INL/RPT-25-86864 Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998–2024 JULY 2025 Zhegang Ma, Tao Liu, Nancy Johnson, and John W. Merickle Idaho National Laboratory INL/RPT-25-86864 Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998–2024 Zhegang Ma, Tao Liu, Nancy Johnson, and John W. Merickle Idaho National Laboratory July 2025 Idaho National Laboratory Idaho Falls, Idaho 83415 http://www.inl.gov Prepared for the Division of Risk Analysis Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NRC Agreement Number 31310024S0038 Page intentionally left blank ABSTRACT This report presents an enhanced performance evaluation of the emergency power system (EPS) and high-pressure core spray (HPCS) emergency diesel generators (EDGs) at U.S. commercial nuclear power plants. This report evaluates component performance over time using (1) Institute of Nuclear Power Operations (INPO) Industry Reporting and Information System (IRIS) data from 1998 through 2024 and (2) maintenance unavailability performance data from Mitigating Systems Performance Index (MSPI) Basis Document data from 2002 through 2024. The objective is to (1) show estimates of current failure probabilities and rates related to EDGs, (2) trend these data on an annual basis, (3) determine if the current data are consistent with the probability distributions currently recommended for use in Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) probabilistic risk assessments, (4) show how the reliability data differ for different EDG manufacturers and for EDGs with different ratings, and (5) summarize the subcomponents, causes, detection methods, and recovery associated with each EDG failure mode. The considered EDG failure modes are fail to start (FTS), fail to load and run (FTLR), and fail to run after 1 hour of operation (FTR>1H). Engineering analyses were performed with respect to time period and failure mode without regard to the actual number of EDGs at each plant. The factors analyzed include subcomponent, failure cause, detection method, recovery, manufacturer, and EDG rating. The following reliability trends in component failure probabilities, failure rates, unavailability, and total reliability were identified for EDGs for the most recent 10-year period: • EPS EDG FTR>1H failure rate—decreasing • EPS EDG total unreliability (24-hour mission)—decreasing. The following engineering trends in demands, run hours, and failure events were identified for EDGs for the most recent 10-year period: • EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year)—increasing • EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year)— increasing • EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year)—increasing • EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year)—decreasing. v Page intentionally left blank vi CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................................. v ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................................................... xi 1. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................... 1 2. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS .............................................................................................................. 3 2.1. Reliability Trends ..................................................................................................................... 3 2.2. Engineering Trends .................................................................................................................. 3 2.3. Consistency Check Results ...................................................................................................... 3 3. FAILURE PROBABILITIES AND FAILURE RATES .................................................................... 5 3.1. Overview .................................................................................................................................. 5 3.2. EDG Failure Probability and Failure Rate Trends ................................................................... 6 4. EDG UNAVAILABILITY AND REPAIR TIMES .......................................................................... 11 4.1. EDG Unavailability Overview ............................................................................................... 11 4.2. EDG Unavailability Trends.................................................................................................... 11 4.3. Emergency Diesel Generator Repair Times ........................................................................... 13 5. EDG TOTAL UNRELIABILITY TRENDS .................................................................................... 15 6. ENGINEERING ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................... 17 6.1. Engineering Trends ................................................................................................................ 17 6.2. Comparison of IRIS EPS EDG Unplanned Demand Results with Industry Results ............. 22 6.3. EPS EDG Performance by Manufacturer .............................................................................. 23 6.4. EPS EDG Performance by Rating.......................................................................................... 23 6.5. EPS EDG Engineering Analysis by Failure Modes ............................................................... 24 7. EDG ASSEMBLY DESCRIPTION ................................................................................................. 32 8. DATA TABLES................................................................................................................................ 33 9. REFERENCES.................................................................................................................................. 50 APPENDIX A EDG EQUIPMENT LIST ................................................................................................. 51 APPENDIX B Overview of SPAR Parameter, Component Performance, and System Study Updates ............................................................................................................................................. 60 FIGURES Figure 1. Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTS. .................................................................. 8 Figure 2. Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTLR. ............................................................... 8 Figure 3. Failure rate estimate trend for EPS EDG FTR>1H. ...................................................................... 9 vii Figure 4. Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTS. ............................................................... 9 Figure 5. Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTLR. .......................................................... 10 Figure 6. Failure rate estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTR>1H. ................................................................. 10 Figure 7. EPS EDG UA trend. .................................................................................................................... 12 Figure 8. HPCS EDG UA trend. ................................................................................................................. 12 Figure 9. EPS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission).................................................................. 15 Figure 10. HPCS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). ........................................................... 16 Figure 11. Frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ................ 18 Figure 12. Frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ......................................................................................................................................... 19 Figure 13. Frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. .......... 19 Figure 14. Frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ............... 20 Figure 15. Frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ............ 20 Figure 16. Frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ......................................................................................................................................... 21 Figure 17. EPS EDG failure breakdown by subcomponent and failure mode. ........................................... 26 Figure 18. EPS EDG breakdown by cause group and failure mode. .......................................................... 27 Figure 19. EPS EDG component failure distribution failure mode and method of detection. .................... 28 Figure 20. EPS EDG component failure distribution by failure mode and recovery determination. ......... 29 Figure 21. EPS EDG failure distribution by manufacturer. ........................................................................ 30 Figure 22. EPS EDG component failure modes by EPS EDG rating. ........................................................ 31 TABLES Table 1. EDG systems................................................................................................................................... 5 Table 2. Industry-wide distributions of p (failure probability) and λ (hourly rate) in the 2020 Parameter Update for EPS EDGs [7]. ......................................................................................... 5 Table 3. Industry-wide distributions of p (failure probability) and λ (hourly rate) in the 2020 Parameter Update for HPCS EDGs [7]. ...................................................................................... 5 Table 4. Industry-average unavailability estimates in the 2020 Parameter Update [7] for EPS and HPCS EDGs. .............................................................................................................................. 11 Table 5. Weibull curve fit parameters. ........................................................................................................ 13 Table 6. Probability of exceeding selected EDG repair times. ................................................................... 13 Table 7. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTS failure mode over time by system. ........................ 21 Table 8. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTLR failure mode over time by system. ..................... 21 Table 9. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTR>1H failure mode over time by system. ................ 21 viii Table 10. EPS EDG unplanned demand performance comparison with industry-average performance from IRIS data. ...................................................................................................... 22 Table 11. EPS EDG manufacturer performance compared with industry-average performance— FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H combined.......................................................................................... 23 Table 12. EPS EDG rating performance compared with industry-average performance—FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H combined................................................................................................... 24 Table 13. Component failure cause groups. ................................................................................................ 25 Table 14. EPS EDG manufacturer population and total failure count. ....................................................... 30 Table 15. EPS EDG population by rating. .................................................................................................. 31 Table 16. Plot data for Figure 1, failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTS. ............................ 34 Table 17. Plot data for Figure 2, failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTLR........................... 35 Table 18. Plot data for Figure 3, failure rate estimate trend for EPS EDG FTR>1H. ................................ 36 Table 19. Plot data for Figure 4, failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTS. ......................... 37 Table 20. Plot data for Figure 5, failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTLR. ...................... 38 Table 21. Plot data for Figure 6, failure rate estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTR>1H. ............................. 39 Table 22. Plot data for Figure 7, EPS EDG UA trend. ............................................................................... 40 Table 23. Plot data for Figure 8, HPCS EDG UA trend. ............................................................................ 41 Table 24. Plot data for Figure 9, EPS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). ............................ 42 Table 25. Plot data for Figure 10, HPCS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). ....................... 43 Table 26. Plot data for Figure 11, frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ................................................................................................................ 44 Table 27. Plot data for Figure 12, frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. .......................................................................................................... 45 Table 28. Plot data for Figure 13, frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDG. ................................................................................................................. 46 Table 29. Plot data for Figure 14, frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ........................................................................................................................ 47 Table 30. Plot data for Figure 15, frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ................................................................................................................ 48 Table 31. Plot data for Figure 16, frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. ................................................................................................................ 49 Table A-1. EDG equipment list. ................................................................................................................. 51 Table B-1. Comparison of SPAR Parameter, Component Performance, and System Study Updates. ...................................................................................................................................... 