Kinematic enhancement for nucleon interpolators Preprint: MIT-CTP/6044 Daniel Reitinger, Tobias Sizmann, Andreas Schäfer, Rui Zhang, Yong Zhao Abstract The reliable treatment of highly boosted hadrons is crucial for many lattice QCD applications. For all these cases the kinematically-enhanced interpolators advocated in 79 promise very significant improvements and are, therefore, ever more often used in recent calculations, especially for highly boosted mesons like the pion. Motivated by, e.g., the physics program of the future Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) in the US and Electron-Ion collider in China (EIcC), we systematically benchmark our code for the unpolarized isovector nucleon quark matrix elements extracted at large source-sink separations, where excited state artifacts are significantly suppressed. We find that the precision of the renormalized nucleon matrix elements is typically improved by an order of magnitude at momentum P z ∼ 2.5 P_{z}\sim 2.5 GeV. By comparing the results from three CLS ensembles with different lattice spacings a a but the same pion mass, we observe no statistically significant dependence on a a in the renormalized matrix elements at nearly identical values of P z P_{z} . These encouraging results suggest that the use of kinematically improved operators is highly advantageous for parton physics calculations and can be extended to a broader class of baryon observables, making them a promising candidate for a standard component of modern lattice QCD. 1 Introduction In recent years several methods 63 ; 31 ; 15 ; 29 ; 52 ; 70 ; 64 ; 19 ; 72 have been proposed and widely applied to extract far more information on the partonic structure of hadrons from lattice simulations than was judged possible before. To a large extent, this effort is motivated by new and more powerful and versatile accelerator facilities like JLab, LHC, EIC, and EIcC. We do not attempt to provide a comprehensive overview of these experimental and theoretical efforts, for which substantial review literature already exists, such as Refs. 8 ; 18 ; 7 ; 14 ; 4 ; 3 ; 27 ; 50 . However, we emphasize the importance of achieving good signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) in order to fully exploit the significantly broadened spectrum of physical effects. Many proposed theoretical approaches require highly boosted hadrons to access the full kinematic information of parton distributions, including Large Momentum Effective Theory (LaMET) 52 ; 53 ; 50 , pseudo-distributions 70 , current-current correlators 15 ; 64 ; 78 , and hadronic tensor 63 or Compton amplitudes 31 ; 19 . Highly boosted hadrons are also crucial for studying form factors at large momentum transfer 32 , heavy-meson and baryon decays 1 ; 2 , and many other physical processes. With this in mind, we focus on LaMET, the most widely used framework for parton physics calculations so far 23 ; 82 ; 60 ; 27 ; 26 ; 50 ; 24 ; 84 ; 61 ; 6 , as we expect our conclusions to remain qualitatively applicable to other methods and physical problems. LaMET relies crucially on an expansion of spatial quasi-observables around the limit P_{z}\to\infty to calculate the x -dependence of corresponding light-cone partonic observables 55 ; 54 ; 56 , including the parton distribution functions (PDFs), Generalized Parton Distributions, Transverse Momentum Distributions, and Wigner distributions. Taking this limit is, however, highly nontrivial due to the rapidly deteriorating SNRs of hadronic observables with increasing P_{z} . For the nucleon, the experimentally most relevant hadron, this typically makes it difficult to reach