FINAL TECHNICAL REPORT SUBMITTED TO U.S. Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory DOE AWARD NUMBER: DE-FE0032261 Advanced Engineered Structures for High Performance Direct Air Capture System PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR Dr. Gökhan O. Alptekin Project Manager Phone: (303) 422-7819 Email: galptekin@tda.com RECIPIENT TDA Research, Inc. 4680 Table Mountain Drive, Suite 100B Golden, CO 80403-2346 PROJECT PERIOD: September 1, 2023 to August 31, 2025 SUBMISSION DATE: April 14, 2026 Advanced Engineered Structures for High Performance Direct Air Capture System Final Report Dr. Gökhan O. Alptekin Dr. Ambalavanan Jayaraman Dr. Bill Gerstler, GE Vernova TDA Research, Inc. 4680 Table Mountain Drive Suite 100B, Golden, CO 80403-2346 (303) 422-7819 Acknowledgment language: This material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy under the Contract DE-FE0032261. Disclaimer: This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference therein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions or authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States government or any agency thereof. 2 Abstract This project, conducted by TDA Research, Inc. in collaboration with GE Research under DOE Award DE-FE0032261, developed and demonstrated advanced structured sorbent-coated contactors for the high-performance Direct Air Capture (DAC) of CO₂. The work focused on integrating TDA’s thermally stable amine-functionalized sorbent with commercially available tube-in-plate heat exchanger structures to achieve a low pressure drop, high heat-transfer rates, and rapid thermal swing adsorption (TSA) cycling. Across two budget periods, the team optimized the sorbent formulations, coating processes, and fin geometries; evaluated coupon-, sub-bench- , and bench-scale contactors; and successfully demonstrated long-term durability, reproducible performance, and scalable fabrication. Sub-bench-scale modules achieved sorbent productivities exceeding 10 g CO₂/kg-sorbent-hr, air-side pressure drops below 2.5 kPa, and stable operation over more than 5,000 cycles with <5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles. Bench-scale slit-fin contactors met targets of 10–50 g CO₂/hr capture and >0.2 kg CO₂/m³-hr productivity, though performance degradation after ~300 cycles was attributed to steam condensation effects. Based on experimentally validated thermal-hydraulic models, a full-scale DAC contactor module was designed to carry out the removal of 100,000 MT CO₂/year from ambient air. The techno-economic analysis (TEA) and life-cycle assessment (LCA) indicated strong potential for cost-effective DAC deployment. The base-case cost of capture is approximately $251/tonne CO₂ (2019$) excluding transport and storage; under optimized conditions, the cost decreases to $153/tonne CO₂, with projected energy-related emissions as low as 0.034 kg CO₂ per kg captured when powered by low-carbon electricity. This work advanced the technology from TRL 3 to TRL 4 and demonstrates a viable pathway toward scalable, low-cost DAC using structured sorbent-coated heat-exchange contactors. 3 Table of Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................ 4 List of Tables .................................................................................................................................. 5 List of Figures ................................................................................................................................. 6 1. Executive Summary ............................................................................................................. 7 2. Introduction.......................................................................................................................... 10 3. Project Objectives ................................................................................................................. 13 3.1 Work Plan ................................................................................................................. 13 4. Accomplishments.................................................................................................................. 14 5. Results and Discussion ......................................................................................................... 16 5.1 Task 1. Project Management Planning ..................................................................... 16 5.2 Task 5. Initial Techno-economic Analysis and Life Cycle Analysis ........................ 18 5.3 Task 6. Extended Cycling Tests (BP2) ...................................................................... 19 5.3.1 Task 6.1 Sub-bench Scale Testing at TDA (BP2) ................................................ 19 5.4 Task 8. Life Cycle Analysis ...................................................................................... 23 5.5 Task 9. Final Techno-economic Assessment ............................................................ 24 6. References Cited ................................................................................................................... 26 4 List of Tables Table 1. Overall Cost of CO2 Capture. .......................................................................................... 8 Table 2. Comparison of Tube-in-Plate Contactor with Additive and Plate and Frame Designs. 12 Table 3. Comparison of Plain Straight Tube-in-Plate Contactor with Enhanced Heat Transfer Fins. ............................................................................................................................................ 12 Table 4. Project milestone log with completed milestones as of the Final Report Submission Date. ........................................................................................................................................... 16 Table 5. Overall Cost of CO2 Capture. ........................................................................................ 24 Table 6. Ideal parameter value for an optimized and mature DAC system................................. 25 5 List of Figures Figure 1. Sub-bench module installed for testing at TDA. ............................................................ 7 Figure 2. CO2 Capacity vs cycle count for sub-bench scale contactor extended cycling tests at TDA. .............................................................................................................................................. 7 Figure 3. Coated Bench Scale GE Contactors. ............................................................................ 7 Figure 4 CO2 capture rate as a function of cycle number for selected dynamic cycles (22 min adsorption, 12 desorption, and 10 min for steam purge and cooling) for films formulated from TDA-SSSA and GE647 sorbents .................................................................................................. 