144 ~fm c. DAWSONAND DR. A. SMITH WOODWARD [VO1.lxxi, 4. O~ a BONE IMPLEMENT ~'om PILTDOW~ (SUSSEX). By CHX]~LES Dkwso~, F.S.A., F.G.S., and A. SMITH WooJ)w~aD, LL.D., F.R.S., Pres.G.S. (Read December 2nd, 1914.) [PLATE XIV.] DI~RI~rO the past season we have spent much time in examining the Piltdown gravel, working round the margin of the area previously explored in detail. 1 In proportion to the amount of material removed, however, discoveries were few. Rolled frag- ments of teeth of Rhinoceros 2 and Mastodon, as highly mineralized as before, were again found in place in the dark gravelS; and they seem to belong to the Pliocene species Rh. etruseus and ~ . arvern- e~sis, already provisionally recorded. No human remains were met with; but a large piece of bone evidently worked by man compensates for much disappointment, and proves to be so sing,uhr that it is worthy of special description. This bone implement was found about a foot below the surface, in dark vegetable soil, beneath the hedge which bounds the gravel- pit, and within 3 or 4 feet of the spoil-heap whence we obtained t h e right parietal bone of the human skull. On being washed away, the soil left not the slightest stahl on the specimen, which was covered with firmly-adherent pale-yellow sandy clay, closely similar to that of the flint-beating layer at the bottom of the gravel) T h e bone, therefore, cannot have lain buried in the soil for any long period, and was almost certainly thrown there by the workmen with the other useless dfibris when they were digging gravel from the adjacent hole. It is much mineralized with oxide of iron, at least on the surface, and it agrees in appearance with some small fragments of bone which we found actually in place in the clay below the gravel. Its surface is yellowish brown, the eu$ facets being slightly darker than the rest; but the bony tissue within is yellowish or creamy white, and the whole is much less darkly stained than the bones from the gravel immediately above. As it lay in the rock it was broken across at its middle, and the two broken faces are stained like the rest of the bone: at its thinner end it was accidentally shattered by our workman's pick. The implement (P1. XIV) is a stout and nearly straight narrow plate of bone, 41 em. long and varying from 9 em. 9to 10 cm. in width, with the thicker e n d artificially pointed or keeled, the thinner end artificially rounded. One face 1 See preceding paper8 in Q. g. G. S. vol- lxix (1913) pp. 117-51, and vol. lxx (1914) pp. 82-89. Found by Dr. A. I)avidson Black, of Wesf~rn Reserve Univeraity, Cleveland (Ohio) U.S.A. a No. 3 of section, Q. J. G. S. vol. lxx (1914) fig. 1, p. 83~ 4 No. 4 of section, i5/d. QUART. JOURN. GEOL. Soc. VOL. LXXI, Pt.. XIV. 5. .q p. . #. ~:.! -4 =_ . \ i t i g. 77. BONE IMPLEMENT FROM PILTDOWN (SUSSEX). G. M. Woodward, del. S=,,.os~.Cot~o.,ae,-by. part 1] ON k BONE IMPLEMENT FROM PILTDOW~r. 145 (P1. X]V, fig. 1) is slightly convex from side to side, with a dense longitudinally-fibrous texture which shows that it is the unwrought original outer surface of the bone. The other face (fig. 2), which is more irregular and slightly concave in its middle portion, has a coarser and less firm texture, indicating the wall of a marrow-cavity which is more or less damaged by fracture, attrition, and decay. The bone at the pointed end measures 5 cm. in maximum thickness, while the thickness at the rounded end scarcely exceeds 8 cm. Its nearly parallel lateral edges show no signs of cutting or polishing, and in the half with the rounded end one edge is much thicker titan the other. The thicker edge (fig. 8) here forms a flattened wall nearly at right angles to the convex face, With the same dense fibrous texture indicating that it represents the original outer surface of the bone. The thinner edge (fig. 4) is irregularly broken, exposing hone of a coarser and less firm texture. The specimen, t h e r e f o r e , a p p e a r s to be a l o n g i t u d i n a l s t r i p f l a k e d f r o m a limb-bone by a blow a t t h e t h i c k e r end, in t h e same way as f l i n t - i m p l e m e n t s were f l a k e d f r o m t h e i r o r i g i n a l cores. The only known Pliocene or Pleisteeene limb-bone big enough to have produced the flake is that of a Proboscidcan; and