- vl 4 by Sig CA tis Paige s y nt ee OY Se ae D w ‘= J — 7a a =, = a a rf Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2025 with funding from | Princeton Theological Seminary Library https://archive.org/details/questforcertaintOOdewe THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY: A STUDY OF THE RELATION OF KNOWLEDGE AND ACTION manners BY JOHN DEWEY NEW YORK:MINTON, BALCH YW COMPANY way i029 COPYRIGHT, 1929 by JOHN DEWEY Printed tn the United States of America by J. J. LITTLE AND IVES COMPANY. NEW YORK CONTENTS CHAPTER I ESCAPE FROM PERIL II PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR THE IMMU- TABLE III CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES eg TLL OD IV THE ART OF ACCEPTANCE AND THE ART OF CONTROL V IDEAS AT WORK VI THE PLAY OF IDEAS aceon VII THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY VIII THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE IX THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD ~~ THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD XI THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION PAGE aN ana lp yy ) nye uy mtd AY: hy uly ey ThE QUEST POR CERTAINTY THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY COR ARP Dis Rook BReCAPE uP RO MiP RRL MAN wuo Lives in a world of hazards is compelled to seek for security. He has sought to attain it in two ways. One of them began with an attempt to propitiate the powers which environ him and determine his destiny. It expressed itself in supplication, sacrifice, ceremonial rite and magical cult. In time these crude methods were largely displaced. The sacrifice of a contrité heart was esteemed more pleasing than that of bulls and oxen; the inner attitude of reverence and devotion more desirable than external ceremonies. If man could not conquer destiny he could willingly ally himself with it; putting his will, even in sore affliction, on the side of the powers which dispense fortune, he could escape defeat and might triumph in the midst of destruction. The other course is to invent arts and by their_means turn the powers of nature to account, man constructs a fortress out of the very conditions and forces which threaten him. He builds shelters, weaves garments, makes flame his friend instead of his enemy, and grows into the complicated arts of associated living. This i ethod of changing the world through action, as the other is the method of chanpi € self in emo- ° tion and idea. It is a commentary on the slight control man has obtained over himself by means of control over nature, that the method of action has been felt to manifest dangerous pride, even defiance of the powers which be. People of old wavered between thinking arts to be the gift of the gods and to be an invasion of their prerogatives. Both versions testify to the sense 3 an THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of something extraordinary in the arts, something either super- human or unnatural. The souls who have predicted that by means of the arts man might establish a kingdom of order, justice and beauty through mastery of nature’s energies and laws have been few and little heeded. Men have been glad enough to enjoy the fruits of such arts as they possess, and in recent centuries have increasingly de- voted themselves to their multiplication. But this effort has . been conjoined with a profound distrust of the.arts as a method of dealing with the serious perils of life. Doubt as to the truth of this statement will be dispelled if one considers the dis- esteem in which the idea of practice has been held. Philosophers have celebrated the method of change in personal ideas, and religious teachers that of change in the affections of the heart. These conversions have been prized on their own account, and only incidentally because of a change in action which would © ensue. The latter has been esteemed as an evidence of the change in thought and sentiment, not as a method of trans- forming the scene of life. The places in which the use of the arts has effected actual objective transformation have been regarded as inferior, if not base, and the activities connected with them as menial. The disparagement_attending the idea of the material has seized upon them. The honorable quality asso- ciated with the idea of the “spiritual” has been reserved for change in inner attitudes. The depreciation of action, of doing and making, has been cultivated by philosophers. But while philosophers have per- petuated the derogation by formulating and justifying it, they did not originate it. They glorified their own office without doubt in placing theory so much above practice. But indepen- dently of their attitude, many things conspired to the same effect. Work has been onerous, toilsome, associated with a primeval curse. It has been done under compulsion and the 4 a ESCAPE FROM PERIL pressure of necessity, while intellectual activity is associated with leisure. On account of the unpleasantness of practical activity, as much of it as possible has been put upon slaves and serfs. Thus the social dishonor in which this class was held was extended to the work they do. There is also the age-long association of knowing and thinking with immaterial and spiritual principles, and of the arts, of all practical activity in doing and making, with matter. For work is done with the body, by means of mechanical appliances and is directed upon material things. The disrepute which has attended the thought of material things in comparison with immaterial thought has been transferred to everything associated with practice. One might continue in this strain. The natural history of 44 conceptions about work and the arts if it were traced through a succession of peoples and cultures would be instructive. But all that is needed for our purpose is to raise the question: Why rad Lye this invidious discrimination? A very little reflection shows that the suggestions which have been offered by way of explanation themselves need to be explained. Ideas derived from social castes and emotional revulsions are hardly reasons to be offered in justification of a belief, although they may have a bearing on its causation. Contempt for matter and bodies and glorifica- tion of the immaterial are affairs which are not self-explana- tory. And, as we shall be at some pains to show later in the discussion, the idea which connects thinking and knowing with some principle or force that is wholly separate from connection with physical things will not stand examination, especially since the whole-hearted adoption of experimental method in the natural sciences. The questions suggested have far-reaching issues. What is the cause and the import of the sharp-diviston-between_theory and ] practice? Why should the latter be disesteemed along with matter and the body? What has been the effect upon the 5 cee ty IR TOI I eee ‘ Se ene = THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY various modes in which action is manifested: industry, politics, the fine arts, and upon morals conceived of as overt activity having consequences, instead of as mere inner personal atti- - tude? How has the separation of intellect from action affected the theory of knowledge? What has been in particular the effect upon the conception and course of philosophy? What forces are at work to break down the division? What would the ; effect be if the divorce were annulled, and knowing and doing were » brought into intrinsic connection with one another? What revisions of the traditional theory of mind, thought and know- ing would be required, and what change in the idea of the office of philosophy would be demanded? What modifications would ensue in the disciplines which are concerned with the various phases of human activity? These questions form the theme of this book, and indicate the nature of the problems to be discussed. In this opening chapter we shall consider especially some historic grounds for the elevation of knowledge above making and doing. This phase of the discussion will disclose that ex: disclose that exaltation of pure intellect and its activity above practical affairs is fundamentally connected with the quest for a certainty which | shall be abso- _lute and unshakeable. The distinctive characteristic of practical aoe probability. Through : activity, one which is so inherent that it cannot be eliminated, is the uncertainty which attends it. Of it we are compelled to say: Act, but act at your peril. Judgment and belief regarding actions to be performed can never attain more than a pre- however, it has seemed that men might escape from the erils of uncertainty. a ~~Practical activity deals with individualized and unique situ- ations which are never exactly duplicable and about which, accordingly, no complete assurance is possible. All activity, moreover, involves change. The intellect, however, according to the traditional doctrine, may grasp universal Being, and ESCAPE FROM PERIL Being which is universal is fixed and immutable. Wherever there is practical activity we human beings are involved as par- takers in the issue. All the fear, disesteem and lack of confi- dence which gather about the thought of ourselves, cluster also about the thought of the actions in which we are partners. Man’s distrust of himself has caused him to desire to get beyond and above himself; in pure knowledge he has thought he could attain this self-transcendence. There is no need to expatiate upon the risk which attends overt action. The burden of proverbs and wise saws is that the best laid plans of men as of mice gang agley. Fortune rather than our own intent and act determines eventual success and failure. The pathos of unfulfilled expectation, the tragedy of defeated purpose and ideals, the catastrophes of accident, are the commonplaces of all comment on the human scene. We survey conditions, make the wisest choice we can; we act, and we must trust the rest to fate, fortune or providence, Moralists tell us to look to the end when we act and then inform us that the end is always uncertain. Judging, planning, choice, no mat- ter how thoroughly conducted, and action no matter how pru- dently executed, never are the sole determinants of any out- come. Alien and indifferent natural forces, unforeseeable conditions enter in and have a decisive voice. The more impor- tant the issue, the greater is their say as to the ulterior event. Hence men have longed to find a realm in which there is an activity which is not overt and which has no external conse- | quences. “Safety first” has played a large réle in effecting a preference for knowing over doing and making. With those to whom the process of pure thinking is congenial and who have the leisure and the aptitude to pursue their preference, the happiness attending knowing iscunalloyed} it is not entangled in the risks which overt action cannot éscape. Thought has been alleged to be a purely inner activity, intrinsic to mind alone; 7 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY and according to traditional classic doctrine, “mind” is complete and self-sufficient in itself. Overt action may follow upon its operations but in an external way, a way not intrinsic to its completion. Since rational activity is complete within itself it needs no external manifestation. Failure and frustration are attributed to the accidents of an alien, intractable and inferior realm of existence. The outer lot of thought is cast in a world external to it, but one which in no way injures the supremacy and completeness of thought and knowledge in their intrinsic natures. Thus the arts by which man attains such practical security as is possible of achievement are looked down upon. The security they provide is relative, ever incomplete, at the risk of untoward circumstance. The multiplication of arts may even be bemoaned as a source of new dangers. Each of them de- mands its own measures of protection. Each one in its opera- tion brings with it new and unexpected consequences having perils for which we are not prepared. The quest for certainty is a quest for a peace which is assured, an object which is un- qualified by risk and the shadow of co which action casts. For it is not uncertainty ger Se hich men dislike, but the fact that uncertainty involves “us-ift peril of evils. Uncertainty that affected only the detail of consequences to be experienced pro- vided they had a warrant of being enjoyable would have no sting. It would bring the zest of adventure and the spice of variety. Quest for complete certainty can be fulfilled in pure knowing alone. Such-is the verdict of our most enduring philo- . sophic tradition. “While the tradition has, as we shall see later, found its way into all themes and subjects, and determines the form of cur- rent problems and conclusions regarding mind and knowledge, it may be doubted whether if we were suddenly released from the burden of tradition, we should, on the basis of present 8 ESCAPE FROM PERIL experience take the disparaging view of practice and the exalted view of knowledge apart from action which tradition dictates. For man, in spite of the new perils in which the machinery of his new arts of production and transportation have involved | him, has learned to play with sources of danger. He even seeks | them out, weary of the routine of a too sheltered life. The enormous change taking place in the position of women is itself, for example, a commentary on a change of attitude toward the value of protection as an end in itself. We have attained, at least subconsciously, a certain feeling of confidence; a feeling that control of the main conditions of fortune is to an appre- ciable degree passing into our own hands. We live surrounded with the protection of thousands of arts and we have devised schemes of insurance which mitigate and distribute the evils which accrue. Barring the fears which war leaves in its train, it is “perhaps a safe speculation that if contemporary western man were completely deprived of all the old beliefs about knowledge and actions he would assume, with a fair degree of confidence, that it lies within his power_to_achieve.a_ reasonable degree of security in life. ' This suggestion is speculative. Acceptance of it is not needed by the argument. It has its value as an indication of the earlier conditions in which a felt need for assurance was the dominant emotion. For primitive men had none of the elaborate arts of protection and use which we now enjoy and no confidence in his own powers when they were reinforced by appliances of art. He lived under conditions in which he was extraordinarily exposed to peril, and at the same time he was without the means of defense which are to-day matters of course. Most of our simplest tools and utensils did not exist; there was no accurate foresight; men faced the forces of nature in a state of nakedness which was more than physical; save under un- usually benign conditions he was beset with dangers that knew 9 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY no remission. In consequence, mystery attended experiences of good and evil; they could not be traced to their natural causes and they seemed to be the dispensations, the gifts and the inflictions, of powers beyond possibility of control. The pre- carious crises of birth, puberty, illness, death, war, famine, plague, the uncertainties of the hunt, the vicissitudes of climate and the great seasonal changes, kept imagination occupied with the uncertain. Any scene or object that was implicated in any conspicuous tragedy or triumph, in no matter how accidental a way, got a peculiar significance. It was seized upon as a ’ _-hafbinger of good or as an omen of evil. Accordingly, some “things were cherished as means of encompassing safety just as a good artisan to-day looks after his tools; others were feared and shunned because of their potencies for harm. As a drowning man is said to grasp at a straw, so men who lacked the instruments and skills developed in later days, snatched at whatever, by any stretch of imagination, could be regarded as a source of help in time of trouble. The attention, interest and care which now go to acquiring skill in the use of appliances and to the invention of means for better service of ends, were devoted to noting omens, making irrelevant prognostications, performing ritualistic ceremonies and mani- pulating objects possessed of magical power over natural events. In such an atmosphere primitive religion was born and j,, fostered. Rather this atmosphere was the religious disposition. Search for alliance with means which might promote pros- perity and which would afford defense against hostile powers was constant. While this attitude was most marked in connec- tion with the recurrent crises of life, yet the boundary line between these crucial affairs with their extraordinary risks and everyday acts was shadowy. The acts that related to common- place things and everyday occupations were usually accom- panied, for good measure of security, by ritual acts. The mak- Io ESCAPE FROM PERIL ing of a weapon, the molding of a bowl, the weaving of a mat, the sowing of seed, the reaping of a harvest, required acts different in kind to the technical skills employed. These other acts had a special es as were thought necessary in order to ensure the success 1e practical operations used. While it is difficult to avoid the use of the word supernatu- ral, we must avoid the meaning the word has for us. As long as there was no defined area of the natural, that which is over and beyond the natural can have no significance. The distinc- tion, as anthropological students have pointed out, was between ordinary and extraordinary; between the prosaic, usual run of events and the crucial incident or irruption which determined the direction which the average and expected course of events took. But the two realms-were_in_no way sharply demarcated from each other. There was a no-man’s land, a vague territory, rom €ac. in which they overlapped. At any moment the extraordinary might invade the commonplace and either wreck it or clothe it with some surprising glory. The use of ordinary things under critical conditions was fraught with inexplicable potentialities of good and evil. The two, dominant conceptions, cultural categories one might call them, which grew and flourished under such circum- stances were those of the holy and the fortunate, with their | opposites, the profane and the unlucky. As with the idea of the - supernatural, meanings are not to be assigned on the basis of present usage. Everything which was charged with some ex- traordinary potency for benefit or injury was holy; holiness meant necessity for being approached with ceremonial scruples. The holy thing, whether place, object, person or ritual appli- ance, has its sinister face; “to be handled with care” is written upon it. From it there issues the command: Noli me_tangere. Tabus, a whole set of prohibitions and injunctions, gather about it. It is capable of transmitting its mysterious potency to other If THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY things. To secure the favor of the holy is to be on the road to success, while any conspicuous success is proof of the favor of some overshadowing power—a fact which politicians of all ages have known how to utilize. Because of its surcharge of power, ambivalent in quality, the holy has to be approached not only with scruples but in an attitude of subjection. There are rites of purification, humiliation, fasting and prayer which are preconditions of securing its favor. The holy is the bearer of blessing or fortune. But a differ- ence early developed between the ideas of the holy and the lucky, because of the different dispositions in which each was to be approached. A lucky object is something to be used. It is to be manipulated rather than approached with awe. It calls for incantations, spells, divinations rather than for supplication and humiliation. Moreover, the lucky thing tends to be a concrete and tangible object, while the holy one is not usually definitely localized; it is the more potent in the degree in which its habitation and form are vague. The lucky object is subject to pressure, at a pinch to coercion, to scolding and punishment. It might be discarded if it failed to bring luck. There developed a certain element of mastery in its use, in distinction from the dependence and subjection which remained the proper attitude toward the holy. Thus there was a kind of rhythm of domination and submission, of imprecation and sup- plication, of utilization and communion. Such statements give, of course, a one-sided picture. Men at _ all times have gone about many things in a matter-of-fact way and have had their daily enjoyments. Even in the ceremonies of which we have spoken there entered the ordinary love of the dramatic as well as the desire for repetition, once routine is established. Primitive man early developed some tools and some modes of skill. With them went prosaic knowledge of the properties of ordinary things. But these beliefs were sur- I2 ESCAPE FROM PERIL rounded by others of an imaginative and emotional type, and were more or less submerged in the latter. Moreover, prestige attached to the latter. Just because some beliefs were matter- of-fact they did not have the weight and authority that belong to those about the extraordinary and unaccountable. We find the same phenomenon repeated to-day wherever religious beliefs have mark Prosaic beliefs about verifiable facts, beliefs backed up by | evidence of the senses and by useful fruits, had little glamour | and prestige compared with the vogue of objects of rite and | ceremony. Hence the things forming their subject-matter were felt to be lower in rank. Familiarity breeds a sense of equality if not of contempt. We deem ourselves on a par with things we daily administer. It is a truism to say that objects regarded with awe have perforce a superior status. Herein is the source of the fundamental dualism of human_attention and regard. The distinction between the two attitudes of everyday control and dependence on something superior was finally generalized intellectually. It took effect in the conception of two distinct realms. The inferior was that in which man could foresee and in which he had instruments and arts by which he might expect a reasonable degree of control. The superior was that of occur- * rences so uncontrollable that they testified to the presence and operation of powers beyond the scope of everyday and mun- dane things. | The philosophical tradition regarding knowledge and prac- tice, the immaterial or spiritual and the material, was not original and primitive. It had for its background the state of culture which has been sketched. It developed in a social at- mosphere in which the division of the ordinary and extraor- dinary was domesticated. Philosophy reflected upon it and gave it a rational formulation and justification, The bodies of in- formation that corresponded to the everyday arts, the store of 13 | THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY matter-of-fact knowledge, were things men knew because of what they did. They were products and promises of utilities. They shared in the relatively low esteem belonging to such things in comparison with the extraordinary and divine. Philosophy inherited the realm with which religion had been concerned. Its mode of knowing was different from that accom- panying the empirical arts, just because use it dealt with a realm of higher Being. It breathed an air purer than that in which exist the making and doing that relate to livelihood, just as the activities which took the form of rites and ceremonies were nobler and nearer the divine than those spent in toil. The change from religion to philosophy was. so great in form that their identity as to content is easily lost from view. The form ceases to be that of the story told in imaginative and emotional style, and becomes that of rational discourse observ- ing the canons of logic. It is well known that that portion of Aristotle’s system which later generations have called meta- physics he called First Philosophy. It is possible to quote from him sentences descriptive of “First Philosophy” which make it seem that the philosophic enterprise is a coldly rational one, objective and analytic. Thus he says it is the most comprehen- \ sive of all branches of knowledge because it has for its subject- | matter definition of the traits which belong to all forms of ’ Being whatsoever, however much they may differ from one another in detail. But when these passages are placed in the context they had in Aristotle’s own mind, it is clear that the comprehensiveness and universality of first philosophy are not of a strictly analytic sort. They mark a distinction with respect to grade of value and title to reverence. For he explicitly identifies his first philosophy —or metaphysics—with theology; he says it is higher than other sciences. For these deal with generation and production, while its subject-matter permits of demonstrative, that is neces- 14 ESCAPE FROM PERIL sary, truth; and its objects are divine and such as are meet for God to occupy himself with. Again, he says that the objects of philosophy are such as are the causes of as much of the divine as is manifest to us, and that if the divine is anywhere present, it is present in things of the sort with which philosophy deals. The supremacy of worth and dignity of these objects are also made clear in the statement that the Being with which philosophy is occupied is primary, eternal and self-sufficient, because its nature is the Good, so that the Good is among the first principles which are philosophy’s subject-matter:—yet not, it must be understood, the good in the sense in which it has meaning and standing in human life but the inherently and eternally perfect, that which is complete and self-sufficient. Aristotle _t : mote antiquity tradition has handed down the idea, in story form, that the heavenly bodies are gods, and that the divine encompasses the entire natural world. This core of truth, he goes on to say in effect, was em- broidered with th tae the benefit of the masses, for reasons of expediency, ‘namely, the preservation of social institutions. The negative work of philosophy was then to strip away these imaginative accretions, From the standpoint of popular belief this was its chief work, and it was a destructive one. The masses only felt that their religion was attacked. But the enduring contribution was positive. The belief that the divine encom- passes the world was detached from its mythical context and made the basis of philosophy, and it became also the foundation of physical science—as is suggested by the remark that the heavenly bodies are gods. Telling the story of the universe in the form of rational discourse instead of emotionalized imag- ination signified the discovery of logic as a rational science. Conformity on the part of supreme reality to the requirements of logic conferred upon its constitutive objects necessary and immutable characteristics. Pure contemplation of these forms 1) THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY was man’s highest and most divine bliss, a communion with un- changeable truth. The geometry of Euclid doubtless gave the clew to logic as the instrument of translation of what was sound in opinion into the forms of rational discourse. Geometry seemed to reveal the possibility of a science which owed nothing to observation and sense beyond mere exemplification in figures or diagrams. It seemed to disclose a world of ideal (or non-sensible) forms which were connected with one another by eternal and necessary relations which reason alone could trace. This discovery was generalized by philosophy into the doctrine of a realm of fixed Being which, when grasped by thought, formed a complete system of immutable and necessary truth. If one looks at the foundations of the philosophies of Plato and Aristotle as an anthropologist looks at his material, that is, as cultural subject-matter, it is clear that these philosophies | were systematizations in rational form of the content of Greek religious and artistic beliefs. The systematization involved a _ purification. Logic provided the patterns to which ultimately real objects had to conform, while physical science was pos- sible in the degree in which the natural world, even in its muta- bilities, exhibited exemplification of ultimate immutable ra- tional objects. Thus, alongwith the elimination of myths and grosser superstitions, there were set up the ideals of science and of a life of reason. Ends which could justify themselves to reason were to take the place of custom as the guide of conduct. These two ideals form a permanent contribution to western civilization. But with all our gratitude for these. enduring gifts, we cannot forget the conditions which attended them. For they brought with them the idea of a hi ealm of fixed reality of which alone true sci ossible and of an interior world of changing things with Wich experience an practical m matters pene sexton pec NIOT I SOP ERL ELA LOLA sh Nermnsreie 7 eR eso ESCAPE FROM PERIL are concerned. They glorified the invariant at the expense of change, it being evident that all practical activity falls within the realm of change. It bequeathed the notion, which has ruled philosophy ever since the time of the Greeks, that the office of A a knowledge is esoapepent nara ssid antecedently real, rather than, as is the case with our_practica al judgments, to gain the kind of judgments, to gain the kind o & understanding which is necessary to deal with problems as they arise. oan fixing this conception of knowledge it established also, as far as philosophies of the classic type are concerned, the | special task of philosophic inquiry. As a form of knowledge it_ is concerned with the disclosure of. the Real ; in itself, of Being in and of itself. It is differentiated from other rae of know- ing by its preoccupation with a higher and more ultimate form of Being than that with which the sciences of nature are con- cerned. As far as it occupied itself at all with human conduct, it was to superimpose upon acts ends said to flow from the nature of reason. It thus diverted thought from inquiring into the pur- poses which experience of actual conditions suggest and from 4a concrete means of their actualization. A ' LT | ie form the doctrine of escape from the vicissitudes. of | eons with STEEN ‘For deliverance Wee means of rites and | cults, it substituted ‘deliverance through reason. This deliver- ance was an intellectual, a theoretical affair, constituted by a knowledge to be teeine | apart from practical activity. The realms of knowledge and action were each divided into two regions. It is not to be inferred that Greek philosophy separated activity from knowing. It connected them. But it distinguished activity from action—that is, from making and doing. Rational and necessary knowledge was treated, as in the celebrations of it by Aristotle, as an ultimate, self-sufficient and self-enclosed form of self-originated and self-conducted 17 ae THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY activity. It was ideal and eternal, independent of change and hence of the world in which men act and live, the world we experience perceptibly and practically. “Pure activity” was sharply marked off from practical action. The latter, whether in the industrial or the fine arts, in morals or in politics, was concerned with an inferior region of Being in which change rules, and which accordingly has Being only by courtesy, for it manifests deficiency of sure footing in Being by the very fact of change. It is infected with zon-being. On the side of knowledge, the division carried with it a difference between knowledge, in its full sense, and belief. The former is demonstrative, necessary—that is, sure. Belief on the contrary is only opinion; in its uncertainty and mere probabil- ity, it relates to the world of change as knowledge corre- sponds to the realm of true reality. This fact brings the discus- sion around once more to our special theme as far as it affects the conception of the office and nature of philosophy. That man has two modes, two dimensions, of belief, cannot be doubted. ‘He has beliefs about actual existences and the course of events, and ‘he has beliefs about ends to be striven for, policies to be adopted, goods to be attained and evils to be averted. The most -urgent of all practical problems concerns the connection the subject-matter of these two kinds of beliefs sustain to each other. How shall our most authentic and dependable cognitive beliefs be used to regulate our practical beliefs? How shall the latter serve to organize and integrate our intellectual beliefs? There is a genuine possibility that the true problem of philosophy is connected with precisely this type of question. Man has beliefs which scientific inquiry 701 uchsafes, beliefs about the actual structure and processes of things; and he also has beliefs about the values which should regulate his conduct. The question of how these two ways of believing may most effectively and fruitfully interact with one another is the most 18 ESCAPE FROM PERIL to us. Some reasone discipline, one obviously other than any ! science, should deal with this issue. Thus there is supplied one way of conceiving of the function of philosophy. But from this mode of defining philosophy we are erie the chief philosophical tradition. For according to ms of knowl- edge and of practical action have no inherent connection with each other. Here then is the focus to which the various elements in our discussion converge. We may then profitably recapitu- late. The realm of the practical is the region of change, and change is always contingent; it has in it an element of chance that cannot be eliminated. If a thing changes, its alteration is convincing evidence of its lack of true or complete Being. What is, in the full and pregnant sense of the world, is always, eternally. It is self-contradictory for that which js to alter. If it had no defect or imperfection in it how could it change? That which becomes merely comes to be, never truly is. It is infected with non-being; with privation of Being in the perfect sense. The world of generation is the world of decay and de- struction. Wherever one thing comes into being something else passes out of being. Thus the depreciation of practice was given : a philosophic, | an ontological, justification. Practical action, as distinct from self-revolving rational self-activity, belongs in the realm of | generation and decay, a realm inferior in value as in Being. In form, the quest for absolute certainty has reached its goal. Because ultimate Being or reality is fixed, permanent, admit- ting of no change or variation, it may be grasped by rational intuition and set forth in rational, that is, universal and neces- sary, demonstration. I do not doubt that there was a feeling before the rise of philosophy that the unalterably fixed and the absolutely certain are one, or that change is the source from which comes all our uncertainties and woes. But in philosophy 19 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY this inchoate feeling was definitely formulated. It was asserted on grounds held to be as demonstrably necessary as are the conclusions of geometry and logic. Thus the predisposition of philosophy toward the universal, invariant and eternal was fixed. It remains the common possession of the entire classic philosophic tradition. All parts of the scheme hang together. True Being or Reality is complete; in being complete, it is perfect, divine, immutable, the “unmoved mover.” Then there are things that change, that come and go, that are generated and perish, be- cause of lack of the stability which participation in ultimate Being alone confers. These changes, however, have form and character and are knowable in the degree in which they tend | toward an end which is the fulfillment and completion of the changes in question. Their instability is not absolute but is marked by aspiration toward a goal. The perfect and complete is rational thought, the ultimate “end” or terminus of all natural movement. That which changes, which becomes and passes away, és material; change defines the physical. At most and best, it is a potentiality of reaching a stable and fixed end. To these two realms belong two sorts of knowledge. One of them is alone knowledge in the full sense, science. This has a rational, necessary and unchang- ing form. It is certaim. The other, dealing with change, is belief or opinion; empirical and particular; it is contingent, a matter of probability, not of certainty. The most it can assert is that things are so and so “upon the whole,” usually. Corre- sponding to the division in Being and in knowledge is that in activities. Pure activity is rational; it is theoretical, in the sense in which theory is apart from practical action. Then there is action in doing and making, occupied with the needs and defects of the lower realm of change in which, in his physical nature, man is implicated. 20 ESCAPE FROM PERIL Although this Greek formulation was made long ago and much of it is now strange in its specific terms, certain features of it are as relevant to present thought as they were significant in their original formulation. For in spite of the great, the enormous changes in the subject-matter and method of the sciences and the tremendous expansion of practical activities by means of arts and technologies, the main tradition of western culture has retained intact this framework of ideas. Perfect certainty is what man wants. It cannot be found by practical doing or making; these take effect in an uncertain future, and involve peril, the risk of misadventure, frustration and failure. Knowledge, on the other hand, is thought to be concerned with a region of being which is fixed in itself. Being eternal and unalterable, human knowing is not to make any difference in it. It can be approached through the medium of the appre- hensions and demonstrations of thought, or by some other organ of mind, which does nothing to the real, except just to know it. There is involved in these doctrines a whole system of philosophical conclusions. The first and foremost is that there is complete correspondence between knowledge in its true meaning and what is real. What is known, what is true for cognition, is what is real in being. The objects of knowledge form the standards of measures of the reality of all other objects of experience. Are the objects of the affections, of desire, effort, choice, that is to say everything to which we at- tach value, real? Yes, if they can be warranted by knowledge; if we can know objects having these value properties, we are justi- fied in thinking them real. But as objects of desire and purpose they have no sure place in Being until they are approached and validated through knowledge. The idea is so familiar that we overlook the unexpressed premise upon which it rests, namely that only the completely fixed and unchanging can be real. 21 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY The quest far certitude hus determined our basi mishaps Secondly, the theory of knowledge has its basic premises fixed by the same doctrine. For knowledge to be certain must relate to that which has antecedent existence or essential being. There : are certain things which are alone inherently the proper objects of knowledge and science. Things in the production of which we participate we cannot know in the true sense of the word, for such things succeed instead of preceding our action. What concerns action forms the realm of mere guesswork and probability, as distinct from the warrant of rational assurance which is the ideal of true knowledge. We are so accustomed to the separation of knowledge from doing and making that we fail to recognize how it controls our conceptions of mind, of nansdoenen and oF HOSS Ren Pe a weaving knowledge, these must all be defined, on the basis of the premise, so as not to admit of the presence of any overt action that modifies conditions having prior and independent existence. | Special theories of knowledge differ enormously from one - another. Their quarrels with one another fill the air. The din thus created makes us deaf to the way in which they say one thing in common. The controversies are familiar. Some theories _ascribe the ultimate test of knowledge to impressions passively ‘received, forced upon us whether we will or no. Others ascribe the guarantee of knowledge to synthetic activity of the intellect. Idealistic theories hold that mind and the object known are ultimately one; realistic doctrines reduce knowledge to aware- ness of what exists independently, and so on. But they all make one common assumption. They all hold that the operation of inquiry excludes any element of practical activity that enters into the construction of the object known. Strangely enough this is as true of idealism as of realism, of theories of synthetic activity as of those of passive receptivity, For according to them 22 ESCAPE FROM PERIL “mind” constructs the known object not in any observable way, or by means of practical overt acts having a temporal quality, but by some occult internal operation. The common essence of all these theories, in short, is that | what is known is antecedent to the mental act of observation | and inquiry, and is totally unaffected by these acts; 3; otherwise it would not be fixed and unchangeable. This negative condition, that the processes of search, investigation, reflection, involved in knowledge relate to something having prior being, fixes once for all the main characters attributed to mind, and to the organs of knowing. They must be outside what is known, so as not to interact in any way with the object to be known. If the word “interaction” be used, it cannot denote that overt production of change it signifies in its ordinary and practical use. The theory of knowing is modeled after what was a posed to take place in the act of vision. The object refracts light to the eye and is seen; it makes a difference to the eye and to the person having an optical apparatus, but none to the thing seen. The real object is the object so fixed in its regal aloofness that it is a king to any beholding mind that may gaze upon it. A spectator theory of knowledge is the inevitable outcome. There have been theories which hold that mental activity inter- | venes, but they have retained the old premise. They have there- fore concluded that it is impossible to know reality. Since mind intervenes, we know, according to them, only some modified semblance of the real object, some “appearance.” It would be hard to find a more thoroughgoing confirmation than this con- clusion provides of the complete hold possessed by the belief that the object of knowledge is a reality fixed and complete in itself, in isolation from an act of inquiry which has in it any element of production of change. All of these notions about certainty and the fixed, about the nature of the real world, about the nature of the mind and 23 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY its organs of knowing, are completely bound up with one an- other, and their consequences famify into practically all im-— portant ideas entertained upon any “philosophic question. They all flow—such is my basic thesis—from the separation (set up & y in the interest of the quest for absolute certainty) between theory and practice, knowledge and actions. Consequently the later problem cannot be attacked in isolation, by itself. It is too thoroughly entangled with fundamental beliefs and ideas in all sorts of fields. In later chapters the theme will, therefore, be approached in relation to each of the above-mentioned points. We shall first take up the effect of the traditional separation upon the concep- tion of the nature of philosophy, especially in connection with the question of the secure place of values in existence. We shall then pass on to an account of the way in which modern philoso- phies have been dominated by the problem of reconciling the conclusions of natural science with the objective validity of the values by which men live and regulate their conduct:—a prob- lem which would have no existence were it not for the prior uncritical acceptance of the traditional notion that knowledge has a monopolistic clai _to.access to_reality, The discussion will then take up various phases of the development of actual know- ing as exemplified in scientific procedure, so as to show, by an analysis of experimental inquiry in its various phases, how com- pletely the traditional assumptions, mentioned above, have been abandoned in concrete scientific procedure. For science in be- coming experimental has itself become a mode of directed practical doing. There will then follow a brief statement of the effect of the destruction of the barriers which have divided theory and practice upon reconstruction of the basic ideas about mind and thought, and upon the solution of a number of long-standing problems as to the theory of knowledge. The consequences of substituting search for security by practical 24 ESCAPE FROM PERIL means for quest of absolute certainty by cognitive means will _ then be considered in its bearing upon the problem of our judg- _ ments regarding the values which control conduct, especially its social phases. 7 Fi 4 if” 25 CHAR Te Rae PHIDOSOPH Y's SBARCH ID OR Viriae IMMUTABLE IN THE PREVIOUus chapter, we noted incidentally the distinction made in the classic tradition between knowledge and belief, or, as Locke put it, between knowledge and judgment. According to this distinction the certain and knowledge are co-extensive. , Disputes exist, but they are whether sensation or reason affords the basis of certainty; or whether existence or essence is its object. In contrast with this identification, the very word “belief” is eloquent on the topic of certainty. We Jelieve in the absence of knowledge or complete assurance. Hence the quest for certainty has always been an effort to transcend beliet. Now since ad WE Rave aincady noted all matters of practical action involve an element of uncertainty, we can ascend from belief to knowledge only by isolating the latter from practical doing and making. ; In this chapter we are especially concerned with the effect of the ideal of certainty as something superior to belief upon the conception of the nature and function of philosophy. Greek thinkers saw clearly—and logically—that experience cannot furnish us, as respects cognition of existence, with anything more than contingent probability. Experience cannot deliver to us necessary truths; truths completely demonstrated by reason. Its conclusions are particular, not universal. Not being “exact” they come short of “science.” Thus there arose the distinction between rational truths or, in modern terminology, truths re- lating to the relation of ideas, and “truths” about matters of 26 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE existence, empirically ascertained. Thus not merely the arts of practice, industrial and social, were stamped matters of belief rather than of knowledge, but also all those sciences which are matters of inductive inference from observation. One might indulge in the reflection that they are none the worse for all that, especially since the natural sciences have developed a technique for achieving a high degree of probabil- ity and for measuring, within assignable limits, the amount of probability which attaches in particular cases to conclusions. But historically the matter is not so simple as to permit of this retort. For empirical or observational sciences were placed in invidious contrast. to rational sciences 1 which 1 dealt ‘with eternal and univers ‘universal il objects and which therefore were “possessed of n ecessary truth. Consequently all observational sciences as far as their material could not be subsumed under forms and prin- ciples supplied by rational science shared in the depreciatory view held about practical affairs. They are relatively low, secular and profane compared with the perfect_realities of ra- tional science. And here is a justification for going back to something as remote in time as Greek philosophy. The whole classic tradi- tion down to our day has continued to hold a slighting view of experience as such, and to hold up as the proper goal and ideal | of true knowledge realities which even if they are located in | empirical things cannot be known by experimental methods. | The logical consequence for philosophy itself is evident. Upon — the side of method, it has been compelled to claim for itself the possession of a method issuing from reason itself, and having the warrant of reason, independently of experience. As long as the view obtained that nature itself is truly known by the same rational method, the consequences—at least those which were evident—were not serious. There was no break between philosophy and genuine science—or what was conceived to be 27 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY such. In fact, there was not even a distinction; there were simply various branches of philosophy, metaphysical, logical, natural, moral, etc., in a descending scale of demonstrative cer- tainty. Since, according to the theory, the subject-matter of the lower sciences was inherently of a different character from that of true knowledge, there was no ground for rational dissatis- faction with the lower degree of knowledge called belief. In- ferior knowledge or belief corresponded to the inferior state of subject-matter. The scientific revolution of the seventeenth century effected a great modification. Science itself through the aid of mathe- et) matics carried the scheme of demonstrative knowledge over to natural objects. The “laws” of the natural world had that fixed character which in the older scheme had belonged only to rational and ideal forms. A mathematical science of nature couched in mechanistic terms claimed to be the only sound natural philosophy. Hence the older philosophies lost alliance with natural knowledge and the support that had been given to philosophy by them. Philosophy in maintaining its claim to be a superior form of knowledge was compelled to take an invidious and so to say.malicious attitude toward the conclusions of natural science. The framework of the old tradition had in the meantime become embedded in Christian theology, and through religious teaching was made a part of the inherited cul- ture of those innocent of any technical philosophy. Conse- quently, the rivalry between philosophy and the new science, with respect to the claim to know reality, was converted in effect into a rivalry between the spiritual values guaranteed by the older philosophic tradition and the conclusions of natural knowledge. The more science advanced the more it seemed to _ encroach upon the special province of the territory over which philosophy had claimed jurisdiction. Thus philosophy in its classic form became a species of apologetic justification for 28 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE belief in an ultimate reality in which the values which should regulate life and control conduct are securely : stated, y “here are undoubted disadvantages in the historic man- ner of approach to the problem which has been followed. It may readily be thought either that the Greek formulation which has been emphasized has no especial pertinency with respect to modern thought and especially to contemporary philosophy; or that no philosophical statement is of any great importance for the mass of non-philosophic persons. Those interested in philosophy may object that the criticisms passed are directed if not at a man of straw at least to positions that have long since lost their actuality. Those not friendly to any form of philosophy may inquire what import they have for any except professed philosophers. The first type of objection will be dealt with somewhat in extenso in the succeeding chapter, in which I shall try to show how modern philosophies, in spite of their great diversity, have. eee th prob ons of aciustinent of the conclusions of modern science fo the chief religious and moral tradition of the western world; together with the way in which these prob- lems are connected with retention of the conception of the relation of knowledge to reality formulated in Greek thought. At the point in the discussion now reached, it suffices to point out that, in spite of great changes in detail, the notion of a separation between knowledge and action, theory and practice, has been perpetuated, and that the beliefs connected with action are taken to be uncertain and inferior to value compared with those inherently connected with objects of knowledge, so that the former are securely established only as they derived from the latter. Not the specific content of Greek thought is peraenet to present problems, but its insistence that security is measured by certainty of knowledge, while the latter is measured by 29 ¥ THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY adhesion to fixed and immutable dbjects, which therefore are inde ndent of what mien do in practical activity. “The other objection is of a GUHPSnt sort It comes from those who feel that not merely Greek philosophy but philoso- phy in any form is remote from all significant human concern. It is willing to admit or rather assert that it is presumptuous for philosophy to lay claim to knowledge of a higher order than that given by natural science, but it also holds that this is no great matter in any case except for professional philosophers. There would be force in this latter objection were it not that those who make it hold for the most part the same philosophy of certainty and its proper object that is held by philosophers, save in an inchoate form. They are not interested in the notion that philosophic thought is a special means of attaining this object and the certainty it affords, but they are far from holding, either explicitly or implicitly, that the arts of intelligently directed action are the means by which security of values are to be attained. With respect to certain ends and goods they accept this idea. But in thinking of these ends and values as material, as related to health, wealth, control of con- ditions for the sake of an inferior order of consequences, they retain the same division between a higher reality and a lower that is formulated in classic philosophy. They may be innocent of the vocabulary that speaks of reason, necessary truth, the universal, things in themselves and appearances. But they incline to believe that there is some other road than that of action, directed by knowledge, to achieve ultimate security of higher ideals and purposes. They think of practical action as necessary for practical utilities, but they mark off practical ' formulation and justification to ideas that were operative in | men’s minds generally. And the elements of these ideas are 30 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE as active in present culture as they ever were in the past. In- deed, through the diffusion of religious doctrines, the idea that ultimate values are a matter of special revelation and are to be embodied in life by special means radically different from the arts of action that deal with lower and lesser ends has been accentuated in the popular mind. Here is the point which is of general human import instead of concern merely to professional philosophers. What about the security of values, of the things which are admirable, honor- able, to be approved of and striven for? It is probably in con- sequence of the derogatory view held of practice that the question of the secure place of values in human experience is so seldom raised in connection with the problem of the relation of knowledge and practice. But upon any view concerning the status of action, the scope of the latter cannot be restricted to self-seeking acts, nor to those of a prudential aspect, nor in general to things of expediency and what are often termed “utilitarian” affairs. The maintenance and diffusion of intellec- tual values, of moral excellencies, the esthetically admirable, as well as the maintenance of order and decorum in human rela- tions are dependent upon what men do. Whether because of the emphasis of traditional religion upon salvation of the personal soul or for some other reason, there is a tendency to restrict the ultimate scope of morals to | the reflex effect of conduct on one’s self. Even utilitarianism, with all its seeming independence of traditional theology and its emphasis upon the general good as the criterion for judging conduct, insisted in its hedonistic psychology upon private pleasure as the motive for action. The idea that the stable and expanding institution of all things that make life worth while throughout all human relationships is the real object of all intelligent conduct is depressed from view by the current con- ception of morals as a special kind of action chiefly concerned 31 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY with either the virtues or the enjoyments of individuals in their personal capacities. In changed form, we still retain the notion of a division of activity into two kinds having very different worths. The result is the depreciated meaning that has come to be attached to the very meaning of the “practical” and the useful. Instead of being extended to cover all forms of action by means of which all the values of life are extended and ren- dered more secure, including the diffusion of the fine arts and the cultivation of taste, the processes of education and all ac- tivities which are concerned with rendering human relationships more significant and worthy, the meaning of “practical” is limited to matters of ease, comfort, riches, bodily security and police order, possibly health, etc., things which in their isola- tion from other goods can only lay claim to restricted and narrow value. In consequence, these subjects are handed over to technical sciences and arts; they are no concern of “higher” interests which feel that no matter what happens to inferior goods in the vicissitudes of natural existence, the highest values are immutable characters of the ultimately real. Our depreciatory attitude toward “practice” would be modified if we habitually thought of it in its most liberal sense, and if we surrendered our customary dualism between two separate kinds of value, one intrinsically higher and one in- herently lower. We should regard practice as the only means (other than accident) by which whatever is judged to be honor- able, admirable, approvable can be kept in concrete experience- able existence. In this connection the entire import of “morals” would be transformed. How much of the tendency to ignore permanent objective consequences in differences made in natu- ral and social relations; and how much of the emphasis upon personal and internal motives and dispositions irrespective of what they objectively produce and sustain are products of the habitual depreciation of the worth of action in comparison with 32 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE © forms of mental processes, of thought and sentiment, which make no objective difference in things themselves? It would be possible to argue (and, I think, with much justice) that failure to make action central in the search for such security as is humanly possible is a survival of the impotency of men in those stages of civilization when he had few means of regulating and utilizing the conditions upon which the occurrence of consequences depend. As long as man was unable by means of the arts of practice to direct the course j of events, it was natural for him to seek an emotional substi- |, tute; in the absence of actual certainty in the midst of a pre- |” carious and hazardous world, men cultivated all sorts of things — that would give them the feelimg of certainty. And it is pos- sible that, when not carried to an illusory at the cultivation of the feeling gave man courage and : ° him to carry the bundeos of fe more scefully But one could hardly seriously contend that this fact, if it be such, is one upon which to found a reasoned philosophy. It is to the conception of philosophy that we come back. No mode of action can, as we have insisted, give anything approaching absolute certitude; it provides insurance but no assurance. Doing is always subject to peril, to the danger of frustration. When men began to reflect philosophically it seemed to them altogether too risky to leave the place of ae values at the mercy of acts the results of which are never sure. | This precariousness might hold as far as empirical existence, existence in the sensible and phenomenal world, is concerned; but this very uncertainty seemed to render it the more needful that ideal goods should be shown to have, by-means of knowl- edge of the most assured type, an indefeasible’ and (inex- 7 ugnable position in the realm of the “ultimately real. So at. We may imagine men to have reasoned. And to-day many persons find a peculiar consolation in the face of the unstable 33 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY and dubious presence of values in actual experience by project- ing a perfect form of good into a realm of essence, if not into a heaven beyond the earthly skies, wherein their authority, if not their existence, is wholly unshakeable. Instead of asking how far this process is of that compensa- tory kind with which recent psychology has made us familiar, we are inquiring into the effect upon philosophy. It will not be denied, I_suppose, that the chief aim of those philosophies which I have called classical, has been to show that the realities which are the objects of the highest and most necessary knowl- edge are also endowed with the values which correspond to our bést aspirations, admirations and approvals. That, one may say, & ia The ven hea ie EMI Oi tonal oh locapan idealisms, There is a pathos, having its own nobility, in philosophies which think it their proper office to give an intellectual or cognitive certifi- cation to the ontological reality of the highest values. It is dificult for men to see desire and choice set earnestly upon the good and yet being frustrated, without their imagining a realm in which the good has come completely to its own, and is identified with a Reality in which resides all ultimate power. The failure and frustration of actual life is then attributed to the fact that this world is finite and phenomenal, sensible rather than real, or to the weakness of our finite apprehension, which cannot see that the discrepancy between existence and value is merely seeming, and that a fuller vision would behold partial evil an element in complete good. Thus the office of philosophy is to project by dialectic, resting supposedly upon self-evident premises, a realm in which the object of com- pletest cognitive certitude is also one with the object of the M heart’s best aspiration. The fusion of the good and the true with unity and plenitude of Being thus becomes the goal of classic philosophy. The situation would strike us as a curious one were it not 34 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE so familiar. Practical activity is dismissed to a world of low grade reality. Desire is found only where something is lacking and hence its existence is a sign of imperfection of Being. Hence one must go to passionless reason to find perfect reality and complete certitude. But nevertheless the chief philosophic in- terest is to prove that the essential properties of the reality that is the object of pure knowledge are precisely those char- acteristics which have meaning in connection with affection, desire and choice. After degrading practical affairs in order to exalt knowledge, the chief task of knowledge turns out to be to demonstrate the absolutely assured and permanent reality of the values with which practical activity is concerned! Can we fail to see the irony in a situation wherein desire and emotion are relegated to a position inferior in every way to that of knowledge, while at the same time the chief problem of that which is termed the highest and most perfect knowledge is taken to be the existence of evil—that is, of desires errant and frustrated? The contradiction involved, however, is much more than a purely intellectual one—which if purely theoretical would be innocuously lacking in practical consequences. The thing which concerns all of us as human beings is precisely the greatest attainable security of values in concrete existence. The thought that the values which are unstable and wavering in the world in which we live are eternally secure in a higher realm (which reason demonstrates but which we cannot experience), that all the goods which are defeated here are triumphant there, may give consolation to the depressed. But it does not change the existential situation in the least. The separation that has been instituted between theory and practice, with its consequent sub- stitution of cognitive quest for absolute assurance for practical endeavor to make the existence of good more secure in ex- perience,-has had the effect of distracting attention and divert- on) THE QUEST POR CERTAINGY ing energy from a task whose performance would yield definite = esas values lies in the perfecting of methods of action. Mére ac- tivity, blind striving, gets nothing forward. Regulation of con- ree sone ditions upon which results depend is possible only by doing, yet only by doing which has intelligent direction, which takes cognizance of conditions, observes relations of sequence, and which plans and executes in the light of this knowledge.éThe notion that thought, apart from action, can warrant complete certitude as to the status of supreme good, makes no contribu- tion to the central problem of development of intelligent methods of regulation. It rather depresses and deadens effort ~in_ that direction, }Phat ; is the chief indictment to be brought against ‘the classic philosophic tradition.) Its import raises the question of the relation which action sustains to knowledge in fact, and whether the quest for certainty by other means than those of intelligent action does not mark a baneful/diversion of thought from its proper office. It raises the question whether mankind has not now achieved a sufficient degree of control of methods of knowing and of the arts of practical action so that a radical change in our conceptions of knowledge and practice is rendered both possible and necessary. That knowing, as judged from the actual procedures of scientific inquiry, has completely abandoned in fact the tra- ditional separation of knowing and doing, that the experi- mental procedure is one that installs doing as the heart of knowing, is a theme that will occupy our attention in later chapters. What would happen to philosophy if it whole- heartedly made a similar surrender? What would be its office if it ceased to deal with the problem of reality and knowledge at large? In effect, its function would be to facilitate the fruit- ful interaction of our cognitive beliefs, our beliefs resting upon 36 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE the most dependable methods of iquiry, with our practical beliefs about the values, the ends and purposes, that should control human action in the things of large and liberal human import. Such a view renounces the traditional notion that action is inherently inferior to knowledge and preference for the fixed over the changing; it involves the conviction that security attained by active control is to be more prized than certainty in theory. But it does not imply that action is higher and better than knowledge, and practice inherently superior to thought. Constant and effective interaction of knowledge and practice is something quite different from an exaltation of activity for its own sake. Action, when directed by knowledge, is method and means, not an end. The aim and end is the securer, freer and more widely shared embodiment of values in experience by means of that active control of objects which knowledge alone makes possible.* From this point of view, the problem of philosophy con- cerns the interaction of our judgments about ends to be sought with knowledge of the means for achieving them. Just as in science the question of the advance of knowledge is the question of what to do, what experiments to perform, what apparatus to invent and use, what calculations to engage in, what branches of mathematics to employ or to perfect, so the problem of practice is what do we need to know, how shall we obtain that knowl- edge and how shall we apply it? It is an easy and altogether too common a habit to confuse a personal division of labor with an isolation of function and meaning. Human beings as individuals tend to devote them- *In reaction against the age-long depreciation of practice in behalf of contemplative knowledge, there is a temptation simply to turn things upside down. But the essence of pragmatic instrumentalism is to conceive of both knowledge and practice as means of making goods—excellencies of all kinds— secure in experienced existence. oy THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY selves either to the practice of knowing or to the practice of a professional, business, social or esthetic art. Each takes the other half of the circle for granted. Theorists and practitioners, however, often indulge in unseemly wrangles as to the im- portance of their respective tasks. Then the personal difference of callings is ear made into an intrinsic differ- ence between knowledge and practice. If one looks at the history of knowledge, it is plain that at the beginning men tried to know because they had to do so in order to live. In the absence of that organic guidance given by their structure to other animals, man had to find out what he was about, and he could find out only by studying the environment which constituted the means, obstacles and results of his behavior. The desire for intellectual or cognitive under- standing had no meaning except as a means of obtaining greater security as to the issues of action. Moreover, even when after the coming of leisure some men were enabled to adopt know- ing as their special calling or profession, merely theoretical un- certainty continues to have no meaning. This statement will arouse protest. But the reaction against the statement will turn out when examined to be due to the fact that it is so difficult to find a case of purely intellectual uncertainty, that is one upon which nothing hangs. Perhaps as near to it as we can come is in the familiar story of the Oriental potentate’ who declined to attend a horse race on the ground that-it was already well known to him that one horse could run faster than another. His uncertainty as to which of several horses could outspeed the others may be said to have been purely intellectual. But also in the story nothing depended from it; no curiosity was aroused; no effort was put forth to satisfy the uncertainty. In other words, he did not care; it made no difference. And it is a strict truism that no one would care about avy exclusively theoretical uncertainty or certainty. 