momenta beyond P_{z}=3 GeV on contemporary lattice ensembles. This precision bottleneck also affects the calculation of quasi-distributions through the Fourier transformation of nonlocal hadronic matrix elements, a topic that has attracted considerable recent discussion 35 ; 75 ; 22 ; 62 ; 66 ; 49 . Ref. 79 introduced a methodological improvement that enhances the SNRs of highly boosted hadrons on the lattice, which has been applied to recent calculations 13 ; 10 ; 30 ; 20 ; 74 ; 81 ; 36 . While these publications primarily presented results for two-point functions and effective energies, we investigate the improvement for nucleon quasi-distribution matrix elements. We implement, optimize, and fine-tune the algorithms for CLS ensembles, the physics program of the Lattice Parton Collaboration (LPC), and GPU architectures. To quantify the improvement, we compute matrix elements of the unpolarized isovector nucleon quark quasi-parton distribution function (quasi-PDF) in a gauge-invariant formulation. We furthermore investigate the results for possible increased excited-state overlap as well as discretization and cutoff artifacts. To this end, we make a direct comparison of quasi-PDF matrix elements obtained using conventional and kinematically enhanced interpolators at different lattice spacings at similar momenta. Our results indicate that the improved interpolators enhance the statistical precision of boosted nucleon matrix elements at P_{z}\sim 2.5 GeV by more than an order of magnitude, suggesting that significantly more ambitious simulations should be feasible. This significant improvement is also partly due to the projector \gamma_{+} contained in the enhanced interpolator, which yields an additional factor-of-four reduction in variance. One factor of two arises from combining the information contained in the \gamma_{t} and \gamma_{z} matrix elements, while the other originates from \gamma_{+} eliminating all “ - ”-components of the propagators, thereby reducing the computational cost of their evaluation. Besides, the quasi-PDF matrix elements renormalized in the hybrid scheme 48 exhibit a well-behaved continuum limit, indicating that the discretization effects remain small even at momenta as large as P_{z}\sim 2.5 GeV. Finally, we also observe that the SNR enhancement increases with finer lattice spacing. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we review the theory of enhanced interpolators and outline the basics of PDF calculations within LaMET. Section 3 presents the lattice setup used in our simulations, while Section 4 contains our numerical results, demonstrating that kinematically enhanced interpolators are highly efficient for nucleons. Finally, we conclude in Section 5 . 2 Theory 2.1 Kinematic enhancement In lattice QCD, the hadrons are simulated with interpolating operators built from the quark and gluon degrees of freedom, i.e., Fock states constructed of quark and gluon fields. A symmetric two-point correlation function admits a spectral decomposition, \displaystyle C_{\rm 2pt}(t)=\langle\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(t)\mathcal{J}(0)\rangle=\sum_{i}\frac{|Z_{i}|^{2}}{2E_{i}}e^{-E_{i}t}, (1) where the overlap factor Z_{i}=\langle i|\mathcal{J}|\Omega\rangle depends on the wave function of the hadron |i\rangle projected onto the corresponding Fock state \mathcal{J}|\Omega\rangle . To have non-vanishing overlap, the interpolating operator \mathcal{J} must have the same quantum numbers and transform in the same irreducible representation as the physical state |i\rangle . In a boosted system, the lattice symmetry group is reduced from the cubic group