Enzyme immobilization: an overview on techniques and support materials By Sumitra Datta, L. Rene Christena, Yamuna Rani Sriramulu Rajaram Published in: 3 Biotech DOI: 10.1007/s13205-012-0071-7 ABSTRACT The current demands of the world’s biotechnological industries are enhancement in enzyme productivity and development of novel techniques for increasing their shelf life. These requirements are inevitable to facilitate large-scale and economic formulation. Enzyme immobilization provides an excellent base for increasing availability of enzyme to the substrate with greater turnover over a considerable period of time. Several natural and synthetic supports have been assessed for their efficiency for enzyme immobilization. Nowadays, immobilized enzymes are preferred over their free counterpart due to their prolonged availability that curtails redundant downstream and purification processes. Future investigations should endeavor at adopting logistic and sensible entrapment techniques along with innovatively modified supports to improve the state of enzyme immobilization and provide new perspectives to the industrial sector. INTRODUCTION Enzymes or ‘biocatalysts’ are remarkable discovery in the field of bioprocess technology. Biocatalysis has been widely accepted in diverse sectors owing to their ease of production, substrate specificity and green chemistry. However, for large extent commercialization of these bio-derived catalysts, their reusability factor becomes mandatory, failing which they would no longer be economic. Maintenance of their structural stability during any biochemical reaction is highly challenging. Consequently, immobilized enzymes with functional efficiency and enhanced reproducibility are used as alternatives in spite of their expensiveness. Immobilized biocatalysts can either be enzymes or whole cells (Kawaguti et al. 2006). Enzyme immobilization is confinement of enzyme to a phase (matrix/support) different from the one for substrates and products. Inert polymers and inorganic materials are usually used as carrier matrices. Apart from being affordable, an ideal matrix must encompass characteristics like inertness, physical strength, stability, regenerability, ability to increase enzyme specificity/activity and reduce product inhibition, nonspecific adsorption and microbial contamination (Singh 2009). Immobilization generates continuous economic operations, automation, high investment/capacity ratio and recovery of product with greater purity (D’Souza 1998). Several methods are used for immobilization and various factors influence the performance of immobilized enzymes (Table 1). Adsorption/carrier-binding method uses water-insoluble carriers such as polysaccharide derivatives, synthetic polymers and glass (Al-Adhami et al. 2002; Rosa et al. 2002; Wu and Lia 2008; Cordeiro et al. 2011). In cross-linking/covalent method, bi/multifunctional reagents such as glutaraldehyde, bisdiazobenzidine and hexamethylene diisocyanate are used (Lee et al. 2006; Singh 2009). Polymers like collagen, cellulose and κ-carrageenan are employed by entrapment method, while the membrane confinement method includes formulation of liposomes and microcapsules (Katwa et al. 1981; Wang and Hettwer 1982; Mislovicová et al. 2004; Hilal et al. 2006; Tümtürk et al. 2007; Rochefort et al. 2008; Jegannathan et al. 2010; Chen et al. 2011a, b; Klein et al. 2011).Table 1Factors influencing performance of immobilized enzymes (Cao 2006)FactorsImplications of immobilizationHydrophobic partitionEnhancement of reaction rate of hydrophobic substrateMicroenvironment of carrierHydrophobic nature stabilizes enzymeMultipoint attachment of carrierEnhancement of enzyme thermal stabilitySpacer or arm of various types of immobilized enzymesPrevents enzyme deactivationDiffusion constraintsEnzyme activity decreases and stability increasesPresence of substrates or inhibitorsHigher activity retentionPhysical post-treatmentsImprovement of enzyme performanceDifferent binding modeActivity and stability can be affectedPhysical structure of the carrier such as pore sizeActivity retention was often pore-size dependentPhysical nature of the carrierCarriers with large pore size mitigate diffusion limitation, leading to higher activity retention This article reviews the existing techniques used for immobilization along with providing insights into the recent developments for each of them. We have tried to throw light on significant modifications with respect to the techniques and innovative support materials employed for immobilization of biocatalysts that have potential implication on future enzyme market. DIFFERENT TECHNIQUES USED FOR IMMOBILIZATION Adsorption Enzyme adsorption results from hydrophobic interactions and salt linkages where either the support is bathed in enzyme for physical adsorption or the enzyme is dried on electrode surfaces. Adsorbed enzymes are shielded from aggregation, proteolysis and interaction with hydrophobic interfaces (Spahn and Minteer 2008). Researchers have used eco-friendly supports like coconut fibers having good water-holding capacity and high cation exchange property; microcrystalline cellulose with irreversible binding capacity; kaolin with high enzyme retainability by chemical acetylation; and micro/mesoporous materials having thiol functionalized, large surface area ideally suited for reduction and oxidation reactions (Dey et al. 2002; Hernández et al. 2007; Karagulyan et al. 2008; Brígida et al. 2010; Mitchell and Ramírez 2011; Huang et al. 2011). Silanized molecular sieves have also been successfully used as supports for enzyme adsorption owing to the presence of silanols on pore walls that facilitate enzyme immobilization by hydrogen bonding (Diaz and Balkus 1996). Various chemical modifications of the currently used supports would