38 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE For by definition in being exclusively theoretical it is one which makes no difference anywhere. Revulsion against this proposition is a tribute to the fact that actually the intellectual and the practical are so closely bound together. Hence when we imagine we are thinking of an exclusively theoretical doubt, we smuggle in unconsciously some consequence which hangs upon it. We think of uncertainty arising in the course of an inquiry; in this case, uncertainty until it is resolved blocks the progress of the inquiry—a dis- tinctly practical affair, since it involves conclusions and the means of producing them. If we had no desires and no pur- poses, then, as sheer truism, one state of things would be as good as any other. Those who have set such store by the de- monstration that Absolute Being already contains in eternal safety within itself all values, have had as their interest the fact that while the demonstration would make no difference in the concrete existence of these values—unless perhaps to weaken effort to generate and sustain them—it would make a difference in their own personal attitudes—in a_teeling_ot pee or of release from responsibility, the consciousness of ‘moral holiday” i in which some philosophers have found the Teton between morals and. religion. a Be Such considerations point to the conclusion that the ulti- mate ground of the quest for cognitive certainty is the need for security in the results of action. Men readily persuade them- selves that they are devoted to intellectual certainty for its own sake. Actually they want it because of its bearing on safeguard- ing what they desire and esteem. The need for protection and prosperity in action created the need for warranting the validity of intellectual beliefs, After a distinctively intellectual class had arisen, a class hav- ing leisure and in a large degree protected against the more serious perils which afflict the mass of humanity, its members 39 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY proceeded to glorify their own office. Since no amount of pains and care in action can ensure. complete. certainty, certainty in knowledge was worshipped as a substitute. In minor matters, those that are relatively technical, professional, “utilitarian,” men continued to resort to improving their methods of opera- tion in order to be surer of results. But in affairs of momentous value the requisite knowledge is hard to come by and the bettering of methods is a slow process to be realized only by the codperative endeavor of many persons. The arts to be formed and developed are social arts; an individual by himself can do little to regulate the conditions which will render im- portant values more secure, though with shrewdness and special knowledge he can do much to further his own peculiar aims— given a fair share of luck. So because of impatience and be- cause, as Aristotle was given to pointing out, an individual is self-sufficient in that kind of thinking which involves no action, the ideal of a cognitive certainty and truth having no connection with practice, and prized because of its lack of con- nection, developed. The doctrine worked out practically so as to strengthen dependence upon authority and dogma in the things of highest value, while increase of specialized knowl- edge was relied upon in everyday, especially economic, affairs. Just as belief that a magical ceremony will regulate the growth of seeds to full harvest stifles the tendency to investigate natural causes and their workings, so acceptance of dogmatic rules as bases of conduct in education, morals and social mat- ters, lessens the impetus to find out about the conditions which are involved in forming intelligent plans. It is more or less of a commonplace to speak of the crisis which has been caused by the progress of the natural sciences in the last few centuries. The crisis is due, it is asserted, to the incompatibility between the conclusions of natural science about the world in which we live and the realm of higher values, 40 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE of ideal and spiritual qualities, which get no support from nat- ural science. The new science, it is said, has stripped the world of the qualities which made it beautiful and congenial to men; has deprived nature of all aspiration towards ends, all prefer- ence for accomplishing the good, and presented nature to us as a scene of indifferent physical particles acting according to mathematical and mechanical laws. This effect of modern science has, it is notorious, set the ' main problems for modern philosophy. How is science to be accepted and yet the realm of values to be conserved? This question forms the philosophic version of the popular conflict of science and religion. Instead of being troubled about the inconsistency of astronomy with the older religious beliefs about heaven and the ascension of Christ, or the differences between the geological record and the account of creation in _ Genesis, philosophers have been troubled by the gap in kind which exists between the fundamental principles of the natural world and the reality of the values according to which mankind is to regulate its life. Philosophers, therefore, set to work to mediate, to find some harmony behind the apparent discord. ‘Everybody knows that the trend of modern philosophy has been to arrive at theories regarding the nature of the universe by means of theories regarding the nature of knowledge—a procedure which reverses the apparently more judicious method of the ancients in basing their conclusions about knowledge on the nature of the universe in which knowledge occurs. The “crisis” of which we have just been speaking accounts for the reversal. Since science has made the trouble, the cure ought to be found in an examination of the nature of knowledge, of the conditions which make science possible. If the conditions of the possibility of knowledge can be shown to be of an ideal and rational character, then, so it has been thought, the loss AI THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of an idealistic cosmology in physics can be readily borne. The physical world can be surrendered to matter and mechanism, since we are assured that matter and mechanism have their foundation in immaterial mind. Such has been the characteristic course of modern spiritualistic philosophies since the time of Kant; indeed, since that of Descartes, who first felt the poig- nancy of the problem involved in reconciling the conclusions of science with traditional religious and moral beliefs. It would presumably be taken as a sign of extreme naiveté, if not of callous insensitiveness, if one were to ask why all this ardor o reconcile the findings of natural science with the “validity of values? Why should any increase of knowledge seem like a threat to what we prize, admire and approve? Why should we not proceed to employ our gains in science to im- prove our judgments about values, and to regulate our actions so as to make values more secure and more widely shared in existence? I am willing to run the risk of charge of naiveté for the sake of making manifest the difference upon which we have been dwelling. If men had associated their ideas about values with practical activity instead of with cognition of antecedent Being, they would mot have been troubled by the findings of science. They would have welcomed the latter. For anything ascertained about the structure of actually existing conditions would be a definite aid in making judgments about things to be prized and striven for more adequate, and would instruct us as to the means to be employed in realizing them. But ac- cording to the religious and philosophic tradition of Europe, the valid status of all the highest values, the good, true and beautiful, was bound up with their being properties of ultimate _ , and supreme Being, namely, God. All went well as long as what passed for natural science gave no offence to this concep- tion. Trouble began when science ceased to disclose in the 42 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE objects of knowledge the possession of any such properties. Then some roundabout method had to be devised for sub- stantiating them. The point of the seemingly crass question which was asked is thus to elicit the radical difference made when the problem of values is seen to be connected with the problem of intelli- gent action. If the validity of beliefs and judgments about values is dependent upon the consequences of action undertaken in their behalf, if the assumed association of values with knowl- edge capable of being demonstrated apart from activity, is abandoned, then the problem of the intrinsic relation of science to value is wholly artificial. It is replaced by a group of practi- cal problems: How shall we employ what we know to direct the formation of our beliefs about value and how shall we direct our practical behavior so as to test these beliefs and make possible better ones? The question is seen to be just what it has always been empirically: What shall we do to make objects having value more secure in existence? And we ap- proach the answer to the problem with all the advantages given us by increase of knowledge of the conditions and rela- tions under which this doing must proceed. But for over two thousand years the weight of the most influential and authoritatively orthodox tradition of thought has been thrown into the opposite scale. It has been devoted to the problem of a purely cognitive certification (perhaps by revelation, perhaps by intuition, perhaps by reason) of the antecedent immutable reality of truth, beauty and goodness. As against such a doctrine, the conclusions of natural science constitute the materials of a serious problem. The appeal has been made to the Court of Knowledge and the verdict has been adverse. There are two rival systems that must have their respective claims adjusted. The crisis in contemporary culture, the confusions and conflicts in it, arise from a division of au- 43 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY thority. Scientific inquiry seems to tell one thing, and tra- ditional beliefs about ends and ideals that have authority over conduct tell us something quite different. The problem of re- conciliation arises and persists for one reason only. As long as the notions persist that knowledge is a disclosure of reality, of reality prior to and independent of knowing, and that know- ing is independent of a purpose to control the quality of ex- perienced objects, the failure of natural science to disclose significant values in its objects will come as a shock. Those seriously concerned with the validity and authority of value will have a problem on their hands. As long as the notion per- sists that values are authentic and valid only on condition that they are properties of Being independent of human action, as long as it is supposed that their right to regulate action is dependent upon their being independent of action, so long there will be needed schemes to prove that values are, in spite of the findings of science, genuine and known qualifica- tions of reality in itself. For men will not easily surrender all regulative guidance in action. If they are forbidden to find standards in the course of experience they will seek them some- where else, if not in revelation, then in the deliverance of a reason that is above experience. This then is the fundamental issue for present philosophy. Is the doctrine justified that knowledge is valid in the degree in which it is a revelation of antecedent existences or Being? Is the doctrine justified that regulative ends and purposes have validity only when they can be shown to be properties belong- ing to things, whether as existences or as essences, apart from human action? It is proposed to make another start. Desires, affections, preferences, needs and interests at least exist in hu- man experience; they are characteristics of it. Knowledge about nature also exists. What does this knowledge imply and entail with respect to the guidance of our emotional and volitional Ad een “Ss PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE life? How shall the latter lay hold of what is known in order to make it of service? These latter questions do not seem to many thinkers to have the dignity that is attached to the traditional problems of philosophy. They are proximate questions, not ultimate. They do not concern Being and Knowledge “in themselves” and at large, but the state of existence at specified times and places and the state of affection, plans and purposes under concrete circumstances. They are not concerned with framing a general theory of reality, knowledge and value once for all, but with finding how authentic beliefs about existence as they currently exist can operate fruitfully and efficaciously in connection with the practical problems that are urgent in actual life. In restricted and technical fields, men now proceed un- hesitatingly along these lines. In technology and the arts of engineering and medicine, men do not think of operating in any other way. Increased knowledge of nature and its con- ditions does not raise the problem of validity of the value of health or of communication in general, although it may well make dubious the validity of certain conceptions men in the past have entertained about the nature of health and com- munication and the best ways of attaining these goods in fact. In such matters, science has placed in our hands the means by which we can better judge our wants, and has aided in form- ing the instruments and operations by which to satisfy them. That the same sort of thing has not happened in the moral and distinctly humane arts is evident. Here is a problem which might well trouble philosophers. Why have not the arts which deal with the wider, more, generous, more distinctly humane values enjoyed the release. and expansion which have accrued to the technical arts? Can it be seriously urged that it is because natural science has dis- closed to us the kind of world which it has disclosed? It is 45 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY easy to see that these disclosures are hostile to some beliefs about values which have been widely accepted, which have prestige, which have become deeply impregnated with senti- ment, and which authoritative institutions as well as the emotion and inertia of men are slow to surrender. But this admission, which practically enforces itself, is far from ex- cluding the formation of new beliefs about things to be honored and prized by men in their supreme loyalties of action, The difficulty in the road is a practical one, a social one, connected with institutions and the methods and aims of education, not with science nor with valueUnder such circumstances the first problem for philosophy would seem to be to clear itself of further responsibility for the doctrine that the supreme issue is whether values have antecedent Being, while its further office is to make clear the revisions and reconstructions that have to be made in traditional judgments about values. Having done this, it would be in a position to undertake the more positive task of projecting ideas about values which might be the basis of a new integration of human conduct. We come back to the fact that the genuine issue is not | whether certain values, associated with traditions and institu- tions, have Being already (whether that of existence or of essence), but what concrete judgments we are to form about ends and means in the regulation of practical behavior. The emphasis which has been put upon the former question, the creation of dogmas about the way in which values are already real independently of what we do, dogmas which have ap- é pealed not in vain to philosophy for support, have naturally if Ui, [ap bred, in the face of the changed character of science, confusion, jal | ane ratie mIeH of will> If the men had been edu- cated to think about broader humane values as they have now learned to think about matters which fall within the scope of technical arts, our whole present situation would be very dif- 46 PHILOSOPHY’S SEARCH FOR IMMUTABLE ferent. The attention which has gone to achieving a purely theoretical certainty with respect to them would have been devoted to perfecting the arts by which they are to be judged and striven for. Indulge for a moment in an imaginative flight. Suppose that men had been systematically educated in the belief that the existence of values can cease to be accidental, narrow and precarious only by human activity directed by the best available knowledge. Suppose also men had been systematically educated to believe that the important thing is not to get themselves personally “right” in relation to the antecedent author and guarantor of these values, but to form their judgments and carry on their activity on the basis of public, objective and shared consequences. Imagine these things and then imagine what the present situation might be. The suppositions are speculative. But they serve to indicate the significance of the one point to which this chapter is de-. | voted. The method and conclusions of science have without | doubt invaded many cherished beliefs about the things held | most dear. The resulting clash constitutes a genuine cultural | crisis. But it is a crisis in culture, a social crisis, historical and | temporal in character. It is not a problem in the adjustment of ! properties of reality to one another. And yet modern philoso- phy has chosen for the most part to treat it as a question of how the realities assumed to be the object of science can have the mathematical and mechanistic properties assigned to them in natural science, while nevertheless the realm of ultimate reality can be characterized by qualities termed ideal and spiritual. The cultural problem is one of definite criticisms to be made and of readjustments to be accomplished, Philoso- phy which is willing to abandon its supposed task of knowing ultimate reality and to devote itself to a Proximate>human office might be of great help in such a task. Temay be « doubted 47 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY whether it can indefinitely pursue the task of trying to show that the results of science when they are properly interpreted do not mean what they seem to say, or of proving, by means of an examination of possibilities and limits of knowledge, that after all they rest upon a foundation congruous with traditional beliefs about values. Since the root of the traditional conception of philosophy is the separation that has been made between knowledge and action, between theory and practice, it is to the problem of this separation that we are to give attention. Our main attempt will be to show how the actual procedures of knowledge, in- terpreted after the pattern formed by experimental inquiry, cancel the isolation of knowledge from overt action. Before engaging in this attempt, we shall in the next chapter show the extent to which modern philosophy has been dominated by effort to adjust _to-each other two systems of belief, one relating to he sists of f knowledge and the other to objects of C “ydeal value. ) 48 CMAP TE REDE : CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES wT Ir 1s THE theme of the present chapter that modern philoso- phy, understanding by this term that which has been influenced by the rise of the newer natural science, has contained within itself an inner division. It has tried to combine acceptance of the conclusions of scientific inquiry as to the natural_warld with acceptance of doctrines about the nature of mind and knowledge which originated before there was such a thing as (sen apernental igi etree he quiry.) Between the two there is an nherent incompatibility. Hence the best efforts of philosophy have been constantly frustrated by artificiality and by contro- versial conflicts. Of all the many artificial problems which philosophy has thereby inflicted upon itself, we are here con- cerned with but one, the one with which the last chapter was concerned in a general way. This is the supposed need of reconciling, of somehow adjusting, (the f scientific knowledge with the validity of ideas concerning value. } # | For obvious reasons, Greek thought, from which stems __ the philosophic conceptions about the nature of knowledge as the sole valid grasp of Vision of reality, did not have this problem. Its physics were in complete harmony with its meta- physics, and the latter were teleological and qualitative. Natural objects themselves tend, throughout their changes, toward ideal ends that are the final objects of highest knowledge. A science of natural changes is possible only because of this fact. The natural world is knowable in as far as its changes are dominated by forms or essences that are immutable, complete or perfect. 49 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY In aspiring to actualize these prior and perfect forms, natural phenomena present characters in virtue of which they may be known, that is, defined and classified. Moreover, these ideal forms form reason in its full and perfect actuality of Being. To know them is to enjoy communion with perfect Being and thus to enjoy the highest happiness. For man as a rational and yet natural being strives also to realize his end, and this reali- zation is identical with apprehension of true and immutable Being. In this apprehension, man rises above the mutabilities of the natural world and comes into possession of a perfection which is incapable of lack and deprivation. Pure rationality is in its purity above physical nature. But in his essential being, his rationality, man is himself above nature. The reality which - satisfies the quest for (cognitive certitude Liu also affords the unqualified possession of perfect good. ” The need of adjustment of the results of knowledge and the apprehension and enjoyment of the highest good came when, in the s ury, new methods of inquiry gave an entirely new turn to the conceptions which could be enter- tained about the natural world” ~ Very early in its history, modern science asserted that the teleology of Greek science was a futile and mischievous en- cumbrance, wholly mistaken in its idea of the goal and method of scientific inquiry, and putting mind on the wrong track. It repudiated the doctrine of ideal forms, rejecting them as “occult.” As the new scientific method progressed, it became increasingly clear that the material of knowledge, provided one took science as the model form of knowledge, gave no justifi- cation for attributing to the objects of cognitive certainty those perfections which in Greek science had been their essential properties. At the same time, there was no disposition to break away from the tradition according to which the valid status of values must be determined by knowledge. Hence the crucial 50 srsepersertcet te CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES problem which modern philosophy found forced upon it, in as far as it\(accepted the conclusions of the new science while it also retained three significant elements of ancient thought: the first, that certainty, security, can be found only in the fixed and unchanging; the second, that knowledge is the only road to that which is intrinsically stable and certain; the third, that practical activity is an inferior sort of thing, necessary simply because of man’s animal nature and the necessity for winning subsistence from the environment. In one significant respect, moreover, modern thought started with accentuation of the gulf between the values which are intrinsic to the real and hence are not dependent upon action, and those goods which, being merely instrumental, are the objects of practical activity. For Greek thought never made a sharp separation between the rational and perfect realm and the natural world. The latter was indeed inferior and infected with non-being or privation. But it did not stand in any sharp dualism to the higher and perfect reality. Greek thinking ac- cepted the senses, the body and nature with natural piety and found in nature a hierarchy of forms leading degree by de- gree to the divine. The soul was the realized actuality of the body, as reason was the transcendent realization of the intima- tion of ideal forms contained in the soul. The senses included within themselves forms which needed only to be stripped of their material accretions to be true stepping stones to higher knowledge. Modern philosophy inherited the framework of Greek ideas about the nature of knowledge although rejecting its conclusions about natural objects. But it inherited them through the medium of Hebraic and Christian religion. The natural world in this tradition was fallen and corrupt. With the Greeks the element of rationality was supreme and the good came into human possession by the realized development of reason. 51 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY The intervening religious development made the ethical more fundamental than the rational. The most significant issues con- cerned the relation of will, rather than intellect, to supreme and perfect Being. Thus there was effected a reversal of per- spective as to the relations in perfect Being of the properties in virtue of which it is respectively an object of true knowledge “and~of perfect good and bliss. Righteousness, in accordance with the Hebraic factors adopted into Christian theology, was primary, and strictly intellectual properties were subordinate. The participation of the mind in perfect being could not be attained by Titetlece-umtil-tie tele was tee morally re- deemed and purified’ The difference between the pure Greek tradition and the Christian is brought out in some words of Cardinal Newman. “The Church holds that it were better for sun and moon to drop from heaven, for the earth to fall, and for all the many millions who are upon it to die of starvation in extremest agony rather than that one soul should commit one venial sin.” In saying that modern philosophy inherited the Greek tradition as passed through this intervening medium of Chris- tian thought, I do not mean to say that all features of the Christian view of nature in relation to God and the fall of man were taken over. On the contrary, distinctively modern thought is marked by a revival of the Greek interest and de- light in nature and natural observation. Thinkers deeply in- fluenced by modern science often ceased to believe in divine revelation as supreme authority and adhered to natural reason in its place. But the supreme place of good as a defining prop- ‘erty of the ultimately real remained the common premise of Jew, Catholic and Protestant. If not vouched for by revelation, it was warranted by the “natural light” of intellect. This phase of the religious tradition was so deeply ingrained in European culture that no philosopher except the thoroughgoing sceptics 52 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES escaped its influence.Ain this sense modern philosophy began its career with an accentuation of the gap which exists between ultimate and eternal values and natural objects and goods. > Thinkers who remained within the framework of the classic tradition held that the moral perfection which is the inherent property of ultimate Being prescribes the law of human ac- tion. It constitutes the norm of all significant and enduring values. Reason is necessary to furnish the foundation of truths without which observations—or experience in general—cannot be constituted a science. But it is even more necessary to provide for the apprehension of the ultimate and immutable end and law of moral action. When the hierarchical ascent of nature to mind and to ideal forms was disturbed by the con- viction that the subject-matter of natural science is exclusively physical and mechanistic, there arose the dualistic opposition of matter and spirit, of nature and ultimate ends and goods. Qualities, excellencies and ends that were extruded from nature by the new science found their exclusive abode and war- rant in the realm of the spiritual, which was above nature and yet which was its source and foundation. The function of rea- son in determination and enjoyment of the good no longer formed the consummation of nature. It had a distinct and separate office. The tension created by the opposition and yet necessary connection of nature and spirit gave rise to all the characteristic problems of modern philosophy. It could neither be frankly naturalistic, nor yet fully spiritualistic to the dis- regard of the conclusions of physical science. Since man was on one hand a part of nature and on the other hand a member of the realm of spirit, all problems came to a focus in his double nature. | The philosophy of Spinoza is noteworthy for its frank statement of this problem and for the uniquely thoroughgoing way in which, given its terms, it was solved. An unqualified 53 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY naturalism in the sense in which he understood the new science was combined by a miracle of logic with an equally complete acceptance of the idea, derived from the religious tradition, that ultimate reality is the measure of perfection and the norm for human activity. The union thus effected is so complete as to afford a pattern of instruction regarding the problem of modern thought. In him, more than in any modern thinker, there are exhibited complete loyalty to the essential element in the Hebraic tradition—ultimate and self-sufficing Being as the standard of all human thought and action—with perpetua- tion of the Greek theory of knowledge and its exaltation of reason over experience, together with enthusiastic adherence to the new scientific view of nature. Thus he thought to obtain from the very heart of the new science a conclusive demonstra- tion of the perfection of Being through which the human soul can alone obtain absolute security and peace. A scientific com- prehension was to give, in full reality, by rational means, that assurance and regulation of life that non-rational religions had pretended to give. In his unfinished essay on the The Improvement of the Human Understanding, he frankly states his impelling motive. He had experienced, he says, that everything in the ordinary course of experience is empty and futile. In desperation he set himself to inquiring whether there is not a good capable of communicating itself, a good so assured and complete that the mind can adhere to it to the exclusion of all else: a good which when found and taken possession of would give him eternally a constant and supreme bliss. For he had discovered. that the cause of the erturbatio: 1s-and vanities of life was that affection and desire were fixed upon things which perish. But “love directed toward that which is eternal and infinite feeds the mind wholly with joy unmixed with any sadness... . The true good of man is that he should attain, together with 54 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES others if possible, to a knowledge of the union which the mind has with Nature as a whole.” He concludes, “I wish to direct all the sciences to this one end and scope in order that we may attain to such perfection.” Certain, enduring and unalloyed Good through the union of mind with the whole of nature is the theme developed in detail in the Ethics. There results a philosophy which unites the Greek idea that man’s highest good is demonstrative ra- tional knowledge of immutable Being; the Hebrew and Chris- tian conviction that the soul is capable of a way of life which secures constant and pure blessedness, and the premises and _ method of the new science, as he saw the latter. Nature was completely intelligible; it was at one with mind; to apprehend nature as a whole was to attain a cognitive certainty which also afforded a complete certainty of good for the purpose of con- trol of appetite, desire and affection—this latter specification being one which Greek thought did not include and which it doubtless would have thought the height of presumption to lay claim to. Right ordering of human conduct, knowledge of the highest reality, the enjoyment of the most complete and unvarying value or good, were combined in one inclusive whole by means of adoption of the ideas of the complete interdepen- dence of all things according to universal and necessary law— an idea which he found to be the basis of natural science. There have been few attempts in modern philosophy as bold and as direct as is this one to effect a complete integration of scientific method with a good which is fixed and final, because based on the rock of absolute cognitive certainty. Few thinkers have been as willing to sacrifice details of the older tradition in order to save its substance as was Spinoza. The outcry from all quarters against him proved that, in the minds of his con- temporaries and successors, he had made too many concessions to naturalistic science and necessary law. But this protest should 55 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY not conceal from us two essential considerations about his work. The first of these is that Nature, as the object of knowledge, is capable of being the source of constant good and a rule of life, and thus has all the properties and the functions which the Jewish-Christian tradition attributed to God. He was hence entitled to confer upon it the name Natura sive Deus. For Na- ture, as he conceived it, carried with it all the emotional associa- tions and all the moral force and authority found in the older religious view of God. It provided an immutable End and Law for conduct, and it was the source, when rationally known, of perfect peace and unqualified security. Nature was naturally— that is rationally—known, and knowledge of it was such a per- fect good that when it takes possession of the human mind the lesser and otherwise disturbing objects of affection and passion are so included within it as to fall into their proper place of subordination: that is, of complete control. The second consideration is that Spinoza exemplifies with extraordinary completeness the nature of the problem of all modern philosophies which have not deserted the classic tra- dition, and yet have made the conclusions of modern science their own. What makes Spinoza so admirably the exponent of this problem is that he adopted with ardor and without the res- ervations displayed by most modern thinkers the essential ele- ments in the Greek tradition of intellectualism and naturalism, the Hebrew-Christian idea of the priority and primacy of the properties of ultimate Being which concern the control of hu- man affection and endeavor, and the method and conclusions of the new natural science—as he saw them. The reluctance of other thinkers to follow the model of solution of their common problems which he offered was not, however, wholly due to their desire to save portions of the older moral and religious tradition that he was willing to sur- render for what seemed to him a greater and more enduring 56 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES good—the unification of science with an ethico-religious con- trol of the springs of human conduct. There were difficulties from the side of science itself. Its experimental trend, as dis- tinct from its mathematical strain, was adverse to Spinoza’s unquestioning faith that the logical order and connection of ideas is one with the order and connection of existence. For as the new science developed, the experimental necessity for sense data and verification by observation reduced the réle of logical and mathematical conceptions from a primary to a secondary rank. Even his predecessor Descartes, also a devotee of rationalistic method, had seen that there had to be some warrant for the application of ideas to nature. Other philoso- phers felt that after all the perfections with which Spinoza had so richly dowered Nature as the object of knowledge, were, in spite of his professed denial of teleology, the fruit of emotion rather than of logic. We do not need to trace these complications. They are im- portant for our purpose because they induced so many varia- tions in the treatment of a single underlying problem: ‘the adjustment to each other of two unquestioned convictions: One, that knowledge in the form of science reveals the antecedent properties of reality; the other, that the ends and laws which should regulate human affection, desire and intent can b derived only from the properties possessed by ultimate Being. If the rest of the chapter is given to a brief survey of the diverse methods of adjustment which have been propounded, it is not for the sake of conveying information upon matters familiar to all students of philosophy. I am concerned only to set forth illustrations of the way in which unyielding adher- ence to traditional premises regarding the object of true knowl- edge and the source of moral authority have set the problem of modern thought, and to provide illustration of the diverse and incompatible ways in which “solutions” have been sought. ai Pa) THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY Before the rise of the new science of nature there was de- veloped a method for adjusting the claims of natural reason and moral authority by means of a division of the field: the doctrine of “the two-fold nature of truth.” The realm of the ends and values authoritative for conduct was that of the revealed will of God. The organ for its apprehension was faith. Nature is the object of knowledge and with respect to it the claims of reason are supreme. The two realms are so separate that no conflict can occur. The work of Kant may be regarded as a perpetuation of the method of adjustment by means of partition of territories. He did not of course de- marcate the realm of moral authority on the ground of faith in revelation. He substituted the idea of faith grounded in practical reason. But he continued the older distinction of one realm where the intellect has sway and one in which the re- quirements of will are supreme. He retained also the notion of an isolation of the two fields so complete that there is no possible overlapping and hence no possibility of interference. If the kingdoms of science and of righteousness nowhere touch, there can be no strife between them. Indeed, Kant sought to arrange their relations or lack of relations in such a way that there should be not merely non-interference but a pact of at least benevolent neutrality. Kant’s systent bristles ith points of internal difficulty; many of these ate-obje¢ts of controversy. Ignoring these as irrelevant to our problem, it can fairly be asserted that the main characteristic of his system is precisely a division of terri- tory between the objects of cognitive certitude and those of equally complete practical moral assurance. The titles of his two chief works, the Critiques of Pure Reason and of Practical Reason are memorials to this interpretation. The first aims to make secure, on rational @ priori grounds, the founda- tions of natural knowledge; the second performs a like office 58 a eae CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES for the foundations of moral and religious conceptions. Science is limited to phenomena in space and time in order that the world of higher and noumenal realities may be appropriated by ideals and spiritual values. Each has complete jurisdiction and undisputed sovereignty in its own realm. Heine’s view that the subject-matter of the practical critique was an afterthought, a concession to the needs and fears of the multitude represented by his manservant, is wittily ex- pressed, but will not stand critical examination. Kant’s argument for the justification of the certitude of the foundations of knowledge is couched at every point so as to indicate the neces- sity of a higher although intellectually unapproachable realm. There was nothing factitious, in Kant’s own conception, in the way in which the two kingdoms excluded each other and yet made each other necessary. On the contrary, the neat way in which the elements of each dovetailed into those of the other was to him a convincing proof of the necessity of the system as a whole. If the dovetailing was the product of his own intellectual carpentry, he had no suspicion of the fact. On the contrary, he thought he had disposed, once for all, of many of the most perplexing problems of prior philosophy. Upon the scientific side he was concerned to provide a final philosophical justification, beyond the reach of scepticism, for the Newtonian science. His conception of space and time as necessary forms of the possibility of perception was the justi- fication of the application of mathematics to natural phe- nomena. Categories of thought necessary to understand per- ceived objects—an understanding necessary to science—sup- plied the foundation of permanent substances and uniform relations of sequence—or causation—demanded by the New- tonian theories of atoms and uniform laws. The tendency of the mind to pass beyond the limits of experience to the thought of unconditioned and self-sufficient totalities, “Ideas” of the 59 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY universe, soul and God, was explained; and while cognitive validity was denied these Ideas, they were admitted as regu- lative ideals which directed inquiry and interpretation. Above all, the thought of these trans-phenomenal and super-empirical realities left room that practical reason with its imperative of duty and postulate of free choice could fill. Thus the su- premacy of righteousness according to the Hebraic-Christian tradition was justified independently of revelation by purely rational means. Moral demand for the final and unquestionable authority of duty authorized and necessitated practical certainty as to the reality of objects beyond experience and incapable of cognitive verification. The quest for certainty was fulfilled; cognitive certainty in the region of phenomena, practical cer- tainty in the realm of moral authority. This outline of obvious points in Kant’s system passes over points which have received much attention—such as the “sub- jectivity” of his view of space and time and the categories; the contrast of the @ priori and the empirical, as well as, in the Critique of Practical Reason, the seemingly arbitrary way in which faith in God and immortality are introduced. But with reference to his ultimate aim of establishing a perfect and unshakeable adjustment of the certainty of intellectual beliefs and of moral beliefs, these matters are secondary. The point on the practical side that had to be protected at all hazards was that no concrete and empirical material be permitted to influence ultimate moral realities—since this would give natural science jurisdiction over them and bring them under the sway of mechanical causality. On the cognitive side, the correspond- ing point to be certified was restriction of natural science to a strictly phenomenal world. For then there could be no en- croachment of specific scientific conclusions upon ultimate, that is ethico-religious, belief. In its essential framework, the Kantian scheme thus agreed 60 Oe Ae CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES marvelously well with the needs of the historic crisis ft gave freedom—and a blessing—to both science and morals, with a guarantee that they could never interfere with each other.) Granted the acceptance of the traditional belief that security of moral authority depends upon some source in Being apart from the experiences by which values are incarnated in concrete objects and institutions, the Kantian scheme has such merits that it is safe to predict that as long as that tradition continues | to have vitality, the main elements of the Kantian system will have devoted disciples. The Kantian method is of course but one of a number of e philosophic attempts at harmonization. There is one phase =; it which may be said to continue the Cartesian attempt to find the locus of absolute certainty within the knowing mind itself, surrendering both the endeavor of the ancients to dis- cover it in the world without, and of the medieval world to find it in an external revelation. In his search for forms and categories inherent in the very structure of knowing activity, Kant penetrated far below the superficial level of innate ideas in which his predecessors had tried to find the locus of certainty. Some of them were conditions of the possibility of there being such a thing as cognitive experience. Others were conditions of there being such a thing as moral experience. His idealistic successors pushed their way further on the road which Kant had broken:—even though he insisted that the doors were locked to traveling on it any further than he had gone. Solution by the method of partition is always unsatisfactory to minds with an ambition for comprehensiveness, just as it commends itself to those of a more modest turn. Moreover, the very neatness with which the essential traits of Kant’s two realms fitted each other suggested a single underlying and unifying principle. And Kant himself in various writings had suggested, particularly in his Critique of Judgment, considera- 61 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tions which softened the sharpness of their separation from each other. Fichte and Hegel saw in these things a challenge to complete a work which Kant had only confusedly undertaken and had not had the intellectual courage and clarity to execute. The controlling purpose of the Post-Kantian idealistic sys- tems was to accomplish by way of integration the task which Kant attempted by way of division. The contrast between the methods of Fichte and Hegel is worth a passing notice. Fichte was wholly in the Hebraic tradition of the supremacy of the moral. He accordingly attempted unification of the cognitive and the practical from the side of moral self, the self from which issues the imperative of duty. The “is” of knowledge is to be derived from the “ought to be” of morals. The effort loes not seem promising; it appears to speak more for the ethical ardor of his personality than for the sobriety of his understanding. Yet given the premises as to the certainty and supremacy in Being of ideal values prior to all action, Fichte’s method has a logic not to be impeached. If the moral ideal is the ultimate reality, it is proper to derive the structure and characteristics of the actual world from the necessities the ideal imposes and the demands it makes. Argument from the actual to the ideal is a precarious undertaking, since the actual is in so many respects so thoroughly un-ideal. Hegel, on the other hand, is never weary of pouring con- tempt upon an Ideal that merely ought to be. “The actual is the rational and the rational is the actual.” There is a definite relaxation of the stern Puritanism of Fichte. The moral task of man is not to create a world in accord with the ideal but to appropriate intellectually and in the substance of personality the meanings and values already incarnate in an actual world. Viewed historically, Hegel’s system may be looked on as a triumph in material content of the modern secular and positi- vistic spirit. It is a glorification of the here and now, an indica- 62 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES tion of the solid meanings and values contained in actual in- stitutions and arts, It is an invitation to the human subject to devote himself to the mastery of what is already contained in the here and now of life and the world, instead of hunting for some remote ideal and repining because it cannot be found in existence. In form, however, the old tradition remains intact. The validity of these meanings and values, their “absolute” character, is proved by their being shown to be manifestations of the absolute spirit according to a necessary and demonstrative logical development:—even though Hegel had to create a new logic to establish the identity of meaning and being. The Hegelian system is somewhat too’grandiosé*for present taste. Even his followers find it necessary to temper the claims made for his logical method. And yet if there be a synthesis in ultimate Being of the realities which can be cognitively sub- stantiated and of the meanings which should command our highest admiration and approval, then concrete phenomena, barring a complete corruption due to some lapse, ought to be capable of being exhibited as definite manifestations of the eternal union of the real-ideal. Perhaps there is no system more repugnant to the admirers of Spinoza than the Hegelian; and yet Hegel himself felt, and with considerable reason, that he was simply doing in a specific and concrete way what Spinoza had undertaken in a formal and mathematical way CHowever, the point important for our purpose is that in both Fichte and Hegel there is expressed the animating spirit of modern ideal- ism in dealing with the basic problem of all modern philoso- | phies. They have sought by examination of the structure of the knowing function (psychological structure in the subjective idealisms and logical structure in the objective idealisms and usually with a union of both strains) to show that no matter what the detailed conclusions of the special sciences, the ideal authority of truth, goodness, and beauty are secure possessions 63 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of ultimate Being independently of experience and human action. There have been attempts at adjustment of the results of knowledge and the demands of ethico-religious authority which have not been mindful of the classic tradition. Instead of bringing nature within the fold of value, the order has been reversed he physical system has been treated as the supporter and carrier of all objects having the properties which confer authority over conduct.JA word about the system of Herbert Spencer among the moderns is appropriate in this connection, as one about Lucretius would be if antiquity were the theme. The doctrine that universal evolution is the highest principle of the physical world, one in which all natural laws are brought to unity, is accompanied with the idea that the goal of evolution marks the ideal of moral and religious beliefs and endeavors. This conclusion is as surely an attempt to adjust the two elements of the problem as anything found in any idealistic system. Were there any doubt about this point, Spencer’s in- sistence on the evanescence of evil in the ongoing evolutionary process would remove it. All evils are the fruits of transitional maladjustments in the movement of evolution. The perfect adjustment of man, personal and collective, to the environment is the evolutionary term, and is one which signifies the elimina- tion of all evil, physical and moral. The ultimate triumph of justice and the union of the good of self with the good of others are identical with the working out of physical law. In objection to this or that phase of the Spencerian system it is easily forgotten that fundamentally he is occupied with the usual quest for a certainty in which a warrant of necessary knowledge is employed to establish the certainty of Good in reality. Comprehensive systems are for the moment out of fashion; and yet if cognitive certainty is possible and if it is admitted 64 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES that the justification of value lies in its being a property of the realities which are the objects of knowledge, comprehensive- ness, whether of the Hegelian or the Spencerian type, would seem to be the proper ideal of philosophy. And if one believes that the conclusions of science exhaust the scope of the universe, then certainly all moral, social and political goods must fall within them; in that case such a task as that of Spencer’s is not only legitimate but one which philosophy cannot evade without being subject to the charge of bad faith. One more illustration awaits us. Contemporary philosophy in its realistic forms shows a tendency to revert to adjustment of the cognitive realm and the realm of values by means of the method of isolation. In detail, however, the method pursued is unlike that of Kant in that it does not start from the knowing mind but rather from the objects of knowing. These, it is argued, show a radical division into the existential and the non-existential. Physical science deals with the former; mathe- matics and logic with the latter. In the former, some things, namely sense-data, are objects of infallible apprehension; while certain essences or subsistences, immaterial in nature because non-existential and non-physical, are the subjects of an equally assured cognition by reason. Uncertainty appertains only to combinations of ultimate and simple objects, combinations formed in reflective thought. As long as we stick to the self- guaranteed objects, whether of sense or of pure intellect, there is no opening for any uncertainty or any risk. In some of these realisms, intrinsic values are included among the immaterial essences of which we have infallible and immediate knowledge. Thus the scheme of cognitive certainty applies all the way through. Science, in its naturalistic sense, is true of existences; ultimate morals and logic are true of essences. Philosophy has to do with the just partitioning of the 65 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY field, and with the problems that arise from the union of ex- istences and essences. Still another conception of philosophy of a more austere character has, however, been advanced. According to this view, values are hopelessly entangled with human affections and im- pulses, and are too variable to be the objects of any kind of sure knowledge—of anything but variable opinion and guess- work. The great mistake of historic philosophy has been to admit values in any shape within the sacred enclosure of per- fect science. Philosophy is concerned only with propositions which are true in any possible world, existentially actual or not. Propositions about good and evil are too dependent upon a special form of existence, namely human beings with their peculiar traits, to find a place in the scheme of science. The only propositions which answer to the specification of pure uni- versality are logical and mathematical. These by their nature transcend existence and apply in every conceivable realm. Owing to the recent developments of mathematics, a philosophy emancipated from the contingencies of existence is now for the first time possible. This view of philosophy has been objected to on the ground that it rests on an arbitrary limitation of its subject-matter. But it may be questioned whether this restriction is not a logical development of that strain in historic philosophy which identi- fies its subject-matter with whatever is capable of taking on the form of cognitive certainty. Without committing one’s self to the subjective view of values that seems to be implied, values are so intimately connected with human affections, choices and endeavors, that there zs ground for holding that the insincere apologetic features of historic philosophies are connected with the attempt to combine a theory of the values having moral authority with a theory of ultimate Being. And a moderate amount of acquaintance with these philosophies discloses that 66 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES they have been interested in justifying values drawn from cur- rent religious faiths and moral codes, not just eternal values as such:—that they have often used the concept of universal and intrinsic values to cover those which, if not parochial, were at least exponents of temporal social conditions. The limitation of philosophy to propositions about what is logically possible eliminates all special physical propositions as well as all matters of morals, art and religion. In its chaste austerity it seems to fulfill the demand for cognitive certainty as no other conception of philosophy can do. Whether one ac- cepts or rejects it, there is provided by it an explicit way in which to raise a question. Because of the sharpness of its delimitation of the office of philosophy, it elicits clearly the problem of the idea to be entertained of that office. For with the restriction that is made there remains over and untouched a problem of the greatest possible human significance. What is the bearing of our existential knowledge at any time, the most dependable knowledge afforded by inquiry, upon our judgments and beliefs about the ends and means which are to direct our conduct? What does knowledge indicate about the authoritative guidance of our affections, desires and affections, our plans and policies? Unless knowledge gives some regulation, the only alternative is to fall back on custom, external pressure and the free play of impulse. There is then need of some theory on this matter. If we are forbidden to call this theory philosophy by the self- denying ordinance which restricts it to formal logic, need for the theory under some other name remains. There is a fatal ambiguity in the conception of philosophy as a purely theoretical or intellectual subject. The ambiguity lies in the fact that the conception is used to cover both the attitude of the inquirer, the thinker, and the character of the subject-matter dealt with. The engineer, the physician, the moralist deal with a subject-matter which is practical; one, that 67 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY is, which concerns things to be done and the way of doing them. But as far as personal disposition and purpose is con- cerned, their inquiries are intellectual and cognitive. These men set out to find out certain things; in order to find them out, there has to be a purgation of personal desire and preference, and a willingness to subordinate them to the lead of the subject- matter inquired into. The mind must be purified as far as is humanly possible of bias and of that favoritism for one kind of conclusion rather than another which distorts observation and introduces an extraneous factor into reflection. Except, then, on the premise that the subject-matter of philosophy is fixed properties of antecedent Being, the fact that it is an intellectual pursuit signifies nothing beyond the fact that those who engage in it should respect the canons of fairness, impartiality, of internal consistency and external evi- dence. It carries no implication with it—except on the basis of a prior assumption—save that of intellectual honesty. Only upon yi of the adage that whoso drives fat oxen must himself be-fat;can it be urged that logical austerity of personal attitude and procedure demands that the subject-matter dealt with must be made lean by stripping it of all that is human concern. To say that the object of philosophy is truth is to make a moral statement which applies to every inquiry. It implies nothing as to the kind of truth which is to be as- certained, whether it be of a purely theoretical nature, of a practical character, or whether it concerns the bearing of one upon the other. To assert that contemplation of truth for its own sake is the highest ideal is to make a judgment concerning authoritative value. To employ this judgment as a means of determining the office of philosophy is to violate the canon that inquiry should follow the lead of subject-matter. It is fair, then, to conclude that the question of the rela- tions of theory and practice to each other, and of philosophy 68 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES to both of them, has often been compromised by failure to maintain the distinction between the theoretical interest which is another name for intellectual candor and the theoretical interest which defines the nature of subject-matter. Over and above this fact, there is reason to suppose that much of the impatience with the suggestion of the practical in connection with philosophy is due to the habit of associating “practical” with affairs of narrow personal concern. The significance of the idea cannot be thus sheared down without an elimination of intellectual regard for the values which are to have authority over our desires and purposes and thus over our entire conduct. It would seem as if only the cynical sceptic would willingly take such a stand. The discussion has indulged in an excursion from the theme of the problem of modern philosophies. But it is relevant to our main topic if it serves to make clear the fundamental ground for the disparaging view held of practical activity. Depreciation is warranted on the basis of two premises: first, namely, that the object of knowledge is some form of ultimate Being which is antecedent to reflective inquiry and independent of it; secondly, that this antecedent Being has among its defining characteristics those properties which alone have authority over the formation of our judgments of value— that is, of the ends and purposes which should control conduct in all fields—intellectual, social, moral, religious, esthetic. Given these premises—and only if they are accepted—it fol- lows that philosophy has for its sole office the cognition of this Being and its essential properties. I can understand that the tenor of my discussion may have aroused a certain impatience among those familiar with current treatment of politics, morals and art. It will be asked: Where is there any evidence that this treatment is controlled by regard for antecedently fixed qualifications of what is taken to be ulti- 69 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY mately real? It cannot be denied, and I have no interest in denying, that the vast bulk of critical discussion of such matters is conducted on quite different grounds, with hardly even a side glance at any standards which flow from any philosophy of ultimate grounds. This admission causes two important con- siderations to stand out the clearer. Traditional religion does refer all ultimate authoritative norms to the highest reality, the nature of God; and failure on the part of those professedly accepting this religion to carry this reference over to concrete criticism and judgment in special fields of morals, politics and art, is only an evidence of the confusion in. which modern thought is entangled. It is this fact which gives the strict ad- herents to old beliefs, such as those trained in the Catholic faith, an intellectual advantage over “liberals.” For the latter have no philosophy adequate for their undertakings and com- mitments. This consideration brings us to the second point. The failure to employ standards derived from true Being in the formation of beliefs and judgments in concrete fields is proof of an isola- tion from contemporary life that is forced upon philosophy by its adherence to the two principles which are basic in the classic tradition. In the middle ages there was no such isolation. Philosophy and the conduct of life were associated intimately with one another ; there was genuine correspondence. The out- come is not fortunate for philosophy; it signifies that its subject- matter is more and more derived from the problems and con- clusions of its own past history; that it is aloof from the problems of the culture in which philosophers live. But the situation has a still more unfortunate phase. For it signifies intellectual confusion, practically chaos, in respect to the criteria and principles which are employed in framing judgments and reaching conclusions upon things of most vital importance. It signifies the absence of intellectual authority. 70 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES Old beliefs have dissolved as far as definite operative hold upon the regulation of criticism and the formation of plans and policies, working ideals and ends, is concerned. And there is nothing else to take their place. When I say “authority” I do not mean a fixed set of doc- trines by which to settle mechanically problems as they arise. Such authority is dogmatic, not intellectual. I mean _mean_ methods congruous with those used in scientific inquiry and adopting their conclusions; methods to be used in directing criticism and in forming the ends and purposes that are acted upon. \ purposes that are acted upon. We have obtained in constantly accelerated measure in the last few centuries a large amount of sound beliefs regarding the world in which we live; we have ascertained much that is new and striking about life and man. On the other hand, men have de- sires and affections, hopes and fears, purposes and intentions which influence the most important actions performed. These need intellectual directiong Why has modern philosophy con- tributed so little to bring about an integration between what we know about the world and the intelligent direction of what we do?