Perpetuum Mobile; or, Search for Self-Motive Power (Henry Dircks, 1861) ======================================================================= Henry Dircks — The definitive 19th-century history of the search for perpetual motion, 17th-19th centuries. Public domain. Scan via Internet Archive (perpetuummobile01dircgoog) — 1861 first edition. This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project to make the world's books discoverable online. It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover. Marks, notations and other marginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the publisher to a library and finally to you. Usage guidelines Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying. We also ask that you: + Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes. + Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help. + Maintain attribution The Google "watermark" you see on each file is essential for informing people about this project and helping them find additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it. + Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe. About Google Book Search Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web at|http : //books . google . com/ c )^ vN\ .'>:^' THREE CENTURIES OF PERPETUAL MOTION. By henry DIRCKS, C.E. PEKPETUUM MOBILE; OR, SEAKCH FOE SELF-MOTIVE POWEE, DURING THE 17th, 18th, and 19th CENTURIES. ILLUSTBATED FBOM VAEIOUS AUTHENTIC SOUBCES, IN PAPEB8, ESSAYS, 3LETTEBS, PABAGBAPHS, AND NUMEJIOUS PATENT SPECIFICATIONS. AN INTEODUCTORY ESSAY, By HENRY DIRCKS, C.E, *A HOSjT INCREDIBLE THING IF NOT SEEN." Marquis of Worcester. ' THE HUMAN CNDER STANDING 18 ACTIVE, AND CANNOT HALT OR REST; BUT BFEN, THOJJGH WITHOUT EFFECT, STILL PRESSES FORWARD." Bacon. E. & F. N. SPON, 16, BUCKLERSBURY. 186 1. [7%« right of Translation is reserved,'] LONDON: PRINTED BT B. HBABNDBN, 12, KINO'S BOAD, BALLS POND. PEEPETUUM MOBILE, CONTENTS. PAGB Introductoet Essay.— 1. Early history, ajjd to the Siiteenth century; 2. Seventeenth century characterized; 3. The Eighteenth century; 4. The Nineteenth century; 5. "Per- petual Motion " defined ; 6. Found to be a fkscinating puT" suit ; 7. Kind of machine sought ; 8. Is a paradox— mathe- maticians divided in opinion ; 9. The inventive faculty ; 10, Undiscovered—constant feilures ; 11. Folly of secrecy ; 12. At best but a toy ; 13. Influence to the study ; 14. Moderu instances and correspondence ; 15. Abortive efforts ; 16. No deciidon offered ; 17. Goneral laws not without excep- tions ; 18. Mathematics opposed to perpetual motion ; 19. Ordinary argumei]its against it ; 20. Incessant failure ; 21. Erroneous contrasts ; . 22. Its inutility often asserted ; 23. Loss of fortune assumed ; 24. Understanding assailed ; 25. Opposition should be feirly directed ; 26. The pursuit likeued to a lock without a key ; 27. Stimulus to continued search ; 28. Belief and disbelief; 29. Error in the application, and not in the sciences of mechanics and mathenjiatics ; 30. Mar- quis of Worcester ; 31. Orfl^nreus ; 32. Invention of the first ; 33. Invention of the second ; 34. The subject in every light paradoxical ; 35. Botl^ the supposed discoveries kept secret ; 36. Scientific disbelief ; 37. Projectors should analyse their schemes ; 38. Its discovery unpromising and unlikely on all known laws ; 39. Apparatus to show the difficulty ; 39. Con- clusion ...... xi — xlii Chapter I. — Early opinions respecting the possibility of, and projects for obtaining, perpetual motion . . 1 — 33 Bishop Wilkins, 1 j Scarce works on perpetual motion, 2 ; Seeming fecility and real difficulty of several contriv- a2 IV CONTENTS. PAOB ances, 2—5 ; Attempts by magnetiBm, 5—7 ; and by wheel and solid weights, 8—12 ; Its power analysed, 9 ; Fhiid weights, Archimedean screw, 12—18 ; Taisnienis on Con- tinual Motion, 18 ; Wheel and magnet, 20 ; Leupold on Perpetual Motion, 21 ; on Orfl^nreus* wheel, 22 ; on a null and syphon, 22 ; and a pump, 23 ; "Manual Arts," 1661, 23 : Turrianus' mill, 24 ; Fludd's works, 1618, and two inventions, 24 — 29 ; Bettino's works, 1645, 29—33. Chaptek n. — Inventions of the Marquis of Worcester and Councillor Orfl^reus .... 34—59 The Marquis of Worcester and his " Century of Inventions," 34 ; Partington's note on the same, 35 ; and on perpetual motion, 36 ; Orfl^T^us, his character, 37 ; his celebrated wheel, 38 — 42 ; and Gravesande*s letter to Sir Isaac New- ton, 39—42; Desaguliers against perpetual motion, 42—48 ; Notice of Orffjrreus and Dr. Kenrick, 48, 49 ; Dr. Hutton on Orfl^^eus and against perpetual motion, 49—54 ; Kenrick's lecture in fitvour of perpetual motion and his own invention, 54—59. Chapter HL — ^Patents of the Seventeenth and Eighteenth cen- turies, with contemporary scientific notices on them and the subject generally ...... 60—84 1630, Ramseye, 60 ; 1635, Barton, 60 ; 1662, Wayne, 61 ; l779,Muller, 61; 1782,Morley, 61 ; 1786, Mead, 62; 1790, Schwiers, 65 ; 1790, Haywood, 66 ; 1794, Mead, 67 ; 1797, Varley, 68 ; and remarks on same, and Schwiers' patent, 70 — 82; 1801, Thiville, and remarks on same, and per- petual motion, 82 — 84. Chapter IV.— Early papers firom the Philosophical Transactions, and Sir Bobert Boyle ; also the Paris Academy of Sciences, with notices of communications to the Academy, 1837—56 85—105 Dr. Papin on a French invention for perpetual motion, 85 ; his Airther remarks, 87 ; and final answer, 88, 89 ; Rev. J. T. Desaguliers, LL.D., his proposition on the balance, 89— 93 ; and on a mechanical paradox, 93 — 97 ; Sir R. Boyle on a self-moving liquor, 98—101 ; M. de la Hire, his celebrated demonstration of the impossibility of CONTENTS. V PAOB perpetual motion, 102 ; list of commmucationB on per^ petnal motion made to the Paris Academy of Sciences, 103, 104 ; M. Parent's demonstration of the impossibility of perpetual motion, 105. Chapter V.— Remarks on Perpetual Motion, derived from trear Uses on Natural Philosophy .... 106 — 147 1747, By Martin, 106—108 ; 1748, Maclaurin, 108—113 ; 1748, Rutherford, 114—119 ; 1783, Hooper, 119, 120 ; 1794, Emerson, 120—122; 1800, Nicholson, 122—137; 1807, Young, 137—139; 1815, Gregory, 139—142; 1823, Mil- Imgton, 142; 1828, Partington, 143; 1828, Dr. Amott, 144, 145 ; Montucla's " Histoire des Mathematiques," 145—147; Cox*s clock (by Nicholson), 123—127. Ohapteb VL — Papers from early scientific and other journals 148—191 From the "Gentleman's Magazine:"—!. Discovery of longitude, 148—153; 11. Raising water^ 153—159; m. Solski's machine, 159 ; IV. A self-moving wheel, 163 ; V. Magnetic motion, and alleged discovery by Hicken, 170 ; VL Archimedean water-raising machine, 173 ; Yll. Ash* nlan's alleged discovery, 177 ; VIH. By Galvanic agency^ 177 ; IX. Ancient attempt at perpetual motion, 177 ; X. Kenrick and Miiller apply for patents, 178 ; XL A mag- netic scheme, 178; XlX. Spence's magnetic motion, 180; XIH. Magnetic wheel, 181 ; Cox*s time-piece, 182 ; Dode* mant's alleged discovery, 183 ; Poppe on perpetual motion, 183 ; Gill's exposure of an impostor, 184—186 ; Dr. Young**^ illustrative model of perpetual motion, 187 ; Gravesande on perpetual motion, 187—190 ; Resolution of the Aca- demy of Sciences agamst memoirs on perpetual motion, 190, 191. Chapter VEL— definitions and descriptions of perpetual motion: from encyclopaedias and dictionaries . . . 192—812^ Article from Rees' Cydopaedia, 192—197 ; Encyclapadia Britannica, 197 ; Chambers' Cyclopaedia, 197 ; Stone's Mathematical Dictionary, 198 ; Dictionary of Mechanical Science (Fisher's), 200 ; Francis' Dictionary of Arts, 200 ; Ogilvie's Imperial Dictionary, 201 ; Brande and Cauvin's ^ctionary of Science, &c., 201—203; Encyclopaedia Tl CONTENTS^ PAGK Americana, 203, 204 ; Diderot and D'Alembert's French EncyclopaBdia, 1765, 204; Encyclopedic Methodique, 205; Zedler's German Universal Lexicon, 1741, 206—209; AUegemeine Encyclopadie, von M. H. E. Meier, 1767, 209—211 ; Dr. Binder's Conversations Lexicon, 211 ; Hof- mann's Lexicon, 1698, 211, 212. Chapter VIII. — Early popular and other jomuals, and the Percy Anecdotes >i . . . . . 213— 236 Absurdity erf perpetual motion deraonsti^ated, 213 ; The perpetual motion hunter, 214—220; Dr. T. P. Jones (America) on the futility of attempting perpetiml motion, 220 —225 ; Stukeley, Anecdote of, 226 ; Spence's perpetual motion, and his inventions, 226—229 ; Pendulum motion, 229—231 ; Alleged discovery, two claimants, 231 ; A de- ception exposed, 231—233; another, 233,234; "Century of Inventions, " reviewed, 235, 236. Chapter IX. — Recent popular scientific and other journals 237—406' Section I. — Possibility of perpetual motion asserted, 237; by Pasley, 237 ; to promote discovery, 239 ; by Welch, 239—241; by Todd, 241—244; Review, 244—250; A query, 250 ; to construct twenty models, 251 ; Arguments for and against, 252—254 ; by Twiss, 254 — 256 ; Pearson's views, 256—259; by Mackintosh, 259. Section n.— Its possibility denied, 259 ; advice, 259, 260 ; Objections to a pump, 260 ; No perpetual motion, 260—264 ; Invariable motion wanted, 264 ; On particles of matter, 266 ; Objec- tions to perpetual motion, 267 ; Editor's advice, 269 ; A lectm-er's observations, 269, 270 ; Scripture texts, 270 ; Re- marks against perpetual motion, and editor's note, 271 — 273 ; T(y perpetual motionists, 273 ; " Penny Magazine " article, 275—277 ; Notes from Mudie's Mathematics, 277, 278 ; W. R. Groves' lecture, 279 ; General T.P.Thompson's lecture, 281. Section HI.- Plans, 283 ; A pump, 283 ; Hydro- pneumatic apparatus, 284 ; De Luc's column, 285 ; A pump, 286 ; Archimedean screw, 287 ; A pump, 288—291 ; By magnetism, 291 ; Several schemes, 293 ; Spence's perpetual motion, 294 ; A clock, 295 : A hydro-pneumatic plan, 296 — 298 ; Band with corks, 299, 300 ; Propelling vessels, 300— 302 ; A pump, 302 ; A clock, 303 ; Ancient attempt, a CONTEXTS. Til PAOB pump, 303—305 ; Orchard's engine, 305 ; Wheel and mag- nets, 307 ; Water-blowmg machine, 307 ; Hydro-pneumatic machine, 310—314 ; Sir W. Congreve's schemes, 314 — 326 ; Pendulum motion, 327 ; Wheel and magnets, 329 ; Cox*s time-piece, 330 — 338 ; Magnetic pendulum, 339 ; Syphon, 340 ; New motion, 342 ; Railway carriage, 343 ; Sims' water elevator, 346; Worcester's scheme, 347 ; Wheels and pumps, 349; Wheel and weighted levers, 350 ; Pump, 351 ; Mill, 354 ; Demonstration against water-wheels, 356—361 ; An hydraulic mover, 361; Paradoxical balance, 363; Arising and descending equal weight, 364; Two "certain" plans, 365; Wheel, ball, and magnet, 367; Its fellacy, 369; An attempt, 369. Section IV. — Claimants, 370 ; Alleged dis- covery in Stamford, 370; Advertisement, 371 ; by Van Dyke, 371; Franklin, 372; A clock, 373; Wright, 373; Sellery, Buckle, Townsend, 374 ; Stringfellow, Hutt, 375 ; in Gravesend, 375 ; Hendrickson, and his sad fate (America), 376 ; Chenhall's clock. Section V.— Impostures, 378; in Scotland, 378 ; from America, 380 ; Adams, 381 ; in Finch- lane, 382 ; Redhoeffer (America), 383. Anecdote of Stukely, 383; Article on impossibility, 384; On impracticability, 385 — 390; A popular view, 390 ; Deuchar on loadstones, 393 ; Spence's imposture, 394 — 395 ; A paradox, 396 ; A pump, 397 ; Hollow-spoked wheel and weights, 398 ; The pursuit censured, 399 ; Eoioto's scheme, 400 ; On attempts, 401 ; Alleged discovery by Wather ; Plan of double wheels (American), 402, and by Willis, 404 ; and others, 404 ; Poppe on perpetual motion, plans, and an imposture, 405. Censure, 406. Chapter X. — Newspapers and miscellaneous sources of informa- tion , , , . . • . . 407—427 The Athenian Qracle, 407 ; Alleged discovery by Bayne, 408 ; Spence's invention, 408 ; Dalling's scheme, 409 ; A wager, 410 ; Mannardet's wheel, 410 ; Garhar's scheme, 410 ; Geyser's imposture, 411 ; Irish Advertisement, 411 ; Alleged discovery, 412; and in Newcastle, 412; An impos- ture, 413 ; Presumed discovery, 413 ; by Van Dyke, 414 ; Richards' engine, 414 ; by Vignemon, 415 ; by Stannard ; by Hutt, 416 ; in Lille,* 417; Pasley's views, 417; Eaton's • Probably the machine patented by Asaert, of Lille. (See page 451.) Vm C0KTEKT9. PAGB gyplion, 418 ; Legge's power, 419 ; Foster's wheel (Ame^ rica), 419; Predaval*s patent motive power company, 420—427. Chapteb XI— Patents of the I^eteenth century, for improve- ments in obtainiog inotivQ power: English, French, and American ...... 428—500 Remarks on patents, 428; Patentees, namely:— Plea- wmts, 429 ; Winter, 430 ; Copland (three patents), 431 ; Linton, 485; Jordan, 437; Congreve, 437; Hainsselin, 438 ; Predaval, 442 ; BraziU, 442 ; Stuckey, 443 ; W. W. Sleigh (four patents), 446 ; Eaton, 450 ; Asaert, 451 ; Fr^che, 455; Buchholz, 459 ; Greaves, 459, 460 ; Faulkner, 460 ; Luedeke, 460 ; Wood, 461 ; Fitt, 461 ; Newton, 461 ; Olomey, 462 ; Bellford, 463 ; A. W. Sleigh, 463 ; Aitken, 463; Shaw, 464; Oulton, 464; Thomas, 465; Hale, 465, 481 ; Malavas, 466 ; Huddart (two patents), 467 ; Benton, 468 ; Weber, 468 ; Gilardeau, 468 ; Jones, 469 ; Herault, 469 ; Lang, 470 ; Dembinski, 470 ; Layeuder, 471 ; Lespi- nasse, 471 ; Barrow, 472 ; Lecocq, 472 ; Predavalle (four patents), 472 ; Commandeur, 475 ; Fontainemoreau, 478 Gilmour, 478 ; Middleship, 479 ; Mennons, 481 ; Hill, 481 Richard, 482; Black, 483; Coates, 484; Pickering, 485 Wright and Mercer, 485 ; Starbuck, 486 ; Roussel, 486 Rigby, 486 ; Smith, 487 ; Picciotto, 489 ; Priuce G. Gen- nerich, 491 ; Redrup, 493 ; Edwards, 495. Patentees' professions, 496. List of French patents, 497 ; iMid Ame- rican patents, 498. Concluding remarks, 499, Chapter XH. — Summary remarks , . . 501—504 Scarce works, 501 ; List of eminent mathematicians, their births and deaths, 501 ; Dr. Kenrick, notice of, 502 ; Century of Inventions, unnoticed in foreign works, 502, 503 ; An error in naming the Marquis of Worcester, 603 ; Orffyreus's name ; some patents probably omitted, 503 ; Condufiion, 504. Appeitoix ^ • . • . . . 505—534 A. Prom "Theatrum Machinarum Generale," by Jacob Leupold. Ldpsic, 1794. Folio. Referred to at page 21.— 505— 509 PREFACE. Who will not be reminded, on perusing the title of this book^ of the exclamation — " Will no one write a book on what he "onderstands ! " Great will be the disappointment of him who seeks here to find an account of any veritable Perpetual Motion ; or, to be enlighteiied on the art of constructing any such machine. Neither will he even meet with any very powerful arguments for or against its possibility. Either way, whatever may be his views, we opine he will discover many deficiencies, little to praise, and, as in all other human works, much to censure. Can such a book be a desideratum? Yes; because it supplies a niche hitherto vacant in the history of Mechanical Science ; it opens to view a ciirious phase in the mental con- stitution of a certain class of inventors ; it brings into a com- prehensive form their labours and the opinions of their bpponents, gathered from sburces scattered through a vast variety of "^Vorks— many inaccessible to the general student ; and, lastly, it fexhibits an amount of infatuia,tion respecting patent schenles that would otherwise have remained long unknown ; or, if asserted without this evidence, could scarcely have been credited. If this publication tends to the attaining of no other result than arresting the further operations of this misguided, though ingenious, class of men, it will have erected a step in the ladder bf ajiv|i;icement. The writer at a vefy^jWly period of life became aware of INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. 1. In the classic ages, Invention was restricted almost exr clusively to Poetry and Painting, hence to however remote a period we may trace the history of manual arts, we find it harren of all interest, save that which always attaches to a comparatively primitive character. Except as considered Metaphysically and Mathematically, we cannot but feel sur- prised how the idea of a self-motive mechanical power should have originated, or at what period it could have been called into existence. As emanating from the fruitful fancy of the poet or romancer, it may readily be conceived, but with what object and by what means the rude mechanician of a remote antiquity woi^d attempt it, is not readily to be conjectured. All modem ideas on the subject would reasonably ally it with im- provements early connected with Horologe, when automata of every kind engaged the attention of the ingenious mecha- nician ; or, to a period when water and other natural agents were commonly to be seen operating machines employed in mechanical arts, and which, as they were early brought to a state of considerable perfection, the ne plus ultras would most likely, for a long time, appear to have been attained ; and what then would be more natural, in the oi^w^rd progress of improvement, than to seek for the obtaining of power by some direct application of grayity ? The problem of a Perpetual Motion once pron^ulgated would prove highly attractive, asf it would appear in ^ primitive age easy, natural, and perfectly attainable. Imagination may thus supply the probable pro- cess originating this pursuit, one equally curious, contra^- Xll INTKODUCTORY ESSAY. dictory, and seductive. We cannot trace the history of its practical operations previous to the sixteenth century, and at that era only to a very limited extent.* When, however, we consider the mutations and dificulties attending early histories generally, we have little to be surprised at in the fact of this meagre information. Whatever may have been the fate of this class of lost inventions, certainly — so far as may be judged from modern models — we seem to have no great occasion for regret ; except, indeed, such as would un- questionably apply to the curiosity of their mediaeval character. 2. In the seventeenth century we find schemes for appljring magnetism, pneumatic agency, weights, and atmospheric changes. To this period belongs the celebrated invention of the Marquis of Worcester, exhibited by him before Charles I. and his court. During the same century were established, in London, the Royal Society ; and in Paris, the Royal Academy of Sciences.f These learned bodies showed less fastidiousness than they afterwards observed, in the class of Memoirs they admitted, consequently we find both were drawn into discussion, by their members, on the then popular topic of the time — " Perpetual Motion." Patents were also being granted in England thus early for reputed perpetual motion machines. 3. In the eighteenth century it was currently reported that the discovery was at length made ; sometimes propagated by the public press, at others by the scientific journals then coming into repute. The latter admitted papers in which ♦ In the 16th century, Edmimd Jentill, in a letter to Lord Burghley, dated October, 1594, amongst other matters, professed to have dis- covered " A perpetuall motion of sufficient force to diyve a myll ;" afterwards, in another statement, adding the words, " in any standinge water, or quike springe, which maie alsoe be converted to sundrie other uses comodious for aJI estates, which have hetherto byn supposed to be unpractyzable." See " Science in England," illustrated in letters from the reign of Queen Elizabeth to Charles the Second, edited by J. O. HaUiweU, F.R.S., &c., 8vo, 1841, pp. 35-6. t See their decision against admitting and discussing papers on the subject, pp. 190-1, INTRODUCTOBY ESSAY. XIU the subject was treated rather favourably than otherwise ; and the " Annual Register '* and " Gentleman's Magazine" made known the invention of Orffyreus, which had acquired re- markable notoriety in Germany ; attributable perhaps to the large premium he required, and the patronage of a Prince of Hesse Cassel. To crown all, during the South Sea Bubble mania, the' prospectus was 'issued of a company " For a Wheel for Perpetual Motion."* 4. But it is to the present century we must look for abun- dant and various schemes. The ready means afforded for making such plans public, through the medium of cheap popular scientific journals and magazines, and likewise the facilities afforded for patenting inventions, have brought to light much curious matter. 5. Before proceeding further, it becomes requisite to premise in what sense the term Pebp:rtuum: Mobile, or Perpetual Motion, should be taken ; that is, in its mechanical applica- tion, which is the only one we have to consider. The term must unquestionably be used in a modified, and not in its absolute literal sense ; being thus accepted as one early, yet wrongfully, though popularly applied, it distinguishes inven- tions intended to be operated through the medium of their own peculiarly-constructed internal arrangements, and seems afterwards, though improperly, to have been extended to in-- genious automata, worked by external agents, as magnetism, &c. ; which latter we reject entirely. It is manifest that the term neither does, nor ever can, strictly apply to any product of human intelligence. In this limited sense it means any machine which (independent of wear) would not run out. A ball always rolling, a fiuid always flowing, a wheel always turning — each operating by gravity alone — would exactly fulfil the required condition. But not so machinery moved by any external commumcated power, as the tides, wind, electricity, temperature, or like agencies. We may even go * See Anderson's History of Commerce. XIV INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. the length to assert that, in this strict mechanical sense, even the planetary system offers no exhibition of perpetual motion in the several planets themselves, although each is in per- petual movement. The distinction lies here : — the motions of the earth, for example, are referable to other causes than its own structural arrangement, internal or external. By Perpetual Motion, then, is simply to be understood — a self- sustained continuous mechanical motive power ; and which we shall now next proceed to consider. 6. A German metaphysician declared his preference to truth being hid, even had he the choice of its being other- wise, from the exquisite gratification which the search after it affords the true philosopher. The long-hidden truth respecting Perpetual Motion has exercised the mental energies of men of the highest intellect, and has entangled in its toils men of the humblest attainments. Much as is known respecting what has been done in this investigation, how much remains untold ! In action, if not in words, those who seek for this perpetuum mobile, much as they desire to find it, take no small pleasure in the endless contrivances it re- quires and suggests. The inquiry always presents itself to the mind as exceedingly simple and easy ; particularly to the iminitiated. The early life-history of inventors continually informs us of the youthful genius fascinated with the pleas- ing prospect of cutting the Gordian knot. The early career of Sir Richard Arkwright was marked by his acquaintance with the clockmaker Kay, who made the first model of his memorable cotton-spinning machine, through his applying to him to construct a perpetual motion model. And it is really remarkable tq find thj^t inventors are not wanting who, although not' possessed of any assured proof of its pos- sibility, nay, in direct opposition to every announcement of its impracticability, and as if in contempt of every censure heaped on the pursuit, are still to be found rushing into this hazardous arena. It has been condemned as a chimera, an is^nis fatuus, an absurdity ; and yet adventurers are nothing INTBODUCTOKY ESSAY. XT daunted. Surely this opens to us a curious phase of the human mind, that sets at nought the dicta of mechanics and mathematics, and the admitted laws of nature. 7. Any machine would deserve the distinctive character of being a perpetual motion, that acquired its rotation, sup- posing it to be a wheel, from a property consequent on the arrangement of its internal parts, always compelling one side to become heavier than the other; such motion being no other than the ability in a machine to generate' and maintain its own power of movement. 8. The attempts to solve this problem would sefeni, so far, only to have proved it to be thoroughly paradoxical. The • inventions I'esulting from it during the last three centuries baffle any attempt at classification developing progressive improvement. It would almost seem as if each inventor had acted independent of his predecessors ; and, therefore, frequently re-inventing, as new, some exploded fallacy. These retrograde operations, and strange resuscitations, have led to unmitigated censure, and a sweeping charge of igno- rance, imbecility, and folly. No doubt many instances exist especially deserving the severest treatment ; but unsparing censure loses half its causticity, and it shows a weak cause, or weaker advocacy, to condenm: all parties alike as deficient both in learning and common sense. It has long been, and so remains to this day, an unsettled question, whether Per- petual Motion is, or is not, possible. To name no other, it is evident, from their writings, that Bishojy Wilkins, Gravesande, Bernoulli, Leupold, Nicholson, and many eminent mathema- ticians, have favoured the belief in the possibility of Perpetual Motion, although admitting difficulties in the way of its dis- covery.* Against it, we find de la Hire, Parent, Papin, Desa- guliers, and the great majority of scientific men of all classes ♦ A recent Gennan writer says : — " The discovery of such a motion is difficult, but not impossible j as Kastner, Laagsdorf, and other cele- brated mathematicians, have frequently shown. (See pa^e 405.) XVI IKTBODUCTOBT ESSAY. and countries. It is evident, therefore, that even mathema- ticians are not agreed. But to the further consideration of this point we shall presently return. 9. The inventive faculty in most men in early life, and in others during their lives, according to the power and bent of their genius, information, and position in life, takes an essentially romantic turn, unless curbed by experience or necessity. This is no evil omen in youth, but is scarcely excusable at a riper age. Invention should not be always soaring among clouds, and finding delight only in mysticism. A fervid imagination forbids the seeing of impossibilities, even when opposed by stern realities. The theoretical or the practical engineer, unhappily led away by this substitution of ' prolific fancies in place of sound judgment, is the last person to be convinced by the most obvious obstacles to success, in the fidfilment of his ■ views and statements. To him, every opponent is the victim of little-mindedness, prejudice, and envy* To himself, all his opinions stand for realizable objects. We cannot avoid having some, though a very chastened, sympathy with such enthusiastic projectors, who would seem to pride themselves on the strongly-expressed notion that " genius to madness is near allied.*' It is, un- questionably, in such cases, a constitutional weakness, ill fitting its possessor for that calm, cool, reflective character which alone commands confidence and ensures respect. The class of men who form the largest body of inventors are better practical than theoretical mechanicians ; to them the refine- ments of geometers are truly a fountain sealed, and it would perhaps be difficult to offer propositions and definitions level to their general comprehension ; but the attempt is worthy of the most gifted mind. If they do not always see the bearing and consequence of one being equal to one, a pound to a pound, the like to the like, and other profound expressions, of this at least they may rest pretty well satisfied — that the easier the problem of self-motive power appears to them, just in a reverse ratio is it the more difficult ; — and that just INTBODUCTORY ESSAY. XVll in proportion as they see two or any greater number of eqiially feasible constructions, they may with certainty take them as representing, not Perpetual Motion, but the squares of distance they are by consequence from the goal of their ambition. 10. The history of the search for Perpetual Motion does not afford a single instance of ascertained success; all that wears any appearance of probability remains secret, and, like other secrets, cannot be defended in any satis- factory way against the opinions of the sceptical, who have in their favour, in this instance, an appeal to learned authorities against the principle of all such machines, and the total want of operativeness in all known prac- tical results. Published statements afford sorry examples of talents and ingenuity strangely misapplied. Some, but very few, are slightly redeemed from contempt by a glimpse of novelty. Of genius all are deficient, and the reproductions of known fallacies shows a remarkable ignorance of first principles on one side, and of the most ordinary sources of information On the other. One of the grossest fallacies of the mind is that of taking for granted that ideas of mecha- nical constructions, apparently the result of accident, must of necessity be quite original. The history of all invention fairly leads to the conclusion that, were all that is known to be swept from the face of the earth, the whole would be re- invented in coming ages. The most doubtful " originality" is that which any inventor attributes to his ignorance of all previous plans, coupled with an isolated position in life. It may be granted that the desire of secrecy often renders in- vestigation difficult, and, from some remarkable feeling of this nature, most inventors of supposed perpetual motion machines, believing themselves possessors of this notable power, make it a matter of profound secrecy. 11. It is difficult to surmise whether the expectancy of honour or hope of high reward has most contributed to pro- mote investigations of this character, and led to the folly of XVlll INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. making a great secret of the presumed discovery. Each in its turn has indubitably had its influence. They who sought fame have been most miserably disappointed ; and as to wealth, who has ever seen a return for his first outlay ? At one period, the large premiums of from £10 to £20,000, offered by Government for means to discover the longitude at sea, stimulated many ; and when rescinded, the problem lost nothing of its interest with many really ingenious individuals ; for at that period there was a real difficulty for the inventive to know what to invent, to satisfy their desire of producing novel mechanical contrivances. The evils of secrecy are Numerous. The inventor is left to believe in a bubble ; the public are deluded, and impostors reap the only harvest, by imposing on the credulity of all lovers of the wonderful — of which a secret will generally be accepted as one ; while the de- ceived are mostly prompted by the hope of making a dis- covery. And who can deny the pleasure there is in solving a secret ? 12. An object of such long-continued, inveterate, and indus- trious inquiry might at least be supposed to be attainable, and when attained to be of superlative value. Reserving the first inquiry for further observation, we will only presume its J)ossibility admitted, and direct attention to the only probably feorrect estimate of its intrinsic value. It has been attempted to effect Perpetual Motion by water, mercury, sand, levers, inclined planes, Archimedean screws, Barker's mills, water- wheels, single wheels, drum wheels, multiplied wheels, and other mechanical means. One might almost desire to know what has not been put on its trial to make wheel-work con- tinually turn itself. A thousand failures do not prove the thing impossible, because a thousand persons may have taken a wrong direction. But it proves this, that something, how- ever trifling, is wanting ; so small, it may be, perhaps, that no one has hitherto taken the trouble to look for it ! Suppose it to be something to act as a lubricator; or something as a detent, at a particular point. Does not this at once suggest INTBODXrCTOKY ESSAY. X13C the weakness and feebleness of such a machine for any utili- tarian purpose ? It must be plain that it would, at best, be little more than an exquisitely curious toy. 13. Many persons may have been dra^vn into this amusing pursuit imder the influence of vague impressions that self- motive ppwer was but a lost invention. The more abstruse the inquiry, the more some minds are gratified in probing the subtleties which mystery abundantly affords. Hence Judicial Astrology, the Philosopher's Stone, the Quadrature of the Circle, the Multiplication of the Cube, the Elixir Vitae — ^a panacea for all diseases — have each been sources of in- tense study. The metaphysical Cowley says, in " The Adept," that, tbough he — his great secret miss, For neither it in art or nature is, Yet things worth while his toils he gains; And does his charge and labour pay With good unsought experiments by the way. The Baconian Philosophy has so far discoui-aged as to have ^spelled nearly all these chimeras. Only for its influence, dreams of philosophy would have increased, rather than, as they have done, fallen into decay. 14. We will not, however, close here, but endeavour to show, from comparatively recent personal experience, the working effects of taking up the study of Perpetual Motion as a serious employment — some men experimenting for years, others for the best part of a lifetime. All studies of a mental kind may be, and continually are being, carried to excess. It has been so in Painting, in Statuary, in Music, in Literature, and in all the Learned Professions. The " pursuit of Knowledge under difficulties" has driven many to despair ; and the irri- tability, anxieties, and distresses of " Genius " imder every phase, have been admirably depicted by D'Israeli. The "Martyrs of Science" have been many — the victims to the pursuit of Perpetual Motion not a few. If Hartmann of Leipsic hanged himself from despair at his vainly-spent life XX INTBODUCTOKY ESSAY. in prosecuting this hopeless attempt, could not an equalty sad tale be related of many a Poet and Artist ? But to pro- ceed, we will first give a series of short narratives relating to modem instances of devotion to this search after a self- motive power* ; followed by extracts from several years' cor- respondence.— First, of personal narratives : — I. A tall old Welshman, a custom-house officer, imagined he had found out Perpetual Motion by some peculiar applica- tion of sand from the sea shore. He went to London with the machine he had invented, and applied to the Board of Longitude, but without receiving any encouragement. He used to say that it was while listening to a sermon at St. James's Church, Liverpool, from a particular text (which he never named) that he had the first idea of the machine he had invented. II. A watchmaker showed his customers the model of a wheel and weights in his shop, belonging to a German. It had employed a man three months cleaning, and had been left on his hands for ten years, therefore he supposed the Qerman would never redeem it, although he had travelled with the machine all over Europe. He had some means of making it work ; but walking across the room, or a passing cart in the street, would suffice to jostle and stop the works. The same watchmaker had been presented by some other party with a pamphlet entitled ** Perpetual Motion: ex- plained as it is discovered in nature. By Peter Brentano. Gloucester : Printed by William Verrinder, 24, Southgate Street, 1830." 27 pages. It is arranged under these heads : — Page 3. " Perpetual Motion, or, self-possessing power to move in space void of air caused by a method of forcing the '*' Since these narratives were arranged, the author has been informed, on unquestionable authority, that Bamsden, celebrated for his dividing machine, used frequently to metttion the fact of the late Duke of Gordon, at Aberdeen, being deeply and expensively engaged in carrying out experiments for obtaining Perpetual Motion. IKTBOBUCTOBr £SSAT«. XXI vatet Tdiich runs out of a tube, back into^ tfie same tube again, the power for forcing back the^ water gained by levers.'* This is followed by* two engravings, one representing an "Iron Case." Page 11. ^'Formation of a Vacuum £or the Moving Machine.'* Page 12. " lUustrations.** Page 14. " Creation of Time." [Genesis^ chap; 1, verses 1, 2, 3, 4, 6.} Page 20. '* The Formation of Time." [Genesis, verses 6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 16, 17, IB.] Page 24. Job, chapv 38, verses 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14. III. Mr. S had a curious Perpetual Motion contrivancev constructed of double cones, made with mathematical pre- cisicm. His first trial of it was before his wife, and shut up- in his room, where all it wanted wa» his continued presence and assistance ! rV. Mr. E— — , a very ingenious workman, devoted all his time to mechanical pmrsuits in relation to Perpetual Motion, reducing himself to a state of beggary through his fondness for his favourite pursuit. He was always in high spirits, peaking confidently of his success being near and certain ; yet, to the last, one thing was wanting, the very thing first sought. V. Mr. P— — followed the pursuit of Perpetual Motion above twelve years, until at last his mind became affected. Later in life he preferred being silent on the subject. He used to say his notions of it were very simple, so much so, that wefe he only a practical mechanic he should not doubt of success, but that to place his plans in the hands of work- men "Would cmly expose his inventions to his disaidvantage. He contrived a quantity of apparatus principally on a large scale, with different kinds of wheels, some operated by water, and aU intended to be kept constantly overbalancing. VI. Mr. E stateathat Mr. Charles, of Bala (Wales), in XXU INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. his Dictionary of the Bible, under the article "Mills,** relates of mills in Wales which worked without wind or water, or the aid of man, after being once set in motion. This, Mr. E says truly, is very like Perpetual Motion. Mr. Charles, he proceeds, further states that, about the year 1500, William Salisbury (first translator of the Bible into Welsh) had a mill of this description. He also gives an account of a wheel and millstone found near Corwen, sup- posed to have belonged to such a mill. The wheel was all of wood, except one qtmrter ; the axle was the thickness of a man's thigh, and the millstone three feet diameter, having a piece of metal attached to its edge, which had probably been a loadstone ! Mr. E says he has tried many plans for Perpetual Motion, all of which have failed ; he has thought of a hundred schemes or more, but still he thinks he knowsr of one plan superior to all hitherto tried. VII. In Manchester, a man forty years of age, who had made his money as a common moulder in a foundry, ex- pended the sum of three hundred pounds in models of wheels having falling arms, arranged with the intention of always preponderating on one side, made for him by a watchmaker. Vm. Mr. B of London, philosophical instrument maker, entered into an engagement with a gentleman, who bound him on oath to keep the secret of his plans in working out his scheme for Perpetual Motion, under a penalty of one thousand pounds. His employer, a rich gentleman, expended above two thousand, and himself one thousand pounds in fruitless efforts. Mr. B when speaking of their career, would take up a scrap of paper, and tearing off a very small portion, exclaim — " We got it — all but that/* throwing the paper scrap on the table. IX. Mr. R was made a confidant by a friend of his, who so firmly believed himself possessed of a veritable self- moving and most powerful machine, that he consulted Mr. R on a means of stopping it, after its being once set in motion ! INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. XXUl X. A mechanic, a model maker, had a neat brass model of a timepiece, in which were two steel balls A and B ; — B to fall into a semicircular gallery C, and be carried to the end D of a straight trough D E ; while A in its turn rolls to E, and 80 on continuously ; only the gallery C not being screwed in its place, we are desired to take the will for the deed, imtil twenty shillings be raised to complete this part of the work ! XI. Mr. F professes to have an unfailing Perpetual Motion, obtained by making the vertical pressure of a column of water work a four-feet wheel, which by a fall of eight feet will enable him, with a one-foot crank, to raise water to a pump to supply the cistern above, and, after allowing for friction, leave a surplus of above one-third of the power employed. He has, he says, studied Perpetual Motion for twenty years ; and has several plans, but this he estimates to be worth all the rest. His brother, who has followed the same pursuit, has a room set round with machines, none of which ever went. His nearest approach to success was in a method acting by the percussion of balls, one after another, as a wheel revolved ; on which, and other plans, he has expended upwards of £1500, Mr. F knows a gentleman who has been thirty years engaged on this subject, and is pecuniarily assisted by a person of good means. XII. In a conversation with Mr. — — , he stated that a friend of his, although he was a Professor of Mathematics in one of our Colleges, had invented a mode of propelling vessels, which was only what would be called a Perpetual Motion ; yet he was for years infatuated with his plan, before he could satisfy himself that it was preposterous to expect it to operate as a propulsive power. XIII. Mr. , a dissenting minister, then resident in the North of England, in conversations with his nephew, about the year 1835, mentioned his having been 14 years seeking to discover Perpetual Motion, in which he at last succeeded, having had a wheel with rolling balls in motion several days; after which he destroyed it to avoid discovery, retaining only XXIV WTTEODUCTOBY ESSAY, his drawings. He liad castings made, which he could finish in a lathe himseif, with all other requisite work for his in- dention. He was a good linguist and mathematician, and ■died at forty years of age ; his relative considered that he must have expended at least ^1500 in experiments. His brother, also a minister, could not be persuaded, by drawings, «f the possibility of this continuous movement, but still he sent an account of his brother's invention to a local publica- tion, about 1835-6. And secondly, the following extracts from correspondence are offered in further corroboration of the opinions and feel- ings of inventors once entangled in the meshes of this mechanical dilemma l-^ XIV. Mr, P writes from Slough, 6th Nov., 1847:— ** I have discovered a system by which Power to any extent may be procured by a self-acting piece of machinery. My object is not the amount of money, but to meet with a party who possesses sufficient knowledge and influence to procure and protect a patent." XV. Mr. H — — , Islington, 28th July, 1848, says :— ** Having matured the plan of a mechanical improvement which I am persuaded will be highly profitable to any capi- talist who will join with me in taking out a patent and ap- plying the invention to practical use, I beg leave to certify the same to you. When I state that I have submitted a drawing and description to the scrutiny of Lord G — — and Mr. V .■ , and that they have both borne practical testimony of their favourable opinion by presenting me with a handsome contribution, I trust you will not allow any preconceived opinion of the impossibility of Perpetual Motion to operate to my prejudice, when I announce that such is the object of my invention.** XVI. Mr. H , of Weymouth, 12th Feb., 1849, com- municates about *' a continuous revolution machine, which overcomes gravity," and "has friction wheels to stop it!" INTKODUCTOBY ESSAY. XXT XVII. Mr. H , Hinckley, 2l8t Jan., 1850, writes :— *' Sir, — ^As I am confident of the machine going, but am in want of money, which stops its progress, I am sure from £4 to £6 will set it a-going." He had previously written : — " Sir, — ^We have always imderstood that there was a free patent and a premium for any one that discovered the Per- petual Motion." XVIII. Mr.' R , Liverpool, 26th Nov., 1850, states :— " I have invented a machine to give motion to any kind of machinery. Its power is not derived from any changeable or expensive element ; in short, it is a Perpetual Motion, It may be applied to any stationary machinery, but not to ships and carriages. 