definitely help in better immobilization. Water activity profiles of lipase adsorbed using polypropylene-based hydrophobic granules/Accurel EP-100 has been reported (Persson et al. 2000). It would be important to note that Accurel with smaller particle sizes increases reaction rates and enantiomeric ratios during biocatalyzation (Sabbani et al. 2006). For better process control and economic production, Yarrowia lipolytica lipase was immobilized on octyl-agarose and octadecyl-sepabeads supports by physical adsorption that resulted in higher yields and greater (tenfold) stability than that of free lipase. This was accounted by the hydrophobicity of octadecyl-sepabeads that enhances affinity between the enzyme and support (Cunha et al. 2008). Candida rugosa lipase adsorbed on biodegradable poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-hydroxyvalerate) showed 94 % residual activity after 4 h at 50 °C and reusability till 12 cycles (Cabrera-Padilla et al. 2011). These supports were preferred because they are less tough and crystalline than polyhydroxybutyrate. 1, 4-Butenediol diglycidyl ether-activated byssus threads have been suitable basement for urease that increased pH stability and retained 50 % enzyme activity under dried conditions (Mishra et al. 2011). Eco-friendly supports of biological origin not only prevent cropping up of ethical issues, but also cut down the production costs. Of late, biocompatible mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) supports have been used for biocatalysis in energy applications owing to their long-term durability and efficiency (Popat et al. 2011). Covalent binding Covalent association of enzymes to supports occurs owing to their side chain amino acids like arginine, aspartic acid, histidine and degree of reactivity based on different functional groups like imidazole, indolyl, phenolic hydroxyl, etc. (D’Souza 1998; Singh 2009). Peptide-modified surfaces when used for enzyme linkage results in higher specific activity and stability with controlled protein orientation (Fu et al. 2011). Cyanogen bromide (CNBr)-agarose and CNBr-activated-Sepharose containing carbohydrate moiety and glutaraldehyde as a spacer arm have imparted thermal stability to covalently bound enzymes (Hsieh et al. 2000; Cunha et al. 2008). Highly stable and hyperactive biocatalysts have been reported by covalent binding of enzymes to silica gel carriers modified by silanization with elimination of unreacted aldehyde groups and to SBA-15 supports containing cage-like pores lined by Si–F moieties (Lee et al. 2006; Szymańska et al. 2009). Increase in half-life and thermal stability of enzymes has been achieved by covalent coupling with different supports like mesoporous silica, chitosan, etc. (Hsieh et al. 2000; Ispas et al. 2009). Cross-linking of enzymes to electrospun nanofibers has shown greater residual activity due to increased surface area and porosity. Use of such nanodiametric supports have brought a turning point in the field of biocatalyst immobilization (Wu et al. 2005; Kim et al. 2006; Ren et al. 2006; Li et al. 2007; Huang et al. 2008; Sakai et al. 2010). Covalent binding of alcohol dehydrogenase on attapulgite nanofibers (hydrated magnesium silicate) has been opted owing to its thermal endurance and variable nano sizes (Zhao et al. 2010). Biocatalytic membranes have been useful in unraveling effective covalent interactions with silicon-coated enzymes (Hilal et al. 2006). Cross-linked enzyme aggregates produced by precipitation of enzyme from aqueous solution by addition of organic solvents or ionic polymers have been reported (Sheldon 2011). Different orientations of immobilized enzyme on magnetic nanoclusters obtained by covalent binding have found their applications in pharmaceutical industries owing to their enhanced longevity, operational stability and reusability (Yusdy et al. 2009). Maintaining the structural and functional property of enzymes during immobilization is one of the major roles played by a cross-linking agent. One such agent is glutaraldehyde, popularly used as bifunctional cross-linker, because they are soluble in aqueous solvents and can form stable inter- and intra-subunit covalent bonds. Affinity immobilization Affinity immobilization exploits specificity of enzyme to its support under different physiological conditions. It is achieved by two ways: either the matrix is precoupled to an affinity ligand for target enzyme or the enzyme is conjugated to an entity that develops affinity toward the matrix (Sardar et al. 2000). Affinity adsorbents have also been used for simultaneous purification of enzymes (Ho et al. 2004). Complex affinity supports like alkali stable chitosan-coated porous silica beads and agarose-linked multilayered concanavalin A harbor higher amounts of enzymes which lead to increased stability and efficiency (Shi et al. 2003; Sardar and Gupta 2005). Bioaffinity layering is an improvisation of this technique that exponentially increases enzyme-binding capacity and reusability due to the presence of non-covalent forces such as coulombic, hydrogen bonding, van der Waals forces, etc. (Sardar and Gupta 2005; Haider and Husain 2008). Entrapment Entrapment is caging of enzymes by covalent or non-covalent bonds within gels or fibers (Singh 2009). Efficient encapsulation has been achieved with alginate–gelatin–calcium hybrid carriers that prevented enzyme leakage and provided increased mechanical stability (Shen et al. 2011). Entrapment by nanostructured supports like electrospun nanofibers and pristine materials have revolutionalized the world of enzyme immobilization with their wide-ranging applications in the field of fine chemistry, biomedicine biosensors and biofuels (Dai and Xia 2006; Kim et al. 2006; Wang et al. 2009; Wen et al. 2011). Prevention of friability