'mi ■rnmi^^ ■M^' m mn m Pm THE HISTORY OF THE NORMAN CONQUEST OF ENGLAND, ITS CAUSES AND ITS RESULTS. BY EDWARD A. FREEMAN, M.A. XATE FELLOW OF TEINITT COLLEGE. VOLUME III. THE REIGN OF HAROLD AND THE INTERREGNUM. Quum ingressus fueris terram quam Dominus Deus tuus dabit tibi et possederis earn, habitaverisque in ilia, et dixeris ; Constituam super me Uegem, sicut habent omnes per circuitum nationes ; eum constitues quern Dominus Deus tuus elegerit de numero fratrum tuorum. Non poteris alterius gentis hominem Regem facere, qui non sit frater tuus.— Dbut. xvii. 14, 15. AT THE CLAEENDON PRESS. F3 3' CONTENTS. CHAPTER XL THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. January 5th — April 6th, 1066. A. D. PAGE 1065 — 1066 Preeminent importance of the year 1066 . . 3 — 5 § I. Sickness and Death of Eadward. December 28, 1065 — January 5, 1066. National anxiety as to the succession ; state of the royal line ...... 5 — *j Position of Eadgar, Harold, William, and Tostig . 7 Importance of Eadward's dying recommendation . 8 ecem r Pi-ogress of Eadward's illness ... g — January 5 ® ^ He recovers his speech ; his vision and prophecy . 9 — 13 Question of the succession ; 'Eadward names Harold as his successor . . . , . 14 His last directions and wishes . . . 14 — 16 Januarys His death ; English spirit of his last days . . 16 — 19 § 2. The Election and Coronation of Harold. January 5-6, 1066. January 5 Vacancy of the throne ; the Witan meet and elect Harold . . . . . . 19 — 21 Position of Harold ; he accepts the Crown . . 22 — 26 January 6 Double rites of the Epiphany ; necessity for a speedy burial and coronation . . . . 27 Burial of Eadward ; position of Stigand ; general sorrow at Eadward's death . . . 28 — 30 His popular canonization . . . . 31 — 32 1 102 His posthumous history; first examination of his body by Gilbert and Gundulf . , . 32 — 33 VOL. III. b CONTENTS. A.D, 1140 I161 October 13, 1163 October 13, 1369 1074 1118 1557 January 6, 1066 Attempt of Prior Osbert to procure his canonization Eadward canonized by Alexander the Third First Translation of his body Second Translation of his body ; rebuilding of West- minster by Henry the Third ; Henry's likeness to Eadward ; presence of Edward the First . The royal tombs around Eadward's shrine ; burial of Eadgyth ...-•• Burial of Eadgyth-Matilda .... The body removed by Henry the Eighth and restored by Philip and Mary .... Coronation of Harold ; Ealdred officiates Order of the ceremony ; the election in the church . The Unction and Crowning .... Question of the Marriage and Crowning of Ealdgyth PAGE 33—34 34 34—35 35—39 39 39 40—41 41—43 43—44 45—48 48 April 16 — 23, 1066 § 3. The First Days of Harold's Beign. January 6 — April 16, 1066. No Earl of the West-Saxons appointed; Harold keeps the South in his own hands and entrusts the North to Eadwine and Morkere .... Character of Harold's government ; Norman and English accounts ; no general expulsion of Normans Harold's military preparations and coinage . His relations to the Church, to Gisa, Wulfstan, and other Prelates ..... Formal concurrence of Northumberland in the elec- tion ; Northumberland never fairly represented in the Witenagemot ..... Refusal of the Northumbrians to acknowledge Harold ; probable agency of Eadwine and Morkere ...... Harold, accompanied by Wulfstan, goes to York and wins over the Northumbrians Harold's Easter Feast and Gem6t at Westminster . Effect of Harold's reign on London . Eadgyth at Winchester . • . . Ecclesiastical appointments in the Gem6t ; Ealdred of Abingdon and Thurstan of Ely ; importance of Thurstan's appointment .... January 15 ? The Crown challenged by William . April 24 — 30 The Comet ; its effects on men's minds Summary ...... 49—51 51—54 54 55—56 57-58 58—60 60 — 65 65 65—66 67 68—70 70—71 71—74 74 CONTENTS. XI CHAPTER XIL THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. I05I — 1066. A. D. PAGE 105 1 Recapitulation ; William returns from England . 75 Character and divisions of the period ; William's wars with France ; his war with Maine ; the Breton war and the oath of Harold . . . 'j6 — 78 § I. The Marriage of William and Matilda. 1049 — 1060. Position of William; political necessity of his mar riage ; domestic purity of his life . His counsellors recommend a marriage with Matilda of Flanders .... Position and greatness of the Counts of Flanders 1036 — 1067 Reign of Baldwin the Fifth; his connexion with France and England Matilda's former marriage and children 1048 — 1049 Beginning of William's courtship ; the marriage for bidden by the Council of Rheims . I 1053 Celebration of the marriage ; its coincidence with the captivity of Leo the Ninth Opposition of Archbishop Malger ; his character 1055 Malger deposed ; his banishment and death 1055 — 1069 Maurilius, Archbishop of Rouen, his life and cha racter ..... Lanfranc opposes the marriage ; his quarrel and re conciliation with the Duke 1054 — 1059 Lanfranc supports the marriage at Rome 1059 — 1060 Lanfranc returns with the dispensation Foundation of the two Abbeys of Caen 1066 ? Anselm Prior of Bee ; excellence of William's eccle siastical appointments Children of William and Matilda 78—80 80 81-83 83-84 84-87 87-89 90—93 93—96 96—98 98 — lOI loi — 103 104 — 106 106 108 — no no — III III— 113 § 2. William's Wars with France. 1053 — 1060. Character of the period ; Norman rebellions supported by France and A njou .... 113 — 114 Greatness of Normandy ; its natural hostility to France 1 1 4 — 1 1 6 1048 — 1053 Revolt of William Busac . . . . 116 The Counts of Eu ; their ecclesiastical foundations . 116 — 118 William Busac defends Eu against the Duke ; he is banished ...... 118 — 119 1058 He takes refuge in France and receives the County of Soissons ..... 119 — 120 b 2 • ' xii CONTENTS. A. D. PAGE 1053 Revolt of William of Arques; his former conduct; the Duke occupies the castle,; description of Arques 1 20 — 125 The castle betrayed to Count William ; his revolt ; march of the Duke from Valognes . . 125 — 128 The Duke blockades the castle ; King Henry helps the rebels ; ambush at Saint Aubin . . 129 — 133 Death of Ingelram ; history of the Cf>unts of Ponthieu 1 34 — 1 36 The King retires ; Moulins betrayed to him . 136 — 138 The castle surrenders ; Count William retires to Boulogne ...... 138 — 140 Hatred of the French towards Normandy ; enmity of Geoffrey of Anjou and other princes ; great con- federacy against Normandy . . . 140 — 144 1054 Double invasion of Normandy under King Henry and his brother Odo ..... 144 — 150 William's preparations ; his plan of defence and divi- sion of his forces ..... 150 — 153 Ravages of the French; they reach Moi'temer . 153 — 155 The French surprised and cut to pieces at Mortemer ; imprisonment of Guy of Ponthieu . . . 155 — 158 Promotion of William of Warren ; he marries the Duke's step-daughter Gundrada . . . 158 The news brought to William ; his stratagem and message to the King .... 158 — 160 Panic and retreat of the French army . . 161 Illustrations of the Norman national character . 161 — 163 William fortifies Breteuil .... 163 — 164 1055 Peace with France ; William authorized to make con- quests at the expense of Anjou . . , 164 1048 — 1063 Extension of William's frontier to the south; Dom- front and Ambribres .... 164 — 166 1055 New fortifications at Ambriferes ; William and Geoffrey before Ambricres ; flight of Count Geoffrey and homage of Geoffrey of Mayenne . 166 — 169 Further extension of William's frontier towards Anjou 169 1055 — 1<^58 Three years' peace . . . . . 170 August, Last French and Angevin invasion ; William's de- 10.^^ fensive policy ; advance and ravages of the French 170 — 172 The French at Varaville ; William's march ; the French surprised and cut to pieces ; the King retreats ...... 172 — 177 Peace with France ; restoration of Tillieres . . 177 1060 Death of King Henry ; his Russian marriage . 177 — 178 1059 Coronation of Philip the First . . . 178 1060 Baldwin of Flanders Regent for Philip ; death of Geoffrey Martel ; his dominions divided between his nephews ..... 179 — 180 CONTENTS. xiii A. D. PAGE 1058 Coincidence of the Battle of Varaville with HaroM's pilgrimage ; change in the state of Gaul after the deaths of Henry and Geoffrey . . . 180 — 182 § 3. The War of Maine. 1060 — 1064. 1060 — 1063 Banishment of various Norman nobles; affairs of Saint Evroul ; Synod of Caen . . . 183 — 185 Old Norman clauns over Maine ; early history of the country ; ecclesiastical and popular element at Le Mans ...... 185—188 924—978 Alleged grants of Maine to Rolf, to Hugh the Great, and to Geoffrey Grisegonelle . . . 188 — 189 Rivalry of the Counts of Maine with the Bishops and with the Counts of Anjou . . . 189 960 — 994 Count Hugh and Bishop Sainfred . . . 189 — 190 987 — 994 Fulk Nerra overruns Maine . . .. . 190 1015 — 1036 Count Herbert Wake-the-Dog . • • 190 — 193 994 — 1036 Avesgaud Bishop of Le Mans ; his disputes with Herbert ...... 190 — 192 1016 — 1028 Herbert's relations with Anjou ; his share in the Battle of Pontlevois ; his imprisonment at Saintes 191 — 192 1035 — 1 05 1 Hugh Count of Maine ; regency of Herbert Bacco . 193 1036 — 1058 Gervase Bishop of Le Mans ; he commends the Bishoprick to Geoffrey Martel ; expulsion of Her- bert Bacco ..... 193 — 194 1044 — 1 05 1 Gervase imprisoned by Geoffrey Martel . . 195 105 1 — 1061 Geoffrey Martel occupies Le Mans . . . 195 1051 — 1058 Gervase takes refuge in Normandy; he becomes Archbishop of Rheims .... 195 — 196 1060 Herbert commends himself to William on the death of Geoffrey; settlement of the succession . . 196 — 199 1063 Herbert dies childless ; succession of Walter and Biota ...... 199 — 200 War of Maine ; William ravages the country ; sur- render of Le Mans .... 201 — 207 Death of Walter and Biota ; William charged with poisoning them . . . . . 207 — 208 Geoffrey of Mayenne still holds out ; conquest of Mayenne ...... 208 — 212 Betrothal and death of Margaret of Maine . . 212 — 213 Importance of the conquest of Maine ; its connexion with that of England . . . . 213 — 215 § 4* The Visit of Harold and the Breton War. 1064 ? Position of William and Harold . . . 215 — 216 xiv CONTENTS. A. D. PAGE Their meeting ; contradictory nature of the stories ; connexion between the bequest of Eadward and the oath of Harold .... 217—218 Three different versions ; Harold's presence in Nor- mandy probably accidental ; probable presence of other members of his family . . . 219 — 221 Harold sets sail at Bosham ; he is wrecked in Pon- thieu and imprisoned by Gruy . . . 222 — 223 He is delivered by William .... 224 — 226- Harold at Kouen ; he engages to marry William's daughter and receives knighthood . . 226 — 229 Harold joins William in the war against Britanny 229 1040 — 1066 Conan Count of the Bretons . . . 230 1056 — 1062 Relations of Conan, Odo, and Hoel ; a party in Britanny favourable to William . . . 230 — 231 Conan's challenge ; Dol held for William . . 232 — 233 March of William and Harold to Dol ; description of the city ...... 233—237 Flight of Conan from Dol . . . . 237 Siege and surrender of Dinan . . . 238 — 240 Harold's oath ; various statements as to time, place, and terms ; question of the relics . . . 240 — 247 Probable nature of the oath ; an engagement to marry William's daughter, combined with a formal homage ...... 248 — 251 Moral aspect of the case; the English people not affected ...... 252 — 253 Summary ...... 254 CHAPTER XIII. THE NEGOTIATIONS OF DUKE WILLIAM. January — August, 1066. Position of William at Eadward's death . . 255 Effect on his schemes of Harold's sudden election . 256 § I . The Negotiations between William and Harold. The news brought to William ; his dialogue with William Fitz-Osbern .... 256 — 259 January 15 ? William's Embassy to Harold ; its object ; its possible 1066 connexion with the Northuuibrian discontents . 259 — 262 ; Constitutional language attributed to Hai'old . 262 — 265 William's point gained in the Embassy . . 265 CONTENTS. XV A. D. PAGE § 2. Claims and Arguments of William. No hope for William but in war ; no English party in his favour ..... 266 Difficulties of the enterprise ; comparison with the Norman exploits in Apulia . . . 267 — 268 William's appeal to his own Duchy ; influence of Lanfranc ; religious character given to the enter- prise ...... 268 — 272 No right of any kind in William ; Harold's oath irrelevant to the question .... 272 — 273 Bearing of William's appeal to public opinion and to the Papacy ..... 273 — 274 Fair colouring put on a bad cause . . . 274 — 275 Harold's claim unintelligible on the Continent . 275 — 276 William's claim adapted to continental opinion . 276 — 279 Wrong done to the Norman saints ; forestalling of the crusading spirit . . , . 280 General character of William's case ; various motives appealed to ; Norman grudge agamst England . 281 — 283 Charges against the English Church ; William out- witted by Hildebrand .... 284 — 286 § 3. The Norman Council and the Assembly of Lillebonne. 1066 William consults a select Council . . . 286 — 288 Its members pledge their own services, but recom- mend the calling of a larger assembly . . 288 The Assembly of Lillebonne ; its constitution . 289 — 290 Position and history of Lillebonne . . . 290 — 292 Parliamentary spirit of the Assembly ; strong oppo- sition to the enterprise . . . .292 — 295 Attempt of William Fitz-Osbern to cajole the As- sembly ; his speech to William ; his offers dis- owned by the Barons .... 295 — 297 No vote passed, but the Barons severally won over by William ..... 297 — 299 § 4. William* s Alliance with Tostig. William's supporters in England to be found only among the Norman settlers , . . 299 Position of Tostig ; his alliance with William . 300 — 303 May, 1066 He attacks England with William's consent . 304 § 5. William's Negotiations with Foreign Powers. William invites volunteers from all parts . . 305 xvi CONTENTS. A. D, PAGE The Conquest not a national Norman enterprise, but a Norman character impressed on the whole . 305 — 306 The foreign troops mainly adventurers; few foreign princes served ..... 306 William's embassies to foreign powers ; he sends to Kii)g Henry of Germany .... 306 — 307 1056 — 1066 Condition of the Empire in the early days of Henry the Fourth ; comparison of his minority with that of William ..... 307 — 308 No mention of the Norman embassy in Geri^an writers ; probable state of the case . . 308 — 309 Alleged embassy to Swend of Denmark . • 309 — 310 Embassy to Philip of France ; William offers to hold England of him ..... 310 — 311 Negotiations with Baldwin of Flanders . . 312 Zeal of Eustace of Boulogne ; Arnold of Ardres . 312 — 313 Great number of Breton auxiliaries ; Alan Fergant . 313 — 314 1066 Volunteers from Anjou, &c. ; state of Anjou ; war between Geoffrey and Fulk . . . 314 — 315 1066 War of Conan of Britanny against Anjou ; legend of his death ...... 315 — 316 William charged with the death of Conan . . 316 1061 — 1073 Negotiations with Rome ; Papacy of Alexander the Second; influence of Hildebrand . . . 317 William's embassy ; debate in the Conclave and strong opposition ..... 317 — 319 Decision in favour of William ; bull and gifts of Alexander ...... 320 — 321 Complete success of William's diplomacy . . 321 — 322 Summary . . .... 322 CHAPTER XIV. THE NORWEGIAN INVASION AND THE CAMPAIGN OF STAMFORDBRIDGE. May — September, 1066. Course of events before William's invasion . . 323 § I. The First Expedition of Todig, May, 1066. Easter, 1066 Harold in full possession of England . . 324 May Tostig lands in Wight ; his ravages . . . 324 — 325 May — Sep- Great preparations of Harold : he hastens to meet tember. Tostig ...... 325—326 Tostig ravages Lindesey ; he is driven away by Ead- wine and Morkere, and takes refuge in Scotland . 326 — 327 CONTENTS. xvii § 2, Tostig^s Applications to Swend and Harold Hardrada. A. D. PAGE Saga of Harold Hardrada ; mythical character of its details ...... 327 — 328 1064 War between Harold Hardrada and Swend ; peace concluded between them . . . . 328 Contradictions between the English, Norwegian, and Norman stories . . . . . 329 Norwegian version ; Tostig asks help of Swend and is refused ..... . 329 — 330 He goes to Harold Hardrada ; discussion between Tostig and Harold ..... 331 — 333 Harold determines on the expedition ; no mention of any Thing as consulted ; Norwegian estimate of the English Housecarls .... 333 — 334 September 8, 1066 §3. The Invasion of Harold Hardrada. September, 1066. Preparations of Harold of England for the defence of the South ; the North left to Eadwine and Mor- kere ; difficulty of keeping the fyrd on foot , 335 — 337 The army disbanded ; Harold returns to London with the fleet ; question of naval operations against the Normans ..... 338 — 339 Harold Hardrada sets sail ; he designs to reign in England ; his wives, children, and treasures . 339 — 341 Greatness of the expedition ; the last Scandinavian expedition against England ; omens on the voyage 341 — 343 Harold Hardrada in Orkney .... 344 1014 — 1064 Reign of Thorfinn in Orkney . . . 344 Tostig and Harold Hardrada meet in the Tyne . 345 Policy of Malcolm ; accession of various princes and volunteers ...... 345 — 346 The fleet on the coast of Yorkshire ; its ravages ; burning of Scarborough ; the English fleet retires into the Wharf ..... 346 — 347 The Northmen sail up the Humber, and land at Ric- call ; Tostig and Harold Hardrada march on York 348 — 349 Wednesday, Eadwine and Morkere march to meet them : Battle September n-r^ip , ,,. », -,-, ti 20 1066 of Fuliord ; defeat of the English . . 349^ — 351 Sunday, 24 Surrender of York ..... 352 — 353 § 4. The March of Harold and the Battle of Stamfordhridge. Hostages from Yorkshire to be delivered to Harold Hardrada at Stamfordhridge ; description of Stam- fordhridge and Aldby .... 353- ■356 XVlll CONTENTS. A. D. PAGE Position of the Norwegian army . . . 357 News of the Norwegian landing brought to Harold of England ; he determines to march to the North ; legend of his sickness and recovery . . 357 — 360 Harold's march ; gathering of recruits . . 360 — 362 Sunday, 24 He reaches Tadcaster and reviews the fleet . . 362 Monday, 25 He passes through York ; Battle of Stamfordbridge . 362 — 363 The Norwegian Saga ; its mythical character . 363 — 367 Sudden advance of the English ; loyalty of the country ...... 367 — 368 The battle begins on the right side of the Derwent . 369 The bridge defended by a single Northman . . 369 — 370 The English cross the bridge ; main fight on the left side ; complete victory of the English . . 370 — 371 Deaths of Tostig, Harold Hardrada, &c. ; escape of Godred ; burial of Tostig .... 371 — 37.^ Harold's mild dealing with Olaf . . . 374 — 375 October i ? Harold at York ; news of William's landing . 375 — 376 CHAPTER XV. THE NORMAN INVASION AND THE CAMPAIGN OF HASTINGS. August — October, 1066. Summer, 1066 June 15 June 18 § I , The Building of the Fleet. Success of all William's negotiations . . 377 — 378 Formation of the Norman fleet ; contributions of ships ; gifts of Remigius of Fecamp and of the Duchess Matilda ..... 378 — 380 Number and character of the ships . . . 381 Ecclesiastical afiairs ; Council at Bonneville ; Lan- franc Abbot of Saint Stephen's . . . 381—382 Consecration of the Holy Trinity at Caen ; dedication of Cecily ...... 383 § 2. The Embarcation and Voyage of William. August — September, 1066. August 1 2 The fleet at the mouth of the Dive . . , 384 — 386 Delay at the Dive ; good order maintained in the army ...... 386— 38 7 Numbers of the army . . . . 387 Spies sent by Harold ; their treatment by William . 388 — 389 CONTENTS. XIX A, D. [September 8] September 12 September 12-27 Wednesday, 27 Thursday, 28 491 Friday, September 29 William changes his position ; probable influence of the disbanding of Harold's army WiUiam sails to Saint Valery ; description and his- tory of the place ..... Losses of the fleet ; further delay at Saint Valery religious ceremonies and procession The south-wind blows ; the embarcation William sets sail ; details of the voyage William lands at Pevensey ; history and description of the place .... Taking of Anderida by ^lle and Cissa Defenceless state of the coast ; no resistance to Wil Ham's landing .... Details of the lauding ; William's ready wit William marches to Hastings ; history and import ance of the town ; he encamps on the hill Question of losses and skirmishes ; fate of the sooth sayer ..... William systematically ravages the country . Kobert the son of Wymarc counsels William to re treat ; his answer .... § 3. The Southern March of Harold. October 1-13, 1066. October i ? The news brought to Harold at York ; messengers from Pevensey and from Hastings Harold's position ; his Council at York ; he begins his march to London .... Merlswegen in command of the North ; Eadwine and Morkere keep back from the war . General zeal of the nation ; charge of parsimony against Harold ..... The army joined by the men of Wessex, East-Anglia, and Eastern Mercia ; loyalty of the Earldom of Waltheof ; special position of the men of Kent and London . . . . . . Names of Englishmen preserved ; Esegar, .^Ifric, Breme, Godric, ThurkiU, Eadric the Deacon ; the Abbots Leofric and -.'Elfwig October 5-1 1 Harold reaches London ; he waits for fresh troops His visit to Waltham ; his vow ; miracle of the Holy Rood . . . ■ . Messages between William and Harold ; mission of Hugh Margot to Harold ; Harold's counter- message and challenge .... PAGE 389—390 391—392 392—395 395—397 398—400 400 — 402 402 — 404 404—405 405—407 407—409 410— 411 411 — 412 413— 416 416 — 419 420 — 421 421 — 422 422—423 423—424 425—4^7 427 428—430 430—433 XX CONTENTS. A. D, PAGE Harold eager for battle ; advice of Gyrth ; Harold refuses to ravage the land .... 433 — 437 Thursday, Harold marches from London ; number of his army ; October 12. his plan and tactics ; he fights on ground of his own choice ..... 437 — 440 Friday, 13. Harold encamps on Senlac ; description of the site; its advantages ; he fortifies the hill . . 441 — 445 Stories of desertions, spies, &c, ; William's last message and challenge ; Harold refuses the single combat ...... 445 — 45° § 4. The Battle. October 14, 1066. The night before the battle ; ceremonial devotion of the Normans ; alleged revelry of the English . 450 — 453 Saturday, 14. Battle of Senlac ; William's speech to his army . 453 — 454 The Normans march to Telham and arm ; story of the reversed hauberk .... 455 — 457 Vital brings news of the English army; William vows to build a monastery on Senlac . . . 457 — 458 Threefold division of William's army ; on the left the Bretons, on the right the French ; the Normans in the centre ..... 458 — 461 Armour and weapons of the Normans . . 462 The standard and the group around it ; William and his brothers ; the standard borne by Toustain the White ...... 462 — 465 The Norman chivalry ; William Patry, Roger the Bigod, William Malet .... 465 — 467 Three classes of troops in each division ; order of the attack ...... 467 — 468 The two armies in sight ; Harold's speech ; story of the English spy ; Harold dismounts at the Standard ...... 468 — 469 Tales of Harold and Gyrth .... 469 — 471 Defences and close array of the English ; their armour and weapons ..... 471 — 474 The English ensigns ; post of the King and his kinsfolk by the Standard .... 475 — 476 Points of attack of the three divisions of the enemy 477 9 A.M. Beginning of the battle ; exploits of Taillefer . 477 — 478 First attack ; Norman and English war-cries ; the Normans beaten back .... 479 — 481 Flight of the Bretons on the left ; the light-armed Englisli pursue ; panic of the Normans ; William and Odo recall the fugitives . . 48 f — 484 CONTENTS. XXI A. D. PAGE Second attack ; personal exploits of William ; deaths of Gyrth and Leofwine .... 484 — 487 Partial success of the French on the right, but the general attack repulsed .... 487 — 488 "William orders the stratagem of the feigned flight ; the English on the right pursue ; the Bretons turn ...... 488 — 490 Slaughter of the French at the detached hill and in the western ravine ..... 490 3 P.M. The Normans ride up the hill ; single combats ; per- sonal exploits of William, Harold, and others . 491 — 495 The English resistance slackens, but the battle un- decided while Harold lives . . . 495 — 496 6 P.M. The archers shoot in the air ; Harold wounded in the eye and disabled .... 497 — 498 Fight round the Standard; the Dragon borne off and the Standard beaten down . . . 498 Harold killed by Eustace and others ; insults to his body ...... 499—500 Resistance and slaughter of the King's following . 500 — 501 Escape of the wounded Esegar and Leofric . . 501 Flight of the light-armed ; pursuit of the Normans and slaughter of the pursuers in Malfosse ; end of the battle ...... 502 — 503 Effect of the death of Harold . . . 504 Military estimate of the battle . . . 503 — 507 § 5. The Burial of Harold. Octob er — December, 1066. William returns to the hill ; his midnight feast . 507 — 509 Sunday, Burial of the dead ; burial of the English allowed ; October 15. discovery of ^ifwig and his monks; Harold's body not forthcoming .... 509 — 5^^ Osgod, ^^tiielric, and Gytha ask for the body ; Wil- liam commands that it shall be buried on the sea- shore . . . . . . 511— 513 The body found by Eadgyth Swanneshals, and buried on the hill at Hastings by William Malet . 513 — 514 Legend of Harold's escape, penitence, and death at Chester; mythical character of the story . . 515 — 518 1066 — 1540 Harold's alleged burial at Waltham; his translation ; destruction of his tomb .... 5^8 — 520 1307 The body of Edward the First at Waltham ; com- parison between Harold and Edward . . 521 — 522 xxii CONTENTS. CHAPTER XVI. THE INTERKEGNUM. October 15 — December 25, 1066. A. D. PAGE .The throne vacant ; William expects a general sub- mission; no submission as yet . . . 523 — 524 The news brought to London ; Eadwine and Morkere reach London, and send Ealdgyth to Chester , 525 Gemdt in London to choose a King ; no qualified candidate ; candidature of Eadwine and Morkere ; election of Eadgar . . . . 525 — 527 Character of the choice ; consent of Eadwine and Morkere; alleged opposition of certain Bishops . 528 — 529 November i Eadgar not crowned; death of Abbot Leofric ; the choice of his successor Brand confirmed by Eadgar 530 The Londoners and others eager for battle ; treason of Eadwine and Morkere ; no further general com- bination against William .... 531 — 532 October William at Hastings ; his policy of subduing the J5~20 country piecemeal ..... 533 20 His ravages ; he marches to Romney ; his vengeance 533 — 534 2 1 He marches to Dover ; description of the castle ; its surrender ; the town accidentally burned . . 535 — 538 October 29 The Kentish towns submit ; William marches to- wards Canterbury and receives its submission on the road ...... 538—539 October 31 — William encamps at the Broken Tower; his sickness December i ^nd consequent delay .... 540 He sends an embassy to Winchester ; position of Eadgyth ; Winchester submits . . . 540 — 541 c. December i London still holds out ; William marches against it ; skirmish and burning of Southwark , . 541 — 542 He keeps on the right bank of the Thames and crosses at Wallingford ; object of this course . . 543 — 544 Esegar in command in London ; tale of his com- munications with William ; his messenger deceived by William ..... 544—546 Submission to William agreed on in London . 546 William at Berldiampstead ; Eadgar, Ealdred, and others submit to him there and are graciously received ...... 547—548 William invited to assume the Crown ; probable feel- ings of Englishmen at the moment . . 548 — 550 William's council ; his professed unwillingness to ac- cept the Crown ..... 55a 551 CONTENTS. XXIU A. D. PAGE Speech of Hanion of Thouars ; William accepts the Crown; the coronation fixed for Christmas . 55 ^ — 553 Position of William ; triumph of his policy . . 553 He sends to fortify a post in London . . 553 His march to London ; opposite accounts of his con- duct ...... 554—555 Alleged refusal of Stigand to consecrate William ; Stigand's real position and share in the ceremony ; Ealdred the actual consecrator , . . 555 — 557 December 25 Coronation of William ; the approach to the church guarded by Norman horsemen . . . 557 The procession and ecclesiastical election . . 558 — 559 The Normans fire the houses near the church ; Wil- liam left alone with the officiating clergy . . 560 William's oath and consecration . . . 560 — 561 Summary . ... . . . 561 — 562 APPENDIX. PAGE, Note A. The Authority of the Bayeux Tapestry . . 563 B. Ead ward's Bequest of the Crown to Harold . 576 C. The Election of Harold .... 597 D. The Coronation of Harold . . . . 612 E. The Ancient Coronation Office . . . 622 F. The Date of the Mai-riage of Harold and Ealdgyth 625 G. The Character of Harold's Government . . 627 H. The Coinage of Harold .... 631 I. The Opposition of Northumberland to Harold's Accession . . . . . 632 K. The Political Position of the Lady Eadgyth . 635 L. The Afiairs of the Abbey of Ely at the time of Harold's Accession . . . . 636 M. The Comet of 1066 .... 640 N. The Marriage of William and Matilda . . 645 O. The Children of William and Matilda . . 658 P. The Revolt of William Busac ... 662 Q. The Revolt of William of Arques . . . 664 R. The Bequest of Ead ward to William and the Oath of Harold ..... 667 S. The ^Ifgyva of the Bayeux Tapestry . . 696 T. The Breton Campaign of William and Harold . 700 U. The Embassies exchanged between William and Harold ...... 701 XXIV CONTENTS. Note W. William's Councils and Negotiations X. The Movements of Tostig after his Banishment Y. Arnold of Ardres .... Z. The Death of Conan A A. The Operations of the English Fleet in 1066 BB. The March of Harold to York CC. The Details of the Battle of Stamfordbridge DD. William's Ravages in Sussex EE. Names of Englishmen at Senlac FF, The Dates of the Events between the two Great Battles ..... GG. The Messages between Harold and William HH. The English Numbers at Senlac . II. The Miraculous Warning given to Harold before the Battle .... KK. The Details of the Battle of Senlac LL. Ralph of Norfolk .... MM. The Burial of Harold NN. Eadgyth Swanneshals 00. The ^theling Eadgar PP. The Submission at Berkhampstead PAGE 708 713 714 716 718 720 728 729 732 733 740 742 743 751 754 763 766 767 ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. p. 6, 1. 14. For *'boy/' here and in one or two other places, it would be safer to say "young." On Eadgar's probable age see p. 766. p. 37, 1, 14, for "among all the Kings whose tombs are gathered together" read "among all the tombs of Kings which are gathered together." p. 52, p. 24, and p. 53, note i. I see that, when I wrote this, I had not fully seen my way to the true history of the two East- Anglian Ralphs. The Staller died soon after Eadward's death, and his son, the future Earl, was banished. See Appendix LL. p. 55, note 2, for "amplori" read " ampliori." p. 118, 1. 13. Bishop Hugh had a son named Roger, "Rogerius Hugonis Episcopi filius." See the Trinity Cartulary at Rouen, pp. 442, 443. p. 133, note I, for "sur" read "tur." p. 135, 1. 2. On Nithard's birth and his father's works at Saint Riquier, see also Nithard's own History, iv. 5. p. 136, note 4, add " Ord. Vit. 504 A." p. 139, note 2, for "armatura" read "armaturse." p. 156, note 3, after " the war" read "took place." p. 179, note 2, for "ut pote" read "utpote." p. 183,1. 5, for "we presently find" read "we shall presently find," and 1. 13, for "the" read "their." p. 190, note 3, for "Fulko" read "Fulco," p. 195, last side-note, for " 1061" read " 1051." p. 224, note I. Guy had two children, Ivo, who was at Senlac (see p. 499, note 4), and Agnes, wife of Robert of Belesme, who succeeded him. It should be noticed that in the Tapestry, pi. 4, he rides on a mule. p. 227, 1. 12. I now feel very little doubt that Harold's marriage happened after his coronation, at the time of his journey to York. p. 234, note I, for "makes" read "puts." p. 244, 1. 5 from the bottom. I here meant William of Poitiers, who makes no mention of the marriage in his direct account of the oath, though he after- wards takes it for granted in an incidental allusion. See pp. 687, 701. p. 247, side-note, for "into breach" read " into a breach." p. 264, note I, put a sign of interrogation after " permittere." p. 266, 1. 7 f-pom bottom. The case of Ralph of Norfolk as a possible ex- ception is to be borne in mind. p. 276, 1. 7, for "looked upon as, wherever" read "looked upon, as wherever." p. 312, 1. 6 from bottom. On the relations between William and Eustace see p. 748. p. 343, 1. 4, for " Northern King " read " a Northern King." VOL. III. C xxvi ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. p. 363, 1. II, for " smite" read " strike." p. 377, note I. I ought here to have quoted Orderic's fuller estimate of William of Poitiers and of Guy of Amiens (503 D) ; " De cujus [Guillelmi Regis] probitate, et eximiis moribus ac prosperis eventibus et strenuis admiran- disque actibus Guillelmus Pictavinus, Lexoviensis Archidiaconus, affluenter tractavit, et libram polito sermone et magni senstis profunditate prseclarum edidit. Ipse siquidem prsedicti Regis Capellanus longo tempore exstitit, et ea quae oculis suis viderit et quibus interfuerit longo relatu vel copioso indubi- tanter enucleare studuit, quamvis librum usque ad finem Regis adversis casibus impeditus perducere nequiverit. Guido etiam Prsesul Ambianensis metricura carmen edidit, quo Maronem et Papinium gesta heroum pangentes imitatus Senlacium bellum descripsit, fferaldum vituperans et condemnans, Ouillermum verb coUaudans et magnijiccms." This is at least as true of the Archdeacon as it is of the Bishop. p. 383, note I. The charter of Roger of Montgomery is a grant to the Trinity monastery at Rouen. Another grant of the same date to the same monastery I have mentioned, as bearing on another point in the history, in p. 717. In p. 451, on the same cartulary, we find the donation of a companion of William, who seems to have been mortally wounded or worn out in the cam- paign ; " E^ tempestate quS, Guillelmus, Dux Normannorum egregius, cum classico apparatu ingentique exercitu Anglorum terram expetiit, quidam miles, nomine Osmundus de Bodes, cum aliis illuc profectus, et languore correptus atque ad extrema perductus, pro animse suae remedio, dedit Sanctae Trinitati omnem decimam terrae suae in alodio," &c. p. 384, 1. 8 from bottom. On William's possible precautions with regard to Maine, see p. 683. p. 428, note 2, for " mere" read " more." p. 433, note I, for ** Chronicles " read "Chronicle." p. 445, 1. 5, dele " threefold." p. 458, note, for "adjuventur congruum," read '^ adjuventur, congruum." p. 466, note 4. On compater see Earle, Parallel Chronicles, p. 318. What a gap between this use of the word and the Sedition of the Ciompi. p. 467, note. On the origin of ^Ifgifu the wife of .^Ifgar, see p. 699, and vol. ii. p. 629. p. 472, 1. 12. On placing the inferior troops in the rear, see the tactics of Eadmund at Sherstone, vol. i. p. 424. p. 474, note 1, for " a-vixfiovKiois" read *' (rvfifiovXeiois." p. 476, note 2. Cf. vol. i. p. 577. p. 477, 1. 14, read, **at the eastern corner of the hill, where the present road from Hastings enters the town of Battle." p. 483, 1. I. Cf. the account of the danger of Severus at the battle of Lyons, Dion. Ixxv. 6 ; aitrhs rhv 'iirirov anofiaXiiV iKivSvpeva-ev, &s Sc elde (pivyovras •rravras rovs Ioutou, tV X^^H-^^i^ Tr€pt^^r]^oiiJ.€vos Koi rh ^icpos l3,st line. On the physical changes along this coast, see Earle, Parallel Chronicles, 315-317. p. 539, note I. This legend is doubtless the same as the legend of Birnam Wood coming to Dunsinane. p. 543, note 3. Another provision of the same kind for the Housecarls is found at Dorchester in Dorsetshire, Domesday, 75. p. 557, last line. Why did William have a new crown made ? One would have thought that he would have made a special point of being crowned with the crown which had been worn by Eadward. Was it held to be desecrated by the irregular coronation of Harold ? p. 607, 1. II from bottom, for ''thirteenth" read ''twelfth." p. 620, 1. II from bottom, after "takes its place," add "Harold the First seems to have been crowned at Oxford, Harthacnut at Canterbury ; Eadward was crowned at Winchester, perhaps at Canterbury also." p. 624, 1. 20. See also Depping, Expeditions Maritimes des Normands, i. 216; Pearson, Early and Middle Ages, i. 188. Depping's specidations are amusing enough, though he does not go quite so deep as Mdnard. p. 641, 1. 15. To these German accounts add Annales Wirziburgenses (Pertz, ii. 245), "A. 1066. Cometa videtur; et Anglia a Normannis subji- citur," and Annales Besuenses (ii. 249), "A. 1066. Stella cometes apparuit, et eo anno Rex Anglorum Haroaldus occiditur." p. 660, 1. 9 from bottom. See p. 703. p. 668, 1. 4, for "fratuelis" read " fratruelis." p. 670, 1. 14, for "need" read "accept." p. 684, 1. 18. It is a charter to Westminster, quoted by Ellis, i. 312. p. 685, 1. 3 from bottom. For another oath taken "supra philacteria reliquiarum," see Dudo, 126 C. xxviii ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS. p. 694, 1. 1 1 from bottom. Yet compare the strange statement of the Enco- miast (see vol. i. p. 454) about the ^thelings Eadward and .Alfred being sent into Normandy for education. p. 709, 1. 9. I ought not to have called "Ordericus Angligena" a ''foreign writer," but he wrote in a foreign country, and from a foreign point of view. For all these purposes he counts as a Norman writer. p. 714, 1. 19. "Ernulfus" or "Arnulfus de Hesding-" occurs also as a large landowner in Wiltshire, Domesday, 66, 69 b, and in other counties. p. 730, 1. 24. I know not whether I ought to have added to my list two other Hampshire Thegns of small estate, Eadnoth and Eadwig, who appear in the same page of Domesday ; " Sudberie tenuerunt Ednod et Edui in alodius de Rege E. et post mortem ejus ipsi quoque sunt mortui. Quidam vero proximus eorum Cola redemit terram de Willelmo Comite," This does not positively show that Eadnoth and Eadwig died at Senlac, but the time of their death and the apparent confiscation of their lands look like it. p. 731, 1. 23. Several curious personal details of Godric will be found in Domesday, 57 6, 58, 149. P- 736, 1. 2, for "six" read "twelve." p. 738, 1. 6, for "in vigiles" read "invigiles." p. 745, 1. II. Sir Edward Creasy, in his lately published History of Eng- land (i. 208), shows a better understanding of the ground than most modern writers. p. 748, 1. 7 from bottom. One or other of these stories about Eustace, it is hard to see which, seems to be darkly alluded to by William of Malmesbury (iii. 244). After mentioning how William had three horses killed under him (see p. 485, note 2), he adds, " Perstitit tamen magnanimi Ducis et corpus et animus, quamvis familiari susurro a custodibus corporis revocaretur ; perstitit, inquam, donee victoriam plenam superveniens nox infunderet." P' 75o> !• 3 from bottom. Thomas Wikes, in the opening of his history, ingeniously rolls together several accounts, and makes altogether short work of the battle, " In primo conflictu totum pondus proelii conversum est in Regem, qui coxa prope nates pene praecisS,, letaliter vulneratus post modicum tempus interiit. Comperta Regis morte dilapsus est ejus exercitus, fere om- nibus qui fugere non poterant interfectis." This reminds one of a passage of William of Malmesbury, which I ought to have quoted elsewhere. After his description of the battle, which he certainly makes out to have been hard fought enough, he goes on to make his celebrated comparison between the Normans and the English. After speaking of the English love of eating and drinking, he adds (iii. 245), "Sequebantur vitia ebrietatis socia, quae vironma animos effoeminant. Hinc factum est, ut magis temeritate et furore prse- cipiti quam scientia militari Willelmo congressi, uno proelio, et ipso perfacili, servituti se patriamque pessumdederint." I believe that some modern writers have inferred from this that the English went drunk into the battle, and have taken this as a text to preach the advantages of temperance. p. 751, 1. 