O_{h}^{D} ( O_{h} ) to the little group {\rm Dic}_{4} ( C_{4v} ) corresponding to the 4-fold rotation around the longitudinal direction 1 1 1 Note that the little group will be different if the hadron’s momentum is not pointing in direction of an axis, but this does not affect the following discussion. . Thus the hadron has non-vanishing overlaps with a larger set of Fock states. Among them, the leading component at large momentum, or near the lightcone, is described by the leading-twist wave function of the hadron 17 ; 47 . This is related to the fact that the “ + ” component \psi_{+}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\gamma_{-}\gamma_{+}\psi is the only dynamic degree of freedom on the lightcone. Here \gamma_{\pm}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\gamma^{M}_{t}\mp\gamma^{M}_{z}) (assuming the hadron is moving in the \hat{z} direction) in Minkowski spacetime, which is related to the Euclidean definition through \gamma_{4}=\gamma^{M}_{t} and \gamma_{\{1,2,3\}}=\mathbf{i}\gamma^{M}_{\{x,y,z\}} . On a Euclidean lattice, although the lightcone does not exist, the “ + ” components still dominate at large but finite momentum in the form of a kinematical enhancement 79 . For a leading-twist interpolator J_{+} constructed with n “ + ”-component quarks, the overlap with the hadron H(P) moving at momentum P is kinematically enhanced as, \displaystyle\langle 0|{\mathcal{J}_{+}}|H({P})\rangle\propto P_{+}^{n/2}, (2) where P_{+}=(E+P_{z})/\sqrt{2} . As a result, the amplitude of the corresponding two-point correlation function is enhanced as \displaystyle|Z_{0}|^{2}=|\langle 0|{\mathcal{J}_{+}}|H({P})\rangle|^{2}\propto P_{+}^{n}. (3) The fluctuation of the measurement can be estimated by the variance operator 69 ; 59 , \displaystyle{\rm Var}(C_{\rm 2pt}) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\langle|C_{\rm 2pt}|^{2}\rangle+\frac{1}{2}\langle C_{\rm 2pt}^{2}\rangle-\langle C_{\rm 2pt}\rangle^{2}, \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\langle\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(t)\mathcal{J}(t)\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(0)\mathcal{J}(0)\rangle+\frac{1}{2}\langle\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(t)\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(t)\mathcal{J}(0)\mathcal{J}(0)\rangle-\langle\mathcal{J}^{\dagger}(t)\mathcal{J}(0)\rangle^{2}, (4) where the first term is the two-point correlation for a static or scattering state with zero total quantum number and momentum, and the second term is for a two-particle state with momentum 2P . At large Euclidean time, the variance is dominated by the lowest-energy state, corresponding to n static pions for n valence quarks. Thus the fluctuation of the correlator does not get a kinematic enhancement, resulting in an improved signal-to-noise ratio, \displaystyle\frac{C_{\rm 2pt}(t\to\infty)[\mathcal{J}_{+}]}{\sqrt{{\rm Var}[C_{\rm 2pt}(t\to\infty)]}}\propto P_{+}^{n}e^{E_{0}-nm_{\pi}/2}. (5) In comparison with the static system, except for the exponential decay, the signal-to-noise ratio from the overlap factor |Z_{0}|^{2} is enhanced by the factor \frac{P_{+}^{n}}{M^{n}} . Since P_{+}\propto E+P_{z} , both the \mathcal{J}_{4} and \mathcal{J}_{\hat{P}} components get enhanced by the factor \frac{E^{n}}{M^{n}} and \frac{P_{z}^{n}}{M^{n}} , respectively. Note that the \mathcal{J}_{4} component has non-vanishing overlap with the ground-state hadron at rest, and thus has already been well studied for static hadrons in the literature. 