LA-UR-26-27380 Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. Title: Dissertation Proposal Characterization of Inorganic Solids for Cherenkov-Based Radiation Detectors Author(s): Rudziensky, Emma Diane Intended for: Report Issued: 2026-10-05 (rev.1) Los Alamos National Laboratory, an affirmative action/equal opportunity employer, is operated by Triad National Security, LLC for the National Nuclear Security Administration of U.S. Department of Energy under contract 89233218CNA000001. By approving this article, the publisher recognizes that the U.S. Government retains nonexclusive, royalty-free license to publish or reproduce the published form of this contribution, or to allow others to do so, for U.S. Government purposes. Los Alamos National Laboratory requests that the publisher identify this article as work performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy. Los Alamos National Laboratory strongly supports academic freedom and a researcher's right to publish; as an institution, however, the Laboratory does not endorse the viewpoint of a publication or guarantee its technical correctness. University of Texas at Austin Nuclear and Radiation Engineering Program Dissertation Proposal Characterization of Inorganic Solids for Cherenkov-Based Radiation Detectors by Emma Rudziensky Supervisor: Dr. William Charlton Committee Member: Dr. Derek Haas Committee Member: Dr. Edward McKigney Committee Member: Dr. Elena Zannoni August 2026 1 Abstract Characterization of Inorganic Solids for Cherenkov-Based Radiation Detectors Cherenkov radiation is of interest to a variety of radiation detection applica- tions including treaty monitoring, medicine, high energy physics, pulsed power, and material science. Proposed is a study to identify new Cherenkov media that can improve upon the performance of fused silica, which is the most common choice of solid Cherenkov radiator. Optical transmission, radioluminescence (RL), photolumi- nescence (PL), photoluminescence excitation (PLE), and thermoluminescence (TL) measurements would be performed and used to develop detector response functions for these materials. Then the materials would be ranked in order of their suitability for use in Cherenkov detectors. Finally, the top material would be used to design a detector module with optimized light collection for a chosen application and its performance simulated using MCNP6. 2 AI Usage Disclaimer ChatGPT model generations 5.1 through 5.6 were used in the preparation of this proposal. Specifically, they assisted with: • Background research related to optics and condensed matter physics • Literature review document discovery • Extracting bibliographic information from reference documents, generating ci- tations using it, and organizing those citations • Extracting data from tables and plots in scientific papers for use in calculations • Writing data visualization scripts in Python • Technical writing with LaTeX Additionally, ”AI Overviews” automatically provided with Google search re- sults were referenced on a variety of scientific and writing topics. All AI outputs were reviewed and, as necessary, edited by the author prior to their inclusion in this document. 3 Table of Contents List of Tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 List of Figures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Chapter 1: Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 1.1 Objective . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 1.2 What is Cherenkov Radiation? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 1.3 Cherenkov Detector Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 1.3.1 Treaty Monitoring . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 1.3.2 Cancer Treatment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 1.3.3 High Energy Physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 1.3.4 Pulsed Power Machine Diagnostics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 1.3.5 Material Science . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Chapter 2: Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 2.1 Theory of Cherenkov Radiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 2.1.1 Energy Threshold . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 2.1.2 Energy Spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 2.2 Identifying and Evaluating Cherenkov Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 2.2.1 Desirable Material Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 2.2.2 Material Evaluation Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Chapter 3: Preliminary Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 3.1 Material Down-Selection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 3.2 Summary of Literature Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 3.2.1 Fused Silica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 3.2.2 Sapphire . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 3.2.3 Heavy Metal Fluoride Glasses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Chapter 4: Proposed Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 Chapter 5: Risk Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Appendix A: Literature Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 A.1 Fused Silica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 A.2 Sapphire . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 A.3 Fluoroindate Glass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 A.4 Fluorozirconate Glass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78 4 List of Tables 1 Properties of selected Cherenkov radiator candidate materials . . . . 28 2 High-level summary of literature review findings. . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 3 Self-assessed risks to project outcomes and schedule . . . . . . . . . . 43 5 List of Figures 1 2D Huygens construction of the emission of Cherenkov radiation . . . 10 2 2D Huygens construction of the pressure waves surrounding an aircraft at different flight speeds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 3 Cherenkov radiation inside the Advanced Test Reactor at Idaho Na- tional Laboratory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 4 Measured refractive index as a function of wavelength for photons in Corning HPFS 7980 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 5 Amount of kinetic energy that an electron must have for it to produce a given wavelength of Cherenkov light in Corning HPFS 7980 . . . . 17 6 Theoretical spectrum of Cherenkov radiation induced in water . . . . 19 7 Figure 6 data re-expressed in terms of wavelength with focus on the low-wavelength region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 8 Experimentally measured Cherenkov spectrum for water irradiated by P-32 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 9 Sample time-resolved RL measurement setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 10 Sample time-resolved RL data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 11 A basic PL measurement setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 12 A basic PLE measurement setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 13 Proposed timeline of completion for dissertation research . . . . . . . 42 6 Glossary 2D Two-dimensional AI Artificial intelligence CL Cathodoluminescence CW Continuous wave DNA Deoxyribonucleic acid HAWC High-Altitude Water Cherenkov HEM Heat exhanger method HMFG Heavy metal fluoride glass HPFS High-purity fused silica IFG Indium fluoride (or ”fluoroindate”) glass IR Infrared IZSB A glass containing In, Zn, Sr, and Ba fluorides LANL Los Alamos National Laboratory LAOS Low-optical-absorption sapphire MCNP Monte Carlo N-Particle NIF National Ignition Facility PALS Positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy PET Positron emission tomography PL Photoluminescence PLE Photoluminescence-excitation PMT Photomultiplier tube 7 RL Radioluminescence SME Subject matter expert TL Thermoluminescence TOF Time of flight TSL Thermally-stimulated luminescence UV Ultraviolet VCR Vavilov-Čerenkov radiation ZBLAN A glass containing Zr, Ba, La, Al, and Na fluorides ZFG Zirconium fluoride (or ”fluorozirconate”) glass 8 Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Objective The goal of this study is to identify and characterize solid materials that can be used to generate Cherenkov radiation for fast, high-time-resolution detection of gamma ray fluxes. 1.2 What is Cherenkov Radiation? Cherenkov radiation is luminescence resulting from the movement of a charged particle through a medium faster than the phase velocity of light in that medium, cm . Cherenkov1 radiation is also known as “Čerenkov” 2 , “Cerenkov” 3 , or “Vavilov- Čerenkov” 4 radiation. The emission of Cherenkov radiation is shown in Figure 1. A charged particle (purple) moves to the right with velocity υ > cm . The charged particle’s electric field causes polarization of nearby material, a disturbance that propagates outward in all directions (a spherical wavelet, grey dotted). Because the charge particle is moving faster than the disturbances can propagate, successive wavelets ”pile up” in the direction of motion. They constructively interfere to form a conical wavefront (solid grey). The result is a coherent flash of light emitted with angle θ relative to the original charged particle trajectory. Cherenkov radiation is to optics as the sonic boom is to acoustics. A super- sonic aircraft generates pressure waves in air faster than they can emanate, causing 1 The most common English spelling 2 The most technically correct transliteration of Nobel laureate Pavel Čerenkov’s Russian name 3 Another common spelling, particularly in older texts where the caron mark could not be rendered properly 4 A variant, common in Russian-language publications, which shares credit for the discovery and explanation of this phenomenon between Čerenkov and his doctoral advisor Sergei Vavilov 9 Figure 1: 2D Huygens construction of the emission of Cherenkov radiation. Each large dot represents the position of the super-luminal charged particle at a different point in time. Only a single Cherenkov photon is shown for clarity, though they would over time be emitted at every point along the conical wavefront. formation of a shock front. Note the similarity of the wavelet patterns in Figure 1 and the rightmost case in Figure 2. Perhaps most ubiquitous example of Cherenkov radiation is the blue glow surrounding the core of a nuclear reactor, as shown in Figure 3. This results from interaction of high energy electrons (i.e., from radioactive decay of unstable fission products) with the cooling water. Another more somber example is the blue flash of light that victims of criticality accidents often report seeing at the time of a super- critical excursion. In this case, fission neutrons and gamma ray interactions in the vitreous humour produce charged particles, and the latter go on to produce Cherenkov 10 Figure 2: 2D Huygens construction of the pressure waves surrounding an aircraft at different flight speeds, adapted from [1]. light. Figure 3: Cherenkov radiation inside the Advanced Test Reactor at Idaho National Laboratory, reprinted from [2]. As previously stated, the purpose of this study is to identify materials that can serve as Cherenkov radiators in gamma ray detectors. Because Cherenkov radiation is produced by charged particles, it is an indirect form of gamma detection. Incident gamma rays must have interactions in the Cherenkov medium that produce charged particles (such as photoelectric absorption, Compton scattering, pair production, etc.) to be detected, as it is the latter that create Cherenkov light. 11 1.3 Cherenkov Detector Applications There is a long history of using the Cherenkov effect as a method of radiation detection, which spans many fields. In most cases, a Cherenkov radiator is used to convert ionizing radiation into an optical signal and a photomultiplier tube (PMT) is used to record it. 1.3.1 Treaty Monitoring This author and collaborators have previously developed a fused silica Cherenkov detector system for potential use in treaty monitoring [3]. The system is portable and is intended for deployment on nuclear weapon physics experiments to prove their com- pliance with the Comprehensive-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT). The detector measures the intensity of fission gamma rays coming from an object under test over time, using the slope trend to infer whether the test was subcritical or supercritical. 1.3.2 Cancer Treatment Cherenkov detectors can support efforts to both find and treat cancer. Positron emission tomography (PET) is a medical imaging technique where a patient is injected with a radioactive tracer that accumulates in areas with high metabolic activity, like tumors. When the radioisotope decays, it emits a positron, and the PET scanner detects the opposing annihilation gammas. The points where opposing gamma rays are detected can be connected by a “line of response”. Lines of response from many radioactive decays intersect at the radioactive source location(s). The result is a 3D image showing where tumors are located in the body. There is a related technique called time of flight (TOF) PET, where higher resolution images can be constructed because the time offset between detection of the two gamma rays is indicative of the specific point along the line of response where the annihilation occurred. This method demands picosecond-order time resolution, prompting interest in Cherenkov-based detectors [4] [5]. 12 Proton therapy is an advanced, noninvasive cancer treatment that uses high- energy proton beams instead of X-rays to destroy cancer cells by damaging their DNA. Bragg peaks allow these particles to deliver maximum energy directly into the tumor and stop, limiting damage to surrounding healthy tissue and reducing side effects. However, uncertainties associated with computing the range as well as variations in clinical implementation motivate the use of range verification methods. Cherenkov detectors have been studied as a potential prompt-gamma-type verification method [6]. 1.3.3 High Energy Physics Cherenkov detectors have been used extensively in the field of high energy physics, for example, as a means of detecting neutrinos and/or cosmic rays. Low interaction probabilities require very large detection volumes, making liquid water and ice practical choices of detector media [7]. Examples include the High Altitude Water Cherenkov Experiment (HAWC), IceCube, Hyper-Kamiokande and its predecessors, and the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory. 1.3.4 Pulsed Power Machine Diagnostics Cherenkov detectors of various forms have also been used to diagnose oper- ating characteristics of pulsed power machines. Aerogel Cherenkov detectors have been deployed as spectral diagnostics on the Cygnus [8] and Mercury [9] pulsed x-ray sources. Both gaseous [10] and solid [11] Cherenkov detectors have been deployed as inertial confinement fusion diagnostics at the National Ignition Facility (NIF). Simi- larly, solid Cherenkov detectors have been deployed on tokamak magnetic confinement fusion reactors [12] [13]. 13 1.3.5 Material Science Positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy (PALS) is a non-destructive spec- troscopy technique that allows material properties, such as void fraction, to be stud- ied on an atomic scale. A radioactive source emits characteristic gamma rays and positrons, which eventually annihilate with electrons in the sample under test. The longer the offset between when characteristic gammas and annihilation gammas are observed (the positron lifetime), the more voids are present. Solid Cherenkov detec- tors have been used for gamma detection in this application due to their nanosecond- order time response [14]. 14 Chapter 2: Background This chapter is intended to familiarize the reader with the basic theory of Cherenkov radiation as well as how Cherenkov media can be identified and evaluated for use in radiation detectors. 2.1 Theory of Cherenkov Radiation 2.1.1 Energy Threshold The speed of light in a medium is cm = c/n, where c is the speed of light in vacuum and n(λ) is the wavelength-dependent index of refraction (dimensionless). Cherenkov radiation of a particular wavelength, λ, is only emitted when the velocity of a charged particle, υ, exceeds cm for that wavelength. Therefore, in this context, cm can also be referred to as the threshold velocity υth . vth = c/n(λ) (2.1) For a relativistic particle, the corresponding threshold kinetic energy, Eth , is Eth = (γth − 1)mc2 (2.2) where m is the particle mass and γth is the threshold Lorentz factor: p γth = 1/ 1 − (1/n(λ))2 (2.3) Figure 4 shows dispersion (the dependence of n on λ) in fused silica. Note how the refractive index is higher at shorter wavelengths. 