2 from bottom, for "difference" read "differences." p. 754, 1. 6, for "text" read "notes." THE HISTORY OF THE NORMAN CONQUEST OF ENGLAND. VOL. III. B CHAPTEE XL THE ELECTION OF HAROLD.^ January 5th — April i6th, 1066. THE central stage of our journey is now reached. We Pre- are now on the threshold of the great year_, of that importance year whose effects on all later English, on all later European, °o66 ^ ^^^^ ^ The authorities for this Chapter and for the whole of this volume may- be dealt with in a single summary. For the most part they are the same as those which we have been using all along ; but they must now be looked at in a somewhat different way. Hitherto, except in the Chapters specially devoted to Norman affairs, our use of the Norman writers has been for the most part incidental. But, through the whole of the con- troversies of the year 1066, we must place English and Norman writers in a certain sense on a level. The writers of each nation — I speak of course mainly of contemporary writers — tell the tale from their own national points of view and in the way which is most favourable to their own national heroes. At no time must their statements be more carefully compared with one another, as no full or accurate narrative could be drawn from either side by itself. The English writers maintain a sort of sullen silence on those points on which the Normans are naturally the most full. The Noraians, on the other hand, through ignorance, through pre- judice, sometimes through direct disregard to truth, grossly misrepresent all English affairs. At this stage we lose the Biographer of Eadward, who ends his story in a most significant way at Eadward's death, and who has nothing beyond one or two dark allusions to anything later. On the Norman side we gain one most valuable source of help in the Tapestry of Bayeux, whose origin and importance I shall discuss in a separate note. (See Appendix A.) The Saga of Harold Hardrada in Snorro must also be carefully studied. Wild as it is in many parts, it is our most detailed account, and our only Scandi- navian account, of the campaign of Stamfordbridge, and it also shows us the way in which English and Norman affairs were looked on in Northern Europe. Later writers, down to as late a time as any one pleases, are, at this B 2 4 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. history can never be wiped out. No one year in later English history can for a moment compare, in lasting importance, with the year which, with some small exag- geration, we may call the year of the Norman Conquest. No later There have indeed been later periods in our history which which"one h^^c been as memorable in their results as the invasion year and ^f William itself. The events of the thirteenth, of one day stand out the sixteenth, of the seventeenth century, are all fully way. entitled to be set side by side with the events of the eleventh. But in all these cases we have to set the work of a whole generation against the work of a single year. One age is famous for the great struggle against alien domination, and for the final establishment of English freedom in its later form. Another age gave us all the results, for good and for evil, of the great Reformation of religion. A third age confirmed on a surer and more lasting basis those political rights which the thirteenth century had won back, but which the fifteenth and six- teenth had once more brought into jeopardy. But, in all these great periods of change, the work was gradual ; there is no single moment, no single year, on which we can place our finger as the moment or the year when the work was actually done. In the eleventh century the work was gradual also. A long series of events prepared the way for William's enterprise, and, when he began his work, it needed more than a single day or a single year to put him in full possession of the Empire for which he had yearned so long. Still in the eleventh century there is a single year and a single day which stand forth in a way in which no single day or year stands forth in the ages after them. There is no later year to compare to the year in which the Crown time, worthy of more than usual attention. Though for the most part of very little value in themselves, they tell us, what it is most important to learn, the way in which different ages looked at the greatest events in English history. CHARACTER OF THE YEAR I066. 5 of England was worn by the last King of the old sacred chap, xi, and immemorial stocky by the first and last King who reigned purely because he was the best and bravest among his people, and by the first and last King who could boast that he held his Kingdom purely of God and his own sword. There is no one day in later times to compare to that memorable morning when Northern and Southern Europe, when England and Normandy^ when Harold and William J met face to face in the great wager of battle on the day of Saint Calixtus. For days of equal moment in our history we must go back to far earlier times^ to times which are still half shrouded in the mist of legend. For a day like the day when England bowed to her first purely foreign lord, we must go back to the day when the first Englishman was baptized into the faith of Christ, to the day when the first Englishman set foot on the shores of Britain. § 1. Sickness and Death of Eadward. December 28, 1065- January 5, 1066. We left Eadward on his death-bed. His work was over ; Eadward's his newly built minster was hallowed, though he had been ^^^^^^ himself shut out from taking any part in that great cere- I^ecember mony. The Witan had been gathered, as usual, for the January 5, Christmas festival; the special summons to the dedication of Saint Peter^s, and, still more, the pressing urgency of the national affairs, had, we may well believe, called together a greater number than usual of the Thegns and Prelates of the land. It was plain that the nation would soon be National called on to elect a King, and to elect a King under to the "^ ^^ circumstances of which no past age had ever seen the like. Perhaps vague reports may already have found their way into the land, warning men of the dangers which were likely to threaten England alike from her own exiles and from the foreign kinsman of the dying King. But, succession. 6 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. even if no thought of Tostig or of William crossed men^s mindsj there was enough to make those days of Eadvvard's last sickness days of the deepest anxiety to every patriotic Englishman. From the beginning of Eadward^s sickness, no hope of his recovery seems to have been entertained. The question in every man^s mind must have been, who should fill his place when he was taken from them. The choice of the electors would be perfectly free. Things were not as they had been when Swend and Cnut were in the land, claim- ing the votes of the Witan at the point of the sword. But things were as they had never been before since the line of State of Cerdic had ruled over united England. The King who lay line.^^^^ at the point of death was_, with the single exception of the Taio^fl^Eadgar and his sisters, the last of his race. The names of Christina and Margaret were most likely never uttered ; England had never yet dreamed of giving herself a female ruler. A sentimental interest might gather round Eadgar as the last male of the kingly house, but a sentimental interest was all that he could awaken. His age and, as events proved, his character rendered him wholly unfit for rule. And Eadgar, it should be borne in mind, did not possess that constitutional claim to a preference which was all that, before the actual election, would have belonged even to a son of the dying King. At three earlier times had the royal line been reduced so low as to number none but members of an age too young for personal government. Eadwig, Eadward the Martyr, ^thelred, had all been chosen in their non-age. But the princes so chosen were all of them true ^Ethelings, Englishmen born, sons of an English King by an English mother. And, in those days, as there was no better qualified candidate in the royal house, so there was no man out of it marked out by the hand of nature as a born King of Men. In those days the greatest of living Englishmen was no Thegn or Ealdor- man, but the renowned Primate Dunstan. England had STATE AND PEOSPECTS OP THE SUCCESSION. 7 therefore^ in all those cases^ accepted a King* in his boyhood chap. xi. or even in his childhood. There was now no such need. Eadgar, grandson of Ironside as he was^ had no consti- No con- tutional claim upon the votes of the Witan beyond any preference other male person in the realm. He was not born in the i^V^ land ; he was not the son of a crowned King and his Lady. And close beside the throne^ iust beyond the strict limits Position of XT 1 1 of the royal hoitse_, stood the foremost man in England^ " ' already^ it may be^ associated in some sort to the honours of royalty^ already an Under-King who received the oaths and homage of vassal princes, as a sharer in the rule of the Empire of Britain.^ Whether he had been marked out by any formal act or not, we cannot doubt that men had long learned to look to Harold the son of Godwine as their future King. And yet, when the day of choice drew near, men might well stop and wonder at the step which they were about to take. The Law justified the act; the needs of the time commanded it ; but it was a strange and un- wonted act nevertheless. It was something new, some- Novelty of thing which might well set the minds and tongues of men from be- at work, to be called on, freely and under no fear of the ^ ■, } ^® -' 'J royal house. Danish axe, to choose a King who had no royal forefathers, a King who came not of the stock of Ecgberht, Cerdic, and Woden. Men whose office or whose sagacity had taught them to scan the chances of the time might ask how such a choice would be looked on by the exile at the court of Attitude Baldwin, and by the prince who now, in the height of ^^^^^ T^^g^ig. success and glory, had made the Norman land the wonder of continental Europe. Humours might already be afloat that the English Earl, soon about to become the English King, had, in some strange and unknown way, already become the man of the Norman Duke. And without going Possible so far afield, men might ask how the great land north of ^orthum- the Humber would look on the choice which to Wessex berland. ^ See vol. ii. pp. 424, 634. 8 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. and East-Anglia seemed the only choice possible. The Thegns and Prelates of Northumberland might give their votes with the other Witan, but would the fierce people of that proud and distant province submit^ without a blow or a murmur, to the kingship of a West-Saxon, a son of God- wine, a brother of Tostig? The days when thoughts like these were working in men^s minds must have been days of Importance care and perplexity. There was one source-from which light ward's ^^'^^ ^^^^P flight be looked for_, light and help which might in dying re- gome sort sccm to come directly from heaven. The words of a commenda- '^ tion. dying man have been in all times looked on as solemn and almost prophetic utterances. The words of a dying King were, by the traditional feelings of Englishmen, clothed with an authority second only to that of the Law itself. Eadward was a dying man and a dying King. And he was yet more. Strange as it seems to us, he was already beginning to be looked on with somewhat of the reverence due to a Saint. The will of Eadward had perhaps never been held to be of such moment, his voice had perhaps never been so eagerly listened for in the Councils of his Kingdom, as when he lay, helpless and wellnigh speechless, on his bed at Westminster. Men waited for the voice of the dying man, the dying King, the dying Saint, to confirm once more with his last breath the nomination of the successor on whom, amidst all doubts and dangers, the heart of England still was fixed. In choosing for the first time a King not of the blood of Cerdic, it would be no small strength and comfort if they knew that the step was taken with the full approval and the full bidding of the last King of Cerdic's house. The King was sick unto death ;' the Witan were gathered round his palace. The moment the breath was out of his body, it would become their duty to choose his successor. It was doubtless with no small anxiety, with somewhat even of religious awe, that they awaited the last expression of the will of Eadward as to who that successor should be. eadward's death-bed. 9 The West Minster was consecrated on Wednesday ; the chap. xi. news was brought to the King, who, as his legend says, The King's illness, on hearing it laid his head on his pillow as if to say, It wednes- is finished.^ For five days his sickness increased, and ^g^^'ijjy^28 the public anxiety heightened at every stage of the dis- 1065. order.2 On the sixth day from the consecration, his speech He becomes l)egan to fail him ; his voice was so feeble that his words Tuesday, could no longer be understood ; for two days he lay worn -'^"^55"^ out by the extremity of his sickness.^ It was no time to trouble the weary sufferer with questions even as to the welfare of his Kingdom. At last, on the following Thurs- He re- day, the eve of the Epiphany, his flagging powers rallied, speech. as. the powers of dying men often do rally at the point of j^J^u^^j^^^^c death. He awoke from his sleep in the full possession of his senses and of his speech. On either side of his bed stood The group IT- the two great chiefs of his realm, Harold the Earl and bed. Stigand the Archbishop.* At the bed''s head, in still more immediate personal attendance on his master, stood the S taller, Robert the son of Wymarc, a man of Norman birth, but whom history does not charge with treason towards ^ ^tliel. Kiev. X Scriptt. 399. "Peractis itaque omnibus pro tanta sollennitate, quasi diceret Rex ' Consummatum est,' inclinat in lectulo caput; et exhinc ccepit gravi dolore fatigari." ^ lb. "Tunc moeror et luctus omnium, una vox plangentium." This we can well believe ; but the hagiographer is plainly writing with the help of his own fuller knowledge, when he goes on to say ; '• Prsesentiebant plures ejus in morte desolationem patriae, plebis exterminium, totius Anglicae nobilitatis excidium, finem libertatis, honoris ruinam." Tlie moment was an anxious one, but no one who had not Ead ward's own gift of prophecy could foresee all this . - ^ Vita Eadw. 430, " Biduo vel amplitis adeo eum languor fatigaverat, ut vix quum loqueretur quid diceret intelligi posset." These details should be compared throughout with the account in ^thelred, who developes and improves upon every touch. * The Biographer (p. 431) describes those present as '^ Regina terrse assidens ej usque pedes super gremium suum fovens^ ej usque germanus Dux Haroldus, et Eodbertus regalis palatii stabilitor et ejusdem Regis propinquus (?}, Stigandus quoque Archiepiscopus." iEthelred (400) gives the same list, but stops to abuse Stigand. The four will be seen in the Tapestry (pi. vii. Bruce, p. 74) as I have described them. 10 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. England. On the ground, close by the foot of the bed, sat the Lady Eadgyth, the sister of the great Earl, cherishing the feet of her royal husband in her bosom. Her thoughts wandered perhaps to the brother beyond the sea, the brother on whose behalf she had so deeply sinned, the brother who had so lately held the place nearest to Eadward's heart, but who was now for ever cut off from all hopes of crowns or earldoms. The tongue of Eadward was loosened, but his first words were words of prayer. ^ In his long slumber he had seen a vision ; if that vision were truly from heaven, he prayed that he might have strength to declare it ; if it were but the phantom of a disordered brain, he would that his tongue should rather cleave to the roof of his mouth. He sat up in his bed, supported in the arms of Robert. But the message which he had to declare from heaven called for a larger audience than the four favoured ones who were gathered round him. A few more of his chosen friends — their names are not recorded — were summoned to He declares the bedside of the dying King.^ He then, fluently and with energy,^ poured forth the awful words of warning. ^ In this account of Eadward's death-bed I follow the contemporaiy Life, which is closely followed by William of Malmesbury, ii. 226, ^thelred, or Osbert whom he copied, evidently had the Life before him, but he thought it his duty to expand every speech and incident. The reader must form what judgement he pleases as to the prediction put into Eadward's mouth. Per- haps most modern readers will be inclined to be of the same opinion as Stigand. But I did not think myself justified in wholly leaving out what T find in a contemporary writer, who affirms that he had his information from eye-witnesses ( " sicut testantur hi qui aderant prresentes," Vita Eadw. p. 430), that is, very probably from Eadgyth lierself. In fact the con- temptuous incredulity attributed to Stigand is of itself a strong argument that something professing to be a prophecy was actually uttered by Ead- ward on his death-bed. Of course I do not pledge myself to the historical accuracy of the exact words. Eadward would speak English, or more pro- bably French, and his words would gain a good deal in the course of their translation into rhetorical Latin. ^ Vita Eadw. 431. "Cum paucis aliis quos idem beatus Rex a somno excitatus advocari jusserat." ^ lb. 430. *' Tanta usus est loquendi copia ut cuivis sanissimo nihil opus esBet suprk." eadwakd's vision. U " Long ago, when I was a youth in Normandy, I knew chap. xi. two monks, most holy men and most dear to me. Many long years have passed away since they were taken away from the cares and sorrows of this world. But now, in my trance, God hath sent them again to me to speak to me in His holy name. ' Know,^ said they to me, ^that they who hold the highest place in thy realm of England, the Earls, the Bishops, the Abbots, the men in holy orders of every rank, are not what they seem to be in the eyes of men. In the eye of God they are but ministers of the fiend. Therefore hath God put a curse He fore- upon thy land ; therefore hath He given thy land over into gor^ow^ of the hand of the enemy. Within a year and a day from England. thy death, shall fiends stalk through thy whole land, and shall harry it from one end to another with fire and sword and the hand of plunder."* Then said I to them, ' Let me then show these things to my people in the name of God. Haply they will repent, and His loving-kindness will have mercy upon them. For He had mercy on the men of Nineveh, when they heard the voice of His threatening, and repented them of their evil ways."* But they answered me, ^ They will not repent, neither shall the mercy of God come nigh unto them.^ Then said I, ' What shall be the time Allegory of or the way in which we may look for these your threaten- tree^^^^^ ings to come to an end V ' In that day,"* they answered, ' when a green tree shall be cut away from the midst of its trunk, when it shall be carried away for the space of three furlongs from its root, when, without the help of man, it shall join itself again to its trunk, and shall again put forth leaves and bear fruit in its season. Then first shall be the time when the woes of England shall come to an end."* ''"' ^ ^ The Biographer records this last famous prediction or similitude without any attempt at an explanation. When he wrote, in the early years of William, a Prometheus after the fiict might well put into Eadward's mouth a prophecy of the Conquest of England and of the general misfortunes of the country. But he could not put into his mouth a pi'ophecy in honour of Stiuand. 12 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. The King ceased his words of prophecy. Harold, Eadgyth, tht^oTher I^o^crt, all who had been gathered to hear, were struck with hearers; ^we, and remained speechless. One heart alone, we are aisbeliefof told, was hardened. Stigand leaned over the King's bed, and whispered in the ear of Earl Harold that all this pro- phetic talk was but the babbling of an old man worn out by sickness.^ The Primate, stout-hearted Englishman as we know him, was, we may well believe, a hard and worldly man, and his experience of men of his own calling, his familiarity with what others looked on as miracle and pro- phecy, may well have made him less inclined to superstition Henry the Second. Either then the passage is a later interpolation, of which the Editor gives no hint, or else Eadward really uttered some alle- gory, quoted some proverb, or, as Stigand thought, simply talked nonsense, on which people began to put a meaning forty years later. The orthodox explanation is that the tree removed from the root for the space of three furlongs (the words are ^'trium jugerwn spatio," but one can hardly make acres a measure of length) means the Crown transferred to usurpers during three reigns, those of Harold and the two Williams (the descent of William Kufus from JElfred is forgotten, see vol. ii. p. 304). The tree returns to the root when Henry the First marries Eadgyth or Matilda the daughter of Margaret ; it bears leaves at the birth of her children. William of Malmes- bury (v. 419) witnesses that the birth of the ^theling William (c. iioi) was looked on as the fulfilment of the prophecy, which shows that it had already attracted attention, most likely at the marriage of William's parents. The death of the -^theling in 11 19 cut off all such hopes, but at the same time it opened the way for a more elaborate fulfilment in the persons of his sister and her son. The tree now brings forth leaves at the birth of the Empress Matilda and fruit at the birth of Henry the Second. See ^thelred 401, and the French Life, 3805 et seqq. The writer seems in v. 3846 to confound Henry the Second and Henry the Tliird. ^ Vita Eadw. 431. " Cunctisque stupentibus et terrore agente tacenti- bus, ipse Archiepiscopus, qui debuerat vel primus pavere vel verbum con- silii dare, infatuato corde suhmurmurat in aurem Duels senio confectum et morbo quid diceret nescire." He had just before said that Harold, Robert, and Eadgyth were all frightened — ''terrentur nimium." ^thelred (400) leaves out Harold's fears, and also leaves out the characteristic and trust- worthy little touch of the Ai'chbishop whispering in the Earl's ear, which, as they stood (see the Tapestry) on different sides of the bed, involved leaning over the dying man. In his account the details of the contempo- rary writer evaporate in this fashion ; ** Is [Stigandus] ad vocem narrantis obduruit, nee terretur oraculo, nee fidem habuit prophetanti, sed potius Ilegeni confectum seniodelirare subraunnurans, ridere maluit quam higere."' DISBELIEF OP STIGAND. 13 tlian to unbelief. The lay heart was more easily touched ; chap. xr. the female heart most easily of all. Ea(lgyth_, and others who were devoutly given, knew well, we are told, the sins of England. They shuddered as they thought how often the warning voice of the Roman Pontiff, how often the voice of Eadward and of Eadgyth herself, had spoken in vain to the guilty nation.^ The pious Lady perhaps deemed that the uncanonical appointment of Stigand was more likely to bring down the wrath of God than the murder of Gos- patric. At the last Christmas feast, she whose heart was now so deeply stirred at the thought of ecclesiastical corrup- tions, had in that very palace stretched forth her hand to shed blood which no Law had bidden to be shed, blood which, as far at least as she was concerned, was innocent. But there was other work to be done that day besides The sue- CGSSlOll hearkening to foretellings of evil, besides disputing as to the degree of trust to be placed in the words of him who foretold it. The moment was come w^hen the all-important question might be pressed on the mind of the dying King. His friends stood and wept around him; the tears of the ^ The meaning of the Biographer (431-432) is perfectly plain ; "Cog- noscebant enim per sacri ordinis personas Christiani cultlis religionem maximfe violatam, hocque frequentitis deelamasse [declar^sse ?] turn per legates et epistolas suas Eomanum Papam, turn in frequentibus monitis ipsum Regera et Reginam ; sed divitiis et mundana gloriS, irrecuperabiliter quidam diabolo allecti, vitae ade5 neglexerant disciplinam ut non liorrerent jam tunc imminentem incidere in Dei iram," That is, the Pope, the King, and the Lady had before this time rebuked the English, but they were stiff-necked and would not hearken ; hence the divine threatenings. ^thelred (400) clearly means the same ; " Recordantur hsec ipsa summo "saepitis narrata Pontifici, ipsumque persaepe, turn per legates, turn per epistolas, eorum vesaniam increpasse, Regemque ac Eeginam his malis curandis diligentiam adhibuisse, sed profecisse nihil." But his first clause was liable to be misunderstood, and the writer of the French Life did misunderstand it. He mistakes the letters written by the Pope for letters written to the Pope to announce Eadward's vision ; " Mais li prudem li plus sen^ En escrit unt tuz les motz mis, Unt ses dits mut meuz not^ ; E a TApostoille tramis, E curaument unt entendu Par epistre, e par legat." L'ordres des motz, e retenu ; Vv. 3787 et seqq. 14 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Lady as she sat at his feet fell faster and more thickly still. He gave orders for his burial. He checked the grief of his friends ; he bade them rejoice at his coming de- liverance, and he craved the prayers of his people for his soul.^ He spoke of the constant love and devotion which had been ever shown him by the wife whom he had once driven away from his hearth and board. She had ever been to him as a loving and dutiful daughter j^ God would reward her for her good deeds in this world and in the next. At last Harold and Stigand— nor have we any riffht to exclude Robert from their counsels — found means of calling Eadward^s mind to the great subject which then filled the whole heart of England. When all was over, when his body was laid in his new minster, when his soul had gone to its reward, who should fill the place which he had so long filled on earth ? Who, when he was gone, should wear the royal crown of England, the Imperial Eadward diadem of Britain? Eadward, at that last moment, was HaroM as ^^^^ wanting to his last duty. He stretched forth his hand his sue- towards the Earl of the West-Saxons, and spake the words, cesser. " To thee, Harold my brother, I commit my Kingdom.^^ ^ He then went on to declare his last wishes to his chosen Eadward's successor. For Eadward to give Harold instructions in the as wis es. ^^ ^^ government was certainly needless, and the dying man doubtless felt it to be so. But there were a few per- sonal wishes which were near to his heart ; there were a few personal favourites whom he wished to commend to the ^ Vita Eadw. 430. " Funeribus exsequiis attitulat se commendatione et precibus summorum Dei fidelium." As might be expected, he recurs more tlian once to the subject. See pp. 433, 434. ^ See vol. ii. p. 531. ^ I think, comparing the evidently cautious expression of the Biographer with the outspoken words of the Chronicles and Florence, that I am justi- fied in putting this meaning on the words (433),"Porrectii manu [the very gesture is shown in the Tapestry] ad prtedictum nutricium suum fratrem Haroldum, 'Hanc,' inquit, 'cum omni regno tutandam commendo.' " See Appendix B. EADWARD NAMES HAROLD AS HIS SUCCESSOR. 15 favourable care of his successor. First among these was chap. xi. the Lady herself. I need not again enlarge on the mys- ^j^g^X^^ terious relations between Eadward and Eadgyth ; but_, in Harold's care the these his last days at least, she is described as enjoying his Lady perfect confidence and affection. But a sister who certainly abetted Tostig, who perhaps abetted William_, against the brother who was now called to reign/ might be thought likely to meet with less consideration at the hands of Harold than she had, latterly at least, met with at the hands of Eadward. The King commended her who was so soon to be his widow to the friendly care of his successor. Let him show to her, as a Lady and a sister, all faithful worship and service, and never, while she lived, let her lose the honours which he had bestowed upon her.^ He com- and the mended also to Harold his Norman favourites, those whom, favourites. in his simplicity, he spoke of as men who had left their native land for love of him.^ Those who were willing to abide in the land as English subjects under Harold^s allegiance he prayed him to keep and to protect. Those who refused to become the men of the new King he prayed him to dismiss under his safe-conduct to their own, land, taking with them all the goods which they had acquired by his own favour.^ The King had now done the last act of his kingly office. His direc- With this last request to Harold all thought of earthly burial. things passed away from the mind of Eadward. But the man and the saint had still friends to comfort ; he had a - ^ See Appendix I. ^ Vita Eadw. 433. "Hanc . . . tutandam commendo, ut pro Domini et sorore, ut est, fideli serves et honores obsequio, ut, quo advixerit, a me adepto non privetur honore debito." Fideli must agree with ohsequio, not with sorore. ^ lb. " Commendo pariter etiam eos qui nativam terram suam reli- querunt caussa amoris mei, mihique hactenus fideliter sunt obsequuti." * lb. "Ut, suscept^ ab eis, si ita volunt, fidelitate, eos tuearis et retineas, aut tud defensione conductos, cum omnibus quoe sub me adquisierunt, cum salute ad propria transfretari facias." 16 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XL His death not to be concealed, lest he lose the prayers of his people. He com- municates and dies. Thursday, January 5, 1066. soul for which to request their prayers ; he had a body to be committed to the ground with the solemn rites of the Church. He craved that his body might be buried in the minster which he had reared, in a special spot within the hallowed walls which their inmates would point out to those who stood round him.^ One faint thought of earth perhaps came back to his mind, when he bade them not to hide his death from his people. At such a moment it might perhaps be convenient to let men believe that Eadward still lived, till every arrangement could be made for the quiet election and consecration of his successor. But Eadward^s care for his own soul made him tremble at such a prospect. " Let my death/'' he earnestly prayed, ^' be at once announced everywhere, that all the faithful may at once call on the mercy of Almighty God for me a sinner.^^^ Eadgyth meanwhile wept without ceasing. Eadward comforted her with the allegorical words ; ^^ Fear not ; I shall not die, but by God^s grace, I shall soon arise to better health.''''^ But the last moment was clearly drawing near ; the last comfort of the Church had to be given. The dying saint received the Body of his Lord, seemingly at the hands of Stigand ; the irregularity of his position as Primate was perhaps not held to affect acts done by him as a simple priest.^ Strengthened by this spiritual ^ Vita Eadw. 434. "Fossa sepulcri mei in monasterio paretur, in eo loco quo vobis assignabitur." ^ lb. " Mortem meam quseso ne celetis [the plural is used in these general directions, while the political requests are addressed in the singular to Harold], sed celeritis circumquaque annuncietis, ut quique fideles pro me peccatore deprecentur clementiam Dei Omnipotentis." Compare the excitement caused by the suspicion that the death of Edward the Sixth was concealed. Froude, Hist. Eng. v. 514. ' lb. " Ne tinieas ; non nioriar modo, sed bene convalescam propitiante Deo." "• lb. " Sumpto a ccelesti mens^ vitee viatico." There is no mention whether the Communion was in one kind only. Communion in both kinds was certainly usual at this time (see Will. Pict. 113. 13O. but it is not likely in the case of a dying man. DEATH OF EADWARD. 17 food^ Eadward's soul gently passed away^ and the last King chap. xi. of the House of Cerdic was no more. His body lay as in sleep ; his cheeks like the rose_, his beard like the lily, his white hands falling peacefully by his side ; men saw written on the face of the departed saint that he had gone to his Creator.^ • The King was dead. The last day of his kingship had Eadward'a been the worthiest. After all the errors and follies of his j^ig j^^. ' reiffn, Eadward died, not only as a saint, but as an Eno-lish- F'ovement ° ' ^ ^ -^ Y ^ since his man and a patriot. For the last thirteen years of his life earlier Harold had been his guide and guardian ; for the last nine years he had been the expectant successor of the Crown. And now the day had come and the word was spoken. Those years of faithful guardianship had not been without their fruit ; Eadward, with Harold and Stigand at his side, had become another man from Eadward who had once listened to every lie which rose to the lips of Robert of Jumieges.2 The old wayward spirit had again burst forth when revolt overthrew his last favourite;^ but his last favourite was at least an Englishman and a son of God- wine. And the latest act of all had made up for all that Englisli had gone before. Eadward showed on his death-bed that Eadward's he had at last learned that the Norman could never bear ^^^^ l^' quests. sway in England with the good- will of the English people. The dream of the Norman Duke as the heir of the English Crown had passed away. The dream of England portioned out among Norman Earls, Prelates, and Knights had passed away with it. England was to have an English King, the noblest man of the English people. No stranger ^ Vita Eadvv. 434. "Erat tunc videre in defuncto corpore gloriam migrantis ad Deum animse, quuin scilicet caro faciei ut rosa ruberet, subjecta barba ut lilium canderet, manus suo ordine direct^e albe- scerent, totumque corpus non morti sed fausto sopori traditum signa- rent." ^ See vol. ii. p. 70. ^ ggg y^i. ii. p. 382. VOL. III. C 18 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. was to be endured in the land_, but such as would plight their homage to the King of England^s choice. For others, however dear to him, all that Eadward now craved was that they might depart, unhurt and unplundered, from the land. Visions of danger may have flitted across his mind, and in the delirium of sickness, in the mere excitement of pious fear, they may have shaped themselves into vague foreshadowings of the wrath to come. But what the last dying wishes of Eadward were we know beyond a doubt. His last wishes, his last hopes, were the same as the wishes and the hopes of every faithful Englishman. His last earthly desire was that Harold should wear his Crown, that Harold should reign over a land freed from the presence of every man whose presence he might find inconsistent with the welfare of England and her King. Eaclward'a And he has had his reward. Far more precious than the paneo-yric. vulgar praiscs of Norman legend-makers, far more precious even than the wrought up panegyric of the courtly chaplain of his widow, is the song in Eadward^s honour preserved in our national Chronicles from the hands of a gleeman of his own time and of his own people.^ The English poet sang of Eadward^s early troubles, how he had to seek a foreign land, when Cnut overcame the race of ^thelred, and when Danes wielded the dear realm of England for eight and twenty winters.^ He sang of Eadward^s personal virtues ; how he was holy, clean, and mild, how the baleless King was ever blithe of mood.^ He sang of the glories of his reign ; how he guarded his land and people ; how renowned ^ Chronn. Ab. Wig. 1065. ^ lb. " J3ah he langa se'r, And Deona weoldon Landes bereafod, Deore rice Wunoda wreclastum Englalaudes Wide geond eorSan, xxviii. Seo^J^an Knut ofercom Wintra gerimes Cynn ^'Selredes, Weolan brytnodon." ^ lb. " Waes a bli'Se mod, Bealeleas King." See vol. ii. p. 531. E AD ward's last WISHES. 19 warriors stood around his throne ; how the son of u^Etheh'ed chap. xi. ruled over Angles and Saxons, how Welsh and Scots and Britons all obeyed the mighty sway of the noble Eadward.^ But before his song ceases,, the minstrel has yet to tell of one deed far above all, of one last act which made the name of Eadward truly glorious. Bitter death snatched the noble King from earth; angels bore his truthful soul to heaven. But a truer note of patriotic feeling rings forth The poet in the words which tell us how the wise King made fast the nomi- his realm to Harold the noble Earl^ in the words which^ Harokl^^ bursting from the poet''s heart, tell us how well the noble Earl deserved the greatest of earthly gifts. He in all time by words and deeds had truly obeyed his lord, and had left nought undone which was needful for the ruler of his people.^ § 2. The Election and Coronation of Harold. Jamiary ^~6j 1066. The throne of England was now vacant^ vacant under Vacancy of circumstances such as England had never seen before. The late King^s dying orders were obeyed, and^ as soon as Eadward^s breath was out of his body, the Witan of Eng- land knew that their King was dead. But by the Law of England in the eleventh century, the announcement that the King was dead could not be answered by a cry for the long life of the King who still was living.^ The * Chronn. Ab. Wig, 1066. "Weold wel ge'Sungsen Swa ymbclyppa]) Walum and Scottum, Cealda brymmas, And Bryttum eac, paet eall Eadwardae Byre ^^elredes. jEpelum Kinge Englum and Ssexum Hyrdan holdelice Oret maegcum. Hagestalde menn." The Welsh, who are thus coupled with Scots, and distinguished from the Britons, can mean only the Welsh of Strathclyde, ^ See Appendix B, and vol. ii. p. 537. ^ ''Le Eoi est mort; vive le Roi" — the exact opposite to old Teutonic feelings. C :i 20 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Witan_, not yet departed from their Christmas gathering*, heard that the throne was vacant, and they knew that it was for them alone to fill it. And, with the news that they had no longer a King, came the news that the last wish of the King who was gone had pointed out to them whom he wished to fill his kingly seat after him. All scruple was taken from every mind when men knew that the son of ^thelred, the heir of Cerdic, had, as his last act, named as his successor the son of Godwine, the grand- Meeting of son of Wulfnoth. It was no time for delay. Men came January 5, together as speedily upon the death of Eadward as they io66. j^^^ come together to choose Eadward himself upon the death of Harthacnut. The King lay dead in his palace, while Earls and Prelates, Thegns and citizens, came to- gether to choose the King who should reign in his stead. Doubtful The choice was speedy and unanimous. Later writers speak candidature n • t • 'jr-nj r ' x. ' -j of William ^* voices being raised tor Eadgar, even oi voices being raised and foj. William.^ And so it may have been. Here and there Eadgar. ... sentimental feelings may have caused this or that voice to utter the name of the royal boy, even in preference to the noblest of a merely subject house. And, in our land of free debate, some daring Norman may even have ventured to breathe the thought that the King^s kinsman, who had made Normandy so great and flourishing, might make England no less great and flourishing also. But words No sign like these told not on the spirit of the Assembly. Nor do jealousies. ^^ ^^^^ ^^ ^^7 expression of those local jealousies which had divided England on more than one earlier vacancy. We hear nothing of any rivalry of the House of Leofric against the House of Godwine ; we hear nothing of any murmurs of the fierce Danes of the North against the * Hen. Hunt. M.H.B. 761 D. ''Quidani Anglorum Eadgar Atheling promovere volebant in Regem." Will. Malms, iii. 238. "Anglia dubio favore nutabat, cui se rectori committeret incerta, an Haroldo an Willelmo an Edgaro . . . Angli diversis votis ferebantur, quamvis palam cuncti bona Haroldo imj>recarentm'." This is an important admission. HAROLD CHOSEN BY THE WITAN. 