\The purport of this chapter is to show that the cause resides in unwillingness to surrender two ideas formulated in conditions which both intellectually and practically were very different from those in which we now live. These two ideas, to repeat, are that knowledge is concerned with disclosure of the characteristics of antecedent existences and essences, and that the properties of value found therein provide the authoritative standards for the conduct of life. Both of these traits are due to quest for certainty by cogni- tive means which exclude practical activity—namely, one which effects actual and concrete modifications in existence. Practical activity suffers from a double discrediting because of the perpetuation of these two features of tradition. It is a mere external follower upon knowledge, having no part in its de- 71 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY termination. Instead of evolving its own standards and ends in its own developing processes, it is supposed to conform to what is fixed in the antecedent structure of things. Herein we locate the source of that internal division which was said to characterize modern philosophic thought. It accepts the con- clusions of scientific inquiry without remaking the conceptions of mind, knowledge and the character of the object of knowl- edge that are involved in the methods by which these con- clusions are reached. The chapters of which this is the concluding portion are introductory. They have tried to make clear a problem and the reasons why it is a problem. If, as has been intimated, the problem arises from continued adherence to certain conceptions framed centuries ago and then embodied in the entire western tradition, the problem is artificial in as far as it would not arise from reflection upon actual conditions of science and life. The next task is accordingly to elucidate the reconstructions of tradition which are involved in the actual procedure and re- sults of knowing, as this is exemplified in physical inquiry. The latter is taken as the type and pattern of knowing since it is the most perfected of all branches of intellectual inquiry. We shall see that for a long time it also was influenced by the survival of the traditional conceptions of knowledge and its supposed relationship to properties of antecedent existence, while in our own time it has finally emancipated itself and ar- rived at a consciousness of the principles contained in its own method. Having discovered what knowledge means in its own terms, that is, in those of the conduct of knowing as a going concern, we shall be ready to appreciate the great transforma- tion that is demanded in the older notions of mind and knowl- edge. Particularly we shall see how completely the separation of knowing and doing from one another has broken down. The conclusion of this part of the discussion will be that stan- 72 CONFLICT OF AUTHORITIES dards and tests of validity are found in the consequences of overt activity, not in what is fixed prior to it and independently of it. This conclusion will lead us to the final point, the trans- formation that is required in the conception of the values which have authority over conduct. ade 73 CHAPTER sv THE ART OF ACCEPTANCE AND Tie ARYT OF CONTROL THERE was A time when “art” and “science” were virtually equivalent terms. There is a reminiscence of this period in university organization in the phrase “faculty of arts and sciences.” A distinction was drawn between the “mechanical” and the “liberal” arts. In part, this distinction was between industrial arts and social arts, those concerned with things and those concerned directly with persons. Grammar and rhetoric, for example, in dealing with speech, the interpretation of liter- ature and the arts of persuasion, were higher than blacksmith- ing and carpentry. The mechanical arts dealt with things which were merely means; the liberal arts dealt with affairs that were ends, things having a final and intrinsic worth. The obviousness of the distinction was reénforced by social causes. Mechanics were concerned with mechanical arts; they were lower in the social scale. The school in which their arts were learned was the school of practice: apprenticeship to those who had already mastered the craft and mystery. Apprentices literally “learned by doing,” and “doing” was routine repeti- tion and imitation of the acts of others, until personal skill was acquired. The liberal arts were studied by those who were to be in some position of authority, occupied with some exercise of social rule. Such persons had the material means that afforded leisure, and were to engage in callings that had es- pecial honor and prestige. Moreover, they learned not by me- chanical repetition and bodily practice in manipulation of ma- 74 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL terials and tools, but “intellectually,” through a kind of study which involved mind, not body. The situation is not recalled as if it had a merely historical significance. It describes in large measure a state of affairs that exists to-day. The distinction between “learned professions” and the occupations of the shop and factory, with correspond- ing differences of social status, of educational preparation, of concern chiefly with material things or with persons and social relations, is too familiar to call for recourse to past history. The chief difference in the present situation is due to the rise of technological industry and of (pecuniary stonomy, at the expense of the inherited status of the eman,” the owner of large estates in land. So our allusion is pertinent not to history, but to still existing conditions that_are influential in creating and maintaining the division between theory and n addition to this distinction between higher and lower arts, there always hovered in the background a distinction be- tween all arts and “science” in the true and ultimate sense of the words. The liberal arts involved much more of knowledge and of theoretical study, of use of “mind,” than did the me- chanical, But in their ultimate import they were still connected with art, with doing, although with a mode of practice held in higher esteem. They remained within the limits of experience, although of an experience having a kind of value not found in the baser arts. The philosophic tradition, as for example it is formulated by Aristotle, ranked social arts lower than pure intellectual inquiry, than knowledge as something not to be put to any use, even a social and moral one. It is conceivable that historically this point of view might have remained a mere laudation of its own calling on the part of a small intel- lectual class. But, as we have already noted, in the expansion of the Church as a dominant power in Europe, religion affili- 75 me tes THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY ated this philosophic conception to itself. Theology was re- garded as “science” in a peculiar, a unique, sense, for it alone was knowledge of supreme and ultimate Being. And the Church had a direct influence over the hearts and conduct, the beliefs and judgments, of men that a secluded intellectual class could never win. As the guardians and dispensers of the truths and sacraments that determined the eternal destiny, the eternal happiness or misery of the soul, they effected the em- bodiment of ideas originating in philosophy in the culture of Christendom. In consequence, differences and distinctions characteristic of actual social life received the sanction not merely of the rational formulation of a few philosophic thinkers but of that power which had the highest authority and influence in the lives of men. For this reason, the survey that has been made of the classic philosophic statement of the dualism between theory and practice, between mind and body, between reason and experience (always thought of in terms of sense and the body) is much more than a piece of historic information. For in spite of enormous extension of secular interests and of natural science, of expansion of practical arts and occupations, of the almost frantic domination of present life by concern for definite material interests and the organization of society by forces fundamentally economic, there is no widely held phi- losophy of life which replaces the traditional classic one as that was absorbed and modified by the Christian faith. ‘Traditional philosophy thus has ¥ treble. Advantage. It has behind it the multitude of imaginative and emotional associa- tions and appeals that cluster about any tradition which has for long centuries been embodied in a dominant institution; they continue to influence, unconsciously, the minds of those who no longer give intellectual assent to the tenets on which the tradition intellectually rests. It has, secondly, the backing 76 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL of the persistence of the social conditions out of which the formulation of the dualism between theory and practice origi- nally grew—the familiar grading of activities from the servile and mechanical to the liberal, the free and socially esteemed. In addition, there is the enforced recognition of the peril and frustration in the actual world of meanings and goods most prized, a matter which makes men ready to listen to the story of a higher realm in which these values are eternally safe. In the third place, and finally, there is the negative counter- part of these positive facts. Conditions and forces that dominate in actual fact the modern world have not attained any coherent intellectual expression of themselves. We live, as is so often remarked, in a state of divided allegiance. In outward activities and current enjoyments, we are frenetically absorbed in mun- dane affairs in ways which, if they were formulated for in- tellectual acceptance, would be repudiated as low and un- worthy. We give our emotional and theoretical assent to prin- ciples and creeds which are no longer actively operative in life. We have retained enough of the older tradition to recognize that a philosophy which formulated what, on the whole and in the mass, we are most concerned with, would be intolerably materialistic in character. On the other hand, we are not pre- pared, either intellectually or morally, to frame such a philoso- phy of the interests and activities that actually dominate our lives as would elevate them to a plane of truly liberal and humane significance. We are unable to show that the ideals, values and meanings which the philosophy we nominally hold places in another world, are capable of characterizing in a concrete form, with some measure of security, the world in which we live, that of our actual experience. On this account any sincere empirical philosophy that holds to the possibility of the latter alternative must be prophetic rather than descriptive. It can offer hypotheses rather than re- Td THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY port of facts adequately in existence. It must support these hypotheses by argument, rather than by appeal to matters clearly within the range of easy observation. It is speculative in that it deals with “futures.” Candor demands that these con- siderations be frankly set forth. But there is also another side to the matter. There is a distinction between hypotheses generated in that seclusion from observable fact which renders them fantasies, and hypotheses that are projections of the possi- bilities of facts already in existence and capable of report. There is a difference between the imaginative speculations that recognize no law except their own dialectic consistency, and those which rest on an observable movement of events, and which foresee these events carried to a limit by the force of their own movement. There is a difference between support by argument from arbitrarily assumed premises, and an argument which sets forth the implications of propositions resting upon facts already vitally significant. The groundwork of fact that is selected for especial ex- amination and description in the hypothesis which is to be set forth is the procedure of present scientific inquiry, in those matters that are most fully subject to intellectual control— namely, the physical sciences. The state of inquiry in them is an observable fact, not a speculation nor a matter of opinion and argument:-Fhe-setection of this field of fact rather than some other as that from which to project a hypothesis re- garding a future possible experience in which experience will itself provide the values, meanings and standards now sought in some transcendent world, has both theoretical and practical justification. From the point of view of technical philosophy, the nature of knowledge has always been the foundation and point of departure for philosophies that have separated knowing from doing and making, and that in conse- quence have elevated the objects of knowledge, as measures of 78 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL genuine reality, above experiences of objects had by the way of affection and practical action. If, accordingly, it can be shown that the actual procedures by which the most authentic and de- pendable knowledge is attained have completely surrendered the separation of knowing and doing; if it can be shown that overtly executed operations of interaction are requisite to obtain the knowledge called scientific, the chief fortress of the classic philosophical tradition crumbles into dust. With this destruction disappears also the reason for which some objects, as fixed in themselves, out of and above the course of human experience and its consequences, have been set in opposition to the temporal and concrete world in which we live. The practical reason for selecting such a technical matter as the method of physical science is the fact that the application of natural science, through the medium of inventions and technologies, is the finally controlling and characteristic fact of modern life. That western civilization is increasingly in- dustrial in character is a commonplace; it should be an equally familiar fact that this industrialization is the direct fruit of the growth of the experimental method of knowing. The effects of this industrialization in politics, social arrangements, communication and intercourse, in work and play, in the de- termination of the locus of influence, power and prestige, are characteristic marks of present experience in the concrete. They are the ultimate source of that waning of the effective influence of older beliefs that has been alluded to. They also provide the reason why a philosophy which merely reflected and re- ported the chief features of the existing situation as if they were final, without regard to what they may become, would be so repulsively materialistic. Both the positive fact that our actual life is more and more determined by the results of physical science, and the negative fact that these results are so largely an obstacle to framing a philosophy consonant with oo THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY present experience—so influential in inducing men to hold on to elements of the older tradition—are punctnarares the proce SAIN NW ts lence as Me SOT our “~There will be little time and opportunity for discussion of the problem in its immediately practical form—the potential significance of that industrial society which has emerged in consequence of the conclusions and methods of physical knowl- edge. But it may be pointed out that, in principle, it signifies simply that the results of intelligence, instead of remaining aloof and secluded from practice, are embodied in influential ways in the activities and experience which actually obtains. Say what we please in derogation of “applied science,” in principle this is what the latter signifies. And there are few persons, I imagine, who would wittingly proclaim that incarna- tion of knowledge and understanding in the concrete experi- ences of life is anything but a good. Derogation on principle of application of knowledge is, in itself, merely an expression of the old tradition of the inherent superiority of knowledge to practice, of reason to experience. There is a genuine and extremely serious problem in con- nection with the application of science in life. But it is a practi- cal, not theoretical, one. That is to say, it concerns the economic and legal organization of society in consequence of which the knowledge which regulates activity is so much the monopoly of the few, and is used by them in behalf of private and class interests and not for general and shared use. The problem concerns the possible transformation of social conditions with respect to their economic and pecuniary basis. This problem time and space will not permit me to consider. But the pe- cuniarily economic phase of society is something radically different from industrialization, and from the inherent conse- quences of technology in current life. To identify the two 80 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL affairs breeds only confusion. It must also be noted that this is a question which has of itself nothing to do with the matter of the relations of theory and practice, of knowledge and its application in doing and making. The practical and social problem is one of effecting a more general equitable distribu- tion of the elements of understanding and knowledge in con- nection with work done, activities undertaken, and a conse- quent freer and more generously shared participation in their results. Before engagi ing in consideration of the significance of the method of science for formation ion of the theory of knowledge and of mind, we shall take > up § some "some general pots, THESE ae all conneéctedsat-bottom, with the contrast between the idea of experience framed when arts were mainly routine, skills ac- quired by mere exercise and practice, and the idea of experi- ence appropriate when arts have become experimental: or, put briefly, between experience as empirical and as experi- mental, “Experience” once meant the results accumulated in memory of a variety of past doings and undergoings that were had without control by insight, when the net accumulation was found to be practically available in dealing with present situations. Both the original perceptions and uses and the appli- cation of their outcome in present doings were accidental—that is, neither was determined by an understanding of the relations of cause and effect, of means and consequences, involved. In that sense they were non-rational, non-scientific, A typical illustration is a bridge builder who constructs simply on the basis of what has been done and what happened in the past, ' without reference to knowledge of strains and stresses, or in general of physical relationships actually involved; or the art of medicine, as far as it rests simply upon the accidents of remedial measures used in the past without knowledge of why some worked and others did not. A measure of skill results, 81 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY but it is the fruit of cut and dried methods, of trial and error— in short it is “empirical.” | The disparaging notion of experience framed under such conditions is an honest report of actual conditions; philosophers in setting experience down as inherently inferior to rational science were truthful. What they added was another matter. It was a statement that this inferiority was inherently connected with the body, with the senses, with material things, with the uncertainly changing as over against the certain because immut- able. Unfortunately their theories in explanation of the defects of experience persisted and became classic after experience it- self, in some of its forms, had become experimental in the sense of being directed by understanding of conditions and their consequences, I'wo points are especially significant with refer- ence to the split thus produced between the traditional theory of experience and that which results from noting its experimental character. In the traditional theory, which still is the prevailing one, there were alleged to exist inherent defects in perception and observation as means of knowledge, in reference to the subject- matter they furnish. This material, in the older notion, is in- herently so particular, so contingent and variable, that by no possible means can it contribute to knowledge; i can result only in opinion, mere belief. But in modern science, there are only practical defects in the senses, certain limitations of vision, for example, that have to be corrected and supplemented by various devices, such as the use of the lens. Every insufficiency of observation is an instigation to invent some new instrument which will make good the defect, or it is a stimulus to devising indirect means, such as mathematical calculations, by which the limitations of sense will be circumvented. The counterpart of this change is one in the conception of thought and its relation to knowing. It was earlier assumed that higher knowledge must 82 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL be supplied by pure thought; pure because apart from experi- remte OMEPONE te BO ence, since the latter involves the senses. Now, it is taken for granted that thought, while indispensable to knowledge of atural existence, can never in itself provide that knowledge. Ybservation is indispensable both to provide authentic ma- terials to work upon and to test and verify the conclusions reached by theoretical considerations. JA specified kind of ex- perience is indispensable to science instead of all experience setting a limit to the possibility of true science. There is an objective counterpart of this shift. In the older theory, sense and experience were barriers to true science be- cause they are implicated in natural change. Their appropriate and inevitable subject-matter was variable and changing things. Knowledge in its full and valid sense is possible only of the immutable, the fixed; that alone answers the quest for cer- tainty.) With regard to changing things, only surmise and opinion are possible, just as practically these are the source of peril. To a scientific man, in terms of what he does in in- quiry, the notion of a natural science which should turn its back upon the changes of things, upon events, is simply incom- prehensible. What he is interested in knowing, in understand- ing, are precisely the changes that go on; they set his problems, and problems are solved when changes are interconnected with one another. Constants and relative invariants figure, but they are relations between changes, not the constituents of a higher realm of Being. With this modification with respect to the object comes one in the structure and content of “experience.” Instead of there being a fixed difference between it and some- thing higher—rational thought—there is a difference between two kinds of experience; one which is occupied with uncon- trolled change and one concerned with directed and regulated change. And this difference, while fundamentally important, does not mark a fixed division. Changes of the first type are 83 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY something to be brought under control by means of action directed by understanding of relationships~ aun the old scheme, knowledge, as science, signified pre- cisely and exclusively turning away from change to the change- less. In the new experimental science, knowledge is obtained in exactly the opposite way, namely, through deliberate institu- tion of a definite and specified course of change/T'he method of physical inquiry is to introduce some change in order to see what other change ensues; the correlation between these changes, when measured by a series of operations, constitutes the definite and desired object of knowledge. There are two degrees of control of change which differ practically but are alike in principle. In astronomy, for example, we cannot intro- duce variation into remote heavenly bodies. But we can de- liberately alter the conditions under which we observe them, which is the same thing in principle of logical procedure. By special instruments, the use of lens and prism, by telescopes, spectroscopes, interferometers, etc., we modify observed data. Observations are taken from widely different points in space and at successive times. By such means interconnected varia- tions are observed. In physical and chemical matters closer at hand and capable of more direct manipulation, changes intro- duced affect the things under inquiry. Appliances and re-agents for bringing about variations in the things studied are em- ployed. The progress of inquiry is identical with advance in the invention and construction of physical instrumentalities for producing, registering and measuring changes. Moreover, there is no difference in logical principle be- tween the method of science and the method pursued in tech- nologies. The difference is practical; in the scale of operations conducted; in the lesser degree of control through isolation of conditions operative, and especially in the purpose for the sake of which regulated control of modifications of natural 84 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL existences and energies is undertaken; especially, since the domi- nant motive of large scale regulation of the course of change is material comfort or pecuniary gain. But the technique of modern industry, in commerce, communication, transportation and all the appliances of light, heat and electricity, is the fruit of the modern application of science. And this so-called “application” signifies that the same kind of intentional intro- duction and management of changes which takes place in the laboratory is induced in the factory, the railway and the power house, The central and outstanding fact is that the change in the method of knowing, due to the scientific revolution begun in _» . the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, has been accompanied — by a revolution in the attitude of man toward natural occur- rences and their interactions,» This transformation means, as was intimated earlier, a complete reversal in the traditional relationship of knowledge and action. Science advances by adopting the instruments and doings of directed practice, and the knowledge thus gained becomes a means of the develop- ment of arts which bring nature still further into actual and potential service of human purposes and valuations. The as- tonishing thing is that in the face of this change wrought in civilization, there still persist the notions about mind and its organs of knowing, together with the inferiority of practice to intellect, which developed in antiquity as the report of a totally different situation. The hold which older conceptions have gained over the minds of thinkers, the sway of inertia in habits of philosophic thought, can be most readily judged by turning to books on epistemology and to discussions of problems connected with the theory of knowledge published in the philosophical periodicals. Articles on logical method will be found which reflect the pro- cedures of actual knowing, that is of the practice of scientific 85 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY inquiry. But logic is then usually treated as “mere” method- ology, having little (probably nothing would be nearer the mark) to do with the theory of knowledge. The latter is dis- cussed in terms of conceptions about mind and its organs; these conceptions are supposed to be capable of adequate for- mation apart from observation of what goes on when men engage in successful inquiry. Of late, the main problem in such discussions is to frame a theory of “consciousness” which shall explain knowing, as if consciousness were either a fact whose meaning is self-evident, or something less obscure in content and more observable than are the objective and public procedures of scientific investigation. This type of discussion persists; it is, in current conception, zhe theory of knowledge, the natural and inevitable way in which to discuss its basic problems! Volumes could not say more for the persistence of traditional ideas. The import of even a rudimentary dis- cussion of actual experimental method can hardly be gath- ered, then, without bearing in mind its significance as a con- trast effect. | While the traits of experimental inquiry are familiar, so little use has been of them in formulating a theory of knowl- edge and of mind in relation to nature that a somewhat ex- plicit statement of well known facts is excusable. They exhibit three outstanding characteristics. The first is the obvious one that all experimentation involves overt doing, the making of de- finite changes in the environment or in our relation to it. The second is that experiment is not a random activity but is directed by ideas which have to meet the conditions set by the need of the problem inducing the active inquiry. The third and con- cluding feature, in which the other two receive their full measure of meaning, is that the outcome of the directed activity is the construction of a new empirical situation in which objects are differently related to one another, and such that the conse- 86 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL quences of directed operations form the objects that have the property of being known. The rudimentary prototype of experimental doing for the sake of knowing is found in ordinary procedures. When we are trying to make out the nature of a confused and unfamiliar object, we perform various acts with a view to establishing a new relationship to it, such as will bring to light qualities which will aid in understanding it. We turn it over, bring it into a better light, rattle and shake it, thump, push and press it, and so on. The object as it is experienced prior to the introduction of these changes baffles us; the intent of these acts is to make changes which will elicit some previously unperceived qualities, and by varying conditions of perception shake loose some prop- erty which as it stands blinds or misleads us. While such experimentations, together with a kind of ex- perimental playing with things just to see what will happen, are the chief source of the everyday non-scientific store of in- formation about things around us, forming the bulk of “common-sense” knowledge, the limitations of the mode of procedure are so evident as to require no expositiong The im- portant thing in the history of modern knowing is the rein- forcement of these active doings by means of instruments, appliances and apparatus devised for the purposes of disclosing relations not otherwise apparent, together with, as far as overt action is concerned, the development of elaborate techniques for the introduction of a much greater range of variations— that is, a systematic variation of conditions so as to produce a corresponding series of changes in the thing under investiga- ton, Among these operations should be included, of course, those which give a permanent register of what is observed and the instrumentalities of exact measurement by means of which changes are correlated with one another. These matters are so familiar that their full import for 87 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY the theory of knowing readily escapes notice. Hence the need of comparing this kind of knowledge of natural existences with that obtaining before the rise of the experimental method. The striking difference is, of course, the dependence placed upon doing, doing of a physical and overt sort. Ancient science, that is, what passed as science, would have thought it a kind of treason to reason as the organ of knowing to subordinate it to bodily activity on material things, helped out with tools which are also material. It would have seemed like admitting the superiority of matter to rational mind, an admission which from its standpoint was contradictory to the possibility of knowledge. With this fundamental change goes another, that in the attitude taken toward the material of direct sense-perception. No noti be further away from the fact than the some- what (sedulously )cultivated idea that the difference between ancient and modern science is that the former had no respect for perception and relied exclusively upon speculation. In fact, the Greeks were keenly sensitive to natural objects and were keen observers. The trouble lay not in substitution of theoriz- ing from the outset for the material of perception, but in that they took the latter “‘as is”; they made no attempt to modify it radically before undertaking thinking and theorizing about it. As far as observation unaided by artificial appliances and means for deliberate variation of observed material went, the Greeks went far. Their disrespect for sensibly observed material concerned only its form. For it had to be brought under logical forms supplied by rational thought. The fact that the material was not exclusively logical, or such as to satisfy the requirements of rational form, made the resulting knowledge less scientific than that of pure mathematics, logic and metaphysics occupied with eternal Being. But as far as science extended, it dealt with 88 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL the material of sense-perception as it directly offered itself to a keen and alert observer. In consequence, the material of Greek natural science is much closer to “common sense”? ma- terial than are the results of contemporary science. One can read the surviving statements of it without any more technical preparation than say a knowledge of Euclidean geometry, while no one can follow understandingly the reports of most modern investigations in physics without a highly technical preparatory education. One reason the atomic theory pro- pounded in antiquity made so little headway is that it did not agree with the results of ordinary observation. For this pre- sented objects clothed with rich qualities and falling into kinds or species that were themselves marked by qualitative, rather than by merely quantitative and spatial, differences. In antiquity it was the atomic theory which was purely speculative and “‘de- ductive” in character. These statements would be misunderstood if they were taken to imply an allegation that in ancient science sense gives knowledge, while modern science excludes the material of sense; such an idea inverts the facts. But ancient science accepted the material of sense-material on its face, and then organized it, as it naturally and originally stood, by operations of logical definition, classification into species and syllogistic subsumption. Men either had no instruments and appliances for modifying the ordinary objects of observation, for analyz- ing them into their elements and giving them new forms and arrangements, or they failed to use those which they had. Thus in content, or subject-matter, the conclusions of Greek science (which persisted till the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century), were much closer to the objects of everyday experi- ence than are the objects of present scientific thought. It is not meant that the Greeks had more respect for the function of per- ception through the senses than has modern science, but that, 89 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY judged from present practice, they had altogether too much respect for the material of direct, unanalyzed sense-perception. They were aware of its defects from the standpoint of knowledge. But they supposed that they could correct these defects and supplement their lack by purely logical or “ra- tional” means. They supposed that thought could take the ma- terial supplied by ordinary perception, eliminate varying and hence contingent qualities, and thus finally reach the fixed and immutable form which makes particulars have the character they have; define this form as the essence or true reality of the particular things in question, and then gather a group of per- ceived objects into a species which is as eternal as its particular exemplifications are perishable. The passage from ordinary perception to scientific knowledge did not therefore demand the introduction of actual, overt and observed changes into the material of sense perception. Modern science, with its changes in the subject-matter of direct perception effected by the use of apparatus, gets away not from observed material as such, but from the qualitative characteristics of things as they are originally and “naturally” observed. It may thus be fairly asserted that the “categories” of Greek description and explanation of natural phenomena were esthetic in character; for perception of the esthetic sort is interested in things in their immediate qualitative traits. The logical features they depended upon to confer scientific form upon the material of observation were harmony, proportion or measure, symmetry: these constitute the “logos” that renders phenomena capable of report in rational discourse. In virtue of these properties, superimposed upon phenomena but thought to be elicited from them, natural objects are knowable. Thus the Greeks employed thinking not as a means of changing given objects of observation so as to get at the conditions and effects of their occurrence, but to impose upon them certain 90 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL static properties not found in them in their changeable occur- rence. The essence of the static properties conferred upon them was harmony of form and pattern. Craftsmen, architects, sculptors, gymnasts, poets had taken raw material and con- verted it into finished forms marked by symmetry and pro- portion; they accomplished this task without the prior dis- integrative reduction which characterizes modern making in the factory. Greek thinkers performed a like task for nature as a whole. Instead, however, of employing the material tools of the crafts, they depended upon thought alone. They bor- rowed the form provided them in Greek art in abstraction from its material appliances. They aimed at constructing out of nature, as observed, an artistic whole for the eye of the soul to behold. Thus for science nature was a cosmos. It was com- posed, but it was not a composite of elements. That is, it was a qualitative whole, a whole as is a drama, a statue or a temple, in virtue of a pervading and dominant qualitative unity; it was not an aggregate of homogenous units externally arranged in different modes. Design was the form and pattern in- trinsically characteristic of things in their fixed kinds, not some- thing first formed in a designing mind and then imposed from without. In his Creative Evolution, Bergson remarks that to the Greek mind that reality which is the object of the truest knowl- edge is found in some privileged moment when a process of change attains its climactic apogee. The Ideas of Plato and the Forms of Aristotle, as he says, may be compared in their rela- tion to particular things to the horses of the Parthenon frieze in relation to the casual movements of horses. The essential movement which gives and defines the character of the horse is summed up in the eternal moment of a static position and form. To see, to grasp, that culminating and defining form, and by grasping to possess and enjoy it, is to know. QI » THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY Thi Bees) of Bergson illustrates the conception of the essentially“artistic character possessed for Greek science by the object of knowledge. It is borne out by the details of Greek science. I know of no one thing more significant for an under- standing of Greek science than Aristotle’s treatment of quantity as an accident, that is, as something which can vary within limits (set by the inherent essence and measure, logos) of a thing without affecting its nature. When we think of the Cartesian definition of quantity as the essence of matter, we appreciate that an intellectual revolution has taken place: a radical change in point of view and not just the product of more, and more accurately stated, information, but a change involving surrender of the esthetic character of the object. Contrast the place occupied in modern science by relations with the Aristotelian illustrations of their nature—namely, distinc- tions of more and less, greater and smaller, etc. For the point of Aristotle’s treatment is that relations, like quantity, are indifferent to the essence or nature of the object, and hence are of no final account for scientific knowledge. This conception is thoroughly appropriate to an esthetic point of view, wherein that which is internally complete and self-sufficing is the all- important consideration. The addiction of Pythagorean-Platonism.to number and geometry might seem to contradict what has been said. But it is one of the exceptions that proves the rule. For geometry and number in this scheme were means of ordering natural phe- nomena as they are directly observed. They were principles of measure, symmetry and allotment that satisfied canons essen- tially esthetic. Science had to wait almost two thousand years for mathematics to become an instrument of analysis, of reso- lution into elements for the sake of recomposition, through equations and other functions. I pass by the evidence of the qualitative character of Greek 92 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL science afforded by the central position of kinds or species in Peripatetic science. The instance is too obvious. More instruc- tive is the purely qualitative treatment of movements, es- pecially as this is the matter that gives the clue to the revolu- tion wrought by Galileo. Movement was a term covering all sorts of qualitative alterations, such as warm things becoming cold, growth from embryo to adult form, etc. It was never conceived of as merely motion, i.e., change of position in a homogeneous space. When we speak of a musical movement, or a political movement, we come close to the sense attached to the idea in ancient science: a series of changes tending to complete or perfect a qualitative whole and fulfill an end. Movement instead of continuing indefinitely spent itself; it tended inherently toward its own cessation, toward rest. The problem was not what external forces bring the arrow to a state of relative rest but what external forces, currents of air, etc., keep it moving and prevent its speedier attainment of its own natural goal, rest. Cessation of movement is either ex- haustion, a kind of fatigue, or it marks the culmination of in- trinsic proper being or essence. The heavenly bodies, just be- cause they are heavenly, and therefore quasi-divine, are un- wearied, never tiring, and so keep up their ceaseless round. For rest when it meant fulfillment was not dead quiescence but complete and therefore unchanging movement. Only thought is completely possessed of this perfect self-activity; but the con- stant round of heavenly bodies is the nearest physical manifes- tation of the self-enclosed changeless activity of thought, which discovers nothing, learns nothing, effects nothing, but eternally revolves upon itself. The treatment of place—or rather places—is the counter- part of this qualitative diversification of movements. There is movement up from the earth, in the measure of their lightness, of those things which belong in the upper spaces; a downward 93 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY movement to the earth of those things which because of their grossness attain their end and arrive at their home only in the gross and relatively cold earth. To the intermediate regions is appropriate neither upward nor downward movement but the back and forth and wavering movement characteristic of winds and the (apparent) motions of the planets. As the cold and heavy moves down, the light and fiery, the finest material moves upward. The stars of the firmament being the most nearly divine, the most purged of the irregular and merely potential, pursue that undeviating circular course which is the nearest approach in nature to the eternal self-activity of thought, which is at once beyond nature and its culmination or “final cause.” These details are mentioned to make clear the completely qualitative character of antique science. There was no conflict with ideas about values, because the qualities belonging to objects of science are values; they are the things we enjoy and prize. Throughout nature as a qualitative whole there is a hierarchy of forms from those of lower value to those of higher. The revolution in science effectively initiated by Galileo consisted precisely in the abolition of qualities as traits of scientific objects as such. From this elimination proceeded just that conflict and need of reconciliation between the scientific properties of the rea] and those which give moral authority. Therefore to apprehend what the new astronomy and physics did for human beliefs, we have to place it in its contrast with the older natura] science in which the qualities possessed by objects of scientific knowledge were precisely the same as those possessed by works of art, the properties which are one with beauty and with all that is admirable. The work of Galileo was not a development, but a revolu- tion. It marked a change from the qualitative to the quantita- tive or metric; from the heterogeneous to the homogeneous; 94 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL from intrinsic forms to relations; from esthetic harmonies to mathematical formule; from contemplative enjoyment to ac- tive manipulation and control; from rest to change; from eternal objects to temporal sequence. The idea of a two-realm scheme persisted for moral and religious purposes; it vanished for purposes of natural science. The higher realm which had been the object of true science became the exclusive habitat of objects connected with values that in their relation to man furnish the norm and end of human destiny. The lower realm of change which had been the subject of opinion and practice be- came the sole and only object of natural science. The realm in which opinion held sway was no longer a genuine although inferior portion of objective being. It was a strictly human product, due to ignorance and error. Such was the philosophy which, because of the new science, replaced the old metaphysics. But—and this “but” is of fundamental importance—in spite of the revolution, the old conceptions of knowledge as related to an antecedent reality and of moral regulation as derived from properties of this reality, persisted. Neither the scientific nor the philosophic change came at once, even after experimental inquiry was initiated. In fact as we shall see later, philosophy proceeded conservatively by compromise and accommodation, and was read into the new science, so that not till our own generation did science free itself from some basic factors of the older conception of nature. Much of the scientific revolution was implicit, however, in the conclusions which Galileo drew from his two most famous experiments, The one with falling bodies at the tower of Pisa destroyed the old distinction of intrinsic qualitative differences of gravity and levity, and thus gave an enormous shock to the qualitative explanatory principles of science. It thus tended to undermine the description and explanation of natural phe- nomena in terms of heterogeneous qualities. For it showed 95 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY that the immanent motion of bodies was connected with a common homogeneous property, one measured by their re- sistance to being set in motion and to having their motion ar- rested or deflected when once set in operation. This property, called inertia, was finally identified by Newton with mass, so that mass or inertia became the scientific definition or stable co-efficient of matter, in complete indifference to the qualitative differentiations of wet-dry, hot-cold, which were henceforth things to be explained by means of mass and motion, not funda- mental explanatory principles, Taken in isolation, it is conceivable that this result would have been only a shock, or at most a ferment. Not so, however, when it was connected with his experiment of balls rolling down a smooth inclined plane (of which his experiment with the pendulum was a variation), the nearest approximation he could make to observation of freely falling bodies. His purpose was to determine the relation of the measured time of falling to the measured space passed through. Observed results con- firmed the hypothesis he had previously formed, namely, that the space traversed is proportional to the square of the elapsed time. If we forget the background of Peripatetic science against which this conclusion was projected, it appears as a mathe- matical determination of acceleration, and in connection with the concept of mass, as affording a new and accurate definition of force. This result is highly important. But apart from the classic background of beliefs about nature, it would have been of the same type as important discoveries in physics to-day. In its opposition to the basic ideas of Peripatetic science, it ushered in the scientific revolution. Galileo’s conclusions were absolutely fatal to the traditional conception that all bodies in motion come naturally to rest because of their own intrinsic tendency to fulfill an inherent nature. The ingenious mind of Galileo used his results to show that if a body moving on a 96 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL horizontal plane, not subjected to the independent force of uniform gravity, were substituted for the body on an inclined plane, it would when once set in motion continue in motion indefinitely—the idea later formulated in Newton’s first law of motion. The revolution opened the way to description and ex- planation of natural phenomena on the basis of homogeneous space, time, mass and motion. Our discussion is not an account of the historic development, and details are passed over. But some of the generic results which followed must be summarily mentioned. Galileo’s conclusion did not at first affect the tra- dition that bodies at rest remained at rest. But his logic and the further use of his methods showed that that when a gross body is brought to rest, motion is transferred to its own particles and to those of the body which checked its movement. Thus heat became subject to mechanical treatment, and in the end the conversion of mechanical motion, heat, light, elec- tricity into one another without loss of energy was established. Then it was shown by Newton, following Copernicus and Huy- gens, that the movements of the planets obey the same me- chanical laws of mass and acceleration as mundane bodies. Heavenly bodies and movements were brought under the same laws as are found in terrestrial phenomena. The idea of the difference in kind between phenomena in different parts of space was abolished. All that counted for science became me- chanical properties formulated in mathematical terms:—the significance of mathematical formulation marking the possi- bility of complete equivalence or homogeneity of translation of different phenomena into one another’s terms. From the standpoint of the doctrine that the purpose of knowledge is to grasp reality and that the object of cognition and real objects are synonymous terms, there was but one con- clusion possible. This, in the words of a recent writer, was ar THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY that “the Newtonian astronomy revealed the whole heavenly realm as a dark and limitless emptiness wherein dead matter moved under the impulse or insensate forces, and thus finally destroyed the poetic dream of ages.” * The conclusion holds good, however, only under condition that the premise be held to. If and as far as the qualitative world was taken to be an object of knowledge, and not of experience in some other form than knowing, and as far as knowing was held to be the standard or sole valid mode of experiencing, the substitution of Newtonian for Greek science (the latter being but a rationalized arrangement of the quali- tatively enjoyed world of direct experience) signified that the properties that render the world one of delight, admiration and esteem, have been done away with. There is, however, another interpretation possible“A philosophy which holds that we ex- perience things as they really are apart from knowing, and that knowledge is a mode of experiencing things which facili- tates control of objects for purposes of non-cognitive experi- ences, will come to another conclusion.» § To go into this matter at this point would, however, an- ticipate later discussion. Consequently we confine comment here to the one question: Just what did the new experimental method do to the qualitative objects of ordinary experience? Forget the conclusions of Greek philosophy, put out of the mind all theories about knowlege and about reality. Take the simple direct facts: Here are the colored, resounding, fragrant, lova- ble, attractive, beautiful things of nature which we enjoy, and which we suffer when they are hateful, ugly, disgusting. Just what is the effect upon them wrought by physical science? If we consent for the time being tq’ denudeAhe mind of philosophical and metaphysical presuppositions, and take the * Barry, The Scientific Habit of Mind, New York, 1927, p. 249. I owe much more to this volume than this particular quotation. 98 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL matter in the most simple and naive way possible, I think our answer, stated in technical terms, will be that it substitutes data for objects. (It is not meant that this outcome is the whole effect of the experimental method; that as we saw at the outset is complex; but that the first effect as far as stripping away qualities is concerned is of this nature.) That Greek science operated with objects in the sense of the stars, rocks, trees, rain, warm and cold days of ordinary experience is evident enough. What is signified by saying that the first effect of experimenta- tion was to reduce these things from the status of objects to that of data may not be so clear.* By data is signified subject- matter for further interpretation; something to be thought about. Objects are finalities; they are complete, finished; they call for thought only in the way of definition, classification, logical arrangement, subsumption in syllogisms, etc. But data signify “material to serve”; they are indications, evidence, signs, clues to and of something still to be reached; they are intermediate, not ultimate; means, not finalities. In a less technical way the matter may be stated as follows: The subject-matter which had been taken as satisfying the demands of knowledge, as the material with which to frame solutions, became something which set problems. Hot and cold, wet and dry, light and heavy, instead of being self-evident mat- ters with which to explain phenomena, were things to be investi- gated; they were “effects,” not causal principles; they set question marks instead of supplying answers. The differences between the earth, the region of the planets, and the heavenly Jaher, instead of Chaat ultimate principles which could be ~used to mark off and classify things, were something to be explained and to bring under identical principles. Greek and medieval science formed an art of accepting things as they are poops Sr *For this shift from objects to data see G. H. Mead’s essay in the volume entitled Creative Intelligence, New York, 1917. 99 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY enjoyed and suffered. Modern experimental science is an art of control. ee oy ~The remarkable difference between the attitude which ac- cepts the objects of ordinary perception, use and enjoyment as final, as culminations of natural processes and that which takes them as starting points for reflection and investigation, is one which reaches far beyond the technicalities of science. It marks a revolution in the whole spirit of life, in the entire attitude taken toward whatever is found in existence. When the things which exist around us, which we touch, see, hear and taste are regarded as interrogations for which an answer must be sought (and must be sought by means of deliberate introduction of changes till they are reshaped into something different), nature as it already exists ceases to be something which must be accepted and submitted to, endured or en- joyed, just as it is. It is now something to be modified, to be intentionally controlled. It is material to act upon so as to transform it into new objects which better answer our needs. Nature as it exists at any particular time is a challenge, rather than a completion; it provides possible starting points and op- portunities rather than final ends. In short, there is a change from knowing as an esthetic enjoyment of the properties of nature regarded as a work of divine art, to knowing as a means of secular control—that is, a method of purposefully introducing changes which will alter the direction of the course of events. Nature as it exists at a given time is material for arts to be brought to bear upon it to reshape it, rather than already a finished work of art. Thus the changed attitude toward change to which reference was made has a much wider meaning than that which the new science offered as a technical pursuit. When correlations of changes are made the goal of knowledge, the fulfillment of its aim in discovery of these correlations, is equivalent to placing 100 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL in our hands an instrument of control. When one change is given, and we know with measured accuracy its connection with another change, we have the potential means of producing or averting that other event. The esthetic attitude is of necessity directed to what is already there; to what is finished, com- plete. The attitude of control looks to the future, to pro- duction. The same point is stated in another way in saying that the reduction of given objects to data for a knowing or an investi- gation still to be undertaken liberates man from subjection to the past. The scientific attitude, as an attitude of interest in change instead of interest in isolated and complete fixities, is necessarily alert for problems; every new question is an op- portunity for further experimental inquiries—for effecting more directed change. There is nothing which a scientific mind would more regret than reaching a condition in which there were no more problems. That state would be the death of science, not its perfected life. We have only to contrast this disposition with that which prevails in morals and politics to realize the difference which has already been made, as well as to appreciate how limited its development still is. For in higher practical matters we still live in dread of change and of prob- lems. Like men of olden time—with respect to natural phe- nomena—we prefer to accept and endure or to enjoy—as the case may happen to be —what is, what we find in possession of the field, and at most, to arrange it under concepts, and thus give it the form of rationality. Before the rise of experimental method, change was. simply PML aS ECT, an inevitable evil; "the world of phenomenal existence, that is of change, while an in inferior realm compared with the change- less, was nevertheless there and had to be accepted practically as it happened to occur. The wise man if he were sufficiently endowed by fortune would have as little to do with such things IOI THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY as possible, turning away from them to the rational realm. Qualitative forms and complete ends determined by nature are not amenable to human control. They are grateful when they happen to be enjoyed, but for human purposes nature means fortune, and fortune is the contrary of art. A good that happens is welcome. Goods, however, can be made secure in existence only through regulation of processes of change, a regulation dependent upon knowledge of their relations. While the abolition of fixed tendencies toward definite ends has been mourned by many as if it involved a despiritualization of na- ture, it is in fact a precondition of the projection of new ends and of the possibility of realizing them through intentional activity. Objects which are not fixed goals of nature and which have no inherent defining forms become candidates for receiving new qualities; means for serving new purposes. Until natural objects were denuded of determinate ends which were regarded as the proper outcome of the intrinsic tendency of nature’s own operations, nature could not become a plastic material of human desires and purposes. Such considerations as these are implicit in that changed attitude which by experimental analysis reduces objects to data: the aim of science becomes discovery of constant relations among changes in place of definition of objects immutable beyond the possibility of alteration. It is interested in the mechanism of occurrences instead of in final causes. In dealing _ with the proximate instead of with the ultimate, knowledge A a REE SRS ML a deats-with-the world in which we live, the world which is experienced, ‘instead of attempting through the intellect to escape to a higher realm. Experimental knowledge is a mode of doing, and like all doing takes place at a time, in a place, and under specifiable conditions in connection with a definite problem. The notion that the findings of science are a disclosure of I02 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL the inherent properties of the ultimate real, of existence at large, is a survival of the older metaphysics. It is because of injection of an irrelevant philosophy into interpretation of the conclusions of science that the latter are thought to eliminate qualities and values from nature. Thus is created the standing problem of modern philosophy:—the relation of science to the things we prize and love and which have authority in the direc- tion of conduct. The same injection, in treating the results of mathematical-mechanistic science as a definition of natural real- ity in its own intrinsic nature, accounts for the antagonism shown to naturalism, and for the feeling that it is the busi- ness of philosophy to demonstrate the being of a realm beyond nature, one not subject to the conditions which mark all natural objects. Drop the conception that knowledge is knowledge only when it is a disclosure and definition of the properties of fixed and antecedent reality; interpret the aim and test of knowing | | | by what happens in the actual procedures of scientific inquiry, | and the supposed need and problem vanish. For scientific inquiry always starts from things of the en- vironment experienced in our everyday life, with things we see, handle, use, enjoy and suffer from. This is the ordinary qualitative world. But instead of accepting the qualities and values—the ends and forms—of this world as providing the objects of knowledge, subject to their being given a certain logical arrangement, experimental inquiry treats them as of- fering a challenge to thought. They are the materials of problems not of solutions. They are to be known, rather than objects of knowledge. The_first-step—in_knowing—is..to locate the pro hich need solution. This step is per- Se qualities. These are effects; they are things zo be understood, and they are under- stood in terms of their generation. The search for “efficient causes” instead of for final causes, for extrinsic relations in- 103 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY stead of intrinsic forms, constitutes the aim of science. But the search does not signify a quest for reality in contrast with experience of the unreal and phenomenal. It signifies a search for those relations upon which the occurrence of real qualities and values depends, by means of which we can regulate their occurrence. To call existences as they are directly and quali- tatively experienced “phenomena” is not to assign to them a metaphysical status. It is to indicate that they set the problem of ascertaining the relations of interaction upon which their occurrence depends. It is unnecessary that knowledge should be concerned with existence as it is directly experienced in its concrete qualities. Direct experiencing itself takes care of that matter. What science is concerned with is the happening of these experienced things. For its purpose, therefore, they are happenings, events. Its aim is to discover the conditions and consequences of their happening. And this discovery can take place only by modify- ing the given qualities in such ways that relations become mani- fest. We shall see later that these relations constitute the proper objects of science as such. We are here concerned to emphasize the fact that elimination of the qualities of ex- perienced existence is merely an intermediate step necessary to the discovery of relations, and that when it is accomplished the scientific object becomes the means of control of occurrence of experienced things having a richer and more secure equipment of values and qualities. Only when the older theory of knowledge and metaphysics is retained, is science thought to inform us that nature in its true reality is but an interplay of masses in motion, without sound, color, or any quality of enjoyment and use. What science actually does is to show that any natural object we please may be treated in terms of relations upon which its occurrence depends, or as an event, and that by so treating it 104 ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL we are enabled to get behind, as it were, the immediate quali- ties the object of direct experience presents, and to regulate their happening, instead of having to wait for conditions be- yond our control to bring it about. Reduction of experienced objects to the form of relations, which are neutral as respects qualitative traits, is a prerequisite of ability to regulate the course of change, so that it may terminate in the occurrence of an object having desired qualities. As long, for example, as water is taken to be just the thing which we directly experience it to be, we can put it to a few direct uses, such as drinking, washing, etc. Beyond heating it there was little that could be done purposefully to change its properties. When, however, water is treated not as the glisten- ing, rippling object with the variety of qualities that delight the eye, ear, and palate, but as something symbolized by H20O, | something from which these qualities are completely absent, it becomes amenable to all sorts of other modes of control and adapted to other uses. Similarly, when steam and ice are no longer treated as what they are in their qualitative differences from one another in direct experience, but as homogeneous molecules moving at measured velocities through specified dis- tances, differential qualities that were barriers to effective regu- lations, as long as they were taken as finalities, are done away with. A single way of acting with respect to them in spite of their differences is indicated. This mode of action is capable of extension to other bodies, in principle to any bodies irre- spective of qualitative differences of solid, liquid and gaseous, provided they are given a like mathematical formulation. Thus all sorts of modes of expansion and contraction, of re- frigeration and evaporation, of production and regulation of explosive power, become possible. From the practical stand- point, bodies become aggregates of energies to be used in all kinds of ways, involving all sorts of substitutions, transforma- 105 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tions, combinations and separations. But the object of direct or perceptible experience remains the same qualitative object, enjoyable and usable, it always was. Water as an object of science, as H2O with all the other scientific propositions which can be made about it, is not a rival for position in real being with the water we see and use. It is, because of experimental operations, an added instrumentality of multiplied controls and uses of the real things of everyday experience. I am aware that this method of dealing with the great problem of modern philosophy will be regarded by many as too cavalier a disposition of a great issue; the solution if there be any (and many thinkers would perhaps feel any solution to be a real deprivation) is too simple and easy to be satisfactory. But I shall be content if the account leads anyone to recon- sider the traditional beliefs which stand in the way of accep- tance of the solution that is proposed. These preconceptions are the assumption that knowledge has a uniquely privileged position as a mode of access to reality in comparison with other modes of experience, and that as such it is superior to practical activity. Both of these ideas were formulated in a period when knowing was regarded as something which could be effected exclusively by means of the rational powers of mind. The development of scientific inquiry with its complete dependence upon experimentation has proved the profound error of the latter position. Is it not time to revise the philo- sophical conceptions which are founded on a belief now proved to be false? The sum and substance of the present argument is that if we frame our conception of knowledge on the experimental model, we find that it is a way of operating “Upon EE CTC SET 0) Sra renee experience so that we can~frame-our ideas of them in terms of their interactions with one another, instead of in terms of the qualities they directly present, and that thereby our control of them, our [es eAAe AAO ecm) TAN TRAIAN “T06 SRIRAM IN HIE II OE BERRY SGA ORTH 9 LC OITILY ARTS OF ACCEPTANCE AND CONTROL ability to change them and direct their changes as we desire, is indefinitely increased. Knowing is itself a mode of practical action and is the way of interaction by which other natural interactions become subject to direction. Such is the significance of the experimental method as far as we have as yet traced its course. As was stated at the beginning of this part of the discus- sion, the examination of scientific knowing is undertaken not so much for its own sake as in order to supply material for pro- jecting a hypothesis about something less technical and of wider and more liberal application. The ulterior issue is the possibility that actual experience in its concrete content and movement may furnish those ideals, meanings and values whose lack and uncertainty in experience as actually lived by most persons has supplied the motive force for recourse to some reality beyond experience: a lack and uncertainty that account for the continued hold of traditional philosophical | and religious notions which are not consonant with the main | tenor of modern life. The pattern supplied by scientific know- | ing shows that in this one field at least it is possible for ex- perience, in becoming genuinely experimental, to develop its own regulative ideas and standards. Not only this, but in addi- tion the progress of knowledge of nature has become secure and steady only because of this transformation. The conclusion is a good omen for the possibility of achieving in larger, more humane and liberal fields a similar transformation, so that a philosophy of experience may be empirical without either being false to actual experience or being compelled to explain away the values dearest to the heart of man. 107 CHART Rin, IDEAS AT WORK OF ALL PHILOSOPHICAL problems that which concerns the na- ture and worth of ideas is probably the one that most readily ‘appeals to any cultivated mind. The eulogistic flavor which hangs about the word Idealism is a tribute to the respect men pay to thought and its power. Theobnoxious quality of mate- rialism is due to its depression of thought, which is treated as an illusion or at most an accidental by-product; materialism leaves no place where ideas have creative or regulative effect. In some sense the cause of ideas, of thought, is felt to be that of the distinctive dignity of man himself. Serious minds have always desired a world in which experiences would be produc- tive of ideas, of meanings, and in-which these ideas in turn would regulate conduct. Take away ideas and what follows “from them and man seems no better than the beasts of the field. It is, however, an old story that philosophers have divided into opposed schools as to the nature of ideas and their power. To the extreme right are those who, under the banner of Ideal- ism, have asserted that thought is the creator of the universe and that rational ideas constitute its structure. This constitutive work, however, is something done once for all by thought in a transcendentala aboriginal work. The empirical world in which we live from day by day is crass and obdurate, stubbornly un- ideal in character because it is only an appearance of the reality of which thought is the author. This philosophic mode of pay- ing reverence to ideas is thus compensatory rather than vital. 108 IDEAS AT WORK It has nothing to do with rendering the natural and social environment of our experience a more ideal abode, namely, one characterized by meanings which are the fruits of thought. There are those who would be willing to exchange the thought which constitutes reality once for all for that thinking which by continued particular acts renders our experienced world here and now more charged with coherent and luminous meanings. At the other pole is the school of sensational empiricists who hold that the doctrine that thought in any mode of opera- tion is originative is an illusion. It proclaims the necessity of direct, first-hand contact with things as the source of all knowl- edge. Ideas are pale ghosts of flesh and blood impressions; they are images, pallid reflections, dying echoes of first hand intercourse with reality which takes place in sensation alone. In spite of the polar opposition between the two schools, they depend upon a common premise. According to both sys- tems of philosophy, reflective thought, thinking that involves inference and judgment, is not originative. It has its test in antecedent reality as that is disclosed in some non-reflective immediate knowledge. Its validity depends upon the possi- bility of checking its conclusions by identification with the terms of such prior immediate knowledge. The controversy between the schools is simply as to the organ and nature of previous direct knowledge. To both schools, reflection, thought involving inference, is reproductive; the “proof” of its results is found in comparison with what is known without any infer- ence. In traditional empiricism the test is found in sensory im- pressions. For objective idealism, reflective inquiry is valid only as it reproduces the work previously effected by constitutive thought. The goal of human thinking is approximation to the reality already instituted by absolute reason. The basic premise is also shared by realists. The essence of their position is that 109 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY reflective inquiry is valid as it terminates in apprehension of that which already exists. When thinking introduces any modi- fication into antecedent reality it falls into error; in fact, pro- ductive origination on the part of mind defines error. The issue is connected with the analysis of experimental knowing which was begun in the preceding chapter. For the common premise of these philosophical schools, so opposed to one another in most ways, goes back to adoption of the idea about knowledge in relation to what is independently real which, originating in Greek thought, has become engrained in tradition. In our summary of the characteristics of experimental thinking, its second trait was said to be the direction of experi- ment by ideas, the fact that experiment is not random, aimless action, but always includes, along with groping and relatively blind doing, an element of deliberate foresight and intent, which determines that one operation rather than another be tried. In this chapter we shall, accordingly, consider the im-. Ne plications for the theory of ideas that follow from experi- “mental method. Let us suppose, for the time being, that all that we can know about ideas is derived from the way in which they figure in the reflective inquiries of science. What con- ception of their nature and office shall we then be led to form? We shall begin, somewhat abruptly, with a statement of the nature of conceptions which has been framed on the basis of recent conclusions in physical science. We shall then com- pare this idea about ideas with that which was embodied in the Newtonian philosophy of nature and science, and take up the reasons which compelled the abandonment of the latter. Finally we shall recur to a comparison of the result reached with the doctrine embodied in traditional philosophies—one that is identical with that found in the now discredited New- tonian natural philosophy. The position of present science on this matter has been TIO IDEAS AT WORK stated as follows: “To find the length of an object, we have to perform certain physical operations. The concept of length is therefore fixed when the operations by which length is meas- ured are fixed; that is, the concept of length involves as much as and nothing more than the set of operations by which length is determined. In general, we mean by any cc concept 1 nothing more than a set of of operations; the concept is synonymous Us With the corresponding set of operations.” * The same idea is re- peated by Eddington in his Gifford Lectures. His statement is as follows: “The vocabulary of the physicist comprises a num- ber of words such as length, angle, velocity, force, potential, current, etc., which we call ‘physical quantities.’ It is now recognized that these should be defined according to the way — in which we recognize them when actually confronted with them, and not according to the metaphysical significance which we may have anticipated for them. In the old text-books mass was defined as ‘quantity of matter’; but when it came to an actual determination of mass, an experimental method was prescribed which had no bearing on this definition.” f The * Bridgman, The Logic of Modern Physics, New York, 1927, p. 5. The italics are in the text. + The Nature of the Physical World, London and New York, 1928, p. 255. It is implied in the quotation that concepts are recognized by means of the experimental operations by which they are determined; that is, operations define and test the validity of the meanings by which we state natural happen- ings. This implication is made explicit a few sentences further along when in speaking of Einstein Mr. Eddington says his theory “insists that each physical quantity should be defined as the result of certain operations of measurement and calculation.” The principle is anticipated in Peirce’s essay on How to Make Our Ideas Clear published as far back as 1881—now reprinted in a volume of essays, edited by Morris R. Cohen, and entitled Chance, Love and Logic, New York, 1923. Peirce states that the sole meaning of the idea of an object consists of the consequences which result when the object is acted upon in a particular way. The principle is one element in the pragma- tism of James. The idea is also akin to the “instrumental” theory of concep- tions, according to which they are intellectual instruments for directing our activities in relation to existence. The principle of “extensive abstraction” as a mode of defining things is similar in import. On account of ambiguities in the notion of pragmatism—although its Jogical import is identical—I shall follow Bridgman in speaking of “operational thinking.” III teens THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY adoption of this point of view with respect to the meaning and content of thinking, and as to the validity or sound- ness of the ideas by means of which we understand natural events, makes possible what has been lacking throughout the history of thought, a genuinely experimental empiricism. The phrase ‘ ‘experimental empiricism” m? sounds redundant. It ought to be so in fact, since the adjective and the noun should have the same significance, so that nothing is gained by using the two terms. But historically such is not the case. For, histori- cally, empirical philosophies have been framed in terms of sen- sations or sense data. These have been said to be the material out of which ideas are framed and by agreement with which they are to be tested. Sensory qualities are the antecedent models with which ideas must agree if they are to be sound or “proved.” * These doctrines have always evoked an abundance of criticisms. But the criticisms have taken the form of depre- ciating the capacity of “experience” to provide the source and test of our fundamentally important ideas in either knowledge or morals, They have used the weaknesses of sensational em- piricism to reinforce the notion that ideas are framed by rea- son apart from any experience whatsoever; to support what is known in the vocabulary of philosophical systems as an @ priori rationalism. i From the standpoint of the operational definition and tests of ideas, ideas having an empirical origin and status. But it is that of acts performed, acts in the literal and existential sense of the word, deeds done, not reception of sensations forced on us from without. Sensory qualities are important. But they are intellectually significant only as consequences of acts inten- tionally performed. A color seen at a particular locus in a spec- The whole empirical logic of Mill professedly, and as far as consistent with itself, is an endeavor to show that all propositions involving reflection and ideas must be proved, or demonstrated to be true, by reduction to propo- sitions consisting only of material directly given in sensation. II2 IDEAS AT WORK tral band is, for example, of immense intellectual importance in chemistry and in astro-physics. But merely as seen, as a bare sensory quality, it is the same for the clodhopper and the scientist; in either case, it is the product of a direct sensory excitation; it is just and only another color the eye has hap- pened upon. To suppose that its cognitive value can be eked out or supplied by associating it with other sensory qualities of the same nature as itself, is like supposing that by putting a pile of sand in the eye we can get rid of the irritation caused by a single grain. To suppose, on the other hand, that we must appeal to a synthetic activity of an independent thought to give the quality meaning in and for knowledge, is like suppos- ing that by thinking in our heads we can convert a pile of bricks into a building. Thinking, carried on inside the head, can make some headway in forming the plan of a building. But it takes actual operations to which the plan, as the fruit of thought, gives instrumental guidance to make a building out of separate bricks, or to transform an isolated sensory quality into a significant clew to knowledge of nature. Sensory qualities experienced through vision have their cognitive status and office, not (as sensational empiricism holds) in and of themselves in isolation, or as merely forced upon attention, but because they are the consequences of definite and intentionally performed operations. Only in connection with the intent, or idea, of these operations do they amount to anything, either as disclosing any fact or giving test and proof of any theory. The rationalist school was right in as far as it insisted that sensory qualities are significant for knowledge only when connected by means of ideas. But they were wrong in locating the connecting ideas in intellect apart from experi- ence. Connection is instituted through operations which define ideas, and operations are as much matters of experience as are sensory qualities. 