and leaching and augmentation of entrapment efficiency and enzyme activity by Candida rugosa lipase entrapped in chitosan have been reported. This support has also been reported to be non-toxic, biocompatible and amenable to chemical modification and highly affinitive to protein due to its hydrophilic nature (Betigeri and Neau 2002). Entrapment by mesoporous silica is attributed to its high surface area, uniform pore distribution, tunable pore size and high adsorption capacity (Ispas et al. 2009). Simultaneous entrapment of lipase and magnetite nanoparticles with biomimetic silica enhanced its activity in varying silane additives (Chen et al. 2011a). Sol–gel matrices with supramolecular calixarene polymers have been used for entrapment of C. rugosa lipase keeping in view their selective binding and carrying capacities (Erdemir and Yilmaz 2011). Lipases entrapped κ-carrageenan has been reported to be highly thermostable and organic solvent tolerant (Tümtürk et al. 2007; Jegannathan et al. 2010). MATERIALS USED FOR FABRICATION OF IMMOBILIZATION SUPPORTS Natural polymers as supports Alginate Alginate derived from cell walls of brown algae are calcium, magnesium and sodium salts of alginic acid and have been extensively used for immobilization as xanthan–alginate beads, alginate–polyacrylamide gels and calcium alginate beads with enhanced enzyme activity and reusability. Cross-linking of alginate with divalent ions (like Ca2+) and glutaraldehyde improves the stability of enzymes (Elçin 1995; Flores-Maltos et al. 2011). Chitosan and chitin Natural polymers like chitin and chitosan have been used as supports for immobilization (Vaillant et al. 2000; Kapoor and Kuhad 2007). The protein or carbohydrate moieties of enzymes are used for binding them to chitosan (Hsieh et al. 2000). Chitosan has been used in combination with alginate where chitosan-coated enzymes had less leaching effect compared to alginate owing to the physical and ionic interactions between the enzyme and support (Betigeri and Neau 2002). Similarly, a wet composite of chitosan and clay proved to be more reliable for enzyme trapping, because it has hydroxyl and amino groups, which easily link with enzymes, together with good hydrophilicity and high porosity. Chitosan in the form of beads can entrap twice as much of the enzymes (Chang and Juang 2007). According to Chern and Chao (2005), the chitin-binding domain of chitinase A1 from Bacillus circulans has a high affinity to chitin; so, this property has been exploited to retain D-hydantoinase. Collagen Being a natural polymer, collagen has been used for immobilization of tannase employing glutaraldehyde as cross-linking agent (Katwa et al. 1981). Fe3+-collagen fibers proved to be excellent supporting matrix for catalase immobilization by retaining significant activity even after 26 reuses (Chen et al. 2011b). Carrageenan Carrageenan, a linear sulfated polysaccharide, has been consistently used for immobilizing a variety of enzymes, like lipase for improving stability (Tümtürk et al. 2007). This support is pseudoplastic in nature, which helps it to thin under shear stress and recover its viscosity once the stress is removed. Jegannathan et al. (2010) could achieve an encapsulation efficiency of 42.6 % by the co-extrusion method using the same support for biodiesel production. Carrageenan has been reported as a cheap and durable support with better entrapment for lactic acid and α-galactosidase enzyme (Rao et al. 2008; Girigowda and Mulimani 2006). Gelatin Gelatin is a hydrocolloid material, high in amino acids, and can adsorb up to ten times its weight in water. Its indefinite shelf life has attracted attention for enzyme immobilization. Gelatin has been utilized in mixed carrier system with polyacrylamide where cross-linking with chromium (III) acetate proved better than chromium (III) sulfate and potassium chromium (III) sulfate (Emregul et al. 2006). Calcium alginate with gelatin forms a good template for calcium phosphate deposition for enzyme immobilization, and gelatin in combination with polyester films promoted 75 % loading efficiency, compared to previous studies which had 50 % loading efficiency (Shen et al. 2011; Ateş and Doğan 2010). Cellulose This most abundant natural polymer has been widely used to immobilize fungi laccase, penicillin G acylase, glucoamylase, α-amylase, tyrosinase, lipase and β-galactosidase (Al-Adhami et al. 2002; Mislovicová et al. 2004; Bryjak et al. 2007; Namdeo and Bajpai 2009; Labus et al. 2011; Huang et al. 2011; Klein et al. 2011). Diethylaminoethyl (DEAE)-modified cellulosic supports have longer storage capacity (Al-Adhami et al. 2002). Cellulose-coated magnetite nanoparticles have been used for starch degradation where the attachment of α-amylase to cellulose dialdehyde-coated magnetite nanoparticles resulted in the formation of a novel starch degrading system (Namdeo and Bajpai 2009). Immobilization with ionic liquid-cellulose film activated by glutaraldehyde gave better formability and flexibility (Klein et al. 2011). Starch Made of linear amylase and branched amylopectin units, starch has been used as enzyme immobilizer. Calcium alginate–starch hybrid supports were applied for surface immobilization and entrapment of bitter gourd peroxidase. Entrapped enzyme was more stable in the presence of denaturants like urea due to internal carbohydrate moieties, while surface-immobilized enzyme had superior activity (Matto and Husain 2009). Radiation grafting of substances like acrylamide and dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate onto starch are among the widely used industrial techniques for a high product yield (Dung et al. 1995; Raafat et al. 2011). Pectin This structural heteropolysaccharide along with 0.2–0.7 % glycerol acts as plasticizer to reduce brittleness