ORNL/TM-2026/4648 Oak Ridge National Laboratory Ceramic Composite Experimental Testing Status Josina W. Geringer John Podhiny Jiyoung Son Melanie O’Connell Zane Wallen Logan Kearney June 2026 ORNL is managed by UT-Battelle LLC for the US Department of Energy DOCUMENT AVAILABILITY Online Access: US Department of Energy (DOE) reports produced after 1991 and a growing number of pre-1991 documents are available free via https://www.osti.gov. The public may also search the National Technical Information Service’s National Technical Reports Library (NTRL) for reports not available in digital format. DOE and DOE contractors should contact DOE’s Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI) for reports not currently available in digital format: US Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information PO Box 62 Oak Ridge, TN 37831-0062 Telephone: (865) 576-8401 Fax: (865) 576-5728 Email: reports@osti.gov Website: www.osti.gov This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof. ORNL/TM-2026/4648 Material Science and Technology Division CERAMIC COMPOSITE EXPERIMENTAL TESTING STATUS Josina W. Geringer John Podhiny Jiyoung Son Melanie O’Connell Zane Wallen Logan Kearney June 2026 Prepared by OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY Oak Ridge, TN 37831 managed by UT-BATTELLE LLC for the US DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725 CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................................................... iv ABBREVIATIONS ...................................................................................................................................... v ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................ vii 1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................ 1 2. MATERIALS ....................................................................................................................................... 2 2.1 MATERIALS RECEIVED ......................................................................................................... 2 2.2 SAMPLE MACHINING AND MARKING PROTOCOLS....................................................... 2 2.3 FIBERS ....................................................................................................................................... 4 3. TESTING AND CHARACTERISATION ........................................................................................... 4 3.1 PRE-IRRADIATION CHARACTERIZATION STATUS ........................................................ 4 3.1.1 Dimensional Inspections ................................................................................................ 4 3.1.2 Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) .......................................................................... 5 3.1.3 X-ray Computed Tomography (XCT) ........................................................................... 6 3.2 PRELIMINARY TEST METHOD AND FAILURE MODE ANALYSIS ................................ 6 3.2.1 Diametrical disc compression analysis .......................................................................... 7 3.2.2 Bending specimen analysis .......................................................................................... 12 3.3 FIBER TESTING...................................................................................................................... 14 4. IRRADIATION STATUS .................................................................................................................. 16 4.1 IRRADIATION VEHICLES AND PREPARATION .............................................................. 16 4.2 IRRADIATION STATUS AND SCHEDULE ......................................................................... 17 5. CONCLUSION................................................................................................................................... 17 6. REFERENCES ................................................................................................................................... 18 iii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2.1. Examples of specimen size and geometries............................................................................... 3 Figure 3.1. Densities of the inspected specimens. ....................................................................................... 5 Figure 3.2. Example SEM images collected for the CMC varieties. ........................................................... 5 Figure 3.3. Example XCT images collected for some of the CMC varieties. .............................................. 6 Figure 3.4. One-eighth symmetry FE model (a) and full model (b). ........................................................... 8 Figure 3.5. Comparison of displacement results for full model and one-eighth model. .............................. 8 Figure 3.6. Comparison of stress response in the one-eighth and full models; S33 is the material thru-thickness ................................................................................................................................... 9 Figure 3.7. Contours of axial stress for D = 12 mm with prescribed lower contour limit of 0 MPa to illustrate differences in tensile stress ......................................................................................... 10 Figure 3.8. Contours of horizontal stress for D = 12 mm with prescribed lower contour limit of 0 MPa to illustrate differences in tensile stress ................................................................................. 10 Figure 3.9. Post-test photos of D = 12 mm with the material thru-thickness direction oriented axially............................................................................................................................................. 