Gx Directorate of SPProved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Top Secret Pf ry 5 Intelligence (b)(3) NatSecAct Warsaw Pact Military Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Initiation (U) An Intelligence Assessment Top Secret (b)(3) NatSecAct June 1986 Copy 3 3 0 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Warning Notice National Security Information - .“ Dissemination Control Abbreviations (b)(3) CIAAct _ Unauthorized Disclosure Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Intelligence Sources or Methods Involved (WNINTEL) Subject’to Criminal Sanctions NOFORN (NF) Not releasable to foreign nationals NOCONTRACT (NC) Not releasable to contractors or contractor /consultants PROPIN (PR) Caution—proprietary information involved ORCON (OC) Dissemination and extraction of information controlled by originator REL... This information has been authorized for release to... WN WNINTEL—Intelligence sources or methods involved Classified Declassify: OADR Derived from multiple sources This page is Confidential. Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 wf (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct CENTR 4? wae Directorate of rae Intelligence Top Secret— Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct Warsaw Pact Military Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Initiation (vu) An Intelligence Assessment (b)(3) CIAAct Office This paper was prepared b of Soviet Analysis. Comments and queries are welcome and may be directed to the Chief. SOVA, sis (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 “Top Seeret_ SOV 86-100201¥ June 1986 Key Judgments Information available as of 1 April 1986 was used in this report. (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 “Top Seeret- (b)(3) NatSecAct Warsaw Pact Military Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Initiation (Uv) The key tenet of Soviet doctrine for nuclear war holds that delivery of the first massed strike provides a decisive, potentially war-winning advantage. Consequently, Soviet military doctrine is preeminently concerned with first use and has a strong bias for preemption on a massive scale. A decision by the Soviets to preempt in a European war would depend upon their perceptions and observations of NATO activities and their predictions of the circumstances under which NATO would use nuclear weapons. Our analysis of all sources suggests that the Soviets lack confidence in their ability to detect preparations for NATO’s imminent use of nuclear weapons. Hence, we judge that the Soviets’ perceptions of the catalysts and conditions for NATO first use would be critical to their decision to preempt. (b)(3) NatSecAct Analysis of authoritative writings leads us to conclude that the Warsaw Pact assesses the conventional “correlation of forces” as being in its favor, especially in ground forces. The Pact believes that, barring the unforeseen, victory in a war is possible without first use of nuclear weapons. We judge that Soviet leaders would approve the first use of nuclear weapons for only two reasons: to preempt NATO’s large-scale use or to prevent general defeat. Only the first reason receives serious attention from Pact theorists because the second is seen only as a remote possibility. (b)(3) NatSecAct The Soviet General Staff’s perception of why NATO might initiate nuclear warfare, as echoed throughout the Warsaw Pact military, varies signifi- cantly in some ways from Western plans and intentions. Our analysis of Pact writings | persuades us that at least some misperceptions arise because the Soviets project their own doctrine, command arrangements, and intentions onto NATO. For example, the Soviets, as well as their allies, do not distinguish the US national nuclear forces from those of France and the United Kingdom, but rather assume they are controlled by a unitary NATO decisionmaking structure dominat- ed by the United States. (b)(3) NatSecAct Drawing upon their analyses of NATO’s doctrine, exercises, nuclear decisionmaking, and defense plans, Pact strategists have refined their estimates of the cause and timing of NATO nuclear initiation into four major cases: (b)(3) NatSecAct iii SOV 86-100201X (b)(3) NatSecAct June 1986 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 —_fop Serer Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct ¢ NATO strikes early and massively. Such a strike typically would occur on the first day of the war, followed by NATO thrusts into Eastern Europe. This is seen by the Pact as an attempt to initiate a decisive surprise attack and is described by Pact sources as the worst case. ¢ NATO strikes to support its first main defense line. Such an attack typically would occur when Pact forces threaten to breach NATO defense lines along the Weser River. ¢ NATO strikes to hold its final defense line along the Rhine River. Pact planners assume that nuclear use is virtually certain as their forces reach and attempt to cross the Rhine. ¢ No nuclear strikes. In recent years, Pact writings have begun to give more attention to the sited of a protracted conventional war. (b)(3) NatSecAct Although the Pact devotes considerable effort to prepare against the worst case scenario, it expects to avert it and may see a chance to escape nuclear attack at NATO’s first main defense line as well. No major Pact theater exercise has simulated the worst case scenario for seven years, although it was regularly featured for nearly two decades. A number of recent major exercises have portrayed Pact forces penetrating NATO’s first main defense line without a NATO nuclear counsel (b)(3) NatSecAct Sensitive Pact writings stress how critical the Rhine would be in support of a last-ditch defense of West Germany by NATO. No major Pact exercise has simulated an advance beyond the Rhine without nuclear initiation. Several major nonnuclear exercises have ended with a suggestion of ~ imminent nuclear initiation as Pact forces reach and attempt to breach NATO’s defenses along the Rhine River. (b)(3) NatSecAct Soviet theorists recognize the paradox in their expectation that the very success of Pact conventional forces would be likely to trigger NATO nuclear strikes to stave off defeat. They further believe that initial limited nuclear strikes by NATO would be ineffective, motivating it to launch larger nuclear strikes. Because Soviet doctrine calls for launching a preemptive, massed nuclear strike once NATO’s intention to use nuclear weapons on a large scale is detected, Pact theater successes could lead directly to a general nuclear war. (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) | NatSecAct To resolve this paradox, the Soviets have undertaken peacetime and wartime initiatives to weaken NATO’s will and capability to use nuclear weapons in a war. They seek to make it difficult for NATO to use nuclear weapons effectively, to demonstrate the futility of their use, and to highlight the risks of preemptive or retaliatory Pact nuclear strikes. The Soviets’ responses to their perception of the probability of NATO nuclear use and the requirement to launch a: preemptive massed strike when ordered could, ironically, provide another motivation for Pact first use in a war. Soviet planners and commanders explicitly trade off resources required for the conventional campaign to support the transition to nuclear war. The withholding of additional forces for possible nuclear strikes would reduce the availability of conventional fire support from air and missile units at times when they would be needed to support the Pact assault on NATO defense lines. This is precisely the same time when NATO first use is seen as increasingly likely (b)(3) NatSecAct We believe that the Soviet threshold for nuclear preemption would be lowered significantly at NATO’s first main line of defense and especially at the Rhine. Confusion and the Soviets’ lack of confidence in their ability to correctly interpret NATO defensive measures heighten the risks of miscalculation. The Soviets believe that NATO plans and prepares for nuclear initiation at these times. The General Staff’s recommendations to the Supreme High Command would be made in the context of the staff's own sense of vulnerability to a massive NATO nuclear strike. Regardless of the Supreme High Command’s decision, Pact forces would be at maximum readiness to carry out a nuclear strike at these times. (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Vv (b)(3) Reverse Blank NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 "_Top-Secret_ (b)(3) NatSecAct Contents Page Key Judgments iii __ Introduction 1 Misperceptions of NATO Nuclear Policies 4 Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Decisionmaking 4 Perceptions of NATO Defense Plans 5 NATO's Cover Zone and Forward Defense Zone 5 NATO’s Main Defense Lines 5 1 Perceptions of NATO’s Nuclear Doctrine 1 Perceptions of Specific Circumstances for NATO First Use 13 Implications for Soviet Planning and Doctrine 16 Appendixes ; ~ A. Soviet Definitions of Nuclear Use 19 B. NATO’s INF and Pact Military Perceptions 21 (b)(3) NatSecAct vii —Ton-Serret__ (b)(3) NatSecAct Reverse Blank’ Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)( (b)(3) NatSecAct ~~" hon-Soviet Warsaw Pact (NSWP), 1) Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Warsaw Pact Military Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Initiation (vu) Introduction Warsaw Pact analyses of NATO’s nuclear doctrine, plans, and exercises help shape Soviet military percep- tions of why, when, and how NATO would initiate the use of nuclear weapons