A U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY NATIONAL LAB • SAVANNAH RIVER SITE • AIKEN, SC • USA The User Guide for the ComPro Database M.C. Hsieh F.C. Johnson September 2025 SRNL-STI-2009-00093, Revision 2 This work was prepared under an agreement with and funded by the U.S. Government. Neither the U.S. Government or its employees, nor any of its contractors, subcontractors or their employees, makes any express or implied: 1. warranty or assumes any legal liability for the accuracy, completeness, or for the use or results of such use of any information, product, or process disclosed; or 2. representation that such use or results of such use would not infringe privately owned rights; or 3. endorsement or recommendation of any specifically identified commercial product, process, or service. Any views and opinions of authors expressed in this work do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government, or its contractors, or subcontractors. Printed in the United States of America Prepared for U.S. Department of Energy ii Keywords: durability, DWPF Retention: Lifetime The User Guide for the ComPro Database M.C. Hsieh F.C. Johnson September 2025 Savannah River National Laboratory is operated by Battelle Savannah River Alliance for the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. 89303321CEM000080. iii REVIEWS AND APPROVALS AUTHORS: M.C. Hsieh, Glass, Cement, & Ceramic Science F.C. Johnson, Glass, Cement, & Ceramic Science TECHNICAL REVIEW: N. Rod, Glass, Cement, & Ceramic Science, Design Verification per E7 2.60 APPROVAL: W. Jolin, Manager Glass, Cement, & Ceramic Science F. Pennebaker, Director Nuclear & Chemical Processing iv EXECUTIVE SUMMARY An extensive database of glass composition and durability data has been compiled at Savannah River National Laboratory to support the development of nuclear waste glasses. This database is referred to as the Glass Composition-Properties Database (ComPro). The ComPro Database, Revision 3, contains 14,134 total rows of data and 125 columns of composition, durability, as defined by the Product Consistency Test, and other fabrication and characterization information, if available, for each glass. Of the 14,134 total rows, 8,484 rows have been classified as “Model” data and 5,650 rows have been classified as “Non-Model” data. An integral supplement to the ComPro database is the User Guide. The User Guide was developed as a tool to aid the End User in a more effective use of the ComPro database. The User Guide provides a road-map of the specific datasets that comprise the ComPro database (both “Model” and “Non-Model” data) as well as a technical basis for the terminology and definitions the End User will encounter. In this report, a general description of the format and information contained in the User Guide is provided. In addition, specific terminology used in the User Guide is also discussed. v TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................................ vii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................... viii 1.0 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 1 2.0 Quality Assurance.............................................................................................................................. 1 3.0 Format of the User Guide................................................................................................................... 1 3.1 Report Number .............................................................................................................................. 1 3.2 Study Description........................................................................................................................... 1 3.3 Primary Author .............................................................................................................................. 2 3.4 QA Level ....................................................................................................................................... 2 3.5 Model versus Non-Model ............................................................................................................... 2 3.6 Notes ............................................................................................................................................. 3 4.0 Terminology and Specific Units......................................................................................................... 4 4.1 “Composition View” Column and Use of “Reference” ................................................................... 4 4.2 Nomenclature for Shielded Cells Glasses........................................................................................ 4 4.3 Detection Limit Issues .................................................................................................................... 4 4.4 Screened versus Unscreened PCT Responses.................................................................................. 4 4.5 Units of Normalized PCT Information ............................................................................................ 5 4.6 Significant Figures ......................................................................................................................... 5 4.7 Converting Oxides ......................................................................................................................... 5 4.8 Abbreviations................................................................................................................................. 5 5.0 Model and Non-Model Data Tables ................................................................................................... 5 6.0 References....................................................................................................................................... 65 vi LIST OF TABLES Table 1-1. Information Regarding the ComPro Database, Revision 3 ....................................................... 1 Table 4-1. Abbreviations Used in the ComPro User Guide ....................................................................... 5 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3)........................................................................................ 6 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) .............................................................................. 52 Table 5-3. Data Excluded from ComPro ................................................................................................ 64 vii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ARG-1 Analytical Reference Glass 1 ARM-1 Approved Reference Material 1 bc bias corrected BCC box centerline cooled CCC canister centerline cooled ComPro Composition-Properties DOE Department of Energy DWPF Defense Waste Processing Facility EA Environmental Assessment HLW high-level waste LAW low-activity waste mol% mole percent msrd measured msrd bc measured bias corrected NC normalized release PCT Product Consistency Test Q quenched QA quality assurance QARD Quality Assurance Requirements and Description REDOX reduction/oxidation SRNL Savannah River National Laboratory SRS Savannah River Site V&V verification and validation wt.% weight percent XRD X-ray diffraction viii 1.0 Introduction The Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) supports glass composition development for the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) at the Savannah River Site (SRS). Taylor et al. developed an extensive database containing pertinent glass composition and durability information to aid in this work.1 This database is the Glass Composition – Properties (ComPro) database. The ComPro database (Revision 3) contains 14,134 rows of glass composition data, durability results as defined by the Product Consistency Test (PCT)2, and other fabrication and characterization information if available. Of the 14,134 total rows, 8,484 have been classified as “Model” data and 5,650 rows have been classified as “Non-Model” data in Revision 3. An integral supplement to the ComPro database is the User Guide. The user guide was developed as a tool to aid the End User in a more effective use of the ComPro database. The User Guide provides a road-map of the specific datasets that comprise the ComPro database (both “Model” and “Non-Model” data) as well as a technical basis for the terminology and definitions the user will encounter. In this report, a general description of the format and information contained in the User Guide is provided. In addition, specific terminology used in the User Guide is also discussed. Table 1-1 provides information regarding the ComPro Database, Revision 3. Table 1-1. Information Regarding the ComPro Database, Revision 3 Model Rows 8,484 Non-Model Rows 5,650 Total Rows 14,134 Date Stamp Monday, July 7, 2025 Time Stamp 2:05:00 PM 2.0 Quality Assurance This work was requested via a Technical Task Request and directed by a Task Technical and Quality Assurance Plan.3,4 The functional classification of this task is Production Support. This work follows the quality assurance (QA) requirements of RW-0333P.5 Microsoft Excel and JMP 16.0.0 were used to support this work.6,7 Requirements for performing reviews of technical reports and the extent of review are established in Manual E7, Procedure 2.60.8 This document was reviewed by a Design Verification. SRNL documents the Design Verification using the SRNL Technical Report Design Checklist contained in WSRC-IM-2002-00011, Rev. 2.9 The completed Design Checklist for this report are stored in electronic laboratory notebook experiment L6390-00413-43. 3.0 Format of the User Guide Information in the User Guide is presented in two tables – “Model” data and “Non-Model” data based on the classification of the data listed in the ComPro database. Specific information contained in each of the tables includes the report number, a general description of the study, the primary author of the report, and the QA Level (including the classification of “RW-0333P Compliant”, “RW-0333P Equivalent”, or “Non- RW-0333P Compliant”), as defined by SRNL-STI-2009-00094, Revision 2.10 A column for notes is also given in each of the tables. Each of these descriptive columns is discussed in more detail below. 3.1 Report Number The “Report Number” column lists the primary document(s) from which the data were obtained. Supplements, such as glass selection reports or memos, are also listed in this column as warranted. 3.2 Study Description The “Study Description” column provides a high-level summary of the study from which the data were obtained (e.g., a high-level waste (HLW) or low-activity waste (LAW) study, “generic” glass IDs may be 1 identified, reference to the Department of Energy (DOE) site for which the work was performed may be specified, etc.). This information may be beneficial to some End Users who are interested in specific studies or groups of studies associated with a common DOE site or waste stream. 3.3 Primary Author The “Primary Author” column lists the primary author of the report from which the specific data or datasets were obtained. 3.4 QA Level The “QA Level” column classifies each study or dataset as “RW-0333P Compliant”, “RW-0333P Equivalent” or “Non-RW-0333P Compliant”. SRNL-STI-2009-00094, Revision 2 provides a detailed description of the process used to determine this classification.10 The designation of “RW-0333P Compliant” as presented in the “QA Level” column of the User Guide and ComPro database indicates that the data were originally obtained under a program that met the DOE/RW- 0333P Quality Assurance Requirements and Description (QARD). The designation of “RW-0333P Equivalent” as presented in the “QA Level” column of the User Guide and ComPro database indicates that the data is qualified to the DOE/RW-0333P QARD as described by SRNL-STI-2009-00094, Revision 2 using “equivalent controls”.10 The designation of “Non-RW-0333P Compliant” indicates that the data could not be classified as RW-0333P Compliant or Equivalent based on the information provided. 3.5 Model versus Non-Model In addition to the QA review, a technical review of the data or datasets was made to assess potential issues or discrepancies between the database entries and the source from which the data came. The technical review should not be confused with the verification and validation (V&V) process in which each cell entry was verified against the original data source (see WSRC-RP-2004-00704).1 The technical review was a more “global” assessment of the data in terms of consistency. Examples of these inconsistencies or technical issues, which were cited during the development of Revision 0, are discussed below. In one case, the electronic data source listed several minor components that were associated with an “Others” group.a The use of an “Others” group was confirmed by the original source document but the “Others” compositions were not described. Therefore, confirmation of the electronic values in the database could not be made. The result was to classify the dataset as “Non-Model” data independent of the QA Level classification. Another specific example encountered was where the electronic database listed glass compositions in weight percent (wt.%) but the original data source listed the glasses in mole percent (mol%). Independent calculations were made to convert the reported mol% values to wt.% values but these resulted in values that did not agree with the database entries. Again, the dataset was classified as “Non-Model” data independent of the QA Level classification. In another case, the electronic dataset identified a specific oxide and wt.