11 Figure 3.10. Stress results for D = 12 mm and D = 6 mm with the thru-thickness material direction oriented axially ............................................................................................................... 12 Figure 3.11. Contours of in-plane stress from five selected bending simulations ..................................... 13 Figure 3.12. Contours of ILS stress from five selected bending simulations, entire specimen shown. ............................................................................................................................................ 13 Figure 3.13. Post-test photos of a symmetric (left) and asymmetric (right) 4-pt bend test........................ 14 Figure 3.14. The Fiber Testing Suite. ........................................................................................................ 15 Figure 4.1. CMC1 capsule design layout. .................................................................................................. 16 Figure 4.2. CMC1 design temperature profiles based on FT positions. .................................................... 16 Figure 4.3. Expanded views of HFIR mini or rabbit capsule examples or rabbit capsule examples. ........ 17 LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Selected fibers and specifications ................................................................................................... 4 Table 2. Orthotropic material properties ....................................................................................................... 7 Table 2. Commercial fiber properties at ½” gauge length (variance shown in brackets) ........................... 15 iv ABBREVIATIONS ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers ASTM ASTM International (formerly American Society for Testing and Materials) ATR Advanced Test Reactor CCA Composite Cylinders Assemblage CMC ceramic matrix composite dpa displacements per atom FE finite element FEA finite element analysis FT Flux Trap HFIR High Flux Isotope Reactor HTR high-temperature reactor INL Idaho National Laboratory LAMDA Low Activation Materials Development and Analysis LWR light water reactor ORNL Oak Ridge National Laboratory PAN polyacrylonitrile SEM Scanning Electron Microscopy TD thermal diffusivity XCT x-ray computed tomography v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported by the US Department of Energy’s (DOE’s) Advanced Reactor Technology Gas-Cooled Reactor program, for the completion of activity milestone M3AT-26OR0605142. Oak Ridge National Laboratory is managed by UT-Battelle LLC under contract no. DE-AC05-00OR22725 for DOE. The authors would like to thank Lianshan Lin, Ercan Cakmak and Adrian Schrell for their support with the mechanical verification tests, x-ray computed tomography (XCT) and capsule images. vi ABSTRACT Over recent years, ceramic matrix materials such as SiC–SiC and C–C have been gaining interest for use in fusion reactors, light water reactors (LWRs), and high-temperature reactors (HTRs). These materials are good candidates to operate in very high temperature and moderate to high radiation environments. The evaluation of composite materials, in general, is challenging because of variations in precursor materials, variations in the fabrication process across fabricators, and the wide range of potential fiber architectures, to name a few. However, the need to evaluate neutron-irradiated properties adds another layer of complexity, which includes cost, timeline, and specimen size limitations (often associated with irradiation testing). A qualification methodology for the use of ceramic composites is provided in the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section III-5-HHB. The methodology is supported by ASTM International (ASTM) guides, which provide a pathway to accomplish this effort. Part of the qualification strategy is for the designer to collect material property data on environmental conditions representative of its design envelope. These data include irradiation effects. This report presents an experimental study and test campaign developed to partially address this gap by providing initial mechanical and physical property data required for design. A variety of different materials using different manufacturing techniques are considered as part of this campaign. The test plan suggests performing a screening or partial irradiation study to assist the designer during the material selection process. The designer can then perform a more comprehensive qualification study if the material performance is promising. This work focuses on the status of the specimen preparations (machining of samples), the current test methods and failure analysis as well as the preparation of irradiation vehicles for the irradiation campaign. The irradiation will be performed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) and at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR). vii 1. INTRODUCTION Ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) are gaining interest for structural applications in high-temperature and radiation-intensive environments, including advanced fission and fusion energy systems. Their low density, high-temperature strength retention, corrosion resistance, and non-catastrophic failure behavior offer clear advantages over monolithic ceramics and many metallic alloys. However, the deployment of CMCs in nuclear environments is limited by an incomplete understanding of how irradiation alters constituent phases, fiber/matrix interfaces, and damage-tolerant toughening mechanisms over relevant dose and temperature ranges. Because these materials derive their performance from a hierarchical architecture—fibers, interphases, matrix, porosity, and processing-induced defects—radiation-induced changes at any length scale can propagate to macroscopic property degradation, making targeted experimental studies essential. Neutron and ion irradiation can