Hydrodynamic Analysis and Optimization of Aquantis Marine Turbine Cooperative Research and Development Final Report CRADA Number: CRD-23-24080 NLR Technical Contacts: Thanh Toan Tran, Stein Housner, and Will Wiley The National Laboratory of the Rockies is a national Technical Report laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, NLR/TP-5700-97259 Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation, January 2026 operated under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. This report is available at no cost from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR) at www.nlr.gov/publications. Hydrodynamic Analysis and Optimization of Aquantis Marine Turbine Cooperative Research and Development Final Report CRADA Number: CRD-23-24080 NLR Technical Contacts: Thanh Toan Tran, Stein Housner, and Will Wiley Suggested Citation Tran, Thanh Toan, Stein Housner, and Will Wiley. 2026. Hydrodynamic Analysis and Optimization of Aquantis Marine Turbine: Cooperative Research and Development Final Report, CRADA Number CRD-23-24080. Golden, CO: National Laboratory of the Rockies. NLR/TP-5700-97259. https://www.nlr.gov/docs/fy26osti/97259.pdf. The National Laboratory of the Rockies is a national Technical Report laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, NLR/TP-5700-97259 Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation, January 2026 operated under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. National Laboratory of the Rockies 15013 Denver West Parkway This report is available at no cost from the National Laboratory Golden, CO 80401 of the Rockies (NLR) at www.nlr.gov/publications. 303-275-3000 • www.nlr.gov This work was authored by the National Laboratory of the Rockies for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), operated under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. Funding provided by the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Water Power Technologies Office. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent the views of the DOE or the U.S. Government. This work was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, nor any of their contractors, subcontractors or their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or any third party’s use or the results of such use of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof or its contractors or subcontractors. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof, its contractors or subcontractors. This report was produced when the laboratory operated as the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). The laboratory is now the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR). This report is available at no cost from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR) at www.nlr.gov/publications. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) reports produced after 1991 and a growing number of pre-1991 documents are available free via www.OSTI.gov. Cover photos (clockwise from left): Josh Bauer, National Laboratory of the Rockies 61725; Visualization from National Laboratory of the Rockies Insight Center; Getty-181828180; Agata Bogucka, National Laboratory of the Rockies 91683; Dennis Schroeder, National Laboratory of the Rockies 51331; Werner Slocum, National Laboratory of the Rockies 67842. National Laboratory of the Rockies prints on paper that contains recycled content. Cooperative Research and Development Final Report Report Date: September 16, 2025 In accordance with requirements set forth in the terms of the CRADA agreement, this document is the CRADA final report, including a list of subject inventions, to be forwarded to the DOE Office of Scientific and Technical Information as part of the commitment to the public to demonstrate results of federally funded research. Parties to the Agreement: Aquantis, Inc. CRADA Number: CRD-23-24080 CRADA Title: Hydrodynamic Analysis and Optimization of Aquantis Marine Turbine Period of Performance: 11/1/2023 – 8/1/2025 Responsible Technical Contacts at NLR: Thanh Toan Tran | thanhtoan.tran@nlr.gov Stein Housner | stein.housner@nlr.gov Will Wiley | will.wiley@nlr.gov Name and Email Address of POC at Company: Henry Swales | hswales@aquantistech.com Sponsoring DOE Program Office(s): Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE), Water Power Technologies Office Joint Work Statement Funding Table showing DOE commitment: NLR Shared Resources Estimated Costs a/k/a Government In-Kind Year 1 $135,000.00 TOTALS $135,000.00 1 Executive Summary of CRADA Work: The primary aim of this proposal is to improve the accurate prediction of hydrodynamic performance and dynamic load responses of the AQ10 floating axial-flow tidal turbine with a tri- cat mooring configuration. The validation of reduced-order modeling approaches with high- fidelity model will be implemented. Additionally, the frequency response domain, Response Amplitude Floating Wind (RAFT) toolbox plus an optimizer expanded for marine hydrokinetic turbines under the Submarine Hydrokinetic And Riverine Kilo-megawatt. Systems (SHARKS) program will be used