The Great Cryptogram: Francis Bacon's Cipher in the So-Called Shakespeare Plays =============================================================================== THE TABLE OF CONTENTS. BOOK I. — THE ARGUMENT. PART I. WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLA VS. Chapter I. — The Learning of the Plays, - - - - 13 II. — Shakspere's /Education, - 27 III. — Shakspere's Real Character, - - - .44 IV. — The Lost Manuscripts and Library, ... 73 V. — The Author of the Plays a Lawyer, - - - IC2 PART II. FR-ANCIS BACON THE REAL AUTHOR OF THE PLA VS. Chapter I. — Francis Bacon a Poet, ... I2r II. — The Author of the Plays a Philosopher, - 149 III. — The Geography of the Plays, - - - - 161 IV. — The Politics of the Plays, .... 173 V. — The Religion of the Plays, ----- 196 VI. — The Purposes of the Plays, - - 212 VII. — The Reasons for Concealment, .... 246 VIII. — Corroborating Circumstances, - 259 PART III. PARALLELISMS. Chapter I. — Identical Expressions, - - - - 295 II. — Identical Metaphors, - 335 III. — Identical Opinions, ...... 370 IV. — Identical Quotations, - - . 307 V. — Identical Studies, - - - - - .411 VI. — Identical Errors, ..... 437 VII. — IDENTICAL Use ok Unusual Words, - - 444 VIII. — Identities op Character, - - - - IX. — Identities of Style, ... . 4?i vii viii TABLE OF CONTENTS. BOOK II.— THE DEMONSTRATION. PART I. THE CIPHER IN THE PLA YS. Chapter I. — How I Came to Look for a Cipher, - - - 505 II. — How I Became Certain There Was a Cipher, - - 516 III. — A Vain Search in the Common Editions, - - 545 IV. — The Great Folio of 1623, - 548 V. — Lost in the Wilderness, .... 565 VI. — The Cipher Found, - .... 575 PART II. THE CIPHER NARRATIVE. Chapter I. — The Treasonable Play of Richard II., - - 619 II. — The Treasonable History of Henry IV., Written by Dr. Hayward, ....... 630 III. — The Cipher Explained, - - 639 IV. — Bacon Hears the Bad News, .... 670 V. — Cecil Tells the Story of Marlowe, .... 688 VI. — The Story of Shakspere's Youth, - - - 694 VII. — The Purposes of the Plays, ..... 702 VIII. — The Queen Beats Hayward, .... 709 IX. — Cecil Says Shakspere Did Not Write the Plays, - ' - 718 X. — Shakspere Incapable of Writing the Plays, - - 729 XI. — Shakspere Wounded, ------ 732 XII. — Shakspere Carried to Prison, ..... 740 XIII. — The Youthful Shakspere Described, • - - 756 XIV. — The Bishop of Worcester and His Advice, - 762 XV. — Shakspere's Aristocratic Pretensions, - - - 770 XVI. — Shakspere's Sickness, ..... 784 XVII. — Shakspere the Model from which Bacon Drew the Characters of Falstaff and Sir Tobie, - - - 809 XVIII. — Sweet Ann Hathaway, ----- 826 XIX. — Bacon Overwhelmed, ------ 844 XX. — The Queen's Orders to Find Shakspere, - - 854 XXI.— Fragments, 870 XXII.— A Word Personal, 889 BOOK III.— CONCLUSIONS. Chapter I — Delia Bacon, ------- 899 II. — William Henry Smith, ..... 916 III. — The Baconians, ------- 923 IV. — Other Masks of Bacon, ----- 939 V. — Francis Bacon, - ... 975 ILLUSTRATIONS. Francis Bacon — The True Shakespeare. After the portrait by Van Somer. Frontispiece. William Shakspere. Facsimile of the celebrated Droeshout portrait in the 1623 Folio, ------ - - - 64 Ben Jonson. After the portrait by Oliver, - g6 Gorhambury. Bacon's residence, xto Sir Robert Cecil. - - - - - - - - 193 f ac-simile of a page from the author* s copy of the great folio, - 566 Letter of Lord Chancellor Verulam (Francis Bacon) to the University of Cambridge. Facsimile, ------- 6S0 Queen Elizabeth. After the portrait in the collection of the Marquis of Salisbury, -------- 712 Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex. After the portrait in the collection of the Earl of Verulam, - - 632 William Henry Smith, - - - 920 William D. O'Connor, ------ . 92S Nathaniel Holmes, ... . ^jjb Mrs. Constance M. Pott, ------- 044 Dr. William Thomson, 950 Prof. Thomas Davidson, - - - 958 1 \ BOOK I. THE ARGUMENT "Nay, pray you come; Orif thou wilt hold further argument, Do itinnotex." Much Ado about Abth/ng,II,3. PART I. WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. CHAPTER I. THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE SHAKESPEARE WRITINGS. " From his cradle He was a scholar, and a ripe and good one." Henry VIII., iv,2. IT was formerly the universal belief, entertained even among the critical, that the writings which go by the name of William Shakespeare were the work of an untaught, unlearned man. Addison compared Shakspere1 to the agate in the ring of Pyrrhus, which had the figure of Apollo and the nine Muses pictured in the veins of the stone by the hand of Nature, without any assistance from Art. Voltaire regarded him as a " drunken savage." Pope speaks of him as "a man of no education." Richard Grant White says Shakspere was regarded, even down to the time of Pope, as " this bewitching but untutored and half-savage child of nature." He was looked upon as a rustic-bred bard who sang as the birds sing — a greater Burns, who, as Milton says, " warbled his native wood-notes wild." This view was in accordance with the dec laration of Hen Jon- son that he possessed " small Latin and less Greek," and the state- 1 Wherever reference is had in these pages to the man of Stratford the name will W s|x-l!<\l, as he spelled it in his will, Shakspere. Wherever the reference is to the Plays, or to the real author of the Plays, the name will be spelled Shakespeare, for that was the name on the title pa^cs ot quartos and folios. *3 1 4 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. ment of old Fuller, in his Worthies, in 1622, that "his learning was very little." Fuller says: Plautus was never any scholar, as doubtless our Shakespeare, if alive, would confess himself. Leonard Digges says: The patterne of all wit, Art without Art unparaleld as yet. Next Nature onely helpt him, for locke thorow This whole booke, thou shalt find he doth not borrow One phrase from Grcekes, nor Latines imitate, Nor once from vulgar languages translate. Rev. John Ward, Vicar of Stratford, writing forty-seven years after Shakspere's death, and speaking the traditions of Stratford, says: I have heard that Mr. Shakespeare was a natural wit, without any art at all. Seventy odd years after Shakspere's death, Bentham, in his State of the English Schools and Churches, says: William Shakespeare was born at Stratford, in Warwickshire; his learning was very little, and therefore it is more a matter for wonder that he should be a very excellent poet.1 But in the last fifty years this view is completely changed. The critical world is now substantially agreed that the man who wrote the plays was one of the most learned men of the world, not only in that learning which comes from observation and reflection, but in book-lore, ancient and modern, and in the knowledge of many languages. I. His Classical Learning. Grant White admits: He had as much learning as he had occasion to use, and even more.5 It was at one time believed that the writer of the plays was unable to read any of the Latin or Greek authors in the original tongues, and that he depended altogether upon translations; but such, it is now proved, was not the case. The Comedy of Errors, which is little more than a repro- duction of the Menoechmi of Plautus, first appeared at certain 1 Chap. 19. White, H/c and Genius o/ Shakespeare, p. 256. THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE PLAYS. 15 Christmas revels given by Bacon and his fellow lawyers, at Gray's Inn, in 1594; while, says Halliwell, "the Menoechmi of Plautus was not translated into English, or rather no English translation of it was printed, before 1595." " The greater part of the story of Timon was taken from the untranslated Greek of Lucian."1 " Shakespeare's plays," says White,2 " show forty per cent of Romance or Latin words, which is probably a larger proportion than is now used by our best writers; certainly larger than is heard from those who speak their mother tongue with spon- taneous, idiomatic correctness." We find in Twelfth Night these lines: Like the Egyptian thief, at point of death, Kill what I love.3 This is an allusion to a story from Heliodorus' sEthiopics. I do not know of any English translation of it in the time of Shakspere. Holmes says: The writer was a classical scholar. Rowe found traces in him of the Electro. of Sophocles; Colman, of Ovid; Pope, of Dares Phrygius, and other Greek authors; Farmer, of Horace and Virgil; Malone, of Lucretius, Statius, Catullus, Seneca, Sophocles, and Euripides; Stevens, of Plautus; Knight, of the Antig- one of Sophocles; and White, of the Alcestis of Euripides.4 White says: His very frequent use of Latin derivatives in their radical sense shows a somewhat thoughtful and observant study of that language.5 White further says: Where, even in Plutarch's pages, are the aristocratic republican tone and the tough muscularity of mind, which characterized the Romans, so embodied as in Shakespeare's Roman plays? Where, even in Homer's song, the subtle wisdom of the crafty Ulysses, the sullen selfishness and conscious martial might of broad Achilles; the blundering courage of thick-headed Ajax ; or the mingled gallantry and foppery of Paris, so vividly portrayed as in Troilus and Cressida?* Knight says: The marvelous accuracy, the real, substantial learning, of the three Roman plays of Shakespeare present the most complete evidence to our minds that they were the result of a profound study of the whole range of Roman history, in eluding the nicer details of Roman manners, not in those days to he acquired in .1 compendious form, but to be brought out by diligent reading alone.1 1 Holmes, Authorship of Shakespeare, p. 57. ft / //"<• and Genius ef Shakespeare, p. 31. 3 Life and Genius cf Shakespeare, p. sift. * I! id., p. 357. 8 Act v, scene 1. ' Knight's Shak. biography, p. 538. * AuthorthiP 0/ Shakespeare, p. 57. 1 6 WILLI AM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. And again: In his Roman plays he appears co-existent with his wonderful characters, and to have read all the obscure pages of Roman history with a clearer eye than philosopher or historian. When he employs Latinisms in the construction of his sentences, and even in the creation of new words, he does so with singular facility and unerring correctness.1 Appleton Morgan says: In Antony and Cleopatra, Charmian suggests a game of billiards. But this is not, as is supposed, an anachronism, for the human encyclopedia who wrote that sentence appears to have known — what very few people know nowadays — that the game of billiards is older than Cleopatra.3 Whately8 describes Shakespeare as possessed of "an amazing genius which could pervade all nature at a glance, and to whom nothing within the limits of the universe appears to be unknown." A recent writer says, speaking of the resemblance between the Eumenides of ^Eschylus arid the Hamlet of Shakespeare: The plot is so similar that we should certainly have credited the English poet with copying it, if he could have read Greek. . . . The common elements are indeed remarkable. Orestes and Hamlet have both to avenge a beloved father who has fallen a victim to the guilty passion of an unfaithful wife; in each case the adulterer has ascended the throne; and a claim of higher than mere mortal authority demands his punishment; for the permitted return of Hamlet's father from the world beyond the grave may be set beside the command of Apollo to Orestes to become the executive of the wrath of Heaven.4 Knight5 sees evidence that Shakespeare was a close student of the works of Plato. Alexander Schmidt, in his lexicon, under the word Adonis, quotes the following lines from Shakespeare: Thy promises are like Adonis' gardens, That one day bloomed and fruitful were the next.6 Upon which Schmidt comments: Perhaps confounded with the garden of King Alcinous in the Odyssey."1 Richard Grant White says: No mention of any such garden in the classic writings of Greece and Rome is known to scholars. But the writer of the plays, who, we are told, was no scholar, had penetrated more deeply into the lassie writings than his learned critics; and a recent commentator, James D. Butler, has found out the source of this allusion. He says: 1 Knight's Shah. Biography, p. 528. * Knight's Shah., note 6, act v, Merchant 0/ Venice. • Some Shah. Commentators, p. 35. 6 1st Henry Vl,% i, 6. • Shah. Myth., p. 82. 7 vii, 117-126. • Julia Wedge wood. THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE PLAYS. 17 This couplet must have been suggested by Plato. {Phaedrns, p. 276.) The translation is Jowett's — that I may not be suspected of warping the original to fit my theory: Would a husbandman, said Socrates, who is a man of sense, take the seeds, which he values and which he wishes to be fruitful, and in sober earnest plant them during the heat of summer, in some garden of Adonis, that he may rejoice when he sees them in eight days appearing in beauty? Would he not do that, if at all, to please the spectators at a festival? But the seeds about which he is in earnest he sows in fitting soil, and practices husbandry, and is satisfied if in eight months they arrive at perfection.1 Here we clearly have the original of the disputed passage: Thy promises are like Adonis' gardens, That one day bloomed and fruitful were the next. Judge Holmes2 finds the original of the expression, " the mind's eye/' in Plato, who uses precisely the same phrase. He also thinks the passage of Plato, — While begetting and rearing children, and handing in succession from some to others life like a torch, and even paying, according to law, worship to the gods, — gave the hint for the following lines in Measure for Measure: Heaven doth with us as we with torches do, Not light them for ourselves. He also finds in Plato the original of Lear's phrase, " this same 1earned Theban." Knight thinks the expression, — Were she as rough As the swelling Adriatic seas,3 — was without doubt taken from Horace,4 "of whose odes there was no translation in the sixteetith century." The grand lines in Macbeth, — And all our yesterdays have lighted fools The way to dusty death. (Jut, out. brief candle! — are traced to Catullus. I give the translation of another: Soles occidere et redire possunt. Nobis, cum scmel occidit brcvis lux, Nox est pcrpctuo una dormienda. (The lights of heaven go out and return. When once our brief candle goes out, One night is to be perpetually slept.) That beautiful thought in Hamlet, — And from her unpolluted flesh May violets spring, 5 — 1 Skakesfieariana, May, i88f>, p. 230. 3 Taming of tit, Shrew, i, _•. ft Act V, scene 1. 3 Authorship of Shakespeare, p. 39ft. 4 Ode xix, book iii. 1 8 WILLIAM SUA KSPERK DID NOT WRITE THE PLA VS. seems to have had its original in the lines of Persius: Nunc levior cippus non imprimit ossa, Laudat posterities , nunc non e manibus illis, Nunc non e tumttlo forttmataque favilla Nascuntur viohe ? 1 — which has been translated: Will a less tomb, composed of smaller stones, Press with less weight upon the under bones? Posterity may praise them, why, what though? Can yet their manes such a gift bestow As to make violets from their ashes grow? W. O. Follett (Sandusky, Ohio), in his pamphlet, Addendum to Who Wrote Shakespeare, quotes8 a remark of the brothers Langhorne in the preface to their translation of the Lives of Plu- tarch, to this effect: It is said by those who are not willing to allow Shakspere much learning, that he availed himself of the last mentioned translation [of Plutarch, by Thomas North]. But they seem to forget that, in order to support their arguments of this kind, it is necessary for them to prove that Plato, too, was translated into English at the same time; for the celebrated soliloquy, "To be or not to be," is taken almost verbatim from that philosopher; yet we have never found that Plato was translated in those times. Mrs. Pott has shown in her great work3 that very many of the Latin quotations found in Francis Bacon's sheets of notes and memoranda, preserved in the British Museum, and called his Pro- mu's of Formularies and Elegancies, are either transferred bodily to the plays or worked over in new forms. It follows, therefore, that the writer of the Plays must have read the authors from whom Bacon culled these sentences, or have had ac^essTo Bacon's manu- scnpt notes, or that he was Bacon himself. In the Promus notes we find the proverb, uDiluculo surgere salit- oerrimum." Sir Toby Belch says to Sir Andrew Aguecheek: Approach, Sir Andrew; not to be a-bed after midnight is to be up betimes, and diluculo surgere, thou knowest.4 Again: Qui dissimulat liber non est. (He who dissembles is not free.)5 In Shakespeare we have: The dissembler is a slave.6 1 Sat. i. » Page 7. • Prornus, pp. 31-38. « Twelfth Night, ii, 3. 8 Promus notes, folio 83 C. • Pericles, i, 1. THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE PLAYS. 19 Again, in the Promus notes, we have: Divitice impedimenta virtutis. (The baggage of virtue.) Bacon says: I cannot call riches better than the baggage of virtue. Shakespeare says: If thou art rich, thou'rt poor; For, like an ass whose back with ingots bows, Thou bearest thy heavy riches but a journey, Till death unloads thee.1 Again: Mors et fugacem persequitur virion. (Death pursues even the man that flies from him.) Shakespeare has: Away! for death doth hold us in pursuit.2 And again: Mors omnia solvit. (Death dissolves all things.) Shakespeare has: Let heaven dissolve my life.3 And again: Hoc solum scio, quod nihil scio. (This only I know, that I know nothing.) Shakespeare has: The wise man knows himself to be a fool.4 Again: Tela honoris tenerior. (The stuff of which honor is made is rather tender.) Shakespeare has: The tender honor of a maid.5 Again: Tranquillo qui libet gubernator. — Eras. Ad. 4496. (Any one can be a pilot in fine weather.) Shakespeare says: Nay, mother, Where is your ancient courage? You were used To say, extremity was the trier of spirits; That common chances common men could bear; That when the sea was calm all boats alike Showed mastership in floating.'1 1 M rasure for Measure, iii, 1. *jt/ Htnry I '/., ii, 5. * Antony and ( 'ltopatray iii, 1 * As You Like //, v, i. 0 .(//'.« Writ that Ends UW/, iii, 3. • Cor iota m us, iv, 1. 2o WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Again: In aliquibus manetur quia uon datur ngressus. (In some [places] one has to remain because there is no getting back.) 1 And in Shakespeare we find: I am in blood Stepped in so far, that, should I wade no more, Returning were as easy as go o'er.8 Again: Frigus adurit. (Cold parches.) And Shakespeare says: i Frost itself as actively doth burn.8 Again: Anosce tripsin . (Know thyself.) Shakespeare has: Mistress, know yourself.4 He knows nothing who knows not himself.5 That fool knows not himself.6 I could cite many other similar instances, but these will doubt- less be sufficient to satisfy the reader. II. His Knowledge of the Modern Languages. It furthermore now appears that the writer of the plays was versed in the languages and literature of France, Italy, and even Spain; while he had some familiarity with the annals and tongues of Northern Europe. As to the French, whole pages of the plays are written in that language.7 His knowledge of Italian is clearly proved. The story of Othello was taken from the Italian of Cinthio's // Capitano Moro, of which no translation is known to haye existed; the tale of Cymbeline was drawn from an Italian novel of Boccaccio, not known to have been translated into English, and the like is true of other plays.8 Richard Grant White" conclusively proves that the writer of Othello had read the Orlando Furioso in the original Italian; that the very words are borrowed as well as the thought; and that the 1 Prom tit notes, No. 1361. • Troilus and Cressida, ii, x. 8 Macbeth, fii, 4. Henry V. • Hamlet, iii, 4. • Holmes, Authorship 0/ Shakespeare, p. 58. * Am You Like ft, iv, 1. * Life and Genius 0/ Shakespeare, p. 35. *Alft Well thai Ends Well, M, 4- THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE PLAYS. 2 I author adhered to the expressions in the Italian where the only translation then in existence had departed from them. The same high authority also shows that in the famous passage, " Who steals my purse steals trash," etc., the writer of Othello borrowed from the Orlando Innamorato of Berni, " of which poem to this day there is no English version." The plot of the comedy of Twelfth Night; or, What Yon Will, is drawn from two Italian comedies, both having the same title, GVInganni (The Cheats), both published before the date of Shake- speare's play, and which Shakespeare must have read in the original Italian, as there were, I believe, no English translations of them. The Two Gentlemen of Vero?ia is supposed to have been written several years before 1598, the year when Bartholomew Yonge's translation of the Diana of Jorge de Montemayor was published in England; and Halliwell believes that there are similarities between Shakespeare's play and Montemayor's romance "too minute to be accidental." If this is the case we must conclude that Shakespeare either read some translation of the romance in manuscript before 1598, or else that he read it in the original. Says Halliwell: The absolute origin of the entire plot has possibly to be discovered in some Italian novel. The error in the first folio of Padua for Milan, in act ii, scene 5, has perhaps to be referred to some scene in the original novel. Tieck mentions an old German play founded on a tale similar to The Two Gentlemen of Verona; but it has not yet been made accessible to English students, and we have no means of ascertaining how far the resemblance extends. It further appears that Shakespeare found the original of The Merchant of Venice in an untranslated Italian novel. Mr. Collier says: In the novel II Pecorone of Giovanni Fiorentino, the lender of the money (under very similar circumstances, and the wants of the Christian bom ver arising out of nearly the same events) is a Jew; and there also we have the equal pound Of your fair flesh, to be cut off and taken In what part of your body pleasclh me. The words in the Italian are "che'l Giudeo gli pottsse levare una libra di €€tnu d'addosso di qualumque luogo e' vo/esse," which are so nearly like those ot Shakespeare as to lead us to believe that he followed here some literal translation of the novel in 77 Pecorone. Nunc such has, however, reached our time, and tin- version we have printed at the foot of the Italian was made and published in 1765.' Mrs. Pott, in her great work, calls attention to the following l Introduction to t It? A liTrnt it r,s ,i odd and 1 An Inquiry into (he Learning of Shakespeare. 3 Art ii, lOSM l< 5 Shah; sp.nriana, Oct., 1884, p. 31a. 4 White, SMaAesfieare' s deninx, p. »57. 24 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. extraordinary words, many of them coined by himself, and such as would not naturally occur to an untaught genius, familiar with no language but his own. I give a few specimens: Rubrous, Twelfth Night, i, 4. Evitate, Merry Wives of Windsor, v, 5. Pendulous, King Lear, iii, 4. Imbost, Antony and Cleopatra, iv, 3. Abortive, Richard III., i, 2. -Disnatured, King Lear, i, 4. [ii, 1. Cautelous, Julius Casar, ii, 1. Inaidable, All's Well That Ends Well, Cautel, Hamlet, i, 3. Unsuppressive, Julius Qcsar, ii, I, Deracinate, Troilus and Cressida, i, 3; Oppugnancy, Troilus and Cressida, i, 3. Henry V., v, 2. Enskied, Measure for Measure, i, 5. Surcease, Macbeth, i, 7. Legerity, Henry V., iv, 1. Recordation, 2d Henry IV., ii, 3. Propinquity, King Lear, i, 1. Enwheel, Othello, ii, I. Credent, Hamlet, i, 3. Armipotent, All's Well That Ends Well, Sluggardised, The Two Gentlemen of iv, 3. Verona, i, 1. Knight says, speaking of the word expedients Expedient. The word properly means, "that disengages itself from all entan- glements." To set at liberty the foot which was held fast is exped-ire. Shakspere always uses this word in strict accordance with its derivation, as, in truth, he does most words that may be called learned* * Knight' also notes the fact that he uses the word reduce in the Latin sense, "to bring back." IV. His Universal Learning. The range of his studies was not confined to antique tongues and foreign languages. He must have read all the books of travel which grew out of that age of sea-voyages and explorations. Dr. Brinton* points out that the idea of Ariel having been pegged in the knotty entrails of an oak until freed by Prospero was borrowed from the mythology of the Yurucares, a South American tribe of Indians, in which the first men were confined in the heart of an enormous bole, until the god Tiri let them out by cleaving it in twain. He further claims that Caliban is undoubt- edly the word Carib, often spelt Caribani and Calibani in olden writers; and his "dam's god, Setebos" was the supreme deity of the Patagonians, when first visited by Magellan. In The Merchant of Venice we read: Bring them, I pray thee, with imagined speed, Unto the tranect, to the common ferry.8 1 King John, ii, x. 1 Knight's Shah., i History, p. 24. 1 Richard III., v, 4. 4 Myths 0/ the New World, p. 240, note. • Act iii, scene g. THE LEARNING REVEALED IN THE PLAYS. 25 Of this word Knight says: No other example is found of the use of this word in English, and yet there is little doubt that the word is correct. Tranare and trainare are interpreted by Florio not only as to draw, which is the common acceptation, but as to pass or swim over. Thus the tranect was most probably the tow-boat of the ferry. 1 In King John we have: Now, by my life, this day grows wondrous hot; Some airy devil hovers in the sky, And pours down mischief.'2 Collier changed airy to fiery, "which, we may be sure," he says, "was the word of the poet." But Knight turns to Burton and shows that he described "aerial spirits or devils, who keep most quarter in the air, and cause many tempests, thunder and light- ning," etc. And he also referred to the fact that "Paul to the Ephesians called them forms of the air" Knight adds: Shakspere knew this curious learning from the schoolmen, but the correctors knew nothing about it. We have another instance, in the following, where the great poet knew a good deal more than his commentators. In Romeo and Juliet he says: Are you at leisure, holy Father, now; Or shall I come to you at evening mass ? 3 Upon this Richard Grant White says: If he became a member of the Church of Rome it must have been after he wrote Romeo and Juliet, in which he speaks of " evening mass; " for the humblest member of that church knows that there is no mass at vespers.4 But we have the authority of the learned Cardinal Bona that the name mass was given to the morning and evening prayers of the Christian soldiers. Salvazzio states that the name was given to the lectures or lessons in matins. In the " Rule of St. Aurelian " it is stated that at Christmas and on the Kpiphany six masses are to be read at matins, from the prophet Isaiah, and six from the gospel; whilst on the festivals of martyrs the first mass is to be read from the acts of the martyrs. In his rule for nuns the same holy Bishop tells them that, as the nights are long, they may recite three masses at the lectern. As the female sex could not act as priests, it is plain that the word mass was formerly the 1 Knight'l Shah-. Com., p. 240. 