tonaliire (220), "Alnod CantuariensiB." To identify this "Alnod" with /Ethelnoth is a matter of conjecture, but it seems at least a more probable conjecture than the identification of Alnod Cild with Wulfnoth the son of Godwine. Sir Henry Ellis (ii. 21) takes thi« from Kelliam (174), who seemingly takes it from a Kentish county history, and it is repeated as if there were no doubt a])out it. but without any reference to Kelliam, in Mr. C. H. l^earson's Hutorical Maps, p. 60. But this notion rests only on the unlucky gneaiof Kelham's Kentish writer, who seemingly thought that "Cilt" waa the same 83 " Clito," and tliat Wulfnoth was called " Cild " " from the royalty of his kindred," Now I do not profess to know HRIHTKIC AND MATILDA. 701 exactly what this most puzzliiifj title of " CiM " means ; it is un- doubtedly applied to the /Kthelintj Ead^^iir, but it is also applied to people who are clearly not so calle), who cannot be. But our I'rihtric appears distinctly as a great landowner in most of the Western shires. We meet him in Doi-set (756, Exon, 30) as the fi>rmer owner of three lordships held by Queen Matilda, with the heading " Has subter scriptas terras tenuit Mathildis Regina," and in Devonshire (loi, Exon, loo) we have the still more distinct heading, " Infra scriptas teri-as tenuit Brietric et post Matildis Kegina." The Queen however had not received the whole of Brihtric's lands in Devonshire, as we find (112, 112 6) some of them in po.ssession of Williatn of Glavile, and in erne place (Exon 370) our Brihtric is ch'arly distinguishe' is added. " Uej^nna (Mil R«»j:trio cum iixore 8ul*' In Cornwall (120) we fiiul an ffktry, " Infni §rriptjui [ternw] IVictrir tonebnt ; ])OKt Mntliilear in Herefonlshire (180 b), and which were in the hands of the King. Immetliately follows the Worcestershire entry of Bisley (sec also 1 73), where we find Brihtric bu}nng land on lease from Bishop Lyfing. It is needless to go tlirough the countless entrie* of the same name in various parts of England, in many of which the l>earer is distinguished in some way or other from Brihtric the w»n of /Elfgiir. We thus find Brihtric the son of ^Ifgar as a powerful Thegn, one to whom leBser Thegns found it expedient to commend them- selves, through the whole of the old Wealhcyn, and also in the toQth-westeni shires of Mercia. We sec also that his lands had a special tendency to fall into the hands of Queen Matilda. He standB out in the Survey as a marked man, almost in the same way as the mcmWrs of the house of God\vine. As for the legend which I Iwvc mentioneeing seized at Hanley, which we see from Domesday was really one of his lordships. The storj' comes from the Continuator BKIIITKIC AND MATILDA. 7G3 of Wtice, ami will be found in KIlis, ii. 55, and Chroniques Anj(lo- Normancles, i. 73. The story, tia far as we are coucenictl with it, runs thus ; I>aquele jadsi, qaiit fu pucelc, Ama un conte dftigleU-Tre Brictrich Mail le oi nomer Apres le roiM ki fu riche ber ; A iui la pucele enuera mcHsager Pur t>a auiur a Iui pri)curer, Meirf Brictrich Maude rcfujia Dune ele m'lt se coruca, H.istiueiuent iner paiwa £ a Willaiu bastard se maria : Qant Willam fu corune E Malde sa feme a reine leue, Icele Malde se purpensa Coment vengier se purra De Brictriche Mau kele ama, Ki a ft-mme pr'ndre la refusa. Tant enchaiita son aeignor, Le rei Willam le Conqueror, Ke de Brictrich Mau lad gmnta De fairc de Iui la volente ; La reine par t4)t le fi^t guerreier K'ele li uolt denheriter, Pris fu a baueleye a son manor, Le ior ke Saint WIstan li ber Sa chapele auoit detUc ; A Wyneestre fu amene, Ilokes inonit en prison Brictricb Mau par treison ; Qant il fu mort senz heir de sei S«jn heritage seisit le Rei, E cum esclieit tint en sa main Dekes il feoffa Rob't fiz liaim : Ki oueke Iui de Nomiandie Vint od m'lt grant cheualerie La t're ke Brictrich li leissa Franchment a Robert dona." We find the story also in the Chronicle of Towkoslmry, printed in the Monasticon, ii. 60, where we find " Haylwardus [.Klfwtanl, iEthelweard, or what?] Snew dictus propter all)edineni, ox illiistri prosapia Regis Edwartli senioris ortus," who flourishes under /Ethelstan in 930, and who, with his wife /Elfgifu, founds in 980 a monastery at Cranborue, to which he makes Tewkesbury, of wliich he was patron, a cell. " Haylwardus" is the father of .KIf;,Mr tlie father of ]>rihtric, a piece of chronology whicli, as usual, attril)ute3 a wonris, habent nobilem virum, scilicet dictum duminum Hrictricum Meaw, et dominum honoris (jllocestrice, exosura, eo quod nollet ei in nnitri- monium eopulari, quum ipse es.set in tninsmarinis partilms circa negotia regia imbassatoria, et ilia erat sola, sed |H)stea nniritata domino Willlclnjo Conquestori, qu;»' tempore opportuno report*). TSI API'KNDIX. licmlUUi A Kont<\ inMiin in ninnorio Htio — ••■• vUxxvii. Kucccssit nilii Willit'lmiiH Kufus filius ejus. IkIc W. H prtHVKKu toniporis dttlit honorem Brictrici Hol)crto filio Haymoniii, rum omni lilxrtatc ct intcj^ritntc qiii])UH pnter 8UU8 vcl etuun ii»»t' HrictricuB umciiuun tonucrunt, et hoc c^nt propter ningnos Ubom quo8 pnwIictuH RolK>rtus sustinuit cum pntro suo." The rrnder mu^t j"out the Honour of Gloucester, nothin;,' about Ilol»ert Fitz-Hamon. But it shouhl he noted that the poem MfB nothing alxnit Gloucester, while it makes "William tlie Con- queror grant Brihtric's lanpendix D. to his :,.,. AI'PRNDIX. CWociUi and EodattasticiU I>i>cuinrnti(, wlicro ho nilcs that, from qAi to ibt nrtinnff of the Coniitih (li(»oohc in tliat of DcvoiiKhirc, the M« w«J mi Saint Qrmiiin''*, but with a hoH of Br( ond catlicilml al im*"**" T\\c church of lUHhuin wnn the Hccnc t)f nmny innnu- ■Hiioai of fUvni (C\h1. I>ipl. iv. 30H ; Iliuldan, 676) whicli hc-l]) ub to Um httt which from DoiiK^hiy we Hhouhl hnnlly have giiCHPed, tKat though Knglii^h naniej* were commtui in Cornwall in the tenth mm! aiercnth centuriea. yet Welhh names were common also. Heavy M the hand of Earl RoWrt fell on the church of Saint Petroc, tliere toe nil no reMon for accepting the story (nee Mon. Angl. ii. 460) thftt he aeiied the whole of its lands. BcHides the lands which Earl Holiert actually seized, there is also (121) a suspicious list of lord«hi|i« which he, a somewhat too powei*ful tenant, held of the church. But Saint Pctroc btill held six lordsliij)8 in his own hands. As for the two mounts and the two monasteries of Saint Michael, there is no doubt that tlie leRser one in Cornwall was in alter times a cell to the greater one in Normandy, but the relations of the two to one another, and of both t<> Earl Robert, at the time with which we are concerned, are anything but clear. I have elsewhere (ii. 519, 520) spoken of an alleged charter of Eadward (Mon. Angl. vii. 989) which j)rofesses to lie a grant to Saint Michael in Normandy. " Tradidi Sancto Michaeli Arch- angelo, in usum fratrum Deo servientium in eodem loco. Sanctum Michaelem qui est juxta mare cum omnibus appenditiis, villis scilioet, castellis, agris, et ca'teris attinentibus." Doubtful as this charter is. the Fpuriousness of that which accompanies it from the same cartularj' is still more manifest. This also professes to be a grant of the Cornish house to the Norman one, made by Earl Robert ; but, to pass by any smaller objections, it is enough that, though it is dated in 1085, it is signed by Queen Matilda who died in 1083, and even by Bishop Leofric who died in 1072, and is followed by an exemj>tion from ecclesiastical jurisdiction granted by the same Prelate "jussione et exhortatione domini mei rever- entisBimi Grcgorii Papae," who did not become Pope till after I^ofric's death. In Domesday both the Norman and the Cornish Saint Michael appear, but there is no hint as to any connexion hetween the two, or as to Earl Robert standing in any relation to either of them, except his usual relation of a spoiler. Saint Michael CONDITION OF WORCESTEK.SHIR?: UNDER WILLIAM. 7r,7 of Cornwall appeai-s in the Kxchcqiier Domesday (120 b), aiui more fully in Exon ( i8y) ; and we read, " Sauctus Miehael liabet i. man- eionem (juae vocatur Treiwal, qiiain teniiit BrLsmarus ea die qua Rex E. fuit vivus et mortuus. ... Do hac inansioue abstulit Comes de Moretonio i. de prudictis ii. liidis qua? erat de doniinieatu beati Michalielis." Thi.s is the only mention of the house that I can find, and it would seem to imply a foundation between 1066 and 108.". Brismar was a man of lar«^e pro[)ei*ty in all the three shires, who contrived to keep one Somerset lordship (99, Exon 455, where he is distingui.shed as " Brismaiiis Anglicus"). He is not unlikely to have been the founder of the Cornish Saint Michael, and, if so, he must have founded it, or at least have given this estate, after Ead ward's death. At all events we have no trace of Earl Robeii in any such character. Elsewhere (65) the Xonnan Saint Michael appears as holding a hide of land and two churches in Wilt- shire on lordships held by the King, one of whieh had belonged to Earl Harold and the other to the Lady Ea(l''vth. It had also three lordships in Devonshire ( 104), two of which had belonged to Harold and one to Gytha. There is one more entry in Hampshire (43) ; " Ecclesia Sancti Michaelis de Monte tenet de Rege i. ecclesiam cum i. hida et decima de manerio Basingestoches . . . Walterius Episcopus [Herefordensis sc] tenuit de Rege, sed non erat de episcopatu suo." It seems })lain then that whatever posses- sions in England were held by the Norman Saint Michael were acquired after William's accession, and that, whoever was the founder of the Cornish house, it was not Earl Robert. A note in the Monasticon (vii. 989) speaks of another tradition as naming Robert's son William as the person who gave the Cornish house to the Noniian one. Here we most likely have the elue to the mistake. NOTE W. p. 174. The Condition of Worcestkrshiiik under Wili.i.vm. The matter of this note also is transferred to the exatuination ot Domesday in the next volume. 70M Al'I'KMUX. NOTE X. p 179. Tm TlTI.KS or QUKKN AM) LaDV. It will be noticed that in the woixls of tho Oironicle quutiKl in Um text tlic I^idy MntiKla is said to be hulloweil to Queeti. The DMMgv is not unlike an earlier one in lof, i, >vlu>re the iVterhoroii^'h Chronicler (toe vol. iL j). 156) F«yH of Kudgylh, " |m forlet t-c cyiif^ W A/e^um, seo wwn gchulgo'8 ipoken of as Lmly i\o\\\\ to the day of lur death (bco p. 587). With this exception, from the coronation of Matilda onwards **cwcn " becomes the usual >vonl ; sec the Chronicles in 1083, 1 100, 1 1 15, 1118. 1 1 19, 1 1 21, 1 123, 1 126 ; ])C8ides 1097 and 1 100 where it in applied to Mar^rct of Scotland, and in 1 140 to a French Queen. But it mubt be remenil>crcd that, while "Lady" was still the regular title in Englifih, *'llegina" had long been familiarly used in Latin. This difference is analogous to that which I mentioned in vol. iii. p. 632 with regard to the wives of Earls, who in English have no title, but whom the Nonnan writers freely call " Coniitissa." In Cod. Dipl. iv. 72 the words " Leofric eorl and his gebedda" become in tlie Latin version more reverentially "Leofricus comes etGodgiva oomitissa.** On the other hand, the style of the Empress Matilda is •' Angli« XomianniaMjue Domina" (Will. Malm. Hist. Nov. iii. 42, 44), and K) in a charter in Rymer (i. 14) ; " Matilda Imperatrix, Henrici Ilegis filia, et Anglorum Domina." But a Queen regnant was something wholly new both in England and in Normandy, and the word " cwen " probably still so far kei)t its elder meaning of wife as to seem hardly suited to one who ruled in her own right. In the Chronicle (1140) Matilda is throughout called ** ]>emperice," while the other Matilda, the wife of Stephen, appears as " j>e kinges cueu." NOTE Y. p. 185. Thk Northern Campaigns of William. Thm« is a good deal of difficulty about the details of William's campaigns, esfKK-ially in the North of England. But the difficulty mainly artseB, not from actual contradictions in our authorities, but THE NORTHERN CAMPAIGNS OF WILLIAM. 769 from one writer recording or dwelling on points which anotlier passes by more lightly or leaves out altogether. "NVe have seen exactly the same sort of thiiig in the narratives of the banishment and of the retuni of God wine. Only now we have to compare, not the narratives of Englishmen of different districts or different j)olitics, but the narratives of men of different anc>iret, of which I uludl ii|K»Ak in another noU». Then tlio Chronicler rrturn* to Exeter and roconln the flij^dit of 0>'tlia. Then come the King's Ewter at Winchester and the Queen's coronati«»n at IVnt(«ost. Then William hears of hostile movements in the North, and goes and builds aistles at Nottini^ham, York, Lincoln, anil (.1^ %k t..>r,v Then " Oospatric eorl and \>ii hetstan menn furon into ^ ." Lastly comes the account of the landing of Harold's •on or sonB and the death of Kadnoth. It is jthiin that in this account there is one great breach of clinint»h»p«'al order. The flight of EadgJir, which is said to be in tbe summer, is put l>eforc Williams Easter Feast on March 23, to ny nothing of the way in which it is thrust in between two events •o closely connected as the surrender of Exeter and the flight of Oyth*. Florence, evidently with this Chronicle before him, cor- rects the order of events. The flight of Gytha is put in its natural place. The flight of Eadgar is put immediately after the corona- tion of Matilda, the later passage about the flight of Go.«patric and others is left out, and the account (1068) stands thus; "Post haec Marleswein et Gospatric et quique Northumbranae gentis nobiliores, Ht-gis austeritatem devitantes, et ne, sicut alii, in custodiam mittc- rentur formidantcs, sumptis secum Clitone Eadgaro et matre sua Agathi, duabusque .s«»roribus suis ^fargareta et Christina, navigio Hcottiam adierunt, ibidemque, llegis Scottorum Malcolmi pace, hieroem exegemnt." Florence also leaves out the account of the Northern movement given in the Chronicle, so that it would seem that it was the flight of Eadgar which led to William's march jto Nottin^rham and York. The Peterborough Chronicle leaves out all these events excci)t the flight of Fjulgar. ImmeTig Melcolm hi eaUe underfeng, and genam |>e8 cildes swuster to wife, Margaretan." THE NOUTHEUN CAMPAIGNS OF WILLIAM. 