15 Figure 4: Measured refractive index as a function of wavelength for photons in Corning HPFS 7980 [15]. Figure 5 shows how this dispersion affects the threshold for a given wavelength of Cherenkov radiation to be generated in that material. To summarize the relation- ship, the longer the incident wavelength, the less that light slows down in a material, and the harder it is for a charged particle to outpace it. Note that while charged par- ticles must have at least the threshold kinetic energy to produce Cherenkov light of a certain wavelength, this production does not cause the charged particle appreciable kinetic energy loss. 16 Figure 5: Amount of kinetic energy that an electron must have for it to produce a given wavelength of Cherenkov light in Corning HPFS 7980. This was calculated using Equations 2.2 and 2.3. 2.1.2 Energy Spectrum In 1937, Ilya Frank and Igor Tamm developed a theoretical description [16] of Cherenkov radiation which later earned them the 1958 Nobel Prize in Physics. This included derviation of what is now known as the Frank-Tamm formula: the energy dE emitted per unit length dx traveled by the particle per unit of frequency dw is ∂ 2E q2 c2   = µ(ω)ω 1 − 2 2 (2.4) ∂x∂ω 4π υ n (ω) where µ(ω) and n(ω) are the frequency-dependent permeability and index of refrac- tion of the medium respectively, and q is the electric charge of the particle. In this context ”permeability” refers to magnetic permeability, which is a measure of a ma- terial’s ability to support the formation of an internal magnetic field, or how easily it magnetizes in an external one. If q has units [C], µ has units [N s2 C −2 ], ω has units [rad/s], and c and v each have units [m/s], then the left hand sides has units [Js/m]. Equation 2.4 can be rewritten to yield the number N of photons emitted 17 per unit distance per unit wavelength in [photons/m2 ] by making the substitutions ω = 2πυ/λ and E = N hc/λ, where h is Planck’s constant in [Js] and λ is in [m]. This gives ∂ 2N c2   1 = πc2 q 2 µ(λ) 3 1− 2 2 (2.5) ∂x∂λ λ υ n (λ) Equation 2.5 implies a continuous intensity vs. wavelength spectrum which that is heavily skewed to the right: the shorter the wavelength, the more intense the Cherenkov radiation (UV divergence). This is unsurpising given the previous discussion of the Cherenkov threshold. It is easier for electrons to ”outrun” UV light than visible light in a medium, so more Cherenkov light is generated at lower wavelengths. The theoretical upper limit of Cherenkov intensity as λ → 0 was an open question for some time. In 1992, L. Fülöp and T. Biró proposed modifications to the Frank-Tamm formula to obtain a theoretical spectrum of Cherenkov radiation which gives decreasing intensities in the near-UV region, with a predictable upper limit as a function of particle velocity [17]. An example spectrum calculated using their approach is shown in Figure 6. 18 Figure 6: Theoretical spectrum of Cherenkov radiation induced in water (n = 1.33, βth = vth /c = 0.75). The velocity ratio v/c is taken to be β = 0.8, corre- sponding to an electron energy of 341 keV. Reprinted from [17]. If one recasts the above data from frequency to wavelength domain and re- stricts the domain to the low-wavelength region for clarity, the result is Figure 7 Figure 7: Figure 6 data re-expressed in terms of wavelength with focus on the low- wavelength region 19 Few measured Cherenkov energy spectra are available in the literature. Those that are typically have water as a Cherenkov medium [18, 19], one of which is pre- sented in Figure 8. Figure 8: Experimentally measured Cherenkov spectrum for water irradiated by P- 32, reprinted from [18]. P-32 emits beta particles with an average energy of 0.7 MeV and a maximum energy of 1.71 MeV. The Cherenkov spectrum was constructed by conducting a series of liquid scintillation spectroscopy measurements using different color filters. Note that both the Fülöp-Biró theoretical spectrum (Figure 7) and Kulcasr’s experimental spectrum (Figure 8) for Cherenkov radiation produced in water show peaks above 400 nm, which places them in the visible range. The author suspects that the peak of the spectrum resides in the UV in many cases, including with fused silica, which makes it difficult to measure experimentally. Most practical detector materials (for instance, the Cherenkov radiators themselves, optical interface pads, and photomultiplier tube windows) typically have poor optical transmission below 200 nm. Thus the Cherenkov photon yield and the overall sensitivity of a radiation detection system attempting to measure it may trend in opposite directions with 20 respect to wavelength, making efficient detection a tricky problem indeed. 2.2 Identifying and Evaluating Cherenkov Materials The following subsections outline general criteria for selecting Cherenkov me- dia and explain some methods that can be used to evaluate their suitability for Cherenkov detector systems. 2.2.1 Desirable Material Properties Several important properties of materials used for Cherenkov detectors are listed below; this likely non-comprehensive. • High density– The more atoms that are present per unit volume, the more material can be polarized along a given charged particle track, increasing the number of Cherenkov photons produced. • High index of refraction– The higher the refractive index, the lower the Cherenkov energy threshold. The lower the threshold, the more particles stand to produce Cherenkov light, increasing overall light yield. However, an applica- tion where appreciable low-energy backgrounds (for example, 511 keV photons from pair production) are present may motivate the selection of a material with a lower refractive index to improve the signal-to-background ratio. • Low UV-VIS absorption– Cherenkov photons cannot reach a detector if they are absorbed in the medium that generated them. Because the Cherenkov intensity is highest at low wavelengths, transmission also needs to be high there. High transmission increases detection efficiency. • Lack of competing luminescence mechanisms– The de-excitation that re- sults in Cherenkov emission occurs on the picosecond time scale [20]. If another type of luminescence is in play, such as scintillation, the time response can be 21 orders of magnitude slower. A material’s luminescence behavior is driven by its electronic structure. A material can have intrinsic luminescence due to lat- tice defects such as interstitials and vacancies. Additionally, luminescence can be caused by the presence of foreign matter, either as intentional dopants or impurities.) 2.2.2 Material Evaluation Methods The following is a description of various measurements whose results can be used to understand whether a candidate material is suitable for use as a Cherenkov radiation detector. They all probe different aspects of a material’s electronic struc- ture. • Radioluminescence – Radioluminescence (RL) is the emission of visible or UV light from a material caused by excitation from ionizing radiation. Cherenkov radiation is one form of RL. Knowing the energy spectrum of the Cherenkov emission from a particular radiator material is important to the design of the greater detector system. However, it is likely that most radiator materials will also exhibit other types of RL, such as scintillation, that could spectrally overlap with the Cherenkov emission. Time-resolved spectroscopy can help differentiate between the two because Cherenkov emission occurs on shorter timescales. For example, a fused silica prism might be irradiated with a pulsed x-ray source, the emitted light passed through a diffraction grating, and a streak camera used to record the spectrum as a function of time, as shown in Figure 9. The resulting record is a 3D ”streak spectrogram” with axes of emitted wavelength (or photon energy), time, and intensity, as shown in Figure 10. Picosecond-order time resolution and nanometer-order wavelength resolution may be required. 22 Figure 9: Sample time-resolved RL measurement setup. Aggregated from [21, 22]. Figure 10: Sample time-resolved RL data. Reprinted from [23]. • Optical Transmission– Optical transmission (or conversely absorption) in a material can be measured as a function of input wavelength by attaching a scanning monochromator to a broadband light source, placing a sample in 23 the monochromatic beam, and measuring the transmitted light downstream of the sample at many different input wavelengths. The ideal result for a Cherenkov radiator is 100% transmission in the wavelength range of that ma- terial’s Cherenkov emission spectrum. • Photoluminescence & Photoluminescence Excitation– Photolumines- cence is a process where a material absorbs photons, exciting electrons to a higher energy state, and subsequently emits lower energy photons as the elec- trons relax. Photoluminescence (PL) measurements and Photoluminescence- Excitation (PLE) measurements are complementary spectroscopic techniques. PL measures emitted intensity versus emission wavelength at a fixed excitation wavelength. Ideally none of the emission peaks overlap with the Cherenkov spectrum of the given material, which would be nuisance signals. Figure 11 shows a basic laboratory setup for measuring PL. The continuous-wave (CW) laser emits light at a fixed wavelength, and the filter removes that wavelength from the emission spectrum so that it does not dominate the signal. The spec- trometer analyzes the spectrum of light coming from the sample by using a diffraction grating to record the intensity of each constituent wavelength one at a time. Figure 11: A basic PL measurement setup PLE measures emitted intensity versus excitation wavelength at a fixed emission wavelength. In this case, it helps identify what specific excitation wavelengths 24 are causing nuisance signals so that potential workarounds (such as filtering) could be identified. Figure 12 shows a basic laboratory setup for measuring PLE. The scanning monochromator makes a beam using one wavelength from the broadband CW source at a time. The sample’s emission spectrum is filtered so that its intensity is only studied at one emission wavelength. Figure 12: A basic PLE measurement setup In practice, both PL and PLE measurements are sometimes performed using the same measurement setup. This is because both require similar equipment and because comprehensive characterization requires iterating between the two methods. The resulting record would be a 3D specrogram with axes of exci- tation wavelength, emission wavelength, and intensity. The overall goal is to understand which excitation wavelengths will cause luminescence in a sample and what the spectrum of that luminescence will be in each case. • Thermoluminescence– Thermoluminescence (TL), also known as Thermally- Stimulated Luminescence (TSL), is the emission of visible or UV light from a material upon heating due to having previously absorbed energy from ionizing radiation. Rather than characterizing the instantaneous emission behavior as in PL and RL, TL characterizes a material’s trap structure. Radiation creates trapped carriers, heating releases those carriers, and then radiative recombi- nation can occur. Observing the radiative recombination can help understand how deep the traps are (based on the temperature of charge release) and how 25 many are present (based on light intensity upon release). Traps are of interest because (a) they can reduce the yield of prompt luminescence mechanisms and (b) de-trapping can create a time-varying background signal in a current-mode Cherenkov measurement. For this study, samples could be irradiated using the same source as the RL measurements. Then glow (intensity vs. temperature) curves could be constructed by slowly heating the irradiated sample and col- lecting the emitted light with a photodetector at different intervals. 26 Chapter 3: Preliminary Work This chapter describes work that has already been completed to lay the foun- dation for the proposed dissertation research. 3.1 Material Down-Selection The selection of candidate Cherenkov materials for purchase for this project took into account the ”desirable material properties” described in 2.2.1 as well as some application-specific considerations described below. Cherenkov radiation is universal in the sense that all transparent bodies in the liquid, gaseous, and solid states glow under the action of charged particles with sufficient energy [20]. However, the scope of the current effort will be restricted to solid Cherenkov media for several reasons. Solids offer relatively high detection efficiency [19] and/or long detector shelf life compared to liquids and gases. Gases also bring unique hazard considerations (pressure safety and chemical safety) and the inefficiency of using a conversion target. Conversion targets are used to convert photons into electrons in order to generate Cherenkov radiation, but high Z materials that have high photon interaction cross sections have high self-attenuation of the resulting electron signal. In contrast, a single homogenous solid can both convert an incident photon signal to an electron signal and allow 100% ”collection” of those electrons for subsequent Cherenkov generation. For scheduling reasons, the candidate materials must also be readily commer- cially available. Four materials were selected and purchased: high purity fused silica (HPFS), sapphire, a fluorozirconate glass (ZFG), and a fluoroindate glass (IFG). Basic material properties for them are aggregated from [15], [24], [25], and [26] in Table 1. 27 Table 1: Properties of selected Cherenkov radiator candidate materials Product Vendor Chemical Structure Density Index of Optical Name Composi- (g/cc) Refrac- Transmis- tion tion nD a sion Range (µm) HPFS Corning SiO2 Amorphous 2.201 1.46 0.193 to 4 7980 (ArF Gradeb ) HEM Crystal Al2 O3 Crystalline 3.98 Unavailable 0.15 to LAOSc Systems 4.6 ZFG La Verre 53ZrF4 − Amorphous 4.5 1.50-1.51 0.22 to 7 Fluoré 20BaF2 − 4LaF3 − 3AlF3 − 20N aF d IFG La Verre 40InF3 − Amorphous 5.0 1.48-1.51 0.255 to 8 Fluoré 20ZnF2 − 20SrF2 − 20BaF2 e a The index of refraction measured at the sodium D line, a famous doublet bracketing 589 nm. b Optics for use with ArF lasers, which have an output wavelength of 193 nm, require extremely low impurity content. c HEM LAOS stands for ”Heat Exchanger Method Low Optical Absorption Sapphire” d One kind of ”ZBLAN” e One kind of ”IZSB” Corning HPFS 7980 (ArF Grade) is already a workhorse Cherenkov radiator material and is included as a baseline to which the performance of the rest of the materials can be compared. Crystal Systems HEM LAOS appears to offer better properties than this HPFS across the board. Wavelength-dependent index of refrac- tion data is not available from the manufacturer for this specialized type of sapphire, but this author expects it to be around 1.76-1.77 (depending on the polarization of incident light compared to the c-axis) at 589 nm. How the ZFG and IFG from Le Verre Fluoré rank will depend on which material property turns out to be most im- portant, as they have the highest densities but average indices of refraction and the poorest UV transmission performance. All material samples are rectangular windows that measure 25 mm wide by 28 35 mm by by 5 mm thick. Other materials considered were MgF2 , CaF2 , C (diamond), AlN, TiO2 (ru- tile), lead oxide glasses of varying compositions, PbF2 , ZrO2 (cubic zirconia), TlBr, TlCl, CsI, and more. Some of these have already been extensively studied; some pose health and safety concerns; some have a subset of the desirable material properties but lack too many others to warrant further investigation. 3.2 Summary of Literature Review A review of existing literature was conducted to answer the following questions: 1. What applications are Cherenkov radiation detectors already used in? 2. What materials have been used as Cherenkov radiators in past detectors? 3. To what extent have optical transmission, PL/PLE, RL, and TL measurements been performed on each of the Cherenkov radiator materials selected for this study? These topics were researched in the order listed above. Findings for the first two topics were included in previous sections of this report. The final topic received the most attention and is the focus of this section. A different subsection is devoted to summarizing findings for each material. Detailed discussion on each individual reference for this topic is available in Appendix A. Literature searches were conducted manually and using ChatGPT 5.1-5.6. The manual searches were conducted on Google Scholar, in the University of Texas Li- braries Database (filtered to content type: “Dissertations”), and in the Los Alamos Authors database (filtered to content type: “Peer-reviewed” and “open access”). Common search terms included “Cerenkov”, “Cherenkov”, “Fluoroindate”, “Fluo- rozirconate”, “Corning 7980”, “Fused Silica”, and “Sapphire”. 