LA-UR-25-29838 Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. Title: EFFICIENCY PROJECT PLAYBOOK Author(s): Scott, Justin Eric Intended for: Report Issued: 2025-10-02 1. Scope the Effort The scoping phase is crucial for defining the boundaries and objectives of the efficiency improvement project. This involves clearly identifying the specific areas, processes, or departments that will be the focus of the improvement efforts. The scoping phase helps ensure that the project remains focused and aligned with Los Alamos National Laboratory’s (LANL) overall goals and priorities. Key Steps and Templates: • Fill out the Project Plan Overview: The Project Plan Overview will help you outline the steps to get to a decision on whether to proceed with the project and establish a timeline for getting there. • Draft the Project Charter: The Project Charter contains the key items that must be determined before proposing a project for approval. While it may not be possible at this phase to fill out all the details, starting will make you aware of the types of information you will need to collect as you diagnose the problem. Start with a working draft and then update as your plans are informed by your research. • Identify the team members – Analyst Team: Working level collecting the information and developing the plan – Delegate Team: Key stakeholders needed to get to the best decision – Leadership Team: Management level that can approve resources for the project and to whom the working team is responsible for completing the project when it is approved. 2. Diagnose Challenges and Opportunities In this phase, you will diagnose the challenges and opportunities. This phase involves a deep dive into the current state of the organization, identifying the key pain points, bottlenecks, and areas for potential improvement. This may include analyzing data, gathering feedback from employees, and conducting process mapping or other diagnostic tools to uncover the root causes of inefficiencies. The goal is to gain a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and opportunities that exist. Remember to maintain curiosity rather than judgment as you investigate. Existing processes often arose for a reason and understanding that reason may be the key to unlocking a better way that will be adopted rather than resisted. Key Steps and Templates: • Assess the current state (where are we now and why?) and define the ideal state (where do we want to be and why?). Ideas to consider: – Map current system or process – Interview process owners, participants, and customers – Identify bottlenecks, waste, and risk points – Identify best practices or define state of the art  What does industry do?  What do other sites do? – Collect baseline metrics – Document constraints • Brainstorm and prioritize improvement ideas – Ideation Workshop – 5 Whys – Fishbone Diagram • Design target-state process (or select solution prototypes and process) – Create implementation roadmap – Assign roles and responsibilities 3. Develop a Recommendation With a clear understanding of the challenges and opportunities, the next step is to develop and refine potential solutions and approaches into a recommendation. The exploration phase should consider a range of options, weighing the pros and cons of each, to identify the most promising strategies for improving efficiency. This involves synthesizing the insights gathered during the previous phases, evaluating the feasibility and potential impact of the various options, and ultimately selecting the most appropriate strategies to implement. Key Steps and Templates: • Define options and the benefits – [Options/Tradeoff Matrix] – [Effort/Impact Matrix] • Evaluate feasibility and impact – Score ideas using impact-effort matrix – Run risk and feasibility assessments – Perform a Return on Investment using one of the financial viability tools – Identify who can make the decision to approve the project • Select the option to recommend and update the project charter 4. Inform and Make Decisions This phase is focused on making a decision about the correct course of action and getting approval from the right management level to use resources to complete the project. The decision-making process should be data-driven and aligned with LANL’s overall objectives and constraints. Key Steps and Templates: • Write a decision paper or prepare a decision brief • Update the project charter with information gained from the previous phases and submit it to the decision maker • Define the change management strategy (see Leading Organizational Change by Ryan L. Raffaelli for ideas on how best to implement change depending on your project) • Develop metrics scorecard for tracking the project execution 5. Execute When the decisions have been made, the next step is to execute and monitor the project. This phase involves creating detailed action plans, allocating resources, and establishing clear roles and responsibilities. Importantly, it also includes ongoing monitoring and evaluation to track the progress and effectiveness of the efficiency improvement efforts. Regular feedback loops and adjustments may be necessary to ensure the project remains on track and delivers the desired outcomes. Project management methods are beyond the scope of this playbook. 