% value for each glass. However, in the original data source (or report) that oxide was not listed. For those situations in which resolution of the discrepancies could not be made, the data were technically classified as “Non-Model” data regardless of “QA Level” classification. Again, the technical review of the data was not a verification of the individual cell entries but a more “global” assessment to ensure that the data entered into the ComPro database was reconcilable with the original data source in a broad sense. a The “Others” component is a group of several oxides whose concentrations are so small (minor components) that instead of expressing each oxide as an individual component, they are grouped, and the percentage of “Others” is presented in the targeted composition. 2 In cases where there were no technical issues or discrepancies with the data, the data were classified as “Model” data if the QA assessment classified the data as “RW-0333P Compliant or Equivalent”. If the QA assessment classified a specific dataset as “Non-RW-0333P Compliant” the dataset was classified as “Non- Model” data by default. Therefore, the terms “Model” data and “Non-Model” data (as used in reference to the ComPro database) are defined as follows: Model Data – Data that may be used for any work that requires compliance with or equivalency to DOE/RW-0333P QARD.5 Data designated as “Model” Data were either “RW-0333P Compliant” or “RW-0333P Equivalent” and no technical issues were identified with the dataset. Non-Model Data – Data that may not be used for work that requires compliance with DOE/RW- 0333P QARD. These data were either classified as “Non-RW-0333P Compliant” and/or technical issues with the dataset were identified and not resolved prior to the issuance of the database. Section 5.0 provides more specific information regarding the classifications of “Model” and “Non-Model” data. End Users of this database are encouraged to identify data or datasets which may have been misclassified based on the technical review. If misclassifications are found or suspected, sufficient evidence to upgrade or reclassify the data should be presented to the database gatekeeper and/or the appropriate SRNL personnel. SRNL-STI-2009-00094, Revision 210 provides a detailed discussion of the protocols of how existing data within the ComPro database can be reclassified. Continual improvement of the database, whether it be the reclassification of datasets or the importing of new data, is critical as the End User should have access to the most recent and reliable data available. 3.6 Notes Perhaps of most interest to the End User is the information presented in the “Notes” column. In the “Model” data section (or Table 5-1), four potential subsections are listed in this column: (1) Compositions, (2) PCTs, (3) General, and (4) X-ray diffraction (XRD). For the composition and PCT sections, specific information (e.g., table numbers) is presented to indicate the precise location from which the data shown in the database were obtained (and used in the V&V process). Additional information is included in the composition column when the target composition view was based on an “Others” component.a The information supplied in the composition section should provide the basis from which the minor component values were computed and entered into the ComPro database (when applicable). In the “General” section, supplemental information is provided that was deemed inappropriate for either the composition or PCT sections, but which provides additional insight into the dataset being reviewed. For example, an attempt to highlight those studies in which a non-zero reduction/oxidation (REDOX) value was intentionally induced is made through the User Guide via a statement such as “REDOX associated with these glasses”. This statement should alert the End Users that REDOX values greater than 0 could be associated with some (or all) of the study glasses within the dataset. Although a relatively thorough review of the “Model” data has been performed, it is possible that all the studies or individual glasses have not been “flagged” appropriately in this revision. This information is provided so that the End User may have the opportunity to partition the REDOX sensitive species accordingly to more effectively assess the impact of REDOX on durability (or another property of interest) if desired. In addition to the REDOX information, pH values supporting the PCT data may be useful to some End Users. Although columns have been developed in the ComPro database for pH information, specific values were not entered. For those original source documents which contained pH information, a general statement has been added to the User Guide. In the “Non-Model” data section (or Table 5-2) the “Notes” column provides a detailed description of the technical issue(s) with the data or datasets that, if resolved, could reclassify the data assuming it is RW-0333P compliant or RW- 0333P equivalent. 3 The End User is strongly encouraged to review and use the User Guide. It is an effective and efficient mechanism to address specific issues and alert the End User to potential technical issues associated with the data that may need to be addressed for certain uses of the data. 4.0 Terminology and Specific Units The ComPro database (as well as the User Guide) utilizes several abbreviations, unique terminology, and standard reference compositions and/or PCT responses for certain glasses. Therefore, it is critical to identify these issues to ensure that the End User can effectively utilize the database. These items are listed below with a brief discussion to provide a technical basis. 4.1 “Composition View” Column and Use of “Reference” Three possible composition views for each glass could be presented in the database. These include target, measured, and measured bias corrected (msrd bc). Target compositions represent the targeted composition for a particular glass. When measured (sometimes referred to as “analyzed” in the source report) compositions were provided, these values were also included in the database. Some reports (in particular the SRNL reports associated with DWPF studies) also provide a msrd bc composition view. This view is based on the measured values being bias corrected to an internal glass standard (or standards) which was analyzed with the “unknown” glasses. In addition to these composition views, the database contains several entries for the Environmental Assessment (EA) and Approved Reference Material 1 (ARM-1), and Analytical Reference Glass 1 (ARG-1) glasses. Unless specifically stated by the original source document, the target composition views for both EA and ARM-1 were based on the reported values.11 The End User will observe an entry of “Reference” in the “Compositional View” column for these two glasses. It should be noted that the ARM-1 and EA glasses are typically used to demonstrate “control” or provide a reference point for the PCT, respectively. Their compositions are not typically re-measured as part of the control process. Any exceptions to the composition or PCT information for these two glasses are noted in the User Guide. 4.2 Nomenclature for Shielded Cells Glasses The work performed in the SRNL Shielded Cells typically involves the fabrication and testing of a single glass sample from actual HLW in support of the qualification process. A Glass ID nomenclature was assigned in the database if the report did not provide a succinct labeling scheme. 4.3 Detection Limit Issues In several original data sources, the composition information (in particular for the measured or msrd bc composition views) indicated a “<” value or a “blank” entry. In those cases, the corresponding database entry was “0”. It is noted that for some studies, the author(s) of the original data report elected to handle the “<” values reported from the supporting analytical service differently. For example, some authors used ½ the detection limit as the reported value. In those cases, the reported value in the original data source document was entered in the database. 4.4 Screened versus Unscreened PCT Responses In some original source documents, two tables or two views of the normalized PCT data are presented: (1) Pre-Screened and (2) After Screened. The use of the terminology “screening” refers to the assessment of potential water loss as specified by the PCT procedure.2 In all cases where two tables were presented, the “after-screening” values (i.e., the resulting values where the replicates had been screened for potential water loss) were entered into the database. 4 4.5 Units of Normalized PCT Information In compiling the ComPro database, two units for normalized elemental PCT information were found: (1) g/L and (2) g/m2. All database entries are presented as g/L values. For those reports that listed the units as g/m2, each value was converted to g/L through a simple multiplication factor (i.e., multiply the g/m2 value by 2 to convert to g/L). The User Guide identifies those studies in which the PCT responses were reported as g/m2. 4.6 Significant Figures Throughout the ComPro database, values are reported with a larger number of figures than are (or may be) significant. The End User is only made aware of this potential given they are ultimately responsible for the model(s) or approach(es) that are potentially developed from these data. 4.7 Converting Oxides For Revision 3, all SO3 measured, msrd bc, and target compositional data has been converted from reported SO4 data. 4.8 Abbreviations Table 4-1 provides a list of abbreviations that are used in the ComPro Use Guide. Table 4-1. Abbreviations Used in the ComPro User Guide msrd measured msrd bc measured bias corrected Q quenched Canister Centerline CCC Cooled BCC box centerline cooled NC normalized release 5.0 Model and Non-Model Data Tables Based on the two-phased approach discussed in Section 3.0, each dataset was classified as “Model” or “Non-Model” data based on QA and technical assessments. The User Guide is divided into three tables. There are two major tables based on the classification of “Model” and “Non-Model” data. Table 5-1 contains the “Model” data while Table 5-2 contains the ‘Non-Model” data as currently defined in Revision 2. Table 5-3 contains data that were reviewed for possible entry into the ComPro database but were ultimately excluded for the reasons detailed in the table. 5 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 INEEL/EXT-02-00386 SBW CVS Scholes RW-0333P Compositions: Phase 1 Equivalent • Table A.1 (target) – (starting on p. A6) • Table A.6 (msrd, msrd bc) – (starting on p. A37) • “Others” are calculated from “Others” compositions in Table 6 (p. 17) (SBW1-01 to SBW1-62) and Table 7 (p. 17) (SBW1-63 and SBW1-64) PCTs: • Table 14 (target) (p. 58) • Table 15 (msrd) (p. 60) General: • SBW1-34 is reported as misbatched (p.57) and therefore moved to the “Non-Model” section of the database. • “% Others” in glass in Table A.1 (starting on p. A6) lists several glasses having suspect data points: SBW1-19, -30, -33, -45, -49, and -52. These glasses have been placed in the “Non- Model” section of the database. 6 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 INEEL/EXT-2000-00110 INEEL Run 78 Musick RW-0333P Compositions: Pilot Calcine Compliant • Tables 2.19, 3.24, 3.37 Demonstration • Table 3.24 - the target comp for GLA78-9-11, - 15 and -18 are represented by the Frit 9 target composition listed in the last column of the table. • Table 3.37 - the target comp for GLA78-10-14, - 15 and -16 are represented by the Frit 10 target composition listed in the last column of the table. • Target glass compositions for DZr-9-78-40 and DZr-10-78-40 as listed in the database were calculated from the DZr-9 and DZr-10 frit compositions and the Run 78-D waste composition as shown in Table 2.19 assuming a 40% waste loading. PCTs: • Tables 2.17, 3.26, 3.27, 3.39, and 3.40 • PCT values in report are expressed as g/m2; converted to g/L in database. General: • REDOX associated with this report – see Tables 3.25 and 3.38. • Frit 5 glasses were moved to non-model because of inconsistency between msrd and target values throughout the report. • DZr-10-78-38 and DZr-10-78d-38 are same glass 7 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 INEEL/EXT-2000-01566 INEEL CVS Scholes RW-0333P Compositions: Phase 3 Equivalent • Table 2 summarizes the target compositions (expressed as mass fraction). • Glass IDs ending with “b” are in the supplemental table below Table 2. • % “Others” in glass (mass fraction) is shown in Table 2. • The “Others” composition is shown in Table 4. PCTs: • Table 11 – PCT values in report are listed as log NC (g/L). Database PCTs are reported as NC (g/L) based on a calculated or converted value. General: • pH values listed in Table 11 0 PNL-10191 West Valley Olson RW-0333P Compositions: CVS glasses Equivalent • Table 3.2 (msrd), target compositions not provided. • The nomenclature for WDGR-14R (compositional view, see Table 3.2, p. 3.3) corresponds to WVDG-14R (PCT information, see Table 4.2 on p. 4.4). More specifically, recognition of an inconsistent nomenclature issue: WDGR versus WVDG. PCTs: • Table 4.1 (1 through 8) • Table 4.2 (11 through 14, REDOX) • Table 4.3 (15 through 30) • Table 4.4 (33 through 48) • All PCT values are reported as g/m2 in report but were converted to g/L in database. General: • Glasses with “R” in Glass ID (see Table 4.2) have REDOX associated with them. 8 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 PNNL-11050 Hanford Hrma RW-0333P Compositions: PNL-10359 CVS Phase 1 Equivalent • The as batched (or targeted) compositions shown and 2 in the database come from Tables A1 (quenched) and A4 (Canister Centerline Cooled) from PNNL-11050. • The target composition for CVS2-101 CCC is in error in PNNL-11050, Table A.4. The target composition for CVS2-101 in Table A1 (PNNL- 11050) and Table A.3 (PNL-10359) agree and were therefore used in the database for the ccc target view. • “Others” compositions from PNNL-11050 were calculated from the following tables in PNL- 10359: o Table 4.1 (“Substitute Others” column), o Table 4.8 (“Internal Standard” column), o Tables 4.10, or o Table 4.13 as outlined in Footnote d of Table 4.15 on p. 4.34 of PNL-10359. • The source for “Others” for CVS2-100 is not identified in Footnote d associated with Table 4.15. The “Others” composition for CVS2-100 can be found on page 4.28 of PNNL-10359. PCTs: • Data in PNNL-11050 are in units of g/m2 (converted to g/L in database). • The PCTs in model data were checked from Tables A.1 and A.4 of PNNL-11050. It should be noted that replicate PCT data are reported for some glasses. When applicable, the database reflects the average of the replicates except as noted below: o CVS1-2 CCC PCTs calculated by replicates 2.2 and 2.3. o CVS2-103 CCC PCTs calculated by replicate 126.1 only. 9 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR o CVS2-25 CCC PCTs calculated by replicates 48.2 and 48.3. o CVS2-35 CCC PCTs calculated by replicates 58.1 and 58.3. o CVS2-88 PCTs calculated by replicate 111.2 only. o CVS2-79 calculated by replicate 102.1 only. General: • pH values in Table A.1 and Table A.4 of PNNL- 11050. • All CVS3 glasses are considered non-model data. • CVS2-95 was placed in the “Non-Model” section of the database due to a discrepancy between Table 4.13 “Others” composition (from PNL- 10359) and the reported compositions in Table A.3 (from PNL-10359 – example: BaO). 