1 have not made a practical experiment of it, but its truth is clear and simple.* What I expect to have for it will be £500 sterling." XIX. Mr. K , PentonvHle, 20th Dec, 1850, cor- responds about two inventions : — " No. 1. Maintaining power by machinery, to gain any power that may be required, to any extent; and No. 2. A maintaining water power from a well, or still tank, thereby to get a perpetual water power." XX. Mr. M , Liskeard, 10th May, 1852, writes about his "new motive power," of which he states : — " The advan- tages are its cheapness and simplicity j not costing more than about £1. per horse power, and its perpetuity of motion, for it will start itself, and will go for ever without requiring any attendance, except for oiling, repairs, &c. As it is not patented, of course I would not describe it further than to say, it is worked by an entirely new principle which I have discovered." In another letter he says : — " The motive force is the buoyant power of water, a force which costs nothing, and is easily obtained." XXI. Mr. H , Kent, 23rd Aug., 1852, writes in a strain which excites our interest and sympathy : — " I have com- ♦ It turned out to be an endless band or chain carrying buckets to fill an upper dstem, from which it was to be worked. XXVI INTRODUCTOBY ESSAY. pleted (he says) a most valuable invention to give true time at sea ; it supersedes the use of the chronometer, has no spring, and never requires to be wound up, being self-acting. It acts by the gravity of mercury, and as gravity is not affected by temperature, when set to Greenwich mean time continues to show that time in every climate or part of the world. It is an invention of the most simple kind, truly mathematical in its mechanical construction, both in practice and theory. It solves the problem of Negative Attraction ^ which is this : — ^A raises B, acting on a wheel C ; and B raises A to its former position, continuing the motion of the toothed wheel C, negativing the attraction of the gravity of A» merely by the change in the position of B, which is mercury, whose gravity shifts in the tube that contains it ; and this change of position, from left to right, and vice versa, constitutes a self-acting balance compensating lever, and that acts on an equally simple and compensating escapement, which is effected by the force of A and B, ultimately ; with these, and four wheels, the machine is a complete chrono- meter, giving quarter second time. It can be varied in size and weight, and can be equally applied for a church clock or a watch. This invention has cost me thirty years' study and experience, and now that I have obtained the result required mathematically, I am aware of its value in a double sense ; the English patent alone is worth £60,000 to the trade of Horlogery generally, and at the same time from neglecting every other thing to attain this object, I am in want of means to render me so far independent of the trade as to be able to demand the above sum, or carry out my principle by absorb- ing the sale of self-acting chronometer watches and clocks." XXII. Mr. S writes from Creetown, Scotland, 12th June, 1855 : — ^" I have a small machine I think might come \o be of some use to the public ; it is a small engine, the same nearly as a steam-engine, which could work itself, without either steam or anything to assist it. It would require no assistance after it commenced, except oiling. I INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. XXVU think I might have something for it, as it would save every cost after put up. It would require no winding up or any- thing. I heard that Government had a reward out for to try and find out something that could work itself. I think it would be of great use ; it could drive mills or the like itself." XXIII. An Irish correspondent (Mr. G — — ) writes from the county of Donegal, dated Moville, 25th Sept., 1855 : — •* After long and painful study of mechanical power, I have at present arrived at my purpose of a power that will drive the British Fleet, at no expense, and at speed never before thought ofi I have been directed by some scientific gentle- men to bring the matter before you." On the 5th Oct. he again wrote: — " I received your most instructive letter, and I trust it (the invention) will not turn out like the mouse and the mountain. To give you some idea of this great power, it is of very simple construction. There is but one wheel in the work, and the power can be raised to any imaginable height ; this power turns the wheel, and the wheel turns the crank, and it will be found that no such simple, useful, and practicable invention has ever come under your notice. It is equally applicable to propel by either sea or land ; either the largest ship or the simplest mill or loom can be driven by it, with the same ease ; and the power can be raised in proportion to the necessity for it. It is taken from the clock, the mill, and the loom combined together. I have not the least doubt of the success of my invention. I have given it many trials, and prod\iced very satisfactory results, but unfortimately I am not in a position, for want of capital, to carry out this great invention ; it may fall bac^ another century, if something does not arise to my aid. I have spent a great deal of money on this matter.'* XXIV. Mr. P , a gentleman of a very igenious turn of mind, writing from Cheshire, 29th Jan., 1856, says : — " I have not been brought up a mechanist in any shape, but in- vention and ingenuity are natural to all our family. Like many other fools, I spent about nine months in trying to dis- XXViii INTBODUCTOBY ESSA.T. cover perpetual motioii. Now, Sir Walter Scott tells us such a thing can never be done, but were he here I could convince him to the contrary, for I discovered it in my first attempt, which was by attraction onwards on a level plane, and then by ever-counterbalancing gravitation backwards down an inclined plane. I secondly tried it on by leverage; I worked at it about six months, levers, wheels, cranks, and everything else innumerable, and the further I went the nearer I got to perpetual stand-still. In my third attempt I considered that in Hydrostatics the same thing that finds its centre of gravitation upwards, in Pneumatics finds its centre of gravity downwards ; for instance, drop a piece of wood, it falls; place that same piece under water, it rises ; so here, by a very simple contrivance, I got up and down perpetual motion to full perfection, but they all amount to nothing ; I cast them aside as mere playthings, for all the power they can ever give is taken up in moving themselves." XXV. Mr. A , writing from Ireland, dated Bally- watter, 20th Feb., 1856, speaks of a "motive power" he has discovered, of which he states : — " It will prove safe, speedy and economical, though of astonishing power ; it will be uniform and steady in operation, and at the highest velocity perfectly within the control of one man, I may say boy. When properly adjusted, it may also for hours, indeed for days, be left to its own discretion ; especially if by mechan- ism oil be kept to its very few bearings. The power is a combination of weight, as the first mover, with the power of the lever, to which is added velocity as the result of both, and which varies with the amoimt of both." XXVI. Mr. B , of Bermondsey, 28th July, 1857, says: — ii Sir, — ^I have (through curious circumstances) discovered * perpetual motion.' It will be a wonderful engine, as it can be constructed to keep in motion (without the least assistance of anybody) everlastingly. I have not the means of carrying it on by myself, therefore I want somebody with money to assist me in doing so." INTBODUCTO»y ESSAY. XXIX XXVII. Another Mr. B , WheyhiU, Andover, Hants, 15th Oct., 1857, writes ;— " Sir, — I beg permission to inform you that I am in a position to prove positively that motive power to any -amount for propelling all kinds of machinery may be maintained without any cost whatever, save the wearing of the machinery by friction. This invaluable invention supersedes the steam-engine, but I cannot proceed to a public development without capital." XXVIII. The last communication that will be here noticed was made by enclosing a printed circular, giving notice that — "Speedily will be published, dedicated to the British people, a Treatise on the discovery and application of a Continuous, Increasing, and Self-generating Motive Power, whereby the agency of steam is superseded in mechanical enterprises. By John Henry Vries, Esq., M.D." In this work the prospectus states : — " The Inventor enters into details relative to the Pneumatic Engine, of whose utility, as applied to practical purposes, Dr. V. is the discoverer.* Oeneral remarks follow (it adds), wherein the labours of Watt, Erichsen, Sir Humphrey Davy, and others, are dwelt «pon, &c., &c." Only a limited number of copies are pro- mised, at the price of 50s. each, 15. It is needless to extend personal narrative or correspon- dence as indicative of the general diffusion of a desire to discover the solution of the problem of a perpetuum mobile,* in each instance adduced, however, will be found charac- teristic traits of the progress, hopes, disappointments, and untiring zeal that distinguishes the various inventors of this 4Drder. Those who read for the first time these statements of devotedness to what seems little ^better than laborious idle- aess ; and peruse the collected examples of published plans # • Dr. J. R Vries, in January, 1853, had granted him provisional protection for six months, for " tnprovements in obtaining Motive tower," but not having been proceeded with, has become void- He employed electricity, the gases from water, a generator, and a rotatory engine. XXX INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. for Perpetual Motion; and find that men have been so enamoured with these schemes that for three centuries they have not only continued patenting abortive efforts to main- tain self-motive power, but rather increase than diminish in avidity to perpetuate their errors, will admit that it becomes matter for serious inquiry, Have Mathematicians and Mecha- nicians exhausted their powers of demonstration ? Who is amenable for the evil which somewhere or other undoubtedly does exist to a lamentable extent ; so much so, indeed, as to be a reflection on the intelligence of the present age of boasted enlightenment ? We shall proceed to examine in order, the several facts connected with this remarkable subject, according to the various aspects in which it is generally viewed. 16. Perpetual Motion either is, or is not, attainable. We do not pretend to decide the question, but merely to show that much may be said on both sides. They who engage in experiments to discover Perpetual Motion, as well as they who undertake to disprove its possibility, equally find them- selves beset with difficulties. It proves a paradox to both. 17. It is accepted by most scientific men that Perpetual Motion is impossible, because no body can at the same time be heavier and lighter than itself. But may there not, after all, be exceptions to this law, as in some other laws, stated in equally general terms? Thus, although water is said always to find its level, and heavy bodies to fall lowest, — yet> no one disbelieves in capillary attraction, or that the heavy fluid, carbonic acid gas, rises to a moimtain's height. 18. The eminent French mathematician and astronomer Philip de la Hire, bom in 1640, died in I7I8. At the age of about 38 years he offered a demonstration on the impos. sibility of Perpetual Motion,* which it^would seem has never been improved on for 182 years ; and although the fact of its existence has been repeated by numerous >vriters, it never * See page 102, and Appendix D. INTEODUCTORT ESSAY. XXXI appears to have occurred to any to reproduce it ; bis name, but not bis reasoning, bas been reiterated during tbe above period as sufficient to warn all projectors from any furtber pursuit of their favourite schemes. To say the least, such indifference is indefensible. Authorities are not wanting who employ bis reasoning, but silence on this fact left the me- chanic to suppose that something even still more conclusive against him lay hid in the closets of the learned. The wonder with many was, what M. de la Hire could have said so de- cisive and iiifallible. We now have his reasons before us ; and we learn that they leave Gravesande, Bernoulli, and many eminent Continental mathematicians in doubt whether Perpetual Motion is impossible, and consequently whether M. de la Hire may not have offered too sweeping a denuncia- tion against its possibility. The demonstration, intended to apply generally, does actually but take into consideration, as data, schemes previously known to be fallacious ; therefore, such demonstration, however clearly unfavourable to one class of schemes, may not strictly apply to an entirely dif- ferent order of inventions. As late as Nicholson (1800), we find this opinion supported. We may remark, for instance, that every demonstration takes for granted the free, unre- strained action of gravity. But suppose a certain arrange- ment could be introduced to frustrate this free action of a rolling or falling body, at some desired point, its liberation to be followed by a like suspension, and so" on; such a modifi- cation would be beyond th^ range of the existing mathe- matical reasoning, which had never contemplated the element now supposed practicable. These examples may be paralleled by supposing theorems and problems relating to the action of a cbiled spring, which would satisfy every one in regard to certain facts, but demonstrate nothing as to results attending the added regulating effect of a pendulum, assuming that to represent an unknown element, the something wanted, and alike sought in either case. Surely the greater the danger and folly of following Perpetual Motion, from believing it XXltU INTBODUCTOBY ESSAY. attainable, the greater is the necessity for reducing- the qnes* tion to its true conditions, and satisfactorily settling the inquiry. An inventor desires to ascertain, not one, but all the difficulties that he may expect will frustrate lus attaining his object. Knowing the real difficulty is next to being half- way to the attainment of his search. Here it is, however, that Mathematics ceases to assist him. It predicts nothing ; it makes no discovery in mechanical invention. 19. Taking their tone from the strongly-expressed objec- tions raised, and clearly and ably defined and demonstrated by Mathematicians, by Natural Philosophers, and Scientific Bodies, the public voice has, for more than a hundred years, been directed against Perpetual Motion as a dream, a delu- sion, a chimera, an ignis fatuus. It is likened to Alchemy and to the Squaring of the Circle. Censure is of the easiest possible acquirement. Few are aware how difficult it is to steer a medium course, and that, while there is no wisdom shown in abuse, it actually requires some skill, some informa- tion, and not a little practice, to praise or censure discrimi- nately. It is not by displaying a nervous irritability that shrinks from all explanation, other than reiterated stale plati- tudes, that minds above mediocrity are to be satisfied on scientific matters- Why should a Perpetual Motion inven- tion be pursued, more than other, timidly and secretly? More, perhaps, for one reason than any other ; because per- sons who profier friendly advice go so far out of their way, to cover their own ignorance of the matter, by offering false, and consequently offensive rather than convincing arguments. 20. Incessant failure does not, of itself, offer sufficient argument against the possibility of Perpetual Motion. The history of all science affords abundant evidence of this fact. Such opponents affect to despise Alchemy, the precursor of Chemistry; false enough in itself, and yet where would Chemistry have been at this day had Alchemy been unknown? Necessity often, but more frequently accident, led to the dis- INTBODUCTOBT ESSAY. XXXUl covery of many early inyentions. In modem times, most discoveries are made solely by a train of scientific reasoning. 21. Another frequent but false argument is the oflTering of disparaging opinions drawn from absurd contrasts; as if failure in one invention or pursuit afforded cogent reasons against the possibility of some other diametrically opposite invention or pursuit* This favourite course of weak oppo- nents, is too ridiculous an estimate of the proper method of settling such disputed points, to require farther comment. 22. Inutility is the presumed consequence of an impossible experiment, and no one can deny the fact. But on what ground is the experiment itself assumed to be impossible? It does not show very good common sense to argue without a sensible reason. What was the use of rubbing a small piece of amber ?— or noticing the quivering of a dead frog's legs, or the action of copper and silver laid on the tongue ? In a word, of what use is the electric telegraph ? 23. But the most invidious distinction and the weakest argument adopted by well-meaning persons is, that the pursuit leads to " wasting time and fortune.*' We have no wish to uphold improvidence, but let us ask, what pursuit in life is ensured against this species of loss ? That it is not peculiar to making geometrical drawings and innocently motionless wheels we feel well assured ; nay, we doubt whether do- mestic life, with its many frivolous amusements and accom- plishments, is always equally thrifty in expenditure, with these well-abused Inventors. If we admit our opinions to be swayed by such representations, how much have the inventors of Rotatory Engines, Screw Propellers, and a thousand other schemes, to answer for on the score of vast unproductive ex- penditure ! 24. Lastly, — It is a singular want of liberality to impeach the understtinding of any one who, for any reason whatever, attempts the discovery of Perpetual Motion. It is not too much to say, that there is scarcely any ingenious youthful engineer or machinist who has not more or less given hi» XXXIV INTRODUCTOEY ESSAY. mind to solving the problem. Infatuation is not confined to the pursuit of Perpetual Motion ; and without attempting or intending the least apology for spending a lifetime or fortune, as a worthy employment of the one or the other, on a matter of such apparently second-rate value, yet, what is unjust in relation to arts and sciences generally, for the acts of a few of their weaker followers, is equally unjust in the present instance, which charges on thousands the foibles of a few eccentric individuals — a class of enthusiasts from which, un- happily, no pursuit and no walk in life is entirely free. 25. Opposition in the right direction might effect much good. A mathematician of an inventive turn of mind would, in en- deavouring to prove the impossibility of Perpetual Motion, be in a fair way to discovery (if within mortal reach), as com- pared to the cleverest mechanic, seeing nothing before him but its ready achievement. The first would seek difficulties and ponder them ; the other would see a machine in motion even before it was made ; and we all know the danger of over confidence. Theoretically, Perpetual Motion may be ac- tually neither impossible nor absurd ; not so, however, the many pretended self-motive machines to which precipitation has given rise, all abundantly absiird. If the theory be sound, then in practice, have all results to which it has led been most unfortunate; whether considered in reference to in- ventors or to opponents. 26. We have, in this tantalizing pursuit, only found an in- genious lock, for which we want now to find a key. The key is all that is wanting. Many set but on the search for it, declaring its discovery to be of very easy attainment ; ex- perience has taught some humility, but posterity follows in their footsteps. Many an ardent student feels assured he has all but found it — such a mere trifle wanting. A few declare they know exactly where it is, and are. providing in- struments for its recovery. Several hasty aspirants have published their good fortime, to avoid piracy. Two foimd it, but alas! it has followed them to their graves; so rKTKODirCTORY ESSAY. XXXV that, after all this boastful parade, the key is not yet forth- coming. 27. It is sufficient stimulus to the human mind, in entering upon any great undertaking, to beliere in its possibility. What has been done by one may be done by another ; so all reasonably argue. Now no doubt, what has tended more than anything else to keep alive the pursuit of Perpetual Motion, is^ aB idea of its being merely a lost invention, and, therefore, ttndoubtedly possible. The scientific sage, however, views all these schemes alike as fallacies and absurdities ; he can only see in thent Nature opposed to herself, which is quite un- tenable. 28. Implicit credulity. Ho less thatl unlimited scepticism it, has been well observed, evidences mental imbecility. The mul- titude adopt the popular opinion ; and the common belief of scientific meii, and through them scientific treatises, being i^ainst the possibility of Perpetual Motion, it is self-evident which is the popular side. And there is little in the "Whole arcana of scientific knowledge to warrant any strikingly opposite view. Half a dbzeii scientific authorities ranged against some hundreds is not a very encouraging spectacle. And such is a true picture of the case. 5S9. Even Science is fallible ; but Mechanics is not a science open to the discovery of new laws, as in Chemistry. If we seek for argument in favour of the possibility of Perpetual Motion, we must believe it attainable on known laws, by means which in no way infringe them, and which themselves only offer additional proof of their stability. Of this there can be no reasonable doubt. And Mathematicians, too, are correct, as f ai* Jts they go, and where they stop. 30. The only appeal that can be made in apology for the pursuit of Perpetual Motion, is derivable from the results represented to have been obtained by the Marquis of Worcester in one instance, and by Orffyreus in another. All the circumstances relating to their singular inventions excite our curiosity, raise our scepticism, and induce us to pause ia b2 3IXXVI INTEODUCTOEY ESSAY. our decision. Let us first consider the inventors personally ;- and secondly their inventions and the circumstances attend- ing their exhibition. The two men were of very different character and position in life. The first noble by birth, of ancient lineage, loyal to the extent of sacrificing his property in support of the cause of Charles I., and evidencing by hi& prayers, his truly religious sentiments. About or before 1648 (as the King died 1649), he exhibited his wheel, or perpetual motion, in the Tower, before his Majesty, two Extraordinary Ambassadors, the Duke of Richmond, Duke Hamilton, most part of the Court, and Sir William Belford, Lord Lieutenant of the Tower. We have to consider the upright character of the Marquis, his having invented the steam-engine, his worthiness in all respects, and the circumstances here de- tailed, and then ask ourselves : — Little as Science favours any belief in such an invention, can we see any reasonable grounds for error in this great experiment, or believe that a person so distinguished, and so much to be admired in all other respects, could thus boldly and recklessly deceive him- self, his noble company, and the public : taking ten years or upwards to elaborate and record a gross falsehood } It seems incredible, and true respect for the Marquis's memory will go far to maintain doubts respecting the infallibility of all ma- thematical demonstrations adverse to the possibility of a self- motive power. Secondly : — 31. Orfiyreus was of humble origin, versatile talents, fickle, discontented, unsettled, irregular, and eccentric. He was ambitious, boasting, and the very man to raise up enemies. Between 1712 and 1718 he made and destroyed in succession four wheels or machines. He had learnt the art of clock-making, and several mechanical arts, and is supposed to have constructed or put these wheels together himself. He had a princely patron, who wished to obtain practical results from the invention for manufacturing and other opera- tions. A misunderstanding ensues ; and from that time to his death, in 1745 — at least twenty-eight years — the subject lies INTBODUCTOBY ESSAY. XXXvii dormant, and the invention dies with him. This last fact, coupled with the wheel having raised so great a weight as 70 lbs., makes a doubtful case still more doubtful ; and par- ticularly when, about the same time, Geiser imposed on the German public with a mere piece of clockwork, as a true perpetual motion. 32. Next, as to the inventions of these two remarkable characters : — The Marquis of Worcester's wheel was fourteen feet in diameter ; it was rotated by the action of forty 50 lb. weights — 2,000 lbs. — an enormous weight, requiring some very laborious operations of the carpenter, to erect a sufficiently strong framework. Its completion must have taken some time, and led to frequent visits from the noble inventor, as well as experiments to test its correct working, before offer- ing a practical demonstration before majesty. 33. Orffyreus's fourth or last wheel, at Hesse Cassel, was twelve feet in diameter, fourteen inches broad, made of light oak framing, and covered with oil-cloth. It would revolve either way, and this alone casts a shade of doubt on there being any deception in practice with it. But, strange to say, it had power enough to raise 70 lbs. to a considerable height. Its operations were seen and attested by so many, that these broad facts rest not alone on the inventor's authority. It was so ingeniously made, that M. Gravesande wrote to Sir Isaac Newton on the subject; and his letter and mathe- matical reasonings, in reference to the matter, appear in his works, edited by Professor Lalande, 1774. 34. The subject of Perpetual Motion opposes paradox to paradox. It is[J^ viewed both as being most simple and most difficult to find. The learned justify both its possibility and impossibility. Many mechanics believe it possible ; but of the only two accepted cases, both 'prove secrets. Its pur- suit always commences in confidence, only to end in doubt. It is as near being discovered now as it was three hundred years ago ; it was then tried, and is now beginning. Inventors XXXVm IV^&ODUCIO&Y £S»AT, stand at cro^s-roads, arguing as to which is the right path ; although there are only two roads, all are allured to take the wrong. Of two men supposed to have got into the right track, some think both were impostors, and many be- lieve that^ one at least deserved no better character. Most inventors reap honour, or at least commiseration ; here they are assailed with opprobrium. Such b the fate of this paradox of paradoxes. 35. It is a singular coincidence, that the^ only two accre- dited ix^ventions acting as evidences of Ferpetu^ Mption, one about 1649, the other 1712, should both have been treasured by their inventors, and yet be lost to posterity. Nothing satis-' factory can be advanced to justify secrecy under such circum-r stances. If due to accident, it may have been unavoidable ; if otherwise, it evinces a narrow selfish principle, to the sus- picion of which no man should lay himself open. Our belief in either is necessarily wavering. We view each with suspicion. Our confidence is shaken by known facts, and receives i^p confirmation from any results obtained by those who thus withhold &om us that evidence, the truth of which we ourselves might easily have tested. 3Q, Pisbelief in the possibility of Perpetual Motion per- vades all scientific classes of society, from whom the popular tone is taken. Yet among scientific men it is often disbelief with a mental reservation. The most incredulous mathema- tician would like to examine a so-called perpetual motion, while he would scout the idea of listening to any attempted proof of the multiplication of two equal amounts to produce an unequal one. It is in the very nature of mathematical fmd mechanical science to afibrd evidence that runs entirely counter to the idea of self-motive machinery. At the same time, as scientific attainments enlarge the understanding, they could have no effect to prejudice the mpst learned against receiving ocidar demonstration of any fact on this subject, however opposed to preconceived views. 37* There are only a limited number of methods which at INIRODUCXO&Y £SSAT. XXX IX the utmost can be expected, by the most sanguine, to offer a transient hope of success ; as wheels, with solid or fluid weights arranged somewhere around their peripheries. Such plans are capable of analysis ; but, if complicated, are all the more likely to prove abortiye in results. It is not to be ex* pected that the discovery, if to be made at all, will ever be the result of haphazard experiment. Ignorance has already done its work, and no one should now bave the presumption to attempt it, unprovided with a large fund of intelligence* and no small ability in experimental investigations generally ; remembering — A little knowledge is a dangerous thing : Prink deep, or taste not the Pierian spring : for, as sad experience truly shows—* ' There shallow draughts intoxicate the brain. 38. Appearances are every way so much opposed to offering any plausible hope of success, that all the wisest can say amoimts to no more than-— -It may be found ; or, it may never be found ; and, if found, the discoverer will probably establish the fame of others quite as much as, if not more than, his own. The insufficiency of the only supposed means of solving the problem — ^namely, by contriving a wheel so that all the weights on one side shall be con« stantly farther from the centre than the weights of the opposite side — has been attempted to be shown in a palpable manner by Desaguliers (see pages 79 and 89) ; but the author has invented a model appa« ratus of a more convincing cha* racter, being an actual wheel, as represented in the annexed diagram. We have here a wheel A B, having a number of spokes, each terminating, at or beyond the periphery, with a weight. It is represented with all the weights extended farthest on the right hand side. Xl IKTBODUCTOBY ESSAY, Now, on giving it a reverse revolution, all these weights will recede, and the weights on the left hand side be extended in like manner. Yet will nothing be gained ; in every posi- tion it will remain neutral. It consists of spokes, as A a and B b, each terminating at their ends A and B in compound levers, or lazy-tongs, while their opposite ends a and b pass through a hole drilled in the axle ; and so for each spoke, which must have a weight equal to the weight of the opposite end. Spokes thus made, when vertical on the top side of the wheel, are extended, while the opposite bottom spoke is depressed or shortened ; and so on with each.* 39. In conclusion, we would briefly observe that we think a careful perusal of all that has been gathered respecting Perpetual Motion clearly establishes that much remains to be done to prove th^ impossibility of practically solving this knotty problem ; and that a full demonstration of the diffi- culties that environ it is worthy of being attempted, even by the most exalted mathematicians. It is not requisite that they should descend to the level of the most ordinary minds, but leave it for others to reduce their elaborated reasoning on the subject to some generally comprehensible form. We fear the proposal partakes too much of the difficulty of proving a negative ; but still, as the attempt has been made by celebrated savans, and is generally considered insufficient ; and as data may have been wanting, which we conceive £v collection gf the chief known examples will supply; we re- commend the consideration of this matter to all geometers. In his Lives of the Poets, Dr. Johnson characterises the " Dunciad" as a work " of which the design is to ridicule such studies as are either hopeless or useless, as either pursue what is unattsiinablQj or what, if it be attained, is of no use." * The spokes can only slide up or down while verticaly in conse- quence of a ring or rim around them, placed to act as a shoulder against the axle, so long as the spokes are inwards, and noi in a vertical posi-. tion ; otherwise they would act at an angle of 45®. The shoulder of each spoke is small enough to slip freely through the hole in which it isHdes in the axle, when the same becomes vertical durmg rotation. Xli INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. It is difficult to surmise to what extent Pope thus benefitted literature ; but it is certain that all the minor *^ Dunciads," in lashing Perpetual Motion, have failed to rid Natural Philosophy of many misgivings respecting its feasibility ; and it is either impossible, and the Marquis of Worcester was him- self strangely deceived ; or it may be possible, and the noble inventor of the steam-engine remain Worthy of his high character as a truthful narrator of facts : quite incapable of misrepresenting, much less elaborately falsifying them. In a mathematical point of view. We think this subject is far from being exhausted ; and, after what has been advanced, may very properly be considered as claiming grave consideration. And that, scientifically examined, it is a mark of mere shallowness and querulousness to attempt the substitution of ridicule and satire for the more difficult, but consistent course of sound, close reason and argument, such as the wonted sobriety and severity of scientific criticism accords to its investigations generally* ♦^* The printing of this work had progressed too far to introduce, iit its proper place, the demonstration of Professor Airy in favour of Perpetual Motion being possible. It is taken from a copy of the Cam- bridge Philosophical Society's Transactions, in the British MuseUm, and forms the last article in the Addenda. PERPETUUM MOBILE; OB, SEAECH FOE SELF-MOTIYE POWEE. CHAPTER I. EARLY OPINIONS RESPECTING THE POSSIBILITY OP, AND PROJECTS FOR OBTAINING, PERPETUAL MOTION. John Wilkins, an ingenious and learned Bishop of Chester, was born near Daventry, in Northamptonshire, in 1614, and died 1672. He was well versed in mechanical science, and his writings display an extensive acquaintance with a variety of ancient authorities on every matter on which he discourses. He is the most exact writer of the seventeenth century on the subject of Perpetual Motion, examining it thoroughly, with admirable acuteness as well as candour. His celebrated work, entitled " Mathematical Magic," is divided into two books, the second quaintly designated " Daedalus," after that ancient inventor. Among the works he has briefly quoted in marginal notes, we may mention more at large — " A Trea- tise on Continuall Motions, by Joannes Taisnierus, a public Professor of Rome, Ferraria, and other Vniuersities in Italic " — no date, but afterwards printed with other works, 1579, c 2 PEBPETxruM mobile; quarto. Also " A Dialogue concerning Perpetual Motion, by Thomas Tymme, Mynister," London, 1612, quarto. He does not, however, allude to another of the same period, "De Inventione JEterni Motoric, b7 James Zabaeella, Teacher of Logic at Padua," where ho died 1589 ; his book was published at Francfort, 1618. The ninth, thirteenth, fourteenth, and fifteenth chapters of Bishop Wilkins' work, second book, here follow : — CHAP. IX. — Of a Perpetual Motion — The seeming facility and real difficulty of any such contrivance— The several ways whereby it hath been attempted, particularly by Chymistry. It is the chief inconvenience of all the automata before- mentioned,* that they need a frequent repair of new strength, the causes whence their motion does proceed being subject to fail, and come to a period ; and therefore it would be worth our enquiry to examine whether or no there may be made any such artificial contrivance, which might have the principle of moving from itself, so that the present motion should con- stantly be the cause of that which succeeds. This is that great secret in Art which, like the Philosopher's Stone in Nature, hath been the business and study of many more refined wits, for divers ages together ; and it may well be questioned whether either of them as yet hath ever been found out ; though if this have, yet, like the other, it is not plainly treated of by any author. Not but there are sundry discourses concerning this subject, but they are rather conjectures than experiments. And though many inventions in this kind may at first view bear a great shew of probability, yet they will fail, being brought to trial, and will not answer in practice what they promised in specu- lation. Any one who hath been versed in these experiments must needs acknowledge that he hath been often deceived in his strongest confidence; when the imagination hath con- trived the whole frame of such an instrument, and conceives that the event must infallibly answer its hopes, yet then does it strangely deceive in the proof, and discovers to us some defect which we did not before take notice of. * Various milli, chariots, clocks, &o., &c. OB, 8BABCH FOB SELF-MOTITE POWEB. 3 Hence it is, that you shall scarce talk with any one who hath never so little smattering in these arts, but he will instantly promise such a motion, as being but an easy atchievement, till further trial and experience hath taught him the difficulty of it. There being no enquiry that does more entice with the prohability and deceive with the subtilty. I shall briefly recite the several ways whereby this hath been attempted, or seems most likely to be effected, thereby to contract and facilitate the enquiries of those who are addicted to these kind of experiments ; for when they know the defects of other inventions, they may the more easily avoid the same or the like in their own. The ways whereby this hath been attempted may be generally reduced to these three kinds : — 1. By Chymical Extractions. 2. By Magnetical Virtues. 3. By the Natural Affection of Gravity. 1. The discovery of this hath been attempted by Chymistry. Paracelsus and his followers have bragged, that by their separations and extractions, they can make a little world which shall have the same perpetual motions with this microcosm, with the representation of all meteors, thunder, snow, rain, the courses of the sea in its ebbs and flows, and the like. But these miraculous promises would require as great a faith to believe them, as a power to perform them ; and the' they often talk of such great matters, — At nusquam totos inter qui talia curant, Apparet ullus, qui re miracula tanta Comprobet — yet we can never see them confirmed by any real experiment ; and then, besides, every particular author in that art hath such a distinct language of his own (all of them being so full of allegories and affected obscurities), that 'tis very hard for any one (imless he be thoroughly versed amongst them) to find out what they mean, much more to try it. One of these ways (as I find it set down) jBtten.Mathem. is this: — Mix five ounces of ? with an B6creat,prob.nB. equal weight of % ; grind them together with ten ounces of sublimate; dissolve them in a cellar upon some marble for the space of four days, till they become like oil olive ; 4 PEBPBTUUM mobile; distil this with fire of chaff, or driving fire, and it will sublime into a dry substance ; and so, by repeating of these dissolvings and distillings, there will be at length pro- duced divers small attorns, which, being put into a glass well luted, and kept dry, will have a perpetual motion. I cannot say any thing from experience against this ; but methinks it does not seem very probable, because things that are forced up to such a vigorousness and activity as these ingredients seem to be by their frequent sublimings and disr tillings, are not likely to be of any duration. The more any thing is stretched beyond its usual nature, the less does it last; violence and perpetuity being no companions. And then, besides, suppose it true, yet such a motion could not well be applied to any use, which will needs take much from the delight of it. oeubratedinan Amongst the chymical experiments to this epigram b]/ Hugo purposc, may be reckoned up that famous Orotius, 11. motion^ invented by Cornelius Dreble, and made for King James ; wherein was represented the constant revolutions' of the sun and moon, and that without the EpUtadEmet. ^®^P ^^^her of Springs or weights. Marcellus turn de Lamp. Vranckhein, speaking of the means whereby it ^***** was performed, he calls it ScintiUula animce mdgneiiccB mundi, seu astralis et insensibtlis sptritm ; being that grand secret, for the discovery of which, those dictators of philosophy, Democritus, Pythagoras, Plato, did travel unto the Gymnosophists and Indian Priests. The author EpisLadJaeo- himself, in his discourse upon it, does not um Begtm. at all rcveal the way how it was performed. But there is one Thomas Tymme, who was a familiar acquaintance of his, and did often pry into his works (as he professes himself), who affirms it to be done thus : By extracting a fiery spirit out of the mineral matter, joining the same with his proper air, which included in the Phiio»oph,Dia' axletree (of the first moving wheel), being logue, confer. 2, hollow, carrieth the other wheels, making a **^ continual rotation, except issue or vent be given in this hollow axletree, whereby the imprisoned spirit may get forth. What strange things may be done by such extractions, I know not, and therefore dare not condemn this relation as impossible ; but methinks it sounds rather like a chymical OB, SEAECH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 5 dream, than a philosophical truth. It seems this imprisoned spirit is now set at liberty, or else is grown weary, for the instrument (as I have heard) hath stood still for many years. It is here considerable that any force is weakest near the center of a wheel ; and therefore, though such a spirit might of itself have an agitation, yet 'tis not easily conceivable how it should have strength enough to carry the wheels about with it. And then, the absurdity of the author's citing this, would make one mistrust his mistake. He urges it as a strong argument against Copernicus ; as if, because Dreble did thus contrive in an engine the revolution of the heavens and the immoveableness of the earth, therefore it must needs follow that 'tis the heavens which are moved, and not the earth. If his relation were no truer than his consequence, it had not been worth the citing. CHAP. XIII. — Concerning several attempts of contriving a Perpetual Motion^ hy Magnetical Virtues* The second way whereby the making of a perpetual motion hath been attempted, is by Magnetical Virtues, which are not without some strong probabilities of proving effectual to this purpose ; especially when we consider that the heavenly revo- lutions (being as the first pattern imitated and aimed at in these attempts) are all of them performed by the help of these qualities. This great orb of earth, and all the other planets, being but as so many magnetical globes, endowed with such various and continual motions as may be most agreeable to the purposes for which they were intended. And, therefore, most of the authors who treat oubertdeMag. concerning this invention, do agree that the net cahcemPM- likeliest way to effect it, is by these kind of ^^^ Magnet, 1 4, ,... ^ ^ C20. qualities. It was the opinion of Pet. Peregrinus, and there is an example pretended for it in Bettinus (apiar. 9, progym. 