2 Ac t iii, scene v. ;i Act iv, scene 1. * Lift nHtt CtntHS of Shak., p. 187. 26 WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PI AYS. synonym for prayers, and did not mean, as nowadays, exclusively the great sacrifice of the church; and therefore " evening mass" simply means the evening service. In fact, as Bishop Clifford shows, the word mass or, as it was written in Anglo-Saxon, mtcsse, came to be regarded as the synonym for feast ; hence, Candlemas, lammas, Miehaelmas, etc., are the feast of candles, the feast of loaves, the feast of St. Michael, etc. "Moreover, mass being the chief religious service of the Catholic Church, the word came to be used in the sense of church service in general. Evening- mass means evening service or vespers." What a curious reaching-out for facts, in a day barren of encyclopaedias, is shown in these lines: Adrian* Widow Dido, said you? You make me study of that: she was of Carthage, not of Tunis. Gonzalo. This Tunis, sir, ivas Carthage. Adrian. Carthage ? Gonzalo. I assure you, Carthage.1 V. Our Conclusion. We commence our argument, therefore, with this proposition: The author of the plays, whoever he may have been, was unques- tionably a profound scholar and most laborious student. He had read in their own tongues all the great, and some of the obscure writers of antiquity; he was familiar with the languages of the principal nations of Europe; his mind had compassed all the learn- ing of his time and of preceding ages; he had pored over the pages of French and Italian novelists; he had read the philosoph- ical utterances of the great thinkers of Greece and Rome; and he had closely considered the narrations of the explorers who were just laying bare the secrets of new islands and continents. It has been justly said that the plays could not have been written with- out a library, and cannot, to-day, be studied without one. To their proper elucidation the learning of the whole world is neces- sary. Goethe says of the writer of the plays: "He drew a sponge over the table of human knowledge." We pass, then, to the question, Did William Shakspere possess such a vast mass of information? — could he have possessed it? 1 Temfitsty ii, i. CHAPTER II. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. Touchstone. Art thou learned ? William. No, sir. Touchstone. Then learn this of me : to have is to have. As You Like It, v, i. TT must not be forgotten that the world of three hundred years ago was a very different world from that of to-day. A young man, at the present time, can receive in the backwoods of the United States, or Canada, or in the towns of Australia, an education which Cambridge and Oxford could not have afforded to the noblemen of England in the sixteenth century. That tre- mendous educator, the daily press, had then no existence. Xow it comes to almost every door, bringing not only the news of the whole world, but an abstract of the entire literary and scientific knowledge of the age. I. England in the Sixteenth Century. Three hundred years ago the English-speaking population of the world was confined almost altogether to the island of Great Britain, and the refinement and culture of the island scarcely extended beyond a few towns and the universities. London was the great center, not only of politics, but of literature and courtly manners. The agricultural population and the yeomanry of the smaller towns were steeped to the lips in ignorance, rude and barbarous in their manners, and brutal in their modes of life. They did not even speak the same language. Goadby tells us that, when the militia met from the different counties to organize resistance to the invasion of the Spaniards, It was hard to catch the words of command, so pronounced were the different dialects. 1 Simpson says : If cattle-driving was to be interpreted as levying war, all England ai harvest tide was in a state of warfare. The disputes about tithes and bnundaiies weie 1 Goadby, /.'//<,// Sh.tk., p. s ;. 28 WILLIAM SNA KSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. then usually settled by bands of armed men, and the records of the Star-Chamber swarm with such cases.1 The cots or dwellings of the humble classes in Shakspere's time were, as the haughty Spaniard wrote, in the reign of Elizabeth's sister, built "of sticks and dirt." "People," says Richard Grant White, "corresponding in posi- tion to those whose means and tastes would now insure them as much comfort in their homes as a king has in his palace, and even simple elegance beside, then lived in houses which in their best estate would seem at the present day rude, cheerless and confined, to any man not bred in poverty."2 II. Stratford in the Time of Shakspere. The lives of the people were coarse, barren and filthy. Thorold Rogers says: In the absence of all winter roots and herbs, beyond a few onions, a diet of salted provisions, extending over so long a period, would be sure to engender disease; . . . and, as a matter of fact, scurvy and leprosy, the invariable results of an unwholesome diet, were endemic, the latter malignant and infectious in medieval England. The virulence of these diseases, due in the first instance to unwholesome food, was aggravated by the inconceivably filthy habits of the people* Richard Grant White says: Stratford then contained about fifteen hundred inhabitants, who dwelt chiefly in thatched cottages, which straggled over the ground, too near together for rural beauty, too far apart to seem snug and neighborly; and scattered through the gardens and orchards around the best of these were neglected stables, cow-yards and sheep-cotes. Many of the meaner houses were -without chimneys or glazed windows. The streets were cumbered with logs and blocks, and foul with offai, mud, muck-heaps and reeking stable refuse, the accumulation of which the town ordinances and the infliction of fines could not prevent even be/ore the doors of the better sort of people. The very first we hear of John Shakespeare himself, in 1552, is that he and a certain Humphrey Reynolds and Adrian Quiney " fecerunt sterauinarium," in the quarter called Henley Street, against the order of the court; for which dirty piece of business they were " /// misericordia," as they well deserved. But the next year John Shakespeare and Adrian Quiney repeated the unsavory offense, and this time in company with the bailiff himself.* Halliwell-Phillipps says: The sanitary condition of the thoroughfares of Stratford-on-Avon was, to our present notions, simply terrible. Under-surface drainage of every kind was then an unknown art in the district. There was a far greater amount of moisture in the land than would now be thought possible, and streamlets of water-power suffi- 1 .Si hoot 0/ Shak., vol. i, p. 60. * Life and Genius of Shak., p. 17. * Work and Wages, Thorold Rogers, p. 96. * Life and Genius 0/ Shak., p. 21. THE EDUCATION OE WILLIAM SHA KSPERE. 29 cient for the operation of corn-mills meandered through the town. This general humidity intensified the evils arising from the want of scavengers, or other effect- ive appliances for the preservation of cleanliness. House-slops were recklessly thrown into ill-kept channels that lined the sides of unmetaled roads; pigs and geese too often reveled in the puddles and ruts, while here and there were small middens, ever in the course of accumulation, the receptacles of offal and of every species of nastiness. A regulation for the removal of these collections to certain specified localities, interspersed through the borough and known as common dung-hills, appears to have been the extent of the interference that the authorities ventured or cared to exercise in such matters. Sometimes when the nuisance was thought to be sufficiently flagrant, they made a raid on those inhabitants who had suffered their refuse to accumulate largely in the highways. On one of these occasions,, in April, 1552, John Shakespeare was fined the sum of twelve pence for having amassed what was no doubt a conspicuous sterquinarium before his house in Henley Street, and under these unsavory circumstances does the history of the poet's father commence in the records of England. It is sad to be compelled to admit that there was little excuse for his negligence, one of the public stores of filth being within a stone' s throw of his residence. 1 The people of Stratford were densely ignorant. At the time of Shakspere's birth, only six aldermen of the town, out of nineteen, could write their names; and of the thirteen who could not read or write, Shakspere's father, John Shakspere, was one. Knight says: We were reluctant to yield our assent to Malone's assertion that Shakspere's father had a mark to himself. The marks are not distinctly affixed to each name in this document. But subsequent discoveries establish the fact that he used two marks — one something like an open pair of compasses, the other the common cross. - III. Shakspere's Family Totally Uneducated. Shakspere's whole family were illiterate. He was the first of his race we know of who was able to read and write. His father and mother, grandfathers and grandmothers, aunts and cousins — all signed their names, on the few occasions when they were obliged to sign them, with crosses. His daughter Judith could not read or write. The whole population around him were in the same condition. The highest authority upon these questions says: Exclusive of Bibles, church services, psalters and educational manuals, there were certainly not more than two or three dozen nooks, if so many, in the whole town. The copy of the black-letter English History, so often depicted . 1 s well thumbed by Shakespeare, in his father's parlor, ne ver existed out of the Imagination.' 1 Outlines Lift 0/ S/iak., p. 18. 'J Knight's V;,j<. /./.'.<•» 1, j>. 17. ■ HaUlweU-Philllppt, / //;• " A >.«*., p. 4.1. 3o WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Goadby says: The common people were densely ignorant. They had to pick up their mother tongue as best they could. The first English grammar was not published until 1586. [This was after Shakspere had finished his education.] It is evident that much schooling was impossible, for the necessary books did not exist. The horn-book for teaching the alphabet would almost exhaust the resources of any common day schools that might exist in the towns and villages. Little if any English was TAUGHT EVEN IN THE LOWER CLASSES OF THE GRAMMAR SCHOOLS.1 Prof. Thorold Rogers says: Sometimes perhaps, in the days after the Reformation, a more than ordinarily opulent ecclesiastic, having no family ties, would train up some :lever rustic child, teach him and help him on to the university. But, as a rule, since that event, there was no educated person in the parish beyond the parson, and he had the anxieties of a narrow fortune and a numerous family.9 The Rev John Shaw, who was temporary chaplain in a village in Lancashire in 1644, tells of an old man of sixty years of age, whose wThole knowledge of Jesus Christ had been derived from a miracle play "'Oh, sir,' said he, 'I think I heard of that man you speak of once in a play at Kendall called Corf its Christi Play where there was a man on a tree and blood ran down.9 " IV. The Universities of That Day. Even the universities were not such schools as the name would to-day imply. The state of education was almost as unsettled as that of religion. The Uni- versities of Cambridge and Oxford were thronged with poor scholars, and eminent professors taught in the schools and colleges. But the Reformation had made sad havoc with their buildings and libraries, and the spirit of amusement had affected their studies.3 The students turned much more readily to dissipation than to literature. In the year 1570, the scholars of Trinity College, Cam- bridge, consumed 2,250 barrels of beer!4 The knowledge of Greek had sensibly declined, but Latin was still cultivated with considerable success.5 The number of scholars of the university fit for schoolmasters was small. "Whereas they make one scholar they n.arre ten," averred Peacham, who describes one specimen as whipping his boys on a cold morning "for no other purpose than to get himself a heate. " * The country swarmed to such an extent with scholars of the universities, who made a living as beggars, that Parliament had to interfere against the nuisance. By the act of 14th Elizabeth, "all 1 Goadby, England of ' Shak., p. 101. 'Goadby, England, p. 97. 8 Ibid., p. 97. * Rogers, Work and Wages, p. 85. * Ibid., p. 73. 8 Ibid., p. 99. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. 31 scholars of the Universities of Oxford or Cambridge that go about begging, not being authorized under the seal of said universities," are declared " vagabonds," and punishable as such. V. "A Bookless Neighborhood." If this was the condition of the two great "twins of learning," sole centers of light in the darkness of a barbarous age, we can readily conceive what must have been the means of public educa- tion in the dirty little hamlet of Stratford, with its fifteen hundred untaught souls, its two hundred and fifty householders, and its illiterate officials. It was, as Halliwell-Phillipps has called it, "a bookless neigh- borhood." We have the inventory of the personal property of Robert Arden, Shakspere's mother's father, and the inventory of the per- sonal property of Agnes Arden, his widow, and the will of the same Agnes Arden, and any number of other wills, but in them all, in the midst of a plentiful array of "oxenne," "kyne," asheepe," "pigges," "basons," "chafyng dyches," "toweles and dyepers," "shettes," "frying panes," "gredyerenes," "barrelles," "hansaws," "knedyng troghs," "poringers," "sawcers," " pott-hookes," and "linkes," we do not find reference to a single book, not even to a family Bible or a prayer-book. Everything speaks of a rude, coarse and unintellectual people. Here is an extract from the will of Agnes Arden, Shakspere's grandmother: I geve to the said Jhon Hill my best platter of the best sort, and my best platter of the second sorte, and j poringer, one sawcer and one best candlesticke. And I also give to the said Jhon one paire of sheetes. I give to the said Jhon my second pot, my best pan, . . . and one cow with the white rump. "One John Shakspeare, of Budbrook, near Warwick, considered it a sufficient mark of respect to his father-in-law to leave him 'his best boots.' " 1 VI. A Gross Improbability. It would indeed be a miracle if out of this vulgar, dirty, illiter- ate family came the greatest genius, the profoundest thinker, tin- broadest scholar that has adorned the annals of the human race. It is possible. It is scarcely probable. 1 Outlitut Lift of Shah.) p. 183. 32 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Professor Grant Allen, writing in the Science Monthly of March 1882 (p. 591), and speaking of the life of Sir Charles Lyell, says: Whence did he come? What conditions went to beget him? From what stocks were his qualities derived, and why ? These are the questions that must henceforth always be first asked when we have to deal with the life of any great man. For we have now learned that a great man is no unaccountable accident, no chance result of a toss-up on the part of nature, but simply the highest outcome and final efflorescence of many long ancestral lines, converging at last toward a single happy combination. Herbert Spencer says: If you assume that two European parents may produce a negro child, or that from woolly-haired prognathous Papuans may come a fair, straight-haired infant of Caucasian type, you may assume that the advent of the great man can occur anywhere and under any circumstances. If, disregarding these accumulated results of experience which current proverbs and the generalizations of psycholo- gists alike express, you suppose that a Newton might be born in a Hottentot family; that a Milton might spring up among the Andamanese; that a Howard or a Clarkson might have Fiji parents: then you may proceed with facility to explain social progress as caused by the actions of the great man. But if all biological science, enforcing all popular belief, convinces you that by no possibility will an Aristotle come from a father and mother with facial angles of fifty degrees; and that out of a tribe of cannibals, whose chorus in preparation for a feast of human flesh is a kind of rhythmical roaring, there is not the remotest chance of a Beethoven arising: then you must admit that the genesis of the great man depends on the long series of complex influences which has produced the race in which he appears, and the social state into which that race has slowly grown. And it is to this social state, to this squalid village, that the great thinker of the human race, after association, as we are told, with courts and wits and scholars and princes, returned in middle life. He left intellectual London, which was then the center of mental activity, and the seat of whatever learning and refinement were to be found in England, not to seek the peace of rural land- scapes and breathe the sweet perfumes of gardens and hedge-rows, but to sit down contentedly in the midst of pig-sties, and to inhale the malarial odors from reeking streets and stinking ditches. To show that this is no exaggeration, let me state a few facts. Henry Smith, of Stratford, in 1605, is notified to "plucke downe his pigges cote, which is built nere the chappie wall, and the house of office there." And John Sadler, miller, is fined for bringing feed and feeding his hogs in "chappie lane." In 1613 John Rogers, the vicar, erected a pig-sty immediately opposite the back court of Shakspere's residence. For one hundred and fifty years after Shakspere's death, Chapel Ditch, which lay next to the New Place THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE. Garden, " was a receptacle for all manner of filth that any person ■chose to put there."1 It was four or five feet wide and filled for a foot deep with flowing filth. More than one hundred years after Shakspere's death, to-wit, in 1734, the Court Leet of Strat- ford presented Joseph Sawbridge, in Henley Street, "for not car- ring in his muck before his door." 2 The houses were thatched with reeds.3 The streets were narrow, irregular and without sidewalks; full of refuse, and lively with pigs, poultry and ravenous birds.4 The highways were "foule, long and cumbersome." 5 Good bridges were so rare that in some cases they were ascribed to the devil. There was no mail service except between London and a few principal points. The postage upon a letter from Lynn to London was 26s. 8d., equal in value to about $30 of our money to-day. The stage wagons moved at the rate of two miles an hour. Places twelve miles apart were then practically farther removed than towns would now be one hundred miles apart. There was little or no intercourse among the common people. Men lived and died where they were born. There were no carriages. The Queen imported a Dutch coach in 1564, the sight of which "put both man and horse in amaze- ment," remarks Taylor, the water poet. " Some said it was a great crab-shell, brought out of China, and some imagined it to be one of the pagan temples, in which the cannibals adored the devil." There were few chimneys; dining-room and kitchen were all one; "each one made his fire against the reredrosse in the hall where he dined and dressed his meat," says Harrison. The beds were of straw, with wooden bolsters (like the Chinese); the people ate out of wooden platters with wooden spoons. The churches were with- out pews and full of fleas." VII. The English People in the Sixteenth Century. The people were fierce, jovial, rude, hearty, brutal and pugna- cious. They were great eaters of beef and drinkers of beer. We find them accurately described in the plays: 1 Outlims I. i/r of S/niA-., p. .(-••>. 11 Cnudliy's I. h^/.dii/ ,. * Ibid. ■ Ibid., p. 205. 'Ibid. * Ibid., p. 75. 34 WILLI AM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. The men do sympathise with the mastiffs, in robustious and rough coming-on, leaving their wits with their wives; and then give them great meals of beef, and iron and steel, they will eat like wolves and fight like devils.1 They lived out of doors; they had few books, and, of course, no newspapers. Their favorite amusements were bear-baitings, bull- baitings, cock-fights, dog-fights, foot-ball and "rough-and-tumble fighting."3 The cock, having crowed when Peter denied his Mas- ter, was regarded as the devil's bird, and many clergymen enjoined cock-throwing, or throwing of sticks at cocks, as a pious exercise and agreeable to God. There were few vegetables upon the tables, and these were largely imported from Holland. The leaves of the turnip were used as a salad. Vegetables were regarded as medicines. No forks were used until 1 6 1 1 , when the custom was imported from Italy. Tea came into England in 1610, and coffee in 1652. Beer or wine was used with all meals. Men and women went to the taverns and drank together. The speech of the country people was a barbarous jargon: we have some specimens of it in the plays. Take, for instance, the following from Lear: Stewart. Let go his own. Edgar. Chill not go, zir, Without vurther 'casion. . . . Let poor volke passe: and chud ha' bin zwaggerd out of my life, 'twould not ha' bin zo long as 'tis, by a vortnight. . . . Keepe out of che vor'ye or ice try whither your Costard or my Ballow be the harder; chill be plaine with you.3 VIII. A Country School in Shakspere's Time. Halliwell-Phillipps says, speaking of Shakspere's education in "the horn-book and the A, B, C ": There were few persons at that time at Stratford-on-Avon capable of initiating him even into these preparatory accomplishments.4 What manner of school was it in which he received all the edu- cation ever imparted to him ? The following is Roger Ascham's description of schools and schoolmasters in his day, as quoted by Appleton Morgan, in a newspaper article: It is pitie that commonly more care is had, yea, and that among verie wise men, to find out rather a cunnynge man for their horse, than a cunnynge man for 1 Henry V., iit, 7. 9 Goadby's England, p. 69. ■ Act iv, scene 6. 4 Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines Life 0/ SAak., p. 24. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE. 35 their children.1 . . . The master mostly being as ignorant as the child, what to say properly and fitly to the matter.'2 They for the most part so behave themselves that their very name is hateful to the scholar, who trembleth at their coming-in, rejoiceth at their absence, and looketh him returned in the face as his deadly enemy. Mr. Morgan continues: To the charges of undue severity, says Drake, "we must add the accusation of immorality and buffoonery. They were put on the stage along with the zany and pantaloon, to be laughed at."3 As to school books, or other implements of instruction, except the following, viz. (to cite them in the order in which they were prized and employed): First, the birch rod; second, the church catechism; third, the horn-book or criss-cross row. Drake says,4 the thirty-ninth injunction of Elizabeth enacted that every grammar school "shall teach the grammar set forth by King Henry the VIII., of noble memory, and continued in the reign of Edward the VI., and none other." This was the Lily's Latin Grammar, and its study appears to have constituted the difference between a "school" and a "grammar school." Drake adds, "There was, however, another book which we may almost confidently affirm young Shakspere to have studied under the tuition of the master of the free grammar school at Stratford, the production of one Ockland, a panegyric on the characters and government of the reign of Elizabeth and her ministers, which was enjoined by authority to be read in every grammar school." Another text-book which may have been extant was the one referred to by Ascham as follows: " I have formerly seen Mr. Horman's book, who was a master of Eton school. The book itself could be of no great use, for, as I remember, it was only a collection of single sentences without order or method, put into Latin." But the rod was for long years the principal instructor. Peter Mason, a pupil of Nicholas Udal, master of Eton, says he used to receive fifty-three lashes in the course of one Latin exercise. At that temple of learning, and from Dr. Busby's time downward, the authorities agree in giving it the foremost place in English curriculums. In The Compleat Gentleman, edition of 1634, the author says a country school teacher "by no entreaty would teach any scholar further than his (the scholar's) father had learned before him; as, if he had but only learned to read English, the son, though he went with him seven years, should go no further. His reason was that they would otherwise prove saucy rogues and control their fathers. Yet these are they that have our hopeful gentry under their charge." Nay, in 1771, when Shakspere had been dead a century and a half, things were about as he left them. John Britton, who attended the provincial grammar school of Kingston, St. Nicholas parish, in Wilts, about 1771-S0. says that he was taught the " criss-cross row," imparted by the learned pedagogue as follows: Teacher — "Commether Billy Chubb, an' brcng the horren book, (u- ma the vester in the wendow, you Pat Came. What! be a sleepid ? I'll wake ye! Now, Billy, there's a good bway; ston still there, an' mind what I da za ta ye, an' whan I da point na! Criss-cross girta little A, B, C. That's right, Hilly; you'll IOOI1 larn criss-cross row; you'll zoon averg it, Bobby Jiffry ! You'll zoom It .1 scoll- ard ! A's a purty chubby bwoy, Lord love en! " 1 Works, Bennett's edition, p. .m.-. I Ibid., p. 12. 3 Shale, and His I'iiitt-s, vol, i, p. 1)7. * Ibid., p. 36. 