0 PNNL-12202 Zr Study Vienna RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Target compositions reported in Table 3.2 (as mass fraction). No msrd or msrd bc compositional views reported. • % “Others” in glass from Table 3.2. • “Others” composition is a footnote to Table 3.2. • Minor components for target compositions were calculated using the “Others” information associated with Table 3.2. PCTs: • Table 4.1 (PCT values expressed as g/m2 in report, converted to g/L in database). General: • No pH values or NC [Si] values reported. 10 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 PNNL-12234 INEEL SBW Vienna RW-0333P Compositions: 1999 Equivalent • Table 3.1(target compositions expressed as mass fraction, converted to wt.% in database) PCTs: • Table 3.5 (expressed as g/m2 in the report, converted to g/L in the database) General: • Unclear whether PCT response for SBW-1-LSM (Table 5.4) was normalized based on SBW-LSM msrd or target composition (Table 5.2), therefore it was moved to the “Non-Model” section of 0 PNNL-13744 HLP glasses Vienna RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Table 2.1 - target compositions • Table A.1 - msrd compositions PCTs: • Table B-14a – normalized based on target compositions • Table B-14b – normalized based on msrd compositions • All PCT responses are labeled as CCC (in the database) unless a “Q” is appended to the Glass ID which denotes a quenched glass. • The glasses are listed as CCC in the database but the potential differences and/or impacts between a DWPF CCC cooling schedule and a box centerline cooling (BCC) schedule for Hanford LAW glass must be recognized. • No NC [Li] values are reported in PNNL-13744. 11 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 PNNL-14050 SBW Melter Vienna RW-0333P Compositions: Glass Equivalent • Appendix A shows target and msrd compositions Formulation • “<” values reported in the document were listed in the database as “0”. • Only target compositions for SBW-11-30 and SBW-24-18.5 are listed in the database. The target compositions were calculated from Tables 2.1 (using the 2001-WM-180 simulant) and Table 5.2 (for the additives or frit compositions) and assuming a 30 and 18.5% waste loading, respectively. Note the glass ID indicates the frit composition (11 or 24) and the waste loading is reflected by the 30 or 18.5. • 3rd decimals for some comps on p. A.4 were indiscernible. All comps from this page should be checked to match the 2nd decimal exactly as seen in the report with the database (no rounding). PCTs: • Table 6.7 (both quenched and ccc values shown, units are in g/m2 in the report which are converted to g/L in database). 12 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 SRT-ASG-95-0038 DWPF WP-14 Edwards RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-ASG-95-0039 Study Compliant • Table B.1 (p. 54-68) of SRT-ASG-95-0038 • Table B.1 uses the LIMS ID to find the glass ID corresponding to the LIMS ID, see p. 44-48 of SRT-ASG-95-0038. There are two LIMS IDs per glass, so the database values are the averages of the two values. • Only msrd compositions are listed in the database and report. • The report lists oxides only by the elementals, therefore elementals with multiple oxidation states were unclear. These oxides were reported in this database as follows: o Mn was assumed to be MnO. o Copper was reported as the oxide wt.% of ½ the elemental value (avg. report value/2.5036 for ½ elemental, and ½ elemental times 1.2518 for CuO and ½ elemental times 1.1259 for Cu2O). o Fe was assumed to be Fe2O3. PCTs: • Table B.1 of SRT-ASG-95-0039 • The database PCTs are the average of 3 replicates. 0 VSL-01R2540-2 RPP-WTP HLW Kot and RW-0333P Compositions: Formulation Pegg Equivalent • Compositions are throughout the report in various tables. • Some SO3 values came from analysis by XRF. PCTs: • PCTs are throughout report in various tables. 13 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 VSL-01R3560-2 RPP-WTP LAW Muller RW-0333P General: Formulation Equivalent • LAWC22 comp ID (Table 22) contains “**” which means no SO4 removal assumed; PCT ID (Table 43) does not contain this nomenclature. • LAWC15 comp ID (Table 22) contains “*” which means SO4 removal assumed; PCT ID (Table 43) does not contain this nomenclature. • LAWC12 for AN107 comp ID (Table 19) corresponds to LAWC12 PCT ID (Table 43). • Some target SO3 values reported from XRF analysis (target value is included in some tables). • Missing row identifier in Table 14, p T-23 assumed to be Re2O7. • LAWB45 was moved to the non-model section of the database due to an inconsistency between Table 23 and Table 67. 0 WSRC-RP-2002-00022 DWPF SRAT Cozzi RW-0333P Compositions: Tank 40 Compliant • Table 4 PCTs: • Table 5 0 WSRC-RP-92-18 Batch 1 Study Schumacher RW-0333P • The glasses in THERMO model data were Compliant validated through a re-creation of the THERMO model. • The glasses from the original Glass Warehouse were listed as msrd comps, but the report appears to have target values. Due to the discrepancy, these glasses were shifted to the “Non-Model” section of the database pending a source with msrd comps. 14 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-RP-95-0539 New Schumacher RW-0333P Compositions: Schumacher Compliant • Appendix A (target compositions only) glasses o Anions (F, Cl, SO3) concentrations listed below the total sum of oxides. • Due to no information on the oxidation state of Te, the value shown below the sum of oxides was not added. • Glasses 14A, 14B and 14C as listed in the database are represented as Glass ID “14” in the • Fe, Cu, and Mn were changed from the original Glass Warehouse entries to as reported in the reference. • Glasses T1, T2, and T3 as listed in the database are represented as Glass ID “T” in the database. • MoO2 is listed in Appendix A of the report but is assumed to be MoO3 as shown in the database. PCTs: • Table 4 lists the PCT response as log NC(g/L). Values reported in database are 10^(Log value as reported in the WSRC-RP-95-0539). General: • Additional PCT data for EA and specially heat- treated glasses are available in Table 5. • REDOX glasses are associated with this report. 0 WSRC-RP-95-1045 SB1A VS Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: (WP200 and Compliant • Tables 9 through 14 WP202 Series) • Both target and msrd (or “analyzed”) compositions are shown in the report. However, only the msrd compositions are shown in the database given the PCT values were normalized to the msrd compositions. PCTs: • Table 16 15 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-RP-96-20 SB1A VS Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: (WP200 series Compliant • Tables 5 and 6 continued) • Both target and msrd (or “analyzed”) compositions are shown in the report. However, only the msrd compositions are shown in the database given the PCT values were normalized to the msrd compositions. • As noted in Section 5.2 of the report, some analyzed values that were below detection limits were replaced by the target value. PCTs: • Table 8, p.13 General: • Table 6 headers indicate glasses WP200-6 through WP200-10 but actually WP200-11 through WP200-16 are shown. 0 WSRC-RP-98-00351 Confirmation Fellinger RW-0333P Compositions: Run of DWPF Compliant • Table 7 SME Cycle Tank PCTs: 42 Frit 200 • Table 5 (High level caves glass) 16 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-TR-2000-00351 Tank 8 and 40- Harbour RW-0333P Compositions: SB2 VS Frit 200 Compliant • Appendices 1 and 3 (“st” glasses) • The “B” nomenclature (which stands for a rebatched glass) as shown in the database is not used in Appendix 1 or 3 of the report. For example, st04 is shown in Appendix 1 but st04B is shown in the database. • See general note below regarding possible double rounding errors in this data set. PCTs: • Appendices 2 and 4 General: • During review of Draft I of ComPro Database (see WSRC-NB-2003-00042), rounding error differences prompted a more thorough review of this report. That review resulted in the identification of potential “double rounding” errors. More specifically, it appears that additional averaging steps were performed in the report (rounding/truncating) but were not reflected in the electronic version of the data. The end user of the database should be aware that these potential rounding issues are present but not deemed to be critical errors. 0 WSRC-TR-2000-00358 ROC Phase 1 Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: (“rc” glasses) Compliant • Table E.3, p. 97-99 (target, msrd and msrd bc). PCTs: • Table VI, p. 22-24 • Note: “CCC” is listed in the database but the nomenclature in the report is “clc”. The heating schedules are the same; only the nomenclature differs. 17 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00123 FY01 PHA Edwards / RW-0333P Compositions: glasses Harbour Compliant • Table 4 (target, msrd and msrd bc). • Target values for P2O5, ZnO, Cl and F as listed in the database are from Table 1 on p. 2. • SO4 values from Table 1 on p. 2 in the report were converted to SO3 and entered into database for target compositions. PCTs: • Table 8 p. 12 • The headers for CCC NC Si (g/L) and CCC NC Li (g/L) on Table 8, p. 12 are switched. 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00124 FY01 CST Edwards / RW-0333P Compositions: glasses Harbour Compliant • Table 4 (target, msrd and msrd bc). • Target values for P2O5, ZnO, Cl and F as listed in the database are from Table 1 on p. 2. • SO4 values from Table 1 on p. 2 in the report were converted to SO3 and entered into database for target compositions. PCTs: • Table 8, p. 11 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00131 MR Study of Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: MB3 – Frit 320 Compliant • Table 14 (target, msrd and msrd bc). Development PCTs: (“MB3N” and • Table 16 – “N” nomenclature glasses “MB3U” • Table 18 – “U” nomenclature glasses glasses) • The IDs in the PCT tables of the report are abbreviated forms of the composition IDs. • The ARM-1 and EA glasses in the database have an additional identifier on the Glass ID to differentiate the 2 ARM-1s and 2 EAs in the report. 18 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00166 DP glasses for Pittman et RW-0333P Compositions: INEEL HLW al. 2001 Compliant • Table 6 - msrd o “<” values shown in Table 6 are documented as “0” in the database. • Table 3 - target o Table 3 lists comps as mass fractions which were converted to wt.% in the database. • There is a discrepancy in the targeted Na2O value for DP-15 between Table 3 (0.08 mass fraction) and Table 6 (0.05 as a mass fraction). The target value in the database (8 wt.%) for DP-15 is the value from Table 3 since using the 0.08 value in Table 6 results in a sum of oxide = 1. Note target composition for DP-15 in Table 6 sums to 97% - a difference of 3%. • Msrd SO3 values are represented by the targeted values as shown in Table 6. • No msrd-bc compositional views are reported. PCTs: • Table 13 (quenched) • Table 14 (CCC) • PCT values are reported as g/m2 in report. Values have been converted to g/L in database. General: • pH values included in report. • No NC [Si] values are reported for either quenched or CCC glasses. 19 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00295 INEEL SBW Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: FY2001 Compliant • Target compositions are not shown in the report. • Target compositions were calculated from the 2000 SBW waste composition (Table 2, p. 4) and the frit compositions (Table 5, p. 8) with the corresponding waste loading. • Waste loading is identified through the glass ID or nomenclature (i.e., SBW-2-25 indicates that the glass is based on the 2000SBW simulant (Table 2), Frit SBW-2 (Table 5), at a waste loading of 25%). • It should be noted that B2O3, Fe2O3, CaO, and/or BaO are present in both the 2000 SBW simulant and the frit composition. The contribution of each of these oxides from both the waste and sludge were considered in calculating the target compositions (i.e., their contributions from both waste and frit were additive). PCTs: • Table 15 – Liq. (glasses produced from the liquid simulant). • Table 9 – Dry (glasses produced using reagent grade (or dry) batch chemicals). • PCT values are reported as g/m2 in report. Values have been converted to g/L in database. 