Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determinations for Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Modules: A Foundational Study Taylor L. Curtis, Ligia E.P. Smith, and Rebekah Townsend National Laboratory of the Rockies The National Laboratory of the Rockies is a national Technical Report laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, NLR/TP-6A20-96847 Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation, January 2026 operated under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. This report is available at no cost from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR) at www.nlr.gov/publications. Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determinations for Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Modules: A Foundational Study Taylor L. Curtis, Ligia E.P. Smith, and Rebekah Townsend National Laboratory of the Rockies Suggested Citation Curtis, Taylor L., Ligia E.P. Smith, and Rebekah Townsend. 2026. Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determinations for Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Modules: A Foundational Study. Golden, CO: National Laboratory of the Rockies. NLR/TP-6A20-96847. https://www.nlr.gov/docs/fy26osti/96847.pdf. The National Laboratory of the Rockies is a national Technical Report laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, NLR/TP-6A20-96847 Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation, January 2026 operated under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. National Laboratory of the Rockies 15013 Denver West Parkway This report is available at no cost from the National Laboratory Golden, CO 80401 of the Rockies (NLR) at www.nlr.gov/publications. 303-275-3000 • www.nlr.gov (CTDEEP) • Noa Klein, Hawaii State Department of Health (HISDH) • Matt Muller, NLR • Mitch Matthews, Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OHEPA) • Dustin Mulvaney, San José State University (SJSU) • Jonathan Jennings and Tom Cusack, Washington State Department of Ecology (WADE). v List of Acronyms As Arsenic Ag Silver ASU-PRL Arizona State University Photovoltaic Reliability Laboratory Ba Barium BOMs Bills of Material Cd Cadmium Cr Chromium CdTe Cadmium Telluride CODPHE Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment CTDEEP Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection c-Si Crystalline Silicon Cu Copper CPU Central Processing Unit DC Direct Current DOE U.S. Department of Energy DTSC Department of Toxic Substances Control EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPRI Electric Power Research Institute GW Gigawatt Hg Mercury HISDH Hawaii State Department of Health IEC International Electrotechnical Commission Kg Kilogram Mo Molybdenum MPCA Minnesota Pollution Control Agency Mt Million tonnes MW Megawatt NCDEQ North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality NLR National Laboratory of the Rockies NSF National Science Foundation NYSDEC New York State Department of Environmental Conservation OHEPA Ohio Environmental Protection Agency O&M Operation and Maintenance Pb Lead PFAS Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances PV Photovoltaic RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 ReMA Recycled Materials Association SDSs Safety Data Sheets Se Selenium SETO Solar Energy Technologies Office SEIA Solar Energy Industries Association SERI Sustainable Electronics Recycling International SJSU San José State University TCA Total Constituent Analysis vi TCLP Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure UFLPA Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act UV Ultraviolet WADE Washington State Department of Ecology XRF X-Ray Fluorescence Zn Zinc vii Executive Summary This report explores the use of “generator knowledge” to determine whether a solar photovoltaic (PV) module must be managed as hazardous waste prior to recycling or disposal.1 Generator knowledge is a legal term and existing regulatory pathway for making a hazardous waste determination that has been used by other industries but is a relatively unknown option to the PV industry (EPA 2025a).2 In the United States, unless an exclusion or an alternative management standard applies, a hazardous waste determination is required before recycling or landfilling a PV module. The results of the hazardous waste determination dictate whether the PV module must be managed as hazardous or nonhazardous solid waste (Section 1). The person or persons who decide to remove a PV module from service and recycle or dispose of it are the “generator(s)” and regulated person(s) who have generated waste and are subject to U.S. federal and state solid and hazardous waste law pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (RCRA) and RCRA regulations (EPA 2025a; 2025b).3 Absent an applicable exclusion or alternative management standard, the regulated person (e.g., asset owner) must either: • Manage the PV module as hazardous waste in compliance with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste law or • Conduct a hazardous waste determination to demonstrate whether the PV module is safe to manage as nonhazardous solid waste or whether it must be managed as hazardous waste (EPA 2025a).4 Managing a PV module as hazardous waste requires compliance with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste laws. Hazardous waste regulations, in every U.S. jurisdiction, mandate accumulation, handling, storage, transport, and treatment requirements and restrictions prior to recycling or landfilling a PV module.5 Hazardous waste regulations, for example, set weight- based accumulation limits and time constraints on how long PV modules may be accumulated before being transported to a recycler or landfill.6 Hazardous waste law may also mandate 1 RCRA, in relevant part, defines “solid waste” to include “other discarded material.” EPA regulations define “discarded material” as materials that are “disposed of,” “burned or incinerated,” “accumulated, stored or treated before or in lieu of being abandoned by being disposed of, burned or incinerated,” “sham recycled,” or “accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling.” This means, by definition and EPA guidance, PV modules that are accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling or disposal are “solid waste” unless an exclusion applies (42 U.S.C § 6903(27); 40 C.F.R. §§ 261.2(a)-(c); EPA 2025a). 2 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d). 3 40 C.F.R. § 260.10 (definition of generator); 45 Fed. Reg. 72024 (1980) (concerns co-generators, clarifying multiple persons or entities can be considered generators of hazardous waste and thus jointly and severally liable for compliance); 45 Fed. Reg. 72026 (1980) (clarifies that when two or more entities or persons share in generating hazardous waste, a mutual agreement can designate which person(s) is the primary generator responsible for compliance). 4 40 C.F.R. § 262.11. 5 40 C.F.R. §§ 262, 265, 268, 270. 6 For example, managing 6 to 55 PV modules per month (assuming each module weighs 40 pounds) prior to recycling or landfilling may cause a person to be regulated as a small quantity generator (SQG). Under federal law, viii personnel training, labeling, shipping, reporting, recordkeeping, and additional permit requirements, and may trigger U.S. Department of Transportation hazardous material regulation if transported off-site.7 In addition to higher management costs––which can be up to 10 times greater than those for nonhazardous solid waste management8––legal liability for PV modules regulated as hazardous waste is also elevated. Civil penalties for noncompliance9 may include violations for “making an inaccurate or faulty hazardous waste determination”10 (Ruhlin 2024; Losurdo 2022). To demonstrate that a PV module can be safely managed as nonhazardous before recycling or landfilling, the regulated person must make an accurate hazardous waste determination to assess whether the PV module exhibits any hazardous characteristics (i.e., ignitability, corrosivity, reactivity, or toxicity).11 The most common reason a PV module is regulated as hazardous is the presence of a regulated metal at a leachable concentration that equals or exceeds the toxicity characteristic regulatory limits (EPA 2025a; Curtis 2021a; Curtis 2021b). Today, commercially available crystalline silicon (c-Si) and cadmium telluride thin-film (CdTe) PV modules may contain trace amounts of regulated metals, with lead (Pb) in c-Si technologies and cadmium (Cd) in thin-film modules the most likely to be detected in waste characterization tests, with some modules exceeding regulatory thresholds (TamizhMani et al., 2021; 2018; Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019; Li et al. 2024; 2025). To conduct a hazardous waste determination, the regulated person must either “apply knowledge [of the PV module] ... in light of the materials and processes used,” “test” the PV module using Test Method 1311 (Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure [TCLP]), or an equivalent EPA- approved method, or use “a combination of both” knowledge and testing.12 Acceptable knowledge for a hazardous waste determination includes: • “Process knowledge (e.g., information about the chemical feedstocks and other inputs to the production process) • Knowledge of products, byproducts, and intermediates produced by the manufacturing process • Chemical or physical characterization of the waste an SQG is restricted from accumulating more than 329 PV modules (less than 6,000 kilograms) on-site at any time. A permit is required to store PV modules for more than 180 days or 270 days if they must be transported more than 200 miles for treatment, recycling, or disposal (40 C.F.R. § 262.16(b)(1)-(d); EPA 2025j). 7 For example: 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.16(b)(9)(iii); 262.17(a)(7) (personnel training requirement); 40 C.F.R. Part 262 subpart B (manifest required by U.S. Department of Transportation and EPA); 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.30 -.33 (pre- transport packaging and labeling); 40 C.F.R. § 262.41 (biennial reporting for large quantity generators); 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11(f); 262.40(a), (d) (recordkeeping); 40 C.F.R. Part 264 (permit and other requirements for treatment, storage and disposal facilities, which apply to third-party recyclers); EPA 2025j; EPA 2025k. 8 Nonhazardous waste management can range from $500 to $5,000 annually, whereas hazardous waste management prices range from $2,000 to $50,000 annually (Ruhlin 2024). Transport costs alone can more than double when managing hazardous waste compared to nonhazardous waste (Losurdo 2022). 9 42 U.S.C. § 6928(a)–(g). 10 40 C.F.R. § 262.11, emphasis added. 11 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11; 261.3(a)(2); 261.10; 261.20–.24. 12 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11(d); 262.11(d)(1)–(2) (To date, Test Method 1311 TCLP is the only EPA-approved laboratory-based analytical test method for determining whether a PV module exhibits the characteristic of toxicity). ix • Information on the chemical and physical properties of the chemicals used or produced by the process or otherwise contained in the waste • Testing that illustrates the properties of the waste • Other reliable and relevant information about the properties of the waste or its constituents.”13 When available knowledge is inadequate to make an accurate determination, the PV module must be tested using Test Method 1311 TCLP or an equivalent EPA-approved method (EPA 2025a).14 Although Test Method 1311 is the primary regulatory compliance pathway currently used to determine whether PV modules are hazardous waste, three main challenges raise both practical and potential legal liability concerns. First, there is no U.S. federal or state regulatory guidance that describes how to develop a scientifically credible sampling plan specific to PV modules––such as specifying how many modules must be tested to characterize the average properties of a batch or installation.15 Under this regulatory pathway (40 C.F.R. 262.11(d)(2)), a sampling plan would be expected to define the purpose of the data and the PV modules to which the results apply, so a hazardous waste determination could be construed by a regulator to apply only to the PV modules and TCLP results covered by that sampling plan (EPA 2025l; 2002; 1986).16 Second, conducting TCLP testing on even a fraction of the modules within a single large-scale project may not be practical (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024). At approximately $550 to $3,000 per module, TCLP testing even 5%–10% of PV modules in a 100-megawatt (MW) utility-scale system installed in the early 2000s could cost on the order of $10 million to more than $100 million.17 Third, variability in TCLP results for PV modules––exceeding 50% in some studies––has raised concerns for those legally responsible for making accurate hazardous waste determinations (TamizhMani et al. 2021; 2018; Libby and Shaw 2018; Warren 2022).18 As 13 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d); Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. at 85,752. 14 40 C.F.R. §262.11(d)(2); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66261.24; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-090(8)(a); Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. at 85,752. To date, Test Method 1311 TCLP is the only EPA-approved laboratory-based analytical test method for determining whether a PV module exhibits the characteristic of toxicity. 15 40 C.F.R. § 260.10 (definition of representative sample means a sample of a universe or whole which can be expected to exhibit the average properties of the universe or whole); EPA 2002 (waste sampling plan guidance). Although EPA has not developed sampling-plan guidance for specific waste streams, it has general waste sampling guidance and recommends replicating testing and using the upper confidence limit of the mean to reduce risk of erroneous hazardous waste determinations and resulting mismanagement (email communication [EPA ORCR 2025]). 16 Consistent with EPA’s Data Quality Objectives framework and SW-846 sampling guidance, the applicability of sampling data is defined by the intended use of the data, the decision unit or population of interest, and the spatial, temporal, and material boundaries for which the results are representative (EPA 2006; EPA 2025l). 17 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022), SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022), and EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022) found the cost to conduct TCLP testing from start to finish ranges between $1,850 and $3,000 per module. Based on cost information from a recent EPA project, estimated TCLP testing costs varied by particle size– reduction technique, with mechanical size reduction estimated at $547.50 per sample and waterjet cutting estimated at $1,897.50 per sample (email communication [EPA ORCR 2025]). A typical 100-MW utility-scale system installed in the early 2000s has approximately 352,000 PV modules (email communication with Smith [2023]; Ramasamy et al. [2022]; Feldman [2021]). 18 TCLP test results variability for c-Si PV modules has been shown to exceed 50% (TamizhMani et al. 2018; 2021) and as much as 32% for CdTe PV modules (TamizhMani et al. 2021). x a result, anecdotal evidence suggests some asset owners manage PV modules as hazardous waste despite passing TCLP test results that would otherwise qualify them for management under less stringent and less costly nonhazardous waste regulation (PVQAT 2023).19 Given the challenges associated with Test Method 1311, solar industry members are calling for a regulatory solution that is both reliable and scalable (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024).20 21 Although PV module hazardous waste determinations are a relatively new regulatory consideration in the United States—because 72% of all installed modules are fewer than 7 years old—these challenges are escalating quickly (Wood Mackenzie 2025d). The number of PV modules reaching an end-of-life management decision is projected to increase nearly 31-fold, from fewer than 1 million in 2024 to 31 million by 2035, and to 157 million by 2045 (Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025). Regulators are beginning to prepare for this surge. At the same time, U.S. recyclers caution that ongoing uncertainty over whether PV modules must be managed as hazardous waste prior to recycling—and the potential resulting compliance burdens—may impede domestic resource recovery opportunities (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024).22 This study finds knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations are an existing regulatory compliance pathway that may offer a scalable framework to address current challenges in making hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. 23 24 Under this approach, a regulated person may rely on multiple lines of evidence to characterize PV modules over time, drawing from diverse sources and forms of information rather than relying solely on contemporaneous Test Method 1311 laboratory testing. For example, knowledge-based determinations may incorporate previously conducted TCLP results or other relevant and verifiable data—such as information from published studies, databases, or product labels—and apply those results to other PV modules with comparable designs or material compositions. This approach may allow PV modules to be characterized using representative data collected at different points in time, across installations or batches, or among identical or substantially similar PV module types, provided the information is relevant, reliable, and verifiable. It may also reduce the need for 19 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); formerly Cascade Eco Minerals (Spivey 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022); SERI (De Vries 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 20 NSF SOLAR’s working group—comprising more than 100 diverse stakeholders—identified hazardous waste compliance challenges as a key barrier to PV module resource recovery in the United States. Specifically, the group emphasized the need for a reliable and scalable regulatory pathway for hazardous waste determinations to support compliance, reduce legal liability concerns, and lessen regulatory burdens associated with PV module end-of-life management (Siegfried et al. 2024). 21 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Cascade Eco Minerals (Spivey 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022); SERI (De Vries 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 22 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022), SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022), Cascade Eco Minerals (Spivey 2022). 23 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 22 CCR § 66262.11; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d); 30 TAC § 335.504(a)(3)(A). 