direct comparison shows that the specimen was probably taken from the postero-external part of a left femur, in the region of the third trochanter and immediately above it (text-figure, p. 146). In fact, the thick ttattened lateral edge (Ph XIV, fig. 8) passes, just beyond the transverse fracture, into a sharply-rounded edge (t), between which and the broken margin of the marrow-cavity there is a distinct hollowing of the surface; and, if the bone here again retains its original outer surface, as it appears to do, this must represent part of the third trochanter itself. In support of this interpretation, it may be noted that the structural fibres of the Pil~lown specimen are not directly longitudinal, but make a very acute angle with the flattened lateral edge, exactly as in the part of the Proboscidean femur with which the fossil has just been compared. Some conh-aetion has taken place at intervals along the line of these fibres, and decay has widened the cracks inf~ small superficial grooves (P1. XIV, fig. 1, g), :resembling those in a subfossil femur of .Elephas from a lake-deposit in Egypt, now in the British Museum (No. NI: 8526). Microscope-sections of the specimen show that there is no difference between its minute strueh~re and that of Proboscidean bone ~--the narrow, elongated bone-cells being united by very numerous canaliculi, of which the majority are nearly s ~ i g h t and extend at righ~ angles to the long axis of the cells. While these comparisons seem to be saVisfactory, however, i~ must be admitted that the genus and species to which ~he Pro- boscidean belonged cannot be determined. The third trochanter 1 See ' Catalogu,~ of the Histological Series contained in the Museum of the Royal College of Sargeons ' vol. ii (1855) p]. xii, figs. 17-20. nr ouai~e of ~ ~Ctfe~u~ of Elephas in the bone from which the im- meridionalis _N'esti: hinder t~w, plement was made was in line showing the Tart of the bo~w with the rest of the edge, and represented ~y the Piltdoum not pro~etting ; but the promi- imptement ; one-eighth of the nence of this feature varies con- natural size. siderably in one and the same species, as shown by the series of femora of .Elephas lrrimi- genius in the British Museum. The microscopical structure is also not distinetive. I t can only be s t a f ~ that the original femur must have been as large as that of •. meridionalis fi'om the Forest Bed in the British Museum (No. M 6928), which measures 1"25 metre in length (see text-figure). The two ends of the imple- ment a r e shaped entirely by cutting, and bear no marks of grinding or rubbing, except perhaps a slight battering at the point. Most of the cut facets are small, and many of them suggest that they were made by some primitive tool, presumably a flint. The gently rounded end (P1. XIV, fig. 5), which seems to have been a ragged flake trimmed for com- fortable handling, exhibits three g.... rows of facets, one bevelling the edge of the outer face, another that of the inner face, and a third mw being directly ter- minal. The facets of the outer and terminal rows have especi- ally sharp margins ; but those of the inner row are less well defined, owing to the coarser and more fragile nature of the bony tissue at this edge. The thicker end of the implement is trimmed to a sharp vertical keel by the cutting of the lateral edges, and this keel is slightly reduced in depth by a little similar cutting of the outer and inner surfaces of the bone. The trimming extends farthest along the inner lateral edge, where the bone has been ~&l~ l ] THE BONE I~PLEMEI~T FROM PILTDOWI~~ 147 larger than elsewhere, and notably long and narrow. The shorter trimmed outer edge (P1. XIV, figs. 3 & 6) has been worked with much labour across the direction of the structural fibres, and. is irregularly hollowed with numerous small cross-cuts. Similar cuts pass over the inner or medullary surface (fig. 2) of the bone, which is only worked slightly. The trimming of the outer surface (fig. 1) extends as far from the sharp terminal keel as that of the outer lateral edge, and the facets here are narrow and smooth like those of the inner edge. The thicker or outer lateral edge of the implement, just beyond its ~orked pel~ion and directly opposite the beginning of the