20 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2001-00511 SB2 VS with Herman RW-0333P Compositions: WSRC-RP-2001-00775 Frit 320 glasses Compliant • Table A.4 of WSRC-TR-2001-00511 (target, (“NS” glasses) msrd and msrd bc). • Major oxides for target compositions come from Table A.4 while minor components (or “Others”) must be calculated. • Table 14 of WSRC-RP-2001-00775 provides the “Others” composition. • Tables 13, 17 and 18 of WSRC-RP-2001-00775 provides the “% Others” in glass (on a mass fraction basis). • Note: target concentrations for Cr2O3, P2O5, TiO2, and ZrO2 (considered minor components associated with “Others”) are also shown in Table A.4 (WSRC-TR-2001-00511). PCTs: • Display 3 (p. 82) of WSRC-TR-2001-00511. 0 WSRC-TR-2002-00096 Confirmation Fellinger RW-0333P Composition: Run of DWPF Compliant • Table 7 SRAT & SME PCTs: Tank 40 • Table 8 (high level caves General: glass) • pH values included in Table 8 of the report 21 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2002-00120 ROC Phase 1 Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-SCS-2004-00031 Experimental Compliant • Table A1 of SRT-SCS-2004-00031 for msrd, WSRC-NB-2003-00042 (rc25 through msrd bc, and targeted. rc-57) • SRS-SCS-2004-00031 can be found in WSRC- NB-2003-00042 on p. 90-93. • For target compositions, the minor components (“Others”) must be calculated. • The % “Others” in glass can be found in Table 3 (WSRC-TR-2002-00120). • The “Others” composition can be found in Table 4 (WSRC-TR-2002-00120). • “Others” contribution (in glass) was calculated by subtracting the sum of oxides for the targeted composition in Table A1 of SRT-SCS-2004- 00031 from 100 to calculate the % “Others” in glass. Then multiplying the % “Others” in glass by the “Others” composition (from Table 4) renormalized without Cr2O3, P2O5, TiO2, B2O3, Li2O, and ZrO2 in the “Others”. PCTs: • Table 8 (p.45) of WSRC-TR-2002-00120 (use screened values). General: • RC31.5 was fabricated due to a batching error with RC31. See Section 6.1 of WSRC-TR-2002- 00120 for discussion. 22 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2002-00426 ICCM Glasses Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: (high waste Compliant • Appendix A - target and msrd loading glasses • The “<” values in the report are listed as “0” in for cold crucible the database. melter) • No msrd bc comps reported. PCTs: • Table 6-5 • Values reported in g/m2 in report converted to g/L in database. General: • PCTs in Table 6-5 were normalized to the target compositions. 23 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2002-00482 ROC Phase 2 Herman RW-0333P Compositions: WSRC-NB-2003-00042 Experimental Compliant • See WSRC-NB-2003-00042 (pp. 76 – 80) for (rc58 through target, msrd, and msrd bc compositional views rc90) (see notes below regarding RC79 and RC80). • For the targeted compositions, the “Others” composition is provided in Table 7 (WSRC-TR- 2002-00482). • For the targeted compositions, Table 5 (WSRC- TR-2002-00482) provides the % “Others” contribution to the glass – except RC79 and RC80 (see note below). • In Table 5 (WSRC-TR-2002-00482), there are two types of “Others” (“old” and “new”). For the glasses based on the “Old Others”, the B2O3, Li2O and TiO2 concentrations from “Others” has already been accounted for in WSRC-NB-2003- 00042, p. 76-80. • For all glasses, the targeted values for Cr2O3, P2O5 & ZrO2 (minor components associated with “Others”) may also be shown in WSRC-NB- 2003-00042, p. 76-80 but should still be calculated as noted above. • The “-“ values shown in WSRC-NB-2003-00042 are represented as “0’s” in the database. • Glasses RC79 and RC80 were misbatched. • Table 8 (WSRC-TR-2002-00482) shows as- batched and target compositions for RC79 and RC80. • “As-batched” compositions are reported in the database for RC79 and RC80 as targeted compositions. • “New Others” (from Table 7 of WSRC-TR-2002- 00482) were used to calculate the minor components for RC79 and RC80. PCTs: • Table 11 in WSRC-TR-2002-00482 24 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2002-00549 SB3 VS glasses Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Table H.4 (target, msrd and msrd bc). • The msrd compositions for Glass IDs with “SME” nomenclature (as denoted in the database) are listed in Table 6-4 on p.45. PCTs: • Table 6-2 • The PCT values for the Glass IDs with SME nomenclature are listed in Table 6-6 on p. 46 (see msrd PCTs; not predicted). General: • PCTs for EA glasses were not listed in the report and were therefore moved to the “Non-Model” section of the database; however, they were calculated in the same JMP spreadsheet as the glass PCTs. 0 WSRC-TR-2003-00246 REDOX on Cozzi RW-0333P Compositions: Durability SB2 Compliant • Msrd and msrd bc compositional views come (“VS” glasses) directly from Table C.3. The target Fe2O3 values also come from Table C.3, but the other targeted oxides come from Table 3-1. • Target compositions are from Table 3-1 (except for FeO and Fe2O3 which come from Table C.3). • Target comps in Table 3-1 are listed as mass fraction. PCTs: • Table 4-3 General: • REDOX is associated with this report. 25 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-TR-2003-00287 “Non-durable” Cozzi RW-0333P Compositions: WSRC-RP-2002-00297 (“ND” glasses) Compliant • WSRC-NB-2003-00042 p. 76-80 for target, msrd WSRC-NB-2003-00042 and msrd bc. • For the targeted compositions, Table 25 (WSRC- RP-2002-00297) provides the % “Others” contribution to the glass. • For the targeted compositions, the “Others” composition is provided in Table 2 of WSRC- RP-2002-000297. • It should be noted that the minor components Cr2O3, P2O5, and ZrO2 are also listed in the target compositions shown in WSRC-NB-2003-00042. PCTs: • Table 4-2 of WSRC-TR-2003-00287 0 WSRC-TR-2003-00386 Effects of Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: U and Th Compliant • Table 3-15, p. 19 – target (target compositions (rchwl, tk, and listed as mass fraction). rcth glasses) o According to the footnote under the composition table, the “Others” compositions are already included in the Table 3-15, but the % “Others” is listed in the last column for completeness. • Table C.4, pp. 77 79 - msrd, msrd bc PCTs: • Table 5-2, pp. 32 – 33 o Table 5-2 header says quenched glasses, but from the row IDs CCC glasses are reported as well (use heat treatment column to determine ccc versus quenched). General: • tk40-01, tk40-02 and tk40-03 (as listed in the report) are the same as tk40-01-new, tk40-02- new, and tk40-03-new (as listed in the database). 26 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 0 WSRC-TR-2003-00393 Cold Crucible Herman RW-0333P Compositions: Induction- 2003 Compliant • Tables III, V, VII, IX, and XI. Heated Melter • Database contains only msrd compositional Testing views. (Russian glasses) PCTs: • Tables IV, VI, VIII, X, and XII. 0 WSRC-TR-2003-00539 SB3 Phase 2 VS- Lorier RW-0333P Compositions: REDOX Compliant • Table E.4 (target, msrd and msrd bc). (“SB2/3” PCTs: glasses) • Table 5-4 General: • Table E.1 (p. 65) shows the FeO and Fe2O3 partitioned based on targeted redox values. The database reflects fully oxidized glasses (all Fe2O3) as shown in Table E.4. 0 WSRC-TR-93-672 THERMO Jantzen RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Appendix B.1 (msrd only) PCTs: • Appendix C • Average g/L PCT were values used in database. General: • The following glasses were moved to the “Non- Model” set due to inconsistencies between the electronic THERMO database and the report for CuO and/or Cu2O: o Hanford Glasses 0254, 0278, 0352 and 0387 o IDMS glasses HM-4 5641, HM-4 5748, PX- 3 5780 and PX-3 5818. 27 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-TR-94-00453 Cicero Data Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Attachment 2 (starting on p. 48) (msrd only) PCTs: • Attachment 5 • g/L values for PCTs begin on p. 60. • Na PCT values as shown in the database reflect those values as msrd by AA. General: • Fe REDOX differences between the report and the original Glass Warehouse database were present. The database reflects the Fe composition as listed in the report. • Cu in the electronic source was partitioned. This database reflects the Cu values as shown in the report. • Based on a statement on p. 6 of the report, these glasses may potentially be msrd bc for analytical instrumentation error. The database lists these glasses as msrd as in Attachment 2. 0 WSRC-TR-95-0154 PUREX Pareizs RW-0333P Compositions: Crucible Studies Compliant • Table 2, p. 9 (msrd only) (“R” glasses) PCTs: • Table 4. PCT values in database are those labeled as msrd in Table 4. • Si PCT values are not listed in the report. Therefore the PCT Si values shown in the database should be considered “Non-Model” data. General: • Based on a statement in the report (see section 3.3), these glasses may be msrd bc against the WCP Purex Glass. The database lists the glass compositions as msrd because there is no direct reference to Table 2 in Section 3.3. • REDOX is associated with this report. 28 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) 0 WSRC-TR-2004-00313 Impacts of Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: REDOX on Compliant • Table G.4 (p. 102) (target, msrd and msrd bc) durability (“RX” PCTs: glasses) • Table 5-3 (p. 24) 0 WSRC-TR-95-0481 SB1A Ferrara RW-0333P Compositions: Confirmation Compliant • Table 12 (msrd only; see wt.% column) Tank 51 Frit 200 PCTs: (high level caves • Table 13 glass) General: • Cooling of glass occurred within crucible, therefore, heat treatment was not considered quenched but labeled as “Other” in the database. • PCT for EA was not msrd, but the published values were reported and used in the database. • pH values listed in Table 13 0 WSRC-TR-98-00180 MB2 study Andrews RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-SCS-98-017 (“SMB” glasses) Compliant • Table A.5 (SRT-SCS-98-017) (msrd) PCTs: • Table A.8 (SRT-SCS-98-017) General: • “As-batched” and “as-msrd” compositional views are shown in Table A.5. The msrd compositions are listed as “Model” data in the database. • No PCT information listed for target compositions. • REDOX is associated with select glasses in this report (p. 10 of WSRC-TR-98-00180). • pH values are listed in Table 10 of WSRC-TR- 98-00180. 29 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-TR-98-00465 Expanded Tank Edwards RW-0333P Compositions: 42 Variability Compliant • Table A.5 (msrd) Study PCTs: (“E” glasses) • Table A.4 General: • “As-batched” and “as-measured” compositional views are shown in Table A.5. The msrd compositions are listed as “Model” data in the • No PCT information listed for target compositions. 0 WSRC-TR-99-00224 INEEL CVS Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Phase 2a Compliant • Table 3, p. 9 (target only) (“P-Ca-F” series PCT: glasses) • Table 6, p. 15 o Two responses are shown for P2-0Ca-1F, P2-3Ca-1F, and P2-9Ca-1F. The PCTs listed in database correspond to the 20-gram melt size version of those glasses. General: • pH values listed in Table 6. • The “0F” and “9Ca” glasses were moved to the “Non-Model” section of the database due to disconnect between composition ID and PCT ID. 0 WSRC-TR-99-00324 Salt Alt FY99 Harbour RW-0333P Compositions: (“CST” glasses) Compliant • Table A.3 (target, msrd and msrd bc) • For target compositions, the values for BaO, PbO, P2O5, ZnO, F, Cl, and SO3 (converted from SO4) are from Tables A.1 and A.2 PCTs: • Table A.4 General: • The FY99 nomenclature used in the database is to distinguish these glasses from those assessed in 2001 (see WSRC-TR-2001-00124). The FY99 nomenclature is not used in the report. 30 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 WSRC-TR-99-00332 Salt Alt FY99, Edwards / RW-0333P Compositions: WSRC-TR-99-00262 (“pha” glasses) Harbour Compliant • Table A.3 (WSRC-TR-99-00332) - for target, WSRC-TR-99-00290 msrd and msrd-bc. • For target compositions, the values for BaO, P2O5, PbO, ZnO, F, Cl, and SO3 (converted from SO4) are from Table 2 in WSRC-TR-99-00262. PCTs: • Table A.4 (WSRC-TR-99-00332) for all glasses except pha14, pha15, pha17, and pha18. • For pha14, pha15, pha17, pha18, see Table 6 (WSRC-TR-99-00290). It should be noted that the glass IDs are erroneously labeled “cst” in Table 6. Cross referencing with “cst” report verifies these PCTs are unique (different than those reported for the “cst” glasses). It was therefore assumed that the values reported in Table 6 were for the “pha” glasses for all compositional views. General: • An asterisk appears next to some glass IDs in the compositional tables. These are of unknown origin and therefore they are not included in the database Glass IDs. • The FY99 nomenclature in the database is to distinguish these glasses from those assessed in 2001. The FY99 nomenclature is not listed in the report. • There are several places where headers and/or glass IDs in tables are incorrect. Each error was coordinated with its cst analog and found to differ. It was therefore assumed that the data were correct but incorrectly labeled. The only exception is Table A.1 of WSRC-TR-99-00332 which was found to be a duplicate of the analogous cst table and assumed incorrect. 