FY a " Soap a fae aha gt SBE pes a eld See ae orale 9 : © .2 we a . Tabetlgew © Vda NO Oy pre x ee es INTELLIGENCE IN RECENT PUBLIC LITE ATURE Sen aa : * fall yt Pe cae ata lee an. coe Bee M Traitors THE NEW MEANING OF TREASON Pay Reberca West (New York: Viking. luGa S04 pp. 3659) TREASON IN THE TWENTIFSIECENTLBRY By Vursaret boven Translated from the Geoman (Plembery Dee bv fo rathan Steun bor * Now York Go Po Putman's Suns bee of pp $00) These ten books cover roughly the sam, subye.¢ matter-—treason and espionage in Work) War Ti and the postwar period Beth are thoughttal and scholarly and obviously required a great deal of re search, whagh on the whole appears fo have been mat careful dome Both tev through detailed und extensive amavses of fpiscctes thas class as treachery to evalye a thesis of phifo wchis od comeepits whi have eeneral apple ation, and here Dhetese beth fal In her carter Deck on Phe Meanie of frecson pbk Miss West presented a good deal ef the same maternal bot came to a quite diiber- ent qcomlesen dn eclfet, she san that the beth ee lonrient of modern cralizaten unpairs the relitoodiip between Phe qitzen and the stute and that lovalty to country is ono denser the sanpleoarel + . ® F ar 1 + Pas 4 t Boek ce Riese padaera ae Quine wears, a eVey eI grey A AGT ee a ne see ree beprees wee oer ' discussion of Welsam jovee, Che wartune Bord Haw Thos ot Barto Bertin. and acd rnore recent cases, motibey these ara eaangd Berto and Maclean, Vassall, Abel the Movenbergs and fr fimo. hee ¢ partaular emphasis on the security aspects, and she canechudes that Of See in taday’s world there wa pervasive and (xpatchrg espronage ediort ae ‘rhe rac, met by an cqnally w iheepread and expanideag sortie re: pranage ¢ tfort " me a4 era While recogniging the natanal nced far secaritw. she dhacihy at gore a x Dit fue poe length onthe dangers that security and countersecurity activity poees c a Sy See to our secretes and warms us te balance secunty require dents wath a eae vos o determination to preserve oar hibertics. oe oahge ae. a The Gesman author, Mis Boveri, argues a change tn the nase of fa : = ao loyalties since the days of feudalnm peantang ent that wath the . 5 - reat French Bevoletion the sinsple alleges CBvascauhte bend began ts ri te * Sf if hreak down and be replaced hy the ae ce Caiepel ated obligations et. ¥ PE of a citusrn an the dew doping dimeacrate states, AS an Crample fal Recent Books: Traitors the feudal practice she notes the soldier's oath required by the King of Prussia as Lite as S31 Clearly inconsistent with this thes is her own observation that the oath of personal loyalty which Hitter required of all German officers was one of the main inhibitions co their active participation im the 20 July PH plot azains. him In developing her thesis Miss Bovers uses a remarkable collection of examples. One af the fist ‘s Vidkun Quishng. who incidentally bears a strong resem lunce to William Joyce. He ws followed by such figures as King Leopold of Belgium, Marshal Petatn, Ad.oual Derlan, and Laval she them mises in fosce, Evra Pound, Tekya Rose, and Knut Harmen) Next she treats at Jength the oppositen to Ebter by the various German groups from the old conservatives Ihe General Beck throuch the carious combination of people imoalved an “Hote Kapelle” and on to Stauffeobere Finatly she mestons rather bricty such cases as those of Rudolf Roster (the “Lucy” of Alexander Foote’s net} and Otte John. She claims bo be able to see a common thread running through al these diverse types, but T find the argument unconvincing [tots difficult ta see the tie between a despicable Wiliam Josce aud Stanflenberg. or between the patriot Rosser and Evra Pound Mae generally, esmonage cases hhe that of Colonacl Abel cannot be clissed as treason, The detaded studies of all these people in both berks seem to me to be not susceptible of the authors ucernetatians but rother te lead tg the canclucon that ‘ The wrong womeeedd Fa traci bfe, Cad vest, Noon ne fae! Passens spin the plot We are betrayed by whatas Pilse wethon # Another book on Lord Haw-Haw appeared in 1964, writte. by J. A. cole? It covers the same ground Miss West did and expands particularly on Joyce's activities in Germany and his personal hfe (Curtousiy, it does not credit or even refer to her work, athou la some of its passages are so Fike hers as to sugeest famuhanty with it) Is William Joyce worth all this effort? Porhups the Brtwh, on whem his beoadeatts had such an impact during the war, fad the subject fascinating, but for me, well written as these books are, they do not taake aomayor figere out of hum, Both authors show a surprising *Cearge Meredith, Modera Lave, XLHUE *Landd Hau daw and Wrlham Joyce The Full Story (New York Farrar, Straus & Crocus. $4.3.) 1. ' ‘ wee esta, a fetree A SO TE I a ane es ra Re chee SET. Tea any ons ‘ a “4 . els BT id mh Recent Books: Traitors aes aA ses . oe pares 3 vo! Se ‘ “7 ey sympathy for there antyberg, whese behasier manifested few pede Sig tise = ae fog boatures except a certain amount od cough cunatage arcs pervade “yt w , oe ag soutumontelity whout Enehuna as " 2 cs a a, a Lawrence Tl Ebsustos + “ Lg Rare + + * ‘ele “pee Ayts * ee Be 0 eS 3 . =e af = » se i tea 4 - y . i om be ay rae ait x ia et a tat a. ae; oF ae % shed Bye ia Wis ra Aue ELEN