3 6 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. IX. English not Taught in the Schools of That Day. And it is very doubtful, as we have seen, whether English was taught at all in that Stratford school. It certainly was not in most of the grammar schools of England at that time. Even White is forced to admit this. He says: For book instruction there was the free grammar school of Stratford, well endowed by Thomas Jolyffe, in the reign of Edward IV., where, unless it differed from all others of its kind, he could have learned Latin and some Greek. Some English, too; but not mucJi, for English was held in scorn by the scholars of those days, and long after.1 It will readily be conceded that in such a town, among such a people, and with such a school, Shakspere could have learned but little, and that little of the rudest kind. And to this conclusion even so stout a Shaksperean as Richard Grant White is driven. He says, in a recent number of the At/antic magazine: Shakespeare was the son of a Warwickshire peasant, or very inferior yeoman, by the daughter of a well-to-do farmer. Both his father and mother were so igno- rant that they signed with a mark instead of writing their names. Few of their friends could write theirs. Shakespeare probably had a little instruction in Latin in the Stratford grammar school. When, at twenty-two years of age, he fled from Stratford to London, we may be sure that he had never seen half a dozen books other than his horn-book, his Latin accidence and a Bible. Probably there were not half a dozen others in all Stratford. The notion that he was once an attorney's clerk is blown to pieces. Where, then, did he acquire the vast learning demonstrated by the plays? X. Shakspere's Youthful Habits. There can be no doubt that the child is father to the man. While little Francis Bacon's youthful associates were enjoying their game of ball, the future philosopher was at the end of a tunnel experimenting in echoes. Pope "lisped in numbers, for the num- bers came." At nine years of age Charles Dickens (a sort of lesser Shakespeare) knew all about Falstaff, and the robbery at Gad's Hill, and had established the hope in his heart that he might some day own the handsome house in that place in which he afterward resided. It was his habit to creep away to a garret in his father's house, and there, enraptured, pore over the pages of Roderick Random, Peregrine Pickle, Humphrey Clinker, Tom /ones, The Arabian Nights, Life and Cenim of Shak.. p. 30. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SUA KSPERE. 37 The Vicar of Wakefield, and Robinson Crusoe. Dr. Glennie tells us of Byron, that in his boyhood "his reading in history and poetry was far beyond the usual standard of his age. . . . He was a great reader and admirer of the Old Testament, and had read it through and through before he was eight years old." At fifteen years of age Robert Burns had read The Spectator, Pope's works, some of Shakespeare's plays, Locke's Essay on the Human Understanding, Allan Ramsay's works, and a number of religious books, and "had studied the English grammar and gained some knowledge of the French." Genius is a powerful predisposition, so strong that it overrules a man's whole life, from boyhood to the grave. The greatness of a mind is in proportion to its receptivity, its capacity to assimilate a vast mass of food; it is an intellectual stomach that eliminates not muscle but thought. Its power holds a due relation to its greed — it is an eternal and insatiable hunger. In itself it is but an instrument. It can work only upon external material. The writer of the plays recognizes this truth. He says, speaking of Cardinal Wolsey: From his cradle He was a scholar, and a ripe and good one, Exceeding wise, fair-spoken and persuading.1 The commentators have tried to alter the punctuation of this sentence. They have asked, "How could he be 'a scholar from his cradle ' ? " What the poet meant was that the extraor- dinary capacity to receive impressions and acquire knowledge, which constitutes the basis of the education of the infant, con- tinued with unabated force all through the life of the great church- man. The retention of this youthful impressibility of the mind is one of the essentials of greatness. And again the poet says: This morning, like the spirit of a youth That means to be of note, begins betimes} How did William Shakspere, the Stratford-on-Avon boy, 4i begin betimes " ? In his fourteenth year it is supposed he left school; but there is really no proof that he over attended school for an hour. 1 Henry I '///., iv, 7. ,J . / uft'tiy tin,/ ( ',',-,'/■, tf> ft, iv, j. 38 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLA VS. White expresses the opinion that "William Shakespeare was obliged to leave school early and earn his living." At sixteen, tradition says, he was apprenticed to a butcher. Aubrey says: I have been told heretofore by some of the neighbors that when he was a boy he exercised his father's trade; but when he killed a calf he would doe it in a high style and make a speech. Rowe, speaking for Betterton, says, " Upon his leaving school he seems to have given entirely into that way of living which his father proposed to him," that of a dealer in wool. Neither the pursuit of butcher or wool-dealer could have been very favorable to the acquisition of knowledge in a rude age and a "bookless neighborhood." But perhaps the boy was of a very studious nature and his industry eked out the poor materials available ? Let us see: There is a tradition of his youth setting forth that in the neigh- boring village of Bidford there was a society — not a literary society, not a debating club like that of which Robert Burns was a member — but a brutal crew calling themselves " The Bidford Topers," whose boast was that they could drink more beer than the " topers " of any of the adjoining intellectual villages. They challenged Stratford, and among the gallant young men who accepted the chal- lenge was William Shakspere. The "Bidford topers" were too many for the Stratford " topers," and the latter attempted to walk home again, but were so besotted that their legs gave out, and they spent the night by the roadside under a large crab-tree, which stands to this day and is known as " Shakspere's crab." As the imagination sees him, stretched sodden and senseless, beneath the crab-tree, we may apply to him the words of the real Shakespeare: O monstrous beast ! — how like a swine he lies.1 The first appearance of the father is connected with a filth- heap. The first recorded act of the son is this spirituelle contest. The next incident in the life of Shakspere occurred when he was nineteen years old. This was his marriage to a girl of twenty- seven, that is to say, eight years older than himself. Six months after the marriage their first child was born. 1 Taming of the Shreiv. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. 39 But perhaps, after this inauspicious match, he settled down and devoted himself to study ? Not at all. The Reverend William Fulman, an antiquary, who died in 1688, bequeathed his manuscript biographical memoranda to the Reverend Richard Davies, rector of Sapperton, in Gloucester- shire, and archdeacon of Lichfield, who died in 1708. To a note of Fulman's, which barely records Shakspere's birth, death and occupation, Davies made brief additions, the principal of which is that William Shakspere was " much given to all unluckinesse in stealing venison and rabbits, particularly from Sir Lucy, who had him oft whipt and sometimes imprisoned, and at last made him fly his native county, to his great ad- vancement." The man who wrote this was probably born within little more than twenty-five years after Shakspere's death. The tradition comes to us also from other sources. The same story is told by Rowe, on the authority of Betterton, who went down to Stratford to collect materials for a life of Shakspere. Rowe says: He had, by a misfortune common enough to young fellows, fallen into ill com- pany, and amongst them some, that made a frequent practice of deer-stealing, engaged him more than once in robbing a park that belonged to Sir Thomas Lucy, of Charlecote, near Stratford. For this he was prosecuted by that gentleman, as he thought, somewhat too severely, and in order to revenge that ill- usage he made a ballad upon him. And although this, probably the first essay of his poetry, be lost, yet it is said to have been so very bitter that it redoubled the prosecution against him to that degree that he was obliged to leave his business and family in Warwickshire for some time and shelter himself in London. A pretended specimen of the ballad has come down to us, a rude and vulgar thing: A parliament member, a justice of peace, t At home a poor scare-crow, at London an asse. If lowsic is Lucy, as some volkc miscalle it, Then Lucy is lowsie whatever befall it. He thinks himself great, Yet an ass is his state; We allow by his ears but with asses to mate If Lucy is lowsie as some volke miscalle it, Sing lowsie Lucy whatever befall it And touching this Sir Th6mas Lucy, Richard Grant White, after visiting Stratford and Chatiecote, speaks as follows: 4o WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. This was a truly kindly nature, we may almost say a noble soul. I am with Sir Thomas in this matter, and if Shakespeare suffered any discipline at his hands,. I believe that he deserved it.1 XI. Shakspere Goes to London. He proceeded to London " somewhere about 1586 or 1587," say his biographers. His twin children, Hamnet and Judith, had been born in February, 1585. We can readily conceive his condition. His father was bank- rupt; his own family rapidly increasing — his wife had just been delivered of twins; his home was dirty, bookless and miserable;, his companions degraded; his pursuits low; he had been whipped and imprisoned, and he fled, probably penniless, to the great city. As his admirer, Richard Grant White, says, " we may be sure he had never seen half a dozen books other than his horn-book, his Latin accidence, and a Bible." There is indeed no certainty that he had ever seen even the last work, for neither father nor mother could read or write, and had no use for, and do not seem to have pos- sessed, a Bible. Says Halliwell-Phillipps : Removed prematurely from school; residing with illiterate relatives in a book- less neighborhood; thrown into the midst of occupations adverse to scholastic prog- ress, it is difficult to believe that when he left Stratford he was not all but destitute of polished accomplishments} To London fled all the adventurers, vagabonds and paupers of the realm. They gathered around the play-houses. These were rude structures, open to the heavens — sometimes the roofless yard of a tavern served as the theater, and a rough scaffold as the stage. Here the ruffians, the thieves, the vagabonds, the apprentices, the pimps and the prostitutes assembled — a stormy, dirty, quarrelsome multitude. Here William Shakspere came. He was, we will con- cede, bright, keen and active, intent on getting ahead in the world,, fond of money, but poor as poverty and ignorant as barbarism. What could he do? XII. He Becomes a Horse-holder. He took to the first thing that presented itself, holding horses at the door of the play-house for the young geotlemen who came to* witness the performance. And this*, tradition assures us, he did. 1 England Without and Within, p. 514. 3 Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines Life o/Shak.y p. 63. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. 41 He proved trustworthy, and the youthful aristocrats would call, we are told, for Will Shakspere to hold their horses. Then his busi- ness faculty came into play, and he organized a band of assistants, who were known then, and long afterward, as " Shakspere's boys." Gradually he worked his way among the actors. XIII. He Becomes a Call-boy, and then an Actor. Betterton heard that " he was received into the company at first in a very mean rank;" and the octogenarian parish clerk of Strat- ford told Dowdall, in 1693, that he "was received into the play- house as a serviture " — that is, as a servant, a supernumerary, or "supe." Tradition says he was the prompter's call-boy, his duty being to call the actors when it was time for them to go upon the stage. In time he rose a step higher: he became an actor. He never was a great actor, but performed, we are told, insignificant parts. " He seems," says White, " never to have risen high in this profession. The Ghost in Hamlet, and old Adam in As You Like Ity were the utmost of his achievements in this direction." It must have taken him some time, say a year or two at the very least, to work up from being a vagabond horse-holder to the career of a regular actor. We will see, when we come to discuss the chro- nology of the plays, that they began to appear almost as soon as he reached London, if not before, although Shakspere's name was not connected with them for some years thereafter. And the earliest plays, as we shall see, were the most scholarly, breathing the very- atmosphere of the academy. XIV. No Tradition Refers to Him as a Student or Scholar. There was certainly nothing in his new surroundings in London akin to Greek, Latin, French, Italian, Spanish and Danish studies: there was nothing akin to medical, musical and philosophical researches. And assuredly his life in Stratford, reckless, improvident! dissi- pated, degraded, does not represent the studious youth who, in some garret, would pore over the great masters, and fill his mind with information, and his soul with high aspirations, There is not a single tradition which points to any such element in his character, Aubrey asserts that, from the time of leaving school until his departure for Warwickshire, Shakspere was a schoolmaster. We 42 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. have seen that it did not require a very extensive stock of learning to constitute a schoolmaster in that age; but even this, the only- tradition of his life which points to anything even akin to scholarly accomplishments, must be abandoned. Lord Campbell says: Unfortunately, however, the pedagogical theory is not only quite unsupported by evidence, but it is not consistent with established facts. From the registration of the baptism of Shakespeare's children, and other well authenticated circum- stances, we know that he continued to dwell in Stratford, or the immediate neigh- borhood, till he became a citizen of London: there was no other school in Stratford except the endowed grammar school, where he had been a pupil; of this he cer- tainly never was master, for the unbroken succession of masters from the reign of Edward VI. till the reign of James I. is of record; . . . and there is no trace of there having been any usher employed in this school.1 Only a miracle of studiousness could have acquired, in a few years, upon a basis of total ignorance and bad habits, the culture and refinement manifested in the earliest plays; and but a few years elapsed between the time when he fled scourged from Strat- ford and the time when the plays began to appear, in his name, in London. Eut plays, now believed to have been written by the same hand that wrote the Shakespeare plays, were on the boards before he left Stratford. The twins, Judith and Hamnet, were born in February, 1585, Shakspere being then not yet twenty-one years of age, and we will see hereafter that Hamlet appeared for the first time in 1585 or 1587. If he had shown, anywhere in his career, such a trait of immense industry and scholarly research, some tradition would have reached us concerning it. We have traditions that he was the father of another man's supposed son (Sir William Dave- nant); and we are told of a licentious amour in which he outwitted Burbage; and we hear of 7f each member of Parliament was betrayed by his tongue; but then the speech of the cultivated 1Oi/////i<:\- Li/t 0/ Shak.y p. 71. 44 WILLI AM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. people of Middlesex and vicinity had become for all England the undisputed stand- ard. Northumberland, or Cornwall, or Lancashire, might have produced Shake- speare's mind; but had he lived in any one of these counties, or in another, like them remote in speech as in locality from London, and written for his rural neigh- bors instead of the audiences of the Blackfriars and the Globe, the music of his poetry would have been lost in sounds uncouth and barbarous to the general ear, and the edge of his fine utterance would have been turned upon the stony rough- ness of his rustic phraseology.1 White seems to forget that the jargon of Warwickshire was well nigh as uncouth and barbarous as that of Northumberland or Cornwall. Appleton Morgan says: Now, even if, in Stratford, the lad had mastered all the Latin and Greek extant, this poem, dedicated to Southampton, coming from his pen, is a mystery, if not a miracle. The genius of Robert Burns found its expression in the idiom of his father and his mother, in the dialect he heard around him, and into which he was born. When he came to London and tried to warble in urban English, his genius dwindled into formal commonplace. But William Shakespeare, a peasant, born in the heart of Warwickshire, without schooling or practice, pours forth the purest and most sumptuous of English, unmixed with the faintest trace of that Warwickshire patois that his neighbors and coetaneans spoke — the language of his own fireside.8 And Shakespeare prefaced the Venus and Adonis with a Latin quotation from the A mores of Ovid. Halliwell-Phillipps, an earnest Shaksperean, says: It is hardly possible that the Amoves of Ovid, whence he derived his earliest motto, could have been one of his school books.8 No man can doubt that the Venus and Adonis was the work of a scholar in whom the intellectual faculties vastly preponderated over the animal. Coleridge notices — The utter aloofness of the poet's own feelings from those of which he is at once the painter and the analyst. Says Dowden: The subjects of these poems did not possess him and compel him to render them into art. The poet sat himself down before each to accomplish an exhaustive study of it. Hazlitt says: These poems appear to us like a couple of ice houses. They are about as hard, as glittering and as cold. It is not possible for the human mind to bring these beautiful poems, written in such perfect English, so cold, so passionless, so 1 Life and Genius 0/ Shak., p. 202. a The Shakespeare Myth, p. 41. • Outlines Life 0/ Shak., p. 63. THE EDUCATION OF WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE. 45 cultured, so philosophical, so scholastic, into connection with the first inventions of the boy we have seen lying out drunk in the fields, poaching, rioting, whipped, imprisoned, and writing vulgar doggerel, below the standard of the most ordinary intellect. Com- pare for one instant: A Parliament member, a justice of peace, At home a poor scare-crow, at London an asse. He thinks himself great, yet an ass is his state, Condemned for his ears with asses to mate. with — Oh, what a sight it was wistly to view How she came stealing to the wayward boy ! To note the fighting conflict of her hue ! How white and red each other did destroy ! But now her cheek was pale, and by and by It flashed forth fire, as lightning from the sky.1 Can any one believe that these two passages were born in the same soul and fashioned in the same mind ? A rough but strong genius, coming even out of barbarian train- ing, but thrown into daily contact with dramatic entertainments, might have begun to imitate the works he was familiar with; might gradually have drifted into play-making. But here we learn that the first heir of his invention was an ambitious attempt at a literary performance based on a classical fable, and redolent of the air of the court and the schools. It is incomprehensible. Even Hallam, years ago, was struck by the incongruity between Shakspere's life and works. He says: If we are not yet come to question his [Shakespeare's] unity, as we do that of " the blind old man of Scio's rocky isle " — (an improvement in critical acuteness doubtless reserved for a distant posterity), we as little feel the power of identifying the young man who came up from Stratford, was afterwards an indifferent player in a London theater, and retired to his native place in middle life, with the author of Macbeth and Lear? Emerson says: Read the antique documents extricated, analyzed and compared, by the assidu- ous Dyce and Collier; and now read one of those skiey sentences — aerolites — which seem to have fallen out of heaven, . . . and tell me if they match.3 . . . The Egyptian verdict of the Shakespcrean societies comes to mind, that he was a jovial actor and manager. I cannot marry this fact to his verse. Othd admirable men have led lives in some sort of keeping with their thought; but this man in wide contrast. . . . This man of men, he who gave the science of mind a new and larger subject than had ever existed, and planted the standard of humanity 1 Venus and Adonis. 2 Introduction to Literature of I it > .yV. AV/. Men, p. -•.>■,. 46 WILLIAM SUA KSPERE DID NOT WHITE THE PLAYS. ity some furlongs forward in chaos — it must ever go into the world's history, that the best poet led an obscure and profane life, using his genius for the public amuse- ment.1 Such a proposition cannot be accepted by any sane man. Francis Bacon seems to have had these plays in his mind's eye when he said: If the sow with her snout should happen to imprint the letter A upon the ground, wouldst thou therefore imagine that she could write out a whole tragedy as one letter ?* 1 Representative Men, p. 215. a Interpretation 0/ Nature. CHAPTER III. THE REAL CHARACTER OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. What a thrice-double ass Was I, to take this drunkard for a god, And worship this dull fool. Tempest, v, I. E have seen that the Plays must have been written by a We have seen that William Shakspere, of Stratford-on-Avon, could not have acquired such learning in his native village, and that his pursuits and associates in London were not favorable to its acquisition there ; and that there is no evidence from tradition or history, or by the existence of any books or papers, or letters, that he was of a studious turn of mind, or in anywise scholarly. We have further seen that the families of his father and mother were, and had been for generations, without exception, rude and bookless. Now let us put together all the facts in our possession, and try to get at some estimate of the true character of the man himself. He was doubtless, as tradition says, "the best of that family." His career shows that he was adventurous, and what we call in America " smart." His financial success demonstrates this fact. He had probably a good deal of mother wit and practical good sense. It is not impossible that he may have been able to string together barbaric rhymes, some of which have come down to us. But conceding all this, and a vast gulf still separates him from the colossal intellect made manifest in the Plays. The probabilities are that he was a usurer. Richard Grant White (and it is a pleasure to quote against Shakspere so earnest a Shaksperean — one who declares that every man who believes Bacon wrote the Plays attributed i<« Shakspere should be committed at once to a mad-house) — Ric h- ard Grant White says: scholar, a man of wide and various learning. I. Shakspere was a Usurer. 47 48 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. The following passage, in a tract called Ratsei s Ghost, ot the Second Part of his Mad Prankes and Robberies, of which only one copy is known to exist, plainly refers, first to Burbadge and next to Shakespeare. This book is without date, but is believed to have been printed before 1606. Gamaliel Ratsei, who speaks, is a highwayman, who has paid some strollers forty shillings for playing for him, and afterwards robbed them of their fee.1 The passage is as follows: And for you, sirrah (says he to the chiefest of them), thou hast a good presence upon a stage, methinks thou darkenest thy merit by playing in the country; get thee to London, for if one man were dead they will have much need of such as thou art. There would be none, in my opinion, fitter than thyself to play his parts; my conceit is such of thee that I durst venture all the money in my purse on thy head to play Hamlet with him for a wager. There thou shalt learn to be frugal (for play- ers were never so thrifty as they are now about London), and to feed upon all men; to let none feed upon thee; to make thy hand a stranger to thy pocket; thy heart slow to perform thy tongue's promise; and when thou feelest thy purse well lined, buy thee some place of lordship in the country; that growing weary of playing thy money may there bring thee to dignity and reputation ; then thou needest care for no man ; no, not for them that before made thee proud with speaking THEIR words on the stage. Sir, I thank you (quoth the player) for this good council. I promise you I will make use of it, for I have heard, indeed, of some that have gone to London very meanly, and have come in time to be exceeding wealthy. This curious tract proves several things: The Shakspereans agree that Ratsei, in the latter part of the extract quoted, referred unquestionably to Shakspere. Ratsei, or the writer of the tract, doubtless expressed the popular opinion when he described Shakspere as a thrifty, money-making, unchari- table, cold-hearted man, "feeding upon all men," to-wit, by lend- ing money at usurious rates of interest, for there is nothing else to which the words can apply. There can be no question that he refers to Shakspere. He was an actor; he came to London "very meanly; " //^ was not born there; he "lined his purse;" he had "grown exceeding wealthy; " he " bought a place of lordship in the country," where he lived "in dignity and reputation." And doubtless Ratsei spoke but the popular report when he said that some others " made him proud with speaking their words on the stage." Let us see if there is anything that confirms Ratsei's estimate of Shakspere's character. Richard Grant White says: The fact is somewhat striking in the life of a great poet that the only letter directly addressed to Shakespeare, which is known to exist, is one which asks for a loan of £30.* 1 Life and Genius of Shakespeare, p. 1^4. * Ibid., p. 123. THE REAL CHARACTER OE WILLIAM SUA A' SEE RE. There is another letter extant from Master Abraham Sturley, 1 595, to a friend in London, in reference to Shakspere lending " some monei on some od yarde land or other att Shottri or neare about us." And there is still another letter, dated November 4, 1598, from Abraham Sturley to Richard Quiney, in which we are told that our "countriman Mr. Wm. Shak. would procure us monei, wc. I will like of." And these, be it remembered, are all the letters extant addressed to, or referring to, Shakspere. In 1598 he loaned Richard Quiney, of Stratford, ^30 upon proper security.1 In 1600 he brought action against John Clayton, in London, for jQ*], and got judgment in his favor. He also sued Philip Rogers, at Stratford, for two shillings loaned. In August, 1608, he prosecuted John Addenbroke to recover a debt of jQ6, and then sued his surety, Horneby. His lawyer, Thomas Greene, lived in his house.'2 Halliwell-Phillips says: The precepts, as appears from memoranda in the originals, were issued by the poet's solicitor, Thomas Greene, who was then residing, under some unknown conditions, at New Place.3 We, of course, only hear of those transactions in which the debtor did not pay, and the loans became matters of court record. We hear nothing of the more numerous instances where the money was repaid without suit. But even these scraps of fact show that he carried on the business of money-lending both in London and at Stratford. He kept an attorney in his house, probably for the better facility of collecting the money due him. No wonder Richard Grant White said, when such facts as these came to light, voicing the disappointment of his heart: These stories grate upon our feelings. . . . The pursuit of an impoverished man, for the sake of imprisoning him and depriving him, both of the power of pav- ing his debt and supporting himself and his family, is an incident in Shakespeare's life which it requires the utmost allowance and consideration for the practice <>! the time and country to enable us to contemplate with equanimity satisfaction is impossible. The biographer of Shakespeare must record these fat ts, because the literary antiquaries have unearthed and brought then) forward as new particulars of the life of Shakespeare. W'c hunger, and wc receive these husks; we open our mouths for food, and we break our teetli against these stones."4 ' Ualliwcll IMiillipps, (hitlitns /.