least detailed, do not make such claims: LS STI AS PNT SERRA BOTT saacueIs ess Ee e+ anenanmemec Bs A TN popie for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172 MEMORANDUM FOR: MEMORANDUM FOR: David B. Low ; of ae NIO/AL 4 é | C. LG FROM: Chairman, DCI BCW-Toxin Working Group SUBJECT: Washington Post Outlook Article by Saul Hormats "One Expert Doubts...", 26 Feb 84 1. Hormats repeats a number of statements often found in recent "negative" stories on Yellow Rain. The thrust of the statements is that the State Department case for violations of Arms Control Treaties or Agreements in BCW Matters rests on interviews with refugees. He states that based on these reports "several hundred combinations of agents and delivery systems seem to have been used." He then concludes that since U.S. weapons are not like those reported in Southeast Asia, and since the best evidence put forth by the U.S. State Department consists of “moldy twigs, leaves, and rock scrapings" that "Congress has been misled." 2. The State Department utterances, even the briefest and o Refugee reports are actually given as reasons to inves- tigate alleged CW use, never as evidence alone. o Sample data includes blood, urine, autopsy tissue, gas masks, and controls. There are several dozen positive samples reported. Key samples, e.g., autopsy tissue or gas masks have been tested in two or three independent laboratories. o Analysis of all data has led the Department of the Army to conclude that a very limited number of kinds of weapons have been used, not hundreds. o Congress has based its judgment on much more than refu- gee reports and State Department Unclassified White Papers...Three special National Intelligence Estimates, and internal/finished intelligence papers by over a dozen analysts in every NFIB Agency...plus at least one ADMINIS NLY Approved for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172 arena or SE TR ~xApproved for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172 * CNR AM RINT II Y SUBJECT: Washington Post Outlook Article by Saul Hormats "One Expert Doubts...", 26 Feb 84 hundred classified briefings of (especially) non-"scientific" intelligence data. 3. The arithmetic the author uses to conclude that "8,000 tons ‘of bombs dropped from the air" would have to be a tremendous logistical problem"! is based on the assumption that Fusarium : concept of how chemical/biological Material is produced...i.e., by growth, from organisms like fungi to be Sure, but then sepa- rated, filtered, extracted, freeze dried in some cases, to tock. Raw growth medium plus original organisms are hardly weap- ons themselves, Similarly, preparations of antibotics which uti- lize exactly the same methods end up being effective in gram quantities...not pounds or tons. An independent study by the National Academy of Sciences Supported the government's conten- tions about mycotoxin effects on humans, and low dose require- ments in animals and humans to cause severe blistering and even death...with tissue half-lives of three weeks, not three days. 4. The errors the author makes in military CW tactics are obvious even to myself, a non-Cy, non-military officer. The Chem- ical Research and Development Center at Edgewood, Maryland is preparing a detailed point-by-point rebuttal. Similarly, a CW 3. One true statement in the article is "Evidence of chemi- cal or biological attack is unmistakable to an experienced observer." The drafters and contributors of the SNIEs and the State Department White Papers included: ° o About a half-dozen military officers with Army Chemical Corps Specialty certifications. o About one dozen Intelligence Officers who are full-time Specialists in Soviet cw R&D, Doctrine, and Special Intelligence ~ ADMINTSTRAPEVE—USE-ONLY. 2 Approved for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172 Approved for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172 ——BREMENTESFRAFEVE—USE—ONLY - SUBJECT: Washington Post Outlook Article by Saul Hormats "One Expert Doubts...", 26 Feb 84 o An Army medical team trained in CW-injuries, epidemiol- ogy, and tropical~refugee medicine who visited the field and examined many dozens of victims. o Army civilian and military CW bench scientists from Edgewood Chemical Systems Laboratory, Ft. Detrick, Maryland, the Armed Forces Medical Intelligence Com- mand, FSTC, and FTD. 6. The National Estimates were very heavily reviewed prior to publication. And the material was briefed to about one hundred scientists from whom critical comments were solicited. The groups included The Defense Science Board, the JASONS, the Presi- dent's Science Advisor and Technical Staff, and others. The most technical material was reviewed by outside chemists, physicians and toxicologists from Columbia School of Medicine, University of Minnesota, University of Texas, University of Tennessee, Rutgers University, National Academy of Sciences, University of Pennsyl- vania, California Institute of Technology, Rockefeller Univer- sity, MIT, CARGILL, and more. A_ selected subgroup of these sci- entists with cadevord clearances reviewed the papers_line-by-tine pero _to pubs ication. Each comment and suggestion they had (with no-éxception) was ‘included in the final publication.. The impli- cation by the author of the Outlook article (and others) that specialized technical review did not occur, or that scientists in the Intelligence Community expressed "doubts" in the major con- clusions given to State is incorrect. ——ADMINTS TRATIVEBSE—ON DS Approved for Release: 2015/01/05 C06158172