in Europe. These perceptions provide a context for monitoring indications of and predicting the first use of nuclear weapons by NATO. (b)(1) b)(1 Because Pact reconnaissance and intelligence systems (b)(3) NatSecAct would be under severe stress in a crisis and unable to produce conclusive evidence of NATO nuclear prepa- rations,' Soviet perceptions of the catalysts and condi- tions for NATO first use are likely to play a key role in advising the Supreme High Command whether to order a preemptive Pact strike, (b)(3) NatSecAct Our evidence indicates that the Soviets have made a concerted effort to understand and predict NATO’s behavior. For Soviet theorists and planners, war is a problem amenable to study using the “‘scientific” principles of Marxism-Leninism. War and human behavior are believed to be predictable when subject- ed to rigorous, systematic study. Consequently, Soviet military leaders can be expected to give more cre- dence to “scientific forecasts” of enemy behavior than would be the case in Western armies (b)(3) NatSecAct This paper addresses Pact military perceptions of NATO nuclear initiation as a reflection of less acces- sible Soviet military perceptions. Our analysis relies /SIDle Sovie upon sensitive and open-source Soviet, and military writings. (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct Although we believe that major trends and decisions are reflected in these writings and in exercise data ' These issues are addressed in DI Research P SOV 85- 10107CX (Top Secret June 1985, Warsaw Pact Tactical Forces: Capabilities and Readiness for used judiciously) (1 ) (U)(O) NatoeTAct over time,? we are aware that such material must be (b)(3) NatSecAct Finally, extrap- Nuclear War, (b) ( 1 ) (b)(3) NatSecAct 1 (b)(3) NatSecAct olation of scenarios - cises is complicated (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct Our evidentiary base is indicative of Warsaw Pact peacetime military perceptions. Of course, these may not survive the stress of war. Further, Soviet political leaders may hold views dif- ferent from those of their military subordinates. We judge this latter possibility unlikely because of the salient importance of the nuclear war issue and the relatively deep and ongoing involvement of Soviet political leaders in national defense planning. We believe any major disagreement between political and military leaders would have been observable and reflected in our evidentiary base. (S NF) This paper focuses upon Pact perceptions of NATO nuclear initiation. NATO nuclear responses to initial Pact use and the interplay between limited NATO and Pact nuclear strikes also evoke discussion and analysis in Pact military writings. But the key tenet of Soviet nuclear doctrine holds that the side that deliv- ers the first massed strike gains a decisive, potentially war-winning advantage. Thus we observe a preemi- nent Soviet, and hence Pact-wide, concern over first use, as well as a strong bias toward preemption ona massive scale, (b)(3) NatSecAct ? For the role played by exercises in the formulation of Soviet military doctrine, see DI Research Paper SOV 86-10014JX (Top Secret April 1986, The Soviet General Staff: Managing Change in Military Doctrine. ( b ) ( 3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct- The Influence of NATO Exercises on the Warsaw Pact Sensitive Pact military writings and the efforts of NATO show that the Pact devotes considerable effort to monitoring NATO exercises and is influenced by its observations. 4 The Pact writes specifically that large, multinational exercises are a primary vehicle for NATO to work out its contingencies and plans for a future war in Europe. The influence af NATO exercises on Pact perceptions and thus indirectly on doctrine can be seen in the following examples: e NATO and the Pact both foresee longer periods of conventional combat before nuclear employment. On the basis af NATO exercises, the Pact perceives that NATO sees a trend toward longer periods of conventional combat before nuclear weapons are employed. Whereas NATO exercises in the early 1960s went only one or a few days before nuclear weapons were introduced, by the mid-1970s the conventional period lasted four or five days, and by the late 1970s it stretched to about a week. As Shown in figure 1, a nearly identical trend can be observed in Pact exercises. NATO is more likely to initiate nuclear use than the Warsaw Pact. NATO exercises analyzed by the Soviets and their allies show NATO initiating nuclear use in every case since the mid-1960s. Evidence from more than 100 Pact military exer- cises between 1970 and 1985 that featured nuclear use in the European theater indicates that the initial use af nuclear weapons by NATO was simu- lated in about 55 percent of the exercises. Addition- al cases of intended NATO initial use are also present within the 10 percent of the exercises we classify as “simultaneous initial use,” and in an- other 10 percent where we cannot determine the Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct Percent Simultaneous initial use 10 Unambiguous Warsaw Pact first use 25 Unambiguous NATO first use 55 Undetermined initiator 10 Nuclear First Use in Warsaw Pact Exercises in the European Theater, 1970-85 | (bb )(3) NatSecAct initiator. Of the remaining 25 percent—cases in which the Pact initiated nuclear use—a substantial portion reflected Pact nuclear initiation motivated by its perceptions that NATO nuclear use was imminent or unavoidable. Pact nuclear initiation in such cases is, in the Soviet view, doctrinally mandated and does not constitute true ‘first use.” Even these figures may understate the dominance af NATO first use in Pact exercises. In recent years, Pact exercises depicting NATO first use are even more common. The depic- tion in Pact exercises af NATO as bearing the onus for initiating nuclear use fulfills both training and propaganda purposes. Nevertheless, the reason for NATO's initial use af nuclear weapons conforms to the Soviets’ assessments and appears to reflect their (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct perceptions of NATO muclear planning and intent. |___(b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct rc eS Figure 1 Timing of Nuclear First Use in Warsaw Pact and NATO Exercises in the European Theater Day of initial nuclear use (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) “> ——~(b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 : (b)(3) NatSecAct Finally, the language of the discussion helps deter- mine the intellectual framework of Soviet and NSWP writings about.war in general and nuclear war in particular. Appendix A provides a lexican of maior Soviet terms concerning nuclear war, Misperceptions of NATO Nuclear Policies In describing NATO nuclear policies, Warsaw Pact military writers reveal perceptions that sometimes vary significantly from NATO’s actual plans and intentions (see inset on pages 2 and 3). These misper- ceptions cannot be explained simply by a lack of information. To the contrary, we have overwhelming evidence that the Soviets, and to a lesser degree the NSWP countries, have gathered extensive informa- tion about NATO’s nuclear capabilities, doctrine, and plans. They expend considerable resources monitoring NATO exercises and incorporate thei i into their own exercises and doctrine, (b)(3) NatSecAct We believe most Warsaw Pact misperceptions result from projecting Soviet doctrine, command arrange- ments, and intentions onto NATO. This mirror imag- ing is most apparent in Pact descriptions of NATO decisionmaking and the military reasons for NATO nuclear initiation. On the other hand, Pact writers discuss NATO defense plans and the most likely form without major distortions. (b)(3) NatSecAct Distorted Pact perceptions do not skew its threat assessments in a single direction. Some appear to diminish NATO’s nuclear threat, but most enhance it. It is ironic that the Pact could hardly face a more obstinate and challenging foe in the nuclear arena than its own mirror image. (b)(3) NatSecAct Perceptions of NATO Nuclear Decisionmaking In its military writings, the Pact generally portrays NATO’s nuclear decisionmaking structure as mono- lithic and highly responsive, although individual national pressures could argue for use at different times. The Supreme Allied Commander in Europe (SACEUR)—always an American in practice if not by treaty provision—is generally depicted as the individual who would request permission for specific nuclear employment from the NATO Council. The NATO Council, according to Pact writers, would grant permission on a case-by-case basis, at least in ~Fop-Secret_ (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) Nat4pproved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 the early stages of nuclear use. These sources state that the final authorization for nuclear use must be given by the President of the United States. | (b)(3) NatSecAct _on pages 6 and 7), (b)(3) NatSecAct The Soviets, as well as the NSWP, do zot distinguish among the different national nuclear forces’ political control or reasons for initial independent use (see inset (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct The formal NATO nuclear decisionmaking structure, including consultative ar- trangements, is a primary collection and analysis target. (b)(3) NatSecAct—(b)(3) NatSecAct Similarly, the Pact either dismisses or misunderstands uniquely French and British national nuclear doc- trines even though the technical characteristics of their systems are regularly and accurately described. An NSWP