2.2 Interpolator kernels In this subsection we present the diquark and free-quark kernels we use in this study, with the following proton interpolators 79 \displaystyle{\mathcal{J}}=\mathcal{P}\epsilon_{abc}{u}_{a}\left({u}_{b}\Gamma^{\prime}{d}^{T}_{c}\right)\;, \displaystyle\overline{\mathcal{J}}=\epsilon_{abc}\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{4}\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}\gamma_{4}\left(\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{4}\Gamma^{\prime*}\gamma_{4}\bar{d}^{T}_{c}\right)\;, (6) where \mathcal{P} projects onto the desired degrees of freedom. \Gamma^{\prime} is the diquark kernel. Both the two-point and the three-point function include a contraction of the respective unpaired quarks in the source and sink interpolators. We summarize the contraction of the projectors as \mathcal{T} , the free-quark kernel. The two-point function C_{2pt} reads \displaystyle C_{2pt}(\mathbf{p},t) \displaystyle=\langle 0|\mathcal{J}(\mathbf{p},t)\,\overline{\mathcal{J}}(\mathbf{p},0)|0\rangle (7) \displaystyle=a^{3}\sum_{\mathbf{x}}e^{-i\mathbf{p}\cdot\mathbf{x}}\;\epsilon_{abc}\,\epsilon_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}c^{\prime}}\; \displaystyle\times\Big\langle 0\Big|\text{Tr}\left[\bar{u}_{a^{\prime}}(0)\,\underbrace{\gamma_{4}\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}\gamma_{4}\mathcal{P}}_{\mathcal{T}}u_{a}(x)\big(u_{b}(x)\,\Gamma^{\prime}\,d_{c}^{T}(x)\big)\big(\bar{u}_{b^{\prime}}(0)\,\gamma_{4}\Gamma^{\prime*}\gamma_{4}\,\bar{d}_{c^{\prime}}^{T}(0)\big)\right]\Big|0\Big\rangle \displaystyle=a^{3}\sum_{\mathbf{x}}e^{-i\mathbf{p}\cdot\mathbf{x}}\;\epsilon_{abc}\,\epsilon_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}c^{\prime}}\;\Big\langle 0\Big|\text{Tr}\left[\underbrace{\bar{u}_{a^{\prime}}(0)\,\mathcal{T}u_{a}(x)}_{\text{free quarks}}\big(u_{b}(x)\,\Gamma^{\prime}\,d_{c}^{T}(x)\big)\big(\bar{u}_{b^{\prime}}(0)\,\gamma_{4}\Gamma^{\prime*}\gamma_{4}\,\bar{d}_{c^{\prime}}^{T}(0)\big)\right]\Big|0\Big\rangle\,. Kinematic enhancement can be applied to both the diquark and the free quark. Previously, the parity projection \mathcal{P}_{+}\equiv(1+\gamma_{t})/2 was commonly used, as it has maximum overlap with the proton ground state at zero momentum. However, as pointed out in 79 , parity is no longer a good quantum number at non-zero momenta, particularly at large ones. More specifically, before projection, the nucleon two-point correlation function constructed with the interpolator \hat{J} can be expressed as 58 ; 73 , \displaystyle\langle 0|\hat{J}^{\dagger}(t)\hat{J}|0\rangle=\sum_{i}|\lambda_{i,+}|^{2}\frac{\gamma\cdot P+M_{i}^{+}}{2E_{i}^{+}}e^{-E_{i}^{+}t}+\sum_{i}|\lambda_{i,-}|^{2}\frac{\gamma\cdot P-M_{i}^{-}}{2E_{i}^{-}}e^{-E_{i}^{-}t}, (8) where \lambda_{i,\pm} are the overlap of the interpolator with the i -th positive (negative) parity states, and E_{i}^{\pm} and M_{i}^{\pm} are the corresponding energies and masses. At rest, the projectors \mathcal{P}_{\pm} can eliminate the entire sector of negative (positive) parity states. But when boosted, this is not possible. On the other hand, for a general spin matrix \mathcal{T} , \displaystyle\mathcal{T}=b_{0}+\sum_{i=1}^{4}~c_{i}\gamma_{i}+\sum_{i=1}^{4}~d_{ij}\sigma_{ij}+e_{0}\gamma_{5}+\sum_{i=1}^{4}~f_{i}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{i}, (9) the projection of the two-point correlator is \displaystyle{\rm Tr}[\mathcal{T}\langle 0|\hat{J}^{\dagger}(t)\hat{J}|0\rangle]= \displaystyle\sum_{i}|\lambda_{i,+}|^{2}\frac{c_{3}P_{z}+c_{4}E_{i}^{+}+b_{0}M_{i}^{+}}{2E_{i}^{+}}e^{-E_{i}^{+}t} \displaystyle+\sum_{i}|\lambda_{i,-}|^{2}\frac{c_{3}P_{z}+c_{4}E_{i}^{-}-b_{0}M_{i}^{-}}{2E_{i}^{-}}e^{-E_{i}^{-}t}. (10) Thus the requirement