21 inauguration of a new West-Saxon dynasty. If the sons chap. xi. of ^Ifgar dreamed^ as they doubtless did, of a divided Kingdom — of the Imperial Crown for one of themselves they hardly could have dreamed — their hopes were doomed to disappointment. Such thoughts, as we shall soon see, still lived in men^s minds, but in that great Gemot of London^ they found no open spokesman. It was not only London, ever foremost in every patriotic cause ; it was not only Wessex, proud of her illustrious son ; it was not only East-Anglia, cherishing the recollections of his earliest rule ; it was not only Hereford, rejoicing in her recovered being, safe alike against British foes and Norman governors ; it was the Witan, not of this or that shire or ancient Kingdom, but of the whole realm of England, who chose Harold Harold the son of Godwine to fill the vacant throne.^ ^^ Eng- His reign had long been looked for, and now the dying ^^"*^' voice of Eadward had marked him out as the worthiest object of their choice. The wise ruler, the unconquered warrior, the bountiful founder, — the shield of the Kingdom, the shelter of the oppressed, the judge of the fatherless and the widow ^ — the Earl of the West- Saxons, the con- queror of GruiFydd, the pacificator of Northumberland, the founder of Waltham — stood forth before them as the foremost man of England. He, and he alone, stood forth above other men, sprung from no line of Kings, but the son of a father greater than Kings, the man who in long years of rule had shown that there was none like him worthy to fill the throne of the heroes of old time, worthy, as none of royal race were worthy, to wield the sword of iEthelstan and sit upon the judgement-seat of ^Elfred. The assembled people of England, in the exercise of their ancient and ^ Would the course of the election have been in any way different^ if the Gemdt had been held in Oxford ? ^ Fl. Wig. 1066. "A totius Anglise primatibus ad regale culmen electus." See Appendix C. ^ See the Waltham writer's character of Harold, vol. ii. p. 540. 22 THE ELECTION OP HAROLD. CHAP. XI. undoubted right, chose with one voice Harold the son of Godwine to be King of the English and Lord of the Isle of Britain. On no day in their annals did the English people win for themselves a higher or a purer fame. The Crown The choicc of the Assembly had now to be announced to offered to the Kiug-elect. We know not whether that choice was ^^° ■ made in his presence. Possibly he may have deemed that his most fitting place was still with his departed brother- in-law and his widowed sister. But^ in any case, two members of the Assembly were sent, in the name of all, to offer the Crown of England, as the gift of the people of England, to the man whom they had chosen as their King. Who discharged that office we know not. None but men of the highest rank would be sent on such an errand. In the pictured record of that day's acts they appear, not as Prelates but as lay chieftains. One bears the official axe;^ the other bears the Crown itself, and points towards the chamber of the dead, whence the Crown had doubtless been brought for the purpose of this symbolic offering.2 Who then were the men whom England thus ^ See vol. ii. p. 334, "^ Tapestry, pi. 7. Bruce, p. 80. " Hie dederunt Haroldo Coronam Regis." It is worth remark that the crown which is here represented as offered to Harold is of a different and simpler form from that with which Harold is represented as being crowned the next day. This last is the same as that which Eadward is always drawn as wearing, even when supported in the arms of Robert on his death-bed. This last representation is of course merely symbolical ; it is simply as much as to say, *' This is the King." This latter crown is doubtless the crown used at the actual coronation, and also on the great days when the King " wore his Crown " publicly. On its form cf. vol. ii. p. 334. But this simpler crown, borne, it would seem, immediately from the chamber of the dead King, suggests that such a crown was commonly kept at hand near the King's person. Compare the well-known story of Henry the Fifth trying on the crown which was kept by his father's bed-side (Monstrelet, i. 163 &), a story which may pass as autho- rity for the custom, whether true or not as to the fact. This crown, as easier of access, would be the one symbolically offered to the King- elect, while the crown of greater ceremony would of course be used in the grfiat rite of the morrow. THE CROWN OFFERED TO HAROLD. 23 trusted to speak such weighty words in her name ? Were chap. xi. they the two Northern Earls_, perhaps already the brothers- in-law of the elected King^ stifling, as they best mighty their local and family jealousies, their hopes of a divided kingdom ? Or were they rather the two Earls of Eastern England, sons worthy of Godwine, brothers worthy of Harold, who were sent to bear the gift of England to the chief of their own house ? That day's vote had placed that house above the royalties of Gaul and Denmark ; it had placed the lino of Godwine on a height lower by one step only than the line whose youthful chief now sat on the throne of Augustus. It was for Gyrth and Leofwine, rather than for any other two men in England, to act on that day as the spokesmen of their country, Harold stood. Position of axe in hand, to receive them. The day for which he had looked so long had at last come. The path from which so many obstacles had been so strangely cleared away had at last brought him close to the great object of his life. He had now, not in figure, but in very truth, only to stretch forth his hand, and to grasp the Crown of England, the free gift of the people of England. No surprise could have filled his mind ; for years he had been marked out, practically if not hj a formal vote, as the man to whom that gorgeous gift must one day come. And yet that moment of realized dreams must have been a moment of anxiety, and even of fear. For him, no son of a kingly father, no scion of legendary heroes and of Gods of the elder faith, to see with his own eyes the diadem of Ecgberht and Cerdic ready for his grasp, was of itself a strange and wondrous feeling, such as few men but him in the world^s history can have felt. He was not like others before and since, who by fraud or violence have risen to royalty or more than royalty. Harold was not a Dionysios, a Caesar, a Cromwell, or a Buonaparte, whose throne was reared upon the ruins of the freedom of his country. He was not an Eastern Basileus, climbing to 24 THE ELECTION OP HAROLD. CHAP. XI. the seat from which a fortunate battle or a successful con- spiracy had hurled a murdered or blinded predecessor. He was not a Pippin, whose elevation, however expedient and rightful, could be brought about only by the displacement of a lawful, though an incompetent. King. He was not even a Rudolf, whose election, free and honourable as it was, came when the royal office had long been discredited in men's eyes, and when traditional reverence no longer at- tached to any one ancient royal house. Harold was freely offered the Crown of England in all its glory and greatness, a Crown which had never before been offered to any but men of royal birth,^ which had never before been freely offered to any but men of the one Imperial House of Cerdic. Difficulties He may well have paused as he looked at the glittering situation, g'iftj through the mere greatness and strangeness of the position in which he stood. And other thoughts may well have pressed upon his mind, before he spoke the word which should change the Earl into a King. Harold knew better than any man the dangers which threatened himself Double and which threatened England. He knew what she had to frmn^^ fear from the vengeance of her own banished son, a ven- Tostig and o-eance which would be kindled into a sevenfold flame if William. ^ Harold were King in a land where Tostig might not hold even an Earldom. He knew also, as no man knew, how much more she had to fear from the claims of the mighty and Effects of wily Duke beyond the sea. And heavy on his soul may William, ^till have pressed the memory of that fatal day when he had become the sworn man of that dangerous rival .^ If he had promised more than simple homage, casuistry and more than casuistry, the instinctive feeling of every honest man, ^ The Danish Kings, though not of royal English blood, were of royal blood in their own land. With the exception of them, the Crown of Wessex.and of England as the developement and continuation of Wessex, had never gone out of the West-Saxon royal house. I cannot answer for all the momentary Kings in Northumberland or in the last days of Mercia. * See below, Chapter xii. § 4, and Appendix R. HAROLD ACCEPTS THE CROWN. 25 would declare that an extorted promise, unlawful and im- chap. xi. possible to fulfil^ was perhaps a crime in him who had plighted it, but could be no crime in him who should obey a higher law by breaking it. But since that day, the heart of Harold could never have beaten so high, his step could never have been so light and joyous, as in the days when his faith was wholly free, when even his enemies could not impeach his truthfulness. And now the full weight of that day^s act must have stared him in the face. Let him accept the Crown now offered him by England, and Normandy would at once declare him a perjurer and a traitor. No Harold's wonder then if, as the picture sets him before us, he looked expressed^^ at the Crown at once wistfully and anxiously, and half ^ ^^^ drew back the hand which was stretched forth to grasp the glittering gift. And yet the risk had to be run. A path of danger opened before him, and yet duty no less than ambition bade him to enter upon the thorny road. If he Greater declined the Crown, to whom should England offer it ? he^deTlined Would the risk be less if the boy Eadgar could win the ^''^'' ^"^^wn. votes of the Witan, and if to the other dangers of England were to be added all the dangers which beset the land whose King is a child ?^ What if the young ^theling failed, as he doubtless would fail, to stand his ground at such a moment ? Could the land hope to be united in any single Danger of choice ? Would Mercia and Northumberland submit to the of the rule of some West- Saxon boasting neither the royal blood of ■^^"^^^"^• Eadgar nor the personal glory of Harold ? Would Wessex and East-Anglia, would mighty and growing London, submit to Eadwine or Morkere or to the youthful son of Siward ? The dangers of accepting the Crown were great, but the dangers of refusing it were greater. Whoever reigned, Tostig and William would still try their chance, and, if it were not Harold who reigned^ they would try their chance with far greater hope of success. The accession * See vol. ii. p. 190. 26 THE ELECTION OP HAROLD. CHAP. XI. of Harold would indeed put fresh weapons into the hand of William^ but it was not likely that the Duke would wholly cast aside his claims and his projects,, simply because he would have some other King, and not Harold, to strive against. The fear indeed was that, if Harold shrank from the burthen, William would find no one single King to resist him. He would win an easy victory over a divided land, a land split asunder as it had been in the days of Hartha- cnut and the earlier Harold, a land, it might be, already torn in pieces by civil war. Under Harold alone could there be the faintest hope that England would offer an united front to either of the invaders who were sure to attack her. The danger then had to be faced. The call of patriotism distinctly bade Harold not to shrink at the last moment from the post to which he had so long looked forward, and which had at last become his own. The first man in Eng- land, first in every gift of war and peace, first in the love of his countrymen, first in renown in other lands, was bound to be first alike in honour and in danger. The gift now lay before him. Ambition bade him seize it. Duty in no way The Crown held back his hand. The offered gift was accepted. The by^Harold. ^^^ ^^ ^^^^ great Epiphany, the day on which King Eadward was alive and dead,^ saw the Crown pass away for ever from the male line of Cerdic, and the next day saw it solemnly placed upon the brow of Harold. Tlie evening of Eadward^s death must have been spent in preparation for the two great ceremonies of the morrow. On the morning of that short winter's day, the Earl of the West-Saxons had kept his watch by the dying bed of his King and brother. Before its last hour had passed, he had become, not yet indeed a crowned and anointed King, but one called to kingship by the unanimous voice of his coimtry, a King- * " Die qua Edwardus Rex vivus fuit et mortuus " is a common form in Domesday. So in Cod. Dipl. iv. 233 ; "To Mm timan Se Eadward cing was cucu and dejid." THE TWO RITES OF THE EPIPHANY. 27 elect of the English^ who on the morrow might claim the chap. xi. sceptre and the diadem as his own. The morning of the Epiphany dawned. It was the Double Feast of the Kings, a fitting day for an august rite within of Friday, the walls of that minster which was reared to be specially "^^"^^^^ ^' the home of Kings alike in life and in death. On that the burial day began that long series of national ceremonies which ^nd the has gone on uninterruptedly to our own time, and which ^ p^^"^,^\^ has made the Abbey of Saint Peter the hearth and Pry- taneion of the English nation. The octave of the conse- cration-day had barely passed, and there was already a Necessity King to be buried and a King to be crowned. Earl gpeedy Harold was King-elect by the choice of the Witan of all coronation, England ; but he was not ^' full King" till he and his people had exchanged their mutual promises, till he had been arrayed with the outward badges of his kingly office, till the blessing of the Church and the unction of her highest minister had made the chosen of the people also the Anointed of the Lord. Those were not days when that crowning rite could be delayed for one needless mo- ment. England could not be safely left for a single day without a King. The twofold right of the new Sovereign, as King alike by the election of the people and by the consecration of the Church, must be at once placed beyond all reach of doubt or cavil. The Christmas feast was not yet over, but it was the last day of the holy season ; the Witan were still assembled; to have waited for another feast of the Church, for another gathering of the nation, would have been simple madness. ^ The day of the coro- nation of Harold must therefore follow at once on the day of his election. And the coronation of Harold involved the and there- previous burial of Eadward. England could not see two speedy Kings of the English above ground at the same moment. ^^'^ * ^ This is well put by Dr. Bruce, p. 79. 28 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. occasion. CHAP. XI. Before then the Crown could be set on the brow of the King-elect, the hallowed soil of Saint Peter^s must close over the King who was no more. The day of the burial of Eadward must therefore follow at once on the day of his death. And never, even in the long history of that venerable Abbey, has there been such another day. Other Greatness Kings have been buried and crowned within its walls ; but there has been no day like that, which beheld the last of one kingly line borne to his grave in the holy house of his own building, and which beheld the first — could men deem that he would be also the last ? — of a newly-chosen race raised to the vacant throne alike by the bequest of his predecessor and by the will of his people. Of all the gorgeous rites celebrated by Kings and Prelates beneath the vaults of the West Minster, the twofold rite of that great Epiphany, which haste and urgency may well have rendered the least gorgeous of them all, is that around which the national memory of Englishmen may well centre most fondly. The first royal burial, the first royal consecration, within the newly -hallowed temple, possess an historic interest and an historic import beyond all those which have followed them. The body of Eadward had been prepared for burial almost as soon as his soul had passed away. Decked in royal robes, the crown on his head, the pilgrim's ring, so legend said, upon his hand, the saint lay ready for his last home. Stigand, who had stood by him in his last moments, seems to have stayed to help in paying this last tribute to his departed master. ^ But the Primate, patriot in the eyes of The Burial of Ead- ward. * The Tapestry (pi. 7) significantly puts together, in one compartment, one over the other, the nomination of Harold by Eadward (•' Hie Eadwardus Rex in lecto alloquit fideles ") and the preparation of Eadward's body for burial ("Hie defunctus est"). Now the churchman in attendance on the death-bed must surely be the same as the churchman who is helping at the preparation for burial. Now the former can only be Stigand, and the latter is still more distinctly marked with the archiepiscopal pallium, the unluckly gift of Benedict. THE BURIAL OF EADWARD. 29 Eng-lishmen, schismatic in the eyes of Rome, was not to chap. xi. minister in either of the ceremonies of the morrow. As a Position of . Stigand. Prelate of doubtful rights he was deemed unfit to bear the chief part in the consecration of Harold. As a simple priestj he might perhaps have been allowed to officiate at the funeral rites of Eadward. But it may well be that the newly- won privileges of the house of Saint Peter gave to the head of that house the ministration of all rites within its walls which did not need the special powers of a conse- crated Bishop to give them sacramental efficacy. And Ead- ward doubtless sought^ above all things, the prayers which the monks of the house which he himself had reared would put up to Heaven for the soul of their founder. At all Stigand did events, the priest who holds the first place in Eadward^s ^t the funeral procession is not set before us in our pictured record ^ "i^^*"^!- as adorned with any badge of pontifical rank.^ We may perhaps be allowed to guess that the chief ministry in the funeral rites of Eadward was assigned to his friend and bedesman, Abbot Eadwine. Early on the winter^s morning,^ perhaps while the minster still needed torchlight within the deep gloom of its massive walls and narrow windows, the King was carried to his grave. The body of Eadward, Funeral of his form shrouded from sight, was borne on the shoulders of eight of his subjects, laymen all, and doubtless men of high degree. There was no need, as in the case of some later Kings, to assure his people, by the sight of his un- covered body, that he had not come unfairly by his end. Boys ringing bells walked on either side of the bier ; behind them followed a crowd of clergy, surrounding the two chief ministers of the funeral ceremony, who walked bearing their * Bayeux Tapestry, pi. 7. Bruce, p. 74. ^ In the coronation-offices of different ages, mention is often made of the weariness of the sovereign, caused, according to Mr. Maskell, by his obli- gation to receive the Communion fasting. In this case therefore, when the burial had to take place before the coronation, it would be specially necessary to begin the ceremony early in the day. 30 THE ELECTION OF HAEOLD. CHAP. XI. office-books in their hands. In this guise the procession moved from the palace to the western door of the newly - hallowed minster. They swept along the nave^ between the long rows of tall and massive pillars still fresh from the axe and hammer of the craftsman. They passed beneath the mighty arches, which, in all the strength and solidity of those early days of art, bore up the great central tower like a vast canopy over the choir below. They bore their burthen to the spot which Eadward had long before chosen as his place of burial, and there, before the altar of the saint whom he so deeply reverenced, the patron alike of Westminster and of Rome,^ the body of the last King of General the olden stock received its last kingly honours. We can Eadward.^ well believe that, not only the poor whom he had relieved, the churchmen whom he had enriched, and the strangers on whom he had lavished the wealth of England, but that Englishmen of all ranks might well weep in awe and in sorrow over the grave of the last son of Cerdic and Woden. At such a moment, reversing the poet^s rule, the good that men have done lives after them and the evil is interred with their bones. There, by his grave in his own church, men^s thoughts would dwell on the virtues rather than on Causes of the weaknesses of the King who was taken from them. His anxiety. faults as a King were great; but men would then think rather of all that was worthy in him as a man, and they might well deem that his last kingly act had covered a multitude of errors. In the crowd which filled the church, there could have been few whom Eadward had personally wronged ; there must have been many whom he had per- sonally benefitted. And, more than this, men must have felt that the two great rites of that day placed a great gulf * Vita Eadw. 434. " Coram altare beati Petri Apostoli conditur corpus." The Chronicles simply mention the burial in the minster; "He for'Sferde on Twelftan sefen, and hyne man bebyrigde on Tvvelftan daeig on ])am ylcan mynstre" (Ab. Wig. 1065)— "innan ]wre niwa halgodre circean on West- mynstre" (Petrib. 1066). POPULAR CANONIZATION OF EADWARD. 31 between them and a long and honoured past^ while a future chap. xi. rose before them_, bright indeed with glorious hopes, but around which two dark clouds were gathering in opposite quarters of the heaven. No wonder then that by the grave of Eadward men wept and trembled.^ Psalms were sung, masses were said, alms were scattered abroad with a bounteous hand, needless offerings it might seem for a soul which men deemed that angels had already borne to the beatific vision.'^ For three hundred days, days which stretch beyond the reign of Harold, the masses, the hymns, the alms, continued to be daily offered.'^ And wonders Miracles soon were wrought at the tomb of the royal saint. The ^i^g ^Jj^^ blind received their sight, the lame walked, the sick were healed, the sorrowing received comfort. "* So thought men of his own day, men who had seen him in the flesh, and who have not shrunk from handing down to us even the less worthy actions of his life. If we deem such a belief and such a worship to be, not only superstitious in itself, but to have been thrown away on an unworthy object, we must remember with how fond a memory men must, ere a year had passed, have looked back to the happy days of the baleless King. We must remember how easily men would forget that the calm of those happy days was due, far less to the crowned monk upon the throne, than to the man of the stout heart and the strong arm who stood beside him. And let us remember too that the canonizing voice of ^ The general sorrow lias quite witness enough in the Life, 434, 435. . ^thelred (402) uses stronger expressions, but which still perhaps do not go beyond the facts of the case; "Dici non potest quantus mox omnes timor invaserit, occupaverit moeror, quomodo totam quoque insulam tenebrosus quidam horror impleverit." 2 See the Poem in the Chronicles, above, p. 18. ^ Vita Eadw. 434. ''Totum quoque a primo die tricesimum celebratione missarum, decantatione prosequuntur psalmorum, expensis pro redemptione ipsius animse multis auri libris in sublevatione diversi ordinis pauperum." * lb. 435. ''Ibi illuminantur caeci, in gressum solidantur claudi, infirmi curantur, moerentes consolatione Dei reparantur." 32 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Other causes of popular canoniza- tion. Posthu- mous history of Eadward. England was not always raised only to commemorate mere monastic virtues like those of Eadward. Foreign Kings and foreign Pontiffs might forbid, but a day came when England looked with no less devout reverence on the true heroes and martyrs of our land. If miracles adorned the tomb of Eadward at Westminster,, no less mighty works were soon deemed to be wrought before Waltheof s tomb in the chapter-house of Crowland, and two ages later, the sick were again healed and the blind again saw, before the tomb where English hearts still revered the relics which were all that the foeman^s sword had left of the mangled form of the martyr of Evesham, i The funeral rites were over ; but the history of Eadward^ as the history of a saint, is one which reaches beyond the grave. A King at whose tomb wonders were daily wrought, a King whom two hostile races could unite to look upon with reverence, gradually filled a larger and a larger space in men^s minds. Such a King, already canonized by the popular voice, a King who had done more than any King before him to bring the English Church into close con- nexion with the Roman See, could not fail, ere long, to obtain, by Papal authority, a formal admission into the register of the saints. But the steps by which he won his saint^s rank were gradual. Six-and-thirty years after ^ At this point we lose the contemporary Life of Eadward. He speaks of no event later than the funeral, except in an allusion to the Battle of Stamfordbridge (426) ; " Quis canet sequoreo vastum fervore tumentem Humbram congressum Reglbus cequivocis ? " He declines entering on the subject for fear of wounding the feelings of Eadgyth. Except from this one place, and from the dying recommendation of Eadward, which last he makes as dark as possible (see Appendix B), we should never learn from him that Harold ever reigned at all. William is never mentioned or alluded to. It is clear that, writing as he did for Eadgyth, under William, he could not write as he would, and, courtier as he was, he was not willing to write in the way that might have been most acceptable. EXAMINATION OF EADWARD's BODY. 33 Eadward^s death,, a Bishop and an Abbot of Norman birth, chap. xi. who had most likely never seen him in the flesh, were the ^x^^^-^^ •^ nation oi first whom pious curiosity led to disturb the rest of the his body by departed. It was already whispered that the body of Gilbert. Eadwardj the instrument of so many miracles^ was itself "°^' the subject of miracle. The holy King, men said, had never seen corruption. Abbot Gilbert, one of the great Norman line of Crispin, whom Lanfranc had put in charge of the house of Westminster/ deemed it his duty to see whether the tale that so often met his ears were true. In company with Bishop Gundulf of Bochester, the Prelate to whose skill we owe the White Tower of London and the lowlier keep of Mailing, and with other noble and pious persons, he opened the grave of Eadward. A sweet savour filled the minster; they unfolded the garments in which Eadward had been wrapped under the eyes of Stigand ; the body lay as in sleep ; the powers of nature had failed to do their work ; the skin was still white and rosy ; the limbs were still flexible; they might deem that he might again arisa from his trance and again denounce the sins of Eng- land. The Bishop would fain have carried off one hair of his snowy beard to keep as a relic more precious than all the treasures of the earth.^ But not a hair could be pulled away from the face of the sleeping saint. The Abbot, with a reverence to which those ages were commonly strangers, checked the attempt; he restored the vestments and the body to their place, and bade that the remains of the man of God should rest in peace. " Thirty-eight years later a vain attempt was made by Attempt of r\ ^ Tk ' • • o Osbert to Osbert, Prior of Westminster, the special trumpeter of procure ^ ' ' Gillebertus cognomento Crispyn," says ^thelred (408), who calls this examination "prima translatio." His appointment by Lanfranc is mentioned in the Tract on the Crispin Family, Lanfranc, ed. Giles, i. 343. ^ ^thel. U.S. "Non tamen conatum hunc memn preesumptioni deputes sed devotioni, quum relliquiarum ejus vel modicam portionem, si mihi copia praestaretur, Croesi opibus praetulissem." VOL. III. D 34 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Eadward's renown/ to obtain formal canonization for him Eadward's £ Innocent the Second. But a day came when the canoniza- -^ tion. House of William had passed away like the House of Cerdic_, a day when men had taught themselves to hail a stranger from Anjou as the corner-stone which united Nor- Eadward man and English royalty. Then^ at last^ the influence of by^AleT- ^ King who reigned from the Orkneys to the Pyrenees was ander the ^]^|g ^^ procurc from Romc the decree which placed the pre- nyl, decessor whom all his subjects agreed to reverence among authorized objects of religious honour. ^ The green tree had now returned to the trunk ; it had brought forth its queenly leaves and its kingly fruit, and the day was now come to do special homage to the seer who had foretold that the good time would at last come back again. As one Pope Alexander had given the blessing of Rome to the enter- prise of the Norman invader, his next successor of the same name might seem in some sort to undo the wrong by making the last King of the old royal stock of England First Trans- an object of worship to the Church Universal. In the Eadward. presence of the Angevin King, in whom men now saw the October 13, j^g-^ q£ Eadward, in the presence of the Norman Primate whom England learned to love as her champion and martyr, the body of Eadward was translated from his royal tomb to the shrine which was the fitting resting-place of the * See Hardy's Catalogue of English History, vol. i. part 2. p. 64-2. Several letters on the subject will be found among the letter? of Osbert published (along with those of Herbert Lozinga) by Colonel Anstruther (Brussels 1846), numbered 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 in the series. Osbert writes on behalf of the canonization to the Pope's Legate, Alberic Bishop of Ostia, and to Henry, Bishop of Winchester, whose somewhat remote kindred to the saint is enlarged on. Bishop Henr}', the Chapter (Con- ventus) of Saint Paul's, and lastly King Stephen, write letters which Osbert carries to the Pope. Lastly comes Innocent's answer to the Convent of Westminster, asking for further proof of Eadward's miracles, &c. There is not!iing of special interest in the whole series. 2 See the opening of ^tholred's Life of Eadward (370. Cf. Geneal. I^^og- 350); lie calls Henry " lapidem angularein Anglici generis et NoiTOannici." eadward's canonization and first translation. 36 relics of a saint in glory. Things were not now as they chap. xi. were in the days of Abbot Gilbert. Then the body, entitled only to the reverence due to the remains of a departed Christian, was allowed to return unhurt and un- plundered to the grave. But now that Eadward claimed the worship due to a canonized saint, whatever had touched the holy corpse became endowed with sanctity and mira- culous power. The ring, the subject of so many legends, was drawn from his finger and was preserved as a .wonder- working relic. The royal robes in which the body had been enfolded were borne away from the tomb and became vestments for the holiest worship of the sanctuary.^ And the anniversary of that day still preserves the memory of Eadward in the Kalendar of the English Church. It was not without a certain fitness that the Feast of the Translation of Saint Eadward should be kept, not on the eve of the Epiphany, but on the eve of the day of Saint Calixtus. It is well that two successive days should remind us of the memory of Eadward and of the memory of him who fell on the morrow of his festival. Years rolled on, and the spot to which Eadward had Second been moved on his first translation was now deemed un- tion of worthy of a Saint who was already looked upon as the q ^ b r i\ patron of England. A King now sat on the throne of Ead- 1269. ward, who was in many points a reproduction of Eadward himself. The same fervent zeal for God, the same neglect of duty towards man, the same vehemence in speech and weakness in action, the same love for men of foreign lands, the same spiritual bondage to a foreign yoke, the same deep and lavish devotion to the holy house of Saint Peter, appeared in Henry the Third which had already appeared in the predecessor whom he reverenced and resembled. The King who, like Eadward, aroused the feelings of the nation ^ See Dart, WestmonasteriXim, p. 53. He quotes from a seemingly unpublished manuscript. D 2 36 THE ELECTION OF HAEOLD. CHAP. XI. by his wasteful preference for strangers of every landj chose as the special objects of his religious devotion two royal saints of English birth. Before all other saints, King Henry^s worship was paid to the East-Anglian Eadmund and the West- Saxon Eadward. By his act those kingly names again found their way into the royal house, and the name of the saint himself became the most glorious in the later history of England.^ In honour of Rebuilding Eadward the work of Eadward was destroyed.^ The West church which he himself had reared was now deemed un- Mmster. worthy to be the dwelling-place of so great a saint.^ The ^' massive arches, broad and round/^ '^ of the church which so long was the model for all England/ now gave way to ^ Edward the First was baptized on the day of the Translation of his earlier namesake the "Martyr." See Matt. Paris, 488. But it is dis- tinctly said that his name was given him in honour of the Confessor. Flores Hist. 1239; "Est Eadwardus vocitatus. Qui denomination em ac- cepit a glorioso Rege et Confessore Eadwardo, cujus corpus gloriosum in basilic^ S. Petri Westmonasterii i^equiescit." So N. Trivet, in anno (p. 225 ed. Hog); "In honorem gloriosissimi Confessoris et Regis Edwardi Edwardum vocavit." But Matthew Paris (u.s.) seems, oddly enough, to make him be called Edward after the contemporary Archbishop Saint 'Edmund; "Archiepiscopus JEdmundus Cantuariensis ipsum confir- mavit, et, Rege sic volente, aptatum est ei nomen, scilicet -^dwardus." The important point is the re- appearance, from any cause, of the royal English name. ^ Matt. Paris, 661. "Eodem anno [1245] .Dominus Rex, devotione quam habuit adversus sanctum Edwardum submonente, ecclesiam Sancti Petri Westmonasteriensem jussit ampliari, Et, dirutis antiquis cum turri muris partis orientalis, prsecepit novos, videlicet decentiores . . . construi." ^ T. Wikes, 1269 (Gale, ii. 89). "Ecclesiam .... Rex opere sump- tuosissimo fabricatam, amotd prorsus veteri [this is not true, see M. Paris, U.S.] qwv, rmllius omnino valoris exstiterat, de propriis fisci regalis exitibus [Simon and the Parliament had something to say on that head], a fundamentis construxit, quai quidem sumptibus pariter et decore sic caeteris per orbem ecclesiis praeponi decernitur, ut videatur coraparem non habere." * Marmion, ii, 10. ' Matt. Paris, 2. "Ecclesia, quam . . post multi ecclesias construentes, exemplum adepti, opus illud expensis semulabantur sumptuosis." See vol. ii. p. 508 for the passage of William of Malmesbury on which this is founded. eadward's second translation. 37 those slender pillars and soaring arches which, alone chap. xi. among English minsters, go some way to reproduce the boundless height of Amiens and of Beauvais. There, alone among English minsters of its own date,^ did the tall apse and its surrounding chapels crown the eastern end of what was now the church of Saint Eadward. But that apse was not reared, as at Amiens and at Le Mans, at Pershore and ^t Tewkesbury, to form the most glorious of canopies for the altar of the Most High. Not in any subordinate chapel, The shrine but in the noblest spot of all, in the spot which elsewhere ^ard. was reserved for the highest acts of Christian worship, was the new shrine of Eadward reared. And the workmanship of that gorgeous shrine was of a type fit for him who reared it, and for him in whose honour it was reared. Among all the Ki:)gs \vh«';3e tombs ar? gathered together in that solemn spot, two alone revieal in their style of art the work of craftsmen from beyond the sea and even from beyond the mountains. The resting-places of the two Kings in whose Com- heart beat no English feeling, the two Kings who loved to Eadward be surrounded by men of any nation rather than their own, +fl^S,^"7 the two Kings who, more than any other Kings in Eng- lish history, laid England, of their own act, prostrate at the feet of Rome,^ the shrine of Eadward, the tomb of Henry, are fittingly adorned with forms which awake no English associations, the work not of English but of Italian hands. To that shrine, a hundred and three years The Trans- after its first translation, the body of the saint was borne October i ^ by a crowd of the noblest of the land.^ Among them two ^269. ^ I know of no other English church of the thirteenth century which exhibits the French arrangement of the apse and surrounding chapels. . It may be seen at an earlier date at Norwich and in the ground-plan of the destroyed monastic church at Leominster, and at a later date at Tewkes- bury, the example most like Westminster, though on a much smaller scale. ^ John's submission to Rome was more ignominious in point of form than anything done by Eadward or Henry, but it was not in the same way the act of his own free will. ^ T. Wikes, p. 88. Henry moved the body " non patiens ulterivis vene- 38 THE ELECTION OF HAKOLD. OHAP. XI. Kiugs and two Kings^ sons bowed their shoulders beneath the hallowed weight. The two highest of earthly rulers, the continental and the insular Basileus, Richard of Germany and Henry of England, were foremost to bear the burthen to which it was deemed a holy work to stretch forth a single finger.^ With the one English Augustus there joined in the task his nephew, the one Englishman besides himself who ever bore the titles of foreign royalty, Edmund of Lancaster, whose vain pretensions to the Sicilian crown had been already transferred to the stronger- hand of the conqueror from Anjou. Fit bearers for the foreign-hearted saint were an English King who hated Englishmen, and English princes who wasted English Presence treasure in seeking after the kingship of other lands. But the First, there was one who shared in their work who might seem sent there expressly to remind us that the object of their worship was, after all, an Englishman. Among those who bent to bear Eadward^s body was the prince who was named after his name, but whose life reproduced, not the life of Eadward the Confessor, but the life of Eadward the Unconquered.2 Those who then pressed to win spiritual blessings by touching the corpse of Eadward hardly deemed that among themselves was one who was to make his name more worthy of honour among Englishmen than the royal saint could ever make it. It was then deemed an honour and a privilege to draw near to the body of Eadward. Was it not rather the highest of honours paid to Eadward rabiles relliquias beatissirai Regis Edwardi Confessoris, quern prae caeteris Sanctis speciali quddani veneratione dilexit, locello quodam huniili recubare." The ceremony was done •' convocatis universis Angliae praelatis et magna- tibus, necnon cunctarum regni sui civitatum pariter et burgorum potenti- oribus." The Witan, in short, buried him and the Witan translated him. Then follows the list of the Kings, Princes, and nobles who bore the body. T. Wikes, p. 89. " Quotquot manus apponere poterant ad onus tarn nobile supportandum in adjutorium evocatis." '^ See vol. i. pp. 58, 63. THE TOMBS AROUND THE SHRINE. 39 himself, that Harold stood by his side at his first burial^ chap. xi. and that in the great rite of his translation a share was borne by him who did in truth live to wield the sceptre of the Isle of Albion,, and in whom the Scot and the Briton once more bowed to an Eadward of England as their father and their lord?^ But the posthumous history of Eadward the Confessor Eadward's slirinG DG' did not end even with this crowning triumph. His shrine comes the at Westminster became the centre of a group of royal x^^^!