of support and has been used to immobilize papain and for development of new materials for skin injury treatment (Ceniceros et al. 2003). Pectin–chitin and pectin–calcium alginate support have enhanced thermal and denaturant resistance and catalytic properties of entrapped enzymes due to the formation of high stable polyelectrolyte complexes between the enzyme and the pectin-coated support (Gómez et al. 2006; Satar et al. 2008). Sepharose CNBr-activated Sepharose-4B has been used to immobilize amylase and glucoamylase owing to its porosity and easy adsorption of macromolecules. Further matrix modifications like alkyl substituted Sepharose with multipoint attachment between hydrophobic clusters of the enzyme and alkyl residues of the support play a major role in retaining the catalytic properties at extremes of pH, high salt concentrations and elevated temperatures (Hosseinkhani et al. 2003). Another example of modified Sepharose matrix is concanavalin A (Con A)–Sepharose 4B where biospecific interaction between the glycosyl chains of the enzyme and Con A plays a pivotal role in fabrication of various biosensors (Mirouliaei et al. 2007). Synthetic polymers as supports Ion exchange resins/polymers are insoluble supports with porous surface for enzyme trapping. Amberlite and DEAE cellulose, renewable matrices with large surface area, have been used for immobilization of α-amylase (Kumari and Kayastha 2011). During white radish peroxidase immobilization, glutaraldehyde and polyethylene glycol act as an additive and protective layer around the active center of the enzyme to prevent the attack of free radicals (Ashraf and Husain 2010). Some synthetic polymers used as enzyme supports are stated as follows: polyvinyl chloride that prevents enzyme, cyclodextrin glucosyltransferase from thermal inactivation; polyurethane microparticles derived from polyvinyl alcohol and hexamethyl diisocyanate in the ratio of 1:3 with high enzyme loading and efficiency; UV-curable methacrylated/fumaric acid-modified epoxy that is proposed to be useful for industrial applications; polyaniline in two different forms, viz. emeraldine salt and emeraldine base powder used for covalent binding of α- amylase; glutaraldehyde-activated nylon for immobilizing lipase and UV-activated polyethylene glycol having high porosity employed for wastewater treatment (Abdel-Naby 1999; Kahraman et al. 2007; Pahujani et al. 2008; Romaskevic et al. 2010; Xiangli et al. 2010; Ashly et al. 2011). Inorganic materials as supports Zeolites Zeolites or ‘molecular sieves’ are microporous crystalline solids with well-defined structures and shape-selective properties and are widely used in molecular adsorption. Microporous zeolites were found to be a better support for α-chymotrypsin immobilization than microporous dealuminized ones because of the presence of more hydroxyl groups that form strong hydrogen bonds with the enzyme (Xing et al. 2000). Likewise, Na Y zeolite was used to immobilize lysozyme because it had higher activity compared to other supports as reported by Chang and Chu (2007). The heterogeneous surface of zeolites with multiple adsorption sites are considered to be suitable for modulating the enzyme and support interactions (Serralha et al. 1998). Ceramics Immobilization of Candida antarctica lipase on ceramic membrane showed that this inert support could be exploited for carrying out hydrolytic and synthetic reactions by limiting feedback inhibition (Magnan et al. 2004). Ceramic foams containing both macro (77 nm) and micropores (45 μm) was found to be efficient in lowering diffusion rate and increasing the specific surface area (Huang and Cheng 2008). Another example of ceramics is toyonite whose variable pore structure can be modified using different organic coatings (Kamori et al. 2000). Celite Celite is highly porous diatomaceous, bioaffinity material and has been used for immobilization of lipase, polyphenol oxidases and β-galactosidase, because it is an inexpensive support having low polarity and large adhesion area (Khan et al. 2006; Liu et al. 2009; Ansari and Husain 2011). It provides resistance against high pH or temperature, urea, detergents and organic solvents (Khan et al. 2006). Celite acts as an additive in sol–gel matrix for ω-transaminases immobilization. It has been preferred due to its chemical inertness and interconnected pore structure (Koszelewski et al. 2010). Silica Enzymes like lignin peroxidase and horseradish peroxidase (HRP) immobilized on activated silica have been effectively used for the removal of chlorolignins from eucalyptus kraft effluent (Dezott et al. 1995). α-Amylase immobilized on silica nanoparticles improves cleaning performance of detergents. They have been used because of their nano-sized structures with high surface area, ordered arrangement and high stability to chemical and mechanical forces (Soleimani et al. 2011). Surface modifications of silica by amination of hydroxyl and reactive siloxane groups and addition of methyl or polyvinyl alcohol groups strengthen enzyme and support bonds (Rao et al. 2000; Shioji et al. 2003; Pogorilyi et al. 2007). Glass Glass is a highly viscous liquid and has been employed in immobilizing α-amylase; phthaloyl chloride containing amino group functionalized glass beads was found to be robust and renewable for the process (Kahraman et al. 2007). Another enzyme nitrite reductase was immobilized on controlled pore glass beads, which served as a biosensing device for continuous monitoring (Rosa et al. 2002). Urease immobilized on glass pH-electrodes has provided a stable biosensor for monitoring as low as 52 μg/ml urea in blood samples (Sahney et al. 2005). Activated carbon Both natural and hydrochloric acid-modified activated carbon has provided valuable support for enzyme adsorption (Alkan