worked portion of the thinner lateral edge, is marked by a smooth and rounded groove (figs. 1-3, p), which passes from the inner to the outer surface of the bone with a slight inclination outwalxls in the direction of the keeled end. This groove is cylindrical, not hourglass-shaped, and presents the appearance of having been worn smooth by friction ; while on each side of it both the colour and the texture of the bone suggest that it represents a perforation, from which the outer wall has been accidentally broken away. On the inner surface of the bone, just within this groove, the beginning of another perforation is clearly seen (fig. 2, x), as if an attempt had been made to remedy the defect. A close examination of the implement leaves no doubt that the working and cutting of the bone were done when it was in a com- paratively fresh state. As the longitudinal grooves of decay on the outer surface (fig. 1, g) pass over the cut facets, they are presumably later than the working. It is, therefore, evident that the individual who made the implement was contemporary with an elephant bigger than the Ma~mnoth (JElephasprimigenius). Such gigantic elephants are only known to have lived in Western Europe at the end of the Pliocene and the beginning of the Pleistocene Period. The nature of the implement itself thus confirms our con- clusion based on its mineral condition, that it originally occmTed in the lowest layer of the Pilfxlown section. This layer sometimes passes imperceptibly into the overlying gravel in which the skull of JEoanthropus was found, and there is no reason to suppose that it is substantially older than the latter. Like the evidence pre- viously described, the discovery therefore seems to suggest that the deposits date back at least to the beginning of the Pleistocene Period. As f~ the probable use of the implement, it can only be remarked that we have no evidence to guide us. Its shape is unique, and an insh~nent with a point would be serviceable for many purposes. In conclusion, we must again express our thanks to Mr. George M. Maryon-Wilson, the Lord of the Manor of Barkham, and his tenant, Mr. Robert Kenward, for allowing us to continue excavations in the Pilklown gravel-pit. 148 mR. c. w w s o ~ x x D ~R. X. S M I T ~ W O O D W ~ [vol.Ixxl, EXPLANATION O F P L A T E XIV. Bone implement from a gravel near Piltdown Common, Fletching(Sussex); half of the natural size. Fig. 1. Original outer surface of bone. 2. Original inner (medullary) surface of bone. 3. Original outer edge of bone. 4. Inner flaked edge of bone. 5. Worked rounded end of bone. 6. Details of cut facets on outer edge of bone. g = grooves along structural lines caused by decay; p = artificial hollow, apparently the inner wall of a perforation from which the outer wall has been accidentally broken away ; t = third trochanter of the femur from which the implement was made; x = a shallow pit, probably the beginning of an artificial perforation. DISCUSSION. Mr. G. F. LAWRENCE said t h a t the form of the implement suggested a club. Its general surface was older than the cutting, being different in colour and more abraded. Mr. W. DxLv. said t h a t the tool-marks on the bone were of a character similar to those on an artificially-cut bone in his pos- session, which was found in the peat, during the dock-excavation at Southampton, in association with a hammer-stone of Neolithic age. The tool-marks appeared to have been made, not with a flint flake, but with some stronger cuttiug or chopping implement. :Mr. REOI~AL]) SMITH said t h a t there was one point on which all were agreed t h a t there was human work on the bone exhibited. I f it came in t h a t condition from the clay below the gravel (as the incrustation suggested), then it would rank as by far the oldest undoubted work of man in bone, nothing universally accepted as such occurring elsewhere before the period of Le Moustier. The possibility of the bone having been found and whittled in recent times must be considered ; and, if it were not shaped in its fossil state, it had evidently never been used for any purpose such as grubbing for roots, as the cuts were unscrat~hed, and must have been made with an even-edged chopper. Experiment might prove whether a similar surface could now be produced