8 Figure 5. Specific energy of CO2 capture as a function of concentration. Pressure drop is fixed at 200 mbar. Note: power consumption is provided on a log scale. .......................................... 10 Figure 6. Effect of pressure drop through the gas-solid contactor on the power consumption for DAC systems. ............................................................................................................................. 11 Figure 7. Sorbent coated on plates of tube-in-plate heat exchanger. ......................................... 11 Figure 8. Heat transfer enhanced fins – (left) wavy fin; (middle) off-set fin and (right) grooved fin. .................................................................................................................................................... 11 Figure 9. GWP results for the Proposed Product System (Solar-powered DAC) and Comparison Product System (Grid-powered DAC) based on the functional unit of the study (1 kg CO2 separated). .................................................................................................................................. 18 Figure 10. Sub-bench modules (left) and bench-scale test apparatus (right). ............................ 19 Figure 11. Sub-bench modules test design (left) and apparatus (right). ..................................... 20 Figure 12. CO2 Capacity vs cycle count...................................................................................... 20 Figure 13. 10-minute adsorption curves at varied feed air flow rates. ........................................ 21 Figure 14. Trend plot of the effect of adsorption time on CO2 capacity. ..................................... 21 Figure 15. Trend plot of the effect of relative humidity on CO2 capacity for 5/5 minute, adsorb/regen. .............................................................................................................................. 22 Figure 16. Trend plot of the effect of air flowrate on sorbent working capacity and capture efficiency for 10/10 minute adsorb/regen cycles. ........................................................................ 22 6 1. Executive Summary This project, conducted by TDA Research, Inc. in collaboration with GE Research under DOE Award DE-FE0032261, focused on the development of an advanced, structured contactor system for the direct air capture (DAC) of CO₂ from ambient air. The work brought together TDA’s thermally stable amine-functionalized sorbent and GE’s commercially scalable tube-in-plate heat-exchange structures, with the goal of demonstrating a low-pressure-drop, high-heat-transfer system that could support rapid thermal-swing adsorption cycles. Over the course of two budget periods, the team refined sorbent formulations, optimized coating methods, and evaluated a variety of fin geometries, progressing from coupon-level testing to sub-bench-scale modules and ultimately to a multi-contactor bench-scale system. Figure 1. Sub-bench To begin the effort, the team formulated sorbent slurries that could module installed for be coated onto the thin aluminum fins of heat exchangers. After testing at TDA. examining multiple binder systems, an organic PVB-based formulation was selected for its superior adhesion and film uniformity. These coatings were successfully applied to several fin geometries—including flat, wavy, offset, and slit fin designs— which were then evaluated for material stability, sorbent capacity, and mass-transfer performance. The coated structures were first assessed at the sub-bench scale, where individual contactors (Figure 1) were stacked into small modules and exposed to Figure 2. CO2 Capacity vs cycle count for sub-bench scale contactor DAC-relevant extended cycling tests at TDA. conditions. The sub-bench units demonstrated exceptionally low pressure drops (well below the 2.5 kPa target) and delivered sorbent productivities significantly exceeding the project milestones. These modules also showed strong durability, completing more than 5,000 cycles with less than 5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles (Figure 2). Based on the thermal-hydraulic analysis, the slit-fin design emerged as the most promising option, providing high heat-transfer rates with manageable pressure drop penalties. This geometry was selected for the bench-scale system, where multiple contactors were assembled into a single module designed to fit within GE’s 1-kg/day DAC test rig (Figure 3). Bench-scale tests demonstrated CO₂ removal rates in the range of 10–50 g/hr and volumetric productivities exceeding 0.2 kg CO₂ per cubic meter of contactor volume per hour—meeting all Figure 3. Coated Bench of the project’s performance targets (Figure 4). While extended Scale GE Contactors. 7 cycling revealed performance degradation after approximately 300 cycles, this decline was traced not to sorbent deterioration but to the condensation of steam within the system, an artifact of the regeneration mode used during testing. TDA-SSA TDA-SSA VER647 VER647 Figure 4 CO2 capture rate as a function of cycle number for selected dynamic cycles (22 min adsorption, 12 desorption, and 10 min for steam purge and cooling) for films formulated from TDA-SSSA and GE647 sorbents Throughout the project, the team performed extensive cycling evaluations, breakthrough analyses, and hydrodynamic characterizations. Sub-bench-scale lifetime tests exceeded 6,500 cycles, with sorbent capacities remaining stable after early corrections to a tubing leak that temporarily affected heating uniformity. The capacity fade across 5,000 cycles was roughly 2.2% per 1,000 cycles, significantly better than the required threshold. Bench-scale cycling produced detailed data characterizing the behavior of both TDA’s tethered-amine sorbent and GE’s proprietary sorbent under dynamic operating conditions. In parallel with this experimental work, the Table 1. Overall Cost of CO2 Capture. project team completed a full COC DACnet 2019 $/ techno-economic analysis. The TEA tonne showed that, using realistic system assumptions and performance data from Component Predicted Optimized the coated heat-exchanger contactors, the Cost Cost cost of CO₂ capture was approximately Capital $116 $68 $251 per tonne of CO₂ (2019 USD), Fixed $54 $48 excluding transport and storage. Sensitivity analyses identified conditions Variable $36 $24 under which the system could achieve Power $45 $13 approximately $153 per tonne, including Total (excluding T&S) $251 $153 lower electricity prices, optimized pressure CO2 T&S $10 $10 drop, and reductions in contactor cost Total (including T&S) $261 $163 through mature manufacturing (Table 1). The life-cycle assessment further highlighted the importance of the electricity source in determining net carbon performance. With solar-powered operation, the system released only 0.034 kg CO₂ per kilogram of CO₂ captured, demonstrating strong alignment with carbon-negative goals. Nuclear also yielded low emissions, while grid-based or coal-based electricity significantly increased the carbon intensity of DAC operations. 