LLNL-TR-2005586 Calculations Document N Roskopf March 2026 This document was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States government. Neither the United States government nor Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC, 1. Perform a force balance at room temperature (RT) to solve for RT sag due to capsule weight 2. Perform a force balance at empirical cryogenic sag conditions to solve for the yarns CTE Room Temperature Force Balance The yarns constrain and support the capsule by going into tension. The simplified and non-simplified Free Body Diagrams for the yarns supporting the capsule can be seen in Figure 3. Figure 3a: Simplified Forces Figure 3b: Force Diagram 3 Where FUTot stands for the total vertical force exerted by both upper yarns on the capsule, FLTot stands for the total vertical force exerted by both lower yarns on the capsule, and WC stands for the weight of the capsule. In Figure 3b πœƒπ‘ˆ and πœƒπΏ represent the angle of the straight sections of yarn with respect to the horizontal, this is a simplification that doesn’t consider the wrapping of the yarn around the capsule. Solving Yarn Elongation The first course of action in solving the yarn forces is to determine the elongation of the yarns as this is directly correlated. The length of the yarn by default is 2L as seen in Figure 1. This is the inner diameter of the hohlraum, which before close is the distance the yarns span from slot to slot. By calculating an estimate for the yarn length when it is wrapped around the capsule we can subtract the default length of the yarn, 2L, and have the yarn elongation. Consider a side view of the capsule, as shown in Figure 4, where the bottom yarns are pointing in/out of the screen. Figure 4: Geometry of Yarn Position Wrapping Around Capsule Where e is yarn deflection in the x direction, 2b is the gap between wires centered about the capsule center, a is the yarn offset, and d is the wire deflection. Intuitively in an ideal world we would expect upon close when the yarns are hugged around the capsule for the yarns to settle in the position along the capsules curvature such that the restoring force (FR) of the yarn is exactly parallel to the normal force (FN) of the capsule on the yarn. In reality, we have verified on Sagometer utilizing actual closed Tetracage targets that the yarn typically settles at a stopping point before it reaches the point along the capsule where the restoring and normal forces are parallel. The additional force that is introduced to allow the system to achieve a static state we denote (Ff,e) which stands for a force either from friction of the yarn on the capsule surface or an elastic force from the yarn winding itself up along the outside of the capsule. Free body diagrams of both the ideal and actual force balances can be seen in Figure 5. 4 Figure 5a: Ideal Force Balance Figure 5b: Actual Force Balance The empirical data from measuring real yarn positions on sagometer shows that the displacement factor e should be adjusted by a factor of 1/3, we will call this empirical factor Ξ². Now let’s find the intersection between the circle cross section shown in Figure 5 and the line from the center of the capsule to the outside of the capsule where the wire would sit if there were no friction or elastic force. Because we don’t have any feasible way to calculate the friction or elastic force given our current understanding of the yarn/capsule interaction we will use the empirical factor Ξ² previously mentioned to adjust for this observed phenomenon in calculations for displacement factor e. Considering the origin at the center of the capsule the equation for the cross-section circle of the outer capsule radius is: π‘₯2 + 𝑦2 = π‘Ÿ2 (1) Solving for y in Equation 1 yields: 𝑦 = βˆšπ‘Ÿ 2 βˆ’ π‘₯ 2 (2) The equation for a straight line from the center of the capsule to the yarn interaction with the capsule in the ideal force case using our pre-defined variables is as follows: π‘Ž (3) 𝑦= π‘₯ 𝑏 By setting Equations 2 and 3 equal to each other the x coordinate of the intercept can be found as follows: (4) 1 π‘₯ = π‘Ÿπ‘βˆš 2 π‘Ž + 𝑏2 Figure 6, which builds on Figure 5b, illustrates the position of the section view used to solve the elongated yarn length. 