29 Over 100 papers went through an initial screening for relevance. Of those, more than 50 papers were fully reviewed, including a closer read, written summary, and re-evaluation of relevance. Table 2 gives a general impression of how each proposed measurement fits into the existing body of work on the materials selected for study. Legend Fused Silica Sapphire IFG ZFG No data found in Transmission existing literature Extended Extended Novel PL/PLE mapping mapping contribution Marked improvement over Time- Novel Time- existing literature RL resolved contribution resolved Marginal Low- Novel improvement over TL temperature contribution existing literature Replicate for thoroughness Table 2: High-level summary of literature review findings. Each cell in the table contains one of the proposed characterizations (for ex- ample, radioluminescence measurements on sapphire) and the colors are used to rate their novelty. The information in the lightest shade of blue is already available, but will be remeasured in the current study for thoroughness. The next darker shade in- dicates areas where the proposed measurements would make a marginal improvement on those already available. For example, much of the existing literature lacks suffi- cient detail about the test samples used for their results to predict those of this study, so added specificity could help eliminate some ambiguity. Morphology, composition, purity, manufacturing method, and geometry are all important sample characteristics to include. Even darker blue indicates areas where the proposed study results would be a substantial improvement over what is already available. The type of improve- ment varies case-by-case for these, so the table gives some additional detail. Finally, 30 the darkest shade of blue indicates areas that, as far as the author can discern, have not been studied at all. These are areas where the proposed study stands to make novel contributions to the field. 3.2.1 Fused Silica Cherenkov production in fused silica is well known both as a nuisance signal in optical fibers [27, 28] and as an intentional form of radiation detection used by both by my team [3] and others [11] in the past. Some meta-analyses [29, 30] have been conducted to provide a comprehensive picture of optically-active defect centers in amorphous silicon oxide. These detail the types of defects present and how they affect optical transmission, PL, and PLE of the material. More focused and contemporary papers such as [31–33] offer additional insight into the structure of the material, common color centers, and the defects that they are associated with. The body of work concerning the optical properties of fused silica is very large. However, values reported ”vary significantly due to numerous sample features and experimental conditions” [34]. Therefore, in order to ensure the relevance of results, the search was narrowed to focus specifically on Corning 7980. The manufacturer provides two key data sheets for 7980 [15, 35] which include manufacturing information as well as optical, chemical, thermal, and mechanical prop- erties. There are several different grades of this material: standard grade, KrF grade, ArF grade, mirror grade, and industrial grade. The ArF grade was selected for this study because it has the lowest impurity content (metallic impurities <100 ppb and OH content 800-1000 ppb). It contains hydrogen to minimize UV absorption and is certified to have internal transmittance ≥ 99.5%/cm at 193 nm. Index of refraction vs. wavelength data are reported in [35]. The manufacturer states in [15] that the ArF grade exhibits ”no visible fluorescence when exposed to a deuterium source from 215 nm - 400 nm”. 31 The most thorough measurement of optical transmission vs. wavelength for Corning 7980 ArF is provided in Figure 1 of [36]. This dataset goes down to a wavelength of 150 nm and the x-intercept appears to be around 162 nm. Photoluminescence data for virgin (undamaged) Corning 7980 is available in [37–39]. None of these references state which grade of material was used; it is assumed that the lack of specificity implies standard grade. While additional PL data provided in [40] are not as relevant because they were measured using radiation-damaged rather than virgin material, experimental setup information may be helpful. This paper also states that the spectroscopic characteristics of non-bridging oxygen hole centers (a common type of point defect in fused silica) were the same regardless of whether they were induced by a laser or ionizing radiation. Studies involving the irradiation of fused silica tend to focus on the impacts of radiation-induced damage [36, 40, 41] rather than the immediate luminescent response of the material to ionizing radiation. However, some RL data are provided in [28] and [27]. In [28], fused silica fibers were irradiated with an electron beam and the angle of the emitted light was indicative of Cherenkov radiation. In [27], fused silica fibers were irradiated both at gamma irradiation facility and at a fission reactor. Though spectrally-resolved RL data are reported, because detailed information about the samples is not given, any comparisons to RL from Corning 7980 ArF should be made with caution. A Cherenkov spectrum for fused silica subjected to a pulsed electron beam is reported in [19]. A streak camera and a set of optical filters allowed for both time-resolved and spectrally-resolved measurements. The measured Cherenkov pulse duration was 27.0 ± 4.0 ps. A theoretical prediction of the Cherenkov spectrum which appears to be different than that predicted in the theory section of this report warrants a closer look. The measured Cherenkov spectrum aligned with prediction between 350 nm and the upper measurement limit of 500 nm. Several possible reasons were given for poor agreement below 350 nm. The peak of the Cherenkov spectrum 32 could not be observed. Fused silica sample characteristics were not reported. Thermoluminescence data for fused silica are available in [42]. However, all of the samples were doped with rare-earth elements and data on the intrinsic material were not reported as a baseline. However, the experimental method used here sounds applicable to the present study, so it is helpful to have details on the instruments used and how results might be analyzed and presented. The only relevant past doctoral research that surfaced in the fused silica lit- erature search was [43]. For the most part, this study’s data will not overlap with that proposed here due to the use of doped fused silica samples. (An exception is Figure 2.4, which provides an RL spectrum for an undoped sample). However, the background information on the scintillation process, the Cherenkov radiation pro- cess, and optical properties in Chapter 1, the experimental setups and analyses used in Chapters 3, 4, and 5, and the general level of detail with which material electronic structure is discussed make this a valuable resource to guide the current effort. 3.2.2 Sapphire The sapphire selected for this study is a C-cut (also known as Z-cut) single crystal grown by the heat exchanger method (HEM). The manufacturer, Crystal Systems, provides basic material properties in [44]. The manufacturing process is designed to yield ”high-purity optical sapphire that eliminates almost all intrinsic photon absorption”. The quoted transmission range is 150 nm to 4.6 µm and a plot of transmission vs. wavelength in the UV region shows transmission of nearly 80% or greater from 190 nm to 298 nm. This data sheet also includes basic physical, mechanical, thermal, and electrical properties. Impurity concentrations and indices of refraction are notably absent from this data sheet. General information concerning sapphire structure, defects, and color centers is available in [45–49]. However, color centers are strongly influenced by the crystal growth procedure [50, 51], so it is unclear how well sapphire data from the literature 33 will represent the behavior of the specific material chosen for this study. In the absence of index of refraction data available from the supplier of this material, the indices reported in [52] will be used. They are for C-cut sapphire at ambient temperature and cover a wavelength range of 200 nm to 5.5 µm. It is unclear whether these are calculated or measured values. PL/PLE data are available from several sources [48, 53, 54], though none would be directly comparable with that from this study due to lack of information about and/or differences in the method of sample manufacture, morphology, and purity. However, these studies do offer helpful information about experimental setups that could yield the desired data. [48] describes setups for time-resolved spectroscopy measurements on millisecond and nanosecond time scales; the latter is fast enough to differentiate Cherenkov from other luminescence. Also, the combination PL/PLE setup used by [53] yielded data of the exact format that I hope to generate, where emission wavelength is plotted against excitation wavelength with intensity as a color map. There have been multiple studies on the radioluminescence of sapphire irra- diated with ion beams. [45] and [55] both used C-cut, monocrystalline samples of unknown manufacturing method and purity. While this makes the data of limited use for comparison, they describe how the intensity of RL in sapphire changes based on the species of ions used, their energy, and fluence, which could help with experi- ment design. [45] also contains useful insight about why so many irradiation studies use ions rather than neutral particles: the latter causes damage that is more uniformly distributed, but sometimes with so much induced absorption that RL is difficult to observe. Finally, [47] reports RL data for polycrystalline samples with a final purity of 3N that were irradiated with an ion beam. Their technique for time-resolved, in- situ spectroscopy allowed measurement of the luminescence produced only in the first 10 ns after irradiation (see Figure 5), which peaks at a wavelength of roughly 325 nm. It’s likely that most of this signal is Cherenkov light; it would be an excellent 34 measurement to replicate with the HEM LAOS sapphire. The thermoluminescence of sapphire has been studied in [50, 56, 57]. Of these, the results from [50] are the most relevant. Sapphire crystals grown by ”thermal gradient techniques” (which sounds similar to the HEM) were irradiated with a Co-60 source at room temperature and then heated to 700 K and the resulting TL recorded. Figure 2 contains a TL glow curve which features a prominent peak at 450 K. I may choose to perform low temperature TL measurements to get more information about shallow traps instead of or in addition to deep ones, depending on what is most relevant to my final application. There are some studies which give rather comprehensive optical characteriza- tions of sapphire in adddition to the more focused papers previously discussed. The first is [51]. Scintillation and dosimetric properties of ”pure” (no quan- titative purity figure is given) Al2 O3 samples synthesized by the Czochralski and the Bridgman growth techniques were studied. The Czochralski sample exhibited an intense scintillation emission peak at 300 nm due to the F+ center. The scintilla- tion decay times of the Czochralski and the Bridgman sample were 7.6 ns and 2.8 ns, respectively. Then samples were irradiated with x-rays so that the immediate radiolu- minesence (which showed emission peaks at 240 nm and 300 nm) and post-irradiation TL could be studied. Both samples showed good linearity between the dose and TL intensity. The Bridgman technique is quite similar to the heat exchanger method that my sapphire samples were grown with, so it is encouraging to see that these samples had fewer defects and exhibited less intense luminescence as a result. Transmission vs. wavelength (Figure 2), x-ray-induced luminescence spectra (Figure 3), scintilla- tion lifetimes (Figure 4), TL glow curves (Figure 5), and TL spectra (Figure 6) are all directly relevant. The second is [49], which studied the luminescence and the thermal stability of defects formed in Al2 O3 single crystals (C-cut; Ti and Cr impurities <0.5 ppm) after pulsed treatment with a beam of C+ /H+ ions with an energy of 300 keV and a pulse 35 duration of ∼80 ns. Measurements included optical absorption, photoluminescence, and pulsed cathodoluminescence. They found that exposure to a pulsed electron beam leads to intense generation of both single F and F+ centers and more complex defects (F2 aggregate centers or vacancy–impurity complexes) in Al2 O3 . The thermal stability of F-type defects formed in Al2 O3 upon exposure to a pulsed ion beam is comparable to the stability of radiation-induced defects in neutron-irradiated samples. Table 1 has a concise summary of absorption and luminescence centers and the defects responsible for them. The pulsed ion beam treatment intentionally melts the surface of the crystal, but the reason for liquid versus solid state measurement is not clear. This is a radiation damage study, but most datasets include an undamaged baselines and most of them seem applicable for comparison with my measurements except maybe Figure 1. Whether luminescent intensity increases or decreases with temperature seems to depend on the specific color center in play, as annealing can help heal certain radiation damage. The work in [58] is probably the best analog to the study proposed here. Its specific goal was to perform optical characterization of candidate materials for Cherenkov radiators. It includes data on cathodoluminescence, photoluminescence, and Cherenkov radiation from 200 nm – 800 nm in crystals excited by an electron beam and an excilamp with a peak wavelength of 222 nm. Spectral and amplitude- time characteristics are reported for many different materials. They conclude ”that cathodoluminescence and photoluminescence should be accounted for in Cherenkov- type detectors of runaway electrons” for tokamaks. This paper came up during the search for sapphire data, as sapphire was one of the materials studied. However, none of the sapphire results are shown. The reason for this is unclear. There is still a lot of helpful background and theory on Cherenkov radiation (section II) and how it can be differentiated from other luminescence that usually destroys the signal-to- background ratio. For instance, this can be done either by analyzing luminescence lifetimes or by focusing only on the Cherenkov light generated in the wavelength band between the UV absorption edge and the lowest wavelength cathodoluminescence 36 peak. Lastly, there is an interesting comment that “increasing the refractive index not only decreases the [electron kinetic energy] threshold . . . but also provides a several- fold increase in its spectral energy density at the same electron energy.” Finally, [20] is a very long, detailed review paper which combines meta-analysis with original measurements. “The survey presents results of investigations of spec- tral, amplitude–time, and spatial VCR characteristics obtained mainly in recent years upon excitation of transparent substances by a flux of electrons with energies of tens or hundreds of keV. The VCR spectra in diamond (natural and synthetic), quartz glass, sapphire, and leucosapphire are presented. It is reported about VCR detection in MgF2 , Ga2 O3 , and other transparent samples. The spectra and amplitude–time characteristics of VCR and pulsed CL are compared at different electron energies.” It provides a thorough introduction to Cherenkov radiation, including history, theory, and general properties. It will be helpful for better understanding the relationship between a Cherenkov spectrum and the electron spectrum used to generate it. The in- troduction states that somewhere it also offers “conditions under which the Cherenkov intensity can exceed the pulsed cathodoluminescence intensity”. It gives optical char- acteristics (transmission band, refractive index, electron energy threshold) of many potential Cherenkov materials, where IFG and ZFG are notably absent. Almost ev- ery figure is likely to teach something, though Figure 15.c (emission and transmission spectra of (1,3) leucosapphire) and Figures 16-17 (emission spectra from sapphire with various filters) may be directly comparable to my datasets. 