^^,°| tombs such as gathered in earlier times in the more ancient tombs. seats of royalty at Winchester and Sherborne. Or a closer parallel still might be looked for in that renowned sanctuary of the West, the resting-place of Eadward^s nobler brother, where Briton and Englishman agreed to revere the name of the legendary Arthur, as at Westminster Englishman and Norman agreed to revere the name of the now well-nigh legendary Eadward.^ Eight years after the burial of Ead- Burial of ward, his widow, the loving sister of Tostig, the loyal 1074 ; subject of William, was laid by his side before the altar of Saint Peter.^ The zeal of King Henry thought of her also, and her remains, translated to the chapel of her husband, were laid as near to his side as the remains of an ordinary sinful mortal might lie to those of a wonder-working saint. To the other side of his shrine was moved the dust ofofEadgyth- another Eadgyth, disguised in history by her Noxman name i jjg. ' Matilda, her in whom the green tree first began to return to the trunk, and in whose grandson Normandy and Eng- land alike became parts of the dominions of the Angevin.* No legend or effigy marks the graves of these royal Ladies, but soon the choicest skill of the craftsman was lavished on the tombs of Kings and princes which crowded round the ^ See vol. i. pp.60, 611. ^ See .vol. i. p. 440. 3 Fl. Wig. 1074. * Ord. Vit. 843 B. " Mathildis Regina, ({xise in baptismate Edit dicta fuit, Kal. Maii [11 18] obiit, ~et in basilic^ sancti Peti-i Westmonasterio tumulata quiescit." 40 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. shrine of their sainted predecessor. To the north King Th'°7 ^^^ Henry sleeps in his tomb of foreign work, beneath the Edward shadow of the patron whom he had so deeply honoured.^ Eleanor Worthier dust lies east and west of him. No graven figure marks the resting-place of his immortal son, but the love- liest work of all within that mighty charnel-house records the love and grief of the great King for a consort worthy of him. Succeeding ages surrounded the sacred spot with the sculptured forms of succeeding generations of English royalty. There sleeps the victor of Crecy and the victor of Richard Azincourt ; there sleeps, beside his nobler Queen, the King ' from whom the Parliament of England, in the exercise of its 1399. ancient right, took away the Crown of which he had shown himself unworthy. Thus around the shrine of Eadward were gathered the successors who in life had sworn to keep his fancied Laws, and who deemed it their highest honour to wear his Crown and to sit upon his royal seat. At last a King arose in whose eyes the wealth which earlier Kings had lavished on that spot outweighed the reverence with which so many ages had surrounded Eadward^s name. One Henry had reared alike the shrine and the pile which held it; the word of another Henry went forth to cast to the owls and to the bats all that earlier ages had deemed holy. The body And yet some remorse seems to have smitten the soul of removed ^bc destroyer before the shrine of the royal patron and law- under giver of England. Elsewhere the shrines of more ancient Henry the ° ° Eighth, saints were levelled with the ground ; elsewhere the dust of Kings and heroes was scattered to the winds. The wealth of Eadward's shrine was indeed borne away to be sported broadcast among the minions of Henry^s court, but the empty casket still stood untouched, and the hallowed re- mains found another, if a lowlier, resting-place within the * Charter of Henry, printed in Stanley's Memorials, p. 504. "Ob rc- verentiam gloriosissimi Regis Ea«i\vardi, cujus corpus in monasterio West- nionasterii requiescit, nostri corporis sepulfcuram . . . eligimus in eodem." LATER HISTORY OF THE SHRINE. 41 minster-walls. And the days yet came when one transla- chap. xi. tion more restored the corpse of Eadward to its place of ^^^^JJ^' honour. And a^ain it was from fitting hands that he under . . , , Pliilip and received this last act of veneration. The foreign-hearted Mary. Eadward. had been first placed in that shrine by the foreign- hearted Henryj the King whose foreign marriage proved the curse of England^ and whose foreign tastes made Eng- land the victim and the bondslave of Rome. Shorn of his honours by a King who^ with all his crimes, was at least an Englishman, Eadward was brought back to his shrine by a Queen whose work it was to bend the neck of England beneath the spiritual yoke of the Roman See and the temporal yoke of her Spanish husband.^ Translated first by the zeal of Henry and Eleanor, he was again restored to his old honours by the zeal of Philip and Mary. And now, while the dust of Eadmund and Harold is scattered to the winds, Eadward still sleeps in his shrine, unworshipped indeed but undisturbed ; and the spot where an Englishman would best love to stand and muse in awe and wonder has become ground from which the votaries of devotion and art and history are bidden to turn away. But we must come back to the doings of the great The Coro- Epiphany. The last King of the House of Cerdic was laid Harold, in his grave ; it was time for the first King of the House J^^^^^y ^» of Godwine to be placed upon his throne. Short as the interregnum had been, England could not go a moment ^ One would have inferred from the account in Dart, Westmonasterium (i. 56), that the body of Eadward was never disturbed. But the testimony of Henry Machyn seems explicit; ** The xx day of Marche [1556-7] was taken up at Westmynst^r agayn "with a hondered lyghtes King Edward the confessor ... it was a godly shyte to have seen yt how reverently he was cared [carried] from the plasse that he was takei.i up wher he was led [laid] when that the abbay was spowlyd and robbed" (p. 130, Camd. Soc. ed.). The shrine was set up on the 5th of January 1555. Chronicle of Grey Friars, p. 94, Camd. Soc. ed., where the day is called Saint Edward's dsij. Stanley, Memoi-ials of Westminster, p. 412. 42 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. longer without a crowned and anointed ruler. From the burial of Eadward men turned at once to the coronation of Harold. That great rite was performed with all solemnity^ no doubt according to those venerable forms whose sub- stance has been followed in the consecration of every English King down to our own time.^ The chief actor in that august ceremony was one not wholly unworthy of so high a function. The Primate of all England^ while his canonical right to his see was called in question at home and abroad_, could not be allowed to discharge the highest duty belonging to his office. The hands of Stigand might not minister an unction which was held to confer somewhat The cere- of Sacramental grace and even of priestly sanctity.^ In his formed by stcad, the rite was performed by the Primate of Northum- ^® ' berlandj his marked adhesion to the new King being perhaps taken as one pledge of the allegiance of his distant province. No living Englishman had seen so much of other lands^ none had so often stood face to face with the rulers of other nations, as he who was now called upon to set the English Crown upon the brow of Harold. Ealdred, alone of living English Prelates, had gone, at the bidding of his King or at the call of his own devotion, to the banks of the Rhine, the Tiber, and the Jordan. He alone had stood, as the representative of England, before the thrones of the spiritual and the temporal chiefs of Christen- dom. He alone had gone, with such worship as none had gone before him,^ far beyond the threshold of the Apostles, to the city where the Infidel bore sway over the very spot of ^ I discuss tlie circumstances of Harold's coronation at length in Appen- dix D. But all that is needed is expressed in the decisive words of Florence, ** Ab Aldredo Archiepisctipo Eboracensi honorific^ consecratus," and in the picture in the Tapestiy, pi. 7, erring only in making Stigand the conse- crator. ^ See Maskell, p. xv. Some canonists seem even to have held, with a special reference to the Emperor John Tzimisk^s, that the unction, like baptism, washed out all earlier sin. ^ See vol. ii. p. 4,^7. CORONATION OF HAROLD. 43 mau^s redemption. He had tarried in the court of Caesar^ chap. xi. he had knelt at the tomb of Christ ; but in all his wander- ings he had never seen such a day or such a scene as when the Witan of all England came together to choose their Father and their Lord, and the diadem of Ecgberht rested on the lordly brow of the King chosen from his brethren. Could he have deemed that, at the next Christmas Feast, he should be called upon again to repeat that solemn rite on the same spot, under circumstances yet more new and wonderful? In the whole range of history, it is hard to point to a stranger fate than that of him to whose lot it fell to receive, within a single year, the coronation- oath of Harold and the coronation-oath of William. The rite began. Earl Harold, the King-elect, was led by The King- two Bishops, with hymns and processions, up to the high ^j^^ Yiigh altar of the minster. Later usage assigned that honourable ^^*^^' function to the Prelates of Durham and of Wells.^ It may then well be that Gisa, the supposed victim and enemy of Harold, really discharged one of the chief parts in his admission to his kingly office. The hymn sung by the choir in that great procession prayed that the hand of Harold might be strengthened and exalted, that justice and judgement might be the preparation of his seat, that mercy and truth might go before his face.^ Before the high altar the Earl of the West-Saxons bowed himself to the ground, and while he lay grovelling, the song of Ambrose, the song of faith and of victory, was sung over one whose sin at Porlock, whose atonement at Waltham, might well make him seem another Tlieodosius.^ The Earl then rose from ^ See Appendix E. ^ Maskell, 3, 5. " Chorus decantet antiphonam * Firmetur manus tua et exaltetur dextera tua ; justitia et judicium prseparatio sedis tuag, miseri- cordia et Veritas praecedent faciem tuam.' " ^ lb. 5. "Perveniens Rex ad ecclesiam, prosternat se coram altare, et hymnizetur, ' Te Deuni laudamus, Te Doiiiinum confitenmr.' Quo fini tentis hymnizato, Rex erigatur de solo." 44 THE ELECTION OF HAKOLD. CHAP. XI. the pavement, and for the last time he looked on the crowd SaTti^af^^" ^^'0^'id ^^^j *^6 Prelates and Thegns and the whole people Election, of England, as still one of their own number. Their voice had already named him as their King^ but a still more solemn election before the altar of God was needed before the Church admitted him to the sacramental unction. Once more the voice of Ealdred demanded of the English people, in ancient form_, whether they would that Earl Harold should be crowned as their Lord and King. A loud shout The Coro- of assent rang through the minster. Chosen thus by Pre- oath^" lates and people/ the King-elect swore with a loud voice his threefold oath to God and to all his folk. Kings swore in after days that they would observe all the rights and liberties which the glorious Eadward had granted to his clergy and his people. The oath of the prince who had so lately renewed the Laws of Cnut was of a simpler form. Earl Harold swore to preserve peace to the Church of God and to all Christian people. He swore to forbid wrong and robbery to men of every rank within his realm. He swore to enforce justice and mercy in all his judgements, as he would that God should have mercy upon him. And all the people said Amen. The Bishops then prayed for the ruler whom they had chosen, for his guidance by the Spirit of wisdom in the government of his realm, for peace to his Church and people, for his welfare in this world and in the next.2 Then a yet more solemn prayer from the lips of Ealdred followed. In that ancient English form, which other nations have been fain to borrow of us,-^ the God who had wrought His mighty works by the hands of Abraham and Moses and Joshua and David and Solomon was implored to shower down all the gifts and graces of those famous worthies upon him who was that day chosen to be King of the Angles and Saxons. Ealdred prayed that Harold, 1 See Appendix E. a See the Prayer, Maskell, p. 6, note. ■' See Appendix E. THE UNCTION. 45 faithful as Abraham, gentle as Moses, brave as Joshua, chap. xi. humble as David, wise as Solomon, might teach and rule and guard the Church and realm of the Angles and Saxons^ against all visible and invisible foes. With feelings too deep for words must that prayer have risen from the hearts of all who could already see the gathering storm, which was still but like a little cloud out of the sea. The Primate prayed that their chosen King might never fail the throne and sceptre of the Angles and Saxons, that for long years of life he might reign over a faithful people, in peace and concord, and, if need be, in victory. Christ Himself was prayed to raise him to the throne of His kingdom, and to pour down upon him the unction of the Holy One. ^^The oaths were said, the prayers were prayed/^ ^ And The U«c- now came the sacramental rite itself which changed an Earl into a King, and which gave him, so men then deemed, grace from on high to discharge the duties which were laid upon him. The holy oil was poured by Ealdred upon the head of Earl Harold.^ And while the symbolic act was in doing, the choir raised their voices in that glorious strain to which the noblest music of later times has given a still higher majesty. The walls of the West Minster echoed to the anthem which told how Zadok the Priest and Nathan the Prophet anointed Solomon King, and which added the prayer of England that Harold might live for ever.* Again the Primate prayed that, as of old Kings and Priests and Prophets were anointed with oil, so now the oil poured on ^ "Totius regni Anglo-Saxonum ecclesiam cum plebibus sibi annexis." (Selden, ii6.) This is one of the rare cases in which this word is used ; but it will be easily seen how completely its use agrees with the rule given in vol. i. p. 608. "Anglo-Saxonum" is simply an abbreviation of the form " Anglorum vel [ = et] Saxonum" used before and after. ^ Marmion, ii. 28. ^ On the unction, whether on the head only, see Appendix E. * Selden, 116. ''Hie unguatur oleo, et haec cantetur antiphona, ' Unxerunt Salomonem Sadooh sacerdos et Nathan propheta Regem in Gion, et accedentes dixerunt, Vivat Rex in seternum.'' " 46 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XT. the head of God^s servant might be a true sign of the inner unction of the heart, a means of grace for His glory and the The Invos- welfare of His people. ^ And now King Harold, the Lord's 1 ure. Anointed, the chosen of the people, the consecrated of the Church, vested in the robes of royalty and priesthood,^ received in due order the insignia of his kingly office. The sword was placed in his hand, with the prayer that he might therewith defend his realm, and smite his enemies and the The enemies of the Church of God.^ The King then bowed his rowning. j^^^^^ ^^^ ^-^q Imperial diadem of Britain was placed by the hand of Ealdred on the head of the King of the Angles and Saxons, the Emperor of the Isle of Albion.^ God was again implored to crown His Anointed with glory and justice and might, and to give him a yet brighter Crown in a more enduring Kingdom. Then the sceptre crowned with the cross, and the rod crowned with the holy dove, were placed, one after the other, in the royal hands. Prayer was again made that the sceptre of Harold's Kingdom might be a sceptre of righteousness and strength, that he who had been anointed with the oil of gladness above his fellows might through all his days be a lover of righteousness and a hater of iniquity.^ Further prayers, further blessings, followed ; the prayers and merits of all the saints, of the Virgin Mother of God, of the Prince of the Apostles, and of his successor the special Apostle of the English nation,^ were ^ Selden, 117. '' Sacratissima unctio super caput ejus defluat, atque ad interiora descendat, et cordis illius intima penetret." ^ On the royal vestments, see Taylor, 79 et seqq. ^ Maskell, p. -27. ''In quo per virtutem Sancti Spiritiis resistere et ejicere omnes inimicos tuos valeas, et cunctos sanctse Dei Ecclesiae adversarios, regnumque tibi commissum tutari, atque protegere castra Dei." * On the Crown and the other regalia used, including the orb, see Appendix E. •' Maskell, pp. 33, 34. •^ lb. 35. "Sanotie Marine ac beati Petri Ajiostolorum Princijils, Sanctique Gregorii Anglorum Apostoli atque omnium sanctorum inter- cedentibus meritis." THE CROWDING. 47 implored on behalf of the crowned and anointed King*. And chap. xi. now King Harold of England sat on his royal throne, the ^^^J^ ^^' crown upon his brow_, in his right hand the sceptre^ in his Harold left the orb of Empire/ the proud badge which belonged giorum." of right to the Caesar of another world. Two chiefs, perhaps his faithful brothers, bore the sword at his side; his people stood and gazed upon him with wonder and delight.^ The day at last had come for which Harold and Import of England had looked so long. The reward of thirteen years mory. of loyal service had been given by the nation to her noblest son. And the die too bad been cast; the danger was now to be faced in common ; King and people were pledged to stand by one another in the struggle which was to come. And King and people did stand by one another, and, if they both fell, they both fell gloriously. The rite of that great day gave Harold, instead of the long and peaceful reign prayed for by his consecrator, a reign of nine months of little stillness. 3 Then England was given over to bondage, and the name of Harold was given over to the voice of slander. But in the eye of truth, those nine months of little stillness, spent in the cause of England, were better than long years of inglorious ease and luxury, better than long years of hardly less inglorious sloth and superstition. As the momentary glory of Eadmund follows on the weary years of iEthelred, so the momentary glory of Harold followed on those years of Eadward which Harold alone had saved from being as weary as those of his father. And, in the eye of authentic history, never was crown more lawfully won, more worthily worn, than that which Ealdred placed that day on the head of him whom calumny marked so long as Harold the Usurper. If there ever was a lawful ruler in this world, such of a truth was Harold, King of the ^ See Taylor, p. 70, and Appendix E. ^ See the Tapestry, pi, 7. ^ Chronn. Ab. Wig. 1065. "And her wser^ Harold eorl eao to cynge gehalgodj and he lytle stilnesse j^asron gehad, J>a hwile j^e he rices weold." 48 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. English and Lord of the Isle of Britain — King, not by the mouldering titles of a worn-out dynasty, not by the gold of the trafficker or the steel of the invader, but by the noblest title by which one man can claim to rule over his fellows, the free choice of a free people. Was Eald- The rite was over. Earl Harold was now King ; but we crowned? Cannot help asking whether he stood alone in the great ceremony which had made him so. Did the Lady Ealdgyth, once again the wife of a King, share in the consecration of her husband? Her coronation is nowhere distinctly spoken of, but our ancient ritual provides a form for the anointing of the King's consort, and for her investiture with the ring and crown.^ There is no reason to suppose that the wife of Harold, the grand-daughter of Leofric, would be debarred from any honour befitting the wife of a King, the mother of future ^thelings. But, in the absence of direct tes- timony, I do not venture to affirm the fact. Indeed I must confess that I feel less certain than I did when writing my last chapter, whether the marriage of Harold and Ealdgyth may not have followed his election to the Crown.^ Whether then the new King had a consort to share in his honours is a point which I must leave uncertain. But, according to all precedent, on the coronation followed the mass, with prayers and collects appropriate for the great solemnity.^ At that mass the King partook of the holiest rite of Christian worship. On the mass followed the banquet, and there, on the last day of the Christmas Festival, we cannot sioubt that King Harold, in all the glory of his new dignity, wore his Crown with all kingly state in what was now his Palace of Westminster. The old dynasty had passed away; the new dynasty had taken possession; but not many days had gone before voices of warning came which ' See the fonii, Selden, 117. Maskell, .si. Taylor, 307 et seqq.and 403. 2 See Appendix F. 3 Maskell, p. 39. Taylor, 404. POSITION OF HAROLD AND THE NORTHERN EARLS. 49 showed that King Harold of England would soon have to chap. xi. do battle for his Crown. § 3. The First Bays of HarolcVs Reign. January 6 — April i6j io66. Within the bounds of his former Earldom the rule of No new T^firl of til© Harold,, King of the English, was simply a continuation of West- the rule of Harold, Earl of the West-Saxons. It is plain fpp^JJftgd. that no other Earl of the great southern Earldom was ap- pointed in his place. In any view of general policy this might be looked on as a backward step. It might be looked on as again uprearing a throne which should be West- Saxon rather than English. It might be looked on as again reducing Mercia and Northumberland from in- tegral parts of the realm into dependent provinces.^ But under the circumstances of the moment, it would seem to have been the wiser course. England was threatened by two enemies in different quarters, and even the energy of Harold could not personally provide for the safety of the land against both. It was absolutely necessary, in Harold''s Necessity position, to treat the Earls of the Northumbrians and the dence in Mercians, perhaps already his brothers-in-law, with a degree ^^^wme of confidence which they certainly did not deserve. It was Morkere. something that they had allowed his election and coronation to take place without any open opposition. It was some- thing that he had received the votes of the Northumbrian Witan, and had been crowned and anointed by the hands "of the Northumbrian Primate. Harold could not do other- wise than at least affect to treat Eadwine and Morkere as loyal subjects or even as loving brothers. He was obliged Division of to trust to them for the defence of Northern England. And, between if they could be trusted for anything, they might surely, tiie^tng it would seem, be trusted to keep their personal enemy ^ See vol. i. p. 470; ii. p. 355. VOL. III. E 50 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Tostig" out of their own Earldoms. While they guarded the North against the English exile^ it was Harold''s own work to guard the South against the foreign pretender. In the eastern shires_, from the Wash to the Straits of Dover,, he had the trustiest of lieutenants in his brothers Gyrth and Leofwine. It was clearly his own business^ while not abdi- cating his duty of general care over the whole Kingdom, to undertake as his special work the defence of the lands which had formed his own Earldom. No one could do that work No avail- SO well as himself. We can hardly see whom Harold, had date for'^he ^^ ^GGVi SO inclined, could have invested with the West- y®^*' Saxon Earldom. Every man who could lay claim to so Saxon ... . . Earldom, high a dignity on the score either of birth or of merit was already provided for. The King^s remaining brother Wulf- noth was probably a hostage in Normandy ; his own sons, his nephew Hakon, were all young and untried. The re- presentatives of the two Northumbrian families, Waltheof and Oswulf, were equally untried, and they were already invested with the government of districts with which they had an ancestral connexion. Nor can we point to the name of any West- Saxon of special personal eminence beyond the Military limits of the great houses. It was clearly the policy of the keeping moment, a moment when military considerations must have Wessex m \)qqyi supreme above all others, for the King to keep the im- own hands, mediate administration of the South in his own hands, avail- ing himself only of the co-operation of his brothers the two Eastern Earls. And, after all, though Northumberland and Mercia again became in a sense dependencies on the West- Saxon Crown, the arrangement might very well suit the purposes of Eadwine and Morkere. They might deem that a step was thereby taken towards the division of the King- dom, when its administration was practically divided between the House of Leofric and the House of Godwine, and when the King took his own share along with his brothers and brothers-in-law. A King who had his own portion of the WESSEX KEPT IN HAEOLD S OWN HANDS. 61 Kingdom in his own hands might seem to be less painfully chap. xi. exalted over their heads, he might seem to remain more nearly on their own level, than a King who acted simply as a central power, equally controlling every portion of the realm. Harold therefore kept the West- Saxon Earldom in his own hands. But it is clear that he kept a watchful eye over his whole Kingdom, and that he was ready to act at a moment^s notice in any part of his Kingdom where his presence might be needed. On the character of Harold^s government as King there Character is no need to enlarge. His government as King was, as I govern- have just before said, simply a continuation of his govern- "^®"*- ment as Earl. Whatever was the character of the one was the character of the other. The Norman writers describe Norman his government as stained by frightful crimes. As usual, stories grow and become more definite as they are further removed from the time. The slanderers of Harold^s own age veiled their charges in the most general terms; but the slanderers of the thirteenth century were ready with long stories of rapine and sacrilege and evil doings of every kind, and the slanderers of a still later age knew perfectly well how cruelly Harold enforced the forest laws, and how the husband of Ealdgyth rem.ained without a wife, that he m.ight the more easily carry off the wives and daughters of the '' Barons " of the realm.^ A charge which better Asserted deserves serious examination is that Harold drove out of pulsion of the land all the Normans who were settled in it, doubtless ^o^^^^^^s. confiscating their lands.^ Now the dying charge of Ead- "ward himself suggested the banishment, though not the * On these charges, see Appendix G. ^ Roman de Rou, 11076 ; "Noraianz ki el paiz maneient Et granz chastels fe fieux dunez, Ki fames et enfanz aveient, Fist Heraut del paiz chacier, Ke Ewart i aveit mendz, N'en i volt un soul lessier." But he does not speak of their expulsion till after William had challenged the Crown and defied Harold. B 2 52 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI, Some Normans at least re- mained in England. Bishop William and Robert the son of Wymarc not mo- lested. Other Stallers. spoliation, of any Normans who might refuse to become the men of the new King.^ The fact that the charge is brought against Harold may lead us to think that some such cases actually occurred, and that Eadward's rule was put in force with regard to them. But it is quite im- possible to believe that all the Frenchmen who were naturalized in England ^ were now driven out. Some record of such a process would certainly have found its way into Domesday. And we know for certain that some Normans of high rank were not driven out. William of London retained his Bishoprick. His name does not actu- ally occur in the history of Harold'^s reign, but it is quite certain that, if he had been meddled with, some Norman writer or other would have taken care to record the fact. The wrongs of the living Bishop of London would have made an excellent sequel to the wrongs of the dead Arch- bishop of Canterbury. And we know distinctly, from the testimony of Norman writers,^ that Robert the son of Wymarc was living quietly in England, as a man of wealth and importance, at the time of William's landing. He clearly retained his lands ; there is no evidence whether he did or did not retain his office of S taller. Nor have we any direct evidence as to the position retained in Harold's reign by Robert's fellow- S taller Ralph,* or by any other of Eadward's Norman favourites. We cannot say whether Hugolin the Treasurer and Reginbald the Chancellor ^ re- tained their offices in the Court of the English King. We can only say that, among the English Stallers employed by * See above, p. 15. 2 gee vol. ii. p. 358. ^ We shall find him in Sussex at the moment of the landing at Pevensey. See below, Chapter xv. Robert the son of Wymarc must be distinguished from another Robert who was also high in Eadward's favour, namely Robert of Rhuddlan, sister's son to Hugh of Grantmesnil (Ord. Vit. 669 C) ; " Hie Eduardi Regis armiger fuit [a sinecure office, one would think], et ab illo cingulum militias accepit." * See vol. ii. p. 347. ^ See vol. ii. p. 359. Reginbald signs many charters. CHARACTER OF HAROLDS GOVERNMENT. 53 Eadward, three at least, Bondig/ Esegar, and Eadnoth^ chap. xi. retained their offices. Esegar and Bondig play not unim- portant parts in the great struggles of the year.^ Ead- Eadnoth. noth, who held large possessions in the western shires, was probably a man who had risen by the favour of Harold during his government of Wessex as Earl. We shall hear of him again as acting against the son of his benefactor. 1067, In opposition to the slanders of his enemies, Harold English de- appears in the national writers as the model of a patriot ^f Harold's Kins'. In the words of the splendid panegyric which ^°°^ ^°' became almost a set form among all true Englishmen, '' he began to abolish unrighteous laws, to establish righteous ones, to be the patron of churches and monas- teries, to reverence Bishops, Abbots, monks, and church- men of every sort, to show himself pious, lowly, and affable to all good men, and to be the enemy of all evil doers.^''^ We are told how he bade his Earls, Sheriffs, and magistrates of every kind, and generally all his Thegns, to seize all thieves, robbers, and disturbers of the public peace, while he himself laboured for the defence of the country by sea and land.* That is to say, his government as King was a continuation of his government as Earl. We must not infer from the opening words of the description that Harold appeared at all as a lawgiver. Those few months ^ There were several Stallers at a time. Besides Robert and Ralph, we find under Eadward, Esegar (see vol. ii. p. 63, and Hist. Elien. ii. 39, where he seems to be confounded with Earl ^Ifgar), Lyfing (Cod. Dipl. iv. 291 ; vi. 198), Eadgar (iv. 148), ^Ifstan (Thorpe, Dipl. Ang. 356), Harold (Domesday, 337), and Bondig (Cod. Dipl. iv. 172, 281 ; Domesday, 148 b, 218 b). The deposition or banishment of Ralph is more likely than that of any other favourite of Eadward. On the other hand his foreign birth is less certain. ^ See below, Chapp, xiv. xv. ^ Fl. Wig. 1066. See Appendix Gr. * Florence mentions his orders as given "Ducibus, Satrapis, Vice- comitibus, et suis in commune Ministris." What were the exact functions of the ''Satraps," put thus in a marked way between Earls and Sheriffs? 64 THE ELECTION OF HAEOLD. CHAP. XI. of little stillness were not likely to be largely devoted either to the repeal of old laws or to the enactment of new ones. By good and bad law is meant^ as usual/ good and bad government. What we are to understand is that Harold^s rule continued to be as just and as vigorous as it had ever been. It would in truth be more vigorous, now that he could act freely for himself, and had no longer to take the pleasure of the wayward Eadward upon any matter. His strictness against all breaches of the peace is simply his old virtue as Earl ; ^ only we see, what of course naturally follows from the state of things at the time, that this duty was now, more than it had been before, thrown upon the King^s officers and representatives, while the King himself was mainly occupied with his military His mill- preparations. We see also that those preparations began ratfonrbT- ^^ui the very beginning of his reign, that there is no gan early o-round to believe that Harold despised either of his in his reign. *^ -^ » enemies, or that he failed from the first to make ready for a ay thing that might happen. His great difficulty must have been to make others feel the importance of the crisis as he felt it himself, and at the same time to avoid anything which could dishearten men^s minds or chill the warmth of the hopes kindled by a new reign and a new djmasty. The spirit of Harold's rule is impressed in a striking, and even touching, way on the few material monuments of his His short reign. The new King found time for a new coinage, and the device on Harold''s coin well spoke the longings of a King whose heart yearned for peace, though he knew that peace could be had only through war. On the one side is the simple legend, PAX, on the other side the King wears the Imperial Diadem.^ All that man could do for his realm and people King Harold did. The evil 1 See vol. i. pp. 244, 463 ; vol. ii. pp. 336, 481, 499. * See vol. ii. pp. 34, 40. ^ On the coinage of Harold, see Appendix H. coinage. HAROLDS RELATIONS TO THE CHURCH. 55 was that^ according to the old Greek saying, even Herakles chap, xi. could not struggle with two foes at once.'^ As for Harok^s devotion to the Church, which is so Good strongly insisted on by his panegyrist, we can see that he Harold to- had every motive at this time to make friends of all classes ^^Y- i® of men, and to make friends of the clergy more than of Church. any other class. He must have known that something like a holy war was likely to be proclaimed against him. He must have felt that he had, wittingly or unwittingly, done an act which ran counter to the religious feelings of the time. If Harold had really done despite to the bones of the Norman Saints, it was the more needful for him to show to other lands that he enjoyed the confidence of the national Church, and to show to the national Church that he was a King who did not belie the oil of his consecration. It is quite possible, and' it may be implied in the words of His rela- the panegyric, that the founder of Waltham, the great monks. patron of the seculars, now found it expedient to extend more of his countenance than before to the religious foundations of his Kingdom. It is certain that the few notices that we have of the reign of Harold show that more of his attention was given to ecclesiastical matters than might have been looked for in a reign so short and so stormy. He continued his care and bounty to his own His further foundation at Waltham ; what the Earl had loved, the waltham. King could not love less.^ If Bishop Gisa had any fears. His writ lo they were quieted by a writ securing him in all the rights and possessions of his see.-^ The construction which we ^ Plat. Phsed. c. xxxviii. dAAa -n-phs Svo Keyerai ovb' 6 'HpaK\ris oUs re ehai. ^ De Inv. c. 20. " Rex . . quod prius dilexerat non potuit odisse. Verumtameii ecclesiam Walthamensem, amplori quam pritis amplexatus dilectione, mult^ donariorum venustate coepit earn ampliare, ita ut postea nullatenus sine multorum munerum oblatione vellet etiam illam sedem visitare." ^ Cod. Dipl. iv. 305, perhaps the only surviving writ of Harold's reign. It is addressed to ^thelnoth, Abbot of Glastonbury (see vol. ii. p. 361) and the Sheriff Tovid or Tofig. See vol. i. p. 590. 56 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. put upon this act must depend upon tlie view which we take of the relations between Harold and Gisa at this moment. We have seen that^ according to Gisa^s own account, the King promised to restore the disputed lands, and was hindered only by his death. ^ At any rate, Harold showed either that he was unconscious of wrong, or that, if he was conscious, he was anxious to make atonement. His friend- Among the monastic Prelates, the history will show that th? Abbots ^6 could count on the loyal service, not only of his Leofric and ^jj^^jlg at the New Minster of Winchester,^ but of the ^thelwig ; ^ ' member of the rival house who ruled over the Golden Borough.^ Peterborough, it should be remembered, is the only monastic foundation of which Harold is distinctly recorded as a benefactor.* The intercourse between Harold and Abbot Leofric was plainly one of mutual confidence and mutual good offices. JEthelwig also, the prudent Abbot of Evesham, stood high in the new King^s favour. The soul of the saintly Mannig had passed away at the same hour as the soul of the saintly Eadward,^ and the church of Evesham was now under the sole rule of the Prelate whose wisdom had already commended him to Ealdred and was afterwards still more specially to commend him to William. With Harold the influence of ^thelwig was great; the Abbot, we are told, obtained from the King whatever he asked. 6 One would like to know more clearly the nature of the requests made by such a Prelate to such a King, and with But among the ranks of monks and Bishops there was one Wulfstan. greater than Gisa or Leofric or iEthelwig, one whose prayers and whose counsels Harold had long learned to value. The holy Wulfstan had for years been his tried friend, and it was on the tried friendship of that true man of God that * See vol. ii. p. 639. 2 gge vol. ii. p. 467. ^ See vol. ii. p. 350. * See vol. ii. p. 42. ' See vol. ii. p. 438. Cf. p. 462. ^ Hist. Eves. 88. " Defuncto nempe Rege isto [^diiuardo] et Haraldo regnum accipiente, quidquid volebat ab 00 impetravit [Ageluuius]." HAROLD ACCEPTED BY THE NORTHERN WITAN. 57 Harold chose to lean in the first of the many trials of his chap. xi. short reign. There can be no doubt that the Witan of Northumber- Formal concur" land, no less than the Witan of the rest of England, had rence of concurred in the election of Harold. The expressions of J^^!"*^^""?' ■'■ berland m our best authorities declare that the chief men of all Eng- Harold's land concurred in the choice ; ^ the Primate of the North- humbrians had filled the first place in the work of Harold^s formal admission to his Kingdom, and there is nothing to show that the Earl of the Northumbrians openly dissented. But a little thought will show that the real feelings of Northumberland could not be so easily tested in an As- sembly held in London as the real feelings of Wessex and East-Anglia. We cannot suppose that the North was re- presented in such an Assembly in anything like the same proportion as the districts nearer to the place of meeting. This is always one of the weak points of a Primary, as Working of distinguished from a Representative, Assembly. In a gemdt as E/cpresentative Assembly, if members are fairly apportioned ^ Primary to districts, a part of the country far away from the place of meeting may be as well represented as one that is close to it. In a Primary Assembly the different parts of the country cannot be put on an equality except by taking the votes, not by heads, but by tribes, cities, or cantons.^ Northumberland might, by this means, have had an equal voice with Wessex in the national Councils, though the West-Saxons present might have been counted by hundreds or thousands, and the Northumbrians only by tens or units. But this political subtlety does not seem to have been thought of in the primitive parliamentary system of our forefathers. It follows then that, wherever a Gemot was held, some part of the country was placed at a disadvantage. ^ Harold was "a totins Anglice Primatibus ad regale culmen electus." Fl. Wig. i66. 2 gee jjjgt^ -ped. Gov. pp. 211, 270. 