8 Finally, the team used the experimental and analytical results to design a full-scale DAC contactor sized for 100,000 tonnes per year of CO₂ capture. This design incorporates the slit-fin configuration and validated pressure-drop correlations, enabling prediction of fan power, thermal energy requirements, and overall module performance. The resulting concept demonstrates a feasible and scalable pathway for next-generation DAC deployment. Overall, the project successfully advanced TDA’s structured sorbent-coated contactor technology from TRL 3 to TRL 4, demonstrated critical technical performance at multiple scales, and delivered a clear roadmap toward cost-effective and scalable DAC systems. The results show that sorbent-coated heat-exchange contactors can deliver high productivity, low pressure drop, and robust durability, making them strong candidates for future commercial DAC installations. 9 2. Introduction Growing concern over climate change has spurred interest not only in stopping the production of anthropogenic CO2 but also reversing the effects through direct air capture (DAC) (Martin 2007, Stolaroff 2006, Lackner 2001). DAC is challenging due to the very low partial pressure of CO2 in air (c.a. 400 ppmv). Recently, adsorption-based DAC systems employing supported amine sorbents have shown the potential to achieve high CO2 uptake and alleviate the issues related to chemical stress and attrition observed in metal oxides/ hydroxides that remove CO 2 by forming carbonate or bicarbonate bonds. These sorbents are regenerated at modest temperatures (80- 120°C) to recover the CO2 at high pressure and purity. However, the first generation of supported amine sorbents suffered from the poor stability of the amine groups under thermal swing. This led several researchers to explore tethering the active amine groups on high surface-area supports such as cellulose (Sehaqui 2015, Gebald 2013), porous polymer networks (Lu 2013), and porous silica materials (Kumar 2015, Kulkarni 2012, Chaitkittisilp 2011), unfortunately these methods met with only limited success. Recently, in several DOE, NASA and DOD SBIR projects (DE-SC-00020846, 80NSSC18C0135, N00178-18-C-8009) TDA developed a new supported amine sorbent where a highly reactive TEPA molecule was tethered to a mesoporous silica support such as SBA-15, as well as to much lower cost fumed silica supports (e.g., AerosilTM from Evonik) used in DAC and various life support applications (e.g., removing low concentrations of CO2 from a spacesuit or from the cabin air of 130-crew Virginia Class Submarine). In these sorbents, the TEPA strongly interacts with the surface groups of the support, ensuring very high stability through repeated high temperature regeneration cycles. In the Navy project we showed stable sorbent operation for 10,000 cycles in a vacuum-assisted TSA process. The sorbent achieved a high working capacity for CO2, 8 to 10% wt. CO2 (~2.0 mmol/g) under DAC conditions when cycled between 0.4 mbar CO2 (400 ppm CO2 at 1 atm) at ambient temperature and regenerated at 90oC, recovering CO2 as a pure product. A critical requirement of any DAC system design is the necessity to achieve a very low pressure drop through the gas-solid contactor to reduce the energy consumption of air blowers that bring the ambient air into contact with the sorbent. An analysis by TDA comparing post- combustion capture systems (coal and natural gas-fired power plants) and DAC indicates that as the CO2 concentration in the gas stream gets lower, the energy needed to drive the capture process (i.e. the energy needed for sorbent regeneration) and CO2 compression to sequestration Figure 5. Specific energy of CO2 capture as a function pressure (2,200 psig) are dwarfed of concentration. Pressure drop is fixed at 200 mbar. by the energy needed to circulate Note: power consumption is provided on a log scale. the gas through the contactor (Figure 5) (as the CO2 concentration drops from 14% vol. from the flue gas of a coal-fired power plant to 400 ppmv in DAC, the amount of gas to be brought in to the system increases more than 10 350X for a given CO2 capture rate. Thus, the gas-solid contactor needs to have an extraordinarily low flow resistance to keep the energy cost of the DAC system down, as shown in Figure 6). Another equally important requirement is the need to increase the CO2 productivity (i.e., kg of CO2 captured per unit mass/volume of sorbent per time) to ensure a compact, low-cost system. In temperature swing adsorption (TSA) operation, the time to heat and cool the sorbent bed constitutes a very significant fraction of the cycle time. To increase sorbent utilization, the heat/cool times Figure 6. Effect of pressure drop through the gas- must be minimized, requiring a solid contactor on the power consumption for DAC completely new approach for the systems. contactor design. In collaboration with GE Research, we developed and optimized tube-in-plate heat exchangers (HEXs) using our tethered amine sorbent. Figure 7 shows two tube- in-plate HEXs that were coated with different thicknesses of sorbent. Tube-in-plate type HEXs are available on an industrial scale and are commonly used in GE Gas Power’s natural gas-fired power plants. In these HEXs, the thin plates (fins) are mechanically and thermally connected to parallel tubes. Multiple plates are combined to construct a high surface area contactor. While straight plates are most often used as fins, other enhanced fins, such as wavy fins, off-set fins, Figure 7. Sorbent coated on plates of and grooved fins (Figure 8) can reduce the total surface tube-in-plate heat exchanger. area required for same amount of heat transfer. Figure 8. Heat transfer enhanced fins – (left) wavy fin; (middle) off-set fin and (right) grooved fin. 11 Table 2. Comparison of Tube-in-Plate Contactor with Additive and Previous research Plate and Frame Designs. has explored the use Aluminum Tube-in-Plate of adsorbents in DAC Off-set applications prepared Metric Plain Straight Grooved Fin Wavy Fin Fin as stacked laminates, 2 Cost/WSA ($/m ) 25 23 23 25 foam structures and 2 3 monoliths to reduce WSA/V contactor (m /m ) 167 178 185 167 pressure drop and DP (Pa) 69 77 263 296 improve mass and Relative Heat Transfer 1 1.3 2.8 2.7 heat transfer to allow Coefficient rapid cycling in a TSA process. Conventional monolithic structures prepared by common wash-coating of the active phase on pre-formed structures (e.g., ceramic, metal or carbon) provide a viable solution to reduce the pressure drop and improve the mechanical strength; however, the active adsorbent amount per unit volume in these structures are limited, leading to a low CO2 uptake (Akhtar 2014; Rezaei 2009). Sorbent foams typically exhibit too high of a pressure drop and too low a volumetric productivity of CO2 (kg CO2/m3 sorbent) for DAC viability (Rezaei 2009) given the tortuous nature of the pores. While stacked laminates provide high volumetric productivity and are scalable, (Raganati 