source in the mid-1960s described France’s rejection of limited nuclear war and its belief that general nuclear war was the only conceivable form for a major European war. However, this theme has not reappeared in either sensitive Soviet or . NSWP military writings. More typically, recent Pact writings portray French and British nuclear systems incorrectly and simplistically as integrated compo- nents of a coordinated NATO nuclear array. French and British strategic systems are described as longer range versions of the US Pershing II surface-to- surface missile (SSM), with the same types of targets. Similarly, the French Pluton SSM is considered a replacement, along with the American-made Lance, for the obsolescent Honest John. An exception in recent years to this view of NATO has been a Soviet proposal to deal separately with France and the United Kingdom on intermediate-range nuclear forces (INF) (see appendix B). Most recently, General Secretary Gorbachev called in January 1986 for the elimination of French and British systems over a five- to 10-year period beginning no later than 1990. (b)(3) NatSecAct \ Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct source as well as classified (b)(3) NatSecAct Measures to counter identified threats ‘ Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Perceptions of NATO Defense Plans Warsaw Pact perceptions of NATO’s defense plans are for the most part realistic and accurate appraisals derived from Pact analyses of NATO exercises, open- writings and statements, peacetime deployment of NATO forces, and geography The appraisals show a strong bias toward the Central European Theater of Military Operations (TMO) and toward the northern half of West Germany 1n particular. This probably reflects the dominant role of that region in Pact plans and presumes NATO interest there, although this bias may 1n part be artificially induced by the nature of our sources} _(b)(3) NatSecAct A substantial number of NSWP sources, some Soviet writings, and virtually all exercise scenarios describe NATO as planning to conduct offensive operations against the Pact NATO 1s depicted as intending to advance toward Szczecin, Berlin, Leipzig, Dresden, and Prague. We believe such intentions are imputed to NATO not just for propaganda purposes but also to __motivate the soldiers and leaders of the Pact. (b)(3) NatSecAct_ Still, we should not totally discount Pact concerns about a NATO offensive. Soviet Marxist-Leninist theory holds that one of the major missions of the armed forces 1s to deter, and if necessary punish, those capitalist states that resist “the inevitable triumph of socialism ” Resistance 1s commonly portrayed in the future when the dying capitalist oligarchy lashes out against the “triumphant, progressive forces of socia- hsm ” Pact military strategists analyze potential con- flict in Europe within this context and their doctrinal requirement to examine all military-technical possi- bilities. It is not the role of the military strategists to judge whether NATO political leaders would order an offensive, but they are charged with investigating NATO’s capabilities for offensive action and takin Soviet military doctrine also emphasizes readiness to defeat a NATO offensive and to seize the initiative with a vigorous Pact counteroffensive. Unsurprisingly, Pact sources state that NATO would undertake de- fensive operations if 1t were clear that even a surprise (b)(3) : NatSecAct attack would not offset numerically superior Pact forces In any case, Pact leaders clearly expect to force NATO onto the defensive, whatever NATO’s initial intentions (b)(3) NatSecAct The basic features of NATO document MC 14/3, NATO’s flexible-response doctrine (see inset), as well as NATO’s command structure and layout of corps sectors, have been portrayed in Pact writings for nearly two decades Unclassified official NATO docu- ments and statements, which the Pact would have access to, do not indicate clearly what geographic features its covering force area and main battle area would rest upon, nor what rear defense lines might be occupied as necessary Pact estimates of these fea- tures and lines are revealing, both for what they indicate about Pact intelligence and analysis and because of the role Pact planners believe these defense lines are likely to play in triggering NATO nuclear use and shaping Pact operations (b)(3) NatSecAct NATO’s Cover Zone and Forward Defense Zone. Sensitive Pact writings claim that NATO will deploy 60 to 70 percent of its forces in its cover zone and forward defense lines. These sources usually describe the depth of NATO’s cover zone as 15 to 50 kilome- ters (km) and depict its forward defense zone begin- ning just beyond (to the west of) 1ts cover zone (see figure 3) These and other Pact writings consistently locate the leading (eastern) edge of NATO’s forward defense zone as running through West Germany from Lubeck, Luneberg, and Uelzen, to Braunschweig South of Braunschweig, this forward defense line is less clear but appears to link the cities of Munden and Passau in a gentle arc around the inner German border (b)(3) NatSecAct NATO’s Main Defense Lines. Pact writers claim that if NATO forces were pushed from their forward defense zone, they would fall back on a series of main defense lines that stretch the length of West Ger- many, ceding each in turn to occupy that to its rear These lines are approximately 40 to 60 km apart Because the battle for Germany may proceed at different rates in the north and south, NATO could (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)( (b)( Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 -ToirSeeret __ (b)(3) NatSecAct The French Nuclear Forces: An Unrecognized Wildcard? We have no convincing evidence that the Soviets view French nuclear forces as separate from or likely to be engaged under different conditions than other NATO nuclear systems. The creation of the French Rapid Action Force, the growing French theater and strate- gic nuclear capabilities, and the convergence of Paris and Bonn on many security issues may, however, focus Soviet attention on French nuclear capabilities and nuclear doctrine in the future.(b)(3) NatSecAc Currently, French main forces are located within French borders or relatively deep in NATO’s rear areas (the II Corps in Baden-Baden), although there is one brigade stationed in West Berlin. The Soviets might therefore expect the French to feel no pressing need to employ theater nuclear weapons to rescue major French forces early in a war (see figure 2). French Army nuclear systems—some 30 Pluton sur- face-to-surface missile launchers—are positioned too deep to be used very near or beyond the eastern FRG border (given their 120-km range) without consider- able forward deployment. On the other hand, French tactical nuclear-capable aircraft could reach East European territory rapidly with relative certainty. (b)(3) NatSecAct 1) 3) We expect the Soviets to reconsider the French nuclear threat as France increases its theater and strategic nuclear capabilities by acquisitions of the 350-km-range Hades missile, additional nuclear- capable strike aircraft, new air-to-surface nuclear missiles, additional and more capable nuclear sub- marines armed with newer missiles, NatSecAct These capabilities must be seen in light of: ¢ Increasing French Army capabilities to intervene quickly with significant forces in the battle for West Germany, both with the formation of the Rapid Action Force and the reorientation of the III Corps of the First Army. a French Pluton SSMs _(b)(3) NatSecAct ¢ Planned organizational changes to subordinate all French theater nuclear forces to a command con- trolled directly by the Joint Staff Command. The French nuclear release procedure is arguably al- ready highly responsive and will most likely be Surther streamlined with this organizational change. © The deliberate effort to link the theater nuclear force to the more threatening and rapidly growing French strategic forces: (b)(3) NatSecAct The French view their theater nuclear force in war as a means to serve as a ‘final warning” to the Soviets that they must cease aggression or suffer a French strategic nuclear strike against cities in the USSR. To reinforce the linkage, the French have none too subtly renamed their theater nuclear forces “prestra- tegic’”’ nuclear forces, _(b)(3) NatSecAct Soviet failure to recognize independent French first use or escalation in a war could draw the Soviets and non-French NATO countries into a nuclear exchange. The same possibility could result from independent British nuclear strikes, although the British decision- making system is relatively more integrated into the (b)(1) formal NATO structure. (b)(3) NatSecAct— (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Figure 2 A Soviet View France’s Ground Forces wae wersermetay Versailiesc Deland | (b)(3) NatSecAct ay 1 {L 3a] t . iy apace ried e Lf 1B ot nat, ‘ erussets *, ~ ELGIUM 4 ~ b's s. “we? J 7 FRG 7 4 Strasbourg | Li? a ee ones 11> 3épnd) i, Mave cre = igen 4asd Be Soe A; a Og am (b)(3) NatSecAct Key: 1A/1, 2, 3 AK—1st Army: I, II, III Army Corps 1. 