58 THE ELECTION OF HAKOLD. CHAP. XI. Northum- berland never fairly repre- sented. Harold's election naturally repugnant to North- humbrian feelings. East-Anglia was placed at a disadvantage when the Gemot was held at Gloucester; Western Mercia was placed at a disadvantage when the Gemot was held in London. And as no regular Gemot seems to have been held in Ead- ward^s time at any place north of Gloucester,^ Northum- berland was always placed at a disadvantage. We may conceive that, in the Gemot which elected Harold, that is, the Gemot assembled for the consecration of the West Minster, Wessex, East-Anglia, and south-eastern Mercia were largely represented. The citizens of London were ready on the spot. But it is not likely that the North- humbrians present would be more than a mere handful. The Archbishop, the Earls, the Bishop of Durham, and a few of the leading Thegns w^ould doubtless obey the royal summons. But it is not likely that many besides these would undertake such a journey in the middle of winter. We can therefore fully understand that the mass of the Northumbrian people might feel that an election had been made to which they had not consented. The election had been made in all due constitutional form. Still a most important step, a step affecting the whole Kingdom, a step likely to be in many ways repug- nant to Northumbrian feeling, a step to which North - humberland had practically not been a consenting party, had been taken by a part of England in the name of the whole. By that step the mass of the Northumbrian people refused to be bound.^ That the old provincial jealousy should break out again at this moment was not wonderful. It was something strange and new even for West- Saxons to set over them a King of their own blood, who was not of the royal house. But it was something stranger and newer still for Northumbrians to be called on to acknowledge a King, ' I except of course the irregular Gem6t of Northampton in 1065. See vol. ii. pp. 491, 492. 2 ggg Appendix H. OPPOSITION TO HAROLD IN NORTHUMBERLAND. 59 who was neither of their own blood nor of the blood of their chap. xi. old West- Saxon conquerors, but who sprang from a West- Saxon house which, two generations back, had been undis- tinguished_, perhaps ignoble. This feeling on the part of the Northumbrian people was short-sighted and ungenerous, but it was perfectly natural. The question is, how far the sons of iElfgar, who had not dared to oppose Harold^s election in open Gemot, now stirred up, or took advan- tage of, the natural feeling of the Northumbrian people. Our evidence is very slight,, but the conduct of Eadwine and Morkere a few months later makes it almost impos- sible to doubt that they saw, in the unwillingness of Northumberland to acknowledge the newly-chosen King, an admirable means towards carrying out their schemes for the division of the Kingdom. We have no distinct details of what actually happened in Northumberland at this moment. The one writer who tells the story wraps up the minuter facts in a cloud of rhetoric.^ It is plain The North- however that the Northumbrians did, in some shape or refuse to other, refuse to acknowledge Harold as their King. There j>cknow- is nothing to show that there was any armed resistance, Harold, or that any Northumbrian Gemot took upon itself to elect another King. The resistance to Harold^s authority was probably passive, but resistance of some kind there was. Harold, in short, found himself in January in very nearly Similar the same position with regard to the northern part of Harold in his King-dom in which William found himself in December. J^^^^^y ^ and 01 Each alike had been elected and crowned; each had re- William in December. ceived the allegiance of the Northumbrian Earl, and had been hallowed as King by the Northumbrian Primate. But Harold and William alike found that the submission of Morkere and the benediction of Ealdred did not neces- sarily carry with them any practical authority over the old Northumbrian realm. And we cannot doubt that ^ Will. Malms. Vit, S. Wist., ap. Ang. Sacr. ii. 253. 60 THE ELECTION OP HAROLD. CHAP. XI, the heart of Morkere went forth as little in his oath to Probable Harold as it went forth in his oath to William. We agency oi Eadwine cannot doubt that Morkere, and Eadwine also, took ad- Morkere. vantage, in the former case as in the latter, of the natural disposition of the Northumbrian people. The momentary hopes which were roused by the unwillingness of the Danish and Anglian North to acknowledge the West- Saxon King overcame the fear lest Tostig should come to recover his Earldom by force. Weighed against such hopes, the tie of allegiance, the tie of gratitude, the tie of affinity, was not likely to be strong. The claims of a King, a benefactor, perhaps a brother, would seem small compared with a chance of personal exaltation. The duty of keeping England united in the face of her foes would seem as nothing compared with the chance of gratifying a paltry provincial jealousy. I may seem to be passing a harsh judgement on the sons of ^Ifgar in a matter in which their names are not directly mentioned. But I am simply supposing that their conduct now was of a piece with their conduct a few months before and a few months after. And it is hard to see what form could be taken by even a passive resistance to Harold^s authority, unless that resistance was fostered by the connivance, to say the least, of the reigning Earl. Harold's Harold then found himself in January, as William found recovering himself in December, King of a realm of which North- a^jcted humberland constitutionally formed a part, but a King to whom Northumberland presented a front of at least passive resistance. But Harold^s way of bringing in the proud Danes of the North to his obedience was not exactly the same as William^s way. Harold knew how to win back the revolted province without shedding a drop of blood and without harrying a single acre of ground. It is ' small blame to William, granting his position in England at all, that no such peaceful means were open to him as HAROLDS VISIT TO NORTHUMBERLAND. 61 were open to Harold. But_, if Harold's way of recovering chap. xi. rebels differed widely from William's,, it differed no less widely from that of Harthacnut, of Tostig^ or of Eadward himself. Three months before, the saintly King had been eager to carry fire and sword into a province which, though it despised his authority, does not seem to have disputed his title. His good genius, in the shape of Harold, had then kept him back from a bootless war against his own people.' That same province was now in revolt against Harold himself; but it was soon shown that the policy of Harold the King was in no way changed from the policy of Harold the Earl. The con- queror of Gruffydd was less eager for war and bloodshed than the King who had never grasped axe or sword except in a peaceful pageant. King Harold showed that the motto on his coin was one which he was ready fully to carry out in practice. He at least knew that, at such a moment, civil war, civil dissension, between Englishmen, was simple madness. With that noble and He deter- generous daring which is sometimes the highest prudence, visit North- Harold determined to trust himself in the hands of the J^""J^®^'' land 111 people who refused to acknowledge him. Those his person, enemies who would not that he should reign over them, instead of being brought and slain before him, were to be won over by the magic of his personal presence in their own land. We know not whether Harold had ever before set foot on Northumbrian ground. His vast possessions indeed extended beyond the Humber. The lordship of Coningsburgh, more famous in romance than in history, together with a large surrounding territory, owned Harold as its lord.^ A house of Harold's probably marked the height which is now crowned by the renowned castle of later times ; but we know not whether the great Earl ever found leisure to visit a possession so far removed ^ See vol. ii. p. 495. ^ Domesday, 321. 62 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. both from the scenes of his labours at Gloucester, Win- chester, and London^ and from the scenes of his pleasure and devotion in his own woods and by his own minster at Waltham. But one thing is certain^ that years had 103 1, passed since Northumberland had seen a King. Thirty- Rarity of fiyg years earlier Cnut had passed through the land on royal visits '' . to the his victorious march against the Scots. ^ Whether the Nortli first Harold, whose capital seems to have been Oxford, ever found his way to York is uncertain. But there is nothing to lead us to suppose that Harthacnut or Eadward had ever seen any part of their dominions north of Shrews- bury, perhaps not even north of Gloucester.^ Thus the mere presence of a King in the North of England would be something strange and exciting, and the mere presence of a King can, as we all know, often work wonders. Harold then set off for Northumberland, to win over the disaffected province, not by arms, but by the power of speech and the magic of royal courtesy. But he went not alone. The companion whom he chose seems to show how important a part of Harold^s policy it was at this moment to show himself as the choice and the friend of the national Church. With the King went the best and holiest Prelate in England, his old and tried friend, the saintly Bishop of Worcester. On the example and the eloquence of Wulfstan Harold relied to win over those in whose ears he might himself charm in vain. Harold and Wulfstan then set forth on their journey northward. They would probably take with them House- carls enough for their own personal protection, but it is plain that they took with them no force capable of controlling or overawing the country. The power of speech and of reason. He takes Bishop Wulfstan with him. ' See vol. i, p. 499. ^ See vol. ii, p. 484. Eadward, born at Islip, is said (Hist. Eli. ii. 33) to have been presented by his parents on the altar at Ely ; I know not whetlier he ever repeated the visit. HAROLD AND WULFSTAN WIN OVER THE MALECONTE^fTS. 63 the example and the influence of the brightest light of the chap. xt. national priesthood, were the arms to which Harold trusted. Our narrative tells us only the result and not the process. Harold and The proud Danes, unconquerable by steel/ bowed their persuade necks to the gentle yoke of Harold and Wulfstan, and the ^^'^ ^°/^^- o •/ ' humbrians authority of the new King was acknowledged throughout to submit. Northumberland. One could well wish to know more of the details. The biographer of Wulfstan attributes the happy result wholly to the reverence with which the Saint inspired the fierce spirits of the North. From the merits and the honour of Wulfstan, a true Saint and the chosen friend of Harold, I should be sorry to derogate one jot or one tittle. But I cannot but think that the presence, the arguments, the eloquence, of the hero-King himself must have had some share in winning over his people to his allegiance. In the Gemot at York, which was evidently Harold in , p , , ^ , • 1 J. 1 J the Gemdt summoned tor the purpose/ he might appeal to every .^^ York. feeling of patriotism, and conjure them, as Englishmen, not, at such a moment, to separate the cause of one Earldom from the common cause of England. If England were torn by civil war, even if England were peacefully divided, what assurance was there that Wessex alone could with- stand the attacks of William, that Northumberland alone could withstand the attacks of Tostig? But if England were united — and under none but Harold could she be united — she might be able to hold up against both enemies at once. He might appeal to every feeling of personal gratitude ; he might remind the Northumbrian people how lately he had sacrificed his brother to their will, how lately he had saved them from a civil war, when King Eadward was eager to march his armies against them. The personal ^ Vit. wist. 2 5^. " Illi populi ferru indomabiles, semper quiddam maynum k proavis spirantes." ^ The matter could only have been decided in a Gemot, and Harold's presence at York is implied in the Chronicles. 64 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Harold acknow- ledged in Northum- berland. Continued dangers from Ead- wine and Morkere. Harold King: pleadings of a King^ even when they are far weaker in themselves_, are seldom heard in vain; and the voice of reason and prudence, speaking from the lips of such a King as Harold, was still less likely to be without fruit. The Northumbrian Danes had received from Harold a mark of consideration and confidence such as they had hardly received from any King since the days of Eadgar.^ It is no wonder then that the mission of the King and his saintly companion was successful for the moment. Harold was received as King by Northumberland, as he had already been received as King by the rest of England. Perhaps none of his exploits was more glorious than thus to win for himself a great province, an ancient Kingdom, by the mere force of reason and justice. And there is nothing to show that the Northumbrian people fell away from their loyalty, or showed themselves unworthy of the trust which their King had placed in them. But the root of evil was left behind. On the decisive step of removing the sons of iElfgar from their Earldoms Harold could not venture. He was obliged to leave a portion of the Kingdom stretching at least from the Welland to the Tweed in the hands of rulers who could not be trusted. The very ease with which Harold had won the hearts of the Northumbrian people would be of itself a root of bitterness in the hearts of Eadwine and Morkere. They were now further than ever from any hopes of peaceful kingship. They must either be loyal lieutenants of their brother-in-law ^ or else open or secret rebels against him. We shall see what was the fate of Northumberland and of England, when so vast a power had to be left in such unworthy hands. But for the moment King Harold was indeed King over the whole realm. He had won the hearts of the whole * See vol. i. p. 67. '^ On the possibility that Harold's marriage with Ealdgyth took place at this point, see Appendix F. Harold's easter gem6t. 65 English people from Wight to Lindisfarne, as perhaps no chap. xi. other King had won them since England had acknowledged ^^^^Jj^Jj'^j a single King. It may be that the holy man whom he had chosen as his guide and partner chose that moment of his highest exaltation to set before him a picture of the sins of England, and to exhort him to devote himself to their reformation. 1 Or it maybe that the warnings of Wulfstan to Harold, like the warnings of Solon to Croesus, are merely part of a grand dramatic picture, showing how the shadow of the wrath to com.e was already spreading over the land. But, for the moment, all was brighter than at any other moment of the year. King Harold, full King over all England, came back in peace to his palace at Westminster. It was there that he kept the Easter Festival, and held Harold his Easter Gemot, the one recorded Festival and the one Easter recorded Gemot of his short reig-n.^ But the reiffn of ^\ ^est- ° ^ minster. Harold, short as it was, marks an important stage in the April i6. gradual process by which London became the capital of -^poj-^^ance England. Eadward and Harold were both, by widely ^^ J^°"*^°" different motives, drawn to Westminster as their chief Harold, dwelling-place. Eadward loved to dwell under the shadow of the church which he was rearing. Harold saw that London was the fittest spot for the ordinary abode of a King who might at any moment be called to the defence of any part of his Kingdom. Less suited than Oxford to be Advan- the gathering-place of assemblies from North and South, position of the great inland haven of the Thames, the city guarded London. alike by its Roman walls and by the strong hearts of its citizens, was the best centre for operations which might ^ Vit. wist. 254. "Multa et illo itinere et aIih;S creLr5 praescita et praenuntiata sunt. Denique Haraldo palkm testificatus est, quanto detri- mento et sibi et Anglise foret, nisi nequitias morum correctum ire cogitaret. Vivebatur enim tunc pane ubique in Anglia perditis moribus, et pro pacis affluentia deliciarum fervebat luxus." ^ Chronn. Ab. Wig. 1066. " On Hsum geare com Harold kyng of Eoforwic to Westmynstre, to }>am Eastran, be wseron sefter }>am middan- wintran J^e se kyng forlSferde." VOL. III. F 66 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. have to be carried on by land or by sea^ eastward^ north- ward; or southward. Wales was subdued; Ireland was seemingly friendly ; at any rate the danger from both those quarters was comparatively trifling, and the western shore and the western fi'ontier might be left to take care of them- selves. But the whole southern and eastern coast of Eng- land was exposed to the double enemy, and for the defence of the southern and eastern coast London was obviously the best centre. For that part of England which was under the immediate rule of the new royal house, for Harold's own Wessex, for the Earldoms of Gyi-th and Leofwine, the city was almost geographically central. London then became, under Harold, a more constant royal dwelling- Four place than it had ever been before. It had perhaps never festivaTs^^ before happened that four successive festivals of the Church at West- were kept by an English Kins' on the same spot. But minster. r J to t> ^ r Christmas such must havc been the case at Westminster during this Easter ' J^ar of wonders. Gloucester had been forsaken for that i°^ ' 4. great Midwinter Feast at Westminster, in which the Crown Fentecost '=' -' 1066 ; was worn by Eadward on the day of the Nativity and by Christmas . 1066-1067. Harold on the day 01 the Epiphany. Winchester was now forsaken for Harold's one Paschal festival. For Pentecost Westminster was now the usual place, and if King Harold found time to hold a Whitsun Feast at all, it was doubtless at Westminster that he held it. At the next Midwinter Feast Westminster again beheld another master, and her church and palace became the scene of other crowning rites. Thick and fast indeed came the events which caused the creation of Eadward to become, from its very birth, the hearth and home of the English nation. Did Harold It is possible that Harold may have had another, a Chester? secondary, motive, which led him to hold his Festival in some other place than the capital of his former Earldom, the resting-place of his father and of his murdered cousin. Harold had faithfully carried out all the dying wishes of EFFECT OF HAROLDS REIGN ON LONDON. 67 Eadward. Those of Eadward''s Norman friends who were chap. xi. willing to dwell peaceably in the land were not disturbed. Every day of Harold^s reign saw masses and prayers go up from the altars of the West Minster on behalf of the soul of its founder. And Eadward'^s other request, that his widow might keep her royal rank and honours, was car- ried out no less faithfully. Eadgyth, now, in Old-English Eadgyth phrase, the Old Lady, withdrew to that royal dwelling- Chester. place at Winchester which seems, in this age, to have been specially reserved for the widows of Kings. There Emma had spent the last days of her life,^ and there now Eadgyth dwelt with all the honours of her rank, but in all pro- Her ap- bability as no faithful subject of her royal brother. Her affection, sisterly affection was set upon Tostig, and it would even seem that, after Tostig''s overthrow, her sympathies were transferred from the brother who had overthrown him to the invader who might be looked on as his avenger.^ It is possible that Harold might feel inclined to avoid a city whose chief inhabitant was a sister in such a frame of mind. But it may simply be that he found London the best centre for his councils and operations. And we may add that the mere fact of Winchester being assigned as the place of dowry to the widows of Cnut and Eadward shows of itself that the old West- Saxon capital was fast yielding the first place among the cities of England to the great military and commercial post on the Thames. At Westminster then King Harold held his one Easter Easter Feast, and there doubtless he wore his Crown in the same Westmin- kingly state as the Kings who had gone before him. The ^^®^-., Feast implies the Gemot, and of the main subjects of de- 16-23. bate in a Gemot at such a moment we can have little doubt. It would be the King's business to obtain from the assembled nation eveiy help that was needed for the defence of the country. It would be his business to ^ See vol. ii. p. 62. ^ See Appendix K. 68 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. Death of Ordric, Abbot of Abingdon. Januaiy 22. Wulfric Abbot of Ely. 1044- 1065 ? The Abbey held in plu- rality by Stigand. warn his people alike against unworthy fear^ against un- reasonable confidence^ and against that mere slowness of movement,, that shrinking from prolonged and wearying service, which were the besetting sins of Englishmen. It was in short the part of Harold to inspire his people, as far as might be^ with that unconquerable energy which was the distinguishing feature of his own character. But of the acts of that Assembly we have no record. All that we can say is that it must have been at that Easter gathering that the two recorded ecclesiastical appointments of Harold's reign were made. At the time of Eadward's death the great Abbey of Ely was without an Abbot^ and Harold had been only a few weeks on the throne when a vacancy also occurred in the Abbey of Abingdon. To this last house the Earl of the West-Saxons had more than once acted a friendly part, sanctioning and suggesting the benefactions of others, even if he did not directly appear as a benefactor himself.^ Seventeen days after the death of Eadward Abbot Ordric of Abingdon died.^ The appointment of his suc- cessor, Ealdred, a monk of the house, must have taken place at the Easter Gemot. Of the new Prelate we shall hear again during the troubles of the next reign. ^ The appointment to Ely is of more moment, as it plainly sets forth Harold in the character of an ecclesiastical re- former. The last Abbot Wulfric, who is spoken of as a kinsman of King Eadward, had lately died. On his death the Abbey was given to Archbishop Stigand, as an addition to his already large stock of preferment. ^ See vol. ii. p. 42. ^ Hist. Ab. i. 482. Cf. the writs in Cod. Dipl. iv. 200, 228. On the affairs of Ely, see Appendix L. ^ See Hist. Ab. 482 et seqq. There is something singular in the way in which the local writer couples the advancement of the new Abbot with that of Harold — his own local Earl. "Tunc duo subrogati sunt, Haroldus comes scilicet in Regem Anglorum ; et Ealdredus, hactenus exteriorum proeposituram Abbendoniae agens, inibi in abbatem monachorum." He had (p. 486) two names (binomius erat) Ealdred and " Brichwinus." haeold's ecclesiastical appointments. 69 Neither Wiilfric nor Stigand is spoken of as a good chap. xi. husband of* his church's worldly wealth. Wulfric had secretly conveyed some of the lands of the Abbey to his brother Guthmund, and he is described as dying of grief and shame for this sin. Stigand now, we are told, suggested to Harold the appointment of an Abbot. But, with Florence's panegyric before us, we may be in- clined to believe that Harold, now at least become the patron of monks and monasteries, was anxious that his reign should be an sera of ecclesiastical reform. It would be a good beginning to put a stop to the scandal of the Archbishop of Canterbury holding the Abbey of Ely in plurality. Possibly the exhortations of Saint Wulf- stan may have dwelt upon this evil, as upon so many others. We may therefore be inclined to believe that it was Harold who suggested to Stigand, rather than Stigand who suggested to Harold, the appointment of an inde- pendent Abbot. At any rate an appointment was made Tlmrstan by the royal authority, and we cannot doubt that it was Abbot. duly made by King Harold and his Witan at this Easter ^^^^ i°76. Gemot. The new Prelate, Thurstan, whose name proclaims his Danish descent, bears a good character in the local history; he had been brought up in the house from his childhood, and had been well instructed in the learning of the times. By the King's order, he received the abbatial He is benediction from the Archbishop who had made way for him. stigand. Stigand had before been deemed fit to bless an Abbot, though not to consecrate a King or a Bishop.^ The new Abbot's reign was a busy and a troubled one. We shall hear again of him and of his house in the course of the great struggle against the Conqueror. At present he had to deal with adversaries on a smaller scale. Stigand, like many Lands of Ely de- other Prelates on resigning one preferment for another, and tained by especially on resigning one held in plurality, continued, so ^nd ^uth- 1 ci 1 .• mund. ' oee vol. n. p. 454. 70 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. the local writers tell us, to keep a large share of the lands of Ely in his own hands. He made up however in some measure for this fault by the most splendid gifts to the church of Ely in the way of vessels and ornaments.^ With Stigand perhaps it might not have been prudent for the new Abbot to meddle,, but he did his best to recover the lands which Wulfric had conveyed to his brother. Guth- mund was brought to a compromise not unusual in such cases, by which the lands were to revert to the Abbey at his death. But the coming overthrow of England carried the stolen possessions away alike from Guthmund and from Saint ^thelthryth. In the storms which soon fell upon the monastery of Ely, the lands of which Abbot Wulfric had defrauded his brotherhood came into the hands of the Norman Hugh of Montfort.^ The Crown Signs of thosc no longer distant days were already be- by Wiiifam. ginning to show themselves in the heaven above and in the [January earth beneath. Perhaps at that very Easter Feast, perhaps at some yet earlier moment of Harold's reign,^ came the message which told him to his face, what he had all along known in his heart, that his reign over England would not be undisputed. Harold was King, acknowledged as King by every Earldom and every shire in England. He was King, alike by the will of his predecessor, by the choice of his people, by the consecration of the Church, by the hom- age of the Thegns and Prelates of England. But now a ^ Hist. Elien. ii. 41. See Appendix L. ^ lb. 40. " Cititis [before the death of Guthmund] Normannis regnum obtinentibus, miles illorum quidam Hugo de Mumford easdem terras invasit, et hactenus eccleaige detenuit." I cannot however identify the lands in Domesday. ^ I know of no authority for the date of William's first message, except the assertion in Bromton (958) that it was on the tenth day after the death of Eadward. I cannot look on this as enough. I shall therefore treat of the message in connexion with those events to which it belongs in order of subject, if not of time. William's challenge of the crown. 71 voice came proclaiming' aloud to Harold, to England, and chap. xi. to Europe, that another claimed the Crown he wore, and claimed it by an earlier bequest of Eadward, by an earlier homage of Harold himself. The great enemy had at last openly thrown down the gauntlet. Duke William of Nor- mandy had proclaimed himself to all the world as the true heir of Eadward, as the lawful King of the English. The benediction of Thurstan of Ely was the last peaceful event of Harold^s reign. Wars and rumours of wars, challenges and answers between leaders of armies, fill up the six months which still divide us from the last act of the great tragedy. And, if those days were on earth days of distress of nations Appear- and perplexity, days when men's hearts were failing them comet. for fear, they were days too in which the men of those times ^P^^^ were led to deem that the very powers of heaven were shaken. Strange and awful signs, mighty storms, a horror of great darkness at noon-day, are recorded in the chronicles of distant lands among the portents of this memorable year.^ But there was one sign above" all which struck the hearts of all mankind with awe. Men looked to the sky, and there they saw such a token in the heavens as no man had ever seen before.^ Not only over all England, but, as men deemed, over the whole world,^ the sky was ablaze with a mighty mass of flame, which no man doubted was sent to kindle a fire upon the earth. The octave of the Easter Feast haist byt comdta steorra wsere, \>one sume menn hata'5 ))one fexedon steorran. And he aeteowde aerest on bone sefen Letania Major, ^aet ys viii. Kal. Mai." [Monday, April 24.] ^ See Appendix M. ^ Ann. S. Germani, Pertz, iv. 4. ** A vespers usque ad gallicinium," * Tapestry, pi. 7. " Tsti mirant stellam." See Appendix M. ^ Will. Malms, ii. 225. Alberic of Trois-Fontaines, 1066. ^thelmoer, it seems, was a man of mechanical skill, who in his youth had attempted to THE COMET. 73 diction. The star had come to bring tears to many mothers ; chap. xi. he had beheld the same sign in former days, but now it had come to bring a far more fearful overthrow upon his native land.^ The sign was indeed one of awe and warning. Ninety Comet of years before, such another sign had been seen in the heavens, ^'^' and fast on its appearance had followed the troubles of the reign of the martyred Eadward.^ Famines, earthquakes, civil commotions, had followed hard upon the track of the blazing beacon. Only a few years later, so the reckonings of 989. of astronomers tell us, the very comet on which men were now gazing must have come to herald in the great renewal of the Scandinavian invasions, the terrible invasions of Olaf [991-994-1 and Swend, the fight of Maldon and the general ravaging of England.^ Still the message of warning was not neces- sarily a message of despair. Another such token had — not ushered in but closed — the horrors of the year of of 10 17. strife between Cnut and Eadmund ; * it had come as it were to shine over the grave of the English hero, to shine as a beacon lighting the path of glory which opened before the Danish conqueror. So now, some great event was doubtless portended; some mighty ruler was soon to meet with his overthrow ; but who could say whether the fiery sword which hung" over the world was drawn on behalf of Harold or on behalf of William? But from that day forth no man doubted that the sword of the Lord was drawn; no man make himself wings like Daidalos, but who had been hardly more successful than Ikaros, though from another cause. " Ipse ferebat caussam ruinse suae quod caudam in posteriori parte oblitus fuerat adaptare." He remained lame for life. ^ Will. Malms, ii. 225. " Venisti, inquit, venisti, multis matribus lugende ; dudum est quod te vidi ; sed nunc multb terribiliorem intueor patriae hujus excidiiim minitantem." ^ Chronn. Wig. Petrib. Cant. 975. ^ See vol. i. pp. 296-319. * Alb. Trium Font. 5 1 . "Annoioi7. Cometes solito mirabilior in modum trabis maximse per quatuor menses apparuit." He then goes on to speak of the reign of Cnut. 74 THE ELECTION OF HAROLD. CHAP. XI. doubted that that sword could not be quiet, and that it would not return to its scabbard till it had drunk its fill. Summary. We must now turn from that great Easter Feast at Westminster,, and from the portent which must have served to light the Witan of England to their homes. We leave King Harold on his throne, the acknowledged chief of his own people, but with his right challenged by the one man among living princes who could stand forth and defy the chosen of England as an equal and worthy rival. The details and the substance of that challenge form the beginning of another portion of my tale. I reserve them therefore till we have traced out the later actions, the wars and the intrigues, of the great enemy beyond the sea. I have now to sketch the events of years neither few nor unimportant in the history of William, and therein to bring to light one page which I would gladly blot out in the history of Harold. I have now to take up the thread of my Norman history, from the day when William, the guest of Eadward, went back to his own land, already deeming himself the heir of England, to the day when, as the open rival of Harold, he put forth before heaven and earth his claim to the Crown which the choice of England had given to another. 75 CHAPTER XII. THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY.^ IO5I-I066. We left the Duchy of Normandy in the enjoyment of a Recapitula- short season of unusual peace, after the energy of its great history of Duke had for a moment quelled all enemies at home and Normandy. abroad. We saw the Duke himself received as a cherished 1051- guest at the Court of England, during those gloomy months when England, in the absence of her defenders, seemed to have already become a Norman land. We saw him return to his home, clothed, there can be little doubt, in his own eyes, with the character of the lawful heir of the English Crown. We have now to trace out his history and that of his Duchy from the time of his return from his first English sojourn till he again steps upon the field of English history as an avowed claimant of the Kingdom of England. The intervening time fills a space of fifteen ^ There is nothing special to remark on the authorities for this Chapter, which consist mainly of the Norman writers whose names and whose relative importance must be by this time familiar to the reader. I will only remark that it is somewhat vexatious that we have to trust almost wholly to authorities on one side. While we have full narratives from the Norman writers, we have only the most fragmentary statements from any French, Angevin, or Bi'eton source to set against them. And, to an English writer, this is specially vexatious when we draw near to the end of the period, when we have to deal with those personal relations between William and Harold on which the Norman writers are so full, while the contemporary English writers are so completely, no doubt significantly, silent. 76 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. Charactei of the period in Norman history. CHAP. XII. years, years crowded with stirring and memorable events in the history of Normandy. But they are events which_, till quite the end of the period, have no direct connexion with the history of England. It is only in the last stage of the present Chapter that the two streams of our narra- tive must again converge^ at the moment when the two great figures of our drama meet face to face in the memo- rable and fatal visit of Earl Harold to the Norman court. The earlier years of the period are wholly occupied with the affairs of William and his Duchy, his marriage, his eccle- siastical reforms and foundations, his wars against rebel- lious kinsmen within his Duchy and with French and Angevin enemies beyond its bounds. But these things all form part of our story. No part of the life of the great Conqueror is foreign to the history of the Conquest of England. Every blow dealt by William against his restless neighbours or against his jealous overlord formed part of his military schooling for the greatest day of his military life. Every exercise of that political craft in which he surpassed all men made his hand more skilful for the weaving of that masterpiece of subtlety by which,, even more than by his lance and bow^ he knew how to make England his own. Divisions of The period will fall naturally into four divisions. First e perio . ^^j^^g ^iHiam'^s marriage with Matilda of Flanders^ a William's ... marriage, step which was, in itself; of no small moment in Williams's career, and which, as I have already hinted/ supplies some His French most characteristic illustrations of William^s temper. Next 1050-1058. come the wars of William with the King of the French and his allies, those allies being not only the ceaseless enemy of Normandy, the Count of Anjou, but also enemies of William's within his own Duchy and within his own His war ducal house. Thirdly comes the later stage of the Angevin 1061 -1063. ^^^^*' when it became almost wholly resolved into a struggle for the possession of Maine. Lastly, we come to William's ' See vol. ii. p. 293. CHARACTER OF THE PERIOD. 77 Breton campaigns, which, in our point of view, necessarily chap. xii. become a mere adjunct to the great question of the visit ^^^r aml°" and the oath of Harold. I have purposely reserved that the oath of All' Harold. question for this stage of my history. As the date is un- certain, and as the event is recorded by no contemporary English writer, I could find no fitting place for it in the course of my purely English narrative. Recorded only by The oath a Norman writers, it seems essentially a piece of Norman his- rather than tory, and the question of riffht or wrong- is essentially a Nor- ^^ Enghsh •^ -^ ^ *^ ® ♦^ question. man question.^ It has no bearing on the events narrated and discussed in my last Chapter ; it has the closest bearing on the events which will be narrated in later Chapters. Any personal obligations towards William, which Harold Its bearing had contracted or which Harold had broken, formed historv. altogether a personal question between William and Harold. It was a question with which the English nation had in strictness nothing to do.^ They might take it into consideration as a matter of prudence; they had nothing to do with it as a matter of right. If any wrong was done to William, it was done, not by England, but by Harold personally. It might be a crime in Harold to accept the Crown to which he was chosen, but that in no way affected the right of the English people to choose him. The ques- tion then, up to this point, is a Norman question ; it became an English question only when William claimed the English Crown, and put forth the alleged perjury of Harold as one of the grounds of his claim. I have there- fore reserved the consideration of the whole story for the present Chapter. It comes in here as a part of the Norman history, which has no direct bearing on the purely English ^ See St. John, ii. 225 et seqq. But I would not, as I shall presently show, be thought to share Mr. St. John's extreme scepticism on the whole matter, ^ It is indeed quite possible that the mass of people in England knew nothing about the matter. The only statement implying that they did is that of Harold's romantic biographer (Chron. Ang. Norm. ii. 187, 188) which I have quoted and discussed in Appendix C. 78 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. events which have gone before^ but which has the most direct and important bearing* on the combined Norman and English events which are to follow. § 1. The Marriage of William and Matilda. 1049 — 1060. Position of William, at the time of his visit to Eadward, had reached the age of about twenty-four years. The negotiations for 1049. his marriage had already begun at least two years before.^ A marriage into some princely house was an object of no small moment for one in William'*s position. The Bastard_, the Tanner^s grandson, had now abundantly made good his position within his own Duchy, and he had shown to his neighbours that he was one whose borders could not be insulted with impunity. The victor of Val-es-dunes, the avenger of Alen9on, the man to whom the impregnable steep of Domfront had yielded in sheer dread of his wrath,^ already held no small place among the princes of Gaul and of Europe. The rulers of the lands nearest to his own had had abundant means of judging of his prowess. His royal overlord at Paris had witnessed what William could do as an ally, and his restless rival at Angers had felt yet more keenly what he could do as an enemy. Alike in warfare and in internal government, he had shown himself in every way the peer of Kings and of long-descended Dukes and Counts. It remained now to be seen whether A princely the rulers of other European states were ready to receive dedraUe ^^^ ^^ their social peer, and to allow their blood to mingle for him. jff'ii\i the blood of the son of Herleva. His own panegyrist has indeed no doubt on the point. The Duke of the Normans had only to choose his wife at his will from the * See vol. ii. p. 293. ^ lb. p. 289. WILLIAM CONTEMPLATES MARRIAGE. 79 houses of whichever of the neighbouring* princes he thought chap. xii. good. Nay^ distant Kings would have vied with one another in offering their daughters to such a bridegroom.