5, pro. 11) that a magnetical globe, or terella, ^^^ ^. r . .1^1 1 J 'i. 1 ij i Athanas. Ktr- bemg nghtly placed upon its poles, would of cherdeArteMag. itself have a constant rotation, like the diurnal net. i. 1. par. 2. motion of the earth. But this is commonly ^^^\^ ^^''^ exploded as being against all experience. Others think it possible so to contrive several pieces of steel and loadstone that, by their continual attraction and a. Tract, de miotu eontinuo. b.DeBotaper- p€t4 tnotui, par. e. De VarteL rerum, 2. 9, a 48. De Magneto I. PEBFETUVM MOBILE; expulsion of one another, they may cause a perpetual revolution of a wheel. Of this opinion were » Taisner, ^ Pet. Peregrinus, and « Cardan, out of Antonius de Fantis. But D. Gilbert, who was more especially versed in magnetical experiments, concludes it to be a vain and groundless fancyl But amongst all these kinds of inventions, that is most likely, wherein a loadstone is so disposed that it shall draw unto it on a reclined plane a bullet of steel, which steel, as it ascends near to the loadstone, may be contrived to fall down through some hole in the plane, and so to return unto the place from whence at first it began to move ; and, being there, the loadstone will again attract it upwards till coming to this hole, it will fall down again ; and so the motion shall be perpetual, as may be more easily conceivable by this figure : — Suppose the loadstone to be represented at A B, which, though it have not strength enough to attract the bullet C directly from the groimd, yet may do it by the help of the plane E F. Now, when the bullet is come to the top of this plane, its own gravity (which is supposed to exceed the strength of the loadstone) will make it fall into that hole at E ; and the force it receives in this fall will carry it with such a violence unto the other end of this arch, that it will open the passage which is there made for it, and by its return will again shut it ; so that the bullet (as at the first) is in the same place whence it was attracted, and, consequently, must move perpetually. OB, SEAECH FOB SELP-MOTIVE POWEB. 7 But however this invention may seem to be of such strong probability, yet thete are sundry particulars which may prove it insufficient : for — 1. This bullet of steel must first be touched, and have its several poles, or else there can be little or no attraction of it. Suppose C in the steel to be answerable unto A in the stone, and to B ; in the attraction C D must always be directed answer- able to A B, and so the motion will be more difficult ; by reason there can be no rotation or turning round of the bullet, but it must slide up with the line C D, answerable to the axis A B. 2. In its fall from E to G, which is motus elementarts^ and proceeds from its gravity, there must needs be a rotation of it ; and so 'tis odds but it happens wrong in the rise, the poles in the bullet being not in the same direction to those in the magnet ; and if in this reflux it should so fall out, that D should be directed towards B, there should be rather a flight than an attraction, since those two ends do repel, and not draw one another. 3. If the loadstone A B have so much strength, that it can attract the bullet in F, when it is not turned round, but does only slide upon the plane, whereas its own gravity would rowl it downwards ; then it is evident the sphere of its activity and strength would be so increased when it approaches much nearer, that it would not need the assistance of the plane, but would draw it immediately to itself without that help ; and so the bullet would not fall down through the hole, but ascend to the stone, and, consequently, cease its motion : for, if the loadstone be of force enough to draw the bullet on the plane, at the distance F B, then must the strength of it be sufficient to attract it immediately unto itself, when it is so much nearer as £ B. And if the gravity of the bullet be supposed so much to exceed the strength of the magnet, that it cannot draw it directly when it is so near, then will it not be able to attract the bullet up the plane, when it is so much further oflf. So that none of all these magnetical experiments, which have been as yet discovered, are sufficient for the effecting of a perpetual' motion, though these kind of qualities seem most conducible unto it ; and perhaps, hereafter, it may be con- trived from them. 8 PEBPETUXTM MOBILE; CHAP. XIV. — The seeming probability of effecting a Continual Motion by Solid Weights in a Hollow Wheel or Sphere, The third way whereby the making of a perpetual motion hath been attempted is by the Natural Affection of Gravity ; when the heaviness of several bodies is so contrived, that the same motion which they give in their descent, may be able to carry them up again. But (against the possibility of any such invention) it is L 17 De ^^^ objected by Cardan : — ^All sublunary bodies Var. R The sum 24. ^o^ The sum 19. 7.o) 12 PERPETUUM mobile; On the ascending side, the weights are to be reckoned according to these degrees : — THE OUTWABD. THE INT^ABD. 4.1, 1.3. 7.2 9.0 r The sum 24. 5.3 \ 0.0'' 6 The sum 19. The sum of which last numbers is equal with the former, and therefore both the sides of such a wheel in this situation will equiponderate. If it be objected, that the plummet A should be contrived to pull down the other at B, and then the descending side will be heavier than the other ; for answer to this, it is con- siderable— 1. That these bullets towards the top of the wheel, cannot descend till they come to a certain kind of inclination. 2. That any lower bullet hanging upon the other above it, to pull it down, must be conceived, as if the weight of it were in that point where its string touches the upper ; at which point this bullet will be of less heaviness in respect of the wheel, than if it did rest in its own place ; so that both the sides of it, in any kind of situation, may equiponderate. CHAP. XV. — Of composing a Perpetual Motion hy Fluid Weights — Concerning Archimedes his Water Screw — The great probability of accomplishing this enquiry by the help of that, with the fallible- \ ness of it upon experiment. That which I shall mention as th^ last way, for the trial of this experiment, is by contriving it in some Water Instrument ; which may seem altogether as probable and easie as any of the rest ; because that element, by reason of its fluid and subtle nature (whereby, of its own accord, it searches out the lower and more narrow passages), may be most pliable to the mind of the artificer. Now, the usual means for the ascent of water is either by suckers or forces, or something equiva- lent thereunto ; neither of which may be conveniently applied unto such a work as this, because there is required unto each of them so much or more strength, as may be answerable to the full weight of the water that is to be drawn up ; and then, besides, they move for the most part by fits and snatches, so that it is not easily conceivable, how they should conduce OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTITE POWER. 13 unto such a motion, which, by reason of its perpetuity, must be regular and equal. But, amongst all other ways to this purpose, that invention of Archimedes is incomparably the best, which is usually called Cochlea^ or the "Water Screw ; being framed by the helical revolution of a cavity about a cylinder. "We have not any discourse from the author himself concerning it, nor is it certain whether he ever writ anything to this purpose ; but if he did, yet, as the injury of time hath deprived us of many other his excellent works, so likewise of this amongst the rest. [Near five pages are occupied in describing the use of this screw, and the form and manner of making it ; then follows : — ^] The true inclination of the screw being found, together with the certain quantity of water which every helix does contain; it is further considerable, that the water by this instru- ment does ascend naturally of itself, without any violence or labour ; and that the heaviness of it does lie chiefly upon the centers or axis of the cylinder, both its sides being of equal weight (saith Ubaldus) ; so that, it should seem, ubaidus de co- though we suppose each revolution to have an «Wtfa,j.3,proj),4. equal quantity of water, yet the screw will remain with any part upwards, according as it shall be set, without turning itself either way; and, therefore, the least strength being added to either of its sides should make it descend, according to that common maxim of Archimedes — any d^ jSquipond, addition will make that which equiponderates ^^ppo'- 8. with another to tend downwards. But now, because the weight of this instrument and the water in it does lean wholly upon the axis, hence is it (saith Ubaldus} that the grating and rubbing of these axes against the sockets wherein they are placed, will cause some ineptitude and resistency to that rotation of the cylinder ; which would otherwise ensue upon the addition of the least weight to any one side ; but (saith the^ same author) any power that is greater than this resistency which does arise from the axis, will serve for the turning of it round. These things considered together, it will hence appear how a perpetual motion may seem easily contrivable. For, if there were but such a water-wheel made on this instrument, upon which the stream that is carried up may fall in its descent, it would turn the screw round, and by that means convey as 14 PEKPETUUM mobile; much water up as is required to move it ; so that the motion must needs be continual, since the same weight which in its fall does turn the wheel is, by the turning of the wheel, carried up again. Or, if the water, falling upon one wheel, would not be forcible enough for this effect, why then there might be two or three, or more, according as the length and elevation of the instrument will admit ; by which means the weight of it may be so multiplied in the fall that it shall be equivalent to twice or thrice that quantity of water which ascends; as may be more plainly discerned by the following diagram : — Where the figure L M, at the bottom, does represent a wooden cylinder with helical cavities cut in it, which at A B is sup- OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIYE POWEE. 15 posed to be covered over with tin plates, and three water- wheels upon it, H I K ; the lower cistern, which contains the water, being C D. Nov/, this cylinder being turned round, aU the water which from the cistern ascends through it, will fall into the vessel at E, and from that vessel being conveyed upon the water-wheel H, shall consequently give a circular motion to the whole screw. Or, if this alone Thcrcia another should be too weak for the turning of it, then Hkcwntrivaneeto the came water which fails from the wheel H, p^J^S^'apJ" being received into the other vessel F, may \pogym,iprop. from thence again descend on the wheel I, by J^* ^* ^^^ *^«** which means the force of it will be doubled, than *tis here pro And if this be yet unsufficient, then may the pond water which fails on the second wheel I, be received into the other vessel G, and from thence again descend on the third wheol at K ; and so for as many other wheels as the instru- ment is capable of. So that, besides the greater distance of these three streams from the center or axis by which they are made so much heavier, and besides that the fall of this out- ward water is forcible and violent, whereas the ascent of that within is natural, — besides all this, there is thrice as much water to turn the screw as is carried up by it. But, on the other side, if all the water falling upon one wheel would be able to turn it round, then half of it would serve with two wheels, and the rest may be so disposed of in the fall as to serve unto some other useful delightful ends. When I first thought of this invention, I could scarce for- bear, with Archimedes, to cry out evprjKa, evprjKa ; it seeming 80 infallible a way for the effecting of a perpetual motion that nothing could be so much as probably objected against it ; but, upon trial and experience, 1 find it altogether insufiicient for any such purpose, and that for these two reasons : — 1. The water that ascends will not make any considerable stream in the fall. 2. This stream, tho' multiplied, will not be of force enough to turn about the screw. 1. The water ascends gently, and by intermissions ; but it falls continually, and with force ; each of the three vessels being supposed full at the first, that so the weight of the water in them might add the greater strength and swiftness to the streams that descend from them. Now, this swiftness of motion will cause so great a difference betwixt them that 16 PERPETUUM mobile; one of these little streams may spend more water in the fall than a stream six times bigger in the ascent, tho' we should suppose both of them to be continuate; how much more, then, when as the ascending water is vented by fits and inter- missions, every circumvolution voiding so much as is con- tained in one helix ; and, in this particular, one that is not versed in these kind of experiments may be easily deceived. But, secondly, tho' there were so great a disproportion, yet, notwithstanding, the force of these outward streams might well enough serve for the turning of the screw, if it were so that both its sides would equiponderate the water being in them (as Ubaldus hath afiurmed). But now, upon farther examination, we shall find this assertion of his to be utterly against both reason and experience. And herein does consist the chief mistake of this contrivance ; for the ascending side of the screw is made, by the water contained in it, so much heavier than the descending side, that these outward streams, thus applied, will not be of force enough to make them equi- ponderate, much less to move the whole, as may be more easily discern' d by this fig. : — Where A B represents a screw covered over, C D E one helix or revolution of it, C D the ascending side, E D the descend- ing side, the point D the middle ; the horizontal line C F shewing how much of the helix is filled with water, viz., of the ascending side, from C the beginning of the helix, to D the middle of it ; and on the descending side, from D the middle, to the point G, where the horizontal does cut the helix. Now, it is evident that this latter part, D G, is OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 17 nothing near so much, and consequently not so heavy as the other, D C ; and thus is it in all the other revolutions, which, as they are either more or larger, so will the difficulty of this motion be increased. Whence it will appear that the outward streams which descend must be of so much force as to coimtervail all that weight whereby the ascending side in every one of these revolutions does exceed the other. And tho' this may be effected by making the water-wheels larger, yet then the motion will be so slow that the screw will not be able to supply the outward streams. There is another contrivance to this purpose, mentioned by Kircher de Magnete, 1. 2, p. 4, depending upon the heat of the sun and the force of winds; but it is liable to such abundance of exceptions that it is scarce worth the mention- ing, and does by no means deserve the confidence of any ingenious artist. Thus have I briefly explained the probabilities and defects of those subtle contrivances whereby the making of a per- petual motion hath been attempted. I would be loth to discourage the enquiry of any ingenious artificer by denying the possibility of effecting it with any of these mechanical helps ; but yet (I conceive) if those principles which concern the slowness of the power in comparison to the greatness of the weight were rightly understood and thoroughly considered, they would make this experiment to seem, if not altogether impossible, yet much more difficult than otherwise, perhaps, it will appear. However, the enquiring after it cannot but deserve our endeavours, as being one of the most noble amongst all these mechanical subtUties. And, as it is in the fable of him who dug the vineyard for a hid treasure, tho' he did not find the money, yet he thereby made the groimd more fruitful, so, tho' we do not attain to the effecting of this par- ticular, yet our searching after it may discover so many other excellent subtilties as shaU abundantly recompence the labour of our enquiry. And then, besides, it may be another encouragement to consider the pleasure of such speculations, ,^^.^j. ^ ^^-^ which do ravish and sublime the thoughts j any contriTance whatever) whilst the weight A describes the arc A a, the weight B is carried in any arc, as B &, so as to come nearer the centre in its rising, than if it went up the arc B D ; the said weight shall be oveipois'd, and consequently, by a number of such weights, a perpetual motion wfll be produced. 'Diis is attempted by several contrivances* which all depend upon this Mse principle ; but I shall only mention one, which is represented by Fig. 4, where a wheel having two parallel circumferences, has the space between them divided into cells, which being curv'd, will (when the wheel goes round) cause weights placed loose in the said cells, to descend on the side A, at the outer circumference of the wheel, and on the side D to ascend in the line B 6 6 &, which comes nearer the centre, and touches the inner circumference of the wheel. In a machine of this kind, the weights will indeed move in such a manner, if the wheel be tum'd round, but will never be the cause of the wheel's going round. Such a machine is mentioned by the Marquis of Worcester, in his *' Century of Inventions," in the following words. No. 56 : — " To provide and make that all the weights of the descending side of a wheel, shall be perpetually farther from the centre, than those of the mounting side, and yet equal in number and heft to the one side as the other. A most incredible thing, if not seen ; but tried before the late King (of blessed memory) in the Tower by my directions, two extraordinary ambassadors accompanying his Majesty, and the Duke of Richmond, and Duke of Hamilton, with most of the Court attending him. The wheel was fourteen foot over, and had fourty weights of fifty pounds a piece. Sir William Balfore, then Lieutenant of the Tower, can justify it, with several others. They all saw, that no sooner these great weights passed the diameter line of the lower side, but they hung a foot farther from the centre ; nor no sooner passed the diameter line of the upper side, but they himg a foot nearer. Be pleased to judge of the consequence." Now the consequence of this, and such like machines, is nothing less than a perpetual motion ; and the fallacy is this : (Fig. 3.) (Pig- *.) (Fig. 5.) ' PhiloiopWcal Tratifactions." No. 369. Vol.31. 1720-1721. OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 47 The velocity of any weight is not the line, which it describes in general, but the height that it rises up to, or falls from, with respect to its distance from the centre of the earth. So that when the weight (Fig. 3) describes the arc A a, its velocity is the line A C, which shews the perpendicular descent (or measures how much it is come nearer to the centre of the earth), and likewise the line B C denotes the velocity of the weight B, or the height that it rises to, when it ascends in any of the arcs B b, instead of the arc B D : so that in this case whether the weight B, in its ascent be brought nearer the centre or not, it loses no velocity, which it ought to do, in order to be raised up by the weight A. Nay, the weight in rising nearer the centre of a wheel, may not only not lose of its velocity, but be made to gain velocity, in proportion to the velocity of its counterpoising weights, that descend in the circumference of the opposite side of the wheel; for if we consider two radii of the wheel, one of which is horizontal, and the other (fastened to and moving with it) inclined under the horizon in an angle of 60 degr. (Fig. 5) and by the descent of the end B of the radius B C, the radius CD by its motion causes the weight at D, to rise up the line p P, which is in a plane that stops the said weight from rising in the curve D A, that weight will gain velocity, and in the beginning of its rise, it will have twice the velocity of the weight at B ; and consequently, instead of being rais'd, will overpoise, if it be equal to the last mentioned weight. And this velocity will be so much the greater, in proportion as the angle A C D is greater, or as the plane P p (along which the weight D must rise) is nearer to the centre. Indeed, if the weight at B (Fig. 3) could by any means be lifted up to p, and move in the arc /3 5, the end would be answer'd; because then the velocity would be diminished, and become /3 C. Experiment (Fig. 5). — Take the leaver BCD, whose brachia are equal in length, bent in an angle of 120 degr. at C, and moveable about that point as its centre : In this case, a weight of two pounds hanging at the end B of the horizontal part of the leaver, will keep in aequilibrio a weight of four pounds hanging at the end D. But if a weight of one pound be laid upon the end D of the leaver, so that in the motion of D along the arc p A, this weight is made to rise up against the plane P/? (which divides in half the line A C equal to 48 PEBFETUUM MOBILE; C B) the said weight will keep in sequilibrio two pounds at B, as having twice the velocity of it, when the leaver begins to move. This will be evident, if you let the weight 4 hang at D, whilst the weight 1 lies above it : for if then you move the leaver, the weight 1 will rise four times as fast as the weight 4.* Notice of the Wheel of OrflPyreus, in the " Gentleman's Magazine," in a letter on — Perpetual Motion said to be discovered, Mb. Ubbak, — Being an admirer of improvements in me- chanics, and desirous of seeing the perpetual motion dis- covered, I Was much pleased on readmg, some time ago, an accoimt of the automaton constructed by Orflfyreus, in two letters, one from Professor s'Gravesande to Sir Isaac Newton, the other from Baron Fischer to Dr. Desaguliers, with the testimonial of the Landgrave of Hesse^Cassel (who had seen the inside of it) in favoiir of its construction. To which are added some remarks by William Kenrick, the writer of the pamphlet, who takes that opportimity to propose a subscrip- tion for a similar machine, which he says he has contrived, and denominated a Rotator. It is much to be lamented that the learned did not examine more strictly into the merit of Orflfyreus*s wheel ; but, on the contrary, being prepossessed with a notion of the impractica- bility of the perpetual motion, suffered it to be neglected, and at last destroyed by the hands of a disappointed mechanic, who, with unwearied application and steady perseverance, had brought it to perfection. I wish we may not again let slip an opportunity of becoming acquainted with an invention, which, when made public, will reflect honour on the inventor, and be of the utmost utility to the world. Such, I woidd hope, is the rotator mentioned by W. Kenrick ; for, unless his disco- very were real, I cannot think that he would have taken the liberty to express himself as he does in p. 26, &c. " The inventor flatters himself that, if the contents of the foregoing pages are seriously attended to, and it be farther considered, that not a penny of the proposed premium is required, till the subscribers are fully satisfied of the reality and utility of the • The PliiloBophtcal Transactions, vol. 31, for the years 1720, 1721. 4to. No. 369, Sep , Oct., Nov., Dec, 1721, page 237. OK, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 49 invention, his proposal will not be treated with so mortifying a neglect as that of Orffyreus." Again he says, " If it does not supply the place of a first mover, at the expense only of the construction and repair of a simple wheel, subject to very little friction, and that in all such engines and machines, even from the slightest piece of clockwork to the waterworks of Marli or London-bridge, he expects nothing for his discovery, but to stand exposed to the contempt that will be justly thrown on him, for having so miserably mispent his time, and frivolously engaged the attention of the public." Now, I think that W. Kenrick's proposals are very fair ; and should be glad to be informed, whether any attention has been paid to them, and whether Sir Isaac Newton took any notice of the letter addressed to him by Professor 8*Gra- vesande. I shall consider it as a favour if any correspondent will oblige me with an answer to these particulars. A Constant Reader.* Dr. Hutton, in his notice " Of the Perpetual Motion," inci- dentally condemns the wheel of Orfiyreus, observing : — The perpetual motion has been the quicksand of mechani- cians, as the quadrature of the circle, the trisection of an angle, &c., have been that of geometricians : and as those who pretend to have discovered the solution of the latter pro- blems are in general persons scarcely acquainted with the principles of geometry, those who search for, or imagine they have found, the perpetual motion, are always men to whom the most certain and invariable truths of mechanics are unknown. It may be demonstrated, indeed, to all those capable of rea- soning in a soimd manner on those sciences, that a perpetual motion is impossible : for, to be possible, it is necessary that the eflfect shoidd become alternately the cause, and the cause the effect. It woidd be necessary, for example, that a weight raised to a certain height by another weight, should in its turn raise the second weight to the height from which it de- scended. But, according to the laws of motion, all that a descending weight coidd do, in the most perfect machine which the mind can conceive, is to raise another in the same time to a height reciprocally proportional to its mass. But • The Gentleman'g Magazine. Vol. 42. 1772. P. 172. F 50 PEBPETUUM MOBILE ; it is impossible to construct a machine in wliich there shall be neither friction nor the resistance of some medium to be overcome ; consequently at each alternation of ascent and descent, some quantity of motion, however small, will always be lost : each time, therefore, the weight to be raised will ascend to a less height ; and the motion will gradually slacken, and at length cease entirely. A moving principle has been sought for, but without suc- cess, in the magnet, in the gravity of the atmosphere, and in the elasticity of bodies. If a magnet be disposed in such a manner as to facilitate the ascension of a weight, it will after- wards oppose its descent. Springs, after being unbent, require to be bent by a new force equal to that which they exercised ; and the gravity of the atmosphere, after forcing one side of the machine to the lowest point, must be itself raised again, like any other weight, in order to continue its action. We shall, however, give an account of various attempts to obtain a perpetual motion, because they may serve to show how much some persons have suffered themselves to be de- ceived on this subject. Fig. 62, pi 12.) Fig. 52, plate 12, represents a large wheel, the circum- ference of which is furnished, at equal distances, with levers, each bearing at its extremity a weight, and moveable on a OE, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIYE POWER. 61 iinge, so that in one direction they can rest upon the circum- ference, while on the opposite side, being carried away by the weight at the extremity, they are obliged to arrange them- selves in the direction of the radius continued. This being supposed, it is evident that when the wheel turns in the direc- tion a b Cy the weights A B and C will recede from the centre ; consequently, as they act with more force, they will carry the wheel towards that side ; and as a new lever will be thrown out, in proportion as the wheel revolves, it thence follows, say they, that the wheel vnll continue to move in the same direction. But, notwithstanding the specious appear- ance of this reasoning, experience has proved that the machine will not go ; and it may indeed be demonstrated that there is a certain position in which the centre of gravity of all these weights is in the vertical plane passing through the point of suspension, and that therefore it must stop. The case is the same with the following machine, which it would appear ought to move also incessantly. In a cylindric drum, in perfect equilibrium on its axis, are formed channels as seen in Fig. 53, which contain balls of lead, or a certain (.Fig, 53.) quantity of qidcksilver. In consequence of this disposition, the balls or quicksilver must, on the one side, ascend by approaching the centre ; and on the other must roll towards 52 PERPETXJXJM mobile: the circumference. The machine then ought to turn inces- santly towards that side. A third machine of this kind is represented Fig. 54. It consists of a kind of wheel formed of six or eight arms, pro- ceeding from a centre, where the axis of motion is placed. Each of these arms is furnished with a receptacle in the form of a pair of bellows, but those on the opposite arms stand in con- (Fig. 54.) trary directions, as seen in the figure. The moveable top of each receptacle has affixed to it a weight, which shuts it in one situation and opens it in the other. In the last place, the bellows of the opposite arms have a communication by means of a canal, and one of them is filled with quicksilver. These things being supposed, it is visible, that the bellows on the one side must open, and those on the other must shut ; OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE FOWEB. 53 consequently the mercury will pass from the latter into the former, while the contrary will be the cage on the opposite side. It might be difficult to point out the deficiency of this reasoning ; but those acquainted with the true principles of mechanics will not hesitate to bet a hundred to one that the machine, when constructed, will not answer the intended purpose. The description of a pretended perpetual motion, in which bellows, to be alternately filled with and emptied of quick- silver, were employed, may be seen in the " Journal des Savans " for 1685. It was refuted by Bemouilli and some others, and it gave rise to a long dispute. The best method which the inventor could have employed to defend his inven- tion would have been to construct it, and shew it in motion ; but this was never done. We shall here add another curious anecdote on this sub- ject. One Orfyreus annoimced, at Leipsic, in the year 1717, a perpetual motion, consisting of a wheel which would con- tinually revolve. This machine was constructed for the Land- grave of Hesse Cassel, who caused it to be shut up in a place of safety, and the door to be sealed with his own seal. At the end of forty days, the door was opened, and the machine was found in motion. This, however, affords no proof in favour of a perpetual motion ; for as clocks can be made to go a year without being wound up, Orfyreus' s wheel might easily go forty days, and even more. The result of this pretended discovery is not known. We are informed that an Englishman offered 80,000 crowns for this machine ; but Orfyreus refused to sell it at that price : in this he certainly acted wrong, as there is reason to think he obtained by his invention, neither money, nor even the honour of having discovered the perpetual motion. The Academy of Painting at Paris possessed a clock which had no need of being woimd up, and which might be con- sidered as a perpetual motion, though it was not so. But this requires some explanation. The ingenious author of this clock employed the variations in the state of the atmo- sphere for winding up his moving weight. Various artifices might be devised for this purpose; but this is no more a perpetual motion than if the flux and reflux of the sea were employed to keep the machine continually going; for this 54 PEKPETUUM mobile; principle of motion is exterior to the machine, and forms no part of it. But enough has been said on this chimera of mechanics. We sincerely hope that none of our readers will ever lose themselves in the ridiculous and unfortimate labyrinth of such a research. To conclude, it is false that any reward has been promised by the European Powers to the person who shall discover the perpetual motion ; and the case is the same in regard to the quadrature of the circle. It is this idea, no doubt, that excites so many to attempt the solution of these problems ; and it is proper they should be imdeceived.* Dr. William Kenrick published " A Lecture on the Perpe- tual Motion," in 1770 and following year ; it is a quarto pam- phlet of ninety-two pages, now very rare, a copy of which, however, is in the valuable library connected with the Patent Office. We shall proceed to give it in an abridged form. In the Apology, occupying six pages, he says : — The mere exhibition of a self-moving machine, without a display of its mechanism, or the principles on which its motion is begun and continued, could produce no conviction. The fate of Orflfyreus and his machine is a proof of this. Scarce fifty years ago that whimsical mechanician exhibited a perpetual motion at Hesse Cassel, the constancy of whose operation was experienced for many weeks imder the most exact caution of the Landgrave of that Principality, whose testimony of such operation, as well as in favour of its con- struction (to the secret of which he was admitted), was given in the most explicit and determinate form. And yet, because Orffyreus would not display the mechanism without the pre- vious assurance of a premium of 200,000 florins (near twenty thousand pounds), or because he would not or could not dis- cover the principles on which it acted, his pretensions were neglected, his machine was destroyed by his own hands, and his life made a sacrifice to the. chagrin attending his disap- pointment. Twenty years had he racked his brains for in- * Recreations in Mathematics and Natural Philosophy. First com- posed by M. Ozanam, greatly enlarged by M. Montucla, and translated into English and improved by Chs. Hutton, LL.D. and F.K.S. In 4 vols* 8vo. 1803. [See vol. 2, p. 102 and plate 12.] OK, 8EAKCH FOB SELF-MOTIVB POWEE. 65 vention, and expended a patrimonial competence with, parsi- mony in prosecuting his design. And, when success inspired the hope of reward, he found his ingenuity suspected of im- posture, and his industry rewarded with contempt. Whether any of his successors in the same pursuit will meet with a hetter fate is at length to be determined. One species of our predecessor's merit, however, I (adds Dr. Ken- rick*) presume myself at least entitled to, that of persever- ance ; it being now fifteen years since I first engaged in this undertaking, which I have since pursued with almost imre- mitted assiduity, and that not only at a considerable waste of time and expence, but imder the constant mortification of hearing it equally ridiculed, by those who do know, and by those who do not know, anything of the matter. It is, indeed, generally supposed, and as confidently affirmed, that the mathematicians have published demonstra- tions of the impossibility of a perpetual motion. But I can safely take upon me to affirm that no such demonstration was ever published by any. Within these twelve years past, the mathematicians who deny the possibility of a perpetual motion have been repeatedly and publicly called upon, both in the foreign and English prints, to produce a single instance of these demonstrations. They have not done it. They might have produced, indeed, the demonstrations of Huygens, De la Hire, and others, to prove, as Desaguliers very properly ex- presses it, the fallacy of the schemes of most of the pretenders to the perpetual motion. They proved nothing more ; and this was so far unnecessary, in that the fallacy evidently appeared in the discovery of the principle on which they were founded. This was done in the last century by the celebrated Mar- quis of Worcester, in the presence of the King and his Court, at the Tower, by the exhibition of a wheel so contrived that, in revolving on its axis, it carried up several weights nearer its centre on one side than they descended on the other. The scheme was plausible, and to appearance practicable ; but, though the wheel was polite enough to turn about while his • We learn from Gorton's Biographical Dictionary that William Kenrick was born at Watford, and brought up to the business of a rule- maker. He procured a doctor's degree at Ley den, and died in 1779, less lamented than he might have been, owing to his generally malignant and vituperative style of writing. 56 PESFETUXTM MOBILE; Majesty was present, it could not be prevailed upon to be so complaisant in his absence.* The mathematicians avenged themselves of the short triumph of the mistaken Marquis, but were equally mistaken themselves in thinking l^ey had routed the problem, or that, in hunting down the jackal, they had destroyed the lion. The perpetujed motion survived ; it had still its advocates ; Professor 'S Gravesande and John Bemouille maintained its practicability, the former giving his testimony in favour of Orffyreus's machine, after a long and scrutinous examination. It is not twelve years since this testimony was republished by Dr. Allaman, the present Pro- fessor of Natural Philosophy at Leyden, whose own opinion, given at the same time, is also greatly in favour of the disco- very. It is even some years later that a dissertation still more in its favour, written, if I am not mistaken, by the cele- brated De Gprter, of Petersberg, appeared in the " Philoso- phical Transactions " of Haarlem. My end is not to amuse or persuade, but, with due deference, to inform and convince. To remove every cause of objection, I must beg leave to expatiate somewhat at large on the theory of this discovery. It is with the more propriety I presume on this method, as the discovery to which 1 pretend has not been (as frequently happens) the effect of mechanical accident, but the premedi- tated result of mathematical reasoning and physical experi- ment. I shall proceed to elucidate the principal arguments d, priori, that prove the practicability of a perpetual motion to be the necessary consequence of the known and established laws of nature. Having proceeded thus far, he opens his lecture at page 7 with the Introduction ; and first " On the nature of motion in general,' ' which, in fourteen pages, being more metaphysical than mechanical, affords no extractable matter for our present object. Part 1, is " On the cause and effect of motion." This elementary part is needlessly laboured and elaborated through twenty-seven pages. In the course of his remarks he states : — The discovery of a perpetual motion, says De la Hire, * On what authority he presumes to make this statement of its inope- rativeness does not appear, and, indeed, seems quiie apocryphal. OB, SEABCBL FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 57 would be to discover a body at once heavier and lighter than itself. But this is not a fair state of the question. It is not necessary that all the parts of a perpetually-moving machine should be attached to, and inseparable from, each other ; which they must be, to constitute one gravitating body of a determinate weight. He proceeds to consider the nature of the circulation of the blood, pneumatic pressure, the steel-yard, real and relative weight, and spiral action. Again, we have Hobbes, Locke, and Stewart, in the same sentence with such language as — " I could almost as readily impute ingenuity to vegetables and dossils — to the sensitive plant and the loadstone — as mediation to muscles, or cogitabimdity to cockles, peri- winkles, and rock oysters !" In conclusion, he says : — I have endeavoured to make it appear that motion is the mechanical effect of the physical action of the primary ele- ments ; that the direction of motion only comes withm the province of animal intellect; that the vital system is sup- ported by mere mechanic motion, kept up by the elasticity of the solids and the gravity of the fluids composing the animal body; that by the same means a more simple inanimate system or machine may be framed, which may have the same property of continued action (or, as it is called, self-motion). And this is all that is, or can be, expected of a perpetual motion ; the momentum of which may be increased to any degree, according to the weight of the bodies employed and the work required to be done. • The second part of this lecture commences with a Proem of thirteen pages : — I am induced (he says) to trespass farther, by extending in like manner the subsequent divisions of it ; making the second and third parts of my printed syllabus the topics of the present reading, and reserving the last part, with the concluding experiment, to the third and flnal lecture. I pretend merely to the investigation of the general prin- ciples of mechanics, and even to illustrate these so far only as I conceive they relate to the immediate object of my lec- ture, the discovery of an artificial perpetual motion ; leaving 58 F£BF£TUUM MOBLLE ; the application of such principles, in the solution of particular phenomena, or the construction of particular machines, to such as make the different arts and sciences their peculiar study. ^ He very prudentiy ends, observing : — But I beg pardon, gentiemen, for the length of this digres- sive introduction, and shall proceed to the more immediate subject of my lecture. Section 1, of this lecture, is ^' On the composition and com- bination of motion." After discussing, in his own peculiar style, mechanical principles of motion, he adds : — It would require a volume, and that not a small oife, to illustrate these subjects, and support them by the necessary demonstrations and experiments. Should Providence give me life and health, therefore, they (his auditors) shall hare it. Indeed, I have already spent some years in preparing such a volume for the press. He is very prolix on gravity and motion, then commences Section 2, " On the communication and dissipation of motion." Five pages are occupied in discussing motion, in popular language, in the course of which he remarks : — . And as to the imperfectiy elastic bodies, their power of retaining or commimicating motion depends entirely on their vis inertia and weight ; nor can they on any occasion what- ever communicate a greater momentum to another body than they themselves possess. It is sufficient for the purpose of a perpetual motion that they can do this. And, indeed, here all the difficulty lies, viz., in the means of communicating the momentum or moving force of a heavy body to a light one. Now, the most virulent opponents to the practicability of perpetual motion have never pretended to demonstrate the impracticability of this communication. The qiwmodo, or means of effecting it, being the point in dispute. It is to this discovery that I pretend ; and to show that my preten- sions are well groimded, have taken the liberty to invite you to this lecture. The lectures appear to have been illustrated by a plate having two figures of a simple apparatus used to demonstrate OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 59 the action of a spring and two unequal weights; also an inflexible ruler suspended between two unequal balls, — ^with both he experimented before his auditors ; but the engraving is wanting in the edition now used. In conclusion, he observes : — You see, gentlemen, I am purposely provided here with a very simple and clumsy app^-ratus. The perpetual motion does not need the assistance of friction wheels, or depend on the niggling nicety of tooth and pinion. If the practical part of my discovery be not superior to the manual dexterity of a village carpenter or country smith, I am satisfied. There will be no great discernment required to comprehend the design they are to put in execution. You will permit me, however, at present, to defer what I have farther to offer on the subject to another opportunity.* ♦ A Lecture on the Perpetual Motion. Part the first. London, 1771. 4to. Pp. 49. A Lecture on the Perpetual Motion. Part the second. London, 177 L 4to. Pp.43. An "Address »» follows the first title page, dated 24 Jan , 1771, signed W. Kenrick j and has a notice at the end that ** The plates will be delivered with the third and last part of the lecture." This "third and last part,'* if published, does not form part of the copy in the Patent Office library. 