24 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). For this study, a former EPA staff member (Helms 2022) is considered a nonregulatory technical expert and is not represented in Figure ES-1. xi repetitive, generator-specific (e.g., site-by-site, batch-by-batch) analytical laboratory testing by enabling the development and use of broader, industry-level datasets, potentially lowering costs and improving scalability across assets (e.g., multiple large-scale installations owned by one utility), products, and markets. Because knowledge-based determinations are not required to use Test Method 1311, this regulatory compliance pathway may also create opportunities for innovation—such as developing tailored analytical testing methods, shared databases, or decision-support tools specific to the solar industry. Collectively, these preliminary findings suggest knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations could enhance transparency and support scalable regulatory compliance for PV module end-of-life management. If broadly implemented, this compliance pathway could potentially drive cost-effective, innovative, and reliable industry solutions. However, as a foundational study, additional research and regulatory engagement are critical to ensure the feasibility of robust and reliable application and regulator acceptance and to evaluate the limitations associated with this approach. As a case of first impression for the solar industry, the authors conducted legal research to determine whether “generator knowledge” could serve as a viable regulatory compliance pathway for end-of-life PV modules (i.e., PV modules with no potential for reuse that will be recycled or landfilled). The team then developed and tested hypotheses through interviews with more than 45 experts, including regulators from EPA and state agencies in Colorado, Connecticut, Minnesota, North Carolina, New York, Ohio, Washington, and Wisconsin (see Appendix A for Methodology details). Insights from these interviews—and input from additional subject matter experts (see Acknowledgments)—informed the analysis of how “generator knowledge” may be applied to PV modules to conduct a hazardous waste determination. This work establishes an initial framework for interpreting and applying knowledge-based determinations for PV modules, identifies potential constraints and limitations to this compliance approach, and highlights areas requiring additional research. The study’s findings provide an initial foundation for evaluating knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. As the first legal analysis of its kind, this research indicates “generator knowledge” may offer a viable regulatory pathway to streamline compliance, support safe and responsible end-of-life management, and strengthen domestic recycling efforts for PV modules. Improving the ability to accurately determine whether PV modules exhibit hazardous characteristics at scale could also help address broader toxicity concerns impacting the solar industry.25 However, as a foundational study, additional research, stakeholder engagement, and consensus building are needed to further assess whether knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations are a desirable regulatory compliance approach for the solar industry. Key findings derived from the legal hypotheses developed in this 25 PV module toxicity concerns have been linked, at least in part, to growing opposition to PV development in the United States, including delays and cancellations of projects. Policy adoption unfavorable to PV development has also been linked, at least in part, to PV module toxicity, which includes PV module technology bans and development moratoriums (Scherzinger 2021; Eisenson 2023). Anecdotal evidence suggests toxicity concerns are also leading to requests developers prove PV modules are not toxic prior to installation as a condition for a permit/approval required for initial development (PVQAT 2023). xii study (shown in bold) 26 and evaluated through engagement with subject matter experts are summarized in Figure ES-1 and include: • Acceptable knowledge can be used instead of an EPA/state-approved test method (Test Method 1311 TCLP) to make an accurate hazardous waste determination for PV modules. Recent EPA guidance and regulators interviewed from five state agencies agreed that acceptable knowledge, as described in 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1), and parallel state regulatory provisions, may serve as an alternative to TCLP (Method 1311) testing for PV module hazardous waste determinations.27 Analysis of regulations in four additional states—Arizona, California, Oregon, and Texas—similarly indicates support for the use of acceptable knowledge in lieu of an EPA/state-approved test method.28 Notably, regulators from another state reported in 2022 that, although acceptable knowledge could theoretically serve as an alternative to TCLP testing, they did not yet consider it a viable option for PV modules because of insufficiently detailed manufacturing data and the absence of comprehensive TCLP result databases or other reliable sources of acceptable knowledge. However, they expressed optimism that the acceptable knowledge pathway could become viable for the industry in the future.29 As EPA has clarified, “…a test other than [Test Method 1311] or an equivalent [EPA or state] approved test . . . may be used as part of a person’s knowledge to determine whether [a PV module] exhibits a characteristic of hazardous waste. However, such tests do not, by themselves, provide definitive results.”30 • A knowledge-based hazardous waste determination may use a wide range of sources and forms of information from both manufacturers and third-party sources. Federal regulators and regulators from six state agencies interviewed agreed with this hypothesis, which is further supported by regulatory guidance in three additional states––Indiana, Oregon, and Washington.31 Acceptable knowledge for a PV module hazardous waste determination may include compositional information and testing data (e.g., previously conducted TCLP test results) presented in various forms such as bills of material 26 Analysis findings of U.S. federal and state statutes, regulations, case law, and regulatory agency guidance and interviews with EPA and state regulators in Colorado, Connecticut, Minnesota, North Carolina, New York, Ohio, Washington, and Wisconsin support these hypotheses. 27 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022). Recent EPA guidance, along with follow-up confirmation from EPA staff, supports this hypothesis and is reflected in Figure ES-1 (EPA Region 5 [Newman 2022]; EPA 2025a). 28 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 30 TAC § 335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102- 0011. 29 NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). NC DEQ’s response is not incorporated in Figure ES-1 because of a temporal limitation not reflected in the hypothesis. 30 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC § 335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d). 31 Communication with EPA Headquarters (ORCR 2023). Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); former EPA staff (Helms 2022). xiii (BOMs), safety data sheets (SDSs),32 product labels,33 and published studies34 and databases35 (EPA 2015a; IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023). • Regulators expect information used to make an accurate knowledge-based hazardous waste determination to be detailed, reliable, and relevant. Federal regulators and regulators from eight state agencies interviewed agreed these three factors are essential to making an accurate knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules.36 Regulatory agency guidance from three additional states—Indiana, Oregon, and Wisconsin—also supports this hypothesis. To be considered detailed, information must be sufficient to determine if the PV module contains a regulated metal(s), and if so, whether the regulated metal(s) concentration(s) equals or exceeds U.S. federal and/or state regulatory toxicity limits (IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023).37 Reliability requires that information be conclusive and verifiable (EPA 2025h; IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023).38 Finally, information must be relevant to the specific PV module being recycled or disposed of (EPA 2015a; IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017).39 • Historical information may be used to make an accurate knowledge-based hazardous waste determination if it is relevant and verifiable. Federal regulators and regulators from seven state agencies interviewed agreed with this hypothesis, which is further supported by regulatory guidance in two additional states––Indiana and Oregon.40 Historical information––defined as information generated before a hazardous waste 32 Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 33 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). Communication with MPCA (Gilkeson and Cotton 2023). 34 Interviews with CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); former EPA staff (Helms 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022). 35 Interviews with CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022). 36 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); communication with MPCA (Gilkeson and Cotton 2023); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022). 37 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); interviews with WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022). 38 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); communication with MPCA (Gilkeson and Cotton 2023). 39 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR 40 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR xiv determination is made, rather than contemporaneous or newly generated data about a PV module once it becomes a regulated solid waste––may be relevant in determining whether another PV module(s) is hazardous (IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017; EPA 2015a).41 However, regulators and technical experts cautioned that factors such as the age and condition of PV modules may affect the relevance of historical information used for a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination.42 • Information about one PV module may be used to make an accurate knowledge- based hazardous waste determination for other PV modules if it is relevant and verifiable. Federal regulators and regulators from seven state agencies interviewed generally agreed that data about one PV module may be applied to other substantially similar PV modules–meaning there are no meaningful differences in design or composition that would affect the accuracy of the hazardous waste determination.43 Regulators concurred that reliable data verified for one PV module may be used for identical PV modules (i.e., same manufacturer, model number, and produced in the same year).44 However, opinions diverged on whether information could be applied to substantially similar but not identical PV modules, such as those from the same manufacturer but with a different model or production year or from a different manufacturer.45 Across all cases, regulators emphasized that to be relevant, the PV modules must be substantially similar in design and material composition so that no meaningful differences affect the determination’s accuracy.46 The ability to apply a single dataset to multiple PV modules is an important factor in assessing whether knowledge- based hazardous waste determinations can be scaled to streamline regulatory compliance. 41 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR 42 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 43 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR 44 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR 45 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022) supported it could be possible that information used to make a verifiable hazardous waste determination for one PV module may be used to make an accurate determination for similar but not identical PV modules. 46 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR xv Figure ES-1. Hypotheses for PV module knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations and responses from U.S. federal and state regulators. Summary of qualitative analysis results showing the number of U.S. federal and state regulatory agency interviews that generally supported each hypothesis. The dataset includes responses from nine regulatory agencies.47 In some cases, responses were indeterminate and therefore not included but should not be interpreted as disagreement. Regulatory determinations are case-specific, and these results should not be construed as conclusive for compliance purposes. 47 This dataset includes responses from interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022), and communication with MPCA (Gilkeson and Cotton 2023). xvi Table of Contents Executive Summary ...............................................................................................................viii 1 PV Modules Managed as Solid and Hazardous Waste ...................................................... 1 1.1 Is the PV module a solid waste? ........................................................................................... 3 1.2 Does an exclusion or alternative management standard apply?........................................... 4 1.2.1 Exclusion Examples ................................................................................................................................4 1.2.2 Alternative Management Standard Examples .......................................................................................5 1.3 Does the PV module need to be managed as hazardous waste? .......................................... 5 2 Hazardous Waste Determination Methods ...................................................................... 9 2.1 Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determinations ........................................................... 9 2.1.1 Acceptable knowledge encompasses a wide range of sources and forms of information and can be used to make a hazardous waste determination if it is detailed, reliable, and relevant ...................................10 2.1.2 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be detailed .........................................................................................................................................................11 2.1.3 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be reliable ..........................................................................................................................................................13 2.1.4 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be relevant .........................................................................................................................................................14 2.2 Testing That Illustrates the Properties of the Waste .......................................................... 18 2.2.1 To conduct Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules is complex, time consuming, and expensive.....18 2.2.2 Variations in PV module sampling and preparation methods may produce inconsistent Test Method 1311 TCLP results ...............................................................................................................................................20 2.2.3 ASTM E3325 establishes a uniform sampling and preparation procedure for using Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules, but cost and accessibility challenges may limit its utility ................................................22 2.2.4 Considerations associated with alternative analytical testing procedures that may illustrate the properties of PV modules prior to recycling ......................................................................................................24 3 Conclusion...................................................................................................................... 26 Glossary ................................................................................................................................ 30 References ............................................................................................................................. 32 Legal References.................................................................................................................... 40 Appendix A. Methodology ..................................................................................................... 46 xvii List of Figures Figure ES-1. Hypotheses for PV module knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations and responses from U.S. federal and state regulators. .................................................................................. xvi Figure 1. Regulatory steps to determine if a PV module is a “solid waste” subject to federal and state solid waste law and at what point a hazardous waste determination is required. ............................. 3 Figure 2. Side-by-side comparison of a c-Si and a thin-film (CdTe) PV module design and composition. . 7 Figure 3. Responses by U.S. federal and state regulatory agencies and technical expert organizations regarding relevancy of information. ....................................................................................... 16 Figure 4. Responses from regulators in six U.S. state agencies regarding usage of ASTM E3325 Standard Practice for obtaining PV module samples for a TCLP Test Method 1311 hazardous waste determination ......................................................................................................................... 24 Figure 5. Number of Decommissioned PV Modules from 2024 to 2050. .................................................. 26 Figure 6. U.S. Map of PV projects and U.S. policy examples related to PV module toxicity concerns..... 29 List of Tables Table 1. U.S. Federal and Selected State Regulatory Limits of Toxic Metal Concentration in Leachates in Milligrams per Liter (mg/L) ..................................................................................................... 6 Table 2. Examples of Potential Sources and Forms of Information for Making a Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determination for PV Modules ................................................................. 11 xviii 1 PV Modules Managed as Solid and Hazardous Waste In the United States, a PV module that is “accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling or disposal or is disposed of” is a “solid waste”48 pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (RCRA) and may be subject to federal and state hazardous waste regulations (EPA 2025a; EPA 2025h). In practice, this means that a hazardous waste determination serves as a prerequisite for recycling or landfilling a PV module, unless an exclusion or an alternative management standard applies. The results of a hazardous waste determination dictate whether the PV module must be managed as hazardous waste or may be managed as nonhazardous waste prior to recycling or disposal. The person who decides to remove a PV module from service and recycle or dispose of it is considered a “generator”49 of solid waste and is the regulated person subject to U.S. federal and state hazardous waste law (EPA 2025a; 2025b). Importantly, if more than one person is involved in the decision to remove a PV module from service and recycle or dispose of it, they may be considered co-generators (EPA 2025h; EPA 1980; EPA 1996).50 For example, an asset owner that decides to remove from service and recycle a PV module, and an operations and maintenance (O&M) contractor that removes the PV module from service prior to recycling, may be considered co-generators and jointly and severally liable to comply with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste law (EPA 2025h).51 Hazardous waste law in every U.S. jurisdiction mandates accumulation, handling, storage, transport, and treatment requirements and restrictions prior to recycling or landfilling a PV module.52 For example, hazardous waste regulations may constrain PV module management options by limiting the number of modules and the length of time they may be accumulated on- 48 RCRA, in relevant part, defines “solid waste” to include “other discarded material.” EPA regulations define “discarded material” as materials that are “disposed of,” “burned or incinerated,” “accumulated, stored or treated before or in lieu of being abandoned by being disposed of, burned or incinerated,” “sham recycled,” or “accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling.” This means, by definition and EPA guidance, PV modules that are accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling or disposal are “solid waste” unless an exclusion applies (42 U.S.C § 6903(27); 40 C.F.R. §§ 261.2(a)–(c); EPA 2025a). 