60 ix Page intentionally left blank x ACRONYMS AOV air-operated valve CCF common-cause failure CNID constrained noninformative prior distribution EDG emergency diesel generator EPIX Equipment Performance and Information Exchange EPS emergency power supply ESF engineered safety feature FTLR fail to load and run FTR fail to run FTR>1H fail to run after 1 hour of operation FTS fail to start HPCS high-pressure core spray ICES INPO Consolidated Events Database INL Idaho National Laboratory INPO Institute of Nuclear Power Operations IRIS Industry Reporting and Information System LOOP loss-of-offsite-power MDP motor-driven pump MOV motor-operated valve MSPI Mitigating Systems Performance Index NPRDS Nuclear Plant Reliability Data System NRC Nuclear Regulatory Commission OLS ordinary least squares PMT post-maintenance testing PRA probabilistic risk assessment SPAR standardized plant analysis risk TDP turbine-driven pump UA unavailability xi Page intentionally left blank xii Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998–2024 1. INTRODUCTION This report presents an enhanced performance evaluation of emergency diesel generators (EDGs) at U.S. commercial nuclear power plants from 1998 through 2024. The objective is to (1) show estimates of current failure probabilities and rates related to EDGs, (2) trend these data on an annual basis, (3) determine if the current data are consistent with the probability distributions currently recommended for use in NRC probabilistic risk assessments (PRAs), (4) show how the reliability data differ for different EDG manufacturers and for EDGs with different ratings, and (5) summarize the subcomponents, causes, detection methods, and recovery associated with each EDG failure mode. This year’s update continues with the three changes implemented in the 2016 update that are different from prior updates. First, the update results are based on calendar year instead of the federal fiscal year. Second, the failure events included in the update are “hard” failures (i.e., the p-valuesa indicating the likelihood the component would have failed during a 24-hour mission are 1.0). Previous updates (2015 and before) included events with lower p-values, indicating degraded conditions that probably would have caused failure during a 24- hour mission but were not quite hard failures at their outset. Third, the discussion of EDG repair times, which was previously included in the annual loss-of-offsite-power (LOOP) updates (see https://nrcoe.inl.gov/LOSP/), is included in the EDG update. The enhanced component performance studies are conducted for the following component types: air-operated valves (AOVs), EDGs, motor-driven pumps (MDPs), motor-operated valves (MOVs), and turbine-driven pumps (TDPs). The EDG performance analysis was first conducted in 2007 with data from 1998 through 2006 [1] and then updated annually (until 2014) or every other year (since 2016) in a series of reports, with the last one being documented in INL/RPT-23-73954, Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998-2022 [2]. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Reactor Operational Experience Results and Databases web page provides the link to the historical and current results of component performance studies (http://nrcoe.inl.gov/CompPerf). An overview of the trending methods, glossary of terms, and abbreviations is documented in the paper Overview and Reference Document for Operational Experience Results and Databases Trending, referred to in this report as Overview and Reference [3], which can also be found from https://nrcoe.inl.gov/. The data used in this study are based on the operating experience failure reports from Institute of Nuclear Power Operations (INPO) Industry Reporting and Information System (IRIS) [4], formerly the Equipment Performance and Information Exchange Database (EPIX) and INPO Consolidated Events Database (ICES) [5]. Maintenance unavailability (UA) performance data came from the Reactor Oversight Process program’s Mitigating Systems Performance Index (MSPI) program and IRIS [6]. Previously, the study relied on operating experience obtained from licensee event reports, Nuclear Plant Reliability Data System (NPRDS), and EPIX. The IRIS database, which includes the MSPI designated devices as a subset, has matured to the point where both component availability and reliability can be estimated with a high degree of accuracy. The EDG failure modes considered are fail to start (FTS), fail to load and run (FTLR), and fail to run after 1 hour of operation (FTR>1H). Annual failure probabilities (failures per demand) are provided for FTS and FTLR events and annual failure rates (failures per run hour) are provided for FTR>1H events. EDG train maintenance unavailability probabilities are also considered. In addition to the presentation of the component failure mode data and the UA data, a 24-hour component total unreliability is calculated a The “p-values” here refer to the component degradation values, which indicate the extent of a component's failure as a probability that the degree of degradation would have led to failure during system operation. This is different from the “p- value” used for statistical tests in the remainder of the report. 1 and trended. Each of the estimates is trended for the most recent 10-year period. Yearly estimates have been provided for the entire study period. The results are reported separately for emergency power system (EPS) and high-pressure core spray (HPCS) EDGs. While this report provides an overview of operational data and evaluates component performance over time, it makes no attempt to estimate values for use in PRAs or Standardized Plant Analysis Risk (SPAR) models. INL/EXT-21-65055, Industry-Average Performance for Components and Initiating Events at U.S. Commercial Nuclear Power Plants: 2020 Update, referred to in this report as the 2020 Parameter Update [7], is the most recent update to NUREG/CR-6928, Industry-Average Performance for Components and Initiating Events at U.S Commercial Nuclear Power Plants [8], using data through 2020, and provides component unreliability estimates for SPAR models. Estimates from that report are included herein for comparison. Those estimates are labeled “SPAR 2020” in the associated tables and figures. Section 2 of this report presents the summary of findings from the study, with particular emphasis on the existence of any statistically significant increasing or decreasing trends in component performances. Section 3 provides the annual estimates of failure probabilities and rates related to EDGs as well as the trend analysis of the estimates. Section 4 provides EDG train UA estimates and their trends (Sections 4.1 and 4.2), as well as the discussion of EDG repair times (Section 4.3). Section 5 provides the annual estimates of total unreliability (24-hour mission) and the trend analysis of the estimates for EDGs. Section 6 presents various engineering analyses performed for EDGs with respect to time and failure modes. In Section 6.1, the same failures used in Section 3 are used to compute estimates of overall failure frequencies per reactor year (with EPS and HPCS EDG failures combined). Frequencies of demands per plant reactor year are also provided for each year and for each of the possible failure modes. As in Section 3, each of the estimates is trended for the most recent 10-year period. The frequencies show general industry performances and are not based on the number of EDGs at each plant. In Sections 6.2 through 6.4, various subsets of the EDG data are compared with the distributions currently recommended for PRA use in the 2020 Parameter Update. First, the subset of failure events and demands from this report that occurred on unplanned demands (engineered safety feature [ESF] actuations) is compared for consistency with the 2020 Parameter Update data. This evaluation provided a check on the ongoing use of the EDG data in the 2020 Parameter Update (which includes failures from testing demands that raises the concern on whether the testing data could adequately predict EDG performance during unplanned demands). In Section 6.3, data from each EDG manufacturer is compared. Finally, in Section 6.4, EDG failure groupings based on EDG ratings are compared. Section 6.5 provides breakdowns of the failures for each failure mode for the two plant systems with EDGs. The analyses are based on the following factors: subcomponent, failure cause, detection method, and recovery. Section 7 provides additional information on the EDG assembly component boundaries and failure modes. Section 8 presents the plot data for various figures in previous sections. Two new additions are included in this update: (1) A list of EPS and HPCS EDG equipment, provided in Appendix A, that are covered in this report for reliability and engineering analyses. Each EDG is identified by its associated plant and system, manufacturer, rating, in-service date, and, where applicable, out-of-service date. (2) A high-level comparison of the enhanced Component Performance Study updates with the SPAR Parameter updates and System Study updates, provided in Appendix B. This comparison summarizes their respective purposes, methodologies, data periods, and other key considerations. 2 2. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS The results of this study are summarized in this section. Of particular interest is the existence of any statistically significantb reliability trends in component failure probabilities, failure rates, unavailability, and total reliability. Engineering trends in component demands, run hours, and failure events provide additional insights. 2.1. Reliability Trends • A statistically significant decreasing trend was identified in the EPS EDG FTR>1H failure rate estimates with a p-value of 0.013. The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. • A statistically significant decreasing trend was identified in the EPS EDG total unreliability (24- hour mission) estimates with a p-value of 0.015. The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. 2.2. Engineering Trends • An extremely statistically significant increasing trend was identified in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) estimates with a p-value of 0.0001. The same trend was observed in the 2022 and 2020 EDG update studies [2], [9] as extremely or highly statistically significant. • An extremely statistically significant increasing trend was identified in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) estimates with a p-value of 0.0003. The same trend was observed in the 2022, 2020, and 2018 EDG update studies [2], [9], [10] as extremely statistically significant or statistically significant. • A statistically significant increasing trend was identified in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) estimates with a p-value of 0.024. The same trend was observed in the 2018 and 2016 EDG update studies [10], [11] as statistically significant or highly statistically significant. • A statistically significant decreasing trend was identified in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) estimates with a p-value of 0.012. The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. 2.3. Consistency Check Results An ongoing concern in the nuclear risk assessment field is whether industry failure rate estimates that are largely derived from test data adequately predict component performance during unplanned ESF demands. Section 6.2 provides results of consistency checks that compare industry failure estimates obtained via simulation tests on parameters from the 2020 Parameter Update against operational failure counts obtained from actual EDG performance with ESF demands. These consistency checks show that the FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H failure observations in the non-test, operational ESF demand data lie within the corresponding industry-average failure estimate distributions, provided in the 2020 Parameter Update that were based on both test and actual non-test operational ESF demands. Section 6.3 provides the results of consistency checks by EDG manufacturer. Two manufacturers’ ESF EPS EDG failure counts lie outside of the 5% to 95% interval of the uncertainty range of the b. Statistically significant is defined in terms of the p-value. A p-value is a probability indicating whether to accept or reject the null hypothesis that there is no trend in the data. P-values of less than or equal to 0.05 indicate that we are 95% confident there is a trend in the data (reject the null hypothesis of no trend.) By convention, we use the “Michelin Guide” scale: p-value < 0.05 (statistically significant), p-value < 0.01 (highly statistically significant), and p-value < 0.001 (extremely statistically significant). 