60 PEHPETUUM moblle; CHAPTER in. Patexts of the setesteexth and eighteenth cex- TUBIES, WITH CONTEMPOBABY SCIENTIFIC NOTICES ON THEM AND THE SUBJECT GENEBALLY. The very fact of patenting inventions, ostensibly to go on gravitating without coining to a stand-still, so long as their materials endure, offers fair presumptive evidence of the unfaltering faith of their designers. And the tone of early scientific journals is by no means decidedly averse to offering encouragement to these workers in the dark. We cannot extend these remarks to recent patentees and journalists ; — the former generally deceive both themselves and others, and the latter now repudiate such productions. The following patents belong to the seventeenth century: — 1630. — David Ramseye [No. 60], esquire, and one of the Groomes of the Privie Chamber. Among other claims to a patent for ^^ his great paines, industry, and chardge^^ in finding out the same, he names — '^ To make any sort of mills to goe on standing waters by continuall mocion, without the helpe of winde, waite, or horse." But no description is given or was then required. 1635.— William Babtok [No. 79], gentleman, " by his own invention, labour and expense, hath gained the ^ skill of making of engines, which being put in order, will cause and maintain their own motions, with continuance and without any borrowed force of man, horse, wind, river, or brooke, whereby many several kinds of excellent rare works may be performed to the great good and benefit of the commonwealth, the like cause and means of which continuance of motion hath not been heretofore brought to perfection.^ " OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 61 This patent, granted ia the reign of Charles L, for the term of 14 years, is in the usual form to secure the right to the patentee and the payment by him of the annual rent of ^' tenn pounds " into the Exchequer " att the Feast of the Annuncia- cion of the Blessed Virgin Marie, att Saint Michaell the Arch- angell,^' beyond which, and the above title, nothing is known of the invention itself. 1662. — Ralph Wayne [No. 135]) gentleman, "hath, through his great charge, labour, and industry, attained the knowledge of ^an engine which, with the perpetual motion of it selfe, without the help or strength of any person or creature, will not only drain great levels of vast quantities of water, but also mines of fifty fathoms deep or more.' '^ This patent, granted in the reign of Charles XL, like the former gives only the title, and requires the yearly payment of ibur pounds per annum, for 14 years. Here follow patents of tlie eighteenth century : — 1779. — John Dietbick Mulleb [No. 1228], of St. Jame8% Westminster, gentleman. "A machine or engine constructed on self-moving principles." It is "a double wheel, consisting of two frames, fixed on and at right angles to an axis, moving on and supported by two pivots or gudgeons.'^ £ach wheel has two or more oval apertures, and boxes and weights made to fit and slide in them, and are to operate on "teeth or trundles," like "a man acting in the wheel of a crane, and thus the powers which are generated in any machine depend upon the exact formation and relative position of these oval holes," &c. &c. 8cc. 1782.— Hildebband Mobley [No. 1324], of Clement's Inn, Middlesex, gentleman. " New-invented wheel, engine, or machine, whereby to give or communicate to mills, clocks, timepieces, or other instruments or engines requiring the same properties, a constant and perpetual force and motion." " My said invented wheel, engine, or machine, whereby 62 PEBPETunc mobile; to gire or commaniaUe to mills, clocks, timepieces, or other instmmeits or engines requiring the same properties, a con- stant and perpetual force and motion, has a framework* of wood, iron, or other metal to which the machinery is fixt and supported. It consists of a wheel which is divid^ on the rim or outward edge into any number of divisions in the manner of a water wheel, so that each division be sufficient to contain a round ball, which balls are made of wood, or hollow balls made of tin, copper, iron, or other metal, or of glass. These balls, as the wheel moves round, fall off on an inclined plane or spout, from whence they acquire sufficient velocity or force to enter through a passage a tall square tube filled either with quicksilver, water, or other fluids, which is there supported by the pressure of the outward air. As soon as those balls enter the aforesaid tube they will rise upwards therein, being lighter than the fluids, and through a certain number of new contrived valves which support the fluids alternately in the tube. When the balls are arrived at the top or broad head of the aforesaid tube, they are conducted to a wheel with a certain number of teeth, on which are placed lifters to lift the balls out of the said fluids. This said wheel is drove by another wheel with the same number of teeth and diameter, to which is joined a pulley, over which passes a cord, chain, catgut, silken thread, or any other line or twist, which, being joined at both ends, is passt over another pulley fixt to the axle of the great wheel, which great wheel, when loaded with the aforesaid balls, turns round the aforesaid two other wheels, by which means the balls are lifted out of and from the fluids, and fall on an inclined plane or spout, which lead to the great wheel. At the lower end of this inclined plane or spout is fixt a small wheel, which is put into motion by spokes fixt on the rim or outward edge of the great wheel, which turns the balls separately on itself to con- tinue the motion.^* 1786.— Thomas Mead [No. 1543], of Sandwich, Kent, carpenter. ^^An automaton or machine upon a self-moving principle, which when in motion, will acquire and preserve velocity and force sufiicient to work every kind of mill, crane, pump, and all other engines and machines in general, and give motion to any sort of carriage or vessel.^^ This invention con- OB, 8EABCH FOB SXLF-MOTIYE FOWEB. 65 sjsts of ** a square frame of wood boarded close on the under side ; square posts of wood fixed into the bottom frame and top frame, boarded top and bottom, in which box moves a circular board, carrying the flies, wheel work, &c." And a complicated affair it is, to be sure. However, the patentee says, '* When this machinery is to be put in motion, the bottom frame, tube, and box, are to be filled with water, mercury, or some other fluid/* How it was intended to work is doubtful ; that it never did do daty is certain. 1790.— CoNBADTJS ScHwiEBS [No. 1746], of Hoztony Middlesex, Doctor in Divinity. ^*A machine on a self- moving principle, or perpetual motion/* ** Now know ye, that in obedience of the said letters patent, and the proviso therein contained, I, the said Conradus Schwiers, do hereby declare my said new invented self*moving principle, or perpetual motion, is made and performed in manner following, that is to say : — ^ Two stiles or uprights marked in the plan (see opposite page) hereunto annexed, A, A, c&c, and fastened together by the • screws 1, 2, 3, and to the base at 4, 4, 4, 4, between which stiles or uprights run the wheel C, and the pinion D, and the two double pinions D, D, &c, over which double pinions runs the double chain E, E, &c., to which chain are fixed the bucketts F, F, &c. The chain is made with joints on each side and bans running across, equal in number to the cogs of the wheel C. Upon the same axle with the wheel C, on the farther side of the inner stile A, runs the wheel G, whose diameter is full double that of the wheel C ; and the pivot of the wheel G runs in the back H as the other pivot of the same axle runs in the front stile A. The wheel G is divided near the periphery into receptacles in number equal to the buckets on the chain, which receptacles are supplied with metal balls I, I, &c. from the buckets F, F, &c. by means of the gutter K, which balls by their weight forcing round the wheel G, and thereby lifting up the buckets F, F, &c. on one side as they go down on the other side, discharge themselves again at the gutter L, where they are taken up by the buckets F, F, &c., and discharged again at the gutter K, and are so repeated in a constant sue- oeasion as often as any receptacle is vacant in the wheel Gat 66 FESPETUUM mobile; the gutter K for their reception, and by thai means the per- petual revolution is obtained, the upper ball being at the same time discharged from one bucket i^hea the lower ball is taken up by another.'* * 1790.— John Haywood [No. 1750], of Long Acre, Mid- dlesex, draftsman and mechanic ^^ A machine for working mills and engines without the aid of fire, water, or wind, or in aid of all or any of those or any other powers.*^ ^* The machine acts on a rotative principle, or, in other words, has a revolving circular or circulating motion round an axis, center, or centers. It may be made or constructed of any materials or matter whatsoever, so it be of sufficient strength to sustain the power of action when applied to any mill, engine, or machine to which action or motion can or may be communicated by a wheel. The size or dimensions of this machine are by no means confined, but may be varied or altered as circumstances may require. ^^ References to the drawings of the machine hereunto annexed : — Fig. 1 is the section of the machine. A, A, B^ a cranked or double center, fixed to the stand or frame £> by • the bolts £. C, C, the wheel which turns or revolves round that part of the cranked center mark A« F, levers which turn or revolve round the cranked centf r B. G, G, rollers or weights which revolve in the circular guides or grooves by means of the leavers F. H, H, circular grooves or guides which are affixed to the inner sides of the wheeL N.B. — The distance from A to B is the radius in all cases to determine the space between the center of the guide or groove H and the center of the roller or weight G. The distance of the two concentric circles which form the guides or grooves H must be equal to the diameter of the roller or weight G. I, I, springs which stop the rollers or weights G from returning when at the horizontal diameter of the wheel. K, weights, which may be increased or diminished at pleasure. L, ledges which con- nect the sides of the wheel together. N.B. — By fixing cogs or teeth on the rim of the wheel, so as to connect it with any * Copied from the original specification. The same also occnrs in The Repertory of Arts and Manufactures, first series, vol. 7, 8vo., 1797, Art. XXIII., p. 165. OK, SEJULCH FOB SELF-MOTITE POWEK. 67 mill, machrne, or engine to which motion can be given by a wheel, the power of this machine may be communicated." {Fig. 1.) 1794.— Thomas Mead [No. 1979]^ of Sculcoates, York, engineer* ^^ Certain methods of exerting, putting, and con- tinuing in motion pneumatic chemical or pneumato-chemical apparatus.'* This is an arrangement of pipes, cylinders, stop- cocks, and ^^ a hollow fire grate," of which it would be folly PEBPETTHTM MOBILE; to quote the description ; indeed, the patentee himself com- placently states — ^^ it was not for any particular apparatus for which the letters patent were granted !" 1797. — RiCHABD Vabley [No. 2181], of Damside, Lanca- shire, merchant. ^ A new perpetual moving power.'* ^^My invention consists of a method of applying the weight of the atmosphere upon a wheel in any other fluid, and by that means destroying its spring or reaction, the manner of doing which I describe as follows, agreeable to the drawing (Fig. 6) annexed : — " A is a circular vessel, made of copper or any other sub- stance, capable of containing water, and covered with a top part so as to be perfectly air tight. B is a wheel placed in the inside of the vessel, with its axle perpendicular, the uppermost part of which comes thro' the top of the vessel, and is made to work air-tight; the lower end runs in a step within the vessel, and no part of the wheel is to touch the vessel but its axis. C is a cylinder placed firmly upon the wheel. D is the piston, suspended by a chain to a strong spring fixed on the wheel* This spring is to be made of such strength as that when the whole weight of the atmosphere is upon the piston the air will only move it about one inch down. E is the tube leading from the axle, which is hollow from the top to the level of the wheel, so as to admit the external air by this tube to the piston D, which piston is a circular vessel, made air-tight, and exactly fits the cylinder. There is a joint in the tube E at F, which is made air-tight by leathers, so that when the piston descends the tube may give way to it. G is a small tube leading from the bottom of the cylinder to the center of the axle, and from thence brought out at the end of it, and by which the air is ex- tracted from the cylinder by means of an air pump, and a vacuum formed in it. On the top part, or any other con- venient place of the vessel, are fixed two cylinders or tubes, of a proportional size to the cylinders on the wheel, one of which is a condensing cylinder, by means of a screw and piston, and by which the water in the vessel may be compressed ; the other has its piston suspended at the bottom, and the top part of the fjjff^der being filled with air, as the other piston is OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 69 screwed down this rises, and condenses the air in the cylinder, the spring of which keeps the water in the vessel pressed to all parts alike ; and when the air is extracted from the cylinder C, and the piston D is forced down by the external atmosphere into the cylinder, this pressure is continued, and the condensed air expands in proportion, and prevents any tendency to a vacuum being formed, which would cause a cohesion of all the parts. By this means the external air is suspended upon the 70 PEKPETUUM mobile; wheel by the chain, the same as a weight, aod the spring of the atmosphere being taken from the cylinder, there is nothing to oppose this weight, there being no spring in water ; and this power may be increased in proportion to the size and number of cylinders on the wheel and its diameter.^'* The following strictures on Mr. Varley's machine for pro- ducing perpetual motion occur in the "Monthly Magazine :" — On the 23rd May, 1797, letters patent were granted to Mr. Richard Varley, of Damside, Bolton-le-Moor, county of Lan- caster, cotton manufacturer, for a machine for producing per- petual motion. The ignorant and prejudiced part of mankind have in all ages attached a folly to the pursuit of yarious mysteries of nature and science ; such as the ascertaining the longitude at sea, the variation of the magnetic needle, the transmuta- tion of metals, the quadrature of the circle, the adhesion of metallic particles, the repulsion of atmospheric particles, the essential differences between bodies to the exclusion of their attributes, and perpetual motion. The last has been thought, in the general meaning of the term, to be the most chimeri- cal, because all machines are composed of perishable sub- stances. Mr. Varley's discovery of a new perpetual power appears, however, to promise as much utility as steam, wind, water, or any other force requisite for working mechanical apparatus. We present our readers beneath with the form of the opened superfices of his apparatus, with this peculiar advan- tage that it never diminishes its force, while the machine upon which it acts preserves its original form and solidity. [Here follows a description, as given in foregoing specifi- cation.] Thus, having described the machine, it appears that the principle of the discovery of the new power is effected by " converging the weight of the atmosphere on a wheel in any other fluid, and by that means destroying the repulsive quality, or re-action of the air." * Copied from the original patent. A copy is published in The Repertory of Arts and Manufactures, 8vo, 1799, vol. 10, first series, p. 9. OB, SEA&CH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 71 The process Mr. Varley pursues in effecting his purpose is as follows : — ^The copper vessel is filled with water or any other fluid, with the other apparatus in it as hefore described. It is then closed with the cover, and by means of leather on the edges is made perfectly air-tight. In this condition, with the help of an air-pump, a vacuum is formed in the larger cylinder, over which cylinder is a spring that is acted upon by the condensed air conveyed into the piston through the tube F, and that produces the action of tiie wheel, because water has no spring. It is found that upon every square inch of the earth's sur- face there exists a weight of nearly sixteen pounds of common air, and that a column of mercury, whose elevation will be thirty inches, and its base one cubic inch, will weigh fifteen pounds avoirdupoise, at the rate of eight ounces for every cubic inch of mercury. Since this atmospheric power can be condensed by various means, the formation therefore of the vacuum in the cylinder, and the pressure of the condensed air against it, of course produces the revolution of the wheel, which is the effect sought for. The cylinders can be increased on the radii, or wheel-spokes, to any weight, as also may the condensed air. Consequently, if a toothed segment or cogged wheel of any description is fitted to it, it will receive the full action of the weight of the atmo- sphere as its impulsive power, and may be easily applied to any machine in the same manner as if it were acted upon by steam, wind, water, horses, weight, spring, or any description of muscular power necessary to produce motion.* The following is an editorial Note to Correspondents in « Nicholson's Journal of Philosophy, &c." 4to. 1797. Vol.1, p. 334:— I should be glad to give a description and drawing of Mr. Varley's machine for producing perpetual motion, as requested by Mr. Notlem, of Wisbech, if an attentive perusal of the specification enrolled in Chancery had shewn me any- thing tending to improve the theory or practice of mechanics. The description in the periodical work he mentions is not sufficiently clear to shew the whole of what the writer • The Monthly Magazine for 1797. Vol. 4 (July No.), p. 58. 72 PEBPETITUM mobile; meant to explain, and I found the original equally imperfect. Mr. Varley's notion, obscured by some extraneous and unim- portant circumstances, appears to be, that if an exhausted cylinder be fixed to one part of the periphery of a wheel, and a piston fitted therein, the pressure of. the atmosphere on tliis last, supposed also to be attached to the wheel by a spring and chain (parallel to a tangent), will tend to drive it into the vacuum, and, if prevented by the shortness of the chain, will draw the wheel round. It is obvious to any person acquainted with statics, that the pressures on his wheel must counter- balance each other, and cannot produce motion. It has always been easy to shew the fallacy of schemes for perpetual motion in the particular instances ; but I have met with no clear enunciation of this project so general as to include every possible scheme, and evince its own absurdity. The difficulty of performing tiiis seems to arise from a want of direct and concise demonstrations of the fundamental principles of the lever, and the equal pressure of fluids in all directions. Mr. Nicholson, in consequence of Mr. Varley's and Dr. Schwiers' patents, wrote as follows : — On the Meehankal Projects for affording a Perpetual Motion. In consequence of the notice* taken of Mr. Varley's attempt to produce a perpetual motion, I have been requested by several correspondents to state how far the mechanical scheme for which Dr. Conrad Shiviersf took out a patent in the year 1790, for the same object, may be worthy of atten- tion. I have, on that occasion, mentioned the difficulties which have prevented any clear general demonstration of the absurdity of this pursuit from being produced, though it has not been difficult to shew the fallacy of the individual plans. It does not, indeed, seem easy to enunciate the scheme itself. What, in universal terms, is the thing proposed to be done ? Is it to cause a body to act in such a manner that the re- ac- tion shall be greater than the action itself, and by that means generate force by the accumulation of the surplus ? Or, can • Nicholson's Phil. Jour. 4to. Page 334. t Read~-Dr. Schwiers. OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIYE FOWEB. 73 tite motion communicated be greater than that lost by the agent? Since these positions are evidently contrary to the physical axioms called the laws of nature, and frictions and resistances would speedily destroy all motions of simple uniformity, it may be presumed that S* Gravesande, who thought that all the demonstrations of the absurdity of schemes for perpetual motion contained paralogism, would haye stated the proposition under different terms. But, without entering upon this apparently unprofitable disquisi- tion, it may be useful, as well as entertaining, to make a few observations on the mechanical contrivances which depend on a mistaken deduction from the general theorem respecting the balance, among which that of Dr. Shiviers''^ must be classed. There is no doubt'but numerous arrangements have been made, and still are laboured at by various individuals, to pro- duce a machine which shall possess the power of moving itself perpetually, notwithstanding the inevitable loss by fric- tion and resistance of the air. Little, however, of these abortive exertions has been entered upon record. The plans of Bishop Wilkins, the Marquis of Worcester, and M. Orfy- reus, are all which at this time occur to my recollection. There is no doubt but the celebrated Wilkins was a man of learning and ability. His essay towards a real character and a philosophical language is sufficient to render his name immortaL Twenty years before the appearance of that work, lie published his '^ Mathematical Magic," namely, in the year 16&, containing 295 pages, small octavo, which, from the nnmber of copies still in being, I suppose to have been a very popular treatise. It is in this work that I find, among other contrivances for the same purpose, a wheel carrying sixteen loaded arms, similar to that deHneated in Fig. 4, plate 16, in which, however, for the sake of simplicity, I have drawn but six. Each lever, A B C D E F, is moveable through an angle of 45^, by a joint near the circumference of the wheel, and the inner end or tail of each is confined by two studs or pins, so that it must either lie in the direction of a radius, or else in the required position of obliquity. If the wheel be now supposed to move in the direction E F, it is evident that the levers A B C D, by hanging in the oblique • Read — Dr. Schwiers. 74 PEBPETUTJM mobile; position against the antecedent pins, will describe a less circle in their ascent than when, on the other side, they come to descend in the positions E F. Hence, it was expected that the descending weights, having the advantage of a longer lever, would always predominate. Dr. Wilkins, by referring the weights to an horizontal diameter, has shewn that in his machine they will not. A popular notion of this result may also be gathered from the figure, where there are three weights on the ascending, and only two on the descend- ing side; the obliquity of position giving an advantage in point of number, equal to what the other side may possess in (Fig. 4, pi 15.) intensity. Or, if this contrivance were to be strictly ex- amined, on the supposition that the levers and weights were indefinitely numerous, the question would be determined by shewing that the circular arcs A K, H I, are in equilibrio with the arcs A G, G L. The simplest method of examining any scheme of this kind with weights, consists in enquiring whether the perpen- dicular ascents and descents would be performed with equal masses in equal times. If so, there will be no preponder- OB, 8EAECH P0» SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 75 ance, and, consequently, no motion. This is clearly the case witii the contrivance before us. The Marquis of Worcester, who will ever be remembered as the inventor of the steam engine, has described a perpetual motion in the fifty-sixth No.* of his " Century of Inventions," published in the year 1655, and since reprinted in 1767 by tiie Foulis's at Glasgow. His words were as follow : — " To provide and make, that all the weights of the de- scending side of a wheel shall be perpetually further from the centre than those of the mounting side, and yet equal in number and heft to the one side as the other. A most incre- dible thing if not seen, but tried before the late King (of blessed memory) in the Tower by my directions, two extraor- dinary ambassadors accompanying his Majesty, and the Duke of Richmond and Duke Hamilton, with most of the Court, attending him. The wheel was fourteen feet over, and forty weights of fifty pounds a-piece. Sir William Balfour, then Lieutenant of the Tower, can justify it with several others^ They all saw, that no sooner these great weights passed the diameter line of the lower side, but they hung a foot further from the centre ; nor no sooner passed the diameter line of the upper side, but they hung a foot nearer. Be pleased to judge the consequence." Desaguliers, in his *' Course of Experimental Philosophy,'* vol. 1, page 185, has quoted this passage, and given a sketch of a pretended self-moving wheel, similar to Fig. 5, plate 16, as resembling the contrivance mentioned by the Marquis of Worcester. The description of this last engineer agrees, how- ever, somewhat better with the contrivance Fig. 4. It must, of course, be a mistake in terms, when he says the weight receded from the centre at the lower diameter, and approached towards it at the upper : the contrary being in fact necessary to a£ford any hope of success ; and accordingly in the quota- tion it is so stated. I am, therefore, disposed to think that Fig. 5 represents the wheel of Orfyreus at Hesse Cassel, much talked of about the year 1720, and which probably was made to revolve, during the time of exhibition, by some concealed apparatus. It consists of a number of cells or partitions, distinguished by the letters of the alphabet, which are made between the interior and exterior surfaces of two concentric * 1663 is the date of the first printed edition, and 1359 date of the MS. 76 PEEPETUFM mobile; cylinders. The partitions being placed obliquely with respect, to the radius, a cylindrical or spherical weight placed on each, {Fig, 5, pi, 15,) it is seen from the figure, that these weights will lie against: the inner surface of the large cylinder whenever the outer end of the bottom partition of any cell is lowest ; and, on the contrary, when that extremity is highest, the weight will rest on the surface of the interior cylinder. Let the wheel be made to revolve in the direction ABC; the weights in C D* E F G H I being close to the external circle, and the weights K L M A B close to the inner, for the reasons last mentioned. As the cell B descends, its weight will likewise run out, at the same time that the weight in the cell I will run in, in conse- quence of its partition being elevated. By the continuation of this process, since all the weights on the descending side pass down at a greater distance from the centre, while those of the ascending side rise for a considerable part of their ascent at a less distance from the same point, it is concluded that the wheel will continue to maintain its motion. On this, however, it is to be remarked, that the perpendicular ascent and descent are alike, both in measure and in time of per- formance ; and that the familiar examination, even to those who know little of such subjects, is sufficient to show that the preponderance is not quite so palpable as at first it appears. For the weights G and F, H and £, I and D are evidently in equilibrio, because at the same horizontal dis- tance from the centre ; and if the favourable supposition that OB, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 77 the weight B hath already ran out be admitted, it will then remain a question whether these two exterior weights, B and C, can preponderate over the four inner weights, K L M A. The more accurate examination of this particular contrivance will lead to thefollowing theorem : — In two concentric circles, if tangents be drawn at the extreme points of a diameter of the smaller, and continued till they intersect the larger, the common centre of gravity of the arc of the greater circle included between the^tangents, and of the half periphery of the smaller circle on the opposite side of the diameter, will be the common centre of the circles. If, therefore, the balls were indefinitely numerous and small, the supposed effective parts of the wheel (Fig. 6) would be in equilibrio, as well as the parts beneath the horizontal tangent of the inner circle. Fig. 6 represents the contrivance of Dr. Shiviers,* which, in a periodical publication, in other particulars respectable, has been said to continue in motion for weeks and even months together. There is not the smallest probability that it should continue in motion for half a minute, or nearly as long as a sifnple wheel would retain part of its first impulse. The external circle denotes a wheel carrying a number of buckets, ABIL, &c. C represents a toothed wheel, on the same axis, which drives a pinion D ; and this last drives another pinion £ upon the axis of a lanthom, or wheel intended to work a chain-pump with the same number of buckets as in the larger wheel A B I. The lanthom G is made of such a size as to receive the buckets abil with a due velocity. K represents a gutter, through which a metallic ball, contained in the bucket m, may run and lodge itself in the bucket A of the wheel. Each of the buckets of the wheel, B I L M, which are below the gutter, is supplied with a metallic ball, and so likewise are the ascending buckets, a b il m, of the chain-pump. As the pump supplies the wheel, it is again supplied at M, where the balls fall into its ascending buckets. Now, it is presumed that the balls in the wheel, I suppose on account of their distance from the centre of motion, will descend with more than sufficient force to raise those on the chain, and, conse- quently, that the motion will be perpetual. The deception in this contrivance has much less seduction than in the two foregoing, because it is more easily referred • Should be Dr. Schwiers. The patent bears date 1790 [No. 1745]. 78 PEBPETUUM mobile; to the simple lever. This, like the others, exhihits no pro- spect of success, when tried by the simple consideration of (Fig. 6, pi. 15.) the equality of the ascent' and descent in the whole time of the rotation of a single ball. It may also be shewn, from the principles of wheel-work, which are familiar to artisans, that whatever is gained by the excess of the diameter of the great wheel beyond that of the wheel C, is again lost by the excess of the lanthom A beyond the pinion E. OK, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER.. 79 The fundamental proposition of the simple lever or balance, that equal bodies at an equal distance from the fulcrum will equiponderate, but that at unequal distances the most remote mU descend, has in these and numberless other instances led mechanical workmen and speculators to pursue tbis fruitless enquiry with labour and expense often ill-a£forded, and with a degree of anxiety and infatuation which can hardly be con- ceived by those who have never suffered the pain of hope long deferred. For this reason chiefly, it has appeared de- sirable and useful to treat the subject in a familiar way, without descending to those expressions of contempt, whicb igno- rance, harmless to aU but itself, is surely not entitied to. If such reasoners were well convinced that the power of a machine is to be estimated by the excess of motion referred to the perpendicular, without any regard to the apparent centre of the machine, and that in machines very little com- pounded it is possible to produce effects directly contrary to the rule which is true of the simple lever, they would proba- bly renounce many flattering projects, grounded only on the supposition of its universality. Desaguliers contrived an apparatus in which two equal weights may be placed at any distance whatever from the centre of motion, and still con- Compound Balance^ (Fig. 3, pi 15.) tinue in equilibrio. Fig. 3 represents this instrument. A D denotes a balance with equal arms, and E F another of the 80 FEBFETTJinC MOBILE; same cdmensions. These move on the centres B and C, and are connected by the inflexible rods A E and D F; the motion being left free by means of joints at the comers. Across the rods A D, E F, are fixed two bars, I E, L M. Now, it is unnecessary to shew that the weight G will de- scribe exactly the same line or circular arc, when the leyers are moyed into the position a d/e^ or any other position, as it would have described in case it had been suspended at A, or E, or E ; and that it is of no consequence in this respect at what part of the line A E or I K it be fixed. The same observations are true of the weight H on the other side. And accordingly it is found that these equal weights may be suspended anywhere on the lines I E and L M without alter- ing their equilibrium. By this contrivance it is most evidently proved, to those who are totally imacquainted with the theory, that weights do not preponderate in compound engines, on account of their distance from the centre. Several other contrivances may be made to the same efiect. The following combination of (Fig, 2, pL 15.) OK, SEAKCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 81 wheel-work presented itself to me as one which would most probably be mistaken for a perpetual motion. (Fig. 2, plate 15.) The dye circles represent the same number of wheels, of equal diameter and number of teeth, acting together. The middle wheel A is fixed between two upright pillars, so that it cannot revolye. The other four wheels are pinned in a frame H I, in which they can revolve, and through which the axis of A likewise passes. From the extremity of the axis of D, and also of d^ proceed the horizontal levers H K and I U which are equal, and point in the same direction parallel to the plane of the wheels. At the extremity of these arms hang the equal weights P and p. Let it now be imagined that the end I of the frame is depressed, the wheel B will turn round by the re-action of the fixed wheel A in the same direction as H I, and it will make one revolution in the same time relative to the frame, or two with regard to absolute space, by reason of its being carried round. The action of B upon D will produce a rotation relative to the frame in the opposite direction during the same time. Instead, therefore, of two revolutions, like the wheel B, this wheel D, with regard to absolute space, will not revolve at all, and in every posi- tion of the apparatus the arm I L will continue horizontal, and point the same way. For similar reasons, the arm H K will retain its position. Consequently, it is seen that the descending weight will move at a great horizontal distance from the centre N, while the ascending weight rises very near that centre. But there will not on this account be a perpe- tual motion : for the action of the levers H K and I L upon the frame H I, by means of the toothed wheels, will in the detail be found precisely alike, and in the general considera- tion of the motions of P and p, the opposite motions in the circle E F G will be accurately the same. It has always been considered as essential to a perpetual motion, that it should be derived from some energy which is not supposed to vary in its intensity. Such are the inertia, the gravity or magnetism of bodies. For an occasional or periodical variation of intensity in any force is evidently pro- ductive of motion, which requires only to be accumulated or applied, and the apparatus for applying it cannot be con- sidered as a machine for perpetual motion. Neither, in strict- ness, can any machine whose motion is derived from the rotation of the earth, and the consequent change of seasons 62 PEKPETUUM mobile; and rotation of events, be to considered, because it does not generate, but only communicates. The perpetual flow of rivers ; the vicissitudes of the tides ; the constant, periodical and variable winds ; the expansions and contractions of air, mercury, or other fluids, by daily or other changes of tem- perature ; the diflferences of expansions in metals, by the same change ; the rise and fall of the mercury in the baro- meter ; the hygrometric chang:e8 in the remains of organized beings, and every other mutation which continually happens around us, may be applied to give motion to mills, clocks, and other engines, which may be contrived to endure as long as the apparatus retains its figure.* 1801. — Specification of the Patent granted to Joseph Gaston John Baptiste, Count de Thiville [2472], of Piccadilly, in the County of Middlesex t for " Certain new methods of giving an independent moving power to all machines, by means of hydraulic engines ; and also of constructing and employing separately several of their parts, such as wheels, pistons, and apparatus for reducing friction, upon new principles,** — Dated February 5, 1801. To all to whom these presents shall come, &c. Now know ye, that in compliance with the said proviso, I, the said Joseph Gaston John Baptiste, Count de Thiville, do hereby declare, that my said invention consists in the application of certain hydrostatical principles not at all or but little known till now, which contrary to the laws of statics in solid bodies, give to incompressible fluids the property of rising almost spontaneously above the place from which they have fallen. Without accounting for the causes, I will con- fine myself to eflects founded on experiments, and give some specimens of these prin- ciples, and of the conse- quences resulting therefrom. Let Fig. 1 be an empty tube, (Fig, 1, pL 14.) ^^^ stopped at bottom or top ♦ A Journal of Natural Philosophy, Chemistn', and the Arts. By WUliam Nicholson. Vol. 1. 4to. 17S>7. Page 875. OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 83 air-tight. If it be immersed into water and suddenly opened, the fluid will rise to a, fall to b, rise again to c, and so on till it flx itself at d, which is the level of the fluid. [He then proceeds to describe Fig. 2 as "a vertical sec- tion of a chest fastened in a large reservoir or pond." Four other figures are given to illustrate this plan on the preceding principle of giving motion to machinery. That he had not reduced his plans to practice, appears from the following : — ] At what height, in what quEintity, and at what expence of power can the water be raised, are likewise liable to great variations, and can only be ascertained by experiments on large scales, and in open water. [Some " Observations by the Patentee ** are added, on *' Friction in Fluids," on " Resistance of Fluids," and] Pebpetuax Motion. — ^Without prejudging anything upon the principles I have introduced in my specification, — which principles I consider as a theorem from which every one may draw the corollaries, — I will confine myself within the limits I have prescribed, and propose the following problem : — — 'H^ ^-■M J=^^^=^^ f:^~-^:37ED\\\\\\\\lJ ■==^=^^^^^^^=^^^^!SSSS 5::-- ^ r^ NhSwS ~. — -. ^-r-^ rr-'TT":'z~;^ {Fig. 13, pL 14.) Let A (Fig. 13) be a wheel or cylinder turning on its gudgeon b; ece is an assemblage of sheets of any material 84 PERPETUUM mobile; or stuff; these sheets pass between thin plates or wires fastened in a fixed box, ii; at o o they pass freely between small cylinders or rollers, turning in another fixed box, V. Instead of being so separated, they may be pressed close to each other by passing between two rollers, u u. Thus, the apparatus being so disposed, and the level of the water being as at 6? ^, I say the phenomenon of spontaneous ascent of fluids in capillary tubes or spaces, ought to take place between the sheets at i i ; and it ought not to do so at o o, or at u «, by their being too close to or distant from each other. That being established, 1 represent by Y the power acquired by the ascent of the fluid at i i ; I represent by Z the mechanical resistance occasioned by the rubbing of the sheets against the cylinders at o o, or by their pressure at u u Now, I ask how, and at what point, the laws which preside over the phenomena of nature at i i, and those which regulate the mechanical effect at o o or t/ ti, coincide so as to determine a constant ratio between the power and the resistance; and finally, what is the ratio between Y and Z. It is obvious that if Z is greater than or equal to Y, the machine will remain immovable. If, on the contrary, Y is greater than Z, the machine once put in motion will never stop.* ♦ The Repertory of Arts and Manufactures. 8vo. 1801. Vol. 14, p. 289. OB, SEAKCH FOK SEXF-ITOTIVE rOWER. 85 CHAPTER IV. BABLT PAPEBS FBOM THE PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS, AND SIB BOBEBT BOYLE ; ALSO THE PABIS ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, WITH NOTICES OF COMMUNICATIONS TO THE ACADEMY, 1837-56. Nothing later than 1733 appears to have heen brought before the Royal Society on Perpetual Motion, and the follow- ing papers are chiefly remarkable as being derived from its Transactions : — Observations of Dr* Paphiy Fellow of the Royal Society, on a French Paper concerning a Perpetual Motion. The paper printed in French, and containing a contrivance for perpetual motion, being set down in such a manner that can hardly be understood but by those that are much ac- quainted with such descriptions, I have endeavour' d to explain it as follows : — Let D E F be a pair of bellows forty inches long, that may be open'd by re- moving the part F from E ; let them be exactly shut everywhere but at the aperture E ; and let a pipe E G, twenty or twenty-two inches long, be soldered to the sayd aperture E, having its other end in a vessel G, full of mercury, and placed near the middle of the bellows. A is an axis for the bellows to turn upon. B, a counterpoise fastened to the lower end of the bellows. C, a weight with a clasp to keep the bellows upright. Now, rf we suppose the bellows open' d only to i or J, standing upright, and full of mercury, it is plain that the sayd mercury, being forty inches high, must fall, as in the Torricellian experiment, to the height of about twenty-seven inches, and, consequently, the bellows must open towards F, and leave a vacuity there. This vacuity must be {Fiq. 184, ph 5.) 86 PEKPETUUM mobile; filled with the mercury ascending from G through the pipe G E, the sayd pipe being but twenty-two inches long; by this means the bellows must be opened more and more, till the mercury continuing to ascend makes the upper part of the bellows so heavy that the lower part must get loose from the clasp C, and the bellows should turn quite upside down ; but (Fig, 185, pi. 5.) the vessel G being set in a convenient place, keeps them horizontal, and the part F engageth there in another clasp C ; then the mercury, by its weight, nms out from the bellows into the vessel G through the pipe E G, and the bel- lows must shut closer and closer untill the part E F comes to be so light that the counterpoise B is able to make the part F get loose from the clasp C ; then the bellows come to be upright again ; the mercury left in them falls again to the height of twenty-seven inches, and, consequently, all the other effects will follow as we have already seen, and the motion will continue for ever. Thus much for the French author. Upon this it is to be observed, that the bellows can never be opened by the internal pressure, imless the sayd pressure be stronger then the extemall ; now, in this case, the weight of the atmosphere doth freely press up the outward part of the bellows, but it cannot come at the inward part but through the pipe G E, which, containing twenty-two perpendi- cular inches of mercury, doth counterpoise so much of the weight of the atmosphere, so that this being supposed to be twenty-seven inches of mercury, it cannot press the inward part of the bellows but with a weight equivalent to five per- pendicular inches of mercury. From this we may conclude, OR, SEIKCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 87 that the pressure of the atmosphere, being weakened within the bellows more then it can be helpt by the mercury con- tained in the same, as may easily be computed, the sayd bellows standing upright must rather shut then open. Thus, without losing any labour and charges in trying, people may be sure that the thing can never do.