for designing and exploring different key design parameters (platform dimension, mooring layout and its parameters) of next marine hydrokinetic (MHK) turbine generation. CRADA benefit to DOE, Participant, and US Taxpayer: • Assists laboratory in achieving programmatic scope • Uses the laboratory’s core competencies • Enhances U.S. competitiveness by utilizing DOE developed intellectual property and/or capabilities. Summary of Research Results: Task 1: Aquantis will provide the latest 3D CAD model of AQ10 floating tidal turbine system. Additionally, Aquantis in coordination with Contractor (NLR) will provide necessary inputs such as desirable design load cases at a specific site condition, interesting mooring design configuration and its properties. Both NLR and Aquantis will identify desired design parameters and objectives for the system exploration and optimization. Task 1 Results: The Aquantis team provided a floating platform design concept (shown in Figure 1) that was fully submerged in water, in contrast to previous Aquantis designs, and modeled the structural geometry of their tidal turbine in TidalBladed. Using data from TidalBladed on node and member properties (e.g., lengths, diameters, thicknesses, point masses, ballast), as well as the rotor and mooring system, we developed an initial design in the Response Amplitudes of Floating Turbines (RAFT) code [1]. Both teams also collaborated to identify potential optimization parameters in RAFT. Figure 2 shows a graphic of the floating tidal platform, including the identified optimization parameters. The fairlead position in the x-direction has four different parameterization options. The fore and aft mooring lines can either (1) attach at the same point, with that fairlead position varied, (2) attach at different points represented as positions equally spaced from the x fairlead location (fairlead x spread), or (3) attach at completely independent points (fore fairlead position and aft fairlead position). The mooring line diameter and length are also treated as independent variables, though not shown in Figure 2. Other mooring line properties such as mass, stiffness, and strength are treated as functions of the line diameter. 2 A design load case with a rated current speed of 2.0 m/s and a JONSWAP wave spectrum, characterized by a significant wave height of 2 m and a peak wave period of 8 s, was selected to optimize the system in this study. Fig. 1. An initial design concept of the Aquantis tidal turbine design via TidalBladed’s graphic. Fig. 2. Aquantis tidal turbine parameterization scheme Task 2. NLR will create a 3-D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) baseline model using the input conditions provided by Aquantis. NLR will quantify simulation uncertainties including spatial and temporal discretization. Task 2 Results: The NLR developed multiple CFD simulation models, including 2D airfoils and 3D turbine blades, with and without the floating platform geometry, to verify and compare against Open- source Fast Aeroelastic Simulation Tool (OpenFAST) simulation results. Figure 3 shows the cross-section of the computational domain and the spatial mesh resolution of the turbine surface for the turbine-only case. Since mesh resolution strongly affects predicted turbine performance and loads, it should be carefully validated to balance computational accuracy and cost. Details of the mesh resolution for different mesh cases shown in Figure 3 are provided in Table 1. 3 Figure 4 presents the 3D numerical simulation outputs (including rotating torque and thrust) for different grid resolutions and their comparison to OpenFAST simulations under the same condition: a current speed of 2.0 m/s and a rotational speed of 12 rpm. A temporal study was also conducted to ensure the timestep size was specified to achieve convergence of both rotor performance and loads, as well as wave propagation in the 3D computational domain. Mesh A Mesh B Mesh C Mesh D Fig. 3. A graphic of CFD domain and its spatial mesh resolutions on the Aquantis’s turbine surface 4 Table 1. A detail of mesh resolution settings Turbine Surface Size Total Cells Mesh Cases Base size (m) Min. (m) Max. (m) (millions) Mesh A 0.2 0.01250 0.02500 6.5 Mesh B 0.28 0.01750 0.01750 3.6 Mesh C 0.2 0.01250 0.01250 8.0 Mesh D 0.14 0.00875 0.00875 16.1 Fig. 4. A spatial convergence study of the Aquantis turbine and its comparison to OpenFAST result (Only turbine case with the current flow of 2.0 m/s and rotating speed of 12 rpm) Task 3: NLR will verify 3-D CFD simulation considering fixed platform conditions and compare OpenFAST and/or Tidal Bladed’s outputs which have been simulated and/or will be simulated by NLR and Aquantis, respectively. NLR will then run massive 3-D CFD simulations considering full floating platform turbine system. Task 3 Results: In addition to the comparison results shown in Figure 4, a comparison of the turbine-only case under the rated condition of an inflow current of 2.1 m/s and a rotational speed of 24 rpm was conducted. Figure 5 presents the comparison between the two fidelity