9th Infantry Division 2. Wl Army Corps: 2nd Armored Division 8th Infantry Division 12th Infantry Training Division 12th Infantry Training Division 15th Infantry Division 11th Airborne Division 14th Infantry Training Division 7th Armored Cavalry Divison 27th Alpine Infantry Division Rapid Action Force: 9th Infantry Division 11th Armored Division 27th Alpine Infantry Division 6th Armored Cavalry Division 4th Airmobile Division PRI AMA aw, 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. (b)(3) NatSecAct 7th Armored Division 3rd Armored Division II Army Corps: Ast, 3rd, 5th Armored Divisions I Army Corps: 7th, 10th Armored Divisions 15th Infantry Division 14th Infantry Training Division I Army Corps, 4th Airmobile Division II Army Corps, 5th Armored Division 1st Armored Division 10th Armored Division 2nd Armored Division FAR (Rapid Action Force) Ill Army Corps, 8th Infantry Division HQ Armed Forces, HQ Ground Forces (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 NATO’s Flexible Response Strategy The strategy of flexible response approved by the Allies in 1967 and set forth in the NATO document MC 14/3 is intended to provide a full range of military responses to potential aggression. 4 It reflects the judgment that a credible deterrent requires a full range of conventional, tactical nuclear, and strategic nuclear forces; together these forces compose the so- called NATO triad. According to this concept, Alli- ance forces should be capable of responding to a Pact attack at three levels: e Direct defense at the border area: Initial reaction would involve the movement of NATO forces from their peacetime garrisons to their assigned general defense positions in one of the eight national corps sectors upon receipt of warning. The primary objec- tive af NATO’s forces would be to meet enemy Sorces at the intra-German and Czechoslovak bor- ders and limit their advance. The main geographic areas involved in this forward defense are the covering force area (extending from the border westward approximately 20 kilometers) and the main battle area (extending to approximately 50 a For a recent interpretation, see Bob Furlong and Macha Levin- son, “SACEUR Calls for Research on a European ABM System,” International Defense Review, No. 2, February 1986. kilometers farther west) where the decisive battles to stop the enemy advance would take place. An effective forward defense is one that could defeat a Pact attack before enemy formations could breach the main battle area. ¢ Deliberate escalation: If faced with the likelihood of a massive conventional breakthrough by Pact forces, NATO commanders may request approval from Alliance political authorities to employ tacti- cal nuclear weapons. Use of these weapons would be intended primarily to restore deterrence by signal- ing NATO's resolve to escalate the level of hostil- ities if deemed necessary to halt the enemy’s ad- \ vance. The timing of deliberate escalation decisions is intentionally left ambiguous to maximize uncer- tainty in the mind of the adversary. ¢ NATO's ultimate deterrent is provided by the option of a general nuclear response, employing long-range strategic systems against targets in the Soviet homeland. ____(b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) 1 (b)(3) NatSecAct — (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 -ForSecret (b)(3) NatSecAct Figure 3 Warsaw Pact Perceptions of NATO Defense Lines in West Germany 400 Kilometers eH 100 Miles ENE, CEX North Sea WX boys Yow Pp, at a Intermediate; a ~ (b)(3) NatSecAct 9 “op-Seeret : ~ (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct link the northern half of one defense line with the southern half of another. This appears to be reflected in some Pact exercises in which NATO’s defense line bows dramatically before breaking, although in most writings this bending effect is not discussed. |(b)(3) NatSecAct | NATO’s first main defense line, which serves as the backbone of its forward defense zone, is linked in Pact writings with the Weser River and a southern exten- sion that, alternatively, connects the cities of Lauter- bach, Karlstadt, Ansbach, and Augsburg to the Lech River, or swings eastward from Karlstadt along the Main to the Regnitz or Altmuhl Rivers, to the Danube. Although a northern extension of the Weser line into the Jutland peninsula would be noncontigu- ous, NATO’s defense of the Kiel Canal may be associated with it. The distance of the first main defense line to the inner German border varies from over 100 km at its northern and southern extremities, to less than 50 km in the German III and US V corps sectors. These distances conform to Pact estimates of the depth of NATO’s corps sectors (b)(3) NatSecAct Pact sources emphasize the likelihood and importance of NATO integrating rivers into its defense scheme. Soviet experience in World War II helped establish a fixation on the role of rivers as defensive obstacles. For example, Col. A. A. Sidorenko’s The Offensive devotes an entire chapter to forcing water obstacles ? and associates the use of nuclear weapons in defense of river lines explicitly. Pact writings name the rivers that NATO would defend, indicate the engineering resources needed to cross them, and note that major crossings would be army and front-level operations. Their planners believe that river-crossing operations would be especially attractive targets for NATO nuclear strikes (b)(3) NatSecAct In keeping with this emphasis on river lines, a main defense line described as intermediate in Pact writings is formed by the Ems River, connected through East German River Crossing Marburg with sections of the Main, Jagst, and Iller Scenes from Warsaw Pact exercise ne > Forcing river obstacles continues to be given prominence in Soviet NatSecAct military writings including the authoritative Taktika by V. G. (b)(3) NatSecAct Reznichenko (1984) and A. I. Radziyevskiy’s Army Operations (1977), translated in JPRS-UMA-85-016-L, 16 July 1985 (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct Rivers. Defenses in the nearly 200-km gap between the Ems and Main Rivers would be supported by the rough terrain that dominates this area| NATO defenses along the Rhine River, and possibly its extension along the Ijssel or Maas, are described by Pact sources variously as NATO’s strategic, rear, or last main defense line in West Germany. Rivers to the west of the Rhine are seldom described in Pact writings as potential NATO defense lines. Those mentioned—the Moselle and Maas, for example—are most likely modifications of the Rhine line. The Rhine River is 150 to 350 km from the inner German border—a distance that coincides with that given in Pact writings for the depth of NATO’s army groups. (b)(3) NatSecAct e Nuclear munitions depots. ¢ Important rear service installations. * State administration centers. ¢ Political and economic centers (b)(3) NatSecAct This worst case threat does not dominate Pact analy- sis and planning: In fact, most sensitive Pact military writings indicate that initial NATO nuclear strikes are most likely to be: ¢ Limited or selective, rather than massive. ¢ Used in support of defensive operations. ¢ Restricted to areas near the forward line of troops. ¢ Directed against the immediate Payee threat, (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct It is difficult to overstate the importance attached to Pact planners believe the Rhine in Pact analyses and exercises. The reasons are clear: .© Its breach would threaten the last naturally bound- ed enclave NATO might attempt to hold in the FRG. ¢ Most of NATO’s main airbases, including the ma- jority of nuclear-capable airfields, are just beyond the Rhine. * Seizure of Rhine crossings would allow Pact forces to advance to the North Sea or the English Channel, splitting NATO in two. ¢ Reaching the Rhine Valley would mean that the Pact had control of most of West Germany and its population and economic assets. (b)(3) NatSecAct \ : Perceptions of NATO’s Nuclear Doctrine ' Pact discussions of NATO’s nuclear doctrine empha- size jthe threat of massive nuclear strikes—NATO’s general nuclear response. Such strikes, as depicted in Pact writings are virtual mirror images of massed Pact strikes. They are on the same scale as the Pact’s, employing several hundred nuclear weapons per NATO army group (roughly the equivalent of a Pact front) and sequenced in the same manner. The targets for such NATO strikes are indistinguishable in type and priority from those commonly given for massed Pact strikes: ¢ Means of nuclear attack. « Airfields. (b)(1) ° Troop groupings. (b)(3) NatSecAct . ' e Air defense systems. ¢ Command posts. 11 NATO would conduct limited nuclear strikes in de- fensive operations against the combat and support elements of the most threatening Pact maneuver forces. In those cases where NATO forces employed a static defense, nuclear strikes would be used primarily to support forward defense: forces. When NATO relied on a mobile defense, a larger allocation would be made for strikes to support counterattacks. The most common features of limited NATO nuclear operations found in authoritative sources are: ¢ Size of limited or selective strikes. Pact exercises in 1977 and 1978 depicted NATO selective strikes of six warheads, although the number of warheads has typically varied from five to 10. Consistent with strikes of this size, Pact writings assert that NATO doctrine calls for five or six warheads to be used against an attacking Pact division. Pact descriptions of massive NATO nuclear strikes typically include several hundred warheads. Range of use. In a period of limited nuclear war, NATO is described as using tactical and operational-tactical weapons. The former consists mainly of artillery; the latter includes SSMs—the Pershing Ia, Lance, and Pluton—and tactical air- craft that could strike up to about a 1,000-km range, or to the Soviet-Polish border. No nuclear Strikes against targets in the Soviet homeland are (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 LOCUM anticipated before the initial massed NATO nucle- ar strike. Moreover, most Pact discussions note that NATO limited use would probably be confined, at least initially, to about 30 km from the forward line of troops (FLOT). This is the approximate range of NATO’s nuclear artillery and is also the approxi- mate depth of attacking first-echelon Pact divisions.