//<■ ,/SkaA., p. 105. ' fold., P- 147. • Ihtd., p. 149. * 1 //•• .»'/./ «.'<•< .<*(., p. 1 .»''. 5o WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Is it possible that the man who described usurers as " bawds between gold and want;" who drew, for all time, the typical and dreadful character of Shylock; who wrote: — I can compare our rich misers to nothing so fitly as to a whale, that plays and tumbles, driving the poor fry before him, and at last devours them at a mouthful. Such whales I have heard of on land, who never leave gaping till they have swal- lowed up a whole parish, church, steeple, bells and all.1 — could, as described by White, have pursued the wretched to jail, and by his purchase of the tithes of Stratford have threatened "the whole parish, church, steeple, bells and all " ? II. He Carried on Brewino in New Place. Let us pass to another fact. It is very probable that the alleged author of Hamlet carried on the business of brewing beer in his residence at New Place. He sued Philip Rogers in 1604, so the court records tell us, for several bushels of " malt " sold him at various times, between March 27th and the end of May of that year, amounting in all to the value of jQi 15s. \od. Malt is barley or other grain steeped in water until it germinates, and then dried in a kiln to evolve the saccharine principle. It is used in brewing.4 The business of beer-making was not unusual among his towns- men. George Perrye, besides his glover's trade, useth buying and selling of woll [wool] and yorn [yarn] and making of malt.3 Robert Butler, besides his glover's occupation, usethe makinge of malt* Rychard Castell, Rother Market, useth his glover's occupation, his wiffe utter- eth weeklye by bruynge [brewing] ij strikes of malte.5 And we read of a Mr. Persons who for a "longe tyme used makinge of mallte and bruyinge [brewing] to sell in his howse."8 There is, of course, nothing dishonorable in this humble occu- pation; but it is a little surprising that a man who in the Plays never refers to tradesmen without a sneer, or to the common people except as " mechanic slaves" " that made the air unwholesome" throwing up " their stinking greasy caps," a " common cry of curs," or " the clusters," "the mutable, the rank-scented many," or " the" beastly plebeians;" and whose sympathies seem to have been always ' Per ides, ii, i. * MS. dated 1595. • Ibid. » Webster s Dictionary. * Ibid. • Ibid. THE REAL CHARACTER OE WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. with the aristocracy, should convert the finest house in Stratford, built by Sir Hugh Clopton, into a brewery, and employ himself peddling out malt to his neighbors, and suing them when they did not pay promptly. Think of the author of Hamlet and Lear brewing beer ! Verily, "the dust of Alexander may come to stop the bung-hole of a beer- barrel." III. Shakspere's Hospitality. And taken in connection with this sale of malt there is another curious fact that throws some light upon the character of the man and the household. In the Chamberlain's accounts of Stratford1 we find a charge, in 1614, for "on quart of sack and on quart of clarett wine geven to a preacher at the New Place," Shakspere's house. What manner of man must he have been who would require the town to pay for the wi?ie he furnished his guests ? And we may be sure the town would not have paid for it unless first asked to do so. And the money was accepted by Shakspere, or it would not stand charged in the accounts of the town. And this was but two years before Shak- spere's death, when he was in possession of an immense income. Did ever any rich man, with the smallest instincts of a gentleman, do a deed like this ? Would even the poorest of the poor do it ? It was, in fact, a species of "going on the county " for help, — a partial pauperism. IV. He Attempts to Enter the Ranks of the Gentry by False Representations. Some one has said: "To be accounted a gentleman was the chief desire of Shakspere's life." Did he pursue this ambition, honorable enough in itself, in an honorable manner? In October, 1596, Shakspere, the actor, applied t<> the College of Arms for a grant of coat-armor to his father, John Shakspere. At this time Shakspere was beginning t<> in. ike money. Ib- bought New Place, Stratford, in 1507. His profession .is a "vassal actor" prevented any hope of having a grant of arms made 1 White, Lifr and Ctntut of Shak., p. 176. 52 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID .VOT WRITE THE PLAYS. directly to himself, and so he applied in the name of his father,, who not long before had been in prison, or hiding from the Sheriff. White would have us believe that the coat-of-arms was granted; but the latest and most complete authority on the subject, Halliwell- Phillipps, says it was not: Toward the close of the year 1599, a renewed attempt was made by the poet to obtain a grant of coat-armor to his father. It was now proposed to impale the arms of Shakespeare with those of Arden, and on each occasion ridiculous state- ments were made respecting the claims of the two families. Both were really descended from obscure country yeomen, but the heralds made out that the predecessors of John Shakespeare were rewarded by the Crown for distinguished services, and that his wife's ancestors were entitled to armorial bearings. Although the poet's relatives, at a later date, assumed his right to the coat suggested for his father in 1596, it does not appear that either of the proposed grants was ratified by the college, and certainly nothing more is heard of the Arden impalement.1 The application was made on the ground that John Shak- spere's " parent and late antecessor, for his faithful and approved service to the late most prudent prince, King Henry VII., of famous memory, was advanced and rewarded with lands and tene- ments given to him in those parts of Warwickshire, . . . and that the said John had married the daughter and one of the heirs of Robert Arden, of Wilmecote." Now, these statements, as Halliwell-Phillipps says, were plainly false. John Shakspere's ancestors had not been advanced by King Henry VII.; and they had not received lands in Warwickshire; and his mother was not the daughter of one of the heirs of Robert Arden, of Wilmecote, gentleman. They had been landless peasants for generations; and John Shakspere was an illiterate farm-hand, hired by Robert Arden, a plain farmer, as illiterate as himself, to work by the month or year. And William Shakspere, who made this application, knew per- fectly well that all these representations were falsehoods. He was trying to crawl up the battlements of respectability on a ladder of lies — plain, palpable, notorious, ridiculous lies — lies that involved the title to real property and the records of his county. Would that grand and noble soul who really wrote the Plays seek to be made a gentleman by such means ? But the falsifications did not end here. • Outlines, p. 87. THE REAL CHARACTER OE WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. "The delay of three years," says Richard Grant White, " in granting these arms, must have been caused by some opposition to the grant; the motto given with them, Non sans droict (not with- out right), itself seems to assert a claim against a denial." Doubtless the Lucys, and other respectable families of the neigh- borhood, protested against the play-actor forcing himself into their ranks by false pretenses. If the reader who is curious in such matters will turn to the two drafts of the application for the coat-of-arms, that of 1596, on page 573 of Halliwell-Phillipps' Outlines, and that of 1599, on page 589 of the same work, and examine the interlineations that were made from time to time, and which are indicated by italics, he will see how the applicant was driven from falsehood to falsehood, to meet the objections made against his claim of gentility. In the first application it was stated that it was John Shakspere's "parents and late antecessors" who rendered valiant service to King Henry VII. and were rewarded by him. This was not deemed sufficiently explicit, and so it was interlined that the said John had " married Mary, daughter and one of the heirs of Robert Arden, of Wilme- cote, in the said county, gent" But in the proposed grant of 1599 it is stated that it was John Shakspere's ^/-^/-grandfather who ren- dered these invaluable services to King Henry VII., and, being driven to particulars, we are now told that this grandfather was " advanced and rewarded with landes and tenementes given to him in those partes of Warwickshire, where they have continued by some descents in good reputacion and credit.'" This is wholesale lying. There were no such lands, and they had not descended by some descents in the family. But this is not all. Finding his application opposed, the fort i It* Shakspere falls back on a new falsehood, and declares that a coat- of-arms had already been given his father twenty years before. And he also produced this, his auneient cote-of-arms, heretofore assigned t<> him whilst he was her Majestie's officer and baylefe of that town. And White tells us that upon tin- margin of the draft "t 1596, John Shakspere Sheweth a patent thereof under Clarrncr Cook's hands in paper, twent] \»-.n- past.1 1 '.iff and Genius 0/ Shakesfleart, p. 1 54 WILLIAM SLLA KSPERE DLD NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. But this patent can no more be found than the land which Henry VII. granted to John Shakspere* s great-grandfather for his approved and faithful services. The whole thing was a series of lies and forgeries, a tissue of fraud from beginning to end ; — and William Shakspere had no more title to his coat-of-arms than he has to the great dramas which bear his name. And living in New Place, brewing beer, selling malt and suing his neighbors, the Shakspere family assumed to use this coat-of- arms, never granted to them, and to set up for "gentry," in the midst of the people who knew the hollowness of their pretensions. And the same man, we are told, who was so anxious for this kind of a promotion to the ranks of gentlemen, wrote as follows: Fool. Prithee, nuncle, tell me whether a madman be a gentleman or a yeoman. L^ear. A king, a king! Fool. No, he's a yeoman, that has a gentleman to his son; for he's a mad yeo- man that sees his son a gentleman before him.1 And that the same man mocked at new-made gentility, in the scene where the clown and the old shepherd were suddenly ele- vated to rank by the king of Bohemia: Shepherd. Come, boy; I am past more children, but thy sons and daughters will all be gentlemen born. • Clown {to Autolyeus). You are well met, sir; you denied to fight with me this other day because I was no gentleman born. See you these clothes? . . . Autolyeus. I know you are now, sir, a gentleman born. Clown. Ay, and have been so any time these four hours. Shepherd. And so have I, boy. Clown. So you have. But I was a gentleman born before my father; for the king's son took me by the hand and called me brother: . . . and so we wept: and these were the first gentleman-like tears that ever we shed." And that the same man wrote: By the Lord, Horatio, these three years I have taken note of it: the age is grown so picked that the toe of the peasant comes so near the heel of the courtier that he galls his kibe.3 And this is the man, we are told, who also wrote: Let none presume % To wear an undeserved dignity. Oh, that estates, degrees and offices Were not derived corruptly ! and that clear honor Were purchased by the merit of the wearer ! How many then should cover that stand bare; ■ Lear, iii, 6. * Winter s Tale, V, 3. 3 Hamlet, V, t. THE REAL CHARACTER OF WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE. How many be commanded that command; How much low peasantry would then be gleaned From the true seed of honor; and how much honor Picked from the chaff and ruin of the times To be new-varnish'd.1 Is there any man who loves the memory of the real Shake- speare— gentle, thoughtful, learned, humane, benevolent, with a mind loftier and wider than was ever before conferred on a child of earth — who can believe that he would be guilty of such prac- tices, even to obtain a shabby gentility in the dirty little village of Stratford ? All this may not perhaps strike an American with its full force. In this country every well-dressed, well-behaved man is a gentle- man. But in England in the sixteenth century it meant a great deal more. It signified a man of gentle blood. A great and impass- able gulf lay between "the quality," "the gentry," the hereditary upper class, and the common herd who toiled for a living. It required all the power of Christianity to faintly enforce the idea that they were made by the same God and were of one flesh. The distinction, in the England of 1596, between the yeoman and the gentleman, was almost as wide as the difference to-day in America between the white man and the black man; and the mulatto who would try to pass himself off as a white man, and would support his claim by lies and forgeries, will give us some conception of the nature of this attempt made by William Shak- spere in 1596. V. The House in Which he Was Born. As to this I will simply quote what Richard Grant White says of it: My heart sank within me as I looked around upon the rude, mean dwelling- place of him who had filled the world with the splendor of his imaginings. It is called a house, and any building intended for a dwelling-place is a house; but the interior of this one is hardly that of a rustic cottage; it is almost that of a hovel — poverty-stricken, squalid, kennel-like. A house so cheerless and comfortless 1 hail not seen in rural England. The poorest, meanest farm-house that I had ever entered in New England or on Long Island was a more cheerful habitation. And amid these sordid surroundings William Shakespeare grew to early manhood ! I thought of stately Charlecote, the home of the 1. 11. y% who WtXt but simple country gentlemen; and then for the first time I knew and felt from how low a condition Ol I Merchant 0/ Vtniety ii, <>• 56 WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. life Shakespeare had arisen. For his family were not reduced to this; they had risen to it. This was John Shakespeare's home in the days of his brief prosperity, and, when I compared it with my memory of Charlecote, I knew that Shakespeare himself must have felt what a sham was the pretension of gentry set up for his father, when the coat-of-arms was asked and obtained by the actor's money from the Heralds' College — that coat-of-arms which Shakespeare prized because it made him "a gentleman" by birth! This it was, even more than the squalid appearance of the place, that saddened me. For I felt that Shakespeare himself must have known how well founded was the protest of the gentlemen who com- plained that Clarencieux had made the man who lived in that house a gentleman of coat-armor.1 VI. His Name. The very name, Shakspere, was in that day considered the quin- tessence of vulgarity. My friend William D. O'Connor, the author of Hamlet's Note Book, calls my attention to a recent number of The London Academy, in which a Mr. Lupton proves that in Eliza- beth's time the name Shakspere was considered vile, just as Kams- bottom, or Snooks, or Hogsflesh would be with us; and men who had it got it changed by legislation. Mr. Lupton gives one case where a man called Shakspere had his name altered by law to Saunders. VII. He Combines with Others to Oppress and Impoverish the People. But there is one other feature of Shakspere's biography which throws light upon his character. From remote antiquity in England the lower classes possessed certain rights of common in tracts of land. Prof. Thorold Rogers says: The arable land of the manor was generally communal, i.e., each of the ten- ants possessed a certain number of furrows in a common field, the several divis- ions being separated by balks of unplowed ground, on which the grass was suf- fered to grow. The system, which was almost universal in the thirteenth century, has survived in certain districts up to living memory.* This able writer shows that the condition of labor steadily improved in England up to the reign of Henry VIII., and from that period it steadily declined to recent times. He makes this remark- able statement in the preface to his work: I have attempted to show that the pauperism and the degradation of the English laborer were the result of a series of acts of Parliament and acts of gov- ernment, which were designed or adopted with the express purpose of compelling the 1 England 11' it /tout ami Within, p. 52ft. > Work ami Wages, p. 88. THE REAL CHARACTER OE IV ILL! AM SHAKSPERE. 57 laborer to work at the lowest rate of wages possible, and which succeeded at last in effecting their purpose.1 Among these acts were those giving the Courts of Quarter Sessions the right to fix the wages of laborers; and, hence, as Prof. Rogers shows, while the inflowing gold and silver of Mexico and Peru were swelling the value of all forms of property in England, the value of labor did not rise in proportion; and the common people fell into that awful era of poverty, wretchedness, degrada- tion, crime, and Newgate-hanging by wholesale, which mark the reigns of Henry VIII. and his children. As part of the same scheme of oppression of the humble citi- zens by those who wielded the power of government, a system of inclosures of common lands by the landlords, without any com- pensation to the tenants, was inaugurated, and aided greatly to swell the general misery. The benevolent soul of Francis Bacon took part against this oppression. In his History of Henry VII. he said: Another statute was made of singular policy for the population apparently, and (if it be thoroughly considered) for the soldiery and military forces of the realm. Inclosures at that time began to be more frequent, whereby arable land (which could not be manured without people and families) was turned into pas- ture, which was easily rid by a few herdsmen; and tenancies for years, lives and at will (whereupon much of the yeomanry lived) were turned into demesnes. . . . The ordinance was that, That all houses of husbandry that were used with twenty acres of ground and upward should be maintained and kept up forever, together with a competent proportion of land to be used and occupied with them, and in no wise to be severed from them. . . . This did wonderfully concern the might and mannerhood of the kingdom, to have farms as it were of a standard sufficient to maintain an able body out of penury. In 1597 Francis Bacon, then a member of Parliament, made a speech, of which we have a very meager report: Mr. Bacon made a motion against depopulation of towns and houses of hus- bandry, and for the maintenance of husbandry and tillage. And to this purpose he brought in two bills, as he termed it, not drawn with a polished pen, but with .1 polished heart. . . . And though it may be thought ill and very prejudicial t<> lords that have enclosed great grounds, and pulled down even whole towns, and converted them to sheep pastures, yet, considering tin- increase of the people, and the benefit of the commonwealth, I doubt not but every man will deem the revival of former moth-eaten laws in this point a praiseworthy thing. For in matters ol policy ill is not to be thought ill, which bringeth forth good. For enclot Ult "t grounds brings depopulation, which brings forth first, idleness; secondly. deca\ of tillage; thirdly, subversion of homes, and deCfCMC wit It was for gentle Shakespeare cut; As well 'in brasse, .is he hath hit Wherein the Graver had a strife His face, the 1'rinl would then BUTpaStt V V i 1 1 1 nature, to out-doo the life: All thai was ever writ in braste, Hut since he cannot, Reader, looke Not on his Picture, but 1 1 1 ^ Booke THE REAL CHARACTER OR WILLIAM SUA K SRERE. Like Shakspere of Stratford, his family consisted of girls, and he was not by any means as wealthy as Shakspere. Did he leave his daughters to sign their names with hieroglyphics ? No. Macaulay says: Katherine, who became Lady Killigrew, wrote Latin hexameters and pentam- eters which would appear with credit in the Musce Etonenses. Mildred, the wife of Lord Burleigh, was described by Roger Ascham as the best Greek scholar among the young women of England, Lady Jane Grey always excepted. Anne, the mother of Francis Bacon, was distinguished both as a linguist and a theologian. She corresponded in Greek with Bishop Jewell, and translated his Apologia from the Latin so correctly that neither he nor Archbishop Parker could suggest a single alteration. She also translated a series of sermons on fate and free will from the Tuscan of Bernardo Ochino.1 They were not alone. There were learned and scholarly women in England in those days, and many of them, as there have been in all ages since. Macaulay says: The fair pupils of Ascham and Aylmer who compared, over their embroidery, the styles of Isocrates and Lysias, and who, while the horns were sounding and the dogs in full cry, sat in the lonely oriel with eyes riveted to that immortal page which tells how meekly and bravely the first great martyr of intellectual liberty took the cup from his weeping jailer.2 It is not surprising that William Shakspere, poacher, fugitive, vagabond, actor, manager, brewer, money-lender, land-grabber, should permit one of his two children to grow up in gross ignor- ance, but it is beyond the compass of the human mind to believe that the author of Hamlet and Lear could have done so. He indi- cates in one of his plays how a child should be trained. Speaking of King Leonatus, in Cymbeline, he says: Put him to all the learnings that his time Could make him receiver of ; which he took As we do air, fast as 'twas ministered, and In his spring became a harvest.'1 If Judith had been the child of the author of the Plays, and had "something of Shakespeare in her," she would have resented and struggled out of her shameful condition ; her mind would have sought the light as the young oak forces its way upward through the brush-wood of the forest. She would have replied tO her neg- lectful father as Portia did: ' Macaulay's Aa.wm'v, />'>i, p. • Ibid., p. 347. 1 ( 'ymSrlimf, i, 1 . 66 HILL/ AM SIIAA'SPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Rut the full sum of me Is sum of nothing, which to term in gross Is an unlessoned girl, unschooled, unpracticed ; Happy in this, she is not yet so old But she may learn ; happier than this, She is not bred so dull but she can learn ; Happiest of all, is, that her gentle spirit Commits itself to yours to be directed, As from her lord, her governor, her king.1 But if she was the natural outcome of ages of ignorance, developed in a coarse and rude state of society, and the daughter of a cold-blooded man, who had no instinct but to make money, we can readily understand how, in the midst of wealth, and under the shadow of the school-house, she grew up so grossly ignorant. XI. . Shakspf.re's Family. There seems to have been something wrong about the whole breed. In 1613, Shakspere being yet alive, Dr. Hall, his son-in-law, husband of his daughter Susanna, brought suit in the ecclesiastical court against one John Lane, for reporting that his wife "had the runninge of the raynes, and had bin naught with Rafe Smith and John Palmer." I Ialli well-Phillipps says: The case was heard at Worcester on July the 15th, 1613, and appears to have been conducted somewhat Mysteriously, the deposition of Robert Whatcot, the poet's intimate friend, being the only evidence recorded, and throwing no substantial light on the merits of the dispute* Nevertheless, the defendant was excommunicated. This being the case of the oldest daughter, the other, the pot- hook heiress, does not seem to have been above suspicion. Judith's marriage with Thomas Quiney was a mysterious and hurried one. Phillipps says: There appears to have been some reason for accelerating this event, for they were married without a license, and were summoned a few weeks afterward to the ecclesiastical court at Worcester to atone for the offense.3 Ignorance, viciousness, vulgarity and false pretenses seem to have taken possession of New Place. Not a glimpse of anything that might tell a different story escapes the ravages of time. * Merchant of Venice, iii, ?. * Outlines Li/e of Shak., p. 166. ■ Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines Life of Shak. % p. 182. THE REAL CHARACTER OF WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. 67 Appleton Morgan says: It is simply impossible to turn one's researches into any channel that leads into the vicinity of Stratford without noticing the fact that the Shakspere family left in the neighborhood where it flourished one unmistakable trace, familiar in all cases of vulgar and illiterate families, namely, the fact that they never knew or cared, or made an effort to know, of what vowels or consonants their own name was composed, or even to prepare the skeleton of its pronunciation. They answered — and made their marks — indifferently to Saxpir, or Chaksper, or to any other of the thirty forms given by Mr. Grant White, or the fifty-five forms which another gentleman has been able to collect.1 Even the very tombs of the different members of the family pre- sent different renderings of the name. Under the bust it is Shak- speare, while he signed the will as Shakspere; over the grave of Susanna it is Shakspere; over the other members of the family it is Shakespeare. In short, the name was nothing. They Answered to " Hi! " Or any loud cry. XII. The Origin of the Name. We have been taught to believe that the name was Shakespeare, and it has been suggested that this was a reminiscence of that " late antecessor " who rendered such valuable services to the late King Henry VII.; that he shook a speare in defense of the King so potently that he was ever after known as Shakespeare. It is in this way the name is printed in all the publications put forth in Shak- spere's lifetime. But it is no less certain that this name is another imposture. There never was a "shake " to it; and possibly never a "speare." The name was Shak-speare, or speer, or spur, or pierret the first syllable rhyming to back and not to bake. Shakespeare was doubtless an invention of the man who assumed the name at a later date as a mask, and he wanted something that would " heroically sound." The fictitious speare passed to the fraud- ulent coat-of-arms. In the bond given to enable William to many, he is called "William Shakspere." In the bill of complaint of is«S() of John Shakspere in connection with the Wilmecote property, his son is alluded to as " William Shackespere." The father signs his cross to a deed to Robert Webb, in which he is described as " John Sliax- I Tk* ShakttPtar* Myth, p. 160. 