introduce point defects, defect clusters, and transmutation products that drive swelling, creep, hardening, amorphization, and microcracking in ceramic phases. In fiber-reinforced systems, irradiation may also modify interphase chemistry and shear strength, altering crack deflection, fiber pullout, and frictional sliding—mechanisms that underpin the pseudo-ductile response of many CMCs. At elevated temperatures, the competition between defect production and recovery further complicates predictions: irradiation can accelerate diffusion and phase evolution while thermal annealing can partially heal damage, leading to non-monotonic dependencies on dose rate, temperature, and irradiation spectrum. Additionally, irradiation can change thermal transport and oxidation behavior, which are critical to component design and safety margins in nuclear service. An experimental study and test campaign are developed to partially address this gap and to support the nuclear industry and potential vendors by providing the initial mechanical and physical property data required for design. The intent for this study is to obtain ASME related CMC material properties to support designers with relevant data collection and also providing industry with supportive irradiation data for down selection. In order to do this, testing techniques that accommodate small specimens and meet ASTM standards (as far possible) are prioritized. However, where this is not possible, new testing techniques are also being assessed and included. For these cases finite element analysis (FEA) has been performed and testing is evaluated accordingly. This includes the asymmetric four-point bend test that is perhaps a more consistent interlaminar shear failure test method compared to the current double notch shear test prescribed in ASTM C1292 [1]. Lastly mentioned introduced large scatter due to machining inconsistencies. Another method that is being assessed includes a nonstandard diametrical compression testing for composites [2]. More on these failure modes are discussed in the pre-irradiation characterization section of this report. A fibers investigation is also included as part of the irradiation study. The goal is to understand the microstructural evolution in carbon fibers with different textures and defect densities in response to irradiation. Objectives for this report include a status update on the machining of samples of the received materials, ongoing testing of the pristine non-irradiated samples, and the current status to encapsulate specimens to start the first irradiation. 1 2. MATERIALS 2.1 MATERIALS RECEIVED Several material vendors were willing to participate in the irradiation program and provided a variety of their materials to support systematic study. Others provided materials of interest tailored for the high temperature reactor market. Some materials emphasized high thermal conductivity with high density C-C with structure that behaves like a quasi-isotropic material. Varieties included pitch and polyacrylonitrile (PAN) unidirectional fiber types from SGL. Other materials from Mersen, included 2.5D carbon fiber composite, reinforced with multidirectional carbon cloth which is stitched to each other. Some were prepared to be used for higher strength and delamination resistance in higher temperature environments. Materials from Americarb, include different fiber tow sizes (3k vs 12k) utilizing a harness satin weave that are applied in either a 2- or 3- directional till weave pattern of 1x1 or 2x2 arrangement. C-CAT provided C-C with SiC coatings and joints materials, while GA supported the study with SiC-SiC variants (Hy-Nicaloy fiber) to establish a baseline. A random fiber C-C composite was also used for comparison purposes. In all cases the materials provided are to assess dimensional stability after neutron irradiation, but different characteristics will be evaluated. The materials are designed for different applications, as some emphasize high stiffness and/or strength while others are developed for increased thermal performance. The list is not complete as some suppliers and/or vendors indicated their interest in participating but requested additional time to prepare materials which will be provided during the latter part of the year. Currently eight to ten material variants are on hand, and another set (of similar size) is expected to be received over the next few months. In addition, eight representative fiber types are included in the study. As with the composites, some of the fibers have high tensile strength and some have high modulus. Single filament tows are prepared to be encapsulated in special designed 1” sub-holders the irradiation capsules. 2.2 SAMPLE MACHINING AND MARKING PROTOCOLS Machining carbon–carbon (C–C) and silicon carbide–silicon carbide (SiC–SiC) composites is challenging because both materials are heterogeneous, anisotropic, and prone to damage mechanisms that depend strongly on fiber architecture and interphase design. C–C is comparatively “softer” than SiC-based systems but is highly abrasive and porous, so conventional cutting often leads to fiber pullout, matrix tearing, edge fraying, and subsurface delamination; dust generation is significant and typically requires aggressive extraction and appropriate controls. In contrast, SiC–SiC is extremely hard and brittle, making it difficult to machine without introducing microcracks or degrading interfacial regions that govern toughness; as a result, diamond tooling, grinding, ultrasonic machining, abrasive waterjet cutting, laser-assisted approaches, and electrical discharge machining (only when a conductive phase is present) are commonly used to limit cutting forces and heat-affected damage. For both material classes, best practice emphasizes minimizing mechanical and thermal loads, selecting tooling and parameters based on layup direction, and verifying surface/subsurface integrity via metrology and non-destructive evaluation, since machining-induced defects can dominate strength, leak-tightness, and fatigue performance in service. 