2021), heat transfer through the laminate stack will be poor (a key limitation). In our work we used HEX structures that have the desired properties (good heat transfer, mass transfer, low pressure drop) and are already available at industrial scale (key advantages over earlier monolith and laminate-based DAC systems). In our project, we used conventional tube-in-plate structures with features that enhance the heat transfer and flow distribution. Aluminum and Copper/Aluminum tube-in-plate heat exchangers are offered commercially with tubes as thin as 0.5 mm and plates/fins as thin as 0.25 mm in a multitude of spacing Table 3. Comparison of Plain Straight Tube-in-Plate Contactor with arrangements to Enhanced Heat Transfer Fins. minimize pressure Aluminum drop in the heat Metric Metal Additive Polymer Additive Plate and Frame Tube-in-Plate exchanger. Table 2 Cost/WSA ($/m2) 25 280-720 230-2100 69 provides a 2 3 WSA/V contactor (m /m ) 167 152 152 100 comparison of key parameters of tube- DP (Pa) 69 135 135 127 in-plate HEXs Fin thickness (mm) 0.25 0.5 1.2 4 prepared with metal and polymer additives against a plate and frame contactor. The tube in plate designs with or without metal or polymer additives (which were introduced to the HEX by GE for purposes other than carbon capture) achieve the high surface area-to-volume needed for compactness, rapid thermal responses due to their thin walls and a low pressure drop compared to conventional contactor designs such as the plate-in-frame HEXs and banks of tubes. Table 3 compares the proposed enhanced heat transfer fin types to the plain straight fins most commonly used in Tube-in-Plate HEX (the Plain Straight Fin performance data is based on analysis from the relationship between friction coefficient and Nusselt number as a function of Reynolds number for the given geometry; the quoted costs are based on quotes for full-scale tube-in-plate HEXs used in GE’s NGCC power plants; the wavy and off-set fin performance data were obtained from Kay and London (1984); the grooved fin performance data is based on internal GE research). These results show particular promise because the increase in heat transfer is greater than the increase in pressure drop. This heat transfer enhancement enables faster cycling times because the material system can heat and cool at a higher rate. These different fin designs were be explored for the application of the sorbent and evaluated for CO2 uptake and productivity. 12 3. Project Objectives TDA Research, Inc., in collaboration with GE Research, developed a structured cell for Direct Air Capture (DAC) of CO2 where the active sorbent phase was coated on the surfaces of tube-in- plate heat exchangers that can be economically produced in large-scale. The sorbent layer thickness and the plate spacing and geometry were optimized to reduce the pressure drop and improve the heat transfer rate (and hence the CO2 productivity). The structured gas-solid contactor design reduces the associated parasitic energy loss for circulating large volumes of air to the system. While the adsorbent was developed in an earlier project and the heat exchangers used in this work are commercially available, the use of sorbent coated heat exchangers for CO2 removal in a thermal swing application had not been previously demonstrated. Key metrics include an improved volumetric CO2 productivity, a decreased pressure drop, reduced capacity fade and a lower cost, scalable fabrication process. The material system developed here demonstrated significant progress towards meeting the goal of $100/MT CO2 removed for DAC. 3.1 Work Plan The proposed work was split into 2 budget periods. The details of the work plan for the two budget periods are summarized below: In BP1 of the project, we optimized the sorbent paste to make it suitable for printing, including adjustments to viscosity and binder content. GE then coated the plates using TDA’s sorbent formulations. The coated test plates (1”×1”×1”) were evaluated individually and as stacks at the bench scale under representative conditions. We optimized the paste properties based on their physical characteristics, mechanical stability, CO₂ adsorption, pressure drop, and surface area. Three types of fin-structure plates were tested at the individual coupon level (Task 3). One baseline (flat-fin) and one alternative fin (slit-fin) structure were down-selected as a result of this optimization (Task 3). In Task 4, the baseline and alternative fin structures were tested at the sub-bench scale, defined as a stack achieving a DAC CO₂ removal productivity of 0.5 to 1.0 g CO₂/hr. An Initial Techno-Economic Assessment (TEA) and Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) were completed (Task 5). In BP2, we further optimized the coating paste at the sub-bench scale as described in Subtask 6.1. Two sub-bench-scale heat exchangers and one larger heat exchanger—representing bench scale, defined as achieving a DAC CO₂ removal productivity of 10 to 50 g CO₂/hr—were coated using the optimized paste formulation and coating process. In Subtask 6.2, we tested the contactors’ performance under DAC conditions in TDA’s automated test rigs. A 5,000 cycle test was conducted to demonstrate the life of the structured sorbent in a sub-bench-scale contactor operating with compressed air. Additionally, a 500 cycle test was completed with the bench-scale contactor to demonstrate the concept at ambient conditions. Based on the results, we designed a full-scale gas-solid DAC contactor, identifying key parameters such as tube size, length and spacing, plate type, spacing and depth, and material selection needed to support 100,000 MT/year of CO₂ capture from air (Task 7). In Task 8, we prepared the final TEA and estimated the cost of CO₂ captured with the new technology. A final Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) was also carried out to fully quantify the carbon-footprint reduction achievable with the new technology (Task 9). The project was completed over two Budget Periods of 12 months each. Over the course of the work, the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of the technology advanced from 3 to 4. We successfully met all of our objectives, on schedule and on budget. 