6. Templates See Playbook Templates for the templates for the following templates. Playbook Step Templates 1. Scope the Effort Project Charter Project Plan Overview Action Item Tracker 2. Diagnose Challenges Identify Key Resources and Opportunities Articulating Strategic Direction (From-To) Fishbone Diagram 5 Whys 3. Develop a Options and Tradeoff Matrix Recommendation Effort and Impact Matrix Financial Viability Metrics 4. Inform and Make PowerPoint-Template for Decisional Brief Decisions Roles & Responsibilities Leading Organization Change Article Appendix A: Efficiency Playbook Templates This workbook provides some optional templates to support the initial scoping of efficiency and effectiveness efforts as well as the development of improvement options and decisions on implementation. Contents Scope the Effort .................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 7 Project Charter ................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Project Plan Overview: Timeline, Roles, and Deliverables.............................................................................................................................................. 9 Action Item Tracker ....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 11 Diagnose Challenges and Opportunities ......................................................................................................................................................................... 12 Identifying Key Resources ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 12 Articulating Strategic Direction (From-To Table) ........................................................................................................................................................... 13 Identifying Internal and External Barriers (Ishikawa/Fishbone Diagram)..................................................................................................................... 14 Five Whys Template ...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15 Develop a Recommendation ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 16 Options and Tradeoffs Matrix ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 16 Effort and Impact Matrix ............................................................................................................................................................................................... 17 Financial Viability Metrics ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 18 Inform and Make Decisions ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 19 PowerPoint-Template for Decisional Brief .................................................................................................................................................................... 19 Roles and Responsibilities ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 20 Leading Organizational Change Article ......................................................................................................................................................................... 22 Scope the Effort Project Charter Project Charter.docx Foundation People Creation 🎯🎯 🤝🤝 👥👥 🏗🏗 📦📦 📋📋 🔄🔄 Purpose Sponsorship Stakeholders Resources Deliverables Plan Change Why are we Who is Who will benefit Who will manage What will the How and when How will we doing the project? accountable for from and be the project, and project produce, will the work be engage the project? affected by the which skills are build, or deliver? carried out? stakeholders and project? needed to deliver manage the risks? it? 💰💰 📈📈 Investment Benefits How much will the project cost? What benefits and impact will the project generate, and how will we know the project is successful? What is the financial viability? Table Version of the Above if Additional Space is Needed: Foundation • Purpose (Why are we doing the project?): • Investment (How much will the project cost?): • Benefits (What benefits will the project generate? How will we know if it is successful? Remember that deliverables are not the same as benefits. Ideally, but not always, the deliverable will produce a benefit. It is essential to understand the intended benefits that are expected to result from the deliverables.): People • Sponsorship (Who is accountable for this project?): • Stakeholders (Who will benefit from and be affected by the project?): • Resources (Who will manage the project? Which skills are needed to deliver it?) Creation • Plan (How and when will the work be carried out?): • Deliverables (What will the project produce, build, or deliver?): • Change (How will we engage stakeholders and manage risks?): Project Plan Overview: Timeline, Roles, and Deliverables SCOPE DIAGNOSE DESIGN INFORM IMPLEMENT/MONITOR The Initial Effort Challenges/opportunities Solutions Strategic Decisions Solutions/Impacts Timeframe Roles Analyst Team Delegate Team Leadership Team Activities Deliverables Sample SCOPE DIAGNOSE DEVELOP INFORM/MAKE IMPLEMENT/MONITOR The Initial Effort Challenges/Opportunities Options/Recommendations Strategic Decisions Solutions/Impacts Timeframe May June July August September-December Roles Analyst Team Structure process Gather and assess data Design/facilitate workshop Facilitate decision-making Evaluate impact Delegate Team Clarify purpose Provide input Develop recommendations Share recommendations Implement changes (along Identify stakeholders with other stakeholders) Leadership Team Endorse initial effort Provide input Provide input Make decisions Review/celebrate progress Activities - Scoping meeting(s) - Literature Review - Workshop - Leadership discussion(s) - Implementation kick-off and decision(s) - Interviews - Periodic reviews - Site visits - Project close out - Team celebration Deliverables - Project Charter - Assessment of