49 A “generator” is defined as “any person, by site, whose act or process produces hazardous waste identified or listed in part [40 C.F.R. § 261], or whose act first causes a hazardous waste to become subject to regulation” (40 C.F.R. § 260.10). 50 45 Fed. Reg. 72024 (1980) (concerns co-generators, clarifying multiple persons or entities can be considered generators of hazardous waste and thus jointly and severally liable for compliance); 45 Fed. Reg. 72026 (1980) (clarifies that when two or more entities or persons share in generating hazardous waste, a mutual agreement can designate which person(s) is the primary generator responsible for compliance); EPA 1996 (confirming that where co-generators mutually agree that one party will perform the generator duties on behalf of all, EPA will look first to the party designated by that agreement rather than to the operator, provided the designation is clear and documented). 51 45 Fed. Reg. 72024 (1980); 45 Fed. Reg. 72026 (1980); EPA 1996. 52 40 C.F.R. §§ 262–265, 268, 270. 1 site without a permit before off-site transport for recycling or disposal.53 Hazardous waste regulation may also mandate personnel training, labeling, shipping, reporting, recordkeeping, and additional permits and may trigger U.S. Department of Transportation hazardous material regulation if transported off-site (Curtis et al. 2021a; 2021b).54 In addition to increased management costs, which can be up to 10 times higher than for nonhazardous solid waste management,55 legal liability for PV modules regulated as hazardous waste is heightened, including civil penalties for “making an inaccurate or faulty hazardous waste determination”56 (Ruhlin 2024; Losurdo 2022). Unless an exclusion or alternative management standard applies, the regulated person(s) must either: • Manage the PV module as hazardous waste in accordance with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste law; or • Conduct a hazardous waste determination to demonstrate whether the PV module is safe to manage as nonhazardous solid waste or if it must be managed as hazardous waste (EPA 2025a).57 Figure 1 outlines the regulatory steps to determine when a PV module becomes a “solid waste” subject to U.S. federal and state solid waste law and at what point a hazardous waste determination is required. 53 For example, managing 6 to 55 PV modules (assuming a 40-lb weight) a month prior to recycling or landfilling may cause a person to be regulated as a small quantity generator (SQG). Under federal law, an SQG may not accumulate more than 329 PV modules (less than 6,000 kilograms) on-site at any time. A permit is required to store PV modules on-site for more than 180 days or 270 days if they must be transported more than 200 miles for treatment, recycling, or disposal (40 C.F.R. §262.16(b)(1)-(d); EPA 2025j). 54 For example: 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.16(b)(9)(iii); 262.17(a)(7) (personnel training requirement); 40 C.F.R. Part 262 subpart B (manifest required by U.S. Department of Transportation and EPA); 40 C.F.R. §§262.30 -.33 (pre- transport packaging and labeling); 40 C.F.R. § 262.41 (biennial reporting for large quantity generators); 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11(f); .40(a), (d) (recordkeeping); 40 C.F.R. Part 264 (permit and other requirements for treatment, storage and disposal facilities, which apply to third-party recyclers); EPA 2025j; EPA 2025k. 55 General waste management costs can range from $500 to $5,000 annually. Hazardous waste management prices are higher, ranging from $2,000 to $50,000 (Ruhlin 2024). Transport costs can more than double when managing a product such as PV modules as hazardous waste rather than nonhazardous (Losurdo 2022). 56 40 C.F.R. § 262.11. 57 40 C.F.R. § 262.11. 2 Figure 1. Regulatory steps to determine if a PV module is a “solid waste” subject to federal and state solid waste law and at what point a hazardous waste determination is required. 40 C.F.R. §§261.2(a)-(c), (e); 40 C.F.R. § 262.11; EPA 2025a. 1.1 Is the PV module a solid waste? A PV module becomes a solid waste and is subject to RCRA and potentially hazardous waste regulation when it is removed from service and it is decided that it will be recycled or disposed of (EPA 2025a).58 California’s Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) guidance provides that “PV modules become a waste when they are disconnected/removed from service [and] not reused” (DTSC 2025a). 58 42 U.S.C § 6903(27); 40 C.F.R. §§ 261.2(a)–(c). 3 A PV module that is directly reused in another application or is sent to a reseller for reuse or repair is not a solid waste (EPA 2025a; DTSC 2025a). In a reuse evaluation, a PV module is considered a solid waste when it is determined that it cannot be reused, and the decision is made to recycle or dispose of it. EPA recommends keeping PV modules with a reasonable expectation of reuse separate from those that are not fit for reuse (EPA 2025a). Any person(s) managing PV modules for reuse should maintain documentation to demonstrate that they were reused rather than reclaimed or discarded, and therefore not solid waste (EPA 2025a; Straus and Bello 1987).59 1.2 Does an exclusion or alternative management standard apply? If an exclusion60 or alternative management standard61 applies, a hazardous waste determination is not required under U.S. federal or state law.62 In some cases, a recycled63 PV module may be excluded from the definition of solid waste and therefore not subject to hazardous waste regulation, or an alternative management standard may similarly eliminate the need for a hazardous waste determination. Importantly, most U.S. jurisdictions (48 states, the District of Columbia, and Guam) manage their own hazardous waste programs, meaning exclusions and alternative management standards are jurisdiction-specific and vary by state or territory (EPA 2025b; EPA 2025c; EPA 2025d).64 Therefore, the federal RCRA exclusions and alternative management standard examples outlined below may differ, or may not be available, in all jurisdictions. 1.2.1 Exclusion Examples Some examples of exclusions under the federal RCRA program that may apply to a PV module or PV module manufacturing scrap in certain jurisdictions include: • Manufacturing scrap that is legitimately reclaimed.65 EPA considers PV module manufacturing scrap to be an off-spec commercial chemical product that, if legitimately reclaimed (recycled), is not subject to U.S. federal hazardous waste regulation and the requirement to make a hazardous waste determination (EPA 2025a).66 • Unused PV modules that are legitimately reclaimed. EPA considers an unused PV module a commercial chemical product that, if legitimately recycled, is not subject to 59 40 C.F.R. § 261.2(f); Straus and Bello (1987; example documentation that proves a material is not a solid waste because there is a “known market or disposition for the material”). 60 40 C.F.R. §§ 261.2(e), 261.4; EPA 2025e (household hazardous waste exclusion, 40 C.F.R. § 261.4(b)(1)). 61 Cal. Code Regs. tit. 22 § 66273 (2020); Haw. Code R. § 11-273.13(g) (2023). 62 40 C.F.R. § 262.11. 63 RCRA uses the terms “recycling” and “recyclable materials” without providing a statutory definition (42 U.S.C. §§ 6901-6992k). EPA’s regulations state “a material is recycled if it is used, reused, or reclaimed” (40 C.F.R. § 261.1 (c)(1)). A material is “used or reused” if it is either “employed as an ingredient in an industrial process to make a product” or “employed in a particular function or application as an effective substitute for a commercial product” (40 C.F.R. § 261.1 (c)(5)). 64 Alaska, Iowa, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands are the only U.S. jurisdictions that do not have their own state-specific hazardous waste program, and these states must follow the federal RCRA program (EPA 2025c; EPA 2025d). 65 A material is “reclaimed” if it is “processed to recover a usable product, or if it is regenerated” (40 CFR § 261.1(c)(4)). 66 40 C.F.R. § 261.2(c)(3). 4 U.S. federal hazardous waste regulations or the requirement to make a hazardous waste determination (EPA 2025a).67 • PV modules transferred to another person for reclamation. EPA guidance states PV modules “transferred to another person for the purpose of reclamation” (recycling) may not be subject to U.S. federal hazardous waste regulation or the requirement to make a hazardous waste determination if certain conditions are met (EPA 2025a). This exclusion, for example, may apply if an asset owner or other person involved in the management of the PV modules being recycled transfers the PV module off-site to a third-party RCRA permitted recycler or makes reasonable efforts to ensure the PV modules are being “legitimately recycl[ed] and not landfilled” (EPA 2022).68 1.2.2 Alternative Management Standard Examples In California69 and Hawaii,70 there is also an option to manage a PV module as universal waste prior to recycling or disposal. Universal waste is an optional alternative management standard created for certain types of hazardous waste that are commonly generated and have relatively low risk during collection and transport compared to other hazardous waste (EPA 2025g). Although still regulated as a subset of hazardous waste, PV modules managed as universal waste are subject to less stringent restrictions and requirements than fully regulated hazardous waste. In practice, a PV module regulated as universal waste eliminates the need for a hazardous waste determination. The EPA71 and New York72 are also considering adopting universal waste regulations for PV modules. 1.3 Does the PV module need to be managed as hazardous waste? If an exclusion or alternative management standard does not apply, the regulated person(s) (generator or co-generators) must manage the PV module as hazardous waste or prove it is safe to manage as nonhazardous (EPA 2025h).73 To prove the PV module is safe to manage as nonhazardous prior to recycling or disposal, the regulated person(s) must make an accurate hazardous waste determination to see whether the PV module exhibits one or more hazardous characteristics (i.e., ignitability, corrosivity, reactivity, or toxicity).74 The most common reason a PV module would be regulated as hazardous is if it contains a regulated metal in a leachable 67 40 C.F.R. § 261.2(c)(3). 68 40 C.F.R. § 261.4(a)(24). 69 Cal. Code Regs. tit. 22 § 66273.7.1. 70 Haw. Code R. § 11-273.6.2. 71 It is important to note that if EPA enacts a new rule allowing PV modules to be regulated as universal waste, it does not automatically apply in every state or territory in the United States (EPA 2025i). Each U.S. state and territory with its own government-specific hazardous waste program would also have to consider and adopt the federal PV module universal waste category, which could be more stringent (different regulatory requirements/restrictions than the federal program). Alaska, Iowa, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands are the only U.S. jurisdictions that do not have their own state-specific hazardous waste program and must follow the federal RCRA program (EPA 2025c; EPA 2025d). 72 The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation is considering adding PV modules to New York State’s universal waste program (NYSDEC 2025). 73 40 C.F.R. § 262.11. 74 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11; 261.3(a)(2); 261.10; 261.20–.24 (emphasis added). 5 concentration that equals or exceeds the toxicity characteristic limits (EPA 2025a; Curtis 2021a; Curtis 2021b). A PV module may be managed as nonhazardous only if it is determined it does not contain regulated “contaminants” (i.e., regulated metals), or if the amounts of regulated metals that could leach are lower than U.S. federal and/or state-mandated maximum toxicity levels.75 Most U.S. states have adopted the federal RCRA toxicity limits for the eight regulated metals (often referred to as “RCRA 8 metals”), whereas California regulates these and additional metals under its own standards. Table 1 lists metals regulated by and referred to as “contaminants” under the U.S. federal RCRA program and California hazardous waste programs. Table 1. U.S. Federal and Selected State Regulatory Limits of Toxic Metal Concentration in Leachates in Milligrams per Liter (mg/L) Jurisdiction Regulated Metals Regulatory Limit of Toxic Metal Concentration in Leachates (mg/L) Federal76 Arsenic (As) 5 Barium (Ba) 100 Cadmium (Cd) 1 Chromium (Cr) 5 Lead (Pb) 5 Mercury (Hg) 0.2 Selenium (Se) 1 Silver (Ag) 5 As, Ba, Cd, Cr, Pb, Hg, Se, Ag Same as limits above 77 California Copper (Cu) 25 Molybdenum (Mo) 350 Zinc (Zn) 250 If the asset owner is unsure whether a PV module is hazardous, they must manage it as hazardous and comply with hazardous waste labeling requirements until a determination is made. This ensures conformance with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste generator requirements (EPA 2025h; EPA 1989). Similarly, if an asset owner wants to accumulate and store multiple PV modules before making a hazardous waste determination, the modules must be labeled with the date accumulation began (EPA 2025h; EPA 1989). Commercially available PV modules include crystalline silicon (c-Si) and cadmium telluride (CdTe), a thin-film technology. As of 2024, c-Si and thin-film PV modules make up ~83% and ~17% of the U.S. market, respectively, and are expected to remain the predominant technologies 75 40 C.F.R. §§ 261.20; 261.24; 262.11. 76 40 C.F.R. § 261.24. 77 22 CCR §§ 66261.24(a)(1)(B); (a)(2)(A). 6 through 2035 (Seel et al. 2024; Fraunhofer 2024; DOE 2022; DOE 2021).78 Accordingly, the scope of this study is limited to commercially available c-Si and thin-film PV module technologies. Figure 2 compares the design and composition of c-Si and thin-film PV modules. Figure 2. Side-by-side comparison of a c-Si and a thin-film (CdTe) PV module design and composition. Image by Silvana Ovaitt, National Laboratory of the Rockies c-Si PV modules comprise an aluminum frame enclosing silicon solar cells, tinned copper wires, silver-paste gridlines, and Pb solder within sheets of polymer (e.g., ethylene-vinyl acetate [EVA] or polyolefin elastomers [POE] encapsulant) laminated between two sheets of glass or a polymer backsheet. On average, c-Si PV modules are composed of 61.3%–81.2% glass, 8.8%–23.7% aluminum, 5.1%–7.5% encapsulant, 1.4%–4.3% backsheet, 3%–6% silicon, and trace metals (≤0.7% Ag, ≤0.05% Pb, ≤0.07% Cu; Ovaitt et al. 2022; Abdelilah et al. 2022).79 Thin-film PV modules deposit thin layers of conductive oxide and CdTe directly on the front glass and are encapsulated with a polymer between front and back glass layers. On average, thin- film PV modules contain 87.2%–97.2% glass, ≤10% aluminum, 2.4%–2.8% encapsulant, and trace metals (≤0.4% Cu, ≤0.05% Cd, ≤ 0.06% Te; Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025; Ovaitt et al. 2022; Abdelilah et al. 2022). Both designs are engineered for 30 years or more of field durability under harsh environmental conditions (Li et al. 2024; Ovaitt et al. 2022; Maani et al. 2020; Sinha et al. 2019a; Sinha et al. 2019b; Libby and Shaw 2018). 78 In 2024, six c-Si PV module manufacturers (QCells, Renewable Energy Corporation, JA Solar, Canadian Solar, Inc., Silfab Solar, and LONGi) collectively accounted for nearly 60% of all installed residential and commercial PV modules in the United States (Wood Mackenzie 2025a). U.S.-based manufacturer First Solar produces nearly all thin-film PV modules installed in the United States and worldwide (Scarpulla et al. 2023). 79 NLR’s PV ICE model uses dynamic material composition values derived from representative module data sheets, life cycle databases, and literature published between 1995 and 2021 to calculate the average mass by weight of c-Si PV module components. The resulting ranges reflect material efficiency and technological improvements, such as thinner silicon wafers and aluminum frames, and reduced silver use (Ovaitt et al. 2022; Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025). 7 Both c-Si and CdTe PV modules are primarily composed of glass but may contain trace amounts of regulated metals. In c-Si PV modules, Pb is the most detected regulated metal, used in solder for cell and string interconnections, whereas Cd is present in the semiconductor layers of thin- film PV modules (EPA 2025a; Li et al. 2025; Li et al. 2024). Lead in c-Si solder typically ranges from 0.01% to 0.05% by weight, with some manufacturers moving toward Pb-free solder designs, which accounted for approximately 20% of the global PV market in 2022 (Abdelilah et al. 2022; Fischer et al. 2021; Li et al. 2024). Trace Ag is also present in c-Si modules (typically ≤0.08% by weight), and Ba may occur in trace amounts in c-Si module glass (Li et al. 2025; Abdelilah et al. 2022). Cd in thin-film modules is present at trace levels, typically 0.03%–0.05% by weight (Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025; Ovaitt et al. 2022; Abdelilah et al. 2022). Importantly, the chemical properties of CdTe are not the same as pure Cd; CdTe in thin-film modules is more stable, less soluble, and less bioavailable (Fthenakis et al. 2020). There is no evidence that commercially available c-Si or thin-film PV modules contain detectable80 levels of As,81 Cr,82 or Hg (Curtis and Anctil 2025; Mirletz et al. 2023; Singh et al. 2021).83 Although not regulated under RCRA, there is also no evidence that these module technologies contain germanium84 or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), and gallium is present only in trace amounts as a dopant in some cells85 (Curtis and Anctil 2025; Mirletz et al. 2023; Singh et al. 2021; Nain and Anctil 2025).86 If no exclusion or alternative management standard applies and the PV module is determined to be hazardous, it must be managed in accordance with U.S. federal and state hazardous waste requirements and restrictions. These requirements include maintaining records of the hazardous waste determination for at least 3 years from the date the PV module was sent to on-site or off- site treatment, storage (prior to recycling), recycling, or disposal.87 80 A “detectable” metal is defined as one with a measured concentration above the reported detection limit (RDL) of 100 nanograms (ng)/mL for each RCRA-regulated metal except for mercury, which has an RDL of 10 ng/mL (Li et al. 2025). A nanogram is one billionth of a gram. 81 One expert noted that arsenic is being explored as a dopant in emerging CdTe technologies, though only at trace impurity levels (communication with NLR [Barnes 2023]). Another expert confirmed that, at such concentrations, arsenic is unlikely to leach from CdTe PV modules (communication with ASU [Tao 2023]). 82 There is no evidence that chromium has been used in PV modules, apart from experimental cells in the 1970s and its historical use in chrome-plated solar thermal water heaters, not PV (Mirletz et al. 2023; communication with NLR [Barnes 2023]). 83 Communication with NLR (Barnes 2023). 84 Germanium was once used in amorphous c-Si PV modules that were never manufactured at scale (Mirletz et al. 2023; communication with NLR [Barnes 2023]); communication with EPRI [Libby 2023]). 85 One expert noted that gallium is being explored as a dopant in emerging thin-film technologies, though only at trace levels (parts per billion; communication with NLR [Barnes 2023]; Mirletz et al. 2023). Another expert stated that as a dopant, gallium is unlikely to leach from thin-film PV modules (communication with ASU [Tao 2023]). 86 Misinformation and misleading information about commercially available c-Si and CdTe PV modules has been found in news articles (e.g., Meidl 2022; Kisela 2022; Atasu et al. 2021; Prendergast 2020; Shellenberger 2018) and U.S. state regulatory agency guidance (e.g., FL DEP 2022; OH DOH 2022; DTSC 2025a; IA DNR 2021). 