31 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR • The original data source (the “Glass Warehouse”) lists a 50/50 split in Cu oxides, but the report differs. The database reflects the compositions as listed in the report. 0 WSRC-TR-2004-00348 Alternative Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Durability Study Compliant • Table C4, p. 46 (target, msrd and msrd bc) (“ADT” glasses) PCTs: • Table 5-2, p.16 1 PNNL-11865 Glass for LANL Vienna RW-0333P Compositions: UC-510 Evaporator Equivalent • Target compositions are given in Table IV on Bottoms Waste page 8. PCTs: • PCT data are given in Table XI on page 20 in units of g/L. 1 WSRC-NB-2001-00061 Sludge Batch 3 Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Frit 202 Glasses Compliant • Measured compositions appear on page 20. PCTs: • PCT data, normalized using the measured compositions, are provided on page 22. 1 WSRC-TR-2005-00371 Nepheline Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Formation for Compliant • Target and measured compositions appear in Sludge Batch 4, Table 3-1 Phase 1 PCTs: • PCT data appear in Table 3-4. 32 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 WSRC-TR-2006-00006 Nepheline Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Formation for Compliant • Target, measured, and measured bias-corrected Sludge Batch 4, compositions appear in Table C4. Phase 2 PCTs: • PCT data for glasses NEPH2-13 through NEPH2-26 appear in Table 4-2. • PCT data for glasses NEPH2-27 through NEPH2-40 appear in Table 4-3. General: • The report notes that three of the glasses studied (NEPH2-21, NEPH2-27, AND NEPH2-28) produced inconsistent composition measurements. These three glasses will be classified as “non-model” as recommended in the report. 1 WSRC-TR-2005-00354 DWPF Pour Bannochie RW-0333P Compositions: Stream Sample, Compliant • Measured composition is listed in Table 3-2. Canister S0312 • The measured composition reports a value for BeO, however there is no column for BeO in the PCTs: • PCT data are listed in Table 3-8. 1 WSRC-TR-2006-00093 Nepheline Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Formation for Compliant • Target, measured and measured bias-corrected Sludge Batch 4, compositions are given in Table D4 on page 69. Phase 3 PCTs: • PCT data are given in Table 3-2 on page 15. 1 WSRC-TR-94-00107 Simulated RFP Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Precipitate Equivalent • Measured compositions are in Table 6 on page 6. Sludge Crucible PCTs: Studies • Normalized PCT data in units of g/L are in Table 9 on page 8. 33 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 1 WSRC-TR-94-00313 LANL TA-50 Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Simulated Equivalent • Measured compositions are given in Table 3 on Sludge Crucible page 6. Studies PCTs: • Normalized PCT data in units of g/L are given in Table 5 on page 8. 1 WSRC-TR-2005-00410 Vitrification and Crawford RW-0333P Compositions: Product Testing Compliant • Target and measured compositions are given in of AY-102/C- Table 3-4 on page 23. 106 HLW (Env. • Note that two composition values are given for D) each oxide component: one for each of the two dissolution methods used. The mean of these two values was entered into ComPro. PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 3-10 on page 34 in units of g/m2. • These values were converted to g/L by multiplying by 2 for entry into the database. 1 WSRC-TR-94-00452 Defining the Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Glass Equivalent • Target composition data are in Appendix A, Composition pages A1-A20. Limits for the • Measured composition data are on page 9. CaO-Al2O3-SiO2 PCTs: Ternary System • PCT data are on page 13. 1 WSRC-TR-94-00451 Defining the Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Glass Equivalent • Target composition data are in Appendix C, Composition pages C1-C4. Limits for SRS • Measured composition data are in Appendix D, Contaminated page D1. Soils PCTs: • PCT data are on page 11. 34 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 1 WSRC-TR-2003-00536 Crucible-scale Crawford RW-0333P Compositions: Radioactive Equivalent • Measured composition data are provided in Vitrification and Tables 9 and 10 on pages 27 and 28, respectively. Product Testing • Two replicates are listed for each oxide for each of Waste of the two dissolution methods used, for a total of Envelope B (AZ- four reported values per oxide. The mean of these 102) Low- four values was entered into ComPro™. activity Waste PCTs: Glass • Normalized PCT data are listed in Table 19 on page 38 in units of g/m2. • These values were converted to g/L by multiplying by 2 for entry into the database. • No data for Li are given. 1 WSRC-TR-2004-00050 Sludge Batch 3 Pareizs RW-0333P Compositions: Qualification in Compliant • Measured compositions are given in Table 7-3 on the SRTC page 33. Shielded Cells PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 7-4 on page 34 in units of g/L. 1 WSRC-TR-2006-00031 Development of Marra RW-0333P Compositions: an Alternative Compliant • Target and measured compositions are listed in Glass Table 9 on page 26. Formulation for • Note that the measured composition values listed Vitrification of in the “average” column were those entered into Excess the database. Plutonium PCTs: • Normalized PCT data for B and Si only are listed in Table 11 on page 30. 35 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 1 WSRC-TR-93-00647 ORR WETF Cicero RW-0333P Compositions: Simulated Equivalent • No target compositions are specified. Sludge Crucible • Measured composition data are on page 7. Studies PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are on page 8. • Note: two measurements were made for each composition (a and b) for some of the study glasses. In those cases, the average of the two was entered in the database. 1 WSRC-STI-2006-00009 Durability and Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Nepheline Compliant • Target, measured, and measured bias-corrected Crystallization composition data are given in Table D4 on Study for High pages 59-62. Level Waste • Note that data for sulfur are given as SO42-. These (HLW) Sludge values were converted to SO3 for entry into the Batch 4 (SB4) database. Glasses PCTs: Formulated with • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 3-2 on Frit 503 page 15. 1 WSRC-TR-99-00055 Composition / Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Property Compliant • Target and measured composition data are given Relationships for in Table A.3 in the Appendix. the Phase 1 PCTs: Am/Cm Glass • Normalized PCT data are given in Table XXII on Variability Study page 52. • Note that Glass ID AC1-19B was not included since the measured composition of this glass was not given in the report. 1 WSRC-TR-99-00393 Composition / Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Property Compliant • Target and measured composition data are given Relationships for in Table A.4 in the Appendix. the Phase 2 Am- PCTs: Cm Glass • Normalized PCT data are given in Table XXIV Variability Study on page 63. (U) • Note that sodium (Na) is mislabeled as Neodymium (Nd) in this table. 36 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 1 WSRC-STI-2006-00204 High Level Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Waste (HLW) Compliant • Target and measured composition data are given Sludge in Table E4 in Appendix E. Batch 4 (SB4) PCTs: Variability Study • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 3-4, beginning on page 23. 1 SRNL-PSE-2006-00258 Tank 51 SB4 Bibler RW-0333P Compositions: Qualification Compliant • Measured composition data are given in Table 3 Glass on page 6. PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 4 on page 7. • Note that data for Si are not given. • Note that pH data are also given in the table. 1 WSRC-STI-2006-00329 SB4 / Frit 418 Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Variability Study Compliant • Target, measured and measured bias-corrected composition data are given in Table C4 in Appendix C on page 51. PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table 3-3 on page 17. 1 WSRC-TR-95-0034 Hanford High Marra RW-0333P Compositions: Na, Low Level Compliant • Target composition data are given in Table II on Waste page 11 and Table X on page 16. PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table VIII on page 15 and Table XI (mislabeled as Table VIII in the report) on page 16. 37 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 SRNL-PSE-2006-00194 SB4 Simulated Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Qualification Compliant • Target and measured (the mean of two values) Glasses composition data are given in Table A2 in the Appendix on page 9. • Note that there is a typo in the table: CrO3 should be Cr2O3. PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table A3 in the Appendix on page 15. 2 SRNL-STI-2009-00025 SB3-Frit 418 Billings RW-0333P Composition: Target and measured compositions are TTT Compliant provided in Table 4 (page 9). PCTs: Table 7 (page 16). This study was a time-temperature- transformation (TTT) study on a single glass composition. Thus, multiple heat treatment temperatures and times were used. See Table 3 (page 7) for details on times and temperatures used which led to the naming convention for the glass IDs. Sample SB3-TTT-MIX-CCC appears to follow the normal DWPF centerline canister cooling profile. SB3-TTT-MIX-ASR was quenched. PCT's reported in Table 7 are assumed to be normalized based on measured compositions. Note: PCTs normalized against measured compositions are entered into the 2 SRNL-STI-2009-00440 Preliminary Frit Fox RW-0333P Target and measured compositions in Table A-1 Development Compliant (pages 20 through 24). Thorium was not measured; and Melt Rate therefore, zero was entered into the ComPro database. Testing for PCT results are shown in Table 4-1 (page 12). Sludge Batch 6 Note that in two cases, the quenched version of glass (SB6) SB6R1-01 and the ccc version of glass SB6R1-08, one of the triplicate PCT vessels had a volume to mass ratio that was outside the limits dictated by the ASTM standard. Therefore, the remaining duplicates for each heat-treated glass were used to compute the normalized PCT response. 38 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 SRNL-STI-2009-00465 Reduction of Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias Constraints for Compliant corrected compositions are found in Table A3 on Coupled pages 42 through 53. Note: The target composition for Operations ROC-09, ROC-09M, and ROC-09RM are the same and can be found in Table A3 on page 45 under the ROC-09 header (i.e., all three glasses target the same composition). The measured and measured bias corrected compositions for ROC-09 and ROC-09M are the same and are listed as ROC-09 in Table A3 on page 45. The composition for ROC-09RM was not remeasured. PCTs: Normalized PCT results are listed in Table 12 (pages 21 through 23) for most of the glasses. The PCT response for ROC-09M can be found in Table 13 (page 24). The PCT response for ROC-09RM can be found in Table 14 (page 25) and is only normalized to target composition given that glass was not measured. 2 SRNL-STI-2009-00778 FY-09 Enhanced Johnson RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias DOE HLW Compliant corrected compositions for the non-rad Matrix 2 Melter glasses (FY09EM21-01 through FY09EM21-27) are Throughput listed in Table A4 (pages 100 through 110). Target, Studies at SRNL measured, and measured bias corrected compositions for the Rad Matrix 2 glasses (FY09EM21-28 through FY09EM21-30) are in Table A6 (pages 115 through 116). Target, measured, and measured bias corrected for the Matrix 2A study glasses (EM-01 through EM- 30) are listed in Table D3 (pages 250 through 261). Normalized PCTs results for the non-rad Matrix 2 glasses (FY09EM21-01 through FY09EM21-27) are listed in Table 11 (pages 32 through 34). Normalized PCTs results for the Rad Matrix 2 glasses (FY09EM21-28 through FY09EM21-30) are listed in Table 18 on page 47. Normalized PCTs results for the Matrix 2A study glasses (EM-01 through EM-30) are listed in Table 22 (pages 72 through 74). 39 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 SRNL-STI-2010-00242 SB6 Variability Johnson RW-0333P Measured vs. target compositions for glasses SB6VS- Study with Frit Compliant 01 through SB6VS-17 are in Table A4 (pages 30 - 39) 418 and for glasses SB6VS-18 through SB6VS-22 in Table C5 (pages 124 - 127). Compositions for the remeasured glasses (SB6VS-02, -04, and -15) are found in Table 3-1 on page 8. Normalized PCTs for non-thorium glasses listed in Table 3-5 on page 14. PCTs for thorium glasses are listed Table 3-6 on page 15. Normalized PCTs for Re-measured glasses (SB6VS-02, -04, and -15) are shown in Table 3-7 on page 15. Note: Glasses SB6VS-01, 03, 05, and 10 are not included in the ComPro database per discussion on page 8. 2 SRNL-STI-2010-00566 Impacts of SCIX Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Target and measured composition for on DWPF Glass Compliant KT1 series are listed in Table A-4 (pages A-5 through Formulation: A-10); for the KT03 series in Table B-4 (pages B-8 KT01, KT02, through B-14); for the KT04 series in Table C-4 KT03, & KT04 (pages C-5 through C-9). Note: chemical composition Series Glass information for KT1-HA2 can be found in Table B-4 Compositions (page B-13). PCT's for the KT1 series are listed in Tables D-2 (page D-4); for KT03 series in Table E-2 (page E-4), and for the KT04 series in Table F-2 (page F-4). Note: PCT information for KT1-HA2 can be found in Table E-2 (page (E-11). 