* Some further Remarhs on the Instrument proposed hy an Anomymous French Author for effecting a Perpetual Motion, an account whereof isgioen in No* 177 of these Transactions. By Dr. Fapin, M.D. , R.S. S. Having seen in the " Journal des Savans " of May 13, and in the " Nouvelles de la Republique des Lettres " of the month of Jime, that the author of the perpetual motion is not satisfied, but doth endeavour to answer the objection that I propounded against his contrivance in the " Philosophical Transactions " of the month of December, 1685, I find I must explain myself more at large than I' did in that paper ; but I begg his pardon if I say nothing concerning the new disposition which he says might be given to his engine. My want of time makes me avoid new matters of dispute, and I think it enough for me, if I do but shew that his first descrip- tion can never succeed. I am very sorry that this author took so much trouble in trying his bellows with several liquors, as oyl, mercury, water. I thought I had sayd nothing that might make him believe that I did in the least question the truth, which he intended to prove against me by those experiments ; and without any tryals I am ftdly enough convinced, that the mercury in his engine must follow the laws of the sequilibrium of fluid bodies. But the consequence which he draws from that prin- ciple seems to me very groimdless ; for, altho' the lowermost part of the bellows be presst by the weight of forty inches of mercury, it doth not follow that all the parts which are situ- ated higher must bear the same pressure. To the quite con- trary, it is plain that the upper part, having no mercury above it, bears none at all ; the parts that lye in the middle near the axes of the bellows bear but twenty inches, and so all the * The Philosophical Transactions. Vol. 15, for the year 1685. 4to. Page 1240. Also, the Phil. Trans, and Collections to the end of the year 1700, abridged, in 3 vols. By John Lowthorp, M.A. and F.11.S. Vol. I,4to.,l70o, p. 592. 88 PEKPETUXJM mobile; rest must bear more or less according as they lye higher or lower. It is evident, therefore, that there are as many parts that bear less then twenty inches as there are that bear more, and the increase of pressure following an arithmetical pro- gression, it is undenyable that all these pressures added toge- ther will do no more than one uniform pressure that would be equal to twenty inches everywhere. Having thus found the quantity of pressure caused by the mercury within the bellows, we must remember that the pres- sure of the atmosphere within the same bellows is equivalent but to five inches, as I observed in my first paper, vid, " Philo- sophical Transaction," No. 177, page 1241 : so that we find that the inward pressure is equivalent but to twenty-five inches of mercury in all. Now, the pressure of the atmo- sphere upon the outside is everywhere equal to twenty-seven inches ; from whence it appears that the pressure without is stronger than the pressure within, and so I had reason to say, that the bellows standing upright, must rather shut than open. I did not think to have given this computation so at large, but I have been necessitated to do it (as I said in the begin- ning), since my first paper was not sufficient to make me be imderstood by the author of the perpetual motion. However, I will be careful to save the time of the reader as much as I can ; and although I might observe some other things in his description that will increase the difficulty of opening the bellows, I forbear to speak of them, and I will stick only to that which is most material, and make his perpetual motion to be altogether impossible. As for the argument the author drawes from comparing his engine to an ordinary siphon, I do beseech him to consider what a difierence there is between a siphon that lets the water rim down at the bottom, and his engine, that should gather up the heavy liquor into the highest part of the instru- ment, and I do not question but he will acknowledge the weakness of this argument.* An answer of Dr. Papin to the Author of the Perpetual Motion. In the last papers I published in " Philosophical Transac- tion " No. 184, against this perpetual motion described in • The Philosophical Transactions. Vol.16, for the years 1686 and 1687. No 182, June, 16.S6, p. 138. OR, SEARCH FOR SELT'-MOTIVE POWER. 89 No. 177j I intreated the author to permit me to say nothing as to what alterations he might make in his engine, resolving to leave it to others to shew him that upon that principle aU he can do signifies nothing. But I find since, in the " Nou- Yelles de la Kepublique " for December last, that he still per- sists to urge some new contrivances, which being added, he conceives his engine must succeed. To this I answer, that I undertook only to shew that his first device woidd faile, which yet I should scarce have done if I had thought a dispute of this nature could have lasted so long. To come, therefore, to the point where he saith that this engine may well succeed without alteration, because he hath tryed with liquors put into bellows immersed in water ; I again say that I grant him the truth of the experiments, but deny the consequences he would draw from them. I have already given the reasons of my dissent, which this gentleman is not pleased to imder- stand. But to end all controversies, he may please to con- sult Mr. Perrault, De la Hire, or any other at Paris well known to be skilled in hydraulicks, and I doubt not but he will find them of the same opinion with Mr. Boyle, Mr. Hook, and other knowing persons here, who all agree that our author is in this matter under a mistake.* A Proposition on the Balance^ not taken notice of by Mechanical Writers, explained and confirmed by an Experiment. By the Rev. J. TrDesaguliert, LL,D., F.R.S. Theor. 6. — ^A B is a balance, on which is supposed to hang at one end, B, the scale E, with a man in it, who is counterpoised by the weight W hanging at A, the other end of the balance. I say, that if such a man, with a cane or any rigid straight body, pushes upwards against the beam anywhere between the points C and B (provided he does not push directly against B), he will thereby make himself heavier, or overpoise the weight W, though the stop G G hinders the scale E from being thrust outwards from C towards G G. I say likewise, that if the scale and man should hang from D, the man, by pushing upwards against B, or anywhere between B and D (provided he does not push directly against D), will make himself lighter, or be •"* The Philosophical Transactions. Vol. 16, 1686-7. No. 186, January, 1687, p. 267. 90 PEBPETUUM MOBILE ; overpoised by the weight W, which before did only counter- poise the weight of his body and the scale. If the common center of gravity of the scale E, and the man supposed to stand in it, be at k, and the man, by thrust- ing against any part of the beam, cause the scale to move outwards so as to carry the said common center of gravity to 'A X, then, instead of B E, hi will become the line of diec- tion of the compound weight, whose action will be increased in the ratio of L C to B C. This is what has been explained by several writers of mechanics ; but no one, that I know of, has considered the case when the scale is kept from flying oat, as here by the post G G, which keeps it in its place, as if the strings of the scale were become inflexible. Now, to explain this case, let us suppose the length B D of half of the brachium B C to be equal to 3 feet, the line B E to 4 feet, the line E D of 5 feet to be the direction in which the man pushes, D F and F E to be respectively equal and parallel to B E and B D, and the whole or absolute force with which the man pushes equal to (or able to rise) 10 stone. Let the oblique force ED ( = 10 stone) be resolved into the two E F and E B (or its equal F D) whose directions are at right angles to each other, and whose respective quantities (or intensities) are as 6 and 8, because E F and B E are in that proportion to each other and to E D. Now, since E F is parallel to B D C A, the beam, it does no way affect the beam to move it upwards ; and therefore there is only the force represented by F D, or 8 stone, to push the beam upwards at D. For the same reason, and because action and reaction are equal, the scale will be pushed down at E with the force of 8 stone also. Now, since the force at E pulls the beam perpendicularly downwards from the point B, dis- tant from C the whole length of the brachium B C, its action downwards will not be diminished, but may be expressed by 8 X B C ; whereas the action upwards against D will be half lost, by reason of the diminished distance from the center, and is only to be expressed by 8 x^Ji ; and when the action upwards to raise the beam is substracted from the action downwards to depress it, there will still remain 4 stone to push down the scale ; because 8 x B C — 8 x^^ = 4 B C. 2 Consequently, a weight of 4 stone must be added at the end OB, SEABCH FOB SBLF-MOTIYE POITEB. 93 A to restore the sequilibrium. Therefore a man, &c., pushing upwards under the beam between B and D, becomes heavier. Q.E.D. On the contrary, if the scale should hang at F, from the point D, only 3 feet from the center of motion C, and a post G G hinders the scale from being pushed inwards towards C, then, if a man in this scale F pushes obliquely against B with the oblique force above mentioned, the whole force, for the reasons before given (in resolving the oblique force into two others acting in lines perpendicular to each other) will be reduced to 8 stone, which pushes the beam directly upwards at B, while the same force of 8 stone draws it directly down at D towards F. But as C D is only equal to half of C B, the force at D, compared with that at B, loses half its action, and therefore can only take off the force of 4 stone from the push upwards at B ; and consequently the weight W at A will preponderate, imless an additional weight of 4 stone be hanged at B. Therefore, a man, &c., pushing upwards under the beam between B and D, becomes lighter.* [The paper concludes with some further rules and experi- ments.] An Experiment explaining a Mechanical Paradox^ that two bodies of equal weight suspended on a certain sort of balance do not lose their aquUibrium by being removed, one farther from^ the other nearer to, the center. By the Rev, «/". T, Desaguliers^ LL,D,t F,R.S. Pbop. 7. — If the two weights P W hang at the ends of the balance A B, whose center of motion is C, those weights will act against each other (because their directions are contrary) with forces made up of the quantity of matter in each multi- plied by its velocity ; that is, by the velocity which the motion of the balance turning about C will give to the body suspended. Now, the velocity of a heavy body is its perpendicular ascent or descent, as will appear by moving the balance into the position a b, which shews the velocity of P to be the perpendicular line e a, and the velocity of B will be the perpendicular line b ^S for if the weights P and W are equal, and also the lines e a and b g, their momenta, made up of « a multiplied into * The Philosophical Transactions, from 1719 to 1733, thridged. 4to. London, 1734. Vol. 6, p. 306. 94 PERPETTTUM MOBILE; W, and h g multiplied into P, will be equal, as will appear by their destroying one another in making an equilibrium. But if the body W was removed to M, and suspended at the point D, then, its velocity being only f d, it would be over- balanced by the body P, because / d multiplied into M would produce a less momentum than P multiplied into b g. As the arcs A o, B 6, and D d, described by the ends of the balance or points of suspension, are proportionable to their sines e a^ g h^ and d f, as also the radii or distances C A, C B, and C D ; in the case of this common sort of balance, the arcs described by the weights, or their points of suspension, or the distances from the center, may be taken for velocities of the weights hanging at A, B, or D, and therefore the acting force of the weights will be reciprocally as their distances from the center. Scholium. — The distances from the center are taken here for the velocities of the bodies, only because they are propor- tionable to the lines e a, b g, and / d, which are the true velocities ; for there are a great many cases wherein the velo- cities are neither proportionable to the distances from the center of motion of a machine, nor to the arcs described by the weights or their points of suspension. Therefore, it is not a general rule that weights act in proportion to their distances from the center of motion ; but a corollary of the general rule that weights act in proportion to their velocities, which is only true in some cases. Therefore, we must not take this case as a principle, which most workmen do, and all those people who make attempts to find the perpetual motion, as I have more amply shewn in the Phil. Trans., No. 369. But to make this evident even in the balance, we need only take notice of the following experiment : — ^A C B E K D is a balance in the form of a parallelogram passing through a slit in the upright piece N O standing on the pedestal M, so as to be moveable upon the center pins C and K. To the upright pieces A D and B E of this balance are fixed at right angles the horizontal pieces F G and H I. That the equal weights P W must keep each other in sequilibrio, is evident ; but it does not at first appear so plainly, that if W be re- moved to V, being suspended at 6, yet it shall still keep P in sequilibrio, though the experiment shews it. Nay, if W be successively moved to any of the points 1, 2, 3, E, 4, 5, or 6, the sequilibrium will be continued ; or if, W hanging at any OB, SEABCH FOB 8EI.F-M0T1VE POWEB. 97 of those points, P be successively moved to D, or any of the points of suspension on the cross piece F G, P will at any of those places ^make an sequilibrium with W. Now, when the weights are at P and V, if the least weight that is capable to overcome the friction at the points of suspension C and K be added to V, as w, the weight V will overpower, and that as much at V as if it was at W. From what we have said above, the reason of this experi- ment will be very plain. As the lines A C and K D, C B and K E, always continue of the same length in any position of the machine, the pieces A D and B E will always continue parallel to one another, and perpendicular to the horizon. However, the whole machine turns upon the points C and K, as appears by bring- ing the balance to any other position, SiS a b e d; and there- fore, as the weights applied to any part of the pieces F G and H I can only bring down the pieces A D and B E perpen- dicularly, in the same manner as if they were applied to the hooks D and E, or to X and Y, the centers of gravity of A D and B E, the force of the weights (if their quantity of matter is equal) will be equal, because their velocities will be their perpendicular ascent or descent, which will atWays be as the equal lines 4 I and 4 L, whatever part of the pieces F G and H I the weights are applied to. But if to the weight at V be added the little weight w, those two weights will overpower, because in this case the momentimi is made up of the simi of V and u multiplied by the common velocity 4 L. Hence follows, that it is not the distance C 6 multiplied into the weight V which makes its momentum, but its perpen- dicular velocity L 4 multiplied into its mass. Q.E.D. This is still further evident by taking out the pin at K ; for then the weight P will overbalance the other weight at V, because then their perpendicular ascent and descent will not be equal.* • The Philosophical Transactions, from 1719 to 1733, abridged. 4to. London, 1734. Vol. 6, p. 310. Another paper by Dr Desaguliers, being " Remarks on some attempts made towards a Perpetual Motion," from the Phil. Trans , abridged, 4to., 1734, vol. 6, p. 323, will be found trans- ferred to Chapter 11. I yO PERPETUUM mobile; An Historical Account of a strangely Self-moving Liquor. Printed first in the Philosophical Transactions, No. 176 , p. 1 188, anno lG85,i;o/. 15. An ingenious teacher of mathematicks, having occasion to make a composition for a new fire-engine, whereof he was to shew his Majesty a trial, mingled divers ingredients in an earthen pot over kindled coals ; but could not or did not do it so warily, but that the matter took fire, and began to blaze furiously, which obliged him to stifle the blaze as hastily as he could ; and having removed the vessel from the fire, and suffered it to grow cold, when afterwards he came to look upon it, to see if what remained might be of any use to him, he was surprised to find it variously and briskly moved. Wherefore, having set it aside, to be sure that it might be thoroughly cold, he, after some hours, visited it again, and found it move as before ; and having cast store of seeds upon it, to see if the liquor would move them also, the bituminous part of it connected them into a kind of thick scimi,that covered most of the superfices, but yet left some intervals, in which the liquor appeared, and discovered that it continued its motions. Two days after, the engineer discoursing with me of this fire-work, about which he had advised with me before, told me, among other things, of this odd accident. And when I asked him if the motion continued still, and had been answered affirmatively, though it was then a dark night and ill weather, my diffidence or my curiosity made me engage him to send for the pot as it was, partly to be sure of the matter of fact, and partly to try if the knowledge I had of the ingredients, which he had before told me, would afford any hint of the cause of so odd an effect ; a like to which in kind, though not in degree, I had many years before devised, and successfully practised, the way of producing. The vessel being come, though the hasty transportation of it seemed to have sufficiently disturbed it, there did appear manifest signs of such a motion as the engineer had ascribed to it ; and, therefore, he being willing to leave it with me, I caused it to be set aside in a laboratory, where some furnaces kept the air constantly warm, and did there and elsewhere, at different times, look heedfuUy upon it, now and then dis- placing or quite taking off" some of the thick scum that too much covered the surface of it, and by this means I had the opportunity to take ixotice of several phaenomena, whereof these are the chief: — OB, SEABCH FOE 8EI/F-M0TJVE POWER. 99 1. I observed that the motion of this liquor was not only brisk, but very various, so that having loosened some small portions of the scum, one of them would be carried towards the right hand for instance, and another towards the left, at the same time. 2. Where the liquor first came out from under the scimi, it seemed to move the most briskly, flowing almost like a stream whose motion upwards had been checked, and, as it were, reverberated by that incumbent obstacle. 3. Several motions in this liquor were the more easy to be observed, because, though it were dark, yet it was not uniform ; consisting in part of oily and bituminous ingre- dients, which, though they seemed to have but one common superficies with the rest of the liquor, yet, but their colours and power of vigorously reflecting the light, they were easily enough distinguishable from the rest. And I often observed that some of these unctuous portions of the matter, emerging to the surface of the liquor, though perhaps at first one of them would not appear bigger than a pin's head, yet, in moving forwards, it would at the same time difiuse itself circularly, and make, as it were, a great halo, adorned with the colours of the rainbow, and so very vivid as afforded a very pleasant, and at first surprising, spectacle ; these phan- tasms often nimbly succeeding one another, and lasting till they lost themselves against or under the thick scum. 4. The motions of this odd liquor were not only various, but fre- quently vortical ; to be satisfied of which, I sometimes put short bits of straw, or fragments of some such like stuff", upon the discovered part of the surface of the liquor, by which they were carried towards very distant, if not opposite, parts of the vessel at the same time. But to make the vorti- cal motion more evident, I several times detached consider- ably large pieces of the thick scum from the rest of the body, and had the pleasure to see them move both with a progres- sive motion in crooked lines, and with a motion about their own middlemost parts. All this while, the liquor, whose parts were thus briskly moved, was actually cold, as to sense. 6. To observe what, the presence, or absence, of the free air woidd do to this liquor, I caused many spoonfuls of it, with some of the scum, to be put into a cylindrical glass, which, though large itself, had a neck belonging to it, that was but about the bigness of one's thimib, that it might be ,well stopped with a cork. But having, by this means, kept the 100 PERPETUITM mobile; free air from having a frill and immediate contact with the whole surface of the mixture, as it had when that mixture lay in the wide-mouthed vessel, I could not perceive the liquor to move to and fro, no, not though the orifice of the neck were left open : whereas, having, at the same time, poured some of the liquor into a very shallow and wide- mouthed vessel, called in the shops a clear-caked glass, it moved rather more than less nimhly and variously than in the great earthen pot (which yet was of the same shape), and shewed us many of those vivid tnd self-dilating circles that have been mentioned in the third number ; and these, by the fineness of their colours and the quickness wherewith they succeeded one another, afforded a delightful spectacle as long as I stayed to observe the liquor. 6. Though the motions of the hitherto mentioned liquor did not seem to be always equally brisk, yet they appeared to continue manifest and various in some diversities of weather, as to cold and heat, and when I looked on it by candle-light as well as by daylight ; and when, being not well enough to visit it myself, I sent one purposely to look upon it, about ten o'clock at night, he brought me word that it continued to move as formerly, and so it has done for ten days ; and how much longer it will continue to do so, time must determine. Postscript. — Some time after the foregoing account had been written, when I came to look upon the liquor (which in the mean time had been several times viewed, and appeared to retain its motions), I found, to my trouble, that somebody's impertinent curiosity and heedlessness had cracked the lower part of the earthen pot ; at which overture, the liquor, though not the scimi, was run out ; which had put a period to our observations, but that, foreseeing that such an accident might happen, I had long before taken out some spoonfuls of the liquor, and kept it close stopped in a vial. By this means I had the opportimity to observe that, when I poured out the liquor into a wide-mouthed vessel, it would move £is before, though this were done some weeks after it had been put up. And I remember that long after, having one day received the honour of a visit from a foreign minister, who was an inquisi- tive person and a man of letters, we chanced, among other things, to talk of the liquor ; and though it were scarce to be hoped that it could still retain any of its motive virtue, yet, to gratify his curiosity, and that of some ingenious men OB, SEABCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 101 there present, I caused the vial to be brought, and having unstopped it, I poured out the liquor into a convenient-shaped vessel, in which, after we had suffered it to rest awhile, they were delightfully surprised to see it move (though not, in my opinion, quite so briskly as before), yet very manifestly and variously. This encouraged me to think it possible that it might retain some motion, though but languid, seven or eight weeks after ; and therefore, on the 25th of July, I looked upon it again, and having caused it to be poured into a china cup, it manifested, at first, a brisk and various motion ; but this, after awhile, did so slacken that I began to have some suspicion that the motion it was put into by effusion and the first contact of the air might have given it the greatest part of its agitation. But this being but suspicion, I put the vessel into divers postures in a window, the better to discover the true cause of this phaenomenon ; but whilst I was busy about this, which ingrossed my attention, a mischance over- turned the cup, and, by throwing down the liquor, pi^t an end to my speculation : yet this mischance hindered me but from observing how long the odd agitation of our liquor would have continued, but not from finding that it lasted a great while ; for I shewed it the foreign minister about or after the beginning of June, that is, about five months or more after the liquor was first observed to move.* The following is extracted from a letter of S. Hartlib to Mr. Boyle : — I had lately received a letter from Mr. Oldenburg, amongst other particulars, in these words : — " In our passing through Mentz we met with a rare artist called Beckor, a young man, who hath found, he saith, the perpetual motion, the possibility whereof hath been hitherto so much disputed by philosophers. He hath almost finished a work, wherein he doth demonstrate his invention, which we have seen, and the design and way whereof the m* E V "■■* to show the possibility of a perpetual motion. Let the height A B (Fig. 4i) be divided into four equal parts A B, C D, OK, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 113 D E, E B — suppose the body A to acquire by the descent A C, a velocity as 1, and this motion by any contrivance to be transmitted to an equal body B ; then let the body A, by an equal descent C D, acquire another motion as 1, to be transmitted likewise to the same body B, which in this manner is supposed to acquire a motion as 2, that is sufficient to carry it upwards from B to A ; and because there yet remain the motions which A acquires by the descents D E and E B, that may be sufficient to keep an engine in motion, while B and A ascend and descend by turns, it is hence concluded that a sufficient gain of force may be obtained in this manner, so as to produce a perpetual movement. But it appears, from what has been shewn, that a motion as 2 cannot be produced in B by the two successive impulses transmitted from A, each of which is as 1. Some authors have proposed projects for producing a per- petual movement, with a design to refute them ; but, by mistaking the proper answer, have rather confirmed the unskilful in their groundless expectations. An instance of this we have in Dr. Wilkins's " Mathematical Magick," book 2, chap. 13. A loadstone at A (Fig. 44) is supposed to have a sufficient force to bring up a heavy body along the plane F A, from F to B ; -^ whence the body is supposed ^kv (^^9* **i ^"°« 3-) to descend by its gravity, along the curve B E F, continually. But supposing B Z E to be the surface upon which, if a body was placed, the attrac- tion of the loadstone and the gravity of the body would balance each other, this sur- face shall meet B E F at some point E between A and F, and the body must stop in descend- ing along A E F at the point E.* * An Account of Sir Isaac Newton's Philosophical Discoveries, in four hoolss. By Colin Maclaurin, M.A. Published from the author's MS. papers, by Patrick Murdoch, M.A and F.R.S. Third edition, 8vo. 1776. Book 2, chap. 3, p. 187. N.B.— First edition, 4to., printed 1748. The foregoing article may be found copied into "A New and Complete Dictionary of Arts and Sciences. By a Society of Gentlemen." 4 vols. 4to. 1764. 114 PEBPETUUM mobile; Dr. Rutherford, in allusion to Perpetual Motion, says : — 98. The friction of the parts of a machine against each other will in time destroy any motion that has been communi- cated to it. Amongst the other mutual actions of bodies upon each other, we reckon friction. No machine can have the surface of its parts made exactly smooth by polishing, though their roughness may be made too small for our eyes to discover it. And as a body by striking directly upon another, that is either at rest or in motion, will lose velocity, so, as the parts of a machine rub against each other, when the prominence of one part, though ever so small, strikes upon the prominence of another part, the motion of the parts will by this means be diminished, and by frequent strokes of the same sort will in time be entirely destroyed. From hence it follows that no machine can be so contrived as to have a perpetual motion, or always to preserve the motion once impressed upon it ; for the motion commimicated will by the friction of the machine be constantly decreasing, and must end at last. To prevent this, in all the contrivances for a perpetual motion the usual attempt has been to find out a way of re- pairing the motion which is lost by friction ; and as bodies move themselves by the force of gravity, and as motion is likewise generated by the spring of such bodies as are elastic, the way of repairing the motion as it decays by fric- tion must be by the application of one or other of these two properties of matter. The motion of some clocks is kept up by the force of gravity ; but then this motion is not a per- petual one, for the clock stops as soon as the weights are down. Other clocks are kept in motion by elastic springs ; but this motion ceases likewise, when the spring, by having expanded itself, is grown too weak to repair it any longer. And indeed, neither of these properties can be so applied as to make a perpetual motion. This I will endeavour to shew, from one or two of the principal contrivances in the two following propositions : — 99. The force of gravity cannot produce a perpetual motion. The general reason for this has been already given ; for, since gravity produces motion in bodies only whilst they can OR, 8EA.BGH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 115 descend, the motion of a machine, which is lost by the fric- tion of its parts, can be repaired by a weight no longer than till the weight is down, or is come to the ground, and is pre- vented by it from descending any longer. In order to remove this difficulty, machines have been con- trived with more weights than one, of which some are to be constantly ascending whilst the others are descending. Where we may observe that the descending weights are applyed to two purposes ; they are to repair the motion in the machine, and likewise to raise the other weights which were down as low as they could go ; and these weights, when they are raised, are to descend again, and in their turn to answer the same purpose. For this end, some one or more of the mechanical powers is made use of, by the assistance of which the descendmg weights may be made to move always with a greater velocity than the ascending ones ; and then, if the quantities of matter in the weights be equal, their moments will be as their velocities, and consequently the descending weights may by this means have a moment given them so much greater than the ascending ones have as to be sufficient to answer the two purposes already mentioned. It would be endless to examine all the inventions of this sort. The principle upon which they depend is applyed in the neatest manner in the wheel described by Desaguliers ; and by examining the principle in this one instance, we shall see the fallacy of it, and how little hopes of success there is in any other application of it. The wheel (Fig. 1, plate 4) has two rims or circumferences, "DeABajidrhi/. The space between the two rims is divided into cells by the spokes q A, / U pjy^ A «, &c., which are bent in such a manner as to ^aiise weights placed loose in ^ilie cells to descend on the side A « ^ B from A to B, which is the lowest point, on the outer rim of the wheel, and to ascend again from B on the other side of the wheel B D, in the line B « m /? r, which comes nearer the centre C and touches the inner rim. Thus the weights {Fig.\,pl^.) 116 PEEPETUUM MOBILE *, on the descending side of the wheel being farther from the centre of motion than those on the ascending side, it is imagined that the moment of the former will always be greater than the moment of the latter. The weight A, in particular, descends to B in the arc A « ^ B, which is a quarter of a circle ; but it rises from B to D in the curve B w «i jt? r, which is less than a quarter of a circle. And, since the velocity is as the space described in a given time, the velocity and consequently the moment of A when it descends is greater than its moment when it ascends. This will be the case of every weight in its turn ; therefore, the descending weights will always have a greater moment than the ascending ones. The fallacy is this : — The velocity with which the weight A descends to B is estimated by the line A s tB, whereas the velocity of all bodies in motion is to be estimated in the line of their direction, by the second law of motion. For it is only in the line of direction that any force acts so as to com- municate motion to a body ; and it is in the same line only that the body in motion acts, when it communicates motion and is itself considered as a moving force. From hence it follows, that the velocity with which a weight descends, if the weight is considered as a moving force, must be estimated in the line of its direction, that is, in a line drawn from its centre of gravity to the centre of the earth ; or, the velocity of a weight is proportional to the approach of it in any given time to Sie earth's centre. In like manner, the velocity with which the weight ascends is to be estimated in the line of its direction, and in any given time it is as the distance to which it is raised from the earth's centre in that time. From hence it appears that, though the weight A descends to B in the curve A 8 tB, yet the velocity with which it descends being as its approach to the earth's centre, is as A G = C B ; and though the same weight ascends in the lesser curve B n m p r, yet the velocity with which it ascends being as the distance to which it is raised from the earth's centre in that time, is as Er = CB = AG. Therefore, the descending and ascend- ing velocities are equal, and consequently the moment of the descending weights will be no greater than the ascending ones. I do not know whether this will be made more intelligible by distinguishing between the weight's velocity whilst it OR, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIYE POWER. 117 descends and the velocity with, which it descends. This may appear to the reader too nice a distinction ; but I hope he will understand my meaning, if he observes that whUst A descends it does not move directly downwards in the line A G, but moves partly downwards and partly in a horizontal direc- tion, and by both these motions together is carried to B. Since, therefore, whilst it descends it is likewise carryed hori- zontally, I think it is evident that it does not descend with its whole velocity ; therefore, its velocity whilst it descends is different from the velocity with which it descends, as different as the whole is from its part. Or otherwise, whilst A de- scends to B in the line A « ^ B, we may consider its motion as resolved into the two sides of a parallelogram, A G and A C = G B ; where the velocity with which it descends is A G, and the other part of its velocity A C or G B carries it horizontally. In like manner we may distinguish between the velocity which the weight has whilst it ascends and the velocity with which it ascends ; for if, as before, the weight ascends in the curve B n mp r, we may consider its motion as resolved into the two sides of a parallelogram, B C = E r and B E ; where the velocity with which it ascends is E r, and the other part of its velocity B E carries it horizontally. Now, the descending velocity A G is equal to the ascending velocity E r; and, therefore, the moment with which the weight descends will be equal to the moment with which it ascends. The horizontal velocity G B of the descending • weight is greater, indeed, than the horizontal velocity B E of the ascending one. But I suppose it is unnecessary to prove that this cannot possibly contribute anything towards turning the wheel, or towards making the moment on the descending side greater than the moment on the ascending side ; for I imagine the reader will easily see that a motion in the direc- tion G B E or A C r will not contribute in the least towards making the point A descend, or towards turning the line A C D round upon the centre of motion. 100. The force of elasticity cannot produce a perpetual motion. Elastic springs, as has been observed already, by ex- panding themselves grow weak ; and, when they are quite expanded, become entirely unable to produce any motion at all. But in proposition 83 it was shown that if an elastic ball A strikes upon another B, which is greater than itself, 118 PEBPETUUM mobile; the moment of B after the stroke will be greater than that of A was before it. In like manner, if B was to strike upon C, another elastic body greater than itself, the motion might still be increased. And thus, by placing more elastic bodies in the row, of which each should be greater than the last before it, the motion might be increased in what proportion we pleased. Now, why might not motion produced in this manner be applied to repair what is lost in a machine by the friction of its parts, and to make the motion of the machine a perpetual one? I intended to supply the reader with an answer to this question when I desired him to remember in the instance of two bodies, in proposition 83, that though there is motion produced if we consider the greater body alone, yet if both bodies are taken together there is no motion produced in the same direction ; but the moment in the same direction is exactly the saine after the stroke that it was before it. This woidd be the case were there ever so many bodies. But a machine can o^y be moved by moving forces in the same direction; for equal moving forces in contrary directions would destroy esLph. other and produce no effect on the machine, and the effect-^produced by unequal ones in con- trary directions will be as their difference. Since, therefore, the moving force, by which the motion of the machine should be repaired, is the moment of these elastic bodies, and since their moment in the same direction is the same after the strolie th|t it was before ; it follows, that no such moment is producedby the stroke as can keep the motion of the machine and make it perpetual. For instance, suppose the machine consists of four wheels; call them c, d^ e, andy. Let c be the first mover, and let / be the last. Now, if c begins to move with 8 degrees of moment, and by the friction 2 degrees are lost when the motion comes to the wheel /, then / can return only 6 degrees of motion on c, the first mover. And thus the motion, as it decays in every round, will at last be entirely lost, imless some method could be found for repairing it. Suppose, therefore, that there were two elastic balls A and B, and that A is to B as 2 to 4 ; then, by proposition 83, if A strikes B with a moment 6, B will gain by the stroke a moment 8. ||fp,if y, the fe^ wheel which has only the moment 6, wa^ to strike updir5v and A to strike upon B, and B Xo strike upon the first wheel c, then this first mover would iave the same motion 8 communicated to it, with which it OB, SEABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 119 began to move. And as the two elastic bodies would always repair the 2 degrees of motion that are lost by friction in conveying the motion from c to/, why might not this con- trivance be so applyed as to make the machine a perpetual motion? I answer, because, though B strikes c with 8 degrees of motion, yet A will at the same time be reflected with 2 degrees against /, and striking /, the last mover, by reflection, will stop the machine with a force 2, whilst B is moving it with a force 8. Therefore, by the action of both bodies together, of B impelling c with the moment 8, and of A reflected back upon f with the moment 2, the machine will be moved only with the difference, or 8 — 2 = 6. So that if c began to move at first with the moment 8, and this moment by being carried round through d and e to /was re- duced to 6, the two elastic balls A and B will not repair the moment lost ; but the machine will have only 6 degrees of moment, notwithstanding the seeming increase of motion by A's striking upon B.* Dr. Hooper describes "A Clock to go perpetually by the influence of the Celestial Bodies," and very properly dis- criminates the difference between such action and a self- motive power. He says : — The construction of the movements in this clock is the same with those in common use ; it differs from those only in its situation and the manner in which it is wound up. This clock is to be placed near a wall, by or against which the tide constantly flows. To each of the barrels round which the string that carries the weight is wound, there must hang a bucket, and into that, when the tide rises to a certain height, the water runs, by means of a pipe fixed in the wall. The bucket then overbalancing the weight, descends, and winds up the clock ; but when it comes to a certain deptlii, it is taken by a catch fixed in the wall, which by turning it over discharges the water ; the weights of the clock ti^en descend in the usual manner, and the buckets are drawn up. Now, as this clock is kept in motion by the tide, and as ♦ A System of Natural Philosophy. By T. Rutherford, D.D., F.R.S. 9, vols. 4to., 1748. Vol. 1, pp. 88-92. 120 PEBPETUTJM mobile; the tide proceeds from the influence of the sun and moon, it necessarily follows that the motion of the clock proceeds from the same cause, and that as long as the parts of the machine remain, motion will be perpetual. This, according to the common acceptation of the term, is certainly a perpetual motion, and so is every mill that is driven by a constcnt stream ; but that is not the sense in which the term was used by the advocates for a perpetual motion in the last century. They meant a machine which, being once put in motion, should, by its peculiar construction, move perpetually without any fresh force impressed. This they attempted by various means : as the attraction of a load- stone, the descent of heavy bodies, the difference of the momentum in revolving weights, &c., all of which, though ingenious enough, discover a want of due attention to the principles of mechanics. Besides, if a perpetual movement could be effected by either of those means, it would be of very little or no use : for the unavoidable wear of the several parts of the machine, arising from the incessant friction, must necessarily destroy that equality of motion which alone could render its perpetuity of any consequence.* Emerson, in Prop. CXVIII., treating how " To determine the friction and other irregularities in mechanical engines," ,;^ys:— • ; li;; As to the mechanic powers. The single leaver makes np^i^sistance by friction. But if, by the motion of the leaver in lifting, the fulcrum or support be changed further from the weight, the power will be decreased thereby. 