87 40 C.F.R. §262.11(f). The recordkeeping requirement applies to both small and large quantity generators. Managing 6–55 PV modules per month (40 pounds each) may qualify as a small quantity generator, whereas managing 56 or more modules may qualify as a large quantity generator. 8 2 Hazardous Waste Determination Methods To conduct a hazardous waste determination, the regulated person must either “apply knowledge” or “test” the PV module using Test Method 1311 (Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure [TCLP]), or an equivalent EPA-approved method, or use “a combination of both” testing and knowledge (EPA 2025a).88 In some jurisdictions, such as California, both TCLP and a state-specific test (e.g., waste extraction test [WET]) may be required.89 90 2.1 Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determinations The regulated person(s) “must apply knowledge of the hazardous characteristic of the waste…in light of the materials or processes used.”91 Acceptable knowledge for a hazardous waste determination can include: • “Process knowledge (e.g., information about the chemical feedstocks and other inputs to the production process) • Knowledge of products, byproducts, and intermediates produced by the manufacturing process • Chemical or physical characterization of the waste • Information on the chemical and physical properties of the chemicals used or produced by the process or otherwise contained in the waste • Testing that illustrates the properties of the waste • Other reliable and relevant information about the properties of the waste or its constituents.”92 Consideration: Process knowledge is recognized as “a substitute for physical testing that can be gleaned from data and records produced at some point when there was reliable knowledge as to the contents of the waste” (U.S. v. Hoffman, 154 Wash.2d 730, 116 P.3d 999 (Wash. 2005)).93 To date, there is no comprehensive U.S. federal or state guidance for making a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules (EPA 2024a). However, U.S. federal and state regulators and technical experts interviewed for this study have provided insight into sources and forms of information that may be used, the detail needed, and factors that may impact the 88 40 C.F.R. §§ 262.11(d); 262.11(d)(1)–(2). However, there are currently no known EPA-approved test method alternatives to Test Method 1311, TCLP. 89 40 C.F.R. §262.11(d)(2); 40 C.F.R. §261.24. 90 Both Method 1311 TCLP and WET simulate landfill leaching, but they are not interchangeable because of differences in analytical methods and regulated constituents. WET uses a citric acid leachate over a 48-hour extraction period and is generally more aggressive, whereas TCLP uses an acetic acid leachate over 18 hours (DTSC 2025b). 91 40 C.F.R. §262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 22 CCR §66262.11; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d); 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A). 92 40 C.F.R. §262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d); Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. at 85,752. 93 40 C.F.R. §262.11(d). 9 reliability and relevance of the information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules. 2.1.1 Acceptable knowledge encompasses a wide range of sources and forms of information and can be used to make a hazardous waste determination if it is detailed, reliable, and relevant Federal and state regulatory guidance provides that acceptable knowledge encompasses a wide range of sources and forms of information from both manufacturers and third parties.94 For example, acceptable knowledge can include compositional information and testing data in various forms, such as bills of material (BOMs), safety data sheets (SDSs), product labels, published studies, and databases (EPA 2015a; IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023).95 Test data can come from previously conducted Test Method 1311 TCLP test results in the form of a database, study, or other test methods.96 Consideration: “A test other than [Test Method 1311 TCLP], or an equivalent [EPA-approved or state-approved] test method may be used as part of a person’s knowledge to determine whether a solid waste exhibits a characteristic of hazardous waste. However, such tests do not, by themselves, provide definitive results.”97 Regardless of the source or format, information used for knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations must be detailed, reliable, and relevant. EPA and state guidance specify such data must fully illustrate the waste’s (PV module) properties and/or constituents to demonstrate it is below regulatory toxicity limits (EPA 2025a; IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023). Federal regulators and regulators from six states, interviewed for this study, indicated they would accept a BOM if it provides total constituent concentrations or detailed compositional data for the PV module. Regulators also noted third-party or peer-reviewed studies, public databases (e.g., previously conducted TCLP test results), or product labels that show regulated metal concentrations below toxicity thresholds may support a determination, provided the information is verifiable, from a trusted source, and specific to the PV module. Table 2 provides examples of potential sources and forms of information that U.S. federal and state regulators, interviewed for this study, indicated may be used for making a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules. 94 Communication with EPA (ORCR 2023). Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 95 Communication with EPA (ORCR 2023). Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 96 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d). 97 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC §335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d). 10 Table 2. Examples of Potential Sources and Forms of Information for Making a Knowledge-Based Hazardous Waste Determination for PV Modules Source(s) Form Requirements Support by Regulatorsa Manufacturer BOM Must be detailed and provide total EPA and regulators concentration levels of PV module constituents from six statesc and/or the compositional makeup of the PV module Third Partyb Studies Must be peer reviewed from trusted source(s) EPA and regulators and contain relevant information to determine from six statesc the potential toxicity of the specific PV module being analyzed Manufacturer Database Must include reliable data about PV module EPA and regulators Third Partyb compositional makeup and/or toxic from six statesd characteristics of PV modules Manufacturer Product Can include a statement that indicates PV Regulators from six Third Partyb Label modules with regulated metals are below the statese prescribed toxicity threshold—e.g., “compliant with federally and state defined regulatory maximum concentration levels of contaminants for the toxicity characteristic” if supported by reliable, trusted, and verifiable data Can include a statement that indicates the PV EPAf module does not contain regulated metals— e.g., “lead free” if supported by reliable, trusted, and verifiable data a The sample size for this table includes EPA and regulators from seven state agencies. b Federal and state regulators emphasize third-party sources must be trusted, reliable, and verifiable. c Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). d Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). e Interviews with NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). f Interview with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022). 2.1.2 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be detailed Federal regulations and state regulatory guidance specify information used to make a knowledge- based hazardous waste determination must be detailed and fully illustrative of the waste’s (PV module) properties and constituents (IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023).98 In practice, this means the information must be sufficient to determine: 98 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1). 11 • Whether the PV module contains a regulated metal(s) and, if so, • Whether the concentration of those metal(s) equals or exceeds U.S. federal and/or state toxicity limits. Determining whether a PV module contains regulated metals is relatively straightforward and could be demonstrated through product labels, manufacturer data, or diagnostic testing using standardized methods such as X-ray fluorescence (XRF) or Raman spectroscopy.99 For example, a product label stating “100% lead free” or a complete BOM may demonstrate a PV module does not contain Pb or other regulated metals.100 Studies have also used XRF analysis to characterize elemental composition and identify regulated metals such as Pb in PV modules (Li et al. 2024; Lee 2014; Lin et al. 2011). If a PV module contains a regulated metal, determining whether its concentration equals or exceeds U.S. federal or state toxicity limits may require additional compositional or analytical data (IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023; EPA 1992; 2016 NC DEQ 2021). For example, if XRF analysis confirms the presence of Pb in a c-Si PV module, the regulated person may use TCLP results—whether from verified third-party sources or conducting Test Method 1311 directly—to determine whether Pb concentrations in the leachate meet or exceed applicable toxicity characteristic limits. As an alternative to laboratory testing, such as Test Method 1311, TCLP, a regulated person may use manufacturer data (e.g., a BOM) or other compositional information to perform a total constituent analysis (TCA; EPA 1992; 2016; DTSC 2025b; Li et al. 2024). The TCA estimates the maximum theoretical leachate potential of a constituent (e.g., Pb) by dividing its total mass concentration in the PV module by 20. If the calculated value is below the applicable regulatory limit (e.g., 5 mg/L for Pb), no further analytical testing is required because the limit cannot be exceeded even if all the regulated metals were to leach out (EPA 1992; DTSC 2025b; Li et al. 2024).101 For example, if a PV module contains less than 0.01% Pb by mass (100 ppm), the module could not exceed the toxicity characteristic regulatory limit of 5 mg/L after leaching a 100% solid sample at a 20:1 solution to solid ratio. Therefore, the PV module could not exceed the regulatory limit, and it could not exhibit the toxicity characteristic for Pb. Notably, current manufacturer data, such as SDSs and BOMs, are often not detailed enough to serve as the sole basis for determining 1) whether a PV module contains a regulated metal or 2) whether its concentration exceeds regulatory toxicity limits. SDSs, for example, typically list only constituents comprising 1% or more of a material by mass (IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023). However, studies show Pb in c-Si and Cd in thin-film PV modules are each typically less than 1% by total weight, meaning SDSs may not capture their exact concentrations (Fiandra et al. 2019; Latunussa et al. 2016; Libby and Shaw 2018; Maani et al. 2020). Accordingly, SDSs and BOMs may need to be supplemented with additional data sources when 99 Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). Communications with NLR (Barnes 2024; Gaulding 2024). 100 Interviews with NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). 101 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); ASU (Tao 2022). 12 making a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules (IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023). 2.1.3 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be reliable In addition to being detailed, information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination must be reliable—that is, conclusive and verifiable (EPA 2025h; IN DEM 2014; OR DEQ 2017; WI DNR 2023). Federal and state regulators interviewed for this study emphasized confidence in the source of information and the ability to verify data are critical in establishing reliability. U.S. federal and state regulators noted third-party sources, such as peer- reviewed publications102 or databases103 that provide PV module compositional information or analytical test data, may be considered reliable if the methodology and results are transparent and verifiable. Similarly, a product label stating a PV module is “100% lead free” may support a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules if verified by a reputable industry standards organization or other reliable methods.104 Experts interviewed noted obtaining reliable compositional data from PV module manufacturers may be challenging. Although manufacturers possess detailed material data, they may be reluctant to share full constituent information for specific PV modules because of proprietary concerns.105 Data may also be more difficult to obtain for older PV modules or those produced by manufacturers no longer in business. Emerging supply chain transparency initiatives may provide a mechanism to improve access to manufacturing data for PV modules. Examples include the Solar Energy Industries Association’s Solar Supply Chain Traceability Protocol and the Global Electronics Council’s EPEAT Ecolabel for PV Modules, both voluntary, consensus-based programs promoting product traceability and data veracity (SEIA 2025; GEC 2025). These initiatives could be leveraged to inform knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. For instance, the EPEAT ecolabel––an independent third-party-verified environmental certification––requires manufacturers to provide a substances inventory (e.g., metals and chemicals) for their PV modules, and future updates could expand to include total regulated metal concentrations (GEC 2025). Similarly, the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA) of 2021 requires companies importing goods produced in Xinjiang, China, to disclose the sources of their raw materials.106 102 Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 103 Interviews with EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022). 104 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022). Communication with MPCA (Gilkeson and Cotton 2023). 105 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); Inovateus Solar (Kanczuzewski 2022; Powers 2022); Greeneye Partners (Keogh 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). SJSU (Mulvaney 2022). 106 Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act, Pub. L. No. 117-78, 135 Stat. 1525 et seq. (2021). 13 This law, which affects major PV suppliers to the United States, could be leveraged to further improve data transparency and support knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. 2.1.4 Information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules must be relevant In addition to being detailed and reliable, federal and state regulatory guidance provides that information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination must be relevant to the specific “waste” (PV module) being analyzed (EPA 2015a; IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017). Findings from this study indicate information about one PV module may be used to inform a determination for another module if the modules are substantially similar—that is, if there are no meaningful differences in design or composition that could affect the accuracy of the determination (e.g., the presence or concentration of a regulated metal).107 For instance, if differences in material composition could alter the results of a TCA calculation (e.g., total metal content) or laboratory testing (e.g., leaching potential), the information would not be considered relevant. Historical data—information generated before a hazardous waste determination rather than contemporaneous or newly produced data—may also be relevant if it accurately represents the PV modules being analyzed (IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017; EPA 2015a).108 When relevant, such data can allow the same information to support knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for multiple PV modules. However, federal and state regulators cautioned that relevancy may be limited by differences in module design, composition, age, or condition.109 Information from one PV module may be used to support a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for other modules; however, variability in module design and composition may impact its relevance. Federal regulators, regulators from seven state agencies, and technical experts from eight organizations interviewed agreed that information (such as compositional or analytical data) about one PV module may be relevant for making a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for another identical PV module (i.e., same manufacturer, same model, produced in the same year).110 In addition, one former EPA staff member and one state regulatory agency 107 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 108 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 109 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 110 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; 14 noted such information may also be relevant for PV modules that are substantially similar in design and composition—such as modules from a different product year or different manufacturer but with comparable material makeup.111 However, federal and state regulatory guidance emphasizes that, to be relevant, a regulated person must demonstrate the PV modules being compared are substantially similar in design and material composition, so no meaningful differences would affect the accuracy of the determination (EPA 2015a; IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017).112 Regulators from four state agencies expressed concern that the design and material composition may vary among substantially similar but not identical PV modules, potentially impacting the comparability and relevance of information used for a hazardous waste determination.113 However, regulators from four state agencies and technical experts from one organization expressed concern that the design and material composition of PV modules may vary between identical PV modules (e.g., same manufacturer, same model, same year) enough to potentially affect the relevancy of the information used to make a hazardous waste determination.114 Figure 3 summarizes responses from 16 U.S. federal and state regulatory agencies and technical expert organizations on whether information from one PV module can support a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for other PV modules. O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 111 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022). 