2 SRNL-STI-2010-00687 Impacts of SCIX Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Measured and target compositions for on DWPF Glass Compliant KT06 glasses are found in Table A-4 (pages A-8 Formulation: through A-15). PCT's for KT06 glasses are found in KT05 & KT06 Table B-2 on pages B-5 through B-6. Note: PCT's Series Glass were not performed for KT05 glasses. Compositions 2 SRNL-STI-2010-00759 Impacts of SCIX Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Measured compositions are found in on DWPF Glass Compliant Table A-4 on page A-5. Target compositions are Formulation: found in Table 2-2 on page 4. Note: Table 2-2 should KT07 Series be used to obtain target compositions which include Glass noble metals. Normalized PCT's are found in Table B- Compositions 2 on page B-4. 40 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 2 SRNL-STI-2011-00063 SB7a Glass Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: Measured vs. target compositions are Variability Study Compliant in Table A5 of Appendix A. Normalized PCTs in with Frit 418 and Table 9 starting on page 16. 702 2 SRNL-STI-2011-00178 Impacts of SCIX Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Measured compositions for KT08 on DWPF Glass Compliant glasses are listed in Table A-5 (pages A-10 through Formulation: A-15). Target compositions for the KT08 glasses are KT08, KT09, & listed in Table 2-4 on page 6. Measured compositions KT10 Series for the KT10 glasses are listed in Table B-4 (pages B- Glass 5 through B-9). Note: SO4 was not measured for the Compositions KT10 glass series, therefore a "0" value was entered into the ComPro database. Target compositions for the KT10 glasses are listed in Table 2-8 on page 10. PCT's found in Tables C-2 (page C-4) for KT08 glasses and Table D-2 (page D-4) for KT10 glasses. 2 SRNL-STI-2011-00440 Sludge Batch 7b Johnson RW-0333P Measured and target compositions provided in Table Variability Study Compliant A-5 (pages A-22 thru A-36). Normalized PCTs in Table 4-1 (pages 14 thru 18). 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00036 Glass Marra RW-0333P Compositions are provided in Table IV for the 503-R Formulation Equivalent glass series (page 15), Table V for the 503-R6 series Development (page 16), Table VI for the 503-R7 series (page 17), and Testing for Table VIII for centroids and extreme vertices (page Cold Crucible 21) and Table IX (page 23). Note: The glass IDs in Induction Melter the ComPro database do not contain "503" but are Technology based on the "R-series" number and the targeted waste Retrofit and loading. For example, R6-45 (as listed in the Deployment database) represents a glass based on 503-R6 frit Project targeting 45% waste loading. The composition Phase II-A – (measured and target) for this glass is shown in Table Demonstrations IV (page 15) under the column headers "45% WL Lab-Scale Measured" and "45% WL Target", respectively. Evaluation and Assessment Report 41 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00056 FY-07 EM-21 Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias Enhanced Melter Compliant corrected compositions can be found in Table A5 Throughput (pages 36 through 53). PCTs: Table 2 (pages 8 Studies Matrix 1 through 15). 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00057 International Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Table 5-2 (pages 13 through 15). Note: Study of Al Compliant only measured bias corrected compositions are Impacts on provided. PCTs: Table 5-3 (paged 16 through 18). Crystallization Note: PCT's were normalized on measured bias corrected compositions. 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00060 Frit Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Table A6 (page 52) Development for Equivalent PCTs: Table 4-4 (page 20) SB5: Varying Al Concentrations 2 SRNL-L3100-2008-00012 SB5 Variability Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias Study-Frit 418 Compliant corrected can be found in Table A4 (page 30). PCTs: Display 4 (pages 12 through 14). 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00099 Refinement of Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias the Nepheline Compliant corrected are listed in Table A4 (pages 38 through 43) Discriminator: PCTs: Table 3-4 (pages 17 through 21). Results of a Phase II Study 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00111 SB5 Pareizs RW-0333P Composition: Measured composition provided in Qualification in Compliant Table 23 on page 30. PCTs: Table 25 on page 33. the SRNL Shielded Cells 2 VSL-11R2580-1 Sludge Batch 7a Kot RW-0333P Compositions: Measured and target compositions Glass Variability Compliant provided in Table A3 on pages A-10 through A-19. Study without PCTs in Table 5.2 on pages T-10 through T-11. Noble Metals 2 VSL-12R2580-2 Sludge Batch 7a Kot RW-0333P Measured composition are provided in Table A3 on Glass Variability Compliant pages A-10 thru A-19. For target compositions refer Study with to Table 2.2 starting on page T-2. Table 2.2 should be Noble Metals used for target to obtain correct values for noble metals. PCTs are provided in Table 5.2 on pages T-10 thru T-11. 42 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00053 Demonstration Pareizs RW-0333P Compositions: measured composition is provided in of the DWPF Compliant Table 3-32 on page 35. Flowsheet in the PCTs: Table 3-33 on page 36. SRNL Shielded Cells in Support of Sludge Batch 4 Qualification 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00477 Variability Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias Study: Solubility Compliant correct are provided in Table D5 (starting on page of Impurities in 116). Note: The SiO2 values listed in the report are Pu Glasses mislabeled as Si2O3. Refer to Table 2-3 (page 18) for the target compositions of Pu35-03B, Pu35-04B, Pu35-06B, and Pu35-17B. Note: The target compositions shown in Table 2-3 have values listed for "C" (carbon). There are no entries in the database for carbon. PCTs: Table 3-4 (pages 39 through 45). PCTs for Pu35-03B, Pu35-04B, Pu35-06B, and Pu35- 17B are shown in Table 3-8 (page 57). Note: NC values for Hf and Na are listed as "<" in Table 3-8 but "0" values are entered in the ComPro database. Although NC Nd values are listed in the report, they are not listed in the ComPro database. 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00659 Refinement of Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Table A4 (pages 51 through 65). Nepheline Compliant Note: glass IDs in Table A4 are listed by number Discriminator: only (e.g., SB5NEPH-01 is listed as 1 in Table A4). Phase 1 PCTs: Table 3-4 (pages 23 through 27). Table 3-3 on page 21 has ARM-1 and EA PCT results. All nepheline glasses have targeted Li values of zero. Therefore, no Li PCT values are reported. 2 WSRC-STI-2008-00149 SB4 Variability Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: Table A4 (page 42) Study First Compliant PCTs: Table 5 (page 17) Note: Table 5 on pages 18 Decant Frit 510 and 19 are mislabeled as Table 4 (continued). 2 WSRC-STI-2008-00315 SB4 Variability Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: Target, measured, and measured bias Study Second Compliant corrected compositions found in Table A4 (pages 29 Decant Frit 510 through 32) PCTs: Table 6 (pages 15 through 17) 43 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 SRNL-PSE-2006-00194 SB4 Simulated Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Table A-2 (page 9). Note CrO3 in Qualification Equivalent Table A-2 should be Cr2O3 and "<" values were zero Glasses in ComPro. Note: Use the "Meas. (Mean)" for the measured compositions. PCTs: Table A-3 (page 15). 2 SRNL-PSE-2007-00231 High Al Fox RW-0333P Compositions: Table 1 on page 3. PCT's: Table 3 on Simulated HLW Equivalent page 5. Glass 3 (original SRNL-L3100-2008-00012 & Sludge Batch 5 Raszewski RW-0333P (From SRNS-STI-2008-00063) data entered in SRNS-STI-2008-00063 Variability Study Compliant Compositions: Revision 2) with Frit 418 • Table 5, pages 11 – 22 • Table 6, pages 23 – 25 XRD: • Section 4.2, pages 8-9 Note: • SB5VS-04 CCC and Quenched Measured samples are classified as “Non-Model” due to “Sum of Oxides” being <95%. 3 (original SRNL-STI-2010-00242 SB6 Glass Johnson RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in Variability Study Compliant • Table A4, pages 29 - 39; Table C5, pages 124 – Revision 2) with Frit 418 127 • SB6VS-02, SB6VS-04, and SB6VS-15 were remeasured, and the results are in Table 3-1 on page 8. • Table 3-5, page 14; Table 3-6 and Table 3-7, page 15; Table B2, page 101 • SB6VS-02, SB6VS-04, and SB6VS-15 were remeasured and the PCT results are in Table 3-7 on page 15. XRD: • Figure 3-1, page 10 (Section 3.3) Note: • SB6VS-01, SB6VS-03, SB6VS-05, and SB6VS- 10 were excluded due to a sample analysis preparation error. 44 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 SRNL-STI-2010-00353 SB6 Pareizs RW-0333P Measured composition: qualification- Compliant • Table 3-17, page 30 Frit 418 PCT results: • Table 3-19, page 31 3 SRNL-STI-2010-00435 SB4 and SB5 Reigel RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: pour stream Compliant • Table 3-2, page 4 glass analysis Measured SB4 composition: • Table 3-3, page 5 Measured SB5 composition: • Table 3-4, page 6 • Table 3-11, page 16 3 (original SRNL-STI-2011-00063 SB7a Glass Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in Variability Study Compliant • Table A5, no page numbers Revision 2) with Frit 418 and PCT results: Frit 702 • Table 9, pages 16 – 18 XRD: • Table 7, page 13 3 SRNL-STI-2011-00226 SB7a Pareizs RW-0333P Measured composition: qualification - Compliant • Table 4-1, page 20 Frit 418 PCT results: • Table 4-3, page 22 3 (original SRNL-STI-2011-00440 SB7v Glass Johnson RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in Variability Study Compliant • Table A-5, pages A-22 - A-36 Revision 2) PCT results: • Table 4-1, pages 14 - 18 XRD: • Table 3-3, page 10 3 SRNL-STI-2011-00548 SB7b Pareizs RW-0333P Measured SB7b composition: qualification – Compliant • Table 4-1, page 25 Frit 702 PCT results: • Table 4-4, page 27 45 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 SRNL-STI-2011-00555 SB6 pour stream Johnson RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: glass analysis Compliant • Table 3-2, page 5 Measured SB6 composition: • Table 3-3, page 5 • Table 3-7, page 9 3 SRNL-STI-2012-00017 SB7a pour Johnson RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: Revision 1 stream glass Compliant • Table 3-1, page 4 analysis Measured SB7a composition: • Table 3-2, page 4 • Table 3-6, page 7 Note: • S03619/SB7aPS#1(MB8) is classified as “Non- Model” due to “Sum of Oxides” being <95%. 3 SRNL-STI-2013-00116 SB8 Pareizs RW-0333P Measured SB8 composition: qualification Compliant • Table 4-1, page 25 • Table 4-2, page 26 3 SRNL-STI-2013-00462 SB7b pour Johnson RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: Revision 1 stream glass Compliant • Table 3-1, page 4 analysis Measured SB7b composition: • Table 3-2, page 4 • Table 3-6, page 7 3 SRNL-STI-2016-00355 SB9 Pareizs RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: qualification Compliant • Table 3-32, page 38 Measured SB9 composition: • Table 3-34, page 39 • Table 3-36, page 41 3 SRNL-STI-2016-00372 SWPF High Ti Jantzen RW-0333P PCT results for ARM-1 and EA reference glasses: Glasses Gap Compliant • Table B4, page 66 Analysis PCT 46 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 SRNL-STI-2016-00726 SB9 SC18 PCT Martino RW-0333P PCT results: Compliant • Table 3-22, page 26 3 SRNL-STI-2018-00699 SB8 pour stream McClane RW-0333P Measured SB8 and ARG-1 compositions: glass analysis Compliant • Table 3-1, page 3 • Table 3-4, page 6 3 SRNL-STI-2024-00229 SB9 TTT Page RW-0333P Targeted TTT glass composition: Compliant • Table 3-3, page 3 Measured SB9 composition: • Table 5-2, page 9 Batch 1 Measured composition: • Table A-11, page A-12 • Table A-14, pages A-40 and A-42 XRD: • Table 5-3, page 10 3 SRNL-TR-2016-00094 SWPF High Ti Edwards RW-0333P Measured EA compositions: Glasses Gap Compliant • Table A3, page A18 Analysis Chem Comps 3 SRNL-TR-2016-00094 & SWPF High Ti Edwards / RW-0333P SWPF glass composition data from SRNL-TR-2016- SRNL-STI-2016-00372 Glasses Gap Jantzen Compliant 00094 were combined with the SWPF glass PCT Analysis Chem results from SRNL-STI-2016-00372. Comps and PCT SWPF Glass Compositions: • Table A3, pages A-18 to A-38 SWPF Glass PCT results: • Table B4, pages 66 to 73 3 VSL-13R2580-1 SB8 VS - Frit Kot RW-0333P Compositions: 803 Compliant • Table A3, pages A-10 to A-18 • Table 5.2, pages T-10 to T-11 47 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES 3 VSL-16R3370-1 SB9 VS - Frit Kot RW-0333P Compositions: 803 Compliant • Table A3, pages A-5 to A-8 • Table 5.2, pages T-6 to T-7 3 VSL-19R4680-1 SB9 Coupled Kot RW-0333P Compositions: with SWPF VS Compliant • Table A3, pages A-6 to A-8 w Frit 803 PCT results: • Table 5.2, pages T-5 to T-6 3 VSL-21R4930-1 SB10 VS Kot RW-0333P Compositions: Compliant • Table A3, pages A-5 - A-10 Note: • PCT results values were entered incorrectly in the report. The peer-reviewed original SRNL table was used for PCT data entry. 