771 In all this we have no mention of Eadwine and Morkere ; the Nonnan account in Orderic is, during' the present year, equally silent about Eadgar, Mierleswegen, and (iospatric. The Northern movement which bej^an after the Queen's coronation is attributed to the brother Earls, and is described at much greater len^'th (see p. 182). William sets out to quell the revolt, and P^idwine and Morkere submit at Warwick (see p. 192). Then William goes on to Nottin^diam, York, ike. Now, in comj)aring these accounts together, we can have little iloubt as to accepting the revolt and submission of Kadwine and Morkere on the sti*ength of the Norman account. It is far more likely that the Chroniclers should, from whatever cause, have left out the doings of the two Earls than that William of Poitiers should have invented an elalnji-ate romance without any obvious motive. On the other hand, we have just as little reason to distnist the English account of the flight of Eadgarand his companions. It is plain that there is no direct contradiction between the two stories. If we take them as two isolated events, happening without any reference to each other, there is not only no contradiction but no difficulty. The real difficulty is that we can hardly fancy the two events taking place without some reference to each other. A flight of the Iciuling Northumbrian Thegns to Scotland is not likely to have taken })la('e just at the same time as a great stir in Northumberland, followed by a submission of Eadwine and Morkere to William, unless the two things had something to do with one another. The obvious explanation would be that all the i)ei'sons mentioned in the two diflVrent accounts had a share in the Northern movement, that Eadwine and Morkere dealt with their comrades as they had dealt both with Harold and with Eadgar, that they submitted to William and were again received to favour, while the more stout -heart etl sought shelter in Scotland till the coming of the Danish fleet in the next year. This is in itself a ])robable and consistent narrative. The only (juestion is whether it can be made to agree with the woixls of the Chronicles, ** And j^oes sumeres Eadgar cild for lit," ike. At first sight these words would certainly not Itad us to think that the going out of ICadgar and his com])anions was the con- secjuence of something which could bo called a campaign. The motive assigned by Florence for their going out looks still less like it. His account would seem to aj>ply only to men who were 3 »^ 2 772 APrKxnix. Urinp in WillwrnV ronrt. or nt any rate were wholly in hin power. Vet thr woni* «»f the* (Mironiclc. " for ut " (boo p. 256), nmy )»c UVcu m pointing; to nonictliin^ like wnrliko doin^ on the part of Eadpir and the othrm, iind, if m, we muRt throw anido Floronco's intorjirctn- ttoo of their motives as an unPUoceBpful piiesa on hiH part. TliiH is tho mon ' ' ' f\« it is not ciuiy to poo who. except perhaps Ahhot (liKlrie of \\ :iil»e (wv p. 177), had been as yet, in any Ktriet Hcnse, impriiionetl l»y William. It would 1k> no jn'eat fltrotoh of lanpiinp* to call the actual |>oBition i»f the yKthelin^' and tin' Earls at William's court an imprisonment, but Florence clearly conceivcB Ibem •• dreading the fate of sonic other unknown j^erFons who were impri»onea»H •umcrea" points to the time wlien Eadp^ar and Gospatric left William's court to join the Northern revolters, and that the hitcr account of '* Oof-pntric eorl and \>i\ bctstan mcnn" points to their fliirht to Scotland after the submission of Eadwinc and Morkerc. If this l»e allowed, there is no real contradiction in the two nar- ratives ; only each fills up paps in the other. The events of the year 1069 are by some chronological confusion di>'ided in the Peterborougli Chronicle into two years, while in Worcester they are wrongly placed under 1068. Mr. Thorpe has further increased the confusion by dividing the Worcester entries Ijctweon the two years without manuscript authority. See Earle, Pftrnllel Chronicles, 205. If we read them consecutively as the events of a single year, they form a consistent narrative, and one which quite agrees with the account in Orderic. The Peterborough Chronicle records mudi the same events as the Worcester text, only it places the imprisonment of Bishop yEthelric quite out of place, namely before the coming of the Danish fleet in the autumn of 1069, whereaa it certainly did not happen till the beginning of 1070. William grants the Northern Earldom to Robert of Comines, who is killed at Durham. This is recorded by ])otli Chroniclers and by Orderic, and we get minuter details of the Mme event from the Northumljrian writers (sec p. 325). Then eomes the first revolt of York, which is also told in all three •ccounta, only Orderic gives details which are not in the Chronicles, •ipecially the death of Ro}>ert Fitz-Kichard. All agree as to the THE NOKTHEKN CAMPAIGNS OF WILLIAM. 773 presence of Eadgar and u lar^'f hody of Noi-tliunibrians, only, while tlie Chroniclers name no one cxcfpt luulgar, Orderic nientiuns also Gospatric and Ma'rlcswegen. All mention the defeat and retreat of the Engliah (" ceteri sunt fugati"), and the Chroniclers distinctly add that the /Etheling went back to Scotland. Tlien in Orderic and the Worcester Chronicle comes the second expeilition of Hiirold's sons, the details of which I shall discuss in Note DD. Then comes the Danish capture of York and all that followed it. In all this there is no contradiction between Orderic and the English Chroniclers. But now comes the singular fact that in the narrative of Florence the coming of Robert of Comines to Durham and the first revolt of York are left out. That is to say, ho leaves out all that appears in the Peterborough Chronicle under 1068, all that appears in the Worcester Chronicle under that year, cxcei)t the Devonshire expedition of Harold's sons. Florence in short records nothing between their two expeditions in 1068 and in 1069. Now Florence certainly wrote with one or both of the Chronicles l>efore him, and a great part of his work was to arrange under their proper years the events which they record with some chronological confusion. His services in this way I fully accept, and I have taken his chronology as the gi'oundwork of my own narrative. But are we therefore to follow him when he leaves out several im])oi-tant events which, however confused may be the chronology, are told in the Chronicles with perfect distinctness and are con- finned by other authorities ? The story of Robert of Comines no one would probably reject, told as it is in both Chronicles, in Orderic, in Simeon's Durham History, and in the Northern inter- polations of Florence, whether those come from Simeon or from any one else. The first revolt of York is not quite so clear. A revolt of York in the spring, in which Eadgar appears and which William comes to crush in jierson, might be ea.sily taken for a mere forc- Btalling of that undoubted revolt of York in the autumn at which also Eadgar appeared, and which also William put down in person. Florence wouKl hardly have struck one of the revolts out of the narrative in the Chronicles uidess he had thought that the one was a repetition of the other. And this is the more remarkable, because he keeps both accounts of the two expcilitions of llaroKl's sons, whi(;h it is <|uite a.s tempting to look on as two account* of the 771 APPKNDIX. mmr cTOOt ■■ lo look in the •ainc wny on the two n mu\ rtJMHr«l it in tho other. Hut tho wcijfht of Iuh jud^fcnirnt is Boinowlmt wmkrcMvl b^ hu aIko utrikinf^ out the story of Kol>crt of Coitiinon, of tht tniU) of which there cnn be no reanonnhlo (lou]>t. On the oo lield to l>e pomowhftt confirniod bv the way in whicli Simeon (if Siine«»n it ho) tnatiul hiH narrative. He rv(it«»red the 8t«»rj- of Rolvrt of ConiinoH and inserted a notice of thf* foundation of Selhy Abbey ; but ho did not restore the account of the springe revolt Rut the negative nuthf)rity of Simoon b afTiiin weakened by the fact that ho hft« not nioroly failed to in- •ert, but has positively Ftnick out of the narrative of Floronro, a iiKMtt ini|M)rtAnt piece of Northumbrian history, of which there can be no doubt, and which is indeed necessary to the understanding of his own narrative. This is no other than William's Northern marrh and occupation of York in 1068, thoufjh without it we cannot undenrtand the presence of the Normans at York in the autumn of 1069. And when wc look at the narratives of tlio pprinp revolt in Ordcric, we shall certainly be inclined to think that details like the deiith of Robert Fitz-Richar«l, the message of William Malct, the building of the second tower (see p. 241 and the note at p. 203) could not Ik* mere inventions or confusions. There is really nothinf^ improlmble in the story that Eadirar and the Nortlniml)rians tried their own powers early in the year, and, on being worsted, tried again in the autumn with the help of the Danes. I therefore accept the double revolt and double submission of York, rea^ling the entries in the Peterborough Chronicle under 1068 and 1069 as the events of a single year, and that year 1069. The cause of the chronological confusion seems to be tliis. The entries in the Worcester Chronicle, under the years 1065 and 1066, run over, as they often do, into the next year. That is to say, the year is made to begin at Easter. Thus the coronation of Harold is placed under 1065 and the voyage of William to Normandy under 1066. This loft the year 1067 almost void of events, the only things rcoonlofl >x*ing William's return and the burning of Christ Church, the death of Bishop Wulfwig, and the short account of Eailric's doings in Herefordshire, all told very briefly. But by this way of reckoning the siege of Exeter is thrust back into 1067, and with the siege of Exeter a paragraph ends in Mr. THE NOUTHEKN CAMPAIGNS OF WILLIAM. 775 Earle's etlition. Then conies the long passage alM)ut Eatl<,'ar anil Margaret thnist in between the fall of Exeter and the flight of Gytha. This insertion or rhapsody has driven out the projM'r heading of the year 1068, the annal for which clearly begins with the wonis, '' On |>isan Eastron com se kyng to Wincestre." The yeai-8 1067 and 1068 having been thus run together, the event** of 1069 were assigned to 1068. Then the short account of the early events of 1070, the reconciliation of AValtheof (see p. 303), and the plunder of the monasteries (see p. 328), which, acconling to the reckoning followed, should have come into the annal for 1069, has, ])roba]>ly in some attempt at correction, got shoved on to 107 i, and the reckoning of this Chronicle remains a year in advance till it breaks off. In Peterborouj'h the confusion is of a different kind. The entry for 1067 stands thus; '*//«>• for se cyng ofer sie, and ha?fde mid him gishis and sceattas, and com \>ces o^res geares on See Nicolaes maessedaeg .... and ]^s sumeres for Eadgar cild ut," &c. Tliis entry follows two ways of reckoning. William's going into Normandy was "her" or in 1067, if the year began at Christmas or on January i. But the reckoning which begins at Easter would place it in 1066, and, according to this reckoning. Saint Nicolas' day in 1067 would be " |)«s o^res geares." Again, reckoning William's voyage to 1067, the flight of Eadgar in the summer of 1068 would be " |)3es o^res geares," though not in the same year as William's return. Tlie Chronicler must have had accounts before him which followed both reckonings. The events of 1067 and 1068 thus got jumbled together. To make matters straight, the events of 1069 were divided into two years, but from the latter part of 1069 the reckoning goes on rightly. We now come to the gi-eat Northern cam[)aign of 1069 1070. The English account here is simply fragnuntary. The two Chroni- cles, Florence, and his Nortlniinbrian etlitor, confine themselves wholly to the events at York ; oddly enough, they take no notice of the movements along the whole western side of England, from Cornwall to Chester. Noi- (h. they take any notice of the earlier course of the Uanisli fleet and its att»'inpts on south-eastern Ent,dand (sec i)p. 251-253); they arc contrnt to begin their story when the fltet (utiis the IIumbtT. They then descril)e the taking y^ .vrrENDix. 0f Yoris bvUie Dftuat aimI Kn^liNh nml 'Un n>covery )>>' Willmm, and Umi fveoni the deniUtion of N\>rtiiuiii)K>rl(Uul. But the rich and nmcd dotAiln. which Hhow thnt the c«in|mi^ni won not a mcro local warfarp, hut ft warfare R|»rv«tl over tlie p-catcr part of EMiaod* oome mainly from OnK'ric, wlio jlouhtlcsn followiMl William of Mtiera. For the wh«>lo westoni sido of KiiLrland. with tho Binj^'le •lenilioQ of the Devoiuihire expcilition of litiroKlH HonH, Ordoric ii our only guide. In the extreme North wc can compare him with the Ehirham writers, who do not always pick out the same §uiM fpedally to dwell on, hut who certainly confirm the general run of hif story. THie aoooonts given by the two Chroniclers of the events nt York teem quite independent of each other. Each supplies Home fiict« which arc wanting in the other. For instance, Worcester gives the names of Uospatric and Ma?rleswe^en among the Elnglish and Tlmrkill among the Danes, while Petcrljorough mentions only Cadgar, Osbeorn, and the sons of Swcnd — two in Peterborou^'h, three in Worcester. Worcester reckons the fleet at two hundred and forty ships, Petorhorough at three hundred. Worcester alone mentions the burning of the minster, and Peterborough only mentions that the Norman commanders were among the captives taken ("pa heafodmen hsefdon on beandon." See p. 269). But the two accounts essentially agree, except in one point where the Woroester writer seems to be led away by a local feeling. The thing which mainly strikes him is the death of Archbishop Kaldred, formerly his own Bishop, which he ])uts before the Danes came at all (see p. 266), whereas they were already in the Humber, hut had not yet reached York. Florence corrects this, and gives more exact dates of cver}'thing ; but his account is clearly an expansion of the W'orcester nan-ative. Simeon inserts one or two things ; thus he restores the name of Gospatric, which Florence leaves out. Florence again mentions the captivity of William Malet^-one of the " heafodmen " spoken of in the Peterborougli Chronicle — and Simeon adds Gill>ert of Ghent. The captivity of these men was most likely passed over by William of Poitiers, as there is no mention of it in Orderic, but the fact turns up in Domesday (see p. 270). The single word " fordyde" by which Pcterlxirough describes the great harrying is somewhat expanded in Worcester, somewhat more so in Florence, and naturally most THE NUKTHEUN CAMPAIGNS OF WILLIAM. 