by cutting, as opposed to fracture. The perforation was not in the centre of the edge, and some theory m i g h t be based on the dh'ection in which the hole was worn, as if by the friction of a t h o n g ; b u t he could not imagine any use for an implement t h a t looked like part of a cricket-bat. The discoverers were to be congratulated on providing a new and interesting problem, such as would eventually provoke an ingenious solution. Mr. E. A. MARTIN wished to call attention to certain marks leading from the perforation, which seemed to show t h a t a thong had passed through the hole, and had been bound tightly around the bone. The thong-marks suggested t h a t the pointed end of the bone was t h a t by which it wm~ held, and t h a t its purpose was t h a t of a club. [September 17th, 1915.] part 1] o~ A BOI~I~ ~ s ~ . M E N _ T . . ~ ~ PILTDOWN. 149 Mr. A. S. K ~ x ~ D wlshe~i~o congratulate the Authors on t h e discovery of a new problem from Pilt~lown. From the differences between the cut portion of the bone and the natural surface, he con- sidered it possible that the bone was not in a fresh state when cut. He suggested that possibly experiments made on a fresh bone might throw light on the question as to how the cuts were made. Mr. F. P . ME~rELL said that experience in countries where elephants were still plentiful showed that the bones began to weather rapidly as soon as the flesh had decayed away. There was consequently no difficulty in detaching pieces from such bones, bu~, they were usually so splintery and even friable, that they were unsuitable for any kind of serviceable implement. It seemed to him very remarkable that so primitive a being as EoanthroTu8 should be capable of making and using any implements at all. 1~[r.S. H. W A R R ~ congratulated the Authors upon the interesl; and importance of the discovery. The implement seemed to him to be a hacking-tool rather than a club; but he thought it a mistake to imagine too much specializationof use in such primitive implements. It had always appeared to the speaker 9 that wood and bone must have been used before flint,and the evidence from Pi]Mown seemed to confirm this opinion. The PRESl])ESZ (Dr. A. SMIzR WOODW~LRD), replying on behalf of the .Authors,thought that every circumstance of the discovery pointed to the contemporaneity of the implement with ~oanthroTus. Mr. Dawson and he were of opinion that the bone was fresh when it was cut. They had not made any experiments in cutting bone with flints. He regretted that the use of the implement still remained a problem. The most plausiblesuggestion that he had 9 received was, that i~ might have been a digging stick; but it bore "no marks of battering and scratching. Q. J. G. S. No. 282. ~r 150 . R~XSED B E A C H ON T ~ E COAST OF J E R S E r . [voL lxxi. 5. On a RAISE]) B~.ACa on the SOUTHERN COAST of JERSEY. By ANDREW DUNLOP, M.D., F.G.S. (Read November 18th, 1914.) IN June last Mr. Emile F. Guiton, a member of the Geological Section of the Soci6t6 Jersiaise, drew my attention to a raised beach which had been exposed in the course of some building operations on the southern coast of the island. I t is on the east side of the ridge between Le Hocq and Pontae, and the section showing it runs from under the surface of the eastern slope about 25 feet westwards: here it is terminated by the rock, fine red granite, which makes a steep descent, and passes under the bed of pebbles. I t is nearly at right angles to the mare axis of the ridge, and faces northwards. The ridge here bends somewhat inwards, so that there was ground sloping to the north-east covering the beds before they were laid bare, and the underlying rock seems also to slope in the same direction. The middle of the section shows the following succession of beds, ~rom above downwards : - - Thickness in feet inches. 1. Loam ..................................................... about 4 2 2. Stiff brownish red clay ................................. ,, 1 0 3. Y e l l o w cl~y, containing waterworn pebbles and angular blocks ......................................... 3 4 4. Coarse b r o w n sand ' ,, 3 6 5. W a t e r w o r n pebbles ...................................... 