et al. 2009). Lately, mesoporous-activated carbon particles containing large contact sites for enzyme immobilization have been used for immobilizing acid protease and acidic lipases where catalytic efficiency has been significantly maintained after 21 cycles of reuse (Kumar et al. 2010; Ramani et al. 2011). It was also found that activated carbon with a high surface area (600–1,000 m2 g−1) and a significant fraction of its pore volume in the 300–1,000 Å range was suitable for enzyme immobilization (Daoud et al. 2010). Charcoal Chemical modification of charcoal by adsorbing papain with sulfhydryl groups increased the number of active sites and has been utilized for recovery of mercury from aqueous solution and efficiently employed for industrial wastewater treatment (Dutta et al. 2009). Charcoal supports have been also used in food industries for immobilizing amyloglucosidase for starch hydrolysis without any cross-linking agent and has 90 % catalytic activity (Rani et al. 2000). As reported earlier by Kibarer and Akovali (1996), charcoal is an excellent adsorbent with high adsorptive capacity and minimum fine particulate matter release. APPLICATIONS AND SCOPE Biocatalysts are the key players in various industrial processes. Constant efforts are being made to improve the enzyme’s activity, efficiency, reproducibility and stability during industrial processes (Wang et al. 2010). Production of regioselective and enantioselective compounds for biomedical application has been possible by immobilized enzymes (Ren et al. 2006; Lee et al. 2009). Glucose biosensors have been developed using electrospun PVA and surface-modified carbon nanotubes (Wen et al. 2011). Hydrogen peroxide biosensors have been devised using γ-aluminum trioxide nanoparticles/chitosan film-modified electrode (Liu et al. 2010). Agarose–guar has been successfully utilized for designing phenol biosensors (Bagal and Karve 2006). Currently, keen efforts are being taken for increasing the stability of biosensors. Immobilization of biosensing enzymes into nanocavities showed significant results (Vamvakaki and Chaniotakis 2007). Biosynthesis of polyester has been facilitated by immobilized C. antarctica lipase B, a greener alternative to petroleum-based conventional catalysts (Idris and Bukhari 2011). With the advent of nanotechnology, silica nanoparticles with immobilized laccase have been applied for elimination of micropollutants from wastewater (Zimmermann et al. 2011). Increasing environmental concerns have led to the use of immobilized biocatalysts for biodiesel production (Jegannathan et al. 2010). The different factors influencing enzyme immobilization and the possible modifications for their enhancement in activity have been chalked out in Fig. 1.Fig. 1Determinants of enzyme immobilization and activity CONCLUSION With the vast array of research on enzyme immobilization, we can conclude that it is one of the most promising techniques for highly efficient and economically competent biotechnological processes in the field of environmental monitoring, biotransformation, diagnostics, pharmaceutical and food industries. Enzyme-based strategies are increasingly replacing conventional chemical methods in both laboratories and industries with attributes like efficiency, quicker performance and multifarious use. However, commercialization of immobilized enzymes is still at a lower pace because of their costs and storage problems. Research should be focused to overcome the current limitations related to immobilization techniques, so as to expand the horizon for all-round application. The authors wish to express their sincere gratitude to Dr. S. Swaminathan (Director, Centre for Nanotechnology and Advanced Biomaterials and Dean, Sponsored Research, SASTRA, Thanjavur) for his constant support and encouragement. Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest. ReferencesAbdel-NabyMAImmobilization of Paenibacillus macerans NRRL B-3186 cyclodextrin glucosyltransferase and properties of the immobilized enzymeProcess Biochem199934399405Al-AdhamiAJHBryjakJGreb-MarkiewiczBPeczynska-CzochWImmobilization of wood-rotting fungi laccases on modified cellulose and acrylic carriersProcess Biochem20023713871394AlkanSGürAErtanMSavranAGürTGenelYImmobilization of catalase via adsorption into natural and modified active carbon obtained from walnut in various methodsAfr J Biotechnol2009826312635AnsariSAHusainQLactose hydrolysis from milk/whey in batch and continuous processes by concanavalin A-celite 545 immobilized Aspergillus oryzae β-galactosidaseFood Bioprod Process2011AshlyPCJosephMJMohananPVActivity of diastase α-amylase immobilized on polyanilines (PANIs)Food Chem201112718081813AshrafHHusainQUse of DEAE cellulose adsorbed and crosslinked white radish (Raphanus sativus) peroxidase for the removal of α-naphthol in batch and continuous processInt Biodeter Biodegr2010642731AteşSDoğanNSProperties of immobilized phenylalanine ammonia lyase and investigation of its use for the prediagnosis of phenylketonuriaTurk J Biochem2010355862BagalDKarveMSEntrapment of plant invertase within novel composite of agarose–guar gum biopolymer membraneAnal Chim Acta2006555316321BetigeriSSNeauSHImmobilization of lipase using hydrophilic polymers in the form of hydrogel beadsBiomaterials200223362736361210968810.1016/s0142-9612(02)00095-9BrígidaAISCaladoVMAGonçalvesLRBCoelhoMAZEffect of chemical treatments on properties of green coconut fiberCarbohydr Polym201079832838BryjakJAniulyteJLiesieneJEvaluation of man-tailored cellulose-based carriers in glucoamylase immobilizationCarbohyd Res20073421105110910.1016/j.carres.2007.02.01417359947Cabrera-PadillaRYLisboaMCFricksATFranceschiELimaASSilvaDPSoaresCMImmobilization of Candida rugosa lipase on poly (3-hydroxybutyrate-co-hydroxyvalerate) a new eco-friendly supportJ Ind Microbiol Biotechnol201110.1007/s10295-011-1027-321870100Cao L (2006) Immobilized enzymes: past, present and prospects. In: Carrier-bound immobilized enzymes: principles, application and design. Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. doi:10.1002/3527607668.ch1CenicerosEPSIlyinaAEsquivelJCCMenchacaDREspinozaJCFRodriguezOEMEntrapment of enzymes in natural polymer extracted from residue of food industry: preparation methods, partial characterisation and possible applicationBecth Mock2003448487ChangYKChuLA simple method for cell disruption by immobilization of lysozyme on the extrudate-shaped Na Y zeoliteBiochem Eng J2007353747ChangMYJuangRSUse of chitosan-clay composite as immobilization support for improved activity and stability of β-glucosidaseBiochem Eng J2007359398ChenGCKuanICHongJRTsaiBHLeeSLYuCYActivity enhancement and stabilization of lipase from Pseudomonas cepacia in polyallylamine-mediated biomimetic silicaBiotechnol Lett2011335255292104619810.1007/s10529-010-0451-1ChenSSongNLiaoXShiBImmobilization of catalase on ferric modified collagen fibersChin J Biotechnol2011271076108122016992ChernJTChaoYPChitin-binding domain based immobilization of D-hydantoinaseJ Biotechnol20051172672751586235710.1016/j.jbiotec.2005.02.001CordeiroALLenkTWernerCImmobilization of Bacillus licheniformis α-amylase onto reactive polymer filmsJ Biotechnol20111542162212153608110.1016/j.jbiotec.2011.04.008CunhaAGFernández-LorenteGBevilaquaJVDestainJPaivaLMFreireDMFernández-LafuenteRGuisánJMImmobilization of Yarrowia lipolytica lipase—a comparison of stability of physical adsorption and covalent attachment techniquesAppl Biochem Biotechnol200814649561842158610.1007/s12010-007-8073-3D’SouzaSFImmobilized enzymes in bioprocessCurr Sci1998776979DaiDXiaLEffect of lipase immobilization on resolution of (R, S)-2-octanol in non aqueous media using modified ultrastable-Y molecular sieve as supportAppl Biochem Biotechnol200613439491689166510.1385/abab:134:1:39DaoudFBOKaddourSSadounTAdsorption of cellulase Aspergillus niger on a commercial activated carbon: kinetics and equilibrium studiesColloid Surface B Biointerfaces201075939910.1016/j.colsurfb.2009.08.01919744839DeyGNagpalVBanerjeeRImmobilization of alpha-amylase from Bacillus circulans GRS 313 on coconut fiberAppl Biochem Biotechnol2002102–10330331310.1385/abab:102-103:1-6:30312396132DezottMInnocentini-MeiLHDuránNSilica immobilized enzyme catalyzed removal of chlorolignins from eucalyptus kraft effluentJ Biotechnol199543161167DiazFJJrBalkusKJEnzyme immobilization in MCM-41 molecular sieveJ Mol Catal B-Enzym19962115126DungNAHuyenNDHangNDCanhTTImmobilization of urease on grafted starch by radiation methodRadiat Phys Chem19954610371042DuttaSBhattacharyyaADePRayPBasuSRemoval of mercury from its aqueous solution using charcoal-immobilized papain (CIP)J Hazard Mater20091728888961969217410.1016/j.jhazmat.2009.07.085ElçinYMEncapsulation of urease enzyme in xanthan–alginate spheresBiomaterials19951611571161856279210.1016/0142-9612(95)93580-7EmregulESungurSAkbulutUPolyacrylamide–gelatin carrier system used for invertase immobilizationProcess Biochem2006382730ErdemirSYilmazMCatalytic effect of calix[n]arene based sol–gel encapsulate or covalent immobilized lipases on enantioselective hydrolysis of (R/S)-naproxen methyl esterJ Incl Phenom Macrocycl Chem2011Flores-MaltosARodríguez-DuránLVRenovatoJContrerasJCRodríguezRAguilarCNCatalytical properties of free and immobilized Aspergillus niger tannaseEnzyme Res201110.4061/2011/768183PMC317176921918717FuJReinholdJWoodburyNWPeptide-modified surfaces for enzyme immobilizationPLoS ONE201110.1371/journal.pone.0018692PMC307300321494577GirigowdaKMulimaniVHHydrolysis of galacto-oligosaccharides in soymilk by κ-carrageenan-entrapped α-galactosidase from Aspergillus oryzaeWorld J Microbiol Biotechnol200622437442GómezLRamírezHLNeira-CarrilloAVillalongaRPolyelectrolyte complex formation mediated immobilization of chitosan–invertase neoglycoconjugate on pectin-coated chitinBioproc Biosyst Eng20062838739510.1007/s00449-005-0043-y16775742HaiderTHusainQConcanavalin A layered calcium alginate–starch beads immobilized β-galactosidase as a therapeutic agent for lactose intolerant patientsInt J Pharm2008359161843977410.1016/j.ijpharm.2008.03.013HernándezMRKispertLRamírezETRosalesDRUlloaRZFerraraFerraraJTElectron paramagnetic resonance analyses of biotransformation reactions with cytochrome P-450 immobilized on mesoporous molecular sieves.Biotechnol Lett2007299199241745032410.1007/s10529-007-9328-3HilalNKochkodanVNigmatullinRGoncharukVAl-KhatibLLipase-immobilized biocatalytic membranes for enzymatic esterification: comparison of various approaches to membrane preparationJ Membr Sci2006268198207HoLFLiSYLinSCHsuWHIntegrated enzyme purification and immobilization processes with immobilized metal affinity adsorbentsProcess Biochem20043915731581HosseinkhaniSSzittnerRNemat-GorganiMMeighenEAAdsorptive immobilization of bacterial luciferases on alkyl-substituted Sepharose 4BEnzyme Microb Tech200332186193HsiehHJLiuPCLiaoWJImmobilization of invertase via carbohydrate moiety on chitosan to enhance its thermal stabilityBiotechnol Lett20002214591464HuangLChengZMImmobilization of lipase on chemically modified bimodal ceramic foams for olive oil hydrolysisChem Eng J2008144103109HuangXJYuAGXuZKCovalent immobilization of lipase from Candida rugosa onto poly (acrylonitrile-co-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) electrospun fibrous membranes for potential bioreactor applicationBioresource Technol2008995459546510.1016/j.biortech.2007.11.00918248984HuangXJChenPCHuangFOuYChenMRXuZKImmobilization of Candida rugosa lipase on electrospun cellulose nanofiber membraneJ Mol Catal B-Enzym20117095100IdrisABukhariAImmobilized Candida antarctica lipase B: hydration, stripping off and