of a positive-definite spectral expansion results only in constraints for its coefficients \displaystyle c_{4}\geq|b_{0}|,\qquad c_{3}\geq 0, (11) while the coefficients d_{ij} and f_{i} are related to the polarization, which does not contribute to the spin-averaged two-point correlation functions. The e_{0} factor will not contribute unless \hat{J}^{\dagger}_{\rm snk} and \hat{J}_{\rm src} operators are defined with opposite parities to each other, for example, when an extra \gamma_{5} is inserted into only one of the diquarks. This opens up other possibilities for \mathcal{T} as well as the option to include linear combinations of multiple “projectors” at no additional computational cost like mixed parity, \mathcal{T}=\mathcal{P}_{+}-\mathcal{P}_{-}=\gamma_{t} , which already provides kinematic enhancement. Another option which we shall explore in this paper is \mathcal{T}=\gamma_{+} , which is not a projector as \gamma_{+}^{2}=0 , but also provides kinematic enhancement 10 . In the following, we considered different choices for both kernels, namely \Gamma^{\prime}=C\gamma_{5}\Gamma , where C is the charge conjugation matrix, with \Gamma\in\{\mathbbm{1},\gamma_{t},\gamma_{+}\} and \mathcal{T}\in\{\mathcal{P}_{+},\gamma_{t},\gamma_{+}\} . Figure 1 : A nucleon 3pt contraction. Quark lines are coloured blue and dark blue for the up- and down quarks, respectively. The Wilson line is coloured red. Source and sink are placed at t_{\mathrm{source}} and t_{\mathrm{sink}} , respectively. Both source and sink are boosted by P_{\mathrm{z}} , which is also the direction of the inserted Wilson link. When using \Gamma^{\prime}=C\gamma_{5}\gamma_{+} , the quarks forming the diquark are projected onto their “ + ”-components. The free quark is projected likewise with \mathcal{T}=\gamma_{+} . This choice creates an additional factor of two improvement in variance compared to (\mathcal{T},\Gamma)=(\gamma_{t},\gamma_{t}) or (\mathcal{T},\Gamma)=(\gamma_{t},\gamma_{z}) , as both information is used. In addition, this reduces the original degrees of freedom by projecting onto the “ + ”-components only. This cancels all “ - ”-components of the propagators in contractions, e.g. a nucleon three-point function, where the operator O(x_{\text{ins}})=\bar{u}^{\delta^{\prime}}_{d^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}})K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}u^{\delta}_{d}(x_{\text{ins}}) has been inserted. \displaystyle C^{u}_{3\text{pt},K}(\vec{p},\,t_{\text{ins}},\,t_{\text{sep}},\,z) \displaystyle=a^{6}\sum_{\vec{x}_{\text{snk}},\,\vec{x}_{\text{ins}}}e^{-i\vec{p}\cdot(\vec{x}_{\text{snk}}-\vec{x}_{\text{src}})}\,\epsilon_{abc}\,\epsilon_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}c^{\prime}}(\mathcal{T})_{\alpha\alpha^{\prime}}(C\gamma_{5}\gamma_{+})_{\beta\gamma}(C\gamma_{5}\gamma_{-})_{\beta^{\prime}\gamma^{\prime}} \displaystyle\times\Bigl\langle u^{\alpha}_{a}(x_{\text{snk}})\, \displaystyle u^{\beta}_{b}(x_{\text{snk}})\,d^{\gamma}_{c}(x_{\text{snk}})\,\bar{u}^{\delta^{\prime}}_{d^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}})\,K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}\,u^{\delta}_{d}(x_{\text{ins}})\,\bar{u}^{\beta^{\prime}}_{b^{\prime}}(x_{\text{src}})\,\bar{d}^{\gamma^{\prime}}_{c^{\prime}}(x_{\text{src}})\,\bar{u}^{\alpha^{\prime}}_{a^{\prime}}(x_{\text{src}})\Bigr\rangle. \displaystyle=a^{6}\sum_{\vec{x}_{\text{snk}},\,\vec{x}_{\text{ins}}}e^{-i\vec{p}\cdot(\vec{x}_{\text{snk}}-\vec{x}_{\text{src}})}\,\epsilon^{abc}\,\epsilon^{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}c^{\prime}}(\mathcal{T})_{\alpha\alpha^{\prime}}(C\gamma_{5}\gamma_{+})_{\beta\gamma}(C\gamma_{5}\gamma_{-})_{\beta^{\prime}\gamma^{\prime}} \displaystyle\times