777 of all ill Simeon, who however looks at the matter from a purely Durham poiut of view. Orileric (see p. 289) adds some reiuarkahio details, hut it is from the Evesham writer (see p. 315) and from various entries in Domesday that wo learn over how lai-ge a part of England William's ravages were spread. From the Chronicles and Florence however we should hardly have found out that the warfare of 1069-1070 touched any part of the country beyond Yorkshire, antl even Simeon would hardly take us beyond Xorthumberland. For the rest we must go to Orderic, that is to William of Foitiers. It is much to be regretted that in large parts of his narrative we have no means of checking him by any English wi'iter; but I see no reason to doubt the general truth of his story. It is our only detailed narrative of the real Concjuest of England; the English writei"s give us only fragmentary portions of the process. The story is probable and consistent, except in two places. One is the extraordinary confusion which seems to make the same force march at once to Shrewsbury and to Exeter (see p. 279), a confusion the more strange in Orderic, who was born in the neighbourhood of Shrewsbury. Of this I cannot suggest any explanation, but the geographical difficulty in Ordcric's account of William's march after Christmas 1069- 1070 (see p. 306) is fully exi)lained by Mr. Hinde's correction. William sets forth to chastise certain enemies who are said (515 B) "in angido quodam regionis latitare, marl vel paludibus undique raunito." These enemies ho follows as far as the Tees (" ad fluraen Tesiam insequitur") ; they were therefore somewhere near the mouth of the Tees, on the York- shire side. But directly after (515 C') we read, " Haugustaldani revertebatur a Tesia ; " the difficulties of the march are set forth, and as the goal of the journey we read of William as " Eboracum reversus." A march from the mouth of the Tees, or from any part of the course of the Tees, to York by way of Hexham, which must be meant by " Ilaugustalda," is of coui-se a geogi'aj>hieal absurdity. I have somewhere seen it proposed to reatl '' Kbomcum " for " Haugustaldani." But no tnmscriber would jmt the less known Hexham for the better known York, with the furlluM- result of tiirniiig 8en.so into nonsense. But if the right reading be, as Mr. Ilinde suggests, Helmsley or Hamclac, nothing was more likely than that a transcriber might turn it into Hexham, a name less known than ^^)rk. but ineomparal)Iy Ultrr known than Helmsley. •7g ArPKNDlX. WiUkm' —h WW thrrrforo IhmuRh the (McvelamI hilln, niul the ni—Ki V ;- tlunn^; tho rrtuni nmrrli tluit tho iliflicultirH of tho rvAil arc mainly imuntrd on iii cli»ul»tlojiH l»ofaUHC in tho incauwhilo ImmI »ri in — " in acrrbisKinio hieniis gi'lu tranhivit." VOTK /. i». iRH The SrnMissioN of Oxford. TlIK tUtc of tho HuldiiU'bi'tn of Oxford to Williani is very doulit- ful. One would have hcen inclined to place it in 1066, when William wa« i»o near an \Vullin<;ford. and the influence of W'ij;ocr nnium tilitjuoi dMpci«itionibai tervi . . . piMtOfi, aicut so ImlNMit ren mor- ^liwi KefgtB ctyttKl«m beneficiu coiiKilii delilH^nitionc cunonicin ptsiUia MA rant rcwtitutn ot uh4|Uo nd aniniin mcxxii. cidiMii •eoUmi pnsllicrunt" Now wliatcvcr in tu Ik; inndo uf ho luinc a ilory m ihla» it U certain from Doniesday that, at tlic tiino of the Survcv, the canonB of Saint FrithHwj-th's were in full poHocBsiou of their pm|>erty. The story of the fighting monks of Oxfonl WDuUI not luive been allowable even in an historical novel, as it does not roppleuient the facts of history, luit contradicts them. NOTE A^V. p. 189. TniRKILL OF W.VBWICK. TuK&B can be little doubt that Thurkill of Warwick or of Arden another of thowj men of English or of Danish descent who, like Wigod of Wallingfonl, contrived to win the Conqueror's favour, and to retain or even to increase their estates under his govern- ment. He stands out more consj>icuously in Domesday than any other Englishman, his lands filling more than four columns (240 />- 2416). Two lordships were held of him in pledge by no less a ])crson than Robert of Oily, of one of which we read (241), "Ailmarus teouit, et lieentid Regis vendidit Aluuino vicecomiti patri Turchil." In the same page and the next, it is noted of two of Thurkiirs lord- ships, " Aluuinus pater T. tenuit." Tliis gives us a Sheriff ^Ifwine ss the father of Thurkill, and the Survey helps us to a little more knowledge of yKlfwine himself. He was a benefactor to the Abbey of Covcntr}' in the time of King Eadward, but his benefaction had shared the fate of so many other ecclesiastical lordships and had passed into the hands of a lay stranger. We read in Warwick- ahire (2386, 239 h) of lands which had been held by Earl Alberic and were now in the hands of the Crown; "Ipse Comes tenuit CUpstone. Aluuinus Vicecomes tenuit T. R E. et cum terra liber fuit."* A marginal note adds, " Hanc terram dedit Aluuin eoclesix de Coventreu pro anima sua T. R. E. Comes Albericus abstolit." Tlie earlier entry adds that yElfwine's grant was made THUUKILL OF WARWICK. 781 **concc8STi Regis E. et filiorum Buorum et testimonio comitatCifl," and the act of Alheric is put more Btrongly, " injuste invasit et ecclesiae abstulit." We seem to find him a^aiin in Oxfordshire (i6o/>), where we read, *• Alwi Vicecomes tenet de lU', where we get the further information that young Richard, doubtless a Norman favourite, had been in possession in King Eadward's days ; " Willelmus Goizenboded tenet Celvestune et Willelmus de co. Ricardus juvenis tenuit T. R.E." If "Aluui" and "Aluuinus" are two men, we meet with two notices of the fonner in Gloucestei-shire (162 6, 163). where we read of one estate, *' j)rrpstitit Aluui Vicecomes," and of another, "Aluui Vicecomes misit extra firmam." Thurkill has become a kind of mythical pei^son in local history, and has got rai.xed up with Warwick Castle and with other things witli which authentic records do not bring him into connexion (see Dugdale's Wanvickshire, jjp. 301 , 606). His Domesday de- scription is " Turchil de Warwic," but there is nothing in the Survey which connects him in any special way with Warwick Castle, Tts ArrKNDix. tiKNigli Im bolib boQMi in tlie lx)rou^h (241 h, 238). In tlio Abii^vloii Hutory (ii. 8, ao, at) \w upiH'uni an a benefactor of tbiit AbUy. Hr u dcscnbed m Tlmrkill of Anleu— " TurkiliuH do Altlcoe," *'Turkillu9 ({uidani de Anglin, valdo intor kuom noliiliM in ptttibua Ardene nuuuutant." llin connrxion with Aliinirdon in •bown ftlfo ID DomeMlay (341 l>), %vlu-iv the Al>l»ey of Aliiii^don appfMV M tenant of one of TliurkiU'H WanvickHhirc lordbhipH ("de T. tenet AbUui de AlnMulone "). and whnv wc alno reud (239), "AbliAtia de AU'ndone hidK;t in Uillo ii. hidus qua8 emit Abbas de fcudo Turchilli." Thiirkill uIho appears ( 160 b) an holding a single lunUlup in OxfonlHhiri'. The entries of Think ill's Wur^vickshire estates jut of grc4it ini- portAnce as illuttrating the relation between Nornmn and English landowners, but I re8er\'e them for examination elsewhere. Tlmrkill is said (see Ellis, i. 497) to have had a sou Siward, who WIS dispooBesse^l of the greater part of his lands by William Rufus. The luune Siward constantly appears as a Burname in the reign of Henry the Third. Cunealogists might do some service by finding out whether its bearers were descendants of Tlmrkill and iElfwine. NOTE liB. p. 195. The Date op the Makiuage of Malcolm and Margaret. TuERE in an apjmrent contradiction between the Chronicles under tJic year 1067 and Simeon, or whatever we are to call the Northern intcrjwlator of Florence, under 1070 as to the date of the marriage of Malcolm and Margaret. The Chronicles seem to place the marriage in 1067 or 1068, soon after Eadgar's first flight to Scotland (see p. 195). Simeon distinctly places it at some time I not earlier than 1070, when he makes Eadgar and his sisters agmb seek shelter in Scotland after the final fall of York. This contradiction is made the most of by Mr. Hindc, both in his History of NortbumWland (i. 186) and in his edition of Simeon (86), in order to depreciate the value of the Northumbrian insertions. Tlie XNorcester Chronicle (see above, p. 770) inserts an account of the flight of Eadgar and the marriage of Margaret under the DATE OF MAKKIAGE OF MALCOLM AND MAliOAKET. 783 year 1067 (1068) between its entries of the fall of Exeter and the fliglit of Gytha. This} account is manifestly out of place, ami I cannot lielp thinkiiiLj that the whole passage, whose prolixity and scriptunil quotations form a strange contrast to the short entries on each side of it, is an interpolation. It is a sort of little Life of Saint Margaret, setting forth her inclination for a single life, the courtship of Malcolm, the ditHculties which he met with, the final consent of Margaret and her kinsfolk, the marriage and its final good results. Lastly we get Margaret's pedigree on both sides, and then we go back to Exeter. It is clear that this is not the annalistic way of writing ; things are put together which have a connexion of idea, but not of time. The mention of Eadgar's flight to Scotland is followed by an account of all which came of it in the end, but we need not suppose that all happened in the year 1068. The reformation of Malcolm and all Scotland could hardly have been quite so speedy as that. And, as Maigaret refused for a long time to marry Malcolm, we can hardly infer that even the marriage haj)pened in 1068, but rather the contrary. Tlie Peterborough Chronicle, in its shorter account, which I have quoted above (see p. 770), would be much better evidence in favour of the early date of the marriage than the longer Worcester entry. Our first impression from its words would certainly be that the niai-riage took place almost immediately on Eadgar's first reaching Scotland, but then we know from the longer Worcester account that this was not so. We are in fact driven to believe that the shorter account, no less than the longer one, follows the order of ideas and not of time ; indeetl the Peterborough account looks very like an abridgement of that of Worcester. And the chronological con- fusion of these years must not be forgotten (see al»ove. p. 774); tlic flight and the marriage are in both Chronicles j)ut under 1067, whereas, on any showing, they did not happen till 1068. Florence records the flight of Eadgar and his sisters and their reception by Malcolm under 1068. He nowhere records the marriage, though he implies it in his narrative of the deaths of Malcolm and Margaret in 1093. lUit in the entrj' of 1068 he uses an expression which is of some importance. Eadgar and the rest, including his sisters, " navigio Scottiam adienint, ibidemque, Hegis Scottorum Maleolmi j>ace, hiemem exegenint." A\'e know that the stay of Eadgar and the Northumbrian chiefs in Scotland was not rtl AITRNDIX. XlMy fUyf^l thrrr liuring the winter of 106H ; but in io^>9 llwy twin left Sci>tliuul ami once rcturtKsi to it (hco pp. 238, 243, •5i» 505)' *^*' ^o'^J* **f Florence would Keeni to imply that Maii^mrH and (*hriittina aloo lefl ScotlAnd in 1069 ; they et>rtninly •Mm quite inctinaistent with tho notion of Margaret marr}'ing Ifaloolni in 1068. Mjufr^rvt't own biographer Turgot givoa no date to her mnrriiigc. William of Malmcdbur}' mentions the nianingc more than once, but he nowhere gives it a dnto. He Hpeaks of it first when he records the return of the /Etheling Endward to f^n^dund (ii. 228), but be says no more than " l^fargnrcta, (juani ]\Iah-olniu8 Rex Scottonim legitimo inatrinionio duxit." In his account of William's reign (iii. 249), where he is grouping together several classes of CmIs, not by tlieir dates but by their subjects, he says, " Malcolmus omiMi Anglorum j^erfugas libenter recipicbat, tutamcntum singidin quAotum i^iternt impendens ; Eme time between 1064 and 1068. And we have to dispose of her in such a way that a saint could consent to take her place. Malcolm may have put away wives as readily as Uhtred, but Margaret would surely be more scrupulous than her great-aunt DATE OF MARRIAGE OF MALCOLM AM) MARGARET. 785 (see vol. i. p. 358). And we can hardly conceive that the widow and mother of Earls of Orkney could have l>een taken •' more Danico." In all this, as it seems to mo, we have nothing to fix the marriage to Eiulgiir's first stay in Scotland in 1068- 1069. And we have another distinct account which puts it in 1070 or 107 1. This is in those Northumbrian insertions in the chronicle of Florence which I am still inclined to call by the name of Simeon. In this version (pp. 86-88) Malcolm is ravaging Xorthcrn P^ngland, and is in the very act of burning the church of AVcaniKHith (see p. 505), when he sees the ships in which Eadgar and his sisters and other English refugees are again seeking shelter in Scotland. He welcomes them and promises them a friendly reception in his Kingdom (see p. 505). By the time Malcolm has got back to Scotland the English exiles get there also, and the marriage seems to take place pretty soon ; " Quo [in Scotiiim] etiam Clitonem Eadgarum cum sociis supra nominatis prospero pervexit cureu. Cujus Eadgari sororem Margaretam Rex Malcolnms, consensu pro- pin(|Uorum illius, matrimonio sibi junxit." The account goes on with Margaret's paneg}'ric, setting forth the good effect which she had upon Malcolm, and the number and names of her cliildren. Now this insertion is one of those j)assages which Mr. Ilinde, undoubtedly the best modern writer on Northumbrian matters, picks out specially to assail the authority of the Northumbrian interpolator. *' The first thing which .startles us," he says (i. 186), " is the circum.stance of the author placing contemporaneously the flight of Edgar with his mother and sistei's to Scotland and the embarkation of Bishop Egelwin for ( 'ologne, and assigning as a common date the year 1070. This date is coirect as regards the departure of the Bishop, but all our authorities, including Florence, with whose work the above quotation is interpolated, agree in fixing the flight of Eur uutlioritiott, including Flort*nco, ... MCit« in fixing . . . the mAiriagc of Mnlcolin at all cvontH two ynun prrriottt," for Florenoe doei not mcntioii tlio inarriu^ at all. For my own piu-t I soe no contradiction. I do not seu tlmt tho *" '•-« positirelj place the marriage in 1068, and the nepitivo *... V of Floirnce is tgaiuBt so early a dntc. The C'lirouicleH Im^T it uncertain wiiat l)ecame of fkulgar after tho hwt fall of York. tilU up the ^p in tho most pix)))a1)le way with u third " tland, foUoweil by a niamago lx?tween Mulcohn and .