^ Notwithstanding this rhetoric^ we may be allowed to sus- pect that, when the chief men of Normandy urged on their sovereign the prudence of an early marriage^ they thought somewhat of the advantage of fixing the position of William in the eyes of the world as well as of the neces- sity of securing the Norman succession.^ This last object indeed was a matter of paramount importance. Nothing Import- but the life of the reigning Duke stood between his Duchy direct heirs and the repetition of such anarchy as his own early years ^^ William. had witnessed. A bastard could, in strict law, have no heirs but heirs of his own body; and, even setting aside William^s bastardy, it was as hard now as it had been at the death of Robert to say who was the lawful presumptive heir to the Norman Duchy. It was before all things necessary that William should, with all speed, raise up sons of his own to sit on his ducal chair. And it is to the eternal honour of Domestic the young Duke that there was no fear of the rights of William's William's lawful sons being interfered with by the claims ' ®' of any elder but unlawful issue. There was no fear of William''s bride, whoever she might be, having to share her place in his house or in his heart with any unlawful or irregular consort. Alone of all his race, William set an example to all the princes of his time of a domestic life of unsullied purity. He had marked, it may well be, the shame, the sorrow, the anarchy, which had been brought upon ^ Will. Pict. 90. '' Reges de longinquo suas unicb caras filias huic marito voluntarife locarent." "^ lb. 89. "Adeo ut et ejus sobolem, quam soM tum spe fovebant, dominum sibi concordi votorum electione ereare certarent." He goes on to speak of the debates on the subject, ''res ponderosa" as he calls it, and how it was discussed "in frequenti curi^," So Will. Gem. vii. 21 "Jam Duce juvenili robore vigente, transcensis annis adolescentiae, coeperunt optimates ejus de successione prolis cum eo attentitis tractare." 80 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. himself and his country by the youthful error of his own parents, or rather — it might be fairer to say — by the neglect of his father to redeem that youthful error by a later marriag-e. He was determined that no such evils should ever arise from any such error on his own part. No mis- tress, no Danish wife, appeared in William^s days in the palace of Rouen; and this virtue, so unusual in one sur- rounded by all the temptations of youth and power, seems to have become the subject of foolish and brutal jests among the profligate scoffers of his Court.^ The private life of William is a bright feature among the varied traits of his strangely mingled character. In this respect the noblest of women would have been no more than an help meet for him. And such an one he found in the wife whom he sought with such characteristic pertinacity, and who, in the end, shared his cares and his glories for more than thirty years. His coun- The counsels of the wise men of Normandy both commend a pi'^sscd William to marry, and further suggested the marriage expediency of selecting for his bride the daughter of some Matilda of neighbouring prince.^ The weighty matter was long and anxiously discussed, but at last either the counsels of his advisers or his own inclination disposed William in favour of the daughter of the reigning Count of Flanders. It may be that, if the English Court had been adorned with a princess, he would have sought, by a marriage with a * Will. Malms, iii. 273. *' Praeter caeteras virtutes, prsecipufe in prima adolescentia castitatem suspexit, in tantum ut public^ sereretur nihil ilium in femina posse. Verumtamen ex procerum sententi^, matrimonio addictus, ita se egit ut pluribus annis nullius probri suspicione notaretur." He then goes on to mention, without believing, an absurd story which I shall have to speak of elsewhere. I do not know on what authority genealogists and antiquaries call the famous William Peverel of Domesday a natural son of William : I know of nothing to that effect in any ancient writer. See Appendix N. ^ Will. Pict. 90. "Consiliis itaque de matrimonio discrepatur .... ac affines habere quos confines potissimtim placuit," HE CHOOSES MATILDA OF FLANDERS. 81 daughter of Eadward^ to strengthen the hopes which he may chap. xii. have ah'eady begun to cherish in the direction of Eadward^s Crown. But no such help was to be looked for in the house of his childless cousin ; still, as I have already hinted, it is possible that one of the merits in his eyes of the wife whom he did choose was that she sprang by direct, if only by female descent, from the blood of ^Elfred.^ It is possible that other princesses might have been found who had the same amount of connexion with English royalty,^ but it would have been hard to find one who united a descent of this kind with the great European position which attached to a daughter of Baldwin. The laureate of William taxes his powers to the uttermost to set forth the greatness of the prince who was thought worthy to become the father- in-law of his hero. No line was so exalted as that of the Descent Count of Flanders, or as, in contempt of the geography of counts of his own time, he wishes rather to call him, the Satrap of ^^^i^^®"- the Morini.^ The lowly origin of Lyderic the Forester* was forgotten among the splendours of a house which, by successive intermarriages, could boast of a descent from the Kings of Wessex, Italy, and Burgundy, and from the Imperial stock of the Great Charles.^ The Flemish Count * Se^ vol. ii. p. 304. ^ Among the many foreign brothers-in-law of ^thelstan, it is certain that the two most prominent, Otto the Great and Duke Hugh of Paris, left no posterity by their English wives. But a search among the princes of the time might have revealed some descendants of Eadgifu and the other sisters. The line of the Karlings of La6n was not extinct. ^ Will. Pict. 90. " Uti k Satrapis Morinorum, quos modern! Flandros appellant," &c. This is somewhat in the style of Richer, our classical companion in my first volume. * See vol. i. 278. Cf. ii. 272, 273. ^ The first Count Baldwin married Judith, daughter of Charles the Bald, widow of our ^thelwulf ; Baldwin the Second married ^Ifthry th, daughter of Alfred ; Arnulf the Old married Adela of the Carolingian house of Vermandois ; his son Baldwin married Matilda, daughter of King Conrad of Burgundy ; Arnulf the Young married Susanna, daughter of King Berengar of Italy; but the mother of the reigning Count, though of princely, was not of royal birth, William of Poitiers (90) is therefore VOL. III. Q 82 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII was in name a vassal of the Roman Emperor ; in truth he was the stay and glory of his counsels. Rarely did he con- descend to visit the Imperial Court ; when he stooped so far, Counts_, Marquesses, Dukes, the mighty Primates of the German Church, even Kings themselves, looked on him Their with wonder and admiration.^ Without accepting all this dignity!^" rhetoric, it is certain that, next to a marriage into the house of an anointed King, no connexion could have been found more exalted than that which William sought to form with the prince whom his contemporaries spoke of as the mighty Import- Marquess. 2 No description could be more apt. It was their ^ ^^ their position as Marquesses in the strict sense of the border word, as princes holding' a border land between France and position. ^ '^ Germany,^ as vassals of both Crowns, but no very humble subjects of either, that the Counts of Flanders owed their special greatness among European princes. Their land, with its sea-board and its rivers, was marked out by nature as the land where commerce and civic greatness were to take a firmer hold than in any other land north of the Alps.^ justified when he says that Baldwin " k Regibus Galliae atque Germaniae natales deducebat;" but I cannot follow him when he goes on to add, "nobilitatis etiam Constantinopolitanae lineam attingentes." ^ Will. Pict. 90, " Stupuerunt mirantes eum Comites, Marchiones, Duces, tum Archiprsesulum alta dignitas, si quando prsesentiam ejus, rari hospitis, Imperatoria cura promeruit . . . nomine siquidem Romani Imperii miles fuit, re decus et gloria summa consiliorum in summS. necessitudine. Reges quoque magnitudinem ejus et venerati sunt et veriti." * In the Annales Blandinienses and Formoselenses (Pertz, v. -26, 36), the Count of Flanders appears as '^Balduinus potentissimus," " poten- tissimus Marchisus." ' Will. Pict. 90. ''Vigebat eo tempore Teutonibus collimitans ac Francis, eminensque potentiS,, preecipuus eorum, Flandrensis Marchio Baldwinus." * The Free Cities of Germany obtained a higher degree of independence than those of Flanders, and those of them which became members of the Swiss League of course became more independent still. Yet, except the Hanseatic towns, none of them rested their greatness so purely on commerce as the Flemish cities, and the Flemish cities were distinctly more democratic ^ in their spirit than any others. Ghent is something quite different either from the Teutonic Rome at Bern or from the Teutonic Carthage at Liibeck. I THE COUNTS OF FLANDERS. 83 And its hardy, sharp-witted, and industrious inhabitants, chap. xn.. near kinsmen of our own Nether-Dutch stock, were no less Cjiaracter of the renowned in warfare than they were in the peaceful arts of people. commerce and manufacture. And we must not forget that, in those days, the Flemish dominion, and, with it, the Low-Dutch speech, reached far to the south of the narrow frontier which is all that successive French aggressions have left to the modern Kingdom of Belgium. The Marquess of Flanders was a near neighbour of the Duke of the Normans. Between them lay only the small Counties of Ponthieu and Boulogne, the representatives of the old disputed land of Herlwin of Montreuil.^ On every political ground, no alliance could be more desirable for the young Duke than one which brought him into close and friendly connexion with this mighty house. Of the reigning Count, Baldwin the Fifth, Baldwin of Baldwin Lisle or Yssel,^ Baldwin the Deionnaire, we have often 1036-1067. heard in other parts of our history. We first heard of him as a rebel against his own father, and as being brought to reason by the potent influence of Duke Robert.^ We next heard of his constant reception of English and other exiles, and of his wars wdth the Empire, in which England bore a part against him.^ In those wars his Norman panegyrist represents him as invariably successful.^ We have seen how far this description departs from the truth of history ; but in after times, when the might of Bome and Germany Baldwin's was represented by a woman and a child, it is said that rebellion Baldwin g-ained concessions which he was not likely to ^?^? recon- _ "^ ciliation, gain at the hands of Henry the Third.^ With his other 1054-1056. * See vol. i. p. 227. Cf. 548. ^ In the Chronicle of Lambert of Saint Omer, 1067 (Pertz, v. 66) he is distinguished as '' Baldwinus Comes Insulanus" from his son '^Baldwinus Montensis." So in the Continuation of Sigebert, vi. 433. ^ See vol. i. p. 519. * See vol. ii. p. 97 et seqq. ^ See the passage quoted in vol. ii. p. 99. ^ He rebelled again in 1054 (Herm. Cont. in anno, Pertz, v. 133. Bernold, G 2 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. His Regency in France. 1061. I05I' His daughter Matilda. William seeks her in mar- riaofe. overlord, the Parisian King, he had formed the closest tie of affinity; his wife was Adela^ the daughter of King Robert and sister of the reigning King Henry .^ In after timeS;, on the death of Henry, Count Baldwin was called on to act as Regent or Protector over the realm of his wife^s young nephew Philip.^ His marriage with Adela gave him two sons_, Baldwin and Robert, both of whom afterwards reigned over Flanders.^ Judith_, who a few years later became the wife of Tostig the son of Godwine, is often spoken of as his daughter, but she was in truth his sister, the child of his father's old age,* and probably in years the contemporary of his own children. But, if the sister of Baldwin shared the viceregal seat of Northumber- land, his daughter was fated to yet higher honour within our island. Matilda, the child of Baldwin and Adela, in after days to be crowned at Westminster as Lady of the English, was the princess whom the advice of Williams's wisest counsellors selected as the fittest bride for their young Duke. One might be curious to know how far this choice was at all prompted in the beginning by personal inclination on William's part. It is certain that Matilda won and re- tained William's deepest affection, that he had to struggle hard to obtain her hand, and that he made her a faithful and loving husband throughout their joint lives. But modern researches have shown that there was a mystery about the marriage which no one would have guessed from the fluent narratives of the Norman writers. They enlarge on ib. 427). On the War, see Annales Elnonenses Majores (Pertz, v. 13). The reconciliation by the agency of Pope Victor is asserted in the Chronicles of Sigebert (Pertz, vi. 360) and Ekkehard (vi. 198) ; on the terms see Art de Verifier les Dates, iii. 4. ^ See vol. i. pp. 519, 562, I shall have to speak of this marriage again. ^ See Will. Pict. 90, and below, § 3. ^ On their history see Lambert, 1071 (Pertz, v. 181). Will, Malms, iii, 256 ; iv. 373. * See vol. ii. p. 134, and Appendix N. MATILDAS FORMER MARRIAGE. 85 Matilda's beauty,, on her accomplishments and her virtues.^ chap. xn. But, just as the Encomiast of Emma keeps out of sight the fact that his heroine was a widow and a mother at the time of her marriage with Cnut/ so the panegyrists of William keep out of sight the fact, revealed to us by a com- parison of several documents and incidental statements, that Matilda's Matilda was the mother of a son and a daughter of whom niarriage William was not the father.^ Some of them further conceal, ^^^.^ , ' children. what others have the honesty to allow, that the marrige of the Duke was objected to on canonical grounds, and that an interval of some years took place between the first pro- posal of marriage and the actual celebration of the rite. The language of William's laureate would lead us to believe that Count Baldwin brought his daughter across the Nor- man frontier almost as soon as William's ambassadors had reached his court with William's proposal.* A more minute examination reveals the fact that the marriage was first thought of before the murder of Beorn, but that the lovers 1 049-1 053. were not joined together by the Church till the year of the death of Godwine. The scandal of a later age told the tale how one Brihtric, Legend of a Thegn of Gloucestershire, was sent as an ambassador from ^ "Corpore valdfe elegantem animoque liberalem," says William of J u- mieges (vii, 21). So Wace, who wrongly calls her mother Constance (9640-9642) ; " Mahelt out non, mult bele e gente." William of Poitiers attributes her excellences to the good training which she had received from her mother Adela ; " Enutrierat autem prudens et sancta mater in fiM quod muneribus paternis multuplo prseponderaret." He then goes on to extol the royal family of France, to which he is not always so loyal, and .he commits the blunder of calling Robert "filius et tie'pos Regum." ^ See vol. i. p. 454. ^ On this disco vei-y of Mr. Stapleton and on other points connected with the marriage, see Appendix N. * William of Poitiers indeed would almost make one think that Baldwin set off with his daughter to meet William as soon as he heard that William wanted a wife, and that they were married without more ado. William of Jumieges (vii. 21) seems to make the marriage follow immediately on the embassy, though he afterwards mentions the objections made on the ground of kindred, on which William of Poitiers holds his peace. 86 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. the King of the English to the court of Bruges_, how the daughter of the Count cast an eye of love on the tall stalwart Englishman^ how she offered herself to him in marriage, how he refused her advances_, and how in later times Matilda, the Lady of the English, found means of ample revenge for the slight which he had offered to Matilda, the Flemish princess. William, we are told, not considering, it would seem, that such hatred might be deemed to savour of love, easily granted his wife^s prayer for the imprisonment of Brihtric and for the transfer of his lands to herself.^ The tale is evidently mythical, but it preserves the kernel of truth that William was not the Gerbod, first lovc, or indeed the first husband, of Matilda. She husband of ^'^^ been already married to Gerbod, a man of distinction Matilda, jj^ Flanders, whose title was taken from his hereditary office as Advocate of the great Abbey of Saint Bertin at Her Saint Omer. To him she had borne two children, a son GerboTand ^^^^ ^^^^ ^^^ father's name, and who, in after times, when Gundrada. hig step-father filled the English throne, held and resigned the great Earldom of Chester, the special home of the house of Leofric.2 The other child of Gerbod and Matilda was a daughter, Gundrada by name, who became the wife of William of Warren, and whose tomb and its inscription have long been among the favourite objects of antiquarian research.^ That tomb was placed in a minster of her own rearing, which has now vanished from the earth, in that great Priory of Saint Pancras at Lewes, whose walls 1264. sheltered the King and the enemies of England in the next great struggle for her freedom. For a long while * See the tale in the Continuator of Wace, ap. Ellis, ii. 55. The only groundwork for the story seems to be the fact that Matilda held certain lands which had belonged to a Brihtric — there were several of the name. 2 Ord. Vit. 522 A, 598 A. His description is "Gherbodus Flandrensis. " ' See Ellis, i. 507. The inscription beginning " Stirps Gundrada Du- cum," has often been copied, and has no doubt misled many. The " Duces" are of course the Counts of Flanders, not those of Normandy. HER CHILDREN BY GERBOD. 87 Gundrada was looked on as a daughter of William him- chap. xii. self/ but there is no doubt that both she and her brother Gerbod were the children of Matilda by her first husband. The question now arises^ which I shall discuss elsewhere,^ whether the elder Gerbod was dead at the time of William's first courtship^ or whether the delays and difliculties which beset the marriage of William and Matilda were not^ partly at leasts caused by the necessity of procuring a divorce be- tween the Flemish princess and her first husband. The balance of evidence and of probability seems to me to be Matilda decidedly in favour of the belief that Matilda was now a a widow, widow. But at any rate it is certain,, though no one would have guessed it from any of the writers who record the marriage^ that the bride of William was already the mother of two children by another man. The whole story forcibly reminds us of the marriage of Cnut and Emma^ except thatj while Emma was clearly many years older than Cnut^ Matilda, married no doubt to Gerbod when very young, must have been about William's own age.^ Another point is plain that, even if the marriage was first thought of as a matter of policy, William's affections were soon firmly fixed upon the woman whose hand he was seeking. No otherwise can we explain the desperate pertinacity with which he pursued his object in defiance of difiiculties to which a merely political suitor would soon have yielded. The scheme of the marriage must have been first broached Beginning . of Wil- soon after the war of Domfront and Alengon. For in the Ham's year following" that war the marrias'e met with the most courtship. •^ =• ^ 1048-1049. formidable of all obstacles. It was forbidden by an express ^ She is assumed to be such even by Sir Francis Palgrave (iii. 254), after the appearance of Mr. Stapleton's paper. ^ See Appendix N. ^ Her parents, Baldwin and Adela, were married about 1027, See Appendix N. 88 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. The Council of Rheims. 1049. Enforce- ment of the eccle- siastical laws of marriage. command of the common Father of Christendom, speak- ing at the head of an Assembly which had a real claim to command no small share of the reverence of Western Europe. The good Pope Leo had gathered together at Rheims that famous Council of some of whose acts I have had occasion to speak earlier in my history.^ For one of those moments which come few and far between in the annals of nations and Churches^ the two lights of the Christian firmament shone in friendship side by side ; the two swords no longer clashed against each other, but were drawn at the same bidding to chastise the same offenders. At the summons of a Pope and an Emperor each alike worthy of his throne, clerks and laymen had assembled from distant lands, among which England had not been slow to send her representatives. ^ The abbatial minster of Saint Remigius had been hallowed by the Pope himself; and a number of Princes and Prelates were next called to account by the assembled Fathers for various breaches of the law, canonical and moral. There, as we have seen_, a Norman Bishop, a member of the mightiest house in Normandy^ had to defend himself on a charge of sacrilegious destruction of his own cathedral.^ There a Prelate of the Ducal Burgundy, Hugh of Langres, was deposed from his episcopal office for various acts of cruelty and adultery.* But Pope Leo did not shrink from smiting offenders yet more exalted, and among them he struck the most grievous of personal blows at the Duke of the Nor- mans himself. One special object of the Council was the stricter enforcement of the Churches law of marriage, a point on which the princes and great nobles of Gaul would seem just then to have been specially lax. Among the canons of the Council, two are aimed specially at ^ See vol. ii, p. 112. 2 j]^ ^ jj^ 3 j^, p jg^ * Ann. Divionenses, ap. Pertz, v. 41. Labb^, Concilia, xi. 1407 et seqq. Chron. of Auxerre, ap. Labbd, Biblioth. i. 293. THE MARRIAGE FORBIDDEN BY POPE LEO. 89 offences of this kind, and the Pope and the assembled chap. xii. Fathers at once proceeded to launch the censures of the Church against offenders of every degree. A whole train of princes were summoned before the Synod, and some of them were actually excommunicated. Among them Censures were the two princes who held the border lands between nounced Flanders and Normandy, two princes of one of whom we p^JJ^^^.^^^"^ have already hSard but too much in our history, and of Princes, both of whom we shall hear again. Eustace of Boulogne, the brother-in-law of King Eadward, and Ingelram, seem- ingly the son of the reigning Count of Ponthieu, were both smitten with excommunication on charges of incest the evidence for which seems to be no longer forthcoming. Theobald of Chartres, the son of Odo the old enemy of Normandy, was also called to account on a charge of putting away his lawful wife without cause. ^ And it Baldwin was now that an order went forth which touched the to give his two mightier neighbours of all these princes. Count ^^^7?f_®^ Baldwin of Flanders was forbidden to give his daughter Ham. in marriage to William the Norman, and he, William, was forbidden to receive her. Such is the only descrip- tion vouchsafed to the great Duke. The other princes receive their usual titles of honour, but it would almost seem that any such respectful mention was still looked on as not due of right to the grandson of the Tanner. * Labbd, Concilia, xi. I412. The two canons run ; *'xi. Ne quis inces- tuosae conjunction! se copularet. xii. Ne quis, legitinia uxore derelicta, aliam duceret." Presently comes the passage quoted by Mr. Stapleton ; ''Excommunicavit etiara Comites Engelrannum et Eustachium propter idcestum, et Hugonem de Braina, qui legitimam uxoreni dimiserat et aliam sibi in matrimonio sociaverat. Interdixit et Balduino Comiti Flan- drensi ne filiam suam Willelmo Nortmanno hupttii daret, et illi ne earn acciperet. Vocavit etiam Comitem Tetbaldum, quoniam suam dimiserat uxorem." I do not know what were the offences of Ingelram (who was not yet Count) or of Eustace. Theobald had put away Gersendis, daughter of Herbert Wake-the-Dog of Maine, of whom we shall hear more anon. In the Art de Verifier les Dates, ii. 615, Theobald's wife Gersendis seems to be confounded with his sister the wife of Hugh son of Herbert. 90 THE LATER IIEIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. At the date then of the Council of Rheims, the marriage had not yet been celebrated, though William^s first pro- posals must have been already made to Baldwin,, and must have been favourably listened to by him. The Papal pro- hibition seemingly stopped the marriage for four years. Alleged The ground of objection was, according to all the evidence ''onsfi Ti ~ ffuinity of which we have on the subject, the usual ground of nearness •^d m"^ of kin. Yet it is by no means easy, either'^to trace up the tilda. pedigree of William and Matilda to a common ancestor, or to see any reasonable ground for the prohibition on any of the usual ecclesiastical theories of affinity. But it certainly seems more reasonable to suppose the existence of some unrecorded hindrance of this kind than to believe that William sought the hand of Matilda, and that her father favoured his suit, at a time when she was actually the The wife of another man.^ At all events, the marriage was delayed, delayed, and the moment when it was actually celebrated Coinci- coincides so remarkably with one of the most memorable dence of . . . its celebra- exploits of Williams's countrymen in another part of Europe tiiTcap- ^ ^^^^ ^^ ^^ hsLYd to believe that the one event had not some tivifcy of influence on the other. The Normans were now pressing 1053-1054. their conquests in the South of Italy, and Pope Leo did not deem it inconsistent with his duty to endeavour to check their progress even by force of arms.^ His own prowess, tried in earlier warfare, the lofty stature and heavy swords of his German auxiliaries, availed him not.^ ' See Appendix N. ^ The whole story is given in the hexameters of WilUam of Apulia, Muratori, v. 259 et seqq, Cf. Milman, iii. 35 et seqq. ^ William's lines on the stature of the Germans are well known as being quoted by Gibbon (x. 257 ed. Milman). His description of their swords and manner of fighting is less familiar, and is worth quoting, as showing how much the Teutonic warfare was the same everywhere (p. 260, C. D) ; " Nam nee equus docte manibus giratur eoruni. Nee validos ictus dat laucea, praeminet ensis. Sunt etenim longi specialiter et peracuti Illorum gladii, percussum k vertice corpus CAPTIVITY OF LEO. 91- The Pontiff became a captive in the hands of enemies who chap. xii. knew as well how to make the most of an advantage as ^fth^the^ if William himself had been their leader. And in truth Normans of Apulia. there was one in their ranks with a head well nigh as His de- , 1 • 1 n • 1 J i. fe'At and cunniDg to devise, and an arm well nigh as strong to imprison- execute, as the head and the arm of William himself. For ^^ent. the Norman host was commanded by the sons of Tancred of HautevillCj and among them^ as yet the least renowned Policy of among his brethren, stood the man before whom Caesars as wiscard. well as Pontiffs were to quail. ^ There stood the founder of the Apulian Duchy, the remote founder of the Sicilian Kingdom, the man who did less only than William himself to make the Norman name famous and terrible throughout the world. The true spirit of Robert Wiscard appears in the demeanour of conquerors who bowed in the lowliest reverence to their holy captive, and who at the same time knew how to win from him what might pass as a lawful in- vestiture of all their conquests. Such were the beginnings Origin of that Norman Kingdom of the South whose fate forms so Sicilian striking a contrast to that of their northern conquest, ^^^"g^io"™- Thus arose that Sicilian realm, whose Crown shone the brightest among the Pleiads which decked the brow of Scindere saepe solent, et firmo stant pede postquam Deponuntur equis, potitis certando perire Quam dare terga volunt, magis hoc sunt Marte timendi, Quam dum sunt equites ; tanta est audacia gentis." This exactly describes an English array before Cnut introduced the axe instead of the sword (see vol. i. pp. 300, 430, 577), and the implied panegyiic of William is the parallel of the implied panegyric of Guy of Amiens. See vol. ii. p. 128. ^ See vol. i. p. 171. So Will. App. 261 D ; ''Robertus et ingeniosus Semper celsa petens, et laudis amans et honoris. Si contingebat sibi palma vel arte vel armis, JEiqnh ducebat, quia quod violentia ssepe . Non explere potest, explet versutia mentis." Compare the wild account of Robert Wiscard in Benedict of Peterborough (ii. 200 Stubbs), where he is transferred to the reign of Henry the First. 92 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. xTi. the Wonder of the World^^ and which^ in its lowest depth of degradation, we have seen merged in a realm of happier i860, omen at the mere approach of the wonder-worker of our own day. The mar- It was while Leo was thus kept in the power of the cdebratid ; Normans of the South that William seems to have thought Baldwin \^\^^j^ ^jjg hour was at last come when he might venture to brings his ... . . daug^hter trample under foot the prohibition of the Council of Rheims. loe, " It may be that the reverential gaolers of the Pope had con- trived to wring from him some concession to the prince whom^ if they did not look on as their sovereign^ they must at least have honoured as the most renowned of all who bore the Norman name. Or it may be that William and Baldwin deemed that^ during such a collapse of the Papal authority, any breach of ecclesiastical discipline might safely be dared, in the hope that an absolution after the fact might be won from some successor less austere than the saintly Leo. At all events the marriage was celebrated while Leo was still in durance. Count Baldwin himself led his daughter through Ponthieu to the Norman frontier. She was there met by the bridegroom who had so long and so patiently waited for her. The marriage ceremony was performed, by what daring priest or Prelate we know not, in the church of the ducal town which stood nearest to the Flemish border. At Eu, under the shadow of the old fortress of Rolf, in the minster which had been lately reared by the bounty of Count Wil- liam and his half-canonized wife,^ Duke William received the hand of the bride whose possession had been forbidden to him by the judgement of Pope and Council. From the border castle the new Duchess was led in all fitting state Matilda's to her husband^s capital. The metropolitan city received arRoueu. ^^^ Lady of Normandy with every expression of joy. Any doubts as to the canonical validity of the marriage * See vol. i. p. 171. * On the Counts of Eu, see below, p. 117. CELEBRATION OF THE MARRIAGE. 93 were likely to give way before the charm of Matilda^s chap. xii. presence, before the mere novelty of seeing the Court of Rouen, after an interval of perhaps thirty years/ once more adorned by the grace and dignity of a reigning Duchess. But, in an age and country where the religious spirit was Opposition so actively at work as it was in Normandy in the days of j^arrfao-e William, it was not likely that any breach of canonical law, withm ^ . the Duchy. even on the part of the sovereign, should pass unchallenged. Men were found who feared not, perhaps in the spirit of the Baptist, to rebuke the prince who had dared so direct a breach of the orders of so revered an assembly as the Council of E-heims. And the opposition was led by one from whom, according to all the accounts of his character which have been handed down to us, we should not have looked for any special zeal either for ecclesiastical discipline or for Christian morality. At the head of the Norman Censure Church now stood William^s uncle Malger, a man who, as edTy ""^ I have already said,^ is described to us only in the darkest Archbishop •^ -^ *^ ^ _ Malger. colours. Yet almost the only act recorded of him is one which, in the life of a saint, would undoubtedly have been set down as one of the most striking proofs of his sanctity. The Primate of Normandy did not shrink from reproving his • prince, and that prince the Great William, for the breach of canonical law which he had committed in marrying his kinswoman. He at least threatened, if he did not actually publish, a sentence of excommunication against the princely offender.^ Was his motive in so doing simply disloyalty ? His pro- bable motives, ^ Thirty-six years if we count from the death of William's grandmother Judith in 1017 ; twenty-seven if we count from the death of Richard the Good in 1026. The question turns on the position of Richard's second wife Papia. See vol. ii. p. 181. ^ See vol. ii. p. 210, ^ Will. Malms, iii. 267. "Ferunt quidam esse arcanam depositionis caussara ; Matildem, quam Willelmus acceperat, pi'oximam sibi sanguine 94 • THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. Was he, as one account seems to imply, in league with his brother the Count of Arques, to overthrow William's throne V Or are we to suppose that Malger was really stirred up by a holy zeal to denounce a breach of eccle- siastical law, however exalted the offenders? Such is the equally distinct statement of another of our authorities, less open than those who are hardest upon Malger to the influ- Nature of ences of flattery or prejudice.^ After all, if we come to ao-ainst^^^^ distinguish the crimes alleged against Malger from the Malger. declamation which is used about them, they are not crimes of any enormous dye. They are the follies and vices which could hardly fail to be expected from a young prince thrust into a great ecclesiastical office to which he clearly had no real call. He is allowed not to have been deficient in the learning of the time.^ But he was fonder of hunting than became an Archbishop, a charge which seems a little hard in an age when an extravagant devotion to brutal sports was not deemed inconsistent with the highest saint- liness.^ He kept too splendid a table,^ and wasted the wealth, and even the ornaments, of his church in reckless largesses.^ All this is likely enough, and the existence of fuisse. Id, Christianae fidei zelo, Malgeriuin non tulisse, ut consanguineo cubili fruerentur, sed in nepotem et comparem excommunicationis jaculum intentS,sse." ^ William, or Orderic, in the death-bed narrative (657 B), puts the two together; "Non multb post alia mihi gravissima adversitas oborta est. Patrui namque niei, Malgerius Rothomagensis Archiepiscopus et Guillelmus frater ejus . . . me velut nothum contempserunt," etc. ^ See the passage of William of Malmesbury just cited. ^ Will. Malms, iii. 267. "' Is erat litteris quidem non mediocriter cultus." This is admitted even by William of Poitiers, 116 ; " Scripturarum arcana intelligentiae literalis oculo colligere non indoctus fuit." * lb. " Pro natalium conscientid professionis oblitus, venationibus et avium certaminibus saepitis justo intendebat." ■'' lb. " Gazas ecclesiasticas conviviis profusioribus insumebat." So Will. Pict. 116; " Mensas equidem nimitim suflBcientes, nimium nitidas, prsebere." ® Will. Pict. 116. "Quam pietaa plurimorum omando ditavit, ille spoliando attenuavit ecclesiara ; non sponsus ejus vel pater dicendus, sed gravissimus dominus vel rapacissimus prsedo Largiendo laudeiu emere OPPOSITION OF ARCHBISHOP MALGER. ^5 his son Michael shows that he was no strict observer of chap. xii. ecclesiastical rule on other points.^ And we can well believe that Duke William, most of whose own faults were * of a kind exactly opposite to those of his uncle, was diligent in rebuking one who certainly departed widely from his ideal of a Prelate.^ But when these intelligible and pro- bable charges are mixed up with vague stories of robbery and other unnamed crimes/ we begin to have our doubts. We are told also that successive Pontiffs had refused him His lack the pallium, as being unworthy of his office/ so that Rouen paiuum. was now in much the same case as Canterbury. He also neglected to attend more than one Council at Rome to which he was* summoned.^ All Rouen and all Normandy, we are told, were utterly weary of their Primate and his doings.^ All this may well have been so ; yet the excommunica- Malger's tion, or threatened excommunication, of the Duke, more probably especially when we remember that the fact is left out by ^o"®^^- those who draw the worst picture of Malger, suggests that there may have been another side to the story. amabat, specie liberalitatis prodigus. . . . Nee enim modum posuit largitioni donee sedes metropolitana omni fere ornamento caruit et thesauro." * Ord. Vit. 566 D. Michael was, when Orderic wrote, an old man in great honour with Henry the First. He was " probus miles et legitimus." Wace (9707) gives him several children, and seems to make them born after his deposition. Michael is " hom mult ^norez, Michiel de Baines [al. Bayeux] apelez." ^ Will. Pict. 116. " Saepenumero monitus atqiie castigatus privatim atque publice domini sui, juvenis et laici, sapiente diligentia." So Will. Malms, iii. 267 ; " Crebrb conventus, expostulante nepote patruelis [patrui ?] offensas." . ^ lb. " Sequuntur multoties largitionem rapinae. Preeterea molestua infamiae ejus odor diffundebatur ob alia crimina. Sed a ratione alienum ducimus in vitiis publicandis immorari," etc. * lb. "Pallio nuraquam est insignitus quod . . . manus Romani Ponti- ficis, mittere ['<] solita, ei denegavit ut minus idoneo." So Will. Malms, u. s. ^ lb. 117. "Apostolici mandate ssepius ad Romanum concilium accitus, renuit ire." William is just now very zealous for the Holy See, quite unlike the Gallicanism of Rudolf Glaber. See vol. ii. p. 275. ^ lb. "Sane pigebat Rotomagum, pigebat cunctam Normanniani, arehi- praesulis." 96 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. The excommunication does not read like the act of one who was utterly dead to the duties and decencies of his office. It reads more like the act of one who^ con- scious that he had greatly neglected those duties and decencies, was anxious to make amends for past offences by an act of saintly zeal and boldness. It is the sort of act which may well have been meant as the first step William's in an amended career. And there is strong ground for tion at hira. believing that it was this over zealous discharge of eccle- siastical duty, quite as much as any of his ecclesiastical or moral offences,, which finally brought down on Malger the wrath of his nephew and sovereign. It would be altogether of a piece with William^s conduct in greater matters still, if his personal indignation, and the complaints and entreaties of Matilda, were mixed up with a real Malger de- feeling of the unfitness of Malger for his office.^ At all the Council Gvcnts, two years after Williams's marriage, long before ofLisieux. ^^^^ marriage was recognized at Rome, Malger was formally deposed from his see by a joint exercise of the ducal and the pontifical authority. Ermenfrid, Bishop of Sitten, a Prelate who seems to have been specially em- ployed to represent the Roman See beyond the Alps, was 1062, now sent into Normandy, as he was in after years twice '°'°' sent into England. William gathered a Council at Lisieux, in which all the Bishops of Normandy, under the presidency of the Papal Legate, sat in judgement on their erring metropolitan. Malger was unanimously con- demned, and the Duke decreed his deposition from his see.2 He was banished to the Isles of the Cotentin, so * Will. Malms, iii. 267. "Quum irae adolescentis uxoriae querelas acce- derent, excogitatas occasiones quibus persequutor peccati sede pelleretur.'' It is clear that Malger had partizans. 