3.2.3 Heavy Metal Fluoride Glasses In 2024, one of the original discoverers of heavy metal fluoride glasses (HM- FGs) wrote an excellent primer on them. [59] explains that, since the discovery of fluorozirconate glasses by the Poulain brothers in the 1970s, three families of heavy metal fluoride glasses have come into popular use: fluorozirconates, fluoroindates, and fluoroaluminates. These are designated ”heavy metal” fluorides to contrast them with with fluoroberylate glasses, which were discovered earlier and have a structure 37 resembling fused silica. Except for BeF2 , no pure fluoride exists in the vitreous state. In general, additional fluorides must be introduced to create a melt with low enough crystallization that a glass can be formed by fast cooling. The ”confusion principle” expresses that glass stability increases as the number of glass components increases [60]. However, having too many components can lead to variations in local stoichiom- etry, which introduce scattering [61]. One of the best characteristics of HMFGs is their unusually large optical trans- mission range. This has helped them achieve widespread use for infrared fiber ap- plications, though they also transmit reasonably deep into the UV. One concern is handling requirements, as some sensitivity to moisture has been observed even at ambient temperature [62, 63]. In general, fluoride glasses are chemically aggressive (for instance, with metal crucibles used for melts) and hygroscopic [61]. However, bulk HMFGs can tolerate a humid atmosphere so long as the temperature does not exceed 100 degrees C and condensation is prevented [59]. Storing the samples with desiccant and exercising care with what they are cleaned with or otherwise exposed to should be sufficient. The lower the pH, the higher the rate of corrosion. Bulk HMFGs are stable in buffered solutions that are slightly alkaline (pH around 8) [59]. 3.2.3.1 Fluoroindate Glass ”Fluoroindate” is a broad term encompassing many possible glass compositions where InF3 is the primary glass former. The samples selected for this study are of the IZSB family; their composition is 40 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 20 BaF2 . The manufacturer has a technical data sheet [64] on this composition which quotes a transparency range of 255 nm to 8 µm and gives the glass transition tem- perature, density, refractive index, non-linear refractive index, and phonon energy. There have been many studies on the luminescence of fluoroindate glasses doped with rare earth metals [65–70]. Dopants are included for several reasons, including scintillation, up-conversion, and stabilization. Most of these studies are 38 irrelevant to the current endeavor because they do not report results on the intrinsic material as a baseline, the baseline fluoroindate composition is different than my samples, or both. One exception is [71], where the baseline material is the same composition as mine. Photoluminescence data recorded with an excitation wavelength of 1550 nm for samples with the lowest dopant concentrations show almost no emission between 400 nm and 1100 nm. This is encouraging to see. It is difficult to know whether emission data at lower wavelengths were excluded because there was no observable signal in that regime or because the author simply wasn’t interested in it, as the instrument recording emissions was sensitive down to 200 nm. 3.2.3.2 Fluorozirconate Glass Much like the case with ”fluoroindate”, ”fluorozirconate” is a broad term en- compassing many possible glass compositions where ZrF4 is the primary glass former. The samples selected for this study are of the ZBLAN family; their composition is 53 ZrF4 – 20 BaF2 – 4 LaF3 – 3 AlF3 – 20 NaF. The manufacturer’s technical data sheet [64] on this composition quotes a transparency range of 220 nm to 7 µm and gives the glass transition temperature, density, refractive index, non-linear refractive index, and phonon energy. There are not many published studies on the luminescence of ZBLAN. How- ever, there is one very thorough study conducted by Yang et al in 1997 [61] that is practically a one-stop shop. The goal of the study was to see if the luminescence behavior of a ZBLAN glass with composition 54 ZrF4 – 23 BaF2 – 4 LaF3 – 3 AlF3 – 16 NaF (similar to, but not the same as, mine) could be used as a probe of material quality. The author concluded that it can be. Cathodoluminescence (Fig. 1), x-ray radioluminescence (Fig. 2-5), and thermoluminescence (Fig. 7-8) were all measured. A de-convolution of the RL spectra revealed six visible-range emission bands that were common to all samples (Fig. 6) and are assumed to arise from intrinsic electron-hole recombination processes 39 because all samples were highly pure. “. . . The form of the spectra and the number of constituent bands did not vary greatly between the samples studied, despite a variety of doping and production changes”. However, the signal intensities increase when more defects (impurities, lattice defects, etc.) are present, and there was still some emission observed during low-temperature TL that they believe is coming from rare-earth impurities. All of these datasets are relevant for comparison with my own. In addition, there are many bits of information that can shape my measurement plan: Low-purity samples are likely to have so many color centers that the spectra can’t easily be analyzed. Impurities cannot only add broadband emission signals but also interact with the glass network to modify the shape and intensity of peaks from intrin- sic processes. Samples that were irradiated and then heated above room temperature for TL swelled and started to decompose. CL and x-ray RL results differed in that the RL spectral intensities varied a lot more with temperature. RL was more intense at low temperature and decreased on the approach to room temperature; the relative intensities of different peaks within a spectrum also change with temperature. At- tempts to attribute specific color centers to specific structural features in the material quickly become highly speculative. The author reinforces that CL, RL, and TL all offer unique insights: “The competitive nature of the charge distribution between alternative luminescence sites means that CL, RL, and TL will all emphasize the presence of different components of the possible luminescence decay routes”. Finally, RL, TL, and CL spectra should be continuous distributions; if discontinuities appear, it may be due to the presence of bulk phase transitions. 40 Chapter 4: Proposed Work The proposed research scope is as follows: 1. Conduct background research. 2. Perform a literature review of Cherenkov detector applications, Cherenkov ra- diator materials, and associated material characterization work. 3. Prepare a dissertation research proposal. 4. Purchase materials that have the potential to improve upon the performance of fused silica as Cherenkov radiators. 5. Perform analytic/semi-analytic calculations to develop intuition for the behavior of Cherenkov radiators as a function of material parameters such as density, refractive index, and optical transmission to use for verification of subsequent Monte Carlo calculations of the expected response. 6. Identify the information required to build a detector response function for a material in Geant4. 7. Characterize the response of each material to visible and ionizing radiation with laboratory measurements. 8. Simulate the expected detector response of each material using Geant4. 9. Rank the materials in terms of their suitability for use in Cherenkov-based radiation detectors. 10. Using the top material, design a detector module with optimized light collection for a chosen application. 41 11. Simulate the performance of the optimized detector module using MCNP with the detector response function previously developed in Geant4. 12. Write a formal dissertation report. 13. Prepare a presentation for the doctoral defense. The proposed timeline for completion is as shown in Figure 13 below. Figure 13: Proposed timeline of completion for dissertation research. Milestones are shown in the first row and the remaining rows each correspond to a numbered task in the previous list. In addition to creating an original research product, completing these deliver- ables will foster the development of research skills that are core to the field of radi- ation detection. These include a deeper understanding of ionizing radiation detector physics, radiation transport simulation in MCNP6 and Geant4, detailed detector re- sponse modeling in Geant4, characterization of detector material properties for use in simulations and data analysis, and the integration of detector response functions with radiation transport simulations for experiment design. 42 Chapter 5: Risk Management Table 3: Self-assessed risks to project outcomes and schedule Issue Likelihood Severity Possible Mitigations Proposed measurements are Low High Prioritize consulting with insufficient for building colleagues who have built detector response functions them previously. Long design and/or High Medium Stick to ambient procurement lead times for measurements or delay TL to additional experimental a second round of evaluation. equipment needed (pulsed x-ray source, cryostat, etc.) Accidental damage to test Low High Purchase practice parts, samples spares, padded storage, and desiccant. Collaborate with MST-7 for any cleaning. Perform PL/PLE before RL and TL. Lack of SME bandwidth to Medium Low Work with committee to support learning (simulation identify suitable resources. workflows and condensed matter physics) Insufficient time or focus on Medium High Coordinate with E.McKigney. dissertation research due to other programmatic needs at LANL Loss of research funding due Low High Coordinate with E.McKigney. to shifting programmatic needs or government shutdown 43 References [1] Blogspot. Pressure waves flowing off an airplane. URL https://1.bp.blogs pot.com/_AWyWOFe-P9w/TTnqXS-0wEI/AAAAAAAAAYo/1ak8yAvyl1o/s1600/su personic.bmp. [2] Office of Nuclear Energy. Cherenkov radiation, explained, 2023. URL https: //www.energy.gov/ne/articles/cherenkov-radiation-explained. [3] C. Ahl et al. Confidence building at keff ≲ 1. Preprint submitted to Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spec- trometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment. Los Alamos National Labora- tory report LA-UR-26-23481; approved for public release, distribution unlimited., April 2026. [4] Suleman Surti. Update on latest advances in time-of-flight pet. Physica Medica, 80:251–258, 2020. doi: 10.1016/j.ejmp.2020.10.031. PDF file: Update on lastest advances in time-of-flight PET.pdf. [5] Canot et al. Development of the fast and efficient gamma detector using cherenkov light. IEEE Xplore, 2017. doi: 10.1109/NSSMIC.2016.8069926. PDF file: Development of the fast and efficient gamma detector using cherenkov light.pdf. [6] A. Lau, S. Ahmad, and Y. Chen. A simulation study investigating a cherenkov material for use with the prompt gamma range verification in proton therapy. Journal of X-Ray Science and Technology, 24:565–582, 2016. doi: 10.3233/XS T-160575IOS. PDF file: Simulation study Cerenkov for Proton Therapy.pdf. [7] A. U. Abeysekara. All-sky measurement of the anisotropy of cosmic rays at 10 tev and mapping of the local interstellar magnetic field. The Astrophysical Journal, 2019. doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/aaf5cc. PDF file: All-sky Measurement of the Anisotropy of Cosmic Rays at 10 TeV and Mapping of the.pdf. 44 [8] Y. Kim et al. Aerogel cherenkov detector for characterizing the intense flash x-ray source, cygnus, spectrum. Rev Sci Instrum., 87, 2016. doi: 10.1063/1.49 60541. [9] K. D. Meaney. Characterization of the mercury pulsed power x-ray source spectrum using multichannel density aerogel cherenkov detectors . Rev. Sci. Instrum., 89:10F113, 2018. doi: 10.1063/1.5038745. PDF file: Characterization of the Mercury pulsed power x-ray source.pdf. [10] H. Geppert-Kleinrath et al. Commissioning the new pulse dilation gas cherenkov detector at the national ignition facility. High Energy Density Physics, 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hedp.2020.100862. [11] Z. L. Mohamed, Y. Kim, J. P. Knauer, and M. S. Rubery. γ-to-neutron branch- ing ratio for deuterium–tritium fusion determined using high-energy-density plas- mas and a fused silica cherenkov detector. Physical Review C, 107(1):014606, 2023. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevC.107.014606. [12] V. Plyusnin et al. Use of cherenkov-type detectors for measurements of runaway electrons in the istt ok tokamaka). Rev. Sci. Instrum., 79:10F505, 2008. doi: 10.1063/1.2956960. PDF file: use of cherenkov-type detectors for measurements of runaway electrons in the ISTTOK tokamak.pdf. [13] V. Plyusnin et al. Development of a diagnostic technique based on cherenkov effect for measurements of fast electrons in fusion devices. Rev. Sci. Instrum., 83:083505, 2012. doi: 10.1063/1.4740512. PDF file: Development of a diag- nostic technique based on Cherenkov effect for measurements of fast electrons in fusion devices.pdf. [14] D.B. Cassidy and A.P. Mills Jr. A fast detector for single-shot positron an- nihilation lifetime spectroscopy d.b. cassidy/c3, a.p. mills jr. Nuclear In- struments and Methods in Physics Research A, 580:1338–1343, 2007. doi: 45 10.1016/j.nima.2007.06.078. PDF file: A fast detector for single-shot positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy - Cassidy 2007.pdf. [15] Corning Incorporated. Corning HPFS 7979, 7980, 8655 fused silica optical ma- terials: Product information. Product information sheet, Corning Incorporated, July 2015. [16] I Frank and I Tamm. Coherent visible radiation from fast electrons passing through matter. C. R. Acad. Sci. USSR, 14:109–114, 1937. URL https: //link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-74626-0_2. [17] L. Fülöp and T. Biró. Cherenkov radiation spectrum. International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 31(1):115–123, 1992. [18] F. Kulcsar, D. Teherani, and H. Altmann. Study of the spectrum of cherenkov light. Journal of Radioanalytical Chemistry, 68(1–2):161–168, 1982. [19] Shohei Wakita, Masakazu Washio, Yoshiro Suzuki, and Masamitsu Hirai. Pi- cosecond pulse sources by čerenkov light generated from fused silica and water. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 24(4):502–505, 1985. doi: 10.1143/JJAP .24.502. [20] V. F. Tarasenko, E. Kh. Baksht, M. V. Erofeev, and A. G. Burachenko. Spectral and amplitude-time characteristics of the cherenkov radiation upon excitation of transparent materials by an electron beam. Optics and Spectroscopy, 129(7): 707–736, 2021. doi: 10.1134/S0030400X21050167. [21] Axis Photonique Inc. Axis-qvs: Compact time-resolved spectrometer, 2017. URL https://www.axis-photon.com/streak-camera/axis-qvs-compact-t ime-resolved-spectrometer/. [22] Golden Engineering Inc. Xrs4 gfx 20v. URL https://www.goldenengineerin g.com/products/xrs4/. 46 [23] Axis Photonique Inc. Axis-trs: Ultrafast time-resolved spectrometer, 2023. URL https://www.axis-photon.com/streak-camera/axis-trs-ultrafast -time-resolved-spectrometer/. [24] Crystal Systems, LLC. HEM® LAOS® Sapphire. https://crystalsystems .com/materials/hem-laos-sapphire/, n.d. Accessed: 2026-03-31. [25] Crystal Systems, LLC. HEM® LAOS® Sapphire Data Sheet. Technical report, Crystal Systems, LLC, 2013. Rev. A, product datasheet. [26] Le Verre Fluoré. Fluoride Glasses. https://leverrefluore.com/scientific -world/fluoride-glasses/, n.d. Accessed: 2026-03-31. [27] K. Toh, T. Shikama, T. Kakuta, S. Nagata, B. Tsuchiya, C. Mori, J. Hori, and T. Nishitani. Studies of radioluminescence in fused silica core fibers. In Scintil- lating and Fiber Sensors and Their Applications, volume 4786 of Proceedings of SPIE, pages 215–220, 2002. doi: 10.1117/12.451745. [28] A. S. Beddar, T. R. Mackie, and F. H. Attix. Cerenkov light generated in optical fibres and other light pipes irradiated by electron beams. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 37(4):925–935, 1992. [29] David L. Griscom. Optical properties and structure of defects in silica glass. Journal of the Ceramic Society of Japan, 99(1154):923–942, 1991. doi: 10.210 9/jcersj.99.923. [30] Linards Skuja. Optically active oxygen-deficiency-related centers in amorphous silicon dioxide. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 239(1–3):16–48, 1998. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3093(98)00720-0. [31] P. B. Sergeev and A. P. Sergeev. Annealing of induced absorption in quartz glasses by ArF laser radiation. Quantum Electronics, 40(9):804–810, 2010. doi: 10.1070/QE2010v040n09ABEH014309. 