2 Defects introduced due to cutting methods can contribute to delamination during irradiation and therefore it is necessary to pay attention to methods applied. For first irradiation screening efforts, three primary specimen geometries are selected and used to limit used capsule volume to maximize the usage of each irradiation capsule. As shown in Figure 2.1 specimen geometries are limited to bend bars, square and disc types. The thickness is material depended based on architecture, but varies between ~1.5 – 2.5 mm for the bend bars and square specimens, while disc thickness is anything between 2 – 5.5 mm. Figure 2.1. Examples of specimen size and geometries. (From left to right are the bend bar, square and cylindrical disc specimens) Specific cut plans were prepared for each of the materials. For the bend bars, the selected screening orientation was to align the length of the specimens along the primary fiber direction. The thickness was aligned with the laminate through thickness direction for both the bend bar and square specimens. The disc specimens were also cut so that the laminate through thickness directions is aligned with the thickness of the disc specimen. All the C-C specimens prepared by ORNL were done with the use of a precise diamond wire saw (Diamond WireTec DWS.100) to avoid any impurities that could result in entrapment of materials with high radiological activiation, and they were engraved with a unique ID for pre- and post-irradiation evaluation. All specimens were clean and dimensionally inspected according to LAMDA’s standard operating guideline (SOG), MST-LAMDA-SOG-009, Dimensional Inspection and Bulk Density Guideline for Bars, Rods, and Disks. The SOG is based on ASTM C559 [3], dimensional inspection of carbon materials. 3 2.3 FIBERS The down selected fibers to be included in this study are shown in Table 1. Various commercial fibers with mechanical properties and tow sizes as well as ORNL produced fibers were selected for comparison purposes. Single filament tows were cut to perform various sizes for size effect testing. For the irradiation study, 1” fibers were prepared to perform ½” gauge testing post irradiation. Table 1. Selected fibers and specifications Sample # Fiber Type Spec Tow Size 1 IM7 700 ksi 12k 2 T700 700 ksi 12k 3 T300 300 ksi 24k 4 T1000 1 Msi 3k 5 HM54 54 Msi 6k 6 P55* 55 Msi 6k 7 P90* 90 Msi 6k 8 ORNL-C1 300 ksi 0.5-2k 3. TESTING AND CHARACTERISATION Small-specimen mechanical testing provides a practical pathway to quantify strength-related properties when material availability is limited, geometry is constrained (e.g., irradiated coupons), or conventional full-size specimens are impractical. In this approach, miniature tensile, flexural, shear, or fracture specimens are designed to preserve representative stress states while enabling higher throughput and reduced material volume, and results are interpreted—where applicable—within established ASTM frameworks (or closely aligned practices) to ensure traceability and comparability. Relevant standards may include ASTM methods for tensile and flexural testing of composites and ceramics, as well as specimen preparation and dimensional tolerancing guidance, with careful attention to size effects, gripping/loading alignment, and surface finish requirements that can disproportionately influence failure in small geometries. When direct compliance with a standard is not possible due to specimen scale, a standards-informed protocol combined with validation against larger-specimen data and appropriate statistical treatment (e.g., Weibull analysis for brittle failure) can still yield defensible estimates of mechanical strength and enable meaningful comparisons across processing conditions, environments, and irradiation states. 3.1 PRE-IRRADIATION CHARACTERIZATION STATUS 3.1.1 Dimensional Inspections After machining, all finished specimens were dimensionally inspected using a combination of a micrometer, a jaw gage and a mass balance according to LAMDA’s SOG, MST-LAMDA-SOG-009. Results from a preliminary subset of samples that have been inventoried and inspected are shown in Figure 3.1 below. ABH01, AW252 and A035 are heat treated and variants from Mersen, while the H- and the T-series are sponsored variants. 4 Figure 3.1. Densities of the inspected specimens. 3.1.2 Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) All the electron microscopy was performed with the TESCAN MIRA3 and the Zeiss Merlin FE-SEM. Samples were imaged with a 10 kV electron beam at various field of view and working distance settings. Scale bars were preserved for image analysis, which was performed with ImageJ for fiber dimension [4]. An example of an Americarb CC13-HC2 composite, is provided in Figure 3.2. Features and fiber sizes of specific specimens from the various CMCs are characterized to establish a basis condition for post- irradiation comparison. Pre-irradiation characterization is in progress and prioritized for the materials that will be included in the next capsules. Figure 3.2. Example SEM images collected for the CMC varieties. (Left shows the specimen face and right shows a higher resolution of a fiber region.) 