112 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 113 Interviews with NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); former EPA staff (Helms 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); WI DNR 114 Interview with NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 15 Figure 3. Responses by U.S. federal and state regulatory agencies and technical expert organizations regarding relevancy of information.115 Summary of qualitative analysis results showing the number of U.S. federal and state regulator interviews and technical expert interviews that generally supported each hypothesis. Caveats are discussed in the body of the report. The dataset includes responses from eight U.S. federal and state regulatory agencies and eight technical expert organizations with expertise in PV module manufacturing and bills of materials. Only one technical expert organization was asked to assess the “substantially similar PV module” hypothesis. Regulatory determinations are made on a case-by-case basis, and these results should not be interpreted as conclusive for compliance purposes. Technical experts noted PV module manufacturers apply rigorous quality control standards to ensure product uniformity and meet performance standards.116 However, variations have been observed both within and across manufacturers and production years, including differences in material composition, component weight percentages, and lamination processes (Li et al. 2025).117 It remains unclear whether such manufacturer variability meaningfully affects the outcome of a hazardous waste determination or the relevance of information (e.g., compositional or analytical data) used in a knowledge-based determination. To evaluate the scalability of this regulatory compliance pathway, further research is needed to determine whether compositional or design variability among identical or substantially similar PV modules affects the relevance and applicability of data. For example, manufacturer data or analytical testing could identify variations in BOMs, whereas Test Method 1311 TCLP testing 115 This dataset includes responses from interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 116 Interview with IEC (Kelly 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 117 Interview with NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 16 could assess whether those differences affect leaching behavior. The resulting data could then be compiled into a database or study to support knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for specific PV module types. Historical information may be used to make an accurate knowledge-based hazardous waste determination if it is relevant and verifiable. Federal and state regulatory guidance indicates, instead of conducting contemporaneous analysis (e.g., compositional, analytical laboratory testing) after a product becomes a solid waste, a regulated person may use existing or historical information118 to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination (IN DEM 2014; OH EPA 2020; OR DEQ 2017; EPA 2015a). PV module experts, along with federal and state regulators from six agencies, agreed historical data—such as compositional or analytical test results collected at the time of manufacturing— can help determine whether a PV module requires management as hazardous waste prior to recycling or landfilling.119 One state guidance document also notes using existing data may save costs compared to new sampling and analysis (OR DEQ 2017). However, experts and regulators cautioned age and condition may affect the relevance of historical data.120 Technical experts and several studies note as PV modules age, degradation and exposure to moisture can increase the leaching potential of regulated metals normally sealed within the laminate, glass, and encapsulant (Aghaei et al. 2022; Kontges et al. 2014; Li et al. 2025). 121 For example, one study found encapsulant aging slightly increased metal leaching (Panthi et al. 2021), 122 whereas another found that missing glass layers significantly elevated leachability (Sharma et al. 2021). Yet, increased leachability does not always result in exceedance of regulatory thresholds: of 14 field-aged modules tested using Method 1311 TCLP, only three exceeded the Pb limit of 5 mg/L (Li et al. 2025). Thus, while age-related degradation may influence leaching behavior, it does not necessarily render historical data invalid. Regulators from two states123 also raised questions about whether chemical changes in module materials could occur over time, potentially reducing the reliability of earlier data. For instance, a recent study found prolonged heat and ultraviolet (UV) exposure may lead to acetic acid 118 In this study, “historical information” refers to information generated sometime prior to the hazardous waste determination. 119 Interviews with former EPA staff (Helms 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); email communication with Inovateus Solar (Kanczuzewski 2023). 120 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022). 121 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); ASU (Tao 2022). 122 Notably, increased leaching potential does not necessarily result in TCLP concentrations above regulatory limits. In a recent study of 33 c-Si and CdTe PV modules tested using Test Method 1311, 14 were field-aged c-Si modules. Of these, three exceeded the federal toxicity limit for lead (5 mg/L), whereas the remaining 11 were below the regulatory threshold (Li et al. 2025). 123 Interviews with WADE (Cusack 2022; Jennings 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022). 17 formation, which reacts with lead oxide in glass to form lead acetate, potentially altering material properties. However, the study did not evaluate whether such changes affect compositional or analytical results obtained before field use (Iqbal et al. 2023). Further research is needed to assess whether aging or condition alters PV module chemistry or analytical results in ways that affect the relevance of historical data. Understanding these parameters is essential to determining the extent to which information derived from one PV module may be applied to others. Ultimately, where deemed relevant and reliable by regulators, the same data could support hazardous waste determinations for multiple PV modules, improving the scalability and efficiency of regulatory compliance through knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations. 2.2 Testing That Illustrates the Properties of the Waste When adequate acceptable knowledge is unavailable, the PV module must be tested using EPA Test Method 1311 TCLP124 or another EPA-approved method (EPA 2025a).125 126 Test Method 1311 evaluates the leaching potential of a solid material, such as a PV module, under simulated landfill conditions and is the primary regulatory compliance method used today for determining whether PV modules exhibit hazardous waste characteristics (EPA 2025a; EPA 1994). Knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations may include “testing that illustrates the properties of the waste,” such as previously conducted TCLP results or other analytical data. Under RCRA, hazardous waste determinations based on testing—whether conducted under 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(2) or relied upon as part of an acceptable knowledge determination under § 262.11(d)(1) (and state equivalents)—are expected to be based on representative samples of the waste, as defined at 40 C.F.R. § 260.10. SW-846 Chapter 9 describes strategies for obtaining representative samples and discusses statistical approaches to reduce the risk of decision errors (EPA 2025l; 1986). This section summarizes key considerations for applying previously conducted TCLP results and other analytical approaches to support a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination for PV modules under 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1) and equivalent U.S. state regulations. 2.2.1 To conduct Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules is complex, time consuming, and expensive Six expert organizations interviewed for this study agreed conducting EPA Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules is a complex, time-intensive, and costly process requiring specialized 124 TCLP is commonly used as shorthand for a multistep toxicity characteristic testing process that includes obtaining representative samples of the waste (40 C.F.R. § 260.10), performing the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure in accordance with SW-846 Method 1311, and analyzing the resulting extract for toxicity characteristic constituents (40 C.F.R. §§ 261.20–261.24). SW-846 Chapter 9 describes general strategies for obtaining representative samples and discusses statistical approaches to reduce the risk of decision errors (EPA 2025l; 1986). 125 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(2); 40 C.F.R. §261.24. 126 California administers its own hazardous waste management program and requires the waste extraction test (WET) to determine toxicity when adequate acceptable knowledge is unavailable (DTSC 2025b; 22 CCR § 66261.24). 18 laboratory equipment and expertise.127 A representative sample must be extracted from the module, size-reduced to meet regulatory specifications, and mixed with acetic acid and rotated or tumbled for approximately 18 hours. The resulting leachate is then analyzed to determine whether concentrations of regulated metals (e.g., Pb) exceed toxicity limits (e.g., 5 mg/L; TamizhMani et al. 2018; Libby and Shaw 2018; EPA 1992; 1994). Although the leaching phase takes about 18 hours, the total testing process typically spans 5–10 days (EPA 1994; Phoslab Testing Laboratories 2016; 2025; AEL 2025).128 Individual TCLP tests may cost $550–$3,000 per PV module, depending on the sample preparation method and laboratory requirements, and off-site sample preparation that includes additional transportation can further increase costs (Phoslab Testing Laboratories 2016; AEL 2025; Libby and Shaw 2018; TamizhMani et al. 2018).129 Most PV systems installed in the United States (83%) are large-scale developments, with utility projects expected to dominate through 2035 (Wood Mackenzie 2025b; 2025c). A typical 100- MW utility-scale system installed in the early 2000s contains roughly 352,000 PV modules (Ramasamy et al. 2022; Feldman 2021).130 EPA guidance allows generators to develop “scientifically credible” sampling plans in which a representative subset of waste is tested to characterize a larger population (EPA 1986; 2002). However, there is no U.S. federal or state regulatory guidance describing how to develop a scientifically credible sampling plan specific to PV modules—such as specifying how many modules must be tested to characterize the average properties of a batch or installation (PVQAT 2023).131 Regulators from three agencies interviewed for this study as well as several asset owners noted uncertainty about how to design such a plan for PV modules (PVQAT 2023).132 Under this regulatory compliance pathway (40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(2)), a hazardous waste determination may apply only to the PV modules included in the sampling plan and the contemporaneous TCLP results generated at that time (EPA 2025l; 2002; 1986). In the absence of an approved sampling plan, conducting TCLP testing on even a fraction of PV modules within a single large-scale project is likely not practical (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024). At approximately $550–$3,000 per module, TCLP testing 5%–10% of PV modules in a 100-MW system (approximately 17,600–35,200 modules) could cost on the order of $10–$100 million—an amount that experts interviewed for this study 127 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); email communications ReMA (Wagger 2023); Inovateus Solar (Kanczuzewski 2023). 128 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022); ASU (Tao 2022). 129 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022), SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022), and EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022) found the cost to conduct TCLP testing from start to finish ranges between $1,850 and $3,000 per module. Based on cost information from a recent EPA project, estimated TCLP testing costs varied by particle size– reduction technique, with mechanical size reduction estimated at $547.50 per sample and waterjet cutting estimated at $1,897.50 per sample (Written communication [EPA ORCR 2025]). 130 Email communication with Smith (2023). 131 Interviews with CO DPHE (Foster 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022, Ching 2022, Vandeusen 2022, Egbon 2022, O’Connell 2022). EPA sampling guidance, although not PV specific, could be applied to PV modules and includes information on sampling designs that limit decision-error risk, representative sampling strategies, and statistical approaches for heterogeneous wastes (EPA 1986). 132 Interviews with CO DPHE (Foster 2022); EPA Region 5 (Newman 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022, Ching 2022, Vandeusen 2022, Egbon 2022, O’Connell 2022). 19 indicated is likely economically and practically infeasible.133 By contrast, a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination could use existing TCLP results (e.g., from databases, studies, or prior tests) and apply them to other PV modules with comparable designs or material compositions, arguably offering a more representative and economically viable approach for large-scale applications. At the same time, reliance on previously generated data requires careful evaluation to ensure the information is sufficiently detailed, reliable, and relevant to the PV modules being evaluated. 2.2.2 Variations in PV module sampling and preparation methods may produce inconsistent Test Method 1311 TCLP results Performing Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules can yield inconsistent results, with some studies reporting variability ranging from approximately 30% to more than 50% when testing the same module (Warren 2022; Nain and Kumar 2020; TamizhMani et al. 2018; 2021; Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019). Experts attribute this variability primarily to: • Challenges and differing approaches for obtaining a representative PV module sample (i.e., which portions of the module are selected for testing) • Variations in sample extraction and preparation methods applied (e.g., mechanical vs. waterjet cutting and differences in particle size reduction), which can influence leaching behavior and test outcomes (Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019; TamizhMani et al. 2018; 2021).134 This variability has raised concerns among those legally responsible for making accurate PV module hazardous waste determinations.135 Anecdotal evidence suggests some asset owners— preferring to recycle despite higher costs—opt instead for disposal in hazardous waste landfills because of uncertainty about the reliability of TCLP test results (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024). 136 Industry experts have similarly noted that concerns about potential liability associated with inconsistent TCLP results may lead to over-management of PV modules as hazardous waste, regardless of test outcomes (PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024).137 138 Although a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination may rely on previously conducted TCLP test results, it is not limited to them, allowing for the use of alternative analytical methods and innovation in PV module–specific waste characterization. Challenges and Approaches for Obtaining Representative PV Module Samples Test Method 1311 TCLP depends on obtaining a representative sample of the solid waste (e.g., an entire PV module) for analysis (EPA 1994; 2002; Vann et al. 2006). However, no federally or state-recognized standard or guidance exists for collecting representative samples from PV 133 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 134 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); former owner of Cascade EcoMinerals (Spivey 2022); SERI (De Vries 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022). 135 Interviews with SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 136 Interview with SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 137 Interview with SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 138 EPA notes testing replicate samples reduces the confidence interval of the mean and reduces the risk of making a decision error based on the average properties of the waste (Written communication [EPA ORCR 2025]). 20 modules (EPA 2025a; Warren 2022; EPA 1994; Vann et al. 2006). PV modules comprise multiple components with distinct physical and chemical properties, making representative sampling difficult (Li et al. 2024). Because of their layered design, constituent concentrations in a sample can vary depending on the extraction location (e.g., near the aluminum frame versus the solar cell; Sinha et al. 2019b; Libby and Shaw 2018). As a result, samples taken from different areas of the same PV module may yield inconsistent or biased results that are not representative of the module’s overall composition (Warren 2022; Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019). Consideration: Obtaining a representative sample from bulky, heterogeneous solids for Test Method 1311 has historically posed challenges across industries. For example, one study found sampling computer central processing units (CPUs) produced variable and inconsistent TCLP results because standard laboratory equipment was “ill-equipped to process large items and materials containing components with different mechanical properties” (Vann 2006). Because of these difficulties, the computer industry later explored alternative methods to TCLP for determining whether CPUs should be managed as hazardous waste (Townsend et al. 2004). Anecdotal evidence suggests limited consensus among technical experts on how to obtain a representative PV module sample for Test Method 1311. Some experts recommended grinding an entire PV module into a homogeneous mixture (e.g., crushing the glass and encapsulant layers that protect internal components) to create a representative sample.139 Others disagreed, noting this approach could inadvertently increase leachability by reducing particle size.140 By contrast, experts from a PV module manufacturer suggested a more accurate approach would be to test individual PV module components in proportions reflecting their weight within the module— such as testing the cell laminate separately in an amount proportional to its contribution to the total module’s mass.141 Variability in Sample Extraction and Preparation Methods Test Method 1311 TCLP specifies the minimum sample size (i.e., total number of samples required to be tested) and weight required for testing but does not prescribe a standardized sample extraction or preparation technique (EPA 1994). Studies have shown the method used to extract samples (e.g., mechanical vs. waterjet cutting) from c-Si PV modules can cause significant variability in TCLP results, ranging from 8% to more than 50% (ASTM 2022; Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019; TamizhMani et al. 2018; 2021). For example, one study analyzing c-Si PV modules from four manufacturers found that mechanical cutting produced the highest variability, with some results differing by more than 50%. The study identified glass cracking 139 Interviews with Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); SEIA (Nicholson 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022); ASU (Tao 2022). 140 Interview with IEC (Kelly 2022). Email communication with ASU (Tao 2023). 141 PV module manufacturers noted they use a formula to calculate the proportion of each component (e.g., glass, laminate, cell) needed to obtain a representative sample that reflects the module’s component weight distribution (interview with Hanwha Q Cells [Galia 2022; Schurade 2022]). 