4 6 At the western ~end of the section is a band of stiI[ brownish- yellow Clay, about 2 feet thick, which lies on the sloping rock, and, passing, downwards, is continued for a short distance under the lowest bed. The lowest bed (5) consists of well-rounded and waterworn pebbles with coarse sand and some angular fragments. The pebbles are of all sizes up to one measuring nearly 2 feet in longest diameter, and they are mostly of fine red granite, but there are some of diabase and quartzite, and a few of flint. Some of the granite pebbles had Undergone so considerable an amount of decomposition, that they could be broken with the fingers. At the eastern end of the bed and for the greater part of its length, the pebbles are closely packed together; but at its western end, where they have been thrown up on the clay-band covering the sloping rock, the pebbles are more thinly scattered in the sand. The overlying bed (4) is of coarse brown sand. For some distance from its eastern end under the slope it is well marked off from the pebbles beneath ; but, farther on, it seems to merge into them. The western extremity of the bed, or of the combined beds, rises and caps the rock which bounds the section, covering also b J .fJ' / - 1 f -J r~ c~ p~ II ~ .p~-- II II ~J c~ ~o,~- II 152 ~R. A. VV~-LOPOX ~ ~ISED BEACH [VO1. Ixxi, the end of the ehy-band, and forming a foot or t~vo of firmly- compacted sand containing some pebbles. At the end of the 1 ~ l , lower down, a large angular block rests upon the cla~--band which covers the granite. The next bed above (3) consists of yellow clay, perhaps somewhat sandy ill places, containing numerous~well-rounded pebbles, and, in its western half, a good deal of angular rubble. I t seems to lie in a hollow in the sandy bed below, and its eastern end (immediately under the slope) rests on a mass of angular fragments, which are, apparently, disintegrating rock i~ situ. None of the pebbles reach the size of the biggest in the bed below ; but, like these, they are mostly of fine red granite, with some of diabase and quartzite, and a few of flint. The layer of clay (2) is of elongated lenticular shape, and i~ about 10 feet long. The topmost bed (1) is of yellow clayey loam and earth. I t descends the slope covering the ends of the lower beds, and contains a layer of rubble which might be artificial, but has, more probably, been calTied down from the highest part of the ridge. A limpet- shell was found at the bottom of this loam where it passes over the bed of sand (4). The surfaces 6f the shell were dull and lustreless, its apex was somewhat abraded, and its margin fvas woral. Some fragments of shells of the same kind were noticed on a heap of sand and pebbles, and in some loam thrown aside by the workmen. The section is perhaps some 30 or 40 yards from the nearest part, of the shore, and its height above mean sea-level, measured by Mr. Messervy, is just over 53 feet, or about 85 feet above mean high tide. As there was some doubt, however, as to the exact level of the base from which the measurements were .taken, it is possible that the height may be from 8 to 5 feet less. On the opposite o1" western side of the ridge, near the top, a section is shown in a quarry, where yellow loamy clay is seen lying on the rock as it slopes towards the shore. The bed is from 2 or 3. to over 10 feet thick ; it contains angular blocks, mostly at its base, and in one place it shows distinct lamination. The raised beach on the St. Clement's. road, which I described a good many years ago, 1. is about a quarter of a mile farther inland. At one time it was seen in an interesting section, but now it is unfortunately buried under a mass of fallen earth and vegetation. Flint, of course, is foreign to the island, but flint-pebbles are found in the recent beaches, more especially on the north-eastern coast, where they occur in large numbers. They have also been found in two of our low-level (about 25 feet above mean sea-level) raised beaches, as well as associated with other pebbles in the chy~ I Q. j. G. S. vol. x]_ix (1893) p. 526. part 2] o x THE SOUTHER~ COAS~ OF JERSEI'. 