3 industry-average estimate. However, these manufacturers have very few EPS EDGs, and so the data are limited. The remaining manufacturers’ failure counts lie within the 5% to 95% interval of the industry- average estimate uncertainty band. Section 6.4 shows the results of consistency checks by EDG load rating. The failure counts by rating all lie within the 5% to 95% interval of the industry-average estimate uncertainty band. 4 3. FAILURE PROBABILITIES AND FAILURE RATES 3.1. Overview The failure probabilities and failure rates of EDGs have been calculated from the operating experience for FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H. The EDG data set obtained from IRIS includes EDGs in the systems listed in Table 1. Table 2 shows failure probability and failure rate estimates for the EPS EDG from the 2020 Parameter Update [7] for reference. Table 3 shows the failure probability and failure rate estimates from the 2020 Parameter Update for the HPCS EDG, also for reference. Table 1. EDG systems. System Description EDG Count EPS Emergency power supply 235 HPCS High-pressure core spray 8 Total 243 The EDGs do not operate all the time. They are standby components required to operate when called upon, both when the reactor is critical and during shutdown periods. The demands and run hours are reported on a quarterly or semi-annual basis through the MSPI Program. All demand types are considered—testing, non-testing, and those ESF demands that require the EDG to mitigate a bus undervoltage condition. Table 2. Industry-wide distributions of p (failure probability) and λ (hourly rate) in the 2020 Parameter Update for EPS EDGs [7]. Failure Distribution 5% Median Mean 95% Mode Type   FTS 1.53E-3 2.19E-3 2.22E-3 3.02E-3 Beta 23.80 1.07E+04 FTLR 1.05E-3 3.01E-3 3.31E-3 6.60E-3 Gamma 3.61 1.09E+03 FTR>1H 3.90E-4 1.08E-3 1.18E-3 2.31E-3 Gamma 3.83 3.25E+03 Table 3. Industry-wide distributions of p (failure probability) and λ (hourly rate) in the 2020 Parameter Update for HPCS EDGs [7]. Failure Distribution 5% Median Mean 95% Mode Type   FTS 7.87E-4 1.97E-3 2.13E-3 4.00E-3 Beta 4.50 2.11E+03 FTR 2.58E-4 7.55E-4 8.34E-4 1.67E-3 Gamma 3.50 4.20E+03 5 3.2. EDG Failure Probability and Failure Rate Trends This section estimates industry-wide annual failure probabilities and failure rates for EDGs in the entire study period, covering 1998 through 2024. The estimates are trended for the most recent 10-year period. The failure probability and failure rate estimates in this section were obtained from a Bayesian update process. The means from the posterior distributions were plotted for each year. The 5th and 95th percentiles from the posterior distributions are also provided and give an indication of the relative uncertainty in the estimated parameters from year to year. When there are no failures, the interval is larger than the interval for years when there are one or more failures because of the form of the posterior variance. Each update utilizes a relatively “flat” constrained noninformative prior distribution (CNID), which has wide bounds [3], [9]. CNID is a compromise between an informative prior and the Jeffreys noninformative prior. The mean of the CNID uses prior belief and is based on a pooling of the component or event type data for the years going into the plot, but the dispersion is defined to correspond to little information (i.e., relatively flat by set) so that the prior distributions do not create large changes in the data. For failure rates or Poisson data, the CNID is a gamma distribution, with the mean (𝜇) given by prior belief and calculated as: ∑ 𝑓𝑖 + 0.5 (1) 𝜇= ∑ 𝑇𝑖 where 𝑓𝑖 and 𝑇𝑖 are the failures and operating/standby time for the ith year, respectively. The CNID shape parameter (𝛼) is a constant number of 0.5. The posterior distribution mean for the ith year (𝜇𝑖 ) can be calculated as: 𝑓𝑖 + 0.5 (2) 𝜇𝑖 = 0.5 𝜇 + 𝑇𝑖 For failure probabilities or binomial data, the CNID is a beta distribution, with the mean given by prior belief and calculated as: ∑ 𝑓𝑖 + 0.5 (3) 𝜇= ∑ 𝐷𝑖 + 1 where 𝑓𝑖 and 𝐷𝑖 are the failures and demands for the ith year, respectively. The CNID shape parameter (𝛼) is a number between 0.3 and 0.5 based on the mean μ (see Table C.8 of [9]). The posterior distribution mean for the ith year (𝜇𝑖 ) can be calculated as: 𝑓𝑖 + 𝛼 (4) 𝜇𝑖 = 𝛼 + 𝐷𝑖 𝜇 6 The horizontal curves plotted around the regression lines in the graphs form 90% simultaneous confidence bands for the fitted lines. The bounds are larger than ordinary confidence bands for the individual coefficients because they form a confidence band for the entire line. In the lower left-hand corner of the trend figures, the regression p-values are reported. They come from a statistical test to assess evidence against the slope of the regression line being zero. Low p-values indicate strong evidence that the slopes are not zero and, therefore, suggest a trend does exist. P-values of less than or equal to 0.05 indicate strong evidence that there is a trend in the data (reject the null hypothesis of no trend). By convention, this study uses the “Michelin Guide” scale: p-value < 0.05 (statistically significant), p-value < 0.01 (highly statistically significant), and p-value < 0.001 (extremely statistically significant). The regression methods are all based on ordinary least squares (OLS), which minimize the residuals or the square of the vertical distance between the annual data points and the fitted regression line. The p-values assume normal distributions for the residuals, with the same variability in the residuals across the years. In the case where the data involve failure counts, the iterative reweighted least squares method is used to account for the fact that count data are not expected to have a constant variance (e.g., the variance for Poisson-distributed counts is equal to the expected number of counts, which is expected to vary proportionally to the expected number of counts). Further information on the trending methods is provided in Section 2 of Overview and Reference [3]. A final feature of the trend graphs includes the baseline industry values from the 2020 Parameter Update (see Table 2), which are shown as “SPAR 2020” in the graphs for comparison. Figure 1 to Figure 6 provide the plots for industry-wide failure probabilities/rates of EPS and HPCS EDGs. The data for these plots are provided in Section 8: • Figure 1 shows the failure probability estimate trends for EPS EDG FTS • Figure 2 shows the failure probability estimate trends for EPS EDG FTLR • Figure 3 shows the failure rate estimate trends for EPS EDG FTR>1H • Figure 4 shows the failure probability estimate trends for HPCS EDG FTS • Figure 5 shows the failure probability estimate trends for HPCS EDG FTLR • Figure 6 shows the failure rate estimate trends for HPCS EDG FTR>1H The following trends were identified for EPS or HPCS EDG failure probabilities/rates for FTS, FTLR, or FTR>1H events in the most recent 10-year period: • Decreasing trend in the EPS EDG FTR>1H failure rate estimates, which is statistically significant with a p-value of 0.013 (see Figure 3). The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. 7 Figure 1. Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTS. Figure 2. Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTLR. 8 Figure 3. Failure rate estimate trend for EPS EDG FTR>1H. Figure 4. Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTS. 9 Figure 5. Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTLR. Figure 6. Failure rate estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTR>1H. 10 4. EDG UNAVAILABILITY AND REPAIR TIMES 4.1. EDG Unavailability Overview The industry-wide test or maintenance UA of EDG trains has been calculated from operating experience. UA data are for EDG trains, which can include more than just the EDG. However, in most cases, the EDG contributes the majority of the UA reported. Table 4 shows overall results for the EDG from the 2020 Parameter Update [7] based on UA data from the IRIS database, which includes the MSPI designated devices as a subset. In the calculations, planned and unplanned unavailable hours for a train are combined. Table 4. Industry-average unavailability estimates in the 2020 Parameter Update [7] for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Standard Description Distribution Mean Deviation EDG Test or Maintenance (EPS) Normal 1.51E-2 7.04E-03 EDG Test or Maintenance (HPCS) Normal 1.33E-2 3.74E-03 4.2. EDG Unavailability Trends The graphs that follow provide overall maintenance unavailability, planned (such as test), and unplanned data for the 1998–2024 period. Note that these data do not supersede the data in Table 4 for use in risk assessments. Trends in EDG train unavailability are shown in Figure 7 and Figure 8. Data tables for these figures are presented in Section 8. The EDGs in systems EPS and HPCS are trended. The yearly unavailability and reactor critical hour data were obtained from the Reactor Oversight Process program (1998 to 2001) and MSPI EPS and HPCS indicators (2002 to 2024). The total EDG downtimes during operation for each plant and year were summed and divided by the corresponding number of EDG-reactor critical hours. Unavailability data for plant shutdown periods are not reported. A change in reporting requirements for UA occurred in 2002. The Reactor Oversight Process program data (1998–2001) did not include EDG overhaul outages while plants were in critical operation, whereas the MSPI (2002–2024) requires plants to report such outages. The difference in the annual means of these two groups is not statistically significant. The mean and variance for each year is the sample mean and variance calculated from the plant-level UAs for that year. The vertical bar spans the calculated 5th to 95th percentiles of the beta distribution with matching means. For the trend graphs, a least squares fit is sought for the linear or logit model depending on which is more appropriate. Section 3 in Overview and Reference [3] provides further information. In the lower left- hand corner of the trend figures, the regression method and the p-value are reported. A review of the p-values identified no statistically significant trends in either the EPS EDG UA or HPCS EDG UA for the most recent 10-year period. 11 Figure 7. EPS EDG UA trend. Figure 8. HPCS EDG UA trend. 12 4.3. Emergency Diesel Generator Repair Times The data for repair times performed under actual emergency conditions are not available so repair durations were based on the number of hours of unplanned unavailability that have been reported to the NRC in the MSPI data. Historically, EDG repair time analyses have utilized 10-year datasets, such as the 2013–2022 MSPI data used in the 2022 EDG update study [2], to support Weibull distribution fitting. In this update, a 15- year dataset (2010–2024) was initially considered to align with the methodology adopted in the 2020 Parameter Update [7]. However, statistical evaluation revealed that the 15-year dataset exhibited significant right-skewness and included extreme outliers. Both Weibull and lognormal distributions failed standard goodness-of-fit tests, and Q-Q and P-P plots confirmed poor alignment—particularly in the upper tail of the distribution. To address these fitness issues, datasets covering different time periods were investigated. The 7-year dataset (2018–2024) was selected for the final analysis, as it minimized the influence of extremely high outage times and demonstrated a strong fit to a Weibull distribution, with a goodness-of-fit p-value of 0.167, indicating statistical acceptability. The Weibull fit parameters are provided in Table 5 along with those values in the 2022 and 2020 EDG update studies [2] [9] for comparison. The probability an EDG unplanned outage duration exceeds a given time (t) is listed in Table 6. Table 5. Weibull curve fit parameters. Parameter This Update 2022 EDG Update [2] 2020 EDG Update [9] Mean (hour) 35.2 33.9 37.1 Median (hour) 16.5 14.7 15.7 Weibull(α) 0.700 0.667 0.656 Weibull(β) 27.85 25.49 27.46 Table 6. Probability of exceeding selected EDG repair times. Recovery Time Weibull Model Observed Data (hr) 0.5 0.942 0.935 1 0.907 0.902 1.5 0.879 0.864 2 0.854 0.864 3 0.810 0.836 4 0.773 0.804 5 0.740 0.780 6 0.711 0.748 7 0.684 0.720 8 0.659 0.706 9 0.635 0.687 10 0.614 0.678 11 0.593 0.650 13 Recovery Time Weibull Model Observed Data (hr) 12 0.574 0.621 13 0.556 0.617 14 0.539 0.603 15 0.523 0.575 16 0.507 0.537 17 0.493 0.523 18 0.479 0.495 19 0.465 0.458 20 0.452 0.435 21 0.440 0.430 22 0.428 0.416 23 0.417 0.411 24 0.406 0.402 14 5. EDG TOTAL UNRELIABILITY TRENDS Trends in total component unreliability are shown in Figure 9 and Figure 10. Plot data for these figures are provided in Section 8. Total unreliability is defined as the union of UA, FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H. The probability of FTR>1H is calculated for 23 hours to provide the results for a 24-hour mission.c The trends are shown at the system-specific level across the industry. The trending method is described in more detail in Section 4 of Overview and Reference [3]. In the lower left-hand corner of the trend figures, the regression method and the p-value are reported. A review of the p-values identified the following trend for the most recent 10-year period: • Decreasing trend in the EPS EDG total unreliability (24-hour mission) estimates, which is statistically significant with a p-value of 0.015 (see Figure 9). The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. Because there are no total unreliability estimates in the 2020 Parameter Update, there is no baseline industry values shown in Figure 9 and Figure 10 for comparison. Figure 9. EPS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). c. Eight-hour mission is used in the analysis in order to account for the fact that recovery of offsite power during LOOP and station blackout sequences most likely occur well before the 24-hour PRA mission time. 15 Figure 10. HPCS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). 16 6. ENGINEERING ANALYSIS This section presents the engineering analysis for factors that could influence the component trends. Engineering trends of component demands, run hours, and failure events are presented in Section 6.1. Differences between testing and actual unplanned demands are considered in Section 6.2. Differences among manufacturers are presented in Section 6.3, and differences among EDG ratings are presented in Section 6.4. Finally, engineering analyses performed with respect to failure mode are presented in Section 6.5. The factors analyzed include subcomponent, failure cause, detection method, manufacturer, and EDG rating. 6.1. Engineering Trends This section presents frequency trends for EPS and HPCS EDG demands, run hours, and failure events. The data are normalized by reactor year for plants that report data for these EDGs with no consideration for plant system (EPS versus HPCS) or for the number of EDGs at a plant. The trends provide an overview of the demand counts, run hours, and failure counts associated with each failure mode across the years. Figure 11 to Figure 16 provide the plots for frequency of EDG start demands, load and run demands, run > 1H hours, FTS events, FTLR events, and FTR>1H events: • Figure 11 shows the trend for EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) • Figure 12 shows the trend for EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of load and run demands (demands per reactor year) • Figure 13 shows the trend for the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) • Figure 14 shows the trend for EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) • Figure 15 shows the trend EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) • Figure 16 shows the trend for the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year). The data for the figures listed above are provided in Section 8. EPS and HPCS systems are trended together for each figure. The rate methods described in Section 2 of Overview and Reference are used [3]. In the lower left-hand corner of the trend figures, the regression p-values are reported. A review of these p-values identified the following trends for the most recent 10-year period: • Increasing trend in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year), which is extremely statistically significant with a p-value of 0.0001 (see Figure 11). The same trend was observed in the 2022 and 2020 EDG update studies [2], [9] as extremely or highly statistically significant. • Increasing trend in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year), which is extremely statistically significant with a p-value of 0.0003 (see Figure 12). The same trend was observed in the 2022, 2020, and 2018 EDG update studies [2], [9], [10] as extremely statistically significant or statistically significant. • Increasing trend in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year), which is statistically significant with a p-value of 0.024 (see Figure 13). The same trend was observed in the 2018 and 2016 EDG update studies [10], [11] as statistically significant or highly statistically significant. 