13 4. Accomplishments The specific accomplishments over each of the budget period are summarized below: In Budget Period 1 (September 1, 2023 to August 31, 2024) we had the following accomplishments: • We updated the Project Management Plan, which was approved by the DOE Project Manager on October 30, 2023 (Milestone 1.1). • The Initial Technology Maturation Plan was completed on November 30, 2023 (Milestone 1.3). • The Project Kick-off Meeting with DOE was held on November 3, 2023 (Milestone 1.4). • In our Initial Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA) we estimated the cost of CO2 capture to be $255/MT excluding transportation and storage (T&S) before any major process optimization (Milestone 1.5). Typical of any DAC design, moving air consumes by far the largest amount of energy. • In our Initial Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) we estimated that for each kg of CO 2 captured, 0.057 kg of CO2 is released leading to a cradle-to-gate capture of 0.943 kg CO2 (Milestone 1.6). • We completed the synthesis of the DAC sorbent batches; 4L of the finished (dried/supported) material was prepared following established procedures. Sorbents demonstrated a CO2 capacity of 7.86 wt% (at 60ºC with 15/15 min adsorb/desorb cycles in TGA) which is within ±20% of the CO2 capacity of 8wt% (Milestone 1.7), the contract target. In fact, our measured performance is within 2% of the 8 wt% target. • Sorbent coatings performed within 20% of plain sorbent and within 10% of plain sorbent when capacity is calculated excluding binder weight (Milestone 1.8). • We submitted the BP2 Continuation Application including a letter and a Decision Point Report (Milestone 1.9) on May 31, 2024. • For the sub-bench scale module, the air flow side pressure drop was confirmed to be <150 Pa at all flow rates tested, meeting the Milestone 1.10 target of < 2.5 kPa. • We demonstrated a sorbent productivity of 32 g CO2 removed per kg of sorbent per hour in the sub-bench scale contactor testing, significantly exceeding the Milestone 1.11 sorbent productivity target of 10 g CO2/kg-hr. • Over 100 cycles, the CO2 uptake remains nearly constant through the bench-scale cycles, with some indication of reduced capacity in the last cycles. However, with the associated uncertainties in measurements, we consider it meeting the Milestone 1.12 target of <1% capacity fade over 100 cycles. The completion date was July 30, 2024. • We identified the optimum fin design configuration from sub-bench scale tests to be slit- fin geometry, demonstrating half-cycle times of <30 minutes with volumetric productivity of 0.89, which is well in excess of 0.2 kg CO2 removed per m3 contactor volume per hour, the Milestone 1.13 target. The completion date was July 30, 2024. • We completed the initial BP1 Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA) on May 31, 2024 and it showed that the cost of DAC is at <$258/MT on $2020 basis within 3.2% of the Milestone 1.14 target and showed feasibility of further reducing the cost of capture to $230 and lower in a sensitivity analysis study. • We completed the initial BP1 Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) on August 27, 2024 (Milestone 1.15). • We completed the bench-scale module testing at GE on August 31, 2024 and the unit was shipped to TDA for further testing in BP2, completing Milestone 1.16. • We successfully met all the GO/NO-GO Decision Criteria on August 31, 2024 and the project moved to BP2. 14 In Budget Period 2 (September 1, 2024 to August 31, 2025) we had the following accomplishments: • We completed the full-scale DAC contactor design on February 28, 2025, delivering the complete design package and meeting Milestone 2.1. • We demonstrated that the bench-scale module meets the air-side pressure-drop target, confirming an air-flow-side pressure drop of <2.0 kPa (20 mbar), satisfying Milestone 2.2 on August 31, 2025. • We successfully scaled up the optimized BP1 fin design to bench scale and demonstrated half-cycle times of <30 minutes with volumetric productivity >0.2 kg CO₂ removed per m³-contactor-hr, meeting Milestone 2.3 on August 31, 2025. • We completed 5,000-cycle durability testing on the sub-bench-scale module, demonstrating stable CO₂ working capacity with <5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles, achieving Milestone 2.4 ahead of schedule on June 30, 2025. • We completed 500-cycle durability testing of the bench-scale module, confirming <5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles, and met Milestone 2.5 on August 31, 2025. • We completed the Final Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) on June 11, 2025, meeting Milestone 2.6, quantifying cradle-to-gate performance for the optimized BP2 DAC system. • We completed the Final Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA) on June 10, 2025, demonstrating that the projected DAC cost meets the target of <$100/net tonne CO₂ removed, achieving Milestone 2.7. • We completed the Final Technology Maturation Plan (TMP) on June 30, 2025, fulfilling Milestone 2.8 and documenting the pathway toward higher TRLs. • We completed the Final State-Point Data Table, supporting the final engineering model set, meeting Milestone 2.9 on June 10, 2025. • We submitted the Final Project Report on April 15, 2026, completing Milestone 2.10. • We presented the full project results at the DOE Final Review Meeting on January 14, 2026, fulfilling Milestone 2.11. 15 5. Results and Discussion 5.1 Task 1. Project Management Planning PMP: The project commenced on September 1, 2023 and we first updated the Project Management Plan, which was approved by the DOE Project Manager on October 30, 2023 (Milestone 1.1). We also updated the Data Management Plan on September 28, 2023. The Project Kick-off Meeting was held on November 3, 2023 (Milestone 1.3). It is to be noted Milestone 1.2 was removed from the Contract by DOE Action in January 2024. The Initial Technology Maturation Plan was completed on November 30, 2023 (Milestone 1.4). We completed all the scheduled milestones and Deliverables for the project as summarized in the Milestone Log (Table 4). Table 4. Project milestone log with completed milestones as of the Final Report Submission Date. Budget ID Task Title and Description Planned Actual Verification Period No. Completion Completion Method Date Date Project Start Date (Expected) 9/1/2023 Complete Project Management Plan 10/1/2023 10/30/2023 PMP 1 M1.1 1 (PMP) Document 1 M1.3 1 Complete Initial Technology 11/30/2023 11/30/2023 Initial TMP Maturation Plan (TMP) Document Complete Kick-off 11/30/2023 11/3/2023 1 M1.4 1 Meeting/Presentation Presentation 1 M1.5 5 Complete Initial Techno-Economic 12/30/2023 1/8/2024 Initial TEA Analysis (TEA). Initial TEA shows Report <$150/net tonne CO2e removed 1 M1.6 5 Complete Initial Life Cycle Analysis 12/30/2023 1/3/2024 Initial LCA (LCA) Report 1 M1.7 2 Complete the synthesis of DAC 2/29/2024 2/29/2024 Progress Sorbent. DAC sorbent batches Report perform within ±20% of a CO2 capacity of 8wt%. 