\int^'»n't. That marriaj^e may liave l)een, as Oixleric wiys, de- tigneil in the time of Ejidward ; in 1068 it certainly was, whether on account of the matter of lugebiorg or purely from her own oeh'batc tastes, utterly offensive to ^[arg^ux't. By all accounts it took some time to overcome her Bci-uples ; to me it seems that they were not overcome till 1070. Of the two last and best writers of Scottish historj', Mr. E. W. Robertson (i. 135) distinctly accepts the later date for the marriaj,'e. Mr. Burton (i. 405, 406) is less clear. Speaking of 1068 he says, " one of the sisterp, Margaret, was afterwards married to Malcolm ;" but in the next page he speaks of Malcolm as already Eadgar's brother-in-law in 1069. NOTE CC. p. 206. The First Slbmission of Malcolm. Mr. E. W. Robertson (ii. 480) calls this submission of Malcolm in question, mainly because it is recorded only by Orderic, who does not record the homage at Abeniethy in 1072. If we weeded out our hiijtor)^- on this principle, there would be little left for us to l)elieve; a larg»? part of our narrative has to be made up by piecing together this fact recorded by one writer and that fact recorded by another. The inik^rtions and omissions in all our authorities are singularly capricious ; and, if it is reason enough to reject a statement that is found in Orderic only, we must cast away most of the details of the eaiDpaigns of 1068- 1070, that is, our only conuected narrative of the real conquest of England. TIIK FIRST SrnMlS.SloN OF MAHOL.M. 787 Of that narrative this su])mis8ion of Malcolm is a part, and tho stor}' hangs quite well together. Malcolm had cngjiged to help the Northumbrians in their resistance to William ; hut, whether through faithlessness or through unavoidable hindrances, he had failed to fulfil his promise. After the fall of York, he makes a nominal submission, which William accepts. Such a course exactly suits the position of the two Kings. Malcolm had no more inten- tion than usual of abiding by his submission, but he staved off any immediate attack on the part of William, and he husbanded his forces for another time. To accept such a nominal submission was of a piece with William's whole policy. He received tho fonnal acknowledgement of his superiority as a means towards establishing a real superiority at some future time. Mr. Robertson argues that, if Malcolm had submitted, the Conqueror would have pro- vided against the recei)tion of Eadgar and his followers by Mal- colm. On my view this presents no kind of difficulty. AVilliam's object was to obtain from Malcolm a formal submission which he would afterwards be able to use ajrainst him. He would not luizard this advantage by insisting on conditions which he had no immediate means of enforcing. On the other hand, Mr. Robertson is quite successful over Sir Francis. Palgi*ave on another point. Sir Francis (Eng. Comm. ii. cccxxxi) has conjured up an invasion of Scotland in 1068-1069, in which William's son Robeii plays the leading part, and the result of which is the submission of Malcolm. This comes, as Mr. Robertson truly says, from transfernng hither a passage from the Abingdon History which really belongs to the year 1080 (see p. 675). An invasion of Scotland in 1068 is utterly impossible, and young Robert would be a most unlikely commander to be sent on such an errand. Sir Francis Palgrave does not seem to lepcat the story in his History of Normandy and England, i>ut his nain-ative just at this stage is not verj- clear. 3Ea f^ ArrKNDix. Tub ExrKDiTioxs of Harold's Sows. It 15, I think, rlwir thiit two distinrt ntt-eniptH were mnd*; I»y the toofl of HiiroKl in the West of Kni,'laiul. in two HUccfssive yearn, 1068 and 1069. As so often hapiuMis, there is no contmdiction fiMMiff our authorities, tliough each tills up oiniBsiouH in the others. The exjiedition of 1068 mainly affected Bristol and Somerset, and wms r^pulsctl by the citizens of Bristol any the Breton Count Brian. It is thus easy to sec why the Noniuui >NTiters speak of the second attempt only. Tl»e fullest account of the attempt of 1068 is that given in the Worcester Chroniele, which I have followed in the text. Florence is fuller only in mentioning three sons of Harold and giving their names, Godwine, Eadmund, and Magnus, while the Chronicler simply mentions one son without giving hi.s name. Here i» no contnulietion ; Gotlwiue was doubtless the eldest brother and the comnuinder of the force, and Eudnmnd and Magnus might be mentioneendent, and which fixes, from what aource I know not, the number of his ships at fifty-two. William of Malmesbury (iii. 254) brings in the story in his usual incidental way, not in its chronological order, but as an illustration of William's jwlicy in setting Englishmen to fight against English- men. But he makes no special mention of Harold's sons ; the adventurers arc simply some Englishmen who had taken shelter in Ireland and Denmark ; " Contra quosdam, qui post pnmam infelieis ominis pugnam Danemarchiam et Hiberniam profugerant, et valida congregate manu tertio anno redierant, Angligenam exercitum et dncem objecit." Bee p. 226. The Worcester Chronicle alone mentions the first harryings at the mouth of the Avon and the unsuccessful attempt on Bristol ; the account in Florence l^egins with the landing in Somerset and THE EXPEDITIONS OF HAKOLl/s SONS. 789 tlie battle with Eadnotli. He however adds the harryings in Devonshire and Cornwall after the battle, which the Chronicle does not record. The second expedition in 1069 is also recorded by the Worcester Chronicler and by Florence. It is not mentioned by William of Malmeslniry or by the Winchester writer, but it is mentioned by Orderic (513 A), and by William of Jumibges (vii. 41). It is from these two latter writers that we get the name of King Diarmid as the protector of the exiles. All the accounts agree in speaking of two sons of Harold without mentioning their names, so we are left to guess which of the three were those concerned in this second attempt. Tlie geography of the campaign is worth studying, as the way in which one story fills uj) another is very curious. All that Florence tells us is that they landed at the mouth of the Taw or the Tavy and were defeated by Count Brian ; *' De Hibernia venientes, in ostio fluminis Tavi applicuerunt, et cum Breona Brjionico comite grave pro^lium commisenmt ; quo confecto, undo venerant retlienmt." The Chronicler fixes the place of their landing to the mouth of the Taw — " into Taw mu^an " — but this at first sight seems only the more contradictory to Orderic's story of their attacking Exeter ; " Xaves armata manu oneratas ducentes Exonio api>ulerunt. Deinde progredientes a littore teiTam audacius de- poj)ulari cceperunt, et fen-o igneque furentes maxima patrare damna conati sunt." Orderic, or William of Poitiers, is clearly so far wrong in his geography as to fancy that the fleet sailed up the Exo instead of the Taw, but his account of an attack on Exeter is not therefore to be cast aside. We have a sort of climax t»f witnesses to Bhow that the harrying was far more widely spread than any one would think from the words of Florence, and that it stretchec'r lrlun«linoH ImmbIm*.** Tht> luiinc* nf tlie plncpj* nro fpven as TorloKtan, PaelMdoiM, ColcConn, IliuiH. Wnlfnintoun, Portliinuita, Rf DfVjniHhirc U^\Hy- ffmphr to Ulcntify every one of thonc phuvH, but I can reco^- nisp ap^Tnil of them which lio in widely distant pnrtfi of the ■htrv. 'vM^'"' '■tona" i» |)rcdm)»ly Alwinj^ton near Hiileford, in the Deigli h1 of their landin^-plnce, while there arc two Obljtona, both in the 8outh-ea8tcrn part of the shire towardH Domt. In the course of a harrying which spread bo far uh this, an attack on Kxetcr itself would \)c anythinj,' but unlikely. Uuiah agnin and Portlcinouth are in the pouth-wcHtern part of the c«»untv towanls riyinouth, while " Walenintona" would seem to be Walkhampton near Launceston. We thus find in Domesday a raTa^ng of Devonshire *' per Irlnndinos homines " which touched the whole pouth and west of the shire. We can hardly fail to identify this exi>ee found in the Monasticon, ill. 485. \s usual, a particular Ijuilding was sho"WTi as his birth- BIRTH AND EDUCATION OP HENRY THE FIRST. 791 place, and, as usual, the buililini? was of far later date. Indeed, however freely we may constnie the wonls of Simeon of Durham under tlie next year 1069, ** Ctenobium Stincti (Jermani de Sikhi Humpsit exordium," it is quite impoKsihle to believe that there was any settled monastery or town at 8ell)y at any time in the year 1068. If therefore Henry was bom at Selby, it e(»uld oidy have been through some such accident as I have suggestetl in the text. The reader must judj^'e whether there is any probability of such being the case. I should myself have cast aside the Sell)y story as utterly unworthy of attention, except for two reasons. Fii-^t, the inherent unlikelihood of the tale itself is really something in its favour; it is hard to believe that the local vanity of Selby could have taken so strange a form, if there had not been some groundwork to go uj)on. Secondly, thouj^h a birth at Selby was a thing not at all to be looked for, a birth at York was a thing by no means unlikely to be deliberately planned. But the whole matter is of no great importance, and it must be left in uncertainty. As to the unusual care bestowed on Henry's education, and the unusual amount of his learning, there seems to be no doubt. The only question is how far his education was an English one. Orderic himself says (510 D), " Hie dum dociles annos attigisset, litterarum scientiam didicit." And in another passage (665 D), "Hie in infantia studiis literaiiim a parentibus traditus est, et tam naturali (piam doctrinali scientia nobiliter imbutus est." William of Malmesbury enlarges still further on his literary acquirements, and he says i)lainly that on account of his royal birth he was the only one of A\'illiam's sons who was looked on as entitled to the English Crown. That this latter argument had a sound foundation in English law I have already shown (see vol. i. pp. 1 17-291). The wh(de passage (v. 390) runs thus ; ** Ilenricus, junior filius Willelmi magni. natus est in Anglia anno tertio posttpiam pater cam adierat ; infans jam turn omnium votis conspirantibus educatus egi-egie, quotl solus omnium filioniiu Willelmi natus csset regie, ct ei regnum videretur competere. Itaque tirocinium nidimentorum in scholis egit lite- ralibufl, et librorum mella adeo avidis medullis indidit ut nulli postea bellonim tumultus, nulli cuninim motus, eas excutere illustri animo posseiit." So Will. Gem. viii. 10; " riurimi sunt hetati, Tff ArrKNDix. ^nod modo Itoy miUini de Regs et Reginft, natam et nutntuni IB AogliA, baberv lucruiiiMnt'* It u ala<> wortJi notii-iiif; tliat Hmiit wm *t Ictttft afU*r his mother's death — HitinctinicH left in B^^gUiwI while his hrothcrs were in Normandy. AVe finovo. p. 735), when it in K|><-cially yL^I (Hist. .'m<-> Ah. ii. 12), " hui.s in Nonnuiinia ciiiii |>iitre fnUfibus ronstitiitis." All theno hinUt look in the Hamc direction. TTw first siffn which I have ct>me ncroMi of the traditional iininc BttmtUrt is in the Annals of ThomuH Wykes (Ann. Mon. iv. 11) under the year 1087, wliere he ix deHcril»cd n** *' llcnricuR |M)Htrcinu8 filiorum suoram [Willolnii], quern vul^'us Clericum niincupalmt." Henry wm thun, unlike either of his hrothers, a born /Ktlicling. I do not remember tlint he ifl himself calleir«'. E jeo I'ai rim*^- en Fran9eiz Ytopet apeluDJi c« livre 81 cum gel' truvai premiferement." Qu*il traveilU et fist escrire ; Count William is said by M. de Roquefort to mean William Earl of Salisbury, who died in 1257. Mark's own date then belongs to the reign of Henry the Tliird. If Henry be the right reading, one can hardly doubt that Henry the First is meant. There is no time in the life cither of Henry the Second or of Henry the Third when we lilKTll AND EDUCATION OF IIKXKV THE FIRST. 793 can fancy liim translating Greek fables either into Latin or into English. It depends on the punctuation, which of course is some- what arhitrar}', and which M. de Hoil nnv fuMi's. niul thcrr \h imthinp to hIiow iImI he hud any kn "' ^ •• «'f (irrok. TIhto \h nlno tlir iil» i» prcw»c. that the Enjjliidi of j^-^lfrtMl wouM Imnlly Imvc Imcm lilr to Man* in the thirteenth centun'. There is htill more (bftr in hif ar^unient (ii. 37- 39) *'"»♦ <''<" ^*^^'^^^ ^^^' ^"'' ''^ "^*'"** • rewiotiR, titles of officen nnd tlic like, which 8uit the time of 1., ... , .'Ut do not unit the lime (»f /Klfretl. On the whole thin I think that ut^lfrcd cnnnot have made tlie English translation of the fahles which Mniy of Fmncc tranHJntt'd from Enpliuh int4) French. I am strongly inclined to think that Henrv the First was the real tninslator. Tlie leamed education of Henry if« certain, and it may j»rol>altly have «?onc so far as to take in n kncmledpe of Greek. His English education is so prohahlc that we may look ujxjn it as all hut certain, and the witness to his Englitih e we may set down for certain on the authority of Simeon of Durham (sec p. 230). This is the whole of our contemporary knowledge. Tliere is no mention in D«»me«day of the church or town of Selby, and for details we are left wholly to the '* Historia Selbiensis Monastcrii " in Labbe, i. 594. Tliis account, which is said to have been written in 11 84, though containing much legendary matter, contains also several names and incidentit which seem to show that there is a kernel of truth in the story. In the heading, as in Simeon, the foundation of the monaMery is assigned to the year 1069. In the early days of William's reign ("eodem ferme tempore quo Angliam Dux NonnanniaB Willelmus invaserat potentique dextera Mio suhjugaN-it imi»erio," p. 596), a brother of the house of Saiut THE FOUNDATION LEOKND OF SELHY ABHEY. 