47 [32] A. P. Sergeev and P. B. Sergeev. Behavior of absorption bands in pure quartz glasses under electron irradiation. Bulletin of the Lebedev Physics Institute, 38 (12):360–365, 2011. doi: 10.3103/S1068335611120037. [33] K. Yu. Vukolov, E. N. Andreenko, R. S. Afanasenko, I. I. Orlovskiy, and R. N. Rodionov. Effect of radiation exposure on optics in ITER. Physics of Atomic Nuclei, 87(7):829–847, 2024. doi: 10.1134/S1063778824070160. [34] Rei Kitamura, Laurent Pilon, and Miroslaw Jonasz. Optical constants of silica glass from extreme ultraviolet to far infrared at near room temperature. Applied Optics, 46(33):8118–8133, 2007. doi: 10.1364/AO.46.008118. [35] Corning Incorporated. HPFS fused silica ArF grade. Product information sheet, Corning Incorporated, September 2003. [36] P. B. Sergeev, A. P. Sergeev, and V. D. Zvorykin. Radiation resistance of optical materials for windows of UV and VUV excimer lasers. Quantum Electronics, 37 (8):706–710, 2007. doi: 10.1070/QE2007v037n08ABEH013444. [37] Rajesh N. Raman, Manyalibo J. Matthews, John J. Adams, and Stavros G. Demos. Monitoring annealing via CO2 laser heating of defect populations on fused silica surfaces using photoluminescence microscopy. Optics Express, 18 (14):15207–15215, 2010. doi: 10.1364/OE.18.015207. [38] Jiangning Zhou and Bincheng Li. Origins of a damage-induced green pho- toluminescence band in fused silica revealed by time-resolved photolumines- cence spectroscopy. Optical Materials Express, 7(8):2888–2898, 2017. doi: 10.1364/OME.7.002888. [39] Vincenzo De Michele, Emmanuel Marin, Aziz Boukenter, Marco Cannas, Syl- vain Girard, and Youcef Ouerdane. Photoluminescence of point defects in sil- icon dioxide by femtosecond laser exposure. physica status solidi (a), 218(15): 2000802, 2021. doi: 10.1002/pssa.202000802. 48 [40] Jingang Wang, Jimeng Cheng, Chongyun Shao, Wei Chen, Chunlei Yu, Lili Hu, Malgorzata Guzik, and Georges Boulon. Effects of oxygen loading on the red- luminescence of non-bridging oxygen hole centers in γ-irradiated silica glasses. Optical Materials, 147:114707, 2024. doi: 10.1016/j.optmat.2023.114707. [41] Vladimir D. Zvorykin, Andrei S. Alimov, Sergei V. Arlantsev, Boris S. Ishkhanov, Alexei O. Levchenko, Nikolai N. Mogilenetz, Victor F. Oreshkin, Andrei P. Sergeev, Pavel B. Sergeev, Victor F. Shtan’ko, Vasilii I. Shvedunov, and Niko- lai N. Ustinovskii. Degradation of the transmissive optics for a laser-driven IFE power plant under electron and X-ray irradiation. Plasma and Fusion Research, 8:3405046, 2013. doi: 10.1585/pfr.8.3405046. [42] A. Vedda, N. Chiodini, D. Di Martino, M. Fasoli, L. Griguta, F. Moretti, and E. Rosetta. Thermally stimulated luminescence of Ce- and Tb-doped SiO2 sol–gel glasses. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 351:3699–3703, 2005. doi: 10.1016/j.jnoncrysol.2005.10.001. [43] Francesca Cova. Rare-Earth Doped Scintillating Silica Fibers for Ionizing Radi- ation Detection. Ph.d. dissertation, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 2020. URL https://hdl.handle.net/10281/263105. [44] Crystal Systems, Inc. HEM LAOS Sapphire Data Sheet. Crystal Systems, Inc., 2013. Revision A, October 2013. [45] A. Al Ghamdi and P. D. Townsend. Ion beam excited luminescence of sapphire. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interac- tions with Materials and Atoms, 46:133–136, 1990. doi: 10.1016/0168-583X(90 )90684-M. [46] Bruce D. Evans, Gerald J. Pogatshnik, and Yok Chen. Optical properties of lattice defects in α-Al2 O3 . Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, 91:258–262, 1994. doi: 10.1016/0168-583X(94)96227-8. 49 [47] Ryo Toshima, Hiroyuki Miyamaru, Jun Asahara, Takehiro Murasawa, and Ak- ito Takahashi. Ion-induced luminescence of alumina with time-resolved spec- troscopy. Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology, 39(1):15–18, 2002. doi: 10.1080/18811248.2002.9715152. [48] M. Itou, A. Fujiwara, and T. Uchino. Reversible photoinduced interconversion of color centers in α-Al2 O3 prepared under vacuum. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 113(49):20949–20957, 2009. doi: 10.1021/jp908417m. [49] D. V. Ananchenko, S. V. Nikiforov, G. R. Ramazanova, R. I. Batalov, R. M. Bayazitov, and H. A. Novikov. Luminescence of F-type defects and their thermal stability in sapphire irradiated by pulsed ion beams. Optics and Spectroscopy, 128(2):207–213, 2020. doi: 10.1134/S0030400X20020022. [50] Wei Chen, PingXin Song, YongJun Dong, YingJiu Zhang, and Wei Hua. Ther- moluminescence of Al2 O3 crystals grown by temperature gradient techniques. Chinese Science Bulletin, 58(16):1964–1968, 2013. doi: 10.1007/s11434-012-561 4-0. [51] Yoshisuke Futami, Takayuki Yanagida, and Yutaka Fujimoto. Optical, dosimet- ric, and scintillation properties of pure sapphire crystals. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 53:02BC12, 2014. doi: 10.7567/JJAP.53.02BC12. [52] Meller Optics, Inc. Sapphire Index of Refraction Table. Meller Optics, Inc., March 2002. Technical data table dated March 11, 2002. [53] G. Alombert-Goget, H. Li, Y. Guyot, A. Brenier, and K. Lebbou. Luminescence and coloration of undoped and Ti-doped sapphire crystals grown by czochralski technique. Journal of Luminescence, 169:516–519, 2016. doi: 10.1016/j.jlumin .2015.02.001. 50 [54] E. Yu. Zykova, K. E. Ozerova, A. A. Tatarintsev, and A. N. Turkin. Photolu- minescence of sapphire irradiated by low-energy electrons and ions. Optics and Spectroscopy, 130(9), 2022. doi: 10.21883/EOS.2022.09.54827.3397-22. [55] Tetsuo Tanabe, Masaaki Fujiwara, and Keiji Miyazaki. Energetic particle in- duced luminescence of Al2 O3 . Journal of Nuclear Materials, 233–237:1344–1348, 1996. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3115(96)00250-4. [56] M. Böhm, P. Iacconi, K. D. Kromm, and A. Scharmann. Low temperature thermoluminescence and thermally stimulated conductivity in α-Al2 O3 crystals. physica status solidi (a), 146(2):757–764, 1994. doi: 10.1002/pssa.2211460220. [57] S. V. Nikiforov, V. S. Kortov, S. V. Zvonarev, E. V. Moiseykin, and M. G. Kazantseva. Basic thermoluminescent and dosimetric properties of Al2 O3 ir- radiated by pulse intensive electron beam. Radiation Measurements, 71:74–77, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.radmeas.2014.02.010. [58] D. A. Sorokin, A. G. Burachenko, D. V. Beloplotov, V. F. Tarasenko, E. Kh. Baksht, E. I. Lipatov, and M. I. Lomaev. Luminescence of crystals excited by a runaway electron beam and by excilamp radiation with a peak wavelength of 222 nm. Journal of Applied Physics, 122:154902, 2017. doi: 10.1063/1.4996965. [59] Marcel Poulain. Heavy metal fluoride glasses: A tutorial review. APL Photon- ics, 9:091103, 2024. doi: 10.1063/5.0226668. [60] M. N. Brekhovskikh, L. V. Moiseeva, S. Kh. Batygov, I. A. Zhidkova, and V. A. Fedorov. Glasses on the basis of heavy metal fluorides. Inorganic Materials, 51 (13):1348–1361, 2015. doi: 10.1134/S0020168515130026. [61] B. Yang, P. D. Townsend, N. Can, A. Janke, P. Baniel, O. Blanc, and J. Granier. Luminescence of levitated Zr-Ba-La-Al-Na fluoride glass. Physical Review B, 56 (10):5876–5884, 1997. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.56.5876. 51 [62] Y. Dai, K. Takahashi, and I. Yamaguchi. Thermal oxidation of fluorozirconate glass and fibres. Journal of Materials Science Letters, 12:1648–1651, 1993. [63] Jaroslaw Cimek, Xavier Forestier, Ryszard Stepień, Mariusz Klimczak, and Ryszard Buczyński. Synthesis conditions of ZBLAN glass for mid-infrared optical com- ponents. Photonics Letters of Poland, 10(1):8–10, 2018. doi: 10.4302/plp.v10i 1.804. [64] Le Verre Fluoré. Fluoride glasses, 2024. Technical overview webpage preserved as PDF. [65] S. J. L. Ribeiro, R. E. O. Diniz, Y. Messaddeq, L. A. Nunes, and M. A. Aegerter. Eu3+ and Gd3+ spectroscopy in fluoroindate glasses. Chemical Physics Letters, 220(3–5):214–218, 1994. doi: 10.1016/0009-2614(94)00176-6. [66] W. Lozano, Cid B. de Araujo, C. Egalon, A. S. L. Gomes, B. J. Costa, and Y. Messaddeq. Upconversion of infrared-to-visible light in Pr3+ -Yb3+ codoped fluoroindate glass. Optics Communications, 153(4–6):271–274, 1998. doi: 10.1 016/S0030-4018(98)00268-5. [67] Zhen Liu, Jiangbo She, and Bo Peng. Spectroscopic properties of Er3+ -doped fluoroindate glasses. Journal of Rare Earths, 40:1037–1042, 2022. doi: 10.101 6/j.jre.2021.05.011. [68] Danilo Manzani, David Paboeuf, Sidney J. L. Ribeiro, Philippe Goldner, and Fabien Bretenaker. Orange emission in Pr3+ -doped fluoroindate glasses. Optical Materials, 35(3):383–386, 2013. doi: 10.1016/j.optmat.2012.09.030. [69] Lukasz Sójka, Bartlomiej Starzyk, Slawomir Sujecki, Lukasz Pajewski, Piotr Miluski, Jacek Żmojda, Wojciech A. Pisarski, Joanna Pisarska, Marcin Kochanow- icz, Dominik Dorosz, Trevor M. Benson, David Furniss, Mark C. Farries, and Angela B. Seddon. Mid-infrared emission from Dy3+ doped fluoroindate glass 52 fiber. Ceramics International, 49:41210–41216, 2023. doi: 10.1016/j.ceramint.2 023.03.075. [70] Bartlomiej Starzyk, Gloria Lesly Jimenez, Marcin Kochanowicz, Marta Kuwik, Jacek Żmojda, Piotr Miluski, Agata Baranowska, Jan Dorosz, Wojciech Pisarski, Joanna Pisarska, and Dominik Dorosz. Investigation of thermal sensing in flu- oroindate Yb3+ /Er3+ co-doped optical fiber. Materials, 16(6):2139, 2023. doi: 10.3390/ma16062139. [71] T. Castro, D. Manzani, and S. J. L. Ribeiro. Up-conversion mechanisms in Er3+ - doped fluoroindate glasses under 1550 nm excitation for enhancing photocurrent of crystalline silicon solar cell. Journal of Luminescence, 200:260–264, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jlumin.2018.04.028. [72] A. P. Sergeev and P. B. Sergeev. How the absorption-band intensities in high- purity quartz glasses depend on the electron-beam fluence. Journal of Optical Technology, 78(5):341–346, 2011. doi: 10.1364/JOT.78.000341. [73] M. Barlet, J.-M. Delaye, M. Gennisson, R. Caraballo, B. Boizot, D. Bonamy, and C. L. Rountree. Influence of electronic irradiation on failure and hardness properties of pure silica glasses. Procedia Materials Science, 7:286–293, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.mspro.2014.10.037. [74] Maxime Royon, Emmanuel Marin, Sylvain Girard, Aziz Boukenter, Youcef Ouer- dane, and Razvan Stoian. X-ray preconditioning for enhancing refractive index contrast in femtosecond laser photoinscription of embedded waveguides in pure silica. Optical Materials Express, 9(1):65–75, 2019. doi: 10.1364/OME.9.0000 65. [75] Dakui Dong, Zhonglin Bo, Jiqian Zhu, and Fuding Ma. Study of properties of InF3-based glasses containing different valent fluorides. Journal of Non- Crystalline Solids, 204(3):260–264, 1996. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3093(96)00422-X. 53 [76] Ahmed Boutarfaia and Marcel Poulain. New stable fluoroindate glasses. Solid State Ionics, 144:117–121, 2001. doi: 10.1016/S0167-2738(01)00895-5. [77] E. La Francesca, A. Cemmi, M. C. De Sanctis, S. De Angelis, I. Di Sarcina, J. Scifo, A. Verna, E. Ammannito, M. Ferrari, and A. Raponi. Physical effects in the VIS-IR of ionizing gamma radiations on indium fluoride optical fibers. Review of Scientific Instruments, 96:064503, 2025. doi: 10.1063/5.0265568. [78] Le Verre Fluoré. Fluoride Glass Fiber Catalog. Le Verre Fluoré, 2024. Product catalog. 54 Appendix A: Literature Review A.1 Fused Silica [19 ] Shohei Wakita, Masakazu Washio, Yoshiro Suzuki, and Masamitsu Hirai. Pi- cosecond pulse sources by čerenkov light generated from fused silica and water. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 24(4):502–505, 1985. doi: 10.1143/JJAP .24.502 A 10-ps electron beam was used to irradiate water and fused silica. The resulting Cherenkov light pulses were recorded as functions of time and wavelength. A streak camera was used to resolve time and a series of filters were used to resolve wavelength. The measured pulse durations were in the vicinity of 30 ps for both materials, though the author believes the true duration to be shorter and cites several pos- sible reasons why this experiment may overestimate it. The measured Cherenkov spectra agree with theoretical prediction between 350 nm and 500 nm but the intensity is far lower than predicted toward the UV. Relevance: Key reference. Experimentally validates the notion that Cherenkov emission occurs on picosecond time scales, makes a some- what novel suggestion to use conical Cherenkov radiators for opti- mized light collection, and describes an experimental method for mea- suring Cherenkov spectra using a streak camera. [29 ] David L. Griscom. Optical properties and structure of defects in silica glass. Journal of the Ceramic Society of Japan, 99(1154):923–942, 1991. doi: 10.210 9/jcersj.99.923 This is a review paper that aggregates electron spin resonance and optical correlations data for fused silica from the literature to trace the origin of many optical absorption bands to specific point defects. Relevance: Since this is a review paper, there is probably a lot of variation in the characteristics of fused silica samples involved. It may be useful for interpreting spectral features in my data so that I 55 can identify what could be changed about the samples to eliminate them. [28 ] A. S. Beddar, T. R. Mackie, and F. H. Attix. Cerenkov light generated in optical fibres and other light pipes irradiated by electron beams. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 37(4):925–935, 1992 Pure fused silica optical fibers were irradiated with an electron beam and the resulting luminescence studied. The relationship between the intensity of emitted light and the emission angle is indicative of Cherenkov radiation. The author discusses a method for measuring this signal independently so that it may be subtracted as a back- ground in scintillation dosimetry measurements. Relevance: Cherenkov emission in fused silica is a documented nui- sance signal in optical fibers. [30 ] Linards Skuja. Optically active oxygen-deficiency-related centers in amorphous silicon dioxide. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 239(1–3):16–48, 1998. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3093(98)00720-0 This is reminiscent of Griscom’s 1991 paper and will probably be useful for the same reasons. Relevance: See entry for Griscom 1991 [27 ] K. Toh, T. Shikama, T. Kakuta, S. Nagata, B. Tsuchiya, C. Mori, J. Hori, and T. Nishitani. Studies of radioluminescence in fused silica core fibers. In Scin- tillating and Fiber Sensors and Their Applications, volume 4786 of Proceedings of SPIE, pages 215–220, 2002. doi: 10.1117/12.451745 Fused silica optical fibers of varying sizes and compositions (doped, undoped) were irradiated at both a gamma irradiation facility and at a fission reactor and the resulting radiation-induced luminescence spectra were recorded. The spectra contain a broadband signal that the author attributes to Cherenkov radiation as well as some peaks and absorption features. 56 Relevance: This source is important in that I have been able to locate very few studies that report RL data for fused silica and it could serve as a basis of comparison for my measurements. However, because the study does not report detailed fused silica sample characteristics and the radiation source is a fission reactor (a mix of photons, electrons, and neutrons), it’s unclear whether such a comparison would be fair or not. [35 ] Corning Incorporated. HPFS fused silica ArF grade. Product information sheet, Corning Incorporated, September 2003 Manufacturer gives a general description of HPFS ArF Grade Corn- ing 7980 glass and quality metrics, mechanical and thermal properties, chemical durability and impurities, internal transmittance as a func- tion of wavelength, and refractive index as a function of wavelength, Relevance: Key reference. Describes purchased samples of Corning 7980 ArF Grade. [42 ] A. Vedda, N. Chiodini, D. Di Martino, M. Fasoli, L. Griguta, F. Moretti, and E. Rosetta. Thermally stimulated luminescence of Ce- and Tb-doped SiO2 sol–gel glasses. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 351:3699–3703, 2005. doi: 10.1016/j.jnoncrysol.2005.10.001 Rare-earth(RE)-doped sol-gel glasses were irradiated with X-rays and then the thermally stimulated luminescence (TSL) amplitude was measured as a function of temperature (glow curves). The TSL in- tensity increased with dopant concentration. Similarity between the glow curves of samples with different doping or thermal treatments indicates that intrinsic defects act as traps and the RE dopants simply increase the number of recombination centers. Relevance: Key paper. This study does not report any glow curves for undoped material but offers good insight into a potential TSL mea- surement setup. Also, comparing glow curves for undoped material to the doped versions included here could be informative. 