153 :Not long ago, Mr. Sinel found some pebbles of Devonian shale, with typical fossils, in what appeared to me to be the remains of a raised beach on the south-western coast of the islafld. They were probably derived from the Devonian rocks of the opposite coast of France. Recently, Colonel Warton has pointed out a raised beach, which had not been previously noticed, in the railway-cutting a little beyond the enid of the platform of the Eastern Raihvay-station. I t lies in a hollow in the rock, and consists of rolled pebbles in a mah~ix of coarse brown sand. I t is about 8 feet thick, and is covered with a thick bed of yellow clay, which forms the rest of the cutting. Its base is 5 feet above the railway-line, and about ,_55 feet above mean sea-level. , Discusslo~r The PRESIDENT (Dr. A. SMITH WOODWX~)) emphasized the importance of studying the superficial deposits of Jersey, in view of the recent discovel T of a typical Pleistocene mammalian fauna m the cavern of La Cotte, St. Brelade's Bay. Mr. W. WHITXKER suggested that, as no occurrence of shells had been noted, there might be a doubt whether the beds described were really a raised beach, although their pebbly character pointed ~hat way. They might be Drift, perhaps of fluviati!e origin. He hoped that the Author would continue his work on the uurface-deposits of Jersey, and that we should thus be placed in possession of a connected account of them. Mr. G. BXRROW regretted the absence of the Author, as one would like to know more of the deposits taken to be part of the raised beach. The evidence from the Channel Islands formed an important addition to that already obtained from the Scilly Isles, (~ornwall, and the opposite coast of France. In Cornwall and the Scilly Isles, the raised beach~ had at one ~ime existed over a large part of the coast-line, and a considerable portion of the rock-shelf, upon which the beach-deposit rested, still remained. But the greater part of the deposit had now gone, and material of more recent formation rested on its platform. In Cornwall the variation in these was not great, and no deposit of undoubted Glacial age had been recognized ; but, in the Scilly Isles, lenticular patches of stones, some glacially striated, were found by the speaker. These occurred in a curious sandy material covering a rather wide extent. It was found later to correspond, both in composition and in stratigraphical position, with the L i m o n of the French coast, which was examined under the guidance of Dr. Charles Barrois : here, however, no Scratched stones were seen. The pebbles of the tree beach-material in the Scilly Isles appeared ~o be all of local origin, but thcse of the distinctly newer Glacial 4eposi~ were largely foreign to the islands. 154 RAISED BE~Ca 0~" TaE COXST OF JZaSZr [VO1.lxxi, The basal bed shown in the Author's section seemed to corre- spond rather wi.'th the Glacial deposit than with the older raised- beach material. Dr. A. STRX~_~ expressed his ssanpathy with the Author on the circumstances that had prevented his p~sence at the Meeting. The section described appeared to be one of a number of examples of raised beach that had escaped destruction on rocky coasts in the Isle of Portland, in Cornwall and Devon, in South Wales and elsewhere. The shells that were usually abundant in the beach were absent , and the caution exercised by a previous speaker in accepting the beach as such was so far justified. In other respects, however, the section appeared to be convincing. 9The age of the beach was doubtful on the South Coast o f England, but in South ~Tales the deposit definitely preceded the manifestation of glacial phenomena. Falconer proved that some of the mammalian remains of the caves of South Wales were embedded in a sand which belonged to the raised beach. I t was to be hoped that the Author would continue his researches, and would be able to throw light on the relation of the Jersey beach to the mam- malian remains, to which reference had been made by the President. Dr. N. O. HOLST, who was invited [iv:the President to take pal~ 9 . . -. .'~ t'-. o in the discussmn, said that he consldere~l the loams covermg the. Channel Islandswthe uppermost deposit in the Author's sectionw to be the same as those that he had seen in Belgium, in Northern France, and in the Thames Valley. During his stay in England he had had so far little opportunity of studying the loams of the Thames Valley, but perhaps he would be able to express a more definite opinion when he had seen more of them.