21 behavior (length and number of cracks) and tempering characteristics as contributing factors to variability (Libby and Shaw 2019). Variability in TCLP results for PV modules has also been documented at up to 50% in replicate tests conducted by TamizhMani et al. (2018) and reaffirmed in TamizhMani et al. (2021). Experts interviewed for this study confirmed waterjet cutting can reduce variability to approximately 8% because it produces cleaner cuts with less fragmentation and cracking compared to mechanical cutting (ASTM 2022; Li et al. 2024).142 Lab-to-lab variations in sample preparation can also produce inconsistent Test Method 1311 TCLP results (Libby and Shaw 2018; 2019; TamizhMani et al. 2018; 2021).143 Studies have found PV module TCLP results are often not replicable across laboratories because of differences in sample preparation procedures. For instance, some laboratories further reduce sample size (e.g., crushing) upon receipt, whereas others do not (Libby and Shaw 2019; Warren 2022). Test Method 1311 prescribes a maximum particle size but does not specify a minimum, resulting in variable particle size distributions that can affect TCLP test outcomes.144 Smaller particle sizes increase exposed surface area and may elevate leachability, potentially resulting in higher detected concentrations of regulated metals. Consequently, the absence of standardized extraction and preparation procedures under Test Method 1311 may result in nonreplicable or inconsistent results across laboratories, creating challenges for accurate PV module hazardous waste determinations.145 2.2.3 ASTM E3325 establishes a uniform sampling and preparation procedure for using Test Method 1311 TCLP on PV modules, but cost and accessibility challenges may limit its utility To address variability and inconsistency in PV module Test Method 1311 TCLP results, the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) contracted with the Arizona State University Photovoltaic Reliability Laboratory (ASU-PRL) in 2021 to develop a standardized sampling protocol using waterjet cutting. The protocol was later refined by an ASTM working group into ASTM E3325: Standard Practice for Sampling of Solar Photovoltaic Modules for Toxicity Testing (ASTM E3325 Standard Practice; ASTM 2021; 2022; Warren 2022). The ASTM E3325 Standard Practice reduces Test Method 1311 TCLP result variability to approximately 8% for both c-Si and CdTe PV modules by prescribing: • Sampling from defined module areas (e.g., silicon cell, cell ribbon, noncell areas) in proportions reflecting their mass distribution • Use of waterjet cutting to minimize sample fragmentation • Specification of target particle size • Instructions for laboratories not to further reduce the size or number of extracted samples (ASTM 2021; 2022; Warren 2022). 142 Interviews with IEC (Kelly 2022); EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022). 143 Interview with IEC (Kelly 2022). 144 Email communication with EPA (Strock 2023). 145 Email communication with ASU (Tao 2023). 22 Despite these benefits, experts from seven interviews—including representatives from three state regulatory agencies—noted high costs and limited access to waterjet cutting facilities may restrict widespread adoption of the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice.146 Few facilities possess equipment large enough to process PV modules, and those that do may be unwilling to handle modules containing regulated metals such as Pb or Cd. Experts also highlighted potential increases in transportation costs and accessibility issues, particularly for facilities located out of state.147 One state regulator also raised concerns regarding copyright and accessibility, noting ASTM standards are proprietary and may not be easily incorporated into state regulations or made publicly available.148 Unless the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice can be used to make hazardous waste determinations at scale (i.e., for multiple modules simultaneously), these cost and accessibility barriers may limit its practical application. ASTM standards are reviewed every 5 years and are withdrawn after 8 years if not reapproved, presenting an opportunity to revise them to address these limitations (ASTM 2025). Evidence from this study’s interviews indicates regulator awareness and acceptance of the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice remain limited. Regulators in two states were unaware of its existence,149 whereas one expressed hesitation to authorize waterjet cutting in the absence of federal EPA guidance.150 Two other states affirmed they would accept TCLP results generated in accordance with ASTM E3325 Standard Practice,151 though one agency noted additional samples from the frame and integrated electronics would still be required.152 The same agency also indicated it would likely not require the use of ASTM E3325 Standard Practice for either regulated persons or compliance officers because of cost and access challenges.153 EPA experts have also expressed concern the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice may yield low-bias measurements of leachable concentrations of Pb or other regulated metals because of loss during waterjet cutting or water rinsing of particle-size-reduced solids.154 This divergence in regulatory interpretation may create potential liability exposure. For example, an asset owner could use the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice to determine TCLP results for a PV module are below regulatory thresholds and therefore manage the module as nonhazardous. However, if a compliance officer later evaluates the same module using a different preparation method and obtains results exceeding TCLP limits, the asset owner could face enforcement risks 146 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022). Email communications with Inovateus Solar (Kanczuzewski 2023); ReMA (Wagger 2023); and SOLARCYCLE (Sharma and Dias 2023). 147 Communication with EPRI (Libby 2023; Shaw 2023). 148 Interview with NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). 149 Interview with CO DPHE (Foster 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022). 150 Interview with OH EPA (Matthews 2022). 151 Interviews with NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022). 152 Communication with NC DEQ (Patterson 2023; Stermer 2023). 153 Interview with NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022). 154 Written communication (EPA ORCR 2025). 23 arising from making an inaccurate hazardous waste determination.155 For this reason, EPA encourages regulated persons to engage with the appropriate regulatory authority in their jurisdiction (e.g., federal, state, or local agencies) when planning and before conducting Test Method 1311 TCLP (EPA 2005; EPA 2015b). Accordingly, unless ASTM E3325 Standard Practice is nationally recognized and adopted by U.S. federal and state regulators, its ability to reduce liability risk or increase confidence in TCLP results may remain limited. Broader industry engagement and regulator participation in future ASTM revisions could enhance awareness, accessibility, and regulatory alignment. Figure 4 provides responses from six U.S. state regulatory agencies regarding the ASTM E3325 Standard Practice for obtaining PV module samples for a TCLP Test Method 1311 hazardous waste determination. Figure 4. Responses from regulators in six U.S. state agencies regarding usage of ASTM E3325 Standard Practice for obtaining PV module samples for a TCLP Test Method 1311 hazardous waste determination156 2.2.4 Considerations associated with alternative analytical testing procedures that may illustrate the properties of PV modules prior to recycling Other analytical testing methods that “illustrate the properties of the waste” may be used in lieu of Test Method 1311 TCLP to make an accurate knowledge-based hazardous waste determination.157 Given concerns about test result variability and the limited ability of Test Method 1311 to reflect realistic leaching conditions, alternative methods may provide more 155 42 U.S.C. § 6928; 40 C.F.R. § 19.4. 156 This dataset encompasses interview responses from six U.S. state regulatory agencies: NC DEQ (Stermer 2022; Patterson 2022); OH EPA (Matthews 2022); NYS DEC (Killeen 2022; Ching 2022; Vandeusen 2022; Egbon 2022; O’Connell 2022); CO DPHE (Foster 2022); CT DEEP (Bunnell 2022); WI DNR (Ellenbecker 2022). 157 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1); A.A.C. R18-8-262; 15A NCAC 13A .0107; 30 TAC § 335.504(a)(3)(A); 22 CCR § 66262.11; OAR 340-102-0011; WAC 173-303-070(3)(d). 24 representative assessments of PV module behavior (Li et al. 2024; Sinha and Wade 2015; Sinha et al. 2019b). Test Method 1311 TCLP was designed to estimate potential leaching from materials disposed of in unlined municipal landfills (EPA 1994; EPA 2016; Li et al. 2024). However, it has been criticized as overly aggressive for PV modules because the required particle size reduction more closely resembles recycling conditions than realistic breakage scenarios (Sinha and Wade 2015). For instance, experimental evidence shows that crushed PV modules compacted under 50-ton loads maintained encapsulation and structural integrity (Sinha et al. 2019b), and that toxic constituents are unlikely to be released unless modules are “ground into a fine dust” (Fthenakis and Zweibel 2003; OH DOH 2022). Because Test Method 1311 TCLP and California’s WET test simulate acidic landfill conditions rather than rainwater exposure, they may overstate leaching potential under realistic PV module field conditions and management scenarios (Li et al. 2024; Sinha and Wade 2015). In contrast, several countries have adopted more representative leaching procedures. Japan’s JLT-13 method uses pre-cracked PV modules and a water-based leachate to simulate rainwater exposure, whereas Germany and South Korea have implemented similar approaches (Sinha and Wade 2015; Li et al. 2024). These methods offer potential models for developing more realistic, PV-specific testing approaches in the United States. Recent studies suggest that even under worst-case conditions, regulated metals in PV modules may not pose significant human health or environmental risks. Using the EPA Method 1312 Synthetic Precipitation Leaching Procedure (SPLP), researchers found Pb and Cd concentrations leached from weathered c-Si and CdTe modules were below EPA screening levels, even after 1 year of full submersion in a water-based solution (Sinha et al. 2019b). Similarly, a Test Method 1311 TCLP-based study found leachate concentrations from both c-Si and CdTe modules below EPA human health and environmental thresholds (Sinha et al. 2019a). Collectively, these findings underscore the value of evaluating alternative leaching tests—such as SPLP and JLT-13—that better reflect realistic rainwater field exposure and end-of-life management conditions for PV modules. These methods could be leveraged to inform the development of approaches tailored to PV modules and representative in-field exposure and end- of-life management conditions, helping support reliable and scalable knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. 25 3 Conclusion In the coming years, millions of PV modules in the United States are expected to reach end-of- life, requiring decisions about whether to recycle them or send them to a landfill. Unless an exclusion or alternative management standard applies, these modules must be managed under U.S. federal and state hazardous waste law–or verified as nonhazardous through a hazardous waste determination. NLR’s PV in the Circular Economy (PV ICE) model finds approximately 35 GWdc of installed capacity—representing 25–32 million PV modules—will be decommissioned in the United States by 2035. By 2045, nearly 80 GWdc (126–157 million modules) are expected to retire, increasing to roughly 130 GWdc (269–336 million modules) by 2050 (Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025). Figure 5 illustrates PV ICE decommissioning modeling based on dynamic PV module composition data derived from representative datasheets, life cycle inventories, and literature published between 1995 and 2024 (Ovaitt et al. 2022; Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025). Figure 5. Number of Decommissioned PV Modules from 2024 to 2050. NLR’s PV ICE model uses dynamic material composition values derived from representative module data sheets, life cycle analysis databases, and literature published between 1995 and 2024 to calculate the average mass by weight of c-Si and CdTe PV module components. The low and high ranges reflect changes in average component mass resulting from material efficiency and technology advancements over time (e.g., 2 m² vs. 1.6 m² modules, thinner silicon wafers, and reduced aluminum frame thickness; Ovaitt et al. 2022; Mirletz and Ovaitt 2025). With hundreds of millions of PV modules expected to reach end-of-life over the next 2 decades, this is a critical period for addressing a key regulatory compliance challenge: making accurate hazardous waste determinations. Application of Test Method 1311 TCLP to PV modules presents practical and potential liability concerns, including temporal limitations and the absence of federal or state sampling guidance specifying how many modules must be tested to represent a batch or installation. Under this regulatory compliance pathway (40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(2) and state analogs), regulators may interpret a hazardous waste determination as applying only to PV 26 modules included in the sampling plan and associated with contemporaneous TCLP results (EPA 2025l; 2002; 1986). Testing even a fraction of PV modules within a large-scale project using Test Method 1311 (under 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(2) and state equivalents) is likely both cost- and time- prohibitive,158 and reported test-result variability—exceeding 50% in some studies—has raised concerns among parties legally responsible for making accurate hazardous waste determinations (TamizhMani et al. 2021; 2018; PVQAT 2023; Siegfried et al. 2024).159 As a result, some asset owners elect to manage PV modules as hazardous waste despite TCLP results that would otherwise allow management in compliance with less stringent and more cost-effective nonhazardous waste regulations––an outcome that has been anecdotally reported to negatively affect domestic PV module resource recovery.160 Consideration: PV module recycling presents a significant economic opportunity for the United States and is recognized as a key strategy to strengthen domestic manufacturing and alleviate supply chain constraints (DOE 2022). NLR’s PV ICE model estimates that by 2050, 5 million tonnes (Mt) of recycled PV modules in the United States could yield 3.63 Mt of glass (72.2%), 0.64 Mt of aluminum (12.8%), 0.18 Mt of silicon (3.6%), 0.003 Mt of copper (0.1%), and 0.002 Mt of silver (0.04%). Knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations are an existing regulatory compliance pathway under 40 C.F.R. § 262.11(d)(1) and state equivalents that may offer a scalable framework for addressing current challenges associated with making hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. This approach allows a regulated person to rely on multiple lines of evidence—such as compositional data, prior TCLP results, published studies, databases, or product labels—rather than laboratory testing alone. In doing so, PV modules may be characterized using representative, verifiable data collected across different time periods, installations, or batches or among identical or substantially similar module types. By reducing the need for repetitive, generator-specific (e.g., batch-by-batch) testing and supporting the use of broader, industry-level datasets, this regulatory compliance approach may lower costs and improve scalability across assets, products, and markets. Because knowledge- based hazardous waste determinations are not required to use Test Method 1311, this regulatory compliance pathway may also encourage innovation through tailored analytical methods, shared databases, or decision-support tools specific to the solar industry. Collectively, these findings suggest knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations could enhance transparency and scalability in PV module end-of-life management. However, as a foundational study, additional 158 Interviews with SEIA (Nicholson 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 159 Interviews with SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). EPA ORCR has also noted additional Method 1311 TCLP testing would reduce variability (written communication [EPA ORCR 2025]). 160 Interviews with EPRI (Libby 2022; Shaw 2022); Cascade Eco Minerals (Spivey 2022); IEC (Kelly 2022); Hanwha Q Cells (Galia 2022; Schurade 2022); ASU (Tao 2022); Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance (Parr 2022); NLR (Muller 2022; Mirletz 2022); SERI (De Vries 2022); SOLARCYCLE (Sharma 2022; Dias 2022). 27 research and regulatory engagement are needed to evaluate this pathway’s applicability, reliability, and limitations. Further research and stakeholder coordination will be essential to determine the feasibility and parameters of knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. Collaboration among industry, EPA, and state regulators could help identify acceptable data—such as product labels, compositional databases, or nondestructive testing methods (e.g., XRF, Raman, TCA)— and establish standards through accredited third-party certification programs. Such collaboration could also clarify when individual PV module waste characterization (e.g., via Test Method 1311 or another approved method) remains warranted. Understanding the scalability of a knowledge-based compliance approach for PV modules is particularly important. Regulators from eight state agencies interviewed for this study generally agreed information used to make a verifiable hazardous waste determination for one PV module could be applied to identical modules—those produced by the same manufacturer, with the same model number and production year. However, perspectives diverged regarding whether that same information could be applied to substantially similar modules, such as those from the same manufacturer but with different model numbers or production years. Regulators and technical experts also cautioned the age and condition of PV modules may influence the relevance of historical compositional or analytical data, underscoring the need for further study to define the boundaries of this approach and its potential for scalable regulatory compliance. Knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations may also help address public concerns about PV module toxicity, which have increasingly influenced permitting decisions, siting delays, and local moratoria.161 Some communities now require evidence that proves PV modules are nonhazardous prior to project approval (PVQAT 2023). Regulators and policymakers are similarly seeking credible, publicly accessible data to inform decisions. Establishing a transparent, third-party-verified database of compositional and analytical information could help counter misinformation and support consistent regulatory decisions across jurisdictions. Concerns about PV module toxicity have contributed to project opposition and policy responses in multiple states, including California, Hawaii, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee, among others (SC DHEC 2022; Curtis et al. 2021a; CPSC 2020; CPUC and CalRecycle 2019; Holm and Martin 2019; ISTC 2019; MPCA 2019).162 Several local 161 Solar PV projects have been canceled or withdrawn in Massachusetts, Florida, and Virginia at least in part because of concerns about PV module toxicity (Hernandez 2020; Scherzinger 2021; Eisenson 2023; Amherst Conservation Comm’n. 2021). 