5 3.1.3 X-ray Computed Tomography (XCT) The XCT measurements were performed using a Zeiss Xradia Versa 520 instrument operated at 40 kV, 3W and at 60 kV, 5 W. To maximize the field of view (FOV), a 0.4× scintillator objective was used in front of the CCD camera. To cover entire sample volumes, stitch scans were employed wherein several overlapping sections of the samples were scanned and stitched together after reconstruction. For all the scans, a 1 × 1 binning was used on the detector to improve resolution, resulting in a voxel size of 15.6 µm for this setup. Data reconstruction was automated using Zeiss software. Dragonfly PRO v.2025.1 was used for data visualization and quantification. For segmentation of the pores, solid and exterior sections, deep-learning-aided segmentation was used. The deep-learning model was trained by the user to recognize regions of interest. The model employed a 2.5D U-Net architecture for its training with a patch size of 64 and a stride ratio of 0.25 (overlap between the patches) limited to a maximum of 100 epochs (iterations). Each training employed several frames with sufficient features to provide input to the model. Automated data augmentation was also employed to create additional training data. Select square specimens were used to collect pre- irradiation for baseline XCT analysis. Preliminary example images are shown in Figure 3.3. Figure 3.3. Example XCT images collected for some of the CMC varieties. 3.2 PRELIMINARY TEST METHOD AND FAILURE MODE ANALYSIS As mentioned earlier, due to size limitations it is not possible to perform irradiation on standard size specimens. However, due to code and designer requirements, it is still prudent to understand the material properties, especially strength and modulus behavior. To accommodate smaller specimens, non-standard test methods are also being evaluated. FEA were performed for two general classes of test specimens namely disc compression and bending. These analyses were performed to assess the most likely stress failure mode. For bending analyses, three types of loading were considered: symmetric three-point, symmetric four-point (in one-third and one-quarter span distances), and asymmetric four-point (in two pin distance configurations). Analyses were performed using orthotropic material properties for the vast majority of cases, with isotropic properties used in several cases for comparison purposes. For the first order analysis an estimated [0/90] 2D C/C orthotropic material properties were calculated using the Composite Cylinders Assemblage (CCA) micromechanics approach (to obtain the orthotropic 6 properties of a unidirectional fiber plus matrix bundle) together with an iso-strain assumption to weight the bundles equally in the 0° and 90° directions. The micromechanics calculations assumed a fiber volume fraction of 50%, a matrix modulus of 6.9 GPa, and adjusted the fiber modulus to obtain an in-plane composite modulus of 75 GPa, which is the value of flexural modulus for SGL Sigrabond Premium [5] for this material. The resulting properties are shown in Table 2. In this table, 1 and 2 denote the 0° and 90° directions, respectively; 3 denotes the thru-thickness direction. In FEA cases with lower stiffness orthotropic properties (denoted Rev1 and Rev2 in the table), E11 was arbitrarily reduced and all other moduli were reduced by the same percentage. In cases with isotropic properties, a modulus of 30 GPa and a Poisson’s ratio of 0.20 were assumed, as a bounding approximation for the initial cases. Table 2. Orthotropic material properties Variant E E E Nu Nu Nu G G G 11 22 33 12 13 23 12 13 23 [--] [GPa] [GPa] [GPa] [--] [--] [--] [GPa] [GPa] [GPa] Baseline 74.28 74.28 7.35 0.018 0.237 0.237 7.27 5.03 5.03 Rev1 30.00 30.00 2.97 0.018 0.237 0.237 2.94 2.03 2.03 Rev2 10.00 10.00 0.99 0.018 0.237 0.237 0.98 0.68 0.68 3.2.1 Diametrical disc compression analysis Analyses of disc compression specimens were performed to assess the likelihood of the specimen failing in interlaminar normal stress and thereby providing an interlaminar tensile strength. A total of eight different configurations were analyzed, by considering all combinations of two diameters (6 mm and 12 mm) and the four sets of material properties cited previously (three sets of orthotropic properties and one set of isotropic properties). For computational efficiency, a one-eighth symmetry finite element (FE) model was used, as described in Figure 3.4(a). In this approach, half of each dimension of the specimen is modeled and, appropriate translational boundary conditions are placed on the symmetry faces (i.e., the X = 0, Y = 0, and Z = 0 faces). The specimen is compressed by applying a downward displacement to the separate rigid plate that is placed in initial tangential contact with the top surface of the specimen; the plate interacts with the specimen only by contact. Results of the one-eighth model were verified by solving one full-model case, illustrated in Figure 3.4(b), where the entire specimen was modeled and an additional rigid plate was placed at the bottom of the specimen to react to the compressive load. 7 Figure 3.4. One-eighth symmetry FE model (a) and full model (b). Comparisons of horizontal and vertical displacement response on the outer face of the specimen for these two models are shown in Figure 3.5. Both cases use the baseline orthotropic material properties, with the material thru-thickness direction oriented in the global X-direction. Results are nearly identical for the two cases. Note that in the full model, vertical displacement ranges from approximately -0.24 mm to -0.12 mm due to the compression of the bottom half of the specimen, whereas vertical displacement in the one- eighth model ranges from -0.12 mm to 0 mm because the Y = 0 centerline has a UY = 0 boundary condition applied and the bottom half of the specimen is not explicitly modeled. Figure 3.5. Comparison of displacement results for full model and one-eighth model. 