3 WSRC-RP-2000-00281 SB1B (canister Fellinger RW-0333P Measured composition: S01142) pour Compliant • Table 2, page 7 stream glass PCT results: analysis • Table 3, page 8 3 WSRC-TR-2004-00316 SB2 (canister Cozzi RW-0333P Measured ARG-1 composition: Revision 2 S01913) pour Compliant • Table 3-1, page 5. stream glass Measured SB2 composition: analysis • Table 3-2, page 6 • Table 3-8, page 10 48 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 (original WSRC-RP-95-01045 SB1A VS Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in (Peeler 202 Compliant • Table 9 - Table 15, pages 16 - 23; Table D-1, Revision 0) Series) page 51 • Table 16 and Table 17, page 24; Table 23, page 34 • ARM-1 and EA PCT values in Table 17 on page 24 were calculated from the ppm concentrations. XRD: • Table 8, page 14; Table 22, page 34 (CCC samples) Note: • WP202-16 is classified as "Non-Model" due to “Sum of Oxides” being >105%. 3 (original WSRC-RP-96-00020 SB1A VS Peeler RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in (Peeler 200 Compliant • Table 5 - Table 7, pages 9 - 12 Revision 0) Series) • Batch 1 - C results from Table 7 on page 12 were excluded because the oxide measurements are out of order. • Table 8, page 13; Table 13, page 19 XRD: • Page 26 3 WSRC-RP-96-00414 SB1A (PC1T - Hodoh RW-0333P Measured composition: canister S00424) Compliant • Table 1, page 2 pour stream PCT results: glass analysis • Table 2, page 3 3 WSRC-RP-96-00529 SB1A (PC0001 - Hodoh RW-0333P Measured composition: canister S00424) Compliant • Table 1, page 2 pour stream PCT results: glass analysis • Table 2, page 3 3 WSRC-RP-98-00053 PC0030 - Bibler RW-0333P Measured composition: canister S00471 Compliant • Table 1, page 3 pour stream PCT results: glass analysis • Table 2, page 3 49 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 WSRC-RP-98-00054 PC0020 - Bibler RW-0333P Measured composition: canister S00482 Compliant • Table 1, page 3 pour stream PCT results: glass analysis • Table 2, page 3 3 WSRC-RP-98-01400 PC0004 - Bibler RW-0333P Measured composition: canister S00834 Compliant • Table 1, page 3 pour stream • The measured MoO2 value was converted to glass analysis MoO3 in the database. • The table lists “ZrO” as an oxide. This was assumed to be a typographical error, and the measured value was placed in the “ZrO2” column in the database. • Table 2, page 4 3 (original WSRC-STI-2008-00149 Initial Sludge Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in Batch 4 Tank 40 Compliant • Table A4, pages 42-50 Revision 2) Decant PCT results: Variability Study • Table 5, pages 17-19 with Frit 510 XRD: • Table 3, page 12. (CCC samples only) 3 (original WSRC-STI-2008-00315 Variability Study Raszewski RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in with Frit 510 to Compliant • Table A4, pages 29-32 Revision 2) Support a PCT results: Second Tank 40 • Table 6, pages 15-17 Decant XRD: • Table 4, page 10 Note: • Batch 1 sample is classified as “Non-Model” due to “Sum of Oxides” being <95%. 50 Table 5-1. ComPro “Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 3 (original WSRC-TR-2000-00351 Tank 40 Only Harbour RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in and Tank 8/40 Compliant • Appendix 1, pages 35 - 40; Appendix 3, pages 45 Revision 0) Glasses-SB2 VS - 50 Frit 200 PCT results: • Appendix 2, pages 41 - 44; Appendix 4, pages 51 - 54 XRD: • Table 6, page 20; Table 11, page 30 Note: • Samples classified as “Non-Model” due to “Sum of Oxides being <95%: st16 Measured Quenched, st29 Measured CCC, st29 Measured Quenched, and st60 Measured Quenched. 3 (original WSRC-TR-2001-00511 SB2 VS w Frit Herman RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in 320 Glasses Compliant • Table A.4, pages 36 - 43 Revision 0) PCT results: • Display 3, page 82 XRD: • Table 8, page 15 Note: • Samples classified as “Non-Model” due to “Sum of Oxides being <95%: Compositional View - Measured bc for NS04 CCC, NS04 Quenched, NS13 CCC, NS13 Quenched, and U std. 3 (original WSRC-TR-2003-00539 SB3 Phase 2 VS Lorier RW-0333P Compositions: data entered in - REDOX Compliant • Table E.4, pages 71-76 Revision 0) PCT results: • Table 5-4, page 28 XRD: • Table 5-1, page 17 51 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR * These data were provided by electronic means only. No document number or hard copy of a report containing the data could be located. Therefore, these data could not be classified from a QA or technical basis and are provided for information only. If the End User can provide supporting information, the data will be considered for reclassification. 0 Ceram. Trans. 39, Canonical Oksoy Non-RW-0333P A review of this reference article does provide 365-380, American Correlation Compliant leachate values (in ppm) for the “7-day” PCT test Ceramic Society (Ramsey) (Table 1) as well as what is assumed to be “target” glass compositions (Table 2) as molar fractions. Calculations could be made to convert these inputs to normalized PCT release values and to express the PCT values in g/L. This was not performed for the current revision of the database, so these data remain in the “Non-Model” section. If the End User provides the calculations or another reference which explicitly states the needed values, these data could be reclassified as “Model” data assuming the required QA information was also presented. 0 * REE Parametric * Not Reviewed – No * Study hardcopy available 0 * DWPF TL Study * Not Reviewed – No * hardcopy available 0 * WV Glasses by Johnston Not Reviewed – No A hardcopy of the report was not obtained. The VSL and PNL hardcopy data currently in the database was obtained via documentation electronic means from PNNL. The PNNL database available Summary & Status states: “Because of batching error, target compositions in the report were not correct. Compositions recalculated from the batch sheets were used in DB.” Therefore, the compositions provided in this database reflect those received from PNNL but remain “Non-Model” data given there is no published reference for which the data could be compared to during a V&V process. 52 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 DPST-85-397 SRL 165 Glasses Pye Not Reviewed Based on a review of the DPST-85-397 report, no PCT or –Based on composition information could be found. Therefore, the technical information in the database could not be verified. These reasons data were considered “Non-Model”. 0 INEEL/EXT-98-00970 INEEL CVS Staples RW-0333P As mentioned in Section 4.0 of INEEL/EXT-98-00970, Phase 1 Equivalent during the fabrication of the IG1 glasses, a batching error occurred in which excessive phosphate (2.6 – 2.9X) was added to the targeted compositions. Some of the glasses contained as much as 13.12 wt.% P2O5. A more thorough review of the report could potentially allow for the actual “targeted” compositions to be determined. If so, these data could be reclassified from “Non-Model” to “Model” given the QA classification of RW-0333P Equivalent. 0 * TWRS HLW Fu and Not Reviewed * Glass Pegg – No hardcopy Formulation documentation available 0 * TWRS LAW Muller and Not Reviewed * Formulation Pegg – No hardcopy available 0 MRS Symp.Proc., Vol. SRS M-Area Fu Non-RW- Based on the MRS report, there were no PCT data reported 465, 139-146 (1997) Mixed Waste 0333P – only TCLP data. Glasses Compliant 0 MRS Symp.Proc., Vol. Kinetics of Reynolds Non-RW- Based on the MRS report, there were no PCT data reported 465, 65-69 (1997) Spinel and Hrma 0333P – only TL data. Crystallization Compliant 0 MRS Symp.Proc., Vol. SP Study Mika Non-RW- Based on the MRS report, there were no PCT data reported 465, 71-78 (1997) 0333P – only TL data. Compliant 0 MRS Symp.Proc., Vol. TRU Study Crum Non-RW- Based on the MRS report, there were no PCT data reported 465,79-85 (1997) 0333P – only TL data. Compliant 0 MRS Symp.Proc., Plutonium Bulkley Non-RW- There were no technical issues observed with this dataset. Vol.465,1243-1250 (1997) Vitrification and Vienna 0333P The MRS report contained both target compositions and Compliant PCT information. 53 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 PNL-3188 Comp. versus Chick Non-RW- The durability information presented in the report is based Prop. Study 0333P on the Soxhlet and “weight loss” tests. No specific PCT Compliant information was found. 0 PNL-4992 WV HLW Chick Non-RW- No specific PCT information was found. The durability Formulation 0333P information presented is based on MCC-1, MCC-2, MCC-3 Study Compliant or MCC-5. 0 PNL-6530 ISV Glass Carter RW-0333P The data currently in the database was obtained via Equivalent electronic means from PNNL. The PNNL database Summary & Status states “Glass compositions in Appendix A1 are all incorrect. Correct target compositions are in database. So, correct analyzed compositions are not available.” Therefore, these data were classified as ”Non- Model” (given there is no published reference for which the data could be compared to during a V&V process) and the values shown reflect those received from PNNL. The durability information (based on the report) indicates that MCC-1, MCC-3, a modified MCC-3, and EP Toxicity tests were performed. No specific PCT information was found. 0 PNNL-10987 Hanford CVS 3 Vienna Non-RW- The data currently in the database was obtained via 0333P electronic means from PNNL. The PNNL database Compliant Summary & Status states “Compositions in report are in error because of batch sheet error.” Therefore, these data were classified as “Non-Model” (given there is no published reference for which the data could be compared to during a V&V process) and the values shown reflect those received from PNNL. 0 PNNL-10918 Hanford LLW Feng RW-0333P The data currently in the database was obtained via Glass Equivalent electronic means from PNNL. The PNNL database Formulation Summary & Status states “Compositions in report are in error because of batch sheet error.” Therefore, these data were classified as “Non-Model” (given there is no published reference for which the data could be compared to during a V&V process) and the values shown reflect those received from PNNL. 0 PNNL-11790 SG Study Hrma RW-0333P There were no PCT data reported in this report. Equivalent 54 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 PNNL-12208 UC-2000 MS Study Wilson and Non-RW- There were no PCT data reported in this report. Hrma 0333P Compliant 0 PNNL-13491 INEEL DZr-CV Riley Non- This report is a “compilation” of various data as reported in Glasses RW0333P other documents. PCT and composition information are Compliant reported. Some of the unique compositions (i.e., those unique to PNNL-13491) contained an “Others” component (expressed as a wt.% in glass) but the “Others” compositions were not identified. Therefore, the target compositions could not be confirmed. 0 A Dissertation Presented to Ramsey Ph.D. Ramsey Non- The document lists the glass compositions as mol%. the Graduate School of Thesis RW0333P Independent calculations were made to convert the reported Clemson University Compliant mol% values to wt.% values but resulted in values that did not agree with the database entries. Again, the dataset was classified as “Non-Model” independent of the QA Level classification. 0 * HWVP 85 Bates Not Reviewed * – No hardcopy 0 * TWRS LAW Ferrarra Not Reviewed * Formulation 2 – No hardcopy 0 * TWRS Envelop Crawford Not Reviewed * D HLW Glass – No hardcopy Formulation documentation 0 WVDP-186, Section 1.3, West Valley West Not Reviewed The data currently in the database was obtained via Rev. 1 WQR Valley –Based on electronic means from PNNL. The PNNL database Nuclear technical Summary & Status states “data can be found in file Services reasons “wv58gla5.xls”. The report does not provide a technical basis from which the V&V process could be performed. Therefore, these data were classified as “Non-Model” and the values shown reflect those received from PNNL. 0 * WVDP Support Olson Not Reviewed * – No hardcopy 55 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 0 * SP-3 Vienna Not Reviewed * – No hardcopy 0 * SPx4 Vienna Not Reviewed * – No hardcopy 0 * Misc. Vienna Not Reviewed * – No hardcopy 0 WSRC-TR-95-0209 Kielpinski Data Kielpinski RW-0333P The report lists normalized msrd comps rather than actual Compliant msrd comps, therefore comps and PCTs could not be confirmed. 0 WSRC-TR-98-00327 ADC PCTs Cozzi RW-0333P This dataset was classified as “Non-Model” given part of Compliant the data were inconsistent with those values documented in WSRC-TR-2000-00339 for the same glasses. 0 WSRC-TR-2000-00339 TFA Jantzen RW-0333P This dataset was classified as “Non-Model” given part of Compliant the data were inconsistent with those values documented in WSRC-TR-98-00327 for the same glasses. In addition, the “M-Area” glasses are considered “Non-Model” because no “Others” composition was found from which the target glass compositions could be confirmed. 0 WSRC-RP-94-1385 DWPF FA-13 Edwards RW-0333P This data has been moved to “Non-Model” section because SRT-ASG-940104 Study Compliant PbO values were included with the electronic version of the WSRC-RP-94-1386 data that was transferred to the database, but not in the SRT-ASG-940105 report from which the data came. Comps: Table A.3 of SRT-ASG-940104, PCTs: Table A.5 of SRT-ASG-940105, Comps are the average of 4 replicates. These oxides were reported in this database as follows: Mn was assumed to be MnO. Copper was reported as the oxide wt.% of ½ the elemental value (avg. report value/2.5036 for ½ elemental, and ½ elemental times 1.2518 for CuO and ½ elemental times 1.1259 for Cu2O). Fe was assumed to be Fe2O3. 56 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 WSRC-NB-2005-00054 T1-1 Peeler Non-RW- Compositions: 0333P • Target compositions are on pages 116-117 of Compliant WSRC-NB-2005-00054. PCTs: • PCT data are on page 159 of WSRC-NB-2005-00054. General: • These data are classified as “non-model” since they are Non-RW-0333P Compliant. 