57 [34 ] Rei Kitamura, Laurent Pilon, and Miroslaw Jonasz. Optical constants of silica glass from extreme ultraviolet to far infrared at near room temperature. Applied Optics, 46(33):8118–8133, 2007. doi: 10.1364/AO.46.008118 This is a review paper that aggregates real (refractive index) and imaginary (absorption index) parts of the complex refractive index of silica glass from 30 nm to 1000 micron. There is generally good agreement on the general features of optical constants as functions of wavelength. However, the actual values can vary significantly due to variation in sample manufacturing method, sample quality, and measurement method. Relevance: This is a cautionary tale. Make sure samples are charac- terized adequately before reporting measurements made using them, and don’t pay too much heed to studies where this characterization is absent because the relevance is unclear. [36 ] P. B. Sergeev, A. P. Sergeev, and V. D. Zvorykin. Radiation resistance of optical materials for windows of UV and VUV excimer lasers. Quantum Electronics, 37(8):706–710, 2007. doi: 10.1070/QE2007v037n08ABEH013444 This is a radiation damage paper where Corning 7980 ArF grade, Rus- sian glasses KU-1 and KS-4V, and CaF2 windows were subjected to an electron beam. Transmission vs wavelength was measured before and after irradiation. Relevance: Relevant. Figure 1 contains transmission vs. wavelength data Corning 7980 ArF grade which expands on that provided by the manufacturer. This data set goes down to 150 nm wavelength, and the x-intercept appears to be around 162 nm. Also, as an aside, it’s interesting to see the Russian “equivalents” to the Corning glasses we are accustomed to using. KS-4V has much better UV transmis- sion than Corning 7980 ArF likely due to the lower impurity content. This material would be an excellent candidate for my study were it available in the United States. [37 ] Rajesh N. Raman, Manyalibo J. Matthews, John J. Adams, and Stavros G. Demos. Monitoring annealing via CO2 laser heating of defect populations on 58 fused silica surfaces using photoluminescence microscopy. Optics Express, 18 (14):15207–15215, 2010. doi: 10.1364/OE.18.015207 A large sample of Corning 7980 (grade unspecified) was intentionally damaged at many microscopic sites with a powerful 355 nm laser. Then the sites were stimulated with much less powerful 266 nm and 355 nm lasers to understand the impact of damage laser irradiance on the PL spectrum from a sample. PL of undamaged sights is also reported as a control. A CO2 laser was then used to anneal some of the damage caused by the original laser. Relevance: The PL data for undamaged sites can be compared with my measurements since the fused silica used is similar (Corning 7980 vs Corning 7980 ArF). [31 ] P. B. Sergeev and A. P. Sergeev. Annealing of induced absorption in quartz glasses by ArF laser radiation. Quantum Electronics, 40(9):804–810, 2010. doi: 10.1070/QE2010v040n09ABEH014309 This is a direct follow-up to the 2007 paper; it builds on the same dataset. The samples that were irradiated with an electron beam are now subjected to ArF laser pulses to undo some of the electron- induced damage. This treatment did increase the transmission of some samples at certain wavelengths, but did not restore the trans- mission to pristine part levels. Relevance: The results are not relevant but discussions of different types of defect centers in this material and their behaviors may make it a helpful resource to return to. [32 ] A. P. Sergeev and P. B. Sergeev. Behavior of absorption bands in pure quartz glasses under electron irradiation. Bulletin of the Lebedev Physics Institute, 38 (12):360–365, 2011. doi: 10.3103/S1068335611120037 A paper characterizing the radiation-induced absorption of the three glasses studied previously (including Corning 7980 ArF). Absorption spectra are decomposed into a series of Gaussian absorption bands, where the center wavelength and absorption center type for each band are specified. 59 Relevance: As with the previous paper, the results are not relevant but discussions of different types of defect centers in this material and their behaviors may make it a helpful resource to return to. [72 ] A. P. Sergeev and P. B. Sergeev. How the absorption-band intensities in high- purity quartz glasses depend on the electron-beam fluence. Journal of Optical Technology, 78(5):341–346, 2011. doi: 10.1364/JOT.78.000341 This is almost identical to the other Sergeev 2011 paper; they ap- pear to contain most of the same information. The other paper was published as an institutional bulletin and this one was published as a journal article at almost the same time. Relevance: See previous entry. [41 ] Vladimir D. Zvorykin, Andrei S. Alimov, Sergei V. Arlantsev, Boris S. Ishkhanov, Alexei O. Levchenko, Nikolai N. Mogilenetz, Victor F. Oreshkin, Andrei P. Sergeev, Pavel B. Sergeev, Victor F. Shtan’ko, Vasilii I. Shvedunov, and Niko- lai N. Ustinovskii. Degradation of the transmissive optics for a laser-driven IFE power plant under electron and X-ray irradiation. Plasma and Fusion Research, 8:3405046, 2013. doi: 10.1585/pfr.8.3405046 Radiation damage study. Corning 7980 ArF grade, Russian KU-1 and KS-4V glasses, and several crystals (calcium fluoride, magnesium fluoride, and sapphire) were irradiated with electrons and x-rays to study short-lived and long-lived induced absorption. All optics stud- ied darkened under all types of ionizing radiation, especially at the KrF laser wavelength of 248 nm. Relevance: None other than a reminder to compare doses that our detectors will experience to some of these radiation damage studies to confirm that the radiation damage that all of these studies report will not be relevant to my target application(s). [73 ] M. Barlet, J.-M. Delaye, M. Gennisson, R. Caraballo, B. Boizot, D. Bonamy, and C. L. Rountree. Influence of electronic irradiation on failure and hardness 60 properties of pure silica glasses. Procedia Materials Science, 7:286–293, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.mspro.2014.10.037 Corning 7980 was irradiated with beta particles at doses in the GGy range to explore the effect on mechanical properties. Raman spec- troscopy was conducted before and after irradiation to help charac- terize the resulting changes in molecular structure. Relevance: None. [15 ] Corning Incorporated. Corning HPFS 7979, 7980, 8655 fused silica optical ma- terials: Product information. Product information sheet, Corning Incorporated, July 2015 Manufacturer compares several available types of high purity fused silica, including multiple grades of 7980. Reported data includes quality grade, impurity content, birefringence, mechanical properties, thermal properties, refractive index as a function of wavelength, dis- persion constants, and internal transmittance as a function of wave- length. Relevance: Key reference. Describes purchased samples of Corning 7980 ArF Grade. [38 ] Jiangning Zhou and Bincheng Li. Origins of a damage-induced green pho- toluminescence band in fused silica revealed by time-resolved photolumines- cence spectroscopy. Optical Materials Express, 7(8):2888–2898, 2017. doi: 10.1364/OME.7.002888 Time-resolved PL measurements were performed on Corning 7980 (grade unspecified) and several other glasses before and after me- chanical and laser-induced damage to identify the origins of two green luminescence peaks. Relevance: Key reference. Pre-damage PL measurements of Corning 7980 will be useful points of comparison for my study, though such comparisons must be qualified by the statement that we may be using different grades of the material. 61 [74 ] Maxime Royon, Emmanuel Marin, Sylvain Girard, Aziz Boukenter, Youcef Ouer- dane, and Razvan Stoian. X-ray preconditioning for enhancing refractive index contrast in femtosecond laser photoinscription of embedded waveguides in pure silica. Optical Materials Express, 9(1):65–75, 2019. doi: 10.1364/OME.9.000065 A sample of Corning 7980 was irradiated with x-rays to speed up the photoinscription process. Photoinscription involves using a laser to cause localized index of refraction changes that form 3D optical path- ways (for example, waveguides) in a bulk material. Pre-conditioning samples with ionizing radiation causes point defects to grow, increas- ing the photosensitivity of the material. PL measurements are used to compare the defect population in samples that have undergone different treatments. Relevance: None. [43 ] Francesca Cova. Rare-Earth Doped Scintillating Silica Fibers for Ionizing Ra- diation Detection. Ph.d. dissertation, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 2020. URL https://hdl.handle.net/10281/263105 Doctoral thesis from the Department of Materials Science at the Uni- versity of Milano – Bicocca. Silica samples doped with Pr and Ce were synthesized using the sol-gel method. The dopants were intro- duced to imbue the fused silica (whose purity does not appear to have been characterized) with scintillation properties. The study involves optical transmission, PL/PLE, RL, and TLE measurements, though none involved undoped samples as a baseline. Relevance: Key reference. For the most part, the study’s data will not overlap with that proposed here due to the use of doped fused silica samples. (An exception is Figure 2.4, which provides an RL spectrum for an undoped sample). However, the background information on the scintillation process, the Cherenkov radiation process, and optical properties in Chapter 1, the experimental setups and analyses used in Chapters 3, 4, and 5, and the general level of detail with which material electronic structure is discussed make this a valuable resource to guide the current study. 62 [39 ] Vincenzo De Michele, Emmanuel Marin, Aziz Boukenter, Marco Cannas, Syl- vain Girard, and Youcef Ouerdane. Photoluminescence of point defects in sil- icon dioxide by femtosecond laser exposure. physica status solidi (a), 218(15): 2000802, 2021. doi: 10.1002/pssa.202000802 Three types of fused silica, one of which was Corning 7980 (grade un- specified) were subjected to laser pulses of varying number and laser power to examine the impact of each on the PL spectrum, which was measured during the laser irradiation (“online photoluminescence”) and not as a secondary step. The Corning 7980 PL data shows two peaks. Peaks grow, shrink, redshift, and blueshift in different scenar- ios. The induced PL is attributed to the generation of ODC defects at low laser powers and NBOHC and STX defects at high laser powers. Relevance: PL spectra for Corning 7980 may estimate those that I measure for Corning 7980 ArF grade; it will be interesting to compare. The induced PL also makes me wonder if I should consider any of my measurements to be destructive testing, though I suspect that the powers and/or number of pulses used in their study and mine may differ substantially. [11 ] Z. L. Mohamed, Y. Kim, J. P. Knauer, and M. S. Rubery. γ-to-neutron branching ratio for deuterium–tritium fusion determined using high-energy-density plas- mas and a fused silica cherenkov detector. Physical Review C, 107(1):014606, 2023. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevC.107.014606 A fused silica Cherenkov detector was used to measure fusion gammas during ICF experiments at OMEGA. The detector is called the “di- agnostic for areal density” after it’s first intended application. There is a tungsten converter in front of a fused silica radiator coupled to a PMT. Relevance: This is an example of an application where solid Cherenkov detectors have been used to diagnose the quality of an implosion de- sign. [33 ] K. Yu. Vukolov, E. N. Andreenko, R. S. Afanasenko, I. I. Orlovskiy, and R. N. Rodionov. Effect of radiation exposure on optics in ITER. Physics of Atomic 63 Nuclei, 87(7):829–847, 2024. doi: 10.1134/S1063778824070160 Studies radiation-induced absorption of a variety of optics. Involves Monte Carlo simulations for estimating damaging fluxes and absorbed dose rates. Corning 7980 is mentioned only in passing. Contains transmittance data but it all appears to be aggregated from other studies. Relevance: Likely not a direct reference, however, the section “Silica Glass” gives a concise background on the structure of the material and common color centers. [40 ] Jingang Wang, Jimeng Cheng, Chongyun Shao, Wei Chen, Chunlei Yu, Lili Hu, Malgorzata Guzik, and Georges Boulon. Effects of oxygen loading on the red- luminescence of non-bridging oxygen hole centers in γ-irradiated silica glasses. Optical Materials, 147:114707, 2024. doi: 10.1016/j.optmat.2023.114707 Corning 7980 (grade unspecified) and one other glass are irradiated with gamma rays from a Co-60 source, and the spectral (intensity vs. wavelength) and temporal (intensity vs. time) characteristics of the radiation-induced luminescence are examined. Then the glasses are loaded with supplemental oxygen and the process is repeated to show differences. Much discussion is devoted to attribution of certain signal features with certain color centers. Relevance: Moderate. This study contains PL/PLE and luminescence lifetime measurements for Corning 7980 after irradiation, but I am interested in those measurements for virgin material. Therefore the study data is of limited use. However, experimental setup information may be of use. I wonder how they selected wavelengths to measure and report PL/PLE data at in Figures 3 and 4. Perhaps the most interesting content for this study is a statement on page 5 that the spectroscopic characteristics of NBOHCs are the same regardless of whether they were induced by a laser or ionizing radiation. Does this mean that I should expect similar results from PL/PLE and RL measurements on undamaged material? 64 A.2 Sapphire [45 ] A. Al Ghamdi and P. D. Townsend. Ion beam excited luminescence of sapphire. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Inter- actions with Materials and Atoms, 46:133–136, 1990. doi: 10.1016/0168-583 X(90)90684-M Z-cut and Y-cut sapphire samples of unknown origin and purity were irradiated with different ion beams and the luminescence was recorded in situ. There are several color centers observed in the UV and visible, some of which are attributed to intrinsic defects and some of which are damage-induced. The intensities are not proportional to the defect concentrations; they are functions of the ion species, dose, irradiation temperature, crystal cut, and polarization of the emitted light. The authors suggests that stress generated by radiation damage reduces the luminescence efficiency. Relevance: Key reference. The introduction contains a very succinct summary of color centers that have been observed in sapphire and what structural features result in them. It also explains why so many radiation damage studies use ions: it isn’t just because the damage is more severe. It’s because the damage is severe only at the surface, in contrast to neutron or electron irradiation, which causes damage more uniformly distributed but with so much induced absorption that it is hard to observe any luminescence. Results in section 3 could be compared with my measurements. [56 ] M. Böhm, P. Iacconi, K. D. Kromm, and A. Scharmann. Low temperature thermoluminescence and thermally stimulated conductivity in α-Al2 O3 crystals. physica status solidi (a), 146(2):757–764, 1994. doi: 10.1002/pssa.2211460220 Crystals were irradiated with X-rays at low temp and then heated in a helium bath cryostat where thermoluminescence was measured. TL (intensity vs. temperature) data are reported between 50 and 70 K (hundreds of degrees Fahrenheit below zero) in Figure 1, showing a peak intensity around 60 K. The spectral composition of this peak is shown in Figure 2; there are large contributions from wavelengths 65 around 330 and 390 nm. These peaks are attributed to F+ and F center transitions, respectively. Relevance: Low. Crystals were grown with a different method (Verneuil process, aka flame fusion) and no indication of sample purity is given. Given the abundance of more detailed and more recent TL data for sapphire, this likely does not provide any unique information. [46 ] Bruce D. Evans, Gerald J. Pogatshnik, and Yok Chen. Optical properties of lat- tice defects in α-Al2 O3 . Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, 91:258–262, 1994. doi: 10.1016/0168-583X(94)96227-8 Experimental optical properties of lattice vacancy defects in single crystal α-Al2 O3 are reviewed. Specific ultraviolet absorption and lu- minescence bands are associated with F-type centers. Following ex- tended exposures to epithermal neutron sources, photobleaching and anisotropic properties allowed the association of several of the visi- ble and near infrared bands with F2 -type centers. Photoconductiv- ity, photostability and charge state considerations provided tentative placement of defect energy levels with respect to the conduction band edge. Relevance: Low. See Figure 1 for spectroscopy of the F and F+ cen- ters. Note that curve ‘a’ in that figure is data from HEM sapphire grown by Crystal Systems, though I imagine some purity improve- ments have been made since 1994, and this plot is confusing to in- terpret. Perhaps the most useful information is Figure 3, a flat-band diagram showing the energy positions of several common types of anion vacancies which can serve as a general reference. [55 ] Tetsuo Tanabe, Masaaki Fujiwara, and Keiji Miyazaki. Energetic particle in- duced luminescence of Al2 O3 . Journal of Nuclear Materials, 233–237:1344–1348, 1996. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3115(96)00250-4 In-situ luminescence measurements are taken during irradiation with ions of various energies, fluences, and species. Samples were “sapphire crystal with the (0001) axis to surface normal”. Spectra showed three 66 bands centered at 335, 420, and 650 nm that are attributed to specific defects. Proves that induced luminescence of Al2 O3 by MeV ions is caused mainly by electron excitation and is not directly correlated with atomic displacement, except possibly at lower energies. Relevance: Medium. Reviewing how RL spectra change with the energy, fluence, and type of source particle could help me choose ap- propriate parameters for my RL measurements. The color centers reported here should probably be taken with a grain of salt consider- ing that no information is provided about the sapphire manufacturing method or purity. [52 ] Meller Optics, Inc. Sapphire Index of Refraction Table. Meller Optics, Inc., March 2002. Technical data table dated March 11, 2002 A table listing refractive indices for ordinary rays (along C axis) and extraordinary rays (normal to C axis) in sapphire at room tempera- ture. The wavelength range covered is 200 nm to 5.5 µm. The percent change between the indices ranges from 0.28% to 0.58%, decreasing almost monotonically with increasing wavelength. Relevance: Though this reference is old and not specific to the man- ufacturer/grade of material that I will be using, it may still be the most relevant dataset available. The same was requested from Crystal Systems for HEM LAOS but they were not able to provide anything more recent or relevant. [47 ] Ryo Toshima, Hiroyuki Miyamaru, Jun Asahara, Takehiro Murasawa, and Ak- ito Takahashi. Ion-induced luminescence of alumina with time-resolved spec- troscopy. Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology, 39(1):15–18, 2002. doi: 10.1080/18811248.2002.9715152 An alumina sample of 3N purity was irradiated with a pulsed deu- terium ion beam and time-resolved spectroscopy was performed in- situ. Emission spectra are reported at different times and Table 1 summarizes the peak wavelength and lifetime of different color cen- ters, some of which are later attributed to specific structural fea- tures/defects. 67 Relevance: Key reference. in-situ, time-resolved spectroscopy setup would be great for differentiating Cherenkov radiation from other lu- minescence coming from a sample. Their samples are alumina (poly- crystalline ceramic aluminum oxide) rather than single-crystal sap- phire, and I’m not sure how that might affect things. [48 ] M. Itou, A. Fujiwara, and T. Uchino. Reversible photoinduced interconversion of color centers in α-Al2 O3 prepared under vacuum. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 113(49):20949–20957, 2009. doi: 10.1021/jp908417m Polycrystalline spheres of α-Al2 O3 were prepared in two different at- mospheres (Ar and vacuum). The raw powder was 5N purity. PL and PLE measurements were made; the former includes both steady-state and time-resolved data. There are several color centers in the visi- ble and near-UV ranges and the decay lifetimes of some of them are shown. They found a reversible interconversion between F-type and F2 -type color centers that can be performed with alternating exposure to 300 nm and 220 nm light. Relevance: High. The data aren’t super applicable because the sap- phire samples were grown by the researchers using a different method than HEM and the final samples were polycrystalline and of unknown purity. (The starting powder was 5N purity but both the crucible and the gas atmospheres used can introduce contaminants.) However, de- scriptions of setups for time-resolved spectroscopy measurements on millisecond and nanosecond time scales are helpful; the latter is fast enough to differentiate Cherenkov from other luminescence. Also, Figure 13 is a helpful visual guide to different point defects in sap- phire. [50 ] Wei Chen, PingXin Song, YongJun Dong, YingJiu Zhang, and Wei Hua. Ther- moluminescence of Al2 O3 crystals grown by temperature gradient techniques. Chinese Science Bulletin, 58(16):1964–1968, 2013. doi: 10.1007/s11434-012-5 614-0 Color center (F and F + at 204, 232, 255) concentrations of Al2 O3 crystals grown by temperature gradient techniques were calculated 68 from Gaussian fits to absorption spectra. States that color centers are strongly influenced by crystal growth procedure. A simple theoretical model is presented to explain a commonly-observed TL glow curve peak at 450 K and the trap depth is determined to be 0.94456 +/ 0.00545 eV. Relevance: Temperature gradient techniques sounds like the HEM, so we may match on manufacturing method. However, this cannot be confirmed: This paper references another for explanation of the technique, and the latter cannot be located. Because color centers are strongly influenced by crystal growth procedure, I should focus on papers where the sapphire is produced in a manner similar to my samples. See Figure 1 for absorption vs. wavelength data covering 180 to 500 nm. See Figure 2 for TL glow curve. [44 ] Crystal Systems, Inc. HEM LAOS Sapphire Data Sheet. Crystal Systems, Inc., 2013. Revision A, October 2013 States that “almost all intrinsic photon absorption in the bulk sap- phire” is eliminated. Solarization resistant. Ultra-high purity. Wide spectral range from 150-4600 nm. Transmission vs. wavelength data is shown on a range of 190-298 nm and transmission is between maybe 78% and 86% throughout it. Contains other physical, mechanical, thermal, and electrical properties. Density is 3.98 g/cc. Index of refraction is notably absent. Relevance: My samples are HEM LAOS sapphire from Crystal Sys- tems, so the properties listed here are the most directly applicable of any available. [51 ] Yoshisuke Futami, Takayuki Yanagida, and Yutaka Fujimoto. Optical, dosimet- ric, and scintillation properties of pure sapphire crystals. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 53:02BC12, 2014. doi: 10.7567/JJAP.53.02BC12 Scintillation and dosimetric properties of pure Al2 O3 synthesized by the Cz and the Bridgman growth techniques were studied. States that color centers are strongly influenced by crystal growth proce- dure. In scintillation, the Cz sample exhibited an intense emission peak at 300 nm due to the F + center. The scintillation decay times 69 of the Cz and the Bridgman sample were 7.6 and 2.8 ns, respectively. Then samples were irradiated with x-rays so that the immediate radi- oluminesence (which showed emission peaks at 240 and 300 nm) and post-irradiation TSL could be studied. Both samples showed good linearity between the dose and TSL intensity, which is desirable for dosimetry work. Relevance: Key reference. The Bridgeman technique is quite similar to the heat exchanger method that my sapphire samples were grown with, so it is encouraging to see that these samples had fewer defects and exhibited less intense luminescence as a result. Transmission vs. wavelength (Figure 2), x-ray-induced luminescence spectra (Figure 3), scintillation decay time profiles (Figure 4), TSL glow curves (Figure 5), and TSL spectra (Figure 6) are all directly relevant. [57 ] S. V. Nikiforov, V. S. Kortov, S. V. Zvonarev, E. V. Moiseykin, and M. G. Kazantseva. Basic thermoluminescent and dosimetric properties of Al2 O3 ir- radiated by pulse intensive electron beam. Radiation Measurements, 71:74–77, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.radmeas.2014.02.010 TL in Al2 O3 :C single crystals exposed to a high-current pulse elec- tron beam was studied. TL peaks connected with the deep trapping centers at 400, 430 and 550 degrees C were found. Deep center fill- ing was found to increase the sample TL sensitivity in the dosimetric peak at 170 degrees C. The glow curve has a double-humped structure that is shown to result from different types of deep traps. Compli- cated dependence of the TL sensitivity with annealing temperature was found. An assumption is made that in the temperature ranges of 350 – 500 degrees C and 650 – 750 degrees C electron traps are emptied, whereas at T =500 – 650 degrees C hole traps are emptied. Relevance: Low. These crystals are doped with carbon, as is often used for radiation dosimeters. See glow curves reported in Figures 1, 2, 3, and 4. This is all high temperature (that is, above ambient) TL, which provides information about deep trapping centers. I may choose to perform low temperature TL measurements to get more information about shallow trapping centers instead of or in addition to this, depending on what is most relevant to my final application. 70 [53 ] G. Alombert-Goget, H. Li, Y. Guyot, A. Brenier, and K. Lebbou. Luminescence and coloration of undoped and Ti-doped sapphire crystals grown by czochralski technique. Journal of Luminescence, 169:516–519, 2016. doi: 10.1016/j.jlumin .2015.02.001 Undoped and Ti-doped sapphires crystals were grown using the Czochral- ski technique. The alumina powder raw material was 4N purity. The effect of growth parameters on the formation of color center was eval- uated by absorption and luminescence measurements. Relevance: My samples are grown by the heat exchanger method (HEM) rather than the Czochralski technique and it is difficult to know how the purities of our samples would differ as a result. While I am not interested in the impacts of specific manufacturing param- eters or in Ti-doping at present, the transmission and PL/PLE data reported for the undoped samples are useful. Note that the undoped samples had a variety of orientations and I don’t think any of them are Z-cut. Take notes from their PL/PLE measurement setup; this is the first time I have seen emission wavelength versus excitation wave- length with intensity as a color map, which is the format of data I hope to produce. [58 ] D. A. Sorokin, A. G. Burachenko, D. V. Beloplotov, V. F. Tarasenko, E. Kh. Baksht, E. I. Lipatov, and M. I. Lomaev. Luminescence of crystals excited by a runaway electron beam and by excilamp radiation with a peak wavelength of 222 nm. Journal of Applied Physics, 122:154902, 2017. doi: 10.1063/1.4996965 Presents data on cathodoluminescence, photoluminescence, and Cherenkov radiation from 200 nm – 800 nm in crystals excited by an electron beam and an excilamp with a peak wavelength of 222 nm. Spectral and amplitude-time characteristics are reported for many different materials. “The research suggests that cathodoluminescence and pho- toluminescence should be accounted for in Cherenkov-type detectors of runaway electrons” for tokamaks. Relevance: Medium. This was initially of interest for sapphire emis- sion data. Unfortunately, although sapphire was studied, none of the results from it are shown. This may be because it’s electron energy 71 threshold for generating Cherenkov is too high for it to detect the elec- trons of interest to the tokamak application (Table 1). There is still a lot of helpful background and theory on Cherenkov radiation (section II) and how it can be differentiated from other luminescence that usu- ally destroys the signal-to-background ratio. For instance, this can be done either by analyzing luminescence lifetimes or by focusing only on the Cherenkov light generated in the wavelength band between the UV absorption edge and the lowest wavelength cathodolumines- cence peak. Lastly, there is an interesting statement that “increasing the refractive index not only decreases the [electron kinetic energy] threshold . . . but also provides a several-fold increase in its spectral energy density at the same electron energy.” [49 ] D. V. Ananchenko, S. V. Nikiforov, G. R. Ramazanova, R. I. Batalov, R. M. Bayazitov, and H. A. Novikov. Luminescence of F-type defects and their thermal stability in sapphire irradiated by pulsed ion beams. Optics and Spectroscopy, 128(2):207–213, 2020. doi: 10.1134/S0030400X20020022 Studied the luminescence and the thermal stability of defects formed in Al2 O3 single crystals (c-orientation; Ti and Cr impurities ¡0.5 ppm) after pulsed treatment with a beam of C + /H + ions with an energy of 300 keV and a pulse duration of 80 ns. Studied optical absorption, photoluminescence, and pulsed cathodoluminescence; found that this type of exposure leads to intense generation of both single F and F+ centers and more complex defects (F2 aggregate centers or va- cancy–impurity complexes) in Al2 O3 . The thermal stability of F- type defects formed in Al2 O3 upon exposure to a pulsed ion beam is comparable to the stability of radiation-induced defects in neutron- irradiated samples. Relevance: Key reference. Table 1 has a concise summary of absorp- tion and luminescence centers and the defects responsible for them. The pulsed ion beam treatment intentionally melts the surface of the crystal but the reason for liquid versus solid state measurement is not clear. This is a radiation damage study, but most datasets include an undamaged baseline and seem applicable for comparison with my results except Figure 1. Whether luminescent intensity increases or 72 decreases with temperature seems to depend on the specific color cen- ter in play, as annealing can help heal certain radiation damage. [20 ] V. F. Tarasenko, E. Kh. Baksht, M. V. Erofeev, and A. G. Burachenko. Spectral and amplitude-time characteristics of the cherenkov radiation upon excitation of transparent materials by an electron beam. Optics and Spectroscopy, 129(7): 707–736, 2021. doi: 10.1134/S0030400X21050167 A very long, detailed paper which combines metanalysis with orig- inal measurements. “The survey resents results of investigations of spectral, amplitude–time, and spatial VCR characteristics obtained mainly in recent years upon excitation of transparent substances by a flux of electrons with energies of tens or hundreds of kiloelectronvolts. The VCR spectra in diamond (natural and synthetic), quartz glass, sapphire, and leucosapphire are presented. It is reported about VCR detection in MgF2 , Ga2 O3 , and other transparent samples. The spec- tra and amplitude–time characteristics of VCR and pulsed cathodo- luminescence (PCL) are compared at different electron energies.” Relevance: Key reference. Provides a thorough introduction to Cherenkov radiation, including history, theory, and general properties. Can likely help me better understand the relationship between a Cherenkov spectrum and the electron spectrum used to generate The introduc- tion states that somewhere it also offers “conditions under which the Cherenkov intensity can exceed the pulsed cathodoluminescence in- tensity”. Gives characteristics (transmission band, refractive index, electron energy threshold) of many potential Cherenkov materials, where IFG and ZFG are notably absent. Almost every figure is likely to teach something, though Figure 15.c (emission and trans- mission spectra of (1,3) leucosapphire) and Figures 16-17 (emission spectra from sapphire with various filters) may directly overlap with my datasets. [54 ] E. Yu. Zykova, K. E. Ozerova, A. A. Tatarintsev, and A. N. Turkin. Photolu- minescence of sapphire irradiated by low-energy electrons and ions. Optics and Spectroscopy, 130(9), 2022. doi: 10.21883/EOS.2022.09.54827.3397-22 73 Photoluminescence of single-crystal sapphire is recorded before and after irradiation by either electrons or ions. Two different excitation wavelengths are used. Relevance: Medium. The sapphire PL data (particularly for unirra- diated baselines) are interesting, though with so little information on the samples (for instance, impurity levels) it is unclear whether they could be compared with my measurements. A.3 Fluoroindate Glass [65 ] S. J. L. Ribeiro, R. E. O. Diniz, Y. Messaddeq, L. A. Nunes, and M. A. Aegerter. Eu3+ and Gd3+ spectroscopy in fluoroindate glasses. Chemical Physics Letters, 220(3–5):214–218, 1994. doi: 10.1016/0009-2614(94)00176-6 Another paper about rare-earth-doped fluoroindate glass. The base glass composition is 34 InF3 – 6 GaF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 15 BaF2 – 2 NaF – 0.5 CaF2 and then all sorts of other fluorides are added. Relevance: None. No data is reported for an undoped baseline, and the baseline is the wrong composition anyway. The author notes that the “pseudo-ternary system InF3 – ZnF2 – SrF2 – BaF2 ” can “be stabi- lized by the addition of small amounts of GaF3 , GdF3 , CaF2 , and NaF” which is probably why I am seeing so many different composi- tions. [75 ] Dakui Dong, Zhonglin Bo, Jiqian Zhu, and Fuding Ma. Study of properties of InF3-based glasses containing different valent fluorides. Journal of Non- Crystalline Solids, 204(3):260–264, 1996. doi: 10.1016/S0022-3093(96)00422-X The goal of the study is to find out what other fluoride can be added to the base InF3 – ZnF2 – BaF2 – SrF2 in order to improve glass form- ing ability / resistance to devitrification. They rank many different compositions based on this criterion. Relevance: None. This likely came up in the original search because of Figure 2, which shoes a typical IR transmission spectrum for this glass system. However, it only covers the IR range and this data is already available directly from the manufacturer of my samples. 