113 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY It is not too much to say, therefore, that for the first time there is made possible an empirical theory of ideas free from the burdens imposed alike by sensationalism and @ priori ra- tionalism. This accomplishment is, I make bold to say, one of three or four outstanding feats of intellectual history. For it emancipates us from the supposed need of always harking back to what has already been given, something had by alleged direct or immediate knowledge in the past, for the test of the value of ideas./A definition of the nature of ideas in terms of operations to be performed and the test of the validity of the ideas by the consequences of As operations establishes connectivity within concrete experience At the same time, by emancipation of thinking from the necessity of testing its con- clusions solely by reference to antecedent existence it makes ages spacer Gea DEMS clear the originative possibilities of thinking. “John Locke has always been the central figure in the em- pirical school. With extraordinary thoroughness he laid the foundations of that empirical logic which tests the validity of every belief about natural existence by the possibility of re- solving the content of the belief into simple ideas originally received through the senses. If we want to know what “solid- ity” or any other idea is, we are, in his own words, “sent to the senses.” In developing this theory of the origin and test of our natural knowledge (for he excepted mathematical and moral ideas) he found himself building upon the foundation laid by his illustrious contemporary, Sir Isaac Newton. The latter was convinced of the unsoundness of the rationalistic philosophy of science represented by Descartes, for a time the great rival of Newton for supremacy in the scientific world. Newton’s own use of mathematics and also his conception of gravitation (with some other of his physical ideas) exposed him, however, to the charge of reviving the “occult essences” of scholasticism. Accordingly, he was very emphatic upon the It4 IDEAS AT WORK point that he was thoroughly empirical in premises, method and conclusions; empirical in that he had gone to his senses and taken what he found there as the origin and justification of his primary scientific ideas about nature. As we shall see, certain assumptions of Newton were in fact far from empiri- cal in any experimental sense of that word, but were intro- duced by him into the philosophical foundations of natural science and were thence taken over into the whole philosophic theory of science to be questioned only in our own day. No saying of Newton’s is more widely known than that “T do not invent hypotheses.” This is only his negative way of asserting complete reliance upon a subject-matter guaranteed by the senses—which in turn signifies, as we have just said, that all scientific ideas go back to sense perceptions previously had for both their origin and their warrant. We shall consider first the effect of Newton’s procedure upon the supposed foun- dations of natural science, and then consider how the recogni- tion of an operational—and relational—definition of scientific conceptions instead of a discrete and sensory one has destroyed those foundations. While Newton employed mathematical conceptions with a freedom equal to that of Descartes and with a heuristic power far exceeding Descartes, he differentiated his own method from that of the latter by insisting that the objects to which his mathematical calculations applied were not products of thought, but were given, as far as the properties which figured in his science were concerned, in sense. That is, he did not claim that he could sensibly observe the ultimate particles or atoms which were the foundation of his system, but he did claim that he had sensible grounds for assuming their existence, and especially he insisted that all the properties with which his scientific theory endowed these particles were derived from and were verifiable in direct sense-perception. In his own words: 115 THE QUEST’ FOR CERTAINTY “Whatever is not derived from phenomena is to be called a hypothesis and hypotheses . . . have no place in experimen- tal philosophy.” The positive counterpart of this negative statement is as follows: “The qualities of bodies which admit of neither intension nor remission of degree and which are found to belong to all bodies within the reach of experiments, are to be assumed the universal qualities of all bodies whatso- ever.” Newton’s assumption that he was only extending to the ultimate proper objects of physical science those qualities of experienced objects that are disclosed in direct perception is made evident by such passages as the following: “We no other way know the extension of bodies than by our senses, nor do these reach it in all bodies. But because we perceive extension in all bodies that are sensible, therefore we ascribe it universally to all others also. That abundance of bodies are hard, we learn by experience; and because the hardness of the whole arises from the hardness of the parts, we therefore justly infer the hardness of the undivided particles not only of the bodies we feel but of all others. That all bodies are im- penetrable we gather not from reason but from sensation. . . . That all bodies are moveable and are endu ued with certain powers (which we call the vires inertiae) of persevering in their motion or in their rest we only infer from like properties observed in the bodies that we have seen.”? Or as Newton says of his “principles,” summing it all up: “I consider them not as occult qualities but as general laws of nature . . . their truth appearing to us by phenomena.” The principles in question were mass, gravity, hardness, impenetrability, extension, mo- tion, inertia, etc. The essential point of his argument is that non-sensible bodies, namely, the ultimate particles to which mathematical reasoning applies, are endowed with no properties save those 116 IDEAS AT WORK which are found by experience t to belong to all bodies of which ®_ 2 ee iene ry er we do have “sensible experience. The static (spatial, extension, volume) qualities, and the dynamic properties (resistance, per- severance in motion) of ultimate physical realities, are homo- geneous with the common qualities of sensibly perceived things. Color, sound, heat, odor, etc., go out, since they permit of absence, and of remission and increase of degrees—or are not universally present, Volume, mass, inertia, motion and moveability, remain as universal qualities. What would hap- pen if some raised the objection that the existence of the ulti- mate particles is hypothetical, since they are not observed? What becomes of his empiricism even if the properties as- scribed to particles are all sensibly verified, provided the bearers of these properties are not observed? It can hardly be said that Newton explicitly discusses this question. It seemed to him practically self-evident that since sensible bodies were divisible without losing the properties that form his “princ- ples,” we are entitled to assume the existence of certain last particles of the same kind incapable of further division. And while, in logical consistency, he could hardly have admitted the argument, the fact that he found that he could “explain” actual occurrences on the basis of this assumption seemed to give him ample confirmation of their existence. Perhaps in the following passage he comes as near as anywhere to dealing explicitly with the point: After saying that if a/J particles, all bodies whatever, were capable of being broken, they would then wear away, he goes on to say that in that case the “nature of things depending on them would be changed,” and adds “and therefore that nature may be lasting, the changes of cor- poreal things are to be placed only in the various separations and new associations and motions of these permanent particles.” “So that nature may be lasting!” It would be hard to find a franker statement of the motive which controlled Newton’s Tl? THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY doctrine. There was needed some guarantee that Nature would not go to pieces and be dissipated or revert to chaos. How could the unity of anything be secure unless there was some- thing persistent and unchanging behind all change? Without such fixed indissoluble unities, no final certainty was possible. Everything was put in peril of dissolution. These metaphysi- cal fears rather than any experimental evidence determined the nature of the fundamental assumptions of Newton regarding atoms. They furnished the premises which he regarded as scientific and as the very foundations of the possibility of science. ‘All changes are to be placed in only the separations and new associations of permanent particles.” In this state- ment there is contained a professedly scientific restatement of the old human desire for something fixed as the warrant and object of absolute certainty. Without this fixity knowledge was impossible. Changes are to be known by treating them as in- different spatial approaches and withdrawals taking place be- tween things that are themselves eternally the same. Thus to establish certainty in existence and in knowledge, “God in the beginning formed matter in solid, massy, hard, impenetrable particles.” Jt was logically inevitable that as science proceeded on its experimental path it would sooner or later become clear that ue all conceptions, all intellectual descriptions, must be formu- lated in terms of operations, actual or imaginatively possible We, There are no conceivable ways in which the existence of ulti- mate unchangeable substances which interact without under- going change in themselves can be reached by means of experimental operations. Hence they have no empirical, no ex- perimental standing; they are pure dialectic inventions. They were not even necessary for application of the mathematical method of Newton. Most of his analytic work in his Prin- ciples would remain unchanged, if his physical particles were 118 IDEAS AT WORK dropped out and geometrical points were substituted. What reason can be assigned for Newton’s desertion of an experi- mental method and for the adoption in its stead of an obvi- ously dialectical conception—since the conception that the per- manence of nature depends upon the assumption of a plurality of discrete immutable substances is clearly dialectical? Doubt- less in part the reason was that the scheme worked or seemed to work. Without developing or acknowledging the conse- quences of this mode of justification, objections based on theory could always be met by pointing to the marvelous conclusions of physical inquiry. But a more fundamental reason was that the minds of men, including physical inquirers, were still possessed by the old notion that reality in order to be solid and firm must con- sist of those fixed immutable things which philosophy calls substances. Changes could be known only if they could be somehow reduced to recombinations of original unchanging things. For these alone can be objects of certainty—the chang- ing is as such the uncertain—and only the certain and exact is knowledge. Thus a popular metaphysics, given rational for- mulation by the Greeks, and taken over into the intellectual tradition of the western world, controlled at first the inter- pretations placed upon the procedures and conclusions of ex- | perimental knowing. This hypothesis as to the origin of the non-experimental factor in the Newtonian philosophy is confirmed by his own use of the metaphysics of the ideas of substance and essential properties. The fact that Newton adopted the Democritean rather than the Aristotelian conception of substance is of course of immense importance scientifically. But philosophically speaking it is of slight import compared with the fact that he followed the supposed necessities of dialectic reasoning rather than the lead of experienced subject-matter in accepting with- 119 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY out question the notion that there must be at the foundation of all existence certain things which are intrinsically unchange- able, and that such immutable entities are the objects of any true knowledge because they give the warrant of fixed certitude. With his acceptance of the old doctrines of substances goes that of the doctrine of essence. If fixed unchangeable things exist, they must have certain inherent, unchangeable proper- ties. Changes are accidental and external; they occur between substances and do not affect their inner nature. If they did, substances would not be substances; they would change and rot away. Hence, in spite of starting upon the experimental and mathematical path, Newtonian science kept the idea that atoms are characterized by eternal properties or qualities, that is by essences. Substances are “solid, hard, massy, impenetrable, moveable particles.” Their essence is precisely these unchange- able, fixed qualities of solidity, mass, motion, inertia. It thus appears that Newton retained a part of the qualita- tive equipment of the objects of Greek science, in spite of their irrelevance to both mathematics and experiment. When one searches through philosophical commentary and discussion (based mainly on Locke’s version of Newton’s results), one finds a great deal of discussion about the fact that the so- called secondary qualities, color, sound, odor, taste, were elimi- nated from “reality.” But not a word as far as I can discover is said about the fact that other sensible qualities under the name of primary were retained in defining the object of science. And yet this retention is the fous et origo malorum. The actual fact was that science by means of its operational conceptions was instituting as its objects of thought things in a dimension different from amy of the direct qualities of objects. It was not a question of getting rid of some immediate sense qualities; but of a treatment indifferent to any and all qualities. New- I20 =~ IDEAS AT WORK ton could not realize this fact, because he insisted that the existence of hard and fixed unchanging substances was the basis of science. Given such substances they had to have some quali- ties as their inherent properties. Hence Newton generously endowed them with those prop- erties which he insisted were directly taken from sense experi- ence itself. Consider the consequences for subsequent thought. Getting rid of some qualities which had been regarded as essential to natural things while retaining others, did not for- ward in the least the actual work of science, while it did work inevitably to establish a fixed gulf and opposition between the things of ordinary perception, use and enjoyment and the objects of science which, according to tradition, were the only ultimately “real” objects. The story of the extent to which this opposition became the underlying problem of mod- ern philosophy need not be retold. Nor are we called upon here to consider the way in which it generated an “epistemo- logical” problem of knowledge in the general terms of rela- tion of subject and object, as distinct from the logical problem of the methods by which inquiry shall attain understanding. For qualities expelled from scientific objects were given an asylum “in the mind”; they became mental and psychical in nature, and the problem arose how mind composed of such elements, having nothing in common with objects of science— by doctrinal definition the real things of nature—could pos- sibly reach out and know their own opposites. In another con- nection, that result would provide a theme most important to discuss:—from its origin in Berkeley’s contention that since “secondary” qualities are avowedly mental and since primary qualities cannot be disassociated from them, the latter must be mental also, through all theSinuositie> of modern thought in dealing with the “problem.” But the first of these points, the rivalry of scientific objects and empirical objects for posi- 127 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tion in natural existence, has already been dealt with and the latter problem is not immediately relevant. We are here concerned with the Newtonian assumption that we must carry over into the conception and definition of physical objects some of the qualities directly experienced in sense-perception, while their presence in such sense-experi- ence is the warrant or “proof” of their validity as ideas, There was no direct experience of the ultimate massy, hard, impene- trable and indivisible and hence unchangeable particles—since indeed their eternal permanence obviously was a thing incap- able of any experience except by some equally eternal mind. Hence these qualities must be thought, they must be inferred. In themselves they exist by themselves. But for us, they exist as objects of thought only. Hence as ideas they need a warrant and justification which primary qualities of immediate percep- tion do not need, since these are self-warranting—according to the doctrine. Now so deeply engrained are the conclusions of the old tradition of rationalism versus (sensationalistic) empiricism, that the question will still be raised: What other certification could be given or can now be given for the properties of scien- tific physical objects save by inferential extension of the uni- versally found properties of all objects of sense perception? Is there any alternative unless we are prepared to fall back upon @ priori rational conceptions supposed to bring their own sufficient authority with them? It is at this point that the recent recognition that the con- ceptions by which we think scientific objects are derived neither from sense nor from @ priori conceptions has its logical and ; -~philosophical force. Sense qualities, as we saw in the previous i) chapter, are something to be known, they are challenges to knowing, setting problems for investigation. Our scientific knowledge is something about them, resolving the problems 122 IDEAS AT WORK they propose. Inquiry proceeds by reflection, by thinking; but ot, most decidedly, by thinking as conceived in the old tradition, as something cooped up within “mind.” For ex- perimental inquiry or thinking signifies directed activity, doing something which varies the conditions under which objects are observed and directly had and by instituting new arrange- ments among them. Things perceived suggest to us (originally just evoke or stimulate) certain ways of responding to them, of treating them. These operations have been continuously refined and elaborated during the history of man on earth, although it is only during the last few centuries that the whole affair of controlled thinking and of its issue in genuine knowledge, has been seen to be bound up with their selection and determination. The central question thus arises: What determines the selection of operations to be performed? There is but one an- swer:—the nature of the problem to be dealt with—an answer which links the phase of experiment now under discussion with that considered in the last chapter. The first effect of experimental analysis is, as we saw, to reduce objects directly experienced to data. This resolution is required because the objects in their first mode of experience are perplexing, ob- scure, fragmentary; in some way they fail to answer a need. Given data which locate the nature of the problem, there is evoked a thought of an operation which if put into execution may eventuate in a situation in which the trouble or doubt which evoked inquiry will be resolved. If one were to trace the history of science far enough, one would reach a time in which the acts which dealt with a troublesome situation would be organic responses of a structural type together with a few acquired habits. The most elaborate technique of present in- quiry in the laboratory is an extension and refinement of these simple original operations. Its development has for the most 123 ioe THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY part depended upon the utilization of physical instruments, which when inquiry was developed to a certain point were purposely invented. In principle, the history of the construc- tion of suitable operations in the scientific field is not different from that of their evolution in industry. Something needed to be done to accomplish an end; various devices and methods of operation were tried. Experiences of success and failure gradually improved the means used. More economical and effective ways of acting were found—that is, operations which gave the desired kind of result with greater ease, less irrele- vancy and less ambiguity, greater security. Each forward step was attended with making better tools. Often the invention of a tool suggested operations not in mind when it was in- vented and thus carried the perfecting of operations still fur- ther. There is thus no a priori test or rule for the determina- tion of the operations which define ideas. They are themselves experimentally developed in the course of actual inquiries. They originated in what men naturally do and are tested and improved in the course of doing. This is as far as the answer to the query can be carried in a formal way Consequences that successfully solve the prob- lems set by the conditions which give rise to the need of ction supply the basis by means of which acts, originally “naturally” performed, kecome the operations of the art of scientific chica, content, a much more detailed answer can be given. For this answer, one would turn to the historical development of science, in which is recorded what kind of operations have definitely been found to effect the transformation of the obscure and perplexing situations of experience into clear and resolved situations. To go into this matter would be to expound the character of the concepts actually employed in the best developed branches of reflec- tion or inquiry. 124 IDEAS AF WORK While such a discussion is apart from our purpose, there is one common character of all such scientific operations which it is necessary to note. They are such as disclose relationships. A simple case is the operation by which length is defined by one object placed end upon end upon another object so many times. This type of operation, repeated under conditions them- selves defined by specified operations, not merely fixes the relation of two things to each other called their length, but defines a generalized concept of length. This conception in connection with other operations, such as those which define mass and time, become instruments by means of which a multitude of relations between bodies can be established. Thus the conceptions which define units of measurement of space, time and motion become the intellectual instrumentalities by which all sorts of things with no qualitative similarity with one another can be compared and brought within the same system. To the original gross experience of things there is superadded another type of experience, the product of deliber- ate art, of which relations rather than qualities are the signifi- cant subject-matter. These connections are as much experi- enced as are the qualitatively diverse and irreducible objects of original natural experiences. Qualities present themselves as just what they are, stati- cally demarcated from one another. Moreover, they rarely change, when left to themselves, in such ways as to indicate the interactions or relations upon which their occurrence de- pends. No one ever observed the production of the thing having the properties of water, nor the mode of generation of a flash of lightning. In sensory perception the qualities are either too static or too abruptly discrete to manifest the specific connections that are involved in their coming into existence. Intentional variation of conditions gives an idea of these connections. Through thought of them the things are understood or truly 125 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY known. Only slowly, however, did there dawn the full import of the scientific method. For a long time the definitions were supposed to be made not in terms of relations but through certain properties of antecedent things. The space, time and motion of physics were treated as inherent properties of Be- ing, instead of as abstracted relations. In fact, two phases of inquiry accompany each other and correspond to each other. In one of these phases, everything in qualitative objects ex- cept their happening is ignored, attention being paid to quali- ties only as signs of the nature of the particular happening in question: that is, objects are treated as events. In the other phase, the aim of inquiry is to correlate events with one an- other. Scientific conceptions of space, time and motion consti- tute the generalized system of these correlations of events. Thus they are doubly dependent upon operations of experi- mental art: upon those which treat qualitative objects as events, and upon those which connect events thus determined with one another. In these statements we have, however, anticipated the actual movement of scientific thought. This took a long time to arrive at recognition of its own import. Till our own day, scientific conceptions were interpreted in the light of the old belief that conceptions to be valid must correspond to ante- cedent intrinsic properties resident in objects dealt with. Cer- tain properties regarded by Newton as inherent in substances and essential to them, in independence of connectivity, were indeed speedily seen to be relations. This conversion hap- pened first as to hardness and impenetrability, which were seen to be reducible to mass. Vis imertiae was a measure of mass. By careful thinkers “force” was treated as a measure of acceleration and so a name for a relation, not as an inherent property .of an isolated thing by virtue of which one thing could compel another to change. Nevertheless, until the pro- 126 IDEAS AT WORK mulgation of Einstein’s restricted theory of relativity, mass, time and motion were regarded as intrinsic properties of ulti- mate fixed and independent substances. We shall postpone till later consideration of the circum- stances attending the change. We are here concerned with the fact that when it took place it was, in spite of its upset- ting effects upon the foundation of the Newtonian philosophy of science and of nature, from the logical point of view only a clear acknowledgment of what had all the time been the moving principle of the development of scientific method. To say this is not to disparage the scientific importance of the discovery that mass varies with velocity and of the result of the Michelson-Morley experiment on the velocity of light. Such discoveries were doubtless necessary in order to force recognition of the operational or relational character of scien- tific conceptions. And yet, logically, the way in which space, time and motion, with their various functions, appear in mathe- matical equations and are translated into equivalent formula- tions with respect to one another—something which is impos- sible for qualities as such—indicates that a relational treat- ment had always been involved. But the imagination of men had become used to ideas framed on the pattern of large masses and relatively slow velocities. It required observation of changes of high velocity, as of light over great distances, and of minute changes occurring at infinitesimal distances to emancipate imagination from its acquired habitudes. The dis- covery that mass varies with velocity did away with the pos- sibility of continuing to suppose that mass is the defining characteristic of things in isolation from one another—such isolation being the sole condition under which mass could be regarded as immutable or fixed. The difference made in the actual content of scientific theory is of course enormous. Yet it is not so great as the 127 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY difference made in the logic of scientific knowledge, nor as in philosophy. With the surrender of unchangeable substances having properties fixed in isolation and unaffected by inter- actions, must go the notion that certainty is attained by attach- ment to fixed objects with fixed characters. For not only are no such objects found to exist, but the very nature of ex- perimental method, namely, definition by operations that are interactions, implies that such things are not capable of being known/Henceforth the quest for certainty becomes the search eae methods of control; that is, regulation of conditions of “" change with respect to their consequences,> Theoretical certitude is assimilated to practical certainty; to security, trustworthiness of instrumental operations. “Real” things may be as transitory as you please or as lasting in time as you please; these are specific differences like that between a flash of lightning and the history of a mountain range. In any case they are for knowledge “events” not substances, What knowledge is interested in is the correlation among these changes or events—which means in effect that the event called the mountain range must be placed within a system consisting of a vast multitude of included events. When these correlations are discovered, the possibility of control is in our hands. Scientific objects as statements of these inter-relations are instrumentalities of control. They are objects of the thought of reality, not disclosures of immanent properties of real sub- stances. They are in particular the thought of reality from a particular point of view: the most highly generalized view of nature as a system of interconnected changes. Certain important conclusions follow. The test of the validity of ideas undergoes a radical transformation. In the Newtonian scheme, as in the classic tradition, this test resided in properties belonging to ultimate real objects in isolation from one another, and hence fixed or unchanging. According 128 IDEAS AT WORK to experimental inquiry, the validity of the object of thought depends upon the consequences of the operations which define the object of thought. For example, colors are conceived in terms of, certain numbers. The conceptions are valid in the degree in which, by means of these numbers, we can predict future events, and can regulate the interactions of colored bodies as signs of changes that take place. The numbers are signs or clues of intensity and direction of changes going on. The only things relevant to the question of their validity is whether they are dependable signs. That heat is a mode of motion does not signify that heat and cold as qualitatively experienced are “unreal,” but that the qualitative experience can be treated as an event measured in terms of units of velocity of movement, involving units of position and time, so that it can be connected with other events or changes simi- larly formulated. The test of the validity of any particular intellectual conception, measurement or enumeration is func- tional, its use in making possible the institution of interactions which yield results in control of actual experiences of observed objects. In contrast with this fact, in the Newtonian philosophy measurements are important because they were supposed to disclose just how much of a certain property belonged to some body as its own isolated and intrinsic property. Philosophi- cally, the effect of this view was to reduce the “reality” of objects to just such mathematical and mechanical properties —hence the philosophical “problem” of the relation of real physical objects to the objects of experience with their qualities and immediate values of enjoyment and use. Mr. Eddington has said that “the whole of our physical knowledge is based on measures,” and that “whenever we state the properties of a body in terms of physical quantities, we are imparting the responses of various metrical indicators to its presence, and 129 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY nothing more.” * His graphic illustration of the physical for- mulation of what happens when an elephant slides downhill comes to mind. The mass of the elephant is the reading of a pointer on a weighing scale; the slope of the hill, the reading of a plumb line against the divisions of a protractor; bulk, a series of readings on the scale of a pair of calipers; color, read- ings of a photometer for light; the duration of the slide, a series of readings on a watch dial, etc. It seems almost too obvious for mention that a scientific object consisting of a set of measurements of relations be- tween two qualitative objects, and itself accordingly non- qualitative, cannot possibly be taken, or even mis-taken, for a new kind of “real” object which is a rival to the “reality” of the ordinary object. But so loath are we to surrender tradi- tional conceptions and unwilling as philosophers to surrender as unreal problems which have long engaged attention, that even Mr. Eddington feels called upon to reclothe these scien- tific measured relations with qualities as something which “mind” mysteriously introduced! Prisoners in jails are often given numbers and are “known” by the numbers assigned. It has not yet occurred to any one that these numbers are the real prisoners, and that there is always a duplicate real object; one a number, and the other a flesh and blood person, and that these two editions of reality have to be reconciled. It is true that the numbers which constitute by means of measurements the object of scientific thought are not assigned so arbitrarily as those of prisoners, but there is no difference in philosophical principle. Incidentally, Mr. Eddington remarks in his discussion of the metric properties of the object of thought that a knowl- edge of all possible responses of a concrete thing as measured by suitable devices “would completely determine its relation to its environment.” The relations a thing sustains are hardly a * The Nature of the Physical World, pp. 152 and 257. 130 IDEAS AT WORK competitor to the thing itself. Put positively, the physical ob- ject, as scientifically defined, is not a duplicated real object, but is a statement, as numerically definite as is possible, of the relations between sets of changes the qualitative object sus- tains with changes in other things—ideally of all things with which interaction might under any circumstances take place. Since these correlations are what physical inquiry does know, it is fair to conclude that they are what it intends or means to know: qn analogy with the legal maxim that any reasonable person intends the reasonably probable consequences of what he does. We come back again to the frequently re- peated statement that the problem which has given so much trouble to modern philosophy—that of reconciling the reality of the physical object of science with the richly qualitative object of ordinary experience, is a factitious one. All that is required in order to apprehend that scientific knowledge as a mode of active operation is a potential ally of the modes of action which sustain values in existence, is to surrender the traditional notion that knowledge is possession of the inner nature of things and is the only way in which they may be experienced as they “really” are. For if one change is correlated definitely with others it can be employed as an indication of their occurrence. Seeing one thing happen we can promptly infer upon what it depends, and what needs to be reinforced or to be weakened if its pres- ence is to be made more secure or is to be done away with. In itself, the object is just what it is experienced as being, hard, heavy, sweet, sonorous, agreeable or tedious and so on. But in being “there” these traits are effects, not causes. They cannot as such be used as means, and when they are set up as ends in view, we are at a loss how to secure them. For just as qualities there are no constant and definite relations which can be ascertained between them and other things. If we wish Loi THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY to regard them not as fixed properties but as things to be attained, we must be able to look upon them as dependent events. If we wish to be able to judge Aow they may be at- tained, we must connect them as changes with other changes more nearly in our power, until by means of a transitive series of connected changes we arrive at that which we can initiate by our own acts. If one with understanding of the whole situation were to set out to devise means of control of the experience of qualitative values, he would plot a course which would be identical with that followed by experimental science; one in which the results of knowledge would bear the same relation to acts to be performed as do those of actual physical knowledge. Ability, through a definite or measured correlation of changes, to connect one with another as sign or evidence is the precondition of control. It does not of itself provide direct control; reading the index hand of a barometer as a sign of probable rain does not enable us to stop the coming of the rain. But it does enable us to change our relations to it: to plant a garden, to carry an umbrella on going out, to direct the course of a vessel at sea, etc. It enables preparatory acts to be undertaken which make values less insecure. If it does not enable us to regulate just what is to take place, it enables us to direct some phase of it in a way which influences the stability of purposes and results. In other cases, as in the arts proper, we can not only modify our own attitude so as to effect useful preparation for what is to happen, but we can modify the happening itself. This use of one change or perceptible occurrence as a sign of others and as a means of preparing our- selves, did not wait for the development of modern science. It is as old as man himself, being the heart of all intelligence. But accuracy and scope of such judgments, which are the only means with power to direct the course of events and to effect 132 IDEAS AT WORK the security of values, depends upon the use of methods such as modern physics has made available. Extent of control is dependent, as was suggested a moment ago, upon capacity to find a connected series of correlated change, such that each linked pair leads on to another in the direction of a terminal one which can be brought about by our own action. It is this latter condition which is especially ful- filled by the objects of scientific thought. Physical science dis- regards the qualitative heterogeneity of experienced objects so as to make them all members in one comprehensive homo- geneous scheme, and hence capable of translation or conver- sion one into another. This homogeneity of subject-matter over a broad range of things which are as disparate from each other in direct experience as sound and color, heat and light, friction and electricity, is the source of the wide and free con- trol of events found in modern technology. Common sense knowledge can connect things as sign and thing indicated here and there by isolated couples. But it cannot possibly join them all up together so that we can pass from any one to any other. The homogeneity of scientific objects, through formulation in terms of relations of space, time and motion, is precisely the device which makes this indefinitely broad and flexible scheme of transitions possible. The meaning which one event has is translatable into the meanings which others possess. Ideas of objects, formulated in terms of the relations which changes bear to one another, having common measures, institute broad, smooth highways by means of which we can travel from the thought of one part of nature to that of any other. In ideal at least, we can travel from any meaning—or relation—found anywhere in nature to the meaning to be expected anywhere else. We have only to compare thinking and judging objects in terms of these measured interactions with the classic scheme 133 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of a hierarchy of species and genera to see the great gain that has been effected. It is the very nature of fixed kinds to be as exclusive with respect to those of a different order as it is to be inclusive with respect to those which fall within the class. Instead of a thoroughfare from one order to another, there was a sign: No passage. The work of emancipation which was initiated by experimentation, setting objects free from limita- tion by old habits and customs, reducing them to a collection of data forming a problem for inquiry, is perfected by the method of conceiving and defining objects through operations which have as their consequence accurate metric statements of changes correlated with changes going on elsewhere. The resolution of objects and nature as a whole into facts stated exclusively in terms of quantities which may be handled in calculation, such as saying that red zs such a number of changes while green is another, seems strange and puzzling only when we fail to appreciate what it signifies. In reality, it is a declaration that this is the effective way to think things; the effective mode in which to frame ideas of them, to formu- late their meanings. The procedure does not vary in principle from that by which it is stated that an article is worth so many dollars and cents. The latter statement does not say that the article is literally or in its ultimate “reality” so many dollars and cents; it says that for purpose of exchange that is the way to think of it, to judge it. It has many other mean- ings and these others are usually more important inherently. But with respect to trade, it is what it is worth, what it will sell for, and the price value put upon it expresses the relation it bears to other things in exchange. The advantage in stating its worth in terms of an abstract measure of exchange such as money, instead of in terms of the amount of corn, potatoes or some other special thing it will exchange for, is that the latter method is restricted and the former generalized. De- 134 IDEAS AT WORK velopment of the systems of units by which to measure sensible objects (or form ideas of them) has come along with dis- covery of the ways in which the greatest amount of free move- ment from one conception to another is possible. ZThe formulation of ideas of experienced objects in terms of measured quantities, as these are established by an inten- tional art or technique, does not say that this is the way they must be thought, the only valid way of thinking them >It states that for the purpose of generalized, indefinitely exten- sive translation from one idea to another, this is the way to think them. The statement is like any other statement about instruments, such as that so-and-so is the best way of sending a number of telegraphic dispatches simultaneously. As far as it is actually the best instrumentality, the statement is correct. It has to be proved by working better than any other agency; it is in process of continuous revision and improvement. For pur- poses except that of general and extensive translation of one conception into another, it does not follow that the “scientific” way is the best way of thinking an affair. The nearer we come to an action that is to have an individualized unique object of experience for its conclusion, the less do we think the things in question in these exclusively metric terms. The physi- cian in practice will not think in terms as general and abstract as those of the physiologist in the laboratory, nor the engineer in the field in those as free from special application as will the physicist in his work-shop. There are many ways of think- ing things in relation to one another; they are, as conceptions, instruments. The value of an instrument depends upon what is to be done with it. The fine scale micrometer which is indis- pensable in the successful performance of one operation would be a hindrance in some other needed act; and a watch spring is useless to give elasticity to a mattress. There is something both ridiculous and disconcerting in the 135 ~ THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY way in which men have let themselves be imposed upon, so as to infer that scientific ways of thinking of objects give the inner reality of things, and that they put a mark of spurious- ness upon all other ways of thinking of them, and of perceiv- ing and enjoying them. It is ludicrous because these scientific conceptions, like other instruments, are hand-made by man in pursuit of realization of a certain interest—that of the maxi- mum. convertibility of every object of thought into any and every other. It is a wonderful ideal; the ingenuity which man has shown in devising means of realizing the interest is even more marvelous. But these ways of thinking are no more rivals of or substitutes for objects as directly perceived and enjoyed than the power-loom, which is a more effective in- strument for weaving cloth than was the old hand-loom, is a substitute and rival for cloth. The man who is disappointed and tragic because he cannot wear a loom is in reality no more ridiculous than are the persons who feel troubled because the objects of scientific conception of natural things have not the same uses and values as the things of direct experience. The disconcerting aspect of the situation resides in the difficulty with which mankind throws off beliefs that have be- come habitual. The test of ideas, of thinking generally, is found in the consequences of the acts to which the ideas lead, that is in the new arrangements of things which are brought into existence. Such is the unequivocal evidence as to the worth of ideas which is derived from observing their position and role in experimental knowing. But tradition makes the tests of ideas to be their agreement with some antecedent state of things. This change of outlook and standard from what pre- cedes to what comes after, from the retrospective to the pros- pective, from antecedents to consequences, is extremely hard to accomplish. Hence when the physical sciences describe ob- jects and the world as being such and such, it is thought that 136 IDEAS AT WORK the description is of reality as it exists in itself. Since all value- traits are lacking in objects as science presents them to us, it is assumed that Reality has not such characteristics. In the previous chapter, we saw that experimental method, in reducing objects to data, divests experienced things of their qualities, but that this removal, judged from the standpoint of the whole operation of which it is one part, is a condition ,; of the control which enables us to endow the objects of ex- perience with other qualities which we want them to have. In like fashion, thought, our conceptions and ideas, are designa- tions of operations to be performed or already performed. Consequently their value is determined by the outcome of these operations. They are sound if the operations they direct give us the results which are required. The authority of thought depends upon what it leads us to through directing the performance of operations. The business of thought is not to conform to or reproduce the characters already possessed by objects but to judge them as potentialities of what they become through an indicated operation. This principle holds from the simplest case to the most elaborate. To judge that this object is sweet, that is, to refer the idea or meaning “sweet” to it without actually experiencing sweetness, is to predict that when it is tasted—that is, subjected to a specified operation— a certain consequence will ensue. Similarly, to think of the world in terms of mathematical formulae of space, time and motion is not to have a picture of the independent and fixed essence of the universe. It is to describe experienceable objects as material upon which certain operations are performed. The bearing of this conclusion upon the relation of knowl-_ edge and action speaks for itself. Knowledge which is ‘merely — a reduplication in ideas of what exists already in the world may afford us the satisfaction of a photograph, but that is all. To form ideas whose worth is to be judged by what exists 137 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY independently of them is not a function that (even if the test could be applied, which seems impossible) goes on within nature or makes any difference there. Ideas that are plans of operations to be performed are integral factors in actions which change the face of the world. Idealistic philosophies have not been wrong in attaching vast importance and power to ideas. But in isolating their function and their test from action, they failed to grasp the point and place where ideas have a constructive_office. A genuine idealism and one com- patible with science will emerge as soon as philosophy accepts the teaching of science that ideas are statements not of what is or has been but of acts to be performed. For then mankind will learn that, intellectually (that is, save for the esthetic enjoy- ment they afford, which is of course a true value), ideas are worthless except as they pass into actions which rearrange and reconstruct in some way, be it little or large, the world in which we live. To magnify thought and ideas for their own sake apart from what they do (except, once more, estheti- cally) is to refuse to learn the lesson of the most authentic kind of knowledge—the experimental—and it is to reject the idealism which involves responsibilityT o praise thinking above action because there is so much ill-considered action in the world is to help maintain the kind of a world in which action occurs for narrow and transient purposes,’To seek after ideas and to cling to them as means of conducting operations, as factors in practical arts, is to participate in creating a world in which the springs of thinking will be clear and ever-flow- ing. We recur to our general issue. When we take the instance of scientific experience in its own field, we find that experience when it is experimental does not signify the absence of large and far-reaching ideas and purposes. It is dependent upon them at every point. But it generates them within its own procedures and tests them by its own operations. In so far, | 138 IDEAS AT WORK we have the earnest of a possibility of human experience, in all its phases, in which ideas and meanings will be prized and will be continuously generated and used. But they will be integral with the course of experience itself, not imported from the external source of a reality beyond. 139 a 4 “ CHAPTER VE LHE PRAY OF TDR As THE PROBLEM OF the nature, office and test of ideas is not exhausted in the matter of physical conceptions we have dis- cussed in the preceding chapter. Mathematical ideas are in- dispensable instruments of physical research, and no account of the method of the latter is complete that does not take into account the applicability of mathematical conceptions to natural existence. Such ideas have always seemed to be the very type of pure conceptions, of thought in its own nature unadulter- ated with material derived from experience. To a constant succession of philosophers, the rdle of mathematics in physical analysis and formulation has seemed to be a proof of the presence of an invariant rational element within physical ex- _Istence, which is on that account something more than physical; this role of conceptions has been the stumbling block of em- piricists_ 1 account for science on an empirical basis. wn The significance of mathematics for phifosophy is not con- fined to this seemingly superphysical phase of the physical world, and a superempirical factor in knowledge of it. Mathe- matical conceptions as expressions of pure thought have also seemed to provide the open gateway to a realm of essence that is independent of existence, physical or mental—a self-sub- sisting realm of ideal and eternal objects which are the objects of the highest—that is, the most assured—knowledge. As was earlier noted, the Euclidean geometry was undoubtedly the pattern for the development of a formally rational logic; it was also a marked factor in leading Plato to his doctrine of a | 140 bs lo tpt Mi bh let THE PLAY OF IDEAS world of supersensible and superphysical ideal objects. The procedure of mathematics has, moreover, always been the chief reliance of those who have asserted that the demonstrated validity of all reflective thinking depends upon rational truths immediately known without any element of inference entering in. For mathematics was supposed to rest upon a basis of first truths or axioms, self-evident in nature, and needing only that the eye of reason should fall upon them to be recognized for what they are. The function of indemonstrables, of axioms and definitions, in mathematical deduction has been the ground for the distinction between intuitive and discursive reason, just as deductions have been taken to be the convincing proof that there is a realm of pure essences logically connected with one another:—universals having internal bonds with one another. CT he theory that conceptions are definitions of conse- quences of operations needs therefore to be developed with ecclesia a for its bearing upon the philosophic issues which are basic to the logic of rationalism and to the metaphysics of essences and universals or invariants.) We shall begin with mathematical concepts in their physical sense, and then consider them as they are developed apart from existential application. Although Descartes defined natural existence as extension, the classic tradition that only sense and imagination, among the organs of mind, refer to physical existence caused him to feel bound to offer justification for the doctrine that natural phenomena can be scientifically stated by purely mathematical reasoning without need of recourse to experimentation. His proof of the existence of God served the purpose of justifying this appli- cation of mathematical conceptions in physics. With Spinoza, the correspondence between physical existence and ideas did not need to be substantiated by God because it was God. This I4I THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY correspondence when modified to give thought such a priority as to include existence within itself became the animating motif of Rost-Kantian idealistic systems. Newton, being a man of science rather than a professed philosopher, made such assumptions as he thought scientific procedure demanded and its conclusions warranted. The skepti- cism of Hume (anticipated, however, by Berkeley as far as the Newtonian metaphysics of mathematical space and time were concerned) was, as is notorious, the chief factor in leading Kant to regard space and time as @ priori forms of all percep- tual experience. One of the grounds for Kant’s conviction that his doctrine was inconvertible was because he thought it had the support of Newtonian physics and was necessary to give that physics a firm foundation. The consideration important for our special purpose is, however, the fact that Newton with respect to the doctrine of space, time and motion (involved in all conception of things dealt with in the universal physics of nature) &rankly deserted the empirical method he professed to use in respect to the properties of the ultimate fixed substancesAt the same time, he regarded the physical and the mathematical as complemen- tary conceptions of two sets of properties of fixed forms of im- mutable Being. He assumed, in addition to atoms having mass, inertia and extension, the existence of empty immaterial space and time in which these substances lived, moved and had their being. The combination of the properties of these two kinds of Being provided the union of the empirically observed prop- erties of phenomena with those that were rational and mathe- matical:—a union so complete and so intimate that it con- ferred upon the Newtonian system that massive solidity and comprehensiveness which seemed to render his system in its essential framework the last word possible of the science of nature. 142 THE PLAY OF IDEAS Definition of space, time and motion from “the relation they bear to sense” is according to him “a vulgar prejudice.” As well as any contemporary physicist, he knew that phe- nomena of space, time and motion in their perceived forms are found in a frame of reference which is relative to an observer. In escape from the relativity of observable traits of the spatial and temporal motions of bodies, he assumed the existence of a fixed container of empty space in which bodies are located and an equably flowing time, empty in itself, in which changes take place. From this assumption, it followed that atoms have an intrinsically measurable motion of their own, independent of any connection with an observer. Absolute space, time and motion were thus the immutable frame within which all particular phenomena take place. The assumption of these rational absolutes was also re- quired by his basic metaphysics of fixed substances having their own inherent and unchangeable (or essential) properties of mass, extension and inertia. The sole ground of assurance that ultimate hard and massy particles persist without internal change, that all changes are merely matters of their external “separations and associations,” was the existence of something empty and fixed within which the latter occur. Without such an intervening medium, interaction with one another would be equivalent to internal changes in atoms. Space provided the condition under which changes would be external and indif- ferent to ultimate physical substances. Since, then, changes have nothing to do directly with the relations of atoms to one another, the temporal order of changes cannot be connected with the atoms themselves. There must be some evenly flow- ing external change—in reality no change at all—in reference to which they have fixed positions of before and after and of simultaneity. Since velocity and acceleration of observed mo- tions would be disjoined from absolute position and date if 143 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY they were relative to an observer—to the disruption of the whole physical scheme—motion must also be absolute. While professing empiricism, Newton thus got the benefit of the rationalistic system of strict deductive necessity. In- variant time, space and motion furnished phenomena those properties to which mathematical reasoning could be attached as a disclosure of inherent properties. The positions of bodies could be treated as an assemblage of geometrical points and the temporal properties of their motions be considered as if they were mere instants. Everything observed had, in its scientific treatment, to conform mathematically to specifications laid down by the mathematics of space and time. Until our own day, until the conception of the determination of simul- taneity of occurrence was challenged by Einstein, the system continued to receive at least Pickwickian assent from scientists. There is no trouble of course about the determination of simultaneity when two events occur within one and the same region of observation. Newton, because of his assumption of absolute time, assumed that the measurement of simultaneity had precise meaning for events not occurring within the same observed field. Einstein saw that this assumption was the Achilles heel of the entire scheme. He demanded an experi- mental method of determining simultaneity—without which events cannot be dated with respect to one another. He made the demand not on purely general principles, but because of a definite problem with relation to the velocity of light. For the existing state of the doctrine of light presented a discrepancy not to be resolved on the basis of the received scheme. The observed constancy of light with reference to the place from which its direction was observed and its velocity measured, did not agree with a fundamental principle of dynamics; with its postulate concerning frames of reference for codrdinate systems having uniform movements of translation. Instead of 144 THE PLAY OF IDEAS maintaining the old theory and denying the validity of the observed result of the Michelson-Morley experiment, Ein- stein asked what change in conceptions was demanded by the experimental result. He saw that the measurement of time relations, centering in the concept of simultaneity, was the cru- cial point. So he said, “We require a definition of simultaneity such that this definition supplies us with a method by which in par- ticular cases the physicist can decide by experiment whether or not two events occurred simultaneously.” * He suggested an arrangement by which two flashes of light, not in themselves capable of inclusion in one region of observation, be reflected to a mirror placed midway between the origin of the two flashes. They are simultaneous if they are then included within one and the same act of observation. To a layman, the sug- gestion might seem innocuous. But taken in its context, it signified that the temporal relation of events was to be meas- ured by means of the consequences of an operation which con- stitutes as its outcome a single field of observed phenomena. It signified, in connection with the fact regarding the constancy of velocity of light, that events occurring at different times according to two watches keeping exactly the same time, placed at the points of the origin of the flashes, may be simultaneous. In scientific content, this was equivalent to doing away with Newton’s absolutes; it was the source of the doctrine of restricted relativity. It signified that local or individualized times are not the same as a generic common time of physics: in short, it signi , ical ti esignates a relation of events, not the inherent property of objects. What is significant for our purpose is thgt it marked the end, as far as natural science is concerned, of the attempt to frame scientific conceptions of objects in terms of properties * Einstein, Relativity, New York, 1926, p. 26. Italics not in original. 145 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY assigned to those objects independently of the observed conse- quences of an experimental operation. Since the former doc- trine about the proper way to form conceptions, to the effect that agreement with antecedent properties determines the value or validity of ideas, was the doctrine common to all philosophic schools—except the pragmatic one of Peirce—the logical and philosophical transformation thus affected may be said to be more far-reaching than even the extraordinary de- velopment in the content of natural science which resulted. It is not too much to say that whatever should be future develop- ments in discoveries about light, or that even if the details of the Einstein theory of relativity should be some time dis- credited, a genuine revolution, and one which will not go back- ward, has been effected in the theory of the origin, nature and test of scientific ideas,> In respect to the special theme of the nature of mathe- matico-physical conceptions, the pertinent conclusion is evi- dent. For the conclusion of Einstein, in eliminating absolute space, time and motion as physical existences, does away with the doctrine that statements of space, time and motion as they appear in physics concern inherent properties. For that notion, it compels the substitution of the notion that they designate relations of events. As such relations, they secure, in their generality, the possibility of linking together objects viewed as events in a general system of linkage and translation. They are the means of correlating observations made at different times and places, whether by one observer or by many, so that translations may be effected from one to another. In short, they do the business that all thinking and objects of thought have to effect: they connect, through relevant opera- tions, the discontinuities of individualized observations and experiences into continuity with one another. Their validity is a matter of their efficacy in performance of this function; 146 THE PLAY OF IDEAS it is tested by results and not by correspondence with antece- Seat propertine of pristencd| |). It is possible to extend this conclusion to logical forms in general. The fact that there are certain formal conditions of the validity of inference has been used as the ultimate war- rant of a realm of invariant Being. But in analogy with the conclusion regarding mathematical conceptions, logical forms are statements of the means by which it is discovered that various inferences may be translated into one another, or made available with respect to one another, in the widest and most secure way. Fundamentally, the needs satisfied by infer- ence are not fully met as long as special instances are isolated from one another. The difference between the operational conception of con- ceptions and the traditional orthodox one may be indicated by an illustrative analogy.* A visitor to a country finds certain articles used’ for various purposes, rugs, baskets, spears, etc. He may be struck by the beauty, elegance and order of their designs, and, assuming a purely esthetic attitude toward them, conclude that they are put to use only incidentally. He may even suppose that their instrumental use marks a degradation of their inherent nature, a concession to utilitarian needs and conveniences, A ‘“‘tough-minded” observer may be convinced that they were intended to be put to use, and had been con- structed for that purpose. He would, indeed, recognize that there must have been raw materials which were inherently adapted for conversion to such appliances. But he would not on that account believe the things to be original instead of being made articles; still less would he conceive them to be * The phrase “conception of conceptions” is used to suggest that the interpretation is self-applying:—that is, the conception advanced is also a designation of a method to be pursued. One may lead a horse to water but cannot compel him to drink. If one is unable to perform an indicated operation or declines to do so, he will not of course get its meaning. 