5 Figure 6: Illustration of Location of Section View for Following Calculations Figure 7 shows the cross section view orthogonally with the yarns extending from the hohlraums to where they begin to interact with the capsule: Figure 7: Section View of Yarn Interaction with Capsule In this figure we can see that rc, the radius of the capsule at this cross section, is equal to y from Equation 2, this y value will be adjusted to be calculated using an empirical x value. The variables x2, y2, x3, y3 are the contact points between the yarn and the capsule. The origin is on the left hohlraum wall at the midpoint between the hohlraums and in line with the plane of the cross section – the extension of the yarn perpendicular to the page will be added into the calculations later. Figure 8 shows the geometry. Figure 8: Close View of Geometry Yarn Wrapping Around Capsule 6 Figure 8 shows a top-down view of the capsule and the solid blue line demonstrates the path of the yarn as it wraps around the capsule. The variable b corresponds to the distance from the center of the capsule to the point the bases of the yarns are mounted to the hohlraums. The deformation from the yarn around the capsule from its non-deformed state, as shown by the dashed light blue line, is characterized by e as discussed earlier. Recall that e will be scaled by an empirical factor Ξ², which is 1/3. The variable h introduced in this diagram was originally a tool to calculate ψ, which is the angle that the yarn deflects away from the capsule on the horizontal plane, but then I realized that a more accurate depiction would be to use the hohlraums length, L, to solve for ψ as the hohlraum inner diameter is where the yarn is anchored – this is covered later in the Forces section. Equation 5 solves for e in terms of known variables: 𝑒 = (π‘₯ βˆ’ 𝑏) βˆ— Ξ² (5) Given this equation for e, we can solve for the capsule radius rc after it’s been adjusted for empirically using Ξ² – this takes into account the difference between the ideal case we solved for in Equation 4 and the known behavior adjusted for in Equation 5. The adjustment can be found by combining Equations 2, 4, and 5. This yields Equation 6: 2 (6) 1 π‘Ÿπ‘ = π‘Ÿ2 βˆ’ 𝑏 (1 βˆ’ Ξ² (1 βˆ’ r√ 2 )) π‘Ž + 𝑏2 √ ( ) Now that we know the radius of the capsule at this cutout where the yarn intercepts the capsule, rc, we can calculate the wire intercepts, x2, y2, x3, y3, in the β€œn” coordinate system shown in Figure 7 including capsule sag as shown in Figure 2. The first side of the equation is the circle of the capsule: (𝑋𝑛 βˆ’ 𝐿)2 + (𝑦𝑛 Β± 𝑆𝑔 )2 = π‘Ÿπ‘ 2 (7) 𝑦𝑛 = βˆšπ‘Ÿπ‘ 2 βˆ’ (π‘₯𝑛 βˆ’ 𝐿)2 Β± 𝑆𝑔 (8) The other side of the equation for which we will set the y intercept equal to is the line that extends from (0, -a) to (L, -rc Β±Sg). The equation for this line is as follows: π‘Ž βˆ’ π‘Ÿπ‘ Β± 𝑆𝑔 (9) 𝑦𝑛 = ( ) π‘₯𝑛 βˆ’ π‘Ž 𝐿 By solving this equation using Β± Sg we can simultaneously solve the cases for both upper and lower yarns. At the end of all the algebra we always know that the greater value of elongation corresponds to the lower yarns and the lesser value of elongation corresponds to the upper yarns. Setting Equation 8 and Equation 9 equal and solving for the corresponding xn