‘ Weapon systems employed. Atomic demolition mu- nitions and nuclear-tipped antiaircraft missiles (for example, the Nike Hercules) were often considered the most likely candidates for initial NATO use in Pact writings and exercises, but both are being phased out of NATO nuclear planning. NATO nuclear artillery would be most commonly used, though nuclear SSMs such as the Lance, with its 115-km range, could also be used selectively for strikes on or near the battlefield. A recurring point in sensitive Pact writings is that NATO aircraft would have a negligible nuclear delivery role in limited nuclear operations. The Pact believes that NATO would employ aircraft extensively in this period for conventional operations. Aircraft would assume their dominant role among NATO nuclear delivery systems only with escalation to massed strikes. Targets for NATO limited use. The most likely targets for limited NATO nuclear strikes would be nuclear-capable systems, maneuver units, and com- mand elements. The scale and range of weapons that the Pact believes NATO would use initially would not support effective interdiction of the Soviet second strategic echelon or counterair operations. Although counternuclear operations would also ap- pear to offer poor payoffs, the Pact believes its nuclear-capable systems would be high-priority can- didates for limited NATO nuclear strikes. ¢ Cumulative use. We cannot make a good estimate of what the Pact considers a reasonable upper bound for the total number of limited stri employed in a limited nuclear war (b)(1) (b)(3) N& pproved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 ———(b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct This information is both too old and too isolated to be a reliable guide to Pact thinking. Because most periods of limited nuclear use in Pact exercises are short, generally lasting a few hours to a few days at most before massed strikes are exchanged, it would appear that cumulative levels of limited usage would not be expected to be high. In Pact exercises that include a period of limited nuclear war, only one or two exchanges have appeared. Consistent throughout Pact writings and exercises is the belief that, once nuclear weapons are employed, an escalation of their use will almost certainly follow. The Pact believes that NATO nuclear use on a limited scale would prove ineffective and be quickly recognized as such by NATO leaders. Faced with the threat of defeat from the Pact’s conventional theater offensive, NATO decisionmakers would, in the Pact view, order massed strikes. Fear of Pact preemption and NATO’s need to alter fundamentally the correla- tion of forces in the theater would drive the West’s leaders toward the use of nuclear weapons on a massive scale. Certainly some Pact sources argue that a limited nuclear war could be terminated before escalation to massed strikes occurs. These writers note that several major NATO exercises in the late 1970s witnessed no such escalation, breaking a pattern that had been in place for decades. Still, the majority of Pact writings from the same period have concentrated on the earlier trend in NATO exercises, in which the period of limited nuclear war lasted typically one to three days before massed strikes were launched. NATO exer- cises that did not escalate to massive use represent NATO victories or exercise scenarios that stopped short of decisive operations. In the Pact view, the former are implausible and the latter incomplete. “In past years, 30 km was also the range of the Honest John rocket—a system now used only by Greece for nuclear delivery. See appendix B for Soviet distinctions among systems by range as well as some of the effects of NATO’s INF decision on Pact perceptions. (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct b)(1 (b)(3) NatSecAct 12 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)( (b)( 1) 3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Perceptions of Specific Circumstances for NATO First Use Pact sources state that the timing and form of NATO’s first use will be driven by its assessment of the correlation of forces and particularly by the progress of the conventional campaign. According to Pact military writings NATO might choose to use nuclear weapons, at least theoret- ically, for any of the following reasons © To prevent an impending Pact breakthrough of NATO defensive lines This threat 1s cited in most Pact sources as the dominant motivation for NATO nuclear use 1n defensive operations. ¢ To support a NATO offensive or counteroffensive The Pact often portrays NATO as executing nucle- ar strikes to support combined-arms thrusts into Eastern Europe early in a war or, 1n less favorable circumstances, as conducting nuclear strikes later in a war to support counteroffensives on West German territory To many Pact officers, the ratio of forces 1s so unfavorable that NATO could not undertake an offensive without supporting nuclear strikes to alter the ratio and upset Pact plans and dispositions ¢ To slow (or destroy) Warsaw Pact forces before they reach or can affect the main battle area Pact writings show that Pact theorists believe NATO may use nuclear weapons in its attempt to isolate the battlefield This can take the form of interdiction strikes against critical lines of communication and direct attacks on forces in transit or in assembly areas to delay or prevent their arrival. To prevent the collapse of NATO forces in one or more sectors following a Warsaw Pact break- through NATO 1s described in some sources, for example, as using nuclear strikes to cover its with- drawal from one defense line to another To prevent the loss of key political, economic, or strategic areas In some sources, NATO’s nuclear use 1s intended to stun the Pact and allow NATO time to reorganize its defense 13 “Top Secret— (b)(3) NatSecAct ¢ To demonstrate NATO’s determination to escalate the war u the Warsaw Pact continues to threaten vital NATO interests Political and military writ- ings show that the Pact is well versed in NATO’s debate over nuclear signaling to show resolve but appears to place little credence 1n the likelihood of a purely demonstrative nuclear “shot across the bow ” Pact writers note that NATO would be inhibited from such use by fear that i1t would prompt a preemptive massed nuclear strike by the Pact According to Pact writers, at a minimum such a move by NATO would cause the Pact to take preventive measures that would render follow-on NATO strikes less effective! (b)(3) NatSecAct Each of these reasons could lead to NATO nuclear initiation at different times. In response to this ambig- uous threat, many Pact military writings state that the time of first use 1s indeterminate, and consequent- ly Pact forces must be constantly prepared for it At the operational-tactical level, Pact analysts recognize that the threat 1s not so open-ended Drawing upon their analyses of NATO doctrine, exercises, nuclear decisionmaking structure and process, and defense plans, Pact theorists have refined their estimates of the cause and timing of initial NATO nuclear use into four major cases. ° NATO strikes early and massively Sensitive Pact writings state clearly that scenarios with early mas- sive NATO nuclear strikes represent worst case planning assumptions. The Soviets believe that such assumptions should constitute the basis for plan- ning For example, a recent authoritative writing states “ in preparing the nation and armed forces for war, one must proceed not from a possible favorable confluence of circumstances but rather place the main bet on the extended, fierce, and protracted nature of future military clashes and make all one’s strategic plans precisely proceeding from this ” * Consistent with this approach, the Pact exercised simulated massive NATO strikes on the first day of the war as late as 1979—although initial use that early had not appeared in NATO exercises analyzed by the Pact since 1962 >See M A Gareyev, M V Frunze Military Theorist, JPRS- UMA-85-027-L, 7 November 1985 7. (b)(3) NatSecAct ~Top-Secret (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct e NATO strikes to support its first main defense line. Pact writings state explicitly that NATO might resort to nuclear strikes to prevent a major Pact penetration of the first main defense line. Penetra- tion by substantial Pact forces, especially in the British or Belgian corps sectors, probably would unhinge NATO’s defense of northern Germany in the absence of mobile NATO reserves or prepared and occupied intermediate defense lines. Examples of NATO use in such a situation appear in Pact exercises Zapad-77 and Soyuz-81. NATO strikes to hold its final defense line along the Rhine River. Even if NATO forces were able to maintain a credible conventional defense for several days or even weeks, trading space for time and attrition, Pact planners believe NATO would choose to employ nuclear weapons to prevent loss of the Rhine defense line. This was simulated, for exam- ple, in the Soviet General Staff exercises Center-78 and Center-82 and is mentioned specifically in sensitive Pact writings. No nuclear strikes. Sensitive Pact writings note that war may be terminated before initiation of nuclear