7. If any wheel of a machine running upon an axis, the friction on the axis is as the weight upon it, the diameter of the axis, and the angular velocity. This sort of friction is but smsdl. 8. In the pulley, if p q he two weights, and q the greater, and if W= r^, then W is the weight upon the axis,i^f the single pulley. And it is not increased by the acceleration of the weight q, but remains always the same. * Rational Recreations. By W, Hooper, M.D. 4 vols. 8vo. 1783. Vo'. 1, p. 187; recieaticn 65. OK, SEAHCH FOU SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 121 The friction of the pulley is very considerable when the sheaves rub against the blocks, and by the wearing of the holes and axles. The friction on the axis of the pulley is as the weight W, its angular velocity the diameter of the axis directly and the diameter of the pulley inversely. A power of lOOlbs. with the addition of 501bs. will but draw up SOOlbs. with a tackle of 5. And 151bs. over a single pulley will draw up only 141bs. 9. In the screw there is a great deal of friction. Those with sharp threads have more friction than those with square threads, and endless screws have more than either. Screws with a square thread raise a weight with more ease than those with a sharp thread. In the common screw the friction is so great, that it will sustain the weight in a position given when the power is taken off. And, therefore, the friction is at least equal to the power. From whence it will follow, that in the screw the power must be to the weight or resistance, at least as twice the perpendicular height of a thread to the circumfer- ence described by gne revolution of the power, if it be able to raise the weight, or only sustain it. This friction of the screw is of great use, as it serves to keep the weight in any given position. 10. In the wedge the friction is at least equal to the power, as it retains any position it is driven into. Therefore, in the wedge the power must be to the weight at least as twice the base to the height, to overcome any resistance. 11. To find the friction of any engine, begin at the power, and consider the velocity and the weight at the first rubbing part, and estimate its quantity of friction by some of the foregoing articles ; then proceed to the next rubbing part, and do the same for it; and so on through the whole. And note, something more is to be allowed for increase of friction by every new addition to the power. Cor. — Hence will appear the difficulty, or, rather, im- possibility of a perpetual motion, or such a motion as is to continue the same for ever, or at least as long as the mate- rials will last, that compose moving machines. For such a motion as this ought continually to return undi- minished, notwithstanding any resistance it meets with, which is impossible. For, although any body once put into motion, 122 PEB?ETUUM mobile; and moving freely without any resistance, or any external retarding force acting upon it, would for ever retain, that motion, yet, in fact, we are certain that no body or machine can move at all without some degree of friction and resistance ; and, therefore, it must follow that, from the resistance of the medium, and the friction of the parts of the machine upon one another, its motion will gradually decay, till, at last, all the motion is destroyed, and the machine is at rest. Nor can this be otherwise, except some new active force, equal to all its resistance, adds a new motion to it. But that cannot be from the body or machine itself ; for then the body would move itself, or be the cause of its own motion, which is absurd,* Among the numerous commimications made by William Nicholson to the journal he conducted, and which bears his name, he contributed the following carefully-written paper — " Concerning those Perpetual Motions which are producible in Machines by the Rise and Fall of the Barometer or the Thermometrical Variations in the Dimensions of Bodies :" — In a former communication, I have given an account of some of the delusive projects for obtaining a perpetual motion from an invariable power.f In that paper, I remarked that the flow of rivers, the vicissitudes of tides, the varia- tions of winds, the thermometrical expansions of solids and fluids, the rise and fall of the mercury in the barometer, the hygrometric changes in organised remains, and every other of those mutations which never fail to take place around us, may be applied as flrst movers to mills, clocks, and other engines, and keep them going till worn out. Many instances of this kind of perpetual motion are seen in water-nulls and other common engines, which are necessarily confined to cer- tain local situations. The windmill, though less confined with respect to place, is the subject of a much more variable power ; other instruments, still less confined with regard to ^situation and exposure, have been made, which are capable of • The Principles of Mechanics. By W. Emerson. 4to. 1794. Tourth ed'tion, p. 173. t Philosophical Journal, voL 1, p. 375. OB, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 123 contmuing their motion without ceasing. Such was the clock, or perpetual motion, in Cox's Museum, which was shewn about twenty years ago in London. My former paper was written to shew the value of the perpetual motion, strictly so called, which has for the most part been pursued by men of little information. In the present memoir, I shall endeavour to ascertain that of this second kind of motion, which, because more promising, and of nearly the same prac- tical value, has been followed at some expense by men of higher claims. For this purpose, I shall first describe a few schemes, and then investigate the quantity of power they are likely to afford. Fig. 1, plate 6, is a sketch of the first ipover in a clock which formed part of Cox's Museum, which was sold by public lottery, about the year 1776^ if my recollection be accurate. A represents the surface of the mercury in a baro- meter, the glass vessel of which had the form of a bottle or chemical mattrass. The diameter of the upper surface of the mercury was, I think, about twelve inches. C D represents the bason, or receptacle, into which the aperture of A B was k»lunged. I suppose, of course, that the lower surface of toercury, which was exposed to the pressure of the atmo- ^here, was nearly the same as the upper, A B, as, in fact, it appeared to be. From the intervention of the case, and other parts of the apparatus, I could only conjecture the manner in which the effect was produced ; but this was after- wards explained to me by Mr. Rehe,* who contrived and made it. The bason B D is suspended by two chains K L, which pass over the pullies or wheels H I, and are attached to the frame E F, which last is fixed to the barometer A B. Let us now suppose the apparatus to be at liberty, and it will be clearly seen, that if the two masses attached to the opposite ends of the chains K L be not precisely equal, the heaviest will descend, and cause the lightest to rise. The masses must, therefore, be brought nearly to this state of equality, by the adjustment of weight added to one or both of them. In this state, suppose the pressure of the atmosphere to in- crease, and the consequence will be, that a portion of the mercury, being forced from the vessel C D into A B, will * This gentleman is at present one of the Board of Inspection of Naval Worksat the Admiralty. June, 1799. 124 PEKPETUUM mobile; render this last heavier, and cause it to descend, while C D at the same time rises. And, on the other hand, when, by a diminished pressure of the external air, the mercury subsides in A B, the vessel C D will preponderate, and A B will rise. Now, the frame E F, which is interposed between the baro- meter and the pullies I K, is jointed at the corners, and also at the places where it is attached to the chain and the baro- meter ; and the inner edges of the upright pieces E F are formed into teeth, like those of a saw, the slopes of which lie in opposite directions, as is shewn in the figure. The wheel G, which is placed between these bars, is also toothed in the same manner ; and its diameter is such, that when the teeth on each side, as, for example, E, are engaged, those on the other side, F, may be free ; but it is too large to admit of both sides beingjdisengaged at once. The wheel G is pre- vented, by a click, from moving in the direction opposite to that which may be produced by the action of the bars E and F. Hence, the play of the machine is evident. When the pressure of the atmosphere diminishes, and the barometer rises from its cistern, the side E of the frame will move the wheel G through a greater or less space, according to the variation ; and when, on the contrary, it falls, the teeth E will be drawn out of their bearing, and those of F will be thrown into the wheel, and still produce a motion of the same kind ; the joints of the frame E F allowing it to change its figure enough for this purpose. It is hardly necessary to remark that this wheel G, being connected with the clock, serves to wind it up, and that the clock is constructed to go for a much greater number of days than the barometer has ever been known to remain stationary. The ingenious mechanic will readily form a notion of many other methods of applying the variations of the barometer to similar objects. The wheel-barometer of Robert Hook, as well as another contrivance, in which the barometer and its cistern are placed at the different extremities of an inclined lever, may likewise be used for this purpose. Several artists have exerted their industry in attempts to apply the variations produced by change of temperature in bodies as a first mover. If a thermometer be suspended by its centre of gravity in such a manner that the tube may lie nearly horizontal, the daily variations in the bulk of the mercury will cause a preponderance on the one side or the other, mm (Fig.\,pL^.) OR, SEARCH FOB SEXF-MOTIVE POWER. 12? accordingly as the temperature is higher or lower than it was at the original fixing of the centre of suspension. The thermo* meter may contain mercury or any other fluid, or it may con- sist of air confined by merciiry, as in the manometer. In this contrivance, the great and frequent ranges of variation afford much promise of utility. The limits of convenient or prac- ticable power from change of equilibrium in a fluid thermo- meter will hereafter be examined. A much greater force seems to offer itself in the power by which the expansion is produced ; but the difficulty of forming a piston or other apparatus for confining fluids, will probably constitute an in • surmountable impediment to this method. The solid thermometer does not present the same difficulty. Fig. 2 represents a series of expansion-bars, each consisting of a plate of brass, soldered to another of steel, and possessing the property of bending by change of temperature, according to the laws already explained in this work.* If the steel face of C A be uppermost, and the end C be fixed to C B, the extremity A will rise from B when the temperature is ele- vated ; and if the succeeding bars be similarly fixed above each other, as in the figure, the whole system will occupy a greater length, or elevation, above C B, when heated, than when cold. Another more convenient method of disposing the bars is shewn in Fig. 3. In this, the bars are fixed toge- ther at the middle, with the brass faces turned towards each other. Each bar has a slight curvature (much less than is here shewn), which will be increased by heat, and by that means cause the distance between the middle of two extreme bars to be greater than it would be at a lower temperature. These causes of action may be applied to machinery by various contrivances, some of which serve to increase the length of range, but add nothing to the power. This last, no doubt, is an object of convenience, according to the effect intended to be produced. The only method of adding to the power will consist in increasing the number of the bars. Fig. 4 represents a system for this purpose, which is the simplest and most convenient that has occurred to me. A C repre- sents the circumference of a barrel, resembling those in which the mainsprings of clocks are put, the length and dia- meter of which may be varied, according to the power * Philosophical Journal, vol. 1. pp. 62, 576. 128 PERPETXJUM mobile; intended to be gained. To this external part is fixed a ratchet- wheeL, to receive the click C, which confines its motion to one direction. At A is fixed a plate, to receive the action of the expansion-pieces. B D is an internal cylinder of the same kind, which is also confined, by a ratchet-wheel and click, to move only in the same direction as the outer part A C. It is not necessary to describe the operative arrangements by which these two cylinders are disposed so as to move on the same axis, and the ends duly applied, so as to form one box, while the interior and exterior parts are allowed to move inde- pendent of each other. At B is fixed a plate, by which the action of the expansion-pieces is communicated to the inner cylinder. A series of bars, similar to those delineated in Fig. 3, are disposed in the space between the two cylinders, the greatest part of which they occupy, leaving only such an interval between A and B as may be sufiicient to allow for the motion of the bars. In this interval is placed a spring, tending to cause A and B to recede from each other ; and, lastly, there are side-pins proceeding from the places of fric- tion of every pair of bars, which respectively pass through circular grooves in the caps, and prevent the motion of the bars from being interrupted or impeded by their touching either the inner or the outer cylinders. E represents a wheel, which is supposed to be connected, by tooth-work or other- wise, with the face of the external cylinder, and may be con- sidered as the machinery intended to be moved. Or other- wise, if the clicks C and D, with the teeth they act upon, be reversed, and the interior cylinder be fixed to the axis itself, that axis may be used as the first mover. Suppose this apparatus to be put together at a certain tem- perature in the day-time, and that in the night the tempera- ture becomes colder, in this case, the curvature of all the bars will diminish, and the distance between A and B will be increased by the action of the intermediate spring ; but as the plate A is prevented by the click C from receding, the plate B will be pushed forward, and the interior cylinder will gather a certain number of its teeth upon the click D. The next day, when the temperature again rises?, all the expansion- bars will bend, and the space between A and B will be dimi- nished ; this, however, cannot happen by the motion of B, which is held fast by the click D. The external part will, consequently, be now carried forward, and will act upon the {Fig, 2.) {Fig.Z.) (Fig. 4.) {Fiq. 6.) BRASS ftHASS STEEL OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 131 apparatus E. A second lowering of the temperature, by whatever cause, will occasion the interior part again to ad- vance, and, in this manner, the accumulations of force may be incessantly reiterated. Experience must determine how far the properties of these compound bars may be changed in the course of time.* It seems probable that the mere changes communicated by the atmosphere could scarcely produce any sensible effect ; and whether this effect would be detrimental to the general result, may also be questioned. Considerations of this nature lead to the enquiry, whether our object may not, with equal facility, be obtained by the direct push or pull of bars of metal, as in the gridiron pendulum, or that of EUicott.f If a succession of bars of brass were disposed round a cylindrical face of less expansible metal, so as to form an helical line from the one end to the other ; or, otherwise, if we suppose a brass clock chain, with a right-lined edge, to be wrapped round such a cylinder ; or, again, if, instead of the cylinder, we suppose the chain to pass over a succession of rollers, whether disposed in a cylindrical system or according to the form of a pulley, the result will be the same ; that is to say, the chain will contract and expand about the ten-thousandth part of its length, for every ten degrees of Fahrenheit's thermometer. In the way of rough estimate, let us, therefore, assume a cylinder of cast-iron, one foot in diameter and one foot in length, having a groove turned in its surface, like a screw, with twelve turns in the inch, for the purpose of lodging a system of friction rollers to receive the brass chain, wrapped round it. Such a chain,J consisting of 144 turns, would measure 450 feet,§ and would contract nearly 0.54 inches for every 10 degrees, or one- twentieth of an inch for each degree of change of tem- perature ; but as the cylinder itself contracts, the whole effect will be somewhat less than half that quantity ; that is to say, each degree of the thermometer will be one-fortieth of an inch. The philosophical world is aware that hygrometers have ♦ Philosophical Journal, vol. 1, p. 62. t Ibid., pp. 59, 60. X And would cost about £25. § For pyromelrical data, see Philosophical Journal, vol. 1, p. 58. 132 PERPETxruM mobile; been made, on this principle, with catgut, hair, whalebone, and other materials. It seems probable that the first of these would exert considerable force as a first-mover, but it would scarcely prove durable ; and, what is still worse, the variations of moisture in the atmosphere are little suited to operate upon machinery preserved in a case in an apartment. If the increase of the space moved through by the expan- sion of metals, upon the principle of EUicott's pendulum, should be adopted instead of the compound bars in Fig. 4, the project of Fig. 6 may be followed. A bar of steel A K is fixed beside a bar of brass B I, the joinings I K being inflexible ; but those at A B, in the lever A F, being jointed, the difference of expansion between the two metals will be magnified at F, in the proportion of A F to A B. The lines L C G D E represent a second combination of the same kind, in which the point G will have a similar and equal motion to that of F ; but the bar E L being prolonged to F, so as to bear upon the lever E F, the whole of the second combina- tion will be pushed forward by the expansion of the first, on account of which, the motion of G will, in fact, be double that of F ; by the addition of a third combination, the motion will be tripled, &c. A sufficient number of these, properly placed in the cavity between the two cylinders. Fig. 4, would afford the same consequences ; but it may be doubted whether any contrivance of this last kind could afford the same power in as small a space as that occupied by the compound bars. I shall now proceed to form an estimate of the quantities of force communicated by these several contrivances. The apparatus (Fig. 1, plate 6), or barometrical clock, is driven by a force which may be estimated in its annual quantity from the sum of the deviations of the barometer taken from a meteorological journal, such as that in the Philosophical Transactions; together with the quantity of mercury so moved, which may be derived from the dimen- sions of the surfaces in the tube and basin. From these variations, severally, must be taken the quantity of what mechanics call lost time, or the ineffectual movement between the direct and retrograde actions on the machinery. The whole power will be measured by the entire column of varia- tion, supposed to descend through half its height ; for this will be the case when a perpendicular tube empties itself by the descent of any fluid contained in it. I have not taken OB, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 133 the trouble to collect these elements ; but it may easily be imagined that the sum of all the variations during the year would amount to no great quantity. I understand, from the ingenious constructor of this apparatus, that the accumulated power was not sufficient to allow the clock to be maintained by a force equal to that which drives a common watch, namely, six ounces, with the daily fall of twelve inches. In the investigation of the power of expansion, in Fig. 4, a variety of curious objects of physical and mathematical research offer themselves to our consideration. In a former part of this journal,* it has been shewn that the curvature assumed by a straight compound bar, having each of its parts uniformly thick, will be circular ; whence it follows, from the nature of versed sines of small arcs, that the dis- tance A B, Fig. 2, will, cceteris paribus^ be as the square of C A ; and it should seem as if a considerable advantage might be derived from using the whole length of the bar, as in that figure (2), instead of the two half-lengths in Fig. 3. But it must be considered that the effect of hammer-hardening the lower part, and wire-drawing the upper, of the compound bar C A, is twice as great at C, Fig. 2, as it is at C in Fig. 3, and is shewn in the greater spring or yielding of the parts, and that the action at A, in this figure, is doubled at the opposite extremity of the bar ; so that, upon the whole, the action at A, on account of the short lever A C, Fig. 3, being twice as powerful as that at A in Fig. 2, and being exerted through the space A B, Fig. 3, of one-fourth part of the space A B in Fig. 2, will be half the action at the end of Fig. 2. But as both extremities of the bar are made to act in Fig. 3, the whole of its action will be precisely equal to that in Fig. 2. The combination. Fig. 3, appears, therefore, to be preferable on account of its convenient figure only. It may also be questioned whether these bars should be made extremely thin or the contrary. If they be very thin, the effect of the reaction being equivalent to a pull or push endways upon the bar, which is greater than the reaction itself, in the proportion of the length of the bar to its half thickness, it may easily be imagined that the texture and cohesion will be most strongly affected ; but, on the contrary, if the bar be very thick, the effect from change of tempera- ♦ Vol. 1, p. 62. 134 PERPETUUM mobile; ture may resolve itself entirely into an action upon the parts near the contiguous surfaces, without producing any flexure at all. It appears, therefore, that there is a thickness which is practically better than any other ; but what this thickness may be, remains to be determined by trials. As the quantity of motion is inversely as the thickness (Philos. Journal, i., 576), and the force directly as that thickness, it must follow that the quantity of mechanic efiect in all similar bars, neither extremely thick nor extremely thin, will be the same upon equal changes of temperature. I should give the pre- ference to thin bars, not so much reduced as to have any perceptible spring. If the Fig. 4 be supposed of such dimensions as that the circular arc struck through the middle parts of all the bars might be three feet in length, and the bars were each six inches long in the radial direction, with a thickness nearly equal to that of the second experiment related at the last- quoted article of our journal, the space moved through by each bar, upon an alteration of 146 degrees, would be about 0.05 inch, or haK a tenth ; but 300 of these bars might with ease be contained in the circular space of three feet ; and these would produce a motion of fifteen inches by the same change of temperature, or one-tenth of an inch for every degree of Fahrenheit. In order to determine the force with which this change of position would be effected, we are in want of some experiments on the expansions of metals. It is generally supposed that a rod or wire will contract or dilate by change of temperature in the same manner, whether it be at perfect liberty to move horizontally, or be made to support a weight hung from its extremity, or placed on its upper end. This is, in fact, supposed to be the case in the estimates for constructing gridiron pendulums ; and if it were strictly true, the power of this wheel would be constantly equal to the reaction against which it should be exerted. But it would be to little purpose to institute a calculation upon data assumed at random. I shall therefore only remark that the power of this wheel is very considerable, and may be increased almost at pleasure, by enlarging the dimensions of the bars in the direction parallel to the axis of the cylinder. Whatever question there may be with regard to the force and durability of this system of bars — neither of which I am disposed to doubt — ^there can be scarcely any with regard to OK, SEAKCH FOB SELF-MOTITS POWEB. 135 the spiral chain round the cylinder. The direct expansion and contraction of metals is certainly very powerful, and was shewn in a striking manner by the Rev. Mr. Jones, in an experiment related, if my memory be correct, in George Adam's Philosophical Lectures. He hung a very heavy weight to the longer end of a lever, the shorter arm of which pressed upwards against the longer arm of another lever, and the shorter arm of this last was supported by a rod of metal. By this mechanical arrangement, it will be understood, without difficulty, that a very slight motion of the arm which bore upon the metal might be attended with a very con- siderable motion of that extremity which supported the weight ; and the dimensions were such, that this was in fact the case. The flame of a candle applied to the bar of metal caused it to expand, and carried up the load without difficulty. Hygrometric contractions and dilations are known to be performed with immense force ; but want of durability in the materials, and the difficulty with regard to exposure, which has been already mentioned, seem to forbid the practical use of this power for the purpose to which our attention is now directed. The contrivance. Fig. 5, may be considered as effectual ; but the objections which have been made to EUicott's pendulum are still more strongly applicable to this, namely, that the friction, the wear, and the irregular action of the joints, must he hurtful to the general effect.* In Nicholson* s Journal, vol. 1, for 1802, page 27, is given the " Construction of an hydraulic apparatus, which by means of the syphon raises water above its level, and performs its alterations without attendance.'* It is the invention of "William Close." It has pipes and valves which require nice adjustment, it is stated, "to prevent the sudden pressure of the atmosphere from forcing the air out of the empty pipes with such rapidity as would [and' no doubt did] destroy the operation of the syphon." The article is not of sufficient interest to extract in extenso. ♦ A Journal of {Natural Philosophy, Chemistry, and the Arts. By WiUiam Nicholson. Vol. 3, pp. 126 and 172. 1800. 4to. 136 PEBPSTUUM mobile; A New Project for Perpetual Motion, In a Letter from R. B, to Mr, Nicholson, Sir, — I was mucli gratified, several years ago, by some essays with which you obliged your readers upon the perpetual motion. In the first volume, p. 375, of your quarto series, I find an accoimt of several schemes (necessarily abortive) for producing perpetual motions by the action of gravity ; and in your third volume I find an accoimt of various methods of keeping up the motion of a machine by means of the changes which take place in the barometer and thermometer. I have ventured to send you the sketch of a project for a perpetual motion of the latter kind, which has long remained among my memorandums. You will see it is not of the class of perpetual motions, properly speaking, but merely the applica- tion of some existing intermittent motions in nature to the purpose of maintaining the rotation of machinery. Fig. 1, plate 12. — A represents the marine barometer of Halley, but varied by the addition of a vessel B at the open (Fig. 1, pi 12, vol. 9.) end, in which the water, or other fluid, exposes a surface nearly equal to that in the closed vessel A. These two OB, SEAKCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 13? vessels are connected by a long horizontal tube G. It is evident that any change, either in the pressure of the external air or the elasticity of the internal air, will cause the fluid to run along the tube, and add to the weight of A or of B, according to circumstances. The heavier vessel will prepon- derate, but it will be prevented from descending too far by a stop or bearing to which it will arrive. Any change in the inclination of G will move the attached lever C D ; by means of which, one of the two horizontal racks will be made to push round that ratchet-wheel into which its teeth fall, at the same time that the other rack will be drawn backwards upon its wheel. The opposite action will drive forward the other wheel ; and, as both these wheels are fixed on the same axis, the system will be driven the same way by every change of densi^ or weight in the air that takes place.* Dr. Yoimg, in his ninth lecture " On the Motions of Con- nected Bodies," remarks : — To seek for a source of motion in the construction of a machine betrays a gross ignorance of the principles on which all machines operate. The only interest that we can take in the projects which have been tried for procuring a per- petual motion must arise from the opportunity that they afford us to observe the weakness of human reason, to see a man spending whole years in the pursuit of an object which a week's application to sober philosophy might have convinced him was imattainable. The most satisfactory confutation of the notion of the possibility of a perpetual motion is derived from the consideration of the properties of the centre of gravity. We have only to examine whether it will begin to descend or to ascend when the machine moves, or whether it will remain at rest. If it be so placed that it must either remain at rest or ascend, it is clear, from the laws of equilibriimi, that no motion from gravitation can take place ; if it may descend, it must either continue to descend for ever, with a finite velocity, which is impossible, or it must first descend and then ascend with a vibratory motion, and then the case will be reducible to that of a pendulum, where it is obvious that no new motion is generated, and that the friction and resistance of the air • A Journal of Natural Philosophy, Chemistry, and the (Arts. By Wm. Nicholson. Vol. 9, p. 212. 18U4. 8vo. 138 PBRPETUUM mobile; must soon destroy the original motion. One of the most co.nmon fallacies, by which the superficial projectors of machines for obtaining a perpetual motion have been deluded, has arisen from imagining that any number of weights ascend- ing by a certain path on one side of the centre of motion and descending on the other at a greater distance, must cause a constant preponderance on the side of the descent : for this purpose, the weights have either been fixed on hinges which allow them to fall over at a certain point, so as to become more distant from the centre, or made to slide or roll along grooves or planes which lead them to a more remote part of the wheel, from whence they return as they ascend ; but it will appear, on the inspection of such a machine, that although some of the weights are more distant from the centre than others, yet there is always a proportionally smaller number of them on that side on which they have the greatest power, so that these circimistances precisely coimterbalance each other. (Fig. 78, pi. 6, page 91.) (Fig. 78, pi 6.) Note on plate 6, page 763, vol. 1 : — Fig. 78. — ^A wheel supposed to be capable of producing a OB, 8EAB0II FOR SELF-MOTITE POWER. 139 perpetual motion ; the descending balls acting at a greater distance from the centre, but being fewer in number than the ascending. In the model, the balls may be kept in their places by a plate of glass covering the wheel. (Page 92.)* The following occiirs in a Scholium at page 82 of Dr. Gregory's " Treatise of Mechanics :" — Before we close our discussion respecting the lever, it may not be amiss just to remark, that in every attempt to deter- mine the advantage gained by this machine peculiar attention must be paid, not only to the directions in which the forces are exerted, but to the points on the lever to which their action is to be referred. Without a due regard to these par- ticulars, the mechanist will often be involved in error, even in simple cases where there might be supposed but little probability of mistake. In fact, even the simple property of the straight lever, that equal weights acting at equal distances from the fulcrum on opposite sides will be in equilibrio, while at unequal distances the one which acts most remotely from the fulcrum will preponderate, has more than once been a source of error in unskilful hands ; and in particular, it has lain at the foundation of most of those ill-fated and useless contrivances which have been struck out by such as were in pursuit of the perpetual motion. In these contrivances the object of the projector has generally been to apply different weights to a rotatory machine in such manner that, at successive moments of time, first one and then another should be brought to greater distances from the centre, and so, by being placed at the extremity of a longer lever, should pro- duce a constant motion. To prevent, therefore, such waste of time and ingenuity, we shall here describe an apparatus invented by Dr. Desaguliers (see Phil. Trans., No. 419, or New Abridg., vol. 6, p. 542), in which two equal weights may be placed at any imequal distance whatever from the centre of motion, and still remain in equilibrio. In Fig. 3, pi. 5, A B represents a balance with equal arms, and E F another of equal dimensions : they turn freely upon the centres C D, and their extremities are connected by equal • A Course of Lectures on Natural Philosophy. By Thomas Young, M.D. 2vol8.4to. 1807. 140 PERPKTUUM mobile; inflexible bars A E, B F ; the whole being permitted to move freely at the points A B C D, so as to assume the forms of varying parallelograms, in consequence of any motion upon {Fig. 3, pi. 5.) the points C and D. Across the bars A E, B F, are fixed others, as W U, P Q, from any points of which equal weights, P W, may be suspended. Now, on whatsoever part of the bar P Q the weight P is fixed, it is manifest that it will, on account of that bar being firmly connected with the vertical rod B F, act as though it were placed at F ; and, in like manner, in whatever part of the bar W U the weight W be suspended, it will act as though it were placed at E : so that, however great may be the difference of the distances of the bodies P and W from C D, they will still, if equal in weight, balance each other in any position of the system. Nor is this in any respect incompatible with the principle of the equal products of weight and velocity, which we have men- tioned (130) as a useful indication of an equilibrium; for, suppose this compound balance to be brought by motion on its centres into the position a b c d, the weights being then at w and p, those weights will have moved through the arcs Ww, Fp, while the extremities of the levers will have passed through the equal and respectively parallel arcs A a, E 6, B 3, OK, SEARCH FOE SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 141 ¥/; of consequence, the velocities of the two weights will have been equal, as they ought to be, in conformity with that principle. Thus, then, it . appears, from this simple con- trivance, that weights do not preponderate in machines merely on accoimt of their different distances from the centre of motion; and, consequently, a mere increase of distance does not universally give a mechanical advantage. [The paragraph 130, before alluded to, occurs at page 71» as follows : — ] 130. Writers on the subject of mechanics have often attempted to demonstrate the properties of the several simple machines by means of a celebrated theorem, which is this : When two heavy bodies counterpoise each other by means of any machine, and are then made to move together, the pro- ducts of each mass into its velocity, or, as it is technically expressed, the quantities of motion with which one body descends and the other ascends perpendicularly, will be equal. Since an equilibrium always accompanies this equality of motions, it bears such a resemblance to the case wherein two moving bodies stop each other when they meet together with equal quantities of motion, that many have thought that the cause of an equilibrium in the several machines might be immediately assigned by saying that, because one body always loses as much motion as it communicates to another, two heavy bodies coimteracting each other must continue at rest when they are so circumstanced that one cannot descend without causing the other to ascend at the same time, and with velocities inversely proportional to their masses ; for then, should one of them begin to descend, it must instantly lose its whole motion by communicating it to the other. But this argument, however plausible it may seem, is (as Dr. Hamilton remarked) by no means satisfactory ; for when we say that one body commimicates its motion to another, we must necessarily suppose the motion to exist first in the one and then in the other ; but in the present case, where the two bodies are so connected that one cannot possibly begin to move before the other, the descending body cannot be said to communicate its motion to the other, and thereby make it ascend ; but whatever we should suppose causes one body to descend, must also be the immediate cause of the other's ascending, since, from the connection of the bodies, it muit 142 PERPExyuM mobile; act upon them both together, as if they were really but one. And therefore, without contradicting the laws of motion, we might suppose the superior weight of the heavy body, which is in itself more than able to sustain the lighter, would over- come the lighter, and cause it to ascend with the same quantity of motion with which the heavier descends ; especially as both their motions, taken together, may be less than what the diiFerence of the weights, which is here supposed to be the moving force, would be able to produce in a body falling freely. For these reasons, and various others which might easily be assigned, we are of opinion that all proofs founded upon this theorem as a basis are necessarily imsatisfactory : we have, nevertheless, thought it right to notice it ; and, as it may serve as a good index of an equilibrium in many machines, and admits in some instances of a useful applica- tion, we may again refer to it in the practical part of this treatise.* In treating " Of Friction," Millington says : — From a number of experiments that have been made to investigate the power of friction, it appears to increase in a less ratio than that of the weight of the moving body, although this conclusion is contrary to the generally-received opinion, and has a limit ; for if the moving siirface be too small or too thin to support its own weight, it will not bear evenly, and will wear into a groove or notch which may occasion much additional friction. However perfectly a piece of machinery may be made, still friction, to a certain degree, must ever exist, and cannot be prevented. It follows, therefore, that the power that is given to one extreme of a machine can never be conveyed without abatement to the other ; and hence it will immediately appear that a perpetual motion is impossible, because this presumes that a certain power is to be communicated to a machine, and is to be transferred through all its different movements from the beginning to the end of the machine, when it must be given back again without diminution, in order that it may be communicated back again to the beginning of the machine to * A Trectise of Mechanics. Bv Olinihus Gregory, LL.D., &c. 2 vols. 8vo. Third edition, 1815. (Vol. 1, pp. 71 and 82.) OB, SEARCH FOR SHLF-MOTIYE POWER. 143 produce a repetition of the same impulse it had produced in the first instance, otherwise the motion of the machine could not be maintained. But since no effect can be produced that is greater than its cause, and as the cause must be diminished by friction, vis inertitSy &c., in its transfer through a machine, so it cannot be renewed with a power equal to that with which it began; consequently, a perpetual motion must be considered as an unattainable thing, inasmuch as it implies a renewal of power which no machine can give to itself.* In his " Manual," Partington describes, as follows, a well-known galvanic apparatus maintaining long-continued motion : — Mr. Singer contrived an arrangement (of M. De Luc's electrical colimm or dry pile) which is well calculated to form a perpetual motion, by excluding, to a very considerable extent, the operation of extraneous causes of interruption ; and it at the same time renders the disposition of the appa- ratus rather elegant. A series of from 1,200 to 1,600 groups are arranged in two columns of equal length, which are separately insulated in a vertical position by glass pillars con- structed on his principle of insulation ; the positive end of one column is placed lowest, and the negative end of the other ; and their upper extremities being connected by a wire, they may be considered as one continuous column. A small bell is situated between each extremity of the colimm and its insulating support, and a brass ball is suspended by a thin thread of raw silk, so as to hang midway between the bells, and at a very little distance from each of them. For this purpose, the bells are connected, during the adjustment of the pendulum, by a wire, that their attraction may not inter- fere with it ; and, when the wire is removed, the motion of the pendulum commences. The apparatus is placed upon a circular mahogany base, in which a groove is turned to receive the lower edge of a glass shade, with which the whole is covered.f ♦ An Epitome of the Elementary Principles of Natural and Experi- mental Philosophy. 1 vol. 8vo. 1823. Page 85. f A Manual of Natural and Experimental Philosophy. By Charles F. Partington. 8vo. 1828. Vol. 2, p. 206. 144 PERPETUUM mobile; Dr. Amott, in his " Elements of Physics," section 2 of the first part, on " Motions and Forces," says : — Further illustrative of the truths that action and reaction are equal and contrary, and that in every case of hard bodies striking each other, they may be regarded as compressing a very small strong spring between them, we may mention that when any elastic body, as a billiard ball, strikes another larger than itseK, and reboimds, it gives to that other, not only all the motion which it originally possessed, but an additional quantity, equal to that with which it recoils, owing to the equal action in both directions of the repulsion or spring which causes the recoil. When the difference of size between the bodies is very great, the returning velocity of the smaller is nearly as great as its advancing motion was, and it gives a momentum to the body struck, nearly double of what it originally itself possessed. This phenomenon constitutes the paradoxical case of an effect being greater than its cause, and has led persons imperfectly acquainted with the subject to seek from the principle a perpetuum mobile, (Page 109.) The following reflections occur at page 141, part 2, " Mechanics :" — What an infinity of vain schemes — some of them displaying great ingenuity — for perpetual motions, and new mechaniced engines of power, &c., would have been checked at once, had the great truth been generally understood, that no form or combination of machinery ever did or ever can increase, in the slightest degree, the quantity of power applied. Ignor- ance of this is the hinge on which most of the dreams of mechanical projectors have turned. No year passes, even now, in which many patents are not taken out for such supposed discoveries; and the deluded individuals, after selling perhaps even their household goods to obtain the means of securing the supposed advantages, often sink in despair, when their attempts, instead of bringing riches and happiness to their families, end in disappointment and utter ruin. The frequency and eagerness and obstinacy with which even talented individuals, owing to their imperfect knowledge of this part of natural philosophy, have engaged in such undertakings, is a remarkable phenomenon in human nature. OB, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 145 In section 1 of the third part, treating on " Hydrostatics,'* he says : — A projector thought that the vessel of his contrivance, represented here, was to solve the renowned problem of the perpetual motion.