current state - Overview of Options and - Decision on next steps and - Implementation Plan and desired state Tradeoffs resource investments - Task Tracker - Metrics Scorecard - Overview of Challenges and - Recommendations with ROI Opportunities assessment - Progress Update Action Item Tracker Action Item Tracker.xlsx Category Action Due Date Owner Status Notes Diagnose Challenges and Opportunities Identifying Key Resources KEY RESOURCES Literature Review • Existing strategies • Reports or articles on emerging trends and dynamics Interviewees • Stakeholders • Internal and external knowledge-holders • Creative, unconventional thinkers Site Visits Articulating Strategic Direction (From-To Table) Category From To Identifying Internal and External Barriers (Ishikawa/Fishbone Diagram) Fishbone.xlsx Five Whys Template 5 Whys Template.xlsx Develop a Recommendation Options and Tradeoffs Matrix Improvement Options Pros Cons Option 1: Option 2: Option 3: Option 4: Other? Recommendation(s): Effort and Impact Matrix High Level of Impact Medium Low Low Medium High Level of Effort and Investment Financial Viability Metrics Financial Viability Metrics.docx Because LANL is not a for-profit company, it is not always simple to figure out a way to assess the viability of a project. Here are a few methods that can be used depending on your project. You do not need to use all of them, just those that make sense for your particular project. You should have some way of conveying to those who review the project what the expected returns are. The document above gives more detailed descriptions of each and links to articles showing how to do the calculations in Excel. “There are both simple and sophisticated ways to assess the financial viability of your project. Without a thorough and appropriate financial analysis, there is a great chance the project will end up losing money. To ensure accuracy, have any estimates validated by your finance department. The most common metrics are these: • ROI: measures the project’s gross financial return on the investment, expressed as a percentage of the total estimated cost. • Net present value (NPV): helps you assess what that future money is worth in today’s dollars. If the NPV is positive, it means that the money you are investing today will generate future cash flows that are earning the required amount of return (above the discount rate). A negative NPV means that project may not be worth doing. • Internal rate of return (IRR): the annualized and compounded interest rate that the project will return as a percentage. IRR is perhaps the most difficult to calculate but arguably gives the most accurate financial assessment of a project. A good IRR will be at a minimum more than what you can get by putting your money in the bank. • Payback period: how long it takes to earn back the investment made in the project. You decide on an appropriate period (e.g., two years), and if the project earns back the investment within that period, it’s good. If it takes longer, then it’s not a good idea. • Opportunity costs: the other initiatives that will be missed out on if you decide to carry out this project. If the value of other projects is higher, then you should reconsider which projects you invest in.” Pg 93-94 of HBR Project Management Handbook by Antonio Nieto-Rodriquez Inform and Make Decisions PowerPoint-Template for Decisional Brief PowerPoint-Templa te for Decisional Brie Guidance on Preparing a Decisional Brief using the LANL PowerPoint Template Roles and Responsibilities Description of Responsible/Accountable/Consulted/Informed (RACI) Process to guide accountability and decision making. Roles and Responsibilities.ppt Role Definition Considerations Responsible • “The doer” • Can be exclusive or combined with “Accountable” • Responsible for input gathering, • Is responsible for executing the recommendation if recommendation development, and approved execution post-approval • Can exist for each Business Unit • Obligation to disclose inputs and issues • Execution can be formally delegated to a direct report or to specifically designed team Accountable • “The buck stops here” • Only one “Accountable” per function or decision unless intentionally shared to achieve a better outcome, divided by • Owns decision-making responsibility business unit, and a clear escalation or conflict resolution • Ultimately accountable for the quality of process is defined for impasses outputs and outcomes and overall • Signs off that the process has been followed performance • Responsible for broader business impact, understanding risk • Can redirect actions (shift effort of and value “Responsibles”) Consulted • “In the loop” and “contributing” • The “Responsible” function required to reach out to each “Consulted” function before a final recommendation is • Consulted for input prior to decisions being made to the “Accountable” made • Provide advice on actions • Balance benefits of tapping expertise and including a diversity of perspectives with the costs of time and • Part of an ongoing two-way communications coordination flow Informed • “Kept in the picture” • Should include anyone who will be affected by actions and decisions • Kept informed of developments and decisions • Should be supported by formal, efficient mechanisms (written notices, regular database updates, etc.) rather than • On the receiving end of a generally one-way left to informal channels communications flow Leading Organizational Change Article This article provides different ways of strategizing for organizational change.