application in ring opening polyester synthesisBiotechnol Adv201110.1016/j.biotechadv.2011.10.00222041165IspasCSokolovIAndreescuSEnzyme-functionalized mesoporous silica for bioanalytical applicationsAnal Bioanal Chem20093935435541864210410.1007/s00216-008-2250-2JegannathanKRJun-YeeLChanESRavindraPProduction of biodiesel from palm oil using liquid core lipase encapsulated in κ-carrageenanFuel20108922722277KahramanMVBayramogluGKayaman-ApohanNGüngörAUV-curable methacrylated/fumaric acid modified epoxy as a potential support for enzyme immobilizationReact Funct Polym20076797103KamoriMHoriTYamashitaYHiroseYNaoshimaYImmobilization of lipase on a new inorganic ceramics support, toyonite, and the reactivity and enantioselectivity of the immobilized lipaseJ Mol Catal B-Enzym20009269274KapoorMKuhadRCImmobilization of xylanase from Bacillus pumilus strain MK001 and its application in production of xylo-oligosaccharidesAppl Biochem Biotechnol20071421251381802557410.1007/s12010-007-0013-8KaragulyanHKGasparyanVKDeckerSRImmobilization of fungal beta-glucosidase on silica gel and kaolin carriersAppl Biochem Biotechnol200814639471842158510.1007/s12010-007-8065-3KatwaLCRamakrishnaMRaoMRRSpectrophotometric assay of immobilized tannaseJ Biosci19813135142KawagutiHYManrichESatoHHProduction of isomaltulose using Erwinia sp. D12 cells: culture medium optimization and cell immobilization in alginateBiochem Eng J200629270277KhanAAAkhtarSHusainQDirect immobilization of polyphenol oxidases on celite 545 from ammonium sulphate fractionated proteins of potato (Solanum tuberosum)J Mol Catal B-Enzym2006405863KibarerGDAkovaliGOptimization studies on the features of an activated charcoal-supported urease systemBiomaterials19961714731479885311710.1016/0142-9612(96)89771-7KimJJiaHWangPChallenges in biocatalysis for enzyme-based biofuel cellsBiotechnol Adv2006242963081640361210.1016/j.biotechadv.2005.11.006KleinMPScheerenCWLorenzoniASGDupontJFrazzonHertzPFIonic liquid-cellulose film for enzyme immobilizationProcess Biochem20114613751379KoszelewskiDMüllerNSchrittwieserJHFaberKKroutilWImmobilization of ω-transaminases by encapsulation in a sol–gel/celite matrixJ Mol Catal B-Enzym2010633944KumarAGPerinbamKKamatchiPNageshNSekaranGIn situ immobilization of acid protease on mesoporous activated carbon packed column for the production of protein hydrolysatesBioresour Technol2010101137713791979693410.1016/j.biortech.2009.09.014KumariAKayasthaAMImmobilization of soybean (Glycine max) α-amylase onto chitosan and amberlite MB-150 beads: optimization and characterizationJ Mol Catal B-Enzym201169814LabusKTurekALiesieneJBryjakJEfficient Agaricus bisporus tyrosinase immobilization on cellulose-based carriersBiochem Eng J201156232240LeeDHParkCHYeoJMKimSWLipase immobilization on silica gel using a cross-linking methodJ Ind Eng Chem200612777782LeeCHLinTSMouCYMesoporous materials for encapsulating enzymesNANO20094165179LiSFChenJPWuWTElectrospun polyacrylonitrile nanofibrous membranes for lipase immobilizationJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200747117124LiuCHLinYHChenCYChangJSCharacterization of Burkholderia lipase immobilized on celite carriersJ Taiwan Inst Chem E200940359363LiuXLuoLDingYXuYLiFHydrogen peroxide biosensor based on the immobilization of horseradish peroxidase on γ-Al2O3 nanoparticles/chitosan film-modified electrodeJ Solid State Electrochem201015447453MagnanECatarinoIPaolucci-JeanjeanDPreziozi-BelloyLBellevilleMPImmobilization of lipase on a ceramic membrane: activity and stabilityJ Membr Sci2004241161166MattoMHusainQCalcium alginate–starch hybrid support for both surface immobilization and entrapment of bitter gourd (Momordica charantia) peroxidaseJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200957164170MirouliaeiMNayeriHShariatSZSAtarAMBiospecific immobilization of lactoperoxidase on Con A–sepharose 4BSci Iran200714303307MishraNPithawalaKBahadurAByssus Thread: a novel support material for urease immobilizationAppl Biochem Biotechnol2011165156815762193841910.1007/s12010-011-9376-yMislovicováDMasarovaJVikartovskaAGermeinerPMichalkovaEBiospecific immobilization of mannan–penicillin G acylase neoglycoenzyme on Concanavalin A-bead celluloseJ Biotechnol200411011191509990110.1016/j.jbiotec.2004.01.006MitchellSRamírezJPMesoporous zeolites as enzyme carriers: synthesis, characterization, and application in biocatalysisCatal Today20111682837NamdeoMBajpaiSKImmobilization of α-amylase onto cellulose-coated magnetite (CCM) nanoparticles and preliminary starch degradation studyJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200959134139PahujaniSKanwarSSChauhanGGuptaRGlutaraldehyde activation of polymer nylon-6 for lipase immobilization: enzyme characteristics and stabilityBioresour Technol200899256625701756139110.1016/j.biortech.2007.04.042PerssonMWehtjeEAdlercreutPImmobilisation of lipases by adsorption and deposition: high protein loading gives lower water activity optimumBiotechnol Lett20002215711575PogorilyiRPSiletskayaEYGoncharikVPKozharaLIZubYLImmobilization of urease on the silica gel surface by sol–gel methodRuss J Appl Chem200780330334PopatAHartonoSBStahrFLiuJQiaoSZLuGQMesoporous silica nanoparticles for bioadsorption, enzyme immobilisation and delivery carriersNanoscale20113280128182154729910.1039/c1nr10224aRaafatAIArabyELotfySEnhancement of fibrinolytic enzyme production from Bacillus subtilis via immobilization process onto radiation synthesized starch/dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate hydrogelCarbohyd Polym20118713691374RamaniKKarthikeyanSBoopathyRKennedyLJMandalABSekaranGSurface functionalized mesoporous activated carbon for the immobilization of acidic lipase and their application to hydrolysis of waste cooked oil: isotherm and kinetic studiesProcess Biochem2011RaniASDasMLMSatyanarayanaSPreparation and