147 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY the original “realities” of which crude or raw material were imitations or inadequate phenomenal exemplifications. As he traced the history of these instrumentalities and found them beginning in forms which were nearer to raw materials, gradually being perfected in economy and efficiency, he would conclude that the perfecting had been an accompaniment of use for ends, changes being introduced to remedy deficiencies in prior operations and results. His_tender-minded companion might, on the other hand, infer that the progressive develop- ment showed that there was some original and transcendental pattern which had been gradually approximated empirically, | an archetype laid up in the heavens. One person might argue that, while the development of designs had been a temporal process, it had been wholly deter- mined by patterns of order, harmony and symmetry that have an independent subsistence, and that the historic movement was simply a piecemeal approximation to eternal patterns. He might elaborate a theory of formal coherence of relations having nothing to do with particular objects except that of being exemplified in them. His tough-minded companion might retort that any object made to serve a purpose must have a definite structure of its own which demands an internal con- sistency of parts in connection with one another, and that man- made machines are typical examples; that while these cannot be made except by taking advantage of conditions and relations previously existing, machines and tools are adequate to their function in the degree in which they produce rearrangement of antecedent things so that they may work better for the need in question. If speculatively—inclined, he might wonder whether our very ideals of internal order and harmony had not themselves been formed under the pressure of constant need of redisposing of things so that they would serve as means for consequences. If not too tough-minded, he would 148 THE PLAY OF IDEAS be willing to admit that after a certain amount of internal rearrangement and organization had been effected under the more direct pressure of demand for effective instrumentali- ties, an enjoyed perception of internal harmony on its own account would result, and that study of formal relations might well give a clew to methods which would result in improve- ment of internal design for its own sake with no reference whatever to special further use. Apart from metaphor, the existence of works of fine art, of interest in making them and of enjoyment of them, affords sufficient evidence that objects exist which are wholly “real” and yet are man-made; that making them must observe or pay heed to antecedent conditions, and yet the objects intrin- sically be redispositions of prior existence; that things as they casually offer themselves suggest ends and enjoyments they | do not adequately realize; that these suggestions become defi- nite in the degree they take the form of ideas, of indications | of operations to be performed in order to effect a desired eventual rearrangement. These objects, when once in existence, have their own characters and relations, and as such suggest standards and ends for further production of works of art, with less need for recourse to original “natural” objects; they become as it were a “realm” having its own purposes and regulative principles. At the same time, the objects of this “realm” tend to become over-formal, stereotyped and “aca- demic” if the internal development of an art is too much isolated, so that there is recurrent need for attention to original “natural” objects in order to initiate new significant move- ments. | The notion that there are no alternatives with respect to mathematical objects save that they form an independent realm of essences; or are relations inherent in some antecedent physical structure—denominated space and time; or else are 149 py ip THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY mere psychological, “mental” things, has no support in fact. / The supposition that these alternatives are exhaustive is a survival of the traditional notion that identifies thought and ideas with merely mental acts—that is, those imside mind. Products of intentional operations are objectively real and are valid if they meet the conditions involved in the intent for the sake of which they are constructed. But human inter- action is a contributing factor in their production, and they have worth in the human use made of them. The discussion so far does not, however, directly touch the question of “pure” mathematics, mathematical ideas in them- selves. Newton’s mathematics was professedly a mathematics of physical although non-material existence: of existential absolute space, time and motion. Mathematicians, however, often regard their distinctive conceptions as non-existential in any sense. The whole tendency of later developments, which it is unnecessary for our purposes to specify (but of which the doctrine of n-dimensional “spaces” is typical), is to identify pure mathematics with pure logi¢Some philosophers employ therefore the entities of pure mathematics so as to rehabilitate the Platonic notion of a realm of essence wholly independent of all existence whatever» Does the doctrine of the operational and experimentally empirical nature of conceptions break down when applied to “pure” mathematical objects? The key to the answer is to be found in a distinction between operations overtly performed (or imagined to be performed) and operations symbolically executed. When we act overtly, consequences ensue; if we do not like them, they are nevertheless there in existence. We are entangled in the outcome of what we do; we have to stand its consequences, We shall put a question that is so elementary that it may seem silly. How can we have an end iz view with- out having an end, an existential result, in fact? With the 150 THE PLAY OF IDEAS answer to this question is bound up the whole problem of intention! regulation of what occurs. For unless we can have ends-in-view without experiencing them in concrete fact, no regulation of action is possible. The question might be put thus: How can we act without acting, without doing some- thing? i If, by a contradiction in terms, it had been possible for men to think of this question before they had found how to answer it, it would have been given up as insoluble. How can man make an anticipatory projection of the outcome of an activity in such a way as to direct the performance of an act which shall secure or avert that outcome? The solution must have been hit upon accidentally as a by-product, and then employed intentionally. It is natural to suppose that it came as a product of social life by way of communication; say, of cries that having once directed activities usefully without in- tent were afterwards used expressly for that purpose. But whatever the origin, a solution was found when symbols came into existence. By means of symbols, whether gestures, words or more elaborate constructions, we act without acting. That is, we perform experiments by means of symbols which have results which are themselves only symbolized, and which do not therefore commit us to actual or existential consequences. If a man starts a fire or insults a rival, effects follow; the die is cast. But if he rehearses the act in symbols in privacy, he can anticipate and appreciate its result. Then he can act or not act overtly on the basis of what is anticipated and is not there __ in fact. The invention or discovery of symbols is doubtless by ¥6 far the single greatest event in the history of man. Without them, no intellectual advance is possible; with them, there is no limit set to intellectual development except inherent stupidity. For long ages, symbols were doubtless used to regulate 151 a THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY activity only ad hoc; they were employed incidentally and for some fairly immediate end. Moreover, the symbols used at first were not examined nor settled upon with respect to the office they performed. They were picked up in a casual man- ner from what was conveniently at hand. They carried all sorts of irrelevant associations that hampered their efficacy in their own special work. They were neither whittled down to accomplish a single function nor were they of a character to” direct acts to meet a variety of situations:—they were neither definite nor comprehensive. Definition and generalization are incompetent without invention of proper symbols. The loose and restricted character of popular thinking has its origin in these facts; its progress is encumbered by the vague and vac- illating nature of ordinary words. Thus the second great step forward was made when special symbols were devised that were emancipated from the load of irrelevancy carried by words developed for social rather than for intellectual pur- poses, their meaning being helped out by their immediate local context. This liberation from accidental accretions changed clumsy and ambiguous instruments of thought into sharp and precise tools. Even more important was the fact that instead of being adapted to local and directly present situations, they were framed in detachment from direct overt use and with respect to one another. One has only to look at mathematical symbols to note that the operations they desig- nate are others of the same kind as themselves, that is, sym- bolic not actual. The invention of technical symbols marked the possibility of an advance of thinking from the common sense level to the scientific. The formation of geometry by the Greeks is probably that which historically best illustrates the transition. Before this episode, counting and measuring had been employed for “prac- tical” ends, that is, for uses directly involved in nearby situa- 152 THE PLAY OF IDEAS tions. They were restricted to particular purposes. Yet having been invented and having found expression in definite sym- bols; they formed, as far as they went, a subject-matter capable of independent examination. New operations could be performed upon them. They could, and in no disrespectful sense, be played with; they could be treated from the stand- point of a fine art rather than from that of an immediately useful economic craft. The Greeks with their dominant esthetic interest were the ones who took this step. Of the creation by the Greeks of geometry it has been said that it was stimulated “by the art of designing, guided by an esthetic application of symmetrical figures. The study of such figures, and the experi- mental construction of tile figures, decorative borders, con- ventional sculptures, moldings and the like had made the early Greeks acquainted not only with a great variety of regular geometrical forms, but with techniques by which they could be constructed, compounded and divided exactly, in various ways. Unlike their predecessors, the Greeks made an intel- lectual diversion of all they undertook.” Having discovered by trial and error a large number of interrelated properties of figures, they proceeded to correlate these with one another and with new ones. They effected this work “in ways which gradually eliminated from their thought about them all guess- work, all accidental experiences such as errors of actual draw- ing and measurement, and all ideas except those which were absolutely essential. Their science thus hecame a science of ideas exclusively.”* . The importance of the intellectual transition from con- crete to abstract is generally recognized. But it is often mis- conceived. It is not infrequently regarded as if it signified simply the selection by discriminative attention of some one quality or relation from a total object already sensibly present * Barry, The Scientific Habit of Thought, New York, 1927, pp. 212-213. 153 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY or present in memory. In fact it marks a change in dimen- sions. Things are concrete to us in the degree in which they are either means directly used or are ends directly appropriated and enjoyed. Mathematical ideas were “concrete” when they rr smmenrtnee e id were employed exclusively for building bins for grain or measuring land, selling goods, or aiding a pilot in guiding his ship. They became abstract when they were freed from con- nection with any particular existential application and use. This happened when operations made possible by symbols were performed exclusively with reference to facilitating and directing other operations also_symbolic in nature. It is one kind of thing, a concrete one, to measure THO HT OFS Wianele so as to measure a piece of land, and another kind—an abstract one—to measure it simply as a means of measuring other areas symbolically designated. The latter type of opera- tion makes possible a system of conceptions related together as conceptions; it thus prepares the way for formal logic. Abstraction from use in special and direct situations was coincident with the formation of a science of ideas, of mean- ings, whose relations to one another rather than to things was — the goal of thought. It is a process, however, which is subject to interpretation by a fallacy. dndependence from any speci- fied application is readily taken to be equivalent to independ- ence from application as such; it is as if specialists, engaged in perfecting tools and having no concern with their use and so interested in the operation of perfecting that they carry _ results beyond any existing possibilities of use, were to argue % that therefore they are dealing with an independent realm having no connection with tools or utilities, This fallacy is especially easy to fall into on the part of intellectual special- ists. It played its part in the generation of @ priori rationalism. It is the origin of that idolatrous attitude toward universals so often recurring in the history of thought. Those who handle 7 154 THE PLAY OF IDEAS ideas through symbols as if they were things—for ideas are objects of thought—and trace their mutual relations in all kinds of intricate and unexpected relationships, are ready vic- tims to thinking of these objects as if they had no sort of reference to things, to existence. In fact, the distinction is one between operations to be actually performed and possible operations as such, as merely possible. Shift of reflection to development of possible opera- tions in their logical relations to one another opens up oppor- tunities for operations that would never be directly suggested. But its origin and eventual meaning lie in acts that deal with concrete situations. As to origin in overt operations there can be no doubt. Operations of keeping tally and scoring are found in both work and games. No complex development of the latter is possible without such acts and their appropriate symbols. These acts are the originals of number and of all developments of number. There are many arts in which the operations of enumeration characteristic of keeping tally are explicitly used for measuring. Carpentry and masonry for example cannot go far without some device, however rude, for estimating size and bulk. If we generalize what happens in such instances, we see that the indispensable need-is—that of adjusting things as means, as resources, to other things as ends. Px 1e origin of counting and measuring is in economy and efficiency of such adjustments. Their results are expressed by physical means, at first notches, scratches, tying knots; later by figures and diagrams. It is easy to find at least three types of situations in which this adjustment_of means to ends are practical necessities. There is the case of allotment or distri- bution of materials; of accumulation of stores against antici- pated days of need; of exchange of things in which there is a surplus for things in which there is a deficit. The fundamental BS. fe X, THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY mathematical conceptions of equivalence, serial order, sum and unitary parts, of correspondence and substitution, are all im- plicit in the operations that deal with such situations, although they become explicit and generalized only when operations are conducted symbolically in reference to one another. The failure of empiricism to account for mathematical ideas is due to its failure to connect them with acts performed. In accord with its sensationalistic character, tfaditional em- piricism sought their origin in sensory impressions, or at most in supposed abstraction from properties antecedently character- izing physical things. Experimental empiricism has none of the difficulties of iy and Mill in explaining the origin of math- ematical truths/It recognizes that experience, the actual expe- rience of men, is one of doing acts, performing operations, ' cutting, marking off, dividing up, extending, piecing together, joining, assembling and mixing, hoarding and dealing out; in general, selecting and adjusting things as means for reaching consequences, JOnly the peculiar hypnotic effect exercised by exclusive preoccupation with knowledge could have led think- ers to identify experience with reception of sensations, when five minutes’ observation of a child would have disclosed that sensations count only as stimuli and registers of motor activity expended in doing things. All that was required for the Roloc of mathematics as a science and for the growth of a logic of ideas, that is, of implications of operations with respect one to another, was that some men should appear upon the scene who were inter- ested in the operations on their own account, as operations, and not as means to specified particular uses. When symbols were devised for operations cut off from concrete application, as happened under the influence of the esthetic interest of the Greeks, the rest followed naturally. Physical means, the straight edge, the compass and the marker remained, and so did 156 PHE PLAY" OF IDEAS physical diagrams. But the latter were only “figures,” images in the Platonic sense. Intellectual force was carried by the operations they symbolized, ruler and compass were only means for linking up with one another a series of operations repre- sented by symbols. Diagrams, etc., were particular and variable, but the operations were uniform and general in their intel- lectual force:—that is, in their relation to other operations. When once the way was opened to thinking in terms of possible operations irrespective of actual performance, there was no limit to development save human ingenuity. In gen- eral, it proceeded along two lines. On the one hand, for the execution of tasks of physical inquiry, special intellectual in- strumentalities were needed, and this need led to the invention of new operations and symbolic systems. The Cartesian ana- lytics and the calculuses of Leibniz and Newton are cases in point. Such developments have created a definite body of sub- ject-matter that, historically, is as empirical as is the historic ‘Sequence of, say, spinning-machines. Such a body of material arouses need for examination on its own account. It is sub- jected to careful inspection with reference to the relations found within its own content. Indications of superfluous opera- tions are eliminated; ambiguities are detected and analyzed; massed operations are broken up into definite constituents; gaps and unexplained jumps are made good by insertion of connecting operations. In short, certain canons of rigorous interrelation of operations are developed and the old material is correspondingly revised and extended. Nor is the work merely one of analytic revision. The detection, for example, of the logical looseness of the Euclidean postulate regarding parallels suggested operations previously unthought of, and opened up new fields—those of the hyper-geometries. Moreover, the possibility of combining various existing branches of geometry as special cases of more 157 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY comprehensive operations (illustrated by the same instance) ,led to creation of mathematics of a higher order of generality. I am not interested in tracing the history of mathematics. jWhat is wanted is to indicate that once the idea of possible operations, indicated by symbols and performed omly by means Lbf symbols, is discovered, the road. is opened to operations of 'pver increasing definiteness and comprehensiveness. Any group | p£ symbolic operations suggests further operations that may “be performed. Technical symbols are framed with precisely this end in view. They have three traits that distinguish them from casual terms and ideas. They are selected with a view to designating unambiguously one mode of interaction and one only. They are linked up with symbols of other operations forming a system such that transition is possible with the utmost economy of energy from one to another. And the aim is that these transitions may occur as far as possible in amy direction. 1. “Water” for example suggests an indefinite num- ber of acts; seeing, tasting, drinking, washing without specifi- cation of one in preference to another. It also marks off water from other colorless liquids only in a vague way. 2. At the same time, it is restricted; it does not connect the liquid with solid and gaseous forms, and still less does it indicate opera- tions which link the production of water to other things into which its constituents, oxygen and hydrogen, enter. It is iso- lated instead of being a transitive concept. 3. The chemical conception, symbolized by H2O, not only meets these two requirements which “water” fails to meet, but oxygen and hydrogen are in turn connected with the whole system of chemical elements and specified combinations among them in a systematic way. Starting from the elements and the relation defined in H2O one can, so to speak, travel through all the whole scope and range of complex and varied phenomena. Thus the scientific conception carries thought and action away 158 THE PLAY OF IDEAS from qualities which are finalities as they are found in direct perception and use, to the mode of production of these quali- ties, and it performs this task in a way which links this mode of generation to a multitude of other “efficient” causal condi- tions in the most economical] and effective manner. Mathematical conceptions, by means of symbols of opera- tions that are irrespective of actual performance, carry abstrac- tion much further; one has only to contrast “2” as attached physically to H, to “2” as pure number. The latter designates an operative relation applicable to anything whatsoever, though not actually applied to any specified object. And, of course, it stands in defined relations to all other numbers, and by a system of correspondences with continuous quantities as well. That numbers disregard all qualitative distinctions is a familiar fact. This disregard is the consequence of construction of sym- bols dealing with possible operations in abstraction from the actuality of performance. If time and knowledge permitted, it could be shown that the difficulties and paradoxes which have been found to attend the logic of number disappear when instead of their being treated as either essences or as proper- ties of things in existence, they are viewed as designations of potential operations. Mathematical space is not a kind of space distinct from so-called physical and empirical space, but is a name given to operations ideally or formally possible with respect to things having spacious qualities: itis not a mode of Being, but a way of thinking things so that connections among them are liberated from fixity in experience and implication from one to another is made possible. The distinction between physical and mathematical con- ception may be brought out by noting an ambiguity in the term “possible” eee os primary meaning is actually, existen- tially, possible. Any idea as such designates an operation that may be performed, not something in actual existence. The idea 159 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of the sweetness of, say, sugar, is an indication of the conse- quences of a possible operation of tasting as distinct from a directly experienced quality. Mathematical ideas are designa- tions of possible operations in another and secondary sense, previously expressed in speaking of the possibility of sym- - bolic operations with respect to one another, This sense of possibility is compossibility of operations, not possibility of performance with respect to existence. Its test is non-incom- patibility. The statement of this test as consistency hardly car- ries the full meaning. For consistency is readily interpreted to signify the conformity of one meaning with others already had, and is in so far restrictive. ““Non-incompatibility” indi- cates that all developments are welcome as long as they do not conflict with one another, or as long as restatement of an operation prevents actual conflict. It is a canon of liberation rather than of restriction. It may be compared with natural selection, which is a principle of elimination but not one con- trolling positive development. Mathematics and formal logic thus mark highly special- ized branches of intellectual industry, whose working princi- ._ ples are very similar to those of works of fine art. The trait that strikingly characterize them is combination of freedom with rigor—freedom with respect to development of new operations and ideas; rigor with respect to formal compossi- bilities. The combination of these qualities, characteristic also of works of great art, gives the subject great fascination for some minds. But the belief that these qualifications remove mathematical objects from all connection with existence ex- presses a religious mood rather than a scientific discovery.* The significant difference is that of two types of possi- *“The long continued and infrequently interrupted study of absolutely invariant existences exercises a powerful hypnotic influence on the mind.... The world which it separates from the rest of experience and makes into the whole of being is a world of unchanging and apparently eternal order, the 160 THE PLAYOFF IDEAS bility of operation, material and symbolic. This distinction when frozen into the dogma of two orders of Being, existence and essence, gives rise to the notion that there are two types of logic and two criteria of truth, the formal and the material, of which the formal is higher and more fundamental. In truth, the formal development is a specialized offshoot of material thinking. It is derived ultimately from acts per- formed, and constitutes an extension of such acts, made pos- sible by symbols, on the basis of congruity with one another. Consequently formal logic represents an analysis of exclu- sively symbolic operations; it is, in a pregnant and not external sense, symbolic logic. This interpretation of mathematical and (formal) logical ideas is not a disparagement of them except from a mystical point of view. Symbols, as has already been noted, afford the only way of escape from submergence in existence. The liberation afforded by the free symbolism of mathematics is often a means of ulterior return to existential operations that have a scope and penetrating power not other- wise attainable. The history of science is full of illustrations of cases in which mathematical ideas for which no physical application was known suggested in time new existential relations. The theory which has been advanced of the nature of essences (universals, invariants) may be tested by comparing the conditions which symbolic operations fulfill with the attri- butes traditionally imputed to the former. These attributes are ideality, universality, immutability, formality, and the subsistence of relations of implication that make deduction possible. There is a one to one correspondence between these characters and those of objects of thought which are defined only Absolute cold intellect need not reject. A conviction thus establishes itself which finally affects the whole of waking thought: that in this experience one has at last discovered the eternal and ultimate truth.” Barry, Op. cit., pp. 182-183. 161 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY in terms of operations that are compossible with respect to one another. : Ppa The correspondence will be approached by pointing out the traits of a machine which marks its structure in view of the function it fulfills. It is obvious that this structure can be understood not by sense but only by thought of the relations which the parts of the machine sustain to one another, in con- nection with the work the machine as a whole performs (the consequences it effects). Sensibly, one is merely overwhelmed in the presence of a machine by noises and forms. Clarity and order of perceived objects are introduced when forms are judged in relation to operations, and these in turn in relation to work done. Movements may be seen in isolation, and products, goods turned out, may be perceived in isolation. The machine is known only when these are thought in connection with one another. In this thought, motions and parts are judged as means; they are referred intellectually to something else; to think of anything as means is to apprehend an object in rela- tion. Correlatively, the physical effect is judged as consequence —something related. The relation of means-consequence may thus justifiably be termed ideal in the sense of ideational. Operations as such, that is, as connective interactions, are uniform. Physically and sensibly, a machine changes through friction, exposure to weather, etc., while products vary in quality. Processes are local and temporal, particular. But the relation of means and consequence which defines an operation remains one and the same in spite of these variations. It is a universal. A machine turns out a succession of steel spheres, like ball-bearings. These closely resemble one another, because they are products of like process. But there is no absolute ex- actitude among them. Each process is individual and not exactly identical with others. But the function for which the machine is designed does not alter with these changes; an 162 THE PLAY OF IDEAS operation, being a relation, is not a process. An operation deter- mines any number of processes and products all differing from one another; but deimg a telephone or a cutting tool is a self- identical universal, irrespective of the multiplicity of special objects which manifest the ines The relation is thus invariant. It is eternal, not in the sense of enduring throughout all time, or being everlasting like an Aristotelian species or a Newtonian substance, but in the sense that an operation as a relation which is grasped in thought is independent of the instances in which it is overtly exemplified, although its meaning is found only in the possibility of these actualizations. The relation, between things as means and things as conse- quences, which defines a machine is ideal in another sense. It is the standard by which the value of existential processes are estimated. The deterioration or improvement in use of a con- crete machine and the worth of an invention are judged by reference to efficiency in accomplishment of a function. The more adequately the functional relation can be apprehended in the abstract, the better can the engineer detect defects in an existent machine and project improvements in it. Thus the thought of it operates as a model; it has an archetypal char- acter with respect to particular machines. Thought of an object as an ideal therefore determines a characteristic internal structure or form. This formal struc- ture is only approximated by existing things. One may con- ceive of a steam engine which has a one hundred per cent efficiency, although no such ideal is even remotely approached in actuality. Or, one may like Helmholtz conceive an ideal optical apparatus in which the defects of the existing human eye are not found. The ideal relationship of means to ends exists as a formal possibility determined by the nature of the case even though it be not thought of, much less realized in 163 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY fact. It subsists as a possibility, and as a possibility it is in its formal structure necessary. That is to say, the conditions which have to be met and fulfilled in the idea of a machine having an efficiency of one hundred per cent are set by the necessities of the case; they do not alter with defects in our apprehension of them. Hence essences may be regarded as having Being independent of and logically prior to our thought of them. There is, however, in this fact nothing of the mystery or transcendental character which is often associated with it. It signifies that if one is to attain a specified result one must © conform to the conditions which are means of securing this result; zf one is to get the result with the maximum of effi- ciency, there are conditions having a necessary relationship to that intent. This necessity of a structure marked by formal relation- ships which fulfill the conditions of serving as means for an end, accounts for the relations of implication which make deduction possible. One goes into a factory and finds that the operation of reaching an end, say, making in quantity shoes of a uniform standard, is subdivided into a number of processes, each of which is adapted to the one which precedes, and, until the final one, to that which follows. One does not make a miracle or mystery of the fact that while each machine and each process is physically separate, nevertheless all are adapted to one another. For he knows that they have been designed, through a “rationalization” of the undertaking, to effect this end. The act of knowing is also highly complex. Experience shows that it also may be best effected by analysis into a number of distinct processes, which bear a serial relation to one another.|’ Terms and propositions which symbolize the pos- sible operations that are to control these processes are designed so that they will lead one to another with the maximum of 164 THE PLAY OF IDEAS definiteness, flexibility and fertility) In other words, they are constructed with reference to the function of implication. De- duction or dialectic is the operation of developing these impli- cations, which may be novel and unexpected just as a tool often gives unexpected results when working under new con- ditions. One is entitled to marvel at the constructive power with which symbols have been devised having far-reaching and fruitful implications. But the wonder is misdirected when it is made the ground for i i eaeD bi the objects of thought into a realm of transcendent Being. / 8 This phase of the discussion is not complete till it has been explicitly noted that all general conceptions (ideas, the- ories, thought) are hypothetical. Ability to frame hypotheses is the means by which man is liberated from submergence in the existences that surrdund him and that play upon him physi- cally and sensibly. It is the positive phase of abstraction. But hypotheses are conditional; the ested by the con- sequences of the operations they define and direct. The dis- covery of the value of-hypothitical ideas when employed to suggest and direct concrete processes, and the vast extension of this operation in the modern history of science, mark a great emancipation and correspondent increase of intellectual con- trol. But their final value is not determined by their internal elaboration and consistency, but by the consequences they effect in existence as that is perceptibly experienced. Scientific conceptions are not a revelation of prior and independent real- ity. They are a system of hypotheses, worked out under con- ditions of definite test, by means of which our intellectual and practical traffic with nature is rendered freer, more secure and more significant. Our discussion has been one-sided in that it has dealt with the matter of conceptions mainly in reference to the “ration- alistic” tradition of interpretation. The reasons for this em- 165 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY phasis are too_patent to need exposition. But before leaving the topic, it should be noted that traditional empiricism has also misread the significance of conceptions or general ideas. It has steadily opposed. the doctrine of their @ priori character; it has connected them with experience of the actual world. But even more obviously than the rationalism it has opposed, empiricism has connected the origin, content and measure of validity of general ideas with antecedent existence. According to it, con- cepts are formed by comparing particular objects, already per- ceived, with one another, and then eliminating the elements in which they disagree and retaining that which they have in common. Concepts are thus simply memoranda of identical features in objects already perceived; they are conveniences, bunching together a variety of things scattered about in con- crete experience. But they have to be proved by agreement with the material of particular antecedent experiences; their value and function is essentially retrospective. Such ideas are dead, incapable of performing a regulative office in new situa- F tions. They are “empirical” in the sense in which the term /\ is opposed to scientific—that is, they are mere summaries of results obtained under more or less accidental circum- stances. Our next chapter will be devoted to explicit consideration of the historic philosophies of empiricism and rationalism about ie Gas ont eaters aac To theme, we conclude with a summary statement of the more important re- sults reached in the present phase of discussion. First, the active and productive character of ideas, of thought, is mani- fest. The motivating desire of idealistic systems of philosophy ~{ is justified. But the constructive office of thought is empirical —that is, experimental. “Thought” is not a property of some- thing termed intellect or reason apart from nature. It is a mode of directed overt action. Ideas are anticipatory plans 166 I THE PLAY OF IDEAS and designs which take effect in concrete reconstructions of an- tecedent conditions of existence. They are not innate properties of mind corresponding to ultimate prior traits of Being, nor are they @ priori categories imposed on sense in a wholesale, once-for-all way, prior to experience so as to make it possible. The active power of ideas is a reality, but ideas and idealisms have an operative force in concrete experienced situations; their worth has to be tested by the specified consequences of © their operation. Idealism is something experimental not ab- stractly rational; it is related to experienced needs and con- cerned with projection of operations which remake the actual content of experienced objects. Secondly, ideas and idealisms are in themselves hypotheses not finalities. Being connected with operations to be performed, they are tested by the consequences of these operations, not _ by what exists prior to them, Prior experience supplies the conditions which evoke ideas and of which thought has to take account, with which it must reckon. It furnishes both obstacles to attainment of what is desired and the resources that must be used to attain it. Conception and systems of conceptions, ends in view and plans, are constantly making and remaking as fast as those already in use reveal their weak- nesses, defects and positive values. There is no predestined course they must follow. Human experience consciously guided by ideas evolves its own standards and measures and each new experience constructed by their means is an opportunity for new ideas and ideals, In the third place, action is at the heart of ideas. The experimental practice of knowirig; mto supply the pattern of philosophic doctrine of mind and its organs, elimi- nates the age-old separation of theory and practice. It dis- closes that knowing is itself a kind of action, the only one which progressively and securely clothes natural existence with 167 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY realized meanings. For the outcome of experienced objects which are begot by operations which define thinking, take into themselves, as part of their own funded and incorporated meaning, the relation to other things disclosed by thinking. There are no sensory or perceived objects fixed in themselves. In the course of experience, as far as that is an outcome in- fluenced by thinking, objects perceived, used and enjoyed take up into their own meaning the results of thought; they be- come ever richer and fuller of meanings. This issue constitutes the last significance of the philosophy of experimental ideal- ism. Ideas direct operations; the operations have a result in which ideas are no longer abstract, mere ideas, but where they qualify sensible objects. The road from a perceptible experience which is blind, obscure, fragmentary, meager in meaning, to objects of sense which are also objects which sat- isfy, reward and feed intelligence is through ideas that are experimental and operative. Our conclusion depends upon an analysis of what takes place in the experimental inquiry of natural science. It goes without saying that the wider scope of human experience, that which is concerned with distinctively human conditions and ends, does not comport, as it currently exists, with the re- sult that the examination of natural science yields. The genu- inely philosophic force, as distinct from a technical one, of the conclusion reached lies in precisely this incongruity. The fact that the most exacting type of experience has attained a marvelous treasury of working ideas that are used in control of objects is an indication of possibilities as yet unattained in asia restricted forms of experience. Negatively, the result in- YT dicates the need of thoroughgoing revision of ideas of mind and thought and their connection with natural things that were formed before the rise of experimental inquiry; such is the critical task imposed on contemporary thought. 168 THE PLAY OF IDEAS Positively, the result achieved in science is a challenge to philosophy to consider the possibility of the extension of the method of operative intelligence to direction of life in other - fields. 169 CHAPTER VII PHE SEATiOF INTEL EEC Oa, OUT EVO RT Pe THE DISPUTE as to whether reason and conception or percep- tion and sense are the source and test of ultimate knowledge is one of the most enduring in the history of thought. It has affected philosophy from the side of both the nature of the object of knowledge and the mental faculty operating to obtain it. From the side of the object those who put forward the claims of reason have placed the universal higher than the individual; those who have held to perception have re- versed the order. From the side of mind, one school has em- phasized the synthetic action of conceptions. The other school has dwelt upon the fact that in sensation the mind does not interfere with the action of objects in writing their own re- port. The opposition has extended to problems of conduct and society. On one hand, there is emphasis upon the neces- sity of control by rational standards; on the other hand, the dynamic quality of wants has been insisted upon together with the intimately personal character of their satisfaction as against the pale remoteness of pure thought. On the political side, there is a like division between the adherents of order and organization, those who feel that reason alone gives security, and those interested in freedom, innovation and progress, those who have used the claims of the individual and his desires as a philosophical basis. The controversy is acute and longstanding. In consequence of it, philosophers have expended energy in controversy with 170 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY one another, and the capella they have given_to_practical affairs has been largely f support to partisans of con- tending forces. The situation raises a further point in our in- quiry: What is the bearing of the_experimental theory of knowing Z upon the rival con contentions? The first polnt Which presents itself is that the object of knowledge is eventual; that is, it is an outcome of directed experimental operations, instead of something in sufficient existence before the act of knowing. The further point to be presented is that, along with this change, sensible and rational factors cease to be competi- tors for primary rank. They are allies, codperating to make knowledge possible. Isolation from each other is an expression of the isolation of each from organic connection with action. When theory is placed in opposition to practice, there is ground for dispute as to whether primacy in theory shall go to sense or intellect. Directed activity demands ideas which go beyond the results of past perceptions, for it goes out to meet future and as yet unexperienced situations. But it deals, both in origin -and outcome, with things which can be had only directly, through immediate perception and enjoyment. The three chief contending da es in this field are sen- sational empiricism rationalism and Kantianism, with ‘its com- promise of the factors isolated in t doctrine of Kant has a superficial resemblance to the one just stated; it insists upon the necessity of both perception and _ideas if there is to be knowledge. It is convenient, accordingly, to be- gin discussion with it. The element of similarity is suggested by Kant’s well known saying that perception without conception is blind, conception without perception empty. His doctrine none the less is fundamentally different from that which results from an analysis of experimental knowing. The fundamental difference lies in the fact that, according to the latter, the dis- tinction of sense and thought occurs within the process of re- Lat THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY flective inquiry, and the two are connected together by means of operations overtly performed. In the Kantian scheme, the two originally exist in independence of each other, and their connection is established by operations that are covert and are performed in the hidden recesses of mind, once for all. As to their original difference, sense-material is impressed from with- out, while connective conceptions are supplied from within the understanding. As to connection, synthesis takes place not in- tentionally and by means of the controlled art of investigation, but automatically and all at once. _ From the experimental point of view, the art of knowing demands skill in selecting appropriate sense-data on one side and connecting principles, or conceptual theories, on the other. \ It requires a developed and constantly progressive technique to settle upon both the observational data and the idea that assist inquiry in reaching a conclusion in any particular case. But in Kant’s view, the distinction and the connection between the two, while necessary to anything which may be termed cognition, have nothing to do with the validity of any particu- lar enterprise of knowing. Illusion and error exemplify the synthesis of sense and understanding quite as much as does the soundest instance of scientific discovery. In one case, the heart of the whole matter is the exercise of a differential control which makes the difference between good and bad knowing. In Kant’s scheme the blessings of the categories descend upon the material of sense without reference to making a distinction be- tween the true and the false. We summarize the differences as follows. 1. In experi- mental knowing, the antecedent is always the subject-matter of some experience which has its origin in natural causes, but which, not having been controlled in its occurrence, is uncertain and problematic. Original objects of experience are produced by the natural interactions of organism and environment, and 172 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY in themselves are neither sensible, conceptual nor a mixture of the two. They are precisely the qualitative material of all our ordinary untested experiences. 2. The distinction between sense- data and interpretive ideas is deliberately instituted by the process of inquiry, for sake of carrying it forward to an ade- quately tested conclusion, one with a title to acceptance. 3. Hence each term of the distinction is not absolute and fixed, but is contingent and tentative. Each is subject to revision as we find observational data which supply better evidence, and as the growth of science provides better directive hypotheses to draw upon. 4. Hence the material selected to serve as data and as regulative principles constantly check one another; any advance in one brings about a corresponding improvement in the other. The two are constantly working together to effect a rearrange- ment of the original experienced material in the construction of a new object having the properties that make it understood or known. These statements are formal, but their meaning is not rec- ondite. Any scientific investigation illustrates their significance. The astronomer, chemist, botanist, start from the material of gross unanalyzed experience, that of the “common-sense” world in which we live, suffer, act and enjoy; from familiar stars, suns, moons, from acids, salts and metals, trees, mosses and growing plants. Then the process of investigation divides into two kinds of operations. One is that of careful and analytic observation to determine exactly what there is which is indubi- tably seen, touched and heard. An operation takes place to dis- cover what the sure data of the problem are, the evidence which theoretical explanation must reckon with. The other operation consists in searching through previous knowledge to obtain ideas which may be used to interpret this observed material and to suggest the initiation of new experiments. By these lat- ter, more data are had, and the additional evidence they 173 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY supply suggests new ideas and more experiments until the prob- lem is resolved. The investigator never makes the division be- tween perceptual and conceptual material at large or whole- sale. He is careful at each stage of inquiry to discriminate between what he has observed and what is a matter of theory and ideas, using the latter as means of directing further ob- servations, the results of which test the application of the ideas and theories employed. Finally, the original ma- terial is reorganized into a coherent and settled form capable of entering integrally into the general system of science, A physician, for example, is called by a patient. His orig- inal material of experience is thereby provided; it requires a stretch of useless imagination to fancy that the ill man is a mass of sense data organized by categories. This experienced object sets the problem of inquiry. Certain clinical operations — are performed, sounding, tapping, getting registrations of pulse, temperature, respiration, etc. These constitute the symp- toms; they supply the evidence to be interpreted. The philoso- pher or logician, looking on, sees they are that part of the original object which is capable of being presented in observa- tion as that is sensibly present. The results are not all that is or can be observed, but are those phases and portions of the experienced whole that are judged to be relevant to making an inference as.to the nature of the ailment. The observations mean something not in and of themselves, but are given meaning in the light of the systematized knowledge of medi- cine as far as that is at the command of the practitioner. He calls upon his store of knowledge to suggest ideas that may aid him in reaching a judgment as to the nature of the trouble and its proper treatment. The analytic philosopher, looking on, notes that the interpreting material, by means of which the scattered data of sense are bound together into a coherent 174 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY whole, is not itself directly sensibly present. So he calls it ideational _ or.conceptual. Sense data are signs which direct this selection of ideas; the ideas when suggested arouse new observations; the two together determine his final judgment or diagnosis and his procedure. Something is then added to the store of the clinical material of medical art so that subsequent observations of symptoms are refined and extended, and the store of material from which to draw ideas is further enlarged. To this process of codperation of observation and conceptual or general ideas there is no limit. In no case are the data the whole of the original object; they are material selected for the purpose of serving as evidence and signs. In no case do general ideas, prin- ciples, laws, conceptions, determine the conclusion—although just as some men collect fragmentary observations without trying to find out what they mean, so in other cases an un- skilled worker permits some preconceived idea to control his decision instead of using it as a hypothesis. The case seems simple enough, so simple indeed that it may be supposed that we have overlooked the conditions which have created perplexity and controversy. But the source of these complications is that theories about the mind, about sen- sation and perception, about reason, the intellect, conceptions and perception, were framed and established .ed_in_ philosophy before the rise of experimental knowing. It is dif is difficult to break loose from habits thus engendered so as to turn attention in a whole-hearted way to actual inquiry. While it may seem pre- sumptuous to set up the case of the physician or some other concrete inquirer over against the elaborate machinery of the Critique of Pure Reason and the countless tomes of commen- tary it has called forth, our picture has behind it the whole weight of the experimental practices by which science has been actually advanced. 175 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY More specifically, it may be asserted that the Kantian the- ory went wrong because it took distinctions that are genuine and indispensable out of their setting and function in actual inquiry. It generalized them into fixed and wholesale distinc- tions, losing sight of their special réles in attainment of those tested beliefs which give security. Consequently artificial com- plications were engendered, and {soluble puzzles created. Take for example the fragmentary and isolated character of sense-data. Taken in isolation from a context in a particu- lar inquiry they undoubtedly have this character. Hence when they are generalized into a character at large, the result is the doctrine of the disconnected “atomicity” of sense-data. This doctrine is common to sensationalism and to some forms of the new realism, along with Kantianism. As a matter of fact, smells, tastes, sounds, pressures, colors, etc., are not iso- lated; they are bound together by all kinds of interactions or connections, among which are included the habitual responses of the one having the experience. Some connections are organic, flowing from the constitution of the subject. Others have be- come engrained in habit because of education and the cus- tomary state of culture. But these habitual connections are obstacles rather than aids. Some of them are irrelevant and mis- leading. In any case, they fail to provide the clews, the evi- dence, which is wanted in the particular inquiry in hand. Con- sequently, sense qualities are ‘artificially isolated from their ordinary connections so that the inquirer is free to see them in a new light or as constituents of a new object. Since the very need for inquiry shows that there is a problem set by the existing situation, there can be no under- standing of it achieved until there are new connections estab- lished. The fragmentary and isolated character of sense-data does not therefore describe anything belonging to them intrin- sically, but marks a transitory, although necessary, stage in 176 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY the progress of inquiry. The isolation of sense-data from their status and office in furthering the objective of knowing is re- sponsible for treating them as a kind of isolated atomic exist- ence. If we keep an eye on the actual enterprise of knowing, it is clear that only sense-data can supply evidential subject- matter; ideas of what is not presented in sense interpret evi- dence, but they cannot constitute it, The whole history of science shows, however, that material directly and originally observed does not furnish good evidential material; as we saw, it was the essential mistake of ancient science to suppose that we can base inference upon observed objects without an artificial prior analytic resolution. Hence there is need of a distinctive type of experimental operations which detach some qualities of the object; these form sense-data in the technical meaning of the word. Traditional empiricism was accordingly right in insisting that no amount of conceptions, of thought material, could by itself deliver any knowledge of existence, no matter how elaborate be the conceptual system and how internally coher- | ent. We cannot derive existence from thought—pace idealism. Observed material is necessary to suggest ideas and it is equally necessary to test them. The senses are, existentially speaking, the organs by which we obtain the material of observation. But, as we have previously noted, this material is significant and effective for purposes of knowing only as it is connected with operations of which it is the product. Merely physical interactions, whether of external things or of the organism, yield observations that form the material of inquiry; a prob- lematic material. Only operations intentionally performed and attentively noted im connection with their products give ob- served material a positive intellectual value, and this condi- tion is satisfied only by thought: ideas-ame-the-perception~ of this connection. Even non-scientific experience, as far as it oi 3 177 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY has meaning, is neither mere doing nor mere undergoing, but is an acknowledgment of the connection between something done and something undergone in consequence of the doing. In its later history, empiricism tended to identify sensory consequences with “mental” or psychical states and processes; this identification was the logical conclusion of taking the ob- ject of science, in which these qualities are not found, as the real object. But the insistence, as by contemporary realists, that sense-data are external and not mental does not remedy the logical error. It repeats the isolation of sense-data from the intentional operations by which they are supplied and from the purpose and function of these operations. Hence it makes it necessary to call in the supplement of logical objects, now termed essences. What is even more important, no light is thrown upon the control of the course of actual inquiry. For there is still failure to see that the distinction between sense- data and objects of rational apprehension is one which occurs within reflective investigation, for the sake of regulating its procedure. The history of the theory of knowledge or epistemology would have been very different if instead of the word “data” or “givens,” it had happened to start with callin _quali- ties in question “takens.” Not that the data are not existential and qualities of the ultimately “given”—that is, the total subject-matter which is had in non-cognitive experiences. But as data they are selected from this total original subject-mat- ter which gives the impetus to knowing; they are discriminated for a purpose:—that, namely, of affording signs or evidence to define and locate a problem, and thus give a clew to its resolution. If we recur to the instance of the patient and the inquiries of the physician, it is evident that the presence of a man who is ill is the “given,” and that this given is complex, marked 178 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY by all kinds of diverse qualities. Only the assumption—such is made by Kant and is common to the traditional theories— that all experience is inherently cognitive leads to the doctrine that perception of the patient is a case of knowledge. In reality the original perception furnishes the problem for knowing; it is something to de known, not an object of knowing. And in knowing, the first thing to be done is to select from the mass of presented qualities those which, in distinction from other qualities, throw light upon the nature of the trouble. As they are deliberately selected, being discriminated by special tech- nical operations, they become data; these are called sensible simply because of the réle of sense organs in their generation. They may then be formulated as the subject-matter of primi- tive existential propositions. But even so, there is no class of such propositions im general. Each inquiry yields its own primitive existential propositions, even though they all agree in having for their objects qualities which investigation reveals to be connected with the use of organs of sense. Moreover, these primitive propositions are such only in a logical sense as distinct from being empirically primitive, and they are only hypothetical or conditional. This statement does not imply that their existence 1s hypothetical; perception, as far as it is properly conducted, warrants their existence. But their status in inquiry is tentative. Many, perhaps most, errors in physical inference arise from taking as data things that are not data for the problem in hand; they undoubtedly exist, but they are not the evidence that is demanded. In some respects, the more undoubted the existence of sensory qualities, the less certain is their meaning for inference; the very fact that a quality is glaringly obvious in perception exercises an undue influence, leading thought to take its evident presence as an equivalent of evidential value. The reader of detective stories is aware that it is a common device to have the inquirer misled by the too 179 me THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY patent character of given “clews”; genuine clews are usually obscure and have to be searched out. The conditional character of sense-data in inferential inquiry means, then, that they have to be tested by their consequences. They are good clews or evidence when they instigate operations whose effect is to solve the problem in hand. It is hardly necessary to repeat the criticisms of the ration- alistic doctrine of conceptions that have been brought out in previous chapters. The doctrine stood for a positive truth:— the necessity of relations, of connectivity in existence and knowledge, and it noted the fact of the connection of relations with thought. For while some connections are always found in the material of experienced things, the fact that as experi- enced these things are problematic and not definitively known, means that important relations are mot presented in them as they stand. These relations have to be projected in anticipation if the reactions of the inquiries are not blind fumblings—if they are genuinely experimental. Such relations must be thought; they are present conceptually, not sensibly. They represent possible consequences of operations, and the possible and the conceivable are one. Just as sensationalism ignores the functional rdle and hypothetical status of sensible qualities in an inquiry, so rationalism makes a fixed and independent mat- ter out of the utility of co ions in directing inquiry to solve particular problems. a ee knowl- tention to the source of their errors. As soon as and when- ever it is assumed that the office of knowledge is to lay hold of existence which is prior to and apart from the operations of inquiry and their consequences, one or other of these errors or some combination of both of them is inevitable. Either logical characters belonging to the operations of effective 180 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY inquiry are read into antecedent existence; or the world as known is reduced to a pulverized multiplicity of atomically isolated elements, a Kantian “manifold”; or some machinery is devised, whether of an “idealistic” or a “realistic” sort, to bring the two together. When, on the other hand, it is seen that the object of knowledge is prospective and eventual, being the result of inferential or reflective operations which redispose what was antecedently existent, the subject-matters called respectively sensible and conceptual are seen to be complementary in effec- tive direction of inquiry to an intelligible conclusion. There is another way of discussing the fundamental issue which does not involve so much going over topics worn thread- bare by previous discussion. In effect, traditional theories treat all reflective or inferential knowing as cases of “explanation,” and by explanation is meant making some seemingly new ob- ject or problem plain and clear by identifying its elements with something previously known, ultimately something said to be known immediately and intuitively, or without infer- ence. In traditional theory, “discursive” knowledge, that in- volving reflection, must always be referred for its validation back to what is immediately known. It cannot bring its credentials with it and test its results in the very process of reaching them. There is postulated identity implicit or explicit of the results of inference with things known without infer- ence. Making the identity explicit constitutes proof. There are many different and opposed theories regarding the way in which this identification takes place. There is a doc- trine that the operation is one of subsumption of given particu- lars under given universals; that it is classificatory definition; that it is a kind of Platonic reminiscence in which perceptual material is cognized by being identified with @ priort forms; that it is a case of schematization 4 Ja Kant; that it is an 181 =o § THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY assimilation of present sensations to images that revive previ- ous sensations. ‘These theories differ widely among themselves; they are irreconcilable with one another. But they all have one premise in common. They all assume that the conclusions of re- flective inference must be capable of reduction to things already known if they are to be proved. The quarrel between them is strictly domestic, all in the family. The differences between them concern the character of the original immediately known objects with which the conclusions of reflection must be identi- fied in order to be really known. They all involve the sup- posed necessity that whatever is a product of inference must, in order to be valid knowledge, be reducible to something already known immediately. Thus they all take the element of knowledge found in inferential conclusions to be simply a mat- ter of restatement.* Thé especial significance of the experimental procedure is that it scraps once for all the notion that the results of infer- ence must be validated by operations of identification of what- ever sort. When we compare the premise which underlies all the different theories that assume a primitive mode of direct knowledge (knowledge which does not include reflection) with the practice of experimental science, according to which only the conclusion of reflective inquiry is known, we find three marked points of contrast. The first difference is that the traditional theories make all reflective knowledge to be a case of recognition going back to an earlier more certain form of * The logic of Stuart Mill is the classic logic of sensational empiricism. Yet he demanded “canons” of proof for induction as rigorous as those of Aristotle were for syllogistic reasoning. The essence of these canons is that proof consists in identification of the results of inference with particulars given in sense, just as with Aristotle demonstration consisted in subsuming them under independently given universals. That the latter was influenced by Euclidean geometry with its assumption of axioms as self-evident truths we have already noticed. Mathematicians now recognize that indemonstrables and indefinables are starting points of operations and that in themselves they have neither meaning nor “truth.” 182 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY knowledge. The second is that they have no place for genuine discovery, or creative novelty. The third point concerns the dogmatic character of the assumption regarding what is said to be immediately known, in contrast with the experimentally tested character of the object known in consequence of reflec- tion. We begin with the last point. When it is stated that the conclusions of knowledge involving inference must be sub- ordinated to knowledge which is had directly and immediately, and must be carried to the latter for proof and verification, we are at once struck by the multitude of theories regarding what is immediately and infallibly known. The diversity and con- tradictions give ground for a suspicion that in no case is the “knowledge” in question as self-evident as it is asserted to be. And there is good theoretical ground for the suspicion. Suppose a man “explains” the eclipse of the moon by saying it is due to the attempt of a dragon to devour it. To him the devouring dragon is a more evident fact than is the darkening of the moon. To us the existence of an animal capable of such a feat is the doubtful matter. It will be objected that it is unfair to take such an absurd case as an instance: dragons are not the sort of thing which any philosopher has asserted to be the ob- ject of direct and certain non-inferential knowledge. But the illustration still serves a purpose. The thing to be known is “explained” by identification with something else. What guarantees this something else? If it too has to be guaranteed by identification with something else, there is an infinite regress, To avoid this regress, we stop short and assert that this or that object or truth is directly known, by sense intuition, by rational intuition, as a direct de- liverance of consciousness, or in some other way. But what is such a procedure except the essence of what Bentham called ipse dixitism? What is it but arbitrary dogmatism? Who guards 183 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY the guardians? The theory which places knowledge in rounded | out conclusions is in no such dilemma. It admits the hypo- thetical status of all data and premises and appeals for justi- fication to operations capable, when they are repeated, of yielding like results. The antecedents do not have to be sub- | stantiated by being carried back to earlier antecedents and so | on; they are good and sound if they do what is wanted of them: if they lead to an observable result which satisfies the conditions set by the nature of the problem in hand. The significance of this point comes out more clearly in dealing with the genuineness of discovery or new knowledge. By terms of the traditional theories, this is impossible in the case of inference and reflective inquiry. We know, according to them, only when we have assimilated the seemingly new to something previously known immediately. In consequence, all distinctive individual, or non-repeated, traits of things are incapable of being known. What cannot be treated as a case of something else stays outside knowledge. Individualized characteristics are unknowable(urds._ According to this doctrine, reflective inquiry may hit upon new instances of laws, new specimens of old truths, new mem- bers of old classes, but not upon intrinsically new objects of knowledge. As far as empiricism is concerned the case of Locke is instructive. His Essay on Human Understanding is one continued effort to test all reflective beliefs and ideas what- ever by reduction to original “simple ideas” that are infallibly known in isolation from any inferential undertaking—a point in which many of the new realisms are still Lockeian. If one looks at the course of science, we find a very differ- ent story told. Important conclusions of science are those which distinctly refuse to be identified with anything_previously known. Instead of having to be proved by being assimilated to the latter, they rather occasion revision of what men thought 184 THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY they previously knew. The recent crisis in physical science is a case in point. The experimental discovery that the velocity of light remains the same when measured either with or against the direction of the earth’s movement was totally unaccount- able on the basis of previous knowing. But scientific men accepted the consequences of their experimental operations as constituting the known object, rather than feeling under obli- gation to “prove” them by identification with what was said to be antecedently known. Inferential inquiry in scientific pro- cedure is an adventure in which conclusions confound expecta- - tion and upset what has been accepted as facts. It takes time for these new facts to be assimilated: to become familiar. As- similation of the new to the familiar is doubtless a precondi- tion for our finding ourselves at home in the new and being able to handle it freely. But the older theories virtually made this personal and psychological phase of assimilation of new and old into a test of knowledge itself. The third point, that cognition is recognition, only presents the same difficulty in another way. It présents it in a light which brings out a distinctive point. The theory that knowledge due to reflection consists in identifying something with what is already known or possessed confuses the psychological trait of familiarity, the quality of finding ourselves at ease in a situation, with knowledge. The conception originated when experimental knowing occurred only occasionally and as if by accident; when discoveries were regarded as gifts of the gods or as special inspirations: when men were governed by custom and were uneasy in the presence of change and afraid of the unknown. It was rationalized into a theory when the Greeks succeeded in identifying natural phenomena with ra- tional ideas and were delighted with the identification because their esthetic interest made them at home in a world of such harmony and order as that identification involved. They called 185 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY the result science, although in fact it fastened wrong beliefs about nature upon Europe for well nigh two thousand years. Newtonian science, as we have seen in another connection, in effect only substituted one set of identifying objects, the mathematical, for those previously employed. It set up per- manent substances, the particles or atoms having inherent mathematical properties, as ultimate realities, and alleged that reflective thought yields knowledge when it translates phe- nomena into these properties. ‘Thus it retained unimpaired the theory that knowing signifies a process of identification. It required over two centuries for the experimental method to reach a point where men were forced to realize that progress in science depends upon choice of operations performed and not upon the properties of objects which were alleged to be so antecedently certain and fixed that all detailed phenomena might be reduced to them. This conception of knowledge still dominates thinking in social and moral matters. When it is realized that in these fields as in the physical, we know what we intentionally construct, that everything depends upon deter- mination of methods of operation and upon observation of the consequences which test them, the progress of knowledge in these affairs may also become secure and constant. What has been said does not imply that previous knowl- edge is not of immense importance in obtaining new knowl- edge. What is denied is that this previous knowledge need be immediate or intuitive, and that it provides the measure and standard of conclusions obtained by inferential operations. In- ferential inquiry is continuous; one phase passes into the next which uses, tests and expands conclusions already obtained. More particularly, the conclusions of prior knowledge are the instruments of new inquiries, not the norm which determines their validity. Objects of previous knowledge supply working hypotheses for new situations; they are the source of sugges- 186 et ie THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY tion of new operations; they direct inquiry. But they do not enter into reflective knowing by way of providing its prem- ises in a logical sense. The tradition of classic logic persists in leading philosophers to call premises what in effect are regulative and instrumental points of view for conducting new observations. We are constantly referring to what is already known to get our bearings in any new situation. Unless there is some reason to doubt whether presumptive knowledge is really knowledge, we take it as a net product. It would be a waste of time and energy to repeat the operations in virtue of which the object is a known object unless there were ground for sus- ‘pecting its validity. Every adult, irrespective of whether he is a man of science or not, carries in his head a large store of things known in virtue of earlier operations. When a new problem comes up, one habitually refers to what is already known to get a start in dealing with it. Such objects, until we have occasion to doubt them, are settled, assured; the given situation is dubious, but they are secure. Hence we take them for granted, we take them as a matter of course. Then if we question them, we tend to fall back upon something else already known. What is too easily overlooked (especially in quest for certainty by attachment to the fixed) is that the objects we thus fall back upon are themselves known in virtue of previous operations of inferential inquiry and test, and that their “immediacy” as objects of reference marks an as- sured product of reflection. It is also overlooked that they are referred to as instruments, rather than as fixed in and of themselves. The case is similar to the use of tools previously manufactured when we are dealing with the conditions of a new situation; only when they prove defective does invention of new tools demand recurrence to the operations by which they were originally constructed. 