employment. A number of Pact exercises in recent years—Zapad-81, Zapad-83, Zapad-84, and Soyuz- 83—have ended before nuclear operations were simulated, although nuclear planning was a con- stant theme. Nonetheless, in most of these exercises and in no case was war termination included in the scenario. Such exercises simulate only specific por- tions of the war and may have played only the conventional phases. |__(b)(3) NatSecAct Scenarios that resemble each of these four major cases are considered plausible by Pact planners, but evidence from a variety of sources suggests that they do not consider the scenarios to be equally likely. We believe the following indicate how the Pact assesses the probability of these scenarios: ¢ No major Pact exercise has simulated the worst case scenario (a surprise, massive NATO nuclear strike —Tan-Sectat— (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 on the first day of the war) for seven years, although it appeared regularly through 1979.6 Especially since 1984, exercises confirm heightened Soviet concern for avoiding the effects of a surprise or sudden attack (see inset). In these exercises, sudden attacks on the first day of the war have been only conventional and have featured hundreds of aircraft, a large portion of which are described as nuclear capable, as well as cruise missiles. Signifi- cantly, even in the face of this threat, Pact forces have never been detected responding with a preemp- tive nuclear strike. A large number of recent major exercises, including Center-78, Center-82, and Soyuz-83, have simulat- ed penetration of NATO’s first main defense line by Pact forces without triggering NATO nuclear use. No major Pact exercise has simulated an advance beyond the Rhine without nuclear initiation by NATO, or by the Pact as a preemptive act. Several of the major nonnuclear Pact exercises end with a suggestion of imminent nuclear use as Pact forces reach and attempt to breach NATO’s defenses along the Rhine River as was the case in Soyuz-83. (b)(3) NatSecAct Pact perceptions of NATO’s nuclear decisionmaking process would contribute to its hope of delaying NATO nuclear initiation. Pact military writings note that the West Germans have preferred the prompt use of tactical nuclear weapons to raise the specter of nuclear escalation quickly and thus preserve as much of their territory as possible. It is probable that the Pact is aware of the British preference for using nuclear weapons quickly to ensure the survival of the British Army on the Rhine (BAOR). Pact planners believe, however, that the United States would be reluctant to begin a nuclear war in Europe and that, 6 Strategic Rocket Forces (SRF) exercises often simulate nuclear operations starting on the first day, after a period of increasing readiness. We do not believe this indicates a Soviet assumption that nuclear weapons would be used on the first day of a war but rather only reflects a concern by the SRF to exercise its own units. (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)( ‘(b)(3) NatSecAct (b)( (b)(3) NatSecAct 1) 1) Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 The Soviet “War Scare’: 1981-85 The Soviet “war scare” of 1981 to 1985 focused on the threat of a surprise or sudden nuclear missile attack on the Soviet Union by the United States, with or without the cooperation of its NATO allies. The Soviets perceived changes in US nuclear capabilities and strategy, illustrated by the deployment of the Pershing II to Europe, as lowering the threshold at which the United States would employ nuclear weap- ons against the Soviet Union. Soviet intelligence was tasked to observe and report on civil and military indicators that would signal preparations for or a decision to launch an attack. (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct nor to what degree it represented a real fear imminent nuclear war. It is entirely possible, that military leaders created and promoted the “war scare,” driven by their worst case assessments of current and projected Western capabilities. (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Before 1981 a clear distinction was made between an attack within the context of a crisis and one outside it. The former was viewed as a plausible if unlikely threat by Soviet intelligence. The latter has been described unequivocally in the past as implausible. Pact exercises have never to our knowledge simulated a “bolt-from-the-blue”’ nu- clear attack by NATO. However, during 1981-85 a NATO nuclear attack outside the context of a crisis was considered credible and worthy of major re- source commitment. We do not know to what extent the “war scare” was created or used by different elements of the Soviet national security apparatus to further their own ends, (b)(3) NatSecAct Beginning in 1984 the “war scare” started to wither. The factors that contributed to its decline are uncer- tain but probably included: * A realization that the threat was not as great as initially feared. © The death in February 1984 of Yuriy Andropov, who may have been one of its early promoters. © The increased concern about US technological ad- vances, especially as applied to new weapons, and the consequent possibility of drastic changes in the correlation of forces in the future. (b)(3) NatSecAct ultimately, the President, not the Europeans, would control NATO’s nuclear decisionmaking process. The threat of escalation to massive use and strikes on US territory would, in the Pact view, strongly argue against American nuclear release(b)(3) NatSecAct On the basis of our evidence and analysis of how the Pact perceives NATO nuclear decisionmaking, doc- trine, and defense plans, we judge that the Pact and, specifically, the Soviet military believe that: e An early, massive NATO nuclear strike is unlikely. e NATO’s decision to use nuclear weapons would be driven by the progress of the campaign in Central Europe and US preferences for timing of escalation 15 to nuclear war. Although first use may occur in one of the peripheral theaters, as simulated in a major Pact exercise in 1978, use in Central Europe would occur at the same time or follow rapidly. e They have some chance of penetrating NATO’s first and intermediate main defense lines without trig- gering NATO nuclear strikes. e There is little if any chance that NATO decision- makers would forgo nuclear use to hold positions along the Rhine. "Top-Secret— (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 e NATO’s initial nuclear use would probably be limited (though not purely demonstrative), ineffec- tive, and would escalate to large-scale use quickly. e There is a small chance that a war would end without the use of nuclear weapons or before it could escalate from limited to massed use. |__(b)(3) NatSecAct_| Implications for Soviet Planning and Doctrine The preservation of the Soviet state is the preeminent objective and constraint of Soviet security policy. To this end, Soviet leaders want to limit the damage to the USSR in any future conflict. They believe that any use of nuclear weapons in Europe would increase the likelihood of nuclear attacks on the Soviet home- land, as well as the uncertainties inherent in a major war. The Soviets are taking costly steps to increase their capabilities to wage a successful conventional campaign in Central Europe should war come about and to increase the likelihood that a war could be won without escalation to nuclear use(b)(3) NatSecAct Soviet theorists recognize that their nuclear doctrine and NATO’s nuclear doctrine as they understand it lead to a paradox. They see the very success of Pact conventional forces as likely to trigger NATO nuclear strikes to stave off rapid defeat, threatening the Pact with unacceptable costs. They also believe that initial limited NATO nuclear strikes would prove ineffec- tive, motivating NATO to launch larger strikes. Sovi- et nuclear doctrine, however, calls for launching preemptive massed nuclear strikes once it is detected that NATO intends to use nuclear weapons on a large scale. Thus, Pact theater successes could lead directly to what the Soviets see as the catastrophe of general nuclear war.|_ ——_(b)(3) NatSecAct The foremost implication of this paradox for Soviet planning is that whatever the Soviet preference for conventional over nuclear war, Pact combat forces, their supporting structure, and elements crucial to the survival and functioning of the Soviet state must be configured and employed for eventual NATO nuclear use on a massive scale. Reconstitution of these assets following massive NATO nuclear strikes is a constant theme in Pact exercises and sensitive writings, and the Soviets’ initiatives and investments confirm their be- lief in this requirement (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) Mpproved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Soviet planners, however, appear to believe that NATO is not structured to fight a nuclear war effectively and that it does not possess the will and means to win. The Soviets believe NATO leaders would realize that a massive nuclear strike would guarantee terrible retaliation and deny NATO vic- tory. Consequently, the Soviets probably believe NATO?’s ultimate capability is, for NATO, a means of deterrence and, failing that, paces and denial. The Soviets have undertaken and will continue to pursue initiatives to weaken NATO’s will and capa- bility to use nuclear weapons in a war. Peacetime initiatives include arms control agreements that would eliminate portions of NATO’s nuclear capabilities and promotion and support of Western antinuclear movements to hamper NATO deployment and mod- ernization efforts. The Soviets are exploring means to postpone, limit, or ideally avert NATO’s first use of nuclear weapons. The Soviets hope to take full advantage of periods of conventional and limited nuclear use to blunt NATO’s nuclear forces and exploit the Pact’s conven- tional superiority. These efforts do not indicate that the Soviets have renounced massed strikes or preemp- tion or that they believe they can unilaterally control nuclear initiation or escalation. Rather, this approach demonstrates pragmatic consideration of other less threatening scenarios In war, the Soviets plan to: ¢ Monitor the nuclear activities of NATO to warn of its readiness and preparations for imminent use and to provide targeting data for conventional and nu- clear strikes against NATO’s weapons and com- mand and control systems.