8 Figure 3.6. Comparison of stress response in the one-eighth and full models; S33 is the material thru-thickness Excellent agreement is observed for stress response in the two models, as illustrated in Figure 3.6 where only the upper one-eighth region of the full model is shown. Specifically, note that there are only marginal differences in peak axial stress in the two models, which occur at or very close to the contact region with the rigid load plate (the full model shows 24.1 MPa, while the one-eighth model shows 20.7 MPa). Similarly, only marginal differences are observed in the peak horizontal stress (less than 1%) and distributions in the two models. The compressive forces in the full model and one-eighth model are 21,194 N and 5,313 N, respectively. The full model therefore requires 4 times the force of the one-eighth model due to symmetry, as expected, with a factor of 2 resulting from the X = 0 plane and the Z = 0 plane. (Note that the horizontal symmetry plane, Y = 0, does not contribute a factor of 2 because it is perpendicular to the loading direction). Based on the overall results between the two models, the rest of the analysis was performed applying the eighth-symmetrical model. As the disc specimen geometries were partly selected due to material and irradiation capsule considerations, it was necessary to perform some initial tests and FEA analysis to verify the failure mode. Analysis on the 6mm (D = 6mm) and the 12mm diameter (D = 6mm) specimens were performed in the axial or in-plane material stress (where the stress component in the FEA model is denoted as S11) as well as in the horizontal or thru-thickness material stress (denoted as S33 in the FEA output). Both cases were evaluated to verify the failure mode. Based on information provided by Walrath and Adams [6] it is expected that the ratio of thru-thickness strength to in-plane strength to be significantly less than 1. It is therefore anticipated that the failure will occur due to thru-thickness stress. Although isotropic materials are not expected for this study, it was included as part of the analysis for comparison purposes. The failure is determined by evaluating which failure has the highest peak condition. Analysis contour plots where the lower contour limit was set to 0 MPa (to highlight the contour differences) for the D = 12mm specimen is shown for the axial stress in Figure 3.7 and the horizontal stress in Figure 3.8. 9 Figure 3.7. Contours of axial stress for D = 12 mm with prescribed lower contour limit of 0 MPa to illustrate differences in tensile stress The general behaviors and trends observed in the these cases are the same as the results for the D = 6 mm cases, with the one notable difference being the stress ratios, which have values of ~3 and ~4.5 for D = 12mm cases, versus the values of ~5 and ~6.3 for the D = 6 mm cases. Suggesting the results make the D = 6 mm design case preferable, but for the materials of interest and their strength ratios, the slightly higher stress ratio for the D = 6 mm design would not be expected to have an observable effect; both designs would be expected to fail due to horizontal stress. Figure 3.8. Contours of horizontal stress for D = 12 mm with prescribed lower contour limit of 0 MPa to illustrate differences in tensile stress 10 Special fixtures were fabricated to perform preliminary diametrical compression tests for both the D = 6mm and the D = 12mm specimens. In both cases the specimens are 5.5mm thick. The model verification tests were performed on the D = 12mm specimens as only limited number of D = 6mm specimens are available and will be used for irradiation. Figure 3.9 shows two 12mm diameter specimens where the thru-thickness direction of the specimens was oriented axially, but the one condition was oriented in a 0º-ply direction and the other in a 90º-ply direction. Newton et. al. [2] applied compression in the lateral direction of the fibers between the two platens, suggesting the thru thickness to be in the horizontal direction when compared to the models which is different from the specimens observed in the tests. Even though the material orientation is different from Newton et. al., the tested specimens were observed to fail due to horizontal stress in testing. Figure 3.9. Post-test photos of D = 12 mm with the material thru-thickness direction oriented axially. (i.e. into the page) As a basic verification of the FEA, the D = 12 mm case was simulated based on actual material properties and component stresses were extracted. For completeness, the D = 6 mm case was also simulated. Brief FEA results for these cases are shown in Figure 3.10. In these results, we see that for the D = 12 mm case, the peak stress is ~164 MPa in the material in-plane direction and ~6 Mpa in the material thru-thickness direction. This results in a stress ratio (in-plane to thru-thickness) of ~27, which is greater than the corresponding strength ratio for any of the materials being considered, implying that failure would be expected in the in-plane material direction (i.e., horizontal stress or S11 as denoted in the FEA output), consistent with the test results shown in Figure 3.9. The stress ratio is marginally lower for the D = 6 mm case, at ~25 (~306 Mpa and ~12 Mpa), but even at the slightly lower value, this specimen, if tested, would also be expected to fail due to stress in the in-plane material direction (i.e., horizontal stress or S11 as denoted in the FEA output). 11 Figure 3.10. Stress results for D = 12 mm and D = 6 mm with the thru-thickness material direction oriented axially Another key finding was that the FEA orienting the material in the non-typical manner (i.e., with the thru- thickness material direction in the axial direction of the specimen) was performed and indicated thru- thickness material failure was unlikely and that failure would occur due to in-plane stress. These findings are consistent with initial disc test results. With the established confidence in the failure mode, the next step will be to verify that the material properties agree to the conditions provided in the model and then to start the test campaign for the respective materials on both the D = 12mm and D = 6mm specimens. 