1 WSRC-NB-2004-00134 Low-Li glasses Peeler Non-RW- Compositions: WSRC-NB-2004-00137 0333P • Target compositions are on pages 161-164 of Compliant WSRC-NB-2004-00134. • Measured compositions are on page 9 of WSRC-NB-2004-00137. PCTs: • PCT data are on pages 7-8 of WSRC-NB-2004-00137 • Some of the glasses do not contain Li2O, and therefore no PCT data for Li are reported for these glasses. • No normalized PCT data are reported for the Low-Li2 ccc glass, but raw PCT data for this glass are listed on page 171 of WSRC-NB-2004-00134. General: • These data are classified as “non-model” since they are Non-RW-0333P Compliant. 1 No report number Advanced Kobelev Non-RW- Compositions: Melter 0333P • Target and measured composition data for 3 glasses are Technology Compliant in Table 2.6 on page 34. Application to • Measured compositions for 2 glasses are listed in the Defense Table 3.5 on page 55. Waste • Note that these compositions were measured using Processing XRF, so the data are classified as non-model. Facility (DWPF) – Cold Crucible PCTs: Induction Heated • Normalized PCT data are given in Tables 2.7 and 3.6 Melter on pages 38 and 57, respectively. 57 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 * Mixed Waste JCM, Non-RW- Compositions: Data WGR, 0333P • Measured composition data were electronically copied MKA Compliant from a series of Excel spreadsheets. PCTs: • PCT data were electronically copied from a series of Excel spreadsheets. 1 SRT-ASG-95-0052 DWPF WP-15 Edwards RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-ASG-95-0053 Study Compliant • Measured composition data are given in Table B.1, Parts 3-5, beginning on page 58 of SRT-ASG-95-0052. The data are listed by LIMS ID. To find the corresponding Sample ID, see Part 1 of Table B.1, beginning on page 46. • There are multiple LIMS IDs per glass, so the average of these values was recorded in ComPro. • The report lists the oxides only by cation, and the elements with multiple oxidation states are not specifically discussed. Therefore: o Mn was assumed to be MnO. o Fe was assumed to be Fe2O3. o Cu was reported as the oxide wt.% of ½ the elemental value (avg. report value/2.5036 for ½ elemental, and 1/2 elemental times 1.2518 for CuO and ½ elemental times 1.1259 for Cu2O). PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table A.5 on page 23 of SRT-ASG-95-0053. • The reported values are the average of 3 replicates. 58 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 SRT-ASG-95-0066 DWPF WP-16 Edwards RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-ASG-95-0067 Study Compliant • Measured composition data are given in Table B.1, Parts 3-5, on page 57 of SRT-ASG-95-0066. The data are listed by LIMS ID. To find the corresponding Sample ID, see Part 1 of Table B.1, beginning on page 45. • There are multiple LIMS IDs per glass, so the average of these values was recorded in ComPro. • The report lists the oxides only by cation, and the elements with multiple oxidation states are not specifically discussed. Therefore: o Mn was assumed to be MnO. o Fe was assumed to be Fe2O3. • Cu was reported as the oxide wt.% of ½ the elemental value (avg. report value/2.5036 for ½ elemental, and 1/2 elemental times 1.2518 for CuO and ½ elemental times 1.1259 for Cu2O). PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table A.5 on page 21 of SRT-ASG-95-0067. • The reported values are the average of 3 replicates. 59 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO STUDY PRIMARY REPORT NUMBER QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 1 SRT-ASG-95-0069 DWPF WP-17 Edwards RW-0333P Compositions: SRT-ASG-95-0070 Study Compliant • Measured composition data are given in Table B.1, Parts 3-5, on page 47 of SRT-ASG-95-0069. The data are listed by LIMS ID. To find the corresponding Sample ID, see Part 1 of Table B.1, beginning on page 41. • There are multiple LIMS IDs per glass, so the average of these values was recorded in ComPro. • The report lists the oxides only by cation, and the elements with multiple oxidation states are not specifically discussed. Therefore: o Mn was assumed to be MnO. o Fe was assumed to be Fe2O3. • Cu was reported as the oxide wt.% of ½ the elemental value (avg. report value/2.5036 for ½ elemental, and 1/2 elemental times 1.2518 for CuO and ½ elemental times 1.1259 for Cu2O). PCTs: • Normalized PCT data are given in Table A.5 on page 21 of SRT-ASG-95-0070. • The reported values are the average of 3 replicates. 60 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO REPORT NUMBER STUDY PRIMARY QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 AFCI-WAST-WAST-MI-DV- Baseline Glass Crum Non-RW- Target and measured compositions in Table 6 (page 2009-000075 Development for (Billings) 0333P 19) and Table 7 (page 20). Note: Glass ID CSLNTM- Combined Compliant 2.5 in Table 6 is assumed to be mislabeled (i.e., it Fission Products should be CSLNTM-C-2.5 as reflected in Table 8 Waste Streams (page 21) for PCTs and in the ComPro database. PCTs in Tables 8 and 9 on page 21. Note: PCTs are based on measured composition only. The normalized boron release for CSLN-6C-Q (in Table 9, page 21) is reported as <0.01 g/L in the report, a "0" value was entered into the ComPro database. In addition, the cooling schedules used in this study are not typical DWPF CCC based. See Section 3.2 on page 11 for specifics. In ComPro, the special heat treatment is indicated as "see report" while in Tables 8 and 9 these heat treatments are indicated by a "-SC" suffix. 2 FCRD-WAST-2011-000404 Glass testing Ebert Non-RW- Compositions: see Table 1, page 6 (use oxide Activities at (Billings) 0333P column). Normalized PCT results for PSON-68 are ANL & SRNL Compliant shown in Table 13 (page 44). Note: The normalized release values for Al are shown as "<" in Table 13 but a "0" value is entered into the ComPro database for PSON-90-1 and PSON-90-2. PCT results for the PAFCI glass are shown in Table 14 (page 45). Notes: PCT values for both glasses are reported in g/m2 in the report. Values have been converted to g/L in database. In addition, only the 7-day duration values for both glasses are listed in the ComPro database. The PCT results of ARM-1, EA, and an AFCI glass shown in Table 12 (page 43) are not included in the ComPro database given the results are from a different study. 61 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO REPORT NUMBER STUDY PRIMARY QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 GNEP-WAST-PMO-MI-DV- Waste/Storage Billings Non-RW- Compositions: Measured compositions for glasses 2008-000151 Form Baseline- 0333P LN-A-SUB (SRNL), LN-X-SUB (SRNL), and LN- Fission Products Compliant 01-2008 (SRNL) are shown in Table 4 on page 13. and Lanthanides Measured compositions for glasses LN/TM-01-2008 (PNNL), LN/TM-02-2008 (PNNL), and LN+TM- SUB (SRNL) are shown in Table 5 on page 15. Measured compositions for glasses LN+TM+NM2 (SRNL) and LN/TM-03-2008 (PNNL) are shown in Table 6 on page 16. Measured compositions for glasses LN+TM-FE (SRNL), LN/TM-04-2008 (PNNL), and LN/TM-05-2008 (SRNL) are shown in Table 7 on page 17. Normalized PCTs provided in Table 8 and Table 9 on page 18. In addition, the normalized release values for Li and Na for the study glasses are reported as "NA" and thus are "missing values" in the database. A "<" value is shown for some of the B and Si values which are listed as "0" in the database. For Table 8 and Table 9, the glass IDs, excluding the lab suffix (SRNL or PNNL), are the same as in the previous compositional tables except for LN+TM-NM2 (Table 9) which is the same glass as LN+TM+NM2 in Table 6. 2 SRNS-STI-2008-00055 FY-07 EM-21 Raszewski Non-RW- Compositions: Table A5 (page 66) Enhanced Melter 0333P PCTs: Table 18 (page 42) Throughput Compliant Studies Matrix 2 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00302 Data Packet for Peeler Non-RW- Compositions: Target and measured compositions in the Frit 202-A11 0333P Table 6 (page 14) and Table 7 (pages 15 and 16). – SB3 Glass Compliant Although target compositions are listed in the report, System: A they are not listed in the ComPro database given the Candidate for the PCT results are normalized from measured Cold Crucible compositions only. PCTs: Both quenched and CCC Induction Melter values are given in Table 9 (page 19). Note: Only NC (CCIM) B release values are reported in Table 9; the Li, Na, Demonstration and Si values not listed in the report and thus "blank or missing" values in the ComPro database. 62 Table 5-2. ComPro “Non-Model” Data (Revision 3) (continued) COMPRO REPORT NUMBER STUDY PRIMARY QA LEVEL NOTES REVISION DESCRIPTION AUTHOR 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00363 Frit Selection to Fox Non-RW- Compositions: Table 2-5 (page 6) and Table 2-6 (page Support Steklo 0333P 7). Note: only target compositions are listed in these Metallicheskie Compliant tables. Konstruktsii PCTs: Table 3-2 (page 11); PCTs are normalized to (SMK) Melter target compositions Testing with SRNL Feeds 2 WSRC-STI-2007-00616 Sludge Variation Peeler Non-RW- Compositions: Table A6 (starting on page 43) in Frit 202-A11- 0333P PCTs: Table 5-4 for quenched (page 21) and Table 5- SB3 System Compliant 5 for CCC (page 23) 63 Table 5-3. Data Excluded from ComPro REPORT NUMBER TITLE JUSTIFICATION WSRC-TR-2006-00033 Glass Fabrication and Product Target and measured composition data are not included in the report (see page Consistency Testing of 21 or 36 of the report). Lanthanide Borosilicate Frit B Composition for Plutonium Disposition PVTD-C95-02.01D Effects of Minor Components on PCT data are not included in the report. Phase Separation of Simulated Nuclear Waste Glasses INEEL/EXT-99-01322 The Preparation and PCT B (Teflon vessels) utilized in collecting durability data. Characterization of INTEC Phase 2B Composition Variation Study Glasses PNNL-4992 West Valley High Level Nuclear PCT data are not included in the report. UC-70 Waste Glass Development: A Statistically Designed Mixture Study PNNL-6530 Process Performance of the Pilot- PCT data are not included in the report. UC-510 Scale In Situ Vitrification of a Simulated Waste Disposal Site at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory PNNL-11790 Liquidus Temperature Data for PCT data are not included in the report. DWPF Glass PNNL-12208 Science to Support DOE Site PCT data are not included in the report. UC-2000 Cleanup: The Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Environmental Management Science Program Awards PNNL-13009 Property Data for Simulated PCT data are not included in the report. Americium/Curium Glasses 64 6.0 References 1. A.S. Taylor, T.B. Edwards, J.C. George, T.K. Snyder, and D.K. Peeler, “The SRNL Composition - Properties (ComProTM) Database,” Westinghouse Savannah River Company, Aiken, SC, WSRC- RP-2004-00704, Revision 0, 2004. 2. ASTM, “Standard Test Methods for Determining Chemical Durability of Nuclear, Hazardous, and Mixed Waste Glasses and Multiphase Glass Ceramics: The Product Consistency Test (PCT),” ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, C1285 - 21, 2021. 3. A.I. Silker, “Update ComPro Database,” Savannah River Mission Completion, Aiken, SC, X-TTR- C-00085, Revision 2, 2024. 4. M.C. Hsieh and F.C. Johnson, “Task Technical and Quality Assurance Plan for Updating the ComPro™ Database,” Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, SC, SRNL-RP-2012-00198, Revision 2, 2025. 5. “Quality Assurance Requirements and Description: DOE/RW-0333P, Rev. 20,” Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, 2008. 6. S.P. Harris, “Software Test Plan for JMP®,” Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, SC, B- STP-A-00056, Revision 2, 2023. 7. S.P. Harris, “Software Quality Assurance Plan for JMP® Used for Statistical Analysis,” Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, SC, B-SQP-A-00103, Revision 1, 2023. 8. “Technical Reviews,” Savannah River Site, Aiken, SC, Manual E7, Procedure 2.60, Revision 23, 2024. 9. “Savannah River National Laboratory Technical Report Design Check Guidelines,” Westinghouse Savannah River Company, Aiken, SC, WSRC-IM-2002-00011, Revision 2, 2004. 10. M.C. Hsieh, “Data Qualification Report: SRNL Glass Composition - Properties (ComPro) Database,” Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, SC, SRNL-STI-2009-00094, Revision 2, 2025. 11. C.M. Jantzen, J.B. Pickett, K.G. Brown, T.B. Edwards, and D.C. Beam, “Process/Product Models for the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF): Part I. Predicting Glass Durability from Composition Using a Thermodynamic Hydration Energy Reaction Model (THERMO),” Westinghouse Savannah River Company, Aiken, SC, WSRC-TR-93-672, Revision 1, 1995. 65 Distribution: william.bates@srnl.doe.gov utopia.boynton@srnl.doe.gov heather.capogreco@srnl.doe.gov tyler.chavous@srnl.doe.gov brandi.clark@srnl.doe.gov vanessa.cofer@srnl.doe.gov alex.cozzi@srnl.doe.gov c.diprete@srnl.doe.gov david.diprete@srnl.doe.gov catelyn.folkert@srnl.doe.gov connie.herman@srnl.doe.gov sarah.hodges@srnl.doe.gov madison.hsieh@srnl.doe.gov charles.james@srnl.doe.gov fabienne.johnson@srnl.doe.gov william.jolin@srnl.doe.gov mary.lamb@srnl.doe.gov brady.lee@srnl.doe.gov joseph.manna@srnl.doe.gov andrew.marvel@srs.gov gregg.morgan@srnl.doe.gov ralph.nichols@srnl.doe.gov frank.pennebaker@srnl.doe.gov amy.ramsey@srnl.doe.gov william.ramsey@srnl.doe.gov luther.reid@srnl.doe.gov nicodemus.rod@srnl.doe.gov aubrey.silker@srs.gov eric.skidmore@srnl.doe.gov darrin.stein@srnl.doe.gov michael.stone@srnl.doe.gov boyd.wiedenman@srnl.doe.gov mary.whitehead@srnl.doe.gov morgana.whiteside@srnl.doe.gov Records Administration (EDWS) 66