characterization of amyloglucosidase adsorbed on activated charcoalJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200010471476RaoMNKembhaviAAPantAImmobilization of endo-polygalacturonase from Aspergillus ustus on silica gelBiotechnol Lett20002215571559RaoCSPrakashamRSRaoABYadavJSFunctionalized alginate as immobilization matrix in enantioselective L (+) lactic acid production by Lactobacillus delbrucekiiAppl Biochem Biotechnol20081492192281850058310.1007/s12010-007-8052-8RenGXuXLiuQElectrospun poly(vinyl alcohol)/glucose oxidase biocomposite membranes for biosensor applicationsReact Funct Polym20066615591564RochefortDKouisniLGendronKPhysical immobilization of laccase on an electrode by means of poly (ethyleneimine) microcapsulesJ Electroanal Chem20086175363RomaskevicTVikantieneEBudrieneSRamanavicieneADienysGImmobilization of maltogenase onto polyurethane microparticles from poly (vinyl alcohol) and hexamethylene diisocyanateJ Mol Catal B-Enzym201064172176RosaCCCruzHJVidalMOlivaAGOptical biosensor based on nitrite reductase immobilised in controlled pore glassBiosens Bioelectron20021745521174273410.1016/s0956-5663(01)00263-9SabbaniSHedenströmENordinOThe enantioselectivity of Candida rugosa is influenced by the particle size of the immobilizing support material AccurelJ Mol Catal B-Enzym20064219SahneyRPuriBKAnandSEnzyme coated glass pH-electrode: its fabrication and applications in the determination of urea in blood samplesAnal Chim Acta2005542157161SakaiSLiuYYamaguchiTWatanabeRKawabeMKawakamiKImmobilization of Pseudomonas cepacia lipase onto electrospun polyacrylonitrile fibers through physical adsorption and application to transesterification in nonaqueous solventBiotechnol Lett201032105910622042489010.1007/s10529-010-0279-8SardarMGuptaMNImmobilization of tomato pectinase on Con A–Seralose 4B by bioaffinity layeringEnzyme Microb Tech200537355359SardarMRoyIGuptaMNSimultaneous purification and immobilization of Aspergillus niger xylanase on the reversibly soluble polymer Eudragit(TM) L-100Enzyme Microb Tech20002767267910.1016/s0141-0229(00)00257-x11064049SatarRMattoMHusainQStudies on calcium alginate–pectin gel entrapped concanavalin A–bitter gourd (Momordica charantia) peroxidase complexJ Sci Ind Res India200867609615SerralhaFNLopesJMLemosFPrazeresDMFAires-BarrosMRCabralJMSRibeiroFRZeolites as supports for an enzymatic alcoholysis reactionJ Mol Catal B-Enzym19984303311SheldonRACharacteristic features and biotechnological applications of cross-linked enzyme aggregates (CLEAs)Appl Microbiol Biotechnol2011924674772188750710.1007/s00253-011-3554-2PMC3189406ShenQYangRHuaXYeFZhangWZhaoWGelatin-templated biomimetic calcification for β-galactosidase immobilizationProcess Biochem20114615651571ShiQ-HTianYDongX-YBaiSSunYChitosan-coated silica beads as immobilized metal affinity support for protein adsorptionBiochem Eng J200316317322ShiojiSHanadaMHayashiYTokamiKYamamotoHContinuous surface modification of silica particles for enzyme immobilizationAdv Powder Technol200314231245SinghBDBiotechnology expanding horizons2009IndiaKalyaniSoleimaniMKhaniANajafzadehKα-Amylase immobilization on the silica nanoparticles for cleaning performance towards starch soils in laundry detergentsJ Mol Catal B-Enzym20117415SpahnCMinteerSDEnzyme immobilization in biotechnologyRecent Pat Eng20082195200SzymańskaKBryjakJJarzębskiABImmobilization of invertase on mesoporous silica to obtain hyper active biocatalystsTop Catal20095210301036TümtürkHKaracaNDemirelGŞahinFPreparation and application of poly(N, N-dimethylacrylamide-co-acrylamide) and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-acrylamide)/κ-Carrageenan hydrogels for immobilization of lipaseInt J Biol Macromol2007402812851699736910.1016/j.ijbiomac.2006.07.004VaillantFMillanAMillanPDornierMDeclouxMReyneesMCo-immobilized pectinlyase and endocellulase on chitin and nylon supportsProcess Biochem200035989996VamvakakiVChaniotakisNAImmobilization of enzymes into nanocavities for the improvement of biosensor stabilityBiosens Bioelectron200722265026551714203610.1016/j.bios.2006.10.040WangHYHettwerDJCell immobilization in κ-carrageenan with tricalcium phosphateBiotechnol Bioeng1982141827183810.1002/bit.26024080918548439WangZGWanLSLiuZMHuangXJXuZKEnzyme immobilization on electrospun polymer nanofibers: an overviewJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200956189195WangLWeiLChenYJiangRSpecific and reversible immobilization of NADH oxidase on functionalized carbon nanotubesJ Biotechnol201015057632063048410.1016/j.jbiotec.2010.07.005WenHNallathambiVChakrabortyDBartonSCCarbon fiber microelectrodes modified with carbon nanotubes as a new support for immobilization of glucose oxidaseMicrochim Acta2011175283289WuSCLiaYKApplication of bacterial cellulose pellets in enzyme immobilizationJ Mol Catal B-Enzym200854103108WuLYuanXShengJImmobilization of cellulase in nanofibrous PVA membranes by electrospinningJ Membr Sci2005250167173XiangliQZheLYinglinZZhengjiaZImmobilization of activated sludge in poly (ethylene glycol) by UV technology and its application in micro-polluted wastewaterBiochem Eng J2010507176XingGWLiXWTianGLYeYHEnzymatic peptide synthesis in organic solvent with different zeolites as immobilization matricesTetrahedron20005635173522YusdyPatelSRYapMGSWangDICImmobilization of L-lactate dehydrogenase on magnetic nanoclusters for chiral synthesis of pharmaceutical compoundsBiochem Eng J2009481321ZhaoQHouYGongGHYuMAJiangLLiaoFCharacterization of alcohol dehydrogenase from permeabilized brewer’s yeast cells immobilized on the derived attapulgite nanofibersAppl Biochem Biotechnol2010160228722991957899410.1007/s12010-009-8692-yZimmermannYSShahgaldianPCorviniPFXHommesGSorption-assisted surface conjugation: a way to stabilize laccase enzymeAppl Microbiol Biotechnol2011921691782184751110.1007/s00253-011-3534-6