intercepts reveals an expected two solutions after a monstrous amount of algebra. The resulting solutions are seen in the following equation: 7 𝐿3 + 𝐿(π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 )2 βˆ’ π‘ŸπΏ(π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) Β± πΏπ‘Ÿπ‘ ((π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) βˆ’ π‘Ÿπ‘ ) (10) π‘₯2 = 𝐿2 + (π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 )2 + π‘Ÿπ‘ 2 βˆ’ 2π‘Ÿπ‘ (π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) The trailing Β±πΏπ‘Ÿπ‘ ((π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) βˆ’ π‘Ÿπ‘ ) depicts the crossroads between the two solutions. One of these solutions we expect to be x2=L as seen in Figure 7. By first substituting in for the addition case we can simplify to the following equation: 2 (11) 𝐿(𝐿2 + (π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) βˆ’ π‘Ÿπ‘ 2 ) π‘₯2 = 2 𝐿 + (π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 )2 + π‘Ÿπ‘ 2 βˆ’ 2π‘Ÿπ‘ (π‘Ž Β± 𝑆𝑔 ) Then by substituting in for the subtraction case we can simplify to the following: π‘₯2 = 𝐿 (12) Seeing as the subtraction case results in Equation 12, we have a sanity check to ensure Equation 11 is correct. Taking a look at Equation 11 again we can see that there are still two solutions, one corresponding to +Sg and one corresponding to -Sg. Through solving out some cases and comparing corresponding y values it was seen that the upper yarn solution corresponds to adding Sg and the lower yarn solution corresponds to subtracting Sg. Even though we can all agree doing pages of algebra is very fun, we can harness known geometry to solve for x3 rather than toiling through with a different line equation. This can be solved as follows: π‘₯3 = 2𝐿 βˆ’ π‘₯2 (13) Subsequently y2 and y3 can be found as follows: 𝑦2 = βˆšπ‘Ÿπ‘ 2 βˆ’ (π‘₯2 βˆ’ 𝐿)2 = 𝑦3 (14) We will assume the yarn segments on either side of the capsule, Lhc standing for length of the yarn from hohlraum to capsule, are the same length. The equation for Lhc is as follows: πΏβ„Žπ‘ = √(𝛼𝑒)2 + π‘₯2 2 + (𝑦2 βˆ’ π‘Ž)2 (15) Where 𝜢 is an empirical factor akin to Ξ² representing the perpendicular offset of the yarn at the location it contacts the capsule. This value was determined to be ~1/5 using empirical data from finished builds on sagometer. The other yarn segment necessary to calculate the elongated yarn length is the arc length for the segment wrapping around the capsule. The points we have in space as illustrated in Figure 7 are (x2, y2, 𝛼e), (x3, y3, 𝛼e), and (L, -Sg, 0) which correspond to the yarn contact points with the capsule and capsule centerpoint respectively. Recall that 𝛼 is a scaling factor corresponding to ~1/5 as observed by Tetracage target builds on sagometer. 8 Looking at Figure 4 and solving for ΞΈ using law of cosines sets up the following equation: 2π‘₯2 2 + 2(𝑦2 βˆ’ 𝑆𝑔 )2 + 2(𝛼𝑒)2 βˆ’ (π‘₯3 βˆ’ π‘₯2 )2 βˆ’ (𝑦3 βˆ’ 𝑦2 )2 (16) πœƒ = π‘π‘œπ‘  βˆ’1 ( ) 2π‘₯2 2 + 2(𝑦2 βˆ’ 𝑆𝑔 )2 + 2(𝛼𝑒)2 Recall that we have two x2, y2, x3, and y3 value sets corresponding to the upper and lower yarns. With ΞΈ solved for in radians the arc length can readily be solved for using the following equation: 𝐿𝐴𝑅𝐢 = π‘Ÿπœƒ (17) Note that there will be a slightly bigger angle for the lower yarns due to sagging. With LARC and Lhc defined and solved for the total elongated length of the yarn can be found easily: 𝐿 𝑇𝑂𝑇 = 2πΏβ„Žπ‘ + 𝐿𝐴𝑅𝐢 (18) Remember there will be two answers corresponding to the lower and upper yarns, we will describe those as 𝑳𝑻𝑢𝑻𝑳 and 𝑳𝑻𝑢𝑻𝑼 respectively. The lower yarn elongation can then be described simply as βˆ†πΏπΏ = 𝐿 𝑇𝑂𝑇𝐿 βˆ’ 2𝐿 (19) βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆ = 𝐿 π‘‡π‘‚π‘‡π‘ˆ βˆ’ 2𝐿 (20) Where previous equation in