705 German at Auxerre, BoneiUct by name, is miraculously bicMen by the patron Siiint to go to a place calletl Selby in ?]nglaiul, which he will find by the banks of the Ouse, not far from the city of York. He is there to found a cell in honour of Saint German on a piece of ground belouLjing to the King. After some stninge adventures, he reaches England with a finger of his patron, and by a confusion of names he is led to Salisbury instead of Selby, for, as the WTiter truly adds (p. 599), " nomen Salesbj-rite percelebre fuit, Selebioe vero tunc temi>ori8 satis incognitum." At Sali.sbury he is kindly received by a certain Eadward, of whose merits a glowing descrijjtion is given (p. 598) ; " Fuit tunc tcmporis in Salcsbyria ciWs quidani, Eduuardus nomine, vir omni moiiim honestate proefulgens, et inter secularia vitam et moreni diffitens secularem, habitu tamcn et specie specimen in eo secularitatis apparebat, qui etiam, non minus eensiis quam sensfis locupletatus honore, propter diversaniin opuni afHuenteni congeriem Dives cog- noniinabatur." Another friend whom he found was a clerk named Theobald, who acted as his interpreter (p. 600). But being puzzled at not finding the river Ouse and the city of York anywhere in that part of England, and being again fui*ther warned by his patron, he set sail at Lyme (Luma) in a merchant ship bound for York. He is landed at the spot called Selby, which we are told means in Latin " marini vituli villa," on the banks of the Ouse, separated from York by about ten miles of wood. Here Benedict made himself a dwelling under a great oak-tree which was called by the natives StriJuic (p. 600). This, we are distinctly told, happene- •» poKhc, ul»iruini|Uo nil)! inTicctn olwncUuit, quin c<>ruin plu -t in virilmH rx|MTiri nitrl«iilur. Hac do cauftii Until milituni nuiltitudino iirnHliotUH Vi(v(t>iiini wnMiiMfctu* incwlebat.** The Sheriff hna an interview with Ilonwlict, he lenven him his own tent as a tempornrj-dwelling- placr. anil «linvtA the liuiMinf? of a cluipcl for Iuh ufuv It next oct'urH to tlic friendly ShcritV that Bemdict, holy uk he is, b after all only a egins to build his monastery. Brethren now flow to him, hut he is trouhlerihu8 cum adhj^rentibus sibi coniplicibus a.ssiduis discursibus TagBbatur.** In this outlaw wc may see a disinherited Englishman of the name of Swegen. Miracles of course follow, one of them txring wrought on behalf of Hugh the son of Erneis of Burun (** KmiMiius Debunim"), who is described as Sheriff of Yorkshire. Lafftly, as far as wc are concerned — for the story of Al)bot Benedict nma on into the days of William Rufus, and his later history is not ipecially honourable — we see Iknedict blessed as Abbot by Thomas Archbi-Hhop of York. The new house was, wc are told (p. 601), the only monastery in Northern England, except Durham ; " per totam Elioraci siriam. excepta Dunclmensi congrcgatione, ncc monachuB nee monachorum locus aliquis in illis diebus facile valuit reperiri.'* Here is a clear confusion, as Durham did not become a monaiitery till several years later (see p. 677). The whole founda- tion was organizeh descent, but which invented a Nonnan forefather for itself. Some of the other (jersons mentioned in the story are also well known. 1 1 iigh the son of Baldric »md Erncis of Burun are real York- bhire landowner's in Domesday, and Hugh appeal's in Nottingham (|». 280) as '* HuL'o filius I'aldriei ^'il•ecomes." Hugh therefore was APPRNDIX. g^r^fr ...n>«fr||«n>, And it U very poMible that ht may have Ikmo apt ^icriflT of YorkHhirc late id 1069, aAcr the capture of WillUm MaUt AU theae touches give us coiiBilenco in the main otttliDv of the i»U>n', but the more we lH.'lievo it the less we can be- lirre ibo tnulition of Uviiry the First's birth at Selliy. MAtthew Paris (Ilistoria Angloruni, i. 34), or soino inteq)uIator of his iiuuiuik^n|>t, has a strange stor^* al>out the foundation of Sclby. Willisiu's two monasteries in Kugluml are oiKlIy dcHcribed as "oaenoiua uobilia, vitK'licet dc Ikllo in partibus Anglio? orientalibus •I Selebi iHviihntalibuH." Selby is said to liavc been founded ** pro eo quoil i|ucnulani Hi)»i consanguinitato ])r(>])infjuuni vcncno oodderit, timeiis ue ipsuni de regno Angliie Bupplantaret vel ducatu vel utro<{ue, quia Btrcnuissimus fuit." This must bo some Yague glimmering of the death of Conan, on which see vol. ill. \k 714. The stor}' goes on to say that William on his death-bed was Tisited by a holy Bishop, his confessor, who asked whether he repented of this crime. William said that he could not repent. Did he repent that he could not repent 1 William had got thus fiir in the way of amendment, and with this the Bishop seems to have beeD satisfieil. NOTE GG. p. 298. W^illiam's Grants of Holderness. Is the local history of the Abbey of Meaux (i. 89, ed. Bond, and Mod. Angl. v. 390) we find a story in which Drogo, a Flemish follower of William (" miles quidam valdc probus et in armis probatus, cjui cum ipso in Angliam venerat, Dnigo de la Bouerer, Flandrensis, qui construxit caste Hum de Skypse"), receives from William a grant of Holderness ("insulam de Holdemese"). Drogo was married to a kinswoman of the King, whom he killed ("habuit autera idem Dmgo uxorem quamdam Ilegis cognatam, quam omine iufausto intcremit "). He then goes to the King, he pretends that he is going with hiH wife to Flanders, and asks for money for the journey. William is deceived and gives him the money, on which Drogo €tomm the sea. The King, on finding out his mistake, sends to arrat him, but his renowned police was for once ineffectual ; Drogo WILLIAMS GRANTS OF HOLDEUNESS. 799 had croBsetl the sea and never came back (" ipse denuo nou rever- surus trausfretavit"). William then j^auts the land to Odo of Cljainpa^nie, who is, as usual (see vol. ii. p. 587), described as man-ying William'3 sister instead of his niece. But Holdemess was a barren hind and p^ew nothing but oats ; so when Olo's wife had borne him a son, wlio was nameil Stephen, he asked the King to give him some land which grew wheat, that he might feed his nephew (''petiit a Rege ut daret ei terram ferentem frumentum, undo alere posset nepotem suum"). He therefore gave him the lonlship of Bytliam and other lauds elsewhere. This Stephen was the father of William the Fat, Count of Albemarle, who founded the Abbey of j^[eaux, at a place so called because it had l>een held (78) by one Gamel the son of Ketel, who had come in William's train from Meaux in France and gave his new abode the name of the old one. " Gamellus filius Ketelli de Melsa, avus seu pater dicti Johannis de Melsa, cum Willielmo Notho, Kege et Conqujestore, de prsedicta civitate Gallic, Meaux Gallice dicta, exiens, cum aliis, in his partibus Holdernesise sortem su£e habitationis est assecutus, et, ob memoriam civitatis sua? egressionis, nomen huic loco quern in- habitabat ut Meaux nuncuparetur impouebat." Now that this story cannot be strictly time is })lain from Domes- day. There (3236 et secjq) one "Drogo de Bevrere" appeai-s as the owner of a va.st estate in the parts of Holderness. He is found also in various other parts of Domesday, especially in Lincolnshire (360 6), where he appears as possessor of Bitluun. On the other hand, I cannot find Odo of Champagne or his son Stephen in any part of the Survey. As for Gamel the son of Ketel, a man with such a thoroughly Danish name would be very likely indeed to be a natural Yorkshi reman, but very unlikely to have come from France into Yorkshire. The only Ganu'l to br found in Domesday as a tenant in rapite is the Gamel who had a share in the Nortlnnnbrian insurrection (see vol. ii. p. 483), nor can I find any man of the name oven as an undertenant of the lord of Holdi'rne.ss. On the other hand, Orderic (522 C) distinctly as.serts that William gave what he calls the Earldom of Holderness to Odo of Champagne ("Odoni Campaniensi, nepoti Theobahli Comitis, <|ui Hororem habebat ejusdcm Ilegis, filiam scilicet Hodberti Ducis, (l('V 'mi nil iiniHtrtaiit. tlioii^'ti not n very ■uccomfti), ]mH in BmIi- .. an« ill the n-i^i of William Uufus. See Florence, 1095, 1096 I muM lo«\T the nmttor to Kvnealogist^t and local in(|uirer8. It it of courw iKMsihle tluit the story of Dro^ii, or the fiicUi on wiiich the itory is foumUxl, niul the j^mtut of H()l(l«'rin«HH to Odo, OMT have hftppeneil in the very latest davK of William, after the Bnrrry wns drawn u|». NOTE nil. i». ,]04. Tlir. CmUCHFrS <»K .TaRKOW and MltNKWKAUMOlTH. Tub histor)* of these churches 8uj)plic8 Mr. llinde with one of hi* ar^nients against the authority of the Northumbrian interi)o- lator of Florence. But, as the arguments are closely connected with the fabrics of the two churches, I reserve their consideration till I cxaniiiie the effects of the Conquest on architecture in my fifth volume. NOTE II. p. 305. Retextion of Enclisii Na3ies in Durham. I BBBXRVE this also for the examination of the effect of the Conquest on nomenclature which I hoi)e to make in my fifth volame. NOTE KK. p. 324. The Laws of Eadward and William. This also I keep for a general examination of the effiect of the Conquest upon English Law. NOTE LL. J). 344. Thb Relations ok the Provinces of Canterbury and York. The discussion of this subject also will find a place when I oome to examine the effects of the Conquest upon ecclcBiastical matters. THE ALLEGED PENANCE ON WILLIAM's SOLDIERS. 801 NOTE MM. p. 345. The Alleged Penance o.v Wiluam's Soldiers. In Wilkins's Concilia, i. 366, we have a set of canons enjoining certain penances on William's soldiers, which are there ilescril>ed as passed in a council at Winchester, and as printeil " ex vetusto libro Saxonico, ad Wigornenseni Ecclesiain spectante." They ap- pear also in Bessin's Concilia Rotomagensis Provincise, p. 50. And it is plain that, if they were ever passed at all, they were i^assed at a Xornian and not an English synod, and the mention of p]rmenfrid tixt'S the date to this synod of the year 1070. The heading stands thus ; " Hiec est pcenitentise institutio secundum decreta Normannonim })i'apsulum, auctoritate Summi Pontificis, eoufirmata per Legatum suum Ennenfredum Episcopum Sedunensem, imponenda illis homi- nihus, quos Willelraus Nonuannoinim Dux suo jussu armavit, et (|ui abs(jue jussu suo erant annati et ex debito ei militiam daliant." I must leave it to the judgement of the reader whether a docu- ment can possibly be genuine which imposes penances on all who had taken any share in William's great crusade, and therefore, by implication, on William himself more than on any one else. But the enactments are exceetlingly curious. They begin by one decree which, according to Guy of Amiens (see vol. iii. p. .509), would liave condemned the Conqueror to a penance of two thousand years ; • (^ui magno prcelio scit se hominem occidisse, secundum numerum lumiinum pro unoquoque uno anno pteniteat." Provisions follow for those who do not know whether those whom they stnick had died, and for those who cannot remember the number of those whom they killed. The will is ])unished as well as the deed ; "Qui autrm nemiiiem j)ercu.sserit, si percutere voluerat, triduo ixenitciit," 'i'lien comes an order seemingly for the special Wncfit of the F.i-hop of Ikyeux; " De clericis qui pugnaverunt aut pugmuidi gratia annati fuenint, (piia pugna.s.se illis illicitum erat secundum iiistituta canonum, ac si in patria sua pecciissent, pceniteant. Pteni- tentix monachonim secundum rcgulam suam et Abbatum judicia VOL. IV. 3 F aOf AITKNDIX. SpfflBil pru\n«ionii art* iiifulo fur tlio luercenftrtat niul lor Um Arebtra; *' De MgtttAriU. <|ui igiiurniiU*r iiIi({UoH cH'cidcnint, Ttl dbtque bomiciilio rulneravoniiit, trihus ({uiulm^cHimiH |Minn- tnuit ' • » iH'rica of tltvni'a alumt actH of vi<»lcnce dono aiWr Uic 'Niiuli hnvo n nioro pMiuiiio mouikI, aii>n >vitli tlio accoiintH wliirli wo have of Williain'ti ■thci di^ p. 30), aud a marked distinction in dniwn bttwiMM n fore the King's coronation and acts done after ; ••Quiruiuijuc, exoepto hoc pnelio, ante Regia conseerationem, vidua quBreodi cauad {tor regnum discurrerunt, et hostibus repugnant!- bus aliquot ooddenint, pro singulin uno anno {)(L>niteunt. "C^ui aotam, non necessitate victus setl pnvdundi cuusii dlscurre- rant, ei aliquog oceidenint, trea anno pwniteant. **Qui autoni |>08t conseerationem llegis hominem occiderunt, sicut de homicidiis p|>onte coniniissis pceuiteant ; hoc excepto, ut si quis de illij quemquc qui adiiue repngnabant Regi occidit vel percussit, ■cut supra pceniteat. ** De adulteriia, et raptihus, et foniicationibus quibuBCumquc, ac li in patrii sui peccissent, poeniteant." Sir Francis Palgrave (iii. 484) accepts the decrees without hesi- Utioo, and fixes the s^nod to tlie same date as I do. NOTE NN. p. 398. FaiTHBic Abbot of Saint Alban's. This Prelate fills a great space in tlic legendary narrative of the Conqoett as given by Thierry ; but Iiis authentic liistory will go into A Twy amall compass. I doubt whetlier it goes beyond the signa- ture which I have quoted in the text and auotlier of " Fredericus Abba* Venilamii" t^j the decree of the Council of London in 1075 OVilkins, i. 363). The Life of Frithric by Matthew Paris, in the Oesta AUjatum (i. 41), seems mythical in all its details. His origin it Uuis described ; " Ute, ex vcteribus Saxonibus claram duccns origi- nal et Dtds, Cnutoni Regi fuit consanguineus, et linealiter de- jWiiideodopropinquus.'' He was appointed Abbot in 1064, and was in bigb favour both with Eadward and with Harold (i. 44). He first FKITllUIC ABBOT OP SAINT ALBANS. 