3.2.2 Bending specimen analysis Various failure modes are evaluated for the bend bar specimens to capitalize on the suggested specimen geometry that fits inside the irradiation capsule. The selected bend bar geometry (24mm in length and 6mm in width), varies in thickness (between 1.5 to 3mm) due to the manufactured material design. These specimens are typically used for flexure bend testing either applying a 3pt or a 4pt tests. However, prior analysis has shown that by changing the load pin arrangement, an interlaminar shear (ILS) test (more valuable for design assessment) can also be applied instead of using the double notch shear specimen which has critical flaws related to the notch size and geometry that can lead to significant scatter in the test data and inconsistent strength values, compromising the accuracy of the results. A total of 20 bending test configurations were simulated with FEA using the properties listed in Table 2. The general approach used was to gather peak bending stress (i.e., in-plane material direction stress) and peak interlaminar shear (ILS) stress from each case, calculate the stress ratio, and compare this with estimated material strengths to predict the anticipated failure mode. Example stress results from five of the 20 analyzed cases are shown in Figure 3.11 and Figure 3.12, Figure 3.11 shows in-plane stress and Figure 3.12 shows ILS stress in the entire specimen. The load pin arrangements for the 3-pt and various 4-pt bend tests are also shown. The 3-pt bend test uses the standard load pin arrangement, but for the symmetrical 4-pt bend tests, both the third and quarter distribution 12 methods are investigated. For the asymmetrical 4-pt bend test, the span between the upper two load pins or the lower two load pins were 7.33mm and 9mm respectively. Figure 3.11. Contours of in-plane stress from five selected bending simulations As with the diametrical compression analysis, the peak values from the in-plane stress (Figure 3.11) and the ILS stress (Figure 3.12) were compared to confirm respective failure modes. Figure 3.12. Contours of ILS stress from five selected bending simulations, entire specimen shown. 13 For the typical [0/90] 2D C/C orthotropic material, almost all cases fail in ILS during an asymmetrical 4- pt bend test, while 2.5 or 3D materials tend to fail because of in-plane failure or flexure stress. Initial tests to verify the models have been performed. Examples of these post-test specimens are visible in Figure 3.13 which shows a [0/90] 2D C/C orthotropic material failure for the 4pt bending and 4pt asymmetric bending tests. Figure 3.13. Post-test photos of a symmetric (left) and asymmetric (right) 4-pt bend test. Additional testing and model verification are required for some of the materials, but in principle the specimens are more often failing though ILS instead of flexure testing. Although the asymmetric 4pt bend specimen is not currently according to an ASTM standard, it may be considered to have that included as part of the suite of ASTM test for composites. 3.3 FIBER TESTING Fiber tensile testing of individual filaments was conducted using ASTM D3379-75 [7], the standard test method for tensile properties and young’s modulus for high modulus single filament materials. Under this standard, a single filament is carefully mounted and subjected to tensile testing to measure its tensile strength and elongation. Testing is performed using a precision tensile testing machine, where the filament is gripped and pulled until it breaks, recording the applied force and elongation during the process. In ambient conditions, tests are conducted at room temperature to determine the filament’s performance under normal environmental settings. High temperature testing, on the other hand, involves subjecting the filament to elevated temperatures using specialized heating chambers or furnaces to assess its tensile properties at elevated thermal conditions. This dual approach allows for comprehensive evaluation of the filament’s mechanical behavior both ambient and high temperature environments, ensuring reliable data for material performance analysis. The standard filament gauge length is at least 1”, but due to irradiation and space limitations, fiber filaments as small as ½” gauge length were tested to perform a size effect study comparison. Generally, carbon and carbon fiber have a low coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) along the fiber axis (between - 0.6 and – 0.38 α.10-6 / ºC [8]), but some dimensional change associated with the fiber diameter can be due to uninhibited expansion of the resin. Smaller gauge lengths up to ¼” and at irradiation temperature are performed for unirradiated condition evaluation. ASTM standards for tow level testing are best represented by 1” single fiber properties in some systems. Testing at multiple lengths allows us to build an understanding of mechanical failure modes and accurately compare with properties tested in rad controlled areas. Baseline size effect testing was 14 performed with a Textechno ROBOT 2 paired with the FAVIMAT single fiber tester, as shown in Figure 3.14(a). The Textechno ROBOT 2 is an advanced automated robotic sample handling test system which is excellent for multiple single filaments testing. It is however limited in that the equipment is not available in the Low Activation Materials Development and Analysis (LAMDA) laboratory. Therefore, special fixtures and instruments are used to validate the test method using the MTS Alliance RT-5 mechanical test frame with a custom fiber fixture prepared by ORNL, as shown in Figure 1(b). Five of the eight fiber types were completed at ½” gauge lengths and the tested properties are summarized in Table 3. Table 3. Commercial fiber properties at ½” gauge length (variance shown in brackets) Fiber Type Tow Size Diameter Break Stress Modulus Strain (%) (µm) (KSI) (MSI) Toray T300 6k 6.30 (0.34) 553.37 (122.93) 34.62 (2.87) 1.55 (0.30) Toray T1000 12k 5.23 (0.37) 951.65 (269.82) 41.02 (4.66) 2.20 (0.55) Hexcel IM7 12k 4.87 (0.31) 895.62 (229.05) 39.09 (3.45) 2.19 (0.45) P25 2k 9.49 (0.62) 269.64 (50.84) 21.87 (2.05) 1.21 (0.20) P55 2k 8.92 (0.73) 451.13 (86.65) 61.78 (10.65) 0.76 (0.09) Figure 3.14. The Fiber Testing Suite. (a) Textechno ROBOT 2 with the FAVIMAT+, and (b) the MTS Alliance RT-5, highlighting the fiber fixtures. 