D^{cc^{\prime}}_{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{src}}) \displaystyle\times\Bigl[{U^{\alpha\delta^{\prime}}_{ad^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{ins}})}\,K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}\,U^{\delta\alpha^{\prime}}_{da^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}},x_{\text{src}})\,U^{\beta\beta^{\prime}}_{bb^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{src}}) \displaystyle\quad-{U^{\alpha\delta^{\prime}}_{ad^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{ins}})}\,K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}\,U^{\delta\beta^{\prime}}_{db^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}},x_{\text{src}})\,U^{\beta\alpha^{\prime}}_{ba^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{src}}) \displaystyle\quad+{U^{\beta\delta^{\prime}}_{bd^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{ins}})}\,K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}\,U^{\delta\beta^{\prime}}_{db^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}},x_{\text{src}})\,U^{\alpha\alpha^{\prime}}_{aa^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{src}}) \displaystyle\quad-{U^{\beta\delta^{\prime}}_{bd^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{ins}})}\,K^{d^{\prime}d}_{\delta^{\prime}\delta}\,U^{\delta\alpha^{\prime}}_{da^{\prime}}(x_{\text{ins}},x_{\text{src}})\,U^{\alpha\beta^{\prime}}_{ab^{\prime}}(x_{\text{snk}},x_{\text{src}})\Bigr]\,. (12) When projecting all quarks in the source onto their “ + ”-components via (\mathcal{T},\Gamma)=(\gamma_{+},\gamma_{+}) , all “ - ”-component contractions of the resulting propagators with the source kernels become exactly 0, only the “ + ”-components contribute. This allows us to reduce the number of inversions to obtain the propagator connecting source and sink, in our case from a point source, by half. This reduction also applies to the propagator connecting the inserted operator to the sink, if it is obtained via the sequential source technique 65 , even if the sink interpolator does not project its quarks onto their “ + ”-components. The propagators obtained from the “ + ”-projected source interpolator ensure that in the contraction with the sink, only “ + ”-components contribute, making all “ - ”-components in the sequential source obsolete. This reduction in inversions also applies to polarized hadrons and partons, as polarization does not mix “ + ” and “ - ” components. Explicitly, “ - ”-components obtained as q_{-}=\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\gamma_{+}\gamma_{-}q still cancel after combining \gamma_{+} with the helicity or transversity projector: \displaystyle\gamma_{+}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{+}\gamma_{-} \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle\gamma_{+}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{\perp}\gamma_{+}\gamma_{-} \displaystyle=0 (13) This applies neither at the source nor the sink if (\mathcal{T},\Gamma)=(\gamma_{t},\gamma_{+}) is chosen, as contractions involving the free quark mix “ + ” and “ - ”-components. An example for this is shown in ( 2.2 ), where the propagators connecting the operator with the sink that contract with the free quark kernel require all 12 indices. One such contraction, the first summand, is presented in Figure 1 , with the down quark propagator shown in dark blue, and the up quark ones in light blue. To fully exploit this additional improvement in computation time, we consider only (\mathcal{T},\Gamma)=(\gamma_{+},\gamma_{+}) for