803 appears in Thierry (i. 263) as blockiuf,' William's course on his way between Bi-rklianipstead and London l>efore his coronation (see vol. "*• P* 555)- 'll'i'' seems to eome from a mjihical Btory in the Gesta (i. 47), which Thieny himself tells over again in ii. 29. William, by Laufranc's advice, desi^s or profes.ses to treat the English more gently. William and Ijtmfranc accordingly meet Frithric at IV'rkhami)stead, and William swears to ol>serve the laws of King Eiidward. This is of course an echo of the sub- mission at Berkhampstead in 1066. But it does not happen till after a great revolt, in which Eadgar, Stiganil, Eadwine, and the Bishops Wulfstan and Walter (see p. 379) all take a part, but of which the chiefs are Archbishop Ealdred and Abbot Frithric (i. 45) ; " Aluredum Archiepiscopum Eboracensem omnes Aquilonares elege- ruut capitaneum, Australes autem Abbatem Frethericum." They have many of the citizens of London on their side, and they seem to give William a good deal of trouble. But he, Ix'ing '' immiseri- cors," " tyrannus inexorabilis," " astutus," and " tjTaunus belliger," contrives to divide them and to crush them separately. Stigand, an unstable man, " similis anindini ventis agitatie," fluctuates between the King and the English, till he is deposed and imprisoned, where he shares the fate of Judas or Arius ; " in carcere contabuit et visce- ribus crepuit circumfusis." The uew Archbishop Lanfiiinc wins the Papal sanction for William, and a fierce war goes on between him and the English, headed by Eadgar and Frithric — Ealdred htis vanished ; " Exercitum numerosum ac fortissimum conflavemnt, praeficientes sibi Eadgarum speciosissimum ct foiiissimum, in cujus sinu tota s|)es reposita fuit Angligenarum. l^ndo in Augliam tale exiit eulogium, ' Eadgar Ethelyng Engeloudes derlyng" (i. 47). Frithric also was '* inter omnes Anglos dux et promotor ethcacissi- mus." Then comes William's oath at Berkhampstead, notwith- standing which he goes on cnishing the English in detail and giving their lands to Normans. Eadgar flies to Scotland, others of the chief men to Dt-nmark, Norway, and elsewhere. Their loss was great ; " Exsularunt ab Aiiglid nobiles, tarn milites (juam pra'lati ; viri sancti, generosi, ac dapsiles, qui more Orientalium, et maxime Trojanorum, barbas et conms nutnelmnt, armis et fide pneclaris- simi. Quibus exsulantibus, pristina regni sanctitas ac nobilitas irre- meabilitrr cxsulavit " (i. 48). William and Lanfranc now greatly op- press the two patriotic Bishops Wulfstan and Walter. WuHstaii API'RNDIX. b milMaloilBlT (loUverrtl in thr hviuhI of WihtiuiiiMtiT, acconlin^ to IIm w«>)1*kBowii tiory : Waltrr mvUh Hhrltcr in WiiIch. William llimirlf wooden at hix own ■ucci'Ah. hikI in fulIOcinot (*' in (iu<>CACt% but Frithric tdlH liint that tho rauHo of kit 9Q€Xjem 'n* that tlio dcryy who lioM ho lar^c a ]»ai*t of thu kttd of the count n* liavc ho commonly playiHl into Imh handn. Had ibe Uity licvn losslilienil. aiul kept tlie \aiuU in tlicir own hamln, the countn* wouhl have been l*etter able to resiHthlin. William anHwers UmU, if ibis be 80, the country cannot be in a state to resist the King of Denmark or any other ]>OHsible enemy. Therefore, for tlie ft«r.-fv rif the Kinplom, he takes part of tlie lands of the Abbey to .tc among his knights. At hwt Frithric, fearing that greater •rila may conic, flees to Ely and dies there, on whicli tlie Abbey is granted to Paul. It i'i hanily nee*lful to point out the iuconsistcncics of this story and itj utter disreganl of chronology. It is chicHy worth noticing becauac large parts of it have Iwen treated by Tliieny as so much ntboiitic history. Of his singular treatment of the story of Bishop Walter I have already spoken (see p. 379). Still it is remarkable that ao elalx>nite a legend should have grown up, as it evidently didf at Saint Alban's itself, and one would think that there must have been aome ground in the tmditioual character both of Frithric and Walter for the part which they are made to play. But all that certain histor}* has to say about Frithric is that he was Abbot of Saint Allian's, and that he died or was deposed some time between 1075 and 1077. NOTE 00. p. 455. The Leoend of Hereward. Tiip. authentic history of Hereward consists of the notices in the Chronicles which I have menticmed in the text and of the entries relating to him in Domesday. At the time of the Survey he held DOthlng in chief, but he or some other person of the same name THE LEGEND OK IIEREWARD. 805 held lands in Warwickshire (Doniesduy. 240. 240 A) of the Count of Melicnt, which he had liimsclf held in the time of King Eiidward. He had also held (241) other lands in Warwickshire which had passal to Tlmrkill, and five hides in Worcestershire (173) held of the Bishop. It is however possihle that the Hereward of these entries may he some other person, hut there ain be no doubt about the entry in 376 h. Among the " Clamores in Clietsteven" we read, "Terrain Asfonl in Bereham lumdred dicit wapentak non habuisse Herewardum die qua aufugiit." And again in 377 ; " Terram Sancti Guthlaci quam tenet Ogerus in Re])inghale dicunt fuisse dominicam niTnam monaehoiiim, et I'lchel Abl)atem commendasse earn ad fir- mam Herewurdo, sicut inter eos conveniret unoquoque anno ; sed Abbas resaisivit earn antequam Hcrewardus de patria fugeret, eo quod conventionem non tenuisset." Lastly, in 364 b Toli and Here- ward appear as former owners on the lands of the same Oger the Hrcton. This is the amount of our positive knowledge. Hereward held lands in Lincolnshire ; j)art of them was held of the Abbey of Crowland, of which Abbot Ulfcytel resumed possession because Here- ward did not kee]) his agreement. At some later time, therefore after 1062, the year of the appointment of Ulfcytel, Hereward fled from the country, but for what cause we are not told. In 1070 and 107 I he appears again as the plunderer of Peterborough and leader of the outlaws at Ely. This is the whole of his undoubted history. The story in the false Ingulf (pp. 67, 70) is not to be wholly cast aside, as it may contain some genuine Crowland tradition. This story makes Hereward the son of a certain Leofric of Brune or Bourne. This Leofiic is described (67) as "cognatus illius raagni Comitis Herfordensis Radini, qui Oodam Edwardi l^egis sororem duxerat in uxorem." This can only mean Ralph the Timid, the son, not the husband, of Eatlward's sister Godgifu, so that any English kinsman of Ralph must have l)een also a kinsman of King Eadward. The mother of Hereward was Eadgyth or Kadgifu (Ixliva), a de- scendant of the famous Earl Oslac in Kadgar's time (see vol. i. p. 292). Hereward was banished by King Eadward at the prayer of his father Leofric, on account of his violent bearing toward;! r)ther lads of his own age. In his exile he vi.^ited Northuml)erland, Cornwall, Ireland and Flanders, but no special a«lventures are told of him, except that in Flanders ho married a wifeTurfrida, by whom }i«' had a daughter, who handed on the paternal estate at Bourne MM APPENDIX. Hugh of Erennouth. Miuinwhilc the 0>nc|iioRt of TT .1 hcarM that liin futlior Ih (IcA^I.ttiid that l^g fglsto* nny* I" i.l to n Nonunii liy whom hi.s niotlicr in bttdhr tfVAtod. H< ^ homo witli liiri wife and lier inotlirr, the of whom lM>fore long ver)' coiiHidcrately takes the veil at the ot Abbot llfcj'tcl. He then receives knighthcMxl at the of AblMit Ilrnnd of retorhorougli, who U said to l>c his uncle ; be beoomei the leader of the outlaws in the Isle ; and, when the Frmch Abbot TuroM hUct"eeffn-y (Palmar first brings Herewanl before us as leader of the oallawi at Ely (Chron. iVjig.-Norm. i. 17) ; *' Dm aUa|{faw mulz i avcit. Ki Hcrcward avcit eralitatis multuni dedita, in mechanicrKpie arte etiam peritissima." Elsewhere (p. 49) wo read that she *' etiam omnom muliebrem jam superexcedebat moUitiem, in omni necessitate iM?rspicui viri compos sa'pe pro])ata." At last Hereward comes back to England, and finds his father's hou.se at I'ourne in the hands of Frenchmen, one of whom has just killed his brother (p. 41 ). We get a description of a banf|uet of the Normans and their female companions, and lu>w " fiuidam joculator intererat psallendo, exprobans genti Anglonim et in medio domCis iucompositos quasi Angligeuos fingeus saltus." ATPHNDIX. Ilrrrvmni of c\»unK' tAkc* h Wniu^ n'vrnjfr. nin! rcpiiiiM i>o88CHioD of hat father* hou*r Ho in thon kni^'littNl l.y nnunl. Iio killn Freclerick nf Warrvn (|v. 4''). (jo«i» \*ack t<» FlumlorH, ami ooiiu'H hmk witli \\\h wife TurfritU •ml bin two iieplu'WH Siwanl the Whit4 mxl Siwunl tk» Hnl Mr fpklhcni • comi»ftny whonc iiamos are given at Kuk^Ii. One or two are irnmrkalilo (]». 51), as "(Joilricus dc Corbi, uejKM* (^milis «lc Wurrwic, et Ttwti «lo Davenesso, co^omtus Coiuitis ojus- drm, cujoB et uoineu in iuiiitihino aocepit" — tliis Tontig ICnrl uf Warwick tboiild be noticitl — " et <|uiilam TurWrtimiH, proiiepoB KJw3*ni ComitU," who, to wiy nothing of his renmrkahle nanu', mtiflt hftTe been great-grcAt-grandhon of the still living (todgifu. But mnotlier name (p. 50) seems to suggest a lost piece of Teutonic •oog or legend; "(»odwinus (Jille. qui vocahatur CJodwinus, quia noo impar Oo<1wino filio Cluthlaci, qui in fahulis anticjuoruni vaUlc priKilit-Htur," which should be t«ken along with the mention of the (futhUdnfnui in Orderic ( ';37 C). Tlien follows a long account of 1 1 err wanlV exploits in the Island and of his later years and death, to which I have made many references in the text. But one detail of hit domestic life must Ik? mentioned. Though Turfrida is Htill alive, be baa proposals of marriage made to him (p. 88) by one who is deaerilied as ** pnp|>otentis}*ima mulier, quae fuit uxor Dolfini Comitia,** and we are told that " illi formosior nee speciosior fuit in rvguo* n«c opihiw jwne pra^clarior." She has made her own peace with the King, and she offei-s to win the same favour for Hereward. The hero is temptc«d, and Turfrida makes a way for the new alliance by entering religion at Crowland. But, to keep up the moral of the tale, we are told (p. 89) that, on this account, "raulta incommoda ci |»oHt evenenint, quml sapientissima erat et in necessitate magni consilii. Postea enim, sicut ipse ssepe professus est, non ei sicut in tempore ejus sic pn)S|>ere contigerunt multa." Now how much of truth is there in this story ] There is nothing in Oomesday to connect Hereward with Bourne, which appears (364 b) as having been held T. R. E. by Earl Morkcre, except that Boamc bad paKsed to the same owner, Oger the Breton, as some of the former poHseasions of Hereward. There is nothing beyond the legend to show whether Hereward's father was or was not called Leoftic. There is a Leofric who appears several times in Lincoln- shire, and once (369) with the title of " Cilt." But he was not the owner of Bourne. The notion of Sir Henry E;ilis (ii. 146) that THE LEGEND OF HEREWAHD. 809 Hcrewanl was a youn*3'er son of Earl Leofric comes only from the genealoj,Mcal roll of the fifteenth centiir)' (Chron. An*(.-Norm. ii. xi), of whiob I have already spoken in vol. ii. p. 629. " Fuit tempore Siinoti Eilwanli Ilt^j^is (piidam Leofricus Comes Cestrise et ^^erL•io^.lm, cognatus Coniitis Herfonlirp, dominus de Bninne, no- mine Scarle." The pedigree- maker had the Gesta hefore him, but he could conceive only one Ix'ofric and only one iuilph, and in his Scarle we see the last trace of Staliere, Staire, Scalre. The early part of the story in the Gesta is plainly mere romance, but when we get Hereward in the Isle we are on somewhat surer gi-ound. The geography at least may be trusted, and one or two of the details, as the death of Frederick and the mention of Warwick, draw incidental confirmation from Doniesday. As to Hereward's death, there is nothing to make us choose between the story in the Gestii and the stor}' in Gaimar, except that it is more likely that so elaborate a tale as the latter should have been left out by one writer than that it should have been invented by the other. As to the wife or wives of Hereward, there can be little doubt that Gaimar and the false Ingulf preserve two independent stories, which have been awkwardly rolled together by the writer of the Gesta. Though independent, they are not necessarily contradictory, as Turfrida may have died before /Elfthryth made her proposals to Hereward. But the notion of Turfrida going into a monastery to make way for yElfthryth is plainly another form of the story in Ingulf which makes, not herself but her mother, do so. The description of the " mulier pra'potentis.sima '' as wife of Earl Doltin sounds as if it were a tradition or confusion of something. Dolfin, we know, was a gi'eat Northumbrian name (see vol. ii. j). 4S2), but no Earl so called is recorded. The name of Wake, given to Hereward by modern writers, comes from the Chronicle of John of Peterborough, a writer of uncertain date and personality. He has several entries about Ilcrewaril, which are to the same effect as the story in the Gesta. Under 1068 we read, *' Herewardus de partibus trausnmrinis rediens in Angliam ad hierew-<< pn>t(y plainly that it in Hiinply another of the MM^kitig of lVter1Mlrou^'h in 1070. I^tMly. under 10; i «r rvAout Fjirl Morken*. Tiishoj) yKtliclwinr, ami Sitrmnl Ram there in no tli>uht. Ah to Al»l>ot Fritliric I have ic|inken in the la>t note ; but his lepjinhiiy coming' to the IhIc is also mixctl up with tho lej^udnry coming; of Sti;,'and. TIjc talc is found in Imth the Histories of Ely, that in the Anj^lia Sacra, i. 609, and more fully in Mr. Stewart's edition, 227 ; *' StiganduB intcrum Mppe dictua Archiepiscopus per loca diflTugiens vaj^H latitabat, nee crmt ubi m* tute vol sua recederet ; tandoin cum sunmia tlicsauronim ^fOM in Kly tranHUii^^ravit, " This stoiy in j)lainly referred to in tho pMnge in the Winchester Annals which 1 quoted in ]). 333. It is aooepCed by Thierry (it 34), who ^aves the date 1072, though nothing can lie plainer than that Stigand was impnsoned in 1070. But Tbieny- had already (ii. 15) made Stigand escape in comi)any with an ima^nar>' Bishop of Lincoln, whom he sceminf^ly gets out of R Wendover, ii. 7 (cf. M. Paris, i. 13), where the Bishop borrows both his see and his name of Alexander from a well-known Prelate of the next century. This storj- of Stigand is by the Ely writers mixed up with the story of ?>ithrie, whom they call " Egfridus " (Stewart, 221), and say that he brought with him the relics of Saint Alljan, a statement indi^mantly denied by Matthew Paris (Gesta Abbatum, i. 51). Thierry tells the story of Ecgfrith in U. 12, and tliat of Frithric in iL 33, without remarking that they are the same llory. I think it is perfectly plain from the MtthflDtic narratives that Stigand was imprisoned at Winchester finom his deposition to his death, and did not visit either Scotland or Ely. Tho names of Ea. 477. BiBUOPS yETIIEIJlIC AND i^TIIELWIXE. Th» iccount of the two brother Bishops in the Chronicles seems qnitc clear. yEthelric wns imprisoned at Westminster in 1070, and dieil in 1072. /Ethelwine was outhiwed at the same time tiiat hia brother was imprisoned, but he was not imprisoned till tJtla the taking of Ely in 107 1. \\\\v\\ he was sent to Abingdon, and dieJ in the winter. But it is plain that, not only William of Mfthnesbur)', but even Florence, confounded the two. Under 1070 Florence tells us, " ^Fgelwinus Dunholmi Episcopus *b bominibus Regis Willelnii capitur et in carcerem truditur, ubi dum ex nimio cordis dolore eomedere nollet, fame et dolore moritur." Under the next year we read, " Rex Episcopum ^gelwinum Ab- bandooiam missum in custodiam posuit, ubi in ipsa hieme vitam finivit" This latter is the true account of yEthelwine translated from the Chronicles. The former entrj- belongs to yEthelric, though the Cbroniclea under 1069 carefully distinguish them; " JEgelric bUceop wR-8 fon^Teged, |)e wses on Burh, and bine man laedde to Wcstmynstre and utlagode his bro^r vEgelwine bisceop." The Worcester Chronicle puts these events under their proper date, as I»rl of the acts of the Easter Gem6t of 1070 (sec p. 336), while PetcrUrfiUgh put* them out of order before the coming of the Daniab fleet in 1069. /ETHELKIC AND .ETIIKLWINK. 