1 M1.8 3 Complete Durable Sorbent 5/31/2024 5/31/2024 Progress Washcoats. Sorbent washcoats Report perform within ±30% of plain sorbent (excluding binder additions) 1 M1.9 1 Complete the submission of the 5/31/2024 5/31/2024 Decision Continuation Application Point Report 1 M1.10 4 Demonstrate the sub-bench scale 5/31/2024 5/31/2024 Progress module has air flow side pressure drop Report; that is <2.5 kPa (25 mbar) Decision Point Report 1 M1.11 3 Demonstrate that sorbent productivity 5/31/2024 5/31/2024 Progress is 10g CO2 removed per kg of sorbent Report; per hour in the sub-bench scale Decision contactor testing (<500 ppm CO2 in air, Point Report Relative humidity >30%, Temperature 20-25°C) 1 M1.12 4 Demonstrate 100 cycles with the sub- 8/31/2024 7/30/2024 Progress bench scale module showing stable Report; CO2 working capacity with less than Decision 1% capacity fade per 100 cycles (<500 Point Report 16 ppm CO2 in air, Relative humidity >30%, Temperature 20-25°C) 1 M1.13 3 Identify optimum fin design 5/31/2024 7/30/2024 Progress configuration from sub-bench scale Report; tests, demonstrating half-cycle times Decision of <30 minutes with volumetric Point Report productivity in excess of 0.1 kg CO2 removed per m3 contactor volume per hour in sub-bench scale contactor testing (<500 ppm CO2 in air, Relative humidity >30%, Temperature 20- 25°C) 1 M1.14 5 Complete the initial BP1 Techno- 5/31/2024 5/31/2024 BP1 TEA Economic Analysis (TEA). The BP1 Report TEA shows the cost of DAC at <$250/net tonne CO2e removed. 1 M1.15 5 Complete the initial BP1 Life Cycle 5/31/2024 8/27/2024 BP1 LCA Analysis (LCA) Report 1 M1.16 4 Complete Bench-Scale Testing in GE 8/31/2024 8/31/2024 Progress Report 1 M1.17 Meet the Success Criteria for GO/NO- 8/31/2024 8/31/2024 Presentation GO Decision Point at the end of BP1, to DOE as listed in Table 4. 1 M1.18 Complete Continuation Application 8/31/2024 8/31/2024 Presentation and Continuation Briefing to DOE 2 M2.1 7 Complete Contactor Design 2/28/2025 2/28/2025 Design Package submitted with Progress Report 2 M2.2 6.1 Demonstrate the bench scale module 8/31/2025 8/31/2025 Progress has air flow side pressure drop that is Report <2.0 kPa (20 mbar) 2 M2.3 6.1 Use optimized fin design from BP1 and 8/31/2025 8/31/2025 Progress scaleup to bench scale with the Report optimized fin design and demonstrate half-cycle times of < 30 minutes with volumetric productivity in excess of 0.2 kg CO2 removed per m3 contactor volume per hour in bench scale contactor testing 2 M2.4 6.2 Demonstrate 5,000 cycles with the 8/31/2025 6/30/2025 Progress sub-bench scale module showing Report stable CO2 working capacity with less than 5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles (<500 ppm CO2 in air, Relative humidity >30%, Temperature 20- 25°C) 2 M2.5 6.2 Demonstrate 500 cycles with the 8/31/2025 8/31/2025 Progress bench scale module showing stable Report CO2 working capacity with less than 5% capacity fade per 1,000 cycles (<500 ppm CO2 in air, Relative humidity >30%, Temperature 20- 25°C) 17 2 M2.6 8 Complete the Final Life Cycle Analysis 5/31/2025 6/11/2025 Final LCA (LCA) Report 2 M2.7 9 Complete the Final Techno-Economic 5/31/2025 6/10/2025 Final TEA Analysis (TEA). Final TEA shows the Report cost of DAC at <$100/net tonne CO2e removed 2 M2.8 9 Complete Final Technology 5/31/2025 6/30/2025 Final TMP Maturation Plan (TMP) Document 2 M2.9 9 Complete Final State Point Data Table 5/31/2025 6/10/2025 Progress Report 2 M2.10 Submit the Final Report 8/31/2025 4/15/2026 Final Report 2 M2.11 Present at the Final Review Meeting 8/31/2025 1/14/2026 Presentation to DOE 5.2 Task 5. Initial Techno-economic Analysis and Life Cycle Analysis The BP1 TEA report was completed and submitted in January 2024 . This report evaluated a DAC system using coated finned heat exchanges capable of removing 100,000 MTPY CO2. The results of this analysis show a cost of capture as low as $247 / MT CO2 for a DAC system that can recover industrial waste heat to drive regeneration. A sensitivity analysis was performed showing pathways to reduce overall cost of capture. One notable improvement that to be explored in BP2is the cost of the sorbent contactor. As the bench-scale contactor is designed and built using sub- bench scale results, the cost of manufacturing will play a significant role in the design to ensure capital investments for the full-scale system are kept to a minimum. The TEA results were used as an input for the LCA. The BP1 LCA report was also completed and submitted in January 2024. The LCA model showed that the solar-powered DAC system led to the emission of 0.0211 kg CO2 eq for each 1 kg CO2 separated (Figure 9). The Life Cycle 45Q Displacement Factor Figure 9. GWP results for the Proposed Product System (Solar- (LC 45Q DF) is 11.041. powered DAC) and Comparison Product System (Grid-powered The Grid-based DAC DAC) based on the functional unit of the study (1 kg CO2 model is identical to the separated). Solar-based DAC model except for the source of electricity. This allows us to show the impact of the electricity sources on the DAC process. For GWP, the highest emissions were shown for coal > grid > nuclear > solar, but nuclear and solar were nearly identical. We showed that electricity source is one of the key modeling parameters that influence the study results, and the results are affected by the sensitivity of that the electricity estimate which comes from the TEA. 18 5.3 Task 6. Extended Cycling Tests (BP2) 5.3.1 Task 6.1 Sub-bench Scale Testing at TDA (BP2) TDA received the down selected sub-bench scale module from GEVAR from the BP1 work and assembled an automated system to test it for extended cycles (5,000 cycles). TDA updated an existing apparatus for this extended sub-bench scale testing (Figure 10). For the purposes of this project, the sub-bench scale is defined as achieving DAC CO2 removal productivity of 0.5 to 1.0 g CO2/hr. Figure 10. Sub-bench modules (left) and bench-scale test apparatus (right). For the sub-bench scale testing, TDA received four identical sub-bench contactors coated with the TDASSSA-7A sorbent and the GE binder formulation. These were arranged in series and installed as shown in Figure 11. The flow region for each individual unit is 3” wide by 2.12” high (with 16 fins evenly spaced) and close to 1.75” deep. Life and durability tests are currently being performed for 10-minute cycles (5-minute adsorb and 5-minute regen). Adsorb conditions are 300 SLPM flow, 500 ppmv CO2 inlet concentration and 40% relative humidity (20 °C). During adsorption, the contactors are cooled with water at 15 °C flowing through the heat exchange tubes. A short vacuum purge, 30 seconds, occurs at the end of each adsorb cycle before switching over to regen. During regeneration, the contactor is held under vacuum pressure, 1 psia, and heated using 90 °C water in the heat exchanger tubes. At the end of regeneration, the bed is brought back up to pressure for 30 seconds before fully switching to adsorb and repeating this cycle sequence. The following results were collected under baseline cycling conditions unless otherwise stated. The baseline adsorption conditions are 5 minutes in duration with 40-50% relative humidity lab air flow at 300 SLPM containing 500 ppmv inlet CO2 concentration. The baseline regeneration conditions are 5 minutes in duration at 1 PSIA vacuum, and 100 °C heat exchange fluid in the heat exchanger/ sorbent contactor. 