162 Examples in California (S.B. 207, 2021–2022 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Cal. 2021)); Paulina Kolic, CalRecycle, email, September 6, 2019; Teresa Bui, CalRecycle, email, January 8, 2021); Connecticut (Conn. Pub. Utils. Reg. Auth., Docket No. 23-08-02, Annual Residential Renewable Energy Solutions Program Review – Year 3 (Nov. 1, 2023)); Hawaii (H.B. 1333, 31st Leg., Reg. Sess. (Haw. 2021)); Illinois (2022 Ill. Laws 102-1025, Renewable Energy Component Recycling Task Force Act); Maryland (Md. Code Ann., Envir. § 2-1303(g) (2022)); Massachusetts (MA DEP 2023); Minnesota (2023 Minn. Laws 60-2310); Nevada (Nev. Rev. Stat. § 444.570 (2023)); New Jersey (2019 N.J. Sess. Law Serv. Ch. 215 (West)); Niagara County, New York (Niagara County, Local Law No. 4 (2021)); North Carolina (2019 N.C. Sess. Law 2019-132); South Carolina (2022 S.C. Act 119, an act to amend sections 44- 96-40 and 44-96-250, code of laws of South Carolina, 1976 Solid Waste Policy and Management Act, to amend 28 governments have enacted or proposed technology-specific module bans163 or moratoria on large-scale PV development related in part to PV module toxicity concerns.164 Figure 6 highlights examples of U.S. jurisdictions where PV projects have been canceled or withdrawn and where state and local policy has been influenced, at least in part, by concerns about PV module toxicity. Ultimately, information used to make a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination—and its potential applicability to identical or substantially similar PV modules— could provide a scalable compliance pathway that reduces costs, enhances confidence in PV recycling, and supports informed decision-making among regulators, developers, and communities. Figure 6. U.S. Map of PV projects and U.S. policy examples related to PV module toxicity concerns. Although both are designed to restrict PV development, bans and moratoriums are distinct policy tools. Bans are typically permanent prohibitions enacted through local zoning or planning ordinances and remain in effect unless repealed. Moratoriums, in contrast, are temporary measures adopted for a defined period to pause development while further study or policy considerations are made. section 44-96-290, to amend section 48-1-50); Tennessee (2022 Tenn. Pub. Acts 1043, Utility Scale Solar Energy Development); Texas (S.B. 1290, 88th Leg., R.S. (2023)); Virginia (S.B. 499, 2022 Gen. Assemb. Reg. Sess. (Va. 2022)); and Washington (Wash. Rev. Code § 70A.510.010, Photovoltaic Module Stewardship and Takeback Program). 163 Local governments in Arizona, California, Delaware, Georgia, Kansas, Ohio, Tennessee, and Virginia have enacted solar PV technology development bans within their zoning ordinances due at least in part to toxicity concerns (Zuckerman 2022; Scherzinger 2021; Eisenson 2023; Union Cty., Ohio Resolution 22-296; Logan Cty., Ohio, Resolution 196-22; Hancock Cty., Ohio, Resolution 250-22; Medina Cty., Ohio, Resolution 22-0077; Maricopa Cty. Zoning Ord. § 1206.2.1; Franklin Cty. Bd. Comm’rs. 2022; San Bernardino Cty. Bd. Comm’rs. 2019; Osage Cty. Planning Comm. 2022; Buckingham Cty., Bd. Of Supervisors, 2022; Madison Cty., Virginia, Zoning Ord. § 14-19-3(C)(7); Prince George Cty., Virginia, Solar Energy Facility Siting Policy § 2(6)(b)). 164 Greene County, Iowa, has enacted a 2-year moratorium on solar development after residents raised concerns about cleanup related to toxic substances within solar modules being released during fire events (Burress 2025). 29 Glossary Term Definition Control “For purposes of [C.F.R. §261.4(a)(23)(i)(B) which states the requirements for hazardous secondary waste generator facilities] … the power to direct the policies of the facility, whether by the ownership of stock, voting rights, or otherwise, except that contractors who operate facilities on behalf of a different person as defined by [40 C.F.R. §260.10] are not deemed to ‘control’ such facilities” (40 C.F.R. §261.4(a)(23)(i)(B)). Detectable “A ‘detectable’ metal is defined as one with a measured concentration above the reported detection limit of 100 nanogram/mL for each RCRA regulated metal” (Li et al. 2025). Discarded Material Includes materials “disposed of,” “burned or incinerated,” “accumulated, stored or treated before or in lieu of being abandoned by being disposed of, burned or incinerated,” “sham recycled,” or “accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling” (40 C.F.R. §§261.2(a)-(c)). End-of-Life PV A PV module with no reuse potential, which must be recycled or Module landfilled. Generator “...[A]ny person, by site, whose act or process produces hazardous waste identified or listed in part [40 C.F.R. §261], or whose act first causes a hazardous waste to become subject to regulation” (40 C.F.R. §260.10). Generating Facility “For purposes of [the definition of hazardous secondary waste generator], ... all contiguous property owned, leased, or otherwise controlled by the hazardous secondary material generator” (40 C.F.R. §260.10). Hazardous “...[A] secondary material (e.g., spent material, by-product, or sludge) Secondary Material that, when discarded [which may include PV modules accumulated, stored, or treated before recycling or disposal] would be identified as hazardous waste [pursuant to 40 C.F.R. §261]” (40 C.F.R. §260.10). Hazardous “... [A]ny person whose act or process produces hazardous secondary Secondary Waste materials at the generating facility” (40 C.F.R. §260.10). Generator Historical Information (e.g., manufacturing compositional data or analytical Information testing results) generated sometime before the hazardous waste determination. 30 Term Definition Identical PV Modules that are from the same manufacturer, have the same model Modules number, and are produced in the same year. Large Quantity “...[A] generator who generates 1,000 kg (2,200 lb) or more of Generator hazardous waste [per month]” (40 C.F.R. §260.10). Legitimately “…[A] secondary hazardous material that must provide a useful Reclaimed contribution to the recycling process or to a product or intermediate of the recycling process; the recycling process that must produce a valuable product or intermediate; the generator and recycler must manage the hazardous secondary material as a valuable commodity when it is under their control; and the product of the recycling process is analogous to a legitimate product or intermediate” (40 C.F.R. §260.43(a)-(b); EPA 2025f). Substantially Similar Similar compositions and design from a different manufacturer or same PV Modules manufacturer produced in the same facility in a different year. Small Quantity “...[A] generator who generates greater than 100 kg but less than 1,000 Generator kg of hazardous waste [per month]” (40 C.F.R. § 260.10). Solid Waste “[A]ny discarded material that is not excluded under 40 C.F.R. §261.4(a) or that is not excluded by a variance granted under 40 C.F.R. §260.30–260.31 or that is not excluded by a non-waste determination under 40 C.F.R. §260.30 and §260.34” (42 U.S.C § 6903(27); 40 C.F.R. § 261.2). Treatment “[A]ny method, technique, or process … designed to change the physical, chemical, or biological character or composition of any hazardous waste so as to neutralize such waste, or so as to recover energy or material resources from the waste, or so as to render such waste nonhazardous or less hazardous; safer to transport, store, or dispose of, or amenable for recovery ... storage, or reduced in volume” (40 C.F.R. § 260.10; 40 C.F.R. § 270.2). 31 References Abdelilah, Yasmina, Heymi Bahar, François Briens et al. 2022. “Special Report on Solar PV Global Supply Chains.” International Energy Agency. https://doi.org/kr9h. AEL (Advanced Environmental Laboratories, Inc). 2025. “FAQ.” Accessed May 12, 2025. https://www.phoslab.com/determining-toxicity-and-the-right-time-for-tclp-testing. Aghaei, M., A. Fairbrother, A. Gok, S. Ahmad, S. et al. 2022. “Review of degradation and failure phenomena in photovoltaic module.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2022.112160. ASTM (ASTM International). 2021. “New Standard Aids in Testing Toxicity of Photovoltaic Modules.” https://newsroom.astm.org/new-standard-aids-testing-toxicity-photovoltaic-modules. _____. 2022. “Standard Practice for Sampling of Solar Photovoltaic Modules for Toxicity Testing.” ASTM E3325-21. September 28, 2022. https://store.astm.org/e3325-21.html. _____. 2025. “What to Expect.” Accessed October 26, 2025. https://www.astm.org/ membership-participation/consumer-participation/what-to-expect. DTSC (California Department of Toxic Substances Control). 2025a. “Photovoltaic (PV) Modules (Including Solar Panels) Universal Waste Management – Frequently Asked Questions.” Accessed May 9, 2025. https://dtsc.ca.gov/solar-panel-faqs/#easy-faq-363943. _____. 2025b. “Toxic Wastes.” Accessed May 12, 2025. https://dtsc.ca.gov/toxic-wastes/. CPSC (California Product Stewardship Council). 2020. “Solar Panel Recycling in California.” Webinar. February 3, 2020. CPUC and CalRecycle (California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery). Memorandum of Understanding Between the California Public Utilities Commission and the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. January 8, 2019. https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/-/media/cpuc-website/divisions/news-and-outreach/documents/news- office/mous/cpuc--calrecycle_mou_fully-exctd_1-8-19.pdf. Curtis, Taylor L., Heather Buchanan, Ligia Smith, and Garvin Heath. 2021a. A Circular Economy for Solar Photovoltaic System Materials: Drivers, Barriers, Enablers, and U.S. Policy Considerations. Golden, CO: NLR. NLR/TP-6A20-74550. https://docs.nlr.gov/docs/fy21osti/74550.pdf Curtis, Taylor L., Heather Buchanan, Garvin Heath, et al. 2021b. Solar Photovoltaic Module Recycling: A Survey of U.S. Policies and Initiatives. Golden, CO: NLR. NLR/TP-6A20-74124. https://docs.nlr.gov/docs/fy21osti/74124.pdf Curtis, Taylor L. and Annick Anctil. 2025. Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Module Facts and Trends. Golden, CO: NLR. NLR/FS-6A20-90740. https://docs.nlr.gov/docs/fy26osti/90740.pdf. 32 DOE (U.S. Department of Energy). 2021. Solar Futures Study. Washington, D.C.: DOE Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy. GO-102021-5621. https://www.energy.gov/sites /default/files/2021-09/Solar%20Futures%20Study.pdf ____. 2022. America’s Strategy to Secure the Supply Chain for a Robust Clean Energy Transition. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Energy. DOE/OP-0014. https://biden whitehouse.archives.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2021/02/24/executive-order-on- americas-supply-chains/. Eisenson, Matthew. 2023. “Opposition to Renewable Energy Facilities in the United States.” Sabin Center for Climate Change Law: May 2023 Edition. https://scholarship.law. columbia.edu/sabin_climate_change/200/. EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). 1980. “Memo, Dietrich to Cooper.” November 18, 1980. RCRA Online (R.O.) #11005. https://rcrapublic.epa.gov/files/11005.pdf. ____. 1986. “Chapter Nine of the SW-846 Compendium: Sampling Plans.” September 1986. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-10/documents/chap9_0.pdf. ____.1989. “Memo, Lowrance to Axtell.” February 23, 1989. RCRA Online (R.O.) #11424. https://rcrapublic.epa.gov/files/11424.pdf ____.1992. “Method 1311: Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure, part of Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste, Physical/Chemical Methods. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files /2015-12/documents/1311.pdf. ____.1994. “Technical Assistance Document for Complying with the TC Rule and Implementing the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP).” New York, NY: EPA Region 2. EPA- 902-B-94-001. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-07/documents/tclp-1994_0.pdf. ____.1996. “Memo, Shapiro to Warshaw.” March 12, 1996. R.O. #14027. https://rcrapublic.epa.gov/files/14027.pdf. ____.2002. “RCRA Waste Sampling Draft Technical Guidance.” EPA530-D-02-002. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Solid Waste. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-10/documents/rwsdtg_0.pdf. ____.2005. Hazardous Waste Management System; Identification and Listing of Hazardous Waste; FDA Pharmaceuticals Waste Exclusion; Final Rule. 70 FR 35122 (June 14, 2005). https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2005-06-14/pdf/05-10197.pdf. ____.2006. “Guidance on Systematic Planning Using the Data Quality Objectives Process.” EPA QA/G-4. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-06/documents/g4-final.pdf. _____. 2015a. Waste Analysis at Facilities that Generate, Treat, Store, and Dispose of Hazardous Wastes – Final. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. EPA 530-R-12-001. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-04/documents/tsdf-wap-guide- final.pdf 33 _____. 2015b. Policy Statement on Federal Register Notices. Washington, DC: U.S. EPA, October 2015. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-10/documents/policy-statement- federal-register.pdf. _____. 2016. “TCLP Questions.” April 4, 2016. https://archive.epa.gov/epawaste/hazard/web/ html/faq_tclp.html. ____. 2022. “Implementation of the Definition of Solid Waste (DSW) Exclusion Found at Title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Section 261.4(a)(24) - Transfer-Based Exclusion vs. Verified Recycler Exclusion.” November 2022. https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/ 202208/ImplementationGuidefortheDSWExclusion_at_40_CFR_261_4_a_24_Final_508.pdf. ___.2025a. “Solar Panel Frequent Questions.” Accessed April 17, 2025. https://www.epa.gov /hw/solar-panel-frequent-questions. ___.2025b. “End-of-Life Solar Panels: Regulations and Management.” Accessed April 22, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/end-life-solar-panels-regulations-and-management. ___.2025c. “State Universal Waste Programs in the United States.” Accessed April 22, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/state-universal-waste-programs-united-states. ___.2025d. “State Authorization under Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA).” Accessed April 22, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/rcra/state-authorization-under-resource- conservation-and-recovery-act-rcra. ___.2025e. “Household Hazardous Waste (HHW).” Accessed April 22, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/household-hazardous-waste-hhw. ___.2025f. “Legitimate Hazardous Waste Recycling.” Accessed April 22, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/legitimate-hazardous-waste-recycling. ___.2025g. “Universal Waste.” Accessed April 25, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/universal- waste. ___.2025h. “Frequent Questions About Hazardous Waste Generation.” Accessed May 1, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hwgenerators/frequent-questions-about-hazardous-waste-generation. ___.2025i. “Improving Recycling and Management of Renewable Energy Wastes: Universal Waste Regulations for Solar Panels and Lithium Batteries.” Accessed June 18, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw/improving-recycling-and-management-renewable-energy-wastes- universal-waste-regulations-solar. ___.2025j. “Hazardous Waste Generator Regulatory Summary.” Accessed July 7, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hwgenerators/hazardous-waste-generator-regulatory-summary#table. ___.2025k. “What a Hazardous Waste Permit Is.” Accessed July 7, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hwpermitting/what-hazardous-waste-permit. 34 ___.2025l. “Sampling Guidance Documents for the SW-846 Compendium (1986).” Accessed October 24, 2025. https://www.epa.gov/hw-sw846/sampling-guidance-documents-sw-846- compendium. Feldman, David, Vignesh Ramasamy, Ran Fu, et al. 2021. U.S. Solar Photovoltaic System Cost Benchmark: Q1 2020. Golden, CO: NREL. NREL/TP-6A20-77324. https://www.nlr.gov/docs/fy21osti/77324.pdf. Fiandra, Valeria, Lucio Sannino, Concetta Andreozzi et al. 2019. “End-of-life of silicon PV panels: A sustainable materials recovery process.” Waste Management 84 (February 2019): 91- 101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2018.11.035. Fischer, Markus, et al. 2021. "International Technology Roadmap for Photovoltaic (ITRPV): Results 2020." 12th ed. VDMA. https://www.vdma.eu/en-GB/international-technology-roadmap- photovoltaic. Fraunhofer ISE: Photovoltaics Report. 2024. https://www.ise.fraunhofer.de/en/publications/ studies/photovoltaics-report.html. Fthenakis, Vasilis and Ken Zweibel. 2003. CdTe PV: Real and Perceived EHS Risks. Golden, CO: NREL. NREL/CP-520-33561. https://www.nlr.gov/docs/ fy03osti/33561.pdf. Fthenakis, Vasilis, Clement Athias, Alyssa Blumenthal, Aylin Kulur, Julia Magliozzo, David Ng. 2020. “Sustainability Evaluation of CdTe PV: An Update.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 109776. May 2020. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S13640321 20300721. GEC (Global Electronics Council). 2025. “Updated EPEAT Criteria.” Accessed June 2, 2025. https://globalelectronicscouncil.org/updated-epeat-criteria/. Hernandez, Melissa. 2020. “County Says No to Proposed Solar Power Farm Near Archer.” The Gainesville Sun. October 7, 2020. https://www.gainesville.com/story/news/local/2020/10/07/alachua-county-says-no-solar-power- farm-proposed-near-archer/5897167002/. Holm, Nancy, and Jennifer Martin. 2019. “Planning for Solar PV End-of-Life Options.” Illinois Sustainable Technology Center. https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/items/112527. IN DEM (Indiana Department of Environmental Management). 2014. “Understanding the Hazardous Waste Determination Process.” Indianapolis, IN: Indiana Department of Environmental Management. https://www.in.gov/idem/waste/files/hw_determination_process. pdf. ISTC (Illinois Sustainable Technology Center). 2019. “Solar Panel End-of-Life Working Group.” https://tap.istc.illinois.edu/programs/renewable-energy-equipment-recover-reuse- program/solar-technology/solar-photovoltaic-pv-end-of-life-eol-working-group/. 35 Iqbal, Nafis, Mengjie Li, Tamil S. Sakthivel, Kurt Mikeska, et al. 2023. “Impact of Acetic Acid Exposure on Metal Contact Degradation of Different Crystalline Silicon Solar Cell Technologies” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 112089. January 2023. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0927024822005062. Kontges, Marc, Sarah Kurtz, Corinne Packard, Ulrike Jahn, Karl A. Berger, Kazuhiko Kato, Thomas Friesen, Haitao Liu, Mike Van Iseghem. 2014. “Review of Failures of Photovoltaic Modules.” International Energy Agency. https://iea-pvps.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/IEA- PVPS_T13-01_2014_Review_of_Failures_of_Photovoltaic_Modules_Final.pdf Latunussa, Cynthia E.L., Fulvio Ardente, Gian Andrea Blengini and Lucia Mancini. 2016. “Life Cycle Assessment of an innovative recycling process for crystalline silicon photovoltaic panels.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 156 (November): 101-111. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.solmat.2016.03.020. Lee, Andrew. 2014. “Using Micro-XRF to Quantify Thickness and Composition of Thin-Film Solar Cells.” American Laboratory. https://www.americanlaboratory.com/914-Application- Notes/154357-Using-Micro-XRF-to-Quantify-Thickness-and-Composition-of-Thin-Film-Solar- Cells/. Li, Fang, Stephanie Shaw, Cara Libby, et al. 2024. “A review of toxicity assessment procedures of solar photovoltaic modules.” 174 Waste Management 646-665. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2023.12.034 Li, Fang, Sai Ravi Tatapudi, Stephanie L. Shaw et al. 2025. Photovoltaic module leach testing: Database development and statistical analysis. 377 Journal of Environmental Management. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2025.124666. Libby, Cara and Stephanie Shaw. 2018. “Solar PV Module End-of-Life: Options and Knowledge Gaps for Utility-Scale Plants.” EPRI Technical Update Report 3002014407. Palo Alto, CA: Electric Power Research Institute. https://www.epri.com/research/products/3002014407. _____. 2019. “Assessing Variability in Toxicity Testing of Photovoltaic Modules.” EPRI Technical Update Report 3002016890. Palo Alto, CA: Electric Power Research Institute. Lin, Kae-Long, Tien-Chun Chu, Ching-Jung Cheng, Ching-Hwa Lee, Tien-Chin Chang, and Kuen-Sheng Wang. 2011. Recycling Solar Panel Waste Glass Sintered as Glass-Ceramics. Environment Progress & Sustainable Energy 31: 612-618. https://doi.org/10.1002/ep.10587 Losurdo, Robert. 2022. “Hazardous Waste Disposal Costs – What to know about transportation fees?” April 6, 2022. https://mcfenvironmental.com/hazardous-waste-disposal-costs-what-to- know-about-transportation-fees/. Maani, Thomas, Ilke Celik, Michael J. Heben, Randall J. Ellingson, and Defne Apul. 2020. “Environmental impacts of recycling crystalline silicon (c-SI) and cadmium telluride (CdTe) solar panels.” Science of the Total Environment 735 (September): 138827. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969720323445. 