this section can be referenced describing each term in the equations. Forces and Geometry Having solved for the elongation of the yarn we can now readily calculate the force the yarn provides through this elongation. Using Hooke’s law and assuming elastic deformation the tension in the yarns can be calculated as follows: 𝐸𝐴 (21) 𝐹𝐿 = βˆ†πΏ 2𝐿 𝐿 𝐸𝐴 (22) πΉπ‘ˆ = βˆ†πΏ 2𝐿 π‘ˆ Where E is the Young’s modulus, A is the cross-sectional area of the yarn L is the inner hohlraum radius and Ξ”L is the yarn elongation. Recall the free body diagrams in Figure 3 depicts a very simple Free Body Diagram of a Tetracage target. There are 2 yarns on the bottom and 2 yarns on the top squeezing the capsule as it applies a greater force on the lower yarns due to gravity. The lower and upper yarns are assumed to be identical in geometry to their respective pair, and all yarns are assumed to be identical in mechanical properties using batch data. A closer look at the upper yarns allows us to solve for the angle the force in the yarns is applied: 9 Figure 9: Upper Yarn Geometry The same can be done for the lower yarns: Figure 10: Upper Yarn Geometry These figures yield the following equations: 𝑦2 βˆ’ π‘Ž βˆ’ 𝑆𝑔 (23) πœƒπ‘ˆ = π‘‘π‘Žπ‘›βˆ’1 ( ) π‘₯2 βˆ’ 𝐿 𝑦2 βˆ’ π‘Ž + 𝑆𝑔 (24) πœƒπΏ = π‘‘π‘Žπ‘›βˆ’1 ( ) π‘₯2 βˆ’ 𝐿 Now that πœ½π‘Ό and πœ½π‘³ are solved for we can determine the vertical component of the force, π‘­π‘³πŸ . Using Figure 3b these forces can be described as follows: 𝐹𝐿2 = 𝐹𝐿 𝑠𝑖𝑛(πœƒπΏ ) (25) πΉπ‘ˆ2 = πΉπ‘ˆ 𝑠𝑖𝑛(πœƒπ‘ˆ ) (26) To isolate only the forces helping keep the capsule in place vertically we must also use the angle ψ from Figure 8. The equation for ψ is as follows: 𝑒 (27) πœ“ = π‘‘π‘Žπ‘›βˆ’1 ( ) 𝑙 This angle then feeds into finally solving for 𝑭𝑳𝑻𝑢𝑻 and 𝑭𝑼𝑻𝑢𝑻 : 10 𝐹𝐿𝑇𝑂𝑇 = 2𝐹𝐿 sin(πœƒπΏ ) cos (πœ“) (28) πΉπ‘ˆπ‘‡π‘‚π‘‡ = 2πΉπ‘ˆ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆ ) cos (πœ“) (29) With everything solved for we can finally do a sum of forces on Figure 3a: βˆ‘ 𝐹𝑦 = 0 = 2𝐹𝐿𝑇𝑂𝑇 βˆ’ π‘Šπ‘ βˆ’ 2πΉπ‘ˆπ‘‡π‘‚π‘‡ (30) Where Wc corresponds to the weight of the capsule, which is a known value, and 𝑭𝑳𝑻𝑢𝑻 & 𝑭𝑼𝑻𝑢𝑻 are a function of all the equations we’ve built on in this document with the only unknown being Sg, the sag at room temperature in this case. This equation needs to be solved numerically. After numerically solving for sag, the value can be plugged into all the equations above to solve for elongation, forces, etc. This gives us an idea for the factors of safety present. Solving Yarn Coefficient of Thermal Expansion Solving for the yarn CTE is only possible given empirical results to back out values from. These empirical values show ~50 microns of sag at cryogenic temperature. The yarn is composed of a spindled forest of carbon nanotubes, and we will determine the total yarn CTE of this yarn as a system. The actual behavior of these yarns at cryo is not fully understood and poses many difficulties during cryogenic proofing, which during the most recent Tetracage target series of 2022-2023 posed significant problems. The added complexity of spindled yarns at cryo is they have been observed to have a tendency to wind/unwind with a shift in temperature, causing many adverse effects that are difficult to deal with. Due to the complexity of the yarn behavior at cryo, coupled with the empirical data available being from full target builds, solving for CTE is largely an estimate. Even so, two methods were developed that present similar results when numbers are tested. Complex Method Under cryogenic temperature the gold hohlraum shrinks in size more than the yarn, leading to the capsule sagging downwards. This change in system geometry impacts the 𝑭𝑳𝑻𝑢𝑻 /𝑭𝑼𝑻𝑢𝑻 values of Equation 30 by changing the