codes. Overall, similar to the previous comparison, there is good agreement between the two codes for the turbine-only case. 5 Fig. 5. A comparison of turbine torque and thrust between CFD and OpenFAST results (Only turbine case with the rated condition of the current flow of 2.1 m/s and rotating speed of 24 rpm) (left) and a flow contour around a turbine cross-sectional plane and its blade-tip vorticity. The CFD simulation of the fully floating marine turbine support structure was conducted by coupling the STAR-CCM+ code with the MoorDyn solver [2]. For this full configuration, different CFD simulations were performed and compared with OpenFAST simulation results. For example, heave and surge free-decay tests were carried out to provide a comparison between the two codes. Task 4: NLR will do data post-processing to quantify net power, dynamic loads, mooring tension for provided simulation inputs. Task 4 Results: Figures 6 and 7 shows an example of 3D CFD simulation outputs for full floating marine turbine configuration. The simulation was conducted by coupling by STAR-CCM+ CFD code and open- source mooring solver, MoorDyn. Due to its bridle mooring configuration (not shown in the graphic), the existing mooring solver in within the CFD code was not able to model it. Fig. 6. An example of dynamic platform responses of the Aquantis’s platform marine turbine considering a combined wave - current condition. 6 Fig. 7. A flow contour at a cross-sectional plane for a CFD simulation including the whole platform + turbine as well as the representation of blade-tip vorticity. Task 5: NLR will create a baseline model using Response Amplitude of Floating Turbines (RAFT) code. NLR will also create a Python interface between frequency domain, RAFT and an optimizer like OpenMDAO or scipy.optimize libraries. Task 5 Results: The initial RAFT model, built from the TidalBladed input provided by the Aquantis team, is shown in Figure 7. However, this initial RAFT design could not be simulated under the rated current speed of 2.0 m/s and a JONSWAP wave spectrum with a significant wave height of 2 m and a peak wave period of 8 s without encountering numerical instability. This indicates that the modeling processes within RAFT could not establish a natural equilibrium of the platform under loaded conditions, where the net forces cancel to zero. This likely meant that the forces exerted on the platform (from the rotor, mooring system, buoyancy, etc.) were too large compared to the corresponding stiffness of the platform. After many optimization runs of this initial RAFT design to find a feasible solution under loaded conditions, a few changes were made to better represent the system and enable the optimizer to find valid solutions. Fig. 8. RAFT representations of the Aquantis tidal turbine design 7 In this work, the NLR team also built an interface to couple RAFT with the optimization solver OpenMDAO (shown in Figure 9). Two different options were explored: building a framework around OpenMDAO or developing custom design optimization scripts. We ultimately decided to use the OpenMDAO environment to develop an optimization framework coupled with RAFT. We found that the programming setup time would be similar for both options, but the existing features within OpenMDAO would enable more effective design exploration and better organization. We also concluded that the objects within OpenMDAO are better suited for this coupled design optimization problem, which involves evaluating both floating platform structural variables and mooring system variables. Task 6: NLR will conduct parameter exploration for different design parameters like platform dimension, mooring configuration, turbine blades, etc. Additionally, NLR will do data postprocessing and analysis. Task 6 Results: Optimization runs with the SLSQP optimization algorithm (gradient-based) typically produced designs that were fairly similar to their initial settings (which is why making the baseline design as accurate as possible was important). We tested many different initial conditions for SLSQP- based design optimization, but most failed to converge because they began in infeasible regions of the design space. Optimization runs with the ALPSO optimization algorithm (gradient-free) generated some feasible designs but required several hours to converge; and when the convergence criteria were relaxed, the algorithm did not always return feasible designs. Including ballast parameters as design variables made convergence difficult for most optimizers. When a feasible design was found, we then added more constraints to better model realistic configurations. Fig. 9. A high-level flowchart of how the OpenMDAO framework works After continued iterations of optimization runs, design explorations, and RAFT model development, we determined that the primary cause of numerical instability in RAFT was that the hydrodynamic forces on the rotor were too large relative to the system stiffness. Once we manually adjusted the stiffness—primarily through the mooring system in the yaw degree of freedom—the baseline design could successfully run through RAFT at rated conditions. We achieved this by adjusting two variables: the distance between the fore and aft fairleads, and the increase in fairlead distance away from the platform (laterally and vertically). The parameters of this adjusted baseline design are shown in Table 2 under “Design (b).” 