* It was goblet-shaped, lessening gradually towards the bottom until it became a tube, bent upwards at c, and pointing with an open extremity into the goblet again. He reasoned thus : A pint of water in the goblet a must more than counterbalance an ounce which the tube b will contain, and must there- fore be constantly pushing the ounce forward into the vessel again at a, and keeping up a stream or circulation, which will cease only when the water dries up. He was confoimded when a trial shewed him the same level in a and in 6.f In Montucla's admirable " Histoire des Mathematiques," completed by J. de la Lande, and published in 4 vols., 4to., 1802, no less than eight pages are devoted to a dissertation (here briefly translated) as follows : — On perpetual motion — a chimera old and celebrated enough in mechanics for us to treat of it in this work. It is under- stood to be a movement which continually preserves and renews itself without exterior help. Many real discoveries have been the result of this enquiry. Montucla's " Mathe- matical Recreations" and the "Journal des Savans," 1678 to 1746, treat on this subject. Several machines have been made, intended to solve this knotty problem, and made much noise in the scientific world, but have all proved failures ; and it is now more an insult than praise to say any one is * A contrivance on precisely the same principle here enunciated, was proposed by the Ahbe de la Roque, in *' Le Journal des Sj^avans, Paris, 1686. The instrument was a U tuhe, one leg longer than the other and bent over, so that any liquid might drop into the top end of the short leg, which he proposed to be made of wax, and the long one of iron. Pre- suming the liquid to be more condensed in the metal than the wax tube, it would flow from the end into the wax tube, and so continue. Page 29* t Elements of Physics, or Natural Philosophy. By Neil Arnott, M.D. Third editioD, 1828. Page 270. M 146 PERPETTJTJM MOBILE; searching after perpetual motion. Among all the known properties of matter and motion, there does not appear among them one single principle that would give the intended effect. It is allowed that action and reaction must be equal. Fric- tion and the air also retard motion. Neither can any machine receive greater motive power than that which is first com- municated to it. And perpetual motion cannot take place imless the power communicated be much greater than the generating power, and imless it compensates for the diminu- tion of power caused by friction, which is impossible. Thus the question is reduced to finding a weight heavier than itself, or an elastic power greater than itself. Thus it is requisite to find some method by which a combination of mechanical power will gain a strength equivalent to that which is lost ; it is principally this last poiijt that is sought, to resolve the problem. It is certain that the multiplication of powers serves no purpose, as whatever is gained in power is lost in time, so that the quantity of motion remains the same. One small power can never be mechanically made really equal to a greater one. Maupertius, in his letters on different scientific subjects, remarks that atmospheric changes, &c., are excluded, and that inertia, &c., are alone made subservient to obtaining perpetual motion, which he considers unattainable. Inertia and elasticity are also inapplicable. In 1700, a report was current that perpetual motion had been found. Sauveur explained it to the Academy of Sciences, and Parent proved its impossibility. In the philosophical works* of *s Gravesande, published at Amsterdam, 1774, is an account of a machine constructed by Orffyreus in 1715. It was called the Wheel of Cassel, and is described in a letter to Newton. Gravesande is persuaded that it can be shown that perpetual motion is not a contra- diction ; and it appears to him that Leibnitz was wrong in regarding as an axiom the impossibility of this movement. It caused general surprise that this great man should try to prove its possibility, and expressing a hope that the prejudices of mathematicians regarding this movement would not pre- vent their giving serious attention to the subject. Jean Bernoulli also believes in the success of Orffyreus' s discovery. (See Opera, tome i., page 41.) Wolf, in I7I6, in his " Dictionary of Mathematics,*' gives OR, SEARCH FOR 8ELF-M0TIYE POWER. 147 the arguments of Sturm, Lorini, St6vin, and Leibnitz, against perpetual motion. He considers there is a doubt whether the movement in Orffyreus^s machine was not the effect of some invisible fluid. The examination that ^sGravesande made of Orffyreus's wheel so aggravated him that he broke the machine the same day, as may be seen in the " Annal. Physico-Med. de Breslaw," Leipzig, 1723, page 427. Also, in his life, ^sGravesande states that Orflfyreus wrote on the wall that it was the imper- tinent curiosity of the professor which caused him to break it. This seems to indicate that he feared an ulterior examination ; but *8 Gravesande has never confessed that he himself was deceived. At the same period appeared D. G. Diez's disser- tation against perpetual motion, and he names De Lanis, Drebbel, Becher, and Mitz, all as chimeras. Peresc and Kepler were incredulous on this subject, the first wrote 1691 and the latter 1607 (published 1718). Baron de Zach has made some very curious researches in respect to different inventions for perpetual motion, in " Reichs-Anzeiger," 1796. In conclusion, there is a lecture on perpetual motion, by Henrich., 1770. In 1775, the Royal Academy of Sciences in Paris passed the resolution not to examine any machines announced as intended for perpetual motion, and gave their motives for so doing in the History of the Academy, 1775, page 65. [See Appendix E.] 148 PERPETUUM mobile; CHAPTER VI. PAPERS FROM EARLY SCIENTIFIC AND OTHER JOURNALS. The "Gentleman's Magazine'* and "Annual Registers" afford several interesting communications; some from each were necessarily transferred to Chapter II. We have here, also, the "Monthly Magazine" of 1806-19; "Annals of Philosophy," 1820 ; and " Royal Institution," 1802. The following are from the " Gentleman's Magazine :" — I. — ^Two " Schemes for the Discovery of the Longitude." Two persons — one at Exeter, the other at Dublin — conceive they have made some discoveries towards finding out the important secret of the longitude. The Irish gentleman declares he has made several trials with good success, after a plain, easy, intelligent way, by machines of his own invention, which have given him an entire confidence of the truth of their operation ; but not having opportunity to try the experiment at sea in different kinds of weather, wherein he has not the least doubt of success, he invites the assistance of some publick-spirited gentleman to fit out a ship two or three months for that purpose ; on which consideration he will communicate the secret, and assign over half the reward. The Exonian (who, by the way, signs himself "The Farmer," because he had wrote something formerly under that name) is more explicit, and gives the following account of his scheme : — Discovery of a Perpetual Motion^ whereby the Longitude may be mechanically found. Before I proceed to this simple, yet most useful, discovery, I shall premise a few necessary things, viz. : — 1. That the difference of time is the difference of longitude. OR, SEABCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 149 because every 15 degrees to the eastward of any meridian is an hour sooner, and every 15 degrees to the westward is an hour later, in time, than at the said meridian ; since 24 times 15 degrees compose the 360 degrees of the earth's circum- ference. 2. Hence it must follow, that if any vessel revolve round the globe westward, a day will be gained when that revolu- tion is performed ; and if she make her revolution eastward, a day must be lost, since by how much she departs from her meridian to the eastward, by just so much she loses ; because every 15 degrees that way is one hour earlier in time ; the 360 degrees in this eastern circuit must be 24 hours earlier, and consequently that time must be lost by a well-regulated perpetual motion, and the contrary. 3. It is generally allow' d, that the perpetual motion being found, this would discover the longitude ; which I also grant, but with this provision, that it is so nicely regulated as to keep time exactly with or without an equation-table ; that is to say, equal time to correspond with the sun. 4. Yet, as I prefer such a perpetual motion as will keep pace with apparent time, or, in other words, with the sun's shadow on a dial, or a true meridian line, being discovered stands in no need of any equation-table at all; so I shall evidently make it appear that such a motion is found, in a proper sense ^for our purpose. So that what has hitherto been thought impossible by the generality of mankind shall no longer be a secret. And, 5. It must be granted, when duly considered, that there are many movements which, in the sense foregoing, may be called perpetual ; yet, hitherto, there never came under my observation any of them that could be depended on in the case before us, except that one which I shall discover. 6. I will instance in two particulars, that are easily framed, tho* not very common. First, There are some spring clocks and watches, so con- trived by art as to lose no time in winding, by having a spring fixed to stand free from the work, except at such times as they are to be wound up ; but then, by pulling a string fastened to it for that end, this spring presses sufficiently on a tooth in the main wheel to keep the movement going, so that no time is lost in winding. And this, I say, in a proper sense to the purpose, may be calFd perpetual ; yet none of them 160 PERPETUtTM mobile; can be so suiEciently adjusted as to keep time to exactness, therefore not to be depended on in this case. Secondly, Our long pendulum clocks, which are by the same contrivance kept going while wound, may be said, in the same sense, to be perpetual in their motion ; yet even these, tho' nearer the truth than the other, are not to be depended on in a matter of so great moment. Nor, indeed, is there any equation-table extant that is just, even Flamstead's correct table being about 15 minutes erroneous at one time of the year, tho' it is right in October, when his greatest difference comes to 16 min. 2 sec. Having thus premised, my next business shall be to demonstrate a perpetual motion, that comes so near the truth as not to vary from apparent time (tho* that is very unequal) 3 min. in a whole year, tho' daily proved by a dial well set, or by a just meridian line ; which I take to be the greatest discovery hitherto so publickly made manifest. But in order thereto, and to carry instruction with me to a mean capacity, I must have recourse to the method whereby so wonder-working a machine was first framed, by the late most ingenious Joseph Williamson, watch-maker, in London, whose name there is famous, and his works greatly admired. [He then explains how this horologist, from "his thirst after the knowledge of equation," spent seven years in forming correct tables.] From this true equation-table, this excellent workman formed an elliptical wheel, that revolved once a year, and so fixed it to the day of the month, that it had such influence on the pendulum, by shortening and lengthening it, that his clocks, thus framed, would keep time to admiration with the sun, and therefore he called them his sun-clocks. This is the perpetual motion I commend to the world, for it loses no time at all in winding. [This last expression shows how much it partook of a real perpetual motion. He goes on to state the praise bestowed on the invention in " a speech made to the Royal Society by Sir Isaac Newton." After this, follow observations on its uses, the mode of fixing it on board ship, with several neces- sary precautions.] And so curious is the invention, that the spring which keeps the work going while the clock is wound up is also fixed to a plate that always by its force slides back again to OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 153 close the holes that receive the key for that end, when the tooth of the main wheel has, in its course, slipt from it. I subscribe, The Farmer. P.S. — Nothing hitherto found can be so regularly ad- justed to the time as a long pendulum movement. All springs are fallible, and short pendulums too. But those of about 33 inches long, that beat true seconds, are next to infallibility, being kept in perpetual motion, as I here mani- fest they may be.* II. — ^Raising water: — ^Fig. 1, Col. Kranach's machine for constant motion, with a power tgt raise water. Fig. 2, Mr. Gervas's engine for raising water. EXPLANATION. Fig. 1 represents an artificial machine for constant motion ; the inventor is Col. Kranach, who, in a book printed at Ham- burgh, asserts that when once put in motion for any of the following works, it will continue its operation both night and day without any other help or assistance except that of a small quantity of standing water : that by it large and heavy weights may be drawn up, to 2,000 weight ; that in 24 hours it will fling out 2,400 barrels of water, and is therefore highly necessary for the draining of land overflown by inundations ; that it wiU be of great use in mines to draw up the water and ore 24 fathoms deep ; that it may be employed instead of wind or water mills, for all manner of uses ; and that this machine may be put either in a quick or slow motion. The author protests that he had laboured for thirty years together before he brought this machine to perfection, and declares his readiness to oblige any gentleman with a small or large model thereof, and to inspect the building of it for use, at a reasonable gratification. Vol. 7, 1737, p. «7. 154 PERPETXJTJM mobile; Fig. 2. — This is a representation of an engine for raising water, like that erected by Mr. Gervas, at Sir John Chester's, near Newport Pagnel. A and B are two copper buckets of an imequal weight and size, suspended by chains, which alternately wind off and on the multiplying wheel Y Z ; the part Y being smaller in diameter, and Z larger, in proportion to the different lift for which each is designed. The buckets being both filled with water from the spring, which affords a fall of ten feet, the larger bucket A, being heavier when fuU, though the lighter empty, descends the ten feet from C to D, and weighs up the lesser bucket, from E to F, perhaps 30 feet, where touch- ing a trigger it discharges its water into a cistern W, whence it is conveyed for service by the pipe T ; at the same time, the water by the like means is discharged (and runs away) from the larger bucket, which then being lighter is drawn up by the smaller (but at that time becomes the heavier) bucket, in order to be filled again at the spring. This work is con- tinued day and night, without any other force, and has not been out of order since it was set up in 1725. The buckets are guided by two iron rods on each side, which run in grooves of the buckets, and the whole motion is kept steady by a jack fly L, which is turned by a spiral wheel at one end of the great axis M; and the other part of the regulator, being a quadrant with a moveable weight at I, is by a proper number of teeth on a conmiimicating wheel suffered to go only in a fourth of a circle, from G to K, and serves as a balance, while the chains of the buckets are winding off and on the wheels. This engine carries up one bucket containing 6 gallons of water in 5 minutes, but then there is a waste of water ten gallons, which are the contents of the larger bucket ; but Dr. Desaguliers observes, that it is not the hundredth part of what is spent by a water wheel to raise an equal quantity of water to the same height. The desirable improvement of this engine is to prevent the great waste of water, — and we are informed that can be effected in some degree by Thomas Yeoman, of Northampton. But the reason of exhibiting this engine, together with that of the German engine (Fig. 1) is from a suggestion, that a round weight might by some means be made to run in and out of a scale or bucket, and so raise up water with very little (Fig. 2, pi. 16.) (Fig. 1, pi. 18 ) OK, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIYE POWER. 159 or no waste. We promise, as an encouragement to the attempt, five pounds for the person who first compleats such a work, or produces a model for the like effect. This, it is apprehended, will be much easier performed than the great operations mentioned by Col. Kranach. However, that person who can come at such a secret will not want five pounds, or a hundred times larger.* III. — ^In the Gentleman's Magazine is described a " Self- moving Machine." A full account of the same machine, with an engraving, as here given, will be foimd in " Le Journal des Sgavans, 1678 [re-printed Paris, 1724], 4to, page 79, entitled " Le mouve- ment perpetuel purement artificiel invente et execute par le P. Stanislas Solski, Jesuite Poonois." The Magazine article proceeds : — Description. — Fig. 1, a self-moving machine, invented by a Polish Jesuit. It consists of a pump, whose body ah f g is a palm and two fingers* breadth in diameter, and four palms in height; the head d e f g\& a palm in height ; the cylinder a b d e of the body of the pump is two palms and a half in height, of which the piston c c fills up one palm ; the other palm and a half must hold at least five cans of water, each containing three quarts. * The wooden pipe from / g to the horizontal pipe n nis about thirty-two palms in vertical height. The author observes that if the diameter of the mouth of the pipe A « be equal to that of the cavity of the pimip, and the diameter of the iron rod h k be of such size as that the pipe f g n shall contain only seventeen cans of water, the maclune will be the easier worked, as the water being forced thro' a passage less strait meets with less resistance. The diameter of the hole / g must be equal to half the diameter d e oi the body of the pump, whence it will be four times straiter than the body of the pump, because circles are to one another as the squares of their diameters. The machine works in the following manner : — The piston • Vol. 17, 1747, p. 459. 160 PEBPETUUM mobile; c c being at the bottom of the pump, the suckers, both of the pump and of the piston, shut by their own weight, whence by the descent of the bucket p, the wheel m w, six feet in diameter, is turned, by which means the chain k z, by passing round the axis II oi the wheel, raises the iron rod k A, and the piston c c, at which instant the sucker of the pump opens, and gives passage to the water, which is forced into the body of the pump by the weight of the external air. The counter- poise V descends, and so turns the wheel m m, round which goes the cord mm o, which, descending on the other side, raises the bucket. In proportion as the counterpoise v descends, and the bucket p is raised, the axis of the great wheel is freed from the twistings of the cord, and so the piston by its own weight, and that of the iron rod, falls down to the bottom of the body of the pump, and by that means the sucker of the pump shuts, and the five cans of water moimt up thro* the piston by its sucker, which opens above. The same operation is readily performed again, in order to carry that water into the pipe f g nni, whence it is discharged thro' the horizontal pipe fi n into the basin, which holds at least thirty-two pounds of water. This water falls into the bucket jo, thro' the pipe q r, whose clap opens, being raised by two cross sticks, which are fastened to the cord, and lift up the bar o y. The bucket p contains four cans and a half of water ; it is two palms in length, ten at the opening, and six inches in depth, where the two long faces \miting form an angle of 120 degrees : being thus filled, it descends apace, and the bar n o being depressed, the clap falls and closes the pipe q r, and as it descends 30 feet, and as the great wheel is 10 feet in diameter, it makes an entire revolution, and thus the axis / / twisting up the chain k z, the rod k b raises anew the piston c, and carries again at least four cans and a half of water into the basin n q, thro' the horizontal pipe n n. The bucket, when descended almost to the surface of the water of the well, is raised again by the cord 8 t, which is too short to reach the water, and being for the present dis- charged of its weight, the piston descends to the bottom of the body of the pump, by its own weight and that of the rod h k, and the cross sticks o of the cord of the bucket coming imder the bar o y, raises it together with the clap, that the water of the basin n q may fall again, thro' the pipe OB, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 163 q r, into the bucket p, causing it to descend anew, and so maintain a perpetual motion. There are several other small pieces in this machine, the use of which is easily comprehended.* IV. — ^A new plain draught of a Self-moving Wheel, tho* not perpetual ; with a description of its parts, and manner of operating; submitted to the inspection and amusement of the curious. Directions to make a Self moving Wheel, Let there be a well-turned board, of at least two feet diameter. At Fig. 1, six pins for the chequers to turn upon. At Fig. 2, let in brass grooves into the board for the receiving of rollers, which must be fastened to the bottom points of the small chequers. At Fig. 3, place pullies. At the points of the small chequers fasten chains that pass lound the pullies, and are made fast to both points of the next large chequer ; the chains must be all of an equal length. Make very substantial brass chequers, with good joints to ^by free without wriggling, and of as large a size as the dicumference of the wheel will admit, and fix weights at the points of the said chequers. Remarks upon the manner of Operating, Observe, that one pound, placed at the zenith of the larg chequer, is correctly equal to two pounds placed at the nadir of the small chequer ; and that this power (if occasion be) may easily be either increased or diminished at pleasure, by only fastening the chains farther off or nigher to the weights : therefore, it is self-evident that the weights above the horizon cannot want full power for the drawing in of all the weights below it ; more especially those particular weights that arrive gradually to the mounting side of the wheel, as is shewn hereafter. And this is done by reason of the chains being all in a diagonal position, therefore the weights below the • Vol.21, 1751, p. 391. 164 PERPETUUM MOBILE ; horizon cannot be otherwise drawn in by such slant lines, than into a gradual, regular, elliptical form, as they appear in . the plate. But to prevent the said weights from being either too much or too little drawn in, this diagonal position of the chains may, by means of the pullies, be made to slant more or less, so as to answer to the right elliptical form of drawing in the weights as shall be requisite ; and thus, by this elliptical form of the weights, the power of gravity must needs give the wheel some considerable share of movement, so as to cause the weight B, &c., to descend below the horizon, where they will run out to the same length, as you see the weight A does, to the very great and constant supply of power to the descending side of the wheel. As to the moimting side of the wheel, by the manner of chaining the chequers to each other, they become partly as it' were all of one piece, so that the weights above the horizon can no way press down their chequers, without communicating their drawing-in power to, and being always felt, in a certain measure, by every weight of the wheel, in the elliptical manner above mentioned, with respect to the diagonal position of the chains. Moreover, whatever number of weights shall descend below the horizon on the one hand, the like number of weights must ascend above it on the other, where they, in conjimction, will press down their chequers with ample force, for the gradual dxawing-in of those extended weights which are their next followers, reducing them into the same less extended form as they themselves were in just before they were carried above the horizon. After the same gradual manner, by the power of the weights above, will all the extended weights be thus gradually reduced, drawn in, and carried round, when, at the same time, the elliptical form of the wheel, by the constant supply of weights running out at the descending side, will at aU times be kept up, like as at the first setting off of the wheel, for the continuance of the movement. By all which it appears that there are two different and distinct acting powers in this wheel, both which, by the freeness of the joints and other parts, in a workman-like manner, cannot but act with that puissance as to leave no room to reflect upon friction in any respect whatever. Therefore, if, upon due inspection, no objection shall appear against either of the said powers, is not here a discovery of a OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTITE POWER. 165 new power in a short, easy, obvious manner, capable of any improvement in proportion to the size of the wheel, so as to be applicable to ten thousand different uses, both great and smaU? Suppose we compare this wheel with the Marquis of Worcester's great wheel (see vol. 18,* pp. 9, 61, 107), some time since shewn in the Tower of London, there will appear the following most material differences : — His wheel was contrived with loose, running weights, forty in number, of fifty pounds each ; which, at the nadir, bore the same distance from the centre as the weights at the descending side, upon which accoimt, no such contrivance can possibly ever answer the design to keep moving, as is easily demonstrable ; whereas, in this wheel, the weights at the nadir will at all times be considerably nigher the center than the weights of the descending side, the consequence of which wants no explaining. And should one of these wheels be made up for any large use, and, by mistakes in the workman, it be so made as not to answer ftdly to the purpose, as mentioned above, still the same would be of exceeding great service by being applied to co-operate with the powers of a fire engine, for the raising of double the quantity of water they now raise, "which is the same thing as the saving of half the quantity of coals that are now consumed. t *^* As a considerable wager is depending whether a model, upon these principles, can be made to operate, any artist, who imagines that he can make such a one, at a moderate price, may send his terms in writing to E. Cave, at St. John's Gate. The Self -moving Wheel shewn to be defective by a Mechanical Demonstration. Mr. Urban, — * * * What I have here sent you is an attempt to prove that the wheel with weights, described in your last magazine, tho* put in motion by the hand, will not continue and preserve that motion any better than a common plain wheel would. * * * * In the following demonstration, I suppose, and take for • Where a copy is given of the Marquis's Century of Inventions, with original remarks on each. t Vol. 21, 1751, p. 448. 166 PERPETUUM mobile; granted, that Mr. A. B., by his self-moving, tho* not perpetual, wheel, as he terms it, means such a wheel as, by the action of gravity alone, would continue in a regular imiform motion round its axis, till some of the parts of it are decayed or out of order. I suppose, too, since he says nothing to the con- trary, the weights are all exactly equal. And I suppose and allow that such weights, fitted to the wheel in the manner he directs, would, by the action of gravity, so form themselves as to be constantly farther distant from the center of motion on the descending side than on the ascending. It must be allowed, too, that any weight so fixed (or, to speak more pro- perly, the center of gravity of it) would, in every entire revolution of the wheel, describe a curve line returning into itself again, and that all the other weights would successively describe the same curve — ^perhaps not of a regular elliptical form, as Mr. A. B. imagines, but quite irregular in its shape. However this be, it matters not, so long as a line passing per- pendicularly thro* the center of motion, and produced both ways till it touches the curve in two points (which points we shall call the zenith and the nadir, and suppose to be marked with the letters Z and N), divides it into two unequal parts, whereof that through which the weights descend is the largest and most distant from the center of motion, as, from what has been already granted, must be the case here. These things being premised, let us now examine what power gravity will supply any one single weight with, to continue the wheel in motion : let us call this weight W. Now, 'tis plain that W, in its passage from the zenith to the nadir, thro' the greatest and most distant part of the curve, will yet descend perpendicularly, or get nearer to the center of the earth only as much as comes to the length of the line Z N. In its further progress from the nadir to the zenith, from whence it first set out, tho' it be thro' a less and nearer part of the curve, it will, notwithstanding this, ascend perpen- dicularly, or recede from the earth's center the length of the same line N Z ; and, therefore, since the weight W is obliged, in every entire revolution, to ascend perpendicularly thro' as large a space as it descends, it follows that the reaction of gravity upon it, whilst it is in the ascending part of the curve, will be exactly equal to the action of gravity whilst in the contrary part of it; whence 'tis plain that, upon the whole, this particular weight W will not be supply' d, by OB, SEABCII FOB SELF-MOTITE POWIfiB. 167 gravity, with the least power to continue the wheel in motion, tho', by application of the hand, it was once set agoing. The same will hold true of every other weight fixed to the wheel ; and therefore all the weights, be the number what it will, will have no power at all, upon the whole, to continue the wheel in motion ; so that (if we abstract from what difference may be caus'd through friction — ^resistance) this wheel would continue moving no longer than any common plain wheel would that had the same velocity at first given to it by the hand. Q.E.D. But to make this still plainer, instead of one, let us con- sider two opposite weights together, and examine wherein the material difference lies between the action of two equal weights so placed in this machine, and of two others fixed to the ends of any common lever, whose center of motion is at some distance from its middle point. Now, with respect to the lever, let the two equal weights fixed to it be called W and X. Let W be that which is farthest from the center of motion, and let the lever be placed in a horizontal situation. The reason why W will in this case preponderate, tho' the weights be equal, is because it can approach the center of the earth faster than it obliges X to recede from it ; for W, in passing from its first position to its lowest point— that is, till the lever becomes vertical — ^will have got nearer to the center of the earth, just as much as comes to its o^vn distance from the center of motion, and X, in the meanwhile, will have ascended thro* a space equal to its distance from the same ; but the distance of X from the fulcrum, or center of motion, was, by supposition, less than that of W ; and, therefore, since W in this case does in the same time descend further than it obliges X to ascend, it necessarily follows that it can and does descend faster, which is the reason of its prepon- derating and causing the lever to move. But tibe case of two equal and opposite weights that are fixed to Mr. A. B.'s wheel is quite different; for, let the two weights be here, also, called W and X, His plain that in the same time that W moves from Z to N, X must move from N to Z ; in which time also X will have ascended just as much as W has descended, or will have receded from the center of the earth just as much as W has approached towards it : the recess of the one and the access of the other being equal to the same line Z N. And therefore, tho' the absolute velocities 168 PERPETUUM mobile; of W and X may be, and are, very different ( W in this case describing a larger part of the curve, whilst X describes a less), yet wUl their perpendicular velocities be the same ; and, consequently, since the two weights are, by supposition, equal, W will not preponderate or cause X to move. The same may be said of every other pair of weights that are opposite, and therefore all the weights on the descending side will not preponderate or cause the wheel to move. Whence 'tis plain again that Mr. A. B.*s wheel with weights is no better (fisposed to be put or continue in motion, by the action of gravity upon it, than any common plain wheel is. Q.E.D. Mb. Ubban, — Now I am writing to you upon this subject, I shall beg leave to add a short general demonstration, to shew that it is utterly impossible for any wheel whatsoever, by means of weights affixed, to be so contrived, as, by the action of gravity alone, to be put and continued in motion round its axis, even so much as for one single revolution. *Tis a well-known truth in mechanicks, that if gravity, actmg on any body, can't move the center of gravity of that body, it can't move the body at all. Now, a wheel furnished with weights, in any manner whatsoever, may be considered as one complete body, the center of gravity of which can either be made to move, by the action of gravity upon the body, or it can not. If the line of direction of the center of gravity of this complex body passes directly thro' the center of motion, in this case, the center of gravity, and, con- sequently, the body itself, will not be moved at all by the action of gravity alone ; but if the aforesaid line of direction passes on one side of the center of motion, in this case, as the center of gravity is not immediately sustained, it may therefore descend, and the wheel may move ;* but this center of gravity, by the action of gravity on the body, will never be made to perform a whole revolution round the center of motion; it will only vibrate for some time in the • I say that in this case it may descend, but not that it always will do so; for tho', in the wheel of the Marquis of Worcester, and of Mr. A. B., the line of direction of the center of gravity of the whole machine passes on one side of the center of motion, and at a considerable distance from it, yet in such machines, tho* turned by the hand, the center of gravity will not move at all, but is as much fixed as if it coincided with the center cf motion. on, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 169 manner of a pendulum, which vibrating motion, by unavoid- able friction and resistance, will be soon destroyed, and the body, with its center of gravity, remain at rest without having performed so much as one single entire revolution. Q.E.D. If the publishing of what has been here said gives such satisfaction to the publick as may prevent any future attempts of this kind, which have hitherto always proved fruitless, and frequently very expensive, and which, I am thoroughly persuaded, can never be successful, my end is answered ; but if not, I shall at least have the satisfaction myself to think that it can do no harm in the world, which is more than can be truly said of many things that have lately appeared in print. Twiford, Nov. 20, 1751. T. P.* Mr. Urban, — Reading in your last Magazine, p. 501, Mr. T. P.*s attempt to prove the wheel with weights, described in your last October Magazine, p. 449, tho' put in motion by the hand, will not continue moving any longer than a common wheel would ; when, at the same time, he allows that weights so fitted to a wheel, in the manner directed, would, by the action of gravity, so form themselves as to be constantly further distant from the center of the wheel on the descending side than on the ascending; he also allowing that weights so ordered would, in every revolution of the wheel, describe a curve line, returning into itself again, and that all the weights of the wheel will describe the same curve, and, by consequence, granting, though he does not mention it, that the weights at the bottom of the wheel, as well as all those at the moimting side, will be always nigher the center than the weights at the descending : these things being supposed must infallibly render the wheel constantly lapsided, which is all that is, or need be, required to continue its motion. Whatever may be in old objections, against old contrivances, is one thing, but to contrive to have the weights at the bottom of the wheel, as well as the weights at the mounting side, to be always nigher the center than the weights of the descending side, I take to be a quite new discovery, and is • Vol.21, 17J1, p. 501. 170 PEBPETUUM mobile; more than can be said of any former contrivance whatever ; but as to the consequences of this promising contrivance, I cannot see how it can be emy further known, without making of the experiment. I am, &c.. Queen Street, Westminster. M. B.* V. — Perpetual Motion proposed to be effected by Magnetism. — Alleged discovery by Hero Hicken, of Friezland. Mb. Ubban, — ^Ever since I became acquainted with the mechanical powers (which is now near seven years ago), the greatest part of my leisure time has been employed upon inventions for the good of the publick. Each branch of ex- perimental philosophy has in turn engaged my attention; and I might also add, that each has in turn but modesty forbids me to proceed. Yet I must tell you, that if the attraction of the loadstone would have supported a weight at the distance of but | of an inch (which a printed book affirms for a truth), gravity before this time had been useless in clockwork, and the longitude effectually discovered. I was extremely sorry, as you may very well suppose, that so useful a scheme should miscarry ; and so much the more, as I was within less than an inch of it. But disappointments, Mr. Urban, we must expect to meet with, as my attempts upon perpetual motion have often experimentally taught me. For that, you must know, in spite of demonstration, has ever been my favorite pursuit, and many are the projects that I have successively been big with ; some lasted a week, some a fort- night, but a month most commonly put an end to them all. But, however, I have at last succeeded. My present scheme had overcome every objection that either my own head, or my neighbour's, could possibly bring against it ; and I was drawing out a plan of it to transmit to you, when the follow- ing article appeared in the " Gazetteer :" — " A paragraph from Amsterdam, in the last * Utrecht Ga- zette,* says, that at Doornum, in East Friezland, a mechanic, named Hero Hicken, has invented a machine, which, being • Vol. 21, 1751, p. 610. OB, SBABCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 171 once set in motion, teeps going perpetually, till such time as the materials of which it is composed are fallen to decay, or the structure of the machine itself altered." It is impossible for me to tell you, Mr. Urban, what a terrible damp this threw upon my spirits ; in spight of all my philosophy, I was neither able to eat, drink, or sleep, for a considerable time after. For this was not only a full demon- stration that my scheme was practicable, but also attended with this melancholy circumstance, that England would lose the honour of it. As a month has now elapsed since I met with the above account, without any further confirmation of it, my uneasi- ness is greatly abated, and I now begin to flatter myself, that either M. Hicken's project has failed, or that the whole account is only one of those periodical paragraphs that appear once in about thirty years. But, as my situation does not permit me to make a strict enquiry into the truth of these matters, I freely resign that office to those of your readers who have leisure enough to examine the arcana of news- mongers, or money enough to take a tramp to Doomum. I am, &c., Andbew DoswiL. EXPLANATION OF THE MACHINE. A B C D represents a frame of brass or wood for the ma- chine E F to rim in. E and F are two brass wheels, similar and equal, fixed upon a moveable axis G. 1, 2, 3, &c., are a nimiber of artificial magnets, placed within the teeth of the wheel all round, and as near each other as is possible, provided they do not touch ; their north poles at E, and their south poles at F. H and I are two similar and equal magnets fixed in the brass plate A C, very near each other, but not touching. K and L two more fixed in the brass plate B D. Now, as the north pole of one magnet repels the north pole of another magnet, and attracts the south ; and inversely the south pole of one magnet repels the south pole of another, and attracts the north ; so the south pole, I, attracts all the north ones at E ; and the north pole, H, repels all 172 PERPETUUM MOBILE I the north ones at M. In like manner, K attracts at N, and L repels at O, and by this means the whole machine E F moves perpetually round. N.B. — As the success of the machine depends a good deal on the nearness of the poles, the twentieth part of an inch is the thickness I would recommend for the magnets ; the proportion of every other part is as the artist pleases. The magnets are to be put, not flat, but edgeway to the wheel ; and to prevent anything affecting their virtue after they are touched, a brass ring to slide over the whole will be most convenient.* * Vol. S.-J, 1763, p. 439. OB, SEARCH FOR 8BLF-M0TITE POWER. 173 VI. — Under the title of "A new-invented Machine for Raising Water," appears a letter — To the Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufac- tures, and Commerce, the following proposal is with great deference submitted, by their most obedient humble sei-vant, Richard Blackwell. Mr. Urban, — Having read your Magazine for July last, wherein you have obliged the public with a print of that curious engine* for raising water in Kew Gardens, erected by the ingenious Mr. Sm^aton, it put me in mind of what I have often thought of — ^viz., that (upon the principle of Archi- Di^edes' water-screw) a machine might be contrived to raise water perpetually, by means of an over-shot wheel applied to the said screw, agreeable to the annexed drawing. On this principle I once undertook to construct a model of such a machine, but other employments not permitting me to finish it, I cannot ascertain the success ; yet I conceive the water which may be raised by the revolution of the screw, when applied to the overshot wheel, will be more than sufficient to keep it in constant motion ; and the surplus water may be applied to many useful purposes in life. The great utility of such a machine is very obvious, especially among the seats of our nobility and gentry, many of whom are so unhappily situated that they have no con- venience of water but at a continual expense of bringing it from some distant place ; whereas, could they raise it to a sufficient height, they might constantly be supplied without any trouble. Add to this the great advantage this machine may yield in pleasure gardens, and the infinite service the reservoir of water would be in cases of fire. If by experiment it should ?ippear that the water raised by the screw is more than sufficient to supply the over-shot wheel, the whole may be employed to add more power to that wheel, which may then be applied to many useful purposes where mill-work is applicable. • An Archimedes screw, erected in 1761. When worked by two horses, it supplies the lake and basins in the gardens with upwards of 3,60U hogsheads of water every twelve hours. 