the case of “ + ”-improvement. We summarize all tuples of kernels for our investigation in Table 1 . Kernels (\mathcal{T},\Gamma) Name (\mathcal{P}_{+},\mathbbm{1}) Conventional (\gamma_{+},\gamma_{+}) \gamma_{+} enhanced (\gamma_{t},\gamma_{t}) \gamma_{t} enhanced Table 1 : Choices of interpolator kernels (\mathcal{T},\Gamma) used in this work. 2.3 Nucleon PDFs with LaMET The unpolarized nucleon quark isovector PDF is a well-studied quantity within the LaMET formalism, as described below. In this work, we do not repeat the entirety of the calculations involved, but restrict ourselves to computing only the quasi-PDF matrix elements as examples. 2.3.1 The unpolarized nucleon PDF In LaMET, the \overline{\rm MS} lightcone PDF f(x,\mu) is calculated from the following effective theory expansion 52 ; 76 ; 53 ; 46 ; 50 , f(x,\mu)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dy}{|y|}\tilde{C}\left(\frac{x}{y},\frac{\mu}{yP_{z}}\right)\tilde{f}\left(y,P_{z},\mu\right)+\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{2}}{\left(xP_{z}\right)^{2}},\frac{\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{2}}{\left((1-x)P_{z}\right)^{2}}\right)\,, (14) where \tilde{C}\left(\frac{x}{y},\frac{\mu}{yP_{z}}\right) is a perturbative matching kernel and \tilde{f}\left(y,P_{z},\mu\right) is the quasi-PDF: \displaystyle\tilde{f}\left(y,P^{z},\mu\right)=P^{z}\int\frac{dz}{2\pi}e^{iz\left(yP^{z}\right)}\tilde{h}_{R}\left(z,P^{z},\mu\right), (15) \displaystyle\tilde{h}_{R}\left(z,P^{z},\mu\right)=\frac{1}{2E}\langle P|\bar{\psi}(z)\gamma^{t}\psi(0)|P\rangle\,. The quasi-PDF matrix elements \tilde{h}\left(z,P^{z},\mu\right) are calculated on the lattice and renormalized and matched to the \overline{\rm MS} scheme. On the lattice, \displaystyle\tilde{h}(z,P_{z},1/a) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2E}\langle P|\bar{\psi}(z)\gamma^{t}\mathcal{W}[z,0]\psi(0)|P\rangle, (16) where \mathcal{W}[z,0] is the straight Wilson line running from 0 to z . Repeating this calculation with otherwise identical parameter sets but different interpolators allows us to assess their merits. While we perform these calculations only for this specific quantity, the results will have implications for all boosted hadrons. For example, precise results for large P^{z} are crucial for a reliable infinite momentum extrapolation in LaMET. See Eq. ( 14 ). 2.3.2 Renormalization The bare correlation function in Eq. ( 16 ) suffers from linear divergences due to the Wilson self-energy and logarithmic UV divergences stemming from the UV regulating lattice spacing 34 ; 28 ; 33 ; 51 ; 45 ; 39 . Both need to be removed correctly for a proper renormalization. We choose the hybrid scheme 48 which renormalizes short distances z in a ratio scheme 70 ; 68 ; 71 and long ones via self-renormalization 44 : \displaystyle\tilde{h}_{R}(z,P_{z},\mu)= \displaystyle\frac{\tilde{h}(z,P_{z},1/a)}{\tilde{h}(z,P_{z}=0,1/a)}\theta(z_{s}-|z|)+\eta_{s}\frac{\tilde{h}(z,P_{z},1/a)}{Z_{R}(z,1/a)}\theta(|z|-z_{s})\,. (17) The short-distance scale z_{s} is introduced as an artificial separator between short and long distances, which will be canceled by the z_{s} dependence in the corresponding perturbative matching kernel. It can be varied in the analysis to reduce bias associated with its choice. \eta_{s} is a normalization factor that guarantees the continuity of renormalization at z=z_{s} during the transition from perturbative to non-perturbative region. At small z\leq z_{s} , we divide the correlation functions at large momenta by the same correlation functions in the rest frame. At large distances, the self-renormalization factor Z_{R}(z,1/a) is used to remove UV divergences while preserving IR physics. The UV physics can be extracted from the short distance bare matrix elements in the rest frame \tilde{h}(z,P_{z}=0,1/a) at multiple lattice spacings. Motivated by perturbation theory it is assumed to be of functional form \displaystyle\ln\tilde{h}(z,P_{z}=0,1/a)=\frac{kz}{a\ln(a\Lambda_{\rm{QCD}})}\!