36 Meidl, Rachel A. 2022. “Solar’s Bright Future Faces a Cloudy Reality: What About All the Waste?” Baker Institute for Public Policy. Rice University. January 12, 2022. https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/solars-bright-future-faces-a-cloudy-reality-what-about- all-the-waste. Mirletz, Heather and Silvana Ovaitt. 2025. “NREL/PV_ICE: 0.4.3 (0.4.3).” Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.13751195. Mirletz, Heather, Henry Hieslmair, Silvana Ovaitt, Taylor L. Curtis, and Teresa M. Barnes. 2023. Unfounded Concerns about Photovoltaic Module Toxicity and Waste are Slowing Decarbonization. 19 Nature Physics 1376, 1376 – 1378. October 2023. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-023-02230-0. MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2019. Minnesota Solar Panel Recycling Strategy Working Group June 27, 2019, Meeting. Nain, Preeti, and Arun Kumar. 2020. Understanding the Possibility of Material Release from End-of-Life Solar Modules: A Study Based on Literature Review and Survey Analysis. 160 Renewable Energy 903 – 918. November 2020. https://www.sciencedirect.com/ science/article/pii/S0960148120311101#bib7. Nain, Preeti and Annick Anctil. 2025. “Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in solar photovoltaic modules,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Volume 215, 2025,115562, ISSN 1364-0321, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2025.115562. NC DEQ (North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality). 2021. “Frequent Questions About Solar Panel Recycling and Disposal” November 17, 2021. https://edocs.deq.nc.gov/Stormwater/DocView.aspx?id=2262125&dbid=0&repo=WaterResourc es&cr=1. NYSDEC (New York Department of Environmental Conservation). 2025. “Rulemaking - Adding Solar Panels to the Universal Waste Regulations.” (Accessed April 25, 2025). https://dec.ny.gov/regulatory/regulations/rulemaking-adding-solar-panels-to-the-universal-waste- regulations. OH DOH (Ohio Department of Health). 2022. “Solar Farm and Photovoltaics Summary and Assessments.” April 2022. https://odh.ohio.gov/know-our-programs/health-assessment- section/media/summary-solarfarms. OR DEQ (Oregon Department of Environmental Quality). 2017. “Fact Sheet: How to Determine if Your Waste is Hazardous.” Portland, OR: Oregon Department of Environmental Quality. https://www.oregon.gov/deq/FilterDocs/DetWasteHaz.pdf. Ovaitt, Silvana, Heather Mirletz, Sridhar Seetharaman, et al. 2022. “PV in the Circular Economy, A Dynamic Framework Analyzing Technology Evolution and Reliability Impacts.” ISCIENCE. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2021.103488. 37 Phoslab Testing Laboratories. 2016. “Determining Toxicity and The Right Time for TCLP Testing.” February 1, 2016. http://phoslab.com/determining-toxicity-and-the-right-time-for-tclp- testing/. _____. 2025. “TCLP Testing.” Accessed May 12, 2025, https://www.phoslab.com/ environmental-services/tclp-testing/. PVQAT (International PV Quality Assurance Task Force) Quarterly Meeting. 2023. Task Group 15: A Circular Economy for PV. June 27, 2023. Ramasamy, Vignesh, Jarett Zuboy, Eric O’Shaughnessy, et al. 2022. “U.S. Solar Photovoltaic System and Energy Storage Cost Benchmarks, With Minimum Sustainable Price Analysis: Q1 2022.” Golden, CO: NREL. NREL/TP-7A40-83586. https://docs.NREL.gov/docs/fy22osti/83586.pdf. Ruhlin, Doug. 2024. “How Much Does Waste & Hazardous Waste Management?” Resource Management Associates. September 30, 2024. https://www.rmagreen.com/rma-blog/how-much- does-waste-hazardous-waste-management-cost. Scarpulla, Michael, Brian McCandless, Adam Phillips et al. 2023. “CdTe-Based Thin Film Photovoltaics: Recent Advances, Current Challenges and Future Prospects: Article No. 112289.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells. March 28, 2023. https://research-hub.NLR.gov/en/ publications/cdte-based-thin-film-photovoltaics-recent-advances-current-challe-2. SC DHEC (South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control). 2022. “Solar Panel Stakeholder Group” https://scdhec.gov/environment/land-management/solar-panel- stakeholder-group. Scherzinger, Alexa. 2021. “Comms restrict county from future wind and solar projects.” The Advertiser Tribune. https://advertiser-tribune.com/news/355495/comms-restrict-county-from- future-wind-and-solar-projects/. Seel, Joachim, Julie Mulvaney Kemp, Anna Cheyette et al. 2024. “Utility-Scale Solar, 2024 Edition: Empirical Trends in Deployment, Technology, Cost, Performance, PPA Pricing, and Value in the United States.” Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. https://emp.lbl.gov/ publications/utility-scale-solar-2024-edition SEIA (Solar Energy Industries Association). 2025. “Solar Supply Chain Traceability Protocol.” Accessed June 2, 2025. https://seia.org/research-resources/solar-supply-chain-traceability- protocol/. Siegfried, G., Taylor Curtis, Cara Libby et al. 2024. PV Module Management Across the Value Chain: Key Takeaways from NSF SOLAR Module Management Working Group. EPRI, Palo Alto, CA. 3002028004. https://www.epri.com/research/products/000000003002028004. 38 Sharma, Hari Bhakta, Kumar Raja Vanapalli, Vikram Kumar Barnwal et al. 2021. “Evaluation of Heavy Metal Leaching Under Simulated Disposal Conditions and Formulation of Strategies for Handling Solar Panel Waste.” Science of the Total Environment 780:146645. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969721017137?via%3Dihub. Singh, Bhuwan Pratap, Sunil Kumal Goyal, and Prakash Kumar. Solar PV cell material and technologies: Analyzing the recent developments. Materials Today: Proceedings, Volume 43, Part 5, 2021. 2843-2849. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.01.003. Sinha, Parikhit, Garvin Heath, Andreas Wade et al. 2019a. Human Health Risk Assessment Methods for PV, Part 3: Module Disposal Risks. International Energy Agency (IEA) PVPS 12, Report T12-16:2020. ISBN 978-3-906042-96-1. https://cupdf.com/document/human-health-risk- assessment-methods-for-pv-be-disposed-in-a-non-sanitary-landfill.html?page=3. _____. 2019b. Human Health Risk Assessment Methods for PV Part 2: Breakage Risks. International Energy Agency (IEA) PVPS 12, Report T12-15:2019. ISBN 978-3-906042-87-9. https://iea-pvps.org/key-topics/iea-pvps-t12-15_human-health-risk-assessment-methods-for-pv- part-2/. Straus, Matthew A. and Charles Bello. 1987. "Letter Requesting Documentation to Demonstrate Known Market or Disposition for Material for Exclusion or Exemption Pursuant to 40 C.F.R. §261.2(f)." June 10, 1987, and June 24, 1987. https://rcrapublic.epa.gov/files/11258.pdf. TamizhMani, GovindaSamy, Cara Libby, Stephanie Shaw et al. 2018. “Evaluating PV Module Sample Removal Methods for TCLP Testing.” Presented at 2018 IEEE 7th World Conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion (WCPEC) Waikoloa, HI, June 10–15, 2018. https://ieeexplore. ieee.org/document/8548084. TamizhMani, GovindaSamy, Stephanie Shaw, Cara Libby et al. 2021. “Sampling Methods for Toxicity Testing of PV Modules for End-of-Life Decisions.” Presented at 2021 IEEE 48th Photovoltaic Specialists Conference (PVSC), Fort Lauderdale, FL, June 20–25, 2021. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9518620. Townsend, Timothy G., Kevin Vann, Sarvesh Mutha et al. 2004. “RCRA Toxicity Characterization of Computer CPUs and Other Discarded Electronic Devices.” University of Florida and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 4 and Region 5. July 15, 2004. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16683614/. Vann, Kevin, Stephen Musson, and Timothy Townsend. 2006. “Evaluation of a modified TCLP methodology for RCRA toxicity characterization of computer CPUs.” Journal of Hazardous Materials. 129 (February 28, 2006): 101-109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2005.08.011. Warren, Chris. 2022. “Why Consistent Sampling is Key to Solar Module Toxicity Testing.” EPRI Journal. June 8, 2022. https://eprijournal.com/why-consistent-sampling-is-key-to-solar- module-toxicity-testing/. 39 WI DNR (Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources). 2023. “Waste Determinations and Recordkeeping.” Madison, WI: Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. Publication WA1152. Revised 2023. https://apps.dnr.wi.gov/doclink/waext/wa1152.pdf Wood Mackenzie. 2025a. U.S. Distributed Solar Leaderboard Q1. _____. 2025b. U.S. Solar Market Insight. 2024 Year in Review Report Data. _____. 2025c. U.S. Solar Market Insight. 2025. Solar PV Capacity Data Q1 2025. _____. 2025d. U.S. Solar Market Insight. 2025. Solar PV Capacity Data Q2 2025. Zuckerman, Jake. 2022. “Ten Ohio counties ban wind, solar projects under new state law.” Ohio Capital Journal. August 23, 2022. https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2022/08/23/nine-ohio-counties- ban-wind-solar-projects-under-new-state-law/. Legal References Executive Orders Exec. Order No. 14017, 86 Fed. Reg. 11849 (2021), America’s Supply Chains. Federal and State Statutes 42 U.S.C. §§ 6901–6992k (1976), Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. 2022. Ill. Laws 102-1025, Renewable Energy Component Recycling Task Force Act. 2023 Ind. S.B. 33, 123rd Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. 2023 Minn. Laws 60-2310. 2019 N.C. Sess. Law 2019-132. 2019 N.J. Sess. Law Serv. Ch. 215. 2022 S.C. Act 119. 2022 Tenn. Pub. Acts 1043, Utility Scale Solar Energy Development. 2023 Tex. S.B. 1290, 88th Leg., R.S. 2022 Va. S.B. 499, 2022 Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. Federal and State Regulations 40 C.F.R. §§ 239–282, Solid Wastes. 40 C.F.R. § 19.4, Statutory Civil Penalties, As Adjusted for Inflation, and Tables. Ariz. Admin. Code Tit. 18 § 8-262, Standards Applicable to Generators of Hazardous Waste. 40 Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 22, § 66261 App. II, Waste Extraction Test (WET) Procedures. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 22 §66262, Standards Applicable to Generators of Hazardous Waste. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 22, § 66273, Standards for Universal Waste Management. Haw. Code R. Tit. 11 § 273, Standards for Universal Waste Management Md. Code Ann., Envir. § 2-1303(g), Working Groups Established N.C. Admin. Code Tit. 15A § 13A .0107, Standards Applicable to Generators of Hazardous Waste Or. Admin Rules Ch. 340 § 102, Standards Applicable to Generators of Hazardous Waste. Tex. Admin Code Tit. 30 §335.53, General Standards Applicable to Generators of Hazardous Waste Tex. Admin Code Tit. 30 §335.504, Hazardous Waste Determination Wash. Admin. Code Tit. 173 § 303, Dangerous Waste Regulations Wash. Rev. Code § 70A.510.010, Photovoltaic Module Stewardship and Takeback Program Federal Register Environmental Protection Agency Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. 85732 (November 28, 2016) (codified at 40 C.F.R. 257 – 279). https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2016-11-28/pdf/2016-27429.pdf. Environmental Protection Agency Rules Hazardous Waste. 45 Fed. Reg. 72024 (October 30, 1980). Local Ordinances Hancock Cty., Ohio, Resolution 250-22 (2022), https://wkxa.com/wp- content/uploads/2022/04/exclusion-zones.pdf Logan Cty., Ohio, Resolution 196-22 (2022), https://www.nosolarinlc.com/post/logan-county- resolution. Madison Cty., Virginia, Zoning Ord. § 2019-12 (2019), https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iBsqhvxF4cI6ypirvTOjRUsal6HkFKvU/view Maricopa Cty., Arizona, Zoning Ord. § 1206.2.1 (2025), https://my.solarroadmap.com/userfiles/Resource-Section_Maricopa-County-Zoning- Ordinance.pdf. Medina Cty., Ohio, Resolution 22-0077 (2022), https://www.medinaco.org/wp- content/uploads/2022/01/Resolutions_1.25.22.pdf 41 Niagara Cty., New York, Local Law No. 4 (2021). https://cms5.revize.com/revize/niagaracounty/Document_center/Department/S-Z/Solar/Solar- Law.pdf Prince George Cty., Virginia, Solar Energy Facility Siting Policy § 2(6)(b) (2020), https://cms1files.revize.com/princegeorgeva/Adopted%20Solar%20Energy%20Siting%20Policy %20-%2008.11.2020.pdf Union Cty., Ohio Resolution 22-296 (2022), https://www.unioncountyohio.gov/information Administrative Body Hearings Amherst Conservation Comm’n. 2021. Meeting Minutes. (Amherst Cty., Massachusetts, October 27, 2021). https://www.amherstma.gov/ArchiveCenter/ViewFile/Item/14087. Buckingham Cty., Bd. Of Supervisors, Minutes from Feb 28, 2022 regular meeting (Buckingham Cty, VA, 2022) 160, https://cms9files.revize.com/buckinghamcounty/ feb%2028%202022%20bos%20pc.pdf Franklin Cty. Bd. Comm’rs. 2022. Regular Session Agenda. (Franklin Cty., TN, 2022). https://www.franklincotn.us/assets/pdfs/agendas_minutes_commission/agendas/2022/04182022. pdf. Osage Cty. Planning Comm’n. 2022. Planning Commission Memo. (Osage Cty., Kansas, 2022). https://ks827.cichosting.com/main/images/pdfs/Osage-County-PC-Memo-on-Alternative- Energy-Amendments-10-06-2217073.pdf. San Bernardino Cty. Bd. Supervisors. Report/Recommendation to the Board of Supervisors of San Bernardino County, California and Record of Action (San Bernardino Cty., CA, 2019). https://s3.amazonaws.com/media.legistar.com/SanBernardino/168/2345487.pdf. Case Law U.S. v. Hoffman, 154 Wash.2d 730, 116 P.3d 999 (Wash. 2005). Legislation H.B. 1333, 31st Leg., Reg. Sess. (Haw. 2021). S.B. 207, 2021-2022 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Cal. 2021). Interviews Barnes, Teresa. May 16, 2023. Written Correspondence. NLR. Barnes, Teresa. February 15, 2024. Written Correspondence. NLR. Boyce, Ken. August 15, 2022. Teleconference. UL. Bui, Teresa. January 8, 2021. Written Correspondence. CalRecycle. 42 Bunnell, Ross. May 3, 2022. Teleconference. Senior Sanitary Engineer, Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection. Ching, Michelle. April 13, 2022. Teleconference. RCRA Compliance & Technical Support, New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Cusack, Tom. March 24, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Specialist, Washington State Department of Ecology. De Vries, Sean. August 9, 2022. Teleconference. Sustainable Electronics Recycling International. Dias, Pablo. August 4, 2022. Teleconference. SOLARCYCLE. Egbon, Alison. April 13, 2022. Teleconference. RCRA Compliance & Technical Support, New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Ellenbecker, Mike. April 5, 2022. Teleconference. Coordinator, Hazardous Waste Program, Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. EPA Headquarters. 2023–2024. Multiple Communications. Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery (ORCR). EPA Headquarters. December 11, 2025. Written Communication. ORCR. Foster, David. May 5, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Protection Specialist, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. Galia, Harsh. August 22, 2022. Teleconference. Hanwha Q Cells. Gaulding, Ashley. May 16, 2023. Written Correspondence. NLR. Gaulding, Ashley. February 15, 2024. Written Correspondence. NLR. Gilkeson, John and Amanda Cotton. March 16, 2023. Written Correspondence. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. Helms, Greg. March 3, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Protection Agency (retired). Jennings, Jonathan. March 24, 2022. Teleconference. Hazardous Waste Program, Washington State Department of Ecology. Kanczuzewski, Tyler. August 4, 2023. Written Correspondence. Inovateus Solar. Kelly, George. July 28, 2022. Teleconference. International Electrotechnical Commission. Keogh, Kelley. August 2, 2022. Teleconference. Greeneye Partners. 43 Killeen, Tom. April 13, 2022. Teleconference. Chief, RCRA Compliance & Technical Support, New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Kolic, Paulina. September 6, 2019. Written Correspondence. CalRecycle. Libby, Cara. August 4, 2022. Teleconference. Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI). Libby, Cara. May 16, 2023. Written Correspondence. EPRI. Matthews, Mitch. April 8, 2022. Teleconference. Manager, Compliance Assurance Section, Ohio Environmental Protection Agency. Mirletz, Heather. May 16, 2023. Written Correspondence. NLR. Muller, Matt. June 30, 2022. Teleconference. NLR. Mulvaney, Dustin. August 10, 2022. Teleconference. San José State University. Newman, Chris. March 10, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Scientist, Environmental Protection Agency, Region 5. Nicholson, Robert. August 4, 2022. Teleconference. Solar Energy Industries Association. O’Connell, Joseph. April 13, 2022. Teleconference. Director, Bureau of Solid Waste Management, New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Parr, Michael. July 27, 2022. Teleconference. Ultra Low-Carbon Solar Alliance. Patterson, Jenny. April 22, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Program Consultant, North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality. Powers, Tim. July 15, 2022. Teleconference. Inovateus Solar. Schurade, Max. August 22, 2022. Teleconference. Hanwha Q Cells. Sharma, Suvi. August 4, 2022. Teleconference. SOLARCYCLE. Shaw, Stephanie. August 4, 2022. Teleconference. Electric Power Research Institute. Smith, Brittany. December 11, 2023. Written Correspondence. NLR. Spivey, Curt. August 1, 2022. Teleconference. Formerly of Cascade Eco Minerals. Stermer, Andrea. April 22, 2022. Teleconference. Environmental Specialist II, North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality. Tao, Meng. Arizona State University. July 29, 2022. Teleconference. 44 Vandeusen, Samantha. April 13, 2022. Teleconference. RCRA Compliance & Technical Support, New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Wagger, David. August 15, 2023. Written Correspondence. ReMA. 45 Appendix A. Methodology The authors conducted legal research, qualitative analysis, and application testing to assess how “generator knowledge” may be used to make a hazardous waste determination—a case of first impression for the photovoltaic (PV) industry. The objective was to understand how knowledge- based determinations have been applied in other industries and approved by U.S. federal and state regulators to ensure accuracy and regulatory defensibility for application to PV modules. The legal analysis examined U.S. federal and state statutes and regulations, federal district and state court decisions, administrative proceedings, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and state guidance documents, and Federal Register notices to evaluate: • The legal standard for making a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination • The forms (e.g., peer-reviewed studies, databases) and sources (e.g., national laboratories, manufacturers) of information that may be used • The information requirements (e.g., constituent concentrations by weight) necessary to ensure an accurate determination • The potential limitations of applying knowledge to PV modules, including whether the timing or age of information affects the validity of a knowledge-based hazardous waste determination. The authors then applied these legal findings to PV module management scenarios to identify sources and forms of information that currently exist—or could be developed—to support accurate, knowledge-based hazardous waste determinations for PV modules. Building on the legal and application analysis, the authors conducted semi-structured interviews to explore how regulators and technical experts interpret what constitutes an “adequate” knowledge-based determination for PV modules, considering both information quality and practical limitations. More than 45 experts participated in semi-structured interviews, including U.S. federal and state solid and hazardous waste regulators and compliance officers; environmental scientists and engineers; testing laboratory specialists; environmental and sustainability professionals; recycling standards auditors; PV module durability and materials scientists; manufacturers; asset owners; and recyclers. Additional U.S. state regulators, industry representatives, and technical experts contributed through follow-up communications and served as expert reviewers of the draft findings (see Acknowledgments and References for details). 46