174 PEHPETUUM alobile; The whole is submitted to those gentlemen whose know- ledge in hydrostaticks renders them proper judges of such matters. A, the reservoir. B, the Archimedean screw, by the revolution of which the reservoir is supplied with water. C, the over-shot wheel, by the force of which the screw is kept in constant rotation. D, a small rivulet, or spring, which supplies the well with water. E, the bolt to regulate the flux of the water into the over- shot wheel.* Mr. Urban, — The ingenious gentleman whose plan of a machine for raising water by a perpetual motion you inserted in your Magazine (see p. 448) was, I am afraid, too sanguine in his hopes of success. Were the slowness of the motion in this machine in proportion to the force with which it is expected to operate thoroughly considered, I imagine no practical trial need be made to convince us of the fallacy of its contrivance. First, then — The water which is thrown up by the screw can never be able • Vol. 33, 1763, p. 448. OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 175 to turn the wheel, both because of the smallness of its quantity and the slowness of its ascent through the screw, in proportion to its descent down the wheel ; for even supposing the screw to turn round twice (which is more than appears from the plan before us) whilst the wheel turns once, yet no more water can be thrown up by each revolution of the screw, than is contained in that part of its uppermost helix, which lies above an horizontal line drawn through the middle of the screw. (See the annexed diagram, A B.) Now, can twice this quantity of water be supposed to turn this wheel round — especially when the stream in which it falls, falls by fits, and is inter- mitted till the return of the mouth of the upper helix of the screw to the surface of the reservoir ? But though we sup- pose even this to be possible, if the screw were suspended at its center of motion, yet we can scarcely allow it to be so, when the screw is far from being thus suspended, and conse- quently far from that equilibrium which is alone consistent with an easy and regular motion. That this must be the case in this machine will, I hope, be sufficiently demonstrated from the annexed diagram. A B represents a screw covered over ; C D E one helix or revolution of it ; CD the side that is to ascend ; E D the descending side ; the point D the middle ; the horizontal line C F showing how much of the helix is filled with water, viz., of the ascending side, from C, the beginning of the helix, to D, the middle of it ; and, on the descending side, from D, the middle, to the point G, where the hori- zontal line cuts the helix. Now it is evident that this latter part D G is nothing near so large, nor, consequently, so 176 PERPETxruM mobile; heavy as the other (ascending) part D C. And thus it must be in all the other revolutions which, as they are either more in number or larger in diameter, so much must the difficulty increase : from whence it appears that the outward stream must be of force sufficient to overcome the difference of weight in the ascending side of the screw, which can scarcely be effected by any contrivance of this sort ; for though the water-wheel might be made larger, yet the velocity of the motion which it could communicate to the screw would be inversely diminished. Most of the arguments I here make use of are to be found in a book of Dr. Wilkins', wherein he also mentions a con- trivance to multiply the same stream so as to apply it several times to the same screw ;* but even with this addition it is impossible. I send this letter with no other view than to prevent any persons making an experiment which must be attended with a disappointment so expensive ; nor, indeed, could any one speak with another view against an artist who seems so in- genious and so modest. Your Magazine, Mr. Urban, bring- ing forth to public view these efforts of invention, must be an incentive to enquiries of this nature, which may be of the greatest service to society. I cannot, therefore, better con- clude this letter than with the words of the author I above mentioned : — " However, the enquiry after it (the perpetual motion) cannot but deserve our endeavours, as being one of the most noble amongst all these mechanic subtelties. And, as in the fable of him who dug the vineyard for a hidden treasure, though he did not find the money, yet he thereby made the ground more fruitful ; so, though we do not attain to the effecting this particular, yet our searching after it may discover so many excellent inventions as shall abundantly recompence the labour of the enquiry." I am, Sir, &c., J. S.f • See Chapter I. t Vol. 33, 1763, p. 554. OR, SEARCH FOR SELf-MOTlVE POWER. 177 VII. — ^Alleged discovery by William Ashman. Horsley, Gloucestershire, Nov. 12, 1800. Mr. Urban, — ^I beg you to announce that Mr. William Ashman, hatter, of this place, has this day been with me anl asserted that he has discovered the perpetual motion, t.e., that he has invented, and actually possesses, a self-moving machine, which, when once set going, will continue so till worn out. He also says it is applicable to the greatest objects and most useful purposes. 1 have thought it my duty to communicate his assertion to Sir Joseph Banks. T. D. FOSBROOKE.* VIII. — Perpetual Motion by Galvanic agency. The perpetual motion, so long sought for in vain, is now sought through the medium of galvanism. A French physi- cian has in his cabinet two galvanic piles, 16 inches high, which alternately attract a pretty heavy beam. The con- tinual oscillation of the beam gives motion to a pendulum, which has never stopped for the last three years. The physician is now endeavouring to give to this movement an isochronism which may render it more useful. f IX. — ^An ancient attempt at Perpetual Motion. Mr. Urban, — In the curious preface of the learned Dr. Dee, prefixed to his Euclid, is the following remarkable passage in the article " Trochilike." If any of your ingenious correspondents can furnish an explanation of so odd a piece of mechanism, it will afford much satisfaction to A Constant Reader. *' By wheels, strange works and incredible are done, as will hereafter appear. A wonderful example of further possibility and present commodity was seen in my time, in a certain instrument, which by the inventor and artificer (before) was sold for twenty talents of gold, and then had (by • Vol. 70, part 2, 1800, p. 1128. t The "Abstract of -Foreign Occurrences," in the •* Gentleman's Magazine," vol. 87, part 2, 1817, p. 170. The same in vol. 88, part 1, p. 63. 178 PERPETUITM mobile; misfortune) received some injury and hurt. And one Janellus of Cremona did mend the same, and presented it unto the Emperor Charles the Fift. Hieronymus Cardanus can be my witnesse, that therein was one wheel which moved, and that in such rate, that, in 7000 years, only his own period should be finished. A thing almost incredible : but how farre I keep me within my bounds, very many men (yet alive) can tel." Quere, Does not the doctor intimate this machine to be very ancient by the mode of fixing the price ? Talents have not, I believe, been used in reckoning by any moderns. I desire likewise to be informed whether he refers to the verbal or written testimony of Cardan ? If the latter, in what part of his works is an account of the same wonderful automaton to be found ?* X. — ^Dr. Kenrick and J. D. Muller make application for Patents. Dr. Kenrickf and Mr. John Dietrick Muller waited on the Attorney-General : the first with reference from the Court of Chancery on a petition for a patent for the exclusive benefit of a discovery of a mechanical principle, of self-motion, for the construction of machines which acquire a constant supply of power from the action of gravity on themselves only ; the latter, on a like reference, for the invention of a machine or engine constructed on self-moving principles. The Attorney- General, on hearing the merits, was pleased to make his report in favour of both parties. J XI. — ^A Magnetic Scheme suggested. Mr. Ukban, — How frequently do we find ourselves in the situation of the author in the farce of the " Critic," who having been discovered in a plagiarism, is driven to his shifts * Vol. 47, 1777, p. 441. f Probably the invention alluded to, but not described, in his lecture (Chapter III.) ; and elsewhere called ** The Rotator." J The ** Historical Chronicle," in the " Gentleman's Magazine," Tol. 49, 1779, p. 269, OE, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTITE POWEB. 179 for an excuse, and at length observes, " that all he has to say- about it is, that Shakspeare and he had the same ideas, but that Shakspeare used them first" (or words to that effect). In some such light does a rude idea of mine stand just now. About two years ago, or not quite so long, I mentioned to a philosophical friend, who had frequently turned his attention towards the construction of a machine that would afford the long sought for desideration of perpetual motion, my opinion as to what I conceived must be selected as the first principle of any such action. I considered that whatever the power may be which shall keep up an action of that kind, would be found only in nature; and that, however art may assist towards the attainment of the end, it would, nevertheless, be found to be but secondary. I told him the power which I conceived was the one required; and he (on my writing to ask if he remembered the conversation) replies, that he per- fectly recollects it ; and that the magnet was that to which I alluded. Now, Mr. Urban, I am very far indeed from wishing to claim anything like discovery ; but I can only say, that the gentleman in whose behalf the interest of Parliament is about to be sought, " has had the same idea (so far as the magnet is concerned) with me, but has used it first." Mine being, however, but a theory, as I never have attempted to construct the machine I had in my mind, I should justly merit both scorn and ridicule, could I have for a moment the effrontery of putting my hypothesis in competition with the tried apparatus of the gentleman in question. Nevertheless, 1 may venture to give them on paper, as they may, perhaps, assist in a small degree towards exciting the attention of more philosophical men than myself. I am well aware of the mechanical difiiculties that will present themselves, but still do think they may be overcome. The power of the magnet we know to be both attractive and repellent ; and as this power exists independent of human agency, I have always looked upon it as the most likely to supply the wants we are anxious to remove. I therefore suppose that a wheel, simple in its construction and like to a water-wheel, might be made to move on a diamond or agate pivot, having its weather boards (I know not if that be the technical term for the parts which dip into the stream or not) armed with iron; the magnet then to be applied nearly vertical and wheel put in motion, when it appeared to me that the attractive power o 180 PEKPETUUM mobile; acting on the extremities of the wheel, on one side of each of the boards and in an opposite power to the other, would continue to propel the wheel with a rotatory motion : the first impetus of course must be given by hand. Rude and untried as my plan is, I cannot but think it practicable, and trust that you will oblige me by giving it a place in yo\ir publication, as through such a channel of scientific informa- tion it may, perhaps, assist some to form new ideas, or to induce others to correct the erroneous one (if it be such) of Yours, &c., Alphabeticus.* XII. — Spence's Motion by Magnetism. John Spence, an ingenious individual, residing at Lin- lithgow, in Scotland, has applied the magnetic power to the production of a perpetual motion. This person was in early life apprenticed to a shoemaker, but the natural bent of his genius ^or mechanics overcame every obstacle ; he got to be keeper of a steam-engine in a spinning factory at Glasgow, and after two years' study in this school, retired to his native place to pursue the shoemaking for bread ; and wheels, levers, &c., for the gratification of his own taste. The perpetual motion was an object worthy of such a devotee, and we find that he has invented a piece of mechanism which is doubly curious, from its own powers, and from the extraordinary diffi- culties in whose despite it has been accomplished. It is not easy to convey an idea of it without plates. A wooden beam, poised by the centre, has a piece of steel attached to one end of it, which is alternately drawn up by a piece of magnet placed above it, and down by another placed below it : as the end of the beam approaches the magnet, either above or below, the machine interjects a non-conducting substance, which suspends the attraction of the magnet approached, and allows the other to exert its powers. Thus the end of the beam continually ascends and descends betwixt the two magnets, without ever coming into contact with either ; the attractive power of each being suspended precisely at the moment of nearest approach. And as the magnetic attrac- tion is a permanently operating power, there appears to be no • Vol. 88, part 1, 1818, p. 391. OB, SEARCH FOR SEIiF-MOTIVB POWER. 181 limit to the continuance of the motion, but the endurance of the materials of the machine. The first machine made by Mr. Spence is very rude, and fashioned by his own hands, but he intends applying the principle to the motion of a time-piece. We trust this ingenious man will meet the encouragement he deserves — if not as the reward of his talents and perseverance, at least for the benefit of the com- munity, for it is from such sources that great national improvements are often derived.* XIII. — ^A Wheel moved by Magnetic influence. The piece of mechanism consists of only one small hori- zontal wheel, not exceeding 3-4ths of an inch in diameter, through the centre of which, on the plane of the wheel, passes a small magnetic bar, projecting about 3-4ths of an inch beyond the circumference of the wheel on the one side, and about 3-8ths of an inch on the other side. These projections are called the north and south poles. The axis of the wheel is of course perpendicular. Its operative power is magnetism ; its motion (probably owing to the friction inseparable from the long-continued action of the axis in its sockets) is somewhat irregular ; but on the whole it is a curiosity highly deserving attention. Owing to a sudden shock, its motion was stopped entirely the other day, but we have learned that it has been restored. About two years ago it was stopped by some unknown cause, but after a short pause recovered its motion of itself, without any additional impulse, and con- tinued its revolutions without intermission. In a room at Mr. Swan's, in Coppergate, which was excessively warm, and crowded with company, its action ceased altogether, after first becoming irregular and sickly. Query. — Might not this simple fact lead to some important issue on the question of the variation of the compass ? This we only know, that the magnetic influence was deadened by excessive heat, and resuscitated by more moderate atmosphere. — Yorkshire Gazette,] • Vol. 88, part 2, 1818, p. 156. t Vol. 91 (July to December, 1821), part 2, p. 628. 182 PERPETUXJM MOBILE ; In the " Annual Register," for 1774, is a " Description of the curious Time-piece in Mr. Cox*s Museum :" — Among other great works now introduced at Mr. Cox's Museum is an immense barometer, of so extraordinary a con- struction that by it the long sought for, and in all likelihood the only perpetual motion that ever will be discovered is obtained. The constant revolution of the wheels moving in vertical, horizontal, and other directions, is not only physi- cally produced, but the indication of time from an union of the philosophic with the mechanic principles is effected. Upon the dial, besides a minute and an hour hand, is another hand dividing the minute into 60 equal parts. These hands are motionless till affixed to the primary motion, so that the motion of the time-piece (as Mr. Cox in his descriptive inventory judiciously expresses it) is originated, continued, and perfected, by the philosophic principle through which it is (solely) actuated. The encouragement Mr. Cox has, for many years, given to men of genius, and the perseverance with which he has pursued the great line of utility, have not only given birth to productions that have astonished all Europe, as well as the eastern world, but have at last produced the wonderful machine above described. Several of the most eminent philosophers and mathematicians in this kingdom, who have examined it attentively, are of opinion that it will lead to farther improvements both in philosophy and mechanics ; and we hear that Mr. Cox intends to devote a part of every week to the gratification of such gentlemen in the scientific world as wish to be acquainted either with the construction or the mode of operation, the principles of action or the masterly execution of so capital a performance. This article is, we are informed, one of the prizes, and the work of many years, during which time numberless ineffectual and expen- sive trials were made, which perhaps would have damped any ardour but Mr. Cox's, and probably prevented the world from ever being benefited by so valuable a discovery. " I have seen and examined (says Mr. James Ferguson, in a letter dated Bolt-court, Fleet-street, Jan. 28) the above-de- scribed clock, which is kept constantly going, by the rising and falling of the quicksilver in a most extraordinary barometer ; and there is no danger of its ever failing to go ; OK, SEABCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 183 for there is always such a quantity of moving power accumu- lated as would keep the clock going for a year, even if the barometer should be taken quite away from it. And, indeed, on examining the whole contrivance and construction, I must with truth say that it is the most ingenious piece of mechanism I ever saw in my life." For a further account of this extraordinary machine, see Mr. Cox's descriptive inventory of his museum.* Alleged discovery in France, by M. Dodemant : — A machine, capable of being set in motion, and pro- ducing a powerful effect, without either the intervention of any combustible, the action of any current of water or of air, or the exertion of animal strength, but possessing within itself the inexhaustible principle of motion, would doubtless prove of great utility to mankind. Such is that of which M. Dodemant, professor of mathematics at Lyons, announces himself the inventor. At his request, the prefect has directed two persons — M. Carron, chief engineer of the department, and M. MoUer, professor of natural philosophy — to examine this machine.f The following, referring to Geiser's imposition and Zam- boni's Column, is extracted from an article headed "The most important inventions and discoveries of our times," which in a note we are informed is " from the German of M. Poppe, of Tubingen :" — Many able mechanicians have been endeavouring to discover a perpetutmi mobile ; but many, who thought themselves on the point of succeeding, found their hopes deceived, and the phantom they had pursued eluded their grasp. The clock of M. Geiser, an admirable piece of mechanism, seemed to have solved this great problem in an ingenious and simple manner; but it deceived only for a time, not only the author of this essay, but many of the most excellent mathematicians ; for in this clock springs were concealed in the most artful manner, which were wound up at certain times, to aid the apparent power, which was not able alone to keep the machine in ♦ The Annual Register, vol. 17, 1774, p. 248. t The Monthly Magazine, vol. 22, part 2, 1806, p. 67. 184 PERPETUUM mobile; motion. Above a year ago, the author of this article dis- covered this trick, with several other lovers of the arts, who had joined with him to examine the machine ; and he soon after made his discovery public. The column of Zamboni, and the clock connected with it, by that artist, at Verona, which have now gone, without interruption, for above four years, as well as that of Ramis, at Munich (called the electric pendulum clock), are therefore, perhaps, the hest perpetuum mobile that we yet have. By this name we of course understand a machine which is able con- stantly to renew the cause of its motion by its own mechanism, and whose moving principle preserves its action without interruption, and without any new impulse, till it is stopped either by the wear of the machine or by violence. The invention of a machine possessed of this property is indeed very difficult, but not impossible, as Kastner Langsdorff and other mathematicians have demonstrated.* An imposition exposed in a letter from Mr. Thomas Gill, Chairman of the Committee of Mechanics in the Society for the Encouragement of Arts, &c. &c., of London, to Prof. Thomson, on a pretended Patent Self-moving Engine : — No. 125, Strand, London, Oct. 4, 1820. Sib, — My attention has lately been directed to a gross imposition upon the public in a pretended self-moving engine, which is now exhibiting in this metropolis, and which I think it highly proper to expose, and thereby, as far as lies in my power, prevent the delusion from being continued. It is announced in the following handbill : — " The newly-discovered patent self-existing engine for propelling ships at sea, carriages on the road, and all kinds of machinery, without the aid of horse, steam, water, or other power now in use. To be seen at work every day, Sundays excepted, from ten in the morning till six at night, at 32, Burlington Arcade, Piccadilly, Admittance, Two Shillings. " N.B. — Gentlemen intending to have their machinery driven by the above power are desired to apply as above. If by letter, post-paid, * The New Moiv.hly Magazine, vol. 12, part 2 (July to December, 1819), p. 162. OR, SEABCH FOR SELF-MOTITE POWER. 185 1 found the machine to consist of a light brass wheel, about two feet in diameter, turning upon an horizontal axis, which is supported at each end in square blocks upon the tops of two brass columns, which are affixed to a mahogany table mounted upon a thick pillar of the same wood, with feet and rolling castors, so that it may be moved about, and thereby show that it has no communication through the floor of the room it is exhibited in. The thickness of the table is about an inch and a half, and the pillar is about 6 inches in diameter. Around the periphery of the wheel are fixed at equal distances, by screws, a number of small cylindrical rods or bars of metal, which are placed parallel to the axis of the wheel ; and at one end of the frame surrounding the wheel (and which frame is besides supported on two other brass columns) is a brass pillar, which has an arm or bracket, on which is fixed, near the periphery of the wheel, a ball, which the inventor pretends is formed of a new combination of metals, the composition of which, he says, possesses a new species of attraction, which is not magnetism, for the metal bars on the periphery of the wheel so as to draw each of them in succession continually towards it ; but as this attraction takes place equally above and below the ball, he says that he cuts it off below by means of a plate of a different composition of metals, which is placed beneath the ball, and thus he pretends that the wheel is continually turned round by this new attempt at reviving the long since exploded doctrine of attraction and repulsion, and with considerable force, and says that he has in the country a machine of two horses' power. On being asked if he had any pieces of the compound metals with him besides those on the machine, he said he had not, and would not suffer any person to possess them, lest they should take them to pieces, and thereby discover their composition. On being questioned as to his patfent, he said that in fact he had none, having merely entered a caveat to prevent any persons from taking out a patent for a similar machine without his being informed thereof. So much, then, for his pretended patent; and I verily believe that his new-invented power rests on no better a foundation, and that, in fact, his wheel is turned by spring mounted on a barrel, as usual in spring clocks and other pieces of mechanism, and which is concealed either in the substance of the table itself or in the thic 186 PEEPETXJUM mobile; pillar which supports it, the barrel having a ring of teeth around it, working in a pinion affixed upon the lower end of an upright axis concealed in one of the brass columns that support the horizontal axis of the wheel, and having at its upper end another pinion which works into a small toothed contrate wheel fixed on the end of the horizontal axis, but also concealed in the brass block on the top of the column, and in another pillar which is screwed upon the top of the* block, and is quite large enough to contain it, and thus gives motion to the wheel ; and, indeed, the artifice is but very clumsily concealed. I should have added that the brass pillar last mentioned supports an upright axis having a pinion at its lower end, which is driven by a contrate wheel on the horizontal axis of the wheel, and which upright axis has at the top of it a fly with wings to regulate the motion of the machine, as in other spring movements. This barefaced imposition reminds me of another which was practised upon the public several years since, and was detected, and very properly exposed, by my friend Mr. J. T. Hawkins, which put an end to the trick : this consisted of what was said to be a self-moving pendulum, and beneath the bottle of it a ball was placed, out of which, as the exhibitor pretended, an elastic fluid was continually proceed- ing, which gave an impulse to the ball as it passed over it. Mr. Hawkins, however, foimd that the impulse was, in fact, given to the pendulum at its upper end ; and that the axis on which it hung communicated with another pendulum which was kept in motion by a weight or other maintaining power ; for in like manner the real cause of the wheel's motion in this new imposition is concealed, and the attention of the spectator is directed to another pretended first mover, and which is besides attended with the additional advantage of afibrding him matter for wonder, which constitutes the chief pleasure of the multitude, and contributes greatly to the profit of the exhibition. I am, Sir, your most obedient servant, Thomas Gill.* • Annals of Philosophy. By Thomas Thomson, M.D. 8vo. Vol. 16, 1820, p. 373. Mr. G., Editor of the Technical Repository, referred to in Chapter VI II. of the present work. OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 187 In the notice given of " Lectures delivered in the Theatre of the Royal Institution," the following occurs, in mentioning " Dr. Young* s Lectures on Mechanics :" — The doctrines of rotatory power and preponderance were considered after those of equilibrium ; the apparatus intended for illustrating the effects of rotatory power was not com- pleted ; but an experiment was made, in a subsequent lecture, in confirmation of the propositions respecting the most advantageous disposition of power in machines. Six equal weights were attached to as many threads, and each pair of threads was passed in opposite directions round the different portions of three pullies. The first pulley was so formed that its larger portion was to its smaller as 3 to 2; the second was in the ratio of 6 to 2, and the third as 4 to 1 ; and the three weights, of which the threads were coiled round the smaller part of each pulley, being suffered to rise at the same instant, the middle weight rose evidently much faster than either of the others. Dr. Young, however, remarked that the greatest velocity would not in all cases be practically desirable, on account of the injury that the machinery would sustain from the shock in stopping it. A model of a wheel with moveable weights, for producing perpetual motion, was employed for showing the fallacy of all projects of this kind, and it was observed that a general demonstration of its insufficiency might be deduced from the properties of the centre of gravity.* In " (Euvres Philosophiques " of M. 's Gravesande, we find his letter to Sir Isaac Newton, already given (Chapter II.), and the following — Remarks touching Perpetual Motion, About eight months ago, by order of His Serene High- ness the Landgrave of Hesse, I was called upon to examine the effects of a machine at Cassel, which the inventor (Orffyreus) professed to be a perpetual motion. He care- fully hid its interior, requiring a certain sum when the ♦ Journals of the Royal Institution of Great Britain, vol. 1, 8vo., 1802, p. 105. 188 PERFETUUM MOBILE*, machine should have been first fully examined and recognised by mathematicians to be, what in mechanics is called a perpetual motion. I was so forcibly struck by what I saw and what 1 heard of it, as to be unable to call it in question. I was obliged to look on the machine as one of the most beautiful inventions in mechanics that I had ever known, and had only to consider the truth of the effects before me. I wrote to Mr. Newton all I had observed about it, which having been printed, fault has been found with what I advance, saying : — " that I do not believe perpetual motion to be a contradiction ;" — " that the demonstrations given on its impossibility do not appear to me as applicable to all machines ;" — and, lastly, " that I find it probable that the machine at Cassel may be a perpetual motion." All the difficulty turns on the first of these remarks ; if that were proved, the remaining ones would not embarrass me much ; and has, no doubt, been found too bold to venture on without proof. In this I quite agree, and I should not have committed the fault had my letter been written for the public. I was so little inclined to advance a proposition without proof, that I have never yet declared what I thought on perpetual motion, foreseeing the judgment that all mathema- ticians must pass on any one who should turn aside from the generally received opinions. What I considered I owed to truth, after having seen the machine at Cassel, induced me to give Mr. Newton my opinion on it, and at the same time to say what I thought of the proofs of the impossibility of perpetual motion. I must now justify myself before the public. We must, however, first establish the state of the question. As no foreign agent must be employed, it will be seen that a clock, in whatever way woimd up, would not be perpetual motion. It may be what mathematicians have taught under the term of collision, on the power of which they are divided in opinion. All agree that the force of collision is pro- portionate to the mass. We must admit the possibility of perpetual motion in all machines which would have the principle of their movement in the collision of bodies. The impossibility of perpetual motion has not been shown in all possible cases, affected by collision. And the laws of nature are not yet well enough known to allow our drawing a conclusion that perpetual motion is contrary to these laws. OR, SEARCH FOR SELF-MOTIVE POWER. 189 As it is possible for a body to rise quicker than it descends, on this I found my proof of the possibility of perpetual motion. Conceive a body falling from one foot high, losing all its movement by the shock ; suppose it to fall four times simi- larly, it would have fallen from the height of four feet, and the four shocks would be equal to the force that the gravity com- mimicated to the body during the four moments of its fall. But it is known that the body could mount in two of these moments to the height of four feet ; consequently, the force of two of these four shocks suffices to make it rise, and the two other shocks may be employed to move a machine : so the movement wbuld be continued perpetually by the falls reite- rated of the same body, which at each revolution would gain the force of two shocks. The gain of the force would be greater at each revolution, if the number of shocks were increased in the descent. Thus, there is in nature an augmentation of strength, which is sufficient to support the opinion that perpetual motion is not a contradiction — ^nay, that it is even possible. This possibility will appear still clearer, if attention is paid, to the property of springs, that they reboimd with the same force that boimd them. This matter was disputed between MM. Leibnitz and Papin, in the " Actes de Leipsic," respecting whether the force of a body was proportionate to its speed ; if admitted, Leibnitz considered perpetual motion would be the consequence ; Papin admitted the validity of the consequence, but doubted the proposition. The only means of replying to the arguments brought forward on the possibility of perpetual motion, is to deny with M. Leibnitz the principle on which they are founded. I should not be able to persuade myself that it is a con- tradiction to construct a machine which would have in itself the principle of the augmentation of power, in consequence of the laws of nature. These laws are so little known to us, and there is little appearance that they will ever be discovered sufficiently for us to arrive at such a conclusion. To me it seems, that these laws, on the contrary, ought to make us look upon such a machine as very possible, although it may never be accomplished by human art. The question of the possibility or impossibility of perpetual motion, then, seems to me of little consequence ; but it is 190 PERPETUUM mobile; desirable that the strong persuasion that mathematicians have regarding its impossibility should not prevent their paying serious attention to such a machine as the astonishing wheel of Cassel ; a wheel having the principle of movement in- ternal, and which is moved by the slightest effort, turning either way without any necessity to reverse the moving power ; lastly, after making some millions of surprisingly rapid turns, continues its motion until stopped by a strong effort of the arm. It' appears to me that such a machine merits some praise, even should it not satisfy all its inventor's representa- tions. If it is perpetual motion, he deserves the recompense he asks ; and if not, the public may here discover a beautiful invention.* [For full details, see Appendix F.] The resolution of the Royal Academy of Sciences in Paris not to entertain communications relating to Perpetual Motion, was passed in 1775. They say : — This year the Academy has passed the resolution not to examine any solution of problems on the following sub- jects : — The duplication of the cube, the trisection of the angle, the quadrature of the circle, or any machine announced as showing perpetual motion. We believe ourselves bound to account for the motives which have led to this determination. ***** The construction of a perpetual motion is absolutely impossible. If even friction and resistance from the middle did not eventually destroy the effect of the first motive power, that power cannot produce an effect equal to its cause ; if, then, it is desired that the effect of a complete power should act continually, the effect must be infinitely small in a given time. If the friction and resistance be subtracted, the first motion given to a body will always continue ; but it will not act in regard to other bodies, and the only perpetual motion possible in this hypothesis • (Euvres Philosophiques et Mathematiques de Mr. G. J, *s Gravesande. AiViSlerdam, 1774. 2 vols., 4to. (Vol 1, p. 305.) OR, SEABCH FOB SBLF-MOTITE POWEB. 191 (which could not exist in nature) would he ahsolutely useless in carrying out the ohject proposed by the constructors of these perpetual motion machines. The drawback to these Iresearches is their being exceedingly expensive, and has ruined more than one family ; often mechanics, who could have rendered great services to the public, have wasted their means, time, and genius. Such are the principal motives that have dictated tie determination of the Academy. In stating that they will not occupy themselves any longer with these subjects, they only declare their opinion of the complete uselessness of the labour of those who so occupy themselves. It has often been said, that in seeking to solve chimerical problems, many useful truths have been found; an opinion which originated in a time when the proper method of discovering the truth was unknown, which in the present day is well known. It is more than probable that the right manner of discovering these truths is to search for them. But the quadrature of the circle is the only rejected problem of the Academy which could give rise to any useful research ; and, if a geometrician should find it out, the determination of the Academy would only enhance his merit, as it would show the opinion that geometricians have of the difficulty, not to say insolubility, of the problem.* * Histoire de l*Acad^mie Koyale des Sciences, 1775. Paris, 1778. 4to* Pp. 61-66. 192 PERPETUUM mobile; CHAPTER VII. DEFINITIONS AND DE8CBIPTI0NS OF PERPETUAL MOTION, FROM ENCYCLOP-EDIAB AND DICTIONARIES. Great similarity in style and matter will be observed in each of these articles, and the paucity of information they generally afford is evidence how little has hitherto been known respecting what had been done and written on the subject. All speak in the most vague and general terms of the amount of attention devoted to its pursuit, — all claim to demonstrate its impossi- bility, either on the authority of M. de la Hire, or on one or two examples. Well has M. 's Gravesande observed on the in- sufficiency of arguments against the possibility of a perpetual motion to meet all known, much less all possible, cases. A false argument, or a weak one, is worse than useless, for the opinionated are only thereby confirmed in erroneous theories. l.-^In the edition of Rees' Cyclopaedia for 1819, we read : — Perpetual Motion, in mechanics, a motion which is sup- plied and renewed from itself without any external cause ; or it is an iminterrupted communication of the same degree of motion from one part of matter to another, in a circle or other curve returning into itself, so that the same momentum still returns imdiminished upon the first mover. This celebrated problem of a perpetual motion consists in the inventing of a machine which has the principle of its motion within itself. M. de la Hire has demonstrated the impossibility of any such machine, and finds that it amounts to this, viz., to find a body which is both heavier and lighter at the same time ; or to find a body which is heavier than itself. To find a perpetual motion, or to construct aii engine, &c., which shall have such a motion, is a famous problem that has OE, SEARCH FOB SELF-MOTIVE POWEB. 193 employed the mathematicians of two thousand years ; though none, perhaps, have prosecuted it with attention and earnest- ness equal to those of the present age. Infinite are the schemes, designs, plans, engines, wheels, &c., to which this longed-for perpetual motion has given birth : it were as endless as impertinent to give a detail of them all. In effect, there seems but little in nature to countenance all this assiduity and expectation: among all the laws of matter and motion, we know of none yet which seems to furnish any principle or foundation for such an effect. Action and re-action are allowed to be ever equal, and a body which gives any quantity of motion to another always loses just so much of its own ; but, under the present state of things, the resistance of the air, the friction of the parts of machines, &c., do necessarily retard every motion. To keep the motion constant, therefore, either : First, there must be a supply from some foreign cause, which in a perpetual motion is excluded ; Or, secondly, all resistance from the friction of the parts of matter must be removed, which necessarily implies a change in the nature of things.* For, by the second law of nature, the changes made in the motions of bodies are always proportional to the impressed moving force, and are produced in the same direction with it ; no motion, then, can be communicated to any engine, greater than that of the first force impressed. But, on our earth, all motion is performed in a resisting medium, and must, therefore, of necessity be retarded ; con- sequently, a considerable quantity of its motion will be spent on the medium. Nor is there any engine or machine in which all friction can be avoided ; there being in nature no such thing as exact smoothness or perfect congruity, — the manner of the cohesion of the parts of bodies, the small proportion the solid matter bears to the vacmties between them, and the nature of those constituent particles, not admitting it. This friction, therefore, will also in time sensibly diminish the impressed or communicated force ; so that a perpetual motion * So far, this is a mere repetition from Diderot and D'Alembert's French Encyclopaedia, 1765, folio. 194 PEBPETuiTM mobile; can never follow, unless the communicated force be so much greater than the generating force as to recompense the diminution made therein by all these causes: but nil dat quod non hahet ; and the generating force cannot communi- cate a greater degree of motion than it hath itself. Or, thirdly and lastly, there must be some method of gaining a force equivalent to what is lost, by the artful dis- position and combination of mechanic powers ; to which last point, then, all endeavours are to be directed : but how, or by what means, such force should be gained, is still a mystery. The multiplication of powers or forces, it is certain, avails nought ; for what is gained in power is still lost in time, so that the quantity of motion still remains the same. This is an inviolable law of nature, by which nothing is left to art, but the choice of the several combinations that may produce the same effect. Although it is allowed that, by the resolutions of force, there is a gain or increase of the absolute quantity of force, as the two forces in the sides of the parallelogram taken together exceed the force in the diagonal which is resolved into them, yet you cannot proceed resolving motion in infinitum by any machine whatsoever; but those you have resolved must be again compounded, in order to make a continual movement, and the gain obtained by the resolution will be lost again by the composition. In like manner, if you sup- pose two bodies to be perfectly elastic, and that the lesser body strikes the other at rest, there will be an increase of the absolute quantity of force, because the striking body will be reflected ; but if you suppose them both to turn roimd any centre, after the stroke, so as to meet again, this increase of force will be lost, and their motion will be reduced to its first quantity. Such a gain, therefore, of force, as must be after- wards lost in the actions of the bodies, can never produce a perpetual movement. There are various ways, besides these, by which absolute force may be gained ; but since there is always an equal gain in opposite directions, and no increase obtained in the same direction, in the circle of actions neces- sary to make a perpetual movement this gain must be presently lost, and not serve for the necessary expense of force employed in overcoming friction and the resistance of the medium. We may observe, therefore, that, though it could be shewn that in an infinite nimiber of bodies, or in an OR, SEARCH FOB SEXF-MOTIYB POWEB. 195 infinite machine, there could be a gain of force for ever, and a motion continued to infinity, it does not follow that a per- petual movement can be made. That which was proposed by M. Leibnitz, in August, 1690, in the " Leipsic Acts," as a consequence of the common estimation of the forces of bodies in motion, is of this kind, and, for this and other reasons, ought to be rejected. The possibility of a perpetual motion has been urged from the following specious argument : — ^Let the height A B be (Fig. 11, pi. 34.) ^^^^ A ^Ap , ■