8 Including new design variables, such as the spread of fairlead locations, in the optimization toolset yielded feasible designs. The optimized version of the adjusted baseline design (Design (b)) is shown in Table 2 under “Design (c).” The optimized results using the same design variables but with additional structural members connecting the fairlead attachment points to the main platform are shown in Table 2 under “Design (d).” The optimized results for the same system without an upper pod are shown under “Design (e),” while the optimized results of the same design under rated conditions—from left-to-right as well as right-to-left—are shown under “Design (f).” Diagrams of these designs are provided in Figure 10. (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Fig. 10. RAFT diagrams of the optimized tidal turbine designs under different optimization settings 9 Table 2. Design optimization and exploration results of the Aquantis marine turbine Design Design Design Design Design Design (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Design (Independent) Variables Upper Pod Diameter (m) 1.5 1.5 1.70 2.73 - - Lower Pod Diameter (m) 3.30 4.0 Lower Pod Length (m) 10.68 10.68 6.70 7.20 6.74 6.7 Upper Pod Position (m) 0.25 0.2 -1.01 0.25 - - Fairlead X (m) -1.917 -2.0 -4.97 - - - Fairlead X Spread (m) 0.0 4.0 5.0 - - - Fore Fairlead X (m) - - - -2.25 -1.79 -1.75 Aft Fairlead X (m) - - - 2.85 2.84 2.96 Fairlead Y (m) 1.2 10.0 10.0 4.38 3.22 1.28 Fairlead Z (m) -9.2 -9.2 -9.2 -11.22 -9.7 -13.06 Line Diameter (mm) 50 50 10.1 23.9 22.3 39.9 Line Mass Density (kg/m) 0.5 0.5 Line Length (m) 110 110 106.6 110.9 111.5 111.0 Dependent Variables Ballast Fill Level (m) 1.5 3.15 0.1 0.83 1.35 1.5 Ballast Fill Density (kg/m3) 6,125 2,239 1,000 7,850 3,125 1,460 Constraints Unloaded Mean Heave (m) 0.05 2.60 -1.11 1.38 0.87 1.37 Unloaded Mean Pitch (deg) 0.01 -0.08 5.04 3.88 3.57 2.57 Loaded Mean Surge (m) *3.08 21.81 4.54 1.88 -0.55 **1.47 Loaded Mean Sway (m) *-0.48 -1.70 0.04 -0.23 -0.25 **-0.22 Loaded Mean Heave (m) *0.15 -20.49 0.14 0.20 0.80 **1.10 Loaded Mean Roll (deg) *2.63 5.47 1.36 2.13 3.34 **1.28 Loaded Mean Pitch (deg) *-0.59 -8.14 -7.16 9.29 -1.25 **9.42 Loaded Mean Yaw (deg) *-0.74 0.30 -0.20 0.56 -0.23 **0.26 Rotor Plane Intersection - 6.46 7.10 0.87 0.03 **0.16 Margin Line 1 (m) Rotor Plane Intersection - 6.52 7.25 0.79 0.14 **0.13 Margin Line 1 (m) Objectives Steel Mass (t) 9.486 9.486 7.310 12.933 8.898 10.754 *run with 0.8 m/s current and 2m-8s JONSWAP waves **results of the conventional load case with currents and waves traveling from left to right. The other load case (with currents traveling from right to left) had similar outputs 10 More details of result finding and discussion can be found in the post-access report uploaded to the Testing Expertise and Access for Marine Energy Research (TEAMER) portal. Task 7: NLR will post access report including simulation input and data at the end of the project. Aquantis will review, edit, and submit it to MHKDR portal. Task 7 Results: At the end of this TEAMER project, the Aquantis team will upload all data coming out from this project to the Marine and Hydrokinetic Data Repository (MHK DR) portal. When the final technical report is approved by TEAMER committee, the Aquantis team will upload these data per request. Task 8: Additional Tasks - NLR will perform other work at the direction of Aquantis, consistent with the scope and subject to the availability of funding. Task 8 Results: Both the Aquantis and NLR have closely collaborated throughout this TEAMER project as well as the (Submarine Hydrokinetic And Riverine Kilo-megawatt Systems) SHARKS project. The CFD simulation results presented in this work were the outcome of this close communication which the platform geometry design was designed and delivered to the NLR team but not conducted by this TEAMER support. Task 9: The Parties will prepare a CRADA Final Report: Preparation and submission in accordance with the terms of this agreement. Task 9 Results: This report serves to meet the requirement for the CRADA Final Report with preparation and submission in accordance with the agreement’s Article X. References: [1] M. Hall, S. Housner, S. Sirnivas, and S. Wilson, “MoorPy (Quasi-Static Mooring Analysis in Python),” National Laboratory of the Rockies. (NLR), Golden, CO (United States), MoorPy, Jul. 2021. doi: 10.11578/dc.20210726.1. [2] Tran, TT, Ross, H, Wiley, W, Wang, L, & Sirnivas, S. "High- and Mid-Fidelity Modeling Comparison for a Floating Marine Turbine System." Proceedings of the ASME 2024 43rd International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering. Volume 7: Ocean Renewable Energy. Singapore, Singapore. June 9–14, 2024. V007T09A088. ASME Subject Inventions Listing: None. ROI#: None. 11