74 [66 ] W. Lozano, Cid B. de Araujo, C. Egalon, A. S. L. Gomes, B. J. Costa, and Y. Messaddeq. Upconversion of infrared-to-visible light in Pr3+ -Yb3+ codoped fluoroindate glass. Optics Communications, 153(4–6):271–274, 1998. doi: 10.1 016/S0030-4018(98)00268-5 Another paper about rare-earth-doped fluoroindate glass. The addi- tion of Pr and Yb results in bright visible fluorescence. The sample composition is (35.5-x)InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 16 BaF2 – 6 GaF3 – 2 NaF – 0.5 PrF3 – xYbF3 (x = 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2). Relevance: None. Wrong glass formulation and no undoped baseline. [76 ] Ahmed Boutarfaia and Marcel Poulain. New stable fluoroindate glasses. Solid State Ionics, 144:117–121, 2001. doi: 10.1016/S0167-2738(01)00895-5 Poulain is the second author. Explores some new IFG compositions in search of a larger thermal stability range. Densities, refractive in- dices, and characteristic temperatures of various samples were mea- sured. The chemical durability is better than that of ZBLAN. The author references “the confusion principle”, which expresses that glass stability increases as the number of glass component increases. Their findings confirm this principle. Relevance: None. The starting point for all compositions studied was the ternary InF3 – YF3 – BaF2 . My samples are 40 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 20 BaF2 which will have different characteristics. The refractive in- dices would be the most useful, but I already have figures for those from Le Verre Fluoré anyway. [68 ] Danilo Manzani, David Paboeuf, Sidney J. L. Ribeiro, Philippe Goldner, and Fabien Bretenaker. Orange emission in Pr3+ -doped fluoroindate glasses. Optical Materials, 35(3):383–386, 2013. doi: 10.1016/j.optmat.2012.09.030 Another paper about rare-earth-doped fluoroindate glass. The base glass composition is 40 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 20 BaF2 and then Pr is added at different concentrations. Relevance: None. No data is reported for an undoped baseline, and the baseline is the wrong composition anyway. 75 [60 ] M. N. Brekhovskikh, L. V. Moiseeva, S. Kh. Batygov, I. A. Zhidkova, and V. A. Fedorov. Glasses on the basis of heavy metal fluorides. Inorganic Materials, 51 (13):1348–1361, 2015. doi: 10.1134/S0020168515130026 A review paper on heavy metal fluoride glasses. Aggregated informa- tion includes history, processing techniques, physiochemical proper- ties, applications, purification techniques, and the effect of impurities on optical transparency. Relevance: Low. Most of the content is irrelevant, though there are some helpful bits of information. The intro states fluoride glasses tend to contain more ionic bonds than oxide glasses, which promotes higher ordering of the structure and makes for some unique optical properties. The section on spectroscopic studies mentions using fluo- ride glasses as scintillators and can stand up to radiation doses up to 103 Gy, making them useful for high-flux environments. [71 ] T. Castro, D. Manzani, and S. J. L. Ribeiro. Up-conversion mechanisms in Er3+ - doped fluoroindate glasses under 1550 nm excitation for enhancing photocurrent of crystalline silicon solar cell. Journal of Luminescence, 200:260–264, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jlumin.2018.04.028 Silicon solar cells that are not sensitive to IR light can be made more efficient with the introduction of upconverting materials that can ab- sorb in the IR and emit in the visible. The author proposes using rare earth doped fluoroindate glass for this and prepares samples according to (100-x)(40 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 20 BaF2 ):xErF3 , where x varies from 0.1 to 7 mol%. Samples are excited at 1550 nm and the emis- sion spectrum is recorded. There is no undoped baseline, but even with low dopant concentrations, there is almost no recorded emission between 400 and 1100 nm. Higher dopant concentrations make peaks in the red, green, and near-IR. Relevance: Their fluoroindate samples are the same composition as mine, so it’s encouraging to see the lack of emission from the low- dopant-concentration samples. It’s hard to know whether data at lower wavelengths is excluded because there was no observable signal in that regime or because the author simply wasn’t interested in it; the instrument recording emissions was sensitive down to 200 nm. 76 [67 ] Zhen Liu, Jiangbo She, and Bo Peng. Spectroscopic properties of Er3+ -doped fluoroindate glasses. Journal of Rare Earths, 40:1037–1042, 2022. doi: 10.1016/ j.jre.2021.05.011 Their goal is to improve the gain coefficient of fluoroindate fibers being used as mid-IR lasers by doping them with various concentrations of Er. They call the base glass IZSB, but this seems inaccurate because even the base composition contains several more fluorides than are implied there. Relevance: None. Figure 1 contains transmission vs wavelength data that extends into the UV, including an undoped baseline, which shows an absorption cutoff around 300 nm. However, that baseline composi- tion is 35 InF3 – 18 ZnF2 – 15 SrF2 – 15 BaF2 – 7 NaF – 5 CdF2 – 5 GaF3 , which is different than mine. Better to stick to the manufacturer’s transmission data because it is the correct composition and covers the largest range of wavelengths. Figure 2 contains some emission data, but it only focuses on the IR. [69 ] Lukasz Sójka, Bartlomiej Starzyk, Slawomir Sujecki, Lukasz Pajewski, Piotr Miluski, Jacek Żmojda, Wojciech A. Pisarski, Joanna Pisarska, Marcin Kochanow- icz, Dominik Dorosz, Trevor M. Benson, David Furniss, Mark C. Farries, and Angela B. Seddon. Mid-infrared emission from Dy3+ doped fluoroindate glass fiber. Ceramics International, 49:41210–41216, 2023. doi: 10.1016/j.ceramint.2 023.03.075 Another paper about rare-earth-doped fluoroindate glass. The base glass composition was (38-x) InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 16 BaF2 – 4 GaF3 – 2 LaF3 and it was doped with DyF3 (x = 0.2–1.6 mol.%). Relevance: None. Initial interest was based on the photoluminescence and decay lifetime data, but no data is reported for an undoped base- line, and the baseline is the wrong composition anyway. [70 ] Bartlomiej Starzyk, Gloria Lesly Jimenez, Marcin Kochanowicz, Marta Kuwik, Jacek Żmojda, Piotr Miluski, Agata Baranowska, Jan Dorosz, Wojciech Pis- arski, Joanna Pisarska, and Dominik Dorosz. Investigation of thermal sensing 77 in fluoroindate Yb3+ /Er3+ co-doped optical fiber. Materials, 16(6):2139, 2023. doi: 10.3390/ma16062139 Another paper about rare-earth-doped fluoroindate glass. The base glass composition was 35.8 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 16 BaF2 – 4 GaF3 – 2 LaF3 – 0.8 YbF3 – 1.4 ErF3 and the dopants were Yb3+ at 1.73e20 ions/cc and Er3+ at 3.02e20 ions/cc. Relevance: None. Initial interest was based on the photoluminescence data, but none is reported for an undoped baseline, and the baseline is the wrong composition anyway. [77 ] E. La Francesca, A. Cemmi, M. C. De Sanctis, S. De Angelis, I. Di Sarcina, J. Scifo, A. Verna, E. Ammannito, M. Ferrari, and A. Raponi. Physical effects in the VIS-IR of ionizing gamma radiations on indium fluoride optical fibers. Review of Scientific Instruments, 96:064503, 2025. doi: 10.1063/5.0265568 Indium fluoride fibers from Le Verre Fluoré were irradiated to very high doses (hundreds of Gy) over several days using a set of Co-60 sources in a pool-type hot cell. Optical transmission was measured before, immediately after, about a day after, and months after irradia- tion to study how transmission changes both with dose and time. The goal was to understand their suitability for use in space instruments. Relevance: None. They do not state the composition of the IFG used, but it is likely similar to mine considering that we both purchased from Le Verre Fluoré around the same time. I was drawn to this study in hopes that it would contain radioluminescence data, but it’s a radiation damage study instead. A.4 Fluorozirconate Glass [62 ] Y. Dai, K. Takahashi, and I. Yamaguchi. Thermal oxidation of fluorozirconate glass and fibres. Journal of Materials Science Letters, 12:1648–1651, 1993 ZBLAN optical fibers were given a surface treatment to protect them from water corrosion. The treatment involved heating the fibers in a furnace with a flowing oxygen gas atmosphere for 20-70 hours. Then 78 treated and untreated fibers were submerged in water at room tem- perature for 20 hours and their surfaces were scanned with a micro- scope. The treatment was successful in protecting the fiber and the untreated fiber severely corroded. Relevance: Referenced in the Cimek paper; read to follow-up on the moisture sensitivity concern. [61 ] B. Yang, P. D. Townsend, N. Can, A. Janke, P. Baniel, O. Blanc, and J. Granier. Luminescence of levitated Zr-Ba-La-Al-Na fluoride glass. Physical Review B, 56 (10):5876–5884, 1997. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.56.5876 Experiments are conducted to see if the luminescence behavior of ZBLAN glass can be used as a probe of material quality and the author concludes that it can be. Cathodoluminescence (Fig. 1), X- ray radioluminescence (Fig. 2-5), and thermoluminescence (Fig. 7-8) were all measured. A deconvolution of the RL spectra revealed six visible-range emission bands that were common to all samples (Fig. 6) and are assumed to arise from intrinsic electron-hole recombina- tion processes because all samples were highly pure. However, the signal intensities increase when more defects (impurities, lattice de- fects, etc.) are present, and there was still some emission observed during low-temperature TL that they believe is coming from rare- earth impurities. Relevance: Key reference. This paper is really a one-stop shop for understanding luminescence in ZBLAN. The datasets are comprehen- sive and are all relevant enough to use for future comparison (“. . . the form of the spectra and the number of constituent bands did not vary greatly between the samples studied, despite a variety of doping and production changes”). Some helpful background information: That ZBLAN has so many components can lead to variations in local sto- ichiometry and introduce scattering. Fluoride glasses in general are chemically aggressive (for instance, to metal crucibles, hence the need for levitation on a gas film) and hygroscopic. In addition, there are many nuggets of information that can shape my measurement plan: Low-purity samples are likely to have so many color centers that the spectra can’t easily be analyzed. Impurities cannot only add broad- band emission signals but also interact with the glass network to mod- ify the shape and intensity of peaks from intrinsic processes. Samples 79 that were irradiated and then heated above room temperature for TL swelled and started to decompose. CL and RL results differed in that the RL spectral intensities varied a lot more with temperature, which the author explains. RL was more intense at low temp and decreased on the approach to room temp; the relative intensities of different peaks within a spectrum also change with temp. Attempts to attribute specific color centers to specific structural features in the material quickly become highly speculative. The author reinforces that CL, RL, and TL all offer unique insights: “The competitive na- ture of the charge distribution between alternative luminescence sites means that CL, RL, and TL will all emphasize the presence of dif- ferent components of the possible luminescence decay routes”. RL, TL, and CL spectra should be continuous; if discontinuities appear, it may be due to the presence of bulk phase transitions. [63 ] Jaroslaw Cimek, Xavier Forestier, Ryszard Stepień, Mariusz Klimczak, and Ryszard Buczyński. Synthesis conditions of ZBLAN glass for mid-infrared op- tical components. Photonics Letters of Poland, 10(1):8–10, 2018. doi: 10.4302/ plp.v10i1.804 ZBLAN glasses with various purities of the main component, zirco- nium tetrafluoride, and different fluorinating agents were synthesized. Transparent glass with no defects to the visible eye resulted when 5N (99.999%) pure zirconium tetrafluoride was used with xenon difluo- ride and sulphur hexafluoride as fluorinating agents. It seems that the purity of zirconium tetrafluoride drives the bulk transparency while fluorinating agents are required to eliminate localized black inclusions. Transmission and phase refractive index are measured as functions of wavelength. Finally, the authors note that ZBLAN is sensitive to moisture even at ambient temperature, which causes degradation of the glass on exposure. Relevance: Key reference. Transmission and refractive index data from the supplier of my samples will be prioritized over these mea- surements due to potential differences in the synthesis process that can change the final composition. However, the paper offers helpful background information, and it is important to run down the ques- tion of moisture sensitivity so that I can handle my samples without damaging them. 80 [78 ] Le Verre Fluoré. Fluoride Glass Fiber Catalog. Le Verre Fluoré, 2024. Product catalog Gives a high-level overview of the different materials that this manu- facturer makes fibers with (including IFG and ZFG), some common applications for them, basic specifications, and pricing. Given spec- ifications are operating wavelength, attenuation per unit length of fiber, Fresnel loss, coating material, operating temp, attenuation vs. wavelength, and internal transmission vs. wavelength for a 10 mm thick sample. Relevance: My IFG and ZFG samples were purchased from this sup- plier. Of greatest interest are the transmission vs. wavelength data for IFG and ZFG. However, they is only reported over a range of 500 nm to 5 micron, so performance in the lower visible and UV ranges in unclear. [64 ] Le Verre Fluoré. Fluoride glasses, 2024. Technical overview webpage preserved as PDF This is a technical resource page on the manufacturer’s website. It gives the chemical formulae for ZFG (53 ZrF4 – 20 BaF2 – 4 LaF3 – 3 AlF – 20 NaF) and IFG (40 InF3 – 20 ZnF2 – 20 SrF2 – 20 BaF2 ), states that their respective transparency ranges* are from 220 nm to 7 micron and from 255 nm to 8 micron, and gives glass transition temps, densities, refractive indices, non-linear refractive indices, and phonon energies. These properties are compared to those of other glasses such as silica. *measured using 3 mm thick samples Relevance: My IFG and ZFG samples were purchased from this sup- plier. The key data are transmission vs. wavelength (which is re- ported over a larger range of wavelengths here than the fiber cata- log), density, and refractive index for each material. Also note that these fluoride glasses have slightly higher refractive indices than silica according to the last figure. [59 ] Marcel Poulain. Heavy metal fluoride glasses: A tutorial review. APL Photonics, 9:091103, 2024. doi: 10.1063/5.0226668 81 Written by one of the original discoverers of fluoride glass, this review paper acts as a contemporary primer on the glass synthesis process, some popular fluoride glass compositions, their physical properties, and their main applications. Relevance: Key reference. The “Composition” section gives helpful background on nomenclature: “Except for BeF2 , no pure fluoride ex- ists in the vitreous state. Only the combination of several fluorides results in melts in which the crystallization rate is low enough to allow glass to be obtained by fast cooling”. There are three major families of heavy metal fluoride glasses (where the word ‘heavy’ is included to contrast with beryllium fluoride glass) that are well-known and currently in use. These are fluorozirconates, fluoroaluminates, and fluoroindates. This is a great reminder that “fluoroindate” and “flu- orozirconate” refer to entire classes of heavy metal fluoride glasses; many compositions fall within each of these, so specificity is warranted in my writing. Both ZFG and IFG glasses are discussed in detail. Fig- ure 2 offers transmission vs. wavelength data on a range from below 100 nm to 10 microns. Figure 3 offers refractive index vs. wave- length (dispersion) curves of standard IFG and ZFG. The section on chemical durability answers to the handling concerns that were raised in reading Cimek’s paper—it sounds like bulk heavy metal fluoride glasses can tolerate a humid atmosphere so long as the temperature does not exceed 100 degrees C and condensation is prevented. Stor- ing the samples with desiccant and exercising care with what they are cleaned with or otherwise exposed to should be sufficient. The lower the pH, the higher the rate of corrosion. Bulk HMFGs are stable in buffered solutions that are slightly alkaline (pH around 8). 82