813 Florence's story about /Ethelric refu.sing to eat soenia hunlly consistent with his vigorous spiritual action against the spoilers of Petorbiirough (see p. 462). But it appears again in a still more confused account, given by William of Malinesbury ((iest. Pont. 271), where the succession of the two Bishops is j)ut in u wrong order, and the actions of both are attributed to /Kthelric ; " Post Edniunduni fuerunt Exlred, Egeluuinus, Egelricus. Quo- rum ultimus sub liege Willelmo rei)ellionis accusatus, quo<] turbiisset pacem regiam, piraticam adorsus, i)erj)etuo exsilio Westmonasterium di'portatus est. Ibi quantum vixit, voluntaria inedia et lacriinaruin atHucutid praeteritos reatus attenuans et diluens, sanctitatis opini- onem apud homines concepit. Denique ab liis qui cum viderunt posteris memoriam tra^lentibus, hodie(iue tumulus ejus nee votis nee frequent ia pet i torn m caret.*' Roger of Wendover (ii. 9) makes the same confusion. He gives the right account in ii. 6, but ho now adds, " Hoc etiam anno Egelwinus Episcopus Dunelmensis, ajmd Westmonasterium sub custodia Regis dctentus, obiit, et ibidem in porticu Sancti Nicolai sepultus est." This is translated from the account given by both Chronicles, under 1072, where, in recording the death and burial of yEthelric, they give a little sketch of his life (see vol. ii. p. 408), including a second mention of his imprisonment. Florence also translates, retaining the right name. NOTE QQ. p. r,77- Thk Connhxion f»K Waltiikof with Tin: Conspiracy ok R.VU'H. The story of the Norman monk rebuked l»y his Abbot for irreverently speaking of the martyrec« Wultlioof'N hirth aiul nciiuiiH down lo bU racoDctlUliiin with Williiun niul luarriufft* with Judith, and thea gm oo ** Noo |)rnuaiui( m fulo, |>nivuni in^'i-niuni coliilx re imjKjtc'nH : fnrfnimtriirt if mini ontnihuH. <|ui I'xi.stiMifinint rchihtt-ndiiin, vivh'xh tA fabjoctijk cliam in lUdulfi tie Wjilur iKrfnliii st* ininilKcuit, Hcd eoigiiritioiM dctccti, cuniprt'hensus diutiuc in vinculiH tcntuH, ultioio ipoUAUui capit«, Crolundo M>pultu8 est ; ({UuniviH qiiidani diouit, DccefliiUto intcrceptuiu, non vohintate addictuni, infidel itn- tia Momoicntum tgit&BBe. An^^lorum est ihU\ ixcusutiu ; nam cwinini in MlaDM conjoctum (piotidianis HJugultibus ])crpcram comniisMu dilutftM^.** A little way on (iii. 255) he f,'ivcH an account of the bride-nlc, iU maf^nificence, and the drunkenness of the guests, adding, " quod Kormannorum gulap jam Anglorum luxus influxerat." He then iMi>-B tliat Roger, Italph, Waltheof, and many otliers conspired the King's death (** in nccem liegis conjurant"), but the next day, when they were sober, the more part repented (" major pars facti pa;iiit€na a convivio dilapsa "). He then adds, " Unus eorum (Weidcof fertur), qui consilio I^anfranci Arcliiepiscopi Nonnanniani ultnj na^ngana, rem Regi, caiLsa sua duutaxat celata, detulit." There ia Bomething singular in this last incidental mention of Walthefatthew changes into " ad instar fulminis." The Hyde writer (294), as usual, has an independent account, WALTHEOF AND KALPH. 815 ami a very curious one. He makes no mention of any but Kuglisli conspimtors ; '* Wilk-linus Ilex, ([uuiii ivj^nuin paci studentlo iiiodtsto coiiart-tur clisponero, quidani prinoipt'S An^^loruni invitte suhjectionis juj^mni excutere cupientcs, rebellare contm turn ad suuni interitum non formidavere. Edinesau Wahletlt, unus ex anti William, in the Uter yean of Ins lifi«, bcsic^ Pol twice or iiolv one* 1 A tiege of Dol. following ininiediiitely iiftor the dunth of Wahiioof. in tliiitiuctly asserteil by nil our best nuthoritiefl. But we ebewbere fiiul mention of a si^o of Dol by Williiini which in placed •evrnU ymn* Utrr. In the note in Houqnct, xii. 566, 596, it is MMKart of Orderic's evidence is that his words would at fir»t sight imply that the marriage of Alan and Constance took place \cry eoou after the siege of Dol in 1076. He Fays (544 C) ; '* Deinde prudcns lUx, ut se vincere virtute Britones non posse proffficxit, aliud consilium tibi posterisque commodum sollerter prwcogitavit. Cum Alanno Fergano fcedus amicitiae firmavit, eiquc Oonstantiam fdiam suam in conjugium Cadomi honorifice copulavit. Qu» cum viro suo fere xv. annis venerabiliter vixit." The fifteen years mast be reckoned to the death of Constance in 1090. H) that it is plain that Orderic, when he wrote this passage, thought that she was married directly after the siege of 1076. But he himself shows elsewhere (see p. 651) that she was still un- married in 1 08 1, and the Breton writers put the marriage in 1086 or 1087. See Chron. Brit., Morice, i. 103 ; Bouquet, xii. 559 ; "Ahinus duxit Con.-tantiam filiam Regis Guillelmi Angloinim in uxorem." So Chron. Kemperlegiense, Bouquet, xii. 562, and Chron. KuyenM?, Morice, i. 151 ; P>ouquet, xii. 563. Cf. Chron. Briocense, Bouquet, xii. 566, where however Alan's marriage with Constance is wrongly placed after his marriage with Hermengarde of Anjou SIEGE OF DDL AND THE MARRIAGE OF CONSTANCE. 817 (sec p. 651). It is impossible to resist this evidence for io86 as the year of the marriage. Kather than put back the marriage, as Prevost does, to 1077, we must give up Orderic's story altogether. But the two stories may be reconciled, if we suppose a betrothal in 1076 and a maniage ten years later, and tiiat Orderie, when writing the account of the siege of Dol, confounded the two. 1 do not know that there is any evidence as to the age of Constance. To speak of Alan as Count before his time is no very wonderful slip ; but it does not affect the question as to the two sieges. He did not become Count till after the date given to the second. But, as he was Count at the time of the mairiage in 1086, it may l)e thought to bhow that Orderie did not simply confound a betrothal and a marriage, but misdated the marriage altogether. The real difficulty is as to the second siege. Among the Breton and Angevin writers, the Angevin Chronicle of Saint Albinus (Labbe, i. 276 ; Bouquet, xii. 479) is the only one which mentions our first siege. Under 1076 it records " obsidio Dolensis." In the Chronicle of Raynald of Anjou (Bouquet, xii. 479) we read, " Anno 1086, in mense Septembri, Comes Normannorum, qui et Rex Anglorum, Willelmus obsedit in Britanniis castrum quod dicitur Dolum, quod quum diu obsedisset, nihil profecit, sed etiam niachi- nis suis succensis ab eo infructuose discessit, defendentibus illud fortibus Andegavorum railitibus." The Breton writers take care not to mention this valiant Angevin contingent, and they give the siege an earlier date. Thus in the Chronicon Briocense (Bouquet, xii. 567) we read, " Hie autem Hoellus, post mortem Conani fnitris Havisfie uxoris suse, fecit bella advei*sus Goffridum Comitcm cogno- mento Granonem ajmd castrum Doli, Guillelmo Comite Normanno- rum sibi auxiliante per <|uudraginta dies ingeniis et aliis machinati- onibus obsedit, quod minimc ca])ere potuit. Et aimo se([uenti, hoc est anno Domini mlxxxiii, Hoellus a suis capitur et eodem anno moritur." And the death of Howel, but witliout any mention of his capture, ap{)ear8 in other Breton Chronicles in Boucpiet, xii. 559» 561. It seems quite impossible that this description and that of the Nomian and English writers can refer to the same event. IV'sides the difference of date, all the circumstiinces are different. In the one story William appears the enemy of the Breton Count, in the other as his ally. But this last state of things falls in very well with VOL. IV. 3 O iia APPENDIX. IIm HHBiMtMMl which 1 have iK^fon^ mm\o tm to n l»otrutiuil in 1076 •ad A BMrilffe in ic86. On tho other Imnd, it in haul to join tho BMon tfUmj on to Williiinrfi aetn in 1083 118 roconled 1>y Kn^lihh •nd Numuu) wriUrm and it is quite inii>oB8iblc to ^ve up the siege of 1076 or to move it to any later timo. The diatinct evidence of aU our own writert, supiwrtixl hy the one Angevnn ChroDiclc. seems quite oooclusive. NOTE SS. p. 648. The Battle of Geuhkroi. The iccount in Onleric leaves out all mention of the ])orp()nal Mieoiinter liotween \Villiain and his son. I follow the account in Um ChronicIe«. It is recorded in both, and each gives sonie details of its own. The account in Peterborough, 1079, runs thus ; " And ^i ilcan geare se cyng Willelm gefeaht togeanes his sunu Rotbearde wi^utan Normandige be anuni castele Gerbome^ hatte, and se cj*ng Willelm wearJ^ |>apr gcHTindod and his hors ofslagcn J>c be on art ; eac his budu Willelm wear¥ ))8er gewundod and fela mAonft ofiilagene." Here we get the name of the castle and the wound of William Hufus. In the Worcester version these are not mentioned, but we get the galUnt exjtloit of Tokig instead; ■Her Rotbert feht wi^ hisfsederand bine on }ja hand gewundade, tnd his hors wear^ under ofscoten and Be |>e him o^r tobrohte wearV Jnerrihte mid anan arblaste ofscoten, \>sdt wses Tokig Wiggodes sunu, and fela \>eer wurdon ofslaegen and eac gefangene." llien follows the passage which I quoted in p. 649. Florence this time forsakes l)oth Chronicles, and gives a version which read.s like a softening of the genuine story. It might even teem that the exploit of Tokig was transferred to Robert ; " Rex Willelmus filio sue Rotberto, ante castellum Gerbothret, quod ei Rex Philij)pus praestiterat, dum pugnam intulerit, ab ipso vulneratus in brachio, de suo dejectus est eraissario ; sed mox ut ilium per vocem cognovisset, fcF-tinus descendit, ac ilium suum ca)«llum ascendere ju.'^sit, et sic abire permisit. Ille autem, multis •oomm occiflis nonnullisque captis, ac filio suo Willelmo cum multis •lik mlnerato, fugam iniit." THE BATTLE OF OERBEROI. 819 Roger of Wcrulover (ii. i6) cuts the story short, but adds a new elemeut in a curse pronouncctl upon Robei-t by his father ; '* K«x "Willchnus, contra Robertum filiuni suum Wllum agens apud Gerberai castnini Galliae, equo pulsus est, et Willelmus filius ejus viilneratus, ct raulti de sud farailiS interfecti ; quapropter Hex maledixit Roberto filio suo, quam maledictionem, antequam obiret, expertus est evidenter." Matthew Paiis (i. 21), as usual, follows Roger, but with some improvements. The battle gets the epithet of " cnientissimum." William Rufus is not merely " \'ulneratus " but " graviter Isesus," and the fight is said to happen "apud Archenbrai," on which Sir Frederick Madden remarks, " The spot here indicated appears to be Auchy en Bray, situated about six miles south-west of Gerberai." Matthew is also more full about the curse ; " Rex in mentis amaritudine maledixit Roberto filio suo ; unde ipse Robertus multipliciter maledictionem paternam ante mortem, quam turpem subiit, in multis agendis evidenter est expertus. Et tunc i)ater abstulit ei Xormanniam, sed moritunis ad instantiam cir- cumstautium, quia cruce signabatur, vel in proximo pro patre signandus erat, earn ei restituit." There is something specially charming in the notion of Robert having already taken the cross, and of William thinking of taking it, in 1087. Lastly, the Hyde writer (297), as usual, has his o\\'n vei*sion. Tlie wound is transfen-ed from the hand to the foot, and it is clearly not meant to be inflicted by the hand of Robert. A sti*ange stoiy connecting William's death with the war with Robert is also added ; "Accidit qualam die, ut cum suis in Normanniam ingressus, raedibus et raj)inis insisteret, occurrit<|ue ei ]>atcr cum exercitu, et fugicntem prosecutus castrum quoddam intrare conipulit. Ubi duni Rex cum suis obstrepcret de foris sagitla in pede ex improvise est percussus. Quumque sanguinem defluere cemeret, terribiliter imprecatus est ne umquam Robertus filius suus haereditatis suae jura perciperet. Quae imprecatio quantum valuit teinj)ora scquentia satis ostendunt. Feiiur autem quod, duin eunidcm filium suum oppugnaret, valdc faligatus et sudore ])erfusus potum j)etierit, aquanujue frigidam sibi oblatam bibens, simul cum frigore mortem, pro hoc dolor I nimis cito potaverit." 302 APPKNDIX. NOTE TT. p. 655. Tub Bftrotiial or William's Dauohter to Alfonso. Ordkric (573 C, D), calling the (laiiL,'htcr of William who wan beiitiilied to Alfonso Agatlin, and making her the sumo who had bMB beCroihed to Ilarolil, tolls hor Btory thus ; •* Agatha Hogis filio, quae prius fuemt Herahlo dcpponsata, jWRt- modum Amfurcio Regi Gallici® per procos pcteuti misaa est dei|K}UMnda.' Hod qua; priori sponso ad votum gavisa noD est, wcundo Bociari valdc abominata ost. Angluni vidcratct dilexcrat. Hed Hiliero conjungi nimis metuit, quern num([uam perspcxerat. Omnipotcnti ergo effudit preccm lacrimosam, nc duceretur ipsa in HispaniAin, sed ipse potius 8uscii)eret cam. Oravit, et exaudita est ; obit^rque virgu defuncta est," William of Malmeshury (iii. 276), distinguishing between the betrulbed of Harold and the 1)otrothed of Alfonso, tells nearly the Mme story of the latter ; " Aldefonso Galliciae Regi per nuntios jarata, virgincam mortem impetravit a Deo. Kepertus in defuuctae genibos calluB crebrarum ejus orationum index est." The date of this proposed marriage is by no means easy to fix. We must not forget the remarkable passage of William of Poitiers (120) alK>ut two brother Kings in Spain disputing for a daughter of William : *' Hispauiie Reges duo germani, audit i ejus magni- tudine, natam ejus in matrimonium cupientissime petierunt, suum et regnum ct posteritatem hac magnificaturi affinitate. Nam ct lb Tilde inimica inter ipsos propter earn orta est, minima degc- iMrem sed omnino dignam t^ili parente, sic moribus omatam, sic n ainore Christi studiosam, ut Rcginis et sanctimonialibus exemplo CMC poMct puella non velata." If the Archdeacon pays the faintest raipeet to chronology', all this is placed before William came into England. But Alfonso of Leon and Sancbo of Castile did not suc- cee«I their father Ferdinand till 1065 (Art de Verifier les Dates, iii. 74 1 ), and the most stirring time of their warfare was in 1070- 1072. But there wa« an earlier struggle of brothers in the former genera- tion, namely the war between Ferdinand and his brother Garcias, THE CLAIM OF ASCELIN. 