187 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY | This act of taking and using objects already known is practically justified; it is like eating a fruit without asking how it was grown. But many theories of knowledge take this retrospective use of things known in virtue of earlier opera- tions as typical of the nature of knowledge itself. Being re- minded of something we already know is taken as the pattern of all knowing. When the thing of which we are now retro- spectively aware was in process of being known, it was prospec- tive and eventual to inquiry, not something already “given.” And it has cognitive force in a new inquiry whose objective and ultimate object is mow prospective. Taking what is already known or pointing to it is no more a case of knowledge than taking a chisel out of a tool-box is the making of the tool. Because some theories of knowledge have taken the operations that yield the known object to be merely mental or psychical instead of overt redispositions of antecedent subject-matter (and thus have terminated in some form of “idealism”) is no reason for denying the mediated character of all known objects. (Thus we are led by another road to the conclusion that the basic error of traditional theories of knowledge resides in the isolation and fixation of some phase of the whole process of inquiry in resolving problematic situations. Sometimes sense- data are so taken; sometimes, conceptions; sometimes, objects previously known. An episode in a series of operational acts is fastened upon, and then in its isolation and consequent frag- mentary character is made the foundation of the theory of knowing in its entirety. 7 Reflective knowing certainly involves identification. But identity itself has to be defined operationally. There are as many meanings of identity and identification as there are types of operation by which they are determined. There is identifi- cation of an object as a member of a class, of a plant as belong- 188 THE SHAY OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY ing to a certain species: taxonomic identity. The classic theory of definition took this to be the sole valid type of logical definition. There are identifications that are historic, that are concerned with individuals as such. They define the identity of an individual throughout a series of successive temporal changes, while the other type is purely static. This kind of identity is secured by operations that introduce temporal con- tinuity into what is otherwise discrete: it yields genetic and generative definitions. For the identity of an individual is constituted by continued absorption and incorporation of ma- terials previously external—as in the growth of a person, a nation or a social movement. It demands operations that re- dispose and organize what antecedently exists. Identifications effected by inferential operations are of this type. They are not reductions of the new object or situation to terms of some- thing already known. Traditional theories treat them as if they were of the static and subsumptive type. Hence these theories have no way of accounting for the discrimination and differentiation, the novel elements, involved in the conclusions of inferential knowing. They must be viewed as mere surds, cognitively speaking. Identifications through processes of temporal growth are, on the contrary, differen- tiations; new and previously external material is incorporated; otherwise there is no growth, no development. All reflective inquiry starts from a problematic situation, and no such situa- tion can be settled in its own terms. It evolves into a resolved situation only by means of introduction of material not found in the situation itself. Imaginative survey, comparison with things already known, is the first step. This does not eventuate in complete knowledge, however, until some overt experi- mental act takes place by means of which an existential in- ‘corporation and organization is brought about. Merely “men- tal” revisions remain in the status of thought as distinct from 189 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY knowledge. Identification through operations that rearrange what is antecedently given is a process of additive discrimina- tion; it alone is synthetic in the true sense of that word, in- | volving likeness-and-difference. Objective idealisms have insisted upon the conjoint pres- ence of identity and difference in objects of knowledge, as in the doctrine of the “concrete universal.” But they have ignored the phase of temporal reconstruction with its necessity for overt existential interaction. A further implication of the experimental determination of the known object concerns its office in the verification of hypotheses. It is often supposed that the value of experiment lies merely in the fact that it confirms, refutes or modifies a hypothesis. From the standpoint of the personal interest of the inquirer such an interpretation often holds good. He is interested in a theory, and views the eventually disclosed state of facts solely in its bearing upon the theory he is entertain- ing. To him, at the time, the cognitive value of the results of experimental operation lies in the test they afford of the claims of his hypothesis. Even so, however, verification, or the oppo- site, is attained only because experimentation effects a transi- tion of a problematical situation into a resolved one. In this development new individual objects with new features are brought to light. As far as the objective course of knowledge is concerned, as distinct from the personal interest of the investigator, zhés result is the important one; in comparison with it the verification of a hypothesis is secondary and inci- dental. The institution of a new object of experience is the essential fact. It would not occur to any one surveying the body of scientific knowledge as a whole to think that its value lay in the corroboration it provides for a number of hypoth- eses, Taken in the large, the significance of the body of sub- ject-matter as a whole clearly resides in the fact that it marks 190 a i a a THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY an added depth, range and fullness of meaning conferred upon objects of ordinary experience. This consequence is the only intelligible end that can be assigned to processes of reflective inquiry. It marks a gain that during their course hypotheses have gained increased solidity. But the eventual object of activity with tools is not to perfect tools, but is found in what tools accomplish, the products they turn out: When a person working on the basis of a certain idea succeeds in making an invention, his idea is verified. But verification was not the purpose of making the invention, nor does it constitute its value when made. The same may be said of physicians working upon a certain hy- pothesis in cure of a disease. Only an ultra-specialist would regard a successful outcome simply as verification of a theory. Since a hypothesis is itself instrumental to inquiry, its verifi- cation cannot constitute the whole significance of inquiry. Hypotheses which have later been rejected have often proved serviceable in discovery of new facts, and thus ad- vanced knowledge. A poor tool is often better than none at all. It has even been doubted whether any hypothesis ever entertained has not turned out later to have been erroneous in important respects. It is still questioned whether many of the objects of the most valuable and indispensable hypotheses in present use have actual existence; the existential status of the electron is still, for example, a matter of controversy. In many cases, as in the older theory of the nature of atoms, it is now clear that their worth was independent of the existen- tial status imputed to their subject-matter; that indeed this imputation was irrelevant and as far as it went injurious. As we have seen, progress beyond the Newtonian scheme was made possible when the ascription of antecedently existing inherent properties was dropped out, and concepts were re- garded as designations of operations to be performed. 191 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY These considerations have a practical importance with re- spect to the attitude of disdain often affeoted—usually in be- half of preservation of some dogma—toward the course of science. It is pointed out that scientific men are constantly en- gaged in furbishing and refurbishing their theories, rejecting those to which they have been devoted, and putting new ones in their place only in time to reject these also. Then it is de- manded why we should put our trust in science self-confessed to be unstable rather than in some old dogma which men have continued to believe without change. It is overlooked that the instability affects the intellectual apparatus which is employed, conceptions which are frankly hypothetical. What remains and is not discarded but is added to is the body of concrete knowledge and of definite controls constructed by conceptions no longer tenable. No one would dream of re- flecting adversely upon the evolution of mechanical inven- tions because the sickle had been discarded for the mowing machine, and the mechanized tractor substituted for the horse- drawn mower. We are obviously confronted with betterment of the instrumentalities that are employed to secure consequences. The adverse criticism of science just mentioned attaches only to some of the philosophic interpretations which have been advanced. If scientific conceptions were valid in the degree in which they are revelations of antecedent properties of real Being and existence (as the Newtonian scheme took them to be), there would be something disturbing in their continual revamping. The claim of any one of them to be valid would suffer discredit. Not so, if they are instrumentalities which direct operations of experimental observations, and if the knowledge-property resides in conclusions. Fruits remain and these fruits are the abiding advance of knowledge. Thus the breaking down of the traditional barrier between theory, sup- posed to be concerned with prior reality and practice con- 192 = si sone THE SEAT OF INTELLECTUAL AUTHORITY cerned with production of consequences, protects the actual results of theory from cavil._ At the same time, it does away once for all with the grounds upon which wholesale skeptical and agnostic philoso- phies have rested. As long as theories of knowledge are framed in terms of organs assigned to mind or consciousness, whether sense or reason or any combination of the two, organs occupied, it is alleged, in reproducing or grasping antecedent_reality, there will continue to exist such generalized skeptical philoso- phies. Phenomenalism, which holds that impressions and ideas come between the knower and things to be known, will have | plenty of support as long as sensations and ideas are supposed | to be valid only when they report to mind something prior to them. Phenomenalism may be objected to on the ground that data, ideas, essences, are means of knowing, not its ob- jects. But as long as they are regarded as merely mental means rather than as means which through overt acts effect actual redisposition of antecedent things, the retort will have the character of an arbitrary tour de force; it will be a pious doctrine rather than a conclusion empirically verified. It is always in place to be doubtful or skeptical about par- ticular items of supposed knowledge when evidence to the contrary presents itself. There is no knowledge self-guaranteed acts of inquiry. Agnosticism as confession of ignorance about special matters, in the absence of adequate evidence, is not only in place under such circumstances but is an act of intel- lectual honesty. But such skepticism and agnosticism are par- ticular and depend upon special conditions; they are not whole- sale; they do not issue from a generalized impeachment of the adequacy of the organs of knowing to perform their office. Theories which assume that the knowing subject, that mind or consciousness, have an inherent capacity to disclose reality, 193 “4 ge . ai to be infallible, since all knowledge is the product of special / THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY a capacity operating apart from any overt interactions of the organism with surrounding conditions, are invitations to gen- eral philosophical doubt. The case stands radically otherwise when it is seen that “mental” states and acts are organs of knowing things not directly, but through the overt actions which they evoke and direct. ‘Kor the consequences of these acts constitute the object said to be known; and these consequences are public and open? Doubt and skepticism attach only to the adequacy of the opera- tions used in achieving the issue which transforms a prob- lematic situation into a settled or resolved one. Instead of being impotent and paralyzing, they are opportunities for bettering concrete methods of inquiry. Once more, we recur to the problem raised concerning the possibility of carrying over the essential elements of the pat- tern of experimental knowing into the experience of man in its everyday traits. A statement that judgments about regulative ends and values, the creeds that are to govern conduct in its important interests, are upon the whole matters of tradition, dogma and imposition from alleged authorities, hardly re- quires argument in its support. It is equally patent that skep- ticism is rife as to the value of purposes and policies of life thus supplied; the skepticism often extends to complete agnos- ticism as to the possibility of any regulative ends and stand- ards whatever. The course of human experience in such matters is supposed to be inherently chaotic. Even more precious than the special conclusions of scientific inquiry is its proof that intel- ligent experimental inquiry is possible which, when it is used, will develop expansion of ideas and regulation of securely tested consequences. It is, once more, a hypothesis rather than a settled fact that extension and transfer of experimental method is gen- erally possible. But like other hypotheses it is to be tried in action, and the future histo ind is at stake in the trial. 194 —— a CHAPTER ViFt TE NAL ORALIZ AL VONY Ok INTELLIGENCE _ Every stupent oF philosophy is aware of the number of seeming impassés into which the theory of knowledge has been led. There are four general types of subject-matter whose rival claims to be the objects of true knowledge have to be either disposed of or in some way accommodated to one an- other. At one pole, are immediate sense-data which are said to be the immediate and accordingly most certain objects in knowledge of existence: the original material from which knowledge of nature must set out. At the other pole, are mathematical and logical objects. Somewhere between them lie the objects of physical science, the products of an elaborate ae of reflective inquiry. Then there are the objects of everyday experience, the concrete things of the world in which we live and which, from the standpoint of our practi- cal affairs, our enjayments and sufferings, form the world we live in. To common sense these are the most important if not the most real of all objects of knowing. Recent philosophy has been increasingly occupied with the problems which grow out of the titles of these various kinds of objects to jurisdic- tion over the field of knowledge. From some point of view, the pretensions of each seem to be supreme. The problem, however, is far from being a purely techni- cal one. There has been repeated occasion to note that the claim of physical objects, the objects in which the physical sciences terminate, to constitute the real nature of the world, 195 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY places the objects of value with which our affections and choices are concerned at an invidious disadvantage. The mathe- matician often doubts the claims of physics to be a science in the full sense of the word; the psychologist may quarrel with both; and the devotees of physical inquiry are suspicious of the claims of those who deal with human affairs, historians and students of social life. The biological subjects which stand between and form a connecting link are often refused the title of science if they adopt principles and categories dif- ferent from those of strict physics. The net practical effect is the creation of the belief that science exists only in the things which are most remote from any significant human con- cern, so that as we approach social and moral questions and interests we must either surrender hope of the guidance of genuine knowledge or else purchase a scientific title and authority at the expense of all that is distinctly human. Those who have followed the previous discussions will not be surprised to hear that, from the standpoint of experimental knowing, all of the,rivalries and connected problems grow from a single root. Shey spring from the assumption that the true and valid object of knowledge is that which has being prior to and independent of the operations of knowing. They spring from the doctrine that knowledge is a grasp or be- holding of reality without anything being done to modify its antecedent state—the doctrine which 3 ce of the sepa- ‘ration of knowledge from practical activity. JIf we see that knowing is not the act of an outside spectator but of a partici- pator inside the natural and social scene, then the true object of knowledge resides in the consequences of directed action. When we take this point of view, if only by way of a hy- pothesis, the perplexities and difficulties of which we have been speaking vanish. For on this basis there will be as many kinds of known objects as there are kinds of effectively con- 196 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE ducted operations of inquiry which result in the consequences intended. The result of one operation will be as good and true an object of knowledge as is any other, provided it is good at all: provided, that is, it satisfies the conditions which induced the inquiry. For if consequences are the object of know- ing, then an archetypal antecedent reality is not a model to which the conclusions of inquiry must conform. One might even go as far as to say that there are as many kinds of valid knowledge as there are conclusions wherein distinctive operations have been employed to solve the problems set by antecedently experienced situations. For operations dealing with different problems never exactly repeat one another and do not determine exactly the same consequences. However, as far as logical theory is concerned, operations fall into certain kinds or types. It is the bearing of our principle upon the valid- ity of these kinds that we are directly concerned with. It is only repeating what has been said to assert that no problem can be solved without a determination of the data which define and locate it and which furnish clews or evi- dence. In so far, when we secure dependable sense-data, we know truly. Again, the systematic progress of inquiry in deal- ing with physical problems requires that we determine those metric properties by means of which correlations of changes are instituted so as to make predictions possible. These form the objects of physical science, and if our operations are ade- quate they are truly known. We develop operations, through symbols, which connect possible operations with one another; their outcome gives the formal objects of mathematics and logic, As consequences of suitable operations these too are truly, known. Finally, when these operations, or some combination of them, are used to solve the problems which arise in con- nection with the things of ordinary perceived and enjoyed 197 —— THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY objects, the latter, as far as they are consequences of these operations, are themselves truly known. We know whenever we do know; that is, whenever our inquiry leads to conclusions which settle the problem out of which it grew. This truism is the end of the whole imatter—upon the condition that we frame our theory of knowledge in accord with the pattern set by experimental methods. The conclusions, however, are not truistic; they certainly are not trivial. The more complex the conditions with which operations are concerned, the fuller and richer are their con- sequences. Consequently, the more significant, although not the truer, is the resulting knowledge. The advantage of physical knowledge depends upon the fact that it deals with fewer conditions, those of a narrower and more isolated range, by means of operations that are more precise and more technical. There is no difference in principle between knowledge of them and knowledge of the most complex human affairs, but there is a decided practical difference. To be an object of specifically physical knowledge is the same thing as being an object of operations that discriminate definitely fundamental relations of the experienced world from others, and that deal with them in their discriminated character. The gain is great. But the objects thus known lay no claim to be final. When used as factors for inquiring into phenomena of life and society they become instrumental; they cease to be inclusive, and become part of a method for understanding more complex phenomena. From this point of view, the objects of our common sense ’ world (by which is signified that in which we live, with our loves and hates, our defeats and achievements, our choices, strivings and enjoyments) have a double status. When they precede operations of competent directed inquiry, they are not matters of knowledge; they are experienced just as they 198 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE happen to occur. They thus set problems for inquiry, problems of varied scope. But they are of such a nature that things of the most limited range, the purely physical, are the first to be successfully dealt with. But in the degree in which fuller and more complex social and moral affairs—which of course in- clude physical and biological conditions and relations within themselves—are transformed by becoming consequences of operations made possible by the limited forms of knowing, they also are objects of knowledge. While they are not more real, they are richer and more significant objects than are those of any other type of knowledge. ‘The special results of science are always finding their way back into the natural and social environment of daily life and modifying it) This fact does not of itself cause the latter to be known objects. A typical example is the effect of physical science upon a worker in a factory; he may merely become an attachment to a machine for a number of hours a day. Physi- cal science has had its effect in changing social conditions. But there has been no correspondingly significant increase of intelligent understanding. The application of physical knowl- edge has taken place in a technical way for the sake of limited consequences. But when the operations in which physical science is used are such as to transform distinctively human values in behalf of a human interest, those who participate in these consequences have a knowledge of the things of ordinary per- ception, use and enjoyment as genuine and fuller and deeper than that of the scientist in his laboratory.AY ere we to define science not in the usual technical way, but_as-a_knowledee- that accrues when methods are employed which deal com- petently with problems that present themselves, the physician, engineer, artist, craftsman, lay claim to scientific knowing. Thesé statements go contrary to the philosophic tradition. 199 a Af THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY They do so for just one reason. They rest upon the idea that known objects exist as the consequences of directed operations, not because of conformity of thought or observation with something antecedent. We may, for reasons which I hope will appear later, give the name intelligence to these directed operations. Using this term, we may say that the worth of any object that lays claim to being an object of knowledge is dependent upon the intelligence employed in reaching it. In saying this, we must bear in mind that intelligence means operations actually performed in the modification of condi- tions, including all the guidance that is given by means of ideas,-both direct and symbolic, he statement may sound strange. But it is only a way of saying that the value of any cognitive conclusion depends ' upon the method by which it is reached, so that the perfecting of method, the perfecting of intelligence, is the thing of su- preme value}If we judge the work of a scientific inquirer by what he does and not by his speech when he talks about his work (when he is likely to talk in terms of traditional notions that have become habitual) we shall have little difficulty, I think, in accepting the idea that he determines the cognitive claims of anything presented to him on the basis of the method by which it is reached- é€ import of this doctrine is simple. It becomes ‘complicated, however, the moment we contrast it with the doctrines which have dominated thought. For these all rest on the notion that a reality in Being indepen- dently of the operations of inquiry is the standard and meas- ure of anything said to be known. Viewed in this connection, the conception just advanced involves hardly less than a revo- lutionary transformation of many of our most cherished con- eronset he essential difference is that between a mind which beholds or grasps objects from outside the world of things, physical and social, and. one which is a participant, interacting 200 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE with other things and knowing them provided the interaction is regulated in a definable way.» In discussion up to this point we have depended upon the general pattern of experimental knowing. It is asserted that when we frame our theory of knowledge and the known object after this pattern, the conclusion is inevitable. But the point is of such importance that we may gratefully acknowledge the support given the conclusion by one of the definite conclusions reached in recent physical science. For this one result is of a crucially decisive nature. It is known technically as Heisen- berg’s principle of indeterminancy. The basic philosophy of the Newtonian system of the universe is closely connected with what is termed the principle of canonic conjugates. The fun- damental principle of the mechanical philosophy of nature is that it is possible to determine exactly (in principle if not in actual practice) both the position and the velocity of any body. Knowing this for each particle which enters into any change, as a motion, it is possible to calculate mathematically, that is exactly, just what will happen. The laws or physical equations that express the relations of the particles and bodies under different conditions are then assumed to be a “govern- ing” framework of nature to which all particular phenomena conform. Knowing volumes and momenta in a particular case we can by the aid of fixed laws predict the subsequent course of events. The philosophy in question assumed that these positions and velocities are there in nature independent of our knowing, of our experiments and observations, and that we have scien- tific knowledge in the degree in which we ascertain them exactly. The future and the past belong to the same com- pletely determinate and fixed scheme. Observations, when cor- rectly conducted, merely register this fixed state of changes according to laws of objects whose essential properties are 201 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY fixed. The implications of the positions are expressed in La- place’s well-known saying that were there a knowledge (in mechanical terms) of the state of the universe at any one time its whole future could be predicted—or deduced. It is this philosophy which Heisenberg’s principle has upset, a fact implied in calling it a principle of indeterminancy. It is true that critics had attacked the Newtonian scheme on the basis of a logical flaw in it. It first postulates that the position and velocity of any particle can be determined in isolation from all others. Then it postulates that there is a complete and continuous interaction of all these particles with one another. Logically, the two postulates nullify each other. But as long as the principles involved gave satisfactory results this objection was brushed aside or ignored. Heisenberg’s prin- ciple compels a recognition of the fact that interaction prevents an accurate measurement of velocity and position for amy body, the demonstration centering about the réle ofthe interaction of the observer in determining what actually happens. The scientific data and the mathematical reasonings which led him to his conclusion are technical. But fortunately they do not concern us. The logic of the matter is not complicated. He showed that if we fix, metrically, velocity, then there is a range of indeterminateness in the assignment of position, and vice-versa. When one is fixed, the other is defined only within a specified limit of probability. The element of indeterminate- ness is not connected with defect in the method of observa- tion but is intrinsic. The particle observed does not have fixed position or velocity, for it is changing all the time because of interaction: specifically, in this case, interaction with the act of observing, or more strictly, with the conditions under which an observation is possible; for it is not the “mental” phase of observation which makes the difference. Since either position or velocity may be fixed at choice, leaving the element 202 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE of indeterminancy on the other side, both of them are shown to be conceptual in nature. That is, they belong to our intellec- tual apparatus for dealing with antecedent existence, not to fixed properties of that existence. An isolation of a particle for measurement is essentially a device for regulation of sub- sequent perceptual experience. Technically, the principle of Heisenberg is connected with recent determinations regarding observation of phenomena of light. The principle as far as the rdle of the conditions of observation is concerned is simple. We should all, I suppose, recognize that when we perceive an object by means of touch, the contact introduces a slight modification in the thing touched. Although in dealing with large bodies this change would be insignificant, it would be considerable if we touched a minute body and one moving at high speed. It might be thought that we could calculate the displacement thus ef- fected, and by making allowances for it determine exactly the position and momentum of the thing touched. But this result would be theoretical, and would have to be confirmed by an- other observation. The effect of the last observation cannot be eliminated. Failure to generalize this conclusion was due presumably to two facts. Until recently physics dealt mainly with bodies of relatively large volume and relatively low velocity. Experiences with these bodies were carried over to minute particles of any velocity; these were treated as mathe- matical points located at fixed, unchanging, instants of time. The second cause is that vision does not involve interaction with the thing seen as obviously as does touch. But the situation changed when it came to dealing with minute bodies moving at high speed. Also, it became clear that a continuous field or even flow of light cannot be ob- served and measured. Light can be observed only as an indi- vidual object, a drop, pellet or bullet. The presence of at 203 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY least one such bullet is required to make, say, an electron visible, and its action displaces to some extent the object ob- served; the displacement or jog, being involved in the obser- vation, cannot be measured by it. As Bridgman says: “A cat may look at a king but at least one bullet of light must pass if any light at all passes, and the King cannot be observed with- out the exertion of that minimum amount of mechanical re- pulsion which corresponds to the single bullet.” * To a layman the full import of the discovery may not seem at first sight very great. In the subject-matter of scientific thought it calls for only slight changes of formulation, in- significant for all macroscopic bodies. The change for the un- derlying philosophy and logic of science is, however, very great. In relation to the metaphysics of the Newtonian system it is hardly less than revolutionary. What is known is seen to be a product in which the act of observation plays a neces- sary role. Knowing is seen to be a participant in what is finally known. Moreover, the metaphysics of existence as something fixed and therefore capable of literally exact mathematical description and prediction is undermined. Knowing is, for philosophical theory, a case of specially dyrected activity in- ,. | stead of something isolated from practice.\[he quest for cer- tainty by means of exact possession in mind of immutable ; } reality is exchanged for search for security by means of active ' control of the changing course of events, Intelligence in op- eration, another name for method, becomes the thing most . worth winning. The principle of indeterminancy thus presents itself as the final step in the dislodgment of the old spectator theory of knowledge. It marks the acknowledgment, within scientific procedure itself, of the fact that knowing is one kind of inter- *In the March, 1929, number of Harper’s Magazine, in an article entitled The New Vision of Science. | 204. THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE action which goes on within the world. Knowing marks the conversion of undirected changes into changes directed toward an intended conclusion. There are left for philoscphy but two alternatives. Either knowledge defeats its own purpose; or the objective of knowing is the consequences of operations pur- posely undertaken, provided they fulfill the conditions for the sake of which they are carried on. If we persist in the tradi- tional conception, according to which the thing to be known is something which exists prior to and wholly apart from the act of knowing, then discovery of the fact that the act of observa- tion, necessary in existential knowing, modifies that pre- existent something, is proof that the act of knowing gets in its own way, frustrating its own intent. If knowing is a form of doing and is to be judged like other modes by its eventual issue, this tragic conclusion is not forced upon us. Fundamen- tally, the issue is raised whether philosophy is willing to sur- render a theory of mind and its organs of knowing which originated when the practice of knowing was in its infancy. One important result of acknowledgment of the philo- sophic modification involved in the principle of indetermi- nancy is a definite change in our conception of natural laws. The individually observed case becomes the measure of knowl- edge. Laws are intellectual instrumentalities by which that individual object is instituted and its meaning determined. This change involves a reversal of the theory which has domi- nated thought since the Newtonian system obtained full sway. According to the latter, the aim of science is to ascertain laws; individual cases are known only as they are reduced to instances of laws. For, as we saw earlier, the Newtonian philosophy allowed itself to become entangled in the Greek metaphysics according to which the immutable is the truly real and our thought is adequate in the degree in which it approximates a grasp of what is antecedently fixed in existence. 205 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY In content, or subject-matter, Newton’s philosophy ef- fected a revolutionary change. The unchanging reality had been thought to consist of forms and species. According to Newtonian science, it consists of fixed relations, temporal and spatial, designated by exact enumeration of changes between fixed ultimate substances, the masses of atoms. The discovery that mass varies with velocity was the beginning of the end. It deprived physical knowledge of its supposedly ultimate permanent coefficient, one having nothing to do with config- uration or motion, and one in terms of which all interactions were to be exactly described. All “laws” were statements of these ultimate and rigid uniformities of being. While perhaps there was felt to be something metaphorical in speaking | of laws as if they “governed” changes and of the latter as if they “obeyed” laws, there was nothing figurative in the notion that laws stated the ultimate unchanging properties of natural existence, and that all individual cases, those observed, were only specimen instances of the antecedent properties of the real world formulated in laws. The principle of indeter- minancy brings to fruition the scientific transformation initi- ated in the discovery that the supposition of a permanent coefficient of mass is illusory—a survival, when judged in his- torical terms, of the old notion that something immutable is the true object of knowledge. In technical statement, laws on the new basis are formulae for the prediction of the probability of an observable occur- rence. They are designations of relations sufficiently stable to allow of the occurrence of forecasts of individualized situa- tions—for every observed phenomenon is individual—within limits of specified probability, not a probability of error, but of probability of actual occurrence. Laws are inherently concep- tual in character, as is shown in the fact that either position or velocity may be fixed at will. To call them conceptual is not to 206 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE say that they are merely “mental” and arbitrary. It is to say that they are relations which are thought not observed. The subject-matter of the conceptions which constitute laws is not arbitrary, for it is determined by the interactions of what exists. But determination of them is very different from that denoted by conformity to fixed properties of unchanging substances. Any instrument which is to operate effectively in existence must take account of what exists, from a fountain pen to a self-binding reaper, a locomotive or an airplane. But “taking account of,” paying heed to, is something quite differ- ent from literal conformity to what is already in being. It is an adaptation of what previously existed to accomplishment of a purpose. The eventual purpose in knowledge is observation of a new phenomenon, an object actually experienced by way of per- ception. Thus the supposed immutable law supposed to govern phenomena becomes a way of transacting business effectively with concrete existences, a mode of regulation of our relations with them. There is no difference in principle between their use in “pure” science and in an art. We may recur to the case of a physician to which reference was made. The physician in diagnosing a case of disease deals with something individ- ualized. He draws upon a store of general principles of physiology, etc., already at command. Without this store of conceptual material he is helpless. But he does not attempt to reduce the case to an exact specimen of certain laws of physiol- ogy and pathology, or do away with its unique individuality. Rather he uses general statements as aids to direct his obser- vation of the particular case, so as to discover what it is lke. They function as intellectual toals or instrumentalittes.— The recognition that laws are means of calculating the probability of observation of an event signifies that in basic logic there is no difference in the two kinds of cases. The full 207 a ee I 7) 1, Tg po 2S Ate = io) rs Sa eee SP Se Repo ee ee, THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY and eventual reality of knowledge is carried in the individ- ual case, not in general laws isolated from use in giving an individual case its meaning. Thus the empirical or observa- tional theory of knowledge comes to its own, although in quite a different way from that imagined by traditional empiricism. It is an old remark that human progress is a zigzag affair. The idea of a universal reign of Jaw, based on properties im- _mutably inhering in things and of such a nature as to be capable _of exact mathematical statement was a sublime idea. It dis- placed once for all the notion of a world in which the unac- geountable and the mysterious have the first and last word, a world in which they constantly insert themselves. It estab- lished the ideal of regularity and uniformity in place of the casual and sporadic. It gave men inspiration and guidance in seeking for uniformities and constancies where only irregular diversity was experienced. The ideal extended itself from the inanimate world to the animate and then to social affairs. It became, it may fairly be said, the great article of faith in the creed of scientific men. From this point of view, the principle of indetermi eems like an intellectual catas- trophe. In compelling surrender of the doctrine of exact and immutable laws describing the fixed antecedent properties of things, it seems to involve abandonment of the idea that the — world is fundamentally intelligible. A universe in which fixed laws do not make possible exact predictions seems from the older standpoint to be a world in which disorder reigns. The feeling is psychologically natural. But it arises from the hold which intellectual habits have over us. The traditional conception displaced in fact lingers in imagination as a picture of what the world ought to be; we are uneasy because the fact turns out not to be in accord with the picture in our minds. As a matter of fact, the change, viewed in a perspective of dis- tance, is nothing like so upsetting. All the facts that were ever 208 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE known are still known, and known with greater accuracy than before. The older doctrine was in effect an offshoot not of science but of a metaphysical doctrine which taught that the immutable is the truly real, and of a theory of knowledge which held that rational conceptions rather than observations are the vehicle of knowledge. Newton foisted a fundamental “rationalism” upon the scientific world atfthé more effectually because he did it in the name of empirical observation. Moreover, like all generalizations which go beyond the range of possible as well as of actual experience, a price was paid for the sublime and inspiring ideal of a reign of uni- versal and exact law: the sacrifice of the individual to the general, of the concrete to the relational. Spinoza’s magnifi- cently sweeping dictum that “the order and connection of ideas is the order and connection of things” was in effect, although not avowedly as it was with Spinoza, the curre of the intelligibility of nature. And a universe whose essential characteristic is fixed order and connection has no place for unique and individual existences, no place for novelty and genuine change and growth. It is, in the words of William James, a block universe. The fact that in detailed content it is a thoroughly mechanistic world is, one may say, a mere incident attending the fact that it is a fixed and closed world. Probably everyone has heard of the child who expressed surprise at the fact that rivers or bodies of water are always located conveniently near great cities. Suppose every one had had engrained in his mind the notion that cities, like rivers, are works of nature. Suppose it was then suddenly ascertained that cities were man made and were located near bodies of water in order that the activities of men in industry and com- merce might be better carried on and human purposes and needs be better served. We can imagine that the discovery would bring with it a shock. It would be upsetting because 209 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY it would seem unnatural; for the ordinary measure of the natural is psychological; it is what we have become accustomed to. But in time the new idea in becoming familiar would also become “natural.” If men had always previously conceived of the connection between cities and rivers as one which was in- trinsic and fixed by nature, instead of being a product of human art, it is moreover probable that in time a liberation would be experienced by discovery that the contrary was the case. Men would be led to take fuller advantage of the facilities afforded by natural conditions. These would be used in new and more diversified ways when it was realized that cities were near them because of and for the sake of the uses they provide. The analogy suggested seems to me close. From the stand- point of traditional notions, it appears that nature, intrin- sically, is grational. But the quality of irrationality is imputed only because of conflict with a prior definition of ration- ality. Abandon completely the notion that nature ought to conform to a certain definition, and nature intrinsically is neither rational nor irrational. Apart from the use made of it in knowing, it exists in a dimension irrelevant to either attribution, just as rivers inherently are neither located near cities nor are opposed to such location. Nature is intelligsble and understandadle. There are operations by méans of which it Becomes an object of knowledge, and is turned to human purposes, just as rivers provide conditions which may be utilized to promote human activities and to satisfy human need, Moreover, just as commerce, carried on by natural bodies of water, signifies interactions within nature, by which changes are affected in natural conditions—the building of docks and harbors, erection of warehouses and factories, construction of steamships and also in invention of new modes of interaction— so with knowiag and knowledge. The _organs, instrumentali- 210 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE ties and operations of knowing are inside nature, not outside. Hence thay are chanaes of what previously existed: the object of knowledge is a constructed, existentially produced, object. The shock to the traditional notion that knowledge is perfect in the degree in which it grasps or beholds without change some thing previously complete in itself is tremendous. But in effect it only makes us aware of what we have always done, as far as ever we have actually succeeded in knowing: it clears away superfluous and irrelevant accompaniments and it con- centrates attention upon the agencies which are actually effec- tive in obtaining knowledge, eliminating waste and making actual knowing more controllable. It_installs_man, thinking man, within nature. The doctrine that nature is inherently rational was a costly one. It entailed the idea that reason in man is an outside spec- tator of a rationality already complete in itself. It deprived reason in man of an active and creative office; its business was simply to copy, to re-present symbolically, to view a given rational structure. Ability to make a transcript of this structure in mathematical formule gives great delight to those who have the required ability. But it does nothing; it makes no difference in nature. In effect, it limits thought in man to retraversing in cognition a pattern fixed and complete in itself. The doctrine was both an effect of the traditional separation between knowledge and action and a factor in perpetuating it. It relegated practical making and doing to a secondary and relatively irrational realm. Its paralyzing effect on human action is seen in the part it played in the eighteenth and nineteenth century in the theory of “natural laws” in human affairs, in social matters. These natural laws were supposed to be inherently fixed; a science of social phenomena and relations was equivalent to discovery of them. Once discovered, nothing remained for 211 pie eid QUEST FOR CERTAINTY man but to conform to them; they were to rule his conduct as physical laws govern physical phenomena. They were the sole standard of conduct in economic affairs; the laws of economics are the “natural” laws of all political action; other so-called laws are artificial, man-made contrivances in contrast with the normative regulations of nature itself. Laissez-faiwe was the logical conclusion. For organized society to attempt to regulate the course of economic affairs, to bring them into service of humanly conceived ends, was a harmful interference. ; This doctrine is demonstratively the offspring of that con- ception of universal laws that phenomena must observe which was a heritage of the Newtonian philosophy. But if man in knowing is a participator in the natural scene, a factor in gen- erating things known, the fact that man participates as a factor in social affairs is no barrier to knowledge of them. On the contrary, a certain method of directed participation is a pre- condition of his having any genuine understanding. Human intervention for the sake of effecting ends is no interference, and it is a means of knowledge. There is thus involved more than a verbal shift if we say that the new scientific development effects an exchange of reason for intelligence. In saying this, “reason” has the tech- nical meaning given to it in classic philosophic tradition, the nous of the Greeks, the imtellectus of the scholastics. In this meaning, it designates both an inherent immutable order of nature, superempirical in character, and the organ of mind by which this universal order is grasped. In both respects, reason is with respect to changing things the ultimate fixed standard— the law physical phenomena obey, the norm human action should obey. For the marks of “reason” in its traditional sense are necessity, universality, superiority to change, domination of the occurrence and the understanding of change. 212 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE Intelligence on the other hand is associated with judgment; shat is, with selection and arrangement of means to effect con- sequences and with choice of what we take as our ends. A man is intelligent not in virtue of having reason which grasps first and indemonstrable truths about fixed principles, in order to reason deductively from them to the particulars which they govern, but in virtue of his capacity to estimate the possibili- ties of a situation and to act in accordance with his estimate. In the large sense of the term, intelligence is as practical as reason is theoretical. Wherever intelligence operates, things are judged in their capacity of signs of other things. If scien- tific knowledge enables us to estimate more accurately the worth of things as signs, we can afford to exchange a loss of theoretical certitude for a gain in practical judgment. For if we can judge events as indications of other events, we can prepare in all cases for the coming of what is anticipated. In some cases, we can forestall a happening; desiring one event to happen rather than another, we can intentionally set about institution of those changes which our best knowledge tells us to be connected with that which we are after. What has been lost in the theoretical possibility of exact knowledge and exact prediction is more than compensated for by the fact that the knowing which occurs within nature in- volves possibility of direction of change. This conclusion gives intelligence a foothold and a function within nature which “reason” never possessed. That which acts outside of nature and is a mere spectator of it is, by definition, not a participator in its changes. Therefore it is debarred from taking part in directing them. Action may follow but it is only an external attachment to knowing, not an inherent factor in it. As a me- chanical addendum, it is inferior to knowledge. Moreover, it must either issue automatically from knowledge or else there must be some intervening act of “will” to produce it. In any 213 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY case, because of its externality it adds nothing to intelligence or knowledge. It can only increase personal shrewdness in pru- dential manipulation of conditions. We may, indeed, engage during knowing in experimenta- tion. But according to the classic logic the effect was not to reorganize prior conditions, but merely to bring about a change in our own subjective or mental attitude. The act no more entered into the constitution of the known object than travel- ing to Athens to see the Parthenon had any effect on archi- tecture. It makes a change in our own personal attitude and posture so that we can see better what was there all the time. It is a practical concession to the weakness of our powers of apprehension. The whole scheme hangs together with the traditional depreciation of practical activity on the part of the intellectual class. In reality, it also condemns intelligence to a position of impotency. Its exercise is an enjoyable use of leisure. The doctrine of its supreme value is largely a com- pensation for the impotency that attached to it in contrast with the force of executive acts. The realization that the observation necessary to knowl- edge enters into the natural object known cancels this separa- tion of knowing and doing. It makes possible and it demands a theory in which knowing and doing are intimately connected with each other. Hence, as we have said, it domesticates the exercise of intelligence within nature. This is part and parcel of nature’s own continuing interactions. Interactions go on anyway and produce changes. Apart from intelligence, these changes are not directed. They are effects but not consequences, for consequences imply means deliberately employed. When an interaction intervenes which directs the course of change, the scene of natural interaction has a new quality and dimen- sion. This added type of interaction is intelligence. The intelli- gent activity of man is not something brought to bear upon 214 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE nature from without; it is nature realizing its own potentiali- ties in behalf of a fuller and richer issue of events. Intelli- gence within nature means liberation and expansion, as reason outside of nature means fixation and restriction. The change does not mean that nature has lost intelligi- bility. It rather signifies that we are in position to realize that the term intelligible is to be understood literally. It expresses a potentiality rather than an actuality. Nature is capable of being understood. But the possibility is realized not by a mind thinking about it from without but by operations conducted from within, operations which give it new relations summed up in production of a new individual object. Nature Aas intel- ligible order as its possession in the degree in which we by our own overt operations realize potentialities contained in it. The change from intrinsic rationality in the traditional sense to an intelligibility to be realized by human action places responsibility upon human beings. The devotion we show to the ideal of intelligence determines the extent in which the actual order of nature is congenial to mind. These conclusions connect directly with the question raised at the outset of this chapter. When knowledge is defined from the standpoint of a reality to which the conclusions of thought must accommodate themselves, as a photograph must be faith- ful to its original, there will always be disputes as to whether this or that subject can possibly be treated scientifically. But if the measure of knowledge is the quality of intelligence manifested in dealing with problems presented by any expe- rienced subject-matter, the issue takes on a different aspect. The question always at issue is the possibility of developing a method adequate to cope with problems. The conclusions of physical knowledge do indeed set a standard for knowing. But it is because of their elaboration of competent method that this statement is true, not because of any superior claim to 215 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY reality on the part of physical subject-matter. All materials of experience are equally real; that is, all are existential; each has a right to be dealt with in terms of its own especial char- acteristics and its own problems. To use philosophical termi- nology, each type of subject-matter is entitled to its own characteristic categories, according to the questions it raises and the operations necessary to answer them. The difference between various types of knowledge thus turns out to be a difference in fullness and range of conditions involved in subject-matter dealt with. When one considers the success of astronomy in attaining understanding of phenomena occurring at enormous distances one may well be lost in admi- ration. But we should also reflect upon how much is omitted from inquiry and conclusion. Our knowledge of human affairs on this earth is inexact and unorganized as compared with some things which we know about bodies distant many, many, light years. But there are vast multitudes of things about these bodies that astronomy makes no pretense of inquiring into. The relative perfection of its conclusions is connected with the strict limitation of the problems it deals with. The case of astronomy is typical of physical science in general as compared with knowledge of human affairs. The essence of the latter is that we cannot indulge in the selective abstractions that are the secret of the success of physical knowing. When we intro- duce a like simplification into social and moral subjects we eliminate the distinctively human factors:—reduction to the physical ensues. The principle is exemplified in the difference which is found between results obtained in the laboratory and in manu- facturing processes carried on for commercial purposes. The same materials and relations may be involved. But under lab- oratory conditions elements are isolated and treated under a control not possible in the factory, where the same rigid isola- 216 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE tion would defeat the aim of cheap production on a large scale. Nevertheless, in the end, the researches of scientific in- quiries transform industrial production. Possibilities of new operations are suggested, and the laboratory results indicate ways of eliminating wasteful operations and make manifest conditions which have to be attended to. Artificial simplifica- © tion or abstraction is a necessary precondition of securing ability to deal with affairs which are complex, in which there are many more variables and where strict isolation destroys the special characteristics of the subject-matter. This statement conveys the important distinction which exists between physical and social and moral objects. The distinction is one of methods of operation not of kinds of reality. In other words, what is meant by “physical” in distinction from other adjectives that are prefixed to subject-matter is precisely an abstraction of a limited range of conditions and relations out of a total complex. The same principle applies to mathematical objects. The use of symbols designating possible operations makes possible a greater degree of exactness and intellectual organization. There is no disparagement of ab- straction involved. Abstraction is simply an instance of the economy and efficiency involved in all intelligent practice:— Deal first with matters that can be effectively handled, and then use the results to go on to cope with more complex affairs. Objection comes in, and comes in with warranted force, when the results of an abstractive operation are given a standing which belongs only to the total situation from which they have been selected. All specialization breeds a familiarity which tends to create an illusion. Material dealt with by specialized abstractive processes comes to have a psychological independence and completion which is converted—hyposta- tized—into objective independence and self-sufficiency. In addition there is a definite social reason for abstractive 217 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY simplification. Intercourse of human_ indivi ith..one another makes it necessary to find common ground. ne because individuals are individuals, there is much in the expe- rience of each which is unique; being incommunicable in and of itself, it is in so far a bar to entering into relations with others. For the purposes of communication, dissection is necessary. Otherwise the personal element is a bar to agree- ment and understanding. If one follows out this line of thought, it will be evident that the more widely extended is the notion of mutual comprehensibility, the more completely all individual traits tend to get excluded from the object of thought. In arriving at statements which hold for all possible experiencers and observers under all possible varying indi- vidual circumstances we arrive at that which is most remote from any one concrete experience. In this sense, the abstrac- tions of mathematics and physics represent the common de- nominators in all things experienceable. Taken by themselves they seem to present a caput mortuum. Erected into complete statements of reality as such, they become hallucinatory obses- sions. But in practice, there is always an accompanying reverse movement. These generalized findings are employed to enrich the meanings of individualized experiences, and to afford, within limits of probability, an increased control of them. It is in this sense that all reflective knowledge as such is instrumental. The beginning and the end is the things | of g gross everyday experience. But apart from knowledge the things of our ordinary experience are fragmentary, casual, unregulated by purpose, full of frustrations and barriers. In the language previously used, they are problematic, obstructive, and chal- lenges to thought. By ignoring for a time their concrete and qualitative fullness, by making abstractions and generalizations, we ascertain certain basic relations upon which occurrence of the things experienced depend, We treat them as mere events, 218 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE that is, as changes brought about in a system of relationships, ignoring their individualizing qualities. But the qualities are still there, are still experienced, although as such they are not the objects of knowledge. But we return from abstractive thought to experience of them with added meaning and with increased power to regulate our relations to them. Reflective knowledge is the only means of regulation. Its value as instrumental is unique. Consequently philosophers, themselves occupied in a fascinating branch of reflective knowl- edge, have isolated knowledge and its results. They have ignored its context of origin and function and made it coexten- sive with all valid experience. The doctrine was thus formed that all experience of worth is inherently cognitive; that other modes of experienced objects are to be tested, not here and there as occasion demands but universally by reduction to the terms of known objects. This assumption of the proper ubiq- uity of knowledge is the great intellectualistic fallacy. It is the source of all disparagement of everyday qualitative experience, practical, esthetic, moral. It is the ultimate source of the doc- trine that calls subjective and phenomenal all objects of ex- perience that cannot be reduced to properties of objects of knowledge. From this derogation of the things we experience by way of love, desire, hope, fear, purpose and the traits character- istic of human individuality, we are saved by the realization of the purposefully instrumental and abstract character of objects of reflective knowledge. One mode of experience is as real as any other. But apart from the exercise of intelligence which yields knowledge, the realities of our emotional and practical life have fragmentary and inconsistent meanings and are at the mercy of forces beyond our control. We have no choice save to accept them or to flee from them. Experience of that phase of objects which is constituted by their relations, 219 ee ai THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY their interactions, with one another, makes possible a new way of dealing with them, and thus eventually creates a new kind of experienced objects, not more real than those which preceded but more significant, and less overwhelming and oppressive. Thus the recognition that intelligence is a method oper- ating within the world places physical knowledge in respect to other kinds of knowing. It deals with those relations which are of the broadest scope. It affords a sure foundation for other more specialized forms of knowing:—not in the sense that these must be reduced to the objects in which physical knowledge terminates, but in the sense that the latter supply intellectual points of departure, and suggest operations to be employed. There is no kind of inquiry which has a monopoly of the honorable title of knowledge. The engineer, the artist, | the historian, the man of affairs attain knowledge in the degree they employ methods that enable them to solve the problems which develop in the subject-matter they are concerned with. As philosophy framed upon the pattern of experimental in- quiry does away with all wholesale skepticism, so it eliminates all invidious monopolies of the idea of science. By their fruits we shall know them. The marking off of certain conclusions as alone truly science, whether mathematical or physical, is an historical incident. It sprang originally from man’s desire for a certainty and peace which he could not attain practically in the absence of the arts of management and direction of natural conditions. When modern physical inquiry began, it had a hard time to get a hearing, or even to be permitted to carry on. The temp- tation was practically irresistible to treat it as an exclusive and esoteric undertaking. Moreover, as it progressed, it required more and more specialized technical preparation. The motive of defense from social attack and the motive of glorification 220 THE NATURALIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE of a specialized calling conspired together. All the eulogistic connotations that gather about “truth” were called into play. Thus “science,” meaning physical knowledge, became a kind of sanctuary. A religious atmosphere, not to say an idola- trous one, was created. “Science” was set apart; its findings were supposed to have a privileged relation to the real. In fact, the painter may know colors as well as the physicist; the poet may know stars, rain and clouds as well as the meteorolo- gist; the statesman, educator and dramatist may know human nature as truly as the professional psychologist; the farmer may know soils and plants as truly as the botanist and min- erologist. For the criterion of knowledge lies in the method used to secure consequences and not in metaphysical concep- tions of the nature of the real. Nevertheless in the end think- — ers in all lines are dependent upon the mathematician and the: physical inquirer for perfecting of the tools employed in their respective callings. That “knowledge” has many meanings follows from the ° operational definition of conceptions. There are as many con- ceptions of knowledge as there are distinctive operations by which problematic situations are resolved. When it is asserted that reflective knowledge as such is instrumental, it is not meant that there is an @ priori form of non-reflective knowl- edge, one which is immediately given. What is signified is that there is a direct possession and enjoyment of meanings to be had in that experience of objects which issues from reflective knowledge. It is futile to argue whether the conclusions of reflective method as such or the eventual objects enriched in meaning which are capable of direct perception and use more truly deserve the title of knowledge. It is congenial to our idiom to call the reflective conclusions of competent methods by the name of science. But science thus conceived is not a final thing. The final thing is appreciation and use of things of 221 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY direct experience. These are known in as far as their constitu- ents and their form are the result of science. But they are also more than science. They are natural objects experienced in relations and continuities that are summed up in rich and definite individual forms 222 CHAPTER IX THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD UNCERTAINTY IS PRIMARILY a practical matter. It signifies uncertainty of the isswe of present experiences; these are fraught with future peril as well as inherently objectionable. Action to get rid of the objectionable has no warrant of success and is itself perilous. The intrinsic troublesome and uncertain quality of situations lies in the fact that they hold outcomes in suspense; they move to evil or to good fortune. The natural tendency of man is to do something at once; there is impatience with suspense, and lust for immediate action. When action lacks means for control of external conditions, it takes the form of acts which are the prototypes of rite and cult. Intelligence signifies that direct action has become indirect. It continues to be overt, but it is directed into channels of examination of con- ditions, and doings that are tentative and preparatory. Instead of rushing to “do something about it,” action centers upon find- ing out something about obstacles and resources and upon pro- -jecting inchoate later modes of definite response. Thinking has been well called deferred action. But not all action is de- ferred; only that which is final and in so far productive of irretrievable consequences. Deferred action is present explora- tory action. The first and most obvious effect of this change in the quality of action is that the dubious or problematic situation becomes @ problem. The risky character that pervades a situation as a whole is translated into an object of inquiry that locates what the trouble is, and hence facilitates projection of methods and 223 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY means of dealing with it. Only after expertness has been gained in special fields of inquiry does the mind set out at once from problems: even then in novel cases, there is a preliminary period of groping through a situation which is characterized throughout by confusion, instead of presenting a clear-cut problem for investigation. Many definitions of mind and thinking have been given. I know of but one that goes to the heart of the matter:— ‘response to the doubtful as such. No inanimate thing reacts to things as problematic. Its behavior to other things is capable of description in terms of what is determinately there. Under given conditions, it just reacts or does not react. Its reactions merely enstate a new set of conditions, in which reactions con- tinue without regard to the nature of their outcome. It makes no difference, so to say, to a stone what are the results of its interactions with other things. It enjoys the advantage that it makes no difference how it reacts, even if the effect is its own pulverization. It requires no argument to show that the case is different with a living organism. To live signifies that a connected continuity of acts is effected in which preceding ones prepare the conditions under which later ones occur. There is a chain of cause and effects, of course, in what happens with inanimate things. But for living creatures, the chain has a particular cumulative continuity, or else death ensues. As organisms become more complex in structure and thus related to a more complex environment, the importance of a particular act in establishing conditions favorable to subse- quent acts that sustain the continuity of the life process, be- comes at once more difficult and more imperative. A juncture may be so critical that the right or wrong present move signifies life or death. Conditions of the environment become more ambivalent: it is more uncertain what sort of action they call for in the interests of living. Behavior is thus compelled to ! 