19 Figure 11. Sub-bench modules test design (left) and apparatus (right). On average we are saw 0.8 wt% capacity (gCO2/gcoating) and a 19% capture efficiency in our initial 1,000 cycles. This corresponds to ~3 gCO2/hr and a productivity of 0.07 gCO2/gcoating/hr. The sub- bench scale can be defined as achieving DAC CO2 removal productivity of 0.5 to 1.0 g CO2/hr. The data noise/decline in performance beginning around cycle 800 up until 1500 was due to a slow-developing leak in one of the heat exchanger tube fittings and is not indicative of degrading sorbent. The leak was causing a decreasing level of heat exchanger fluid and creating unstable heating conditions during regen. After the leak was fixed we see the capacity stabilize as indicated by the increase in CO2 capacity around 1,600 cycles. Over the course of 6,500 cycles (well past our Milestone M2.4 target) the sorbent maintained a high capacity of > 0.7% wt. CO2, there was minimal degradation of the sorbent, as shown in Figure 12. The estimated degradation in CO2 capacity is around 11% over the initial Figure 12. CO2 Capacity vs cycle count. 5,000 cycles, which 20 comes to ~2.2% capacity fade over 1,000 cycles, well exceeding our Milestone M2.4 target of <5% capacity fade over 1,000 cycles. Figure 13. 10-minute adsorption curves at varied feed air flow rates. The characteristic breakthrough curves for different feed air flow conditions air shown in Figure 13. We see that the capture efficiency slightly improves ta lower feed air flow rates, as evidenced by the lower CO2 leakage rates seen in the breakthrough curves at lower feed air flow rates. To compare the effect of cycle time on CO2 capacity we ram tests at different adsorption times. The results are shown in Figure 14. As expected, the CO2 capacity increases with increased adsorption time, however the overall capture efficiency decreases as we increase the adsorption time. This is an expected result as more CO2 will slip as the sorbent becomes saturated with CO2 with increased adsorption times. Figure 14. Trend plot of the effect of adsorption time on CO2 capacity. 21 Figure 15. Trend plot of the effect of relative humidity on CO2 capacity for 5/5 minute, adsorb/regen. The effect of relative humidity on sorbent performance is shown in Figure 15. Data was collected under baseline conditions, except with a regeneration temperature of 90 °C. The cycle sequence was 5 minute of adsorption and 5 minute of regeneration durations. There is a positive correlation between elevated relative humidity conditions and the CO2 capacity of the sorbent. There is nearly a 50% increase in CO2 working capacity between the 40-50% relative humidity baseline condition and the elevated 70-80% relative humidity operating conditions; and the capacity reaches a maximum at 70% RH and shows no change up to 80% RH. Figure 16. Trend plot of the effect of air flowrate on sorbent working capacity and capture efficiency for 10/10 minute adsorb/regen cycles. 22 5.4 Task 8. Life Cycle Analysis TDA Research, Inc., in collaboration with GE Research, has developed a structured cell for Direct Air Capture (DAC) of CO2 where the active sorbent phase will be coated on the surfaces of tube- in-plate heat exchangers that can be economically produced in large-scale. The sorbent layer thickness and the plate spacing and geometry were optimized to reduce the pressure drop and improve the heat transfer rate (and hence the CO2 productivity). The structured gas-solid contactor design will also reduce the associated parasitic energy loss for circulating large volumes of air to the system. While the adsorbent was developed in an earlier project and the heat exchangers are commercially available, the use of sorbent coated heat exchangers for CO 2 removal in a thermal swing application was not previously demonstrated. In this project we demonstrated coated heat exchangers for DAC with contactors that are in sub-bench and bench scale sizes. Key metrics included an improved volumetric CO2 productivity, a decreased pressure drop, reduced capacity fade and a lower cost, scalable fabrication process. The material system fabricated in the project demonstrated significant progress towards meeting the goal of $200/net Tonne CO2 removed for DAC. The study goal was to determine the environmental impact of capturing CO2 using TDA’s DAC plant including the sorbent plant. The scope included a DAC plant and sorbent plant taking account any emissions during production of the sorbent and procurement of raw materials, contactor fabrication and steel and concrete used for the construction of the DAC plant and sorbent production plant. This LCA was a cradle-to-gate analysis determining CO2 consumption and release from both direct sources (e.g. CO2 used as the feedstock for the sorbent system) and indirect sources (e.g. CO2 released from fuels used for transportation) throughout the life of the product. Since the CO2 will be stored underground permanently, the LCA used the boundary of the DAC facility. The functional unit of the Proposed Product System is 1 kg of CO2, separated but not compressed or sequestered. This LCA details the inputs and outputs to the system from the cradle (raw materials), through system use, to the gate (separation of 1 kg CO2). To determine transportation emissions, we placed the DAC plant near our facility in Golden, Colorado. The DAC system manufacturing facility and sorbent plant were placed next to the DAC operation. The DAC plant is assumed to have a lifetime of 30 years. The sorbent lifetime is assumed to be 4 years with the used contactor metals being recycled back into new contactors. Major drivers that impact the environmental result are the source of the electricity used to drive the DAC process,, amine sorbent production and aluminum production. After these flows, the next major categories are copper production, steel production, and Portland cement production (Portland cement is a component of concrete). For solar electricity, the global warming potential (GWP) impact is low, but when coal generated electricity is used, the GWP impact is higher. In general, solar and nuclear had the lowest values when comparing energy emissions followed by the grid power and coal-based power. A summary of the LCA findings is given below, while the full details are included in Appendix B. The LCA model showed that the solar-powered DAC system led to the emission of 0.0340 kg CO2 eq for each 1 kg CO2 separated. The Life Cycle 45Q Displacement Factor (LC 45Q DF) is 933.96. The Coal-based DAC model is identical to the Solar-based DAC model except for the source of electricity. This allows us to show the impact of the electricity sources on the DAC process. For GWP, the highest emissions were shown for coal > grid > nuclear > solar but nuclear and solar were nearly identical. We showed that electricity source is one of the key modeling parameters that influence the study results, and the results are affected by the sensitivity of that the electricity estimate which comes from the TEA. 23 5.5 Task 9. Final Techno-economic Assessment The result of our BP2 final techno- Table 5. Overall Cost of CO2 Capture. economic analysis (TEA) of TDA’s direct