2 William of Poitiers (117) does not name the Legate. He says only "Princeps .... deposuit patruum in publico sanctae synodi, Apostolici vicario cunctisque Normanniae episcopis, juxta canonum auctoritatem, sen- tentiam dantibus unanimi consensus." The List in Mabillou (Analecta, ii. 439) names Ermenfred (see vol. ii. p. 461), and mentions the place, DEPOSITION OF MALGER. 9^ familiar to us as the Channel Islands.^ His life there is chap. xii. said to have still given scandal; 2 if Malger's ebullition ^^[*^^^^" of zeal against William was really the beginning of his death. own reformation^ nothing was more likely to throw him back in the work of amendment than the consequences which his over diligence had brought upon him. One of the charges against him was that of dealing with a familiar spirit/^ a charge which has been ingeniously explained by the supposition that the learning of Malger took in mathematics and astronomy^ and that, as in the case of Gerbert and many others, the reputation of practising magic was the penalty of knowledge beyond his age.^ It was his custom to sail about among the islands, and some- times to visit the mainland of the Cotentin. One day, on Lisieux, William of Jumifeges (vii. 24) makes Malger resign his see ; " Eo tempore Malgerius Archipraesul Rotomagensis desipere coepit, et insipientia ductus Archipraesulatum Duci reddidit." The strong regale, or rather ducale, of all our accounts should he noticed. See vol. ii. p. 209. ^ William of Poitiers does not mention the banishment of Malger, but it is spoken of by most of our other authorities. Will. Gem. vii. 24. " Dux autem Malgerium in insult quas dicitur Ghernervia retrusit." The list in Mabillon (ii. 439) says, " Dedit postea illi quamdam insulam in Constanti- niensi pago in mari sitani." Roman de Rou, 9703 ; " Es isles vint de Costentin, Lk fu e vist tresqu' h la fin." On the "Isles of the Cotentin" see vol. i, p. 211 et seqq. ^ Mabillon, u. s. " In qua, [insula] pluribus annis, non quidem ut decuit, vixit." Wace, as a Jersey man, is much fuller on this part of the story. ^ Roman de Rou, 9714 et seqq. He has ''un deable priv^ " called Toret or Toreit, who was always at his beck and call. What is Toret ? Pluquet makes it a diminutive from Thor. Sir F. Palgrave (iii. 276, 277) speaks of French antiquaries " who discover in the name Thoreit the ex- jclamation Thor-aie, an invocation of Thor the Hammerer." Pluquet at least does not. (On Thor-aie see vol. ii. p. 257.) Sir Francis goes on, " But the vocable is pure hoch deutsch, and however gained or bestowed, simply signifies Folly." Of two improbable explanations Pluquet's seems to me the less improbable. See Mr. Thorpe's amazing note to Lappenberg, Norman Kings, p. 86, where he mixes up Malger's familiar spirit with Ralph of Tesson's war-cry. See vol. ii. p. 257, and Taylor's Wace, p. 20. * Histoire des Archevesques de Rouen (Rouen, 1667), p. 253. The author, a Benedictine father, is disposed to let Malger off more easily than most people. VOL. III. H 98 THE LATER KEIGN OP WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. entering the vessel, his supernatural power enabled him to prophesy that one of the company would die that day. He knew not however who was the doomed person, nor \)j what means he would perish. His prediction was fulfilled in him- self: he fell overboard and was drowned. His body was afterwards found among the rocks, and he was buried at Cherbourg.^ Malger A Prelate of a very different stamp from Malger sue- SllCCGGClGQ. by Mau- cceded him on the metropolitan throne of Rouen. William Hirfife and ^^^^ ^^^ ^^^^7 learned that the high places of the Church character, could not be rightly turned into mere provisions for the younger members of sovereign houses. He determined to give the Norman Church a thoroughly worthy chief pastor, and in his choice he overlooked all prejudices of family and even of nation. This willingness to recognize the claims of merit in strangers from every land has been already spoken of as one of the marked features of the Norman national character. ^ The new Primate, Mau- rilius, was a man of foreign birth, one who had seen much of various parts of the world, and who seems to have made choice of Normandy as his adopted country. His His birth Career in many respects reminds us of that of Lanfranc, Rheims, with this difference, that the earlier years of Lanfranc *f'^^?'"?^f^ were spent in a character wholly lay, while Maurilius at i^tttticii. had first entered the ecclesiastical calling as a secular priest. He was a Frenchman by birth, born of a noble house in the neighbourhood of Rheims.'^ But his higher ^ Mabillon, ii. 439. "Posteaver6, quo autem divino judicio ignoratur, in mari submersus eat." Wace tells the story at length, 9727 et seqq. But there must, as Prevost says, be some mistake in the name Win9ant, which suggests the Picard Witsand rather than any haven of the C6tentin. ^ See vol. i. p. 170. Will. Malms, iii. 246. "Omnium gentium benign- issimi advenas sequali secura honore colunt." ^ Mabillon, ii, 439. "Nobili prosapiS, ex Remensi pago exortus, et in ejusdem civitatis ecclesia. educatus, inde in Leodicensi ecclesiS. omni libera- lium artium peritiil imbutus." Orderic (567 C) calls him " genere Magun- tinus." He must have confounded the birthplace of Maurilius with the LIFE AND CHARACTEE OF MAURILIUS. 99 education was Teutonic. He first studied at home at chap. xii. Rheims, then at Liittich^ and lastly, as the reward of his proficiency in learning, he was raised to the dignity of '^ Scholasticus/"' Chancellor or Lecturer, in the cathedral He be- COIUGS church of Halberstadt, one of the richest secular founda- < * Scholas- tions in the Saxon Church.^ But the zeal of Maurilius soon ^a^ber^* aspired to a straiter life than that of a secular canon. He stadt. left his stall at Halberstadt, he betook himself into Nor- He be- mandy, and there became a monk in the Abbey of Fecamp.^ monk at That g-reat house, the favourite foundation of Richard the -^^^f^^P* ^ o •' 1001-1031. Fearless, and one of the objects of the misapplied bounty of our own Eadward, was now flourishing in all the odour of youthful sanctity.'^ The secular canons, who had been its Secular first inmates, had, under the rule of Richard the Good, the j^^camp. patron and father of monks, made way for regulars of 99o- the Benedictine order, under the rule of their first Abbot, Bene- the renowned and holy William, a native of Italy, and of j^qj^]^^ illustrious birth. He it was who received the Chancellor of ^°°^- Halberstadt as one of his spiritual household/ till, like Maurilius Lanfranc,^ the neophyte sought for a still more complete camp, and place of his preferment, Halberstadt being, at all events, in the province of Mamz. ^ Mabillon, ii. 440, " Halverstatensis [mark the Low-Dutch form] ecclesise Scholasticus efFectus est, qui locus in Saxoni£i ditissimus habetur." On the office of the Scholasticus, compare Adelard at Waltham, vol. ii. p. 443. ^ This first profession at Fecamp rests on the authority of the list in Mabillon, Orderic (u. s.) mentions only his second sojourn there. But does not a profession at Fdcamp under the Italian Abbot William form a kind of transition between Halberstadt and the Italian hermitage ? ^ I reserve some notice of the history of Fecamp (see vol. i. p. 218), and of the connexion of the )nonastery with England, for a more appro- priate place in the fourth volume. * The profession of Maurilius at Fecamp would naturally come within the time of Abbot William, 1001-1031. After so varied a career, we can hardly fancy him less than fifty at the time of his appointment to the Archbishoprick, and we want several years for each of his metamorphoses between Halberstadt and Eouen. His first sojourn at Fecamp, his hermit life, his Abbacy at Florence, his second sojourn at Fdcamp, might well take up twenty-four years among them. ^ See vol. ii. p. 226. H 2 ' 100 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII, becomes a hermit in Italy. He is made Abbot of Saint Mary's at Florence by the Marquess Boniface. [1027- 1052.] He returns to Fecamp. Abbot John. 1031-1080. Maurilius Arcli- bishop of Rouen. 1 055-1069. isolation from the world, and, with the leave of his Abbot, Maurilius left Fecamp for some undescribed part of Italy, where he led a hermit^s life, supporting himself by the work of his own hands.^ His sanctity at last drew on him the attention of the famous Boniface, Marquess of Tus- cany, the father of the more famous Countess Matilda. This prince constrained him, much against his will, to undertake the government and the reform of the great monastery of Saint Mary in the city of Florence. He laboured there for some years, and brought his monks into some degree of order and good living. But the elder members of the brotherhood, accustomed to the lax govern- ment of former Abbots, proved too much for his powers of reformation. 2 He resigned his dignity and returned to Fecamp, where he lived for some years as a private monk, under the new Abbot John. This Prelate was another Italian^ high in favour alike with the Duke of the Normans and with the King of the English, who, like so many others of his order, found it to his advantage to cross the sea and visit the saintly Eadward face to face.^ Under his rule the ex- Abbot of Florence lived in peace, till he was called by Duke William to the highest place in the Nor- man Church. He held more than one Council of his Pro- vince.* He also finished the rebuilding of the metropolitan ^ Mabillon, ii. 440. " Eremi cultor solitariam vitam ducens opere manuum vixit." ^ Mabillon, u. s. So Ord. Vit. 567 C, who adds a characteristic Italian trait; "In urbe Florenti^ monachili ccenobio Abbatis jure pnefuit, et exosus transgressoribus pro rigore disciplinse venenum in potu sibi pro- pinato deprehendit." ^ Ord. Vit. U.S. "Tempore Johannis Abbatis compati'ioti:e sui Fiscan- num venit." But the local accounts make John a Lombard. Orderic might have assumed that an Abbot at Florence must be an Italian, but how could this be reconciled with his description of Maurilius as " Magun- tinus"? Of. Neustria Pia, 223, * Bessin, 47-49. Pommeraye, 71. Mabillon, ii. 441. "Adstante Wil- lelmo Normannorum Duce, postea Anglorum Rege, cum omnibus suffra- ganeis suis, concilium in l^ptluim.-KTPngi ecclesia de castitate conservandd et MAURILIUS ARCHBISHOP OF ROUEN. 101 Church, which had been begun by his predecessor Robert, chap. xii. and had been possibly interrupted during the unthrifty reign of Malger. The church of Maurilius, which has wholly made way for the works of later architects, was He com- . . , , pletes and consecrated three years before the invasion oi England, consecrates in the presence of all the Bishops of his Province, and (^atiiTdral. of Duke William himself.^ He survived this great cere- 1063, mony six years, and died in the full odour of sanctity, having seen his sovereign and benefactor for three years on the throne of England. The deposition of Malger, the succession of Maurilius, The mar- . liage of and the men to whom the career of the new Primate w iiiiam introduces us, serve well to illustrate that great religious ^[J^^ ^^'^_ movement which was now going on in Normandy,^ and sured by j_j fin iT£i n c • which was beyond doubt greatly fostered by the wise appointments which William had now learned to make to the great ecclesiastical offices in his gift. But the unlucky Archbishop was not the only churchman who felt that it was dangerous to administer rebuke to one of William^s temper. A greater than Malger or Mau- rilius also took upon him the function of Micaiah, and, strangely enough, he found, through a temporary dis- grace, a path to a higher place in the favour of his prince. Lanfranc, now Prior of Bee, already high in Hispresent the Duke^s favour and a sharer in his inmost counsels,-^ William. perhaps took upon him personally to rebuke his sovereign caeteris sanctorum patrum institutionibus, pastorum incuria negligenter postpositis, viriliter restituendis religiose celebravit." Everything bears witness alike to the ecclesiastical supremacy of the Norman Dukes and of the persf)nal zeal of William in all ecclesiastical matters. ^ See vol. ii. p. iSi. ^ See vol. ii. pp. 213, 214. ^ Vit. Lanfr. ap. Giles, i. 287. "Ad administranda quoque totius patriae negotia summus ab ipso Normannorum Duce Willelmo consiliarius assu- mitur." Allowing for the natural exaggeration of a panegyiist, there seems enough to imply a very close relation between William and Lanfranc, See vol. ii. p. 227. 102 THE LATER KEIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. Papal Interdict on Nor- mandy ? William's incapacity to bear personal insult. for his uncanonical marriage ; at all events he was known to have spoken his mind freely and openly on the subject.^ The writer whom we have to follow for the share taken by Lanfranc in the affair adds that all Normandy was laid under an interdict by Papal authority as a punish- ment for the sin of its prince.^ The contemporary writers so evidently avoid the whole subject that their silence counts for less than it otherwise would; but it would certainly be strange if so memorable an exercise of Papal authority as the interdiction of divine offices throughout the Duchy found no one to record it except the local chronicler of Bee. But, however this may be^ we need not doubt that Lanfranc spoke out on the subject in a way which was far from agreeable to the Duke and probably still less agreeable to the Duchess. The darker side of William^s character now stands forth. He was already stark beyond measure to the men who withstood his will.^ With all his great qualities^ he could not endure anything which savoured of personal insult, least of all when that insult touched his wife as well as himself. The stern executor of justice, the reformer of the Norman Church, is for- gotten for a while in the man who mutilated his prisoners at Alen9on,* and who, years after, burned Mantes to punish a silly jest of its sovereign. Lanfranc had also enemies at hand, who did not fail to stir up the mind of the Duke against him.^ The vengeance taken by "William ^ Vit. Lanfr. i. 288. " Hujus tarn improvidse jussionis caussam agunt, quod idem Lanfrancus contradicebat nuptiis filise Comitis Flandrise, quam ipse sibi Dux copulaverat in matrimonio, quia proximo carnis consangui- nitate jungebatur." So Chron. Becc. 198. '^ lb. " Unde auctoritate Romani Papae tota Neustria fuerat ab officio Christianitatis suspensa et interdicta," So Chron. Becc. u. s. Wace (9659) makes Malger pronounce the interdict ; " Mangier ki tint I'Arceveskie Sor Willame fe sor sa moillier. Mist Normendie tute en uie Andui les fist eacumengier." ' See vol. ii. p. 169. * See vol. ii. p. 287. ' Vit. Lanfr. 287. " Quorumdam etiam accusationibns delatorum Dux in eo vehementer amaricatus." LANFIUNC OPPOSES THE MARRIAGE. 103 was cruel, one might almost add, cowardly. For the fault chap. xn. or virtue of one member he punished the whole society, and, as commonly happened in such cases, the punishment fell more heavily on the dependants of the society than on the society itself.^ William ordered that Lanfranc He orders should at once be dismissed from the monastery and j^e^t of banished from Normandy. But he also ordered the Lanfranc, 'J and burns ravaging and burning of part of the possessions of the the "Park" Abbey.2 He was obeyed in both orders. Lanfranc set Abbey. forth from Bee, to seek his fortune once more, and he set forth in a guise almost as lowly as that in which he first appeared in the presence of Herlwin. But his journey was not a long one. By chance or by design, he met Reconcilia- William on the way j'"^ the visible change in his fortunes, Lanfranc aided by his own ready wit, procured him an audience of 5:!^^, the Duke, and in that audience terms of reconciliation were readily agreed on. Lanfranc was again admitted to William^s fiill favour, confirmed by the kiss of peace.'* ^ See vol. ii. pp. 218, 236. ^ Vit. Lanfr. 287. " Mandat ut monasterio exturbetur, patria discedat, Lanfrancus. Nee motus animi sui hac vindicta sedare valens, mandavit juris monasterii villam, quae Parcus dicitur, flammis excidi." On the word Park, see Earle, Parallel Chronicles, p. 323. ^ In the story in Lanfranc's Life (287 Giles), the banished Prior sets out on a horse which went on three legs, because the house had none that was better ("quia melior non habebatur, tripes equus quarto pede inutili illi tri- buitur'), and accompanied by one servant. He meets the Duke ; '' Protinus quk ille discedebat Duci obvius venienti appropinquans." The meeting may have been accidental, or Lanfranc may have gone by a way where he was likely to meet William, but I cannot think, with Dr. Hook (ii. 93), that * 'Lanfranc directed his steps to Rouen, where he probably had been sum- .moned to appear before the duke. " The lame horse — the narrator quite enters into the joke — bows its head, and his rider salutes the Prince ; " Equo per singulos passus caput ad terram submittente, dominum salutat." William at first turns away, but presently listens. Lanfranc begins with a joke ; he is obeying William by going out of his dominions as fast as he could ; he would go faster, if the Duke would give him a better horse. William laughs, and asks whether any criminal before had ever ventured to ask a present of his judge. The Duke is fairly won over, Lanfranc makes his speech, and ail is soon settled. * Vit. Lanfr. 287. '< Gratissimi mox succedunt amplexus et oscula." 104 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. The damage done to the estates of the House of Bee was more than made good.^ But Lanfranc was required in return to withdraw his opposition to the Duke''s marriage^ Lanfranc and even to make himself the champion of his cause. A becomes p it t x j -j i? the chani- ^^^^ ^T scrupulous houour, accordmg to modem ideas oi pionofthe j^onour, would not have accepted such an office. But maiTiage. ^ ^ modern ideas of honour differ widely from monastic ideas of conscience. There was nothing in the terms agreed to by Lanfranc at which the most tender and the most formal conscience could be offended.^ Lanfranc had denounced the marriage as sinful^ and he was not called on to with- draw that denunciation. He might still look upon the act as sinful, but he pledged himself to do his best to procure that the sin should be forgiven. The marriage was at most a breach of a canonical restriction, and it was not beyond the power of the Apostolic See to heal such a breach even after the fact. Lanfranc then was to go to ^ Vit. Lanfr. 287. "Multo etiam cum augraento restituenda promit- tuntur quae Dux nuperrime devastari jusserat." ^ See this point discussed by Dr. Hook, ii. 94. A quite different account of the reconciliation of Lanfranc to the Duke, or rather of his first intro- duction to him, is given in two passages of William of Malmesbury, De Gest. Pont. 116 6 and 136, one in the Life of Lanfranc himself, the other in that of Herfast, afterwards Bishop of Thetford. William's Chaplains excite him against Lanfranc, because he had mocked the ignorance of one of their number. The Duke orders him to leave Normandy, but he goes to Court, obtains an interview with the Duke, and speedily wins his favour. In the second account it appears that the Chaplain mocked at was Herfast himself, who came to Lanfranc's school with great pomp. Lanfranc then makes a mock of his ignorance ; "Ex prima colloquutione intelligens quam prope nihil sciret, abecedarium ipsi expediendum apposuit, ferociam hominis Italica facetiS, illudens." The order for banishment then follows. Lanfi-anc, some- what oddly, goes to court to ask for provisions for his journey ("Quum ad curiam commeatum petiturus venisset"). Then comes the story of the lame horse, and the Duke is won over to Lanfranc, mainly through the interces- sion of William Fitz-Osbern. There is no mention of Lanfranc's opposition to the marriage. This story about the Chaplain may be true ; but it can hardly be doubted, first that Lanfranc was already known to the Duke, secondly that the main ground of offence was the opposition to the marriage. LANFRANC SUPPORTS THE MARRIAGE AT ROME. 105 Rome, and to use all the power of his learning and chap. xii. eloquence to obtain from the Pontiff a dispensation which would make good the marriage which had been irregularly contracted.^ If these transactions between William and Lanfranc Negotia- took place soon after the celebration of the marriage, the ^jth tiie negotiations with the Roman Court must have been pro- Ji^^^"^" longed indeed. William^s anxiety to keep his wife would 1054 ? seem to have proved as fertile a source for canonical dis- putations as the anxiety of Henry the Eighth to get rid of his. It is at least certain that the matter was not finally settled till the Pontificate of Nicolas the Second, the Pontiff* who yielded so readily to the threats of the English Earl Tostig/ and who found it equally expedient to yield to the milder persuasions of the orator of Pavia. But Nicolas did not ascend the Papal throne till six Succession years after the marriage ceremony at Eu. It is quite .y. ' possible that stern and resolute Popes like Victor the Second. Second and Stephen the Ninth refused to grant any gtephen concession, and it is probable that the scruples of Lan- ^^^ Ninth. ... . 1057-1058. franc, perhaps those of "William himself, would forbid any Benedict application to the usurper Benedict. ^ But, in any case, ^^® ^^"*^^- Nicolas granted the required dispensation. Lanfranc Nicolas visited Rome, both on the Duke's errand and on his own. ^^^^ Second. The theological dispute with Berengar of Tours* was still 106 1.] ffoinff on, and in the second Lateran Council, held under Second the presidency of Nicolas, the heretic publicly retracted council. his errors.^ Lanfranc was again present as the champion ^P'^^ ^3. af orthodoxy,^ and his performances in this way may well Lanfranc have inclined Pope and Council to listen favourably to his ^^^^" •^ «^ opposes petitions on other subjects. He pleaded the cause of his berengar; ^ Vit. Lanfr. 289. " Lanfrancus . . Romano venerat . . ut ageret pro Duce Normannorum et uxore ejus apud Apostolicum." ^ See vol. ii. p. 458. ^ lb. 431. * lb. 116. ^ He however retracted back again. Vit. Lanfr. 289. See Milman, iii. 51. " See vol. ii. pp. 116, 227. 106 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. and pleads for Wil- liam and Matilda. Nicolas grants the dis- pensation. Lan franc returns to Normandy. 1059-1060, sovereign firmly and effectually, and he seems to have used language nearly as plain-spoken as Tostig did two years later. William, he argued, was determined not to give up his wife;^ the Pope would therefore do well to yield, for ecclesiastical censures — the interdict is clearly intended — would fall quite as heavily on the innocent as on the guilty.-^ Another argument is also put into Lanfranc's mouth, that the pride of Count Baldwin would not endure to have his daughter returned on his hands — he might have added with a second brood of children, and those too of doubtful legitimacy. War would certainly break out between Normandy and Flanders, and it was the duty of the common Father of Christendom to hinder, as far as in him lay, the shedding of Christian blood. To these various arguments the mind of Pope Nicolas yielded. Lan- franc at last returned with the wished-for dispensation which at last ratified by the highest ecclesiastical authority the marriage which had been, in ecclesiastical eyes, rashly and irregularly entered into six years before. ^ Condition of the dis- pensation. Founda- tion of the two Abbeys at Caen, So great a favour however was not to be granted, except on condition that the sinners should atone for their fault by worth}'' works of penance. The Duke and the Duchess were each to rear and endow a monastery for religious persons of their respective sexes."^ Another * Vit. Lanfr. 289. "Nam Dux puellam [Gerbod is, as usual, forgotten] quam acceperat nullo pacto dimittere veUet." ^ lb. "Loquutus cum Pap^ Nicolao ostendit quia ejus sententia illos tanttim gravabat, qui eos nee conjunxerant nee separare poterant." ^ Will, Gem, vii. 26. "AVillelmus Dux, dum h, quibusdam religiosis [no mention of Lanfranc personally] ssepiiis redargueretur, e6 quod cognatani suam sibi in matrimonium copulfisset, missis legatis, Romanum Papam super hS,c re consuluit. At ille sagaciter considerans qu6d, si ilivortium fieri juberet, fort^ inter Flandrenses et Normannos grave beilum exsurgeret, maritum et conjugem a reatu absolvit." Vit. Lanfr. 289. "Hoc audiens et verum esse advertens summus Pontifex, dispensatione habita, conjugium concessit." * Will. Gem. u.s. " Eis poenitentiam injunxit. Mandavit enim, ut ab eis duo crenobia conderentur, in quibus pro ipsis ab utioque sexu Deo THE MARRIAGE CONFIRMED AT ROME. 107 account adds that four foundations of still more direct chap, xii. usefulness, hospitals namely for the sick, blind, and aged, were also to be established in four of the chief towns of Normandy, at Rouen, Bayeux, Caen, and Cherbourg.^ The discharge of the former part of the Papal command caused the creation of two of the noblest architectural monuments of the Duchy. The two stately Abbeys of Caen arose as at once the monument and the atonement of the irregular marriage of William and Matilda. Each ( haracter of those noble piles retains to this day large portions of buiidln^H. the original work of its founder, and each exhibits a character of its own, a sort of personality received from its founder's hand. The church of Matilda, the Abbey of Matilda's the Holy Trinity, the first to be begun, the last to be the Holy brought to perfection, bears witness, we may say, to the Tnmty, feminine impatience of the Duchess, to her anxiety not sedul6 preces ofFerentur." Vit. Lanfr. 289. " Eo tamen modo quatentis Dux et uxor ejus duo monasteria construerent, in quibus singulas con- gregationes virorum ac mulierum coadunarent, qui ibi sub norma sanctae relligionis, die noctuque Deo deservirent et pro salute eorum suppli- carent." William of Malmesbury (iii. 267) would almost seem to have looked on the foundations as a voluntary expiation, like the pilgrimage of Swegen ; " Postmodiim, provectioribus annis, pro expiatione sceleris, ilium sancto tStephano Cadomis monasteriura sedificasse, illam beatae Trinitati in eodem vico idem fecisse, utroque pro sexu suo personas habitantium eligente." On the history of Saint Stephen's, T must refer to two excellent local works, "L'Abbaye de Saint -Etienne de Caen, par C. Hippeau," Caen, 1855 (M. Hippeau is also known as the editor of the first complete edition of Garnier's Life of Saint Thomas), and "Analyse Architecturale de I'Abbaye de Saint-Etienne de Caen, par G. Bouet," Caen, 1867, a book distinguished by the writer's characteristic caution and minute accuracy. ^ Roman de Rou, 9665 ; "Li Dus por satisfacion, As meshaigniez, as non poanz, Ke Deus Ten face veir pardon, As langoros, as non veanz, E ke I'Apostoile cunsente A Chieresborc et a Roem, Ke tenir poisse sa parents, A Baieues et k Caem ; Fist cent provendes establir Encore i sunt et encor durent A cent povres paistre h vestir, Issi come establies furent." On the blind hospital at Caen, see Hippeau, p. 4. Were persons admis- pible whose eves had been put out by the Duke's own authority ? 108 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. Its con- secration. June 1 8, 1066. William's church of Saint Stephen, begun 1064 ? conse- crated 1077. to delay the work of atonement for her fault. Her church was so far completed as to be ready for consecration in the year of the great crisis of her husband^s life, and its solemn hallowing forms an incident which will again claim our attention even in the midst of William^s preparations for the invasion of our island.^ But the church then hallowed seems to have been a mere fragment, simply so much as was necessary for the devotions of the sisterhood ; the greater portion of the present fabric belongs to a some- what later age. But enough remains of Matilda's own work to show that the building was carried on in the full spirit of her original design. No contrast between two build- ings so nearly alike in plan and style can be more striking than the contrast between the minster of William and the minster of Matilda. William was no more inclined to hurry in this undertaking than in any other undertaking of his life. His wife hastened to consecrate a fragment ; but William knew how to bide his time as much in a work of architecture as in a work of war or politics. Eleven years later/ William and Lanfranc, now promoted to be the ^ In William's charter of 1066 (Gallia Christiana, xi. 59-61. I have to thank M. Chatel, the Archivist of the Department of Calvados, for the reference), he distinctly says that " honestissima conjux mea Mathildis, nobilissimi Ducis Flandrensis Balduini filiam .... construxit basilicam," and goes on to record its consecration on June i8th. The charter in Neustria Pia, 658-661, is of 1082. He there says "ecclesiam . . . coaedifi- cavimus." Either it was still unfinished, or the nave has been rebuilt. It is only the eastern part which can be Matilda's work. ^ This was the great year of consecrations in Normandy. See vol. ii. pp. 212, 222. The consecration of Saint Stephen's is distinctly placed in this year by Orderic, 548 D. At Bee Lanfranc himself officiated (Will. Gem. vi. 9), but at Caen the ceremony was performed by the ^Metropolitan John. I gather from what goes before in Orderic that William was present at Caen, though he was not at Bee. But the Chronicle of Saint Stephen itself (Duchbsiie, 1018) places the ceremony in 1073. Other dates given arc 1 08 1 and 1086 (see Neustria Pia, 625, Bouet, 15, 16). One cannot doubt that 1077 is the right date for the main co: secration, and that the other dates, if correct, refer to some smaller ceremony. The western towers (of course not the upper portions) nmst have been .idded soon after the church was finished. Their style is that of the church, and the masonry shows 1 I FOUNDATION OP THE ABBEYS OF CAEN. 109 Caesar and the Pontiff of another world,^ were present at chap. xii. the consecration of the great Ahbey of Saint Stephen, perfect from east to west, save only that the addition of the western towers was a later work, and was probably 1086. celebrated with a second feast of dedication. And that Character mighty pile, perhaps the noblest and most perfect work (jonqueror of its own date, shows us the spirit of the Conqueror impressed ' ^ -^ on his impressed on every stone. The choir has given way to building. a later creation; but the nave of William and Lanfranc is still there,^ precisely such a nave as we should expect to arise at the bidding of William the Great. Erected at the moment when the Romanesque of Normandy had cast aside the earlier leaven of Bernay and Jumieges, and had not yet begun to develope into the more florid style of Bayeux and Saint Gabriel, the church of William, vast in scale, bold and simple in its design, disdaining orna- ment, but never sinking into rudeness, is indeed a church worthy of its founder. The minster of Matilda, far richer, even in its earliest parts, smaller in size, more delicate in workmanship, has nothing of that simplicity and grandeur of proportion which marks the work of her husband. The one is the expression in stone of the imperial will of the conquering Duke ; the other breathes the true spirit of his loving and faithful Duchess. But, though the completion of William^s minster was Beginning delayed till a much later date, yet, according to the custom foundation of the founders of monasteries,^ the society itself, furnished 0/ Saint •^ Stephen.s. no doubt with a temporary church and other temporary 1064 ? buildings, was established as soon as possible after the that they were designed from the first, though not built at the same time as the nave. This would quite agree with the date of 1086. For the con- secration of a steeple see vol. ii. p. 437. ^ See vol. ii. p. 222, and the verse of Abbot Baldwin in Duchesne, Rer. Franc, ii. 257 ; ''Qui Dux Normannis, qui Caesar prsefuit Anglis." ^ Allowing, of course, for the , reconstruction of the clerestory and the addition of the vault. ^ See vol. ii. p. 442. 110 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. receipt of the Papal rescript. The monks of Saint Stephen already dwelt in their suburb beyond the walls of Caen, and the care of their founder had already given them the most famous man in his dominions for their ruler. In the same year in which the sister church was dedicated^ in the same year in which England was invaded, the house was fit for at least the temporary accommodation of its new ruler. Lanfranc Lanfranc, the Prior of Bec^ was called to the office of Abbot June it;^ ^^ ^^® rising house. It was fitting that the man who had 1066. wrought the reconciliation between the Duke and the Holy See should receive the dignity which came into being as the fruit and seal of that reconciliation. Lanfranc long resisted ; ^ he had no wish to encumber himself with the cares and responsibilities of a post which was designed to hold a high place among the Norman Prelacy. His learned retirement at Bee was far more to his taste. But the will of Duke William was not to be withstood^ either by those to whom he would give or by those from whom he would take away. Lanfranc became the first Abbot of the great Anselm, house of Saint Stephen. In the office which he vacated at Monk of' ' Bee he was succeeded by one no less renowned than him- PH r ° 66? ^^^^' ^ ^^^ years before the foundation of Saint Stephen's^ Ai>bot of another wanderer from the South had found his way to the Bee 1078 ; Arch- holy shelter of Bee, and had become one of the spiritual Cante!-burv household of Abbot Hcrlwin. Anselm of Aosta, the pro- 1093-1109. foundest of metaphysicians and divines,, the father of all Christian theology since his time, had heard of the fame of Lanfranc, and he had left his home and his heritage to sit at his feet as his scholar. He soon, by the counsel of Lanfranc himself and of Archbishop Maurilius, became not only his scholar, but his brother in the monastic pro- fession. He now succeeded him in his office of Prior j^ he ' Will. Gem. vi 9. " Tarn doniiiii quam Normanniae primatura supplica- tione coactus." I accej)! Orderic's date, but tlie Chronicle of Bee (Giles. 19;) places the appointment in 1062, ^ C'hron. Bee, 197 Giles. PROMOTION OF LANFRANC AND ANSELM. Ill lived to succeed their common father Herlwin in tlie ahbatial chap. xii. chair of Bee, and at last to succeed Lanfranc himself on the throne of Augustine. We have now reached quite another E & ^ policy, in order to act for once as a generous and honour- able neighbour and suzerain. It was only natural that every advance which was made by the lord of Rouen, whether in the way of external greatness or of in- ternal prosperity, should be felt by the lord of Paris as Greatness a blow dealt against himself and his kingdom. We may of Nor- mandy perhaps better understand the greatness of Normandy in Ster times ^^^ d^J^ of its independence, if we look at some of the signs of the greatness which it retained after two centuries and a half of subjection, after having long served as the chief battle-ground between England and France. In the days of Lewis the Eleventh, Normandy, far from being a third part in extent, was in wealth and importance a third part of the kingdom into which it had been merged, and it furnished a third part of the revenue of the Parisian Crown. The great object of every enemy of the Parisian Kingdom was to wrest Normandy from its grasp. No blow could be so great as to give even a qualified inde- pendence to the great province which cut oiF the city which was the cradle and kernel of the Kingdom from Its import- all communication with the English seas. There was no the English object on which the enemies of France, English and ffundian ^urgundian, were more strongly bent, than on the separa- Wars. tion of Normandy from the French Crown. There was no sacrifice which a French King would not make rather than surrender the noblest province of his Kingdom. The last 1421. dying injunction of the great English conqueror of France was, at all risks, at all sacrifices, to keep Normandy in full GREAT AND ABIDING IMPORTANCE OF NORMANDY. 115 possession.' One main object of the great Burgundian chap. xn. rival of France was to give Normandy a Duke of her ^"^ ^' own,2 even though that Duke was himself a member of the royal house of France. And_, whatever we say of the Spirit of wish of the Englishman^ the wish of the Burgundian was indepen- certainly met by a strong vein of local feeling in Normandy ^emainfng- itself. Even in those times, Norman patriotism still held i" the fif- . . . . , teenth that Normandy was too great for simple incorporation with century. France,, and that so great a Duchy ought not to be without its Duke.'^ On the other hand, there was no sacrifice from which French policy so instinctively shrank. Lewis the Eleventh, who at least knew his own interests, was willing to surrender anything rather than make that one great sacrifice. He would give up Champagne, even Aquitaine, far greater in extent than Normandy, anything rather than the precious dominion itself.* And, if the extended France indepen- of the fifteenth century could so little afford to see Nor- mandy mandy separated from its body, even though it was to to France"^ form an appanage of one of its own princes, how far more threatening must a practically independent, and often hos- tile, Normandy have been to the infant France of the eleventh century, when Champagne and Anjou were the fiefs ^ Monstrelet, i. 3246 (ed. Paris 1595). " Vous charge," says Henry the Fifth, " sur tant que vous povez mesprendre, que tant que vous vivrez, ne souffrez h, faire traictd avecques nostre adversaire Charles de Vallois, ne autres pour chose qu'il advienne, que la Duch^ de Normandie ne luy [to his son] demeure franchement." ^ Phil. Comines, i. 15 (vol. i. p. 71, ed. Godefroy 1723). "La chose du monde qu'il desiroit le plus, c'estoit de voir un Due en Normandie ; car par ce moyen il luy sembloit le Roy estre affoibly de la tierce parti^." See the whole history of the grant and reconquest of Normandy, cap. xii-xv, and Kirk, Charles the Bold, ii. 338 et seqq. ^ lb. i. 13 {vol. i. p. 64). " Et a tousjours bien sembld aux Normands, et fait encores, que si grand' Duch^, comme la leur, requiert bien un Due ; et, h dire la verity, elle est de grand' estime, et s'y leve de grands deniers." So, in the same chapter, Lewis says, " que de son conseulement n'eust jamais bailie tel partage h, son frfere, mais puis que d'eux mesmes les Normands en avoient fait cette npuvellet^, il en estoit content. " * Phil. Comines, ii. 9, 15 (vol. i. pp. 116, 137). Kirk, i. 272, 334,525. T ^ 116 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP, XII. Norman rebels con- stantly- supported by France and Anjou, of princes well nigh as powerful as tlieir overlord, when Aquitaine was, in all save a nominal homage, a foreign land? Independent Normandy, flourishing under its illustrious Duke, was as sharp an eye-sore to Paris as ever Aigina was to Peiraieus.^ As he who held Demetrias, Chalkis, and Akrokorinthos was said to hold the fetters of Greece,^ so he who held Eu, Cherbourg, Honfleur, and Rouen, might truly be said to hold the fetters of royal France. The King of the French then, throughout this period, is the arch-disturber, powerfully helped on occasion by his now loyal vassal the Count of Anjou. We shall see both of them advance, step by step, from giving shelter and comfort to Norman rebels to giving them active help in their warfare, and from giving them active help in their warfare to formal invasions of the Norman land at the head of their own armies. Revolt of The first revolt against William after the war of Busac. Domfront and Alen9on is wrapped up in great obscurity. Itf'i ^^® ancient writer alone records it; among modern writers, some pass it by unnoticed, while others recount it with a singular amount of confusion.