15 4. IRRADIATION STATUS 4.1 IRRADIATION VEHICLES AND PREPARATION For the first irradiation, focus is on the plate materials less than 2.5mm thick. From these small square specimens and bend bar specimens are prepared, which are prioritized for the first capsules. Other capsule designs housing cylindrical disc type specimens (CMC2) and mini holders containing fiber whiskers (CMC3), are also being prepared with second priority. The chosen irradiation vehicle concept, referred to as CMC1, housed two large CMC bend bars and eight small CMC square specimens with several SiC thermometers. An alternative to this design is to house up to 16 small CMC square specimens with several SiC thermometers. A capsule layout of the prioritized is provided in Figure 4.1. Details of the irradiation capsule design are described elsewhere [9]. Figure 4.1. CMC1 capsule design layout. Capsules were designed to achieve 800˚C and 1100˚C and for a target dose of 2 or 6 HFIR cycles which depending on Flux Trap (FT) position, are roughly equivalent to ~3 dpa or ~10 dpa respectively and. The capsules are designed with different He/Ar fill gas ratios to achieve the target temperature. The expected design temperatures are shown in Figure 4.2. Figure 4.2. CMC1 design temperature profiles based on FT positions. 16 The other capsule designs, shown in Figure 5.3, includes expanded layouts for the cylindrical disc and fiber whisker with mini fiber holder. Temperature analysis and parts procurement are in process. Figure 4.3. Expanded views of HFIR mini or rabbit capsule examples or rabbit capsule examples. (a) cylindrical sample geometries and (b) mini holders containing fiber whiskers. 4.2 IRRADIATION STATUS AND SCHEDULE The first capsules are in process of preparation. Parts have been procured and inspected. Next steps are assembly. Depending on HFIR FT availability, it is aimed to begin its first irradiation during HFIR cycle 517 during September 2026. More capsules will be introduced during HFIR cycles, 518 through 521. HFIR cycled 521 is currently scheduled to start March 2027. This will include a variety of capsule layouts CMC1 through CMC3. Additional irradiation will be performed in the Advanced Test Reactor at Idaho National Laboratory. 5. CONCLUSION This report presents the status of an irradiation experiment work package to support CMC qualification studies. Output from this study will hugely benefit HTR designers and vendors in their demonstrated interest in C–C and SiC–SiC composites for use in core components. The test strategy suggests performing a screening study to supply CMC designers with initial and useful information to support materials decision-making when considering irradiation effects. The proposal follows the materials qualification intent of ASME III-5 for a variety of materials manufactured using different fabrication techniques. The end goal will be to evaluate the material’s postirradiation condition. but currently pre-irradiation examinations are performed on all the specimens that are slated for irradiation, while test methods are being evaluated for the pre-and post- irradiation campaign. Irradiations will be performed in HFIR (at ORNL) and in ATR (at INL). The irradiation capsules are making progress with the first capsule expected to start HFIR irradiation for cycle 517. Baseline or pre-irradiation testing will be performed during the irradiation periods. 17 6. REFERENCES [1] ASTM International. ASTM C1292-22, "Standard Test Method for Shear Strength of Continuous Fiber-Reinforced Advanced Ceramics at Ambient Temperatures," ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2022.DOI: 10.1520/C1292-22 [2] C.D. Newton, S.P. Jeffs, L. Gale, S. Pattison, M.R. Bache, Determining the interlaminar tensile strength of a SiCf/SiC ceramic matrix composite through diametrical compression testing, Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 43(7), 2023, pp 2951-2957, ISSN 0955-2219, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeurceramsoc.2022.11.014. [3] ASTM International. ASTM C559-16, 2016, "Standard Test Method for Bulk Density by Physical Measurements of Manufactured Carbon and Graphite Articles", ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, DOI: 10.1520/C0559-16, http://www.astm.org. [4] Schneider, C. A., Rasband, W. S., & Eliceiri, K. W. (2012). NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nature Methods, 9(7), 671–675. https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth.2089 [5] SGL Carbon (SIGRABOND Premium technical data): SIGRABOND® Premium Carbon Fiber- reinforced carbon (C/C) for High-Temperature Application. https://www.sglcarbon.com/pdf/SGL- Datasheet-SIGRABOND-Premium-EN (SGL Carbon (SGL SIGRABOND Premium technical data) [6] D.E. Walrath and Donald F. Adams, "Finite Element Micromechanics and Minimechanics Modeling of a Three-Dimensional Carbon-Carbon Composite Material", ONR Contract No. N00014-77-C- 0503, December 1985. [7] ASTM International. ASTM D3379-75: Standard Test Method for Tensile Strength and Young’s Modulus for High-Modulus Single-Filament Materials. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA. http://www.astm.org. [8] Toray (carbon fiber technical data): CTE values for carbon fibers are very small (often near zero or negative in the fiber direction). https://www.toraycma.com/resources/data-sheets/ (Toray carbon fiber properties/technical information) [9] Zane Wallen et al. “Design and Thermal Analysis of Ceramic Matrix Composite Specimen Bearing Capsules in HFIR”, ORNL/SPR-2025/4094. 18