821 which is recorded in tlie Chronicle of S;iiiit Muxentius (Lahbc, ii. 210) under the year 1058 (see Art. de Verifier lew Dates, u. 8.). But tins was womlcrfully early for any one to \>e thinking of a daughter of William, who could hardly have yet displayed the remarkable excellences of which we hear, and the Kings concerned are not Alfonso and his brother, but their father and uncle. Again, in the same Chronicle t>f Siiint Maxentius, 1069, we read that Alfonso married a daughter of Guy-Geoffrey of Aquitaine, of whom we have heard before (see vol. iii. p. 137). She is said to have been divorced and Alfonso to have manied again in 1080, so that the chronology becomes nearly hopeless. NOTE UU. p. 718. The Claim of Abcelin. The story of Ascelin appears in Orderic and, with some varieties, in AVace and Benoit. It ai)peai"3 also in AVilliam of Malmesbury (iii. 283), in the Hyde writer (297), in Eadmer (Hist. Nov. 13, Selden), and in William of Newburgh (i. 13), who is copied by "Walter of Hemingburgh (i. 19). But none of them give the name of the claimant. In "William of Newburgh he is pimply ''(juidam;" Ridmer calls him "quidam nisticus," and the Hyde writer ''ju- venis satis infimus." AVilliam of Malmesbury's version is, " Miles (juidam, ad cujus patrimonium locus ille pertinuerat, clard contestaus voce rapinam, sepulturam inhibuit, dicens avito jure solum suum ease, nee ilium in loco quern violenter invaserat paustire debere." In Walter of Hemin<,d)ur^h " terribiliter accedit, omnipotentis Dei pi*jptento nomine." Ho adds much the same comment as "William of Malmesbury ; " Obstupuere onmes (pii aderant, tninsitoria* domi- nationis actum considerantes, ut princej)s potentissimus, «jiii tarn late dominatus fuerat vivus, locum coqwris sui capacem mortuus sine querela non liaberet." Orderic's story should be comparecau, Saint- lit icnne, 34 ; " Vendidit Itannulfus filius Anselmi []^I. llij»p«'au seems to rentl Aftcfilini] Willehu<» .\l)l)ati Sancti Stephani oinnem teiTam sui juris AVVKSDiX, il eirea, et qui(l<(niil ccclefiiA ah cm) eiiierat in omni- bat locu. fub eA ooiulitiono ut non lit^Mit vol ipHi vol nlicui mio Ihh^ in rebtM iwicdictas aliqucm (|naii(lo(iuo clnnioivin fiicoro. la bk) Teoditiooe oomprahenBa est otuuiiio terra quain ImbiuTnt ^ilM dommm yrtyftwn et duo jugem prati ct unuin ju^'oniiii tami cum trihuB virgis. Hec quicUnn omnia ita diffinivit et Hr- BUint coram altAri Sancti Stcphani et coram Abbate etmagiid parte eoDWOtAft. prwwDie uxorc 8u;i et ])rfPsentibuK liboris ct concedcn- tibof atquc cum pat re doniuitibus." A little way on wc read, •• Veodidit Lanfinanoo Kamiulfus filiiis -fVsceliui qiiatuor jugera terra? •rids undc lapidcs extrahuutur ad opus monaRterii." Both thcBC Mlat belong to an earlier time than the death of William, as the AblK>t William of the charter is the William who was now Arch- bbhop of Konen ; see p. 66 1. One can hardly doubt that these passages refer to the same IuikI •ad the mme family as the story in Orderic. To me they cer- tainly mggeat the idea that there may have been two sides to the qjoattion, and perhaps the more so when wc mark the unusual care which the charter seems to take to bar all possible claims, and the equal vehentenoe with which Ascclin, in Wucc's version, is made to deny all atles or transfers. We must further remember that the temw "violenter" and "par la force" do not necessarily mean more th^n an occupation alleged to be illegal, just like "per vim" in E>oine0day or " mid unlage" in our own charters. And I am incline^l to give William the benefit of the same favourable con- •tmction which in a somewhat similar case I have asked for Harold ; •ee ToL ii. p. 544. One of the gates of Caen was called Porte Arthur ; see Wace, 16407 ; Hippeau, Saint- Etienne, p. 36. The objection to burjnng William in ground not his own may be compared with the scruples of Simon of Valois about his father ; •ee above, p. 653. APPENDIX. 92$ I add a few things which Imve «)courroil to inc while puttiujj these Notes together. 1. The answer of the men of Exeter to Wflliam in p. 146 may \)e coini)areil with the answer of the Tyriuns to Alexander under circumstances not unlike those of William l>efore Exeter. They fii-st promise (Aman, ii. 15. 9) to obey all his commands {nf)a(r(rti9 6 Ti &p f'nayyfWtj 'AXt'^avipoy) ; but when hc demands to cuter the city, they draw back (ii. 16. 1 1) ; ra fuv aXXa tio^ o-f^io-i noit'ip o TiTTfp (rrityytWrj 'AXt^avdpos^ tls d* rfjv froXiv ^qrt riva Utfxrit w firjri 2. The storj' of William's humiliation before Ealdred is also found in William of Xewburgh, i. 1 2 ; '* Cujus motum ille { Willelmus) non Bustiuens, ad {K^des ejus (Aldredi) procidit, veniam petiit, satis- factiouem spopondit, Quumque optiraatos qui aderant suaderent, ut regeni prostratum erigeret ; * Sinite,' inquit, ' ilium jacere ad l>ede.s Petri.' Plane in hoc et quanta fuerit ferocissimi j)rincipis pnesulis circa principem auctoritas atque fiducia, satis declaratum est." Tliis is copied by Walter of Heniingburgh, i. 10. 3. In 8]>€aking of Rittle Abbey (p. 409), I ought to have men- tioned the legend which says that the blood of the slain is still to be seen, a legend which I found in full force on the s|>ot. The story is told by William of Newburgh, i. 13, where lu; cites it as a proof of the injustice of William's invasion ; " Saue quod idem (Willelmus) Christianos innoxios hostiliter Christianus impetiit, et tanto sibi sanguine Christiano regnum paravit, quant«e apud homines glorioe, tanta etiam aj)ud Deuni noxa? fuit. Cujus rei argumentum est (|Uod a tcstibus fide dignis acccpimus." He then mentions the foundation of the Abbey, and goes on ; '^ Denicjue in codem nionas- terio locus ille ubi Anglorum pro patria dimicantium maxima strages facta est, si forte medico imbre maduerit, verum sanguinem et quasi recentem exsudat : ac si aperte |>er ipsam rei eviilentiam dicatur, quourgh, i. 20. Ilf4 AI'I'KNDIX. Mfttthrw Pan»intlio Abbirvi»tio riironiconim (iii. 169) HtninHy ta»kf ihc coii^ ' "f lb*' church of lUitth* happen within tho yrmr after the i-^mv.- .iM-lf. ami h«fn)inj;ly Uforo NVilliunrH coronn- Uoo; •* b>«>lr«An». qimm IWlum umK-lhivit, nnuo soquenti BoUem- aiirr fcrit d«li«m ; ubi jumni ct ccrtiwiime proniittcns se dilec- laMiini I^fii Riwanii lepw in>nolabilitcr obsonfttunim. et vcfitiffia #lat ■Mtiendo gcntcm An^'licanftiii Kincoro conic conHcrvntnni dih^c- lorum. j^Untor ob omnihuH c8t suBCcptus. Et Lon(h>niaH vmions, • rivibut cunctU c«t honorntUH ct [ah] Aldifdo, Archicpiscopo Ebormoeoti, apud We«tmuua8tcrium corouatus est/' 4. There U ft good deal of confusion as to the dates of the Abbots of Ely. and I seem to have been misled in pp. 482, 483 bv fidlowinjf the niar^nnal dates in Stewart's llif^toria Eliensis. Neither tluit version nor the version of Thomas t)f Ely in Anglia 6mcn U quite consistent in its chronolog}-. From the Winchester Aniudf (Ann. Mon. ii. 33) it seems plain that Simeon was appointed, not in 1086, but in 1082. Godfrey administered the church of Ely for seven years (Stewart, 251). This takes us hack to 1075, in which year, aceonlin^ to Wharton's note in Anglia Sacra (i- 610), Tlieodwine died in the month of December, after an incumbency of two years and a half. He could not have died in 1074, as Thomas of Ely says in his text, because he signs the decrees of the Council of London in 1075. It follows therefore that Theodwine's predeeesBor Thurstan probably died early in 1073. He could not have lived till 1076, nor yet have died, as lliomas of Ely makes him. in 107 1, because he signs the decrees of the Council of Windsor in 1072 (Will. ^falm. iii. 298). The confusion is pn^bahly due to a mistake of the writer of the Historia Eliensis, who mistook the five years assigned to Tliur- stan^s abbacy by Thomas of Ely (Anglia Sacra, i. 610) for five jean alicr the surrender in 1071. But the reckoning of five years most be wronj?, because both Thomas of Ely (Anglia Sacra, i. 609) and the Ely History (Gale, ii. ch. 44) make Thurstan appointed by Harold in 1066. Thurstan therefore was Abbot just seven jcmni ; Thomas of Ely probably got his five years by confounding the surrender in 1071 with Thurstan's death in 1073. The order will th»refun- Htaiul finis ■ AITENDIX. 825 Thurstan ... 1066 — 1073. Theoilwine .... 1073 — 1075. Adiniiiistmtion of Godfrey . 1075 — 1083. ►Simeon .... 1082 — 1094. 5. The history of RichiUli.s, of which I have said something' in pa«,'e 533, comes out more fully in the Oenealogia Comituni Flaudrij© (Pertz, ix. 320-322). Some of the details are curious, and Kichildis, like some of our other heroines, must have Ijeen far from younjjf at the time of William Fitz-Osbeni's wooinj(. Piy her former Imsband Hermann she had a son Ro^er, who was conveniently made Bishop of Chalons ; " Vitricus ejus Balduiuus pro nimia simplicitate minus sjeculo idoneum clerieatu et Cata- hiunensi episcopio sublimare procuravit, ejus hsereditate ita sibi usurpata." She and Baldwin were excommunicated by Enijfelbert Bishop of Cambray on the ground of kindred between liald- win and Hermann, but Pope Leo the Ninth, who was uncle of Kichildis, partly released them in the Council of Rheims in 1049 (see vol. ii. p. 112); " Hanc meruerunt indulgeutiam ut in con- jugio quidem, sed absque camali commixtione manerent." (Yet, according to the same account, their son Arnulf was only fifteen years old in 1070.) During her regency we hear of her *• muliebris insolentia," her " t}Tannis," " superbia," and the '* nimia cmdelitas qua in clerum et populum saeviebat," and especially of her spoliations of the church. Her dealings with William Fitz-Osl>ern are thus described ; " Mulier rixosii et callida . . . ncc eiiibcscens trigamiam conatur adhuc nubcre cuidam Guillelmo subcomiti superbo de Xor- mannia, in hoc quo(juc commovens amplius contni se (piosdam Flandriarum principes et populum." Robert has an interview with Richildis at Ghent and demands the possession of what is oddly called his " patemum reijnum," but Richildis, " femineo furore exagitata, injuriosis responsionibus protestatur ;" the " in- juriosae rcsponsiones " taking the fonn of five hexameters. Robert appeals to King Philip, who promises hira help, but is bribed by Richililis, wlio " consilio Regis compcrto, animum ejus quattuor millium libninmi auri spon.sione corrupit et ab incepto negotio fraudulenter revocavit." We then get a minute account of the war and of the battle <»f Casscl, with the further details that both ati APPENDIX. P^iknilU tad Bobert were (nkcn primtnoni, lait wcn^ nrtcnvnnlfl rtltMML Bat we gvi no mention of tlic |>onMinH in wimni >vi> nrc ■MctAllr ioUmwtMl, cxcrpi no far m they coroo under t)M> general kcadof " KanmnnL'* We alto hear of tlic refornmtion of Jiichihlis, Aod of lix* holy life of her later dap. 6. I know not how I came, when writing the account of tJio ffajliih Warangiani in pp. 6a8, 633, to pn^s hy the second mention of their exploit* in Onlerie, 640, 642, where he gives an account of the camiMiign of Dyrrhaehion, but does not mention the exploits of the Knglish in the hat tie. He has a curious panegjric on Ale&ioA, and telU us (641 W) of his taking the English into his wpf !^l favour; "Anglos qui, jH'renipto HeraKh) Rcge, cum ])ro- ocribtu regni Albionem reliquerant et a facie Willelmi Regis per pootmn in Tliraciam navigavenmt, Alexius in amicitiam sihi ascivit, ebque princiiMile palatiura regiostjue thcsauros palam comnicnda- ▼it ; quinetiam eos cajMtis sui rennnque suarum custodis ])osuit." This is so far not in favour of my theory of a special migration in 1081. A fn^cat numlK-r of passages bearing on the history of the Warangians are collected by Zeuss, Die Deutschen unci die Nachba/r- stantme^ 560, 561. In the wildness of Byziintiue ethnology they are caJled Germans, Celts, and Britons, but the most remarkablo paaeage is one which does not immediately concern the "Warangians, bat which shows how tlK»roughly the notions of axeman and Englishman were identified in Byzantine minds, and how it had not wholly paased out of memory that the land which was then England had once been Britain. This is in Nikctas, Isaac Angelos, ii. 8 (p. 267, Paris) ; Philip Augustus and Bichard Cojur de Lion appear as 6 pq^ ♦payyt'ar xai 6 TOiv TTfKfKvf^opoiv Kardpxoiv Bp(Tapvo)Vy otf rvr ifMcw ' lygXivovsj and directly after Richard is 'lyyXuov f)q$. 7. I do not profess to know with certainty what Florence means by the wortf '* Ytene," which he gives as the English name of the New Forest (see p. 612), but some light is thrown upon it by a passage ID the genealogies attached to his Chronicle, i. 276, where we are told that William Rufus " in provincia Jutamm in Nova Foresta, «gitt4 percuaniB, sine filiis occubuit" I presume that Ytene APPENDIX. 827 htm something to do with the Jutes, but I conceive it simply to refer to the ohl Jutish settlement in Hampshire. Sir Francis PalL,n-avc, in one of the noblest passages of his work, the description of the Xew Forest in iv. 644, 648, calls it *' the Jetten-Wald, the Eotena-Wald, the Giant's- Weald." 8. yKthelnoth's story of the English lacing bidden to shave their lx?ards, which I mentioned in p. 689, appears again in two paasages of Matthew Paris in the Gesta Abbatuni, i. 42 (cf. the passage quoted in p. 803). With a grand contempt of fact and chronology, we reatl, ''Conculcabantur spreti et derisi nobiles Angli, jugimi servitutis a tempore Bruti nescientes, et more Normannorum barl)as radere, cincinnos tondere cogebantur." The other j)assage in the Historia Anglorum, i. 11, is to the same effect. The same idea comes out in .Nfatthew's account of William of the long beard in 1 196 (181, Wats), •* Cujus genus avitum ob indignationem Xonnan- nonim radere barbam contempsit," in which case it is a little strange that he should have borne the name of William. But how is this doctrine to Imj reconciled with the Tapestry, where no Englishman of the generation of Harold and William appears with a beard I END OF VOLUME THE FOURTH,