^ But there seems reason to believe that, at the beginning of this period, at some time after the affair of William of Mortain,'* the Duke was disturbed by a revolt of another kinsman of his The Counts own name at the other end of his Duchy. Duke Richard the Good had granted to his half-brother William the castle and county of Eu, the old border-fortress of Rolf.^ Castle of That famous spot, known in modern times as the last Eu. home of lawful royalty in France, was marked by a castle, ^ Arist. Rhet. iii. lo, X-fjIXTjV Tov Ileipaiews. Kal UepiKXris rrjv Mlyivav a -n • Richard of princely descent_, Jttichard oi Huglevine^ a son oi rapia_, a Hugleville, daughter of Richard the Good. She had married beyond the limits of Normandy. Her husband was Gulbert^ Advocate of Saint Valery in Ponthieu, a name soon to become so famous in Norman history. The Ponthevin dignity continued in the elder branch of the family; but Richard, the second son of Gulbert and Papia^ had received an establishment in the land of Talou^ and he now stood firmly by his cousin the Duke^ while nearly the whole of the surrounding country was hostile.^ With him no doubt stood his son^ the younger * This feudal scruple, which really seems the only intelligible explanation of William's conduct in leaving the most important operations to others, comes from William of Malmesbury (u. s.) ; " Simul quia sciebat Regem Francorumjampridem, nescio qu^ simultate, sibi infensum, ad opem obsesso ferendam adventare ; namque praedicandi moderaminis consilio, quamvis justiorem caussam habere videretur, cum eo decernere ferro cavebat, cui et pro Sacramento et pro suifragio obnoxius erat." Henry the Second felt the like scruple at the siege of Toulouse in 1159, but Thomas of London, then the worldly Chancellor, thought otherwise; " Vana superstitione et reverentia Rex tentus consilio aliorum, super urbem, in qua esset dominus suus Rex Francipe, irruere noluit ; dicente in contrarium Cancellario, quod personam domini Rex Francorum ibi deposuisset, co quod supra pacta conventa hostem se ei opposuisset." (Will. Fil. Steph. p. 200, ed. Giles.) ^ We learn the spot of thecombat from Wace, Roman de Rou, 8622 et seqq. ; " Jk ert li Rei a Saint-Albin," &c. And this agrees with the description of Richard of Hugleville given by Orderic (606 B), where he sets forth the pedigree of the family ; " Tem- pore Guillelmi juvenis filii Rodberti Ducis, Guillelmus de Archis contra Ducem rebellavit, et pene omnium Calogiensium parilis defectus nothum principem deseruit ; solus Ricardus contra rebelles in castello suo secus ecclesiam Sancti Albini perstitit, et pro fidelitate Ducis contra discursus Archacensium provinciam circumjacentem defensare curavit. " K 2 132 THE LATER REIGN OP WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII, His son Gulbert. Richard's son-in-law Geoffrey and his son Bernard of New- march. His priory and castle at Breck- nock. The French halt at Saint Aubin. Gulbert, a man whose name we shall again greet with honour, one whom Englishmen at least may look on as the noblest among the chivalry of Normandy.^ With Richard too stood his son-in-law Geoffrey, the husband of his daughter Ada, and Geoffrey's brother Hugh, the sons of Thurcytel who held the lordship of Neufmarche by the famous forest of Lions. Of these, Hugh had already fallen in an earlier skirmish with the rebels of Arques.^ Geoffrey lived to be father of one who made himself a name in a remote corner of our own island. Bernard of Newmarch, the son of Ada the daughter of Richard of Hugleville, be- came as terrible an enemy to the central land of the Cymry, as the son of Hamon Dentatus showed himself to the Cymry of the southern coasts.-^ His fame still lives, far away from the forest of Lions and the hill of Arques, where the minster and the castle of Brecknock look forth on the vale of the Welsh Axe, and on the mountain rampart which, when Arques was beleaguered and defended, still guarded the realm of GrujSydd the son of Bhydderch.* The King of the French and his comrades must have been strangely ignorant of the state of the country, when they chose a spot for their halting-place so near to the home of such tried and loyal warriors as these. They had brought with them a good stock of provisions of corn and of wine, for the relief of the besieged of Arques. At Saint Aubin they began to make ready a train of sumpter-horses with a military convoy, to carry these good things to their suffering friends, just as if they had been in a country where ^ See Ord. Vit. 606 D. It is with a thrill of sympathy alike for the hero and for his chronicler that an Englishman reads the passage, which I shall have to refer to again. '^ Ord. Vit. 606 C. *' Hugonem cum omnibus suis Archacenses apud Moriummontem repente circumdederunt, seseque viriliter defendentem interemerunt." •'' See vol. ii. p. 246. ' Ord. Vit. u. s. AMBUSH AT SAINT AUBIN. 133 no danger was to be looked for.^ But, no doubt by the chap. xii. help of the loyal lord of Saint Aubin/ the besiegers of Arques, in their wooden castle,^ soon learned the careless approach of the French. A plan was speedily devised ; an Success of . p .^ , the Nor- ambush was laid ; a smaller party was sent lorth to prac- man am> tise that stratagem of pretended flight which Norman craft ^^ ^' was to display thirteen years later on a greater scale.* The Normans turned; the French pursued; presently the liers- in-wait were upon them, and the noblest and bravest of the invading host were slaughtered or taken prisoners before the eyes of their King.^ One Norman traitor at least was Capture of taken. '' Hugh Bardulf himself, that great man/'' ^ was Bardulf. among the captives. The exact nature and measure of Hugh''s greatness does not appear; but his capture is * Roman de Rou, 8620 ; " La sur d'Arches voleit garnir. La les fist li Rei arester, Kar li bl^ lur debvait faillir, E lur garnisun aprester Ja ert li Rei k Saint-Albin, Sumiers ki lur herneis portassent;, Asez portout fe bl^ ^ vin ; E chevaliers k'il conv^iassent." So Will. Gem. vii. 7. " Exercitum castra metari apud Sanctum Albinum jussit." ^ See Appendix Q. ^ Roman de Rou, 8628 ; " Cil del chastel oirent tost La garnisun e li grant ost." The " tur " is the castle of Arques ; the " chastel " is the wooden castle of the besiegers. * Will. Gem. vii, 7. " Cujus [Regis] adventum milites Ducis comperientes, de suis miserunt, si quos forte hostiuni k regio coetu abstraherent, quoa illi in latibulis degeutes incautos exciperent. Quo dum venissent, non minimam exercittis partem inde protraxerunt, et fugientes in insidias in- duxerunt. Statim vero qui videbantur fugere, versa facie coeperunt eos acriter csedere." So Roman de Rou, 8632 et seqq. Less fully Will. Pict- 94 ; *' Adducti in spem memorandi facinoris quidam ex eo numero qui in prsesidio Ducis relicti custodiunt, Francorum adventantium itinera ex- plorata insidunt. Et ecce numerosa pars minils cauti excipiuntur." ^ Will. Malms, iii. 232. " Quorum astutiel insidiis exceptus, Isembardum Pontivi comitem coram se obtruncari, Hugonem Bardulfum capi, merito ingemuit." ^ All our accounts speak of the capture of Hugh Bardulf as of an event of at least equal importance with the death of the Count of Ponthieu. William of Poitiers (u. s.) says, " Hugo Bardulfus ipse item, vir magnus, capitur," 134 THE LATER REIGN OP WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. spoken of as one of the most important events of the fight. I know of no record of his earlier exploits or of his later fate ; but the name of Bardulf occurs repeatedly in the later records both of the Norman and of the English Exchequer, and one at least of his descendants seems to have been as Death of little amenable to lawful authority as his ancestor.^ By the ffelram of sidc of the captivc Bardulf died a sovereign prince, a neigh- Ponthieu. j^^^j, q£ Normandy^ bound by ties of the closest affinity The Counts alike to William the Duke and to William the rebel. The thieu. house of the Counts of Ponthieu is one whose name will meet us more than once again in the course of the present volume. Sprung of the blood of Herlwin of Montreuil, a name so familiar to us in Norman history a hundred years before,^ they held, as he had done_, the border land between Normandy and Flanders. But they had held it by various Hugh the tenures and under various titles. Hugh, the great-grand- "First Advocate father of the present ruler, a prince, if we may so call him, p o • J, o rsaint higli in the favour of his namesake the Parisian King, had borne no title but that of Advocate of Saint Biquier.^ He was, as the chronicles of the Abbey take care to tell us, enriched at the expense of the great monastery of which he was bound to be the defender.* The house of Saint Biquier was the work of the bounty of the great Charles ; it was ^ " In the roll of Norman fees in the red book of the Exchequer, we find Doon Bardulf returned as one of those ' qui non venerunt, nee miserunt, nee aliquid dixerunt.' " I copy this from Taylor's W.ace, p. 44. The name of Bardulf, including several Doun Bardulfs, occurs constantly in the Ex- chequer Records both of Normandy and of England (see the Indexes to Madox and Stapleton), but I have not lighted on the particular story re- ferred to by Mr. Taylor. ^ See vol. i. p. 227 et pass. ^ Chron. Cental, iv. 2 r (ap. D'Achery, ii. 343). " Attamen huic numquam Comitis nomen accessit, sed erat illi insigne quod Sancti Richarii voca- batur Advocatus." On Saint Riquier see vol. ii. p. 535. * lb. " Ablatis monasterio Centulo tribus oppidis, Abbatis- villa, Sancto Medardo, et Incra, et his castellis efFectis, in eorumque stippendia niultis aliis Sancti Richarii villis et reditibus ab Hugone Rege praerogatis." Cf. iv. 12. I THE COUNTS OF PONTHIEU. 135 the house where a saintly Abbot and an Emperor's daughter chap. xii. so strangely became the parents of that famous Nithard_, who figures alike as Count and as Abbot^ and who is yet more renowned as a lay historian in whose steps neither iEthel- weard nor Fulk knew how to walk.^ The son of Hugh, Ingelram Ingelram or Enguerrand^ the Firsts was the first to bear the count of* title of Count of Ponthieu, a title sometimes exchanged for "'^^JlV^i!^^^ that of Count of Abbeville.^ The grange stolen away ville. from the house of Saint Riquier grew into the capital of a principality, and the town was in after days adorned with that unfinished minster,, which, as it is looked at from the west or from the east^ may be called the noblest or the meanest in France. This elder Ingelram has already appeared in our history as a foe of Count Gilbert of Brionne^ his an- tagonist on the field where Herlwin^ not yet of Bee, taught the contending chiefs how a Christian soldier had learned to return good for evil.* From him the County passed to Hugh the a second Hugh, and from him, only a year before, it had 1046-1052. passed to a second Ingelram. This prince now, whether led Ingelram by border enmity, by loyalty to his suzerain, or by preference 105 2-1053. to one domestic tie over another, had joined the call of King Henry to an invasion of the Norman Duchy. The Count His affinity of Ponthieu went forth to help the husband of his sister Williams. against the brother of his wife. Count Hugh had given ^ See Chron. Centul. ii. 7. Sir Francis Palgrave (iii. 226), by one of the slips so natural in a chapter not revised by the author, confounds father and son. "^ I find that in my second volume I have written this name Ingelram in the text (p. 217) and Enguerrand in the Appendix (p. 587). Such accidents will happen, especially with foreign names. Ingelram (whence Ingram) is certainly the English form, though the name was never common in England ; I therefore prefer it, as does Sir F. Palgrave. 2 Hariulf (Chron. Cent. iv. 21) calls the elder Hugh " Hugo Abbatensis," and the Ingelram slain at Saint Aubin is by William of Jumifeges (vii. 7) called " Abbatis-villse Comes." Ingelram, according to Hariulf, took the title of Count (" Dei gratia Comes ") on slaying Baldwin Count of Bou- logne and marrying his widow Adelaide. Chron. Cent. iv. 12. * See vol. ii. p. 217. 136 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. his daughter in marriage to William of Arques/ but his son was also the husband of a full sister of Duke William.^ As such_, he was himself the son-in-law of the Tanner's daughter,, and he had therefore no right to join the Lord of Arques in his sneers at the Bastard of Falaise. He now felt the strength of the Norman steel, even in the absence of the Prince against whom he came. He fell in the ambush Guy. of Saint Aubin;^ his County passed to his brother Guy, ' soon again to appear in our story ; * but his daughters, Daughters the nieces of Duke William, were treated as members of ram.'' ^^^ ducal family, and one of them, Judith the wife of Waltheof, lived to leave behind her an evil renown in the history of our own land.^ King The Count of Ponthieu was thus slain fighting valiantly.^ tires. His overlord King Henry escaped the ambush, and pressed on towards the hill of Arques, in the hope of relieving the besieged. But he found Duke William'^s wooden castle too strong, and the courage of its defenders too deter- mined, for his attacks upon it to prevail.'^ He accordingly ^ William of Jumifeges (vii. 7) calls the wife of William of Arques *^soror Widonis Comitis Pontivi," That is a daughter of Hugh. Why is Ingelram called "Comes Abbatisvillae," and his brother "Comes Pontivi/' in the same chapter? ^ See vol. ii. p. 587. ' The death of Ingelram is mentioned in all our accounts, like the cap- ture of Hugh Bardulf * This is Guy who imprisoned Harold. His uncle, another Guy, squ of Ingelram the First, was Bishop of Amiens (see Chron. Cent. iv. 36. p. 355), and wrote the famous poem " De Bello Hastingensi." See Will. Gem. vii. 44. ■"' The other daughter married Odo of Champagne. See vol. ii. p. 588, and below, p. 142. « William of Poitiers (94) calls him "nobilitate notus ac fortudine," and William (or Orderic) in the death-bed speech (657 B) says " prsecur- sores mei prgeoccupavenmt Engelrannum Comitem in castrum intrare festinantem, ipsumque fortiter pugnantem, quia miles erat asperrimus, occidcrunt, et agmina ejus fugaverunt." Hariulf, in the Chronicle of Saint Ritiuier (iv. 21), calls him "homo formae mirabilis." ■^ Will. Pict. (u. 8.) " Perveniens tamen quo ire intenderat, Rex ex- acerbatissimis animis summa vi prsesidiura attentavit : Willolmum ab RETKEAT OF HENRY. 137 returned home^ having done nothing towards the imme- ch.vp. xii. diate object of his journey, the relief of the besieged Count of Arques.^ He had however gained some partizans in Normandy, and one Norman fortress at least was betrayed into his hands. Its position shows that the rebellion must have spread far beyond the immediate neighbourhood of Arques. One Wimund, who commanded the fortress of Moulins Moulins, surrendered it to the King.^ The fortress thus the'^King ^ gained by Henry lay on the other side of the Seine, in the ^^^' County of Hiesmes and Diocese of Seez, on the very frontier of the debateable land of the House of Belesme.^ The post was therefore an important one. It received a It is gar- French garrison, and its command was entrusted to a man under Guy of princely rank from a distant quarter of Gaul, whose of Poitiers ^ -^ ^ ^ orGascony. presence in the royal host is not the least perplexing thing about the story. This was Guy- Geoffrey, Count of Gas- cony,* son of that William of Aquitaine who bore the title of the Great. He was therefore brother of the prince who had suffered so hardly at the hands of Geoffrey of Anjou; he was brother of the reigning Duke, who, from serumnis uti eriperet, pariter decrementum sui, stragem suorum vindicaret. Sed ubi negotium difficile animadvertit, quippe inimicos impetus facile toleraverunt castelli muuimenta et militum virtus aeque validae .... abire maturavit." ^ So I understand the not very clear statement of William of Poitiers that the King went away. ^ Will. Pict. 96. " In ipsa mora obsidionali Normannorum aliquanti , potentiores ab Duce ad Regem defecerunt, quos jam antea conspirationis rebellantium occultique fuisse adjutores opinabile erat. Malevolentiam, qua olim contra infantem fuerant inflati nondum evomuere totam. Eorurn eo consortio Guimundus prsesidens munitior.i quam Molendinas appellant in manus Regis eam dedit." W^illiam of Malmesbury seems to make the movement a popular one ; ''Hujusce obsidionis intervallo populus castri quod Molendinis dicitur, exolescens, ad partes Regis incentore quodam Galterio transiit." Is this Walter the same as the Wimund of the other William ? •'' See Stapleton, i. cxxxiii. et al. ■* Will. Pict, 96. " Guido frater Comitis Pictavensis Willelmi atque Romanae Imperatricis." So Will. Malms. This Guy (see Art de Verifier les Dates, ii. 356) is the same as the Geoffrey whom Geoffrey Martel established in Gascony, See vol. ii. p. 595. 138 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. Peter^ had changed his name to William/ and brother too of AgneSj the wife of the reigning Emperor_, whose name was soon to become famous during the minority of her son.^ Guy- Geoffrey himself, on his accession to his brother's do- minions a few years later, also changed his baptismal name 1058-1087. for that so familiar to his family, and reigned as William Return of the Eighth of Aquitaine and Sixth of Poitiers.^ By this liam.^ ^ ^i^® Duke William had returned to the siege ; he had no longer to fear the commission of any feudal offence by The fighting personally against his lord. The defenders of hard^^ Arques were now sorely pressed by hunger. They con- pressed, trived to send messages to King Henry; but all was in vain; no help came from their royal ally.^ At last the sure but slow means to which the Duke had trusted had The castle thoroughly done its work ; Count William and his garrison wretched ' Surrendered, on the sole condition that the horrors of state of the ^lencon were not to be repeated. Safety for life and limb besieged. ^ ^ ■'• "^ was promised ; the gates were opened, and a company came forth in whose sad condition the Norman panegyrist sees at least as much matter for scorn as for pity. Knights of renown throughout France and Normandy came forth with marks of hunger on their faces, and with their necks bowed down alike by hunger and by shame. Some rode on famished horses, whose feeble feet could hardly raise the dust or give forth an audible sound as they crept * '■ Chron. Maxent. 1058 (Labbe, ii. 210). ''Willermus, qui et Petrus cognomen to Acer." ^ See vol. ii. p. 373. ' In the Chronicle of Saint Maxentius he is called Geoffrey in 1044, 1058, 1060, 1061, 1062, Guy and Geoffrey in 1068, William in 1071, lastly in 1086, ''Guido qui et Goffredus." This is certainly the way to confuse genealogists. * Will. Pict. 95. "Rex denuo accitus multo et miserfe supplici nuncio venire abnuit." The Archdeacon now gets very eloquent, and gives us all the inner workings of the mind of one whom he calls " Papiic partus." It takes a minute or two to see that by this odd description he means the Count of Arques. SURRENDER OF ARQUES. 139 along. Others came forth on foot^ booted and spurred^ chap. xii. bearing saddles on their backs, seemingly ready for that last symbolical rite of humiliation in which the vanquished offered himself for the victor to mount upon his back.^ And, if the proud gentlemen of France and Normandy were brought so low as this, it is not wonderful if the aspect of their more lowly followers,, the light-armed troops of the garrison, was equally sad.^ The news soon reached Guy of the fortress of Moulins, which was still held by the French surrenders troops under Guy of Aquitaine. The Poitevin prince, the °^ ^"^* brother-in-law of CaBsar, had no mind to tempt the strength of the Norman. He and his garrison, and the garrisons of such other posts as had been occupied by the royal forces, fled out of the land without waiting to be attacked.^ Towards The Duke's his own subjects the Duke more than kept the terms of his to^his"^"^ capitulation. Count William was not even required to ^^^^^' leave Normandy. He was offered licence to remain in the land and to retain possession of a considerable estate, of which however it need hardly be said that his own famous hill-fortress was not to form a part.* But life in his native country had no longer any charms for him. The dis- Count Wil- possessed Count and his wife, the sister of the slain Count Arques of Ponthieu, retired to the court of Count Eustace of ^^^\^^ ^^ Boulogne. ^ This ceremony was gone through by the Count-Bishop Hugh (see vol. i. p. 514) to Richard the Good; " Equestrem sellam ferens humeris, provolutus genibus Riohardi," &c. Will. Gem. v. 16. Palgrave, iii. 133. Cf. Will. Malms, iii. 235. So we now read in William of Poitiers ; " Pars ocreis et calcaribus ornati [why ?], insolito comitatu incedentes, et eorum plerique sellam equestrem incurvo languidoque dorso, nonnulli solum se nutabundi vix eportantes." ^ Will. Pict. 95. " Erat item cernere calamitatem levis armatura egre- dientis fcsdam ac variam." ^ lb. 96. " Verum et ii, et quiqui alias relicti sunt a Francis, quum deditas esse comperissent Arch arum latebras,, sese nostris fuga furati sunt." * lb. 95. "Noluit extorrem et inopem casu magis pudendo cruciari ; sed cum gratia et possessionibus quibusdam amplis atque multorum redituum, patriam ei concessit." 140 THE LATER KEIGN OF WILLIAM JN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. Boulogne.^ The fall of one William of Arques led the way to the advancement of the other. The Viscount had had no share in the treasons of the Count. He was not indeed raised to fill a place which the Duke had learned to be The castle too dangcrous an elevation for any subject. The County of wmbim ^^ Talou was abolished ; the castle of Arques became a ducal possession ; but the care of the fortress reared by the Wil- liam of Arques who figures in Norman history was en- trusted to that other William of Arques whose name is written in Domesday.^ the Vis- count. Marriage of Duke William. Duke William was now allowed a few months of peace, and J having brought one troublesome matter to a happy end, he seems to have thought it a fitting time to bring another matter of no less moment in his eyes to an end no less happy. It was in this year, therefore probably in the short interval between the French invasion which we have thus far followed and the second invasion which followed it in the next year, that William at last won his long-wished- for bride. Count Baldwin now brought his daughter to the frontier castle of Eu, and William led her thence to his palace at Bouen.^ I have already discussed the puzzling circumstances of this marriage; I have already spoken of the indignation which it called forth among men so unlike one another as Malger and Lanfranc* Malger, it must not be forgotten, was a brother of the fallen Count of Arques ; he may have been concerned in his treason ; his deposition may have been his punishment. But the clemency which William showed towards the uncle who had been actually in arms may make us doubt whether he would have taken this kind of revenge on a kinsman who was at least not more guilty.^ * Will. Gem. vii. 7. See Deville, p. 78 et seqq. I see no diflBculty in reconciling the two accounts. 2 See Deville, p. 89. 3 See above, p. 92. * See above, pp. 93, 101. * See above, p. 94. HATRED OF THE FRENCH TOWARDS NORMANDY. 141 King Henry had failed to give any help to the defenders chap. xii. of Arqnes in their last extremity; but hatred towards Normandy was far from being lulled to rest in the breasts either of the French King or of the French people. We Hatred of seem to be carried back a hundred years^ to the wars waged towards by Lewis and Hugh and Arnulf against the defenceless ^^^^^ childhood of William Longsword. Through the whole extent of the King^s domains, and through the domains of his chief vassals, the feeling of jealousy against Normandy was bitter indeed. The King complained that Nor- mandy, a land which had been part of the immediate possessions of his forefathers, even before they wore a Crown,^ had now itself become almost a Kingdom.^ He, a crowned King, the overlord of so many Princes, the ally of the Roman Emperor himself,^ looked with an evil eye on the one corner of his realm whose master paid him no obedience.^ We may doubt whether the vassalage of Flanders or Aquitaine, to say nothing of Barcelona, in- volved more of practical submission than the vassalage of Normandy ; but, as I have explained more than once, there was no other among the great vassals of the Crown whose greatness seemed so directly stolen from that of the Crown itself, no other whose fief, by its very position, seemed so literally to hold its royal overlord in fetters.^ And Jealousy of jealousy of William and his Duchy was by no means con- Princes fined to the King and his immediate subjects ; nearly all ^^^y^^ William. ^ See vol. i. p. 189 ; vol. ii. p. 202. '^ Will. Pict. 96. " Normanniam, quse sub Eegibus Francorum egit ex antiquo, prope in regnum evectam." What would our old friend Dudo (see vol. i. pp. 193, 209, 247) have said to the ''prope" ? ^ lb. " Quum Imperatorem Romanum, quo majus potentise sive dignitatis nomen in orbe terrarum aliud non est, amicum et socium habei-et." * lb. " Quum provinciis multis praesideret potentibus, quarum domini aut rectores militise suae essent administri, Comitem Willelmum suum nee amicum nee militem, sed hostem esse." ^ See above, p. 116. ^ 142 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. the Princes of Gaul seem to have been for once ready to abet their suzerain against one whom they all equally Geoffey dreaded and envied. That the Hammer of Anjou was eagerly waiting for the fitting moment to deal another Theobald blow need hardly be said. And the old hereditary grudge and Cham- ^^7 have rankled in the breast of Theobald of Blois^, now pagne; rejoicing in the higher dignity of Count of Champagne. He had won that County by driving out his nephew Odo,^ and the favourable reception which the dispossessed prince found at the court of William, his marriage with a near kinswoman of the Duke/ may have been either the cause or William the result of his uncle's enmity. But it is hard to see how Aquitaine. the powcr of Normandy could be threatening to a prince so distant as the Count of Poitiers and Duke of Aquitaine. Nor had William given his southern namesake any offence, unless indeed the Duke of Aquitaine thought it his duty to avenge the ignominious escape of his brother from the dominions of the Duke of the Normans. Yet all these princes, we are told, were eager, in an unusual fit of loyalty, to avenge the wrongs of the King whom they all so faithfully served, but to whom the upstart Bastard at Rouen refused all obedience.^ And all, King and Princes, were specially stirred up by certain members of the royal family, whom it is not easy to identify, but who are said to have thought that Normandy, or some part of it, might ^ Art de Verifier les Dates, ii. 614. ^ lb. But it must be borne in mind that the kinswoman of Wil- liam's whom Odo married was not Adelaide, the Duke's sister, but the younger Adelaide, her daughter by Ingelram of Ponthieu. See vol. ii. p.^588. ^ Will. Pict. 97. "Condolentes in eiidem Theobaldus, Pictavorum Comes, Gaufredus, item reliqui summates, quadam insuper indignatione l^rivatH intoleranduni ducebant sese Regis, quocumque praevia vocarent, sigiiis parere ; Willelmum Normannorum nequaquam pro Rege, sed confidenter atquc indesinenter ad ejus magnitudinera, quam aliquanttim attrivit, ulteritis atterendam, vel si qua vi.l valeant, conterendani, in armis agitare," I GREAT CONFEDERACY AGAINST NORMANDY. 143 form convenient appanages for themselves.^ A joint ex- chap. xn. pedition against Normandy, on a scale which should surpass all former expeditions, was agreed upon. The panegyrist of William lavishes all his rhetoric and all his powers of classical allusion to set forth the greatness of the danger by which Normandy was now threatened. Caesar himself, the conqueror of the Gauls, Danger of or a general greater than Caesar, if Rome herself had pro- duced a greater, might have felt fear at the approach of such a host as was now poured from every region of Gaul upon the devoted Duchy .^ The whole land was stirred even to its remotest corners. The movement reached to the Ducal Burgundy, the most eastern fief of the Parisian Crown. It aroused the Gascon at the foot of the Pyrenees, and the men who dwelt among the volcanic peaks of less distant Auvergne. All these drew the sword; but France and Britanny, as the nearest of all to the Norman land, were the most eager for its destruction.^ Through all Nor- mandy, the men of peaceful callings, the priest, the peasant, the burgher, all trembled for their wives, their children, their goods, their very lives. But they thought what a champion they had in their mighty Duke, and their hearts were comforted. Lapng aside flourishes like these, and confessing the extreme difliiculty of seeing the warriors of Gascony and Auvergne, or even those of Burgundy, there ^ Will. Pict. 97. " Praeterea concupiebant Normanniam, aiit ejus partem, quidam Regis proximi." ^ lb. *' Julium Caesarem, vel bellandi peritiorem aliqnera, si fuerit peritior, exercittls Romani duceni (ex mille nationibus coacti olim, dum Roma florentissima mille provinciis imperitasset) hujus agminis immanitate terreri potuisse affirmares." ^ lb. "Burgundiam, Arverniam, atque Wasconiam properare videres horribiles ferro : imo vires tanti regni, quanttim in climata mundi quatuor patent, cunctas, Franciam tamen et Britanniam, quanto nobis viciniores, tantb ardentius infestas." As he speaks of the " regnum," he clearly means by Burgundy only the Duchy which held of the French Crown. His use of " Francia" along with the rest, as the name of one part of Gaul, should be noticed. Compare the use of the word by Flodoard ; see vol, i. p. 199. 144 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. is no doubt that a great and unusual effort was made, both by the King and by those of his great vassals who were Union of most immediately open to his influence. An invasion of several Normaiidy was decreed, which really was planned on a against greater scale, and carried out in a more systematic way, than any that had ever gone before it. The whole forces of the royal domain — of France, in the language of the time — Guy of together with the forces of Count Theobald and of Count andTheo- ^^^J ^^ Ponthicu, were assembled for a combined attack bald, QjQ ^Y^Q Duchy. Guy came, naturally enough, to avenge Seeminsf absence of the death of his brother ; ^ what is most to be remarked is Geoffrey ^^^q seeminff absence of the Prince whom we should have of Anjou. ^ expected to find first at the muster, the restless Hammer of Anjou. Some of his subjects seem indeed to have shared in the expedition, but there is no certain account of Geoffrey himself till the campaign was over.^ His absence is not easily to be accounted for. The chronicles of his own country do not supply us with any records of other undertakings which might explain his failure to share in an enterprise which one would have thought would have had every charm for him. But, even in his Double absence, the muster was a great one. The forces of the Normandy. King and his vassals were divided into two armies for the I054- invasion of Normandy at two distinct points. Our Latin authorities, glad as ever to fall back on the geography of a past age, tell us how the forces both of Celtic and of ^ Will.Pict. 98. ''Guido, Pontivi Comes, ad vindicandum fratrem Ingel- rannum nimis avidus." Will, Malms, iii. 233. "Guido Pontivi Comes studiositis ultionis fratris intendit." ^ I find no mention of Geoffrey as present, except in William of Jumieges (vii. 24), who makes him accompany the King, This account is followed by Benolt of Saint More, 35245 ; " Li quens d'Aiijou Gefrei Martel, 1 vint od riche compaignie Qui del ovi-aigne esteit mult bel, E od ses archei-s de valie.'' But it is strange that William of Poitiers and the other writers should have left out so important a person, had he really been there, and his absence, hard as it is to account for it, agrees better with w)mt follows. DOUBLE INVASION OF NORMANDY. 145 Belgic Gaul were gathered together in two divisions. The ohap. xii. Celtic host was to march under the command of the King in person, the forces of the Belgian lands under that of his brother Odo. With Odo was joined in command the King's special favourite, Reginald of Clermont^ not the more famous Clermont in the distant land of Auvergne, but the lowlier Clermont in the nearer land of Beauvais. With them marched two other leaders of the rank of Count, Ralph of Montdidier and he of whom we have already heard, Guy of Ponthieu.^ The vernacular poet more kindly helps us to the real names of the districts which are veiled under the obsolete titles delighted in by the Latin writers. Normandy was to be invaded on each side of the Seine, and the Seine was taken as the limit alike of the lands to be invaded and of the hosts which were severally to invade them.^ The Northern, the Belgic, Forces of host was to enter the elder Normandy, the first home of q^uI" Rolf, the French-speaking land of Rouen. They were to ""^^*" ^*^*'' enter by way of Beauvais, to advance and ravage the land of Caux, the coast-land to the right of the Seine, the land around the minster of Fecamp and the castle of Lillebonne. They were to harry the whole district and diocese of Rouen, and to carry their ravages up to the metropolis ^ Ord. Vit. 657 D (cf. 638 D). *' Aliam [phalangem] Odoni fratri sue ac Rainaldo de Claro Monte, et duobus Consulibus, Kadulfo de Monte-De- siderii atque Widoni de Pontivo, commendavit." William of Poitiers, like Richer of old (see vol. i. p. 223, note 3, cf. 237, note 2), is strong in his anti- quated geography. He tells us (98) about "Quantus miles inter Sequanam et Garonnam fluvios colligeretur (quas gentes multas uno nomine Gelti- gallos appellant) ;" then about those who were '' inter flumen E,henum [Henry the Frank's notions about the Rhine frontier were doubtless different] et Sequanam collect!, quae Gallia Belgica nuncupatur," Lastly, *'Regem insuper comitabatur Aquitania pars Gallise tertia." Reginald of Clermont is "Rainaldus famiiiarissimus." Was he commissioned to supply the incapacity of Odo ? See vol. i. p. 520. ^ Roman de Rou, 9919 ; " La gent de.dous parz a mand^e Si come Saine I'a devisee." VOL. III. L 146 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. itself.^ To the muster of Odo came the men of pri- matial Rheims; the men too of Soissons^ once the home of Merovingian royalty, and so soon to become the guerdon of a Norman traitor.^ There also were the men of Laon^ where the line of the Teutonic Emperor had so long lingered^ and the men of Noyons_, the city which had beheld the permanent inauguration of the Parisian King- dom.^ There marched the forces of Vermandois, whose Carolingian Lord appeared as the loyal homager of the upstart dynasty.* The promise of Norman spoil drew the men of Amiens^ soon to become the flock of the Prelate whose verse was to hand down to us the minutest con- temporary record of Norman victory.^ Himself, not yet a father of the Church, may well have followed^ among the men of his native Ponthieu_, to avenge a slaughtered nephew and a self-banished niece. ^ Thither men came from Meulan on the Seine and from Beaumont on the Oise/ from the corn-fields of Brie and from the rose-gardens^ of ^ Ord. Vit. 657 D. " Ut per vada Eptae Neustriam cito introirent, Braium et Calcegium totumque Rothomagensem pagum invaderent ferro et flammS., nee ne rapinis usque ad mare penitus devastarent." ^ See above, p. 119. ^ Hugh Capet was crowned at Noyon. Richer, iv. 12. See vol. i. p. 268. * Roman de Rou, 9923. "Gels de Melant d de Vermendeiz." See above, p. 120. The reigning Count was Hei-bert the Fourth. ^ Guy, Bishop of Amiens, the author of the poem ** De Belle Has- tingensi" (see Will. Gem. vii. 44), was a son of Ingelram the First and uncle of Guy and of Ingelram the Second. He succeeded to the see about 1058. " See above, pp. 136, 139. ' Wace, 9925, says ''Cels de Flandres h de Belmont," and Benoit (35255) "La furent Flamenc e Poher." But the presence of subjects of Baldwin is exceedingly unlikely, and Benoit in some sort confutes himself by adding " E Braiben9on e Hainuer," thus getting beyond the borders of the Western realm within which the others strictly confine themselves. He was most likely misled, as others have been since, by the grand talk about the Rhine. ^ That is, if Provins roses, brought from the East by pilgrims or Cru- saders, had reached Europe so soon. THE TWO DIVISIONS OF THE FRENCH ARMY. 147 Provins. By twenties, by hundreds, by thousands^ the chap. xii. force of all the lands rig-ht of the Seine gathered under the banners of Guy and Odo^ to carry slaughter and devastation through those parts of Normandy which lay on their own side of the great Norman river. The other muster gathered round the standard of the Forces of . . ''Celtic King himself. Thither came the men of those ancient Gaul" cities of central Gaul, which, now no less than then_, which ^.^^^ *"^ then no less than in the days of Caesar and in the old time before him_, still sit, each one as a lady for ever/ by the banks of their ancient rivers or on the proud crests of their everlasting hills. If their peaceful calling did not keep them by their thrones and altars, the crosses of three Metropolitans might have been borne to the camp of Henry. The men of Bourges and Berry ^ came from around the steep of old Avaricum, whence Ambigatus had sent forth his swarming colonists to more southern lands,^ and where Vercingetorix had bid defiance to the mightiest of southern invaders.* Thither too came the men of Sens, the countrymen of Brennus and his host, the city whose sons had encamped upon the Roman forum and had wound their way round the steep of the Boman capitol.^ And from the banks of the rushing Loire, from around the towers of Saint Martin and Saint Gatian, came the men ^ Isaiah xlvii, 7. ^ Roman de Rou, 9943. '' De Bourges e de Berri." As usual, the names of the city and of the district are both slightly varying forms of the old Gaulish name ; but it is curious to see them distinguished in such a marked way, which seems not to be done in any other part of the catalogue. ^ Livy, V. 34. " Celtarum quas pars Gallise tertia est penes Bituriges summa imperii fuit ; ii Regem Celtico dabant, Ambigatus is fuit," etc. Then follows the account of his sending forth the Colonies under his sister's sons Bellovesus and Sigovesus. Did the special sanctity of a sister's son (see vol. ii. p. 368) extend to the Celts ? * Caesar, B. G. vii. 18, 19. Merivale, Roman Empire, ii. 14. ^ Livy, V. 35. '' Senones recentissimiadvenarum," They alone seem to have been concerned in the taking of Rome. L 2 148 THE LATER REIGN OF WILLIAM IN NORMANDY. CHAP. XII. of Tours, the fellow-citizens of so many saints, whose land, now crushed beneath the Hammer of Anjou, had once seen 732. the Hammer of Christendom break in pieces the hosts of the False Prophet. Thither too came the contingents of the other cities by the great boundary stream, the men of Count TheobaWs Blois and of King Henry's Orleans. There were the men of the border-land of Perche, and of the King's own towns of Etampes and Montlhery, towns whose fame, such as it is, was reserved for later days. Thither came the men of the bocage and the men of the plain,^ the men of the vast cornland which surrounds the hill of Chartres, the hill where Druids had once held their orgies, but where the rites of the heathen had now given way to the learning and holiness of Prelates like Fulbert and like Ivo. Full no doubt of faith in that revered relic before which R-olf and his pirate-host had quailed,^ the land of the old enemy of Richard the Fearless^ sent forth its forces to wreak a tardy vengeance on the successor alike of E/olf and of Richard. The King's The host of Celtic Gaul held its trysting-place at a spot assembles