+\!g(z)\!+\!f(z)a^{2}\! \displaystyle+\!\frac{3C_{F}}{11-2N_{f}/3}\ln\left[\frac{\ln{[1/(a\Lambda_{\rm{QCD}})]}}{\ln{[\mu/\Lambda_{\rm{QCD}}]}}\right]\!+\!\ln\left[1\!+\!\frac{d}{\ln(a\Lambda_{\rm{QCD}})}\right]\,. (18) The first term includes the linear divergence stemming from the Wilson line self-energy. The second term, g(z) , contains the non-perturbative information necessary for renormalization as well as a renormalon ambiguity term, which we will have to remove later. The third term, f(z)a^{2} , accounts for discretization errors. The last two terms result from the resummation of leading and sub-leading logarithms, affecting normalization at different lattice spacings. As higher order effects and further lattice artifacts cannot be removed entirely, \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}} and d are treated as fit parameters as well 44 . The normalized long distance renormalization coefficient Z_{R}(z,1/a)/\eta_{s} is defined as \displaystyle\frac{Z_{R}(z,1/a)}{\eta_{s}} \displaystyle=\tilde{h}(z_{s},P_{z}=0,1/a)\exp\left[-{\frac{k(|z|-z_{s})}{a\ln(a\Lambda_{\rm QCD})}-m_{0}(|z|-z_{s})}\right]\,, (19) where the renormalon mass m_{0} is extracted via a linear fit to the difference of the continuum perturbative \overline{\mathrm{MS}} result C_{0,\mathrm{NLO}}^{\overline{\mathrm{MS}}}(z) and g(z) obtained from ( 2.3.2 ) \displaystyle g(z)-\ln(C_{0,\mathrm{NLO}}^{\overline{\mathrm{MS}}}(z))=m_{0}z\, (20) The fixed order (NLO) result was obtained in 46 and is given as \displaystyle C_{0,\mathrm{NLO}}^{\overline{\mathrm{MS}}}(z)=1+\frac{\alpha_{s}C_{F}}{2\pi}\left(\frac{3}{2}\ln\left(z^{2}\mu^{2}e^{2\gamma_{E}}/4\right)+\frac{5}{2}\right). (21) Note that the determination of m_{0} is not unique due to the renormalon ambiguity, and needs to be properly regularized when matched to the lightcone PDF to avoid introducing extra linear corrections in 1/P_{z} 80 ; 41 . However, the scope of this work only focuses on the statistical uncertainties of quasi-PDF lattice data, not including the perturbative matching to the lightcone PDFs. It makes no difference if we simply use the fixed-order NLO result from ( 21 ), as the ambiguity does not affect the relative statistical errors of the lattice data. 3 Lattice setup and techniques To obtain ( 16 ) for the isovector case on the lattice, we compute the two-point function C_{2\mathrm{pt}}(\vec{p},t) : C_{2\mathrm{pt}}(\vec{p},t)=\sum_{\vec{x}}e^{-i\vec{p}\cdot\vec{x}}\langle 0|\mathcal{J}(\vec{x},t)\,\overline{\mathcal{J}}(\vec{0},0)|0\rangle (22) and the three-point function C^{u-d}_{3\mathrm{pt},V}(z,\vec{p},\tau,t) , of which one contraction is illustrated in Figure 1 , C^{u-d}_{3\mathrm{pt}}(z,\vec{p},\tau,t_{\mathrm{sep}})=\sum_{\vec{x},\vec{y}}e^{-i\vec{p}\cdot(\vec{x}-\vec{y})}\langle 0|\mathcal{J}(\vec{x};t_{\rm sep})\,\mathcal{O}(\vec{y},z;\tau)\,\overline{\mathcal{J}}(\vec{0};0)|0\rangle\,, (23) where \mathcal{O}(\vec{y},z;\tau)=\bar{u}(\vec{y};\tau)\gamma^{t}W(\vec{y},\vec{y}+z\hat{z};\tau)u(\vec{y}+z\hat{z};\tau)-\bar{d}(\vec{y};\tau)\gamma^{t}W(\vec{y},\vec{y}+z\hat{z};\tau)d(\vec{y}+z\hat{z};\tau)\,, (24) containing a straight Wilson line W of length z in \hat{z} (momentum) direction. The operator \mathcal{O}(\vec{y},z;\tau) is inserted at all insertion times 0<\tau