® (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(1) (b)(3) iain ® See DI Research Paper SOV 85-10107CX (Top Secret June 1985, Warsaw Pact Tacti ces: Capabilities and Readiness for Nuclear War, (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct 16 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct | (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 ¢ Attack NATO’s nuclear forces, including com- mand, control, communications, and intelligence support, with conventional as well as improved conventional munitions.’ Provide disincentives for Western nuclear use by closing rapidly with NATO forces to complicate NATO targeting, operating on NATO territory to increase the collateral costs of NATO use, and engaging in costly engineering efforts to protect forces from the full effects of nuclear attacks. For example, six hours of preparatory engineering work is expected to reduce troop losses by one-half to two- thirds. Strike NATO nuclear systems preemptively with a massed nuclear attack if large-scale NATO nuclear use is believed imminent or unavoidable.” In the event of limited NATO nuclear strikes—or the conviction that imminent NATO strikes would be limited—Soviet leaders might forgo launching massed nuclear strikes to prolong the period of war dominated by their own superior conventional arms. We believe these circumstances could arise if Soviet leaders expected their objectives could be achieved without extensive nuclear fire support and were confident that NATO could not or would not massively employ nuclear weapons in the immediate future. Under such restrictive and indeed unlikely conditions, the Soviets could respond to limited NATO nuclear use with their own limited nuclear strikes or forgo nuclear use _ entirely. By the combination of measures noted above, retaliatory threats, and demonstrating the futility of NATO nuclear use, Soviet strategists hope to resolve the paradox that their own conventional superiority has generated.| _(b)(3) NatSecAct * See TY Intelligence Assessment SOV 85-10001CX (Top Secret January 1985, Warsaw Pact Air Forces: Support of Strategic Operations in Central Europe (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct —Fop-Secret____ (b)(3) Still, on the basis of their perceptions of the probabili- ty of NATO nuclear use and the requirement to launch a preemptive massed strike when so ordered by the Supreme High Command, Soviet planners must make force employment decisions that affect conven- tional operations and the transition to nuclear war. Their practices, exercises, and writings reveal their concerns that: ¢ Nuclear strike units cannot be kept at high states of readiness over extended periods without suffering degradation. In their exercises, Pact commanders regularly maintain only a portion of devoted nuclear strike assets at the highest levels of readiness—even after conventional combat begins—until escalation to nuclear warfare is considered imminent. In a 1985 exercise, for example, front nuclear weapons storage authorities and missile forces were ordered to mate nuclear warheads to missiles only after three days of conventional war. There was an apparent appreciation that keeping nuclear forces “cocked” over an extended period would lower their true readiness—their ability to carry out their mis- sion effectively in a timely manner. This would be critical in the event of protracted conventional operations prior to nuclear initiation, a contingency increasingly simulated in Pact exercises. Dual-purpose forces withheld for contingent nuclear use weaken conventional firepower. Aircraft with- held for contingent nuclear use, as well as tactical missile forces and artillery, deprive Soviet com- manders of longer range heavy firepower. Recent exercises show an increased willingness to use, for example, tactical missiles with conventional war- heads during the early stages of a war. Nuclear warheads would be available to mate with reloads when nuclear war becomes more likely. Soviet commanders in exercises vary the percentage of dual-capable aircraft withheld for nuclear alert and their degree of readiness based on assessments of the likelihood of nuclear initiation. (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct 17 (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 NatSecAct NatSecAct (b)(3) Napproved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 LWIOUFAYVL (b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct The attrition of dual-capable aircraft and SSMs during conventional operations would increase the percentages withheld for nuclear contingencies. ¢ Reconnaissance would be overstretched throughout a war, and the priority task of monitoring NATO's nuclear forces would draw down resources initially intended to support conventional operations. Pact writings demonstrate concern over a shortfall in reconnaissance capabilities because of the number, character, and dispersal of targets that must be covered. Reconnaissance aircraft tasked to search out NATO SSMs to update contingency plans for the initial massed nuclear strike would suffer signif- icant attrition. Other assets would almost certainly be drawn off to support this priority task, leaving fewer reconnaissance assets to support conventional operations. (b)(3) NatSecAct Soviet planners and commanders explicitly trade off capabilities that support conventional operations for those that support the transition to nuclear war. When NATO nuclear initiation is seen as increasingly likely, Soviet planners intend to shift resources to support the transition to nuclear operations, most probably by increasing the ability to launch a preemptive massed strike. Soviet commanders almost certainly would strive for maximum readiness in theater and possibly strategic nuclear systems as they attempt to breach NATO?’s first main defense line and when they ap- proach and attack the Rhine. Ironically, resources shifted to prepare for nuclear operations would be most sorely needed by field commanders conducting the conventional campaign precisely at those times they are shifted. (b)(3) NatSecAct We believe that the Soviet threshold for nuclear preemption would be lowered significantly at these critical points because of: ¢ Confusion and ambiguity in detecting a NATO decision to launch a nuclear strike. ¢ Perceptions that NATO plans and prepares for nuclear initiation at such times. ¢ Predictions of vulnerability to a massive NATO nuclear strike. (b)(3) NatSecAct “Tam-Secret _ 18 (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Appendix A Soviet Definitions of Nuclear Use Warsaw Pact writings are confusing and appear contradictory to Western readers, in part because Pact writers think and write about NATO doctrine ‘and practices using, for the most part, terms and concepts native to Soviet military theory. Soviet terms and concepts of nuclear employment are presented below as a reference and to provide insight as to how they approach NATO nuclear emnlovment." (b)(3) NatSecAct—_ Single, Group, and Massed Strikes According to the Soviets, nuclear weapons can be employed in the form of single, group, and massed nuclear strikes. They define ” these as: ¢ Single nuclear strike—‘A strike delivered against an objective with one nuclear weapon. It is used in those cases when the yield of a nuclear weapon ensures that the required damage will be inflicted on the target.” Group nuclear strikes—‘Strikes delivered simulta- neously by means of several nuclear devices. A group [or ‘grouped’] nuclear strike is used when the desired degree of damage to the target cannot be achieved with a single nuclear device or when the situation precludes the use of a single, more power- ful nuclear device.” Massed nuclear strike—“A strike made by a large number of nuclear munitions, delivered simulta- neously or in quick succession. The purpose of a massed nuclear strike is to annihilate enemy means of nuclear attack that have been spotted, to inflict damage on the main enemy troop groupings, and to disorganize the enemy rear areas, his economy, troop control, and state administration.” Massed nuclear strikes (also occasionally referred to as (b)(3) NatSecAct " For more details on Soviet nuclear doctrine, see the Intelligence Assessment referenced in footnote 10 " These definitions are taken from the Soviet Dictionary of Basic Military Terms, which is translated under the auspices of the US Air Force. They are consistent with definitions found in the Military Encyclopedic Dictionary, the Soviet Military Encyclope- dia, and sensitive Pact military writings, (b)(3) NatSecAct 19 FonSeeret- (b)(3) NatSecAct “mass” or “massive” strikes) are composed of many single and ania el out against