68 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID XOT WRITE THE TLA VS. pere;" and his mother makes her mark as " Marye Shaksper." His father is mentioned in the will of John Webbe, in 1573, as "John Schackspere." In 1567 he is alluded to in the town records as "Mr. Shakspyr," and when elected high bailiff, in 1568, he is referred to as "Mr. John Shaky sper." The only letter extant addressed to Shakspere was written October 25, 1598, by Richard Quiney, his townsman, and it is addressed to "Mr. Wm. Shackespere." In 1594-5 he is referred to in the court record as "Shaxberd." In 1598 he is referred to in the corporation records of Stratford as selling them a load of stone: "Paid to Mr. Shaxpere for on lod of ston x d." In his will the attorney writes it " Schackspeare," and the man himself signed his name Shakspere. Hallam says: The poet and his family spelt their name Shakspere, and to this spelling there are no exceptions in his own autographs. The name is spelled by his townsman, Master Abraham Sturley, in 1599, S/ia&spere, and in 1598 he alludes to him as "Mr. William Shak." And when he himself petitioned the court in chancery in 161 2, in reference to his tithes, he described himself as "William Schackspeare." White says: In the irregular, phonographic spelling of antiquity, the name appears some- times as Chacksper and Shaxpur. It is possible that Shakespeare is a corruption of some name of a more peaceful meaning, and therefore perhaps of humbler derivation.1 It has been suggested, and with a good deal of probability, that the original name was Jacques-Pierre, pronounced Chacks- pere, or Shaks-pere. The French Jacques (James) seems, by some mutation, to have been transformed in England into "a nickname or diminutive for John." 2 Thus it may be that the original progenitor of this grandilo- quent, martial cognomen, which "doth like himself heroically sound," may have been, in the first instance, a peasant without a family name, and known as plain Jack-Peter. 1 White. Life and Genius of Shak., p. 5. * Sec Webster's Unabridged Dictionary, p. 722, the word Jack. THE REAL CHARACTER OE WILLIAM SHAKSPERE. 69 XIII. His Humiliation. Despite his wealth, his position in his native town could not have been a very pleasant one. In 1602, and again in 1612, the very year in which we are told Shakspere returned to Stratford to spend the rest of his life, the most stringent measures were taken by the corpo- ration to prevent the performance of plays. The pursuit in which he had made his money was thus stamped by his fellow townsmen as something shameful and degrading. Even this dirty little village repudiated it. The neighboring aristocracy must have turned up their noses and laughed long and loud at the plebeian's son setting up a coat-of-arms. By profession he was, by the statutes of his country, a "vagabond," and had, in the past, only escaped arrest as such by entering himself as a servitor, or servant, to some nobleman. The vagabond, according to the statutes, was to "be stripped naked, from the middle upwards, and to be whipped until his body was bloody, and to be sent from parish to parish, the next straight way, to the place of his birth."1 He was buried in the chancel of the church, not as recogni- tion of his greatness, but because that locality was "the legal and customary burial-place for the owners of the tithes."2 XIV. His Handwriting. The very signature of Shakspere has provoked discussion. The fact that the will as originally drawn read, "witness my seal," and that the "seal" was erased and "hand" written in, lias been cited to prove that the lawyer who drew the will believed that the testator could not read or write. In an article in The Quarterly Review in 1871, we read: If Shakspere's handwriting was at all like his signature, it was by no means easy to decipher. IT we may speak dogmatically upon such slender proofs as we now |><>s sess, he learnt to write after the old German text-hand then in use at the grammar school of Stratford. It was in this respect fifty years behindhand, ;is any one may see by comparing Shakspere's signature with that of Sir Thomas Lucy, Lord Bacon, or John Lilly. The wonder is how with such •<> much. Mr. William Henry Burr, <»f Washington, D. C, lias written an interesting pamphlet, to prove that Shakspere could not read or write, but simply traced his name from a COpy set him; and that. 1 Knight'i Fllust. Stinks.^ />,/<,•.. i, p. it '* ( W//«f.f /. //"<• •'/ \/ttiA., p. 171. WILLIAM SUA KSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. as the copy furnished him at different times was written by differ- ent hands, there is a great difference in the shape of the letters composing his name. Certain it is his autographs do not look like the work of a schol- arly man. The following cut is a representation of all the signatures known, beyond question, to have been written by Shakspere: Pa At The first is from Malone's facsimile of a mortgage deed which has been lost; the second is from a conveyance in the possession of the corporation of London; the other three are from the three sheets of paper constituting his will. Compare the foregoing scrawls with the clear and scholarly writing of Ben Jonson, affixed in 1604-5 to a copy of his Mask of Blackness, and now preserved in the British Museum: Or compare them with the handwriting of the famous and popular John Lyly, the author of Euphues, written about 1580: THE REAL CHARACTER OE WILLIAM SUA EST ERE. Or compare them with the following signature of Francis Bacon: Or compare them with the signature of the famous Inigo Jones, who assisted in getting up the scenery and contrivances for masks at court: XV. His Death. Let us pass to another point. We saw that the first recorded fact in reference to the Stratford boy was a drunken bout in which he lost consciousness, and lay out in the fields all night. The history of his life terminates with a sim- ilar event. Halliwell-Phillipps thus gives the tradition: It is recorded that the party was a jovial one, and, according to a somewhat late but apparently reliable tradition, when the great dramatist was returning to New Place in the evening, he had taken more wine tlian ^uis conducive to pedestrian accuracy.- Shortly or immediately afterwards, he was seized by the lamentable fever which terminated fatally on Friday, April 23. The cause of the malady, then att^buted to undue festivity, would now he readily discernible in the wretched Ban itary conditions surrounding his residence. If truth, and not romance, is to he- invoked, were there the woodbine and the sweet honeysuckle w ithin reach ol the poet's death-bed, their fragrance would have been neutralized by their vicinity to middens, fetid water-courses, mud-walls and piggeries.' > Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines Li/* 0/ S/ml., |>. 17a 72 WILLIAM SIIAK'SPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. And from such a cause, and in the midst of such surroundings, we are told, died the greatest man of his race; leaving behind him not a single tradition or memorial that points to learning, culture, refinement, generosity, elevation of soul or love of humanity. If he be in truth the author of the Plays, then indeed is it one of the most inexplicable marvels in the history of mankind. As Emerson says, " I cannot man y the facts to his verse." • CHAPTER IV. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. Come, and take choice of all my library, And so beguile thy sorrow. fit us A ndronicus, iv% /. THE whole life of Shakspere is shrouded in mystery. Richard Grant White says: We do not know positively the date of Shakespeare's birth, or the house in which he first saw the light, or a single act of his life from the day of his baptism to the month of his obscure and suspicious marriage. We are equally ignorant of the date of that event, and of all else that befell him from its occurrence until we find him in London; and when he went there we are not sure, or when he finally returned to Stratford. . . . Hardly a word that he spoke has reached us, and not a familiar line from his hand, or the record of one interview at which he was present.1 And, again, the same writer says: From early manhood to maturity he lived and labored and throve in the chief city of a prosperous and peaceful country, at a period of high intellectual and moral development. His life was passed before the public in days when the pen recorded scandal in the diary, and when the press, though the daily newspaper did not yet exist, teemed with personality. Yet of Dante, driven in haughty wretched- ness from city to city, and singing his immortal hate of his pursuers as he fled, we know more than we do of Shakespeare, the paucity of whose personal memorials is so extreme that he has shared with the almost mythical Homer the fortune of having the works which made his name immortal pronounced medleys, in the com- position of which he was but indirectly and partially concerned. - Hallam says: Of William Shakespeare it may be truly said we know scarcely anything. . . . While I laud the labors of Mr. Collier, Mr. Hunter and other collectors of sue h crumbs, I am not sure that we should not venerate Shakespeare as ninth if they had left him undisturbed in his obscurity. To be told that he played a trick Oil ■ brother player in a licentious amour, or that he died of a drunken frolic, does not exactly inform us of the man who wrote Lear, it there was a Shakespeare ol earth there was also one of heaven, and it is of him that we desire to know some- thing.8 This is certainly extraordinary. It was an age of threat men, 1 White, Lift ii'ii/ Gtniut o/Shak.^ p, \ "■ [bid., p. i. 1 /«/»■,.,/«, /'>'» H LfttntWH /'*• /.-. 73 74 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. Richard Grant White says: Unlike Dante, unlike Milton, unlike Goethe, unlike the great poets and trage- dians of Greece and Rome, Shakespeare left no trace upon the political, or even the social life of his era. Of his eminent countrymen, Raleigh, Sidney, Spenser,. Bacon, Cecil, Walsingham, Coke, Camden, Hooker, Drake, Hobbes, Inigo Jones, Herbert of Cherbury, Laud, Pym, Hampden, Selden, Walton, Wotton and Donne may be properly reckoned as his contemporaries; and yet there is no proof what- ever that he was personally known to either of these men, or to any others of less note among the statesmen, scholars, soldiers and artists of his day, except the few of his fellow craftsmen whose acquaintance with him has been heretofore men- tioned.1 It was an age of pamphlets. Priests, politicians and players all vented their grievances, or set forth their views, in pamphlets, but in none of these is there one word from or about Shakspere. I. Where are his Letters? It was an age of correspondence. The letters which have come down to us from that period would fill a large library, but in no one of them is there any reference to Shakspere. The man of Stratford passed through the world without leaving the slightest mark upon the politics or the society of his teeming and active age. Emerson says: If it need wit to know wit, according to the proverb, Shakespeare's time should be capable of recognizing it. Sir Henry Wotton was born four years after Shake- speare, and died twenty-three years after him, and I find among his correspondents and acquaintances the following persons: Theodore Beza, Isaac Casaubon, Sir Philip Sidney, the Earl of Essex, Lord Bacon, Sir Walter Raleigh, John Milton, Sir Henry Vane, Isaac Walton, Dr. Donne, Abraham Cowley, Bellarmine, Charles Cotton, John Pym, John Hales, Kepler, Vieta, Albericus Gentilis, Paul Sarpi, Arminius — with all of whom exists some token of his having communicated, with- out enumerating many others whom doubtless he (Wotton) saw — Shakspeare, Spenser, Jonson, Beaumont, Massinger, two Herberts, Marlowe, Chapman and the rest. Since the constellation of great men who appeared in Greece in the time of Pericles, there was never any such society; yet their genius failed them to find out the best head in the universe. Our poet's mask was impenetrable.8 We read in a sonnet attributed to his pen that he highly valued Spenser; and we find Spenser, it is claimed, alluding to the author of the Plays; the dedications of the Venus and Adonis and the Rape of Lucrvce are supposed to imply close social relationship with the Earl of Southampton; we are told Elizabeth conversed with him and King James wrote him a letter; we have pictures of him sur- Li/e anti Genius 0/ S/mk., p. 185. Reftresentativc Men, p. aoot THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 75 rounded by a circle of friends, consisting of the wisest and wittiest of the age; and yet there has been found no scrap of writing fro?n him or to him; no record of any dinner or festival at which he met any of his associates. In the greatest age of English literature the greatest man of his species lives in London for nearly thirty yearsr and no man takes any note of his presence. Contrast the little we know of Shakspere with the great deal we know of his contemporary Ben Jonson. We are acquainted some- what with the career even of Ben's father; we know that Ben attended school in London, and was afterward at Cambridge; — there is no evidence that Shakspere ever was a day at school in his life. We know that Jonson enlisted and served as a young man in the wars in the Low Countries. Shakspere's biography, from the time he left Stratford, in 1585-7, until he appears in London as a writer of plays, is an utter blank, except the legend that he held horses at the door of the theater. We know all about Jonson's returp home; his marriage; his duel with Gabriel Spencer. We are certain of the date of the first representation of each of his plays: there is a whole volume of matter touching the quarrels between himself and other writers. He published his own works in i6i6r and received a pension from James I. We have letters extant describing the suppers he gave, his manners, weaknesses, appear- ance, etc. But with Shakspere all this is different. Where are the letters he must have received during the thirty years he was in London, if he was the man of active mind given out by the Plays ? If he had received but ten a year, they would make a considerable volume, and what a world of light they would throw upon his pursuits and character. But two letters are extant — those to which 1 have already referred: one addressed to him soliciting a loan of money: an other addressed to a third party, in which he is referred to in the same connection; but there is not one word as to st udies, or art. Or literature, or politics, or science, or religion; and yet the mind that wrote the Plays embraced all these subjects, and had thought profoundly <>n all of them, lie loved the art of poetry passionate!) . he Speaks of " the elegance, facility and golden cadence <>t poet t v ; " 1 LoT'f'i T.abor l ost, iv, a. 76 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. he aspired to a " muse of fire that would ascend the highest heaven of invention; " he struggled for perfection. Had he no intercourse with the poets of his time ? Was there no mutual coming-together of men of kindred tastes and pursuits? Is it not most extraordinary that he should leave behind him this vast body of plays, the glory and the wonder of which fills the world, and not a scrap of paper except five signatures, three of which were affixed to his will, and the others to some legal docu- ments ? On the one side we have the Plays — vast, voluminous, immortal, covering and ranging through every department of human thought. These are the works of Shakespeare. On the other hand, these five signatures are the sum total of the life-labors of Shakspere which have come down to us. In these rude, illiterate scrawls we stand face to face with the man of Stratford. What an abyss separates them from the majestic, the god-like Plays ? It is a curious fact that all the writings were put forth in the name of Shakespeare, very often printed with a hyphen, as I have given it above, Shakespeare ; while in every one of the five cases where the man's signature has come down to us, he spells his name Shakspere. In this work, wherever I allude to the mythical writer, I designate him as Shakespeare ; whenever I refer to the man of Stratford, I give him the name he gave himself — Shakspere. The history of mankind will be searched in vain for another instance where a great man uniformly spelled his name one way on the title-pages of his works, and another way in the important legal documents which he was called upon to sign. Can such a fact be explained ? But passing from this theme we come to another question: II. Where are his Books? We have seen that the author of the Plays was a man of large learning; that he had read and studied Homer, Plato, Heliodorus, Sophocles, Euripides, Dares Phrygius, Horace, Virgil, Lucretius, Statius, Catullus, Seneca, Ovid, Plautus, Plutarch, Boccaccio, Berni and an innumerable array of French novelists and Spanish and THE LOST LIBRARY AXD MANUSCRIPTS. 77 Danish writers. The books which have left their traces in the Plays would of themselves have constituted a large library. What became of them ? There were no public libraries in that day to which the student could resort. The man who wrote the Plays must have gathered around him a vast literary store, commensurate with his own intel- lectual activity. Did William Shakspere, of Stratford-on-Avon, possess such a library ? If he did, there is not the slightest reference to it in his will. The man who wrote the Plays would have loved his library; he would have remembered it in his last hours. He could not have forgotten Montaigne, Holinshed, Plutarch, Ovid, Plato, Horace, the French and Italian romances, to remember his"brod silver and gilt bole," his " sword," his " wearing apparel," and his "second best bed with the furniture." The man of Stratford forgot Homer and Plato, but his mind dwelt lovingly, at the edge of the grave, on his old breeches and the second-hand bed-clothes. Compare his will with that of one who was his contemporary, Robert Burton, the author of The A?iatomy of AT e lane holy. I quote a few items from it. After leaving certain sums of money to Christ Church, Oxford, to buy books with, and to Brasennose Library, he says: If I have any books the University Library hath not, let them take them. If I have any books our own library hath not, let them take them. I give to Mrs. Fell all my English Books of Husbandry one excepted. . . . To Mrs. lies my Gerard's Herbal. To Mrs. Morris my Country Farm, translated out of French, 4, and all my English Physick Books to Mr. Whistler, the Recorder of Oxford. . . . To all my fellow students, Mrs. of Arts, a book in Folio or two apiece. . . . To Master Morris my Atlas Geogra/er and Ortelius TheatruM Mond. . . . To Doctor lies, his son, Student Salauntch on Paurrhelia and Lucian's Works in 4 tomes. If any books be left let my executors dispose of them with all BUCfa Books as are written with my own hands, and half my Melancholy copy, for Crips hath the other half. This will was made in 1639, twenty-three years after Shakspere's death, and shows how a scholar tenderly remembers his lihrarv when he comes to bid farewell to the earth. The inventory of Shakspere's personal property has never been found. Halliwell-Phillipps says: 78 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. If the inventory ever comes to light, it can hardly fail to be of surpassing interest, especially if it contains a list of the books preserved at New Place. These must have been very limited in number, for there is no allusion to such luxuries in the will. Anything like a private library, even of the smallest dimensions, was then of the rarest occurrence, and that Shakespeare ever owned one, at any time of his life, is exceedingly improbable} But surely the man who could write as follows could not have lived without his books: Sir, he hath never fed of the dainties that are bred in a book; . . . his intellect is not replenished; he is only an animal; only sensible in the duller parts.' There is no evidence that Shakspere possessed a single book. It was supposed for some time that the world had a copy of a work from his library, the Essays of Montaigne, but it is now conceded that the signature on the title-leaf is a forgery. The very forgery showed the instinctive feeling which possessed intelligent men that the author of JIa mlet must have owned a library, and would have lov- ingly inscribed his name in his favorite books. III. Where is the Debris of his Work-shop. It was an age of commonplace-books. Halliwell-Phillipps calls the era of Shakspere " those days of commonplace-books." Shakespeare himself presented a commonplace-book to some friend, and wrote this sonnet, probably on the fly-leaf: Thy glass will show thee how thy beauties wear, Thy dial how thy precious moments waste; The vacant leaves thy mind's imprint will bear, And of this book this learning mayst thou taste. The wrinkles which thy glass will truly show Of mouthed graves will give thee memory; Thou by the dial's shady stealth mayst know Time's thievish progress to eternity. Look, what thy memory cannot contain, Commit to these waste blanks, and thou shalt find These children nursed, delivered from thy brain To take a new acquaintance of thy mind. These offices, so oft as thou wilt look, Shall profit thee, and much enrich thy book.* That distinguished scholar, Prof. Thomas Davidson, expresses the opinion that this word offices may be identical with the Protnus of Bacon, some leaves of which are now in the British Museum. 1 Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines Life of Shalt., p. 186. * Love's Labor Lost, iv, 2. * Sonnet lxxvii. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. The sonnet describes just such a commonplace-book as Bacon's Promus is; and Prpf. Davidson adds: Promus is the Latin for offices, that is, larder. Offices here has always seemed a strange word. Its significance appears to have been overlooked. The German translations omit it. The real author of the Plays was a laborious student; we will see hereafter how he wrote and re-wrote his works. This sonnet shows that he must have kept commonplace-books, in which he noted down the thoughts and facts which he feared his memory could not contain, to subsequently "enrich his book " with them. With such habits he must have accumulated during his life-time a vast mass of material, the debris, the chips of the work-shop, hewn off in shaping the stately statues of his thought. What became of them ? IV. Where are the Original Copies of the Plays? Let the reader write off one page of any one of the Shakespeare Plays, and he can then form some conception of the huge mass of manuscripts which must have been in the hands of the author. But as there is evidence that some of the Plays were re-written more than once, and "enlarged to as much again," there must have been, in the hands of the author, not only these original or imperfect manuscript copies, but the final ones as well. Moreover, there had been seventy-two quarto editions of the Plays. These, even it imperfect and pirated, as it is claimed, were His children, nursed, delivered of his brain; and if the Stratford man was really the father of the Plays, and believed that Not marble, Nor the gilded monuments of princes, Should outlive this powerful rhyme, what would be more natural than that he should take with him t<> Stratford copies of these quarto editions? Can we conceive oi 8 great writer withdrawing to his country residence, to live out the remainder of his life, without a single copy Oj£ the works which had given him wealth, fame and standing as a gentleman ? And if he possessed such books, commonplace-books and man- uscripts, why did he not, Dying, mention then within hi^ will, So WILLIAM SUA KSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. as tlu* real author says the Roman citizen would a hair from tin- head of the dead Caesar? For all the dust of all the Caesars would not compare in interest for mankind with these original manu- scripts and note-books; and the man who wrote the Plays knew it, and announced it with sublime audacity: Hut thy eternal summer shall not fade, Nor lose possession of that fair thou owest; Nor shall Death brag thou wanderest in his shade, When in eternal lines to time thou goest. So long as men ean breathe or eyes ean see, So long lives this, and this gives life to thee. Appleton Morgan says: More than a century and a half of vigorous and exhaustive research, bounded only by the limits of Great Britain, have failed to unearth a single scrap of memo- randa or manuscript notes in William Shakespeare's handwriting, as preparation for any one or any portion of these plays or poems. But it will be said that this utter disappearance of the original copies, note-books, memoranda, letters, quarto editions and library is due to the destruction and waste of years. Time hath, my lord, a wallet at his back, Wherein he puts alms for oblivion. But certain things are to be remembered. It must be remembered that Shakspere was the one great man of his race and blood. He had lifted his family from obscurity to fame, from poverty to wealth, from the condition of yeomanry to that of pretended gentry; all their claims to consideration rested upon him; and this greatness he had achieved for them not by the sword, or in trade, but by his intellectual genius. Hence, they represented him, in his monument, with pen in hand, in the act of writing; hence, they placed below the monument a declaration in Latin that he was, "In judgment, a Nestor — in genius, a Socrates — in art, a Maro," and an English inscription which says that All that he hath writ Leaves living art but page to serve his wit. His daughter Susanna was buried with these lines upon her tomb: Witty above her sex, but that's not all, Wise to salvation was good Mistress Hall; Something of Shakespeare was in that, but this Wholly of him with whom she's now in bliss. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 8 1 His genius was more or less the subject of comment even while he lived and soon after his death. We are told, in the preface to the quarto edition of Troilus and Cressida, published in 1609, that Shakespeare's Plays are equal to the best comedy in Terence or Plautus. And, believe this, that when he is gone and his Comedies out of sale, you will scramble for them, and set up a new English Inquisition. In 1662, forty-six years after his death, and eight years before the death of his grand-daughter Elizabeth, wife of Sir John Bar- nard, the vicar of Stratford proceeded to note down the traditions about him. How comes it, then, that this family — thus made great by the genius of one man, by his literaiy genius; conscious of his great- ness; aware that the world was interested in the details of his character and history — should have preserved no scrap of his writing; no manuscript copy of any of his works; no quarto edition of the Plays; no copy of the great Folio of 1623; no book that had formed part of his library; no communication addressed to him by any one on any subject; no incident or anecdote that would have illustrated his character and genius ? They had become people of some note; they lived in the great house of the town. One son-in- law was a physician, who had preserved a written record of the diseases that came under his observation; his grand-daughter Elizabeth, in 1643, entertained Queen Henrietta Maria, wife of King Charles, the reigning monarch, and daughter of the great King Henry IV. of France. The Queen remained in Shakspere's house, New Place, for three weeks, on her progress to join King Charles at Oxford. The Plays of Shakespeare were the delight of King Charles' court. We are assured by Dryden that Shakespeare was greatly popular with " the last King's court" — that of Kin*; James — and that Sir John Suckling, and the greater part of the courtiers, rated him "our Shakespeare," far above Ben Jonson, "even when his (Jonson's) reputation was at the highest." Could it be possible that the Queen and courtiers would find themselves in the house of the author of Hamlet and The U Wives of Windsor and yet ask no questions about him? And it they did, what more natural than for his grand-daughter to produce the relies she possessed of the great man the letter <>l Compliment 8j WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DIP XOT WRITE THE PLAYS. which King James, the King's father, had written him, as tradition affirms. Kings' letters were not found on every bush in Stratford. And such memorials, once presented to the inspection of the curious, would never again be forgotten. Would not a sweet and gentle and cultured nature have left behind him, in the bosom of his family, a multitude of pleasant anecdotes, redolent of the wit and humor that sparkle in the Plays? And, once uttered, the world would never permit them to die. No accent of the Holy Ghost The heedless world has ever lost. We are told, by Oldys, that when his brother, in his latter years, visited London, he was beset with questions by the actors touching his illustrious relative, held by them in the highest veneration; but he could tell them nothing. Would not similar questions be pro- pounded to his family? His nephew, the son of his sister, was an actor in London for years, but he, too, seems to have had nothing to tell. We know that Leonard Digges, seven years after his death, refers to the "Stratford monument." Interest in him was active. Dr. Hall's diary of the patients he visited, and the diary of law- yer Green, Shakspere/s cousin, concerning his petty law business, are both extant, and are pored over by rapturous students; but where are Shakspere's diary and note-books? Neither is there any reason why his personal effects should dis- appear through carelessness. Dr. Hall was a man of education. He must have known the value of Shakspere's papers. His own and his father-in-law's personal property continued in the hands of Shakspere's heirs down to the beginning of the present century, having passed by will from Lady Barnard in 1670 to the heirs of Joan Hart, Shakspere's sister. This was long after the great Garrick Jubilee had been held at Stratford, and long after the world had grown intensely curious about everything that concerned its most famous man. Surely the memorials of one who was believed by his heirs to be the rival of Socrates in genius and of Maro in art would not be permitted to be destroyed by a family of even ordinary intel- ligence. See how the papers of Bacon — of Bacon who left no chil- dren, and probably an unfaithful wife — have come down to us: the MSS. of his books; great piles of letters, written, most of them, not when he was Lord Chancellor, but when he was plain Master THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 83 Francis Bacon. Even his commonplace-books have found their way into the British Museum, and the very scraps of paper upon which his amanuensis tried his pen. Remember how Spedding found the original packages of the private letters of Lord Bur- leigh, just as they were tied up by the great Lord Treasurer's own hand, never opened or disturbed for nigh three hundred years ! In the British Museum they have the original manuscript copies of religious plays written in the reign of Henry VI., two hundred years before the time of Shakspere; but that marvelous collection has not a line of any of the plays written by the author of Lear and Hamlet. V. The Money Value of the Plays. Nothing is clearer than that Shakspere was a money-getting man. He achieved a very large fortune in a pursuit in which most men died paupers. He had a keen eye to profit. He was ready to sue his neighbor for a few shillings loaned. I have shown that he must have carried on the business of brewing in New Place. He entered into a conspiracy to wrrest the right of common from the poor people of the town, for his own profit. Now, the Plays represented certain values; not alone their value on the stage, but the profits which came from their publica- tion. They were popular. Appleton Morgan says: Although constantly pirated during his lifetime, it is impossible to discover that anybody, or any legal representative of anybody, named Shakespeare, ever set up any claim to proprietorship in any of these works — works which beyond any literary production of that age were (as their repeatedly being subjects of piracy and of registration on the Stationers' books proves them to have been) of the largest market value. Why should the man who sued his neighbors for petty sums like two shillings pass by, in his will, these sources of emolument ? But it may be said he had already sold the plays and poems u> others. This answer might suffice as to those already printed, but there were seventeen plays that never saw the light until they appeared in the Folio edition of 1623, published seven years after his death. lie must have owned these. Why did he make no pro- vision in his will for their publication — if not for glory, for grain? It may be said that John Heminge and Henry Cundtlit who appear to have put forth the Folio of if>-\>, are mentioned in his will, and that 84 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. they acted therein as his literary executors. But they are not named as executors. His sole executors are Dr. John Hall, his son- in-law, and Susanna, his daughter, with Thomas Russell, Esq., and Francis Collins, gent., as overseers. None .of these parties appear to have had any connection with the great Folio. It was a large and costly work, and, even though eventually profitable, must have required the advance of a large sum to print it. Where did this money come from ? Is it probable that a couple of poor actors, like Heminge and Condell, would have undertaken such an outlay and risk while the children of Shakspere were alive and exceed- ingly wealthy ? I do not suppose that a work of the magnitude of the Folio of 1623 could have been printed for a less sum than the equivalent of $5,000 of our money. But at the back of the Folio we find this entry: Printed at the charges of W. Jaggard, Ed. Blount, I. Smithweeke and W. Aspley, 1623. On the title-page we read: Printed by Isaac Jaggard and Ed. Blount, 1623. So that it appears that three men, W. Jaggard, I. Smithweeke and W. Aspley, paid the expenses of the publication, while only one man, Ed. Blount, was concerned in printing and expense both. So that it appears that neither Heminge and Condell, nor Dr. John Hall, nor Shakspere's daughter Susanna, nor Thomas Russell, nor Francis Collins, nor anybody else who represented Shakspere's blood or estate, had anything to do with the expense of publishing the complete edition of Shakespeare's Plays, including seventeen that had never before been printed. VI. A Mysterious Matter. But there is still another curious feature of this mysterious business. I quote again from Appleton Morgan: It is not remarkable, perhaps, that we find no copyright entries on the Station- ers' books in the name of Jonson, Marlowe, or other of the contemporary poets and dramatists, for these were continually in straitened circumstances. But, William Shakespeare being an exceedingly wealthy and independent gentleman (if, besides, one of the largest owners of literary property of his time), it is remark- able that the only legal method of securing literary matter, and putting it in shape to alienate, was never taken by him, or in his name. The silence of his will as to THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 85 any literary property whatever is explained by the commentators by supposing that Shakespeare sold all his plays to the Globe or other theaters on retiring, and that the Globe Theater was destroyed by fire. If so, let it be shown from the only place' where the legal transfer could have been made — the books of the Stationers' Company, which were not destroyed by fire, but are still extant. Other commentators — equally oblivious of such trifling obstacles as the laws of England — urge that, being unmentioned in the will, the Plays went by course of probate to Dr. Hall, the executor. But even more, in that case, certain entries and transfers at Stationers' Hall would have been necessary. Moreover, the copyright, being not by statute, was perpetual, and could not have lapsed. In the preface to their first folio Heminge and Con- dell announced that all other copies of Shakespeare's plays are " stolen and surrep- titious." But on consulting the Stationers' books it appears that the quarto edi- tions were mostly regularly copyrighted according to law, 7vhereas the first folio was not. Nor were the plays already copyrighted ever transferred to Heminge and Condell or to their publishers. What legal rights in England ever centered in this great first folio, except as to the plays which appeared therein for the first time (which Blount and Jaggard did copyright), must always remain a mystery. If " stolen and surreptitious copies " ex- isted, therefore, they were the folio, not the quarto copies. And again, in another publication, Mr. Morgan says: Heminge and Condell asserted, in 1623, that all the editions of the plays called Shakespeare, except their own, were "stolen and surreptitious copies." If the laws of England in those days are of the slightest consequence in this investigation, it must appear that it was actually these very men, Heminge and Condell, and not the other publishers, who were utterers of "stolen and surreptitious copies." For, whereas all other printers of Shakespeare's plays observed the laws and entered them for copyright, Heminge and Condell appear never to have heard of any legal obligations of the sort. Unless they stole them, it certainly passes man's under- standing to conceive how they got hold of them. For, whatever property could be legally alienated in those days without a record, literary property certainly could not be so alienated. The record of alienation could have been made in but one place, and it was never made there. It may be said that Heminge and Condell, being merely play- actors, were unfamiliar with the copyright system and law, and, hence, failed to properly enter the work. But Heminge and Con- dell, it appears by the first Folio itself, were not the men who put their money into the venture, but Messrs. "W. Jaggard, Ed. Blount, I. Smithweeke and W. Aspley." Why did they not secure a title to the work in which they were venturing $5, 000 ? They were busi- ness men, not actors. As the Folio of 1623 declares that the previous quarto editions were " stolen and surreptitious copies " of the Plays, " maimed and deformed by the frauds and stealths of injurious impostors th.it exposed them," and that they now present them "cured and perfect Of their limbs, and all the rest, absolute in their numbers AS he con- 86 WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. ceived them," etc., it follows that in 1623 Heminge and Condell must have had the original manuscripts in the handwriting of "the poet." And they assert this: And what he thought he uttered with that easiness that we have scarce received a blot in his papers. Now, as Heminge and Condell possessed Shakspere's original copies in 1623, they could not have been burned in the Globe Theater in 16 1 3. A very large box would be required to contain them. What became of these fairly written, unblotted manuscripts ? Did his " pious fellowes," who so loved the memory of their associate that they compiled and published in huge and costly folio his com- pleted works, care nothing for these memorials, in the very hand- writing of him whom Ben Jonson pronounced, in the same volume and edition, the Soul of the age, The applause, delight, the wonder of our stage; who "was not for an age, but for all time," and in comparison with whom "all that insolent Greece or haughty Rome" had produced was as nothing ? Those manuscripts have never been found, never been heard of; no tradition refers to them; no scrap, rag, remnant or fragment of them survives. Why did not the men who so eagerly questioned his brother, and who, we are told, so carefully preserved the Chandos portrait, secure some part of these invaluable documents, which would to-day be worth many times their weight in gold ? VII. Another Mystery. But another mystery attaches to these manuscripts. The first appearance of Troilus and Cressida was in quarto form in 1609, and the book contains a very curious preface, in which we are told that the play had never been played, " never clapper-clawed with the palms of the vulgar/' " never sullied with the smoky breath of the multitude," and we find also this remarkable statement: And believe this, that when he is gone and his comedies out of sale, you will scramble for them and set up a new English Inquisition. Take this for a warning and at the peril of your pleasures' loss and judgments refuse not, nor like this the less for not being sullied with the smoky breath of the multitude; but thank for- THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. *7 tune for the 'scape it hath made among you, since by the grand possessors' wills I believe you should have prayed for them rather than been prayed. Here two remarkable facts present themselves: 1. That Shakspere, who was supposed to have written his plays for the stage, for the profit to be drawn from their represent- ation to the swarming multitudes, writes a play which never is acted, but printed, so that any other company of players may pre- sent it. And this play is one of the profoundest productions of his great genius, full of utterances upon statecraft that are a million miles above the heads of the rag-tag-and-bobtail who " thunder at the play-house and fight for bitten apples." 1 2. That the original copies of this play and his other come- dies— some or all of them — have passed out of his hands, and are now possessed by some grand persons not named. For, note the language: The writer of the preface speaks of Shakespeare's "com- edies" in the plural; then of the particular comedy of Troilus and Cressida; then of the " 'scape it hath made amongst you," that is, its escape out of the "grand possessors'" hands, who were unwill- ing to have it "'scape." In other words, we are told that these "grand possessors' wills" were opposed to letting them — the com- edies— be published. Charles Knight says: It is difficult to understand this clearly, but we learn that the copy had an escape from some pojverftil possessors. It appears to us that these possessors were powerful enough to prevent a single copy of any one of the plays which Shakspere produced in his "noon of fame," with the exception of the Troilus and Cressida and Lear, being printed till after his death; and that between his death, in 1616, and the publication of the Folio, in 1623, they continued the exercise of their power, so as to allow only one edition of one play which had not been printed in his life- time (Othello) to appear. The clear deduction from this statement of facts is, that the original publication of the fourteen plays published in Shakspere's lifetime was, with the exceptions we have pointed out, authorized by some power having the right to prevent the publication ; that, after 1603, till the publication of the Folio, that right was not infringed or contested, except in three instances.' Knight thinks that these "grand possessors" were Shakspere's fellow actors, to whom he had assigned the Plays; but this diffi- culty presents itself: Would the man who wrote the preface' to the Troilus and Cressida of 1609, and who evidently looked with con- tempt upon the players and the play-house, and who boasts that » Henry VI 11., V, ;,. 2Sti,iA., ///stt>rv, vol. i, p. U4 88 WILLIAM SIIAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. the play in question had never been "clapper-clawed with the palms of the vulgar," or "sullied with the smoky breath of the multitude" — would he speak of the actors who made their humble living before this vulgar multitude, the "vassal actors," the "legal vagabonds," as "grand possessors"? Do not the words imply some persons of higher social standing? And then comes this further difficulty: If the actors owned Troilus and Cressida, why would they not have played it, and gotten all the pennies and shillings out of it possible? Or why, if written by an actor for actors, should it have been written so transcend- ently above the heads of the multitude that it could not be acted ? And why, if it was worth anything as a play, would the actors have allowed it to " 'scape " into the hands of a publisher who sends it forth with a sneer at the audiences who frequent their places of amusement. And why, if they owned all the Plays, does not their ownership appear somewhere on the books of copyright? And why, if they owned them, would they destroy their own monopoly by publishing them in folio in 1623, thus throwing open the doors to all the players of the world to act them ? And why would they not even copyright the book when they did so publish it? And why, if they did so publish it, does it appear, by the book itself, that they were not at the charge of publishing it, but that it was sent forth at the cost of four men, not actors, therein named ? Thus, in whatever direction we penetrate into this subject, inex- plicable mysteries meet us face to face. VIII. Pregnant Questions. Why should the wealthy Shakspere permit the Plays, written while he was wealthy, to pass into the hands of certain "grand possessors"? And if these men were not actors, but bought the Plays of Shakspere, why should they make no attempt, during twenty years, to get their money back by publishing them? And could they have procured them of the money-making Shakspere, if he wrote them, without paying for them ? And what business would "grand" men, not actors, not publishers, not speculators for profit, have with the Plays anyway? And why should they stand guard over them and keep them from the public for twenty years, and then put them all out at once, and not copyright them, thus THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 89 making them a present to the public ? And when they did publish them, why should they place the papers in the hands of two play- actors, Heminge and Condell, who pretend that they are putting them forth out of love for the memory of that good fellow, Will Shakspere? Were not Heminge and Condell a mere mask and cover for the " grand possessors" of the unblotted manuscripts? And if the man who sued Philip Rogers for jQi 19s. lod. for malt sold, and for two shillings money loaned, had any ownership in any of these plays, can we believe he would not have enforced it to the uttermost farthing ? Would not he and his (for they were all litigious) have chased the stray shillings that came from their publication, through court after court, and thus placed the question of authorship forever beyond question ? We are forced to conclude: 1. Shakspere did not own the Plays and never had owned them. 2. They were in the hands of and owned by some "grand" person or persons. 3. This " grand " person or persons cared nothing for the interests of the players and made them public property; therefore, Heminge and Condell did not represent the players. 4. This " grand " person or persons cared nothing for the money to be derived from their sale, and took out no copyright, but presented them freely to the world; and this was not in the interest of Shakspere's heirs, if he had any claim to them. 5. And this " grand " person or persons cared nothing for the money to be made out of them, or he or they would, in the period of twenty years, between 1603 and 1623, have printed and reprinted them in quarto form, and made a profit out of them. But there is another striking fact in connection with the ques- tion of the manuscripts. IX. Another Mystery. The whole publication of the Folio of 162J is based on a fraudulent statement. Heminge and Condell, in their preface, addressed " to the great variety of readers," say: 9o WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. It had bene a thing, we confesse, worthy to have been wished that the author himself had lived to have set forth, and overseen his own writings. But since it hath bin ordained otherwise, and he by death departed from that right, we pray you do not envy his friends the office of their care and paine. to have collected and publish'd them; and so to have publish'd them as where (before) you were abus'd with diverse stolne and surreptitious copies, maimed and deformed by the frauds and stealthes of injurious impostors, that exposed them, even those are now offered to your view cur'd and perfect of their limbs, and all the rest, absolute in their numbers, as he conceived them. Who, as he was a happie imitator of nature, was a most gentle expresser of it. His mind and his hand went together. And what he thought he uttered with that easiness that we have scarce received from him a blot in his papers. And on the title-page of the Folio we read: " Mr. William Shake- speare's Comedies, Histories and Tragedies. Published according to //it' true original/ copies." We have also a list of " the principal actors in all these plays," prefaced by these words: The works of William Shakespeare, containing all his Comedies, Histories and Tragedies: Tmely set forth according to their first originall. Here we find four things asserted: 1. That the Folio was printed from the original copies. 2. That Heminge and Condell had "collected" these copies and published them in the Folio. 3. That the quarto editions were " stolne and surreptitious copies, maimed and deformed." 4. That what Shakespeare wrote was poured from him, as if by inspiration, so that he made no corrections, and " never blotted a line," as Ben Jonson said. These statements are met by the following facts: I. Some of the finest thoughts and expressions, distinctively Shakespearean, and preeminently so, are found in the quarto edi- tions, and not in the Folio. For instance, in the play of Hamlet, nearly all of scene iv, act 4, is found in the quarto and not in the Folio. In the quarto copy we find the following passages: What is a man, If his chief good and market of his time Be but to sleep and feed ? A beast, no more. Sure he that made us with such large discourse, Looking before and after, gave us not That capability and god-like reason To fust in us unused. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 91 And again: Rightly to be great Is, not to stir without great argument, But greatly to find quarrel in a straw, When honor's at the stake. No one can doubt that these passages came from the mind we are accustomed to call Shakespeare. Hundreds of other admirable sentences can be quoted which appear in the quartos, but not in the Folio. It follows, then, that Heminge and Condell did not have "the true original copies," or they would have con- tained these passages. It follows, also, that there must have been some reason why portions of the quarto text were omitted from the Folio. It follows, also, that, in some respects, the "stolne and surreptitious " copies of the quarto are more correct than the Folio, and that but for the quartos we would have lost some of the finest gems of thought and expression which go by the name of Shakespeare. II. The statement that Shakespeare worked without art, that he improvised his great productions, that there was scarce "a blot in his papers," in the sense that he made no corrections, is not only incompatible with what we know of all great works of art, but is contradicted on the next page but one of the Folio, by Ben Jonson, in his introductory verses. He says: Yet must I not give Nature all. Thy Art, My gentle Shakespeare, must enjoy a part. For though the Poet's matter Nature be, His Art doth give the fashion. And that he Who casts to write a living line must sweat (Such as thine are) and strike the second heat Upon the Muse's anvile, turn the same (And himself with it) that he thinks to frame, Or for the laurel he may gain a scorne; For a good Poet's made, as well as borne. And such wert thou. Look how the father's fact- Lives in his issue; even so the race Of Shakespeare's mind and manners brightly shines In his well-torned and true-filed lines. Here, then, we have the two play-actors, and friends of Shake- speare, Heminge and Condell, squarely contradicted by another friend and play-actor, Hen jonson. One asserts that Shakespeare wrote without art; the other, thai he sweat over his "true 9 2 WILLIAM SU. i KSPERE DID NO 7 ' WKI I £ 1 UK PLAl rS. filed lines" and turned them time and again on the " Muse's anvile." Several of the plays exist in two forms: — first, a brief form, suitable for acting; secondly, an enlarged form, double the size of the former. This is true of Romeo and Juliet, Henry K, The Merry Wives of Windsor and Hamlet. For instance, the first edition of Henry V. contains 1,800 lines; the enlarged edition has 3,500 lines. Knight says: In this elaboration the old materials are very carefully used up; but they are so thoroughly refitted and dovetailed with what is new, that the operation can only be compared to the work of a skillful architect, who, having an ancient mansion to enlarge and beautify, with a strict regard to its original character, preserves every feature of the structure, under other combinations, with such marvelous skill, that no unity of principle is violated, and the whole has the effect of a restoration in which the new and the old are undistinguish- able.1 Knight gives a specimen of Henry V. of 1608 and the Folio column, in italics, those parts of and which reappear in the Folio: Qiarto 1608. King. Sure we thank you; and, good my lord, proceed Why the law Salique, which they have in France, Or should or should not stop us in our claim: And God forbid, my wise and learned lord, That you should fashion, frame or wrest the same. For God doth know how many now in health Shall drop their blood, in approbation Of what your reverence shall incite us to. Therefore, take heed how you impawn our person; How you awake the sleeping sword of war: We charge you in the name of God take heed. After this conjuration speak, my lord; And we will judge, note and believe in heart this work, taken from the quarto of 1623. We print in the second the text derived from the quarto, Folio 1623. King. Sure, we thank you. My learned lord, I pray you to proceed And justly and religiously unfold Why the law Salique, that they have in France, Or should or should not bar us in our claim. And God forbid, my dear and faithful lord, That you should fashion, wrest or bow your reading, Or nicely charge your understanding soul With opening titles miscreate, whose right Suits not in native colors with the truth For God doth know how many now in health Shall drop their blood, in approbation Of ivhat your reverence shall incite us to: Therefore, take heed how you impawn our person ; How you awake the sleeping sword of war; * Charles Knight, Pict. Shak., Histories, vol. i, p. ^io. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 93 That what you speak is washed as pure We charge you in tlic name of God take As sin in baptism. heed. For never two such kingdoms did con- tend Without much fall of blood, whose guilt- less drops Are every one a woe, a sore complaint, 'Gainst him whose wrongs give edge * unto the swords That make such waste in brief mortality. Under this conjuration speak, my lord ; . And rve will hear, note and believe in heart, That what you speak is, in your con- science, washed As pure as sin with baptism. Now Heminge and Condell claim, in the Folio, that the play of Henry V. was printed from the "true original " copy, and that it came from the mind of Shakspere without a blot; while here is proof conclusive that it was not printed from the first original copy; and that it did not come, heaven-born, from the soul of the creator; but that the writer, whoever he might be, was certainly a man of vast industry and immense adroitness, nimbleness and subtlety of mind. False in one thing, false in all. Heminge and Condell did not have the author's original manuscripts, with all the interlineations and corrections, before them to print from, but a fair copy from some other pen. They do not seem to have known that there was that 1608 edition of the play. In fact, they do not even seem to know- how to spell their own names. At the end of the introduction,, from which I have quoted, they sign themselves, "John Heminge " and " Henrie Condell," while in the list of actors, published by themselves, they appear as "John Hemmings"and " Henry Con- deli;" and Shafcspere calls them, in his will, "John Hemynge" and " Henry Cundell." If the play-actor editors thus falsified the truth, or wen- them- selves the victims of an imposition, what confidence is to be placed in any other statement they make? What assurance have we ih.it they had collected the original manuscript copies; that they ever saw them; in short, that they were the work of Shakspere or in his handwriting? What assurance have we .hat the whole introduction and dedication to which their names are appended were not written 94 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. by some one else, and that they were but a mask for those "grand possessors" who, seven years before Shakspere's death, owned the play of Troilus and Cressida / In fact, a skeptical mind can see, even in the verses which face the portrait of Shakspere in the Folio of 1623, the undercurrent of a double meaning. They commence: # The figure that thou here seest put, It was for gentle Shakespeare cut. Is the word gentle here, a covert allusion to Shakspere's ridiculous and fraudulent pretensions to "gentle" blood, and to that bogus coat-of-arms which we are told he had engraved in stone over the door of New Place in Stratford ? Wherein the graver had a strife 1 With Nature to out doo the life. No one can look at that picture and suppose that B. I. (Ben Jonson) was serious in this compliment to the artist. Appleton Morgan says: In this picture the head of the subject is represented as rising out of an horizontal plane of collar appalling to behold. The hair is straight, combed down the sides of the face and bunched over the ears; the forehead is disproportionately high; the top of the head bald; the face has the wooden expression familiar in the Scotchmen and Indians used as signs for tobacconists' shops, accompanied by an idiotic stare that would be but a sorry advertisement for the humblest establish- ment in that trade. If this picture " out-does the life," what sort of a creature must the original have been? O, could he but have drawn his wit As well in brass as he hath hit His face, the print would then surpass All that was ever writ in brass. This thought of "drawing his wit" is singularjy enough taken from an inscription around another portrait — not that of Shak- spere, but of Francis Bacon. On the margin of a miniature of Bacon, painted by Hilliard in 1578, when he was in his eighteenth year, are found these words, "the natural ejaculation, probably," says Spedding, "of the artist's own emotion": Si tabula daretur digna, animum mallcm — if one could but paint his mind ! 1 1 The Shak. Myth, p. 95. * Lift and Works 0/ Bacon, Spedding, Ellis, etc., vol. i, p. 7. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 95 Let us read again those lines: O, could he but have drawn his wit As well in brass as he hath hit His face, the print would then surpass All that was ever writ — in brass ! That is to say, his wit drawn in brass would surpass, in brass, all that was ever written. Is not this another way of intimating that only a brazen-faced man, like Shakspere, would have had the impu- dence to claim the authorship of plays which were not written by him ? And that this is not a forced construction we can see by turning to the Plays, where we will find the words brass and brazen used in the same sense as equivalents for impudence. , Can any face of brass hold longer out?1 Well said, brazen-face.' A brazen-faced valet.3 It seems to me there is even a double meaning to some of the introductory verses of the Folio of 1623, signed Ben Jonson. The verses are inscribed — To the memory of my beloved — the Author — Mr. William Shakespeare — and — what he hath left us. What does this mean: "what he hath left us"? Does it mean his works ? How could Ben Jonson inscribe verses to the memory of works — plays? We speak of the memory of persons, not of productions; of that which has passed away and perished, not of that which is but beginning to live; not of the Soul of the age ! The applause ! delight ! the wonder of our stage ! In the same volume, on the next page, we are told, For though his line of life went soon about, The life yet of his lines will never out. Could Ben Jonson inscribe his verses to the memory of works which, he assures us in the same breath, were not "for an age. but for all time " ? Can you erect a memorial monument over immortal life ? What did William Shakspere leave behind him that held any :onnection with the Plays ? Was it the real author — l'Yancis Bacon 5 1 Loves Labor Lost, v, a. J M<> > v " 7. <> of II '/«» . iv, • I. tar, ii, t. 96 WILLIAM S1IAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE TLA VS.. And this thought seems to pervade the verses. Jonson says: T/iou art alive still — while thy book doth live. And again: Sweet Swan of Avon! what a sight it were To see thee in our waters yet appear, And make those flights upon the banks of Thames, That so did take Eliza and our James. That is to say, Ben Jonson expresses to the dead Shakspere the hope that he would reappear and make some more dramatic " flights" — that is, write some more plays. Such a wish would be absurd, if applied to the dead man, but would be very significant, if the writer knew that the real author was still alive and capable of new flights. And the closing words of the verses sound iike an adjuration to Bacon to resume his pen: Shine forth, thou Starre of Poets, and with rage Or influence chide or eheer the drooping stage, Which, since thy flight from thence, hath mourned like night, And despaires day, but for thy volumes' light. The play-houses had the manuscript copies of the Plays, and had been regularly acting them; it needed not, therefore, the pub- lication of the Folio in 1623 to enable the poet to shine forth. If the "drooping stage" "mourned like night," it was not for the Plays which appear in the Folio, for it possessed them; it had been acting them for twenty years; but it was because the supply of new plays had given out. Hugh Holland says on the next page: Dry'd is that vein, dry'd is the Thespian spring. How comes it, then, that Ben Jonson expresses the hope that the author would reappear, and write new plays, and cheer the drooping stage, and shine forth again, if he referred to the man whose mouldering relics had been lying in the Stratford church for seven years? X. Ben Jonson's Testimony. It must not be forgotten that Ben Jonson was in the employ- ment of Francis Bacon; he was one of his "good pens ;" he helped him to translate his philosophical works into Latin. If there was a secret in connection with the authorship of the Plays, Ben Jonson, as Bacon's friend, as play-actor and play-writer, doubtless knew it. And it is very significant that at different periods, far apart, he employed precisely the same words in describing the genius of THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 97 William Shakspere and the genius of Francis Bacon. In these verses, from which I have been quoting, he says, speaking ostensi- bly of Shakspere: Or when thy socks were on, Leave thee alone, for the comparison Of all that insolent Greece or haughty Rome Sent forth, or since did from their ashes come. Jonson died in 1637. His memoranda, entitled Ben Jonson s Discoveries, were printed in 1640. One of these refers to the emi- nent men of his own and the preceding era. After speaking of Sir Thomas More, the Earl of Surrey, Challoner, the elder Wyatt, Sir Nicholas Bacon, Sir Philip Sydney, the Earl of Essex and Sir Wal- ter Raleigh, he says: Lord Egerton, a grave and great orator, and best when he was provoked; but his learned and able but unfortunate successor (Sir Francis Bacon) is he that hath filled up all numbers, and performed that in our tongue which may be compared or preferred either to insolent Greece or haughty Rome. What a significant statement is this ! Francis Bacon had "filled up all numbers." That is to say, he had compassed all forms of poetical composition. Webster defines " numbers " thus: That which is regulated by count; poetic measure, as divisions of time or number of syllables; hence, poetry, verse — chiefly used in the plural. I lisped in numbers, for the numbers came. — Pope. Yet should the muses bid my numbers roll. — Pope. In Love's Labor Lost, Longaville says, speaking of some love verses he had written: I fear these stubborn lines lack power to move; O sweet Maria, empress of my love, These numbers will I tear, and write in prose} But when Ben Jonson, who had helped translate some « t Bacon's prose works, comes to sum up the elements of his patron's greatness, he passes by his claims as a philosopher, a scholar, a lawyer, an orator and a statesman; and the one thing that stands out vividly before his mind's eye, that looms up above all other considerations, is that Francis Bacon is a port — a great poet a poet who has written in all measures, "lias filled up all numbers" — the sonnet, the madrigal, rhyming verse, blank verse. And uli.it had he written ? Was it the translation of a few psalms in his old I Act iv, scene \. 98 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. age, the only specimens of his poetry that have come down to us, in his acknowledged works? No; it was something great, some- thing overwhelming; something that is to be "compared or pre- ferred either to insolent Greece or haughty Rome." And what was it that "insolent Greece and haughty Rome" had accomplished to which these "numbers" of Bacon could be preferred ? We turn to Jonson's verses in the Shakespeare Folio and we read: And though thou hadst small Latine and less Greek, From thence to honor thee I would not seeke For names, but call forth thundering vEschilus, Euripides and Sophocles to us, Paccuvius, Accius, him of Cordova dead, To life again, to hear thy buskin tread, And shake a stage; or, when thy socks were on, Leave thee alone, for the comparison Of all that insolent Greece or haughty Rome Sent forth, or since did from their ashes come. The "numbers" of Bacon are to be compared or preferred either to insolent Greece or haughty Rome — that is to say, to the best poetical compositions of those nations. And when Ben Jonson uses this expression we learn, from the verses in the Folio, what kind of Greek and Roman literary work he had in his mind; it was not the writings of Homer or Virgil, but of jEschylus, Euripides, Sophocles, etc. — that is to say, the dramatic writers. Is it not extraor- dinary that Jonson should not only assert that Bacon had pro- duced poetical compositions that would challenge comparison with the best works of Greece and Rome, but that he should use the same adjectives, and in the same order, that he had used in the Folio verses, viz.: insolent Greece and haughty Rome? It was not haughty Greece and insolent Rome, or powerful Rome and able Greece, or any other concatenation of words; but he employs precisely the same phrases in precisely the same order. How comes it that when his mind was dwelling on the great poetical and secret works of Bacon — for they must have been secret — he reverted to the very expressions he had used years before in reference to the Shakespeare Plays? And it is upon Ben Jonson's testimony that the claims of Will- iam Shakspere, of Stratford, to the authorship of the Plays, princi- pally rest. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 99 If the Plays are not Shakspere's then the whole make-up of the Folio of 1623 is a fraud, and the dedication and the introduction are probably both from the pen of Bacon. Mr. J. T. Cobb calls attention to a striking parallelism between a passage in the dedication of the Folio and an expression of Bacon: Country hands reach forthe milk, cream and fruits, or what they have.1 Bacon writes to Villiers: And now, because I am in the country, I will send you some of my country fruits, which with me are good meditations, which when I am in the city are choked with business.2 And in the " discourse touching the plantation in Ireland," he asks his majesty to accept "the like poor field-fruits." We can even imagine that in the line, And though thou hadst small Latine and less Greek, Ben Jonson has his jest at the man who had employed him to write these verses. For Jonson, it will be remembered, was an accurate classical scholar, while Bacon was not. The latter was like Montaigne, who declared he could never thoroughly acquire any language but his own. Dr. Abbott, head master of the City of London school, in his introduction to Mrs. Pott's great work,3 refers to "several errors which will make Latin and Greek scholars feel uneasy. For these in part Bacon himself, or Bacon's amanuensis, is responsible ; and many of the apparent Latin solecisms or mis- spellings arise . . . from the manuscripts of the Promus" He adds in a foot-note: I understand that it is the opinion of Mr. Maude Thompson, of the British Museum manuscript department, that all entries, except some of the French prov- erbs, are in Bacon's handwriting ; so that no amanuensis can bear the blame of the numerous errors in the Latin quotations. How "rare old Ben" must have enjoyed whacking Bacon over Shakespeare's shoulders, in verses written at the request of Bacon ! XI. A Greater Question. When the Crushing blow of shame and humiliation fell upon Francis Bacon in 1621, and he expected to die under it, he hurriedly drew a short will. It does not much exceed in length one page of Sped ding's book, and yet in t his brief 'document he found time 1 1 > s.i \ 1 Dtdication, K<>li'> i< i ,J MofttSgUi 'ii. p. loo WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. My compositions unpublished, or the fragments of them, I require my servant Harris to deliver to my brother Constable, to the end that if any of these be fit, in his judgment, to be published, he may accordingly dispose of them. And in partic- ular I wish the Elogium I wrote, //; felieem memoriam Reginir Elizabethan, may be published. And to my brother Constable I give all my books; and to my servant Harris for this his service and care fifty pieces in gold, pursed up. He disposed of all his real property in five lines, for the pay- ment of his debts. And when Bacon came to draw his last will and testament,1 he devoted a large part of it to the preservation of his writings. He says: For my name and memory, I leave it to men's charitable speeches, and to for- eign nations, and the next ages. But as to the durable part of my memory, which consisteth of my -works and writings, I desire my executors, and especially Sir John Constable, and my very good friend Mr. Bosvile, to take care that of all my writings, both of English and of Latin, there may be books fair bound and placed in the King's library, and in the library of the University of Cambridge, and in the library of Trinity College, where myself was bred, and in the library of the University of Oxonford, and in the library of my lord of Canterbury, and in the library of Eaton. Then he bequeaths his register books of orations and letters to the Bishop of Lincoln; and he further directs his executors to u take into their hands all my papers whatsoever, which are either in cabinets, boxes or presses, and them to seal up until they may at their leisure peruse them." We are asked to believe that William Shakspere was, neces- sarily, as the author of the Plays, a man of vast learning, the owner of many books, and that he left behind him, unpublished at the time of his death, such marvelous and mighty works as The Tempest, Macbeth, Julius Ccesar, Timon of Athens, Coriolanus, Henry VIII. and many more; and that, while he carefully bequeathed his old clothes and disposed of his second-best bed, he made no provision for the publication of his works, "the durable part of his memory." Is it reasonable? Is it probable ? Is it not grossly improbable ? What man capable of writing Macbeth and Julius Caisar, and know- ing their value to mankind — knowing that they lay in his house, in some " cabinet, box or press," probably in but one manuscript copy each, and that they might perish in the hands of his illiterate family and "bookless" neighbors — would, while carefully remembering 1 Life and Works, vol. vii, p. 539. THE LOST LIBRARY AND MANUSCRIPTS. 101 so much of the litter and refuse of the world, have died and made no provision for their publication ? But it may be said he did not own them; he may have sold them. It seems not, for Heminge and Condell, in their intro- duction to the first Folio, say that they received the original copies which they published from Shakespeare himself: And what he thought he uttered with that easiness that we have scarce received from him a blot in his papers. And again: It has been a thing, we confess, worthy to have been wished, that the author himself had lived to have set forth and overseen his own writings. What right would he have had to set them forth if they belonged to some one else ? But since it hath been ordained otherwise, and he by death departed from that right, we pray you do not envy his friends the office of their care. If this introduction means anything, it means that Shakspere owned these Plays; that he would have had the right to publish them if death had not interfered; that his friends and fellow-actors, Heminge and Condell, had, " to keep the memory of so worthy a friend and fellow alive as was our Shakespeare," assumed the task of publishing them; that they had received the original manu- scripts from him — that is, from his family — free from blot, and that they published from them, as all the quarto copies were " stolne and surreptitious, maimed and deformed by the frauds and stealthes of injurious impostors." And yet these Plays, which belonged to Shakspere's wealthy family, as the heirs of the author, which were printed by his " fel- lows " to sell to make money — for they say in their introduction: The fate of all books depends upon your capacities: and not of your heads -alone but of your purses. . . . Read and censure. Do so, but buy first. — these Plays were not published or paid for by Shakspere's family, but, as the Folio itself tells us, were Printed at the charges of W. Jaggard, Ed. Blount, [, Smithwceke, and W. Aspley, 1623. CHAPTER V. THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS A LAWYER. Why may that not be the skull of a lawyer > Hamlet, p, /. NOTHING is more conclusively established than that the author of the Plays was a lawyer. Several works have been written in England and America to demonstrate this. I quote a few extracts: Franklin Fiske Heard says: The Comedy of Errors shows that Shakespeare was very familiar with some of the most refined of the principles of the science of special pleading, a science which contains the quintessence of the law. . . . In the second part of //en ry I V., act v, scene 5, Pistol uses the term absque hoe, which is technical in the last degree. This was a species of traverse, used by special pleaders when the record was in Latin, known by the denomination of a special traverse. The subtlety of its texture, and the total dearth of explanation in all the reports and treatises extant in the time of Shakespeare with respect to its principle, seem to justify the conclusion that he must have attained a knowledge of it from aetual practice} Senator Davis says: We seem to have here something more than a sciolist's temerity of indulgence in the terms of an unfamiliar art. No legal solecisms will be found. The abstrusest elements of the common law are impressed into a disciplined service with every evidence of the right and knowledge of commanding. Over and over again, where such knowledge is unexampled in writers unlearned in the law, Shakespeare appears in perfect possession of it. In the law of real property, its rules of tenure and descents, its entails, its fines and recoveries, and their vouchers and double vouchers; in the procedure of the courts, the method of bringing suits and of arrests; the nature of actions, the rules of pleading, the law of escapes and of contempt of court; in the principles of evidence, both technical and philosophical; in the dis- tinction between the temporal and spiritual tribunals; in the law of attainder and forfeiture; in the requisites of a valid marriage; in the presumption of legitimacy; in the learning of the law of prerogative; in the inalienable character of the crown, this mastership appears with surprising authority.' And again the same writer says: I know of no writer who has so impressed into his service the terms of any science or art. They come from the mouth of every personage: from the (Jucen; from the child; from the merry wives of Windsor; from the Egyptian fervor of Cleopatra; from the lovesick Paphian goddess; from violated Lucrece; from Lear; 1 Shaietftare oj a Lawyer, pp. 43, 48. * The Law in Shakeipeare, p. 4. I02 THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS A LAWYER. Hamlet and Othello; from Shakespeare himself, soliloquizing in his sonnets; from Dogberry and Prospero; from riotous Falstaff and melancholy Jacques. Shake- speare utters them at all times as standard coin, no matter when or in what mint stamped. These emblems of his industry are woven into his style like the bees into the imperial purple of Napoleon's coronation robes.1 Lord Chief Justice Campbell sees the clearest evidences in the Plays that the writer was learned in the law. I quote a few of his expressions: These jests cannot be supposed to arise from anything in the laws or customs of Syracuse; but they show the author to be very familiar with some of the most abstruse proceedings in English jurisprudence.'1 Quoting the description of the arrest of Dromio in The Comedy of Errors, he says: Here we have a most circumstantial and graphic account of an English arrest on mesne process [" before judgment "] in an action on the case.3 In act iii, scene I (of As You Like It) a deep technical knowledge of the law is displayed.4. It is likewise remarkable that Cleomenes and Dion {The Winter s Tale, Act iii, scene 2), the messenger who brought back the response from the oracle of Delphi, to be given in evidence, are sworn to the genuineness of the document they pro- duce almost in the very words now used by the Lord Chancellor when an officer presents at the bar of the House of Lords the copy of a record of a court of justice: You here shall swear. . . . That you, Cleomenes and Dion, have Been both at Delphos; and from thence have brought The sealed-up oracle, by the hand delivered Of great Apollo's priest; and that since then You have not dared to break the holy seal Nor read the secrets in't. 5 And again, Lord Chief Justice Campbell says: We find in several of the Histories Shakespeare's fondness for law terms; and it is still more remarkable that whenever he indulges this propensity he uniformly lays down good lata.6 While novelists and dramatists are constantly making mistakes as to the law of marriage, of wills and of inheritance, to Shakespeare's law, lavishly as he pro- pounds it, there can neither be demurrer, nor bill of exception, nor writ of error.7 If Lord Eldon could be supposed to have written the play, I do not see how he would be chargeable with having forgotten any of his law while writing it." The indictment in which Lord Say was arraigned, in act iv, scene 7 (_'i. » Ibid., p. 73. io4 WILLIAM SHAKSPERE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. knowledge of that rather obscure and intricate subject — "Felony and Benefit of Clergy." 