224 THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD become more hesitant and wary, more expectant and prepara- tory. In the degree that responses take place to the doubtful as the doubtful, they acquire mental quality. If they are such as to have a directed tendency to change the precarious and problematic into the secure and resolved, they are intellectual as well as mental. Acts are then relatively more instrumental and less consummatory or final; even the latter are haunted by a sense of what may issue from them. This conception of the mental brings to unity various modes of response; emotional, volitional and intellectual. It is usual to say that there is no fundamental difference among these activities—that they are all different phases or aspects of a common action of mind. But I know of but one way of making this assertion good: that in which they are seen to be distinctive modes of response to the uncertain. The emotional aspect of responsive behavior is its #mmediate quality. When we are con- fronted with the precarious, an ebb and flow of emotion marks a disturbance of the even tenor of existence. Emotions are conditioned by the indeterminateness of present situations with respect to their issue. Fear and hope, joy and sorrow, aversion and desire, as perturbations, are qualities of a divided response. They involve concern, solicitude, for what the present situation may become. “Care” signifies two quite different things: fret, worry and anxiety, and cherishing attention to that in whose potentialities we are interested. These two meanings represent different poles of reactive behavior to a present hav- ing a future which is ambiguous. Elation and depression, more- over, manifest themselves only under conditions wherein not everything from start to finish is completely determined and certain. They may occur at a final moment of triumph or defeat, but this moment is one of victory or frustration in connection with a previous course of affairs whose issue was in suspense. Love for a Being so perfect and complete that our 225 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY regard for it can make no difference to it is not so much affec- tion as (a fact which the scholastics saw) it is concern for the destiny of our own souls, Hate that is sheer antagonism without any element of uncertainty is not an emotion, but is an energy devoted to ruthless destruction. Aversion is a state of affectivity only in connection with an obstruction offered by the disliked object or person to an end made uncertain by it. | The volitional phase of mental life is notoriously connected with the emotional. The only difference is that the latter, is the immediate, the cross-sectional, aspect of response to the uncertain and precarious, while the volitional phase is the tendency of the reaction to modify indeterminate, ambiguous conditions in the direction of a preferred and favored outcome; to actualize one of its possibilities rather than another, Emotion is a hindrance or an aid to resolute will according as it is over- whelming in its immediacy or as it marks a gathering together of energy to deal with the situation whose issue is in doubt. Desire, purpose, planning, choice, have no meaning save in conditions where something is at stake, and where action in one direction rather than another may eventuate in bringing into existence a new situation which fulfills a need. The intellectual phase of mental action is identical with an indirect mode of response, one whose purpose is to locate the nature of the trouble and form an idea of how it may be dealt with—so that operations may be directed in view of an intended solution. Take any incident of experience you choose, seeing a color, reading a book, listening to conversation, ma- nipulating apparatus, studying a lesson, and it has or has not intellectual, cognitive, quality according as there is deliberate endeavor to deal with the indeterminate so as to dispose of it, to settle it. Anything that may be called knowledge, or a known object, marks a question answered, a difficulty disposed of, a 226 THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD confusion cleared up, an inconsistency reduced to coherence, a perplexity mastered. Without reference to this mediating element, what is called knowledge is but direct and unswerving action or else a possessive enjoyment. Similarly, thinking is the actual transition from the problematic to the secure, as far as that is intentionally guided. There is no separate “mind” gifted in and of itself with a faculty of thought; such a con- ception of thought ends in postulating the mystery of a power outside of nature and yet able to intervene within it. Thinking is objectively discoverable as that mode of serial responsive behavior to a problematic situation in which transition to the relatively settled and clear is effected. The concrete pathologies of belief, its failures and perver- sions, whether of defect or excess, spring from failure to ob- serve and adhere to the principle that knowledge is the com- pleted resolution of the inherently indeterminate or doubtful. The commonest fallacy is to suppose that since the state of - doubt is accompanied by a feeling of uncertainty, knowledge arises when this feeling gives way to one of assurance. Think- ing then ceases to be an effort to effect change in the objective situation and is replaced by various devices which generate a change in feeling or “consciousness.” Tendency to premature judgment, jumping at conclusions, excessive love of simplicity, making over of evidence to suit desire, taking the familiar for the clear, ‘etc., all spring from confusing the feeling of certi- tude wit . Thought hastens toward the settled and is only too likely to force the pace. The natural man dislikes the dis-ease which accompanies the doubtful and is ready to take almost any means to end it. Uncertainty is got rid of by fair means or foul. Long exposure to danger breeds an overpowering love of security. Love for security, translated into a desire not to be disturbed and unsettled, leads to dogmatism, to acceptance of beliefs upon authority, to in- go7 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tolerance and fanaticism on one side and to irresponsible de- pendence and sloth on the other. Here is where ordinary thinking and thinking that is scrupu- lous diverge from each other. The natural man is impatient with doubt and suspense: he impatiently hurries to be shut of it. A disciplined mind takes delight in the problematic, and cherishes it until a way out is found that approves itself upon examination. The questionable becomes an active questioning, a search; desire for the emotion of certitude gives place to quest for the objects by which the obscure and unsettled may be developed into the stable and clear. The scientific attitude may_almost_he defined_as that which is capable of enjoying dla ei 0 co the doubtful; scientific method is, in oné aspect, a technique for making a productive use of doubt by converting it into ‘operations of definite inquiry. No one gets far intellectually eae) who does not “love to think,” and no one loves to think who does not have an interest in problems as such. Being on the alert for problems signifies that mere organic curiosity, the restless disposition to meddle and reach out, has become a truly intellectual curiosity, one that protects a person from hurrying to a conclusion and that induces him to undertake active search for new facts and ideas. Skepticism that is not such a search is as much a personal emotional indulgence as is dogmatism. Attainment of the relatively secure and settled takes place, however, only with respect to specified problematic situations; quest for certainty that is universal, applying to everything, is _ a compensatory perversion. One question is disposed of; an- other offers itself and thought is kept alive. When we compare the theory of mind and its organs which develops from analysis of what takes place when precarious situations are translated into statement and resolution of prob- lems, with other theories, the outstanding difference is that the first type of theory introduces no elements save such as are 228 THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD public, observable, and verifiable. In general, when there is discourse about the mental organs and processes of knowing we are told about sensations, mental images, consciousness and its various states, as if these were capable of identification in and of themselves. These mental organs having had meaning assigned to them in isolation from the operations of resolving a problematic situation, are then used to give an account of the actual operations of knowing. The more evident and ob- servable is thus “explained” in terms of the obscure, the ob- scurity being hidden from view because of habits that have the weight of tradition behind them. We do not need to repeat the results of the previous dis- cussion. They are all connected with the theory that inquiry is a set of operations in which problematic situations are disposed of or settled. Theories which have been criticized all rest upon a different supposition; namely, that the proper- ties of the states and acts of mind involved in knowing are capable of isolated determination—of description apart from overt acts that resolve indeterminate and ambiguous situations» The fundamental advantage of framing our account of the organs and processes of knowing on the pattern of what occurs in experimental inquiry is that nothing is introduced save what is objective and is accessible to examination and report. If it is objected that such an examination itself involves mind and its organs, the rejoinder is that the theory we have advanced is self-applying. Its only “assumption” is that something is done, done in the ordinary external sense of that word, and that this doing has consequences. We define mind and its organs in terms of this doing and its results, just as we define or frame ideas of stars, acids, and digestive tissues in terms of their behavior. If it be urged that we do not know whether the re- sults of the directed operations are really knowledge or not, the answer is the objection assumes that we have some kind 229 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of advance intimation of what sort of a thing knowledge must be, and hence can use this conception as a standard for judging particular conclusions. The theory in question makes no such assumption.< It asserts that by some operations conclusions - emerge in which objects once uncertain and confused are ren- dered clear and stable, Alter names as much as you please; re- fuse to call one set of consequences knowledge and another error, or reverse the appellations, and these consequences re- main just what they are. They present the difference between resolved and clarified situations and disordered and obscure ones. A rose by another name would smell as sweet; the gist of the theory advanced 1 1s to oint to operatio d and to ~ Another point io lite rence aa! ae oe mind and its organs of knowledge isolate them from continuity with the natural world. They are, in the literal sense of the word, super-natural or extra-natural. The problem of mind and body, of how it happens that bodily structures are involved in observing and thinking, is then unavoidable. When little was known about organic structures, one reason for looking down upon perception was that its connection with bodily or- gans, the eye and ear and hand, could not escape notice, while thought could be regarded as a purely spiritual act. But now we are aware that the exercise of thought bears the same rela- tion to the brain that perception bears to sense organs, and that there is no separation, structural or functional, between the eye and ear and the central organs. Consequently it is impossible to think of sense as quasi-physical and thought as purely mental, as if the mental meant just the non-material. Yet we retain theories about the mental formed before we had this knowledge. Consequently, since those theories isolate knowing from doing, the dependence of knowing upon bodily organs becomes a mystery—a “problem.” 230 THE SUPREMACY OF METHOD But if knowing is one mode of doing, then it, as well as other modes of doing, properly involves bodily instru- ments. The metaphysical problem of the relation of mind and body is converted into a question, to be solved by observa- tion of facts, of a differentiation of actions into those on a strictly physiological level, and those which, because of di- rected quality and distinctive consequences, are mental. While traditional theories regard mind as an intruder from without into the natural development, or evolution, of organic structures, or else in the interest of natural continuity feel compelled to deny that mental behavior has any differential features, the theory that organic responses have mental quality in the degree in which they deal with the uncertain recognizes both continuity and difference. It can, in principle if not as yet in detail, give a genetic account of the development of mental and intellectual processes. There is neither a sudden jump from the merely organic to the intellectual, nor is there complete assimilation of the latter to primitive modes of the former. On the objective side, the great difference between the ; conception proposed and that of traditional theory consists in recognition of the objective character of indeterminateness:/ it is a real property of some natural existences. Greek thought at least acknowledged the presence of contingency in natural existence, although it used this property of uncertainty to assign to natural existence a lower status than that which be- longs to necessary Being. Modern thought, largely under the influence of a Newtonian philosophy of nature, tended to treat all existence as wholly determinate, The inherently in- complete was eliminated from nature along with qualities and ends. In consequence, the mental was sharply marked off from the physically natural; for the mental was obviously charac- terized by doubt and uncertainty. Mind was placed outside of nature; its relation to nature in knowing the latter became a 231 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY dark mystery; the uncertain and indeterminate were said to be merely subjective. The contrast between the doubtful and the determinate became one of the chief marks by which ob- jective and subjective were demarcated from each other and placed in opposition. According to this doctrine, we are doubtful, puzzled, con- fused, undecided; objects are complete, assured, fixed. It is not easy to reconcile this notion with the fact that in order to relieve our doubt, to “make up” our minds, we have to modify in some way, in imaginative or overt experimentation, the situation in which uncertainty is experienced. Moreover, the procedure of science is conclusive. If doubt and inde- terminateness were wholly within the mind—whatever that may signify—purely mental processes ought to get rid of them. Its seemingly solid foundation was, however, undermined by the conclusions of modern science. They effected, both in themselves and even more in the new interests and activities they generated, a breach between what man is concerned with here and now and the faith concerning ultimate reality which, in determining his ultimate and eternal destiny, had previously given regulation to his present lifeThe problem of restoring integration and codperation between man’s beliefs about the world in which he lives and his beliefs about the values and purposes that should direct his conduct is the deepest problem of modern if is the problem of any philosophy that is not isolated from ‘that life. The attention which has been given to the fact that in its experimental procedure science has surrendered the separa- tion between knowing and doing has its source in the fact that there is now provided within a limited, specialized and techni- cal field the possibility and earnest, as far as theory is con- cerned, of effecting the needed integration in the wider field of collective human experience. Philosophy is called upon to be the theory of the practice, ou h ideas sufficiently definite THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY to be operative in experiment experimental il endeavor, by which the inte- gration_may be _may be made secure in actual experience. Its central problem is the relation that exists between the beliefs about the nature of things due to natural science to beliefs about values—using that word to designate whatever is taken to have rightful authority in the direction of conduct. A philos- ophy which should take up this problem is struck first of all by the fact that beliefs about values are pretty much in the position in which beliefs about nature were before the scientific revolution. There is either a basic distrust of the capacity of experience to develop its own regulative standards, and an appeal to what philosophers call eternal values, in order to ensure regulation of belief and action; or there is acceptance of enjoyments actually experienced irrespective of the method or operation by which they are brought into existence.Com- plete bifurcation between rationalistic method and an empirical method has its final and most deeply human significance in the ways in which good and bad are thought of and acted for and. upon.> As far as technical philosophy reflects this situation, there is division of theories of values into two kinds. On the one _ hand, goods and evils, in every region of life, as they are con- cretely experienced, are regarded as characteristic of an inferior order of Being—intrinsically inferior. Just because they are things of human experience, their worth must be estimated by reference to standards and ideals derived from ultimate real- ity. Their defects and perversion are attributed to the same fact; they are to be corrected and controlled through adoption of methods of conduct derived from loyalty to the require- ments of Supreme—Bemrg. This philosophic formulation gets actuality and force from the fact that it is a rendering of the beliefs of men in general as far as they have come under the influence of institutional religion. Just as rational conceptions 256 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD were once superimposed upon observed and temporal phe- nomena, so eternal values are superimposed upon experienced goods, In one case as in the other, the alternative is supposed ‘to be confusion and lawlessness. Philosophers suppose these — eternal values are known by reason; the mass of persons that they are divinely revealed. Nevertheless, with the expansion of secular interests, tem- poral values have enormously multiplied; they absorb more and more attention and energy. The sense of transcendent values has become enfeebled; instead of permeating all things in life, it is more and more restricted to special times and acts. The authority of the church to declare and impose divine will and purpose has narrowed.(Whatever men say and profess, their tendency in the presence of actual evils is to resort to natural and empirical means to remedy Ahem. But in formal belief, the old doctrine of the inherently disturbed and un- worthy character of the goods and standards of ordinary ex- perience persists. This divergence between what men do and what they nominally profess is closely connected with the-con- fusions and conflicts of modern thought. dit-is not meant to assert that no attempts have been made to replace the older theory regarding the authority of immu- table and transcendent values by conceptions more congruous with the practices of daily life.)The contrary is the case. The utilitarian theory, to take one instance, has had great power. The idealistic school is the only one in contemporary philoso- phies, with the exception of one form of neo-realism, that makes much of the notion of a reality which is all one with ultimate moral and religious values. But this school is also the one most concerned with the conservation of “spiritual” life. Equally significant is the fact that empirical theories re- tain the notion that thought and judgment are concerned with values that are experienced independently of them. For these 257 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY theories, emotional satisfactions occupy the same place that sensations hold in traditional empiricism. Values are consti- tuted by liking and enjoyment; to be enjoyed and to be a value are two names for one and the same fact. Since science has extruded values from its objects, these empirical theories do everything possible to emphasize their purely subjective char- acter of value. A psychological theory of desire and liking is supposed to cover the whole ground of the theory of values; in it, immediate feeling is the counterpart of immediate sensation. I shall not object to this empirical theory as far as it con- nects the theory of values with concrete experiences of desire and satisfaction. The idea that there is such a connection is the only way known to me by which the pallid remoteness of the rationalistic theory, and the only too glaring presence of the institutional theory of transcendental values can be escaped. The objection is that the theory in question holds down value to objects antecedently enjoyed, apart from reference to the method by which they come into existence; it takes enjoyments which are causal because unregulated by intelligent opera- tions to be values in and of themselves. Operational thinking needs to be applied to the judgment of values just as it has now finally been applied in conceptions of physical objects. “Experimental empiricism in the field of ideas of good and bad is demanded to meet the conditions of the present situation. The scientific revolution came about when material of direct and uncontrolled experience was taken as problematic; as supplying material to be transformed by reflective operations into known objects. The contrast between experienced and known objects was found to be a temporal one; namely, one between empirical subject-matters which were had or “given” prior to the acts of experimental variation and redisposition and those which succeeded these acts and issued from them. 258 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD The notion of an act whether of sense or thought which sup- plied a valid measure of thought in immediate knowledge was discredited. Consequences of operations became the important thing. The suggestion almost imperatively follows that es- cape from the defects of transcendental absolutism is not to be had by setting up as values enjoyments that happen any- how, but in defining value by enjoyments which are the con-\\y sequences of intelligent action. Without the intervention of | thought, enjoyments are not values but problematic goods, be- coming values when they re-issue in a changed form from in-' telligent behavior. The fundamental trouble with the current empirical theory of values is that it merely formulates and justifies the socially prevailing habit of regarding enjoyments as they are actually experienced as values in and of themselves. It completely side-steps the question of regulation of these enjoyments. This issue involves nothing less than the problem of the directed reconstruction of economic, political and reli- gious institutions. There was seemingly a paradox involved in the notion that if we turned our backs upon the immediately perceived quali- ties of things, we should be enabled to form valid conceptions of objects, and that these conceptions could be used to bring about a more secure and more significant experience of them. But the method terminated in disclosing the connections or interactions upon which perceived objects, viewed as events, depend. Formal] analogy suggests that we regard our direct and original experience of things liked and enjoyed as only possi- bilities of values to be achieved; that enjoyment becomes a value when we discover the relations upon which its presence depends. Such a causal and operational definition gives only a conception of a value, not a value itself. But the utilization of the conception in action results in an object having secure and significant value,7 259 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY The formal statement may be given concrete content by pointing to the difference between the enjoyed and the en- joyable, the desired and the desirable, the satisfying and the satisfactory. ‘To say that something is enjoyed is to make a statement about a fact, something already in existence; it is not to judge the value of that fact. There is no difference between such a proposition and one which says that something is sweet or sour, red or black. It is just correct or incorrect and that is the end of the matter. But to call an object a value is to assert that it satisfies or fulfills certain conditions. Func- tion and status in meeting conditions is a different matter from bare existence. The fact that something is desired only raises the guestion of its desirability; it does not settle it. Only a child in the degree of his immaturity thinks to settle the ques- tion of desirability by reiterated proclamation: “I want it, I want it, I want it.”? What is objected to in the current empirical theory of values is not connection of them with desire and enjoyment but failure to distinguish between enjoyments of radically different sorts. There are many common expressions in which the difference of the two kinds is clearly recog- nized. Take for example the difference between the ideas of “satisfying” and “satisfactory.” To say that something satisfies is to report something as an isolated finality. To assert that it is satisfactory is to define it in its connections and interac- tions. The fact that it pleases or is immediately congenial poses a problem to judgment. How shall the satisfaction be rated? Is it a value or is it not? Is it something to be prized and cherished, zo be enjoyed? Not stern moralists alone but every- day experience informs us that finding satisfaction in a thing may be a warning, a summons to be on the lookout for conse- quences. To declare something satisfactory is to assert that it meets specifiable conditions. It is, in effect, a judgment that the thing “will do.” It involves a prediction; it contemplates a 260 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD future in which the thing will continue to serve; it wll do. It asserts a consequence the thing will actively institute; it will do. That it is satisfying is the content of a proposition of fact; that it is satisfactory is a judgment, an estimate, an appraisal. It denotes an attitude zo de taken, that of striving to perpetuate and to make secure. It is worth notice that besides the instances given, there are many other recognitions in ordinary speech of the distinc- tion. The endings “able,” “worthy” and “ful” are cases in point. Noted and notable, noteworthy; remarked and remark- able; advised and advisable; wondered at and wonderful; pleasing and beautiful; loved and lovable; blamed and blame- able, blameworthy; objected to and objectionable; esteemed and estimable; admired and admirable; shamed and shameful; honored and honorable; approved and approvable, worthy of approbation, etc. The multiplication of words adds nothing to the force of the distinction. But it aids in conveying a sense of the fundamental character of the distinction; of the differ- ence between mere report of an already existent fact and judg- ment as to the importance and need of bringing a fact into existence; or, if it is already there, of sustaining it in existence. The latter is a genuine practical judgment, and marks the only type of judgment that has to do with the direction of action. Whether or no we reserve the term “value” for the latter, (as seems to me proper) is a minor matter; that the distinc- tion be acknowledged as the key to understanding the rela- tion of values to the direction of conduct is the important thing. This element of direction by an idea of value applies to science as well as anywhere else. For in every scientific un- dertaking, there is passed a constant succession of estimates; such as “it is worth treating these facts as data or evidence; it is advisable to try this experiment; to make that observation; 261 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY to entertain such and such a hypothesis; to perform this calcu- lation,” etc. | The word “taste” has perhaps got too completely associ- ated with arbitrary liking to express the nature of judgments of value. But if the word be used in the sense of an appre- ciation at once cultivated and active, one may say that the for- mation of taste is the chief matter wherever values enter in, whether intellectual, esthetic or moral. Relatively immediate judgments, which we call tact or to which we give the name of intuition, do not precede reflective inquiry, but are the funded products of much thoughtful experience. Expertness of taste is at once the result and the reward of constant exer- cise of thinking. Instead of there being no disputing about tastes, they are the one thing worth disputing about, if by “dispute” is signified discussion involving reflective inquiry. Taste, if we use the word in its best sense, is the outcome of experience brought cumulatively to bear on the intelligent ap- preciation of the real worth of likings and enjoyments. There is nothing in which a person so completely reveals himself as in the things which he judges enjoyable and desirable. Such judgments are the sole alternative to the domination of belief by impulse, chance, blind habit and self-interest. The forma- tion of a cultivated and effectively operative good judgment or taste with respect to what is esthetically admirable, intel- lectually acceptable and morally approvable is the supreme task set to human beings by the incidents of experience. Propositions about what is or has been liked are of instru- mental value in reaching judgments of value, in as far as the conditions and consequences of the thing liked are thought about. In themselves they make no claims; they put forth no demand upon subsequent attitudes and acts; they profess no authority to direct. If one likes a thing he likes it; that a a point about which there can be no dispute:—although it 1s 262 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD not so easy to state just what is liked as is frequently assumed. A judgment about what is zo de desired and enjoyed is, on the other hand, a claim on future action; it eae helo not merely de facto) quality. It is a matter of frequent experi- ence that likings“and enjoyments are of all kinds, and that many are such as reflective judgments condemn. By way of self-justification and “rationalization,” an enjoyment creates a tendency to assert that the thing enjoyed is a value. This as- sertion of validity adds authority to the fact. It is a decision that the object has a right to exist and hence a claim upon action to further its existence. The analogy between the status of the theory of values and the theory of ideas about natural objects before the rise of experimental inquiry may be carried further. The sensa- tionalistic theory of the origin and test of thought evoked, by way of reaction, the transcendental theory of @ priori ideas. For it failed utterly to account for objective connection, order and regularity in objects observed. Similarly, any doctrine that identifies the mere fact of being liked with the value of the object liked so fails to give direction to conduct when direction is needed that it automatically calls forth the asser- tion that there are values eternally in Being that are the standards of all judgments and the obligatory ends of all ac- tion. Without the introduction of operational thinking, we oscillate between a theory that, in order to save the objec- — tivity of judgments of values, isolates them from experience and nature, and a theory that, in order to save their concrete and human significance, reduces them to mere statements about our own feelings. Not even the most devoted adherents of the notion that enjoyment and value are equivalent facts would venture to assert that because we have once liked a thing we should go on liking it; they are compelled*to introduce the idea that some 263 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tastes are to be cultivated. Logically, there is no ground for introducing the idea of cultivation; liking is liking, and one is as good as another. If enjoyments are values, the judg- ment of value cannot regulate the form which liking takes; it cannot regulate its own conditions, Desire and purpose, and hence action, are left without guidance, although the question of regulation of their formation is the supreme problem of ‘y practical life. Values (to sum up) may be connected inher- ently with liking, and yet not with every liking but only with those that judgment has approved, after examination of the relation upon which the object liked depends. A casual liking is one that happens without knowledge of how it occurs nor to what effect. The difference between it and one which is sought because* of a judgment that it is worth having and is to be striven for, makes just the difference between enjoyments which are accidental and enjoyments that have value and hence a claim upon our attitude and conduct. In any case, the alternative rationalistic theory does not afford the guidance for the sake of which eternal and immu- table norms are appealed to. The scientist finds no help in determining the probable truth of some proposed theory by comparing it with a standard of absolute truth and immutable being. He has to rely upon definite operations undertaken under definite conditions—upon method. We can hardly imag- ine an architect getting aid in the construction of a building from an ideal at large, though we can understand his framing an ideal on the basis of knowledge of actual conditions and needs. Nor does the ideal of perfect beauty in antecedent Being give direction to a painter in producing a particular work of art. In morals, absolute perfection does not seem to beé more than a generalized hypostatization of the recognition that there is a good to be sought, an obligation to be met—both being concrete matters. Nor is the defect in this respect merely 264 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD negative. An examination of history would reveal, I am con- fident, that these general and remote schemes of value actually obtain a content definite enough and near enough to concrete situations as to afford guidance in action only by consecrating some institution or dogma already having social currency. Concreteness is gained, but it is by protecting from inquiry some accepted standard which perhaps is outworn and in need of criticism. When theories of values do not afford intellectual assist- ance in framing ideas and beliefs about values that are adequate to direct action, the gap must be filled by other means. If intel- _ligent method is lacking, prejudice, the pressure of immediate circumstance, self-interest and class-interest, traditional cus- toms, institutions of accidental historic origin, are mot lacking, and they tend to take the place of intelligence. Thus we are led to our main proposition: Aud gments about values are judg- ments about the conditions and the results of experienced ob- jects; judgments about that which should regulate the forma- tion of our desires, affections and enjoyments.\For whatever decides their formation will determine the main course of our conduct, personal and social. If it sounds strange to. hear that we should frame our judgments as to what has value by considering the connections in existence of what we like and enjoy, the reply i ‘is not far to seek. As tong as we do not engage in this inquiry enjoyments (values if we choose to apply that term) are casual; they are given by “nature,” not constructed by art. Like natural ob- jects in their qualitative existence, they at most only supply material for elaboration in rational discourse. A feeling of good or excellence is as far removed from goodness in fact as a feeling that objects are intellectually thus and so is re- moved from their being actually so. To recognize that the truth of natural objects can be reached only by the greatest 265 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY care in selecting and arranging directed operations, and then to suppose that values can be truly determined by the mere fact of liking seems to leave us in an incredible position. All the serious perplexities of life come back to the genuine diffi- culty of forming a judgment as to the values of the situa- tion; they come back to a conflict of goods. Only dogmatism can suppose that serious moral conflict is between something clearly bad and something known to be good, and that un- certainty lies wholly in the will of the one choosing. Most conflicts of importance are conflicts between things which are y or have been satisfying, not between good and evil. And to - suppose that we can make a hierarchical table of values at large once for all, a kind of catalogue in which they are ar- ranged in an order of ascending or descending worth, is to indulge in a gloss on our inability to frame intelligent judg- ments in the concrete. Or else it is to dignify customary choice and prejudice by a title of honor. | The alternative to definition, classification and systematiza- \ tion of satisfactions just as they happen to occur is judgment of them by means of the relations under which they occur. If we know the conditions under which the act of liking, of desire and enjoyment, takes place, we are in a position to — know what are the consequences of that act. The difference between the desired and the desirable, admired and the ad- mirable, becomes effective at just this point. Consider the difference between the proposition “That thing has been eaten,” and the judgment “That thing is edible.” The for- mer statement involves no knowledge of any relation except the one stated; while we are able to judge of the edibility of anything only when we have a knowledge of its interactions with other things sufficient to enable us to foresee its prob- able effects when it is taken into the organism and produces effects there. 266 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD at o assume that anything can be known in isolation from its connections with other things is to identify knowing with merely having some object before perception or in feeling, and is thus to lose the key to the traits that distinguish an object as known It is futile, even silly, to suppose that some quality that is directly present constitutes the whole of the thing presenting the quality. It does not do so when the qual- ity is that of being hot or fluid or heavy, and it does not when the quality is that of giving pleasure, or being enjoyed. Such qualities are, once more, effects, ends in the sense of closing termini of processes involving causal connections. They are something to be investigated, challenges to inquiry and judg- ment. The more connections and interactions we ascertain, the more we know the object in question. Thinking is search for these connections. Heat experienced as a consequence of directed operations has a meaning quite different from the heat that is casually experienced without knowledge of how it came about. The same is true of enjoyments. Enjoyments that issue from conduct directed by insight into relations have a mean- ing and a validity due to the way in which they are experi- enced. Such enjoyments are not repented of; they generate no after-taste of bitterness. Even in the midst of direct en- joyment, there is a sense of validity, of authorization, which intensifies the enjoyment. There is solicitude for perpetua- tion of the object having value which is radically different from mere anxiety to perpetuate the feeling of enjoyment. Such statements as we have been making are, therefore, far from implying that there are values apart from things actually enjoyed as good. To find a thing enjoyadle is, so to say, a plus enjoyment. We saw that it was foolish to treat the scientific object as a rival to or substitute for the perceived object, since the former is intermediate between uncertain and settled situations and those experienced under conditions 267 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of greater control. In the same way, judgment of the value of an object to be experienced is instrumental to appreciation of it when it is realized. But the notion that every object that happens to satisfy has an equal claim with every other to be a value is like supposing that every object of perception has the same cognitive force as every other. There is no knowledge without perception; but objects perceived are known only when they are determined as consequences of connective op- erations. There is no value except where there is satisfaction, ~~ but there have to be certain conditions fulfilled to transform a satisfaction into a value. The time will come when it will be found passing strange that we of this age should take such pains to control by every means at command the formation of ideas of physical things, even those most remote from human concern, and yet are content with haphazard beliefs about the qualities of objects that regulate our deepest interests; that we are scrupulous as to methods of forming ideas of natural objects, and either dogmatic or else driven by immediate conditions in framing those about values. There is, by implication, if not explicitly, a prevalent notion that values are already well known and that all which is lacking is the will to cultivate them in the order of their worth. In fact the most profound lack is not the will to act upon goods already known but the will to know what they are. It is not a dream that it is possible to exercise some degree of regulation of the occurrence of enjoyments which are of value. Realization of the possibility is exemplified, for ex- ample, in the technologies and arts of industrial life—that is, up to a definite limit. Men desired heat, light, and speed of transit and of communication beyond what nature provides of itself. These things have been attained not by lauding the enjoyment of these things and preaching their desirability, but 268 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD by study of the conditions of their manifestation. Knowledge of relations having been obtained, ability to produce followed, and enjoyment ensued as a matter of course. It is, however, an old story that enjoyment of these things as goods is no war- rant of their bringing only good in their train. As Plato was given to pointing out, the physician may know to heal and the orator to persuade, but the terior) knowledge of whether it is better for a man to be he r to be persuaded to the orator’s opinion remains unsettled. Here there appears the split between what are traditionally and conventionally called the values of the baser arts and the higher values of the truly _ personal and humane arts. With respect to the former, there is no assumption that they can be had and enjoyed without definite operative knowl- edge. With respect to them it is also clear that the degree in which we value them is measurable by the pains taken to con- trol the conditions of their occurrence. With respect to the latter, it is assumed that no one who is honest can be in doubt what they are; that by revelation, or conscience, or the in- struction of others, or immediate feeling, they are clear be- yond question. And instead of action in their behalf being taken to be a measure of the extent in which things are values to us, it is assumed that the difficulty is to persuade men to act upon what they already know to be good. Knowledge of conditions and consequences is regarded as wholly indifferent to judging what is of serious value, though it is useful in a prudential way in trying to actualize it. In consequence, the existence of values that are by common consent of a secondary and technical sort are under a fair degree of control, while those denominated supreme and imperative are subject to all the winds of impulse, custom and arbitrary authority. This distinction between higher and lower types of value is itself something to be looked into. Why should there be 269 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY a sharp division made between some goods as physical and material and others as ideal and “spiritual”? The question touches the whole dualism of the material and the ideal at its root. To denominate anything “matter” or “material” is not in truth to disparage it. It is, if the designation is correctly ap- plied, a way of indicating that the thing in question is a con- dition or means of the existence of something else. And disparagement of effective means is practically synonymous with disregard of the things that aérvtermed, in eulogistic fashion, ideal and spiritual. For the latter terms if they have any concrete application at all signify something which is a de- sirable consummation of conditions, a cherished fulfillment of means, The sharp separation between material and ideal good thus deprives the latter of the underpinning of effective support while it opens the way for treating things which should be em- ployed as means as ends in themselves. For since men cannot after all live without some measure of possession of such mat- ters as health and wealth, the latter things will be viewed as values and ends in isolation unless they are treated as integral constituents of the goods that are deemed supreme and final. The relations that determine the occurrence of what hu- man beings experience, especially when social connections are taken into account, are indefinitely wider and more complex than those that determine the events termed physical; the latter are the outcome of definite selective operations. This is the reason why we know something about remote objects like the stars better than we know significantly characteristic things about our own bodies and minds. We forget the infinite num- ber of things we do not know about the stars, or rather that what we call a star is itself the product of the elimination, enforced and deliberate, of most of the traits that belong to an actual existence. The amount of knowledge we possess about stars would not seem very great or very important if it were 270 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD carried over to human beings and exhausted our knowledge of them. It is inevitable that genuine knowledge of man and society should lag far behind physical knowledge. But this difference is not a ground for making a sharp division between the two, nor does it account for the fact that we make so little use of the experimental method of forming our ideas and beliefs abou the concerns of man in his char- acteristic social relations. at this separation religions and philosophies must admit some responsibility. They have erected a distinction between a narrower scope of relations and a wider and fuller one into a difference of kind, naming one kind mate- rial, and the other mental and moral. They have charged pe gratuitously with the office of diffusing belief in the necessity of the division, and with instilling contempt for the material as something inferior in kind in its intrinsic na- ture and worth, Formal philosophies undergo evaporation of their technical solid contents; in a thinner and more viable form they find their way into the minds of those who know nothing of their original forms. When these diffuse and, so to say, airy emanations re-crystallize in the popular mind they form a hard deposit of opinion that alters slowly and with great difficulty. What difference would it actually make in the arts of con- duct, personal and social, if the experimental theory were adopted not as a mere theory, but as a part of the working equipment of habitual attitudes on the part of everyone? It would be impossible, even were time given, to answer the ques- tion in adequate detail, just as men could not foretell in ad- vance the consequences for knowledge of adopting the ex- perimental method. It is the nature of the method that it has to be tried. But there are generic lines of difference which, within the limits of time at disposal, may be sketched. Change from forming ideas and judgments of value on 271 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY the basis of conformity to antecedent objects, to constructing enjoyable objects directed by knowledge of consequences, is a change from looking to the past to looking to the future. I do not for a moment suppose that the experiences of the past, personal and social, are of no importance. For with- out them we should not be able to frame any ideas whatever of the conditions under which objects are enjoyed nor any estimate of the consequences of esteeming and liking them. But past experiences are significant in giving us intellectual in- strumentalities of judging just these points. They are tools, not finalities. Reflection upon what we have liked and have enjoyed is a necessity. But it tells us nothing about the value of these things until enjoyments are themselves reflectively con- trolled, or, until, as they now recalled, we form the best judgment possible about what led us to like this sort of thing and what has issued from the fact that we liked it. We are not, then, to get away from enjoyments experi- enced in the past and from recall of them, but from the no- tion that they are the arbiters of things to be further enjoyed. At present, the arbiter is found in the past, although there are many ways of interpreting what in the past is authorita- tive. Nominally, the most influential conception doubtless is that of a revelation once had or a perfect life once lived. Re- lance upon precedent, upon institutions created in the past, es- pecially in law, upon rules of morals that have come to us through unexamined customs, upon uncriticized tradition, are other forms of dependence. It is not for a moment suggested that we can get away from customs and established institu- tions. A mere break would doubtless result simply in chaos. But there is no danger of such a break. Mankind is too inertly conservative both by constitution and by education to give the idea of this danger actuality. What there is genuine danger of is that the force of new conditions will produce disruption ex- 2°72 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD ternally and mechanically: this is an ever present danger. The prospect is increased, not mitigated, by that conservatism which insists upon the adequacy of old standards to meet new con- ditions. What is needed is intelligent examination of the con- sequences that are actually effected by inherited institutions and customs, in order that there may be intelligent considera- tion of the ways in which they are to be intentionally modified in behalf of generation of different consequences. This is the significant meaning of transfer of experimental method from the technical field of physical experience to the wider fie timan life: /We trust the method in forming our beliefs about things rot directly connected with human life. In effect, we distrust it in moral, political and economic affairs. In the fine arts, there are many signs of a change. In the past, such a change has often been an omen and precursor of changes in other human attitudes. But, generally speak- ing, the idea of actively adopting experimental method in social affairs, in the matters deemed of most enduring and ulti- mate worth, strikes most persons as a surrender of all stand- ards and regulative authority. But in principle, experimental method does not signify random and aimless action; it implies direction by ideas and knowledge. The question at issue is a practical one. Are there in existence the ideas and the knowl- _ edge that permit “experimental method to be effectively t used in social interests and affairs? Where will regulation come from if we surrender familiar and traditionally prized values as our directive standards? Very largely from the findings of the natural sciences. For one of the effects of the separation drawn between knowledge and action is to deprive scientific knowledge of its proper serv- ice as a guide of conduct—except once more in those techno- logical fields which have been degraded to an inferior rank. Of course, the complexity of the conditions upon which ob- 273 ase A IO THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY jects of human and liberal value depend is a great obstacle, and it would be too optimistic to say that we have as yet enough knowledge of the scientific type to enable us to regu- late our judgments of value very extensively. But we have more knowledge than we try to put to use, and until we try more systematically we shall not know what are the important gaps in our sciences judged from the point of view of their moral and humane use. For moralists usually draw a sharp line between the field of the natural sciences and the conduct that is regarded as moral. But a moral that frames its judgments of value on the basis of consequences must depend in a most intimate manner upon the conclusions of science. For the knowledge of the relations between changes which enable us to connect things as antecedents and consequences 7s science. The narrow scope which moralists often give to morals, their isolation of some conduct as virtuous and vicious from other large ranges of conduct, those having to do with health and vigor, business, education, with all the affairs in which desires and affection are implicated, is perpetuated by this habit of exclusion of the subject-matter of natural science from a réle in formation of moral standards and ideals. The same attitude operates in the other direction to keep natural science a technical specialty, and it works unconsciously to encourage its use exclusively in regions where it can be turned to personal and class advantage, as in war and trade. Another great difference to be made by carrying the ex- perimental habit into all matter of practice is that it cuts the roots of what is often called subjectivism, but which is bet- ter termed egoism, J[he subjective attitude is much more wide- spread than would be inferred from the philosophies which have that label attached. It is as rampant in realistic philoso- phies as in any others, sometimes even more so, although dis- 274 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD guised from those who hold these philosophies under the cover of reverence of and enjoyment of ultimate values. For the implication of placing the standard of thought and knowledge in antecedent_existence is that our thought makes no differ- ence in what is significantly real. It then affects only our own attitude toward it. This constant throwing of emphasis back upon a change made in ourselves instead of one made in the world in which we live seems to me the essence of what is objectionable in “subjectivism.” Its taint hangs’ about even Platonic realism with its insistent evangelical dwelling upon the change made within the mind by contemplation of the realm of essence, and its depreciation of action as transient and all but sordid —a concession to the necessities of organic existence. All the theories which put conversion “of the eye of the soul” in the , place of a conversion of natural and social objects that modifies | goods actually experienced, is a retreat and escape from ex-_ istence—and this retraction into self is, once more, the heart of subjective egoisms. The typical example is perhaps the other-worldliness found in religions whose chief concern is with the salvation of the personal soul. But other-worldliness is found as well in estheticism and in all seclusion within ivory towers. It is not in the least implied that change in personal atti- tudes, in the disposition of the “subject,” is not of great im- portance. Such change, on the contrary, is involved in any at- tempt to modify the conditions of the environment. But there is a radical difference between a change in the self that is cultivated and valued as an end, and one that is a means to alteration, through action, of objective conditions. The Aris- totelian-medieval conviction that highest bliss is found in con- templative possession of ultimate Being presents an ideal at- tractive to some types of mind; it sets forth a refined sort of 275 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY enjoyment. It is a doctrine congenial to minds that despair of the effort involved in creation of a better world of daily ex- perience. It is, apart from theological attachments, a doctrine sure to recur when social conditions are so troubled as to make actual endeavor seem hopeless. But the subjectivism so externally marked in modern thought as compared with an- cient is either a development of the old doctrine under new conditions or is of merely technical import. The medieval version of the doctrine at least had the active support of a great social institution by means of which man could be brought into the state of mind that prepared him for ultimate enjoyment of eternal Being. It had a certain solidity and depth which is lacking in modern theories that would attain the re- sult by merely emotional or speculative procedures, or by any means not demanding a change in objective existence so as to render objects of value more empirically secure. The nature in detail of the revolution that would be wrought by carrying into the region of values the principle now embodied in scientific practice cannot be told; to attempt it would violate the fundamental idea that we know only after we have acted and in consequences of the outcome of action. But it would surely effect a transfer of attention and energy from the subjective to the objective. Men would think of themselves as agents not as ends; ends would be found in experienced enjoyment of the fruits of a transforming ac- tivity. In as far as the subjectivity of modern thought repre- sents a discovery of the part played by personal responses, organic and acquired, in the causal production of the qualities and values of objects, it marks the possibility of a decisive © gain. It puts us in possession of some of the conditions that control the occurrence of experienced objects, and thereby it supplies us with an instrument of regulation. There is some- thing querulous in the sweeping denial that things as experi- 276 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD enced, as perceived and enjoyed, in any way depend upon in- teraction with human selves. The error of doctrines that have exploited the part played by personal and subjective reactions in determining what is perceived and enjoyed lies either in exaggerating this factor of constitution into the sole condition —as happens in subjective idealism—or else in treating it as a finality instead of, as with all knowledge, an instrument in direction of further action. | A third significant change that would issue from carrying over experimental method from physics to man concerns the import of standards, principles, rules.| With the transfer, these, and all tenets and creeds about good and goods, would be recognized to be hypotheses. Instead of being rigidly fixed, they would be treated as intellectual instruments to be tested and confirmed—and altered—through consequences effected by acting upon them. The uld lose all pretence of finality —the ulterior source of dogmatism. It is both astonishing and | depressing that so much of the energy of mankind has gone into fighting for (with weapons of the flesh as well as of the spirit) the truth of creeds, religious, moral and political, as distinct from what has gone into effort to try creeds by put- ting them to the test_of acting upon them. The change would do away with the intolerance and fanaticism that attend the notion that beliefs and judgments are capable of inherent truth and authority; inherent in the sense of being independent of what they lead to when used as directive principles. The trans- formation does not imply merely that men are responsible for acting upon what they profess to believe; that is an old doctrine. It goes much further. Any belief as such is tentative, hypothetical; it is not just to be acted upon, but is to be framed with reference to its office as a guide to action. Consequently, it should be the last thing in the world to be picked up casually and then clung to rigidly. When it is apprehended as a tool 277 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY and only a tool, an instrumentality of direction, the same scrupulous attention will go to its formation as now goes into the making of instruments of precision in technical fields. Men, instead of being protd of accepting and asserting beliefs and “principles” on the ground of loyalty, will be as ashamed of that procedure as they would now be to confess their as- sent to a scientific theory out of reverence for Newton or Helmholz or whomever, without regard to evidence. If one stops to consider the matter, is there not something strange in the fact that men should consider loyalty to “laws,” principles, standards, ideals to be an inherent virtue, accounted unto them for righteousness? It is as if they were making up for some secret sense of weakness by rigidity and intensity of insistent attachment. A moral law, like a law in physics, is not something to swear by and stick to at all hazards; it isa formula of the way to respond when specified conditions pre- sent themselves. Its soundness and pertinence are tested by what happens when it is acted upon. Its claim or authority rests finally upon the imperativeness of the situation that has to be dealt with, not upon its own intrinsic nature—as any tool achieves dignity in the measure of needs served by it. The idea that adherence to standards external to experienced objects is the only alternative to confusion and lawlessness was once held in science. But knowledge became steadily progressive when it was abandoned, ne’ len tests found within con- crete acts and objects were employed. The test of consequences is more exacting than that afforded by fixed general rules. In addition, it secures constant development, for when new acts are tried new results are experienced, while the lauded immu- tability of eternal ideals and norms is in itself a denial of the possibility of development and improvement. The various modifications that would result from adop- tion in social and humane subjects of the experimental way 278 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD of thinking are perhaps summed up in saying that it would | place method and means upon the level of importance that has, in the past, been imputed exclusively to ends. Means have been regarded as menial, and the useful as the servile. Means have been treated as poor relations to be endured, but not inherently welcome. The very meaning of the word “ideals” is significant of the divorce which has obtained be- tween means and ends. “Ideals” are thought to be remote and inaccessible of attainment; they are too high and fine to be sullied by realization. They serve vaguely to arouse “aspira- tion,” but they do not evoke and direct strivings for embodi- ment in actual existence. They hover in an indefinite way over the actual scene; they are expiring ghosts of a once signifi- cant kingdom of divine reality whose rule penetrated to every detail of life. It is impossible to form a just estimate of the paralysis of effort that has been produced by indifference to means. Logically, it is truistic that lack of consideration for means signifies that so-called ends are not taken seriously. It is as if one professed devotion to painting pictures conjoined with con- tempt for canvas, brush and paints; or love of music on con- dition that no instruments, whether the voice or something external, be used to make sounds. The good workman in the arts is known by his respect for his tools and by his interest in perfecting his technique. The glorification in the arts of ends at the expense of means would be taken to be a sign of complete insincerity or even insanity. Ends separated from means are either sentimental indulgences or if they happen to exist are merely accidental. The ineffectiveness in action of “ideals” is due precisely to the supposition that means and ends are not on exactly the same level with respect to the atten- tion and care they demand. It is, however, much easier to point out the formal con- 279 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY tradiction implied in ideals that are professed without_equal regard for the instruments and techniques of their realization, than it is to appreciate the concrete ways in which belief in their separation has found its way into life and borne corrupt and poisonous fruits, 0 he separation marks the form in which the traditional divorce_of theory and practice has expressed itself in actual life. It accounts for the relative impotency of arts concerned with enduring human welfare. Sentimental at- tachment and subjective eulogy take the place of action. For there is no art without tools and instrumental agencies. But it also explains the fact that in actual behavior, energies de- voted to matters nominally thought to be inferior, material and sordid, engross attention and interest. After a polite and pious deference has been paid to “ideals,” men feel free to devote themselves to matters which are more immediate and pressing. It is usual to condemn the amount of attention paid by people in general to material ease, comfort, wealth, and suc- cess gained by competition, on the ground that they give to mere means the attention that ought to be given to ends, or that they have taken for ends things which in reality are only means. Criticisms of the place which economic interest and action occupy in present life are full of complaints that men allow lower aims to usurp the place that belongs to higher and ideal values.