angles and elongation of the yarn. What very conveniently doesn’t change from room temperature to cryo is Wc, the weight of the capsule. We can then build out equations as follows: π‘Šπ‘π‘π‘Ÿπ‘¦π‘œ = π‘Šπ‘π‘Ÿπ‘œπ‘œπ‘š (31) 𝐸𝑐 𝐴𝑐 𝐸𝑐 𝐴𝑐 𝐸𝐴 𝐸𝐴 (33) βˆ†πΏπΏπ‘ sin(πœƒπΏπ‘ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆπ‘ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆπ‘ ) = βˆ†πΏ sin(πœƒπΏ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆ ) 𝐿𝑐 𝐿𝑐 2𝐿 𝐿 2𝐿 π‘ˆ Where Ec is Young’s Modulus at cryo, Ac is yarn cross-sectional area at cryo, Lc is the hohlraum inner diameter at cryo, βˆ†π‘³π‘³π’„ & βˆ†π‘³π‘Όπ’„ are lower and upper yarn elongation at cryo respectively, and πœ½π‘³π’„ & πœ½π‘Όπ’„ 11 are lower and upper yarn angle at cryo respectively. Lc is the most important term in this equation as it is where we will pull out the yarn CTE using the known change in temperature, Ξ”T: 𝐿𝑐 = 2𝐿 + 𝐢𝑇𝐸 βˆ— βˆ†π‘‡ (34) Substituting Equation 34 into Equation 33 and solving for CTE yields: 𝐸𝑐 𝐴𝑐 βˆ†πΏπΏπ‘ sin(πœƒπΏπ‘ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆπ‘ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆπ‘ ) (35) 2𝐿 𝐸𝐴 [ ] βˆ’ 2𝐿 βˆ†πΏπΏ sin(πœƒπΏ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆ ) π›₯𝑇 And converting CTE to ppm/k by multiplying it by 106/2L yields: 𝐸𝑐 𝐴𝑐 βˆ†πΏπΏπ‘ sin(πœƒπΏπ‘ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆπ‘ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆπ‘ ) (36) ( 𝐸𝐴 [ ] βˆ’ 1) βˆ†πΏπΏ sin(πœƒπΏ ) βˆ’ βˆ†πΏπ‘ˆ sin(πœƒπ‘ˆ ) 𝐢𝑇𝐸 = βˆ— 106 π›₯𝑇 Simple Method The next method doesn’t consider the force balance. This method calculates the sag we would observe if the yarns stayed the same length at cryo temperatures then uses the ratio between this hypothetical and the observed empirical sag to develop a ratio between the yarns and the hohlraum CTE of 11.87 ppm/k. Figure 11 helps to depict the geometry at play: Figure 11: Simple Method Geometry Where the only new variable, x, corresponds to the sag that would be present if the yarn cte was zero. Because we said the yarn has a CTE of zero in this case the hypotenuse at this cryogenic state depicted is the same as the hypotenuse at room temperature, i.e. the case where the triangle has sides of just L, and d depicted in the very first figures. This leads to the following equation: 2 (37) π‘₯ = βˆ’π‘‘ Β± βˆšπ‘‘2 + 𝐿2 βˆ’ [𝐿(1 βˆ’ π‘π‘‘π‘’π‘”π‘œπ‘™π‘‘ )] Where we take the positive solution to solve for the sag if the yarn stayed the same length. This value of x can then be used in the following equation to solve for the cte: 12 50 (38) π‘π‘‘π‘’π‘¦π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘› = π‘π‘‘π‘’π‘”π‘œπ‘™π‘‘ (1 βˆ’ ) π‘₯ Where 50 microns is the empirical sag at cryo. Important Note + Future Work This document is the most up to date version of these calculations. Both the scanned handwork and the code are slightly outdated. Should this ever be used a new code should be made using these equations. The forces section is applicable to any type of yarn used, whereas the CTE section uses empirical data specific to the yarns we use for builds – this can vary with yarn process. These calculations can be expanded to modify parameters to determine yarn loads and system response for a given setup of a Tetracage target. The real test of Tetracage targets is the behavior under cryogenic conditions. The tents work so well in typical targets because they have a higher CTE than the hohlraums, meaning they tighten around the capsule holding it firm. Ideally we would want yarns that could do the same without becoming too tight and breaking. There are ample vibrations in a targets lifecycle as well from proofing, transporting, etc. and these are not captured in these calculations. 13