1 Speaking of Gloster's language in Lear? Lord Campbell says: In forensic discussions respecting legitimacy the question is put, whether the individual whose status is to be determined is "capable," i.e., capable of inheriting; but it is only a lawyer who could express the idea of legitimizing a natural son by simply saying: I'll work the means To make him capable. Speaking of Hamlet, his Lordship says: Earlier in the play3 Marcellus inquires what was the cause of the warlike preparations in Denmark: And why such daily cast of brazen cannon, And foreign mart for implements of war? Why such impress of shipwrights, whose sore task Doth not divide the Sunday from the week? Such confidence has there been in Shakespeare's accuracy that this passage has been quoted, both by text-writers and by judges on the bench, as an authority upon the legality of the press-gang, and upon the debated question whether shipwrights as well as common seamen are liable to be pressed into the service of the royal navy.4 Lord Campbell quotes sonnet xlvi, of which he says: I need not go farther than this sonnet, which is so intensely legal in its language and imagery that 7vithout a considerable knowledge of English forensic procedure it cannot be fully understood. Sonnet XLVI. Mine Eye and Heart are at a mortal war How to divide the conquest of thy sight; Mine Eye my Heart thy picture's sight would bar, My Heart mine Eye the freedom of that right. My Heart doth plead that thou in him dost lie (A closet never pierced with crystal eyes), But the Defendant doth that plea deny, And says in him thy fair appearance lies. To 'cide this title is impaneled A quest of Thoughts, all tenants of the Heart; And by their verdict is determined The clear Eye's moiety, and the dear Heart's part; As thus: mine Eyes' due is thine outward part, And my Heart's right, thine inward love of heart. One is reminded, in reading this, of Brownell's humorous lines: Tin Lawyer's Invocation to Spring. Whereas on certain boughs and sprays Now divers birds are heard to sing; And sundry flowers their heads upraise, Hail to the coming on of spring! 1 Shak. Legal Acquirements, p. 75. ■ Act ii, scene 1. ■ Hamlet, \,\. * Shak. Legal Acquirements, p. 83. THE WRITER OE THE FLAYS A LAWYER. The songs of those said birds arouse The memory of our youthful hours, - As green as those said sprays and boughs, As fresh and sweet as those said flowers. The birds aforesaid — happy pairs ! — Love, 'mid the aforesaid boughs, inshrines In freehold nests; themselves their heirs, Administrators and assigns. Oh, busiest term of Cupid's court, Where tender plaintiffs actions bring; Season of frolic and of sport, Hail — as aforesaid — coming spring! Lord Campbell says: In Antony and Cleopatra,1 Lepidus, in trying to palliate the bad qualities and misdeeds of Antony, uses the language of a conveyancer's chambers in Lincoln's Inn: His faults, in him, seem as the spots of heaven, More fiery by night's blackness; hereditary Rather than purchased. That is to say, they are taken by descent, not by purchase. Lay gents (viz., all except lawyers) understand by purchase buying for a sum of money, called the price, but lawyers consider that purchase is opposed to descent; that all things come to the owner either by descent ox by purchase, and that whatever does not come through operation of law by descent is purchased, although it may be the free gift of a donor. Thus, if land be devised by will to A in fee, he takes by pur- chase; or to B for life, remainder to A and his heirs (B being a stranger to A), A takes by purchase; but upon the death of A, his eldest son would take by descent* Appleton Morgan says: But most wonderful of all is the dialogue in the graveyard scene. In the quarto the two grave-diggers are wondering whether Ophelia, having committed suicide, is to be buried in consecrated ground, instead of at a cross- road with a stake driven through her body, and clumsily allude to the probability that, having been of noble birth, a pretext will be found to avoid the law. It happens that in the first volume of Plovvden's Reports there is a case (Hales vs. Petit, I. PI. 253) of which the facts bore a wonderful resemblance to the story of Ophelia. Sir James Hales was a judge of the Common Pleas, who had prominently con- cerned himself in opposing the succession of Mary the Bloody. When Mary ascended the throne, he expected decapitation, and was actually imprisoned, but by some influence released. His brain, however, became affected by his vicissi- tudes, and he finally committed suicide by throwing himself into a water-cout m-. Suicide was felony, and his estates became escheated to the crown. The crown in turn granted them to one Petit. But Lady Hales, instructed that the escheat might be attacked, brought ejectment against Petit, the crown tenant. The point was as to whether the forfeiture could be considered as having taken place in the lifetime of Sir James; for, if not, the plaintiff took the estate by survivorship. In other words, could Sir James be visited with the penalty for plunging into a Act i, scour 4. tt.S"//«iX\ f.f&it /. ; .'Story's Equity Jut ., $ i ui, etc. 'l Art i, scene \. J Act iv, scene i. n4 IV ILL! AM S//AASPEKE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. land, by simply paying the debt and interest. In July, 1603, he was arrested at the suit of a Jew (the original probably of Shylock), and thrown into a sponging-house, and we have his letter to his cousin Robert, Lord Cecil, Secretary of State, begging him to use his power to prevent his creditors from " taking any part of the penalty [of his bond] but principal, interest and costs." The Judge says: There is no power in Venice Can alter a decree established. ' Twill be recorded for a precedent. And many an error by the same example Will nish into the state. Before a writ of error can be taken from Portia's ruling, it must be shown by some precedent, or " decree established," of the Venetian chancery, that Antonio had the right to avoid the forfeiture by ten- dering the amount received and simple interest; and as no such man as Shylock ever lived, and no such case as that in question was ever tried, it will puzzle the critics to know just how far back to go to establish the priority of such a decision. Again, the point is made that, if Shylock was entitled to his pound of flesh, he was entitled to the blood that would necessarily flow in cutting it; upon the principle, it is said, that if I own a piece of land I have the right to a necessary roadway over another man's land to reach it. True. But in case I can only reach my land by committing murder (for that was what Shylock was under- taking), my lesser property right must be subordinated to the greater natural right of the other man to his life. But all this reasoning, if it be intended to show that the writer of the play was but partially learned in the law, must give way to the fact that Shylock vs. Antonio is a dramatic representation, for popular entertainment, and not a veritable law-suit. The plot of The Merchant of Venice was taken from the Italian romance II Pccoronc, of Giovanni Fiorentino, written in 1378; and there we have the decision of the judge, that the Jew must cut a precise pound of flesh, neither more nor less, and that, if he draw a drop of Christian blood in so doing, he must die for it. It would be absurd to suppose that a dramatic writer, even though a lawyer, would be obliged to leave out these striking incidents, and substitute a tamer something, in accordance with THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS A LAWYER. "5 that barbarous jumble of justice and injustice called law in England. But the question after all is to be decided by Venetian, not English precedents. The scene is laid in Venice. John T. Doyle, Esq., of California, writes a letter to Lawrence Barrett, Esq., the celebrated actor, which has been published in the Overland Monthly, in which he discusses "The Case of Shylock." He says: The trial scene in The Merchant of Venice has, however, always seemed inconsistent with his [Bacon's] supposed legal learning, for the proceedings in it are such as never could have occurred in any court administering English law. Lord Campbell, in his letter to Payne Collyer, has attempted to gloss over the difficulty, but to all common lawyers the attempt is a failure. Save in the fact that the scene presents a plaintiff, a defendant and a judge — characters essential to litigation under any system of procedure — there is no resemblance in the pro- ceedings on the stage to anything that could possibly occur in an English court, or any court administering English law. No jury is impaneled to determine the facts, no witnesses called by either side; on the contrary, when the court opens, the duke who presides is already fully informed of the facts, and has even com- municated them, in writing, to Bellario, a learned doctor of Padua, and invited him to come and render judgment in the case. Mr. Doyle then proceeds to give his experience of a lawsuit he had in the Spanish-American republic of Nicaragua in 1851-2. After describing the verbal summons he received from the alguazil to the alcalde in his court, Mr. Doyle says: Proceedings of some sort were going on at the moment, but the alcalde sus- pended them, received me very courteously, and directed some one present to go and call Don Dolores Bermudez, the plaintiff, into court. The substance of Mr. Bermudez' complaint against the company was then stated to me, and I was asked for my answer to it. I sent for my counsel, and the company's defense was stated orally. The contract out of which the controversy arose was produced, and perhaps a witness or two examined, and some oral discussion followed; those details I forget, for there was nothing in them that struck me as strange. There was, in fact, little, if any, dispute about the facts of the case, the real controversy being as to the company's liability and its extent. We were finally informed that on a given day we should be expected to attend again, when the judge would be prepared with his decision. At the appointed time we attended accordingly, and the judge read a paper in which all the facts were stated, at the conclusion of which he announced to us that he proposed to submit the question of law involved to Don Buenaventura Silva, a practicing lawyer of Granada, as a "jurisconsult." unless some competent objec- tions were made to him. I learned then that I could challenge the proposed ju- risconsult for consanguinity, affinity or favor, just as we challenge a juror. 1 knew of no cause of challenge against him; my counsel said he was an unexceptionable person; and so he was chosen, and the case was referred to him. Some davs after, he returned the papers to the alcalde with bis opinion, which was in my favor, and the plaintiff's case was dismissed. n6 WILLIAM S1IAKSPKRE DID NOT WRITE THE PLAYS. In the course of the same afternoon, or next day, I received an intimation that Don Buenaventura expected from me a gratification — the name in that coun- try for what we call a gratuity — and I think the sum of $200 was named. This did not harmonize with my crude notions of the administration of justice, and I asked for explanations. They were given in the stereotyped form used to explain every other anomaly in that queer country, " Costumbrc del pais." I thought it a custom more honored in the breach than the observance. Here we find that the writer of the Plays followed, in all proba- bility, the exact course of procedure usual in Venice, and in all countries subject to the civil law. We even have, as in Portia's case, the expectation that the judge should be rewarded with a gratuity. The only difference between the writer of the Plays and his critics is, that he knew what he was talking about, and they did not. My friend Senator Davis, of Minnesota, as a crowning proof that Francis Bacon did not write the Plays, says: . . . Again, Bacon was actively engaged in the court of chancery many years before he became Lord Chancellor. It was then that the memorable war of juris- diction was waged between Ellesmere and Coke — and yet there is not in Shake- speare a single phrase, word or application of any principle peculiar to the chancery.1 To this my friend John A. Wilstach, Ksq., the learned translator of Virgil," and an eminent lawyer, says in a letter addressed to me: In the English courts, ancient and modern — as even laymen know — the practice at common law and in chancery were and are severed, although the bar- riers between the two are now, by the gradual adoption of chancery rules in com- mon law practice, largely broken down. In the time of Bacon and Shakespeare the division was distinct: the common-law lawyer was not a chancery practitioner; the chancery practitioner was not a practitioner in the courts of common law. But the general language of both branches of the profession was necessarily (for in history and method they intertwined), if even superficially, known to the fol- lowers of both, and the probability is that a practitioner of the one would easily use the current verbiage of the other; indeed it would be strange if either should hold away from the other. A Lord Coke, in the wide scope of literature, would relax his common-law exclusiveness and enlarge the narrow circuit of his pro- fessional prepossessions. A Lord Bacon, a student or a judge in chancery, would delight to turn aside from the roses and lilies of equity — some of them exotic plants — and become, for the time, a gratified wanderer in an historic com- mon of pasture, among the butterflies and bees of an indigenous jurisprudence. Hence my suggestion, opposed to tfeit of the learned jurist, is, that this very scope and freedom of law in literature is what the writer of the Shakespeare Plays has given himself. And I find in the rambling pasture of the common law, according to his own outgivings, he has met, besides its attractive features, other and repel- ling ones — thorns, quagmires and serpents. I find that, on a close examination of Law in ShtiArs^in rt-. • Hosn.n : Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1884. THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS A LAWYER. 117 the Shakespeare Plays, the averment of the learned jurist as to the want of chan- cery features therein is not proven. I find that there are passages wherein, in the most evident manner, chancery principles and the equity practice are recognized and extolled; and, further yet, that among passages tolerant or praiseful of the common law are also found passages wherein its principles and practice are held up to derision and even to scorn. And while it is true that phrases are not proofs, but only grounds whence inferences may be drawn, yet the citations I shall offer will be of as high a grade as those which are offered to support the propositions which I contest. Nor is the argument weakened in its application to the Baconian question by the establishment of the fact that the participation in the production of the Shakespeare Plays on the part of Bacon was the work of his early manhood. Coleridge well formulates the general experience when he says that "a young author's first work almost always bespeaks his recent pursuit. " He is, at this early age, too, more conversant with the literature of his art; is more recently from the books and sometimes is observed to carry a head inflated with pride in that branch of the profession which his bent of mind has led him to favor. First let me recall some of those passages wherein derision and censure are visited upon the common law — the "biting" severity of its principles, the " hideous " deformity of its practice. The most superficial reader of these dramas will need no reminder of the satires conveyed in the conversation of Justices Dogberry and Shallow, Constable Elbow and the clowns in T7vclfth Night, and the more dignified broadsides of Wolsey and Queen Katharine, and Hamlet and Portia, and their interlocutors. As my reading goes, puerility, pedantry, corruption and chicanery, in legal practice, have found in all literature no denunciations so severe, no ridicule so effective. In 1st Henry IV., i, 2, the derision takes, in the mouth of Falstaff, the form of " the rusty curb of old Father Antic, the Law," the metaphor being that of a super- annuated clown who, with rusty methods, methods old and lacking polish, cheats the people out of the attainment of their cherished desires. When law can do no right, Let it be lawful that law bar no wrong.1 Since law itself is perfect wrong, How can the law forbid my tongue to curse ?' The state of law is bond-slave to the law. 3 But in these nice, sharp quillets of the law, etc.4 The laws, your curb and whip, in their rough power. Have checked theft.5 The bloody book of law, etc." Crack the lawyer's voice, That he may nevermore false title plead. : My head to my good man's hat, These oaths and laws will prove an idle scorn. * Parolles, the lawyer in All's Well that Ends Well, uses contemptuously the legal machinery applicable to English estates in describing how Dumain would convey away a title in fee-simple to his salvation; and, with the same contemptuous reference to the same machinery, Mrs. Pa^e describes the devil's titles to Falstaff. Now let us take up the praises of chancery. 1 King John, iii, i. I //•/,/., iii, [, s AV>/, i, 1. n8 WILLIAM S1IAKSPERE DID XOT WRITE THE PLAYS. And, first, I cite a passage which the learned jurist himself quotes. My italics will indicate my impression that, in his bent for common law, he has. failed to give emphasis to the most important feature of the passage. In the corrupted currents of this world Offense's gilded hand may shove by justice, And oft 'tis seen the wicked prize itself Buys out the law: but 'tis not so above; There is no shuffling, thtft the action lies In his true nature, and ice ourselves compelled Even to the teeth and forehead of our faults. To give in evidence. } • And, to pass to others : Ah, gracious lord, these days are dangerous; Virtue is choked with foul ambition, And charity chased hence by rancor's hand, Fell subornation is predominant, And equity exiled your highness' land.8 What a trinity is here: Virtue, Charity, Equity! Opposed, too, to the hellish trio of ambition, rancor and subornation. A larger definition of equity jurisprudence could not well be had than that it is "strong authority looking into the blots and stains of right." King John. From whom hast thou this great commission, To draw mine answer from thine articles ? King Philip. From that supernal judge that stirs good thoughts In any breast of strong authority, To look into the blots and stains of right. That judge hath made me guardian to this boy: Under whose warrant I impeach thy wrong, And by whose help I mean to chastise it. This passage is also cited by the learned jurist, but it is only to remark upon the words warrant and impeach. It contains, as I have observed, the very definition of chancery jurisprudence, and besides employs terms technical in chancer)' prac- tice, commission articles and answer. Themes which, in an especial manner, engage the intellect and the heart of the student and practitioner of chancer)' principles are "Charity," "Mercy," "Con- science." In contrast with the evasions and chicanery which are, in the Shakespeare Plays and elsewhere, the reproach of the practice at common law, chancery decides from considerations of what is right and just between man and man, ex tcquo et bono* Chancery jurisdiction enters the breast of the party himself, and there sets up its forum in his conscience. The interrogatories authorized by the chancery practice arraign and search that conscience, and, upon an oath binding upon it, "compel" the reluctant litigant, "even to the teeth and forehead of his faults, to give in evi- dence." Every man's conscience is a thousand swords.* My conscience hath a thousand several tongues.4 The worm of conscience still begnaw thy soul !s Well, believe this, No ceremony that to great ones 'longs Not the king's crown, nor the deputed sword, The marshal's truncheon, nor the judge' s robe, Becomes them with one-half so good a grace As mercy does.4 > Hamlet, Hi. 3. * Richard ///., V, a. • 2nd Henry 17., Hi, 1. *Ibid., v, 3. 5 Ibid., i, 3. • Measure /or Measure, ii, 2. THE WRITER OF THE J' LAYS A LAWYER. 119 The quality of mercy is not strained; It is an attribute to God himself; And earthly power doth then show likest God's, When mercy seasons justice.1 In addition to these citations, touching Shakespeare's use of the terms of the equity courts, I would quote the following from Judge Holmes: Indeed, it is clear that Portia's knowledge extended even to chancery practice, and continued to the end of the piece: The terms of chancery practice, charges, interrogatories and answer, are dragged in by the heels despite the protests of the refractory meter. But passing from this point, I will add a few more extracts which bespeak the lawyer: Sir, for a quart d'ecu he will sell the fee-simple of his salvation, the inherit- ance of it; and cut the entail for all remainder.3 And again: If the devil have him not in fee-simple, with fine and recovery, he will never, I think, in the way of waste, attempt us again.4 And again: Time stays still with lawyers in the vacation; for they sleep between term and term.5 Judge Holmes says:6 Mr. Rushton cites the statute 16 Richard II., which was leveled against the Pope's usurpations of sovereignty in England, and enacted that " if any do bring any translation, process, sentence of excommunication, bulls, instruments, etc., within the realm, or receive them, they shall be put out of the King's protec tion, unit their lauds, tenements , goods and chattels forfeited to the King" and compares it with the speech of Suffolk in the play of Henry VIII. , thus: Stiff. Lord Cardinal, the King's further pleasure is, Because all those things you have done of late By your power legatine within this kingdom, Fall into the compass of a praemunire, That therefore such a writ be sued against you: To forfeit all your goods, lands, tenements t Chattels and lohatsoei'er, and to be Out of the King s protection . This is my charge,1 Portia. Let us go in And charge us there upon int'rogatories, And we will answer all things faithfully.2 1 Merchant of Venice^ iv, 1. '- . / Hthorthip of Shak.% 3d ed., |>. « > 17 . 3 .Itt's U ,11 that End* W rit, iv, 3. * Mrrry f/'/Vr.v of ll'/>/,t.u<> , iv, a. 6 . Is You Like It, iii, a. n . I wthorthij t/ Y, whom it can be ascribed ? His saint is sure of his unspotted heart, says the poem. A pure, unspotted heart, says Shakespeare.1 Allow this aged man his right To be your beadsman now. Says Bacon to Lord Burleigh (1597): I will still be your beadsman. X. Bacon's Concealed Writings. Let us next inquire: Were these extracts all of Bacon's poetical works ? Is there any evidence that he was the author of any con- cealed writings ? Yes. Mrs. Pott says: There are times noted by Mr. Spedding when Bacon wrote with closed doors and when the subject of his studies is doubtful; and there is one long vacation of which the same careful biographer remarks that he cannot tell what work the inde- fatigable student produced during those months, for that he knows of none whose date corresponds with the period. Perhaps it was at such a time Bacon took recreation in the form in which he recommended it to others, not by idleness, but by bending the bow in an opposite direction; for he says: " I have found now twice, upon amendment of my fortunes, disposition to melancholy and distaste, especially the same happening against the long vacation, when company failed and business both." The same distaste to what he in a letter calls the "dead vacation" is seen in As You Like Lt, act iii, scene 2: Who stays it [time] still withal ? With lawyers in the vacation. Bacon says in a letter to Tobie Matthew: I have sent you some copies of my book of the Advancement, which you desired; and a little work of my recreation, which you desired not. My Instauration I reserve for conference; it sleeps not. Those works of the alphabet are in my opinion of less use to you where you now are than at Paris. [1607-9.] Mr. Spedding cannot guess what those works of the alphabet may have been, unless they referred to Bacon's experiments at cipher-writing. When he has become Sir Francis, Bacon writes to Tobie Matthew : I send my desire to you in this letter that you will take care not to leave the writing which I left with you last with any man so long that he may be able to take a copy of it. And that this was evidently some composition of his own ap- pears by the fact that he asks his friend's criticism upon it, and to 1 at Henry /'/.,", 4. FRANCIS BACON WAS A POET. *33 " point out where I do perhaps indormiscere, or where I do in- dulge re genio ; or where, in fine, I give any manner of disadvantage to myself." Does this mean that he fears he will reveal himself by his style ? Again, he writes to the same friend: You conceive aright, that in this and the other, you have commission to impart and communicate them to others, according to your discretion; other matters I write not of} What was the meaning of all this mystery ? Bacon refers to some unnamed work which he sends to his friend as " a work of his recreation." And in The Advance?nent of Learning2 he says : As for poesy, it is rather a pleasure or play of the imagination than a work or duty thereof. And in Macbeth we have: The labor we delight in physics pain.5 And in Antony and Cleopatra we have: The business that we love, we rise betimes And go to it with delight.4 Bacon in his Apology says: It happened, a little before that time, that her Majesty had a purpose to dine at Twickenham Park, at which time I had (although I profess not to be a poet) prepared a sonnet directly tending and alluding to draw on her Majesty's recon- cilement to my Lord, which I remember I also showed to a great person. Mr. William Thompson5 calls attention to the fact that this sonnet has never been found among Bacon's papers, or elsewhere, and suggests that this is one of the sonnets that go under the name of Shakespeare. When James I., after the death of Elizabeth, was about to come to England, to assume the crown, Master John Davis, afterward Sir John Davis, the poet and courtier, went to meet him, where- upon Bacon sent after him this significant letter: Master Davis: Though you went on the sudden, yet you could not go before you had spoken with yourself to the purpose which I will now write. And, therefore, I know it shall be altogether needless, save that I meant to show you that I was n«>l asleep. ' Letter to Tobie Matthew, \<**t- 5 Mook ii. s Aet ii.Mene ;. • \i t n , mcmc ( * The Renascent Drama; <>r, History Ma