€[he final source of the trouble is, however, that moral and spiritual “leaders” have propagated the notion that ideal ends may be cultivated in isolation from “mate- rial” means, as if means and material were not synonymous While they condemn men for giving to means the thought and energy that ought to go to ends, the condemnation should go to them. For they have not taught their followers to think of material and economic activities as really means. [hey have been unwilling to frame their conception of the values that should be regulative of human conduct on the basis of the 280 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD actual conditions and operations by which alone values can be actualized.) »* Practical needs are imminent; with the mass of mankind they are imperative. Moreover, speaking generally, men are formed to act rather than to theorize. Since the ideal ends are so remotely and accidentally connected with immediate and urgent conditions that need attention, after lip service is given to them, men naturally devote themselves to the latter. If a bird in the hand is worth two in a neighboring bush, an actuality in hand is worth, for the direction of conduct, many ideals that are so remote as to be invisible and inaccessible. Men hoist the banner of the ideal, and then march in the direc- tion that concrete conditions suggest and reward. Deliberate insincerity and hypocrisy are rare. But the no- tion that action and sentiment are inherently unified in the con- stitution of human nature has nothing to justify it. Integration is something to be achieved. Division of attitudes and re- sponses, compartmentalizing of interests, is easily acquired. It goes deep just because the acquisition is unconscious, a mat- ter of habitual adaptation to conditions. Theory separated from concrete doing and making is empty and futile; practice then becomes an immediate seizure of opportunities and en- joyments which conditions afford without the direction which theory—knowledge and ideas—has power to supply. The problem of the relation of theory and practice is not a prob- lem of theory alone; it is that, but it is also the most practical problem of life. For it is the question of how intelligence may inform action, and how action may bear the fruit of in- creased insight into meaning: a clear view of the values that are worth while and of the means by which they are to be made secure in experienced objects. Construction of ideals in general and their sentimental glorification are easy; the responsibilities both of studious thought and of action are shirked. Persons 281 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY having the advantage of positions of leisure and who find pleasure in abstract theorizing—a most delightful indulgence to those to whom it appeals—have a large measure of liability for a cultivated diffusion of ideals and aims that are sepa- rated from the conditions which are the means of actualization. Then other persons who find themselves in positions of social power and authority readily claim to be the bearers and de- fenders of ideal ends in church and state. They then use the prestige and authority their representative capacity as guardians of the highest ends confers on them to cover actions taken in behalf of the harshest and narrowest of material ends. The present state of industrial life seems to give a fair index of the existing separation of means and ends. Isolation of economics from ideal ends, whether of morals or of or- ganized social life, was proclaimed by Aristotle. Certain things, he said, are conditions of a worthy life, personal and social, but are not constituents of it. The economic life of man, con- cerned with satisfaction of wants, is of this nature. Men have wants and they must be satisfied. But they are only prerequi- sites of a good life, not intrinsic elements in it. Most philoso- phers have not been so frank nor perhaps so logical. But upon the whole, economics has been treated as on a lower level than either morale-er-polttics, Yet the life which men, women and children actually lead, the opportunities open to them, the values they are capable of enjoying, their education, their share in all the things of art and science, are mainly deter- mined by economic conditions. Hence we can hardly expect a moral system which ignores economic conditions to be other than remote and empty. Industrial life is correspondingly brutalized by failure to equate it as the means by which social and cultural values are realized. That the economic life, thus exiled from the pale of higher values, takes revenge by declaring that it is the only 2.82 THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD social reality, and by means of the doctrine of materialistic determination of institutions and conduct in all fields, denies to deliberate morals and politics any share of causal regulation, is not surprising. When economists were told that their subject-matter was merely material, they naturally thought they could be “scien- tific? only by excluding all reference to distinctively human values. Material wants, efforts to satisfy them, even the scientifically regulated technologies highly developed in indus- trial activity, are then taken to form a complete and closed field. If any reference to social ends and values is intro- duced it is by way of an external addition, mainly hortatory. That economic life largely determines the conditions under which mankind has access to concrete values may be recognized or it may not be. In either case, the notion that it is the means to be utilized in order to secure significant values as the com- mon and shared possession of mankind is alien and inopera- tive. To many persons, the idea that the ends professed by morals are impotent save as they are connected with the work- ing machinery of economic life seems like deflowering the purity of moral values and obligations. The social and moral effects of the separation of theory and practice have been merely hinted at. They are so mani- fold and so pervasive that an adequate consideration of them would involve nothing less than a survey of the whole field of morals, economics and politics It cannot be justly stated that these effects are in fact direct consequences of the quest for certainty by thought and knowledge isolated from mir or, as we have seen, this quest was itself a reflex product of actual conditions. But it may be truly asserted that this quest, under- taken in religion and philosophy, has had results which have reinforced the conditions which originally brought it about. Moreover, search for safety and consolation amid the perils 283 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY of life by means other than intelligent action, by feeling and shout alone Geeua When aicial 2 cane GEE ae lack- ing, when arts were undeveloped. It had then a relative his- toric justification that is now lacking. The primary problem for thinking which lays claim to be philosophic in its breadth and depth is to assist in bringing about a reconstruction of all beliefs rooted in a basic separation of knowledge and action; to develop a system of operative ideas congruous with present knowledge and with present facilities of control over natural events and energies. _ ~ We have noted more than once how modern philosophy has been absorbed in the problem of affecting an adjustment between the conclusions of natural science and the beliefs and values that have authority in the direction of life. The genuine and poignant issue does not reside where philosophers for the most part have placed it. It does not consist in accommodation to each other of two realms, one physical and the other ideal and spiritual, nor in the reconciliation of the “categories” of theoretical and practical reason. It is found in that isolation of executive means and ideal interests which has grown up under the influence of the separation of theory and practice. For this, by nature, involves the separation of the material and the spiritual. Its solution, therefore, can be found only in action wherein the phenomena of material and economic life are equated with the purposes that command the loyalties of affection and purpose, and in which ends and ideals are framed in terms of the possibilities of actually experienced ' situations. But while the solution cannot be found in “thought” alone, it can be furthered by thinking which is operative— which frames and defines ideas in terms of what may be done, and which uses the conclusions of science as instrumentalities. William James was well within the bounds of moderation when he said that looking forward instead of backward, look- 284. THE CONSTRUCTION OF GOOD ing to what the world and life might become instead of to what they have been, is an alteration in the “seat of authority.” It was incidentally remarked earlier in our discussion that the serious defect in the current empirical philosophy of values, | the one which identifies them with things actually enjoyed irrespective of the conditions upon which they depend, is that it formulates and in so far consecrates the conditions of our present social experience. Throughout these chapters, primary attention has perforce been given to the methods and state- ments of philosophic theories. But these statements are tech- nical and specialized in formulation only. In origin, content and import they are reflections of some condition or some phase of concrete human experience. Just as the theory of the separation of theory and practice has a practical origin and a -momentous practical consequence, so the empirical theory that values are identical with whatever men actually enjoy, no mat- ter how or what, formulates an aspect, and an undesirable one, of the present social situation. For while our discussion has given more attention to the other type of philosophical doctrine, that which holds that regulative and authoritative standards are found in transcend- ent eternal values, it has not passed in silence over the fact that actually the greater part of the activities of the greater number of human beings is spent in effort to seize upon and hold onto such enjoyments.as the actual scene permits. Their energies and their enjoyments are controlled in fact, but they are controlled by external conditions rather than by intelligent judgment and endeavor. If philosophies have any influence over the thoughts and acts of men, it is a serious matter that the most widely held empirical theory should in effect justify this state of things by identifying values with the objects of any interest as such. As long as the only theories of value placed before us for in- tellectual assent alternate between sending us to a realm of 285 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY eternal and fixed values and sending us to enjoyments such as actually obtain, the formulation, even as only a theory, of an experimental empiricism which finds values to be identical with goods that are the fruit of intelligently directed activity has its measure of practical significance. 286 CHAPTER XI THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION KANT CLAIMED THAT he had effected a Copernican evolution in philosophy by treating the world and our knowledge of it from the standpoint of the knowing subject. To most critics, the endeavor to make the known world turn on the constitu- tion of the knowing mind, seems like a return to an ultra- Ptolemaic system. But Copernicus, as Kant understood him, effected a straightening out of astronomical phenomena by interpreting their perceived movements from their relation to the perceiving subject, instead of treating them as inherent in the things perceived. The revolution of the sun about the earth as it offers itself to sense-perception was regarded as due to the conditions of human observation and not to the movements of the sun itself. Disregarding the consequences of the changed point of view, Kant settled upon this one feature as characteristic of the method of Copernicus. He thought he could generalize this feature of Copernican method, and thus clear up a multitude of philosophical diffi- culties by attributing the facts in question to the constitution PVE of the human subject_in knowing. That the consequence was Ptolemaic rather than Coper- nican is not to be wondered at. In fact, the alleged revolution of Kant consisted in making explicit what was implicit in the classic tradition. In words, the latter had asserted that know]l- edge is determined by the objective constitution of the universe. But it did so only after it had first assumed that the universe is itself constituted after the pattern of reason. Philosophers 287 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY first constructed a rational system of nature and then borrowed from it the features by which to characterize their knowledge of it. Kant, in effect, called attention to the borrowing; he insisted that credit for the borrowed material be assigned to human reason instead of to divine. His “revolution” was a \ shift from_a-theological to a human autl eyond that point, it was an explicit acknowledgment of what vhilosophes in the classic line of descent had been doing unconsciously before him. For the basic assumption of this tradition was the inherent correspondence subsisting between intellectus and the structure of Nature—the principle so definitely stated by Spinoza. By the time of Kant difficulties in this rationalistic “1 premise had become evident. He thought to maintain the yl” underlying idea and remedy the perplexities it entailed by | placing the locus of intellect in man as a knowing subject. f if The irritation which this performance arouses in some minds f is due rather to this transfer than to any doubt about the valid is function of reason in the constitution of nature. Kant refers incidentally to the experimental method of Galileo as an illustration of the way in which thought actually takes the lead, so that an object is known because of conformity to a prior conception:—because of its conformity to the speci- fications of the latter. The reference makes clear by contrast the genuine reversal contained in the experimental way_of knowing. It is true that experimentation proceeds on the basis “of a directive idea, But the difference between the office of the idea in determining a known object and the office assigned to it in Kant’s theory is as great as between the Copernican and the Ptolemaic systems. For an idea in experiment is tenta- tive, conditional, not fixed and rigorously determinative. It controls an action to be performed, but the consequences of the operation determine the worth of the directive idea; the latter does not fix the nature of the object. 2.88 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION Moreover, in experiment everything takes place above- board, in the open. Every step is overt and capable of being observed. There is a specified antecedent state of things; a specified operation using means, both physical and symbolic, which are externally exhibited and reported. The entire process by which the conclusion is reached that such and such a judg- ment of an object is valid is overt. It can be repeated step by step by any one. Thus every one can judge for himself whether or not the conclusion reached as to the object justifies assertion of knowledge, or whether there are gaps and deflections. More- over, the whole process goes on where other existential proc- esses go on, in time. There is a temporal sequence as definitely as in any art, as in, say, the making of cotton cloth from gin- ning of raw material, through carding and spinning to the op- eration of the loom. A public and manifest series of definite operations, all capable of public notice and report, distinguishes scientific knowing from the knowing carried on by inner “men- tal”? processes accessible only to introspection, or inferred by dialectic from assumed premises, There is accordingly opposition rather than agreement between the Kantian determination of objects by thought and the determination by thought that takes place in experimenta- tion. There is nothing hypothetical or conditional about Kant’s forms of perception and conception. They work uniformly and triumphantly; they need no differential testing by conse- quences. The reason Kant postulates them is to secure uni- versality and necessity instead of the hypothetical and the prob- able. Nor is there anything overt, observable and temporal or historical in the Kantian machinery. Its work is done behind the scenes. Only the result is observed, and only an elaborate process of dialectic inference enables Kant to assert the exist- ence of his apparatus of forms and categories. These are as inaccessible to observation as were the occult forms and essences 289 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY whose rejection was a prerequisite of development of modern science, These remarks are not directed particularly against Kant. For, as has been already said, he edited a new version of old conceptions about mind and its activities in knowing, rather than evolved a brand new theory. But since he happens to be the author of the phrase “Copernican revolution,” his phi- losophy forms a convenient point of departure for considera- tion of a genuine reversal of traditional ideas about the mind, reason, conceptions, and mental processes. Phases of this revo- lution have concerned us in the previous lectures. We have seen how the opposition between knowing and doing, theory and _ ¥ practice, has been abandoned in the actual enterprise of scien- [ Ta om + We have seen how the cognitive quest for absolute certainty ¥) tific inquiry, how knowing goes forward by means of doing. by purely mental means has been surrendered in behalf of search for a security, having a high degree of probability, by means of preliminary active regulation of conditions. We have considered some of the definite steps by which security has come to attach to regulation of change rather than absolute certainty to the unchangeable. We have noted how in con- sequence of this transformation the standard of judgment _ has been transferred from antecedents to consequents, from inert dependence upon the past to intentional construction of a future. If such changes do not constitute, in the depth and scope of their significance, a reversal comparable to a Copernican revolution, I am at a loss to know where such a change can be found or what it would be like. The old center was mind knowing by means of an equipment of powers complete within itself, and merely exercised upon an antecedent external mate- rial equally complete in itself. The new center is indefinite interactions taking place within a course of nature which is 2.90 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION not fixed and complete, but which is capable of direction to new and different results through the mediation of inten- tional operations. Neither self nor world, neither soul nor nature (in the sense of something isolated and finished in its isolation) is the center, any more than either earth or sun 1s the absolute center of a single universal and necessary frame of reference. There is a moving whole of interacting parts; | a center emerges wherever there is effort to change them in a particular direction. The reversal has many phases, and these are intercon- nected. It cannot be said that one is more important than another. But one change stands out with an extraordinary dis- tinctness. Mind is no longer a spectator beholding the world from without and finding its highest satisfaction in the joy of self-sufficing contemplation. The mind is within the world asa part of the latter’s own on-going process. It is marked off as mind by the fact that wherever it is found, changes take place in a directed way, so that a movement in a definite one- way sense—from the doubtful and confused to the clear, re- solved and settled—takes place. From knowing as an outside beholding to knowing as an active participant in the drama of an on-moving world is the historical transition whose record we have been following. As far as philosophy is concerned, the first direct and im- mediate effect of this shift from knowing which makes a differ- ence to the knower but none in the world, to knowing which is a directed change within the world, is the complete abandon- ment of what we may term the intellectualist fallacy. By this is meant something which may also be termed the ubiquity of knowledge as a measure of reality. Of the older philosophies, framed before experimental knowing had made any significant progress, it may be said that they made a definite separation between the world in which man thinks and knows and the 291 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY world in which he lives and acts. In his needs and in the acts that spring from them, man was a part of the world, a sharer in its fortunes, sometimes willingly, sometimes perforce; he was exposed to its vicissitudes and at the mercy of its irregular and unforeseeable changes. By acting in and upon the world he made his earthly way, sometimes failing, sometimes achiev- ing. He was acted upon by it, sometimes carried forward to unexpected glories and sometimes overwhelmed by its disfavor. Being unable to cope with the world in which he lived, he sought some way to come to terms with the universe as a whole. Religion was, in its origin, an expression of this en- deavor. After a time, a few persons with leisure and endowed by fortune with immunity from the rougher impacts of the world, discovered the delights of thought and inquiry. They reached the conclusion that through rational thought they could rise about the natural world in which, with their body and those mental processes that were connected with the body, they lived. In striving with the inclemencies of nature, suffer- ing its buffetings, wresting sustenance from its resources, they were parts of Nature. But in knowledge, true knowledge which is rational, occupied with objects that are universal and im- mutable, they escaped from the world of vicissitude and uncer- tainty. They were elevated above the realm in which needs are felt and laborious effort imperative. In rising above this world of sense and time, they came into rational communion with the divine which was untroubled and perfect mind. They became true participants in the realm of ultimate reality. Through knowledge, they were without the world of chance and change, and within the world of perfect and unchanging Being. How far this glorification by philosophers and scientific investigators of a life of knowing, apart from and above a life of doing, might have impressed the popular mind without 292 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION adventitious aid there is no saying. But external aid came. Theologians of the Christian Church adopted this view in a form adapted to their religious purposes. The perfect and ulti- mate reality was God; to know Him was eternal bliss, The world in which man lived and acted was a world of trials and troubles to test and prepare him for a higher destiny. Throug thousands of ways, including histories and rites, with symbols that engaged the emotions and imagination, the essentials of the doctrine of classic philosophy filtered its way into the popular mind. It would be a one-sided view which held that this story gives the entire account of the elevation of knowing and its object above practical action and its objects. A contributing cause was found in the harshness, cruelties and tragic frustra- tions of the world of action. Were it not for its brutalities and failures, the motive for seeking refuge in a higher realm of knowledge would have been lacking. It was easy and, as we say, “natural” to associate these evils with the fact that the world in which we act is a realm of change. The generic fact of change was made absolute and the source of all the troubles and defects of the world in which we directly live. At the very best, good and excellence are insecure in a world of change; good can be securely at home only in a realm of fixed unchanging substance. When the source of evil was once as- serted to reside in the inherent deficiencies of a realm of change, responsibility was removed from human ignorance, incapacity and insusceptibility. It remained only to change our own attitude and disposition, to turn the soul from perish- able things toward perfect Being. In this idea religion stated in one language precisely what the great philosophic tradition _ stated in another. Nor is this the whole of the story. There was, strangely enough, a definitely practical ground for the elevation of 293 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY knowledge_above doing and making. Whenever knowledge is Sri) ned See ae through ability to control ensues, [There is a natural inclination to treat value as a measure of reality. Since knowledge is the mode of expe- rience that puts in our hands the key to controlling our other dealings with experienced objects, it has a central position. There is no practical point gained in asserting that a thing is what it is experienced to be apart from knowledge. If a man hasctyphoid fever, he has it; he does not have to search for or pry into it. But to know it, he does have to search:—to thought, to intellect, the fever is what it is known to be. For when it is known, the various phenomena of having it, the direct experiences, fall into order; we have at least that kind of control called understanding, and with this comes the pos- sibility of a more active control. The very fact that other experiences speak, so to say, for themselves makes it uneces- sary to ask what they are. When the nature of an existence is in doubt and we have to seek for it, the idea of reality is consciously present. Hence the thought of existence becomes exclusively associated with knowing. Other ways of experi- encing things exist so obviously that we do not think of existence in connection with them. At all events, whatever the explanation, the idea that cog- nition is the measure of the reality found in other modes of experience is the most widely distributed premise of philoso- phies. The equation of the real and the known comes to ex- plicit statement in idealistic theories. If we remind ourselves of the landscape with trees and grasses waving in the wind and waves dancing in sunlight, we recall how scientific thought of these things strips off the qualities significant in perception and direct enjoyment, leaving only certain physical constants stated in mathematical formule. What is more natural, then, than to call upon mind to reclothe by some contributory act 294. THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION of thought or consciousness the grim skeleton offered by sci- ence? Then if only it can be shown that mathematical rela- tions are themselves a logical construction of thought, the knowing mind is enstated as the constitutive author of the whole scheme. Realistic theories have protested against doc- trines that make the knowing mind the source of the thing known, But they have held to a doctrine of a partial equation of the real and the known; only they have read the equation from the side of the object instead of the subject. Knowledge must be the grasp or vision of the real as it “4s in itself,” while emotions and affections deal with it as it is affected with an alien element supplied by the feeling and desiring subject. The postulate of the unique and exclusive relation among experi- enced things of knowledge and the real is shared by epistemo- logical idealist and realist. The meaning of a Copernican reversal is that we do not have to go to knowledge to obtain an exclusive hold on reality. The world as we experience it is a real world. But it is not in its primary phases a world that is known, a world that is understood, and is intellectually coherent and secure. Knowing consists of operations that give experienced objects a form in which the relations, upon which the onward course of events depends, are securely experienced. It marks a transitional redirection and rearrangement of the real. It is intermediate and instrumental; it comes between a relatively casual and accidental experience of existence and one relatively settled and defined. The knower is within the world of existence; his knowing, as experimental, marks an interaction of one existence with other existences. There is, however, a most important difference between it and other existential interactions. The difference is not between something going on within nature as a part of itself and something else taking place outside it, but is that between a regulated course of changes and an uncontrolled 295 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY one. In knowledge, causes become means and effects become consequences, and thereby things have meanings. The known object is an antecedent object as that is intentionally rearranged and redisposed, an eventual object whose value is tested by the reconstruction it effects. It emerges, as it were, from the fire of experimental thought as a refined metal issues from operations performed on crude material. It is the same object but the same object with a difference, as a man who has been through conditions which try the temper of his being comes out the same man and a different man. Knowledge then does not encompass the world as a whole. But the fact that it is not coextensive with experienced existence is no defect nor failure on its part. It is an expression of the fact that knowledge attends strictly to its own business:— transformation of disturbed and unsettled situations into those more controlled and more significant. Not all existence asks to be known, and it certainly does not ask leave from thought to exist. But some existences as they are experienced do ask thought to direct them in their course so that they may be ordered and fair and be such as to commend themselves to admiration, approval and appreciation. Knowledge affords the sole means by which this redirection can be effected. As the latter is brought about, parts of the experienced world have more luminous and organized meaning and their significance is rendered more secure against the gnawing tooth of time. The problem of knowledge is the problem of discovery of methods for carrying on this enterprise of redirection. It is a problem never ended, always in process; one problematic situa- tion is resolved and another takes its place. The constant gain is not in approximation to universal solution but in betterment of methods and enrichment of objects experienced. Man as a natural creature acts as masses and molecules act; he lives as animals live, eating, fighting, fearing, repro- 296 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION ducing. As he lives, some of his actions yield understanding and things take on meaning, for they become signs of one another; means of expectation and of recall, preparations for what is to come and celebrations of what has gone. Activities take on ideal quality. Attraction and repulsion become love of the admirable and hate of the harsh and ugly, and they seek to find and make a world in which they may be securely at home. Hopes and fears, desires and aversions, are as truly responses to things as are knowing and thinking. Our affec- tions, when they are enlightened by understanding, are organs by which we enter into the meaning of the natural world as genuinely as by knowing, and with greater fullness and inti- macy. This deeper and richer intercourse with things can be effected only by thought and its resultant knowledge; the arts in which the potential meanings of nature are realized demand an intermediate and transitional phase of detachment and abstraction. The colder and less intimate transactions of know- ing involve temporary disregard of the qualities and values to which our affections and enjoyments are attached. But knowledge is an indispensable medium of our hopes and fears, of loves and hates, if desires and preferences are to be steady, ordered, charged with meaning, secure. The glorification of knowledge as the exclusive avenue of access to what is real is not gong to give way soon nor all at once. But it can hardly endure indefinitely. The more wide- spread become the habits of intelligent thought, the fewer enemies they meet from those vested interests and social insti- tutions whose power depends upon immunity from inspection by intelligence, in short, the more matter of course they be- come, the less need will there seem to be for giving knowledge _ an exclusive and monopolistic position. It will be prized for its fruits rather than for the properties assigned to it when it was a new and precarious enterprise. The common fact that we prize 297 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY in proportion to rarity has a good deal to do with the exclu- sive esteem in which knowledge has been held, There is so much unintelligent appetite and impulse, so much routine action, so much that is dictated by the arbitrary power of other persons, so much, ‘in short, that is not informed and enlight- ened by knowledge, that it is not surprising that action and knowledge should have been isolated in thought from one another, and knowledge treated as if it alone had dealings with real existence. I do not know when knowledge will become naturalized in the life of society. But when it is fully acclimatized, its instrumental, as distinct from its monopolistic, role in approach to things of nature and society will be taken for granted without need for such arguments as I have been engaging in. Meantime, the development of the experimental method stands as a prophecy of the possibility of the accom- plishment of this Copernican Revolution. Whenever anyone speaks about the relation of knowledge (especially if the word science be used) to our moral, artistic and religious interests, there are two dangers to which he is exposed. There exist on one hand efforts to use scientific knowledge to substantiate moral and religious beliefs, either with respect to some specific form in which they are current or in some vague way that is felt to be edifying and com- forting. On the other hand, philosophers derogate the im- portance and necessity of knowledge in order to make room for an undisputed sway of some set of moral and religious tenets. It may be that preconceptions will lead some to inter- pret what has been said in one or other of these senses. If so, it is well to state that not a word has been said in depreciation of science; what has been criticized is a philosophy and habit of mind on the ground of which science is prized for false reasons. Nor does this negative statement cover the whole ground. Knowledge is instrumental. But the purport of our 298 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION whole discussion has been in praise of tools, instrumentalities, means, putting them on a level equal in value to ends and consequences, since wit out them the latter are merely acci- dental, sporadic and unstable. To call known objects, in their capacity of being objects of knowledge, means is to appreciate them, not to depreciate them. Affections, desires, purposes, choices are going to endure as long as man is man; therefore as long as man is man, there are going to be ideas, judgments, beliefs about values. Nothing could be sillier than to attempt to justify their existence at large; they are going to exist anyway. What is inevitable needs no proof for its existence. But these expressions of our nature need direction, and direction is possible only through knowl- edge. When they are informed by knowledge, they themselves constitute, in their directed activity, intelligence in operation. Thus as far as concerns particular value-beliefs, particular moral and religious ideas and creeds, the import of what has been said is that they need to be tested and revised by the best knowledge at command. The moral of the discussion is any- thing but a reservation for them of a position in which they are exempt from the impact, however disintegrative it may be, of new knowledge. The relation between objects as known and objects with respect to value is that between the actual and the possible. “The actual” consists of given conditions; “the possible” de- notes ends or consequences not now existing but which the actual may through its use bring into existence. The possible in respect to any given actual situation 1s thus an ideal for that situation; from the standpoint of operational definition—of thinking in terms of action—the ideal and the possible are equivalent ideas. Idea and ideal have more in common than certain letters of the alphabet. Everywhere an idea, in its intel- lectual content, is a projection of what something existing may 299 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY come to be. One may report a quality already sensed in a proposition, as when standing before the fire I remark upon how hot it is. When seeing something at a distance, I judge without sensible contact that it must be hot; “hot” expresses a consequence which I infer would be experienced if I were to approach close enough; it designates a possibility of what is actually there in experience. The instance is a trivial one, but it sets forth what happens in every case where any predicate, whether quality or relation, expresses an idea rather than a sensibly perceived characteristic. The difference is not between one mental state called a sensation and another called an image. It is between what is experienced as being already there and what marks a possibility of being experienced. If we agree to leave out the eulogistic savor of “ideal”? and define it in con- trast with the actual, the possibility denoted by an idea is the ideal phase of the existent. The problem of the connection or lack of connection of the actual and the ideal has always been the central problem of philosophy in its metaphysical aspect, just as the relation between existence and idea has been the central theme of philosophy on the side of the theory of knowledge. Both issues come together in the problem of the relation of the actual and the possible. Both problems are derived from the necessities of action if that is to be intelligently regulated. Assertion of an idea or of an ideal, if it is genuine, is a claim that it is pos- sible to modify what exists so that it will take on a form pos- sessed of specifiable traits. This statement as it relates to an idea, to the cognitive aspect, takes us back to what has been said about ideas as designations of operations and their con- sequences. Its bearing upon the “ideal” concerns us at this point. In this basic problem of the relation of the actual and ideal, classic philosophies have always attempted to prove that 300 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION the ideal is already and eternally a property of the real. The quest for absolute cognitive certainty has come to a head in the quest for an ideal which is one with the ultimately real. Men have not been able to trust either the world or them- selves to realize the values and qualities which are the possi- bilities of nature. The sense of incompetency and the sloth born of desire for irresponsibility have combined to create an overwhelming longing for the ideal and rational as an ante- cedent possession of actuality, and consequently something upon which we can fall back for emotional support in times of trouble. The assumption of the antecedent inherent identity of actual and ideal has generated problems which have not been solved. It is the source of the problem of evil; of evil not merely in the moral sense, but in that of the existence of de- fect and aberration, of uncertainty and error, of all deviation from the perfect. If the universe is in itself ideal, why is there so much in our experience of it which is so thoroughly unideal? Attempts to answer this question have always been compelled to introduce lapse from perfect Being:—some kind of fall to which is due the distinction between noumena and phenomena, things as they really are and as they seem to be. There are many versions of this doctrine. The simplest, though not the one which has most commended itself to most phi- losophers, is the idea of the “fall of man,” a fall which, in the words of Cardinal Newman, has implicated all creation in an aboriginal catastrophe. I am not concerned to discuss them and their respective weaknesses and strengths. It is enough to note that the philosophies which go by the name of Idealism are attempts to prove by one method or another, cosmological, ontological or epistemological, that the Real and the Ideal are one, while at the same time they introduce qualifying addi- tions to explain why after all they are not one. 301 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY There are three ways of idealizing the world. There is idealization through purely intellectual and logical processes, in which reasoning alone attempts to prove that the world has characters that satisfy our highest aspirations. There are, again, moments of intense emotional appreciation when, through a happy conjunction of the state of the self and of the surround- ing world, the beauty and harmony of existence is disclosed in experiences which are the immediate consummation of all for which we long. Then there is an idealization through actions that are directed by thought, such as are manifested in the works of fine art and in all human relations perfected by loving care. The first path has been taken by many philoso- phies. The second while it lasts is the most engaging. It sets the measure of our ideas of possibilities that are to be realized by intelligent endeavor. But its objects depend upon fortune and are insecure. The third method represents the way of deliberate quest for security of the values that are enjoyed by grace in our happy moments. That in fortunate moments objects of complete and ap- proved enjoyment are had is evidence that nature is capable of giving birth to objects that stay with us as ideal. Nature thus supplies potential material for embodiment of ideals. Nature, if I may use the-locutiony is idealizable. It lends itself to operations by which it is pérfected. The process is not a passive one. Rather nature gives, not always freely but in response to search, means and material by which the values we judge to have supreme quality may be embodied in existence. It depends upon the choice of man whether he employs what nature provides and for what ends he uses it. Idealism of this type is not content with dialectical proofs that the perfect is already and immutably in Being, either as a property of some higher power or as an essence. The emo- tional satisfactions and encouragements thus supplied are not 302 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION an adequate substitute for an ideal which is projected in order to be a guide of our doings. While the happy moment brings us objects to admire, approve and revere, the security and extent in which the beautiful, the true and the revered qualify the world, depend upon the way in which our own affections and desires for that kind or world engage activities. Things loved, admired and revered, things that spiritualistic philosophies have seized upon as the defining characters of ultimate Being, are genuine elements of nature. But without the aid and sup- port of deliberate action based on understanding of conditions, they are transitory and unstable, as well as narrow and confined in the number of those who enjoy them. Religious faiths have come under the influence of philoso- phies that have tried to demonstrate the fixed union of the actual and ideal in ultimate Being. Their interest in persuad- ing to a life of loyalty to what is esteemed good, has been bound up with a certain creed regarding historical origins. Religion has also been involved in the metaphysics of sub- stance, and has thrown in its lot with acceptance of certain cosmogonies. It has found itself fighting a battle and a losing one with science, as if religion were a rival theory about the structure of the natural world. It has committed itself to asser- tions about astronomical, geological, biological subject-matter; about questions of anthropology, literary criticism, and history. With the advances of sciences in these fields it has in conse- quence found itself involved in a series of conflicts, compro- mises, adjustments and retreats, The religious attitude as a sense of the possibilities of existence and as devotion to the cause of these possibilities, as distinct from acceptance of what is given at the time, gradu- ally extricates itself from these unnecessary intellectual com- mitments. But religious devotees rarely stop to notice that what lies at the basis of recurrent conflicts with scientific find- 393 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY / ings is not this or that special dogma so much as it is alliance | with philosophical schemes which hold that the reality and power of whatever is excellent and worthy of supreme devo- tion, depends upon proof of its antecedent existence, so that the ideal of perfection loses its claim over us unless it can be dem- onstrated to exist in the sense in which the sun and stars exist. Were it not because of this underlying assumption, there could be no conflict between science and religion. The currency of attempts to reconcile scientific conclusions with special doc- trines of religion may unfortunately suggest, when such a statement is made, the idea of some infallible recipe for con- ciliation. But nothing is further from its meaning. It signifies that a religious attitude would surrender once for all commit- ment to beliefs about matters of fact, whether physical, social or metaphysical. It would leave such matters to inquirers in other fields. Nor would it substitute in their place fixed beliefs about values, save the one value of the worth of discovering the possibilities of the actual and striving to realize them. Whatever is discovered about actual existence would modify the content of human beliefs about ends, purposes and goods. But it would and could not touch the fact that we are capable of directing our affection and loyalty to the possibilities resident in the actualities discoveredZAn idealism of action that is de- voted to creation of a future, instead of to staking itself upon propositions about the past, is invincible, /The claims of the beautiful to be admired and cherished do not depend upon ability to demonstrate statements about the past history of art. The demand of righteousness for reverence does not depend upon ability to prove the existence of an antecedent Being who is righteous. It is not possible to set forth with any accuracy or complete- ness just what form religion would take if it were wedded to an idealism of this sort, or just what would happen if it broke 304 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION away from that quest for certitude in the face of peril and human weakness which has determined its historic and insti- tutional career. But some features of the spirit of the change which would follow may be indicated. Not the least impor- tant change would be a shift from the defensive and apolo- getic position which is practically compulsory as long as religious faith is bound up with defense of doctrines regarding history and physical nature; for this entanglement subjects it to constant danger of conflict with science. The energy which is thus diverted into defense of positions that have in time to be surrendered would be released for positive activity in behalf of the security of the underlying possibilities of actual life. More important still would be liberation from attach- ment to dogmas framed in conditions very unlike those in which we live, and the substitution of a disposition to turn to constructive account the results of knowledge. It is not possible to estimate the amelioration that would result if the stimulus and support given to practical action by science were no longer limited to industry and commerce and merely “secular” affairs. As long as the practical import of the advance of science is confined to these activities, the dualism between the values which religion professes and the urgent concerns of daily livelihood will persist. The gulf between them will continually grow wider, and the widening will not, judging from past history, be at the expense of the territory occupied by mundane and secular affairs. On the con- trary, ideal interests will be compelled to retreat more and more to a confined ground. The philosophy which holds that the realm of essence sub- sists as an independent realm of Being also emphasizes that this is a realm of possibilities; it offers this realm as the true object of religious devotion. But, by definition, such pos- sibilities are abstract and remote. They have no concern nor 305 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY traffic with natural and social objects that are concretely expe- rienced. It is not possible to avoid the impression that the idea of such a realm is simply th Hiypostatizing in a wholesale way of the fact that actual Crete ecu possibilities. But in any case devotion to such remote and unattached possibili- ties simply perpetuates the other-worldliness of religious tra- dition, although its other-world is not one supposed to exist. Thought of it is a refuge, not a resource. It becomes effective in relation to the conduct of life only when separation of essence from existence is cancelled; when essences are taken to be possibilities to be embodied through action in concrete objects of secure experience. Nothing is gained by reaching the latter through a circuitous course. Religious faith which attaches itself to the possibilities of nature and associated living would, with its devotion to the ideal, manifest piety toward the actual. It would not be queru- lous dil earioer eoTenerdatecte and hardships of the latter. Respect and esteem would be given to that which is the means of realization of possibilities, and to that in which the ideal is embodied if it ever finds embodiment. Aspiration and endeavor are not ends in themselves; value is not in them in isolation but in them as means to that reorganization of the existent in which approved meanings are attained. Nature and society in- clude within themselves projection of ideal possibilities and contain the operations by which they are actualized, Nature may not be worshiped as divine even in the sense of the intel- lectual love of Spinoza. But nature, including humanity, with all its defects and imperfections, may evoke heartfelt piety as the source of ideals, of possibilities, of aspiration in their behalf, and as the eventual abode of all attained goods and excellencies. I have no intention of entering into the field of the psychol- ogy of religion, that is to say, the personal attitudes involved 306 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION in religious experience. But I suppose that no one can deny that the sense of dependence, insisted upon, for example, by Schleiermacher, comes close to the heart of the matter. This 1 Sella ra sense has taken many different forms in connection with dif- ferent states of culture. It has shown itself in abject fears, in practice of extreme cruelties designed to propitiate the powers upon which we depend, and in militantly fanatical intolerance on the part of those who felt that they had special access to the ultimate source of power and a peculiar authorization to act in its behalf. It has shown itself in noble humilities and unquenchable ardors. History shows that there is no channel in which the sense of dependence is predestined to express itself. But of the religious attitude which is allied to acceptance of the ideally good as the to-be-realized possibilities of exist- ence, one statement may be made with confidence. At the best, all our endeavors look to the future and never attain certainty. The lesson of probability holds for all forms of activity as truly as for the experimental operations of science, and even more poignantly and tragically. The control and regulation of which so much has been said never signifies certainty of out- come, although the greater meed of security it may afford will » not be known until we try the experimental policy in all walks of life. The unknown surrounds us in other forms of practical activity even more than in knowing, for they reach further into the future, in more significant and less controllable ways. A sense of dependence is quickened by that Copernican revo- lution which looks to security amid change instead of to cer- tainty in attachment to the fixed. It would, moreover, alter its dominant quality. One of the deepest of moral traditions is that which identifies the source of moral evil, as distinct from retrievable error, with pride, and which identifies pride with isolation. ‘This attitude of pride assumes many forms. It has found among those who 307 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY profess the most complete dependence, often preéminently among them. The pride of the zealously devout is the most dangerous form of pride. There is a divisive pride of the learned, as well as of family wealth and power. The pride of those who feel themselves learned in the express and explicit will of God is the most exclusive. Those who have this pride, one that generates an exclusive institutionalism and then feeds and sustains itself through its connection with an institution claiming spiritual monopoly, feel themselves to be special organs of the divine, and in its name claim authority over others. The historic isolation of the church from other social in- stitutions is the result of this pride. The isolation, like all denials of interaction and interdependence, confines to special channels the power of those who profess special connection with the ideal and spiritual. In condemning other modes of human association to an inferior position and réle, it breeds irresponsibility in the latter. This result is perhaps the most serious of the many products of that dualism between nature and spirit in which isolation of the actual and the possible eventuates. The sense of dependence that is bred by recogni- tion that the intent and effort of man are never final but are subject to the uncertainties of an indeterminate future, would render dependence universal and shared by all. It would terminate the most corroding form of spiritual pride and isolation, that which divides man from man at the foundation of life’s activities. A sense of common participation in the in- evitable uncertainties of existence would be coeval with a sense of common effort and shared destiny. Men will_never love their enemies until they cease to have enmities. (The antago- nism between the actual and the ideal, the spiritual and the natural, is the source of the deepest and most injurious of all enmities. 3 308 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION What has been said might seem to ignore the strength of those traditions in which are enshrined the emotions and im- aginations of so many human beings, as well as the force of the established institutions by which these traditions are car- ried. I am, however, engaged only in pointing out the possi- bility of a change. This task does not require us to ignore the practical difficulties in the way of realizing it. There is one aspect of these difficulties which is pertinent at this point. It is appropriate to inquire as to the bearing of them upon the future office of philosophy. A philosophy committed to rational demonstration of the fixed and antecedent certainty of the ideal, with a sharp demarcation of knowled e and higher activity me all forms of practic ) erpetuates the obstacles i in the way of realization of the possibili en pointed out. It is easy both to minimize the practical effect of philosophic theories and to exaggerate it. Directly, it is not very great. But as an intel- lectual formulation and justification of habits and attitudes already obtaining among men its influence is immense. The vis inertiae of habit is tremendous, and when it is reinforced by a philosophy which also is embodied in institutions, it is so great as to be a factor in sustaining the present confusion and conflict of authorities and allegiances. A final word about philosophy is then in place. Like reli- gion it has come into conflict with the natural sciences, or at least its path has diverged increasingly from theirs since the seventeenth century. The chief cause of the split is that philos- _ ophy has assumed for its function a knowledge of reality. This fact makes it a rival instead of a complement to the sciences. It has forced philosophy into claiming a kind of knowledge which is more ultimate than theirs. In consequence it has, at least in its more systematic forms, felt obliged to revise the conclusions of science to prove that they do not mean what they say; or 309 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY that, in any case they apply to a world of appearances instead of to the superior reality to which philosophy directs itself. Idealistic philosophies have attempted to prove from an ex- amination of the conditions of knowledge that mind is the only reality. What does it matter, they have said in effect, if phy- sical knowledge recognizes only matter, since matter itself is mental? Idealisms in proving that the ideal is once for all the real has absolved itself from the office, more useful if hum- bler, of attempting that interpretation of the actual by means of which values could be made more extensive and more secure. General ideas, hypotheses, are necessary in science itself. They serve an indispensable purpose. They open new points of view; they liberate us from the bondage of habit which is always closing in on us, restricting our vision both of what is and of what the actual may become. They direct operations that reveal new truths and new possibilities. They enable us to escape from the pressure of immediate circumstance and provincial boundaries. Knowledge falters when imagination clips its wings or fears to use them. Every great advance in science has issued from a new audacity of imagination, What are now working conceptions, employed as a matter of course because they have withstood the tests of experiment and have emerged triumphant, were once speculative hypotheses, There is no limit set to the scope and depth of hypotheses. There are those of short and technical range and there are those as wide as experience. Philosophy has always claimed universality for itself. It will make its claim good when it con- nects this universality with the formation of directive hypoth- eses instead of with a sweeping pretension to knowledge of universal Being. That hypotheses are fruitful when they are suggested by actual need, are bulwarked by knowledge already attained, and are tested by the consequences of the operations 310 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION they evoke goes without saying. Otherwise imagination is dis- sipated into fantasies and rises vaporously into the clouds. The need for large and generous ideas in the direction of life was never more urgent than in the confusion of tongues, beliefs and purposes that characterizes present life. Knowledge of actual structure and processes of existence has reached a point where a philosophy which has the will to use knowledge has guidance and support. A philosophy which abandoned its guardianship of fixed realities, values and ideals, would find a new career for itself. The meaning of science in terms of science, in terms of knowledge of the actual, may well be left to science itself. Its meaning in terms of the great human uses to which it may be put, its meaning in the service of possibilities of secure value, offers a field for exploration which cries out from very emptiness. To abandon the search for absolute and immutable reality and value may seem like a sacrifice. But this renunciation is the condition of entering upon a vocation of greater vitality. The search for values to be secured and shared by all, because buttressed in the founda- tions of social life, is a quest in which philosophy would have no rivals but coadjutors in men of good will. Philosophy under such conditions finds itself in no oppo- sition to science. It is a liaison officer between the conclusions of science and the modes of social and personal action through which attainable possibilities are projected and striven for. No more than a religion devoted to inspiration and cultivation of the sense of ideal possibilities in the actual would it find itself checked by any possible discovery of science. Each new dis- covery would afford a new opportunity. Such a philosophy would have a wide field of criticism before it. But its critical mind would be directed against the domination exercised by prejudice, narrow interest, routine custom and the authority which issues from institutions apart from the human ends they 311 THE QUEST FOR CERTAINTY serve. This negative office would be but the obverse of the creative work of the imagination in pointing to the new possi- bilities which knowledge of the actual discloses and in project- ing methods for their realization in the homely everyday experience of mankind. Philosophy has often entertained the ideal of a complete integration of knowledge. But knowledge by its nature is analytic and discriminating. It attains large syntheses, sweep- ing generalizations. But these open up new problems for con- sideration, new fields for inquiry; they are transitions to more detailed and varied knowledge. Diversification of discoveries and the opening up of new points of view and new methods are inherent in the progress of knowledge. This fact defeats the idea of any complete synthesis of knowledge upon an intel- lectual basis. The sheer increase of specialized knowledge will never work the miracle of producing an intellectual whole. Nevertheless, the need for integration of specialized results of science remains, and philosophy should contribute to the satis- faction of the need. The need, however, is practical and human rather than intrinsic to science itself; the latter is content as long as it can move to new problems and discoveries. The need for direction of action in large social fields is the source of a genuine demand for unification of scientific conclusions. They are organized when their bearing on the conduct of life is dis- closed. It is at this point that the extraordinary and multifa- rious results of scientific inquiry are unorganized, scattered, chaotic. The astronomer, biologist, chemist, may attain sys- tematic wholes, at least for a time, within his own field. But when we come to the bearing of special conclusions upon the conduct of social life, we are, outside of technical fields, at a loss. The force of tradition and dogmatic authority is due, more than to anything else, to precisely this defect. Man has 12 THE COPERNICAN REVOLUTION never had such a varied body of knowledge in his possession before, and probably never before has he been so uncertain and so perplexed as to what his knowledge means, what it points to in action and in consequences. Were there any consensus as to the significance of what is known upon beliefs about things of ideal and general value, our life would be marked by integrity instead of by distrac- tion and by conflict of competing aims and standards. Needs of practical action in large and liberal social fields would give unification to our special knowledge; and the latter would give solidity and confidence to the judgment of values that control conduct. Attainment of this consensus would mean that modern life had reached maturity in discovering the meaning of its own intellectual movement. It would find within its own inter- ests and activities the authoritative guidance for its own affairs which it now vainly seeks in oscillation between outworn tradi- tions and reliance upon casual impulse. The situation defines the vital office of present philosophy. It has to search out and disclose the obstructions; to criticize the habits of mind which stand in the way; to focus reflection upon needs congruous to present life; to interpret the conclu- sions of science with respect to their consequences for our beliefs about purposes and values in all phases of life. The development of a system of thought capable of giving this service is a difficult undertaking; it can proceed only slowly and through codperative effort. In these pages I have tried to indicate in outline the nature of the task to be accomplished and to suggest some of the resources at hand for its realization. THE END 313 4 INDEX Absolute and Absolutism, 6, 3, 109, 143, 1617., 264. Abstraction, 1I117., 216-8, 238, 246. Action and Knowledge, 6, 7, 8, 30, 33, 35, 72, 86, 88, 150, 167, 194, 206, 25%, 214, 223, 231, 245, 290; see Knowl- edge, Operations, Theory. Activity, pure, 17-19, 93. Actual, 62, 299-301. Agnosticism, 193. Analysis, 92, 123, 174. 153-4, 159, 165, Antecedents and Consequences, 22, 44, 68, 72, 86, 103, 126, 129, 137, 146, 149, 165, 171, 185, 192, 196, Sai, 230, 258, 266, 272. Appearances, 19, 23, 30, 34, 104, 108, 110, Application of science, 79-80, 86. Appreciation, 221, 262, 268, 299. A priori, see Reason. Aristotle, 14-16, 40, 75, 91, 275, 282. Arts, 3-6, 8, 30, 45, 47, 85, 100, 132, 138, 149, 207, 233, 254, 269, 2975 liberal and mechanical, 74; social, 40; and science, 75. Authority, 95; conflict in, Ch. III; seat of, Ch. VIII, 255, 261, 269, 285; see Control, Standards. Axioms, 141, 183. 1827, 243, Barry, F., 98, 153, 160-17. Beliefs, 6, 17, 18, 26, 82, 56. Bergson, H., 91. Berkeley, Bishop, 121, 142. Body, 82; and Mind, 230. Bridgman, P. W., 111, 204. Causality, 159. Certainty, 5, 33, 51, 60, 128, 204, 2543 see Control, Security. Change, 16, 83, 84, 100-1, ¥2%,'205, 211,.236-7, 2513, Immutables. Church, the, 75-6, 255, 276, 282, 293, 308. pone, M. R., 11127, 105, 129, 292-3; see Concrete, meaning of, 153-4. Communication, 150. Compossibility, 160. Conception of conceptions, 1477.; em- pirical, 166; and laws, 206-7; see Ideas, Operations, Thought. Consciousness, 86, 227-8. Consequences, see Antecedents, Ends. Contingency, 19, 201-4, 231, 244, 249- 54, 307; see Luck, Probability. Continuity, 224, 230-1, 234, 240; see Operations, Relations. Control, 98, 100, 104, 105, 128, 172, 213, 241, 247, 259, 296; by arts, 3, 30; by rites, 3, 10, 223, 254; by in- telligence, Ch. IV; two kinds, 84, 132; ground of, 133. Crisis, 44, 52, 224. Crisis in Culture, 40, 43, 47, 70, 77; 251. Data, 99, 122, 134, 137, 172-3, 178. Deduction, see Implication. Definition, 50, 99, £26, 141; 352, 281. Demonstration, 108, 112; see Proof Test. Dependence, 307. Descartes, 42, 57, 61, 92, I41, 157. Discovery, 183-5. Discreteness, 114, 125, 142, 176, 181, 204, 232-4, 243. Dualism, 13, 32, 51, 58, 76, 244, ao 308. Economics, 80, 211-2, 280-3. Eddington, A. S., 111, 129-30, 240. Education, 252. Einstein, A., 127, 144-6. Emotion, 225-6. Empiricism, 77, 107, 144. Ends, 17, 20, 41, 49-50, 56-7, 94, 100, 102, 149, 152, 155, 236, 243; and means, 37, 46. Enjoyment, see Values. Epistemology, 85, 121, 24¥. Escape, from Peril, Ch. I; see Con- trol. 315 INDEX Essences, 34, 65, 90, 120, 140, 149-50, 164, 178, 275-6, 305-63 properties of 161-67. Esthetic, 90, 94, 100, 153, 156, 237. Euclid, 16, 89, 140, 157, 182. Events, 83, 104, 126, 129, 146, 241. Evil, 35, 64, 101, 301, 308. Evolution, 64. 185, Experience, and Experienced Ob- jects, 76, 98, 106-7, 137, 167-8, 194- 99, 216-9, 241-3, 276, 294; as em- pirical and experimental, 81-4. Experimental Method, 5, 24, 36, 81, 87-107 and Ch. V, 168, 171, 186, 201, 214, 242, 263, 271, 273, 288-9. Explanation, 181, 229. Faith, 58. Familiarity, 185-6, 209-10. Fichte, 62. First Philosophy, 14-15. Freedom, 250. Galileo, 93-7, 288. Generalization, 125, 134. Good, 15, 34, 53-5, Ch. D.¢ Values. Greek Science, see Aristotle, tonian Philosophy. see Ends, New- Habit, inertia of intellectual, 84, 136, 175, 208, 238. Hartshorne, C., 2497. Hegel, 61-63. Heine, 59. Heisenberg, 201-4, 248. Heterogeneity and Homogeneity, 94, 97, 105, 122, 133, 241. History, 246. Holy, the, 11-12. Hume, D., 142, 156. Hypostitazation, 154, 165, 217, 239, 247, 264, 306; see Substance. Hypothesis, 78, 107, 165-7, 173, 175, 179, 184, 186, 277, 288. Idealism, 22, 34, 61-3, 108, 130, 138, 142, 166-7, 178, 188, 233, 257, 277; 294, 302, 310. Ideals, 62, 108-9, 163, 270, 279, 299-303. Idealization, three modes of 302-3. Ideas, 59, 86, 166-7, 173, 177, 299-3003 and operations, Ch. V; free, and mathematics, Ch. VI; see Reflective Thought. Identification, 188-9r. 2975 Immediacy, 108, 109, 127, 183, 186-7, 221; 225, (202, Immutables, Ch. II; 18, 20, 22, 51, 90, 143, 161, 163," 209; 2t2,) 250, 318s see Change. Incompatibility, 160. Indemonstrables, see Axioms, Imme- diacy. Indeterminancy, gency. Individual, 6, 135, 146, 162, 170, 184, 203, 205-8, 218, 225, 236-7, 240, 247. Industry and Industrialism, 24, 79-80, 217, 282, 304. Inference, see Reflective Thinking. Instrumental and _ Instrumentalism, 377., 106, 135, 147, 205, 207, 218, 236-8, 250, 295, 298. Intellectualism, 21, 56, 219; see Ubi- quity, Vision. Intelligence and Nature, Ch. VIII. Intelligibility, of nature, 55, 208, 215. Interaction, 23, 37, 78, 106-7, 150, hy 177, 207, 214, 234-6, 239, 244, 290-1 see Operations, Relations. Intuition, 141, 183, 186. Irrationality, of nature, 209-10. 201-4; see Contin- James, Wm., 209, 238, 284-5. Judgment, 137; defined, 213; 260, 265. Kant and Kantianism, 42, 58-62, 287- 290. Knowledge and Action, Ch. I, 36, 48, $2, 106, 137, 171-5, 204-6; theory of, 41, 47, 84, 181, 229; types of, 196-8, 221-2; unification of, 312. Laissez-faire, 212. Laplace, 201. Laws, 28, 56-7, 201, 205-7, 247. Life, 224. Light, 127, 185, 202-4. Locke, J., 26, 120, 184. Logic, 15-16, 63, 65-6, 160, 187, 197. Logical Forms, 66, 88-9, 147, 197; see Essences. Logos, 90, 92. Luck, 7, 11-12, 102, 223. 140, 154, 156, Machine, nature of, 162, 247. Magic, 40. Mass, 96, 127, 142. Materialism, 77, 108, 283. Mathematics, 16, 28, 57, 65, 88, 92, 97, 108, 127, 133, 203, 240, 2543 in 316 INDEX physics, 141-6; Symbols. Matter, 96, 270. Maxwell, C., 248-49. Mead, G. H., 99. Means, 45, 155, 162, 234, 237, 2703 see Antecedents, Consequences, Ends. Measurement, 87, 125, 152. Mechanism, 209, 245. Method, 2, 27, 36, 200, 215, 217, 228, 251; supremacy of, Ch. IX; see Experimental Method. Metric Objects, 129-30, 210, 240-2. Michelson-Morley Experiment, 127, pure, 151-56; see 145. Mill, J. S., 112, 156, 1827. Morals, 6, 31, 39, 60, 10%, 244, 251, 266, 272-30; see Values. Motion, 96, 126, 133. Movement, qualitative, 93. Nature, 53, 55, 210, Ch: VIII, 243, 307; as God, 56. Newman, Cardinal, 52, 301. Newtonian Philosophy, 59, 97-8, Ir10, 114-6, 142-4, 186, 191, 201-2, 204-5, 252,28: Noble, E., 2477. Non-being, 18, 19, 353 see Changes. Novelty, 183-5. Number, 129, 152, 155. Objects, Perceived; see Experience, Perception, Qualities. Objects, Physical, 99, 104. Observation, 82, 84, 143, 146, 172, 202, 206-7. Operations, 84, Ch. V, Passim, 137, 173-74, 200, 217, 258 origin of, 123. Opinion, 20, 22, 83, 95. Participation, 204, 212, 245, 291, 308. Pathology, of beliefs, 227-8. Peirce, C. S., 377., 145. Perception, 82, 88-90, 121, 142, 176-9, 230, 240, 267-8; see Observation, Sense. Peril, Ch. I passim, 3-5, 6, 33, 223. Peripatetic Philosophy, see Aristotle. Phenomena, 59, 148, 242, 301; nature of, 104. Phenomenalism, 193. Philosophy, 4, 13, 14, 18, 24, 30, 66- 70; modern problem of, Ch. II, es- pecially, 41, 44, 49, 67, 72, 103, 195, 284; true problem of, 46, 67, 168-9, 252-3, 255-6, 309-313. Physical, 20, 64, 78, 79, 186, 189, 238- 41; science, Chs. V, VI, passim; 217-221. Plato, 140, 157, 181, 269, 274. Possibility, 155-60, 163-4, 226, 299-303, 311; see Symbols. Practice, depreciated, 4-5, 13, 22, 29, 37; meaning of, 31-32. Pragmatism, 377. Primitive Life, 9-10, 33, 38, 101, 254, 259) 284. Probability, 6, 26, 199, 202, 267, 290, 307. Problem, importance of, 99-103, 122-3, 134, 176, 179, 206, 218, 223-236, 243, 247. Proof, 181, 183. Purpose, 102, 245-6. Qualities and Qualitative Objects, Chs. II and III, passim; 89, 173, 231, 233, 239; in modern science, 53, 159; primary and secondary, 120-1; tertiary, 239; static, 125; see Data, Esthetic. Quantity, 92. Rationalism, 27, 83, 122, 144, 154, 165, 171, 180, 210, 256-7, 264. Realism, 65, 176, 178, 184, 240, 257, 274, 295, 305-6; see Essences. Reason, 17, 50, 58, 76, 88, 90, 109, 170, 212, 287-8, 292. Recognition, 185. Reflective Thinking, 109, 141, 178, 181-4, 218-9, 221, 262. Relations, 84, 92, 102, 104, 120, 125, 130, 133, 145-6, 154, 159, 162, 168, Uy 176, 184, 207, 219, 244, 250, 266. Relativity, theory of, 127, 145. Religion, 10-14, 30, 51-2, 70, 160, 221, 254, 292, 298, 303-9. Revolution, Copernican, Ch. XI. Revolution, Scientific, 28, 50, 85, 87- 8, 92, 255, 258. Santayana, G., 239. Satisfaction, 258-60. Science, 20, 22, 24, 26, 413 and art, 75; physical, 78; and the real, 136, 207, 217-21, 246, 250. Schleiermacher, 307. Security, Ch. I passim, 23, 29, 33, 35) 37, 132, 187, 2043. see | Control, Values. Sensational Empiricism, 22, 109, 122, 156, 166, 171, 177. Cy INDEX Sense, 82-3, 88-90, 112, 143, 156, 170, 230, 258; see Data, Perception. Sense Data, 65, 174-7, 195. Signs, 99, 129, 132, 175, 213, 236, 239, 241. Simultaneity, 145. Skepticism, 193-4, 219, 228. Social Knowledge and Objects, 136, 198, 216-8, 270-1. Solutions, see Problems, Thought. Space, 126, 133, 142, 159. Spectator Theory of Knowledge, see Vision. Spencer, H., 64. Spinoza, B., 53-57, 141, 209, 288, 307. Standards, 54, 163, 167, 170, 200, 239, 255, 273, 277; see Test, Validity. Subjective and Subjectivism, 31, 47, 60, 150, 214, 232-3, 239, 241-2, 246, 274-5, 280, 287. Structure, 148, 163. Substance, 119-20, 128, 186, 206, 303. Supernatural, 11, 230. Symbols, 150-54, 217. Security, Taste, 262. Technology, I24, 75, |30,; 133, 268. Tertiary, see Qualities. Test, 103, 109, 122, 124, 128, 165-7, 237, 278. Theology, 14, 28, 52, 75. Theory, placed above action, 5-6, 22, 29; in relation to practice, 67- 70, 192-3, 281. 135; This and The, 237-8, 241. Thought, 7, 108; as directed activity, 123, 134, 162, 166, 223, 267; de- fined, 224, 227. Time and Temporal, 95, ror, 126, 133, 142, 145, 234, 272, 289. Tools, 8, 84, 89, 124, 135, 136, 148, 152, 186, 187, 233, 278; see Instru- mental. Tradition, Classic, 8, 17, 21, 26-8, 34, 43, 76, 133, 199-200, 214, 231, 287-8, 293. Transcendentalism, 34, 60, 78, 164-5, 256-7, 285 Truth, see Antecedents, Consequences, Test, Validity. Ubiquity of Knowledge, 106, 131, 179, 219, 241, 291-5, 297-8. Uncertainty, 38-9, 65, 223-36, 244. Uniformity, 162-3, 208. Universals, 20, 141, 154, 161, 163. Use and Utility, 40, 105. Utilitarianism, 31, 257. Validity, 43, 60, 109, 129, 141, 146, 197, 263. Values, 21, 24, 30, 32, 35, 39, 42-3, 65-7, 95, 98, 194, 196, 233, Ch. X. Verification, see Test, Validity. Vision, as knowledge, 23, 196, 21%, 245. Will, 52, 58, 213, 226, 233. Work, as a curse, 4; as material, 5. 318 a ae es Hoy ape iec oa? athe OMT Sos ae wah ; or A Ain) 4 WA wy ; ‘ 7 1 hy elas \ ve ; i) J | Ly rah, q My a : ey AD ee honed mi bh ia tM 4 me ¢.. : , } : ee Ma RT WPA Th: ay Sel n at A WT on Ue ee 4, Ae u i: ; ; ' ¢ \ av ei fa 4, pie y + Te Aj ij wo ‘ nes } ' } a is NNT ( Lia 7 iW i, “Mi sta hE Ah b yeh 5 Ver eta 4 vane! s " j f ; We pe at FY iy Wh 5 a) ry i : i ’ A} y hat nity n oe Raia bi, Sh i rh ) Ny ; } Thy: ! hi Ae tal. ee ek es ee ve } I SR BROOM { , BAe 1 As Lvaw' a) Teer 4 i iS rh J \ pe f 7 b é ) \ , ‘ ‘ + Sint): =, git 7 | } * F '] ‘ae | : 4 ny | ha +P rat mh i! ; a. ’ i” ( i a i) / a % , i ; \4 on 7 } ; ue } ¥ y 1 Py " iS mr a » - I | : i ¥ hi iy: i i ij vy }" AP i i ‘ y P , ‘ ; 4 ? a ) f yay un : ay ; ae u a j ne 1 : a ! ; er, hi Bea ae Tiare i € ae ot J DP hoi | ae 9, be i q a i a tues Li an Pa Z cal y hd Vit i ; as ‘ ~ Are Wy eI | Fi ny Au ee \ ma 8 | as pa! Hy 2 (> ay ; . q ‘ 6 wy ¥ . er) | ¥ y B945 .D43Q5 The quest for certainty: a study of the Princeton Theological S Speer Library t logical Seminary— — 1 1012 00101 5504 . DATE DUE % Be 2 Lae = ae at. whens — HIGHSMITH #45115 s; git pe ener Heat Tata Po ee heder Pah rr ster, Per eri foosG t