COC DACnet 2019 $/ air capture (DAC) system equipped with tonne a structured sorbent (sorbent applied as a coating on the surface of the fins of a Component Predicted Optimized tube-in-plate heat exchanger) following Cost Cost the guidelines provided in the U.S. DOE Capital $116 $68 funding opportunity announcement DE- Fixed $54 $48 FOA-00002614, Appendix M is summarized below. Full details are Variable $36 $24 included in Appendix C. TDA identified Power $45 $13 the major process equipment for the Total (excluding T&S) $251 $153 DAC system balance of plant including CO2 T&S $10 $10 air fans, heat exchangers, vacuum pumps, etc., and carried out the material Total (including T&S) $261 $163 and energy balances around the DAC system to determine the auxiliary power requirements, capital and operating costs and the CO2 capture costs. Performance data for the DAC system consists of all key process parameters, including the air flow rate, sorbent capacity and regeneration temperature. The heat and material balance for the process was modeled using Aspen Hysys process simulation software. The parameters for the adsorption contactor were based on performance data reported by GE from testing conducted on a sorbent-coated fin and tube heat exchanger. The sorbent was provided by TDA, and the coated heat exchanger geometry was developed and characterized by GE. Performance data obtained in preliminary flow testing by GE was used for this TEA. The analysis was carried out by TDA on a 2019 $ basis following guidelines provided in DOE/NETL-2021/2864. During budget period 2 (BP2), we increased the fidelity of the BP1 TEA to provide a better cost estimation based on results and predictions provided from GE test data. We updated the process model for the modular TDA DAC system, updated the capital and operating costs, power requirements, and the CO2 capture costs based on coated heat exchanger sub bench-scale testing data and predicted large scale performance received from GE. We initially evaluated a stand-alone DAC system (using and electric boiler for steam generation) to provide a direct comparison to the DOE Case 0B-EB. However, we determined that the thermal energy required to heat the metal in the heat exchangers far exceeded the sorbent regeneration energy making an electric boiler infeasible. This study evaluates a system that incorporates the coated fin and tube heat exchangers into an industrial process with available waste heat. Because air cooled condensers are commonly used to reject heat, the proposed design can easily be incorporated into processes that already use air cooled condensers and utilize that rejected heat for DAC sorbent regeneration. Additionally, we evaluated potential savings that could be achieved by running a sensitivity study on various parameters. Using these optimizations, we show the potential cost of capture for an optimized plant using TDA’s DAC technology. Table 5 shows the results for two scenarios for the proposed DAC system. Using experimental data from GE’s flow studies and similar assumptions to case 0B-EB in NETLs DAC sorbent reference case, we estimate an overall cost of capture for $251/tonne CO2 not including transport and storage. If we assume the most favorable conditions listed in Table 6, we estimate an overall cost of capture of $153/tonne CO2 which is well below the BP2 milestone of $200/tonne CO2. 24 Table 6. Ideal parameter value for an optimized and mature DAC system. Variable Assumed Justification Value Electricity Cost $30/MWh DOE target for renewable energy cost Sorbent Cost $15/kg TDA target for structured sorbent cost Capacity Factor 90% Estimated CF for Geothermal power plants Contactor Shell Cost $80,000 Assuming 10% bulk discount on original cost estimation Pressure Drop 5 mbar Can minimize pressure drop with contactor fin design. (Assuming experimental data does not indicate significant loss in performance) Fixed Charge Rate 0.0508 DOE financial assumption for Cement plant 25 6. References Cited Chaikittisilp (2011) Chem. Euro. J. 17, 10556–10561. Choi, Sunho, Jeffrey H. Drese, and Christopher W. Jones. "Adsorbent materials for carbon dioxide capture from large anthropogenic point sources." ChemSusChem 2.9 (2009): 796- 854. Gebald (2013) Environ. Sci. Technol. 47, 10063–10070. Horcajada (2010) Nature materials, 9(2), 172-178. Hu (2019) Advanced Sustainable Systems, 3(1), 1970002. Kim (2013) Langmuir 29 (2013) 1446. Knox, James, et al. "Development of Carbon Dioxide Removal Systems for Advanced Exploration Systems." 42nd International Conference on Environmental Systems. 2012. Kreno (2012) Chemical reviews, 112(2), 1105-1125. Kulkarni (2012) Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 51, 8631–8645. Kumar (2015) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 54, 14372–14377. Lackner (2001). Capturing carbon dioxide from air. Lawson, Shane, et al. "Amine-functionalized MIL-101 monoliths for CO2 removal from enclosed environments." Energy & Fuels 33.3 (2019): 2399-2407. Lee (2009) Chemical Society Reviews, 38(5), 1450-1459. Lee (2018) Chemical science, 9(23), 5197-5206. Li, Xin, et al. "Catalytic cracking of n-hexane for producing light olefins on 3D-printed monoliths of MFI and FAU zeolites." Chemical Engineering Journal 333 (2018): 545-553. Liao (2016) Chemical science, 7(10), 6528-6533. Lu (2013) J. Phys. Chem. C. 117, 4057−4061. Madden (2017) Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, 375(2084), 20160025. Martin (2007) LA-UR-07-7897.McDonald (2012) Journal of the American Chemical Society, 134(16), 7056-7065. Sanz-Pérez (2016) Chem. Rev. 2016, 116, 11840. Sava (2013) Chemistry of Materials, 25(13), 2591-2596. Sehaqui (2015) Environ. Sci. Technol. 49, 3167–3174. Shekhah (2014) Nat. Commun. 2014, 5, 4228. Stolaroff (2006). Capturing CO2 from ambient air: a feasibility assessment (Doctoral dissertation). Thakkar, Harshul, et al. "3D-printed zeolite monoliths for CO2 removal from enclosed environments." ACS applied materials & interfaces 8.41 (2016): 27753- 27761. Thakkar, Harshul, et al. "Adsorption of ethane and ethylene over 3D-printed ethane- selective monoliths." ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 6.11 (2018b): 15228- 15237. Thakkar, Harshul, et al. "Development of 3D-printed polymer-zeolite composite monoliths for gas separation." Chemical Engineering Journal 348 (2018a): 109-116. Thakkar, Harshul, et al. "Formulation of aminosilica adsorbents into 3D-printed monoliths and evaluation of their CO2 capture performance." ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 9.8 (2017): 7489-7498. Travitzky, Nahum, et al. "Additive manufacturing of ceramic‐based materials." Advanced engineering materials 16.6 (2014): 729-754. Vilhelmsen (2012) J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 3 (2012) 3702. Wójtowicz, Marek A., et al. "Monolithic Trace-Contaminant Sorbents Fabricated from 3D- printed Polymer Precursors." https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190028890 26