17 • Decreasing trend in the EPS and HPCS EDG frequency of FTR>1H events (hours per reactor year), which is statistically significant with a p-value of 0.012 (see Figure 16). The same trend was observed in the 2022 EDG update study [2] as highly statistically significant. Table 7 through Table 9 provides a summary of the total failure event count for each of the years a trend line is plotted. Table 7 summarizes the failures by system and year for the FTS failure mode. Table 8 summarizes the failures by system and year for the FTLR failure mode. Table 9 summarizes the failures by system and year for the FTR>1H failure mode. The data in Table 7 through Table 9 show failure events resulting from FTLR and FTR>1H occur in roughly equal numbers, while FTS failures occur somewhat less frequently. Furthermore, HPCS EDGs are about 3% of the EDG population, but account for only 1%-2% of the failure counts throughout the trending period. Figure 11. Frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) for EPS and HPCS EDGs. 18 Figure 12. Frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Figure 13. Frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. 19 Figure 14. Frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Figure 15. Frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. 20 Figure 16. Frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Table 7. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTS failure mode over time by system. Year Percent EDG EDG System Total of Count Percent 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Failures EPS 235 96.7% 13 13 10 7 4 4 12 4 10 8 85 93.4% HPCS 8 3.3% — — — 1 1 2 — — 1 1 6 6.6% Total 243 100% 13 13 10 8 5 6 12 4 11 9 91 100% Table 8. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTLR failure mode over time by system. Year Percent EDG EDG System Total of Count Percent 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Failures EPS 235 96.7% 13 11 9 14 7 4 5 10 6 9 88 94.6% HPCS 8 3.3% 1 — — 1 — 1 1 1 — — 5 5.4% Total 243 100% 14 11 9 15 7 5 6 11 6 9 93 100% Table 9. Summary of EDG failure counts for the FTR>1H failure mode over time by system. Year Percent EDG EDG System Total of Count Percent 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Failures EPS 235 96.7% 12 10 22 10 8 5 4 5 4 6 86 96.6% HPCS 8 3.3% — 1 — 2 — — — — — — 3 3.4% Total 243 100% 12 11 22 12 8 5 4 5 4 6 89 100% 21 6.2. Comparison of IRIS EPS EDG Unplanned Demand Results with Industry Results Because the IRIS EPS EDG data are dominated by test demands (over 95% of the demands are typically from tests), there is a concern on whether the test data could adequately predict EPS EDG performance during unplanned demands. This comparison evaluates the same data set for standby components used for the overall trends shown in this document but limits the failure data to those that are discovered during an ESF demand reported in IRIS. The data are further limited to 2003 to present since the ESF demand reporting in IRIS is inconsistent prior to 2003. IRIS failure records were reviewed to identify actual unplanned EPS EDG demands involving bus undervoltage conditions. Such events require the associated EPS EDG to start, load onto the bus, and power the bus until normal power is recovered to the bus. There are additional EPS EDG unplanned demands in which a bus undervoltage condition did not exist. In these cases, the EPS EDG did not have to load and power the bus. Such unplanned demands do not fully exercise the mission of the EPS EDGs and therefore were not counted. The EPS EDG unplanned demand data covering 2003–2024 are summarized in Table 10. Consistency between the unplanned demand data and the 2020 Parameter Update (see Table 2) was evaluated using the predictive distribution approach outlined in NUREG/CR-6823, Handbook of Parameter Estimation for Probabilistic Risk Assessment, Sections 6.2.3.5 and 6.3.3.4 [9]. The unplanned demand data were aggregated at the industry level (failures and demands). The industry-average failure mode distribution (from Table 2) was sampled, and the predicted number of events was evaluated using the binomial distribution with industry-average failure probability and associated number of demands. This process was repeated 1,000 times, each time obtaining the total number of failures predicted by the industry-average failure parameters. Then the actual number of observed unplanned demand failures (listed in the Observed Failures column of Table 10) was compared with this sample to determine the probability of observing this number of failures or greater. If the probability was greater than 0.05 and less than 0.95, then the Table 2 industry-average distribution obtained from the IRIS data analysis is consistent with the observed unplanned demand performance. Table 10. EPS EDG unplanned demand performance comparison with industry-average performance from IRIS data. Probability of Consistent with Failure Demands Observed Expected Plants ≥ Observed Industry-Average Modes or Hours Failures Failures Failures Performancea FTS 95 626 0 1.4 1.00 Yesb FTLR 95 375 1 1.2 0.66 Yes FTR>1H 95 5,903 4 7.0 0.75 Yes Note: a. If the probability of observing the actual failures or greater is ≥ 0.05 and ≤ 0.95, then the observed performance is considered to be consistent with the industry-average performance estimate. b. In this case, P(X=0) = 0.25, which is considered consistent with the industry-average data. These consistency checks show that the FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H failure observations, in the non- test operational ESF demand data, lie within the corresponding industry-average estimate distributions provided in the 2020 Parameter Update (see Table 2) that were based on both test and non-test operational ESF demands. 22 6.3. EPS EDG Performance by Manufacturer Table 11 presents the results of summarizing EPS EDG performance by manufacturer. IRIS contains information on EPS EDG manufacturers, but over the years some manufacturers have changed names or have been acquired by others. Therefore, to identify the original manufacturer, the IRIS information was supplemented by other EPS EDG reports. The results are a second consistency check against the industry-average distributions in Table 2. The comparison was made for the combination of all three failure modes. Two manufacturers’ EPS EDG failure observations outside of the 5% to 95% interval of the uncertainty range of the industry-average distribution. However, these two manufacturers involve very few EPS EDGs. The rest of the manufacturers’ failure observations lie within the 5% to 95% interval. Table 11. EPS EDG manufacturer performance compared with industry-average performance—FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H combined. Probability Consistent with EPS Observed Expected Manufacturer Code ≥ Observed Industry-Average EDGs Failures Failures Failures Performancea ALCO Power AP 24 75 89.5 0.71 Yes Cooper Bessemer CB 37 89 144.2 0.93 Yes Electro Motive/General EM/GM 70 230 258.7 0.62 Yes Motors Fairbanks Morse/Colt FM/C 69 292 264.1 0.32 Yes Nordberg NB 8 42 35.1 0.27 Yes SAC/Compair Luchard/ SC/JS 3 28 9.3 0 No Jeumont Schndr TransAmerica DeLaval TD 20 95 79.6 0.23 Yes Worthington Corp WC 4 42 12.8 0 No Note: a. If the probability of observing the failures or greater is ≥ 0.05 and ≤ 0.95, then the industry-average estimate is considered consistent with the observed failure count. 6.4. EPS EDG Performance by Rating Table 12 presents the results of the evaluation of EPS EDG performance by rating. The results are a consistency check of the industry-average distributions in Table 2 against observed performance by EDG rating. The comparison was made for the combination of all three failure modes. The failure observations for ratings all lie within the 5% to 95% interval of the industry-average distribution and are therefore consistent with the industry-average failure rate estimates. 23 Table 12. EPS EDG rating performance compared with industry-average performance—FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H combined. Probability Consistent with EPS Observed Expected Rating ≥ Observed Industry-Average EDGs Failures Failures Failures Performancea 50-249 KW 2 9 11.1 0.68 Yes 1,000-4,999 KW 173 655 659.0 0.46 Yes 5,000-99,999 KW 58 227 222.7 0.43 Yes 100,000-499,999 KW 2 2 5.3 0.95 Yes Note: a. If the probability of observing the actual failures or greater is ≥ 0.05 and ≤ 0.95, then the industry-average estimate is considered consistent with the observed failure count. 6.5. EPS EDG Engineering Analysis by Failure Modes The engineering analysis of the EPS EDG failure breakdown by failure mode and other factors, such as subcomponents, failure causes, detection methods, and recovery possibility, are presented in this section (there are too few HPCS EDGs to perform similar analyses on them). The failure modes are determined as a result of the IRIS data review by INL staff. See Section 7 for further description of failure modes. EPS EDG subcomponent contributions to the three failure modes are presented in Figure 17. The subcomponent contributions are similar to those used in the common-cause failure (CCF) database. For FTS, the instrumentation and control, generator, engine, and starting air piece parts are the top contributors to failures. For FTLR, the instrumentation and control and breaker are dominating contributors to failures. For FTR>1H, high contributors include the engine, cooling, fuel oil, and instrumentation and control. EPS EDG failure cause group contributions to the three failure modes are presented in Figure 18. The cause groups are similar to those used in the CCF database. Table 13 shows the breakdown of the cause groups with the specific causes that were coded during the data collection. The most likely causes are component issues and human errors. The Component cause group includes the causes that were related to something internal to the component or an aging or worn-out part, which were categorized as the Internal cause group in 2016 and earlier studies. The Human cause group is primarily influenced by maintenance and operating procedures and practices. EPS EDG failure detection methods for the three failure modes are presented in Figure 19. A failure can be detected during inspection, testing, post-maintenance testing (PMT), non-test demand, or ESF demand. The most likely detection method is a test demand, which is the prevalent detection method for most standby components. The inspection failure detection method is also important in the FTS failure mode. EPS EDG recovery results for the three failure modes are presented in Figure 20. Most EPS EDG failures were judged as unrecoverable. The overall non-recovery to recovery ratio is approximately 14:1, meaning that 14 of every 15 failures were not recovered. 24 Table 13. Component failure cause groups.d Group Specific Cause Description Component Internal to component, Used when the cause of a failure is a non-specific result of a piece-part failure internal to the component that failed other than aging or wear. Set point drift Used when the cause of a failure is the result of set point drift or adjustment. Age/wear Used when the cause of the failure is a non-specific aging or wear issue. Design Construction/installation error Used when a construction or installation error is made during or inadequacy the original or modification installation. This includes specification of an incorrect component or material. Design error or inadequacy Used when a design error is made. Manufacturing error or Used when a manufacturing error is made during component inadequacy manufacture. Environment Ambient environmental stress Used when the cause of a failure is the result of an environmental condition from the location of the component. Internal environment The internal environment led to the failure. Debris/foreign material as well as an operating medium chemistry issue. Extreme environmental stress Used when the cause of a failure is the result of an environmental condition that places a higher-than-expected load on the equipment and is transitory in nature. Human Accidental action Used when a human error (during the performance of an (unintentional or undesired activity) results in an unintentional or undesired action. human errors) Human action procedure Used when the correct procedure is not followed, or the wrong procedure is followed (e.g., when a missed step or incorrect step in a surveillance procedure results in a component failure). Inadequate maintenance Used when a human error (during the performance of maintenance) results in an unintentional or undesired action. Inadequate procedure Used when the cause of a failure is the result of an inadequate procedure operating or maintenance. Other State of other component Used when the cause of a failure is the result of a component state that is not associated with the component that failed. An example would be the diesel failed due to empty fuel storage tanks. Other (stated cause does not Used when the cause of a failure is provided, but it does not fit other categories) meet any one of the descriptions. Unknown Used when the cause of the failure is not known. d. The cause groups have been rearranged to align with those currently used in the CCF database. 25 Figure 17. EPS EDG failure breakdown by subcomponent and failure mode. 26 Figure 18. EPS EDG breakdown by cause group and failure mode. 27 Figure 19. EPS EDG component failure distribution failure mode and method of detection. 28 Figure 20. EPS EDG component failure distribution by failure mode and recovery determination. 