different targets, ' (b)(3) NatSecAct General Versus Limited Nuclear War The Soviets also differentiate between general nuclear 7 war and /Jimited nuclear war. The former entails the unlimited use of nuclear weapons and includes inter- continental strikes. The latter is restricted to a given geographic area and can vary in scope and intensity. It may feature small- or large-scale use of nuclear weapons throughout an entire theater or in part of it. (b)(3) NatSecAct The Soviets’ commentaries on and descriptions of limited nuclear war offer tantalizingly incomplete insights into their thinking about an area that has dominated Western debate off and on for years. Evidence in Pact writings and exercises from the late 1960s and early 1970s indicates that the limited nuclear option was controversial and generated con- siderable debate. Although a consensus was reached by the mid-1970s, Soviet views might undergo further debate and evolution:as a result of NATO INF deployments (see appendix B), evolving improved con- ventional munitions, and other changes in factors that influence Soviet nuclear doctrine. We have not seen further debate or evolution to date. (b)(3) NatSecAct The consensus Soviet view of limited nuclear war holds that, if it occurs at all, it will be brief and lead with near certainty to general nuclear war. Its basic instability results from the potentially decisive advan- tages that would accrue to the side that launches massed nuclear strikes first. Pact writers note that both sides would enhance the readiness of their nuclear forces in a crisis and during the conventional period of war and that indications of likely nuclear use by an opponent would be delayed, limited, uncer- tain, and contradictory. Hence, both sides would be trigger happy and prone to launch preemptive massed strikes to limit the damage they might otherwise (b)(3) suffer NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 (b)(3) NatSecAct The consensus Soviet view holds that limited nuclear war is self-contradictory as well. By definition, in limited nuclear war limited means are employed to achieve limited objectives. The result is that it be- comes more difficult to achieve those objectives quick- ly, raising the risk of eventual escalation. Further- more, the defeated side can always choose to escalate to general nuclear war rather than accept defeat. The “diplomatic” aspect of limited nuclear war—threat- ening one’s opponent with escalation to more destruc- tive levels—is seen as essentially a denial of the limited character of limited nuclear war. (b)(3) NatSecAct Finally, some Soviet sources note that NATO believes limited nuclear war implies a need for negotiations, perhaps conducted during pauses in the fighting, to bring about its end. This contradicts the consistent Soviet line that war between NATO and the Pact would be the decisive armed conflict between the opposing capitalist and socialist camps and fought at a rapid tempo for decisive rather than finely negotiated ends. (b)(3) NatSecAct We detect an additional, complementary view in the Soviets’ sensitive writings and exercises that holds that limited nuclear war may be forced upon them but could offer significant advantages over general nucle- ar war. Massive nuclear strikes against the Soviet homeland are seen as the greatest political and mili- tary threat presented by NATO. Consequently, limit- ed nuclear war could offer the possibility of excluding homeland exchanges between the United States and the USSR. —_(b)(3) NatSecAct None of the writings associated with this view advo- cate it as a choice among various options. They only imply a willingness to consider a possible situation that may be pressed upon the Pact in a conflict and to explore its implications. Pact exercises that include a period of limited nuclear war help train commands and staffs to operate within the constraints of such a war and probably have a major effect upon the Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Massed Versus Limited or Selective Strikes Soviet writings and exercises distinguish between massed strikes and limited or selective nuclear strikes. Massed strikes are consistent with general rather than limited war. Although, in theory, massed strikes could be restricted to non-Soviet Europe, Soviet writers are pessimistic about exchanging massed strikes with NATO while avoiding strikes on the USSR. (b)(3) NatSecAct: We believe that the Soviets have adopted NATO’s terms for limited (ogranichenniy) nuclear strikes and selective use (vyborochnoye primeneniye) without de- fining them precisely. Single and group strikes are operational military terms that focus on weapon allocation for different target clusters. They do not account for the political dimension of limited or selective strikes—the need to signal the limited inten- tions of nuclear use—while still achieving military effect. — (b)(3) NatSecAct Soviet writings enumerate and discuss NATO’s de- limitations for limited or selective nuclear strikes— including types and locations of targets and numbers, yields, and types of warheads—but do not appear to have adopted them. Sensitive Soviet writings dating from 1970 indicate that the Soviets may restrict their use of delivery systems to those under a 1,000-km range in a limited nuclear war. Several sources explic- itly equate the use of longer range systems ~ith general nuclear war, (b)(1) | (b)(3) NatSecAct are not as explicit about what constraints might be applied to Pact limited or selective nuclear use. The Soviets applied these descriptors to their simulated strikes in a 1978 exercise in which 16 nuclear weapons were used, and in a 1981 exercise in which at least five weapons were used. ______(b)(1) (b)(3) NatSecAct——___, Limited evolution of Soviet doctrine in this area (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct strikes would probably be directed against forces in the field, command posts, and supporting elements— especially those that would support nuclear opera- tions. (b)(3) NatSecAct 20 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476' : Appendix B | NATO’s INF and Pact ' Military Perceptions NATO decisions in 1978 and 1979 have affected Warsaw Pact military perceptions. The planned de- ployment of 108 Pershing II SSMs and 464 ground- launched cruise missiles (GLCMs)—the NATO Intermediate-Range Nuclear Force (INF)—is cor- rectly seen by the Pact as central to NATO’s long- term plan to modernize its theater nuclear capabili- ties. Pact military planners quickly focused on the potential threat posed by these systems and began taking steps to familiarize Pact officers with the nature of the threat and methods to counter it vears_ before the weapons were fielded, (b)(3) NatSecAct Pact military writings note that INF demands espe- cially vigorous countermeasures because: e INF represents a significant growth in the total numbers of forward-based nuclear systems available to NATO in the European theater of war. e The Pershing II can deliver nuclear strikes to a strategic depth within seven to eight minutes of launch. The proportion ‘of SSMs is expected to grow to more than 40 percent of NATO’s theater nuclear capabil- ity, assuring NATO of more rapid and certain strike capabilities. The Pershing II is assessed to be virtually immune to interception after launch. Although the GLCM is potentially more vulnerable to in-flight interception, it has a small radar cross section and thermal image, is capable of flying at very low altitudes, can be employed in massed attacks to saturate defending forces, and can be directed to fly toward its target from different directions. The widespread geographic distribution of theater nuclear capabilities from England to Sicily will make detection of launch preparations, disruption by conventional strikes, and nuclear preemption extremely difficult. / Reverse Blank 21 “Top Settret— (b)(3) NatSecAct e The accuracy of the Pershing II and the GLCM are assessed at approximately 30 meters. e The warhead on the Pershing II is capable of penetrating underground before exploding, thus threatening hardened positions. (b)(3) NatSecAct Although Pact planners have noted that INF in- creases NATO’s capability to carry out selective nuclear strikes, they have concentrated upon the threat it poses as a means of conducting a massive disarming first strike. A massive NATO strike could employ: e The Pershing II to destroy Soviet command and control by “decapitating” the Soviet leadership in a crisis before they could enter deep underground shelters. ¢ The Pershing II, GLCM, and aircraft to strike into the Pact’s strategic and operational-strategic depth. e The Pershing Ia, Lance, Pluton, and aircraft to attack the Pact’s operational-tactical depth. ¢ The Honest John and artillery to attack the Pact’s tactical depth. (b)(3) NatSecAct In Pact worst case planning, INF appears to give NATO’s forward-based systems not merely devastat- ing theater nuclear ‘capabilities, but even strategic, potentially war-winning capabilities. Pact strategists State that, because the gap between theater and strategic nuclear capabilities has narrowed, the gap between theater nuclear war and strategic nuclear war has narrowed. Recent authoritative evidence indi- cates that the Pact has interpreted NATO’s enhanced theater nuclear capabilities as providing an additional incentive to launch a preemptive massed nuclear strike when NATO nuciest use is assessed as immi- nent, (b)(3) NatSecAct (b)(3) NatSecAct Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476 Approved for Release: 2024/10/18 C06568476