29 Figure 21 shows the percentage of failure events for the three failure modes segregated by EPS EDG manufacturer as indicated in the IRIS database. Table 14 shows the distribution of the various manufacturers of EPS EDGs in the IRIS database and the total failure count associated with each. Based on the information given in Error! Reference source not found., EPS EDG manufacturers do not appear to be correlated to any particular failure mode pattern. Figure 21. EPS EDG failure distribution by manufacturer. Table 14. EPS EDG manufacturer population and total failure count. Total Percent EPS EDG Manufacturer Code Failure of EDGs Percent Count Failures ALCO Power AP 24 10.2% 75 8.4% Cooper Bessemer CB 37 15.7% 89 10.0% Electro Motive EM/GM 70 29.8% 230 25.8% Fairbanks Morse/Colt FM/C 69 29.4% 292 32.7% Nordberg NB 8 3.4% 42 4.7% SAC/Compair Luchard/Jeumont Schndr SC/JS 3 1.3% 28 3.1% Transamerica Delaval TD 20 8.5% 95 10.6% Worthington Corp WC 4 1.7% 42 4.7% Totals – 235 100.0% 893 100.0% 30 Figure 22 shows the percentage of failure events for the three failure modes segregated by EPS EDG rating as indicated in the IRIS database. Table 15 shows the distribution of the various rated EPS EDGs in the IRIS database used in this study. The larger EDG differs from the others in not yet having any FTS events, but the operational experience for this EDG is much shorter than for other EDGs. Figure 22. EPS EDG component failure modes by EPS EDG rating. Table 15. EPS EDG population by rating. Total Device Device Percent of EPS EDG Rating Failure Count Percent Failures Count 50–249 KW 2 0.9% 9 1.0% 1,000–4,999 KW 173 73.6% 655 73.3% 5,000–99,999 KW 58 24.7% 227 25.4% 100,000–499,999 KW 2 0.9% 2 0.2% Total 235 100.0% 893 100.0% 31 7. EDG ASSEMBLY DESCRIPTION The EDGs are those within the Class 1E AC electrical power system at U.S. commercial nuclear power plants and those in the HPCS systems. Station blackout EDGs are not included. The EDG includes the diesel engine with all components in the exhaust path, electrical generator, generator exciter, output breaker, combustion air, lube oil systems, fuel oil system, starting compressed air system, and local instrumentation and control circuitry. The sequencer is excluded from the EDG component. For the service water system providing cooling to the EDGs, only the devices providing control of cooling flow to the EDG heat exchangers are included. Room heating and ventilating are not included. The EDG failure modes include FTS, FTLR, and FTR>1H. These failure modes were used in NUREG/CR-6928 and are similar to those used in the MSPI Program. There is some uncertainty concerning when the run hours should start to be counted; for example, should they start as soon as the EDG is started, or should they start only after the output circuit breaker has closed? For this study, the run hours start as soon as the EDG is started, which is the way data have been reported in IRIS. The total run hours are partitioned by failure mode, with the first hour being used for FTLR, and the remaining hours assigned to FTR>1H. Guidelines for determining whether a component failure event reported in IRIS is to be included in FTS, FTLR, or FTR>1H are similar to those used in the MSPI Program. In general, any circumstance in which the component is not able to meet the performance requirements defined in the PRA is counted. This includes conditions revealed through testing, non-testing, ESF demands, or inspection. Run failures that occur beyond the typical 24-hour mission time in PRAs are included. However, certain events are excluded: slow engine starting times that do not exceed the PRA success criteria, conditions that are annunciated immediately in the control room without a demand, and run events representing degraded conditions that are shown to not have caused an actual run failure within 24 hours. Events occurring during maintenance or PMT that are related to the actual maintenance activities are excluded. Finally, in contrast to the MSPI Program, a general guideline on slow starting times is to include only those slow starts requiring more than 20 seconds as FTS events, similar to what was done for the CCF database and the EPS system study. (In the MSPI Program, most licensees chose to use technical specification requirements for fast starts as their success criteria—typically less than 10 seconds to start.) All EDG events within IRIS were reviewed to ensure that they were binned to the correct failure mode—FTS, FTLR, FTR>1H, or no failure. However, even given detailed descriptions of failure events, this binning still required some judgment and involves some uncertainty. Guidelines for counting demands and run hours are similar to those in the MSPI Program. Start and load/run demands include those resulting from tests, operational demands, and unplanned demands. Demands during maintenance and PMT are excluded. Similarly, run hours include those from tests, operational demands, and unplanned demands. Note that the test demands and run hours dominate the totals, compared with operational and unplanned demands and run hours. 32 8. DATA TABLES In this section, the plot data for Figure 1 to Figure 16 in previous sections are provided in Table 16 to Table 31, respectively. Figure Table Analysis Figure 1 Table 16 Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTS Figure 2 Table 17 Failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTLR Figure 3 Table 18 Failure rate estimate trend for EPS EDG FTR>1H Figure 4 Table 19 Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTS Figure 5 Table 20 Failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTLR Figure 6 Table 21 Failure rate estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTR>1H Figure 7 Table 22 EPS EDG UA trend Figure 8 Table 23 HPCS EDG UA trend Figure 9 Table 24 EPS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission) Figure 10 Table 25 HPCS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission) Frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and Figure 11 Table 26 HPCS EDGs Frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and Figure 12 Table 27 HPCS EDGs Frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS Figure 13 Table 28 EDG Frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS Figure 14 Table 29 EDGs Frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS Figure 15 Table 30 EDGs Frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and Figure 16 Table 31 HPCS EDGs 33 Table 16. Plot data for Figure 1, failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTS. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Failures Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 1.53E-03 3.02E-03 2.22E-03 1998 18 4,773 — — — 2.42E-03 5.24E-03 3.72E-03 1999 8 4,634 — — — 8.98E-04 2.85E-03 1.76E-03 2000 12 4,565 — — — 1.53E-03 3.95E-03 2.62E-03 2001 12 4,571 — — — 1.53E-03 3.94E-03 2.62E-03 2002 10 4,667 — — — 1.19E-03 3.36E-03 2.16E-03 2003 17 4,422 — — — 2.43E-03 5.38E-03 3.78E-03 2004 14 4,328 — — — 1.96E-03 4.69E-03 3.20E-03 2005 16 4,374 — — — 2.28E-03 5.18E-03 3.61E-03 2006 9 4,361 — — — 1.11E-03 3.31E-03 2.08E-03 2007 11 4,277 — — — 1.46E-03 3.93E-03 2.57E-03 2008 8 4,318 — — — 9.61E-04 3.05E-03 1.88E-03 2009 15 4,227 — — — 2.18E-03 5.07E-03 3.50E-03 2010 15 4,142 — — — 2.22E-03 5.17E-03 3.57E-03 2011 19 4,178 — — — 2.93E-03 6.22E-03 4.45E-03 2012 14 3,972 — — — 2.12E-03 5.10E-03 3.47E-03 2013 6 4,049 — — — 6.94E-04 2.63E-03 1.53E-03 2014 12 4,019 — — — 1.73E-03 4.46E-03 2.96E-03 2015 13 3,994 2.56E-03 1.37E-03 4.78E-03 1.93E-03 4.78E-03 3.22E-03 2016 13 4,011 2.42E-03 1.43E-03 4.10E-03 1.92E-03 4.76E-03 3.21E-03 2017 10 3,959 2.29E-03 1.47E-03 3.56E-03 1.40E-03 3.93E-03 2.53E-03 2018 7 3,964 2.16E-03 1.47E-03 3.16E-03 8.73E-04 3.00E-03 1.80E-03 2019 4 3,973 2.04E-03 1.43E-03 2.91E-03 3.99E-04 2.03E-03 1.08E-03 2020 4 3,941 1.93E-03 1.33E-03 2.80E-03 4.02E-04 2.05E-03 1.09E-03 2021 12 3,859 1.82E-03 1.19E-03 2.79E-03 1.80E-03 4.64E-03 3.08E-03 2022 4 3,869 1.72E-03 1.03E-03 2.85E-03 4.09E-04 2.08E-03 1.11E-03 2023 10 3,796 1.62E-03 8.88E-04 2.96E-03 1.45E-03 4.09E-03 2.63E-03 2024 8 3,828 1.53E-03 7.55E-04 3.10E-03 1.08E-03 3.43E-03 2.11E-03 Total 301 113,070 34 Table 17. Plot data for Figure 2, failure probability estimate trend for EPS EDG FTLR. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Failures Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 1.05E-03 6.60E-03 3.31E-03 1998 14 4,096 — — — 2.08E-03 4.99E-03 3.40E-03 1999 5 4,040 — — — 5.44E-04 2.34E-03 1.31E-03 2000 8 4,141 — — — 1.01E-03 3.20E-03 1.97E-03 2001 13 4,173 — — — 1.86E-03 4.62E-03 3.11E-03 2002 14 3,930 — — — 2.16E-03 5.19E-03 3.54E-03 2003 15 3,876 — — — 2.39E-03 5.56E-03 3.83E-03 2004 10 3,821 — — — 1.46E-03 4.10E-03 2.63E-03 2005 15 3,784 — — — 2.44E-03 5.69E-03 3.92E-03 2006 15 3,756 — — — 2.46E-03 5.73E-03 3.95E-03 2007 21 3,642 — — — 3.80E-03 7.76E-03 5.63E-03 2008 16 3,718 — — — 2.69E-03 6.09E-03 4.24E-03 2009 18 3,673 — — — 3.13E-03 6.78E-03 4.81E-03 2010 11 3,625 — — — 1.73E-03 4.64E-03 3.03E-03 2011 16 3,659 — — — 2.73E-03 6.19E-03 4.31E-03 2012 17 3,509 — — — 3.06E-03 6.76E-03 4.76E-03 2013 12 3,525 — — — 1.98E-03 5.10E-03 3.39E-03 2014 12 3,543 — — — 1.97E-03 5.07E-03 3.37E-03 2015 13 3,501 3.21E-03 2.00E-03 5.13E-03 2.20E-03 5.47E-03 3.68E-03 2016 11 3,494 3.01E-03 2.02E-03 4.48E-03 1.79E-03 4.80E-03 3.14E-03 2017 9 3,451 2.83E-03 2.03E-03 3.95E-03 1.40E-03 4.17E-03 2.63E-03 2018 14 3,483 2.66E-03 1.99E-03 3.55E-03 2.43E-03 5.83E-03 3.97E-03 2019 7 3,419 2.50E-03 1.90E-03 3.28E-03 1.01E-03 3.49E-03 2.09E-03 2020 4 3,407 2.35E-03 1.76E-03 3.13E-03 4.66E-04 2.37E-03 1.26E-03 2021 5 3,350 2.21E-03 1.59E-03 3.07E-03 6.52E-04 2.80E-03 1.57E-03 2022 10 3,371 2.07E-03 1.40E-03 3.07E-03 1.64E-03 4.62E-03 2.97E-03 2023 6 3,293 1.95E-03 1.22E-03 3.10E-03 8.53E-04 3.24E-03 1.88E-03 2024 9 3,325 1.83E-03 1.06E-03 3.16E-03 1.45E-03 4.32E-03 2.72E-03 Total 320 98,604 35 Table 18. Plot data for Figure 3, failure rate estimate trend for EPS EDG FTR>1H. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Run Time Year Failures Lower Upper Lower Upper (hr) Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 3.90E-04 2.31E-03 1.18E-03 1998 4 11,291 — — — 1.41E-04 7.18E-04 3.82E-04 1999 1 11,691 — — — 1.44E-05 3.21E-04 1.23E-04 2000 7 13,608 — — — 2.58E-04 8.87E-04 5.32E-04 2001 2 14,166 — — — 3.91E-05 3.78E-04 1.71E-04 2002 7 13,238 — — — 2.64E-04 9.10E-04 5.46E-04 2003 10 11,931 — — — 4.67E-04 1.32E-03 8.45E-04 2004 13 11,733 — — — 6.61E-04 1.64E-03 1.10E-03 2005 14 12,293 — — — 6.93E-04 1.66E-03 1.13E-03 2006 4 11,365 — — — 1.40E-04 7.14E-04 3.80E-04 2007 17 11,458 — — — 9.40E-04 2.08E-03 1.46E-03 2008 20 11,615 — — — 1.13E-03 2.35E-03 1.69E-03 2009 8 11,637 — — — 3.58E-04 1.14E-03 7.01E-04 2010 13 11,299 — — — 6.85E-04 1.70E-03 1.15E-03 2011 21 12,332 — — — 1.13E-03 2.31E-03 1.68E-03 2012 11 7,352 — — — 8.35E-04 2.24E-03 1.47E-03 2013 17 7,913 — — — 1.34E-03 2.96E-03 2.08E-03 2014 17 7,228 — — — 1.46E-03 3.23E-03 2.27E-03 2015 12 7,783 1.80E-03 1.14E-03 2.82E-03 8.83E-04 2.28E-03 1.51E-03 2016 10 7,593 1.58E-03 1.08E-03 2.31E-03 7.17E-04 2.02E-03 1.30E-03 2017 22 7,402 1.39E-03 1.01E-03 1.91E-03 1.94E-03 3.91E-03 2.85E-03 2018 10 7,875 1.22E-03 9.20E-04 1.63E-03 6.93E-04 1.95E-03 1.26E-03 2019 8 7,392 1.08E-03 8.11E-04 1.43E-03 5.50E-04 1.75E-03 1.08E-03 2020 5 7,414 9.47E-04 6.91E-04 1.30E-03 2.89E-04 1.24E-03 6.96E-04 2021 4 7,193 8.33E-04 5.75E-04 1.21E-03 2.16E-04 1.10E-03 5.86E-04 2022 5 7,326 7.33E-04 4.70E-04 1.14E-03 2.93E-04 1.26E-03 7.04E-04 2023 4 7,258 6.45E-04 3.81E-04 1.09E-03 2.15E-04 1.09E-03 5.81E-04 2024 6 7,589 5.67E-04 3.08E-04 1.05E-03 3.65E-04 1.38E-03 8.05E-04 Total 272 266,975 36 Table 19. Plot data for Figure 4, failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTS. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Failures Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 7.87E-04 4.00E-03 2.13E-03 1998 0 153 — — — 5.33E-06 5.41E-03 1.41E-03 1999 1 187 — — — 4.51E-04 1.00E-02 3.85E-03 2000 0 145 — — — 5.45E-06 5.54E-03 1.44E-03 2001 0 154 — — — 5.31E-06 5.40E-03 1.40E-03 2002 0 146 — — — 5.44E-06 5.53E-03 1.44E-03 2003 0 152 — — — 5.34E-06 5.42E-03 1.41E-03 2004 0 139 — — — 5.54E-06 5.63E-03 1.46E-03 2005 0 133 — — — 5.64E-06 5.73E-03 1.49E-03 2006 0 136 — — — 5.58E-06 5.68E-03 1.47E-03 2007 0 126 — — — 5.77E-06 5.86E-03 1.52E-03 2008 1 152 — — — 4.97E-04 1.10E-02 4.24E-03 2009 0 138 — — — 5.56E-06 5.65E-03 1.47E-03 2010 0 151 — — — 5.35E-06 5.44E-03 1.41E-03 2011 0 152 — — — 5.34E-06 5.42E-03 1.41E-03 2012 0 128 — — — 5.73E-06 5.83E-03 1.51E-03 2013 0 158 — — — 5.25E-06 5.34E-03 1.39E-03 2014 1 136 — — — 5.21E-04 1.16E-02 4.44E-03 2015 0 140 2.48E-03 1.00E-03 6.12E-03 5.53E-06 5.62E-03 1.46E-03 2016 0 138 2.73E-03 1.26E-03 5.88E-03 5.56E-06 5.65E-03 1.47E-03 2017 0 139 3.00E-03 1.57E-03 5.73E-03 5.55E-06 5.64E-03 1.46E-03 2018 1 144 3.30E-03 1.90E-03 5.73E-03 5.08E-04 1.13E-02 4.34E-03 2019 1 129 3.64E-03 2.21E-03 5.97E-03 5.32E-04 1.18E-02 4.54E-03 2020 2 139 4.00E-03 2.44E-03 6.56E-03 1.68E-03 1.62E-02 7.32E-03 2021 0 122 4.41E-03 2.55E-03 7.61E-03 5.84E-06 5.93E-03 1.54E-03 2022 0 131 4.85E-03 2.55E-03 9.19E-03 5.68E-06 5.77E-03 1.50E-03 2023 1 127 5.34E-03 2.49E-03 1.14E-02 5.35E-04 1.19E-02 4.56E-03 2024 1 138 5.87E-03 2.39E-03 1.43E-02 5.17E-04 1.15E-02 4.41E-03 Total 9 3,830 37 Table 20. Plot data for Figure 5, failure probability estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTLR. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Failures Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 2.58E-04 1.67E-03 8.34E-04 1998 0 110 — — — 7.24E-06 7.47E-03 1.94E-03 1999 1 131 — — — 6.33E-04 1.41E-02 5.41E-03 2000 0 121 — — — 6.96E-06 7.18E-03 1.86E-03 2001 0 125 — — — 6.84E-06 7.06E-03 1.83E-03 2002 1 128 — — — 6.40E-04 1.42E-02 5.46E-03 2003 0 129 — — — 6.75E-06 6.97E-03 1.81E-03 2004 1 130 — — — 6.35E-04 1.41E-02 5.43E-03 2005 0 120 — — — 6.99E-06 7.21E-03 1.87E-03 2006 0 125 — — — 6.85E-06 7.07E-03 1.84E-03 2007 0 118 — — — 7.04E-06 7.26E-03 1.88E-03 2008 0 140 — — — 6.49E-06 6.70E-03 1.74E-03 2009 0 119 — — — 7.02E-06 7.24E-03 1.88E-03 2010 1 133 — — — 6.29E-04 1.40E-02 5.37E-03 2011 0 138 — — — 6.54E-06 6.75E-03 1.75E-03 2012 1 117 — — — 6.65E-04 1.48E-02 5.68E-03 2013 0 137 — — — 6.54E-06 6.76E-03 1.75E-03 2014 1 118 — — — 6.63E-04 1.47E-02 5.66E-03 2015 1 127 3.97E-03 1.61E-03 9.75E-03 6.41E-04 1.42E-02 5.47E-03 2016 0 126 3.91E-03 1.82E-03 8.37E-03 6.81E-06 7.03E-03 1.82E-03 2017 0 125 3.84E-03 2.02E-03 7.30E-03 6.84E-06 7.05E-03 1.83E-03 2018 1 129 3.78E-03 2.19E-03 6.53E-03 6.36E-04 1.41E-02 5.43E-03 2019 0 116 3.72E-03 2.27E-03 6.08E-03 7.07E-06 7.30E-03 1.89E-03 2020 1 125 3.66E-03 2.24E-03 5.98E-03 6.45E-04 1.43E-02 5.51E-03 2021 1 114 3.60E-03 2.08E-03 6.21E-03 6.73E-04 1.50E-02 5.75E-03 2022 1 121 3.54E-03 1.86E-03 6.72E-03 6.56E-04 1.46E-02 5.60E-03 2023 0 115 3.48E-03 1.62E-03 7.46E-03 7.11E-06 7.34E-03 1.90E-03 2024 0 126 3.43E-03 1.39E-03 8.41E-03 6.82E-06 7.04E-03 1.83E-03 Total 11 3,364 38 Table 21. Plot data for Figure 6, failure rate estimate trend for HPCS EDG FTR>1H. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Run Time Year Failures Lower Upper Lower Upper (hr) Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 2.58E-04 1.67E-03 8.34E-04 1998 0 317 — — — 2.34E-06 2.28E-03 5.95E-04 1999 1 459 — — — 1.79E-04 3.97E-03 1.53E-03 2000 0 348 — — — 2.25E-06 2.20E-03 5.73E-04 2001 0 361 — — — 2.22E-06 2.17E-03 5.65E-04 2002 0 350 — — — 2.25E-06 2.20E-03 5.72E-04 2003 0 390 — — — 2.15E-06 2.10E-03 5.47E-04 2004 0 331 — — — 2.30E-06 2.25E-03 5.85E-04 2005 1 376 — — — 1.96E-04 4.34E-03 1.67E-03 2006 0 378 — — — 2.18E-06 2.13E-03 5.54E-04 2007 0 306 — — — 2.37E-06 2.31E-03 6.02E-04 2008 0 452 — — — 2.01E-06 1.97E-03 5.12E-04 2009 0 380 — — — 2.17E-06 2.12E-03 5.53E-04 2010 1 391 — — — 1.92E-04 4.27E-03 1.64E-03 2011 0 424 — — — 2.07E-06 2.03E-03 5.27E-04 2012 0 161 — — — 2.87E-06 2.80E-03 7.30E-04 2013 1 297 — — — 2.14E-04 4.76E-03 1.83E-03 2014 0 193 — — — 2.74E-06 2.68E-03 6.97E-04 2015 0 228 1.90E-03 8.06E-04 4.48E-03 2.62E-06 2.56E-03 6.65E-04 2016 1 205 1.77E-03 8.55E-04 3.68E-03 2.41E-04 5.36E-03 2.06E-03 2017 0 194 1.65E-03 8.95E-04 3.06E-03 2.74E-06 2.68E-03 6.96E-04 2018 2 185 1.54E-03 9.17E-04 2.60E-03 8.07E-04 7.80E-03 3.52E-03 2019 0 194 1.44E-03 9.08E-04 2.28E-03 2.74E-06 2.67E-03 6.96E-04 2020 0 203 1.34E-03 8.57E-04 2.11E-03 2.70E-06 2.64E-03 6.88E-04 2021 0 191 1.25E-03 7.68E-04 2.05E-03 2.75E-06 2.69E-03 6.99E-04 2022 0 190 1.17E-03 6.61E-04 2.07E-03 2.75E-06 2.69E-03 7.00E-04 2023 0 172 1.09E-03 5.54E-04 2.15E-03 2.83E-06 2.76E-03 7.19E-04 2024 0 184 1.02E-03 4.57E-04 2.27E-03 2.78E-06 2.71E-03 7.07E-04 Total 7 7,861 39 Table 22. Plot data for Figure 7, EPS EDG UA trend. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Critical Year UA Hours Lower Upper Lower Upper Hours Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 3.48E-03 2.67E-02 1.51E-02 1998 21,235 1,874,166 — — — 2.01E-03 2.42E-02 1.04E-02 1999 22,769 2,005,223 — — — 2.55E-03 2.42E-02 1.10E-02 2000 18,409 2,042,467 — — — 2.27E-03 2.08E-02 9.53E-03 2001 19,233 2,075,373 — — — 1.54E-03 2.36E-02 9.72E-03 2002 24,631 2,093,196 — — — 2.31E-03 2.78E-02 1.20E-02 2003 28,961 2,047,203 — — — 1.91E-03 3.49E-02 1.39E-02 2004 29,617 2,099,392 — — — 1.24E-03 3.71E-02 1.36E-02 2005 26,350 2,070,016 — — — 2.81E-03 2.90E-02 1.29E-02 2006 28,713 2,083,212 — — — 1.73E-03 3.36E-02 1.33E-02 2007 34,106 2,104,115 — — — 2.41E-03 3.99E-02 1.62E-02 2008 31,755 2,089,978 — — — 2.87E-03 3.53E-02 1.52E-02 2009 33,204 2,059,429 — — — 2.86E-03 3.79E-02 1.61E-02 2010 30,037 2,081,690 — — — 3.32E-03 3.16E-02 1.44E-02 2011 36,401 2,023,478 — — — 2.95E-03 4.18E-02 1.75E-02 2012 32,470 1,977,596 — — — 3.02E-03 3.68E-02 1.59E-02 2013 30,642 2,007,371 — — — 2.29E-03 3.34E-02 1.39E-02 2014 28,292 2,027,147 — — — 3.15E-03 3.19E-02 1.43E-02 2015 30,706 2,008,809 1.44E-02 1.28E-02 1.60E-02 3.65E-03 3.36E-02 1.54E-02 2016 29,859 2,025,233 1.42E-02 1.30E-02 1.54E-02 2.95E-04 5.06E-02 1.51E-02 2017 30,465 1,997,343 1.40E-02 1.31E-02 1.49E-02 2.00E-03 3.69E-02 1.47E-02 2018 25,798 1,990,438 1.38E-02 1.33E-02 1.44E-02 2.85E-03 2.92E-02 1.30E-02 2019 24,498 1,975,944 1.36E-02 1.35E-02 1.38E-02 2.19E-03 2.88E-02 1.22E-02 2020 21,822 1,887,082 1.34E-02 1.33E-02 1.36E-02 1.30E-03 2.96E-02 1.14E-02 2021 24,031 1,824,673 1.32E-02 1.27E-02 1.38E-02 2.35E-03 2.99E-02 1.28E-02 2022 23,839 1,807,766 1.30E-02 1.22E-02 1.39E-02 2.94E-03 3.02E-02 1.35E-02 2023 24,253 1,802,893 1.28E-02 1.16E-02 1.41E-02 2.46E-03 2.99E-02 1.29E-02 2024 25,772 1,772,656 1.26E-02 1.11E-02 1.42E-02 1.96E-03 3.62E-02 1.44E-02 Total 737,870 53,853,891 40 Table 23. Plot data for Figure 8, HPCS EDG UA trend. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Critical Year UA Hours Lower Upper Lower Upper Hours Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) SPAR 2020 — — — 7.13E-03 1.94E-02 1.33E-02 1998 255 42,029 — — — 4.24E-04 1.15E-02 4.27E-03 1999 760 55,565 — — — 7.09E-04 3.99E-02 1.35E-02 2000 959 65,705 — — — 8.40E-04 4.33E-02 1.48E-02 2001 474 65,093 — — — 1.27E-03 1.69E-02 7.13E-03 2002 431 65,329 — — — 1.14E-03 1.59E-02 6.66E-03 2003 825 65,040 — — — 6.07E-03 2.11E-02 1.26E-02 2004 855 65,589 — — — 4.00E-03 2.63E-02 1.31E-02 2005 610 64,383 — — — 3.59E-03 1.75E-02 9.42E-03 2006 453 66,949 — — — 1.85E-03 1.40E-02 6.71E-03 2007 592 64,512 — — — 1.92E-03 2.07E-02 9.14E-03 2008 861 65,262 — — — 2.31E-03 3.24E-02 1.36E-02 2009 519 63,966 — — — 2.54E-03 1.63E-02 8.13E-03 2010 1,050 67,158 — — — 2.34E-03 3.80E-02 1.55E-02 2011 991 62,329 — — — 4.37E-03 3.29E-02 1.58E-02 2012 815 64,557 — — — 2.20E-03 2.92E-02 1.24E-02 2013 952 64,142 — — — 2.33E-03 3.51E-02 1.45E-02 2014 1,012 66,677 — — — 2.39E-03 3.66E-02 1.51E-02 2015 627 65,277 1.29E-02 8.67E-03 1.91E-02 1.40E-03 2.37E-02 9.56E-03 2016 884 62,704 1.31E-02 9.64E-03 1.78E-02 3.09E-03 3.03E-02 1.37E-02 2017 827 63,353 1.33E-02 1.07E-02 1.66E-02 1.76E-03 3.45E-02 1.36E-02 2018 1,346 64,262 1.36E-02 1.19E-02 1.55E-02 1.46E-03 6.04E-02 2.12E-02 2019 593 65,338 1.38E-02 1.32E-02 1.44E-02 3.04E-03 1.77E-02 9.08E-03 2020 1,332 65,659 1.41E-02 1.35E-02 1.47E-02 6.53E-03 4.20E-02 2.10E-02 2021 740 65,168 1.43E-02 1.26E-02 1.63E-02 1.34E-03 3.00E-02 1.15E-02 2022 1,518 66,249 1.46E-02 1.17E-02 1.81E-02 8.05E-03 4.36E-02 2.29E-02 2023 655 62,218 1.48E-02 1.09E-02 2.01E-02 3.24E-04 3.81E-02 1.18E-02 2024 851 68,112 1.51E-02 1.02E-02 2.24E-02 1.96E-03 3.01E-02 1.24E-02 Total 21,786 1,722,625 41 Table 24. Plot data for Figure 9, EPS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Mean Lower (5%) Upper (95%) Lower (5%) Upper (95%) Mean 1998 — — — 1.53E-02 4.09E-02 2.57E-02 1999 — — — 7.64E-03 3.04E-02 1.69E-02 2000 — — — 1.58E-02 3.93E-02 2.59E-02 2001 — — — 9.70E-03 3.26E-02 1.91E-02 2002 — — — 1.71E-02 4.67E-02 2.96E-02 2003 — — — 2.49E-02 6.19E-02 4.08E-02 2004 — — — 2.62E-02 7.00E-02 4.39E-02 2005 — — — 3.04E-02 6.40E-02 4.57E-02 2006 — — — 1.34E-02 4.90E-02 2.76E-02 2007 — — — 3.79E-02 8.29E-02 5.66E-02 2008 — — — 3.96E-02 8.13E-02 5.81E-02 2009 — — — 2.40E-02 6.35E-02 4.06E-02 2010 — — — 3.04E-02 6.66E-02 4.61E-02 2011 — — — 4.32E-02 8.90E-02 6.26E-02 2012 — — — 3.65E-02 8.14E-02 5.63E-02 2013 — — — 4.28E-02 9.04E-02 6.44E-02 2014 — — — 4.79E-02 9.70E-02 7.00E-02 2015 5.91E-02 4.38E-02 7.97E-02 3.62E-02 7.80E-02 5.56E-02 2016 5.45E-02 4.23E-02 7.03E-02 2.70E-02 8.68E-02 5.03E-02 2017 5.03E-02 4.06E-02 6.23E-02 5.72E-02 1.14E-01 8.22E-02 2018 4.64E-02 3.87E-02 5.57E-02 2.94E-02 6.61E-02 4.64E-02 2019 4.28E-02 3.64E-02 5.04E-02 2.31E-02 6.13E-02 3.91E-02 2020 3.95E-02 3.35E-02 4.65E-02 1.42E-02 5.10E-02 2.95E-02 2021 3.64E-02 3.04E-02 4.37E-02 1.54E-02 4.90E-02 2.99E-02 2022 3.36E-02 2.72E-02 4.16E-02 1.83E-02 5.33E-02 3.35E-02 2023 3.10E-02 2.41E-02 4.00E-02 1.53E-02 4.97E-02 3.04E-02 2024 2.86E-02 2.12E-02 3.86E-02 1.93E-02 6.21E-02 3.70E-02 42 Table 25. Plot data for Figure 10, HPCS EDG total unreliability trend (24-hour mission). Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Year Mean Lower (5%) Upper (95%) Lower (5%) Upper (95%) Mean 1998 — — — 3.81E-03 5.47E-02 2.08E-02 1999 — — — 1.88E-02 1.13E-01 5.57E-02 2000 — — — 5.25E-03 7.85E-02 3.07E-02 2001 — — — 5.24E-03 6.44E-02 2.31E-02 2002 — — — 7.61E-03 6.22E-02 2.58E-02 2003 — — — 1.04E-02 6.44E-02 2.76E-02 2004 — — — 1.17E-02 7.34E-02 3.20E-02 2005 — — — 1.60E-02 1.03E-01 4.81E-02 2006 — — — 6.02E-03 5.95E-02 2.37E-02 2007 — — — 6.39E-03 6.68E-02 2.63E-02 2008 — — — 9.30E-03 6.38E-02 2.99E-02 2009 — — — 6.57E-03 6.37E-02 2.44E-02 2010 — — — 2.03E-02 1.15E-01 5.82E-02 2011 — — — 1.01E-02 6.92E-02 3.08E-02 2012 — — — 9.35E-03 8.27E-02 3.58E-02 2013 — — — 1.63E-02 1.29E-01 5.80E-02 2014 — — — 1.37E-02 9.01E-02 4.15E-02 2015 4.78E-02 2.86E-02 7.97E-02 8.83E-03 7.71E-02 3.17E-02 2016 4.63E-02 3.00E-02 7.15E-02 1.80E-02 1.32E-01 6.18E-02 2017 4.49E-02 3.12E-02 6.47E-02 7.34E-03 7.71E-02 3.19E-02 2018 4.36E-02 3.19E-02 5.95E-02 3.89E-02 1.91E-01 1.03E-01 2019 4.23E-02 3.20E-02 5.59E-02 9.71E-03 7.03E-02 2.98E-02 2020 4.10E-02 3.10E-02 5.42E-02 1.98E-02 9.40E-02 4.77E-02 2021 3.98E-02 2.91E-02 5.43E-02 9.90E-03 7.94E-02 3.44E-02 2022 3.86E-02 2.68E-02 5.56E-02 1.75E-02 9.00E-02 4.42E-02 2023 3.74E-02 2.42E-02 5.78E-02 7.12E-03 8.37E-02 3.35E-02 2024 3.63E-02 2.17E-02 6.05E-02 8.93E-03 7.95E-02 3.33E-02 43 Table 26. Plot data for Figure 11, frequency of start demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Reactor Year Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 4,926 96.0 — — — 5.01E+01 5.25E+01 5.13E+01 1999 4,822 96.0 — — — 4.90E+01 5.14E+01 5.02E+01 2000 4,710 96.3 — — — 4.78E+01 5.01E+01 4.89E+01 2001 4,724 96.0 — — — 4.80E+01 5.04E+01 4.92E+01 2002 4,813 96.0 — — — 4.90E+01 5.13E+01 5.01E+01 2003 4,574 96.0 — — — 4.65E+01 4.88E+01 4.76E+01 2004 4,468 96.3 — — — 4.53E+01 4.76E+01 4.64E+01 2005 4,507 96.0 — — — 4.58E+01 4.81E+01 4.69E+01 2006 4,498 96.0 — — — 4.57E+01 4.80E+01 4.69E+01 2007 4,403 96.0 — — — 4.47E+01 4.70E+01 4.59E+01 2008 4,470 96.3 — — — 4.53E+01 4.76E+01 4.64E+01 2009 4,365 96.0 — — — 4.43E+01 4.66E+01 4.55E+01 2010 4,293 96.0 — — — 4.36E+01 4.59E+01 4.47E+01 2011 4,330 96.0 — — — 4.40E+01 4.63E+01 4.51E+01 2012 4,100 96.3 — — — 4.15E+01 4.37E+01 4.26E+01 2013 4,207 93.6 — — — 4.38E+01 4.61E+01 4.50E+01 2014 4,154 92.0 — — — 4.40E+01 4.63E+01 4.52E+01 2015 4,133 91.0 4.53E+01 4.47E+01 4.59E+01 4.43E+01 4.66E+01 4.54E+01 2016 4,148 91.0 4.56E+01 4.51E+01 4.61E+01 4.44E+01 4.68E+01 4.56E+01 2017 4,097 90.0 4.59E+01 4.55E+01 4.63E+01 4.44E+01 4.67E+01 4.55E+01 2018 4,107 89.7 4.62E+01 4.58E+01 4.65E+01 4.46E+01 4.70E+01 4.58E+01 2019 4,102 88.0 4.65E+01 4.62E+01 4.68E+01 4.54E+01 4.78E+01 4.66E+01 2020 4,080 86.2 4.68E+01 4.65E+01 4.71E+01 4.61E+01 4.86E+01 4.73E+01 2021 3,981 84.3 4.71E+01 4.67E+01 4.74E+01 4.60E+01 4.85E+01 4.72E+01 2022 4,000 83.4 4.74E+01 4.69E+01 4.78E+01 4.67E+01 4.92E+01 4.80E+01 2023 3,922 83.0 4.77E+01 4.72E+01 4.82E+01 4.60E+01 4.85E+01 4.73E+01 2024 3,965 83.2 4.80E+01 4.74E+01 4.86E+01 4.64E+01 4.89E+01 4.76E+01 Total 116,901 2,496.6 44 Table 27. Plot data for Figure 12, frequency of FTLR demands (demands per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Reactor Year Demands Lower Upper Lower Upper Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 4,207 96.0 — — — 4.27E+01 4.49E+01 4.38E+01 1999 4,171 96.0 — — — 4.23E+01 4.46E+01 4.34E+01 2000 4,262 96.3 — — — 4.32E+01 4.54E+01 4.43E+01 2001 4,298 96.0 — — — 4.37E+01 4.59E+01 4.48E+01 2002 4,058 96.0 — — — 4.12E+01 4.34E+01 4.23E+01 2003 4,005 96.0 — — — 4.06E+01 4.28E+01 4.17E+01 2004 3,951 96.3 — — — 4.00E+01 4.21E+01 4.10E+01 2005 3,903 96.0 — — — 3.96E+01 4.17E+01 4.07E+01 2006 3,881 96.0 — — — 3.94E+01 4.15E+01 4.04E+01 2007 3,760 96.0 — — — 3.81E+01 4.02E+01 3.92E+01 2008 3,858 96.3 — — — 3.90E+01 4.12E+01 4.01E+01 2009 3,792 96.0 — — — 3.85E+01 4.06E+01 3.95E+01 2010 3,758 96.0 — — — 3.81E+01 4.02E+01 3.91E+01 2011 3,796 96.0 — — — 3.85E+01 4.06E+01 3.95E+01 2012 3,626 96.3 — — — 3.66E+01 3.87E+01 3.77E+01 2013 3,663 93.6 — — — 3.81E+01 4.02E+01 3.91E+01 2014 3,662 92.0 — — — 3.87E+01 4.09E+01 3.98E+01 2015 3,628 91.0 3.96E+01 3.91E+01 4.01E+01 3.88E+01 4.10E+01 3.99E+01 2016 3,620 91.0 3.98E+01 3.94E+01 4.03E+01 3.87E+01 4.09E+01 3.98E+01 2017 3,576 90.0 4.01E+01 3.97E+01 4.04E+01 3.86E+01 4.08E+01 3.97E+01 2018 3,612 89.7 4.03E+01 4.00E+01 4.06E+01 3.92E+01 4.14E+01 4.02E+01 2019 3,536 88.0 4.05E+01 4.02E+01 4.08E+01 3.91E+01 4.13E+01 4.02E+01 2020 3,532 86.2 4.07E+01 4.05E+01 4.10E+01 3.98E+01 4.21E+01 4.10E+01 2021 3,464 84.3 4.10E+01 4.06E+01 4.13E+01 3.99E+01 4.22E+01 4.11E+01 2022 3,492 83.4 4.12E+01 4.08E+01 4.16E+01 4.07E+01 4.31E+01 4.19E+01 2023 3,408 83.0 4.14E+01 4.10E+01 4.19E+01 3.99E+01 4.22E+01 4.11E+01 2024 3,451 83.2 4.16E+01 4.11E+01 4.22E+01 4.03E+01 4.26E+01 4.15E+01 Total 101,968 2,496.6 45 Table 28. Plot data for Figure 13, frequency of run > 1H hours (hours per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDG. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Run Reactor Year Lower Upper Lower Upper Hours Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 11,607 96.0 — — — 1.19E+02 1.23E+02 1.21E+02 1999 12,151 96.0 — — — 1.25E+02 1.28E+02 1.27E+02 2000 13,956 96.3 — — — 1.43E+02 1.47E+02 1.45E+02 2001 14,527 96.0 — — — 1.49E+02 1.53E+02 1.51E+02 2002 13,588 96.0 — — — 1.40E+02 1.44E+02 1.42E+02 2003 12,321 96.0 — — — 1.26E+02 1.30E+02 1.28E+02 2004 12,064 96.3 — — — 1.23E+02 1.27E+02 1.25E+02 2005 12,669 96.0 — — — 1.30E+02 1.34E+02 1.32E+02 2006 11,743 96.0 — — — 1.20E+02 1.24E+02 1.22E+02 2007 11,764 96.0 — — — 1.21E+02 1.24E+02 1.23E+02 2008 12,067 96.3 — — — 1.23E+02 1.27E+02 1.25E+02 2009 12,017 96.0 — — — 1.23E+02 1.27E+02 1.25E+02 2010 11,690 96.0 — — — 1.20E+02 1.24E+02 1.22E+02 2011 12,756 96.0 — — — 1.31E+02 1.35E+02 1.33E+02 2012 7,513 96.3 — — — 7.66E+01 7.95E+01 7.80E+01 2013 8,210 93.6 — — — 8.62E+01 8.94E+01 8.77E+01 2014 7,421 92.0 — — — 7.91E+01 8.22E+01 8.07E+01 2015 8,011 91.0 8.56E+01 8.29E+01 8.84E+01 8.64E+01 8.97E+01 8.80E+01 2016 7,798 91.0 8.62E+01 8.39E+01 8.86E+01 8.41E+01 8.73E+01 8.57E+01 2017 7,596 90.0 8.68E+01 8.48E+01 8.88E+01 8.28E+01 8.60E+01 8.44E+01 2018 8,060 89.7 8.74E+01 8.57E+01 8.91E+01 8.82E+01 9.15E+01 8.98E+01 2019 7,586 88.0 8.80E+01 8.64E+01 8.95E+01 8.46E+01 8.79E+01 8.62E+01 2020 7,617 86.2 8.86E+01 8.70E+01 9.02E+01 8.67E+01 9.00E+01 8.83E+01 2021 7,384 84.3 8.92E+01 8.74E+01 9.10E+01 8.59E+01 8.93E+01 8.76E+01 2022 7,517 83.4 8.98E+01 8.77E+01 9.19E+01 8.84E+01 9.18E+01 9.01E+01 2023 7,429 83.0 9.04E+01 8.79E+01 9.29E+01 8.78E+01 9.12E+01 8.95E+01 2024 7,772 83.2 9.10E+01 8.81E+01 9.40E+01 9.17E+01 9.51E+01 9.34E+01 Total 274,836 2,496.6 46 Table 29. Plot data for Figure 14, frequency of FTS events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Reactor Year Failures Lower Upper Lower Upper Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 18 96.0 — — — 1.19E-01 2.71E-01 1.84E-01 1999 9 96.0 — — — 5.02E-02 1.62E-01 9.43E-02 2000 12 96.3 — — — 7.23E-02 1.99E-01 1.24E-01 2001 12 96.0 — — — 7.25E-02 1.99E-01 1.24E-01 2002 10 96.0 — — — 5.75E-02 1.75E-01 1.04E-01 2003 17 96.0 — — — 1.11E-01 2.59E-01 1.74E-01 2004 14 96.3 — — — 8.76E-02 2.23E-01 1.44E-01 2005 16 96.0 — — — 1.04E-01 2.47E-01 1.64E-01 2006 9 96.0 — — — 5.02E-02 1.62E-01 9.43E-02 2007 11 96.0 — — — 6.50E-02 1.87E-01 1.14E-01 2008 9 96.3 — — — 5.01E-02 1.62E-01 9.40E-02 2009 15 96.0 — — — 9.57E-02 2.35E-01 1.54E-01 2010 15 96.0 — — — 9.57E-02 2.35E-01 1.54E-01 2011 19 96.0 — — — 1.28E-01 2.83E-01 1.94E-01 2012 14 96.3 — — — 8.76E-02 2.23E-01 1.44E-01 2013 6 93.6 — — — 3.00E-02 1.27E-01 6.61E-02 2014 13 92.0 — — — 8.35E-02 2.20E-01 1.40E-01 2015 13 91.0 1.17E-01 6.97E-02 1.98E-01 8.43E-02 2.22E-01 1.41E-01 2016 13 91.0 1.13E-01 7.27E-02 1.75E-01 8.43E-02 2.22E-01 1.41E-01 2017 10 90.0 1.08E-01 7.49E-02 1.57E-01 6.12E-02 1.86E-01 1.11E-01 2018 8 89.7 1.04E-01 7.58E-02 1.43E-01 4.59E-02 1.59E-01 8.99E-02 2019 5 88.0 1.00E-01 7.45E-02 1.35E-01 2.47E-02 1.21E-01 5.93E-02 2020 6 86.2 9.63E-02 7.06E-02 1.31E-01 3.24E-02 1.37E-01 7.14E-02 2021 12 84.3 9.26E-02 6.49E-02 1.32E-01 8.20E-02 2.25E-01 1.40E-01 2022 4 83.4 8.90E-02 5.84E-02 1.36E-01 1.89E-02 1.12E-01 5.10E-02 2023 11 83.0 8.55E-02 5.19E-02 1.41E-01 7.46E-02 2.15E-01 1.31E-01 2024 9 83.2 8.22E-02 4.57E-02 1.48E-01 5.75E-02 1.86E-01 1.08E-01 Total 310 2,496.6 47 Table 30. Plot data for Figure 15, frequency of FTLR events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Reactor Year Failures Lower Upper Lower Upper Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 14 96.0 — — — 8.77E-02 2.23E-01 1.44E-01 1999 5 96.0 — — — 2.27E-02 1.11E-01 5.45E-02 2000 8 96.3 — — — 4.29E-02 1.49E-01 8.40E-02 2001 13 96.0 — — — 8.00E-02 2.11E-01 1.34E-01 2002 14 96.0 — — — 8.77E-02 2.23E-01 1.44E-01 2003 15 96.0 — — — 9.55E-02 2.35E-01 1.54E-01 2004 10 96.3 — — — 5.73E-02 1.74E-01 1.04E-01 2005 15 96.0 — — — 9.55E-02 2.35E-01 1.54E-01 2006 15 96.0 — — — 9.55E-02 2.35E-01 1.54E-01 2007 21 96.0 — — — 1.44E-01 3.05E-01 2.13E-01 2008 16 96.3 — — — 1.03E-01 2.46E-01 1.63E-01 2009 18 96.0 — — — 1.19E-01 2.70E-01 1.83E-01 2010 11 96.0 — — — 6.49E-02 1.87E-01 1.14E-01 2011 16 96.0 — — — 1.03E-01 2.47E-01 1.64E-01 2012 17 96.3 — — — 1.11E-01 2.58E-01 1.73E-01 2013 12 93.6 — — — 7.42E-02 2.04E-01 1.27E-01 2014 12 92.0 — — — 7.54E-02 2.07E-01 1.29E-01 2015 13 91.0 1.23E-01 7.72E-02 1.96E-01 8.42E-02 2.22E-01 1.41E-01 2016 11 91.0 1.16E-01 7.84E-02 1.72E-01 6.82E-02 1.96E-01 1.20E-01 2017 9 90.0 1.10E-01 7.88E-02 1.53E-01 5.33E-02 1.72E-01 1.00E-01 2018 14 89.7 1.04E-01 7.77E-02 1.38E-01 9.35E-02 2.38E-01 1.53E-01 2019 7 88.0 9.77E-02 7.45E-02 1.28E-01 3.91E-02 1.48E-01 8.07E-02 2020 4 86.2 9.22E-02 6.92E-02 1.23E-01 1.82E-02 1.08E-01 4.94E-02 2021 5 84.3 8.71E-02 6.25E-02 1.21E-01 2.56E-02 1.25E-01 6.16E-02 2022 10 83.4 8.22E-02 5.54E-02 1.22E-01 6.56E-02 1.99E-01 1.19E-01 2023 6 83.0 7.76E-02 4.86E-02 1.24E-01 3.35E-02 1.42E-01 7.39E-02 2024 9 83.2 7.32E-02 4.23E-02 1.27E-01 5.74E-02 1.85E-01 1.08E-01 Total 320 2,496.6 48 Table 31. Plot data for Figure 16, frequency of FTR>1H events (events per reactor year) trend for EPS and HPCS EDGs. Regression Curve Data Points Plot Trend Error Bar Points Reactor Year Failures Lower Upper Lower Upper Years Mean Mean (5%) (95%) (5%) (95%) 1998 4 96.0 — — — 1.65E-02 9.74E-02 4.45E-02 1999 1 96.0 — — — 1.74E-03 5.48E-02 1.48E-02 2000 7 96.3 — — — 3.58E-02 1.36E-01 7.40E-02 2001 2 96.0 — — — 5.67E-03 6.96E-02 2.47E-02 2002 7 96.0 — — — 3.59E-02 1.37E-01 7.42E-02 2003 10 96.0 — — — 5.74E-02 1.74E-01 1.04E-01 2004 13 96.3 — — — 7.97E-02 2.10E-01 1.33E-01 2005 14 96.0 — — — 8.76E-02 2.23E-01 1.44E-01 2006 4 96.0 — — — 1.65E-02 9.74E-02 4.45E-02 2007 17 96.0 — — — 1.11E-01 2.58E-01 1.73E-01 2008 20 96.3 — — — 1.35E-01 2.93E-01 2.02E-01 2009 8 96.0 — — — 4.29E-02 1.49E-01 8.41E-02 2010 13 96.0 — — — 7.99E-02 2.11E-01 1.34E-01 2011 21 96.0 — — — 1.43E-01 3.05E-01 2.13E-01 2012 11 96.3 — — — 6.46E-02 1.86E-01 1.14E-01 2013 17 93.6 — — — 1.14E-01 2.65E-01 1.77E-01 2014 17 92.0 — — — 1.16E-01 2.69E-01 1.80E-01 2015 12 91.0 1.51E-01 9.66E-02 2.37E-01 7.61E-02 2.09E-01 1.30E-01 2016 10 91.0 1.34E-01 9.19E-02 1.95E-01 6.04E-02 1.83E-01 1.09E-01 2017 22 90.0 1.18E-01 8.61E-02 1.62E-01 1.61E-01 3.37E-01 2.37E-01 2018 10 89.7 1.05E-01 7.88E-02 1.39E-01 6.12E-02 1.86E-01 1.11E-01 2019 8 88.0 9.24E-02 6.98E-02 1.22E-01 4.66E-02 1.62E-01 9.14E-02 2020 5 86.2 8.17E-02 5.97E-02 1.12E-01 2.51E-02 1.23E-01 6.03E-02 2021 4 84.3 7.22E-02 4.98E-02 1.04E-01 1.86E-02 1.10E-01 5.04E-02 2022 5 83.4 6.38E-02 4.10E-02 9.93E-02 2.59E-02 1.26E-01 6.22E-02 2023 4 83.0 5.64E-02 3.34E-02 9.52E-02 1.89E-02 1.12E-01 5.11E-02 2024 6 83.2 4.98E-02 2.71E-02 9.18E-02 3.34E-02 1.42E-01 7.36E-02 Total 272 2,496.6 49 9. REFERENCES [1] U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. 2007. “Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998-2006,” Accessed March 8, 2022. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/CompPerf/edg-2006.pdf. [2] Ma, Z. 2023. “Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998- 2022,” INL/RPT-23-73954, Idaho National Laboratory. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/CompPerf/edg-2022.pdf. [3] Gentillion, C. D. 2016. “Overview and Reference Document for Operational Experience Results and Databases Trending.” Accessed March 8, 2022. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/Overview-and-Reference.pdf. [4] Institute of Nuclear Power Operations. 2019. “Industry Reporting and Information System (IRIS),” INPO 19-002, Revision 1, Institute of Nuclear Power Operations. [5] Lane, J. C. 2015. “NRC Operating Experience (OpE) Programs,” Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research, SPAR Workshop Public Meeting, July 14–15, 2015. http://pbadupws.nrc.gov/docs/ML1518/ML15189A345.pdf. [6] Nuclear Energy Institute. 2013. “Regulatory Assessment Performance Indicator Guideline,” NEI 99-02, Revision 7, Nuclear Energy Institute. https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1326/ML13261A116.pdf. [7] Ma, Z., T. E. Wierman, and K. J. Kvarfordt. 2021. “Industry-Average Performance for Components and Initiating Events at U.S. Commercial Nuclear Power Plants: 2020 Update,” INL/EXT-21- 65055, Idaho National Laboratory. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/AvgPerf/AvgPara2020.pdf [8] Eide, S. A., T. E. Wierman, C. D. Gentillon, D. M. Rasmuson, and C. L. Atwood. 2007. “Industry- Average Performance for Components and Initiating Events at U.S. Commercial Nuclear Power Plants,” NUREG/CR-6928, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML0706/ML070650650.pdf. [9] Ma, Z. 2022. “Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998- 2020,” INL/RPT-22-66601, Idaho National Laboratory. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/CompPerf/edg-2020.pdf. [10] Ma, Z. 2019. “Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998- 2018,” INL/EXT-19-54609, Idaho National Laboratory. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/CompPerf/edg-2018.pdf. [11] Schroeder, J. A. 2018. “Enhanced Component Performance Study: Emergency Diesel Generators 1998-2016,” INL/LTD-17-44204, Idaho National Laboratory. https://nrcoe.inl.gov/publicdocs/CompPerf/edg-2016.pdf. [12] Atwood, C. L., et al. 2003. “Handbook of Parameter Estimation for Probabilistic Risk Assessment,” NUREG/CR-6823, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML0329/ML032900131.pdf. 50 APPENDIX A EDG EQUIPMENT LIST This appendix provides a list of the EPS and HPCS EDG equipment included in this report for reliability and engineering analyses. Each EDG is identified by its associated plant and system, manufacturer, rating, in-service date, and, where applicable, out-of-service date. Table A-1. EDG equipment list. In-Service Out-of- Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating Date Service Date 1 Arkansas Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/19/1974 2 Arkansas Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/19/1974 3 Arkansas Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/26/1980 4 Arkansas Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/26/1980 5 Beaver Valley Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/10/1976 6 Beaver Valley Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/10/1976 7 Beaver Valley Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 8/4/1987 8 Beaver Valley Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 8/4/1987 9 Braidwood Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/15/1987 3/31/2012 10 Braidwood Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/15/1987 3/31/2012 11 Braidwood Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 12 Braidwood Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 13 Braidwood Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 100,000-499,999 KW 5/30/1988 3/31/2012 14 Braidwood Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 5/30/1988 3/31/2012 15 Braidwood Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 16 Braidwood Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 100,000-499,999 KW 4/1/2012 17 Browns Ferry Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 6/1/1972 18 Browns Ferry Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/1/1974 19 Browns Ferry Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/1/1974 20 Browns Ferry Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/1/1974 21 Browns Ferry Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1977 22 Browns Ferry Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1977 51 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 23 Browns Ferry Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1977 24 Browns Ferry Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1977 25 Brunswick Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 11/3/1975 26 Brunswick Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 11/3/1975 27 Brunswick Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 3/18/1977 28 Brunswick Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 3/18/1977 29 Byron Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/2/1985 3/31/2012 30 Byron Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/2/1985 3/31/2012 31 Byron Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 32 Byron Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 33 Byron Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/9/1987 3/31/2012 34 Byron Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/9/1987 3/31/2012 35 Byron Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 36 Byron Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 4/1/2012 37 Callaway EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 10/2/1984 38 Callaway EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 10/2/1984 39 Calvert Cliffs Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 5/8/1975 40 Calvert Cliffs Unit 1 EPS SAC/Compair Luchard/Jeumont Schndr 5,000-99,999 KW 5/17/1995 41 Calvert Cliffs Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 4/1/1977 42 Calvert Cliffs Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 4/4/1996 43 Catawba Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 1/7/1985 44 Catawba Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 1/7/1985 45 Catawba Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/19/1986 46 Catawba Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/19/1986 47 Clinton Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 1/3/1986 48 Clinton Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 1/3/1986 50 Columbia EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/19/1983 51 Columbia EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/19/1983 53 Comanche Peak Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/13/1990 52 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 54 Comanche Peak Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/13/1990 55 Comanche Peak Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/3/1993 56 Comanche Peak Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 8/3/1993 57 Cook Unit 1 EPS Worthington Corp 1,000-4,999 KW 1/1/1975 58 Cook Unit 1 EPS Worthington Corp 1,000-4,999 KW 1/1/1975 59 Cook Unit 2 EPS Worthington Corp 1,000-4,999 KW 3/10/1978 60 Cook Unit 2 EPS Worthington Corp 1,000-4,999 KW 3/10/1978 61 Cooper Station EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 2/21/1974 62 Cooper Station EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 2/21/1974 63 Crystal River Unit 3 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/13/1977 64 Crystal River Unit 3 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/13/1977 65 Davis-Besse EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 11/21/1977 66 Davis-Besse EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 11/21/1977 67 Diablo Canyon Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 4/29/1984 68 Diablo Canyon Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 4/29/1984 69 Diablo Canyon Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 4/29/1984 70 Diablo Canyon Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/20/1985 71 Diablo Canyon Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/20/1985 72 Diablo Canyon Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 5/1/1993 73 Dresden Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 1/7/1970 74 Dresden Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 1/7/1970 75 Dresden Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 10/5/1971 76 Duane Arnold EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 2/27/1974 77 Duane Arnold EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 2/27/1974 78 Farley Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1977 79 Farley Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1977 80 Farley Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1977 81 Farley Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1977 82 Farley Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 7/30/1981 53 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 83 Fermi Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 1/23/1984 84 Fermi Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 1/23/1984 85 Fermi Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 1/23/1984 86 Fermi Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 1/23/1984 87 FitzPatrick EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/28/1975 88 FitzPatrick EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/28/1975 89 FitzPatrick EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/28/1975 90 FitzPatrick EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/28/1975 91 Fort Calhoun EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 9/26/1973 92 Fort Calhoun EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 9/26/1973 93 Ginna EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1970 94 Ginna EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1970 95 Grand Gulf EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/16/1982 96 Grand Gulf EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/16/1982 98 Harris EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 11/17/1986 99 Harris EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 11/17/1986 100 Hatch Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/31/1975 101 Hatch Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/31/1975 102 Hatch Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 5/4/1996 103 Hatch Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 9/5/1979 104 Hatch Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 9/5/1979 105 Hope Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/28/1986 106 Hope Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/28/1986 107 Hope Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/28/1986 108 Hope Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/28/1986 109 Indian Point Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/15/1973 110 Indian Point Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/15/1973 111 Indian Point Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/15/1973 112 Indian Point Unit 3 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/30/1976 54 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 113 Indian Point Unit 3 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/30/1976 114 Indian Point Unit 3 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 8/30/1976 115 Kewaunee EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 6/16/1974 116 Kewaunee EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 6/16/1974 117 La Salle Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 9/4/1982 118 La Salle Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 9/4/1982 120 La Salle Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/10/1984 122 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/20/1984 123 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/20/1984 124 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/20/1984 125 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/20/1984 126 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 10/1/2018 127 Limerick Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 10/1/2018 128 Limerick Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/23/1989 129 Limerick Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/23/1989 130 Limerick Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/23/1989 131 Limerick Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/23/1989 132 McGuire Unit 1 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1981 133 McGuire Unit 1 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1981 134 McGuire Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1984 135 McGuire Unit 2 EPS Nordberg 1,000-4,999 KW 3/1/1984 136 Millstone Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/26/1975 137 Millstone Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/26/1975 138 Millstone Unit 3 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 4/23/1986 139 Millstone Unit 3 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 4/23/1986 140 Monticello EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/4/1971 141 Monticello EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/4/1971 142 Nine Mile Pt. Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/14/1969 143 Nine Mile Pt. Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/14/1969 55 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 144 Nine Mile Pt. Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 4/5/1988 145 Nine Mile Pt. Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 4/5/1988 147 North Anna Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/6/1978 148 North Anna Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 6/6/1978 149 North Anna Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 1/1/1977 150 North Anna Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/14/1980 151 Oyster Creek EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/23/1969 152 Oyster Creek EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/23/1969 153 Palisades EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 12/31/1971 154 Palisades EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 12/31/1971 155 Palo Verde Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/27/1986 156 Palo Verde Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/27/1986 157 Palo Verde Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 9/18/1986 158 Palo Verde Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 9/18/1986 159 Palo Verde Unit 3 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/8/1988 160 Palo Verde Unit 3 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 1/8/1988 161 Peach Bottom Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 7/5/1974 162 Peach Bottom Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 7/5/1974 163 Peach Bottom Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 7/5/1974 164 Peach Bottom Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 7/5/1974 165 Perry EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/1/1986 166 Perry EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/1/1986 168 Pilgrim EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 12/9/1972 169 Pilgrim EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 12/9/1972 170 Point Beach Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/21/1970 171 Point Beach Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/21/1970 172 Point Beach Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/1/1994 173 Point Beach Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/15/1995 174 Prairie Island Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/16/1973 56 In-Service Out-of- Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating Date Service Date 175 Prairie Island Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 12/16/1973 176 Prairie Island Unit 2 EPS SAC/Compair Luchard/Jeumont Schndr 5,000-99,999 KW 1/1/1993 177 Prairie Island Unit 2 EPS SAC/Compair Luchard/Jeumont Schndr 5,000-99,999 KW 1/1/1993 178 Quad Cities Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 10/7/1971 179 Quad Cities Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 10/7/1971 180 Quad Cities Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 4/26/1973 181 River Bend EPS Transamerica Delaval 1,000-4,999 KW 1/15/1985 182 River Bend EPS Transamerica Delaval 1,000-4,999 KW 1/15/1985 184 Robinson Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/7/1971 185 Robinson Unit 2 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 3/7/1971 186 Salem Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 6/30/1977 187 Salem Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 6/30/1977 188 Salem Unit 1 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 6/30/1977 189 Salem Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 10/13/1981 190 Salem Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 10/13/1981 191 Salem Unit 2 EPS ALCO Power 1,000-4,999 KW 10/13/1981 192 San Onofre Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/8/1983 193 San Onofre Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/8/1983 194 San Onofre Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 4/1/1984 9/5/2008 195 San Onofre Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 4/1/1984 196 San Onofre Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 9/5/2008 197 Seabrook EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 6/13/1989 198 Seabrook EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 6/13/1989 199 Sequoyah Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 6/7/1982 200 Sequoyah Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 6/1/1982 201 Sequoyah Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1981 202 Sequoyah Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1981 203 South Texas Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 7/4/1987 204 South Texas Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 7/4/1987 57 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 205 South Texas Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 7/4/1987 206 South Texas Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/15/1989 207 South Texas Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/15/1989 208 South Texas Unit 2 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 2/15/1989 209 St. Lucie Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/31/1994 210 St. Lucie Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/31/1994 211 St. Lucie Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/14/1990 212 St. Lucie Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/14/1990 213 Summer EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 10/22/1982 214 Summer EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 10/22/1982 215 Surry Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1972 216 Surry Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/1/1972 217 Surry Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 7/19/2022 218 Surry Unit 2 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 3/7/1973 219 Susquehanna Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 6/8/1983 220 Susquehanna Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 6/8/1983 221 Susquehanna Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 6/8/1983 222 Susquehanna Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 1,000-4,999 KW 6/8/1983 223 Susquehanna Unit 1 EPS Cooper Bessemer 5,000-99,999 KW 6/8/1987 224 Three Mile Isl Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 9/2/1974 225 Three Mile Isl Unit 1 EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 9/2/1974 226 Turkey Point Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/4/1972 227 Turkey Point Unit 3 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 12/4/1972 228 Turkey Point Unit 4 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/15/1991 229 Turkey Point Unit 4 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 8/15/1991 230 Vermont Yankee EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 11/30/1972 231 Vermont Yankee EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 1,000-4,999 KW 11/30/1972 232 Vogtle Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/1/1987 233 Vogtle Unit 1 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 6/1/1987 58 Item Plant Name System Manufacturer Rating 234 Vogtle Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 5/19/1989 235 Vogtle Unit 2 EPS Transamerica Delaval 5,000-99,999 KW 5/19/1989 236 Waterford Unit 3 EPS Cooper Bessemer 50-249 KW 5/27/1985 237 Waterford Unit 3 EPS Cooper Bessemer 50-249 KW 5/27/1985 238 Watts Bar Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/27/1996 239 Watts Bar Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/27/1996 240 Watts Bar Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/27/1996 241 Watts Bar Unit 1 EPS Electro Motive/General Motors 1,000-4,999 KW 5/27/1996 242 Wolf Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 5/22/1985 243 Wolf Creek EPS Fairbanks Morse/Colt 5,000-99,999 KW 5/22/1985 59 APPENDIX B Overview of SPAR Parameter, Component Performance, and System Study Updates This appendix provides a comparative overview of the three primary update activities under the NRC’s operating experience data analysis program: the SPAR Parameter Update, the Component Performance Study Update, and the System Study Update. Although these activities use common operating experience data sources, they differ in purpose, update frequency, data periods, methodologies, and outputs. Table B-1 summarizes the key attributes of each update activity, highlighting how industry-average parameters, yearly component performance estimates, and system-level reliability results are developed and used within the SPAR modeling and trending analyses. Table B-1. Comparison of SPAR Parameter, Component Performance, and System Study Updates. Component Performance Study Item SPAR Parameter Update System Study Update Update Use operating experience data from a Use operating experience data from a Run SPAR system fault trees with selected period to estimate yearly selected period to estimate industry- yearly system-specific component Purpose component parameters for average PRA parameters for SPAR parameters to conduct system component performance trending models. reliability trending analysis. analysis. Original NUREG NUREG/CR-6928 NUREG-1715 NUREG/CR-5500 Update Every five years (2010, 2015, 2020, Annually from 2002 to 2014; biennially Annually from 2002 to 2014; Frequency 2025). from 2016 to present. biennially from 2016 to present. Industry Reporting and Information Source Data System (IRIS); IRIS IRIS Licensee Event Reports (LERs) Industry-average PRA parameters, Yearly system unreliability, along Yearly component parameters, including component failure with yearly system-specific including component failure Output probabilities, failure rates, initiating component parameters (including probabilities, failure rates, and Parameters event frequencies, component or train component failure probabilities, component unavailability for each unavailability, and common-cause failure failure rates, and unavailability for individual year. (CCF) parameters. each individual year). 1998-Update Year for yearly 1998-Update Year for the 2010 and 1998-Update Year for yearly system unreliability and yearly 2015 updates component parameter estimates system-specific component Data Period parameter estimates Most recent 15-year period for the 2020 Most recent 10-year period for trending Most recent 10-year period for and 2025 updates analysis trending analysis 60 Component Performance Study Item SPAR Parameter Update System Study Update Update SPAR base models with industry- average PRA parameters are used to calculate average system unreliability as benchmark values. The Empirical Bayes (EB) method (see NUREG/CR-6823) is used to estimate SPAR models with change sets The constrained noninformative prior component failure probabilities and containing yearly system-specific distribution (CNID)—a compromise failure rates. If the EB method does not component parameters are used to Methodology between an informative prior and the yield a solution, the Jeffreys calculate yearly system JNID with wide bounds—is used to noninformative prior distribution unreliability for trending analysis. estimate yearly component parameters. (JNID) is applied to perform a Bayesian update of the component failure data. Informative priors (from the latest industry-average PRA parameter estimates) rather than CNID, are used to estimate yearly system- specific component parameters. Industry-average PRA parameters Industry-average PRA parameters are Industry-average PRA parameters from Industry- serve as inputs to SPAR base outputs of the SPAR Parameter Update the SPAR Parameter Update are Average PRA models, which are used to calculate and serve as inputs to the SPAR base included in the component reliability Parameters average system unreliability as models. trending results as benchmark values. benchmarks. N/A—Yearly component parameters Yearly system-specific component Yearly (i.e., yearly component failure Yearly component parameters are parameters serve as inputs to the Component probabilities, failure rates, and outputs of the Component Performance SPAR model change sets, which are Parameters unavailability) are not produced as part Study Update. used to calculate yearly system of the SPAR Parameter Update. unreliability for trending analysis. SPAR varying models—consisting of the SPAR base models and SPAR base models use industry-average N/A—SPAR models are not used in the associated change sets containing SPAR Models PRA parameters Component Performance Study. yearly system-specific component parameters—are used to evaluate trends in system unreliability. 61